windowbox

City Life Committee Meeting

Official agenda

Transcript

Transcript

Automatically generated transcript. It may contain errors and includes testimony in languages other than English that is not individually marked up for assistive technology.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 7:13 - 7:25

7:13Good afternoon.

7:15It is Tuesday, November 10th at 2:02 PM.

7:18I am calling to order today's City Life Committee meeting.

7:24Uh, Wendy, could you please take the roll?

Unidentified speaker 7:27 - 7:32

7:27Zimmerman.

7:30Avalos.

7:32Ryan.

Candace Avalos 7:33 - 7:33

7:33Here.

Unidentified speaker 7:34 - 7:34

7:34Morillo.

Angelita Morillo 7:36 - 7:40

7:36Here, virtually.

7:39Pirtle-Guiney.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 7:40 - 7:46

7:40Here.

7:42And Kevin, could you please read us the rules of decorum?

Kevin 7:47 - 8:59

7:47Welcome to the meeting of the City Life Committee.

7:49To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/city-life-committee or by calling 311.

8:04Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

8:07Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

8:11In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

8:14If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify Yes.

8:18You may now testify for 3 minutes unless the Chair states otherwise.

8:20Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

8:23The Chair preserves order.

8:24Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

8:33If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

8:36Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

8:39Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

8:43Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

8:47Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

8:49When testifying, state your name for the record.

8:52If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

8:55Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

8:59Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 9:01 - 10:01

9:01Thank you.

9:02And colleagues, we have a couple of items on the agenda, but 2 main topics we will be talking about today.

9:07We will start with general input on City Life Committee topics, as we always do.

9:13We will hear an overview of our city's cannabis program, including hearing from some practitioners within our community who are working within that industry.

9:25We will then hear from the administration about some updates to the code regulating the city's marijuana licensing program.

9:33And then after, we may take a break somewhere during that last portion, and then we will and our meeting with an update on the workforce and contractor equity provisions within the Portland Clean Energy Fund and some updates that we need to make to that program.

9:54So Wendy, could you start us out by calling the first item and then calling up our first testifiers on our City Life Committee topics?

Unidentified speaker 10:03 - 10:31

10:03Yes, thank you.

10:04Item number 1, document number 2026-404, public input on City Life Committee topics.

10:11We have 2 or 3 people signed up for this.

10:14I'll call, uh, Galib Bin Imhotep El, Bret Born, and we also have Tyler Fellini signed up.

10:26I'm not sure, Tyler, if you want to speak to this item or the other one.

10:31Okay, why not?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 10:35 - 10:43

10:35Thank you so much.

10:43Go right ahead.

Galib Bin Imhotep El 10:44 - 13:23

10:44Okay, greetings committee members, beloved committee members.

10:49Um, last meeting I was here 2 weeks ago Tuesday, it was a bit of a fiasco.

10:54Somehow I ended up in a cameo appearance because of a troll, and I think the whole thing went viral.

11:01Guy danced on the table.

11:03Not necessarily something that I prefer to be associated with, but when you put yourself before the public with all of its vainglorious foibles, anything can happen.

11:14Prior to the adjournment of that meeting, Councilor Pertolini, you brought up a topic that piqued my interest.

11:21As an avid marijuana user and promoter of its usage in the stead of alcohol, I take keen interest City Life Committee topics and the agenda.

11:32So I took the time that I generally would not in order to, you know, give this agenda a little more thorough inspection.

11:40And there it was, PSEF, sitting at the back end of today's agenda.

11:47I was unable to actually submit a testimony for that item.

11:51I have so many pressing matters to attend to, my plate's kind of full.

11:58But from what I read, I grew a little concerned.

12:03The Portland Clean Energy Fund is exactly that.

12:07It's a fund created for the purpose of utilizing only clean, sustainable energy sources that minimize and reduce or completely eliminate environmental pollution.

12:20My concern and what I read, not a single thing that I read in that material that I perused spoke about clean energy.

12:30The topic involved is centered around what I can best determine as an equal opportunity workforce and contractor foundation to set more robust guidelines to make it a more fair, diverse, and competitive race for PSEF funds and PSEF-funded projects.

12:46There is one simple question that I hope has been asked.

12:49If it has not, then I hope it is asked today.

12:52And if it is, I hope it has a simple answer.

12:55Yes.

12:56That question: are those projects that are receiving PSEF funds projects for construction of clean, renewable, and sustainable energy sources?

13:08Will they have a verifiable positive impact on the local ecology?

13:14Find out for your public, please.

13:17They have a right to know.

13:20Thank you, and I love you all unconditionally.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 13:25 - 13:32

13:25Thank you very much.

13:29Uh, Tyler, before we have you get started, did we have another person who had signed up?

Unidentified speaker 13:35 - 13:38

13:35Brett?

13:37Brett Born, come on up.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 13:50 - 13:52

13:50Thank you very much for being here.

13:51Go right ahead.

Bret Born 13:52 - 16:29

13:52Good afternoon, councilors.

13:55Um, I'm here today just as a public, uh, member, also a business owner within cannabis, but I just want to kind of use this opportunity, being that cannabis is in the City Life, but I want to go ahead and give a shout out to CPOT and point out a few things that have gone on over the years as a group.

14:15From '20 to 2025, if people go back and look at our policy recommendations, it's very in alignment with other economic forecasts that we've seen come through our cannabis and within Portland.

14:29That being said, when we, when we go back and look at some of our initiatives that fall around workforce development, looking at how to support businesses and all those different things, the one thing that stands out to me that I wanted to point out that shows how government works is when we were experiencing a high level of crime in our businesses and it was grossly impacting a lot of stores, Christina Corsi, she was able to get together with police officers, policymakers, city council members and assistants, industry workers.

15:07And we saw results from that big time that are measurable.

15:13And so that being said, as we move forward with CPOT, I want the city council to take a look at some of the work we've done over the years and look at where we've pointed out policy recommendations that align directly with the deterioration of our cannabis industry.

15:28Thank you.

15:29I don't know if that stuff's been read by council members when it's shared, but it's fascinating and remarkable evidence that a group that the city has put together through Civic Life originally and through the cannabis programs, comprised of a large variety of professionals, were able to parallel the recommendations that Prosper Portland paid $50,000 for.

15:54So I'm thinking moving forward, we need to be looking at that.

15:57Thank you.

15:59I think as a CPOT member, business owner, I'm desperately asking that councilors listen to people in the industry and CPOT, because I could go on for days and days and days about why our industry's struggling and policy recommendations that we can come forward with in the future.

16:15But if we don't have the support of our councilors and our city officials, I don't see the— I don't see us making the growth that we're capable of making.

16:23Thank you.

16:24I'm going to come back later after the final topic also and address the Measure 110 funds.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 16:32 - 16:34

16:32Thank you.

Robert Smith 16:40 - 17:55

16:40Good afternoon, Chair and members of the committee.

16:42My name is Tyler Fellini, and I'm the executive director of and a registered lobbyist for Portland Jobs and Justice.

16:48Generally at these, I try to be a bit more composed, but I've been in pouring rain for the last 2 days joining city workers in an avoidable strike that was— that, uh, and this, this was last minute once I had the blessing of the union.

17:00After nearly a year of bargaining, the people who run payroll, collect revenue, and keep city bureaus working have walked off the job.

17:07This is a historic strike, and it lands squarely on Mayor Wilson.

17:12If the problem is the budget, we don't buy that.

17:15This contract is in line with other union contracts that the city intends to ratify right here on Thursday, and those unions support CPPW right now.

17:22Councilmember Herbold.

17:24Every day that this goes on, Portlanders are feeling it.

17:26Services are slowing down and people are noticing.

17:29The mayor can end this and he hasn't.

17:32I'm angry and I'm not alone.

17:34Many of you consider yourselves friends of labor, and so I'm imploring you to stand up to the mayor right now.

17:40Council has the power to step in and I'm asking you to use it.

17:43Authorize the money needed to settle this contract.

17:46Publicly call on the mayor to settle.

17:49This is an emergency and it should be treated like one.

17:53Portland Jobs with Justice stands with CPPW.

Tyler Fellini 17:56 - 17:59

17:56These workers have earned a fair contract.

17:58Settle this strike.

17:59Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 18:04 - 18:08

18:04Thank you for being here today and raising that really critical issue.

Unidentified speaker 18:12 - 18:23

18:12Is there anyone else here to testify on a general matter before the committee and not one of the legislative items?

18:21Okay, that concludes public input.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 18:25 - 18:31

18:25Thank you.

18:27Uh, Wendy, could you please call the second item on our agenda?

Unidentified speaker 18:37 - 18:40

18:37Item number 2, document number 2026.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 18:40 - 18:43

18:40And I'm getting a note that we should open 2 and 3 together.

18:43Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 18:43 - 19:07

18:43Thank you.

18:44Item number— items number 2 and 3, documents number 2026-405, Overview of the City Cannabis Programs Presentation.

18:53And item number 3, document number 2026-407, Amend Marijuana Regulatory License Procedure and Requirements Code, Amend Code Chapter 14B.130.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 19:10 - 20:07

19:10Thank you.

19:12And we are going to start with a presentation from the administration about the cannabis program.

19:19We'll have an opportunity for some questions about that presentation.

19:24We will then hear a presentation from folks who work within the industry, and we will have time for more discussion and questions after that.

19:32Then we will move into a conversation specific to code changes that are before us.

19:40But let's start with bringing up the members of the administration who are here for a presentation.

19:45I believe we have Director Kutch, Christina Corsi, and Robert Smith.

20:05Thank you all for being here today with us.

Eric Kooch 20:08 - 20:14

20:08Yeah, thank you, and good afternoon.

20:11My name is Eric Kooch.

20:12I'm the Director of Portland Permitting Development.

Christina Corsi 20:16 - 20:17

20:16Cannabis and Liquor Program Manager.

Robert Smith 20:19 - 20:22

20:19Entrepreneurship and Community Economic Development Manager.

Eric Kooch 20:31 - 20:31

20:31No, you go ahead.

Christina Corsi 20:32 - 37:36

20:32Okay, good afternoon, Chair, and and members of the committee, my name is Christina Corsi and I'm the Cannabis and Liquor Program Manager with Portland Permitting and Development.

20:41I present before you today an overview of the past, present, and future of Portland cannabis.

20:46I'm joined today by Robert Smith, Entrepreneurship and Community Economic Development Manager with Prosper Portland.

20:52Also present today and available for questions if needed are representatives from the City Budget Office, City Attorney's Office, Prosper Portland, and Jeanette Ward from New Project.

21:01Thank you.

21:02Next slide, please.

21:10The presentation will cover the history of Portland's cannabis program, provide an overview of cannabis licensing and compliance, highlight the recreational cannabis tax fund, and introduce the cannabis policy oversight team.

21:22Following the presentation and a Q&A session, I will introduce the proposed cannabis program amendments to Portland City Code Chapter 14B.130.

21:32Next slide, please.

21:34And next slide.

21:37Oregon's adult use cannabis industry began in 2014 when voters approved Measure 91 with 56% support.

21:44The measure legalized the possession and use of limited amounts of cannabis by adults 21 and older and established a framework for regulating and taxing sales.

21:53This same year, Portland City Council initiated the creation of the Portland Cannabis Program, originally housed in Office of Community and Civic Life.

22:02In 2015, the Oregon Legislature passed House Bill 3400, establishing much of the regulatory framework for the adult use market and expanding local governments' authority to regulate cannabis businesses through local taxation and time-place manner regulations.

22:18While the state, through the Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission, Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission retained commercial licensing authority.

22:26The legislation recognized the important role local governments play in addressing the impacts of cannabis businesses within their communities.

22:35Building on that authority, Portland City Council formally established Portland City Code Chapter 14B.130 in 2015.

22:43This created a local framework to license, oversee, and regulate cannabis businesses operating within city limits.

22:50In 2016, Portland voters approved Ballot Measure 26-180, establishing an additional 3% local tax on recreational cannabis sales on top of the state's 17% tax.

23:03Revenue from the local tax is deposited in the— into the Recreational Cannabis Tax Fund, which I'll discuss in greater detail later in the presentation.

23:12Finally, in 2018, City Council adopted an ordinance establishing access and support initiatives that I will also discuss in greater detail momentarily.

23:22Together, these milestones laid the foundation for Portland's cannabis regulatory program and shaped the city's approach to licensing, compliance, local taxation, and community investment.

23:33Next slide, please.

23:35And next slide.

23:39The Portland Cannabis Program oversees the licensing, regulation, compliance, community impacts, and social initiatives associated with Portland's cannabis industry.

23:48The program operates on a 100% cost recovery model, meaning we conduct annual fee studies to ensure licensing fees adequately cover the cost of administering the program.

23:59We currently have a team of 5 full-time employees: 1 supervisor, 2 compliance specialists, and 2 support staff.

24:06I often describe us as a small but mighty team given the breadth of our responsibilities and the relatively small staff managing them.

24:14One question we are frequent— we are frequently asked is, why does the city regulate cannabis businesses?

24:20Why can't the OLCC independently oversee cannabis businesses throughout the state without an additional layer of local regulation?

24:28The answer to that is Portland has unique local considerations that require a local regulatory approach.

24:34As the largest city in Oregon, Portland has a diverse urban landscape encompassing residential neighborhoods, industrial areas, and commercial districts, each with different land use zoning and community considerations.

24:49The city established its own regulatory framework to reflect Portland's interest in community priorities while providing the ability to respond directly to local impacts.

24:59These include cannabis retail concentration, odor concerns, neighborhood livability issues such as parking, littering, and loitering, Unlicensed and unregulated operations, and local permitting and land use concerns.

25:13Ultimately, the city's program is not intended to duplicate the state's regulatory role.

25:18Rather, it provides an additional layer of local oversight, allowing Portland to address issues specific to neighborhoods, businesses, and communities that may not be adequately addressed through statewide regulation alone.

25:32Next slide, please.

25:36Portland serves as central hub for Oregon's cannabis industry.

25:39Although the city accounts for just over 13% of the state's total cannabis industry licenses, it is home to more than a quarter of Oregon's dispensaries and wholesale businesses, making Portland an important role— important center for the distribution and movement of regulated cannabis products.

25:56Portland currently has 357 active cannabis business licenses, approximately 25%, which are held by minority-owned businesses.

26:06The breakdown by license type is shown here on the screen.

26:10Since January 1st, 2022, Oregon has maintained a moratorium on new cannabis license applications, limiting opportunities for new businesses to enter the regulated market.

26:20As a result, new market entry is generally limited to purchasing an existing business through a change of ownership or transferring an existing license to another location within the state.

26:31Despite the moratorium, Portland has maintained a relatively stable number of licensees, with current totals comparable to 2022 and higher than that of 2025.

26:42During fiscal year '22— or '25-'26, the program processed 46 changes of ownership, while 15 businesses surrendered their licenses without a change of ownership.

26:52These closures can result from financial hardship, bankruptcy, or an inability or unwillingness to sell.

26:59The cannabis program may impose administrative sanctions of up to $5,000 for violations of city code.

27:06Businesses also have the opportunity to appeal licensing denials, revocations, and violations through the city's administrative review and code hearing processes.

27:16Our primary goal is to help businesses achieve and maintain compliance So they can succeed and thrive within Portland's regulated market.

27:23We work directly with businesses to resolve concerns whenever possible, with enforcement generally serving as a last resort when opportunities for voluntary compliance have been exhausted.

27:36In fiscal year '25-'26, the program issued 13 violations, all involving businesses operating without a required city license.

27:45Overall, the program receives a relatively low volume of complaints.

27:49The most common concerns involve cannabis odors, personal cultivation exceeding legal limits, which falls outside of our regulatory authority, or community opposition to cannabis businesses at particular locations.

28:02Our role is to evaluate these concerns, coordinate with appropriate city and state partners, and determine whether a violation of city code exists that warrants regulatory action.

28:13Next slide, please.

28:16Contrary to popular belief, Portland is not the only jurisdiction in Oregon with its own cannabis licensing and regulatory requirements.

28:24While Portland was the first to establish local licensing regulations and licensing fees, at least 8 other jurisdictions have since adopted local cannabis regulations, and approximately 15 charge some form of local licensing fee.

28:38Portland is also not the most expensive jurisdiction.

28:41As shown in comparison, Gresham currently has the highest annual licensing cost at $5,130, followed by Ontario.

28:49Portland ranks 3rd at $3,970, with Springfield close behind.

28:55Each jurisdiction takes a different approach to its fee structure.

28:59Businesses may be charged for applications, annual licenses, renewals, land use compatibility statements, inspections, late fees, employee counts, individual OLCC endorsements, and other regulatory services.

29:13Portland's fee structure is relatively straightforward.

29:16We charge for the initial application, which includes deluxe annual and renewal licenses and late fees.

29:22The key takeaway is that Portland is not unique in maintaining local cannabis oversight or charging local licensing fees.

29:30Other Oregon jurisdictions have also recognized the importance of local regulatory authority and established fee structures to support their respective licensing and oversight responsibilities.

29:41Next slide, please.

29:45As part of the annual licensing cycle, the cannabis program conducts yearly inspections of every licensed facility.

29:52Each application is first reviewed for completeness before moving forward to the inspection stage.

29:57Throughout this process, we maintain ongoing coordination with multiple city bureaus, state agencies, and regulatory partners to ensure businesses meet applicable requirements.

30:09Next slide, please.

30:13In September 2018, Portland City Council adopted an ordinance establishing the license fee reduction program and deferred payment program.

30:21Both initiatives were designed to reduce financial barriers to entering and operating in Portland's regulated cannabis industry.

30:28By offering eligible business owners lower licensing costs and greater payment flexibility.

30:34The license fee reduction program provides annual licensing fee reductions of 15 to 25% based on 3 qualifying criteria: meeting the program's small business definition, which is $750,000 or less in annual income and fewer than 3 state licenses; having business owners or staff with prior cannabis-related convictions; In contracting for goods and services with ancillary businesses registered with the state as minority-owned, women-owned, or emerging small businesses.

