windowbox

City Council · morning

Official agenda

Transcript

Transcript

Automatically generated transcript. It may contain errors and includes testimony in languages other than English that is not individually marked up for assistive technology.

Jamie Dunphy 5:35 - 5:40

5:359:31 On Wednesday, November 4th.

5:39Keelan, can you please call the roll?

Keelan McClymont 5:41 - 5:42

5:41Yep.

5:41Good morning.

5:41Clark?

Olivia Clark 5:43 - 5:43

5:43Here.

Keelan McClymont 5:44 - 5:44

5:44Green?

Mitch Green 5:45 - 5:45

5:45Here.

Keelan McClymont 5:46 - 5:49

5:46Zimmerman?

5:49Avalos?

Candace Avalos 5:49 - 5:50

5:49Present.

Keelan McClymont 5:52 - 5:52

5:52Smith?

Loretta Smith 5:52 - 5:53

5:52Here.

Keelan McClymont 5:54 - 5:54

5:54Kanal?

Sameer Kanal 6:00 - 6:00

6:00Here.

Keelan McClymont 6:01 - 6:02

6:01Ryan.

Dan Ryan 6:02 - 6:03

6:02Here.

Keelan McClymont 6:05 - 6:07

6:05Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 6:08 - 6:08

6:08Here.

Keelan McClymont 6:09 - 6:09

6:09Here.

Sameer Kanal 6:10 - 6:11

6:10On cloud nine.

Jamie Dunphy 6:14 - 6:19

6:14I'm here.

6:16And can we please have our attorney read the rules of decorum?

Keelan McClymont 6:21 - 7:18

6:21Good morning.

6:22Welcome to the Portland City Council.

6:24To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

6:34Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

6:39Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

6:43Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

6:46The presiding officer preserves order.

6:48Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony, When your time is up, or interrupting other testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

6:58If you cause disruption, a warning will be given.

7:00Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

7:04Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

7:06When testifying, state your name for the record.

7:08Your address is not necessary.

7:10If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

7:14Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

Millicent Williams 7:18 - 7:18

7:18Thank you.

Raymond C. Lee 7:18 - 7:18

7:18Thank you, Council Clerk Keelan McClymont.

Jamie Dunphy 7:19 - 7:37

7:19Thank you very much, colleagues.

7:21Our first item, as with every agenda, is approval of today's agenda.

7:24May I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

7:29Seeing a lot of happy nodding faces and some thumbs up.

7:32I see no objections, and the agenda is approved.

7:35Thank you.

7:36Keelan, can we please move to public communications?

Keelan McClymont 7:40 - 7:43

7:40First up today— am I muted?

Jamie Dunphy 7:43 - 7:44

7:43Nope, we can hear you.

Keelan McClymont 7:46 - 7:48

7:46First up today, we have Hao Pham.

Jamie Dunphy 7:56 - 7:58

7:56Welcome, Hao.

7:57You are here.

Keelan McClymont 8:02 - 8:14

8:02Hao, are you— you're muted.

8:04Are you able to unmute?

8:08Dennis, could you ask our public communications to unmute?

Unidentified speaker 8:16 - 8:35

8:16Hao Phạm, Hao Phạm, anh mở cái microphone.

8:20Anh Hao Phạm mời mời mời anh mở microphone để nói chuyện.

8:33Nhờ anh nhấn vào cái microphone.

Keelan McClymont 8:36 - 8:37

8:36Ah, there we go.

Hao Pham 8:39 - 8:39

8:39Nghe chưa ạ anh?

Unidentified speaker 8:41 - 8:47

8:41Nghe rồi, dạ, dạ nghe rồi.

8:47Yeah.

Keelan McClymont 8:48 - 8:53

8:48Go ahead whenever you're ready.

Unidentified speaker 8:53 - 8:57

8:53Khi nào khi nào anh sẵn sàng thì anh cứ bắt đầu nói ha.

8:56Yeah.

Hao Pham 8:57 - 12:17

8:57Xin xin chào tất cả các quý vị điều hành thành phố.

9:03Ở đây tôi tôi có biết được cao sơ lơ Ryan.

9:08Là tôi có đến đến cao sầu meeting năm hai nghìn hai mươi ba thì bây giờ tôi muốn phản ảnh cái sự việc là cái cái khu vực của tôi ở là sau East Morrison và một trăm hai mươi hai tôi đã chịu đựng cái vấn đề homeless là nếu mà tới tháng sau nữa là mà mười năm rưỡi, mười năm rưỡi thì khi mà tôi dự họp năm hai nghìn lẻ hai mươi ba đó thì tới chu tới ngày lễ độc lập của năm hai nghìn lẻ hai mươi bốn là cái cái cái tôi bị những cái người hong lé tới người ta xâm nhập vào cái nhà kế bên người ta và người ta đốt cháy cái hàng rào nhà tôi.

9:58Anh ơi anh có thể ngừng để mà tôi dịch không bây giờ anh anh ghi xuống dầm đi tại vì anh được được anh cứ tiếp tục rồi tới tới tới tháng tới ngày bảy tháng tới ngét ngày mười tháng bảy năm hai nghìn hai mươi lăm á thì cái nhà kế bên tôi cũng bị đốt hàng rào cái nhà đó là có bốn bốn bốn trẻ em dưới dưới mười mười bốn tuổi Háng mười một năm hai nghìn lẻ hai mươi lăm, tôi gửi thơ đi khắp nơi.

10:30Có đến văn phòng của cao cao sơ đơn phi, có trả lời tôi.

10:37Nhưng mà cuối cùng thì cũng nói là tôi phải đi vào dự cái meeting này thôi.

10:43Thì cái mười năm chịu đựng của tôi á là bị bị hàng rào bị đốt, bị bị cướp đồ.

10:51Khi mà người ta giao hàng bị đập kiến xe mười hai tháng thì có ít nhất là mười tháng là hôm lét cắm trại xung quanh gần nhà rồi khi mà tôi báo cáo sự việc lên thành phố thì thành phố nói với tôi là thành phố không có một cái giải pháp nào hết về cái về cái vấn đề này họ chỉ đến dọn dẹp thôi không cho nó phát triển thôi thì tôi có đề nghị là đặt những cái tảng đá hàng rào rồi này kia để ngăn chặn tại vì cứ một người đến là sẽ có rất nhiều người đến liên tục liên tục và hiện bây giờ là người ta đang cấm chạy ở ở gần nhà tôi cách có mấy trăm feet thôi mà một tháng nay chưa dẹp xong chưa dẹp được cứ cứ dẹp xong là quay lại dẹp xong là quay lại không được một ngày nữa giờ tôi hát Good morning council city council I I'm very happy to have this opportunity to testify in front of the city council Back in 2023, I had the opportunity to talk with the councilor by the name Ryan.

Unidentified speaker 12:19 - 15:07

12:19And my residence is at Southeast Morrison, on the intersection between Southeast Morrison and Southeast 122nd.

12:30And I have been homeless for the last 10 years.

12:36Back in 2023 and '24, there was a number of incidents with the homeless people, you know, surrounding my area.

12:51And then I've been complaining to the city council so many times, but then the reply that I got back from the people that I reported was that I supposed to be testified in front of a city council like this to be noticed of my complaint?

13:12Back in 2020, back in July 10th, 2020, there were a few incidents of— my residence was surrounded by the homelessness, and then I've been putting up fences to protect myself, but then the fences didn't do any good.

13:35And there was some incident that there was a fire in the area, and then that incident of fire endangered 4 children.

13:47And then back in November of 2025, I talked with Officer Dong Phi.

13:55Councilor And then I'm, you know, I couldn't— I've been talking with the different council, and then I couldn't resolve this incident of looting and breaking fences and breaking glasses.

14:15And then my situation hasn't improved.

14:20And then there was some people from the city, they come by to clean up the area.

14:27They said that they want to clean up the area to make sure that the homeless people won't come back again.

14:32But then as soon as they clean up the area, the next day the people would come back again.

14:40And then my complaint was answered that their job was just to clean up the area, but they cannot do anything to prevent the situation.

14:51So I'm very happy for this opportunity to be testifying in front of the City Council to express my givenness, and hopefully you can resolve the situation to improve the situation.

15:06Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 15:07 - 15:09

15:07Thank you very much for coming and sharing your testimony.

Keelan McClymont 15:12 - 15:15

15:12Next, next up we have Diana Stewart.

Jamie Dunphy 15:18 - 15:23

15:18Welcome, Diana.

15:19Please introduce yourself for the record.

15:20You're welcome to share your pronouns, and you have 3 minutes.

Diana STUART 15:24 - 18:15

15:24Good morning.

15:27Good morning, Council.

15:28My name is Diana Stewart, speaking on behalf of the Downtown Neighborhood Association.

15:33As soon as the week of November 16th, the administration is expected to choose a manager for the P5 venues with apparently no public input and no chance of public comment.

15:43Chance for council to review or advise.

15:46This matters.

15:47The P5 venues carry a $336 million capital maintenance deficit and an annual $5 million operating deficit, and these 5 art venues are key to bringing vitality back to the downtown.

16:02It is reported that of the original 8 FRIs, only 2 RFP proposals were submitted, but the city is apparently withholding them until one is chosen, with no chance to analyze them.

16:15As Councilor Clark has said 2 choices appear to be very limiting.

16:19One reason for so few submittals may be uncertainty over whether the highly profitable Broadway Across America series will stay at the Keller supporting the P5.

16:30The order of decision-making creates that uncertainty.

16:34Picking the venue manager in mid-November but council not deciding until December whether or not to fund a new PSU venue that would take BAA away from the P5 creates that uncertainty.

16:47Would more more bidders have applied.

16:48If Broadway's place at the Keller were secure, why not reverse the order of decisions after council's December decision?

16:56If BAA stays at the Keller, the city could reopen the RFPs for more options.

17:01There would be time for council and the public to see the proposals and testify rather than continuing this closed process.

17:08It is reported that one of the proposals is from the Portland Cultural Trust, an entity that Broadway Across America has created, partnering with the PSU Foundation and the Oregon.

17:19Symphony.

17:20It is also reported that BAA has made promises to other arts entities in exchange for their support.

17:27Concerns have been raised about conflicts of interest given the secrecy around the RFPs.

17:33Broadway is Portland's largest source of arts venue.

17:36Imagine BAA as both the manager and the largest act negotiating with itself over dates, rents, and fees.

17:46And if PSU manages the Keller while a new PSU venue is, is still possible, is there a distinction to a disincentive to boost the Keller's profitability or reduce capital maintenance if that venue is built?

18:03Both the PSU Foundation and BAA have conflicting loyalties.

18:07So the DNA asks the council to press for 3 things.

18:11One, ask Mr. Lee to release and present the proposals publicly to council.

Loretta Smith 18:15 - 18:17

18:152, Ask Mr.

Diana STUART 18:17 - 18:33

18:17Lee to delay the manager decision until council decides on the PSU venue concept.

18:24And 3, request a written conflict review from the city attorney, including whether any quid pro quo for support violates the law.

18:32Thank you very much.

Jamie Dunphy 18:34 - 18:53

18:34Thank you very much for being here today.

18:51Keelan, you're muted if you were.

Keelan McClymont 18:54 - 18:58

18:54Yep, I am.

18:55Thank you.

18:55Uh, next up we have Galib Bin Imhotep.

Jamie Dunphy 19:01 - 19:01

19:01Good morning.

Galib Bin Imhotep El 19:02 - 19:03

19:02Good morning.

19:02Can you hear me?

Jamie Dunphy 19:03 - 19:04

19:03We can, yes.

19:04Please go ahead.

Galib Bin Imhotep El 19:05 - 19:08

19:05Uh, greetings, beloved committee members.

19:07Can you see me?

Jamie Dunphy 19:08 - 19:09

19:08We cannot.

Galib Bin Imhotep El 19:09 - 21:01

19:09Okay, I can't see myself.

19:10I don't know what's a blank screen, but maybe that'll change.

19:15I'm not tech savvy enough.

19:17My apologies for that.

19:18But I am Galib Bin Imhotep El.

19:21My domicile is in District 4, and I speak today on a topic that leaves a bitter taste in my mouth.

19:28That topic, politics.

19:31By my testimony's conclusion, you'll comprehend why that word has such an unattractive stigma in my perception.

19:38First off, I watch sports— football, baseball, and now, thanks to poor Laker personnel decisions and an exciting team to root for, basketball again.

19:49I generally do not watch television for any other reason.

19:52I can't remember the last time I streamed something that wasn't a song or a sport.

19:57With that limited sample window of data, it scares me to think how much more political campaigning is being done.

20:05The issue with this campaigning form of politics—it shows a person who knows what to look for a sad, grim truth.

20:15I have seen commercials of campaign ads for governors where I couldn't tell you anything other than who I shouldn't vote for.

20:26I have seen exactly two of the hundreds of ads give me any confidence.

20:31In the person trying to procure votes.

20:34Thankfully, those 2 ads were from Portland city councilors.

20:38They spoke of themselves, what they stood for, what they've accomplished, and not once spoke of any other candidate.

20:46For that refreshing deviation from a deviant norm, I want to thank you, Councilors Tiffany Koyama Lane and Angelita Morillo.

20:59Thank you very much.

21:00Oh, I'm not, I'm not done.

Dan Ryan 21:01 - 21:01

21:01I'm sorry.

Jamie Dunphy 21:01 - 21:02

21:01Okay, I was gonna say.

Galib Bin Imhotep El 21:02 - 21:07

21:02I'm, I'm navigating through 2 screens right now, and I'm not very good at that on computers.

Jamie Dunphy 21:07 - 21:09

21:07I feel that in my bones.

21:09Please continue.

Galib Bin Imhotep El 21:10 - 22:22

21:10They restarted my clock.

21:11I apologize for that.

21:13Uh, let's— of the remaining mass production of campaigning, allow me to paint the picture that I do see.

21:21It's disastrous.

21:22It's worse than competition.

21:24It's smear.

21:26Councilor Green, I see the poster that they put on downtown.

21:32It's libelous.

21:33It's criminal.

21:34It shouldn't be there.

21:36It's divisive.

21:39It's honestly depressing.

21:41Candidates complain about the problems or deficiencies of their opponents, but say not a single positive thing about their opponents.

21:48Or themselves.

21:50The whole thing is a war of words.

21:52And what is one of the creeds to winning a war?

21:55Divide and conquer.

21:58I see a nation so divided that us against them is a national battle cry for political campaigning.

22:07Well, if the whole nation is divided, then who is this nation's conqueror?

22:14Now it should be understood why the word politics leaves a nasty taste in my mouth.

22:19Thank you, and I love you all unconditionally.

Jamie Dunphy 22:25 - 22:27

22:25Thank you so much for being here, and thanks for putting up with our tech challenges.

Galib Bin Imhotep El 22:29 - 22:30

22:29Oh, it was my fault.

Jamie Dunphy 22:30 - 22:34

22:30No, it's all of our faults.

22:34Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 22:36 - 22:44

22:36Uh, next up we have Eyla V. Next we have Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk.

Unidentified speaker 22:47 - 22:48

22:47Welcome.

Lisa Jackson Spottedelk 22:51 - 22:51

22:51Can you hear me?

Jamie Dunphy 22:52 - 22:53

22:52Yes, we can hear you.

Lisa Jackson Spottedelk 22:53 - 26:02

22:53I just want to make sure I'm not having no technical difficulties.

22:58Um, I just wanted to start out by saying hi.

23:11So I introduced myself in my language because we're honoring Native American Heritage Month.

23:16I had to be on your panel because I just need to remind you again, we're still here.

23:22Um, hearing some of the people just talk just now, you know, um, I've been in circles with this, this whole government system in the state of Oregon.

23:33You know, now visiting with the Tribal Affairs Office to start a coalition to help you guys learn how to govern with Native people because I feel like— I don't even know where to start.

23:47I went to the first Democratic Party last night and I've seen a few councilors there and I think about how you all operate, right?

23:57Yeah.

23:58I think about how this whole system is run, and I always say this, it's pretty awesome that the city governs itself, you know, and how they operate.

24:10But what I just can't come to find out is how you all don't advocate for even like indigenous people as a whole, right?

24:21Your policies are built around Thank you.

24:25I'm here to speak on behalf of the immigrants, communities.

24:27Mind you, being a native of this land, might as well call me an immigrant, right?

24:30Because our rights are violated tremendously by this city.

24:36I don't know if anyone has went to those buildings that I talk about, hearing this elder guy talk in a different language, not even being able to understand, but being homeless of this land.

24:48Some of these people didn't ask to be here.

24:50You know what I mean?

24:51Some of these people, they're just here.

24:54But, you know, a native of this land and honoring Native American Heritage Month is some fucking bullshit at this point.

25:06And I say that with my chest because that's like giving me my water bottle back over empty, right?

25:15I visited with Pirtle Gunny, and, you know, that was alarming.

25:20Because there was like what, no natives there but me.

25:26In the native community, that should show colors on how let down this community is, right?

