---
title: "Portland City Council PM Session 11/05/26"
date: 2026-11-05T18:00:00-08:00
durationMinutes: 37
videoUrl: "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EWm3N-nU2tQ"
---

# Portland City Council PM Session 11/05/26

**The Portland City Council voted 11-0 Thursday, with Councilor Olivia Clark (District 4) absent, to write its earlier amendments into the final text of two ordinances regulating Portland's Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub fuel terminals, setting up final votes Nov. 12.**

## Fuel hub ordinances move to final vote

Council President Jamie Dunphy (District 1) presided over the 33-minute session. He said the legislative records were closed and the only task was to replace the ordinances with versions that include council-approved amendments plus technical and conforming changes. The council voted on the land-use ordinance first. The clerk announced **11 ayes and 1 absent** ([00:19:07](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=1147)), though the transcribed roll does not capture every name. A second vote replaced the text of the companion ordinance, which would reduce fuel storage at the hub by 2036. The clerk again announced **11 ayes and 1 absent** ([00:20:29](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=1229)). Both items return **Nov. 12 at 2:15 p.m.** for second reading and final passage ([00:20:34](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=1234)).

A Bureau of Planning and Sustainability staff member, who is not named in the record, described the changes. Council amendments "collapsed the 3 land use reviews into a single review," so staff removed references to transloading expansion being eligible for review ([00:09:54](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=594)). Staff also reposted revised documents this week after community members flagged more needed edits. Those edits were mainly in the ordinance findings, "not in the code changes that were approved by council" ([00:11:22](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=682)).

Councilor Sameer Kanal (District 2) said some input favored moving the land-use reporting deadline from **Dec. 31, 2028** to 2027 ([00:11:55](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=715)). The staff member said the later date gives companies time to begin required seismic improvement programs. Staff do not expect the state Department of Environmental Quality to approve those plans "until well into 2027." Separately, staff said terminals must report fuel and inventory data by **March 31, 2027**, and staff will return with options for the reduction program by September ([00:12:27](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=747)).

Kanal also asked about the one expansion the code allows. The staff member said the 5% cap "applies to the total capacity, fuel capacity on the site as of the date of the adoption." That added capacity can only store aviation fuel, and terminals must still prove need with a current fuel demand analysis ([00:15:15](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=915)). Kanal restated it this way: the increase must be aviation fuel, sized at 5% of total current capacity. Staff answered, "Yes" ([00:16:18](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=978)).

Councilor Mitch Green (District 4) thanked staff for "an above and beyond level of engagement" with residents ([00:16:39](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=999)). Councilor Elana Pirtle-Guiney (District 2) said "there was a significant amount of last-minute work to try to figure out how to make this something that could be broadly supported" ([00:17:17](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=1037)).

## Ida B. Wells rebuild appeal denied

The council voted to deny the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association's appeal of a hearings officer's approval of the Ida B. Wells High School rebuild. The motion upheld the decision with an added condition proposed by Portland Public Schools. Dunphy moved it and Councilor Steve Novick (District 3) seconded. The council had tentatively denied the appeal at its prior meeting and asked staff for revised findings. The clerk announced **11 ayes and 1 absent** ([00:36:30](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=2190)). Most votes on that roll appear in the transcript only as unlabeled "Aye" lines.

## Central City zoning text updated

Councilors replaced the text of the Central City code amendments, which aim to boost housing production and downtown recovery, on an **11-0** roll call with one absent ([00:23:21](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=1401)). Every present member is recorded voting aye. Kanal seconded Dunphy's motion. No one signed up to testify because the record was closed. The item also returns **Nov. 12 at 2:15 p.m.** for final vote ([00:23:25](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=1405)).

## On the dais

Midway through the Central City roll call, Pirtle-Guiney addressed Councilor Loretta Smith (District 1): "And Councilor Smith, it's really distracting to hear the sound in the background. If you can mute that, thanks" ([00:22:54](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=1374)). The noise itself is not identifiable in the record. Earlier, during the fuel-terminal roll call, audio resembling a charity appeal was picked up, including "$10 could be the reason" ([00:19:56](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=1196)). Its source is not identifiable.

During the Ida B. Wells vote, an unidentified speaker noted that the school had won a championship and would host Grants Pass that Friday at 7 p.m. ([00:36:09](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=2169)). Another unidentified voice followed: "Down with Grants Pass. Aye." ([00:36:25](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=2185)).

