windowbox

Community & Public Safety Committee

Official agenda

Transcript

Transcript

Automatically generated transcript. It may contain errors and includes testimony in languages other than English that is not individually marked up for assistive technology.

Angelita Morillo 3:55 - 4:05

3:55All right.

3:58Hello, everybody.

4:01Can folks hear me okay?

4:04Okay.

Steve Novick 4:05 - 4:05

4:05Yes.

Angelita Morillo 4:06 - 4:23

4:06Great.

4:07Look at all of us here on time, um, virtually.

4:12Uh, good morning, everybody.

4:14Today is Tuesday, November 17th, 2026, at 9:30 AM.

4:19Fake gavel moment.

4:21Clerk, could you please call the roll?

Keelan McClymont 4:25 - 4:25

4:25Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 4:26 - 4:27

4:26Absent.

Keelan McClymont 4:27 - 4:32

4:27Smith?

4:31Councilor Smith, are you present?

Loretta Smith 4:34 - 4:35

4:34Absent.

Keelan McClymont 4:35 - 4:36

4:35Kanal?

Sameer Kanal 4:36 - 4:37

4:36Present.

Keelan McClymont 4:38 - 4:38

4:38Morillo?

Angelita Morillo 4:40 - 4:40

4:40Here.

Steve Novick 4:43 - 4:45

4:43Novick.

4:45Here.

Angelita Morillo 4:45 - 5:31

4:45Um, thanks everybody.

4:46Thanks for being here virtually.

4:47Sorry to folks watching at home.

4:49Uh, we have a few folks that are at a conference right now.

4:52Um, I am recovering from being sick, and so we are— a lot of us are going to be— all of us are going to be virtual today because of that.

5:00Um, but we have a pretty good agenda, and, um, because there's only 3 of us present virtually today, uh, colleagues, just so you're aware, We have to keep our cameras on at all times to maintain quorum.

5:14So I think in about, you know, an hour and a half or so, I can give us a 5-minute break in case anyone needs to take a pause, use the restroom, get some water, and that way we can still maintain quorum.

5:28And could you please read the first item on the agenda?

Keelan McClymont 5:33 - 5:36

5:33And Council Operations will read the statement of conduct.

Angelita Morillo 5:36 - 5:38

5:36Oh, yes, please.

5:37Thank you.

5:37Sorry.

Unidentified speaker 5:39 - 6:13

5:39Welcome to the meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee.

5:42To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/community-and-public-safety-committee or by calling 311.

5:57Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

6:00Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

6:04In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

6:07For public testimony during today's meeting, individuals may testify for 90 seconds unless the chair states otherwise.

Keelan McClymont 6:13 - 6:46

6:13Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

6:15The chair preserves order.

6:17Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

6:26If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

6:28Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

6:30Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

6:34Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

6:38Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

6:41When testifying, 1, state your name for the record.

6:432, If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

Unidentified speaker 6:46 - 6:50

6:46And 3, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

6:50Thank you.

Angelita Morillo 6:52 - 6:55

6:52Thank you so much.

6:54Um, Councilor Novick, do you have your hand up?

Steve Novick 6:56 - 7:09

6:56I, I do.

6:57Um, I just want to remind you, I actually have to leave in 90 minutes.

7:00I told you a couple of weeks ago I had a flight to Nashville, and I could— we could do a short meeting, or I could change the flight.

7:06And you told me not to change the flight, so I haven't.

Angelita Morillo 7:10 - 7:34

7:10Okay, great.

7:11Well, I think that means that we could get through the first item then, which is Councilor Kanal's, and then anything else we'll have to— oh, I think that's all we have anyways.

7:22So yeah, we can do this efficiently.

7:25We have until 10:55 scheduled for this item.

7:31So, um, could you please read into the record the next item?

Keelan McClymont 7:35 - 7:46

7:35Item number 1, document number 2026-417, add city code to establish a Community Safety Bureau, add code chapter 3.137.

Angelita Morillo 7:48 - 8:09

7:48Awesome, thank you so much.

7:50Um, and Councilor Kanal, this is your item, so I will pass it off to you and your team for the presentation.

7:57And I think it would be good to get, you know, this done today.

8:00So again, this item is scheduled till 10:55, and I presume that, Councilor Novick, you will let us know when you are ready to run out the door so we can get that done beforehand.

8:09Thank you.

Sameer Kanal 8:11 - 12:38

8:11Thank you, Vice Chair Murillo.

8:12Thank you, Chair Novick.

8:14Very happy to have this opportunity to present today.

8:16I apologize I can't be in person today.

8:19My chief of staff, Lisa Freeman, is there.

8:20She can help answer questions.

8:21She'll also be sharing the slides.

8:26So this is an ordinance to establish a Community Safety Bureau within the Public Safety Service Area.

8:30You may remember from our last meeting on October 20th, 2026, the creation of this bureau was the first recommendation from the Portland Street Response Advisory Committee, which this council created last year.

