WEBVTT

1
00:05:07.872 --> 00:05:08.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon.

2
00:05:08.982 --> 00:05:12.581
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am calling back to order this recessed meeting of the Portland City Council.

3
00:05:12.709 --> 00:05:16.036
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is Thursday, September 3rd at 2:01 PM.

4
00:05:16.629 --> 00:05:17.723
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can you please take the roll?

5
00:05:18.382 --> 00:05:18.927
<v Keelan McClymont>Good afternoon.

6
00:05:19.201 --> 00:05:19.732
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

7
00:05:21.113 --> 00:05:21.355
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

8
00:05:21.675 --> 00:05:22.158
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

9
00:05:22.334 --> 00:05:22.512
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

10
00:05:23.764 --> 00:05:24.117
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

11
00:05:24.906 --> 00:05:25.017
<v Steve Novick>Here.

12
00:05:25.709 --> 00:05:25.966
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

13
00:05:26.271 --> 00:05:26.432
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

14
00:05:26.978 --> 00:05:27.283
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

15
00:05:28.747 --> 00:05:28.860
<v Mitch Green>Here.

16
00:05:29.406 --> 00:05:29.858
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

17
00:05:32.211 --> 00:05:32.322
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

18
00:05:33.209 --> 00:05:42.202
<v Jamie Dunphy>We cannot hear you, Councilor Avalos, but we can see you.

19
00:05:44.009 --> 00:05:44.605
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, we're good.

20
00:05:44.749 --> 00:05:44.846
<v Keelan McClymont>Yep.

21
00:05:45.634 --> 00:05:46.422
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Smith.

22
00:05:47.403 --> 00:05:47.757
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

23
00:05:48.303 --> 00:05:48.577
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

24
00:05:50.057 --> 00:05:50.266
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

25
00:05:51.490 --> 00:05:51.766
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

26
00:05:52.483 --> 00:05:52.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

27
00:05:53.069 --> 00:05:53.362
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

28
00:05:54.435 --> 00:05:54.728
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

29
00:05:56.706 --> 00:05:56.819
<v Candace Avalos>Here.

30
00:05:56.934 --> 00:05:59.466
<v Jamie Dunphy>And can we please read the rules of decorum for the chamber?

31
00:06:01.939 --> 00:06:03.454
<v Keelan McClymont>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

32
00:06:03.745 --> 00:06:11.305
<v Keelan McClymont>To testify before council in person or virtually, you may sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

33
00:06:15.572 --> 00:06:19.298
<v Keelan McClymont>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

34
00:06:20.026 --> 00:06:24.367
<v Keelan McClymont>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

35
00:06:24.791 --> 00:06:27.115
<v Keelan McClymont>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

36
00:06:27.661 --> 00:06:29.745
<v Keelan McClymont>The presiding officer preserves order.

37
00:06:29.985 --> 00:06:40.069
<v Keelan McClymont>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

38
00:06:40.918 --> 00:06:43.259
<v Keelan McClymont>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

39
00:06:43.851 --> 00:06:46.560
<v Keelan McClymont>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

40
00:06:47.153 --> 00:06:51.466
<v Keelan McClymont>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

41
00:06:51.882 --> 00:06:55.345
<v Keelan McClymont>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

42
00:06:55.971 --> 00:06:58.425
<v Keelan McClymont>Your testimony testimony should address the matter being considered.

43
00:06:58.843 --> 00:07:01.668
<v Keelan McClymont>When testifying, 1, state your name for the record.

44
00:07:01.750 --> 00:07:03.307
<v Keelan McClymont>Your address is not necessary.

45
00:07:03.980 --> 00:07:07.658
<v Keelan McClymont>2, If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

46
00:07:08.235 --> 00:07:12.843
<v Keelan McClymont>3, Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

47
00:07:12.987 --> 00:07:13.374
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

48
00:07:13.629 --> 00:07:14.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

49
00:07:15.557 --> 00:07:25.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>So for those paying attention at home, but mostly to my colleagues up here on the dais, we have some carryover from yesterday that has been placed as per usual at the end of our agenda.

50
00:07:28.105 --> 00:07:28.396
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

51
00:07:28.509 --> 00:07:33.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>We had anticipated that and actually had built time into this agenda for that carryover.

52
00:07:33.435 --> 00:07:41.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, there are more than 50 people signed up for item number 9, and there are more than 30 people signed up for item number 8.

53
00:07:41.470 --> 00:07:43.826
<v Jamie Dunphy>So it will be a very tight timeline.

54
00:07:45.814 --> 00:07:49.290
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is still likely more testimony than we can actually accommodate today.

55
00:07:49.387 --> 00:07:50.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will get to absolutely everybody.

56
00:07:51.093 --> 00:07:53.577
<v Jamie Dunphy>We just may not get to council deliberations and conversation.

57
00:07:54.221 --> 00:07:54.718
<v Jamie Dunphy>And votes.

58
00:07:55.728 --> 00:08:00.939
<v Jamie Dunphy>If items are not able to be completed today, they will start at the beginning of the agenda next week.

59
00:08:01.997 --> 00:08:05.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Additionally, yesterday went very, very, very long.

60
00:08:06.709 --> 00:08:13.987
<v Jamie Dunphy>As since the budget season ended, I had stopped tracking councilors' individual times on a time on my stopwatch.

61
00:08:14.500 --> 00:08:15.605
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm gonna be bringing that back today.

62
00:08:15.766 --> 00:08:20.944
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need to get through this agenda and councilors will be given 5 minutes per councilor per turn, including responses.

63
00:08:20.992 --> 00:08:22.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>But councilors are always welcome to get back in the queue.

64
00:08:23.637 --> 00:08:28.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>Before we turn it over to the City Administrator for an update on his, uh, monthly administration report.

65
00:08:29.076 --> 00:08:30.697
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to turn it over to Vice President Clark.

66
00:08:31.980 --> 00:08:33.200
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

67
00:08:33.408 --> 00:08:42.524
<v Olivia Clark>Um, thank you for giving me just a moment to recognize, uh, take a few minutes to recognize Gloria Steinem, who passed away I think yesterday.

68
00:08:43.279 --> 00:08:46.522
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, that's a very meaningful name for a lot of us in this room.

69
00:08:47.211 --> 00:08:53.260
<v Olivia Clark>She was a trailblazer for women's rights, having dedicated her life Uh, to women's freedom.

70
00:08:53.870 --> 00:09:01.644
<v Olivia Clark>She was an outspoken advocate for women's reproductive freedom, as someone who had actually sought out an illegal abortion in the 1950s.

71
00:09:02.783 --> 00:09:16.922
<v Olivia Clark>Earlier in her journalism career, she went undercover, if you recall, as a Playboy Bunny to expose the poor working conditions in the famous Playboy Clubs, and this began her trajectory as a feminist icon.

72
00:09:16.970 --> 00:09:17.211
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

73
00:09:18.476 --> 00:09:23.764
<v Olivia Clark>As a journalist, she co-founded Ms. Magazine, a platform where women's rights were front and center.

74
00:09:24.966 --> 00:09:34.244
<v Olivia Clark>Gloria Steinem was an inspiration to me personally and millions of women worldwide, empowering us to expect more and fight for what we deserve.

75
00:09:35.381 --> 00:09:41.215
<v Olivia Clark>She wore many hats— a journalist, a writer, an activist— and she was our symbol in the fight for equality.

76
00:09:42.351 --> 00:09:48.493
<v Olivia Clark>I hope we can all take a minute to reflect on her work towards women's rights and social justice.

77
00:09:49.139 --> 00:09:59.312
<v Olivia Clark>May she rest in power and know her fight was not in vain, and we will keep her legacy alive by continuing to fight for the change we need in this world.

78
00:10:00.119 --> 00:10:00.601
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

79
00:10:01.796 --> 00:10:02.618
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

80
00:10:07.740 --> 00:10:08.758
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we— I see a—.

81
00:10:08.758 --> 00:10:10.254
<v Sameer Kanal>There we go.

82
00:10:10.318 --> 00:10:10.631
<v Michelle DePass>Okay.

83
00:10:11.197 --> 00:10:15.057
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call, uh, our time-certain item number 7?

84
00:10:19.080 --> 00:10:26.744
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, um, sorry, item 7, document 2026-295, September 2026 City Administrator Update.

85
00:10:27.532 --> 00:10:29.782
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr. City Administrator, uh, turning it to you for an update.

86
00:10:29.846 --> 00:10:36.856
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, though this is not your fault, I will ask for this to be a brief, uh, presentation today because we are on a tight timeline.

87
00:10:36.970 --> 00:10:38.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>So take it away.

88
00:10:39.614 --> 00:10:41.826
<v Raymond C. Lee>You don't have to tell me twice on that.

89
00:10:43.320 --> 00:10:51.644
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'll just do this CA's report and just talk about a few key items, but really spending more time on kind of federal response update.

90
00:10:52.530 --> 00:10:54.792
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you, Council, for this opportunity.

91
00:10:57.039 --> 00:10:59.750
<v Raymond C. Lee>Before I begin with this, let me scroll.

92
00:11:00.701 --> 00:11:00.942
<v Raymond C. Lee>Here we go.

93
00:11:01.589 --> 00:11:07.139
<v Raymond C. Lee>First, as of this week, the Immigrant Affairs Lead position has moved officially into my office now.

94
00:11:08.363 --> 00:11:19.734
<v Raymond C. Lee>Her responsibilities and partnerships will remain the same, and we will expect this move to strengthen her ability to coordinate and implement the city's sanctuary initiatives across the bureaus.

95
00:11:20.489 --> 00:11:26.994
<v Raymond C. Lee>The city's land use enforcement process involving the Portland ICE facility is still moving through the courts.

96
00:11:27.556 --> 00:11:31.700
<v Raymond C. Lee>In July, the city's hearings officer appealed the violation finding.

97
00:11:32.679 --> 00:11:36.615
<v Raymond C. Lee>The county circuit court has set a hearing date of November the 20th.

98
00:11:36.663 --> 00:11:36.774
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

99
00:11:37.048 --> 00:11:40.620
<v Raymond C. Lee>To consider the appeals filed by the building owner.

100
00:11:41.182 --> 00:11:50.490
<v Raymond C. Lee>As a reminder, the hearing officer ruled against the building owner, and the owner appealed the matter to the circuit court by filing several writs of review.

101
00:11:51.756 --> 00:11:55.826
<v Raymond C. Lee>At the hearing on November 20th, the court will consider those appeals.

102
00:11:56.244 --> 00:12:00.874
<v Raymond C. Lee>Legal briefs will be filed by both parties in advance of that hearing.

