# Portland City Council Finance & Governance Committee (Whole) 11/05/26 # Meeting ID: 2026-11-05-fgc-1 Duration: 189 min [00:07:03] Sameer Kanal: It is 9:31 AM on November 5th, 2026. I don't have a gavel, so that is a cell phone that I am hitting. Um, Rebecca, will you please call the roll? [00:07:15] Rebecca Dobert: Good morning. Clark? [00:07:19] Olivia Clark: Here. [00:07:20] Rebecca Dobert: Zimmerman? Avalos? [00:07:24] Candace Avalos: Present. [00:07:25] Rebecca Dobert: Smith? [00:07:27] Loretta Smith: Here. [00:07:35] Rebecca Dobert: Ryan? [00:07:36] Dan Ryan: Here. [00:07:37] Rebecca Dobert: Koyama Lane? [00:07:39] Tiffany Koyama Lane: I'm sick, but I'm here. [00:07:42] Rebecca Dobert: Morillo? [00:07:44] Angelita Morillo: Ah, I am here. [00:07:47] Rebecca Dobert: Novick? [00:07:47] Steve Novick: Here. [00:07:49] Rebecca Dobert: Dunphy? [00:07:50] Jamie Dunphy: I'm here. [00:07:51] Rebecca Dobert: Kanal? [00:07:52] Sameer Kanal: Here. Thank you. And Christopher, could you please read the statement of conduct? [00:07:58] Unidentified speaker: Yes, good morning. Welcome to the meeting of the Finance and Governance Committee of the Whole. To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/committee-whole or by calling 311. Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link. Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting. In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard. [00:08:23] Rebecca Dobert: If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise. Your microphone will be muted when your time is over. The chair preserves order. Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed. If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given. Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting, or in this case, being muted. Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass. Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually. Second. Your testimony should address the matter being considered. When testifying, state your name for the record. [00:08:56] Unidentified speaker: If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent. Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name. Thank you. [00:09:06] Sameer Kanal: Thank you both. So colleagues, today we've got a full agenda. We probably will not get to the last item, which is a continuation of the council leadership election process discussion. That'll be most likely continued to another meeting. I would like to try to get through everything else, or at least the testimony on the last thing. So we have first our minutes approval, which I'll go to in a second, then the committee chair update. After that, we will be discussing the investment policy of the city, which is an annual resolution that we adopt with the exhibit to that resolution being the investment policy itself. We've had a couple discussions on this stemming from an amendment last year to a work session kind of conversation in August, and this is the actual document coming back to us for first discussion and potentially referral to the full council. And then after that, we'll continue the 2 items from the chemical weapons discussion from last meeting, starting with the testimony. We'll be reading those 2 items together into the record. So with that, Rebecca, could you please read the first item into the record? [00:10:14] Rebecca Dobert: Item 1, Finance and Governance Committee of the Whole minutes for August 6th, 2026, August 13th, 2026, September 3rd, 2026, September thank you. [00:10:35] Sameer Kanal: Minutes for these 7 meetings will be approved by unanimous consent. If there are no objections, then they'll be approved. Are there any objections? Seeing none and seeing some head shakes to that, the minutes are approved. Thank you. Thank you. Beck, can you please read item 2? [00:10:53] Rebecca Dobert: Item 2, Committee Chair Updates, document number 2026-394. [00:10:59] Sameer Kanal: Thank you. So the chair's update for this week, I don't have printouts obviously, but they are posted online. And we'll get to Councilor Novick's portion in just a moment. But I did want to just kind of flag that most of the appointments that were flagged on the 18th have been moved up to next week, the 12th of November, and will follow the Future of Downtown presentation and discussion colleagues in the workgroup have been working on. There are a few appointments that are still scattered around through the rest of the year, and we're trying to consolidate those as well. The other thing I wanted to bring back up is that there will be an oversight hearing on December 3rd. We do have one foreclosure that was tabled that we'll be bringing back. The other foreclosures have been— the administration has asked to hold those back for a little longer, so those probably won't come until next year, but the one that was tabled will come back. Thank you. And that's pretty much it for the first page. Nothing new on the second page of things that are proposed but not yet scheduled. Really nothing else that's new at all other than the fact that we're about to handle the one upcoming council deadline for the administration in a future agenda item today. Any questions for me before I pass it over to Chair Novick from the Community and Public Safety Committee? Chair Novick, please take it away. Thank you, Council President Jamie Dunphy. [00:12:23] Steve Novick: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So we've got 3 meetings of the committee left in the year. On the 17th, um, Councilor Morillo is going to chair a meeting which will include codification of the Community Safety Bureau as recommended with the PS— by the PSR committee report on the PSSA. Um, and then on the 1st, we're going to continue our discussion of police response times. Following up on some of the things that the police said the last time we discussed them and asked them for, you know, information behind what they said. For example, they said that they're dealing with more— one of the reasons for lower response times, they're dealing with more complex situations and they're, you know, paying more attention to de-escalating situations, etc., which implies that, okay, that means that there's calls that are taking more time than calls used to take 10 years ago. So what I'm asking them is, okay, can you break that down for us? Does that mean that 10 years ago you had 250 calls that required 3 hours of police officer time on scene, and now you have 1,600 of them. I mean, what's the, uh, what's the numbers behind that? Uh, they also told us that the number of self-initiated calls has gone up, which they think is a good thing. So my question is, okay, that implies that, um, you have decided that some forms of self-initiated calls are more important than improving response times in some kinds of calls. So can you break that down for us? So those will be some of the questions we're going to be asking them. And we also are going to ask Chief Day to give us an update on whether they're taking more advantage of restorative justice programs, because what we heard before is that there's restorative justice programs that they're looking for referrals from the police that aren't getting them. [00:14:13] Dan Ryan: So. [00:14:14] Isaiah Kaplan: Thank you. [00:14:14] Steve Novick: So we're going to ask the chief if he has any update on that. On the 15th, we're going to have a discussion of property crimes. According to national statistics, we are 2nd worst in the nation in property crimes. So we want to explore that. Which particular crimes are we particularly bad at? Pick some cities to compare us to. Pick some demographics of cities to compare us to. And do we have— and also talk a bit about clearance rates. Are our clearance rates better or worse than other places? What might we do to improve them? And then on the 15th, we'll also have a call allocation study update. For example, what we'd heard before that on welfare checks that we should be moving towards unarmed folks taking more of the welfare checks, but that would require additional training, changes to labor contracts, etc. So I want to know what progress has been made. Are there any benchmarks we've already passed? What needs to be done to move ahead with that? So that's what I got. Unless Councilor Morillo wants to add anything, if there's any other topics you want to add on to, other than the Community Safety Bureau, that you want to add on to the 17th. [00:15:24] Angelita Morillo: No, I think you covered it all. We were looking at a few different potential items, but it was sort of a quick turnaround to try to get more folks all right. [00:15:40] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Chair Novick. I see Councilor Ryan's in the queue. So, Councilor Ryan, do you have a question? [00:15:45] Dan Ryan: I just wanted to thank Councilor Novick for that preview. I'm not on the committee, so it really helps to hear what's coming up. And I'll just plug how important ride-alongs are. [00:15:54] Steve Novick: I do 2 a year. [00:15:55] Dan Ryan: I spent Friday night from 8:00 PM to 3:00 AM into Saturday morning. It was just so telling and everything that Councilor Novick was saying, I now have some really good insight into what he was talking about because I keep it fresh in terms of ride-alongs. I hope all the colleagues are doing those. So it's the biggest part of our budget, and it's important for us to have insight into what goes on. And the best way to see that is a ride-along. [00:16:21] Rebecca Dobert: Thank you. [00:16:21] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Councilor Ryan. Chair Novick, I just have one clarifying question, which is you mentioned the 3rd meeting coming up the 15th. December 15th, right? And yes, and I guess the other piece— actually, sorry, that was on December 1st. You mentioned the conversation included restorative justice on December 1st as well. [00:16:46] Steve Novick: Yes, we just want to— I mean, we know that the police haven't been taking advantage of referrals to restorative justice programs. We know that the chief is a believer in restorative justice programs. I just want to ask the chief to come back and say, you know, have you taken any steps to increase the extent to which we're taking advantage of those programs? [00:17:03] Sameer Kanal: Appreciate it. I actually got asked about this at a community event a couple days ago, so excited to be able to report back and say this is the date to come in. All right, any other questions related to the chair's update? Okay, with that, we will move forward. Rebecca, will you please call item 3? [00:17:23] Rebecca Dobert: Item 3, adopt City of Portland Investment Policy, document number 2026-396. [00:17:31] Sameer Kanal: All right, colleagues, last year we had an amendment made to the investment policy resolution, but not to the investment policy itself, which is an exhibit on it. We then had a report back from our chief financial officer, Joe Spiri, who's here with us today, as well as our investment officer and our treasurer. In August, and we kind of had a presentation discussion and preliminary feedback. The resolution has been refiled by the, by the mayor's office, and we are here, and this is the next step. We can continue this conversation and/or refer it to the full council today. And with that, I'll pass it over to Chief Financial Officer Jonas Beery. [00:18:11] Jonas Beery: Great. Thank you, Chair. And just kind of thumbs up that you can hear me okay. Awesome. Thank you so much. Good morning, Chair, Councilors. For the record, Jonas Beery, the city's chief financial officer. You'll hear a little bit from me and Treasurer Bridget O'Callaghan here just briefly this morning so we can get to, I think, public testimony and questions. So we're here today to move forward the city's investment policy for calendar year 2027. This proposed legislation, as the Chair identified, is responsive to Resolution 3773. Thank you. Approved by council in December of last year and reflects community engagement conducted during 2026 and reflects the prior conversation with this committee a couple of months ago. In addition to fulfilling the city's core fiduciary and legal responsibilities related to investment of public dollars, this legislation proposes adding a supplemental screening tool to advance an ethical investment policy, as was discussed and described in last year's council directive. And while we presented some background to you in September, for full public transparency, We'll very briefly touch on some of those key points again today with regard to the city's current investment portfolio and policy, and then we'll describe the new recommended policy section regarding that additional investment screen. Next slide, please. Yep, got it. Thank you. [00:19:30] Sameer Kanal: Just for one second. Of course. Whoever's sharing the slides, can you go to display settings and invert the— we're seeing your backend view. [00:19:39] Bridget O'Callaghan: Oh, my apologies. Apologies. [00:19:43] Sameer Kanal: Go up to the top. It should be display settings. [00:19:47] Bridget O'Callaghan: My apologies, because this is not my forte. Display settings. I'm not seeing that. [00:20:00] Sameer Kanal: I'm seeing it up at the top of your screen. [00:20:04] Bridget O'Callaghan: Here. My apologies. I don't use Zoom very often. And then swap. Is that what I'm trying to do? Thank you. My apologies about that. [00:20:11] Sameer Kanal: No worries. Sorry for the interruption. Yeah, it's great. Sorry for the interruption, CFO Beery. [00:20:17] Jonas Beery: No worries. Thank you for flagging that. I can't see my screen as I'm looking at my notes here, so appreciate any help along the way. All right. So let me make sure we're on here. Yeah, purpose slide. Great. So the city's investment policy provides a clear framework and criteria that can be objectively followed by the city's investment professionals in managing the city's investment portfolio. Next slide, please. Like most government investment frameworks, the investment policy encourages safe and low-risk investments. Its objectives are to preserve principal, ensure liquidity, i.e., ensure that funds are available to spend when they're needed to cover expenditures, and lastly, to earn a market return. And by market return, we mean consistent with benchmarks that mirror the city's conservative investment constraints. Next slide. All right. So the policy is guided and superseded by state law related to public investments, including a requirement for annual readoption of the policy, which is the resolution before you today. We are obligated— the council is obligated to pass that policy by the end of the calendar year so that our investment professionals can continue investing public funds beginning January 1st. The policy is written in alignment with State Treasury templates and expectations, and it's periodically reviewed for next slide, please. And then we wanted to just acknowledge here, we've had some dialogue about this obviously over the last many months, but wanted to acknowledge that socially responsible investing has been a city priority since at least the early 2010s, and the city's been a national leader in this space. This slide lists some of the major discussions, prior council directives, and implementation actions that demonstrate the city's continuous evolution to stay at the forefront of socially responsible investing. And today's proposal will continue that leadership. And now I'll hand to City Treasurer O'Callaghan to describe the current investment portfolio and current investment limitations. [00:22:20] Bridget O'Callaghan: Great. Thank you, CFO Beery. For the record, my name is Bridget O'Callaghan, and I'm the City Treasurer. Also joining me here today is the city's investment officer, Michael Montgomery. By way of history and background, the city's— the city manages all city funds in a pool, which means that funds from any collection point, whether they be taxes, fees, et cetera, are all centrally collected by the city's Treasury Department. If you sort of think of us as the bank for the city in the sense that we collect the funds, but we also finance transactions through our public finance arm. So they are all managed— the funds are all managed centrally. It represents the operating funds or the cash assets, if you will, for the city. Okay. As of June 30th, that was approximately $2.8 billion. It's closer to $3 billion today. The net investment earnings on that portfolio are distributed based upon the allocated fund balances. So if you will, whatever Treasury earns on the funds are all returned back directly to those funds, those programs for which the balances were attributed to. And in 2020, fiscal year 2026-27, that was $117 million. Now I've just done something strange to my screen, so my apologies here. Um, this is not again my forte, and I've managed to get myself to a point where I can't change slides. So, um—. [00:24:00] Sameer Kanal: Please click on the slide that you would like to return to or scroll back okay, give me one moment to try and do that. [00:24:09] Bridget O'Callaghan: All right, is that—. [00:24:12] Sameer Kanal: Rebecca. [00:24:13] Bridget O'Callaghan: Okay, we're back. Give me one second. Okay, my apologies, this is, uh, not my expertise. All right, so the city's historical earnings, um, as you will see, um, we, um, historically have earned, um, a market return on the funds, and it is Jonas referenced that's the important part about what we're doing, right? Our first— first and foremost, our goal is to preserve the principal. Then it's to make sure that it's liquid and available when we need to spend it, and then to earn a market return. And you can see here some most recent history in terms of the funds. Again, all the funds this past year, $117 million was returned directly to the bureaus where those funds were attributed to. Now, for some reason, the version of the slide I'm looking at does not have balances. Are you seeing the balances in there? [00:25:07] Sameer Kanal: Just for the one that says U.S. Treasuries. [00:25:10] Bridget O'Callaghan: Okay, well, my apologies. I can get you a better copy of this. What this slide was intended to do was to give you a view of the portfolio as it stood as of 6/30 of this year, the end of the fiscal year, and it's showing the distribution of funds. My apologies. I can get you a better version of, of this slide. [00:25:32] Jonas Beery: Bridget, sorry, just to interrupt. It does look like the version that's posted alongside the agenda item does show these amounts. So for folks who want to see those, if you can access the agenda, it's available in the posted presentation. [00:25:46] Bridget O'Callaghan: Thank you. What I wanted to take a few moments to talk about here, though, is in terms of the safety and security of the portfolio, what you'll see is the vast majority of our funds are in treasuries and agency securities, again, very safe and very stable investments. And a portion of it is in the local government investment pool, portion of it, it's in local community banks and national banks. And approximately 30% of the portfolio, or $851 million, is in corporate securities. Again, there are certain parameters around the securities that are allowed in the portfolio. And if you want to discuss this, I'll get you a better copy of this for later in the discussion. All right, as I mentioned, we have very safe and secure types of investments that, that are allowed under the investment policy. And what you'll see here are the maximum distributions of those. Again, very— we very heavily weighted in treasuries and agencies. We do have the ability to have, of course, interest-bearing deposits, the local government investment pool, municipal bonds. Bonds of Oregon, Washington, Idaho, and California, and then of course corporate debt. And I want to be clear about the corporate debt component of