windowbox

Housing & Permitting Committee

Official agenda

Transcript

Transcript

Automatically generated transcript. It may contain errors and includes testimony in languages other than English that is not individually marked up for assistive technology.

Candace Avalos 2:46 - 2:55

2:46Good afternoon.

2:47I am calling the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee to order on Tuesday, November 17th at 2:00 PM.

2:54Diego, please call the roll.

Diego 2:56 - 2:57

2:56Good afternoon.

2:57Green?

Mitch Green 2:58 - 2:58

2:58Here.

Diego 2:59 - 3:00

2:59Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:00 - 3:00

3:00Here.

Diego 3:01 - 3:02

3:01Koyama Lane?

Tiffany Koyama Lane 3:02 - 3:02

3:02Here.

Diego 3:03 - 3:05

3:03Novick?

3:05Avalos?

Candace Avalos 3:05 - 3:08

3:05Present.

3:07Claire, can you please read the statement of conduct?

Claire 3:09 - 3:32

3:09Thank you, Chair.

3:10Good afternoon and welcome to the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

3:13To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at portland.gov/council/agenda/housingandpermittingcommittee or by calling 311.

3:25Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

3:29In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

Keelan McClymont 3:33 - 4:11

3:33If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

3:38Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

3:41The chair preserves order.

3:42Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

3:50If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

3:53Further disruption, disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

3:56Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

4:00Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

4:04Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

4:06When testifying, please state your name for the record.

4:08If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

Claire 4:11 - 4:16

4:11And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

4:15Thank you.

Candace Avalos 4:17 - 4:38

4:17Thank you, Claire.

4:18For today's agenda, we will have our usual time for public comment at the top, and then we will spend the rest of our time today discussing 3 ordinances on relocation assistance.

4:27We will open these items together.

4:28We'll have some time for some technical questions followed by public testimony, and then we'll move to committee discussion.

4:35Um, but let let's go ahead with item 1.

4:37Diego, if you could please read that.

Diego 4:38 - 4:44

4:38Item 1, document number 2026-416, Housing and Permitting Community Feedback.

Candace Avalos 4:45 - 4:48

4:45All right, so, uh, let's go ahead and call up our first person.

Diego 4:49 - 4:53

4:49Zachary Langford, followed by River Scholl.

Zackery Langford 5:03 - 5:05

5:03Hi, can you, can you hear me?

Candace Avalos 5:06 - 5:06

5:06Yes.

Zackery Langford 5:06 - 7:34

5:06All right, um, so first I just want to state that I have experience with homelessness.

5:12I've been living with my— I lived in my car for 4 months before.

5:16It was like a year ago.

5:18And so I just want to first just start off by stating how traumatic homelessness can be.

5:24And, um, with the rents rising and everything getting more expensive, and over the last 10 years rents have increased by over 50%, Yes.

5:33While wages have stagnated.

5:35And if people aren't able to afford rent, people— many Portlanders and working-class families and young people and seniors might feel like they might not be able to afford to relocate and might be forced to go on the street.

5:50And that can be very traumatic.

5:53And it's also a quick way trip to going to prison, which can be very terrible.

6:03And many Portlanders, and if they often, they often cannot, they often have to try to find cheaper rent outside the city, which can often make going to work or going to school a lot more difficult and a lot more tedious.

6:21And also having to change schools just because you have to find cheaper rent can often disrupt lives or educational outcomes.

6:30Thank you.

6:31So the ordinances before the committee today are essential to help keep people remain housed.

6:40And lowering the relocation assistance threshold of 5% would provide a modest yet very important safety net within a broken housing system.

6:55Adjusting relocation assistance amounts to reflect inflation and necessary to ensure that costs do not thank you.

7:08So I just urge you to pass this ordinance into this— urge the community to, uh, to, to pass this ordinance because I think it's very important.

7:21Um, and, um, I also think it's not going to fix the housing crisis, but I think it'd be a very good, uh, safety net.

7:29I mean, anything will help, honestly.

7:31And that's, that's all I got for today.

7:34Thank you for your time.

Candace Avalos 7:35 - 7:37

7:35Thank you for sharing.

River Scholl 7:38 - 7:45

7:38River Scholl.

7:44Neil Whitacre.

Neil Whitacre 7:55 - 8:45

7:55Respected members of the Housing Committee, my name is Neil Whitacre.

7:59I am in full support of this renter relocation funding.

8:02I think it's a wonderful thing to see shifting funding wherever we can to a more tenant-based approach.

8:08I don't see renters getting a lot of access to Portland Housing Bureau's director's meeting calendar for direct access to your ears, but I see somewhat excessive shoveling of public money to big housing entities that are not really asked to even prove exactly why they need it.

8:25So watching big housing nickel and dime single moms and all the people that we've kind of left with a very difficult housing landscape.

8:32Thank you.

8:33In causing unnecessary disruptions to families and kids.

8:36I hope we can avert some of these sort of life derailments that are going on.

8:41I think this committee has— this is a really solid move in the right direction.

8:43I think this is a really good job.

8:45Thank you.

ZACHARY SMURTHWAITE 8:49 - 9:01

8:49Zachary Smurthwaite.

8:59Anthony Haroian.

Anthony Haroian 9:10 - 11:49

9:10Good afternoon, my name is Anthony Haroian.

9:14I'm here to talk about the development permitting process in Portland.

9:20It's been stated that Oregon, the state of Oregon, has dictated the rules in which Portland follows sort of blanketly.

9:30And I am here to propose that there should be some sensibility written into the Portland permitting and development process to make sure that one size doesn't fit all, because that's the way it seems to be.

9:46The idea of density in a density corridor makes sense.

9:51The idea of density regardless of where it's placed, doesn't always make sense.

9:56And I'm looking at the neighborhood of Sellwood, for one, where you have a very dense business and commercial corridor that's impacted mostly by the parking situation where development is— developers are not required at most, at the most permitting stages, project stages, they're not required to put in parking, which really impacts the local neighborhood around it.

10:27And I think that in cases like this where it makes sense, where you have commercial street-level businesses and residential density infill above it, makes sense.

10:40Parking is an issue.

10:41But to have the same sort of density put into neighborhoods where— Yeah.

10:46That the outer neighborhoods of Sellwood where you still do not require parking impacts everybody.

10:54The idea of the cottage clusters is a big piece for me because you have on small parcels multiple individually owned properties, no centralized management.

11:11Yeah.

11:12No discussion with city services about things like garbage collection or fire or emergency service access.

11:21Multiple meters, multiple— the sewer systems, you know, are they now, you know, they're for 10 homes where there was 1 before or 3 before.

11:33So anyway, I would like to just ask that the council consider— Thank you.

11:39Looking at the permitting process and at least providing some sort of sensibility within the neighborhoods that these are being proposed.

11:49Thank you very much.

Diego 11:52 - 12:01

11:52Once more, for River Scholl, Zachary Smurthwaite.

12:00That concludes testimony.

Candace Avalos 12:04 - 12:05

12:04All right, thank you so much.

Diego 12:06 - 12:08

12:06Oh, so sorry, looks like they're here.

Candace Avalos 12:09 - 12:09

12:09Go ahead.

ZACHARY SMURTHWAITE 12:10 - 12:15

12:10Hello, I don't know how this works, first time I've done this.

Candace Avalos 12:16 - 12:18

12:16Hello, have a seat, introduce yourself, and you can begin.

12:18Can I stand?

ZACHARY SMURTHWAITE 12:19 - 12:20

12:19I think it's more comfortable.

Candace Avalos 12:20 - 12:23

12:20We need to hear you on the mic, and so it's hard to do that.

ZACHARY SMURTHWAITE 12:25 - 12:34

12:25So yeah, I'm here about the, um, 10% And the relocation fee that's on the document.

12:33Sounds good.

Candace Avalos 12:34 - 12:35

12:34Please state your name and then, yeah, go ahead.

ZACHARY SMURTHWAITE 12:36 - 12:37

12:36Zachary Smurthwaite.

Candace Avalos 12:43 - 12:44

12:43Go ahead.

12:43Go ahead.

12:43Yeah.

ZACHARY SMURTHWAITE 12:44 - 15:09

12:44Okay, so, um, I'm here because, uh, I was facing homelessness, uh, up until 1:30 today.

12:56Um, the apartment complex that I lived in— um, sorry, I'm gonna be emotional.

13:04I was hoping this wasn't going to happen.

13:06Um, 4 out of the 5 years that I lived there, um, I got 10% a year, which is 40% over 5 years.

13:21Um, And that led me to the situation I'm in now.

13:27I didn't know about the relocation things until recently.

13:34Thank God I received some assistance from Clear Clinic.

13:43And going through the documents and the rental increases.

13:48They didn't follow the— this is tough— the letter of the law, as you say.

13:58Mm-hmm.

14:01Um, I was never late on one payment in over 5 years, um, until some things happened outside of my control.

14:12Um, You know, we're seeing it every day on our streets.

14:26We see the, you know, the repercussions of certain people's actions.

14:40And so I just, you know, I just implore, like, 10% a year is insane.

14:43Yeah.

14:45Thank you.

14:45Um, anyone raise their hand who's got a 10% increase in wages this year?

14:57I, I don't see one, right?

14:59Yeah.

15:00So 40% in 5 years to a good tenant, zero complaints, I've never been late until April of 2026.

Candace Avalos 15:14 - 15:16

15:14You have 30 more seconds.

Unidentified speaker 15:16 - 15:42

15:16Well, I just implore this council to, you know, do something.

15:20You have a unique opportunity to change the landscape of Portland, Oregon.

15:26I fell in love with the city because it was a community, and it's not like that anymore.

15:33You have corporations and companies coming in here and dictating what we're facing every day, and you can walk outside right now and see it.

Candace Avalos 15:46 - 15:52

15:46Thanks.

15:48I'm sorry.

15:50Don't apologize.

15:51Thank you for sharing your story.

Diego 15:54 - 15:55

15:54That concludes testimony.

Candace Avalos 15:57 - 16:31

15:57Thank you all.

15:58That's a hard but important note to lead on because this is what we're here to talk about.

16:03This is what we're experiencing.

16:04People are facing eviction, threat of eviction.

16:07They're not seeing their wages go up and their housing costs keep going up.

16:12And that is why we have thousands of people living on our streets.

16:15So I want to thank him for his vulnerability.

16:18I know he ran off, and I, I really wish, um, I really hope that that informs the discussion we're about to have today, because the repercussions of not acting are what we just saw.

16:29Please go ahead and read, Diego, the next 3 items.

Diego 16:32 - 17:19

16:32Item 2, document number 2026-418, amend Portland Renter Additional Protections Code to adjust percentage rent increase triggering relocation assistance.

16:44Amend code section 30.01.085.

16:48Item 3, document number 2026-419.

16:52Amend Portland Renter Additional Protections Code to adjust relocation assistance amount to align with inflation.

17:00Amend code section 30.01.085.

17:04Item 4, document number 2026-420.

17:08Amend Portland Renter Additional Protections Code to add relocation assistance increase for tenants with school-aged children, amend Code Section 30.01.085.

Candace Avalos 17:20 - 19:57

17:20Thank you, Diego.

17:22Okay, so colleagues, I am very excited to be devoting the rest of our agenda today to discuss much-needed improvements in renter protections.

17:31We have heard a lot lately about the affordability crisis that has swept the nation, but Portland in particular has been in a multi-decade-long housing crisis.

17:39Crisis of our own that has now dovetailed with the broader pressures of inflation, rising energy bills, and Trump's tariffs and budget cuts.

17:48Back in 2017, Portland City Council unanimously passed a policy called Mandatory Renter Relocation Assistance, and it was aimed at giving renters more options when faced with no-cause evictions or steep rent increases.

18:01The program helps renters by requiring landlords to compensate tenants facing no-cause evictions or rent increases of 10% or more within a 12-month period with specific notice and that was a huge achievement, and I'm grateful to our predecessors for passing a creative solution to a persistent problem.

18:19But now, nearly 10 years later, today's City Council offices have been asking a key question: if Portland is going to have a relocation assistance policy, is it actually providing enough protection to help people relocate safely when they are displaced?

18:34We are hearing loud and clear from renters that no, it's not enough, and the program isn't fully living up to its promise of protecting renters from relocation hardships.

18:41Thank you.

18:42The goal of relocation assistance is to help renters cover the real costs of having to move unexpectedly.

18:48Families are squeezed— they are squeezed so tight right now that even a moderate rent increase can be the last straw in forcing someone to find a new place to live.

18:58This is something that we call economic evictions.

19:01Furthermore, moving costs, like so many other things in today's economy, are much, much more expensive now than they were in the last decade.

19:09And families with school-aged kids are sometimes forced to find housing in a new school district, which severely disrupts child development and well-being.

19:17So without further ado, I'd like to open up presentations on the 3 policies that we have before us today to strengthen Portland's Renter Relocation Assistance Program.

19:26First, we'll hear a presentation from the sponsors of each of the ordinances.

19:30Then we'll have a little bit of time for technical questions, though I will ask my colleagues to make that as quickly as we can so we can get to public testimony, as we have over 40 people signed up.

19:40And then, uh, for now, uh, let's get started with my staff who will do the first presentation.

19:45Then I'll hand it off to Councilor Green's office, followed by Councilor Koyama Lane's office.

19:49And so first up, I'd like to call up Damon Matztori, my Director of Policy and Communications, to share about our relocation percentage ordinance.

Damon Matztori 19:59 - 21:52

19:59Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

20:00For the record, my name is Damon Matztori, Director of Policy and communications for Councilor Candace Avalos.

20:07I'm going to share my screen real quick.

20:15Let's hit that present button.

20:17Okay, I think we're all good on the visuals.

20:20Yes.

20:21All right, excellent.

20:21So, uh, councilors, I'm going to keep this very, very brief.

20:25Um, this is probably the simplest of the 3 ordinances on your agenda today, uh, so I'm going to talk about what it does.

20:31Thank you.

20:32We're updating the rental relocation percentage.

20:35Officially, this is document 2026-418, amending renter additional protections to adjust percentage rent increase triggering relocation assistance.

20:45So what that means in plain language, Portland's 2017 renter relocation policy requires landlords to provide renter relocation assistance to tenants facing no-cause evictions or rent increases of 10% or more.

20:57Thank you.

20:58Within a 12-month period of time.

21:00This ordinance would lower the threshold to rent increases of 5% or more, and that's all this ordinance does.

21:08Why are we doing this and why now?

21:10Over the past 10 years, inflation, cost of living, tariffs have drastically changed renters' circumstances.

21:15And what we're hearing from constituents is that many landlords increase the rent by the maximum amount without triggering relocation assistance.

21:24For example, a 9.99% rent increase.

21:26Thank you.

21:28And when you run the numbers, even a 5% increase on rent that is over $2,000 a month already represents added costs of $100 or more every month for families.

21:38And at this point in time, we're hearing that there is not much in the margins for families facing all of these different cost pressures.

21:44And so this feels like a critically important piece of the relocation assistance policy to update.

21:51And that's it for my presentation.

21:52Thank you.

Candace Avalos 21:54 - 22:04

21:54Thank you, Damon.

21:57All right, next I'm going to hand it over to my colleague Vice Chair Green and his office to talk about the compensation amounts for renter relocation assistance.

Mitch Green 22:05 - 22:29

22:05Uh, thank you, Chair Avalos, and bear with me as I, uh, attempt to present.

22:09Um, I'm going to present this.

22:11My staff economist, uh, has a cold and sounds like Tom Waits, which some of you may appreciate, but, uh, some of you may not.

22:19All right, All right.

22:19Let's see here.

22:21I presume that you can see some sort of presentation, although it may not be in presentation mode.

Candace Avalos 22:33 - 22:34

22:33Yeah, it's okay.

Mitch Green 22:34 - 25:44

22:34All right.

22:35Can we work— can we live with that?

22:36Is that fine?

22:37Okay.

22:38So this is the second ordinance that addresses an important part of the broader policy framework in our code, Section 30 of our code, which determines the amount of the relocation payment.

22:51When this was adopted in 2017, council more or less just wrote the nominal sort of stated figures into the policy, and they were not indexed to inflation.

23:06And in a 2022 study, Commissioner— then Commissioner Dan Ryan sort of had requested recommendations from the Bureau to say, you know, how would we go about indexing this, or should we index these?

23:23And they did recommend that we should pursue a policy framework that came up with a methodology to index those to inflation.

23:31Stakeholders recommended both.

23:34And so, but we never took that step.

23:37That was 2022.

23:38It is now 2026.

23:39And so what this ordinance does is simply update the stated values for the relocation amounts based upon the unit size.

23:50In the code to reflect increases in the market since then.

23:57And the specific methodology used here to set this, we worked with the Bureau of Housing, the Portland Housing Bureau, that used CoStar data, which sort of is a good indication of where the rental market is today that looks across averages, right?

24:12So it's not necessarily CPI.

24:15It's a good indicator.

24:16Where is Portland at today?

24:19And so simply what you see in the table here, the proposed amounts reflect the real-world average increase in rents based upon studios, RSOs, 1-bedroom, 2-bedroom, and 3-bedroom and more.

24:35And then triples that because it's not just a month's rent.

24:39It's to relocate, you know, there's significant costs associated with that.

24:44So the spirit of this is to sort of COVID first last month's rent and a security deposit.

24:51And recently we held a rental rip-off event in my district, and I had a constituent say that they were assessed like a supplemental down payment, sort of a deposit based upon some arbitrary risk methodology.

