windowbox

Portland City Council Special Session

Official agenda

Transcript

Transcript

Automatically generated transcript. It may contain errors and includes testimony in languages other than English that is not individually marked up for assistive technology.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 8:14 - 8:24

8:14Good afternoon.

8:16It is 1:03 on Tuesday, June 10th.

8:20I am calling our council meeting to order.

Keelan McClymont 8:26 - 8:26

8:26Aye.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 8:26 - 9:10

8:26We have a number of, a number of agenda items that we are going to open today.

8:37Most of which we are not going to do a lot with today.

8:42But this is where we start to do more of the technical pieces of the budget.

8:48We're going to go through some of those technical pieces of the budget right now, and then we will hear public testimony, and then we will have time to do a little bit more with amendments on the budget.

9:03Thank you.

9:04We will pick up where we left off tomorrow.

9:08Keelan, could you please call the roll?

Karen Chire 9:13 - 9:13

9:13Here.

Keelan McClymont 9:15 - 9:17

9:15Here.

Karen Chire 9:22 - 9:22

9:22Here.

Keelan McClymont 9:22 - 9:22

9:22Green.

Karen Chire 9:23 - 9:25

9:23Here.

9:24Zimmerman.

Keelan McClymont 9:25 - 9:27

9:25Avalos.

9:27Dunphy.

Dilgash Ahmadi 9:27 - 9:28

9:27Smith.

Michelle Miller 9:28 - 9:32

9:28Smith.

9:32Here.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 9:33 - 9:36

9:33And Robert, could you please read us our rules of decorum?

Robert Taylor 9:36 - 10:57

9:36Thank you.

9:38Welcome everyone to the Portland City Council.

9:42To testify before council in person or virtually, you must please sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

9:54Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

9:59Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

10:04Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

10:07Presiding officer preserves order.

10:10Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

10:21If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

10:24Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

10:28Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

10:33Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

10:38Your testimony should please address the matter being considered.

10:42When testifying, please state your name for the record.

10:45Your address is not necessary.

10:47If you are a lobbyist, please identify the organization you represent.

10:51Thank you.

10:52Virtual testifiers should please unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

10:57Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 10:59 - 11:17

10:59Thank you, Mr. Taylor.

11:02Keelan, could you please read agenda items 1 through— is it 1 through 6?

11:12There are 7 things here and my script says 1 through 6.

Keelan McClymont 11:19 - 11:19

11:19The first—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 11:19 - 11:20

11:19Agenda approval.

Keelan McClymont 11:20 - 11:21

11:20Yeah.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 11:21 - 11:24

11:21Got it.

11:21Okay.

11:22Could you please read agenda item 1?

Joe Jackson 11:25 - 11:26

11:25Ah, yes.

Keelan McClymont 11:26 - 11:33

11:26Item 1, agenda approval.

11:28Council will vote to approve the agenda, to reorder items on the agenda, or to add an item to the next meeting's agenda.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 11:34 - 11:40

11:34Thank you.

11:34Colleagues, are there any requests to amend or reorder the agenda?

Michelle Miller 11:45 - 11:45

11:45Okay.

Keelan McClymont 11:46 - 12:42

11:46Item 2, conduct a proposed use hearing on state shared revenue.

11:52Item 3, certify that certain services are provided by the city to establish eligibility for state shared revenue.

11:59Item 4, approve accepting funds from the State of Oregon under the State Revenue Sharing Program for fiscal year beginning July 1st, 2025 and ending June 30th, 2026.

12:11Item 5, adopt the annual budget of the city and establish appropriations for the fiscal year beginning July 1st, 2025, and ending June 30th, 2026.

12:22Item 6, approve levying taxes for the city for the fiscal year beginning July 1st, 2025, and ending June 30th, 2026.

12:30And item 7, authorize a temporary interfund loan not to exceed $50 million from the Portland Parks and Recreation System Development Charge Fund to the Fire and Police Disability and Retirement Fund.

Karen Chire 12:42 - 12:42

12:42Second.

Keelan McClymont 12:43 - 12:52

12:43Fund to provide interim financing for fiscal year 2025 through '26 cash flow deficit due to the timing of property tax collections.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 12:53 - 13:17

12:53Thank you, Keelan.

12:55So colleagues, before we start taking on each of these agenda items, which we will do some brief work on today, hear some public testimony on, and then spend most of our time on agenda item 5, Budget Director Levine is going to go over our process in a little bit more detail.

13:12Director Levine, could you please sure, thank you.

Ruth Levine 13:17 - 14:09

13:17And for the record, Ruth Levine, the Director of the City Budget Office.

13:21Good afternoon, Council President, City Council.

13:25So as Council President mentioned, we're here today for the next steps in adopting the budget for fiscal year 2025-26.

13:31Following today and tomorrow's proceedings, the budget ordinance will pass to second reading and Council will vote on all of the budget items on June 18th.

13:38There are a number of procedural steps we need to go through, and as Keelan read into the record, We have 6 items in front of you that are part of this process.

13:46The first 3 items relate to the acceptance and use of state shared revenues in our budget.

13:51Revenues shared by the State of Oregon primarily consist of cigarette, liquor, and retail marijuana taxes.

13:57So first, council will hold a proposed use hearing on the state shared revenue.

14:02Then you will consider a resolution certifying that the city meets the eligibility requirements of state shared revenue, and then you will consider an ordinance accepting the state shared revenue.

Michelle Miller 14:09 - 14:10

14:09Thank you.

Ruth Levine 14:11 - 14:53

14:11The 4th and 5th items, numbers 6 and 7 on the agenda, that council will consider today and tomorrow are— or today are the ordinance levying taxes and an interfund loan between the Parks Capital Fund and the Fire, Police, and Disability and Retirement Fund, which addresses technical timing issues with the FPDR revenues.

14:32And the 6th and final item, which is item number 5 on the agenda, that council will consider is the adopted budget ordinance, and that will be obviously the focus of your time today and tomorrow.

14:44So with that overview, we can begin with our first item, the state shared revenue hearing.

14:48Council President, you can open the state shared revenue hearing.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 14:55 - 15:28

14:55Thank you.

14:55So we actually have all 6 of these open.

15:02So we are going into a hearing, colleagues, to discuss proposed uses of state revenue sharing.

15:11This hearing is being held by the City Council in compliance with the provisions of state revenue sharing regulations, which are in ORS 221.770, to allow Portlanders to comment on the possible use of the funds in conjunction with the annual budget process.

Karen Chire 15:29 - 15:30

15:29Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 15:30 - 16:02

15:30As proposed for council adoption for fiscal year 2025-26, the budget anticipates receiving $21 million from state revenue sharing under ORS 221-770.

15:45As has been the case in prior years, it's proposed that this revenue be allocated in equal parts to support fire prevention and police patrol services.

15:54Director Levine, could you provide an overview of the eligibility for state revenue, state shared revenue resolution.

Ruth Levine 16:03 - 16:41

16:03Certainly.

16:03Council will consider a resolution to certify that the city meets the eligibility requirements for state shared revenue.

16:09State law requires that we provide a number of services to be eligible for this revenue, and this resolution certifies that we do so.

16:16The services certified by the City of Portland are police protection, fire prevention, street construction and maintenance and lighting, sanitary sewers, storm sewers, planning, zoning and subdivision control, and water.

16:28The third and final step in accepting the state shared revenue is for council to consider and vote upon the ordinance to accept state shared revenue.

16:36Once you've had a hearing and certified that the city is qualified, you need to take action to accept the revenue.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 16:42 - 17:03

16:42Thank you.

16:43And Director Levine, because this is a new process for a number of folks up here, could you just give us a brief overview of what the shared revenue comes from, what those sources are that the state collects sure, it's just state revenues from cigarette, liquor, and cannabis taxes.

Ruth Levine 17:04 - 17:09

17:04So these are statewide revenues that are shared out based on population, and Portland gets our share.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 17:10 - 17:35

17:10This is separate, colleagues, from the expenditures that we've talked about in the general fund from revenue that comes from the state.

17:16These are very specific funds that are collected from the purposes Director Levine named that are then distributed based on population across the state with limited uses.

17:28Keelan, has anybody signed up to testify on the state shared revenue hearing, resolution, or ordinance?

Keelan McClymont 17:36 - 17:42

17:36Yes, one person has signed up, Loretta Guzman.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 17:42 - 17:51

17:42Great, and colleagues, these are agenda items 2, 3, and 4 that we're talking about right now.

17:49Keelan, could you please call Loretta up?

Keelan McClymont 17:52 - 17:54

17:52Yeah, Loretta Guzman.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 17:55 - 17:57

17:55I think you might have signed up for the wrong time.

Keelan McClymont 17:59 - 18:02

17:59Oh, okay.

18:00Are you signed up for the budget adoption one?

Karen Chire 18:03 - 18:04

18:03Yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 18:04 - 18:09

18:04You're signed up for the budget.

18:06I think there's some confusion.

18:07There was some confusion with the signups.

Keelan McClymont 18:09 - 18:14

18:09Yep.

18:09Okay.

18:10Yep.

18:10I think that makes sense.

18:11We'll make sure you get called for the budget adoption.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 18:14 - 18:15

18:14Yeah.

Ahmed Alshamani 18:15 - 18:15

18:15Apologies.

Keelan McClymont 18:15 - 18:18

18:15That completes testimony for those items.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 18:18 - 18:40

18:18Okay.

18:19Colleagues, these agenda items will come back up when we hear the budget.

18:25On the 18th.

18:27But for now, we are going to— I'm making sure we're also closing agenda item 4, which is an ordinance.

18:38I'm looking to you, Ruth.

18:39Are we closing all 3 of them?

Ruth Levine 18:41 - 18:46

18:41That's right.

18:42Continuing them to June 18th.

18:44And then you're going to close the state shared revenue hearing.

Michelle Miller 18:46 - 18:46

18:46Right.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 18:47 - 19:33

18:47So for now, we are closing the state shared revenue hearing.

18:50And we are going to move— we're going to I'm going to skip agenda item 5, colleagues, which is our annual budget, and move on to agenda item 6, which is the tax levy ordinance.

19:05This is the action that allows us to levy property taxes that accrue to the general fund, the parks local option levy fund, the recently renewed children's investment fund, and the fire and police disability and retirement fund.

19:21It also includes property tax levies for general obligation bonded debt and our 6 urban renewal areas.

19:30Keelan, has anyone signed up to testify on the tax levies ordinance?

Keelan McClymont 19:35 - 19:57

19:35Let me check here.

19:41We have 2 people signed up to testify on that item, Karen Chire and Matt Nicholson.

19:56Karen Chire, Matt Nicholson.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 20:00 - 20:08

20:00And Karen and Matt, if either of you had meant to sign up for agenda item 5, please let our clerk know and she'll make sure to move you over to the other testimony list.

Keelan McClymont 20:13 - 20:18

20:13Oh, I'm sorry, I'm sorry.

20:15Oh.

20:16Council President, Matt Nicholson is online.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 20:18 - 20:31

20:18Let me go ahead and— Uh, can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 20:31 - 20:33

20:31We can hear you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 20:33 - 20:57

20:33Okay.

20:34Um, I just wanted to voice my support for, uh, the parks levy and, um, I feel that the community has a strong support for our parks, and I would encourage all councilors to put a robust levy on the November ballot to allow us to fully fund our parks and parks maintenance.

Jonas Biery 20:58 - 20:59

20:58Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 21:00 - 21:03

21:00Thank you so much.

Keelan McClymont 21:07 - 21:08

21:07And that completes testimony for that item.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 21:11 - 22:19

21:11Okay, councilors, is there any discussion on agenda item 6, the, um, tax levy ordinance?

21:21Okay, this is a first reading as well, so we will continue this agenda item to second reading on the 8th.

21:29Oh, Councilor Smith, did you have something here?

21:32Yes, Madam President.

21:33Go right ahead.

21:34I wanted to find out what is the normal process of doing inter-fund loans and those kinds of things?

21:44Director Levine, is that something you can help us with?

21:47There's a question about the process for inter-fund loans, and I assume that's as it relates to this tax levy ordinance.

21:54Right.

21:55And how did we choose parks to get a loan from them versus any other agency?

22:01Councilor, are you looking at agenda item 7?

22:04Let's see.

22:14I think we can take the question now.

22:17I just want to make sure that folks are all looking at the right thing.

Karen Chire 22:21 - 22:21

22:21Oh, I'm so upset.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 22:23 - 22:44

22:23So, Director Levine, there's a question.

22:26Agenda item 7 is a temporary interfund loan from Portland Parks and Recreation System Development Charge Fund to Fire and Police Disability and Retirement Fund.

22:40And there's a question about why that fund was chosen, or perhaps Jonas would like to answer.

Ruth Levine 22:45 - 23:25

22:45Yeah, I mean, I guess to the process for this specific fund, this is the second year that we've done this this way.

22:51And I think we may have talked about this on the 21st a little bit, but essentially it has to do with the very specific situation in the Fire, Police, and Disability Disability Retirement Fund, the way it's created in charter and the timing of the tax revenue.

23:08So they don't get their tax revenue in until October, November, and they need to start paying out claims in August.

23:14And so they need the cash.

23:16And so this is just the simplest and cheapest way to do it for the city.

23:22And yeah, happy to turn it over to Jonas as well.

Jonas Biery 23:26 - 24:16

23:26Great.

23:27For the record, Jonas Biery, DCA of Budget and Finance and Chief Financial Officer.

23:32Ruth is correct that this just addresses a cash flow mismatch between the language in the charter around the Fire and Police Disability Retirement Fund who collects that levy receipt in November.

23:43So this bridges the payment requirements between the start of the fiscal year and November.

23:48I would add in the past, in prior years, we've achieved this objective by getting an external borrowing either by issuing a short-term bond or note.

23:57Or having a loan from a bank and paying interest on that to an external party, an investor.

24:03This strategy utilizes that available balance in the Parks SDC Fund, fully replenishes the fund from that tax levy in November, and returns the interest back to an internal partner at the city via that parks fund.

Dilgash Ahmadi 24:19 - 24:19

24:19Thank you, Jonas.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 24:21 - 24:22

24:21Any other questions, Councilor?

Michelle Miller 24:24 - 24:24

24:24Nope.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 24:24 - 24:37

24:24Councilors, does anybody else have a question about agenda item number 6?

24:32Keelan, did you send me a note that we have our second testifier available now?

Keelan McClymont 24:37 - 24:38

24:37Yes, they arrived.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 24:38 - 24:39

24:38Let's give them an opportunity.

Keelan McClymont 24:40 - 24:41

24:40Great, thank you.

24:41Karen Shirey.

Karen Chire 24:44 - 24:47

24:44Can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 24:48 - 24:48

24:48We can hear you.

Karen Chire 24:49 - 26:27

24:49Okay, my name is Karen Chire.

24:53I'm a resident of District 3, business owner in District 4.

24:56I'm writing to express my strong disapproval of the proposed ordinance to levy taxes for the fiscal year beginning July 1st.

25:04While I understand the importance of funding city services, I believe that this ordinance has raised several concerns that warrant reconsideration.

25:12The financial burden on residents The proposed tax levies represent a significant financial burden on residents, especially in a time when many families are facing economic challenges.

25:25Increasing property taxes constrain household budgets, making it difficult for families to meet their basic needs.

25:31There appears to be a lack of transparency regarding the budget process.

25:35The ordinance states that the budget was adopted on June 18th, 2025, but as of June 10th, 2025, it has not yet been approved.

25:46This discrepancy raises concerns about the legitimacy, legitimacy of the proposed tax levies and the decision-making process involved.

25:55It's crucial to ensure that tax revenue is allocated effectively and efficiently.

26:01I'm concerned that the funds raised through these tax levies may not be utilized in ways that directly benefit the community or address pressing I urge the City Council to explore alternative funding solutions that do not place an additional burden on taxpayers.

26:16This could include reevaluating existing programs, identifying areas for cost savings, or seeking additional state or federal funding.

26:24I respectfully request— Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 26:28 - 26:34

26:28Thank you so much for being here.

26:32Keelan, is that the end of public testimony?

Keelan McClymont 26:34 - 26:35

26:34It does.

Michelle Miller 26:35 - 26:35

26:35Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 26:35 - 27:17

26:35Okay, thank you, colleagues.

26:37I am not seeing anybody else with comments, so I am going to close today's hearing on this bill, on this ordinance, and move us to agenda item 7.

26:56So we are going to open our discussion on agenda item 7, the FPD and our Interfund Loan Ordinance, which is where this funding that Councilor Smith was asking about takes place.

27:12Keelan, has anybody signed up to testify on this agenda item?

Keelan McClymont 27:18 - 27:19

27:18Signed up.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 27:19 - 27:40

27:19Okay.

27:20Councilors, is there any further discussion on agenda item 7?

27:27Okay, this is again a non-emergency ordinance, so it will move to second reading on the 18th.

27:36Councilor Green.

27:39Thank you, Madam President.

Robert Taylor 27:40 - 28:03

27:40I just kind of want to put into the record, yesterday we heard from Kevin Matches who provided testimony regarding this item, and he wanted us to flag that there is a different yield associated with this interfund loan relative to the previous one that we heard as well.

28:02And so I just—.

Alan Combs 28:04 - 28:04

28:04No action.

Robert Taylor 28:04 - 28:10

28:04I just wanted to flag and make sure we brought that discussion out of the Finance Committee and before the full council.

28:10Thanks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 28:13 - 28:48

28:13Thank you very much, Councilor.

28:16Councilors, seeing no one else in the queue for discussion, we are going to send this to second reading on the 18th.

28:24The next item on the agenda is agenda item 5, which is the adopted budget ordinance.

28:32And before we go to public testimony, I just want to take a moment to go over what to expect today and tomorrow for everybody who is listening.

28:43So we will start with another round of public testimony on our budget.

Michelle Miller 28:48 - 28:49

28:48Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 28:49 - 29:40

28:49We've set aside 2 hours, 2 additional hours for public testimony today.

28:55After public testimony, the first thing that we will do is consider an amendment, which I want to get the language right here.

29:06So I'm trying to pull up the email that has it, but I may not get there in time.

29:11We're going to consider the language which, or an amendment which will allow us to discuss carryover packages from Council Operations and Council Offices.

29:27These are the items that also are reflected separately in the overexpenditure ordinance that we have talked about.

29:33They've sometimes been called overexpenditure items.

29:38We'll then talk about parks.

Joe Jackson 29:40 - 29:40

29:40Yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 29:41 - 31:02

29:41Then public safety, community engagement and equity, housing and homelessness.

29:46And then there is an other category.

29:48And we'll take these categories like we did on the 21st, where everybody will have an opportunity to bring forward their most important amendment or package if you have a few things that should be considered together but were separated for technical reasons.

30:08After we get through everybody's most important piece in those categories, we'll go back and consider budget notes, which, except as they have been related to packages we've not yet considered, and then we will open up for consideration of additional amendments.

30:23So if you have something new that you have brought forward in a category that we've already considered, or if you have additional amendments that you want to bring forward in categories where it wasn't your most important amendment, We'll do those at the end.

30:39I suspect today we'll get through the council carryover package and the parks section and probably not much further than that, but it'll just depend on whether we use our full 2 hours for public testimony or not and how quickly debate moves.

30:54We'll recess at 6 o'clock and reconvene tomorrow at 9:30, and we are scheduled from 9:30 to 6:00 PM.

Joe Jackson 31:02 - 31:02

31:02Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 31:05 - 31:16

31:05Obviously, if we get through everything, we could always end earlier.

31:10I appreciate, I appreciate the laughs.

31:14Councilor Clark, do you have a question on process?

Marissa Wolf 31:16 - 31:17

31:16Yes, I do.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 31:17 - 31:48

31:17I just wondered on the OEOs, are you grouping them or are we gonna go through individually?

31:21I believe that we have a new amendment which grouped them as we talked about at our previous work session to help us move one thing a little bit more quickly.

31:32Any other questions on process?

31:37Okay, then I would like to move us into public testimony so that we can hear from Portlanders about how they're feeling about the current state of our budget.

Karen Chire 31:48 - 31:49

31:48Sorry.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 31:49 - 31:49

31:49And—.

Ruth Levine 31:50 - 31:50

31:50Council President.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 31:51 - 31:51

31:51Did I miss a piece?

Ruth Levine 31:52 - 32:11

31:52Yes, sorry.

31:53What did I miss?

31:53We're supposed to talk about the changes to the budget as so it's talking about the changes that are reflected in Attachments B and C, and that basically just lets Council have like the starting point for further adjustments to the budget.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 32:13 - 32:38

32:13Okay, here's what we're gonna do.

32:14I'm gonna say to the public who are here, feel free to testify not just on the budget before you, but the amendments that are filed.

32:22This is an opportunity for testimony on anything within Agenda item 5.

32:27So amendments as well, please.

32:30But before we do that, let's let Ruth talk about some of the changes that we have here.

32:35I apologize, Director Levine, that I missed that part.

Ruth Levine 32:38 - 33:17

32:38No problem.

32:40So I'm just going to describe at a high level the changes in the adopted budget as filed, which are reflected in Attachments B and C. These are primarily technical changes.

32:53That were made in advance, and there are kind of a couple of buckets of types of changes.

32:58Some of them are cleanup from amendments that were voted for in the approved budget hearings.

33:04So just making sure those get into the right spots in the budget.

33:10A couple of them are updates based on sort of year-end projections of revenues and expenditures.

33:15And so you'll see that in a couple of different places.

Dilgash Ahmadi 33:18 - 33:18

33:18Thank you.

Ruth Levine 33:19 - 34:03

33:19There's also the largest adjustment is for the FPDR loan that we just talked about and sort of adjustments between funds, particularly in our public works bureaus, adjusting contingency and revenues based on that.

33:40So those— That kind of covers it and essentially Council, you need to motion and second to adopt the changes as currently reflected in Attachments A through H. And again, that just kind of provides you with a clean starting point from which you'll discuss further amendments to the budget.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 34:06 - 34:13

34:06Director Levine, would it be best practice for us to make that motion before we move into public testimony or after?

Ruth Levine 34:14 - 34:17

34:14I, I, I think it makes sense to do it just before you move into public testimony.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 34:18 - 34:29

34:18Okay, councilors, do we have a motion?

34:28Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

Keelan McClymont 34:29 - 34:30

34:29Seconded.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 34:30 - 34:46

34:30Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

34:32So we are moving and seconding to extend accept the changes that are noted in, which attachments are we looking at, Director Levine?

Ruth Levine 34:47 - 34:48

34:47Attachments A through H.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 34:48 - 35:22

34:48Thank you.

34:48Attachments A through H. There we go.

34:50So if you're looking at the website, I and J are the new proposed amendments.

34:56A through H are the changes that have already been proposed.

35:01We are discussing and then we'll vote on accepting those changes so that we are starting with a clean slate with any amendments that we bring forward.

35:08Councilor Clark, are you in the queue for discussion?

35:15Is there any discussion?

35:20Okay, Keelan, Robert.

Alan Combs 35:24 - 35:24

35:24This—.

Robert Taylor 35:24 - 36:06

35:24The motion and second for this opens all of those items up, and now they can be amended individually as you move forward.

35:33And then at the end of that process, we will have a— we will vote on this motion To adopt all the changes as reflected in A through H. So that'll be— think of it as a nesting amendment.

35:46Now we're moving and seconding to opening A through H. You will then consider all the individual amendments that make changes to A through H, vote on all those, and then there will be one final vote on accepting all of the changes to A through H. That's similar to the process you went through with On May 21st.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 36:07 - 36:12

36:07But we need to do that now before we start hearing additional amendments that we have not yet considered.

Alan Combs 36:12 - 36:12

36:12Correct.

Robert Taylor 36:13 - 36:28

36:13You do the motion and second now.

36:15You don't vote on it.

36:16You hear all of the testimony on all of the amendments as filed so folks can talk about all of the changes that are being proposed.

36:25Then you take the individual—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 36:28 - 36:29

36:28So you prefer that we vote on these at the end?

Joe Jackson 36:30 - 36:30

36:30Correct.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 36:31 - 36:31

36:31Okay.

Unidentified speaker 36:33 - 36:33

36:33Great.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 36:33 - 36:46

36:33Then why don't we move now into public testimony?

36:37And Keelan, if you could call folks up 3 or 4 at a time so that we can hear from as many people as possible, that would be great.

36:45Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 36:46 - 36:55

36:46Yeah, thank you.

36:48First up, we have Loretta Guzman, Michelle Miller, Alan Combs, and Karen Chire.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 36:58 - 37:10

36:58Just sit here, that's okay.

Keelan McClymont 37:11 - 37:14

37:11Sure, go ahead, Loretta.

Dilgash Ahmadi 37:14 - 38:41

37:14Hi, my name is Loretta Guzman.

37:16I'm the owner of Bison Coffee House.

37:18I live and work in District 2.

37:19Before this budget is finalized and adopted with these amendments, I'm requesting that we are given the proper funding for public safety to PPB so they can better serve our communities and businesses.

37:30We have standards as a business we are held to.

37:33Safety shouldn't be compromised, but currently it is.

37:36Look around us as businesses are fail— failing.

37:39Even Big Pink is up for sale.

37:41How much more damage has to occur before our city starts prioritizing people's lives?

37:46Big businesses have left, small businesses have closed.

37:50Whole families have moved.

37:52We are, we are a city that we want to believe it can come back and it will, but how long before this will happen?

37:58Yes, I understand that we are forever changed, but as death is all around us, it's not normal.

38:04Yes, I have experienced it in the last few years.

38:08Deaths that shouldn't have occurred, unanswered 911 calls in a life and death situation.

38:14Councilor Loretta Smith.

38:16It's something I think of every day.

38:18Thanks to our city that is crumbling with no accountability, the things that used to work are not an option, and this new form of ideas is destroying and killing people's— people.

38:28Our streets are not what, what they once used to be.

38:31Public safety is compromised currently, when in reality it is a fundamental right which we are not given.

38:40Michelle.

Michelle Miller 38:42 - 39:08

38:42Good afternoon, councilors.

38:44My name is Michelle Milla.

38:45I'm a parent and public safety advocate in the District 4 Stadium neighborhood, where we've been doing the hard work of organizing, meeting with electeds, and also coordinating with law enforcement because the city has left too many of us on our own.

38:59So I'm here to strongly oppose Amendment 3 from Councilor Avalos, which would strip $15 million from the police bureau's overtime budget and place it into a council-controlled contingency fund.

Karen Chire 39:08 - 39:08

39:08Thank you.

Michelle Miller 39:08 - 39:59

39:08This is clearly a power grab.

39:10Councilor Avalos and her Progressive Caucus allies are attempting to exert direct control over the police bureau by holding critical overtime funds hostage, and that's a dangerous precedent, and it directly contradicts the will of the voters who passed charter reform to remove operational control from individual councilors and place it under a city administrator.

39:30Police overtime is what keeps our neighborhoods covered when staffing is when there's a crisis, a shortage, or a public safety emergency, those funds allow the system to flex and respond, and we need that right now.

39:42Putting that in a set-aside will equate to less safety for the people who need it most.

39:48It is a misuse of your power, Avalos, and I urge you to all vote no on Avalos 3.

39:53We ask you to respect the charter, your constituents, and stop gambling with public safety.

39:58Thank you for your consideration.

Karen Chire 40:02 - 40:02

40:02Alan.

Alan Combs 40:04 - 41:42

40:04All right, thank you, thank you.

40:06Uh, good afternoon, uh, councilors and mayor.

40:08My name is Alan Combs, Portland resident for, uh, over 25 years, and I live in District 3.

40:13I'm here today because I'm angry and disappointed that 7 councilors, including all of those from District 3, voted to shift $2 million from Portland Police Bureau to the parks based on a false choice and a lack of imagination that public safety must be cut to fund park maintenance.

40:29I support justice, equity, and sustainability.

40:32Indeed, cities are key to realize these goals, but none are possible if the city isn't safe and livable.

40:39Portland has underfunded public safety for years and now has one of the smallest police forces per capita of major U.S. cities.

40:47The mayor's requested budget for PPB isn't excessive, it's essential.

40:51What happens if you continue to defund the police?

40:54It means Portland Street Response will suffer.

40:57PSR needs police backup to expand safely into evening or indoor spaces.

41:02Recruitment and training will stall, just as PPB is making progress on recruiting and training a younger, diverse force.

41:09And that'll solve your overtime concerns, by the way.

41:12Targeted missions to address sex trafficking, car theft, and retail crime will be cut.

41:17Thank you.

41:17Traffic enforcement will stall despite being one of the most effective ways to reduce pedestrian injuries and fatalities.

41:25So how do you afford both parks and public?

41:28A little imagination, yes, and by doing the hard work of identifying lower priority spending.

41:34I urge you to work with the mayor and city administrator to find a solution.

41:38Don't settle for simple false choices.

41:42Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 41:47 - 41:49

41:47Karen is joining us online.

Karen Chire 41:51 - 43:27

41:51My name is Karen Fieray.

41:53I'm the owner of the convenience store Stadium Superette in District 4 and a member of Stadiumhood.

41:59And yes, Vice President, I have testified multiple times regarding the budget, but the squeaky wheel gets the grease.

42:06As a business owner in this community, I am deeply concerned about the recent challenges we have faced over the past 2 weeks alone.

42:13Our security log has had over 25 new recorded incidents, including 3 arrests, repeated vandalism, employee threats, thefts, and even drug deals.

42:24This level of criminal activity has taken a devastating toll.

42:28In the last 2 years, we have seen 18 businesses close or relocate from our neighborhood, and at least 3 more confirmed to leave.

42:34By the end of the year.

42:36We are in a doom loop in our Stadium Hood neighborhood.

42:40These closures mean lost jobs, lost investments, and a loss of the community hubs that our neighbors rely on.

42:46We are in a danger— dangerous downward spiral, and I fear for the future of our small business district and residential district if drastic action is not taken.

42:56This is why I'm pleading with you, do not let another business leave our neighborhood.

43:00We need more robust public safety budget to empower the police to work hand in hand With the community on solutions.

43:06Community policing, where law enforcement and residents collaborate toward the common goal of safety and livability, is the only way forward.

43:14When I call the police to report suspects from my store, I am doing my part to be a partner in public safety, but I need the police to have the resources and support to respond effectively.

43:24With your commitment to funding— thank you.

Keelan McClymont 43:29 - 43:36

43:29Next up, we have Vadim Mazierski.

43:32Brian Owendoff, Marissa Wolf, Joe Jackson.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 43:41 - 43:43

43:41Just a second, just a second.

Unidentified speaker 43:48 - 44:34

43:48Uh, hello, councilors.

43:48I'm here to urge you, uh, to vote no on Avalos 3 and to restore the $1.9 million that was cut from the mayor's public safety budget request.

43:57Recently, the Tribune noted that mayor— that the mayor believed that the funding cuts would hinder efforts to recruit officers and address critical missions like combating fentanyl and human trafficking.

44:06This was corroborated recently in a 7-page memo from the next Public Safety Administrator.

44:10But the mayor struck an optimistic tone.

44:11Thank you, Mayor.

44:14Noting that he was hopeful that City Council will restore the $1.9 million when it considers the final version of the budget.

44:20I too am hopeful that City Council will work together to restore the public safety and oppose drug dealers and human traffickers.

44:26I'm hopeful because common sense leaders like Councilors Zimmerman, Smith, Ryan, Clark have noted that the city does not have to choose between parks and police.

Robert Taylor 44:34 - 44:34

44:34Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 44:34 - 45:21

44:34We have options to fund both.

44:36I'm hopeful because the Oregonian editorial board advocated for restoring that same police funding.

44:42I'm hopeful because 3 recent citywide polls, one funded by City Council, one funded by the business community, one funded by a nonprofit, show that the majority of Portlanders are against cutting the police budget.

44:52A vast majority felt that even non-emergency police services were essential or very important, and a large majority would actually support doubling the police force.

45:01I'm hopeful because many people in this room are taking time off from their jobs and their families to advocate for restoring that funding.

45:08I know sometimes politicians heed the loudest voice in the room rather than the too often silent majority, but I'm also hopeful that this council will act differently and listen to what people are asking you to do in your districts and citywide.

45:21Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 45:23 - 45:23

45:23Brian.

Brian Oendolph 45:23 - 45:54

45:23Brian Oendolph.

45:24Thank you, Mayor, City Council President, councilors.

45:27I live and work in District rebuilding Portland requires a commitment to public safety.

45:32Law and order, rooted in the rule of law, is the cornerstone of any thriving society.

45:36It ensures treatment, safeguards against individual rights, deters crime, and maintains the peace and stability that our community needs to prosper.

45:43In Portland, we're facing a stark reality.

45:44Our city has half the number of police officers as other comparable cities.

45:48Despite a $318 million police budget, that funding only delivers 50% of the officers that we need.

Ahmed Alshamani 45:54 - 45:54

45:54Need.

Brian Oendolph 45:54 - 47:06

45:54This shortfall has real consequences for residents, businesses, and visitors.

45:59Portland's revitalization and its ability to generate revenue essential services for parks, roads, fire department depends on restoring public safety.

46:07The Portland Police Bureau strives to be a leader in policing that is respectful to all layers of our community.

46:12Entrepreneurs will not invest in neighborhoods plagued by break-ins and vandalism.

46:16Workers and visitors will avoid areas of high drug use.

46:20District 1 experiences the highest crime, yet Councilors Dunphy and Avalos representing that district voted to cut an already lean budget by another $2 million.

46:29That decision directly undermines efforts to make our community safer.

46:33We need leaders that support effective law enforcement, not those that spread misinformation about police or whose ideological agendas interfere with practical needs of our city.

46:43Portland's problems are not due to lack of revenue.

46:45They stem from bad policy decisions and misplaced priorities.

46:48Reducing the police budget now risks driving away more businesses, more residents, and more taxpayers.

46:53We will remember who stood before the public safety and who voted to erode it.

46:57With District 3 and District 4 councilors up for reelection next November, accountability is coming.

47:03Let's stop the decline, restore funding, restore order, restore Portland.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 47:06 - 47:07

47:06Next item on the agenda.

Karen Chire 47:07 - 47:08

47:07Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 47:11 - 47:12

47:11Marissa.

Marissa Wolf 47:12 - 48:49

47:12Hi, I'm Marissa Wolfe.

47:14I'm the artistic director of Portland Center Stage.

47:16We're in District 4, and I am here to support and ask you to support Motion 6, Green's Motion 6, the one-time $450,000 funding for Portland Center Stage, and also want to lift up Dunphy's Motion Number 2, $1.5 million for City Arts funding.

47:34So Portland Center Stage, we're the second largest theater in the state of Oregon.

47:38We serve 100,000 people, including 9,000 students every year.

47:43We are a space to gather.

47:44We are more than a theater.

47:45We are a space to gather, which is— which has such a great need right now.

47:51We are a space for collective imagination, to renew the investment in all people's ability to dream into democracy.

48:00We are an economic driver in our community.

48:03For every $1 spent at Portland Center Stage, $39 are spent in our neighborhood.

48:08When you consider the revitalization of downtown Portland, Councilmember Herbold.

48:12When you think about Portland's future, you must consider the arts and Portland Center Stage.

48:15We drive business to all of the local businesses in the Pearl District, and we are a major part of safety in our neighborhood in bringing tens of thousands of people downtown and partnering with local nonprofits around the houseless community.

48:29We are in emergency campaign to stay alive, and this, this one-time funding is absolutely critical as a public-private partnership in leveraging private gifts So that we can stay alive.

48:40It's a win for this incredible group of new council members and mayor that tens of thousands of people will benefit from this funding for generations to come.

48:49Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 48:52 - 48:52

48:52Joe.

Joe Jackson 48:54 - 50:39

48:54President Pirtle-Guiney, Vice President Koyama Lane, Mayor Wilson, members of the council.

49:00My name is Joe Jackson.

49:02I've been a rideshare driver in the Portland metro area for 10 years.

49:06I've driven thousands of trips and amassed hundreds of thousands of miles on these roads, and I need your help to support our— to support a fund for our driver resource center.

49:17Whether it's a ride to work, the hospital, school, or just getting home after a night out, people depend on us, and now we depend on the city to be there for us.

49:27We rideshare drivers are fighting for our rights, and sometimes we feel alone out there.