that. Those are corporate bonds and not stocks, so we're not taking an ownership position in any of these companies. If you will, the industrial classifications. The city, as Jonas mentioned, over several years has been continually trying to improve the social responsibility aspects of our portfolio and, you know, certainly focusing on human rights and values that are important to the community. And so as part of that process over the last several years, we have identified a number of industry classifications that we have prohibited in the policy. So here's a list on the screen of those prohibited business codes, classification codes. Thank you. At the end of last year, we did take it— we are— we take the investment policy to council once a year for an annual review. The end of last year, there was an amendment to the policy which asked us essentially 3 things. The first thing was to— it directed the administration to work with interested council offices to look at options for improving the ethicalness of our policy and to focus on certain parameters there. It asked us to do some community outreach. Those things were accomplished throughout the past year. It asked us to develop a screening for potential investments based on human rights in accordance with the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and to come back to council and present some options. And those options were presented to council in September of this year. Taking that input into account, And listening to testimony, conducting some research on model policies around the country, we are coming back today with the policy that is set before you, and that policy is incorporating a new section that will focus more on social responsibility and social governance. So with that, let me turn it back to CFO Beery to talk a little bit about what's in the policy and how we want to move forward. [00:29:44] Jonas Beery: Great. Thanks. Thanks, Brigid. So yeah, there's 2 kind of proposed changes to the policy in 2027. The first here is really just kind of housekeeping administrivia, which is updating to reference the Budget and Finance Service Area, which is reestablished in the City Administrator's recent organizational chart. And then the second change is much more material and important, and that's adding a new section that we've titled Environmental, Social, and Governance, or ESG for short. That's Section 16 of the policy that's posted as, I believe it's Appendix A or Exhibit A. And so I just wanted to also note we've chosen to use the term ESG. As that aligns with the standard kind of nomenclature of the investment industry. But the intent of this language is also aligned more broadly with the concept of socially responsible investing, or SRI, and more specifically, the language relates to the ethical investment priorities that we've been talking about here over the last 11 months. The crux of the addition, and you can see the language detail in the exhibit itself, but the crux of the language is that the city will acquire a third-party provider to perform ongoing independent assessment of the qualifying securities within the portfolio, and then provide the city with a score or a minimum threshold based upon the values that are identified in the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which was called out in last year's ordinance and is a fairly, I think, accepted neutral resource of sort of value statement that are aligned, I believe, with the intent of last year's directive. And in making investment decisions, the city will ensure that in addition to checking all of the criteria related to credit quality, current restrictions around the industry classifications, additionally will confirm that an appropriate ESG threshold is met in alignment with those criteria. And then last key update to the policy is additionally, and for full transparency, When we publish monthly the investment report, we'll add an indicator that includes the third-party ESG information related to any securities that the city has purchased. Next slide, and I think we're almost done here. Just kind of next steps in the pathway to get there, assuming passage of the resolution at council, we will prioritize procurement of the third-party ESG provider. To prepare and maintain a list of those investments that align with the direction. We know that the procurement process will take a little bit of time, but we'll certainly work with procurement to prioritize the effort and get that independent provider on board as rapidly as possible. And then next slide, I think, is the last one here, which is just acknowledging— appreciate the dialogue and conversation we've had to get to this point. Along with the city treasurer and investment officer online, we're happy to take any questions or receive any other feedback. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. [00:32:52] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, CFO Beery. So colleagues, we're going to do a technical Q&A along with floating of any amendments. We do have testimony. I believe 23 people are signed up, but Clerk's Office can correct me on that. So we'll do that first, then we'll take the testimony, and then we'll come back. If there are any amendments to be moved, we'll discuss those then and have a broader conversation on potential referrals. I've just been updated that it is 25 testifiers. So, um, are there any technical or clarifying questions for CFO Beery, uh, or Treasurer Callahan? Councilor Novick? [00:33:28] Steve Novick: Yeah, I don't know if this is really a technical or clarifying question, but we talked last year about adding screens for labor and environmental and consumer protection standards, which seems to have dropped out. So I just want to serve notice, particularly those who are planning to testify, That I am planning to introduce an amendment to Exhibit A, Section 15— 16, to say that after the language, the city will use an ESG screen to consider the effects of its investments in alignment with the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, I would add the city shall also use an ESG screen or screens that consider companies' record of compliance or noncompliance with labor laws or standards, environmental laws, and consumer protection thank you, Councilor Novick. [00:34:18] Sameer Kanal: I have a point as well. So there was a slide that showed the 3 things we added in the resolution amendment last year. That text was partially designed to initiate the process that led us to the text being added in the exhibit that was added this year. But part of it was to sort of continue to emphasize what the values are. And so I I do have an amendment that I have put up that would restore the same language as last year for the 2nd and 3rd of those clauses. And I'll just share screen here. Believe that should show what we're looking at here. Yeah. So the only real changes are it removes the initiating a new process clause, and it retains the rest of it with the addition of sort of remain these committed to kind of continue to emphasize our values here, because I think that's helpful to understand the sort of legislative intent behind what we're doing. So I'll make sure that this is circulated as well. But that is— the rest of this is exactly the same text as last year. I guess the 2026 went to 2027. Thank you. So that's the amendment I'll be floating now. And yeah, are there any other questions, technical or clarifying questions for the staff? I guess I'll ask CFO Beery, can you explain sort of how, when a score is given on a potential investment through the new text, how that will be used to the degree that it is above or below a threshold, and that's yes or no, to the degree that it's a subjective evaluative component, how will that be used? [00:36:19] Jonas Beery: Yeah, thank you, Chair, for the question. So just a reminder that, you know, any— you know, we're talking corporate bonds, right? And so there's a somewhat limited universe of that. So just going to go through the order of operations, right, which I think will get to the answer to your question. We, of course, want to screen first for credit quality, make sure it meets those thresholds of the investment policy. We screen for industry classification, right? So that narrows that universe. I think currently there's around 35 corporate— corporations that meet that threshold. So just to tee up, that's the universe of corporations that we're talking about at that first cut, even before we get to any additional screening. And then we, of course, need to make sure that the investment aligns from a term and maturity perspective with our cash flow needs, right? So that further narrows the universe. So what I intend this additional ESG screen would do is we'd have to work with a provider. We'll have to ask some of these questions, I think, in the procurement process, because different providers are going to have different rubrics and, you know, either yes, no, or, you know, 1 through 5 or 1 through 100 or A through F, whatever the scale might be. Yeah. But we will identify a threshold that meets the intent and values identified in the resolution, should it pass, and the policy. And so that'll be an additional checkpoint. Once we get to those— through those first checkpoints, sort of the last checkpoint will be, does that intended investment also meet sort of the minimum threshold screen? And like I said, it might be a score of 3, or it might be a score of 90 if it's on a scale of 100. But we'll have to determine that based upon the responses we get during the procurement process. And then of course we'll report that score out so we can be transparent about the fact that we are in fact doing as directed and intended. [00:38:18] Sameer Kanal: Thank you for that clarification. And I'll say this more later, but thank you for the work that you've done to be responsive to council as well as Bridget and Michael as well. Seeing no one else in the queue, we'll move to public testimony. Rebecca, can you please call the first list of testifiers? [00:38:35] Rebecca Dobert: Our first testifiers, our first slate, I'm going to go Sally Joughin followed by Cherice Bock. Sally, you can unmute and go ahead. [00:38:45] Sameer Kanal: And actually, I just want to note one thing for the record because we do have 24 folks. Again, you're going to get your 3 minutes here. Everybody feel free to use as much of it as you want. Don't feel obligated to use the full amount if you don't need it all. Thanks. [00:38:59] Rebecca Dobert: Okay, Sally, you can unmute. Go ahead. Go ahead. Yep, you're good to go. [00:39:08] Sally Joughin: Oh, okay. So, um, I don't show here, but is it just verbal? [00:39:17] Rebecca Dobert: Uh, you would have to turn your camera on if you have one. Otherwise, we can hear you clearly. [00:39:22] Sally Joughin: How do I do the camera? Oh, the video. [00:39:26] Rebecca Dobert: Yep. [00:39:28] Sally Joughin: Okay, there you go. There I am. Okay, so my name is Sally Joughin. I live in District 3. I'm a member of the Multnomah Democrats Foreign Policy Study Group, and ethical investing is a topic of our interest. I believe the majority of Portlanders would agree with us that financial investments, besides bringing in funds for the needs of our city, should not support entities that abuse anyone's human rights. I think people understand that human rights abuse can occur in a number of areas— intentionally harming people through militarism, detention, deportation, genocide, racial and ethnic discrimination. That's one category of human rights abuse. Other abuses of human rights can be economic, environmental violations of labor rights and technology used for harm and invasion of privacy. I believe most Portlanders don't want to put our money into entities that are responsible for such abuses, and they don't want to be complicit in the unethical behaviors of other countries. We need a universal human rights screen with no exception made for our own country or any other country. I hope that Finance and Government Finance Committee of the Whole will pass the Portland Investment Policy being considered today, and I call on you to add some amendments in addition to the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, um, to outline what, what kind of, um, human rights abuses would be screened out. And, um, I appreciate, um, Councilor Novick additions that he he is gonna going to submit. There should be more U.S. and international authorities or conventions cited as sources for definitions of various human rights abuses that are unlawful and should be screened out of our city's investments. Occasionally, I have heard someone speak in opposition to Portland installing a universal human rights. Rights screen. It seems that they want to invest in a particular country or a business that they like, and they fear that a screen will prevent it. I'm always surprised that such persons don't seem to realize that they are basically publicly stating that a particular country or business that they like is an abuser of human rights. But the proposal being— the proposal being being presented for the vote today is for a universal screen, so no specific country or business is excluded by the policy. Any country or business that wants Portland's investment can be eligible for it if they are financially financially profitable and do not commit human rights abuses. They select or reject themselves by their own behavior. Thank you. [00:42:39] Rebecca Dobert: Cherice, you can go ahead. [00:42:42] Cherice Bock: Good morning, councilors. My name is Cherice Bock, and I'm representing 350 PDX, which is a local nonprofit with thousands of members in the Portland area working on environmental issues and climate justice. And we're supportive of this environmental, social, and government governance frame for working toward ethical investing. Councilor Novick's amendment also sounds good. As I commented in September and many written comments reflected at that time, while you're working on this policy, we would also like to see an update relating to fossil fuels. As you all know, fossil fuels cause climate change, which exacerbates and compounds injustice and inequity. ESG screens unfortunately do not always exclude fossil fuel companies. Currently, Appendix A, which is on page 11 of the redline document, lists several areas that will be excluded based on the Bloomberg Industry Classification Standards, or BICS. The first category is the BICS codes related to oil. In 2024, those BICS codes were updated to include gas. So things like crude oil and natural gas exploration and production, oil and natural gas market and trading, And so forth. So gas was added into those BICS codes. So we would like to see the BICS codes updated in Appendix A to reflect the current titles. Also, we'd like to see coal excluded either by adding in the appropriate BICS codes or by using a list such as the Urgewald Global Coal Exit List, which was included as an evaluating tool in the state-level Coal Act in relation to the Oregon State Treasury. Eventually, we'd like to see an expansion of the investment policy to also include screening the financial institutions that hold our funds regarding their investment in fossil fuel projects, but we're content to take this first step of updating Appendix A to exclude not only oil but also natural methane gas and coal, as well as the ESG frame. One additional note is that the City of Olympia passed a human rights investment policy that suggests exploration of positive new investment opportunities. Which seems important for us to also pursue. Thanks for all your efforts on this and appreciate all the work that has been done by the council and the staff to get this ESG policy, and we're happy to see it moving forward. Thank you. [00:45:06] Rebecca Dobert: Lydia Kiesling. [00:45:09] Lydia Kiesling: Hi, my name is Lydia Kiesling. I live in District 3 and I'm very sick, so I am not gonna be very eloquent and I will keep it short, but, um, I want to thank the councilors who have championed this effort and the CFO and treasurer and city staff who have worked really hard on finding meaningful tools and really meaningfully engaging people about the best way to do this. Thank you so much for that work. I hope that the council will honor all of that work by passing a policy that has, you know, these— has meaningful changes and And to kind of build on what the previous testifier said, that means really using tools that take into account the entirety of our fossil fuel infrastructure and also tools that talk about, you know, genocide and atrocity crimes so that really like all the things that we're trying to avoid investments in are reflected in the tools that are used. This is such an important thing to have in place to allow a city to kind of speak about how our corporate cultures are connected to horrible abuses of human rights and environmental devastation and unfair labor practices. And I hope that you will pass a strong policy, and thank you again for working on this. That's it. [00:46:41] Rebecca Dobert: Maxine Fookson. [00:46:44] Maxine Fookson: Thank you so much. Can you hear me okay? Am I in? [00:46:47] Rebecca Dobert: You are. [00:46:47] Maxine Fookson: Great, thank you. My name is Maxine Fookson. I live in Northeast Portland, District 2, and I'm testifying in support of the universal human rights screen as an important ethical investment addition to our city's investment policy. In the election this past Tuesday, we saw a remarkable sea change in the political landscape of our there was an excitement and electricity that we all craved for in our deepest hopes and aspirations. We saw the power of the people winning over the cold dollars of the corporations and those unwilling to condemn even the bombing of children. So today, by passing this human rights resolution, we can seize that opportunity to continue this energy by aligning our city with this inspiring progressive— with these inspiring progressive wins. I am here as a member of Oregon for Human Rights Coalition. I represent 2 groups, Jewish Voice for Peace and Healthcare Workers for Palestine, as part of that coalition. There are several core values from my Jewish faith: justice, justice thou shalt pursue, and to see that in every life there is a universe as a nurse practitioner, I took the oath, do no harm. This resolution puts these foundational values into action. I actually believe that these are not just my values but are pillars in our civic commitments and in our universal covenant to one another. This screen proposes aligning our investment decisions utilizing parameters of human rights from the seminal 1948 UN Declaration of Human Rights. The United Nations, in their own words, recognizes the Declaration of Human Rights as, quote, having inspired and paved the way for the adoption and additional human rights treaties applied today on a permanent basis at global and regional levels, unquote. These additional accords add specificity yes. And update the original UN Declaration. The Oregon for Human Rights Coalition suggests including a number of them to strengthen the resolution, and I reference, uh, Councilor Kanal's important areas that were highlighted as well as Councilor Novick's areas. These additional accords would add specificity and help us to align our our, um, our businesses, our ethical decisions with these parameters. As we saw in the people-powered wins on Tuesday, it's now up to us. The human rights screen is one incredibly important thing Portland can do to demonstrate our commitment to humanity and the planet. Let's stand with other municipalities taking similar actions and pass this screen to assure that our values and alignments are aligned. Thank you. [00:49:54] Rebecca Dobert: Jenny Abeling and Nadia Hasan. [00:49:59] Jenny Abeling: We're going to take the full 6 minutes if that's okay. I know you're going to put 3 