25:10And so the point being here is there are significant vulnerabilities to displaced tenants that are just simply not being compensated because we didn't write into the law numbers that automatically update.

25:22So that's the first part of what the ordinance does.

25:26And then it also directs the city administrator on an annual basis to update those amounts using a methodology that they see fit.

25:34So that's what the ordinance does.

25:37And— Thank you.

25:38I'll, I'll stop there.

25:39And I think there's a 3rd ordinance in play, and, uh, I'll now hand it over to whoever's presenting on that.

Candace Avalos 25:45 - 25:53

25:45Yes, thank you, Councilor.

25:47Uh, last but not least, I'll hand it over to Councilor Koyama Lane to share an ordinance that will protect renters with school-aged children at home.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 25:55 - 28:20

25:55Thank you, Chair.

25:56Um, as a PPS teacher myself and parent, I know how important it is for students to finish the school year in the same classroom that they first, I want to say I'm really grateful to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney and members of her team for their partnership on this ordinance.

26:14We are co-sponsoring this, and we're both— we're fellow PPS parents.

26:19So she is also someone who really understands firsthand that importance of supporting families and their— and kiddos.

26:27I have taught for about 17 years if I include my years as a substitute.

26:32Substitute teacher, and I have seen, um, different times when kids have not been able to finish the school year.

26:38And sometimes that has been because of, uh, the family not being able to afford their rent and getting pushed out of the neighborhood.

26:47Uh, one story that some of you might have heard me talk about was when I was teaching 5th grade at Fabian School, which is in District 2, and one of my 5th graders, he— his mom had grew up in the area and, but they lost their housing in the middle of the year.

27:01And I saw that play out and take a couple months, but they lost their housing.

27:06They went without housing for a little bit.

27:08They eventually got housing way out in East Portland.

27:12And I remember how hard it was.

27:14That 5th grader was taking 2 different public buses to get to school.

27:18He was coming late.

27:20He was falling asleep in class.

27:22And— Wow.

27:24It was really hard.

27:25It's one thing to like hear the stories and then to really see that first, see that through my student and his mom.

27:32It was really impactful.

27:34He did finish the school year with us even though he had to take those 2 buses.

27:38And part of it was we have built a really strong community.

27:41And he, I remember he also came back after the last days of school and he like helped me clean the classroom and do some end of the year closing up.

27:49But I really— Thank you.

27:51It's really important that we're supporting our kiddos to be able to be in these spaces, in their classrooms.

27:59For some kiddos, it's the hot meal that they get that day.

28:04It can be a place where they can get safety, and being able to have that continuity is really important.

28:10And so, Chair, if it's okay, before I invite my staff member, Aubrey Chen, to provide a brief technical overview of the ordinance, I'd just like to see if Councilor Pirtle-Guiney would like to add anything.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 28:21 - 29:13

28:21Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

28:24I think you went over that brilliantly.

28:27I am proud to be a co-sponsor of this legislation.

28:30We know that that stability of staying in the same classroom can make the difference in whether kids continue to do the learning they need to do to stay at grade level and keep up with their classmates.

28:47We also know that with Portland's rental market, there are a whole lot of pressures on a lot of our neighborhoods, and making sure that families have a little bit more flexibility tied to a little bit more money in finding housing that keeps their kids near their schools is absolutely critical.

29:07So glad to be a co-sponsor, and thank you, Aubrey, for taking the lead on this work and going over the details for us.

29:13Thank you.

Audrey Chen 29:18 - 31:41

29:18Great.

29:18Well, thank you so much.

29:20For the record, Audrey Chen, she/her pronouns.

29:22I'm a senior staffer for Councilor Koyama Lane's office.

29:25I do wanna take a moment to also recognize that I am a former CPPW union member and over 800 of my colleagues are currently out on strike today.

29:34And I wanna recognize the labor of those staffers.

29:38First, I just wanna start with a basic value that our office has, which is we believe that student, every student has the right right.

29:45To education.

29:46And that belief and value really drove our initial research.

29:50The scientific literature shows that changing school years during the school year has a disproportionate harm to children.

29:57This supports— the evidence supports both short-term and long-term negative impacts.

30:02Science shows that mid-year school changes lead to short-term drops in math and reading scores.

30:08It increases the long-term dropout risk and increases the likelihood of a student being held back a grade or not graduating high school.

30:15In addition to those academic risks, We also see that these mid-year school changes lead to disrupted development.

30:22There's additional strains on child and adolescent growths, and there are a number of lasting consequences that affect well beyond that sort of movement period.

30:32We began this discussion actually a year ago to the day, and I would like to take a moment to thank Council Operations staff, Claire.

30:39I'd also like to thank PHB staff and the number of partners that have engaged with us throughout this process.

30:45In trying to mitigate the negative harms experienced by students, we look towards the relocation assistance program as an avenue to help kids stay in school and finish the school year.

30:55Our intent is to increase the relocation assistance amount for eligible families to make sure that these families cannot— can go beyond just relocating within the city of Portland, but actually have the resources necessary to relocate within that same school attendance boundary.

31:12This expansion also applies year-round.

31:13Thank you.

31:14We wanted to avoid any potential repercussions or potential incentives to have relocation happen during like August, for example, right before the beginning of a school year.

31:25We're also relying on the expertise of subject matter experts within PHB and the city administration to construct a payment schedule and process guidelines in order to construct those specific assistance amounts in order to support those aims.

31:38Thank you.

31:40And with that, that is my, uh, presentation.

Candace Avalos 31:44 - 32:15

31:44Thank you, Aubrey.

31:47Okay, colleagues, um, so let us take a couple moments here if we would like to ask any technical questions before we get into the, um, public testimony.

31:58And we've got some, um, folks in the room here to help us, including Matt Gander from the City Attorney's Office and Josh Roper and Queesha Light from PHB.

32:08Okay, I'm not seeing it.

32:13Okay, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, go ahead.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 32:15 - 32:26

32:15Councilor, I do have— or Chair, I apologize— I do have some questions, but I'd like to hold them to the discussion part so we can hear from testifiers.

32:23Uh, we'll have time for dis— for questions after that.

32:25Is that accurate?

Candace Avalos 32:26 - 32:32

32:26That's the goal.

32:27Yeah.

32:29Okay, well then why don't we go ahead and jump on into the testimony?

Keelan McClymont 32:32 - 33:22

32:32Diego, if you want to get that for those signed up to testify, a reminder that each testifier will receive 2 minutes.

32:40I will call up folks in groups of 5.

32:43For those testifying in person, you will see a timer countdown displayed on the monitor in front of the testimony table.

32:49For those testifying virtually, the timer is displayed in Zoom.

32:53When testifying, you will hear the timer chime twice.

32:57The first chime is a warning when there are 30 seconds left.

33:00Then the second is when your time is up.

33:03And lastly, before you begin your testimony, please state your name for the record.

33:08So first is Becky Straus, Chris Olson, Rowan Harvey, Henry Scheffer, Jordan Carter.

33:21Hi.

Becky Straus 33:26 - 36:04

33:26Good afternoon, Chair Avalos, members of the committee.

33:30My name is Becky Straus.

33:31I use she/her pronouns.

33:32I'm here on behalf of the Oregon Law Center.

33:39There is a red light on.

33:42You can speak a little closer.

33:44Okay.

33:46The Oregon Law Center is a nonprofit law firm.

33:50We serve low-income tenants.

33:52Oh, there we go.

33:53Okay.

33:54Should I start over?

33:56Thanks.

33:56Thank you again, Chair Avalos, members of the committee.

33:58Becky Straus, I use she/her pronouns.

34:00I'm here on behalf of the Oregon Law Center.

34:02Thank you for the opportunity to testify in favor of all 3 of these proposals.

34:07Our client community includes the 16,000 people in Multnomah County struggling with homelessness and the thousands more who are living on extremely low or fixed incomes and are rent burdened in their housing.

34:19Thank you.

34:20We support all of these proposals, which grimly recognize the often insurmountable challenges that tenants face when they're displaced in today's rental market.

34:30These incremental improvements to tenant protections in Portland are an important piece of the city's work to address the growing homelessness crisis.

34:38I want to make 2 points with my testimony.

34:42The first here is that we're— the 2 triggers covered here that would trigger relocation assistance, the rent increase and the no-cause evictions.

34:50On the second piece, The no-cause evictions section is very narrow.

34:55There are— it is very rare that relocation is triggered during a no-cause eviction.

35:03I went and looked at the Multnomah County eviction docket today and see that a mere 0.2% of cases— that's obviously less than half of 1%— were for relo eligible landlord business reasons.

35:16So we're talking about situations where tenants are not at fault.

35:19Landlords are making business decisions to move them out of the unit.

35:22It is very rare.

35:23Thank you.

35:23It's very impactful for the tenants.

35:29It's life-changing, or it could be life-changing.

35:32Our clients at Legal Aid are all living on the margins.

35:35They're one health event, family emergency, employment change, or in this case, rent increase or no-cause eviction away from crisis.

35:43And when we see the legislature just recently in last session gutted eviction prevention funds, the housing safety net is evaporating, and it's decreasingly likely that tenants can access help to stay in their homes.

35:53Thank you.

35:54And so we're seeing more and more So they need the relocation assistance to help them stay off of the streets and stably housed.

36:00We appreciate all of your leadership on these important proposals.

36:03Thank you.

Diego 36:06 - 36:09

36:06Chris is online.

36:07Chris, you may unmute and begin when you're ready.

Chris Olson 36:12 - 38:09

36:12Hello.

36:14Yeah, hello, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, Housing Permitting Committee members.

36:18For the record, my name is Chris Olson.

36:20I'm a resident of District 2 and a member Portland DSA Housing Working Group.

36:26Rents, as you know, have increased by almost 50% in the last 10 years since the Rental Renters Additional Protections Code was passed.

36:34Portland still remains unaffordable for working-class families, young people, and seniors.

36:38Many, many Portlanders live in fear knowing that they are one missed paycheck away from losing their housing.

36:42If the rent rises further, many won't be able to afford to relocate, forcing them onto the streets.

36:48Or they find cheaper housing outside the city, which lengthens commutes to work and forces families and children to travel far away from home.

36:55To change locations, change schools.

36:58Landlords like to call themselves housing providers.

37:01But when housing becomes too expensive for a tenant to afford, the landlords abandon their responsibility to provide housing.

37:07If landlords want to be considered housing providers, they must take responsibility for providing housing in all circumstances, not only when it benefits their bottom line.

37:17If a landlord raises rent above what tenants can afford, it should not be the tenant's responsibility to relocate.

37:23No, no one is forcing the landlords to raise their rent 10% every year, and inflation has not increased by double digits since 2022.

37:31If a tenant is forced to relocate, the burden must be placed on the housing provider for failing to provide housing.

37:38The ordinances before the committee today are essential to help people remain housed.

37:43Lowering the relocation assistance threshold to 5% would provide a modest yet important safety net within a broken housing system.

37:50Adjusting relocation assistance amounts to reflect inflation is necessary to ensure that costs keeping students enrolled in the same school, as we know, is widely recognized as supporting the strongest educational outcomes.

38:04I urge you to pass these ordinances out of committee and amend the Portland Renters Additional Protections Code.

Unidentified speaker 38:10 - 38:10

38:10Thank you.

Diego 38:12 - 38:13

38:12Rowan, you may begin.

Rowan Harvey 38:15 - 39:39

38:15Hi.

38:16Okay, good, we can hear.

38:17My name is Rowan Harvey.

38:18For the record, I am a District 3 resident, and I am also a parent to 2 Portland Public Schools students.

38:22I'm a single mom to 2 school-aged children and someone that has a lot of experience having to move because we can't afford it.

38:30When my daughter was barely—.

38:33She wasn't even a year old, we had to move from Portland to Gresham, which doubled my commute at that time.

38:40And currently I'm living in Southeast Portland and just got a notice that our rent is being raised just barely under 5%.

38:48Thank you.

38:49Um, 5% would be $94.

38:51They're raising it by $68, um, which means that we will barely be able to afford our rent for the next year.

38:59And if they raise it again next year, we're definitely not going to be able to afford it.

39:03Um, like I said, I got 2 kids, and it is already a lot to commute without a car, and having to extend that commute again for them is I'm kind of going off the cuff here, so I don't really have much more to say, but I definitely support all 3 of these.

39:25I want to make sure that families are protected and that renters no longer have to move for economic— like you said, the word is dying in my brain, but thank you for your time.

Candace Avalos 39:40 - 39:43

39:40Economic eviction.

39:42Thank you.

39:42Thank you.

Diego 39:44 - 39:46

39:44Henry is online.

39:45You may unmute and begin when you're ready.

Henry Scheffer 39:49 - 41:50

39:49Hi there, I'm Henry Scheffer, a renter in District 2.

39:52Thank you for taking the time to listen to the needs of tenants in Portland.

39:55I've come to you to ask that the threshold for triggering relocation assistance be lowered to 5%.

40:01I do not think I need to tell you that it's currently very unaffordable to be a renter in Portland.

40:05Housing prices and rental rates continue to rise under those conditions, even moderate increases in rent can prove financially disastrous.

40:16I myself currently pay around 50% of my income on my rent.

40:21Under current laws, if my landlord were to increase rent by anywhere above 5%, I would be forced to move out and relocate without any assistance.

40:28Because of the current rental environment, without assistance, I would likely have to move somewhere cheaper or move in with family in another another city.

40:33Thank you.

40:33State, taking the economic activity of my small business and my contributions to my community out of Portland.

40:39I'm fortunate enough to have a support system that can help me if that were to happen, God forbid.

40:43However, many of the valued tenants in my community do not have the same support to fall back on.

40:48Decreasing the threshold to trigger for relocation assistance will provide a vital safety net to, quote unquote, stop the flow of Portlanders into homelessness.

40:56One of the strongest tools we have in our toolbox to address the homelessness crisis in Portland is to prevent people from entering homelessness as anyone will tell you, it's incredibly difficult to become housed once one loses their housing due to a failed transition from cost prohibition.

41:10As I said, I'm a business owner.

41:11I'm a tutor who works with Portland Public School students.

41:14As an educator, I know how damaging it can be for a student to have to forcibly switch schools in the middle of a school year.

41:19School offers a unique network of support that takes significant time, trust, and resources to build.

41:25Preventing this during the school year will ease the burden on PPS as well, which as we all know is going through a going staffing crisis.

41:28Thank you.

41:28Through some, some issues at the moment.

41:31And tying it to inflation will make this a dependable policy that Portlanders can rely on.

41:37Lastly, I would urge the council to consider what exemptions to relocation assistance might look like.

41:41For example, a landlord moving a family member in.

41:45I would argue that just because it's a family member, that does not relieve the hardship put on the tenant who is losing their housing.

41:50Thank you.

Diego 41:53 - 41:54

41:53Jordan, you may begin.

Jordan Carter 41:55 - 43:56

41:55Hi, my name is Jordan Carter, Portland native, and I've been a commercial real estate broker in Portland for 20 years.

42:01Uh, I sell apartment buildings for a living.

42:04I talk to owners, uh, every day and investors.

42:07I review financials and rent rolls for hundreds of buildings every year.

42:11Um, I respect the intent behind lowering the relocation trigger, uh, but there's intent and there's impact.

42:18Uh, Portland doesn't have a rent problem.

42:21It has an expense problem, and it has an income and jobs problem, and these ordinances fix none of that.

42:28Over the last 20 years, Portland rents have increased an average of 2.2%, and over the last 5 years, they've increased less than 1% per year.

42:38And adjusted for inflation, rents are actually down 14% over the last 5 years.

42:44Over that same time, total expenses for apartment buildings have increased 40%.

42:51That's 55% for electricity, Insurance is up 45%.

42:55Water and sewer, which the city sets, 32%.

42:58Garbage, 30%.

43:01On expenses, the lever that, that you control directly is, is cost, like the utilities and the development fees.

43:09Most current apartment owners want out of this city, and the investors that we talk to every day say, I'll look anywhere but Portland.

43:18And most developers won't touch Portland right now at all.

43:22Tightening the regulations is only going to make this worse.

43:24Thank you.

43:25When few people will build or invest money here, we lose the jobs that create income and lose the new supply that actually brings rents down.

43:34Let's focus on controlling runaway expenses, creating jobs and support for small businesses, and increasing targeted rental assistance rather than further tightening regulations, which the market has shown are not necessary and will only continue to negatively impact the the city's reputation.

43:55Thank you.

Diego 43:58 - 44:22

43:58Next is Christian Bryant, Monet Wilds, Molly Hogan, David Buerer, Shona Lepis.

44:19David is online.

44:20David, you can unmute and begin when you're ready.

David Buerer 44:24 - 46:22

44:24Hi, my name is David Buerer.

44:25I grew up in Beaverton and have lived in Gladstone for 8 years.

44:29These topics are important to me because I love transforming apartment complexes into communities.

44:34I'm not out.

44:35I invest in Portland.

44:36I don't want out.

44:37There are 3 questions, however, you must ask.

44:40One, how will these policies impact the community members who need a place to live?

44:44Secondly, how will these policy members impact those investing in our communities, and how will landlords react?

44:50Let's talk about reality.

44:52I'm certain there's a perception that landlords have all this money, and it's simply not true right now.

44:57Handyman maintenance costs run $60 to $90 an hour.

45:00Garbage, insurance, landscaping services, and even wages are up.

45:04We feel this pain.

45:05Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies just published its 2026 State of the Nation's Housing Report, where they discovered a couple of interesting facts.