31:07In fiscal year '25-'26, approximately 11% of Portland cannabis licensees received a fee reduction.

31:15The deferred payment program was established to assist businesses experiencing financial hardship, mainly when state and city licensing fees are due around the same time.

31:23Thank you.

31:24It allows businesses to make a small down payment and pay the remaining balance within 6 months.

31:30On average, 31% of Portland cannabis licensees have used the program.

31:35Together, these programs reflect the city's efforts to reduce financial barriers, support eligible businesses, and provide flexibility in meeting local licensing obligations.

31:47In addition to these financial assistance programs, The cannabis program developed a voluntary cannabis business ownership transfer and investment opportunity listing in response to frequent inquiries from licensees and interested parties looking to buy or sell cannabis businesses.

32:04The listing provides a centralized resource where interested parties can register through the city's website and view current, current business sale and investment opportunities, including contact information for prospective buyers and sellers.

32:18The goal is to help retain cannabis businesses in Portland, encourage, encourage continued local investment, and support the city's economic vitality.

32:27The city provides the platform for sharing information and connecting interested parties, but does not participate in or facilitate private business transactions.

32:37Next slide, please.

32:39Yeah, next slide.

32:44In November 2016, Portland voters approved Local Ballot Measure 26-180, establishing a 3% local tax on recreational cannabis sales, with collections beginning January 1st, 2017.

32:56The measure identified 3 priority areas for revenues: drug and alcohol education treatment, public safety, and neighborhood small business and economic opportunity.

33:10In 2019, the City Auditor's Office reviewed the RCT fund and identified opportunities to strengthen transparency and accountability in how revenues are allocated and monitored.

33:21While recognizing City Council's authority to allocate funds based on city needs, the auditor identified the absence of a designated oversight body as a contributing factor to community concerns.

33:33Recommendations included establishing an advisory committee to inform funding decisions, Incorporating RCT allocations into budget discussions, and publishing annual reports detailing allocations, funding decisions, and program outcomes.

33:48To my knowledge, there has not been a comprehensive ongoing audit of RCT-funded programs to evaluate whether expenditures align with the intent of the measure or whether those investments are achieving their intended outcomes.

34:02This presents an opportunity to strengthen public confidence through regular independent review consistent oversight and transparent reporting.

34:10We need an accountability process that examines how RCT revenues are allocated and spent, whether funded programs align with the measure's intended purposes, and what outcomes and community benefits those investments deliver.

34:24Ultimately, this is about ensuring that revenue generated by Portland's cannabis industry is used as voters intended, with a meaningful accountability and transparency in how those dollars are invested.

34:35Thank you.

34:37Next slide, please.

34:40The data presented on this slide was obtained from the City Budget Office and reflects recreational cannabis tax fund budget expenditures from the start of the tax collections in 2017 through fiscal year 26-27.

34:53For questions on this slide, I will defer to the City Budget Office.

34:59Next slide, please.

35:04In December 2021, Portland City Council unanimously voted to establish the Cannabis Emergency Relief Fund, making Portland the first government jurisdiction in the country to provide emergency financial assistance specifically for cannabis businesses and workers who were largely excluded from federal relief programs.

35:25CERF provided grants of up to $25,000 for small licensed cannabis businesses operating within Portland and up to $5,000 for cannabis industry workers experiencing financial hardship.

35:36Eligible circumstances included COVID-19, vandalism, robberies, wildfires, and the lasting impacts of illness, trauma, and grief.

35:46The city initially allocated $1.33 million in recreational cannabis tax revenue in fiscal year '21-'22.

35:52Following the program's success and continued demonstrated need, City Council allocated an additional $456,901 and fiscal year 2022-23.

36:04Across both fiscal years, SURF provided financial assistance to 102 businesses and 195 individuals, helping address immediate financial hardships and support recovery throughout Portland's cannabis community.

36:18Next slide, please.

36:22In 2017, the Portland Cannabis Program, then housed with Office of Community and Civic Life, launched the Social Equity and Educational Development Initiative.

36:29SEED was the first U.S. government program to use local cannabis tax revenue to fund community investment grants centered on equity.

36:39The program received approximately $1 million annually in ongoing recreational cannabis tax revenue to support restorative justice, community reinvestment, and wealth creation in communities of color, as well as communities disproportionately impacted by cannabis prohibition.

36:55SEED investments focused on 3 priority areas: education, entrepreneurship and economic development, and social justice.

37:04Across 5 grant cycles while with Civic Life, the program awarded approximately $5.4 million through 46 grants supporting organizations and initiatives advancing these priorities.

37:16In fiscal year '23-'24, responsibility for SEED transferred to Prosper Portland as part of a broader city organizational transition.

37:24At the same time, the cannabis program's licensing and compliance functions moved to the Bureau of Development Services, now Portland Permitting and Development.

37:34With that, I will turn it over to Robert Smith from Prosper Portland.

Robert Smith 37:38 - 46:53

37:38Thanks, Christina.

37:39Again, my name is Robert Smith.

37:40I manage the entrepreneurship and community economic development team at Prosper Portland.

37:44Today I'll be providing— excuse me, next slide, next 2 slides, please.

37:48Thank you.

37:49I'll be providing an overview of how Prosper Portland utilizes recreational cannabis tax revenues, highlight RCT-funded programs, and talk a little bit about those who have benefited from those investments.

38:01Here we have the programs that are RCT-funded that are either current or have been supported through recreational cannabis tax revenues.

38:10These aren't necessarily characterized as cannabis-only programming, but rather community-centered programs that are carried out in deep partnership with a focus on community and economic development.

38:20First, we have the Inclusive Business Resource Network.

38:22Thank you.

38:22This is our small business support program that provides technical assistance and business advising through a network of community-based partners, organizations like Apano Built, Northwest Native Chamber, and Accelerate Women.

38:35These partners provide cultural and industry-specific support services in 3 main categories: helping individuals launch, stabilize, and grow their businesses.

38:46Their work helps strengthen these businesses, create jobs, expand their markets, and open physical spaces and build wealth.

38:55Next we have My People's Market, which lives in our Office of Events and Film and is a community-centered marketplace supporting entrepreneurs, makers, and artists while celebrating Portland's cultural diversity through art, food, performances, and community building.

39:09The market creates economic opportunities for entrepreneurs by increasing sales, building brand awareness, developing relationships, and expanding market reach.

39:19Hopefully you all have had an opportunity to attend at least one market, and if for some reason you haven't, I'm going to put in a quick plug for our Office of Events and Film.

39:26The next market will be held in a few weeks on December 5th and 6th and is a great opportunity to get an early jump on some holiday gift buying and support some awesome local businesses.

39:37In the middle here, we have the Mercatus Directory, an online business directory and initiative created to support, celebrate, and connect Portland Metro's entrepreneurs.

39:45The directory aims to increase visibility for small businesses and connect them to business opportunities.

39:51The program also aims to build community amongst entrepreneurs through meetups, networking events, workshops, resource fairs, and connecting them with community partners like the ones that can be found in the Inclusive Business Resource Network.

40:04Other supports have included collaborations with the State of Oregon's COVID office, business-to-business convenings like catering fairs, and participation in supplier diversity initiatives.

40:15When funding has allowed, we've also been able to provide digital marketing support to Mercatus businesses by pairing them with coaches to assist with establishing their online presence and expanding their digital footprint.

40:26And we've been able to provide small supportive grants to assist with the implementation of what they've learned through that consult.

40:35Next, we have Reimagine Oregon.

40:37In 2020, Reimagine Oregon began as a statewide community-led initiative that brought community-defined agenda to government leaders in Oregon at, at the federal, state, and local levels.

40:48The initiative focused to address lasting consequences of systemic impacts on community, including those experienced through the prohibition of cannabis and the criminal legal system.

40:58Reimagine Oregon did not limit its agenda to the cannabis industry participation and had a broader vision of equity, Economic opportunity, wealth creation, and restorative justice.

41:09In June 2020, Portland City Council committed to supporting Reimagine Oregon with an ongoing allocation of approximately $1.5 million, and the program and relationship started off with Civic Life.

41:24That funding and the partnership was transferred to Prosper Portland, where we launched the Reimagine Oregon Economic Opportunity Investment Fund in 2023.

41:33Thank you.

41:33There were 3 main areas of focus there, and that was to accelerate business growth and entrepreneurship, strengthen community organizations and increase capacity, and enhance community engagement and collaboration through support of anchor projects.

41:47Since Christina already touched on this, and for the sake of time, I won't go long on the SEED grant.

41:52However, the SEED grant was established to provide financial support to community-based organizations and initiatives that advance economic opportunities Yes.

42:00—And educational development with an emphasis on communities impacted by historic and systemic barriers.

42:07SEED was transferred to Prosper at the same time as Reimagine.

42:10Prosper Portland assumed open grants with funds that were still remaining to be disbursed, as well as a paused application process and 4 grants that were awarded but not yet executed that were funded through Reimagine dollars.

42:29Next slide, please.

42:32So here on this slide, we can see what that investment in these programs looks like over, over time.

42:36Again, I wouldn't classify the programs we covered today as cannabis programs.

42:41However, PROSPER's initial allocation of RCT was provided to specifically stand up supports for the cannabis industry as part of our small business programming.

42:51Since launching, we've been able to grow our support and maintain this industry focus every year since 2018.

42:58In the 19-20 year, we utilized RCT to more broadly support IBRN and began investing these dollars into My People's Market and the Mercatus Directory.

43:07That investment has also been consistent over time, uh, through the current fiscal year, with the exception of Mercatus, which is not receiving an RCT allocation this year.

43:17My People's Market has put on 18 markets with supporting 100 to 150 businesses per market and attracting 2,000 to 3,000 visitors per day.

43:27The Mercatus directory has grown to almost 2,500 businesses, and we were able to support over 100 businesses with digital marketing coaching and grant support.

43:37RCT has also been crucial to maintaining core business advising services as part of IBRN.

43:43The program uses a braided funding approach, bringing together city general funds, community development block grant dollars, and enterprise zone funds alongside RCT.

43:51Thank you.

43:52IBRN serves between 600 and 700 businesses annually, and on average, RCT has funded services to around 160 of those businesses.

44:05So in the '22-'23 year, you can kind of see that's when the discussions about, uh, the reorganization that Christina referred to began.

44:14Um, Reimagine, uh, you can kind of see the the increased level of RCT in the '23-'24 year, that jump reflects an accumulation of Reimagine funds from the previous 3 years along with the, the '23-'24 allocation.

44:33Similarly, we did also assume balances of SEED grants that were transferred over as well.

44:39So we had 12 grants that were assumed, and then once SEED came over to Prosper, we resumed the application process, were able to award 13 grants for around $1 million.

44:51SEED and Reimagine have both built capacity and strengthened organizations with close connections to community, with a focus on community workforce and business development.

45:01In addition, and in addition to organizational nonprofit partner support, Reimagine Oregon has also been able to support 47 businesses over the 2 grant cycles.

45:12Next slide.

45:16Okay, before turning it back over to Christina, I do want to take a moment to highlight our, our partnership with New Project.

45:22The cannabis industry, as I'm sure you will hear today, is complicated, and running a cannabis business is not easy.

45:28The industry is highly regulated, operates primarily in cash, faces challenges when it comes to banking and access to capital, and must navigate the nuance of what it is to be permissive at the local level while restrictive at the federal level.

45:43That is why having such a strong partner in New Project has been vital in supporting the industry.

45:48They bring a tremendous amount of industry-specific expertise in the areas of accounting and finance, packaging and branding, growth planning, and operational scaling.

45:58And they provide these services through one-on-one advising, cohorts, and workshops.

46:03As you can see on the slide, New Project has delivered over 3,500 hours of technical assistance cannabis businesses here in Portland.

46:09And in addition to those business advising services, and because of the challenges the industry faces when accessing capital, we have also partnered with New Project to provide direct assistance to the industry in the form of loans and grants.

46:21In the current cycle of IBRN, we have worked with New Project to establish a revolving loan fund which has supported 11 businesses and has been performing well in terms of delinquencies and repayment, and there are currently funds available to be lent out at this time.

46:35New Project has been a valued partner in supporting cannabis businesses and has helped establish trust between the industry and Prosper.

46:43We value not only the industry acumen that Jeanette Ward and her team bring to this work, but also the care and compassion they show their clients.

46:52Then I'll turn it back over to you.

Christina Corsi 46:53 - 48:24

46:53Okay, next slide please.

46:57And next slide.

47:00Established in 2017, the Cannabis Policy Oversight Team, or referred as CPOT, is a 12-member public advisory body that provides non-binding policy recommendations to the bureau director through an annual report.

47:13CPOT brings together cannabis industry representatives, advocates, and community members with in-depth knowledge of issues affecting and affected by the cannabis industry.

47:23The team also includes 2 ex officio non-voting members representing Prosper Portland and Multnomah County.

47:30CPOT's primary objective is to discuss develop and recommend policies that advance social initiatives and positive outcomes for the cannabis industry, cannabis consumers, and all residents, residents of Portland.

47:42Next slide, please.

47:46CPOT has been engaged in policy discussions throughout the year, and we are currently drafting policy recommendations for our 2026 annual cannabis policy report that will be published earlier next year.

47:57We look forward to working with councilors over the coming months On further discussions and exploration on advancing future policy considerations such as social consumption, Measure 110 tax return to cities, and other regulatory and economic industry advocacy, as well as ongoing concerns surrounding public safety and cannabis thefts.

48:18Next slide, please.

48:20That concludes this portion of the presentation, and we are available for questions.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 48:26 - 48:51

48:26Thank you all very much.

48:28I want to get to our industry panel as well, but if there are questions, colleagues, specifically to the presentation that we saw or some of the details of the program, let's get those out now, and we can always get folks back up for a broader discussion after we hear from our industry panel.

48:50Did you have a question?

Dan Ryan 48:51 - 49:10

48:51Yeah, just a technical question.

48:54When you were mentioning the graphs, inclusive business network, My People's Market, and then I was trying to trace them to the bar charts that you did, then you mentioned the new, um, what's it called, the new program, the new—.

Robert Smith 49:10 - 49:11

49:10New project.

Dan Ryan 49:11 - 49:21

49:11New project.

49:13I couldn't track where that was because it's not one of these boxes up here.

49:19It seems like it landed in one of the boxes down here.

Robert Smith 49:22 - 49:27

49:22Yeah, the new project relationship is part of the Inclusive Business Resource Network.

Dan Ryan 49:27 - 49:28

49:27Oh, so it's included in that.

Robert Smith 49:28 - 49:48

49:28We are an IBRN partner, and so it's embedded into that, the dollar allocation there.

49:33When we look at probably over the last 5 years, the current IBRN grant cycle of the RCT that Prosper has received, about 40% of that has gone to cannabis industry.

49:47What percent?

Dan Ryan 49:48 - 49:55

49:48About 40.

49:51And that— what's the aggregate number, the big number?

49:54So 40% of what?

Robert Smith 50:00 - 50:27

50:00I think in aggregate— give me one minute.

50:08Yeah, $1.8 million.

50:13Uh, since it began, or in, in the 5-year cycle?

50:17So that's the actuals from, um, the start of this cycle of IBRN and then the budgeted amount this year.

Dan Ryan 50:29 - 50:36

50:29And so the report that was mentioned earlier, it has all these details.

50:32I don't— that hasn't been sent to council.

50:35There was a report that was mentioned.

Robert Smith 50:40 - 50:42

50:40The, the industry research report?

Dan Ryan 50:43 - 50:44

50:43That could be what I heard.

Unidentified speaker 50:44 - 50:45

50:44Yeah.

Robert Smith 50:45 - 50:47

50:45Was that what Brett had referenced?

Dan Ryan 50:47 - 50:47

50:47Yes.

Robert Smith 50:47 - 51:15

50:47Yes, yes.

50:48So when, when the, um, SEED program was at Prosper, there were some discussions about the possibility of leveraging the fund for more cannabis-specific supports as well.

50:59And so there was a market analysis that was done.

51:02It's outside of the programming dollars So it's, it's a broader scan of the conditions locally as well as kind of potential of the local market as well as how the state is, is positioned for future growth.

Dan Ryan 51:16 - 51:24

51:16Okay, thank you.

51:16And Christina, on another technical question— good to see you, by the way— you mentioned an audit.

51:22Is that something that you'll be asking for?

Christina Corsi 51:26 - 51:43

51:26So I mentioned, well, there's 2 things of the audit.

51:29I just mentioned a 2019 tax audit.

51:32That had recommendations.

51:34But I also do believe that there should be further follow-up to that audit as to auditing programs that have received the RCT fund over the years.

Dan Ryan 51:44 - 51:50

51:44Thank you for saying that, and I appreciate that.

51:46So we haven't had a detailed audit since 2019?

Christina Corsi 51:50 - 51:51

51:50Not to my knowledge, no.

Dan Ryan 51:51 - 51:55

51:51Okay, that's helpful.

51:53Thank you.

51:54Those are my technical questions for now.

Christina Corsi 51:55 - 51:55

51:55Yeah.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 51:56 - 52:19

51:56Thank you, Councilor.

51:57I have a couple of questions as well.

52:00Starting with just a follow-up on an answer you had to Councilor Ryan.

52:05Were you— did you state that 40% of the IBRN funds go to the cannabis industry, or 40% of the total funds distributed through PROSPER that come in through the cannabis program are redistributed to the cannabis industry?

Robert Smith 52:19 - 52:34

52:19So of the— so with IBRN, it's a, it's a blended or braided funding approach, right?

52:24So with the recreational cannabis tax revenues, one's input.

52:28Of those dollars that go to small business supports, 40% of the recreational cannabis tax revenues.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 52:34 - 52:45

52:34So not of the total recreational cannabis tax revenues, but 40% of the recreational cannabis tax revenues that go into IBRA go back out to the cannabis industry?

Robert Smith 52:45 - 52:46

52:45That's right.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 52:46 - 52:52

52:46Okay, thank you.

52:46I was trying to figure out what the 40% was of.

52:51The total number?