minutes up on the clock, but we are going to testify together. [00:50:07] Sameer Kanal: Okay. [00:50:07] Nadia Hasan: Hi, City Council. For the record, my name is Nadia Hasan and I'm here with Jenny Abeling. Um, we are going to talk about care and community. A couple days ago, we had just gotten off the phone to 2 moms navigating the sandwich of elderly parents and growing children while struggling to stay afloat. One of us is consoling the other while offering elder care resources to support the obstacles of aging parents. One of us is Muslim and one of us is Jewish. We exchange stories and resources and we go about our days balancing the mental load of motherhood, working full-time, and the intense phase of our lives and all that's happening around us. And while our religion is an element of our identity, we rooted in care and community for the people we love. We know that care and caregiving for each other goes beyond religion, and city policy can too. [00:50:53] Jenny Abeling: On September 3rd, the Portland City Council was supposed to review its investment policy and ideate on what its values should be. Instead, it turned into a heated discussion about antisemitism. We both watched from our separate spaces, a Muslim and a Jewish mom wondering how our politics had become so divided. We understand these conversations are nuanced and can even cause discomfort. Rising antisemitism and anti-Muslim hate are very real. Incidents of hate have risen across the country, and our communities feel that. Just recently, my daughter went on a school field trip, and the playground slide said, F all the girl who did a presentation in 3rd grade about what it means to be Jewish does not want people to know she is Jewish now. [00:51:44] Nadia Hasan: Meanwhile, my daughter's friends worry about wearing a headscarf to school in fear of how people will treat her. When did this fear and hate become normalized? But there's a difference between fighting bigotry and shutting down financial investment accountability. Mixing those up does not protect Jewish or Muslim people. It just makes it harder to build the care and safety we want for all generations in our community. Safety for Jewish elders, safety for Muslim elders, safety for Jewish kids, safety for Muslim kids. From grandparents and grandkids everywhere, these are not competing claims. They are the same claim said from different perspectives. [00:52:19] Jenny Abeling: So here's where we land plainly. We support tightening the city's investment policy. Keep public dollars out of war and human rights abuses. This isn't a foreign affair policy. It's a financial care policy. The staff presentation laid out ways to screen city investments against basic human rights standards, the same kind of standards the city already uses to avoid oil, gas, and private prisons. Ammunition, drones, armored tanks, surveillance tech— the companies that these products need war to keep happening somewhere, to someone's grandma, to someone's son, in order to make enormous profit. [00:53:07] Nadia Hasan: War and the companies that enable and profit from it are the opposite of care. And this isn't about picking sides. It's simpler than that. We want communities and cities that care about people, people at every stage and every age of life who are loved and valued, neighbors growing old together, Care doesn't start or end at a border. It's the place where 2 backgrounds meet without any friction at all, because no society should invest in the idea that some people's lives matter less than others. Portland's proposed human rights standard doesn't single out a country or a war. It asks for something bigger. Should the city's money go to industries and companies that perpetuate war to keep making millions or even billions, no matter who it hurts? [00:53:47] Jenny Abeling: It's a statement about our values of care and safety for all in the community we want to be. We believe the same standard that standard should hold for Multnomah and Washington County, the state, and across the country. It shouldn't take an accusation of antisemitism to end the discussion about our financial investment policy. And we know and we see the internet— intergenerational divide grow deeper as we strive to build care and community. We have had heated discussions, awkward silences, crying sessions to mourn the moments we are in. But we can do hard things. We can respect the perspectives of our community under the banner of care and creating safe through building on our values that bridge the divide. That's what Portlanders can do with this policy. So to the city councilors pushing this human rights standard forward, we are with you. Finish the vote on this ordinance. Don't let the media scare you. And to those who are pushing the label of antisemitism in this discussion, we say, not in our name. [00:54:46] Nadia Hasan: Underneath all the name-calling and divisive rhetoric, we believe in building the same care into Portland's finances that we have already built in our own families. Care doesn't stop at a border, a religion, or a headline. Care starts here with each other, loving one another, and building policies that are rooted in that compassion. [00:55:04] Laurie Mercier: Thank you. [00:55:04] Kelcie Smolin Grega: Thank you. [00:55:09] Rebecca Dobert: Kelcie Smolin Grega. [00:55:12] Kelcie Smolin Grega: Hi everybody, my name is Kelcie Smolin Grega. I'm a Jewish Portlander and a District 4 constituent. I'm a member of Jewish Voice for Peace Portland chapter and a member of the Oregon Human Rights Coalition, and I support the city adopting a universal human rights screen for its investments. Justice is deeply rooted in my Jewish traditions and my own family history. My ancestors came to this country seeking safety and acceptance. Our name was changed from Smolowitz to Smolin at Ellis Island, which was a small marker of this pressure to assimilate. But my family's history is also one of resilience and solidarity. Our traditions teach us that justice cannot be selective and that the dignity and safety of one person cannot come at the expense of another. That is why Portland's values must be reflected in how it invests its public dollars. A universal human rights screen must truly be universal, no exceptions. Our investment policy should not reward corporations that enable or profit from human rights violations. Thank you. Including genocide, apartheid, war profiteering, racial discrimination, violations of immigrants and labor rights, and environmental harm, both here and abroad. We cannot ignore the corporate corporations profiting from ICE's actions and surveillance in our own communities, nor corporate complicity in genocide abroad. This must include Israel and corporations that profit from its war crimes. I know that there are some on the dais who have suggested that this policy specifically targets Jews. I vehemently reject this idea that our identity, our history of persecution, or the very real threat of antisemitism should be used to shield a nation-state and corporations that support it from accountability. Doing so dishonors the lessons of our history. Tikkun olam the Shema, repair the world, calls for us to act. Justice, justice shall you pursue does not stop when justice becomes politically inconvenient, but when the people suffering are not our own. We must apply the same standards to Israel that we apply to any other country. There should be no exceptions to undermine this human rights screen itself. Jewish safety is bound up in the safety and dignity of all people. Thank you. All of our liberation is interconnected. A human rights screen is an important first step. It gives Portlanders a clear framework to evaluate investments and the basis to ask the city to divest. Thank you for your time. [00:57:48] Rebecca Dobert: Ricky King. [00:57:51] Ricky King: Hi there. My name is Ricky King. I'm a constituent from City District 3, and I'm a member of Portland DSA, and I organize with Oregon for Human Rights. I support a yes vote on the proposed investment policy as well as a yes vote on the upcoming potential friendly amendment from Councilor Kanal. I urge the council to recommit to last year's December 3rd resolution, which said that the investment screen would have, quote, the intention of ensuring the city doesn't invest in companies that enable or facilitate war, armed conflict, armed conflict, or human rights abuses, including but not limited to genocide, slavery, torture, indefinite or arbitrary detention, war crimes, and crimes against humanity, as well as labor, environmental, and consumer policies and I think that that specificity is really valuable. After learning about the city's investment policy and overlays over the last couple years, I believe that outlining criteria for more ethical investments outside of the overlay system will do a lot to bridge the gap left behind by the broader overlay categories and allow us to adapt to companies' changing behavior. An adaptable screen based on behavior and impact will go a lot further than a named list of companies. The point isn't to check a name of a corporation off a list. Thank you. Corporation off of lists, and then shrug our shoulders should a similar situation arise with a different corporate investment in the future. Despite claims that international geopolitics are irrelevant to us here in Portland, our money talks. For example, the South African government didn't decide to end apartheid out of the goodness of their hearts. It took resistance and advocacy from South Africans living under said apartheid, as well as outside economic pressure from international trading partners, including the U.S. If there are concerns about specific companies or countries, then let's, let's the same kind of approach is needed now since there are companies in the portfolio implicated in human rights and labor abuses. We have Amazon, where a worker dropped dead at the Troutdale distribution center earlier this year, just a couple miles away from Portland, as well as Amazon Web Services, which hosts products used to surveil people incarcerated in the U.S. The city's current investment policy prohibits investments in companies investment that engage in unethical practices. And the city's current investment policy prohibits investments in companies that engage in unethical practices. In correctional facilities, but the current corporate bonds includes tens of thousands of dollars loaned to Amazon. That's an instance of the industry overlay categories needing to be patched with this additional ESG screen and ongoing independent assessment. We also have Google, which just clear-cut a quarter of a million trees in Finland. It's another instance of our environmental, our environmental investment overlay not adapting to behavior. Then we have Walmart, widely criticized by labor unions for racial and gender discrimination and instances of wage theft. In the past, the city council and Councilor Novick in particular paved the way with the 2014 socially responsible investing policy. We suspended our Walmart investments, and we're the first city to do so. But now $34 million of our public dollars are invested in Walmart. So we have a chance to learn from the past year by passing an ongoing check, including the friendly amendments. So I'm just here to say to vote yes on the modified investment policy, including the friendly amendments. Thank you. [01:01:00] Gwendolyn Scott: Thank thank you. [01:01:01] Cherice Bock: You. [01:01:04] Rebecca Dobert: Dianne Albright. Laurie Mercier. Laurie, you can go ahead. [01:01:12] Laurie Mercier: Hi, my name is Laurie Mercier. I'm a longtime Portland resident in District 4 and with the Oregon for Human Rights Coalition. In the blue tsunami we witnessed this week, Democratic candidates won because of messages that challenged the billionaire class and asserted that our tax dollars should be put into socially productive uses rather than wasted on violence here and abroad. Across the country, Americans rejected the unbelievable cruelty they've witnessed— attacks on our immigrant neighbors and on freedom of speech, and senseless wars and genocide around the world. Portland City Council Council needs to read the room and adopt the human rights screen on city investments. The city's portfolio is currently invested in tech giants that have become increasingly embedded in the military, ICE, the Department of Homeland Security, and human rights violators around the world. Although investments in the tech military surveillance incarceration industries have been relatively profitable, in recent years due to enormous public financing. There is a growing movement in cities, counties, and states across the US to divest from companies complicit in human rights violations. And just a few days ago, 75% of voters in Providence, Rhode Island supported a divestment ballot measure. The Investor Alliance for Human Rights notes that this is having a material thank you. And it has an impact on investors. Studies indicate that portfolios with a human rights screen typically perform similarly to or better than traditional portfolios. Plus, they can reduce risk. Portlanders do not want to support genocide, surveillance, war, racial profiling, and incarceration that suck resources away from what could be more productive investments. Investments that support workers, a clean environment, and human rights. I appreciate the efforts of councilors and city staff for working to update our investment policy to reflect the values of Portlanders. Thank you. [01:03:30] Kyle Prosen: Good morning. Uh, some of you may know me as Polly Pop-Tart, but today I'm coming to you as Kyle Prosen to voice my opposition to the bill's written. A little bit about me, I do medical policy for a genetics lab and I've spent the last decade expanding access to prenatal genetic testing for Medicaid patients across the United States, especially in Puerto Rico where the challenges for patients are much greater than the rest of the country. I also volunteer with Portland's Jewish community, advise a local Jewish youth group, I'm a student of both Arabic and Hebrew, Hebrew, and I'm a drag queen. One of the most meaningful lessons that I've learned is that a law is unjust if it is enforced disproportionately against minorities or written in a way that invites such enforcement. While I appreciate many of the goals of this proposal, I believe that the human rights threshold from the UN will function as a witch hunt against Jews and Jewish businesses who already face elevated levels of discrimination, harassment, intimidation, I've experienced each of these myself and have heard a dozen stories from teens in the youth group that I volunteer with that echo mine. That group only has a few dozen kids, and hearing their stories in such high concentration is heartbreaking. My friend's 12-year-old daughter was thrown to the ground by a boy in her grade for the sole reason that she's Israeli, and his sister told her that she deserved it. Councilmember Herbold. Another girl's hockey team assembled their sticks in the shape of a swastika to intimidate her. Jewish-owned businesses I regularly visit endure a barrage of discrimination and harassment that few other Portland businesses experience for the sole reason that they are owned by Israelis or Jews. The part of this bill that concerns me were written and supported by people who seek to destroy the world's only Jewish state under the guise of morality. This bill doesn't single out Israel, but the United Nations frequently does. Many people see the United Nations as an independent body, but it has a long record of anti-Israel bias. How else would you explain Qatar sitting on the UN Human Rights Council when it funds terrorists around the world and would put me to death for being gay? Every woman in this room is free to decide how she wants to wear her hair today. In a Iran, women are beaten to death over that choice, and Iran was elected to the UN Commission on the Status of Women. Hmm. The U.S. is one of the only countries on Earth where Jews can safely live, practice freely, and build successful businesses, and that is already changing. Don't make it worse by legalizing a witch hunt against those who do business here, unless your goal is to erode the vitality of the Jewish community in a city where things are already challenging. I had the honor of participating in Portland's You Belong campaign as the Jewish participant. The proposal as written makes Jewish Portlanders like— like, it makes Jewish Portlanders like me feel like we don't belong. I ask you to vote against the proposal as written. I am one, the only one. There's so much I can do. Thank you. [01:06:37] Rebecca Dobert: Rod Such. [01:06:41] Rod Such: Hi, my name is Rod Such. I live in District 3, and I'm active in the Oregon for Human Rights Coalition. I'm here to testify in support of the human rights screen for Portland's investment portfolio. I also support a friendly amendment to the language of the resolution by clarifying that the screen incorporates not only the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, but also subsequent additions to international law, such as the UN Conventions on Apartheid, Genocide, and Racial Discrimination, the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, and the International Labor Convention. Because respect for human rights and international law has been eviscerated under the Trump administration, it is important to reaffirm the whole. Body of international law. When I last testified on this resolution in September, 3 councilors said they opposed a human rights screen because it singled out Israel. Proponents were accused of being anti-Semites. It was a slanderous and just plain weird accusation. I never uttered the word Israel in my testimony. I did use the terms apartheid and genocide. So these accusers must have just made the connection themselves. But the more I thought about this weaponization of antisemitism, the more puzzled I became. Were the 3 councilors who made the slander unaware that in April this year, Oregon's 2 US senators, Jeff Merkley and Rod Wyden, supported a Senate resolution to block the sale of bulldozers and 1,000-pound bombs to Israel? I don't know. The resolution applied only to Israel, so their vote did in fact single out Israel. Did that make them antisemites? A majority of Democratic senators also supported the resolution. All antisemites, apparently. Then in July 2026, Oregon congressional reps Maxine Dexter, Suzanne Bonamici, Val Hoyle, and Andrea Andrea Salinas voted to cut off military aid to Israel. They singled out only Israel for this cutoff in aid. Did that make them antisemites, along with more than 100 other congressional reps? Finally, 6 city councilors in this chamber signed a pledge to take steps towards ending Portland's complicity in Israeli genocide and apartheid. A pledge that uplifted the legitimate rights of the Palestinian people to live free of these crimes against humanity. What better way to do it than applying a human rights screen with universal standards? Thank you. [01:09:37] Eli Berne: Hi, councilors. Uh, my name is Eli Berne. I am the director of government affairs at the Jewish Federation of Greater Portland, the central philanthropic convening and public affairs body for the local Jewish community. Community cares deeply about human rights and has some concerns about this policy and would therefore like clarity on a few points. Would the policy prohibit investment exclusions based solely on a company's nationality, geographic presence, or lawful commercial relationships with a particular country? We would welcome language clarifying that any restriction rests on documented conduct by the specific country with the same standards applied consistently. We would also like to understand how the city would make sure any criteria applied consistently to every— it