25:35But since we're honoring Native American Heritage Month, take into consideration on how to collaborate more with native actual native people of the land.

25:47To help you guys better your, um, your policy, because your team can be winning with people at your table.

25:56So thank y'all.

25:58Y'all have a beautiful day and stay blessed.

Jamie Dunphy 26:03 - 26:04

26:03Thank you very much for being here today.

Keelan McClymont 26:06 - 26:08

26:06That completes communications, Council President.

Jamie Dunphy 26:09 - 28:41

26:09Thank you very much, colleagues.

26:11Next on our agenda is, uh, the the section we've sort of generally referred to as the presidential update.

26:17I am at the— I'm going to be reading a proclamation declaring November as Native American Heritage Month.

26:24So, whereas the City of Portland recognizes that Native American peoples have inhabited the lands now known as the Americas since time immemorial, and whereas the City of Portland is situated at the confluence of the Willamette and Columbia Rivers within a region with a rich history of Native American villages, trade routes, and enduring cultural relationships to the land and waters, that long predate European and American settlement and continue to this day.

26:49And whereas Native American peoples continue to advocate for their communities, cultures, and ways of life, as well as the protection and well-being of the lands and waters that have sustained their peoples, cultures, and traditions since time immemorial and across generations.

27:04And whereas the City of Portland is committed to integrating Native American knowledge and perspectives into city practices and policies to address institutional racism and the enduring impacts of policies and actions that have contributed to And whereas the City of Portland's Tribal Government Relations Program supports and facilitates meaningful consultation with Native American tribes, strengthening government-to-government relationships and promoting greater understanding of the cultures, histories, and enduring relationships to land of tribal nations in this region.

27:41And whereas Native American Heritage Month 2026 provides an opportunity for the City of Portland to recognize and honor the history, culture, and values of Native Americans.

27:47Thank you, Councilor Smith.

27:49Cultures, contributions, and contemporary presence of the Native American peoples, reaffirm its commitment to meaningful government-to-government relationships with Native American tribal nations, elevate Native American voices and perspectives through city policies, practices, advocacy, and investments, and foster meaningful collaboration with Native American communities on city initiatives.

28:12Now, therefore, I, Keith Wilson, Mayor of the City of Portland of Oregon, do hereby declare this ordinance passed.

28:15Thank you.

28:15Portland, Oregon, the City of Roses, do hereby proclaim November 2026 as Native American Heritage Month and encourage all residents, businesses, and community members to join in support and celebration of their incredible contributions.

28:29Thank you very much.

28:32We are now moving to our City Administrator report.

28:36City Administrator Lee, I'm actually— Keelan, can we call item number 4?

Keelan McClymont 28:42 - 28:45

28:42Yes, thank you.

28:42Document number 2026-392, November 2026.

Jamie Dunphy 28:48 - 28:51

28:48Thank you very much.

28:50Mr. City Administrator, I'm turning it over to you.

Raymond C. Lee 28:52 - 32:12

28:52Good morning, councilors.

28:53Hopefully everyone can hear me clearly, um, virtually.

28:57All right, happy to share my monthly report, uh, to council for the month of November.

29:03As you know, last month I shared updates to the city's organizational structure.

29:08The updates are designed to provide greater stability, strengthen accountability, and create cleaner roles and responsibilities across the organization.

29:18The report you have today reflects that new organizational structure.

29:22I want to provide a few highlights from the report.

29:27The Civic Life team launched Around the Neighborhoods, a new monthly newsletter to keep neighborhood leaders up to date on city news, community resources, neighborhood stories, and opportunities to get involved.

29:41In news related to immigrant affairs, employee trainings on protocols for interacting with immigration enforcement agents will be launching in the coming weeks.

29:51I also want to share and let you be sure to check out the Creative Storefront Initiative this winter.

29:57This is a partnership between the Office of Arts and Culture and Night Lab that will transform vacant retail spaces into opportunities for vibrant public art installations, and you will see some of this right across the street of City Hall on the 5th Yes.

30:14On the 1st Avenue side, you could see the lights and the show.

30:17Great thing to see in the evenings.

30:20And Portland Fire and Rescue recruiting team attended a Women in the Trade Symposium to introduce the career of firefighting and build awareness ahead of an open application period early next year.

30:35There were also a few questions from last month's report that I wanted to circle back on.

30:41We have been in touch with councilors regarding other specific inquiries, but I wanted to I would like to highlight several of them here today.

30:49There is a new appendix this month, Appendix G, which is solicitations reports that shows the city's open and closed solicitations from the past month.

31:01There was also a question as to when the work related to the mayor's executive order is coming to council.

31:07We expect to bring an update to council in the first few months of 2027, and we look forward to the conversations continuing around this topic.

31:17Thank you.

31:19You'll see that we added some more information and context around a few of the budget notes, specifically notes that have come up in these meetings.

31:29You'll see updates in Appendix A and throughout the report.

31:33We're happy to answer more questions regarding that as well.

31:39For the formatting of Appendix D through G, please note that these are the first few pages of what is a larger list Thank you.

31:47Thank you, Councilor Smith.

31:48The full report is accessible via the web pages linked on the reports themselves.

31:52The procurement disparity study summary is expected to be in next month's report also.

31:58If you need any additional information on that, please let me know beforehand.

32:02And I just want to thank you again for the team doing the great work across the city and pulling these things together.

32:08My leadership team and myself are here to answer any questions that council may have.

Jamie Dunphy 32:14 - 32:25

32:14Thank you very much, City Administrator.

32:17Colleagues, feel free to jump into the queue if you have any questions for the City Administrator about this, and I'll call on folks as I can.

32:24Councilor Kanal kicks us off.

Sameer Kanal 32:26 - 33:01

32:26Thank you, Council President.

32:28Thank you, DCA Lee, and I guess acting for a little bit, DCA Lee.

32:33I was going to start with the public safety stuff, but I'll actually just kind of go chronologically.

32:38I appreciate the information about the org chart, but I'm a little unclear from looking at the actual, the full chart, how we're currently viewing Portland Solutions, the way that it's listed equivalent to everything else in Strategic Enterprise Services area, does it— does that imply that we are now looking at Portland Solutions as a bureau or office within the service area?

Raymond C. Lee 33:02 - 33:23

33:02No, Portland Solutions will remain a program within the CA's office, which it has been.

33:08What you see now with the new DCA over Strategic Enterprises, it's just pulling those portfolio of offices, bureaus, and chiefs from me in creating a new area.

33:20It is not a new office or bureau.

33:22It is a program.

Sameer Kanal 33:24 - 34:09

33:24Okay.

33:25All right.

33:27I appreciate you highlighting the immigrant affairs work, in particular the work of our immigrant affairs lead.

33:33We talked about this in Committee of the Whole, so I won't talk about it too much.

33:37I wanted to ask about— you highlight a panel that BTS Director Rosenberg was on about AI.

33:48And I guess the first question, I have a few on this, is I'm very curious what exactly was presented in terms of, quote, the city's, end quote, forward-thinking approach to AI.

33:59And I'm just curious if we can get video of that presentation.

34:03I'm curious what's being stated as sort of in my name here, or in our name.

Raymond C. Lee 34:10 - 34:21

34:10What I can do, Councilor, we can prepare some information to get out to Council, to the full body of what all that entailed.

34:17And we'll try to get that out, if not by the week's end, first part of next week.

Sameer Kanal 34:22 - 35:31

34:22Thanks.

34:23I have—.

34:26I guess I'm going to kind of continue on this question for a second.

34:31In the awards report, I have 2 questions about it.

34:35One of them is that there's a $306,000 item called, quote, new co-op contract PPB and MCSO, end quote, with a company called Tech5 USA Incorporated, which brands itself as, quote, innovative AI solutions for identity Mm-hmm.

34:52And sells biometric products and something called Global AI Face Capture.

34:56Mm-hmm.

34:58Can we— I'm curious if that aligns with what's being described as a forward-thinking approach to AI, and also if this is something that's going to be decided upon.

35:10I mean, it sounds like it already has been decided upon before the full standing up of the Data Privacy Office.

35:20And I mean, in general, that's a pretty alarming thing.

35:22We do have a ban on facial recognition in the city.

35:25So I'm just curious if you can speak a little bit more to what that contract is and what it is going to be allowed to do.

Raymond C. Lee 35:32 - 36:13

35:32Councilor, I would have to research that actual contract to see what services we're actually receiving from them.

35:40What I'll do in the process of giving you and the rest of the council an update on kind of the work that you've already requested, I'll include that into it as well to give a full scope synopsis of that, because I know we're going through a, a conversation as it relates to, uh, Council President Dunphy, uh, moratorium stop on AI uses.

36:00So this is currently conversations that we're having right now, uh, with all bureaus to kind of get a better understanding of what these different services are.

36:09I just don't have that one at the top of my mind, but we will most definitely follow up on it.

Sameer Kanal 36:13 - 38:00

36:13Okay, well then I'll just— I see others in the queue.

36:16I'm going to ask one more because it's related, and then I'll come back in the queue for other things, Council President.

36:20On October 28th, there was an article in Street Roots entitled, quote, Portland Police Are Banned from Using AI.

36:27They Plan to Use It Anyway, end quote.

36:30It shows that in August, the administration, specifically including BTS again, determined, quote, Copilot at police is feasible, end quote, without council consultation or input or even a briefing.

36:45The article says that Copilot is marketed to law enforcement as providing steps for arrest, prepare it— that you can use it to prepare investigation briefs and automatically summarize witness testimony.

36:55Those are 3 distinct quotes from the article.

36:58And I'm trying to understand, these 3 things are related, right?

37:03There's how we're looking at AI as an inevitably good thing in how we're branding it.

37:10There's the fact that we are— we have rules that are clearly not being followed because, CA Lee, you yourself told us that this would not be used for police in a previous one of these monthly reports.

37:21To council earlier this year.

37:23And then there's the— I don't even know what the Tech 5 contract or award is, but that's deeply alarming to see that out here.

37:35So I would really like us to, at a minimum, while council is having the conversation, for you to use your administrative authority to just put a pause on everything.

37:46And let us actually have a conversation about whether or not we want to create the movie Minority Report.

37:57Is that something that we can— is that something that you're able to do?

Raymond C. Lee 38:01 - 38:38

38:01I won't say that I can put just a monitoring stop on it right now.

38:05I'm still reviewing what's in the pipeline and understanding what contracts we have going right now.

38:13But what I will promise council is that I will set up some time to make sure that we have the time to go through all of this information.

38:22There's a tremendous amount of work associated with these contracts, and I need to be able to understand the impacts and implications to anything that we already have in progress.

38:32What does it mean to stop it?

38:35So before I can say that, I at least want to do that full review first, Councilor.

Sameer Kanal 38:39 - 38:58

38:39I understand.

38:40What I'm, what I'm trying to avoid is every month we find out the things that happened in the previous I understand, Councilor.

Raymond C. Lee 38:58 - 39:02

38:58Let me look into it and I'll follow up with, with the full council on it.

Sameer Kanal 39:02 - 39:04

39:02Thank you.

39:03Thank you, Council President.

Jamie Dunphy 39:04 - 41:07

39:04Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

39:05Colleagues, I put myself in the queue next.

39:07Um, following up on Councilor Kanal's comments with regard to the org chart, uh, City Administrator, thank you for the continued work on that.

39:14Um, I, uh, you know, I'm not a member of the city staff, but I do appreciate the work that you're doing.

39:16I find it exceptionally helpful to have a broad understanding of how the city is structured.

39:21I was—.

39:22But building on what Councilor Khan was saying, I think that there's also still a technological opportunity for us to put this into SAP so that this is actually a live org chart.

39:32That would be exceptionally helpful for the work that I find myself doing to understand who exactly does what and where is their boss.

39:41So if there is an ability to continue work on that and build it into SAP specifically, I would love to see that.

39:48Thank you.

39:48Would be willing to help figure out what is necessary if there's needed extra work to make that happen.

39:54So thank you for the work on that.

39:57With regard to the Vision Zero update, I'm really glad to see that the number of vehicle and bicycle fatalities is down from where we were a few years ago.

40:06But we're looking at 15 motorcyclist fatalities just this year, which is almost— it's double what was last year's, and 40% of all Uh, traffic-based fatalities.

40:18Um, you know, seeing everything else sort of moving in the right direction, but this is ticking up in the other direction, is making me wonder what may have changed.

40:25And I've also heard concerns directly from the motorcycle community that some of the newer street designs, like protected bike lanes, are actually making it hard for motorcyclists to escape scary situations as they're facing cars.

40:39As a former motorcyclist myself and a motorcycle endorsement holder, The first rule with, you know, a bad car accident is you swerve out of the way.

40:47But if we are building concrete tunnels, I'm wondering if there may have been something that has happened.

40:54So my question is to you, is there work being done right now to look at this data spike?

41:00Are the teams at Vision Zero starting to get a sense of why this number in particular is going up this year?

Raymond C. Lee 41:09 - 41:13

41:09If DCA Williams is on this call, I'll ask her to chime in on this question.

Millicent Williams 41:14 - 43:37

41:14Thank you, City Administrator Lee, and thank you for the question, Councilor Dunphy.

41:18As we discussed briefly at our last meeting, thank you for bringing that information forward, especially about your constituent or city constituent who acknowledged that there were potentially some challenges to some of the ways that we're designing streets.

41:35The PBOT team is really thoughtful and intentional about where it I know that Director Cully, who is now PBOT's director, but in her former role was the city traffic engineer, has a great deal of experience in helping to support street design that ensures highest safety opportunities for all users.

42:04So hearing the experiential information about the ways that motorcyclists are experiencing what we are proposing, or what we have installed in the right-of-way, is something that is worth not just noting, but investigating further.

42:27And I know that the team continues to evaluate the best ways for us to be able to be responsive and supportive of community while creating the greatest level of safety for all users.

42:37So you can expect Um, more information.

42:42Uh, I will acknowledge that motorcycle, um, uh, crashes, the trends are spiking, uh, statewide, uh, nationwide, and even globally.

42:56Um, so it's not to suggest that, um, and we're not using that as a scapegoat for not doing something, but it is, um, a phenomenon that we're seeing across a number of topographies, a number of geographies, and certainly parts of the country as people are looking at alternatives for how they move about.

43:17So we will do our work here.

43:20We look forward to continuing to engage in the conversation, both from the PBOT perspective, working in partnership with our colleagues in law enforcement, and certainly supporting our Vision Zero lead, Dana Dickman, as she.

43:34Thank you.

43:36Connects with you all directly.

Jamie Dunphy 43:38 - 44:00

43:38Perfect.

43:38I have a lot of confidence in the team, both at PBOT and Vision Zero, and really appreciate the seriousness of this.

43:46This is a, you know, as I wonder if, you know, not maybe not just our street designs, but also the combination of wet weather and gas prices being as crazy as they are.

43:56Folks are looking for the cheapest way to get to work, and with traffic—.

Millicent Williams 44:00 - 44:23

44:00I didn't want to hypothesize on any of the causes, especially related to traffic.

44:05Totally.

44:06Economy.

44:07But if I were to speak anecdotally, I would potentially suggest that that might be some of the reason.

44:13But from a fact-based, data-based statement, I would not be able to say that.

44:19But I will say that we are committed to making sure that we're creating the safest spaces for all users.

Jamie Dunphy 44:23 - 44:30

44:23Perfect.

44:24Thank you very much.

44:25Thank you both.

44:28That is the end of my questions, colleagues.

44:29I'm going to Councilor Avalos next.

Candace Avalos 44:32 - 45:21

44:32All right, good morning.

44:33Thank you, Administrator Lee, for the updates on these issues.

44:36Definitely good to continue hearing about the progress of the immigrant affairs work, um, and then the opportunities for federal engagement, and of course the full town.

44:45Glad to see that coming together.

44:47Um, I just have a couple of questions about the PGE Harborton reliability project since a city hearings officer just held a hearing a couple weeks ago, and I just want to understand, uh, what the latest is, um, and especially because there's significant public interest in the So are you able, or, or others on the call able to help me understand how the city staff interpreted the Forest Park Natural Resources Management Plan in making their newest recommendation?

45:16And like, what criteria was used to evaluate the new proposal?

45:19Could we get some information on that?

Raymond C. Lee 45:22 - 45:27

45:22I see if DCA Oliveira is on this call as well, see if he could chime in.

Donnie Oliveira 45:29 - 46:16

45:29Yeah, sorry.

45:30Good morning, councilors.

45:32Get the screen set up.

45:33Uh, Councilor Avalos, to your question about next steps first, where the hearings officer made— or they're making the recommendation, we expect to get, uh, that, uh, shortly actually, um, to get that to be published, at which time, um, if there's an appeal, that would go to council for the— for a review of that decision.

45:53As far as the second question about staff's review of the application, it met all the land use laws and our codes, and it also met the expectations that was laid out in the agreement that we had settled over the first application.

