windowbox

Budget Committee Meeting: FY2026-27 Approved Hearing Day 1

Official agenda

Transcript

Transcript

Automatically generated transcript. It may contain errors and includes testimony in languages other than English that is not individually marked up for assistive technology.

Jamie Dunphy 2:18 - 2:21

2:18I'm not embarrassed to use it.

2:20I'm going to use it right now.

2:21I'm sweating.

Rebecca Dobert 2:22 - 2:26

2:22Testing, testing, open signal.

2:25Testing, captions are good in chambers.

Loretta Smith 4:59 - 5:00

4:59Yes.

Jamie Dunphy 5:01 - 5:11

5:01Good morning.

5:02I'm calling to order this meeting of the Portland City Council.

5:07It is Monday, May 18th.

5:10Can we please call the roll?

Rebecca Dobert 5:13 - 5:13

5:13Good morning.

5:13Kanal?

Sameer Kanal 5:14 - 5:15

5:14Good morning.

5:14Here.

Rebecca Dobert 5:15 - 5:16

5:15Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:16 - 5:17

5:16Here.

Rebecca Dobert 5:18 - 5:18

5:18Ryan?

Dan Ryan 5:19 - 5:19

5:19Here.

Rebecca Dobert 5:20 - 5:20

5:20Koyama Lane?

Tiffany Koyama Lane 5:21 - 5:21

5:21Here.

Rebecca Dobert 5:22 - 5:22

5:22Murillo?

Angelita Morillo 5:23 - 5:23

5:23Here.

Rebecca Dobert 5:23 - 5:24

5:23Novick?

Steve Novick 5:24 - 5:24

5:24Here.

Rebecca Dobert 5:24 - 5:28

5:24Clark?

5:28Green?

Mitch Green 5:28 - 5:29

5:28Here.

Rebecca Dobert 5:30 - 5:35

5:30Zimmerman?

5:32Avalos?

5:35Smith?

Loretta Smith 5:36 - 5:36

5:36Here.

Rebecca Dobert 5:37 - 5:37

5:37Dunphy?

Jamie Dunphy 5:37 - 5:40

5:37Here.

5:38And can we please read the rules of decorum?

Rebecca Dobert 5:41 - 7:01

5:41Thank you.

5:43Welcome to the Portland City Council.

5:45To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

5:57Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

6:02Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

6:08Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

6:11The presiding officer preserves order.

6:14Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

6:25If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

6:29Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

6:33Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

6:38Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

6:43Your testimony should please address the matter being considered.

6:47When testifying, please state your name for the record.

6:50Your address is not necessary.

6:52If you are a lobbyist, please identify the organization you represent.

6:57Virtual testifiers should please unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

Eric Zimmerman 7:02 - 7:02

7:02Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 7:03 - 8:44

7:03Thank you very much.

7:04Good morning, colleagues, and welcome to the public.

7:07This week we are going to be taking a series of steps and votes as part of the approval of the fiscal year '26-'27 budget as prescribed by Oregon state law.

7:17As the City of Portland's Budget Committee, we will be holding a hearing on the uses of state revenue sharing We will consider amendments to the approved budget, and we will approve the tax levies for fiscal year 26-27.

7:29As Portland City Council, we will consider 6 ordinances related to utility rates, water system bonds, and to transferring interest from the Portland Clean Energy Fund to the general fund.

7:40As the Prosper Portland Budget Committee, we will consider amendments to the approved budget and conform the Prosper budget to any changes made in the city budget.

7:49Today we will hear public testimony on both budgets, their proposed amendments, and all of the ordinance.

7:56Today is the day for testimony.

7:59We will begin today with the Portland City Budget.

8:01We will hold revenue hearing— hold the revenue hearing, identify the pre-filed amendments, and take public testimony.

8:08As of this morning, there were nearly 150 people signed up to speak for 90 seconds each.

8:13We will take rest breaks as necessary.

8:16After testimony on the city budget, we will move to the PSEF interest and utility rate ordinances and hear testimony on them.

8:22As of this morning, there are 6 people signed up to testify, all to the PSEF interest ordinance.

8:28Finally, we will close the day by opening the Prosper Portland Budget Committee hearing and taking public testimony on the Prosper budget.

8:36As of this morning, there are 15 people signed up to speak.

8:39We will return on Tuesday and Wednesday to consider and vote on amendments to the city budget.

Rebecca Dobert 8:44 - 8:44

8:44Thank you, Mayor.

Jamie Dunphy 8:45 - 10:18

8:45After lunch on Tuesday, we will consider amendments to the Prosper budget and conform it to make any changes made to the city budget.

8:53As time allows, we will close Tuesday with further amendments to the city budget.

8:58On Wednesday, we will begin with the PSEF interest and rate ordinances, then return to amendments to the city budget.

9:05We will vote on the approved budgets at the end of our Wednesday hearing, and the budgets will be sent to the TSCC, the Tax Supervisory something committee.

9:14Tax Supervisory Committee.

9:16On Thursday.

9:18The pre-filed amendments are in 5 major thematic chunks: public safety cut restorations, PCF dollars, PMO, and trees; parks cut and restorations; and citywide governance.

9:31There's also a small cluster of items that impact Prosper Portland programming and a dozen or so proposed amendments that do not fit into a clear category.

9:40I plan for us to spend our Tuesday on public safety, Prosper.

9:44Prosper.

9:45And the PCEF PIMO Trees, in that order.

9:49We will discuss Wednesday as things develop.

9:52Following Wednesday's votes, we will return for a work session on budget notes and post-approved amendments on June 3rd.

9:59The TSC— TSSC hearing is at 9:30 to 11:00 AM on Tuesday, June 9th.

10:05Council will take up the first reading of the adopted budget at 9:30 on June 10th.

10:10Second reading will take place at 6:00 PM on June 17th, and at that point, the annual budget will be complete.

10:16So now on to the business of the day.

Loretta Smith 10:19 - 10:23

10:19Mr. President, I have a point of parliamentary inquiry.

Jamie Dunphy 10:24 - 10:24

10:24Okay.

Loretta Smith 10:25 - 11:20

10:25Is it accurate to state that 3 months ago, 90 days ago, during the Black History Month, you, Council President Jamie Dunphy, moved to indefinitely postpone my housing ordinance This ordinance was intended to allocate unbudgeted housing funds to community-based homeownership developers, specifically to support Williams and Russell Self-Enhancement, Inc. and Oasis of Praise, enabling them to purchase and renovate their rented community service building.

10:57And what I'm asking you for today, I'm asking you because you have failed to give us a placement On May 6th, May 13th, May 27th.

11:09You even assured a group of Black pastors led by Pastor Mark Jackson that the ordinance would be included in the May 27th agenda.

11:17In a written email, you canceled May 27th.

Jamie Dunphy 11:20 - 11:22

11:20Councilor, what's your parliamentary inquiry, please?

Loretta Smith 11:22 - 11:41

11:22And the parliamentary inquiry is that you have been not honest with us, and I want to— I want to suspend the rules so that you can give us a date and time certain for that ordinance that you moved to indefinitely put This is not a parliamentary inquiry.

Jamie Dunphy 11:41 - 11:43

11:41This is a separate scheduled inquiry.

11:43That is your opinion.

Loretta Smith 11:43 - 11:45

11:43It is my parliamentary inquiry.

Jamie Dunphy 11:45 - 11:47

11:45I find this out of order.

Loretta Smith 11:47 - 11:57

11:47I am out of order and you are out of order because you are supposed to put something on the agenda within 90 days.

11:54And you have failed to do that.

11:57I need you to give us a time certain.

Jamie Dunphy 11:58 - 11:58

11:58Councilor, I find you out of order.

Loretta Smith 11:59 - 12:01

11:59I need you to give us a time certain, Mr. President.

Jamie Dunphy 12:01 - 12:02

12:01Councilor, I find you out of order.

Loretta Smith 12:02 - 12:06

12:02You are out of order, Mr. President.

12:04You are out of order, sir.

Jamie Dunphy 12:06 - 12:07

12:06Thank you, Councilor.

Loretta Smith 12:07 - 12:07

12:07You are out of order.

Jamie Dunphy 12:08 - 12:09

12:08May the clerk please read item number 1?

Rebecca Dobert 12:12 - 12:21

12:12Item 1, approval of the FY 2026-27 budget for the City of Portland.

12:17Council convenes as Budget Committee, document number 2026-157.

Jamie Dunphy 12:23 - 12:34

12:23I now recess this meeting of the Portland City Council, and I'm now convening this meeting of the Portland City The City of Portland Budget Committee.

12:33Rebecca, can you please call the roll?

Rebecca Dobert 12:34 - 12:35

12:34Kanal?

Sameer Kanal 12:36 - 12:38

12:36Here.

Rebecca Dobert 12:39 - 12:39

12:39Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 12:40 - 12:40

12:40Here.

Rebecca Dobert 12:41 - 12:41

12:41Ryan?

Dan Ryan 12:42 - 12:42

12:42Here.

Rebecca Dobert 12:44 - 12:49

12:44Koyama Lane?

12:47She's here.

12:48Morillo?

Angelita Morillo 12:49 - 12:49

12:49Here.

Rebecca Dobert 12:51 - 12:51

12:51Novick?

Steve Novick 12:51 - 12:51

12:51Here.

Rebecca Dobert 12:53 - 12:53

12:53Green?

Mitch Green 12:54 - 12:54

12:54Here.

Rebecca Dobert 12:55 - 12:56

12:55Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 12:56 - 12:57

12:56Here.

Rebecca Dobert 12:57 - 12:58

12:57Avalos?

Candace Avalos 12:58 - 12:58

12:58Present.

Rebecca Dobert 12:59 - 13:00

12:59Smith?

Loretta Smith 13:00 - 13:00

13:00Here.

Rebecca Dobert 13:01 - 13:01

13:01Dunphy?

Jamie Dunphy 13:02 - 14:17

13:02Here.

13:04The City of Portland Budget Committee received the proposed budget and conducted a hearing to receive testimony on April 21st.

13:11The Budget Committee received the approved budget memo and attachments A through G on May 12th.

13:17This week we will vote to amend and approve the report, which approves the attachments A through G and the fiscal year '26-'27 budget.

13:26I am now opening a hearing to discuss the uses of state revenue sharing.

13:32This hearing is being held on the City of Council— the city— by the City Council of Portland, Oregon, in compliance with the provisions of Oregon State Revenue Sharing Regulations, ORS 221.770.

13:44It is to allow citizens to comment on the possible use of these funds in conjunction with the annual budget process.

13:50As proposed for the council adoption, the Fiscal year '26-'27 budget anticipates receipts totaling $19,496,999 from state revenue sharing.

14:05As has been the case in prior years, it is proposed that this revenue be allocated in 5 parts to support fire prevention and police patrol services.

14:14Is there anyone here today who wishes to be heard on this subject?

Rebecca Dobert 14:18 - 14:18

14:18Yes.

Jamie Dunphy 14:22 - 14:55

14:22Okay, this is a state-required request to see if anyone is testifying on state revenue sharing specifically.

14:30Seeing none, I am now closing this hearing to discuss the uses of the state revenue sharing.

14:37I am now opening a hearing— uh, sorry, there's a lot of procedural stuff here, so apologies ahead of time, folks.

14:43I'm opening a hearing on the City of Portland's FY26-27 approved budget.

14:48Prior to amendments, testimony, and debate, I call for a motion to consider and approve the approved budget report.

Sameer Kanal 14:55 - 14:56

14:55So moved.

Jamie Dunphy 14:57 - 14:59

14:57Councilor Kanal moves.

14:57Is there a second?

Candace Avalos 14:59 - 14:59

14:59Second.

Jamie Dunphy 15:00 - 15:45

15:00Councilor Avalos seconds.

15:02Colleagues, before we begin in earnest, there are 3 technical amendments being brought by the city administrator and the city budget office.

15:09They have been posted online for public review.

15:12These are corrections to errors made in the proposed budget.

15:15In prior years, these kinds of technical amendments were folded into the approved budget when it was filed.

15:20This year, for transparency, CBO has broken them out for council to consider individually.

15:27Is Budget Director Levine here?

15:30When you could walk us through very quickly these 3 technical amendments.

15:34And we're going to actually— colleagues, I'm going to move and have us vote on them or open them as we are talking about them.

15:43So— Point of information.

Steve Novick 15:46 - 15:49

15:46We were asked to give scores on these as well.

Jamie Dunphy 15:49 - 15:50

15:49Yes.

Steve Novick 15:50 - 15:53

15:50So that doesn't affect the timing of them?

Jamie Dunphy 15:54 - 15:57

15:54We're not voting on them right now.

15:56We're just opening them to—.

Sameer Kanal 15:58 - 15:58

15:58Okay.

Steve Novick 15:58 - 15:58

15:58Thank you.

Ruth Levine 15:59 - 17:22

15:59Thank you for clarifying.

16:02Great.

16:02For the record, Ruth Levine, City Budget Director.

16:04So I'm going to speak to Amendment 1 first, which is called Technical True-Ups.

16:11Yes.

16:12Is really just correcting things in the budget, either to true up to votes that council has taken between when we were preparing the proposed budget and now, essentially.

16:24So the spring TAO, not all of that made it into the proposed budget due to timing.

16:29And then a couple of other votes that have taken place since then.

16:37So there are just a few Things that need to be aligned to correctly reflect those votes in the budget.

16:45A couple of other things, there were just some errors in aligning position authority to the personnel budget that need to be fixed.

16:53And then the other items are just moving things into like the correct fund center or functional area, getting the money in the correct bucket in the budget.

17:04And for all 3 of these technical amendments, there was an attachment, Attachment I.

17:09Yes.

17:10On the filing that has each change listed out separately and explained.

17:16So if there are any questions on that, I'm happy to speak to those.

17:19But that is, um, that is Amendment 1.

Jamie Dunphy 17:24 - 17:39

17:24Thank you.

17:26And I think we're going to, we're going to hold on the vote on actually moving these, adopting these, till after testimony.

17:34Um, but Let's move to explain what technical changes.

Ruth Levine 17:39 - 17:57

17:39Keep going.

17:39Okay, great.

17:40All right, Amendment 2 is similarly, they're all budgeting errors that were made in the proposed, but these ones actually move general fund.

17:53There are 5 changes.

Eric Zimmerman 17:58 - 18:03

17:58Can you please reference what attachment it is you're talking about?

18:02You said I for the last one.

Ruth Levine 18:05 - 18:06

18:05They're all listed in Attachment I.

Eric Zimmerman 18:06 - 18:07

18:06Oh, okay.

Ruth Levine 18:07 - 18:08

18:07All 3 amendments.

Eric Zimmerman 18:08 - 18:09

18:08All 3 are in there, okay.

Ruth Levine 18:09 - 19:15

18:09The attachments, the language, there's language in the attachments, Attachment H, and then there's more detailed information for all 3 of them in Attachment I.

18:23So in Amendment 2, There are— there was a position that was incorrectly reduced in the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

18:39There's a position that was double-budgeted in the City Administrator's Office, so that doesn't need to be there twice.

18:46There is a position that was incorrectly reduced in the Office of City Operations.

18:54Thank you.

18:55And then some true-ups that are not position related.

18:59One is truing up to the exact 5% number on the Office of Community-Based Police Accountability.

19:05And then there's a $12,000 entry that's unnecessary in special operations, sorry, special appropriations.

19:14That is Amendment 2.

Jamie Dunphy 19:15 - 19:19

19:15Thank you.

19:16And could you read technical or walk us through Technical Amendment 3 as well?

Ruth Levine 19:19 - 20:06

19:19Sure.

19:19And then Technical Amendment 3 is specific to a couple of corrections within parks.

19:25These are things that were intended to be reflected in the proposed budget, but were not done so due to timing.

19:31The first is the Leach Botanical Garden.

19:34So there was an intention to include $200,000 for Leach Botanical Garden in the proposed that didn't make it in.

19:40And then on the USTA, there was sort of miscommunication about the, how much of the year the change would be in effect.

19:49And so it was budgeted for a full year amount, but should have been budgeted for a half year amount.

19:54And that means also that those 4, the position authority can't be removed at this point because the positions are needed for a portion of the year.

20:04So that's Amendment 3.

Jamie Dunphy 20:06 - 20:30

20:06Okay, and I would like, just wanna at the very top here acknowledge, as with last year, I am recusing myself from Technical Amendment 3.

20:16My spouse works at Leach Botanical Gardens, and so I am neither motioning, seconding, debating, or voting on that amendment in any capacity.

20:26Colleagues, I see a number of folks in the queue.

20:27Are we asking questions about the technical amendments at this time?

Sameer Kanal 20:30 - 20:30

20:30Are we?

Jamie Dunphy 20:31 - 20:36

20:31Okay.

20:35Councilor Knoll.

Steve Novick 20:37 - 20:38

20:37Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 20:38 - 20:39

20:38Morning, Ruth.

Steve Novick 20:39 - 20:59

20:39Thanks so much for being here, and thanks for all your work on this process.

20:42Writ large, it could go on for a while, but I won't.

20:45Um, for Technical Amendment 1, um, I'm looking at the, the Attachment H, the bottom right of each of these tables, and I'm trying to understand where is the $34 million coming from that this seems to be adding to the budget.

Ruth Levine 21:00 - 21:02

21:00Um, sorry, one second.

Steve Novick 21:03 - 21:07

21:03Question for, uh, Amendment 2 in terms of what happens to the $79,000.

Ruth Levine 21:09 - 22:47

21:09Yes.

21:09So on Amendment 2, sorry, I'm just looking at Amendment 1 for a second.

21:13I think, so on Amendment 2, that amount is made available for council to allocate through the process this week.

21:29On Amendment 1, the— $300,000.

21:37Sorry.

21:38I believe that is— it's not— it's just a change in appropriations in Amendment 1.

21:46So it's not necessarily actually adding resources.

21:55It's just changing how they're budgeted.

21:57And I may have to call somebody up to speak to the specifics of it.

22:02But I think on the FPDR line, which which is the bulk of that increase in Amendment 1.

22:10That's a change in the way that they're budgeting their cash flow issue, which they brought to council a week or 2 ago in terms of— yeah, I can bring someone up if you have questions on that, but that's the bulk of it.

22:24And then I think another portion of it is in fleet and facilities, which is a change, I believe, in how they're budgeting for the— For the vehicles.

22:33Interfund loan as a result of the interfund loan with the health fund that we discussed in the spring TAO.

22:39So we can get you more, I can get you more details if you'd like, but that's the, it's really just a change in appropriations, not so much a change in, it's not adding resources.

Steve Novick 22:48 - 22:59

22:48I'm seeing CFO Biery nodding behind you, so thanks for that.

22:53And so I'll interpret that as effectively it's not creating a need that we have to fill.

22:58I'm seeing a nod again.

Ruth Levine 22:59 - 22:59

22:59Yes.

Steve Novick 22:59 - 23:06

22:59Is the same thing true for Amendment 3 where it says $1.06 million $1.067 million at the bottom right there.

Ruth Levine 23:06 - 23:11

23:06So that one's a little bit different.

23:08So that would in fact be covered by the parks levy in '26-'27.

Steve Novick 23:12 - 23:53

23:12Okay, so, and that's where it says it reduces the amount available in future years.

23:16Okay.

23:17One other question on this, and it's not numerical, also on Amendment 3, is the— it talks about thoughtful decision-making and implementation of the potential transition I'm a little curious as to that.

23:33There hasn't yet been a council vote on transferring anything with USTA, and there's been several councilors who have expressed concern, trepidation, whatever word, hesitation, let's say, about it.

23:48So I'm curious how much this commits us to that course of action without a debate.

Sameer Kanal 23:57 - 24:18

23:57It doesn't commit you to it.

23:58Council officially has to adopt the budget, which this would be a part of it.

24:03This is just amending the portions of the mayor's proposed budget as it relates to this work.

24:09Council officially will make the decision as it relates to the overall adopted budget, which this may be included as part of your deliberation with this amendment.

Steve Novick 24:18 - 24:28

24:18So the adopted budget is where the decision on, on Transferring on privatizing this, the Portland Tennis Center, is made, or is that a separate standalone ordinance?

Sameer Kanal 24:28 - 24:39

24:28It's the appropriation of the money is done through this budgeting process.

24:34If there's documentation as it relates to the privatization of that, that would be done separately.

Steve Novick 24:39 - 24:53

24:39Okay.

24:40Does— but we're only funding half the year to operate this at this moment.

24:46So as of right now, unless we adopted a second ordinance, if we adopt this budget, the Portland Tennis Center would close on December 31st.

Sameer Kanal 24:53 - 24:54

24:53Potentially, yes.

Steve Novick 24:55 - 24:56

24:55Okay, just wanted to get that on the record.

Ruth Levine 24:56 - 25:16

24:56Sorry, and just to clarify one other thing, I think the— in terms of order of operations here, this kind of sets the baseline.

25:03You could, you could approve this amendment, Amendment 3, and then also change course through a later amendment in the approved.

25:11It doesn't— sure, it just says like this is the correct starting point, essentially.

Steve Novick 25:17 - 25:17

25:17Great, thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 25:18 - 25:20

25:18Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

25:19Councilor Green.

Steve Novick 25:20 - 25:21

25:20Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 25:21 - 25:39

25:21Just briefly, will you be able to make available at some point, like, what is the net effect of general fund resources that either are lower than or greater than to be made available this week relative to what we saw in the mayor's proposed?

Ruth Levine 25:42 - 25:44

25:42Sorry, can you restate the question?

Eric Zimmerman 25:44 - 26:03

25:44This has a number of funds that change, and so I see on Amendment 2, negative $79,718.

25:49So that would suggest that there's a change in the That's available to council to appropriate.

25:55But then the other one, we're adding $1,066,000 to the parks budget.

25:59Does that mean we're $1 million to the worse relative to the mayor's proposed?

Ruth Levine 26:04 - 26:20

26:04No.

26:04So the only Amendment 2 impacts general fund resources so that it makes available $79,718 of general fund for council to appropriate.

26:15On Amendment 3, that's in the parks levy and the Amendment 1 changes all impact other funds.

Jamie Dunphy 26:21 - 26:24

26:21All right, thanks.

26:23Thank you, Councilor Green.

26:23Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 26:27 - 27:11

26:27Thank you, Council President.

26:30Um, with Amendment 3, 2 things.

26:33First, a flag, Council President.

26:35I hope— I'm hoping we can get a change on the labeling of this.

26:38My name is on this as a co-sponsor, and I didn't co-sponsor it.

26:44So I would Just love to have my name taken off of it.

26:49I'm sure it's lovely, but I did not co-sponsor it.

26:53Um, if that can be fixed by whoever needs to fix it, I would appreciate it.

26:58As it relates to the levy, I know there is a careful balance to make sure that what we spend in the first year is sustainable in the last year.

27:10This is a technical amendment.

Ruth Levine 27:11 - 27:11

27:11Yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 27:12 - 27:23

27:12Does that mean that this was captured in the calculation to make sure that what we were spending this year is sustainable in the last year, or is this going to put us in a deficit in year 5?

Ruth Levine 27:25 - 27:31

27:25Um, my understanding is that it won't put us in a deficit in year 5, that this is, um, sort of captured within the—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 27:31 - 27:37

27:31Um, okay, this is putting us back to where we needed to be.

27:35This is not throwing us out of where we need to to be.

Ruth Levine 27:38 - 27:38

27:38Yeah.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 27:39 - 27:40

27:39Okay, thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 27:40 - 27:42

27:40Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

27:42Councilor Zimmerman.

Eric Zimmerman 27:43 - 29:07

27:43Thanks.

27:44I'm going to start where Councilor Pirtle-Guiney started on Amendment 3.

27:49I, I've done a lot of municipal budgets in my life.

27:52I've never seen them co-sponsored by members of the body.

27:55So what is the thinking behind this, and why is it not just a technical administration's amendment coming forward?

28:02They're afraid of him.

28:05It, it adds a level of— most of the times over, over a lot of years of doing this, technical amendments are not really a thing you debate.

28:14Mhm.

28:15They're an oops, we put a 1 instead of a 0, right?

28:20This seems very different, and I'll say it seems very different at the end of one of the worst prepared budgets I've ever seen.

28:26So now I'm skeptical on things I'm not sure I should be skeptical on.

28:29And adding co-sponsor names to it and then hearing one of them is not even a co-sponsor, I have a lot of concern here about what normally in years of experience is just a pass-through.

28:42And now I'm hearing we're going to talk about it and not just vote on it quickly.

28:46Makes it feel like it is the other amendments.

28:49So I'd like an understanding about just the crop of these.

28:53What is going on?

28:55Why so many are coming forward and why they were not considered just a very technical adjustment, because something about this seems more than a technical adjustment, and I'm trying to understand that.

Ruth Levine 29:10 - 29:49

29:10We brought these all forward to correct errors that were in the proposed and respond to the fact that some of them are more, oops, we put a 1 instead of a 0, and some of them have more are a little more substantive.

29:26And so we wanted to make that clear to council.

29:29And there were conversations specifically about Amendment 3 among the administration and individual councilors.

29:37And so that's all that's intended to do.

29:40Apologies if there was miscommunication.

29:42We were balancing a lot of amendments and conversations that were happening in a short period of time.

29:46So that's all.

29:48We're just trying to bring transparency to the process.

Rebecca Dobert 29:49 - 29:49

29:49Thank you.

Sameer Kanal 29:50 - 30:41

29:50And Councilor, you're correct.

29:51Typically in the budgeting process, this would've been a technical thing that would've been just approved.

29:57And I think this is some of the conversation as we look at our processes as it relates to our budgeting framework.

30:05How do we move forward with these type of things?

30:07My preference and best management practices is these things would just be technical adjustments that we make and council approves those technical adjustments as part of the budget.

30:17Thank you.

30:18The shaky ground that you get on is when those things are not sometimes just technical adjustments.

30:24It may be some things that might have been missed in the proposed budget that needs to be discussed amongst the council.

30:30But if we're just talking about a zero added or one to add it, those are technical things that I would say as we move forward, we just need to take care of those things separately than the amendment process.

Ruth Levine 30:42 - 30:42

30:42Okay.

Eric Zimmerman 30:42 - 30:51

30:42And then, Mr. President, why have you decided not to just have these put up and voted on to get them off the docket so we can move on to the part where there's actually a debate.

Jamie Dunphy 30:52 - 31:10

30:52Yeah, well, I was hoping we would get to testimony a lot quicker, but I didn't realize councilors were going to want to discuss this too.

30:57So I was hoping to just do all of our talking at once and get the public going.

31:02That was my intention.

31:07I wanted to lay them on the table, get it out there in the public, and—.

Eric Zimmerman 31:10 - 31:25

31:10So to lay them on the table and then get them out there in the public makes it seem like there's something here to consider or not to consider.

31:17So the question begs, if we don't adopt these technical amendments, what happens then?

31:22So what would be the point then of the testimony to that end?

Jamie Dunphy 31:26 - 31:29

31:26No, Councilor, I was just trying to get us to the public testimony.

Eric Zimmerman 31:31 - 31:44

31:31That's fine and that's admirable, but I'm trying to get us to a budget that's workable and actually factual, and this is throwing a wrench into that.

31:40So I was asking for your motivation in terms of why we wouldn't take care of these and be done with them, but I will pause that because I don't think you have an answer.

Jamie Dunphy 31:47 - 31:49

31:47Councilor Avalos.

Candace Avalos 31:49 - 32:29

31:49Yeah, so just for some clarity on the Leach one in particular.

31:54So one, I am a little bit confused because I— my understanding was that I was co-sponsoring the Leach one simply because Council President cannot due to the conflict of interest.

32:04And so the Leach one would have been under the technical package, and since the Council President brings that package, we had to take that specifically out.

32:12So that was my understanding of that.

32:13Now, however, I did not understand that USTA was gonna be in that same amendment.

32:18So that's where my confusion is coming.

32:20And I was not planning on sponsoring that.

32:22My goal was just Leach for the conflict of interest.

32:25So just to add context for that specific one, the rest of it I don't have answers for.

Jamie Dunphy 32:30 - 32:32

32:30Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

32:31Councilor Knoll.

Steve Novick 32:34 - 32:58

32:34Yeah, I have just one quick question.

32:36I'm comfortable just approving these and moving on for the sake of process.

32:39But I did wanna ask if we are going to be allowed to make amendments or update our amendments related to the content of this, even though, because we weren't able to put up anything with relation knowing this information by our deadline of Friday.

32:53So if, as long as we're still allowed to make adjustments to this, then I think that's a fair sort of way to handle it.

Jamie Dunphy 32:59 - 33:11

32:59I think that makes sense.

32:59All right, well, I'm hearing from this body that there is some interest in just getting through the technical amendments very quickly.

33:05So Councilor Koyama Lane.

33:09And then I'm gonna, I'm gonna move these 3.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 33:11 - 33:13

33:11I don't have to say more, but I can explain.

Jamie Dunphy 33:13 - 33:24

33:13I'll just, I'll just move them real quick.

33:15I'm going to move Technical Amendment 1, and I would seek a second.

33:19Second.

33:19Thank you.

33:20Any debate?

33:23Can we please call the roll on Technical Amendment Number 1?

Rebecca Dobert 33:28 - 33:41

33:28Technical Amendment 1, moved by Councilor, uh, Dunphy and seconded by Koyama Lane.

33:39No.

33:41Pirtle-Guinea?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 33:42 - 33:42

33:42Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 33:43 - 33:43

33:43Ryan?

Dan Ryan 33:43 - 33:44

33:43Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 33:44 - 33:45

33:44Koyamalene?

Tiffany Koyama Lane 33:45 - 33:45

33:45Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 33:46 - 33:46

33:46Murillo?

Angelita Morillo 33:47 - 33:47

33:47Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 33:48 - 33:48

33:48Novick?

Steve Novick 33:49 - 33:49

33:49Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 33:49 - 33:49

33:49Clark?

Olivia Clark 33:50 - 33:51

33:50Absent.

Rebecca Dobert 33:51 - 33:51

33:51Green?

Mitch Green 33:52 - 33:52

33:52Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 33:53 - 33:53

33:53Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 33:57 - 33:57

33:57Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 33:59 - 33:59

33:59Avalos?

Candace Avalos 33:59 - 33:59

33:59Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:00 - 34:00

34:00Smith?

Loretta Smith 34:01 - 34:01

34:01Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:02 - 34:02

34:02Dunphy?

Jamie Dunphy 34:03 - 34:03

34:03Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:04 - 34:07

34:04And the amendment is approved with 10 aye, 1 nay, 1 absent.

Jamie Dunphy 34:07 - 34:14

34:07Okay, I would like to move technical amendment number 2, and I would seek a second.

34:12Second.

34:13Councilor Pirtle-Guiney seconds.

34:14Is there discussion?

Rebecca Dobert 34:20 - 34:27

34:20Technical amendment 2, moved by Council President Dunphy, seconded by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

34:26Kanal?

Sameer Kanal 34:30 - 34:30

34:30Aye.

Angelita Morillo 34:31 - 34:31

34:31Aye.

Sameer Kanal 34:31 - 34:32

34:31Aye.

Dan Ryan 34:33 - 34:33

34:33Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:35 - 34:35

34:35Aye.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 34:36 - 34:36

34:36Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:37 - 34:39

34:37Clark is absent.

34:39Green?

Mitch Green 34:40 - 34:40

34:40Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:41 - 34:41

34:41Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 34:42 - 34:42

34:42Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:42 - 34:43

34:42Avalos?

Candace Avalos 34:44 - 34:44

34:44Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:45 - 34:45

34:45Smith?

Loretta Smith 34:46 - 34:46

34:46Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:47 - 34:47

34:47Dunphy?

Jamie Dunphy 34:48 - 34:48

34:48Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 34:49 - 34:51

34:49The amendment is approved with 11 aye, 1 absent.

Jamie Dunphy 34:56 - 34:57

34:56I would entertain somebody else moving.

Candace Avalos 34:58 - 34:59

34:58I will move Amendment 3.

Jamie Dunphy 34:59 - 35:03

34:59Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

35:00Councilor Avalos moves Technical Amendment 3.

35:02Is there a second?

Steve Novick 35:03 - 35:04

35:03Second.

Jamie Dunphy 35:04 - 35:07

35:04Councilor Novick seconds.

35:07Is there debate?

Candace Avalos 35:08 - 35:22

35:08My only debate is, uh, I'm unsure about the USDA thing.

35:12I'm going to move it forward.

35:13It sounds like we have an opportunity to make some changes, so I just want to put that on the record.

35:18Um, Because I definitely have some questions about that one, but I want to just get this forward.

Jamie Dunphy 35:23 - 35:24

35:23Thank you.

35:23Councilor Knoll.

Steve Novick 35:25 - 35:50

35:25Yeah, my understanding is that this, the current state, if we don't adopt this amendment, is that there's no funding for continued management of USTA, and this adds 6 months of it, which I think is better than the current situation.

35:36But I'm looking forward to the debate as well, so I'll be voting yes on this.

35:39And just to clarify, to get it on the record for future, the reason I voted no on Technical Amendment 1 was because of the communications realignment Thank you very much.

Jamie Dunphy 35:51 - 35:52

35:51Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 35:53 - 36:25

35:53Thank you, Council President.

35:54I'm a bit nervous.

35:58Um, our budget director's answer wasn't as confident sounding as I wanted about this not leaving us with a deficit in year 5 of the parks levy.

36:07I am willing to accept that it is truly technical and will not leave a deficit, but I'm just wondering if there's a way to But if, to the points that Councilor Zimmerman was raising, some of these are less technical, I just want to make sure we are eyes wide open that we may have a problem in the future.

36:23Hopefully this is truly technical.

Jamie Dunphy 36:25 - 36:29

36:25Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

36:28Can you please call the roll?

Rebecca Dobert 36:31 - 36:36

36:31Technical correction, Amendment 3, moved by Councilor Avalos, seconded by Councilor Novick.

Jamie Dunphy 36:36 - 36:36

36:36Aye.

Candace Avalos 36:39 - 36:40

36:39Aye.

36:40Aye.

Loretta Smith 36:42 - 36:42

36:42Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 36:43 - 36:43

36:43Aye.

Mitch Green 36:46 - 36:46

36:46Aye.

Steve Novick 36:47 - 36:47

36:47Aye.

Sameer Kanal 36:48 - 36:49

36:48Aye.

36:49Aye.

Loretta Smith 36:49 - 36:49

36:49Aye.

Rebecca Dobert 36:49 - 37:01

36:49I abstain.

36:56Okay, and the amendment is approved with 10 aye, 1 absent, 1 abstain.

Jamie Dunphy 37:02 - 39:29

37:02Okay, thank you, colleagues.

37:05Colleagues, we now return to discussion about amendments to the approved budget filed by council.

37:10On March 30th, I sent a memo to council, council operations, the city attorney's office, the clerk, the city administrator, the mayor, his chief of staff, the CFO, the CBO, city administrator— administrative leadership, including the DCAs, the chief officers, and key support staff.

37:26This memo provided guidance on the method and deadline to pre-file budget amendments and the process by which they would be released to the public.

37:33My office provided regular reminders, clarifications, and updates on this process in the 45 days between the memo's release and the first deadlines.

37:41The submission deadline for amendments seeking CBO review was 10:00 AM on Thursday, May 14th.

37:47They were posted for the public by the clerk at approximately 5:30 on Friday, May 15th.

37:53Media releases calling the public's attention to the amendments followed, sent by Council Operations, official city channels, Council offices and the mayor's office.

38:01Last year, council filed 170 budget amendments and notes.

38:0590 Of them were not even discussed because there was not enough time.

38:09To help us prioritize in the case of another excess, excess of amendments, my memo called for the Council Operations to confidentially seek prioritization preferences on pre-filed amendments from council over this weekend using a 10-point scale.

38:23Council Operations has directly and confidentially Surveyed individual council offices and has not shared any aggregated information prior to public release.

38:3110 Council offices participated.

38:33As of last night, the results of their survey have been posted to the public and council simultaneously as an exhibit to the budget report.