8:40They shared a lot of information about why they recommend this path.

8:43I encourage everyone to watch that presentation if you missed it.

8:46But what you may not know is that the request for a bureau to surround the community safety programs was first made by the Public Safety Service Area itself in early 2025 in response to a fiscal year 2025 next slide, please.

9:18So today's presentation, we're going to talk about the legislation, why it's important, hear from the Community Safety Bureau programs themselves.

9:23We have 3 invited speakers with us to share about why this legislation matters both locally and nationally and how we can learn from the experience of other jurisdictions who've established similar community safety departments.

9:34We'll hear from Amie Wexler, Executive Director of the Alliance for a Safe Oregon, Amy Barden, Chief of the CARE Department in Seattle, and Mariela Ruiz-Angel, Community Safety Programs Director at Georgetown Law's Center for Innovation in Community Safety.

9:49And then as usual, we'll have time for technical Q&A, public testimony, and committee deliberation.

9:54Next slide, please.

9:57This ordinance is pretty simple.

9:59It adds city code to create a Community Safety Bureau within the Public Safety Service Area.

10:04You can see all the different parts that we're talking about here.

10:08Next slide, please.

10:09The way it would bring this together is in an org chart.

10:12This org chart may look very familiar to you because it is almost exactly the same as the current PSSA org chart.

10:18What we're doing with this legislation is actually primarily codifying what already exists in practice.

10:22Which is that the Office of Violence Prevention, Ceasefire, and Portland Street Response are part of Community Safety Programs within the Public Safety Service Area.

10:30The difference is that Community Safety Programs, which currently operate as part of the office of the DCA, would become their own bureau under their own bureau director.

10:38And this is all in service of establishing Community Safety as a co-equal branch of Portland's public safety system, which is work that this council started through the Portland Street Response resolution that was adopted last year.

10:50Thank you.

10:51So some might ask, if the org structure is basically already in place, why create a new bureau?

10:55What is gained by codifying the current practice?

10:58And if you could go to the next slide, please.

11:01And the simple reason is, for too long, violence prevention, community violence intervention, and community or mobile crisis response work has been seen as nice-to-have extras alongside quote-unquote core public safety service areas.

11:14This work has been viewed as programs to be funded when money is available, but maybe not funded when money is tighter.

11:19Thank you.

11:19Support and funding for these services has ebbed and flowed.

11:22One year, Rose City Self-Defense is on the chopping block.

11:25The next year, the Safe Blocks program is on the chopping block.

11:28And violence prevention programs have gone from $2 million a year to $10 million a year during a gun violence crisis, and then back down when the crisis has subsided.

11:35It is very difficult, as I'm sure everyone here can imagine, to build a program strategy when one does not know if you're going to have $2 million or $10 million in a given year.

11:45This ordinance starts to acknowledge formally and officially that these programs are core public safety services.

11:51They're no longer pilots.

11:52They're no longer alternative.

11:54They're not supplemental or optional.

11:55They're critical and core public safety programs of our city.

11:59And it's time for us to establish them as permanent and essential, affirm that they're critical to a robust, holistic, and integrated public safety system.

12:07In Portland, our core public safety services are organized into bureaus.

12:10So community safety programs should be organized as a bureau as well.

12:15I'm next gonna turn it over to our Community Safety Program staff themselves to share a bit about what they do and how the programs and the community benefit from working together.

12:23I'm not sure who's in the room and who's online, but I know that collectively we have our Community Safety Programs Director, Stephanie Howard, Sarah Ellis from Portland Ceasefire, Jamie Evans Baker from the Office of Violence Prevention, and Ebony Morgan from Portland Street Response.

12:37Thank you to all of you for being here.

Angelita Morillo 12:49 - 12:53

12:49Um, thank you all for being here.

12:51Sorry, we have to be virtual and go ahead and get started.

Sameer Kanal 13:06 - 13:07

13:06Looks like we're having a microphone issue.

Stephanie Howard 13:10 - 16:54

13:10There we go.

13:11There we go.

13:11Okay, we've got sound.

13:13Uh, thank you so much, Councilor Kanal, uh, and, and to the committee for bringing this item forward for us to, to talk about today.

13:19My name, for the record, is Stephanie Howard.

13:21I use she/her pronouns, and I'm the Director of Community Safety Programs.

13:25Um, there's so much that was said, uh, better than I could by Councilor Kanal, but I'll, I'll just briefly touch on a few aspects of this.

13:33This item and why this is a very meaningful and important moment for public safety in the City of Portland.

13:40As you heard from Councilor Kanal, this is not a new idea.

13:44This is an idea that has come out of prior leadership, several generations, and has been in the works and on the agenda for many of us working in public safety for years.

13:57I took over as the director of these programs in January of 2024, and at that point, at that point, former DCA Mike Myers had established the structure.

