---
title: "Portland City Council Finance & Governance Committee (Whole) 11/12/26"
date: 2026-11-12T12:06:00-08:00
durationMinutes: 104
videoUrl: "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6cEkhqFyoo"
---

# Portland City Council Finance & Governance Committee (Whole) 11/12/26

**Portland's Finance and Governance Committee of the Whole voted 7-2 to recommend that the full City Council accept Mayor Keith Wilson's reappointment of Tom Kramer to the Fire and Police Disability and Retirement Board of Trustees, at a meeting where a hearing on downtown's future ended without councilors discussing it.**

## Kramer reappointment sent to full council

The clerk announced the vote on the Kramer reappointment as **7 ayes, 2 nays and 3 absent** ([01:22:53](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=4973)). The transcript does not capture the item's discussion or roll call, so the record does not show who voted no.

Councilors Eric Zimmerman (District 4), Olivia Clark (District 4) and Tiffany Koyama Lane (District 3) were absent. Councilor Dan Ryan (District 2) said their absences were prearranged. Ryan presided. He said the committee's chair, Councilor Sameer Kanal (District 2), was traveling and attending virtually and had asked him to run the meeting.

## Downtown hearing ends without council discussion

The committee heard invited presentations and public testimony on the future of downtown. Ryan said at the outset that no legislation was on the docket. He later said 38 people had signed up to speak, at two minutes each ([01:17:42](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=4662)). The transcript captures only the first panel of testifiers before it jumps to the Kramer vote.

When Ryan moved on to the next appointment, Councilor Candace Avalos (District 1), attending remotely, raised a point of information. "I feel frustrated that we didn't have an opportunity to talk about a very big topic like downtown Portland," she said ([01:24:29](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5069)). Ryan answered that "there was a lot of pressure to try to accommodate those that were here today" and said, "I'm going to table the discussion from the council to the next meeting" ([01:25:20](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5120)).

Avalos said she had "a lot to say about East Portland." She then added: "I don't appreciate how the meeting been facilitated to erase our opportunity to respond" ([01:25:39](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5139)). Ryan replied "noted" and said city employees had waited hours for their appointments: "So 3 hours is 3 hours" ([01:26:00](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5160)). Avalos responded: "I disagree with your decision. I'm just putting that on the record" ([01:26:13](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5173)).

## Business groups describe job losses and empty offices

Andrew Hone of the Portland Metro Chamber said the region lost **22,000 jobs** while the nation added jobs, and that "every single private sector industry is contracting" ([00:16:44](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=1004)). He said large employers vacated 2.25 million square feet and 8,000 employees left the central city, mostly for the suburbs. He set Multnomah County's office vacancy of 38-plus percent against Clark County's figure of below 7%. He credited a weekly tent count's decline since 2023 for better perceptions of downtown, but said crime was "beginning to slip backwards." "We will not attract new businesses to downtown Portland," he said, citing taxes and city services ([00:16:44](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=1004)).

Madeline Miller, a Portland Metro Chamber lobbyist, put office vacancy in the Central Business District at nearly 40%, compared with 4.6% in Wilsonville ([00:32:29](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=1949)). She cited sale discounts of 56% on the Jackson Tower and 93% on the Royal Sonesta Hotel. She also said converting offices to housing "is not a silver bullet."

Sydney Mead, senior director of downtown programs for Downtown Portland Clean and Safe, said this was downtown's busiest summer since 2019, up 3.6% over 2025. She said 16 weekend days exceeded 2019 traffic ([00:41:58](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=2518)). She added that "it is less expensive to rent the Moda Center than it is to rent Waterfront Park" ([00:46:32](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=2792)).

Andrew Fitzpatrick, director of economic development at Prosper Portland, said the Vacant Storefront Grant program stopped taking applications after two weeks, with more than 80 received. He said applicants already in the queue will hear back as funds become available ([00:56:28](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=3388)).

## Housing and Old Town proposals

Rebecca Markley, Oregon Housing Alliance coalition organizer at Neighborhood Partnerships, urged extending the pedestrian-only section of Harvey Milk Street toward Naito Parkway. She cited a 2023 Portland Bureau of Transportation survey in which 90% of respondents wanted the COVID-era street plazas kept open ([01:04:55](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=3895)). She also asked the city to support social housing, including a tenant opportunity to purchase policy.

Hanako Wakatsuki-Chong, executive director of the Japanese American Museum of Oregon, spoke for four Old Town cultural institutions and asked the city to designate a cultural district. She said the 2014 Old Town Chinatown Action Plan was backed by **$57 million** in public funds before the pandemic froze its projects. She also said "public money went to an unvetted private venture called Made in Old Town" ([01:11:33](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=4293)).

## Testimony: safety, parking and taxes

The record shows no separate open-comment period; public testimony addressed downtown. Keren Eichen, director of real estate for Unico Properties, said more than 100,000 people worked downtown before COVID and roughly half do now ([01:19:03](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=4743)). "What helps is not new taxes or more social housing," she said, and asked for consistent public safety and an extension of downtown lease tax credits.

Eric Murfitt of Mercantile Portland called the condition of the SmartPark garage elevators "unacceptable" ([01:20:42](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=4842)). He also asked the city to stop removing on-street parking.

Anita Paas, general manager of the Dossier Hotel, said "we are not okay." She described an October 15 incident in which a man standing next to her "pulled out a box cutter and lunged" ([01:22:53](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=4973)).

## Two other appointments advance

The committee voted **9 ayes, 3 absent** to recommend that the council accept Charity Kreider's reappointment to the Portland Children's Levy Allocation Committee ([01:32:46](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5566)). Councilor Loretta Smith (District 1) moved it, and Council President Jamie Dunphy (District 1) seconded. Kanal asked whether reappointments involve recruiting other candidates. Interim director Meg McElroy replied, "We do not do a recruitment typically" ([01:31:56](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5516)).

The clerk announced **9 ayes** to recommend Charles Freeborn's appointment to the Noise Review Board ([01:43:06](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=6186)). Smith moved it, and Councilor Steve Novick (District 3) seconded.

Kanal asked Freeborn whether any case would be a "hard no." Freeborn answered: "I'm inclined to say that there is never a hard no" ([01:37:09](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5829)). Dunphy, who has criticized the city's noise code, told him: "I want a lot of noise emission in this city" ([01:37:44](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=5864)). Councilor Elana Pirtle-Guiney (District 2) asked about neighborhoods near Portland International Raceway. Freeborn said he would raise concerns if he saw the code was not meeting the need.

## What's next

Ryan said the committee meets next on **Wednesday, November 18**, and will "bring back the conversation about the future of downtown Portland" ([01:43:19](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-fgc-1?t=6199)). The Kramer, Kreider and Freeborn appointments now go to the full City Council. Prosper Portland's Westside Activation Grant is open through November 30. Fitzpatrick said work on a new citywide economic development strategy will begin in the middle of next year.

---

## Regular agenda

**Keelan McClymont** [1:06]

Captions test. Captions test.

**Dan Ryan** [7:22]

Just want the green light to come on. Good morning. I call the meeting of the Committee of the Whole to order. It's Thursday, November 12th, at 9:30. Clerk, can you please call the roll?

**Keelan McClymont** [7:38]

Good morning. Clark. Green.

**Mitch Green** [7:41]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [7:43]

Zimmerman. Avalos.

**Dan Ryan** [7:49]

She's online.

**Keelan McClymont** [7:52]

Oh, Councilor Avalos. We'll come back. Uh, Smith?

**Eric Zimmerman** [8:00]

It's like she's on that show where you—.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [8:03]

Hello, good morning.

**Loretta Smith** [8:06]

Here.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [8:07]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [8:12]

Murillo.

**Angelita Morillo** [8:13]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [8:14]

Novick.

**Steve Novick** [8:14]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [8:15]

Dunphy.

**Jamie Dunphy** [8:16]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [8:17]

Kanal. Uh, Councilor Avalos, it looks like you're present. Can you hear us?

**Dan Ryan** [8:27]

Can she hear us?

**Keelan McClymont** [8:30]

Oh, okay. Uh, okay. Uh, we are having just a quick technical issue. We need to make sure that folks in Zoom can hear us. So we're troubleshooting right now.

**Dan Ryan** [8:46]

With Councilor Avalos?

**Keelan McClymont** [8:48]

Right. Yeah, the folks in Zoom can't hear us right now, so we're trying to make sure that we can get the room— there, looks like— okay, there we go. Councilor Avalos, can you hear us?

**Candace Avalos** [9:02]

Yes.

**Keelan McClymont** [9:03]

Great. Okay, great. Avalos is present. Kanal?

**Sameer Kanal** [9:10]

Present.

**Keelan McClymont** [9:10]

Great. Okay. Okay. All right.

**Dan Ryan** [9:14]

Hey, thank you. We have a quorum.

**Keelan McClymont** [9:16]

Sorry.

**Dan Ryan** [9:16]

We do have 3 people who are absent today, Councilor Zimmerman, Clark, and Koyama Lane. So I just wanted you to know that that was prearranged and here we are and the rest are virtual. So Christopher, will you please read the statement of conduct?

**Unidentified speaker** [9:29]

Good morning. Welcome to the meeting of the Governance Committee of the Whole. To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council. Council/agenda/committee-whole or by calling 311. Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link. Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting. In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

**Keelan McClymont** [9:51]

If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise. Today's testimony will be 2 minutes per testifier. Your microphone will be muted when your time is over. The chair preserves order. Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed. Thank you. If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given. Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting. Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass. Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually. Your testimony should address the matter being considered. When testifying, state your name for the record.

**Unidentified speaker** [10:25]

If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent. Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves before the clerk calls your name. Thank you.

