---
title: "Portland City Council PM Session 11/12/26"
date: 2026-11-12T13:56:00-08:00
durationMinutes: 195
videoUrl: "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQcDptKVWgE"
---

# Portland City Council PM Session 11/12/26

**The Portland City Council gave final approval to two ordinances regulating the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub, including a new code chapter to reduce the hub's fuel storage by 2036, each by a 10-0 vote ([00:38:49](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=2329)).**

Council President Jamie Dunphy (District 1) presided. Councilors Olivia Clark and Eric Zimmerman (both District 4) were absent.

## Fuel hub rules pass

The companion policy ordinance amending zoning and building codes also passed **10-0** ([00:37:53](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=2273)). Dunphy read a statement from Clark, who said she had secured budget funding for the work and that "this package before us is just a start." Councilor Sameer Kanal (District 2) said "having 90% of this entire state's liquid fuel supply on one site in a liquefaction zone is and has always been dumb" ([00:32:33](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=1953)). Councilor Elana Pirtle-Guiney (District 2) said "This legislation is not a panacea." Councilor Steve Novick (District 3) urged regular check-ins with the state Department of Environmental Quality.

## Technical workers' contract approved amid strike

The council ratified a contract with the Professional & Technical Employees, Local 17 (PROTEC17), **10-0** ([02:24:09](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=8649)). City negotiator Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie said it costs roughly **$39.5 million over 3 years**, "a skosh higher than our budget authority," with a retroactive 3% cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) from July 1, 2026 ([01:53:12](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=6792)).

Union representative Rachel Whiteside called the talks "unnecessarily drawn out" and said a strike "results in what I see as a colossal waste of public money" ([01:58:58](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=7138)). Two testifiers backed ratification; James O'Laughlen of LIUNA 483 said COLAs "were delayed by more than a year." Councilor Angelita Morillo (District 3) noted "800 CPBW workers on strike" from the City of Portland Professional Workers ([02:09:07](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=7747)). Pirtle-Guiney said she had not seen a contract settled before the previous one expired, and Councilor Mitch Green (District 4) told administrators, "you need the resources, just come to us."

A second contract, with the Portland Fire Fighters' Association's Community Health unit, was pulled. Gwarki-Maddie said members did not ratify it: "In my 20, almost 22 years with the city, I don't recall that this has happened" ([02:25:06](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=8706)).

## Clash over points of order

As Morillo spoke, Councilor Loretta Smith (District 1) said "Point of order, Mr. President. Are we talking about—" ([02:10:33](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=7833)). Dunphy ruled: "We are discussing the Pro-Tech, but I find her comments to be germane." Morillo replied, "But I don't need your approval to continue speaking, Councilor Smith. Stop interrupting me" ([02:11:01](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=7861)). Smith answered, "Mr. President, quit calling my name" ([02:11:21](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=7881)). Councilor Candace Avalos (District 1) later said "points of orders are not for interrupting colleagues you disagree with" and "I'm sick of the disrespect, and I demand a real point of order, which is decorum" ([02:21:54](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=8514)).

On the next item, Smith asked City Attorney Robert Taylor to explain the rule, saying "when I said point of order, they kept talking." Taylor said "when the president calls a member to order, they must immediately stop" ([02:32:49](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=9169)). Morillo asked whether there "can be repeated patterns of obstruction and intimidation" ([02:34:33](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=9273)); Dunphy responded, "I'm not recognizing anybody in the queue at this moment" ([02:34:37](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=9277)).

## Habitat land transfer approved after consent snag

Smith's "No" sank the routine consent agenda ([00:41:18](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=2478)); Taylor said it requires "the unanimous vote of all councilors present and of not less than 9" ([00:44:21](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=2661)). Smith moved to reconsider, pulled the Habitat for Humanity item, and the remainder, a budget-season schedule change, was approved without debate ([00:48:40](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=2920)). Dunphy apologized to public commenter Lacey Sutton for "misinformation" about who may pull consent items; any member of the public can.

Smith said she supports the 22 family-sized homes but objected that the Housing Bureau paid the Water Bureau **$225,110** in 2023 with no current appraisal public ([02:54:28](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=10468)). Deputy City Administrator Donnie Oliveira said, "I don't believe we would go back for another appraisal" ([03:11:04](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=11464)). Housing Bureau manager Tanya Wolfersberger said a Water Bureau appraisal set the $225,000 price and that the homes will be limited to 80% of area median income and below, with 99-year affordability. The transfer passed **10-0** ([03:14:54](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=11694)).

## SW Jackson Street renamed for Rose Hill

The council renamed SW Jackson Street between Fifth and Park avenues SW Rose Hill Street, after Itway Rose Hill, who advocated for Portland State University's Native American Student and Community Center. Councilor Dan Ryan (District 2) added an emergency clause, as Downtown Neighborhood Association President LaJune Thorson requested so elders could witness the vote; it passed 10-0 ([01:33:24](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=5604)), as did the ordinance ([01:36:19](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=5779)). All eight testifiers supported it; Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk told councilors "I noticed every single one of you looking at your computer" ([01:18:45](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=4725)).

## Rules overhaul continued

Pirtle-Guiney's amendment requiring items be referred to committees with matching subject jurisdiction failed **7-3** ([02:52:02](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=10322)). Kanal called it "a solution in search of a problem"; Avalos called it "unnecessarily pedantic." The roll was garbled; Green, Avalos and Smith voted no, and the city's published agenda lists Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan and Novick as the ayes.

## Other actions

- Central City zoning changes passed 10-0 ([00:40:00](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=2400)).
- Bureau of Transportation code changes passed 9-1 ([00:49:50](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=2990)); the roll is garbled, but the "No" falls in Pirtle-Guiney's slot and the published agenda lists her as the nay.
- Two surplus transportation parcels were approved 10-0; staff estimated one site at "probably around $125,000" ([00:50:47](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=3047)).

## Public comment and updates

Three people spoke. Addie Smith criticized Home Forward board appointments and said Oregon Black unemployment "is over 9%." Rob Martineau of AFSCME Local 189 backed the strikers and said the city "has benefited 2.5% over real inflation" over workers in his 26 years ([00:16:15](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=975)). Sutton opposed the Habitat transfer over balcony railings at her Habitat home.

City Administrator Raymond C. Lee introduced Deputy City Administrator Dr. Joel F. Fitzgerald Sr. and reported 11 immigration detentions last week ([00:23:27](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-12-1?t=1407)). Taylor said a recent Ninth Circuit tear gas ruling "does not apply to us."

## What's next

- A Multnomah County Circuit Court hearing on the city's violation notice against the ICE facility owner is November 20.
- Negotiators aim to resume Community Health talks as soon as next week.
- The rules ordinance returns at a future meeting; Dunphy referenced November 18.
- Oliveira agreed to provide Kanal information on the Habitat transfer's terms.

---

## Agenda Approval

**Jamie Dunphy** [9:34]

Good afternoon. I am calling to order this meeting of the Portland City Council. It is 2:05 on Thursday, November 12th. Rebecca, can we please call the roll?

**Rebecca Dobert** [9:47]

Clerk. Green.

**Mitch Green** [9:49]

Here.

**Rebecca Dobert** [9:50]

Zimmerman. Avalos. Uh, Smith.

**Candace Avalos** [9:58]

Here.

**Rebecca Dobert** [9:59]

Kanal.

**Sameer Kanal** [10:00]

Here.

**Rebecca Dobert** [10:01]

Pirtle-Guiney. Ryan. Oh, is that Councilor Avalos?

**Dan Ryan** [10:11]

Yes.

**Unidentified speaker** [10:12]

Yeah.

**Jamie Dunphy** [10:12]

Thanks.

**Rebecca Dobert** [10:14]

Have you present? Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [10:16]

Here.

**Cynthia Castro** [10:17]

Nice.

**Rebecca Dobert** [10:18]

Ryan.

**Dan Ryan** [10:19]

Here.

**Rebecca Dobert** [10:20]

Koyama Lane.

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [10:21]

Here.

**Rebecca Dobert** [10:23]

Murillo.

**Angelita Morillo** [10:23]

Here.

**Rebecca Dobert** [10:24]

Novick.

**Steve Novick** [10:27]

Here.

**Candace Avalos** [10:28]

Here.

**Rob Martineau** [10:29]

And can we—.

**Jamie Dunphy** [10:30]

Could our attorney please read the rules of decorum for the chamber?

**Nancy Thorington** [10:33]

Good afternoon. Welcome to the Portland City Council. To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda. Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage. Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the providing— presiding officer states otherwise. Your microphone will be muted when your time is over. The presiding officer preserves order. Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed. If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given. Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting. Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass. Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually. Your testimony should address the matter being considered. When testifying, state your name for the record. Your address is not necessary. If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent. Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [11:38]

Thank you very much. Colleagues, first I would like to notify everybody that the PFFA Community Health CBA has been referred back to the mayor's office for further work and has therefore been pulled from our agenda. City Administrator Lee, is there anything else to share on that subject?

**Raymond C. Lee** [11:54]

Not at this time.

**Jamie Dunphy** [11:55]

Okay, thank you very much. So colleagues, our first item is always approval of the agenda, noting that we are pulling that item back. Are there any requests to amend the agenda, reorder items, or reschedule an item to a future meeting? Seeing no one excitedly—.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [12:09]

Charge your iPhone first.

**Jamie Dunphy** [12:10]

I do not. Do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda? The agenda is approved. Thank you very much. Can we please move to public communications?

**Rebecca Dobert** [12:22]

First, we have Addie Smith.

## Public Communications

### 2. Public comment

**Addie Smith** [12:35]

Good afternoon. My name is—. Today is November 12th, 2026. I'm speaking before the Portland City Council congratulations to Mitch Green, Angelita Morillo, and Tiffany Koyama Lane. Please keep in mind that transplants also voted for you. Congratulations to Governor Kotek on her reelection. The clemency papers for Brian Hakim Simpson have been on your desk for over 2 years now. Why haven't you signed them? We are waiting. If you are an attorney who handles tort claims, please DM me. Please provide your firm's website and/or name and contact information. To the House Democrats in the Oregon State Legislature, we do not support Julie Fahey for Speaker. We support State Rep Thuy Tran of Portland. The Portland City Council had an opportunity to put qualified, educated, informed commissioners on Home Forward's board. Instead, they unanimously voted to put 2 racist white men, one of whom is a former slumlord, on the board. This includes those in Districts 3 and 4 who were running for reelection and won. If talking out of both sides of your mouth was a person, it would be them. These rental ripoff town hall events are just meaningless fluff. These city council members are literally putting slumlords on the board. These city council members and Portland's mayor have put people on the board who will help keep Home Forward's secrets. Ian Davies should be fired. Michael Bonaccore should be fired and never should have been allowed to return. Thank you. Even on this contractual basis. Matthew Gebhardt, Damian Hall, Jenny Kim, Kathy Keithley, Jesse Ledezma, and Brianne Preston should all be removed as board commissioners at Home Forward. They don't want anyone to be on the board or even employed at Home Forward who will point out that what they're doing is wrong, very likely illegal, violates state and federal law, and violates— and violates the bylaws. The entire board should be replaced and investigated. Second. Oregon's Black unemployment is over 9%. That is intentional. Portland State University went into their system and canceled the financial aid of a Black student. She was a witness for the defense in a criminal case. Portland State University just received a 5-year grant from the university— from the U.S. Department of Education's Strengthening Institutions Program for nearly $3 million to improve outcomes and address barriers that trip up undergraduate students. That money should not be given to the university. Thank you. The university, its president, trustees, and staff are anti-Black and racist. They intimidated that student and took her financial aid. They retaliated against that student because she was a witness in a case wherein their own campus police told the grand jury they had no intentions of investigating the case. Portland State University should lose its accreditation. President Ann Cudd, Interim Chief Kevin Modica, Officer Haley Wright-Salinas, and other staff at the university should be terminated. Racism is alive and thriving in Portland, and they are working very hard to, to keep their violations a secret. But I'm working harder. Your backdoor deals and closed-door meetings and signal emails are causing Black people harm. There are Black people helping white racists cause harm to Black people, and they're doing it to keep their, their lifestyle. And I'm going to name names. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [15:49]

Thank you very much.

**Rebecca Dobert** [15:52]

Irina Owens. Rob Martineau.

**Wendy Cully** [16:04]

Welcome.

**Rob Martineau** [16:08]

Thank you. 5 minutes, is it?

**Jamie Dunphy** [16:12]

Uh, 3 minutes.

**Mitch Green** [16:13]

3 minutes.

**Dan Ryan** [16:14]

Okay, great.

**Rob Martineau** [16:15]

My name is Rob Martineau. I am a city employee for the last 26 years and a designated Representative of AFSCME Local 189. I'm here today to talk a little bit about my observations in labor relations and somewhat in the context of the current strike and the work that is being struck in the City of Portland by one of your unions, the City of Portland Professional Workers. I support their effort for a fair contract. I don't have the answers of what switches need to be flipped, what needs to be increased or decreased, or how you all will be able to find the, the right solution that will open the door for this. But I I know we need to find people that can be at the table and, and know when the deal is there. The Art of the Deal wasn't just a cheesy book by a failed politician. The Art of the Deal is a turn of phrase that means a whole lot when you get to the end of days on a contract. When you reach the end of the PECBAS system, the art of those negotiations is critical. And it's not always clear that there are people in the room that know when the deal is there or know what needs to happen or be shifted to get there. Thank you. That's something that I would love for this council to be able to take a look at as part of a broader systematic change to how we do business. When I started in March of 2000, I entered a 6,000-hour apprenticeship. About 15 months into that, I was told I'd be losing my job because of the budget in— at that time, so mid-2001. Thank you. But for the suicide of a coworker, I probably would not be here today. I was scheduled to be laid off, and it was, uh, it was not lost on me that, that when they won't— no one will technically say, yes, this was the reason, but there were both managers and my own representative folks who said, boy, you caught a lucky one, didn't you? And I thought, that's an absurd, absurd thing to carry, you know, as I'm, as I'm trying to get through a 6,000-hour apprenticeship to be a crew leader and, and this council used to hold great sway in what happened in labor relation negotiations under its commissioner form of government. It no longer does. You get to— I don't mean this disrespectfully, but rubber stamp a contract that's been inked by your parties, by the union and by your representatives in the administration. I think that's a little bit of a stretch. This became a broken system. Portland changed its form of government, but that system did not. It has become and continues to be more and more problematic, and you're the council that sits in the void as labor screams into it. I would encourage you to develop a system that reflects Portland's values and this council's values as a city and this council as an employer.

## Council President Update

### 3. Federal response update

**Rob Martineau** [19:13]

I would like to spend some time and talk about COLA. This is something that has been apparent the city or the administration is a fight they're willing to pick, and I think there needs to be a longer conversation. The city, over my time in 26 years, has benefited 2.5% over real inflation over what these employees have gotten. This has not been a windfall. This has been how we do not slip or drift into poverty. I appreciate the extra time. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [19:41]

Thank you very much.

**Rebecca Dobert** [19:44]

Lacey Sutton.

**Loretta Smith** [19:45]

Welcome.

**Lacey Sutton** [19:50]

Hello, I'm Lacey Sutton. Um, I will admit I did not think I would be allowed to testify today. I came to just witness the consent agenda today. I was really disappointed that, um, the conveyance of property to Habitat for Humanity was not something that was going to be discussed by the full council, and there were really limited opportunities for public feedback. So moving forward, I feel like public land, um, any discussion surrounding this really should be something that— where more public input is allowed. That said, I did send you all a letter today, and I'm just going to read that. Thank you. Um, so I was— yeah, I was disappointed to see this item on the consent agenda today, meaning you will not be discussing it nor hearing public testimony. Unfortunately, I missed the ordinance when it was presented at the City Life Committee last month, or I would have testified there. You've heard me speak before, so it should, uh, should come as no surprise to you why I oppose yet another conveyance of city-owned property to Habitat for Humanity, especially as there have been so few opportunities for public input and no full council discussion. This public land is only about a mile from Cherry Blossom, which Habitat will readily remind you passed inspections. Yet since I began filing complaints and testifying about the numerous code violations and construction defects on our property, they have repeatedly returned years outside any warranty period to remedy them. Um, sorry, I'm going to skip a little bit of this. You've heard it before. Uh, most recently, Habitat paid thousands of dollars to cut down a tree that just days prior I publicly accused them of butchering during construction. The tree the DCA, Donnie Oliveira, told you was fine, they cut it down because they, they knew what they did. They knew what they did. Today I'm asking you to please stipulate the replacement of our horizontal balcony railings, which children climb like ladders, prior to the conveyance of this property. This should be fairly straightforward as 2-inch vertical railings were already made a condition of approval by the Design Commission in 2017. Despite what former PP&D Director Kuhnhausen told you, Habitat did not amend this condition in the Type 2 review they received in 2020, which cited only minor changes to the previous approval. The railings were not even mentioned. Last year, Mr. Kuenhassen's executive assistant informed me that he had met with Habitat CEO Steve Massanetti last year and discussed— or sorry, issued Habitat directives to replace the railings. But after KOIN News aired this story, PP&D changed its mind. I wrote to staff every day for months asking for an explanation and did not receive a single response. And for the record, this occurred well before I filed my tort claim notice. They were just ignoring me for months. So today I'm asking you to do what PP&D has so far failed to do and require Habitat for Humanity to meet this condition of approval for the use of our land before you hand them any more. And while the fire chief is here, why don't you ask her why they approved our development without a fire access? You know, I have been asking that question for several years and I still have not received an answer.