14:09Then DCA Bob Causie was champion for this and for bringing this forward as a bureau.

14:16And frankly, for the last few years, we have been doing everything we can to operate as a bureau.

14:21And that includes some really uninteresting things at the back of the house, like creating accounting codes and functional areas and things like that.

14:28But it's important to distinguish, to allow us to distinguish the work from the larger DCA's office and enable that more broad impact of public safety across the spectrum of our services.

14:41This structure has proven to be a successful and impactful structure.

14:49In bringing these programs together under one sort of roof, what we have found is that they have increased stability.

14:57They have a lot more opportunity for collaboration, and we're seeing a great deal more of our ability to identify ways to work better together and to build our collaboration.

15:07Thank you.

15:09So the, the other thing is, because these programs, many of which have been around for decades, they have been moved from place to place to place because they didn't quite fit in with traditional safety approaches, but they all clearly have a safety nexus.

15:28And by bringing them together, what we can do is ensure that they have more consistency in strategy that is cohesive with the broader public safety system.

15:38We have greater inconsistencies in funding.

15:41We can remove inefficiencies and try to create more opportunity that helps serve the community as a whole.

15:48And I think establishing a bureau that's focused on bringing those community-based tools to complement the traditional public safety tools really benefits the community and our system partners.

15:59Preventing a crisis from occurring in the first place is something I think we all would prefer to have done.

16:04And it— in preventing those, we're not only reducing harm to the community, we're helping to alleviate system strain, we're relieving costs and overwhelm on our police, our courts, jails, prisons, many other systems where we can bring more immediate support to folks who are in need.

16:23I will hand it over briefly to each of our program managers for the programs today, but I did just want to say that I think enshrining this work in a bureau gives community-based programs a permanent place at the table in helping to decide how our city delivers public safety.

16:39This is a lasting commitment to bringing more approaches to the work so we can reach more people and respond in more ways that meet the community's needs.

16:47So thank you very much for bringing this forward.

16:49I'll hand it over to Sierra Ellis, our— to speak for the Ceasefire Program.

Sierra Ellis 16:55 - 18:06

16:55Good morning, everyone.

16:56My name is Sierra Ellis.

17:00And I am the Ceasefire Program Manager.

17:02I'm going to talk to you a bit about Ceasefire and why this bureau creation is important to Ceasefire.

17:09Ceasefire is an essential gun violence reduction strategy that is focused on intervening with individuals at the highest risk of involvement in gun violence, providing both direct support, resources, and accountability to individuals and families who need it most.

17:24Ceasefire service providers can leverage additional resources and support systems through the Office of Violence Prevention and Portland Street Response to better meet, meet the needs of their clients.

17:35Sharing a physical space and having direct access to managers leading these programs creates opportunities for greater collaboration and more effective communication and coordination and coordinated service delivery.

17:47Ultimately, this integration allows us to operate as a more cohesive, efficient community safety system while maintaining the distinct mission and specialized expertise of each program.

17:57The greatest beneficiaries of this alignment are the individuals, the families, and the communities we all collectively serve.

18:05Now I'll pass it on to my colleague Jamie.

Jamie Evans Butler 18:08 - 20:58

18:08Good morning, everyone.

18:09My name is Jamie Evans Butler, and I'm the manager of the Office of Violence Prevention.

18:14I'm going to also speak for a few moments about the work that we do in the Office of Violence Prevention and why the Community Safety Bureau and the creation of the bureau is important from our perspective.

18:26Violence prevention is really the work that we do to address the root causes of violence, and we do that through the Office of Violence Prevention through a number of different ways.

18:35I think some of you may be familiar with our grants, the Safer Portland grants, which provide funding to community-based organizations to really work with young people that are at risk of violence.

18:46Where Ceasefire works with the highest-risk individuals, we really focus at the at-risk individual population.

18:52Thank you.

18:52And those grants, those services are really critical to providing things like wraparound services, mental health support, workforce development, mentorship.

19:03And we really rely on funding for those community-based organizations to be able to provide that support.

19:10And as Councilor Kanal was mentioning, when that funding is vulnerable, that means that our programming is vulnerable as well.

19:17So creating a bureau and having more financial stability for the work that we're doing would be really essential.

19:23Also, there are other teams within our office as well that do all different kinds of violence prevention work, like crime prevention, and that is really done through our Safe Blocks team.

19:33They work really closely with communities to do things like support resource fairs, different events within the communities.

19:41They also provide a lot of support in terms of analyzing the physical risks to spaces by doing SEPTED analysis, which is basically an assessment of an environment to see what physical security improvements you can make to a business or to a housing development or to an individual's residence.

20:01And that also relies on consistent funding as well.

20:04And having a bureau would really create a solid foundation for that team and the work that they do.

20:11And then lastly, the Rose City Self-Defense team is also part of the Office of Violence Prevention, and they really work on individual safety through providing self-defense training to individuals all across Portland.