103
00:12:01.530 --> 00:12:07.126
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are also seeing continued federal immigration enforcement activities across Oregon.

104
00:12:07.705 --> 00:12:29.517
<v Raymond C. Lee>Nearly, uh, newly released data from the Deportation Data Project obtained through federal records requests show that federal agents arrested more than 700 people in Oregon as of August 6th, compared to 462 during the first 8 months of 2025.

105
00:12:30.432 --> 00:12:41.817
<v Raymond C. Lee>PERC reported 85 detentions as of August 29th, putting August on track to have the highest number of reported detentions since 2026.

106
00:12:42.602 --> 00:12:49.129
<v Raymond C. Lee>One development we are watching closely is the use of what were called mega master hearings.

107
00:12:49.739 --> 00:12:54.774
<v Raymond C. Lee>These are immigration court hearings where a very large number of people are scheduled at the same time.

108
00:12:55.143 --> 00:12:58.625
<v Raymond C. Lee>Some hearings have also been rescheduled with little notice.

109
00:12:59.205 --> 00:13:08.265
<v Raymond C. Lee>When someone is missing a hearing, the court can issue a deportation order right away because the person was not present for their hearing.

110
00:13:09.004 --> 00:13:25.759
<v Raymond C. Lee>At these circumstances, as circumstances evolve, we want to make sure the city can respond quickly with clear information, meaningful language access, and strong partnerships with the community organizations and legal providers already doing this work.

111
00:13:26.273 --> 00:13:33.942
<v Raymond C. Lee>I will continue to provide updates as we monitor federal immigration activity and the impacts on our community as a whole.

112
00:13:34.712 --> 00:13:41.981
<v Raymond C. Lee>Now I will share just a few highlights from the CA report, and then the DCAs and myself are here to answer any questions you may have.

113
00:13:42.559 --> 00:13:46.506
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, want to focus on I-5 southbound closure.

114
00:13:47.133 --> 00:13:51.192
<v Raymond C. Lee>As you know, this large ODOT project is scheduled to begin next Friday.

115
00:13:51.866 --> 00:13:58.446
<v Raymond C. Lee>As we talked about in a recent work session, teams across the city have been working together to prepare for this closure.

116
00:13:58.527 --> 00:14:07.658
<v Raymond C. Lee>We want to continue to provide excellent services to our community from emergency management work and to support our employees through this closure period.

117
00:14:09.118 --> 00:14:12.793
<v Raymond C. Lee>Wanted to share some other updates on BES and water.

118
00:14:13.129 --> 00:14:27.090
<v Raymond C. Lee>Our supporting field staff and working on strategies such as staged generations and emergency vehicles alternative fuel locations and adjusting hauling and sampling new schedules to try to help with this event as well.

119
00:14:29.717 --> 00:14:42.993
<v Raymond C. Lee>Only other thing I would like to share with you too as well, and this is really a shout out to our CFO and the debt management team and our underwriting and legal partners in structuring and execution of this transaction.

120
00:14:43.250 --> 00:14:52.865
<v Raymond C. Lee>And just thank you to the investors who continue to place their confidence in the city and provide us with capital to build critical infrastructure for Portland.

121
00:14:52.976 --> 00:15:01.139
<v Raymond C. Lee>This is really surrounding our improvement credit rating that we saw came through last month.

122
00:15:01.349 --> 00:15:07.294
<v Raymond C. Lee>That was really kudos to our staff for really managing our resources in a responsible manner.

123
00:15:08.162 --> 00:15:15.778
<v Raymond C. Lee>And lastly, I wanted to take another moment to thank our former Portland Solutions Director, Sky, for her incredible service.

124
00:15:16.438 --> 00:15:21.953
<v Raymond C. Lee>To the city and welcome Hank Smith to the interim director role over Portland Solutions.

125
00:15:23.600 --> 00:15:25.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Mr. City Administrator.

126
00:15:25.166 --> 00:15:28.153
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have some councilors in the queue, starting with Vice President Clark.

127
00:15:28.475 --> 00:15:29.768
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor President.

128
00:15:30.171 --> 00:15:42.871
<v Olivia Clark>I just wanted to thank you, Administrator Lee, for including both a budget note update on utility rates, which is coming to Public Works in the next few weeks, and also thank you for highlighting partnerships.

129
00:15:43.883 --> 00:15:49.864
<v Olivia Clark>Next Tuesday, the Public Works Committee is going to be talking about something we call Partnership for Portland's Public Spaces.

130
00:15:50.682 --> 00:16:04.841
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm hoping that you will consider potentially a citywide partnership strategy that extends beyond parks to all the other bureaus and potentially even consider having that in your office.

131
00:16:04.970 --> 00:16:06.701
<v Olivia Clark>But that's for a future conversation.

132
00:16:06.750 --> 00:16:12.796
<v Olivia Clark>I just want to thank you because the world really goes around here with volunteers and public-private partnerships.

133
00:16:12.860 --> 00:16:14.254
<v Olivia Clark>So I appreciate your recognizing that.

134
00:16:14.335 --> 00:16:14.495
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

135
00:16:14.672 --> 00:16:19.379
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Council President.

136
00:16:19.491 --> 00:16:23.509
<v Sameer Kanal>Just before I get into the questions, I have a lot of questions on this month's report.

137
00:16:23.750 --> 00:16:32.220
<v Sameer Kanal>Would it be possible for me to invite you, because you're normally there anyway, to the Committee of the Whole next week to continue, and I'll just ask one today?

138
00:16:33.139 --> 00:16:34.500
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I appreciate that.

139
00:16:34.549 --> 00:16:35.943
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that all right with you, Council President?

140
00:16:37.131 --> 00:16:39.898
<v Sameer Kanal>And I assume the clerk's office will need to— okay, thank you.

141
00:16:40.307 --> 00:16:43.673
<v Sameer Kanal>The one question I wanted to ask, It's at the top of page 3.

142
00:16:44.683 --> 00:16:54.508
<v Sameer Kanal>It mentions a reduction in hours to 311 in spite of the fact that council voted to provide enough money to retain hours at 311.

143
00:16:55.519 --> 00:17:00.849
<v Sameer Kanal>And I had concern about this for the somewhat obvious reasons that we put money into it.

144
00:17:01.379 --> 00:17:07.654
<v Sameer Kanal>I understand that the fact that it was one time is a challenge.

145
00:17:07.719 --> 00:17:14.682
<v Sameer Kanal>I also understand that you might have to at least temporarily reduce it until a limited-term position could be created.

146
00:17:15.036 --> 00:17:21.099
<v Sameer Kanal>But I'm curious why it is framed as effectively this was meaningless and it's a permanent reduction in hours.

147
00:17:21.630 --> 00:17:30.469
<v Sameer Kanal>So could I get a— ideally there'd be a time at which you're posting it and then limited duration, I'll come back and get the hours back.

148
00:17:30.982 --> 00:17:32.137
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes, the hours will come back.

149
00:17:32.201 --> 00:17:38.375
<v Raymond C. Lee>This is a temporary situation where the hours will be reduced until we're able to get the position filled.

150
00:17:39.498 --> 00:17:43.377
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, and do you have a rough idea, I would, of when that would be?

151
00:17:43.891 --> 00:17:46.118
<v Raymond C. Lee>I can follow up with you with that scheduling.

152
00:17:46.776 --> 00:17:56.682
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I am aware that HR has processes that need to be followed, and I'm also aware that the city administrator's prioritization of it might be helpful for that.

153
00:17:57.387 --> 00:17:58.557
<v Sameer Kanal>So I appreciate it.

154
00:17:58.959 --> 00:18:09.337
<v Sameer Kanal>And while I have the floor, I'll just mention there, right below that is an item for those who may be interested in helping steward the future of our fire and police Disability and Retirement Program.

155
00:18:09.402 --> 00:18:19.854
<v Sameer Kanal>The Board of Trustees is recruiting through September 27th, and it's on page 3 of the report, as well as at government jobs has recruitment there as well.

156
00:18:20.015 --> 00:18:20.271
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

157
00:18:21.221 --> 00:18:22.042
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

158
00:18:22.203 --> 00:18:22.734
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

159
00:18:24.538 --> 00:18:26.067
<v Candace Avalos>Can you hear me now?

160
00:18:26.388 --> 00:18:27.355
<v Jamie Dunphy>We can hear you now, yes.

161
00:18:27.820 --> 00:18:30.105
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you.

162
00:18:30.315 --> 00:18:33.838
<v Candace Avalos>I had a question about the implementation of the Keep Portland Housed ordinance.

163
00:18:34.250 --> 00:18:45.962
<v Candace Avalos>So one, I have heard some concerns from community about getting access to the rental assistance dollars and wanted to know if you had an update on how that progress has gone.

164
00:18:46.556 --> 00:19:02.135
<v Candace Avalos>And then 2, it was my understanding that since we sent the rental assistance money over to the county because they were better suited to get those dollars out, that we were going to be receiving eviction prevention money to the city for similar reasons.

165
00:19:02.249 --> 00:19:02.345
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes.

166
00:19:02.698 --> 00:19:04.175
<v Candace Avalos>I'm curious where that stands.

167
00:19:05.478 --> 00:19:15.753
<v Raymond C. Lee>Councilor, let me follow up, uh, in a memorandum to you because we just did receive some information as it relates to the housing dollars itself, but I'll follow up with you with a full, uh, write-up on it.

168
00:19:19.634 --> 00:19:22.753
<v Candace Avalos>Um, is there anything you can tell me now about what, what does that mean?

169
00:19:22.851 --> 00:19:24.569
<v Candace Avalos>You, you said you've received some information.

170
00:19:24.634 --> 00:19:25.292
<v Candace Avalos>That sounds ominous.

171
00:19:25.421 --> 00:19:25.773
<v Candace Avalos>What do you mean?

172
00:19:26.803 --> 00:19:30.497
<v Raymond C. Lee>That means we received some, uh, updates on our—.

173
00:19:30.497 --> 00:19:33.877
<v Candace Avalos>Turn your mic on because Oh, sorry.

174
00:19:34.880 --> 00:19:38.644
<v Raymond C. Lee>Just an update on our resources that we already sent over to county.

175
00:19:38.758 --> 00:19:41.765
<v Raymond C. Lee>We've got an update of how those funds are being expensed.

176
00:19:42.234 --> 00:19:48.951
<v Raymond C. Lee>We will follow up in the full memorandum though to you on the other points though, just for the essence of time.

177
00:19:50.722 --> 00:19:50.884
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

178
00:19:52.913 --> 00:19:53.234
<v Michelle DePass>Okay.