would be applied consistently to every country and company. We ask because many United Nations bodies have consistently held Israel to a different standard than other nations. For example, the United Nations Human Rights Council maintains a permanent standing agenda item devoted to Israel, the only such country in the world addressed in this way. We are curious whether the city has considered how escrow drawing on such sources would avoid singling out any one country in practice, and how the policy would relate to established United States foreign policy. In this regard, the proposed amendment concerns us. We can see we could see the how how this language has been weaponized in other municipalities and states to single out one specific country. Our interest in these questions comes from the care for our neighbors. We want every Portlander, including Jewish residents, to feel included and secure. We know the council shares that. An ethical investment policy must prioritize protection against geographic discrimination, independent verification of third-party assessments, protection of taxpayer financial interests, and oversight and transparency. We are not quite sure that the current policy as written addresses those kind of key points. Thank you for your time and continued work to build a Portland where every community feels safe and welcome. We are here to be a partner in this and look forward to working with you. [01:11:38] Sameer Kanal: Thank you. [01:11:40] Tyler Fellini: Good morning, councilors. My name is Tyler Fellini, and I'm the executive director of and a registered lobbyist for Portland Jobs with Justice. We represent over 100 labor, community, faith, and student organizations, and we are a member of the Oregon for Human Rights Coalition. We urge you to adopt a broad universal human rights screen as part of the city's investment in the future of Portland. [01:12:06] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Tyler. [01:12:10] Tyler Fellini: Thank you both, councilors, for those. Every public dollar reflects a choice. When the city invests in corporate bonds, it becomes a lender to those companies and it shares in what they do. Portlanders do not want their tax dollars tied to war crimes, torture, mass surveillance, illegal ICE activity, labor violations, or the destruction of our climate. Thank you, Councilor Mitch Green. That is a basic expectation of a humane city. This is not a new idea for Portland. The resolution before you says the policy incorporates socially responsible investment parameters, including those listed in the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Last December, this council voted 10 to 1 to move the city away from companies that enable war, genocide, torture, arbitrary detention, labor and environmental abuse. [01:12:57] Jordan Lewis: Thank you. [01:12:57] Dan Ryan: Abuses. [01:12:58] Tyler Fellini: The policy already restricts investments in fossil fuels, private prisons, small arms, and casinos. A human rights screen finishes that work. What we're asking for is consistency. If we screen by industry, we can screen by conduct. Our members are the people who build and maintain the city. They know a public dollar is never neutral. When the city buys corporate bonds, it becomes a lender to those corporations. A universal standard means the same rules for every company and every country. That is the point. A screen that applies to everyone cannot single out anyone. Nothing about this conflicts with the city's core duties to protect public funds, maintain liquidity, and earn a market return. Plenty of cities, universities, and pension funds have shown that you can apply human rights criteria and still invest prudently. Responsible investing is, in fact, fact about managing risk, including legal, reputational, and ethical risk. So we ask you to do 3 things: adopt a human rights screen grounded in universal standards, direct the treasurer to apply it consistently across all holdings, and require regular public reporting and community engagement so that Portlanders can see how our money is being invested. This is a chance for Portland to show that our public investments reflect our highest values. Thank you for your time and your leadership. [01:14:20] Rebecca Dobert: Steven Goldberg. [01:14:27] Steven Goldberg: Um, my name is Steven, um, Goldberg. I live in District 3. I am a retired attorney who spent a significant portion of my last years practicing on human rights issues, including in South Africa, Tunisia, and in Israel and Palestine. I am Jewish and a longtime member of Congregation Havara Shalom in Portland. My family, my daughter, my granddaughter, are also members of Havara Shalom. Although the proposed policy, which I totally support and support the test testimony, the brilliant testimony of people who testified before me. Although the policy does not focus on one country or corporation, I do believe that the State of Israel is one of the most significant violators of international law in their actions against Palestinians living in the West Bank as well as in Gaza and Israel proper. Calling Israel out does not make me anti— an anti-Semite, as I was accused of being at the last council meeting we testified at, but in fact is demanded by all of the principles of Judaism with which I was raised. The most recent report of the independent International Commission of inquiry on the occupied Palestinian territory through the United Nations. A report just issued on October 14th makes Israel's continued violations of international law absolutely clear. Again, I totally support the proposed human rights screen in the ordinance before the council and the testimony of hi, my name is Isaiah Kaplan, and I'm an organizer with Jewish Voice for Peace and the Oregon for Human Rights Coalition. [01:16:49] Isaiah Kaplan: And I'm here today to testify in favor of passing this human rights screen with the proposed amendments by Councilor Znovik and, uh, councilor I wanted to start by thanking the City Council for taking the time to update and consider the community's concerns regarding the nature of our city's investments, and for their desire to make sure that our investments are in line with the city's values of respecting and upholding human rights, environmental concerns, as well as labor concerns and consumer protection concerns. The last time that we held a hearing on this, I testified in favor of an amendment, and I spoke about how American corporations had profited off of slave labor created by the genocide that my family survived in Nazi Germany. Corporations like Ford Motors used slave labor from Auschwitz concentration camp in the labor camp where many of my families ultimately met their end. Protecting human rights is decent— is deeply personal to me as a descendant of Holocaust survivors. We've also heard testimony from some members of the community that somehow this screen unfairly targets Jews or Jewish people, and I want to completely refute refute that statement. It is not unfair to apply a universal human rights screen. What would be unfair would be to single out one country for a special exemption based on their identity, and that is what it seems like some members who have testified against this measure are proposing: that we create an exception for. One group of people for one country. I also want to refute the idea that this is somehow a universally or popularly held belief by the majority of the members of that community. I don't believe that any person or institution can speak for the members of that community. And we saw recently that there was an attempt to say that Jewish voters would not support Senator Abdul El-Sayed in the Michigan Senate. But we saw from exit polls that over 66% of Jews actually voted for Abdul El-Sayed, which refutes this idea that this is some universally held idea, held value by Jews. And frankly, it is offensive to me to propose otherwise. I, I hope that you will vote in favor of this screen with the proposed amendments. Thank you. [01:19:48] Rebecca Dobert: Ido Shoshani. [01:19:52] Ido Shoshani: Good morning, Council. Uh, my name is Ido Shoshani, living in St. Johns in District 2. I was born in Ramat Gan near Tel Aviv and moved to the U.S. from Israel with my parents when I was young. Since moving to Portland in 2021, I've been actively involved in the community community, including organizing of the Tech Workers Coalition and working with my Jewish community through Erev Rav. My grandparents and most of my relatives still live in Israel. I've also worked at tech companies for almost 10 years now, including Israeli companies. I know that there are good people in Israel and in tech, and also that tech companies do not always operate with the good of the broader public in mind. So please understand when I I say that Portlanders deserve to consider every aspect of what companies our tax dollars are invested in and to be honest about everything those companies do. For our tax dollars to be spent ethically, we need to screen the companies we invest in to confirm that they are not benefiting from or contributing to human rights violations in any place. My birth country, Israel, is one of those places. It is not the only one, but it is the one that has spent millions to make sure that its goal, that's Hebrew for, uh, to extinguish the Palestinian people, is considered the only definition of Jewish safety. As a Jew and as Israeli, I don't agree. I believe in an Israel that isn't a rogue ethnostate, one where real justice is possible, apartheid can be undone, and a real democracy can be forged, as it was in South Africa, creating a safer world for all of us. But for now, we have to reckon with what Israel actually is and what it actually does, or else we can never change it, same as any other nation on this planet. Making sure our ESG screener is truly universal and using the most up-to-date and honest definitions for human rights to make sure that our investments aren't going to crimes against humanity anywhere in the world would let Portland make its own small thank you. [01:22:05] Rebecca Dobert: Jordan Lewis. Jordan, you can go ahead. [01:22:09] Jordan Lewis: Hello, Council Committee. My name is Jordan Lewis. I'm a District 4 resident and a member of Portland DSA who happens to also be a volunteer lobbyist for Portland DSA. I'm calling in today in support of the city adopting a human rights screen for city investments. I appreciate the use of a clear criteria to determine whether or not to invest in something. Don't like it? Didn't meet the criteria. I also welcome friendly amendments to include labor and environmental violations as criteria to the human rights screen, in addition to human rights considerations. Living in the imperial core, I've become acutely aware of how complicity is weaponized against people who were born into exploitative power. When people find out they are complicit in exploitation or some other evil they never consented to, they understandably become insecure. People might even begin defending behavior they would have opposed in a vacuum. The American Empire makes good use of this feature. And yes, I say it's a feature and not a bug. Personally, I do not want to traffic in shame or guilt or assign responsibility. I want justice, and justice means thoughtfully reevaluating our behaviors and changing them to bring about better outcomes for all. Thank you. Through thoughtful and considered policy like the human rights screening, we can not only work towards international justice, we can break the cycle of complicity and shame, which allows us to imagine a better world. Just like the imperial core sees complicity as a feature and not a bug, socialists see breaking complicity as a step towards imagining a better future. Thank you. Thank you. [01:23:49] Rebecca Dobert: Sorry about that. Robert Miller, Isai Aguilar, Gwendolyn Scott. Sorry, we're having some promotion issues. We have Gwendolyn Scott online. Gwendolyn, you can unmute and go ahead. Sorry about that. While we're trying to promote, uh, Gwendolyn, I will call Emily Hawley and Benjamin Gilbert. And Gwendolyn is our last testifier for 396, if we can can you hear me okay? Hi, we can hear you. [01:25:11] Gwendolyn Scott: Yes, sorry, it left me out of the meeting really quick. [01:25:14] Rebecca Dobert: Okay, you can go ahead. [01:25:16] Gwendolyn Scott: Okay, perfect. Um, okay, good morning, Council. Support of a yes vote on the universal human rights screening for Portland's investments alongside the proposed friendly amendments from Councilor Novick. Technology has the power to change lives, and we as Portlanders have the power to do so when we choose to value the people at the heart of creating this technology, people from the Congo, India, the Philippines, Nepal, just as much as we do its capabilities, we say no and ask for divestment from companies like Google and Amazon who've dumped billions of dollars into generative AI investments that serve human rights abuses like the very ones our city wishes to avoid, from here to Palestine. We need not just this proposal itself, but more vigilance in our standards and metrics. Thank you. Community input on our city's investment portfolio ensures that what Portland spends is what Portland wants, that human rights are upheld by our hometown. Divestment and reinvestment into ethical funds is no simple task, but I sincerely believe that there's no world that we wish to live in that we cannot build for ourselves. Thank you so much, and I yield the rest of my time. [01:26:23] Rebecca Dobert: And we do have one more testifier, Benjamin Gilbert. [01:26:27] Benjamin Gilbert: Hello, uh, my name is Ben Gilbert and I am a tenant in District 4 and a volunteer lobbyist for the Portland DSA. Um, start by saying we support Kanal's amendment, um, and I implore you to uphold human rights around the world and pass this human rights screen today. Human rights are a priority for DSA. DSA is a member of the Progressive International, which launched in May of 2020 with a mission to unite, organize, and mobilize the world's progressive forces. Since then, it has grown to include over 100 organizations representing millions of people on all inhabited continents. DSA recently sent a delegation to Brazil to serve as election observers in their presidential election, including Congressman-elect Chris Rabb. DSA members saw firsthand how US tech companies like Meta interfered in the elections by shutting down the WhatsApp channels of trade unions and restricting Lula and the Workers' Party's social media accounts. Beaverton Representative-elect Tammy Carpenter was just weeks ago detained by Israel and refused entry into the West Bank, where she and representatives and members of Parliament from around the world were learning— were going to learn about the human rights abuses and system of apartheid. That same system of apartheid is powered by U.S. tech companies like Google, Amazon, Microsoft, IBM, and Palantir. Palantir, which is right now undermining democracy in the United Kingdom by sending threatening letters to members of Parliament like Sawaris living in the Moroccan-occupied territories of Western Sahara face violent repression as part of day-to-day life in refugee camps, extreme poverty, and social and economic marginalization. The United States is right now actively encouraging U.S. companies to invest in this occupied territory. This investment policy is a political tool, and we must ask ourselves, what side are we on? The side of exploitation, abuse, capital imperialism, and war, or human rights, peace, justice, freedom, and socialism. As working people, we are all united in the struggle for better lives, and our fates are inherently intertwined. Thank you. [01:28:28] Rebecca Dobert: That concludes testimony. [01:28:32] Sameer Kanal: Rebecca, there— I've been trying to see— I thought we saw that Charlie Henderson was online, so just wanted to make sure. Um, sorry, one of the folks that we weren't able to get—. [01:28:43] Rebecca Dobert: Checking. Charlie Henderson. Sorry, I'm not seeing them, Councilor. [01:28:58] Sameer Kanal: And I know someone also has their hand up in the, uh—. [01:29:01] Rebecca Dobert: Yeah, um, I'm not sure if that—. [01:29:04] Sameer Kanal: If there's a naming issue. Sometimes that happens with with the link being sent twice. So, great. [01:29:12] Rebecca Dobert: Yeah, we do not have Charlie. [01:29:19] Sameer Kanal: Okay. All right. Well, thank you, colleagues. We are now back into councilor discussion. You can still ask clarifying questions. We can also consider amendments. And eventually either continue the item or refer it on to the full council. Just open up the queue, Council President Dunphy. Thanks. Testimony and the presentation prior raised a question for me, for Bridget specifically, for our treasurer. We have a—. We've had a ban on investments on casinos for as long as I've been paying attention to this, which is at least a decade now. I'm wondering, does that inherently prevent us from investing in bonds that are issued by tribal nations? You know, if the Warm Springs or other folks who are our, you know, government partners are issuing bonds, does that mean we can't invest in them? [01:30:18] Bridget O'Callaghan: Good question. I want to step back and remind you that we do have a very defined universe of investments, right? Roughly 35 names. And that's primarily driven by credit quality and a number of other factors. So we wouldn't today be investing in, you know, tribal casinos, not necessarily because they wouldn't— they would be filtered out on that list, but because of the other qualities, right? Making sure that they would have the right credit quality that we that makes sense. [01:31:05] Sameer Kanal: Thank you very much. Hey, I am next in the queue, and I just wanted to clarify, you have similar— potentially a similar question in terms of investments. Everything on that list is a corporation, right? We do not currently invest in any country directly. [01:31:22] Bridget O'Callaghan: Absolutely not. That is prohibited in our existing rules. [01:31:27] Sameer Kanal: Thank you. Just wanted to make sure that was on the record. Seeing no one else in the queue, I'll take the opportunity to ask Councilor Novick if you'd like me to go first or not in terms of amendments here. [01:31:41] Steve Novick: Yeah, go ahead and then I'll add mine. [01:31:43] Sameer Kanal: Okay, so I will move Canal 1. Again, it is filed online. This adds 2 clauses to the Resolution itself, it does not change the exhibit. We have already voted to approve every word in this other than the word remains, and I think the year. So be it further resolved that the council remains committed to screening potential investments based on human rights, including those listed in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, with the intention of ensuring the city does not invest in companies that enable or facilitate war, armed conflict, or human rights abuses, including but not limited to genocide, slavery, torture, indefinite or arbitrary detention. Second. Detention, war crimes, and crimes against humanity, as well as labor, environmental, and consumer policies and impact, and to evaluate other jurisdictions' policies as part of this process. And be it further resolved that the council encourages the administration to continue community outreach in advance of the 2027 City of Portland Investment Policy, including through relevant boards and commissions, and to include interested council offices in this process. So I'll move that and I'll ask for a second. [01:32:48] Mitch Green: Second. [01:32:49] Sameer Kanal: Moved by myself, seconded by Councilor Green. Is there further discussion on this amendment? Councilor Novick, I believe you're in the queue, but I don't know if it's on for this or for yours. Okay, I'll move on