20:25And this is a team of 2 staff that has a really robust volunteer network that has traditionally not had any funding and now has a little bit of funding.

20:35So that kind of support for, for their work as well is really essential in terms of working on individual safety.

20:43And all of those efforts combined really are what we do at the Office of Violence Prevention in terms of working on those root causes of violence.

20:52And I really think having a bureau would really create a lot more stability for that work.

20:58Thank you.

Stephanie Howard 20:59 - 21:01

20:59We'll hand it over to Ebony.

Ebony Morgan 21:03 - 23:41

21:03Hi, I'm Ebony Morgan.

21:04I am the new Portland Street Response permanent program manager.

21:09Um, I've been here for a couple of months now and gotten very familiar with PSR and the variety of opinions and hopes and dreams that folks have for this program.

21:21Um, I have previously led 2 crisis response programs, um, CAHOOTS in the city of Eugene and UMCR in the city of Los Angeles.

21:30Um, and so my goal here is to get PSR To where folks in Portland want it, to also have 24-hour services and as much scope as the City of Portland wants to give us that we can safely manage.

21:46There's a lot of different takes on how to do that.

21:49And one of the things about crisis response, regardless of where I've been, is that it always exists in kind of a gray area.

21:56The work itself is a little bit of everything else.

21:58Thank you.

21:59And the feedback that I've been able to gather from our community partners and from the community themselves since I've gotten to Portland has some similarities.

22:09And one of those, the most kind of consistent through line, is that people want to understand exactly what the intention is and they want to understand what makes PSR accountable.

22:18What are our protocols?

22:20What is our structure?

22:21How does it work?

22:22And I think the more that PSR can exist inside of already established city structures that will give it some credibility and consistency along with our other partner agencies is going to help folks understand what we do and also feel like there's a way to kind of hold us accountable to what we've promised to be able to do.

22:44I intend to bring all of our goals into kind of a synthesized fruition with my own vision in mind.

22:52Thank you.

22:53But I need buy-in from folks to believe that it'll work.

22:56And I think putting a structure together that holds PSR and our partner programs to the expectations of a city bureau is one of many steps in making sure that we are as effective as we can be for the city and for— to assuage some concerns, not creating too much redundancy among programs that could easily exist together.

23:19I think there's a lot of very good work we can do, and I just want to quickly flag my gratitude for a conversation that is aimed at making Portland Street Response and OVP and ceasefire permanent and essential rather than something considered alternative.

23:34I think that regardless of what happens, it is very, very motivating to hear that that's a goal within the city of Portland.

Stephanie Howard 23:42 - 23:47

23:42And thank you so much.

23:43We will be in the audience and happy to answer questions if councilors have any.

Sameer Kanal 23:48 - 25:40

23:48Thank you.

23:50To Stephanie, Sierra, Jamie, and Ebony, I'll note I got Jamie's name wrong.

23:53Apologies there.

23:55Uh, so, um, as we go forward in the slides, um, just to include what's in the, in the code that would establish this bureau, it may not surprise anyone here to know that, um, if you look at the city code, the code that establishes other bureaus is completely inconsistent, uh, has different things.

24:13Some of it overlaps, but there's no particular structure, rhyme, or reason to how code establishes bureaus.

24:20So we tried to stick to the bare essentials that is in that overlap: the purpose, the duties and responsibilities, organization, and community engagement.

24:26So I'll start with this.

24:29The purpose of it is to create an unarmed, non-enforcement, trauma-informed branch of the public safety system.

24:35All portions of that are really important— how its attributes are defined, but also the fact that it is part of the public safety system.

24:41It is It's not separate from it, but integrated with it.

24:44The duties and responsibilities, these are a list of things that are mentioned in the code, all of which are already things that parts of this bureau or parts of this office currently do.

24:56Organization, as stated, bureau will consist of an Office of Violence Prevention, Portland Ceasefire, Portland Street Response.

25:04And then community engagement, which is a requirement that each unit will have a publicly available Community Engagement Plan, and that renews on a regular basis, as well as this code renewing the Portland Street Response Committee, which council established last year.

25:20All right, I think we're ready for the panel presentation.

25:24So I'm not, again, not sure who's online, who's— I think they're all online actually, probably, but would love to pass it over to Amie Wexler from Alliance for a Safe Oregon, followed by Amy Barden, Seattle Care, and Mariela Angel.

25:36From the Georgetown University Center for Innovations in Community Safety, and they're all online.

Angelita Morillo 25:41 - 25:59

25:41Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

25:42And just to keep us on track, we have about 5 minutes budgeted for this presentation, then we'll move on to technical questions from the councilors, and then we'll move into public testimony.

25:52And I believe we have 4 people signed up, so just giving you a time frame for all the stuff coming up.

25:58And if folks are online, go right ahead.

Amy Wexler 26:02 - 26:08

26:02Hi there.