46:10So from that perspective, staff's evaluation was that it was good to move forward, and that's what the hearings officer reviewed.

Candace Avalos 46:18 - 46:28

46:18And are you able to share a little bit more about the difference between the proposal that was before us last year and what is coming back to us and why changes were made?

Donnie Oliveira 46:29 - 46:47

46:29Councilor, I'll have to get back to you all on that one to do that kind of crosswalk with what changed, but that's something that we should be able to do.

46:35I also want to acknowledge that I'll look to city attorneys about what we can share, given that you all will be likely taking action on this item later this year.

46:44But more to come on that, and we'll follow up shortly.

Candace Avalos 46:48 - 47:04

46:48Thank you.

46:49Yes, I appreciate this opportunity to ask about this.

46:51As you know, the public has a lot of And I know that we are discussing, uh, when it comes back to council.

46:58So I look forward to hearing more about the PGA Harborton Forest Parkland issue.

47:03So thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 47:06 - 47:09

47:06Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

47:06Expect to hear more soon.

47:09Uh, Councilor Ryan.

Dan Ryan 47:10 - 48:09

47:10Yeah, good morning.

47:11Thank you, Council President, and, uh, good to see you, uh, City Administrator Lee.

47:17Council President, you, you jumped in on my biggest concern on the report that we got from Vision Zero, and I appreciated that dialogue.

47:26I hope there'll be more updates on what our strategies are with that, that rather significant noticeable spike in incidents and deaths to motorcycle riders.

47:41I had this on in there already, and then the testimony earlier made me definitely want to ask a question about it.

47:46The system improvement we're looking for with our performing arts venues was supposed to be a A revamp of P5, and it's a big deal, um, system change development.

48:00And is it true that, uh, what we just heard is that there's only 2 finalists for that, uh, for that very important role?

Raymond C. Lee 48:10 - 48:13

48:10I'll have DC Oliveira chime in on this one.

Dan Ryan 48:14 - 48:15

48:14Okay, thank you.

Donnie Oliveira 48:15 - 48:48

48:15Yeah, thank you, Councilor, uh, Ryan.

48:17Donnie Oliveira, for the record.

48:18Councilor, yeah, there are 2 submittals.

48:21Both were approved, like, as being competitive, and we are in that process.

48:26I just want to reiterate to council that we have very clear procurement rules about why these things aren't transparent, but we have an expert panel that's reviewing both applications that we hope to have a decision on, you know, later this year.

48:40This is an incredibly important decision for the management of the venues, and so I know procurement and arts and culture staff and our external experts are taking that review very seriously.

Dan Ryan 48:50 - 50:16

48:50Okay, thank you.

48:51I think when we had Arts and Economy, I think we were probably more in the know about such things.

48:57And maybe Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, who's the chair of City Life, we could maybe get an update at that meeting.

49:05I would say that it was a little startling to hear all that update and not know basically what was going on.

49:11And perhaps that's because of my previous attachment asking for This about 4 years ago that we looked at this more systemically, why we had the opportunity.

49:20And I think the testimony had some wisdom in saying the order might be off.

49:24I thought that was good to call that out.

49:28The other one that was— I was excited to see there's a neighborhood newsletter.

49:33I, you know, all of us, especially in this new form of government, probably spend more time connecting with our neighborhood associations.

49:39And I would I would like to know more about the distribution list.

49:43So where that's landing.

49:44And just, I want to support the fact that this exists, but I'd like to know more about it and how it's being distributed and if it's being received so we can listen and provide feedback on how that communication device is being received by the neighborhoods.

50:04Does there—.

50:05Do you have any— does it go to every neighborhood association?

50:07Does anyone have any I don't believe so.

50:14And the first one went out in October, I believe?

Raymond C. Lee 50:19 - 50:22

50:19Probably so.

50:19I don't— we have to follow up on the distribution list, Councilor.

Dan Ryan 50:23 - 50:27

50:23Okay.

50:24All right, thanks.

50:24I look forward to knowing more about that.

50:26Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 50:27 - 50:31

50:27Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

50:30Councilor Smith.

Loretta Smith 50:34 - 53:05

50:34Thank you, Council President.

50:35Uh, thank you for the update about Vision Zero, but I want to add a little bit more to give a little more context to that, Diana Dickman sent us preliminary numbers.

50:47Well, while you say some of the— we have reduced our crashes, but from last year, 2025, on the PBOT streets, there were 19 deaths from '11 to 2025 to '11 to 2024.

51:06Yes.

51:06And from 11/2/2025 to 11/2/2026, there have been 28 deaths on PBOT streets, 12 deaths on ODOT streets.

51:19And so we have risen.

51:21And so of those 28 deaths that we've had in this last year, 18 of them were in District 1.

51:29And that is very, very, uh, That's that's concerning because that's three times the deaths in District Four, two times the deaths in District Three, and two times the deaths in District Two.

51:48So District One in our high crash corridors, we are experiencing a lot of death on our streets.

51:58And I'd like to look at this through our Community and Public Safety Committee and identify some of those things that you were talking about.

52:07We need to study this or have some more information because I would like to have some more information about how we do that, not just if the bike lanes are causing some of these deaths.

52:16We have to really study this from a really ground level to see what all of those look like.

52:25And I was not happy to see that report this morning, but I think that all of us, since we voted 12-0 about Vision Zero, we need to zero in on why is District 1 experiencing so many deaths.

52:41And if you look at Dana Dickman's report, I think she emailed it to everyone.

52:46They, they have it if it's versus speed and other issues, but we should actually be talking about this in our community and public safety.

52:54And I'm I'm going to talk to Chair Steve Novick about it because it's very concerning to me.

53:04Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 53:06 - 53:09

53:06Thank you, Councilor Smith.

53:08Councilor Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 53:10 - 55:37

53:10Thank you, Council President, and thank you colleagues who are talking about Vision Zero, and thank you to all the— all my colleagues who care a lot about this.

53:18I appreciate it being in there.

53:19City Administrator Lee, thank you for adding that in.

53:22Monthly, and just want to emphasize how important it is that we are continuing, especially when we're talking about deaths and serious injuries, really coming back to facts and data and making sure that it's rooted in that.

53:36And want to point people to the joint press release between the Portland Bureau of Transportation and the Portland Police Bureau on July 21st, earlier this year, that is about urging awareness and safety after seeing an increase in fatal crashes involving motorcyclists.

53:56A reminder that Vision Zero includes everyone, whether you're in a car or you're on a scooter or a motorcycle.

54:04Everyone.

54:04We want everyone to get home safely.

54:07And what they talk about in that press release specifically is that it's important for those who are riding motorcycles to slow down, stay alert, and safely share the road.

54:17Thank you.

54:18And that is— they talk about that because it's following a sharp increase in fatal motorcycle crashes.

54:25The facts are that 11 of the 25 deaths at that point, more than 50%, were motorcyclists who died.

54:36And thank you, Councilor Smith, for pointing back to that deadly traffic crash report.

54:41I love the idea also of this coming to Public Community and Public Safety.

54:44This is a very important issue.

54:45Thank you.

54:46Is Community and Public Safety.

54:47And what we hear in the press release from Sergeant Betsy Hornstein is, uh, she says, what we're seeing in both our enforcement efforts and fatal crash investigations is that some motorcyclists are making unsafe choices.

54:59We continue to see motorcyclists speeding, making sudden or unpredictable movements, lane splitting, and driving while impaired.

55:06While drivers of motor vehicles also engage some of these behaviors, the consequences are far more serious for motorcyclists.

55:12Motorcycles are smaller, less visible to other road users, and offer none of the protection of an enclosed vehicle.

55:17Thank you.

55:18And also, I think most of those happened in between dusk and dawn, which is— studies show that more people are riding motorcycles during the summer months.

55:27And also, those are when the— when deadly crashes tend to be, between dusk and dawn.

55:33So thank you everyone for being engaged on this topic.

55:35Look forward to talking more about this.

Unidentified speaker 55:37 - 55:37

55:37Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 55:38 - 55:41

55:38Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

55:40Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 55:43 - 56:39

55:43Thank you, Council President.

55:44Thank you, Council President.

55:46First, on page 6, there's a recruitment upcoming for not only the Community Board for Police Accountability, but also the Citizen Review Committee and the Police Review Board, which are part of our current system.

55:59I'm really excited to see that that's happening and that there's coordination between those.

56:03I worked really hard.

56:04I've done recruitment for all 3 of those in some way and helped, especially with the current system.

56:11To try and get collective application and review processes for efficiency.

56:15So hopefully it's not just the recruitment announcement, but also that review.

56:20And I think that's a really good sign.

56:21I see you nodding there.

56:22Thank you, CA Lee.

56:24All my questions on Arboretum were answered except one.

56:28Do we know when it would come back to council in terms of calendar year?

56:38If appealed.

Donnie Oliveira 56:39 - 57:09

56:39Yeah, uh, thanks for the question, Councilor.

56:42So we are working with the Council President's office to find time.

56:46Uh, there is technically a 120-day clock that this process— that's a land use process clock that started when the application came in, and that, that sunsets on December 31st.

56:56So the goal would be to try to get some time scheduled in December, but as I said, we're working with the Council President and city attorneys to, to figure out what that looks like given the Okay, thank you for that.

Sameer Kanal 57:12 - 57:43

57:12Um, under public safety, this is page 9, it talks about the local emergency accommodation program.

57:17City Attorney Lee, I imagine you won't be able to answer this on the spot, so just flagging for later.

57:21I would love some information on how we're ensuring that this is voluntary, um, meaning not simply a requirement of participation but not an expectation of participation.

57:30In order to receive that specific type of response tailored to the needs of a person with disabilities who maybe hasn't been aware or chosen not to participate.

57:38And so I don't know if that's maybe better for here later or for a committee, but just wanted to flag that.

Raymond C. Lee 57:44 - 57:49

57:44Got it.

57:44Well, and sure, we'll follow up and we'll find the right resource to make sure we can communicate it out.

Sameer Kanal 57:51 - 58:45

57:51Okay, thank you.

57:53I love seeing the shout out to Jamie Cuddy and the work that's going on at PBIM and BOK and all that.

57:58So thank you.

58:01Vision Zero, everything got asked.

58:02So the other question I had on the awards report there, in addition to that one on Tech 5 USA, just below that, there are 3 awards for $1 million each to 3 executive search firms, to AP, to CPS, and to Triad.

58:22My understanding is that we used SGR for the partially successful search for DCAs.

58:28So I don't know what these are for.

58:30We use MODIS for the other profile executive search recently, which was the OCPA director.

58:36And I'm just curious, those are pretty large sums.

58:39So what is the way— where is that money coming from too, I guess is the second part of it.

58:44But what's it for?

Raymond C. Lee 58:46 - 58:55

58:46If my memory serves me correct, this is not something— this is an amount not to exceed.

58:51So each year we budget, it's just building in the capacity for executive searches.

Sameer Kanal 58:55 - 59:15

58:55This is not saying that we're actually going to spend that dollar Okay, so this, it's, this is in the awards report, not the contracts report.

59:06So maybe I'm misunderstanding what that's about, but I know it's coming out of HR in some way.

59:12I just don't know sort of the, the nature of it.

Raymond C. Lee 59:15 - 59:42

59:15Well, let me take a look at it because I was looking at it from the standpoint, I know we had, we did an RFP process as it relates to recruiters, which is Modus, SGR, CPH HR, where we were getting a list of recruitment firms that could do executive recruiting for us.

59:33But let me look to see exactly what you were referring to, Councilor, and then we can follow up on that if that's— if I'm not answering that component of the question.

Sameer Kanal 59:42 - 1:00:27

59:42No, I appreciate that.

59:43And I've always appreciated that since you came in, you are looking broadly for talent and for folks both within and outside the city.

59:51So I don't mean to be speaking or have anything I say, you know, I don't want to be inferred as I'm trying to speak against that.

59:58I'm just trying to understand the specifics.

1:00:01I think I will say some of these firms we have experience with, I think maybe all of them, but certainly they have— each has their own track record.

1:00:11And I think that that's helpful to know going forward in terms of whether we continue to work with them or maybe give a different firm more of that work.

1:00:22So I appreciate that.

1:00:24Thank you.

1:00:26Thanks, Council President.

Jamie Dunphy 1:00:29 - 1:00:30

1:00:29Thank you, Councilor Connell.

1:00:30Councilor Ryan.

Dan Ryan 1:00:34 - 1:02:13

1:00:34Thank you.

1:00:34I just wanted to get back in there to thank you, CA Lee, and also DCAs Williams and Oliveira for responding to my request to provide an infrastructure and economic development index for our public schools in our city.

1:00:50I know this is a start.

1:00:51It was a response to what PPS is currently contemplating with 14 I think that's a good point.

1:00:57—Between said sites.

1:00:58I do think this is a beginning, though.

1:00:59I think that this document will keep improving.

1:01:03I think it's something that should be active and fluid for each— for all the school districts in our city, which include beyond PPS to Parkrose, David Douglas, Centennial, Reynolds, and Riverdale.

1:01:18All of them have buildings in our city, and attracting and sustaining families in the City of Portland has always been a big economic prosperity equation for Portland, and we've been losing families pretty dramatically.

1:01:34And that's a responsibility of both the city and the schools.

1:01:39The birth rates are, of course, half of it, but we're unfortunately beating other markets with the loss of families, and we just have to do better.

1:01:49And so I think that we can use this time as an opportunity to have a more fluid dialogue between how we support our schools.

1:01:58At this time, we're responding and reacting, but I think this is hopefully the beginning of a system that we have in place.

1:02:05And I just want to acknowledge the response and thankful for that.

1:02:10And I wanted to daylight the importance of this for the long term.

Jamie Dunphy 1:02:15 - 1:02:32

1:02:15Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1:02:19Councilor Clam Lane, is that a legacy hand, or are you still in line?

1:02:22Okay, perfect.

1:02:24Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, City Administrator, thank you for the update.

1:02:28Let's— Keelan, can we please move to call the consent agenda?

Keelan McClymont 1:02:33 - 1:02:39

1:02:33Yes, thank you.

1:02:34Uh, no items have been pulled.

1:02:36I'll call the roll to approve the consent agenda.

1:02:39Clark?

Olivia Clark 1:02:40 - 1:02:40

1:02:40Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:02:41 - 1:02:41

1:02:41Green?

Mitch Green 1:02:43 - 1:02:43

1:02:43Aye.

Dan Ryan 1:02:48 - 1:02:48

1:02:48Aye.

Candace Avalos 1:02:51 - 1:02:51

1:02:51Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:02:56 - 1:02:57

1:02:56Councilor confirming that was an aye?

Candace Avalos 1:02:58 - 1:02:58

1:02:58Yeah.

Keelan McClymont 1:02:58 - 1:03:00

1:02:58Okay, thank you.

1:03:00Uh, Smith?

Loretta Smith 1:03:02 - 1:03:02

1:03:02Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:03:04 - 1:03:04

1:03:04Kanal?

Sameer Kanal 1:03:04 - 1:03:05

1:03:04Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:03:06 - 1:03:06

1:03:06Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:03:08 - 1:03:08

1:03:08Aye.

Candace Avalos 1:03:10 - 1:03:10

1:03:10Aye.

Loretta Smith 1:03:10 - 1:03:10

1:03:10Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:03:11 - 1:03:12

1:03:11Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 1:03:13 - 1:03:13

1:03:13Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:03:14 - 1:03:15

1:03:14Murillo.

Angelita Morillo 1:03:16 - 1:03:16

1:03:16Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:03:17 - 1:03:17

1:03:17Novick.

Steve Novick 1:03:17 - 1:03:18

1:03:17Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:03:19 - 1:03:19

1:03:19Dunphy.

Jamie Dunphy 1:03:19 - 1:03:19

1:03:19Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:03:21 - 1:03:23

1:03:21The consent agenda is approved with 12 aye votes.

Jamie Dunphy 1:03:23 - 1:03:29

1:03:23Thank you very much.

1:03:24Can we please move to our first item on the regular agenda, item number 8, document 2026-364.

Keelan McClymont 1:03:31 - 1:03:41

1:03:31Amend transportation fee schedule to establish an event parking rate within the Lloyd Event District and Zone B parking permit area.

1:03:38Amend TRN 3.45.

Jamie Dunphy 1:03:42 - 1:03:59

1:03:42Thank you very much, colleagues.

1:03:43This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1:03:45The last time this item came before us, we moved it to a second reading with the understanding that there might be an amendment coming this week, but I've not seen that so far.

1:03:53Are there any amendments to the underlying forthcoming?

1:03:58Councilor Ryan?

Dan Ryan 1:04:00 - 1:04:02

1:04:00Yeah, Councilor Kanal, you were going to kick this off.

Sameer Kanal 1:04:05 - 1:04:11

1:04:05Yeah, so, uh, thank you, Council President.

1:04:08It's a pre-filed amendment.

1:04:10It is available on the, uh, the website.

Loretta Smith 1:04:12 - 1:04:12

1:04:12It's—.