Dan Ryan 52:52 - 52:53

52:52Yeah, the 40%.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 52:54 - 52:58

52:54That was the 1 point— did you say $5 or $1.8 million that you said?

Robert Smith 52:59 - 53:01

52:59$1.8, Right.

53:00And this is—.

Dan Ryan 53:01 - 53:03

53:0140% Of that.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 53:03 - 53:05

53:03No, $1.8 is the 40%.

Robert Smith 53:05 - 53:29

53:0540% Of about $4.45.

53:09And so that is not the entire RCT allocation because there are— there are— there's funding that goes to support My People's Market.

53:17There's funding that So the, the entire allocation that is received, the 40% is specific to the small business supports that we provide and use those funds for.

Dan Ryan 53:30 - 53:32

53:30Small business, cannabis small business?

Robert Smith 53:34 - 53:38

53:34Through the Inclusive Business Resource Network.

53:36It's a subset of the network.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 53:39 - 53:53

53:39Subset of the funds that come in goes to IBRN.

53:44It's mixed with other funds.

53:4540% Of what goes in from cannabis goes back out to cannabis.

53:50Okay, do you want to follow up on that?

Dan Ryan 53:53 - 53:57

53:53I just was seeking some clarity on exactly how much goes to the cannabis small businesses.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 53:58 - 53:59

53:58That's the $1.8 million.

Dan Ryan 54:00 - 54:05

54:00Yes, but then I thought I heard other resources that went to other tributaries, if you will.

Robert Smith 54:06 - 54:07

54:06Other programming.

Dan Ryan 54:07 - 54:10

54:07Other programs.

54:08Yeah, it'll be great to see that spelled out somewhere.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 54:11 - 54:11

54:11Sure.

Dan Ryan 54:11 - 54:11

54:11Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 54:11 - 54:12

54:11No problem.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 54:13 - 54:52

54:13So on the chart on page 17— 13, I apologize, page 13 of the presentation— we see a big increase in recreational cannabis tax revenue or budget expenditures.

54:26So I assume also revenue in 2023-24, and then a significant drop.

54:32Is that a drop in revenues coming in Or were expenditures not equal to revenues coming in every year?

54:41Why are we seeing that big tick up and then immediate dropdown?

54:46I see, I see a phone-a-friend helping, coming to help.

54:52You want me to go to that slide?

Ruth Levine 54:53 - 54:54

54:53Sure.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 54:54 - 54:57

54:54What slide did you say it was?

54:56Number 13, page 13.

Ruth Levine 55:02 - 56:24

55:02Hi, Ruth Levine, City Budget Director.

55:05So yeah, so these are expenditures.

55:07So, and we, I don't know if we put the revenue slide in as well then, but maybe we can go there in a second.

55:15But the sort of shape of the expenditures over time for RCT is not actually that aligned to the shape of the revenues.

55:24And there were a couple of reasons for that, but the basic reason you see that big jump up in '23-'24 has to do with the sort of launch of the Reimagine Oregon work.

55:37And there was a bit of a delay during the post-COVID years when after the initial ongoing allocation was made to that work, and then there were subsequent increases on a one-time basis, but the program hadn't been stood up yet.

55:55And so—.

55:56Thank you.

55:57It was kind of accumulating for a couple of years, and then the program transferred to Prosper, and then a big backlog of that funding was spent kind of all in one year once the infrastructure was in place to actually do so.

56:16So that's why you see that kind of funny shape to the expenditures.

56:20We can look quickly at the revenues.

56:22No, I don't have that.

56:23Okay, we can—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 56:24 - 56:46

56:24So if we were to see, a line for the revenues placed alongside this chart of the expenditures, would we see that over the last 3 fiscal years revenues and expenditures roughly aligned, or is there a significant amount of money building up not being spent or significant variation year over year?

Ruth Levine 56:46 - 57:04

56:46Yeah, so essentially what happened, and we can get you the revenue chart, we have it.

56:53But essentially what happened is there was a really significant uptick in the first couple of years of the tax because it was just coming online.

57:02It was 2016, '17.

57:04So—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 57:05 - 57:06

57:05Everyone was smoking legal pot.

Ruth Levine 57:07 - 58:27

57:07Yeah, business was booming.

57:09And then it really quickly leveled off in the post-pandemic years at right exactly the same time that this program was just getting stood up.

57:19And so we actually had a couple of years where we had to do interfund loans just to keep the fund whole because It turns out to be a much more difficult revenue source to predict than we had thought.

57:33And there are ongoing expenditures funded out of here.

57:38And so the— yeah, it's basically been more or less flat, a little bit down.

57:48And I'm sorry, it's basically been flat.

57:50Yeah.

57:50It spiked and then came down, and then it's been more or less flat over the last 3 years with some significant variation kind of year to year that depend a bit on like when the payments come in and things like that.

58:02Okay.

58:03So it is no longer the case that there is like a backlog of money being spent.

58:09We've now like sort of brought it down to the more expected ongoing level.

58:15I will say though that Um, you know, we are still pretty uncertain about the forecast for this fund and just how much money will be coming in year to year.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 58:27 - 58:42

58:27Thank you, that's helpful.

58:29Um, in that same chart, we heard later about the emergency relief fund that was made available specifically to the cannabis industry.

58:39Where is that reflected in the numbers on this chart?

Christina Corsi 58:43 - 59:01

58:43That is the green of the Office of Community and Civic Life in '21-'22 and '22-'23.

58:52But that's also mixed in with the seed on this chart.

58:56So it's not— there's not a differentiation between those 2 funds.

58:59That's with Civic Life right there.

Candace Avalos 59:01 - 59:02

59:01Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 59:02 - 59:29

59:02And I have heard that there are limitations to how we can support the industry.

59:06Some of those are policy decisions where we're spending the money, but I've I've also been told there are some legal limitations.

59:13If the council were interested in providing that type of support again in the future, is that something we could bring back as a policy decision, or is that something where there are new limitations that didn't exist when that green patch was on the bar chart?

Christina Corsi 59:30 - 59:43

59:30So when I was creating SURF, it was heavily vetted and heavily researched just to ensure the legality of it all.

59:37So I do believe that you would be able to bring it back Okay, and final question.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 59:43 - 1:00:00

59:43I apologize for taking up so much time on these.

59:45Um, is the New Project tapped out?

59:49Are they using all of the time and money that we are making available through the grants from Prosper Portland, or is there room to support more members of the industry?

Robert Smith 1:00:02 - 1:00:05

1:00:02More members of the industry through the relationship with New Project?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:00:06 - 1:00:11

1:00:06Is New Project at capacity in terms of who they can help, or do they have capacity to support more businesses?

Robert Smith 1:00:12 - 1:00:55

1:00:12Yeah, I believe at the funding levels that we're at right now, they are programmed for the year.

1:00:18The IBRN is about ready to kind of go back out for new services.

1:00:23This is the final year of the grant cycle.

1:00:25And so, I mean, there's the kind of question of more resources would provide more capacity.

1:00:32And also, you know, with the revolving loan fund, there's the opportunity, I think, also— I think there was a slide, it's a little up over $700,000, and it's great that we're able to have that in place.

1:00:44And we know that the industry faces a number of challenges.

1:00:48And so I think being able to also kind of build on the loan fund would provide some direct supports as well.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:00:56 - 1:00:59

1:00:56Thank you.

1:00:58Councilor Morillo, you had questions?

Angelita Morillo 1:01:02 - 1:01:23

1:01:02Yes, thank you, Chair.

1:01:04I was curious about the—.

1:01:07So there's $1.5 million, if I'm not mistaken, that's allocated for Portland Street Response.

1:01:12And I was wondering if that year by year is met with inflation increases as well.

1:01:19Since it's used to purchase personnel, it seems like that would be important.

Ruth Levine 1:01:26 - 1:01:32

1:01:26There are inflationary increases built into the recreational cannabis tax forecast, yes.

Angelita Morillo 1:01:33 - 1:01:34

1:01:33Gotcha.

1:01:33Okay, thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:01:37 - 1:01:38

1:01:37Okay, seeing no other—.

Ruth Levine 1:01:39 - 1:01:39

1:01:39Slide.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:01:40 - 1:01:42

1:01:40I'm sorry, did you have something else?

Ruth Levine 1:01:43 - 1:01:56

1:01:43We were able to pull up the revenue chart, so I think that is being shared right now.

1:01:50So that is just the picture to what I was trying to speak.

1:01:54So happy to answer other questions about that.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:01:56 - 1:02:11

1:01:56Okay, I'm gonna hold my other questions about this.

1:02:00That's helpful to see and think about how it aligns with the expenditures.

1:02:04Um, it might be great to get those 2 overlaid at some point as follow-up if that's possible.

1:02:09Sure, go right ahead, Councilor.

Dan Ryan 1:02:12 - 1:02:27

1:02:12My husband, my husband says I'm colorblind, and I think they're right, but I can't distinguish between the blue colors on this chart on number 18.

1:02:23So Mercatus, that's a darker blue.

1:02:26Did that just go away?

Robert Smith 1:02:29 - 1:02:30

1:02:29In the 26— in the current year.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:02:32 - 1:02:35

1:02:32Mercatus is the really thin line on top of—.

Dan Ryan 1:02:35 - 1:02:40

1:02:35Not to be confused with the blue that's underneath it.

1:02:38That's okay.

Robert Smith 1:02:40 - 1:02:41

1:02:40Apologies for that.

Dan Ryan 1:02:41 - 1:02:50

1:02:41Yeah, they're really— they're hard for me.

1:02:43I think perhaps because I just can't— I can't distinguish them very well.

1:02:47But, but you didn't answer my question.

1:02:49Or CADES just went away.

Robert Smith 1:02:51 - 1:02:54

1:02:51It still exists as an initiative not funded through RCT this current fiscal year.

Dan Ryan 1:02:54 - 1:02:58

1:02:54Got it.

1:02:55It doesn't have money from the cannabis tax.

1:02:57Okay, thanks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:02:58 - 1:03:43

1:02:58Okay, there may be more questions as we get into discussing, discussing the proposal before us, but I'd like to have us hear from our industry representatives who are in the room today.

1:03:08Thank you all so much.

1:03:10And next we are going to hear from Leanne Stevenson, Ian Shaughnessy, and Catherine Leathers-Self.

1:03:20My list is wrong, I apologize, but hopefully we got it right here.

1:03:30Thank you all so much for being here today and making sure we're hearing from you about how this is working on the ground.

1:03:38I have down that Leanne is kicking us off, but please, whatever order you all prefer to go in, go right ahead.

Unidentified speaker 1:03:43 - 1:06:47

1:03:43I'll go for it.

1:03:44Thank you for having us here today.

1:03:46We sincerely appreciate you being willing to listen.

1:03:49I'm Leanne Stevenson, founder and CEO of The Dub Wholesale.

1:03:53We've been operating in Oregon's regulated cannabis industry since 2016, and this year marks our 10th year in business.

1:04:01As a cannabis logistics company, we have a unique perspective on what's happening across the industry because we work with multiple brands.

1:04:08And deliver their products to most retailers in Portland as well as across the state.

1:04:13And what we're seeing is concerning.

1:04:16While we're continuing to make deliveries to retailers, the actual volume of cannabis we're transporting has declined significantly.

1:04:23Retailers are ordering less because consumers are purchasing less, and I think you saw that in the revenue numbers.

1:04:30That decline affects everyone throughout the supply chain, from growers and manufacturers to distributors and retailers.

1:04:35Thank you.

1:04:36Unfortunately, while revenue is declining, the cost of operating a licensed, licensed cannabis business is not.

1:04:44One area where I believe the city could make an immediate and meaningful difference is licensing fees.

1:04:49As a cannabis wholesale licensee operating in Portland, including application fees, we pay approximately $5,000 annually to the state of Oregon and another $4,565 to the city of Portland.

1:05:02Thank you.

1:05:02Portland.

1:05:03That's nearly $10,000 a year in licensing fees alone, before insurance, security, compliance, payroll, employee benefits that we offer, and other operating expenses.

1:05:15I understand and support the need for regulation and oversight.

1:05:19That's my background, and I appreciate it.

1:05:22But given the current state of the industry, I think it's reasonable to ask whether this additional financial burden is sustainable.

1:05:29I also want to acknowledge, however, the city's efforts to support cannabis businesses.

1:05:33The Dub has received 2 small grants totaling $3,500 to help with accounting and security expenses.

1:05:39These grants have been helpful, and I genuinely appreciate that support.

1:05:44But I also think we need to examine whether we're providing financial assistance to businesses with one hand while continuing to impose substantial costs with the other.

1:05:54I would encourage this committee and the council to take a serious look at Portland's cannabis licensing fees and consider reducing those costs for existing operators.

1:06:03I also believe we need to look beyond helping businesses manage expenses and focus on opportunities to grow revenue.

1:06:10Responsible social consumption, for example, could create new opportunities for tourism, local businesses, and additional tax revenue.

1:06:18After 10 years in this industry, I believe Portland still has a tremendous opportunity to be a leader.

1:06:22Thank you.

1:06:23In cannabis.

1:06:24But if we don't address the challenges facing existing operators, I believe we're going to see more established businesses move out of Portland or close their doors.

1:06:34My request to the council is simple: help make Portland a place where responsible cannabis businesses can not only survive but grow again.

1:06:43Thank you for your time and for listening to those of us working in this industry every day.

Niki Terzieff 1:06:50 - 1:06:51

1:06:50Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:06:51 - 1:06:52

1:06:51Go right ahead.

Christina Corsi 1:06:54 - 1:06:55

1:06:54Sure.

Katherine Leather Self 1:06:55 - 1:08:43

1:06:55Hi, my name is Katherine Leather Self.

1:06:57I'm a co-owner of Self Made Cannabis Company.

1:07:00We have a processing license and a wholesale license here in Portland in the same building.

1:07:04We pay licensing fees, um, for both of those licenses in the same location, and we have 3 retail licenses and we pay licensing fees there as well.

1:07:15Kind of what Leanne said, I think it is a burden, the cost of the licensing fees.

1:07:24But I do have to say that I really didn't understand, and I'm very grateful to learn so much about how that money is spent and all of the ways that the city is working behind the scenes.

1:07:35And I'm grateful to have learned that, and we're grateful for the privilege to be here.

1:07:39You know, it's been 12 years 11 years now, and it's, it's really amazing that we get to, to do what we're doing here and, and to have you guys here asking what we think and, and help support us.

1:07:51Licensing fees are, are challenging, and, you know, we understand your, your part, but whatever you could do to not increase those at the very least.

1:08:00Um, helping support the police for police response times— one thing that is challenging for our industry is that we have a significant Um, you know, tax burden.

1:08:10We have some other banking limitations, um, that, you know, force us to use a lot more cash than other businesses and, and make us a target, um, of crime.

1:08:20Um, you know, giving support to police for increased support times for the safety of our, of our staff, um, is, is really important.

1:08:28Um, and of course, social consumption is something we've always wanted and we've been working at for over a decade, and if that were something that were able to come to fruition, we think that that would be great for our industry and for our city.

1:08:41Um, thank you for the opportunity to speak today.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:08:44 - 1:08:51

1:08:44Thank you very much for being here and being part of the conversation.

1:08:50Yeah, please go right ahead.

Ian Shaughnessy 1:08:51 - 1:12:14

1:08:51Hi, uh, my name is Ian Shaughnessy, and, um, yeah, thank you for inviting us to be here.

1:08:57Thank you for inviting our industry to be here.

1:08:59I think this is the first time that we've ever been invited to Uh, come speak here.

1:09:03And so I, I just want to, uh, express appreciation for that.

1:09:08Um, I, you know, we were told just tell our stories, right?

1:09:11So my story is I'm from Portland.

1:09:14I grew up in Northeast Portland.

1:09:15I went to Grant High School.

1:09:16Actually, we went to high school together.

1:09:18We actually also went to high school with Councilor Dunphy.

1:09:20So, uh, so, you know, like, we're in— we're huge supporters of the city.

1:09:25I'm a huge supporter of the city, uh, you know, and, and this city, it's a wonderful place.

1:09:28I spent my 20s just being surrounded by art and music and creativity in this city.

1:09:33And it's interesting how Portland has this ability to capture the national spotlight.

1:09:38You know, we do this kind of on a regular basis, sometimes in ways we don't want to.

1:09:41But the cannabis industry has also done it as well.

1:09:43We have—.

1:09:44We've produced some of the biggest cannabis companies in the world have come from the Portland area.

1:09:48And this is something that I think a lot of people here don't realize, you know, outside of our industry.

1:09:53But there have been, you know, Wild and Groon and Select have all come from the Portland area.

1:09:59And none of these businesses are based in Portland anymore.

1:10:03And this kind of speaks to just the landscape of doing business as a growing business in this city.

1:10:09So, you know, we've— my company, we've got 30 employees.

1:10:13We're in the Parkrose neighborhood.

1:10:15We're a processor.

1:10:16We make a lot of weed products.

1:10:18Last year, I think we made around 3 billion milligrams of THC.

1:10:23And that's something that I'm very proud of.

1:10:24It's a lot of A lot of, you know, great experiences that we got out there for people.

1:10:27A lot of people that chose to smoke weed over alcohol, over other drugs, that, you know, had edibles to get a good night's sleep, you know, or even just to like put on a record and relax after a hard day's work.

1:10:41So the work that we do is important work.

1:10:43The costs that we pay are outrageously high.

1:10:46I mean, across the board, from, you know, the local taxes all the way up to, you know, The federal tax situation is its own special thing, but, you know, from a local tax perspective, I mean, it's very expensive to do business in the city of Portland.

1:10:58And right now we've got about 3 years left on our lease over in Parkrose, and we're starting to look at what is our forever home.

1:11:05As we, you know, we're a growing company, uh, we are going to be continuing to grow hopefully for a long time to come.

1:11:10And if I look at Washington County, if I look at these other counties, it is a significant tax advantage.

1:11:16I mean, like 5% immediate just, you know, tax breaks to go to other counties versus being in Multnomah County.

1:11:23And I don't want to do that because I love Portland.