26:04Is it, is it my turn?

26:05Sorry about that.

26:06Yes, Amy Wexler.

Angelita Morillo 26:08 - 26:08

26:08Yes.

Amy Wexler 26:08 - 26:31

26:08Okay, thank you.

26:09So sorry.

26:10Um, my name is Amy Wexler.

26:11I am the executive director of the Alliance for a Safe Oregon.

26:14Thank you so much for the opportunity to testify in support of establishing a Community Safety Bureau that brings together the Office of Violence Prevention, Portland Street Response, and Ceasefire.

26:23The Alliance for a Safe Oregon believes that public safety must be about more than I'm sorry, can you still hear me?

Keelan McClymont 26:35 - 26:36

26:35Yes, we can hear you.

Amy Wexler 26:36 - 30:44

26:36Okay, sorry, my, uh, my, my own visual went away.

26:39Sorry about that.

26:40Um, it must also be about preventing violence, intervening before conflicts become deadly, and supporting people in crisis and building communities where everyone has the opportunity to be safe.

26:53That requires a comprehensive approach, and it requires sustained investment.

26:57For too long, community-based violence intervention programs have had to navigate fragmented systems, uncertain funding, and competing priorities.

27:05Organizations doing this work cannot build lasting relationships with communities, retain experienced staff, or plan effective interventions when they are constantly wondering whether the funding will exist next year.

27:16The proposal before you is an important opportunity to change that.

27:19While these programs are different, their connected missions make them a good fit for combining into one bureau.

27:25The Office of Violence Prevention works with communities to address the underlying conditions that contribute to violence and to support prevention, intervention, and healing.

27:34Ceasefire focuses on reducing shootings and homicides by working with individuals at the highest risk of involvement in gun violence while connecting them with services, support, and pathways away from violence.

27:44And Portland Street Response provides an alternative to a traditional emergency response for people experiencing behavioral health crisis, offering a compassionate, unarmed response that connects people with appropriate care.

27:57Each program has a distinct purpose and requires specialized expertise, but together they represent something that Portland needs: a public safety system that recognizes prevention, intervention, and crisis response as essential components of A unified bureau can help these programs coordinate their work, share information and resources appropriately, reduce administrative barriers, and develop a more cohesive strategy for responding to the needs of Portland communities.

28:25Importantly, the structure also recognizes that public safety is not exclusive— exclusively the work of police and traditional emergency responders.

28:33Community-based organizations, violence intervention professionals, behavioral health responders, survivors, and neighborhood leaders are essential partners in keeping our city safe.

28:43But organizational structure alone is not enough.

28:46We must also commit to stable, ongoing funding.

28:49A new bureau will only succeed if it has the resources to carry out its mission.

28:54We know that violence prevention work depends on relationships.

28:57It takes time to build trust with young people, families, survivors, and individuals at the highest risk of being involved in gun violence.

29:05It takes sustained investment to support credible messengers, community-based organizations, outreach workers, and the people who show up every day to help prevent the next shooting.

29:14When funding is temporary or unpredictable, those relationships and programs are put at risk.

29:20Experienced staff leave and community partners struggle to retain their teams, and prevention efforts lose momentum.

29:27Community members are left responding to crises Councilmember Wexler.

29:30Thank you, Mayor.

29:30We have heard from many witnesses that could have been prevented.

29:31We cannot continue to treat violence prevention as an optional investment that is funded when resources are available and reduced when budgets become difficult.

29:40The city needs to establish this dependable ongoing commitment for the bureau with transparent budget allocations for each of its core programs.

29:47This funding should support both city operations and the community-based organizations that are doing critical work on the ground.

29:54We also encourage council to ensure that the new bureau maintains meaningful community engagement the people most affected by gun violence and behavioral health crises must have a voice in shaping these programs, setting priorities, and evaluating whether the work is making a difference.

30:10That means listening to community partners, survivors, young people in neighborhoods that have experienced disproportionate levels of violence.

30:17At the Alliance for a Safe Oregon, much of our work is focused on reducing gun violence and preventing firearm suicide.

30:23We know that no single policy, program, or agency can solve these challenges.

30:25Thank you.

30:26Challenges alone.

30:27Progress requires coordination across government, law enforcement, healthcare, community organizations, and the people directly affected by this violence.

30:36A Community Safety Bureau is a meaningful step toward that kind of coordination.

30:40Thank you for this opportunity, and I'd be happy to be a resource going forward.

Angelita Morillo 30:50 - 30:59

30:50Thank you, Amy.

30:52I only see Amy Barden online, and then I think we're also waiting for Mariela.

30:57So, um, Amy, why don't you take it away?

Amy Barden 31:00 - 32:54

31:00Yeah, good morning, councilors.

31:01Amy Barden, Department.

31:03I'm actually in New York with Mariela.