49:33Drivers need a place to go to get help if we have questions or issues with the TNCs.

49:40The Driver Resource Center could offer legal help at little to no cost for drivers worried about feeding their families after deactivation, translation services for the culturally biased English-speaking AI chatbots that dominate the customer service of both of the current TNC giants, and outreach for the massive and diverse driver community with education on labor rights.

50:05This $2 per trip fee that goes into effect without supporting drivers that so desperately need support.

50:15We understand that Portland has needs, but so do drivers.

50:19And without this, without us, this new funding wouldn't exist.

50:22So please, councilors, Mayor Wilson, set aside just a small portion of this fee to fund a driver resource center so that we can get the assistance that drivers have needed.

50:33We continue to support this city, but drivers deserve to be included in these decisions.

50:38Thank you, and we look forward to working together.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 50:41 - 50:42

50:41Thank you all for being here today.

Keelan McClymont 50:44 - 50:54

50:44Next up, next up, we have Ahmed Alshamani.

50:49Craig Bethel, Dilgash Ahmadi, Dahir Sheikh Ahmed.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 51:00 - 51:01

51:00Thank you all for being here.

Ahmed Alshamani 51:12 - 51:41

51:12Hi guys, my name is Ahmed Shahmani.

51:14I'm Uber driver, 10 years I was in Fox 12 News for Uber karaoke, and I was in the page Uber for Tabby Driver in Portland.

51:25I have multiple DIB tickets with Uber.

51:29And then guess what?

51:30After that, all this, I have over 4,000 I got deactivated in 2020 in the pandemic, and no one give me the reason what's going on for all that.

51:39And then guess what?

51:40I have a—.

Robert Taylor 51:41 - 51:42

51:414,000.

51:41$10,000.

Ahmed Alshamani 51:42 - 52:34

51:42$10,000 Give me Uber for have over, uh, 2,000 trips.

51:48So all this, this, if you— I'm all the type of driver, how is the regular driver is deactivation?

51:53I'm here to share the story what's going on for this company.

51:56This company is a slave the driver, don't care for the driver, don't care for the customer.

52:01He just hiring people, firing people.

52:03And then after 2 years, I share my, uh, situation, everything, and my account back Guess what?

52:10And then I go back again, work, and then I work again.

52:13And then some customer have a one stop, and then I tell them I can't be stopped.

52:17And then I call the support, say, okay.

52:19Next day I find my account deactivation.

52:21And after that I go to Vancouver.

52:24Vancouver have a support for Payfair deactivation and then, uh, uh, Payfair.

52:30So guess what?

52:31I, I connect with the driver union, and then guess what?

52:33My account back again.

Robert Taylor 52:34 - 52:35

52:34Thank you.

Ahmed Alshamani 52:35 - 52:45

52:35That's why I'm here.

52:36I want to drive a union because driver union back almost 1,700 people in Washington.

52:42So why don't do it here in Portland to support the brother and sister?

52:44Thank you so much.

Karen Chire 52:47 - 52:48

52:47Craig.

Craig Bethel 52:50 - 54:12

52:50Good afternoon, Mayor Wilson and members of the City Council.

52:54My name is Craig Bethel.

52:56I'm a 5th generation Oregonian and a resident of the Portland metro area for 68 years.

53:02And for the last 8 of those years, a member of the rideshare community.

53:06I love my job and serving the people of Portland.

53:12I am proud to call myself an essential service provider.

53:16Currently, we have— we don't have any place to go to get help if we have questions or issues with the TNCs.

53:25Uber and Lyft refuses to pay us a living wage.

53:28And they terminate us without any help of getting our jobs back.

53:33A $2 trip fee is about to go into effect without supporting the drivers that don't have the protections available like other essential workers.

53:44We understand the city has needs, but we do too.

53:47But so do we.

53:48And without us, none of the funding comes in.

53:51So please, Council and Mayor Wilson, set aside a small 10% portion of this fee to fund the Drivers Resource Center, a place that has experience serving our diverse community of drivers, so we can get the assistance we need from an independent organization that has drivers' best interests at heart.

Unidentified speaker 54:13 - 54:25

54:13We want to continue to support the city, but drivers deserve to be included in these decisions.

54:20We look forward to working together to make both of these things happen.

54:24Thank you very much.

Dilgash Ahmadi 54:26 - 55:02

54:26All right, good afternoon, Mayor Wilson, councilors.

54:33My name is Dilgash Shamidi, an essential rideshare worker in the Portland metro area going on, uh, 8 years now.

54:39Drivers are working long hours for low pay without basic labor protection, and Uber and Lyft keep deactivating us.

54:48Portland wants to raise the TNC fee to $2 without supporting us, even though every ride we support the city.

54:56Please take just 20 cents, just 10% on each ride to fund a driver resource center.

Unidentified speaker 55:12 - 55:35

55:12I was deactivated for 18 months with no reason whatsoever.

55:16If it wasn't for the driver's union, I wouldn't be reactivated.

55:19All it takes is, uh, a passenger to falsify some stuff, and, uh, they will not hesitate to deactivate a rideshare driver.

55:28Um, so please, we need your help, and thank you very much.

55:34Dahir is joining us online.

Dahir Shigamat 55:36 - 57:15

55:36Yeah, good afternoon, uh, Mayor Wilson and all members of the council.

55:41My name is Dahir Shigamat, and I'm the rideshare driver's I was living in Portland 25 years, and I have been a rideshare driver over 8 years.

55:55I'm happy to serve the residents and visitors of the Portland metro area.

56:00As you might be aware, we're constantly reporting drivers to, to the city of Portland or the council.

56:08Drivers are working long hours and never earn or close to the minimum wage of Portland.

56:14Thank you.

56:14Portland, Oregon.

56:16Drivers has no basic labor protection at all.

56:20Uh, rideshare companies keep pronging the expectation with us without any notice or warning.

56:27Therefore, we— therefore, to able or continuous our essential service in Portland City and Portland metro area, please, drivers need your help and support to fund our driver resources Second.

56:42Please just take, take 20 cents or just 10% in each ride from the new TNC fee of $2 to fund Driver Resource Center so the drivers have place to go to get support they need, such as fair pay, necessary basic benefits, and protection of the wronged driver.

57:02We hope and looking forward to work together to make those things happen and make city of Portland great place to be residency or work or protect the rights of the labor.

57:15Thank you very much.

Talia Giardini 57:17 - 57:19

57:17Thank you all very much for being here.

Unidentified speaker 57:21 - 57:27

57:21Next up we have Yusuf Fiki, Nathaniel Hudson Hartman, Angela Todd.

Sonia Szymanski 57:39 - 58:54

57:39Okay, you guys are tough acts to follow.

57:43Privyet, President, Vice President, Mayor Dubiet, and company.

57:47I'm Nathaniel Hudson Hartman, proud 8-year rideshare driver and advocate with Drivers Union Oregon, the voice for fairness for Rose City rideshare.

57:55As you can see, my merry band of largely low-income Black, brown, and immigrant drivers and I are here back again to ask for your help.

58:01We support this city providing essential mobility services, and as our wheels turn, y'all know millions are pouring into this city.

58:08But why is none of that supporting us?

58:11Impossibly long work weeks, jobs unfairly taken away, all thanks to Uber and Lyft.

58:16We need actual human beings, actual humans that have drivers' best interests at heart without the influence of the TNC giants, as my brother said.

58:25Great, great work.

58:27Um, That can serve our diverse driver community in languages other than English.

58:32And this place our community desperately needs, just like its Seattle counterpart that has already helped thousands restore their jobs and access countless benefits and have a voice, is the Driver Resource Center.

58:45This TNC fee was adopted without considering the negative impacts to our already struggling driver community.

58:51And as usual, Uber and Lyft are propagandizing this proposal.

Unidentified speaker 58:54 - 58:55

58:54Councilmember Herbold.

Sonia Szymanski 58:56 - 59:21

58:56But we are offering an equitable pathway forward that solves both of those problems, and that is the Driver Resource Center.

59:03We're eager to collaborate more to ensure drivers not only have a seat behind the wheel, but at the table.

59:09Remember, without us, there is no rideshare economy, no TNC taxation without driver representation.

59:16That being said, Councilor Knoll, we are encouraged by Amendment 17.

59:20Vamos a trabajar.

59:21Thank you, Councilor Sameer Kanal.

Unidentified speaker 59:22 - 59:23

59:22Thank you.

Angela Todd 59:27 - 1:01:07

59:27New topic.

59:28Good afternoon, Council and Mayor.

59:30I'm Angela Todd with PDX Real.

59:32Last week, this Council approved an $8.5 million settlement during a budget deficit.

59:37I'm here today because I'm aghast at that decision.

59:40You approved a settlement for 27 people claiming ancestral ties to a home in Albina.

59:46In the court documents that I read, there's no proof their family wasn't already paid when the home was sold.

59:52Or that they lived at the property.

59:54This isn't equity, it's precedent.

59:56I'd like to explain, even though I recognize this is a tough topic.

1:00:00It opens the door to every other family in Albina, but also every eminent domain claim in Portland's history, including the Coliseum, the Highway 405, to the Mount Hood Freeway that was never built.

1:00:11Meanwhile, present day, right now, the City of Portland has seized 2 family-owned nursery properties from the Bull Run Filtration Plant, and homeowners in rural Multnomah County are being harassed over new setbacks tied to that same project as we speak.

1:00:26Oddly, they're the ones who raised money to sue the city.

1:00:29I keep hearing from this body that a budget is a moral document.

1:00:33Well, let's be honest, symbolic justice won't fix what's broken today.

1:00:38This council should be confronting the real abuse that's happening now, not 70 years ago.

1:00:44Councilmember Because the greatest injustice I see today is the one being carried out by the city of Portland against its own people through political muscle, inadequate public safety, and policies that leave families and businesses crushed by financial pressure with no relief in sight.

1:01:01It's time to show moral courage in the present, not just the past.

1:01:07Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:01:10 - 1:01:25

1:01:10Uh, Yusuf Vicky.

1:01:13Okay, next we have Tiana Tozer, Eve Ashkar, Todd Littlefield, and Talia Giardini.

1:01:24I got—.

Keith Wilson 1:01:25 - 1:01:29

1:01:25I spent $64 on coffee, so is it me?

Tiana Tozer 1:01:39 - 1:03:16

1:01:39My name is Tiana Tozer.

1:01:40I'm a D2 resident.

1:01:41I'm concerned about the misinformation that has been floating around the police budget.

1:01:45Contrary to Green and Kanal's claims that the police budget is being increased by $21 million, according to the PPB budget summary, taking away the $2 million is a 0.4% increase.

1:01:57Page 4 of the budget summary states, and I've given you all copies of it, putting aside inflationary increases, PPB's general fund revenue would have increased by a total, including ongoing and one-time, of $861,379, 0.3% in the proposed budget, and decreased by $1,130,237.

1:02:19That's a 0.4% after the reductions in the approved budget.

1:02:23Where is the $21 million increase?

1:02:25Someone needs to show me the math.

1:02:27I would also like to clarify how and why the $2 million decrease will result in a decrease in services.

1:02:32The money from the 90 vacant positions is currently used for overtime to maintain a level of service.

1:02:37When a new officer is hired, they start being paid.

1:02:40New police officers have an 18-month training period during which they do not operate solo.

1:02:45That means a position is filled, but it takes 18 months for the staffing increase to take effect.

1:02:51In the meantime, to continue the level of service, the bureau needs the same amount of money for overtime.

1:02:56The result is a decrease in response times and services.

1:02:59During your campaign, Councilor Novick, on October 2024, you stated if it's a matter of cutting public safety or parks, Probably you would have to cut parks.

1:03:07Are you going to follow through on your campaign promise, or will you give in to the piratical bullying of Councilor Maria?

1:03:13Portlanders want police and parks, and there are ways to fund them both.

Keith Wilson 1:03:17 - 1:03:30

1:03:17Yeah, and I'll remind folks that while I know folks have reactions to a lot of what we hear, we try to keep those reactions silent so we can keep moving.

1:03:26Thank you.

1:03:27Okay.

Talia Giardini 1:03:30 - 1:03:33

1:03:30Sorry, I'm like, deep breaths.

1:03:32Okay, can I go?

Unidentified speaker 1:03:33 - 1:03:34

1:03:33Yeah, go ahead.

Keith Wilson 1:03:34 - 1:03:34

1:03:34Okay.

Talia Giardini 1:03:34 - 1:04:55

1:03:34Hi, I'm Talia Giardini.

1:03:36I'm a registered nurse and a Portland native.

1:03:38Taking away $2 million from police, which with inflation is actually a 0.4% decrease, this goes directly against what the majority of the public wants.

1:03:47This is not democracy, it's entitlement and abandonment.

1:03:50Our DSA councilors are in denial of the facts and frankly dishonest.

1:03:54They're open about police abolition, which is ridiculous.

1:03:57I care for victims of gun violence, domestic violence, stabbing in adults, and this includes children.

1:04:03The hospital is regularly on lockdown due to gun violence in surrounding areas and parks.

1:04:08We now have metal detectors at every entrance after a security guard was killed on site.

1:04:12I myself am a victim of domestic violence, assault, and car theft.

1:04:16We want and need police, and to say anything different is a complete fallacy.

1:04:20It shows the Progressive Caucus would rather double down on their political ideologies than protect the public.

1:04:26Councilmember I've heard no mention of cutting their own multimillion-dollar security budget.

1:04:31We don't want to lose traffic enforcement, human trafficking missions, or PSR support.

1:04:35We don't want delayed 911 response times, which are critical to the health of the community.

1:04:40I was at the 2020 protests, and I'm proud of the reforms PPB has made, including an oversight board and community policing.

1:04:47PPB, thank you for your service.

1:04:49I'd like to add, we are on the stolen land of the Kalapuya Tribe, who have been invisible in these conversations regarding reparations.

Keith Wilson 1:04:55 - 1:04:55

1:04:55Thank you.

Talia Giardini 1:04:56 - 1:05:06

1:04:56And you better watch out for them to sue next.

1:04:59I encourage all of you to support the mayor's practical proposed budget, widely supported by the public, and support our public servants.

1:05:06Thanks.

Unidentified speaker 1:05:08 - 1:05:12

1:05:08Eve is joining us online.

1:05:11Go ahead and unmute, Eve.

Keith Wilson 1:05:13 - 1:05:16

1:05:13Hello.

Unidentified speaker 1:05:20 - 1:06:48

1:05:20My mother and I own a small property management company that was started by my grandfather over 40 years ago in the Lloyd Center area.

1:05:28We have a diverse group of tenants who work in various industries ranging from nonprofit community outreach, gun violence prevention, software, audiovisual services, kids after-school programs, and high-end auto repair.

1:05:39We do our best to keep our 3 blocks of buildings clean and safe for all of our tenants and their clients and customers.

1:05:45Over the last few years, this has become increasingly difficult.

1:05:49When our tenants' clients arrive to drop off their children for classes or deliver vehicles for repair, They are met with the unpleasantness of mobile homes, unlicensed cars dealing drugs, and leaving trash and human waste along the properties.

1:06:01Often camper vans are parked in front of our buildings for upwards of 6 to 8 weeks, and their presence deters people from wanting to use our tenant services, thus negatively affecting their businesses and income.

1:06:11We have heard from our tenants directly how some of their clients are no longer using their services because they do not feel safe in the area.

1:06:18Our tenants are not able to maintain their business income that will not only hurt them, but will hurt us as the landlords who are financially responsible for these properties.

1:06:26We are aware that there are only about 8 people employed with PBOT to address parking and car camping, and given the state of the city, that is not enough.

1:06:34We need more funding towards PBOT and the police that will focus specifically on removing people and vehicles who continue to cause issues for local businesses.

1:06:42I continue to observe the city leadership putting the needs of those individuals above the needs of property and business owners in the city.

Keith Wilson 1:06:48 - 1:06:48

1:06:48Councilmember.

Unidentified speaker 1:06:49 - 1:07:27

1:06:49It is families like ours and people like our tenants who make every effort to keep commerce going in our neighborhoods and generate tax revenue.

1:06:55It is time for the city to take significant steps towards resources for PBOT and police to help business owners.

1:07:01Thank you.

1:07:05Uh, Todd Littlefield.

1:07:08Uh, next up we have Kai McMurtry.

1:07:13Giles Gardner.

1:07:18Dave Crepo, Anastasia Howard, Rob Martineau, and Tara Carlson.

Talia Giardini 1:07:37 - 1:07:39

1:07:37Welcome.

1:07:38Thank you all for being here.

Giles Gardner 1:07:43 - 1:07:48

1:07:43Would you like us to start?

Keith Wilson 1:07:50 - 1:07:51

1:07:50Please, Dave.

Dave Crapo 1:07:51 - 1:08:32

1:07:51For the record, my name is Dave Crapo.

1:07:54I am a chapter chair with ASPB 189, and I'm the city's first park ranger dispatcher.

1:08:01I and my team, the dispatch team, are also in the process of receiving our layoff notices This week.

1:08:06So my job right now is to earn your vote in favor of budget amendments that will restore park ranger dispatch for our funding, and then to place us under 311.

1:08:16311 Management is prepared and ready to receive and support us in our work, and we believe that this is the best solution for everyone.

1:08:25If these amendments do not pass, our workflow will stop, and there is no serious plan in place to take over our functions.

Keith Wilson 1:08:32 - 1:08:32

1:08:32Thank you.

Dave Crapo 1:08:33 - 1:08:59

1:08:33Ranger calls will stack up in a work queue and they'll be passed out to rangers as time permits, frequently after problems have passed with no resolutions.

1:08:43So I have 3 observations about our work that I need everybody to understand.

1:08:47First, Ranger Dispatch lightens the load for PPB and BOEC by taking non-emergency calls and correctly routing them to safety resources around the city.

1:08:56Usually that's a ranger team, but sometimes we partner with others.

Keith Wilson 1:08:59 - 1:08:59

1:08:59Thank you.

Dave Crapo 1:09:00 - 1:09:29

1:09:00We are a force multiplier for Portland's safety and security apparatus, and that helps with neighborhood livability.

1:09:05Second, we provide critical access to community services for people who are usually not comfortable calling city services.

1:09:13We help triage calls, we help people get social services, and we help people get health resources.

1:09:20Third, Portland is a union town.

1:09:22We are represented labor.

1:09:24We're the cheapest Uh, labor on the Ranger team, and we need your help.

1:09:28Please vote for our amendments.

Tara Carlson 1:09:30 - 1:11:11

1:09:30Hi, I'm Tara Carlson, AFSCME 189 Vice President and Building Plans Examiner for PP&D.

1:09:39City Councilors, we are deeply concerned about any proposed layoffs of workers at PP&D, any mandated halt on our reserves, and waiving of FDC fees as we move into peak construction season.

1:09:50Our bureau had no intention of decreasing our staffing levels this year because of a steady climb toward cost recovery.

1:09:57And yet there is still an amendment that mandates PP&D to reduce the draw on reserves and decrease bureau costs through employee layoffs.

1:10:05This action will cause our community to endure additional longer wait times for critical construction, development, and community services due to the 71 layoffs we already endured in January 2024.

1:10:19While waiving SDC fees will likely promote an influx of permits, we share PBOT, BES, Water and Parks concerns that fee losses will continue to strain critical infrastructure with unintended consequences on our legacy of livability.

1:10:35Portland has fallen behind major city jurisdictions nationwide by not implementing a steady governance from general funds for our building department to manage the inevitable ebbs and flows of construction.

1:10:47We agree with Councilor Smith that the amendment to retain 31 jobs and reduce the drawdown of reserves did not go far enough.

1:10:57We stand by Smith's proposal to provide a one-time fund of $9.5 million to PP&D to preserve all staffing levels by amending Pirtle-Guiney's Amendment 101.

Keith Wilson 1:11:11 - 1:11:12

1:11:11Where's my card?

Anastasia Howard 1:11:27 - 1:11:38

1:11:27Hello, I'm Anastasia Howard.

1:11:30I'm an AFSCME 189 chapter chair, and I have worked for 10 years at the Portland Permitting and Development Bureau in the Property Compliance Division.

Keith Wilson 1:11:38 - 1:11:38

1:11:38Thank you.

Anastasia Howard 1:11:39 - 1:13:11

1:11:39Picking up where Tara left off, Management forecasts— our management forecasts that layoffs will balloon permit services backlogs and increase program losses that resulted from the 71 staff layoffs in January 2024.

1:11:53For example, on-time plan reviews are down to 90%.

1:11:57Wait times for free appointments for customers to get help with their permit applications have increased to 4 days and will likely be eliminated.

1:12:05The residential building inspectors are averaging 295 inspections daily among 13 inspectors, which hasn't proved easy.

1:12:15Layoffs of commercial inspectors from 7 to 3 will decrease inspections from 70 to only 23 a day, hampering the mayor's initiatives toward new construction of affordable housing and business revitalization downtown.

1:12:29The Property Compliance Division was forced to shut down yearly systematic yes.

1:12:37Inspection programs for multifamily rentals citywide.

1:12:41Demand for inspections for unpermitted construction, health and safety violations, and squatter houses is increasing.

1:12:49We currently have 889 properties in active code enforcement alongside a backlog of 406 citywide complaints that are waiting for an inspector.

1:13:00We welcome the opportunity to further discuss how we can continue our mission to promote safety, livability, and economic vitality in line with the city's compliance goals and our shared dedication to public service.

Keith Wilson 1:13:11 - 1:13:11

1:13:11And we thank you.

Rob Martineau 1:13:14 - 1:13:59

1:13:14Thank you, Portland City Council.

1:13:16My name is Rob Martineau.

1:13:17I'm the president of AFSCME Local 189 and a water operations mechanic in the Portland Water Bureau for the last 25 years.

1:13:24In addition to these cuts in permits and parks, which easily connects to housing and livability in Portland.

1:13:31There's an additional thing that I— issue I'd like to raise, and that is the constant cutting of vacancies.

1:13:39That seems to be how all bureaus are forced to balance budgets.

1:13:43Those vacancies of my members are real work.

1:13:46Those are people that should be in the queue to be hired.

1:13:49Those are Portlanders that need good jobs, and we need to figure out how we put back these vacancies.

1:13:55I understand it may not happen in this budget, but it needs to happen in the next.

Unidentified speaker 1:13:59 - 1:13:59

1:13:59The work—.

Rob Martineau 1:13:59 - 1:14:52

1:13:59Will still need to be done.

1:14:02Another area that's easy to forget is Portland's 14th elected official, and that's the office of our auditor.

1:14:09As a result of this budget, the one person who does the training on records retention for all of the agencies and bureaus in Portland is being laid off.

1:14:20So where we talk about transparency, which all of us at this dais have done, it is antithetical to that to unfund the support to the entire city of that records retention.

1:14:34And you all have one hell of a task.

1:14:36You have gotten here halfway through a budget cycle, and it's always budget season in Portland.

1:14:40I am encouraged at the progress that this council has made, and I am excited to— you all have a full budget cycle to really guide Portland forward as we move into our next budget season.

1:14:51Good luck.

Talia Giardini 1:14:52 - 1:14:54

1:14:52Thank you all for being here.

Dave Crapo 1:14:54 - 1:15:01

1:14:54May I also please share I have a letter signed by 26 park rangers and also a fact sheet about our work.

Talia Giardini 1:15:01 - 1:15:06

1:15:01Could you hand that to our clerk and she'll make sure that it gets to all of our offices?

1:15:05Thank you so much.

Unidentified speaker 1:15:11 - 1:15:13

1:15:11Um, Giles is joining us online.

Giles Gardner 1:15:15 - 1:16:40

1:15:15Uh, good afternoon, council members.

1:15:16My name is Giles Gardner.

1:15:18I'm a Portland resident and an ISA board I'm here to express my clear opposition to Council Member Zimmerman's proposed amendment, which will have devastating long-term effects on Portland's tree canopy.

1:15:30I'm here to urge you to preserve funding for Urban Forestry's permitting and regulation team and to protect Portland's tree code.

1:15:37Cutting staffing and weakening protections will dismantle years of progress at a time when our urban canopy is more important than ever.

1:15:44Mature trees are not easily replaced.

1:15:46Thank you.

1:15:47While new trees can be planted, survival rates are low, and it takes decades for them to deliver the same benefits.

1:15:53Large established trees provide unmatched value in cooling neighborhoods, improving air quality, increasing property values, and reducing stormwater runoff.

1:16:02These benefits are especially vital in underserved communities already suffering from heat inequity and low canopy coverage.

1:16:10The urban forestry permitting and regulation team are not bureaucratic overhead.

1:16:14They're highly skilled public servants doing essential climate resilience work.

1:16:18Recent staffing improvements have dramatically reduced permitting delays.

1:16:22Cutting that staff now will reverse this progress.

1:16:26This proposal will disproportionately harm Portland's most vulnerable communities and result in lasting environmental and public health costs.

1:16:33Please don't trade long-term livability for short-term savings.

1:16:37Preserve urban forestry.

1:16:39Protect the trees we still have.

Keith Wilson 1:16:40 - 1:16:40

1:16:40Thank you.

Giles Gardner 1:16:41 - 1:16:43

1:16:41Once they're gone, we can't get them back.

1:16:43Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:16:45 - 1:18:34

1:16:45Go ahead, Kai.

1:16:47Good afternoon, Mayor Wilson and councilors.

1:16:48My name's Kai McMurtry.

1:16:50I'm a resident of D3.

1:16:51I appreciate you making this additional space to hear public testimony on the budget.

1:16:55I rewatched your discussion at the close of the May 21st marathon session in response to Avalos's First Amendment to, quote unquote, uncrease the PPB budget.

1:17:04As a Portland taxpayer, it is insulting to me to hear some councilors position that $1.9 million as somehow the make-or-break amount of a bureau budget in excess of $300 million, a budget that's up almost 8% and is already the largest recipient of general fund dollars in the city.

1:17:20Those who opposed the redirection to parks wanted us to believe that it signaled some great concession to lawlessness.

1:17:26If $2 million made us safe, then $300 million should make us safe 150 times over, right?

1:17:33You know what many contribute— what else many contribute to a feeling of public safety?

1:17:37Litter removal, lighting, amenity repairs, ADA barrier removal, all things that are being cut in our cherished public spaces.

1:17:44By the current reduction in parks maintenance dollars.

1:17:46I am encouraged by Avalos 3, Koyama Lane 8, excuse me, Koyama Lane 8, Novick 2, Murillo 7, but I gotta go to work and walk my dog and I cannot digest all that y'all are being asked to take on.

1:17:58So I have to speak to my values, which unfortunately leaves me open to interpretation because we are all using the word safety, but we mean different things by it.

1:18:06I don't think the state's threat of violence and incarceration can build a world of true holistic community and safety.

1:18:12And every year that we increase the police budget at the expense of alternative methodologies, including well-maintained parks and public spaces, we are choosing to delay real community harmony.

1:18:22Thank you.

1:18:24Thank you very much.

1:18:27Next up, we have Benjamin Gilbert, Kevin Christensen, Marie Tyvall, Jordan Lewis.

Talia Giardini 1:18:37 - 1:18:38

1:18:37Thank you for being here.

Benjamin Gilbert 1:18:47 - 1:20:20

1:18:47My name is Benjamin Gilbert and I'm a tenant in District 4 and a member of the Portland Democratic Socialists of America.

1:18:54I'd like to voice strong support for Green 10.

1:18:58We can afford to cut from the external material and services budget, which is funding overwhelmingly directed towards consultants.

1:19:06And redirects work away from represented city employees.

1:19:09It also funds the necessary study to facilitate the expansion of Portland Street Response, protects tenants, and funds the arts.

1:19:17We need to defend the increase.

1:19:19Don't give the police more than they need and more than they asked for.

1:19:22When I look at Los Angeles right now, I see what an overfunded police department looks like.

1:19:28I also strongly urge councilors to support Morillo 16.

1:19:32Which supports tenants in the midst of a housing crisis.

1:19:35Also vote yes on Avalos 3.

1:19:38We need accountability on police overtime.

1:19:40Just look at San Francisco where an audit found police overtime was rife with fraud and abuse.

1:19:45When my neighbor was injured in front of my Northwest apartment, more than 6 police officers came and harassed them, making them feel unsafe.

1:19:54I bought my neighbor a cool bottle of water.

1:19:57To help with his head wound and walked him back to his apartment.

1:20:01This seems like an overfunded police department.

1:20:03It seems inefficient, and it seems like we can take care of our neighbors.

1:20:07Like, Portland Street Response would be better served to do this kind of work.

1:20:12And we don't need 6 people showing up when one gentleman has a head wound who can just be walked back to his apartment.

1:20:17I did that.

1:20:18They didn't do that.

1:20:19Thank you.

Keith Wilson 1:20:20 - 1:20:21

1:20:20Jordan.

Unidentified speaker 1:20:24 - 1:21:50

1:20:24Hello, City Council.

1:20:25I'm Jordan Lewis with Portland DSA.

1:20:27I also live in the stadium hood as well.

1:20:30I'm here today thanking everyone who voted yes on the police increase.

1:20:3390 Unfilled positions don't keep us safe, and the move would save parks employees' jobs while not a single officer would lose theirs.

1:20:40Police conspire with ICE and threaten cutting human trafficking work at the first whiff of accountability.

1:20:45I'm also here in support of the increase to TNC Uber Lyft fees as well as Canal 7 17 towards a driver resource center.

1:20:52I checked the Lyft app just now, and a ride one way from here to Kaiser Interstate East is $15.

1:20:57Meanwhile, a TriMet ride costs less than $3.

1:21:00The additional $1.35 fee on rides would be a splash in the bucket for such a luxury convenience.

1:21:05To be clear, I support funds being used on a driver resource center.

1:21:08I'm really here against the apps themselves and asking you to take it even higher.

1:21:13The Uber and Lyft apps sent out alerts telling customers to show up and stall this effort, not unlike in May when they did the same thing in Illinois, asking users to testify against a transit funding bill.

1:21:23This bill failed, pushing transit over the fiscal cliff and forcing Chicago to cut up to 30% of their transit service.

1:21:29These apps function by undermining public transit and union taxi services with exploited labor.

1:21:34This is not the behavior of a public servant.

1:21:35This is the behavior of a tobacco company.

1:21:38If climate change is a problem, if road fatalities are a problem, if traffic congestion is a problem, the fee needs to be higher.

1:21:45$2 Is a start.

1:21:47But please put, put it towards the Driver Resource Center as well.

1:21:50Thank you.

Talia Giardini 1:21:52 - 1:21:54

1:21:52Thank you both for being here.

Unidentified speaker 1:21:55 - 1:22:10

1:21:55Checking on Kevin Christensen, Marie Tyboul.

1:22:03Next we have Jeremy Smith, Jim Labby, Yoko Silk, Jesse Hannan.

Jeremy Bosley-Smith 1:22:18 - 1:23:57

1:22:18Good afternoon, councilors and Mayor Wilson.

1:22:20My name is Jeremy Bosley-Smith.

1:22:21I've been following the coalescence of the District 4 Coalition over the past year and a half.

1:22:26What I've seen is concerning.

1:22:28Councilor Clark's Amendment 9 motions to increase funding for the District 4 Coalition by $80,000 to boost their newsletter reach.

1:22:35The newsletter does not need $80,000 and can be grown organically At pre-existing community events and utilizing social media to its full potential.

1:22:44Right now it's only on Facebook, declining.

1:22:46It's a dying social media.

1:22:49We need to do better.

1:22:50At the June 2nd District 4 Coalition board meeting, a $3,000 celebratory dinner at the Lanzhou Chinese Garden was planned.

1:22:59This option was chosen over a community picnic that would have been open to everybody.

1:23:03Coalition President Jesse Burke who is also the chair of the Old Town Community Association, used their pulpit to speak about bottle drop concerns for over 30 minutes in the media— or in the meeting, prioritizing the concerns of her neighborhood over the 31 other neighborhoods that they're supposed to represent.

1:23:22Zimmerman Amendment 8 motions to restore $130,000 in funding to the District Coalition Office operations and $180K to the District Coalition Office grants.

1:23:30Any funds given to District 4 will be disproportionately applied to the Old Town Community Association, a neighborhood that just received $30,000 from Multnomah County for the Community Vitality and Economy Opportunity Grant.

1:23:42Over the past few days, PPB has been communicating with aiding and abetting Federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement down at the South Waterfront.

1:23:50Please vote no on Clark Amendment 9, Zimmerman Amendment 8, and the $2 million Portland Police Bureau increase.

1:23:57Thank you.

Keith Wilson 1:23:57 - 1:23:57

1:23:57Thank you.

Jeremy Bosley-Smith 1:24:00 - 1:24:59

1:24:00Good afternoon, Mayor and City Council.

1:24:02My name's Jim Lavey.

1:24:03I'm a District 2 resident.

1:24:05I'm here to oppose Zimmerman 2 and 3 and support Green Amendment 10.

1:24:10From 2002 to 2016, I served as urban conservationist for the Oregon Bird Alliance and staffed the East Portland office out at Leach Botanical Garden.

1:24:20And during that time, I served on the Citywide Tree Project Stakeholder Committee, and then subsequently, several years later, on the Title 11 Citywide Tree Code Thank you.

1:24:29Oversight Committee.

1:24:31So I spent a lot of time with this tree code.

1:24:35It emerged, that project emerged outta a genuine grassroots movement across the city in 2007 to protect and safeguard the urban forest by revising very outdated city tree code regulations.

1:24:51Amendment 4, as it was presented for, would basically gut those efforts, those decade-long efforts to try to improve those policies and their implementation.

Unidentified speaker 1:24:59 - 1:24:59

1:24:59Yeah.

Jeremy Bosley-Smith 1:25:01 - 1:25:35

1:25:01There's issues with the code, but the budget process is not the way to deal with those code issues.

1:25:08Let's debate the code.

1:25:09Let's not gut the program via the budget.

1:25:11Urban forestry staff that we cut do more than inspection.

1:25:15They do education and information sharing, which is a critical part of that project.

1:25:20And I understand this is maybe a strategy to cut parks to fund parks.

1:25:25That doesn't get us anywhere.

1:25:26A much better approach is Green 10, which partially addressed the cuts to parks in the mayor's proposed budget.

Keith Wilson 1:25:35 - 1:25:38

1:25:35Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:25:39 - 1:25:40

1:25:39Go ahead, ma'am.

Keith Wilson 1:25:41 - 1:25:41

1:25:41Oh, sorry.

Unidentified speaker 1:25:42 - 1:25:42

1:25:42Go ahead.

Angela Todd 1:25:42 - 1:25:42

1:25:42Me?

Yoko Silk 1:25:42 - 1:26:24

1:25:42Yoko Silk.

1:25:43I'm a District 2 resident and a Portland Parks employee.

1:25:46I wanna say thank you to Councilors Murillo, Green, Avalos, Dunphy, Kanal, Novick, Koyama Lane for your yes vote for the redirection of $1.9 million from police to parks.

1:25:56Councilor Ryan, I'm hoping that I can see you uphold Supporting Parks like you used to do when you were our commissioner, when I'm also a Parks employee under you.

1:26:04I cannot believe that this decision about $1.9 million redirect is being contested.

1:26:08Honestly, PPB got exactly the budget they requested plus some, and this redirection is just slightly reduces their increase while all the other bureaus are facing massive cuts.

1:26:18Parks is still facing an $8 million in cuts.

1:26:21Please stop spreading the false narrative that this is somehow defunding police.

Unidentified speaker 1:26:24 - 1:26:24

1:26:24It is not.

Keith Wilson 1:26:24 - 1:26:25

1:26:24Thank you.

Yoko Silk 1:26:25 - 1:27:23

1:26:25This redirection of $1.9 million is helpful for parks maintenance, but it isn't even enough.

1:26:30Please work to fund parks fully.

1:26:33I was a part-time casual staff for PP&R years ago and have been an FTE union member for the past 10 years.

1:26:39I know firsthand the incredible value of city nature programming, for example, that is still on the proposed cut list.

1:26:45These high ROI programs that serve over 7,000 youth a year are still posed to lose poised to lose all funding for casual staff, which is over 100 positions.