to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. [01:33:03] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Yeah, I'm just wondering if you can speak to the— I think it's the second piece there about continued engagement. And what I'm thinking about is that we have asked our CFO and budget teams to do a significant amount of additional engagement compared to what they were doing before we all took office around the budget. And I know I personally have had asks that we haven't been able to get to around engagement tools for the budget. I think others do as well. And it made a lot of sense to me for there to be engagement in this process as a one-time process leading up to a policy change, but you are putting language in that would presumably become an ongoing amount of engagement around our investment policy that's different from what they do on any other internal policies. So I'm wondering what your thoughts are there and why you are— why you're prioritizing that over potentially other yeah, thank you for the question. [01:34:13] Sameer Kanal: I'll just note 2 things. One, that I think processes are generally iterative, and this is just the idea that as we iterate on a policy that state law requires us to do annually, that engagement should be a part of that process. Having said that, I agree with your general premise that, that the thank you. Thank you, Mayor. So I think it would leave that up to the city administrator to determine sort of where the best place to own that work would be. And I guess I'll add one other thing, which is I'm hopeful, given that this is generally adopted by the end of the calendar year, that the specific zero-sum aspect of capacity as it relates to budget engagement is a little bit lessened by the fact that one has to get voted on by June and the other by December. I can't guarantee that, but that's sort of my anticipation. [01:35:26] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: I'm curious to hear if any of our colleagues have anything to say. I've got some pretty significant capacity concerns there. I've got some questions about the direction for the ongoing council engagement on something that I think is really important to have be an objective financial policy, just like all of our other financial policies again to direct our investment officers to engage with council on one policy and not all of the policies is curious to me. So I, I've got some concerns there, but like I said, I'll be curious to hear from our colleagues. Thank you, Councilor. [01:36:08] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. Councilor Zimmerman, followed by Councilor Smith. Thank you. What are the relevant boards and commissions as of right now, that would include at a minimum the Investment Advisory Committee, which is, you know, in code. But I think if there's others that are relevant in the future, that's a conversation. I don't know, or if anyone's identified anyone else, but it's— the idea was to not be an exhaustive list, but last year it was the Investment Advisory Committee, and again, this is the same text. [01:36:43] Rebecca Dobert: Okay. [01:36:44] Eric Zimmerman: I was going to ask this question, but I think it relates to this amendment as well then. To the City Treasurer, of the 35 groups that you said we're allowed to invest in now, I'm trying to think about it with the underlying, if it passes, what will change? Who will be eliminated? Will any be eliminated? And the reason I'm asking that in this amendment is I'm trying to get a sense why the councilor is putting in these boards and commissions. This seems like there may be a focus coming at some point for a board that we're trying to, like, anticipate. So I'm just trying to get a sense of, of the 35, where will we go? How low will we go if things are passed? [01:37:29] Unidentified speaker: Well, councilor—. Sorry, Bridget, let me take a crack and then you can supplement. I mean, I think To your first question, you know, we don't necessarily know, right? That's why we want to have the independent party do the screen so that we're getting that. I think it is feasible that there could be zero, depending on the, you know, the independent kind of assessment that's performed. It could be a handful of corporations. So we'll learn more about that in the next few months. I think the boards and commissions question is a little bit different in that that's around engagement. And you know, appreciate that the directive is to the city administrator. I will call out that ultimately myself and the treasurer's office are probably going to participate in that at that same, the same volume, whether we're in the lead or not. Would also just acknowledge that I think appreciate Councilor Perugini, your question. I have somewhat the same question as it's— I appreciate and value kind of ongoing engagement and the value in that. It's a little different from last year where it felt like we had really clear direction about what the engagement was around and what it was attempting to do. [01:38:38] Jonas Beery: Thank you. [01:38:40] Unidentified speaker: Intended to achieve. And this is a little bit more nebulous. So just would call out, it'd be helpful if this should pass around a directive to have more outreach and engagement, more clarity about what that's— the intent of that is so that we can respond appropriately to that when we come back next year. Councilor, did that answer your question? [01:39:02] Eric Zimmerman: Yeah, it's helpful. What I'm trying to understand here, to Jonas and to Councilor Kanal, is like there's an aspect to this policy about the objectiveness. And I think that the second clause of your amendment, Councilor, is immediately introducing a subjectiveness. And so that's giving me some pause here. I think that I would worry if all of a sudden we start seeing random boards and commissions start, you know, because we've, like, members like, now this is a thing we've gotta have a discussion on when, no, your job is the Planning Commission. Your job is the advisory board for X, Y, or Z. Yeah. So, so this seems like an invite of, of not only an expansion of what groups that we've asked to do certain work on our behalf may, may start leaning into, but also you have some stuff in the underlying that I'm trying to hear for the objectiveness that's been really touted. But now we're— I believe this is introducing a subjectiveness. And so I'm just I think that your amendment is stronger without the number 2 part there, and the number 1 holds. And, but those are just my thoughts. I'm trying to just understand how this plays out in the long term for— because it's a be it resolved and not a whereas, this comes with something to it. And so that's what I'm trying to understand here a little bit. [01:40:30] Sameer Kanal: Thanks for that. I'll go to Councilor Smith, and I'll respond when I'm next in the queue after that. [01:40:35] Unidentified speaker: Democratic Leader King Jeffries said this. [01:40:38] Loretta Smith: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'm trying to figure out if, if the folks who we invest in, if those change during the year, do we get notified that we add folks or that we change investments? [01:40:54] Unidentified speaker: Yeah, yeah, Councilor, I'll answer that question. I mean, we don't provide, you know, notification. Often those, those happen in real time, but we do publish the monthly investment report, which is a publicly available document. It shows every month what changed in our portfolio. So it is transparently communicated when that— when those changes do occur. And just also note that that report, in addition to adding in the ESG score once we have that available, also shows things like when it's maturing. So folks can see, oh, we have XYZ thing that we own that matures, you know, on December 1st, 2026. So you can sort of observe that's an opportunity when that will leave our portfolio and we may be purchasing something else. [01:41:39] Loretta Smith: So when you get a chance, it's not urgent, urgent, but I want you to walk me through that so that I can see how to look at that, because I look at them and it's a lot. Yep. Yeah. [01:41:52] Unidentified speaker: Happy to, happy to make space to do that, Councilor. Okay. [01:41:55] Loretta Smith: Thank you. [01:41:57] Sameer Kanal: Councilor Smith, I'll go to Councilor Koyama Lane first, and then I'll be next in the queue. [01:42:04] Tiffany Koyama Lane: Thank you, Chair Kanal. And I also want to thank everyone for coming to testify today and to all those who came to the last Committee of the Whole meeting when we were discussing this last fall. I seconded the amendment from Councilor Kanal. That prompted this process and voted in support of the action from council to look into our investment policy because many of my constituents say that, and I do believe that it's our responsibility as a council to ensure that our city investments are aligned with our stated values to the greatest extent possible. I've been really grateful that my office has been part of the process over the last year of the working group that's been getting updates on this. And I also really want to underscore that I've been incredibly impressed by how thorough and thoughtful CFO Beery, Treasurer O'Callaghan, and other city staff have been who have worked on this. Um, I believe what we are looking at today is— it really accurately reflects the outcome of this pro— the process. And, um, I plan to be both supportive of Councilor Kanal and Councilor Novick's amendments. I appreciate them both being in the workgroup and engaging in good faith genuinely. I really urge my colleagues to also support these. And I just thank you, Chair Kanal. I know this is— I appreciate your leadership throughout the past year and through this process, and I appreciate your amendment that gives some more clarity and guidance. [01:43:48] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane. I am next in the queue, colleagues. So I just wanted to clarify a couple things. I appreciate the questions that were raised here. I don't think that the relevance of a board or commission to a topic is determined on the fly by the members. Having worked on city advisory bodies for a while, I know that there is often a risk of mission creep, and that's why it's really important. And we've started a process as a city create the ABC program in a way that has clear direction to those. So for example, the Planning Commission was raised. The Planning Commission, it has a very defined scope of work that does not include human rights. It does not include investments. It does not include environmental, social governance investment policies. So that's, I think, a broad thing to worry about. The other thing I wanted to mention is I want to be clear, the idea behind this amendment, the second piece of it, is not to— Yes. To have bodies be involved in the application of the human rights screen that is in this year's investment policy. The idea is that the investment policy itself will be adjusted over time, not necessarily every year, but every year it gets resubmitted. State law requires us to approve it. And so the idea is if there are to be future iterations or adjustments to the policy, that that should also include community engagement as part of that policy or part of that policy revision process. So again, they wouldn't be applying the investment screen in any way. So this is separate from the sort of objectivity conversation around that. I would say that in terms of understanding that this is objective, the text in the exhibit itself is what folks should be able to— folks should be able to evaluate and hopefully find sufficiently strong in that regard. Thank you. I do acknowledge what Councilor Pirtle-Guiney is saying and CFO Beery as well about, you know, capacity. And again, I think if there's a conversation to be had around how to make sure that that's not as heavy of a lift and it's not expected to be, I'm hoping that I'm establishing intent here by stating that, that the idea here is just as you make potential revisions, that that includes engagement, not that there is a clear endpoint in place for it. But I don't know if that's clear enough absent a word choice change. So I would love folks to comment on that if so. It hasn't come up anything on the first part of it. So I'll just note my intention is to kind of keep that clarity in there about what values are behind this and to ensure in particular, I don't know if Councilor Novick's amendment is going to pass. I support it, but I'm not sure yet because we haven't voted that we're also keeping that specific specific piece in there about labor, environmental, and consumer policies. That's, uh, part of the reason behind that first part. So that's sort of my intention there, and, um, I'll go to Councilor Koyama Lane next. [01:46:57] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Thank you. [01:46:57] Tiffany Koyama Lane: Just to be crystal clear, Chair, so the engagement is not at all about applying the human rights screen. It's only about how to potentially improve the policy in the future. [01:47:17] Unidentified speaker: Yes. [01:47:17] Sameer Kanal: Okay. Is there anyone else? Just looking around, making sure I didn't miss anything. I'll go to Councilor Zimmerman. Yeah. [01:47:29] Eric Zimmerman: I'd like the first thing to pass. I just, I don't, I think the second part of it is problematic. So I'm toying with the idea of Or just adjusting it, but I don't know the right path here. I wish that those were separate clauses. I think together the amendment is— I just don't accept the number 2 part. So I'd like to actually divide the question. And if— whether it's you or me, Councilor Kanal, but I'd like to vote on the first one first and the second one second, if that's okay. [01:48:05] Sameer Kanal: Yeah, that's, that's perfectly fine. If you could just bear with me a second, I'm seeing that there was somebody with— so just to clarify, we'll divide the question. I accept the suggestion. We'll vote on the first part first, the second part second. I am hearing from the clerk's office that one of our testifiers that was unable to get on has gotten on. So if there's no objection, I would love to give them their time. Thank you. Seeing none, we'll do that, and then we'll come back and vote on these 2 and then hear the other amendment as well. So Rebecca, if you could please promote— I'm not sure who it is, but yeah. [01:48:41] Rebecca Dobert: Thank you, Chair, and thank you, committee. Testifier Charlie Henderson is online. You can unmute and go ahead. [01:48:47] Charlie Henderson: Amazing. Thank you so much for helping me get that. Okay. Good morning, Council. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today in support of incorporating a human rights screening into the city's budget. For the record, my name is Charlie Henderson. I'm a husband, dad, public servant, and a veteran of the Navy, and I'm here, and I am part of a number of groups in our area dedicated to protecting human rights and opposing war and genocide, including Code Pink, Jewish Voice for Peace, and most often Veterans for Peace. I'm here today to help push back against points that we've heard from some members of this council who made it clear at the beginning of September that they were not— that they are not here operating in good faith on this issue. Despite this policy going out of its way to make it clear that this is not about one this was disgusting, knowingly dishonest. Your constituents are not that stupid, so please avoid doing that again. But since it's come up today anyway, I wanted to level set. It is no one's opinion that Israel has violated human rights. Thank you. That is the finding of every major humanitarian rights organization on the planet, including B'Tselem in Israel. According to polling, 80 to 90% of Democrats, 50 to 60% of Republicans, 30% of Israeli society, Israeli genocide and Holocaust scholars, several UN rights commissions, hundreds of countries around the world, and a growing number of congressional representatives, including D3's Representative Dexter here in Portland, have all concluded that Israel is guilty of genocide of the Palestinians. We see the terror attacks on its surrounding neighbors. We see the illegal wars against Iran and Lebanon. Councilmember Herbold. We see the ethnic cleansing taking place in Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem, southern Lebanon, and land grabs in Syria. This is not a quote-unquote conflict. This is a genocide we here in the U.S. are helping to pay for. So if this council media sees all of this and your response is, well, why aren't we talking about Bangladesh? You reveal how dishonest and bad faith you are. The reason we're not talking about Bangladesh is because we're not actively funding their genocide and war crimes. Thank you. So now that that tactic isn't work— isn't working, we're going to talk about how we're worried about having too many commissions and resource constraints. And these nebulous questions that were never brought up before, they'll continue to move the goalposts because they know that a human rights screening for all will include organizations and countries that they don't want it to. But again, this isn't just about Israel. This is about any and all nations, organizations, corporations, and individuals profiting off of violations of human rights. This includes those entities here in the U.S. helping to support things like the starvation of Cuba, the bombing of fishermen off the coast of South America, the ethnic cleansing occurring here in our immigrant communities, Russian bombings of civilians and infrastructure, as well as any ties to ongoing genocides in Sudan and the Congo, just to name a few. It's this simple. We don't want our tax dollars going to fund governments and organizations that are guilty of killing kids. If you want to pretend that all of this, you know, supporting this policy, including constituents and Jewish Voice for Peace, are doing it because we're all a bunch of antisemites, or because you're suddenly concerned around resource constraints, Councilmember Dan Ryan. And having too many commissions, please know that only the dumbest and most heavily propagandized of your constituents will believe that. Thank you. [01:52:04] Unidentified speaker: Thank you. [01:52:07] Rebecca Dobert: That was our final testimony. [01:52:09] Sameer Kanal: Okay, thank you. Um, okay, so we're, we're still in the queue to discuss the amendment. It's now divided. I'll ask if we can just do all the discussion together and then take 2 votes separately. Um, Councilor Zimmerman, is that a legacy hand? Seeing a nod. Anyone else in the queue to discuss amendment, let's say, Canal 1A and Canal 1B? We'll be voting on these in order with the first paragraph first and the second paragraph second. So Rebecca, could you please call the roll on Canal 1A? [01:52:41] Rebecca Dobert: So Canal 1A, this was To vote on the, uh, adding the first be it further resolved clause, correct? [01:52:52] Sameer Kanal: Yeah, the, the one that begins that the council remains committed. [01:52:55] Rebecca Dobert: Council remains committed, uh, moved by Kanal, seconded by Green. Uh, Clark absent. Green? [01:53:03] Mitch Green: And a yes vote is an affirmative vote for that first piece, right? Yes. Aye. [01:53:10] Rebecca Dobert: Zimmerman? [01:53:11] Eric Zimmerman: Aye. [01:53:12] Rebecca Dobert: Avalos? [01:53:13] Candace Avalos: Aye. [01:53:15] Rebecca Dobert: Dunphy? [01:53:17] Jamie Dunphy: Aye. [01:53:18] Rebecca Dobert: Smith? [01:53:19] Loretta Smith: Aye. [01:53:20] Rebecca Dobert: Pirtle-Guiney? [01:53:22] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Aye. [01:53:23] Rebecca Dobert: Ryan? [01:53:24] Dan Ryan: Aye. [01:53:26] Rebecca Dobert: Koyama Lane? [01:53:27] Tiffany Koyama Lane: Aye. [01:53:29] Rebecca Dobert: Murillo? [01:53:31] Angelita Morillo: Aye. [01:53:32] Rebecca Dobert: Novick? [01:53:34] Steve Novick: Aye. [01:53:35] Rebecca Dobert: Kanal? [01:53:36] Sameer Kanal: Aye. [01:53:37] Rebecca Dobert: And, uh, Kanal 1A, the amendment is approved with 11 aye, 1 absent. [01:53:43] Sameer Kanal: Is there any further discussion on Kanal 1B? Becca, could you please call the roll on Kanal 1B? This is the paragraph that begins that the council encourages the administration. [01:53:54] Rebecca Dobert: Yeah, Kanal 1B, to add the second for B, it further resolved, also moved by Kanal, seconded by Green. Clark, also absent. Green. [01:54:02] Mitch Green: Aye. [01:54:04] Rebecca Dobert: Zimmerman. [01:54:05] Eric Zimmerman: No. [01:54:06] Rebecca Dobert: Avalos? [01:54:08] Candace Avalos: Aye. [01:54:09] Rebecca Dobert: Dunphy? [01:54:10] Jamie Dunphy: Aye. [01:54:11] Rebecca Dobert: Smith? [01:54:13] Loretta Smith: Aye. [01:54:14] Rebecca Dobert: Pirtle-Guiney? [01:54:16] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: No. [01:54:18] Rebecca Dobert: Ryan? [01:54:20] Dan Ryan: No. [01:54:20] Rebecca Dobert: I'm sorry, Councilor Ryan, that was a no? [01:54:22] Dan Ryan: Yeah, no. [01:54:23] Rebecca Dobert: Thank you. Thank you. Koyama Lane? [01:54:26] Tiffany Koyama Lane: Aye. [01:54:28] Rebecca Dobert: Murillo? [01:54:29] Angelita Morillo: Aye. [01:54:31] Rebecca Dobert: Novick? [01:54:32] Steve Novick: Aye. [01:54:33] Rebecca Dobert: Kanal? [01:54:34] Sameer Kanal: Aye. [01:54:35] Rebecca Dobert: And the amendment Kanal 1B is approved with 8 aye, 3 nay, 1 absent. [01:54:42] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, colleagues. I'm going to pass it to Councilor Novick, but with your permission, Councilor Novick, I'd love to take a break first. Okay, we'll be back in 10 minutes. See you back at 11:30. Let's do 11:31. Thank you. I want to recognize Councilor Novick. [02:05:55] Steve Novick: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [02:05:56] Sameer Kanal: Again, um, let's see, this has been filed actually, uh, I might have neglected to send this to everybody, but it's pretty simple. It's an amendment to Exhibit A, Section 16, Environmental, Social, and Government and Governance. And after the words, the city will use an ESG screen to consider the effects of its investments in alignment with the United States— United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adding this sentence: The city shall also use an ESG screen or screens that consider companies' records of compliance or noncompliance with labor laws or standards, environmental laws, and consumer protection laws. Okay, that has been formally moved by Councilor Novick. Is there a second? Seconded by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. We'll now go into discussion of this amendment. Councilor Avalos? Are we going to receive it in writing? Uh, you should have actually just now. Spencer sent it out. Apologize for not getting it to you before. Okay, I have received it as of a minute or two ago, so hopefully you all will too. Okay, uh, Councilor Avalos, anything further, or is that—. [02:07:16] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: I need a minute to read it, so I'll get back in the queue. [02:07:18] Unidentified speaker: Thanks. [02:07:19] Sameer Kanal: Great. Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. [02:07:22] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Thank you, Chair. And first of all, thank you, Councilor Novick, for making sure that we did not lose these pieces of the conversation that were an equally important part of the discussion last year. I am wondering if I can hear from staff whether we can do this through the same contract and through the same ESG screen, or whether we will need to pay for 2 screens. In order to make this happen, or have even— I think worst-case scenario would be 2 contracts, but that's possible as well. Do we— can either Bridget or Joan speak to that? [02:08:02] Bridget O'Callaghan: Yes, I— Joan has had to step away. Bridget O'Callaghan, City Treasurer. Yes, we should be able to do it under the same contract. [02:08:12] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Okay, so we shouldn't see an increase in timing complication, maybe a slight increase in price, but if so, pretty minor, or do you think that this could double our cost? [02:08:24] Bridget O'Callaghan: I would not say double our costs. It would add some additional time, and we do need to understand the clarification right around what some of the terminology means. So that's all part of what would be involved in engaging in the scope of work with a vendor for that. But once we have that all outlined, then it should be under that same contract. [02:08:48] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Great. Thank you so much. [02:08:53] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. I want to give folks a moment to get in the queue just in case. Okay. Seeing no one else in the queue, we are in discussion of an amendment Councilor Novick proposed, Novick 1, seconded by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. Rebecca, will you please call the roll on Amendment Novick 1? [02:09:16] Rebecca Dobert: On Novick 1, moved by Novick, seconded by Pirtle-Guiney. Clark absent. Green? [02:09:22] Mitch Green: Aye. [02:09:23] Rebecca Dobert: Zimmerman? [02:09:24] Eric Zimmerman: Aye. [02:09:25] Rebecca Dobert: Avalos? [02:09:26] Candace Avalos: Aye. [02:09:28] Rebecca Dobert: Dunphy? [02:09:28] Jamie Dunphy: Aye. [02:09:29] Rebecca Dobert: Smith? [02:09:30] Loretta Smith: Aye. [02:09:32] Rebecca Dobert: Pirtle-Guiney? [02:09:33] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Aye. [02:09:34] Rebecca Dobert: Ryan? [02:09:35] Dan Ryan: Aye. [02:09:36] Rebecca Dobert: Koyama Lane? [02:09:37] Tiffany Koyama Lane: Aye. [02:09:39] Rebecca Dobert: Murillo? [02:09:41] Angelita Morillo: Aye. [02:09:42] Sameer Kanal: Aye. [02:09:44] Steve Novick: Aye. [02:09:45] Rebecca Dobert: The amendment is approved with 11 aye, 1 absent. [02:09:50] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, colleagues. We're now back in the queue on the underlying. I believe we do not need a motion, or we do need a motion to refer this on to the full council with a do pass recommendation. Councilor Zimmerman? [02:10:07] Eric Zimmerman: Thank you. I appreciate how this has gone and some adjustments here. And Jonas, what I'm really wondering about is, I was hoping in your initial presentation that we get some sense of an idea for what the impact is of your proposed changes from the current investment policy. We didn't really get any impact. We got, here's what we're doing. So in order to make a change, I would expect to see a, you know, of the 35, we think this will go down by 3, or we think no change, or something to that effect. But we got nothing from that. So I'm trying to get a sense for what, what is it that we invest in today that we won't invest in tomorrow if this is adopted? [02:10:59] Bridget O'Callaghan: Councilor Zimmerman, I believe that CFO Berry had to step away, so I will try and answer your question as best I can. The challenge at this juncture is that we honestly don't know. We've just added some new amendments to the policy, so we're going to need to understand what those mean in terms of how they might be interpreted, defined, et cetera, and how they would roll out to the plan. So the honest answer is that we don't know. Thank you. I don't know. Um, in terms of the companies that are presently on our, our list, we call it the investable universe, roughly 35 names. Of those 35 names, those companies are generally very highly rated and historically have also had very high ESG ratings. So based upon that presumption, one would assume that there wouldn't be a whole lot of change in terms of the investable universe. There were some names that were mentioned, though, in testimony today that are still on the list and would still be available to invest in. So it all depends on, on how we define the terms that were just added today. And of course, that would be outlined in the scope of work for, you know, the ESG vendor that we would select. So unfortunately, I'm not able to really provide you with much of an estimate of that. I will tell you that there is some additional cost to the city in terms of staff time. Of course, this new contract, um, and, you know, when you're adding additional screens, it just simply, um, requires more work to do that. So the cost estimate in the, um, original resolution was between, you know, I believe it was $200,000 and $500,000. So it was a pretty big, you know, range in terms of that. With the amendments today, it's going to add some to that. There will be some decisions that we'll be making on the investment portfolio that will adjust the return as well. So the return will likely be lower because we're not investing in certain things as well. So all of those impacts are hard for me to put a number on now, but I'm hoping that gives you at least a flavor of what we're looking at. [02:13:21] Eric Zimmerman: What I'm trying to understand, I guess, is specifically, who are we investing in that has a notable human rights violation? Because based on the testimony, you would think that this is going to be a significant change. And then you just noted that there will be a lower return. So I'd like to know, who is it that we're investing in that we won't, given this new policy? And that's the kind of specificity. If we're going to add a clause, I'd like to understand what that is, because what was conveyed previously and what my understanding was is that this was largely no change. So I— it can't be both, right? Yeah, I understand. It's got to be one or the other. I just— I, I, um, there's an aspect of we don't know because we have to go through the assessment that I do understand that. I want to give grace there. But I also— there's got to be an initial assessment that led the team to decide to put it in this year's policy instead of just adopting last year's again, right? We have one of the more robust social investment policies, I think, frankly, across the country. So we're going to go another step. And I thought there must be a reason why the CFO's team has done this, and I'm not hearing the reason why. And then I'm not hearing also what we expect the impact to be, but we expect there'll be losses. So I'm, I'm struggling here a little bit, and I'm hoping that maybe, maybe it would be better if I pause if there's no complete answer now, and other questions might flush it out a little bit. But I'll give that back to you, Ms. O'Callaghan. [02:14:55] Bridget O'Callaghan: Yeah, I appreciate that, Councilor. I'm not trying to, you know, be vague. It's just that with the latest amendments, that's unclear. When we brought the this particular—. [02:15:12] Eric Zimmerman: Sorry, can I just—. [02:15:13] Bridget O'Callaghan: Yes. [02:15:14] Eric Zimmerman: Let me just clarify, not with the most recent amendments, the— what Novick and Kanal, what those just passed. I just mean what you all brought forward as the staff document. And I recognize the unclear nature of an amendment in the moment, but just for the staff document that you all have been working on, I'll keep it limited to that. [02:15:41] Sameer Kanal: Is everybody else getting that? We're having an audio issue. Do you want to try again, Bridget? [02:15:48] Bridget O'Callaghan: Sure, my apologies. I seem to be having some, uh, technical difficulties today. My apologies. Just to answer the question very clearly, um, the original proposed investment policy before the revisions was anticipating very minor changes to the firms that the city could choose to invest in. So I want to be clear about that. It's unclear with the new amendments what that might look like, but as of what we brought forward— forth, that was the case. Now, the reason for proposing the changes we proposed to the investment policy was really because of that workgroup, right? There was a workgroup of interested council offices and community that put forth the concerns that were included in that new ESG section. And so that's the reason it was added. Did that answer your question, Councilor Zimmerman? [02:16:49] Eric Zimmerman: It did in partial. [02:16:51] Sameer Kanal: Are the—. [02:16:51] Eric Zimmerman: Of the 35, given the original policy, not the new amendments, of the 35, are you anticipating that City of Portland is currently investing in any one that is a human rights violator and thus with this new policy would not be invested in in the new year? I'm not hearing you. [02:17:13] Unidentified speaker: Sorry about that. [02:17:15] Bridget O'Callaghan: No, we are not investing in any known human rights violators that, you know, would be removed from the list. [02:17:24] Sameer Kanal: Okay. [02:17:24] Eric Zimmerman: I really appreciate the help here. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. [02:17:31] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman. Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, followed by Green. [02:17:38] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Thank you, Chair. I've got a couple of questions for staff, starting with a question or two about the presentation. Bridget, there was some information in the presentation about our returns year over year on our investments, and there was a pretty sharp increase since 2022. And just as we're, as we're talking about changes to our investment policy, I want to understand what's happening with our investments to know how that might change with changes in the policy. Was that sharp increase since just a few years ago because the market got better and it has nothing to do with us? Because we made changes in our investments and how we invest and we have a more profitable portfolio right now and we should understand that as we take part in this discussion? Or are we just investing more now than we did before, so the returns are higher? How, how do I understand that number? [02:18:34] Bridget O'Callaghan: Great question. Thank you. There are a number of factors. So in the, in that horizon that you saw, there are a variety of different things that affect the return on that portfolio. One is the actual size of the underlying portfolio itself, and that is going to fluctuate from time to time based upon a variety of factors, including when the city issues debt. So for example, when we issued We have funds to invest for a short period of time while a project may be underway, that sort of thing, right? So that's going to affect our return because the balances themselves are different. What you might have also seen in that was at several years ago, at council's direction, we discontinued investing in corporate securities for a period of time. So that might have also been influenced by this. We added them back. I believe it was in 2021 when we introduced the Bloomberg industry classification prohibitions. So that allowed us to add them back in 2021. So what you would have seen in '22 and thereafter would have included this select group of corporate securities. And then, of course, the market, right? The market has certainly— is certainly going to fluctuate. And so that's what's another component. Thank you. [02:19:56] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: I'm seeing sharp increases between '22 and '23 and '23 and '24, and then a leveling off. So it sounds like between '22 and '23, that could be our market investments coming back into the portfolio. What about '23 to '24? And again, I'm trying to understand if, if our current investments are particularly strong for the city, Changes to our investment portfolio way different for me than if our current investments are kind of humming along in a stable way, but we haven't made any changes that have made them particularly strong. And I, I'll pause for a minute before I have you answer just to say I'm really supportive of what you all brought back. I want to make sure that it's something I can feel fully comfortable voting for in good faith while keeping our investments strong, which is why I'm asking this question. I want to make sure that we can move forward responsibly on the legislation before us today. So whatever you can tell me with specifics about those 2 years is really helpful. [02:21:13] Sameer Kanal: Thank you. [02:21:14] Unidentified speaker: Sure. [02:21:15] Bridget O'Callaghan: Um, I— for more specifics, I will certainly invite the city's investment officer to share specifics about that period of time. But at a high level, um, you know, we have to look at the, the market itself, uh, in those years was significantly impacted. Those of you who might have pension plans or your own 401s will notice that back in 20— 22 and '23, that was a really difficult time. It's also coming off of the whole COVID pandemic time, right? So that naturally was going to affect the market. Michael, is there anything that you would want to add in terms of specifics on the differences, you know, between '21 and '22, '23, that period of time? Please feel free to share that. [02:22:04] Michael Montgomery: Sure. Thank you, Bridget. Michael Montgomery, Investment Officer for the City of Portland. Hopefully you can all hear me well. Yeah, so to expand upon what Bridget had mentioned, a lot of factors go into the sort of return that the city's earning on our assets. Cash flow is one of them, how much assets we have to manage, how much debt is being issued, and on the other side, how much is being spent to balance out where our investments are. Investable book is coming out of COVID and you know, hate to go back to that era, but that was a major impact on our returns going forward. As we invest money, as certain securities that mature and new money comes in, we're then you know buying new assets. And coming out of COVID we had you know. For a rough estimate, the 2-year Treasury, which is sort of a benchmark on kind of the duration at which we're buying assets, and was around 50 basis points during COVID and to date, it took until January of 2022 for that to even go above 1%. And since then, the economy's come back. Did you say 50 basis points? In today's terms, a 2-year Treasury, we could earn 4.5% roughly, right? So we've come off very, very historical lows in terms of interest rates and return, you know, the rate of return we're getting on our assets to more of a traditional point where the Federal Reserve has raised rates quite a bit. Overall yields are much higher than they were back then. Yeah. So assets since '21-'22 have been, you know, and new money that's coming in has been reinvested in higher and higher returns. And that happens pretty quickly. But, you know, I kind of say sometimes, you know, driving the portfolio is like driving a large ship. It shifts, but it takes time because we're considered traditionally a buy-and-hold. Yeah. Portfolio, so you know our our approach to asset management is to one ensure the principal is returned to us and all of those sorts of things. And so it takes time for our returns to sort of reset in in today's rate of return. So it's been going up; it will continue to go up. Things have sort of. Stabilized over the last year. I mean, there's a lot of market turbulence, especially today, but it's generally, generally kind of a slow-moving curve. And as rates go up, the returns go up, and as they go down, conversely. [02:25:03] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Thank you. So I, I'm looking specifically at a tripling in our return between '22 and '23. It sounds like that is because we went back to having market investments. I'm going to take that to mean that pulling out of market investments altogether could have significant consequences to our portfolio that we would want to think very carefully about, but some tinkering around the edges of our portfolio is probably not going to impact our return. I'm also seeing a doubling between '23 and '24 