38:41As I mentioned in my introductory remarks, our amendments appear to have arrived in about 5 compact subject areas, plus about a dozen individual ideas.

38:51With under 50 pre-filed amendments, it's It's almost possible that we could hear votes— hear and vote on every amendment.

38:58That would be really nice.

39:00As the amendments have been visible to council and the public for over 48 hours, I believe that the community is sufficiently aware of what has been proposed for us to move to public testimony on the approved and its amendments.

39:10If any councilor intends to move an altogether new amendment concept or to withdraw any that are pre-filed, please feel free to surface them now so that the public can have a chance to So colleagues, if you have any other amendments that you wish to propose, now would be a great time.

39:28Councilor Zimmerman.

Eric Zimmerman 39:30 - 39:55

39:30Can you clarify— thanks.

39:31Can you clarify how the— because I didn't participate in your survey.

39:36I consider it a serial meeting.

39:38But how will that information be used to— I'm still trying to understand.

39:44At any time someone can move an amendment.

39:45So what is it that you're Prioritization list is going to do?

39:51Not in terms of information, but is it going to be used for an action by you?

Jamie Dunphy 39:55 - 40:11

39:55Yes, I'm trying to use it in order to figure out the amendments where there is broad consensus so that we can move to those quickly, or amendments where there is going to be healthy debate, or ones where there is very clearly little public or little interest among the entire body and we can—.

Eric Zimmerman 40:11 - 40:52

40:11Yeah, so to that end, it makes it seem like it may be even more of a serial meeting than Previously understood if it is leading to the type and process of deliberation.

40:22So I hope that those who have amendments up for consideration, they'll make them.

40:28And I think that that debate happens here and not in a behind-the-scenes survey.

40:32But I certainly intend to both bring new amendments as well as remove some amendments that were on that list based on what we hear today and also based on some of the, what I think are great amendments that some colleagues have put up.

40:46Thank you.

40:48But those are worthy of debate regardless of their score, and I'm hoping to have that.

40:51Thank you all.

Rebecca Dobert 40:54 - 40:55

40:54Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 40:56 - 41:11

40:56Okay, so with over 100 individuals signed up to testify, we have given prior notice that we will limit each individual's speaking time to 90 seconds to ensure that all voices can be heard.

41:07So Rebecca, can we please call our first panel of testifiers?

Rebecca Dobert 41:12 - 41:52

41:12Good morning.

41:13A quick note of housekeeping for testifier.

41:15For those signed up to testify, each verbal testifier will receive 90 seconds.

41:22I will call folks up in groups of 5.

41:25For those in person, you will see a timer countdown displayed on the monitor in front of the testimony table on the floor.

41:31For those virtual, the timer is in Zoom.

41:34You will hear the timer chime twice, once as a warning when you have 30 seconds remaining and a second time when your time is up.

41:41Thank you.

41:43Up.

41:43Our first 5 testifiers are Isaac McLennan, Elijah Goodrick, Christy Crampton, Karen Aguirre, and Dare Elliott.

Jamie Dunphy 41:54 - 42:08

41:54And good morning, folks.

41:54As you are all coming up to the, uh, dais here, please go ahead and feel, uh, however you sit down and jump in.

42:01Feel free to introduce yourselves.

42:03Uh, folks are welcome to share their pronouns, and you have 90 seconds Isaac, take us away.

Isaac McLennan 42:08 - 43:38

42:08Okay.

42:09Good morning, Council President Dunphy, members of City Council, my fellow firefighters, and neighbors.

42:14My name is Isaac McLennan.

42:16I'm the president of the Portland Firefighters Association, a firefighter in East Portland and resident in District 3 in the Roseway neighborhood.

42:23Let's kick this off the right way, under time and with urgency.

42:27Large swaths of Portland are already at risk because we do not have enough firefighters serving our neighborhoods.

42:33Right now, Portland Fire and Rescue can only reach 46.7% of the city within the 4-minute response time standard.

42:40The proposed budget before you would only make that worse.

42:43Closing Engine 22 in St. Johns and reducing nighttime response for 3 rescues in Southeast and East Portland would devastate firefighters' ability to protect life and property.

42:54Our chat teams provide medical response services, reducing the strain on our system and help preserve critical When Portlanders call 911, they deserve a quick response.

43:05These cuts would have real consequences.

43:07Slower response times and public safety— I'm sorry, slower response times put public safety and firefighter safety at risk.

43:15Community safety is a connected system.

43:18Street response, police, dispatchers, firefighters, crisis responders, chat, and support staff all work together to keep Portland safe.

43:26Now firefighters are the ones calling 911.

43:28We need the community's help.

43:30We need council's help.

43:31Let's get this one right.

43:33On behalf of all firefighters and EMTs in Portland, I ask you to restore funding to keep Portland safe.

Jamie Dunphy 43:39 - 44:16

43:39Thank you very much.

43:46Appreciate that, but we got to limit— Thank you.

43:56Thank you, folks.

44:02If we could please try to keep, uh, the chamber to some less loud, uh, shows of appreciation.

44:10Thank you.

44:13Whoever wants to go next?

44:14Yeah.

44:14Yeah.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 44:17 - 44:17

44:17I will.

Karen Aguirre 44:18 - 45:54

44:18Council President Dunphy and Portland City Councilors, my name is Karen Aguirre, and I'm speaking as a member of AFSCME 189 for myself.

44:28I'm a front desk clerk at Central Precinct, and I received my layoff papers last week.

44:33Front desk staff triage every situation presenting at the precinct in person or by phone.

44:40We determine what we can resolve immediately versus referral to other bureaus or escalation to officers.

44:47We discuss solutions with people who truly have nowhere else to go.

44:52Mothers with children in our lobby at 1:00 AM escaping abusers, victims of crime with no phone or computer to call dispatch, folks with warrants turning themselves in, arrestees released at 3:00 AM looking for their cars or property, tourists speaking no English who've been scammed or assaulted.

45:11We assert boundaries for individuals who are yelling and aggressive while tactfully explaining expectations to your constituents when police response is not immediately available.

45:23And the hidden duties that keep officers functioning and safe— managing an inventory of thousands of items: laptops, batteries, handcuffs, first aid kits, uniforms, the tiny wires connecting earpieces to radios.

45:36We arrange cleaners when drunks vomit in police cars and holding cells.

45:40Thank you.

45:41We run background checks and field media personnel for press conferences, and we do all of this while simultaneously handling all of those calls and walk-in visitors.

45:52Thank you.

45:52Thank you so much.

Angelita Morillo 46:00 - 47:38

46:00My name is Christy Crampton, and I am a senior PASS, or a Police Administrative Support Specialist, that was on the chopping block last week where I've got my, um, layoff papers too.

46:13I was promoted to this position 2 years ago, and I work in the Personnel Division.

46:18I create and distribute, track and file all probationary performance evaluations for new hire employees, promoted PPB members, as well as all PPB employee annual performance evaluations.

46:30I send out position announcements and BHR eligible to all members, and I ensure the language is equitable and abide by union terms and conditions.

46:39I pay all of Personnel Division's invoices in SAP, like bills for occupational medical exams, hearing tests, internet explanation reports, and digital advertising at PDX.

46:49I keep PPB in compliance with DPSST, the Oregon Department of Public Safety and Standards training, by changing the status of separation Stats or separation on F4 forms, and I ensure they are filled out in a timely manner.

47:06I set up hiring and promotional ceremonies by calendar invites, room reservations, emails ordering badges, and creating new new hire paperwork for Multnomah County Courts, Fire and Police, Disability and Retirement, and the City Auditor's Office, just to name a few.

47:24These are just a few of the many duties I provide for the.

47:26Police Bureau, and I've worked for the City of Portland Police Bureau since October of 1999.

47:31My senior past position is needed, and it's crucial to keeping the Personnel Division and the Portland Police Bureau working efficiently.

47:38Thank you for your time.

Steve Novick 47:39 - 47:40

47:39Thank you very much.

Jamie Dunphy 47:45 - 48:00

47:45I'm sorry, we have a rule in the chambers that we can't— we don't do clapping.

47:49Uh, silent hands, show of appreciation, jazz fingers, whatever they call them.

47:53Um, but thank you.

47:54I don't make up the rules.

47:56Well, I kind of do, but we'll get to you faster.

47:59Thank you.

Mitch Green 48:01 - 49:49

48:01Uh, Council President—.

48:07Smart kid.

48:08Council President Dunphy and Portland City Councilors, my name is Elijah Goodrick, and I am here speaking as a member of Ask Me 189 on my own behalf.

48:16I have been a business systems analyst with PBOT for the last 7 years, with 23 years total with the City of Portland.

48:22I received my layoff notice as part of the core city— core services realignment last week.

48:27For the past 3 years, I've been responsible for the function of the city's parking management technology, which includes 5 integrated systems responsible for over $72 million in PBOT revenue, including Parking Kitty, SmartPark, permits, meters, and we'll be rolling out a text-to-pay option in the next few weeks.

48:44Each of these systems is unique and requires specialized training and understanding of parking management.

48:48To effectively configure and troubleshoot.

48:51These are complex systems and fully integrated to report payment to parking enforcement and ensure accurate operations.

48:58When something goes wrong with it, it's my responsibility to determine what has gone wrong, identify what the causes are, and either fix it myself or coordinate the fixes with the vendors.

49:08As many of these issues involve a live member of the public actively trying to pay for their parking, a timely response is essential.

49:15Thank you.

49:16With BTS assuming responsibility for this work, parking operations will no longer be able to respond to customers promptly.

49:23My concern, aside from my own personal situation, is that any reduction in our responses to broken machines or payments not going through will be a reduction in our already abysmal compliance rates, directly impacting PBOT's ability to generate revenue.

49:37To this effect, Councilors Murillo, Green, Novick have proposed borrowing some reserves to spend the time necessary Thank you very much.

Dan Ryan 49:50 - 51:19

49:50All right.

49:52Hi, I'm Dare Elliott.

49:54I've worked for the city for almost 20 years and in the Fire Bureau for the last few.

49:57I'm an office support specialist and member of Ask Me 189.

50:01I have also been given my layoff notice.

50:03I triage calls from the public, support Bureau of Finance and payroll teams, assist the recruitment staff, and help coworkers when their paycheck looks funny.

50:10It's an inward-facing job, but it helps a key bureau work efficiently.

50:13When I'm gone, my work will be transferred to my remaining— my manager, my remaining coworkers, all of whom are already doing the jobs of previous staff who were cut.

50:20That means calls won't be answered, projects will be delayed, and things will be left undone.

50:24I hope that in the amendments being considered, my work and my position are included.

50:29The mayor is not an expert in the functions of the Fire Bureau and the Police Bureau and Parks and every complicated job in the city.

50:35He asked the experts, and when they gave him what he asked for, he disregarded their expertise.

50:38Thank you.

50:39These decisions will make things more expensive and less efficient.

50:42One of the positions cut in the Fire Bureau is the last analyst who secures outside funding to help cover costs, saving the city money.

50:49Other cuts in many bureaus reduce maintenance or replacement of worn-out equipment.

50:53It's a short-sighted budget that offers tweet-sized promises: no firefighters laid off, no stations closed.

50:59But this budget will cost more, not less, in failing equipment and in reduced services that help people avoid medical crises.

51:06My job and others like me make sure frontline staff can do their jobs instead of worrying about paperwork.

51:11We make the lives of firefighters, police officers, and sewer workers easier so they can do their jobs.

51:16That work is invisible.

51:17That doesn't mean it's not essential.

51:19Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 51:19 - 51:23

51:19Thank you very much.

51:21Thank you all for being here.

Rebecca Dobert 51:24 - 51:47

51:24Next we have Ali Hollenbach, Autumn Blankenship, Monzella Johnson, Andre Buenacosa Brooks, Welcome, folks.

Jamie Dunphy 51:47 - 51:50

51:47Feel free to— somebody, whoever wants to jump in, introduce yourself.

Steve Novick 51:50 - 51:52

51:50And, uh, good morning.

Dan Ryan 51:53 - 51:53

51:53Perfect.

Monzella Johnson 51:54 - 53:28

51:54Council President Dunphy and Portland City Councilors, my name is Manzella Johnson, and I am here speaking today as a member of Ask Me 189.

52:01I'm a Portland Police Central Precinct desk clerk and have been a clerk for almost 2 years, and I'm slated to be laid off.

52:06At the core of being a desk clerk is being able to delegate resources and information to the public in an easily digestible manner.

52:12This means learning rules, regulations, and procedures as quickly and confidently as possible.

52:16I'm responsible for explaining to the public on how to make a police report, what is considered a valid inquiry, and the limits in which officers can help concerning civil disputes.

52:24I have a personal script I created that helps in simplifying what can be an overwhelming influx of new information.

52:28Thank you.

52:29The people I serve at work are facing challenging situations which require tactful and professional assistance.

52:34I credit my ability to de-escalate intense situations to my lived experience as a young Black woman who has had to navigate complex situations throughout my whole life.

52:42Whether it be defusing racist encounters, misogynistic anecdotes, or simply interacting with emotionally unregulated individuals, I've had to master my patience and learn how to move through these encounters with dignity and purpose.

52:53At the root of these stressful encounters with the public is the simple fact that they need help and are attempting to reach out for a solution.

52:58They may not go about it the right way, the right way, and they may not like the answer they receive, but I make sure that respect, understanding, and patience is my foundation for every interaction.

53:06The city of Portland is home to incredibly beautiful and diverse community.

53:09Beyond using translation resources, I often write down written instructions for the elderly, those hard of hearing, and those that struggle to verbally process instructions.

53:16With big and neat lettering, I write down instructions, phone numbers, and phrases to repeat.

53:21Taking that extra bit of time to accommodate certain needs is what fosters a positive relationship between Portland Police and the community it serves.

53:27Thank you for your time.

Rebecca Dobert 53:28 - 53:29

53:28Thank you.

Jeanette DeCastro 53:31 - 54:57

53:31Hello, good morning.

53:33My name is— good morning, Chair and councilors and Mayor Wilson.

53:37My name is Jeanette DeCastro.

53:39I'm a City of Portland employee since 2017.

53:42I'm a union steward with PROTEC 17, and I am speaking on my own behalf.

53:47Right now, Mayor Wilson is asking for money for the wealthy and job cuts for working people.

53:55Governor Kotek's Prosperity Council is asking for subsidies for businesses.

54:01President Trump's administration is decimating federal agencies in favor of moving dollars to the rich.

54:08Let's not emulate that.

54:10Let's not emulate Trump.

54:12Trickle-down economics has been proven wrong.

54:15It was Reaganomics in the '80s, and it sucked then too.

54:20Mayor Wilson, I don't want you to be associated with the failure of core services realignment and this, this austerity.

54:29Um, former City Administrator Jordan is retired and comfortable.

54:33Good.

54:35But balancing the budget on the back of workers is wrong, and it means fewer services for Portlanders.

54:41Order.

54:42I'm asking council, please stop golden parachutes.

54:47Please protect PCF's mission.

54:49Please support budget amendments that keep frontline jobs, including Morillo Green and Novick 1.

54:57Thank you very much.

Alan Hipólito 54:59 - 54:59

54:59Thank you so much.

Autumn Blankenship 55:01 - 56:39

55:01Hello, my name is Autumn Blankenship.

55:03I'm a code specialist with City of Portland Tree Permitting and one of 6 staff who have received layoff notices.

55:10I am on my own time speaking as a member of my union, AFSCME Local 189.

55:15I was born and raised in Portland, and I currently live and work in District 4.

55:19I started my career in urban forestry as a seasonal employee resolving backlog from the February 2022 ice storm.

55:28In 2024, I was hired on to the newly established code compliance team.

55:33We investigate reports of tree code violations, ensure dangerous trees are removed, and verify mitigation trees are planted.

55:40Thank you.

55:41Tree management is public safety.

55:44Remember last January when trees blown down in Southeast caused power outages for thousands of homes and businesses?

55:51Or the heat dome of summer of 2021 when temperatures rose over 110 degrees?

55:59Healthy, well-managed trees reduce harm in extreme weather events.

56:03Invasive beetles are compromising our giants.

56:06The elm, ash, birch, and now oak trees.

56:09A strong forestry program is needed to safely remove large trees when necessary and rebuild the tree canopy in a strategic way.

56:18Urban forestry cannot fulfill its mission without a regulatory arm.

56:23Tree expertise needed to lead permitting does not exist in PP&D.

56:28To meet the climate crisis facing our generation, Thank you very much.

Unidentified speaker 56:42 - 58:43

56:42Hi, my name is Allie.

56:46I am a member of AFSCME Local 189.

56:49I am here to advocate for myself, the 311 team, and the Portlanders who depend on us.

56:56311 Is the main customer service department for all of the City of Portland as well as Multnomah County, and we're often the first point of contact for emergency services.

57:04And sometimes the only point of contact that people have with their local government.

57:08We make sure community voices are heard and people get connected to the right services the first time.

57:13When cuts are made to 311, this impact spreads far beyond our team.

57:17Work shifts to other bureaus, our hold times increase, and our calls are routed to 911 when our phones are not on.

57:24So that delays emergency response, it strains overloaded teams, and sends general questions to specialized staff.

57:31Thank you.

57:32The reason people reach a real person today instead of a voicemail is because we exist.

57:37These cuts undermine access to— access and equity.

57:41Older adults, those with language barriers, no internet access, anyone relying on real human help will face barriers.

57:51We turn overwhelming moments into relief because we're available when people need us.

57:56We listen and we're there to help.

57:57Everyone deserves that access.

58:00In addition to phone support, Councilor Loretta Smith.

58:016 311 Staff rotate shifts at the Portland Building front desk.

58:05This proposal will remove 2 of those positions, one of those being my own.

58:09So not only are we providing support to our community, we're also providing support to the employees of the City of Portland.

58:18We help the public city navigate services and de-escalate stressful situations, find answers every single day, and I'm honored to do this work because I see how much it matters to the people of Portland and the people I work with.

58:31We could have all the programs and services in the world, but without access, they mean nothing.

58:36Government only works when people can actually reach it.

58:39311 Is how they reach that.

58:42Thank you.

Tavaris Means 58:43 - 58:44

58:43Thank you all so much for being here.

Keelan McClymont 58:45 - 58:48

58:45Andre is online.

58:46You can unmute and go ahead, Andre.

Gloria Gonzalez 58:49 - 58:50

58:49Hello.

Andre Buenacosa Brooks 58:51 - 1:00:15

58:51Hello, councilors.

58:52My name is Andre Buenacosa Brooks, and I am a resident of District 3, and I'm on the board for Parks and Recreation.

58:58I'm here today to reiterate the concern that, that the members of the board have shared with many of you, that the proposed budget cuts will have a negative impact on the service levels that parks is able to give to the community.

59:10The voters approved a 75% increase to the parks levy to maintain current service levels.

59:17The proposed budget, along with core services realignment, sees a net loss of 70.5 FTUs to parks.

59:24With less staff to perform maintenance, clean bathrooms, or provide programming, there will inevitably be a reduction in service as teams are spread thin and capacity reaches critical limits.

59:36If services decline despite higher taxes, this creates a trust and credibility problem for the city.

59:42Public trust will be eroded if residents perceive they are paying more but getting less.

59:47Throughout the years of many levies gone by, there has been a continual overreliance on passing a parks levy That is eventually saddled with a reduction in general funds.

59:57The reliance on a levy to fund parks puts one of our most— or one of our prized and most loved public institutions at risk.

1:00:05The board implores you to restore parks' core maintenance, repair, and safety functions, as well as truly find a more sustainable funding approach for our parks.

1:00:14Thanks.

Mike Lindberg 1:00:16 - 1:00:17

1:00:16Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 1:00:23 - 1:00:55

1:00:23Next up we have Lawson D'Ambrosio, Jacob Carson, Beth Chivicek, and Marcus Mundy, Jamie Pulliam.

1:00:49Like, we have folks coming from Chambers.

1:00:53Um, Jacob's online.

1:00:54Jacob, you can go ahead.

Jacob Carson 1:00:57 - 1:02:25

1:00:57Councilors, I'm testifying today on behalf of the Portland Parks Board to urge you to reject the proposed $2.7 million in cuts to daily care, maintenance, and repair work for Portland Parks.

1:01:08This is money that keeps our parks functional, safe, and affordable to maintain over time.

1:01:12For example, line item 2, 26964, cuts $225,000 from field maintenance, and line item 26918 cuts $464,000 from the EMS budget that allows for large-scale trash pickup, vandalism remediation, and trail maintenance.

1:01:30When daily care gets cut, small problems go unnoticed.

1:01:33When maintenance gets deferred, those small problems become repair projects, and when repairs are delayed, Those repair projects become major capital failures.

1:01:41Deferred maintenance compounds.

1:01:42It compounds expensively.

1:01:44The infrastructure debt that this proposed budget would create will become visible to every resident.

1:01:49It'll look like dirty facilities, unrepaired playgrounds, damaged fields, unsafe paths, graffiti, failing irrigation, and parks that simply feel neglected.

1:01:58The public notices when daily care disappears, but the real danger is what comes after that.

1:02:03If we continue— continue hollowing out routine maintenance capacity, we are creating a ticking time bomb for the city that It is future capital liabilities that the city will eventually have to pay for at a far greater cost than if we had just paid for ongoing care, maintenance, and repair work up front.

1:02:19I urge you to protect the maintenance and repair line items in the parks budget before temporary savings become a permanent decline.

1:02:25Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:02:28 - 1:02:30

1:02:28Jamie's also online.

1:02:29Jamie, you can unmute.

1:02:30Go ahead.

Jamie Pulliam 1:02:32 - 1:03:57

1:02:32Thank you, members of the Budget Committee.

1:02:34My name is Jamie Pulliam.

1:02:35I'm a resident of the Buckman neighborhood, District 3.

1:02:39We all know that a budget is a statement of values.

1:02:42I'm here to remind you that it's also a model of assumptions.

1:02:45A budget reflects what we believe may happen when resources are removed, reduced, or shifted.

1:02:51I initially came here concerned about human trafficking and exploited youth in our region.

1:02:55Thousands of trafficking victims have been identified while critical systems are already under immense strain.

1:03:01After reviewing these discussions, however, my concern has become much larger.

1:03:05Thank you.

1:03:05This budget appears to reduce capacity across shelter, outreach, victim services, public safety, and community response.

1:03:14These are interconnected and they directly affect people's lives.

1:03:18Cuts create pressure elsewhere.

1:03:20The downstream effects may include increased vulnerability, emergency service demand, instability, criminalization, and harms that are most often absorbed by vulnerable communities first.

1:03:31So my question for the record is this: before you adopt and approve this budget, I want to know who owns responsibility for modeling these compounding harms, what data are you using, and how will you publicly track the downstream impacts that these decisions will have?

1:03:47Portland deserves to see the interdependent plan, and so far I have not heard a clear public accounting of how these reductions are being modeled across systems.

1:03:57Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:03:58 - 1:03:59

1:03:58Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 1:04:01 - 1:04:02

1:04:01You can go ahead at the testimony table.

Tavaris Means 1:04:04 - 1:05:44

1:04:04Thank you.

1:04:05Good morning, councilors.

1:04:06Morning.

1:04:07My name is Jordan, and I'm currently a firefighter paramedic currently assigned to Truck 8, stationed behind the Interstate Fred Meyer.

1:04:14My family and I have lived in North Portland for the last 15 years.

1:04:17We spend much of our time in the St. Johns neighborhood and truly value everything North Portland has to offer.

1:04:22The closure of Engine 22 has both personal and professional impacts on our community.

1:04:27On a personal level, having only one responding unit for one of the most remote stations in the city places additional strain on neighboring fire stations.

1:04:34Because of how remote Station 22 is, removing an engine from that station could have catastrophic consequences.

1:04:40Delays in engine response can mean the difference between saving a life and losing one.

1:04:45In the past few weeks alone, Station 22 has responded to 2 residential fires where a staffed engine helped prevent even greater property loss.

1:04:52Professionally, this closure affects my station.

1:04:55We are already operating with limited resources, and the closure of Engine 22 creates a ripple effect throughout North Portland.

1:05:01The closure of Engine 22 will place an even greater demand on an already busy station and further stretch limited resources across North Portland.

1:05:09I understand how difficult financial decisions the city is facing.

1:05:13However, I ask you— I ask that you reconsider the real-world impacts these cuts have on the communities we serve and the firefighters tasked with protecting them.

1:05:20Thank you.

1:05:21In emergency response, time matters.

1:05:24Minutes matter.

1:05:25The availability of properly staffed apparatus matters.

1:05:28North Portland residents deserve reliable emergency coverage, just like every other part of the city.

1:05:33I respectfully urge you to reconsider the closure of Engine 22 and the long-term consequences it may have on public safety, response times, and the resilience of our emergency response system.

1:05:43Thank you for your time.

Jamie Pulliam 1:05:45 - 1:05:45

1:05:45Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:05:49 - 1:05:52

1:05:49Thank you, friends.

1:05:52Thank you.

Lawson D'Ambrosio 1:05:56 - 1:07:32

1:05:56My name is Lawson D'Ambrosio.

1:05:58I am the board secretary for the Portland-Bologna Sister City Association, and I'm here speaking on behalf of the Portland Sister City Coalition.

1:06:06The Portland Sister City Coalition urges, uh, the city to preserve its international relations program in the fiscal year '26-'27 budget.

1:06:14In Mayor Wilson's proposed budget, the city administrator's portfolio is proposed to cut $315,000 from the government relations function in the city administrator's office by eliminating, among many other things, one FTE in the international relations program, therefore discontinuing the office's services to manage the program.

1:06:35While being cognizant that this year's budget is one of unavoidable cuts, we question whether the complete elimination of our city administrator's Councilmember Smith.

1:06:41Thank you, Mayor.

1:06:41We strongly oppose reducing the funding for the city's International Relations Program as a necessary measure, or a well-intentioned yet short-sighted reduction as the result of a genuine and urgent need to balance a difficult budget.

1:06:52We support Kanal 6, which preserves the International Relations Program specialist, though we would encourage further amendments to also preserve the Deputy Director of Government Relations, as both roles have been vital in the sister city's work with the city.

1:07:04Our sister city's international ties contribute greatly to our local culture and economy.

1:07:08Whether it's Portland Guadalajara's Cinco de Mayo festival that brings dozens of vendors and thousands of attendees to the Portland Waterfront Park every May, or the dragon boat race organized by Portland Khao Soong that some of you will be participating in in just a few weeks.

1:07:22Um, excuse me.

1:07:24Our international ties provide not merely economic value, but invaluable social and cultural contributions to our city and our community.

1:07:32Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:07:32 - 1:07:33

1:07:32Thank you very much.

Betsy Vilacek 1:07:35 - 1:09:15

1:07:35Council President Dunphy, members of the committee, my name is Betsy Vilacek and I'm the advocacy manager at the Coalition of Communities of Color.

1:07:41Our executive director, Marcus Mundy, had a delayed flight and won't make it today, but sends his regards.

1:07:47CCC is an alliance of culturally specific organizations dedicated to collective action for racial justice, including research and data justice.

1:07:56I'm writing to express CCC's support for Diversity and Leadership Fund and ask you to adopt the Avalos 5 Amendment.

1:08:03I also urge you to protect PCF funds.

1:08:05Thank you.

1:08:06Thank you.

1:08:06CCC has been an advocate for both PCF and DCL since the funds were established.

1:08:10We and our membership organizations know firsthand how important these funds are to all Portlanders, but particularly amongst Portlanders of color.

1:08:18PCF and DCL were established to help repair the disproportionate harms that communities of color face.

1:08:23Regarding PCF, we are concerned about the continuation of proposals to fund budget gaps and projects unrelated to the program's mission and without proper deliberation with community members.

1:08:33With regard to this budget, we support efforts to maintain tree canopy and permitting positions and program These draw from the same strategic programs, and this will maintain the program expertise held by these staffers.

1:08:45The Public Environment Management Office and Impact Reduction Program are plainly not climate-related initiatives and therefore should not be funded by PCEF.

1:08:53We urge you to support these amendments that remove PCEF dollars from these programs.

1:08:57Regarding DCL, many of our members are recipients of the project's funding and rely on it in order to provide trainings, programming, and leadership programs to community members.

1:09:07Organizations utilize DCL funding to enact real tangible change in communities, uh, and please continue funding it.

1:09:14Uh, thank you for the work that you're doing.

Jamie Dunphy 1:09:16 - 1:09:16

1:09:16Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 1:09:18 - 1:09:46

1:09:18Talia Giardini, Alan Ippolito, Mike Lindberg, Lynn Handlin, Chris Gustafson, Brian Kotlove, Nicholas Hash.

1:09:41Welcome up, folks.

1:09:43You can go ahead at the testimony table.

1:09:44Yeah, whoever wants to start.

Chris Gustafson 1:09:49 - 1:11:48

1:09:49Uh, hello everyone.

1:09:50Uh, Council President, uh, councilors, Mayor Wilson, CA Lee, I feel like we're old friends at this point.

1:09:57I am Chris Gustafson.

1:09:59I'm testifying on my own behalf.

1:10:01I am the Treasurer of the City of Portland Professional Workers Union.

1:10:05I am the accounting lead with the Portland Housing Bureau, and I am a resident of District 3, the Fightin' Third.

1:10:12So, uh, I'm grateful for a number of members of the City of Portland Professional Workers Union that spent their time over the weekend, uh, working on analyzing the budget amendments.

1:10:24Uh, specifically, I'd like to shout out my, um, colleague Meg Green— Meg Wren, who has done a great job setting up the infrastructure for us to work on.

1:10:33Uh, And I would like to point out a few amendments in specific that we are pretty much in full alignment that we are in support of.

1:10:42Murillo-Green, Novick 1, Avalos 3 and 6, Kanal 6, Murillo 1, Novick 2, and Dunphy 3.

1:10:51I would like to speak specifically to Murillo-Green, Novick 1, which is addressing core services realignment.

1:10:59This is an excellent opportunity.

1:11:02We absolutely feel heard.

1:11:03Thank you.

1:11:04This process has been flawed from the start.

1:11:07It has lacked engagement.

1:11:09It has been subject to flawed inventory.

1:11:10Over the last week, members, the stewards of CPPW, have been sitting with our members who are being notified of their impending layoffs.

1:11:19And in one particular example, there is a member who is being laid off as part of the HR realignment who has no HR functions at all.

1:11:27There's no remedy.

1:11:28There's no accountability or mechanism for this to be challenged.

1:11:31And in fact, there's a sinister disincentive for his manager to support him because supporting core services realignment is one of the things that managers are being reviewed on in their success factors this year.

1:11:44So please support Murillo-Green-Novick 1.

1:11:47Thank you very much, everyone.

Jamie Dunphy 1:11:48 - 1:11:49

1:11:48Thank you very much.

Alan Hipólito 1:11:51 - 1:13:25

1:11:51Buenos días, consejeras.

1:11:52Me llamo Alan Hipólito, trabajo por SUMA.

1:11:55Hello, my name is Alan.

1:11:56I work for SUMA.

1:11:57I'm here to speak in support of Avalos 1 and also to be in alignment with the prior testimony by Thank you.

1:12:05And then I'd like to use the rest of my time to underscore for this council what the PCEF Climate Investment Plan is all about and what its equity plus climate framework requires for all investments made under the CIP.

1:12:23And I'll start with a 2024 letter that was written by Verde, the Coalition of Communities of Color, and SUMA During the deliberation of the CIP, specifically to the Equity Plus Climate Framework, where we said we strongly support the framework's function as an evaluation mechanism for CIP's strategic programs.

1:12:42And what's important about that is that there are many ways to say things are consistent with PCEF, but what CIP does is set a framework, and there are 5 pieces.

1:12:53We've heard parts of them, but we rarely hear all 5.

1:12:56Benefits to frontline communities, implementation feasibility, climate impact, accountability, and fifth, community leadership.

1:13:08And I want to underscore that very clearly here because you can speak to accountability, folks can make claims of job creation or GHG reduction, but it's really hard to say that you have community leadership when you do not.

1:13:21Thank you.

1:13:21And if you do not have community leadership, it's not a PSF project.

Betsy Vilacek 1:13:25 - 1:13:25

1:13:25Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:13:26 - 1:13:27

1:13:26Thank you very much.

Nicholas Hash 1:13:31 - 1:15:09

1:13:31Good afternoon, Council.

1:13:32My name is Nicholas Hash, for the record.

1:13:35I am a city employee, a citizen of District 2, St. Johns, and I'm an organizer for the City of Portland Public Workers Local Union.

1:13:41I'm here speaking on behalf of my own views and not those of my role in the city.

1:13:46I want to start by thanking you for doing the work to make me feel represented for maybe the first time in this city.

1:13:51And that comes after a long-holding pattern of hoping that every next mayor is finally going to be the good one.

1:13:56This is why Portland changed its form of government, to establish a true form of representation, to create checks and balances, and to assure power is shared instead of concentrated.

1:14:06Council, I truly mean this when I say you are earning our trust, my trust, and the Murillo, Novick, Kanal, and Avalos amendments speak volumes towards building that trust by checking individual power in favor of those who are represented.

1:14:17Thank you.

1:14:18These amendments restore vital public services, public safety amendments, and the administrative support necessary to keep those systems functioning effectively.

1:14:25And on top of it, they do it by not pitting us against one each other— against one another for the last scraps.

1:14:31So today, I especially want to speak to what we call the moderate councilors.

1:14:36You know who you are.

1:14:37I want to acknowledge and give appreciation to you and the work you've done.

1:14:41I see it.

1:14:41We see it.

1:14:42And I'd like to acknowledge your willingness to take these issues head on.

1:14:45That has not gone unnoticed.

1:14:47But today, the amendments that best serve the people of the City of Portland are those ones before you from the Councilors Morillo, Novick, Kanal, and Avalos.

1:14:55So I'm asking you, because I know you deeply care, I'm asking you to put the people of Portland ahead of any agendas, campaigns, or perceived political alignments and vote yes on the Morillo, Novick, Kanal, and Avalos amendments, those which truly serve the good of our city in this difficult moment.

1:15:09Thank you, Council.

Jamie Dunphy 1:15:10 - 1:15:10

1:15:10Thank you very much.

Brian Kotlove 1:15:13 - 1:16:46

1:15:13Good morning, councilors.

1:15:13My name is Brian Kotlove.

1:15:15I'm a resident of District 4 along with my wife and 3 young children.

1:15:19Public safety is not a luxury item in a budget.

1:15:22It's the foundation that allows everything else to work for families, for businesses, for schools, for parks, and for every resident in this city.

1:15:29That's why I strongly support Clark Amendment 1 that restores funding for core public safety services like Station 22, rescue vehicles, the CHAT program, and public safety support specialists.

1:15:41These are practical, proven programs that directly impact response times, emergency readiness, and neighborhood safety.

1:15:48I also support Dunphy Amendment 4, which pauses COLA and merit increases for the city's highest-paid non-represented employees.

1:15:55In a difficult budget year, that's a reasonable and responsible step before cutting frontline services that everyone relies on— emergency response, parks maintenance, public safety, and Thank you.

1:16:04Before asking taxpayers for additional revenue, the city must show Portlanders that it can responsibly manage And before creating more experimental, non-proven programs, the city should focus on delivering the reliable core services that make the city that works more than just a slogan on the side of a truck.

Nicholas Hash 1:16:47 - 1:16:53

1:16:47Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:16:54 - 1:16:55

1:16:54Mike Lindberg is online.

1:16:55Mike, you can go ahead.

Mike Lindberg 1:16:57 - 1:16:58

1:16:57Can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 1:16:58 - 1:16:59

1:16:58We can.

Mike Lindberg 1:16:59 - 1:18:44

1:16:59Okay, my name is Mike Lindberg.

1:17:02I worked as a City of Portland employee for 24 years.

1:17:0517 Of those years I was on the Portland City Council.

1:17:09I'm also representing Concerned Citizens, a group, today.

1:17:13During my era, we faced severe budget challenges.