1:26:56What makes these programs— which will make these programs impossible to run and reduces valuable job opportunities for our Portland residents.

1:27:03The police bureau budget is 67% larger than it was 10 years ago.

1:27:07More police don't keep crime off the streets, but engaging youth programs does.

1:27:11Healthy park systems do.

1:27:12Programs that provide childcare like recreation summer camps do.

1:27:15They are an investment in our city's welfare and Portland's future.

1:27:18Funding youth programs is funding public safety.

1:27:20Funding parks is public safety.

1:27:22Thank you.

Keith Wilson 1:27:23 - 1:27:25

1:27:23Thank you all.

Unidentified speaker 1:27:28 - 1:27:36

1:27:28Jesse Hannon, Tim Larson, Nike Green, Eric Knox.

1:27:36Go ahead.

Jesse Hannon 1:27:37 - 1:28:28

1:27:37Thank you, councilors.

1:27:40My name is Jesse Hannon.

1:27:41I've lived in Portland most of my life.

1:27:42I'm a District 3 resident.

1:27:44I'm honestly a little confused why we're even talking about this.

1:27:47My understanding is that the Portland Police got the budget increase they asked for, and Portland Parks, even if they were to receive the $1.9 million budget bonus, would still be looking at an $8 million shortfall.

1:28:01I think we all understand that the Portland Police Bureau is not underfunded currently, and the Portland Parks Bureau is.

1:28:10Especially youth programs are well known to reduce crime in the city, and we seem to have hit the maximum of how much police funding will even do that.

1:28:19So I'm urging all the council members to please retain the $1.9 million with the Portland Parks rather than give it to the police department, which didn't even ask for it.

Keith Wilson 1:28:29 - 1:28:31

1:28:29Thank you.

Tim Larson 1:28:32 - 1:30:14

1:28:32My name is Tim Larson, and I've spoken to the— your predecessors in City Council and I've been trying to get your attention, Dan, before, and it kind of reminds me of speaking to an assembly at the deaf school in Washington, in Vancouver, without having a sign language translator.

1:28:55I hope that I have got your attention now because this is really important.

1:29:01What does defunding the police mean, or taking money away from the police budget mean?

1:29:05First, there's the Existential crisis for business community in Portland.

1:29:11Downtown Portland property values have plummeted 57% since 2019, from $3 billion to just $1.3 billion.

1:29:21There was an article in the paper the other day that the Old Town Pizza owner had purchased the Merchant Hotel building that he was in for $2.5 million.

1:29:33While just in 2017, the previous owner paid $12.5 million for that building.

1:29:40Then we have the human crisis.

1:29:43I'm a rideshare driver myself.

1:29:44In the last 2 years, I have given rides to a 78-year-old man who was stabbed 3 times at an East Portland MAX station, a 40-year-old— 74-year-old Hispanic woman who was hit on the head by a 38-pound rock wielded by a homeless man, causing 3 life-threatening cracks to her skull and sending her to the ICU.

1:30:05By the way, this was the same mentally ill homeless man who just weeks before had critically injured a woman doctor who was jogging on Northwest 23rd.

Keith Wilson 1:30:15 - 1:30:16

1:30:15We need more police.

Tim Larson 1:30:16 - 1:30:18

1:30:16We need police to protect us.

Talia Giardini 1:30:18 - 1:30:19

1:30:18Thank you.

Nike Green 1:30:23 - 1:31:03

1:30:23My name is Nike Green.

1:30:24I am the CEO and founder of Triple Threat Mentoring, a 50-year-plus resident and in District 2.

1:30:29We're a small D.C.-based nonprofit a deeply rooted Black-led organization which was recently awarded funding through the Portland Children's Levy for mentoring.

1:30:38Mayor, Madam President, and council members, we're grateful for the opportunity to be here today and share our perspective, especially given that we were previously asked not to lobby or provide any testimony.

1:30:47So here we are, not just sitting in front of you, but in the room, the balcony, and watching online.

1:30:52We're a coalition of organizations including the Ethiopian Eritrean Cultural Resource Center, ELSO, Hala Mentors, and Triple Threat that were significantly impacted by the decisions you made in the last council PC Councilmember Smith.

Dave Crapo 1:31:03 - 1:31:03

1:31:03Thank you, Mayor.

Nike Green 1:31:03 - 1:31:49

1:31:03I'm here to speak on behalf of the Portland Council of Black Leaders, or PCL, remand.

1:31:05Our organizations work within Black communities through— within workforce development, science education, college and career readiness, and intensive mentoring.

1:31:13Across all of our nonprofits, over 90% of our board members, staff, mentors, and constituents identify as Black.

1:31:19So we are disheartened by the decision to reallocate funds to previously funded organizations, many of them larger legacy nonprofits, at the expense of smaller Black-led orgs that have long been underfunded and overlooked.

1:31:31So what is our ask?

1:31:32That you would fully fund all newly awarded grants for at least the first year to prevent gaps in our services.

1:31:38If review is necessary, we ask that you do a partial remand to limit it to only the specific hunger relief funding lane in question rather than delaying the full cohort.

1:31:48Thank you for listening.

Eric Knox 1:31:51 - 1:33:21

1:31:51My name is Eric Knox.

1:31:52I am the executive director and founder of HALA.

1:31:55I've been in Portland for 35 years.

1:31:58I've been in mentorship for 31 years.

1:32:00I live in the community I serve.

1:32:02I don't drive into that community.

1:32:04I fully embody this work because I believe, especially for my Black and brown babies, you can't be what you haven't seen.

1:32:14I have the resources to not live there, but I do because that's the heart and essence of mentoring.

1:32:20So today I stand with my sister Nike, And the other 2 Black-led mentoring organizations, ELSO and Ethiopian Eritrean Cultural and Resource Center, harmed by your recent remands of the PCL, Portland Children's Levy, which protects previously funded groups for another year while leaving thousands of Black families and youth in limbo.

1:32:43We applied, we interviewed, we planned with integrity.

1:32:46Holla was recommended by a community-led, equity-rooted process for a reason.

1:32:52For over a decade, we've centered lived experience equity and delivered real impact.

1:32:57Now we ask the council to honor that process and protect the progress.

1:33:021, Fully fund all newly awarded grants for at least 1 year to prevent gaps in services.

1:33:092, If a review is necessary, limit it to hunger relief lane.

1:33:13Don't stall the entire cohort.

1:33:15Request a report from PCL outlining the safeguards and fairness measures built into the process.

Angela Todd 1:33:22 - 1:33:22

1:33:22Thank you.

Eric Knox 1:33:22 - 1:33:36

1:33:22This is about community trust, continuity of service, and the city's own commitment to equity.

1:33:28We're not asking for special treatment, just consistency.

1:33:31We're not asking for charity, we're just asking for respect.

1:33:35Thank you for your time and consideration.

Talia Giardini 1:33:38 - 1:33:39

1:33:38Thank you all for being here.

Unidentified speaker 1:33:43 - 1:33:44

1:33:43Todd Littlefield.

Keith Wilson 1:33:50 - 1:33:58

1:33:50Thank you.

Todd Littlefield 1:34:00 - 1:34:41

1:34:00Todd Littlefield.

1:34:01I live in District 1.

1:34:03Good afternoon, councilors.

1:34:05Mayor Wilson, thank you for your hard work, persistence, determination.

1:34:10Your budget is thoughtful, restrained, with the right priorities.

1:34:16After seeing the lawlessness and chaos which occurred Saturday night, which my neighborhood and many in Portland have lived with on a daily basis going on a decade now, I Googled, why do we have laws?

1:34:27The AI-generated response: laws are crucial for maintaining order.

1:34:33They establish standards of accepted behavior, ensuring fairness.

1:34:37In essence, laws are the foundation of a well-functioning society.

Keith Wilson 1:34:41 - 1:34:41

1:34:41Thank you.

Todd Littlefield 1:34:41 - 1:35:31

1:34:41Without laws, society would be prone to chaos and conflict.

1:34:46They are essential for ensuring that everyone has the opportunity to live a safe, productive, and fulfilling life.

1:34:52When Portland does not have enough officers to send and stop anarchy Saturday night at Lloyd Center and several other locations, we have a major problem.

1:35:02It's a miracle no one was killed.

1:35:04Have there been any amendments to improve the budget Reflecting funding and mandating the hiring of hundreds of more officers immediately.

1:35:12D1 medium income is far below the other districts.

1:35:16We have 40% of the city's children, yet we have councilors who voted to dramatically increase the cost to play golf, thus robbing our children of the opportunity to learn or enjoy the game.

1:35:27What are the council's morals, priorities, standards, and values?

1:35:30Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:35:33 - 1:35:35

1:35:33Murray is joining us online.

Keith Wilson 1:35:37 - 1:35:39

1:35:37Thank you.

Marie Tyvall 1:35:39 - 1:35:40

1:35:39Can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 1:35:40 - 1:35:41

1:35:40We can hear you.

Marie Tyvall 1:35:42 - 1:36:52

1:35:42Thank you.

1:35:43Good afternoon, my name is Marie Tyvall.

1:35:45As a person of white privilege, I applaud Councilor Kanal's comment about the $8.5 million for displaced Albina Black families and that it only begins the process of making people whole.

1:35:55I urge you to vote no for Councilor Clark and Zimmerman's budget amendments funding the District Coalition Neighborhood Association system.

1:36:01Clark and Zimmerman apparently are determined to make people whole, but these are primarily white privileged folks who will benefit from this inequitable system.

1:36:09For example, Councilor Clark will donate $2,000 each to the neighbor— District 4 neighborhood associations whose past actions in the '90s contributed to today's segregated Portland, as documented in the 2019 report on our racist land use history.

1:36:24Councilor Clark also proposes $80,000 of tax Taxpayer funds for the District 4 Coalition newspaper propaganda media that prohibits letters to the editor from the public.

1:36:33Last week, the taxpayer-funded District 4 Coalition announced they will start a neighborhood watch program with the police.

1:36:39Portland's neighborhood watch program was dissolved in 2019, likely because studies show the program incites racial profiling and vigilantism.

1:36:48You may remember 17-year-old Trayvon Martin was shot and killed by a neighborhood watch volunteer.

Keith Wilson 1:36:52 - 1:36:53

1:36:52Thank you.

Marie Tyvall 1:36:53 - 1:37:13

1:36:53Finally, last week Leslie Hammond announced the District 4 Coalition will spend $3,000 of taxpayer funds for a celebration of success dinner held exclusively for board members and their significant others at Lonsdale Gardens.

1:37:05District 4 Coalition may hold the distinction for being Portland's only taxpayer-funded organization currently flush with cash.

1:37:12Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:37:18 - 1:37:25

1:37:18Next up we have Diane Salazar.

1:37:20Patrick Tran, Audrey Kanes, Micah Meskel.

Keith Wilson 1:37:32 - 1:37:33

1:37:32Welcome, go right ahead.

Ruth Levine 1:37:34 - 1:38:46

1:37:34Thank you, councilors.

1:37:35I'm Deion Salazar, all right, District 1 tenant.

1:37:39First, quickly, I support the rideshare union demands.

1:37:43Now, let me be frank, councilors.

1:37:45I ask you, why are you so eager to view department budgets as indispensable except for the police budget?

1:37:52If we need to plug gaps, then we ought to reject the notion that any specific department is solely the one to bear that burden.

1:37:59That's not to reject police accountability, police reform, or say that the police budget is perfect.

1:38:04But at the current moment, this feels more like a vendetta than a targeted move to sustain parks, especially through targeting police recruitment funds.

1:38:12That's not good governance.

1:38:13That's grandstanding.

1:38:15I hope I'm proven wrong about this, but at this moment, I voice my concerns about this I hope this does not become a pattern.

1:38:22Milwaukee, Wisconsin, a diverse progressive city, provides a better model through progressive Mayor Cavalier Johnson because accountability and fairness are what truly matters.

1:38:32That's what Portland believes in.

1:38:34Let's turn that value into our budget commitment by adopting the mayor's budget and funding the auditor's office fully.

1:38:41Lastly, as a PCL community advisory councilor, I oppose a top-down budget reallocation.

1:38:45Thank you.

1:38:46Thank you.

Patrick Tran 1:38:49 - 1:40:35

1:38:49Thank you for the opportunity to be here today.

1:38:53Today I join my nonprofit colleagues from earlier.

1:38:56My name is Patrick Tran.

1:38:57I work with Elso Inc., a nonprofit founded by 2 Black women and led by the board, constituents, and staff that are all 90% Black.

1:39:06I'm honored to speak today with their trust.

1:39:09I would like to address the integrity and equity of the PCL grant process.

1:39:13In my 15 years as a nonprofit fundraising executive, this is the most inclusive and equity-focused process I've seen, public or private.

1:39:23PCL brought a BIPOC consulting firm to help hundreds of community voices and lived experience that this committee questioned last week.

1:39:32The Citizen Oversight Committee leveled the playing field, giving new community groups a real shot and fixing flaws like outlier scores.

1:39:41Equity and fairness in action.

1:39:43For a year, community-rooted organizations went through an exhaustive equity-centered grant-making process.

1:39:50We showed up, we followed the rules, and under PCL's well-thought-out process, no organization had any issues with the process.

1:39:59That is until the recommendations came out.

1:40:02The decision now before this body risks undermining the process and sending a message that even when BIPOC organizations meet the bar, their funding is still negotiable, especially when lobbying and bias comes into play by organizations with more resources and connections to city leaders.

1:40:19That is the core of what happened at last week's meeting, not the equity-centered process that had— has been years in the making.

1:40:26That meeting and decision were not equitable.

1:40:29We urge you to honor the process Respect the recommendations and restore the funding to the youth that we serve.

1:40:35Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:40:37 - 1:40:38

1:40:37Micah.

Micah Mescal 1:40:38 - 1:42:18

1:40:38Mayor and councilors, my name is Micah Mescal, and I'm representing the Bird Alliance of Oregon and our 10,000 local members.

1:40:47I urge you today to not support Councilor Zimmerman's attempts to defund the Urban Forestry Program or shift any of its capacity over to PPMD.

1:40:56Please see a letter submitted yesterday by over a dozen local health, environmental, livability organizations on why we collectively oppose Zimmerman's attempts to further defund the program.

1:41:07The mayor's proposed budget already included a 9 FTE reduction to urban forestry to align with the city's overall budget reductions, and any additional staffing cuts to this team would severely impact its ability to meet the city's and community goals.

1:41:20We understand this is a tough budget year, but urge you not to further cut this program's budget as it will have short-term and long-term impacts on the city's trees.

1:41:29Additional cuts to urban forestry regulatory or code compliance team, which protect our current tree canopy and is a valuable asset of our community, valued at over $9 billion.

1:41:42This, this group, the code compliance group, educates the public on the importance of trees and supports urban forestry's entire scope of work.

1:41:50Any further defunding of this team could roll back much-needed progress in managing this asset and, um, and finally facing our deferred maintenance problem.

1:41:58The community has worked for years with the city to align the urban forestry program capacity with demands for services, balancing robust and cohesive set of non-regulatory and regulatory tools, improved inter-bureau coordination and accountability.

1:42:11Further cuts would have dire impacts for longer-term public health.

1:42:14So please oppose, um, Councilor Zimmerman's attempts to defund.

Marie Tyvall 1:42:18 - 1:42:18

1:42:18Thank you.

Micah Mescal 1:42:19 - 1:42:19

1:42:19Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:42:21 - 1:42:21

1:42:21Jacqueline.

Jacqueline Rivera 1:42:23 - 1:44:04

1:42:23Hello everyone, my name is Jacqueline Rivera and I'm currently 22 years old.

1:42:29I was born and raised here in Southeast Portland and I started working with Portland Parks and Recreation when I was 15 years old.

1:42:37I got denied the first time and then reapplied and completely fell in love with this job.

1:42:42Portland Parks and Rec has given me so many amazing opportunities, so it's saddens me to hear that we aren't going to receive enough funding.

1:42:49I specifically work with the Youth Conservation Crew, which— this crew, I've loved it.

1:42:55I've been with them for like about 4 or 5 years, and I'm back now being a crew leader for a group.

1:43:00I will be— I will be leading a youth group of 9 kids from ages 14 to 18, and I believe it's really important to have these kids come out with us and explore parks if it wasn't for Portland Parks and Recreation, I don't think I'd be outside doing all of this nature work.

1:43:17So I give a big thanks to everyone that has led me into this position.

1:43:22I did give a speech to Mayor Ted Wheeler back in 2020 for Portland Parks and Rec funding, and thanks to him, he was able to give us funding.

1:43:31And also thanks to my position with Portland Parks and Rec, I've inspired other people in my family to pursue careers outdoors, such as Metro.

1:43:39My sister Daniela, she's currently 16 years old and she gives tours for Metro at the Oregon Zoo.

1:43:46I believe it's really important that we get more funding so we get youth educated on why it's important to keep all these parks healthy and safe, because Portland— keeping Portland parks doesn't only make a healthier city, it keeps everyone happy.

1:43:59And we have beautiful parks, and I hope we can continue to protect them.

1:44:02Thank you guys so much for listening to me.

Keith Wilson 1:44:04 - 1:44:04

1:44:04Thank you.

Talia Giardini 1:44:05 - 1:44:06

1:44:05Thank you for being here.

Jesse Hannon 1:44:06 - 1:44:07

1:44:06Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:44:08 - 1:44:39

1:44:08Uh, next up we have Ernie Munch, Daniel Barbato, Anand, Anand Jain, and Henry Kaiser.

1:44:22Henry is joining us online.

1:44:31Go ahead, Henry.

1:44:38Henry, can you hear us?

Keith Wilson 1:44:47 - 1:44:47

1:44:47No.

Unidentified speaker 1:44:48 - 1:45:12

1:44:48All right, we'll come back to Henry.

1:44:52Uh, one more time, Ernie Munch, Daniel Barbato, Anand Jain.

1:44:59Okay, we'll move on to Carol Orloff, Robert Ball, Janet Parker.

1:45:09Okay, I see Henry is connected.

1:45:11Go ahead, Henry.

Henry Kaiser 1:45:13 - 1:45:14

1:45:13Is it my turn?

Keelan McClymont 1:45:14 - 1:45:15

1:45:14Yep, go ahead.

Henry Kaiser 1:45:16 - 1:46:11

1:45:16Okay, I am Henry Kaiser, uh, and I am co-chair of the Health and Senior Safety Committee of the City Club of Portland, and I, uh, speak today to advise people of a July 23rd meeting looking at the issue of mental health for the homeless and access to it.

1:45:36There's a lot of myth and misinformation.

1:45:40If people come to this meeting, they'll find out what's possible, what can be done to overcome, uh, the challenges to make it affordable and to make it effective.

1:45:51Uh, this will be— take place from 6 to 8 PM at Kel's Restaurant on 2nd Avenue.

1:45:57And, uh, if we can deal— uh, bring mental health to the, uh, homeless, I think we'll do a lot to deal with the homeless issues that are challenging our community.

1:46:10Thank you very much.

Talia Giardini 1:46:14 - 1:46:15

1:46:14Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 1:46:16 - 1:46:23

1:46:16All right, I believe we have Janet Parker online.

1:46:21Janet, you're muted.

Janet Parker 1:46:26 - 1:46:26

1:46:26Can you hear me?

Unidentified speaker 1:46:27 - 1:46:27

1:46:27We can hear you.

Keith Wilson 1:46:28 - 1:46:29

1:46:28Okay, thank you.

Janet Parker 1:46:30 - 1:48:10

1:46:30My name is Janet Parker.

1:46:31I live in District 4.

1:46:33The main thing I want to say today is that I don't want any budget cuts to anything to do with public safety in my neighborhood.

1:46:43And I'm nervous about recent news that at least 2 new homeless shelters will be opening in my neighborhood in the very near future.

1:46:50As a member of Stadiumhood and Friends of Pooch Park, I've been impressed with and inspired by the efforts of my neighbors in drawing attention to the serious problems of the flagrantly open use of fentanyl all around us.

1:47:05The homeless, mentally ill, and a chronic problem with tent campers, graffiti, vandalism, and all kinds of garbage on the streets and sidewalks.

1:47:15I live in the south end of the Alphabet District between Trinity Episcopal Cathedral and St. Mary's Catholic Cathedral and School in a 4-unit condo building built in 1884, which was a wonderful place to move to when my husband and I relocated here for 16 years ago, tried to sell our beautiful home last year, and though all who came to look at it couldn't believe it hadn't already sold, not one person made an offer on it because of the neighborhood.

1:47:46My now ex-husband moved back to New York in late 2023, and I recently bought his share of the house because I still love this neighborhood for all the reasons we initially I'm doing what I can to help keep this neighborhood from being destroyed by all the stressors on it.

1:48:06We really can't do it without your help.

1:48:08Thank you for the time.

Unidentified speaker 1:48:14 - 1:48:14

1:48:14Go ahead, Jamie.

Jamie Partridge 1:48:16 - 1:49:59

1:48:16Greetings, Councilor and Mayor.

1:48:20I'm Jamie Partridge.

1:48:21I'm a retired letter carrier and living in Northeast Portland, District 2.

1:48:27I am speaking in favor of a number of amendments here.

1:48:32The current proposed budget increases police funding from the general fund, bringing the Police Bureau's total budget to $318 million for the 2025-26 fiscal year.

1:48:45Portland Police Bureau is the city's largest share of the general fund, 34% in '24-'25, and in 2025-'26 would bring it to 38%.

1:48:57This all the while Portland is looking at a huge $65 million budget deficit, or maybe it's more.

1:49:03Mayor Wilson is proposing to cut every other public service except the Portland Police Bureau at a time when we could be making cuts, should be making cuts to police and investing in the services and programs that truly make our communities safe.

1:49:17In a time when white supremacists are in control of the federal government and targeting vulnerable communities— see Los Angeles— the historic connection and overlap between white supremacists and the police in this region specifically, it's illogical to prioritize police for crisis response.

1:49:34Recently observed Portland police assisting the Immigration and Customs Enforcement removing protesters attempting to defend our it's a clear violation of our sanctuary city guidelines.

1:49:44So I support the Green-Dunphy amendment to increase the police fund, parks, et cetera, and in favor of the Green Amendment 10 for housing tenants, parks, arts, and Portland Street Response.

1:49:59Thank you very much.

Talia Giardini 1:50:00 - 1:50:00

1:50:00Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:50:26 - 1:50:37

1:50:26Misha Litvak.

1:50:32John Hollister.

1:50:36Darren Campbell.

Nikhilesh Desai 1:50:51 - 1:52:17

1:50:51Good afternoon, Council.

1:50:52My name is Nikhilesh Desai.

1:50:55I live in District 3.

1:50:57I'm a city employee.

1:50:58However, I'm here today on my own time representing my personal views.

1:51:02I'm here to speak in opposition to the amendments to eliminate urban forestry permitting, staff, and funding.

1:51:08I'm going to begin with a quote from William Sullivan, a researcher at the University of Illinois.

1:51:14Lack of green infrastructure in the urban environment is the greatest predictor of mortality among low-income communities.

1:51:22Like sewers and city streets, our city's trees across all property types function as infrastructure.

1:51:28Trees play a vital role in mitigating the effects of climate change and, and in improving our public and environmental health.

1:51:36The City Tree Code is an implementation tool of Portland's Urban Forest Plan.

1:51:41This plan reflects industry best practice for managing green infrastructure, and it was written to intentionally align with the city core values.

1:51:49Thank you.

1:51:50Together, the tree code and management plan work to protect and grow our urban forests so that all Portlanders will have access to shade, clean air, mental— better mental health, cooler neighborhoods, and more.

1:52:03Trees are an investment in our future.

1:52:05If these amendments pass, they'll have a devastating effect on the livability of our city for generations to come, with immigrant, refugee, people of color, and low-income communities suffering the most— our most vulnerable communities.

Unidentified speaker 1:52:18 - 1:52:21

1:52:18Please.

1:52:18Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:52:21 - 1:52:22

1:52:21Go ahead.

John Hollister 1:52:22 - 1:54:06

1:52:22My name is John Hollister and I live in District 4.

1:52:26In mid-2020, City Council voted to defund the police by $15 million.

1:52:31Then in November 2020, City Council tried to reduce the police budget by another $18 million, but Commissioner Ryan cast the deciding vote against this ridiculous proposal.

1:52:41Thank you, Dan.

1:52:42I love you very much.

1:52:445 Of you who publicly supported the defund the police campaign on their website would have voted to cut another $18 million in, in 2020.

1:52:52Thank God you weren't in office at this time.

1:52:55One of you said diverting $1.9 million from the police wasn't a cut, that no one would lose their job.

1:53:02Last year, Portland had the highest number of police retirements in history.

1:53:07You're voting not to replace any of them.

1:53:09Nordstrom, multiple Safeways, REI, Walmart are all on month-to-month leases as they plan their departures because of safety issues.

1:53:17You think Portland has a budget shortfall now?

1:53:19Just wait.

1:53:20Oh, one correction.

1:53:21REI and Walmart have already left.

1:53:23Commissioner Novick, I campaigned for you because you, you put public safety first.

1:53:29I feel betrayed.

1:53:31This vote is on you.

1:53:32How do you want to remember— be remembered in 2026?

1:53:36At reelection time and beyond.

1:53:39Commissioner Dunphy, I also campaigned for you.

1:53:41We discussed this.

1:53:42You put public safety as your number one, and I feel the same betrayal.

1:53:48Nick Fish is turning over in his grave.

1:53:49Well, he was cremated, but you know what I mean.

1:53:52This vote is on you.

1:53:54Actually, Trump is hoping you vote to take all $1.9 million away because he'd love to send the National Guard here, like, like when Portland can't handle the big next, next big incidents, just like he's in LA and New York.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:54:06 - 1:54:06

1:54:06Very much.

Misha Litvak 1:54:09 - 1:55:01

1:54:09My name is Misha Litvak.

1:54:11I'm the vice president of AFSCME Local 1790, representing frontline behavioral healthcare workers in our city's homeless shelters.

1:54:19I myself am also a case manager working at one of the village model shelters.

1:54:23I've been here a couple times before now.

1:54:26So these cuts to our services, they, they punish the workers.

1:54:31This is like an austerity measure that punishes workers.

1:54:33It leaves us less able to do our jobs.

1:54:35I'm hearing all this about the police are not able to do their jobs and their budget's getting increased, or people are wanting to increase the budget.

1:54:41We don't get that same treatment.

1:54:43Right now we are being punished for, I mean, basically policies and practices that are being enacted by people who will not be affected by this.

1:54:52These contractors, these CEOs, they can sign up again.

1:54:55They can propose to run something else 2 or 3 years down the line.

1:54:58The people who work at these programs, the people we serve, we don't have those options.

Sarah Morrissey 1:55:01 - 1:55:01

1:55:01Thank you.

Misha Litvak 1:55:03 - 1:55:22

1:55:03We just faced our 3rd round of layoffs since January 2025.

1:55:07It's going to leave us without peer mentors, who are people who, you know, they show the way out.

1:55:12These are people with lived experience.

1:55:15Less budget is less staff, less safety, less services, and worse outcomes.

1:55:20I yield back the rest of my time.

1:55:22Thank you.

Darren Campbell 1:55:22 - 1:57:08

1:55:22Good afternoon, uh, Council President Pirtle-Guiney, uh, Vice President Good evening, Councilors, Mr. Mayor, Mr. Jordan.

1:55:33My name is Darren Campbell.

1:55:35For the last 3 years, I've chaired the PBOT Private Hire Transportation Advisory Committee, and I'm here to speak on the increase to the ride fees of $1.35.

1:55:46My personal belief is it needs to be more than that.

1:55:48I've met with many of you and, and I've spoken towards this.

1:55:56And since the time that Uber and Lyft have come to Portland, Uber has increased their safety fee, their ride fee, from $1 to $5.

1:56:07And in that same amount of time, the City of Portland has increased a 50-cent ride fee to 65 cents.

1:56:14This is an overdue increase.

1:56:16I think it's too little.

1:56:19I think incrementally you can increase it an extra dollar every year until you get up to that $5 mark, but more More than that, I think you're leaving money on the table.

1:56:29I think you need to include taxis and shuttles.

1:56:32And I also think you need to add the Lime bikes and the other bikes.

1:56:39These are fees that people will not blink an eye at paying.

1:56:44Now, Uber and Lyft, they will come screaming saying that the number of trips are gonna drop.

1:56:50They're gonna see less trips per year.

1:56:52And I'm here to tell you, they're absolutely right.

1:56:55They're gonna have about 1.5 to 2 million trips go right to TriMet because that's what they took early on when their trips were so inexpensive.

1:57:06So by doing this increase, you're going to help TriMet as well.

John Hollister 1:57:09 - 1:57:10

1:57:09I appreciate your time.

Darren Campbell 1:57:10 - 1:57:10

1:57:10Thank you so much.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 1:57:12 - 1:57:13

1:57:12Thank you all.

Keelan McClymont 1:57:13 - 1:57:32

1:57:13Next, next up we have Jay Nicholson, Kevin Matches, Benson Raby, Emily Stebbins.

1:57:30Go ahead.

Jay Nicholson 1:57:32 - 1:57:54

1:57:32All right, thanks.

1:57:34My name is Jay Nicholson, and I'm here yet again to bring forth the concerns of represented shelter and behavioral health workers in AFSCME Local 1790.

1:57:42Recent budget restrictions handed to some of our represented shelter organizations by Portland Solutions have destroyed our client assistance funds used to help people afford necessary documentation, transportation, phone services, and housing costs.

Christopher Ward 1:57:55 - 1:57:55

1:57:55Additional Councilmember Herbold.

1:57:55Thank you, Mayor.

Jay Nicholson 1:57:55 - 1:59:12

1:57:55Over the past 2 years, significant cuts have been made to case management services, peer services, and the overall staffing of shelter programs.

1:58:01It's a critical loss and will have a disproportionate impact on clients with disabilities and those belonging to other marginalized communities.

1:58:08Many of the city's moves seem to draw from this narrative that people struggling with homelessness are apathetic.

1:58:13They need only to clean up their act and get a full-time job.

1:58:16What about people who can't work a full-time job, can't save for housing?

1:58:20What about people who need the aid of peer services, case management, or assistance funds?

1:58:24To address their obstacles to income or housing?

1:58:27Do you plan to keep them in purgatory?

1:58:30You can end unsheltered homelessness.

1:58:32You can push people out of sight and corral them to holding spaces with nothing else to offer.

1:58:36You can get them out of the way, but where does that leave them?

1:58:39Years ago, a fellow colleague shared this metaphor with me that I will remember for the rest of my life.

1:58:44You don't row out to someone who's drowning and try to make them swim.

1:58:47You bring them to shore and offer support.

1:58:50With the acquisition of and ensuing cuts to these programs at the hands of Portland Solutions, you, the City of Portland, are sending a clear message if any of you want to change this trajectory, the time to act is now.

1:59:04Reinforce funding for supportive services.

1:59:06Reexamine the budget decisions being made by Portland Solutions.

1:59:09We aren't giving up, and neither should you.

1:59:12Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 1:59:14 - 1:59:17

1:59:14Thank you.

1:59:15Kevin is joining us online.

Darren Campbell 1:59:22 - 2:00:56

1:59:22Thank you.

1:59:22My name is Kevin Matches.

1:59:24Councilors, I'm concerned about a pattern of misinformation being given to this body.

1:59:29In a May 14th, 2025 work session, Councilor Kanal asked staff, does the FPDR money show up as an interagency into fire and/or police and then an expenditure there, or is the money completely separate from fire and police budgets?

1:59:43End quote.

1:59:44Staff falsely responded that, quote, it's completely contained within the FPDR system, end quote.

1:59:50This explanation was reaffirmed by staff a second time.

1:59:53In fact, the FPDR Bureau's sole revenue source is its property tax levy, and it does provide interagency revenue to PPB and Portland Fire.

2:00:01The FPDR Bureau's expenditures include benefit payments to retired members in the city-run pension plan who were first sworn before 2007, as well as interagency revenue for PPB and Portland Fire to pay for 100% of OregonPERS contributions Covering members first sworn beginning in 2007.

2:00:18It is the responsibility of PPB and Portland Fire to send contribution payments along to OregonPERS, but they bill these payments back to the FPDR Bureau.

2:00:26I emailed a correction to Councilor Kanal and copied staff.

2:00:29Staff acknowledged the error and thanked me for the correction on May 15th.

2:00:33However, I was disturbed to read a news article dated June 6th containing a link to a memo from staff repeating the same piece of misinformation.

2:00:40The memo falsely states that OregonPERS contributions are a cost subject to inflation to be covered by the general fund.

2:00:46The FPDR Bureau is a topic which has been subject to baseless speculation and outright misinformation in the public record.

2:00:52In my opinion, the lack of adequate discussion at council and in other forums has contributed to this pattern.

Unidentified speaker 2:00:56 - 2:00:56

2:00:56Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:00:59 - 2:01:05

2:00:59Emily is joining us online.

2:01:04Emily, please unmute.

Emily Stebbins 2:01:10 - 2:01:10

2:01:10Hey, can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 2:01:11 - 2:01:11

2:01:11We can hear you.

Emily Stebbins 2:01:12 - 2:02:02

2:01:12Okay, good.

2:01:13My name is Emily Steben, and I know you have a lot to talk about, so I'll keep this short.

2:01:17I want to urge you not to make any further cuts to urban forestry.

2:01:21I'm a volunteer with 350 PDX's Forest Defense Team and have been working on shade equity for several years.

2:01:28Trees provide us all with so many valuable gifts: shade and cooling, clean air, water, Noise reduction, and well-documented mental health benefits.

2:01:36They're a public good, and it is unfair that the burden of caring for them should be shouldered by individual families.

2:01:41The effect of that unfairness is that only neighborhoods where people can afford to take care of trees get to have them.

2:01:48The Equitable Tree Canopy Program is just beginning to counter that effect, but urban forestry cannot implement it or much of the other important work that they do if the funding is pulled out from under them.

2:01:59Please maintain the funding needed to protect our urban forest.

2:02:02Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:02:04 - 2:02:24

2:02:04All right, checking for Megan Murphy, Corinne Frechette, Benson Raby.

2:02:14Okay, we'll move on to Kate Phillips, Amjad Hassan, Charlie Michelle Wesley, Devin Casey.

Unidentified speaker 2:02:28 - 2:02:30

2:02:28Hi, Council.

Kate Phillips 2:02:30 - 2:03:13

2:02:30My name is Kate Phillips, and I'm an ICU nurse and member of Portland DSA.

2:02:34Growing up in Florida, I was accustomed to a lack of investment in parks, with bathrooms often closed or dirty and playground equipment that was in disrepair.

2:02:44When I moved to Portland, I was impressed with the beauty, variety, and maintenance of city parks.

2:02:49I moved to my neighborhood in District 2, specifically to live near Peninsula Park, which is my favorite in Portland.

2:02:56Parks draw community members like myself to choose to reside in the city.

2:03:02I strongly assert that city parks are a higher priority than is expressed in this budget.

2:03:07Beautiful public spaces are incredibly important to a healthy community.

2:03:11I urge the council to fully fund parks.

Unidentified speaker 2:03:13 - 2:03:13

2:03:13Thanks.

Keelan McClymont 2:03:17 - 2:03:17

2:03:17Oh, go ahead.

Devin Casey 2:03:20 - 2:04:13

2:03:20Good afternoon.

2:03:21My name is Devin Casey.

2:03:23I am a case manager and a union steward with ASHMIE 1790, and I work at a safe rest village culturally specific for queer and trans individuals.

2:03:36Right now, as it stands, us and our sister site for BIPOC homeless individuals are facing severe budget cuts.

2:03:47Including layoffs and elimination of our client assistance funds.

2:03:51Our shelter, to put simply, is being set up to fail.

2:03:54This is a step backwards and a blow for our queer, trans, and BIPOC community.

2:03:59At a time when it's more and more difficult to be queer, transgender, and BIPOC in this country, Portland should not be aiding and abetting the likes of the Trump administration in rolling back services and safety nets for queer and trans and BIPOC Portlanders.

Jay Amaechi 2:04:13 - 2:04:13

2:04:13Thank you.