Jamie Dunphy 1:04:12 - 1:04:13

1:04:12I'm not sure if it's—.

Sameer Kanal 1:04:14 - 1:04:21

1:04:14If this is a new thing the clerk's office is doing.

1:04:16If so, great.

1:04:17But it's below the— it's at the bottom of the list as opposed to the top.

Jamie Dunphy 1:04:22 - 1:04:22

1:04:22I missed it.

1:04:22My bad.

Sameer Kanal 1:04:23 - 1:05:19

1:04:23So that, yeah, it adds to the ordinance, not to the exhibits.

1:04:32It adds to a— to the ordinance, a new directive, number— the 5th one.

1:04:38I guess it's lettered, so letter E. And it is the narrower version.

1:04:43Last week we talked about on Flint between either Russell and Page or Russell and Tillamook, the narrower version being Page.

1:04:53This does refer to that narrower area, and it instead of directly changing it, it encourages the city administrator to suspend the boundaries on North Flint between Russell and Page.

1:05:06And then it also asks PBOT to improve the signage and communication proposal.

1:05:13And it cites the relevant code in there.

1:05:15So I'm not sure if someone needs to share screen on that, but it is posted live.

Jamie Dunphy 1:05:21 - 1:05:22

1:05:21And are you formally moving this?

Sameer Kanal 1:05:23 - 1:05:24

1:05:23I will formally move it.

Jamie Dunphy 1:05:24 - 1:05:35

1:05:24Okay.

1:05:25Councilor Kanal formally moves and Councilor— there we go.

1:05:29Councilor Kanal moves Kanal-Ryan 1 and Councilor Ryan seconds.

1:05:33Colleagues, we are now in discussion of this amendment.

Dan Ryan 1:05:37 - 1:06:49

1:05:37Yeah, um, thank you, Councilor Knoll, for getting this started.

1:05:40And mostly I want to thank PBOT.

1:05:41The dialogue was very responsive with both of our offices.

1:05:46I think this is an example of where in this form of government we have more, uh, we have more voices on the ground hearing sometimes these little nuances.

1:05:57Having one business lose 70% of its revenue since this was an In January was alarming at a time when we're really trying to be there for our small businesses.

1:06:07And I must say, it was the sign confusion that was at the top of the list for me.

1:06:12So I'm grateful that's going to be a big part of this, and that PBOT saw it fit to then just narrow it down a bit based on the dialogue.

1:06:21I appreciate that response.

1:06:22So I think that I appreciate colleagues that we could take a little bit more time.

1:06:26I think when these issues are interrelated, Yeah.

1:06:28Our own districts, we sometimes get— we get the feedback that will bring this closer to, uh, what could be a win-win for both the neighborhoods that have been seeking this and also, um, what reality looks like.

1:06:41So I'm grateful for that.

1:06:42When we get to the vote, um, after this, I hope we can then move, uh, emergency ordinance so that we don't have to delay the progress.

1:06:49Thanks.

Jamie Dunphy 1:06:51 - 1:06:52

1:06:51Thank you very much, Councilor Ryan.

1:06:52Councilor Green.

Mitch Green 1:06:54 - 1:07:25

1:06:54Thank you so much.

1:06:55Thanks, colleagues, for filing that amendment.

1:06:57Thanks for entertaining my dialogue last week.

1:07:01I could imagine that was maybe a little frustrating because I'm a District 4 councilor, but I was really trying to understand.

1:07:06I think your amendment's reasonable.

1:07:09I appreciate the focus on the signage clarification piece.

1:07:14I think that's the most important piece.

1:07:15I hear you there, Councilor Ryan.

1:07:17It doesn't look like it's like directly amending in a thing to a map, and I think it's fairly reasonable.

1:07:22So I I, I'm prepared to support your amendment today.

Dan Ryan 1:07:25 - 1:07:25

1:07:25Thanks.

Jamie Dunphy 1:07:27 - 1:07:28

1:07:27Thank you very much, Councilor Green.

1:07:28Councilor Knoll.

Sameer Kanal 1:07:29 - 1:08:21

1:07:29Thanks.

1:07:29I gave the sort of anodyne what it does, so I'll just say, um, you know, Councilor Ryan and I both, uh, and I know all of us indeed too, um, when we hear from, you know, a neighborhood business on a relatively low-traffic street that, that a change that is well designed on the whole and well-intentioned on the whole has this one mitigatable but not yet mitigated impact that might cause a pretty impact for that business, that's something that gets our attention.

1:07:55So I'm really grateful for the partnership on that with Councilor Ryan's office, as well as, as he pointed out, with PBOT, who did a lot here.

1:08:02This is obviously hyperlocal, right?

1:08:05This isn't even just a district-wide issue.

1:08:06This is a street-level issue.

1:08:08And so it's really important to help with those where we can.

1:08:15And this is one of those where we actually can, I think.

1:08:17So I'd ask for your support in that.

1:08:20And again, thanks for your time.

Unidentified speaker 1:08:21 - 1:08:21

1:08:21Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:08:23 - 1:08:25

1:08:23Thank you very much, Councilor Kanal.

1:08:24Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:08:26 - 1:10:00

1:08:26Thank you, Council President, and thank you to my colleagues for doing the heavy lifting on this one.

1:08:32Uh, I want to just note that this is a really important change for this business.

1:08:39I think the signage piece is really important for not only the whole district but the whole city.

1:08:44We need to make sure that our, um, our signage in these areas where we have overlapping sometimes on, sometimes off paid parking spaces is clear.

1:08:58The other side of this is the residents who have this program so that they have a place to park.

1:09:04And I want to bring that up right now, not to take away from the celebration of this solution for a small business, but DCA Williams mentioned at our last meeting that they wanted to do some work in advance with residents.

1:09:17Yes.

1:09:17Residents to make sure they understood the impact on residents.

1:09:21And I'm hoping that I could get a nod from the DCA, not that you will delay this change to do that work, because this change is clearly important and needs to move forward, but that the outreach will still happen with residents, uh, after the fact to make sure that we understand if this change to help mitigate the impact on the Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, and I acknowledge I didn't identify myself when I spoke earlier.

Millicent Williams 1:10:00 - 1:11:07

1:10:00Millicent Williams, Interim Deputy City Administrator for Public Works.

1:10:03Yes, our commitment is to ensuring that we engage the community that Thank you.

1:10:09As the mayor said, this is a community that is affected by all of the policy changes that we make, but most specifically in this case, the community that will be directly affected.

1:10:17It is our obligation, it is our responsibility, and it is our practice to make sure that we do really deep engagement on things that are as personal as parking.

1:10:27We recognize the sensitivity.

1:10:29We recognize that the levers that we have and the options that we have to use and pull are quite limited in many instances.

1:10:37And so it's really important that people are very, very clear about what is proposed to happen and what they can anticipate the outcome of that potential change will be so that they can plan accordingly.

1:10:54I don't anticipate that we will not hear about this more down the road, but we are doing our level best to make sure that all parties are well engaged, well informed, Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:11:07 - 1:11:43

1:11:07I appreciate hearing that.

1:11:10I also appreciate that this is the narrowest of versions that we can do to make sure that we're supporting the business and also still hopefully supporting residents in the area.

1:11:20But because those conversations haven't been had yet, I wanted to make sure to raise that today and just state the importance of finding that balance and figuring out where a policy can narrowly serve all of the interested parties.

1:11:32I hope we're meeting that today.

1:11:33Thank you.

1:11:35On this one, and I am glad to hear that the work will be done to ground truth that and make sure that, that we're hitting the right spot.

Jamie Dunphy 1:11:47 - 1:12:00

1:11:47Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1:11:51Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue to discuss the amendment— pausing for dramatic effect— Keelan, can we please call the roll on Kanal Ryan?

Keelan McClymont 1:12:02 - 1:12:04

1:12:02Uh, moved by Kanal, seconded by Ryan.

1:12:04Clark?

Olivia Clark 1:12:07 - 1:12:07

1:12:07Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:08 - 1:12:08

1:12:08Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 1:12:09 - 1:12:09

1:12:09Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:10 - 1:12:10

1:12:10Avalos?

Candace Avalos 1:12:11 - 1:12:11

1:12:11Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:12 - 1:12:12

1:12:12Smith?

Loretta Smith 1:12:13 - 1:12:13

1:12:13Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:14 - 1:12:15

1:12:14Kanal?

Sameer Kanal 1:12:15 - 1:12:16

1:12:15Thanks, colleagues.

1:12:16Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:17 - 1:12:17

1:12:17Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:12:18 - 1:12:18

1:12:18Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:19 - 1:12:21

1:12:19Ryan?

Dan Ryan 1:12:22 - 1:12:22

1:12:22Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:23 - 1:12:23

1:12:23Aye.

Angelita Morillo 1:12:24 - 1:12:24

1:12:24Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:25 - 1:12:25

1:12:25Aye.

Jamie Dunphy 1:12:27 - 1:12:27

1:12:27Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:12:29 - 1:12:31

1:12:29Uh, the amendment is approved with 12 aye votes.

Jamie Dunphy 1:12:31 - 1:12:33

1:12:31Thank you very much.

1:12:32Councilor Ryan?

Dan Ryan 1:12:34 - 1:13:23

1:12:34Yeah, thank you, Council President.

1:12:35Before we move on, there was concerns about the timeliness of this because in fact we do have events taking place in that area, and we'd like to ensure that PBOT and the city can move forward with the implementation of this said policy.

1:12:52And today was the day that we were hoping to have that finalized for the second reading.

1:12:56So with the passage of this amendment, I move that we put this with an emergency clause, which would demand 9 votes in favor.

1:13:06And in the old days, we just would say it like this.

1:13:09It is in Section 2, the council declares an emergency exists due to the start of the heavy event season in the Rose Quarter, and therefore this ordinance shall be in full force and effect upon after this passage.

1:13:20Therefore, I move that we add an emergency clause.

Loretta Smith 1:13:24 - 1:13:25

1:13:24Second.

Jamie Dunphy 1:13:25 - 1:13:37

1:13:25Councilor Ryan moves, uh, we'll call it Ryan 1, for an added emergency clause.

1:13:30Councilor Smith seconds.

1:13:31Councilor, are you able to share the text of that with us, uh, electronically?

1:13:36I'd like to make sure the clerk gets a copy of it.

Dan Ryan 1:13:37 - 1:13:53

1:13:37Will, can you do that wherever you are?

1:13:41And, um, it basically just says in Section 2, the council declares that an emergency exists due to the start of the heavy event season at the Rose Quarter, and therefore this This ordinance shall be in full force and effect upon its passage.

Jamie Dunphy 1:13:54 - 1:13:55

1:13:54Great.

1:13:54Thank you.

1:13:55Checking in with our—.

Dan Ryan 1:13:55 - 1:13:59

1:13:55And again, I'm used to back— we just would add these without any of this.

Jamie Dunphy 1:13:59 - 1:14:03

1:13:59So, yep, just want to make sure our team and the clerks have, uh, everything they need.

Dan Ryan 1:14:04 - 1:14:07

1:14:04Thank you for sending that to the clerk and to the rest.

Jamie Dunphy 1:14:10 - 1:14:31

1:14:10Okay, colleagues, is there further discussion of— we will call it Ryan 1— they added the addition of an emergency?

1:14:17And okay, seeing no further discussion, Keelan, can we please call the roll on the amendment to add an emergency clause?

Keelan McClymont 1:14:32 - 1:14:35

1:14:32Moved by Ryan, seconded by Smith.

1:14:35Clark?

Olivia Clark 1:14:36 - 1:14:36

1:14:36Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:14:37 - 1:14:37

1:14:37Green?

Mitch Green 1:14:38 - 1:14:38

1:14:38Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:14:39 - 1:14:39

1:14:39Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 1:14:40 - 1:14:40

1:14:40Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:14:41 - 1:14:41

1:14:41Avalos?

Candace Avalos 1:14:42 - 1:14:42

1:14:42Aye.

Unidentified speaker 1:14:44 - 1:14:44

1:14:44Aye.

Sameer Kanal 1:14:46 - 1:14:47

1:14:46Aye.

Unidentified speaker 1:14:49 - 1:14:52

1:14:49Aye.

1:14:50Aye.

1:14:52Aye.

Angelita Morillo 1:14:54 - 1:14:54

1:14:54Aye.

Unidentified speaker 1:14:56 - 1:14:56

1:14:56Aye.

Millicent Williams 1:14:58 - 1:14:58

1:14:58Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:14:59 - 1:15:02

1:14:59The amendment is approved with 12 aye votes.

Jamie Dunphy 1:15:02 - 1:15:07

1:15:02Thank you very much.

1:15:03And can we please call the roll on the now amended emergency ordinance?

Keelan McClymont 1:15:14 - 1:15:18

1:15:14Yes.

1:15:14Um, this will require 9 affirmative votes to pass.

1:15:18Clark?

Olivia Clark 1:15:19 - 1:15:19

1:15:19Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:15:22 - 1:15:23

1:15:22Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 1:15:24 - 1:15:32

1:15:24Uh, I just also wanted to say I appreciate the deference to the district councilors on this.

1:15:28I think this was an important example of where we can use these districts, so thank you.

Millicent Williams 1:15:32 - 1:15:32

1:15:32Aye.

Donnie Oliveira 1:15:36 - 1:15:36

1:15:36Aye.

Loretta Smith 1:15:37 - 1:15:37

1:15:37Aye.

Angelita Morillo 1:15:38 - 1:15:38

1:15:38Aye.

Unidentified speaker 1:15:39 - 1:15:39

1:15:39Aye.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:15:42 - 1:15:42

1:15:42Aye.

Unidentified speaker 1:15:43 - 1:15:43

1:15:43Aye.

Millicent Williams 1:15:46 - 1:15:46

1:15:46Aye.

Angelita Morillo 1:15:49 - 1:15:49

1:15:49Aye.

Eric Zimmerman 1:15:51 - 1:15:51

1:15:51Aye.

Keelan McClymont 1:15:54 - 1:16:14

1:15:54The ordinance passes with 12 aye votes.

1:15:57Thank you very much.

1:15:59Keelan, can we please move to item number Item 9, document 2026-371, declare 2 parcels of land as surplus property and authorize the Bureau of Transportation to dispose of the property for fair market value.

Jamie Dunphy 1:16:15 - 1:16:24

1:16:15Thank you, colleagues.

1:16:16This is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1:16:18I believe Kevin Alvarez from committee— from Council Operations is here with a committee staff summary report.

Dan Ryan 1:16:26 - 1:16:26

1:16:26Good morning, Council.

Kevin Alvarez 1:16:27 - 1:16:27

1:16:27Can you hear me?

Jamie Dunphy 1:16:27 - 1:16:28

1:16:27We can.

Kevin Alvarez 1:16:30 - 1:18:11

1:16:30Council President and councilors, for the record, my name is Kevin Alvarez.

1:16:33I serve as a council policy analyst for the City Life Committee.

1:16:36The ordinance before you, document number 2026-371, was heard in the City Life Committee on October 27th, 2026, where it was referred to council with a recommendation it be passed.

1:16:48The ordinance declares 2 remnant parcels of city-owned land as surplus property and authorizes the Portland Bureau of Transportation P-BOT to sell the parcels on the open market for fair market value.

1:16:59The parcels are located at the east end of the Southeast Foster and Southeast Woodstock couplet and measure 3,163 square feet and 346 square feet.

1:17:10They are identified in Multnomah County assessor records as R215658 and R715365.

1:17:20Thank you.

1:17:21And are remnants of land the city acquired in 1970 for the Southeast Foster and Southeast Woodstock Road Improvement Project.

1:17:29PBOT has no transportation-related use for the parcels, and no other city bureau expressed interest in them or a need to control or reserve easements on them.

1:17:40The sale generates one-time revenue that is not included in the fiscal year 2026 through 27 budget, and would be applied in the fiscal year in which it is.

1:17:48The ordinance also returns the parcels to the tax rolls and ends PBOT's ongoing maintenance and liability for the property.

1:17:56The full impact statement on this item includes financial and budgetary impacts, community impacts and community involvement, and economic and real estate impacts and analysis.

1:18:05No verbal or written testimony was provided prior to committee action, and that concludes the committee staff summary.

1:18:11Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:18:12 - 1:18:19

1:18:12Thank you very much.

1:18:14And Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, this came out of your committee.

1:18:17Any opening remarks?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:18:23 - 1:19:34

1:18:23Thank you, colleagues.

1:18:24As you may remember, we had a conversation in City Life about the disposition of property.

1:18:31Uh, this is one of the items we have considered since that conversation.

1:18:37It was pretty straightforward.

1:18:39There was no interest within the city, and as A small parcel.

1:18:44We were told that there were not opportunities for long-term land banking.

1:18:50One of our colleagues asked a question about whether the city should be banking this for future PHB use, and we were told that PHB generally prefers larger parcels for that.

1:19:00There was also a question which, preview and full disclosure, I will ask when we get to full discussion again.

1:19:07Thank you.

