Transcript
Automatically generated transcript. It may contain errors and includes testimony in languages other than English that is not individually marked up for assistive technology.
Keelan McClymont
Captions test.
Jamie Dunphy
Good evening.
I now call this meeting of the City Council to order.
Keelan, can you please call the roll?
Keelan McClymont
Avalos.
Candace Avalos
Present.
Olivia Clark
Aye.
Dan Ryan
Aye.
Elana Pirtle-Guiney
Aye.
Angelita Morillo
Here.
Here.
Keelan McClymont
Murillo.
Angelita Morillo
Here.
Keelan McClymont
Novick.
Steve Novick
Here.
Keelan McClymont
Clark.
Olivia Clark
Here.
Keelan McClymont
Green.
Mitch Green
Here.
Keelan McClymont
Zimmerman.
Eric Zimmerman
Here.
Keelan McClymont
Dunphy.
Jamie Dunphy
Here.
And Mr. Porter, could you please read the rules of decorum?
Keelan McClymont
Welcome to the Portland City Council.
To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.
Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.
Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.
Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.
The presiding officer preserves order.
Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.
If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.
Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.
Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.
Thank you, Councilor Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.
Your testimony should address the matter being considered.
When testifying, state your name for the record.
Your address is not necessary.
If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.
Unidentified speaker
Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when council clerk calls your name.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
And, uh, colleagues, before we move to, uh, item 1, which is agenda approval, I'm going to take a moment of privilege and turn the, uh, microphone over to my new vice president, Councilor Clark, to say a couple of The opening of our first full council meeting.
Olivia Clark
Thank you, Council President Dunphy.
I appreciate this.
Colleagues, I woke up this morning feeling a little blue.
Don't worry, I'm, I'm better now.
But I wanted to share a reflection with all of you really about the times that we're living in and what is happening all around us.
We just experienced the first year of the Trump administration and what would have been the 97th birthday of Martin Luther King.
But I wanted to reflect very briefly on the responsibility that we have for our city in the midst of the challenges that we confront.
This really hit home for me with the shooting of the 2 immigrants by federal agents in Portland, what, about 2 weeks ago?
Yes.
Right after the murder of Renee Goode in Minneapolis, and then again this week with the shooting of 2 of our city employees, both police officers in the line of duty.
Colleagues, I, I feel there are forces swirling above us and around us that we don't control, but they have a deep impact on us, on all of us and the people in our community.
And I just wanted to call this out today or tonight.
And I know I can only speak for myself, but I believe we are all feeling it and we're all coping in our own ways.
And in addition to what's coming at us from Washington, D.C. or, or other parts, we have our own challenges guiding the city through a difficult budget and many pressing issues in partnership with the mayor and the city manager.
I have faith that we will rise to the challenge And feel the full measure of our responsibility to the entire city.
My desire, my ask in bringing this reflection to you tonight is that we don't take these pressures, internal or external, that we don't take these pressures out on each other, and that we move forward with respect and kindness towards one another.
Thank you.
Thank you, Councilor.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Vice President Clark.
Um, that moves us to item 1, which is our agenda approval.
Um, at the beginning, I'd like to make a note on our agenda update.
Um, I— we've added an update on the implementation of Resolution 37730, the council strategic priority setting.
I'll be inviting City Administrator Lee and the resolution co-sponsors, Councilors Ryan and Koyama Lane, to offer updates and comments, but we'll take this after the City Administrator's report.
Are there any concerns with that?
Unidentified speaker
No.
No?
Jamie Dunphy
Are there any requests to amend the agenda, to reorder items, or to reschedule an item to a future meeting date?
Do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?
Lots of nods.
Great.
The agenda is approved.
Keelan, can we please call public communications?
Keelan McClymont
First up, we have Holly Brown.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, thank you for being here.
Holly Brown
Uh, can I start?
Yeah.
Okay.
On September 17th, 2025, after months of public pressure, the City of Portland issued a land use violation to the Portland Ice facility for violating the human It is now January 21st, 2026, and the city has yet to even collect fines for the violation of the conditional use permit by ICE.
In the 4 months since the land use violation was issued, Portland experienced a surge in ICE raids with a minimum of 380 detentions occurring in November 2025 alone.
The National Guard was deployed to Portland to protect the ICE facility, as they say, and just a couple weeks ago, the city issued an emergency order to Renee Goode was murdered by ICE in Minneapolis, and 2 Portlanders were shot by Border Patrol the very next day.
How many more lives need to be lost or destroyed for City Council and the mayor to treat this like the emergency that it is?
I am here today to call upon the mayor and Portland City Council to do your jobs, step up, and protect Portlanders like you are sworn to do, and to put forth immediate emergency legislation to revoke the permit for the Portland ICE facility and shut it down.
Thank you.
We do not accept your excuses.
We do not accept silence, and we do not accept inaction.
Most of you on council have remained completely silent about this issue, and shame on you.
Others have told us repeatedly that there is nothing you can do, that at the advice of the city attorney, who I'm glad is here today, you must remain silent on the issue and just let the situation play out through the undemocratic and lengthy permitting and development process.
Councilmember I want to say very clearly to City Council, the people did not elect the city attorney.
The position exists to protect the city from lawsuits, not to protect the people from harm.
In the time I have been politically active, I have repeatedly seen city attorneys act in the interests of wealthy and powerful people and attempt to stifle the people's movements.
When you turn up your nose at the movement and tell us over and over that you won't do what the community asks of you at the direction of highly paid lawyers who likely don't even live in the neighborhoods that are under attack by ICE, You make it very clear who you stand with.
I'm not sure what more needs to happen to convince City Council and the mayor to start using legislative and administrative power to actually do something real to combat ICE and Trump.
ICE is terrorizing Portland out of a home base that was approved by City Council in 2011.
This process happened in just 7 months, the approval of the facility.
We're now on month 4 since a land use violation was issued and the process to begin revoking the permit for the facility.
Councilor Smith.
Many of you have the nerve to say abolish ICE but won't even do the bare minimum when it comes to kicking ICE out of Portland.
Until those words are paired with action, they are nothing more than that.
They're just words.
To City Council, you have legislative power.
The ICE facility is privately owned.
You must and have to put forth immediate legislation to shut down the ICE facility and to prevent any other facilities like this from being created.
Councilmember Herbold.
We are depending on you.
Lives are at stake.
There's nothing more important that is happening in Portland and across the country right now.
Revoke the ICE permit and shut the Portland ICE facility down.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you for being here.
And folks, I appreciate the enthusiasm.
I appreciate the support of our testimony.
But please remember, we ask not to applaud in here.
We are happy to Uh, jazz hands or other expressions of, uh, approval.
I appreciate the community showing, but please, thank you.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Casey DeSantis.
Jamie Dunphy
Welcome, Casey.
Casey DeSantis
Hello, Council.
Uh, today I sit in front of you at 120 days since the notice of land use violation was handed down to the Portland Ice facility.
In the latest update posted to Portland City website, Since the closure of the site on January 9th, we have been told that there is no timeline to see action, and it has been 120 days and no fines have been collected on the original violation either.
In these 120 days, we have seen ICE operations not only continue but ramp up in the Portland metro area, with the McAdam ICE facility serving as the hub for ICE agents and many other federal agencies.
2 Weeks ago, Renee Nicole Goode was killed by ICE agents in Minneapolis while exercising her rights to protest in free speech.
When this happens, we can very easily make the connection that it could have happened here to any community member that does MigraWatch, Adopt-a-Corner action, or hands out Know Your Rights information or whistle kits.
It has been made very clear by comments from PPB officers that anyone who dares to stand up to ICE are deemed criminals and can get shot as a result.
One day after Good was killed in Minneapolis, 2 immigrants were shot by Border Patrol agents here in Portland.
Portland City Council, this legislative body needs to be treating this like the emergency situation that it is.
We have killer ICE in our streets and members of Portland's own police force that agree with their actions.
This is a public safety emergency.
With this, I urge the City Council to pass emergency legislation that shuts down the McAdam ICE facility or ceases their operations at the very least.
Move approval.
We cannot afford to have a hub for ICE and federal agents For more than 120 days, we have been begging this council for substantial action regarding the ICE facility, anything that can affect its operations in a real way.
What we have received are councilors who make double or triple our salaries talking down to and patronizing us.
We have been told by councilors that your hands are tied.
And while I love the idea of progressive councilors in office, I have been profoundly disappointed at how you have been seemingly You and I know that change does not occur by playing by the rules of a broken system or even merely throwing sand in its gears, but by being bold in change and fighting back.
I direct my next comments towards Mayor Wilson, who I see is absent yet again for a public comment.
So Mayor Wilson, it must be really hard to properly respond to this emergency situation when you're also busy being a CEO of your company.
I am not a CEO.
We have been told by multiple councilors that this is in your hands and you hold the power to push this along.
So while over 18,000 people have signed the petition to revoke the ICE permit for the facility, while we have sent thousands of emails to your office and met with other councilors regarding this matter, your office has not responded to any of our requests to meet with us.
We have sought you out in public and at other meetings trying to have this conversation.
And, you know, your position aligns more with landlord Stuart Lindquist than those of working Portlanders affected by your inaction.
Councilwoman Pirtle-Guiney, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
Jamie Dunphy
Again, folks, I am sorry, I have to ask to please not cheer and clap.
Casey DeSantis
I—.
Jamie Dunphy
We have rules in this committee, in this chamber, and we have to show our support in, uh, other ways.
I apologize.
Thank you.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Nancy Moreno-Waden.
Unidentified speaker
Thanks for being here.
Hello.
Nancy Moreno-Waden
All right, this is my first time doing this, so I'm nervous.
My name is Nancy Moreno-Waden, and I am here as a concerned citizen, as a member of Portland Contra las Deportaciones.
I want to start by saying that our community deserves better.
City Council, Mayor Keith Wilson, and Governor Tina Kotek keep saying they oppose ICE violence.
They issue statements, they express concern, and they say the right words.
But when— but when it comes to action, there is no urgency.
Thank you.
None.
Our community members are getting hurt because of it.
2 Of our community members were shot just recently, shot over civil matters.
Immigration violations are not crimes.
Being undocumented is not a crime.
Yet these ICE terrorists are using military-style force on our streets while our elected leaders stand by and watch.
Thank you.
Mayor Wilson himself said after our community members were shot, he says our community deserves answers and our community deserves peace.
City Council says ICE's actions are unnecessary and unjustified and potentially unconstitutional.
Governor Kotek has said federal immigration tactics foster lawlessness and recklessness.
These are their words.
But where is their action?
Right now, we already know that the ICE facility on McAdam has violated its permit by detaining people overnight and holding them longer than allowed.
A sanctuary city should never allow that.
City Council keeps saying there's nothing they can do, but there's— that just sounds like a cop-out.
They have the tools.
And they're simply not using them.
If Oregon calls itself a sanctuary state, then it must actually protect people, not with statements, not with sympathy, but with action.
Shut down the McAdam facility and protect our community now, because no one should be shot by these violent ICE goons over a civil matter.
No one should be detained in an illegal facility, and no one should die in ICE custody Thank you for being here.
Keelan McClymont
Uh, next—.
Jamie Dunphy
And again, folks, sorry, please, I appreciate the support we're showing our speakers, and I have rules I have to enforce.
Thank you.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Cole Donahue.
Holly Brown
Welcome, Cole.
Cole Donahue
My intent today was to speak directly to Mayor Keith Wilson, but unsurprisingly, he has once again refused to talk to his own constituents about ICE and the threat they pose in Portland.
It has been 126 days since Permitting and Development found that ICE's facility on McAdam is in violation of its conditional use permit, And since then, there has been zero movement towards revoking the permit, with ICE kidnapping and brutalizing hundreds and hundreds of Portlanders since this notice of violation was issued.
This has all happened under Keith Wilson's watch as someone with direct control over permitting and development.
The Revoke the ICE Permit campaign has sent Wilson's office well over 1,000 emails demanding to meet with him and for him to provide a detailed plan for how he is going to kick ICE out of the city he was elected to represent.
Thank you.
He has never responded.
Myself and other organizers with the campaign went to his office on January 8th, the day after ICE murdered Renee Nicole Goode, to demand a meeting with him.
We did not get a meeting that day because Border Patrol attempted to murder 2 Portlanders, and we needed to respond to that crisis because we knew the mayor would do nothing.
He would do nothing but send thoughts and prayers.
We are still demanding that meeting with him, and we are still demanding for the immediate revocation of ICE's permit to operate the facility.
Councilmember facility here.
We are also demanding that the City Council assembled here today, although some of them could not bother to come to work today, to start putting in the work to kick ICE out.
Every single time you all meet with the mayor, you should be demanding that he hold a town hall to listen to his own constituents about how ICE is affecting them.
You should be demanding that he do more than just spew empty rhetoric and instead take real action.
You should be demanding that he revokes the ICE permit.
I yield.
Additionally, you all should be bringing forth legislation to shut it down on your own.
We will not accept you throwing your hands in the air and saying there's nothing you can do.
You are Portland's legislative body, and you should start acting like it.
We don't have time to wait.
This is an emergency, and we need action to end this emergency as soon as possible.
Just a few minutes ago, Councilor Clark dared to invoke the names of Renee Nicole Goode and the 2 Portlanders that were shot by Border Patrol, and yet she refuses to take any action to revoke the permit.
Shame on you.
Councilor Dan Ryan.
Unidentified speaker
James!
Cole Donahue
James!
Unidentified speaker
James!
Cole Donahue
Until the permit is revoked, until ICE— as long as ICE has a home base in this city that they use to terrorize thousands and thousands of Portlanders, we will not allow business as usual.
Because outside the walls of this City Hall, we have not had business as usual for a very long time.
Revoke the permit immediately.
Yes!
Unidentified speaker
Thank you for being there.
Jamie Dunphy
And again, folks, I will remind— I know you're doing it on purpose, but I have to do a job regardless.
Please remember that we have rules of decorum where we express our support without clapping.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Chris Olson.
Chris Olson
Good evening, Council.
Hey, how's it going?
All right, well, good evening, Council President Dunphy and councilors.
Uh, first, I want to congratulate you, Councilor Dunphy, for your election.
I look forward to the next year of your leadership.
I really do.
For the record, my name is Chris Olson, and I'm a resident of District 2, and most of you know me for my work with the Portland DSA, but I'm not speaking for the chapter at this time.