179
00:19:53.766 --> 00:19:54.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

180
00:19:54.973 --> 00:19:56.406
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

181
00:19:57.002 --> 00:20:01.565
<v Keelan McClymont>Very, very quickly, I wanted to quickly second Vice President Clark's comments about the updates on utility rate setting.

182
00:20:03.747 --> 00:20:06.270
<v Keelan McClymont>Really looking forward to that presentation coming to Public Works.

183
00:20:06.674 --> 00:20:13.601
<v Keelan McClymont>I know that many of my colleagues are concerned about the rising costs of living and are looking for ways to decrease the impacts on Portlanders.

184
00:20:13.714 --> 00:20:18.618
<v Keelan McClymont>And I think this is an area where I believe all of the council members can work collaboratively together.

185
00:20:20.208 --> 00:20:21.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

186
00:20:21.340 --> 00:20:21.892
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

187
00:20:22.474 --> 00:20:24.191
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

188
00:20:24.240 --> 00:20:27.980
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll be really brief 'cause I know we have limited time today and lots of folks eager to testify.

189
00:20:28.665 --> 00:20:57.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I really appreciated the portion of the report that talked about the contracts and IGAs, and I just wanted to put a request that we add another appendix that lists the current open requests for proposals, RFPs, or the RFIs, or PHBs, notices of funding availability, because there's been, I think, some lack of information for the council about different RFPs and things that are coming up for us, and making sure that we can be included in that information sharing would be really helpful.

190
00:20:58.945 --> 00:20:59.846
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

191
00:21:00.471 --> 00:21:01.098
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

192
00:21:01.243 --> 00:21:06.686
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator, I would just ask that I'd be interested in the memo that you'd be sending to Councilor Avalos as well.

193
00:21:06.736 --> 00:21:13.544
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm sure the rest of the council would also be interested because we spent months talking about those dollars and are excited to see the good work that is being done.

194
00:21:13.721 --> 00:21:15.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you very much.

195
00:21:15.343 --> 00:21:17.125
<v Jamie Dunphy>I see no other councilors in the queue.

196
00:21:17.832 --> 00:21:18.249
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mr.

197
00:21:18.297 --> 00:21:18.778
<v Jamie Dunphy>Administrator.

198
00:21:19.518 --> 00:21:21.138
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please move to item number 8?

199
00:21:22.327 --> 00:21:31.656
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-285, direct the city administrator to advance a process to identify a development partner for city-owned properties adjacent to the Moda Center.

200
00:21:32.890 --> 00:21:36.509
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is a resolution that came out of the City Life Committee.

201
00:21:36.509 --> 00:21:40.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have Claire Adamsick, Council Operations, here for a committee staff summary report.

202
00:21:40.490 --> 00:21:41.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh no, it's not.

203
00:21:41.210 --> 00:21:42.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi, hi Kevin.

204
00:21:42.890 --> 00:21:44.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't remember your last name.

205
00:21:45.390 --> 00:21:49.609
<v Kevin Alvarez>Good afternoon, uh, Council President, councilors.

206
00:21:49.609 --> 00:21:56.450
<v Kevin Alvarez>For the record, my name is Kevin Alvarez, uh, and I serve as a council policy analyst for the City Life Committee.

207
00:21:57.170 --> 00:22:06.185
<v Kevin Alvarez>The resolution before you, document number 2026-285, heard in the City Life Committee on August 11th, 2026.

208
00:22:07.211 --> 00:22:13.896
<v Kevin Alvarez>The document advanced to full council on August 11th, 2026 with the recommendation it be adopted.

209
00:22:14.617 --> 00:22:40.734
<v Kevin Alvarez>So what this resolution does, it states that the city administrator anticipates selecting a new development partner to advance vertical development of the city-owned properties adjacent to the Moda Center and the Veterans Memorial Coliseum following execution of a new long-term lease for the Moda Center and directs the city administrator to to negotiate with Albina Vision Trust for the opportunity to serve as that partner.

210
00:22:42.001 --> 00:23:02.295
<v Kevin Alvarez>It establishes the qualifications expected of a development partner, including a community-oriented mission, demonstrated experience in real estate financing and development, the ability to bring significant philanthropic or private investment, and experience advancing the public interest of the city's adopted objectives for the area.

211
00:23:02.343 --> 00:23:02.454
<v Kevin Alvarez>Thank you.

212
00:23:03.497 --> 00:23:18.902
<v Kevin Alvarez>It further directs that the process consider the organization's development vision, the relationship to the broader Rose Quarter and Lower Albina area, compatibility with the event campus, the monetary value of development rights, and any anticipated public financial support.

213
00:23:19.624 --> 00:23:27.493
<v Kevin Alvarez>Additionally, the resolution addresses the partnership structure, disposition strategy, timeline, roles and responsibilities, and key milestones.

214
00:23:28.279 --> 00:23:39.750
<v Kevin Alvarez>Binding agreements return to the City Council for consideration on a timeline concurrent with the long-term lease for the Moda Center, and negotiations may not exceed 12 months from commencement.

215
00:23:40.311 --> 00:23:45.175
<v Kevin Alvarez>The resolution does not convey the property's transfer development rights or appropriate funds.

216
00:23:46.477 --> 00:23:56.029
<v Kevin Alvarez>On amendments, one amendment was approved by the City Life Committee on August 11th, 2026, the effects of which can be read in detail in the committee staff summary posted online.

217
00:23:57.250 --> 00:24:12.587
<v Kevin Alvarez>On impact statements, the full impact statement on this item includes Financial and budgetary impacts, economic and real estate development impacts, community impacts and community involvement, 100% renewable goal, and economic and real estate development analysis.

218
00:24:13.632 --> 00:24:17.454
<v Kevin Alvarez>No verbal or written testimony was provided prior to committee action.

219
00:24:18.049 --> 00:24:20.442
<v Kevin Alvarez>And that concludes the committee staff summary for this item.

220
00:24:21.005 --> 00:24:21.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

221
00:24:21.824 --> 00:24:25.728
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, this— you are both a co-sponsor and this came outta your committee.

222
00:24:25.920 --> 00:24:28.555
<v Jamie Dunphy>Before I turn it to your other co-sponsors with some committee chair remarks.

223
00:24:29.905 --> 00:24:33.978
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you want me to do these separately or just lead right into my co-sponsor remarks also?

224
00:24:34.141 --> 00:24:34.678
<v Jamie Dunphy>You go nuts.

225
00:24:35.500 --> 00:24:36.326
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

226
00:24:36.730 --> 00:24:38.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That was a fantastic overview.

227
00:24:38.737 --> 00:24:39.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

228
00:24:39.318 --> 00:24:49.211
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is something that we took up in committee and incorporated some amendments to ensure that there was a bit of time certainty.

229
00:24:49.888 --> 00:24:54.410
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There were some questions about how long negotiations could last, and we shored that up.

230
00:24:56.390 --> 00:24:57.880
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So thank you for the overview.

231
00:24:57.961 --> 00:25:03.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Kevin, I think this might be your first time presenting something here, and you actually weren't even with our committee at that point.

232
00:25:03.760 --> 00:25:07.205
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we appreciate you jumping in and are looking forward to working with you.

233
00:25:07.654 --> 00:25:07.911
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

234
00:25:08.615 --> 00:25:11.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, if I may, I'll launch into some co-sponsor remarks and then—.

235
00:25:12.782 --> 00:25:15.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll even let you turn it over to your colleagues.

236
00:25:15.634 --> 00:25:17.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does that work?

237
00:25:17.766 --> 00:25:18.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

238
00:25:19.048 --> 00:25:24.626
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, today we are at the threshold of a truly momentous opportunity.

239
00:25:25.443 --> 00:25:33.701
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As the city embarks on our negotiations for a long-term lease for the Moda Center, we are also invited to envision what happens to the land around the Moda Center.

240
00:25:34.680 --> 00:25:39.651
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In this space, a transformational community-led restoration is already underway.

241
00:25:40.613 --> 00:25:48.934
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a chance to help shape the future where the Rose Quarter and Lower Albina are not only individually revitalized, thank you.

242
00:25:49.673 --> 00:26:02.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But where they meet in a place where— in a place which can be a beacon of what our city can accomplish when we act boldly and strategically together and with community.

243
00:26:03.624 --> 00:26:13.192
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The construction of I-5 and decades of urban renewal displacement removed thousands of Black Portlanders, Black homeowners, Black-owned businesses from Lower Albina.

244
00:26:13.897 --> 00:26:16.549
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The consequences of those decisions Councilmember Herbold.

245
00:26:16.549 --> 00:26:16.549
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

246
00:26:16.549 --> 00:26:18.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The impacts of the sale of Moda Center and Veterans Memorial Coliseum are still clear today.

247
00:26:18.710 --> 00:26:23.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While we can't undo this history, we can make different choices about what comes next.

248
00:26:23.490 --> 00:26:42.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the resolution before us asks the city to begin a process of intentionally identifying and negotiating with a development partner for city-owned parcels surrounding Moda Center and Veterans Memorial Coliseum by establishing a clear set of expectations for what we want in a potential development partner.

249
00:26:43.307 --> 00:26:55.846
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're asking for a partner with a community-oriented mission, demonstrated development and financial experience, the ability to bring significant outside investment to the table, and a track record of advancing the public interest.

250
00:26:56.536 --> 00:26:58.924
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because these are right now public properties.

251
00:27:00.160 --> 00:27:10.085
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Importantly, the resolution acknowledges that there is an organization which fits these criteria, which has already come to the city and expressed an interest in these parcels.

252
00:27:11.048 --> 00:27:20.192
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Albina Vision Trust is interested in doing this work with us and has a vision for what the future of these parcels could be.

253
00:27:20.529 --> 00:27:35.674
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Albina Vision Trust has spent years not only developing a comprehensive vision for the restoration of Lower Albina, building relationships, partnerships, and an investment strategy necessary to turn that vision into a reality, but that reality, that project, is already underway.

254
00:27:37.038 --> 00:27:43.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Fair restorative redevelopment of Lower Albina is one of the most transformative projects happening in our city today.

255
00:27:44.258 --> 00:28:01.904
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With the resolution before us, we can take a step toward ensuring that alongside the important decisions we have been debating about the Moda Center itself, the city is advancing restorative development, creating opportunities for community wealth building, and supporting a more vibrant, connected Lower Albina.

256
00:28:02.803 --> 00:28:04.021
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right alongside that work.

257
00:28:05.031 --> 00:28:15.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am immensely proud to support and co-sponsor this resolution honoring the history of the neighborhood while creating the conditions for people who live here to benefit from its future.

258
00:28:16.258 --> 00:28:32.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to thank my fellow D2 councilors for co-championing this work with me and thank the many incredible individuals and organizations who are here today who have been a part of this work and are stepping up to be a part of the next chapter of it.