Devin Casey 2:04:14 - 2:04:29

2:04:14I implore the City Council, if there's any way at all, to restore funding to our necessary culturally specific services.

2:04:21This is a chance to show up for queer and trans and BIPOC Portlanders, not just in words alone, but with real action.

2:04:28Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:04:35 - 2:04:50

2:04:35Okay, um, let's see, checking on Aye.

2:04:40Amjad Hassan, Charlie-Michelle Wesley.

2:04:45Okay, let's move on to Justin Skolnick, Terry Parker, Christopher Olsen.

Justin Skolnick 2:05:07 - 2:06:17

2:05:07I'm here for parks maintenance.

2:05:08Please bear with me.

2:05:10My name is Justin Skolnick.

2:05:11I'm a graduate of the University of Chicago Divinity School.

2:05:14I enrolled because sketchy theological ideas had crept into American politics and no one could tell me why.

2:05:20I have a booklet from the National Council of Churches examining the Christian Identity Movement.

2:05:24It describes, quote, a theological stalking horse of the organized racists and anti-Semites who have found it useful as a rallying symbol and recruiting tool.

2:05:32This is from 1986.

2:05:34Today, that movement's kissing cousins set the federal policy agenda.

2:05:38It is evident to the authors and to generations of religious scholars that personal behavior tends to overlap with metaphysical commitments.

2:05:45Behavior resists reform without a change of heart or a change of infrastructure.

2:05:50The plainly discriminatory patterns of local law enforcement are not the kinds of problems you can fix with money.

2:05:56You can't conjure safety sacrificing everything else on the altar of policing.

2:06:00If recruitment is down because critics of police brutality found popular support, then what attracted people to the job was brutality.

2:06:07Without changing the heart of the institution, new recruits can only reproduce the problems.

2:06:12So instead of feeding PPB this little treat, please keep our parks clean.

Terry Parker 2:06:19 - 2:07:03

2:06:19Uh, Terry Parker, District 3.

2:06:24At about 5:45 this past Friday evening, I was in the Hollywood District when a police vehicle went speeding by eastbound on Sandy Boulevard, navigating around heavy traffic by traveling east East in the westbound lanes.

2:06:35That was followed about 4 minutes later by another police vehicle doing the same thing.

2:06:39What became apparent after listening to the TV news, officers were heading to a location on 115th Avenue and Parkrose, 70-plus blocks away where a deputy sheriff had shot a suspect.

2:06:51Last month, a motorcyclist crashed into a parked car and was killed at 57th and Tillamook.

2:06:59Had there been police presence in the neighborhood, just maybe the motorcycle would've been caught speeding.

Emily Stebbins 2:07:03 - 2:07:03

2:07:03Thank you.

Terry Parker 2:07:04 - 2:07:35

2:07:04Prior to the crash or not speeding at all.

2:07:06The police were the last to respond to the scene.

2:07:10Police response times are unacceptably too low.

2:07:14If you want vacant storefronts along Sandy— if you want to fill vacant storefronts around Sandy Boulevard with taxpaying businesses, sidewalks that are more vibrant where people can feel safe, and if you want to cut down on shoplifting, vandalism, and graffiti, break-ins and drug dealing, Portland needs more police officers patrolling the streets and faster law enforcement.

Christopher Ward 2:07:35 - 2:07:35

2:07:35Thank you.

Terry Parker 2:07:37 - 2:07:53

2:07:37The common sense road to accomplishing these goals is to restore the original $9.1 million to PPB as proposed by Mayor Wilson.

2:07:46And I would also like to see you fully fund the neighborhood— our world-renowned neighborhood association budgets.

2:07:53Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:07:56 - 2:07:57

2:07:56Christopher is joining us online.

Christopher Olsen 2:07:59 - 2:08:00

2:07:59Yeah, can you hear me?

Keelan McClymont 2:08:01 - 2:08:01

2:08:01We can hear you.

Christopher Olsen 2:08:02 - 2:09:41

2:08:02Thank you.

2:08:02Hello, Mayor, Council President, and council members.

2:08:05My name is Chris Olson and I live in District 2.

2:08:07Today I'm speaking on my own behalf.

2:08:09First, I want to express my sincere gratitude to the members of this body, who are— which are all of you— who voted in favor of last week's $8.5 million settlement agreement for displaced Albina residents.

2:08:20That was the right decision, both morally and legally.

2:08:23That being said, I'm concerned today about the increasing and increasingly disturbing and false narratives Coming from reactionary forces in our city who claim to speak for the so-called silent majority.

2:08:33They call for more public safety, but define that almost exclusively in terms of expanding police budgets rather than investing in social infrastructure that actually keeps our communities safe.

2:08:42Let's be clear, allocating $2 million for park maintenance does more for our public safety than increasing the number of armed officers or their hours.

2:08:50For example, if an unhoused person does not have access to a public restroom in parks due to a lack of maintenance, where do we expect them to go to the restroom?

2:08:59In doorways, in front of businesses, onto our streets.

2:09:03Public infrastructure makes our city safer and healthier for everyone.

2:09:07And on the topic of small businesses that we keep hearing that are disappearing and going away, uh, that are justifying harsher policing and anti-homelessness policies, let's be clear.

2:09:17A lot of these beloved businesses like REI, Sizzle Pie, Hot Lips, Shoofly Bakery— why did they close?

2:09:23It's because in most cases the workers attempted to unionize and were met with retaliation.

2:09:28It's, it's very clear our, our safest communities are those that are those with the most resources, and all the people of Portland deserve to be invested in, not criminalized.

2:09:37So let's stop with this fearmongering and build a city that works for everyone.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:09:43 - 2:10:13

2:09:43Thank you, colleagues.

2:09:44I know a few people are looking to have a quick break, so I think we're going to take a 10-minute break now instead of waiting until the end of public testimony.

2:09:53Folks, when we get back, we will have About another 40 or so minutes for public testimony.

2:10:01So we should be able to get through all or almost all of the people who are left who have signed up.

2:10:08Colleagues, let's meet back here at 3:15.

2:10:11We will be on a 10-minute recess.

Unidentified speaker 2:10:14 - 2:24:11

2:10:14Thank you.

2:24:10Welcome back.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:24:11 - 2:24:34

2:24:11We are calling today's City Council meeting back into order.

2:24:16Thank you for everyone's patience.

2:24:18We are picking up about 2/3 of the way through public testimony, and we should have 30 to 40 minutes left that we can do for public testimony.

2:24:30So I'm hopeful that we can get through everybody.

2:24:32Keelan, could you call up our next panel, please?

Emily Stebbins 2:24:34 - 2:24:35

2:24:34Great.

Keelan McClymont 2:24:35 - 2:24:43

2:24:35Yes, thank you.

2:24:36We have Henry Hazelton, Christopher Ward, James O'Loughlin, Leah Dawkins.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:25:03 - 2:25:05

2:25:03Please go right ahead.

James O'Loughlin 2:25:07 - 2:26:39

2:25:07Good afternoon, Council.

2:25:10My name is James O'Loughlin.

2:25:11I'm a labor representative with LIUNA 483.

2:25:14I represent parks workers, transportation workers, Environmental services workers and basically everything else the city does.

2:25:23First, I want to say thank you to everyone that's spoken on behalf of sufficiently funding parks and protecting our urban forestry workers.

2:25:32That work is— it's so essential to protecting the city, especially moving forward through our climate crisis.

2:25:38I'm here today to speak about a less visible component of our work, the Environmental System Development Group in PBOT.

2:25:47This group is funded by funding from BES that has been reduced in this budget cycle.

2:25:54That would lead to about 24 FTE terminations.

2:25:58Nearly half of those are filled.

2:26:00These workers basically maintain and repair all the equipment that collects water throughout the city, redirects it to our wastewater treatment services plant.

2:26:13And BES has robust ability to fund these positions.

2:26:19If they don't fund these positions, the alternative plan is to support emergency work that is likely to cost more.

2:26:26But with $300 million in contingency and redundant supervisor positions that have been created, the $1.2 million to just keep the staff we have would be worthwhile investment.

Zulema Figueroa 2:26:39 - 2:26:39

2:26:39Thank you.

James O'Loughlin 2:26:40 - 2:26:43

2:26:40Around this council's priorities.

2:26:43Thank you for your time.

Christopher Ward 2:26:48 - 2:28:00

2:26:48My name is Chris Ward.

2:26:50Welcome, councilors, to your new role.

2:26:52I want to speak to you as a tree care provider in the Portland metro area and as a citizen, and I want to urge you to continue your support for urban forestry and all of its services, including permitting and regulation, at full capacity.

2:27:05Now and in the future, we live in a historic period characterized by changing warming climate.

2:27:10The urban forest canopy provides important necessary services for human survival.

2:27:15The future livability of our city depends upon investments in urban forestry now.

2:27:20Why is that?

2:27:21Consider the urban heat island effect, wherein the absence of tree canopy in urban centers equates to increase in surface temperature compared to the surrounding rural.

2:27:30Areas.

2:27:31Portland State scientists in a recent paper noted that Portland's annual temperature has increased by 3 degrees since 1940 and an average 4.6-degree increase in the summer temperatures in that period.

2:27:45They were able to show that surface temperature throughout Portland decreases linearly with canopy coverage.

2:27:52Let's look at this effect as seen in the various social strata in Portland.

2:27:55What about the homeless?

2:27:56Where do they go to That's right, in tents under the trees in the parks and the right-of-ways.

Misha Litvak 2:28:01 - 2:28:01

2:28:01What about you?

Christopher Ward 2:28:01 - 2:28:21

2:28:01Where do you go to escape the heat?

2:28:03That's right, in your house under the cooling shade of the trees.

2:28:06This brings us up to a third point.

2:28:08Most of the tree canopy in Portland is on residential lots.

2:28:11You take away the tree code and there's no end to the removal of trees and all sorts of reasons, valid to frivolous and so forth.

2:28:18Having a tree code is an expression of Portland's public will.

Jay Amaechi 2:28:21 - 2:28:22

2:28:21Thank you.

Christopher Ward 2:28:24 - 2:28:37

2:28:24Don't cripple this institution.

2:28:25Make the wait times for permits up to 3 months.

2:28:27Private property owners, tree service providers, contractors, developers, and many other interested parties depend upon the efficient and timely inspection regime for their tree permitting needs.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:28:38 - 2:28:39

2:28:38We appreciate you being here.

Keelan McClymont 2:28:41 - 2:28:43

2:28:41Charlie Michelle Wesley has joined us online.

Charlie Michelle Wesley 2:28:50 - 2:29:17

2:28:50Hi, uh, yes, Charlie Michelle Wesley, Northwest tribal member.

2:28:54I'm mainly here on behalf of Portland Cop Watch.

2:28:58The city budget is a police accountability tool that has been sorely underutilized.

2:29:05So we at Portland Cop Watch were encouraged by the councilor's efforts to use it to require PPV transparency, closer oversight, investment in safer, proven, publicly supported efforts like PSR.

Unidentified speaker 2:29:17 - 2:29:18

2:29:17Thank you.

Corinne Frechette 2:29:18 - 2:29:19

2:29:18Thank you.

Charlie Michelle Wesley 2:29:19 - 2:30:31

2:29:19However, until public safety for all is the case, we do not support any additional funding, nor do we believe the police budget should be exempt from cuts.

2:29:29Just a few weeks ago, the city paid out $475,000 on 2 settlements for police brutality and violating constitutional rights.

2:29:38This is not accountability.

2:29:40Personally, for hours I sat in overflowing auditoriums of community members begging, pleading, and rightfully so, demanding funding for their beloved parks and recreation.

2:29:50So many, uh, support and many supportive services.

2:29:54We were so grateful for those few city councilors that went to bat for us, who listened to us, who value us, to bring at least a minimum of $1.9 million funding to community while $21 million goes to cops.

2:30:07These councilors bring an anti-discriminatory conscience to this chamber versus those serving the privileged powerful and who are more willing to ignore these community members as collateral damage.

2:30:18When election rolls around, we will remember who broke promises versus those who fought for us and met our needs.

2:30:25Support our community, not policing.

2:30:27Let them figure out how quality over quantity is a solution.

Terry Parker 2:30:32 - 2:30:32

2:30:32Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:30:34 - 2:30:35

2:30:34Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:30:35 - 2:30:56

2:30:35Okay, uh, checking Henry Hazelton, Leah Dawkins.

2:30:42Okay, next up we have Shelly Bigley, Babs Spinelli, Tony Gracia, Rain Talley.

2:30:55Go ahead, Babs.

Babs Spinelli 2:30:57 - 2:30:58

2:30:57Hi, thank you very much.

Emily Stebbins 2:30:59 - 2:30:59

2:30:59You—.

Babs Spinelli 2:30:59 - 2:31:00

2:30:59I assume you can hear me okay, correct?

Keelan McClymont 2:31:01 - 2:31:01

2:31:01We can hear you.

Babs Spinelli 2:31:02 - 2:32:34

2:31:02Thank you.

2:31:02Babs Spinelli, 77-year-old lifelong Portland resident currently in District 2.

2:31:07I've had the privilege and honor of meeting all of you at various points over the last 2 years.

2:31:13While I sometimes disagree with some of the things some of you say, I have never doubted your commitment to improving things in my beloved City of Roses.

2:31:23All right, I'm just going to highlight a few things.

2:31:26By the way, I am wearing my Ruth Bader Ginsburg t-shirt today because that reminds me to never give up.

2:31:33Okay, as for me, I support parks, support expansion of Portland Street Response and the program through the fire department, Community Health Assess and Treat.

2:31:46I support city-county collaboration on transition from shelters to housing, including mental health and addiction treatment as necessary, and help with applying for jobs.

2:31:58As in terms of the police, The piece that I do support is that allocated funding goes specifically to training, including training in sensitivity, so that officers can get on the job as soon as possible.

2:32:19Ultimately, perhaps we will be able to reduce overtime hours.

2:32:25Thank you so much.

2:32:26Appreciate all the members who have testified today.

2:32:29We are coming out in droves to make our voices heard, and we know you are listening.

Unidentified speaker 2:32:35 - 2:32:36

2:32:35Thank you.

2:32:36Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:32:37 - 2:32:40

2:32:37Shelly, you're muted.

Shelly Bigley 2:32:44 - 2:32:44

2:32:44There we go.

Unidentified speaker 2:32:46 - 2:32:47

2:32:46Hi.

Keelan McClymont 2:32:47 - 2:32:48

2:32:47Oh, go ahead, Shelly.

Shelly Bigley 2:32:49 - 2:33:59

2:32:49Hi there.

2:32:50Um, my name is Shelly Bigley, and I'm born and raised in Portland.

2:32:55I've been a restaurant owner in Portland since 1991, and specifically I would like to express to the council the importance of public safety.

2:33:05In my experience in District 2 over the last 5 years, my security costs have dramatically gone up.

2:33:11I've had to replace 12 windows, been broken into several times causing significant damages.

2:33:17I've had to buy a $4,000 security door, hire private security and remove my outside street patio due to crime and drug use.

2:33:27I have never made an insurance claim for fear of being canceled.

2:33:31So again, I just urge to continue police funding and adding the boots-on-the-ground presence.

2:33:37In addition to the funding the police, I would like to see programs continue to be funded to get people off of the streets for housing, treatment, and job training.

2:33:47I applaud Dan Ryan for all of his efforts for our business owners and Portland residents.

2:33:53Uh, please listen to him and people like me that don't want to give up on our Portland.

Babs Spinelli 2:33:59 - 2:34:00

2:33:59Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:34:02 - 2:34:04

2:34:02Corinne Frechette has joined us online.

Corinne Frechette 2:34:08 - 2:34:39

2:34:08Hi, I hope you can hear me.

2:34:11Um, thank you so much for having us.

2:34:13My first comment is, uh, Please keep on funding police and law enforcement.

2:34:18In Old Town, we suffer from big issues with human trafficking, drug interdiction needs.

2:34:25Please don't give up on that.

2:34:27We're working really hard for very little money, and for some of us, we're volunteers.

2:34:32I'm also a resident in District 4.

2:34:34I witness a lot of crime, a lot of difficulties for people, and we just beg for police.

Emily Stebbins 2:34:40 - 2:34:40

2:34:40Thank you.

Corinne Frechette 2:34:40 - 2:34:53

2:34:40So if there's a way for you guys to actually vote for this, that would be great.

2:34:44It's also extremely difficult for working people to testify.

2:34:48So just, I appreciate the people that are here, and that's it.

2:34:52Please fund our police.

Unidentified speaker 2:34:53 - 2:34:53

2:34:53Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:34:56 - 2:35:02

2:34:56Okay, checking for Tony Garcia, Rain, Tally.

Tony Gracia 2:35:04 - 2:35:05

2:35:04Tony Garcia's here.

Zulema Figueroa 2:35:06 - 2:35:07

2:35:06Oh, great.

Keelan McClymont 2:35:07 - 2:35:07

2:35:07Thanks.

Tony Gracia 2:35:09 - 2:35:10

2:35:09Would now be a good time for me to go?

Keelan McClymont 2:35:11 - 2:35:11

2:35:11Yeah, please go ahead.

Unidentified speaker 2:35:12 - 2:35:13

2:35:12Okay.

Tony Gracia 2:35:13 - 2:36:51

2:35:13Uh, my name is Tony Gracia.

2:35:15I'm an owner of a business that has been around since 2013.

2:35:19We started in Northwest Portland and then in 2020 moved to the St. Johns area where we operate now.

2:35:25Uh, we do fitness instruction, things like personal training, as well as martial arts instruction.

2:35:31I'm a jiu-jitsu coach.

2:35:33And just like the previous speaker said, as a business owner, it's pretty difficult to carve time out of our day in order to be at something like this.

2:35:41In fact, I literally was just on a call with a mom who wants to get her kids into my jiu-jitsu classes and had to excuse myself from the phone call because I heard it was almost my turn to talk here.

2:35:51Now, I would also echo what the previous speaker said, where the crime and the public safety is the top priority for me personally.

2:35:59My business has had a We had a ton of different issues, the most frustrating of which is we had one individual repeatedly vandalize our building by defecating on it, uh, literally taking a poop in his hand and smearing it on our storefront windows on multiple occasions, urinating on our building on multiple occasions.

2:36:18Um, and all of this is caught on high-quality video camera.

2:36:21I reported it to police every time and nothing would happen.

2:36:25It wasn't until he tried to set our building on fire fire during business hours with our members inside of the building that he finally got arrested and charged with something.

2:36:35And it's absurd that it should take this many instances for something to be done about it.

2:36:40And just a couple months ago, a different individual defecated on my storefront window again, and he was finally arrested and released the same day.

2:36:48And so I urge more funding for police and public safety.

Keelan McClymont 2:36:55 - 2:37:08

2:36:55Uh, Lydia Moges, Amy Wexler, Zulema Figueroa, Emma Darden.

Lydia Moges 2:37:15 - 2:38:36

2:37:15Good afternoon, um, council members.

2:37:17My name is Lydia Moges, and I'm here representing the Ethiopian and Eritrean Cultural and Resource Center, and standing in solidarity with our coalition partners, ELSO, Hala Mentors, and Triple Threat Mentoring, that were significantly impacted by the decisions made in the last councilor mandate for the Portland Children's Levy mentorship awardees.

2:37:36We are located in District 1 and serve in District 1 and 2.

2:37:39We're grateful for the chance to speak today, especially after being previously asked not to provide testimony or lobby, but I must speak honestly.

2:37:46The outcome of the sessions are deeply devastating, not just for EE CRC but for all of us who have spent the last 5, 10, and more years building trusted, culturally specific programs that serve Portland's Black youth and their families.

2:37:59At EE CRC specifically, our work centers on intensive Black and Black refugee youth mentoring, career development, trauma response, and extensive education.

2:38:08The founder and executive director and 95% of our staff, board, We placed our trust in the PCL grant process, one that centered equity, lived experience, and community voice.

2:38:21Your recent decision undermines that process.

2:38:23It sends the message that even when BIPOC organizations follow every rule and meet every standard, our success is still negotiable.

2:38:30That is not equity.

2:38:31It is bias.

2:38:32Again, we urge you, honor the process, respect the recommendations, and restore the funding.

Zulema Figueroa 2:38:37 - 2:39:33

2:38:37Our Good afternoon, um, Portland City Council and Mayor Wilson.

2:38:45My name is Selena Figueroa.

2:38:47I'm a Local 483 shop store and utility worker too in the Environmental Service Division in the maintenance operations at PIVOT.

2:38:56I'm a resident of District 2, St. Johns.

2:38:59I'm here in support of labor brothers and sisters, workers Who day by day are in the field maintaining and repairing our sewers and stormwater systems.

2:39:09We are essential employees who are in the field of rain, hot weather, and freezing weather conditions.

2:39:16We work like from 8 to 12 hours a day whenever it is needed.

2:39:21My job consists with multiple tasks from traffic control such as flagging, taking a lane in Columbia Boulevard for the backdoor operator to clean catch basins.

2:39:33Thank you.

Lydia Moges 2:39:34 - 2:39:35

2:39:34Yes.

Zulema Figueroa 2:39:35 - 2:40:22

2:39:35Cleaning sewer lines, or to— for the TV truck to be inspecting and maintaining sewer lines as well.

2:39:43Additionally, my job is to inspect and clean stormwaters like trash rack around the city.

2:39:48This service is super important in our community, especially during the rainy season.

2:39:52Our labor force makes sure that our stormwater sewers are clean and flowing.

2:39:56The impact of this budget could reduce the labor force services.

2:40:00So a storm— a simple example is like It will be, you know, when it's a rainy season, you know, can be flooding and debris in those catch basins.

2:40:08So therefore jeopardize the safety of the pedestrians, also the drivers.

2:40:12So I'm here to ask for more funding from BES to our division, PYSD Environmental Service Division, so that we continue with our essential environment service.

2:40:21Thank you for your time.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:40:23 - 2:40:25

2:40:23Thank you both.

Keelan McClymont 2:40:26 - 2:40:28

2:40:26Amy Wexler is joining us online.

Amy Wexler 2:40:30 - 2:41:46

2:40:30Thank you so much.

2:40:31Amy Wexler, and I'm the executive director for Alliance for a Safe Oregon.

2:40:36Mayor Wilson and city councilors, it's my first time testifying in front of this new configuration, and I welcome all of you.

2:40:42I am a resident of District 2, and if you're not familiar with Alliance for a Safe Oregon, we are a statewide gun violence prevention group, and we work on across a number of areas councilmember Herbold.

2:40:54Thank you, Mayor.

2:40:54I'm going to talk about a couple of areas, including we have an equity table which convenes community violence interruption organizations, and I am asking you to fund community violence interruption for the city of Portland.

2:41:08I'm sure you're aware there's great need for this.

2:41:11Black and brown community members are on the front lines of our gun violence crisis in this city, and we really can prevent gun tragedies by properly funding this work.

2:41:22Additionally, we ask that you fully fund Portland Street Response.

2:41:27An unarmed response is often what's needed, and police gun violence is also gun violence.

2:41:33So we are asking for community safety to be seen in the most broad sense possible, and that would also include funding parks.

2:41:42Respite areas for, for people are— creates community safety and community.

Corinne Frechette 2:41:46 - 2:41:46

2:41:46Thank you.

Amy Wexler 2:41:46 - 2:41:55

2:41:46So, um, thank you so much, and I look forward to working with all of you in the time to come to make Portland the safest place possible for all and to prevent gun tragedies.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:41:57 - 2:41:58

2:41:57Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:41:59 - 2:42:14

2:41:59Uh, Emma Darden.

2:42:03Okay, moving on to Jay Amaechi, John H., Lance Nippert, Ross Freeman-Levin.

2:42:13Go ahead, Jay.

Jay Amaechi 2:42:14 - 2:43:59

2:42:14Hello, Mayor Wilson and members of council.

2:42:18My name is Jay Machi.

2:42:19I'm the organizing director of Unite Oregon.

2:42:21I'm here because the people we represent are tired, tired of our essential services being starved while the police budget consistently consumes resources meant for our well-being.

2:42:31The $2 million to parks originally diverted from police represents a crucial step towards correcting that balance.

2:42:36Do not reverse it.

2:42:38For far too long, Portland's Black, brown, working-class, and houseless communities have been defunded by the overwhelming priority of our social services have suffered chronic underinvestment as police budgets balloon.

2:42:50The $2 million in parks and rec is no extravagance.

2:42:52It's a down payment in investing on what actually keeps us safe, healthy, and resilient.

2:42:57Do not cave to the reactionary voices calling for law and order.

2:43:00These are the white moderates that MLK warned us about, who have always prioritized their own comfort over justice, and history has always proved them wrong.

2:43:09Police and their supporters stood against the marches that gave us our civil rights in the name of law and order.

2:43:14In fact, they stood against every single movement demanding dignity for poor and oppressed people in the name of public safety.

2:43:20Their panic now is the same old song, one that sacrifices our community to prop up a violent, repressive system.

2:43:26I hope that you have the wherewithal to see through it.

2:43:28Pouring money into the police amid Trump's authoritarianism is the farthest thing from safety.

2:43:33We've watched officers brutalize disabled people to the point where the DOJ had to intervene.

2:43:38And recently we've seen them protect and work with ICE as ICE terrorizes our immigrant community.

2:43:43Make no mistake, overfunding the police fuels fascism, and sensitivity training and hiring more local or Black or brown police will not fix the toxic racist culture of PPB.

2:43:54But on the other hand, Parks and Rec feeds hungry kids, shelters the houses in heat waves, and gives youth alternatives to the streets.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:44:00 - 2:44:01

2:44:00Thank you very much.

Keelan McClymont 2:44:05 - 2:44:06

2:44:05Thanks.

Unidentified speaker 2:44:06 - 2:44:06

2:44:06John.

John H. 2:44:06 - 2:45:07

2:44:06My name is John.

2:44:08Good afternoon.

2:44:09I'm here today to strongly oppose any new funding for the Portland Police Bureau.

2:44:13I also would like some clarification because I know that last year it was $295,000 and then the proposed budget says like $316,000 or $318,000.

2:44:21So curious what the actual proposed increase is going to be.

2:44:24They already have the largest budget in the history In their history, they do not need more.

2:44:29Since 2020, after a brief 5% reduction, their budget has increased by nearly 28%.

2:44:35Meanwhile, vital community programs continue to be cut.

2:44:39I want to challenge the misinformation driving the push for even more police funding.

2:44:43One, the claim that we need more police to reduce crime.

2:44:48This claim is not supported by research.

2:44:50Roughly, there's 30 independent studies showing that the size of police force has no consistent impact on crime rates.

2:44:56There's a study by Y.J.

2:44:58Lee et al.

2:44:59That put it, policymakers who want police to have an impact on crime will be better suited investing resources into new evidence-based strategies.

Unidentified speaker 2:45:13 - 2:45:13

2:45:13Wow.

John 2:45:14 - 2:45:59

2:45:14I'm gonna just talk, I have 4 points, so I'll just mention one other one.

2:45:19One of the main arguments that's used is around our police force being much smaller than like the average per capita.

2:45:27I think this argument's absurd.

2:45:29If you look at the cities that have the largest police per capita, these are cities— DC wins, Chicago's second, Baltimore's third, New York City's fourth, Philly, Detroit, Memphis— these are all the places with the most police per capita.

2:45:45Obviously those cities are not the safest cities.

2:45:47Those are some of the cities with the highest crime rates.

2:45:50And then other places like San Jose are very low and they're very safe.

2:45:55So that's, that's that, uh, argument just doesn't work well.

2:45:59That's it.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:46:01 - 2:46:01

2:46:01Thank you.

Lance Snippert 2:46:03 - 2:47:29

2:46:03My name is Lance Snippert.

2:46:04I'm a resident of District 1, beautiful East Portland.

2:46:08Thank you.

2:46:10Portland Police Bureau has been documented on video aiding and assisting Immigration and Customs Enforcement, otherwise known as ICE, in deportation operations in the city of Portland.

2:46:20This is a clear and direct violation of Oregon state law And aside from being morally repugnant, no further funding can go to Portland Police until this matter is investigated, and all funding must be frozen from them until done.

2:46:39The PPB are already underfunded according to them and stretched too thin, again according to them, providing basic public safety to the citizens and businesses of Portland as it is.

2:46:52Diverting the resources they already have to aid a fully funded federal agency in their operations is a double use of my tax dollars and is a misuse of Portland and Oregonian taxpayer funds.

2:47:08Portland is made better by immigrants.

2:47:11Our communities are more vibrant, more alive, and happier when immigrants are welcome and feel safe among us.

2:47:18As a non-immigrant in the sense that I was born within the U.S., my daily life is easier, happier, and better with immigrants around me.

2:47:28Thank you for your time.

2:47:29I yield the remainder.

Keelan McClymont 2:47:32 - 2:47:34

2:47:32Ross is joining us online.

Ross 2:47:38 - 2:47:39

2:47:38Yes, can you hear me?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:47:39 - 2:47:40

2:47:39We can hear you.

Ross 2:47:41 - 2:49:22

2:47:41Excellent.

2:47:42Thanks for the opportunity to address you.

2:47:45And thank you to all the people who've spoken ahead of me.

2:47:49I'd like to echo Jamie Partridge's comments, especially being a fellow volunteer at a local community access radio station in the past with Mr. Partridge.

2:48:03His comments were especially right on spot for me, as were many of the other people's about Retaining services for transition for homeless people and supportive services for houseless and addicted people.

2:48:24I do not think that additional funding for law enforcement is going to address the mental health issues or the addiction issues that I witness on the street in front of my house.

2:48:37Every day, even though there is a drug house on my street— actually, 2 of them— and non-stop drug trafficking.

2:48:47Uh, I don't think law enforcement is prepared to address those issues effectively by arresting people and putting them in jail.

2:48:57I think we need more support services, parks funding, maintenance funding for parks.

2:49:05I just don't think cutting social services is the right way to deal with issues of addiction and houselessness and crime.

2:49:14So thank you all for the opportunity, and I'll just shut up and listen.

2:49:19Thank you.

2:49:21Walter.

Walter Valenta 2:49:24 - 2:49:56

2:49:24Hello, my name is Walter Valenta, and I live in Bridgeton in District 2.

2:49:29I'm speaking for myself.

2:49:32It took many years for us to create the situation we're in now, and it's really hard to try to solve everything with this budget.

2:49:39So I believe what needs to happen is we've got to focus on the most important things and get them fully funded and get them to work, and then build off from there as we bring Portland back from the places that we've been.

2:49:52To me, it's— those priorities need to be having Portlanders feel safe.

Sarah Morrissey 2:49:56 - 2:49:56

2:49:56Thank you.

Walter Valenta 2:49:57 - 2:51:02

2:49:57And having Portlanders see that major strides are being made in our resolution of homeless and people that are living on the streets.

2:50:05Now, if anybody that knows me knows that I care a lot about parks, and I've been on the 40 Mile Loop Land Trust for over 20 years building parks.

2:50:13However, the most important thing the city can do to help the 40 Mile Loop right now is to make the trails we've already built safe to use.

2:50:21People don't feel safe on them.

2:50:23And people are using the trails as a place to live.

2:50:26So by solving those issues, we're solving things for parks.

2:50:31So when we changed the city structure, one of the reasons why we did is that the old system created silos.

2:50:38And I hope I'm not seeing the new council creating a new set of silos that we're going on.

2:50:43I really implore you to find a unified voice as we tackle the most important things, get them done right.

2:50:50And move on to the next things next year.

2:50:52And to me, those are fully funding people feeling safe with public safety and making sure that we make a dent in the real problems with homelessness.

Unidentified speaker 2:51:02 - 2:51:02

2:51:02Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:51:05 - 2:51:16

2:51:05Next up, we have Brittany Gadbury, Matt Nicholson, Rod Such, Tommy Jarvis, Bill Crane.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:51:21 - 2:51:23

2:51:21Matt Nicholson is joining us online.

Matt Nicholson 2:51:27 - 2:52:58

2:51:27My name is Matt Nicholson.

2:51:28I'm an architect that lives in District 4 in the Reed neighborhood.

2:51:33I would like to urge the council to vote no on the Zimmerman 02 amendment.

2:51:38This proposal is a bad faith effort to change policy via the budget process.

2:51:43Uh, the tree code deserves our full support because trees are part of our city's essential infrastructure.

2:51:48The tree code is the tool for creating and protecting that infrastructure.

2:51:52Trees protect us from extreme heat by increasing shade and reducing the heat island effect.

2:51:58They increase our property values, make our streets more walkable, and provide habitat for wildlife.

2:52:04All of these benefits are key to what makes Portland special.

2:52:07In addition to the great environmental harm that this proposal would cause our city, It would also make the tree permit process less efficient.

2:52:14With or without a staff, the tree code will still be the law, and residents will still be required to abide by the code.

2:52:20But without a full staff, callback times will go from days to weeks or months.

2:52:25And now is certainly not the time to make our tree permit process slower.

2:52:29Portland is facing an imminent mass die-off of ash trees due to the arrival of the emerald ash borer.

2:52:34Cutting urban forestry's regulatory staff will make it harder to implement the pest management plan.

2:52:40The tree code was adopted by the residents of Portland because it was a bold, long-term plan for the future health and well-being of our city.

2:52:46It is worth standing up for because it provides huge benefits to all residents of Portland.

2:52:51It has taken decades to get us to where we are today, and our urban forest will quickly disappear if we don't protect it.

2:52:58Thank you.

Keelan McClymont 2:52:59 - 2:53:10

2:52:59Okay, uh, checking to see, uh, Brittany Gadbury.

2:53:06Rod Such.

2:53:09Tommy Jarvis.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:53:12 - 2:53:12

2:53:12Bill Crane.

Keelan McClymont 2:53:17 - 2:53:18

2:53:17That completes testimony.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:53:23 - 2:53:34

2:53:23Thank you, Keelan, and thank you so much to everybody who is still here with us right now for listening to your fellow Portlanders share their thoughts and experiences with us.

Sarah Morrissey 2:53:34 - 2:53:35

2:53:34Yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:53:35 - 2:55:11

2:53:35Colleagues, we are now going to move into, um, adopting some amendments, or at least debating some amendments.

2:53:46And I had sent out a run of show to everybody and also talked about this a little bit at the top of the hour, and I am pulling up not as quickly as I would like to.

2:54:04The amendment list.

2:54:06I'd like us to start with a bit of a housekeeping measure.

2:54:11We voted on a couple of carryover packages last time and then had a discussion in a work session, which included the idea that in order to save time, we batch some of those carryover packages that were left okay.

2:54:29Into one amendment.

2:54:32And I'm now looking for that number, 14.

2:54:34Pirtle-Guiney 14 is the council carryover package.

2:54:40It includes the carryovers from council offices that we had not yet addressed, plus a carryover from council operations to next year.

2:54:50The details are in the packet of amendments, attachment I. Aye.

2:54:56And if there— I would like to start by moving this amendment so that our colleagues have some assurances that what they're hoping happens with the remainder of their office budgets actually does.

2:55:09I would love to have a second.

Walter Valenta 2:55:11 - 2:55:11

2:55:11Second.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:55:12 - 2:55:21

2:55:12Thank you, Councilor Clark.

2:55:14Is there any discussion about Pirtle-Guiney 14?

2:55:20Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 2:55:22 - 2:55:57

2:55:22Thank you, Madam.

2:55:24Thank you, Madam President.

2:55:27I'm just gonna start by asking a couple questions if that's okay.

2:55:33And maybe this is something that I'm not sure if CBO's the best responder to this or what, but how typical is it to use the OEO for councilor office carryover into not next year's budget for the same council office.

2:55:51That I think is a separate question, but over into the bureaus.

2:55:56Is that something that's—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:55:57 - 2:55:58

2:55:57Go ahead, Director Levine.

Candace Avalos 2:55:59 - 2:56:41

2:55:59Sure, yeah.

2:56:01Typically our policy is to do all carryover, whether it's council office or otherwise, in the spring technical adjustment ordinance.

2:56:09I think since this was just the first year of you all going through that process and through the supplemental budgeting process, we— there's no reason it can't be done in the OEO.

2:56:21And so we said that was a fine practice.

2:56:26I mean, I think council has the authority to allocate general fund underspending to any other purpose as long as— yeah.