I'm speaking as a proud resident of the city for the last 5 years who wants to see everyone being treated with the dignity and respect that they deserve.
I wanna talk about what I can best describe as the disgraceful racist comments made last week during the presidential election in these chambers.
In particular, I will focus on the white members of this council in my comments.
To the BIPOC members, I want you to know that I approach this topic with humility, and I may not say the right things, and maybe my criticism doesn't go far enough for you.
As a white man committed to anti-racist practices, I'm open to correction and criticism myself.
I'm extremely disappointed by the lack or minimal response to the racist comments by Brian Orendoff and others in the council.
Group chat shown at the Portland Mercury last week, particularly Councilors Clark, Novick, Ryan, and Zimmerman.
I saw no written condemnation of their comments on their social media.
Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, I appreciate your statement, but honestly, I did expect a stronger condemnation for someone who represents District 2 and who has had a history of racist land use policies that came from real estate developers like Brian Owen Doff.
It's no surprise that all the councilors I mentioned were endorsed by the Portland Metro Chamber, of which Owen Doff has been a member for many years.
The Portland Metro Chamber also failed to issue any statement condemning the remarks of a prominent individual associated with their organization.
Clearly, many of the white councilors here are putting the interests of a racist real estate developer over those of the people of color in their districts.
Your lack of serious comment on the matter means you are too cowardly to say anything for the fear of losing the support of Owen Doff and the group, those in his group chat.
Since we are remembering Martin Luther King Jr. this week, let me read my favorite passage from his Letter from Birmingham Jail.
A message for the more moderate members of this council.
I must make 2 honest confessions to you.
First, I must confess that over the past few years, I have been gravely disappointed by the white moderate, and I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro's great stumbling block in his stride towards freedom is not the White Citizens' Councilor or the Ku Klux Klaner, but the white moderate who is more devoted to order than to justice, who prefers a negative peace, which is the absence of tension, to a positive peace, which is the presence of justice, who continually says I agree with you on the goal you seek, but I cannot agree with your methods of direct action.
Who paternalistically believes that he can set the timetable for another man's freedom, who lives by the mythical concept of time, who constantly advises the Negro to wait for a more convenient season.
A shallow understanding from people of goodwill is more frustrating than an absolute misunderstanding from people of ill will.
Lukewarm acceptance is much more bewildering than outright rejection.
Second.
It's not enough to just not be racist these days, but you must be anti-racist.
You must do better and condemn any racist language with the strongest language possible.
And I'm very disappointed by some of you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Verena.
Keelan McClymont
That completes communications.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you very much.
Colleagues, 3rd item on our agenda is committee referral reports.
It is posted online.
You all can read it.
I'm not going to try and read it very quickly.
Many things have been referred to committees.
Some have already gotten heard.
Take a look online and they will have a hearing in a committee near you.
Thank you.
Moving on to item 4.
Can we please call item 4?
Keelan McClymont
Annex—.
Casey DeSantis
Revoke the permit!
Revoke the permit!
Jamie Dunphy
This is considered disruptive conduct.
This is a warning that if there is continued or otherwise disruption of this meeting, we will be facing ejection from this meeting.
Sir, this is a disruption, and I'm asking you to please return to your chair.
This is a council disruption.
Security, I'd like you to please have this gentleman removed from our council chambers.
This is a disruption, and if it does continue, I will be clearing the chamber.
Council is going to move to a 2-minute recess.
Keelan McClymont
Christina, can you hear me?
Hey, Keelan, I can hear you.
Perfect, thank you.
Tracy Warren
Sure.
Raymond C. Lee
Good evening, folks.
Jamie Dunphy
We are starting to reconvene here.
If anybody who has signed up to testify, as we are reconvening virtually, has not received a link to log in to testify, please do let us know.
You can email council.clerk@portlandoregon.gov to get an additional link.
So, Councilor Dan Ryan.
Sent to you, or find some other way to let us know that you haven't gotten your link, and we will try to get you to testify.
If folks who are signed up to testify are still in the building, we have opened the Lovejoy Room, and Lovejoy will still accept public testimony where you can come speak to us directly.
So, and as councilors are logging on, we will give it just one more minute before we start again.
Thank you.
Everyone has very different quality of cameras.
Candace Avalos
They should all be the same, bro.
They're not.
Raymond C. Lee
Oh, fun.
Jamie Dunphy
And I can't hear anything.
Raymond C. Lee
Sorry, hold on a sec.
Candace Avalos
Councilor Can you hear us now, Jamie?
No, I can't hear you.
Jamie Dunphy
Okay, are we ready to go?
I am reconvening this meeting of the Portland City Council virtually.
Uh, Keelan, can you please call item 4?
Keelan McClymont
Yes, just a moment.
Can you hear me okay, Council President?
Yeah, okay, great.
Thank you.
Item 4, annex the—.
Jamie Dunphy
You're on mute.
I can't hear you.
Keelan McClymont
Are others having trouble hearing me?
Candace Avalos
I can hear you.
Loretta Smith
Councilor—.
Jamie Dunphy
Apologies to everybody who is watching at home as we are exploring this technology.
We're gonna try this again.
Keelan McClymont
All right, can you hear me now?
Raymond C. Lee
We still can't hear.
I still can't hear anybody, so let us move over to this.
Donnie Oliveira
Hey, Keelan, do you mind, uh, giving us a test?
Keelan McClymont
Yep.
Can you hear me now?
Raymond C. Lee
Okay, thank you.
Sameer Kanal
Keelan's on mute still.
Jamie Dunphy
Oh, she's through the main one.
Sameer Kanal
Yes, I see.
Donnie Oliveira
Okay, one more time.
Keelan McClymont
Oh, sorry.
Can you hear me now?
Does that work?
Donnie Oliveira
Okay, one more time.
Tracy Warren
Hey, Adam, I think we're seeing energy.
Jamie Dunphy
Perfect.
Raymond C. Lee
You can hear me?
Tracy Warren
Okay, great.
Raymond C. Lee
Okay, we have audio.
Donnie Oliveira
Uh, we are ready to, uh, we are ready to go here.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Adam.
Sincere apologies, colleagues.
I think if folks can hear me and I can hear you, we are ready to go.
And Keelan, I'm still not here.
Wait, okay, go ahead.
Keelan McClymont
Can you hear me now, Council President?
Jamie Dunphy
Yeah, there we go.
Technology.
Thank you so much for everybody.
Keelan McClymont
All right, uh, item 4, annex the 5048 Southwest Hilltop Lane property.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, colleagues.
This is the second reading of an ordinance.
Uh, is there any discussion on this item?
Not seeing any hands.
Keelan, could you please call the roll?
Tracy Warren
Oh, sorry, we're addressing some technical issues.
Keelan McClymont
Avalos?
Aye.
Smith?
Councilor Smith?
Okay, uh, Kanal?
Yes.
Aye.
Aye.
Aye.
Aye.
Olivia Clark
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Aye.
Raymond C. Lee
Aye.
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Councilor Council Aye.
The ordinance passes with 11 yes votes and 1 absent.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you very much.
If City Administrator Lee is ready, we're ready to call item number 5.
Raymond C. Lee
Trying to unmute myself.
There we go.
Can you hear me?
Keelan McClymont
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Keelan, uh, needs to call the item real quick.
Raymond C. Lee
Hold on.
Jamie Dunphy
Again, to everybody watching at home and to everybody on this meeting, I really appreciate your patience as we figure out these technical difficulties and logistics.
Keelan McClymont
All right, Council President, um, are we, are we on the consent or the city administrator report now?
Jamie Dunphy
Yes, please.
Keelan McClymont
Okay, thank you.
Number 5, January 2026 city administrator report.
Jamie Dunphy
City Administrator Lee, thank you for, uh, joining us.
And, uh, for, uh, this is your first presentation to us for your report.
Congratulations and welcome.
Raymond C. Lee
Thank you.
Thank you, Council President and Vice President, City Council.
This is my first opportunity to formally present the City Administrator's Report, and I want to begin by saying how much I appreciate the partnership already taking shape between Council and the administrative team.
I approach this role with deep respect for Council's authority and a clear understanding that your direction, priorities, and values help set The course for this organization.
The purpose of this monthly report is straightforward.
It is designed to provide you with a clear, high-level view of how the organization is operating, where progress is being made, and where challenges require attention or shared problem solving.
It is not intended to capture everything happening across the city, but rather to surface the issues, trends, and decisions That matter most to effective governance.
As you review this report, as I know all of you have already, you will see both positive momentum and real constraints.
You will see where we're dedicated employees are delivering critical services every day, progress on public safety, infrastructure, and community investment, and also the fiscal and organizational realities we must navigate together.
My commitment is to be candid about both, to communicate clearly, bring forward our options, and ensure you have timely and accurate information to support your decision-making.
Going forward, you can expect this report to continue to evolve.
My goal is for it to become a dependable tool for transparency, accountability, and alignment between policy and operations.
I look forward to working closely with each of you through these reports.
Through briefings, through ongoing dialogue, to translate council's priorities into measurable results that Portlanders can see and experience.
With that, I'm happy to walk through the highlights from this month's report and answer any questions you may have.
I also have my executive leadership team on this call as well to address any questions that council may have as it relates to the report.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, City Administrator.
Just to be clear, would you prefer to go through to present or give a highlight of any of these, or would you rather any of our councilors, in interest of time, who might have questions jump in the queue and ask that?
Raymond C. Lee
Let's jump into the queue and ask any questions that they may have just for the essence of time.
Sameer Kanal
Great.
Jamie Dunphy
Colleagues, if you have any questions for our City Administrator for his first City Administrator report in this Challenging environment, please go ahead and jump into the queue.
Vice President Clark, please go ahead first.
Olivia Clark
Thank you, Council President.
Thank you, City Administrator Lee.
I just wanted to note that in the report— they're vacuuming out here, I don't know if you can hear it— the section on public works under parks calls out partnerships, and I was really pleased to see that.
That's something I'd like to see across all the bureaus, more partnerships.
But I really appreciate it being highlighted in the Public Works Parks section.
Raymond C. Lee
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
EVP Clerk, Councilor Green.
Mitch Green
Uh, thank you.
Um, I'm going to shout because the vacuuming is the worst timing you can possibly imagine here.
Um, uh, just wanted to note, I think given what we've experienced tonight, I think it would be a good idea to have a standing line item that just Gives us the status of the phase at which we're at in the land use reconsideration process for the McAdam Ice Facility.
Um, I, I don't expect that we would put any sort of editorializing in that, and we would not talk about any pre-decisional, um, uh, you know, um, opinions or sort of leanings.
But I think at a minimum, I think what we could do To show the community that we're working on this is just to provide a timeline.
Here's where we're at.
And so we, so we have some of that information.
So I think I've shared that in a private venue, but I just wanted to raise that now.
Thanks.
Raymond C. Lee
Most definitely, we can do that and accommodate that.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, sir.
Any other questions or comments for our city administrator on his first city administrator report?
Sameer Kanal
Thank you, Council President.
I see that DC Oliveira has turned on his camera, so I think I'd like to first just allow him to answer anything about the permit process and timeline, and then I might have some other things after that.
I'm also happy to wait until later at your discretion, Council President.
Donnie Oliveira
All right, thank you, Councilor Kanal and Councilor Green.
Hello, everyone.
Donnie Oliveira, for the record.
Just for a quick background, since we haven't touched this topic in a while, Following a formal complaint in July of 2025, Portland Permitting and Development issued on September 18th a notice of violation to the McAdam facility for violation of their conditional use.
This triggered 2 timelines, one, a 30-day window for the violation and a potential 60-day window for reconsideration of that conditional use.
On October 3rd, a law firm representing the owners of the McAdam Avenue requested administrative review of that notice of violation, which essentially was they were challenging the violation itself.
They had time to provide their findings to suggest that that violation was void.
We actually had staff— excuse me, not me, but staff had a meeting with the legal team on December 30th to receive those findings.
We've collected that information, and now staff in the City Attorney's Office are earnestly at work evaluating that administrative review for a decision.
And the— for the 2 outcomes of that is one, we would see their findings as accurate and would remove the violation.
If we don't believe those findings are accurate, we would proceed with the timelines that would result in potentially a fine on that 30-day window, or if on that 60-day window, that would restart that clock.
That would be the situation where a hearings officer could reconsider the conditional use for the permit that was granted in 2013.
I will also note that this appeal process that we are in can be appealed to a circuit court.
So we are far from completing the legal process on this admin review for the initial violation.
But the next step is staff will make a determination on if the admin review process resulted in any findings that we hadn't found that would make the violation void.
Sameer Kanal
Can I clarify on that?
That's where—.
Jamie Dunphy
Yeah.
Sameer Kanal
What is the timeline on the staff making that determination?
What is the deadline, I should say?
Mitch Green
Great question.
Donnie Oliveira
There's not a code-specific timeline, but I can tell you that staff and city attorneys are actively working at pace to get that result as soon as possible.
Sameer Kanal
Okay, and when you say code-specific, you're referring to city code, DCL?
Tracy Warren
Yeah.
Raymond C. Lee
Okay.
Sameer Kanal
So the timeline is defined there.
That's helpful.
And then the other piece is after that is done, then a hearings officer, what's their timeline for issuing their finding?
Donnie Oliveira
If we restart that 60-day clock that started in September but was paused in October, Restart that clock.
We get to that 60 days, the permitting director would have the authority to initiate a reconsideration of the conditional use.
That would require staff to actually put together a recommendation to a hearings officer.
And that, that is, again, on staff's diligence to get that to them.
There's not a, there's not a clock-specific timeline, but again, it's a, it's an issue that we take very seriously and would move as quickly as possible to get that scheduled.
And just to follow that thread, Councilor, if we get to that point in the proceedings, of course, that process could be appealed at a hearings officer, at which point then that decision would move to council for contemplation.
But I have to restate, there's a lot of steps in there related to appealing.
So there's legal processes that would have to play out before that happens.
Sameer Kanal
Okay, and then my last question on this, and then I'm happy to circle back around for other things later in the queue, Council President, is Last time I asked questions about this in the City Administrator's Report, I think I was imprecise in how I asked the question.
I asked when the mayor's next public engagement was to discuss this, and I think that was a little narrow in its focus.
So I want to be a little clearer now.