1:19:08About our policies around offering properties to, um, certain types of developers first to ensure that, for example, low-income developments have an opportunity to locate on land like this.

1:19:24Other than those questions, the conversation was technical and straightforward, and it passed committee, as you heard, with a unanimous vote.

Unidentified speaker 1:19:34 - 1:19:34

1:19:34Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:19:38 - 1:19:45

1:19:38Thank you very much, Councilor Bertolini.

1:19:39Colleagues, let's, uh, begin with— actually, very quickly, Keelan, has anyone signed up for public testimony on this item?

Keelan McClymont 1:19:46 - 1:19:59

1:19:46Uh, we have one person signed up.

1:19:47I don't believe they're here.

1:19:48If you will let me just check to see.

1:19:52Um, Penny T. Okay, nope, we're all done with testimony.

Jamie Dunphy 1:20:00 - 1:20:09

1:20:00Okay, colleagues, we are now in Uh, discussion of the underlying both technical clarifying and broader discussion.

1:20:08Councilor Smith, kick us off.

Loretta Smith 1:20:10 - 1:20:18

1:20:10Thank you, um, Council President.

1:20:12Uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, could you tell me what is this zoned for, this, this property, and how big is it?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:20:20 - 1:20:55

1:20:20I'm gonna let our technical staff discuss the specific zoning, but if you picture On the map, there's like a triangle where 2 roads come together, um, and it is the last 2 lots.

1:20:39So it is 2 lots, but think about it more like a lot and a half that make a triangle.

1:20:44It is just past 205 where, um, Foster kind of dips down and curves around.

1:20:53I don't know if you can picture that part of the city.

Millicent Williams 1:20:55 - 1:20:55

1:20:55Yeah.

Loretta Smith 1:20:56 - 1:21:17

1:20:56Okay, okay, because I was wondering why it didn't come through, um, Public Works Committee, uh, since it is PBOT, and I would have liked to have seen it as well.

1:21:07I didn't know that you were talking about this in your committee, um, and it is in District 1, so I wanted to get some more information.

1:21:14So is there someone there from PBOT that I can talk to?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:21:18 - 1:21:47

1:21:18And Councilor, before PBOT jumps in, I will flag that There was a conversation amongst a few folks about how we deal with surplus property, and the council president asked if I would take all surplus property in the City Life Committee so that we have consistent conversations about when and how we dispose of property.

1:21:44That was the conversation that I flagged, I believe, at our last council meeting.

1:21:47Thank you.

Loretta Smith 1:21:48 - 1:23:10

1:21:48Yeah, I don't know that that's totally appropriate because I have a resolution coming through Public Works that's going to be talking about what we do with surplus property in general, and it's in regards to changing zoning to get additional residential property.

1:22:07And I just think that that's something that should be talked about amongst all the the folks before direction is given to one individual counselor to do that, particularly when PBOT has the majority of the properties that are available.

1:22:26And since we have not received— since we have not received a full report on the $82 billion worth of assets that me and Councilor Clark asked for, it seemed like she would have been taking the lead on that because she asked for all the assets.

1:22:42And so when, when we're kind of disjointed like that, um, it just makes it difficult, uh, to figure out what's going on because I think everybody has a certain interest about some of the surplus property.

1:22:54And I want to use some of that surplus property, um, to go back into housing.

1:22:59So that is my concern about this.

1:23:02And, um, I don't know if Millicent is still on or someone else from PBOT is Uh, thank you, Councilor.

Millicent Williams 1:23:10 - 1:23:13

1:23:10I am here, and Dave Mackeldowney is also on the line.

Loretta Smith 1:23:14 - 1:23:17

1:23:14So the first question that I have, what is this zoned for?

Millicent Williams 1:23:18 - 1:23:20

1:23:18Dave will be able to answer those questions.

Donnie Oliveira 1:23:21 - 1:24:38

1:23:21Good morning, Council.

1:23:22David Mackeldowney, Portland Bureau of Transportation.

1:23:26There are 2 parcels here, and it's split zoning.

1:23:29The smallest of the 2, the 300-something square foot parcel has, uh, I believe, an IG-1, or I'll pull it up, EG-2 zoning, general employment.

1:23:42But the majority of the parcel is, uh, zoned RM-1, so residential multi-dwelling, and we believe it can accommodate, uh, 1 or 2 units.

1:23:56Okay, so did you all talk to any community-based developers to see if they wanted this We spoke with Portland Housing Bureau originally, and they indicated that they need a property that can accommodate more like 20 units at a minimum.

1:24:14We also asked them, following up on Chair Pearl Guinea's question, whether or not there were, you know, smaller developers, independent developers who had developed that for affordable housing.

1:24:27And they indicated that they had not.

1:24:29And the response we got back was that it didn't rise, or it was too small really to, um, 300 square feet.

Loretta Smith 1:24:38 - 1:24:40

1:24:38300,000 square feet is too small?

Donnie Oliveira 1:24:41 - 1:24:43

1:24:413,500 square feet total.

Loretta Smith 1:24:44 - 1:25:42

1:24:44I was just meeting with a community-based— and he's not a community-based developer, African-American developer who is for-profit, who is— who lives in that area in District 1.

1:24:55And I don't know that we have Talking to PHB, they don't give voice for all the other developers that are in that area who may consider it as something that they may want to do.

1:25:09I think that we we need to take some time to talk to some other developers other than PHB and some community-based developers to see if this is something that they will want to partner with PHB with with some of those.

1:25:23Those dollars that they have, because this is, this is, this is opportunity.

1:25:28And if you put it out there for the highest bidder, those kinds of highest bidders, they're always going to outbid a community-based developer.

1:25:38And I don't think we're giving folks a fair opportunity.

Donnie Oliveira 1:25:44 - 1:25:54

1:25:44I don't want to speak for DCA Williams.

1:25:46You can correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't I don't believe that PBOT has any objections to prioritizing affordable housing developers.

Loretta Smith 1:25:55 - 1:26:45

1:25:55No, no, you're misunderstanding me.

1:25:57I don't necessarily want affordable housing.

1:25:58We need middle housing in District 1.

1:26:01Um, the, the problem is that we, we, we don't get enough middle housing opportunities in that district, and, and so I want to see more middle housing.

1:26:11We have a lot of affordable housing that are coming up in District 1, but Thank you.

1:26:14But I want to see some mixed-use developments, middle housing opportunities, opportunities for disadvantaged developers and community-based developers to be able to have an opportunity to partner with us before we just wholeheartedly just say, oh no, there's nobody who wants it at the city.

1:26:36But there are opportunities that the city can partner with a community based developer on this that I think that we have not taken into consideration.

Millicent Williams 1:26:50 - 1:27:57

1:26:50Thank you, Councilor.

1:26:52We can certainly evaluate, reevaluate our process.

1:26:57There are some limitations to how we're able to present opportunities to the open market regardless as to their designations around who they're servicing and how they're servicing them.

1:27:11Our protocol right now, however, is to first engage with Portland Housing Bureau and then make it available on the open market.

1:27:20We don't have the ability to, for lack of a better term, segregate the effort to direct it in one place or another.

1:27:34What we can do, however, is if in fact someone is interested in making a purchase or coming up with an agreement, have that as a part of a negotiation that while at market— while we may put something forward at market rate, that does not necessarily mean that that is what the ultimate purchaser would end up paying.

Keelan McClymont 1:27:57 - 1:27:57

1:27:57Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:27:59 - 1:27:59

1:27:59Right.

Millicent Williams 1:27:59 - 1:28:01

1:27:59So it's much like a regular competitive market.

Loretta Smith 1:28:02 - 1:29:51

1:28:02Oh, I understand that.

1:28:03I mean, when you're talking about something that can be used for residential housing, and we have lifted the city's— all the fees, the SDCs and everything, we're still not where we need to be in terms of the amount of housing that we're putting forward.

1:28:20And I think we need to put housing forward at every level of government, and I think I think that if I would have known about this earlier, I would have talked to Portland Housing and gave them a suggestion on maybe this is something that they can do to partner with a developer that would make sure that we put housing on those 2 pieces.

1:28:49And I just don't think that we've done enough with that.

1:28:53I think it was just rushed through.

1:28:55Councilmember And people didn't want to deal with their opportunities.

1:28:59But if it's not a big— like they said, if it's not big, they don't usually like to mess with it.

1:29:05And when you're talking about something small, but we need to take every opportunity to take some of this surplus property.

1:29:10That's why I'm putting this resolution forward next week so that underutilized properties, surplus properties that can be rezoned, whether it be employment, light industrial, to things that we're commercial, And we put it into housing specifically.

1:29:29People could just hold on.

1:29:30They could buy the property and then just hold on to it, you know, and then resell it while we have opportunities.

1:29:36And I thought that we were going to stop actually selling things until we got that asset list.

1:29:42I thought that that's what we made very clear, that we should not be selling any properties until we had that full-fledged asset list that was not made available.

Millicent Williams 1:29:51 - 1:29:52

1:29:51Councilor Smith, Councilor Smith.

Keelan McClymont 1:29:51 - 1:29:51

1:29:51I think you're missing the point.

Loretta Smith 1:29:52 - 1:30:34

1:29:52The asset inventory is not available that we were supposed to have a couple of weeks ago, last month, through the Public Works Committee, and we didn't get it.

1:29:59We got a number.

1:30:00I don't know how we get a number of $82 billion in assets and we don't have the assets to match it to see what properties are worth what.

1:30:09And so that's really concerning to me.

1:30:12So you can tell that I'm kind of frustrated right now that we're selling, we're trying to rush through properties, And we said that we were going to hold off on not selling properties or surplus properties until we get that asset list.

1:30:26And so I'm concerned.

1:30:28I'm just concerned that we're just forgetting all the things that we talked about.

Millicent Williams 1:30:35 - 1:31:31

1:30:35Thank you, Councilor.

1:30:38I can't speak for all of the ways that we engage in the sale or disposition of properties I can speak to what the service area does and can do.

1:30:48We will work with, of course, the Public Works Committee as well as continue to work with the City Life Committee as per the direction that has been given.

1:30:58I recognize that you and your colleagues are going to need to further discuss the best ways for us to engage regarding the disposition of land and how we support community in creating the neighborhoods and communities that we We would like.

1:31:13With regard to the list of assets, while that was brought up in the Public Works Committee, and I know that there is a strong desire for a list of not just properties but buildings and fleet and all of the other things—.

Loretta Smith 1:31:32 - 1:31:32

1:31:32All assets.

Millicent Williams 1:31:33 - 1:31:49

1:31:33Yes.

1:31:34And I know that that was an expectation.

1:31:36I do know that our new city asset manager is working on on that list and is going to be prepared to provide that for you early in the new year.

1:31:45Uh, it is not just, um, Public Works, um, assets that will be affected.

Loretta Smith 1:31:49 - 1:31:55

1:31:49No, it's the entire city, but it came out of Public Works.

1:31:53And yeah, I, yeah, I do.

Millicent Williams 1:31:55 - 1:32:28

1:31:55I just wanted to acknowledge that it is a bigger, um, opportunity for us as a city to figure out how to best support, uh, the initiatives that you as councilors are bringing forward, the, the thoughtfulness that you're bringing to supporting your constituencies.

1:32:12And I don't want for there to be the impression that we're rushing things through as much as we are continuing to move through the process that we have before us as has been previously designed.

1:32:25But we have some— we see that there is room for redesign to our process.

Loretta Smith 1:32:29 - 1:32:55

1:32:29So can you give me some kind of assurance that if you're going to put any proper that has anything to do in the public works area, whether it be water, PBOT, parks, and you put it through public works as well.

1:32:47And I'm— yeah, I'm a little frustrated over here.

1:32:53So you have my commitment.

Jamie Dunphy 1:32:55 - 1:33:27

1:32:55Oh, and Councilor, I will just say though that the one unique authority and responsibility of the council president is the referral to committee and the referral to the full agenda.

1:33:04As a Council President, I have made the decision that the City Life Committee is the singular place where we should be talking about land dispositions, and that is absolutely an internal policy that the next council president can change.

1:33:15But for the remainder of 2026, which is 42 more days, uh, 44 more days, uh, we'll continue on this path forward.

1:33:24But that is certainly a topic for the next council president to discuss.

Loretta Smith 1:33:28 - 1:34:16

1:33:28And Council President, um, we had a bigger conversation at the City Council— as city councilors, not just in the City Life Committee, that we would hold off on selling properties until we got that asset list.

1:33:44And so we have dual kinds of direction going on.

1:33:49And so it would be appreciated if we wouldn't try to rush through properties when we're still in this process.

1:33:56And I'm fine with it, but I'm just letting folks know that there— we got dual things that we have agreed upon in addition to your direction that you gave to one councilor.

1:34:06So I, I appreciate what you're saying, but also understand that it's, it's, it's buffing up against the, the bigger, uh, um, direction that we all agreed upon.

1:34:16Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:34:17 - 1:34:18

1:34:17Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1:34:18Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:34:20 - 1:35:10

1:34:20Thank you, Council President and Councilor Smith.

1:34:23I am So glad to hear that there is other resistance to selling off property willy-nilly.

1:34:31I was very frustrated over the last year and a half with how much property we have disposed of already, um, and this is the first I've heard about that other conversation, so that, that's great to hear.

1:34:44I have a question, and I am hoping that either DCA Oliveira or somebody from the Housing Bureau is Excuse me, Councilor.

1:35:07Sorry, DCA Oliveira, that this one may be coming to you.

Donnie Oliveira 1:35:11 - 1:35:11

1:35:11Yep.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:35:11 - 1:35:44

1:35:11So when the Housing Bureau is asked if they are interested in a property, I understand that even as they look at a direction from this council to think about land banking differently, that a property like this is too small for the development that the Housing Bureau would be a part of.

1:35:28Do they in turn— let me back up and say this differently.

1:35:33When it is a Housing Bureau property, my understanding is that before it is disposed of, they ask affordable housing developers if they are interested in the property.

1:35:43Is that accurate?

Donnie Oliveira 1:35:44 - 1:35:48

1:35:44There's a variety of different scenarios, but yes, that is one scenario that Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:35:49 - 1:36:01

1:35:49When it is a PBOT property like this, does it automatically get offered to affordable housing developers before it comes to council to dispose of on the market?

Donnie Oliveira 1:36:03 - 1:36:07

1:36:03Councilor, honestly, I would defer that to PBOT about their process for, you know, evaluation.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:36:07 - 1:36:19

1:36:07PBOT was not able to answer the question in committee.

1:36:10They said that that was a Housing Bureau question, which is why I brought it here, because there was not any Understandably, there wouldn't be from Housing Bureau in the committee at the time.

Donnie Oliveira 1:36:20 - 1:36:40

1:36:20Yeah, Councilor, it's not current— our current model to have Housing Bureau staff look at all available properties that the city might be disposing of outside of the process that we have.

1:36:30We have this, uh, this team that works on properties, real property, you know, real estate teams that share information, but it's not a formal process where the Housing Bureau looks at every property that any bureau might be disposing of.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:36:43 - 1:39:04

1:36:43Okay, so colleagues, what I said in committee was that I was not going to hold up this property because we have heard from neighbors around this property that they would like it to be developed soon because it's been sitting empty for quite a while.

1:37:01But I would like us to consider a policy moving forward that would require that small properties like this, if we are going to dispose of them, um, be considered or, or be offered to developers of affordable homeownership opportunities first.

1:37:23We know that we need more affordable housing, both rental and homeownership, in our community.

1:37:28We know that a property of this size and shape is not going to a larger-scale development that would lead to affordable rentals.

1:37:38But that doesn't mean that this couldn't still be used for affordable opportunities in our community if it were developed into 1 or 2 or 3 affordable homeownership opportunities.

1:37:52And I think it is a missed opportunity that this property was not offered to those developers off market before we bring it to the market.

1:38:03I would like us to consider a policy that changes that, and frankly, I would look to the administration because right now your process for property disposition is not codified.

1:38:12It is in rule.

1:38:14So I would look to the administration to tell me whether that is a conversation that they are willing to engage in with our council, uh, as something they might change in rule, or if this council needs to look at codifying Um, our property disposition process more fully so that we can have the conversation about doing something like that.

1:38:36I don't need that answer today.

1:38:37I'm happy to take it and follow up offline, but I'm very serious about limiting our practice of sending things to the market without being intentional about what the city wants done with property if we dispose of it, and also being far more intentional I think it's really important to have that on the record today, and I will be looking for follow-up from the administration.

1:39:02City Administrator Lee, thank you very much.

Jamie Dunphy 1:39:04 - 1:41:09

1:39:04Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1:39:05Um, I actually put myself next in the queue, but then I accidentally dropped out.

1:39:09I apologize for that.

1:39:10I'm just going to very briefly say, colleagues, I'm not necessarily opposed to disposing of the Woodstock couplet parcels.

1:39:17I actually used to live right by this, and these properties are small.

1:39:20They're kind of oddly placed, and I'm honestly not very sure what they'd be worth on the open market.