259
00:28:32.247 --> 00:28:32.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

260
00:28:33.499 --> 00:28:40.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's a lot of work to do, but I hope that as we hear from these organizations, we can gain the rest of your support.

261
00:28:41.377 --> 00:28:55.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do want to note in closing that I am going to have to go remote for part of our meeting today, and I apologize that I won't be in person to hear all of the testimony, but I will be online listening and appreciate everybody who is here to talk about this important decision before us.

262
00:28:56.542 --> 00:29:05.463
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, I would like to turn it over to my co-sponsors, Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

263
00:29:05.560 --> 00:29:06.756
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President, colleagues.

264
00:29:06.836 --> 00:29:07.935
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks everybody for being here.

265
00:29:08.848 --> 00:29:19.519
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, before— since you mentioned testimony, I did also want to ask the Council President if we can be deferential to— we have an elected official who'd like to give testimony, Commissioner Singleton, just her schedule when we get to that.

266
00:29:19.632 --> 00:29:20.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely, yes.

267
00:29:20.632 --> 00:29:23.275
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the ordering within the, the normal testimony frame.

268
00:29:23.435 --> 00:29:23.693
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

269
00:29:25.867 --> 00:29:45.294
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I'm very excited to be a part of this conversation with everyone here and to have worked with both Councilors Ryan and Pirtle-Guiney in championing this together, and grateful to the City Life Committee just before the recess for discussing this and forwarding it on to the full council with a 5-0 vote.

270
00:29:45.759 --> 00:30:07.720
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate the conversation because it is important for us to constantly remember as we talk about something development in the area from an economic lens and from a civic pride lens, to keep it focused on the specific region that we're talking about, to keep it focused on Albina, it is impossible to separate the conversation there from a history of displacement.

271
00:30:08.297 --> 00:30:18.932
<v Sameer Kanal>And this provides an opportunity for us as a city, and I don't just mean a city government, a capital C city or a council, I mean the entire city, to create a new story.

272
00:30:19.461 --> 00:30:29.237
<v Sameer Kanal>Written collaboratively by the people of Albina and of the city at large, a future in which the surrounding neighborhood shares in the future prosperity we see in the Rose Quarter.

273
00:30:30.598 --> 00:30:38.211
<v Sameer Kanal>Today will be an opportunity to continue centering equity and community and to lay out a direction framework for how we move forward with restorative development.

274
00:30:38.836 --> 00:31:06.323
<v Sameer Kanal>And as my colleague mentioned, when you look at the requirements in our existing rules as well as in the Resolution itself, community-oriented mission, leadership with demonstrated experience in real estate financing, development, and securing partnerships and bringing significant philanthropic and private investment to the table, as well as advancing our adopted objectives for the region specifically, that conversation cannot possibly exclude Albina Vision Trust.

275
00:31:06.772 --> 00:31:19.557
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I'm very grateful for the opportunity to, to talk about this with you and for us to take a vote that Eventually, which will show that we're living our values through a good faith commitment to pursue partnership with the Albina Vision Trust.

276
00:31:20.021 --> 00:31:25.738
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm looking forward to seeing what I'm sure we're gonna hear from them with more information as well on redeveloping these parcels in the future.

277
00:31:26.540 --> 00:31:27.392
<v Sameer Kanal>Take it away, Councilor Ryan.

278
00:31:27.826 --> 00:31:28.242
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

279
00:31:28.612 --> 00:31:30.378
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Kevin, first of all, for the overview.

280
00:31:30.635 --> 00:31:37.924
<v Dan Ryan>And thank you, Chair Pirtle-Guiney, for the further framing of this important step to move this restorative economic development work forward.

281
00:31:38.423 --> 00:31:45.019
<v Dan Ryan>And it's always wonderful when the 3 of us can come together in lockstep to move something that's really a big deal forward.

282
00:31:45.484 --> 00:31:56.462
<v Dan Ryan>You know, Albina Vision Trust has been at the helm reimagining the revitalization of Lower Albina for about a decade, and I was able to hear about that before I was on council with much excitement.

283
00:31:56.784 --> 00:32:01.244
<v Dan Ryan>And then since I've been on now almost 6 years, it's been a really methodical process.

284
00:32:01.390 --> 00:32:05.048
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, I remember the meetings where I said, you and the Blazers need to be at the same table together.

285
00:32:05.561 --> 00:32:10.423
<v Dan Ryan>So if you just travel north of the Moda Center, you can see the hard work that's taking shape.

286
00:32:10.615 --> 00:32:14.980
<v Dan Ryan>So congratulations, Albina Vision Trust, and all 3 D2 councilors.

287
00:32:15.251 --> 00:32:20.145
<v Dan Ryan>We've been proud to figure out how to integrate this as we move forward with the Moda Center work.

288
00:32:20.321 --> 00:32:21.236
<v Dan Ryan>Timing is everything.

289
00:32:22.632 --> 00:32:29.659
<v Dan Ryan>We can add up to 10 parcels, again, in a welcome part of the AVT's larger neighborhood plan to restore the area.

290
00:32:30.076 --> 00:32:33.186
<v Dan Ryan>And bring economic opportunity into Portland.

291
00:32:33.780 --> 00:32:39.569
<v Dan Ryan>AVT's objectives are intertwined with the city's, as the council has previously affirmed.

292
00:32:40.019 --> 00:32:45.182
<v Dan Ryan>They also emphasize supporting youth and children, which is so very important, of course, to our city's future.

293
00:32:45.663 --> 00:32:52.431
<v Dan Ryan>I'm just really proud to be a co-sponsor of this and support this resolution so we can keep the momentum going and not lose a step at this important time.

294
00:32:52.784 --> 00:33:04.335
<v Dan Ryan>And again, this is not just for North Portland, for District 2, Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

295
00:33:05.355 --> 00:33:14.806
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, I'm going to hold on technical or clarifying questions to the part with council discussion, and I'm going to turn it over to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney to call up some invited testimony to get us started.

296
00:33:16.000 --> 00:33:16.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

297
00:33:16.923 --> 00:33:19.650
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And with your permission, we have 2 panels of invited testimony.

298
00:33:19.925 --> 00:33:20.153
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

299
00:33:20.330 --> 00:33:23.154
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For the first panel, we will hear from some of the community partners.

300
00:33:23.342 --> 00:33:25.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That are leading on the work in this region.

301
00:33:26.135 --> 00:33:32.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And for the second panel, we will hear from some of our fellow elected leaders who also represent this area.

302
00:33:32.654 --> 00:33:42.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So first, I'd like to call up Wynta Johannes, Trent Aldridge, D'Artagnan Calliman, Andrew Kollas, and Azalea Renfield.

303
00:33:43.236 --> 00:33:45.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize, Azalea, when I'm reading it, it's different.

304
00:33:45.998 --> 00:33:46.351
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry.

305
00:33:52.653 --> 00:33:55.442
<v Jamie Dunphy>We know we've got some folks in maybe some of the overflow rooms as well, so—.

306
00:33:55.442 --> 00:33:57.381
<v Wynta Johannes>Yes, we'll go ahead and get started.

307
00:33:57.509 --> 00:33:58.967
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would defer to you on the order.

308
00:33:59.511 --> 00:34:00.121
<v Wynta Johannes>Okay, okay.

309
00:34:00.489 --> 00:34:05.345
<v Wynta Johannes>Yeah, I know that, um, the other folks are making their way, so we'll go ahead and get started.

310
00:34:05.857 --> 00:34:07.106
<v Wynta Johannes>Good afternoon, councilors.

311
00:34:07.203 --> 00:34:08.630
<v Wynta Johannes>My name is Wente Johannes.

312
00:34:08.838 --> 00:34:12.603
<v Wynta Johannes>I have the privilege of serving as the executive director of the Albina Vision Trust.

313
00:34:13.148 --> 00:34:19.070
<v Wynta Johannes>Before I begin, I'd like to acknowledge and appreciate the leadership of our D2 councilors.

314
00:34:19.590 --> 00:34:23.510
<v Wynta Johannes>Thank you for helping us move forward from rhetoric to action.

315
00:34:23.625 --> 00:34:24.773
<v Wynta Johannes>We would not be here without you.

316
00:34:25.239 --> 00:34:35.432
<v Wynta Johannes>I'd also be remiss to not share my appreciation for Councilor Smith's steadfast commitment to Albina and Councilor Avalos for strengthening today's resolution.

317
00:34:36.981 --> 00:34:48.864
<v Wynta Johannes>All of you have heard me talk about the tactile and spiritual legacy of Albina, and I know a lot of folks will talk about the history and future, so I'd like to focus remarks on just a few key points.

318
00:34:49.922 --> 00:34:55.264
<v Wynta Johannes>Our work fundamentally started with a commitment to not start the story in the middle.

319
00:34:55.858 --> 00:35:02.804
<v Wynta Johannes>And in that spirit, I think it's important that we acknowledge that the resolution before you today is nearly a decade in the making.

320
00:35:03.494 --> 00:35:23.427
<v Wynta Johannes>It was nearly 15 years ago that Portland was fortunate enough to benefit from the visionary leadership of Rekia Adams, who catalyzed the spirit and imagination of the entire city by helping us to reclaim the identity of Albina and ensuring that its future would be built around the safety and prosperity of Black and brown children.

321
00:35:24.181 --> 00:35:35.204
<v Wynta Johannes>Early on, the Albina Vision recognized that the business models of nearly everyone in the district would be changing, and we had the opportunity to either witness the change or lead the transformation.

322
00:35:35.860 --> 00:35:36.822
<v Wynta Johannes>We chose the latter.

323
00:35:37.784 --> 00:35:45.539
<v Wynta Johannes>And in the years since, we have worked methodically to bring both private and publicly owned land under community control.

324
00:35:46.293 --> 00:35:55.755
<v Wynta Johannes>Our boundaries are constrained and focused, which is why we are the obvious partner for the city for the redevelopment of the city-owned sites.

325
00:35:56.235 --> 00:36:11.599
<v Wynta Johannes>We have had intentional partnerships and investments in this area and have been willing to do the arduous work, including fundraising for the planning studies, providing the local match so that the city of Portland could take advantage of federal funding.

326
00:36:12.047 --> 00:36:14.646
<v Wynta Johannes>Doing parking studies with the Blazers.

327
00:36:14.902 --> 00:36:17.612
<v Wynta Johannes>This is the obvious and next step with the city.

328
00:36:18.045 --> 00:36:20.755
<v Wynta Johannes>Council President, is it okay if I take 30 seconds to wrap up?

329
00:36:20.835 --> 00:36:21.108
<v Wynta Johannes>Thank you.