1:11:26I grew up here.

1:11:26I'm from here.

1:11:27I care deeply about this place.

1:11:29But we need— I mean, we need— I guess we need help as an industry.

1:11:34If I were to ask for something, it would just be for full-throated support from the city council for us, for our industry, for what we do.

1:11:41You know, taxes and fees go a long way to helping things out.

1:11:44Also, just We want Portland to talk about weed the same way we talk about beer and talk about music and talk about— we have all these cultural exports that we produce, and marijuana is one of them.

1:11:58We do.

1:11:58We make amazing cannabis products in this city, and we should, we should be telling that story more and get people to come here and to try them, to bring their dollars here to, you know, then also go to the cool restaurant down the street.

1:12:09So, um, I think that's a really important thing.

1:12:10Thank you.

1:12:10Anyways, yeah, that's, that's my story, and thank you for listening.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:12:17 - 1:12:29

1:12:17Thank you all so much for being here.

1:12:18Colleagues, do any of you have questions for folks who are here from the industry that might be able to help us with our conversations?

1:12:27Councilor Ryan, I see you going for the mic.

Dan Ryan 1:12:29 - 1:12:36

1:12:29Yeah, Ian, you mentioned some of the larger companies that have left.

1:12:35Could you name those?

Ian Shaughnessy 1:12:37 - 1:12:42

1:12:37Wild is based in Clackamas.

1:12:39Select left the entire Oregon market a few years ago.

Dan Ryan 1:12:42 - 1:12:43

1:12:42Select?

Ian Shaughnessy 1:12:43 - 1:12:50

1:12:43Yeah.

1:12:44And Groon just recently has their, you know, shutting down their Portland operations.

Dan Ryan 1:12:53 - 1:12:57

1:12:53And would you say that probably has some impact on the drop in revenues that we were seeing?

Ian Shaughnessy 1:12:58 - 1:13:11

1:12:58You know, I'm sure.

1:12:59I don't think that, you know, the, the, the Groon revenue probably hasn't been felt yet, but, um, the, you know, and Select would have pulled out a couple of years ago, so that would have absolutely impacted that as well.

Dan Ryan 1:13:16 - 1:13:18

1:13:16Do you have any questions?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:13:20 - 1:13:37

1:13:20I, you know, I, I have had the opportunity to talk to a couple of folks about the concept around social consumption 2 of you have mentioned that.

1:13:30I'm wondering if you just want to take a minute or 2 to share a little bit more about what that would look like from your perspective.

Katherine Leather Self 1:13:39 - 1:13:58

1:13:39I know that the Clean— the Indoor Clean Air Act— I may not be saying it correctly— has been a barrier to this.

1:13:47I wonder if outdoor covered consumption areas could be a way to be more open-minded about it and find a way past that barrier.

Ian Shaughnessy 1:14:00 - 1:14:21

1:14:00Yeah, and I mean, there's— I'm sure there's many ways the city could also support this, you know, and the city could be supporting us with, you know, the same way that we have beer gardens, have cannabis gardens that are outdoors.

1:14:11You know, there's— I think there's a lot of ways that we could be doing this that would be fun and exciting, and, you know, and they would be— it would bring people to the city, and it would bring great press to the city and to what we do here.

Dan Ryan 1:14:22 - 1:14:24

1:14:22So can I join on that one?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:14:24 - 1:14:24

1:14:24Councilor Ryan.

Dan Ryan 1:14:25 - 1:14:43

1:14:25I was in Denver for a conference.

1:14:27It was right before COVID It must have been 2018, 2019, and it was in April.

1:14:32It was around April 20th.

1:14:34So at the airport, there was just tons of tourists coming into Denver.

1:14:39So does Denver have those type of systems set up in a way that Portland does not?

Unidentified speaker 1:14:44 - 1:14:44

1:14:44I think that—.

Ian Shaughnessy 1:14:45 - 1:15:10

1:14:45And, and this is, this is just pure speculation, but I mean, yeah, they— but they had— they early on, they, you know, they were one of the first states to legalize.

1:14:53People know about this and they travel there for that.

1:14:56Uh, and, you know, Portland, we've got all these other things that we're known for and we talk a lot about it.

1:15:01We talk a lot about our, our food and drink culture, but we don't talk about the cannabis culture.

1:15:06Denver talks about it.

1:15:07Like, they make it known.

1:15:08People go there for this.

1:15:08That's a thing that they support.

Dan Ryan 1:15:10 - 1:15:29

1:15:10Yeah, I'll never forget that at the airport, how many people were coming into town.

1:15:14And at the hotel, same thing.

1:15:15The people checking out, um, and those, those checking in, and they were ready for a big weekend, and, uh, they were going to spend a lot of money in Denver.

1:15:23So you're basically giving us a hint, like, why aren't we capitalizing on that?

1:15:27Okay.

Katherine Leather Self 1:15:30 - 1:15:58

1:15:30Well, one other thing is that it really is illegal to smoke anywhere publicly, to consume anywhere outside of your own home, and that includes some people who rent.

1:15:38Um, they're not allowed to consume anything, um, I'm not sure that that keeps them from that necessarily, but we have really strict rules around that.

1:15:48I know that some other cities and states are more lenient that way, and I wonder if that would make it easier to capture cannabis tourism.

Dan Ryan 1:15:58 - 1:16:01

1:15:58Okay, yeah, helpful.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:16:02 - 1:16:42

1:16:02Thank you all so much.

1:16:03I know that, um, it's a piece that we need to spend more time thinking about.

1:16:09I also would love to hear ideas in the future about how we can support the production side of our industry.

1:16:17I know we have production both in terms of the plants themselves and also edibles and other products made with THC.

1:16:28And thinking about how we can make sure that the production side of the industry is supported here, it sounds like that's a lot of what we're losing right now are those headquarters and production facilities to other places.

1:16:37So I'd love to have some follow-up conversations there.

1:16:41Colleagues, are there any other questions?

Dan Ryan 1:16:42 - 1:17:06

1:16:42Yeah, I just want to say I appreciate you all bending my ear on the last couple years.

1:16:46Um, I do think that this report was 360 and very well done compared to when we just heard from one side.

1:16:53So to have the actual people that are the end users of all of this is really important, and it's important for policymakers to have you in the room.

1:17:01So thank you for taking up time today to, to shed a lot of wisdom on what's really happening.

Unidentified speaker 1:17:06 - 1:17:08

1:17:06Well, thank you for the time.

1:17:08We appreciate it.

Katherine Leather Self 1:17:08 - 1:17:09

1:17:08Yeah, thank you.

Ian Shaughnessy 1:17:09 - 1:17:09

1:17:09Yeah, thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:17:10 - 1:32:43

1:17:10Thank you all.

1:17:12Colleagues, we are an hour and 12 minutes into our conversation.

1:17:18I'm going to have us take a 15-minute break.

1:17:22When we come back, we will consider the code changes that are before us.

1:17:26And then we will move into a presentation on the workforce and contractor equity agreements within the Portland Climate— Portland Clean Energy Fund.

1:17:38Sorry about that.

1:17:40Recess.

1:17:40We will recess and be back here at 3:27.

1:32:01Good afternoon.

1:32:02I am calling back to order our City Life meeting.

1:32:06We are in the middle of agenda items 2 and 3.

1:32:10We have had the presentation listed under agenda item 2, so we are moving to conversation around code changes.

1:32:18We do have a brief presentation on the specifics of those code changes from the cannabis program coordinator, Christina Corsi.

1:32:29We are going to hear from her, and then we will open up testimony.

1:32:32Thank you, Council Clerk.

1:32:33I believe we have about 10 people signed up to testify on the code changes and also our cannabis program more broadly.

1:32:40So Christina, if you are ready, why don't we jump into the presentation?

Christina Corsi 1:32:49 - 1:32:58

1:32:49Thank you, Deputy City Attorney.

Eric Kooch 1:33:01 - 1:33:05

1:33:01Good afternoon.

1:33:01My name is Eric Kooch.

1:33:02I'm with Portland Permitting and Development.

1:33:04I'm the director of Portland Permitting and Development.

Christina Corsi 1:33:07 - 1:41:26

1:33:07Thank you, Chair and committee, for your time and attention today.

1:33:10Again, for the record, I am Christina Corsi, Cannabis and Liquor Program Manager with Portland Permitting and Development.

1:33:15I'm here today with a request to amend Portland City Code 14B.130, Marijuana Regulatory License Procedure and Requirements.

1:33:25Next slide, please.

1:33:36For today's agenda, I'll provide a brief history of the deferred payment program, discuss the proposed changes to the program and related processes, and discuss the removal of language addressing drive-through and walk-up windows.

1:33:49Next slide, please.

1:33:52On September 26th, 2018, City Council adopted Ordinance Number 189183 establishing the deferred payment program.

1:34:00The program was created to promote equity in cannabis licensing and reduce barriers to entry by providing a payment plan that helped businesses manage the timing of state and local licensing obligations.

1:34:12It also provided financial flexibility and support for small locally owned businesses that needed assistance.

1:34:19After several years of administering the program and evaluating its use, the cannabis program has identified recurring challenges that have increased administrative demands, complicated collection efforts, and created unintended financial impacts for participating businesses.

1:34:35Based on these experiences, the program is requesting the proposed amendments to improve the program's effectiveness and better align the code with current operational needs.

1:34:45Next slide, please.

1:34:49The proposed amendments also address outdated fee amounts in PCC 14B.130 that no longer align with the program's current fee schedule due to annual licensing fee increases.

1:35:00The cannabis program recommends amending the code to better reflect current program processes, remove outdated fee amounts, and adjust payment requirements.

1:35:09These changes are intended to improve program administration, reduce opportunities for misuse, and minimize unnecessary financial hardship for businesses experiencing economic challenges while participating in the deferred payment program.

1:35:24Under the current code, licensees participating in the deferred payment program are required to make a $500 down payment toward their license fee, with the remaining balance due within 6 months.

1:35:35If the balance remains unpaid 30 days after the due date, a $250 late fee is assessed.

1:35:42An additional $500 is charged should an account become 60 days overdue.

1:35:48These fixed dollar amounts have become outdated as annual license fees have increased through council-approved fee schedule changes.

1:35:55Removing the specific dollar amounts from the code will allow the program to maintain consistency with future fee schedule adjustments without requiring additional code amendments each time licensing fees change.

1:36:09Another proposed amendment would eliminate the second late fee and adjust the timeline so that a single $300 late fee is assessed when payment remains outstanding 14 days after the 6-month payment deadline.

1:36:23This change is intended to reduce additional financial burdens on licensees who may already be experiencing economic hardship while also reducing the staff time required for repeated collection efforts.

1:36:34Thank you.

1:36:35We are proposing to remove the code language establishing different late fee amounts for micro license holders and non-micro license holders.

1:36:44Instead, the program recommends applying a single flat $300 late fee to all license holders.

1:36:50This creates a consistent approach to late fee assessments, simplifies payment tracking and collection processes, and reduces administrative complexity for staff.

1:37:00Next slide, please.

1:37:04The deferred payment program has experienced recurring issues with unpaid balances, missed payment deadlines, and increased administrative demands.

1:37:13Requiring a 50% down payment helps ensure that licensees have the financial ability and commitment to meet their licensing obligations while reducing the city's financial and administrative risk.

1:37:26Under the existing program, when a licensee fails to pay the remaining balance within the 6-month payment period, additional late fees may be assessed at 30 and 60 days.

1:37:34Staff must then spend additional time contacting licensees, following up on outstanding balances, and pursuing collections.

1:37:42This can create a cycle that is difficult for both the city and the business to resolve.

1:37:47Small businesses already experiencing financial hardship may request additional payment arrangements, and while staff work to accommodate reasonable requests, These arrangements require additional administrative oversight and can extend payment deadlines well beyond the original 6-month period, sometimes until the next renewal.

1:38:06This can result in accumulated fees, increased financial pressures on the business, and additional collection work for staff.

1:38:14The proposed changes are intended to establish a clearer and more manageable timeline for licensees to meet their payment obligations.

1:38:21By providing a defined opportunity to come into compliance while avoiding extended payment arrangements that carry over the next annual renewal, the program can help reduce additional financial hardship and minimize the risk of a licensee being unable to renew on time.

1:38:38Increasing the required down payment to 50% is intended to address these recurring issues by reducing outstanding balances, establishing greater financial accountability at the outset and limiting the need for extended payment arrangements and collection efforts.

1:38:54The change is also intended to help prevent small businesses from accumulating additional fees and facing further financial hardship due to prolonged unpaid balances.

1:39:04Next slide, please.

1:39:07The proposed amendments also streamline payment timelines to improve administrative efficiency, reduce unnecessary late fee assessments, Minimize additional financial hardship for licensees, and decrease the staff resources required for payment tracking, collections, and compliance activities.

1:39:25Overall, these revisions are intended to provide greater clarity for both staff and licensees while aligning the code with current program practices.

1:39:34These changes reflect practices the cannabis program implemented in August 2016.

1:39:39Prior to implementation, the program provided licensees.

1:39:42With advance notice of these changes, and to date we have received little to no negative feedback from licensees regarding the revised payment process.

1:39:52Next slide, please.

1:39:56For the final proposed code amendment, we are requesting the removal of outdated language prohibiting marijuana retail establishments from using drive-through and walk-up windows that are lawfully established and permitted for retail use.

1:40:09The original language in PCC 14B.130 prohibited marijuana retail establishments from using drive-through and walk-up windows.

1:40:18This restriction mirrored state requirements under Oregon Administrative Rules 845-025-2885.

1:40:27In March 2020, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic and the need to promote social distancing, the Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission adopted a temporary rule allowing cannabis retailers to provide delivery and curbside pickup within 100 feet of their store boundary.

1:40:41This temporary allowance included the use of existing walk-up and drive-through windows.

1:40:47In September 2020, permanent administrative rules under Division 20— under Division 25, including Oregon Administrative Rules 845, took effect and established on-site delivery as a permanent option for licensed cannabis retailers.

1:41:02The proposed amendment would bring Portland City Code into alignment with these changes in state regulations and current industry practices by removing the outdated city-level prohibition.

1:41:13Retailers would still be required to comply with all applicable state licensing requirements and city building and land use regulations.

1:41:21Next slide, please.

1:41:23This completes my presentation, and I am available to take any questions.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:41:28 - 1:41:37

1:41:28Okay, colleagues, again, any, uh, technical questions, let's go ahead and get out.

1:41:33But we do have about 10 people signed up for public testimony as well.

1:41:36Councilor Ryan, go right ahead.

Dan Ryan 1:41:38 - 1:41:49

1:41:38I think this will be easy and quick, Christine.

1:41:40It's, um, it— I couldn't track if there was really an increase as much as there's more.

1:41:45If you're late, you want the— they want them to feel more pain?

Christina Corsi 1:41:49 - 1:41:51

1:41:49No, we do not want them to feel more pain.

Dan Ryan 1:41:52 - 1:41:58

1:41:52If they're late, doesn't the amount go up?

1:41:55Like, isn't there incentives to this to pay on time?

Christina Corsi 1:41:59 - 1:42:33

1:41:59So instead of $500 down and then requiring the remaining $3,370, uh, $3,370 in 6 months.

1:42:10We are increasing the down payment to half, which would relieve some of that financial burden within the 6 months.

1:42:19Right.

1:42:20And instead of having 2 late fees at $250 at 30 days and $500 at 60 days, we are recommending just a flat $300 late fee within 14 business days.

Dan Ryan 1:42:33 - 1:42:40

1:42:33Within 14.

1:42:34Okay, so it's about expediting the revenues coming in.

1:42:38Okay, just wanted to do a fact check on that.

Christina Corsi 1:42:40 - 1:43:10

1:42:40Thank you.

1:42:40And also, just, we do often have a lot of businesses that are experiencing economic hardship that we like to be flexible and work with and enter them into, you know, further payment plans.

1:42:54And so if there's less than that they are having to pay at the onset, or that their— that balance is due.

1:43:00We're able to help them more without pushing it to the renewal date, and then they have licensing fees and application fees, and then they're experiencing further hardship.

Dan Ryan 1:43:10 - 1:43:18

1:43:10And then was this already factored into the budget that we passed in June, these fee— this payment increase?

Christina Corsi 1:43:18 - 1:43:19

1:43:18Yes.

Dan Ryan 1:43:19 - 1:43:22

1:43:19Or payment, um, expediting the payment process?

1:43:21It was.

Christina Corsi 1:43:22 - 1:43:22

1:43:22Yes.

Dan Ryan 1:43:22 - 1:43:48

1:43:22Okay, just note to file.

1:43:24I'm pretending the city manager's there.

1:43:27Um, it really will be helpful when we go into budget this season to not be surprised that things were worked into the budget and then it's months and months later and we find out that that happened and that these were— we just have had this happen recently with a couple other bureaus, so it's a practice that I don't think any of us really enjoy.

Christina Corsi 1:43:48 - 1:43:48

1:43:48Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:43:49 - 1:44:23

1:43:49Thank you, Councilor.

1:43:52And I'll just say that again because we do have some bureau leaders in the room or watching online.

1:44:01You need to know about these changes and make the policy decisions on them before they are built into the budget.

1:44:12So for an average payor who is paying late for whatever reason, is their cost going to go up or down under this new system?

Christina Corsi 1:44:24 - 1:44:29

1:44:24Well, that all depends.

1:44:25I mean, if they are a late payee, then their cost would go down.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:44:29 - 1:44:37

1:44:29Okay.

1:44:31Is the system going to be more or less simple for a cannabis industry business?

Christina Corsi 1:44:37 - 1:44:41

1:44:37It's definitely more simple.

1:44:38It's simple for both the program and the business?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:44:42 - 1:44:51

1:44:42Perfect.

1:44:42That was my second question, was simple or more or less simple for the program.

1:44:47What portion of our licensees end up paying late on average in a year?

Christina Corsi 1:44:53 - 1:45:01

1:44:53Oh goodness, I don't have that number in front of me, but it is— it's a large number.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:45:01 - 1:45:06

1:45:01Okay.