1:17:16Although I was assigned the bureaus of Arts and Culture, Parks and Rec, Energy Policy, Climate Change, Water Environmental Services, and the Portland Bureau of Transportation, I came to view public safety as a core service.

1:17:29In the words of a successful small business consultant I met recently, recently, public safety is foundational, not peripheral.

1:17:38I'm here today to support the amendment introduced by Councilor Clark and supported by Councilors Smith, Ryan, Pirtle-Guiney, and Novick that has to do with public safety.

1:17:48My input is based on my experience and my values, which generally have been viewed as progressive.

1:17:53911 Calls must be answered immediately, and police officers need to arrive, and firefighters need to arrive within a few minutes, a standard that we did have during the 1980s and 1990s.

1:18:07My own house in Laurelhurst was burglarized by armed criminals while I wasn't home, and my twin boys were in danger as they slept on the 3rd floor.

1:18:15Because a neighbor called 911 and police responded in 4 minutes, a potential catastrophe I support the way funding for public safety is identified, having fought to establish the first police oversight committee, which passed 50.1 to 49.9.

1:18:33I support a reasonable level of staffing.

1:18:35In closing, I strongly believe that if a city can't assure the safety of its families and businesses, it won't prosper in an equitable fashion.

1:18:44Thank you.

Manzella Johnson 1:18:45 - 1:18:45

1:18:45Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 1:18:47 - 1:18:49

1:18:47Lynn Handlin is also online.

1:18:49Lynn, you can go ahead.

Lynn Handlin 1:18:51 - 1:20:32

1:18:51Thanks, and thanks to City Council.

1:18:55My name is Lynn Handlen.

1:18:56I'm a small business owner in District 1, and I support Councilors Koyama Lane and Novick's amendments 2 and 3 to restore PISA funding for tree canopy programs, including restoring the 12 PISA-funded positions that the mayor wants to cut.

1:19:12These jobs are for tree protection, planting, and care needed to implement or already Thank you.

1:19:18Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1:19:18Thank you, Mayor.

1:19:18I'm here to speak out against the weak tree code.

1:19:20PSF funds must be used as they were intended by the voters, which includes taking care of trees that provide so many benefits to communities, especially in communities that do not have the shade they need and will need so much more as the planet continues to heat up, in part because of the loss of trees.

1:19:37The ever-decreasing tree shade canopy in Portland is a real injustice enabled by past city councils.

1:19:44And I know you guys can do better.

1:19:46These amendments help alleviate that.

1:19:49Shade trees increase climate resilience and help slow the heating of the planet.

1:19:55Contrary to the mayor's desires, PSF funds were very definitely not intended for things like funding the improvements of a sports palace that does not actually bring promised jobs.

1:20:05PSF funds must be— must be used to be spent on jobs, Like caring for trees that benefit for all.

1:20:13I also— related, I also support Avalos 1.

1:20:16PCF money must not be used for sidewalk cleaning and the like.

1:20:21We are in a climate emergency.

1:20:23We need to protect PCF funds.

1:20:26Side note to Mayor Wilson's very rude email, I'm wearing a red shirt.

1:20:30Thank you very much, City Council.

Manzella Johnson 1:20:33 - 1:20:35

1:20:33Thank you very much.

1:20:35Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:20:36 - 1:20:37

1:20:36You can go ahead at the testimony table.

Talia Giardini 1:20:38 - 1:22:07

1:20:38Hi, my name is Talia and I'm a person in recovery.

1:20:40First, I absolutely support Clark's amendment to use millions in unspent OCPA funds to fill the fire and police budget gap.

1:20:47A city can't function without safety.

1:20:49We can't have functioning transit, businesses, jobs, parks, schools, or hospitals without public safety.

1:20:54Nothing else matters if we aren't safe.

1:20:56My other concern is Green's amendment to cut Urban Alchemy's contract, which is a bad idea when the city has a better track record than the county Um, for homeless vendors.

1:21:06The county just started implementing auditor's recommendations and have found several financial issues causing them to cut ties.

1:21:12Urban Alchemy moves the most people the fastest through shelter and housing, while county SRVs have people sitting for 1 to 3 years who are still not ready for housing.

1:21:20We should not cut their contract until we have full picture of accountability on all of our homeless vendors, considering these issues are not an isolated event.

1:21:28BHRC was also closed due to staff selling drugs and engaging in misconduct.

1:21:32Thank you.

1:21:33We use people in— we use peers in recovery as staff, usually in early recovery, and place them in triggering situations with active drug use and chaos.

1:21:42I would have not made it through early recovery in a situation like that.

1:21:45It's hypocritical to punish an organization for staff slipping up when we set them up for failure.

1:21:51The low-barrier shelter approach prioritizes people who are actively using drugs over people trying to improve their lives.

1:21:58Audit all homeless nonprofits before cutting Urban Alchemy.

1:22:01Councilmember Herbold.

1:22:01Again, I support public safety.

1:22:04You could cut the entire accountability budget and put it in public safety.

Jamie Dunphy 1:22:10 - 1:22:10

1:22:10Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 1:22:17 - 1:22:38

1:22:17Next we have Tiana Tozer, Carol Pinniger, Casey Barnard, Matt Shipke, Gloria Gonzalez.

1:22:37You can go ahead, Carol.

Carol Pinniger 1:22:39 - 1:24:05

1:22:39I'm Carol Pinniger, living in Cully, District 2, where farsighted homeowners before me preserved trees so it's cooler around me than in District 1, East Portland.

1:22:48I urge you to support Councilor Avalos' proposal to return PSEF money to PSEF.

1:22:54The mayor's proposed budget steals revenue from strategic programs to give it to Portland Solutions An initiative that serves the Portland Business Alliance by funding trash cleanup, graffiti removal, and laundry services, but has nothing to do with PCEF's core services of climate change solutions.

1:23:11This is about equity.

1:23:12We voted for PCEF to help deal with effects of climate change, which hit hardest in East Portland, where many of our most vulnerable citizens live.

1:23:21I volunteer weekly at an East Portland elementary school that serves students who have no shade on their way to school and few parks with mature trees in which to play.

1:23:30They need shade just as much as my neighbors and I. I also urge you to support Councilors Koyama Lane's Amendment 2 and Novick's 3 to retain PCF-funded positions for tree canopy programs.

1:23:42Mayor Wilson proposes to cut these 12 positions that are responsible for enforcing Portland's tree code on top of the 11 cuts since last June.

1:23:51Running on a platform touting a climate-friendly business fleet of electric vehicles, the mayor now wants to gut the climate-friendly program designed to plant, protect, Protect PCEF funds.

Lynn Handlin 1:24:06 - 1:24:06

1:24:06Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:24:06 - 1:25:31

1:24:06Thank you very much.

1:24:09Hello, councilors.

1:24:10My name is Matt Chipke, and I'm a resident of District 4 and the vice chair of the Portland Parks and Recreation Board.

1:24:15I'm here today to reiterate the concern that we have shared personally with many of you, that parks is once again being asked to bear the brunt of budget cuts and that those cuts will materially change what residents experience in parks for the worse.

1:24:28As noted by my colleagues, this reduction in service is not what Portlanders thought they were signing on to when they voted to increase what they pay for the parks levy.

1:24:36Parks is bearing the brunt of the city's general fund reductions at a close to 16% reduction from last year's general fund contribution, with police and fire seeing cuts of less than half of that amount.

1:24:47Parks is also seeing a net loss of 70 FTEs.

1:24:49This is the largest reduction to any bureau and represents 34% of all citywide FTE reductions.

1:24:57We do appreciate this is a difficult budget year, but disproportionately cutting a service that polliners consider— consistently say they highly value in polls and at the voting booth is not consistent with citizen preference.

1:25:10We have shared with you all 3 areas where modest add-backs could significantly positively impact user experiences and reduce future costs.

1:25:17We urge you to consider those targeted and modest adjustments.

1:25:21In areas of daily ongoing maintenance work, repair and maintenance work, and security and emergency contracting.

1:25:27Appreciate your time today, and the Parks Board looks forward to future opportunities to engage with you all.

Manzella Johnson 1:25:32 - 1:25:33

1:25:32Thank you very much.

Tiana Tozer 1:25:36 - 1:27:12

1:25:36Tiana Tozer, District 2.

1:25:37I've taken vacation time to be here today.

1:25:39The key to getting out of this budget crisis is economic development.

1:25:42The key to economic development is safety and livability.

1:25:45Fully funding police, fire, and PMO is the base for safety.

1:25:48We all know what the definition of insanity is.

1:25:51I'm here to support the Clark 1 amendment.

1:25:53Hiring a director and 7 staff for the police accountability will not cost $16 million, and I would support moving even more from the Office of Police Accountability.

1:26:02Why does the OCPA need more staff than the city administrator?

1:26:07When voters passed a ballot measure to establish a police accountability commission, they had no idea how much 5% of the police budget was and is.

1:26:14Councilmember And of course, the ballot measure didn't include that information.

1:26:18It seems ironic to me that we are establishing accountability board based on information that wasn't transparent, and now certain council members don't want to be accountable to correct bad policy.

1:26:29Most of the city of Portland's advisory and citizen boards do not have standalone operating budgets.

1:26:34In addition, the Canal Green Amendment to cut management positions only makes sense if we are protecting the jobs of frontline workers.

1:26:41Public-facing and on-the-street employees, not people working behind a desk from home.

1:26:46Finally, I will remind you that the ADA settlement does not expire until June 30th, 2028, and you have camp cleanup obligations under that settlement.

1:26:54If you do not meet them, I will see you in court.

1:26:57Now is not the time for pet projects and ideology.

1:27:00Like all Portlanders, you have difficult decisions to make.

1:27:02For me, the baseline is, does this or does this not make Portland Safe for our children.

1:27:08I did not think your email was rude, Mr. Mayor.

1:27:12Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:27:14 - 1:27:16

1:27:14Casey Barnard.

1:27:15Casey's online, you can go ahead.

Casey Barnard 1:27:18 - 1:29:07

1:27:18Yes, thank you everyone.

1:27:19My name is Casey Barnard and I work for Work Systems and I am a resident of District 2.

1:27:26We believe that city leaders value equity and workforce investments that strengthen our local economy by helping Portlanders gain the skills needed to fill competitive jobs.

1:27:36Cutting annual sustained workforce programs in this economy puts Portlanders at even greater risk.

1:27:43We ask City Council to act now to restore COEP construction workforce services to $1.46 million in the mayor's budget.

1:27:54This—.

1:27:54We ask that you also work with the city procurement team to restore COEP programs in alignment with the city's commitment to the Regional Construction Career Pathways Aye.

1:28:07The COEP investment leverages an additional $1.3 million through Work Systems Community Construction Training Program, CCTP.

1:28:18This supports more than 300 community members with career coaching, pre-apprenticeship training, connections to registered apprenticeships and jobs.

1:28:26Any gap in funding would immediately destabilize services with trusted community-based partners.

1:28:32Without funding, as of July, almost 20 dedicated and experienced CCTP staff could lose their jobs, and their organizations may have to shutter critical programs.

1:28:43Portland residents would lose trusted on-ramps to family-wage careers with organizations who are uniquely positioned to help workers and employers navigate today's slower market.

1:28:55Thank you for your consideration.

1:28:57Please support Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's amendment and add additional funding to ensure these workforce Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 1:29:08 - 1:29:12

1:29:08Gloria Gonzalez is online.

1:29:11You can go ahead.

Gloria Gonzalez 1:29:13 - 1:30:31

1:29:13Hi, my name is Gloria Gonzalez.

1:29:15I am not an organization representative.

1:29:17Instead, I'm someone whose life was personally impacted by gang violence.

1:29:21Therefore, I am here supporting POIC's outreach program.

1:29:25There are many people in our community who are struggling silently, young people dealing with violence, So programs like this matter because they actually reach people before it's too late.

1:29:40I know this firsthand because POIC helped myself, my husband, and most importantly, my kids.

1:29:45They provided support, guidance, and people who genuinely cared when we needed it most.

1:29:51Instead of being judged or ignored, we were given encouragement, resources, and hope.

1:29:56That kind of outreach changes lives in ways statistics alone cannot possibly measure.

1:29:59Councilmember Fully Herbold.

1:30:00Measured.

1:30:01Without programs like POIC, many people in our community would have nowhere to turn because not everyone has strong support systems at home or safe environments around them.

1:30:10Sometimes one mentor, one conversation, or one opportunity can completely change someone's direction in life.

1:30:17So I'm asking that you continue to fund and support this program because I've seen firsthand the impact it has.

1:30:23This is not just another program on paper.

1:30:25They actually help Real people in real life within the city every single day who need support just like I did.

1:30:30Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 1:30:31 - 1:30:47

1:30:31Thank you very much.

1:30:34Okay, colleagues, it is just about 11 o'clock right now.

1:30:38We are an hour and a half into this.

1:30:40I'm going to give us a 15-minute break.

1:30:42Everybody please be back here at 11:10, and we will get back into testimony at that point.

1:30:47Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:47:05 - 1:47:31

1:47:05And we are coming back to order now.

1:47:08Thank you all for indulging a quick bio break.

1:47:12Let's go ahead and call back our—.

1:47:13Call up our next panel of testimony.

1:47:20Next up we have Hayag Brown, Sarah Fisher, Crystal Delehanty, Roy Moore, Christopher Olson, Pedro Sanchez.

Tavaris Means 1:47:32 - 1:47:34

1:47:32Let's go.

Unidentified speaker 1:47:34 - 1:47:43

1:47:34Thanks, folks.

1:47:35Come on up, introduce yourselves, feel free to share your pronouns, and you have 90 seconds apiece.

1:47:42Well, I have to—.

Haig Brown 1:47:45 - 1:49:10

1:47:45Good morning, City Council President Dunphy and City Council.

1:47:50Thank you.

1:47:51My name is Haig Brown.

1:47:52I'm with POIC.

1:47:54As you heard prior to the break, Ms. Gloria Gonzalez was one of our past participants and her family and what the work has done for the City of Portland and our community.

1:48:06We're here to support the Ceasefire program as well as all public safety in the Office of Violence Prevention.

1:48:15The reason why right now it's so important, because the growth of this program of Ceasefire and OVP within the past 5 to 6 years has given us the opportunity as a community to work together.

1:48:31And this is the first time that a lot of the CBOs have had the chance to actually work with one another.

1:48:37Thank you.

1:48:37Doing this work and collaborate together.

1:48:41Also, along with the police, the FITCOG crisis response, Multnomah County, everything that falls under public safety is a key right now at keeping our city safe.

1:48:58And that's all I have for now.

1:49:00I'm a co-director of the Community Safety Department at Good morning, President Dunphy and city councilors.

Roy Moore 1:49:10 - 1:50:28

1:49:10My name is Roy Moore.

1:49:11I am the co-director of the Community Care Team along with Haig Brown at POIC.

1:49:16First, let me start off by saying thank you for this opportunity to speak on behalf of the Ceasefire Program and Office of Violence Prevention.

1:49:23My story is, is that I'm a survivor of gun violence.

1:49:27I know what it's like firsthand to sit in that hospital bed and to have somebody like who works for my program show up at that hospital bed and provide support.

1:49:35And I always say, if I had that when I was going through my moment, I would have changed my life a lot sooner than what I did.

1:49:42Unfortunately, in our sector, when we have success, historically support runs out.

1:49:48So I challenge you to double down in a time where we are seeing success.

1:49:51As long as bullets are flying, nobody is safe.

1:49:54I don't care what district you work for.

1:49:57So I am here advocating for the continued support of funding with no cuts.

1:50:02Any cuts will severely impact the recent success that we have.

1:50:06What we do works.

1:50:08I oversee our hospital violence intervention program, the only one in this state.

1:50:12Last year, we served over 140 victims.

1:50:15Our recidivism rate is less than 1%, and since 2020, a victim signing on to our caseload, only one has been revictimized.

1:50:23What we do works, and the city should fund what works.

1:50:26Thank you.

1:50:28Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:50:28 - 1:50:32

1:50:28Thank you.

Sarah Fisher 1:50:32 - 1:52:30

1:50:32Good morning, Council President and City Council.

1:50:36I'm Sarah Fisher.

1:50:37I'm an Episcopal priest, and I belong to Hope and Bread Street Church on 82nd Avenue.

1:50:43I'm also on the board of Ground Score Association, Go Green 3, and Go Glitter.

1:50:48My faith teaches me that when you protect widows and orphans, When we provide hospitality to strangers and comfort the afflicted, everyone thrives.

1:51:00Our parks are a Portland treasure that belong to all of us.

1:51:05The Montavilla Picnic Shelter is an investment in East Portland that provides barrier-free shared space to gather in community.

1:51:15As the mayor's budget seeks to dismantle vital programs, building this park shelter is a way to provide hope To our community, housed and unhoused, and show that we are not turning our backs on them.

1:51:30This is particularly meaningful for seniors, people with disabilities, and families with young children.

1:51:36The price tag has gone up considerably since the plans were made in 2021.

1:51:43That is a good reason to do it now rather than waiting.

1:51:47It is an opportunity for the city to monitor costs, identify inefficiencies, and create a tested model for Thank you.

1:51:55I'd like to thank Councilor Koyama Lane for visiting Hope and Bread multiple times, and we're grateful to Councilors Avalos and Dunphy for joining us last December.

1:52:07Councilor Novick, I know that we are on your radar, and our office is looking forward to getting you out to see us very soon.

1:52:14And Councilors Smith and Murillo, you are always welcome any Sunday at 5, as are the rest of you.

1:52:23Once you see what we're doing in community, you will understand why we are so proud of our work.

1:52:27How important this shelter is.

1:52:29Thank you so much.

Unidentified speaker 1:52:31 - 1:52:31

1:52:31Thank you.

Carrie Coe 1:52:34 - 1:52:35

1:52:34I'm Crystal Delahanty.

Tiana McMullen 1:52:35 - 1:52:51

1:52:35I'm the founding executive director of PDX Saints Love.

1:52:39I have submitted written testimony, but for the sake of democracy today, I am going to yield my time to, uh, a Umatilla Confederated Tribal member and longtime elder in East Portland.

Unidentified speaker 1:53:03 - 1:54:45

1:53:03Good morning, Mayor Wilson, City Administrator Lee, Council President, and City Council members.

1:53:11I am here this morning, um, I'm a resident in the Cully neighborhood of District 2.

1:53:18I'm here to give testimony in support of the Councilor Green 3 amendment.

1:53:23My testimony includes one of my 4 sons who has— have lived experiences as home— as a homeless person on the streets of Portland.

1:53:32My son's success in part is from the workforce development program of PDX Saints Love.

1:53:39After making the decision between life and death, he chose to get clean and live after 30 years of addiction and homelessness.

1:53:47The valuable life skills and employment readiness The skills and confidence he learned under the internship program allowed him to get hired at the day center.

1:53:54The peer support and communication skills gave him confidence to get placement into housing.

1:54:00The barriers that he, his peers, and prospective trainees gained allowed them to be of service in their involvement with the Lents Park food serving, day centers, showers, clothing, and donations.

1:54:12To this day, my 4 sons are all in recovery, employed, and have housing.

1:54:17I would say this is a generational success story.

1:54:20The kind we'd like to see area-wide.

1:54:22It is possible.

1:54:24I look forward to Gerald Skelton's presence and participation as the Tribal Government Relations Manager in Portland.

1:54:31Again, I support Councilor Green's Amendment 3 to move sanitation hygiene workforce development from IRO to its own line item so organizations can apply via RFP.

1:54:44Thank you.

1:54:45Thank you very much.

Ruth Levine 1:54:46 - 1:54:46

1:54:46Thank you all.

Unidentified speaker 1:54:47 - 1:55:24

1:54:47Thank you.

1:54:53We're going to Darice Weller, Donna Cohen, Ron Schmidt, Jamal Williams, Candace Jimenez, Carrie Cook.

1:55:12Thank you.

1:55:20You can go ahead at the testimony table.

Daryce Weller 1:55:25 - 1:56:53

1:55:25Mayor Roslyn and councilors, my name is Daryce Weller.

1:55:28I'm a Linnton resident in District 4.

1:55:31Lives and safety should not be compromised by budget cuts.

1:55:35Fires spread over significant distances and quickly.

1:55:39More than Linnton is at risk.

1:55:41St. Johns Fire Station Number 22 best serves Linnton, which is the most at-risk neighborhood for wildfires in the city of Portland, the CEI hub, St. Helens Highway with heavy traffic carrying flammable fuels, the railroad lines storing Zenith's highly volatile fuels, and wildfires in Forest Hills Park.

1:56:03A fire truck from downtown, which is the next closest fire station, could be hampered by daily occurring heavy traffic.

1:56:10Councilmember Loretta Smith.

1:56:13And by 2 hairpin turns to access Germantown Road into Forest Hills Park, whereas Station 22 is close and comes directly across the St. Johns Bridge.

1:56:25We all held our breaths last year due to drought conditions that a wildfire would not occur.

1:56:32This year's drought conditions are predicted to be worse.

1:56:35Last year, a fire was started in a homeless camp in Forest Hills Park off Germantown Road, but was quickly doused before it could spread because of the rapid response by Station 22.

1:56:47Green won.

1:56:48The compromise to fully fund Station 22 should be adopted to keep us all safe.

Kimberly Ruffew 1:56:53 - 1:56:53

1:56:53Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:56:54 - 1:56:55

1:56:54Thank you very much.

Ron Schmidt 1:57:00 - 1:58:49

1:57:00Good morning, Mayor Wilson, Commissioner Administrator Lee, President Dunphy, and City Commission.

1:57:06I am Ron Schmidt.

1:57:07I'm the director of the East Portland I'm a director and past president of the Waterfront Organizations of Oregon, and I'm a liaison between the East Portland Chamber and the Oregon Association of Minority Entrepreneurs.

1:57:24I'm a past president and longtime director of the Hayden Island Neighborhood Association, but I am speaking today as a businessman and a family person.

1:57:35I love Portland for its vibrancy, its culture, its proximity to the beautiful nature, and of course, the waterfront.

1:57:42Thank you.

1:57:43I'd like to talk about the issues with the front door to our city of Portland, that being Hayden Island, to this, the entire state of Oregon, but we don't have time for that.

1:57:54What's critical today is the budget and public safety.

1:57:58Small business is the economic foundation of any community, and it is the generator of family jobs.

1:58:05Those of us that pay taxes to this beautiful city deserve basic services.

1:58:11Councilor Mitch Green.

1:58:11That begin and end with public safety— 911, police, and fire.

1:58:16All these basic public safety cuts must be restored, or it will leave longtime volunteers like myself and businesses continuing to flee the city of Portland.

1:58:28You have a choice today to restore basic services for businesses and families as a vote of confidence for us to stay in this city and work together.

1:58:39You don't want to lose any more volunteers.

1:58:41I am grateful to live in the city of Portland.

1:58:45I'm grateful for your service.

1:58:47Give us the basic service we need.

1:58:49Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:58:50 - 1:58:50

1:58:50Thank you very much.

Carrie Coe 1:58:53 - 2:00:12

1:58:53Hello, Council.

1:58:54My name is Carrie Coe.

1:58:55I am president of the City of Portland Professional Workers Union, and I'm here today on my— on a break from my day job at the Portland Permitting and Development Bureau.

1:59:04There are many important stories about why you should do the right thing today and vote for Morillo-Green-Novick 1.

1:59:10In fact, you've heard dozens and dozens and dozens of Staff testify about the impacts of this project of core realignment over the last year, and I want you to listen to your workers.

1:59:23You can see— I know you can— that the city is rushing and ramshackling together core realignment.

1:59:30Even if you think that centralization is a good idea, you know that poor planning has real consequences with the potential to put the city at real risk.

1:59:39It is your job to not just prioritize the shiny programs that people can easily see out outside of their front door, but to also prioritize the internal city systems that keep every other thing working.

1:59:53And this is the essence of core realignment.

1:59:56You have the opportunity to reject the false urgency and demand the city do better.

2:00:01You have the opportunity to do it right, preserve services and preserve jobs here at the City of Portland.

2:00:07Please, we advocate— we're advocating for yes vote on Murillo.

2:00:11Thank you.

2:00:11Green Novick 1.

Unidentified speaker 2:00:12 - 2:00:14

2:00:12Thank you.

2:00:14Thank you very much.

Candace Jimenez 2:00:22 - 2:02:05

2:00:22Good morning, councilors.

2:00:24My name is Candace Jimenez.

2:00:26I'm a citizen of the Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs, a Portland community member, and board chair of the Portland Harbor Community Coalition.

2:00:33I'm here to urge your support of Koyama Lane's amendment to add $30,000 to support the Tribal Nations Summit.

2:00:40I want to acknowledge the weight of the decisions before you today.

2:00:43This budget includes difficult trade-offs, and I honor the many community members who are testifying here today for urgent needs across housing, safety, health, climate, infrastructure, and basic services.

2:00:55These needs are real, and this moment asks the city to be both careful and courageous.

2:01:00I also come to this testimony as someone living on cultural and accustomed lands that hold the memory and responsibility of many tribal nations.

2:01:07These include the lands and waters shared through trade, travel, fishing, gathering, ceremony, kinship, and co-stewardship across generations.

2:01:16This is also a city whose growth and wealth are tied to land settlement and the disposition of Indigenous peoples.

2:01:22Naming that history is not about staying in the past.

2:01:25It's about being honest enough to build a different future.

2:01:28Portland sits within a living Indigenous landscape where the Willamette and Columbia Rivers where water, land, salmon, medicines, first foods, and natural spaces carry memory, responsibility, and relationship.

2:01:40A Tribal Nations Summit is a small but meaningful investment in tribal sovereignty, government-to-government relationship, repair, and responsibility.

2:01:49It affirms that tribal nations must be engaged as governments, not stakeholders, especially as Portland works to repair trust and strengthen its tribal relations program.

2:01:58I respectfully urge you to support Koyama Lane's amendment for this place, for our responsibilities and future generations.

2:02:04Thank you.

Annette Ramirez 2:02:05 - 2:02:06

2:02:05Thank you very much.

Unidentified speaker 2:02:07 - 2:02:08

2:02:07Donna Cohen, go ahead online.

Donna Cohen 2:02:10 - 2:03:48

2:02:10Thank you.

2:02:10Um, my name is Donna Cohen.

2:02:12I live in St. Johns.

2:02:14A couple of quick points about Station 22.

2:02:18The geographic area it covers is huge— St. Johns, Cathedral Park, Forest Park, Linnton, Sauvie Island, The Port of Portland and Rivergate Industrial Area alone employs 30,000 people.

2:02:32This is not just a District 2 or District 4 issue.

2:02:35The tens of thousands of people who work on the North Peninsula live in every district.

2:02:41And of course, after the earthquake, now estimated at a 1 in 3 chance in the next 35 years— a 1 in 3 chance—.

2:02:50Thank you.

2:02:51In the next 35 years, much of this area will be completely severed from the rest of Portland.

2:02:58It is irresponsible enough the council has not moved to secure an emergency route for the North Peninsula.

2:03:04Leaving Station 22 with no fire engine would be unconscionable.

2:03:10And a very small but important request on behalf of a group of seniors.

2:03:15We lost our Friday senior exercise class at Charles Jordan Community Center 2 years ago when the teacher moved away.

2:03:22We've been waiting for a replacement, which the director now says depends on the budget.

2:03:27Given that all the senior exercise classes at St. John's Community Center were eliminated, and many of us used to go there a few years ago, we would really appreciate if we could have this one once-a-week class reinstated at Charles Jordan.

2:03:45This is about health.

2:03:46For seniors, not recreation.

2:03:48Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:03:49 - 2:03:53

2:03:49Thank you very much.

2:03:51Jamal Williams is online.

2:03:53You can go ahead.

Jamal Williams 2:03:55 - 2:05:49

2:03:55My name is Jamal Williams, and I want to speak briefly about why continued funding for Ceasefire, POIC, plus RAHS and Healing Hurt People is so important to our community during the most difficult moments and my family's life, the staff at POIC and Healing Hurt People showed up for me and my family.

2:04:20I'm just simply asking that the mayor, the council president, and others keep your promises to Black Portland.

2:04:30Do not continue to disenfranchise our community with underfunded programs that Work hand in hand with public safety.

2:04:44It is our kids that are out here dying.

2:04:47It is our kids that are out here in East Portland and in North Portland and Central Northeast Portland that are suffering from the disenfranchisement of funds and equitable services.

2:05:04Thank you.

2:05:05I am just plainly asking, as a person who is vested in District 2, right, and has lived my whole life in the city of Portland, please do not continue, right, to underserve our population.

2:05:22Please, Mayor, keep your promises to Black Portland.

2:05:30We are already Underrepresented in our city structure.

2:05:36We are already underrepresented in a lot of areas in Portland.

2:05:40So just please continue, right, the services that are so vitally needed by those programs.

2:05:48Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:05:50 - 2:06:18

2:05:50Thank you very much.

2:05:53Tiana McMullen, Kevin Block, Stacy Brewster, Christine Albertson, Deanne Salazar.

2:06:17Whoever's ready can go ahead.

Tiana McMullen 2:06:19 - 2:07:36

2:06:19Oh, hi, I'm Tiana McMullen.

2:06:23Uh, I'm here with PDX Saints Love serving District 3.

2:06:28I'm here today because I believe workforce development needs to be taken seriously and funded separately from Portland Solutions.

2:06:36I am proof of what workforce development can do to stabilize someone transitioning out of homelessness.

2:06:44Opportunities for employment and support services create real pathways towards stability, independence, and long-term success.

2:06:53If we truly want a city where everyone can thrive, we need to invest in people before they fall deeper into crisis, not just respond after the fact.

2:07:03Lastly, I want to express concern over the dismissive tone the mayor has used towards City Council and voters in recent communications.

2:07:12Leadership should be rooted in respect, accountability, and follow-through.

2:07:17Many people supported this administration because of promises made to vulnerable communities.

2:07:22Thank you.

2:07:24And too many of those promises have not been kept.

2:07:27Our city deserves leadership that listens to the people it serves and invests in solutions that create lasting stability and dignity for everyone.

2:07:36Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:07:37 - 2:07:37

2:07:37Thank you very much.

Deon Salazar 2:07:40 - 2:09:13

2:07:40Greetings, Mayor and councilors.

2:07:42I am Deon Salazar.

2:07:43I serve on state and local boards for foster youth, East Portland, children's funding, and other issues.

2:07:50I'm here today to testify as myself from D1 and acting campaign manager for D3 Council candidate Mike Johnson on specific budget amendments.

2:08:01First, I strongly urge you to support Dunphy 3.

2:08:04East Portland has been long sold out by elitist insiders for just too long, and, uh, oh, who ignore the vulnerable forgotten pillars of Portland.

2:08:15$480,000 In funding is the bare minimum.

2:08:18Thank you.

2:08:19We deserve to feel like Portland.

2:08:23Next, I am cautious of Dunphy 4.

2:08:26I have long called for fiscal responsibility, but this is currently written too broad.

2:08:31I would suggest a more targeted freeze for middle and upper management.

2:08:35Green 1 is a step in the right direction in public safety.

2:08:39I endorse that amendment.

2:08:41I have mixed feelings on Avalos 4.

2:08:44I support the goal of stronger homelessness governance and transition planning, But I have to sadly urge council to reject this current iteration.

2:08:55It needs clearer metrics, deadlines, and reporting requirements so this, so this reserve produces measurable improvement.

2:09:03It's time for a budget that improves outcomes.

2:09:07The people are sick of empty sentiment.

2:09:10Let's use this budget to deliver bold action.

Emory Mort 2:09:13 - 2:09:13

2:09:13Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:09:14 - 2:09:15

2:09:14Thank you very much.

Alice Christine Walker 2:09:18 - 2:11:02

2:09:18Good morning, councilors, Mayor C.A.

2:09:21Lee.

2:09:22My name is Alice Christine Walker, and I'm here representing East Columbia Neighborhood Association.

2:09:28I'm here as a conduit for the many voices in our community who cannot physically be in this room— our elderly, our disabled, our working parents with inflexible schedules, and those too intimidated to speak out.

2:09:41East Columbia is a 2.3-mile tapestry that contains the full economic and ecological spectrum of Portland.

2:09:48We have high-density fixed-income homes and an active agricultural core.

2:09:54We are incredibly proud of creating the nearly 30-acre Children's Arboretum, a massive natural canopy with unmatched potential for citywide climate education.

2:10:04While much of the city's budget process relies on top-down, bureau-driven allocations, the actual self-identified infrastructure needs of our community are consistently bypassed.

2:10:14Councilmember Loretta Smith.

2:10:16Like everybody, we feel— we desire to feel safe at work, but more importantly, we need to feel safe, seen, and supported in our own backyards first.

2:10:26We know that conversations that begin with shame and blame are never productive, and so we're here in the spirit of collaboration with the council, backed by a loyal commitment to serve our community.

2:10:36We do not envy the decisions that the council has to make with these drastic budget shortfalls, but we ask you to consider a more balanced rising tide lifts all ships approach.

2:10:48As you finalize this year's budget, please ensure that neighborhoods like ours with this level of socioeconomic and ecological diversity receive the support necessary to keep our neighborhoods safe, connected, and resilient.

2:11:01Thank you very much for your time and consideration.

Unidentified speaker 2:11:03 - 2:11:03

2:11:03Thank you.

Kevin Block 2:11:06 - 2:11:41

2:11:06Thank you, councilors, for taking the time to hear our comments today.

2:11:09My name is Kevin Block.

2:11:10I am a program and policy coordinator at BPS and the elected chief steward of the City of Portland Professional Workers Union.

2:11:17But today I am here speaking as someone who lives in D3 and works in D4.

2:11:22Like most of my fellow union members, consecutive years of budget cuts means I hold a wide variety of duties in my job.

2:11:28This means this experience has provided me with certainty when I say this: when you cut jobs, the work doesn't go away.

2:11:35It gets delayed, done rushed, spread out among already overworked staff, contracted out, and ultimately costs lives.

Unidentified speaker 2:11:41 - 2:11:43

2:11:41Thank you.

2:11:43More.

Kevin Block 2:11:43 - 2:12:10

2:11:43In order to preserve safe and efficient functioning of the city services, I urge you to consider adopting the following amendments: Morillo-Green-Novick 1, Morillo 1, Avalos 3 and 6, Kanal 6, Novick 2, and Dunphy 3.

2:12:00These amendments will help ensure that Portlanders remain engaged and safe, city staff are appropriately trained, and the city's bills are paid on time.

2:12:07Thank you.

2:12:08Thank you very much.

Stacy Brewster 2:12:14 - 2:13:27

2:12:14Morning, councilors, mayor, city administrator.

2:12:17My name is Stacy Brewster, and I am an everyday Portlander in a blue shirt.

2:12:21My husband and I live near Creston Park in District 3.

2:12:24He is a mental health therapist.

2:12:26I'm a writer who works as communications staff for the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

2:12:30I also serve as a steward and elected board member of the City of Portland Professional Workers Union.

2:12:35I'm here in support of your amendments protecting frontline jobs essential for our city to thrive, and we'll speak to Murillo Green Novick 1, which would pause the ill-conceived and poorly implemented core services realignment project until there's an actual plan, transparency, and real engagement with labor and staff.

2:12:52I would also suggest you take it a step further and stop the demotions of line staff and promotions of managers that are also happening as part of this plan.

2:13:00At PBOT, realignment will hit hard and hurt the very priorities this council and mayor have identified: Vision Zero, good asset management, building new sidewalks, bringing back residential street sweeping citywide, mayor, regulating companies like Waymo who want to bust into our market, and of course being fully staffed to hit the ground running with new ongoing funding this council just passed.

2:13:23None of this can be done without our GIS techs or the people who ensure we track $22 billion in assets.

Unidentified speaker 2:13:28 - 2:13:28

2:13:28Councilmember Herbold.

Stacy Brewster 2:13:29 - 2:13:53

2:13:29None of this can be done without those who handle complex payment systems, including compliance and accuracy of millions of Lyft and Uber rides, ensuring corporations pay their fair share and operate legally, and which bring in $14 to $17 million a year.