45:14Between 2025 and 2026, rents have declined somewhat sharply.

45:19Yet between 2019 and 2026, operating expenses jumped nearly 37%.

45:25That works out to about 5.3% increase per year.

45:30Secondly, utilities, which are regulated, have also increased between 2023 and 2027.

45:37Electricity went up 11%, 7%, 18.5%, 5.5%, and in 2027, it's proposed a 3.9% increase.

45:44Thank you.

45:46Increase.

45:48One property I've been looking at in the city, expenses are running about 66% of income, and that's before capital or any mortgage payment.

45:56If expenses are increasing at a rate of more than 5% per year, how do we impose a 5% rent cap and call it reasonable?

46:04The existing state 10% increase is reasonable and something we can live with.

46:08We don't want drastic increases in rent.

46:10It creates hardships for our tenants.

46:12However, communities must stay operational.

46:16So thank you for taking the time to listen to me.

46:19Thank you for the time and your efforts in this, and have a fantastic day.

Diego 46:25 - 46:34

46:25Christian, you may begin.

46:33Monet?

Monet Wilds 46:36 - 48:54

46:36That's me.

46:38Um, good afternoon, people behind the desk and everybody else.

46:43In the seats.

46:44Um, I— my name is Monet Wilds, and I'm actually not in any of your districts.

46:49I'm lined out just a little bit, but I would hope that you guys could hear me not as somebody who has a stake necessarily in this, but as somebody who has a lived experience that I know is all too common.

47:01Um, I have just this year recently escaped houselessness, and, um, this, this year has been my first experience with rent hiking.

47:15Um, when I first received the notice in November, because my lease is on February, I was very taken aback.

47:24I actually wanted to throw up and cry.

47:27Um, my rent right now is on a voucher, um, and if I didn't have that voucher that I waited 3 years in poverty for, I wouldn't be able to make rent naturally.

47:38But I wanted to run some numbers and do some math because I wasn't always this poor.

47:43I once tried to make a living and I worked at Intel for $22 an hour.

47:48This was around 2023, and that was me making around $45,000 a year.

47:54I would usually take home actually about $2,000 a month after taxes and non-household bills.

47:59I would not be able to afford my current rent.

48:01I would not be able to afford my current rent.

48:04Even if I was still working there, even if I was still making that much and including all of the hypothetical raises that I probably wouldn't have even gotten.

48:14That means very much that this is unattainable.

48:189.9% Right now is the fine line between humane and cruel and unusual.

48:24You guys have the power to change that to 5%, which is so much more attainable, like we've heard.

48:29So just remember when you're considering the full scope of what humanity looks like, that protecting Portland renters means adjusting adjusting the percentage at which the rent increase triggers relocation assistance, adjusting relocation assistance amounts to reflect inflation, and increasing the assistance for tenants with school-aged children all go hand in hand in efficacy, because to stifle one is to stifle them all, especially the latter.

48:51I think we all can agree that even competent parents deserve help.

48:54Thank you.

Diego 48:57 - 48:57

48:57Molly Hogan.

Molly Hogan 49:00 - 51:27

49:00Hello, members of the committee.

49:02My name is Molly Hogan, and I'm with the Welcome Home Coalition.

49:06A housing justice alliance in the Portland Metro.

49:09I'm also a registered lobbyist with the City of Portland, and I'm here today to ask you to please pass all 3 of these ordinance amendments discussed as quickly as possible and vote on them in the full council, like ASAP.

49:22They are awesome.

49:23The first amendment to reduce the existing threshold that triggers the relocation assistance from 10% to 5% is an overdue improvement to renter protection city law.

49:33Since the state passed the rent cap at 10% statewide, we know that there's increases happening at rates between 5% and 10% that also displace renters due to affordability issues.

49:44We've heard these powerful testimonies today, and lowering the rate to 5% just makes sense to match that reality.

49:52The second amendment to increase relocation assistance amounts to adjust for inflation is another no-brainer.

49:58All everybody's talking about these days, right, is the inflation of cost of living.

50:03Everything's going up, and that includes, includes the cost of moving.

50:07So this should be an obvious yes for the city to update.

50:11And the landlords can handle this cost.

50:12They invest in a property and the renters pay the mortgage for them.

50:16At the end of the day, the investment in property is a business, and doing business has costs.

50:22This is one of those costs.

50:24And I want to speak directly to some of the testifiers today talking about rents decreasing in the last year.

50:29Okay.

50:29I'm sorry.

50:30That's fair.

50:31But you know what?

50:31Rents skyrocketed so much in the last decade that them falling a little bit doesn't mean they're suddenly affordable.

50:37All right.

50:38So if we're talking a numbers game, like, we need to keep that in front of mind.

50:43And also, they kept quoting utility increase costs.

50:47Guess who pays utilities?

50:48Tenants.

50:50Like, I'm sorry, my landlord doesn't pay my utility bill.

50:53I do.

50:55And so the 3rd amendment to offer additional relocation costs for households with children under 18 is also so humane.

51:01Thank you.

51:02I'm going to get personal now.

51:04I'm a mother, and I actually received relocation assistance when I was evicted 2 years ago because the house I was renting was sold.

51:12Moving as a single mom with my 10-year-old was emotional.

51:15Oh my gosh, I didn't think I was gonna get— and physically exhausting.

51:19And the relocation assistance was huge to reduce my stress.

51:22So pass these and let's get it going, y'all.

51:26Good job.

51:26Thanks.

Shona Lepis 51:29 - 52:28

51:29Shona Lepis.

51:30Shona is online.

51:39Shona, you should be able to click the unmute button when you're ready.

51:50We'll move on to Christian Bryant.

51:52Once more for Christian.

52:02All right, we'll move on to, let's see, Kaydee Williams, Chris Merz, Benjamin Gilbert, Jacob Gerke, Lacey Sutton.

52:17Aye.

52:26And Chris Merz is online.

52:27You may begin when you're ready.

Chris Merz 52:35 - 52:37

52:35All right, can everyone hear me?

Shona Lepis 52:38 - 52:39

52:38We can hear you.

Chris Merz 52:39 - 54:48

52:39Great, thank you.

52:41Chair, members of the committee, my name is Chris Merz.

52:45We buy and renovate older apartment buildings in Portland.

52:49I'm here on documents 2026-418, 419, and 420.

52:55Let me start with tenants.

52:56An unexpected move is genuinely hard.

53:00A new school, a longer commute, a neighborhood you did not choose.

53:05Displaced families deserve real help.

53:09That is a goal I share.

53:10Thank you.

53:11How help rises matters.

53:14If payments go up, phase them in over several years.

53:18Document 2026-419 raises them 32 to 53% in one step, then grows them automatically every year.

53:27On a 60-unit building of 2 bedrooms, if every tenant qualified and requested one lawful 6% increase, could mean over $360,000 due in 31 days.

53:44On 2026-418, state law already caps rent increases at 9.5%.

53:50A trigger at half the cap punishes owners who kept rents low for years.

53:55Tie the trigger to the statewide cap.

53:59On 2026-420, the children's payment has no stated amount, and the city itself warns it could increase discrimination against the families it aims to help.

54:13Define the amount first.

54:17Finally, the bigger picture.

54:19Construction across the Portland metro has fallen from nearly 13,000 apartments in 2022 to about 2,500 today, the lowest in over a decade.

54:29This package adds no homes.

54:31It adds costs and risks to older rentals and discourages owners from buying them at all when Portland most needs investment in the housing it already has.

54:40Phase any increase in gradually.

54:43Tie the trigger to the state cap.

54:45Define the children's payments before the vote.

54:47Thank you.

Diego 54:53 - 55:03

54:53Kaydee, you may begin.

55:01Benjamin Gilbert, you may begin.

Benjamin Gilbert 55:04 - 56:51

55:04My name is Benjamin Gilbert, and I'm a volunteer lobbyist for the Portland Democratic Socialists of America and a tenant in District 4.

55:11I want to start this testimony with a message of solidarity.

55:13CPPW workers are, as we speak, on strike and deserve a fair contract.

55:18Launa workers are also without a contract and may strike.

55:20Every city councilor should be demanding that Mayor Wilson come to the table and give city workers a fair contract, and they should be I want to thank Councilor Mitch Green and Councilor Candace Avalos for bringing this crucial legislation.

55:36Many of you on the dais would agree with the statement housing is a human right, but this right is hollow if we don't back it up.

55:43Housing is a human right means that we as a society have an active obligation to house the people.

55:47If that means the owning class doesn't profit, so be it, because it is the working class being thrown onto the street.

55:52It is the working class forced to live in tents or cars.

55:55Councilor Mitch Green.

55:56In 2017, Portland City Council passed an ordinance to create mandatory renter relocation assistance.

56:02But now, nearly 10 years later, Portland is still in a housing crisis.

56:06We will hear and have heard from landlords that will whine about the effect on their investments.

56:10To that, I say that investments carry risks, and when your ROI requires crushing working families and putting people on the street, get ready for democracy to crash your balance sheet.

56:20Thank you.

56:21More than 50% of Portland renters were cost burdened in 2023, and a quarter of those renters paid 50% or more of their income in rent.

56:30And they have a voice in this government too, and they vote, and they have voted.

56:35Lowering the relocation assistance threshold is just one step towards a just housing system.

56:40We need a renters' bill of rights to ensure no one is left behind, and we need social housing to fix this long term.

56:46Workers deserve more.

56:48Workers deserve a system where housing is truly a human right.

Diego 56:56 - 56:57

56:56Jacob Gerke.

Jacob Gerke 57:00 - 58:59

57:00Hello, my name is Jacob Gerke.

57:01I am a renter in District 3.

57:04We all know what this ordinance is.

57:06It's an incentive to landlords to never again raise the rent more than 5%.

57:09To the landlords, do you think that we intend to stop at 5%?

57:13Because that's not even close.

57:15Housing is an inelastic good.

57:16Do you all know what that means?

57:18Economics 101.

57:20Elastic goods are things whose demand curve changes with price.

57:22Think about a can of Coke.

57:23At $0.25, you'd buy a lot of cans of Coke.

57:26At $25, you'd buy zero cans of Coke because you don't need Coke to survive.

57:29That's a pretty simple concept.

57:31But inelastic goods are things whose demand curve does not change with price.

57:35If housing costs $0.25, everyone can have good housing.

57:38If housing costs $2.5 million, only the rich get to have good housing.

57:41And if someone buys up all the housing in the city and says you're only allowed to live here if you pay X amount of dollars per month, then we literally call that landlords right now are making profits off of doing absolutely nothing.

57:55The claim from landlords who have spoken today is that they do maintenance, but I guarantee almost every single person in this room has a story of ignored or shoddy maintenance handling by landlords and managers.

58:04No, rent-seeking behavior is literally defined by charging money to do absolutely nothing.

58:08And so while economists will teach you about inelastic goods and rent-seeking behavior, what they will never do is say that profiting off of these things is immoral or sinful or against all basic human decency, because that would expose the game of capitalism for what it is.

58:20Thank you.

58:22As stated before, I live in District 3.

58:25I happily ranked Councilors Murillo and Koyama Lane 1 and 2 because they do not need to hear what I have to say.

58:31They understand it fully.

58:33Where my doubt lies with Councilor Novick, I did not rank him because I did not think he could meet this moment, but now is the chance for him and Councilor Pirtle-Guiney to prove me wrong.

58:41These ordinances are a tiny step for the working class.

58:44Landlords complaining about cost of living increases do not get one single pity tear out of me.

58:50If you're a landlord scared of making not enough money, if your name is Eric Zimmerman or I have one sentence for each of you.

58:56I work at Hawthorne Safeway and we're hiring right now.

58:58Thank you for your time.

Diego 59:02 - 59:03

59:02Lacey Sutton.

Lacey Sutton 59:04 - 1:01:13

59:04I'm Lacey Sutton.

59:06I fully support strengthening protections for renters.

59:09Is this loud enough?

59:11I thought you might appreciate a story from someone who actually got relocation assistance and just how hard it was to get it.

59:184 Years ago in our old apartment, we learned our rent was increasing by 23%.

59:23I read the fine print that came with the notice and requested relocation assistance.

59:27The manager told me, however, that we did not qualify because they were part of the MULTI program, which is the Multiple Unit Limited Tax Exemption program, which made our apartment technically affordable and the rules didn't apply to it.

59:40That is nonsense.

59:41So I argued with them a lot.

59:44I requested everything in writing and I went door to door to tell my neighbors that they could do the same and request this assistance.

59:51And several people did.

59:52Thank you.

59:53I tried to get help from the city, but there really wasn't a lot of help available.

59:57Like, the Portland Housing Bureau mostly just sent me the letter of the law and reminded me that they were not attorneys.

1:00:06So I just Googled it a lot and prepared to take these— this company to small claims court.

1:00:12But just before the 30 days, we got a letter in the mail.

1:00:15We all got letters in the mail.

1:00:17They were not going to increase the rent after all.

1:00:20Oh, good.

1:00:20We were very happy, but the cherry on top was getting another letter from the management company's attorney who clearly also read the fine print.

1:00:29It was a check for $4,200.

1:00:32And in case anyone was worried about this, uh, company, they own hundreds of properties across the United States and they're going to be just fine.

1:00:41They're going to be all right.

1:00:43Um, they did even eventually increase the rent by 9.99%.

1:00:47Of course.

1:00:48Uh, I went to a couple of rental rip-off town halls, and several people said they requested assistance and were denied.

1:00:54So, um, I suspect that this happens a lot.

1:00:58Uh, relocation assistance is good at primarily 2 things: it helps people move, but it also disincentivizes large rent hikes.

1:01:05That is only true if landlords believe renters will actually be able to get it.

1:01:09A tool is only useful if people can actually use it.

1:01:13So thank you.

Diego 1:01:16 - 1:01:45

1:01:16Once more for Kaydee Williams.

1:01:22Next up is William Grippo, Coty Thurman, Mike Brennan, Madeline Miller, Patrick Barry.

1:01:43And William, you may begin when you're ready.

William Grippo 1:01:48 - 1:03:57

1:01:48Yes, hello, my name is William Grippo.

1:01:50I'm a dad, a housing provider, and a real estate broker.

1:01:55While I appreciate the intent here, I still oppose 2026, 418, 419, and 420 as written.

1:02:04My immediate concern is for both residents and owners.

1:02:06When these added costs land on small owners, many will sell to buyers who move in.

1:02:12I know because I helped them.

1:02:13I helped them in 2017, 2018.

1:02:17Each of these single-family houses is one less house to rent.

1:02:21With fewer houses, the next resident pays more as a lower supply of available houses puts upward pressure on asking rents.

1:02:29I realize that these new proposals impact multifamily as well.

1:02:32But single-family houses, you know, the impact on them can't be overstated.

1:02:39They're becoming more scarce each year or scarcer each year as small owners exit the market.

1:02:44I know this as I've helped them, housing providers sell their forever, these homes, and they never come back to the market.

1:02:52So I feel it's my opinion that since we are in a housing crisis, Thank you.

1:02:59I think your first goal should be, does what we're doing today increase housing?

1:03:04Does it increase incentives to develop housing?

1:03:08You know, it should not diminish housing.

1:03:13So I just feel like we do not need to disincentivize single-family homeowners.

1:03:18And this is no dig on my multifamily folks here, but we don't need to give them another reason to not.

1:03:27I support a system that's publicly funded that is sustainable.

1:03:30A family's help doesn't depend on whether one particular owner can absorb the cost.

1:03:34We are not going to solve a major issue and a societal issue without the public support.

1:03:39The current relocation ordinance was meant to help tenants that have a move after a no-cause termination or a large rental increase and to reduce the chance those moves end up in homelessness.

1:03:49That need is real.

1:03:51The city keeps trying to meet its housing goals by shifting more costs and risks onto housing providers by piling more and more costs.

1:03:56I think that's a good point.

Diego 1:04:02 - 1:04:06

1:04:02Time's up.

1:04:02Thank you.

1:04:04Coty, you may begin.

Coty Thurman 1:04:07 - 1:05:52

1:04:07Hi, good afternoon, councilors.

1:04:08I'm Coty Thurman.

1:04:09I'm a property manager here in Portland.

1:04:11I'm advocating for the individuals and families across all districts who provide the 400 single-family homes that are in my rental portfolio.

1:04:18I'm advocating to vote no for all 3 housing proposals.

1:04:22Any potential new client who calls my office right now falls into one of 2 camps.

1:04:27They're either struggling to sell their home or they are selling their home because they are looking for a new home.

1:04:29Self-managing and are unraveling from a very tough tenancy.

1:04:33When I ask them, why do you want to be a housing provider, the answer is usually, I don't, uh, followed by, I just can't afford to pay 2 mortgages, or it's too complicated to do this without professional help.

1:04:45This is not the temperament we want from our housing providers, but it's what's left.

1:04:49Potential housing providers are fighting these costs— are figuring these costs into the rent prices when they are deciding if they can afford to rent their home.

1:04:57Oftentimes the answer is We can't afford it.

1:04:59So the home goes to the sales market and becomes a $650,000 starter home that our renting families still can't afford.

1:05:06This is one less home offered to a renter for the next 2 to 3 years.

1:05:10The renters who pay for this are not the ones who are being relocated, the ones who never got the keys because the home was never made available.

1:05:18The proposal revisits a common theme regarding housing shortages and inflation, yet the conditions to be a housing provider become more and more unfavorable, and rents as reported by data centers like Zillow, provide that rents themselves have remained flat for the last 3 years.