**Dan Ryan** [10:32]

Thank you, Christopher. And first of all, I just wanna acknowledge Councilor Kanal is the chair of this committee. He's traveling and will be virtually attending. Mm-hmm. However, it's hard to conduct a meeting when you're virtual sometimes. So he asked me to go ahead and do that. So colleagues, here's what we're doing today. We're going to receive a presentation on the future of downtown Portland. We're going to listen. That's the big part of today's session is listening to public testimony on the future of downtown. Time permitting, we'll have additional discussion amongst colleagues. It's likely that we'll have to have additional conversations. This is a really big, complex topic. And I know we want to dig into it. That's why we're having this meeting. And legislation is not on the docket today. We hope that something will come from this because we want to take action and be responsive. And we'll see what that looks like. We will receive committee chair updates, and Councilor Kanal will be on board for that virtually. And then we'll consider appointments to FPDR, Children's Levy, and the Noise Review Board. We will take one little break in between, but our goal, most biggest goal today is to listen to all of you. We wanna respect your time boundaries. Thank you all for being here. It's great to see a full council chamber. And I wanna add that the legislative body has work to do and the union leadership understands that. And we were in communication with them on Tuesday. Chair Pirtle-Guiney did before the City Life meeting. I took her cue and it's Thursday, so I thought it merited a new conversation or at least a fresh one. And we talked earlier this morning. Thank you. And union leadership did say, yes, we want the legislative body to do their work at City Hall. So I just wanted you to know all of that. There'll be some joyful noise coming now and then into the room. Just see it as that. Bring your theater voices, not in the audience, but those that are on the stage. Be loud and articulate. That'll be really helpful.

### 1. Future of Downtown Portland (Presentation) and Public input on the future of Downtown Portland (Public hearing)

**Dan Ryan** [12:22]

And without further ado, let's go ahead and— Clerk, can you please read the first and second items together?

**Keelan McClymont** [12:29]

Item 1, document 2026-01. Future of Downtown Portland. Item 2, document 2026-409, public input on the future of downtown Portland.

**Dan Ryan** [12:41]

Thank you, Keelan. Colleagues, again, we're going to hear presentation first, then we're going to listen to public testimony, and there's quite a few people signed up. How many have signed up, Keelan? 25. 25, Great. And then we'll have discussion. I'm really pleased that we're going to start this conversation. I know in the former committee called Arts and Economy, we, we tackled this, but we really wanted to bring it back. It was kind of in limbo between this committee and another committee. So the good news is it finally got on an agenda. And so I'm thrilled that we're here today. It's often said that so goes Portland, so goes the rest of the state. I'd like you to think about that with Portland. So goes downtown, so goes the rest of the city. That might sound alarming and uncomfortable, but if you look at metrics, if you look at the data, it really does suggest, especially for our revenue streams, think of it like a turnstile of collection of revenue downtown. And we used to collect a lot of revenue not too long ago, and that significantly dipped. And it's really impacting our general— it's impacting our budget tremendously. And so— I think that's a great point. I'm representing North and Northeast Portland, and yet I know that you have to have a really strong and robust downtown. I'm going to bore you all a little bit because I'm older than most on this dais, and I also lived here in the '70s, and it was bleak. And the difference then was it was busy during the day, but everyone left at 5 o'clock, and weekends were pretty quiet. So there was a renaissance. There was a renaissance to get people to move downtown, to bring life downtown. Thank you. And we saw our night and our weekend economy really soar beginning in the mid-'80s up until really just before COVID And so we want to reimagine that livelihood of downtown once again. We know that it's good for all of us up here and all of our constituents throughout the city. And so we want to get to the bottom of how this council can be responsive to being as bold as the leaders were in the '70s when they figured out how to make Portland's downtown a premier downtown on the West Coast. We want to bring that back. And so that's, I hope, what the beginning of today looks like. And we're going to hear some problems, of course, but we're going to really try to think out loud with you together about solutions. So there was a script that I was supposed to read that said, I think, some of this. I'm looking at my chief of staff right now just because I went wildly off of it. But I really do want to acknowledge you, Chief of Staff Adam Green. Thank you. Really, District 4 was bringing this up and no one really had the capacity, it seemed, to take on the cat herding. And so thank you, Chief of Staff Adam Green, working with all the District 4 chiefs of staff. It was a collaborative effort and I hope you'll experience that today. We do our best work when we do it in collaboration, of course. I also want to now begin this testimony with a panel that was selected to come up. And I'm going to go ahead and read your names. We're going to first hear from Andrew Hone at the Portland Metro Chamber, Madeline Miller, the Director of Commercial Real Estate, Sydney Mead, who is the Senior Director of Downtown Programs, and Andrew Fitzpatrick, Director of Economic Development at Prosper Portland. Thank you all for being here. The floor is yours to get us started, and then you will be able to ask technical and clarifying questions of this panel before we get into the rest of the testimony. Take it away.

**Unidentified speaker** [16:17]

I can hold on to it.

**Dan Ryan** [16:21]

Are you doing that polite Portland thing on who's going first?

**Unidentified speaker** [16:24]

Oh yeah, we're just going to stare politely at each other until, you know, someone makes a decision. We're just trying to share our presentation.

**Dan Ryan** [16:34]

Adam to the rescue. Okay.