330
00:36:21.157 --> 00:36:26.416
<v Wynta Johannes>Um, I'll, I'll just get, uh, to the closing here.

331
00:36:26.769 --> 00:36:30.731
<v Wynta Johannes>You know, in Portland, we're often forced between a false choice.

332
00:36:30.795 --> 00:36:38.460
<v Wynta Johannes>We either talk about equity endlessly with no action, or we are asked to rebrand crumbs fortunes.

333
00:36:38.974 --> 00:36:40.465
<v Wynta Johannes>We can reject both.

334
00:36:41.041 --> 00:36:54.608
<v Wynta Johannes>And the partners in the room today are here to affirm that all of us are deeply invested in this collective effort to rebuild Albina, and the Albina Vision Trust is one part of this bigger effort to do that.

335
00:36:54.768 --> 00:37:05.398
<v Wynta Johannes>We know that our greatest currency is trust, and the breadth of the organizations here today reflect that the grandness of our vision has never been about the fancy architectural renderings.

336
00:37:05.978 --> 00:37:14.476
<v Wynta Johannes>We know that the people of Portland are grand and that it is time to build a central city neighborhood that reflects that the people are beautiful already.

337
00:37:14.605 --> 00:37:16.949
<v Wynta Johannes>So thank you for your consideration and support.

338
00:37:20.300 --> 00:37:21.056
<v Azalea Renfield>Cool, thank you.

339
00:37:21.427 --> 00:37:27.643
<v Azalea Renfield>Um, good afternoon, Councilor President, um, Councilor Vice President, and all councilors at the dais.

340
00:37:27.869 --> 00:37:29.737
<v Azalea Renfield>Um, my name is Azalea Renfield.

341
00:37:29.820 --> 00:37:31.373
<v Azalea Renfield>I'm the CEO of Womans and Russell.

342
00:37:33.076 --> 00:37:35.597
<v Azalea Renfield>You know, when I came here, I had a whole script, but I want to throw it out.

343
00:37:36.293 --> 00:37:38.248
<v Azalea Renfield>I want to speak honestly and truthfully from the heart.

344
00:37:39.030 --> 00:37:42.782
<v Azalea Renfield>This is truly nothing more than opportunity meets preparation.

345
00:37:44.710 --> 00:37:49.956
<v Azalea Renfield>As Wynta said before, this work has been already happening before we even had this opportunity zone.

346
00:37:51.610 --> 00:37:53.498
<v Azalea Renfield>This is such a beautiful moment right now.

347
00:37:54.210 --> 00:38:02.152
<v Azalea Renfield>I want to make sure I come down personally to be here in the Council Chambers with you all to share this moment of something that's going to be transformative.

348
00:38:02.217 --> 00:38:02.347
<v Azalea Renfield>Thank you.

349
00:38:03.715 --> 00:38:08.547
<v Azalea Renfield>When we think about community benefit, what's so beautiful about our city is that people are watching.

350
00:38:09.826 --> 00:38:16.715
<v Azalea Renfield>Albina Vision Trust is a nationally recognized organization that happens to be in our city limit.

351
00:38:18.329 --> 00:38:27.518
<v Azalea Renfield>Their ability to raise funding, to work in community, to gain notoriety and respect is unprecedented.

352
00:38:27.565 --> 00:38:27.793
<v Azalea Renfield>Thank you.

353
00:38:29.172 --> 00:38:38.916
<v Azalea Renfield>When you think about the dedication and the folk that sits here on my right and left, that we all come here as a united force to say this is the opportunity.

354
00:38:40.389 --> 00:38:42.201
<v Azalea Renfield>But be, but be not dismayed.

355
00:38:42.617 --> 00:38:43.963
<v Azalea Renfield>This is about all of Portland.

356
00:38:44.940 --> 00:38:49.251
<v Azalea Renfield>When we revitalize one part of the area, it really impacts the whole city.

357
00:38:50.228 --> 00:38:51.559
<v Azalea Renfield>It's right next to the Moda Center.

358
00:38:52.313 --> 00:38:53.675
<v Azalea Renfield>And think about those plans being uncovered.

359
00:38:53.755 --> 00:38:54.059
<v Azalea Renfield>Thank you.

360
00:38:55.054 --> 00:38:55.760
<v Azalea Renfield>And what's to come.

361
00:38:57.125 --> 00:38:58.023
<v Azalea Renfield>That time is now.

362
00:38:59.452 --> 00:39:06.079
<v Azalea Renfield>I couldn't be more proud to be part of this delegation here and to sit before you all to do some wonderful work.

363
00:39:06.512 --> 00:39:12.692
<v Azalea Renfield>Thank you for trusting us, and thank you for getting on a resolution and making it right to actually spell out Albina Vision Trust.

364
00:39:13.510 --> 00:39:18.871
<v Azalea Renfield>Avalos, thank you so much for the amendment and for you all accepting that amendment.

365
00:39:19.367 --> 00:39:21.230
<v Azalea Renfield>This is prime opportunity for all of us.

366
00:39:21.277 --> 00:39:23.588
<v Azalea Renfield>I'm so proud of this city and what we're doing.

367
00:39:24.702 --> 00:39:28.961
<v Azalea Renfield>May God be with us and may we continue to serve our city, the great city of Portland.

368
00:39:29.253 --> 00:39:29.594
<v Azalea Renfield>Thank you.

369
00:39:33.871 --> 00:39:37.405
<v Andrew Colas>Thank you very much, uh, Council President, Vice President, all the councilors.

370
00:39:37.777 --> 00:39:38.621
<v Andrew Colas>I'm Andrew Kolis.

371
00:39:38.831 --> 00:39:45.434
<v Andrew Colas>I'm the president and CEO of Kolis Construction, a second-generation family-owned business started by my father, Armand Kolis.

372
00:39:46.356 --> 00:39:49.057
<v Andrew Colas>Most importantly, I'm a Portlander, born and raised here.

373
00:39:49.413 --> 00:39:50.125
<v Andrew Colas>I love this city.

374
00:39:50.318 --> 00:39:50.972
<v Andrew Colas>I love this state.

375
00:39:51.679 --> 00:39:56.173
<v Andrew Colas>And, um, I really want to talk about the industry that I've been in all my life.

376
00:39:56.414 --> 00:40:00.989
<v Andrew Colas>I've had the privilege of being in the construction and development industry all my life.

377
00:40:01.791 --> 00:40:07.458
<v Andrew Colas>And when I think about what that means, developers, they have vision.

378
00:40:08.695 --> 00:40:19.764
<v Andrew Colas>Albina Vision Trust, their vision is so broad and so great that it's something that a lot of us can't even see.

379
00:40:21.219 --> 00:40:30.692
<v Andrew Colas>But it's taken leadership of people like Wynta and all of her team to be able to see what our city actually can and will become.

380
00:40:31.483 --> 00:40:37.465
<v Andrew Colas>It also takes leadership, takes leaders like all of you to understand that this isn't a handout.

381
00:40:38.257 --> 00:40:43.775
<v Andrew Colas>This is a negotiation with a viable development organization that has put in the time.

382
00:40:43.840 --> 00:40:43.936
<v Andrew Colas>Thank you.

383
00:40:44.492 --> 00:40:52.452
<v Andrew Colas>Put in the work, put in the dedication, and put in the effort to have a broad range of our entire community.

384
00:40:52.516 --> 00:40:55.340
<v Andrew Colas>It's not one person, it's all people.

385
00:40:56.030 --> 00:40:59.048
<v Andrew Colas>They see that our community represents more.

386
00:41:00.059 --> 00:41:09.030
<v Andrew Colas>And the most important part that excites me about this vision is that when I talk to little kids, they see themselves in Winter.

387
00:41:09.447 --> 00:41:10.635
<v Andrew Colas>They see themselves in Trent.

388
00:41:11.132 --> 00:41:15.541
<v Andrew Colas>They see themselves in this incredible team that's standing before you.

389
00:41:16.407 --> 00:41:18.635
<v Andrew Colas>And what that does, it changes.

390
00:41:19.132 --> 00:41:20.237
<v Andrew Colas>It changes society.

391
00:41:20.751 --> 00:41:23.603
<v Andrew Colas>It changes what we believe we can and should become.

392
00:41:24.358 --> 00:41:26.521
<v Andrew Colas>Because if you can't see it, you can't be it.

393
00:41:26.827 --> 00:41:46.523
<v Andrew Colas>I've had the fortune of having a father that told me from the time I was a little kid we were going to create a construction company in this town of Portland, in one of the most non-easy industries to get into, and we were going to employ people, and we were going to change the way people thought about this industry.

394
00:41:47.039 --> 00:41:52.838
<v Andrew Colas>What Alvin A Vision Trust is doing is going to change this entire society.

395
00:41:53.193 --> 00:41:56.012
<v Andrew Colas>So thank you for your time and your commitment to this incredible work.

396
00:41:59.510 --> 00:42:02.568
<v Trent Aldridge>Uh, good morning, President Dunphy and members of the council.

397
00:42:03.355 --> 00:42:08.347
<v Trent Aldridge>My name is Trent Aldridge, and I have the privilege of being the CEO at SEI.

398
00:42:09.878 --> 00:42:15.456
<v Trent Aldridge>For 45 years, SEI has worked alongside young people, families, and communities across Portland.

399
00:42:16.327 --> 00:42:23.320
<v Trent Aldridge>During that time, we've seen buildings rise, businesses open, and districts transform.

400
00:42:23.920 --> 00:42:34.869
<v Trent Aldridge>But too often, the people who carried the history, culture, and character of those neighborhoods were left out of the decisions that shaped them and the benefits that followed.

401
00:42:35.865 --> 00:42:41.713
<v Trent Aldridge>That is why I am here in strong support of AVT and this resolution.

402
00:42:42.853 --> 00:42:48.202
<v Trent Aldridge>What excites me most is not simply what we may build, but who is there to shape it.

403
00:42:49.599 --> 00:42:55.429
<v Trent Aldridge>The effort represents a different model, an approach that recognizes that thriving communities thank you.

404
00:42:55.478 --> 00:43:01.331
<v Trent Aldridge>Our vision is that thriving communities are built through connected investments in people, place, opportunity, and culture.

405
00:43:02.021 --> 00:43:08.661
<v Trent Aldridge>A model that recognizes that economic vitality and community well-being are not competing goals.

406
00:43:09.817 --> 00:43:11.628
<v Trent Aldridge>In fact, they are deeply connected.

407
00:43:12.880 --> 00:43:21.123
<v Trent Aldridge>SEI has long believed that no single strategy creates economic mobility, but many strategies working together.