2:13:44And of course, none of these things can be done while cutting the very people who do our hiring and onboarding of new staff at this critical time.

2:13:50Stop the cuts.

2:13:51Pause this project.

2:13:52Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:13:53 - 2:17:45

2:13:53Thank you very much.

2:14:01Luis Del Toro Garcia, Simone Cordery Cotter, Chris Roller, Kimberly Rufu, Muhammad G.

2:14:19Welcome, folks.

2:14:21Hi there.

2:14:22Um, I signed up for online testimony, but I didn't get my Zoom link, so I'm here in person.

2:14:26Just wanted to share that.

2:14:29Um, my name is Luis.

2:14:29Mi nombre es Luis.

2:14:30I'm a City of Portland employee.

2:14:32I'm here today because I'm deeply concerned about the lack of transparency, consistency, and accountability surrounding this year's proposed budget.

2:14:39I read the mayor's 1,141-page budget document in full, and I found critical information either missing, inconsistently represented, or difficult to interpret.

2:14:47At the time when the city is facing historic financial shortfalls and proposing major workforces and service impacts, the public should not have to piece together the truth from scattered documents, leadership comments, and media reporting.

2:14:58Media reporting.

2:14:59Councilor Zimmerman stated it clearly: the mayor's document is accessible, but it is not transparent.

2:15:04I agree.

2:15:05Councilor Kanal also raised the desire to further examine how labor is organized within the city.

2:15:10If councilors are raising confusion, these are signs that the information being presented.

2:15:14To council and to the public is incomplete.

2:15:16Compared to last year's budget document, the year's— this year's format removed key context that helped workers, residents, and the council understand what was actually changing.

2:15:24Last year's bureaus included staffing comparisons between fiscal years, including impacts to existing positions and associated budget changes.

2:15:31This year, much of that context is gone.

2:15:34The mayor's budget document has also failed to clearly identify how many proposed position cuts affect currently filled positions versus vacant positions.

2:15:41Yes, shortly after the document was released, city leadership was able to privately provide some of that information internally.

2:15:48If leadership already has that information available, why is that not being transparently included in the mayor's budget document within the beginning?

2:15:55The core services realignment was also in the works and not finalized.

2:15:58So how is this document representative and accurate?

2:16:00Council, workers, and the public deserves the full picture and impartial disclosure after the fact.

2:16:05Another major concern is the absence of impact analysis.

2:16:08Earlier this year, the City Budget Office released of budget scenario documents that included an analysis of how proposed cuts would affect services, communities, and internal operations.

2:16:17That level of transparency was valuable and informative.

2:16:19The mayor's proposed budget does not include this context, which would be very helpful.

2:16:23The city is proposing cuts to impact workers and public service and the public this serves.

2:16:27Thank you.

2:16:27Sorry.

2:16:28Oh, yep, run out of time.

2:16:29It's all good.

2:16:30Thank you.

2:16:34Mayor, City Council, I'm Chris Roller of AFSCME Local 88.

2:16:38I represent over 6 years of homeless services experience in frontline and support roles.

2:16:43I speak on my own behalf.

2:16:45We keep hearing about hard choices.

2:16:47My colleagues facing layoffs and lost capacity put their hearts and often bodies on the line to raise the minimum standard for dignity and well-being for every Portlander, showing up through the heartbreak of mental health crises, overdose, and deaths of people you know and care about.

2:17:02Is a hard choice during an affordability crisis.

2:17:05Compromising on stability for vulnerable and working-class Portlanders with cuts to supportive shelters with accountable cultures while scrambling to fully fund a stadium subsidy that decades of research show are wasteful wealth transfers isn't a hard choice.

2:17:20It's a failure to prioritize everyday Portlanders' needs over special interests' wants.

2:17:26I remind our elected officials That unless they make the hard choice to do it themselves, it's going to be left to my colleagues at closing shelters to try explaining to Portlanders having their worst days why a safe, reliable space for them with safe, reliable advocates wasn't worth the cost, but an oversold stadium was.

2:17:43Thank you.

2:17:45Thank you very much.

Simone Cordery Cotter 2:17:47 - 2:18:56

2:17:47Good morning, members of City Council, Mayor Wilson, Council President Chief— or Jamie Dunphy.

2:17:53My name is Simone Cordery Cotter.

2:17:54I live in Southeast Portland in District 1.

2:17:56I'm not representing any group today.

2:17:59I just live here.

2:18:01In 2021, my family and I witnessed a car crash in South Waterfront.

2:18:05A vehicle left the road and it smashed a sign and nearly hit a pedestrian.

2:18:09We stopped.

2:18:10My mother-in-law, who is a volunteer EMT, stabilized the driver who clearly had a head injury, and my husband called 911, and he was on hold for 11 minutes.

2:18:20It then took another 5 minutes for first responders to arrive, and I was stunned that in a city like Portland, It took that long for people to show up.

2:18:30This is longer than it took me to get help in a small rural community that I grew up in.

2:18:36Cut to this past winter, late 2025, someone broke into my neighbor's garage.

2:18:41His daughter heard a noise and he called 911 and police were there within 5 minutes, which I thought was fantastic.

2:18:48They extracted the burglar and we were all saved from my neighbor needing to go full vigilante in his boxers with his pistol.

2:18:55That I'm willing to pay for.

Alice Christine Walker 2:18:57 - 2:18:59

2:18:57That public safety I would like.

Wynne Furth 2:18:59 - 2:18:59

2:18:59Thank you.

Simone Cordery Cotter 2:19:00 - 2:19:27

2:19:00And I would like everyone who works there to feel safe and supported.

2:19:04People need help when they call 911.

2:19:06I really don't want to backslide.

2:19:08I think that's important.

2:19:10I'm also willing to advocate that PCF dollars be used to upgrade the Moda Center, provided those dollars have a clear public benefit.

2:19:16Those dollars have potential to upgrade one of the oldest arenas in the NBA with climate-smart upgrades that could make the building a heat and smoke refuge, clean air refuge for the community.

Ruth Levine 2:19:27 - 2:19:27

2:19:27Thank you.

Simone Cordery Cotter 2:19:28 - 2:19:35

2:19:28I know you have to make some tough choices.

2:19:29Please do better.

2:19:31Prove that you can manage the dollars that you have before you before asking for more.

2:19:35Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:19:36 - 2:19:39

2:19:36Thank you very much.

2:19:37Kimberly is online.

2:19:39You can go ahead.

Kimberly Ruffew 2:19:45 - 2:21:24

2:19:45Okay.

2:19:45Good morning, councilors.

2:19:47My name is Kimberly Ruffew.

2:19:48I'm a community member and live in the cute little northeast portion of District 3.

2:19:54I serve my colleagues through my work on the CPPW bargaining team, and I'm speaking to you on my own time.

2:20:01Like many others who have already shared with you this morning, I received my formal layoff notice last week.

2:20:06I'm keeping this brief today, so here's my message.

2:20:09The city must invest in its most important asset, the workers who deliver daily essential services and programming to the communities you serve.

2:20:17The budget as proposed does the opposite.

2:20:20Core realignment as proposed slashes positions, capacity, and services under the guise of streamlining and efficiency.

2:20:28In the 3 and a half years I've spent in my position at Portland Parks and Rec as the East Development Parks Coordinator focusing on community partnerships and volunteerism, I've already witnessed the increasing strain on workers and their workloads at our current staffing levels from organizational realignment and budget constraints because the work doesn't stop.

2:20:47It continues to grow.

2:20:49The narrative that the city can do more with less, or even the same with less, isn't true and has already been disproven by cuts to the workforce at a federal level.

2:20:58To protect workers and the services Portlanders care about and deserve, I urge councilors to support the following proposed amendments: Morillo, Green, Novick 1, Morillo 1, Dunphy 3, Avalos 3, Avalos 6, Kanal 6, and Novick 2.

2:21:13These amendments are a starting place to reduce the exacting burden that workers bear again for another year with the budget gap that we didn't create.

2:21:22Thank you for your efforts, consideration, and time.

Unidentified speaker 2:21:25 - 2:21:55

2:21:25Thank you very much.

2:21:27Bats Whitlock, Tavaris Means, Hector Marquez, Rob Wolfson, Micah Meskel, Lorraine Wilson.

2:21:42Welcome, folks.

2:21:43As you're coming on up, feel free to introduce yourself, to share your pronouns if you're so inclined, and you have 90 seconds.

2:21:54You can go ahead if you're ready.

Rob Wolfson 2:21:56 - 2:23:41

2:21:56Okay, uh, good morning, Council.

2:21:57My name is Rob Wolfson.

2:21:59I lived— I have lived and paid taxes in District 2 for over 20 years.

2:22:04I'm also the 3rd most senior Public Safety Support Specialist at Portland Police Bureau, as I joined when the program launched in 2019.

2:22:12I'm not here representing PPA nor PPB.

2:22:15I'm only representing my own views and experience regarding the significant value PS3s have to the community.

2:22:222 Important points I want to make.

2:22:24One, we need the amount of officers proposed in the budget and then some.

2:22:29I feel less safe both as a PS3 and a Portlander When I walk into roll call and most days we're down below minimum.

2:22:36Some days we've been down below 4 or 5 minimum.

2:22:39That's not safe for me or for the community at all, or my family who lives here.

2:22:43Second, PS3s have become a critical element of PPB's mission to deliver public safety.

2:22:49Under the proposed budget, only 8 PS3s would be funded and 30 would be cut.

2:22:54Although I hate seeing any cuts and it hurts us, I urge you to at least increase funding so we have a functional day shift.

2:23:01Thank you.

2:23:01I define functional as having the capability to cover my job duties, which is public engagement as well as handling regular calls.

2:23:11While officers should be the top focus, PS3s in the community, we have some unique things.

2:23:15One, we're unique.

2:23:17Our productivity and quick call response capability and how cheap we are.

2:23:21I know I have limited time, so I want, I want you to ask me questions.

2:23:25Maybe you want to talk about how I'm compared to officers and what we do.

2:23:28Thank you.

2:23:29What would change if we have— with call response times, if you cut us by 80%?

2:23:34How do we increase the range and knowledge of capability at PPB?

2:23:39Please invite— I invite your questions.

Unidentified speaker 2:23:41 - 2:23:42

2:23:41Thank you.

Tavaris Means 2:23:43 - 2:25:18

2:23:43Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, distinguished council members and the mayor.

2:23:50My name is Tavaris Means.

2:23:52I am a case manager, a peer wellness specialist, a navigational specialist, and now soon in This summer will be a, a CRM 2 national dealing with recovery, with mental wellness, and also substance abuse.

2:24:10I was recently employed at Sunstone Way, and thanks to my colleagues from 1790, from my union, I thank them for this opportunity to give me the chance to speak with you guys.

2:24:24Thank you.

2:24:25I want to ask you guys a question, and, and just being just straight up and forward, what is the difference between a mechanic and a technician?

2:24:34I'm gonna tell you the difference.

2:24:38A mechanic, he sees a part, looks at a part, sees it is slightly damaged, replaces that part, and moves the customer along.

2:24:48A technician sees a part, See the part that's damaged, diagnose everything within that part so that way once they put that new part in, it won't be damaged again and have more longevity.

2:25:00Well, that's what we are as peer wellness specialists.

2:25:02That's what we are as navigational specialists.

2:25:05That's what we are as counseling with mental illness and deal with also substance abuse and domestic violence.

2:25:10So I ask you to take that under consideration once you make a decision on that budget and think about the people who really are boots on the ground.

Unidentified speaker 2:25:18 - 2:25:21

2:25:18Thank you.

2:25:21Thank you very much.

Wynne Furth 2:25:26 - 2:27:13

2:25:26Good morning.

2:25:26Lorraine Wilson, co-chair of the Public Utility Board, here to share the perspective of informed community volunteers on the utility budget.

2:25:36Affordability and equity are at the center of our work, and our recommendation reflects that focus.

2:25:42The city should adopt the 7.5% combined rate increase needed to maintain current current service levels.

2:25:49This reflects real cost pressures and legally required work already underway.

2:25:55Protecting affordability means being honest about the cost of essential infrastructure.

2:25:59Delays only increase long-term costs and shift heavier burdens to future ratepayers, an outcome that is neither equitable nor financially responsible.

2:26:09Reducing the increase to the proposed budget level does not offer meaningful Thank you.

2:26:146.3% Fees, nearly the same as 7.5%, with the average household saving less than $2 a month.

2:26:23Those savings are symbolic, while the operational risks from cuts are significant, affecting capacity, increasing deferred maintenance, as mentioned by City Administrator Lee last week, and adding strain during future Bureau restructuring.

2:26:42I have so much more to say, but this is the only opportunity us as volunteers on the Public Utility Board are getting to engage with city.

2:26:52And I want to reiterate last year that we are here, we are engaged with the utility bureaus on a yearly basis, and we can provide you with informed information on why we support that 7.5% combined rate increase.

2:27:13Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:27:14 - 2:27:15

2:27:14Thank you very much.

Hector Marquez 2:27:17 - 2:28:58

2:27:17Good afternoon, Mayor, councilors.

2:27:20My name is Hector Marquez, and I am the executive director of Historic Parkrose in District 1.

2:27:25When I started this job a year and a half ago, Parkrose was in crisis.

2:27:29Businesses were dealing with needles, human waste, unsafe sidewalks, Long police response times, a lot more than 5 minutes, and people in deep distress with nowhere to go.

2:27:41It was not safe, period.

2:27:43Today, because of coordination services, things are improving.

2:27:46PIMO and council members from District 1 have helped clean and stabilize our streets.

2:27:51Police response has improved.

2:27:53Businesses feel more represented.

2:27:54Neighbors feel more included.

2:27:56Historic Parkrose— and Historic Parkrose is working towards an enhanced service district So our community can keep building on this progress.

2:28:04But now, as budgets are being cut across the city, county, and school districts, I am asking you, do not cut the services that are working.

2:28:12If you cut Pima street cleaning and outreach alongside small business support, workforce development, as school districts let go of hundreds of teachers, the conditions we fought so hard to change will return, and East Portland will pay the price first.

2:28:27Thank you.

2:28:27For too long, Portland has focused on saving downtown while communities like Parkrose are asked to survive with less.

2:28:35Historic Parkrose and the Neighborhood Prosperity Network members are doing the work on the ground.

2:28:40We need the city to stand with us, not step back.

2:28:43Please protect the services that protect our communities.

2:28:45Sustaining these vital community efforts hinges upon the critical funding protection outlined in Dunphy's Amendments 1, 3, and 4.

2:28:55Thank you very much.

Unidentified speaker 2:28:58 - 2:29:01

2:28:58Thank you all.

2:29:00Micah, you can go ahead online.

Micah Meskel 2:29:04 - 2:30:39

2:29:04Thank you, councilors.

2:29:05My name is Micah Meskel.

2:29:06I'm with the Bird Alliance of Oregon, a local nonprofit conservation organization.

2:29:10I'm going to highlight our top priority amendments related to our work and follow up with written testimony.

2:29:15We support Avalos 1.

2:29:17The PSF CIP was a collaborative and intentional program crafted between the city and community to help the city's birds.

2:29:22And as Alan Hippolito highlighted earlier, is grounded in Equity Plus Climate Framework.

2:29:27The mayor's proposed budget unilaterally and inappropriately moved PCF-CIP funding from BES and PBOT to a new bureau for activities outside of the Equity Plus Climate Framework.

2:29:38We support Koyama Lane 2.

2:29:40PCF-CIP strategic programs related to trees are popular with the public and were significantly harmed by amendments sponsored by Councilor Zimmerman last year.

2:29:48Councilmember Koyama Lane 2.

2:29:49This amendment helps to ensure the necessary capacity is restored.

2:29:53I think there's also opportunity to be paired— this concept to be paired with Novick 1 and Novick 3 and Zimmerman 4.

2:30:00We support Murillo Green Novick 1.

2:30:03We've observed the core service realignment process having a negative impact on environmental and EJ programs throughout the city due to its blunt application and inability to properly navigate retention of specialized positions.

2:30:15They're essential to meet city and community goals.

2:30:18We support Green 1, we support Green 5, or Novick 5, we support Technical Correction Amendment 3, and we oppose Novick 1.

2:30:27We appreciate the intent, but the swap of, swap of PCF CIP funds across strategic programs could have unintended impacts similar to Zimmerman's amendments transferring tree permitting to PP&D last year.

2:30:39Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:30:40 - 2:33:04

2:30:40Thank you very much.

2:30:42Michelle Tulin, Kyle Chipman, Sabina Erdez, Annette Ramirez, James Donnelly, Kelly Lansbaugh, Dylan Evanston.

2:31:00You can begin at the table.

2:31:04Hi, my name is— excuse me— Michelle Shalene, and I am here to advocate for myself and all the other marginalized people that are outside.

2:31:15I recently completed the WorkSource program with PDX Saints Love, and I have to say that's the only place that I've been since a month before COVID that their word means something and they follow through with what they promise.

2:31:32And I have a couple questions.

2:31:35I have been kind of nosing around websites and I'm trying to understand the accountability factor of a lot of things.

2:31:42How many times, how many years does a person need to be outside when they call 911 because they want to get away from a domestic violence situation?

2:31:50Like, how many years do you think is acceptable for them to be outside and not get any help?

2:31:54Second of all, how many times should they be assaulted while they're outside?

2:32:022, 3?

2:32:04I mean, you guys tell me.

2:32:06I don't understand where the money's going.

2:32:08I know that I've heard about like the $120 million sitting around.

2:32:12I've heard— I've been— watched a housing manager be arrested right in front of me for embezzlement.

2:32:17She'd been arrested for this before.

2:32:18Like, how do we create that accountability where people can't just go change their spelling of their name and go get a job somewhere else and do the same thing?

2:32:25It's affecting people's lives, and you guys and everyone else is getting paid, and we are not getting the help that we need.

2:32:32I still have not got help with the domestic violence situation.

2:32:36I called to— they Send me to 311, Coalition Against Domestic Violence.

2:32:43Like, they don't help.

2:32:44So where— what— what's— where's all this money going?

2:32:48I just don't understand that at all.

2:32:52I want to create the Coalition Against Shelter Abuse and Embezzlement because I— and then you guys, your website, you show like your audits, but you don't show where the accountability comes in.

2:33:01Like, or at least I couldn't find it.

2:33:03Maybe you can help me with that.

Emory Mort 2:33:04 - 2:33:04

2:33:04Sorry.

Unidentified speaker 2:33:05 - 2:33:21

2:33:05Because aren't you here to help the people?

2:33:07And I am a person.

2:33:08I worked my whole life.

2:33:09I paid taxes.

2:33:10Thank you.

2:33:11Sorry, we're out of time.

2:33:12I was clean when I first got homeless.

2:33:15Thank you.

2:33:16I'm sorry, we got to move on.

2:33:19Yeah, sorry, we are over time.

Annette Ramirez 2:33:22 - 2:33:22

2:33:22Sorry.

Unidentified speaker 2:33:22 - 2:33:29

2:33:22Thank you.

2:33:24Yeah, go ahead.

Annette Ramirez 2:33:29 - 2:34:53

2:33:29Oh yes, hello, my name is Annette Ramirez.

2:33:34Should be ready every time.

2:33:36I'm a member of the City of Portland's Professional Workers Union, and I'm also an everyday Portlander of District 1.

2:33:44My work group is payroll and recruitment at the Water Bureau, and my team and I are slated for layoff on June 30th.

2:33:50I'm here to talk about the core services realignment, and the concern is that this will not— this work will not disappear.

2:33:56It will get delayed, reduced, or shifted onto fewer workers, and it will not be Our work is extensive and technical.

2:34:04Come July 1st, who will be doing this work?

2:34:07Is cross-training happening now?

2:34:09Is there a plan in place to prepare staff for changes?

2:34:12Who will ensure that paychecks are getting processed and that employees are being paid correctly in compliance with federal and state laws as well as labor contracts?

2:34:20Who will calculate upgrades, submit actions for employee movement, complete new hire verifications, audit for overpayments and underpayments?

2:34:26Councilor Smith.

2:34:26Maintain employee personnel data, and so much more.

2:34:30Second, what equity lens was used in this process?

2:34:34Aside from me, everyone on my team that is slated for layoff, including my supervisor, is a person of color.

2:34:39The majority of us are women.

2:34:41Please support the Murillo-Green-Novick 1 amendment to allow for a thoughtful and deliberate approach to core services realignment that will not cause issues with the services that we're providing today.

2:34:52Second.

2:34:53Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:34:54 - 2:34:54

2:34:54Thank you very much.

Sabina Ordez 2:34:56 - 2:36:38

2:34:56Good morning, Council President, councilors, and Mayor Wilson.

2:34:59My name is Sabina Ordez.

2:35:00I live in District 1.

2:35:02I'm an immigrant, and I'm speaking on behalf of Thrive East PDX, a coalition of more than 28 East Portland organizations and nonprofits.

2:35:10We ask you to vote no on Avalos 2 because it cuts storefront support funding that East Portland businesses desperately need.

2:35:16East Portland is home to Portland's largest immigrant and refugee population, and many of our small businesses are immigrant-owned.

2:35:23Immigrant support should not come at the expense of vulnerable immigrant businesses.

2:35:27Our businesses have already been disproportionately harmed by past funding cuts.

2:35:31When Prosper Portland cut funding to business associations, we lost nearly all of ours while other parts of the city retained theirs.

2:35:37We need more support to reach equity, not less.

2:35:40Instead, we support Dunphy 1 and Dunphy 3, reserving funds to Neighborhood Prosperity Network and investing in CBOs that support existing immigrant-led organizations already doing this work.

2:35:51Guerreras Latinas, Historic Park Rose, Rosewood Initiative, Division Midway Alliance support our communities without forcing us to compete against our own businesses for resources.

2:36:02We want to be clear that without funding for NPNs, organizations like Historic Park Rose and Division Midway Alliance will cease to exist.

2:36:09However, having Prosper Portland Disperse these funds sounds scary because of our past experiences with their unsuccessful attempt to deliver measurable community impact and funds absorbed into administrative overhead.

2:36:21What will you do to ensure these funds actually reach our community?

2:36:25Finally, we must protect BICEP, but not by defunding PIMO.

2:36:28Vote no on Avalos 1 and 4 because it would put Cultivate Initiatives' contract with PIMO at risk.

2:36:34We need Cultivate Initiatives in Parkrose, and we need PIMO in East Portland.

2:36:38Thank you.

2:36:38Councilmember Herbold.

Unidentified speaker 2:36:39 - 2:36:40

2:36:39Thank you very much.

Kyle Chipman 2:36:42 - 2:38:19

2:36:42Good morning.

2:36:42My name is Kyle Chipman.

2:36:43I serve as co-chair of the Portland Utility Board.

2:36:46I live in District 3.

2:36:47I want to show briefly appreciation for my other co-chair, Lorraine Wilson, and all of our community volunteers who serve as board members.

2:36:53I want to begin by stating that I am also in support of the 7.5% combined rate for both utilities, as well as the $525 million bond for the Bull Run facility.

2:37:03Um, 2 major points I want to hit in this testimony.

2:37:05First, just an offer of active collaboration to council members, staff, and the entire community of Portland.

2:37:10PUB was founded for community oversight in 2015 to provide budget transparency and rate setting across the Water Bureau and the Bureau of Environmental Services.

2:37:20We meet the first Tuesday of every month, the third Thursday of every month.

2:37:23We're here to work together to deliver this transparency, and it's just an open invitation.

2:37:27In addition to all the folks that testified last Wednesday evening to council, I also want to give special appreciation to DCA Donapal, Director Liu, Cecilia Hune, Joanne Johnson, Amy Archer Masters, and Johnalynn Bransford.

2:37:38Thank you.

2:37:39Additionally, this is personally and through the board.

2:37:42I'm really excited to provide real-time transparency around a lot of these upcoming efforts and this major investment.

2:37:49I have really been through 2 budget seasons now in the prism of the board, and I felt the way that halt— the halting flow of information creates constrained timeframes and reactive and fraught decision-making.

2:37:59And I'm actually pursuing how to deliver real-time portals and transparent information around ongoing maintenance, deferred maintenance, Capital improvement projects, including Bull Run, as well as long-term initiatives, including the smart metering program.

2:38:11And that's in service of more effectively communicating the value we receive through collective investment as opposed to the headline of cost.

2:38:19Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:38:20 - 2:38:22

2:38:20Thank you very much.

2:38:21Me?

James Donnelly 2:38:22 - 2:38:51

2:38:22I'm up.

2:38:24Good morning— good afternoon, councilors.

2:38:27My name is James Donnelly.

2:38:28I guess you saw me last week.

2:38:29I live in East Portland District 1.

2:38:31I understand the budget cuts are due primarily to a drop in business tax revenue.

2:38:36It seems to me that the sensible action then is to ask local businesses what help they need to reverse this drop and then make corrections over things for which the city has control.

2:38:46That being said, it should be clear that insulating police, fire, and PMO from these cuts should be a step in the right direction.

Haig Brown 2:38:51 - 2:38:52

2:38:51Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 2:38:53 - 2:38:58

2:38:53Thank you very much.

2:38:56Dylan, you can go ahead online.

Dylan Evanston 2:38:59 - 2:40:28

2:38:59Thank you.

2:39:00My name is Dylan Evanston and I'm on the board of the Sumner Neighborhood Association as well as Historic Parkrose NPN, and I work full-time as an IT manager for an architect.

2:39:08I'm here to speak to you on my own behalf as a resident of District 1.

2:39:12Please support Dunphy 1 and reallocate a couple hundred thousand dollars current from a currently vacant position in the Office of Civic Life to help fund NPNs.

2:39:18While I participate on my NA and value the work of our District 1 East Coalition, it makes sense to target neighborhoods identified by council as needing additional support through the NPN program for direct support.

2:39:29Please also support Dunphy 4.

2:39:31The amendment freezes COLA and merit raises for city management staff.

2:39:34Working in the private sector, when the market is very rough, I have been asked to accept pay freezes, and I've seen pay cuts for senior staff to avoid layoffs and fill budget gaps.

2:39:42These measures make sense, demonstrate shared responsibility and accountability for turning the tide of budget shortfalls and keeping operations running.

2:39:48Perhaps this money could be used to back Second.

2:39:50Second.

2:39:50Motion passes.

2:39:52In future sessions, I also ask the council to go further in consolidating and broadly examining the entirety of city spending.

2:39:59Specifically, I would ask council to consider reconsidering the East Portland Plan, as EPAP no longer maps directly to District 1 East Portland, uh, while it seems also to be out of date and sees hundreds of thousands in spending annually.

2:40:13Beyond that, please select a new process for water filtration.

2:40:15The prior And take a hard look at additional projects of this nature that ask Portlanders to spend significant amounts of money above and beyond the national average on new fees and taxes, especially as services are cut.

2:40:27Also, please say no to Waymo.

Unidentified speaker 2:40:28 - 2:40:29

2:40:28Thank you.

2:40:29Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:40:30 - 2:40:31

2:40:30Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 2:40:33 - 2:41:22

2:40:33Anna Kemper, Jenny O'Connor, Ryan Sotomayor, Molly Romey, Reuven Sussman, Corinne Frechette, Charlie Wesley.

2:40:50Anna's online, you can go ahead.

2:41:05Anna, can you hear us?

2:41:07Yes, hello.

2:41:08Oh, you can go ahead, we hear you.

2:41:20We can circle back if you're ready at the table.

Anna Kemper 2:41:23 - 2:41:26

2:41:23Hi, sorry about that.

2:41:25Oh, can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 2:41:26 - 2:41:29

2:41:26Apologies, sorry.

2:41:27Yes, go ahead, Anna.

2:41:28Thanks.

Anna Kemper 2:41:30 - 2:42:39

2:41:30Okay, good afternoon, councilors and mayor.

2:41:32Thank you so much for your important work today in balancing the city's budget.

2:41:34My name is Anna Kemper and I'm the Great Communities Program Director at 1000 Friends of Oregon.

2:41:401000 Friends believes that everyone who calls Oregon home deserves an I first gave testimony in front of Portland City Council back in 2019 when I was 23 years old.

2:41:51When I gave testimony then regarding the upzoning to allow for more dense transit-oriented housing, I spoke about how I was worried about my future due to the catastrophic threat of climate change.

2:42:01Now, 7 years later, the threat is even more serious.

2:42:04I'm here today on behalf of 1000 Friends of Oregon, as well as future generations of Portlanders, to urge you to protect the voter-approved PSF funds and use PSF dollars the way they were intended on climate Related issues that have a disproportionate impact on BIPOC and marginalized communities in our city.

2:42:20I ask you to approve amendments to preserve PSF funding for what the voters approved them for, as well as Commissioner Koyama Lane's Amendment 2 to maintain tree canopy funding and protect critical positions that preserve our critical tree canopy, which is vital for community health and climate resilience for all communities, but especially in East Portland.

2:42:39Thank you so much.

Jamie Dunphy 2:42:40 - 2:42:41

2:42:40Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 2:42:45 - 2:42:49

2:42:45You can go ahead at the testimony table, whoever's ready.

Corinne Frechette 2:42:50 - 2:42:51

2:42:50Either—.

Jenny O'Connor 2:42:51 - 2:44:20

2:42:51Yeah, you want to go first?

2:42:53Oh, go ahead.

2:42:54Okay.

2:42:54Hi, my name is Jenny O'Connor.

2:42:57I am a citizen of Portland.

2:42:59I live in District 4, and, um, I wanted to thank all of you, all you councilors, um, And the mayor, but particularly the council people.

2:43:12I'm here to support the amendments.

2:43:13I counted at least 7 as I went through the list brought forward by you to find alternative funding to restore the fire station and the firefighters, the safety personnel, and the community health access— assess and treatment program.

2:43:36You know, I appreciate the fact that you all, all of you, when I watched the work session, I think it was on May 5th, you all supported this.

2:43:47You know, you have our backs, you have the community backs, and I know you do too.

2:43:57I just wanted to make sure that, Mayor Wilson, you review all those amendments and review the, the different choices that you have and adhere to what you said, that your budget priorities will continue to focus on community health and safety.

2:44:19Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:44:21 - 2:44:23

2:44:21Thank you very much.

Charlie Wesley 2:44:26 - 2:46:07

2:44:26I'm Charlie Michelle Wesley, Indigenous matriarch of this, our land now called Oregon.

2:44:31Clark's budget amendment undermines the Community Board for Police Accountability.

2:44:35The city values of fiscal responsibility, resiliency, and the needs of our most vulnerable populations will be the focus of every budget decision.

2:44:45This amendment does not do that.

2:44:47The CBPA is mandated to address PPB's lack of real accountability for police violence against our most marginalized.

2:44:55The lack of police trauma healing, recognizing police are unsuitable for a myriad of calls, and unaddressed stereotyping equates to more death.

2:45:05Throwing more money at a systemically Aye.

2:45:07The result of this deeply flawed system is extreme misappropriation.

2:45:10CBPA needs the funding they are allotted towards full functionality, and in collaboration with unarmed public safety support by PSR and CHAT leads to a safer Portland.

2:45:22Per the city charter, funding for the board shall be proportional to no— to be no less than 5% of PPB's annual operation budget, and the board shall have independent judgment in performing all legally assigned powers and duties that the city shall not interfere with.

2:45:38Discussing a multitude of budgetary priorities Wednesday night at CBPA meeting, we found out that Clark's plan was to abscond with $10 million from their budget.

2:45:47Where's the transparency?

2:45:49Public safety for all needs real accountability to save lives, those that are typically overlooked in so many of your decisions— Black lives, brown lives, indigenous lives, and those with mental illness.

2:46:03Reject Clark 1 because it does not Take that into account.

Molly Romaine 2:46:07 - 2:46:08

2:46:07Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:46:08 - 2:46:08

2:46:08Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 2:46:10 - 2:46:15

2:46:10Molly's online.

2:46:11You can go ahead.

2:46:14Can you hear me?

Corinne Frechette 2:46:15 - 2:47:55

2:46:15We can.

2:46:17Great.

2:46:17My name is Corinne Frichette, and I'm testifying today as a longtime community member in District 4, particularly Old Town, as a volunteer serving the unhoused community for over 30 years, as an immigrant to this country, and as a mother of young adults who live in D4.

2:46:31I also serve on the CBPA board, but I'm speaking solely in my personal capacity.

2:46:36Portlanders are tired of stagnant, hidden public money sitting unused while essential services are being cut.

2:46:42The Police Accountability Office is an important part of our municipal system, and it's still in its infancy.

2:46:48For the past 2 years, it has carried a potential allocation of roughly $16 million annually, while historically using only about $1 to $2 million per year.

2:46:58Even for fiscal year 26-27, the requested budget is approximately $5 million.

2:47:03Thank you.

2:47:03Supporting an office that currently has 1 employee and may grow up to 7 employees by the end of the fiscal year.

2:47:09The board members are volunteers, and investigations are funded separately.

2:47:14That leaves at least $10 million effectively sitting idle.

2:47:18Meanwhile, the community is loudly opposing cuts to public safety, all public safety.

2:47:24Other amendments attempt to soften the damage, but none fully restore 911 dispatch services.

2:47:30Victim services, or the proposed cuts to PPB operations.

2:47:34This amendment restores the funds for training at PPB, which is a critical part of fostering transparency and accountability.

2:47:40It also restores accessibility to precincts affecting our most marginalized community members and helps prevent response time from increasing.

2:47:49I urge you to support reallocating these unused funds to restore essential public safety.

2:47:54Support Clark 1.

Jamie Dunphy 2:47:57 - 2:47:58

2:47:57Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 2:47:58 - 2:47:59

2:47:58Molly Romaine, you can go ahead.

Molly Romaine 2:48:05 - 2:49:56

2:48:05Good afternoon, councilors.

2:48:06My name is Molly Romaine.

2:48:07I use she/her pronouns, and I serve as a senior director of security and emergency management for Portland Public Schools.

2:48:14My responsibility each day is to help ensure the safety and security of more than 40,000 students and thousands of staff members across our district.

2:48:23I also understand the difficult financial realities you are facing.

2:48:27PPS itself is experiencing significant budget shortfalls, so I know firsthand how hard these decisions are.

2:48:34I am deeply concerned about the proposed reductions to the Portland Police Bureau and the Impact Reduction Program, and I urge you not to deepen those cuts.

2:48:43In 2020, the elimination of the Police Bureau's Youth Services Division fundamentally changed the relationship between schools and law enforcement.

2:48:51Since then, we have worked very hard to rebuild trust, communication, and coordination between schools and the Bureau.

2:48:57Today, we have 3 outstanding school liaison officers who have helped reestablish that connection, but I want to be very clear: that system is still fragile.

2:49:07At the same time, our schools are already experiencing long response times for law enforcement, EMS, and other first responders.

2:49:14I am highly concerned that the additional reductions of PPB resources will further extend those response times and leave school staff to manage increasingly complex.

2:49:22Complex and dangerous situations on their own.

2:49:25Reductions to the impact reduction program also has consequences for school safety.

2:49:30When campsite removals decrease, the effects are felt directly around our campuses and along routes students travel to and from school every day.

2:49:39I recognize that none of these decisions are easy, but I respectfully urge you not to make additional reductions that will further strain already, already limited public safety systems that schools rely on every day.

2:49:51Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 2:49:56 - 2:49:58

2:49:56Reuven Sussman, you can go ahead.

Reuven Sussman 2:50:00 - 2:51:38

2:50:00Thank you.

2:50:01Thank you, councilors.

2:50:02My name is Dr. Reuven Sussman.

2:50:03I direct the Behavior and Health Program at the American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy, which is a national energy efficiency research organization.

2:50:11I'm testifying in opposition to the proposed budget cuts to the Home Energy Score Program, a small but impactful budget item.

2:50:18At a moment when energy affordability concerns are high among homeowners and climate change is a growing problem, the Home Energy Score program is even more valuable.

2:50:26The Home Energy Score encourages home sellers to invest in energy efficiency upgrades.

2:50:31This matters because the transfer of ownership is a key— an important moment to invest in upgrades.