1:45:02Is it consistent year over year which businesses it is, or does it vary?

Christina Corsi 1:45:07 - 1:45:12

1:45:07I would, I would say that we do have repeat, repeat licensees.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:45:13 - 1:45:30

1:45:13Okay.

1:45:16We may need to do some work on figuring out why that is and making sure that folks are able to pay on time.

1:45:22But in the meantime, something that is simpler both for the city and for industry seems like a good place to start a conversation.

Christina Corsi 1:45:32 - 1:45:42

1:45:32And I would like to note that as far as budget discussions, there was no changes in our licensing fees this current year.

1:45:38So there, there wasn't, you know, an increase within that budget.

Unidentified speaker 1:45:42 - 1:45:43

1:45:42Okay.

1:45:43Right.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:45:45 - 1:45:52

1:45:45Colleagues, any other questions?

1:45:49Okay, why don't we move to public testimony?

1:45:52Thank you.

Christina Corsi 1:45:52 - 1:45:54

1:45:52Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:45:57 - 1:46:17

1:45:57Thank you.

1:45:57I'll call up people in groups of 5.

1:46:02Feel free to come up and begin your testimony when you hear your name.

1:46:06Brett Born.

1:46:08Benjamin Richardson.

1:46:11Christoffer McCollom.

1:46:13Niki Terzieff.

1:46:16Cleophas Chambliss.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:46:18 - 1:46:26

1:46:18Great, thank you all so much for being here, and go right ahead while your colleagues settle in.

Bret Born 1:46:26 - 1:50:17

1:46:26Thanks for having me back again.

1:46:28I just wanted to touch base a little bit, um, on the 2 things.

1:46:32One, this— I think we all saw today how that amount of money gets gobbled up to run the program.

1:46:38And so around this, I think from a business standpoint, it's good because I can split my payments.

1:46:43I don't have a huge chunk coming in at the end of this period of the forgiveness period that I have to pay.

1:46:48So I wanted to comment on that.

1:46:50But more importantly, when we look at tax dollars coming into the City of Portland, um, over the last 3 fiscal years, $17.6 $75 million was collected with cannabis tax revenue at the tills.

1:47:02However, that doesn't show the true picture.

1:47:06The first Measure 110 Behavioral Health Network grant cycle put $91.7 million into Multnomah County.

1:47:18That being said, when we went to go look, doing research to see where that money was allocated, who it was allocated to, and what for what services, my question for councilors is, could you tell me where Measure 110— where that part of that $91.7 million ended up in your district?

1:47:34I'd like to know who got it and what services were provided and what were the outcomes.

1:47:39So that being said, we're getting another $80 million coming through on the '25 to '29 grant cycle, and we still haven't reported which 61 recipients got the money from the first cycle.

1:47:51We see 42.

1:47:53Right.

1:47:53So my concerns are, is that the city is not receiving all this money.

1:47:56We look at money taxed at the till, that's $17-point-some million.

1:48:01That's not the problem here.

1:48:02The problem is the $190 million that's going to come across the city's desk in 2 grant cycles, and we don't know where that money went.

1:48:12All right.

1:48:13This is an accusation of misuse by the City of Portland.

1:48:16This is an accusation that something's happening at BHRN in Multnomah County.

1:48:21And I'll cross it statewide.

1:48:22If you take the time to read the 2025 report from OHA, it will tell you that it was a hot mess.

1:48:28And so I don't think we can expect anything else coming our way.

1:48:32So as CPOT members, we're going to ask for this accountability and provide ways that we can use a geographical equity allocation model that looks at where the need is.

1:48:41That being said, if we really want to fund a program, those tax dollars should come directly to the city.

1:48:46Thank you.

1:48:47In my opinion, go straight to the cannabis program industry, make sure that money gets to the people that need it.

1:48:53We need to fund cannabis.

1:48:54Last thing I have to say, we took a look at the state of New York's public consumption memo.

1:49:00I couldn't get past the header.

1:49:03It said New York Division of Cannabis, not Liquor and Cannabis.

1:49:08I dug in why New York is going to protect the monster alcohol cash cow.

1:49:12Thank you.

1:49:13And not let anything get in the way while they develop and nurture their marijuana tax cow.

1:49:19We've done just the opposite here.

1:49:21Right?

1:49:22Last thing, public consumption.

1:49:24That doesn't mean smoke in public.

1:49:25I want to put this out there.

1:49:27We have 98,000 multifamily dwellings in this city, 32% of our housing.

1:49:32Millennials, Gen Zers, high percentage of our users in this state according to Bow Whitney Economics.

1:49:41So when we have all these apartment dwellers that can't smoke due to federal regulation, it might be squeezing our industry.

1:49:47So we need to look at not a place where we can go sit down and club, because there's no money in that, it's not insurable, and it won't go around the Clean Air Act based on, right, preemptive clause.

1:49:57But we need to look at providing a place for people to smoke and use cannabis, flower in particular, because it provides us with our highest profit margins as a store and the largest amount of tax for the city, and we're, we're strangling it based on our dense housing and proper urban growth boundaries.

1:50:16Thanks for your time.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:50:19 - 1:50:23

1:50:19Thank you very much.

1:50:21Um, I'm not sure who is called up next, but—.

Benjamin Richardson 1:50:24 - 1:53:31

1:50:24Hello, councilors.

1:50:25My name is Benjamin Richardson.

1:50:27I own 3 cannabis licenses and as one of the youngest cannabis license owners in Oregon It is saddening to me a little bit that we are looking to adjust these fee appliances, if you will.

1:50:47Right now, this month, I am paying my re— uh, my license renewals.

1:50:53So I'm shelling out $15,000 to the OLCC, and thank you for only requiring $500 down currently.

1:51:01Thank you.

1:51:03Because as I looked at the math, instead of being, uh, $1,500 for my license renewals to the city, it would be right around $5,000.

1:51:11One thing I think that you guys don't take into consideration, or maybe even know, is that this time of year everything is starting to slow up for cannabis.

1:51:19In December, dispensaries will start holding back on their purchasing.

1:51:24They will, they will put in orders, but they will not ask for them to be delivered until the 1st of January.

1:51:30Due to the fact of their taxation based off of their inventory, or at least their thought of that.

1:51:36So in November— sorry, in December, it gets really tight for cannabis businesses.

1:51:41Our industry really slows up, and that puts a real big chokehold on our ability to pay.

1:51:47I also believe that one, if, if we're looking at why people aren't paying, maybe we should look at the money coming in, because none of us cannabis businesses are hoarding money.

1:51:57Right.

1:51:57So if we're having a problem paying fees, maybe that's because we're not getting paid.

1:52:02So most of my business is production.

1:52:06I have my own brand and I also sell another brand in the, in the industry.

1:52:12My AR is my biggest headache.

1:52:14Same thing with you guys.

1:52:15You guys have late fees, people paying their fees late to you.

1:52:19Well, there are many a time that I'm not getting paid from dispensaries.

1:52:24So if I think if we looked at that aspect.

1:52:26Thank you.

1:52:27I would be happy to pay on time.

1:52:28I would pay all of my money on time, but I'm usually trying to rob Peter to pay Paul.

1:52:34And this adjustment in requirement of fees up front, that just makes me again look at who am I not paying.

1:52:42It is really awesome that right now I'm only having to pay $1,500, and in 6 months I will have all the rest of my fees paid.

1:52:50But if we had to shell out another I don't know, it's like $3,500 this month.

1:52:55Again, that just tells— that just asks me who's not getting paid this month.

1:53:00So really what I would like us to look at is how do we get the people that I sell products to, dispensaries, to pay on time?

1:53:10I think if you guys— if we looked at the money coming into the big businesses that are producing products and how that's being affected, Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:53:31 - 1:53:33

1:53:31Councilor McCollom.

Christoffer McCollom 1:53:33 - 1:56:38

1:53:33Good afternoon, Chair and members of the committee.

1:53:36My name is Christoffer McCollom, and I have the pleasure of serving as the business banking sales manager for Salal Credit Union.

1:53:41Salal was one of the first credit unions in the country to serve the cannabis industry, and today we proudly bank the industry in 20-plus states, including Oregon, where I have the pleasure of residing.

1:53:51I'm here today to discuss the economic realities facing the local cannabis industry through the lens of a financial institution.

1:53:57There's a common misconception that cannabis remains a green rush industry where businesses are generating significant profits.

1:54:05That's simply not the reality for most operators in the local legal cannabis market today.

1:54:10In fact, the opposite is true.

1:54:12The local cannabis market continues to struggle after years of pressure on prices and shrinking margins for licensed operators.

1:54:20At the same time, cannabis businesses continue to face higher operating costs than most other industries for comparable services.

1:54:26They pay more for banking, compliance, security, and regulatory requirements.

1:54:32They also operate under Section 280E of the federal tax code, which prevents them from deducting many ordinary business expenses that every other small business in the country takes for granted.

1:54:43This includes items like rent, marketing, insurance, and many payroll-related expenses.

1:54:49The result is that many cannabis businesses are paying taxes on income that does not reflect their actual profitability.

1:54:55From the banking side, we see this really clearly.

1:54:59One of the indicators we monitor in operating is operating account balances, which are the funds used to pay items like employees' payroll, Wow.

1:55:10In Oregon, our members' average operating account balances have declined approximately 37% in the last 2 years.

1:55:19That's an alarming downward trend that leaves us re-looking at strategic approaches.

1:55:27We also track access to capital for traditional non-cannabis business entities.

1:55:31Federal Reserve data shows that roughly 42% of businesses receive the full financing amount they request, and nearly 80% receive at least some level of funding.

1:55:42In Oregon cannabis, less than 10% of our lending inquiries result in funding at any dollar amount.

1:55:50The primary reason was insufficient cash flow to support underwriting requirements.

1:55:55This should come as a concern to all of us because it extends well beyond the cannabis license holders.

1:56:01When cannabis businesses struggle, so do commercial landlords.

1:56:04Contractors, accountants, attorneys, packaging companies, security firms, financial institutions, and the employees who rely on those industries for their livelihood.

1:56:16My message today is simple: Oregon's cannabis industry is not in the growth phase; it's in a true preservation phase.

1:56:23The struggles, issues, and concerns that the industry is here sharing with you today are real.

1:56:29As the city considers policies that affect this industry, I would encourage careful consideration of the economic realities these businesses.

1:56:36Thank you for your time and consideration.

Unidentified speaker 1:56:40 - 1:56:41

1:56:40Niki, go ahead.

Niki Terzieff 1:56:41 - 1:59:55

1:56:41Thank you, Chair, Councilors.

1:56:44Thank you for having us today and elevating the voices of these folks that are a part of the billion-dollar industry contribution to this economy here in the state of Oregon.

1:56:53Uh, we do want to take a moment just to applaud Ms. Kersey, our appreciation for the work that, um, that you do, Christina, and across the industry, a very well-respected partner to us from and representative of the city.

1:57:04And we really appreciate looking at ways to get creative as far as efforts for mitigating, um, your loss of dollars coming in.

1:57:12Uh, but that may have unintended consequences, as you heard previously, because cash flow in this business and the way cash flow works here could actually create some additional struggles.

1:57:21Um, importantly, there are additional ways that we can support them.

1:57:24Why are people late?

1:57:25Um, what are you going to hear?

1:57:26You've heard a little bit of raw emotion today because of the posture of these entrepreneurs.

1:57:31They do not have access to banking.

1:57:33They cannot, uh, declare bankruptcy.

1:57:35They're not going to jail.

1:57:36Most of these folks can't find loans at reasonable interest rates, so you're either at high interest rate or you're opting to run through a second home loan, your grandmother's inheritance, you're breaking into your retirement.

1:57:49These are very dire decisions made so that somebody can pursue their legal labor of love.

1:57:56So personal also for people who have been harmed by the criminalization of this plant over the years, over the decades.

1:58:01It has robbed families here in Oregon of intergenerational wealth, and having an opportunity to use this marketplace to recover that and to lift those entrepreneurs up is an opportunity that we should not squander.

1:58:13So additional lofty fees, they burn real hot.

1:58:17There is a perceived duplicate of structures and services and regulations that the OLCC layers on and then the City of Portland takes on.

1:58:25There is a perceived additional cost, not to mention now I've heard twice a curiosity about whether or not this is just in conflict with state law.

1:58:33The plant, the industry dripping with potential.

1:58:37I think we'd welcome a city audit more recent than the last one that was mentioned today.

1:58:42You've heard repeatedly this may not be a revenue problem, this may actually be an allocation problem.

1:58:48So the unique organ industry that is sitting before you, they deserve returned investment.

1:58:55These are durable businesses, or should be more durable businesses, and that would produce more revenue.

1:59:00Thank you.

1:59:01This will pose a cycle of growth for programs at Prosper Oregon— excuse me, Prosper Portland— pose a cycle of growth for public health and public safety programs.

1:59:11We mentioned Measure 110.

1:59:13I agree we should check out where those dollars are going.

1:59:16And we're an income state tax, so the greater the squeeze on these businesses, the less employees, the less income coming in.

1:59:23We should consider unique things like grants from PPP's allocation of these cannabis tax dollars to help harden locations.

1:59:29We should consider grants from PSEF for LED lights, high-efficiency HVACs.

1:59:33That fights environmental and economic impacts and energy costs.

1:59:36We should consider what it means when the largest city in the state of Oregon can shake its fist at the state and say, we want tourism, we want social consumption, come to Salem and help support us in our legislative pursuits.

1:59:49We don't want to be boxed in.

1:59:50This city has a chance to help us break out.

1:59:53Our hands are up.

1:59:55Please call on us.

Unidentified speaker 2:00:01 - 2:00:01

2:00:01Cleophas?

Cleophas Chambliss 2:00:01 - 2:03:10

2:00:01Hello.

2:00:02Um, I'm a volunteer.

2:00:05Um, I'm here to speak for the consumer.

2:00:09As of today, currently there's no place to consume.

2:00:12You know, like we just said, there are people that are living in apartments and they have no place to consume.

2:00:18Um, I feel as though consumption should be— of cannabis should be the same as consumption of tobacco.

2:00:26At least cannabis doesn't give you lung cancer.

2:00:29Well, we can't say that, but, um, people are, uh, consuming in their cars, which is illegal, or they're consuming in dark places where they could get harmed.

2:00:42And, um, it's just not right.

2:00:46I remember when we used to have festivals.

2:00:50Um, we had a hemp festival here and we had some other festivals Um, on the waterfront when it was medical marijuana.

2:01:00But now we don't have any festivals, and that's a way to bring consumption, um, into the public.

2:01:08And if alcohol does it, cannabis should be able to do it.

2:01:14Um, I also have ideas about— I know that in certain places there are places where you can have like cannabis-infused meals or special cocktails.

2:01:24There's a lot that can be done in this industry to grow the tourism market, but also help the local consumer, because right now our hands are tied.

2:01:36And that could be another problem why sales are down.

2:01:38There's no place to consume, or what you consume is not— you can't consume flower, which is the number one seller.

2:01:46Yeah.

2:01:47And so, um, I just want to say that we could do better in the city.

2:01:55I mean, we could be great.

2:01:56We are great.

2:01:58Our flower is great.

2:02:00Our dispensaries are great.

2:02:01The variety of products that are available are great.

2:02:05And we just need to make the whole system better to where we can consume.

2:02:10Um, we were able to— I went with a group of friends this We just wanted a place to sit down together and smoke and enjoy each other's company and listen to the music, just like going to a bar.

2:02:29There's a bar almost— there's 1 to 2 bars on every block.

2:02:33It's ridiculous.

2:02:34But there's no place for us to consume cannabis.

2:02:37It's just not right.

2:02:37Thank you.

2:02:38It's just not right.

2:02:40Like, I don't consume alcohol.

2:02:43I enjoy cannabis, and a lot of other people do as well.

2:02:47So I'm speaking for those that are not here that consume and purchase your market.

2:02:52That's your— those are your consumers.

2:02:54Those are the people that buy the cannabis to make that billion dollars of sales.

2:03:01We need our rights as well.

2:03:03Thank you.

2:03:04We want a place to consume legally.

2:03:08Thank you.

2:03:08Thank you.

2:03:09Peace be with you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:03:11 - 2:03:15

2:03:11Thank you all very much for being here and adding to the conversation today.

2:03:14We appreciate it.

Unidentified speaker 2:03:17 - 2:03:26

2:03:17Call the next panel: Peter Racht, Colin Hobbs, Cory Cooper, Brian Staffa, and Eddy Montes.

Niki Terzieff 2:03:39 - 2:03:41

2:03:39Uh, Chair, Mr. Racht has taken off.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:03:42 - 2:03:42

2:03:42I'm sorry?

Niki Terzieff 2:03:43 - 2:03:44

2:03:43Uh, Mr. Peter Racht has left.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:03:44 - 2:03:49

2:03:44Okay, thank you.

2:03:46Thank you.

2:03:49Go right ahead.

Eddie Montes 2:03:51 - 2:06:23

2:03:51Hi there, Council.

2:03:53My name is Eddie Montes.

2:03:54I'm I'm an Oregon-born native.

2:03:57I live and own a cannabis delivery service here in Portland, District 3.

2:04:03It's called Kush Cart.

2:04:05We've been operating since January of 2018 and currently employ 16 people who also live throughout the city.

2:04:12I'm happy to say that I pay all my bills on time and have no debts with any of the city or our partners.

2:04:18I'm here to ask for support from the city in the form of advocacy financial relief, and rule changes.

2:04:25Currently, in order to operate a retail delivery service in Portland, the city requires us to pay close to $1,500 for the license and associated fees yearly.

2:04:35This is on top of the $5,000 we spend with the OLCC yearly to renew our retail license and an additional 3%, uh, we provide to the city from every sale that goes towards public safety and education.

2:04:48Since cannabis is not federally legal, we do not get to We do not get the same tax benefits as most businesses here, so every additional dollar we have to spend has to be put to good use.

2:05:00I wouldn't mind paying these additional fees if the city allowed us to deliver to hotels or other non-residential buildings.