31:05Um, we are at a, a small convening of leaders talking about this subject, how to set up and legislate 3rd public safety department.

31:12So commend your progress so far.

31:14Um, what I wanted to share with you is just retrospectively the 4 years almost that I've been in this role, the significance of actually establishing that parent that we have 3 public safety departments with 3 chiefs.

31:27So I think about the care department principally as the diversion department.

31:32What resources are available prior to the 911 calling call coming in?

31:36And then who is responding to reentry needs?

31:40How are we actually breaking these cycles?

31:43And structuring it with 3 co-equal leaders creates a different hierarchy.

31:48It organizes the work and it creates accountability.

31:51Seattle now is used to 3 chiefs in every conversation.

31:53It would be highly irregular to hear from the police chief.

31:55Thank you.

31:55Now, in part, that's because I have oversight of 911, and so I can comment on the types of calls and needs in community.

32:05But Seattle also understands the way that Portland does, that law enforcement is a tool in public safety and should not be principally responsible for preventing or breaking cycles of crisis that do relate to behavioral health needs.

32:19And so I think this is a very important step forward you're taking.

32:22You basically have invested in all of these different programs, and now you just need to consolidate them.

32:26Thank you.

32:27And organize them and make sure that there is a leader with a voice in the conversation who is accountable for sort of the integration and cooperation, and also integration with the police and fire bureaus down there.

32:39That's really important.

32:41I do feel like I'm part of both of those departments as well.

32:44So just applaud this important move.

32:46I am always a resource to you.

32:48You know, you're my hometown, and I am cheering for this progress.

32:51And thanks for the opportunity to comment on it.

32:53Thank you.

Mariela Ruiz-Angel 32:58 - 36:38

32:58Good afternoon, New York.

33:00Again, Amy, I'm always happy to be in your space.

33:03So my name is Mariala Ruiz-Angel, and I serve as the Director of Community Safety Initiatives at the Center for Innovation and Community Safety at Georgetown, also known as CICS, the longest title ever.

33:17I am the founding director for Albuquerque Community Safety Department, And it is one of the nation's first cabinet-level departments that is dedicated to community crisis response, CBI work, and street outreach.

33:32And so just like Amy, we are here in New York.

33:36And the funny part about the conversation that we're having today is that it— and particularly how momentous, momentous this, like, situation is, is that this is actually this is about the community safety ecosystem.

33:52And so, um, Amy and many other cities, as a guilty plug, we just published a report literally on the ecosystem that we are building here because that's what this is actually leading to.

34:06This is the phase 2 of the work.

34:09So, um, Councilmember Herbold.

34:12I want to emphasize that you're also considering today is much more than the organizational change.

34:18It's a decision about how Portland defines public safety and whether the programs and people doing this critical work have the leadership, resources, and infrastructure they need to succeed.

34:28When we established ACS, we weren't simply trying to create another program.

34:34We were trying to fundamentally change how our city approached public creating a standalone department gave us dedicated leadership, operational infrastructure, accountability, and perhaps most importantly, a seat at the table where public safety decisions were being made, similar to how Amy just talked about how all the chiefs are involved.

34:55We also just passed legislation just in November to also start having our community safety director now be a chief.

35:03Thank you.

35:03Chief.

35:03So she will now be voted in with City Council, just like our other public safety departments.

35:12Additionally, we have— ACS has also just passed— we have a public safety tax, and it went to voters to redistribute how that tax is now being used.

35:25So they will now get 8% of that public safety that is real sustainability.

35:33And I think that this is where Portland is headed, right?

35:36And so it matters.

35:37It matters about how we actually look at these bureaus and these departments.

35:43I won't go too much into the works.

35:45I think you've, you've already heard a lot about what's working really well in Portland.

35:49But I will say that this is now, right, the work that we're doing at Georgetown and other locations around the city is now the work that we're doing the nation is, is really about the jurisdictions across the country that are building and strengthening these similar approaches.

36:03So I think the biggest and clearest lessons that we've learned is that creating programming is just the beginning.

36:09We've got to build the institutions that allow those programs to succeed and endure what matters.

36:17Community safety is not an alternative anymore, guys.

36:19It is public safety.

36:20Thank you.

36:22So I appreciate it.

36:24I am also here.

36:25I am— this is near and dear to my heart.

36:27We are stronger together.

36:29I'm so happy to see Portland moving forward in this way, and I really encourage the vote, and I am here also as a resource as you need it.

36:38Thank you.

Sameer Kanal 36:40 - 36:45

36:40Thank you to all 3 of our testifiers.

36:42It's really great to have you here, and that concludes the presentation.

Angelita Morillo 36:47 - 37:32

36:47Thank you so much, Councilor Kanal, and to all the folks who came to testify and share your expertise with us.

36:53We have 10 minutes now for some technical questions in case folks have any questions for Councilor Kanal or some of the panelists that were here.

37:01And then we will move into public testimony.