2:50:37Research from Portland shows that homes with a Home Energy Score are 10 times more likely to apply for an energy efficiency rebate.

2:50:44Than those without.

2:50:45The Home Energy Score program supports Portland's impactful requirement that home sellers share the home's energy efficiency score when they're listing their home for sale.

2:50:53The requirement is an example for the nation, and my research shows that this type of disclosure has the power to shift buyer decisions.

2:51:01They buy more efficient homes.

2:51:02Without a funded Home Energy Score program, disclosure and compliances will fall.

2:51:07The program's notices— without the program's notices, the compliance rate is just 52%, but with them, 92% of sellers come into compliance.

2:51:16Energy efficiency reduces people's energy use, it cuts pollution, it makes homes more comfortable for future owners.

2:51:22The Home Energy Score program gives sellers information to make common-sense upgrades and homebuyers the information they need to assess the potential energy bills of their future homes.

2:51:31Please do not cut the budget for this program.

2:51:34It is small but has large impacts.

2:51:36Thank you very much for the opportunity to testify today.

2:51:38Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:51:39 - 2:51:39

2:51:39Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:51:40 - 2:51:42

2:51:40Ryan Sotomayor, you can go ahead.

Ryan Sotomayor 2:51:46 - 2:53:31

2:51:46Hello, Council President Dunphy and other councilors, Mayor Wilson, and members of the public.

2:51:55Um, appreciate the time and the opportunity to speak to the work that folks are doing around amendments for the budget.

2:52:03And We really need everything right now.

2:52:08You know, we need all the safety, we need all the parks programming, we need, we need a little bit of everything.

2:52:15So we do not envy any of you of your positions.

2:52:20That being said, I'd like to encourage you all to support Muriel 1, the health and safety package that would restore free lunch and play, chat, PSR, and other programs.

2:52:31The Muriel Green Novick 1 that will pause the elimination of 46 city frontline positions for a year.

2:52:39Uh, Koyama Lane 2 that would restore, uh, levels of urban forestry and tree permitting, particularly around the canopy.

2:52:49Um, along those lines, we also like Novick 3 and Zimmerman 4, and we really appreciate that there's a lot of people trying to solve a lot of problems.

2:53:01Thank you.

2:53:02Um, like Pirtle-Guiney 2, particularly around community center closures days.

2:53:07We think that there's more work that could be done there.

2:53:10Uh, Koyama Lane 1, 4, 6, and 7 around age-friendly parks and recreation, the Montavilla Park picnic shelter and other programming.

2:53:19Uh, we like Dunphy 4 pausing COLA, but particularly the merit increases for management, and Pirtle-Guiney 4 that restores free lunch and play.

2:53:29Thank you for your time and all the work that all of you are doing.

2:53:31Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:53:34 - 2:53:35

2:53:34Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 2:53:36 - 2:53:50

2:53:36Sharice Bach, Noel Studer-Spievak, Jackie Wurz, Loretta Guzman, Connor Lennon, Allison Paley, Tyler Fellini, Emily Barrett.

Jamie Dunphy 2:53:50 - 2:53:58

2:53:50And just for my colleagues and for the public, it is my intention after this panel to take a lunch break where we'll be gone for 30 minutes and get back into more public testimony.

Keelan McClymont 2:53:59 - 2:54:03

2:53:59Charisse is online.

2:54:02You can go ahead, Charisse.

Charisse Bach 2:54:04 - 2:55:47

2:54:04Good afternoon, councilors.

2:54:08Thank you for this opportunity to testify and for your hard work in this budget season.

2:54:13I'm Charisse Bach, she/her, climate policy director at 350 PDX, a Portland nonprofit with thousands of members.

2:54:19With the low snowpack and strong El Niño developing, this summer will likely break more climate records.

2:54:26We need to make sure our PCF dollars are going toward climate impacts with an equity focus.

2:54:31Our main concerns relate to PCF.

2:54:33Substantive changes to the PCF Climate Investment Plan, which has already allocated all PCF dollars through 2029 with extensive community engagement, should be first routed through the PCF Committee for an update to the CIP before being proposed in a budget.

2:54:47Therefore, we strongly support Avalos 1, return PCF funds to BES and PBOT, If the mayor wishes to try to make the care— the case for using PSF for PIMO and IRP, or the Moda Center for that matter, he should send a proposal through a CIP update for public deliberation.

2:55:02We support Koyama Lane 2 and Novick 3 to retain staffing, uh, staffing for Portland's tree canopy, which my colleague Noel will discuss shortly.

2:55:11We support Murillo Green Novick 1, PAWS core services realignment.

2:55:16We need to carefully analyze impacts on PSF program deliverables.

2:55:20We appreciate Pirtle-Guiney 5 about the Portland Harbor Superfund set-aside.

2:55:24Please confirm these funds are not coming from the Superfund surcharge.

2:55:27The city will need those funds to pay for the $5 billion Superfund site remediation soon.

2:55:33And finally, we support Green 1.

2:55:35The St. Johns Fire Station and Engine 22 serves the CEI hub and Linnton neighborhood.

2:55:40We need to build in better safety measures for this part of the city, but retaining the station and engine is the bare minimum.

2:55:46Thank you.

2:55:46Thank you very much.

Jamie Dunphy 2:55:47 - 2:55:48

2:55:47Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:55:48 - 2:55:49

2:55:48You can go ahead at the table.

Noel Studer-Spievak 2:55:50 - 2:57:38

2:55:50Hello, my name is Noelle Studer-Spievak.

2:55:53I work for— I live in District 2, work for 350 PDX, and I staff the Shade Equity Coalition created by 12 membership organizations after the deadly 2021 heat dome.

2:56:05We helped create PSEF Strategic Programs 8 and 34 to ensure that Portland invests in street tree retrofits for long-term cooling.

2:56:13Over half of Portland's neighborhoods do not meet the basic 25% shade tree canopy cover goal.

2:56:20We ask you to support Koyama Lane 2 to halt further damage to the team that protects existing tree infrastructure.

2:56:26Service levels have yet to stabilize after last year's budget cut and unplanned staff transfer proposed by Zimmerman and adopted by council.

2:56:35This team can't take any more cuts.

2:56:38We also need Murillo Green Novick 1 to protect PSIP Strategic Programs 8 and 34.

2:56:432 Core members of the Equitable Tree Canopy team have received notice that their positions will be terminated.

2:56:49Novick No one can explain why this makes sense or where the money's going.

2:56:54I'm also very concerned about this year's budget process.

2:56:57We're exhausted.

2:56:59Mayor— Mr. Mayor, when councilors propose amendments that you disagree with, it's not harm and disruption, it's democracy.

2:57:06And, and also wearing t-shirts, it's okay to, to organize and wear the same t-shirts.

2:57:13If you really want to make this process accessible to more Portlanders, release the proposed budget more than 17 hours before the first public hearing.

2:57:20Release a spreadsheet showing exactly where the savings are going.

2:57:24Bureau staff are under a cone of silence and no one has the information they need.

2:57:28I encourage councilors to add budget notes for next week with your best thinking on how we can have a better, more transparent process in 2027.

2:57:37Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 2:57:38 - 2:57:39

2:57:38Thank you very much.

Tyler Fellini 2:57:41 - 2:59:03

2:57:41Good afternoon, councilors.

2:57:42Uh, my name is Tyler Fellini.

2:57:43I'm a registered lobbyist and executive director of Portland Jobs with Justice.

2:57:47I'm here today because working-class Portlanders are exhausted from constantly having to fight you just to protect the things we already democratically voted for.

2:57:54We got independent police accountability passed with over 80% of the vote, yet today we have to fight Amendment Clark 1 just to stop you from robbing that board of $10 million before it even gets started.

2:58:05We rallied 65% of Portland voters to pass the Portland Clean Energy Fund for climate justice, yet today we are here Joining Councilor Avalos in defending the fund from the mayor who wants to raid PCF to pay for non-voter-aligned pet projects.

2:58:19The city has a pathological pattern of dismissing real Portlanders in favor of high-priced consultants and a 36% explosion in upper management.

2:58:27While the mayor sends citywide emails patronizing community members for showing up in t-shirts— I made sure to wear mine today— he is simultaneously trying to lay off 177 union workers, reclassify their jobs, and protect out-of-state contractors.

2:58:40Only a few years ago, social workers and working-class Portlanders stood right here and warned the previous council that outsourcing our neighbors to Urban Alchemy would end in abuse and disaster.

2:58:49They dismissed us, and now the arrests and the systemic failures are playing out on the nightly news.

2:58:54Pass the Green, Novick, and Avalos amendments.

2:58:57Chop from the top.

2:58:58We did everything right at the ballot box, and we demand that you hear us today.

2:59:02Do not expect us to be patient anymore.

Jamie Dunphy 2:59:04 - 2:59:06

2:59:04Thank you very much.

Allison Paley 2:59:11 - 3:00:39

2:59:11Hello, is, is this audible?

2:59:13Okay.

2:59:15Hello, City Council.

2:59:16My name is Allison Paley.

2:59:17I'm a resident of District 3, and I work front desk at Matt Dishman Community Center.

2:59:21Today I'm just here on behalf of myself.

2:59:24I'm here today to support budget amendments put forward by Councilors Novick and Green, which would make significant cuts to management, administration, and the City Council's own budgets.

2:59:34The City of Portland, as it stands, has a serious problem with administrative bloat.

2:59:39Since 2019, Portland's frontline staff, the people directly serving the public, has increased by 7%.

2:59:45In that same time, Portland's administrative staff has grown by 16%, and its management has grown by a whopping 63%.

2:59:53The current budget proposes reductions to free lunch programs that could be entirely prevented by cutting one of these highly paid management jobs.

3:00:00One.

3:00:01Thank you.

3:00:02I want facilities that aren't falling apart.

3:00:05I don't want to cut services so popular that there is always a waitlist for them.

3:00:09I want someone I can call when patrons are harassing or threatening staff or other patrons, because despite what we keep being told, we cannot just leave.

3:00:17I want fast medical services so that when someone's heart stops and our aquatics lead has to perform CPR, EMTs can be there quickly with the equipment and training to save that person's life.

3:00:28I want my work to be safe and the kids to be fed and my community to have the resources it needs.

3:00:34The people making that happen are the workers on the ground, not the expensive suits.

3:00:39Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 3:00:40 - 3:00:40

3:00:40Thank you very much.

Loretta Guzman 3:00:44 - 3:02:33

3:00:44Hi, my name is Loretta Guzman.

3:00:46I was born and raised here in the city of Portland.

3:00:48I own Bison Coffee House.

3:00:49I live in District 2 and my business is in District 2.

3:00:53I have been here before you all many a times, and it seems my testimony falls on deaf ears.

3:00:59I don't know how much worse it has to get.

3:01:01I am here once again to address our public safety.

3:01:04I have personally suffered from the failure of our system.

3:01:07I have been watching it erode, all while testifying and pleading for our public safety.

3:01:12During a life-and-death situation, I couldn't even get a real person when I called 911.

3:01:17All I could do was pray upon my favorite nephew as he turned cold and died.

3:01:21It's a different kind of cold when the spirit leaves the body.

3:01:24Councilwoman, something that I will never forget.

3:01:27I feel it to this day in my hands, or when I hear gunshots.

3:01:31I have since been immediately paralyzed to the point I couldn't move.

3:01:36This new form of government imposed on us is not working.

3:01:39The old system gave us accountability for bad behavior and crime, a real person when calling 911, fast immediate response if you needed an ambulance or a fire truck, and we had public safety.

3:01:51People are being shot as they go out to meet up with friends for no, no reason at all.

3:01:56Young men are being gunned down in our streets as if their lives have no value, and this is putting everyone in grave danger.

3:02:03People are being traumatized.

3:02:05I am here asking that our public safety, PS3, firefighters, BOEC, and more be fully, all fully funded.

3:02:13The city needs all these to operate in caring for people and saving lives.

3:02:17It's not to pretend it's okay here in Portland, because it's not.

3:02:21And this is the failure of our leaders.

3:02:23The little kids and the youth and the young are our future, and we need to give them a chance to grow up in a city that gives life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, as public safety is a fundamental right.

Keelan McClymont 3:02:37 - 3:02:40

3:02:37Jackie, Jackie's online.

3:02:39You can go ahead.

Jackie Wurz 3:02:41 - 3:04:09

3:02:41Good afternoon.

3:02:42My name is Jackie Wurz, and I'm here today as the executive director of Link Oregon in support of maintaining the community technology program in the upcoming budget.

3:02:51Link Oregon works to ensure that students, educators, researchers, nonprofits, and government entities have access to affordable, reliable broadband, and Portland's Community Technology Program is a critical partner in that mission.

3:03:03Digital equity is not a luxury.

3:03:06It is core infrastructure.

3:03:08Portland's Community Technology Program, including its Digital Equity Program and Small Business Digital Navigator services, ensure that the benefits of technology reach everyone, especially historically underserved communities.

3:03:19Thank you.

3:03:20Portlanders, from our youngest learners to small businesses to healthcare facilities to countless nonprofits and other entities, depend on digital tools to operate, grow, and access resources.

3:03:31When we lack connectivity, training, or technical support, we fall behind.

3:03:36And when those barriers are concentrated in communities already facing the greatest obstacles, the whole city pays the price.

3:03:43The closest vehicle maintaining digital equity is the Morillo-Green-Novick one, the core services realignment pause.

3:03:49Councilmember which includes potential funding restoration of these programs.

3:03:52We urge the committee to pass that amendment.

3:03:55Community technology is a small investment with outsized lasting impact for small businesses, workforce development, and for communities that cannot afford to be left behind in a rapidly changing technology landscape.

3:04:07Please protect this program today.

3:04:09Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 3:04:10 - 3:04:10

3:04:10Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 3:04:12 - 3:04:14

3:04:12Connor, you can go ahead online.

Connor Lennon 3:04:15 - 3:05:10

3:04:15Thanks.

3:04:16For the record, my name is Connor Lennon.

3:04:17I'm a resident in District 4.

3:04:20Um, not a lot of time today, so I'm just gonna kind of go through it real quick.

3:04:23Big fat yes to Avalos 1, Murillo 1, uh, Green, Novick, Murillo 1, Green 1, Green 2, Green 3, Green 4.

3:04:30Big fat no to Clark 1, Clark, Pirtle-Guiney, Novick, Ryan-Smith 1.

3:04:35We need to be chopping from the top.

3:04:37We need to be taking Portlanders straight from the streets, keep them right here, right at the top of your head every single second for every decision that you make in these coming days, in these coming weeks.

3:04:46Councilmember Green.

3:04:46We cannot be putting businesses first.

3:04:48We need to be putting the people on our streets first.

3:04:51Our current shelter system is not working.

3:04:52Homelessness has doubled in the past year.

3:04:55We are leaving people behind every day.

3:04:57They are dying on the streets, and it is completely unacceptable.

3:05:00And while I have the floor, we need to not get rid of that bike lane on Southeast Alder Street.

3:05:05That is absolutely unacceptable.

3:05:07Do not forget your commitment to Vision Zero.

3:05:09Thank you for your time today.

Jamie Dunphy 3:05:11 - 3:05:26

3:05:11Thank you very much.

3:05:16Okay, it is 12:31.

3:05:19Colleagues, I'm going to ask everybody back here at please at 1 o'clock, and we will get started with more testimony.

3:05:23Thank you for your patience, members of the public.

3:05:25We'll see you in 30 minutes.

Allison Paley 3:05:26 - 3:05:26

3:05:26Thank you.

Keith Wilson 3:44:06 - 3:44:11

3:44:06And we are back, calling back to order the meeting of the Portland City Council.

3:44:09Rebecca, can we please call up the next panel of testimony?

Rebecca Dobert 3:44:16 - 3:44:54

3:44:16Corey McCall, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Lisha Shretha, Aaron Glenn, Andy Olson, Alex Wick.

3:44:31We have some folks online.

3:44:42Aaron, you can go ahead online.

3:44:49Aaron Glenn, you can unmute and testify.

3:44:53Hi, can you hear me?

Aaron Glenn 3:44:54 - 3:46:33

3:44:54We can.

3:44:56Hi, thank you for, uh, allowing me the opportunity to speak here.

3:45:00I primarily want to address, uh, the council on the subject of the Columbia Pool.

3:45:06Um, I'm a North Portland resident.

3:45:08I live right next to Columbia Pool.

3:45:10It was a phenomenal asset to have in this neighborhood, and, um, Unfortunately, it had to shut down due to the need for some maintenance.

3:45:20That was my understanding.

3:45:23The pool shut down, and all I've heard since then is this talk of a new aquatic center being built to replace it rather than fix this asset that we already had.

3:45:33I know the new aquatic center is going to be expensive.

3:45:36It's like $50 million.

3:45:38And I know that, you know, repairing the pool that we have Today is going to be a lot less than that.

3:45:45So my only message to the council today is please consider the amendment to earmark funds to repair the Columbia Pool.

3:45:54It seems like a no-brainer here to spend less money and fix this asset that we have rather than trying to find a way to get you know all of this additional money for another pool.

3:46:09We we have one.

3:46:10It, it just feels like the physically responsible thing to do.

3:46:14Um, I would love the ability to swim in my neighborhood again.

3:46:18It's been 5 years.

3:46:19Um, so please consider this.

3:46:21Uh, you know, I would, I would really appreciate, um, seeing that smart move being made here and allowing us to swim in this neighborhood again.

3:46:31Thank you very much.

Keith Wilson 3:46:33 - 3:46:34

3:46:33Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 3:46:35 - 3:46:37

3:46:35Alicia's online.

3:46:36You can unmute and go ahead.

Leisha Shrestha 3:46:41 - 3:48:12

3:46:41Good afternoon, councilors.

3:46:42My name is Leisha Shrestha.

3:46:43I'm the executive director of Division Midway Alliance.

3:46:47At DMA, we have consistently demonstrated our ability to engage and support East Portland's most underserved communities and small businesses.

3:46:56As a place-based organization, we provide critical on-the-ground support with very limited resources.

3:47:03In the past, I often shared data and success stories to demonstrate our impact.

3:47:07Thank you.

3:47:08But today I want to take a different approach and let the council know that despite putting our hearts into this work and making real differences in people's lives, year after year we continue coming before council to advocate for modest levels of funding to sustain programs that are already creating meaningful impact.

3:47:27Our entire team are first-generation immigrants and refugees, and for many of us and communities we serve, this is our first time participating in the democratic process.

3:47:38I respectfully ask you to continue listening fairly and help our communities continue believing that our voices matter.

3:47:46Programs like Community Workforce Navigator are a critical bridge connecting residents to jobs, training, and essential services.

3:47:54I also urge council to fund the Neighborhood Prosperity Network, which invests in relationship-based, community-led strategies that create lasting opportunities for Therefore, I request council to vote yes on Dunphy 1 and Pirtle-Guiney 1.

3:48:12Thank you so much.

Keith Wilson 3:48:13 - 3:48:14

3:48:13Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 3:48:17 - 3:48:18

3:48:17Andy, you can go ahead online.

Andy Olsen 3:48:23 - 3:50:14

3:48:23Hi, um, behind you is a project we're working on, on 129th and Stark.

3:48:30My name is Andy Olsen, and I am the executive director of Cascadia Clusters.

3:48:36I am a former, uh, covering lawyer, former San Francisco Deputy City Attorney, and homeless coordinator for former Mayor Willie Brown.

3:48:44I've been a citizen of Portland since '97.

3:48:46I've been mostly quiet politically, but right after Trump was elected the first time, I founded cascadiacusters.org.

3:48:53We've helped build Hazelnut Grove, Agape Village, Beacon Village, the This past year, we've hired more than 20 individuals referred by Urban Alchemy.

3:49:04This was part of a project set up by the mayor and has been really successful.

3:49:10The job works.

3:49:11Half the individuals we hired have had a positive life outcome 6 months into their time with us.

3:49:17What about the rest?

3:49:18Here's the kind of big idea that Willie Brown used to love: jails, institutions, This is what happens to all, or many, all too many of my fellow addicts and alcoholics.

3:49:30Please reach out to all privately faith-based and nonprofit owners, shelters, sober housing, and alternative shelters.

3:49:37Bring us all together and ask us what we should do.

3:49:43Step up, ask the folks doing the work.

3:50:00Invite all relevant foundations and individual authorities.

3:50:04Ask the Meyer Memorial Trust to facilitate.

3:50:07Think about— think big and step up.

3:50:10Thank you.

3:50:11We know you can do it.

3:50:12And thank you, Mr. Mayor, for your time.

Keith Wilson 3:50:15 - 3:50:23

3:50:15Thank you, Andy.

3:50:16And a large amount of your testimony got a little bit garbled with our connection.

3:50:20If you would be interested in sending in your written testimony so you can read it as well, that'd be, that'd be great.

Rebecca Dobert 3:50:27 - 3:50:48

3:50:27Corey McCall, Ryan Fitzpatrick, or Alex Wick.

3:50:35Sean Hutchinson, Michelle Watkins, Aaron Schmouts, Caitlin Geary, Darlene Sherman, excuse me, Sherman, Caitlin M., Karen T. Ray.

Keith Wilson 3:50:50 - 3:51:04

3:50:50Welcome folks.

3:50:51As you're coming up, please feel free to introduce yourselves.

3:50:53You're welcome to share your pronouns and, uh, Folks have 90 minutes.

3:50:57Whoever's seated is welcome to jump in.

3:50:5990 Seconds.

3:51:00Yeah, 90 minutes.

3:51:01Everybody get comfy.

3:51:02We're all going to just—.

Aaron Schmautz 3:51:04 - 3:51:07

3:51:04Yeah, 90 seconds.

Keith Wilson 3:51:07 - 3:51:08

3:51:07Thank you.

Rebecca Dobert 3:51:08 - 3:51:10

3:51:08You can go ahead at the testimony table, whoever's ready.

Aaron Schmautz 3:51:11 - 3:51:12

3:51:11You want me to go first?

Mike Roach 3:51:13 - 3:51:13

3:51:13Go ahead.

Lori Wimmer 3:51:13 - 3:51:13

3:51:13Go ahead.

Aaron Schmautz 3:51:14 - 3:51:15

3:51:14Go ahead.

3:51:14I was not called first.

Jordan Lewis 3:51:15 - 3:51:15

3:51:15Oh, whatever.

Caitlin Geary 3:51:16 - 3:51:16

3:51:16Okay.

Aaron Schmautz 3:51:16 - 3:52:47

3:51:16Sorry, I was just still recovering from the 90 minutes.

3:51:19My notes aren't long enough.

3:51:21My name is Aaron Schmalz.

3:51:22I'm the president of the Portland Police Association.

3:51:24The cuts to public safety proposed in this budget will negatively impact Portlanders access to service on their darkest of days.

3:51:30The proposed cuts would decrease 911 call takers and dispatchers' hours, impact patrol response through overtime cuts and the decimation of the PS3 program, decrease victims' services and connection with city resources through cuts of civilian personnel, and impact accountability by cutting critical training.

3:51:47We appreciate the common-sense efforts at proposed amendments restoring funding to core services, including several by Councilor Novick, including Novick 2 regarding the funding for PS3 and non-sworn employees, several by Councilor Zimmerman, including 1 and 2 regarding training and staffing.

3:52:03Smith 1, which provides summer jobs for youth in underserved communities.

3:52:07And Clark, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, Novick, and Smith 1, which uses unallocated funds in the form of a loan readdressed in the fall TAO from the CBPA, which retains all needed funds for this year and restores dozens of jobs for our friends in AFSCME, keeping open police precincts to community members in North and East Portland as opposed to having them have to find a way downtown.

3:52:30PFFA, Restoring personnel and equipment, victim services, as well as critical training dollars for police officers, an essential accountability tool, and jobs for our public safety support specialists.

3:52:41This amendment is a pro-labor, pro-community, pro-public safety, and common sense move with no impact on other services.

Keith Wilson 3:52:49 - 3:52:49

3:52:49Thank you very much.

Michelle Watkins 3:52:51 - 3:54:26

3:52:51Good afternoon, Mayor, Council.

3:52:53My name is Michelle Watkins, and I am a care coordinator at Urban Alchemy Oasis site 2 and a half years ago, I was living in my car under the Hawthorne Bridge.

3:53:02I'd been on the streets for 3 years and in active addiction for 6.

3:53:06Everything changed in October 2023 when I arrived at Urban Alchemy at the Clinton Triangle SRV as a guest.

3:53:13From day one, the staff did something simple but profound.

3:53:17They looked me in the eyes and they called me by my name.

3:53:20They saw my humanity when I no longer felt human myself.

3:53:24While living at Urban Alchemy, I felt safe, a feeling I hadn't known in years.

3:53:30My path wasn't a straight line.

3:53:32I faced setbacks, but with Urban Alchemy support, I moved into my own apartment.

3:53:37I got clean May 28th, 2024, and was eventually hired to do the very work that saved me September 30th, 2024.

3:53:46Today, I have helped house over 25 people and sent I'm fostering a 17-month-old, my Urban Alchemy baby, whose parents also went through our doors.

3:53:58I am here to tell you that Urban Alchemy Safe Rest Villages are more than just shelter beds.

3:54:03They are places where people are truly seen and protected.

3:54:07My story is not an exception.

3:54:10I am one of many.

3:54:11I respectfully ask that the council to, to continue funding Urban Alchemy.

3:54:15Your investment is the difference between someone sleeping under a bridge tonight and someone like me 2 years from now raising a child, holding a job, and helping the next person find their way home.

Keith Wilson 3:54:28 - 3:54:29

3:54:28Thank you.

Sean Hutchinson 3:54:34 - 3:56:08

3:54:34Um, my name is Hutch.

3:54:35I'm from District 3, Kerns neighborhood.

3:54:38I voted for all 3 of my councilors, and I'm legit 1 out of 4 people that approves of the job that the council is doing.

3:54:4624%.

3:54:48So some would say that makes me a Pollyanna.

3:54:50To that I say, go Fire all the way to the finals.

3:54:54We have a challenge in front of us, $160 million shortfall.

3:54:58Why?

3:54:58Because tax revenue is down.

3:55:00People and businesses have already left.

3:55:02Now there's another poll that says 41% are considering leaving.

3:55:0662% Cite taxes, not crime.

3:55:10What is the solution to this?

3:55:11We need to retain these tax dollars.

3:55:13We need to draw more people.

3:55:15We need to lean into what makes Portland great.

3:55:17We have smart voters Voters here who passed the PCEF, which was supposed to make $30 million a year, is making $200 million a year on the back of billion-dollar retailers.

3:55:28So $50 million to the police?

3:55:30Uh, I'm no fan of billionaires, but it pains me to, you know, it pains me to buy my half-and-half at Whole Foods, but I, you know, I'm trying to save money on driving, so I have to walk to Whole Foods.

3:55:42So We own the Moda Center.

3:55:46We paid $1 for it.

3:55:49Hold Dundon's feet to the fire.

3:55:50Yes, get the, get the deal for naming rights and rent, but do not let the tragic Cold War brinksmanship lead to the loss of our only major sports franchise and more affluence drain that foots the bill for this city largely.

3:56:06Rip City runs deep.

3:56:07Go Blazers!

Leisha Shrestha 3:56:08 - 3:56:08

3:56:08Thank you.

Lori Wimmer 3:56:12 - 3:56:15

3:56:12All right.

Caitlin Geary 3:56:16 - 3:58:09

3:56:16Hello, um, my name is Caitlin.

3:56:21Are we ready?

3:56:23Sweet.

3:56:24Um, hi, so my name is Caitlin.

3:56:26Um, I'm here basically testifying in support of Mitch Green's amendment, the Sanitation Hygiene Workforce Development Amendment.

3:56:34Um, I also, I also just want to say that I've heard this earlier But I do have a frustration with how this budget process is going, where these amendments we got only a few days ago, and it's not a lot of time for the public to review this all.

3:56:47But that's why I'm going to focus on one amendment, and specifically because it's going to redirect $1 million away from the sweeps program.

3:56:53And I'm really glad that you very much emphasized that sweeps program and not just IRP in general, as we know that the budget is way bigger than just the sweeps.

3:57:03But I want to Talk about why that's so significant.

3:57:05So I work at a day center, and I'm looking at you, Mayor Wilson, because you talk so much about day centers and how great they are.

3:57:11So I work at Clackamas Service Center, which, although we are in Clackamas technically, we are 2 blocks away from Portland.

3:57:17Most of the people who come to our center are in Portland and are getting swept by rapid response in Portland.

3:57:23And that has huge impacts for our day-to-day operations because we're giving out free clothing, we're giving out food boxes, and We give people stuff one day and then the very next day I have people coming to me in tears about how Rapid took all of the stuff we gave them the previous day.

3:57:39And that's a huge strain on our resources as a day center.

3:57:42And it's extremely frustrating and horrible to see this happen over and over again.

3:57:46And it's been intensifying, especially in recent years.

3:57:50And I feel like that Rapid's contract since I've been in Portland, like, started out at like $4 million.

3:57:56And I know our IRP's budget is like $14 million.

3:57:59It just keeps— Councilmember Loretta Smith.

3:58:00Expanding and expanding, and all it's doing is traumatizing people.

3:58:04It's putting strain on our day centers, and I think this is a step in the right direction, but it could go further.

Keith Wilson 3:58:10 - 3:58:11

3:58:10Thank you so much.

Rebecca Dobert 3:58:13 - 3:58:27

3:58:13Darlene Sherman's online.

3:58:14You can go ahead.

3:58:22Darlene, you can unmute and testify.

3:58:26Sorry.

3:58:27You're good.

Darlene Sherman 3:58:29 - 4:00:04

3:58:29All right.

3:58:31I'm Darlene Sherman.

3:58:32I'm a resident of District 3.

3:58:34I've had 2 careers, one as a nurse, the second as an ecologist, and from both these perspectives, human health and ecological health and climate mitigation, we must continue, not postpone, tree planting, tree care, and tree preservation in Portland.

3:58:54The—.

3:58:55I understand the need to address this budget deficit, in which case I do support the transfer of PSEF interest to the general fund.

3:59:05This year that is $26.9 million.

3:59:10It does need the approval of the PSEF committee.

3:59:13That is our process.

3:59:16I support Avalos 1.

3:59:18Which would restore $5.9 million to PCF-funded projects and staff that the mayor is proposing moving to impact reduction programs, Portland Solution.

3:59:31These may have really valuable components, but they do not fit with the PCF goals and would violate the voter intent.

3:59:42I also support Koyama Lane 2. to restore funding to the 12 PCF-funded positions in the tree permitting that, uh, really protect and support the planting program.

3:59:54Also support the Sustainability Office for, um, 2 positions for creating the new climate action plan.

4:00:03Thank you very much.

Keith Wilson 4:00:05 - 4:00:05

4:00:05Thank you.

Rebecca Dobert 4:00:08 - 4:00:24

4:00:08Karen Chire, Jordan Lewis, Eugene Jackson, Benjamin Gilbert, Jim Rice, Deborah Field, Audrey DeCourcy, and Vicki Payne.

4:00:23Karen is online.

4:00:23You can go ahead, Karen.

Karen T. Ray 4:00:26 - 4:02:01

4:00:26Good afternoon.

4:00:27My name is Karen T. Ray.

4:00:28I'm a business owner in District 4 and a resident in District 3, and you all know me by now.

4:00:35I've testified at the very first City Council sitting in front of you waiting for 6 hours to testify.

4:00:41And what I testified then, and as I've been testifying throughout this whole 16 months, is about public safety and the need for more police officers on our street.

4:00:54And I'm going to continue to say that.

4:00:56Having a business in downtown Portland off of West Burnside, you can only imagine the amount of crime that I deal with on a weekly basis.

4:01:05And just recently have a shoplifter that continually comes in to shoplift.

4:01:12Councilwoman, I'm sorry.

4:01:133 Times.

4:01:14Uh, the 3rd time he didn't get away with it, but I did follow him waiting for police to catch up to us so that they can arrest him, but there was no officers available.

4:01:25Um, I then found him, uh, through a co-worker the next morning and followed him through town.

4:01:32I called police again to potentially have him apprehended, where he then stole from other places during our, our walk around downtown.

4:01:43So I urge you, please do not cut any funding, and if not, give more funding to the police bureau so that we can protect the citizens of our, our city and also the businesses that continually close around my business.

Leisha Shrestha 4:02:01 - 4:02:02

4:02:01Thank you.

Keith Wilson 4:02:02 - 4:02:03

4:02:02Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:02:03 - 4:02:05

4:02:03You can go ahead at the testimony table.

Benjamin Gilbert 4:02:07 - 4:04:03

4:02:07Hello, Mayor, Councilors, members of the council.

4:02:08My name is Benjamin Gilbert, and I'm a volunteer lobbyist for the Portland chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America, a mass democratic organization of over 3,000 volunteers in the Portland metro area.

4:02:19I want to preface my testimony by acknowledging a specter looming over this budget conversation.

4:02:23Many of you on council know I'm all in on red, but when our mayor is proposing spending hundreds of millions on a handout to a Texas billionaire Moda Center deal while cutting fire engines, Something is wrong.

4:02:38I want to show strong support for the Morillo-Green-Novick 1 core services realignment pause, and I want to strongly oppose Clark 1 and Clark-Pirtle-Guiney-Novick-Ryan-Smith 1.

4:02:48Um, the Office of Community-Based, uh, Police Accountability was passed by an 82% vote of Portland voters in 2020 and took 6— and has taken 6 years to finally begin operation.

4:03:00Defunding this body is an attack on the very concept of police accountability.

4:03:05Police oversight and democracy.

4:03:08What else has 82% of the vote?

4:03:13I strongly support Green 1.

4:03:14We need to chop from the top, and firefighting capacity in St. Johns will be especially important with the CEI hub.

4:03:20I support Green 2 and 3.

4:03:22The mayor's paternalistic night shelter vision has not delivered on its promises.

4:03:27And to Mayor Wilson, sticking your head in the sand when the numbers don't go your way doesn't change the reality we all see.

4:03:33Canal 3 protects democracy.

4:03:35Canal 4 and 5 are crucial for our city.

4:03:37We need to fund CHAT and PSR.

4:03:39Koyama Lane 4 is also great and we're supportive.

4:03:43And the tribal summit must be adequately funded.

4:03:46It's not a lot of money.

4:03:47Rio 1 for community health and safety are also great.

4:03:51Avalos 1 and 4 are awesome.

4:03:52And finally, I want to call on the city to build municipal capacity by stopping regressive practices like contracting out and public-private partnerships.

4:04:00Enough of bloated golden parachutes for upper management.

Darlene Sherman 4:04:03 - 4:04:03

4:04:03Thank you.

Keith Wilson 4:04:06 - 4:04:07

4:04:06Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:04:08 - 4:04:09

4:04:08Jim Rice is online.

4:04:09You can go ahead.

Jim Rice 4:04:14 - 4:05:56

4:04:14Good afternoon, uh, council members.

4:04:16Thank you so much for giving me the opportunity to be able to speak today.

4:04:20Uh, Portland has entered the doom loop.

4:04:22Uh, your decisions, uh, through this budgetary process will determine if our decline will continue.

4:04:28Our suburbs believe that Portland is not safe, significantly impacting small businesses and the revitalization of downtown.

4:04:372025 Had the highest number of small business bankruptcies in over 12 years, more than during the pandemic itself.

4:04:45Currently, there's over 10,900 small businesses that are losing money across our area, possibly impacting over 70,000 jobs.

4:04:55We are the second highest tax burden place in the country, and what do we get for it?

4:04:59We have the smallest police force of any city our size.

4:05:03In fact, we'd have to double our police force just to be average.

4:05:08Government has shown that crime has been dropping, yet a poll recently out shows that 67% of small businesses were either burglarized or vandalized in the past year.

4:05:19Crime isn't dropping.

4:05:21Our communities have stopped calling the police for help.

4:05:24For many, the businesses and jobs they support, crime is the nail in their coffins.

4:05:29It's critical now more than ever to prioritize where not to cut.

4:05:35You have to ensure that the citizens are safe.