1:05:33This narrative that rents are increasing across the board is false.

1:05:37Please don't raise the relocation amounts and push out another tier of potential rental inventory.

1:05:42Yes, housing is expensive for both parties, so solve the housing shortage problem without tying the hands of the few left willing to provide it.

1:05:51Please vote no on all 3 proposals.

Diego 1:05:55 - 1:05:56

1:05:55Mike, you may begin.

Mike Brennan 1:05:58 - 1:07:53

1:05:58Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak.

1:06:00I'm Mike Brennan, property manager here in Portland.

1:06:03I might want to touch on the point of who a lot of these rental property owners are.

1:06:10I think it's easy in this conversation to kind of paint with a big brush and think of them as large corporations or out-of-state entities.

1:06:19Pretty much all of our clients, in fact all of them, are just everyday working folk like just about everybody here.

1:06:28They are teachers, they are single moms, they are government employees, and they have to deal with the rising costs that we're all experiencing as well.

1:06:41So when that comes to maintenance, when it comes to, in some cases, covering utilities, They have to bear that additional cost and it's really hard for them.

1:06:53So in the greater context, you know, we're looking at what those folks own, approximately 34,000 single-family homes in Portland, which are really valued by families who rent.

1:07:12Yeah.

1:07:13It's been stated here several times that as regulation increases, as the difficulty in owning a rental property increases for these individuals in Portland, they're more likely to sell and be replaced.

1:07:29The rental becomes an owner-occupied home in a lot of cases, and we lose that inventory.

1:07:34Unfortunately, Portland isn't stimulating a lot of rental housing development right now.

1:07:40And I am concerned that a significant portion of the 34,000 single-family homes could go away in the next 5 years or so if these proposals pass.

1:07:51So I encourage you to vote no.

1:07:53Thank you.

Diego 1:07:56 - 1:07:57

1:07:56Madeline, you're up next.

Madeline Miller 1:07:58 - 1:10:08

1:07:58Good afternoon, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, and members of the committee.

1:08:03For the record, my name is Madeline Miller.

1:08:04I use she/her pronouns.

1:08:05I'm a lobbyist with the Building Owners and Managers Association CREA Oregon and Oregon Smart Growth and the Portland Metro Chamber.

1:08:13I'm also a researcher.

1:08:14I spent 9 years at ECHO Northwest evaluating housing supply and housing affordability policies and 3 years working at an affordable housing nonprofit.

1:08:21And I'm also a mom and an almost stepmom to 3 young kids.

1:08:26I share the goal of preventing displacement and helping Portlanders remain stably housed, but my concern is that parts of this proposal may produce the opposite effect over the longer term.

1:08:36I want to ensure that we pass thoughtfully, carefully evaluated policies to house Portlanders now and in the future.

1:08:44I am particularly concerned about reducing the rent increase trigger from 10% to 5% and pairing it with the substantially larger relocation payments phased in all at once.

1:08:53Recently, I heard from the owner of a 9-unit apartment building in Northwest Portland.

1:08:57As you've heard, their operating costs have gone up 20%, 25% in a single year due to insurance, maintenance, trash, cleaning, other service contracts.

1:09:06Like many small housing providers, they're not seeing rapidly rising rents year over year.

1:09:11They are just trying to keep pace with expenses and break even and maintain their properties.

1:09:17One or two of these larger bedroom relocations as proposed would wipe out years of reserves intended for capital repairs.

1:09:26The risk is not that housing disappears, but the risk is that local owners leave the market.

1:09:30When I worked at ECHO Northwest, I analyzed rental housing consolidation in the city of Eugene.

1:09:35We found evidence that small landlords were exiting the market and selling to larger operators, and the city's own survey found that smaller landlords were more flexible with their tenants, less likely to charge additional fees, and more likely to raise rents only when necessary.

1:09:48I know Portland Housing Bureau is almost ready to conduct its own study of these types of policies, and I urge you to wait until we see those results.

1:09:55I respectfully ask you to slow down, study the long-term impacts, and avoid changes that may ultimately reduce housing Patrick, you may begin.

Diego 1:10:09 - 1:10:09

1:10:09Thank you.

Patrick Barry 1:10:09 - 1:12:04

1:10:09Good afternoon, councilors.

1:10:10Thank you for the opportunity to testify.

1:10:12My name is Patrick Barry, and I'm here to urge you to vote no on lowering Portland's relocation assistance threshold from 10% to 5%.

1:10:18I'm a lifelong resident raising my family here, and I want Portland to succeed.

1:10:23I want vibrant neighborhoods, a strong economy, a city where people of all income levels can afford to live.

1:10:28For the past 16 years, I've worked as a commercial real estate appraiser specializing exclusively in multifamily housing.

1:10:35I strongly believe that the most important things we can do for Portland's future is increase housing supply.

1:10:40Publicly funded and nonprofit housing play important roles, but their enormous development costs, almost 2 times that of market rate, mean we cannot rely on them alone.

1:10:48The vast majority of our existing rental housing was built through private investment, and we'll need that investment to continue.

1:10:54Thank you.

1:10:55Every additional expense, restriction, and layer of uncertainty makes Portland less competitive for that investment.

1:11:01I admit, lowering the threshold from 10% to 5% won't make or break Portland's housing market, but that's precisely the problem.

1:11:08It's one more regulatory burden layered on top of many others, each making Portland a less attractive place for investment.

1:11:16The recent departure of Mill Creek, which developed nearly 2,700 housing units in Portland, over a 10-year period is further evidence of the challenges facing developers and investors in our market.

1:11:27The real cost of this proposal isn't just the relocation payments.

1:11:30It's the investment that goes elsewhere, the properties that don't get improved, and the housing that never gets built.

1:11:36I understand the desire to protect tenants from displacements, and I share that goal, but we need to consider whether the limited relief this may change— provide justifies the much larger opportunity cost to Portland's housing future.

1:11:49Second.

1:11:49It's hypocritical to claim that we want more housing while continuing to pass regulations that discourage the very investment needed to build it.

1:11:56We cannot regulate our way into housing abundance.

1:11:59We have to make it easier to provide housing, not harder.

1:12:02I respectfully urge you to vote no.

1:12:04Thank you.

Zachary Lindahl 1:12:08 - 1:14:30

1:12:08Next up is Zachary Lindahl, Jonathan Clay, Cyndi Monroe, good afternoon, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, and members of the committee.

1:12:29Uh, for the record, my name is Zachary Lindahl with Multifamily Northwest and registered lobbyist here in Portland.

1:12:35Uh, and I'm here on behalf of this organization to, uh, discuss the relocation ordinance that would reduce the rent increase threshold trigger for relocation payments from 10% to 5%.

1:12:46In September, the Housing Bureau told this committee that relocation notices tied to rent increases fell from 27 in fiscal year 2022-2023 to 4 in fiscal year 2024-2025.

1:12:58Large rent increases have become rare in Portland under the rules already in place.

1:13:02Oregon already has statewide rent stabilization protections in place since 2019.

1:13:07State law has established an annual limit on rent increases for residential tenancies across Oregon.

1:13:12Since 2023, the limit has been, been the lesser of 10% or 7% plus, uh, inflation— 9% this year and 10% in 2027.

1:13:23Portland's proposal would effectively create an additional layer of rent regulation on top of the protections already established by the state.

1:13:31By lowering the relocation threshold to 5%, the city is creating a significant financial penalty for housing providers who exercise a right that is already expressly regulated under state law.

1:13:40It is also important to consider the current rental market.

1:13:43Average rents across the Portland metropolitan area have remained relatively flat for more than 3 years.

1:13:48The narrative that drastic rent increases are occurring throughout the market and necessitate additional restrictions does not accurately reflect these broader market conditions.

1:13:57We are concerned about the precedent this proposal sets.

1:13:59Oregon established a statewide framework to provide consistency and predictability for both renters and housing providers.

1:14:04Allowing individual jurisdictions to layer additional financial penalties onto the framework creates an increasingly fragmented regulatory environment.

1:14:12Housing providers need predictability to make responsible business decisions, maintain their properties, plan for capital improvements, and continue providing rental housing.

1:14:20Continually changing the rules makes this increasingly difficult.

1:14:24We respectfully ask this committee to reject the proposed reduction of the relocation threshold from 10% to 5%.

1:14:29Thank you for your consideration.

Diego 1:14:33 - 1:14:34

1:14:33Jonathan, you may begin.

Jonathan Clay 1:14:36 - 1:16:43

1:14:36Good afternoon.

1:14:37My name is Jonathan Clay, a registered lobbyist here today on behalf of Multifamily Northwest to express our serious concerns regarding the proposed increases to Portland's mandatory relocation payments.

1:14:52The proposed increases are substantial, ranging from 32% to a 53% again, these are not modest adjustments.

1:15:01They represent significant new financial obligations for housing providers, many of whom are already navigating increased operational costs and an expanding regulatory environment.

1:15:14Housing providers understand the importance of stability and recognize that unexpected costs can create significant hardships for residents.

1:15:23Thank you.

1:15:24And at the same time, policies designed to protect renters must also consider the financial realities of providing and maintaining rental housing.

1:15:35Stakeholders ought to be involved in this policy development, not merely sharing perspectives in hearings when the policy is already written.

1:15:44These relocation payments are not being proposed in isolation.

1:15:50They would be layered on top of Oregon's existing statewide rent stabilization laws, which already limit the amount housing providers can increase rents annually.

1:16:01The rationale for this policy is as if renter protections don't already exist.

1:16:07It's very much the opposite.

1:16:09The state has, has established a framework that balances renter protections with operational realities that housing providers are facing, Portland's proposal would add substantial financial penalties to a framework without adequately demonstrating why these increases are necessary.

1:16:30We are particularly concerned that the city has not conducted sufficient technical analysis or financial modeling to better understand these— the implications of these proposed increases.

1:16:42Thank you for your time.

Diego 1:16:45 - 1:16:46

1:16:45Cyndi, you may begin.

Cyndi Monroe 1:16:47 - 1:18:59

1:16:47Good afternoon, councilors.

1:16:48My name is Cyndi Monroe.

1:16:50I am a lifelong Oregonian, a single mom, a grandma, a humble investor, and a small business owner.

1:16:57I work with small independent investment property owners, often called mom-and-pop housing providers, who have chosen to invest in Portland and provide housing for our communities.

1:17:11I am here today to oppose expanding the Portland Relocation Ordinance.

1:17:17I understand and I wholeheartedly share the desire to protect tenants.

1:17:23Housing stability absolutely matters, but good intentions do not always produce good policy.

1:17:31Lowering rent increase thresholds from 10% to 5% Increasing relocation fees by as much as 53% and adding additional fees for households with school-aged children, which I fully support, creates another financial layer of risk and uncertainty for housing providers.

1:17:51And who ultimately pays for that?

1:17:54We all do.

1:17:56I want you to understand what's happening on the ground.

1:17:59Portland's investment climate has become increasingly hostile toward the very people who provide its housing.

1:18:08Small property owners are being vilified, burdened with increasing regulations, and made to feel like investing is not worth the risk anymore.

1:18:19The result: owners are selling their properties, taking their investment capital out of Oregon and reinvesting in other states.

1:18:29When a mom-and-pop owner sells the rental home, we know that that doesn't magically become affordable housing.

1:18:34Housing, it often disappears on the market permanently.

1:18:40You cannot regulate your way out of a housing shortage or a bad economy or a very needy city.

1:18:48And when you cannot create housing affordability by making providers afraid to invest in your city, I ask you to reconsider and do better.

Diego 1:19:02 - 1:19:05

1:19:02Sarah is online.

1:19:03Sarah, you may unmute and begin when you're ready.

Sarah Hayes 1:19:12 - 1:19:12

1:19:12Are you able to hear me?

Diego 1:19:13 - 1:19:14

1:19:13We can hear you.

Sarah Hayes 1:19:15 - 1:21:38

1:19:15Okay.

1:19:16Hi, uh, good afternoon, councilors.

1:19:19My name is Sarah Hayes.

1:19:20I'm a resident of District 3.

1:19:23I am a small-time independent landlord, and I oppose the ordinances before you today.

1:19:29My family depends on modest income from duplexes— from a duplex that I've owned for 20 years.

1:19:36I'm disabled.

1:19:37My daughter has 5 different diagnoses.

1:19:39I'm a single mom and I'm her primary caregiver.

1:19:43We rely on public assistance to stay housed ourselves.

1:19:49Because of this, we have very little ability individually to absorb these costs and risks.

1:19:56I understand personally the the goals behind these proposals very deeply.

1:20:01However, I don't believe that requiring individual landlords to take on these risks and and pay for the broader shift in affordability is the right tool.

1:20:12Instead, I support a city-funded needs-based program that helps renters directly who need it, and also.

1:20:19Critical for my own experience removes direct payouts from the landlord-tenant relationship, which takes them from positive to souring them.

1:20:29In my case, I actually had a dispute with a former tenant over relocation money.

1:20:35There was never a rent increase more than three percent during this period.

1:20:40I experienced a four-year conflict with the former tenants who involved that they.

1:20:46It involved vandalism, repeat entry into my private space, noise issues, other transgressions in order to create an attempt to invoke the relocation.

1:21:01More came.

1:21:03They took me to court after they moved out.

1:21:05They still took me to court twice to attempt to get relocation fee.

1:21:09They were not entitled to this.

1:21:10The judges dismissed their cases.

1:21:12I encourage you to not put these burdens on individual landlords and instead have a clear program that the city administers so that we are not in these types of situations.

1:21:37Thank you.

1:21:37Thank you.

1:21:38Thank you.

Diego 1:21:41 - 1:22:20

1:21:41Peter, you may begin when you're ready.

1:21:50Once more for Peter Robinson.

1:21:54We'll move on to Jodi Bannon, Chloe Eudaly, Margot Black, Spencer Trumm, Amon Rutherford.

1:22:19And Jodi, you may begin when you're ready.

Chloe Eudaly 1:22:27 - 1:22:28

1:22:27I think you're up.

Keelan McClymont 1:22:28 - 1:22:28

1:22:28Jodi?

Diego 1:22:29 - 1:22:36

1:22:29Who's Jodi?

1:22:29Looks like once more for Jodi.

1:22:32We'll move on to Chloe Eudaly.

Chloe Eudaly 1:22:37 - 1:26:21

1:22:37All right, is this thing on?

1:22:40Uh, hello, Chair Avalos and Vice Chair Green and committee members.

1:22:45My name is Chloe Eudaly.

1:22:47I'm a renter in D3, a former Portland City Commissioner, and I write Street Wonk, a newsletter covering local politics.

1:22:58I got to switch here because I was prepared for 3 minutes, but it's 2.

1:23:07Critical comments about Portland's tenant protections made by the mayor, Home Forward, the Econ Northwest study commissioned by the landlord lobby, and the Housing Bureau's internal evaluation have left me concerned that attacks may be coming.

1:23:24On our protections, so I'm pleased to see your effort to strengthen them, and I'm here to support your proposals today.

1:23:32My experience as a cost-burdened renter led me to the housing justice movement and eventually to City Hall and passing the relocation ordinance in 2017.

1:23:44Our biggest concession was the 10% trigger.

1:23:47City attorneys were concerned that a lower trigger made it more vulnerable to challenge.

1:23:52Thank you.

1:23:52Legal challenges.

1:23:54It has now survived every legal challenge.

1:23:57Oregon has adopted its own version of RELO, as well as cities around the country, protecting millions of renters from unchecked rent increases, landlord retaliation, and no-cause evictions.

1:24:11However, these protections didn't solve the housing emergency, didn't lower existing rents, and don't protect tenants from rents rising faster than wages.

1:24:22So yes to lowering the trigger, yes to pegging it to inflation, and yes to protections for families with minor children.

1:24:31My only suggestion is that you consider extending similar protections to vulnerable renters in the middle— in the winter months, as Seattle and Tacoma have.

1:24:43Uh, how much time do I have left?

1:24:452 seconds.

1:24:46Really?

1:24:47Will you guys give me one minute?

1:24:48Finish your thought.

1:24:49Okay.

1:24:51To the landlords that are here today, I'm tempted to repeat the messages I received as a cost-burdened renter, which were, get a better job, make better life choices, just move, eat less avocado toast.

1:25:09But I know how unhelpful those messages were to me.

1:25:13And they're not helpful today.

1:25:15They just feel good to say out loud.

1:25:19As far as the concerns about the impact on landlords and property managers, I wanna raise just a few quick issues.

1:25:28I'll give you 15 seconds.

1:25:29Sorry, I can't.

1:25:30Number one, expenses get written off.

1:25:33Tenants pay some or all of the utilities they're talking about.

1:25:39Headline rents are what those rent increases are based on, not the rents increases they charge existing tenants.

1:25:49So when they say that rents are barely going up and we don't need more protections, what they're really saying is we can't get as much from people who are just moving in and signing new leases, so we need to be able to price gouge existing tenants.

1:26:04Okay.

1:26:05I'll leave it at that.

1:26:06Thank you very much.

1:26:07I know that it's easy to say housing is a human right.

1:26:12It's harder to face the political realities of making it so.

1:26:17So I really want to commend you today.

1:26:19Thank you.

1:26:21Thank you.

Diego 1:26:22 - 1:26:27

1:26:22Margot Black is online.

1:26:24Margot, you may unmute and begin when you're ready.

Margot Black 1:26:29 - 1:26:30

1:26:29All right, can you guys hear me?

Diego 1:26:31 - 1:26:31

1:26:31We can hear you.