**Solen Hering** [23:00]

Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [23:02]

Thank you very much.

**Rebecca Dobert** [23:04]

Uh, I just want to note that registered testifiers David Gwyther, Rose Collins, and Laura Labarre canceled their testimony. That concludes testimony.

**Jamie Dunphy** [23:14]

Thank you very much. Thanks, everybody. Next item on our agenda is the President's Update. City Administrator Lee, I'd like to recognize you to give a brief introduction of your new DCA for Public Safety, Dr. Joel Fitzgerald Sr.

**Raymond C. Lee** [23:27]

Thank you. I will start with that introduction. I'm pleased to officially welcome Dr. Joel F. Fitzgerald Sr. as Portland's new Deputy City Administrator over Public Safety. DCA Fitzgerald brings more than 30 years of experience leading major public safety agencies, regional public safety systems, and emergency management operations. His career includes serving as Chief of Police in Missouri City, Allentown, and Fort Worth, Texas, where he oversaw more than 2,200 employees and advanced nationally recognized reforms focused on community trust, procedural justice, and organization modernization. He later held senior roles with the Philadelphia Sheriff's Office, the Waterloo, Iowa Police Department, and the Regional Transportation District in Colorado, where he led complex multi- as you get a chance, please welcome DCA Fitzgerald to Portland and wish him success as he takes on this very important role for the city. I also want to share this week's federal response update. I will share that PERC reported 11 detentions last week, including 5 during ICE and Border Patrol operations. Thank you. Yes. Advocates emphasize that the vast majority of people attending appointments have not been detained. Of the 270 people who've had appointments and spoke with PERC last week, around 2% were detained. Still, advocates strongly encourage anyone with an upcoming ICE appointment to connect with the support teams outside the Portland ICE Processing Facility for information. Guidance and assistance. I will also turn it over to Robert to talk about any additional updates in on the facility.

**Robert Taylor** [25:33]

Hello, Council. Uh, Robert Taylor, City Attorney. Um, I will tell you that the hearing is still scheduled for November 20th on the appeal on the notice of violation. Just for the benefit of the public who might be listening, I know council is aware of this, but just for the benefit of the public who might be listening, the city issued a notice of violation in September of 2025 against the owner of the ice facility, finding that they were in violation of their conditional use approval. Thank you. That was appealed to the hearings officer, and a hearing was held in May of 2026. The hearings officer found in favor of the city and upheld the notice of violation. That decision was issued in July. The hearings officer's decision has been appealed to the Multnomah County Circuit Court. The Circuit Court has issued a stay pending this appeal. Thank you. While that stay is in place, the city cannot take any enforcement action. You will recall that at one point the stay was so broad that it even stopped the hearings officer from issuing a decision. We were successful in having that portion lifted so the hearings officer could issue the decision. The circuit court hearing is scheduled for the 20th of November, so next week. Thank you. And we will keep you posted as that progresses.

**Jamie Dunphy** [27:12]

Thank you very much. Thank you all very much. Welcome, DCA Fitzgerald. And thank you, City Administrator, for those updates. Thank you, City Attorney, for the updates. Can we please move now to our first time-certain item? Oh, Councilor Knoll, I'm sorry, I didn't see you there.

**Sameer Kanal** [27:30]

Yeah, thank you, Council President. I was hoping that since we're discussing federal activity, if we could hear anything about the 9th Circuit Court's tear gas ruling. I'm not sure if there's an update from either on how that affects the city, but the 9th Circuit Court has issued a ruling saying that they have that there is no longer a limit on tear gas usage.

**Jamie Dunphy** [28:05]

So, City Attorney's welcome back up.

**Robert Taylor** [28:13]

Uh, thank you. Uh, Robert Taylor, City Attorney, again. Uh, that, that is the Dickinson case. You'll recall that was a case filed related to the federal government's use of tear gas outside the ICE facility last year, last summer and fall. And the, the plaintiffs in that case were residents of Portland, and they were successful in getting an injunction from the district court against the use of tear gas. That was appealed by the federal government to the Ninth Circuit, and the Ninth Circuit, uh, overturned that lower court decision. So that injunction is no longer in place. So that's the, the issue there.

**Loretta Smith** [29:05]

Thank you.

**Sameer Kanal** [29:10]

Courts are going to be those who save us all this, but we have to deal with it ourselves. Thanks.

**Jamie Dunphy** [29:16]

Thank you, Councilor Colonel. Councilor Smith.

**Loretta Smith** [29:19]

Thank you, Council President. Um, thank you, uh, Attorney Robert. Um, does that have any impact on us, that circuit, the 9th Circuit Court, uh, ruling yesterday?

**Robert Taylor** [29:30]

Uh, that, that was a— well, in all litigation, it's specific to the, the facts and the parties involved. Uh, that had to do with, um, Whether the plaintiffs in that case could make a claim against the federal government for their use of tear gas and the impact it had on them. It does not apply to us. We were not parties to that case. In fact, members of the police bureau, Franz Schoening, who has appeared before you recently, he was a witness in that case in favor of the plaintiffs and the residents. Testified about the federal government's use of tear gas and how that was not in line with what we would do as an agency, but we were not a party to that, so it doesn't have an impact on us in that sense.

**Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk** [30:21]

No.

**Loretta Smith** [30:22]

Okay, perfect. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [30:27]

Okay, thank you again, Mr. City Attorney. Now, Rebecca, can we please call item 4, document 2026-311?

**Rebecca Dobert** [30:37]

Item 4, adopt the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Policy Project to support public health and natural hazards risk reduction, amend Code Titles 33 and 24, document number 2026-311.

**Jamie Dunphy** [30:50]

Thank you very much, colleagues. This is—.

## Time Certain

### 4. Adopt the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Policy Project (2026-311)

**Jamie Dunphy** [30:51]

Today is the final vote on both legislative items related to the CEI Hub Project. Is there any more discussion before we take our vote? I am gonna put myself in the queue actually on behalf of Vice President Clark who is unable to be here today. I'm gonna read a couple of remarks regarding CEI. Again, Vice President Clark says, I wish I could have been here today to make this pivotal vote. I have long been advocating for safety measures at our CEI hub that both secure the tanks and reduce storage capacity. During the '25-'26 budget cycle, I secured the funding that added capacity at BPS to create these land use and zoning regulations for the hub that council is voting on today. These regulations are the result of significant public input with community members who are strong advocates for safety of our city more specifically, all who will be directly affected if there is a catastrophic event at the CEI hub. But we know that the impact is statewide, and this package before us is just a start. I, Councilor Clark, will continue to approach this issue with a sense of urgency by continuing my work to find more impactful policies to address safety concerns from our— for our community, especially those living in the direct impact area. So thank you, Councilor Clark.

**Rebecca Dobert** [32:00]

Thank you.

**Mitch Green** [32:01]

Thank you, Councilor President. I'll just be brief. I just want to say thanks again to staff and BPS for helping, you know, iterating with the community so much. I think it was really meaningful for them. And thanks for your partnership in that. We're not done. We have more work to do and we'll keep doing it. So thanks so much.

**Jamie Dunphy** [32:23]

Thank you, Councilor Green. Councilor Knoll. Oh, Councilor Knoll fell into the queue. Are you still wanting to?

**Sameer Kanal** [32:29]

I can go. I was just taking the hand down. Oh, perfect.

**Jamie Dunphy** [32:31]

Great. Okay. Councilor Knopf.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [32:33]

Yeah.

**Sameer Kanal** [32:33]

So I want to thank— thank you, Council President. I also want to thank all the community advocates who've been sounding the alarm for years about the risk that the CEI hub poses and calling on the city to do something about it. I think everything that came out of this, certainly the staff contributed so much by iterating, but ultimately the driving force behind the changes that were made were the advocates. And I want to thank them for their time, their unwavering dedication, and the audacious belief that the city can and should live up to our commitments and take bold action to end overreliance on fossil fuels and create a net-zero carbon future. We're able to do this because we have a new form of government that listens to community, that values expertise that exists outside of the city government, and practices intentional inclusion. I'll be voting aye because I believe today is an important step on the path towards a safer and more resilient Portland. Thank you. And I'm grateful to my colleagues who have worked really hard to strengthen this because it is better than what it was before. I also agree with Councilor Green that it's not enough still. A major earthquake would be catastrophic. It would ignite an environmental disaster on par with Deepwater Horizon. No amount of industry profit is worth that. We are human beings and living beings before we're consumers of fuel. The good news is that we can still work on this. We can still do something about it. We can make it so that the need for fuel exceeds what Portland is legally allowed to store, we can meaningfully draw down the amount of combustible, flammable, and toxic fuels stored on the site, not just the tank capacity. We can adequately fund our Emergency Management Bureau, now under the new leadership of a new DCA, so we're better prepared for everything that both folks on, on either side of the St. Johns Bridge will need to deal with in the event of an emergency. And we can create incentives to reduce demand for liquid fuels and advocate for regional transportation alternatives. Thank you. I stand by the statement that, that having 90% of this entire state's liquid fuel supply on one site in a liquefaction zone is and has always been dumb. And I look forward to continuing to work with community, industry, and the bureaus to keep North Portlanders safe and keep our city on track to meet climate goals. Thank you, Council President.

**Jamie Dunphy** [34:39]

Thank you, Councilor Kanal. Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [34:42]

Thank you, Council President. You know, we take a lot of votes up here, and many of them are meaningful, but rarely do we get to take an action that will thank you. This legislation will, years from now, have an impact that we can look out and predict. This sets us up for a long-term drawdown of fuel stored at what one emergency manager in our state called the worst possible place to store our city and our state's liquid fuel. This legislation is not a panacea. It will not solve all of the concerns that we have about safety or all of the work we need— or take on all the work we need to do to create a less carbon-intensive thank you. It's not a comprehensive solution to the future for our city and for our state, but it's a meaningful start. And it's a meaningful start because of a lot of people's hard work within our city bureaus, within advocacy communities, and the staff who work for many of us up here at this dais. I want to thank every single person who put that work in, and I want to remind us that the work we have left to do involves our state partners as well, because the real solution here is ultimately moving storage to a place that is not the least safe place in our state to store this fuel. I am immensely proud of the work that went into this and excited to see the next steps as they unfold. I know our bureau has a lot of work that this is setting them up to need to take on, and I appreciate every single person who is going to be taking that work on. And I hope that for my constituents in North Portland who have been waiting for someone to take this is seen as a first step, not a last step, but a really important one along the way. I am excited to vote yes today.

**Jamie Dunphy** [36:24]

Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. Councilor Novick.

**Steve Novick** [36:26]

Thank you, Mr. President. 2 Things. One, I hope that this council will periodically check in with DEQ on the progress of their requirements that the fossil fuel companies Uh, make modifications to their facilities to reduce, to reduce the risk. That's an important effort, and we should be keeping track of it and making sure and watchdogging it. Second, I want to thank my 7 colleagues who joined me in passing my amendment acknowledging that if we really want to reduce the amount of fuel in the CI hub, we should do our best to reduce the demand for liquid fuel, which includes investing more of the Portland Clean Energy Fund and alternative transportation methods, including transit and biking and walking and electric car infrastructure.

**Jamie Dunphy** [37:16]

Thank you, Councilor Novick. Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, Rebecca, can we please call the roll?

**Rebecca Dobert** [37:25]

Calling the roll on document number 2026-311. Clark absent.

**Mitch Green** [37:32]

Green Aye.

**Dan Ryan** [37:43]

Aye.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [37:45]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [37:46]

Aye.

**Raymond C. Lee** [37:47]

Aye.

**Candace Avalos** [37:49]

Aye.

**Raymond C. Lee** [37:50]

Aye.

**Candace Avalos** [37:51]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [37:52]

Aye.

**Raymond C. Lee** [37:52]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [37:53]

And the ordinance passes with 10 aye, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [37:57]

Thank you very much. Can we please call our next time-certain item? Item number 5, document 2026-312.

### 5. Add Bulk Fuel Terminal Capacity Reduction Regulations Code (2026-312)

**Rebecca Dobert** [38:04]

Item 5, add bulk fuel terminal capacity reduction regulations code to reduce critical energy infrastructure hub fuel storage by 2036 in support of hazard mitigation. Add code chapter 17.112.

**Jamie Dunphy** [38:17]

Hey colleagues, this is the second of our 2 items related to the CEI hub legislation. Is there any further discussion? Seeing none, Keelan— or Rebecca, it's Keelan in my own thing. I'm sorry, Rebecca. Rebecca, could we please call the roll?

**Rebecca Dobert** [38:33]

Aye.

**Tabitha Whitefoot** [38:37]

Aye.

**Sameer Kanal** [38:39]

Aye.

**Angelita Morillo** [38:41]

Aye.

**Ann Cudd** [38:42]

Aye.

**Solen Hering** [38:43]

Aye.

**Sameer Kanal** [38:44]

Aye.

**Candace Avalos** [38:45]

Aye.

**Modesta Minthorn** [38:47]

Aye.

**Steve Novick** [38:49]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [38:49]

And the ordinance passes 10 aye, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [38:53]

Can we please call our next time-certain item, document 2026-.

### 6. Amend Portland Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan Map for the Central City (2026-343)

**Rebecca Dobert** [38:59]

Item 6, amend the Portland Zoning Code, Portland Comprehensive Plan Map, and zoning maps to facilitate housing production and post-pandemic economic recovery and revitalization in the Central City. Amend Title 33, Portland Comprehensive Plan Map, official zoning maps.

**Jamie Dunphy** [39:17]

Colleagues, this is the final vote on the Central City Code Amendment Project. Is there any discussion before we move to a final vote? Seeing none, Rebecca, please call the roll.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:29]

Green?

**Mitch Green** [39:30]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:31]

Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [39:33]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:34]

Smith?

**Loretta Smith** [39:36]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:37]

Kanal?

**Sameer Kanal** [39:43]

Sorry, I was muted. Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:45]

Thank you. Kanal, aye. Pirtle-Guiney?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [39:50]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:50]

Ryan?

**Dan Ryan** [39:51]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:52]

Koyama Lane?

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [39:53]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:54]

Murillo?

**Angelita Morillo** [39:55]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:57]

Novick?

**Steve Novick** [39:57]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [39:58]

Dunphy?

**Jamie Dunphy** [39:59]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [40:00]

The ordinance passes 10 aye, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [40:02]

Thank you. Can we please move to the consent agenda?

**Rebecca Dobert** [40:09]

Uh, item 7, authorize conveyance of city-owned real property, former Menlo Park Water Tower site, to Habitat for Humanity Portland, Metro East, doing business as Habitat for Humanity Portland, Oregon, document number 2026-344.

## Consent Agenda

### 7. Amend Council schedule during FY 2027-28 budget process (2026-393)

**Rebecca Dobert** [40:25]

Item 8, amend council schedule during FY 2027-28 budget process to implement budget calendar, document number 2026-393.

**Jamie Dunphy** [40:36]

Can we, uh, can we please call the roll? Is there any—.

**Candace Avalos** [40:42]

Yeah.

**Jamie Dunphy** [40:43]

Do we need to call the roll on consent agenda?

**Rebecca Dobert** [40:46]

Do you have unanimous consent or—.

**Jamie Dunphy** [40:48]

I'm just— let's find out. Yeah, do we have unanimous consent on the consent agenda? Ah, that's easy enough. Yeah, look at that, we got unanimous consent.

**Rebecca Dobert** [40:56]

We can do a roll.

**Jamie Dunphy** [40:57]

Don't we normally do a roll on consent?

**Rebecca Dobert** [40:59]

We could do a roll call.

**Jamie Dunphy** [41:00]

Okay, cool.

**Rebecca Dobert** [41:03]

Clark, absent. Green?

**Mitch Green** [41:04]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [41:05]

Zimmerman?

**Eric Zimmerman** [41:06]

Absent.

**Rebecca Dobert** [41:07]

Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [41:07]

Aye.

**Loretta Smith** [41:18]

No.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [41:25]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [41:27]

Aye.

**Cynthia Castro** [41:30]

Aye.

**Angelita Morillo** [41:31]

Aye. Aye.

**Xavier Stickler** [41:38]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [41:38]

Uh, consent information.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [41:42]

Yeah, if somebody votes no on the consent agenda, are we still able to adopt it as a package, or do we need to vote on items separately?

**Jamie Dunphy** [41:50]

That's a great question. Is our city attorney here?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [41:57]

Sorry to raise a question that's difficult, but it It seems better to raise it than to just move on.

**Jamie Dunphy** [42:03]

Yeah, we're going to see if we can't get an answer for that.

**Nancy Thorington** [42:11]

Councilor Smith, did you want to pull an item from the consent agenda?

**Loretta Smith** [42:16]

No.

**Jamie Dunphy** [42:25]

Okay, okay. Okay, uh, Rebecca, Councilor Smith would like to change her vote. Uh, I understand. He said okay. Okay, well then I think we aren't able to— if with the no vote on the consent agenda, unless we're pulling an item from it, we can't— we have to have unanimous consent on it. And so we're trying to figure out what to do about that right now. So I see that you're okay with moving it forward, but we're having Robert Taylor coming down right now.

**Sameer Kanal** [43:02]

Yep.

**Jamie Dunphy** [43:05]

Right.

**Jeanette DeCastro** [43:06]

And—.

**Jamie Dunphy** [43:07]

Well, and I think broadly, Councilor Kanal, I see your hand.

**Sameer Kanal** [43:16]

Yeah, I'm, I'm gonna, uh, unless, uh, Robert Taylor says we don't need to do this, I'm going to move to reconsider the items and so that we can, uh, pull things off and do it separately as needed.