**Unidentified speaker** [16:44]

Just press spacebar. Okay, I'll take it. All right. Uh, thank you, Council. Council President, thank you, Councilor Ryan, for the invitation. Thank you, Councilor Green, for being our sole D4 downtown representative that is in the house today. So appreciate that and the invitation to have this discussion. We love downtown Portland. We love Portland. We also want to acknowledge this is the first time that the council has invited a conversation around downtown. I think that's really exciting to be able to engage collaboratively with you. My team is here today. I'm also so appreciative of the dozens of folks that have signed up to testify and share their stories about downtown Portland and communicate what's going on on the street. So with that, I'm going to walk us through a little bit about the state downtown where things are today, talk about perceptions, talk about progress, talk about challenges, and then of course talk about the future. So let's get going. The first thing that we should celebrate is, boy, has there been a change in the perception of downtown Portland. So I think you've heard the axiom before that you take the elevator down in perception, you walk the staircase back up, and that has certainly been true. We took a national reputational hit throughout the pandemic and early on post-pandemic, and now we are seeing the turning of the tide, and that is thanks to very intentional collaborative collaborative efforts with Travel Portland, Prosper Portland, and so many of you in elected office that have come together to send the positive message about what's happening in Portland. And this has been true not just in the headlines that you read, but what you have in front of you here is incredible work that is conducted by Travel Portland on Portland as a destination for visitors, not just from around the region, but the country and around the world. The blue line on the top is a good line. That's that our destination is appealing. The red line is not good, and you can see the rapid diversion of those 2 lines. That's something we should celebrate. It's a leading indicator about how people feel. And while surveys like this may be imperfect, it just tells you that the country is seeing Portland in a better light, and that is something that we can all be celebrating because we know where that will take us in the future. And then let's talk about our region. So since 2023, we've been tracking perceptions in the region around how people view downtown Portland. And as you can see, the good news is that the positive vibes are up and the negative vibes across the board are down. These are truly reflective of the fact that people are feeling safer, better, and feeling like they have something to do in downtown Portland. Then if you get into perceptions of daytime and nighttime, I don't think we should celebrate these numbers overall. Yeah. But these are perceptions we've been tracking as well since 2022. But what you should be evaluating is the positive trajectory in the way people perceive feeling safe in downtown Portland. That's probably one of the biggest inhibitors of why people weren't coming during the pandemic. And frankly, you look at these numbers, a doubling in the feelings of safety at night and an improvement of nearly 50% of feeling safe in the day. This is progress and it's on the right track, on the right trend line, and we expect it to continue to improve in that manner. This is producing results. So perception improves, people start returning. That same survey asked the questions, who has visited downtown Portland at least once in the last month? Portlanders never really walked away from downtown. They kept coming to downtown even in the dark days, even in the challenging days. Their general feel is that I can go to downtown. What we lost was our suburban neighbors. They decided not to come to downtown, to stay in their communities. They had concerns, and you can see that that has improved substantially. Now let's talk about the big numbers. I think all of you know this, but in the Downtown Portland Clean and Safe District, 273-block enhanced service district, we track using Placer AI what are the footfalls happening. So what you're looking at on the screen right here is 2024 to 2025. This is the last full years that we have for evaluation. And as you can see, from '24 to '25, we saw substantial improvements. Now clearly we're nowhere where we used to be in 2019. That's of course to be recognized, but I want to call out the difference in the colors because it will matter in the next slides ahead. So total number of folks coming down, that's workers, that's residents that live here, those are visitors whether they're from the region or the state or beyond. And then in that green line, I want you to pay particular attention to that. Those are folks like me, like you, that work in downtown Portland. You can tell who's coming in and working in the community. And as you can see, it is specifically flatlined. And that's something we're going to talk about as a challenge moving forward. If you extend the line out and how things are going through the rest of the year, and I know Sydney Mead is going to talk a lot more about this in the presentation that she has, but we continue to see that upward trajectory. And it is driven by what? Visitors. Visitors coming here and having a good time. Employees are not increasing. In fact, this year they went down for the first time since pandemic openings of offices. Thank you. What is driving this is, of course, our events and activations, our big festivals, those celebrations that bring people together, and that is a good thing. And why? So let's talk about what happened with conversions from perception on safety and livability in downtown Portland. I put this up here. A lot of people evaluate what's going on with homelessness in our community. I will proudly state that I believe this is at least in a very narrow way one of the most accurate counts that we have on homelessness. And why? This only looks at tents. So this does not take into account all the different contributing factors to homelessness. Not here to say this is comprehensive in any way. But what it is, is a person that is out on the street once a week counting tents on behalf of Downtown Portland Clean and Safe. And why are they doing this? Because of course there are issues that happen when there's tents out there, cleaning that needs to happen because our service providers need to be out there responding to any concerns out there. And if you look at the dramatic improvement year in and year out since 2023. This progress should be celebrated. Every single individual in a tent is finding their way to shelter and permanent supportive housing and on their way to a better life. Living on the street is not a choice, and we are thrilled that people are finding their way to a better livelihood after living in downtown Portland. So this is a significant improvement that I think is driving that perception of safety, livability, cleanliness, and people are coming back. In droves. Safety, however, considers— continues to be a concern. You're looking at crime statistics between 2 areas downtown, so sort of think south of Portland and north of Portland, and we can see that we are beginning to slip backwards in terms of safety. These are Portland Police Bureau-related statistics. We are seeing crime increase mildly across the board in both sets of the downtown core. For our part on Downtown Portland Clean and Safe, we are thrilled to be able to provide services to the Central City and to the District. Just to point out, if you break this out on a daily basis, our cleaners pick up 150— 185 bags of trash a day, 75 needles a day. I will not describe what the biohazards are for the well-being of all of us in this room, but I will state if it were not for Downtown Portland Clean and Safe, all of this would be on our streets right now. There is no comparable city service offered. And of course, the safety program— all of these are calls that would have otherwise gone to non-emergency lines and 911. One thing that you'll hear from almost everybody in this room, that our current wait times for calls for services to Portland Police are still too high, stressing these core services in our central city. Okay, so let's talk economics. Yes, we've got problems. We've got a few of them. So let's get into that. You've heard this before from me before. This has not changed. We have been in a localized recession since 2023. Thank you. Consumer sentiment that is tracked is last or near last in the nation. Our ability to build multifamily permitting is last in the nation. Office vacancies are the highest in the recorded history of the Central Business District. Our office foot traffic, you saw, is recovering, but it stopped growing, and of course it is now last of all cities in the nation. Because of the ridiculous trade wars we engaged in over the last year, we saw the largest drop in export value in the nation, and this is a trade-dependent state. Thank you. Our employment is also, in terms of Portland, near last in the nation. We did get some good real estate news, but I don't think celebrating going from 80 to 73 of 81 cities on real estate investment is anything to, to, you know, put on the refrigerator at home. But we'll, we'll take the wins that we can. So let's dial into this, because I think jobs, jobs, jobs, jobs, jobs, jobs, jobs are the most important thing we need to talk about. So these are statistics produced by the Oregon Employment Department. This is not our information. This is readily available to all of you, the region lost 22,000 jobs. And I say this because it happened at the same time that the nation grew jobs. And anyone who's either a real economist or an armchair economist like myself can observe that the axiom has always been true. As the country grows and adds jobs, Oregon grows faster and adds jobs faster. As the country shrinks, we shrink faster and we lose jobs faster. Now we have decoupled from the national economy. Should the national economy tip into recession and start losing jobs, I can— I am extremely concerned about what that will mean for our community. So what does this mean very specifically for Portland? Let's take a look. This is as of September of last year. That giant red arrow pointing to those tiny little scripts at the very absolute bottom of that list is Portland. So this is every single city in the country. Thank you. And we are second to last. You'll also notice that we are one of only 4 states that were currently losing jobs as of this time last year. What's happening right now? Not much has changed. So we are still second to last as of October of 2026, simply last month. We are joined by a number of other cities that are now also losing jobs, but the preponderance of other cities are growing and adding jobs. The only thing that is distinct about us besides contracting by 2,400 jobs is that every single private sector industry is contracting. The only growth industry in this region right now is government employment. That's called an upside-down pyramid. I hear this a lot. Businesses have always said that they're going to leave, but they never leave. I'm going to linger a little bit on this concept. What you're looking at here are major lease terminations or vacating of spaces or the exodus of companies that exist in the Central Business District ever since the pandemic hit. And this list includes folks that are doing things for different reasons. Let me give an example. OCHIN is an incredible nonprofit that is an education technology nonprofit that used to occupy the Central City. They were in office 5 days a week. When the pandemic hit, they went all virtual. So that is just the trends that happen when we have a, you know, once-in-a-generation event like a pandemic occur. But— and The Standard is another good one. They're not fully gone from downtown Portland, but they have substantially reduced their workforce and their building is primarily vacant. Thank you. What I want to point to is that overall we have a challenge. 2.25 million square feet of space just on these large-ticket employers departing. You'll notice there's an other category. These aren't giant leases, but they're substantial enough. Those also, when aggregated, are significant in nature. And those retailers, while you may not want to personally go to REI, Target, CVS, or Nordstrom Rack— some people do— and those spaces will lie vacant because they are substantial enough. Substantially converted for the purposes of serving large box retailers. This has resulted in 8,000 employees, just by employee count of businesses, have left the central city, have gone from our community. And the good news is this, if you want to call it good news, they haven't left the state, they haven't left the region. They believe in the Pacific Northwest, they believe in Oregon, but they've moved to the suburbs. So they've kept their presence, but they left our central city hollow. Thank you. Anyone believing that cities and regions that are dense urban places can't grow, just look north of the river. So while Multnomah County continues to lose population and employment and has a sky-high office vacancy rate of 38-plus percent, Clark County has grown population, grown its employment, and has below 7% office vacancy. Okay, so what the heck is the future of downtown Portland? It should be different. It shouldn't be what it was. No one thinks we should go back to the days that we saw before. While we may have designed our transit center to transit system to bring people to downtown. Things are changing. Things are going to be different. We have to think differently. But what we can all agree on is downtown should be safer. It should be cleaner. It should be a business incubator, an accelerator, cultural entertainment, culinary capital, 24/7 neighborhood where we have residents living here and where we don't push businesses to the suburb where they're taking up precious farmland and green spaces. Kids that are in school today should believe that they can work in downtown Portland. Not move to another state for a job. How do we get there? First and foremost, stop reinventing wheels. We like to do things, come up with plans, and then never actually execute on them. Guess what? There are amazing plans that were built by the public and private sector working together. The Central City Task Force convened people who don't agree on almost anything, and we all agreed on the All In on Portland. That is a central city roadmap for what we can do to the physical landscape of our central city. The Tax Advisory Group was comprised of public and private partners saying, how do we stabilize public funding so that we don't cut core services. There are good plans that have broad-based consensus among organizations, labor, community working together to improve the tax conditions of the central city. And lastly, the mayor's convened the Central City Roundtable, Advance Portland plans that are conducted by Prosper Portland. These are things that exist right now and that we can do. So from recommendations of how we do things, you will not hear a ton of divergence from the people sitting behind me right now. We cannot continue to have unsheltered individuals on our street. They need a place to sleep. They need a pathway to a vibrant future. We need more police, park rangers. We need effective outreach to our unsheltered individuals on the street. We need street sweeping like any other big city. We need park maintenance and an absolute laser focus on just keeping up basic city assets. We need to concern ourselves with the nighttime economy because that's our future. Families, young people, and the aging, they should feel safe, because if they feel safe, we all feel safe. We will not attract new businesses to downtown Portland. I want to just put that out there. That is not a reality in this moment when we have the nation's highest business taxes and highest personal income taxes and some poor core services. We will not attract big employers. We have to grow from within and scale those businesses. Housing especially. You've got 4 big bets. They are able to produce massive quantities of housing. That's OMSI, Broadway Quarter, Albina Vision Trust, and the Lloyd District. Lastly, arts, culture, and entertainment. They are economic drivers. The Portland Art Museum was the largest expansion in cultural history in the state of Oregon. It was a $144 million expansion. It was $137 million paid for by private interest. That math doesn't math anymore. We have to do things together. We need partners in the public sector to support this kind of improvements in our central city. And now with a deeper dive going into— and I would say this, we're all on Team Portland, we all need alignment— and to understand the central city, specifically commercial real estate market, is Madeline Miller.

**Madeline Miller** [32:29]

Thank you. Hi everyone, my name is Madeline Miller. I'm a lobbyist with Portland Metro Chamber, and I'm here, a newer staff a newer staff member in a new position that was funded by a couple of different, uh, commercial real estate and building trades organizations. So they all recognized the need to, uh, grow and grow our economy, and they're recognizing the need and the struggles in this sector. And so my position was brought together to better partner with you and other, uh, jurisdictions and other levels of government to restore vitality to the sector. And as we know, the commercial real estate sector is synonymous with downtown, so we're to restore vitality and vibrancy back to downtown. I came from ECHO Northwest, where I was evaluating policy research for about 9 years, and before that, an affordable housing nonprofit. I don't know many of you, so I wanted to make sure that you knew a little bit more about my background and where I'm coming from in that research perspective. Thank you for having me today. So I was asked to talk about commercial real estate with regard to the future of downtown. The first thing we need to discuss is these high office vacancy rates Andrew spoke to this a little bit. Portland has one of the highest vacancy rates in the country, and it's highest in the Central Business District at nearly 40%. This compares to 4.6% in Wilsonville, just under 10% in Lake Oswego, 7.2% in Clackamas, and 13% in Beaverton. You can also see some statistics here on the net absorption, which just means, did we gain or lose occupied office space, both in the 3rd quarter and year to date? So you can see that the Central Business District continues to shed occupancy. Thank you. With negative absorption while the surrounding areas are growing. The Central Business District saw 75,000 square feet loss in occupancy in Q3, whereas Cruise Way saw 100,000 square footage positive improvement. Tigard and Tualatin each saw about 30,000 square foot improvements, and Vancouver saw 81,000 square feet. Our loss is their gain. Our offices are vacant both because firms have been moving out of the CBD and because workers have been extremely slow to return to office. While things are improving, we are still above the median for the top 50 metro areas in the country in terms of workers who return to office or workers who are primarily working from home. Andrew shared a lot of that data about downtown foot traffic and how our employees and workers are flatlining in our recovery. Without office workers, our Central Business District has really very few housing units. We have one of the lowest ratios of housing units to office space in the entire country, and that makes it even harder for small businesses to survive without workers, particularly on Mondays, Fridays, and the weekend. This is forcing businesses to close, move, or shift their formats despite having extremely low storefront rent and leasing terms. One analysis this summer looked at the economics of why a locally owned coffee cart was parked behind a truck on a towing, on a towing cart in front of a vacant Starbucks. They pointed to the lack of consistent foot traffic to sustain sales. The economics of the brick and mortar no longer work when there aren't enough foot traffic workers and residents in downtown to sustain their ongoing sales. But the cart could relocate. It was more mobile. It was more flexible. It could move to events and activations and move around town. Thank you. So they were finding a way to make it work. Ground floor vacancy can really be contagious. It can spread when foot traffic declines because there's vacancy here, and then another business can't sustain itself. It becomes vacant, and it can be contagious. It can also beget other challenges, as we're seeing elsewhere in the community. Another major statistic that you all know about is the massive fire sales that we're seeing on some of our iconic buildings. You're all aware of this. We're seeing these historic declines from, you know, 56% off the Jackson Tower adjacent to Pioneer Courthouse Square to the 93% discount on the Royal Sonesta Hotel that was announced a couple of weeks ago. These declines are driven by all of the aforementioned challenges in the market, and these prices and valuations will have lingering effects on the tax revenues collected by the city for budgets in the years to come. A lot of people have the opinion that we have not bottomed out yet. Thank you. Unfortunately, you know, what do we do with these empty office buildings? Office to residential conversion is not a silver bullet due to floor plates, where HVAC and plumbing is located in a building, where the elevators are, and building code requirements for windows and bedrooms and things like that. Um, many buildings in our downtown are simply too big to convert. The floor plates simply don't work with the requirements of how we can fit the units in the building. This really leaves just a handful of projects that are even eligible, but there are also other challenges with scattered occupancy, different requirements on seismic and historic designations, inclusionary zoning, and just the rents and costs don't align. The rents we could charge would not cover the cost of conversion without major subsidy. I know of a couple of projects that are under consideration, and they're both still working on their financing. They just are having a really hard time making it work. Thank you. With these hyper-local challenges coupled with the macroeconomic factors of high interest rates, crazy insurance premium increases, and the cost of labor and materials, many development firms have closed their Portland offices or closed up shop. This is a list of firms on the left side and the number of buildings that they built in the last cycle on the right side of the screen. These are mostly residential. Not all of these are in the Central Business District, but it shows the impact that we are going to be facing when we do return to growth. There's so many people betting on Portland. Portland will come back. The downtown will come back. But we will need residential developers and trades unions and the workers that fund development, that build development. We will need them when the population grows. We know we're growing anemically, but housing construction really lags that population demand, population growth and demand. Thank you. And that's what we saw in the 2010 cycle. We saw the construction sector took nearly 10 years to return to growth in its employment levels after the Great Recession. And we were having population growth at a time when we just couldn't find the labor or the firms to build the units that we desperately needed. Commercial real estate is synonymous with downtown, from our office towers to our large residential properties to the arts and culture centers to our restaurants and retail shops. Commercial real estate is the builders, the operators, and the project property managers that staff those buildings in those spaces. The industry is struggling because downtown is struggling, and a prosperous downtown is absolutely essential to city life. Councilor Wren, you said it well, that so goes downtown, so goes Portland. Unfortunately, we're not bottoming out yet. Office leases will continue to term out. Firms will decide whether to stay, downsize, or leave. Demand is still weak. The rents are low and many buildings are simply stuck. Sales prices are continuing to decline and development firms have left, putting— and local developers are putting their staff on projects outside of the city, outside of the central area. The construction trades, people retrain. They will be slow to return if we lose them. And this sets us up really poorly for the next cycle when demand will pick up. So there's tremendous opportunity right now to show up for local businesses, local employers, and the local players who are committing to Portland right now. This slide shows some of the solutions that would help restore vibrancy in the Central Business District. These are ideas that we want to bring to the table as a strong partner with the city. Really, it comes down to regaining economic vitality, returning our employment sector to growth, and passing policies that encourage employment retention and recruitment. We need to reduce storefront vacancy. We really support the storefront improvement programs that have been passed. And small business supports. We also need help to reposition some of these buildings, and we need an activated downtown via strong revitalization efforts, programming, and pro-tourism. In addition, the sector and the district needs to rethink some of the buildings, and we need help with streamlined feasibility and development processes. We need predictability and consistency so that people can know what to expect when they pull a permit to re— Purpose a building or do a tenant improvement. We need reforms to fees, processes, timelines, and regulations that will help get to feasibility, because right now the math simply doesn't work. We saw the system development charge waiver report showing that it wasn't quite enough to make some of these larger projects pencil. And we really just need a get-to-yes mentality with these strong partnerships with you all and the county and the state. Housing production needs to return to growth through some of those same consistency and predictability and reduced regulatory burden. Thank you. Burdens on the sector. We need to partner with you all to come up with the most applicable incentive programs, both zoning and financial, and we need increased accountability to do everything we can to return to growth. At, at the building level, we need to also see just public safety and cleanliness that will lead to a good operating environment and lower costs for building operations. So thank you again for having us today. We really appreciate the opportunity to speak with you. Thank you.