2:56:39So it's, you know, I don't think there's an issue with—.

Sarah Morrissey 2:56:41 - 2:56:41

2:56:41Thank you.

Candace Avalos 2:56:42 - 2:56:51

2:56:42Sort of essentially deappropriating it in the current fiscal year and appropriating it for a different use next fiscal year, which is essentially what's happening here.

Sameer Kanal 2:56:54 - 2:57:16

2:56:54Okay, thank you.

2:56:55And then I hope that this will be taken in the spirit of just wanting to provide an opportunity to respond to the comments that were made about it.

2:57:03But I do have a question for Councilor Clark because there was some questions around $80,000 for, the District 4 Coalition's newsletter reach.

2:57:13And I just wanted you to speak to that and maybe give a little more clarity.

Walter Valenta 2:57:16 - 2:57:17

2:57:16Sure.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:57:17 - 2:57:42

2:57:17Thanks, Councilor Kanal.

2:57:18I think some of the people who spoke today misunderstood what's in the amendment.

2:57:24It's actually— it is $80,000, and I've identified $15,000 for Voices, which is the District 4 Coalition newsletter, to help with their fundraising to keep that going.

2:57:38And the remainder is divided up between the 32 neighborhood associations.

Sameer Kanal 2:57:52 - 2:57:53

2:57:52Okay, thank you for that information.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:57:55 - 2:57:56

2:57:55Thank you, Councilor.

2:57:56Councilor Green.

Mitch Green 2:57:58 - 2:58:03

2:57:58Uh, thank you, Madam President.

2:57:59I'm looking at Pirtle-Guiney 14.

2:58:01That's what we're talking about right now, right?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:58:04 - 2:58:04

2:58:04It is.

Mitch Green 2:58:04 - 2:58:17

2:58:04Okay, can you tell us how this is connected to what the Finance Committee dealt with yesterday, if there's any connection?

2:58:11I think that there's a little bit of an overlap here, but but not completely.

2:58:15Can you just explain that a little bit?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:58:17 - 2:59:09

2:58:17When there are expenditures from this biennium that bureaus or offices wish to carry over into the next biennium, that requires 2 actions.

2:58:33It requires deappropriating the funds, or I'm sorry, I said biennium out of old habits, fiscal year.

2:58:39It requires deappropriating the funds in this fiscal year, which is done through an overexpenditure ordinance, the Finance Committee discussed yesterday, and then appropriating those funds into next fiscal year's budget, the '25-'26 budget, which is what we do through our budget amendments.

2:59:00So many of the things on this list likely look familiar to folks who sit on the Finance Committee or who looked at yesterday's Finance Committee documents.

Mitch Green 2:59:10 - 2:59:30

2:59:10Thank you.

2:59:10And so, like, for instance, Green, whatever it was, we dealt with on May 21st.

2:59:16So it's not on this— in this ordinance, but it is in the OEO package that the Finance Committee.

2:59:22So I just want to be clear, this Pirtle-Guiney 14 is just carrying forward the OEOs that councilors had submitted that didn't get heard on the 21st.

Lance Snippert 2:59:30 - 2:59:31

2:59:30Is that right?

Keelan McClymont 2:59:31 - 2:59:31

2:59:31Correct.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:59:31 - 2:59:37

2:59:31We heard your amendment and I believe one other and didn't have time for other councilors.

Mitch Green 2:59:41 - 2:59:45

2:59:41I, I think that's my questions for now.

Matt Nicholson 2:59:45 - 2:59:45

2:59:45Thanks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 2:59:45 - 2:59:48

2:59:45Councilors, any other discussion?

2:59:47Councilor Avalos?

Keelan McClymont 2:59:49 - 2:59:50

2:59:49Yeah, I'm not—.

Candace Avalos 2:59:50 - 3:00:01

2:59:50I'm actually confused though.

2:59:52So what are you saying?

2:59:53Because yesterday the OEO had the council ops, clerk, Smith, Koyama Lane, and Green.

2:59:58This one has all of those except for Green.

3:00:00I don't understand why.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:00:01 - 3:00:07

3:00:01We voted on the amendment to reappropriate those as requested by Councilor Green on the 21st.

Candace Avalos 3:00:08 - 3:00:09

3:00:08Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:00:09 - 3:00:14

3:00:09We didn't get to these other requests at that time.

Candace Avalos 3:00:16 - 3:00:19

3:00:16And then we're doing it via an amendment.

Lance Snippert 3:00:19 - 3:00:19

3:00:19Why?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:00:21 - 3:00:52

3:00:21There are 2 actions that need to be taken.

3:00:23The OEO had all of those amendments reflected in it because that's the deappropriating of the funds from the '24-'25 fiscal year.

3:00:33We had only reappropriated We've already appropriated one of those sets of funds, the amendment that Councilor Green brought forward.

3:00:42This is the reappropriation of the others that our colleagues brought forward, as well as a carryover that Council Operations has asked to use next year.

Sarah Morrissey 3:00:55 - 3:00:57

3:00:55Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:00:57 - 3:01:17

3:00:57Councilor, you and I had had some conversation about what we thought of this practice generally, I see this year frankly as a courtesy to our colleagues.

3:01:16Councilor Ryan.

Eric Zimmerman 3:01:19 - 3:01:57

3:01:19Yeah, colleagues, I'm trying to make the decision here that's principled for me.

3:01:23And one, I didn't vote yes on the amendment that we did, the vote that we took in January, I thought we went too far on our council funding.

3:01:32And so I wouldn't— I'm not gonna vote to deappropriate and reappropriate.

3:01:36I think these funds should go like they always have been traditionally, which is to be deappropriated and then into the bigger picture funding.

3:01:45I'm just against the principle of using our office funds to do one-time funding in the next year.

3:01:52And so even though I like some of them and I don't like some of them, I'm just gonna make a decision to vote no on these.

Walter Valenta 3:01:57 - 3:01:58

3:01:57Thank you.

Eric Zimmerman 3:01:58 - 3:01:59

3:01:58I just wanted to say that up front.

Claudio Campuzano 3:01:59 - 3:01:59

3:01:59Thanks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:02:00 - 3:02:02

3:02:00Thank you, Councilor.

3:02:01Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 3:02:06 - 3:02:26

3:02:06Thank you, Madam President.

3:02:08I just wanted to ask if you could speak a little bit more to the last thing you said a moment ago, Madam President, which is that you see this year as a courtesy to our colleagues.

3:02:18Does that imply that we're going to have a conversation about what our community practice is here as a council going into next year's budget?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:02:27 - 3:02:51

3:02:27Some of our colleagues have raised concerns, as Councilor Ryan just did, about this practice generally.

3:02:34But because this was an option that was put on the table and because we have already done so for one of our colleagues, while I do personally share some of Councilor Ryan's concerns, I, from my perspective, we should extend that same courtesy to all if we're going to extend it to one.

Sameer Kanal 3:02:52 - 3:02:53

3:02:52Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:02:58 - 3:03:08

3:02:58Colleagues, any other discussion on Pirtle-Guiney 14?

3:03:04Okay, Keelan, could you please call the roll?

Sameer Kanal 3:03:09 - 3:03:13

3:03:09I too share some of Councilor Ryan's concerns, but I found that last argument compelling from the council president.

Claudio Campuzano 3:03:13 - 3:03:14

3:03:13I vote aye.

Keelan McClymont 3:03:14 - 3:03:15

3:03:14Ryan?

Dan Ryan 3:03:15 - 3:03:16

3:03:15No.

Keelan McClymont 3:03:16 - 3:03:17

3:03:16Koyama Lane?

Tiffany Koyama Lane 3:03:19 - 3:03:19

3:03:19Aye.

Sameer Kanal 3:03:20 - 3:03:20

3:03:20Aye.

Steve Novick 3:03:21 - 3:03:29

3:03:21Aye.

3:03:23I also share some of Councilor Ryan's concerns and hope that we will come up with an overall policy before this time next year.

Olivia Clark 3:03:30 - 3:03:30

3:03:30Aye.

Keelan McClymont 3:03:31 - 3:03:31

3:03:31Clark?

Olivia Clark 3:03:32 - 3:03:32

3:03:32Aye.

Keelan McClymont 3:03:33 - 3:03:33

3:03:33Green?

Mitch Green 3:03:33 - 3:03:38

3:03:33Due to the concerns raised, aye.

3:03:38Aye.

Candace Avalos 3:03:38 - 3:03:42

3:03:38Reluctantly voting aye because I have a lot of those concerns too.

Loretta Smith 3:03:43 - 3:03:43

3:03:43Aye.

Walter Valenta 3:03:44 - 3:03:44

3:03:44Aye.

Keelan McClymont 3:03:44 - 3:03:45

3:03:44Smith?

Loretta Smith 3:03:45 - 3:03:45

3:03:45Aye.

Keelan McClymont 3:03:46 - 3:03:47

3:03:46Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:03:47 - 3:03:47

3:03:47Aye.

Keelan McClymont 3:03:48 - 3:03:54

3:03:48The amendment is approved with 12 yes votes and 1 no vote.

3:03:52Oh, sorry, 11 yes votes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:03:54 - 3:03:57

3:03:54I'm gonna write down 11-1 on my page.

Ross 3:03:57 - 3:03:58

3:03:57Sorry.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:03:59 - 3:05:02

3:03:59Thank you, Keelan.

3:04:03Colleagues, we are now moving into something similar to the work that we were doing on the 21st where we took amendments category by category, and everybody had the opportunity to bring forward their highest priority amendment or package, not meaning everything under the sun, but we know that in some cases amendments were broken into a couple of different structural amendments, even though it was one concept.

3:04:34And we're going to pick up with the the policy areas that we did not get to on the 21st.

3:04:43I know that there are many new amendments or policy areas where colleagues, you had a number of priorities that you were hoping to bring forward.

3:04:52After we do this run-through of all of the topic areas and then talk through some budget notes on the run of show where it says additional amendments is where we will come back to those other things.

Sarah Morrissey 3:05:03 - 3:05:03

3:05:03Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:05:03 - 3:05:19

3:05:03So they are not off the table.

3:05:05We're just trying to do this, picking up where we left off before.

3:05:10We are going to move into the parks policy area.

3:05:13Councilor Zimmerman, are you in the queue to talk about an amendment around parks or are you in the queue for something else?

Sarah Morrissey 3:05:19 - 3:05:20

3:05:19Parks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:05:21 - 3:05:25

3:05:21Fantastic.

3:05:21Would you like to kick off our conversation around amendments related to parks?

Eric Zimmerman 3:05:26 - 3:06:28

3:05:26Thanks.

3:05:27I appreciate this, the conversations around the dais that I've been able to have with many of you regarding my efforts in the tree regulation work.

3:05:36And also just the public comments, right?

3:05:39I think that there's been a lot of recognition in terms of the importance of the urban forestry program in the City of Portland.

3:05:47One of the unfortunate aspects of the last few weeks has been, even on this dais at times, a mischaracterization that somehow my original amendment was removing all aspects of urban forestry.

3:06:01And I will— Councilor Dan Ryan.

3:06:03I will own that with only it must have been the way I delivered it.

3:06:06And that I have always said that maintaining the outreach, the science, the tree planting, the tree maintenance programs in urban forestry was important and remains a priority for me.

3:06:18I also heard from my colleagues about a willingness to admit that we've got some problems in tree regulation and how we apply the code against Portlanders.

Sarah Morrissey 3:06:28 - 3:06:28

3:06:28Yeah.

Eric Zimmerman 3:06:28 - 3:06:45

3:06:28And so I've developed 2 amendments and I have sent those to many folks.

3:06:34And I'd like to read in the first one and then the second one, if that would be all right.

3:06:41And then have discussion, Council President.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:06:46 - 3:06:54

3:06:46You'd like to read in both of them together and then discuss?

3:06:52Or separately?

3:06:53I'm sorry, I didn't understand.

Eric Zimmerman 3:06:54 - 3:07:01

3:06:54Yeah, I guess I'm open to— let me describe both.

3:06:57And if we wanna discuss one at a time, I think that's fine.

3:07:00I'm going to introduce both.

Steve Novick 3:07:01 - 3:07:01

3:07:01All right.

Eric Zimmerman 3:07:01 - 3:07:53

3:07:01So Amendment 1, Amendment 1, amend to move 100% of parks levy funds, which equates to about $2.1 million, from the tree regulation program within the Urban Forestry Division and reallocate the parks levy funding, $2.1 million, to the parks maintenance program.

3:07:22This restores $2.1 million to the parks maintenance program that was reduced in the mayor's proposed budget.

3:07:29Parks levy funds are not intended to fund code compliance and enforcement officials, and their use is better aligned within parks maintenance.

3:07:39This is particularly sensitive as the city prepares to refer a levy to voters in November '25, and the city should take every effort to ensure voters know that their support for the levy is dedicated to meaningful recreation and maintenance programs.

Sarah Morrissey 3:07:53 - 3:07:54

3:07:53Thank you.

Eric Zimmerman 3:07:55 - 3:08:12

3:07:55This amendment does not make any changes to the Urban Forestry Division programs of science, outreach, tree maintenance, and these are contained in programs in different parts of the urban forestry budget.

3:08:07So that's my first amendment.

3:08:08It's just the parks levy moving into parks maintenance.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:08:13 - 3:08:19

3:08:13And Councilor, to be clear, this is a change to Zimmerman 1, you said, not a new numbered amendment?

Eric Zimmerman 3:08:19 - 3:09:16

3:08:19Correct, thank you.

3:08:21I made it clear last time that I, The budget office had me break up previous amendments into many steps.

3:08:29I'm going to go ahead and push back against that and just deliver these in a little bit more clear message.

3:08:35And I've also adjusted them significantly.

3:08:37These are not just a repackaging of the old 4.

3:08:39This is a significant change.

3:08:41And the, the biggest change coming is amendment number 2.

3:08:44Amendment number 2, amend to move all aspects of tree regulation program and staff from the urban forestry programs in the Parks and Recreation Bureau to the Portland Permitting and Development Bureau.

3:08:58Code enforcement, permitting, and compliance work requires evaluation and critical application skills and organizational culture to fairly and appropriately apply city code.

3:09:10The Parks Bureau is poorly positioned and untrained to be able to provide such a service to the Portland community.

Sarah Morrissey 3:09:16 - 3:09:16

3:09:16Thank you.

Eric Zimmerman 3:09:17 - 3:10:06

3:09:17Rather, placing tree regulation inside of Portland Permitting and Development, PP&D, allows a system of oversight, organizational culture, and holistic application of the Tree Code Title 11.

3:09:30This amendment does not cut any funding from the tree regulation program.

3:09:35The bureau leadership of PP&D will have the full authority to implement Title 11 design of and work prioritization for the administration of tree regulation programs, currently housed in the Portland Parks Bureau Urban Forestry Division.

3:09:50So those are 2 amendments and significant changes in that to the previous amendments I had made about reducing the workforce.

3:10:00That now just brings that workforce under a different oversight umbrella.

3:10:04Thank you, Madam President.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:10:07 - 3:10:15

3:10:07Thank you, Councilor.

3:10:07I think we should take discussion on the 2 together since it sounds like they Move together and then obviously vote on them separately.

3:10:15Does that work for you?

Eric Zimmerman 3:10:16 - 3:10:42

3:10:16I don't think they move together.

3:10:18I think that I would say to all my councilors that even if it doesn't move over to PP&D, I think that the concern I have about having parks levy dollars inside the tree code enforcement remains regardless of where tree regulation is housed.

3:10:35So I don't want it to sound like they're one and the same.

3:10:38I'm just noting 2 changes because they're so different from my original amendments.

Candace Avalos 3:10:44 - 3:10:44

3:10:44Got it.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:10:44 - 3:10:51

3:10:44Thank you.

3:10:45Councilor Koyama Lane, are you in the queue to discuss Zimmerman 1 and/or Zimmerman 2?

Keelan McClymont 3:10:51 - 3:10:52

3:10:51Yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:10:52 - 3:10:53

3:10:52Go right ahead.

Keelan McClymont 3:10:53 - 3:11:43

3:10:53I appreciate all my colleagues' work during this first budget process.

3:10:57We're working hard, we're learning a lot, and we're figuring out at what level do we hold responsibility for governance and policy and balancing that with managing at a line item budget level process.

3:11:11These amendments brought forward by Councilor Zimmerman, and to be fair, along with other various amendments on our very long list, appear to move to a level of management over governance.

3:11:22If there is an attempt to manage at this level through the budget, then I have been clear with my colleagues that I am going to expect a high level of information to be convinced that the councilors bringing it forward have done their due diligence.

3:11:34Councilor Loretta Smith.

3:11:34And necessary collaboration.

3:11:37So since I'm seeing these amendments for the first time today, I have some questions that I would like to ask Councilor Zimmerman, if that's okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:11:45 - 3:11:48

3:11:45Councilor Zimmerman, are you open to answering some questions?

Keelan McClymont 3:11:49 - 3:11:53

3:11:49Can you clarify specifically what is the problem that you're hoping to solve?

Eric Zimmerman 3:12:00 - 3:14:36

3:12:00So I think that one thing we have seen is that tree regulation has grown over the previous years significantly with the number of FTE, while other code compliance, code enforcement in the city has been cut.

3:12:20We heard earlier that there are 850 properties, I think 880 properties that are under current code compliance process, and they've got less than half of the amount of employees in the regular PP&D world to deal with all the codes as it relates to property.

3:12:38I think that's partially in, in what happens in government when a pet project gets to grow with little oversight, and I think we're in that situation.

3:12:48When the Parks Bureau presented to us early in this year and, and said that they were unaware of people being denied permits that then had trees fall on their homes, I felt that was pretty disingenuous.

3:13:03When the Parks Bureau, um, just a couple of weeks ago insisted that no levy funds were used in the Parks Bureau, um, uh, budget, well, I want to just highlight that I gave every opportunity to that director to clarify that.

3:13:23But while folks have thought that the Parks Bureau budget entirely was going to be cut with this change, I want to just highlight this is urban forestry.

3:13:34This one line is the $2 million from levy funding.

3:13:39But Adina Long told us that levy funds are not being used for parks levy.

3:13:43I think that's a misnomer.

3:13:44I think if Portlanders continue to read stories like they read in the Willamette Week and the Oregonian in the years as we go to a parks levy, I think we're going to lose that levy.

3:13:55And we might deserve to lose that levy given how this program is being administered in Portland.

3:14:02But when I go to Portland permitting and, and development, I've learned some things over my time in the city and those code compliance officers are applying a holistic approach of many codes, many safety regulations, and they're doing it in a culture that is trying to solve problems versus protecting one thing.

3:14:28So I, I think that the code compliance professionals that exist in our other bureau can probably save this program in the long term.

Steve Novick 3:14:36 - 3:14:36

3:14:36Thank you.

Eric Zimmerman 3:14:37 - 3:15:34

3:14:37I think that's going to be really important because right now I think they're out of line with the public.

3:14:42And I say again, this has absolutely nothing to do with the planting, the outreach, the maintenance of trees.

3:14:48I'm purely trying to make sure that we are not allowing a division of Portland city government to continue to, I think, run unchecked and fairly abusively against Portlanders as it relates to the tree code.

3:15:02Just as we were sitting here, Councilor I sent a message to my 3 colleagues in District 4, one of our constituents who's had their tree code regulation bounced between PP&D and city tree regulation code enforcement officers multiple times.

3:15:17And this weekend, that tree came down on their neighbor's deck, but they had been denied permits on Thursday.

3:15:23So I don't know that we have the oversight that's, that's serving the program very well.

3:15:29And if we want to keep it, we We owe it to the oversight, and I think PP&D is positioned to do that more effectively.

Keelan McClymont 3:15:36 - 3:15:56

3:15:36And I want to understand your process used to develop these amendments.

3:15:39I'm wondering if you can explain how Deputy City Administrators, city employees doing this work, community members were involved.

3:15:46Was there collaboration?

3:15:48We also know that at the end of this year, Urban Forestry Program is leading a Title 11 tree code amendment.

3:15:54How does that fit in with your decisions and amendments?

Matt Nicholson 3:16:00 - 3:16:01

3:16:00Thanks.

Eric Zimmerman 3:16:01 - 3:18:29

3:16:01We've asked multiple times for alternative packages and recommendations to come from the Urban Forestry Division.

3:16:11We have not been given those types of alternative plans.

3:16:17In my original amendments, I asked for what is the right number because I preserved, I think, 5 FTE.

3:16:24And I said I'm open to if there's other right sizes.

3:16:28So I didn't get any of that, but I'm also not cutting any of that either because I've heard from colleagues a willingness not to, not to cut that.

3:16:35So I'm preserving the tree regulation program but placing it under a different oversight bureau.

3:16:42And so that part is significantly different from the original amendment.

3:16:46So there are no additional FTE cuts in the movement to PP&D, and I want to that clear, clear, clear.

3:16:54I will continue to feel very strongly that no Portlander voted for parks levy, which I think most of us think about when it comes to the maintenance of parks, kids having access to recreation, community centers being open.

3:17:09I think, I think looking at the practices that we're getting hammered for with the way code enforcement is going against the tree code, and when people have things like, we'll save, you know, save people, save trees at the expense of people.

3:17:23I think that's a terrible thing to tie our levy to.

3:17:25And so I'm making a strategic and frankly a cultural community-based idea that I don't think we should be spending levy dollars in the regulation.

3:17:35So that was my decision process.

3:17:37I've worked with anything I could, was able to get from the Parks Bureau, which wasn't a lot.

3:17:42I think that's a good point.

3:17:43I think that the braided funding model that they've used has been deliberate.

3:17:47I think that's made it very difficult.

3:17:49And so I'm gonna not take an action today in these amendments that hurts the employees in that or the work of it, but instead set some standards.

3:18:03Levy dollars are not gonna be used for tree regulation and allows, I think, whether those code changes come later this summer from Title XI, or for Title XI.

3:18:14I think that the recommendations we get out of them will be much stronger under the guise and leadership of PP&D, who I think is taking a holistic look about all of these types of things in Portland versus just the one thing.

3:18:27I think that's a big difference in perspective.

Keelan McClymont 3:18:30 - 3:18:49

3:18:30I'm hearing your points and concerns.

3:18:32I would also want us to consider beyond the individuals involved I'd also want to have an understanding of the structures and systems at play.

3:18:40What do we know about if and how these amendments would change the structures and systems?

3:18:44I'm willing to hear from you, or if it makes sense, I'm open to hearing from DCA Szymanski or—.

Eric Zimmerman 3:18:50 - 3:19:53

3:18:50So I think that within the Parks Bureau, you've got things like the helpline, the program administration, the non-development permit, development permit, those types of groups.

3:18:59None of those groups would cease to exist.

3:19:01By these amendments.

3:19:04This aspect, right, is really important when it comes to the fact that all of the services that we expect of tree code remain intact.

3:19:17They may not be as full with general fund, but we're allowing PP&D to better evaluate and say, okay, I've got, I've got $4-some-odd million instead of $6-some-odd million to accomplish this.

3:19:28I think that's a good point.

3:19:29Where do I want to assign it?

3:19:30And in a place where we've got, by the way, PP&D already has tree inspectors on their books.

3:19:36This is not a line of work they're out of touch with.

3:19:39So I think that the worry that we were slicing one portion of this division off and that was going to hurt us, I think we've belayed that in this because we're just moving it over to a new section.

Keelan McClymont 3:19:58 - 3:20:03

3:19:58And what would be the reason for this being a council decision versus an administrative decision?

Eric Zimmerman 3:20:04 - 3:20:50

3:20:04Great question.

3:20:07I would have loved to have seen this come out of the proposed budget.

3:20:10We didn't, we didn't see that.

3:20:12But in a place where I think we've got a city program who is being administered in either an unfair manner or in a manner that is not treating Portlanders well, I think we do have a duty to act.

3:20:23And we can do that through budget.

3:20:27I would've preferred to have better recommendations come out of the Bureau, but I do not think that the Bureau, the Parks Bureau, is really particularly interested in working on a solution here.

3:20:39And if Portlanders love urban forestry, which I think they do, but if we think tree regulation should be part of that, we may have to save tree regulation in spite of the Bureau leadership on this topic.

Sarah Morrissey 3:20:50 - 3:20:51

3:20:50Thank you.

Eric Zimmerman 3:20:51 - 3:21:16

3:20:51Because they have gone to ground in terms of trying to find a solution here.

3:20:55And frankly, since January, their appearance at this Budget Committee as well as the Finance Committee has been a series of months of gaslighting, who would say we don't have a problem, who have said that we actually only— we issue permits all the time.

3:21:13But I want to just kind of show folks, see this graph?

Sarah Morrissey 3:21:16 - 3:21:16

3:21:16Yes.

Eric Zimmerman 3:21:17 - 3:22:22

3:21:17See where the line starts to drop?

3:21:20That's our urban canopy.

3:21:23And so when urban forestry tree regulations went into place, for the first time in 15 years, we started losing canopy.

3:21:32Something is wrong here.

3:21:34Something doesn't make sense.

3:21:37I would have loved a bureau who was willing to work on a solution, but instead we got a bureau who said there is no problem.

3:21:44There's no problem whatsoever.

3:21:46And this cut is getting up after the part that can hurt Portlanders.

3:21:49It is not getting after the part that is going to plant any trees in, you know, in East Portland.

3:21:54It's not getting after the part that's going to make sure that trees are planted, continue to be watered and cared for.

3:22:00We're preserving the best parts and we're giving the part that's struggling a new boss to see if that new boss can figure it out.

3:22:07Because the fact that we turned urban forestry on and then started losing canopy Councilor Green.

Mitch Green 3:22:25 - 3:23:19

3:22:25Uh, thank you, Madam President.

3:22:27Uh, I originally got into the stack to talk about other things, but the chart now gives me a comment to provide that's relevant.

3:22:34Um, if you, you show a chart like that, Councilor, you're going to get my comments on it.

3:22:38Uh, I don't know where I'm at on your amendments.

3:22:40I am Interested in the balance of this debate and discussion today.

3:22:44I just want to note on the chart, um, you can't draw that conclusion on a causal basis.

3:22:52There was other factors happening such as heat waves and, and pests.

3:22:57And so I think when we lose capacity, it's difficult to tease out the role of spinning up this program.

3:23:04And I know that's the argument you're making, but I don't think— I don't think that's the strongest argument you have in your Your toolkit.

3:23:09I, I think issues related to the parks levy is a little more compelling to me, but I just wanted to share my, my complaints with the chart.

3:23:18So that's, that's all I have.

Steve Novick 3:23:24 - 3:23:48

3:23:24Thank you, Madam President.

3:23:27Just a few short points.

3:23:29I am sympathetic to many of Councilor Zimmerman's points.

3:23:34I'm just not prepared to support these proposals now.

3:23:38For one thing, on the move to PP&D, I'm certainly open to considering that, but I confess I haven't asked PP&D what they think about it.

3:23:45And I— okay, you have, and they're fine with it?

Walter Valenta 3:23:49 - 3:23:49

3:23:49Yeah.

Steve Novick 3:23:49 - 3:23:49

3:23:49All right.

Eric Zimmerman 3:23:50 - 3:23:58

3:23:50I'm not going to speak for them, but they got an absolutely, we can administer this and there's no change to the full program was the answer I got back.

Steve Novick 3:23:58 - 3:24:27

3:23:58Okay.

3:23:58I mean, that's something that I don't think has I'd still want to hear from them, but I think that's something that doesn't have to happen in the budget process.

3:24:04That's something we could take up next month.

3:24:07On the issue of— I think it's perfectly reasonable to say that when we send out a levy, we can specify that the levy isn't spent for tree regulation.

3:24:17As to removing the $2 million now, though, my concern is that the tree regulatory people don't just go out and beat people up.

3:24:26They also process permit applications.

Sameer Kanal 3:24:28 - 3:24:28

3:24:28Right.

Steve Novick 3:24:28 - 3:25:04

3:24:28And although it may be that we should say you— that we would reach the conclusion that you don't need to have a permit to remove a tree on your own property, right now you do.

3:24:37So I'm afraid that what effect might be that people will apply for permits to remove trees and there won't be enough people there to process the application.

3:24:47So it'll take weeks and weeks for them to get a response, which is as bad as getting a no.

3:24:51So that's my concern about making a cut without knowing exactly what the immediate consequences would be.

3:24:57Councilor Mm-hmm.

Candace Avalos 3:25:10 - 3:25:46

3:25:10I think more than anything, I'm just— this is really hard to follow.

3:25:16I mean, I'm seeing that there was some information that you gave other councilors to explain this.

3:25:23I'm reading what I see in the document that's been pre-filed and is on the website.

3:25:27That's not adding up.

3:25:29Like, none of it's adding up for me, and I'm just feeling frustrated that I'm so confused, and I don't understand why I'm confused if I'm supposed to be looking to this document to understand what these updates are and they're not reflected.

3:25:41I get that there's probably a floor amendment thing that's going on, but also I didn't receive any information.

Keelan McClymont 3:25:46 - 3:25:47

3:25:46I—.

Candace Avalos 3:25:47 - 3:26:15

3:25:47This is really complex, and I wasn't given the opportunity to think that through with any new information.

3:25:53So definitely going off of Councilor Novick, I mean, I don't feel comfortable making any kind of decision on this right now because I don't have it in front of me.

3:26:01I was already not really, you know, I was already concerned with it even prior to these new updates, but now I'm even more concerned that I feel like I don't have the tools to make a good decision.

3:26:12So that's very frustrating, and I'll just leave it at that.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:26:17 - 3:26:19

3:26:17Thank you, Councilor.

3:26:19Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 3:26:20 - 3:27:16

3:26:20Thank you, Madam President.

3:26:23I just want to first start by saying I see a lot of the same problem statement, and I think there's been a clear effort here to try and narrowly approach this to resolve it.

3:26:33I have a couple questions.

3:26:36I mean, we did hear from Director Long, and Councilor Zimmerman's right, he did follow up a couple times about whether or not levy funds are going to code enforcement.

3:26:47And I can't read the details of that graph from over here.

3:26:50So I just want to verify that probably with CBO about the use of levy funds going to code enforcement.

3:27:02The other question I have about the first part of this is basically, is there— and I know, Councilor Zimmerman, you mentioned, I'm going to get to part 2 in a second, that part 2 does not do anything in terms of the number of FTE.

Steve Novick 3:27:16 - 3:27:16

3:27:16Correct.

Sameer Kanal 3:27:16 - 3:27:26

3:27:16But Part 1, $2.1 million, I imagine could theoretically be personnel related.

3:27:21So if you could speak to that a little bit more, I'd love to, and then I'll make a comment on Part 2.

Eric Zimmerman 3:27:26 - 3:27:57

3:27:26Sure, thank you.

3:27:27And Councilor Avalos, I apologize for not sending it.

3:27:30I've sent it to you in terms of getting it to everybody and not bringing a quorum.

3:27:34I broke it up into different emails.

3:27:35It is on the way to you.

3:27:36You should have all the written text now in your email.

3:27:39Councilor Knoll, yes.

3:27:42In terms of the funding that keeps tree regulation alive, we get $3.2, I think, million in PCF funding, another $780, it looks like, in general fund funding.

3:27:56$3.6 In PCF.

Steve Novick 3:27:57 - 3:27:58

3:27:57$3.6.

Eric Zimmerman 3:27:58 - 3:29:03

3:27:58And $780 in general fund.

3:28:01So essentially it takes the program from $6.5 down $2.1 million because of the levy funding.

3:28:10I certainly think that when the PP— well, whomever the oversight is and the bureau director is of this at the end of it, if they have a program that has $2.1 million less, they're gonna reduce the footprint.

3:28:24What I'm not doing is dictating what section should survive full employment or which section should take a full hit.

3:28:33I think that the bureau director of the bureau wherever this lies will have a $4 point million, a $4 point something million program instead of a $6.5 million program.

3:28:42And they need to make the choices within their set to accomplish all the same things that exist in tree regulation.

3:28:49So I do think there would be some cuts, but it's very different than the previous where I only outlined tree inspectors being sent over to PP&D in my original amendments.

3:29:00I've changed that significantly so that all aspects of tree regulation—.

Walter Valenta 3:29:03 - 3:29:03

3:29:03Okay.

Eric Zimmerman 3:29:04 - 3:29:36

3:29:04Survive in this amendment unless the bureau comes and says, well, given this new size of it, we would have— we would do that.

3:29:11But that— I'm putting that on the administration side, not in the amendment side.

3:29:15I think that's, um, I'm just— I, I'm, I'm happy that it evolved that direction.

3:29:21I think that's a better direction for amendments that put— that affect whole programs, because the ins and outs of how to accomplish the tree regulation with with foursome million dollars instead of $6.5 million, I think is best taken at that level with, with the administration.

Sameer Kanal 3:29:37 - 3:30:53

3:29:37So thank you.

3:29:40Thank you for that.

3:29:41Um, so moving to the second part, I think, and I, I'll, I'll wait for more information on the first part here, um, but, but moving on to the second part, um, I'm inclined to support it, and my rationale is simply that we have seen And I have had what feels like dozens of meetings with constituents complaining not only about code enforcement that protects the trees that are clearly failing at the expense of the safety of residents and their homes, but occasionally, and sort of the exception that proves the rule, the exact opposite in a way that is inconsistent.

3:30:19I think there was an article about the— there's a tree at 11th and Siskiyou.

3:30:23I think That the idea that code enforcement makes sense in a singular place is compelling to me.

3:30:31I am gonna check one aspect of this, which is that, you know, we would probably need to adjust the— we might need to do a corresponding code fix to ensure that that makes sense.

3:30:45And that's not a reason not to do it today in my mind.

3:30:48So that part of it makes sense to me.

3:30:50And I do think, as you mentioned, that it can stand alone.

3:30:52I'm not 100% clear.

Lance Snippert 3:30:53 - 3:30:53

3:30:53Okay.

Sameer Kanal 3:30:54 - 3:30:58

3:30:54On the— on where I'm at on the first one.

3:30:55So I'm gonna enjoy listening to what other folks have to say.

3:30:58Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:31:01 - 3:31:46

3:31:01Thank you, Councilor.

3:31:03I am next in the queue.

3:31:05And Councilor Zimmerman, I mentioned to you earlier today that I had been working on something similar because I, after hearing your presentation previously where I had pushed back that I thought the numbers were too high.

3:31:24I agree that the balance was off and that as I look at the cuts in parks and the growth in parks and as somebody who is strongly in favor of expanding our urban canopy and someone who frankly believes that we must do more for our urban canopy, I also am strongly in favor of maintaining more of our parks.

Sarah Morrissey 3:31:46 - 3:31:46

3:31:46Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:31:47 - 3:32:16

3:31:47And I think doing something like this is important.

3:31:50I'm struggling right now because I was told by CBO that while there is funding in urban forestry from the levy, that there is only a very small amount of funding specifically in this part of urban forestry from the levy.

3:32:10And I was told that when we were figuring out our numbers because I didn't realize you were going to bring a slimmed-down version, so I was going to try to.

Keelan McClymont 3:32:16 - 3:32:16

3:32:16Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:32:18 - 3:32:23

3:32:18Today to reset the balance.

3:32:21So I was given different numbers, and I'm—.

Eric Zimmerman 3:32:23 - 3:32:25

3:32:23That's the story of the season, Madam President.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:32:26 - 3:32:53

3:32:26I want to make sure that I understand what's on your chart, because what I saw under tree regulation showed something like $4,000 in levy funds.

3:32:40So I don't know if we need to have I don't know if we need to turn this to Ruth and Jonas to get an answer, but I'm hoping we can figure out why we were given different numbers.

Eric Zimmerman 3:32:53 - 3:33:05

3:32:53I would agree, and we were given these by CBO that last year was 1.58 and this year was 2.1, and continued to say that this remains part of the problem with this braiding of it.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:33:09 - 3:33:11

3:33:09Jonas, can you Can you help here?

Jonas Biery 3:33:12 - 3:34:00

3:33:12I will attempt.

3:33:13For the record, Jonas Biery, DCA of Budget Finance and Chief Financial Officer.

3:33:19There is in fact some confusion, and I might lean to my parks colleagues to assist.