When is the next time that the administrative side of our city government is having a place where the public can weigh in on this process to you?
And that might include the mayor, might include the administration, administrator all the way down.
To anyone in this, in this process?
Donnie Oliveira
Yeah, Councilor, thank you for the question.
As far as the process that we're in right now, which is this admin review, there is not a public comment period on this particular case.
Once we get into the phase where it might be going to a hearings officer, people that had standing, i.e., people that, you know, submitted the complaint on the initial violation, could in fact participate in that reconsideration.
So when we get to that phase of reconsideration, People who have standing in our policy, because this is obviously following a legal process, would have standing.
As far as a scenario where we are hosting an information session, not that you suggested that, I would obviously talk to City Administrator Lee and the mayor about that.
But right now we're staying focused on making sure our process is airtight and we don't have an administrative appeal about process, because that certainly is—.
Candace Avalos
Yeah.
Donnie Oliveira
Potentially an option if we don't, you know, dot all our i's and cross our t's.
Sameer Kanal
Yeah, thank you.
And I'll just, uh, pass it back to the council president.
But first, I wanted to mention portland.gov/news for those who haven't seen it, has a statement from the mayor about this process from 5:30 PM today.
Thank you, Council President.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Kanal.
Councilor Koyama Lane.
Tiffany Koyama Lane
Thank you, Council President.
Um, warm welcome to City Administrator Lee.
Appreciate that you're with us and you're hitting the ground running.
I appreciated our coffee chat the other And I love that you are prioritizing having those with each elected.
I saw in there a shout out for the Arts Access Fund, which is exciting and will distribute over $8 million to Portland's 6 different school districts.
And those funds plant artistic seeds that are very important, help students grow into artists, musicians, performers.
Also, not sure how many folks saw buried in Appendix D, but there was a note there about the Creston Skatepark Award that went out before the holiday break.
Mitch Green
Yes.
Tiffany Koyama Lane
And I have a staffer who's an avid skateboarder who pointed out that this is going to bring an amazing covered park to the heart of D3 that's really going to bolster Portland's reputation as a leader in city-supported skate— skatepark design.
I'll let you try to figure out later on who the skater on my team is.
And I also appreciated the section that you wrote about your hope for partnership with council, regular engagement, candor.
Candace Avalos
Thank you.
Tiffany Koyama Lane
Healthy dialogue, and you specifically talked about alignment between policy and operations being essential.
I'm just wondering if you can let us know a little bit more about what you envision in with respect to aligning policy and operations.
Loretta Smith
Thank you.
Raymond C. Lee
You know, as we continue to go through the process of our priority setting session that we will have with City Council, that's a huge part of aligning policy with operations.
Once we have clear priorities and alignment from where City Council wants to take the organization, it'll be staff's main objective to really develop the goals and operational pieces that help achieve those goals and objectives and priorities that council has overall.
And that will be critical for us to have that buy-in from City Council on how we plan on achieving those goals.
This can't be done in a vacuum, and it can't be done from our eyes where we are the only ones with lenses On this.
This has to be a collaborative process, uh, that we are engaging with council regarding what does success look like, uh, what are those outcomes and measures that we're using to gauge success, what are those key performance indicators that we can communicate to the community of what success is for this organization.
Those are all key things that we're going to have to partner with in aligning What that policy direction is from City Council to the operational things that we're doing as a city.
And it will play dividends in how we look at our budget as well, which is the biggest policy decision that Council will be making year after year is the city's budget, a huge policy document.
And we're really leaning into those priorities that Council has of shaping what that policy document truly looks like.
And what are we and how are we funding programs and initiatives and, and actual projects to help achieve the overall priorities that council has for the organization.
This is a continuous conversation that we have to have.
I also believe in quarterly check-ins with council as it relates to those priorities and where are we in achieving those things, and also a year-end report that kind of talks through what we have done for that full year from a policy standpoint of implementing what council The council has asked of us to do and where we are with implementing those and where we are with tracking the successes of those policies as well.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.
Councilor Smith.
Loretta Smith
Thank you, Council President.
Can you hear me?
Jamie Dunphy
Yes, we can.
Loretta Smith
Thank you.
Um, thank you, City Administrator Raymond Lee.
I appreciate you, uh, attending the Martin Luther King, um, Urban League celebration brunch this Monday.
Got a chance to introduce you to a, a lot of folks, so I guess this is going to be your life for the next year or so.
Um, I have a question.
We have $26.7 million And pending federal grant awards.
Um, what areas of, um, the city government do those— a good portion of those lie?
Are they block grants, transportation grants?
What, what are they?
Raymond C. Lee
You know, that's a good question.
I don't know if we have our CFO Jonas on this call to be able to Talk to our Tracy on this call that may have a better understanding from a budgetary standpoint.
See, Jonas just jumped on to kind of speak to that, uh, topic.
Thank you.
Jonas Biery
Yeah, uh, uh, good evening, Council.
For the record, Jonas Biery, Chief Financial Officer.
Uh, Councilor Smith, great question.
Um, I'm not— um, um, pulling up the report here and not finding the exact $26 million that you're referring to.
I'm guessing we won't know that even if we can identify that on the spot, but more than happy to follow up with you and get that information.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, I'm more than happy to do that.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Loretta Smith
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Smith.
Uh, Councilor Avalos.
Candace Avalos
All right, hello.
Um, thank you so much, City Administrator Raymond Lee.
Uh, welcome to this role.
Quite a first day, uh, officially.
I really appreciate the report, and I have some specific questions as it relates to the Protect Portland initiative.
So, um, first, can you explain the rationale for opening the immigrant affairs lead position for only 1 week and how the city ensured that the abbreviated posting period still allowed for a robust and inclusive candidate pool?
Raymond C. Lee
You know, when we look at that position overall, I believe the staff were looking at the amount of applicants that they had rolled in for that, which it was a good amount of applicants to come in as it relates to that role within the organization and going through those interviews.
It's one of those situations, if we didn't feel that we had an adequate number of applicants that met the minimum qualifications for that role, we probably would have kept that position open longer.
We were able to receive a good number of applicants that met those minimum qualifications and went through a very aggressive And very important recruitment process of interviewing, selecting people for that role.
I know Tracy can kind of talk through some of the typical processes, how we do some of the hires and the hiring process and interview process for those type of roles.
But I know that was one of the important roles for the city, that we were able to pull in a number of applicants, qualified applicants for that role, to be able to fill that position.
Thank you, Mayor.
Tracy Warren
That's right.
Happy to also answer any questions, Councilor Avalos.
Um, but we did, uh, have a process in which we did an initial posting for 1 week with the understanding that we would evaluate the applicant pool, see the level of, um, applicants and their level of qualifications to determine whether or not we would keep it open longer.
Or close the recruitment.
We did have quite the applicant pool with lots of talented individuals on that applicant pool that helped us to feel comfortable in moving forward with the recruitment process.
That did include an interview panel that included multiple stakeholders for a first round.
Then we had a second round interview process that also included—.
Mitch Green
Thank you.
Tracy Warren
Stakeholders, and then we are in the process of making final decisions.
Olivia Clark
Thank you.
Candace Avalos
So my next question is that my understanding is that each bureau has designated an immigration lead.
So I was curious what criteria and process were used to select those individuals and what resources or support are given— are being given to these leads.
Tracy Warren
Absolutely happy to weigh in on that as well.
So each of the bureaus' directors were provided criteria for selecting immigration affairs liaisons for their bureau.
We listed out things like a natural affinity to the work, an interest in doing the work, capacity to be able to do the work.
Having an understanding of policy and other dynamics related to the work within the city.
They were then supposed to identify folks who could participate as their bureau representative, and they had to be willing to commit them to a certain amount of time.
We estimated, you know, roughly somewhere between 5 to 10 hours a week that they would be needed.
Keelan McClymont
Thank you.
Tracy Warren
And then we quickly realized that we needed to add a resource in the mayor's office to help continue to facilitate that work and make sure that they had adequate support for ongoing needs.
So that's part of the driving factor of creating the immigration affairs liaison lead position and recruiting for it quickly.
Mitch Green
Okay.
Candace Avalos
And my last question is 2 parts.
So, My understanding is that the city has implemented a new immigration leave policy.
So my first question on that is, does this policy create 40 new hours of immigration leave for employees, or does it allow employees to use up to 40 hours of their existing leave for immigration-related matters?
Tracy Warren
So it is neither.
What it does is it allows employees to use up to 40 hours They're not using an existing leave bank, and a new leave bank is not being created.
It's kind of like when someone attends jury duty and we say you're doing that on city time.
There's a special code that they use, but it doesn't take away from their leave banks, and they don't have a pot sitting there that's available.
Candace Avalos
That's good to know.
And then the second part to that is, what protections are in place to ensure that immigration leave records and any related communications are kept confidential?
Communications to that cannot be accessed, disclosed, or used by federal immigration authorities to identify individual city employees that are using this service?
Keelan McClymont
Absolutely.
Tracy Warren
So, um, the requests are going through the Bureau of Human Resources, and we are specifically not asking for certain levels of documentation.
Okay, thank you.
Candace Avalos
That's all for now.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Avalos.
Councilor Kanal.
Sameer Kanal
Thanks, um, Council President.
So, uh, welcome again, City Administrator Lee, and thanks for your, uh, report.
Thanks also to, to former Administrator Jordan.
I know you were probably part of, uh, some of that planning.
Uh, excited to see the iteration month over month, including the inclusion for the first time of the intergovernmental agreement list on page 59.
Uh, I also wanted to thank you for the updates on the direct impact of the sanctuary codification on Protect Portland initiatives and the continued status updates on budget notes, in particular around the updates coming back to council due back on February 28th for long-term residential and commercial vacancy fees and package delivery fees.
I appreciated the shoutouts.
Michelle Koenig-North has done a lot in leading, building, managing 311, her whole team, and Ranger Schultz as well in the other section related to park rangers.
I had one question and then a comment.
How many citations and arrests were there in the first 5 weeks of the camping ordinance enforcement actions?
On page 3, it talks about 111 people connected to services and 11 people sent to deflection, but it doesn't talk about what was in the, the sort of small-scale reports on a few days at a time about how many folks were arrested or cited.
Do you happen to know that off the top of your head?
Raymond C. Lee
I don't know that off the top of my head, and we can follow up with that information.
Before the end of this week, so you can have that information.
Okay, great.
Sameer Kanal
Then the comment I wanted to say, and I know Councilor Clark had already touched on a lot of this earlier on, but I was excited to see the success in recruiting.
PBEM did a great job in filling some of those net volunteers at Bumper Crop there.
I will note that there are also vacancies we've been seeing for years at PPB.
And I wanted to second Councilor Clark's appreciation to our city employees for all that they do and also add my well wishes and hopes for a full and speedy recovery to the 2 police officers who were shot a few nights ago in Northeast Portland.
Thank you, Council President.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Kanal.
I would also like to take a moment to acknowledge and send speedy wishes to the 2 police officers who are recovering from injuries sustained in the shooting.
Who were experiencing gun violence trying to do their jobs, and to all the police officers who are out there trying to find the gentleman who did this to them.
We wish those 2 officers a speedy recovery, and we wish the community safety as soon as possible.
And thank you to all the city staff who are helping with this, this report.
Colleagues, I would accept a motion and a second in order to vote on this report.
Loretta Smith
So moved.
Second.
Sameer Kanal
So moved.
Olivia Clark
Second.
Jamie Dunphy
That's a motion from Councilor Kanal, second from Vice President Clark.
Keelan, can you please take the roll?
Keelan McClymont
Avalos?
Candace Avalos
Aye.
Loretta Smith
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Kanal?
Sameer Kanal
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Pirtle-Guiney?
Elana Pirtle-Guiney
Aye.
Sameer Kanal
Aye.
Olivia Clark
Aye.
Loretta Smith
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Aye.
Aye.
Jamie Dunphy
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Aye.
Loretta Smith
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
The report is accepted with 12 yes votes.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
And colleagues, I mentioned at the beginning that following the city administrator report, I was going to take a moment to turn over to city administrator, as well as Councilors Ryan and Koyama Lane, with regard to an update on Resolution 3773.
Before I do that, I just wanted to explain to my colleagues This is the council resolution that we all passed about strategic priority setting exercise.
In order to ensure that that work is met to the extent that the authors of this bill wanted to see it done, and it wasn't at my discretion because I ultimately, you may recall, voted against it.
I want to see this be successful on behalf of the entire council.
And so I have asked City Administrator to work directly with Councilors Ryan and Koyama Lane on scoping.
And I'm going to turn it over to them to give us a brief update on where this stands.
Raymond C. Lee
I can probably open this up.
We are making headway.
We should have an agreement in place hopefully by the end of this week, uh, which is a major milestone for us to be able to get that done within the time frame.
I know we also have some upcoming meetings, uh, with the city attorney, with the city clerk, With the council offices as well to, to kind of talk through expected outcomes of this retreat and kind of the timing of the retreat.
We would love to be able to schedule that meeting along with the facilitator that we're looking at to conduct this retreat.
So soon as we have that in place, we can start the ball rolling on that.
What, you know, what I'm also anticipating in this, so forewarn the council on this.
Okay.
There will be potentially some pre-work associated with this retreat that we're going to be asking the councilors as individuals to sit down and think through some priority work and think through some priorities that you have overall and some of the objectives that you're looking at trying to achieve, not only in the upcoming fiscal year, but also thinking 3 years down the road as well and being— having some foresight in some of the priorities that we're setting as an organization.
But I just want to kind of set the table with that piece.
Thank you.
First, to let council know we are almost there of having a contract in place and having a facilitator on board to help facilitate that conversation.
There will probably be some more information going out to trying to locate dates for the full council to be able to sit down for this retreat as well.
Jamie Dunphy
Excellent.
And Councilor Ryan or Councilor Koyama Lane, would you like to also add anything to your expectations for this process?
Steve Novick
Sure.
Dan Ryan
Thank you, Council President, and thank you for the update, City Administrator Lee.
Former Council Vice President Koyama Lane and I joined forces with Councilor Kanal and Councilor Vice President Clark to sponsor this resolution.
It establishes an annual priority setting exercise in January of every year.
The original version is that the council will come together to talk high level.
About their individual priorities to see where there might be collective priorities to move forward on.
This can only help to guide the work of this year.
Additionally, I'm a big believer in us having a less formal discussion that is not scripted.