**Jamie Dunphy** [43:27]

Okay, we're gonna wait for Robert Taylor to come down here in just a second. He's on his way.

**Sameer Kanal** [43:31]

I'm pretty sure it's 3.02.030 G1B— sorry, G2, not G1B.

**Loretta Smith** [43:39]

Okay.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [43:41]

We have to vote on this.

**Jamie Dunphy** [43:46]

Yeah, I think essentially that means—.

**Nancy Thorington** [43:47]

So if Councilor Kanal has moved to reconsider it, then and then you can take the vote on the motion to reconsider.

**Jamie Dunphy** [43:53]

Great, let's do that. Let's take the vote on the motion to reconsider the consent agenda. Oh, hi, Robert. Look, they're your rules, Robert.

**Robert Taylor** [44:21]

Uh, so the, uh, Robert Taylor, City Attorney. Uh, the consent agenda requires the unanimous vote of all councilors present and of not less than 9 to pass the consent agenda. Uh, so you have failed to meet that requirement, so the consent agenda fails. Thank you. I think you can reconsider that vote, bring the consent agenda back in front of you, remove the item that is objectionable, and then pass the remainder of the consent agenda. I'm out of breath because I ran down here.

**Jamie Dunphy** [45:03]

I appreciate you, your dedicated commitment to public service. Thank you very much. Okay, so a motion to reconsider the vote has been moved. Does it need a second?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [45:16]

Second.

**Jamie Dunphy** [45:18]

Okay, um, let's go ahead and vote to reconsider. So the motion now before us, a yes vote, is that we will reopen the vote on the consent agenda. And is that right?

**Rebecca Dobert** [45:33]

Well, I—.

**Dan Ryan** [45:36]

The councilor just wants to pull one item.

**Candace Avalos** [45:38]

Yep.

**Jamie Dunphy** [45:39]

So we got to reconsider.

**Robert Taylor** [45:45]

Uh, the prevailing side for purposes of, uh, moving for reconsideration would be the person that prevented, prevented passage. So in this instance, it would be Councilor Smith would have the opportunity to move for reconsideration.

**Raymond C. Lee** [46:06]

Right.

**Loretta Smith** [46:07]

Okay.

**Sameer Kanal** [46:09]

I will withdraw my motion then.

**Raymond C. Lee** [46:11]

Okay.

**Jamie Dunphy** [46:11]

Councilor Kanal withdraws the motion to reconsider. Councilor Smith?

**Loretta Smith** [46:15]

What I'm trying to do is pull out, uh, consent agenda item 7.

**Jamie Dunphy** [46:21]

Okay. So, Councilor, if you move— if you make a motion to reconsider, then we can go to that.

**Sameer Kanal** [46:28]

So moved.

**Unidentified speaker** [46:30]

Okay.

**Loretta Smith** [46:31]

I make a motion to, uh, reconsider the consent agenda.

**Modesta Minthorn** [46:35]

Second.

**Jamie Dunphy** [46:36]

Okay, there we go. Now we have to vote on that. Rebecca, can you please call the roll on the motion to reconsider?

**Rebecca Dobert** [46:43]

Green?

**Mitch Green** [46:45]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [46:47]

Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [46:47]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [46:48]

I'm sorry, Councilor Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [46:53]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [46:53]

Thank you. Smith?

**Loretta Smith** [46:57]

Aye.

**Sameer Kanal** [46:58]

Aye.

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [47:00]

Aye.

**Olivia Clark** [47:01]

Aye.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [47:04]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [47:07]

Novick.

**Steve Novick** [47:07]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [47:08]

Dunphy.

**Jamie Dunphy** [47:09]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [47:10]

The motion to reconsider is approved.

**Jamie Dunphy** [47:12]

Okay, and now, uh, item 7, as per Councilor Smith's request, has been pulled off of the consent agenda and placed at the end of the agenda per our rules. Can we then move to a another vote on the remaining consent agenda item?

**Sameer Kanal** [47:26]

Okay.

**Jamie Dunphy** [47:26]

Can we please call the roll on the remainder of the consent agenda?

**Sameer Kanal** [47:29]

Council President?

**Jamie Dunphy** [47:30]

Councilor Powell.

**Sameer Kanal** [47:31]

I have a request, a request for information first.

**Rachel Whiteside** [47:33]

Yes.

**Sameer Kanal** [47:35]

Yeah, this came up in the, in the public communications as well. Any person can remove something? I, I just like a confirmation. Any person can remove something from the consent agenda, right? It does not have to be a councilor.

**Jamie Dunphy** [47:47]

That is correct.

**Sameer Kanal** [47:49]

So if a community member felt that something was on consent agenda that they wanted to be able to testify on, they could remove it?

**Unidentified speaker** [47:57]

Yes.

**Sameer Kanal** [47:57]

Thank you. Just wanted to get that on the record.

**Jamie Dunphy** [47:59]

Thank you. Okay, Rebecca, can we call the roll on the remainder of the consent agenda, item number 8?

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:09]

Green?

**Mitch Green** [48:11]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:12]

Avalos? I'm sorry, Councilor Avalos, was that an aye?

**Candace Avalos** [48:20]

Yes.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:21]

Thank you. Kanelle?

**Sameer Kanal** [48:25]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:26]

Pirtle-Guiney?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [48:28]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:28]

Ryan?

**Dan Ryan** [48:30]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:31]

Koyama Lane?

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [48:34]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:34]

Murillo?

**Angelita Morillo** [48:35]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:36]

Novick?

**Steve Novick** [48:37]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:38]

Dunphy?

**Jamie Dunphy** [48:38]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:40]

And the remainder of the consent agenda is approved.

**Jamie Dunphy** [48:43]

Great. Can we now move to item number 9, document 2026-387?

**Rebecca Dobert** [48:49]

9, Amend vehicles and traffic code to clarify Bureau of Transportation Authority and allow flexibility, replace Code Section 16.10.080, and amend Chapter 16.90.

## Regular Agenda

### 8. Amend Vehicles and Traffic Code to clarify Bureau of Transportation authority (2026-387)

**Jamie Dunphy** [49:02]

Thank you very much, colleagues. This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance. Is there any further discussion? Seeing no one in the queue, Rebecca, can we please call the roll on item number 9?

**Rebecca Dobert** [49:15]

Item 9, calling the roll. 2026-387. Clark absent. Green. Zimmerman absent. Avalos.

**Candace Avalos** [49:27]

Aye. Can you hear me?

**Rebecca Dobert** [49:28]

Yes, yes, thank you. Smith.

**Loretta Smith** [49:33]

Aye.

**Jamie Dunphy** [49:35]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [49:37]

No. Aye.

**Mitch Green** [49:40]

Aye.

**Rob Martineau** [49:46]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [49:47]

Novick?

**Steve Novick** [49:47]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [49:48]

Dunphy?

**Jamie Dunphy** [49:49]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [49:50]

The ordinance passes with 9 aye, 1 nay, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [49:53]

Thank you very much.

### 9. Declare two parcels of land as surplus property (2026-371)

**Jamie Dunphy** [49:54]

Can we please move to item 10, document 2026-371?

**Rebecca Dobert** [49:59]

Item 10, declare 2 parcels of land as surplus property and authorize the Bureau of Transportation to dispose of the property for fair market value. Uh, document number 2026-371.

**Jamie Dunphy** [50:11]

Thank you very much, colleagues. This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance. Is there any further discussion? Councilor Knoll.

**Sameer Kanal** [50:20]

Just wanted to, um, ask to follow up.

**Jamie Dunphy** [50:23]

Did we end up getting looking around the room to see if we have— hello, just a second.

**Raymond C. Lee** [50:40]

Welcome up.

**Tabitha Whitefoot** [50:42]

Thank you.

**Sameer Kanal** [50:44]

David McEldowney, Portland Bureau of Transportation.

**Donnie Oliveira** [50:47]

We haven't had an appraisal yet because we don't want to spend the the funds on that unless the council declares property as surplus. But generally, it's probably around $125,000 for that building site.

**Sameer Kanal** [51:03]

All right, thank you for clarifying, and thanks for being here, David.

**Jamie Dunphy** [51:07]

Thank you very much. Seeing no one else in the queue, colleagues, Rebecca, can we please call the roll?

**Rebecca Dobert** [51:18]

Calling the roll on document number 2026-371. Clark, absent. Green.

**Mitch Green** [51:24]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [51:26]

Zimmerman, absent. Avalos.

**Candace Avalos** [51:28]

Aye. And can you hear me better now?

**Rebecca Dobert** [51:30]

Yes, thank you, much better. Smith.

**Loretta Smith** [51:34]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [51:35]

Kanal.

**Sameer Kanal** [51:36]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [51:38]

Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [51:38]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [51:40]

Ryan.

**Dan Ryan** [51:40]

Aye.

**Steve Novick** [51:43]

Aye.

**Angelita Morillo** [51:45]

Aye.

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [51:47]

Aye.

**Jamie Dunphy** [51:49]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [51:50]

Ordinance passes with 10 aye, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [51:53]

Thank you very much. And can we please move to item number 11, document 2026-386?

### 10. Authorize renaming of SW Jackson St to SW Rose Hill St (2026-386)

**Rebecca Dobert** [52:01]

Authorize the renaming of Southwest Jackson Street between Southwest 5th Ave and Southwest Park Ave to colleagues, this is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

**Jamie Dunphy** [52:13]

This item first passed out of our City Council back in February but had to be delayed in order to go back through other land use processes outside of the city. We've brought it back directly to Council for final review. We have a brief presentation from our friends here at— hello— Cynthia Castro, PBOT Policy and Special Projects Analyst, and Cynthia Camino Gomez, PSC's Director of Local Government and Community Relations. Welcome, take it away.

**Wendy Cully** [52:41]

Great, thank you, and good afternoon, Council President Dunphy and council members. For the record, my name is Wendy Cully, PBOT Interim Director. It's my pleasure to be here today for the final step in a multi-year process to authorize the renaming of a portion of Southwest Jackson Street to Southwest Rose Hill Street. Our presentation today will provide a picture of the process and the work that has led us to this moment. I want to thank Portland State University President Ann Cudd, Cynthia Carmina Gomez, and all of the community members who have dedicated hours, days, months, and years into this effort. I also want to acknowledge my PBOT team who've spent a considerable amount of time on this since 2024, especially Cynthia Castro and Mariana Lamonto, as well as Anthony Butsek and Trong Vo. And finally, I want to thank you for allowing us to bring this final step directly to City Council rather than through a committee. PSU has already been through the City Council process twice during this journey, first in October 2024, and then again, as you mentioned, in February of this year. Today's moment is a follow-up from your February action, and we appreciate the streamlined process today. Thank you. I'll now turn it over to Cynthia Castro, who will kick off our presentation.

**Cynthia Castro** [54:02]

Thank you, Director Cully. For the record, my name is Cynthia Castro, and I serve as PBOT's Policy and Special Projects Analyst. I've been leading the process— or sorry, I've been the lead in processing PSU's Southwest Jackson Street renaming application and in fulfilling the city's administrative duties in accordance with Chapter 17.93. On the slide is the agenda for our presentation. We will start by grounding you in the street renaming proposal before you today. Because it's been a while since we last talked to you about this street renaming, we will provide you background again on the community-driven process to rename Southwest Jackson Street and the new street name honoree. We will conclude our presentation by discussing the city's street renaming process steps that were completed by both PSU and the city. Next slide. Council's approval of the ordinance that we brought forward to you today would authorize the renaming of Southwest Jackson Street Jackson Street between Southwest 5th and Southwest Park Avenues to Southwest Rose Hill Street, as proposed by Portland State University. Southwest Jackson Street is currently named after former U.S. President Andrew Jackson, who was known for his harsh treatment of Native Americans, including signing the Indian Removal Act of 1830, which led to the deaths and forced displacement of thousands of Native Americans. Next slide. Before I review the city's street renaming steps that were completed as part of this effort, I will turn it over to Cynthia Carmina Gomez from PSU, who will provide background on the multi-year community-driven effort to rename Southwest Jackson Street. She'll talk about the significance of this renaming and will tell you about It Way Rose Hill. Next slide.

**Cynthia Carmina Gomez** [55:38]

Thank you, Cynthia. Good afternoon, Council President Dunphy and council members. It's a pleasure to be here with you today. For the record, my name is Cynthia Carmina Gomez, and I am the Director of Local Government and Community Relations at Portland State University. The Native American Student and Community Center is located on the street we are proposing to rename. Our gathering space celebrates and empowers Indigenous student success through culturally relevant programming, academic support, and intergenerational community engagement. Thank you. The NAISEC community works to preserve and perpetuate intertribal connection for Native American, Alaska Native, Pacific Islander students and their allies through tradition, ceremony, and storytelling. The center has its roots in PSU's longstanding commitment to serving Indigenous students. The NAISEC is a short 2-story structure. It has a salmon-inspired architecture symbolizing Native student journeys with features like 4 directional entrances. Outside stands a 50-foot sculptural marker depicting the salmon's journey from birth to spawning. The space includes a large gathering room, classrooms, 2 conference rooms, a full kitchen, computer lab, fireplace lounge, and rooftop garden. It is gorgeous. Multiple student organizations are housed in the center, and for 10 years I had the privilege of working closely with the Native Center community while serving as a director of the Cultural Resource Centers. This is a special It is a home away from home, a place where students come to be nurtured while discovering who they are becoming. Next slide, please. The story begins in 2023 when the NASP was established. A Native caucus decided to pursue changing the name of Southwest Jackson Street. Momentum built over the years. In 2020, a GIS map was created and outreach to neighbors began. Thank you. By 2021, a formal street renaming committee had been formed, and in January '22, community engagement to identify a new name kicked off. That summer, in July 2022, the committee began convening and meeting regularly, and by November 2022, they had made their first approach to the city to formally pursue the change. The process moved into its selection phase in 2023. A list of potential names was created and put on a poll in March, and by May, the committee had narrowed it down to a final list of names. Finally, in November 2023, in-person polling was conducted and the community's choice was decided— Itway Rose Hill. Next slide, please. In tribal custom, we use the word Itway, and it's placed before the name of someone who's passed. This is a sign of respect when speaking about them. I wanted to share that with you so you know why we're using the word Itway. Itway Rose Hill, a member of the Oneida Nation of Wisconsin, came to Portland in 1979 and earned her BA from Portland State University in 1985. As a student, she began advocating for Native cultural— for a Native cultural center on campus, enlisting support from Portland mayors and PSU President Judith Ramaley, may she rest in peace. During her 15 years from '92 to '08 as coordinator for the Native American Student Services at PSU, she rallied community volunteers to keep the vision alive. And in 2003, the Native American Student Community Center finally opened. The Native American Student Community Center would not have been established without Itway's— Rose Hill's leadership and persistence. She also worked in Native health, education, and child welfare organizations across Portland, later earning a master's in educational counseling from Lewis& Clark College. In 2008, she joined the Native American Rehabilitation Association, NARA, working in children's mental health and later in its Culture Keeper initiative. Itway Rose Hill passed on October 11th, 2025. Now I'll turn it back to Cynthia Castro.

**Cynthia Castro** [59:48]

Thank you, Cynthia. In the next slides, I will discuss the legislation that kicked off our work to process PSU's application, followed by an overview of the city's process steps that were completed for the street renaming proposal. Next slide. When PSU approached the city in 2022 about renaming Southwest Jackson Street, PBOT had instituted a temporary pause on processing street renaming applications due to resource constraints. On October 30th, 2024, former PBOT Commissioner-in-Charge Mingus Maps introduced a resolution making an exception to PBOT street renaming moratorium policy and directing the newly formed Public Works Service Area to dedicate the necessary resources to process PSU's application in accordance with City Code Chapter 17.93. Council unanimously approved Resolution Number 37682 in front of a large crowd of supporters, including Native American community members, PSU students and faculty, PSU President Ann Cudd, downtown neighborhood association representatives, and Itway Rosehill herself, who you can see seated in the front of this photo. Council's passage of this resolution is what initiated our work to process PSU's application. Thank you. Next slide. Over the past 18 months, there's been a significant amount of work completed by PSU and the city to fulfill the requirements outlined in Chapter 17.93. Under each arrow you could see on this slide represents each process step. You'll see a code citation as well as notes about the fulfillment of these steps, including timeline. I will quickly walk you through each process step. The city street renaming application includes 2 parts. The first part requires that the applicant demonstrate that the proposal meets certain criteria for renaming a city street and for selecting a street to be renamed. You might recall that PSE's proposal does not conform to 2 code provisions related to criteria. On February 4th, council passed ordinance number 192142, waiving these code provisions as well as a 3rd provision to shorten the dual signage posting timeframe from 5 years to 6 months. PSU's proposal met all other criteria to satisfy application Part 1 requirements. PSU also fulfilled every requirement for the second part of their application, including gathering over 2,500 signatures from Portland residents, obtaining a letter of concurrence from Itway Rosehill's family, and submitting a biography for the honoree. PSU also received letters of support from the Downtown Neighborhood Association, the Portland Metro Chamber, and Native American Youth and Family Center. Thank you. Following PSU's completion of our street renaming application requirements, we began work to fulfill the city's administrative responsibilities outlined in Chapter 17.93. Even though PSU's application included letters of support from the Downtown Neighborhood Association and the Portland Metro Chamber, we still conducted outreach to these 2 organizations to reconfirm their support and follow through with the code requirement that we provide notice to the relevant neighborhood associations a 3-person historian panel was convened to review PSU's application and provide recommendations on the proposed street renaming to the Portland Planning Commission. The historian panel unanimously supported PSU's proposal and submitted a letter to the Planning Commission communicating their position. We mailed postcards to each legal owner and occupant on or abutting this segment of Southwest Jackson Street, notifying them of the September 8th Planning Commission public hearing on the street renaming and seeking their input within 30 calendar days. The postcard mailer with a QR code to an online feedback survey was sent to 513 addresses. 6 responses were received, with 3 indicating support and 3 opposed. At the September 8th Planning Commission public hearing, commissioners considered PSU's complete application, the historian panel's recommendation, the survey of legal owners and occupants, and public testimony to help them in developing recommendations for City Council. The Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend City Council approve renaming Southwest Jackson Street between Southwest 5th and Southwest Park Avenues to Southwest Rose Hill Street. Their letter to Council with this recommendation was included as an exhibit with this ordinance. And as the star on this slide indicates, we have reached the final step in the authorization process. Which is this council hearing. Next slide. I will end our presentation by restating that council's approval of this ordinance would authorize renaming of Southwest Jackson Street between Southwest 5th and Southwest Park Avenues to Southwest Rose Hill Street. Thank you. Next slide.