3:33:26In the approved budget, there was in fact $2.1 million of what I believe is levy-funded resources going into tree regulation and $3.6 Of PSF, $780,000 of general fund discretionary.

3:33:42So Councilor Zimmerman, exactly what you described.

3:33:45At some point, and I don't know, I may need some help identifying how this occurred, there was an adjustment made into the adopted that moved that amount out.

3:33:54And I believe that the information CBO referenced and pulled from the system was reflective of that change.

Steve Novick 3:34:01 - 3:34:01

3:34:01Okay.

Jonas Biery 3:34:01 - 3:34:08

3:34:01And I can't tell you how that change happened, but I'd be happy to welcome anyone who can describe that To come join me.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:34:09 - 3:34:26

3:34:09Jonas, given that any changes between the approved and the adopted, I believe are supposed to be amendments from Council.

3:34:16And given that we haven't touched this line and given that there is no adopted budget yet since we haven't adopted a budget, I'm really concerned with what I just heard.

Jonas Biery 3:34:26 - 3:35:14

3:34:26I agree.

3:34:28So let me try again to— so there's a point in the system as this gets tracked and so we don't have an adopted budget, but there's an entry in the budget system to start to track these changes as they're in motion so that the adopted budget can be ultimately produced.

3:34:46There are multiple, multiple points throughout the year where those adjustments are made.

3:34:51And I believe the information, Council President, that you referenced that CBO provided and pulled from the system included a number that had been changed.

3:35:02And again, I'm saying I don't know how that number was changed, and I would welcome someone who does know how that number has changed to come join me and describe that because I don't have that information.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:35:14 - 3:35:35

3:35:14I see Claudio coming up who does for Vibrant Communities.

3:35:22Can you— I wanna make sure if we're going to pass Councilor Zimmerman's amendment, amendment that we can actually do it.

3:35:29And if we can't do it, I would offer you alternate numbers, but I, so I don't wanna—.

Eric Zimmerman 3:35:36 - 3:35:39

3:35:36Yeah, we can go into budget make-believeville if we need to.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:35:39 - 3:35:46

3:35:39I don't wanna move money that isn't actually real and isn't actually there, Councilor.

3:35:44So I apologize for doing this, but—.

Claudio Campuzano 3:35:46 - 3:36:49

3:35:46Yeah, and Claudio Campuzano, for the record, Finance, Property, and Technology Manager for Vibrant Community Support Services.

3:35:53Yeah, this is a change that we had discussed with the City Budget Office a couple of days ago.

3:35:57I believe that it was included in the approved change memo, or is it in the adopted change memo?

3:36:05It's in the adopted change memo, so it's actually something that you have not voted on yet.

3:36:09And it was something that we did really as something that was intended to capture the Yes.

3:36:18In the spirit of what Councilor Zimmerman noted earlier in the process, first of all, recognizing that the parks levy has paid for parts of tree regulation over the last several years.

3:36:32It does— it is an allowable use of the parks levy.

3:36:38We included that clarification in the response to Councilor questions from last week, so I won't reread that.

3:36:48But those—.

Sameer Kanal 3:36:50 - 3:36:50

3:36:50The—.

Claudio Campuzano 3:36:52 - 3:38:27

3:36:52That over the last couple of years, we've published that use of parks levy in reports for year 1, 2, and 3.

3:37:02But given the concerns raised by council, we had included in the adopted— so as I said, you have not We have not yet voted on it.

3:37:11It is in the change memo, though.

3:37:14The shifting of parks levy out of tree regulation, so we would only use general fund rather than the blended funding model.

3:37:26That said, I don't think that that, from a technical perspective— and CBO can help clarify this— I don't think that actually changes the effect of Councilor Zimmerman's amendment, I think that that $2.1 million is— you can reduce it from that program.

3:37:46It does save— it does save parks general fund levy.

3:37:51It can be used to cover maintenance.

3:37:54So I think that really it was more a technical change that was intended to reflect the intent of Councilor Zimmerman from several weeks ago.

3:38:04So forgive us for sort of jumping ahead.

3:38:09And ultimately then, it would conflict with Councilor Zimmerman's amendment.

3:38:13So I'd say they were mutually exclusive, what's in the change memo versus this.

3:38:17But I don't know, it's not something that I was aware of, that amendment, until today.

3:38:25So I would look to CBO.

Sarah Morrissey 3:38:27 - 3:38:27

3:38:27Councilor Herbold.

Claudio Campuzano 3:38:27 - 3:38:31

3:38:27To determine whether they do conflict or not.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:38:31 - 3:39:13

3:38:31Jonas?

3:38:35I think we need to answer that question.

3:38:38And it seems to me that because this amendment specifically calls out reallocating levy funding, there might need to be some slight wording changes.

3:38:48But once you answer that question, I'd also like to know if there are other changes in the change memo that this council has not had the opportunity to talk about.

3:38:56Because I skimmed this over looking through my materials, but frankly did not look for the level of detail that I might have if I knew that bureaus were making changes between the approved and the adopted that they hadn't brought to council.

3:39:12So I just—.

Eric Zimmerman 3:39:13 - 3:39:18

3:39:13After Jonas answers that, I would like to respond specifically for where we got this number, if that's okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:39:18 - 3:39:19

3:39:18Absolutely, Councilor.

Jonas Biery 3:39:20 - 3:40:09

3:39:20Yeah, so the first answer I'll give is that the the actions that this council has taken are on the approved as discussed previously.

3:39:32So the amendments that you're discussing should be amendments to that document.

3:39:38And Ruth can correct me if that's incorrect, but for purposes of making amendments, you're making amendments to the next step in the process, the prior step in the process, which was so I think the question that came up was the gap in information that was provided, the gap in the numbers that were in the adopted versus the numbers that were reflected that CBO mentioned to you, Council President.

3:40:05And I'll pause for a second before we talk about the change amendment.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:40:11 - 3:40:12

3:40:11Councilor Zimmerman.

Eric Zimmerman 3:40:12 - 3:40:46

3:40:12Yeah, I just want to, this feels like a big boo-boo, but I also want to give a little bit of grace to the fact that in terms of how we have allowed general fund and parks levy to get used, and I think this sentence will help.

3:40:32This is a conversation between one of my staffers and one of the Central Budget Office employees.

3:40:41$1,582,931 Is budgeted as parks levy revenue for tree regulation in 2024-25?

Michael Jordan 3:40:47 - 3:40:47

3:40:47Yes.

Eric Zimmerman 3:40:48 - 3:41:38

3:40:48The amount will likely be smaller depending on how their actual spending ends up.

3:40:54Parentheses, they only transfer as much as is needed to cover actual expenses.

3:41:00I think for me that kind of highlights this idea that Because they have authorization to use levy funds, they kind of run the credit card, so to speak, or maybe it's the debit card against the levy funds.

3:41:14I think that's a practice we should call out.

3:41:18What makes it difficult though is to apply, if I say in my amendment to save $2.1 million from the tree regulation, then— Councilor Dan Ryan.

3:41:30If that same practice is used, can we really say that $2.1 million could go to parks maintenance?

3:41:36I think the answer is yes.

Ruth Levine 3:41:38 - 3:41:38

3:41:38Yes.

Eric Zimmerman 3:41:39 - 3:42:42

3:41:39But that is accurate because I think about, we're spending a lot of time talking about tree stuff, but I also want to, on the other side of that, we also know what's going to be lost on the maintenance side.

3:41:48And I do want to add that into it, right?

3:41:53If I have to make priority choices, I'm being very clear with everybody in the public, particularly within my district.

3:42:01I am prioritizing better ongoing park maintenance over a code enforcement program I think is beneficial but probably not hitting the mark right now.

3:42:12But the bathroom cleaning and the playground cleaning is.

3:42:15I'm saying, I'm saying I'm picking winners and losers.

3:42:18I'm asking you to help me pick a winner and loser in this.

3:42:20It's not fair.

3:42:21Councilor but this use of these funds is making this complicated, which I think the reason I'm highlighting this is it has been very difficult to get straightforward numbers to all of you, not because I was playing hide the rock under the red cup, but because it literally might exist in 4 different ways in 4 different documents.

3:42:40We've got to work, we've got to work on that, I think.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:42:46 - 3:42:47

3:42:46Thank you, Councilor.

Jonas Biery 3:42:49 - 3:42:55

3:42:49So I believe the second part of your question, Council President, was on the change memo, and I'll move to Ruth to address that.

Angelita Morillo 3:42:56 - 3:42:56

3:42:56Sure.

Angela Todd 3:42:56 - 3:43:27

3:42:56So the change memo, as I briefly went through earlier, is— should— it does contain only things that are either like technical changes that just align the adopted budget to things like the year-end revenue forecasts and year-end expense forecasts.

3:43:18Forecasts and technical changes that correctly budget the amendments that were voted on on the 21st.

Ruth Levine 3:43:27 - 3:43:29

3:43:27Plus this.

Angela Todd 3:43:30 - 3:44:10

3:43:30And there's this.

3:43:32So yeah, I think it was just a miscommunication in this case, and it is not— I think we need to be a little tighter going forward now.

3:43:43Honestly, I think this is just a, Change in the form of government and how we budget differently going forward.

3:43:50So yes, it should be very closely tailored to only very minor technical changes or things that are meant to align it to what you all voted on on the 21st so that it's just correct because it's the last chance to make those technical corrections.

3:44:08So that is what the technical—.

Mitch Green 3:44:10 - 3:44:10

3:44:10What—.

Angela Todd 3:44:10 - 3:44:24

3:44:10That is what the fund change memo attachment B is As opposed to line item.

3:44:15And there are 2 pages of lines that kind of explain that.

3:44:20And then Attachment C actually has more detail than Attachment B.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:44:26 - 3:44:34

3:44:26Thank you, Director Levine.

3:44:29Sonia, I wanna make sure that I wrap up and get to other councilors, but did you have something you wanted to add here?

Sonia Szymanski 3:44:35 - 3:44:38

3:44:35Not in a pressing way.

3:44:37Thank you.

Unidentified speaker 3:44:41 - 3:44:42

3:44:41Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:44:42 - 3:45:35

3:44:42Colleagues, as I said at the start before we uncovered this very interesting budget twist, I believe very strongly in protecting our urban canopy.

3:44:56And I actually have a district where I hear more often from people who are upset that trees are coming down than people who are upset that they can't take trees down.

3:45:08It's very different incoming on these regulations than I think District 4 sometimes receives.

3:45:14I also think that on balance, as we are trying to weigh difficult decisions, there was in my mind a little too much cutting in parks maintenance, and I think we could have taken a little bit more from the part of parks that has grown significantly.

3:45:29So at this lower level, I'm willing to support a change like this.

Angelita Morillo 3:45:35 - 3:45:36

3:45:35Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:45:37 - 3:46:00

3:45:37I still am a little bit confused, frankly, as to whether the funds that are in Councilor Zimmerman's new amendments are available.

3:45:47If our budget folks are saying they are, I am willing to trust that for today.

3:45:53And if they are not, then Councilor, I'm happy to partner with you on something where we can find the funds.

Eric Zimmerman 3:46:00 - 3:46:09

3:46:00I think we heard they are available and they would make it to park maintenance.

3:46:04Today if we made the first amendment.

3:46:06And we got a solid up and down from the staff on that.

Michael Jordan 3:46:09 - 3:46:09

3:46:09Yes.

Olivia Clark 3:46:13 - 3:47:05

3:46:13Thank you, Madam President.

3:46:16This has been a very interesting budget discussion that really presages what we're going to be doing in the future.

3:46:22But I don't want to speak to number 1.

3:46:23I want to speak to number 2.

3:46:27Number— Zimmerman number 2 makes perfect sense to me given what's happening to the Parks Bureau anyway.

3:46:35In the mayor's budget.

3:46:37We're breaking parks up into pieces.

3:46:40One goes here, one goes there.

3:46:41And this is just another piece that it makes absolute sense to me that the regulation goes into PP&D because PP&D is actually a blending of 8 other bureau permitting processes already.

3:46:57This is just another— adding another one to this, to the regulatory soup.

3:47:00Councilor Loretta Smith.

3:47:01So it makes perfect sense to me, and I intend to support it.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 3:47:13 - 3:48:20

3:47:13I hear Councilor Zimmerman's statement of the problem, and these complaints being outlined are very valid.

3:47:19I believe they need to be addressed, and I still question whether or not this is the best way to fix it here as council.

3:47:27It seems clear to me that there is an interest from councilors to make sure that this program is hitting the mark better.

3:47:33And I believe it is an expectation that we're working on this with the executive branch.

3:47:38And just to be clear, in general, I value giving ourselves the time and opportunity to build strategic collaborative relationships with the executive branch that will take more time than this budget process.

3:47:51I also invite all of my colleagues up here to not refer to our city staff by name and instead by title, because this isn't about individuals, it's about positions and function.

3:48:02At this point, I can't support these amendments because I haven't Thank you, Madam President.

Loretta Smith 3:48:20 - 3:48:48

3:48:20I am glad that we had this discussion today.

3:48:23I'm glad that we were able to find out information about, uh, items that were not language and items that were not put in that we didn't have information on.

3:48:36And I feel confident that the Civic Life folks are saying that they have the $2.1 million.

3:48:47Is that correct?

Sarah Morrissey 3:48:50 - 3:48:50

3:48:50Yes.

Loretta Smith 3:48:50 - 3:48:52

3:48:50Vibrant Communities, I apologize.

Unidentified speaker 3:48:52 - 3:49:00

3:48:52You absolutely take— make a reduction to Urban Forestry $2.1 million, move it to, move it to, uh, maintenance.

Loretta Smith 3:49:01 - 3:49:13

3:49:01Okay, thank you so much.

3:49:02I wanted to make clear that we had that because I don't want us to come down to the 11th hour and then we're short, especially because we didn't transfer over information.

3:49:12Thank you very much.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:49:16 - 3:49:17

3:49:16Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 3:49:19 - 3:49:39

3:49:19Um, yeah, let me start by asking a question about the change memo in general, and this is about Attachment C. Um, at the bottom, the citywide total goes down by $12 $12.851 million, uh, from $8.651 to $8.638.

3:49:36Can, can I get a little information on what that aggregate total represents?

Angela Todd 3:49:42 - 3:50:33

3:49:42Sure.

3:49:43So, um, hold on, sorry, I'm just trying to get the right attachment up.

3:49:49Um, I, I mean, I think if you look at the individual lines, it's just— it should just be a sum of the individual lines.

3:49:57So if it, you know, so for example, the Fireplace Disability and Retirement Fund, there's a reduction of $44 million of bond and note proceeds to reflect the shift from tax anticipation note revenue to interfund loan revenue.

3:50:10So that's a reduction in appropriation.

3:50:13All of these are from the perspective of how much money are you appropriating for these particular purposes.

3:50:21And so what is the maximum they can spend?

3:50:23So it's It's just aligning those appropriations based on the adopted budget as filed.

3:50:33So—.

Donnie Oliveira 3:50:34 - 3:50:34

3:50:34Sure.

Sameer Kanal 3:50:34 - 3:50:53

3:50:34But I guess let me put it another way.

3:50:36When we approved a budget at $8.651 billion and that was considered a balanced budget, and now we're coming back and being told that we are, through this memo, we've appropriated $8.638 billion given these changes.

3:50:49Should we not therefore have $12.851 million to play with the way that you've written this?

Angela Todd 3:50:54 - 3:51:27

3:50:54It's all funds and all sources of money.

3:50:57So for example, in that particular $44 million example I just gave, it's just, it had budgeted money for bond and note proceeds that we're not going to receive and therefore we don't need, but it doesn't free anything up because we're just not issuing those bonds.

3:51:17We're not receiving that revenue.

3:51:18So it just is a technical correction to the appropriation schedule based on the actual budget as filed.

Mitch Green 3:51:28 - 3:51:28

3:51:28Okay.

Sameer Kanal 3:51:29 - 3:51:39

3:51:29I look forward to that being clearer next year.

3:51:34And because I had some certainty, then I got some confusion through this process.

Jonas Biery 3:51:39 - 3:51:56

3:51:39Sorry, Councilor, can I just jump in?

3:51:41'Cause I think it may help a little bit to provide another example of what's included in the budget.

3:51:46So that $8.5 million or $8.6, whatever it is, includes things like transfers between funds, right?

3:51:52So money goes from one fund and it's appropriated from that fund.

Sameer Kanal 3:51:56 - 3:52:00

3:51:56The double count, 'cause there's about $6.5 real billion dollars in the budget.

Jonas Biery 3:52:00 - 3:52:33

3:52:00So sometimes you'll see a small adjustment.

3:52:02I mean, $12 million's not small, but in the context of the budget, maybe there's a resource from golf fees, right, that are coming in that were adjusted.

3:52:09I'm just picking on a sort of example.

3:52:11So that increases.

3:52:13That amount and reduces the amount of a fund transfer that needs to come to offset that.

3:52:18And so some of those balancing activities are what's happening in that scale of adjustment.

3:52:24And it's not a release of new revenues, it's just realigning the new version to be balanced with the decisions that council made to move dollars around previously.

Loretta Smith 3:52:34 - 3:52:34

3:52:34Right.

Sameer Kanal 3:52:34 - 3:53:05

3:52:34Okay, thank you.

3:52:35And I guess just to, for those who may be listening at home, not following along with this, the one thing that maybe isn't relevant to this, but is relevant perhaps in general is there's not $8.5 actual billion in our budget.

3:52:47There's something closer to 6, between 6 and 6.5 if I recall correctly.

3:52:52And money gets double counted when it's in one bureau's budget, gets paid to another bureau's budget and then is expensed there.

3:52:59And that's, I think, something that isn't necessarily the most well-known fact.

3:53:02No, it hasn't come up yet, so figured I'd say it.

Sonia Szymanski 3:53:05 - 3:53:06

3:53:05Thank you.

Sameer Kanal 3:53:07 - 3:53:32

3:53:07Yeah, I guess I am open to the argument about winners and losers and that our job is in large part to pick winners and losers.

3:53:16That is a compelling argument to me about our not just ability, but frankly responsibility to make a decision like this and not solely defer to the administration about it.

Ruth Levine 3:53:32 - 3:53:32

3:53:32Councilor Herbold.

Sameer Kanal 3:53:34 - 3:54:34

3:53:34Because if we don't do this, it's not as though the conversation will continue while both the park maintenance staff and the urban forestry staff are both gonna be funded with the same $2.1 million.

3:53:48It's that some of these people are gonna lose their jobs while the conversation may continue, and then we might be hiring some of them back if over time the money Is moved around between these.

3:54:00The only other thing I wanted to mention is that in the event that this 2nd amendment does pass, I do think, I did wanna just confirm the thing I speculated earlier, that there would need to be a small update to code to just replace references to the Parks Bureau.

3:54:19And we've done this before several times over the course of the last council, did it in the 2nd half of last year, updating code to fix the references to bureaus and service areas that did or didn't exist at the time it was created.

3:54:31But I just wanted to flag that.

3:54:33Yeah, thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:54:36 - 3:54:39

3:54:36Thank you, Councilor.

3:54:37Councilor Novick.

Steve Novick 3:54:42 - 3:54:44

3:54:42Is DCA Oliveira here?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:54:45 - 3:54:47

3:54:45I believe he's in the back of the room.

Steve Novick 3:54:55 - 3:55:15

3:54:55Good afternoon, DC Oliveira.

3:54:56And this might be an unfair question, sort of like answer as you see fit, but do you think that PP&D is— how much time has PP&D had to study whether the concept of absorbing the tree code regulation, and how easy do you think it would be for them to do so expeditiously?

Donnie Oliveira 3:55:16 - 3:55:38

3:55:16Thanks for the question, Councilor Donnie Oliveira, for the record.

3:55:19Councilor, about a year ago, then BDS worked with infrastructure bureaus to contemplate a merger at the time of a 30% staff reduction.

3:55:30So not too dissimilar from the moment we're in today.

3:55:33So I think, is there a culture and a will to support council direction, something like this?

Jonas Biery 3:55:38 - 3:55:38

3:55:38Of course.

Donnie Oliveira 3:55:39 - 3:56:12

3:55:39I would say for this particular amendment, have we contemplated how it would be integrated?

3:55:44No, not to the degree that we probably would like.

3:55:47Assuming this would go into effect July 1st, but given the sort of resilience of the bureau, I think in partnership with Parks, I think we can make that happen.

3:55:54The one thing I'll just offer is it's not just moving people over, it's how we embed them in the system, make sure that they're being supported as staff, that we'd want to think about.

3:56:04And until we know fully what's happening to PP&D, I think that's hard to fully give a confident answer that we're ready for that change, but it is certainly doable.

Steve Novick 3:56:12 - 3:56:23

3:56:12Thank you.

3:56:14Another unfair question.

3:56:16Would you feel safer if we— if this decision didn't take effect until like September 1st or something?

Donnie Oliveira 3:56:26 - 3:56:26

3:56:26Thank you for the question.

Steve Novick 3:56:26 - 3:56:27

3:56:26Would more time help?

Donnie Oliveira 3:56:27 - 3:56:29

3:56:27Yeah, I think any day—.

Eric Zimmerman 3:56:29 - 3:56:31

3:56:29I have no strong opinion on that either.

Donnie Oliveira 3:56:32 - 3:56:38

3:56:32I think— how about this?

3:56:34The more time that's given for staff to contemplate this change, the more effective that change could occur.

Steve Novick 3:56:39 - 3:56:40

3:56:39Thank you.

Dan Ryan 3:56:46 - 3:57:37

3:56:46I just want to make a couple comments before I vote.

3:56:49Councilor Zimmerman, I was opposed to your original amendments, and I respect the rework that you sent out today at 1:29.

3:56:56I thought that was great work.

3:56:57I was a commissioner in charge of parks for 18 months.

3:57:01Yes, I know it did seem longer based on the circumstances during those 18 months.

3:57:05And the big winter storm of 2024 was one of them.

3:57:08I took a lot of punches from Portlanders.

3:57:11I will never forget their stories.

3:57:12In fact, I, of course, believed them.

3:57:15And I went out during the storm during cleanup and I witnessed so many hardworking foresters, which made it easier to take punches for them at that time.

3:57:24The truth is, I think we need to do a move right now.

3:57:27And this is the right step at the right time.

3:57:30And I support this updated amendment.

3:57:32And I thank you, Councilor Zimmerman, for your persistence on this one.

3:57:36Thank you.

3:57:36I'll be supporting both of them.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:57:40 - 3:57:51

3:57:40Thank you.

3:57:41Before Councilor Kanal, we move on, I'm just looping back to make sure folks who are in the queue for other things didn't want to speak to this.

3:57:47Councilor Green, did you want to speak to this?

3:57:50Okay, go right ahead.

Mitch Green 3:57:52 - 3:59:44

3:57:52Uh, thank you, Madam President.

3:57:53Um, I just want to come back to this question of whether it's appropriate for City Council through budget amendments to create kind of changes for our bureaus.

3:58:04And I think one of the things I struggle with is, on the one hand, that's stepping too far over into the other side of the executive branch's side of the house.

3:58:15But this is our opportunity to provide a budget that provides guidance to this government.

3:58:20And so I think, you know, you— it's, you know, carefully crafted budget note helps, helps us do that.

3:58:27I think it is appropriate on, on You know, in some cases.

3:58:30And so I do think I want to defend this aspect of it.

3:58:34I also don't have a credit card that we can swipe to run up a big debt.

3:58:40We have to balance a budget, and there is a trade-off here.

3:58:42And the thing that I really struggle with is we still have deep cuts in parks maintenance that are going to live through this next fiscal year.

3:58:52And there were amendments that I had brought forward with some colleagues earlier in this process that did not pass that would have provided resources for that, but those failed.

3:59:00Councilor And so now we're in a situation now where we have to make a choice between a diminished, relatively, you know, I think it's about a third cut to tree regulation program here from this parks levy question versus a relatively large cut to parks maintenance.

3:59:19And so I'm leaning towards support at this time.

3:59:22I know that that's not gonna be popular with some people, but we're not making good— I mean, it's trade-offs on the margin for all of this stuff.

3:59:29Councilor Dan Ryan.

3:59:30And I'll just, I just leave it at that.

3:59:33I just wanted to air the, the piece that I think, I think, I think we can put our voices and our intention as councilors, duly elected officials, in the budget amendment process for how we think the execution side should go.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:59:45 - 3:59:52

3:59:45Councilor Smith, were you back in the queue for something on this amendment, or are you in the queue still for something later?

Loretta Smith 3:59:52 - 3:59:53

3:59:52I'm not in the queue at all.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 3:59:54 - 3:59:55

3:59:54Okay.

3:59:55Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 3:59:56 - 4:00:18

3:59:56I apologize, I just forgot one question for DCA Schimanski, and it's based on something Councilor Clark said earlier.

4:00:02Can you speak to other potential org chart bureau changes to parks that are in this budget or not?

4:00:11I believe the comment was that it's being separated out into parts, or I don't want to— that's not a quote.

Sonia Szymanski 4:00:19 - 4:00:26

4:00:19Yeah, I heard that too.

4:00:20Sonia Szymanski, DCA for Vibrant Communities.

4:00:23I wasn't entirely sure what you were referring to, but I'm sure that it's something.

Olivia Clark 4:00:28 - 4:00:45

4:00:28Uh, I was under the impression that Parks is moving into the Public Works service area.

4:00:35Yes, and perhaps not all of Parks.

4:00:38Another piece of Parks might move into, um, DCA Oliveira's, uh, service area.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:00:47 - 4:00:54

4:00:47I see Councilor— or I, I see City Administrator Jordan making an aha face.

Michael Jordan 4:00:54 - 4:01:02

4:00:54Excuse me, just to be clear, Part of vibrant communities is moving to economic and community development, not part of parks.

Mitch Green 4:01:02 - 4:01:04

4:01:02So, okay, thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:01:06 - 4:01:08

4:01:06Councilor Novick, did you want another bite at the apple here?

Steve Novick 4:01:09 - 4:01:20

4:01:09Uh, yes, um, questions for Councilor Zimmerman.

4:01:13For one, Zimmerman 3 talks about increasing position authority in PP&D by 5 permanent ongoing FTE.

Eric Zimmerman 4:01:21 - 4:01:23

4:01:21Those are up.

4:01:22I'm not even proposing those.

Steve Novick 4:01:23 - 4:01:42

4:01:23Okay, so you're, you're proposing moving, um, moving the authority from, uh, Parks to PP&D just as a standalone administrative thing.

4:01:37Um, would you accept a friendly amendment to say that that would take effect on November 1st?

Eric Zimmerman 4:01:44 - 4:01:46

4:01:44I'd take a friendly amendment for September 1st.

Steve Novick 4:01:48 - 4:01:50

4:01:48What about October 1st?

Eric Zimmerman 4:01:53 - 4:02:27

4:01:53I love negotiation, but I, I, if I'm— if I appreciate it, Councilor.

4:01:57So I, I think getting through the summer is appropriate, but, um, I am acting with urgency because I think we do have serious concerns.

4:02:05So I'm going to stick to— I'm amenable and I'm happy to entertain that at September 1st as a date, which is similar to some other rightsizing that the Councilors, I don't see anybody else in the queue, and I'm not sure what the resolution was there.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:02:27 - 4:02:33

4:02:27And I think we need a resolution before we know what we're voting on.

4:02:31Was there a friendly amendment accepted or not?

Steve Novick 4:02:36 - 4:02:38

4:02:36I'm debating whether to make it unfriendly.

Eric Zimmerman 4:02:40 - 4:02:42

4:02:40Okay, let's do October, Steve.

4:02:42Come on.

Steve Novick 4:02:43 - 4:02:52

4:02:43All right, I offer an amendment that the shift from, um, of regulation from parks to PP&D take effect on October 1st.

Eric Zimmerman 4:02:53 - 4:02:54

4:02:53No later than October 1st.

Sameer Kanal 4:02:54 - 4:02:55

4:02:54No later than October 1st.

Eric Zimmerman 4:02:55 - 4:02:58

4:02:55I think that's a friendly amendment I could accept.

4:02:57Thank you.

Dan Ryan 4:02:58 - 4:02:59

4:02:58I'll second.

Sonia Szymanski 4:02:59 - 4:03:06

4:02:59Council President, um, I'm sorry, resolve that first, come back to me.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:03:07 - 4:03:13

4:03:07I, I just, I heard Councilor Ryan second the friendly amendment and realized that I don't think I caught who seconded these to begin with.

Eric Zimmerman 4:03:14 - 4:03:16

4:03:14I think I heard Clark.

Loretta Smith 4:03:18 - 4:03:18

4:03:18Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:03:18 - 4:03:32

4:03:18Clark thinks that she was the one who seconded these, so.

4:03:22What?

4:03:24It was a long time ago.

4:03:25So we have that captured.

4:03:27And Councilor Clark, do you then, are you maintaining your second with this friendly amendment?

Olivia Clark 4:03:32 - 4:03:33

4:03:32Absolutely.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:03:33 - 4:03:36

4:03:33Thank you.

4:03:33Okay, fantastic.

4:03:35Sonia.

Sonia Szymanski 4:03:37 - 4:04:26

4:03:37Thank you.

4:03:38And I hesitate to offer a comment that might introduce a new line of conversation at this point.

4:03:44Part of why I come up here was to share the question I had when I saw this, and I hadn't had long to look at it or think about it.

4:03:50But my question to my team was, does this standardize what is otherwise an outlying situation where you are administering this code, PP&D is administering other code?

4:04:02Does this bring you into greater alignment with how the rest of the city does things?

4:04:06And what I heard from them is that it more creates an anomaly than resolves one.

4:04:11And I welcome better thinking about this because I am not the expert structurally here.

4:04:17My understanding is that PP&D administers code related primarily, maybe not exclusively, to private property development.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:04:26 - 4:04:26

4:04:26Mm-hmm.

Sonia Szymanski 4:04:27 - 4:05:05

4:04:27And that as a general matter, other bureaus administer code related to other things within their scope of work.

4:04:36Fire marshal, parking enforcement, sewer pipes.

4:04:40These codes mostly live within and are administered by those bureaus.

4:04:45Park rangers, Title 20, also in parks.

4:04:49So I guess I'm offering as a consideration, does this otherwise match how code is applied and administered in other parts of the city?

4:05:01I think, It does not.

4:05:03And so that's a policy question for you all.

Eric Zimmerman 4:05:05 - 4:05:54

4:05:05Oh, I think that, um, fair points.

4:05:09However, um, the, the private property aspect of tree code is, I think, where we have the greatest problem, right?

4:05:19That's where a person who's just at their home, who doesn't have the lawyers and developers to help navigate a really tough system, are are not getting good outcomes when they work with the City of Portland.

4:05:32And PBOT, for instance, is, as we learned in the Oregonian, able to throw some curbs down and take down trees, no problems, no questions asked, from urban forestry.

4:05:44So given the fact— I don't disagree that this is a slight anomaly, but given the fact of how much work PP&D does on the private property, so if you have—.

Michael Jordan 4:05:54 - 4:05:54

4:05:54Yes.

Eric Zimmerman 4:05:54 - 4:06:46

4:05:54If you've got a rental property that is derelict and it's a slumlord situation, these folks are involved.

4:06:00If you— when I helped shut down the 4th and Washington drug den a few years ago, it's these folks who are involved.

4:06:06That private property aspect, I think they work with property owners all the time.

4:06:11And I will say over and over, we have heard that some code changes are planned to come toward the end of the summer into the fall.

4:06:18And if there is some realignment that says, hey, this would be better served in the In the public works side of it, I'm all ears, but we haven't seen that happen without this action from council.

4:06:31And so for the short term, I think, uh, I have all faith in the code compliance folks at PP&D.

4:06:37Frankly, I think they're very skilled and working with Portlanders well all the time.

4:06:41So I think the anomaly is a safe risk and we should accept it.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:06:50 - 4:07:00

4:06:50DC Oliveira.

4:06:52Is there tree enforcement in PP&D already in other areas or would this be a completely new line of work?

Donnie Oliveira 4:07:00 - 4:07:44

4:07:00Not explicitly.

4:07:02Don Oliveira, for the record, Council President, not explicitly in Title 11.

4:07:06There may be things that come up through nuisance complaints, but those are typically redirected to Parks if they're specific to Title 11.

4:07:13Just to follow up on DC Szymanski's comments, it is true that largely the code that PP&D oversees with permitting is in the private sector, But in our code enforcement, we're covering everything from noise complaints to other nuisance infractions that typically the team interacts with the, you know, residents and businesses more, you know, ad hoc.

4:07:33I would guess that this would be a new element.

4:07:35So it's not, you know, unique, but it's distinct enough where there would be subject matter expertise that'd be relied upon coming from Parks to administer that code.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:07:44 - 4:07:50

4:07:44So the tree inspectors in PP&D's budget Are focused on other code, not on Title 11.

Donnie Oliveira 4:07:51 - 4:07:55

4:07:51Generally in support of, but not directly, you know, that's Parks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:07:56 - 4:08:43

4:07:56Okay, councilors, I don't see anybody else in the queue, so Keelan, could you please call the roll on the new Zimmerman 1, which moves $2.1 million in parks levy funds from the tree regulation program within urban forestry to the parks maintenance program, knowing that we may need to do some work in the change memo to make sure that those funds are available.

4:08:33Is that how we're doing this?

4:08:34Haley, I see you leaning forward.

4:08:36Hi, sorry, quick question.

4:08:37Were you intending to replace Zimmerman 1 and 2, or are you withdrawing Zimmerman 1 and 2 and adding 13 and 14?

Eric Zimmerman 4:08:46 - 4:08:49

4:08:46I think a full withdrawal of the old ones.

4:08:48These are freshly new.

Sonia Szymanski 4:08:49 - 4:08:51

4:08:49So you would be voting on Zimmerman 13.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:08:51 - 4:09:15

4:08:51Okay.

4:08:53What we had before us said 1.

4:08:54So Zimmerman 13, and this is the first part that Councilor Zimmerman went over, which is the funding change moving the levy funding from Urban Forestry's tree regulation program to Parks maintenance.

4:09:14Keelan, could you call the roll?

Sonia Szymanski 4:09:17 - 4:09:17

4:09:17Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 4:09:20 - 4:09:33

4:09:20As I said on May 21st, I think it's really important that we have clean bathrooms and, uh, we have maintenance, uh, fully funded.

4:09:28Um, and that's a major, major lack in the, in the mayor's proposed that we get a chance to rectify.

Eric Zimmerman 4:09:33 - 4:09:33

4:09:33I vote aye.

Olivia Clark 4:09:36 - 4:09:36

4:09:36Aye.

Keelan McClymont 4:09:37 - 4:09:38

4:09:37Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 4:09:39 - 4:09:39

4:09:39No.

Keelan McClymont 4:09:40 - 4:09:41

4:09:40Morillo.

Angelita Morillo 4:09:42 - 4:10:27

4:09:42Councilor Zimmerman, I really appreciate all the work that you've put into this and trying to address this problem.

4:09:48My concern at this time is that I just don't feel like I have a full grasp of the impacts of this policy on the different bureaus and staffing and funding that we have.

4:09:58And maybe that's not your fault.

4:09:59Maybe that's the fact that Parks didn't get that information to you.

4:10:02But that doesn't change the fact that I feel like this is a substantial change and we haven't, as a council, received a full scope of information to make that decision.

4:10:11I would also point out that that's an issue that is not isolated with your research and amendment.

4:10:17That's something that's going on overall.

4:10:19So maybe everyone should consider approving my amendment to add a CBO position so that we can get more information later.

4:10:27I vote no.

Keelan McClymont 4:10:28 - 4:10:28

4:10:28Novick?

Steve Novick 4:10:29 - 4:10:29

4:10:29No.

Keelan McClymont 4:10:30 - 4:10:30

4:10:30Clark?

Olivia Clark 4:10:31 - 4:10:31

4:10:31Aye.

Keelan McClymont 4:10:32 - 4:10:32

4:10:32Green?

Mitch Green 4:10:34 - 4:11:03

4:10:34For the same reasons that I complained about Councilor Zimmerman's chart not showing causation where there may only be a correlation, I think a relatively modest cut of the parks levy funds is not going to hamper our overall urban canopy in the short run.