Margot Black 1:26:32 - 1:28:46

1:26:32Great.

1:26:33All right.

1:26:33Thank you for hearing my testimony today, councilors.

1:26:37This is my first time testifying in front of the new government.

1:26:40So thanks for making the time today.

1:26:43I'm very excited about these amendments.

1:26:47I was— I'm a D1 resident.

1:26:49I'm actually a homeowner as of less than a year.

1:26:53I guess according to Billy Grippo, I'm sort of what shouldn't happen.

1:26:58I'm 40, I just turned 48, and I bought my very first home with a lot of down payment assistance at 47.

1:27:18But when I was finally ready to buy, it turned out that the, the home I bought was a rental for the previous 12 years.

1:27:25I got in touch with the previous tenants.

1:27:28The owner didn't have to pay RELO.

1:27:30He just waited for them to decide to put in their notice.

1:27:34Naturally, they all found new places to live.

1:27:37He just— he and his wife just decided that— I guess they— I don't know.

1:27:41I guess they left the business, but he didn't.

1:27:43I also got in touch with him and he didn't say it had anything to do with RELO and I ended up, you know, being able to buy my very first home and put down roots in D1 in outer Southeast Portland.

1:27:55My youngest is 16.

1:27:57I'm hoping that I'll be able to have grandkids here, and I hope that it's not my fault as a homebuyer, first-time homebuyer of a former rental, that's really causing the housing crisis here, because to hear the landlords talk about it, landlords leaving the market is really the biggest risk.

1:28:14First of all, I talk to renters all the time whose buildings are being bought by national investors, whose property managers are switching.

1:28:23Investment in the Portland area is not a problem.

1:28:27The relo trigger really should be lower.

1:28:30Mitch, you know, through exponential growth, 5% a year, every year looks real bad after 10 years.

1:28:37So there's even more reform that we should be doing, but I really support the changes that are proposed, and I'll be back to testify when it's in front of City Council.

1:28:45Thank you so much for your hard work.

Keelan McClymont 1:28:50 - 1:28:51

1:28:50Spencer, you may begin when you're ready.

Spencer Trumm 1:29:07 - 1:31:06

1:29:07Good afternoon, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, and Councilors Novick, Koyama Lane, and Pirtle-Guiney.

1:29:12For the record, my name is Spencer My name is Spencer Trumm, and I'm a renter in District 3.

1:29:16I'm a state employee, but today I'm testifying only on my own behalf and on my own time.

1:29:20I'm here to urge you to adopt Ordinances 2026-418, 419, and 420.

1:29:25I live in Southeast Portland with 2 housemates on a month-to-month lease.

1:29:29I've been trying to get by on reduced hours for the last year, and this means my paycheck has gone down, not up.

1:29:36For the first half of this year, I paid nearly 50% of my salary.

1:29:40Order.

1:29:41As net paycheck into rent.

1:29:42And for reference, I've always lived with housemates across districts 1, 3, and 4.

1:29:47My rent has gone up 43.9% over the last 12 years, and my paycheck has certainly not gone up that much.

1:29:54A 10% rent increase would be difficult for me to swallow, but for renters with kids or disabilities and our lowest-wage workers, it is unsurvivable.

1:30:02Let's be clear, these ordinances do not ban rent increases above 5%, but they do force landlords to reckon just a little bit more with the life-shattering consequences of eviction.

1:30:14They don't provide renters with a home, but with a parachute.

1:30:17A parachute can save your life when you're falling.

1:30:21The money the city wisely allocated for relocation in 2017 doesn't buy what it used to.

1:30:26Inflation has continued to raise the cost of living across America, and corporate speculation has been turbocharged by AI models and a greed-is-good culture.

1:30:34Working people like me have to pay more for less as a result of this.

1:30:37Inflation makes it that much harder for renters to move, even when they find a new place.

1:30:40Thank you.

1:30:41But we can relieve the pressure.

1:30:43We can relieve the pressure, the pressure on workers who make Portland go and their families who make it special.

1:30:49To do that, we need to cool things down.

1:30:51We need to encourage stability by discouraging economic evictions, and we need to help Portlanders when they're pushed out of their homes through no fault of their own.

1:31:01We need to discourage economic evictions.

1:31:03So I urge you to vote yes and pass these ordinances without delay.

1:31:06Thank you.

1:31:06Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:31:09 - 1:31:10

1:31:09Amon, you may begin.

Amon Rutherford 1:31:10 - 1:32:16

1:31:10My name is Amon Rutherford.

1:31:12I'm a chef for the Blazers.

1:31:13I also work for Hygiene for All Safe Transportation.

1:31:17I was supposed to have like a theme developed like everybody else writing, but my phone broke.

1:31:21So I'm gonna come off the cuff like the dude that just left with the hat on his head.

1:31:27I liked this speech because it was real.

1:31:29It was in the moment, and that's how I am.

1:31:31So I'm not nervous.

1:31:33I see you guys a lot of times.

1:31:34Some of you guys are like my Instagram family.

1:31:38So, um, I'm gonna let you know that, um, when I was in Arizona and I used to talk to family and friends out here, all they talked about was the rent increase.

1:31:46They didn't talk about the hood.

1:31:47They didn't talk about family things.

1:31:49They just talked about rent increase.

1:31:51Every time I walk into my house, I sit back and see if you flush the toilet, flush this in the toilet, we're gonna raise our rent up.

1:31:56We're gonna raise our rent up.

1:31:57Right now I got no heat in my house.

1:31:59Right now I don't have a refrigerator in my house.

1:32:01He wants the same rent.

1:32:03And he's willing to do an increase.

1:32:04So for me, I see y'all got a tough job.

1:32:07I've come here many times, I didn't see the tough job y'all had.

1:32:09But when I sit back and see the, the renters talk about what they saying, I can hear what they talking about.

1:32:14But I vote yes on all 3 ordinances.

1:32:16Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:32:20 - 1:32:38

1:32:20Next up we have Cassidy Bolger, Jim Rostel, Lauren Armony, Mike Nuss.

1:32:31David Thompson.

1:32:35We have Cassidy online.

1:32:37You may unmute and begin when you're ready.

Cassidy Bolger 1:32:40 - 1:34:35

1:32:40Hi, thank you.

1:32:41My name is Cassidy Bolger.

1:32:42I'm a resident of District 2.

1:32:45I'm the Director of Development at Killian Pacific, uh, and I'm the President of the Board of Oregon Smart Growth.

1:32:50I'm here to urge you to vote no on all 3 proposals to rule changes to the MRRA program.

1:32:56We remain in the midst of a housing crisis driven by a shortage of supply of new housing.

1:33:00These rules will continue to disincentivize housing production and drive investors and landlords, both big and small, out of our market.

1:33:07Many have left already.

1:33:10As we've heard today, the city passed the original FAIR ordinance in 2019.

1:33:14Oregon Smart Growth and many of our partners have asked the city's administrative leadership for an independent review of the FAIR ordinance policies to understand what their effect has been.

1:33:24This has not occurred.

1:33:25How can we be offering new and expanded rules before we know how our existing rules are working?

1:33:31I want to draw your attention to a recent article in the Washington Post, an editorial from November 11th, because I think it's a harbinger of what's to come in Portland.

1:33:40The title is The Bill for New York City's Rent Regulations Is Coming Due.

1:33:44It outlines what similar policies are doing in New York City with buildings containing rent-restricted apartments being lost to foreclosure.

1:33:51Thank you.

1:33:51Something that hurts everyone, both landlords and tenants.

1:33:55It's unfortunate that as I listen to testimony today to my fellow Portlanders, that we are talking past each other and attempting to deny each other's or debunk each other's economic realities.

1:34:06The fact is, it's unfortunate for both of us.

1:34:09I think what we're trying to do here today is seek a political solution to something that should be an economic solution.

1:34:15We need sound economic governmental policy.

1:34:17Thank you.

1:34:18And we need those of our elected leaders to present that to us rather than simply an economic or a political battle in front of you.

1:34:26So I encourage you to spend the time to do the study and make sound policy that helps the city as a whole and not accept these, not vote for these rule changes.

1:34:35Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:34:38 - 1:34:39

1:34:38Jim, you're up next.

Jim Rostel 1:34:40 - 1:36:39

1:34:40Thank you.

1:34:42My name is Jim Rostel.

1:34:43I am the Chief Operating Officer at Anchor Northwest Property Group.

1:34:46Here in Portland.

1:34:48We are a family-owned company.

1:34:49My father-in-law, mother-in-law, wife, 2 kids all work there.

1:34:55We built our first apartment building in 2013 in Irvington.

1:34:58Since then, we've built 36 other apartment buildings.

1:35:00We have 2,400 units.

1:35:02We have a great relationship with our tenants.

1:35:05You can look at our Google reviews.

1:35:07We're at 4.4 stars across 600 reviews.

1:35:11Thank you.

1:35:14Many people are coming here talking to you about the economic impact of the regulatory environment on, on developers.

1:35:21We are one of the few people, the local people, we're not the national people that are building here in Portland.

1:35:27We love the city.

1:35:28We love Oregon.

1:35:29We're from Oregon.

1:35:29Our kids went to school here.

1:35:30We went to school here.

1:35:31My parents went to school here.

1:35:33We want the best for the city.

1:35:35The regulatory environment is so out of control.

1:35:38We're done building.

1:35:40Not because we don't have land.

1:35:41I've got a piece of property on 14th and East Burnside, bought, paid for, permitted, ready to go, 157 units.

1:35:50I could start tomorrow, but I can't make it pencil out.

1:35:53And then you layer on top of that the regulatory risk that continues to get piled on top of us, and it just doesn't make sense.

1:36:00I've got another piece of property northwest that we bought that we were planning on putting apartments on.

1:36:05We're not going to do it now.

1:36:07We just can't.

1:36:09At some point, you need to take a look at solutions that help the tenants but also work with housing providers.

1:36:17Because at the end of the day, our biggest issue is that we don't have enough housing for our people.

1:36:25And that's the number one driver of rents in the marketplace.

1:36:31I would encourage you, vote no on this and go back to the drawing board and find something that helps both tenants and housing providers.

1:36:38Thank you for your time.

Keelan McClymont 1:36:41 - 1:36:45

1:36:41Lauren Armony is online.

1:36:42Lauren, you may unmute and begin your testimony.

Lauren Armony 1:36:47 - 1:38:55

1:36:47Dear Housing and Permitting Committee, my name is Lauren Armony with Welcome Home Coalition, and I am here to testify in support of agenda items 2, 3, and 4.

1:36:57I am a tenant and have experienced homelessness.

1:37:00I was born and raised in Portland, and I live in terror every day that I will lose my job or that my rent will be raised alongside my food, water, healthcare, electricity, and student loans.

1:37:15Progressive taxes are getting indexed for inflation at far higher rates than social supports, and I I learned a joke from one of my boy— from my boyfriend's mother, um, who is— has a PhD in statistics and works for HP.

1:37:31And she said— she told me as a professional, you know, statistics are like a lamppost for drunk people.

1:37:40Um, they are not that great for support or illumination.

1:37:46Um, so— I agree.

1:37:48Just hearing the way statistics have been manipulated during the course of this testimony is really frustrating to me.

1:37:54I am also still shaken at hearing a community described as operational.

1:37:58If you want to describe a community as operational, it would mean that that community had clean air, water, free education, rapid and reliable public transit, and time off to spend with loved ones or, you know, at our local coffee shops who are local businesses.

1:38:12If landlords want to call themselves housing providers and they can't afford to provide housing with reasonable regulation, Then that is proof that our housing market should not be predicated on a for-profit system.

1:38:25And I cannot help but think of all of the tenants who have died in New York City because their buildings have fallen.

1:38:29We need regulations.

1:38:31We need landlords to step up or give it up, give it to people who will do the work.

1:38:36I also heard earlier about intent versus impact.

1:38:40This is a city council.

1:38:40The intent and impact of city policy should be to support residents, especially our most vulnerable.

1:38:45Thank you.

1:38:46So realtors in the room and wondering why people can't buy houses, why people aren't buying houses, it's because the rent is too damn high to save for them.

1:38:53So thank you so much for letting me testify.

Keelan McClymont 1:38:59 - 1:39:12

1:38:59Mike, you're up next.

1:39:06Once more for Mike Nuss.

1:39:11Move on to David Thompson.

David Thompson 1:39:13 - 1:41:47

1:39:13Good afternoon, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, and members of the committee.

1:39:18My name is David Thompson.

1:39:20I am the executive director of Multifamily Northwest and a registered lobbyist with the City of Portland.

1:39:26I share the committee's concern regarding the cost of housing and the effect of displacement.

1:39:31However, I'm here today to express my concern that the proposed changes to Portland's relocation ordinance will work directly against the city's stated housing production and availability goals, as well as increased rents.

1:39:46Portland has identified a need for roughly 120,000 additional housing units by 2045, according to its housing analysis.

1:39:56Meeting that demand will require significant investment, continued development, and environment where housing providers have the confidence to own, operate, and maintain an investment in rental housing.

1:40:07Unfortunately, the city's continued expansion of housing regulations is creating the opposite environment.

1:40:14Could not have said it better than my friend here.

1:40:16At Eco Northwest, analysis commissioned by the Multifamily Northwest and Oregon Realtors found that Portland lost about 14% of its single-family rental homes between 2017 and 2020, twice the rate of the surrounding metro area.

1:40:32That loss reduced the variety of rental market and once those houses are sold, they will likely never come back, decreasing the supply, increasing the demand, and hurting the very residents this policy hopes to help.

1:40:49Residents will have to move to cities like Hillsboro in order to find housing and work in Portland.

1:40:57The proposed changes will only accelerate that risk.

1:41:00Increasing mandatory relocation payments and lowering the rent increase threshold that triggers those payments creates and additional financial uncertainty for anyone considering investing in or operating rental housing in Portland.

1:41:16When housing providers leave the market, Portland does not gain additional housing.

1:41:20It loses rental housing options and further concentrates the demand amongst the properties that remain.

1:41:25The city cannot simultaneously acknowledge its need for tens of thousands of additional housing units while continuing to implement policies that discourage the very investment needed to produce those and maintain those housing.

1:41:38Portland needs more housing providers willing to invest in the city, not fewer.

1:41:44I strongly encourage you to vote no on the proposals.

Keelan McClymont 1:41:52 - 1:42:18

1:41:52Next up, we have Zackery Langford, Maria Sworske.

1:42:00Edith Gillis.

1:42:02Tess Herman.

1:42:04Blake Gordon.

1:42:16And Zachary, you may begin when you're ready.

Zackery Langford 1:42:18 - 1:43:56

1:42:18All right, so my name is, uh, Zachary Langford.

1:42:21My pronouns are she/her, and I just kind of want to reiterate I just wanna address what has been said by the people opposing this.

1:42:33They're saying, oh, it's a problem because we don't have enough, it's a housing-providing issue.

1:42:40We need to build more houses, we need investment.

1:42:44And I like to say, like, maybe housing should not be for profit, you know?

1:42:49Like, housing is essential for us.

1:42:53If we don't have it, it's— Councilor Herbold.

1:42:55Difficult, traumatic, and you can die.

1:42:58And as someone who's been homeless myself, it's, it's very difficult.

1:43:02And things that are human, like human needs, should not be like privatized like this.

1:43:08And it's really just a bullying tactic, you know, like they're saying, oh, you know, if we, if you put on additional regulations that protect tenants, you know, then we're not going to build housing.

1:43:20We're not going to do it.

1:43:21We're only going to build housing.

1:43:22Thank you.

1:43:23If we can exploit tenants.

1:43:25And I just find that like very, um, very mean.

1:43:29And it's also like, it's gaslighting because it's like, it's not, it's not because people aren't like moving into Portland because it's like, oh, the regulations.

1:43:39That's because the rent is high.

1:43:42And we need to protect tenants and make it so that people can actually afford housing and actually build housing for need, for human need, not for profit.

1:43:52And, um, that's what I got to say.

1:43:55Thank you for your time.

Keelan McClymont 1:44:00 - 1:44:01

1:44:00Maria, you may begin when you're ready.

Maria Sworske 1:44:01 - 1:45:43

1:44:01My name is Maria Sworske.

1:44:04I own a triplex in Northeast Portland, and I oppose these 3 ordinances.

1:44:10I manage with common sense and caring, not a spreadsheet.

1:44:13I care about my residents, and I want to continue providing safe and affordable housing.

1:44:18Our rising costs cause the rents to increase.

1:44:22We didn't cause this inflation.

1:44:24Please don't put the burden on the private rental housing providers.

1:44:28Don't push us out of the business with increasing costs, liability exposure, and difficult regulations.

1:44:35More and more rental units are becoming corporately owned, where the financial return is the only concern of the investors.

1:44:43We private rental property owners have a stake in the community.

1:44:46Thank you.

1:44:47I live in Northeast Portland.

1:44:48We should have the ability to manage as we see fit for the best overall outcome.

1:44:55Rental housing of 1 to 3 units, when offered for sale, tends to be bought by owner-occupant buyers, further diminishing the rental housing supply.

1:45:04I know this because for decades I was a licensed realtor specializing in helping rental property owners get out of the business.

1:45:13They just couldn't take it anymore.

1:45:15They could not operate, and they were like me, the kind-hearted, want to help people, and they just got burned.

1:45:22The housing industry needs the private owners.

1:45:27Instead, institutional and corporate housing providers are taking over as the primary housing providers because they have stronger legal backing and they can weather the losses better.