4:05:38A K2 poll recently showed 79% of the populace want to see the budget, the police budget, be increased, not reduced.

4:05:46Citizens want to know when they call for help, help will actually arrive.

4:05:51Thank you.

4:05:52Please support Olivia Clark and her proposals.

4:05:55Thank you so much.

Keith Wilson 4:05:57 - 4:05:58

4:05:57Thank you very much for being here.

Rebecca Dobert 4:05:58 - 4:06:01

4:05:58Jordan Lewis is online.

4:06:00You can go ahead, Jordan.

Jordan Lewis 4:06:02 - 4:07:41

4:06:02Hello, councilors.

4:06:03My name is Jordan Lewis.

4:06:04I'm a volunteer lobbyist with the Portland Democratic Socialists of America.

4:06:08My t-shirt is dirty after a very long and very busy weekend, but I hope you can recognize the humanity within me even as I tell you things that you don't want to hear.

4:06:17I need to express my disappointment at a budget amendment process that seemed designed to depress outreach and public comment.

4:06:23The amendments were released Friday night and testimony was 9 AM Monday morning.

4:06:28That's preposterous.

4:06:30People can't make that.

4:06:31I'm gonna need you to do just a little bit better going forward.

4:06:36Anyways, I'm gonna be a no on Clark 1 and the similar joint amendment.

4:06:4082% Of Portland voters didn't approve the OCPA with the expectation it would take 6 years to have its first meeting and get defunded before it could even hear its first case.

4:06:50Thank you.

4:06:51This is a dereliction of your responsibility to voters.

4:06:53Not a single one of you earned 82% of votes in your district.

4:06:57Hands off OCPA.

4:06:59Filing a budget amendment that violated the city charter and then following up with a duplicative amendment to resolve the violation is really sloppy work.

4:07:06And if I did that at my day job, I'd get a really unpleasant Microsoft Teams call afterwards, and I'd actually have to attend that meeting.

4:07:13My boss also might ask why anyone is demanding increases to the PPV budget when we've seen PPV hiring levels decrease as funding increased.

4:07:20Thank you.

4:07:22The correlation between police funding and hiring is literally negative.

4:07:26I get that as politicians your job is not to make evidence-based policy or to better evidential outcomes, but to virtue signal to your base.

4:07:33And I think we can do a little bit better.

4:07:36To quote the city's public hearings office in 2025, it really is about facts, not feelings.

4:07:41Thank you.

Keith Wilson 4:07:42 - 4:07:43

4:07:42Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:07:44 - 4:07:46

4:07:44Audrey DiCorsi's online.

4:07:45You can go ahead, Audrey.

Audrey DeCourcy 4:07:47 - 4:09:18

4:07:47Hello, I hope you can hear me.

4:07:50Esteemed councilors, you are working hard.

4:07:54Thanks for listening.

4:07:55My name is Audrey DiCorci.

4:07:56I'm a voter in District 3.

4:07:58I am not a paid lobbyist.

4:08:00I am not even wearing a t-shirt today.

4:08:03I will note that I am here because of the mayor's email asking me to testify.

4:08:08Um, there have been some interesting emails from the mayor during this budget season, but I urge you to follow 2 principles in your deliberations over this budget.

4:08:17Number one, preserve frontline city jobs.

4:08:20Don't lose the deep knowledge that these workers bring.

4:08:22Please take a hard look at management consultants contracts before cutting union jobs with the city.

4:08:29And 2, listen to voters.

4:08:31Please preserve PCF's intent and impact.

4:08:34Voters asked for real climate justice solutions.

4:08:37Spending on city services that help climate justice does make sense, but not diverting it to unrelated issues.

4:08:45Same goes for OCPA funds.

4:08:47Please use them as voters intended.

4:08:49You cannot have true public safety without accountability.

4:08:53We're seeing that on a national scale, and that's scary.

4:08:57Um, since I'm just getting to the yellow portion of my time, I'll add a third.

4:09:01Please preserve jobs supporting our digital accessibility transition for city websites.

4:09:07Digital accessibility is key, and it's hard work, but please continue to fund this.

4:09:14You have a really tough job ahead of you.

4:09:16I just want to thank you for your service.

4:09:18Have a good afternoon.

Keith Wilson 4:09:19 - 4:09:20

4:09:19Thank you so much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:09:27 - 4:09:29

4:09:27Sorry, Vicki Payne is online.

4:09:28Vicki, you can go ahead.

Vicki Payne 4:09:32 - 4:11:12

4:09:32Hi, my name is Vicki Payne.

4:09:34I'm echoing the sentiments of many who've already spoken today.

4:09:37I support the Clark et al.

4:09:38Amendment to use OCPA funds to backfill cut public safety positions.

4:09:43I'm guessing most Portlanders like myself voted on this ballot measure because of course we always wanted police accountability, but didn't read the fine print or attempt to understand it.

4:09:525% Sounds like a very small number, and if you told me we'd be putting $16 million towards that every year or more, I probably would have had a bit more pause, especially now knowing that's more than the Auditor's Office budget.

4:10:03We're not going to need that much money even after we hire a director and staff in next year's budget, so I'm not sure what the issue is.

4:10:09Ditto for PSF.

4:10:11We were told it would only bring in $30 to $50 million a year.

4:10:13It's bringing in up to $200 million a year.

4:10:15This absolutely does need to go back to the voters, as recent polling about the police staffing ballot measure shows folks are very much in support of using these unanticipated funds To support safety and livability, which does uplift the concept of meeting climate goals.

4:10:28Handing out air conditioners and e-bikes are not moving the needle on climate emissions, and folks like myself still, still don't feel safe riding public transit or commuting regularly by bike because the bike lanes are filthy and we're nervous about locking up our e-bikes in public for more than 10 minutes.

4:10:42I also echo earlier sentiments about not cutting Urban Alchemy.

4:10:47They've been— they have the best proven track record of moving folks through quickly to supportive housing.

4:10:52And we have a city and county have chosen to support the model of low-barrier shelters and peers in recovery handling them.

4:10:58So we can't be hypocritical when folks relapse as we put them in tempting situations full of available open drug use in an increasingly expensive city to live in with their low wages.

4:11:08We need to— we need to respect the ugly, inevitable dark side of doing behavioral health work.

4:11:12Thank you.

Keith Wilson 4:11:14 - 4:11:14

4:11:14Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:11:15 - 4:11:42

4:11:15LeJune Thorson.

4:11:17Lori Wimmer, Michaela McCormick, Mike Roach, Diana Stewart, Devin Ruiz, David Dixon.

4:11:31Mike's online.

4:11:32You can go ahead.

4:11:40Mike Roach, you can unmute and testify.

Andy Olsen 4:11:42 - 4:11:42

4:11:42Thank you.

Mike Roach 4:11:49 - 4:13:07

4:11:49Good afternoon.

4:11:50My name is Mike Roach.

4:11:51I have co-owned Paloma Clothing in the Hillsdale business district in Southwest Portland for the last 51 years.

4:11:595-1.

4:12:00My purpose in speaking today is to ask all of you to unify yourselves into a single caucus called the Hope for Small Business Owners Caucus as you consider the proposed budget.

4:12:14Thousands of Portland small business owners are hanging on by a thread and are just one more burglary or vandal attack from closing their doors, giving up, and walking away.

4:12:26Small business owners will not understand why presently idle funds are not being used to pay for police and fire protection for their businesses and customers, and the critical business district crime prevention program called PMO, that we all count on.

4:12:45The proposed amendment by Councilor Clark to use the $10 million— to use $10 million from the Police Oversight Board to avoid police, fire, and PMO cuts is a common sense way to give small business owners the hope we need to hang on.

4:13:04Please support the Clark amendment.

4:13:06Thank you very much for your time.

Keith Wilson 4:13:08 - 4:13:09

4:13:08Thank you.

Rebecca Dobert 4:13:10 - 4:13:11

4:13:10Go ahead at the testimony table.

LaJune Thorson 4:13:12 - 4:14:44

4:13:12Hi, my name is La June Thorson, the president of the Downtown Neighborhood Association, and I'm on the board of the Frog Ferry, but my remarks today are my own, and I'm going to share some priorities.

4:13:26Um, my priorities are very pragmatic.

4:13:29We must make— we must make it more affordable for residents to stay in Portland.

4:13:34And we must support businesses, both large and small, to stay here and encourage new businesses and residents to come to Portland.

4:13:42Broadly, my long-term concern is about restoring our economy for its long-term sustainability.

4:13:50I believe we must restore public safety, including fire and rescue, CHAT, and police.

4:13:57These are what people expect from their government and our city moving forward.

4:14:00Thank you.

4:14:01Into economic recovery.

4:14:04Continue the programs that are helping our homeless neighbors move forward into housing and stability, like our very successful Southwest NADO Village.

4:14:14Thank you, Mayor.

4:14:18And manage our public assets, and this includes the Moda Center.

4:14:22I wish I were as funny as the guy who was here a little while ago.

4:14:27We must not lose the income it generates by bringing people into Portland from throughout the region, and we can't afford to lose the job it provides.

4:14:35Let's continue to do what we can to restore our livability and economy while exercising good fiscal stewardship.

Andy Olsen 4:14:46 - 4:14:46

4:14:46Thank you.

Aaron Glenn 4:14:46 - 4:14:48

4:14:46Thank you.

Lori Wimmer 4:14:48 - 4:16:37

4:14:48Good afternoon.

4:14:50Uh, Lori Wimmer representing Northwest Oregon Labor Council and also convener of the City of Portland Labor leaders ad hoc budget coalition for the second year in a row.

4:15:00First of all, I just want to say thank you to all of you.

4:15:03I know the job you have is super tough and you have to sit through a lot of very difficult testimony, and I apologize for all of those who can't be kind.

4:15:13I'm going to be very quick because I have given you my written testimony.

4:15:18It's in your record, and if you have the time to read it, it'll give you a lot more detail.

4:15:22We like a lot of what you have all offered, but chiefly a few.

4:15:27And before I start, I wanted to say that it would be really great if this body would resist the inclination to expand programs, add new programs, or add new staffing in a time of crisis with some 150-plus employees being targeted for cuts.

4:15:44As worthy as any of these ideas might be, now is not the We support that.

4:15:54I would like to also say that Clark-Pirtle-Guiney-Novick-Ryan is alone.

4:15:59There's been some misunderstanding.

4:16:01We support that because we believe that things like victim services and union jobs are worth saving.

4:16:06So thank you all for that.

4:16:08We love Murillo-Green-Novick 1, Novick 3, and Novick 5, Green 4, And Maria 1, because these all restore frontline workers, and we really do think that that, rather than administrative bloat, ought to be a concern.

4:16:23And once again, I'm just going to put in a pitch for taking out those contracts to private vendors when you could have a city employee do the same job for less.

4:16:33I haven't seen that in anything you've offered, but I'm hopeful, and hope springs eternal.

Vicki Payne 4:16:38 - 4:16:38

4:16:38Thank you.

David Dixon 4:16:38 - 4:18:18

4:16:38Councilor My name is David Dixon, and I have been actively engaged in addressing the issue of unsheltered homelessness for the last 7 years.

4:16:473 Years delivering survival items and friendship to my unsheltered downtown neighbors, and the last 2 years as convener of the Homeless Solutions Coalition.

4:16:56Today I offer 3 recommendations.

4:16:59They do not address specific budget line items or amendment proposals, but focus on the big picture and how we address homelessness.

4:17:06A crisis that Portlanders consistently rank as our city's greatest problem.

4:17:11First, please do not cut funding to address unsheltered homelessness, especially cuts which will accelerate death on our streets and worsen the quality of life for all Portlanders.

4:17:23Second, the city and the county must work together and design a system of outreach, intake, shelter, treatment, housing, and workforce training that is integrated and accountable to the taxpayer.

4:17:35Thank you.

4:17:35Third, we are losing the race to produce housing faster than people are becoming homeless in Portland.

4:17:42Our low-barrier housing-first approach is placing people in housing without adequate behavioral health treatment and little to no preparation to live independent of government support.

4:17:54A roof overhead is essential, but we must shift our end goal to societal reentry.

4:18:00It will not happen overnight.

4:18:02But if every paid worker and volunteer who serves our unsheltered neighbors would become laser-focused on giving people the treatment and support to discover their sense of purpose and gain the skills needed to successfully reenter society, we could turn unsheltered homelessness around.

Keith Wilson 4:18:19 - 4:18:20

4:18:19Thank you very much.

Diana Stewart 4:18:21 - 4:19:57

4:18:21Good afternoon.

4:18:22My name is Diana Stewart.

4:18:23I'm a resident of the downtown.

4:18:25I'm on the board of the DNA and the District I'm also a concerned citizen participant.

4:18:31I'm speaking for myself today.

4:18:33I add my voice to today's excellent testimony and urge passage of Clark Amendment 1.

4:18:39I'm not going to give you all the reasons, they've been given to you, but just to say, look at today's Business Journal, which recites that statistic that Portland is 47th out of 50 cities in the police officers per 1,000, which significantly impacts our communities of color and our economically struggling residents when response time is so low.

4:19:01On a different matter, I draw your attention to the written testimony of the concerned citizens, which is in detail, but in sum, it requests that you avoid any amendments today and tomorrow and the day after that will threaten long-term viability of parks.

4:19:16We urge that you create a budget note directing parks to provide you in the next year with a fiscal Sustainability plan, which includes capital asset maintenance and tells you how we can get there rather than relying on uncertain voter passage in the future.

4:19:33I also want to just— and this is just from today's testimony— join the passionate and persuasive testimony asking you to shift money from the top administrative budgets down to the street-level city workers providing those core services to us.

4:19:50It makes sense that we have to all struggle and all take a hit in today's budget circumstances.

4:19:56Thank you.

Keith Wilson 4:19:57 - 4:19:58

4:19:57Thank you so much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:19:59 - 4:20:01

4:19:59Devin Ruiz is online.

4:20:01You can go ahead.

Devin Ruiz 4:20:03 - 4:21:37

4:20:03Good afternoon, Council.

4:20:04My name is Devin Ruiz.

4:20:05I live in D2, and I'm a registered lobbyist for Next Step.

4:20:08We're a nonprofit organization that works to amplify the voice and leadership of diverse young people to achieve a more just and equitable Oregon.

4:20:15Like so many residents, young people across Portland are facing financial hardship.

4:20:19Our budget cannot be balanced against their future.

4:20:21We cannot go against the will of the voters, making our own interpretations and stretching the definition of what qualifies for use of PSF funds.

4:20:29We sure— we strongly urge you to return money to PSF through Avalos 1.

4:20:35It feels like there is a new raid on PSF funds every month.

4:20:38This tells me that our city government sees the value in corporate or large business taxes and potential for similar tax Mayor Wilson needs to be working with our governor and our state legislature to find new streams of revenue and wealth taxes while not wasting money on solutions that don't work.

4:20:55Funding for sweeps, Urban Alchemy, and temporary overnight shelter beds should not be considered in this budget.

4:21:00These are not solutions and instead actively harm the communities they are working to protect.

4:21:04Balancing this budget requires taking a hard look at what actually works, not complacently funding Failing programs that result in more harm and more people on the streets.

4:21:13Balancing our budget should mean— not mean slashing funds that were intended to be investments for our future, for climate infrastructure and resiliency.

4:21:20In addition to supporting Avalos 1, we ask you to oppose Clark 1 because we need to respect the intent of the voters.

4:21:26We also support Avalos 1, 4, 5, 6, Green 1, 2, 3, Murillo Green Novick 1, Novick Murillo 1, Canal 1 and 3, Dunphy 3, Koyama Lane 2, and Smith 1.

Keith Wilson 4:21:37 - 4:21:39

4:21:37Thank you.

4:21:37Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:21:40 - 4:21:56

4:21:40Kip Silverman, Rowan Harvey, Azalea Renfield, Tanisha Renee, Alan Combs, Dr. J.W.

4:21:50Matt Hennessey, Jeff Love.

4:21:55Kip, you can go ahead online.

Kip Silverman 4:21:57 - 4:23:41

4:21:57Thank you.

4:21:57Uh, my name is Kip Silverman.

4:21:59I use he/him pronouns, and I am co-chair of the Portland Community Committee on Community Engaged Policing, but I'm representing myself as a resident of St. Johns District 2 and of Portland for nearly 30 years now.

4:22:13As someone who's worked, uh, been deeply involved and committed many volunteer hours on public safety, hunger, and homeless issues over the years, it's incomprehensible to me that having a full year with intentions that were campaigned on and several months since fully understanding that the accounting Of the various bureaus is likely deeply flawed.

4:22:36That we've been presented to us another austerity budget, with the biggest cuts coming to public safety, and the people can least afford the inevitable outcome of this.

4:22:47I can't tell if it's incompetence or intentional malfeasance that year after year we keep having the same discussions while the ability for people to live day to day, whether housed or unhoused.

4:23:00Becomes increasingly difficult.

4:23:02D2 and D1 are continually designated sacrifice zones, and these cuts will affect us most.

4:23:09The city's administration needs to get its crap together.

4:23:12Making any cuts to public safety, letting go working-class city staff, or raising rates yet again on people who can't afford it is reprehensible when it's clear that the city does not have a good understanding of the money it has.

4:23:26Thank you.

4:23:27I support Canal 1 through 6 and honestly didn't have time to read everything else because that's totally undemocratic the way that this has been presented to us.

4:23:37Please do better.

4:23:39Please.

Keith Wilson 4:23:41 - 4:23:42

4:23:41Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:23:42 - 4:23:44

4:23:42Rowan, you can go ahead online.

Rowan Harvey 4:23:46 - 4:25:09

4:23:46Thank you so much.

4:23:47Um, thank you, councilors.

4:23:48My name is Rowan Harvey and I'm a District 3 resident, parent, and organizer with Next Up, a civic home for young people to build their political power and take the lead on shaping their communities.

4:23:58In their future.

4:23:59I'm urging you to support the Avalos 1, Morillo 1, Morillo-Green-Novick 1, Green 1, 2, and 3, Smith 1, and Kanal 3 amendments.

4:24:08Um, these amendments are examples of meeting community needs without impacting our most vulnerable.

4:24:14When we're cutting funding— when we cut funding to community safety, to our mental health support, to climate resilience, to programs like CHAT, Portland Street Response, and Lunch and play, it is at the expense of our future.

4:24:26And when we put forth disingenuous solutions that give the appearance of meeting community needs while gutting community-led projects like the Board for Accountability, or misappropriating funds voted on for specific purposes like the continued attempts to use PISA for the Moda Center, it destabilizes community trust.

4:24:45Our community deserves solutions that don't further erode the We're taking toward a more equitable, accountable, affordable future for all, including our most disenfranchised.

4:24:56So on behalf of the future our communities deserve, I urge you to support Avalos 1, Morillo 1, Morillo-Green-Novick 1, Green 1, 2, 3, Knoll 3, and to oppose Clark 1.

Keith Wilson 4:25:11 - 4:25:12

4:25:11Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:25:13 - 4:25:14

4:25:13Azalea, you can go ahead online.

Azalea Renfield 4:25:16 - 4:25:17

4:25:16Hi, can everybody hear me?

Benjamin Gilbert 4:25:19 - 4:25:19

4:25:19Yep.

Rebecca Dobert 4:25:19 - 4:25:19

4:25:19We can.

Azalea Renfield 4:25:19 - 4:26:36

4:25:19Okay, great.

4:25:20Sorry, I'm like in transit picking up my kids from school.

4:25:23I apologize.

4:25:23Good afternoon, Mayor and Commissioners.

4:25:26My name is Osceola Winfield.

4:25:27I'm the CEO of Wombs and Russell.

4:25:29It's an honor to be here before you all.

4:25:31Thank you for getting this budget before everybody.

4:25:33I think it's super important to examine.

4:25:35It shows our priorities for the city.

4:25:38I want to recognize the broad support across Council that reflects the areas of housing, economic development, and community health and safety.

4:25:46It matters because our communities need more than just promises.

4:25:49We need investment.

4:25:50With that being said, um, Williams and Russell, we're building homes for ownership right now, not just housing units, but pathways for working families and first-time homebuyers.

4:26:00Um, I want to be sure to let you all know that we support, um, Avalos on, um, Amendment 4 and 5.

4:26:06Second.

4:26:07Kanal on 1 and 3, Murillo on 1, Novick on 1, Ryan on 1, Smith on 1 and 2, Pirtle-Guiney on 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5, Green on 2, Zimmerman on 3, Koyama Lane on 7, Dunphy on 1, and Clark on 1.

4:26:24We support these efforts because it's housing, economic development, community safety, and all the things that relate to our, our build.

4:26:31Thank you so, so much.

4:26:33We appreciate your effort.

4:26:34And we look forward to seeing you on the 27th.

4:26:36Thanks.

Keith Wilson 4:26:37 - 4:26:38

4:26:37Thank you very much.

Rebecca Dobert 4:26:40 - 4:26:42

4:26:40Tanisha Renee, you can go ahead.

Tanisha Renee 4:26:42 - 4:27:57

4:26:42Yes, thank you.

4:26:43Good afternoon.

4:26:44My name is Tanisha Renee.

4:26:46I am the Deputy Executive Director at Williams and Russell, and just as my colleague Azalea said, I'm here today in support of the budget amendments that advance housing, economic development, community health and safety.

4:26:59So I urge the council to support the amendments from Avalos, 4 and 5, Kanal 1 and 3, Morillo 1, Novak 1, Ryan 1, Dunphy 1, Clark 1, Smith 1 and 2, um, EPG 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5, Green 2, Zimmerman 3, and Camoya Lane at 7.

4:27:20These amendments matter because Portland cannot separate housing from public safety, economic opportunity, and community stability.

4:27:28Families need homes they can afford.

4:27:32Neighborhoods need emergency services that respond when people are in crisis.

4:27:37Communities have carried that burden of displacement, disinvestment, and instability, need the city to make real investment and not just symbolic commitments.

4:27:46This is about whether Portland is willing to fund the basic conditions that allow people and neighborhoods to be safe, stable, and thrive.

4:27:53So again, I urge council to support these amendments and move forward with a budget that invests in housing, economic development, and community safety.

Joe Squires 4:27:57 - 4:27:58

4:27:57Thank you, Councilor Tiffany Koyama Lane.

Tanisha Renee 4:28:00 - 4:28:08

4:28:00Health and Safety, and I look forward to speaking more specifically about Williams and Russell and SEI on May 27th.

4:28:07Thank you so much for your time.

Jamie Dunphy 4:28:09 - 4:28:10

4:28:09Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 4:28:12 - 4:28:38

4:28:12Next we have Simone Crowe, Erin Meehan, Elle McFarland, Brooke Buranew, Anais Tupker, Rachel Miles Davis and Joe Squires.

4:28:37Simone, you can go ahead online.

Simone Crowe 4:28:40 - 4:28:46

4:28:40Hi, I'm 5 minutes away from City Hall.

4:28:42I was hoping to join in person, but I can testify online if, if that is the preference.

Keelan McClymont 4:28:48 - 4:28:49

4:28:48We're ready for you to testify.

Marnie Glickman 4:28:50 - 4:28:51

4:28:50Okay.

Simone Crowe 4:28:54 - 4:30:56

4:28:54I'm so sorry.

4:28:58Hi, my name is Simone Crowe, and thank you all for having me here today.

4:29:05I am with Thrive East PDX and owner of Tending Blue Fields Massage and Bodywork, a small business.

4:29:12First off, I'd like to offer my suggestions on areas of funding to evaluate and consider cutting or not funding.

4:29:19Thank you.

4:29:22So first off, Moda Center renovations.

4:29:26Secondly, East Portland Action Plan.

4:29:30Thirdly, Prosper Portland.

4:29:31And finally, Dunphy 4's amendment, high earners raise— high earners raises and bonuses at the city.

4:29:41And I hope that you all adopt Dunphy 1 and use the Office of Community and Civic Life to help us make sure that we're Thank you for recently investing in housing.

4:29:53Please continue to fund housing.

4:29:55It's not just the fact that Portlanders and immigrants are facing evictions.

4:29:59Homes are our first line of defense against climate disasters.

4:30:03This summer, we're likely going to see higher temperatures and more smoke than ever before.

4:30:08East Portland has one emergency— or no, has no emergency shelters anymore.

4:30:12Councilmember Loretta Smith.

4:30:13Invest in resilience hubs.

4:30:15If you're going to divert PSF funds, channel it to resilience.

4:30:19That was the original intent of the ballot measure.

4:30:20It wouldn't be difficult to broaden the definition and channel money into places like community-based organizations and libraries to stand up cooling or warming shelters.

4:30:29Next year, for the newfound EPAP bucket of funds, create an RFP process for East Portland CBOs.

4:30:37Fund the Public Management Office.

4:30:38So that East Portland organizations like Cultivate Initiatives can continue to do the great work of beautifying our city like they do in Parkrose.

4:30:47I urge you to support small businesses.

4:30:49Could you partially match the IDA program?

4:30:52Create a tiered system that offers tiered permitting and business licenses?

Zach White 4:30:56 - 4:30:57

4:30:56Thank you, Simone.

Jamie Dunphy 4:30:57 - 4:30:58

4:30:57Sorry, we're out of time.

Joe Squires 4:30:59 - 4:31:00

4:30:59Oh, shit.

Keelan McClymont 4:31:06 - 4:31:08

4:31:06Brooke is online.

4:31:07Brooke, you can go ahead.

Brooke Buranew 4:31:11 - 4:32:42

4:31:11Hello.

4:31:11Good afternoon, council members.

4:31:13My name is Brooke Burhanu.

4:31:14I currently live in District 2, and I'm a voting member of the Portland Utility Board, also known as PUB.

4:31:20And I also serve as a PUB representative on the Project Delivery Advisory Team for the Bull Run Filtration Project.

4:31:27I'm speaking today to reiterate and emphasize PUB's position previously provided by co-chairs Chipman and Wilson on the proposed utility budgets.

4:31:35The pub would like to urge council to please adopt the full 7.5% combined utility rate increase needed to maintain current service levels and authorize the $525 million bond towards the Bull Run Filtration Project.

4:31:49This is the minimum needed to preserve operations, reliability, and long-term financial stability of essential utility services.

4:31:57Construction costs only continue to rise, and further delaying much-needed infrastructure improvements will only increase those costs over the long term and leave Portland's water and wastewater systems more susceptible to the impacts of climate change.

4:32:10At the same time, aging infrastructure also contributes to water loss, which is lost revenue from water that we pay to produce, but the Bureau does not collect any revenue on.

4:32:20Beyond the impacts to service, the proposed budget will constrain the utility's ability to complete the core services realignment in progress and transition to the unified One Water model that will support customer affordability in the short and long term.

4:32:33Thank you.

4:32:34With all that said, I'd like to reiterate public support for an appropriate budget that does not continue the cycle of shifting cost burdens to future generations.

4:32:41Thank you for your time.

Jamie Dunphy 4:32:43 - 4:32:43

4:32:43Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 4:32:45 - 4:32:46

4:32:45Anais, you can go ahead online.

Anais Tupker 4:32:48 - 4:34:40

4:32:48Hello, thank you.

4:32:49Uh, hello, councilors, the mayor, and everyone.

4:32:52My name is Anais Tipker.

4:32:54I live in District 3.

4:32:55Um, I'm calling in during my work hours, so I need to state I'm testifying during my break time, and I am— my comments are my own.

4:33:04I am not speaking as a federal employee.

4:33:07Uh, I'm testifying today in support of Avalos 1, Koyama Lane 2, Novick 3, and Green 1 in particular.

4:33:16Um, I'm testifying— I'm motivated to testify today particularly because I was one of the hundreds, maybe thousands, of Portlanders who collected the signatures and canvassed door to door across Portland in order to make PCEF a reality.

4:33:35I did that because of the bold vision of PCEF that recognized that we needed serious and targeted investments in a clean energy transition, really looking towards a different model for our future.

4:33:51I did not put my heart and time into creating a general-purpose fund for the city to use when it needs Band-Aids.

4:34:00I find it particularly distasteful that some of the use for PCF now would be for things like trash collection, which sounds a lot like— and supporting sweeps of our unhoused neighbors.

4:34:12I was moved by testimony by others about problems with that, and I You know, PSF has shown that the model works.

4:34:22If the city needs money, I encourage them to work with others to find ways to have additional licensing taxes on corporations.

4:34:32I want us to keep this money where it belongs, protect the vision of PSF.

4:34:39Thank you very much.

Jamie Dunphy 4:34:41 - 4:34:42

4:34:41Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 4:34:42 - 4:34:56

4:34:42Patricia Rojas.

4:34:45Marnie Glickman, Madeline Carroll, Cheryl Gardner, Diana Ross— excuse me, Dina Ross, Joe Zettler.

4:34:55And Patricia's online, you can go ahead.

Patricia Rojas 4:34:58 - 4:36:40

4:34:58Thank you.

4:34:58Good afternoon, Mayor Wilson, Council President Dunphy, and city councilors.

4:35:02My name is Patricia Rojas.

4:35:04I use she and her pronouns, and I'm the executive director of the Regional Arts and Culture Council.

4:35:10I'm here today in support of Dunphy 2 with which backfills most of the proposed cuts in arts and culture.

4:35:17Often budget investments and subsequent cuts are talked about in terms of programming, but it's important that we talk about public dollars in terms of outcomes and impact on the city of Portland and her residents.

4:35:28In a fiscal landscape of budget deficits, it's easy for some to think of funding the arts as a, quote, nice to have.

4:35:35But I'm here to uplift the role of artists and arts in our community as foundational to a thriving economy One of the reasons people come to visit Portland, move to Portland, and choose to stay in Portland is the richness of the arts in our community.

4:35:52Any day of the week, Portlanders can enjoy world-class live music, theater, dance performances, visit art galleries with beautiful paintings, and so many other mediums of art.

4:36:03Families enjoy concerts and movies in the park, all because we have a healthy and thriving arts community.

4:36:09Thank you, Mayor.

4:36:10That is due because we have individual artists that call Portland home, and those artists are business owners.

4:36:17They're not hobbyists.

4:36:19These are folks making a living off of the art that they create.

4:36:22And they're not the only ones.

4:36:25Restaurants, parking facilities, bars, small storefronts, other auxiliary businesses are also thriving because people come to see the arts, watch that performance, and spend those dollars in those businesses.

4:36:37Thank you.

4:36:38Uh, is that, is that all the time that I have?

Jamie Dunphy 4:36:40 - 4:36:41

4:36:40Yeah, that was time, unfortunately.

Simone Crowe 4:36:41 - 4:36:42

4:36:41Sorry.

Patricia Rojas 4:36:42 - 4:36:43

4:36:42Okay, thank you so much.

Unidentified speaker 4:36:43 - 4:36:44

4:36:43Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 4:36:46 - 4:36:47

4:36:46Cheryl, you can go ahead.

Cheryl Gardner 4:36:52 - 4:38:18

4:36:52Good afternoon, Mayor Wilson, Council President, and City Council.

4:36:56I'm Cheryl Gardner, and I belong to Hope and Bread Street Church on 82nd Avenue.

4:37:02I worked for Portland Parks in the last years of the 20th century, and it was well known at the time that the city east of 82nd Avenue was underserved by Portland Parks.

4:37:12Sadly, not much has changed in the past 26 years.

4:37:16As a person of faith, I believe that everyone is my neighbor and that the city I love isn't providing a fair share of its resources to my neighbors in East Portland.

4:37:27Fewer than 9% of parks are located east of 82nd Avenue.

4:37:31Parks website states that 5 of those parks have a shelter.

4:37:35But it includes Montavilla, making it an unreliable source.

4:37:39With a higher than average number of people of color, immigrants, and families with children living in the area, it's not a good look for Portland.

4:37:48The shelter at Montavilla Park may seem insignificant, but it would show our neighbors that they matter to the people in power and that their voices are heard.

4:37:59We appreciate that Councilor Koyama Lane has spent time with us And look forward to hosting Councilors Morillo and Novick.

4:38:07And all of you have an open invitation to join us at Hope and Bread any Sunday afternoon at 5 o'clock.

4:38:14Please pass Koyama Lane 6, and thank you for your time.

Jamie Dunphy 4:38:19 - 4:38:20

4:38:19Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 4:38:21 - 4:38:22

4:38:21Dina, you can go ahead.

Dina Ross 4:38:26 - 4:39:25

4:38:26Good afternoon.

4:38:27My name is Dina Ross, and I serve as a member of the Community Board for Police Accountability, but I'm speaking today in an individual capacity as a constituent of District 4.

4:38:37I am here to urge City Council to reject Council Vice President Clark's amendment to remove $10 million from the CBPA budget through the OCPA.

4:38:47This funding is not unused because the board does not need it.

4:38:50It is unspent because the voter-mandated system has only just begun meeting and it is still being built from the ground up.

4:38:56Portlanders have waited more than 5 years for the oversight system they approved in 2020.

4:38:59Councilmember Koyama Lane, you have 2 minutes.

4:39:01Measure 26-217 passed with 81.58% support.

4:39:06Pulling these funds now would undermine the voters, the board, and the city's stated commitment to police accountability.

4:39:13I also find it concerning that this proposal was released without first consulting the CBPA.

4:39:18Public safety and police accountability are not opposing goals.

4:39:22Accountability is public safety.

4:39:23Please reject this amendment.

Unidentified speaker 4:39:25 - 4:39:26

4:39:25Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 4:39:26 - 4:39:27

4:39:26Councilmember Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 4:39:30 - 4:39:31

4:39:30Joe, you can go ahead.

Joe Zettler 4:39:34 - 4:41:08

4:39:34Hi, I'm Joe Zettler, and I'm afraid my aging brain couldn't quite make it in time to look at the detail of the amendments, so my suggestions are more like guidelines based on what I feel are the important issues.

4:39:49I believe we should continue anything that contributes to the police bureau's current renovation process.

4:39:55I've been very impressed with their new approaches to community policing and the use of non-officer staff for quicker, more efficient first response.

4:40:05And I think it's a great idea to use unused funds from the Not Ready for Prime Time Police Accountability Fund, which gets annual funding.

4:40:15I agree that we should hold harmless traditionally underserved communities as much as we can within the limitations of this year's budget.

4:40:24I approve of any spending for kids and youth, particularly in low-income areas.

4:40:31I'm opposed to any increase in funding for urban forestry until it's audited.

4:40:36Interaction with property owners have shown it to be difficult to deal with and inefficient.

4:40:43I'm opposed to more funding for parks except for underserved Public safety and public works maintenance, which could include park structures, are this year's top priorities.

4:40:56And I urge each of you to commit to work together in the face of these competing priorities that we've seen here today and to continue our push toward a workable city.

Gina Taylor 4:41:09 - 4:41:09

4:41:09Thanks.

Jamie Dunphy 4:41:10 - 4:41:10

4:41:10Thank you so much.

Jim Corcoran 4:41:12 - 4:41:12

4:41:12Trish.

Keelan McClymont 4:41:14 - 4:41:42

4:41:14Trish Garner, Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk, Gina Taylor, Maya Spencer, Sophie Chirlik-Rittenbaum, Wynne Firth, and Emery Mort.

4:41:41Trish, you can go ahead online.

Trish Garner 4:41:43 - 4:43:17

4:41:43All right, good afternoon.

4:41:45My name is Trish Garner.

4:41:47My pronouns are she/her.

4:41:48I live in District 2, and while I serve on the Community Board for Police Accountability, I'm speaking here today solely in my personal capacity against Clark 1.

4:42:002 Points.

4:42:01Firstly, the CPBA is making real and measurable progress.

4:42:06After a lengthy security check process, it's now actively engaged in hiring a director, defining priorities, and building the systems necessary to fulfill its mission.

4:42:17The meeting cadence has increased to accelerate that work.

4:42:21A reduction in funding now would hinder this momentum.

4:42:24Secondly, reducing the CBPA budget would send the wrong message to the community.

4:42:31Independent Police accountability is not optional infrastructure.

4:42:37It is essential public trust infrastructure.