4:10:51And I do think that we need to set ourselves up for a good conversation at the parks levy.

4:10:56And I, and I, I've been talking ceaselessly about the need for parks maintenance in this budget.

4:11:01Thank you.

4:11:02So for those reasons, I vote aye.

Olivia Clark 4:11:05 - 4:11:05

4:11:05Zimmerman.

Eric Zimmerman 4:11:07 - 4:11:31

4:11:07Thank you.

4:11:07I appreciate those who gave input to help me craft this in a way that was most palatable and also I think addresses a pretty serious concern.

4:11:18And I think we are set up better if this passes to pass a successful levy.

4:11:22And so if this passes, I'm also very eager for those parks employees who work in our maintenance to continue their work and their service to this city.

4:11:31So thank you.

Dan Ryan 4:11:31 - 4:11:31

4:11:31I vote aye.

Olivia Clark 4:11:36 - 4:11:37

4:11:36No.

Sameer Kanal 4:11:38 - 4:11:40

4:11:38I continue to be deeply concerned about the park's maintenance, so I vote aye.

Donnie Oliveira 4:11:44 - 4:11:44

4:11:44Aye.

Michael Jordan 4:11:45 - 4:11:45

4:11:45Aye.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 4:11:46 - 4:11:50

4:11:46The amendment is approved with 8 yes votes and 4 no votes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:11:53 - 4:11:59

4:11:53Keelan, could you please call the roll on Zimmerman 14?

4:11:57I'm looking to Haley to make sure that number is correct.

Olivia Clark 4:12:00 - 4:12:00

4:12:00It is correct.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:12:00 - 4:12:07

4:12:00And if I could just get Councilor Novick and Councilor Zimmerman to clarify the friendly amendment language and where it goes.

Eric Zimmerman 4:12:07 - 4:12:11

4:12:07To be implemented no later than 1 October 2025.

Olivia Clark 4:12:12 - 4:12:12

4:12:12Okay.

Eric Zimmerman 4:12:12 - 4:12:14

4:12:12Steve.

Olivia Clark 4:12:15 - 4:12:15

4:12:15Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:12:16 - 4:12:45

4:12:16So what you have listed in the email from Councilor Zimmerman as 2, which is officially Zimmerman 14 with the friendly amendment from Councilor Novick, that this would be implemented no later than October 1st.

4:12:29This is the proposal to move tree regulation program staff, program and staff from Urban Forestry Programs to Portland Permitting and Development.

4:12:44Keelan, could you please call the roll?

Keelan McClymont 4:12:46 - 4:12:47

4:12:46Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 4:12:47 - 4:12:47

4:12:47Aye.

Keelan McClymont 4:12:48 - 4:12:49

4:12:48Ryan.

Dan Ryan 4:12:49 - 4:12:49

4:12:49Aye.

Keelan McClymont 4:12:50 - 4:12:51

4:12:50Koyama Lane.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 4:12:52 - 4:13:12

4:12:52To clarify, I'm not completely opposed to amendments that reach over and make executive-type changes or management decisions, but my bar is high for those types of amendments, and I believe that I don't have enough information to know how this will be affecting programs and all of the staff.

4:13:11So I vote no.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:13 - 4:13:13

4:13:13Morillo?

Angelita Morillo 4:13:14 - 4:13:14

4:13:14No.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:15 - 4:13:16

4:13:15Novick?

Steve Novick 4:13:16 - 4:13:16

4:13:16Aye.

Loretta Smith 4:13:17 - 4:13:17

4:13:17Aye.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:17 - 4:13:18

4:13:17Clark?

Olivia Clark 4:13:19 - 4:13:19

4:13:19Aye.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:20 - 4:13:20

4:13:20Green?

Mitch Green 4:13:22 - 4:13:22

4:13:22No.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:24 - 4:13:24

4:13:24Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 4:13:25 - 4:13:26

4:13:25Aye.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:26 - 4:13:27

4:13:26Avalos?

Candace Avalos 4:13:27 - 4:13:27

4:13:27No.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:28 - 4:13:29

4:13:28Dunphy?

Sameer Kanal 4:13:29 - 4:13:34

4:13:29I would very much like to have this as a conversation in a policy committee, but I'm not there today, so no.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:35 - 4:13:35

4:13:35Smith?

Loretta Smith 4:13:36 - 4:13:36

4:13:36Aye.

Keelan McClymont 4:13:37 - 4:13:38

4:13:37Pirtle-Guiney?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:13:39 - 4:13:39

4:13:39Aye.

Tiffany Koyama Lane 4:13:40 - 4:13:43

4:13:40The amendment is approved with 7 yes votes and 5 no votes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:13:48 - 4:13:56

4:13:48Councilor Green, do you have an amendment within the parks program area that you are in the queue to speak to?

Mitch Green 4:13:57 - 4:14:13

4:13:57Yes, but I just— so I have a new omnibus amendment that has some elements that talk about parks.

4:14:04I guess my question to you would be, would you prefer to use this space right now to talk about things that are just standalone parks things?

4:14:11Or can I talk about my thing now?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:14:14 - 4:14:25

4:14:14Well, the precedent that we set last time was that if it touches an area, you can choose which area it falls within.

4:14:20So I am going to try to stay consistent to the best of my ability.

4:14:24Go right ahead.

Mitch Green 4:14:26 - 4:14:29

4:14:26Uh, yes, then I would like to talk about Green 9.

Olivia Clark 4:14:31 - 4:14:31

4:14:31Okay.

Mitch Green 4:14:34 - 4:14:36

4:14:34Let me pull up my text for my own.

Sameer Kanal 4:14:36 - 4:14:37

4:14:36I'm going to second it.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:14:37 - 4:14:44

4:14:37Okay, we have a motion and a second on Green 9.

4:14:42Hopefully we can hear a little bit about it.

Mitch Green 4:14:46 - 4:15:52

4:14:46Okay, thank, thank you, Madam President.

4:14:51Um, since May 21st, I've put a lot of effort into trying to, um, fund some priorities that are of my own but also some of my colleagues' Through a new funding source.

4:15:06My previous ones failed.

4:15:08The Prosper one failed.

4:15:08So, you know, we did our best.

4:15:11It didn't work out.

4:15:12So I'm coming back again and I'm offering a motion.

4:15:16The title is Motion to Amend Attachment D and Add a Budget Note to Reduce External Materials and Services Spending and Add Funding for Housing, Arts, and Operational Capacity.

4:15:26So colleagues, the way this works is It funds Green 3, which is fund Portland Street Response Program evaluation at a reduced level, $200,000.

4:15:35It funds Green 6, which provides one-time grant to Portland Center Stage at a reduced level.

4:15:40It's $200,000.

4:15:42It funds one of Clark 2 CEI positions on a one-time basis.

4:15:48It's got Dunphy 2, fund arts and economic development at $365,000.

Donnie Oliveira 4:15:52 - 4:15:52

4:15:52Thank you.

Mitch Green 4:15:54 - 4:17:35

4:15:54It has Canal 4 funding for community centers, aquatics, the Portland Tennis Center PM hours.

4:15:59So it's restoring the cut hours in the evening, an alternative community session.

4:16:04It also removes— it moves one of the parks ranger service dispatcher roles that was being cut into 311 and paying for that.

4:16:15That's part of Canal 4.

4:16:17And then we have Morillo 9, which is restore analyst positions in the The CBO at $350,000.

4:16:22So the way that this is all paid for is by, um, a 2% additional reduction in external materials and services with some, with some key, uh, exemptions.

4:16:33And these exemptions are as follows: exempting all outgoing grant subrecipients, all outgoing grant beneficiaries, and outgoing loan disbursements.

4:16:44And it also excludes Prosper Portland's line item for EMS Because I think that that complicates the fact that we already passed that budget.

4:16:54The net effect is it makes available $1.5 million in general fund discretionary resources, $192,000 in general fund overhead resources, and $151,000 in additional other revenue.

4:17:12And all of that pays for these— for this package.

4:17:14So I know that's a mouthful.

4:17:16If you look at Attachment I, it has— the CVO has created the sort of individually impacted bureau areas that have the cuts.

4:17:26That looks like it's part of Morello 9.

4:17:28It's not.

4:17:28It's just a formatting piece.

4:17:31So I know that there will be certainly some questions.

4:17:34So I'm happy to take them.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:17:40 - 4:17:40

4:17:40Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 4:17:42 - 4:17:56

4:17:42Yeah, so if I was a little early on that, sorry, I will second it now.

4:17:46Um, I do have one question about it, which is, um, the overhead $192,371.

4:17:53If you can speak to where that specifically went, that's the only question I had.

Mitch Green 4:17:57 - 4:18:06

4:17:57Yeah, happy to.

4:17:58Um, that covers part of, um, Morillo 9, which they're— the CBO analyst positions have that, uh, general fund overhead.

Sameer Kanal 4:18:07 - 4:18:11

4:18:07Thank you.

4:18:08I'll come back later.

Loretta Smith 4:18:15 - 4:18:25

4:18:15Yes, thank you, Madam President.

4:18:17I'd like to verify with, um, or Ruth.

Sonia Szymanski 4:18:28 - 4:18:28

4:18:28We—.

Loretta Smith 4:18:28 - 4:18:49

4:18:28I, I, I, I just think that, that you're leaving some money on the table.

4:18:37I think you're leaving some money on the table.

4:18:38So I, I want to, I want to know for sure, is the, is the 2% that, that you're cutting off of EMS, is it in fact $1.5 million or a, a different number?

Angela Todd 4:18:52 - 4:19:26

4:18:52So I can speak to, um, a little bit how that, how we got to that number.

4:19:00So there's There's definitely more EMS in the city's budget than that.

4:19:05But I think this is, first of all, I believe it was general fund only.

4:19:11If I'm remembering this correctly, it's ongoing and it is only for things that we aren't legally required to pay.

4:19:23So like, is it one time?

Mitch Green 4:19:26 - 4:19:28

4:19:26The amendment says this is a one-time general fund.

Sonia Szymanski 4:19:29 - 4:19:29

4:19:29Sorry.

Angela Todd 4:19:29 - 4:20:04

4:19:29Okay, sorry, I'm misremembering.

4:19:32So, but I think this is general fund only.

4:19:34So like none of the EM&S that's in the utilities, for example, would be in here.

4:19:39Additionally, things that we're legally required to pay, like FPD&R benefits that are paid out as EM&S and health benefits that are paid out as EM&S aren't in this denominator.

4:19:48So I think getting into EM&S is tricky just because there are so many things lumped into there, many of which we don't really have discretion over.

4:19:58So I think there was an attempt to get at sort of a denominator that made sense in order to come up with that number.

Loretta Smith 4:20:06 - 4:20:13

4:20:06And could you explain the difference between the external materials and services versus the internal?

Sonia Szymanski 4:20:15 - 4:20:15

4:20:15Sure.

Angela Todd 4:20:15 - 4:20:57

4:20:15So external materials and services are any external That's right.

4:20:22So that would include anything that's like contracts, grants, anything that goes out the door.

4:20:28So it includes a huge variety of different types of expenditures.

4:20:32Internal materials and services is only for services that are provided internally.

4:20:39So our central services, and those are done through interagency agreements and MOUs.

4:20:49Um, and budgeted as internal materials and services as the sort of category in which they're budgeted.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:20:58 - 4:21:01

4:20:58Okay, thank you.

Olivia Clark 4:21:03 - 4:21:43

4:21:03Thank you, Madam President.

4:21:05Um, while I really appreciate Councilor Green adding Clark 2 very much and, uh, Green 6, I'm struggling with reading through the list of all the reductions and noting that the big reductions come from parks, police, and fire.

4:21:29So I'm, I'm kind of wrestling with that.

4:21:32I'm not really comfortable with it.

4:21:34I don't know if we can ask if interim DCA I think Kazi is here, or if I—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:21:44 - 4:21:51

4:21:44Okay, then we do, I believe, have all of the DCAs in the room, and we have, um, with us.

Olivia Clark 4:21:52 - 4:21:54

4:21:52Councilor Green wants to address this.

Mitch Green 4:21:54 - 4:23:21

4:21:54First of all, I appreciate the question.

4:21:57Um, I was remiss in my motivation to also say that this is paired with a budget amendment that directs how these EMS reductions should happen.

4:22:06So that's Green 10.

4:22:08The budget amendment says to guide the implementation of the 2% reductions to EMS, council directs the city administrator to prioritize eliminating expenditures that reflect contract bloat, excessive consulting, and overreliance on external vendors for functions that could be fulfilled by city staff.

4:22:26So for instance, when I talk to labor leaders, they say, well, why are we paying consultants to do design work or pay— I think Councilor Kanal uses this phrasing a lot, which is, why are we paying other people to think for us?

4:22:41So the idea here is, you know, please do not execute— find the reduction in not hiring Solem Consulting, for instance, for a million-dollar contract to help with a strategy session.

4:22:53That's the intention with this, and that's what the budget note directs.

4:22:56The sort of schedule of cuts you're seeing is the kind of undirected, like, If you do nothing else and if you apply 2% to this, these are those impacts.

4:23:06And so I do want to just be fully transparent that there are risks here.

4:23:10And the risk is that we don't get the outcome that the budget note is directing, right?

4:23:18And then they start going after some of the kind of things that you care about there.

Olivia Clark 4:23:21 - 4:23:27

4:23:21Councilor Herbold, can we hear from Interim DCA Causse?

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:23:27 - 4:23:36

4:23:27Yeah, and Director Kazi, Director Myers is online as well if you'd like for him to come on screen too, or we are happy to defer to you.

Bob Causie 4:23:36 - 4:23:41

4:23:36You know, if he would like to go first, that would be fantastic, and I'm happy to chime in where I can.

Donnie Oliveira 4:23:42 - 4:23:42

4:23:42Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:23:46 - 4:23:54

4:23:46Director Myers, would you like to add anything here before we turn to— or DCA Myers, I apologize— before we turn to Interim DCA Kazi?

Bob Causie 4:23:58 - 4:24:18

4:23:58You know, I'm almost wondering, um, for the record, I'm Bob Causie, interim DCA for Public Safety Service Area.

4:24:05I know that a lot of our team across the bureaus had DCA Myers' link to this meeting, so that might be what we're looking at right now is, uh, someone else who, uh, didn't change their name.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:24:18 - 4:24:19

4:24:18So go right ahead.

Bob Causie 4:24:19 - 4:25:41

4:24:19I apologize for that.

4:24:20Yeah, yeah.

4:24:22Thank you, and, and I am really jumping into deep water here, uh, and, and thank you for this opportunity.

4:24:29Uh, on one hand, I look at, you know, additional funding, uh, for, uh, you know, evaluation of Portland Street Response, and that's certainly something that, uh, PSR could welcome.

4:24:43I look at some of the other components in here, and I do have some concern when Uh, when I see that there is a reduction to the Portland Police Bureau general fund by $287,000 and a reduction to Portland Fire, $183,000.

4:24:58Now, um, there's also a, uh, a section in PBEM, uh, for a reduction of $13,000.

4:25:06And, uh, you know, knowing the, uh, the structural deficiencies, particularly at PBEM, um, I'm just beginning to get a handle on the fact that they don't have adequate staffing.

4:25:19I'm certainly concerned there.

4:25:21I see the other cuts as well as without having a lot of time to review what the impact would be, I certainly have concerns.

4:25:32What I— a question that I had, and I think, Ruth, that you answered this earlier, is contracts that we have with current vendors.

Loretta Smith 4:25:41 - 4:25:41

4:25:41Yes.

Bob Causie 4:25:42 - 4:25:48

4:25:42Those are not included in this, is that correct?

4:25:46Because we have a legal obligation to pay.

Mitch Green 4:25:51 - 4:26:00

4:25:51That, that is the spirit behind the exemptions that I put in there.

4:25:54Outgoing recipients, um, you know, was intended to pick that up.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:26:00 - 4:26:00

4:26:00Okay.

Unidentified speaker 4:26:01 - 4:26:12

4:26:01Um, you know, without really knowing what the impact will be, um, I don't think I can speak much further, but I am here Um, to hopefully answer some questions if you have them.

Olivia Clark 4:26:12 - 4:26:20

4:26:12We asked the same question of, um, our Parks DCA as well.

4:26:18That's a big— that's a big chunk of dough.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:26:21 - 4:26:22

4:26:21DCA Szymanski.

Sonia Szymanski 4:26:29 - 4:26:46

4:26:29Hi again, Sonia Szymanski.

4:26:31Um, I think I saw that it's about a $700,000 EMS cut in the Parks Bureau and that an amount to be added back.

4:26:38I, I did ask, is it the same amount or is it a different and greater amount to be added back for those particular services?

Olivia Clark 4:26:48 - 4:26:50

4:26:48I don't believe it's the same.

Unidentified speaker 4:26:51 - 4:26:57

4:26:51It's just, it's a lesser amount, but it's also for different sorts of—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:26:57 - 4:27:11

4:26:57Yeah, I believe that through Canal 4 that's brought in, $265,000 is added specifically to restore PM hours at a few facilities, but the external material and services budget is reduced by $692,000.

Sonia Szymanski 4:27:17 - 4:27:45

4:27:17These are all very reasonable and fair things for you to consider and to do.

4:27:20I know that EMS sometimes surprises me in how directly the spending contributes to provision of services.

4:27:29That's not to say It's, I'm not making a judgment about its importance or how closely it should be protected.

4:27:37I will just say $700,000-ish is significant and the services that are proposed for restoration are highly valued and very important to community.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:27:49 - 4:28:34

4:27:49Councilor Clark, anything else?

4:27:52Councilor Smith?

4:27:58Oh no, that goes to me next.

4:28:01Um, I, I'm trying to understand what is cut in the contracts here, um, because I'm trying to weigh these trade-offs.

4:28:12There are some things, Councilor Green, that you include that I really like, and I appreciate that you tried to carve out some pieces of EMS that we wouldn't want to cut.

4:28:25Director Szymanski, since you're up here, I'm wondering if you have a sense of what external materials and services buys within parks.

Sonia Szymanski 4:28:36 - 4:28:48

4:28:36I know it buys bark chips, and I know it buys a lot of other things.

4:28:42Claudio, can you give us as specifically as possible, maybe a handful of examples?

Unidentified speaker 4:28:49 - 4:29:00

4:28:49Sure, I would say that the single biggest item is utilities.

4:28:54So specifically the utilities necessary to run pools, community centers, etc.

Dan Ryan 4:29:01 - 4:29:01

4:29:01They are—.

Unidentified speaker 4:29:02 - 4:29:31

4:29:02And water.

4:29:04We pay water and BES bills as well.

4:29:06We are, I think, the city's biggest water user, and that shows up as an external material and service.

4:29:13And of course As was mentioned, there's all of our garbage hauling that is external materials and services.

4:29:24So I would need to look closer at sort of where there are opportunities to do a $700,000 cut.

4:29:29But if it's council's direction, we would do it.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:29:33 - 4:30:11

4:29:33Is there an ability to take a cut like this on things like, and I hate to call out any service as unimportant because they are all important, but something like Bark chips, for example, as a permanent cut would be problematic, as a 1-year cut might be weatherable, whereas garbage hauling as a 1-year cut would not be weatherable.

4:29:53Using those as kind of standards on either side, do you suspect if you looked at the numbers that there would be a way to take a cut like that in weatherable cuts, or would we be cutting into things like water to fill the pools, electricity in our community centers, and garbage hauling?

Sonia Szymanski 4:30:12 - 4:30:36

4:30:12Conceptually, yes.

4:30:13And we did put forward a number of EMS cuts to meet our own cut target.

4:30:17And the theory was, yes, we will scale what's scalable and we will not eat into what is not discretionary.

4:30:24I think this is a question of at this amount relative to the denominator, can we keep doing that or does it begin to cut into things like pool water or that are not as discretionary?

Unidentified speaker 4:30:37 - 4:31:05

4:30:37Yeah, I would say that a one-time reduction is definitely much more manageable than an ongoing reduction.

4:30:44Going further than that in the moment, I wouldn't want to characterize it.

4:30:48We would just need to go back.

4:30:49We've spent a lot of effort getting to the reductions that we've gotten to.

4:30:54We could certainly do more.

4:30:55We potentially have more on the table depending on where things go with the levy.

4:30:59So it's— but I wouldn't want to characterize thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:31:06 - 4:31:40

4:31:06City Administrator Jordan, I noticed that there's a significant cut in the City Administrator's Office, almost $500,000.

4:31:15Is that a cut from contracts through Portland Solutions, or are there other external materials and services that cut could come from?

4:31:25And I'd ask— we use the phrase a lot, Washington Monument here.

4:31:28I'd ask that you not give me the Washington Monument, but but realistically, what would this— what are these external materials and services within the city administrator's budget?

Mitch Green 4:31:41 - 4:31:43

4:31:41So thank you for the question.

Michael Jordan 4:31:45 - 4:32:20

4:31:45We currently don't do any maintenance or contracts on the Washington Monument.

4:31:50So we— I have spoken previously about Expenses in the City Administrator's office.

4:32:00And so I'm on the record saying that the bulk of expenses in the office are in Portland Solutions.

4:32:08And I can tell you that the bulk of expenses in Portland Solutions is external M&S.

4:32:15It's in contracts for the operation of shelters primarily.

4:32:19And then there are other things, but—.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:32:20 - 4:32:21

4:32:20Thank you.

Michael Jordan 4:32:23 - 4:33:16

4:32:23You know, you have the city, and I might add that the City Attorney's Office is listed specifically, I think, for an EMS cut.

4:32:36And the City Attorney's Office is the second biggest office in the City Administrator's Office.

4:32:43So if we're including OGR, government relations, Equity and Human Rights, the Attorney's Office, and Portland Solutions.

4:32:56Those are the bulk of where EMS is.

4:33:01And I would say proportionately, OGR and OEHR have very small amounts in them of EMS.

4:33:11I'm not looking at the specific figures right in front of me, but that's my assessment.

Jonas Biery 4:33:16 - 4:33:16

4:33:16Okay.

Michael Jordan 4:33:17 - 4:33:26

4:33:17To come up with, uh, almost half a million dollars, I think we'd have to take at least a look, uh, at some of the programs in Portland Solutions.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:33:28 - 4:34:09

4:33:28Thank you, colleagues.

4:33:30I'm getting notes that other DCAs may want to speak to this as well.

4:33:35I also see that there are a lot of other councilors in the queue, so I will put myself back at the end of the queue to give other DCAs an opportunity after other councilors have I will just say now, Councilor, I like a lot of what you're buying.

4:33:50I am really concerned with the extent of some of these cuts.

4:33:55I am leaning no right now because I don't think I've had enough time to sit with some of these, and I apologize for not spending more time with it previously.

4:34:06I will continue to think about it as I hear from other colleagues.

Michael Jordan 4:34:09 - 4:34:09

4:34:09Thank you.

Dan Ryan 4:34:14 - 4:35:03

4:34:14Thank you, Madam President.

4:34:15I kind of want to listen to the other DCAs come up.

4:34:18That said, you know, I made it clear back in May that my lens would be shaped by a few things.

4:34:23One, going into the weeds of operations at this elevation does start me at a no.

4:34:28And so I started at a no on this one.

4:34:31And sure, there are a lot of pieces of this that politically have nudged me to a yes, and these have been fascinating conversations.

4:34:38So I've had conflicted debates with my own self as I listened to all the conversations over the last half hour.

4:34:44I don't know who hasn't, but clearly there will be impacts of these reductions.

4:34:48And I also said I would not support amendments to the mayor's balanced budget that made cuts to police and fire, and they seem to be included here based on what I've listened to.

4:34:56And now I heard that about Portland Solutions.

4:34:59So this is a very well-intentioned amendment, but I will not be supporting it at this time.

4:35:02Thanks.

4:35:02Councilmember Herbold.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:35:04 - 4:35:05

4:35:04Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 4:35:06 - 4:35:59

4:35:06Thank you.

4:35:09Um, I, I'm gonna just note that there may be some space.

4:35:13There is, I think it's 8, where is it?

4:35:17$600,000 Plus that's not allocated here.

4:35:21There's some restrictions on that funding and I'm trying to understand that a little bit better.

4:35:24I might be able to sort of soften some of the specific blows, but I wanna take a step back for a second and say 2 things.

4:35:30One is, as it relates to unintended consequences, it's a concept that comes up and there is a certain level.

4:35:36I think it's less about— the way I would frame it is less about unintended consequences and a consequence that we know the details of versus one that we have a general idea of.

4:35:47We know that 2 people in the city budget office are going to get laid off right now if we don't do anything about it.

4:35:52We know that.

4:35:53That's categorical.

4:35:53We know that the only person who does racial equity plans for the whole city at OEHR is going to get laid off.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:35:59 - 4:35:59

4:35:59I think that's a good point.

Sameer Kanal 4:36:00 - 4:39:20

4:36:00One of the 4 people in the ADA team at OHR.

4:36:03Some of that's not in this, some of that is.

4:36:06But I know that these are things that we have to weigh.

4:36:08So it can't just be a general opportunity cost conversation.

4:36:13We should engage with that specific opportunity cost, which is that absent a revenue source, we are not going to find a way to save some of these positions.

4:36:22And that's very concerning to me.

4:36:23I think we have seen the value of both the current and a future beefed-up CBO through this process.

4:36:31And I want to make sure I want to make sure that Director Levine has everything and everyone that she needs for that.

4:36:37That's particularly important to me.

4:36:39The other thing I wanted to talk about is the contracting piece.

4:36:46There are dozens of examples I can give in my 3 and a half years working at the Portland Building about work that can and should be done by city employees.

4:36:57That is contracted out.

4:37:00And it is work that I've often described, as Councilor Green put it, that is thinking for us.

4:37:07There is work where contractors are good.

4:37:09Community-based organizations that do violence prevention, which are exempted from this, by the way, that's very important.

4:37:15This doesn't cut OVPs, grantees, or anything like that.

4:37:18There was a testimony virtually about the violence prevention, community violence intervention money.

4:37:25None of that's affected by this.

4:37:26There's work that we can't do ourselves But then there is work like strategic planning assistance, and there is work like community engagement contracts where people do really well, but they're more expensive than a city employee.

4:37:42I managed a project where we had the money for 3 years to fund a city— a community engagement staffer.

4:37:51And we were told over and over and over again that we would get that funding or get that position authority to spend our own money.

4:37:56I think that's a good thing.

4:37:57And I can know from a different project that I worked on that the community engagement contract cost more than a staffer to do the same amount of work.

4:38:06There's so many examples I could give about how we squander money, and it's to not have an ongoing labor commitment.

4:38:17And that is a profoundly anti-labor practice that we do.

4:38:22And I, I've I think that this is the beginning of asking the administration to start looking at that differently and bringing these, these particular types of work back into the city, back to AFSCME and Pro-Tech and CPPW, back to all these specific unions that are doing this work.

4:38:43And in many cases, there are still some FTE that has to then manage the contract.

4:38:48So we're also wasting the money there.

4:38:50So that's my interest in this, is starting the process of going at the practice of contracting out work that could be done by unionized labor in this workforce, people who can afford to live here and do live here.

4:39:04Because a lot of this, uh, you know, professional services contracting is to people in Philadelphia or Baltimore or something, and, um, I'm sure they're great, but I want to make sure that we're working to put our Portland Councilor Zimmerman.

Eric Zimmerman 4:39:24 - 4:40:36

4:39:24Um, I think we have a little bit of a better idea from Parks what, what this could be used on in terms of materials and services, what's truly used on, maybe in the city administrator's, um, I'm, I'm looking for a way to get to yes on this amendment as well, but noting that there are a couple areas that have just significant cuts, like multiple, uh, employees' worth of cuts.

4:39:55And I know they're not employees, but that, that level of work.

4:39:57So I, I'm going to think out loud a little here in terms of, of options that might exist.

4:40:06Okay.

4:40:08What I don't know right now is if I were to go and look at Parks and Rec, this is noting $692,000 of materials and services, but I'm wondering what the amount of unspent revenue in that bucket was in the current year.

4:40:30And I could apply that question to all the big hitters here above 6 figures and say, about how much do we normally return?

Dan Ryan 4:40:36 - 4:40:37

4:40:36Yeah.

Eric Zimmerman 4:40:38 - 4:40:59

4:40:38To know if it has a substantial categorical change in service or if it's one of those we don't want to ever get right up to the edge.

4:40:47And I'm going to look quickly just to see if there is a feeling of severity in terms of these numbers and what that might look like.

4:40:57Sure.

4:40:58That is always a difficult—.

Sameer Kanal 4:40:59 - 4:41:01

4:40:59It's a totally legitimate question to ask.

Eric Zimmerman 4:41:01 - 4:42:26

4:41:01It's a difficult one because a lot of Spending is encumbered in one year and it gets carried over into the next.

4:41:08And so what you see as underspending in the current year often is not— there are sort of encumbrances against that resource.

4:41:17But looking at projections for the current fiscal year, I'm looking at just in general fund only.

4:41:28Yes.

4:41:29For parks, we're probably going to underspend by $1 or $2 million.

4:41:35Yeah, okay, so $1 or $2 million.

4:41:38And I note that because what we may end up seeing here is that in the next year we have a slightly lower— well, where I come from, beginning fund balance.

4:41:52But actually the way the city does it is we wouldn't see that reflection of savings until the fall, what we used to call the fall bump, the technical adjustment in fall.

4:42:01It may be a little bit smaller than we're normally used to in our operations, but I'm sensing a workability here, and that's what I'm trying to kind of put my head around.

4:42:12For Ruth Levine, our budget director, I think that you mentioned the amount of general fund contingency that we had left over last time was in around the $999,000 range.

Loretta Smith 4:42:26 - 4:42:26

4:42:26Yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:42:28 - 4:42:29

4:42:28Category?

Olivia Clark 4:42:29 - 4:42:30

4:42:29That's right.

Eric Zimmerman 4:42:30 - 4:43:44

4:42:30Okay, now loud part here is that if we were to have a bureau, for instance, come and say, hey, Mr. City Administrator, we're at risk of not paying the water bill at one of our, at one of our bureaus, our utility bill, the lights may go off, that is exactly what contingency is for.

4:42:51That's the kind of thing that As the finance chair, I would say, yes, we have a problem.

4:42:56Some sort— something spiked.

4:42:58You come on in, and to keep the lights on at a community center, we're going to float you an extra quarter of a million dollars from the general fund contingency.

4:43:07So if we were to potentially add a set-aside from that almost million dollars that we created in excess last month, As a fund to tap into, I think I'm quite— I think I could get comfortable with this amendment because I don't think any of the groups listed here should feel like they have to do the same thing with less.

4:43:36I think we're saying, please get closer to finalizing out your budgets, but if you run up against something, we have a set-aside that you can make the case for materials and services.

Mitch Green 4:43:44 - 4:43:44

4:43:44Thank you.

Eric Zimmerman 4:43:45 - 4:43:58

4:43:45As a fund to tap into.

4:43:46And I would be curious what colleagues think about that, given that we created nearly $1 million extra in contingency on the 21st.

4:43:55But thank you for that quick answer.

4:43:57I appreciate it a lot.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:44:04 - 4:44:06

4:44:04Councilor Novick, you haven't spoken to this yet, have you?

Steve Novick 4:44:07 - 4:45:01

4:44:07I have not.

4:44:08Thank you, Madam President.

4:44:09First of all, as to Councilor Zimmerman's last point, some of us have some designs on that million dollars.

4:44:14So for example, For example, some of us are thinking about using it, which includes some discretionary funding and some overhead to fund some PBAM positions.

4:44:23But second, I just think this is— I don't think it behooves us who believe in the value of government to decide, well, we think there must be a bunch of waste, fraud, and abuse here, so let's just vote to cut 2% and they'll find the waste, fraud, and abuse somewhere.

4:44:40I don't— if we— if there is Contract bloat, excessive consulting, and overreliance on external vendors or functions that can be fulfilled by city staff.

4:44:51Let's identify that specifically.

4:44:53Let's not just assume that the Parks Bureau has $692,000 of those things without knowing.

Mitch Green 4:45:06 - 4:45:10

4:45:06Would love to offer some responses when you think that's appropriate.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:45:12 - 4:45:32

4:45:12Why don't, Councilor Green, we have you offer responses?

4:45:16And while you're offering responses, I'll just note that I'd put myself back in the queue to give a couple of DCAs an opportunity to come up.

4:45:22So I think DCA Oliveira wanted to speak, and I wasn't sure if DCA Biery wanted to come back up.

4:45:29If you all come up while Councilor Green is speaking, that'd be great.

Mitch Green 4:45:34 - 4:47:17

4:45:34Thank you, Madam President.

4:45:38Councilor Novick, to respond, if we were given budget documents with the level of specificity for me to identify specific contracts, and I wouldn't mean— I wouldn't go down this road.

4:45:51I think it is an imperfect road to go down.

4:45:53That's why the budget note is attached to give more clear guidance to the city administrator on what the priority is.

4:45:59And I'll just use an anecdote that I remember from Aspen 189's Uh, contract struggle from last year.

4:46:07They had pointed out that the City of Portland found over $1 million to buy a piece of granite from Vermont and have it moved here for the base of a statue.

4:46:17That is an EMS expenditure, but they didn't have that money for, you know, on the table for their negotiations at the time.

4:46:25I've heard other anecdotes where we pay management consultants over $1 million Yes.

4:46:30For like a weekend of work for strategy visioning.

4:46:32Those anecdotes exist.

4:46:34And while I don't have a spreadsheet of all the specific contracts, I know that they exist.

4:46:38And so I would very much looking forward to a world where we have that level of resolution, and so we can be much more prescriptive.

4:46:45And I'll just say, you know, I do think we need to get a handle on our external contracting consulting.

4:46:52My vision for this city, and insofar as I have a voice as a city councilor in the budget process, I believe in public sector capacity.

4:47:00I don't believe in outsourcing that to third-party contractors.

4:47:05It's just fundamentally something I don't— that I don't agree with.

4:47:12So I think we've got some other DCAs up here who want to kind of talk to it.

4:47:16So thanks.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:47:19 - 4:47:41

4:47:19Thank you all for coming up.

4:47:21If you wanted to respond to any of the questions that we've asked of some of your colleagues about impact I think we'd be happy to hear those.

4:47:29And I think in doing so, the question from Councilor Zimmerman also about how much of these you have left at the end of the year, and if perhaps while difficult, it's something that could be absorbable for one year.

Mitch Green 4:47:42 - 4:48:31

4:47:42Great, thanks, Council President.

4:47:43I think I'll go first.

4:47:44Donnie Oliveira for the record.

4:47:46The one item I want to flag for council's situational awareness is the $75,000 in the Office of Economic Development.

4:47:54That EMS allocation is part of a 2-year project for the permit improvement team to upgrade PP&D's permitting software.

4:48:02It is a discrete project that is both software and implementation, and once completed, it'll be done.

4:48:10And I'll just offer for your consideration that while we could probably get through with that, it's a contract not just again for people, Councilor Green, but for actual systems.

4:48:19That we're investing in that we would ideally like to purchase what we agreed to a year and a half ago.

4:48:25So my recommendation would be for your consideration is to consider that as a project that's close to, you know, completion.

4:48:31Thank you for your consideration.

Jonas Biery 4:48:33 - 4:50:17

4:48:33Great.

4:48:35Just for the record again, Jonas Biery, DCA Budget Finance and Chief Financial Officer.

4:48:40A couple of things I'll flag looking at the reductions.

4:48:44And maybe I'll just say I appreciate the effort and intent of looking citywide at citywide contract efficiencies.

4:48:49Certainly something a CFO that's a priority It's a priority of mine.

4:48:53The thing that catches my attention is a reduction in the Office of the Chief Financial Officer, which will be the new evolution of budget and finance.

4:49:02As I mentioned at previous budget work sessions, within that service area, we have already reduced our EMS in this to meet the original budget reductions to the bare minimum.

4:49:15So a further reduction to EMS will be a reduction to services.

4:49:19Thank you.

4:49:21Within that office, it'll be a reduction to tax support, specialty tax support that we get from external sources, software support, specialty and surge support, background checks, translation services, employee trainings to make sure that we're maintaining our financial expertise, et cetera.