very specifically. And it sounds like that may just be chalked up to market gains coming out of COVID itself, and that I shouldn't read anything more into that. Is that a fair statement? I think that's—. [02:25:57] Michael Montgomery: Yeah, I think that's fair. [02:25:59] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Um, okay, great. [02:26:01] Michael Montgomery: It's, you know, the amendments and so forth are dealing specifically with the corporate investing. And we can get into a detailed discussion about what spread or additional income is earned off that portion of the portfolio. The real driver in that long discussion is really how is the implementation of the limits and the categories at which the city wants to look at from an ESG standpoint. Yeah. Allowable, what's not allowable, and how we develop that process in, in layering that overlay into the portfolio. So that part of it is sort of, in my view, the second part of this, which is the developing the implementation of how we look at ESG scores and how those are then decided, like what is an investable issuer. Yeah. And what isn't. And so our engagement after issuing an RFP is to develop, you know, what are the grading criteria that they're using, which ones do we want to use, and what metrics do we want to set a threshold in determining what's allowable and what's not allowable. You know, Bridget had mentioned currently we're at about 30% of the portfolios and And very high-grade corporate bonds. We've shared a lot of documents about who those are. And where the rubber meets the road sort of is like, okay, well, where's that criteria drop-off and what's going to be then overlaid on the portfolio? It's hard to say, like, you know, many of these corporations are highly rated for a lot of reasons and they meet generally operating in the United States are meeting a lot of regulatory guidelines now. So some names that might be mentioned may have really high scores, and so they may not, you know, necessarily depending on what our criteria level is, get booted off or become an uninvestable security. But that's really the development of how the implementation great, thank you. [02:28:22] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: I do have 2 or 3 additional questions, and I want to make sure I'm not taking up too much time. [02:28:29] Sameer Kanal: You're at about 11 minutes. [02:28:30] Unidentified speaker: If you can prioritize. [02:28:32] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: I'm sorry, that was one question, Chair. [02:28:34] Sameer Kanal: So I'll ask for the folks who are responding to be as brief as you can be. [02:28:40] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: So very, very just yes or no answer. With this change, Are we keeping our list, our current list of prohibited industries? I want to just confirm that that stays a part of how we are operating our investment portfolio. [02:28:57] Bridget O'Callaghan: Yes. [02:28:58] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Okay. I'm going to ask the next 2 questions. Well, no, I'm going to keep them separate. I'm sorry. I'll ask what I hope is the more straightforward one first. During the presentation, you talked about publishing the results of the third-party review. Can you explain so that we know what to expect, what that will include? Is that how each company ranked? Is that just if anybody was removed from our investment portfolio? What level of detail should we expect in that follow-up information? [02:29:39] Bridget O'Callaghan: What we're envisioning is that if we are using an ESG rating in the choice, in the selection of that investment, it will be noted in the reports that we publish monthly. [02:29:53] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: So if we are using it in the choice to invest, it will be noted. And presumably because all of our corporate investments will be run through this, that would be noted for all of our corporate investments. [02:30:11] Bridget O'Callaghan: But I want to recognize that we have an existing portfolio that for a period of time, right, those, those will be running off, right? So they will not apply to the existing portfolio. But if we use it going forward, then yes. [02:30:28] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Okay, so there will be a transition time where that publication is very significant, and that will help people understand why we may have investments that are not being made. That they assumed wouldn't qualify under this policy, we will reach a point in time in the future where it's labeled for all of our corporate investments. [02:30:47] Bridget O'Callaghan: Correct. [02:30:48] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: Okay, great. Final question, which may take a little bit more to really understand. Your first slide talked about an objective course of action. And I think that's really important. When we met in September, I had said that I was really looking forward to getting a recommendation from you all and had appreciated the work you put in because I do think we need to adopt an ESG screen for our investments, but that I wanted to make sure that we were objective. And that if possible, we were using a screen that already existed, so we didn't even get into the subjectivity of picking it. Unfortunately for me, you all brought back something where we do have to pick. So how are we keeping that work objective? Who is in charge of doing that? How is that influenced? We have put language in, or will put language in our policy if we adopt this, specifically pointing to the types of of human rights listed in the UN Declaration of Human Rights, which is a great way to base this work. We've now added some language around labor and the environment and a few other pieces. So who is taking that direction from council and boiling it down to something that we are then giving to companies? Are you doing that? Is staff doing that? Are we putting just the council language out and getting RFPs back? [02:32:25] Bridget O'Callaghan: Yes. [02:32:26] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: And who's making the choice about whether it qualifies or not? Where does the objective come in? [02:32:32] Bridget O'Callaghan: Great question, and a lot of pieces to that. So, Councilor, um, bear in mind that we're treading some new ground here, um, because in many cases policies will either have a list of prohibitions or it'll have some ESG parameters. So what I would foresee is that once this resolution is passed, the Treasury Division, Michael, of course, as the Chief Investment Officer for the city, will pull that information together and we will develop a scope of work for an RFP, or request for proposal, that will incorporate all of these things. I will admit that I'm a little concerned with some of the language that's been added to in the amendments. It's not insurmountable. We can certainly work with it, but it's—. Okay. It's not as defined as we would like it to be. Again, back to your point about objectivity. When you're investing the city's funds, it's really important to be very objective so that we have parameters of what we can do and we can't, and we carry that out. And so my responsibility is to make sure that Michael has that at the end of the day when he's investing the city's monies. That's very clear what he can and can't do. So there will be an effort. If you look at the very last slide that had sort of the pathway graphic in it, that you'll notice. Thank you. There are a number of steps along the way. So there will be steps where we will engage the city's Investment Advisory Committee. We will be drafting some information there. [02:34:03] Unidentified speaker: We will be seeking input from council in certainly any way that council would like us to, but the thought would be back to working with that workgroup, a similar workgroup to what we worked with this past year, with interested council offices having an opportunity to provide input. And then once we've drafted that scope of work and, and have narrowed it down to the parameters that we wish to use with the vendor, we'll issue the RFP. We will also have an opportunity to have community members perhaps join us on the evaluation committee for that RFP. So that would be the other thought in terms of getting some input and, and making sure that we're balancing that. Thank you. [02:34:48] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: I would just like to request that that objectivity remain a core value as you all go through this. To me was the primary thing I was looking for in a policy recommendation, something that allows us to feel like we are investing the city's money as morally as an investment in a corporation can be made. But that we are doing so objectively so that there is stability, right? So that the specific interests of any given councilor coming on or off of council doesn't create drastic changes in the work that we do with our funds at the city. And we can have a clear policy moving forward that Portlanders can understand, that we all can understand, and that is stable, better than we have now, more moral than we have now, and stable. So I would sincerely ask that if we move this forward, that remain a fundamental part of how you all set up the work moving forward. Chair, I will hold my other questions for when presumably this comes to full council. [02:36:11] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. Councilor Green. [02:36:17] Unidentified speaker: Thank you. [02:36:17] Mitch Green: I'll keep my comments brief because I know we've got an agenda item that follows this. Um, so, uh, firstly, a good discussion, I think, on the yield piece. Um, excuse me, $117 million of, of the total balances is pretty in line with what we get on our Treasury yields anyway. So it's—. I don't think it's particularly high or low or remarkable rate of return for a relatively conservative investment portfolio. I think the piece that's important is in this kind of recent historical piece. You know, 2021 was a banner year for capital gains income in corporate, like just corporate income broadly. And so while we don't invest in corporate securities, we do invest in our investment yields are a function of fund balances, and the PCF revenue that we accrued during that period of time immediately following that was substantially driven by that capital gains income. And so that's going to be driving that sort of thing. So I don't think that we're going to see a big jump like that again anytime soon. I could wax— I could pontificate on this for longer, but I won't. But I want to thank the team so much for the work that you've done. You've, you've grappled with some really complicated and tricky issues here. Uh, thanks for everyone for your testimony. At this point, I would move to refer this to the full council with a do pass recommendation. [02:37:47] Unidentified speaker: Second. [02:37:48] Rebecca Dobert: Second. [02:37:49] Sameer Kanal: Moved by Councilor Green, seconded by Councilor Avalos. Um, colleagues, I am going to— I'm only in the queue just to close the queue, um, on this item, so I will do that. I know we have 14 people waiting to testify on the next item, so that's the, the interest I have here. Thank you. Yes, I'll be brief as well. I just want to appreciate the effort to better align the city's investment practices with our values while continuing to prioritize responsible financial management. Investing in death, destruction, and detention is not aligned with our values as Portlanders, as public testimony today clearly demonstrates. This is not about singling out any particular community or country. This is about making sure our investment dollars do no harm and protect dignity and human rights everywhere. Moving forward, I want to ensure that council has clear reporting on implementation, costs, and outcomes so we can evaluate how the policy is working in practice. Thank you to all of the councilors who have worked to make this policy responsive to Portlanders, and I look forward to supporting it. Thank you, Councilor Avalos. Councilor Ryan, followed by Zimmerman. [02:38:57] Dan Ryan: Yes, thank you, Chair Kanal. I just want to say, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, your dialogue that you had with Bridget was really compelling. And I went from feeling the momentum to pass this to then having more concerns. I think that we have to keep it objective and the ESG screening and how that's implemented, it's clear it's going to take a while to really know what the impact is. And I just think we're putting out more mystery here at the very end of before we vote. So I just really appreciated that dialogue. Thank you for lifting that. Those were questions that I was trying to get to the bottom of. And I think I will reserve my right to be concerned until we take this all the way to the council. But today I'm in a more cautionary place after hearing that dialogue. I really appreciate, Bridget, that you were very clear and candid. And Michael, it's great to have you join the conversation. You brought a lot more depth to the dialogue. Thank you. [02:39:59] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Councilor Ryan. Councilor Zimmerman. [02:40:03] Unidentified speaker: Thanks. [02:40:04] Eric Zimmerman: So I appreciate the CFO's team just being clear-eyed that they expect that no organization that we invest in today will not be invested in tomorrow based on what they brought forward. And I, I say that for, for really a reason of this item, at least in its infancy, got, got fairly hurtful. And then you go for, for what impact? And I think that that's important to think through in terms of some of the targeting that, that we identified. And I know not everybody agrees with that, and that, that's okay. But there are ways to achieve the values statements that I think are being achieved in some of what the CFO's team brought forward here that I think is a better way than maybe it was coming some months and year ago. So that's important. And so much— this also goes to the heart of things that go on at the City of Portland, we often will pass something and the public has an expectation that it makes significant change upon passing. And I think we have to be cautious about leading the public to think that an action the city is taking is doing something that it's not, right? And we've seen a few of those cases over the time, and there's a way in which we discuss values, and then there's where we take action, and those are different things. And in this case, what we see is a value statement that I think is workable, but I caution Portlanders who came in and continued to say this isn't about one thing, one place, one group, but then continued to cite one place, one thing, one group. And that kind of stuff, I think it really, it set this up poorly from the beginning in a way that I hope that we can avoid in the future. Councilor Kanal, in this session, I just wanted to say thank you for just how you've helped with the, the conversation on this one. Um, and I know that there are some folks in my— well, many folks in my district who are very concerned about how this came about. I'm going to vote to pass this today to the full council. Uh, if there are parts in this to my constituents that you see are— um, you see a hole that I'm not identifying or something of that nature, I hope you let me know. And we'll come— and I also share some concerns that we're hearing from the treasurer about some of those amendments that got brought forward. But I do think keeping those labor standards in there, the war standards, human rights standards, those are important things. And that's why I'll vote to pass it on to full council. But a challenging topic given some of this council's other histories. And generally, I've always been really proud of Portland's investment policy. We have one of the more restrictive socially aware investment policies that I've seen across the country. We should be proud of that instead of finding the divisiveness of like, what's the next step, right? 35 structures to invest in only out of all the options that exist. We can only invest in 35. So I think we've, we've set a set of standards that, that Portland can be proud of, that, that I am. So I appreciate Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's comments, not just last time but also this time. Uh, they are helpful in framing questions and where the objectivity exists that I think will be important. Uh, a lot of stuff in government and this type of stuff is actually, I think, good when it's boring and when it's kind of just the, the administrative side of it. And, and, uh, that should be okay. Not everything always has to be a political take of a new decision. And this is one of those areas where the city has a fund, we invest that fund, we try to have good returns for folks, we set some values with it, and we come back and we just, we kind of do that each year. And I think we've had a good history of that. So again, Councilor Knoll, thank you for this session, and I'll wrap it up there. [02:44:25] Unidentified speaker: Thank you. [02:44:26] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman. Colleagues, I do see 2 people added themselves to the queue. I did close the queue earlier, so if I can keep to that, I would love to. I appreciate it, colleagues. There is a motion to refer this item as amended to the full council with a do pass recommendation. Rebecca, can you please call the roll? [02:44:50] Rebecca Dobert: Calling the roll on 2026-396, moved by Green, seconded by Avalos. Clerk, absent. Green? [02:44:59] Mitch Green: Aye. [02:45:01] Rebecca Dobert: Zimmerman? [02:45:01] Eric Zimmerman: Aye. [02:45:02] Rebecca Dobert: Avalos? [02:45:03] Candace Avalos: Aye. [02:45:04] Rebecca Dobert: Dunphy? [02:45:05] Jamie Dunphy: Aye. [02:45:06] Rebecca Dobert: Smith? [02:45:07] Elana Pirtle-Guiney: I'm sorry, sorry, I should have got back in the queue to say this earlier. I need to, out of an abundance of caution, just declare a potential conflict of interest because yeah, I look forward, Bridget, to getting more information when this comes to the full council on the objectivity that was discussed, and, um, with hopes that it will be revealed to us that this is a green light and won't have the impact that we're concerned about. For today, I'll go ahead and vote aye. Aye. I just want to say again to the folks that came and testified that the arguments that councilors can have against each other is fine, but I don't think we should be chastising the public, especially a lot of the Jewish elders that have come to share a perspective that other people may not agree with. I don't think that's acceptable. So thank you for being here today and saying something that may have been hard for you. [02:46:12] Loretta Smith: Aye. [02:46:13] Rebecca Dobert: Novick? [02:46:15] Steve Novick: Aye. [02:46:16] Rebecca Dobert: Kanal? [02:46:17] Sameer Kanal: Aye. [02:46:19] Rebecca Dobert: The motion to refer is approved with 11 aye, 1 absent. [02:46:23] Sameer Kanal: Thank you. I won't speak for Council President Dunphy, but I do know this needs to come back sometime before the end of the year, so I'll let him update on when. Appreciate that, colleagues. I will continue the last item on today's agenda, which is the council president— council leadership election process discussion to a future meeting. We have 2 items left on the agenda, and I'd love to have those both called together, if you could please, Rebecca. [02:46:47] Rebecca Dobert: Item 4, chemical weapons usage, document number 2026-389. Item 5, public hearing on items before Committee of the Whole, uh, document number 2026-391. [02:46:59] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, colleagues. We had a discussion with 2 parts that was continued forward. Those are what's coming back today. I want to