1:39:26But as my colleague, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, was talking about, Councilor Smith was talking about, I've testified also before on the value of land banking, and it applies here too.

1:39:36We need a citywide land banking policy, and we obviously need to hear, as we've heard today, we need consistency about how we are dealing with public property across city bureaus and across service areas.

1:39:48You know, as Councilor Pirtle-Guiney was sort of saying, like, once we sell a parcel, it is likely that we will never get a chance to buy it back.

1:39:55Back at a— and we'll certainly never get it back at a lower price.

1:39:59Every piece of land that we hold on is an investment into Portland's future, even if they're small ones.

1:40:05These 2 properties are less than about 4,000 square feet combined, and I'm sure that there is someone who could help us find a creative public benefit, whether it's a small fenced dog space or more trees, just simply more trees along Woodstock and Foster.

1:40:20What I don't want is for this land to be sold and then sit vacant because they're odd spaces.

1:40:27That is the worst outcome.

1:40:28We lose the asset and the neighborhood gains nothing.

1:40:31And in fact, there's a number of vacant properties in that specific neighborhood of the, the Lents Town Center that are, are long-term, uh, serious challenges for the community.

1:40:43And I would hope that these odd pieces don't simply sit fallow.

1:40:47Um, so I'm going to add my voice to the chorus broadly in saying that we need to find a citywide consistent policy on what we are doing with our land, recognizing that it's the only thing they're not making more of anymore, and that we find cost-effective ways to put these spaces to use today while still holding them for the future.

1:41:07So thank you, colleagues, and Councilor Knoll.

Millicent Williams 1:41:13 - 1:41:13

1:41:13Thanks.

Sameer Kanal 1:41:13 - 1:44:16

1:41:13There is so much here that is I think worthy of follow-up.

1:41:21I appreciate the clarification from you, Council President, about sort of your prerogatives to file— when things are filed by the administration, or for that matter, the auditor, to refer them to a specific committee.

1:41:35And I think that's, I think, a conversation that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney alluded to, that we sort of— you haven't made that decision unilaterally.

1:41:43You have the prerogative to do so, but there was a group conversation about what committee makes the most sense.

1:41:49And so I just wanted to make sure that that was part of this conversation too.

1:41:53I don't have a problem with the idea that it should go to a singular committee.

1:41:57I think that's helpful to create a consistency around it.

1:42:01I do think we have a few different conversations that Councilor Smith alluded to, one of those that we need to bring the threads together on.

1:42:08When I got in the queue, the thing that was originally I think the other thing that was compelling to me was something that the DCA Williams said about sort of we're following the existing process while a new one goes on.

1:42:20I think this has to do procedurally with something that came up in the City Administrator's report too.

1:42:27If council's voting to change a system that isn't working, but that change, fully implementing that change takes time.

1:42:35The other example of this is the Data Privacy Office.

1:42:36Yes.

1:42:37I think, then I think there's an implicit expression of the legislative branch's viewpoint that we don't want the current system to continue exactly as it is while the new one's being stood up.

1:42:51I also think there's a practicality around we obviously can't do the new thing until it is set up, right?

1:42:58So it can't be either of those.

1:43:00And I think we're default— we obviously—.

1:43:02I agree.

1:43:03Aren't fully defaulting either, but we seem to be defaulting more than just keeping it going until the new system is set up fully.

1:43:09And I have a concern about that, and I want to kind of philosophically unpack that at some point, because these big changes to systems that have been in place, not just in the year and a half, you know, almost 2 years we've been here, but for frankly decades, are going to take a long time to change.

1:43:26But also we have to deliver on at least a portion of that change.

1:43:29Thank you.

1:43:29Change while we're doing these things.

1:43:32And I think one of the ways we do that is to slow down pretty much all of the older processes.

1:43:39But specific to this, I think what DCA Olvera referred to, or referred to not yet existing, is really important.

1:43:47I think we should be, as was alluded to, having every single property that is going to be put on sale evaluated.

1:43:58That seems to me to be something that should come out of this no matter what else comes out of this conversation.

1:44:07And I don't know how to, off the top of my head, how we're going to achieve that, but I think that's something that I want to make sure doesn't get lost in this conversation.

Millicent Williams 1:44:17 - 1:44:17

1:44:17Thanks.

Jamie Dunphy 1:44:19 - 1:44:21

1:44:19Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1:44:21Councilor Smith.

Loretta Smith 1:44:23 - 1:46:35

1:44:23Thank you, Council President.

1:44:25I agree with Councilor Kanal.

1:44:26It should go through Housing Bureau and other bureaus as well.

1:44:31I did have a conversation with the administration a couple of days ago about my resolution and how we dispose of surplus properties and how we zone them and those kinds of things.

1:44:44So I would like to take a stab at it as well.

1:44:47We have a resolution coming out that's going to be online on Friday.

1:44:49Councilor Smith, but I want to make sure that we have a full conversation, and I will make sure that I keep in contact with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney so that she's aware of some of the things that I am thinking about.

1:45:06And so I want us to also be mindful, everyone's talking about affordable housing, but I want to remind you all, affordable housing costs just as much as luxury housing.

1:45:18The rent for both have met.

1:45:21They're the same price.

1:45:23So when we say we only want our stuff to be affordable, that's fine when you live in District 2 and you have all sorts of housing opportunities.

1:45:32Um, we don't have a lot of middle housing opportunities in District 1, and we can't just write a blanket policy that is in general our thought because we want to put more affordable housing on the table, but it's costing just the same and people are paying the same amount.

1:45:50So we need to account for that inflationary cost and the cost of what it costs to do a project like this.

1:45:59And yeah, I just think that we need to talk more about it.

1:46:03I won't try to hold this up or anything, but I just want to make sure that people don't just— it's easy to say, yeah, let's do it for affordable Okay, that's fine, but District 1 is a little bit different.

1:46:14We got a lot of affordable housing.

1:46:16We got a lot of affordable housing online, multi-family affordable housing.

1:46:20We don't have any middle housing, and until we start getting middle housing, people that can pay for stuff, and multi-use housing properties in our district, we're not going to be able to put back into that tech space.

1:46:33That's all I'm saying, you guys.

1:46:35Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:46:35 - 1:46:37

1:46:35Thank you, Councilor.

1:46:36Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1:46:37Councilor Avalos.

Candace Avalos 1:46:39 - 1:48:20

1:46:39Yeah, thanks.

1:46:40I'm glad to hear the discussion.

1:46:42I wasn't expecting it to go this way, but I think it is good and it is signaling just the general interest that we're all sharing about, you know, wanting to have some comprehensive land banking, land use policies.

1:46:54Um, I think one, I'll flag that this is a big part of what will come out of the Unified Housing Strategy.

1:47:01This is something that we've been Thank you.

1:47:02This is something that we keep discussing with all of the practitioners, with community.

1:47:05It keeps rising to the top when people ask what we should prioritize or when we ask people what we— the city should prioritize.

1:47:14And, you know, I know Metro is making some big moves right now on trying to establish some good policies.

1:47:19I think that we don't have to reinvent the wheel here.

1:47:21And in fact, we should look to our partners at Metro to see how we can align those policies Thank you.

1:47:29I think also, you know, this is a— this broader, like, how do we— who is in charge, I guess, of this policy is, I think, something we need to discuss.

1:47:40But the SETSA service area, right, I don't think it would all fall strictly under housing.

1:47:45I think there are different ways we would go about it, especially because different kinds of lands that we would bank, not just land for housing.

1:47:52And I think overall, you know, I hear from my constituents in District 1 often too that they're like, we don't want more affordable housing.

1:47:59And what I always respond is, I think affordable housing has a negative connotation.

1:48:04What I want is housing that's affordable.

1:48:06And I think that can come at all kinds of levels for different kinds of incomes.

1:48:10I met with a couple just the other day, for example, who are like, we're doing everything right.

1:48:14We have, you know, on paper enough income to buy a house, but there are so many gaps between people being Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:48:20 - 1:48:20

1:48:20Thank you.

1:48:20I think that's a great point.

Candace Avalos 1:48:20 - 1:49:26

1:48:20I think that we're being able to go to that next level, especially in District 1.

1:48:25But yeah, I think that I would caution us to put such a broad blanket on what affordable housing means, because in my view, you know, I live in— I personally live in housing that's affordable, middle housing, right?

1:48:37But it's like these connotations, I think, don't help us have a thorough discussion about what types of housing we need, because that is different across the city.

1:48:46So I would encourage us to keep talking about this.

1:48:50You know, the Housing Committee is going to keep taking this Yes.

1:48:53We just finished our last round of community engagement for UHS, and so we're in the phase of kind of crunching numbers, putting everything together into a plan that will come back to council after it gets through committee in December.

1:49:05So know that land banking is definitely at the top of what we're hearing from community and stakeholders, and it's going to be top of the list once we get through Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

Jamie Dunphy 1:49:26 - 1:49:27

1:49:26Councilor Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 1:49:28 - 1:50:13

1:49:28Thank you, Council President.

1:49:29I'll try to be quick.

1:49:30I appreciate this conversation.

1:49:32Agree that we need to get clear on the processes and policies around surplus properties.

1:49:36I understand that it's up to the Council President to decide where these conversations are being sent, and I just want to note that I, I do— I can see a place for more conversations for this in housing and permitting as well, possibly at some point.

1:49:51And to Councilor Smith's point, I think middle housing opportunities are really something that are important and we should be considering as part of our housing production strategy.

1:50:01For example, there are a lot of opportunities for cottage clusters that support older adults and intergenerational communities.

1:50:08Um, yeah, so looking forward to talking Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

Jamie Dunphy 1:50:13 - 1:50:15

1:50:13Councilor Smith, last word.

Loretta Smith 1:50:15 - 1:50:39

1:50:15Yeah, I just have one question.

1:50:16So, uh, to PBOT, so did the administration, uh, in terms of the mayor's office and the administrator, did they, did they want this property sold, or have we talked to them about what their vision was on how property is, uh, disposed of since that direction comes from the mayor's office?

1:50:35Is—.

1:50:35I'm just trying to get some clarity Thank you, Councilor.

Millicent Williams 1:50:39 - 1:50:58

1:50:39Uh, no, we did not discuss this with the city administrator other than through regular briefings in terms of, uh, seeking, uh, their recommendation.

1:50:50It was a part of our normal process.

1:50:52Um, Dave, uh, goes through this on an annual basis where he is identifying properties.

Loretta Smith 1:50:59 - 1:52:48

1:50:59We're determining whether or not there is a transportation-related use and then moving forward So I think there's 2 conversations here, Director Williams, DCA Williams, that there's where does the conversation happen, and that is through City Life.

1:51:15And then there's direction that comes from the mayor and the administrator on how they want to see these properties, how they want to see these properties disposed of or kept.

1:51:29So that's a conversation too.

1:51:31So I think that there, there should have been some conversation on the administrative side to say, okay, what do y'all think of this?

1:51:38You probably— because it's such a little thing, you probably didn't think that it would rise to that occasion.

1:51:42But there's, as you see, we have taken it to another level in terms of where the conversation happens.

1:51:50But, but how that happens and who makes those decisions, that comes from the mayor's office and the So there are things that need to be done concurrently as we're, as we're disposing of these properties and to get some direction from the mayor's office and administrator on what their idea of how this should, should be so that we can, with the policymakers, see if we can come to some sort of agreement.

1:52:17Because this is bigger than just this piece of property.

1:52:20It's a small piece.

1:52:22Thank you.

1:52:22And I, I generally don't really get involved with this, but this was a heavy week this week, so I didn't really pay a lot of attention to the agenda, but I would have said the same thing regardless.

1:52:36So if I had caught it last week, I would have been having these conversations with you and the administration prior to.

1:52:43So that's, that's my last thing.

1:52:44I just wanted to figure out if the administration had weighed in on this before.

1:52:48Thank you.

Candace Avalos 1:52:48 - 1:52:51

1:52:48Thank you, Councilor Smith.

Jamie Dunphy 1:52:52 - 1:53:13

1:52:52Colleagues, this is the 1st reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1:52:55Seeing no one else in the queue for discussion, it now moves to 2nd reading.

1:53:00And the time is currently 11:19.

1:53:04I'm going to go ahead and give us a quick break.

1:53:06I'm going to ask folks to be back here at— let's call it 11:30.

1:53:10See you in 11 minutes or so.

Keelan McClymont 2:04:49 - 2:04:52

2:04:49All right, thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:04:52 - 2:04:54

2:04:52Can we please call item number 10?

Keelan McClymont 2:04:56 - 2:05:08

2:04:56Document 2026-308, Add Regulation of Dynamic Pricing and Prohibition of Surveillance Pricing in Retail Code, Add Code Chapter 7.28.

Jamie Dunphy 2:05:08 - 2:05:20

2:05:08Thank you, colleagues.

2:05:09This is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

2:05:12This time, uh, we have Kevin Alvarez with Council Operations here to do a committee staff summary report.

2:05:20Kevin, please take it away.

Kevin Alvarez 2:05:21 - 2:05:23

2:05:21Thank you, Council President.

2:05:22Uh, can you hear me okay?

Jamie Dunphy 2:05:24 - 2:05:25

2:05:24Can hear you perfectly.

Dan Ryan 2:05:25 - 2:05:26

2:05:25Perfect.

Kevin Alvarez 2:05:26 - 2:09:05

2:05:26Council President and councilors, for the record, my name is Kevin Alvarez and I serve as a council policy analyst for the City Life Committee.

2:05:32The ordinance before you, document number 2026-344, was heard in the City Life Committee on October 13th, 2026, where it was referred to full council with the recommendation it be passed.

2:05:44The ordinance approves the conveyance of the form— oh, I am sorry, I'm reading, uh, a different ordinance.

2:05:50Let me go back here.

2:05:52Here we go.

2:05:53Um, the document number 2026-308 was heard in the City Life Committee on September 22nd, 2026, where it was referred to full council as amended with a recommendation it be passed.

2:06:06So the ordinance adds a new chapter to the Portland City Code Chapter 7.28, Regulation of Dynamic Pricing and Prohibition of Surveillance Pricing in Retail, as shown in Exhibit A, and if passed, takes effect July 1st, 2027.

2:06:22The chapter prohibits retail vendors and third-party service providers from engaging in surveillance pricing, which the code defines as offering a retail price for a consumer good based on personal data about a specific consumer account or device.

2:06:38It also prohibits them from increasing the retail price of a consumer good more than once in a calendar year.

2:06:45These restrictions do not apply to discounts offered through volunteer, uh, voluntary loyalty membership rewards or subscription programs, discounts based on publicly disclosed uniform terms, or discounts for broadly defined professional groups such as youth, senior citizens, or residents of a specific area, coupons, sales, and similar discounts offered to all consumers, or delivery and service fees based on objective costs.

2:07:14The city administrator enforces the chapter through written notices of violation with an opportunity to cure a first notice within 45 days.

2:07:22The city administrator may seek civil penalties before the code hearings officer of up to $1,000 for a first notice, $5,000 for a second Thank you.

2:07:31The proposed ordinance would impose a maximum penalty of $10,000 for the first notice, $20,000 for the second notice, and $7,500 for each subsequent notice within a 24-month period, with each affected consumer counted as a separate violation.

2:07:42The chapter does not authorize a private right of action.

2:07:45Lastly, the chapter would be superseded or deemed unenforceable upon the effective date of any conflicting law passed by the State of Oregon.

2:07:55There was one amendment that was approved by the City Life Committee on September 22nd, 2022.

2:08:01The amendment adds a definition of retail price as the then current price of a good offered to a consumer before any loyalty or membership pricing, promotions, limited time sales, discounts, and fees for premiums or added additional features are applied, and reletters the definition that reletters the definitions that follow.

2:08:23Revises two exemptions to cover discounts offered to a consumer rather than discounts available to all.

2:08:29Consumers, and it shortens the preemption provisions so that the chapter may be superseded upon the effective date of any conflicting law passed by the state of Oregon.

2:08:39The full impact statement on this item includes financial and budgetary impacts, community impacts and community involvement, and economic and real estate development impacts.

2:08:49One person provided verbal testimony at the committee meeting on September 22nd, 2026.

2:08:54No written testimony was submitted prior to the committee The general themes of testimony was just appreciation for the council's attention to the topic of dynamic pricing.

2:09:03And that concludes the committee staff summary.

Jamie Dunphy 2:09:06 - 2:09:16

2:09:06Thank you very much, Kevin.

2:09:07Um, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, who I'm suddenly not seeing on my screen— this came out of the City Life Committee.

2:09:13I'm seeing if she is available for any opening remarks.

Eric Zimmerman 2:09:16 - 2:09:18

2:09:16She lost some connection where she's at.

Jamie Dunphy 2:09:19 - 2:09:46

2:09:19Okay.

2:09:20Uh, well then, I— if she hops back on, we'll Great.

2:09:23But Councilor Zimmerman, I'll turn this over to you.