**Steve Novick** [1:04:32]

Perfect.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:04:32]

Okay, thank you very much for the presentation. Colleagues, before we get to technical or clarifying questions, I'd I'd like to jump to public testimony. Rebecca, can we call anybody who is here to testify?

**Andrea Robideau** [1:04:55]

Robideau, R-O-B-I-D-E-A-U. I don't know if that's—.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:04:59]

Hold on just a quick second.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:05:00]

Oh, sorry. Andrea is on the list. Yes, yes, for testimony. Um, you can go ahead.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:05:06]

Yeah, sorry, meant to call you up first, but—.

**Andrea Robideau** [1:05:09]

Oh, sorry.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:05:10]

You're good. No, go ahead.

**Andrea Robideau** [1:05:10]

Okay, y'all paused and I was like, guess I better.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:05:13]

All good. No, um, jump right in. Thank you.

**Andrea Robideau** [1:05:16]

Much of what I wanted to say was already covered, so I'll just cut right to Rose. Atway Rose meant so much to us, even if we weren't PSU students. I first attended an event that she, uh, coordinated in Um, when I was in middle school, and to be welcomed onto a college campus before I was even in high school really set the course for me to want to go to college, which meant I had to make it through high school. And so she used every opportunity to create intergenerational participation at PSU and in other institutions to bring us into places like this, to make us know that we belong and we can be in these seats and hold in leadership positions. And it, it's been just a big piece of my heart to see this come forward, especially because future generations are going to come to the Native Center, future generations are going to continue coming to Portland State University, and they may not choose Portland State University, but they're going to know that somewhere there's going to be a place to receive them, and they can let down their barriers, let down their guard, and open up to learning. And so I just want to say that piece and then let you call somebody else.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:06:37]

Thank you so much.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:06:38]

Thank you so much for being here.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:06:44]

LaJune Thorson and Ann Cudd.

**LaJune Thorson** [1:06:59]

Um, before I begin my remarks from the Downtown Neighborhood Association, um, I'm LaJune Thorson, president of the DNA. Um, we're asking for a procedural fix through an emergency ordinance. An emergency ordinance would allow our community to witness the finale of this long, drawn-out process. If we can't secure this fix, our elders and community leaders will not witness this historic vote today. Instead, it will take place on the 18th, the week after the discussion and community gathering in the City Hall atrium following today's council discussion. Our effort began in 2022 when our office first approached the city. Over many years, through multiple meetings and processes, as you've seen, the Indigenous community has shown up to community and city meetings and hearings time and time again in support. We would like to move to the next step and celebrate. Thank you. Do you need to act on that? Should I just go ahead?

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:08:01]

Keep going. We will, uh, have council discussion after public testimony.

**LaJune Thorson** [1:08:05]

All right, thank you. I'm here representing the DNA, LaJune Thorson, and the DNA is proud to have been involved in this project since the summer of '24. Thank you to Cynthia Castro and City Commissioner Mingus Maps and Cynthia Gomez of PSU for getting this moving. When we started this process, Rose Hill was here with us, and she is here in spirit. Thank you. Itway Rose Hill was an amazing person, as you've heard, who persistently and patiently promoted the PSU Native American Student and Community Center. She had big dreams for her community. There are others here who can speak directly to the impact she made on their lives. There are many, many people. With so many setbacks right now to human rights, this recognition is the right thing to do, and this is the right time. Thank you. We all need this positive and inspiring push forward. Thank you, councilors, and thank you, Itway Rose Hill, for your enduring gift to the Native community, the City of Portland, and to Portland State University.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:09:16]

Thank you very much.

**Ann Cudd** [1:09:19]

Good afternoon, councilors. For the record, my name is Ann Cudd, and I live and work in District 4, where I also serve as the president of Portland State University. For years, students and elders have had to enter a space designed for Indigenous healing and student success on a street named after Andrew Jackson, the architect of the Indian Removal Act of 1830. By finalizing this change, we are aligning our city's physical geography with its stated values of equity and historical truth. Thank you. This hearing also falls during Native American Heritage Month, which makes this hearing especially meaningful. As we honor the history, resilience, and contributions of Indigenous peoples, council has the opportunity to do so not only in words, but by permanently changing the name of a street that stands between— beside a center for Indigenous students and community. 2 of the 3 blocks we are requesting be renamed are located on Portland State University campus, abutting the Native American Student and Community Center. The center at PSU, which we also call the NASK for short, is a gathering space that celebrates and empowers student success through culturally relevant programming, academic support, and intergenerational community engagement. Preserving and perpetuating intertribal connection for Native American, Alaskan Native, Pacific Islander students, and our allies through tradition, ceremony, and storytelling. This renaming effort has been a years-long advocacy campaign led by Indigenous staff, community members, and students. While the city previously paused street renaming applications, Due to capacity constraints, the council's decision to make an exception for this 3-block section was the right one. It recognizes this location's unique significance and the profound impact this change has on the Indigenous community. Renaming Southwest Jackson Street to Southwest Rose Hill Street is an important step in making our city a place where everyone can feel they truly belong. Thank you, Mayor Wilson. I had the honor of meeting Itway Rose Hill before she passed, and I was impressed by her kind and strong presence. Renaming this street after Itway Rose Hill is a deeply fitting tribute. She was a cultural keeper and a former NASC student coordinator. Itway Rose Hill's life's work has been about cultivating a sense of belonging and representation. In a city that sits on the traditional homelands of Multnomah, Kathlamet, Clackamas, and many other Indigenous nations, it is exciting when our public spaces reflect the leaders who have worked to preserve and perpetuate these cultures. So I want to thank PBOT and especially Cynthia Castro for working with us to ensure this renaming received the care and attention it deserves. And thank you, councilors, for your commitment to this historic transition. After this agenda item, as, as LaJune mentioned, we will gather in the atrium of this building to celebrate this important occasion, and we hope that those of you who can will join us.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:12:50]

Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:12:51]

Thank you very much.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:12:55]

Tabitha Whitefoot, Modesta Minthorn, And Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:13:02]

Welcome. You're welcome to share your pronouns if you'd like, and you have 3 minutes apiece. And whoever wants to go first.

**Rachel Whiteside** [1:13:19]

Elders first.

**Tabitha Whitefoot** [1:13:22]

Um, my name is Tabitha Whitefoot. I, um, am and a citizen of the Yakama Nation. Rose and I were colleagues at the Native American Student and Community Center, but before that, we were volunteers who worked tirelessly to first get the center built. And there were no few obstacles to that. There was fundraising, there was getting the land, Thank you. You know, approving so many things. If you've had the joy of walking in the building, it's special. The, the—. There are, um, things that were donated by all of the 9 tribes in the state of Oregon, and, um, there are flags of many of our students hanging in the gathering area because, you know, it's, it's all Native peoples. My friend was a coalition builder. Um, she was an educator and a passionate leader. She was very humble. She did not seek this notoriety, but she wanted parity for both our students and for our community. I laud the city to step up and recognize a local legend. Modern Native Americans need to see and rec— see recognition of our people. Thank you. People who have been living in this city, who have been working in community and making our lives better. She's a 21st century hero. She loved and influenced so many of the young leaders in Indian Country today. We have people who are doing amazing and remarkable things that were— we still call them kids, but they're not any longer. They're you're just amazing. I appreciate the opportunity to help my city bring recognition to the people who work and build a diverse and caring leadership. I grew up in Portland, Oregon. I didn't go to Portland State for college. I went to Lewis and Clark College. But, um, I— Rose and I were very, very close, and this has been long coming, but I'm really happy that it's happening. Thank you. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:15:39]

Thank you very much.

**Modesta Minthorn** [1:16:06]

Payu, um, payu ni tamna chana chikook. Good afternoon. My name is Modesta Minthorn. I'm the executive director for tribal relations at Portland State University, and I thank you for the opportunity to speak today in support of renaming Southwest Jackson Street to Rose— Southwest Rose Hill Street. The current name, Andrew Jackson, a former president of the United States, also known as the Indian Killer. Kind of lets you know where the history lands on that. And the fact that Portland State University's Native students and faculty and the Indigenous community here in Portland have the, the NASK located on that street and being named after him is a crazy contradiction. Thank you. And this is our opportunity to correct that contradiction. Rose Hill, Atwe Rose, was a Portland State University alumni. She was an advocate for Native students, instrumental in establishing the NASC, dedicated years of her life mentoring students and advocating for their needs and creating a welcoming place where Native students could feel supported, valued, and connected to their communities. She also understood that education is not simply about earning a degree. It's also about belonging, cultural identity, community, and knowing that someone believes in your future. Renaming the street in her honor sends a powerful message to Indigenous students and future generations: you belong here, your history matters, your leaders matter, and your contribution to this community deserves recognition. This is also an opportunity for Portland to demonstrate that honoring Indigenous people must be more than words spoken during public ceremonies. It must be reflected in the decisions we make, the places we name, and the history we choose to celebrate. I respectfully urge the Portland City Council to approve the renaming of Southwest Jackson Street to Southwest Rose Hill and I thank you for your time, your consideration, and your commitment to recognizing Portland's Indigenous community.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:18:38]

Thank you very much.

**Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk** [1:18:45]

Hiya na washte, abetu washte, iyaka pie washte wi, dakota wacichina awashte wi. I just wanted to come and also share a personal story and being able to personally be and know Rose. I've actually met Rose through Andrea, another really important advocate in the community, and showed the importance of how, how important it is to be involved in the culture and the community here. Being in the education system and, you know, being able to hear Rose speak on why she did what she did and being able to advocate for cultures and other people and Tribal people of this land left a really humbling moment with me, and I am grateful that you know we get to be here. In the Native culture, we should have never waited. We honor our elders, and I noticed every single one of you looking at your computer. The thing is. It shouldn't take this long to to come to anything when it comes with Native people. Start writing policy to help our community like this. We shouldn't wait for people to to be gone before we're honoring them. We should honor them while they're still here, while they're gone. You know, I'm grateful to be here with y'all. I know that it's hard to do your job, but one thing when it comes to our elders is they're really humble people. They will help be able to change ways and, you know, care about the land. Maybe listen to some of them once in a while because we're here to take care of our land, and that's one thing our elders always taught us. We need to take care of each other while we're doing this job. And advocating for our community and our generations to come. That's one thing this elder showed me, that no matter what, where you are, a community is always going to be here for you. All these beautiful women and ladies that I'm here with, she's the reason why we're here. We're connected in all different ways, and it's because of her. And so with that, I just want to say a prayer for y'all. Uh-huh. Let's change this 116 years later from Jackson to Rose Hill.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:21:29]

Thank you very much.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:21:32]

Xavier Stickler and Solen Hering.

**Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk** [1:21:42]

Welcome.

**Mitch Green** [1:21:42]

Thank you.

**Xavier Stickler** [1:21:43]

Council President Dunphy, members of Portland City Council, good afternoon. My name is Xavier D. Stickler, and I'm the vice president of the Downtown Neighborhood Association, a student of urban planning and architecture at Portland State University, and a person of mixed race and indigenous heritage. Needless to say, I'm quite excited to be here before you today to express the great enthusiasm and wholehearted support both myself and the DNA for the initiative to rename Southwest Jackson Street to Southwest Rose Hill Street, presently named for seventh U.S. President Andrew Jackson. Jackson Street in the downtown travels east from Southwest Park Avenue to Fifth Avenue, passing directly in front of Portland's PSU's Nask. This is glaringly inappropriate given Jackson's legacy as a man who typified imperial cruelty, colonial hatred for indigenous peoples. And brutishness in his personal affairs, which often culminated in bloodshed and death. It is the opinion of the DNA that is unacceptable and inappropriate that our city's cornerstone space for members of the Native community be on a street named in honor of a man who is instrumental in perpetuating, indeed a key architect of, systematic violence against First Nations people— peoples. Honor, respect, or even tolerance for genocide or its perpetrators here or anywhere in the world has no place in our community or in the year 2026. Portland's street names are integral to its identity and sense of place. With the life and vibrancy that each street fosters, the legacy of its namesake grows in dignity. To be memorialized with a street conveys a sense of esteem. It signifies that the individual made a positive contribution to our community. For President Jackson, slave owner, white supremacist, and killer. This is simply not the case. For Itway Rose Hill, an educator, a guide, a creator, and a champion of knowledge and community, this is emphatically the case. Simply put, Itway Rose Hill left Portland better than she found it. I had the privilege and pleasure of meeting Itway Rose Hill on just a few occasions as part of this renaming process, but when I did, I was struck. No matter how long your interaction with her, She exuded kindness, a sense of compassion and comfort for her, for others, for her community, for her students. Her love for others, for her community, for her students was palpable. You need only look to her legacy, the successful construction of the NASK, and the students she shepherded to graduation to see her effect. I can only describe the idea of replacing the current namesake with that of a woman who embodied love, this segment of public right-of-way is only 3 blocks long, and renaming will affect few properties but will result in tremendously positive symbolic impact to the downtown area, PSU, and our Native neighbors. This is a grassroots community-led effort which has the strong backing of the downtown neighborhood. By at long last ratifying this change to our streets, you'll help create a place in our central city that is welcoming to everyone, You will honor a legacy of which we can all be proud. You will bring respect to the people who have been here since time immemorial and are still here, and on whose ancestral lands we all reside. The Portland we deserve, the one that truly represents us, is a city which elevates the voices and missions of people like Itway's Rose Hill. With your voice today, we can begin to realize that vision of Portland. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:25:08]

Thank you very much.

**Solen Hering** [1:25:10]

Hi, um, honorable city council members. My name is Solen Hering, and I'm a student at St. Mary's Academy, which is located in I am a senior at Portland State University. I am a resident of Portland and live less than a half mile from the PSU Native American Student and Community Center. I have lived in Portland my entire life, and today I travel downtown every day as a senior in my last year of high school. This position means that despite downtown Portland's flaws, it has become one of my homes. I spend the majority of my time here, as many students do. The PSU Native American and Student and Community Center is located on Southwest Jackson Street, Street, and it serves as an important cultural and community hub for students. It should be a place that is safe, welcoming, and one that reflects belonging. Renaming Southwest Jackson Street to Southwest Rose Hill Street would strengthen the sense of community in downtown Portland. I urge you to consider a student's perspective when considering authorizing the renaming of Southwest Jackson Street. The incredible individuals who have spent such a substantial amount of time working so hard to fight for the renaming of Southwest Jackson Street have taught me resilience, understanding, and they inspire me every day. Itway Rose Hill inspires me. The passion that I have seen working with individuals over the past year is why I've written my college supplemental essays about this issue. It is why I'm here, slightly nervous, in front of you all. The renaming of this street is so incredibly important. Councilmember which is why I respectfully submit this testimony in support of the proposed renaming of Southwest Jackson and ask for your approval. Thank you for your time and your service to our city.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:26:48]

Thank you very much.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:26:50]

That concludes testimony.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:26:52]

Okay, thank you all very much for everybody who came and testified. Colleagues, we are now in, uh, council discussion. Additionally, technical or clarifying questions if anyone has any, but feel free to jump into the queue. We've got 4 councilors in the queue right now. Start with Councilor Ryan.

**Dan Ryan** [1:27:04]

Yes, thank you, Council President. Um, thank you for the compelling testimony. It's great to be back here. I was at the first one. Thank you to the Cynthias for seeing this through. I appreciate it. Um, I have an amendment, Ryan 1, uh, which was suggested in testimony authorizing the renaming of Southwest Jackson between Southwest 5th Avenue and Southwest Park Avenue to South— to Southwest, sorry, Rose Hill Street. It says this: the council declares that an emergency exists due to the need of its community to honor the elders and community leaders who worked for years to institute this street renaming. This ordinance shall be in full force and effect upon its passage.

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [1:27:44]

Second.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:27:45]

Okay, Councilor Ryan has moved an emergency clause or amendment, and Councilor Koyama Lane has seconded the motion.

**Dan Ryan** [1:27:53]

And I did pass it around because we're having email challenges today.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:27:56]

Correct. Yeah, um, get you a— we'll get a copy over to you in just a second. Yeah, thank you so much, Councilor Ryan.

**Mitch Green** [1:28:14]

I got in the queue to introduce a similar amendment, and I'm glad that you drafted it, so I'm going to be supportive of this. So I really appreciate it. I think that we have to take swift action. I would like to sort of take this vote now, and we can honor Mayor Wilson's request to move forward with this.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:28:26]

Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:28:30]

Thank you very much, Councilor Green. Councilor Morillo.