I advocate that the work session moves from beyond— from behind the dais, and we can sit at a table together, preferably without constant reliance upon technical devices.
A device-free conversation, if you will.
And what a great dialogue that we could have.
Imagine that.
I would like to also clarify how others have talked about this exercise.
I don't see this work session as a long retreat or really a long strategic priority type planning session.
Those are much more in-depth, as we know.
So I think it's important in this dialogue to right-size this and what it is.
So I hope people just come free and open to discuss their priorities.
Thank you.
It's intended to be a focused conversation, and I look forward to that and not getting down into the details and tactics of everything that we are prioritizing.
So I really think that what I wanted to do right now is just kind of right-size this a bit.
It's about coming up with our individual priorities, sitting around a table and discussing those with one another and seeing where we can find some commonality.
And I look forward to that.
Thank you.
Being scheduled, and I know that the council president and vice president, along with you, City Administrator Lee, are on that, and I look forward to those details being worked out.
Thanks.
Jamie Dunphy
Thanks.
Councilor Koyama Lane, did you want to add anything?
Tiffany Koyama Lane
No, thank you for that, Councilor Ryan.
The only thing to add, and you can let me know if you agree with this, but what I'm hearing is Administrator Lee is going to need some flexibility in executing the resolution, especially with the deadline that was set.
And so I am supportive of him having that flexibility as needed to make sure that this goes as well as possible.
Molly Hogan
Agreed.
Mitch Green
Excellent.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Councilor Smith.
Loretta Smith
Thank you, Council President.
Is this supposed to be a day long, 2 days long?
What is, what, what is the scope of the retreat?
Raymond C. Lee
I know some of the conversations that we've had with council has been a day retreat.
Of discussion.
Some of that is going to be really hinged on what the expected outcomes of this retreat and what we're looking for.
So in upcoming meetings that we'll have with the council liaisons that are working on this retreat will help kind of set that course.
But what I'm thinking is a day retreat of getting this out, at the most, most a day and a half.
Okay.
Um, to get it through.
Because what I would love to be able to see— if we're moving towards a good direction, everybody's satisfied, good.
If we're moving towards a direction where people want an evening to really contemplate and think about what they have on the table right now and what we will move forward with, to be able to have that as an option also.
But nothing longer than that.
Loretta Smith
Okay, thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Smith.
Councilor Avalos.
Candace Avalos
Um, I might have missed this.
Raymond C. Lee
Where—.
Molly Hogan
What is—.
Candace Avalos
What is the budget for this?
Where is the budget coming from for these actions?
Raymond C. Lee
That's a good question.
We're looking through the budget right now to find funds, uh, to be able to actually have this actual, uh, work session retreat for council.
Candace Avalos
And then to be clear, this will be like, uh, in public?
Raymond C. Lee
Yes, uh, we have to have this meeting in public.
Our, uh, laws require us to— for this to be a public meeting.
Candace Avalos
Okay, sounds good.
Thanks.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor.
Councilor Green.
Mitch Green
Yeah, thank you.
Um, thanks for making a little space if you're here, uh, to get the little update.
I appreciate the motivation by the, the carriers of it.
Um, I was supportive of this from day one.
Um, I really want to echo my support for the, um, The idea of stepping away from the dais and getting into a different space, maybe a roundtable, uh, put the phones away.
Um, I, I'm going to start to get myself mentally prepared for this, uh, knowing, yes, the public will be watching through some sort of, um, Noticed and, uh, maybe Open Signal.
But, but also it's important that we enter that room being willing to, to be vulnerable and understand that what we're doing is we're laying on the table Our priorities, and it's not a performance, but it's really just us coming together and speaking to each other directly about what we think the city needs, which I think all of us want to do.
So I'm just really, I'm really excited for the work, and thanks for your— one of the first things you do, City Administrator, when you come into this and help us focus on priority-based policymaking.
So I appreciate that.
Looking forward to it.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Green.
Councilor Ryan.
Dan Ryan
Yeah, thank you.
I just want to add this.
I think that City Administrator Lee, the way you're talking about it, I just want to say the word retreat in Portland, Oregon, I think can move people into a very different touchy-feely place than I think we were intending to do with this.
I think we're seeing ourselves as sitting around a table having Conversations about our priorities.
I think that I just wanted to put that out because I think the word retreat sometimes can suggest a much longer process and would get into some places that were never really discussed when we were looking at this as merely a dialogue about our priorities.
So I think I'm trying to just manage the expectations by making this comment right now.
Thank you.
So I hope that you can take that feedback, um, where it was coming from, which was to just, uh, manage expectations and move this forward.
Raymond C. Lee
Yeah, there, there will be no trust falls, uh, on this session.
Dan Ryan
Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Bye-bye.
Molly Hogan
Excellent.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Thank you, City Administrator.
And, uh, with that, we're going to move forward to, uh, Council Item Number 6.
It's our consent agenda.
Keelan McClymont
Do— oh yeah, Council President, I can call a roll for the consent agenda if you would like.
Jamie Dunphy
Yeah, let's do that please.
Molly Hogan
Thank you.
Keelan McClymont
Avalos?
Candace Avalos
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Thank you.
Smith?
Loretta Smith
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Kanal?
Sameer Kanal
Yes.
Keelan McClymont
Pirtle-Guiney?
Elana Pirtle-Guiney
Aye.
Becky Strauss
Aye.
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Aye.
Aye.
Steve Novick
Aye.
Mitch Green
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Aye.
Aye.
The consent agenda is approved with 12 yes votes.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Please call item number 7.
Keelan McClymont
Item number 7, assess property for sidewalk, curb, and driveway repair for the Portland Bureau of Transportation.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, colleagues.
This is a second reading, but I believe, uh, Councilor Zimmerman has an amendment to this.
Is that correct?
Loretta Smith
Yes.
Eric Zimmerman
Um, and I'm trying to make sure that I'm, I'm basically— folks, I'm introducing an amendment just from the administration.
I'm making sure we've got our ducks in a row here, so just give me one second.
It's a housekeeping item.
Um, okay, so on December 8th, 2025, the Finance Committee referred this item to the council.
A property subsequently filed a remonstrance— hopefully I said that correctly— and the ordinance and the exhibit now need to be updated to reflect the removal of that property from this document.
For the record, these changes will remove lien number 178721 from property R169569 located at 443 31 Southeast Taylor, Portland, Oregon 97215, for $6,328.61.
The number of liens assessed is updated from 180 to 179, and the ordinance amount is updated from $500,018.204.16 to $511,875.55.
Uh, when this was originally programmed, uh, we did have some revenue folks in the room at the previous council meetings.
I just having gone virtual, I don't know if we do right now, but if the question comes up, folks, um, I would say we, we would be best to refer them to refer those questions to those folks.
But with that, I want a motion to amend this ordinance and have Exhibit A as filed with the clerk to reflect these changes.
And sorry for the detailed work here, but when we were talking dollars and cents and liens on properties, it's important to get this right.
So thank you for the staff who prepared this.
And colleagues, I would appreciate a second to that amendment.
Dan Ryan
Second.
Jamie Dunphy
Amendment is moved by Councilor Zimmerman, seconded by Councilor Ryan.
Colleagues, Councilor Kanal.
Sameer Kanal
Just a quick question.
This is the only the one property at the bottom of page 14 of the exhibit, is that correct?
And is there any— I'll just ask both my questions, I guess.
The other question is, is there anything we should read into it that, uh, at all, that there was a, uh, this item was introduced by Mayor Wilson but that Councilor Zimmerman, that you're putting up the amendment?
Eric Zimmerman
I wouldn't read anything into it, Councilor.
Turn up the audio.
I wouldn't read anything into it, Councilor.
I, uh, most of the things that come through finance happen to just be From them, and once it's here, there's no way for a CFO, for instance, to read an amendment to us.
And so I'm carrying the amendment on behalf of them.
Sameer Kanal
Got it.
Thank you.
Raymond C. Lee
Great.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, colleagues.
Is there any further discussion around this amendment?
And I'd like to ask the clerk to please call the roll.
Rebecca Morgan
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
I don't agree.
Aye.
Aye.
Candace Avalos
Aye.
Angelita Morillo
Aye.
Candace Avalos
Aye.
Loretta Smith
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Novick?
Steve Novick
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Clark?
Olivia Clark
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Green?
Mitch Green
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Zimmerman?
Eric Zimmerman
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Dunphy?
Jamie Dunphy
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
The amendment— oh, thank you, Councilor Smith.
The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes.
Jamie Dunphy
And Keelan, please Confirm for me, this is a non-emergency ordinance, is that right?
Keelan McClymont
Yep, that's correct.
It'll pass to second reading again.
Jamie Dunphy
Okay, we will, we will move this item to second reading, uh, next week.
Could you please call item 8?
Keelan McClymont
Assess property for sidewalk, curb, and driveway repair for the Portland Bureau of Transportation.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, colleagues.
This is also a second reading of an ordinance.
There is no amendment to, uh, being proposed.
Uh, is there any further discussion on this item?
Seeing none, could we please call the roll?
Keelan McClymont
Avalos.
Candace Avalos
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Smith.
Loretta Smith
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Kanal.
Sameer Kanal
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Pirtle-Guiney?
Elana Pirtle-Guiney
Aye.
Mitch Green
Aye.
Tiffany Koyama Lane
Aye.
Jamie Dunphy
Aye.
Keelan McClymont
Aye.
Aye.
Councilor Aye.
The ordinance passes with all yes votes.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Please call item number 9.
Keelan McClymont
Establish City Council's priorities for the allocation of approximately $20,700,000 in unspent Rental Services Office funds and urge the mayor to reflect these priorities in the proposed budget.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Do we have a Council Ops Committee summary?
Hi, Claire.
Unidentified speaker
Hi, Mr. President.
Claire Adamcik
Yes, we do.
Mr. President and councilors, for the record, Claire Adamcik, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Homelessness and Housing Committee.
The resolution before you, document number 2025-478, was heard in the Homelessness and Housing Committee on December 9th, where it was referred to the full council with a recommendation it be adopted.
The resolution urges the mayor to allocate approximately $20.7 million in funds within the Rental Services Office within Portland Housing Bureau budget to investments focused on renter stabilization.
The resolution specifies that allocations should prioritize community-based organizations serving Portlanders at risk of experiencing housing insecurity, including immigrant, refugee, Black, Indigenous, and people of color, and linguistically isolated households.
Allocations recommended by the resolution are in addition to funds already allocated in FY25-26, the current fiscal year, for certain purposes, and include $4 million over 3 fiscal years for rent assistance for tenants at risk of losing housing, $2 million over 3 fiscal years for rent assistance and rapid rehousing for tenants facing eviction, $3 million over 3 fiscal years for rent assistance for individuals experiencing homelessness.
$1.5 Million in FY26-27 for a right-to-counsel pilot program providing legal assistance to households facing eviction.
$9 Million in— to Home Forward in FY26-27 for emergency housing vouchers.
$200,000 In FY26-27 for the development of landlord-tenant education resources.
$750,000 In FY26-27 for nonprofit housing providers in the North Northeast Preference Policy catchment area.
To stabilize operations, and $250,000 in FY25-26 for down payment assistance for tenants ready for homeownership.
The full impact statement on this item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts and analysis, economic and real estate development impacts, and community impacts and community involvement.
23 People testified during the committee meeting on December 9th.
48 People submitted written testimony on this item.
Thank you.
Prior to committee action, and an additional 2 people submitted written testimony prior to the posting of this full council agenda.
The general themes of the testimony that the committee heard included the urgency of local long-term rental assistance support in light of projected reductions or elimination of federal funding, lack of accessible housing and disproportionate representation of people with disabilities, seniors, and domestic violence survivors who are experiencing homelessness.
Balancing the city's investments in shelter with investments in eviction and homelessness prevention and housing placements for individuals exiting shelter.
Acknowledgment of cost increases that small landlords are experiencing.
Recognizing that some of the— recognizing some of the root causes of homelessness, including unaffordable rents, lack of living wages, medical debt, and lack of rent regulation.
Oversight and accountability for how the funds are dispersed.
And finally, inclusion of community expertise and lived experience when designing these rental assistance programs.
And that concludes the committee staff summary.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you very much, Claire.
Colleagues, I want to give a couple of notes.
There are over 70 people who are signed up to testify tonight, and there is simply not enough time for us to be able to hear all of them.
As such, I have already moved the remainder of our— this meeting and the final vote on this resolution to next week.
We will have a conversation next week regarding votes on amendments and the final resolution and the conversation as it pertains to amongst ourselves about the ordinance that actually allocates these dollars.
But I would like to take a moment to just say something.
I, as council president, it is my expectation that we will be prioritizing items that are filed first come, first serve as they come out of committee.
And with the exception that we are going to be hearing things of high particular public interest on evening meetings.
Thank you.
Council sessions like we're hearing tonight.
But I would like to acknowledge that I think that there are some things that have happened around these dollars in particular that go against some of the best policy practices that I think that we should be adhering to as a city.
By having multiple conflicting ordinances over the same dollars, it creates a hostile working environment.
It creates an opportunity where we are using procedural power in order to try and control narrative, when instead my preference would be always to—.
Thank you.
Do this how we're supposed to.
We have amendments.
We can amend an ordinance.
Anybody is able to do that.
But I would ask my colleagues to please strive for better so that we don't get stuck in the doldrums of infighting over really legitimate reasons.
Because this, I will tell you, there are no good— there are no— well, there are some bad uses, but there are almost no bad uses for how we're going to use these dollars.
And we, the public, deserves an opportunity to hear And from both from us, and we deserve to hear from the community about how to spend these dollars.
So thank you for that.
And with that, I'd like to turn it over to the— to Councilor Avalos, who is the chair of the Housing and Homelessness Committee, who heard this bill.
Thank you.
Candace Avalos
Thank you, Council President.
Yes, I would like to take an opportunity to provide some additional context to the council and to the community.
About what is in front of you today and why it looks different from what passed out of the Homeless and Housing Committee.
So on November 20th, Councilor Dunphy and myself were made aware of these excess funds from the Rental Service Office.
At that time, the mayor asked to work with— to work together on a proposal to bring to the Homeless and Housing Committee.
The next day, on November 21st, an email was sent out by the administration to all of council letting them know about these funds.
And asking them to connect with our offices on the development of the proposal.