2:09:24I just wanted to, before we verified, um, originally we had heard that there was a request to push this item for a vote in January, uh, but since January was past the 90-day timeline to schedule, uh, bringing this item forward today and after public testimony, my intention was to postpone to a later time so that the next council president can schedule it in January.

2:09:44Is that—.

2:09:44Is my understanding correct at this point?

Eric Zimmerman 2:09:47 - 2:10:18

2:09:47Yes, Council President, thank you for that.

2:09:49Um, as the vice chair of that, I think the Staff did a great summary, and I appreciate you working with us.

2:09:56My only intention today was to meet your, your intent, as well as given that there was some discussion about a future amendment, I wanted to inform my colleagues that we have posted a Zimmerman amendment that you will see.

2:10:08I hope that you all review that, and I would move, uh, Council President, to the public testimony, and then postponing this to the first month of the 2027 year would be a great plan.

2:10:18Thank you.

2:10:18Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:10:19 - 2:10:23

2:10:19Absolutely.

2:10:19Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2:10:21So, Keelan, with that, can we please call public testimony?

Keelan McClymont 2:10:25 - 2:10:34

2:10:25We have one person signed up, Dixon M. I don't believe they've joined us.

2:10:33That completes testimony.

Jamie Dunphy 2:10:35 - 2:10:51

2:10:35Okay, colleagues, as mentioned, it is my intention to move this to January, as Councilor Zimmerman and I discussed.

2:10:45Without objection, I will motion to postpone this to a later— oh, Councilor Morillo.

2:10:51Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:10:51 - 2:10:51

2:10:51Thank you.

Angelita Morillo 2:10:53 - 2:12:56

2:10:53I appreciate the work that's done on the amendments to update this because we had a pretty robust committee— or, well, we didn't get a chance to have a really robust committee discussion, and this is a pretty complicated topic.

2:11:07And we only had 2 people signed up for testimony last time.

2:11:10It was the person who's the lobbyist for the grocers and then a union that backs this.

2:11:16And I think that it's important for us to have more community engagement and to go through this because it's really complicated.

2:11:23So I appreciate the amendment that was brought forward.

2:11:26I think Zimmerman 2 addresses part of what I tried to bring in committee in September.

2:11:32It brings discounts and fees inside the ban, and I support that direction.

2:11:36But it's a very different ordinance than the one that came out of committee.

2:11:40Committee heard testimony on a text its sponsor said doesn't regulate discounts, and this one does.

2:11:46And the public hasn't spoken on it on the record, and we haven't had a lot of opportunity to review and consider all of the implications of this.

2:11:54And, and this is part of why I said that we needed to discuss this in committee.

2:11:58And the text still has a lot of gaps, even if this amendment does go through.

2:12:01Councilmember Smith, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry.

2:12:03The new rule that a discount has to be the same for everyone in the program only applies to loyalty programs.

2:12:09It doesn't apply to coupons, sales, or senior and veteran discounts.

2:12:13So a store could still send every shopper a coupon and let its software determine that one person's worth is $2 and the next person's is 50 cents.

2:12:22So I guess what I'm saying here is there is a lot to dig into.

2:12:26Even with what I think are some improvements in this amendment, there are still big gaps.

2:12:29Thank you.

2:12:29Gaps.

2:12:30And when there is such a substantive change, I, I would actually move that this go back to the committee for further discussion and work, because committees are supposed to be where we have this type of intensive discussion.

2:12:43And then, you know, we go through that process and we pass it.

2:12:46I do want to pass this.

2:12:47I'm excited about it.

2:12:49But this— nothing is lost by doing this, taking a little bit more time in committee since the effective date is going to be in July of next year.

2:12:56Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:12:57 - 2:13:04

2:12:57And Councilor Murillo, is that a formal movement, or is, uh, to, to refer this?

Angelita Morillo 2:13:05 - 2:13:06

2:13:05Uh, yes.

Jamie Dunphy 2:13:07 - 2:13:12

2:13:07Okay, so Councilor Murillo has moved to refer this item back to committee.

2:13:12Is there a second?

Candace Avalos 2:13:17 - 2:13:19

2:13:17Second.

Jamie Dunphy 2:13:19 - 2:13:33

2:13:19Councilor Avalos has seconded.

2:13:20Colleagues, we're now in discussion of the motion to move it And very quickly, checking with my council clerk and city attorneys, is the motion to refer to committee a debatable motion?

2:13:32I believe it is.

Donnie Oliveira 2:13:35 - 2:13:40

2:13:35It is debatable to the extent of which committee.

Unidentified speaker 2:13:40 - 2:13:40

2:13:40Yeah.

Jamie Dunphy 2:13:41 - 2:13:42

2:13:41Thank you.

2:13:42Councilor Zimmerman.

Eric Zimmerman 2:13:46 - 2:14:22

2:13:46Thank you.

2:13:47Well, I missed some of that.

2:13:49My computer logged me off quickly, but I'm back on.

2:13:53The crux of what I think I understand is that the councilor is moving to have it go to committee for more work.

2:14:00I would encourage not to do that.

2:14:02I think that we have an amendment put forward that I've asked you all to review.

2:14:07I think that this could pass today, frankly, but I also think that this is an important enough ordinance that doing it virtually is not optimal.

2:14:16And so I don't know that that reason is a reason to go to committee, so I'd encourage it.

Jamie Dunphy 2:14:23 - 2:14:23

2:14:23Let's just—.

Eric Zimmerman 2:14:24 - 2:14:38

2:14:24I think the council president and I have put together a plan that gets this forward, and I think that folks are looking forward to that.

2:14:29Um, and, um, yeah, I'll leave it there.

2:14:35So I appreciate the respect to keep it here.

2:14:37Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:14:38 - 2:14:40

2:14:38Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2:14:40Councilor Knell.

Sameer Kanal 2:14:41 - 2:14:44

2:14:41I just have a question.

2:14:42Which committee is the proposal to go to?

Angelita Morillo 2:14:47 - 2:14:47

2:14:47May I answer?

Jamie Dunphy 2:14:48 - 2:14:48

2:14:48Yes, please.

Angelita Morillo 2:14:50 - 2:16:05

2:14:50I am recommending it go back to the City Life Committee so that we can dig into some of these, you know, policy gaps that there are.

2:14:57Even with the amendment that's brought forward that I do think is an improvement, there are still a lot of gaps.

2:15:02The amendment was also sent to us right now, right before this meeting.

2:15:06So I haven't had time to dig into that language in depth.

2:15:10And again, you guys know I hate price fixing and I hate AI.

2:15:14So this is something I really care about, but it's complicated.

2:15:19And the state also has a really robust process that they're bringing forward.

2:15:24This is usually enforced at the state level.

2:15:27And this is a very substantive, or should be a very substantive amendment.

2:15:32So when I was in committee and I brought forward some of these changes, I don't want to speak for Councilor Pirtle-Guiney while she's out, but I don't really have I don't have a choice.

2:15:41It was— I was told that some of the things, the gaps that I was trying to address are a whole separate ordinance and we don't have to address it in this one.

2:15:49But we can clearly address it all at once.

2:15:50It doesn't make sense to not do that.

2:15:52So I would recommend sending it back to City Life or to Committee of the Whole because it is such a complicated topic area that if it would benefit for people to all hear some of the substance here, I think that's fine as well.

2:16:04But this is a committee discussion.

Candace Avalos 2:16:05 - 2:16:05

2:16:05Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:16:07 - 2:16:17

2:16:07And Councilor, for the purposes of, uh, helping our, our council clerk and such understand what— uh, we do need to identify one committee.

2:16:14So would you prefer it Committee of the Whole or City Life for your motion?

Angelita Morillo 2:16:18 - 2:16:29

2:16:18You know what, I'm sorry, after talking about this out loud, I would say let's do Committee of the Whole because there is so much complexity to, uh, surveillance pricing and AI policies, and I think that would be a good place to have it discussed.

Jamie Dunphy 2:16:30 - 2:17:27

2:16:30Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

2:16:31Okay, so the motion on the table is To refer this to the Committee of the Whole.

2:16:36It was moved by Councilor Murillo and seconded by Councilor Avalos.

2:16:41I will note, uh, Councilor Murillo as well, uh, having worked with Councilor Zimmerman on the plan to bring this back in January, I additionally have some amendments depending on how the conversation goes.

2:16:51And so I was— I am not on those committees, and so I would want to be on the Committee of the Whole, but not on the City Life Committee.

2:16:59Um, But would, you know, depending on how that conversation goes, additionally want to be able to bring an amendment to this.

2:17:07And I agree with Councilor Zimmerman that trying to do this in a digital, in a virtual format is cumbersome.

2:17:12So if this is not brought to the Committee of the Whole, I will, you know, to the extent possible as council president, ensure that this conversation happens in January, and I'll work with the next council president to ensure that happens promptly.

2:17:24Thank you.

2:17:26Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 2:17:31 - 2:18:28

2:17:31Yeah, thank you.

2:17:32I— sorry, I, uh, I want to be super, um, clear just so that there's clear expectations.

2:17:40Speaking as a chair of the committee, if it's referred to me, I don't know when we'd have time.

2:17:45Um, I don't want to overpromise on that.

2:17:48Um, I do try to prioritize councilor legislation wherever I can.

2:17:52I just We've been making some commitments, and I've been asking for a few weeks now if anyone had anything coming to committee of the whole, and nobody did at the time.

2:18:00Obviously, that's not the sponsor's fault on this one if it ends up getting referred.

2:18:04So it may end up being a relatively moot point on the timing and more of a relevant point on who's, you know, whether it's the committee or the council discussing, just in case anyone was curious there.

2:18:17I haven't had a chance to check my notes and give you a more specific timeframe than that.

2:18:21I know that's not super helpful, but I didn't want people to think Thanks.

Jamie Dunphy 2:18:28 - 2:18:30

2:18:28Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

2:18:29Councilor Koyama Lane.

Keelan McClymont 2:18:32 - 2:18:32

2:18:32Thank you.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:18:32 - 2:19:45

2:18:32I'm trying to figure out, um, what place this is in and if there is a majority of council that feels like it has been worked on enough.

2:18:42I'm hearing different people wanting to bring amendments, and so I'm wondering if this were to stay at full council, is it going to get that 7/3 vote?

2:18:52I know my team flagged that they're glad to see the amendment brought by Councilor Zimmerman, and it addresses some of the concerns, but there are still some concerns around electronic price tickets specifically.

2:19:07And so I guess my question, if that's— if it's okay, is for Councilor Zimmerman.

2:19:12This amendment that you're bringing, is this kind of it?

2:19:16Is that where, as far as you want to go in terms of bringing amendments?

2:19:20Are you open to I'm open to between now and a future council meeting when this is scheduled, working with some other colleagues to make, you know, ahead of time on some other amendments where you can feel good about them.

2:19:35And, or, yeah, can I ask Councilor Zimmerman if he is open to that, to more amendments, to doing some of the workshopping behind the scenes before it comes to full council?

Eric Zimmerman 2:19:46 - 2:19:46

2:19:46Yes.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:19:46 - 2:19:55

2:19:46And also, I do recognize that Committee of the Whole is really packed, and so I I am a bit worried that we send it there and then this takes a long time.

Eric Zimmerman 2:19:59 - 2:23:39

2:19:59Thank you.

2:20:02You know, in committee we got an amendment that was brought during committee by another councilor.

2:20:07It was a significant rewrite of quite a lot actually, which I'll just say personally it didn't land well, right?

2:20:16Because when you see your amendment get essentially rewritten, right, paragraphs upon paragraphs, pages upon pages, So that took a little bit of kind of relaxing once it left committee and digging into the intent there and what we read.

2:20:30And I will say that my office has a more straightforward way of writing ordinances in terms of just like we use more specific or we use more pointed language.

2:20:45We don't try to address every every single scenario that could exist, and that's a very different way of writing ordinances.

2:20:52And so you see that style come out.

2:20:55But we pared down what I think were areas where we had shared concerns and, and, you know, notable learning from the amendment that was proposed and worked with our legal counsel to bring that into, I think, a more clear way of saying it within the same style.

2:21:13In my And you see that reflected in the amendment that I brought forward today.

2:21:18I just want to note, I brought that— I made that aware for you all so that you would have time to look at it, noting what the council president and I said is that probably wouldn't come back until January.

2:21:29And I think that that addresses the concerns that I see.

2:21:34Councilor Koyama Lane, um, I I am unaware of a lot of other ordinances, right?

2:21:42So hearing from Council President that he maybe has ones, like, I'm open to that.

2:21:47And I think that if we're talking about, um, the normal course of ordinance or normal course of amendments, that seems like something we do in council a lot when we have ordinances come forward.

2:21:59So I'm not sure why we'd have to go back to committee for that.

2:22:03I am motivated by our timeline.

2:22:04I think the state is motivated for the city of Portland to take an action before they enter into session because they are very much trying to see what we can achieve so that they can model a good plan and not— I'm a little afraid that this will all fall apart at the state, frankly.

2:22:20And so we've seen that happen before.

2:22:22I think that we can set an important tone.

2:22:26This got delayed significantly this summer, which was unfortunate, and we're hitting now another delay.

2:22:31So So I would ask— I think it's appropriate that if a person has an amendment that it's debatable and we can bring it forward in the regular course of action at the council meeting.

2:22:43I don't think we need to go back to committee.

2:22:46I appreciate your honesty, Councilor Kanal, about when it could be or couldn't be scheduled.

2:22:50I do understand that, so thank you for that.

2:22:53So I'm feeling a little bit bamboozled here.

2:22:58All right, I kind of— we could have just had this hearing and we could go through a first hearing.

2:23:02And frankly, I think I got the votes.

2:23:06So I'd say please don't vote to move this to committee.

2:23:09Please do what Council President and I have asked you to do.

2:23:12I appreciate the input, but a wholesale rewrite to try and go after, you know, some of the things we've seen in other cities is not really the vibe I'm going for here.

2:23:23I'm trying to find something that is workable and keeps this Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

Jamie Dunphy 2:23:39 - 2:23:42

2:23:39Councilor Avalos.

Candace Avalos 2:23:42 - 2:27:13

2:23:42Yeah, thank you.

2:23:43Um, so I seconded this motion and just wanted to talk about what happened in committee.

2:23:48Um, so yeah, there was a substantial amount of discussion about this ordinance.

2:23:51I read the actual amendment that was proposed, and it raised a lot of questions and concerns that I had.

2:23:57So one, just grateful to Councilor Morillo for putting in the time to provide some, some changes that I think would address the privacy concerns that I have, especially as it relates to the broader conversations we're having at the city about AI.

2:24:11And so I see the intent about moving it to Committee of the Whole with the notion that it would help inform broader broader data privacy discussions as an important one.

2:24:21I'm listening for like timeline restraints and things.

2:24:24I mean, I guess, uh, you know, I understand and can, you know, empathize with frustration of, you know, someone feeling like your policy is taking a while.

2:24:33Um, and I, I feel that, you know, I'm trying to— I was listening for what you were saying about the state, and I guess I just don't know enough about what the state is doing to know how that impacts this legislation.

2:24:43So I'm— I don't, I don't have an opinion on that.

2:24:45Um, but it sounds like the this policy wouldn't go into effect until July, and so there is a little bit more time that we have to workshop some of the details.

2:24:56Ultimately, you know, I voted it out of committee, but I expressed my concern on the record that I felt like I wish we had more time to discuss the amendment that was proposed.

2:25:06I think it's one thing to be like you're holding it back just because you want to hold it back and you don't actually have a proposal.

2:25:12I think that's That's not what happened, right?

2:25:14I've definitely been in scenarios where people are like, we want to hold it for some unknown reason.

2:25:19But there was a very clear reason why we wanted to have a discussion, and that reason was in the very intricate amendment that Councilor Morillo proposed.

2:25:27So I see that as different.

2:25:29I don't see that as like a way to, you know, propose to stall something for no reason.

2:25:33I thought that there was a clear one.

2:25:34So that's why I voted to support this motion.

2:25:38Thank you.

2:25:38You know, I think that it is worth, especially hearing that their councilor— Council President Dunphy might have some amendments.

2:25:47It's something, you know, I'm glad, one, that we're not doing it today because I've got some thoughts and amendments I just haven't had time to put together.

2:25:53So I was glad to hear that it was getting pushed and we weren't going to actually be discussing today.

2:25:58But then seeing the amendment that came in, seeing that that was responsive to Councilor Murillo's concerns, now I have more questions, right?

2:26:04Because I'm like, okay, now I got to parse through both of those, is that something that is meeting the needs that I had in the committee?

2:26:10And if other councilors are considering amendments, then I think it sounds like there's some workshoppable time that could be worth getting it right.

2:26:18So that's why I'm supporting this.

2:26:20I think that the intent is, you know, and you heard from Councilor Morillo, she obviously cares about this.

2:26:24I also care about this policy, and I want to see this passed because it will definitely help for my constituents.

2:26:31Thank you.

2:26:32I'm just trying to help facilitate the— I guess trying to help with this standard setting that we keep having around, like, how we work through policy, where they happen, if it's in committee.