## Public comment

This session had no open public comment period. The council took no testimony because the records on all four items were closed.

## What's next

The two fuel hub ordinances and the Central City zoning amendments are set for second reading and final votes **Nov. 12 at 2:15 p.m.** Under the fuel storage ordinance, terminals must report fuel and inventory data by March 31, 2027. Planning staff are to return with reduction-program alternatives by September 2027. The land-use implementation report is due Dec. 31, 2028. The meeting adjourned at 2:32 p.m. ([00:36:43](https://portland.windowbox.app/meetings/2026-11-05-1?t=2203)).

---

## Call to Order and Meeting Procedures

**Jamie Dunphy** [6:11]

It is 2 o'clock on Thursday, November 5th. I found a hammer in my garage. Keelan, could we please call the roll?

**Keelan McClymont** [6:20]

Yes, good afternoon. Clark? Green? Zimmerman?

**Eric Zimmerman** [6:29]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [6:30]

Avalos?

**Candace Avalos** [6:33]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [6:34]

Canal.

**Sameer Kanal** [6:37]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [6:38]

Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [6:39]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [6:40]

Ryan.

**Dan Ryan** [6:41]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [6:42]

Koyama Lane.

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [6:43]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [6:44]

Murillo.

**Angelita Morillo** [6:46]

Here.

**Keelan McClymont** [6:47]

Novick. Dunphy.

**Jamie Dunphy** [6:52]

Here. And could the attorney please read the rules of decorum for the chamber?

**Nancy Thorington** [6:57]

Good afternoon. Welcome to the Portland City Council. To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda. Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage. Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise. Your microphone will be muted when your time is over. The presiding officer preserves order. Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed. If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given. Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting. Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass. Additionally, council may take short recess and reconvene virtually. We're already virtual. Um, your testimony should address the matter being considered. When testifying, state your name for the record. Your address is not necessary. If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent. All testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls their name. Thank you. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [7:57]

Thank you very much, colleagues. We have 4 time-certain items today on our agenda. We're going to start off by calling the first 2 time-certain items together, document 2026-311 and 2026-312.

## Time Certain Items

### 12. Adopt the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Policy Project to support public health and natural hazards risk reduction (Ordinance 2026-311)

**Jamie Dunphy** [8:11]

Keelan, can you please call those items?

**Keelan McClymont** [8:13]

Item 12, uh, 2026-311, adopt the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Policy Project to support public health and natural hazards risk education, amend Code Titles 33 and 24. Item 13, document 2026-312, Add bulk fuel terminal capacity reduction regulations code to reduce critical energy infrastructure hub fuel storage by 2036 in support of hazard mitigation. Add Code Chapter 17.112.

**Jamie Dunphy** [8:43]

Thank you very much, colleagues. Our items before us today are land use items, and so I will be, as normal, limping along because it's so prescribed and formal. Lauren, thank you in advance for any questions I may ask. This is a continued council meeting for item 2026-311, the ordinance for land use amendments to the CEI Hub policy project, and for item number 2026-312, an ordinance amending Title 17 to add bulk fuel terminal capacity reduction regulations. The legislative records for these ordinances are closed. The purpose of today's meeting is to replace the ordinances and as amended versions of these supporting exhibits that incorporate the council-approved amendments, plus the technical and conforming with that, we can get into technical and clarifying questions. If there are technical or clarifying questions, we have BPS staff available online to ask about what it is we are updating. I'm sure everybody did all the homework and reread all the notes and reviewed our last meeting. But Tom, is there anything that we need to know immediately about what has changed since last time? No, I think we're good.

**Unidentified speaker** [9:54]

I don't think so. I think, as you know, that the technical and conforming changes are really to update the other parts of the code. So, for example, council amendments collapsed the 3 land use reviews into a single review. So we've updated the references and taken out references to, say, for example, the transloading expansion being eligible for review. And so those, those are the types of changes that we've made in the, in the ordinance documents and in the exhibits. The findings exhibit, Exhibit A for 311, we've acknowledged all of the testimony that council has received and responded to it. So it's much more extensive than the original filed version of that.