408
00:43:24.411 --> 00:43:27.503
<v Trent Aldridge>Can solve the complex challenges we face.

409
00:43:28.882 --> 00:43:36.717
<v Trent Aldridge>Real progress happens when organizations, institutions, bureaucracies, and communities align around a commitment to community.

410
00:43:37.853 --> 00:43:40.128
<v Trent Aldridge>That is what I see in this collective action.

411
00:43:40.434 --> 00:43:47.931
<v Trent Aldridge>Albina Vision Trust, City of Portland, 1803, Williams and Russell, Colas Construction.

412
00:43:48.909 --> 00:43:53.219
<v Trent Aldridge>All of us together bring an expertise that can move something profound forward.

413
00:43:54.632 --> 00:44:09.304
<v Trent Aldridge>This is an opportunity for Portland to create economic growth while honoring history, expanding opportunity, and building wealth where communities see themselves reflected in what's being built around them.

414
00:44:10.349 --> 00:44:14.121
<v Trent Aldridge>We have heard many ideas about how to revitalize Portland.

415
00:44:15.085 --> 00:44:19.949
<v Trent Aldridge>Today we have an opportunity to demonstrate what people-centered development looks like.

416
00:44:21.811 --> 00:44:32.875
<v Trent Aldridge>And an opportunity to show that when community is centered, when we create lasting prosperity, we honor history, and we build stronger future for generations to come.

417
00:44:33.951 --> 00:44:35.813
<v Trent Aldridge>I am proud to stand with this group.

418
00:44:36.134 --> 00:44:42.525
<v Trent Aldridge>I'm proud to stand with AVT, and I would highly encourage a vote yes.

419
00:44:43.809 --> 00:44:45.157
<v Trent Aldridge>Thank you for your time and your leadership.

420
00:44:45.206 --> 00:44:45.367
<v Tanisha Renee>Thank you.

421
00:44:48.561 --> 00:44:49.380
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>Good afternoon.

422
00:44:49.846 --> 00:44:56.186
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>For the record, I am D'Artagnan Calliman, Vice President of Philanthropy and Partnership for 1803 Fund.

423
00:44:57.166 --> 00:44:59.702
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>I'm also a resident of North Portland District 2.

424
00:45:01.146 --> 00:45:08.835
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>I express my gratitude to Council President Dunphy, the councilors of District 2, to all councilors.

425
00:45:09.108 --> 00:45:16.523
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>1803 is a capital investor together, we envision a rooted and prosperous Black Portland.

426
00:45:18.061 --> 00:45:22.833
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>Today, my brief testimony is an important endorsement.

427
00:45:24.349 --> 00:45:30.414
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>On the record, I state that the 1803 Fund is in partnership with Albina Vision Trust.

428
00:45:32.646 --> 00:45:45.771
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>The work that Albina Vision Trust leads in Lower Albina is integral to 1803's vision and mission, and we are in consistent communication collaboration and partnership with Albina Vision Trust.

429
00:45:46.829 --> 00:46:05.190
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>I'm here to state that 1803 is in full agreement and supports that Albina Vision Trust be granted the development rights as written in the community benefit agreement and per what is outlined in the resolution on record, including the Albina Vision Trust community investment plan.

430
00:46:06.009 --> 00:46:07.757
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>I also want to thank all of our—.

431
00:46:07.757 --> 00:46:07.998
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>Council members.

432
00:46:08.432 --> 00:46:16.967
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>Partners here at the table, and I am— and 1803 Fund are in full support of Wynta, her team, and Albina Vision Trust.

433
00:46:17.500 --> 00:46:17.757
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>Thank you.

434
00:46:17.836 --> 00:46:20.150
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

435
00:46:20.648 --> 00:46:21.436
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, all 5 of you.

436
00:46:21.855 --> 00:46:22.224
<v Michelle DePass>Thank you.

437
00:46:22.271 --> 00:46:22.737
<v Wynta Johannes>Thank you.

438
00:46:25.405 --> 00:46:28.731
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, may we call up one more panel of invited testimony?

439
00:46:28.795 --> 00:46:29.411
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please, please.

440
00:46:29.766 --> 00:46:30.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

441
00:46:30.398 --> 00:46:35.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would like to invite District 6 Metro Councilor Duncan Wong.

442
00:46:36.003 --> 00:46:41.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And District 2 County Commissioner Shannon Singleton to share their thoughts with us.

443
00:46:47.701 --> 00:46:49.797
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Commissioner Singleton at least is online.

444
00:46:55.429 --> 00:46:56.344
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Commissioner, go right ahead.

445
00:46:57.342 --> 00:46:57.840
<v Shannon Singleton>Wonderful.

446
00:46:58.144 --> 00:46:59.157
<v Shannon Singleton>Thank you so much.

447
00:47:00.217 --> 00:47:00.668
<v Shannon Singleton>Hello, all.

448
00:47:01.519 --> 00:47:02.693
<v Shannon Singleton>My name is Shannon Singleton.

449
00:47:02.951 --> 00:47:05.333
<v Shannon Singleton>I am the commissioner for District 2 in Multnomah County.

450
00:47:06.807 --> 00:47:20.199
<v Shannon Singleton>I wanted to start with just appreciating and thanking my council— City Council colleagues, Councilors Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, and Ryan, for moving this forward and ensuring that we have the opportunity to actualize restorative development.

451
00:47:20.954 --> 00:47:28.998
<v Shannon Singleton>And thank you, Councilor Smith, for always uplifting the needs and voices of Black Portlanders, and Councilor Avalos, for your work to make this a stronger resolution.

452
00:47:29.864 --> 00:47:38.260
<v Shannon Singleton>As you all mentioned, the Black community was displaced by the development of the Rose Quarter, I-5, and Legacy Health expansion, and robbed of the wealth that had been created.

453
00:47:39.481 --> 00:47:44.201
<v Shannon Singleton>Albina Vision Trust has the experience and trust to actualize changes for our community.

454
00:47:45.019 --> 00:48:13.744
<v Shannon Singleton>I have been working in lockstep with Albina Vision Trust on this issue since the Motor Center renovation discussions were brought to my attention, and I was ecstatic to unanimously pass my amendment stating that county funds are contingent on an agreement that that, quote, includes a commitment to concurrently and successfully negotiate a binding agreement between the City of Portland and Albina Vision Trust that establishes Albina Vision Trust development rights for city-owned parcels adjacent to the Moda Center.

455
00:48:14.643 --> 00:48:20.643
<v Shannon Singleton>I wanted to come today to say that I stand here ready to continue to partner with you all and make sure that we can actualize this.

456
00:48:21.141 --> 00:48:23.563
<v Shannon Singleton>And I want to appreciate all the speakers that came before me.

457
00:48:23.692 --> 00:48:34.434
<v Shannon Singleton>I think you have seen today that the whole community is behind this and that everybody is going to do the work to make sure that this can happen and we can actually have restorative development for our community.

458
00:48:34.547 --> 00:48:38.070
<v Shannon Singleton>So thank you so much for giving me some time today, and I will end there.

459
00:48:40.760 --> 00:48:41.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Commissioner.

460
00:48:42.240 --> 00:48:43.255
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, go right ahead.

461
00:48:43.592 --> 00:48:43.914
<v Duncan Hwang>Thank you.

462
00:48:44.478 --> 00:48:47.440
<v Duncan Hwang>Uh, good afternoon, uh, Council President Dunphy and councilors.

463
00:48:47.617 --> 00:49:01.326
<v Duncan Hwang>My name is Duncan Huang, and I'm the Metro Councilor rep for District I'm here to share encouragement and enthusiasm from our council and Council President Gonzalez, who is very disappointed he couldn't make it here himself today.

464
00:49:02.610 --> 00:49:24.822
<v Duncan Hwang>In Metro's 2019 voter-approved Parks and Nature Bond, our council created the Large-Scale Community Visions Program because we wanted to support visionary, multifaceted capital projects that could increase community access to nature, while creating benefits like inclusive economic development, job opportunities, affordable housing, and safe and reliable transportation.

465
00:49:25.577 --> 00:49:36.139
<v Duncan Hwang>The bond and other Metro programs have helped catalyze large-scale projects, projects up and down Portland's riverfront, including the OMSI District and the redevelopment of Tom McCall Waterfront Park.

466
00:49:36.733 --> 00:49:51.588
<v Duncan Hwang>So when Albina Vision Trust came up to us in 2023 with a vision for Lower Albina as a complete neighborhood reconnected to itself, into the river, we are proud to invest $5 million on behalf of our region to begin acquiring the land needed to bring it to life.

467
00:49:52.661 --> 00:50:06.487
<v Duncan Hwang>With the many other public, private, and philanthropic investments now flowing into Lower Ambina, our region has the chance to repair the historic harms done right here to Portland's Black community and to set a national example of how to do this right.

468
00:50:07.561 --> 00:50:14.179
<v Duncan Hwang>But reconnecting this district will be made much more difficult if our investments and development aren't interconnected with each other.

469
00:50:14.355 --> 00:50:14.659
<v Duncan Hwang>Thank you.

470
00:50:15.396 --> 00:50:25.818
<v Duncan Hwang>Fortunately, Albina Vision Trust's deep roots in the community and proven track record of success in revitalizing Albina have made them a potent leader and anchor for the district's transformation.

471
00:50:26.556 --> 00:50:32.320
<v Duncan Hwang>We're excited to continue to partner with you all, and I think the region has actually spoken.

472
00:50:32.514 --> 00:50:39.835
<v Duncan Hwang>All 24 cities believe that this is a regional project of significant importance and look forward to your support on this project.

473
00:50:39.884 --> 00:50:39.980
<v D'Artagnan Caliman>Thank you.

474
00:50:40.059 --> 00:50:40.317
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

475
00:50:41.585 --> 00:50:43.112
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

476
00:50:43.273 --> 00:50:48.913
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, with that, I would turn it over to you for the public testimony.

477
00:50:49.057 --> 00:50:49.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect, thank you.

478
00:50:50.407 --> 00:50:56.851
<v Jamie Dunphy>I did notice on our public testimony sheet that there are 2 other elected officials who are signed up, and if they are in the room, I'd love to invite them down first.

479
00:50:56.914 --> 00:51:02.554
<v Jamie Dunphy>Michelle DePass with Portland Public School Board and Justice Rajeev with the Beaverton School Board.

480
00:51:03.293 --> 00:51:05.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if they're not, we will just continue on to public testimony.

481
00:51:07.922 --> 00:51:11.943
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, okay, it's your day job part here.

482
00:51:12.025 --> 00:51:15.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>Never— well, then we'll, we'll— I know which hat to wear at the different times.

483
00:51:15.965 --> 00:51:16.914
<v Duncan Hwang>Got it.