2:05:07This would help bolster Portland's hospitality to non-locals who visit.

2:05:12We reject— we've rejected thousands of orders since our launch due to this rule.

2:05:17Thank you.

2:05:18Additionally, we could also provide more tax revenue for the city if we could deliver to our neighbors in Milwaukee, Beaverton, or Gresham.

2:05:26Currently, adjacent counties or cities need to opt in for delivery from Portland in order for us to deliver and serve them.

2:05:34This is unnecessary.

2:05:36No other delivery business is restricted like this, and it prevents us from serving people who benefit from our service.

2:05:44We have close to 1,000 Google reviews to show as a testimony of our benefit that we bring to our local community.

2:05:52This is not only in regards to convenience, but also the— for the folks who are medical patients or have ailments that prevent them from leaving their homes.

2:06:01Portland is the largest city in Oregon, and it should be spearheading innovation in this industry, pushing the limits to create a more fruitful environment for everyone involved.

2:06:10Thank you.

2:06:11I urge you to stand up and fight for our right to be treated with dignity and respect, as, as it is preached time over time for small businesses you all serve.

2:06:20Thank you for your time.

2:06:21I appreciate the opportunity to speak.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:06:24 - 2:06:25

2:06:24Thank you very much.

Unidentified speaker 2:06:25 - 2:06:30

2:06:25Colin is joining us online.

2:06:27Colin, you can unmute and begin your testimony.

Christoffer McCollom 2:06:31 - 2:08:38

2:06:31Thank you very much.

2:06:31I appreciate you for the opportunity to speak today, councilors.

2:06:35Um, I've been in the cannabis industry for 13 years.

2:06:38I've worked at a variety of different businesses that have a significant difference in size, multi-state operators, small 3-person businesses.

2:06:47And I'm one of those people who in 2018 was unable to file for bankruptcy when my, when my business collapsed and had to face lawsuits from 7 or 8 different creditors.

2:06:58My family almost became homeless.

2:07:01So there's some real struggle out there for some of the folks in the cannabis industry.

2:07:05A lot of regulation, way too much, and a lot of that comes from the federal level.

2:07:12Jeanette, would you mind muting, please?

2:07:13Thank you.

2:07:15And I think that, you know, if we could get a little respite at a local level, I think it would go a long way.

2:07:22I currently serve as the, as the chair of the board of directors for the Cannabis Industry Alliance, and I know that a lot of our members really feel this way.

2:07:32It's difficult to do business in Portland, not only because the lack of police response at times, but because it's more difficult with the regulations here, and it's more costly to do business here.

2:07:42My business is currently— I have a wholesale in District 3.

2:07:45As our business currently grows, and I'll be looking for a new place to expand, I will very much be looking outside of Portland unless the situation changes.

2:07:56There are advantages to going right, as close as I can get to Portland without being in city limits.

2:08:03And that's just because it's more advantageous, because they're more friendly with their business climate.

2:08:08We've seen so many large businesses leave Oregon.

2:08:11Look at Dutch Brothers, right?

2:08:13Packed up and left.

2:08:14They left Grants Pass and they went down to Arizona because the business climate was a better fit for them.

2:08:19And it was an expensive move.

2:08:21And as a microcosm of that, you're going to see local businesses move to other areas.

2:08:23Thank you.

2:08:23Local businesses in Portland pack up and leave the city when they have the opportunity to do so because there's more advantageous business climates outside of the city limits.

2:08:33And I really hope, I really hope we see some change.

2:08:36So I'll yield the rest of my time.

2:08:37Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:08:40 - 2:08:41

2:08:40Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:08:41 - 2:08:41

2:08:41Cory?

Cory Cooper 2:08:43 - 2:10:16

2:08:43Hey, thanks for having us.

2:08:45You know, I would echo what a lot of other people have said.

2:08:50We have 4 licenses, all in District 2.

2:08:54We employ 46 people.

2:08:59But, you know, with regards to the licensing that the city— part of the problem, right, is just keeping track of all the timelines, I think, you know, between— we have different timelines for each OLCC license with each city license.

2:09:16And it's, you know, as we've downsized, to try to maintain our business.

2:09:23You know, more— everybody's been stretched thinner and thinner, you know.

2:09:28So I feel like the first couple years— we've been in, you know, business for 10 years plus now, going on, I think, year 11.

2:09:38You know, the first years, I think we were pretty good about doing everything on time, being on top of all of our paperwork, you know.

2:09:45And now it's year 10 and it's like—.

2:09:46Yeah.

2:09:46You know, I think a common refrain in the industry is death by 1,000 paper cuts.

2:09:54You know, and it isn't any one thing in particular, but it's a lot of what, you know, everybody up here has said.

2:10:01You know, I don't know how much change can affect at the city level, but, you know, for us, having started as a small processor in a 3,000-square-foot space, we expanded to a warehouse with 7,000 square feet.

2:10:15And then we expanded to a 15,000-square-foot warehouse.

Dan Ryan 2:10:16 - 2:10:16

2:10:16Wow.

Cory Cooper 2:10:16 - 2:11:53

2:10:16We were able to grab another processor license and grab another retail license.

2:10:23But, you know, as a result, we're paying a lot more license fees than, you know, what you would in an ideal scenario where you have one facility.

2:10:33So we're looking to consolidate our facilities and we're, you know, targeting spots outside of Portland to find a big facility.

2:10:41Thank you.

2:10:42You know, again, I'm going to echo what another person has said.

2:10:53I don't know how much change can be affected at the city level.

2:10:56You know, so I would think the biggest thing that you guys could do to help the industry is really advocate for us at the level of the OLCC.

2:11:04The cannabis industry, you know, all the excitement for all the possibilities that were, you know, presented to us, you know, present in the industry, you know, 2015, at the beginning of it, has largely all, you know, evaporated.

2:11:20And, you know, we're basically stuck with overall just lack of excitement and jadedness, you know, just because of the lack of progress.

2:11:31We went from being like at the forefront, you know, everybody likes to think of Portland as a progressive city.

2:11:36Yeah.

2:11:37And, you know, and we see, you know, states that aren't considered progressive, you know, becoming leaders in this industry that we feel like we have a superior, you know, competitive advantage to the rest of the country.

2:11:51And thanks for your time.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:11:54 - 2:11:56

2:11:54Thank you very much, both of you.

Unidentified speaker 2:11:56 - 2:12:00

2:11:56Brian is joining us online.

2:11:58Go ahead and unmute, Brian.

2:11:59Begin your testimony.

Brian Staffa 2:12:02 - 2:15:18

2:12:02Hey, thank you all for having me on.

2:12:03Thank you for providing the opportunity to speak.

2:12:07My name is Brian Staffa.

2:12:09I'm the CEO and managing partner of High Revival Holdings.

2:12:14And in— we have 5 licenses across the state, or excuse me, 6, and 3 of them are in Portland.

2:12:22I have 2 dispensaries in Portland, and I also have a very small cultivation facility as part of one of my retail operations in Portland.

2:12:32And I'm here today to speak virtually.

2:12:34Thank you.

2:12:35What I do as part of High Revival is I try to find the businesses that are struggling, uh, to be able to allow those owners an opportunity to exit, uh, so that I can turn those businesses around, uh, and save jobs, uh, and potentially save some, save some tax revenue for, for everyone involved.

2:12:54Uh, and I'll say, uh, I will never acquire an additional business in the city of Portland unless things change.

2:13:03I, like I said, I've got those 3 licenses in Portland.

2:13:06I have a license in Albany, I have a license in Eugene, and I have a license in Springfield.

2:13:11To give you guys a very clear comparison, my city license fees in Albany are zero.

2:13:19My city license fee in Eugene is $165.

2:13:24That is compared to the $4,565 that Leanne so eloquently put.

2:13:28Yeah.

2:13:29Earlier in testimony, and I ask, what is it that I get for that?

2:13:36The—.

2:13:36What I've experienced in Portland is I've had to spend on armed security at some of my dispensaries because of police response time.

2:13:45I've had the privilege of operating across 31 legal states over the last 13 years, and the security, the police response time is actually a running joke among the industry, and we've had to band together to solve for our own solutions.

2:14:05And I'd say the, the greatest challenge is that I see myself as being someone that's in the compliance business.

2:14:12If I do my job really well, I get to then manufacture and sell cannabis, and the cost of compliance in this city is so onerous.

2:14:23Yeah.

2:14:23Uh, to provide one very specific suggestion, make it so that we are paying monthly fees instead of the, you know, the— I will say the deferred payment plan has been helpful, but it doesn't go far enough.

2:14:44Uh, I, as I've really brought on my accounting teams and really tried to do everything exactly right, pay all my fees on time, that includes my license fees, I have not been able to do that.

2:14:55That includes the alarm permit fee that I need to permit to pay so that the police can charge me for false alarms.

2:15:02Finally, when I had the city assessor and the county assessor come and tell me that if I was lucky enough to be profitable, that I still have to pay an additional tax on top of all of the fees, that by itself was, was really the final straw.

2:15:17I appreciate the time.

2:15:17Thank you all.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:15:18 - 2:15:20

2:15:18Thank you very much.

Unidentified speaker 2:15:22 - 2:15:23

2:15:22That concludes testimony.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:15:25 - 2:16:13

2:15:25Thank you.

2:15:26Thank you.

2:15:26Thank you to everybody who took the time to, uh, share your business stories with us and help us gain some additional understanding about the, the way the industry is operating and the code change before us.

2:15:40I know that I heard some, some new ideas through that testimony on what the industry might need that I'm sure we'll get back to in future discussion.

2:15:49Colleagues, is there any discussion on the ordinance before us?

2:15:54This is the, uh, amendment to the Marijuana Regulatory License Procedure and Requirements Code.

2:16:08If there is— oh.

2:16:13Councilor Avalos.

Candace Avalos 2:16:16 - 2:16:58

2:16:16Yeah, thank you.

2:16:17Um, hi everybody.

2:16:18Uh, apologies that I am not there in person.

2:16:20Thank you to all of the testifiers for, um, sharing a bit about your experiences with your businesses and also the presentation earlier.

2:16:29Um, the earlier presentation, you know, outlined, I guess, where all of the fees are going, but what I didn't fully hear is why we have, um, the fee that we set it at.

2:16:41Just from a quick, you know, looking on the internet, looking around at neighboring cities, getting a sense for how much everybody is charging for the cannabis licensing fees, there just seems to be a lot of variety.

2:16:52And I guess I wanted to hear maybe from staff about why we landed on the amount that we did.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:17:03 - 2:17:06

2:17:03We've got folks coming up to answer that question right now, Councilor.

Christina Corsi 2:17:12 - 2:17:52

2:17:12Again, for the record, Christina Corsi.

2:17:14To answer your question, in the beginning of the program, so implementation in 2015, 2016, licensing fees were actually $4,975.

2:17:27We are 100% cost recovery program, so therefore every year we do annual fee studies.

2:17:33And through the years, we've actually lowered our fees.

2:17:37Up until, um, 2 fiscal years ago, we increased them from $3,500 to $3,970, and that was just after determining the cost of running the program with staff and incidentals.

Candace Avalos 2:17:55 - 2:18:05

2:17:55Would you happen to know, just comparatively, how the fees for cannabis does cannabis licensing differ to alcohol licensing?

2:18:03Is that something that we keep track of at the city level?

Christina Corsi 2:18:06 - 2:18:41

2:18:06Yes, absolutely.

2:18:07So I'm actually the liquor program manager also.

2:18:10So we are pushing forward in this next legislative session to increase liquor licensing fees.

2:18:19Right now, for— they range for a new application, $75, for a change of ownership, $100, for renewal, $35.

2:18:29Um, this was set by the Oregon State Legislature in 1999 and did not, um, consider any type of inflation over the years.

2:18:37And that is something that is set for all jurisdictions, is that price.

Candace Avalos 2:18:43 - 2:21:06

2:18:43That's good to know.

2:18:45Um, yeah, well, thank you.

2:18:47I, I think I'm just reacting to, um, what we're hearing.

2:18:51Obviously folks are describing hardship and concern about increasing the rate at which we collect the amount because of cash flow issues and just other things that we heard in the testimony.

2:19:03So I'm kind of just still sitting with that and not sure what to do with that information right now.

2:19:09I see the proposal in front of us as a, you know, if you take away all of that and just look at like an administrative and, you know, cost recovery kind of way, it makes Thank you.

2:19:22I think that the ordinance makes sense on its face, but I think when you tie it in with this broader ecosystem of what cannabis businesses might be facing, how it might be different from other businesses, and the fact that it's, you know, a new and emerging area and industry, and especially I agree with the comments about how could we, you know, take advantage of maybe some cannabis tourism.

2:19:43I know I would love to see that as a representative of District 1 who has the airport.

2:19:48You know, I'd love to see that be more of a thing that we try to do, but I recognize I that it's a recognize very that there are some state-level barriers to the city doing much on that, and I'm open to hearing, you know, if there's any interest from councilors to talk to the legislature about those kinds of restrictions so that we can look at what potential economic development opportunities there are.

2:20:09So yeah, just processing out loud what I'm hearing.

2:20:12Again, the ordinance is straightforward, and I haven't made a final decision on how I plan to vote on it right now.

2:20:21But I guess I would love to keep thinking as a committee about exploring more of, you know, what— how we are supporting the businesses.

2:20:31And I also will name and appreciate that there has been a lot of, like, technical assistance, for example, that we've been offering.

2:20:38I'm hearing Prosper say that there is some money available still in capital to hand out in loans that, you know, I want to make sure people hear, because if there's availability, availability So yeah, just not sure how I feel, but I'm concerned about the broader ecosystem and ready to talk with all the folks who have testified about potential policy solutions.

2:21:05Thanks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:21:08 - 2:21:11

2:21:08Thank you, Councilor.

2:21:10Councilor Ryan?

Candace Avalos 2:21:11 - 2:21:12

2:21:11Oh, sure.

Dan Ryan 2:21:14 - 2:22:56

2:21:14First of all, thank you to the presenters.

2:21:15Thank you.

2:21:16Thank you to the folks who took time out of their day.

2:21:18That impacts your profit margins as well to advocate for us, for your industry.

2:21:24It's not lost on me that we haven't had a moment like this yet in the chambers, and we've been hearing, I think, one-sided perspective on this.

2:21:34So it was really important that we daylighted what your concerns are.

2:21:39Like the previous speaker, Councilor Councilor Avalos, I'm reflecting on a lot of what I heard today, and you gave some very blunt, crisp feedback to us, and I wanted to just put that out there.

2:21:55And I also just have to say that I was disappointed the members from Prosper Portland left the chambers.

2:22:03They are administrating— they administer these funds.

2:22:07And you all gave some really good feedback.

2:22:10And I'm going to ask to hear that Prosper Portland's listening to your testimony since they left before they could hear the majority of it.

2:22:19So I wanted to daylight that concern.

2:22:22I do have a question for you, Christina.

2:22:23This, this was eye-opening for me.

2:22:25Um, I know you're in this world more often than all of us, but I can't right now think it's a good idea to just rush the approval of this based on what I just listened to.

2:22:38And I'm wondering if you and your team is comfortable reflecting on some of the feedback you heard, and if you could provide some edits, uh, to what, what we are proposing based on what I thought was some very thoughtful, um, helpful suggestions.

Christina Corsi 2:22:56 - 2:24:05

2:22:56Yes, so I actually have stats from a, from a question.

2:23:00Um, over the course of 3 years, from 2023 to 2026, of the second late fee, we charged 151 late fees.

2:23:11That would be additional $500.

2:23:13In an effort to support the cannabis industry, we have waived 123 late fees.

2:23:20Um, so just moving up a timeline from 30 days, or actually 60 days, to 14 days gives us more opportunity to provide more flexibility and work more closely with those businesses that are experiencing those struggles.

2:23:38Often what we do see is that, you know, our requests for, you know, the 30-day late fee gets ignored, it's 60-day late fee that is also ignored, and once we start enforcement action, that is when they want to come to the table and, and work with us.

2:23:52Thank you.

2:23:52On a payment plan.

2:23:53So just by moving up that timeline, it's allowing them more opportunity for us to work with them so they don't experience that financial hardship coming up on renewal.

Dan Ryan 2:24:07 - 2:24:28

2:24:07Thank you.

2:24:08And so you're letting me know that there are some adjustments that you're proposing today that would be helpful based on what you heard.

2:24:16For example, when the one gentleman stated that It would be better to have lower monthly fees.

2:24:22And is that an example of what you can do for a said organization if they asked for it?

Christina Corsi 2:24:29 - 2:24:49

2:24:29Yes, if they ask for it.

2:24:30It's not something that we offer upfront because tracking gets very difficult.

2:24:33But if somebody does, you know, acknowledge that they communicate that they're experiencing that financial hardship and unable to pay the licensing fee at that time, we do work with them.

2:24:44To make sure that they are still in compliance and not receiving enforcement action or repeated late fees.

Dan Ryan 2:24:50 - 2:26:11

2:24:50Okay, um, I'm not comfortable today passing this on to the full council without Prosper Portland and your office working together to give some feedback to what was listened to today and how we can work in partnership.

2:25:04The amount of revenue I saw leaving the city based on folks saying that when their leases are expire, that they will be moving out of Portland, is troublesome.

2:25:15We're known as the city council that's experiencing the biggest loss of that type of revenue from our city, and we want to stop that.

2:25:23Mm-hmm.

2:25:23And so when we're in these moments in time, we have to make sure that we're cognizant of the small businesses that are coming to us that are asking for an opportunity to keep their businesses here.

2:25:35And we heard some great suggestions.

2:25:36I also think that Government Affairs and this council can have some dialogue about what we can do in parallel structure with the state.

2:25:45I think the contrast with the OLC regulations with alcohol and cannabis are a lot more stark than I realized until the question was asked directly.

2:25:55Yeah.

2:25:55So I'm just, um, I'm here to help get this right, you know that.

2:25:59And I think that today was a big step in airing out in public, which is good government, And I think now we have to take a pause to see if we got this right.