**Jamie Dunphy** [10:47]

Thank you very much. I'll also give this opportunity for anybody else from BPS if they want to jump in and add anything. No, not eager to talk. I gotcha. I'm there. Colleagues, is there any technical or clarifying questions for our colleagues from BPS? Councilor Knoll.

**Sameer Kanal** [11:03]

Thanks. I just wanted to first thank you all for the work on this. I wanted to ask, it looks like there was updates to the conforming and technical amendments yesterday. So this is the revised version of that. And just if colleagues had seen the old version, There was a change. Can you speak to that a little bit?

**Unidentified speaker** [11:22]

Yeah, we posted the amended versions earlier this week, and a couple of community members pointed out some additional changes. Again, more just like removing reference to the transloading expansion opportunity and just tightening up this— these were mainly in the findings that go in the ordinance itself. And not in the code changes that were approved by council.

**Sameer Kanal** [11:55]

Got it. I wanted to ask, so with relation to the ordinance Part F, just wanted to ask about the reporting timeline. It's about reporting back on the implementation of the ordinance and that that date is set for December 31st, 2028, and some of the input we've received is that 2027 would be preferable and just seems like a long time. Can you speak to why that date was chosen?

**Unidentified speaker** [12:27]

Yeah, so that applies to the land use ordinance 311, and then we also have in 312 the reduction program reporting in 2027. But what we wanted— what we picked as 2028 for the land use is to get that, um, that in place and have the companies start to implement their required seismic improvement programs and then report back to council as to how that's going and what the review's like. And we wanted enough lag time to be able to, you know, we're not expecting those, those RMIPs to be approved by DEQ until well into 2027. Okay. Also, for the other ordinance, the, the 312, the Title 17, we're going to be back to council and talking about this issue because that is the one that requires the terminals to report their, their fuel data and inventory data by March 31st of '27, and for us to bring back to council by September. Alternatives for the reduction program. So there'll be opportunities for us to come back to council and talk about this issue in 2027 itself, and we can include updates on the RMIPs as part of that discussion.

**Sameer Kanal** [14:01]

Thanks. I have one other question, and it's in the code itself. I'm pulling up— it's in the approval criteria 33-870. 0.060 Part C. Trying to look between all the different— excuse me— ordinances. So I have the copy paste, but I don't know which exhibit it's in. Um, just wanted to verify. It says that if the expansion is for the storage of aviation fuel, the total amount of expanded storage tank capacity cannot exceed 5% more than the storage tank capacity that existed on the applicant's sites on— applicant's site, singular, on— and then there's a blank where we'll put in the date that this is adopted. Plus transloading facilities necessary to connect the expanded storage tank capacity to the terminal, end quote. And I just wanted to get on the record, does this mean that overall storage at the site can increase by 5%, or only the aviation fuel storage on the site can increase by 5%? I think in our prior discussion, it was referred to as only for aviation fuel. I just wanted to get that on the record.

**Unidentified speaker** [15:15]

Yes, it is and applies to the total capacity, fuel capacity on the site as of the date of the adoption, and that, that 5% can only be used for aviation fuel. And that's how it's been from coming through the, the Planning Commission recommendation. I will say that, that C, that allowance also works with approval criteria A, which means in order to go through that process, the terminals still have to show an overall need for that expansion with a current fuel demand analysis. Thank you.

**Sameer Kanal** [16:03]

Okay, so would I be correct if I summarize that as saying the increase, the actual fuel increase, has to be aviation fuel, but the amount by which it can increase is 5% of the total capacity currently in use?

**Unidentified speaker** [16:18]

Yes.

**Sameer Kanal** [16:19]

Okay, thank you for clarifying that. Uh, I think that's all I need right now, Council President. Thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [16:26]

Thank you, Councilor Kanal. Colleagues, any further questions about this item? Pausing for dramatic effect. Okay. Oh, oh, Councilor Green. I didn't—.

**Mitch Green** [16:39]

Sorry, not a question, but I just didn't want to miss the opportunity to just note my, my deep respect and gratitude to the BPS staff for, I think, what was— what is really an above and beyond level of engagement with some community members who are maybe largely from my district, but not just from my district, citywide, who are from all of our districts who care deeply about this project. So, Tom, Patricia, you know, Eric, Donnie, your whole staff, thank you.