484
00:51:17.139 --> 00:51:19.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, and apologies, Council President, I didn't have them on my list.

485
00:51:19.903 --> 00:51:22.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>No problem, I was just— I saw them on there, I wanted to call it out really quickly.

486
00:51:22.846 --> 00:51:24.835
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, Keelan, can we please call public testimony?

487
00:51:27.760 --> 00:51:31.541
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, uh, as a reminder, I will call up testifiers in groups of 5.

488
00:51:31.590 --> 00:51:33.548
<v Keelan McClymont>Each individual will have 2 minutes.

489
00:51:33.726 --> 00:51:39.451
<v Keelan McClymont>For those testifying in person, you will see the timer countdown displayed on the monitor in front of the testimony table.

490
00:51:39.500 --> 00:51:42.505
<v Keelan McClymont>For those testifying virtually, the timer is displayed in Zoom.

491
00:51:43.438 --> 00:51:49.000
<v Keelan McClymont>You will hear the timer sound twice, once when there are 30 seconds left, then a second time when your time is up.

492
00:51:49.143 --> 00:51:52.606
<v Keelan McClymont>Before you begin your testimony, please state your name for the record.

493
00:51:53.119 --> 00:51:53.713
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, thank you.

494
00:51:56.163 --> 00:52:10.173
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Alex DeRora, Akasha Lawrence-Spence, Tanisha Renee, Mike Alexander.

495
00:52:11.802 --> 00:52:14.802
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I also see Michelle is here, so hi.

496
00:52:15.257 --> 00:52:16.463
<v Michelle DePass>Hello, everyone.

497
00:52:17.065 --> 00:52:17.699
<v Olivia Clark>Hi, how are you?

498
00:52:17.764 --> 00:52:18.463
<v Candace Avalos>I'm doing well.

499
00:52:18.528 --> 00:52:18.855
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

500
00:52:19.001 --> 00:52:19.472
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dive on in.

501
00:52:21.070 --> 00:52:23.195
<v Michelle DePass>Are you ready?

502
00:52:23.474 --> 00:52:23.623
<v Michelle DePass>Yeah.

503
00:52:24.378 --> 00:52:28.454
<v Michelle DePass>Good afternoon, Council President Dunphy, members of the council.

504
00:52:28.503 --> 00:52:30.123
<v Michelle DePass>For the record, my name is Michelle DePass.

505
00:52:30.813 --> 00:52:39.978
<v Michelle DePass>That's D as in David, E, capital P— make sure it's capitalized— A-S-S. And I'm speaking as a member of the Portland School Board and a longtime Albina resident.

506
00:52:40.541 --> 00:52:46.527
<v Michelle DePass>I'm here to speak to the importance of this resolution for our entire city in general and Black Portlanders in particular.

507
00:52:47.748 --> 00:53:00.798
<v Michelle DePass>This council resolution is an important piece of Albina Vision Trust's work to bring the community vision for Lower Albina to life over the it will enable AVT to reconnect the neighborhood and build community wealth.

508
00:53:02.018 --> 00:53:17.175
<v Michelle DePass>And AVT, in partnership with the city, will be able to do this using the very tools that were used to dismantle and displace residents, dismantle the neighborhood: land use policy, transportation investment, access to capital, and anti-displacement strategies.

509
00:53:18.474 --> 00:53:21.460
<v Michelle DePass>My grandparents on both sides settled here from New Orleans and Panama.

510
00:53:24.074 --> 00:53:28.079
<v Michelle DePass>They met— my parents met at Dawson Park the first day my dad was in this country.

511
00:53:30.742 --> 00:53:36.036
<v Michelle DePass>I was born in this district, and I had my first job at the Black Panthers Free Health Clinic before it was legal to work.

512
00:53:36.197 --> 00:53:38.965
<v Michelle DePass>It was a long time ago, and I've raised my family here.

513
00:53:39.750 --> 00:53:44.583
<v Michelle DePass>My grandparents contributed to the social and neighborhood institutions, and they spent their money and time in this district.

514
00:53:45.855 --> 00:53:47.103
<v Michelle DePass>And that's the vision for tomorrow.

515
00:53:47.708 --> 00:53:53.958
<v Michelle DePass>A place where commerce can happen and an economy that will not extract but instead enrich this community.

516
00:53:54.715 --> 00:54:03.273
<v Michelle DePass>Dollars that will circulate within this community and where people won't be strangers, where families can once again afford to settle like my grandparents did.

517
00:54:04.826 --> 00:54:20.806
<v Michelle DePass>I urge you to vote an enthusiastic yes when the time comes to vote because the city has an opportunity right now to keep this historic moment focused on reconnecting a neighborhood and returning land to Portland's Black community regardless of any outcome of the current arena negotiations.

518
00:54:22.092 --> 00:54:22.396
<v Michelle DePass>Thank you.

519
00:54:22.976 --> 00:54:23.521
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

520
00:54:25.081 --> 00:54:29.563
<v Tanisha Renee>Okay, um, good afternoon, members of council and all that are joining us here today.

521
00:54:29.788 --> 00:54:30.994
<v Tanisha Renee>My name is Tanisha Renee.

522
00:54:31.106 --> 00:54:34.969
<v Tanisha Renee>I'm the Deputy Executive Director at Williams and Russell CDC.

523
00:54:35.693 --> 00:54:42.483
<v Tanisha Renee>I'm here today in strong support of the city moving forward with Albina Vision Trust as its development partner for the Rose Quarter.

524
00:54:43.269 --> 00:54:45.498
<v Tanisha Renee>AVT is not simply developing property.

525
00:54:45.916 --> 00:55:01.007
<v Tanisha Renee>They are taking under— or they are undertaking one of the largest restorative redevelopment efforts in the country, working to buy back land, rebuild community, and reroute Black lives, legacies, and futures in the Lower Albina area.

526
00:55:01.648 --> 00:55:07.068
<v Tanisha Renee>As a sister organization doing reparative development work, we understand that who develops this land matters.

527
00:55:07.117 --> 00:55:07.244
<v Tanisha Renee>Thank you.

528
00:55:07.501 --> 00:55:10.844
<v Tanisha Renee>Stewardship matters, and community accountability matters.

529
00:55:12.708 --> 00:55:19.005
<v Tanisha Renee>And the ability to bring public, private, and philanthropic investment together around a shared vision matters.

530
00:55:20.750 --> 00:55:26.112
<v Tanisha Renee>ABT has demonstrated that capacity and more importantly has earned the trust required to lead this work.

531
00:55:26.650 --> 00:55:29.793
<v Tanisha Renee>I urge council to move these negotiations forward and vote yes.

532
00:55:30.309 --> 00:55:30.711
<v Tanisha Renee>Thank you.

533
00:55:31.420 --> 00:55:31.599
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

534
00:55:33.047 --> 00:55:33.610
<v Olivia Clark>Nice.

535
00:55:34.878 --> 00:55:38.894
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>Good afternoon, Chair Dunphy, Vice Chair Clark, and members of the Portland City Council.

536
00:55:39.376 --> 00:55:52.001
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>My name is Akasha Lauren Spence, and I have the honor and privilege of serving as the Director of External Affairs at Albina Vision Trust, carrying forward the community vision of a reconnected and abundant Lower Albina.

537
00:55:53.172 --> 00:56:01.590
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>When I moved to Portland over a decade ago, I was wooed by the promise of walkable neighborhoods, new-age transit, local food, and a vibrant small business community.

538
00:56:02.425 --> 00:56:14.231
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>But as I embedded myself into the Black community, I learned of a past not unfamiliar to me, one wrought with discrimination, exclusion, and missed opportunities at restoration and redevelopment.

539
00:56:15.195 --> 00:56:39.333
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>I felt the resonance of displacement as I learned how homes, businesses, playgrounds, and civic institutions were seized from this community in the name of progress and prosperity when over 13 city blocks were flattened I learned that despite every tactic used to scatter and dismantle Black wealth and civic power, that it was striving, alive in the faces you see in this chamber today.

540
00:56:40.391 --> 00:56:53.956
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>This resolution to return 6.2 acres of land in the heart of Lower Albina's entertainment district is a chance to embed the resonance of community life and culture present in Lower Albina in the parcels at the heart of Portland's sports and entertainment arena.

541
00:56:54.021 --> 00:56:54.389
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>Councilmember Herbold.

542
00:56:55.945 --> 00:57:06.742
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>It is an opportunity to call forward Portland's status as a city globally recognized for urban planning and design, community participation and empowerment, and strategic planning.

543
00:57:07.833 --> 00:57:20.699
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>It's an opportunity to call forward a city that espouses the reasons Portlanders love their city for its attractive, walkable neighborhoods, with the opportunity to make walkability and livability a promise fulfilled for Black Portlanders.

544
00:57:21.748 --> 00:57:34.572
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>This is our vision, but both ours and yours, a collective vision to make the reality of our community abundance a dialogue between past, present, and the thriving future we build as an inheritance to our descendants.

545
00:57:36.612 --> 00:57:45.197
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>In the longer term, it creates an example for how our cities can do this right, proactively and collaboratively plan its future with all its communities in mind.

546
00:57:45.748 --> 00:57:47.320
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>I urge a yes vote on this resolution.

547
00:57:47.369 --> 00:57:47.483
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>Thank you.

548
00:57:47.911 --> 00:57:48.242
<v Akasha Lawrence-Spence>Thank you.

549
00:57:48.590 --> 00:57:50.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

550
00:57:51.746 --> 00:57:51.925
<v Wynta Johannes>Great.

551
00:57:53.541 --> 00:57:57.115
<v Andrew Colas>Good afternoon, President Dunphy and members of City Council.

552
00:57:57.980 --> 00:58:09.931
<v Michael Alexander>My name is Michael Alexander, and I have the privilege to serve as a member of the board for our Bonavision Trust for the last decade and as its chair since 2024.

553
00:58:11.545 --> 00:58:22.661
<v Michael Alexander>This City Council resolution is an important piece of AVT's work to bring the community vision for Lower Albina to life over the next 50 years.

554
00:58:24.358 --> 00:58:43.490
<v Michael Alexander>It enables AVT to reconnect the network of our neighborhood, to align development around the Avena with the city's adopted plans that are already reshaping some of the area, and to build community wealth through durable and equitable community benefits.

555
00:58:43.577 --> 00:58:43.713
<v Michael Alexander>Thank you.

556
00:58:44.949 --> 00:58:57.538
<v Michael Alexander>Over the past decade, AVT has stewarded a community-defined vision for Albina rooted in its past and in a deep belief in the possibility of repair and transformation.