**Angelita Morillo** [1:28:35]

Thank you. I was also in the queue to do the same thing, so I think we will get this passed today and then folks can go celebrate and really enjoy their time. I just wanted to say, you know, I have seen people work on this for so many years. I think Cynthia, I think I saw you working on this back when I was on council. I worked in Commissioner Hardesty's office, and this has been something that the community has been working on for so long. So thank you so much for, for going through this process and fighting to get this name change. I think it's really special and important that we do this. And we heard some of this testimony as well during the— when the Transportation Committee existed. And so I'm really excited that we're getting this done today. I'm fully supportive of an emergency clause so that people can just celebrate and be done with it.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:29:16]

Thank you.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [1:29:17]

Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:29:17]

Thank you, Councilor Morillo. Councilor Novick.

**Steve Novick** [1:29:21]

Thank you, Mr. President. I just wanted to say that when I saw that Itway Rose Hill was of the Oneida Nation of Wisconsin, I was confused because I thought of the Oneidas being New York. So I looked it up and discovered that yes, the Oneida were in New York. And even though they were the only Iroquois nation that supported the revolutionaries during the American Revolutionary War, they were then systematically deprived of their land in New York, so many of them relocated to Wisconsin. So I just thought that that was something worth mentioning, one of the many evils visited upon Natives by this country, this one not by Andrew Jackson. But I also wanted to say that I look forward to the day when Andrew Jackson is removed from the $20 bill, something which Barack Obama had set in motion that was interrupted by that Joe Biden, I think, had set in motion, was interrupted by this past president. So very honored to be able to support this today.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:30:23]

Thank you, Councilor Novick. Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [1:30:26]

Thank you, Council President. I'm also excited that we have this back before us today. I am wondering, because the emergency clause that is before us says that the ordinance shall be in full force and effect upon its passage, if there's any complications with that specific language, given that there are often timelines on renaming, or if this— if the language in this emergency clause is right and works for how we need to implement it? Because there's 2 pieces to the emergency clause: the let's vote on it today, and then the implementation side. And does this still work on the implementation side as well?

**Unidentified speaker** [1:31:02]

Yes.

**Cynthia Castro** [1:31:07]

Thank you for the question and your consideration for that. Yes, for the record again, Cynthia Castro with PBOT. Yes, this adding the emergency clause does not disrupt the implementation process.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [1:31:18]

Fantastic. I'm excited to see this done, and I will just say for our PBOT folks, I hope it can be done with full transparency and communication and consistency with what is shared with the community around what the timing is thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:31:39]

Councilor Avalos.

**Candace Avalos** [1:31:42]

Thank you. I just wanted to add my voice in the chorus of appreciation that this is coming to us at the council and that we are making— moving forward with the emergency ordinances, which I support, because updating the names of our places is a way that we can show respect to the peoples who lived there far before European settlers came to this land. European. Wow. European settlers came to this land. And I just want to say, I, as somebody that worked at PSU for 8 years and did a lot of events at the NASEC, it is such a beautiful space. It is such a great way to unite the community. And I'm glad that the street will now be able to reflect the work of Itway Rose Hill. So thank you again.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:32:26]

Thank you, Councilor Avalos. Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue to discuss the, uh, motion by Councilor Ryan, seconded by Councilor Koyama Lane, Rebecca, can we please call the roll on the emergency clause?

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:32:40]

Calling roll on Ryan 1 to add an emergency clause to— we're at that too, the item. Uh, Clark absent. Green Aye. Zimmerman, absent. Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [1:32:56]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:32:57]

Smith?

**Loretta Smith** [1:33:00]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:33:01]

Kanal? Councilor Kanal, we can't hear you.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:33:11]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:33:12]

Thank you. Pirtle-Guiney?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [1:33:14]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:33:15]

Ryan?

**Dan Ryan** [1:33:16]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:33:17]

Koyama-Lane?

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [1:33:18]

Aye.

**Angelita Morillo** [1:33:20]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:33:21]

Novick.

**Steve Novick** [1:33:21]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:33:22]

Dunphy.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:33:23]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:33:24]

And the amendment is approved with 10 aye, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:33:27]

Thank you, colleagues. Before we have final vote, is there any discussion on the now amended emergency ordinance before us? Councilor Kanal.

**Sameer Kanal** [1:33:34]

Thank you, uh, Council President. Um, I am really grateful to the Cynthias, to everyone else who is here as well for working on this for a very long period of time. I'll add my voice in the appreciation chorus here. And going back through everything which has been done shows how long this process takes and how long— how much longer than it should take that it does. And I still think we need to have the conversation and I'm still committed to having the conversation around 17.93 so that no community needs to go through this again. In particular, I really appreciated the testimony from Lisa that mentioned that, you know, it's— we have a cultural assumption built into our code that you have to have been dead for 5 years before you get honored, and we have to waive it otherwise. And that isn't necessarily how everyone honors their elders, right? And I think that's really important for us to consider as part of what we do here. As we all know, Jackson Street was named to honor a man who, upon his election to the presidency, committed a lot of atrocities against Indigenous people. He also owned 95 human beings. He told his overseer that his Black enslaved cook should be ruled with the cowhide. He signed the Indian Removal Act, initiating the Trail of Tears. It was a state-sanctioned genocide. These are things that make it very clear what we must do here. The people, events, and histories we choose to honor should represent the values of our community. Nitwa Rose Hill was a steadfast advocate for PSU students, for Native communities in Portland. She created spaces that provided support and resources and fostered belonging. That aligns with our value. She did shape our city for the better, and her legacy is part of Portland's story and worthy of remembrance. I'll be gladly supporting this ordinance, and I hope this renaming smudges away a bit more bad energy. Thank you.

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [1:35:30]

Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:35:31]

Thank you, Councilor Connell. Councilor Ryan? Oh, I guess—. Okay, excellent. Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue for discussion, pausing for dramatic effect. Rebecca, can we please call the roll on the now amended emergency ordinance?

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:35:50]

Calling the roll on 2026-386 as amended. Green.

**Mitch Green** [1:35:55]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:36:00]

I'm sorry, Councilor Avalos, that was—.

**Candace Avalos** [1:36:02]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:36:03]

Thank you. Smith?

**Loretta Smith** [1:36:05]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:36:06]

Kanal?

**Sameer Kanal** [1:36:07]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:36:08]

Pirtle-Guiney?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [1:36:09]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:36:10]

Ryan?

**Dan Ryan** [1:36:11]

Aye.

**Candace Avalos** [1:36:13]

Aye.

**Angelita Morillo** [1:36:15]

Aye.

**Robert Taylor** [1:36:16]

Aye.

**Solen Hering** [1:36:18]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:36:19]

And the ordinance passes with 10 aye, 2 absent votes.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:36:22]

Any further discussion or comments? Any further discussion or comments? Seeing none, the motion passes unanimously. Thank you all very much. Colleagues, it is 3:30. I'm going to give us a 10-minute break. Please be back here. I'm going to give us more than that. It's 3:32. I'm going to have everybody back here at 3:45, please. Thank you. Welcome back, everybody. Thank you all for the brief humanity break.

### 11. Ratify collective bargaining agreement with Professional & Technical Employees, Local 17 (2026-412)

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:51:50]

We have 3 items left on our agenda for this afternoon.

**Unidentified speaker** [1:51:53]

Thank you, Madam Chair.

**LaJune Thorson** [1:51:53]

Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:51:54]

Can we please move to item 12, which is document 2026-412?

**Rebecca Dobert** [1:51:59]

Ratify a collective bargaining agreement with the Professional and Technical Employees Local 17 relating to the terms and conditions of employment of represented employees in the bargaining unit for 2026 through 2029. Document number 2026-412.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:52:15]

Thank you, colleagues. The item before us is an emergency ordinance. We'll require 9/12 We have our friends here from the Bureau of Human Resources. Hello, take it away.

**Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie** [1:52:24]

Hi, my name is Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie with the Bureau of Human Resources Labor Relations, the lead negotiator for the city side for the Protect 17 agreement. And of course, I'm joined here today by Rachel Whiteside. Uh, are you a business representative?

**Rachel Whiteside** [1:52:43]

Union representative.

**Loretta Smith** [1:52:46]

Close.

**Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie** [1:52:47]

Uh, anyway, we're here to, uh, present our ordinance, and I'm going to share a screen here as soon as I figure out how to do that. There we go.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [1:52:57]

Maybe.

**Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie** [1:52:59]

Hmm, I see it somewhere. There we go. All right, so, uh, first of all, I want to, um, Thank you, Mayor.

**Tabitha Whitefoot** [1:53:10]

Thank you, Council President Jamie Dunphy, for the opportunity to bring this ordinance together.

**Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie** [1:53:12]

I feel like this is good news. We have been working together for quite a long time. The city and Pro-Tech started negotiations all the way back in May of 2025. That is just a— well, I don't know, that was kind of a long time ago. It's November already. And this was a challenging set of negotiations for a variety of reasons. And I want to just appreciate Thank you. I really appreciate all of the hard work that we did as a team between our city side, especially with the union side— excellent labor partners at the table. I really just appreciate Rachel being here today sitting next to me while we bring this item together. Um, I'm going to walk you through some of the details briefly on the agreement. I'm happy to take questions But again, this is a 3.5-year agreement retroactive to January of 2026. It spans through June 30th, 2029. There are economic and non-economic agreements that we brought forward in this. Our priority, our priority from the city side is to create fiscally sustainable agreements that also maximize shared interests, and we did that through an interest-based bargaining process through I would say about 90% of the process, and that yields us great outcomes in the end, even through the most difficult days and conversations. So as part of this agreement, we're bringing forward a retroactive COLA of 3% effective July 1st, 2026. We've agreed to a 1 to 4% COLA in the second and third year of the agreement, in fiscal year '27 We agreed to targeted wage increases for several classifications. I don't have the exact number in front of me, but those are based off of market-driven needs. We did increase a clothing allowance for this bargaining unit, an increase of $100 per calendar year. We also introduced a 2% longevity. This is a heavily tenured group. Thank you. Averaging more than 10 years of service in the city. That'll go into effect in July of 2028. We also added 3 additional personal holidays for fully in-person employees, which primarily impacts those in Portland Street Response and in the parks classifications. We did increase the standby calculation for all members that are required to be available in their off hours. Thank you. We increased the shift differential to match some of our other bargaining units. And then this last line here, other increases including wage benefit, those are just the roll-up costs that we have. So we brought this contract to a close roughly at $39.5 million over 3 years. That is a skosh higher than our budget authority, and that is just because we are taking on the additional difference between the 3% budget authority that we were provided by the council and the difference of the actual assumed COLA now of 3.6% for fiscal year '27-'28 and the potential of 3% for '28-'29.

**Loretta Smith** [1:56:34]

Let's see.

**Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie** [1:56:37]

And then I— the second component of our tentative agreement is the non-economic terms. And this is a substantial impact for both the bargaining unit and for the city. So we've reclassified our IT classifications. Those are the information technology systems— nope, information systems technology analysts, application analysts, et cetera. And we are now having a singular naming convention, IT professionals 1 through 8. We are also introducing new classifications to this bargaining unit, building infrastructure modeling, Okay. Geographic Information Systems Analysts, often known as GIS Analysts 1 through 3, Transportation Demand Specialists, Community Garden Technicians, and then we are introducing some additional specialties under the Engineering 1 classification and the Botanic Specialist classifications. Further, this agreement also provides the official voluntary recognition of the Capital Project 3 classification into this bargaining unit. It also strengthens contract language around pay equity analysis upon hire and promotion for all members of the bargaining unit, strengthens their language, contract language related to notification when there are layoffs that will be occurring. It establishes a working out of class classification guideline for long-term assignments, which we felt particularly strongly about in the name of equity. Thank you. It creates a mandatory overtime policy for the Portland Street Response and provides an incentive for those employees that would be impacted by that policy. And it enhances our qualified citywide closure language. Those are some highlights. There are obviously other benefits that are baked into this contract. I think overall, you know, there are, there are great takeaways for this particular contract, especially given our limited economic opportunities, uh, during this bargaining season. And so, um, I'm very glad that the Pro-Tech side of the house was able to ratify the agreement, and I'm happy to bring this before your— before you today for approval. I'll hand it over to Rachel.

**Jamie Dunphy** [1:58:56]

Great.

**Dan Ryan** [1:58:57]

Rachel.

**Rachel Whiteside** [1:58:58]

Thank you, Ann Marie. Uh, members of council, thank you for your time today. I'm going to to start by clearly asking for your support of this tentative agreement that's before you. And while we are eager to begin the work of implementing our new labor agreement, I feel like I would also be remiss if I failed to call out our overall bargaining experience. I also want to say really clearly, I don't feel like it's a reflection of my, um, counterpart here at the table with me, but our experience this negotiation cycle felt like this was unnecessarily drawn out. And when we started looking at the costs of that, both the dollars and cents as well as the lost opportunity costs because of the thousands of hours that were spent at the negotiating table, it really feels important to call that out. In contrast, Annmarie and I were both co-leads in our last negotiation cycle, and that is what I would coin as the perfect example of demonstrating that negotiations do not have to be a knockdown, drag-out fight when they are approached with honesty, transparency, and more importantly, creativity, which is something that I really feel is lacking with the current administration. Our bargaining team and broader membership were dismayed by this change, and we think it's important that you understand the harm that's caused caused by these types of negotiations. Beyond the costly waste of time and resources, the city's new approach, a prolonged refusal to compromise, is damaging to our ongoing labor relations. Annemarie and I and all of our members and their managers have to continue to work together when we are done, and this form of negotiations breeds distrust and makes working together to achieve the goals of our respective bureaus and the city all that much harder once negotiations are concluded. As an example, the Lyonna strike 3 years ago led to years of mistrust and ongoing expenses for the Bureau of Environmental Services in the form of mediation and team building that was needed post-strike. There will be similar, if not larger, ramifications on a citywide level by the strike that happens to be going on— maybe not right this very moment, but this very week. One union striking or even getting ready to strike represents a failure in leadership and results in what I see as a colossal waste of public money. I am asking the city to stop wasting their money and intentionally sowing labor disharmony. It's damaging for the rest of the city's workforce. It doesn't serve the people of Portland. I'm a resident and taxpayer, and it is not in alignment with the city values. That you were elected to uphold. There are no victories to be had in taking this approach, regardless of the hypothetical outcomes of these negotiations. Failing to meet with striking workers for days on end just feels absolutely deplorable from where I'm sitting. There is real harm that's being caused, and you have very little time left to our members have ratified our TA on its own merits and their own needs, but we do stand in solidarity with our labor siblings at CPPW, and we ask you to please return to the table with them immediately. Like Rob Martineau said at the top of the meeting, I don't have the answers for you with regards to which levers you need to pull, but for the good of the city and frankly self-servingly, I urge you to return to the table with them. Thank you. So I'm just going to conclude by saying, uh, PROTECT 17 members unequivocally urge you to approve our tentative agreement and also return to the table and settle with the CPPW.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [2:02:54]

Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:02:56]

Thank you very much. Thank you very much for the presentation. Uh, Rebecca, has anyone signed up to testify on this?

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:03:02]

We have 2 people signed up.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:03:03]

Okay, colleagues, before we get into any technical clarifying or broader council discussion, I'd like to invite our testimony up. So thank you both very much.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:03:11]

James O&#039;Laughlen and Jeanette DeCastro.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:03:18]

Welcome. Please introduce yourselves for the records. You're welcome to share your pronouns, and you have 3 minutes apiece.

**James O'Laughlen** [2:03:26]

James O&#039;Laughlen, he/him. I am a city worker operating on release time to represent my union, LIUNA 483. I appreciate council providing this opportunity to speak, though I have to admit that, as well as every setting where I'm speaking after Rachel, I'm very intimidated. She spoke very eloquently about what I came here to talk about. The, uh, first off, to encourage you to ratify this agreement that Pro-Tech and the city worked so hard to reach, but also to emphasize the dysfunctional process and the real cost to city workers that that led to. I mean, the cost of living adjustments you saw just put up there were delayed by more than a year. That has dramatic impacts on the, the people and their families and our broader community. Um, Yeah, it really just emphasizes such a clear example of the dysfunctional relationship the city has developed with its workers. You know, our unit having gone out on strike, what I view very unnecessarily, to arrive at a reasonable deal, CPPW being out now in pursuit of the same, and the huge amount of cost, not just to the public and our coffers, But to trust in us as an institution when we're constantly under siege from external barbs and arrows that are thrown at our community. When, you know, I'm the proud father of 3 Native Portlanders, and our libraries, our parks, our people— this is a wonderful place to raise a family. And at the same time, as committed as I am to our public good here, There is so much waste and inefficiency and at least things that smack of corruption in the way we handle these labor relationships. I mean, considering the process that Pro-Tech went through, it is no surprise that CPPW is out on strike and that it's very likely hundreds more workers will be out in a matter of weeks. You know, we are going through a joint crisis of affordability and accountability, where city workers are constantly under the chopping block for the sin of being transparent in our costs, where contracting out and special projects, if they spiral out by 400% or simply never tracked so that we have no idea how much we're spending in those spaces, that's just a natural response to a crisis of the day. Thank you. And it incentivizes brinksmanship from our workers to become that crisis when they want nothing more than to show up and perform the city's work. So I strongly encourage you to ratify this agreement and take the current crises as an opportunity to repair our labor relationships. Nobody benefits from this, least of all the people of Portland.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:06:34]

Thank you very much.