**Jamie Dunphy** [17:13]

Thank you, Councilor Green. Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [17:17]

Thank you, Council President. Councilor Green was faster than I there. I want to echo that gratitude. Thank you. There was not only a huge amount of process all the way through this, as there always is with these types of changes, but there was a significant amount of last-minute work to try to figure out how to make this something that could be broadly supported. And I have a lot of gratitude to everybody who took the time to weigh in on that and worked even more than we usually do to, to get this to where it is today. So thank you very much.

**Jamie Dunphy** [17:59]

Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. Okay, seeing no one else in the queue for comments or discussion, I now move to replace item 2026-311, the ordinance for the CEI Hub policy project, and the as-amended versions of Exhibits A and B to reflect the council-approved amendments, technical and conforming changes, plus the updated second. Thank you, Councilor Novick. Colleagues, is there discussion of the motion? Seeing none, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

**Keelan McClymont** [18:41]

Uh, Clark is absent. Green?

**Mitch Green** [18:44]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [18:46]

Zimmerman?

**Eric Zimmerman** [18:47]

Aye.

**Sameer Kanal** [18:50]

Aye. Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [18:54]

Aye.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [18:57]

Aye. Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [19:07]

The amendment is approved with 11 aye votes and 1 absent Thank you, colleagues.

### 13. Add Bulk Fuel Terminal Capacity Reduction Regulations Code (Ordinance 2026-312)

**Jamie Dunphy** [19:15]

I now move to replace the ordinance and the as-amended version of Exhibit A for item 2026-312, the ordinance for the bulk fuel terminal capacity reductions regulations, to reflect the council and technical amendments. Is there a second?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [19:31]

Second.

**Jamie Dunphy** [19:32]

Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney. Colleagues, is there further discussion? Seeing none. Can we please call the roll on item 13?

**Keelan McClymont** [19:46]

Green.

**Mitch Green** [19:47]

Aye.

**Nancy Thorington** [19:47]

Send you the Save the Children— Sorry, just a moment.

**Keelan McClymont** [19:51]

Zimmerman.

**Eric Zimmerman** [19:55]

Aye.

**Nancy Thorington** [19:56]

Your small monthly— $10 could be the reason— Hi. Show that I can all— or go online.

**Sameer Kanal** [20:07]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [20:08]

Colonel Guinea?

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [20:09]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [20:11]

Ryan?

**Dan Ryan** [20:11]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [20:13]

Koyama Lane? Great work, everyone.

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [20:16]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [20:19]

Morillo?

**Angelita Morillo** [20:20]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [20:22]

Novick?

**Steve Novick** [20:26]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [20:26]

Uh, Dunphy?

**Jamie Dunphy** [20:27]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [20:29]

The amendment is approved with a vote of 11 ayes and 1 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [20:34]

Thank you very much, colleagues. Item 2026-311 and item 2026-312 are continued to November 12th at 2:15 PM, time certain, for second reading and final vote.

### 14. Amend the Portland Zoning Code, Comprehensive Plan Map and zoning maps for Central City (Ordinance 2026-343)

**Jamie Dunphy** [20:48]

And Keelan, can we please call item number 13, document 2026-343? This is a 2:15 time certain, and it's 2:16 right now.

**Keelan McClymont** [20:56]

Amend the Portland Zoning Code, Portland Comprehensive Plan Map, and zoning maps to facilitate housing production in post-pandemic economic recovery and revitalization in the Central City, Amend Title 33 Portland Comprehensive Plan Map, Official Zoning Maps.

**Jamie Dunphy** [21:11]

Thank you. I might have said item 15 there. I'm again limping along. I apologize, colleagues. This is a continued council meeting for item number 2026-343, the ordinance for the Central City Code Amendment Project, amendments to Title 33 zoning code. The legislative record for these ordinances are closed. The purpose of today's meeting is to replace the ordinances and as-amended versions of the supporting exhibits that incorporate the council's Council-approved amendments, plus technical and conforming changes. BPS staff are available to respond to questions. We have same exact folks on the call available if there are any questions about the changes to the document. Any questions for our folks at BPS about what is being updated? Okay, Keelan, is anyone signed up for public testimony? I believe the record's closed on this one.

**Keelan McClymont** [22:07]

So, that's correct.