2:26:09But I feel too rushed today to vote yes on this.

Christina Corsi 2:26:12 - 2:26:26

2:26:12Thanks.

2:26:13I would like to say that I support the cannabis industry 100%, and everything that they've said, I also acknowledge.

2:26:20We welcome the feedback, and we also welcome the opportunity to work further with council on how we can support the industry further.

Dan Ryan 2:26:28 - 2:26:38

2:26:28I'd like to see you coming together with a solution, and right now there's a bridge that seems that we could cross, but right now it's a distance.

2:26:38Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:26:39 - 2:27:43

2:26:39Thank you, Councilor.

2:26:41One of the things that I heard in the testimony that I hadn't quite realized was that operations have a separate license for every location, and where they are limited in location size, I'm not thinking about dispensaries where you might want multiple locations around the city to reach different consumer bases, but where they're limited in size on the cultivation and production end simply by the real estate that's available.

2:27:12Mm-hmm.

2:27:13I wonder if we have ever considered allowing for a license to cover multiple non— again, not dispensaries, but production, cultivation, or distribution centers If they are identical in the work, in the operations that's happening and run by the same company, is that something that we have looked at as a way to help lower costs for that, that manufacturing side that has a potential to support jobs in our community?

Christina Corsi 2:27:43 - 2:27:58

2:27:43So that is not something that we've looked at, and we've just tailored our fee structure around they have to obtain an OLCC license, a state license, And then they come and get the city license.

2:27:53So we've just been kind of duplicating the license, so to speak.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:27:58 - 2:28:24

2:27:58Okay.

2:27:59It was notable to me when I heard somebody say they might look for a facility outside of Portland where they could have a larger facility.

2:28:08And if we are, again, because of the size of production or cultivation spaces, inadvertently driving people out of the city because they're paying those duplicative fees for identical operations.

2:28:22That's something that I hope we could think about in the future.

Christina Corsi 2:28:25 - 2:28:25

2:28:25Absolutely.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:28:25 - 2:28:54

2:28:25Okay, colleagues, I heard Councilor Ryan say he is not ready to move this forward today.

2:28:30Councilors Avalos and Morillo, I'd be curious to hear where you are at, but I do want to ask our bureau first, uh, what is your timing and are there complications that we should know about if we don't move this One thing I'd like to add, so I'd like to clarify our earlier response.

Eric Kooch 2:28:55 - 2:28:57

2:28:55These changes did not impact this year's budget.

Christina Corsi 2:28:58 - 2:29:07

2:28:58We're not anticipating any additional revenues from this, so this wasn't something that we anticipated in June that we added in there.

2:29:06So I just wanted to clarify that.

Eric Kooch 2:29:09 - 2:29:15

2:29:09Christina, did you want to add anything as far as how it could impact us if we did not move forward today.

Christina Corsi 2:29:15 - 2:29:18

2:29:15Is there anything timeline-wise that could impact us?

2:29:18No.

Unidentified speaker 2:29:18 - 2:29:19

2:29:18Okay.

2:29:19Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:29:19 - 2:29:31

2:29:19And are these changes already in operation?

2:29:22You said something about not having received pushback.

2:29:24So is this a check the box, you're already doing this and we need to update code, or is this implementing something new?

Christina Corsi 2:29:32 - 2:29:47

2:29:32We implemented these changes in August of 2026.

2:29:36Okay.

2:29:37After they were included into the, The new fee schedule for fiscal year '26-'27, that is just the, just the 50% down.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:29:47 - 2:29:51

2:29:47Okay, thank you.

2:29:49Councilor Avalos, go right ahead.

Candace Avalos 2:29:54 - 2:30:03

2:29:54Wait, on that last part, what the changes that were implemented in August were a change in the fee amount, or you're already doing the 50% down requirement?

Christina Corsi 2:30:04 - 2:30:14

2:30:04We're already doing the 50% down requirement, and it was It was added into the fee schedule that was approved by council in the last budget cycle.

Candace Avalos 2:30:16 - 2:30:19

2:30:16So then what does this action do that's different if we're already doing it?

Christina Corsi 2:30:20 - 2:30:22

2:30:20This is just amending the code to our current processes.

Candace Avalos 2:30:24 - 2:30:24

2:30:24I see.

Christina Corsi 2:30:24 - 2:30:26

2:30:24And changing, changing the fixed dollar amounts.

Candace Avalos 2:30:28 - 2:30:40

2:30:28Got it.

2:30:28Okay.

2:30:29So it sounds like either way, what is before us or the Yeah, the changes have already been made, so this is just about updating the language to reflect what we've already done, just to confirm that's what's happening?

Christina Corsi 2:30:41 - 2:30:41

2:30:41Correct.

Candace Avalos 2:30:41 - 2:31:21

2:30:41Okay, so then I had my hand raised because in the spirit of, you know, trying to figure out how we talk through these things in committee, I was wondering if Councilor Ryan— and I see you're next in the queue, so maybe you can just answer this when you get in there— but I'm just trying to get a sense of like what it is that's holding you back because I'm grappling with it too, but I guess especially hearing what I just heard, it seems like this is largely procedural, but there are some broader, you know, cannabis industry questions that came in, came through the testimony that are worth discussing, but I don't know are necessarily related to the ordinance.

2:31:15So maybe if you could just share a little bit more so I could get a sense of what you're thinking about and can react to that.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:31:24 - 2:31:25

2:31:24Councilor Ryan, go right ahead.

Dan Ryan 2:31:26 - 2:34:44

2:31:26Thank you, Councilor.

2:31:30When do you have a moment in time to actually air something out and to get to the bottom of this disconnect between an industry that, when you listen to them, is not very content with doing business in Portland, an industry that has a lot of opportunity in the city of Portland, And so this procedure allowed us to air all this out, and that's what was most important to me today.

2:32:01Procedurally, I'm comfortable.

2:32:04Well, I learned today that the practice is already in motion and that we're just retroactively doing these changes.

2:32:12I question if the people that were here— many of them had to leave because again, they're running businesses.

2:32:17Yeah.

2:32:18If they even knew that this was already implemented in August, the nonverbal made me— would suggest that they did not.

2:32:26And so I think we're at a moment in time where we just have to figure out how the city and Prosper Portland can work better with this industry that feels pretty left out of this process.

2:32:42And and so I'm kind of using leverage right now to say, if it wasn't for this code coming up, we could have maybe had this conversation.

2:32:52And I thought it needed to be daylighted based on what I've been hearing.

2:32:56Again, I really thank all of you for coming today.

2:33:00I've had my ear bent on this for a while.

2:33:03When I was doing the storefronts, that's when it first came to me.

2:33:06I think the agriculture opportunities the opportunities that the city's missing out on are vast.

2:33:12I know somebody that's doing growing not for cannabis, but for basil and lettuce just 3 blocks into Milwaukee because they couldn't get a license, they couldn't get permits in Portland.

2:33:25And agricultural updates in other countries are taking over large buildings in downtown areas.

2:33:33And so I just think we're missing out.

2:33:34I think the the fact that PSEF came up as an opportunity.

2:33:39I don't— I couldn't agree more that we're taking what is ours, which is a growing climate that's world-renowned, and we're not seizing the moment in terms of this being a prosperous system in a state of Oregon, which everyone would assume we could just pull that off.

2:34:00Thank you.

2:34:01So I do think that the City of Portland has to take a leadership role in waking up perhaps the state and OLCC on the fact that we're missing out on, and we're leaving money on the table, if you will, because we're not building a better system for this industry.

2:34:21So I'm comfortable just to table this until we get some more concrete answers.

2:34:27And we, we have Prosper Portland, the cannabis industry, and the good people in permitting come together to maybe take care of this cosmetic issue that almost sounds like, but have a vision on where we're going and not just wait for another regulatory conversation to air this out.

Candace Avalos 2:34:46 - 2:36:01

2:34:46Okay, thank you for sharing your thinking.

2:34:49I guess my reaction to that is I— if this is cosmetic, I don't see— I guess I don't feel maybe as strongly about tabling this now or not moving it forward.

2:35:07It's good to know that there is no time limit necessarily, per what staff are saying.

2:35:11Um, and it sounds like what I'm hearing you say, Councilor, is also like if we table it, this would create just another place Is that kind of your intention for possibly delaying it?

2:35:24Which I think is a way to do it, but I guess I would have a suggestion of maybe can we just create more space for that policy discussion?

2:35:32Because those, I think, solutions aren't necessarily going to be tied to this cosmetic code thing, especially if they're already doing it, right?

2:35:39So that's what I, you know, because the chair asked, you know, how we're feeling, because one of us was feeling like not wanting to move it forward.

2:35:46I'm still trying to figure out where I'm landing, but I guess I would feel maybe more comfortable moving it out of committee because it seems cosmetic, and then ask that we do bring back more discussion to this committee about the broader, you know, industry problems.

2:36:00Is that— is that—.

Dan Ryan 2:36:02 - 2:37:14

2:36:02Yeah, and I'm comfortable tabling it and knowing that although it was implemented in August with practices, it's clear to me that the lobby of the industry wasn't brought along, and so maybe there there still could be edits to that and stay focused on the fact that we've been not— we've been, let's see, what's the right word?

2:36:25We haven't been focused on this issue.

2:36:26We looked at it as, oh, cannabis is going to do great.

2:36:29There's going to be a lot of money coming in.

2:36:31Let's find our causes and get money over to Prosper.

2:36:34I mean, it happened really fast and now it's 10 years plus later.

2:36:40Yeah.

2:36:41And we're having people that know about this better than any of us telling us, time out, it's not going that well.

2:36:48Like, we're— we need to, to come together to work with you to try to figure out how we can have better policy.

2:36:56Um, that starts— all we can do is focus on the city, but we maybe have to also focus on lobbying the state for some of these changes.

2:37:04So I'm comfortable tabling it so we can keep the conversation fluid.

2:37:09And I don't always trust when these moments slip by that you're going to have another chance to air this out.

Candace Avalos 2:37:17 - 2:37:42

2:37:17Okay.

2:37:18And then maybe one last quick question to staff.

2:37:22If there were changes desired because you're already implementing it, I guess what would it require to make a change?

2:37:28I'm not suggesting a change, but just procedurally want to know what that would look like if, for example, we're tabling this to have more discussion to possibly make some kind of change in the future.

2:37:37What does that look like for something that, again, this is cosmetic and you're already make— you've already made the change?

Christina Corsi 2:37:43 - 2:37:47

2:37:43Uh, so is your question what would it take to revert it back to what it was?

Candace Avalos 2:37:48 - 2:37:53

2:37:48I guess.

2:37:49I don't know what the change is that people are seeking, but to make a change like reverting it back.

Christina Corsi 2:37:54 - 2:38:32

2:37:54Yeah, so, um, we did alert the industry over the course of June and August.

2:38:00We sent out 3 newsletters and welcomed any feedback and comment, and we did not receive any.

2:38:05So therefore, we moved forward with the changes because we received little to no feedback, especially no negative feedback.

2:38:14As far as what would it take to revert these changes back to— it says in code $500 down, but we were overcharging $600 due to annual fee increases over the years.

2:38:28Okay.

2:38:29Um, it would just be writing a new script in our technology portal to revert it back.

Candace Avalos 2:38:36 - 2:38:43

2:38:36Okay, thank you for that.

2:38:37Um, I guess I'll see where the rest of the conversation takes us and if we're going to move on to vote or not.

2:38:43Thanks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:38:44 - 2:39:23

2:38:44So colleagues, um, we do need to move on and at least begin the next item on our agenda.

2:38:54It sounds It sounds like there is interest in more conversation whether we move this forward today or table it for the future.

2:39:04I don't hear an interest from councilors in asking the Bureau to revert to the way they were previously operating.

2:39:11I didn't hear that interest from stakeholders either.

2:39:14And I did hear at least one stakeholder say that this change would be helpful.

2:39:19So I want to be clear that I don't think we're asking you all to—.

Niki Terzieff 2:39:23 - 2:39:23

2:39:23I think that's a good point.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:39:24 - 2:40:22

2:39:24Revert, though there was a question about how that would happen.

2:39:28I could entertain a motion at this point to move this forward, or I could, without objection, continue the item to a future meeting, either the December meeting if that is enough time for folks to sit down together, or the first meeting of the new year if more time is needed.

2:39:48So I'm going to pause for dramatic effect and see if anybody would like to make a motion to move this to the full council.

2:39:54And if I don't hear one, then I will, um, continue the item.

2:40:04Okay, so if we are going to continue this item, does a December 8th meeting give you all enough time to have the conversations that Councilor Ryan has asked for, or should I continue it to the first meeting of the new Yeah, I think so.

2:40:21Yeah.

2:40:21December?

Christina Corsi 2:40:23 - 2:40:27

2:40:23Yeah, I think we can, um, I think we can make that work.

Dan Ryan 2:40:27 - 2:40:28

2:40:27December 8th, right?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:40:28 - 2:40:29

2:40:28December 8th.

Candace Avalos 2:40:29 - 2:40:29

2:40:29Yeah.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:40:29 - 2:40:57

2:40:29So colleagues, I will— without objection, I will continue this item to the December 8th meeting.

2:40:36I will note for folks who are, um, paying attention to this item that if we hear heading into that meeting that there just hasn't been enough work done, what we'll do is open the item and immediately continue it on to a January meeting to make sure that there's time for the work to happen.

2:40:54But we'll shoot for December 8th.

Christina Corsi 2:40:57 - 2:40:58

2:40:57Okay, thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:40:59 - 2:41:06

2:40:59With that continuation, let's move on to the 4th item on our agenda.

2:41:02Thank you, everybody.

2:41:05And Councilor Avalos?

Candace Avalos 2:41:07 - 2:41:35

2:41:07Yeah, sorry, just one last comment.

2:41:09Um, so if this is continuing on to December, and I heard you say, is that enough time for, you know, Councilor Ryan to discuss?

2:41:16I guess I'm just wondering, what is the step that's being taken?

2:41:19Is Councilor Ryan doing something between now and then?

2:41:21Are we supposed to be doing something?

2:41:23I guess I don't know what the changes are, especially since a lot of what I heard today wasn't exactly about that exact change.

2:41:30It was broader industry things.

2:41:31So I guess I'm just unclear on what my next step is as a committee member.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:41:36 - 2:42:21

2:41:36I believe that Councilor Ryan will be following up with the Bureau and convening a conversation with the Bureau and industry about what else could be added by amendment to this ordinance before we move it forward.

2:41:52If any members of the committee are interested in being a part of that conversation, as a 5-member committee, quorum is 3, so it would be one other member would be able to reach out to Councilor Ryan's office to talk about being a part of that conversation.

2:42:06And otherwise, I think we wait to see what amendments might come forward at the, at the next meeting.

2:42:13And I will just say for myself, I'm interested in thinking about how we help with the manufacturing and that job-producing industrial side.

Dan Ryan 2:42:22 - 2:42:45

2:42:22Yeah, and I think it's one step at a time, but I know that this will be a healthy step based on the nonverbal in the room.

2:42:28So, and also when you said that it's already been implemented So, you know, that was fascinating.

2:42:37So I think that, um, I think that it's okay to, to wait for a few more weeks as we get this right between the industry and the people in the Bureau.

Christina Corsi 2:42:45 - 2:42:46

2:42:45Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:42:46 - 2:42:50

2:42:46And Councilor, it may be worth reaching out to Councilor Avalos to see if she's interested in being a part as well.

Dan Ryan 2:42:51 - 2:42:53

2:42:51And you all just reach out to me.

2:42:52Yeah, we can always talk one-on-one.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:42:54 - 2:42:56

2:42:54Okay.

2:42:55Yeah, thank you all.

Christoffer McCollom 2:42:56 - 2:42:56

2:42:56Thank you.

Christina Corsi 2:42:56 - 2:42:58

2:42:56Forward to future conversations.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:42:58 - 2:43:02

2:42:58Thank you.

2:42:58We look forward to having you back.

2:43:00And Wendy, could you please call item 4 on the agenda?

Unidentified speaker 2:43:03 - 2:43:14

2:43:03Item number 4, document number 2026-406, amend the Portland Clean Energy Community Benefits Fund Climate Investment Plan to include workforce and contractor equity agreement.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:43:16 - 2:43:33

2:43:16Thank you.

2:43:17And thank you, Mr. Barrasso and Director Engstrom, for your patience as we got to this item.

2:43:26Wendy, so that we can plan how we're spending the 22 minutes we have for this, do we have anyone signed up for public testimony?

Unidentified speaker 2:43:33 - 2:43:33

2:43:33No one's signed up.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:43:34 - 2:43:46

2:43:34Okay, then let's jump into the presentation and we will see after that if we have time for committee discussion or if we need to hold over the discussion and vote on this item as well.

2:43:45Sam, whenever you are ready, go right ahead.

Sam Brosso 2:43:47 - 2:51:54

2:43:47Beautiful.

2:43:47Okay.

2:43:50All right.

2:43:51Good afternoon, Chair Pirtle-Guiney, members of the committee.

2:43:54For the record, my name is Sam Brosso and I'm the program manager for the Portland Clean Energy Community Benefits Fund here at the City of Portland.

2:44:00I'm here with you all this afternoon to present on our Workforce and Contractor Equity Agreement update, which I will describe here in the coming slides.

2:44:08So first, the background here is we'll start first with giving you a background on our Workforce and Contractor Equity Agreement, what it is, and then we'll talk about the amendment process itself that brings us to this point, and then we'll get into some of the components that sit within our Workforce and Contractor Equity Agreement.

2:44:27And so just first, as we take a step back, when we think about PSEF and the work that we do and the work that we fund, core of that work is making sure that we're providing opportunities, well-paying opportunities, to the folks that work on our projects.

2:44:40That is embedded within our city code, uh, that essentially all of our grants and our contracts have workforce and contractor equity-related items as part Thank you.

2:44:50Now, when we first adopted our climate investment plan in the fall of 2023, we incorporated program-wide workforce and contractor equity terms for all of our grants and our programs as part of that climate investment plan.