4:49:40So I just wanna be explicit that there will be reductions directly resulting from that, at least in that service area.

4:49:46I can't speak for others.

4:49:48The other thing I'll mention and then maybe hand to DCA Morrissey is, We also know we have upcoming enterprise efficiency work that we need to work on, and that may benefit from having some of those resources available to help facilitate that work and get to some long-term efficiency.

4:50:06Some of those efficiencies identified that are likely to be identified will be to EM&S.

4:50:11And so we'll actually need to— this, I think, takes us a little bit of a step backwards in implementing that.

4:50:16And Sarah, I don't know if you want to add more.

Sarah Morrissey 4:50:17 - 4:51:08

4:50:17Yeah, thanks so much.

4:50:18For the record, Sarah Morrissey, DCA for City Operations.

4:50:21I wanted to flag 2 items.

4:50:23One, we are unable to take a reduction for the Office of Community-Based Police Accountability, so that will need to be redistributed to another fund balance due to the settlement with the DOJ.

4:50:36And then the second is in the Office of City Operations, we have the independent police review, we have the DCA office, we have almost no EMNS, and we also have 311 and Procurement, procurements, EM&S is primarily co-op.

4:50:52And so we will not be— that's basically committed to Prosper via an IGA for the implementation of that program.

4:50:59So that full impact would likely sit with 311, and that would likely have a staffing impact as well.

4:51:06So wanted to share that with the council.

Angelita Morillo 4:51:11 - 4:51:12

4:51:11Thank you all.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:51:12 - 4:51:16

4:51:12Councilor Clark.

4:51:15Um, thank you.

Olivia Clark 4:51:16 - 4:52:06

4:51:16Sure.

4:51:17Um, thank you, Madam President.

4:51:19Um, I'm desperately searching for my magic wand.

4:51:23Uh, I don't know where it is, but we really need one right now, um, because there's so much in this that I want.

4:51:29Um, not just my own, um, amendment, uh, and, and Councilor Green's and Councilor Dunphy's.

4:51:38I, I really want what's in your amendment.

4:51:40Terribly, but I'm afraid of unintended consequences here with this sort of haircut approach.

4:51:47And I thought that we had talked earlier about not doing haircuts per se.

4:51:51But I also want to make a comment about the contracting piece because I totally agree with you.

4:51:56And I, I think that we could bring that up, uh, in the Governance Committee and have a really good discussion about our, our philosophy around contracting.

Sarah Morrissey 4:52:06 - 4:52:07

4:52:06Thank you.

Olivia Clark 4:52:07 - 4:52:39

4:52:07Um, other pieces may not be so easily adapted to a resolution or, or a policy here, but I guess I'm, I'm just, I'm wrestling out loud, um, with the tension I feel over this because I really want these things, but I just think there are going to be unintended consequences that we're just— with this sort of haircut approach.

4:52:29And actually, I don't— I think it was maybe— oops, sorry.

4:52:33Uh, Councilor Ryan that mentioned the public safety side.

4:52:37I, I just, I can't abide by that.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:52:40 - 4:52:46

4:52:40Thank you.

4:52:41Thank you, Madam President.

Angelita Morillo 4:52:47 - 4:54:21

4:52:47Um, so I guess I just have a few questions.

4:52:51And to be clear, under Green 10, this isn't a blind cut, right?

4:52:55Um, we would pass Green 10 and then get the updates on these cuts every 6 weeks to understand the implications of every cut, and we're going to be working with the agencies to make the most sense about which areas it needs to be taken out of when discussing excess outsourcing.

4:53:14I guess that was a rhetorical question.

4:53:16Really, I'm just saying that that's what I'm seeing here.

4:53:20But also, no bureau is required to cut a particular part of the contract.

4:53:24What DCA Oliveira cited as a particular contract that is $75K Okay.

4:53:29He's not obligated to cut those specific contracts.

4:53:32That's not specified in the amendment or the no, quite the opposite.

4:53:36So what we're talking about is 2% of EMS, which could be any contract of choosing.

4:53:45So I think that it's very reasonable to find 2% in our own budgets.

4:53:52And if there are impacts that we don't like with certain contracts, then we should find them elsewhere.

4:53:57But these are really critical services that we're trying to support that are going to help a lot of people during a budget crunch.

4:54:03So frankly, I really appreciate Councilor Green finding creative ways to give us more flexibility with this budget, 'cause I feel like you're the only person that's actually tried at all to do that.

4:54:16And maybe you're taking a lot of public beatings for doing so, but I appreciate it.

Angela Todd 4:54:21 - 4:54:22

4:54:21Thanks.

Loretta Smith 4:54:25 - 4:56:33

4:54:25Thank you, Madam President.

4:54:29Others of us have tried too, Councilor Murillo.

4:54:32We just didn't get our stuff passed.

4:54:36So I'm going to add a finer, finer point to this.

4:54:40It is so very interesting that as this was presented, we watched DCA, CFO, Um, you know, the CBO office identify, um, what could be a problem.

4:55:01And from day one, I have said that we don't line item stuff.

4:55:07And when you hide stuff in external materials and services and internal Materials and services and don't line item what your stuff is and, and if they're FTEs in those materials.

4:55:24And so I have a big problem with that to begin with.

4:55:27Stop putting your stuff in the external, um, materials if you're, if you're paying for FTEs.

4:55:34Let me see that line item.

4:55:36And then you come up and you say, oh, but that pays for this person or that Person, stop.

4:55:45It is meant— some of this stuff, yes, we can't just take a haircut.

4:55:49I agree with you, uh, Councilor Clark.

4:55:52But if we do and have a, a, a general way where we can know exactly what's in it, every time I talk about asking for money out of, um, the administrator's budget and, and, um, In the EMS or IMS.

4:56:10Oh, that's for Portland Solutions.

4:56:11Well, if you would put Portland Solutions exactly out there on how much we're paying for how many FTEs, then we would know what we could take and we couldn't take.

4:56:22So that part is a, is an issue.

4:56:24And I appreciate everybody coming up and vouching for their programs and saying this is what we can't take.

4:56:31And I, I agree with Councilor Murillo.

Olivia Clark 4:56:33 - 4:56:33

4:56:33Thank you.

Loretta Smith 4:56:34 - 4:56:54

4:56:34They're going to be in contact if this passes and not going to try to take those things out that we cannot absolutely take out.

4:56:43But note to self, it would be more helpful to us if we had better line items of what's in each of these things.

4:56:52If you're going to say material services, what is it?

Candace Avalos 4:56:55 - 4:56:55

4:56:55What is it?

Loretta Smith 4:56:56 - 4:57:02

4:56:56And, and you all don't say it because you don't want us to know.

4:56:59Or maybe it was the practice that you didn't do it.

Olivia Clark 4:57:02 - 4:57:02

4:57:02I'm sorry.

Loretta Smith 4:57:02 - 4:57:45

4:57:02In the past, so you're not doing it in the future.

4:57:05But for me and others who are used to seeing line items, we wouldn't have this issue right now of saying 2%.

4:57:12So we're giving you an opportunity to say where the 2% is from.

4:57:17And the fact that it gives direction to the city administrator to do that because he knows what's in all of this, it didn't take any of his power away.

4:57:28Thank you.

4:57:29Not one bit, because he understands what is— what can be done and what can't be done.

4:57:35And I just want to say thank you for bringing this up because it's, it's needed, and we got to do better for this next cycle, and we will.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:57:47 - 4:57:50

4:57:47Thank you, Councilor.

4:57:50Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 4:57:52 - 4:58:18

4:57:52So, um, thank you.

4:57:54I, I have a question for both Councilor Ryan and Councilor Clark.

4:57:59Which is, if hypothetically, because you both mentioned one of the concerns was public safety, if hypothetically public safety was exempted, would that affect your support for this?

4:58:12And I will have a response, I have a comment after I have questions, I get a response if they would be willing.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 4:58:19 - 4:58:21

4:58:19Councilors, if either of you would like to respond, go right ahead.

Olivia Clark 4:58:22 - 4:58:50

4:58:22That's a tough one.

4:58:25I think it's the public safety piece that probably pushed me over the edge, but I do— I am concerned about the unintended consequences, and I do think that some of these things can be taken up as policies in our committees.

4:58:40I think, you know, we're all wrestling with limited resources and scrambling for anything we can get, and I appreciate what Councilor Smith said about finding out really what the truth is.

Sameer Kanal 4:58:50 - 4:58:50

4:58:50Thank you.

Dan Ryan 4:58:51 - 4:59:24

4:58:51I made other comments as well, and it wouldn't change my vote.

4:59:03It's, it's not the right practice.

4:59:04I had experiences as a commissioner in charge where if we didn't have outside opinions, it would have been not good for Portlanders.

4:59:12So there needs to be some money in the budget for this.

4:59:16And what I've listened to from all of the collective administrators today, Sure.

Sameer Kanal 4:59:24 - 5:02:24

4:59:24Thank you for clarifying that.

4:59:26So I think what I'm struggling with is I agree with Councilor Ryan that there needs to be money in the budget for this.

4:59:32And you see these $314,000 of general fund discretionary coming from parks, plus an additional $377,235 of other revenue, which is some— that money's going back into parks for the other programs.

4:59:46But these are huge numbers.

4:59:47You know, large sums of money.

4:59:49And then you stop and think for a second that that 3— just the first one of those, the $314,000, is part of $15 million of EMS.

4:59:58That's just the discretionary EMS, right?

5:00:00There's an additional $17 million-ish in parks for that— that is EMS that's funded through a different type of revenue.

5:00:11So I think that's something where I struggle with the idea that they wouldn't— $15 million, when you frame it that way, to find $314,000 out of— I mean, I think there's— I want there to be bark chips.

5:00:29I want to say that emphatically.

5:00:31Bark chips are important.

5:00:32They actually do matter.

5:00:34I think there's money for bark chips in here.

5:00:37And so that's what I'm struggling with.

5:00:40Having said that, I'm gonna float something.

5:00:43And I just note that if you look at the top of the— before it gets into the enumerated parts of it, again, this is Green 9, and I hope that we get a chance to talk about Green 10 because I support it and I think it helps ensure that Green 9 makes sense the best possible way once passed.

5:01:01It raises, you know, these 3 types of revenue that total $2.567 million.

5:01:11And it spends $1.88 million, $1.881 million.

5:01:16So there's $686,553 left over.

5:01:20And so the thing I'm gonna float is exempting the $287,661 from police, exempting the $183,100 from fire, exempting the $5,000 from the Community Board for Police Accountability, Exempting the $31,371 for the Office of Public Safety DCA, exempting $13,044 from PBEM.

5:01:41There are no cuts to BOEC here that I saw.

5:01:44So that's the entirety of the public safety space.

5:01:46And that adds up to $520,176, which leaves $166,377 that I think we should probably use to soften the blow to parks because parks has taken the biggest hit here.

5:02:00And so that would be the thing that I would float instead of making this a budget, a non-neutral amendment that raises revenue we could use somewhere else.

5:02:07It would keep it as budget neutral, but it would soften the blow on the bureau taking the biggest hit, which is parks, and it would exempt public safety.

5:02:16And I would— that's an important value for me and I wanted to just float it.

5:02:20I'm not proposing at this moment, but see where— what folks think about it.

Eric Zimmerman 5:02:24 - 5:02:29

5:02:24Can you say it again?

5:02:26Slowly and carefully for my slow little brain.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:02:30 - 5:02:43

5:02:30And cue Haley.

5:02:32Exemption to police, fire, the Office for Community-Based Police Accountability, the DCA Office for Public Safety, and PBEM.

Sameer Kanal 5:02:43 - 5:03:43

5:02:43Yeah, so this was non-neutral.

5:02:47It was $683,000, I'm sorry, $686,000 $553 up.

5:02:57I would remove the 3rd line, $287,861 reduction to police.

5:03:05So this would not reduce that.

5:03:08$183,100 In the 4th line for Portland Fire and Rescue.

5:03:1410Th line, reduce bureau program expense in the Office of Public Safety General Fund by $31,371.

5:03:22You go down to the bottom line on the page, $13,044 for PBEM.

5:03:30You can go to the first line on the next page, CBPA for $5,000, which by the way is a charter requirement, not the DOJ.

5:03:40And that adds up to $520,176.

Dan Ryan 5:03:46 - 5:03:47

5:03:46$520,176.

Sameer Kanal 5:03:48 - 5:04:15

5:03:48That leaves an additional $166,377, which I would reduce the second line, that's $692,000 to parks, by the $166,377, which would actually— sorry, got the number off here.

5:04:08$692,000 Minus $166,377.

5:04:13Doing math live in a Windows calculator.

Dan Ryan 5:04:15 - 5:04:16

5:04:15$525,000.

Sameer Kanal 5:04:17 - 5:04:24

5:04:17$623,000 Would be the reduction, not $692,000.

5:04:23And that would make this budget neutral.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:04:25 - 5:04:29

5:04:25Councilor Green, would you like to respond or should we move on in the queue to Councilor Avalos first?

Mitch Green 5:04:31 - 5:04:36

5:04:31I am intrigued by your suggestions.

5:04:35I would like to hear from Councilor Avalos.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:04:36 - 5:04:39

5:04:36Councilor Avalos, you are next in the queue.

Candace Avalos 5:04:40 - 5:04:57

5:04:40Okay.

5:04:45Well, I'll start by responding to this proposal, I guess.

5:04:51Did you in this proposal decide how the things would get reallocated?

5:04:56Maybe I missed that.

Dan Ryan 5:04:57 - 5:04:58

5:04:57It was a lot of numbers.

Candace Avalos 5:04:58 - 5:05:08

5:04:58And like, are you going to be suggesting that— because that's revenue essentially that you're cutting, and therefore we're— because all of these dollars are allocated.

5:05:06So how are we going to do that?

Sameer Kanal 5:05:08 - 5:05:10

5:05:08There were, there were dollars that were not allocated.

Dan Ryan 5:05:11 - 5:05:11

5:05:11Balanced.

Sameer Kanal 5:05:11 - 5:05:25

5:05:11And this is, this is, uh, it was unbalanced in a good way.

5:05:16Uh, it would have ended us up with $686,000.

5:05:20So I'm putting it back into the bureau's if in this suggestion, which again is not a formal motion at this time.

Unidentified speaker 5:05:29 - 5:05:29

5:05:29Okay.

Candace Avalos 5:05:40 - 5:07:26

5:05:40I agree with the larger sentiment that it's really frustrating to try to make any of these decisions when we operate with such limited information, when we're not getting line-by-line items, when every— everybody does the whole, you know, national monument thing or whatever.

5:06:04And, um, That just puts me in such a hard spot because I obviously want a lot of the things that are in the package that our community, I think, needs.

5:06:16And I am concerned about, you know, where those cuts are going to come, if they're going to result in NAFT.

5:06:24And, you know, we could definitely debate, you know, the reasonableness of what the bureau heads or whatever are proposing.

5:06:31But at the end of the day, once we make this decision, Yes.

5:06:34So it feels like a lot of it will be out of our control, and I'm scared about those repercussions.

5:06:38So I'm really grappling with all of this, um, and I'm going to keep listening to see how I feel.

5:06:45But just, yeah, it's just a really conflicting feeling to get information right from your bureaus and your DCAs because ideally they're giving you the best information they can, but it doesn't I just don't always trust it, and I don't know how to feel about that, honestly.

5:07:02And I can't make my own decisions because I don't have all of it in front of me.

5:07:07So it just feels like a really— I'm put in this really hard spot, and I don't want to have the negative repercussions of certain contracts getting cut or FT getting cut.

5:07:17And then it just feels like I don't know what's going to happen, and I don't know how to grapple with that right now.

5:07:24Honestly, I'm really conflicted.

5:07:25Councilor Loretta Smith.

Sameer Kanal 5:07:26 - 5:07:48

5:07:26So I'm just going to answer the first question there about if any FTE are going to get cut.

5:07:32This is all EM&S, so no FTE would get cut.

5:07:35This would instead restore 3 positions that would get cut, 1 Park Service dispatcher, 2 analyst positions at the City Budget Office, and then additionally some hours that I don't know if it adds up to an FTE for those community center hours.

5:07:47Just clarifying.

Candace Avalos 5:07:48 - 5:08:04

5:07:48Well, but I don't know that that's entirely true because the thing is, like, and this is the thing I've largely had an issue with as it relates to contracts, like, Some contracts aren't just for external things, right?

5:07:58We might have contracts that pay for us to bring in staff.

5:08:01And so what if there's a contract that is going to affect us?

Sameer Kanal 5:08:04 - 5:08:04

5:08:04Or—.

Candace Avalos 5:08:06 - 5:08:07

5:08:06You're making a face.

5:08:06What's the face for?

Sameer Kanal 5:08:08 - 5:08:10

5:08:08I'm not familiar with that.

Candace Avalos 5:08:10 - 5:08:50

5:08:10I'm just thinking about— I'm thinking about when I was an executive director, okay?

5:08:15And I have a budget and I'm getting money from all these kinds of sources.

5:08:19I'm getting it from grants.

5:08:20I'm getting it from individual donors.

5:08:22All of those things, they're messy.

5:08:24Right?

5:08:24Like, one grant that I'm getting, it could fund some of my staff, it could fund an external contract, it funds all these things.

5:08:31And I don't know this, how the bureaus work with that.

5:08:33I don't have that information.

5:08:35So I don't like feeling like I don't know the real impact because these things are all really intertwined.

5:08:41And if we're going to leave the decision, I mean, I appreciate having, you know, Green 10 that like gives some more direction about how to make those cuts.

Sameer Kanal 5:08:50 - 5:08:50

5:08:50Thank you.

Candace Avalos 5:08:51 - 5:09:31

5:08:51I'm also, you know, and I have a bunch of budget notes that I'm like, you know, I'm putting these suggestions.

5:08:57I also, to be quite honest, I don't know if that's actually going to happen.

5:09:00I don't know if like how to keep them accountable to that either.

5:09:04So I don't feel that the notes are like a solid thing for me.

5:09:11But I think I'm just frustrated because I don't really know the impact.

5:09:14And I know how dollars are just, again, they're so woven together.

5:09:18Councilor Loretta Smith.

5:09:18And so I don't think that it exactly means that just because it's EMS and that's technically not FTE, I don't believe that that exactly means that FTE won't be lost.

5:09:27But I can't answer that question because I don't have the information, and I'm frustrated about that.

5:09:31So.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:09:34 - 5:10:37

5:09:34Thank you, Councilor.

5:09:38People keep jumping in the queue.

5:09:40I want to remind us that while there's a lot we can debate, we are moving toward A vote here, so I don't want to stop people from saying things they need to to explain how and why they're going to vote the way they are or to try to influence your colleagues.

5:09:56But I do want to make sure that we don't have folks just, um, jumping in if we don't need to use that time and space.

5:10:07Um, I also am seeing that our interim fire chief is online with a comment, and in the same way that we gave some space to the DCAs, I'm wondering, um, DCA Casi, if you mind if we hear from AJ Jackson.

5:10:34Chief Jackson, Director Casi is— or DCA Casi is coming up.

Eric Zimmerman 5:10:38 - 5:10:38

5:10:38I'm up here.

Mitch Green 5:10:41 - 5:11:05

5:10:41So, um, again, for the record, um, DCA Causie, um, my phone was blowing up, uh, through the conversation, and, uh, Chief Jackson had messaged me and said that she does have some specific examples of, of the impact, uh, to Portland Fire.

5:10:59And I, um, mentioned to her that if we have the opportunity, that I could come back up.

5:11:03So, Chief Jackson.

AJ Jackson 5:11:06 - 5:12:27

5:11:06Hi, thank you for allowing me to sign in for the record.

5:11:09My name is AJ Jackson.

5:11:10I'm the interim fire chief for Portland Fire and Rescue.

5:11:13And just to provide a little bit of context, I know there's a lot of questions and there's kind of fears about what's embedded in the external materials and services.

5:11:21And I just want to speak for fire and I don't want to speak for anyone else, but the majority of our EMS is really going to support our station operations apparatus maintenance and suppression support.

5:11:33So that's simple repairs, that's fire hose, self-contained breathing apparatus.

5:11:39It is a big chunk of our budget overall that goes to supporting our efforts.

5:11:44And just to kind of give a little bit of perspective, as it is like right now, we are projected to go over our budget.

5:11:49And right now it's about at $10 million is the projected ending, which is 5% of our budget.

5:11:57Um, and I guess for me and for who might be, you know, stepping in behind, behind me as the new fire chief coming in, I just want that person to have, um, a full arsenal, right?

5:12:09And to not be, uh, caught kind of already on the defensive on how to support our operations and ensure that we can maintain the services we provide to the community.

5:12:18So, um, if there are further questions or line item We are more than happy to provide that information to you all so you can have a more informed decision, at least from the fire perspective.

Sameer Kanal 5:12:28 - 5:12:31

5:12:28Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:12:31 - 5:12:51

5:12:31Thank you, Chief.

5:12:32Thank you, DCA Kazi.

5:12:36Um, we have a couple of additional people in the queue.

5:12:38I'll note that our colleague Councilor Koyama Lane is going to try to jump back online with us but had to, um, had to leave the meeting.

5:12:48Councilor Zimmerman, did you have anything additional to add?

Eric Zimmerman 5:12:51 - 5:14:47

5:12:51Thank you.

5:12:52I just wanted to comment on the ideas that were put forward by Councilor Kanal in terms of exempting those that you listed.

5:13:00I appreciated that.

5:13:02That helps me get much closer.

5:13:05The one area that I would actually say I'd rather, because it's a smaller amount and we are in this constant Negotiation with the county on our Portland Solutions stuff and our joint office stuff.

5:13:22I would say that extra $160,000 you noted for parks, maybe that could go back into the administration, the city administration, where I think that would probably benefit Portland Solutions in a sheltering manner.

5:13:32Um, but I— there's a couple of, of eaches out here.

5:13:38I generally am comfortable with the EMS The areas I wouldn't, I wouldn't want a cut applied based on this action if we miscalculated in this amendment the 2%.

5:13:56So if we said we think there's 2% represents this number, and actually that bureau doesn't have that in EMS, the way the budget document would signal that is that they'd have to make that cut in some other way because they've got to balance.

5:14:07Okay.

5:14:08So I want to make sure that that's avoidable, that we aren't adding or sending a signal of make this cut regardless.

5:14:14I think it needs to make sure that we are signaling only make this cut in EMS if that's happening.

5:14:19But I feel like there are some conversations and some work here, and I just appreciated Councilor Kanal's adjustment because saving the public safety pieces here, the apparatus that the chief just spoke about, I know the work it takes to get a fire truck serviced, and that's important.

5:14:34These are investments.

5:14:35You do not want things to go Down years without the right maintenance, it gets a lot more expensive.

5:14:40So I'm generally getting there, and I think we can move a few things around maybe to pass this at a different time.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:14:52 - 5:14:54

5:14:52Councilor Morillo.

Angelita Morillo 5:14:56 - 5:16:09

5:14:56Thank you.

5:14:57Um, I'm getting a little frustrated by the fact that it seems like no one seems to comprehend what a budget note is.

5:15:05A budget note is legally equivalent to a resolution, which means that it is giving direction to our agencies.

5:15:13As the legislative body with the power of the purse, we can give direction to our agencies about how they're going to spend these dollars.

5:15:20So when it says that they are required to check in with us every 6 weeks and give us updates, that does not mean that this is going to go You know, randomly through bureaus without any oversight from us.

5:15:33We are quite literally the oversight body.

5:15:36So I feel like this is as clear as it can be as far as engagement timeline.

5:15:42Do people want it more than every 6 weeks?

5:15:45What is it going to take to make people happy?

5:15:48Because I, I'm just failing to see how EMS would involve cuts to FTE.

5:15:55By definition, these are 2 separate and different parts of the budget that do not overlap.

5:15:59Councilor Loretta Smith, Am I misunderstanding something?

5:16:07Okay, Zimmerman, answer it then.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:16:13 - 5:16:17

5:16:13Councilor Zimmerman, did you want to say something to that before we move to Councilor Kanal?

Eric Zimmerman 5:16:17 - 5:17:03

5:16:17I, I, I totally agree.

5:16:19I think there's one question that remains, which is if in this amendment, because it has specific dollar amount reductions that are cited If we apply it in this amendment to a bureau and they don't actually have that in their EMS, that could have a different effect because they still have to balance it.

5:16:36I think it is such a minuscule percentage point, it's not really worth wrapping the axle, but it could cause pause because you're right, EMS is not people, right?

5:16:47And given the fact that the way that we lump things together in this city's operations of budget, I think if we can clarify one or two things there, your point is made.

Mitch Green 5:17:04 - 5:17:47

5:17:04I just, I need to jump in here.

5:17:05I've been trying to respect the stack, but the numbers that are enumerated there did come from the CBO, and those were from EMS budgets.

5:17:16Now, whether or not there's a preference to cut those budgets, that's a different question.

5:17:20But those are EMS categories in their budgets.

5:17:22So I think that's important to clarify.

5:17:24I would be open to amendments or friendly approaches that could get us closer.

5:17:31But really, Green 10, the budget note, is providing the vision for this.

5:17:36And we are, you know, to Councilor Smith's points, ditto.

5:17:41And I think that that is, you know, next time we gotta have more resolution.

5:17:45So thanks for letting me jump in here.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:17:47 - 5:17:52

5:17:47Thank you.

5:17:49Thank you, Councilor.

5:17:51Councilor Kanal.

Sameer Kanal 5:17:53 - 5:18:46

5:17:53Yeah, I've had a little time to think about it and hear feedback.

5:17:57I think regardless of whether or not this is the thing that makes it pass or not, this aligns with how I'm viewing the situation.

5:18:03So I will make the request for a friendly amendment to Councilor Green that I floated earlier.

5:18:11I am very open to saying up to That last dollar amount for that last category in case there's a rounding or a small amount as opposed to the hard and fast number of $166,377.

5:18:31And if it's the gap between living and dying on this to get what we need, I'm happy to put it elsewhere, but I'd ask if we could go 50/50 on it for parks and the city administrator.

5:18:44Councilor Zimmerman, if that's, uh, if that's okay with you.

Eric Zimmerman 5:18:48 - 5:18:52

5:18:48Yeah, I appreciate it.

Candace Avalos 5:18:52 - 5:18:52

5:18:52I—.

Eric Zimmerman 5:18:53 - 5:19:30

5:18:53We, we're under the gun right now from the county's perspective in terms of whether or not they're going to live up to the IGA.

5:19:04And frankly, I would like tomorrow to Bring a note that is stern about our position on that.

5:19:11And I want to be careful that we don't add to the messiness in our own, because last week hearing that they had a 40% reduction in their— potentially a 40% reduction in their sheltering, I don't want to then further contribute to it because I think that agreement right now is hanging on by like a thread of a thread.

Olivia Clark 5:19:30 - 5:19:30

5:19:30Okay.

Eric Zimmerman 5:19:31 - 5:19:31

5:19:31So that's my concern.

Sameer Kanal 5:19:31 - 5:19:50

5:19:31Yeah, that's a bit— I'm realizing that you just put $2.1 million, uh, into parks maintenance, so I'm happy to float it the way I said it earlier, but putting $100,000 $66,377 into the City Administrator's Office instead of parks at the end there.

5:19:45And I'd ask if Councilor Green would be comfortable considering that amendment friendly.

Mitch Green 5:19:53 - 5:19:54

5:19:53I am comfortable with that.

Sameer Kanal 5:19:54 - 5:19:55

5:19:54And I was the seconder.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:19:56 - 5:20:31

5:19:56You were the seconder, so I assume that you are also okay with it.

5:19:59So councilors, the proposal before us is now Green 9 with a number of items taken out of the reductions, generally those related to public safety, and an increase bullet added, which would send the remainder of the dollars, because this did raise more than it spent, to— or actually, I guess it would decrease the reduction.

Olivia Clark 5:20:31 - 5:20:31

5:20:31Yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:20:32 - 5:20:51

5:20:32It would decrease the reduction to the City Administrator's Office general fund discretionary with the remainder of the dollars specifically in order to keep Portland Solutions as whole as possible.

5:20:48Is that a fair summary of what you're doing here, councilors?

Olivia Clark 5:20:51 - 5:20:51

5:20:51Yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:20:53 - 5:21:30

5:20:53Okay.

5:20:54Councilor Avalos?

5:21:17Did you remove yourself from the queue?

5:21:19Okay.

5:21:20Councilor Kanal, are you back in the queue?

5:21:23Okay, councilors.

5:21:24Seeing no one else in the queue, I am assuming, Councilor Green, that that's a legacy hand there.

Mitch Green 5:21:30 - 5:21:31

5:21:30Legacy hand, so sorry.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:21:31 - 5:21:32

5:21:31Fantastic.

Olivia Clark 5:21:35 - 5:21:37

5:21:35Can we repeat the amendment?

Unidentified speaker 5:21:38 - 5:21:38

5:21:38Yeah.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:21:38 - 5:22:12

5:21:38So Keelan, I'm gonna have you call the roll, but before then, can you, Haley, please tell us the changes to the ordinance Green 9.

5:21:52We are not voting on an amendment to Green 9.

5:21:54We're voting on Green 9.

5:21:55This was a friendly amendment that was accepted to it.

5:21:57So it's Green 9, different from what is on the page because we have removed some reductions and reduced a reduction.

5:22:05And Hayley, can you share with us what those changes are?

5:22:08We need the amounts shared back to us.

5:22:11Councilor Kanal, can you send it to you?

Angela Todd 5:22:12 - 5:22:13

5:22:12Teams?

5:22:13Yep.

Steve Novick 5:22:13 - 5:22:13

5:22:13Yeah.

Loretta Smith 5:22:14 - 5:22:14

5:22:14Great.

Olivia Clark 5:22:14 - 5:22:15

5:22:14Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:22:15 - 5:22:17

5:22:15Or I can, you can vocalize them here and I can record them.

Steve Novick 5:22:17 - 5:22:17

5:22:17Sure.

Sameer Kanal 5:22:18 - 5:23:09

5:22:18So in the first line, and this is page 20 of the document, it's the first of the points under green 9, reduce program, bureau program expense in the City Administrator's Office general fund by $323,930.

5:22:37So that's a reduction in the amount reduced.

5:22:42The third line would be struck that says bureau program expense, reduce bureau program expense in the Portland Police Bureau general fund by $287,860.

5:22:49That would be struck, so it would not be reduced.

5:22:51The 4th line would also be struck.

5:22:53Reduce bureau program expense in Portland Fire and Rescue General Fund by $183,100.

5:22:58If you go down to the, uh, it's in the middle of the page.

5:23:03Reduce bureau program expense in the Office of Public Safety General Fund by $31,371.

5:23:08That would also be struck.

Mitch Green 5:23:09 - 5:23:10

5:23:09It's the—.

Angela Todd 5:23:11 - 5:23:11

5:23:1110Th.

Sameer Kanal 5:23:12 - 5:23:40

5:23:1210Th.

5:23:13The last one on that page Reduce bureau program expense in the Portland Bureau of Emergency Management general fund by $13,044 would be struck.

5:23:22The next one after that, first on the next page, reduce bureau program expense in the Office of Community-Based Police Accountability general fund by $5,000 would also be struck.

5:23:30So that is 6 lines that are— sorry, 5 lines that are struck.

5:23:34And the very first one, the dollar amount changed from $490,307 to $323,930.

Unidentified speaker 5:23:41 - 5:23:41

5:23:41Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:23:47 - 5:23:49

5:23:47Councilors, did everybody catch that?

Loretta Smith 5:23:53 - 5:23:53

5:23:53Okay.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:23:54 - 5:24:02

5:23:54Keelan, could you please call the roll on the amended version of Green 9?

5:24:02Connell.

Sameer Kanal 5:24:04 - 5:24:20

5:24:04Thank you to Councilor Green for your consistent effort in trying to figure out how to make these things happen and save As politically seductive as this one is, I still have to remain on my principles.

Dan Ryan 5:24:20 - 5:24:20

5:24:20I vote no.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:24:22 - 5:24:43

5:24:22Koyama Lane, let me see if she's joined.

5:24:25Can you guys hear me?

5:24:26Yeah, we can hear you.

5:24:27We can.

5:24:29I very much appreciate the discussion and the effort, um, I literally just said right before this, as much as possible, I think it's important that we try to stay at the governance level.

Angelita Morillo 5:24:44 - 5:24:45

5:24:44There are problems that we need to address.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:24:45 - 5:24:46

5:24:45I want to address them.

Angelita Morillo 5:24:47 - 5:24:50

5:24:47I'm not convinced that this is the right approach at this time.

Unidentified speaker 5:24:50 - 5:24:50

5:24:50I vote no.

Steve Novick 5:24:55 - 5:25:05

5:24:55The day I start governing by anecdote and assuming there must be a bunch of waste in government, so I'm going to vote to make Random cuts and hope somebody else will find the waste is the day I join the Republican Party.

5:25:05Hell no.

Olivia Clark 5:25:10 - 5:25:38

5:25:10Well, um, I think I'm being seduced.

5:25:18Um, I, I want the CEI hub staffing very, very badly.

5:25:25I want the Portland Center I want all the things that are in Councilor Dunphy's amendment.

5:25:34Um, perhaps against my better judgment, I'm voting yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:25:39 - 5:25:40

5:25:39Green?

Mitch Green 5:25:41 - 5:25:41

5:25:41Yes.

Olivia Clark 5:25:42 - 5:25:43

5:25:42Zimmerman?

Eric Zimmerman 5:25:47 - 5:26:00

5:25:47I am, I am always glad that Councilor Green is on the Finance Committee.

5:25:52With me.

5:25:53I appreciate the way you look at this.

5:25:55I think that's why we get along on a lot of stuff.

5:25:57Budgets are fast.

5:25:58You got to keep up or you will get lost in the dust.

5:26:00I vote yes.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:26:24 - 5:26:37

5:26:24I don't believe the rules allow that.

5:26:26I apologize, Councilor.

5:26:34You can always change your vote at the end if you need to.

Candace Avalos 5:27:00 - 5:27:07

5:27:00Um, I'm gonna vote no right now, and then I might change it.

Olivia Clark 5:27:09 - 5:27:09

5:27:09Dunphy.

Loretta Smith 5:27:11 - 5:27:11

5:27:11Aye.

Unidentified speaker 5:27:12 - 5:27:12

5:27:12Smith.

Angela Todd 5:27:13 - 5:27:13

5:27:13Aye.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:27:17 - 5:27:32

5:27:17I heard things from our DCAs that don't line up with the numbers on the page.

5:27:23I think there likely is room for cuts like this, but I can't do it in this hatchet of an attempt.

Candace Avalos 5:27:33 - 5:27:33

5:27:33No.

Olivia Clark 5:27:36 - 5:27:37

5:27:365-6.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:27:38 - 5:29:07

5:27:387-5, I believe.

5:27:40Sorry, I'm looking for the official count from our clerk though.

5:27:43Yeah, my, uh, vote tally tracker just crashed.

5:27:47Um, I believe it was 7 yes to 5 no, but I'll verify.

5:27:53That's what I wrote down as well.

5:27:59Colleagues, we were scheduled to stop at 6 o'clock tonight because we also have time tomorrow.

5:28:05So I am going to pause us here.

5:28:12We did 2 things in 2 hours.

5:28:15We have a lot to do tomorrow.

5:28:17I am going to encourage us all to say what we need to say to try to convince our colleagues to change their minds, to reach better policy, and to explain our votes before we vote.

5:28:30But to try to not say more than that tomorrow so we can get through this all.

5:28:35We will reconvene at 9:30 tomorrow morning, and we are scheduled between 9:30 and 6:00 tomorrow, and that is the time we have for our budget work.

5:28:46Hayley, do you have something before I recess our meeting?

5:28:50One request would be for councilors whose amendments were encompassed in Green 9 to send me a quick Teams message that formally withdraws your amendment if it was encompassed and you're happy with that, so we can officially remove those from the to-do list for tomorrow.

Mitch Green 5:29:08 - 5:29:08

5:29:08Thank you.

Elana Pirtle-Guiney 5:29:09 - 5:29:13

5:29:09And with that, I will recess our meeting to tomorrow at 9:30.