**Dan Ryan** [41:40]

Thank you, Madeline. If we could just go right on to Sydney and then Andrew. And colleagues, we now have 38 people signed up. We're giving them 2 minutes each. The goal again today is to listen to everybody. So, um, Sydney, it's your— you have the floor. Thank you.

**Sydney Mead** [41:58]

Hi, good morning. Um, my name is Sydney Mead. I'm the senior director of downtown programs for Downtown Portland Clean and Safe, uh, and also a registered lobbyist, uh, for the Portland Metro Chamber. Uh, it is my I'm privileged to be leading the events and activation team at Downtown Portland Clean and Safe, which means that I help direct the work that we do in Director Park and Darcelle XV Plaza, as well as leading the Downtown Retail Council. Connecting this work is the Visit Downtown campaign, a marketing and PR campaign targeting local audiences within a 25-mile radius of the city center. Andrew and Madeline have outlined some of the significant challenges that we are facing as a community. There are some encouraging things happening, and I'm hoping to highlight some of those. All right. Downtown's changing rhythms. So we've spent a little bit of time talking about our foot traffic reports. People are coming downtown. We are seeing that on Friday and Saturdays, especially including Sundays as well. We're seeing a shift in that behavior. Instead of having a real consistent Thank you. We're seeing a consistent amount of traffic throughout the week. We're seeing peak times between 6 PM and midnight in the downtown core on Friday and Saturdays. People are coming downtown for arts performances, dining, public art, and cultural experiences. For businesses, the question becomes, how do we connect these visits with more of what downtown has to offer? We have some momentum. Again, this was our busiest summer since 2019. We have seen an increase of 3.6% over 2025. But I think one of the stats that I'm most intrigued with— whoops, did my— okay, sorry, I think my microphone went out for a second there— is the 16 weekend days that we actually exceeded traffic in 2019. That's pretty remarkable, and it is showing that people are coming downtown. The next step is to make those visits rewarding enough that people explore more, they stay longer, and then support businesses and come back. People are looking for experiences and for ways to connect with their community. We're seeing that in the parks that we manage, and when a public space is cared for, welcoming, and programmed, people have a reason to gather. A performance, a market, or a public art installation can turn a place that somebody passes through into a place where they choose to spend their time. The Visit Downtown campaign helps share these— this invitation with a wider local audience. The retail reality, um, obviously we've just heard a little bit about the national headwinds that our retailers and small businesses face. Uh, a busy, uh, public space does not automatically translate into a strong week Yes. Downtown businesses are dealing with all of those national headwinds, and they're also trying to navigate safety and cleanliness challenges and the reputation of the downtown core that is different than many of our cities on the West Coast and throughout the nation. One of our longest-running responses to this problem is one of my favorite programs, the PDX Pop-Up Program. This is been going on for the last 17 years through Downtown Portland Clean and Safe and our private sector supporters. We help small businesses and small retailers try out the downtown for themselves, providing a brick-and-mortar location and giving them an opportunity to connect with a broader audience. This year we received a record 96 applications from businesses that were really interested in being part of this pop-up program. We've been able to support a record 17 Over the years, businesses that have gone through this program and graduated are some of our favorite local brands: Crafty Wonderland, Bridge and Burn, Bring Treats for Dogs, and so many others. The Visit Downtown campaign supports those shops with marketing and public relations that helps to introduce the business and gives people another reason to make downtown part of our holiday plans. Thank you. Councilmember Herbold.

**Dan Ryan** [46:27]

Sydney, I know I told you to get really close to the mic. I think I gave you bad advice. Just a little bit further back.

**Sydney Mead** [46:32]

A little bit farther back. Sorry. All right. Can you hear me at this? Yeah, your enunciation, you're projecting great. Thanks. Thank you. That program extends beyond our own channels. With our PBX pop-up program, we garner a tremendous amount of media with 142 mentions for the 2025 program. That gives it the a small business, um, the kind of introduction to the public that it can be difficult to, uh, create on their own. The next question is what it takes for those businesses to stay. Uh, we would like to build on the city's existing vacant storefront grant program and create stronger connections between temporary activations and long-term leases. We are advocating for a year-round retail incubator that could extend the opportunity beyond the holiday season. And most important, as helping these businesses open for the first time, is making sure that customers know that they are there. This is where the Visit Downtown campaign comes in. It brings together the City of Portland, the Portland Metro Chamber, and Downtown Portland Clean and Safe through the Downtown Marketing Initiative. And I just want to thank the council and the mayor for making sure that this funding continued in this last fiscal year, it was really important to help market our downtown retailers. The campaign roots go back to the downtown retail strategy developed during Portland's previous major economic downturn in 2009. It received substantially higher funding in its peak, and our funding is a little bit limited. In fact, we're at this point a little bit lower than 2019, where people were still eager to be in the downtown area. This campaign connects people so they can experience downtown with wider audiences. We maintain a year-round rhythm of stories about small businesses, restaurants, bars, cultural destinations, and events. We produce original content, work with partners and creators, and combine organic social media with paid advertising and earned media. We also help create experiences that promote programs such as the Bloom Tour and Portland Staycation. And Wildwood Follow the Crows. Andrew mentioned how grateful we are to our Travel Portland partners and their work with helping our national brand. We realized that we needed to do something locally because our brand locally was really suffering. In a separate program in fiscal year 2025 and '26, we partnered with the State of Oregon, Multnomah County, and the City of Portland again to work on a brand and reputation repair project. We placed targeted messages and created approximately 4.7 million impressions throughout the downtown on a campaign that really sought to increase people's pride in their city and their downtown area. We launched several videos and tested several approaches. We were able to survey afterwards and see that a lot of these videos did increase the sense of pride in the downtown area. In particular, one of them, uh, the Nowhere Else campaign, uh, featured a video, uh, with Loretta Lynn and Jack White, um, performing the music in the background. Um, we did an organic launch on this, and just to show you, um, it was over 4.5 million impressions, uh, and a considerable outreach. Leveraging dollars— that same approach, combining resources and working with our partners, is how we stretch the city's investment across programs included in this calculation, every Downtown Marketing Initiative dollar spent on the Visit Downtown campaign was combined with additional sponsorships, partner contributions, and collaborations, resulting in a part, um, more than $3.40 for every dollar spent on the program value. It helps explain how a relatively small marketing, um, investment connects with a much larger body of work. Let me show you a few examples. The Bloom Tour. I hope that you guys are aware of this program. It's becoming a favorite for retailers in the downtown area. It combines local creativity with an invitation to explore the downtown. Installations give people a route to follow, a reason to walk downtown, and a reason to discover businesses along the way. It generated 1.7 million impressions, and it also generated about 25 media mentions. The relationship between the experiences and the promotion is important. The installations gave us a distinctive story to share with the broader public, and the campaign helped people discover and participate in the tour. I want to highlight public spaces. The same relationship is available— is visible in our public spaces. Our Summer of Love program brought music performances and community gatherings to that work. Darcelle XV Plaza, we recorded more than 100,000 visits to that park, a brand new park thanks to the City of Portland that opened in June, much later than we hoped, but it did open. We also hosted 53 events in Darcelle XV Plaza. That takes consistent work, staffing, security, and coordination with event producers and promotion. Together, those pieces create a public Public space function as a destination. People know that something is happening, they feel welcome when they arrive, and they have a reason to return. Our Wildwood Follow the Crows extended that invitation to the entire city. Working with Leica Wild and Art, Oregon Health and Science University, Doernbecher Children's Hospital, about 30 artists and partners, we helped create a free public art trail. People were invited to explore at their own pace, discover the sculptures, meet the artists, and support Doernbecher Children's Hospital. For the farewell weekend, which we held in Darcelle XV Plaza, we saw more than 14,000 visits over the 2-day period. It brought together public art exploration, community participation, and a charitable purpose. The trail also gave regional, and I would say national and international media, a positive story about Portland to share. At the time of this report, for just the Wildwood Follow the Crows program, separate from the Wildwood movie media blitz that we have going on, we generated about 53 stories and approximately 8.6 million reported potential reach. The stories were about artists. They were about families exploring the city, Leica's creativity, and the support for Doernbecher. This is part of the brand and reputation work that we do, giving people reasons to discover and talk about downtown in a positive way. Thank you. Thank you. I will just say that we had an amazing app, and I will look forward to sharing kind of some of the interesting details on the app. We also passed out about 40,000 paper maps that were free for people that wanted to participate with this program. This was definitely a love letter to Portland, and it captured the spirit of the campaign, giving people again a way to connect with the city in an enjoyable and meaningful way. We coordinated significantly with Travel Portland and Travel Oregon, generating more than 1 million collaborative impressions across 10 posts. These partnerships extended the invitation beyond our own audiences. And throughout the trail, we kept sharing new stories, artist perspectives, and reminders, giving people a reason to participate before the experience ended. What comes next? These examples point to 4 priorities. First, investing in the reputation and brand, Thank you. So businesses and cultural experiences have a consistent platform for reaching customers. Second, making sure that it is easier to produce events in our city. I will just point out, and you may have heard this already, but it is less expensive to rent the Moda Center than it is to rent Waterfront Park. And the Moda Center comes with bathrooms, water, power, and a roof in case it rains. So we really should kind of look at that. Second, make it easier to produce event— or excuse me, third, strengthen the path from a temporary storefront to a lasting business through lease support, negotiations on transitional grants. TI grants, I think, are really significant in this, and year-round incubator. And finally, the James Beard Market really gives us an opportunity to connect this work with Portland's culinary identity and surrounding businesses. Thank you. We have an opportunity here to become the epicenter of culinary work in this region. And I think that's really important to really focus in on that. Thank you for your time and your partnership.