2:26:46And everybody can reasonably disagree on timing.

2:26:49I'm gonna agree with Councilor Murillo's assessment, and that's why I supported it and plan to vote to move it back.

2:26:54But regardless of what happens with the vote, I hope it's clear that there are intentions from many councilors to look at this policy more clearly.

2:27:02And I, I hope that that, regardless of the next step, is getting built into the timing of this.

2:27:07And so I don't want to rush something like this that would have big implications.

2:27:11Um, so yeah, that's, that's my 2 cents.

2:27:13Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:27:14 - 2:27:16

2:27:14Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

2:27:15Councilor Morillo.

Angelita Morillo 2:27:17 - 2:29:46

2:27:17Yeah, thank you.

2:27:18Um, I would just say that I, um, we do have different styles of writing policy, and I think that the May not be captured by the language that's put forward.

2:27:30Sorry, my cat will not leave me alone this morning.

2:27:33He's like, she's finally done campaigning, I can talk to her again.

2:27:37But I think that with— I think that the committee would be the place to discuss if the updated language meets the intent.

2:27:47And I don't think that it fully captures the intent that we are trying to convey.

2:27:50Councilor Smith, I think that's a fair point.

2:27:51Trying to impact here.

2:27:53So I will also say the state has actually asked that we not be involved.

2:28:00They have a pretty robust process and they have a bunch of, you know, they have a pretty large convening.

2:28:07So we are, we can do that at the local level, but even the lobbyist for the grocers said that they would prefer the state process.

2:28:15So it's not a wholesale rewrite.

2:28:19Right.

2:28:20Zimmerman 2 in the amendment itself is a very substantive amendment, and it partially addresses what I brought forward.

2:28:28But it's, it's our amendment.

2:28:30It's my amendment, but just incomplete.

2:28:32And so it doesn't solve the issue that it purports to solve, and that's the problem here.

2:28:39So the intent was not captured ultimately, and.

2:28:43Councilmember Smith, I'm sorry.

2:28:44I think that this needs to be discussed more thoroughly.

2:28:48It was voted out of committee pretty quickly.

2:28:51That's why it's being amended here now, because it, it has some big changes that need to be made.

2:28:57And it sounds like for if it goes to Committee of the Whole, it would be around the same timeline as bringing it back to council, right?

2:29:05It would be sometime next year in January.

2:29:08So it's the same timeline either way.

2:29:12But I think that if we have this discussion at council, Yes.

2:29:14We're going to have a bunch of councilors bringing forward a bunch of different amendments rather than having a place to discuss it, distill it down, bring like one or two that actually capture the stuff that we're trying to do and get it over with in a more comprehensive way.

2:29:31And I think that Zimmerman 2 as an amendment is a reflection of the fact that the intent was not captured, right?

2:29:37So I just think that this needs more work.

2:29:39I think it's a good policy.

2:29:41I'm excited about it, and it just needs a little bit more work.

2:29:42Thank you.

2:29:43Bit more work, that's all.

2:29:44But I, I've said my piece, so I will be done now.

Jamie Dunphy 2:29:47 - 2:29:52

2:29:47Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

2:29:48Colleagues, I am limiting debate to those in the queue, uh, to the motion.

2:29:51Councilor Kanal, then Councilor Smith.

Sameer Kanal 2:29:55 - 2:30:34

2:29:55I guess I'll ask 2 questions.

2:29:57One, does anybody know what the, the information I gave, if it goes to Committee of the Whole, does anybody know the similar conversation if it were to be referred to City Life?

2:30:06And the second question I, I had, so So in the event that we were— that we would— in the event that this motion fails and we keep discussing it, I doubt we're going to be closing the first reading today.

2:30:23So what's the situation in terms of our ability to get more public input into this?

2:30:28Has sign-up— has the oral testimony sign-up closed?

Keelan McClymont 2:30:34 - 2:30:34

2:30:34Yes.

Jamie Dunphy 2:30:36 - 2:31:02

2:30:36Um, my intention, uh, Councilor, uh, as discussed with Councilor Zimmerman, was to continue this.

2:30:41That would be a continued first reading, but we would continue it to a future January date.

2:30:45And I'm not at this time, uh, able to set a time certain because I don't want to tie the hands of the next council president.

2:30:52But my intention would be to work with the council, uh, next council president on an additional first reading, uh, to give space for that amendment discussion at the full council in January.

Angelita Morillo 2:31:02 - 2:31:02

2:31:02Thank you.

Sameer Kanal 2:31:03 - 2:31:08

2:31:03And would— could somebody in the public still sign up to testify if it remained at full council?

Jamie Dunphy 2:31:09 - 2:31:09

2:31:09Yes.

Sameer Kanal 2:31:10 - 2:32:12

2:31:10Okay, that's helpful for me.

2:31:12I don't care either way about the state question personally.

2:31:16I think it might matter to other folks, and I respect that if it does matter to you.

2:31:21I think this is really interesting, especially given how much we're talking about Waymo and some of the other things where there's preemption versus is it better for us to do a thing and then the state model it after us?

2:31:30I would love it if the state modeled their autonomous vehicle proposal after whatever we end up coming up with in Portland.

2:31:36So it may end up being good or bad that way.

2:31:38I don't know.

2:31:39And it's hard to predict.

2:31:41There's a bunch of legislators that are probably not even done partying yet because they just got elected, or legislators-elect at this moment.

2:31:48So I— that's not a concern to me either, in either direction.

2:31:52I am interested in this conversation.

2:31:55I just want to understand sort of what the, the impacts are because of potentially referring it to the other committee that was brought up as well.

2:32:06I know that that's not the motion here, Council President.

2:32:07I'm just trying to understand to be able to evaluate if I should vote yes or no on this.

2:32:11So thanks.

Jamie Dunphy 2:32:13 - 2:32:22

2:32:13Thank you.

2:32:13And I will, uh, I said I was going to limit debate, uh, to those in the queue, but Councilor Pirtle-Guiney has rejoined us, and so I will now limit it.

2:32:20Uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney will be the last, uh, in this.

Loretta Smith 2:32:23 - 2:32:42

2:32:23Councilor Smith, followed by Koyama Lane, and then Councilor, um, Council President Dunphy, you had said that you were going to close after me, and so I, I will go ahead with calling the question on this particular amendment right now.

Jamie Dunphy 2:32:43 - 2:32:44

2:32:43Okay.

Candace Avalos 2:32:44 - 2:32:46

2:32:44We're not in an amendment, are we?

Jamie Dunphy 2:32:47 - 2:33:09

2:32:47Uh, we, we are, uh, we are in a motion to, to To refer to committee, right?

2:32:57I'd love to be able to give Councilor Koyama Lane an opportunity, and I want to be able to hear Councilor Pirtle-Guiney specifically because she's rejoining us, and this came out of the City Life Committee originally, and Councilor Connell had a specific question about that.

Loretta Smith 2:33:09 - 2:33:14

2:33:09Councilor Dunphy, can I call the question?

Eric Zimmerman 2:33:15 - 2:33:15

2:33:15The call—.

Jamie Dunphy 2:33:15 - 2:33:32

2:33:15The motion to call a question requires a second and then an additional vote on the decision to call the question, followed by the actual vote.

2:33:21It'd be a series of Multiple votes.

2:33:24But if we can wait until Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, I will move us to a vote after that.

2:33:30Okay, Councilor Clameling.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:33:34 - 2:34:13

2:33:34I think this topic is really important.

2:33:36I want us to get this right.

2:33:38I don't have very strong feelings about where more of the work happens, if it's at a committee or if it is with a smaller group of councilors.

2:33:47Um, I might be reading the tea leaves a little differently than So I am fine with this staying at council, but I do think that means that more work might need to happen to make sure that people— some people are brought along and there are amendments that, um, that solve for some of the concerns.

2:34:12Um, I'll leave it at that.

Jamie Dunphy 2:34:14 - 2:34:17

2:34:14Thank you, Councilor.

2:34:14Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, you have the floor.

2:34:16Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, last word.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:34:17 - 2:35:17

2:34:17I am in the queue solely to answer Councilor Kanal's question.

2:34:21Um, I would have to look at our agendas.

2:34:24I know we did have a little bit of space left in the City Life December meeting.

2:34:29However, we moved a couple of things around, so that space may be taken now.

2:34:34Um, but knowing that, uh, none of us know what committee leadership will look like next year, I have items to be scheduled for next year, but not, um, not an agenda yet.

2:34:49I certainly would put this on that list of priority items for either me or somebody else to schedule the beginning of next year, uh, if it were referred back to City Life.

2:34:59I think it's really important that we move this, um, quickly before stores start adopting the technologies that we're talking about prohibiting.

2:35:09We know that there are stores that are already adopting them.

2:35:10Thank you.

2:35:14Um, so just wanted to, to direct respond there.

2:35:17Thanks so much.

Jamie Dunphy 2:35:19 - 2:35:31

2:35:19Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2:35:22Keelan, can we please call the roll on, uh, Murillo's motion to refer to the Committee of the Whole?

2:35:30Moved by Murillo, seconded by Avalos.

Keelan McClymont 2:35:32 - 2:35:34

2:35:32Yes.

2:35:33Thank you.

2:35:33Clerk?

Angelita Morillo 2:35:34 - 2:35:35

2:35:34No.

Keelan McClymont 2:35:35 - 2:35:36

2:35:35Green?

Candace Avalos 2:35:37 - 2:35:37

2:35:37Aye.

Eric Zimmerman 2:35:39 - 2:35:39

2:35:39No.

Candace Avalos 2:35:41 - 2:35:44

2:35:41Aye.

2:35:44No.

Raymond C. Lee 2:35:47 - 2:35:48

2:35:47No.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:35:49 - 2:35:51

2:35:49No.

Jamie Dunphy 2:35:52 - 2:35:53

2:35:52No.

Loretta Smith 2:35:55 - 2:35:55

2:35:55No.

Angelita Morillo 2:35:57 - 2:35:57

2:35:57Aye.

Keelan McClymont 2:35:58 - 2:35:59

2:35:58No.

Jamie Dunphy 2:35:59 - 2:35:59

2:35:59No.

Keelan McClymont 2:36:03 - 2:36:09

2:36:03Uh, the motion to refer the item has failed with a vote of 3 ayes and 9 nays.

Jamie Dunphy 2:36:09 - 2:36:19

2:36:09Thank you, colleagues.

2:36:10Without objection, I'm going to postpone this item to a further first reading, and we'll work with the next council president to get it scheduled promptly.

2:36:18Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

Eric Zimmerman 2:36:20 - 2:36:21

2:36:20Thank you, Council President.

Jamie Dunphy 2:36:21 - 2:36:23

2:36:21Keelan, can we please move to the next item?

Keelan McClymont 2:36:27 - 2:36:46

2:36:27Yes, we, uh, item 11.

2:36:31Document 2026-387, amend vehicles and traffic code to clarify Bureau of Transportation authority and allow flexibility, replace code section 16.10.080, and amend chapter 16.90.

Jamie Dunphy 2:36:46 - 2:36:56

2:36:46Thank you very much, colleagues.

2:36:47This is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

2:36:50Uh, I believe— is Claire Adamsick going to be here with Council Operations to give us a staff summary report?

2:36:55All right, Claire, take it away.

Angelita Morillo 2:36:57 - 2:38:17

2:36:57Hi, Council President.

2:36:58Thank you.

2:36:58Council President and councilors, for the record, Claire Adamsick, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Public Works Committee.

2:37:04The ordinance before you, document number 2026-387, was heard in the Public Works Committee on October 27th, where it was referred to full council with a recommendation to pass.

2:37:14The ordinance replaces Portland City Code Section 16.10.080, Altering or Erecting Traffic Control Devices, to allow the city administrator to authorize property owners or a representative to paint a driveway clearance upon receipt of a signed application and fee payment as shown in Exhibit A of the ordinance.

2:37:34The ordinance also amends Code Chapter 16.90 by adding definitions for driveway clearance and driveway key as shown in Exhibit B. Driveway clearance is defined as the area in the street directly adjacent to the end of a driveway wing or wings, identified by a painted yellow portion of the driveway key is defined as the space extending from the curb line into the roadway designed to allow additional clearance for a vehicle to access a driveway.

2:38:07The full impact statement on this item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts and community impacts and community involvement.

2:38:14No verbal or written testimony was submitted on this item prior to committee approval.

Unidentified speaker 2:38:17 - 2:38:17

2:38:17Thank you, Deputy City Administrator.

Jamie Dunphy 2:38:20 - 2:38:26

2:38:20Thank you very much, Claire.

2:38:22Vice President Clark, this came out of the Public Works Committee.

2:38:24Any opening committee chair remarks?

Loretta Smith 2:38:27 - 2:38:40

2:38:27Thank you, Council President.

2:38:28I am so excited about this, and you should be too.

2:38:32This is actually going to make a more affordable sort of self-serve process for folks who want to protect their driveways.

Candace Avalos 2:38:41 - 2:38:43

2:38:41I know I'm a major violator of encroachment.

Loretta Smith 2:38:44 - 2:38:51

2:38:44This will affect me and many other people, but I think it's a great solution.

Candace Avalos 2:38:51 - 2:39:11

2:38:51It's also a safety issue, and I'm hoping that we can build on this in the future and create other self-serve sorts of processes that involve public safety as well.

2:39:05So as Claire said, it came out of the committee with a 4-1 vote, one person absent.

Loretta Smith 2:39:11 - 2:39:12

2:39:11So I would really encourage my colleagues to support this ordinance.

Candace Avalos 2:39:12 - 2:39:12

2:39:12Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:39:14 - 2:39:24

2:39:14Thank you very much, Vice President Clark.

2:39:19Um, colleagues, before we move to technical and clarifying questions, I just want to verify, Keelan, do we have anyone signed up for public testimony?

Keelan McClymont 2:39:25 - 2:39:25

2:39:25No one signed up.

Sameer Kanal 2:39:26 - 2:39:26

2:39:26Great.

Jamie Dunphy 2:39:26 - 2:39:46

2:39:26Colleagues, we are now in clarifying and technical discussions as well as council discussion.

2:39:32So, uh, feel free to jump in the queue if you have any.

2:39:36Thank you very much.

2:39:36Uh, Councilor Smith, you have 2 minutes.

2:39:38Councilor Smith, is that you?

2:39:45Oh, thank you.

2:39:45Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 2:39:47 - 2:40:47

2:39:47Yeah, I'll start with good bill should pass, but I'll add that I think that one of the conversations that I thought was really meaningful in committee is that this is a good starting point for going further, and that I want to be transparent about that fact that We have folks who are able, willing, and really organized in some cases to get involved in helping out in the city, and that helping to reduce the barriers to their involvement is really helpful.

2:40:22I also was really happy to hear PBOT and I guess Public Works broadly and their approach to how this would work.

2:40:30So I'm grateful for this, and I think that it doesn't take a whole lot of conversation on it other than what, you know, understanding what it is and what it does.

2:40:38There doesn't seem to be a ton of debate that happened in committee, and maybe there will be here, but I do want to keep that momentum going, and I wanted to at least give voice to that here.

2:40:47Thanks.

Jamie Dunphy 2:40:48 - 2:40:50

2:40:48Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

2:40:49Councilor Green.

Mitch Green 2:40:52 - 2:41:21

2:40:52Yeah, I was really excited.

2:40:54I think the whole committee was really excited about this.

2:40:56This was a really good example of the kind of stuff that's the kind of stuff that I think Portlanders are yearning for, just these little small things that I, I think, um, the city— it's, it's hard to imagine the impact that this would have on everyday people's lives in a very meaningful way.

2:41:13And so, uh, thanks for bringing it forward.

2:41:15Thanks, uh, Chair Clark, for, for hearing it.

2:41:18Um, uh, let's see more of it.

Dan Ryan 2:41:22 - 2:41:22

2:41:22Thanks.

Jamie Dunphy 2:41:23 - 2:41:25

2:41:23Thank you, Councilor Green.

2:41:24Councilor Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 2:41:26 - 2:41:52

2:41:26Thank you.

2:41:27Thank you so much, Chair Clark, for bringing this forward.

2:41:30This is a really practical change to our code that empowers Portlanders to take on work that they can accomplish, that improves our neighborhoods, and also builds trust between community and the city.

2:41:43And I just also want to shout out PBOT.

2:41:45Thank you for working with my office and many other offices to figure out how we can be empowering community to do some of these things.

2:41:51Councilor Smith.

2:41:51Stuff like this.

Jamie Dunphy 2:41:53 - 2:42:14

2:41:53Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

2:41:56Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, this item now passes to 2nd reading.

2:42:02And with that, we have completed our agenda.

2:42:04We are adjourned.

2:42:06With— I will recess us until 2 o'clock tomorrow, Thursday, November 5th.

2:42:12With that, we are adjourned.

2:42:14Thank you all.

Candace Avalos 2:42:15 - 2:42:15

2:42:15Thank you.