Our offices immediately set about connecting with community partners, reviewing recommendations for these funds that were developed by the previous Housing Bureau director, looping in our fellow District 1 councilor, Councilor Smith, and creating a package that would align with the need and the urgency to keep people housed.
We followed all of the established processes we've been using to create and pass policy, and the Slow the Inflow resolution passed out of my committee on December 9th with a clear intent.
To prioritize keeping people housed by investing heavily in renter stabilization, eviction prevention, and homelessness prevention.
Councilors Zimmerman, Ryan, Dunphy, and Murillo all sit on the committee, and except for Councilor Murillo, no amendments were offered or discussed.
Since then, that resolution had been waiting to be scheduled for a full council vote, and no one from any other office has approached me about amendments.
However, in the time between committee passage and today, Councilor Zimmerman created a counterproposal through a separate ordinance process with a completely different set of funding priorities for the same dollars.
Thank you.
And instead of running it through the Housing Committee, he chose to run it through his Finance Committee.
I want to say this plainly.
I am collaborative by nature.
I believe deeply in shared governance.
And when it became clear that other councilors wanted different priorities reflected in this funding, I chose to engage rather than dig in.
So what is before you today reflects that effort.
It is not the package me or the co-sponsors originally brought forward.
It is not the full investment in renters that this community deserves.
And I know many of you showed up today to Expecting something stronger because that is what you were advocating for.
And so I share that disappointment.
But I also believe that partial progress is better than no progress and that protecting at least some of these investments now is better than losing them altogether.
So that is why we, Councilors Dunphy and Smith, are going to be bringing forward an amended package today, which I'll explain in a moment.
I want to be clear about one thing.
The changes to this package were not driven by a lack of need, data, or community support for rent assistance.
I heard about the need all the time when I was at the doors in East Portland, and these changes are the result of differing views among councilors about how these dollars should be used and what our priorities need to be to keep people housed.
I remain committed to renters, to prevention, and to slowing the inflow into homelessness, and I will continue to fight for that every day and in the budget and beyond.
So with that, let me go ahead and introduce the 2 amendments that Councilor Smith and I— Councilor Smith-Dunphy and I are proposing.
These were pre-filed so that folks have an opportunity to see them.
So first, I would like to move Avalos-Dunphy-Smith Amendment 1, which removes the be it further resolved clause that establishes a revolving loan fund.
The reason that we have to remove this language is because the Housing Bureau informed us that there are not additional dollars coming in that could fund this as we previously thought.
So to keep this language in could risk defunding other rental service office programs that current funds provide.
Second.
Second, I want to move Avalos-Dunphy-Smith Amendment Number 2, which replaces the funding allocations under the second be it further resolved with a new compromise package of funding allocations.
I think I've said enough about how and why this package came about, but I know that my colleague, Councilor Smith, would also like to say a few words, so I will go ahead and pass it on to her.
Thank you.
Loretta Smith
Thank you, Councilor Avalos.
I appreciate this, uh, collaboration.
Colleagues, this amendment represents a thoughtful and collaborative effort and District 1 councilors to ensure that our limited resources are directed where they can make the most meaningful impact for Portlanders during a critical moment.
Our shared goals with this resolution is straightforward.
To reduce the flow into homelessness by strengthening the full continuum of housing support, funding affordable housing development, expanding rent and financial assistance, supporting tenants facing eviction, and creating pathways to homeownership.
In developing this amendment, it was important to us that we benefit that the benefits reach each and every district.
Housing stability is a citywide priority, and every community deserves to see tangible investments that reflect their needs.
Portlanders are looking to us for steady, practical action, and this amendment is one way we demonstrated good governance by developing one-time resources.
Thank you.
Quickly and responsibly to projects and programs that can both help people now and expand our capacity to house folks in the future.
This past— this package reflects what we heard from the community partners across the city, and I am so very grateful and thankful for my District 1 colleagues for their partnership.
I appreciate the effort across this council.
Thank you.
As we work together to respond to the housing crisis with some clarity, compassion, and commitment to serving all Portlanders.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Smith.
Thank you.
So the chair recognizes the motion for the amendments of Avalos, Dunphy, Smith 1 and 2.
Councilor Avalos, do you mean to move these as a package?
Yes.
Yeah, okay, so we'll move both, both the individual amendments together as one motion forward.
Is there a second?
Second.
Councilor Avalos introduced, uh, moves.
Councilor Smith seconds the amendments.
Um, I am, uh, colleagues, CFO Beery and Budget Director Levine are both here available for technical clarifications.
Uh, do councilors have any technical questions at this moment?
Councilor Kanal.
Sameer Kanal
Yeah, I'd just like to ask if CFO Biery or Budget Director Levine could talk through what the legal limitations are on usage for this particular fund.
I think that might be helpful for both the public and for councilors.
Jamie Dunphy
See if either are able to jump online.
Oh.
Hello, Budget Director Levine.
Ruth Levine
Hi, for the record, Ruth Levine.
I'm the budget director.
I'm also just looking to see if the city attorneys are on at all.
I don't know.
Candace Avalos
Just gonna pause for a second.
Ruth Levine
So there are some legal restrictions around the use of the Um, of the dollars in the Housing Investment Fund, which is where this rental services office sits.
Um, the, uh, I would, I think, defer to the city attorney on the specifics around the, like, original ordinance passage and the like.
Um, but I think the, the dollars need to be used in alignment with that ordinance and with the fund statement of purpose, which is the administrative rule essentially that governs how the housing investment fund can be spent.
So funds can be sort of reallocated, and because this is a resolution, it would require an ordinance, a follow-on ordinance to actually reallocate or to appropriate And/or reallocate any funding within the Housing Investment Fund to kind of codify if the resolution passes in whatever form it passes.
So I think I'll pause there unless there are follow-up questions or if City Attorney is on.
Jamie Dunphy
Councilor Kanal, do you have any follow-up questions?
Sameer Kanal
Yeah, I mean, I think that we'll get into it when we get into the actual things, but I'm basically trying to understand if some of these things are legal to use the money on and that Um, the link that was provided, uh, for it was dead, so I'm trying to get the, uh, the updated fund statement of purpose, um, for it.
Raymond C. Lee
And Councilor Kanal, we can follow up with the City Attorney's Office to give an update.
There was a memo previously sent out on this as well, but we can follow up with any legal interpretation of that as well to get to, uh, council, uh, and that should suffice if we're not taking any action today at that time.
We should be able to get that out to you.
Sameer Kanal
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Councilor Green?
Mitch Green
Yeah, I just entered the queue because I, I just want to remind folks that we have a lot of people sign up for testimony and it's already 8:07.
So as is sometimes our habit to keep talking well before it, I, I hope that we can just move to the testimony at this point.
Thanks.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor.
Councilor Smith?
Candace Avalos
Thank you.
Loretta Smith
Can you hear me?
Uh, Yes, Council President, thank you.
And just for the record, I have a companion ordinance that is to the letter of the Slow the Flow resolution.
So we do have one of those available that we can use as our instrument to be legal.
And if we're going to hear this next week as well, we can pull that up in our next meeting because it is identical to the Slow the Flow with the amended versions, um, that we— if, if they pass today.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Smith.
Councilor Novick?
Steve Novick
Yes, I plan to introduce an amendment to the amendment as proposed to be amended, uh, version, and I just wanted to know, should I quickly state what my proposals are going to be so that people giving public testimony can Keep that in mind.
Jamie Dunphy
Yeah, I think that'd be fine if you want to explain.
I was given instructions that we would need to do some procedural work to amend an amendment, but you are welcome to explain your amendment at this time.
Steve Novick
Okay, and I'm not going to go into justifications.
I'm just going to say literally what it would do.
Thank you.
What it would do is it would delete the first 4 items under rent and financial assistance in the latest proposal.
It would delete the $250,000 in funding to United Way, the $250,000 in funding to Our Just Future, the $2 million for rent and other financial assistance to be divided among various organizations, and the $2 million for rent assistance and other financial assistance for tenants prior to eviction.
It would increase the amount allocated to eviction defense from $1.2 million to $1.56 million.
But instead of saying that would go to the Commons Law Center's Tenant Eviction Defense Services, It would say that it would be for eviction defense services to be administered by the Portland Housing Bureau, and it would also return $4.14 million to the general fund by applying PHB's authorized administrative fee to the total $20.7 million.
$4.14 Million is the maximum amount that can be reserved, and the purpose there is to use that $4.14 million to reduce the amount of deficit that we're going to have to address.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Councilor Novick.
Councilor Koyama Lane.
Tiffany Koyama Lane
Yeah, I have one question.
My team and I have not been able to figure this out.
The original resolution passed out of Housing and Homelessness recommended $9 million for housing vouchers to support 426 families, seniors, and people who need that assistance.
But that is nowhere in this resolution or in the ordinance passed out of Finance.
Keelan McClymont
So, I'm just wondering if that's something that we can address.
Tiffany Koyama Lane
Wondering what happened there.
Why is that?
Candace Avalos
Yes, it was removed.
As you can see, the amended package is definitely not similar to the original resolution.
That's what we will be here debating.
But it was— yeah, people did not— people that were negotiating did not want that money to go towards that purpose.
So it was removed entirely.
Loretta Smith
Okay.
Jamie Dunphy
Councilor Green, is that a— are you back in the queue or is that a legacy hand?
Okay, Councilor Koyama Lane, was there further questions on that?
Okay, thank you.
Uh, with those being technical questions out of the way, uh, Keelan, can we, uh, please move to public testimony?
Loretta Smith
Yes.
Keelan McClymont
Thank you, Council President.
Um, we'll call people in groups.
First up, we have Lydia Kiesling, followed by Molly Hogan and Rebecca Morgan.
Jamie Dunphy
Welcome, Lydia.
Go ahead.
Lydia Kiesling
Hi, my name is Lydia Kiesling.
I live in District 3, and I'm a member of Portland DSA.
In order to pursue a headline-grabbing stunt of ending unsheltered homelessness on a very short timeline, the mayor has employed methods that do not work.
I don't even want to call them Band-Aids because Band-Aids can at least be momentarily helpful.
When the mayor moves to kick traumatized people out of tiny house shelters where they have a little bit of stability and force them into overnight-only shelters, that is literally making people more homeless.
Right now, there are almost 2,000 quote-unquote affordable housing units sitting empty because what a market-based housing system calls affordable is not what many houseless people can afford.
But rather than work to layer subsidies or streamline and centralize a very complex affordable housing system, The mayor chose to fire one of the foremost experts of social housing in this country and hide millions of dollars from the city council.
The housing crisis is not solved by a single bed for a single night.
The solution lies in the weeks and months and years that lead up to that single night, keeping people in homes with robust rental assistance, eviction defense, and a social safety net.
And when people have been failed and are forced to sleep outside, it's about easing a speedy return to housing.
It's about flooding the system with navigators who can do the arduous things like build trust, get people ID, help them figure out disability payments, rental assistance, legal issues, and healthcare.
City Council has been very accommodating to the mayor, and I think that was a gracious way to move in the beginning.
But if you look outside, it's clear the mayor's methods have not led to his promised result, no matter what the little thermometer out in your hallway says.
Please listen to the experts who have been begging for more upstream prevention and downstream support.
Fund eviction defense, fund rental assistance, fund a coordinated process for getting people housed.
Stop letting housing sit empty.
Stop employing inhumane sweeps that make this crisis work, and stop trying to shove people into a bed instead of a home.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you for being here.
Thank you for your testimony.
Keelan McClymont
Molly.
Molly Hogan
Hello, Council.
My name is Molly Hogan, and I'm the director of Welcome Home Coalition, an alliance of organizations Working for housing justice in the Portland region.
I'm testifying tonight in support of Slow the Inflow resolution, but also want to share concerns with the last-minute amended version.
We were excited to support the original resolution because it responded to the moment of crisis we are in.
The crisis of the Trump administration halting rental subsidies for emergency housing vouchers.
The crisis of ICE terrorizing our immigrant neighbors and making those households unstable.
The crisis of our state slashing eviction prevention.
We turned in a petition to you last month signed by over 2,000 people with a clear demand to fund eviction prevention.
The original Slow the Inflow put $18 million toward rent assistance over 3 years.
Local government proactively reducing the federal harm.
So while I speak tonight in support of $8.5 million in rent assistance, because it's better than nothing, there are concerns over this money being shifted away from direct relief for renters today.
Thank you.
Towards developments tomorrow.
Our main concern is with a quarter of the $21 million being allocated to, quote, Broadway Corridor Project for 230 affordable units.
Welcome Home members, Home Forward, and Urban League are developers on this project and both shared today that it is fully funded and they did not ask for $5.6 million.
The public deserves clarity on who is getting this funding and what is it going to build.
Thank you.
I also want to be clear about the decision to remove funding intended to cover the lost federal vouchers.
Over 850 people live in these households, including over 400 children.
Over 1/3 are people experiencing disability and older adults, folks who are not likely to make additional income to cover rent increases.
You have the chance to prevent these people from becoming homeless, and you choose instead to focus on funding apartments that won't be open for 5+ years.
For a city that spent $325 million over 5 years solely on sweeps and shelters, essentially paying to keep people homeless, I am angry to see you miss this opportunity for more meaningful impact right now.
But I've been in the game long enough to know that for tonight, I will ask you to say yes to this funding proposal because it's better than millions continuing to sit in the city bank account while thousands do their best to survive in a city that ignores their cries for help.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you for your testimony.
Is it Rebecca next?
Mitch Green
Go ahead.
Rebecca Morgan
Yes, thank you so much.
Good evening, Chair and councilors.
My name is Rebecca Morgan.
I was displaced from District 4, um, for safety reasons.
I'm keeping my current location off public record, uh, but what I'm sharing applies across Portland.
I am testifying in support of Item 2025-478.
Slow the inflow into homelessness, because domestic violence is a major driver of housing instability for women and families, and prevention only works if people can access it in time.
I moved to Portland in 2017 with my children and my then partner.
I survived domestic violence, and my children were impacted by abuse in our home.
We became homeless in 2020 while the abuse was still ongoing.
In 2022, after a no-fault eviction and with no relocation assistance available, I put our name on a Community Action Family Shelter waitlist, and we became homeless again, living in a tent until shelter space opened.
I rebuilt through rapid rehousing.
I rebuilt stability as a licensed home daycare provider and community volunteer.