start by apologizing to those who testified and had to wait, and I did— or signed up to testify and had to wait an additional but I want to make sure that we have that time for you today. So we're going to start with that testimony, and then we're going to continue with any remaining time, which will probably not be much, for our councilors to get in the queue and begin discussion. We have 14 people who were signed up that were unable to testify last time. I don't know how many of them are able to be here today, but I want to hear from as many as are. And again, thank you all in advance for your patience on that. Thank you. Rebecca, could you please call the first group of testifiers? [02:47:40] Rebecca Dobert: First up, we have Beatrix Li, followed by Tyler Fellini. Beatrix, you can unmute and go ahead. [02:47:48] Dan Ryan: Good afternoon, councilors and everyone. My name is Beatrix Li, a member of Portland Cop Watch and a Portland resident with asthma. I'm outside today because my apartment had fire testing, so hopefully that's I'd like to thank Councilor Kanal's office for bringing forth this ordinance to ban tear gas in Portland. We heard loud and clear on Election Day that Americans everywhere, including Portland residents, don't want to live under an authoritarian government. One of the tenets of authoritarianism is suppression of the First Amendment, of freedom of speech, and restricting protest. Let's be clear-eyed here. In the U.S., we spend astronomical amounts of money on military spending. We spend economically more on policing than any other country other than China that spend on military spending. So the first in military spending is the U.S. military, then it goes China's military, and the third is U.S. police. Police spend this budget on military weapons and toys like tear gas, yet we can barely afford to pay rent and buy groceries. From civil rights activists to attorneys, I want to emphasize that we all lost for a world where our First Constitution— our First Amendment right to protest is protected, and a future where in this city and across the world we are free of tear gas and free of police violence. Let's also be clear, PPB has not had a history, to my recollection, of tear gassing or using crowd control munitions and uses of force against white nationalist groups, but has a long history of reserving tear gas and uses of force to oftentimes we saw protests about ending police brutality met with more police brutality. Last week, a PPB officer stated that chemical weapons can prevent the need for a physical or lethal confrontation and is a tool for de-escalation. I would argue that tear gas is escalatory and can lead to physical bodily harm. Councilmember Herbold, for example, a volunteer EMT street medic was hit in the head with a tear gas canister, had symptoms of concussion following, following the incident, leading to memory loss. The danger is not just itself, but also the canisters used to deploy it and aimed at people's heads. And let's also not focus on CS gas used by just federal and local law enforcement. Thank you. Agents or ICE. John Rudolph, a photographer on protest, shared, I shot the Syrian refugee crisis, I shot Paris protests, I shot Hong Kong, and it was Portland police who beat the explicit out of me. While many in 2020 and at the protests against ICE at the detention facility experienced being tear-gassed by the alphabet soup of law enforcement from federal agencies, Locally sourced tear gas is not any better of an experience. When you are in a cloud of tear gas, it doesn't matter who is tear gassing you. It is all harmful. Thank you for your time. [02:50:52] Rebecca Dobert: Tyler, you can go ahead. Tyler. [02:50:55] Steve Novick: I just want to say I feel like we've learned a lot about all of you this week since everybody's Zooming in. So I spoke earlier, but again, my name is Tyler Fellini. I'm the executive director of and a registered lobbyist for Portland Jobs with Justice. I own 4 gas masks. I bought this one in 2017 when PPB was teargassing crowds of Portlanders during Trump's first election. I bought this one in 2020 when downtown Portland was shrouded in gas. This one I bought last year when the federal government was threatening to deploy the National Guard. And then this one I had to buy earlier this year after federal agents indiscriminately teargassed thousands of Portlanders in January. Thank you, Mr. Goldberg. I didn't buy them to do anything more than practice civil disobedience. Despite PPB's comments last time about only using chemical munitions on individuals engaged in unlawful activity, tear gas does not care who you are. The toxic cloud travels. So let me ask you all, is it normal to need a gas mask to take part in a protest, a tradition as old as civil society? Is it normal for a school to relocate is it normal for residents of an apartment building to be sickened by gas seeping in, or for those chemicals to wash towards the Willamette River, where thousands of Portlanders swim during the summer? In January, thousands of Portlanders marched in a nonviolent labor rally, children and elders among them. They were met with tear gas from armed, trained, and well-fortified federal agents. Councilmember Herbold. And our mayor justified it by blaming a handful of unarmed, unarmed demonstrators who crossed a blue line on a sidewalk while thousands of others marched past. Personally, I find that justification indefensible. As long as these chemicals are allowed, someone will always find a way to justify using them on your constituents. This ordinance ends that. It fines unlawful use up to $15,000, and it lets injured people sue. The city has already paid nearly $1.2 million in settlements over tear gas just since 2020. Soldiers in wartime are prohibited from using these chemicals on enemy combatants. Why on earth would we allow them against unarmed neighbors? In PPB's own testimony, they said that the use of these chemicals by law enforcement is not banned by the Geneva Convention and the Chemical Weapons Convention. That may be true, but the city of Portland and the state of Oregon have already taken measures to rein in the use of these weapons. I agree. The fact that carve-outs for domestic law enforcement purposes exist has not deterred legislators from going further. It is up to you as the legislative body representing Portland to recognize that weapons not fit for warfare have no business being used on our city streets. Please vote yes. Thank you. [02:53:44] Rebecca Dobert: Match Kay. [02:53:50] Match Kay: Okay, Match Kay. I'm a resident in District 3. I'm 29 years old, and I have been in in 2020, like many Portlanders, I took to the streets to protest police brutality after George Floyd was murdered. I also graduated from Lewis& Clark College that May. So to pay for my undergrad degree, I donated my eggs 5 separate times between 2017 and 2021. The last 2 rounds were the fall of 2019 and the spring of 2021. Between those rounds of egg donation, I was tear-gassed well over 100 times. I'm sorry. PBV didn't use gas every night, and sometimes it was the feds. I was unable to purchase a gas mask until midway through 2020, July 2020, to be specific. Before I had that mask, I noticed that every night I was in the gas, it became a little bit easier to keep my eyes open and breathe normally as I built a tolerance to it wearing only a KN95 and a bandana. Thank you. I was unable to get a mask until July 2020. I still knew it was taking its toll on me as my period lasted for over 4 straight months. When I donated— when I went back to donate my eggs in early 2021 to pay off my now occurring student loans, I was informed that I was entering perimenopause. The medication wasn't stimulating my ovaries as it usually did, and ultrasound showed my egg count was severely depleted. Multiple doctors have confirmed this diagnosis, and I became I did not sue this city, the state, or the federal government because I work in law and I know what would happen if I tried. I could vividly see my face on Fox News, a woman with short hair labeled Antifa who was whining over fictional symptoms. They would tear apart every aspect of my life, including my sexual history, desperate to pin my infertility on anything else. I'm frankly just telling you it was the I had to tell my parents that they will not have grandchildren. I had to tell my long-term partner that we could never conceive. I would not wish this on anyone—the hot flashes, the loss of bone density, the increased cancer risk, and the shorter general life expectancy. I frankly would not change my actions in 2020, but if I can save anyone else from this experience, I will try. For any police who consider yourselves to be pro-choice, you took away my choice. I, I know I'm not the only person that this happened to, so I urge you to please ban the use of tear gas in this city. Thank you. [02:56:25] Rebecca Dobert: Alissa Azar. [02:56:30] Loretta Smith: Um, hi everyone, uh, my name is Alissa Azar. I'm a local journalist who has been exposed to chemical weapons more times than I can count while covering protests and events, I've witnessed PPB's indiscriminate chemical attacks reach babies sleeping in their cribs. I've seen people lose consciousness, vomit, and children scream in pain and fear. The list is honestly really long, but after listening to the testimony presented by PPB last week, I felt a little bit compelled to address. The disgusting minimization of these weapons as harms, and also the suggestion that without the ability to deploy chemical weapons, police would have no choice but to use live ammunition and lethal force on community members. This erases alternatives like de-escalation, disengagement, as though the only options are chemical weapons or murdering Portlanders. Councilmember Herbold. Also, the officer's repeated minimization of reproductive harm was particularly sickening. After PPB's heavy use of tear gas in 2020, my menstrual cycle has still never returned to normal. To this very day, I continue to suffer from ovarian cysts almost monthly, accompanied by debilitating pain. I know multiple people who have been unable to have children since 2020. Councilmember Herbold. And we're all still trying to understand what these weapons have even done to our bodies. And rather than acknowledge these harms, the officer discussed prolonged exposure in a way that shifted responsibility onto the people who were exposed. Let's be clear about one thing: we did not choose to be exposed. We did not choose where these weapons were deployed. The responsibility belongs to the people who authorized and carried out those deployments. Thank you. In early June of 2025, I was exposed to tear gas multiple times while covering protests, and on June 11th, I had a miscarriage. My most recent exposure had been the very night before when I was exposed to CS gas. That day, I was reminded of the state-sanctioned violence imposed on all of our bodies, and I had to sit in that violence all over again. Any choice that I had was taken away from me. When an officer minimizes reproductive harm and suggests that chemical weapons are the alternative to lethal force, I hope people really understand what that sounds like to those of us who have lived through it. It sounds like our suffering doesn't matter. It sounds like our bodies are an acceptable price to pay for the department's preferred methods of crowd control. I beg you to take these harms seriously. Our bodies are not acceptable collateral damage. Councilmember Herbold. [02:59:19] Rebecca Dobert: Benjamin Gilbert. [02:59:23] Jamie Dunphy: Uh, my name is Ben Gilbert and I'm a tenant in District 4 and a voluntary— volunteer lobbyist for the Portland Democratic Socialists of America. Around the world, tear gas is being used to crush and repress dissent. High school students in France are rejecting the status quo of austerity and are met with tear gas. Yes. If our students take to the streets to fight against school closures, will they, will they be met with tear gas? Tenants in Spain resisting the violence of eviction and the housing crisis are met with tear gas. If our neighbors struggling to make ends meet, crushed by rising rents and wages that fail to rise with productivity, take to the streets to demand their right to housing, will they be met with tear gas? Where the people rise up, when the workers, students, and tenants fight back against austerity, oppression, That's what tear gas is. The Portland Police have told us that they aren't using chemical weapons to repress the people when we take to the streets in protests, but this hasn't always been the case, as we all know. And as long as they are purchasing these weapons, we cannot be sure that sometime in the future, when the people rise up once again to resist injustice and their voices are stronger than ever, they will not be met with tear gas. Thank you. They will use them again. The Portland police have told you that they don't use tear gas to repress demonstrations right now, but they told us all that they think the feds' use of tear gas was out of line. At the same time, they say that they want to reserve the right to use it in the future. At the same time, they think it's okay to use these chemical weapons against us when we're alone, even in our own homes. Their Special Emergency Response Reaction Team uses it against Portlanders. In February, CERT shot OC vapor and tear gas into a man's apartment building as a less lethal or de-escalation tactic. This clearly didn't work because shortly after they shot him— because shortly after they shot and killed him. It is unacceptable to use tear gas outside against a crowd. How could it be justifiable to be used against Portlanders who may be experiencing mental health crises good afternoon. [03:01:46] Bethany Ross: Thank you for your time and just to hear me. For the record, my name is Bethany Ross, former Portland resident, Milwaukee currently. Portland enough, if I say so. I just want I'm gonna run everyone through my personal interaction and take you all back to the date of February 1st, 2026, where a red line was severely crossed in my personal belief, and that is tear gas being used upon children and everyone over the age of 18. That was my red line to come out and peacefully protest along with countless other folks. We marched down from City Hall to the ICE facility. Thank you. To also let the agents of DHS know our frustrations with just gassing anyone and everyone. And honestly, it was my first experience with gas. I think that just simply put it, it's horrifying. I wish that pain and suffering upon no one. And they may say that we had safety exits. We did not. We did not. We only had Bond Street to get out, and the munitions that were dispersed by the federal agents was beyond what needed in the first place. And gas is indiscriminatory. It does not just stay in one place. Sure, it was a nice weather night, but there was a breeze, and because of that slight breeze that came from the south moving north, that giant fog of chemical munitions pushed all the way up to OHSU's South Campus. Even as countless droves of us were trying to safely disperse and get away from the area, we still could not escape the gas. My heart and sympathy especially goes out to any and all residents in the areas of South Portland who have no choice in the matter. Thank you. Whether they get gassed or not. For the families especially, that housing is what it is— limited. And at least the opportunity to have housing, just, it's a horrible thing to think about, honestly. So just, it's personal testimony. I really honestly do not see Portland moving forward being pro-gas should not be considering gas at all in crowd control. Policing is slightly getting better, but I think as a whole entire community, if we all come to the table, we can work and redefine what policing means, what crowd control means, and just set a better example going forward. I would like for you all to consider the ban on munitions of chemical agents upon. [03:04:43] Rebecca Dobert: We have 2 more folks online. Wilfred Barrett. Excuse me, Wilfred Barrett. [03:04:52] Wilfred Barrett: All right. [03:04:52] Rebecca Dobert: Hello. [03:04:53] Wilfred Barrett: Thank you. My name is Wilfred Barrett. I'm a resident of District 3 here in Portland. I do want to thank members of the council for listening to testimony about the ban on the use of chemicals by Portland Police Department. Thank you. I'm in support of a ban against using of crowd control chemicals. I experienced them both in 2020 and 2026, one used by federal agents at the ICE facility, the other down at the Justice Center when protests were against police brutality. I think it's amusing that the Portland Police Bureau did mention that they don't think that I don't think the federal one was justified, but theirs was. Personally, I think it is not a good idea to use these gases at any time for any reason. But the use of chemicals, again, is not particularly banned by the Geneva Convention, even though, you know, things like we wouldn't have a soldier use it against people in wartime. Why are you having it used on civilians? A great point. But do you want to talk about some of the things that were mentioned environmentally? Yeah. They did mention a lot of heavy metals being an increased dose. Heavy metals, from a healthcare perspective— I'm a nurse— are cumulative. So it's one of these things where if there is some lead in the air and you're exposed to that continuously over and over again, it's going to build up in a person's central nervous system. This is especially important when you consider developing brains like children and developing people who have uteruses. It's going to be even more prominent how badly it's going to affect the human body, having these heavy metals enter the body, especially through the lungs. But yeah, it's, it's one of these things where I do appreciate your time considering a ban on all use of chemical weapons. And again, I strongly support banning the use of chemical weapons by Portland Police Bureau and entirely in the city of Portland would be nice too. But thank you so much for your time and hope you have a great day. [03:07:01] Unidentified speaker: Thank you. [03:07:03] Rebecca Dobert: Jack Dickinson. [03:07:05] Jack Dickinson: Hi there. I will be pretty brief. So I just wanted to comment on a particular slide from last week's presentation. There was this section with a bar graph talking about how little Portland has paid out in settlement fees compared to other cities. And I just wanted to speak from my experience with the legal side of tort claims, as well as other people's experiences. The implication the police were clearly giving there was that chemical munitions cause less injury. However, I think I'm fairly certain that the real reason why the tort claims are significantly lower is because they're so much harder to win when there isn't a photo of a bruise or an X-ray, or when it's some 10-year slightly nebulous possibility of cancer. So I'd just say if you're comfortable with further shifting the cost of police brutality onto victims, then tear gas is a tool you should absolutely keep. Thank you. But if you have any understanding of how difficult the process is for rectifying harm done by state actors, you'll see through this argument from PPP. So thank you. [03:08:11] Rebecca Dobert: And just one last call. Laura Wadlin, Robert Trafford, Brett Butte, Morrigan Powell, Sandy Em, Heather Hellman. That concludes testimony. [03:08:26] Sameer Kanal: Thank you, colleagues. We're now at 12:33. I appreciate everyone staying a couple minutes over. We're going to continue this item on. Thank you to everyone who testified on either item. Thanks to colleagues. And I believe we have council at 2 o'clock today, so we'll see you there. And this meeting is adjourned. [03:08:42] Unidentified speaker: Thank you.