**Jeanette DeCastro** [2:06:38]

Hello, my name is Jeanette DeCastro. My pronouns are she and they. I wear several hats, including steward with my union, Protect 17. I'm here on my own time. Please ratify the Protect 17 collective bargaining agreement. I'm going to emphasize the word collective. Thank you, Annemarie, for the presentation. It has been a very long haul. I'm going to insert a side comment. Please continue to dig in and explore the impacts of outside contracting. It is very opaque, and city workers can generally do the work for less. Okay. And I want to read this into the record. On September 7th, 2026, Mayor Wilson gave an interview with Coin 6 News, and part of the narrative from the interviewer: It's no wonder that the Northwest Oregon Labor Council's Labor Day picnic attracts politicians. And Mayor Wilson's remarks included: Because affordability is becoming more and more of an issue, and when you think about the union protections that those individuals have It is critical that we protect our staff. I look at the city of Portland. We have a heavily unionized staff. The city of Portland—they are our coworkers. Solidarity is a fundamental value of organized labor. We show up with a shared purpose here as city of Portland employees. We do the day-to-day work, and we collectively push for workplace safety, for respectful working conditions, and the opportunity to grow our skills so we can continue to serve our community. And City of Portland workers are a part of the community, and as labor, we show up in solidarity with the City of Portland Professional Workers Union, and we will continue to show up until their contract is settled. Thank you. Like Mayor Wilson said, they are our coworkers.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:08:50]

Thank you. Thank you very much. That completes testimony.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:08:56]

Thank you very much for everybody who came to testify. Thank you for the presentation, colleagues. We are now into technical and clarifying questions as well as council discussion. Councilor Maria.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:09:07]

Thank you, Council President. Thank you so much to those of you who came to testify. Testify and who often come to my constituent coffees and things to speak with my office. I, to be frank with you, I don't have a lot of questions about the contracts that are being settled. I think I'm ready to vote for those, but it's not really lost on me that we're ratifying 2 huge contracts. And what this tells me is that the city does know how to compromise and we do know how to reach an agreement with the unions and with our city employees. And meanwhile, we have 800 CPBW workers on strike at the very— at this very moment. And I want to be very clear to the administration that I do stand with the CPBW employees who are expecting to have their contract ratified next week. Right now, this contract is in Mayor Wilson's hands. And since he is a CEO mayor who often talks about running the city like a business or an enterprise, then I'm going to explain it in a way that could be comprehensive to him. Our constituents are our shareholders, and our shareholders expect excellent, efficient, and on-time city services. By delaying this contract, we are letting our workers and our shareholders down. As our workers continue fighting for a fair contract, our shareholders are experiencing unpaid process payments to food pantries, including—.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:10:30]

Councilor Maria is still recognized.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:10:33]

Thank you.

**Loretta Smith** [2:10:33]

Point of order, Mr. President. Are we talking about—.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:10:36]

Grant money is not going out to culturally specific programs.

**Loretta Smith** [2:10:41]

Point of order. Point of order. I'm trying to get more information.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:10:48]

We are discussing the item 12 before us.

**Loretta Smith** [2:10:50]

Right. Are we talking about PROTEC? Are we talking about CPE?

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:10:53]

I find Councilor Maria's conversation to be in, in order.

**Loretta Smith** [2:10:57]

Okay, which one?

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:10:58]

We are discussing the Pro-Tech, but I find her comments to be germane.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:11:01]

We're talking about union contracts as a whole, and I'm talking about the disparate treatment that a different union is experiencing in contrast with this. But I don't need your approval to continue speaking, Councilor Smith. Stop interrupting me.

**Loretta Smith** [2:11:14]

I can call point of order.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:11:15]

As our workers continue fighting—.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:11:18]

Councilor Smith, Councilor Murillo has the floor.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:11:21]

Yeah, I do.

**Loretta Smith** [2:11:21]

Mr. President, quit calling my name. She's She's speaking out too.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:11:24]

She's been the only one who has been recognized.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:11:26]

I'm recognized. I'm allowed to do this.

**Raymond C. Lee** [2:11:28]

Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:11:29]

Councilor Murillo, please.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:11:30]

Once the chair has made a ruling, you are no longer recognized. Thank you. As our workers continue fighting for a fair contract, our shareholders are experiencing unprocessed payments to food pantries, including school-based pantries. Grant money is not going out to culturally specific programs and working with foster youth or to prevent homelessness. Child abuse. Non-union employees without the necessary expertise are running payroll, which is causing people to be warned about potential over and underpayments in their checks. Only one manager is doing the work of four people to process police and fire pension and retirement benefits and claims, and contractors and grantees are not getting their invoices paid. There are seven upcoming tree planting programs that have not received the trees they need, and orders are not. Being processed, resulting in rescheduling delays or cancellations altogether. And that's just a few things that have been delayed because we have not been willing to settle a fair contract with them. I also know that CPBW is not asking for anything in their contract that is unprecedented or is not listed in the 2 contracts that we are voting on shortly. Every day that we don't come to a deal, we are not just failing to provide for our workers and our community, we are antagonizing bargaining units and the others in the city are actively seeing that we are not willing to treat our employees with dignity and respect. So what kind of enterprise or city are we trying to run here? Is it one that is going to churn through upper-level management and have massive settlements, or is it one where we are committed to our constituents, to getting them the services that they need, and that is dedicated to the workers that deliver those services every day? There is no reason to not reach an agreement here. We are doing it for 2 major contracts right now, and I expect the city will be at the table every single day. And I expect that we are going to be here next week ready to ratify CPBW's contract. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:13:24]

Councilor Morillo. Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [2:13:27]

Thank you, Council President. Mr. City Administrator, there's no need to be nervous. I'm going to keep my remarks to the contracts before us. I've already shared with you how I feel about other contracts. I am so grateful that we were able to settle this contract. I am grateful that our bargaining teams were willing to take up interest-based bargaining. I am grateful that we have a union and our management representative before us together. Thank you. Saying that this is a contract that both sides can wholeheartedly support. That is how labor relations should work. But I am concerned that I am hearing yet again about a drawn-out process, and I am concerned that in the almost two years I have been on this city council, I don't think I have seen a single contract come before us that was settled before the previous contract. Expired. The expiration date of a contract is not when bargaining should start in full. The expiration date of a contract is when we should have a goal of wrapping up bargaining so that there isn't a delay, so that we don't have back payments of COLAs, so that there's certainty and consistency. And if it takes an extra couple of weeks to get it done or get it ratified and get everybody's timing lined up, so be it. But I have heard repeatedly that it does not feel like there's a culture right now of working collaboratively with our unions to get contracts bargained and settled in a timely manner. And I heard that again today, even as I heard that the ultimate product was one that our city employees could support. So I am so glad we have a contract before us today that our city employees feel good about and our management team feels good about. But I would like to ask that the folks who are giving direction, Mr. City Administrator, to our bargaining teams reset the culture So that as we see contracts come before us in the future, we are seeing them come before us before the previous contracts expire or very soon thereafter, so that we have that consistency and continuity. And so that frankly, from a fiscal perspective, we have consistency and continuity and aren't planning for large back payments because we weren't able to settle a contract in a timely manner. Thank you. Thank you, Council President.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:16:13]

Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. Colleagues, after Councilor Green finishes his remarks, I will close the queue. So if anyone wants to get in to queue for discussion, please do so while Councilor Green speaks. Councilor Green.

**Mitch Green** [2:16:24]

Thank you, Council President. I'm grateful that we got to a TA that both sides can accept, and I look forward to voting on that. I want to echo what I heard from both of my colleagues just now. I think that they are connected. I think that we do have to have a culture reset, and whatever it takes, you need the resources, just come to us. We will resource that. It's extremely costly to have a lengthy and drawn-out and acrimonious process. I think everyone should understand that. And it's not the first time I've heard that when Rachel made that point at the dais. And so it's very germane. Thank you. Into the conversation. I want to lift up also something that our Protec 17 steward raised, which is a perennial issue for this union, which is the external contracting. Because from the experience of the workers, you know, they'll go out, they'll get a scope of work approved, it'll be contracted out, and then they have to do it again anyway internally to check their work. I think that this is a big— it's not just a purely economic issue. It's a matter of respect and it's a matter of building administrative capacity inside the city and our ability to in-house this stuff. So I think that will go a long ways. If we can be serious about that, I think that will go a long ways towards helping the relationship with this specific union. But I know it's not just Pro-Tech 17 members who are worried about this. Thank you. And, um, whatever you need to close this contract outside, get it done, because I'm ready to vote on a ratification on that. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:18:06]

Thank you, Councilor Green. Councilor Smith.

**Loretta Smith** [2:18:09]

Thank you, Council President. I want to thank all the folks who came and testified today. Thank you for your patience. Thank you for holding our feet to the fire, making sure that we get it right. And I just wanted to let you know that I will be supportive of this contract and will vote for it.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:18:30]

Thank you, Councilor Smith. Councilor Kanal.

**Sameer Kanal** [2:18:35]

Thank you, Council President. Uh, I intend to vote yes on this contract as well. Uh, thank you to Rachel and the Protect 17 team. Thank you, Dan Marie, and your team as well. Um, specific to this contract, you know, Protect 17 represents, among many other city workers, responders, I'm really grateful for the new policy that was arrived at mutually on that. And I think it's important for us to show how much we continue to value these workers. Earlier today, we had conversations around public safety and talking about different responders needed for each type of incident or need that may occur in committee. And I think this is very much in line with that to continue to support the work of one of our emerging and developing departments. Thank you. Responders. I'm also very happy to see peer support specialists getting a compensation increase in this contract. How the city values this type of experience, skills, and abilities is a moral issue and should be compensated appropriately, and I'm glad that we're moving in the right direction on that. I do have 2 broader notes. This is the first time in several years that a Pro-Tech contract took this long to settle. I'm glad that we got to an agreement. It didn't have to take this long. I agree with my colleagues, any savings we might theoretically achieved through this is eaten up with the costs, and not just the financial costs, but outweighed by the combination of those financial costs and the non-financial ones of loss of morale, loss of trust, diminished work, late payments, et cetera. And then secondly, yeah, we do have a concern with— I'm hearing it from many unions as well, including those who've been here. Yeah. Today, but also including other labor representatives and partners who are not in the room or haven't spoke yet about this issue that is being perceived widely about how the city is going about interaction with our labor partners. I want to stress, you know, this— much of this, including this contract, started before our current city administrator's tenure. I'm not putting this on you, CA Lee, at all. But I do think that I think that like many other issues, you're here now and are being tasked with solving a problem that is not of your making and predates your tenure. I think this is something that we must work on. And I'm also very much in line with the 2 councilors who just spoke, or the 3 councilors who just spoke before me, in saying to those folks who are outside right now, I'm looking forward to ratifying a contract for CPPW as well. Thank you. My understanding is that the other contract, the next agenda item today, has been referred back to the mayor's office because that was actually not agreed to yet. And I would love to hear more about that later, maybe when we get off of this agenda item, when it is concluded, as to what exactly happened there, why that's being referred back to the mayor's office. But if anything, that at minimum perpetuates the feeling that we've been hearing today about where the city's at in terms of how we interact with labor. Because I was looking forward to ratifying 2 contracts that related to both sides of our community health responses. And it sounds like we're only going to be able to do the one, which I'm grateful for and I will support it, but I would have loved to do the other as well. Thank you, Councilor Perlin.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:21:49]

Thank you, Councilor Kanal. Councilor Avalos, last word.

**Candace Avalos** [2:21:54]

Thank you. Just wanted to add my voice to echo what I've heard from many councilors in that we clearly have a long way to go to restore our relationships with our employees. And with the strike that is ongoing right now, that is just another signal that we are not doing enough to ensure that our employees feel supported, not only in their contract but in just their everyday as city employees. And I, I would really urge I urge the mayor and the city administrator and the administration to continue to find ways to do that and to lean on councilors for support. I definitely stand in solidarity with CPPW as well, and I am trying to get to a place where we can ratify a contract. And whatever work that that requires, let's do it. Let's not delay. The longer that we allow folks to continue to be on strike like this, it is going to continue to hurt all of the other contracts have coming, because again, the ripple effects of the disrespect that our union employees have continuously come up to this dais to tell us that they're feeling will keep showing up, and the costs will also keep going up as a result. And I want to just take a moment to— excuse me— to thank Councilor Morillo for your words and to say that you deserve to be able to speak what you need to say. Thank you. And I really don't appreciate the lack of decorum that continues to be displayed in this chamber because points of orders are not for interrupting colleagues you disagree with. And I unfortunately am constantly seeing Councilor Morillo being interrupted, and I'm sick of the disrespect, and I demand a real point of order, which is decorum. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:23:32]

Thank you, Councilor Avalos. Colleagues, a reminder, this is an emergency ordinance. It requires 9 votes to pass.

**Steve Novick** [2:23:39]

Yes.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:23:39]

Rebecca, can we please call the roll?

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:23:42]

Calling the roll on document number 2026-412. Green?

**Mitch Green** [2:23:49]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:23:52]

Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [2:23:54]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:23:55]

Smith?

**Loretta Smith** [2:23:56]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:23:57]

Kanal?

**Sameer Kanal** [2:23:58]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:23:59]

Pirtle-Guiney?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [2:24:00]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:24:00]

Ryan?

**Dan Ryan** [2:24:01]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:24:02]

Koyama Lane?

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [2:24:03]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:24:05]

Morillo?

**Angelita Morillo** [2:24:05]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:24:06]

Novick?

**Steve Novick** [2:24:07]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:24:07]

Dunphy?

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:24:08]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:24:09]

And the ordinance passes 10 aye, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:24:13]

Thank you. Can we please call item number 13?

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:24:18]

Item number 13, amend Council Organization and Procedure Code, amend Code Chapter 3.02.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:24:26]

Colleagues, this item—.

**Sameer Kanal** [2:24:27]

Oh, sorry, may I ask a, uh, Request for information.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:24:31]

Yeah, Councilor Knoll, go ahead.

### 12. Ratify collective bargaining agreement with Portland Fire Fighters' Association – Community Health (2026-411) - referred back

**Sameer Kanal** [2:24:33]

The item that was proposed for being referred back, uh, which was item 13 on the agenda originally, can we get more information on that from either yourself or from the mayor's office as to what the rationale was for the referral back or what the timeline is that we can expect for that item to be returned to us?

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:24:54]

Still showing as item 13 on the, on the yeah, we're having our folks come on up real quick.

**Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie** [2:25:06]

Hi, Ann Marie Kevorkian-Maddie, Labor Relations again. Uh, I think I can probably address some of your questions. Um, however, uh, Isaac McLennan, the PFFA president, had originally planned to be here with me today to present this item, uh, and I think I can say safely, even on his behalf, that we were We're both surprised to find this item not ratified. We fully intended to be here today to present this item together. So for Councilor Kanal's benefit, again, this was a heavily supported item by both the city management side and by the PFFA bargaining team. Sometimes the will of the voters is different than the will of the bargaining team. Thank you. It is an uncommon occurrence. In my 20, almost 22 years with the city, I don't recall that this has happened. But I will say there is more than one way to solve a math problem. And so we are intentional about getting additional feedback. PFFA is already working on coordinating with their membership for additional feedback as soon as tomorrow. And it is my goal and Isaac McLennan's goal to meet as soon as next week. Thank you. To continue negotiating the terms. So I hope to have good news back to you all soon, but unfortunately today is not that day.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:26:27]

Thank you very much.

**Sameer Kanal** [2:26:28]

Thank you for that. Can I, can I clarify? So standard practice is you bargain it, both bargaining teams agree to it, it gets placed on an agenda ideally after the labor partner has ratified it. Is that correct?

**Ann Marie Gwarki-Maddie** [2:26:43]

Yes, that is true. This item was originally intended or scheduled to be heard on November 18th and moved up a week, which overlapped with the PFFA ratification vote. So hence the late pull of the item.

**Sameer Kanal** [2:27:03]

That makes sense. Thank you for that information. I think I'd hope that we get any updates on In whatever format is most appropriate in your view for any ongoing steps on that or any information that we need to have to be helpful to you or just asks to be helpful to you in that regard. Yeah, I think that answers my question. Thank you. Thank you, Council President. I'll note just for the record that Council Clerk had already fixed it. I just haven't reloaded the page, so the agenda item numbers are correct. Thank you.

**Unidentified speaker** [2:27:36]

Perfect.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:27:37]

Thank you very much, Councilor.

**Cynthia Castro** [2:27:38]

All right, thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:27:39]

And Rebecca, you, you did full— you finished calling this item up, right? All right, cool. I'm going to dive into my talking points then very quickly. Thank you, colleagues. This item is back in council after an extremely productive and thoughtful work session last week. Thank you. I really appreciate the— appreciate the way we went through most of the amendment concepts before us and shared our understandings on good governance and a balance of guardrails and flexibility for great leadership. So today we are back and we're going to start moving forward on voting on amendments. We do not have to rush.