37:05So I will— I've been advised that you must always wait an uncomfortable 8 seconds to see if people So I'm going to do that.

37:24All right, nobody's got any questions because it was so clear and well done.

37:27Thank you, everybody.

37:29Um, could we please call up, uh, the public testimony now?

Keelan McClymont 37:35 - 37:43

37:35Thank you.

37:35Yes, we have 4 people signed up, and, uh, Susan Weedall, Weedall, are you— please come up.

Susan Weedall 37:52 - 39:02

37:52Good morning, councilors.

37:54I'm Susan Weedall, a D2 resident and a volunteer with the Alliance for a Safe Oregon.

38:00I'm strongly in favor of the city establishing a permanent Community Safety Bureau.

38:06I've met members of local gun violence prevention groups who are on the front lines dealing with the pain and loss from firearm deaths and injuries that occur in this city on an almost daily basis.

38:18Our city should be aiming for zero firearm deaths and not just celebrating when firearm deaths drop to pre-pandemic levels.

38:26I regularly follow the Community and Public Safety Committee meetings, and I no longer want to experience anxiety each budget season it is time to follow the examples of cities like Baltimore and Philadelphia, and I now know Seattle, and create stability that allow our gun violence prevention programs to thrive.

38:52Having these offices be at the bureau level will make them more accessible and responsive to community members who are concerned about gun tragedies and are unsure of where to turn.

Angelita Morillo 39:02 - 39:04

39:02Councilmember Sawant.

39:03Thank you so much for your time.

Keelan McClymont 39:10 - 39:14

39:10Troy Ramsey is joining us online.

39:13Troy, you can unmute and begin.

Troy Ramsey 39:16 - 41:40

39:16Yes, uh, good morning, uh, City Council members.

39:20Uh, thank you for the opportunity to speak today.

39:22My name is Troy Ramsey with Free Now 21.

39:26I'm here to express my strong support for evaluating— elevating the Office of Violence Prevention, Ceasefire, and Portland Street Response to the bureau status within— excuse me, sorry about that— within the City of Portland.

39:40I believe this is an important step towards creating a safer, stronger, and more responsive city for everyone.

39:47First, we need to— we need funding stability.

39:50Violence prevention and community safety cannot be effective if these programs are consistently fighting for funding.

39:56Year after year, the work requires consistency, long-term investment, and the ability to build meaningful relationships within the communities being served.

40:06Establishing these offices as a bureau provides a stronger foundation to sustain that work.

40:12Second, we need to recognize that public safety is bigger than enforcement alone.

40:19Police and fire services are essential, but are also.

40:23But so are violence prevention, intervention, outreach, and alternative emergency response.

40:28These services deserve the same level of recognition, investment, leadership.

40:33Elevating them to bureau status sends a clear message that Portland values a comprehensive approach to public safety.

40:42Third, we need accountability and accessibility.

40:45Having dedicated bureau leadership creates a stronger connection between city government and the people who depend on these services.

40:54It provides a clearer path for community members to be heard, access resources, receive meaningful support.

41:01It also creates opportunities to reduce duplicate administrative work and use tax dollars more efficiently.

41:09At the end of the day, we cannot simply respond to violence after the damage has been done.

41:14We must invest in prevention.

41:16Thank you.

41:16Strengthen our communities, and create pathways for people to get help— get the help and support they need before crisis happens.

41:25Community safety is not about responding to emergencies.

41:29It's about preventing them.

41:31I urge City Council to support this transition and recognize these offices as the essential services they are.

41:38Thank you for your time and consideration.

41:40Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 41:45 - 41:49

41:45Juma Whatley is also joining us online.

41:48Juma, you can go ahead and unmute and begin.

Juma Whatley 41:58 - 44:49

41:58Uh, trying to get my— oh, there it is.

42:00Uh, thank you for having me today.

42:02Uh, Chair Novick and members of the Community and Public Safety Committee, my name is Juma Whatley.

42:07And I'm the new director of Metro Violence Prevention at the Alliance for a Safe Oregon.

42:13I'm here today to express our support in establishing a community, community safety bureau that brings together the Office of Violence Prevention, Portland Ceasefire, and the Portland Street Response.

42:26My experience also includes serving as chair of THICCOC, where I worked alongside community members and leaders committed to developing solutions to gun violence.

42:35Thank you, Deputy City Attorney Nancy Thorington.

42:37That experience reinforced something I believe deeply: the people closest to the problem must have a meaningful role in shaping the solutions.

42:46Community members, particularly those who have experienced violence firsthand, bring knowledge and expertise that government cannot replicate on its own.

42:56Creating a Community Safety Bureau is an opportunity to recognize that public safety is about more than responding after something terrible has happened.

43:07It is also about preventing violence before it occurs, intervening when people are at risk, and providing compassionate responses when someone is experiencing a crisis.