4:42:41The CBPA represents Portland's commitment to fair, independent, community-centered oversight of police misconduct.

4:42:49Weakening that commitment now risks undermining public confidence in the city's willingness to follow through.

4:42:57I surely recognize the city faces serious fiscal challenges, but reducing the CBPA budget as proposed would jeopardize years of work and public investment at the very moment the board is beginning to deliver on its mandate.

4:43:12I urge you to preserve the funding necessary for the CBPA to succeed.

4:43:16Thank you.

Brooke Buranew 4:43:17 - 4:43:18

4:43:17Thank you so much.

Keelan McClymont 4:43:20 - 4:43:21

4:43:20Lisa, you can go ahead.

Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk 4:43:24 - 4:45:01

4:43:24Democracy is native Democracy is indigenous.

4:43:28For 100 years and hundreds of years before any white person stepped on this land, it's been intact with developing practices, deeply felt democracy of the independent nations living interdependently under the great law of peace.

4:43:44These deep roots of principles of governance and self-governance where the 7 generations were truly sustainable, where Mother Nature is a table, is sitting at the table right next to you, and where Peace is the highest caring of governance and where law is aligned with life.

4:44:03This is the opportunity in life where we have the opportunity to reset.

4:44:07In many ways, this democracy is— this democracy is dying.

4:44:12In many ways, it never really served most of us that have been here.

4:44:19Desperation deserves mercy.

4:44:21This racial equity thing is all fake.

4:44:24All of you, if you can't see you're racially divided, that's a problem.

4:44:29When the people ask you for housing, when people ask you for mental health resources, and they ask you for help, and they ask you to not be hunted on their lands, we need to come together.

4:44:43We are undermining each other.

4:44:48When people are losing faith because of the collaboration between one another is suffering, We need to come together.

4:44:55The $30,000 isn't anything.

4:45:00Keep that in mind.

Keelan McClymont 4:45:03 - 4:45:06

4:45:03Go ahead at the testimony table.

Gina Taylor 4:45:10 - 4:45:11

4:45:10Hi.

4:45:10Is that my turn?

Jamie Dunphy 4:45:11 - 4:45:12

4:45:11You're good.

Jim Corcoran 4:45:12 - 4:45:12

4:45:12Okay.

Gina Taylor 4:45:13 - 4:46:05

4:45:13I'm a volunteer at the Clackamas Service Center.

4:45:14My name's Gina Taylor, and I want to bring to the attention about Rapid Response's Biohazard Team, how their company culture is to degrade and ridicule our most vulnerable citizens of our city experiencing homelessness.

4:45:25I've witnessed firsthand the trauma that they inflict on many people.

4:45:29Over 200 people were left in extreme weather without blankets and tents to protect them from the elements.

4:45:34Necessary medications were withheld and disposed of instead of being given to them, which endangers lives and they have caused death.

4:45:41Sadly, settling out of court isn't okay.

4:45:43The city has turned a blind eye to this behavior, which makes the city complicit and condoning it in my eyes.

4:45:50I know we can do better.

4:45:51I'm here to support Amendment Green 3 and, you know, remind you guys to give trash bags to campsites, porta-potties.

4:45:58Nobody wants to live in filth, and we need to do more outreach and case management to help solve this problem.

4:46:04Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 4:46:05 - 4:46:06

4:46:05Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 4:46:11 - 4:46:11

4:46:11You can go ahead.

Wynne Furth 4:46:15 - 4:47:14

4:46:15Good morning— sorry, good afternoon.

4:46:17Thank you for still being here.

4:46:19Council President, Council, Mayor Wilson, Good afternoon.

4:46:22City Administrator Raymond Lee.

4:46:25My name is Wynne Furth.

4:46:26I speak as an individual today.

4:46:28Some good work was done during the 100-plus years that we were governed by the commission form of government, but we also earned a reputation for siloed bureaus, uncoordinated projects, duplicative, even contradictory activity, for the neglect of basic maintenance, and a lack of coherent planning.

4:46:49In 2022, I was part of a group that spoke to a lot of Portlanders about the new form of government that was proposed in the charter amendment, and the most informed, passionate advocacy was from the city employees who turned out to be in the audience, who testified about what they'd seen of the waste of their time and the city's money.

4:47:09When people in Portland voted for the charter amendment, we wanted better representation.

Joe Squires 4:47:14 - 4:47:15

4:47:14Yes.

Wynne Furth 4:47:15 - 4:47:59

4:47:15But we also wanted the more effective and efficient government that could come with that.

4:47:21For years, our problems have been well known, and there have been efforts to clean up our act, but they failed because every time money is tight, nobody wants to spend it on organizational cleanup.

4:47:32But you need to hold fast to this.

4:47:35You are our chance to turn the page on that history.

4:47:39Crowds don't turn out On behalf of administrative infrastructure, it's even hard to pronounce.

4:47:45Nobody cuts a ribbon.

4:47:48It's not anybody's baby, but it should be everybody's baby, because unless we clean up our act, we can't deliver all the things that people do turn out for.

4:47:59Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 4:48:00 - 4:48:01

4:48:00Thank you so much.

Keelan McClymont 4:48:04 - 4:48:05

4:48:04Maya, you can go ahead online.

Maya Spencer 4:48:06 - 4:49:46

4:48:06Good afternoon, everyone.

4:48:08My name is Maya Spencer.

4:48:09I'm a resident of District 2.

4:48:11I have served the City of Portland for over 20 years in my work, and I'm a proud member of the CPPW union.

4:48:16I'm speaking on my own behalf today in favor of several amendments.

4:48:20First of all, Avalos 6 to restore a community engagement coordinator position in parks.

4:48:25I wanted to note council may not have the context that this team already lost 2 of its 6 FTE positions in last year's budget.

4:48:32Thank you.

4:48:32Losing an additional position would be a cumulative 50% cut over 2 years to an already small team and will impact parks' ability to engage and be responsive to Portlanders' needs from their parks and recreation system.

4:48:44I also support Avalos 3, Dunphy 3, and Novick 2.

4:48:47All of these provide ways to preserve the parks coordinator who supports partners and volunteers on the east side and many other vital community safety services.

4:48:56I also support Koyama Lane 4 to add $30,000 for those Tribal Summit.

4:49:00Our city must support this work in respect to tribal sovereignty and to show— to put our money where our values are.

4:49:08As a District 2 resident, I also support Canal 1 to increase homeownership opportunities for the Black community.

4:49:14And finally, I commend the collaboration and thoughtfulness on the Murillo-Green-Novick 1 amendment to pause core services realignment, a process that has felt neither collaborative nor thoughtful due to the lack of engagement of staff Thank you so much, Maya.

Keelan McClymont 4:49:46 - 4:49:47

4:49:46Emery, you can go ahead online.

Emory Mort 4:49:49 - 4:50:20

4:49:49Good afternoon, President Dunphy, councilors, uh, and thank you for your public service.

4:49:54My name is Emory Mort, D4 resident, longtime volunteer organizer with the Portland Metro People's Coalition.

4:50:01While speaking for myself, the amendments I support align with our coalition's adopted Bill of Rights.

4:50:07While there are many important items for us to consider, my focus in this testimony is on improving Portland by increasing City Council oversight and direction to the city's homelessness response, currently largely running under the direction of the mayor.

Kevin Block 4:50:20 - 4:50:20

4:50:20Thank you.

Emory Mort 4:50:21 - 4:51:33

4:50:21Specifically, I call on you to support Councilor Green's 2 and 3 and Avalos' 4.

4:50:27These 3 amendments are not disruptive to current services.

4:50:31They are creative, participatory, and have future-looking checkpoints designed to build more positive momentum.

4:50:37Taken together or individually, they say no unlimited funds for unproven pet projects.

4:50:43They say yes to proven methods like hygiene infrastructure and small villages.

4:50:47Thank you, Councilor Mitch Green.

4:50:48They say no to wasting precious dollars on unaccountable methods and facilities.

4:50:53They say yes to responsible frameworks formed and executed between 2 elected branches of government and the people impacted.

4:51:01Passed in tandem, Housing and Permitting Chair Avalos 4 with Committee Vice Chair Green 2 and 3 put a stake in the ground saying this past fiscal year is the last one where we try to address homelessness by doing 9,000 sweeps, Needlessly using thousands of police hours, opening undesired shelters to hit gamified quotas, and driving many people deeper into the woods.

4:51:25To summarize in a single line: while Portland City Council shouldn't micromanage, perhaps it should manage more micro villages.

Joe Squires 4:51:34 - 4:51:34

4:51:34Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 4:51:35 - 4:51:36

4:51:35Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 4:51:38 - 4:51:48

4:51:38El McFarland, Jeff Love, and Marnie Glickman.

4:51:47You can come right up to the table.

Jim Corcoran 4:51:52 - 4:51:54

4:51:52Okay.

Jeff Love 4:51:56 - 4:53:56

4:51:56Hi, I'm Jeff Love.

4:51:58I'm a longtime Oregon resident and Portland resident, uh, currently residing in District 4.

4:52:04Uh, last time I spoke at the City Council, there were 5 councilors in And now it seems more— my analogy was going to be like a basketball team.

4:52:13Now it seems to be more like a football team I'm addressing.

4:52:15But the main thing that concerns me is that I see from all these amendments essentially a partnership, which is what I view all of you as, not working together the way it should.

4:52:28And I'm a lawyer.

4:52:29I've been a partner in a firm for many years.

4:52:32You get together in a partnership meeting with 30 partners people just have to look, work together, and they have to follow a leader.

4:52:39The city elected a leader.

4:52:41Next time it could be you.

4:52:43This time, you know, it's Mayor Wilson.

4:52:45And what I want to see from the city council is support for his agenda.

4:52:51It's just like a basketball team or a football team.

4:52:54If you've got players who don't want to run the play that the coach called or the quarterback called, or the point guard wants to run.

4:53:02It's just so disruptive.

4:53:04It's so ineffective.

4:53:05And so— and I know how partnerships work.

4:53:08When you got disputes, you try to work them out before the partnership meeting.

4:53:12There shouldn't be this many disputes at the partnership meeting, which is essentially what this is.

4:53:17And so I'm just asking all of you to try to work more as a team by supporting the person who's currently in the leadership chair And specifically, just to throw out a number, for those of you who are proposing amendments that the mayor's office is strongly against, I'd ask you just today, take out your pencil, drop half of them.

4:53:39That would be a start.

4:53:41Now, when it comes to the merits, others have testified they know a lot more about the merits of all these amendments.

4:53:46I get the idea that dropping any of these things is going to hurt some of your constituents and it's going to hurt your agendas.

4:53:53But do it anyway for the purpose of improving the teamwork.

4:53:56Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 4:53:57 - 4:53:58

4:53:57Thank you very much.

Marnie Glickman 4:53:59 - 4:55:35

4:53:59Good afternoon, councilors.

4:54:01Thank you for your deep, respectful listening to us today.

4:54:04My name is Marnie Glickman.

4:54:06I'm a resident of District 2.

4:54:08I'm the executive director of Braided River Campaign and a registered city lobbyist.

4:54:13My main point today is to encourage you councilors to collaborate better and take on this big budget battle with hope.

4:54:21Do not back down from doing what is right.

4:54:25There are dozens of problems you've heard with the mayor's proposed budget.

4:54:29When I read it, I too was disappointed.

4:54:31And Mr. Mayor, I was also disappointed when you belittled people wearing t-shirts coming to City Council and voicing their concerns.

4:54:40Portlanders work hard and the city should work hard for Portlanders.

4:54:44We don't wanna waste our taxpayer dollars subsidizing the billionaire owner of the Trail Blazers, and we care about children and elders.

4:54:52Thank you.

4:54:53The city should too, especially the children who go to preschool inside the CEI hub less than 1/2 a mile away from Kinder Morgan's tank farm.

4:55:03Even though you eliminated the Climate Committee this year, you know, we all know Portlanders are environmentalists and conservationists.

4:55:11We want you to protect PCEF and fulfill our obligations to clean up the Portland Harbor Superfund site.

4:55:18This budget is your chance.

4:55:20Thank you.

4:55:20Our chance to make life better for all of us.

4:55:2410 Years from now, will we look back and say, wow, we came a long way from those difficult times?

4:55:31I believe in you, and I know that you'll make the right decisions for all of us.

4:55:34Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 4:55:36 - 4:55:36

4:55:36Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 4:55:39 - 4:55:42

4:55:39Elle McFarland's online.

4:55:42Elle, you can go ahead.

Lauren Farley 4:55:46 - 4:55:47

4:55:46Hello, can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 4:55:48 - 4:55:48

4:55:48We can.

Lauren Farley 4:55:51 - 4:57:03

4:55:51Hi, my name is Lauren Farley.

4:55:53I work with the NRDC, Earthjustice, and other national advocates on lead and water issues.

4:55:59I support Green One to restore vital fire and safety services by trimming managerial bloat across bureaus.

4:56:06Under the commission form of government, managers did not manage; they protected bureau silos, budgets, and.

4:56:12Portland officials denied Portland Water Bureau's crisis despite multiple lead exceedances.

4:56:20In comparison, Flint had one exceedance.

4:56:24Last Wednesday, council heard utility managers ask for an additional $525 million to comply with cryptocurrency and regulations.

4:56:31In August 2017, managers claimed this would cost $105 to $500 million Depending on the treatment choice, then persuaded old council on the $500 million choice, a filtration plant.

4:56:457 Years later, respected conservationists and Portland Utility Board members Bob Salinger called out this project, soaring costs, begging for oversight that never came.

4:56:57Last Wednesday, Councilor Green wisely asked about the total cost of the project over its full debt repayment period.

Rob Wolfson 4:57:03 - 4:57:03

4:57:03Councilor Green, I'm sorry, I didn't hear you.

Lauren Farley 4:57:03 - 4:57:29

4:57:03CFO Jonas Beery wasn't sure, then returned with water-related debt, a jaw-dropping $4.98 billion.

4:57:12What about other fees, other damage claims, and so on and so forth?

4:57:17In short, multiple managers are still engaging in, um, big omissions about the most expensive treatment option on the most expensive rural site.

4:57:27Please vote yes on Green 1.

4:57:29Thank you.

4:57:29Councilmember Herbold.

Jamie Dunphy 4:57:30 - 4:57:31

4:57:30Thank you so much.

Keelan McClymont 4:57:32 - 4:57:35

4:57:32Sophie Terlik-Rittenbaum's online.

4:57:35You can go ahead.

Tanisha Renee 4:57:38 - 4:57:38

4:57:38Hey, thank you.

Sophie Chirlik-Rittenbaum 4:57:39 - 4:59:11

4:57:39My name is Sophie Terlik-Rittenbaum.

4:57:40I use she/her/they pronouns, and I'm here to testify in support of the amendments championed by the DSA members on Councilor and Councilor Avalos that actually help the people of Portland and our planet, to testify against shifting more of Portlanders' tax dollars to the Portland Police Bureau, which I'll be referring to as PBB.

4:57:56PSF is not a slush fund.

4:57:57That money is for climate action because we are in a climate emergency.

4:58:01That money is not for giving a billionaire a handout for a sports stadium renovation, nor is it for policing.

4:58:06It is outrageous that severe cuts to programs that actually help people and protect our planet are always proposed while the police are only asked to give up what to them is a drop in the bucket, if anything.

4:58:17PPB is eating up $318 million in Portland's budget in the current fiscal year.

4:58:22PPB has received more and more money every year.

4:58:25It never actually faced cuts after the Black Lives Matter protests.

4:58:27Thank you.

4:58:27In fiscal year 2025-2026, $279,066,000 was spent on policing, not counting the retirement plan, retirement plan for police.

4:58:39That amount divided by $2,545, the amount spent on average per apartment funded by a Portland housing measure, is nearly 110,000 apartment units.

4:58:52This is enough to house the 30,000 homeless people in Portland.

4:58:54Thank you.

4:58:55And it would have left over $203 million to prevent the cuts to other programs we are considering today.

4:59:01And this doesn't even account for PBV's budget ballooning to $318 million this year.

4:59:06Budget is a moral document.

4:59:07Do we want to cut coercion, or do we want to cut climate justice and actual safety?

Jamie Dunphy 4:59:13 - 4:59:14

4:59:13Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 4:59:16 - 4:59:27

4:59:16Jeremy Beausoleil-Smith, Steve Herring, Mark Porras, Matteo Fredrickson.

4:59:23Chris Lapanis.

4:59:26Zach White.

Jamie Dunphy 4:59:30 - 5:01:08

4:59:30Good afternoon, councilors.

4:59:31My name is Steve Herring.

4:59:32I'm the CEO of Living Room Theaters here in downtown Portland.

4:59:35I'm a lifelong resident of Portland.

4:59:36I was born in Portland.

4:59:38I've lived here most of my life.

4:59:40I wanted to address you all not on the specific budget measures that everyone has addressed.

4:59:43There's a lot of activists that have testified here today on behalf of interests that they're very tied to.

4:59:48I wanted to talk about the unlucky number 13, which is the number of councilors plus the mayor, which has led to just abysmal level of dysfunction.

4:59:57I came and testified before you right around the beginning of this council.

5:00:01You guys had a dysfunctional election for president, and then right after getting your first president, you voted to give yourselves a massive amount of money.

5:00:08You all ran knowing how much money and how many staff you were going to have in your offices.

5:00:14The goal of voters was to see the districts work together, to share resources, not to each one of you have your own specific private interests, your own private fund, and your own private office.

5:00:25Our company has 2 theater locations, one here in Portland, Oregon, and one in Indianapolis.

5:00:29We also have a corporate headquarters located here in downtown Portland.

5:00:33Our entire annual revenue is just over $3 million between our 2 locations.

5:00:38That's down from what we used to have with 2 smaller locations pre-COVID, largely because we're in such dysfunction.

5:00:46Councilor Avalos, you released a survey response just a couple days ago talking about how your district wants to see $200,000 taken from downtown reputation improvement, and you said that businesses downtown just need to adjust to the new realities.

5:01:00Well, those new realities are all because of the lack of public safety, which was the number one thing shown in your survey.

5:01:06Please follow those results.

5:01:08Thank you.

Mateo Frederickson 5:01:12 - 5:02:18

5:01:12Good afternoon, councilors and Mr. Mayor.

5:01:15My name is Mateo Frederickson.

5:01:16I'm a senior at Roosevelt High School in District 2.

5:01:18Let's go, let's go.

5:01:20I've lived in District 2 all 18 years of my life, and I've seen many sides of the homeless crisis here in Portland.

5:01:27I witnessed lots of drug abuse, seeing people trying to raise kids on the street, and it's even affected my family personally as People have tried to live outside my father's business down in downtown Kenton.

5:01:41I'm in favor.

5:01:42I'm not here to discuss the amendments individually, but the budget as a whole.

5:01:48I'm in favor of the budget because I believe it gives us a stable financial foundation, which we have not had for the last few years.

5:01:55And I believe that'll allow us to truly tackle our issues like vacancies in downtown Portland, And most importantly, homelessness and the significant, uh, um, high— significantly high cost of living here in Portland.

5:02:10Um, our city and our residents, I believe, are ready to heal from our many wounds.

5:02:15And in the words of the mayor, we cannot put the brakes on our recovery.

5:02:18So thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 5:02:20 - 5:02:20

5:02:20Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 5:02:23 - 5:02:24

5:02:23Jeremy, you can go ahead online.

Rob Wolfson 5:02:26 - 5:03:57

5:02:26Jeremy Bosoli-Smith, District 4.

5:02:28Please support the following amendments.

5:02:30Avalos 1, we need to preserve the core mission of PSF and protect our houseless neighbors from sweeps.

5:02:35Avalos 2, we need to protect our neighbors under attack by immigration controls and enforcement.

5:02:42Avalos 4, we need to find systemic solutions to homelessness.

5:02:46Uh, Dunphy 2, arts and culture will always bring more foot traffic to downtown than any marketing initiative.

5:02:52Green 1, firefighting capacity in St. Johns, particularly because of the CEI hub.

5:02:58Poses a huge threat, and it's way too important to not be funded.

5:03:02Green 2, self-governing microvillages can develop self-confidence and build communication skills.

5:03:07Definitely an essential part of getting everyone housed.

5:03:10Green 3, sweeps are cruel and they're not effective means of promoting public health and cleaning.

5:03:16Canal 1, we need to guarantee the safety of money for social housing.

5:03:20Canal 3, small donor election program keeps the rich from buying our elections and is vital to the health of our democracy.

5:03:27I will skip down to— Lane 4.

5:03:31Portland is a global epicenter for Indigenous people from across the planet to gather.

5:03:35We need to continue our investments in positioning Portland as a city that's recognizing the wrongs of the past and charting a better future for all of us by adequately funding the 2026-2027 Tribal Summit.

5:03:47And I will jump to— please oppose Clark 1.

5:03:52This is a slap in the face of police oversight.

5:03:54Please do not support this.

5:03:57Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 5:03:59 - 5:04:00

5:03:59Thank you so much.

Keelan McClymont 5:04:01 - 5:04:02

5:04:01Mark, you can go ahead online.

Trish Garner 5:04:03 - 5:04:03

5:04:03Thank you.

Mark Porras 5:04:03 - 5:04:04

5:04:03Can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 5:04:04 - 5:04:05

5:04:04We can.

Mark Porras 5:04:05 - 5:05:40

5:04:05Fantastic.

5:04:06I'm Mark Porras, he/him pronouns, District 2 resident.

5:04:09I want to fully endorse the testimony I heard today from Jamal Williams, Charlie Michelle Wesley, Dina Ross, and Trish Garner.

5:04:15Please also support Murillo 1, Canal 4 and 5, and Green 1.

5:04:19I see a budget decision to eliminate the retire-rehire program.

5:04:22It's about time.

5:04:23Chief Day expects 40 to 50 retirements this month, but only 30 to really leave, which means 10 to 20 more cops will be double dipping at his sole discretion.

5:04:30A public servant who will only stay on the job for double pay should be thanked for their service and sent a final paycheck.

5:04:35The current police chief and his chief of staff both pull in 6-figure pensions alongside their 6-figure salaries.

5:04:41I want to speak out strongly against the Clark amendments that take $10 million of the Office of Community-Based Police Accountability's $16 million budget.

5:04:48Claiming that any of the new board's money is underutilized is baloney.

5:04:52The volunteer members of this board could and should direct the city to pay for independent counsel, hire the OIR group to review the past 5 years of critical incidents, including the 2 files that were withheld by PPB and the city attorney from their most recent report, the killings of Michael Townsend and Robert Delgado.

5:05:07They could hire consultants to help with feedback on directives, send all CBPA members to the NACOL conference, spend heavily on community engagement.

5:05:14And much more to make up for years of starving police accountability of money.

5:05:17This will set them up for success once they start case— taking cases in 2027.

5:05:21I know you remember the $3.75 million settlement you approved last year for the family of Manny Clark, an unarmed Black man who was shot in the back and killed by PPB.

5:05:29An internal affairs investigator found all 3 shots to be out of policy.

5:05:33Chief Day disagreed.

5:05:34No discipline was imposed.

5:05:35As long as we have police, it's not possible to have public safety for all without police accountability.

5:05:39Thank you.

5:05:40Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 5:05:41 - 5:05:42

5:05:41Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 5:05:45 - 5:05:46

5:05:45Zach's online, you can go ahead.

Zach White 5:05:48 - 5:07:21

5:05:48Hello, I'm Zach White.

5:05:49I was born in Portland.

5:05:50I'm a resident of District 4, and my work with Next Up— we seek to empower youth voices in the city.

5:05:57I knocked on doors for most of you on the dais.

5:05:59Um, Amendment Green 1 restores funding for fire engine and rescue units by cutting from unneeded management or chopping from the top.

5:06:08I'm very disturbed at the eagerness of some to cut from Portland's new police system accountability.

5:06:16Green 1 does not do that.

5:06:17Powerful institutions of people who carry weapons are not easy to hold accountable.

5:06:22Amendments Green 2 and 3 invest in giving dignity to our homeless neighbors.

5:06:26I remember Mayor Wilson on the debate stage capturing the moral outrage of our homelessness crisis.

5:06:32The crisis is continuing, and we need to tackle it by following the leadership of people who are homeless.

5:06:37I believe these amendments align with that approach.

5:06:39Green 2 and 3.

5:06:412 Weeks ago, walking to my apartment in District 4, I saw a tent on the street with a sign that read, how are we supposed to put our broken lives together when the pieces are always getting swept away over and over?

5:06:53I have a photo of that that I can send to any of you.

5:06:56Hearing from 156 testifiers is great, but I don't understand why you are only hearing I recently read that Mayor Mamdani in New York has balanced their budget, quote, not on the backs of working people.

5:07:11It seems that we are very far from that, but I hope we can all agree to work toward that as a North Star.

5:07:17Please consider Green 1, 2, 3, and Avalos 1 and 5 as well.

Mark Porras 5:07:21 - 5:07:21

5:07:21Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 5:07:22 - 5:07:23

5:07:22Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 5:07:30 - 5:07:58

5:07:30Next up we have Joe Squires, Jennifer Hoyt, Nike Green, Herman Green, Valerie Pierce, Pastor Mark Jackson, Pastor Robin Wisner, and Jim Corcoran.

5:07:51Thank you.

5:07:56You can begin at the testimony table, whoever's ready.

Nike Green 5:08:02 - 5:09:38

5:08:02Good afternoon.

5:08:02My name is Nikee Green.

5:08:04I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist and the founder of Triple Threat Mentoring.

5:08:07I'm a part of District 2.

5:08:08I want us to think about this budget like a grocery store.

5:08:11The healthiest foods are usually on the outside aisles— the fruits, vegetables, and fresh foods that create vitality, prevent disease, and sustain life long-term.

5:08:19But the middle aisles are full of processed food systems built for convenience, reaction, survival, and not true health.

5:08:25Right now, too much of our budget basket looks like processed food, because when cuts come, it always cuts upstream prevention work.

5:08:33The very programs addressed that look at social determinants of health and root causes, they're the first that get threatened to be cut.

5:08:41Healthy communities require healthy investments.

5:08:43Canal is fruit.

5:08:45Investing into housing in North Northeast Portland, Williams and Russell, and SEI is prevention work.

5:08:51Keeping OVP and Ceasefire POIC funding is fruit.

5:08:54Thank you.

5:08:54Violence prevention is cheaper and more humane than reacting after harm happens.

5:08:59Avalos is fruit because Portland Clean Energy Fund dollars should continue to supporting climate and community health work, not be redirected away from the prevention-focused bureaus.

5:09:09Our St. Johns Firehouse 22 is fruit.

5:09:11PS3s are fruit.

5:09:13And we need to throw out the processed food proposal attempting to take money from the Office of Community-Based Police Oversight before it even begins work.

5:09:21This budget is not just about moving dollars around on a spreadsheet.

5:09:24Thank you.

5:09:24It is about deciding what nourishes our city.

5:09:27So I ask council today, pause, listen to the people, because some things may look good politically, but in the long run they create harm more than help.

5:09:34But put the processed food back on the shelf and go grab some fruit.

Brooke Buranew 5:09:40 - 5:09:40

5:09:40Thank you.

Herman Green 5:09:41 - 5:11:34

5:09:41That girl bad.

5:09:44All right, uh, good afternoon, council.

5:09:46I need you to understand that for communities like North Portland and Northeast Portland This conversation is not theoretical.

5:09:52This is not just about numbers on a spreadsheet.

5:09:55This is about whether people believe their lives matter enough to be protected.

5:09:59Because when communities that are already struggling begin to see cuts to Fire Station 22, cuts to emergency response systems, cuts to violence prevention programs like Ceasefire and OVP, cuts to victim services and frontline public safety infrastructure, it begins to feel a lot more intentional.

5:10:15And whether that Councilmember Herbold.

5:10:16Whether that is the intent or not, perception matters when you're talking about communities that have been historically underserved, overlooked, displaced, and forced to fight for every basic resource.

5:10:26Station 22 is not just another fire station for families in North Portland.

5:10:30It represents survival.

5:10:31It represents response time.

5:10:33It represents whether help comes fast enough when a child cannot breathe, when a home catches fire, or when an elder is in crisis, or when violence breaks out in our streets.

5:10:42And your own budget notes acknowledge that removing the station increases risk to life, safety, and resiliency in North Portland.

5:10:49So the question becomes, why would we knowingly increase vulnerability in communities already carrying the weight of poverty, addiction, gun violence, housing instability, instability, and generational inequity?

5:11:01At what point do we stop asking the vulnerable communities to absorb every cut?

5:11:06Because these decisions.

5:11:07Thank you.

5:11:07These cuts create ripple effects, more pressures on already stressed responders, families waiting longer than they should, communities feeling abandoned by every system that's set up for them.

5:11:18Public safety cannot become something reserved for communities with wealth, influence, and political leverage.

5:11:24And let me say this clearly, prevention matters.

5:11:26So when you reduce ceasefire, OVP, PS3s, and community-based intervention programs, you are not saving money.

5:11:32You are simply postponing pain.

Jamie Dunphy 5:11:35 - 5:11:36

5:11:35Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 5:11:39 - 5:11:39

5:11:39Jim, you can go ahead.

Jim Corcoran 5:11:44 - 5:13:00

5:11:44My name is Jim Corcoran.

5:11:46Um, I'm a little over my head in your company, but, uh, uh, Keelan McClymont and her staff are friends of mine, and I think that you're doing something really important, so thank you.

5:12:00Please support Councilor Lane's critical budget amendments.

5:12:04I want to ask your help to preserve the funding for critical services to 3 of my most important organizations.

5:12:11I have been aware of, uh, around for about 15 years of the critical contributions of this council in support of these places: the Community for Positive Aging, Bridge Meadows, And Friendly House.

5:12:28Most of you in leadership at the city are aware of the, the important decisions you have on that.

5:12:37All of us have elders in our families, and I have recently become one myself.

5:12:44We belong to each other across the generations.

5:12:50Your own children Your parents, your grandparents will need to stay connected to have a good life.

5:12:56Please work hard to protect these connections.

5:12:59I'm Jim Corcoran.

Jamie Dunphy 5:13:01 - 5:13:01

5:13:01Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 5:13:03 - 5:13:29

5:13:03Next, we'll go to Joe Squires.

5:13:06Joe's online.

5:13:07You can go ahead, Joe.

5:13:18Joe Squires.

5:13:23Okay, while we're waiting for Joe, we can go to Valerie Pierce, also online.

5:13:28Valerie, you can go ahead.

Valerie Pierce 5:13:30 - 5:15:03

5:13:30Good afternoon, everyone.

5:13:31I'm Bishop Valerie Dokes Pierce.

5:13:33I'm a faith leader, an educator, and a daughter carrying the legacy of my father, Bishop C.E.

5:13:38Dokes.

5:13:39And I'm also a board member of the Coalition for African and African-American Pastors Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

5:13:44Councilor Loretta Smith.

5:13:44Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

5:13:44I'm here today to speak on the ordinance that is before us, which is why I'm here today.

5:13:46The foundational DNA of the Black church and the Black community are interchangeable.

5:13:50They've been deeply communal, spiritual, prophetic, political, and justice-centered.

5:13:55Historically, the Black church has not merely functioned as a worship space, but as a refuge, as organizing centers, educational institutions, economic support systems, and a prophetic witness in the face of oppression.

5:14:09Councilor Smith has requested to have a I'm asking that the ordinance to allocate funding for SEI and Williamson Russell's, as well as the Oasis of Praise Church capital project, approved.

5:14:18I'm asking that the ordinance to allocate these funds be approved.

5:14:22This way, all 3 organizations are funded under Councilor Smith's ordinance.

5:14:27Councilor President, thankfully we met with you— a group of pastors including myself and Pastor Mark Jackson met with you last week to ask you to examine your heart towards the right thing You shared how this very work has benefited you and your family.

5:14:43These are desperate and polarizing times.

5:14:45As a leader in the faith community, I'm asking everyone to be followers of what is right, what is good, what is just.

5:14:52I'm requesting that this ordinance be approved to allocate funding for all 3 projects: the SEI in Williams and Russell, along with the Oasis of Praise Church capital project.

5:15:02Thank you so much.

5:15:03Councilor Smith.

Jamie Dunphy 5:15:05 - 5:15:06

5:15:05Thank you so much.

Keelan McClymont 5:15:08 - 5:15:10

5:15:08Mark Jackson is online.

5:15:09You can go ahead.

Mark Jackson 5:15:12 - 5:16:37

5:15:12Yes, for the record, Mark Jackson.

5:15:14I want to just, uh, appreciate the time to, uh, to share this afternoon and appreciate Bishop Pierce's remarks.

5:15:20I'm going to say ditto.

5:15:21I am deeply concerned about the, uh, silencing tactics of both community members and also Councilor Smith.

5:15:29Uh, who back in February put forth this ordinance that Bishop Pierce referenced, uh, that was taken off the table.

5:15:36And here we are now in the month of May and so forth.

5:15:39And I just want to appeal to the council that you in fact take into deep consideration the recommendation from Bishop Pierce.

5:15:47Uh, also, I want to appeal to you, Councilor President Dunphy, that you in fact would, uh, acknowledge, as you have in privacy, in terms of we're doing tremendous work in the community.

5:15:57Thank you.

5:15:57That you partner with District 3 councilors to find a pathway toward those funds to support our project.

5:16:05Not all Black folks are in Northwest East Portland.

5:16:07There are those who are in Southeast Portland and so forth.

5:16:10So we just want to underscore the importance of this hour, that we not just be focused upon process, what is right, but what is just.

5:16:16And we saw very clearly from Councilor Smith back in February a real clear path for everyone's pet project to be funded, but it was put on the, on the table because of a philosophical difference.

5:16:28But I believe there's an opportunity to reimagine outside the box to do what's best for the community, and that's what's so much best for processes.

5:16:36Thank you for your time today.

Jamie Dunphy 5:16:38 - 5:16:38

5:16:38Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 5:16:39 - 5:16:46

5:16:39I'm going to try for Joe Squires again online.

5:16:43Joe, you can unmute your call and testify.

Joe Squires 5:16:49 - 5:16:50

5:16:49Hello?

Keelan McClymont 5:16:51 - 5:16:53

5:16:51Hi, we can hear you.

5:16:53We can.

Joe Squires 5:16:53 - 5:18:31

5:16:53Great.

5:16:54Hi, thank you very much.

5:16:56I'm Joe Squires.

5:16:57I'm a District 2 constituent.

5:17:00I've lived here all my life other than a stint in the Navy.

5:17:03I've spent the last 25 years owning a business and owning some commercial real estate in Portland and Vancouver.

5:17:11As mentioned a couple times, I'm not really calling in to address a specific budget item more The top-line revenue of the, uh, of the budget, not really the, you know, the guts of the P&L.

5:17:23Uh, I think we can all look around and see that things aren't going very well in downtown, that businesses are fleeing the city for various reasons.

5:17:33And I, I, I like to, I like to ask the question, uh, when I've met my councilors and the, and the mayor, why would I start a business in Portland right now?

5:17:42If you take one of those Benjamin Franklin pro and con lists and you put on the pro side, why would I start a business, versus the con side, you'll find it's very difficult to talk someone into starting a business in Portland right now.

5:17:56And I think the same could be said of why would I keep a business that is capable of moving in Portland, because it's becoming very difficult with usury taxes that keep getting added and added.

5:18:07Councilor And quite frankly, the services that are being provided by the city aren't adding up to what the ROI should be.

5:18:15$724 Million in homeless is more than— is almost double what we spend on police and fire.

5:18:22I think that's spending money in the wrong category.

5:18:26The ROI isn't there.

5:18:27The problem keeps getting bigger and we keep throwing more money at it.

5:18:30Thank you.

Hector Marquez 5:18:31 - 5:18:32

5:18:31Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 5:18:36 - 5:18:57

5:18:36That was the last of our registrants.

5:18:38I'd like to make a final call for anyone in the room or joining online who missed their slot.

5:18:48Hi.

5:18:49Sure, you can approach the table.

5:18:55Please state your record— your name for the record.