**Dan Ryan** [56:12]

Thank you, Sydney. And now, good transition to Andrew, who will tell us more about the Storefront Program that you were just mentioning. Good morning.

**Andrew Fitzpatrick** [56:28]

Good morning, Chair Kanal, Vice Chair Ryan, members of the committee. Appreciate this time. I'm Andrew Fitzpatrick. I'm the Director of Economic Development at our city's economic and urban development agency, Prosper Portland. As you know, we are the city's economic and urban development agency, and we implement a number of different activities to focus on downtown revitalization. So I wanted to briefly outline some of those. And share with you how they intersect with Advance Portland, our city's economic development strategy. Advance Portland, as you also know, is really focused on inclusive growth, on strengthening Portland's competitiveness, and on supporting climate action. Objective 3 of the strategy is focused on downtown revitalization and the importance of downtown in our economy. Prosper is taking both actions for vibrancy today while also investing in longer-term strategies and assets assets for durable economic vitality tomorrow. We realize that our vitality also relies heavily on continued improvements to safety and livability and our overall business environment. As you know, our downtown represents a disproportionate share of our employment and tax base. It includes many of our revered cultural institutions, venues, and shared public spaces, and it's how many visitors to Portland first experience our community. We know that a healthy downtown means a healthy city, and that's why all of us together need to continue to support the central city now more than ever to build on some of the momentum that we're seeing positively. As Sydney just noted, we are encouraged by the consistent increases in foot traffic throughout our downtown, and we're eager to see those numbers continue to grow as we head into the holiday season. More people are returning to our shops, our restaurants, and our public spaces, and that energy is exactly what makes our downtown With this momentum in mind, I'll briefly highlight a few of our initiatives that revitalize downtown by activating our storefronts, our residential and commercial assets, and our public spaces. As Chair— Vice Chair Ryan mentioned, the Vacant Storefront Grant Program is based on the storefront support work that was led in part by Councilor Ryan and championed by Mayor Wilson and funded by you all in the last budget cycle. Thank you. This grant fosters a vibrant central city and commercial districts by providing tenant improvement grants for eligible businesses that choose to lease vacant storefronts anywhere within the City of Portland. Due to high demand, we were forced to pause applications for this program after just the first 2 weeks. Before pausing, our grants team had already received more than 80 applications, many of which were in our central city, highlighting strong demand and need. Those who have already applied will remain in the queue and can expect to hear from our staff as their applications are reviewed for eligibility and as funds become available. Related to these storefront grants, Prosper is proud to have recently invested in the expansion of Downtown Clean and Safe's successful holiday pop-up program so that it can include 17 storefronts during this holiday season. Our Office of Small Business is ready and available to partner with these pop-ups with the goal of helping some of them sign long-term leases. Additionally, Prosper Portland recently opened the Westside Activation Grant through November 30th to fund activation projects within the Westside TIF District that generate foot traffic, leverage additional investment, and stimulate economic activity. We know that for downtown storefronts and public spaces to be successful, we must also enable greater private investment into producing more residential units, retenanting vacant office spaces, and in some cases repositioning commercial assets to arts and entertainment, education, childcare, light manufacturing, laboratory, business incubator, and other uses. Public investment can help ignite some new housing units, targeted office conversions in key anchor destinations like the James Beard Public Market, but we also must intentionally compete for private investment by improving both the real Recently moving up 7 spots in the ULI real estate rankings is welcome news, but we still must do much more to respond to what our employers and their employees are clearly and consistently telling us about safety and livability and the tax and regulatory barriers they must contend with. Our business advancement team at Prosper Portland continues to work hard with limited tools to retain our existing employers downtown and attract new ones. Councilor while also pursuing expansions and recruitments to keep and create quality jobs. Despite our headwinds, Portland offers several strong industry ecosystems today and a cost competitiveness compared to other West Coast cities. We offer a deep talent pool, a high quality of place and strategic location, and attractive real estate values. We must lean into marketing these competitive advantages while we concurrently solve On Tuesday of this week, Prosper Portland, Pioneer Courthouse Square, and an array of our partners presented the Downtown for the Holidays press event. Your colleague, Councilor Zimmerman, served as our keynote speaker as we celebrated the arrival of Portland's holiday tree and the start of an event-packed season. As you all know, many small businesses make a major portion of their annual revenue and their profitability during the holiday season. That means every purchase you make locally whether it's a cup of coffee, a gift, or attending a show, helps sustain our jobs, strengthen our economy, and keeps our downtown thriving. The vibrancy we're seeing grow is a testament to our incredibly resilient local businesses, a broad mix of public and private partners, and our city colleagues. I first want to thank our Office of Film and Events for their work supporting and leading Central City events through direct financial assistance, permitting support. And I'll also give a shout out to PBOT for sponsoring free parking at all 5 SmartPark garages on Saturday, November 28th, in support of Small Business Saturday. We need to keep making it inviting and frictionless for people to spend time and money downtown. Our cross-bureau collaboration is critical for successful events and activations. The Prosper team works closely with Parks, PBOT, Police, Fire, PP&D, PBAM, Portland Solutions, and others on a daily basis to make Basis. Sure that we're providing the best experience for our customers. Thank you. The collaboration and partnership are essential to the success of our events and the broader vibrancy of our downtown. Finally, please come downtown with friends and family to spread— and spread the word about our New Year's Eve drone show, which returns to Pioneer Courthouse Square on December 31st with 2 performances, a family-friendly 9 PM flight, and a midnight show to ring in 2027, plus great food, company, and a dance party. Events like this highlight the power of public-private partnerships and the many positive benefits that come with large-scale community events in our city center. Center as we continue to activate our storefronts, our residential and commercial assets, and our public spaces. All this work helps to inform the next citywide economic development strategy as we capture learnings, measure results, and assess where, where additional tools and investments are needed. We need to identify new opportunities with your input to build on our momentum and to strengthen Portland's economy. We anticipate kicking off development of that new strategy in the middle of next year in partnership with each of you, with Mayor Wilson, and with our community and business stakeholders. As dedicated public servants, Prosper Portland is committed to bringing our expertise, our leadership, and our partnerships to bear in support of the future of our downtown. Thank you very much for this time. I appreciate the opportunity and look forward to discussion.

**Dan Ryan** [1:03:50]

Thank you. Thank you, Andrew. And thank you, the entire panel. Madeline, I called you Madeline, right? Madeline. All right, thank you so much, Sid and Andrew. Okay, next we will hear the final 2, uh, people who are invited guests, Rebecca Markili and Oh Wakasuki Chong. Rebecca is a housing policy advocate, writer, and zine maker interested in the intersections of political economy, public policy, and everyday life. Welcome. Thank you. She brings advocates together to advance housing policy. It's good to see you. We also have Hanako. She is executive director of the Japanese American Museum of Oregon in Portland, in Old Town, professionally trained as a public historian, political scientist, and museologist. Museologist. I didn't even know that was a thing, so that's a great word. Thank you. Welcome to both of you. And again, we'll try to do no more than 10 minutes so we can get to the public testimony. Thanks so much.