43:18The Office of Violence Prevention, Ceasefire, and Portland Street Response each play an essential role in that broader vision of safety.

43:27These programs have different responsibilities.

43:29Yes.

43:30But they share an important purpose: keeping people safe while treating them with dignity and recognizing the needs of our communities.

43:38Bringing these programs together under one bureau can strengthen— can strengthen— I totally apologize— coordination, elevate these— their work, and establish community-based safety As essential parts of Portland public safety systems.

44:02As you move forward, I encourage the council to keep several priorities at the center of this work.

44:08First, provide stable and sustained funding.

44:12Community-based violence prevention cannot operate effectively through short-term investments and uncertainty from one budget cycle to the next.

44:22Second, preserve and strengthen meaningful community partnerships.

44:27Much of this work is carried out by trusted community organizations and individuals who have spent years building relationships with people most affected by violence.

44:38Third, ensure that people with lived experience have meaningful voices in the Bureau.

44:44Finally, establish clear goals and accountability.

44:46Thank you, Councilor Loretta Smith.

44:49Thank you for your time.

Keelan McClymont 44:54 - 44:55

44:54Kaia Sand is joining us online.

Kaia Sand 44:58 - 45:34

44:58Good morning, councilors.

44:59I'm Kaia Sand, District 3, and as co-chair of the Portland Street Response Advisory Committee, I talked to you last meeting presenting our recommendations, and I'm so pleased to see 3 of them in this ordinance.

45:13Our committee committed numerous hours to researching and discussing the importance of creating this bureau to stabilize these very important programs.

45:25So I, in the interest of saving time so you can bring this to a vote and Councilor Novick can catch his flight, I'll cede the rest of my time.

Angelita Morillo 45:38 - 45:57

45:38Thank you, Kaia.

45:38Appreciate you.

45:39Thank you to everyone who came and testified today.

45:42Really appreciate you showing up.

45:43Thank you, Councilor Novick, for such an important item.

45:46Now we are moving on to committee discussion.

45:49And Councilor Novick, it's 10:11 right now our time.

45:54How many minutes do you have, just so we are aware and keeping with pacing?

Steve Novick 45:58 - 46:01

45:58I have basically until 11.

Angelita Morillo 46:02 - 46:21

46:02Until 11.

46:03Okay, great.

46:04You heard the man.

46:05So let's move into discussion.

46:07Are there any questions, thoughts, Questions, concerns, praise?

46:19Chair Novick.

Steve Novick 46:21 - 46:28

46:21Praise.

46:22Looks good.

46:28Should pass.

Angelita Morillo 46:30 - 46:59

46:30Looks good.

46:30Should pass.

46:31Okay.

46:31I mean, we love an efficient government moment.

46:34We don't have to belabor the point.

46:36I will say I'm really excited about this.

46:38I think this is really wonderful.

46:40I really appreciate that we as the Community and Public Safety Committee are looking at a more holistic public safety system.

46:47So to be frank, I don't have a lot of questions, colleagues.

46:51I think this is the right direction for the City of Portland to go in, and I feel ready to vote if other people do.

46:56But Councilor Kanal, I see you are off mute as well.

Sameer Kanal 47:00 - 47:03

47:00I was just ready if someone asked a question.

47:02I obviously don't have any for myself.

Angelita Morillo 47:07 - 47:17

47:07All right.

47:08Dang, is this the most efficient discussion we've ever had?

47:11This is great.

47:14Should we— if anyone wants to move it to a vote, go for it.

Steve Novick 47:19 - 47:19

47:19So moved.

Angelita Morillo 47:21 - 47:29

47:21I'll second.

47:23Okay.

47:24Councilor Novick moves.

47:25Councilor Kanal seconds.

47:28Clerk, would you please call the roll?

Keelan McClymont 47:32 - 47:39

47:32Zimmerman, absent.

47:34Smith, absent.

47:38Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 47:40 - 47:40

47:40Aye.

Keelan McClymont 47:41 - 47:42

47:41Morillo.

Angelita Morillo 47:43 - 47:43

47:43Aye.

Keelan McClymont 47:44 - 47:44

47:44Novick.

Steve Novick 47:47 - 47:47

47:47Aye.

Keelan McClymont 47:48 - 47:56

47:48The motion to refer the ordinance 2026-417 to City Council with the recommendation it be passed is approved.

Angelita Morillo 47:58 - 48:23

47:58Woo!

47:59We did it, everyone.

48:00Um, good time.

48:02Okay, well, thank you, everyone.

48:03That concludes our agenda for today.

48:05That was way more efficient than, uh, we thought could ever be possible in the City Council.

48:10So maybe the media will pick up on that.

48:13Uh, and I hope everyone feels better from all their various traveling and illnesses and has a wonderful rest of the day.

48:19And we will gavel out at 10:13.

48:22Big gavel moment.

Sameer Kanal 48:24 - 48:25

48:24That's why I said—.