1:45:38Portland needs the private rental housing providers.

1:45:41Please don't pass these ordinances.

Keelan McClymont 1:45:49 - 1:46:02

1:45:49Edith, you may begin when you're ready.

1:45:55Once more for Edith Gillis.

1:46:01Tess Herman.

Tess Herman 1:46:05 - 1:48:57

1:46:05I feel like everybody's pretty much summed it up for me, but I, I'll read what I wrote today.

1:46:11I'm here today because I'm concerned that the city continues to add policies to an already overregulated rental housing environment.

1:46:18The cumulative effect is making it really hard for small independent landlords like myself, Maria as well, to provide rental housing.

1:46:26And I think it's important that you understand who some of us actually are.

1:46:30Um, my mother suffered from a lifetime of substance abuse, and I became a renter at 16 after my dad died at 42, renting on my own, not living with a parent.

1:46:40I didn't come from money.

1:46:41I remember the shame of showing my ticket to get my free school lunch and using food stamps when I was sent to the grocery store.

1:46:49And I know what it feels like to worry about money.

1:46:51And I was a renter for 20 years.

1:46:54Then came the Great Recession.

1:46:55Work dried up.

1:46:57With no college degree, no pension, no clear path forward, my husband and I generally did not know how we were going to support ourselves financially.

1:47:05So in our 50s, and we knew we needed to find a way to support our family and build some, some kind of security for retirement, we bought ourselves a job.

1:47:14We became small landlords.

1:47:16And over the course— which I really loved the first 5 years until the Eudaly things came to place— over the course of many years, we bought a few older rundown plexes because it was what we could qualify for.

1:47:28Thank you.

1:47:29Because we had good retirement and we set aside money for our retirement because that's what you do when you're self-employed.

1:47:36We put that retirement money down on payments and we put in a lot of sweat equity into making these homes that we're really proud of for people to live in.

1:47:46It is not passive income.

1:47:47It's a full-time job.

1:47:49We manage the properties, maintenance, repairs, weeding, cleaning.

1:47:52And for the record, I've cleaned more toilets I care to count.

1:47:55We have to do all the work because otherwise the numbers simply do not pencil.

1:48:01An $18,000 roof like the one we recently put on our duplex was an unexpected financial burden that the rents on that building for a year did not cover.

1:48:09We pay mortgages, property taxes, city taxes, county taxes, state taxes, property insurance, very high water bills, and ongoing maintenance and repairs.

1:48:19And gross rent is not our take-home income.

1:48:22We're not rich.

1:48:23We do not own these properties outright, and we don't have a corporate office, an attorney on retainer, or staff to do this work for us.

1:48:31I am a proud Go Blue Wave Democrat.

1:48:34I believe in fairness, equality, and protecting people who are struggling because that is what my own life was like growing up, including my family.

1:48:42But I also believe in small businesses, working people, and economic fairness, and those values should include small housing providers who are trying to make a living while providing nice homes for other people.

1:48:54Thank you.

1:48:54Which is why I'm concerned you're almost a minute over.

Candace Avalos 1:48:57 - 1:48:58

1:48:57Go ahead and wrap up with that.

Tess Herman 1:48:58 - 1:48:59

1:48:58I'd love to talk to you more.

Candace Avalos 1:49:00 - 1:49:01

1:49:00Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:49:04 - 1:49:12

1:49:04Blake Gordon.

1:49:05Blake is online.

1:49:07You should be able to click the unmute button and begin your testimony when you're ready.

Blake Gordon 1:49:15 - 1:49:17

1:49:15Hello.

1:49:16Can y'all hear me?

Keelan McClymont 1:49:18 - 1:49:18

1:49:18We can hear you.

Blake Gordon 1:49:19 - 1:51:40

1:49:19Well, thank you all for taking the time to let us all speak.

1:49:24So myself, I've worked in property management for private owners in the Portland area and throughout the Valley for over 20 years.

1:49:32I've also worked with housing organizations such as Habitat for Humanity, Corvallis Housing First, AmeriCorps YouthBuild.

1:49:40I own several rental homes myself, and I rent them out, several of them to families.

1:49:46I'm also a renter.

1:49:48Housing costs are so high, just like everyone— I think everyone can agree here, costs are high.

1:49:53We all know that.

1:49:54Yeah.

1:49:55Uh, but it's not feasible for me to buy a house in Portland, occupy it, pay the entire mortgage, insurance, and property taxes.

1:50:02Um, so I completely empathize with the frustration, um, of people on both sides, uh, in this meeting.

1:50:09But, uh, all the proposals discussed today will have the opposite effect of what their summaries imply.

1:50:16Uh, it's short-term relief for a few at the expense of drastically exacerbating the actual issue.

1:50:23Which all boils down to there are not enough homes.

1:50:26The housing crisis is a supply and demand issue.

1:50:30With more people looking for housing than there is available, prices will just keep increasing.

1:50:34If we want to alleviate the housing crisis, we need to implement solutions that create more housing, such as the state bill 2001 that allows development of single-family properties into multiple units.

1:50:47That was meaningful and effective legislation.

1:50:49Thank you.

1:50:50So legislation such as this is what the city needs to do and what they need to be spending their time on.

1:50:56These proposals will disproportionately burden individual small local rental owners.

1:51:0190% Of the single-family homes, which are like 10 units and less, are owned by small local landlords, as we've heard from a lot of people here.

1:51:11These are the ideal homes for families, an individual house.

1:51:15Uh, this— these proposals will reduce the incentive for developers to build focused, affordable 3 and 4-bedroom apartments near schools.

1:51:24Uh, it'll strategically incentivize them not to build units for families.

1:51:29So, uh, to solve the housing crisis, we need the city to step up and develop meaningful legislation that'll increase the housing supply.

1:51:39Thank you.

1:51:40Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:51:44 - 1:51:58

1:51:44Next up, we have Kip Silverman, Jordan Lewis, Brian Simmons, Kaydee Williams.

1:51:55Looks like Kip is online.

1:51:56You may unmute and begin when you're ready.

Kip Silverman 1:51:59 - 1:53:59

1:51:59Awesome.

1:51:59Thank you.

1:52:00My name is Kip Silverman.

1:52:01I use he/him pronouns, and I am a renter and resident of District 2.

1:52:07I support these proposed updates.

1:52:08It is critical they move forward.

1:52:10It's getting harder to just exist in the city as a renter.

1:52:14I'm lucky that I've stayed relatively gainfully employed recently and currently have a good landlord that doesn't gouge me.

1:52:21But if landlords aren't radically raising rents, then they really have nothing to worry about.

1:52:26That being said, a 9.9% increase would make my own situation absolutely untenable.

1:52:32Thank you.

1:52:33I would like to recommend to the committee some things to consider.

1:52:37The original relocation ordinance was missing some key provisions which made it far less effective than it could have been.

1:52:44Uh, first, education.

1:52:46Most people are not aware the relocation ordinance even exists.

1:52:50Should be mandatory on all rental applications and contracts that relo and rent increase laws are front and center, as well as what help there is to the renter.

1:53:00When a landlord does act in bad faith.

1:53:03Second, data.

1:53:04Even if a landlord or their agents follow the ordinance rules, there's no centralized database tracking any of this.

1:53:11We have no idea how many people that were eligible for relocation assistance actually received it and how many have not.

1:53:21Third, the idea that most tenants are being pushed out of their home to no fault of their own.

1:53:27Will have the time— that they would have the time and means to take a landlord to court, much less antagonize the very person that is evicting them, is not reasonable.

1:53:38Tenants need the weight of the city to make sure its laws are being followed.

1:53:43There are solutions to all of these issues that are not overly complicated.

1:53:47I hope by the time this advances to council, there will be time to workshop them.

1:53:52Please move this forward and feel free to reach out with any questions.

1:53:55Thank you.

1:53:55I'd be happy to help, and I appreciate you all championing this.

1:53:59Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:54:02 - 1:54:03

1:54:02Jordan, you're up next.

Jordan Lewis 1:54:04 - 1:56:17

1:54:04Hello, Council Committee.

1:54:05My name is Jordan Lewis.

1:54:06I'm a tenant in District 4 and a volunteer lobbyist for Portland Democratic Socialists of America.

1:54:12I just moved for the first time in 5 years, and I just want to state, in case you don't— you haven't moved recently, moving really sucks.

1:54:21Moving is like an immense psychic, financial burden.

1:54:25And it is like you're sleeping, you're living among boxes for like a month.

1:54:29You are paying double utilities 'cause you might be moving between the places.

1:54:32You might be paying double parking.

1:54:35My landlord at my old place wouldn't let me terminate the lease early, so I was paying double rent for a month.

1:54:40This is like an immense burden and it is distributed unequally because I don't wanna move.

1:54:45I only moved because I had like a huge life change.

1:54:48Yeah.

1:54:49I was lucky to live in a place for 5 years, but that was only because I was secure.

1:54:54And so let's think, who is being burdened the most by moving costs?

1:54:58It's the lowest income, it's the least able people in our society.

1:55:01That's one of the reasons I'm in support of all 3 amendments.

1:55:05But the real reason I'm here is because I was listening and a couple landlords testified and they said, oh, rent has gone down over the past year or 2.

1:55:13And I was like bugging out and I was I was losing my mind.

1:55:16I was going crazy.

1:55:17So I printed it off.

1:55:18I found Portland Housing Bureau has a document where it has documented like rents over the past 10 years.

1:55:26And I have this like black— this black line right here is 0%.

1:55:31So wherever it's above it, your rent has gone up.

1:55:34And this is 5% is the top.

1:55:37That's per quarter.

1:55:38So there was this insane period in like 2016.

1:55:40Oh, wow.

1:55:41Where people's rent was going up on average by 5% in a quarter.

1:55:45So we're talking like double-digit rent increase.

1:55:48That's crazy.

1:55:49And this is like a cumulative burden.

1:55:50It's an integral.

1:55:51So like imagine like a pile of sand, and the pile of sand is getting bigger every year that it's rent.

1:55:57And so if you have a decrease, you're scooping like the tiniest little bit of sand off of this burden.

1:56:01And if you've lived in Portland for the past 10 years, you've been paying more every year because of the additional increase in rent that you've suffered.

1:56:09So I'm in support of this, and I really don't like when landlords manipulate statistics and say that a decrease matters.

1:56:15The decrease has not been substantial.

1:56:17Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:56:20 - 1:56:21

1:56:20Brian, you may begin when you're ready.

Brian Simmons 1:56:22 - 1:58:01

1:56:22Thank you.

1:56:23First, Brian Simmons.

1:56:25I'm a resident of District 2, but I'm a landlord in all of the districts in Portland.

1:56:32One of the things that I'd like to just make a comment on is that I think that one of the things that's missed here is the idea of community.

1:56:41I sat back there in the room and I watched the snickering and the laughter and the, uh, sideways glances by people here when everybody was speaking, and it's from both sides.

1:56:52Um, it's disgusting.

1:56:53Manipulation of data just happened, and it happened by every— everybody else.

1:56:58Um, what I'd like to say is that this to me is the equivalent of a mechanic telling me that my tire needs to be changed and it is going to need my motor to be removed.

1:57:10So I, I'm not opposed to 419 or 420.

1:57:14I think there probably needs to be a little bit of more restrictions around 420.

1:57:19418 Is truly the issue, although none of my clients or myself will ever suffer from that because I don't increase the rents beyond 5% normally unless there's some extreme situation.

1:57:32I would say that my rents go up To meet the costs burden of the property.

1:57:39But one of the things that we do is that we have a community approach with our residents.

1:57:45I'm not gonna call 'em tenants, I'm not gonna call 'em customers, I'm not gonna call 'em anything other than residents.

1:57:51They are, they're my responsibility, the same as the owners are.

1:57:55And I think that that is what is missed in this entire process is that we're not looking at community.

1:58:00Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:58:06 - 1:58:08

1:58:06Kaydee is online.

1:58:07You may unmute and begin when you're ready.

Kaydee Williams 1:58:09 - 1:58:10

1:58:09Can you hear me okay?

Keelan McClymont 1:58:11 - 1:58:12

1:58:11Yes, we can.

Kaydee Williams 1:58:13 - 2:00:34

1:58:13Uh, good afternoon.

1:58:14My name is Kaydee Williams.

1:58:15I'm a local real estate investor, business owner, and mother.

1:58:18I own a company that helps people buy and sell real estate properties throughout the Portland area, primarily Portland.

1:58:25According to batch data analysis, nearly 20% of all the single-family homes in Multnomah County are owned by small mom-and-pop, I heard it earlier.

1:58:35And that doesn't even include duplexes, triplexes, small apartment buildings owned by private landlords.

1:58:40These are not giant corporations.

1:58:42They're parents, retirees, ordinary people who have invested in real estate hoping to build financial security and keep the kind of retirement that we all would love to have.

1:58:52A healthy rental market depends upon private landlords continuing to make homes available for rent.

1:58:58Without them, families have fewer housing options.

1:59:00Thank you.

1:59:00Particularly those that need a single-family home, not a condo, not a townhouse, not an apartment.

1:59:07As an expert in single-family investment properties, I receive hundreds of phone calls over the last several years from landlords desperate to get out of their rental properties.

1:59:17They call me every single week.

1:59:18When they call me, they're not celebrating a successful investment.

1:59:21They're exhausted, they're scared, and they want out.

1:59:24They tell me about rising taxes, insurance, repairs, mortgages.

1:59:28Thank you.

1:59:28Some have spent years breaking even or losing money, hoping for appreciation that may never come.

1:59:34They tell me that they don't have unlimited reserves.

1:59:37A roof replacement, an unexpected vacancy, or some major repair can wipe out the entirety of their cash flow.

1:59:43Eventually, they come to me and they say, "I can't do this anymore.

1:59:46Can you please buy my house?" Now consider these ordinances mean that somebody who is collecting $2,500 a month in rent.

1:59:54Maybe paying $2,000 on a mortgage, you think they're making $500 a month in rent.

1:59:59That's not the case.

2:00:00That's not happening.

2:00:01We're not making a bunch of money.

2:00:03Instead, they have vacancy, tenant turnover, major repairs, and they're making maybe $100 a month on a property, also trying to buy more avocado toast.

2:00:13This isn't guaranteed money.

2:00:15It's expected.

2:00:16It's hoped for, but it's not a guarantee.

2:00:18Now you're proposing additional financial obligations that could cost thousands of dollars for someone who's barely making any money on an investment as it is.

2:00:26How much more risk do you expect these people to absorb?

2:00:29I'm going to try to go forward here.

2:00:31When the rental supply shrinks and the demand remains—.

2:00:34Thank you.

Candace Avalos 2:00:34 - 2:00:37

2:00:34You're actually 20 seconds over.

2:00:36Why don't you wrap up your thought?

Kaydee Williams 2:00:38 - 2:00:52

2:00:38I'm going for it.

2:00:38I thought I had 3.

2:00:39Prices face upward pressure and housing becomes harder to address.

2:00:43If you haven't thought about how many single-family homeowners are going to leave the market and sell their properties that are not going to become rentals again, then you shouldn't be making decisions to pass these measures.

Keelan McClymont 2:00:56 - 2:00:57

2:00:56That concludes testimony.

Candace Avalos 2:00:58 - 2:21:42

2:00:58All right, thank you.

2:00:59Um, for the sake of time, I'm going to move us quickly into a break.

2:01:02Let's come back at 4:10 and we'll— we will enter discussion.

2:12:29All right, thank you so much.

2:12:31We are going to call this meeting back to order, and we're gonna get started here in a moment with some discussion.

2:12:39And, uh, I put myself first because I wanted to just reflect a little bit on what we heard in the testimony and just to kick us off.

2:12:47So thank you again to everyone who testified today.

2:12:51We heard very different experiences from renters and small landlords and property managers and advocates, and I genuinely appreciate the time that people took to come speak with us.

2:13:01Like I've said previously, regardless of if I agree with what you say or not, your voice is important to shaping our legislation.

2:13:08That's the goal.

2:13:09I wanted to just respond to a couple of themes that came up repeatedly, just so that— because I believe there are some important distinctions that might be getting lost, and I just want to discuss those as we enter this discussing the ordinances.

2:13:22So first, let me start with these ordinances are not a 5% rent cap.

2:13:29Let me start there because I just heard that characterization a lot.

2:13:32These ordinances don't prevent a landlord from raising the rent by more than 5%.

2:13:36State law continues to determine how much a landlord can legally increase the rent, and we're not changing that.

2:13:41What we are saying with these ordinances is that if a landlord chooses to increase the rent by 5% or more, and that increase makes the home unaffordable enough that the tenant chooses to leave, our existing relocation policy should recognize that as economic displacement.

2:13:54So that's very different from prohibiting the increase altogether.

2:13:58The state rent cap is actually part of the reason for the current— part of the reason the 10% trigger No longer makes sense in my view.

2:14:06When Portland created relocation assistance in 2017, Oregon didn't have the statewide rent stabilization framework that it has today.

2:14:14Since then, the state has capped allowable increases at levels that are generally below or around the city's existing 10% relocation trigger.

2:14:21We heard testimony today arguing that large rent increases have become less common because of state law, and that's precisely the point.

2:14:27The policy was created to respond to rent increases that can cause economic displacement, and if state law has changed where those increases are now occurring, then our policy should and a renter doesn't become less displaced because their increase was 7% over 10%.

2:14:43We also heard, and this was some data that we were looking at as well, so I'm glad it came up in the testimony, that the average increase right now in rents is 4%.