Daryce Weller 5:18:58 - 5:20:28

5:18:58Hello, councilors.

5:18:59My name is Taylor.

5:19:00I'm a member of DSA and I live in District 4.

5:19:04I support all of Councilor Avalos's budget amendments.

5:19:08PCF funds are for climate resiliency of marginalized communities.

5:19:12PCF is not for sweeps, hostile architecture, or the Moda Center.

5:19:18Homelessness has increased by 3,000 people since Mayor Wilson took office, so clearly this approach has failed.

5:19:24Housing First is more successful than emergency shelters, which is why I support Green 2 and Canal 1.

5:19:29Councilmember Koyama Lane 2 and 6 ensure shady equity and improve our parks.

5:19:36Portlanders rely upon third spaces like parks.

5:19:39Let's also increase accessibility by adding and maintaining more public restrooms.

5:19:44I strongly reject Clark 1 and Clark-Pirtle-Guiney-Novick-Ryan-Smith 1.

5:19:50These amendments reject the will of the people.

5:19:53If you want us to vote, stop undermining it.

5:19:56I support Canal 4 and Green 3 to fund crucial community safety and hygiene programs.

5:20:02We need Green 1 and Dunphy 4 to reduce managerial bloat in favor of essential employees.

5:20:07Remember the pandemic?

5:20:08Most managers aren't essential.

5:20:11Morillo 1 is also imperative.

5:20:13I relied on programs like Lunch and Play as a child.

5:20:16They level the playing field and allow you to be just another kid.

5:20:20At a time when 1 in 6 children in Oregon are food insecure, The future of our city depends on these programs.

5:20:27Thank you for your time.

Jamie Dunphy 5:20:28 - 5:20:29

5:20:28Thank you so much.

Keelan McClymont 5:20:32 - 5:20:59

5:20:32Uh, apologies, we have a couple more people who signed up and the timer froze, so I'm going to restart that.

5:20:48And we have, uh, Edwin Nunez.

5:20:52And is Simone Crowe here?

5:20:54She already testified.

5:20:57Oh, sorry, they signed up for 157 again.

Shelley Hack 5:21:01 - 5:21:09

5:21:01We are— sorry, just checking our online folks.

5:21:09All right, that concludes—.

Jamie Dunphy 5:21:09 - 5:21:11

5:21:09Don't get excited, we're not done yet.

Shelley Hack 5:21:12 - 5:21:17

5:21:12Yeah, that concludes testimony for 2026-157.

Jamie Dunphy 5:21:17 - 5:31:29

5:21:17Okay, colleagues, just to give a run of show for what's going to happen right now, we're going to take another 15-minute break starting now and reconvene at 3 o'clock.

5:21:24When we get back, we have items 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 to read and hear some testimony on, including, uh, I believe there are a number of folks who have signed up with regard to the PSEF interest rate transfer.

5:21:38So, uh, we will come back at 3 o'clock and we will call it back.

5:21:47Oh.

5:31:17Historically speaking, they were needed and necessary.

5:31:21Sure.

5:31:21But I find it crazy that, you know, even like the city councilors, the fact that they want their staff unionized.

Nick Sovey 5:31:29 - 5:31:29

5:31:29For what?

Sameer Kanal 5:37:50 - 5:37:50

5:37:50Aye.

Jamie Dunphy 5:37:51 - 5:38:19

5:37:51Thank you.

5:37:53I am calling us back into order.

5:37:55Public testimony on the city budget is now closed.

5:38:00I now recess this hearing of the City of Portland Budget Committee.

5:38:05Item 1, the city budget, will be taken up again tomorrow morning.

5:38:11And the Portland City Council now returns from recess.

5:38:16Diego, can you please call items 2 through 7?

Unidentified speaker 5:38:20 - 5:38:52

5:38:20Item 2, document number 2026-158, amend Portland Clean Energy Community Benefits To allow a transfer of interest earned in fiscal year 2024-25 for the fiscal year 2026-27 budget.

5:38:37Item 3, document number 2026-159, adopt solid waste and recycling rates and fees for franchise residential collection and the commercial tonnage fee effective July 1st, 2026.

Kim Neal 5:38:52 - 5:38:52

5:38:52Second.

Unidentified speaker 5:38:53 - 5:39:35

5:38:53Item 4, document number 2026-160, revise transportation fees, rates, and charges for fiscal year 2026-27 and amend transportation fee schedule.

5:39:07Item 5, document number 2026-161, revise sewer and stormwater rates, charges, and fees for fiscal year 2026-27.

5:39:19Item 6, document number 2026-162, adopt rates, charges, and fees for water and water-related services for the fiscal year beginning July 1st, 2026, and ending June 30th, 2027.

Luis Del Toro 5:39:38 - 5:39:38

5:39:38Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 5:39:39 - 5:39:41

5:39:39And we also reading item 7.

Unidentified speaker 5:39:43 - 5:40:00

5:39:43Item 7, document number 2026-134, Authorize water revenue bonds to finance water system capital improvements for an amount sufficient to produce net proceeds of up to $525 million and to refund outstanding water revenue bonds.

Jamie Dunphy 5:40:01 - 5:40:57

5:40:01Colleagues, these items comprise the annual fee and rate ordinances for city-regulated services and a code change to transfer interest from the Portland Clean Energy Fund to the general fund.

5:40:12That last proposal was heard by the PCEF Committee on May 13th, Prior to its hearing in City Council, as is required by City Code 7.07.05— I'm gonna try that again.

5:40:297.07.050.G.

5:40:30Technical staff summaries were given on these items last week in the work session.

5:40:34Staff will be available for questions, but we will not be providing additional presentations.

5:40:37We will hear testimony on these ordinances together.

5:40:41Individuals signed up to testify on multiple items have been deduplicated, but if you wish to speak separately to separate issues, You may request to be added for a second testimony slot by speaking to the clerk.

5:40:53Can we please call, uh, our first panelist testimony?

Unidentified speaker 5:41:00 - 5:41:24

5:41:00First up, and we had a couple cancellations, but I'll go ahead and read the names just to be sure: Jenny Lee, Alan Hipólito, East Columbia Neighborhood Association, Welcome.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:41:24 - 5:41:24

5:41:24Come on up.

Jamie Dunphy 5:41:24 - 5:41:25

5:41:24Thank you very much.

Alice Christine Walker 5:41:28 - 5:43:30

5:41:28Good afternoon again, councilors.

5:41:30Alice Christine Walker for East Columbia Neighborhood Association.

5:41:34Portlanders passed PCEF as a values-based promise for community-led climate resilience.

5:41:41Not a stabilization fund for city bureaus.

5:41:44The budget creep is real.

5:41:45Nearly $8 million in 2024, $19 million in 2025, now $27 million this year.

5:41:53The February auditor's report explicitly warned that this top-down approach destroys community trust.

5:41:59Unfortunately, East Columbia has recently discovered the BES is deploying PCF funds without our neighborhood's involvement or our engagement.

5:42:08Bureau-led PCF programs need structural reform, transparency, and accountability.

5:42:12Councilmember Herbold.

5:42:12Accountability to rebuild this broken trust.

5:42:15Top-down is not working.

5:42:18Communities can stretch $1 to do $5 of work.

5:42:21The city spends $20 on that same $5 task.

5:42:25These PSEF funds can go so much further.

5:42:29We are the ground truth that these funds are not reaching communities in a meaningful way.

5:42:34Access to these funds need to be simplified.

5:42:37Our residents don't even have a sidewalk to safely access our only bus stop.

5:42:41Thank you.

5:42:42Because East Columbia sits outside the current TIF boundaries, PSF is our only safety net to provide our vulnerable environment and the citizens who have historically had— who have historically stewarded it.

5:42:56Before another dollar of interest is redirected to cover these structural deficits, please give our community and other frontline communities like ours a path to yes and the chance to show you all what we the people can achieve with less.

5:43:10Thank you.

5:43:11We hope you will do— we hope you will work with us to find a collaborative path towards true community-led climate justice.

5:43:17We will be submitting a package for your review to provide you all with important additional context for our concerns.

5:43:23We leave here with love for our community, our city, and a question for you all: is East Columbia peace-effable?

5:43:29Thank you all for your time.

Jamie Dunphy 5:43:31 - 5:43:32

5:43:31Thank you very much.

Unidentified speaker 5:43:38 - 5:43:46

5:43:38I don't see any other members in the room or in the Zoom.

5:43:45That concludes testimony.

Jamie Dunphy 5:43:47 - 5:44:13

5:43:47Okay, just pause in case somebody magically appears.

5:43:55Okay, items 2 through 7 will be taken up again on Wednesday morning for council discussion.

5:44:04Diego, can you please call item number 8?

5:44:10Read number—.

5:44:11Item number 8.

Unidentified speaker 5:44:13 - 5:44:18

5:44:13Oh, sorry, I think I misunderstood.

5:44:15I was reading the public testimony just for that first.

Jamie Dunphy 5:44:18 - 5:44:19

5:44:18Oh, that was just for the first item?

Unidentified speaker 5:44:19 - 5:44:20

5:44:19Yes.

Jamie Dunphy 5:44:20 - 5:44:20

5:44:20Oh, I see.

Luis Del Toro 5:44:20 - 5:44:20

5:44:20I'm sorry.

Unidentified speaker 5:44:20 - 5:44:21

5:44:20Sorry about that.

Luis Del Toro 5:44:21 - 5:44:22

5:44:21Okay, thank you.

Unidentified speaker 5:44:23 - 5:45:02

5:44:23That was for document number 2026-158.

5:44:29For 2026-161, we have Brooke Burhanu.

5:44:46Brooke, Brooke, we see you online.

5:44:51Not sure if you can unmute yourself.

5:44:59I also have Luis Del Toro from the previous item.

Brooke Burhanu 5:45:10 - 5:45:15

5:45:10Hello, sorry about that.

5:45:12Um, I'm ready to go whenever you are ready for me.

Nick Sovey 5:45:16 - 5:45:16

5:45:16Yeah, go ahead.

Jamie Dunphy 5:45:17 - 5:45:17

5:45:17Thank you.

Brooke Burhanu 5:45:19 - 5:46:19

5:45:19Thank you.

5:45:20Hello, good afternoon again, council members.

5:45:22Nice to see you all again.

5:45:24Once again, my name is Brooke Burhanu.

5:45:25I'm a voting member of the Portland Utility Board, also known as the PUB, which is the community oversight body for the Portland Water Bureau and the Bureau of Environmental Services.

5:45:34I'm speaking today to emphasize previous testimony for myself and PUB co-chairs, as well as to communicate some of PUB's reasoning on our position related to the rate ordinances, as well as the Bull Run Filtration Project.

5:45:49Bond authorization in a little more detail.

5:45:52Um, first on rate— uh, well, uh, the pub would like to urge council once again to adopt the full 7.5% combined utility rate increase needed to just maintain current service levels, as well as to authorize the $525 million bond towards full-run filtration project.

5:46:10Uh, first on rates, um, pub's rationale is looking at the relatively small difference in rate increase between the proposed budget and the current service level budget.

Luis Del Toro 5:46:19 - 5:46:19

5:46:19Thank you.

Brooke Burhanu 5:46:19 - 5:47:12

5:46:19That results in about $2 per month of savings per household on average.

5:46:24However, when you aggregate that impact up to the utility level, that results in a disproportionate impact to the utility's capacity to both continue its core functions and make up for the time lost from previous delays to the filtration project.

5:46:40Increasing the backlog of deferred maintenance only increases the risk of infrastructure failure and emergency repairs that end up costing more in the long run.

5:46:48And ultimately, those increased costs are borne by ratepayers, if not now, then in the future.

5:46:54The filtration plant project will ensure that Portland is not only able to meet its current regulatory requirements, but will also provide resilience to extreme weather events and natural disasters that are only becoming more frequent due to climate change and will increasingly threaten our water supply for decades into the future.

5:47:10That's all for now.

5:47:11Thank you all for your time.

Jamie Dunphy 5:47:13 - 5:47:13

5:47:13Thank you so much.

Unidentified speaker 5:47:19 - 5:47:20

5:47:19Luis, are you still online?

Luis Del Toro 5:47:21 - 5:47:22

5:47:21Yeah, I'm here.

Unidentified speaker 5:47:22 - 5:47:24

5:47:22You may begin when you're ready.

5:47:24We can hear you.

Luis Del Toro 5:47:25 - 5:49:03

5:47:25Okay, nice.

5:47:26Uh, hi, my name is Luis El Toro.

5:47:27I am a PSF city employee and I'm part of the Agroforestry Canopy Program.

5:47:31I oppose this measure.

5:47:33Uh, for the record, this ordinance has been proposed for 3 consecutive years for a total of $53 million transferred from PSF.

5:47:38Repeating this— repeating these transfers years after years signals the normalization of PSF as an ongoing revenue source for the general fund.

5:47:46I believe that the city needs to explain how there is a meaningful distinction between interest earnings and a tax revenue when both exist solely because voters approved the PSF initiative.

5:47:56I am also wondering if the city has invested in studying the community impacts of diverting these funds away from the climate action.

5:48:02How many additional trees could be planted or maintained with $53 million?

5:48:06How many more Portlanders could receive e-bikes if the city stepped away from a lottery basis?

5:48:10Thank you.

5:48:11How many renters would receive climate resilience upgrades?

5:48:13Portland has hundreds of thousands of aging housing units that are not resilient and extreme— or resilient to extreme heat or cold.

5:48:21While climate initiatives will broadly benefit the public, I am deeply concerned that the city is using PSAP to fund programs that are merely environmentally branded instead of investing in new initiatives that directly serve the low-income communities and communities of color, as PSAP was created to support.

5:48:35Councilmember Sameer Kanal.

5:48:36PSEF's mission is not simply to fund anything environmentally friendly.

5:48:39It's a mission to deliver direct climate and economic benefits to frontline communities.

5:48:44Instead, the city is repeatedly using PSEF to backfill existing legacy programs in order to reduce pressure of the general fund and offset ongoing budget shortfalls.

5:48:52That is deceptive and contrary to the mission voters approved.

5:48:56Uh, I'm running out of time.

5:48:59Uh, please deliver on PSEF in a way that is equitable, accountable, and truly groundbreaking.

Sameer Kanal 5:49:03 - 5:49:04

5:49:03Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 5:49:04 - 5:49:05

5:49:04Thank you so much.

Unidentified speaker 5:49:10 - 5:49:22

5:49:10Next up we have Kim Neal, Shelley Hack, LeJune Thorson, Deanna D'Souza.

Jamie Dunphy 5:49:25 - 5:49:30

5:49:25Welcome up, folks.

5:49:26Please feel free to introduce yourself.

5:49:27You're welcome to share your pronouns, and you have 90 seconds.

Sabina Erdesh 5:49:31 - 5:49:31

5:49:31Thank you.

Kim Neal 5:49:32 - 5:51:18

5:49:32Hi, my name is Kim Neal, and I'm the senior project manager for the construction sector At Work Systems, I have found— I've seen firsthand the impact of pre-apprenticeship programs have on the lives of women and people of color in our community.

5:49:47Before joining Work Systems, I worked over a decade at Oregon Trades Women's Pre-Apprenticeship Training Program as a workforce development coordinator.

5:49:55Pre-apprenticeship programs build confidence and practical skills.

5:49:58Participants learn how to operate power tools and gain hands-on experience working as a crew.

5:50:03As they begin their careers, many Workers need support with tools, transportation, childcare, and childcare.

5:50:09Pre-apprenticeship programs help connect workers to those resources.

5:50:14I have personally seen the life-changing impact these programs have had.

5:50:18I know women who left abusive relationships because they finally made a living wage.

5:50:23I have worked with formerly incarcerated women who entered the trades and ultimately became business owners in construction, all because of the opportunities provided by pre-apprenticeship Thank you.

5:50:34This work changes lives.

5:50:36It strengthens our workforce, expands opportunity, and builds a more inclusive and resilient local economy.

5:50:44I respectfully urge the City Council to act now to restore the COEP Construction Workforce Services funding to $1.46 million in the mayor's budget.

5:50:56The construction industry is cyclical.

5:50:57While we are all in a slow period now, we know projects will move forward.

5:51:02Maintaining funding Protects long-term strategy and ensures Portland is prepared for the next wave of construction and economic opportunity.

5:51:12I'd like to thank Work Systems, COEP, Construction Workforce Partners for their verbal and written testimony this month.

5:51:18Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 5:51:18 - 5:51:19

5:51:18Thank you so much.

Unidentified speaker 5:51:20 - 5:51:35

5:51:20And apologies to our public testifiers and Council President as well.

5:51:24That's actually for the PROSPER budget item, so that does conclude testimony.

5:51:29For this first batch of items.

5:51:31Okay.

5:51:31Apologies to our testifiers.

5:51:33We'll call you back up once, uh, we've reconvened.

Jamie Dunphy 5:51:35 - 5:51:57

5:51:35I got to do a little one-step, two-step.

5:51:37We'll be right back.

5:51:38Thank you.

5:51:39Okay, I'm going to try this again real quick because I, I got a little bit ahead of myself.

5:51:44Colleagues, that concludes testimony on items 2 through 7.

5:51:48These items will be taken up again on Wednesday morning for council discussion.

5:51:54Diego, can you please call item number Read number item number 8.

Unidentified speaker 5:51:59 - 5:52:18

5:51:59Apologies for the wait.

5:52:06Item 8, document number 2026-163, City Council convenes as Prosper Budget Committee to approve the fiscal year 2026-27 budget.

Jamie Dunphy 5:52:19 - 5:52:31

5:52:19Okay, I am now recessing this meeting of the Portland City Council And I am now convening this meeting of the Prosper Portland Budget Committee.

5:52:29Diego, will you please call the roll?

Deanna D'Souza 5:52:37 - 5:52:38

5:52:37Here.

Kim Neal 5:52:41 - 5:52:42

5:52:41Here.

Sameer Kanal 5:52:43 - 5:52:43

5:52:43Here.

Unidentified speaker 5:52:44 - 5:52:46

5:52:44Here.

5:52:46Here.

Sabina Erdesh 5:52:47 - 5:52:47

5:52:47Here.

Brooke Burhanu 5:52:50 - 5:52:50

5:52:50Here.

Unidentified speaker 5:52:51 - 5:52:53

5:52:51Here.

5:52:52Present.

Alice Christine Walker 5:52:55 - 5:52:55

5:52:55Here.

Jamie Dunphy 5:52:57 - 5:54:58

5:52:57Here.

5:52:59The Prosper Portland Budget Committee received the proposed budget and conducted a hearing to receive testimony on April 21st, 2026.

5:53:07The Budget Committee received the approved budget memo and Exhibit A to Resolution 7649 on May 19th, 2026.

5:53:15For those following on the city website, the resolution is posted in our system as Exhibit A, and the exhibit to the resolution is posted as Exhibit B.

5:53:24The approved budget memo and Exhibit A corresponds to the proposed budget received by the Budget Committee on April 20th, 2026, and presented to Prosper Portland staff on April 21st, 2026.

5:53:36Exhibit A to the resolution aligns to the total appropriations included in the approved budget for the city.

5:53:42City of Portland general fund and recreational cannabis tax funds appropriated to Prosper Portland.

5:53:48This week, we will vote to approve the report, which approves Resolution 7649 and Exhibit A. I am now opening a hearing on the Prosper Portland 2026-2027 approved budget.

5:54:00Prior to testimony and debate, I call for a motion to consider and approve the report.

5:54:06So moved.

5:54:07So moved.

5:54:08Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

5:54:09Is there a second?

5:54:12Second.

5:54:13Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

5:54:15Councilors have pre-filed amendments to the city budget that impact the Prosper Portland budget, specifically Avalos 2, Avalos 5, Dunphy 1, Dunphy 3, and Pirtle-Guiney 1.

5:54:25These amendments were posted publicly around 5:30 PM on Friday, May 15th, and communicated to the media and the public.

5:54:31I believe that the community is sufficiently aware of what has been proposed for us to move to public testimony on the approved and its amendments.

5:54:38If any councilor intends to move an altogether new amendment concept or to withdraw a pre-filed amendment, please surface this now so the public can have a chance to respond during testimony.

5:54:52Okay, Diego, can we please call our panel of testifiers on the Prosper Portland budget?

Unidentified speaker 5:54:59 - 5:55:13

5:54:59Yes, we just heard from Kim Neal earlier.

5:55:01Next Welcome.

Jamie Dunphy 5:55:14 - 5:55:15

5:55:14Take it away.

5:55:14Welcome back.

Kim Neal 5:55:15 - 5:55:15

5:55:15Thank you.

Shelley Hack 5:55:17 - 5:56:22

5:55:17Good afternoon, President— Council President Dunphy, council members.

5:55:22My name is Shelley Hack, and I'm the president of AFSCME Local 3769, which represents the staff of— the represented staff of Prosper Portland.

5:55:31As the union highlighted Uh, during the presentation of the mayor's proposed budget last month, Prosper has implemented a 10% reduction in force in alignment with that budget.

5:55:4510% Of our, our staff will no longer be with us as of June 30th.

5:55:50That percentage of reduction is far greater than what we're seeing in other city bureaus.

5:55:55Um, so what, uh, as you move through your deliberation on the proposed amendment, I and my members ask that you ensure that the amendments do not have further further impacts on represented staff.

5:56:09And, uh, if you do find that they might have impacts, that you reach out to me or my, my vice president to, to discuss those, those cuts and the implications and impacts on represented staff.

Sabina Erdesh 5:56:23 - 5:56:23

5:56:23Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 5:56:23 - 5:56:33

5:56:23Thank you so much.

5:56:30Yeah, go ahead.

5:56:31Waiting for the little timer.

5:56:33Just jump in, you're good.

Deanna D'Souza 5:56:35 - 5:58:03

5:56:35Good afternoon, mayors and city councilors.

5:56:37Thank you for your continued support of workforce development programs during an incredibly challenging budget season.

5:56:42My name is Deanna D'Souza, and I'm the community programs manager at Work Systems.

5:56:46I'm here representing Portland Economic Opportunity Program, known as Portland EOP, which is funded through Prosper Portland for more than 10 years.

5:56:54We partner with Central City Concern, ERCO, Our Just Future, Southeast Works, and Trash for Peace to connect residents facing barriers to employment with career coaching, training, and support services that help move them from crisis to stability.

5:57:06Last year alone, Portland EOP served 620 participants.

5:57:10Many were navigating poverty, housing instability, prior justice involvement, recovery, or are immigrants and refugees.

5:57:17Through long-term coaching and wraparound supports, 85% exited the program with employment.

5:57:22This work is especially critical right now.

5:57:24The recent State of the Economy report shows our region has one of the steepest job losses among major metro areas in the country, and income in Multnomah County have declined most sharply for lower-income households.

5:57:36In moments like this, workforce investments are not optional.

5:57:39They are part of the solution to economic recovery and are essential to assuring residents with barriers are not left behind.

5:57:46Portland EOP helps Portlanders find jobs, supports local businesses in finding workers, and strengthens the economic stability of our community.

5:57:53I respectfully urge City Council to protect the workforce investments and avoid the additional cuts proposed in the amendments before you today.

5:57:59Thank you.

5:58:00Thank you for your leadership and commitment to an inclusive and equitable Portland.

Jamie Dunphy 5:58:04 - 5:58:04

5:58:04Thank you very much.

Unidentified speaker 5:58:10 - 5:58:31

5:58:10See, next we have Nick Sabi, Leisha Shrestha, Nicole Leone, Amanda Reese, Um, uh, good afternoon.

Nick Sovey 5:58:31 - 6:00:35

5:58:31Uh, my name is Nick Sovey.

5:58:33I'm the co-executive director of Rose Community Development, and, um, thank you all for your service to the city and the Portland community.

5:58:42I encourage City Council to demand accountability from Prosper Portland as you oversee the city's economic development budget.

5:58:50After 20 years and $200 million spent in the Lents Urban Renewal Area, the auditor found that the median income in Lents declined by 24%.

5:59:00Poverty was up, housing affordability was down, as was the BIPOC homeownership rate.

5:59:07In 2020, a city auditor's report recommended that Prosper Portland set economic goals for their investments and report regularly to the public.

5:59:16Prosper's response to the auditor was, nah, we're gonna just keep doing what we're doing.

5:59:22Just this year, Prosper gave away $10 million in one of the largest city-owned parcels in Portland to a for-profit Only 9 of the 171 proposed units are rent-restricted affordable housing.

5:59:36More than 80% of the units are one-bedrooms, despite the known glut of one-bedroom units on the market.

5:59:44Prosper has done no public engagement in Lents since 2018.

5:59:50Worst of all, Prosper bought the property in 2000.

5:59:54That parcel could have provided desperately needed affordable housing for decades.

5:59:59Instead, it sits gathering weeds.

6:00:03The budgets for the 3 new urban renewal areas in East Portland total $1.5 billion.

6:00:09About 25% of that will go to Prosper staff and overhead and Portland Housing Bureau staff, nearly $400 million.

6:00:19Community-based organizations serving East Portland are starved for resources while Prosper for, um, sits on hundreds of millions of dollars.

6:00:28Um, stronger city council oversight is needed, or we'll see the same sad story repeated elsewhere in East Portland.

6:00:35Um, thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 6:00:36 - 6:00:41

6:00:36Thank you so much.

6:00:40Hi, me please.

Shelley Hack 6:00:42 - 6:00:42

6:00:42Okay.

Amanda Reese 6:00:43 - 6:02:36

6:00:43Hi, um, my name's Amanda Reese.

6:00:44I am with District 1, and, um, I'm here this evening on behalf of Portland Economic Opportunity Program with Trash for Peace.

6:00:55These are organizations that truly change lives.

6:00:58I want to share a little of my personal story.

6:01:01I came from homelessness, suffering from addiction, and for a long time I felt stuck and unsure of my life and if I could really change.

6:01:10I did not want that story— that to be my story.

6:01:13I wanted stability, purpose, and a chance to build a better future for myself.

6:01:18These programs gave me that chance.

6:01:21They do much more than help others find jobs.

6:01:23They help people become employment ready.

6:01:26They build and help them believe themselves again.

6:01:29They help with resumes, career planning, confidence building, goal setting, interview preparation, and even provide clothing for interviews and appropriate work clothes once you get hired.

6:01:41They also help provide laptops and other tools.

6:01:44Thank you.

6:01:45For people, for people to be successful in today's workforce.

6:01:49For many people, especially those facing barriers to employment or housing instability, these things can make a difference between staying stuck and moving forward.

6:01:58Because of their support, I am now working for an organization called Cascadia Clusters, an organization that also helps men and women in recovery and getting work and employment and, and as well as housing.

6:02:12What means even more to me is their support did not stop once I got this job.

6:02:16After I started working, they continued helping me with things like transportation, clothing, and even moral support when I needed encouragement.

6:02:24Having people who continue to stand beside you while building stability and confidence makes a huge difference.

6:02:30I ask that you continue supporting these programs like Portland Economic Opportunity Program with Trash for Peace.

6:02:36Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 6:02:41 - 6:02:44

6:02:41Thank you so much for being here.

Unidentified speaker 6:02:48 - 6:02:50

6:02:48I see we have Sabina online.

Sabina Erdesh 6:02:53 - 6:04:26

6:02:53Good afternoon, Mayor Wilson and councilors.

6:02:55My name is Sabina Erdesh.

6:02:56I live in Lents, District 1, and I'm speaking on behalf of Thrive East PDX.

6:03:01I want to speak directly about Prosper Portland's budget and the growing frustration many of us feel watching Prosper continue to receive massive public investment while East Portland continues to see delayed projects, broken promises, and little measurable progress.

6:03:15For years, Prosper has come to our communities asking for engagement, feedback, and trust, but too often what follows is delay after delay.

6:03:22The 92nd and Herald side, just down the street from me, has sat empty for decades, uh, despite multiple planning processes and developer awards.

6:03:31The Lents Town Center still struggles with vacancy and unrealized promises.

6:03:35Gateway continues to lose grocery stores and commercial activity while residents face increasing food insecurity.

6:03:41At the same time, Prosper eliminated support for business associations, leaving East Portland with only 2, 2 serving 15 neighborhoods.

6:03:48Now we are hearing proposals that threaten neighborhood prosperity networks and community-based organizations that are actual lifelines for immigrant and refugee communities, including Historic Parkrose, Division Midway Alliance, and Rosewood.

6:04:01Equity does not mean treating every part of Portland the same.

6:04:04East Portland has historically received less Before applying for more funding, we are asking for accountability, clear project timelines, measurable outcomes, public reporting on where dollars are going, and protections for NPNs and community-based organizations.

6:04:22Our communities deserve investment that we can actually see and count on.

6:04:26Thank you.

Jamie Dunphy 6:04:28 - 6:04:28

6:04:28Thank you so much.

Unidentified speaker 6:04:32 - 6:04:37

6:04:32We have Javier online.

6:04:33Javier, if you could unmute yourself.

6:04:35Accept the unmute request and begin when you're ready.

Sameer Kanal 6:04:41 - 6:06:07

6:04:41Hi.

6:04:43Hi, we can hear you.

6:04:45Hi.

6:04:45Um, so I'm Xavier Perry, and I am a 10-year veteran of the United States Army.

6:04:51I was in special operations, and I was a paratrooper.

6:04:54And recently I became a father.

6:04:57I became a, um, a single parent of a 6-year-old little girl, and, um, the Portland Economic and Opportunity Program with Trash for Peace have been helping my daughter and I throughout my process.

6:05:11I went back to school and became a medical assistant, and my daughter is thriving right now.

6:05:16And Midori, uh, Midori Hirose has been helping her and I, uh, benefit throughout this time.

6:05:23Uh, it's been a struggle, but with the help of, uh, the help of Trash for Peace Been able to get things that we've needed.

6:05:30And also, she's also helped us in areas like, uh, getting me an e-bike for my daughter and I to commute back and forth to school.

6:05:39And also, they helped us with the move to our new home that we have.

6:05:43And I really appreciate everything that they've done for us.

6:05:46So I hope that you will continue to offer them funding.

6:05:50And this is something that is desperately needed, especially for Disabled veterans like myself.

6:05:55So I urge you to assist them, and I would, I would tell you that they do a dynamic job when it comes down to helping people in need.

6:06:05That's all I have to say.

6:06:06Thank you for your time.

Jamie Dunphy 6:06:08 - 6:06:08

6:06:08Thank you so much.

Unidentified speaker 6:06:12 - 6:06:45

6:06:12Next we have Nahila Osborne, Vivian Lackey, Sarah I'm so sorry to interrupt, Nehaila.

6:06:33Uh, you're coming in a bit muffled.

6:06:35I'm not sure we can hear you.

6:06:44It's still muffled.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 6:06:45 - 6:08:03

6:06:45I'm not sure if Okay, good afternoon, City Council.

6:06:53My name is Nahila Osborne.

6:06:55I am a participant speaking on behalf of the Career Service Portland Economic Opportunity Program with Trash for Peace.

6:07:03As a mother of 3, being the only income in my household isn't always easy.

6:07:09Trash for Peace not only helped me maintain housing needs, but also provided me with a sense of purpose.

6:07:12Thank you.

6:07:12They create a peace of mind while I build foundation for my family, including aiding me with the support needed to apply for nursing school, tutoring, as well as financial scholarships for the first few terms.

6:07:26It wasn't easy pivoting from one career to another.

6:07:29However, with their help, I felt reassured.

6:07:33I am requesting that you continue funding this program for the sake of the families willing to better their future while maintaining the safety and the stability in their homes.

6:07:43My family and I are greatly appreciative for the opportunities and the ongoing support they provide— provide, excuse me.

6:07:50Special thanks to Midori Hyros for her accountability and reminder that no matter the circumstance, I have everything it takes to succeed.

6:07:59I appreciate your consideration and your time.

Jamie Dunphy 6:08:03 - 6:08:03

6:08:03Thank you so much.

Nick Sovey 6:08:09 - 6:08:09

6:08:09No?

Unidentified speaker 6:08:09 - 6:08:10

6:08:09Okay.

Vivian Lackey 6:08:10 - 6:09:47

6:08:10My name is Vivian Lackey.

6:08:12I work at the Employment Access Center for Central City Concern, and I'm back here today to voice the importance of funding the construction program community— Community Opportunity Economic Program.

6:08:29We partner with Work systems to live— to deliver workforce career coaching to our clients.

6:08:36The majority is women and people of color.

6:08:39We support them during pre-apprenticeship and other construction industry training programs.

6:08:45Most of these training courses do not come with a stipend or a wage during that time.

6:08:51They do not come with financial aid, and like— unlike a full-time college student may have access to.

6:08:59Our career coaches ensure that they have proper clothing and tools during training.

6:09:04This support includes access to funds for utilities, phones, child care, transportation, and sometimes rental assistance.

6:09:14This supports them to graduate and be placed into a living wage career.

6:09:19We support clients enrolled in community partnerships Oregon Tradeswomen, Constructing Hope, Portland Community College, and other trainings like CDL truck driving.

6:09:30The construction industry is attractive to our clients due to low barriers and living wage jobs.

6:09:37This is an important sector that needs our support for clients who may not be able to attend longer-term educational goals and are interested in the trades.

Jamie Dunphy 6:09:47 - 6:09:52

6:09:47Thank you for your time and Thank you so much for being here.

Unidentified speaker 6:09:54 - 6:09:57

6:09:54David is online.

6:09:55Feel free to begin, unmute and begin when you're ready.

David Rodriguez 6:09:58 - 6:11:24

6:09:58Good afternoon, distinguished panel of judges.

6:10:00Clap once if you can hear me.

6:10:04No movement.

6:10:05Okay, clap twice if you're gonna help fund Foster, uh, Prosper Portland.

6:10:09Uh, okay, my name is David Rodriguez and I'm a career coach with Our Just Future.

6:10:14Today I'm here to share The real success stories I've witnessed firsthand throughout my journey as a career coach.

6:10:19For nearly 4 years, I have dedicated myself to helping individuals access life-changing employment opportunities, and I can confidently say the results speak for themselves.

6:10:28Through this program, we have helped graduate 6 CDL holders who are now driving cross-country, 7 medical assistants, 5 medical interpreters and counting, 1 human resource director who will— who, if this program is not funded, I may need to call personally.

6:10:42I'm just saying.

6:10:446 Teachers assistants and counting, 14 administrative assistants, 2 Sun School community partners, 16 hospitality workers and supervisors, and 14 GED graduates.

6:10:54These are not just numbers.

6:10:56These are lives transformed, families supported, and futures rebuilt.

6:11:00Thanks to Work System and Our Just Future, I have the opportunity to continue sharing my passion, faith, and confidence with every member of our community.

6:11:09I said it last year and I will say it proudly again this year.

6:11:11We're not asking for a handout.

6:11:13We're asking for your hand and support to continue this dream.

6:11:16Thank you for your time, your consideration, and your commitment to our community.

6:11:20There are 10 seconds left.

6:11:21I'm open for questioning.

6:11:22I'm just letting you know I'm out.

Jamie Dunphy 6:11:24 - 6:12:45

6:11:24Have a good day, everybody.

6:11:28Thank you very much.

6:11:36I believe that concludes testimony.

6:11:38Okay, just pausing for a second to see if anybody else in the room got— was hoping to speak.

6:11:45Okay, okay, with the conclusion of, uh, our signed-up testifiers, public testimony on the Prosper Portland budget is now closed.

6:11:57I am now recessing this hearing of the Prosper Portland Budget Committee.

6:12:02Item 8, the Prosper budget, will be taken up again tomorrow afternoon.

6:12:08And now the Portland City Council returns from recess.

6:12:16Colleagues, the time is now 3:40.

6:12:19We have concluded all of our testimony for the day.

6:12:22Uh, we are now done for the day.

6:12:24We will return tomorrow to take up amendments to the city budget in the morning and again in the afternoon And we will take up amendments to the Prosper budget in the afternoon.

6:12:34I now place this meeting of the City Council in recess to reconvene at 9:30 AM tomorrow morning, May 19th, 2026.

6:12:44We'll see you all tomorrow.