In December 2024, I left my abusive ex, and since then I have been navigating post-separation abuse and 3 court systems at once.
As the state's witness in a criminal case, in family court, and in eviction court, with a jury trial pending in March.
Then in August, my apartment became structurally unsafe and I had to pause my daycare.
Losing that income pushed me back onto TANF and SNAP, and I'm doing everything I can to keep my children from becoming homeless for a 5th time.
This is what inflow looks like.
Families fall through gaps because help arrives too late or the process is not built for real-life complexity.
Slowing the inflow means stopping eviction and displacement before they happen.
Thank you.
Please vote yes on 2025-478 and implement it so people can actually access help in time.
Thank you for the opportunity to provide this testimony to you this evening.
Thank you.
Sameer Kanal
Thank you.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Chris Olson, Christina Dirks, Natalie Hutchinson.
Christina, go ahead and unmute.
Christina Dirks
Good evening, Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and fellow councilors.
My name is Christina Dirks, and I'm here on behalf of Home Forward, the Public Housing Authority for Multnomah County.
We support the following provisions of the Avalos, Dunphy, and Smith proposed amendment.
First, we support the $1.4 million for affordable housing portfolio stabilization.
This is a critical needed resource due to dramatically, dramatically increased operating costs and market-driven vacancy rates.
Second, we support the collectively a little over $8 million in rent assistance for tenants and individuals exiting shelters.
We know emergency rent assistance both lifts and saves families from homelessness.
We also want to recognize that there are multiple competing and valid priorities in how the city spends these funds.
With that context, I want to flag the removal of the 12 months of rent assistance for Home Forward's emergency voucher.
Thank you.
Participants from all resolution amendments.
Our EHV program, as we call it, serves approximately 420 families.
390 Of those live in the city of Portland.
These families will completely lose their federally funded monthly rent assistance in the fall of 2026 due to the early sunset of this program by HUD.
These families are some of our most vulnerable neighbors.
They are formerly homeless individuals.
91% Of them are living at 30% of area median income or below.
Thank you.
95% Of the heads of households are older adults or people with disabilities, and more than half of the families are BIPOC renters.
This program provides stable housing for hundreds of children across the city.
Absent local support, these families will likely enter homelessness and access our coordinated systems at significantly higher financial cost and capacity by our partner providers.
Ultimately, the choice before council involves, involves trade-offs, and we know that.
And the decision not to include this targeted rent assistance for EHV households should be understood in the context of the real downstream impacts for both these families and the broader system that the city supports.
Thank you for the opportunity to share this with you this evening.
And take care.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Christina.
Keelan McClymont
Natalie.
Natalie Hutchinson
Good evening.
My name is Natalie Hutchinson.
2025 Was the first year in my 17 years as a renter that I was served an eviction notice.
My partner and I were both full-time, full-time students working over 30 hours a week at $25 an hour.
We fell behind by 1 month of rent, about $1,700.
So I did what tenants are told to do.
I called 211, I asked for help, and I was told that unless my debt exceeded $10,000, that there was nothing available to me.
Let that sink in.
And then I learned that the city of Portland was sitting on $21 million earmarked.
Oh my God.
To rent, you need a high credit score, a clean rental history, no criminal record, quiet compliance, and perfect on-time payment, or, or you're punished with fees.
We lived at a Merida property that required us to log into personal bank accounts and hand over private financial data just to sign a lease.
They use Ciardi, which is an AI-driven rent pricing system, to inflate rents and force tenants out of their homes.
Councilmember Herbold.
And our unit went from $1,600 to $1,850 in 1 year.
They applied rubs fees, which means your landlord owns your utilities.
So our garbage bill jumped from $20 a month to over $90 a month by the end of our tenancy.
In 15 months, I saw 26 eviction notices posted on my neighbors' doors, including on my own.
Excuse me.
Molly Hogan
Um.
Keelan McClymont
Thank you.
Natalie Hutchinson
So my question to the council is simple.
How do we hold these parties accountable while serving the great need in our community?
I'm an architecture graduate student.
I've studied and designed housing systems for 8 years.
My understanding of our circumstance here is clear.
The way that we fund and build housing in the city is structurally broken and actively extracting from the people who live here.
We cannot keep relying on outdated or out-of-state investors, AI pricing tools, and Delayed intervention, will residents fall into crisis?
My work proposes the creation of a neighborhood-scale housing governance model where communities invest in, govern, and benefit from housing directly, where stabilization happens before eviction, where money moves at the speed of need, not paperwork.
This is not theoretical to me.
This is my lived experience.
Housing policy that waits until people are already homeless is not policy.
It's negligence.
Jamie Dunphy
With that, I'll— Yeah, sorry.
Yeah, thank you for your testimony.
Keelan McClymont
Chris.
Chris Olson
Thank you.
Good evening, councilors.
My name is Chris Olson, and I live in District 2, and I'm a member of the Portland DSA Housing Working Group and a tenant advocate.
I'm here to testify in support of the Slow the Inflow resolution while also expressing my deep disappointment with the last-minute amendments that cut rent assistance nearly in half.
Many of us signed up to testify because this resolution originally centered the people most at risk for homelessness right now.
Cutting rent assistance from $18 million to $8.5 fundamentally changes that promise.
While I strongly support affordable housing development, it is not a substitute for eviction prevention.
Affordable housing projects take years to come online and will have long waitlists.
Rent assistance keeps someone housed this month.
Thank you.
These amendments seem to assume that we can mostly build our way out of this crisis, but that aspirational future doesn't help a family facing eviction tomorrow.
Redirecting eviction prevention dollars to development will create homelessness in the near term, and that is exactly what this resolution was meant to prevent.
Half of Portland renters pay more than 30% of their income to stay housed, and at the same time, direct eviction prevention funding Has been slashed by the federal— at the federal and state levels.
That makes local dollars here in the city even more critical than ever.
So I ask, why are we cutting the one tool proven to immediately keep people in their homes?
In the last 5 years, the city has spent over $300 million on sweeps and shelters, and yet there remains a persistent refusal to invest in the same— with the same urgency in the upstream, uh, Investments that keep people in their homes.
I urge the council to pass this resolution, but I also ask you to honor its original intent to stop people from falling into homelessness today, not years from now.
Also, we're going to be canvassing Districts 3 and 4 in the upcoming months, and we will be telling tenants, councilors who decided to cut these funds.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Thank you for your testimony.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Becky Strauss, Sonia Goodstephani, Leslie Nelson.
Jamie Dunphy
All right, Becky, go ahead.
Becky Strauss
Thank you.
Good evening, Councilor Dunphy, President Dunphy, City Councilor.
My name is Becky Strauss.
I'm with the Oregon Law Center.
I'm the managing attorney of our Eviction Defense Project.
We have a current contract through the Portland Housing Bureau to provide eviction legal defense.
Our contract pays for 2 attorneys and 1 paralegal, and we field calls from tenants across the city and connect them with resources and lawyers, including our own.
I appreciate your comments, Councilor Avalos, in the beginning about incrementalism and support as much rent assistance as possible.
That's some of our best homelessness prevention efforts that the city can be doing right now.
And I want to focus my comments on the legal services piece of the resolution.
Thank you.
Portland tenants who are facing eviction can call us.
We are the central intake line in the city of Portland for legal help for tenants.
We screen every single case that's filed in Multnomah County and statewide.
That's a growing number.
There are about 1,000 per month these days.
90% Of those are for nonpayment of rent.
We provide legal information to anyone who calls.
For tenants who become clients, we help them reach favorable settlements with their landlord.
We screen for legal defenses.
We help them soup to nuts.
Thank you.
On their case, including represent— representation in negotiations and at trial.
Any eviction legal services funding package that comes out of a resolution, we urge for the council to have all of those parts adequately funded in the legal system, not just a direct allocation to one provider.
So we urge council instead to decide together the types of services and interventions on legal support that you would like to fund.
Thank you.
Um, and then resolve the decision about the specific provider through a bid process through the Housing Bureau.
The current amendment would leave our program without additional resources to meet the growing need for our services.
So we urge an addition to the resolution that would direct resources to eviction legal defense generally and provide for a procurement process through PHB to determine how best to support all critical aspects of eviction legal defense.
Thank you.
Loretta Smith
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Becky.
Sonia.
Becky Strauss
Hello, good evening, councilors.
Uh, my name is Sonia Goodstefani.
Molly Hogan
I.
Sonia Goodstefani
Thank you for allowing me to speak today.
I am also— my team is also one of the legal organizations that is funded by the Portland Housing Bureau to provide full-scope eviction legal defense.
We were really excited by the resolution.
We were disappointed by the amendment, and then I think we're a little bit excited about Novick's amendment to the amendment.
Although being a lawyer, I'd love to see it in writing.
I'm gonna focus my testimony just on highlighting the importance of full-scope legal eviction defense.
As I said, my team has a contract with the Portland Housing Bureau for full-scope legal defense.
We represent 350 city residents a year.
Becky Strauss
Thank you.
Sonia Goodstefani
Facing eviction, from whenever we get the case to the end of the case, we have a 91% positive outcome rate.
For these cases, we track the difference between what is originally demanded by the landlord and what is ultimately settled upon on the eviction case.
For last year, when I pulled the numbers on it, we saved just over $284,000 for our tenants because of legal negotiation that took place over the course of the entire case.
Thank you.
Case, not just the initial hearing.
Through this contract, we also provide rental assistance dollars that we can use as leverage to stop evictions.
With 85% of evictions defended for nonpayment, we really need these rental assistance dollars to make a difference in people's lives.
This contract also comes with a case manager so that we can get to the root causes of evictions.
I applaud this council for the progressiveness of Providing that kind of service.
What I want to say just is that while I am constantly thrilled by the work my team does, we don't get to help enough clients.
We really look forward to this amendment passing and whatever amendments there are so that we can continue to provide these services.
Thank you for your time.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you so much.
Leslie.
Keelan McClymont
Leslie.
Leslie Nelson
Hi, council members.
My name is Leslie Nelson.
I'm a lifetime Portland resident, and I currently live in District 4.
I work along with Sonya Good Stefani, who you just heard from, at the Community Law Division of the Metropolitan Public Defender.
I've worked at the Metropolitan Public Defender for more than 35 years now as a criminal defense attorney, and then working for the past More than a decade in the Community Law Division, where I work with landlord-tenant issues, homelessness issues, and work along with Sonya on supervising the housing team with our Community Law Division.
And I would like to encourage you to allocate funds toward eviction defense and rent stabilization programs.
Every day, along with my colleagues, I see Portlanders facing eviction.
Thank you.
Families, seniors, veterans, people with disabilities, and workers who simply fell behind after a job loss, an illness, or rent increases.
Eviction is not an abstract policy issue for us.
It's something we witness in courtrooms every day and in our office with our clients, with real and immediate consequences for people's housing, health, employment, and children's well-being.
One thing's very clear from the work that we do in that is that people do better when they have attorneys.
Tenants with legal representation legal representation are far more likely to remain housed, are to be able to negotiate reasonable outcomes, and avoid the long-term harm that comes with an eviction on their record.
Access to counsel in situations where the other side almost always has representation makes the process fairer and prevents avoidable displacement of Portlanders who are in need.
I urge the councilor to invest in both robust rental assistance and legal representation for low-income tenants facing eviction.
I thank you for your time and for your commitment Thank you very much for being here.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Tyler Fellini, Jennifer Park, Aaron Meachen.
Tyler Fellini
Good evening, councilors.
My name is Tyler Fellini, and I'm the executive director of and a registered lobbyist for Portland Jobs with Justice.
I'm here today to urge you to vote yes on the Slow the Inflow resolution championed by Councilors Avalos, Dunphy, and Smith.
At Portland Jobs for Justice, we fight for the rights and dignity of working people, but we can't— The worker from their home.
A worker who doesn't know where they will sleep tonight cannot focus on their job tomorrow.
A family facing eviction is a family in economic freefall.
The numbers from the 2025 Tri-County Point-in-Time Count are more than just statistics.
They represent our neighbors, your constituents.
38% Of respondents reported that last year was their first time experiencing homelessness.
The number of BIPOC community members on our streets has almost doubled since 2023.
We need funding now to slow the inflow.
In the past 5 years, the city has spent $325 million solely on sweeps and shelters.
How many Portlanders could that have kept housed?
The last-minute cuts to rent assistance in this resolution are deeply disappointing.
While the development of affordable housing is an essential investment, it is a tool that is already funded with federal and state dollars, while direct eviction prevention has been slashed enormously at every level of government.
The original resolution directed $21 million in unexpected funds exactly where they belong—.
Unidentified speaker
Prevention.
Tyler Fellini
That is the most cost-effective way to address homelessness.
It is far more expensive to pull someone out of homelessness than it is to keep them in their home in the first place.
Over 2,000 Portlanders signed the Finding Home petition asking you to meet this moment and uplift Portland's working class by ensuring housing remains a human right, not a luxury good.
Vote yes on the resolution.
Use these funds to protect our people, stabilize our neighborhoods, and invest in a future where working families can actually stay in Portland.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Tyler.
Erin Meehan
Hello, thank you, uh, President Dunphy, Vice President, um, Clark, and council members.
My name is Erin Meehan, for the record, and I, uh, testified last December.
I'm really excited about the resolution, slow the inflow, um, uh, about finding that money under the, under the mattress, as, um, I think it was, uh, Councilor Zimmerman mentioned something about that.
Um, here's the deal though.
That's what happened to that original resolution.
The amendments reduced prevention from eviction and stabilization efforts and emergency voucher support.
This is a stabilization effort.
What happened to that?
I don't know if you know, but I'm on the Housing Stability Council.
I'm not here as a council member.
I'm actually a resident of Gresham.
I also worked for Community Alliance of Tenants, where I was laid off due to the 75% cuts to the budget for stabilization programs and tenant education.
Mediation works.
I've been in that courtroom with an eviction.
I've been on both sides of that fence.
Have you been to the courtroom to listen, to see, to hear these stories, and to see what these defense attorneys do to help these folks that are going through an eviction?
Unidentified speaker
It's amazing work.
Thank you.
Erin Meehan
I don't really understand what the amendment is.
I do support the stop the inflow the way that it was originally put forth.
I do know that part of the problem I feel really on these developments is, are we talking to our other government partners?