**Jamie Dunphy** [22:08]

Okay, no one signed up to testify. There we go. Well, colleagues, I move to replace the ordinance and the as-amended versions of Exhibit A and B to reflect the council-approved amendments and technical conforming changes, including the updated findings. Is there a second?

**Sameer Kanal** [22:26]

Second.

**Jamie Dunphy** [22:27]

Thank you, Councilor Kanal. Colleagues, is there further discussion of this motion? Seeing none, Keelan, can you please call the roll? Keelan, we lost you.

**Keelan McClymont** [22:45]

Oh, sorry, I was muted. Green.

**Mitch Green** [22:49]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [22:51]

Zimmerman.

**Eric Zimmerman** [22:51]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [22:53]

Avalos.

**Candace Avalos** [22:53]

Aye.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [22:54]

And Councilor Smith, it's really distracting to hear the sound in the background. If you can mute that, thanks.

**Unidentified speaker** [23:00]

The reason he's going—.

**Keelan McClymont** [23:02]

Smith.

**Loretta Smith** [23:03]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [23:04]

Kanal.

**Sameer Kanal** [23:05]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [23:06]

Pirtle-Guiney.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [23:08]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [23:09]

Ryan.

**Dan Ryan** [23:11]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [23:12]

Koyama Lane.

**Tiffany Koyama Lane** [23:13]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [23:14]

Murillo.

**Angelita Morillo** [23:15]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [23:16]

Novick.

**Steve Novick** [23:18]

Aye.

**Jamie Dunphy** [23:21]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [23:21]

The amendment is approved with a vote of 11 ayes and 1 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [23:25]

Thank you very much. Item 2026-343 is continued to a time certain on November 12th at 2:15 PM for second reading and final vote. Item 15 is a time certain item on our agenda that starts at 2:30, and we have been a little fast, colleagues, so I'm going to be giving us a 10-minute recess. See you back here at 2:30.

### 15. Consider an appeal by the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association regarding rebuilding of Ida B Wells High School (LU 26-026160 CU AD)

**Jamie Dunphy** [34:14]

Bringing us back to order. Thank you very much. Keelan, can we please move to item 15, document 2026-347?

**Keelan McClymont** [34:24]

Consider an appeal by the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association requesting to add conditions of approval to the hearings officer's decision to approve the rebuilding of Ida B. Wells High School, LU 26-026160 CUAD.

**Jamie Dunphy** [34:40]

Thank you very much, colleagues. At our last meeting, council approved a motion to tentatively deny the appeal and uphold the hearings officer's decision and conditions of approval, with the addition of the condition of new findings as proposed by the applicant. Council directed staff to return today with revised findings. I want to remind everyone that the evidentiary record is closed. No further presentation from staff or verbal or written testimony will be accepted on this matter. Thank you. It— colleagues, is there further technical or clarifying questions on this, or any further discussion of the item? Seeing no one, I move that council deny the appeal, uphold the decision of the hearings officer with the additional conditional condition of approval as proposed by Portland Public Schools, and adopt the finding. Second. Second. Thank you, Councilor Novick. Colleagues, is there discussion of this motion? Seeing no one, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

**Keelan McClymont** [35:50]

Green?

**Mitch Green** [35:53]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [35:55]

Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.

**Elana Pirtle-Guiney** [36:08]

Aye.

**Unidentified speaker** [36:09]

Speaking of Ida B. Wells, they won the PIL championship and they host Grants Pass this Friday at 7 o'clock. Just thought you should all know that.

**Keelan McClymont** [36:20]

All right, aye. Aye. Aye.

**Unidentified speaker** [36:25]

Down with Grants Pass. Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [36:28]

Dunphy?

**Jamie Dunphy** [36:29]

Aye.

**Keelan McClymont** [36:30]

Uh, the motion carries with a vote of 11 ayes and 1 absent.

**Jamie Dunphy** [36:34]

Okay, I am looking to our city attorney just to get verification. Is there anything else we need to do on any of these items as of today?

**Robert Taylor** [36:42]

No, you didn't.

**Jamie Dunphy** [36:43]

Okay, hooray, colleagues! We have officially completed our agenda for this afternoon. With that, unless there's any further business or comments for the good of the order, I am adjourning this meeting of the Portland City Council. It is 12— uh, 2:32 on Thursday the 5th. Happy Guy Fawkes Day.