2:14:54And that actually gives me more confidence in a 5% threshold.

2:14:59If that is the average, then a 5% relocation threshold is above the typical increase happening in the market right now.

2:15:05So that makes it hard for me to accept the argument that the 5% threshold is too high.

2:15:06Thank you.

2:15:08This is suddenly going to affect every landlord or every routine rent adjustment in Portland.

2:15:12It is designed to address increases above what we are currently seeing on average, when those increases become significant enough that a tenant decides they can't afford to remain.

2:15:21Also, flat rents don't necessarily mean affordable rents.

2:15:24I heard lots of folks talk today about the rents being flat or declining somewhat, and that might be true at the market level, but affordability is not simply whether rent went up this year.

2:15:34Affordability is whether a household can afford the rent relative to their income.

2:15:38Portland renters experience enormous thank you.

2:15:40We've seen enormous increases in housing costs over the last decade, and so a year or two of flat rents does not suddenly make the market affordable.

2:15:46Half of Portland renters are already cost burdened, as we have discussed.

2:15:53So for households already spending 40%, 50% of their income, even another 5% can be consequential.

2:16:00About the concerns that we heard today about landlords' operating costs, I thank you for sharing that, and I'll just say to that that renters are experiencing those same cost pressures.

2:16:11We heard We've heard testimony about rising insurance and maintenance and labor, utilities, and I don't dispute that those costs are real, but renters are living in the same economy.

2:16:20Their groceries are more, their transportation is more, their childcare is more, their insurance is more, and many renters pay their own utilities.

2:16:27So those increasing energy costs we heard about today is also part of the affordability pressure on renter households.

2:16:34So we can acknowledge that operating housing has become more expensive without pretending that the people renting that housing somehow escaped inflation.

2:16:41Thank you.

2:16:42And yes, we absolutely need better-paying jobs and rising incomes, but we have to address the problem immediately in front of us today.

2:16:48People are being priced out of their homes.

2:16:51Updating the relocation amounts is also not some arbitrary new cost.

2:16:56So we already decided— Portland already decided years ago that when certain landlord actions displace a tenant, relocation assistance is appropriate.

2:17:03The question before us is whether the amount of assistance still reflects what relocation actually costs.

2:17:07Thank you.

2:17:08It clearly costs more to move today than it did when those amounts were established.

2:17:12And if we had regularly adjusted the amounts over time, we wouldn't be talking about a larger catch-up adjustment today.

2:17:18So that is why I support us continuing to adjust that mechanism in the future so that we don't come in the next decade having the same problem.

2:17:26For the 2 ordinances that Councilor Green and I are sponsoring, we are not creating an entirely new regulatory system.

2:17:32The relocation assistance policy already exists.

2:17:34Thank you.

2:17:35The process exists, the exemptions exist.

2:17:37We are just simply updating 2 parts of an existing policy because the economic and legal conditions around it have changed.

2:17:43So calling every adjustment to an existing protection another layer of regulation isn't landing with me because to me, I wonder ultimately if we're just increasing a regulation that already occurs.

2:17:57I don't see how that's another layer that we're adding.

2:18:00I also want to address the housing supply argument because this keeps coming up in all of our spaces as we're talking about Portland's housing future.

2:18:08I agree, we agree that Portland needs more housing.

2:18:11I spend an enormous amount of my time as housing chair working on exactly that.

2:18:14We've been working on things like permitting reform, development incentives, the housing— the unified housing strategy, social housing.

2:18:21But I guess I just reject the idea that we have to choose between building more housing and keeping people in the housing that they already have.

2:18:27We have to do both.

2:18:29And increasing housing supply is essential to our long-term affordability strategy as well.

2:18:34So preventing unnecessary displacement is essential to our housing stability strategy.

2:18:38Thank you.

2:18:40If we build thousands of new homes while people who already live there are continuing to fall into homelessness because they can't absorb rent increases or afford the cost of moving, then I don't think that's a successful housing strategy.

2:18:52I also heard some suggestions that the city should simply pay relocation instead.

2:18:56I absolutely believe the city should invest public dollars in things like rental assistance and eviction prevention.

2:19:01It's— in fact, that's what we have done.

2:19:04But I guess to me, that's a separate question from who bears responsibility when a specific business decision causes a tenant to relocate.

2:19:11I don't think that we can answer all of those questions with simply taxpayers must absorb that cost.

2:19:16There's a role for public assistance, and I don't believe that's one of them.

2:19:20I also want to say I take really seriously the experiences of small landlords.

2:19:23I don't think we need to caricature either side of this conversation.

2:19:27There are small landlords who are struggling with costs.

2:19:29There are renters who are struggling with costs.

2:19:31Both things are true.

2:19:31Thank you.

2:19:32The question is not whether landlords are good or bad.

2:19:35The question is whether our current existing relocation policy still works in the economic conditions that we have today.

2:19:41And our answer to that is we believe it needs to be updated.

2:19:45Ultimately, I— this is about homelessness prevention.

2:19:48I want to bring us back to why Portland created relocation assistance in the first place.

2:19:52Moving is expensive.

2:19:54A security deposit, application fees, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, can turn losing one home into losing housing altogether.

2:20:01So we can either intervene during that moment of instability Or we can spend substantially more public resources after someone becomes homeless.

2:20:09And I personally would rather slow the inflow into homelessness.

2:20:12These policies are not going to solve Portland's affordability crisis.

2:20:15That is very clear.

2:20:16This is just one part of a much larger housing strategy because we need more housing, we need better wages, we need lower development costs, we need preservation, we need rental assistance, and we need more permanently affordable housing.

2:20:28And we also need renter protections that actually function.

2:20:30Thank you.

2:20:31Updating a policy created nearly a decade ago to reflect today's rents, today's incomes, today's state law is a reasonable thing for council to do.

2:20:40So I appreciate all the testimony today.

2:20:42I just wanted to offer some of my reflections as I heard the arguments, including from people that might disagree with me.

2:20:49But after all of that, I still believe that these solutions that we're presenting today are thoughtful and necessary updates to the relocation policy.

2:20:58So we've got a bunch of people in the queue.

2:20:59I'm going to call those lines.

2:21:00Let me also just give a broader note.

2:21:03These 3 ordinances all affect the same chapter, right?

2:21:07And at some point, I want to have a discussion amongst us on if there's any— if there's worth— if it is worth blending any of these to make them one package.

2:21:17I know the clerks have feelings about the fact that we have, you know, 3 different ordinances in the same chapter.

2:21:21I'm sorry, clerks, we're working on it.

2:21:23But, you know, that logistical problem, we don't need to— is not necessarily the point, but more so if we agree, if I'm hearing in the discussion that we're agreeing on certain concepts, then it would be worth blending them to make it easier on the clerk.

2:21:36So something to consider.

2:21:38With that, Councilor or Vice Chair Green, please take it away.

Mitch Green 2:21:42 - 2:28:49

2:21:42Thank you so much, Chair Avalos.

2:21:45I was sort of winding up to make a bunch of economic arguments, but you nailed it.

2:21:49And so I just want to add a finer point on a couple things.

2:21:56I think we need both a supply-side approach to solving our housing crisis, and while we— but we also need to be very cognizant that we are adopting anti-displacement policies at the same time, because when you have periods of rapid growth, the people with the least amount of means will get displaced, and that's a fact, and that's been our experience.

2:22:19And so I don't see a mutually exclusive setup between being pro-housing production, slashing the red tape.

2:22:27I mean, this body waived system development charges on the order of almost $30,000 per unit.

2:22:32That's not small potatoes.

2:22:36We just went through a central city code alignment process that makes it easier to build a lot of housing in the central city, and the list goes on.

2:22:44We've taken that— in fact, I would argue most of our attention has been on that side.

2:22:46I think that's fair.

2:22:47And very little for tenants.

2:22:49And so I just wanna— there's a couple pieces here that I wanna add a finer point on, on the economics of it.

2:22:55On the first ordinance, Councilor Avalos is correct.

2:22:59We received a briefing from the Portland Housing Bureau, gosh, some time back, this committee.

2:23:06I can't remember the exact— maybe it was in September.

2:23:08And I think Josh Roper had sort of suggested that the recent average growth in rent is 4%.

2:23:16Yeah.

2:23:18And so 5% has no impact on the market on average.

2:23:24Now, it's been noted, and it's true, that not every single landlord-tenant sort of renewal decision is at the average.

2:23:36That's because the market is not perfect.

2:23:37It doesn't clear perfectly.

2:23:38It's subject to market failure because there is an imbalance of power between— and frankly, the ability for both sides of the— Yeah.

2:23:47The transaction to have the same level of mobility and power.

2:23:52And so you can have a situation where one tenant can get a 9.9% rental increase even though the 4% is the average.

2:24:03And so what this does is allow— it sort of creates a way for the externalized cost of that market failure to be internalized for that— the person creating it.

2:24:17And it allows a payment to be made for the person with less ability to pay to move out of that unit that they can no longer afford and into something that they can.

2:24:27And that actually helps the market clear.

2:24:29So for everyone who wants and believes in free markets, Economics 101, all that, if that's what you're pinning your hopes and dreams on, you should be supportive of the relocation payments.

2:24:42And in particular, you should be supportive of a better calibrated, uh, 5%.

2:24:48Um, and you want to do it before you have the period of expansion.

2:24:52That's actually crucial.

2:24:53When you, when you do sort of, um, changes that affect the market, whether you're talking about housing or you're talking about labor markets or you're talking about, you know, markets for goods more broadly, um, the best time to adopt A setup that has potentially, you know, policy or economic implications is when you have a period of slack in the market, when it's not white hot.

2:25:15And so if we were to adopt this RELO change during the period of expansion, we would expect the relocation payments to trigger much more often.

2:25:23That's true.

2:25:24And so you want to get it in place before you have the threat of displacement in the first place.

2:25:29And that's what this does.

2:25:30This allows a lot more certainty for both sides of the transaction.

2:25:33Thank you.

2:25:35On the other piece, sort of updating the amounts, you know, when these were put in place, it was based upon the true cost all in, broadly defined, of having to move.

2:25:49And because these were not updated to inflation, what has essentially happened is a windfall of value has been transferred from the lowest income earners in the City of Portland, which tend to be the renters who are displaced to those with the most ability to earn income.

2:26:04And in the last several years, when we've had the basic expansion of the pandemic inflation, we had a K-shaped recovery.

2:26:12So we saw people at the upper end of the income distribution command higher and higher wages.

2:26:17That partly drove the inflation.

2:26:19But we saw people at the low end of the income distribution see no wage increase.

2:26:24And if you're subject to you know, economic eviction, which is what happens when you can't afford the rental increase and you're sort of kicked out.

2:26:35Your income has not kept pace with both rent and goods inflation.

2:26:39And so if we don't update this, then that means we're basically asking those tenants to bear an even larger share than we contemplated in 2017 of the cost of a move.

2:26:49And we're giving a benefit to the landlords, even the ones that, you know, we would hope are taking good care of their tenants on average.

2:26:57And so this is just, this is just just, I think, and it's consistent with our original policy thinking in 2017.

2:27:05And finally, I just want to address, and I'll move on here and yield, but I just want to address, there was a lot of claims, and we hear this a lot in a lot of different discussions, that this will just add to one more reason why people won't invest.

2:27:20Like, this will be the reason why we won't get that marginal outside capital to flow into Portland and build that new housing.

2:27:25I think that's a very fair point.

2:27:26And I just— I, at this point, I would just— people can say whatever they want without evidence, but I would say show me your pro forma.

2:27:34Show it to me.

2:27:35Show me the part of your pro forma that says, you know what, because of the relo moving from 10 to 5 and the increase in payment, this project never— doesn't pencil out now.

2:27:44Because I would challenge you to do that because there's no reasonable basis to forecast that.

2:27:49So if you're coming up with scenarios where your pro forma shows rent rent growing at the state maximum or this— or the sort of minimum of the rent control or even some sort of low-growth scenario.

2:28:00Those are all just conjectures.

2:28:02There's no way to model the impact of paying the relocation payment because the conditions by which that's triggered are extremely niche and rare.

2:28:12And so most of your tenants are not going to be subject to this because not everyone who receives an offer for a rent increase will choose to move.

2:28:20I think that's a good point.

2:28:22Some people have the incomes growing to support that and like where they live.

2:28:25And so I think a lot of that stuff is just sort of like, just trust us, we're the guys at the Capitol, we know what we're doing, and we're telling you this is bad.

2:28:32But I demand to see evidence for that because I have to show up for the tenants here who are literally telling me that they're getting evicted because they can't afford the rent.

2:28:43So those are the finer points I wanted to add.

2:28:46I support all 3 ordinances, and I'm happy to answer any questions.

2:28:49Thank you.

Candace Avalos 2:28:52 - 2:28:53

2:28:52Thank you, Vice Chair.

2:28:52Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:28:55 - 2:30:46

2:28:55Thank you, Chair.

2:28:57You know, I appreciate everybody who came to testify today.

2:29:02I want to specifically thank my constituent who testified toward the end, Mr. Simmons, who centered community and respect and, um, asked us all to make sure that we are paying attention to each other and, and being respectful of each other in this conversation.

2:29:21A 10% year-over-year rent increase is, is just not manageable for just about anyone.

2:29:32And as long as we live in a capitalist housing system, which none of these proposals change, I want to make sure that we are not inadvertently leading our housing market toward more and more corporatization because I've done policy work and advocacy work long enough to know that sometimes our best intentions help to corporatize parts of our market when we don't intend to.

2:30:01And I, I named both of those things because I'm holding both of those truths.

2:30:06Yeah.

2:30:07As I ask a couple of questions about the policies before us.

2:30:10And I, Chair, I'm not sure who we have from the Bureau or folks who can help answer questions, but my first question is about the second policy around the inflation rate.

2:30:24And I'm wondering why an inflationary tool wasn't included in the original proposal.

2:30:32And if there's anybody here who can provide us with a little bit of history, was that just overlooked?

2:30:36Was that intentional?

2:30:37Councilor Stevens.

2:30:38To understand how the change that we might be making today would fit with whatever that original rationale was.

Candace Avalos 2:30:47 - 2:30:51

2:30:47Yeah, we have some folks from the Housing Bureau.

2:30:48I can't see them in my line of sight, but there you go.

2:30:51Perfect.

2:30:51Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:30:52 - 2:30:55

2:30:52Behind the columns in this room, it's hard to know.

Candace Avalos 2:30:58 - 2:31:00

2:30:58Can't hide from us.

2:30:59We gotta ask you questions.

2:31:00Sorry.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:31:00 - 2:31:11

2:31:00So I'll just state the question again.

2:31:04As you're both sitting down, do we know why the original proposal didn't include an inflationary tool?

Josh Roper 2:31:13 - 2:31:20

2:31:13Josh Roper, Portland Housing Bureau.

2:31:15I don't actually.

2:31:17And if you mean a tool, sort of an automatic—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:31:21 - 2:31:34

2:31:21An automatic inflationary adjustment to ensure that the relocation assistance keeps up with, makes sense compared to both rents and also the yeah,.

Josh Roper 2:31:35 - 2:31:38

2:31:35I don't know.

2:31:36It was an option, but it wasn't chosen.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:31:39 - 2:32:18

2:31:39Okay.

2:31:39And, you know, we have a proposal before us that, Councilor, it sounds like you worked with the Bureau to develop, but I just want to hear from you all.

2:31:50Are you comfortable with the direction that's in there?

2:31:53It's to the City Administrator, but presumably that comes to you year over year and the guidance on how to adjust the fee structure.

2:32:02And are you comfortable that that will both keep up with what the need is, but also not surpass the need in a way that changes the incentive structure on either side, either by not keeping up or by surpassing the growth of costs?

Queesha Lyte 2:32:23 - 2:34:06

2:32:23Queesha Lyte, Interim Director of the Housing Bureau.

2:32:27From the perspective of are we comfortable with, you know, at the end of the day, the direction the council's gonna set is what we are going to follow.

2:32:37So what I will say, you know, I don't think that we're— you're asking us to necessarily do work we haven't, that we don't do in some way.

2:32:52But my concerns are more about what this will do, the cumulative impact of all of this, and what it would do from an administrative standpoint because of everything that we need to do to ensure that we're carrying out the direction of council from— so whether it's administrative rules and making sure everything is updated and done at the time it needs to be done, what that means from what the impact to my team is going to be as this especially in the, you know, the first year.

2:33:26What does this bring?

2:33:27Because it's new.

2:33:29And so getting the word out.

2:33:30So I don't know that necessarily there's a concern from, can we do this?

2:33:37And it's a matter of what it means, what it means in the context of the evaluation work that we're going to be doing, because we are still going to be doing that policy evaluation.

2:33:49And so what comes out of that?

2:33:50Yeah.

2:33:52So there are just some things of that nature that until we have done some of the evaluation, I don't know that— because you're getting at what are the unintended consequences or unintended impacts, and I don't necessarily— I think some of that is also in your question.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:34:07 - 2:34:23

2:34:07Some of— more specifically, I'm looking at the language that says that you will adopt administrative rules for assistance that looks at changes in the cost of relocation using data for rental cost averages multiplied by 3.

Queesha Lyte 2:34:24 - 2:34:24

2:34:24Yeah.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:34:25 - 2:34:49

2:34:25So as if the goal is for this to keep up with costs, is that formula the right formula?

2:34:35Do you think you're going to be able to get the right number that allows us to keep up with costs?

2:34:40My concern is if we're too low, we change the incentives.

2:34:43If we're too high, we change the incentives.