**Rebecca Markley** [1:04:55]

Great. Thank you. Good morning, Vice Chair Ryan and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. For the record, my name is Rebecca Markley. I use she/her pronouns, and I'm the Oregon Housing Alliance coalition organizer at Neighborhood Partnerships, where I work on state housing policy. I wear many different hats, but I also wanted to mention that I am a D2 resident. And I'm a PSU student pursuing a Master's of Urban and Regional Planning. So I spend a lot of time in downtown for school, for work, and for play. And I also spend a lot of time thinking about the intersections of urban life and housing. When I think about the future of downtown, I keep coming back to a question about what makes a place feel like a neighborhood. It's not just the buildings or the number of people who pass through, but it's also made up of all the everyday things that we do to live our lives. Thank you. It's knowing where to get groceries, where to pick up a prescription. It's seeing the people at the bus stop every day, getting to know your neighbor's dogs, finding somewhere to sit down for a while without having to pay for a cup of coffee. These things seem small, but they are just a part of how we get to know a place and the people around us. They're how a collection of buildings and streets start to feel like someplace we belong. We heard in previous presentations that downtown Portland is experiencing significant changes and has disrupted some of the traditional ways that we consider downtown and how downtown functions. And I agree that we have the opportunity now, almost a necessity, to respond to those changes by moving beyond a back-to-the-office mentality and thinking more intentionally about the people who already live here, who play here, who work here, and might want to call downtown home in the future. I'd love to see the city you know, seriously consider expanding the pedestrian-only portions of Harvey Milk Street towards Naito Parkway. You know, in the 2023 survey that PBOT did, 90% of the respondents wanted the COVID-era street plazas to remain open. Experiences in cities like New York and Copenhagen and Rotterdam have also demonstrated the potential for pedestrian-only streets to increase foot traffic and support local businesses. Thank you. Imagine what that space could be with more room for food carts, places to sit, play equipment, art, greenery, all the things that we heard about in the last presentation. More investment into active storefronts. These are investments that make downtown feel more comfortable and give people more reasons to spend their time here. I also want to talk about something that I think needs to be at the center of the conversation, and that's particularly around housing. In my writing and research, at school and in my work in housing policy, I've been thinking a lot about the— all of the labor it takes to make a home. Making a home and being a part of a neighborhood means establishing routines, developing relationships, and figuring out how you want to participate in the world around you. It's much harder to do that when you don't know if you can afford to stay. This brings me to a project that I worked on last spring. A group of urban planning students and I partnered with the transit-oriented development team at Oregon Metro Metro for a graduate capstone project. We developed a tool to evaluate how well different sites around the metro area would support affordable housing development. The tool considered financial factors, development readiness factors, but it also looked at things like access to open space, grocery stores, and child care. We tested many sites around the metro region, and downtown Portland sites evaluated repeatedly as some of the I think that's really exciting and something worth paying attention to. Downtown already has many of the ingredients that make a neighborhood work: transit access, existing infrastructure, employment opportunities, cultural institutions, and proximity to essential services. And these are invaluable public investments that can make downtown an important place to expand housing and job opportunities. We should be asking, how can we build on those assets and make sure that the people who live downtown are actually the ones that are benefiting from them. And I think social housing also offers an important framework for doing that. As the Portland Housing Bureau report on social housing articulates, social housing is a pretty broad term, but it can take on different— many different typologies, including publicly owned housing and limited equity cooperatives. What these models have in common, however, is a commitment to lasting affordability, preservation of that asset, and housing that serves residents over the long term. Thank you. And I want to see the city think more ambitiously about how to support those models downtown. That could be exploring a tenant opportunity to purchase policy. If paired with financing, that would allow residents to collectively purchase and maintain their buildings. It could also mean developing limited equity housing opportunities supported by a permanent source of public funds. This approach offers something beyond just an affordable rent. Thank you. They create opportunities for residents to have a meaningful stake in their homes and in their communities and have a say in the decisions that affect their buildings and their lives. I think that particular— that's particularly important when we talk about the future of downtown. Resident participation in housing decisions can be a pathway to broader civic engagement, and people who have a meaningful role in their buildings also have the opportunity to develop relationships, skills, and collective power that We should be thinking about housing as a part of civic infrastructure of downtown. Homes are where the jobs go to sleep at night. People who work in downtown businesses, maintain its buildings, provide services, and keep the city functioning need places that they can afford to live, hopefully nearby. And the people who already live in downtown deserve the opportunity to stay, to establish roots, and participate in its future. Councilmember Herbold. So as you consider the future of downtown, I hope you look at the many of the surface parking lots near the Morrison Bridgehead as opportunities for housing development. I hope you'll explore expanding Pride Plaza's pedestrian space and pursue adaptive reuse where it makes sense financially. But I especially hope that you'll pair those physical investments with a serious commitment to long-term housing affordability and a social housing ecosystem. We have an opportunity to to respond to a changing downtown with real imagination. We can make room for people to live, walk, gather, and get to know one another. We can invest in housing that remains affordable, gives residents a meaningful voice, and helps build stronger communities. And ultimately, I hope we stop thinking about downtown as solely as a place where people work, shop, and visit, and start thinking about it as a place where people can build a life. Thank you.

**Hanako Wakatsuki-Chong** [1:11:33]

And I am trying to share my screen for my presentation. Um, here we go. Let's see. Oh, okay, there we go. Okay, uh, good morning, council members, and thank you for this time to present. My name is Hanako Wakatsuki-Chong, and I'm the executive director of the Japanese American Museum of Oregon here Old Town. And I'm here representing, um, for some of our partners, including the Lan Su Chinese Garden, Portland Chinatown Museum, and the Oregon Jewish Museum and Center for Holocaust Education. So this is a presentation on more than a decade of work towards a cultural district in Old Town. It tells 3 different things: we planned, we were derailed, and we are ready. This is also the groundwork for the proposal that we will bring to City Council. So let me tell you a bit more about what I mean with we planned, we were derailed, and we are In 2014, the city adopted the Old Town Chinatown Action Plan backed by $57 million of public funds with the support for our cultural institutions written in. In 2019, the city extended it with 2 signature projects, one at 4th and Burnside and one on Block 25 in the heart of Japantown. Agreements were due in spring of 2020. We were derailed when the pandemic froze those projects while the neighborhood carried a disproportionate share of the city's crisis response funding. Thank you. And recently, public money went to an unvetted private venture called Made in Old Town. But we are ready to move forward. Our four institutions and community partners have a phased plan. Investing in culture here is a matter of equity and the strongest economic opportunity that Old Town has. But let's talk a little bit about the history and why equity matters. In 1880s, Portland had the second largest Chinatown in the country. Japantown thrived here until May 6th, 1942, when it emptied in a single day with the forced removal of Japanese Americans. To prison camps in Northern California and South Central Idaho just because they're Japanese. The Golden West Hotel was for 25 years the only hotel in Portland where a Black traveler could get a room, and Jewish, Greek, and Roma families started out here too. Our institutions have been building on this history. Both the Jewish Museum and JAMMO, the Japanese American Museum of Oregon, were founded in 1989. To Lon Su's $54 million expansion plan for our cultural institutions currently bring in over 150,000 visitors into Old Town a year. If we fail, Old Town will fall. We have over a century and a half of history on these blocks that make up Old Town. Many communities made their start here and are still struggling to stay in Old Town today. So for the last 37 years, our communities have been trying to prevent eminent domain. Councilmember Herbold. Provide a cultural grounding rod for Portlanders and other Oregonians. Projects like Lan Su's Festival Celebration shows that it's more than a garden. Portland Chinatown's Museum has high-quality collections and has plans for the acquisition of the Tuk Long Building to preserve the storefront face of Old Town. And at JAMMO, we created a Japantown story map, and we are trying to create a community space for healing. The Oregon Jewish Museum has extensive programming on civil rights, and even SETI x Archives VR tours shows that the cultural district is ready to work. So we have 4 plans, and some of it's already in motion. So JAMA, we just expanded into the Povey Building for community programming and was recently named a Smithsonian affiliate. Lawn Suit Chinese Gardens plans to expand into Block 24, doubling the garden's footprint and programming space. Oh, sorry. And Portland Chinatown Museum is looking to fundraise to purchase the Tuck Long Building, and the Oregon Jewish Museum is executing a new strategic plan for their museum. So this is a justice issue where the city of Portland has a pattern of disregard, and now you all have a chance to change it. Old Town, Japantown, Chinatown is Portland's oldest neighborhood and is the city's original downtown. Again and again, decisions about it have been made without the communities whose history it holds. Thank you. And both of these communities, like the Jewish— the Japanese American community and the Chinese community, were pushed out due to institutionalized racism. So equity here means investing in people who never left and the places their family built. Also, Old Town's recovery is downtown's recovery. Mayor Wilson has said Old Town is ground zero for Portland's recovery, and we agree. And culture is how it will recover. So here is our phase plan. Portland Chinatown Museum, um, on the short term wants to acquire Tuk Lung Building first, and then hopefully Lonsu could be successful in their capital campaign and expand into Block 24. Um, and then we at JAMO, we're hoping to create a community space and spaces for all of our community's story. And that's more of a long-term, like a 10-year plan, um, because we want to do building acquisitions as well. Uh, research states that heritage travelers spend about 60% more per trip, and they bring that spending to restaurants, hotels, and shops all around us. And remember, at our current capacity in this current economic situation and environment we are in, um, our 4 cultural organizations bring in over 150,000 visitors per year, but it will increase when conditions in Old Town improves, and we could be part of that solution. So we have, um, 4 steps that we think the city could help towards, um, establishing this cultural district. One is have the city designate a cultural district to preserve and protect our collective cultural histories. 2, Provide economic support to help cultural organizations emerge from the COVID-related setbacks. 3, Um, have the city lead discussions with the county and state to support balanced service and community-rooted investment. And 4, have the city to fund potential planning to bring together Oregonians like the Oregon Black Pioneers, the Greeks, the Roma, LGBTQ, and other community partners into a more long-term planning with our 4 institutions. So thank you all for your time, and if you have any questions, feel free to reach me out to the museum.

**Dan Ryan** [1:17:42]

Thank you so much. We're going to go ahead and try to transition right now into public testimony. Colleagues, if we could at least get through 20 minutes, then we'll do a very brief break, like 5, 6 minutes. There's 38 people signed up. We really want to honor your time boundaries that, that you took time to be here today. So, Council Clerk, if you could start the testimony, that'd be great. Read the list.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:18:03]

Thank you. I'll call up testifiers in groups of 5. Each individual will have 2 minutes. For those testifying in person, you'll see the timer countdown displayed on the monitor in front of the testimony table. For those testifying virtually, the timer is displayed in Zoom. You will hear the timer sound twice, once when there are 30 seconds left, then a second time when your time is up. Before you begin your testimony, please state your name for the record. Our first panel includes Keren Eichen, Thomas Kilbane, Eric Murfitt, Anita Paas, and Susan Bladholm.