### 13. Amend Council Organization and Procedure Code (2026-372)

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:28:09]

And in fact, specifically, colleagues, I intend to work on this only until about 4:45 today and then to continue it to a future item so that we can hear the item that was pulled. I have further time already saved on— for this item on the agendas in coming weeks. However, I hope that we can eventually work towards getting to a place where the underlying is good enough To move forward meaningful updates that reflect our nearly 2 years of experience as a government. This work will be ongoing, of course, but building this institution as we fly depends on codifying practices as they become norms. I'm really confident that the underlying does so in meaningful ways. And on the areas where we don't have majority consensus, we can continue to experiment with and learn about those boundaries, the edge cases and the like, and define where that consensus might be in the future. Thank you. Today we're going to begin by opening amendments roughly in the order that they were discussed in the work session, with some adjustments and corrections made in response to feedback. You all have printouts, I believe, of the amendments. A list has been published for the public to follow along. There's a document in the thing titled Presentation Amendment Order in the exhibits and the attachments. My staff is available to run slides as well. I'm going to introduce each topic area and open the floor to any councilor to make motions to amend. After we've debated and voted on the items in that topic area, we'll move on to the next one. I'm expecting that once we have closed a topic area, it should not need to be reopened. And at the end of the time we have today, as I said, we'll either extend to an additional first reading on November 18th, or if we somehow magically get through everything today, we will move the item to a second reading with that, let's begin.

**Loretta Smith** [2:29:56]

Mr. President, point of information.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:29:58]

Councilor.

**Loretta Smith** [2:29:59]

Um, I want to go back to something because I want to make sure that I am in line with the rules. And since we're going over the rules, can we have Robert Taylor come up and tell us what is supposed to happen when someone calls point of order or point of information so that I'm clear on what it is that I can say and if people are supposed to stop talking after I call point of order. Can, can we do that first? Because this is going to be a very contentious kind of thing, and I want to make sure that I am on the right track.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:30:30]

Mr. President, I will ask that, uh, Robert Taylor come over and clarify what a point of order— how a point of order is materialized.

**Robert Taylor** [2:30:49]

Uh, thank you, Council President. Uh, Robert Taylor, City Attorney, for the record. Um, so as you know, you have rules that govern, um, the meeting, including rules of decorum, uh, rules of germaneness, uh, rules about when it's appropriate to make a motion or not. And anytime a member— so those are your rules, you adopt them. Yeah. Anytime you, you think— and it's the president's job to make sure that the body follows the rules. Now, anytime any member, any individual thinks, you know what, we are not following the rules here, You can raise a point of order, and you just say, point of order, Mr. President, we are not following the rule XYZ. Okay, then the president, as the presiding officer, he makes a decision. He will say, you are correct, we're not following that rule, we need to change what we're doing so we're following the rule. Or the president will say, I disagree with you, I think we are following the rule. I disagree with you. And then that decision on the point of order is subject to appeal. So the— any, any 3 members can appeal that point of order, and then the body gets to decide. So the whole council would vote on whether to uphold the president's ruling on the point of order or not. So that's how, that's how that works. Okay. So it gives any— just Just to put a real fine point on it.

**Loretta Smith** [2:32:31]

But is the person speaking supposed to stop, or are they supposed to keep going?

**Sameer Kanal** [2:32:35]

Yes.

**Loretta Smith** [2:32:35]

Because the person, when I said point of order, they kept talking.

**Dan Ryan** [2:32:38]

Yes, sir.

**Loretta Smith** [2:32:38]

And it made it seem like I was out of order. I just thought that we were not pertinent to what we were talking about. That's all I wanted to say.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:32:45]

Well, there was already a ruling on your request.

**Robert Taylor** [2:32:49]

So when the president calls a member to order, under your rules that you've adopted for yourself, when the president calls a member to order, they must immediately stop okay.

**Loretta Smith** [2:33:02]

And then he can say whether or not he is in support of or not in support of what I am saying, but he has to listen to it. The person doesn't just keep talking before we even get an answer from the presiding officer.

**Cynthia Castro** [2:33:19]

Yeah.

**Robert Taylor** [2:33:19]

And the other— I mean, there's the calling a member to order if they're breaking the rules. If a member is called to order, they must immediately stop If the member wants to appeal to the body to be able to keep talking, they can make an appeal to the body. Okay. The other thing is the president has the authority to name which councilor speaks first when 2 members are trying to speak at the same time. And so I think if there's a situation where 2 members are talking over each other in a way that is not conducive to council business, he could call them both to order and then say, Return the body to order. Everybody please stop. Let's return to the, to the business at hand.

**Loretta Smith** [2:34:03]

Okay.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:34:06]

All right, colleagues, the time is currently 4:30. We've got about 15 minutes to do any amount of work on this, and we are going to move forward as swiftly as we can. So I'd like to continue the presentation, please.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:34:18]

I have more follow-ups for Robert. If we're going to do this, then let's do it.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:34:24]

I would prefer not to do it, honestly.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:34:26]

I don't want to do it either.

**Raymond C. Lee** [2:34:27]

Okay.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:34:28]

Colleagues, I am going to move us forward to discuss the presentation in front of us then. Thank you. We can have further conversations afterwards.

**Angelita Morillo** [2:34:33]

So there can be repeated patterns of obstruction and intimidation from Councilor Wilson?

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:34:37]

Colleagues, I'm moving us forward. I'm not recognizing anybody in the queue at this moment. Thank you. Colleagues, we have about 15 minutes. I'm going to try and move us towards some of the actual substance of this, this being our 3rd attempt having this conversation. Can we please move this forward? Thank you. The first block of amendments that I want to discuss, please, as listed in the packet presentation, regards referral to committee. As we discussed last week, there are a handful of these different amendments. The underlying— can we go back one slide, please? Stand by. The current language is on the right. The proposed underlying language as filed in the amendment is in the underlying streamlines this and clarifies a number of parts about what is referred and how those documents are moved. So there are 3 amendments filed specific to this to discuss changes. And I'm— next slide, please. I'd like to turn it over to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney to discuss Pirtle-Guiney 3. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [2:35:45]

Thank you, Council President. Pirtle-Guiney 3 maintains what we have been doing, um, but clarifies in the code what I think is a— an oversight in our language in the code in order to ensure that our current practice moves forward. So the language— and I apologize, the amendment language that is before us in the underline and the new amendment language are both in the same color in what is submitted online. So I'll talk through it. The amendment language adds 2 things. In 3.02020, after the elected official submitting an item may propose the item be first heard in a committee, And before adding that it could also be heard in full council or that the individual may indicate no preference, I am proposing that we add the language with subject matter jurisdiction as set out in subsection 3.02050. And then similarly in 3, after in a particular committee, I've added as established by subsection 3.02020. Second. B1A2, which refers to the language above. What this does is says that any of us may propose an item be heard in committee or in full council or indicate no preference, but that if we propose that an item be heard in a particular committee, we propose that it be heard in a committee with subject matter jurisdiction laid out In the code that we— or the resolution, rather, I apologize— in the resolution that the council president proposes and we adopt that lays out the committees and their jurisdictions. That leaves us a significant amount of flexibility. For example, there are many items which could be appropriately referred to the City Life Committee or the Housing and Permitting Committee. Or items which could be referred to both the Housing and Permitting Committee and our, our Infrastructure Committee. Most items that we hear could fit into the broad jurisdictions that we've created for this year's committees into multiple committees, but it would ensure that we are sending items to the committees that we have laid out they should go to in the resolution that we pass. This is our current practice. Nobody has done anything different than this over the last 2 years. But as we are updating our rules to make sure that there's clarity and we're running efficiently, I wanted to ensure that we had the opportunity to put in our code what our current practice is and to ensure that that resolution that we adopt, which lays out what our committees are, is meaningful as we do our work through the year. I'm happy to take any questions and would ask for support for this concept.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:39:04]

Are you going to formally move it?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [2:39:05]

And I will move Pirtle-Guiney— I believe this is listed as 3— Pirtle-Guiney 3.

**Dan Ryan** [2:39:10]

Second. Second.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:39:11]

Councilor Pirtle-Guiney moves Pirtle-Guiney 3 and Councilor Ryan seconds. Colleagues, discussion of Pirtle-Guiney 3?

**Sameer Kanal** [2:39:23]

Thank you, Council President. Thank you for moving this, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. I guess the first question I have from a sort of implementation perspective is how would it be determined in the moment? So, you know, in January we have the resolution that makes the committees. It's several months later, let's say, and there's an item proposed. Where the subject matter jurisdiction of a committee is in question. Is your intention that the council president makes that call? Is your intention that the submitting councilor makes the call? What— how does that actually get implemented?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [2:40:03]

Council President, may I respond?

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:40:04]

Please.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [2:40:05]

Councilor, I did not lay out an enforcement mechanism in this amendment. What I'm intending to do with this amendment is capture what our current practice is, and we haven't had any issues with this. Everything I have seen any of us over the last 2 years send to a committee has been in line with that adopted resolution. I guess we could look to the future and see somebody who tries to make an argument that is outside of the language in that resolution, but that they contend Council President could disagree with that. And certainly at that time, there would need to be a determination about who has the final say there. I would look to our city attorney to, you know, weigh in on how he might interpret the language in the future if that were to happen. I think in all cases, we have to be mindful of the fact that we are a We can't capture every single what-if in our code, and we do have to assume that we are working amongst professionals with good intent here, which I— at this moment we are. And I know we can't always make assumptions about the future. Um, if you think that we need to have a remedy in the code, I certainly would be open to working with you on one moving forward, though I would ask that we adopt this today so that we can start moving in the right direction. I am comfortable putting this forward without that remedy, but if you're not, let's talk about what that could look like.

**Sameer Kanal** [2:41:53]

I appreciate that answer. My purpose for asking that question is I'm concerned about 2 things. One is just sort of the The overutilization of council president power to direct things to committees where things can die. I think this, this relates to several other amendments as well, attempting to get rid of the discharge so that this can effectively become the state legislature. That's, that's sort of the one piece of it. And then on the other hand, just, I don't understand why this needs to be here if it's already in the resolution establishing the subject matter. Thank you. I think it's implicit in there. I agree with the assessment that it has not been a problem that's arisen. And so I would view this code provision that's being proposed in this amendment as a solution in search of a problem. And although Councilor— sorry, although Councilor Zimmerman is not here, I would imagine that the point that he made I think is appropriate when we have the work session, which is some things don't need to be written down in that explicit of a way because I think it is implicit in the code. Thank you. It in the, um, in the resolution that establishes the subject matter of the, the, um, committees in the first place. Uh, thank you, Council President.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:43:07]

Thank you, Councilor Kanal. Councilor Avalos.

**Candace Avalos** [2:43:11]

I agree with Councilor Kanal's assessment. I think it's unnecessarily pedantic, and I don't think that we need to, uh, add more language when, like, uh, Kanal said, it is implicit thank you, Councilor Avalos.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:43:34]

Councilor Smith.

**Loretta Smith** [2:43:36]

Thank you, Council President. Uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, um, I see where you're going with this, but if there was no enforcement mechanism, it would be really difficult. And I'll go back to as early as last week when we were talking about the The PBOT property being disposed of through City Life. I was not aware, and I don't know if it was posted anywhere, that the president had given you the ability to put all properties to come through City Life. Well, if we go by this, then that means that any property that is disposed of from water or, or from transportation should be going through Public Works.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:44:16]

Yes.

**Loretta Smith** [2:44:17]

Parks, and that's the appropriate committee that it should come through. But I had no idea that the president had given you that power to do all— I mean, is there a space that you can say this is true unless the president has given specific direction to have certain properties or certain properties come through a separate City Life Committee instead of it coming from Housing, I wouldn't expect water or transportation disposition to come out of City Life. I would have thought that it would come through Public Works. So for me, this doesn't work, and we need to put some kind of way that when When the president or the presiding officer gives you a particular ability to do something, there should be a place that we go to see where he gave that ability, in which committee. And I think he sits on that committee, so I'm not sure. This is just confusing to me. When I learned that you had the ability to do that— Mr. President, you can tell me, did you say that inside of a committee or a Um, a city council meeting.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:45:36]

I currently have the authority to, to send referrals. Uh, we—.

**Loretta Smith** [2:45:41]

I mean, did you let the public— did you let the other folk— and that's what I'm saying, unless there is a—.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:45:46]

I, I made a scheduling decision to, to have a singular, singular place for the same types of legislative action.

**Loretta Smith** [2:45:51]

And, and I have no problem with your power and what you can do with it and how you use it, but what I'm saying, this particular amendment says it will go through the appropriate committee, which would supersede what you're saying because you gave her permission to have it all come through City Life. And so that's what I'm saying, that if it doesn't go through the correct committee, which one would think it would, then how am I supposed to know about it or to, to get any additional information if I don't sit on your committee and know it?

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:46:25]

Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [2:46:26]

Thank you, Council President. This is actually a great example of something that could go to multiple committees. Right. There are many items that we have heard this year where there has been a conversation amongst committee chairs about where it should go, given that there are multiple appropriate committees. And the conversation around land disposition was in fact around whether land disposition should go to the committee that is related to the bureau disposing of the land, or whether land disposition should be batched together and go to the committee that is talking about what our city is like, what life in our city is like, and how the disposition of land affects that. And those are both, I think, under the current resolution laying out committees, very legitimate placements. Now, we've had 2 council presidents who have looked to that resolution to determine where items should be sent, and we have had 12 councilors who have made requests about where their items are sent based on the language in the resolution. But there is currently nothing in our code that says we have to follow the descriptions in that resolution? There's not. So we could in the future have somebody make a request to send a land disposition from a housing item to the Public Safety Committee, and there is nothing in our code that would allow the council president to do anything other than send it there. So if we want to have a sense of where things go, If we want to have some consistency, I am suggesting that we say in code that we want that resolution to mean something, that we want it to have teeth, and that we want to be able to rely on, as you said, Councilor Smith, knowing where items are going. And this would be the way to do that in the future. But if we still would have the flexibility that we have right now when an item could fall to multiple committees To make a choice as a councilor about where we want to send it. And the council president still would have the flexibility that the council president has now on administrative items, because those are separate from councilor-led items where a councilor gets to choose where it goes. On administrative-led items, to work with committee chairs to determine the right place to send that item or to decide on the council president's own. This doesn't change any of those things. Thank you. But it ensures that what we approve in that resolution actually has some teeth to guide where we request that our items be sent to committee. So I appreciate the second and again would ask for folks' support in ensuring that that work that we do be meaningful. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:49:28]

Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. Colleagues, I'm going to limit discussion of this item to those in the queue. Councilor Kanal and then Councilor Ryan.

**Sameer Kanal** [2:49:39]

Thank you, Council President. I think this is a really important place to note that this is really about who solves a problem. Because as Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said, there's nothing in our code that would allow the council president to do anything other than send it to a committee of the filing councilor's choosing. That's true. But that implies something that I don't think is true, which is that there's no way to fix it. There is and remains a way to fix it, which is that if somebody were to send a land disposition issue from the Water Bureau to the Public Safety Committee, the Public Safety Committee has no interest in necessarily giving up its time for that agenda item and can refer it as a committee, refer it back to the relevant committee of its choice. And so there is a failsafe, and I think that that creates a deterrent from abusing the system, which, as has been noted, has not been abused to date. There have been some places where there's been, you know, gray areas. Does it make sense here? Does it make sense there? But I don't think that we require empowering the council president solely to solve a problem when we have the ability to solve it ourselves. And this is really about the relative level of empowerment of the council president. Thank you. Which is why I asked that question in the first place. So, um, that I think is, is really the, the reason why it's not necessary.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:50:58]

Thank you, Councilor Connell. Councilor Ryan, last word.

**Dan Ryan** [2:51:02]

Yes, uh, thank you, Council President. I did second this amendment because I think, um, it's a step in the right direction, so I remain supportive. However, this conversation just reminds me why I'm supportive of us eliminating the committees and just going to an entire council. Because then I think everything is transparent, everything's on the table, and we don't continue to have these long conversations that circle around.

**Modesta Minthorn** [2:51:26]

Thanks.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:51:26]

Thank you, Councilor Ryan. Rebecca, can we please call the roll on Pirtle-Guiney 3?

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:51:32]

Pirtle-Guiney 3. Green?

**Mitch Green** [2:51:35]

No.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:51:38]

Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [2:51:40]

No.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:51:41]

Smith?

**Loretta Smith** [2:51:41]

No.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:51:46]

No.

**Loretta Smith** [2:51:46]

No.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:51:49]

Aye.

**Candace Avalos** [2:51:50]

Aye.

**Loretta Smith** [2:51:53]

No.

**Dan Ryan** [2:51:57]

No.

**Wendy Cully** [2:51:57]

Aye.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:51:59]

No.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:52:02]

And the amendment fails with 7 nay, 3 aye, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:52:07]

All right, colleagues, well, it is the time is 4:47, so I am going to be continuing this item to a future council meeting. Can we please move to—.

**Sameer Kanal** [2:52:14]

Council President, just for, for ease of the next, um, meeting, can I, can I just put on the record some amendments are being withdrawn?

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:52:24]

Sure, absolutely.

**Sameer Kanal** [2:52:26]

Okay, I won't go into the explanations. I may— I'll put it out some other way for, for those to know, but I just want to note that I will be withdrawing, uh, 8 of the amendments that that have been put up in the past, and just so that folks know they're not coming and we don't need to make a— make time for it. And so I'll read those in numerical order. So Canal 2A, 2B, 2C are all being replaced with a new 2D. So 2A, B, and C are all being withdrawn. 7, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, And 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 13B, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, as 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, in 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131, boy, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146 are all being withdrawn. I think some of them are worth discussing at other times, but don't necessarily need to be in this ordinance. And I would look forward to talking with colleagues about some of the concepts in it in another time. But just wanted to get those on the record so that the next time probably Evan has to make the spreadsheet, you don't have to put all those on there. Thank you, Council President.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:53:22]

Thank you, Councilor Kanal. Rebecca, can we please call item number 7, or I guess It's item—.