2:45:03This had the effect of establishing diverse contractor and workforce utilization goals, apprenticeship utilization goals, outreach and recruitment strategies, reporting and wage requirements, as well as requirements for respectful workplace training expectations as part of the projects that we fund.

2:45:23Now, following the mayor's executive order in July 2026, we did a comprehensive review of our program, soup to nuts.

2:45:30And in that, we flagged that our workforce and contractor equity agreement as one of the elements that needed to get updated so that it could align with broadly city best practices.

2:45:41And so while we had begun working with external stakeholders to explore ways to support our goals of ensuring all Portlanders benefiting from our workforce and contracting opportunities created by the program, it was clear that that effort would take time in light of the new political environment that we're working in.

2:45:58At the same time, this coincided with our first annual update of our climate investment plan, where we had also identified minor adjustments for our definitions for our PCF priority populations, our workforce— PCF workforce priority populations definitions.

2:46:11And so So we saw that as an opportunity where we could in one swoop clean some things up and get ourselves, just get ourselves right is I think the best way to say it.

2:46:20And so we used that moment to strike the existing workforce and contractor equity plan language as we worked with stakeholders to update it.

2:46:30Now I will acknowledge in that time we missed a key coordination opportunity with our colleagues in the executive order implementation team.

2:46:37Thank you.

2:46:38Resulting in some of the confusion that played out here in March of this year, which brings us to where we are, what we're talking about here today.

2:46:46So you all certainly requested at that time that we come back to you all with an update, and the next slides will speak to that update that we're bringing back into our climate investment plan.

2:46:56Okay, so led by our workforce policy lead, Abby Bonduraga— she's not here with us today— we analyze federal nondiscrimination regulations, the mayor's executive order and approved Portland Housing Bureau language and strategies.

2:47:11We connected with regional partners that do this work, both at Metro and our other regional governments.

2:47:17We collaborated with the mayor's executive order implementation team, and then we reviewed our workforce and contractor equity— oh, we reviewed our updated language that we had been working on with our PCF High Roads Advisory Council as well as the PCF committee.

2:47:33So now here I'm gonna be discussing the actual update content itself in terms of where we're getting to to plug up our climate investment plan and bring some of that language back.

2:47:41I wanna acknowledge what we have here very much is a placeholder.

2:47:44We see this as a longer body of work that we've gotta do, and it's likely gonna coincide with our climate, our next, the development of our next climate investment plan.

2:47:52But what we have here is a strong placeholder.

2:47:55First, I wanna say collectively the addback reaffirms our commitment to ensure that no community is excluded in our climate action work, and it does so in 5 ways.

2:48:06One, it establishes apprenticeship— uh, reestablishes apprenticeship utilization goals.

2:48:10PCF requires that 20% of labor hours in each apprenticiable trade is performed by state-registered apprentices on PCF-funded projects.

2:48:182, It requires recipients of PCF funds to implement evidence-based targeted outreach and recruitment strategies where disparities exist.

2:48:27So namely here, it gives just a placeholder, an acknowledgement, because the city is working on its broader disparity study that where the city has a valid and applicable disparity study, we will require funding recipients to implement evidence-based targeted contractor workforce outreach and recruitment strategies to maximize making sure those opportunities are benefiting those businesses and workers where those disparities exist.

2:48:52No.

2:48:53Three, it requires that recipients of PISA funds implement.

2:48:59Oh, my notes are a little bit off here.

2:49:01Okay.

2:49:02It It requires that recipients of PISA funds essentially develop their individualized workforce and contractor equity plans.

2:49:12At minimum, they have to include approaches and methods about removing barriers.

2:49:15This is just about making sure that those that are receiving our funds are thinking through the process.

2:49:20And so as part of this, we provide a template that walks them through the steps so that we're saying, yes, we're in a different landscape, but we still make— we still want to make sure you are thinking inclusively about how you solicit contracting opportunities for the work that you're putting out there.

2:49:354, It implements reporting and wage requirements.

2:49:38Again, we've continued to do this, but this just makes it clear that it is there.

2:49:41It requires funding recipients to provide information on all workers, contractors, subcontractors of PSF projects, including hours, wages earned, benefits received, as well as voluntary demographics.

2:49:54And last but not least, And this is an important part of area where we're putting a lot of energy, is implementing safe and respectful workplace training requirements as part of all of our capital or construction projects that we fund.

2:50:07So all contractors, subcontractors, workforce, including apprentices on PCF-funded projects, must complete PCF-approved respectful workplace training.

2:50:18Now, that work exists.

2:50:21It's going to continue to work, but we broadly in this bigger conversation with our regional partners, starting with the Regional Workforce Equity Table.

2:50:28This is a table that was established by Metro and includes many partners.

2:50:32The city certainly has a seat at the table, the county, Metro, and many labor partners and contractors.

2:50:38So we continue to actively engage with the partners there, and one of the core members of that Regional Workforce Equity Table serves on our PSIF High Roads Advisory Council.

2:50:49And then right now, later this fall/winter, we're going to be soliciting a contractor to support us in rebuilding out our safe and respectful workplace training programming.

2:51:00And this is really about making sure that as we fund projects, we don't just have requirements on the one side of it, but that we're actually working with our contractors and others on promoting a culture shift on our construction sites.

2:51:13And this is building on a lot of the work that our partners Thank you.

2:51:17And last but not least, we're an active participant as part of this work in the Safe from Hate Alliance and their Respectful Workplace Program Review Committee.

2:51:28And so with that, this, this wraps this up.

2:51:30I think what I want to just share is we see this as ongoing work.

2:51:34This has never stopped.

2:51:35I think we saw it as a moment to clean up, and there's a misstep in this moment.

2:51:38We're adding some of that language back in, but I think there's a bigger conversation we're having with regional partners, and we expect that to really unfold as we develop the next next climate investment plan, which we will come back before you all later this spring to discuss.

2:51:53So that concludes my presentation.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:51:57 - 2:52:01

2:51:57Thank you.

2:51:57Colleagues, questions?

2:52:00Councilor Ryan.

Dan Ryan 2:52:01 - 2:52:16

2:52:01Thank you so much, Sam.

2:52:03Um, here's what I'm trying to do with the information.

2:52:05So it was last year, earlier in the year, where we had a robust dialogue about the disparity study with procurement.

2:52:15Did you know about that?

Sam Brosso 2:52:17 - 2:52:22

2:52:17Our colleagues are tracking that, and we're tracking the, the, the fact that that disparity study is in play.

Dan Ryan 2:52:22 - 2:52:37

2:52:22So when you hear items that are similar to an item that you spend a lot of time on, you just, as a legislator that's trying to look at the big picture, you're trying to make sure we're connecting the dots.

2:52:30So, um, so that was a robust conversation, and I want to make sure that we're using that data so you're talking to each other.

Sam Brosso 2:52:37 - 2:52:51

2:52:37Yes, yes, we're eagerly tracking that.

2:52:39I mean, we're not the lead role or partner in that, but we have reached out and We are tracking that, and I think we're waiting for the study to be completed, as that will have a lot of information, and the granularity of that study is going to certainly influence what we can do in our work.

Dan Ryan 2:52:51 - 2:53:24

2:52:51Yeah, because we don't want PSEP to be such a separate program that it's not connected to all the good policy that we passed related to our COVID programs being robust.

2:53:02And I— for me, equity gains have always been about workforce, and That's the best lever that we have at the city.

2:53:11So I just want to make sure that we're in parallel construct with everything else that we've been passing in regards to that.

2:53:17And sometimes when I listened, it felt like a whole new track that we were on just with PSEF.

Sam Brosso 2:53:24 - 2:53:57

2:53:24We—.

2:53:25I'll say all of the attributes and the elements that we have within our program have been lifted and are comparable to what exists within the regional workforce equity.

2:53:34And that is why those regional tables which the city participates in, we're participating alongside our city partners, are important so that what we do doesn't feel— when you're on our project versus a Housing Bureau project versus a Water Bureau project, the experience doesn't feel different.

2:53:50There are nuances, but which is just to say, Councilor Ryan, yes, we are tracking very closely with the work happening with our partners.

Dan Ryan 2:53:57 - 2:53:59

2:53:57And are we reaching our 20% minimum figure?

Sam Brosso 2:54:01 - 2:54:04

2:54:01I can't answer that.

2:54:02I'd have to follow back up with you because I just—.

Dan Ryan 2:54:04 - 2:54:05

2:54:04Follow up.

2:54:04That's the key question.

Sam Brosso 2:54:06 - 2:54:09

2:54:06And I should have been prepared to answer that question, so I can follow back up afterwards.

Dan Ryan 2:54:10 - 2:54:20

2:54:10Okay.

2:54:10My biggest concerns, I think, are being addressed, that this is such a big issue that we've been spending a lot of time on.

2:54:15I want to make sure that the right and left hand are working together.

2:54:18Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:54:20 - 2:54:22

2:54:20Thank you, Councilor.

2:54:21Councilor Avalos.

Candace Avalos 2:54:28 - 2:55:17

2:54:28Thank you.

2:54:29Where are my notes?

2:54:29Okay.

2:54:31Well, first of all, thank you, PSF.

2:54:32I'm very glad to see that we're returning to this issue and ensuring that our workforce and contractor equity guidelines and values are current and in effect.

2:54:40So thank you, PSF, for your work.

2:54:42So under item 2 in this workforce and contractor equity plan, it states, quote, where the city has a valid and applicable study indicating a disparity in participation by contractors and workforce, end quote.

2:54:54And then it goes on to say we require fund recipients to work towards So first question is, what studies do the city— does the city already have about disparities in various workforces and industries?

2:55:08Is there an example that can help illustrate this section?

2:55:11I know that there was a workforce disparity thing that maybe Councilor Smith was working on, but I don't know if that's relevant to this or not.

Sam Brosso 2:55:18 - 2:56:32

2:55:18Yes, I think this was getting to the point that Councilor Ryan was raising just a bit ago.

2:55:23I believe one of the last disparity studies that we had that focused on the business side was that was in around 2012, 2013 or so.

2:55:29So it's fairly dated.

2:55:29And right now I know procurement has been actively working on a disparity study that is accounting for both workforce and contractors.

2:55:38Unfortunately, I don't have my colleague here that is more— that understands more of the details on that disparity study itself.

2:55:44But we're eagerly awaiting for the findings of that disparity study to look at the specific sort of trades and sectors that they look at because fundamentally, that matters in terms of being able to use the results from that study, assuming a disparity is evident, and applying it to the program.

2:56:04It needs to be— there needs to— the disparity needs to show up in the specific trades that PCF would be working in, whether that's, let's just say, HVAC or carpentry, where that shows up.

2:56:13So we are— I know we're in active conversation awaiting that disparity study, and I suspect I suspect significant parts of it will be relevant for the work that we do.

2:56:23I also suspect some parts won't.

2:56:26Um, so I think— but, but without my—.

2:56:28Without—.

2:56:28I think, uh, I think some of the questions, um, we can follow up on.

2:56:32Maybe that's fine.

Candace Avalos 2:56:34 - 2:57:00

2:56:34Okay, thank you.

2:56:36Um, I guess, are there ways that PSF or the city more broadly, um, is supporting— um, well, I guess PSF— um, the fund recipients in implementing strategies like outreach and recruitment to help remediate these disparities?

2:56:50I guess there's money that PCF has towards workforce, but is it going towards this part of workforce?

2:56:55Not just like— is it going towards the disparity issues of workforce?

Sam Brosso 2:57:02 - 2:58:29

2:57:02It does.

2:57:03No, it does.

2:57:04I, I'd say on the one side, so we have our, our grantees and our contractors that are going out and doing the building.

2:57:11In that realm, we do, we do work, and, and we've provided guidance templates to help them navigate in this new landscape around how they essentially create their strategies and their approaches towards recruiting diverse workers and diverse contractors and making sure they're inclusive in their practices.

2:57:31So we do provide those resources as part of the packet of work and the resources we provide to our grantees and contractors.

2:57:40That's one side of it.

2:57:41Now the other side of it is the the investments we make in training, both pre-apprenticeships, making sure folks are workforce ready, investing in youth.

2:57:52And so that side of it is making sure that there's a robust pipeline of folks that are well trained in, with credentials and skill sets that our employers are desiring.

2:58:02So I think it's sort of both sides of it so that we have the demand on one side and we have the pull on the other side.

2:58:09But But we—.

2:58:11And maybe taking it one step further, we also invest in organizations that work with— that support diverse businesses that do their own training for those businesses.

2:58:23So there's an element where we support both sides, but at some level we expect them to find each other in between there.

Candace Avalos 2:58:32 - 2:58:46

2:58:32Well, thank you for your work, and I'll take this moment to congratulate you on the record, Sam, for earning a spot on time.

2:58:402026 100 Most Influential Climate Leaders.

2:58:43We are very grateful to have your leadership at the city.

2:58:46Thank you.

Sam Brosso 2:58:46 - 2:58:48

2:58:46Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:58:50 - 2:59:02

2:58:50Thank you, Councilor.

2:58:53So Sam, you said that this proposal was reviewed by both the PSEF committee and also the High Road Advisory Council?

Sam Brosso 2:59:02 - 2:59:02

2:59:02Correct.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:59:03 - 2:59:43

2:59:03Okay, you've got a lot of folks I trust on the High Road Advisory Council, but it is it is notable to me that we don't have any testimony from folks here today saying that this language is strong enough.

2:59:15And while I know we are limited under the mayor's executive order, this language is much more limited than what we had before, at least at first blush to me.

2:59:25So I am wondering if you can share anything about the reaction from the High Road Advisory Council, whether there was pushback, whether there was dissent, whether it was unanimous support.

2:59:37What are we not hearing that we should know about how this document was received?

Sam Brosso 2:59:44 - 3:00:36

2:59:44I think that there is acknowledgment that we're in a different political climate on there.

2:59:48And I think it was— I don't want to— I think there was an acceptance that this is where we have to start.

2:59:53This is, in some ways, this is what it is.

2:59:55And we have to collectively as a community come together and figure out how do we retool the ways in which we've approached both workforce and contractor equity.

3:00:04The approaches we've taken in the past with setting goals and whatnot just aren't quite landing in this moment.

3:00:11And so I don't— what I picked up is that there's a frustration generally out there.

3:00:17There's a desire to figure out how we can do better, but there was also a recognition and acceptance that this is probably the best we can do now as we work as a community to to figure out the path forward.

3:00:28That's the sentiment that as I've connected with staff and I've checked in, they've said that there's not pushback.

3:00:34It's because it's a little bit more of a resigned acceptance.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:00:37 - 3:01:44

3:00:37I know at one point there was a lot of really good work happening within the Metropolitan Alliance for Workforce Equity around trying to figure out how we can have as strong language as possible, specifically on the workforce side.

3:00:49And the contractor side is separate, and there are different things we can do there, but specifically on the workforce side to try to make sure that we have the strongest language possible.

3:00:59I am comfortable moving this forward today because frankly I want to get anything back in there as quickly as we can.

3:01:07But I may have some conversations with folks to see if there are best practices that we could bring in.

3:01:12And I hope that when we are talking about our next piece of amendments coming forward, which as I understand it will come forward closer to the budget I would appreciate if there's any best practices that would allow us to strengthen this language for us to do that at that time.

3:01:33Although it's not related to adjustments to the CIP, that is when we were asked to take this language out.

3:01:38I think we could further strengthen it at that time if possible.

3:01:41I do think we need to get this in as quickly as we can though.

Sam Brosso 3:01:46 - 3:02:06

3:01:46If I may, Chair Pirtle-Guiney, I think we're eager.

3:01:48I, I, I, I I hope, um, you know, wherever there's ideas that we can— that can pass muster in this moment that gives us more strength, we're absolutely there.

3:01:58So I think we're eager to partner on that and, and find those, those, those, those, those, those, those wins that we can get to as we think about a bigger, broader strategy.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:02:07 - 3:02:15

3:02:07Thank you.

3:02:09Colleagues, we are at 4:57.

3:02:11Um, I believe we still don't have anybody signed up for public testimony.

Unidentified speaker 3:02:15 - 3:02:20

3:02:15I'm looking to Wendy though I will check again, but last time I checked, there was no one.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:02:21 - 3:02:36

3:02:21Okay, perfect.

3:02:23Um, at this point, we could have more discussion, or if we need more time for discussion, I can table this.

3:02:29But if folks feel ready to move this forward, I would entertain a motion to send this to council with a do pass recommendation.

Candace Avalos 3:02:38 - 3:02:38

3:02:38So moved.

Dan Ryan 3:02:39 - 3:02:39

3:02:39Second.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:02:39 - 3:02:45

3:02:39Okay, moved by Councilor Avalos and seconded by Councilor Ryan.

3:02:43Wendy, could you please call the roll?

Unidentified speaker 3:02:46 - 3:02:48

3:02:46Zimmerman, absent.

3:02:48Avalos?

Candace Avalos 3:02:50 - 3:02:50

3:02:50Aye.

Unidentified speaker 3:02:51 - 3:02:52

3:02:51Ryan?

Dan Ryan 3:02:52 - 3:02:52

3:02:52Aye.

Unidentified speaker 3:02:53 - 3:02:53

3:02:53Morillo?

Angelita Morillo 3:02:56 - 3:02:56

3:02:56Aye.

Unidentified speaker 3:02:57 - 3:02:57

3:02:57Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:02:59 - 3:02:59

3:02:59Aye.

Unidentified speaker 3:03:00 - 3:03:02

3:03:00The motion to refer is approved with 4 ayes and 1 absent.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:03:03 - 3:03:41

3:03:03Okay, colleagues, our next meeting is December 8th.

3:03:07We will hopefully have the Um, a cannabis ordinance back before us at that time, and there is currently a noise code update scheduled for that meeting, though I am told that there may be some concerns and we may need to delay it further depending on what happens with that ordinance.

3:03:26There are a few other things that I had penciled in for the agenda moving into next year that we might bump up instead, but I will make sure you all have a sense Thank you.

3:03:38Thank you to everybody for being here today, and we are adjourned.