**Dan Ryan** [1:18:45]

Adam, if you could talk to the clerk about the people that, um, were the elected officials and such. I don't have that with me right here. You're on it. Okay.

**Keren Eichen** [1:19:03]

Good morning. I'll go first. My name is Karen Eichen. I'm the director of real estate for Unico Properties. We manage millions of square feet of office real estate downtown, and I'm a proud resident of D3. Before COVID more than 100,000 people worked downtown. Today, that number is roughly half. Those aren't just office jobs. Empty buildings mean less work for custodians, elevator technicians, electricians, plumbers, and more who keep those buildings running. This gap shows up in empty space, fewer customers, and millions less in property tax revenue. Public safety and the perception of disorder are not separate from the economy. When streets feel unmanaged and people don't feel secure, employers don't expand and workers don't come in. Imagine what a thriving downtown could do— more jobs, more activity, and millions more in property tax revenue to fund the services the city needs. We keep investing on the private side in security partnerships and events. It works if the conditions outside match. What helps is not new taxes or more social housing. It is consistent public safety and practical tools like extending downtown lease tax credits that make it competitive to locate and grow jobs here. The decisions you make land directly whether a business and workers stay in Portland. Please treat reliable safety and a competitive environment as the foundation for recovery. Downtown still has the pieces. It needs the conditions that let them work. Thank you. Thanks so much for your time.

**Dan Ryan** [1:20:37]

Any order? Yeah, please go. No one— it's like being at a 4-way stop in Portland. Just, yeah, go.

**Eric Murfitt** [1:20:42]

All right, thank you for hearing our testimony today. My name is Eric Murfitt. I'm a lifetime resident and 20-year employee of Mercantile Portland, a woman-owned retail shop in downtown Portland. Been doing business for over 50 years. Located on Park and Alder. Mercantile Portland is committed to downtown for its walkability, unique mix of local businesses, and seasonal activations that promote visits to downtown from both locals and tourists. We appreciate the security presence at SmartPark and the responsiveness of Clean and Safe patrols for both cleanups and security issues. Recently, we've heard several compliments about downtown from tourists visiting our store, and our staff is excited about the James Beard Public Market set to open this year. Thank you. Next year. Next year. However, as you know, the last 7 years have been very challenging for Portland retail as we have seen a sustained drop in local pedestrian traffic and tourism. We still hear from many of our loyal customers that they avoid coming downtown due to, due to a perception that it is not as safe as it once was. They mention open drug use, reduced police presence, and frankly, people with mental health issues not being taken care To respect everyone's time, I'll state very briefly what we would like to see more of. Invest in cleanliness and maintenance at SmartPark garages. The condition and functioning of the elevators in particular is unacceptable.

**Thomas Kilbane** [1:22:05]

Marketing messages and programs often feature new businesses and pop-ups, which is nice, but businesses that have been committed to downtown for decades need similar support. This could include marketing and improvement grants.

**Eric Murfitt** [1:22:16]

Thank you. Quit removing on-street parking. Our customers prefer parking on the street. We need to remove any hindrance perceived or real that prevents a customer from visiting downtown.

**Thomas Kilbane** [1:22:28]

The flower pots that once hung from the lampposts in front of our store did not return this year. They add a great deal to improve the streetscape and welcoming feel of our immediate neighbors. A few things to continue real quickly: promoted events and activations that draw locals back downtown. Clean and safe services provide a visible sense of security and help keep the sidewalks clean and enhance security in smart park garages. Thank you for your time.

**Anita Paas** [1:22:53]

Okay, good morning, councilors. My name is Anita Paas. I'm the general manager of the Dossier Hotel, which is located on Alder and Park. I need to start by saying we are not okay. On October 15th, I was standing next to a man when he pulled out a box cutter and lunged. I ran into the hotel and held the lobby door shut. An off-duty security guard helped me and my team. Imagine coming back for your next shift and walking through those same doors. You put on your name badge, you greet a guest with a smile, and you hear a question we get all the time: is it safe to walk around downtown? You want to say yes. You want them to go out, enjoy a meal, and see the parts of Portland that you're proud to share, you also want to give them an honest answer. A few hours later, you'll be walking out the same doors yourself. We brought in counseling for our team after the attack. I wish they never needed it. I see how my team care for our guests and look out for each other.

### 4. Reappoint Tom Kramer to the Fire and Police Disability and Retirement Board of Trustees for a term to expire December 31, 2029 (Report)

**Anita Paas** [1:24:04]

I'm— 2020 Recommendation it be accepted is approved with a vote of 7 ayes, 2 nays, and 3 absent.

**Dan Ryan** [1:24:15]

Thank you, Councilor. Can you please read item 5?

**Candace Avalos** [1:24:19]

Mr. Chair, I have a point of information.

**Dan Ryan** [1:24:22]

Excuse me, Councilor Avalos.

**Candace Avalos** [1:24:26]

Am I recognized?

**Dan Ryan** [1:24:28]

Yes.

**Candace Avalos** [1:24:29]

Thank you. Um, before we go on with the rest of the agenda, I guess I just wanted to circle back because I, I am feeling a little frustrated actually by what transpired when we finished the previous item, um, not this last one, the one before. So I just want to get clarity on when we're actually going to talk about that, because I feel like there's a missed opportunity to actually speak to the folks that came to present. I wish this wasn't a one-sided or a one-way conversation. So, uh, it's— I'm looking, I'm not there. It looks like people left anyway, uh, but I feel frustrated that we didn't have an opportunity to talk about a very big topic like downtown Portland. So could I get an explanation from you, Chair, of why we are moving forward? Is there some pressing time for the remainder of the, um, the appointments, or could those have been pushed so we could have completed that conversation?

**Dan Ryan** [1:25:20]

Uh, yes, in the room, we, uh, there was a lot of pressure to try to accommodate those that were here today, and we did our best to listen to the vast majority. Um, and we then are going I'm going to table the discussion from the council to the next meeting. And we will, of course, invite— we will invite those to come back for that.

**Candace Avalos** [1:25:39]

Okay. Because I think that's, again, a missed opportunity for us to react to the 30 people, 40 people that spoke to us. And I'm just wanting to express my disappointment with that decision, Chair, because I have a lot to say about East Portland and a lot to say about economic development. And I don't appreciate how the meeting been facilitated to erase our opportunity to respond.

**Dan Ryan** [1:26:00]

Uh, noted. And, uh, I had to make a call because we had— we have people that work for the city that have been in the meeting for several hours. I wanted to make sure we could get through their business of appointments. So 3 hours is 3 hours. Yeah.

**Candace Avalos** [1:26:13]

Thank you. I disagree with your decision. I'm just putting that on the record. Thanks.

**Dan Ryan** [1:26:17]

Got it.

### 5. Reappoint Charity Kreider to Portland Children's Levy Allocation Committee for term to expire December 12, 2028 (Report)

**Dan Ryan** [1:26:18]

Can you please read item 5?

**Keelan McClymont** [1:26:21]

Document 2026-340, reappoint Charity Kreider to Portland Children's Children's Levy Allocation Committee for term to expire December 12th, 2028.

**Meg McElroy** [1:26:35]

Good morning and afternoon, councilors. My name is Meg McElroy. I'm the interim director at the Children's Levy. I use she/her pronouns, and my brief presentation will reorient you to Children's Levy governance, remind you who currently serves on the Children's Levy Allocation Committee, and then I'll turn it over to Charity Thank you, Councilor Pryor, to share remarks about her reappointment. So just a reminder that the levy was first created in November of 2002, and that property tax measure passed by voters established the 5-member allocation committee that is charged with granting funds to programs for services to children and families across Portland. Council Resolution 37610 was most recently referred to voters for the election in May of 2023 that reauthorized the levy overwhelmingly by voters for another 5 years from July 1st, '24 through June 30th, 2029. Pursuant to that authorizing legislation, the 5-member allocation committee continues to govern the levy. 3 Of 5 seats are appointed by the mayor, a city councilor, a resident with knowledge and experience related to children's services, and a representative of the business community. And 2 of 5 seats are appointed by the Multnomah County Commission. One is a county commissioner and another is a resident with knowledge and experience in children's services. Next slide, please. This slide shows you the current 5 members of the Allocation Committee. The 3 city appointees are Councilor Dan Ryan, who chairs the committee, Charity Kreider, who is the resident with knowledge and experience in children's services, and Dan Floyd, who's a representative of the business community. The 2 county appointees are Commissioner Megan Moyer And Felicia Tripp-Folsom, who is the resident with—. Another resident with experience and knowledge in children's services. Their terms are staggered according to their bylaws. Their term length is 2 years, and members may serve any number of terms not to exceed 8 years of total consecutive service. 4 out of 5 members are eligible for reappointment in accordance with the bylaws, including Charity, who's with us today. Next slide, please. Thank you. Next item on the agenda is the appointment of a new member of the Council Allocation Committee. Next item on the agenda is the appointment of a new member of the Council Allocation Committee. The mayor seeks reappointment for Charity. She was appointed in 2024 by the previous mayor and confirmed by the previous city council. Her 2-year term expires next month. She is interested and willing to continue serving for a second 2-year term. She's attended all allocation committee meetings and completed all of her duties requested of allocation committee members, so I'll turn it over to her to share her Good afternoon, councilors, and thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today.

**Charity Kreider** [1:29:17]

My name is Charity Kreider. I'm a mama, a community member, and a strong advocate for children and families. My husband and I are raising 2 neurodivergent children here in Portland. We know how isolating and exhausting it can be to raise a child with a disability. Exhausting it can be to have kids with significant health needs and how hard it is to find and afford the help that they need. The challenge is real. Everything I have lived has led to public service, both personally and professionally, doing my part to eliminate inequities, standing up against systems that perpetuate racial injustice, and taking responsibility for my own power and knowledge and impact. It's why I've spent more than 20 years in public and health education and why I'm now finishing my coursework to become a counselor for children and families. I serve on the allocation committee as a volunteer. My time is my most valuable asset, and I give it to the children's levy because no family should have to do this alone. The levy is a families across Portland told us what matters to them, and I believe my job as a volunteer is to listen with humility, act with integrity, and to carry their voices into every decision by investing in programs that offer resources and that are tailored to what communities need. Councilmember Herbold. Need. Portland families are strong and resourceful, and they deserve programs, systems, and leadership that work as hard as they do. It would be my honor to continue this work for a second term. Thank you.