2:34:45If we're trying to maintain the policy incentives, Does this do that?

Josh Roper 2:34:51 - 2:35:10

2:34:51Yeah, I think a precise formula, we would wait for the evaluation to develop.

2:34:58I don't think this is an unreasonable approach.

2:35:01Okay.

2:35:02But in an ideal world, we would have the opportunity to spend more time evaluating.

2:35:08But I think it's, yeah, not unreasonable.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:35:10 - 2:35:11

2:35:10Okay.

2:35:11Thank you.

Candace Avalos 2:35:11 - 2:35:13

2:35:11Councilor, the sponsor has a response if you want.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:35:15 - 2:35:16

2:35:15Sure, happy to hear from you as well.

Mitch Green 2:35:17 - 2:36:18

2:35:17Yeah, I would just note that, um, we wanted to keep it a little flexible for the city administrator to determine what is the best way going forward, um, to do precisely with the thing I think that you're worried about, which is to make sure that it's calibrated at the appropriate level— not too hot, not too cold.

2:35:35And we started in this first tranche of just updating the numbers, uh, Using the CoStar data, which is based— which is sort of backward looking.

2:35:44It says, where are we at right now?

2:35:46We did test it with like CPI West, much higher numbers.

2:35:50Okay.

2:35:51And so we wanted to kind of be cognizant of, I think, that feeling, that sort of like, are we overshooting on this?

2:35:58And, you know, we want this to be credible and we want it to be durable.

2:36:03And so, you know, with the advice or sort of with the collaboration and iteration with the Housing Bureau, we landed on the CoStar here.

2:36:10I would expect that philosophy would be how this would continue to go forward.

2:36:15But I can't speak for the bureaus, but that's what I was thinking when we were working on it.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:36:19 - 2:36:46

2:36:19Thanks.

2:36:19I appreciate that and I appreciate the answer.

2:36:21And I recognize that trying to find that sweet spot of enough direction but not too much and enough time, but let's get this in a meaningful way is always hard to find.

2:36:31I think my hope is that what we're doing today is resetting what was the initial attempt at incentives and that we're resetting that and that we stay there.

2:36:44And it sounds like we're going to be able to do that.

Queesha Lyte 2:36:47 - 2:37:53

2:36:47Well, and I want to be clear that I think what we are saying also, I don't want to lose the fact that the evaluation could produce a methodology that gets us at, you know, not too hot, not too cold.

2:37:01And I don't know what that is going to say we should do.

2:37:05Right.

2:37:05So I think that, yes, I think if we looked at it and said, yes, it's minimal taken where we are right now, but if it's that the evaluation tells us that we should take a certain approach to ensure that we're not overly burdening landlords or renters, you know, that we're striking the right balance, I think that's where We just don't know, right?

2:37:35And I would just ask council to think about that.

2:37:39That would be my response to you, that we just don't know without that evaluation to really tell us that this is the right process, this is what the evaluation should be.

2:37:48And I don't know what that is, and therefore, what is that impact going to be on staff?

Josh Roper 2:37:53 - 2:38:03

2:37:53And I'd add that regardless of what decision is made here at full council, we would We would include this work in the evaluation regardless.

2:38:01So that work would continue either way.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:38:04 - 2:39:01

2:38:04Great.

2:38:04And I want to ask another question about the evaluation in a minute.

2:38:06I have 3 other questions, but I just, I want to note that I hear from you all the concern about how much is being piled on, right?

2:38:14There's a lot that we've asked of your bureau over the last almost 2 years, and now we're asking for even more.

2:38:22And I also recognize the other is the trying to hold a system that is not in a great place right now and make sure that we are making improvements and not doing things that inadvertently move us in the wrong direction.

2:38:38And I hear that, I hear both of those things in what you're saying.

2:38:42Yeah.

2:38:43I do have 3 additional questions.

2:38:46The first, relatively straightforward, Councilor Avalos, On the lowering the eligibility threshold, 5%.

2:38:56Why was 5% the number that was chosen as opposed to 3% or 7% or any other number?

Candace Avalos 2:39:03 - 2:40:02

2:39:03Yeah, I think that part of it is, you know, we know that the 10% is at the high level for the state, right?

2:39:09And that's why it was set at the 10% back then.

2:39:12Since then, the state law changed, right?

2:39:14And it created other I don't know what the word is.

2:39:18Caps, maybe?

2:39:19Caps.

2:39:20And yeah, the 5%, especially in line with the fact that it is in— it is still above the average, felt like we're trying— I'm trying to get it to a place where if we have another spike, if we have another pandemic years where the rent was going up like crazy, and then prior to the state, right, that we are ensuring that this is the threshold that we believe is— equals economic displacement, and therefore it triggers the relocation.

2:39:47So it just felt like aligned with the state law, with the averages, that that made sense to bring it down to 5%.

2:39:53Because in my view, it's not really affecting the market that much because you even heard from a lot of folks, they don't rent— they don't raise the rent more than 5%.

2:40:00So it's like a future protection more than anything.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:40:03 - 2:40:39

2:40:03Okay.

2:40:04So partly based on half of the state cap, partly based on where is the market today.

2:40:10Okay, okay, thank you.

2:40:12Um, I know that part of the initial concern in the setting at 10% was about legal challenges.

2:40:18Do we have anyone from our attorney's office?

2:40:21Perfect, thank you.

2:40:23Um, I am wondering if those concerns about legal challenges remain and the proposal today is essentially saying we're willing to take on that risk now in a way that we weren't previously, or if the legal calculation Matt.

Nancy Thorington 2:40:40 - 2:41:28

2:40:40Gander, Deputy City Attorney.

2:40:44When this was initially considered by council, we advised that there was legal risk.

2:40:50The city was sued.

2:40:52We went to the Supreme Court, the Oregon Supreme Court, and won.

2:40:57And we think that that was a good decision for the city, but not necessarily a result that was preordained.

2:41:07So we've advised that all of the options before you are yellow lights, that, you know, the city has clear precedent that the law that we have on the books survived the legal challenges.

2:41:21And, you know, kind of the further you get away from the laws that we have right now, the more legal risk.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:41:30 - 2:42:58

2:41:30So this, when you say yellow light, there is an increase in legal risk if we pass any of these policies.

2:41:37That increase probably goes up the more we pass collectively.

2:41:41It is, each one individually is a yellow light, not a red light.

2:41:45I won't press you too hard on at what point we hit red light, but presumably too much tinkering hits red light.

2:41:51Medium tinkering keeps us in yellow light.

2:41:54Okay.

2:41:55Thank you.

2:41:55That's helpful context.

2:41:57And then final question.

2:42:00I have heard repeatedly for a significant amount of time and again today that there's going to be a PHB study of our tenant protections.

2:42:10And the policies that we're considering today are just one of our tenant protections.

2:42:15We have others on the books as well.

2:42:17We have other affordability measures on the books as well.

2:42:22What is the state of that study?

2:42:24What is the timing?

2:42:25How broad will it be?

2:42:26I am cognizant of the fact that all 3 of these proposals change what we have.

2:42:33I think some change what we have more than others, and I'm trying to balance.

2:42:39We have some critical needs in our rental market, and I want to understand what is working and what is not.

2:42:48Thank you.

2:42:49Before we go and change it too much.

2:42:51And so I'm trying to figure out the balance there.

2:42:54Where are we at with a study, both breadth of the study and timing of the study?

Queesha Lyte 2:43:00 - 2:43:20

2:43:00Well, we are excited to at least be able to say the contract has finally been taken care of.

2:43:06It's been a long road to get through that procurement process.

2:43:10So I'll allow Josh to kind of walk you through where the team is with that, the scope and other things right now.

2:43:17But we are at least done with the contract.

2:43:20So,.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:43:20 - 2:43:21

2:43:20Right, in process.

Josh Roper 2:43:21 - 2:44:53

2:43:21Yes, in process.

2:43:22Yeah, contract is executed.

2:43:24We're about to have a kickoff meeting with the consultant team and start the process of designing the evaluation.

2:43:30We're looking to get a report delivered December of next year, and we're expecting some interim findings or interim report mid— probably mid-year next year.

2:43:43So depending on the structure of the design of the evaluation itself, we will decide which pieces get included in which of those or both in some cases.

2:43:54I'll also say the contract is for 2 years because part of what we're trying to accomplish is building out a more robust research and evaluation function within the Housing Bureau.

2:44:05So that is, to an extent, a staffing question.

2:44:07It's also just an expertise question among staff.

2:44:10Okay.

2:44:10Who are at the Bureau already building those skills.

2:44:15So we're moving in this direction in kind of a comprehensive way.

2:44:21In terms of the breadth of the study itself, it is meant to be quite broad.

2:44:25It includes fare, it includes mandatory relocation, and it includes other policies both from the landlord and tenant perspective.

2:44:35We really want to think about just speaking to the landlord side, how can we make it easier for landlords to comply with the regulatory landscape in Portland without harming tenants?

2:44:46Because I think that is a legitimate, valuable exercise, and I think there's real progress we could make there.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:44:54 - 2:45:29

2:44:54Okay, and I assume that as we get those results, maybe even the interim results, not waiting until the end, Yeah.

2:45:03And you may have recommendations for us on what is working and we need to absolutely keep on the books, what is creating the incentives it's supposed to, but we need to make some changes to keep up, and what is perhaps creating some of the inverse incentives that we heard might be being created right now.

2:45:25We don't have that research yet, though, in order to offer us recommendations.

Queesha Lyte 2:45:30 - 2:45:30

2:45:30Correct.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:45:31 - 2:46:12

2:45:31Okay, thank you.

2:45:32I really appreciate all the answers to those questions as I hold the need to make sure that we are ensuring that these policies keep up with changing needs and changing economy, and also the need to make sure that we are not creating inverse incentives.

2:45:50And we are getting the report to let us know how we're doing.

2:45:53I think we need to make thank you, Chair.

Candace Avalos 2:46:15 - 2:46:15

2:46:15I.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:46:19 - 2:48:12

2:46:19Wanted to say thank you to everyone who came out today.

2:46:21Testify today.

2:46:22I know that for many of you, it's really— it's vulnerable.

2:46:27And folks were sharing personal things about challenges, whether it's challenges facing as a tenant or also, you know, coming here and really wanting to highlight the difference between small-scale landlord situations and corporate landlord situations.

2:46:45I think those are conversations we need to keep discussing.

2:46:49And another councilor said this, but I think that, I believe you can, multiple things can be true at the same time.

2:46:56And I know it's true that there are, you can be a landlord and also care about the rights and wellbeing of tenants too.

2:47:04There's actually one of my constituents here at, who was at one of the rental ripoffs and was saying themself as a small landlord that they— Yeah.

2:47:14I want to see the city doing— being more proactive in enforcing some of the laws that we have on the books and making sure that we're beefing that up and making sure that we're able to be proactive at the city.

2:47:26Otherwise, it's like, it might as well some of those laws don't exist if they're not being enforced.

2:47:30So I think that's another thing we need to be discussing.

2:47:33And I do want to also underscore and remind everyone, one testifier said this specifically too, that none of these ordinances are rent caps.

2:47:42There's no prohibition on raising the rent.

2:47:45We're preempted by the state.

2:47:47They can— only they can do that.

2:47:48Um, and what these ordinances really do, um, are offering tenants options and support, uh, to find something if, um, that they can afford if they are priced out.

2:47:59So really appreciate everyone, really appreciate, um, all the work of our staff too, and I, um, appreciate you Attorney Gander, I've heard that you've been really wonderful to work with and very helpful.

2:48:11So thank you, everyone.

Candace Avalos 2:48:17 - 2:49:13

2:48:17Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

2:48:23Right.

2:48:23I don't see other folks in the queue right now.

2:48:27Maybe I'll just say one quick note because it, you know, has come up around the study that the Housing Bureau is going to do and and it's broader than just this policy.

2:48:38But I think my general response to that is we can't wait.

2:48:43We can't wait for a study.

2:48:45These are common sense reforms.

2:48:46They're reforms that have been suggested over many years.

2:48:49RSO has suggested we make some of these changes.

2:48:52Even Councilor Ryan has suggested them in the past.

2:48:55They're pretty straightforward.

2:48:57And so it's my view that we don't need to wait for that study, though that study will provide more future information that we can adjust.

2:49:05So just wanted to answer that because I'm sure that'll come up at some point of like, why are we doing this now?

2:49:09Why do I feel we should do this now instead of waiting?

2:49:11And that's my answer.

2:49:13Councilor Green.

Mitch Green 2:49:15 - 2:49:22

2:49:15Thank you, Chair Avalos.

2:49:16I was getting in the queue to, to make some motions if, if that's your prerogative at this time.

Candace Avalos 2:49:22 - 2:49:23

2:49:22Yeah, sure.

Mitch Green 2:49:24 - 2:49:38

2:49:24Okay, I, I will move document number 2026 —418, um, uh, to be recommended— gosh, how does this go— referred to—.

Candace Avalos 2:49:38 - 2:49:39

2:49:38I can—.

Mitch Green 2:49:39 - 2:49:40

2:49:39You've got the language, right?

Candace Avalos 2:49:40 - 2:49:42

2:49:40Sorry.

2:49:42Yeah,.

Mitch Green 2:49:42 - 2:49:46

2:49:42Referred to city— the full council for the due pass recommendation.

2:49:45Do I have a second?

Candace Avalos 2:49:46 - 2:49:53

2:49:46Yes, second.

2:49:47Thanks.

2:49:48I have the language here.

2:49:49Sorry.

2:49:50Okay.

2:49:51Um, okay, so that was 418, yes?

Mitch Green 2:49:53 - 2:49:55

2:49:53Yes, that's correct.

Candace Avalos 2:49:55 - 2:50:07

2:49:55Okay, so Councilor Green moved uh, I have seconded it.

2:50:02Discussion?

2:50:06Seeing none, let's move to a vote.

Mitch Green 2:50:11 - 2:50:11

2:50:11Aye.

Keelan McClymont 2:50:12 - 2:50:30

2:50:12No.

2:50:15Aye.

2:50:17Avalos.

2:50:18Aye.

2:50:19With 3 ayes, 1 nay, and 1 absent, the motion carries.

2:50:23And the ordinance document number 2026-418 moves to City Council with the recommendation it be passed.

Candace Avalos 2:50:32 - 2:50:34

2:50:32Thank you.

2:50:34Councilor?

Mitch Green 2:50:35 - 2:50:46

2:50:35Uh, thank you, uh, Chair.

2:50:37I, I, at this time, I will move document number 2026-419 to be recommended, uh, to be referred to the full Council with a do pass recommendation.

Candace Avalos 2:50:47 - 2:50:53

2:50:47Second.

2:50:50Further discussion?

2:50:53Oh, Councilor Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:50:54 - 2:50:55

2:50:54Oh, sorry, I'm just—.

Candace Avalos 2:50:55 - 2:50:59

2:50:55Oh, for the— okay, got it.

2:50:57Uh, please call the roll.

Unidentified speaker 2:51:01 - 2:51:08

2:51:01Motion to refer document number 2026-419, moved by Green, seconded by Avalos.

2:51:08Green?

Mitch Green 2:51:09 - 2:51:09

2:51:09Aye.

Unidentified speaker 2:51:10 - 2:51:11

2:51:10Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:51:11 - 2:51:11

2:51:11Aye.

Unidentified speaker 2:51:12 - 2:51:13

2:51:12Koyama Lane?

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:51:13 - 2:51:13

2:51:13Aye.

Unidentified speaker 2:51:14 - 2:51:14

2:51:14Avalos?

Candace Avalos 2:51:15 - 2:51:15

2:51:15Aye.

Unidentified speaker 2:51:16 - 2:51:23

2:51:16With 4 ayes and 1 absent, the motion carries, and the ordinance is referred to the full council with the recommendation it be passed.

Candace Avalos 2:51:24 - 2:51:24

2:51:24Councilor Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:51:26 - 2:51:42

2:51:26Chair, I'd like to move item number 4, document number 2026-420, which is an ordinance to amend Portland Renter Additional Protections Code to add relocation assistance increase for tenants with school-aged children, to be referred to the full council with a do pass recommendation, and I'd appreciate a second.

Candace Avalos 2:51:43 - 2:51:51

2:51:43Second.

2:51:44Moved by Councilor Koyama Lane, seconded by Pirtle-Guiney.

2:51:47Any other discussion?

2:51:50Seeing none, please call the roll.

Mitch Green 2:51:55 - 2:51:55

2:51:55Aye.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:51:56 - 2:51:58

2:51:56Aye.

2:51:58Aye.

Unidentified speaker 2:52:00 - 2:52:10

2:52:00Aye.

2:52:01With 4 ayes and 1 absent, the motion carries, and the ordinance document number 2026-420 will move to the full council with a recommendation it be.

Candace Avalos 2:52:12 - 2:52:51

2:52:12Okay, uh, colleagues, so we have moved these out of committee.

2:52:16Uh, they, I, they will go to full council.

2:52:18I suspect that there will be some further discussions.

2:52:21I came into this meeting hoping that we could try to find a way to blend some of them, but just due to time, uh, and interest, I think it's, it's a discussion we can have at the full council with the rest of our colleagues.

2:52:32Um, so with that, uh, announcements, we've got 2 more meetings We have 2 meetings coming up in December on the 1st and on the 15th, uh, and on the 1st we will be returning to our discussion on the climate and health standards.

2:52:44Uh, with that, I will now adjourn our meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee at 4:50 PM.

2:52:50Thank you.