Has anybody spoken to anybody at Oregon Housing Community Services and discussed the Broadway Corridor Project and how in December, as a matter of fact, they were— Housing Stability Council passed for The past, um, you know, for them to have an impact statement for over like $40 million.
Are we working together with our account, with your government agencies across the board here to find out what's going on around us so that we can put this money to where it's supposed to be for housing stabilization?
I hope that we can do that.
Collaborative inquiries, roadside needs, and testimonies from the orgs named in this amended resolution should guide you back as proposed in December to stop the inflow.
Thank you.
Thank you so much for your time.
Jennifer Park
Good evening, councilors.
My name is Jennifer Park.
She/they.
Focusing on priorities that slow the inflow into houselessness is the right approach at the right time to actualize the outcomes to the mission of the 2018 Residential Rental Registration and Fee Ordinance.
Quote, to provide essential support for existing and potential tenant protection policies of the city.
Preventing evictions before they occur is one of the most cost-effective steps toward addressing our homelessness crisis and results in approximately 4x social return on investment, including improved educational outcomes, Lower healthcare usage, and the decreased use of homeless services.
Missed rent payments are the cause of over 90% of local evictions, dramatically spiking from 13% 5 years ago this month during Oregon's COVID eviction moratorium era.
As you debate and discuss your multifarious legislations around homelessness and housing, I ask that you reflect on a few considerations.
Number one, Where does the homelessness to housing continuum really begin?
If we think of the start of the continuum at the point at which people are already houseless, not when their housing becomes unstable, we're trying to screw the cap onto a running hydrant.
Number 2, for 6 years I worked in permanent supportive housing of high acuity chronically homeless adults.
No one is unhousable.
To believe that is to believe that housing is not a human right and somehow a person can be undeserving of the barest necessity for stability and health.
Due to the testimony time constraint, I will submit the rest of my testimony, references, and data sources to your offices directly.
Thank you for your time.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Jennifer.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Skyler Cruz, Jonathan Greenwood, Jesse Moran.
Jesse, go ahead and unmute.
Jesse Moran
Um, thank you for the opportunity to speak.
My name is Jesse Moran.
I'm currently a Brooklyn neighborhood resident.
When I saw that the city would be expelling people from shelters for failing to properly engage with the system within the system's timeline, I was reminded of several friends I made back in 2019 while working with my Sunnyside neighbors to get the shower project and Beacon Village up and running.
Several of the folks who came in regular that first year started out as just being between places.
They'd never been homeless before.
They were bright-eyed.
They were funny.
They were employed.
They were fed.
They were just living rough until they could get that housing part stabilized.
Within a year, every one of those folks had been arrested, were experiencing addiction, had experienced severe mental health breaks on our facilities, and 2 had died.
They had crossed an invisible line into another world.
The thing about living unhoused is that it's a different country.
The rules, the customs, the language, the necessary survival skills are all different, unfamiliar.
Thank you.
And very often invisible to those of us who live in houses, who get water when we turn on our tap and find our garbage magically whisked away on a regular schedule.
Not everybody who crosses that line survives, and once you've crossed, it can be extremely challenging to get back to the land of the housed again.
I've only lived in Portland for a couple of decades, but in my short time here, the one consistent thread has been the commitment of the entitled class.
Order.
Representing the mayor's office and the council to speak aspirational words, to act in political self-interest, to fund bureaucracy, and to push the hard work out to the community level.
I respectfully request that the diversion of monies to the general fund be rejected and that council tangibly protect your constituents from the mental and physical, in addition to financial damage of housing instability by providing direct rental support on balance with eviction protection.
Thank you for the opportunity to speak to you, and thank you for everyone who signed up to testify tonight.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Jesse.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you for being here.
Keelan McClymont
Uh, okay.
Um, Skylar Cruz, Jonathan Greenwood.
Okay.
Um, let's move on to Jeremy Smith.
Diane Meisenhelter and Jamie Partridge.
Jeremy Bosley-Smith
My name is Jeremy Bosley-Smith.
I live in District 4 in the Lair Hill neighborhood.
All of us should be able to afford to live in Portland.
Housing is a human right.
Rental assistance is critical to slowing the inflow into homelessness.
Welcome Home Coalition surveyed over 400 people experiencing homelessness, and 91% of them ranked rent assistance as their top We need to slow the amount of evictions because once people are on the streets, it's exponentially more difficult to get them back into housing.
Skyrocketing rents make it harder for working-class people to thrive in our city.
Half of Portland renters pay over 30% of what they make on housing.
This is completely unsustainable.
I'm a proud supporter of the Renters' Bill of Rights.
I believe we should require a 6-month notice before all rent increases.
Protect children and education workers from eviction during the school year, and cap fees such as pet rent, late fees, laundry fees, and other excessive charges and deposits, as well as requiring that code violations be resolved before rent can be increased.
These protections are not included in this bill but should be in future legislation because all of us should be able to afford to live in Portland.
What is included in this bill is the Legal Counsel Pilot Program.
This is a vital piece to keeping Portlanders in their homes and ensuring that we can all live happy and fulfilling lives.
Evictions are violence against the working class, and they leave a wound inflicted on our community that is not easily healed.
We need to meet the moment.
Portlanders elected you to take bold action.
I support Councilor Avalos, Smith, and Dunphy's original Slow the Inflow bill and urge every council member to vote yes on it.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Jeremy.
Go ahead, Diane.
Unidentified speaker
Okay.
As someone who in the past served on Portland's Housing and Community Development Commission, directed a local community development corporation which worked to create low-income housing, and has spent many nights working emergency shelters, I can say without a doubt that shelters have never been the answer to homelessness, and Portland's housing problems will continue to worsen if we do not heed the research and recommendations put forward by the Welcome Home Coalition.
Right now, as state and federal governments slash funding, preventing evictions is the first stopgap measure that must be taken to prevent— to protect low-income renters from becoming homeless, and rental assistance is critical for helping those who are homeless obtain housing and stabilize their lives.
Housing advocates and concerned Portlanders have made it very clear that it's absolutely key to redirect funds towards eviction prevention, Rental assistance and peer support plus case management for pathways out of shelter and into housing.
And this is particularly true for families below 50% median family income.
I'm very, very— I was very supportive of the original goals of the Slow the Inflow proposals, but I'm very disappointed and upset about the proposed amendments that would take almost $10 million out of those original goals.
Housing development is a long-term process, and we have a really vital crisis on our hands right now.
I oppose us— I really encourage you to go back to the, to the table and work through this, reinstitute that original intent.
I really am appalled I'm appalled by the idea of diverting these funds to the general fund.
That is just totally not acceptable.
And we really, really need— a lot of the housing development that's happening in Portland right now does not address the needs of our lowest-income families, and that needs to be our focus with very scarce public resources.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Diane.
Jamie, go ahead.
Jamie Partridge
Good evening.
Um, I'm Jamie Partridge, retired letter carrier, uh, in District 2.
I've seen plenty of homelessness in my work on the streets of Portland.
Uh, sweeps and temporary shelter do nothing to decrease homelessness.
Every one of my houseless friends wants the dignity and privacy of a home, not having to be stuffed into a room with dozens of strangers where harassment and abuse are rampant and where they can't bring their dog or partner.
And sweeps and criminalizing sleeping in public cause great harm, including physical and mental breakdown, addiction, and even death.
We need to slow the inflow into homelessness with rental assistance, eviction defense, and affordable housing— most importantly, non-market social housing.
Thank you.
The last-minute cuts to rent assistance in this resolution are deeply disappointing.
Why are we making cuts to dollars that keep someone in their home to invest in projects that are years out and will substantial— will have substantial waitlists?
These amendments will create homelessness today.
Out-of-control rents in the city make it harder for working-class people to live in today.
As many have said, 50% of Portland renters currently pay more than 30% of their income to stay housed.
In the past 5 years, the city has spent $325 million solely on sweeps and shelters, yet there remains a persistent refusal to give everyday Portlanders what they need the most— help to stay in their housing.
Renters living on low incomes deserve the same urgency with which the city rolled out shelter beds, or else our city will continue to push people into homelessness.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Councilmember Thank you, Jamie.
And colleagues, I just want to very quickly note, Jamie Partridge was our 19th piece of testimony.
We have 72 people signed up tonight, and clearly we are not going to get through everybody.
It is my hope to get to our 30th person in line, and we will hold— we are going to be hearing additional remainder of testimony of folks who were unable to be heard tonight next Wednesday when we hear the remainder and move to council deliberation on it.
Thank you.
And Keelan, sorry to interrupt.
Could you please call the next panel?
Keelan McClymont
John Hollister, Michelle Alajmi, Lily Bernas.
All right, let's jump to Maddie Garrison, Justice Reggie.
Um, oh, sorry.
Unidentified speaker
I'm just as friendly.
I didn't know what—.
Keelan McClymont
Oh yeah, sure, come on up.
Unidentified speaker
Thanks.
Jamie Dunphy
Welcome and go ahead, jump on in.
Justin Faraji
Thank you.
Thank you.
My name is Justin Faraji.
I'm the Director of Advocacy for Urban League Portland.
Um, here tonight, uh, I want to share that public dollars are a precious resource that need to be maximized for the greatest impact.
They should be spent in a timely manner, ethically prioritize immediate conditions and future needs.
We appreciate Portland City Council's work on moving to get these funds that were not put into action in the past or in the same manner that they were originally brought into the city's control.
And we appreciate the decision to focus on rent stabilization with a deep understanding that even where this current amendment lands is not where it started.
Yeah.
Um, circumstance where folks largely agree and have committed their life and time and agency to make sure that folks can get everything that they need, um, are landed in a place where they're almost at odds with each other about doing the right thing, which is a very, very uncomfortable place that community constantly finds itself with government, that we have to fight a moral position and also an outcome position.
And we're landing in this place where some of those who are better resourced than us Yes.
Don't have to deal with the stress and the strain of how this communication happened and ultimately may not face the people day to day that need these resources most.
So while we definitely 100% support passing this resolution, we want to see it as the agreement is presented to us today be the way that we move forward and that we do not experience circumstances where we are continuing to have a refight of a decision that has already put many people at odds and threatened and raised their cortisol levels Well, they're just trying to do the right thing, make sure people stay housed, and we also make a way for the future.
Keelan McClymont
Thank you for your time.
Lori Palmer
Hi.
Keelan McClymont
Go ahead.
Jung Ho
Hello, councilors.
My name is Jung Ho, and I am the Tenant Education and Support Director and also interim co-executive Co-executive director at CAT, Community Alliance of Tenants.
I'm here to support the Slow the Inflow resolution, the original proposal.
I am, as many have said, disappointed to see the last-minute amendments.
Now more than ever, we really do need to prioritize these funds for eviction and homelessness prevention and landlord-tenant education as well.
Tenant education is tenant empowerment.
Thank you.
There are organizations such as CAT that have been doing this upstream work to help people stay housed and prevent evictions for decades.
CAT runs effective, well-established programs with longtime support from the City of Portland's Housing Bureau to help tenants on our renters' rights hotline through our tenant protections teamwork with— in partnership with SCI, Apano, ERCO, Legal Aid, Portland Defender, and many partner referrals and resources.
Many of our organizations have faced severe budget cuts this year, leading to reductions in our own services and staffing, meaning layoff of highly skilled and compassionate workers.
We absolutely need to see this $20.1 million allocated to rent assistance, eviction defense, tenant education empowerment, housing vouchers during this type of crisis.
And thank you so much for allowing me to provide my testimony again.
Thank you.
Keelan McClymont
Next up, we have Devin Ruiz, Bernabe Ruiz, Michelle Hornbeck.
Jamie Dunphy
Welcome.
Devin Ruiz
Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of council.
My name is Devin Ruiz.
I live in District 2 in Cully, and I'm a registered lobbyist for NextUp.
We are a local nonprofit, nonpartisan organization, and we work to amplify the voice and leadership of diverse young people.
As an organization that supports young working-class people, we know housing is a human right, and we know firsthand because we see the struggle our young people are facing with securing sustained and affordable housing.
There must be urgency behind ensuring that all Portlanders have stable and secure housing.
As such, we urge you to pass Slow Thank you.
Councilmember Herbold.
Thank you, Mayor.
I'm here to support the Slow the Inflow resolution and oppose the Slow the Inflow as initially passed in the Housing and Homelessness Committee.
And we do not support the last-minute cuts to rental assistance for this ordinance.
The original Slow the Inflow resolution addresses the root issues of Portland's homelessness crisis.
Each month, 1,400 people lose housing while only 1,100 people are able to find it again, presenting a gap of 300 people per month who are— who may be left unhoused.
Over 90% of evictions in Multnomah County are due to to missed rental payments.
The ordinance passed in the Finance Committee and the amendments presented today seem to be responding to a reality where we can meet the needs of Portlanders by predominantly building our way out of this crisis.
The amendments do not achieve the original goal of this resolution to immediately stop people from falling into homelessness.
Our state and federal governments have slashed funding for rent assistance and other services that would otherwise keep people in their homes.
Councilmember We must use our local funding to fill this critical gap while investing in our future.
Using rental service office dollars to keep people housed is urgent and evidence-based.
Data shows that young people are disproportionately impacted, as those under 35 make up the largest percentage of renters in Portland.
Please fund rental assistance, fund rapid rehousing for people evicted from their homes, fund emergency housing vouchers.
Please support Slow the Flow as written without cuts to rental assistance.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you.
And I will submit my full remarks as written testimony.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Devin.
Barnaby
I am Barnaby, and I'm a person with lived experience.
Um, in the late 1980s, the 1990s, I used to work in agriculture, but in early 2000s I lost my sight.
Because of that, I fall in depression and I can't pay my rent anymore, and I become homeless.
I remain homeless for the next 14 years.
In 2014, I come to Portland.
3 Years later, in 2017, I get rent assistance and I start living in a place that I call home today.
And, uh, I remember that I used to sleep under those Portland bridges alongside train tracks on the sidewalks under the cold Portland rain.
And tonight I'm just finding this vote of, uh, this low resolution because I don't want nobody else to sleep under those bridges alongside those train tracks.
Thank you.
On the sidewalks, under the Portland Boulevard, right?
Because that's fucked up.
I want it more, and thank you for listening to me.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you, Barney.
Marlon Luther
Um, I'm on Rutherford Green.
Unidentified speaker
I think I'm going blue.