**Dan Ryan** [1:31:07]

Thank you so much, Charity. Uh, is there any testimony?

**Keelan McClymont** [1:31:13]

No one signed up.

**Dan Ryan** [1:31:14]

Okay, great. Colleagues, any questions of the renewal of Charity Kreider to serve on the Portland Children's Thank you, Councilor Wright.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:31:30]

Um, my question is also for staff on, on this. I think, um, thank you for covering all the qualifications, and you seem very qualified, plus you've been there, so thank you for your service, Charity. Um, but for staff, I did want to ask, was this— is the normal process for this one— um, I had context for the last one, so I don't have it for this one— is the normal process when there's a potential reappointment to evaluate the, um, the potential reappointee in a vacuum, or do you also do a recruitment?

**Meg McElroy** [1:31:56]

We do not do a recruitment typically. We, um, if the appointee is interested in continuing their service, then we work with them to continue serving.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:32:07]

Okay, great. Thank you. Yep.

**Dan Ryan** [1:32:09]

Thank you, Chair Kanal. Anyone else? Okay, can I get a motion So moved. Thank you. Councilor Smith, second? Second. Give it to Dunphy, uh, President Dunphy. Please call the roll.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:32:24]

Green.

**Mitch Green** [1:32:25]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:32:26]

Avalos.

**Candace Avalos** [1:32:28]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:32:29]

Dunphy.

**Dan Ryan** [1:32:30]

Thanks for your service to our kids.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:32:31]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:32:32]

Smith.

**Loretta Smith** [1:32:33]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:32:34]

Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [1:32:35]

Aye.

**Dan Ryan** [1:32:35]

It's an honor to serve with you, Charity. Aye.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:32:45]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:32:46]

Motion to refer the report document number 2026-340 to City Council with the recommendation it be accepted is approved with a vote of 9 ayes and 3 absent.

**Dan Ryan** [1:32:57]

Thank you.

### 6. Appoint Charles Freeborn to the Noise Review Board for a term to expire December 1, 2029 (Report)

**Dan Ryan** [1:32:58]

Can you please read item 6?

**Keelan McClymont** [1:33:02]

Document 2026-398, appoint Charles Freeborn to the Noise Review Board for a term Welcome.

**Dan Ryan** [1:33:14]

Got Eric and Beth. Welcome. All right, floor is yours. Thank you for your patience today.

**Eric Murfitt** [1:33:25]

Yeah, of course. Good afternoon, council members. My name is Eric Murfitt, Director of Portland Permitting and Development. I'm joined today by Beth Bitten, our Property Compliance Division Manager and Noise Review Board Liaison. Liaison, and Charles Freeborn, whom we're recommending for appointment to the Noise Review Board for his first 3-year term. I'll now turn it over to Beth Benton to walk you through the appointment.

**Beth Benton** [1:33:48]

Good afternoon, Council. Um, I'd like to begin with a quick overview of the Noise Review Board.

**Dan Ryan** [1:33:57]

The new Noise Review Board— I didn't mention it, but we, we can go till a quarter, 15 minutes over. We can go to 12:45. I just wanted to give you that so we can get through the item. Okay, thanks. I will go quickly.

**Beth Benton** [1:34:07]

Um, the Noise Review Board was established in 1987. They meet monthly to advise on noise-related issues and approve high-impact noise variances. It's also one of the few quasi-judicial bodies in the city. Um, it has 5 members: 3 community-at-large positions, 1 representative of construction, and 1 from the field of Next slide, please. Here's a list of the current board members. Michael Dilts, his term ended in September, and Charles Freeborn will be replacing that community-at-large seat. And again, they can be— they serve 3-year terms, and they can be reappointed for a second term. Next slide, please. Charles Freeborn, throughout Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Councilor Tiffany Koyama Lane. Throughout his career in woodworking and construction, his love of music, auto racing, Mr. Freeborn has been on both sides of the noise debate, and he understands the impact noise can have on neighboring properties. From 2021 to 2025, he has volunteered his time, first serving on the Noise Review Board's PIR subcommittee studying the impacts from Portland International Raceway, and next serving on the Noise Advisory Workgroup formed to recommend improvements for amending Title 18. Mr. Freeborn looks forward to being part of the process, recommending meaningful and realistic regulations to minimize impacts on neighborhoods while promoting business and recreation opportunities that make our city vibrant. Next slide. If this appointment is approved, Mr. Freeborn's first term would run from December 2nd, 2026 to December And with this appointment, the Noise Review Board membership will have all seats filled. We appreciate your support in recommending this appointment move forward to full council for confirmation. Next slide. And this concludes our presentation. Happy to answer any questions.

**Dan Ryan** [1:36:05]

Thank you. Yes, um, we have some hands up, so starting with Chair Kanal.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:36:11]

Thank you, uh, Vice Chair Ryan. Charles, thank you for being here and your willingness to serve. I wanted to ask you, and this relates to the last item on the slide with your bio, you know, if there are— if there are— I really like the idea of pursuing relationships and trying to dig deep on issues. My question for you is, are there hypothetical issues or potential issues that might come Yes. Before the noise review board where you would be a hard yes or a hard no? Or is it let's always try to make something work? Are there— I guess really more, is there a hard no? Are there types of potential activities which create a noise concern where the answer is not to try to get to yes, or it's simply to say this is not going to work? And I'm trying to understand how you think about issues.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:37:09]

Um, I'm inclined to say that there is never a hard no. As a problem solver, both professionally and personally, I'm always looking for a way to come up with some sort of an accord that works or gives something to both sides of every argument or discussion. Thank you.

**Dan Ryan** [1:37:30]

Okay, uh, Councilor Dunphy.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:37:32]

Thank you very much. Uh, thank you for your well I'm excited by the fact that you have both specific construction experience, woodworking experience, and music experience.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:37:42]

Those are all very loud things.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:37:44]

I'm interested to know, I guess, some of your thoughts about, you know, you were on the Title 18 Noise Advisory Group. I've been critical that our noise— Title 18 is based around how loud a jackhammer can be at 2 in the morning or 2 in the afternoon and not how loud a drum kit can be at 10 at night. If I'm successful, your job is going to be harder on this board because I I want a lot of noise emission in this city. Can you tell me sort of where you see, having been in that workgroup, where you see the future of noise regulation going in this city and where— how you think that the city should be reacting to that?

**Unidentified speaker** [1:38:16]

Well, I believe that it is clearly a complex issue. There's a lot of variables to not only the way that noise is made, but the way it's measured and also the way it's And there are new technologies that are emerging that I'm hoping that we can bring all of those factors to the table to address them all. And I'm willing and open to listen to pretty much all the sides of those arguments.

**Dan Ryan** [1:38:43]

Great. Excellent. Thanks. Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [1:38:50]

Thank you, Councilor Ryan, and thank you for stepping up and being willing to serve. Thank you. On the Noise Board, you are helping to enforce the code, but I'd like to ask you a question about the current code because you have been a part of the process to overhaul it, and I'm guessing you're more familiar with it than another appointee might be. And I'm wondering if you think the code is currently serving our neighborhoods in 2 cases, and if not, Councilor McClymont, as a board member, whether you see your role as somebody who would stand up and bring forward recommendations or raise those concerns, or if you see your role just as enforcement. The first is an area that you have some experience with, the neighborhoods surrounding PIR, and the second is spaces where there are what I might call intermittent noises. So in our industrial residential interfaces, for example, where you get periodic loud noises but not the sustained noise of, say, a concert or a construction site. And I wonder if you think our code right now is serving residents in those cases, and if you— whether or not you think it currently is, if you start to see patterns where the code might not be working, how you would handle that. I think it's working well.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:40:16]

I would in all likelihood refer back to Beth and the other experts in the field. I have tremendous respect for the work they've done. Paul Van Orden has been a tremendous asset, is a tremendous asset to the city, and I would want to fully understand the issues first before I were to impart any sort of an opinion of my own onto it all. Councilmember Herbold? So my first step in it all is to first understand the questions being asked, and then with as broad and open of a, of a, um, of an attitude towards it, then I would move forward with my opinion on that same subject. And if you were seeing patterns where you thought perhaps our code isn't, um, isn't meeting the need, would you raise those concerns to Absolutely, absolutely. And we would then circle back and see if we can't either interpret the code to better serve the public, or if necessary, go back to the, to the formation of the code and see if it needs to be revised.

**Dan Ryan** [1:41:23]

Thank you. Thank you. No more colleagues for— oh wait, Chair Kanal, your hand's up.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:41:28]

Yeah, I just wanted to ask about If you have any, uh, relationship with any of the potential, um, folks that might be applying for noise review, specifically around delivery services of any variety.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:41:52]

Uh, no, I'm— I, um, I, I am not employed by any of the of the entities with whom I— some of which I volunteer for, but no, I don't have any material involvement. And I'm not sure exactly what you're referring to with the delivery services.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:42:12]

Companies whose job it is to move goods from a warehouse or other type of storage facility to an end user or customer.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:42:21]

I have no material involvement with any of those types of organizations, no.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:42:25]

Thanks for clarifying.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:42:26]

Absolutely.

**Dan Ryan** [1:42:28]

Thank you, colleagues. I don't see anyone else in the queue. Would anyone get a motion? So moved. Moved by Councilor Smith. Second? Second. Second by Councilor Novick. Please, uh, read the roll. Call, call the vote.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:42:45]

Green. Aye. Avalos. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

**Dan Ryan** [1:43:01]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [1:43:06]

Uh, the motion to refer report document 2026-398 to council with the recommendation it be accepted is approved with a vote of 9 ayes and 3 Thank you, Keelan.

**Dan Ryan** [1:43:19]

Thank you, colleagues, for your patience today. We went— we got through a lot of materials, we heard a lot of testimony. Our next meeting in the committee hall is Wednesday, November 18th, and we will, um, look at the River Community Advisory appointments, PSAP appointments, and we will bring back the conversation about the future of downtown Portland. It's just getting started. Thank you, colleagues. The meeting's adjourned. Thank you.