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:53:27]

It's item— new item 14.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:53:29]

New item 14. There we go.

### 14. Authorize conveyance of Menlo Park Water Tower site to Habitat for Humanity (2026-344)

**Rebecca Dobert** [2:53:31]

Uh, item 14, authorize conveyance of city-owned real property, formerly Menlo Park water tower site, to Habitat for Humanity Portland Metro East, doing business as Habitat for Humanity Portland Region. Document number 2026-344.

**Jamie Dunphy** [2:53:45]

Thank you, colleagues. This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance. I would like to start by apologizing, first of all, to Lacey Sutton, who has spent her entire for the purposes of the public, any item on a consent agenda, even if it is a second reading, may be removed by any member of the public or any member of this body. It does not require a councilor to withdraw something from it, even if it is a second amendment because— or second reading, because second readings can be amended. So I apologize for the misinformation. And with that, we are now in this item. And colleagues this is an emergency— or this is a second reading of a non-emergency ordinance. We will be voting on this. Is there further council discussion? Councilor Smith.

**Loretta Smith** [2:54:28]

Thank you, Council President. Uh, and just for the record, I'm pulling— I pulled this item from the consent agenda because I believe that the public deserves clear answers on how the City of Portland manages, values, and transfers taxpayer-owned land. First, let me be completely let me be clear about this. I strongly support building 22 family-sized affordable homes for homeownership in East Portland, and I appreciate the track record of Habitat for Humanity. My objection today is not to the mission of affordable housing. My objection is to the disposition process that leaves the public in the dark On basic financial and timeline accountability. Specifically, I have 3 major concerns that must be answered on the record before I can support this transfer. Number 1, there is no current property valuation or value for money test. We are being asked to approve a non-competitive disposition of 2 city-owned tax lots, R2-1676 164 and R2-16769 without a current independent appraisal in the public record. We know from the City Budget Office analysis that the Portland Housing Bureau paid the Water Bureau $225,110 out of the housing investment fund for these parcels back in 2023, yet today, 2026, we are transferring this public asset without a disclosed current valuation, without a transparent justification of, of why a competitive disposition process was bypassed, and without clear metrics showing how the public is capturing fair value for the subsidy. Second, unexplained 2-year delay since the 2024 council action. In 2024, council authorized the transfer of the adjacent southern parcels to Habitat for Humanity, and these former Water Bureau lots were acquired by Portland Housing Bureau back in 2023. Why has it taken over 2 years since that 2024 council action to bring this companion land transfer forward? Question. East Portland families cannot afford multi-year administrative bottlenecks. When we have a public land sitting idle, before we rubber stamp this ordinance, the bureau needs to explain what caused this delay and what steps are being taken so future land transfers do not stall for two years. The third thing that I'm concerned about is delegating enforceable terms out of public view. Finally, this ordinance delegates. The actual terms, conditions, conveyance documents to the city administrator after our vote today, which means they can either charge a cost for the lots, they can either add money to the lots without us knowing about it from the Portland Housing Bureau. They can do a number of things with this piece of property that we have no idea what the value of these 2 properties are. Thank you. That means council is being asked to give away public land before the public can see the binding affordability covenant, the exact duration of the affordability requirement, or the recapture provisions that protect taxpayers if these units ever convert to market rates. And my request, lastly, is transparency and accountability are not negotiable, especially when we're dealing with scarce public land and housing dollars. There was no mention about whether housing investment funds would be used to help this project pencil. And after the fact, whatever they do inside the bureau, as long as those dollars were appropriated, they can spend them. There was so much conversation about where monies went to with— when we talked to minority community-based organizations and how much money they were to get. There was such a big to-do, but you can't tell me that no dollars will follow this contract in addition to the giving away of the property, which is zero. That's what we know right now. So I want to know what it is, what it's going to be before we actually do it, if they're going to add any additional dollars to it, the current appraised value of these 2 parcels, and the written justification for sole source disposition. A clear accounting of why this transfer took 2 years following the 2024 council vote, and the draft conveyance terms, specifically the affordability period and the recapture projections, before this council takes a final vote. Until those basic safeguards and answers are in front of us, I cannot vote to approve this disposition on a, on a consent agenda. And since I don't I don't sit on the Housing Committee. Once again, there are people who are sitting here who sit on that Housing Committee. I don't know if you discussed this. I don't know if this was ever an issue, but it is an issue for me. And there are strict guidelines to disposing of surplus property that we must go through. If we give this over to the city administrator, he does not have to follow any of those rules. Councilwoman, I'm sorry, I'm sorry. So if somebody could give me some answers to this, whether it be the DCA Oliveira, someone who— the, the chair of the Housing Committee, did you ask these questions? I have no idea, but I'm coming in cold with this, and it caught me because the same thing happened at Multnomah County for a property on Williams Street that I had to stop because they did not follow the disposition rules. Okay. So, um, I am a blessing and a curse in many ways. But I do want to know what happened. What's the value of this property?

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:00:47]

Thank you, Councilor. Council President, uh, Donnie Oliveira, for the record, Deputy City Administrator for Community Economic Development. Uh, Councilor, I'm going to start by answering a couple of the questions and hand it over to my colleague, uh, to kind of walk through some of the specifics you asked for. Uh, first, I just want to take a moment to acknowledge, uh, following up on a conversation this body had recently related to the disposition of how of city property and the potential for, for housing development. I think this is an exact moment where we're showing you all what it looks like when our bureaus are working together to find the right properties for housing. Given that the fact that these properties are adjacent to existing Habitat for Humanity properties, it made a lot of sense for the Housing Bureau, once the Water Bureau flagged that they were available, to purchase them and make it available. So this is kind of speaking to that conversation from a couple weeks ago. Second, related to the turnaround time and why it took 2 years, Councilor, frankly speaking, this is not the only deal that the bureau is working on. There's many deals across the city with many partners that they're responsible to. And frankly, our parties, our partners need to be ready to develop once we transfer these projects over with all the capital stack necessary to make these— this project real. So practically speaking, from a housing development timeline perspective, this 2-year window is appropriate. I would say that this is consistent with other projects we have, not just passed but in the pipeline, for when we have these sorts of complex deals that have different funding options. So I'll start— I'll stop there and hand it over to Tanya to kind of walk through the value and some of the other mechanics you requested.

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [3:02:19]

Hi, good afternoon, councilors. My name is Tanya Wolfersberger. I manage the construction services team at the Portland Housing Bureau. I'm happy to answer the questions you might need to like kind of go one by one so I can remember them all.

**Loretta Smith** [3:02:32]

So can we start like back in, uh, 2023, the, um, Housing Bureau, uh, transferred this over to, uh— no, the Water Bureau transferred this over to the Portland Housing Bureau for $225,000. And so I didn't see a, um, I didn't see an appraisal of what the property was worth at the time. I just saw the number, and I just looked at the, um, the council operations, um, description of what happened. And so that didn't fly well with me because I know you have to have an appraisal, an official appraisal. And was there an appraisal done?

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [3:03:10]

Yes, there was. The Water Bureau conducted an appraisal to determine the, the amount that we would, uh—.

**Loretta Smith** [3:03:16]

And it was the $225,000?

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [3:03:18]

That's correct.

**Loretta Smith** [3:03:18]

Is there a way that we can get a copy of that appraisal?

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [3:03:21]

Um, I may have a copy. If I don't, then the Water Bureau will definitely have it in their records. Yes.

**Loretta Smith** [3:03:27]

And was there any written description of why we, um, we were giving this as a single source without a competitive RFP on this?

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [3:03:36]

Uh, well, just to be clear that the disposition to Habitat for Humanity is for the land only. It is not paired with any development funding at the time. We, we don't Right now, we don't have any identified development funding for this, but part of why the Housing Bureau was interested, not only because it's adjacent to currently owned Habitat land, is that we determined— we predicted that it would become a future TIF district and may have development funding available at that time. If that was the case, then we would put out a solicitation. Habitat could come in and apply for those TIF dollars or any other You know, vertical development dollars that we made available.

**Loretta Smith** [3:04:19]

But what you— in doing that, you didn't put that in anybody else's space. This is all in your heads. This is not a council decision that was made, because when you have surplus property, you have to put it on, you have to put it up, and you— and people have to see. There could have been a private sector developer who wanted to give us $500,000 for that property and buy it straight out and put a middle housing project. And so I've been pushing very hard in East Portland. That's my district. And the reason why I did this was because, because you all thought it would be better for an affordable housing project. Maybe there was a middle-income project that could have been right next door to it so that we can bring as much money into this East Portland as we possibly can. And I love it because yes. Because it's, it's homeownership. I'm not against the project at all. I'm just against the process that you all made some assumptions without actually bringing it to council to let them make that, um, that policy decision. You made those policy decisions in-house. And I can appreciate you saying that, you know, you didn't have enough bandwidth to do all these projects that you have in line, but there's nothing that prevents the city administrator once he— once we take over our jurisdiction and give it to him, he can tell you, Donnie Oliveira, go give me— get me $5 million out of the Housing Investment Fund. I'm going to attach that to this, to this project because I think it's that important.

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:05:47]

Councilor, may I just— just in this particular case, and a couple of things I alluded to it, but I'll, I'll try to make the point more clear. In this particular case, with the acquisition of these properties in conjunction with the, the properties that Habitat owned, it made that broader parcel make a lot more sense. It increases the likelihood that this type of project will pencil out now that Habitat has all those parcels to work with. It strengthens their— it strengthens their position. Second, to your point about options, absolutely. We always look at different properties with where's the highest and best use of the land for what type of development. In this particular case, the Housing Bureau policy team, which I support, looked at this as let's leverage the existing land that Habitat owns to maximize that development opportunity. And then to the last point about opportunities to put money in, I think Tanya was alluding to it. We're not in for the development. That's 100% on Habitat's. We're just kind of giving them the keys to this. And all development projects are complex, and we have to allow our staff, our subject matter experts— I think Councilor Gaines was alluding to this earlier. To be in position to make smart decisions when the decision point is timely. And so I know it feels like 2 years is a long runway for you, Councilor, but in a development cycle, this is incredibly appropriate and frankly, like, ideal for us to work with our housing developers to do something like this. So I would just kind of ask you to respect that our staff are putting together a really good proposal in front of you today. Thank you. That will give one of our key partners in housing production a chance to do something important for the city.

**Loretta Smith** [3:07:22]

And I hope that when there are other lots that are available, that when minority community-based organizations come and they want to get free property— because this is what this is, this is free property— that they're given the same kind of deals put forward. Because this is— there's— we have codes for disposition and we didn't follow them.

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [3:07:43]

Yes.

**Loretta Smith** [3:07:43]

And that's the issue. You follow them when you want them or when somebody calls you out on them. And that's what I'm saying. If it's going to be the same everywhere, then make it the same. But it's not. This is doing 2 things. This one is giving property away without having the appraisal available to the public online and to us. 2, We could have put this up if, if the case was we didn't know. We— I believe we knew we, we wanted to do this all along for Habitat for Humanity. You said you didn't know, but you did know you were going to do this for Habitat for Humanity all along.

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:08:25]

No, Councilor, to be clear, we, we did know that Habitat owned the adjacent properties. That's, that's why this felt like a good, good move.

**Loretta Smith** [3:08:31]

But did they ask you for it, or you just assumed that you would be able to, to to transfer it to them and have them do a bigger project, or did they want it, or is this something you wanted to offer to them?

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:08:40]

At the time, the old former government, the commissioner at that time of the Housing Bureau was in coordination with Habitat for Humanity, yes.

**Dan Ryan** [3:08:47]

Okay.

**Loretta Smith** [3:08:48]

And like I said, all the information wasn't there, wasn't available, and how this whole thing came about, it just came out of the, out of the air that this is coming. And so, and the other is not you, um, DCA Oliveira, Um, I am still so frustrated with the fact that a year later we don't have the entire list of all the properties that the City of Portland owns. And, um, we were given a report in our Public Works, uh, committee a couple weeks ago that basically said we had $82.5 billion worth of property, but they could not connect the dollars with the properties, and they, they, they needed another 6 months to do that. Well, how do you know we got $82.5 billion worth of property if you don't know which properties they are? So I don't understand it. And so this is another example. That example, the Piedmont example over there off of Powell, is another example. Properties are popping up all over the place. People say they don't know about it, but then we got it on our agenda. And so that's why I'm a little frustrated and concerned in asking these questions, because because somebody knows about these properties. They really do. And so why it's being slow-walked, I have no understanding. But like I said, I like the project. It is in my district. I would have liked this project to go and, and, and be started, uh, many, many years ago because we have so few opportunities to get new homeownership. And it didn't also say if this is going to be up to the 80%, so I have no information. Councilwoman? Because I didn't sit on the Housing Committee, and that's why I'm— when I saw it, I was like, uh-uh, my mind went a different way. So is this 80% of MFI? Is this 100%, 120%? What kind of property is this?

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [3:10:35]

I believe, Councilor, this is limited to 80% AMI and below.

**Loretta Smith** [3:10:40]

Okay, I can check on that. Just give me a sec. And if you could get me a copy of the appraisal, because I assume since that was 2 years ago, that appraisal does not, um, work today, that, that, that we need a new appraisal of the property, correct? Because the appraisal was done maybe, uh, 2, 3 years ago.

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:11:04]

Councilor, I don't believe we would go back for another appraisal at this time. I think that's still a relatively reasonable number to, to work from.

**Loretta Smith** [3:11:10]

Are you sure?

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:11:13]

I would say it's pretty consistent.

**Loretta Smith** [3:11:15]

Well, I, I talked to Prosper Portland about some things, and, and they were looking at a appraisal for, for a piece of property, um, from a few years ago, and now they're saying that that's not good. So if they're not accepting properties from 3-year-old appraisals, then so we're accepting 2-year-old, 3-year-old appraisals?

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:11:35]

Councilor, there's a lot of, a lot of specifics that go into the volatility of a particular parcel location, what's on the property already. So it's, it's rarely an apples-to-apples comparison on how how relevant.

**Loretta Smith** [3:11:47]

And, um, you don't think it's changed? You don't think its value has gone up?

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:11:52]

I, I do not, Councilor.

**Jamie Dunphy** [3:11:53]

And Councilor Smith, you're at, uh, just over 15 minutes.

**Loretta Smith** [3:11:56]

Okay, thank you, um, presiding officer. Thank you so much. But if you could give me that information— like I said, I like the project. I'm not against the project. I'm just against how it was, how it was brought to us.

**Candace Avalos** [3:12:07]

Sure.

**Tanya Wolfersberger** [3:12:07]

And I just want to confirm it is at 80% AMI and below. That's what it would be restricted for, and it will Uh, our affordable housing restrictions for 99-year affordability coverage.

**Loretta Smith** [3:12:19]

Yeah, thank you so much.

**Jamie Dunphy** [3:12:20]

Thank you, Councilor. Councilor Kanal?

**Sameer Kanal** [3:12:25]

Yeah, first on a, on a process note, you know, that I appreciate folks who stuck around for this item. Um, to the previous item, there's an amendment, Kanal 10, which would make it so that consent agenda items, if pulled, are just immediately dealt with right after the consent agenda, and I think that would save everybody a lot of time. Also keep fresh in our minds the conversations we were having at the time of the pulling from the consent agendas. So just wanted to note that. With relation to the content of this, most of what I was going to say was said by Councilor Smith, but I do think that there's a broader conversation here about the disposition that's important. The part that I really want to follow up on and maybe get more information since I think we're I think the last time for today and probably won't end up deciding on this today is if we can get more of the information on how we know what the city administrator is going to do. Because from the outside, it does appear to me the same way it appears to Councilor Smith, that it's sort of just up to the administration to make it happen. And I think there are probably some guardrails built in on that or some intentions built in on that that Is just not in this particular document. And so I, I'd love DC Oliveira or whoever else to just sort of provide us with what is intended. Um, that, that's, I think, the, the piece that's, that's missing there, especially given that we've had concerns raised with Habitat from not just the one testifier, but, but others as well in terms of how they've done things. Um, so I just wanted to make sure that we had that information on the record before the eventual vote. Thank you, Council President.

**Jamie Dunphy** [3:13:57]

Thank you, Councilor.

**Donnie Oliveira** [3:13:59]

Can do.

**Jamie Dunphy** [3:14:01]

Colleagues, as previously mentioned, this is the second reading of an ordinance, so we are moving on to a vote. If there's no one else in the queue, Rebecca, please call the roll.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:10]

Green?

**Mitch Green** [3:14:11]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:13]

Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [3:14:14]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:15]

Smith?

**Loretta Smith** [3:14:19]

I am supportive of this project, but I still do want that information. Even if I vote aye on this, and I'll say aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:28]

Thank you. Kanal?

**Sameer Kanal** [3:14:30]

Ditto, aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:32]

Pirtle-Guiney?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [3:14:33]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:34]

Ryan?

**Dan Ryan** [3:14:36]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:37]

I'm sorry, there was, uh, uh, Ryan, thank you. Councilor Malane?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [3:14:45]

Sorry, my home is noisy.

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [3:14:47]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:48]

Thank you. Thank you. Morillo?

**Angelita Morillo** [3:14:50]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:51]

Novick?

**Steve Novick** [3:14:51]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:52]

Dunphy?

**Jamie Dunphy** [3:14:53]

Aye.

**Rebecca Dobert** [3:14:54]

And the ordinance passes 10 aye, 2 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [3:14:56]

Thank you very much. With that, we are adjourned.