Marlon Luther
I got a piece of paper.
My name is Marlon Luther for green, um, with Wong Wong.
But I got a piece of paper because they're here to tell you things.
But I'm actually— live experience.
I think I'm the only one going to actually go to a shelter tonight.
That's about a year and a half of, uh, being here.
I heard one, one of the ladies said that she woke domestic violence for women.
I'm a victim of domestic violence.
And my baby's mom came here and got funding to be able to have a place.
I didn't fight it because I didn't want my kids to be in this situation tomorrow.
I don't want to be in this situation.
I work 3 jobs.
I'm actually going to go work with the homeless at Hygiene for All tomorrow.
Worked yesterday, just got off of work from the Blazers today.
Shouldn't be homeless.
And I agree with the first initial thing.
I was one of the people that testified before, and I'm just hoping that people actually get it.
House.
I've been in 3 shelters.
Ain't nobody getting housed.
They even— they getting kicked out of the shelters.
They're fighting in the shelters.
I'm in the shelters.
Nobody's getting home housed.
That's it.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you for being here.
Keelan McClymont
Uh, Michelle Thank you, Councilor Hornbeck.
Uh, Lorena Mora is joining us online.
Lorena, go ahead and unmute.
Lorena Mora
Good evening, City Council members.
Thank you for the opportunity to speak in support of the Slow the Inflow resolution.
My name is Lorena Mora, and I'm the Programs and Partnership Manager at Division Midway Alliance, and we're also a member of Welcome Home.
We are a place-based nonprofit committed to building a socially and economically resilient, safe, and healthier East Portland, delivering services through our 5 community-driven programs in District 1.
One of the core areas of our direct assistance program is supporting low-income immigrant and refugee renters through rental assistance and housing stability support.
Between 2022 and 2024, Division Midway Alliance supported 248 households, and 81% of those households received services in languages other than English.
Thank you.
Including Arabic, Chinese, Nepali, Burmese, Karen, Spanish, and Vietnamese.
During the pandemic, we worked with families experiencing job loss and eviction risk.
I want to share one example.
We supported a Karen family with 5 children and another household led by a single mother with a disabled child.
Both families were just a few days from being evicted and had no income.
With short-term rent assistance, we covered past due rent and several months of future rent, giving them time to stabilize, find work, and avoid homelessness.
Thank you.
This rental assistance funding ended early 2024, but the need did not end.
We still receive around 45 to 50 requests for support monthly, and now many immigrant families are losing income due to ICE activity impacts, putting more households at risk for eviction.
In 2024, one elderly Spanish-speaking lady lost her apartment and became homeless just 3 days before Christmas.
After many calls, we were able to secure shelter placement, but she still has not found stable housing.
These are preventable crises.
That is why we strongly urge the council to vote yes on the original Slow the Inflow resolution today.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Keelan McClymont
Naomi Vigos.
All right, Council President, that is number 30.
Would you like me—.
Jamie Dunphy
Colleagues, I would like to ask, uh, and if anybody has any objections, I'd like to ask for 10 more minutes, um, to try and see if we can get any additional people, especially folks who have hung around in person tonight.
Keelan McClymont
Uh, okay, so I think anyone in the room in person Um, if we could just have you come on up.
Barnaby
Oh, thank you.
Keelan McClymont
Um, why don't we go—.
Lauren Armony
No, this is like hour 15 from—.
Keelan McClymont
Oh, ready?
Barnaby
My turn?
Keelan McClymont
Yeah, you can sit here.
So go ahead and, uh, state your name for the record and you may begin.
Thank you.
Unidentified speaker
All right, my name is Mitch.
I'm Vice President of AFSCME Local 1790, representing behavioral work, health workers, and shelter staff.
City, um, I came here to speak to the original unamended resolution.
I worked today and did not have time to change what I was going to say, so I'm going to have to improvise on the fly.
Lauren Armony
Yes.
Unidentified speaker
So today at work, I had a number of people on my caseload.
I'm a case manager at one of the city's alternative shelters.
Um, I had a number of people on my caseload express the desire to end their lives, um, if they're not able to find placement up shelter.
And a number of these people are income constrained on SSI or SSDI, meaning their income does not even come close to the minimum thresholds for these so-called low-income buildings.
Um, in light of that, I'm disgusted, appalled by the decision to give the money that is intended for The people I serve and people like them, or people at risk of falling, all this might continue to— that suggestion is, is honestly disgusting.
And to me, you must not do that.
You must not do that.
What are the people on my caseload supposed to do?
What are they supposed to do?
They make $1,100 a month at maximum.
If they work, their, their income will offset those benefits and it will net $1,100 a month.
What are they supposed to do about these buildings that might exist in the future?
What are they supposed to do?
And this is without getting into the, the large number of people who were exited from shelters, um, in the first week of January for alleged non-engagement.
What were they supposed to do?
What were they supposed to do?
That's all I got.
Lauren Armony
Thank you.
All right, good evening, councilors.
Uh, my name is Lauren Armony and I'm with Welcome Home Coalition.
However, I don't think I got this message approved by my boss, so I can represent myself.
I support the initial intent of the Slow the Inflow resolution to keep people in their homes and exit them out of homelessness.
But I'm going to be very frank with you.
As you've heard, after 6 weeks of waiting for this resolution to hit council, to have an amendment come in 12 hours ahead of a scheduled meeting is inexcusable.
Y'all got to get your stuff together.
And to hear you, Councilor Novick, Propose eliminating all rental assistance is frankly appalling.
How dare you say that in front of this room of people who sacrificed getting into shelter, going home.
We're going to be going out into freezing temperatures.
All right.
We see who of you tried to divide us with these individual appropriations.
I want you to know it did not work.
It will not work.
We will not be divided.
We are united in knowing that the biggest barrier for people in Portland staying housed is affordability.
All right.
Do not play with us.
Thank you.
This $21 million was not going to end homelessness in Portland.
However, it can be much better used than what is currently proposed in this amendment, what I'm hearing you propose, Councilor Novick.
It can fill these gaping holes, government cuts.
All right, until you are all together to make housing affordable for all, invest in rent assistance.
All right, it is the best, best To keep people in their homes.
It is not a Band-Aid.
It creates stability so people can create the lives that they want and contribute to our community.
People can't afford these affordable housing units without this rent assistance.
However, I still urge you to approve this.
Some rental assistance.
All right, please reappropriate the funds for the Broadway Quarter Redevelopment Project back into the emergency housing vouchers for Home Forward residents losing theirs.
Many thanks to Councilor Green highlighting how social housing will create more housing stability and community wealth over homeownership so that I don't have to.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you.
All right, Miss Lori, take it.
Keelan McClymont
Take it.
Oh, ready?
Lori Palmer
Yes, I'm just going to read right off here.
Good evening, um, Council President and councilors.
Thank you for allowing me to speak tonight.
My name is Lori Palmer.
I am the founder of Go Get Your Child Community And I'm on here on behalf of Welcome Home Portland-Linton.
I'm asking you to please vote yes to pass the resolution.
Rent assistance is powerful.
It's a powerful tool to stabilize households that are close to homelessness or trying to exit homelessness.
We need our local funding to prevent households from falling into homelessness.
Councilmember Linton.
Yes.
Because right now our current system is currently not working.
It's not working at all.
Prevent eviction before they occur is the most cost-effective way to address— We, when someone misses rent, it's often one crisis, loss of hours, medical bills, a family emergency that pushes them over the edge.
Rent assistance is the bridge that keeps families stable and prevents a preventable eviction.
That data also shows who is being hit the hardest.
The 2025 Tri-County Point in Time count shows that number of BIPOC community members experiencing homelessness has almost doubled since 2023, and it also found that 38% of representatives said that last year was the first time experiencing homelessness.
This is not a coincidence.
State and federal governments have slashed funding for rent assistance and other services to keep people in their homes.
And local government has to fill this gap while we build.
In 1994, a Portland Metro survey found that 91% of the people experiencing homelessness said rent assistance is the need to get housed and stay housed.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you so much.
Lori Palmer
And our community needs mandated access.
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you.
Action now.
Keelan McClymont
Um, how many other people?
One, one more?
Okay, come on up.
Jamie Dunphy
Okay, these will be our last testifiers.
Thank you all for being here so late with us.
Ben Gilbert
My name is Ben Gilbert, and I'm a volunteer lobbyist for the Portland chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America and a tenant in District 4.
Yesterday, as I marched to protest federal ICE overreach, I saw, like I do every day, our fellow Portlanders sleeping on the sidewalk.
We're experiencing a crisis in the city, a crisis of rising rent, of rising rents and wages that don't keep up, and false solutions like overnight shelters and sweeps.
Portlanders deserve more.
I support Slow the Inflow.
However, the last-minute cuts to rent assistance in this resolution are deeply disappointing.
I was looking forward to testifying in support of this proposal because of its immediate relief for the people who are most at risk of homelessness today.
These amendments do not help us achieve the original goal of this resolution to immediately stop people from falling into homelessness.
Out-of-control rents make our city harder for working-class people to live in.
50% Of Portland renters, um, are rent burdened, paying more than 30% of their income to stay housed.
And in the past 5 years, the city has spent $325 million solely on sweeps and shelters.
Yet there remains a persistent refusal to give everyday—.
Mitch Green
To get money out, um, help provide housing to our citizens.
Uh, my name is Mitch Green, and as the president of the Williams and Russell CDC, A nonprofit committed to reparative development.
We know the value of affordable affordability in both housing rentals and homeownership.
Throughout our process, we have talked to hundreds of our community members who were displaced by the expansion of MaineHealth Hospital.
A common refrain that we heard from the community was the importance of housing for both those struggling to afford rentals.
Uh, as well as wealth restoration and building for those in our community who were displaced by the city through urban renewal actions and who are struggling to afford homeownership.
For a long-term solution to the housing crisis, we need to emphasize both rental and homeownership affordability.
We greatly appreciate the council's consideration of support for us and many other great organizations as we try to bring more affordable housing to the city.
Thank you.
The Williams and Russell housing projects will provide 20 affordable townhomes, 85 affordable apartments, and we're working on a future project that will provide some more affordable homes for people to purchase.
Our projects will provide housing to folks who make between 30% and 100%.
The first housing project will be completed around this time next year, and this funding will support that.
Self-Enhancement Inc.
Is another great organization that provides rental and homeownership support, knowing that stable housing environment is necessary for successful students and stable families.
And as an attorney, and in my role at Williams and Russell, I've seen the good work that the Commons Law Center, uh, does for people that our legal community struggles to adequately serve, and I support funding their services.
Thank you.
Know that the money that you are considering allocating to these organizations will go to house our community members and will help provide an avenue to make rents, restore lost wealth, and maintain housing stability.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you.
Thank you so much for being here.
Saham McKelvey
Good evening, Council President Dunphy and members of the council.
My name is Saham McKelvey, and I'm a member of the Wealth Home Steering Committee and the Director of Advocacy and Engagement at Self Enhancement Inc., or SCI.
I'm here to support the amended resolution put forward by Councilors Davalos, Smith, and Dunphy, and would like to thank the councilors who work collaboratively on these amendments.
My hope is that this level of collaboration is a foundation for the future to serve this city with the excellence that comes from all of us contributing our ideas into the pool of shared meaning.
The reality is that our city faces significant needs with regards to housing access, availability, and affordability.
I testified before the Housing Committee when this resolution was introduced.
I do not want to debate the weight of our various needs.
However, when we are put in a position to weigh the merits of multiple council proposals, then we are forced to minimize one need to uplift another.
My hope would be that we move beyond this dynamic in the future.
Thank you, Councilor Mitch Green.
And are able to collectively partner to execute the business of addressing needs and not debating them.
I've sat in front of this body multiple times and said that housing is a housing problem.
I've also sat in front of this body and called for eviction prevention and rent assistance to create alignment in our housing system.
I know we have limited resources to address our challenges.
I also know that the only path to maximizing the impact of our limited resources is to work together, not just within the city, but with the county, with Metro, and with the state.
We have to be intentional in building a system that is greater than the sum of our limited revenue.
I speak to you today as a representative of the communities that we are all called to serve.
SEI provides a huge array of services that meet a multitude of needs.
We know that every need of every community member is vitally important.
Lens to speak from, to partner with each of you to create a housing system that can meet this moment.
So please vote to approve, but please remember the missteps and the positive steps that brought us here so that we can all be better going forward.
Unidentified speaker
Thank you.
Jamie Dunphy
Thank you very much for being here tonight.
Colleagues, I'd If that concludes anyone who's physically in person who is interested in testifying, I believe I'm just gonna look at Keelan.
Okay.
Colleagues, it is my intention to— we have only made it about halfway through the list of folks who are signed up to testify on this.
We have already scheduled this to continue this hearing over to next Wednesday.
Testimony signups are now closed, but we will do our best to try and follow up with the folks who have signed up but did not get a chance to testify.
We'll hear from them, and then we will, as a body, move towards conversation around the amendments.
Before we adjourn for the night, I see a couple of hands in the queue from our colleagues.
I would like to give them the opportunity to speak.
Thank you, Mayor.
Councilor Morillo.
Angelita Morillo
Thank you, Council President Dunphy.
I just wanted to address the folks who are in the room and the folks who are still online right now.
I apologize for having to be off camera a bit.
I'm not feeling super well today, and then my signal was kind of bad, and I wanted to make sure I could hear people's testimony.
I just want to say that I am eternally grateful for you coming out tonight and for sharing your testimony and For being here and foregoing possibly a shelter bed for some of you tonight to come and tell us what you need.
And I am extremely frustrated with my colleagues that we have proposals that are being brought forward that you're testifying on that are being changed last minute due to— I don't even know what I would call it, probably not something I can say and maintain my decorum, but It's a measuring contest of sorts.
And I think that people need to be prepared to justify the amendments that they are— they have brought forward next time, because I will be pushing for the original proposal.
That is what the community asked of us.
That was what originally was brought forward.
And I don't approve of this watered-down proposal.
It's just, it feels Wrong in my spirit to push that forward.
So I really hope that the people who did make those negotiations to change it last minute are prepared to defend it next time because I have a lot of questions about how that went.
Thank you for being here today.
Jamie Dunphy
Okay, with that, I will— I am adjourning this meeting of the Portland City Council.
Thank you all for your patience with bizarre night we had.
Thank you all.