557
00:58:58.597 --> 00:59:24.471
<v Michael Alexander>This resolution gives us the opportunity to reconnect Albina as a complete neighborhood with streets where children play in safety, Where people want to gather, where businesses and storefronts are owned by our neighbors, and where wealth and prosperity reach the people who have waited the longest to share in it.

558
00:59:25.755 --> 00:59:40.048
<v Michael Alexander>AVT's community-centered 94-acre redevelopment vision for Lower Albina makes it the natural long-term developer of the city-owned parcels surrounding the arena.

559
00:59:41.398 --> 00:59:45.364
<v Michael Alexander>Over the past decade, we have earned local and international recognition.

560
00:59:46.713 --> 01:00:00.088
<v Michael Alexander>We've constructed and opened Albina 1, our inaugural 94-unit family-centered housing, and we've secured rights for the first offer and refusal for the Portland Public Schools site.

561
01:00:06.108 --> 01:00:11.313
<v Michael Alexander>We believe this resolution can be more than an element of an arena deal.

562
01:00:11.474 --> 01:00:17.217
<v Michael Alexander>It can be a catalyst for the long-term overdue restoration of Lower Albina.

563
01:00:18.170 --> 01:00:18.606
<v Michael Alexander>Thank you.

564
01:00:19.543 --> 01:00:20.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all very much.

565
01:00:23.128 --> 01:00:24.351
<v Keelan McClymont>Alex DeRosa.

566
01:00:28.498 --> 01:00:38.302
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Nate McCoy, Burke Nelson, Anthony Sai Arakaki, Mark Jackson, James Posey.

567
01:00:45.260 --> 01:00:46.340
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

568
01:01:01.615 --> 01:01:03.717
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome to kick us off since you are here.

569
01:01:04.606 --> 01:01:09.659
<v Mark Jackson>Well, good afternoon, Council President Dunphy and council members.

570
01:01:09.998 --> 01:01:20.246
<v Mark Jackson>Um, what you are experiencing today is the richness and the vibrance of the Black community.

571
01:01:22.045 --> 01:01:37.583
<v Mark Jackson>And though we have faces before you representing organizations, we come in the spirit of our ancestors to beseech you, to encourage you to recognize and understand this is a kairos moment.

572
01:01:39.777 --> 01:01:44.844
<v Mark Jackson>You have the opportunity to support a transformative Thank you.

573
01:01:45.021 --> 01:01:48.195
<v Mark Jackson>This is a revolutionary opportunity.

574
01:01:49.976 --> 01:02:13.275
<v Mark Jackson>If we were to go ahead and wind back time and eavesdrop on table conversations and bedrooms where families lamented being uprooted from what they knew in terms of Albina, today as a council, we can engage in restorative justice.

575
01:02:14.748 --> 01:02:29.505
<v Mark Jackson>And set the record straight, not just for Black people, but for Portland and for the nation, that we have courage and we have conviction to do what is just and what is right.

576
01:02:29.585 --> 01:02:40.065
<v Mark Jackson>We support, as a coalition of African and African American pastors, me being Pastor Mark Jackson, whom you all know, we endorse and we celebrate this moment with AVT.

577
01:02:40.976 --> 01:02:42.652
<v Mark Jackson>Support the vote with a yes.

578
01:02:43.231 --> 01:02:43.505
<v Mark Jackson>Thank you.

579
01:02:45.277 --> 01:02:46.518
<v Nate McCoy>I'm supposed to go after that?

580
01:02:49.150 --> 01:02:49.784
<v Nate McCoy>Make Burke do it.

581
01:02:49.851 --> 01:02:51.034
<v Nate McCoy>Just kidding, just kidding.

582
01:02:52.909 --> 01:02:58.135
<v Nate McCoy>Good afternoon, Council President Dunphy, uh, members of the council, even our city administrator as well.

583
01:02:58.588 --> 01:03:08.994
<v Nate McCoy>My name is Nate McCoy, and today I'm wearing my interim executive director hat of the Black Business Association of Oregon, while my senior policy advisor next to me will speak on behalf of NAMAC Oregon.

584
01:03:09.190 --> 01:03:19.257
<v Nate McCoy>I'm here today to express a strong support for the resolution before you and to continue the milestones of achievement and progress made by Albina Vision Trust.

585
01:03:19.865 --> 01:03:29.501
<v Nate McCoy>For those of us who know the saying, it takes a village to raise a child, we also understand that it takes a village to rebuild, restore, and raise up a community.

586
01:03:30.206 --> 01:03:33.460
<v Nate McCoy>Albina is more than just a place, as Mark said, on a map.

587
01:03:34.054 --> 01:03:34.679
<v Nate McCoy>It is home.

588
01:03:35.096 --> 01:03:45.001
<v Nate McCoy>It is history, it is culture, it is vibrance, it is generations of Black Portlanders, including my own family, like many others here today.

589
01:03:45.530 --> 01:03:52.023
<v Nate McCoy>It represents both what we have taken or have seen taken and what we can restore moving forward.

590
01:03:52.744 --> 01:03:57.554
<v Nate McCoy>What makes this moment significant is not simply talking about development.

591
01:03:57.938 --> 01:04:05.536
<v Nate McCoy>We are talking about restorative justice and economic justice in one of the most desirable and historically significant parts of our city.

592
01:04:05.969 --> 01:04:19.563
<v Nate McCoy>The Albina Vision represents an opportunity to rewrite past wrongs while creating a future where Black businesses, Black families, entrepreneurs, workers, and communities have a meaningful stake in the prosperity being created.

593
01:04:20.300 --> 01:04:26.440
<v Nate McCoy>From the perspective of Black Business Association of Oregon, the economic participation is crucial right now.

594
01:04:26.568 --> 01:04:28.731
<v Nate McCoy>We know what our financial climate looks like.

595
01:04:29.213 --> 01:04:38.269
<v Nate McCoy>Community development must include pathways for Black-owned and historically underrepresented businesses to participate, grow, build wealth, and remain rooted in the community.

596
01:04:38.655 --> 01:04:47.166
<v Nate McCoy>The the second of opportunity is before us and with— and happening in the Central Core is also becoming a Portland success.

597
01:04:47.568 --> 01:04:48.724
<v Nate McCoy>And we've heard it nationally.

598
01:04:49.512 --> 01:04:49.896
<v Nate McCoy>What we—.

599
01:04:49.994 --> 01:04:57.204
<v Nate McCoy>I want to end with is we have an opportunity to demonstrate that development does not have to mean displacement and investment.

600
01:04:57.782 --> 01:05:07.675
<v Nate McCoy>We can really create a long and standing access to capital and ways to move a community forward in a Black-led way.

601
01:05:07.740 --> 01:05:07.836
<v Nate McCoy>Thank you.

602
01:05:08.288 --> 01:05:13.601
<v Nate McCoy>This is about legacy, and I implore you to vote yes and support this resolution before us.

603
01:05:13.875 --> 01:05:17.851
<v Nate McCoy>And let me just say, I love seeing leadership working together at the council.

604
01:05:18.269 --> 01:05:21.389
<v Nate McCoy>This is a beautiful thing, and I hope we see a lot more of it moving forward.

605
01:05:22.130 --> 01:05:22.467
<v Nate McCoy>Thank you.

606
01:05:24.141 --> 01:05:24.800
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

607
01:05:25.668 --> 01:05:29.235
<v Burke Nelson>Good afternoon, Council President Dunphy and the rest of council.

608
01:05:29.847 --> 01:05:35.025
<v Burke Nelson>Um, my name is Burke Nelson, and I'm here on behalf of the National Association of Minority Contractors.

609
01:05:35.980 --> 01:05:44.838
<v Burke Nelson>I'm proud to express our strong support for the Albina Vision Trust and its transformative vision for the Rose Quarter and the broader Lower Albina community.

610
01:05:45.737 --> 01:05:50.166
<v Burke Nelson>For decades, the Albina neighborhood has carried the burden of displacement and disinvestment.

611
01:05:50.550 --> 01:06:02.056
<v Burke Nelson>Today, we have an opportunity not only to reconnect a community physically divided by infrastructure, but to restore economic opportunity, cultural identity, and generational wealth for future generations.

612
01:06:02.778 --> 01:06:10.851
<v Burke Nelson>UrbanaVision Trust's redevelopment strategy represents the type of bold, inclusive investment that can become a model for cities across America.

613
01:06:11.735 --> 01:06:24.364
<v Burke Nelson>From NAMAC's perspective, the effort has the potential to create thousands of family-wage construction jobs, expand opportunities for minority-owned businesses, and generate long-term economic activity throughout Portland's urban core.

614
01:06:25.054 --> 01:06:35.016
<v Burke Nelson>Just as importantly, it creates a pathway for historically marginalized communities to participate in and benefit from the prosperity generated by redevelopment.

615
01:06:36.219 --> 01:06:41.974
<v Burke Nelson>Albina Vision— the closest comparison is something similar down south where I'm from.

616
01:06:42.054 --> 01:06:55.429
<v Burke Nelson>Los Angeles had a huge economic impact around 1999 when a bunch of buildings were erected around a sports facility, much like Albina Vision Trust is doing here in Portland.

617
01:06:55.476 --> 01:06:55.668
<v Burke Nelson>Thank you.

618
01:06:56.422 --> 01:07:07.094
<v Burke Nelson>Albina Vision Trust presents a similar opportunity by combining community-centered planning, infrastructure investment, housing, commercial development, and workforce participation.

619
01:07:07.559 --> 01:07:14.317
<v Burke Nelson>The Rose Quarter can become a thriving economic engine for the region while honoring the history and legacy of the Albina community.

620
01:07:15.182 --> 01:07:22.501
<v Burke Nelson>NAMAC believes that true economic development is measured not only by buildings constructed, but by the people whose lives are improved along the way.

621
01:07:23.344 --> 01:07:35.018
<v Burke Nelson>AVT's vision embodies the principle, and we look forward to supporting a redevelopment effort that creates jobs, grows minority business participation, and leaves a lasting legacy of shared prosperity for Portland.

622
01:07:35.989 --> 01:07:37.596
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

623
01:07:39.057 --> 01:07:39.443
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good timing.

624
01:07:43.411 --> 01:07:44.166
<v Melvin Broadus>Good afternoon.

625
01:07:45.420 --> 01:07:46.893
<v Melvin Broadus>My name is Melvin Broadus.

626
01:07:48.193 --> 01:07:53.121
<v Melvin Broadus>I'm with I didn't have anything prepared.

627
01:07:53.492 --> 01:07:59.083
<v Melvin Broadus>I'm going to speak from my heart, which is about to pound out of my chest right now.

628
01:08:04.809 --> 01:08:10.922
<v Melvin Broadus>Council President, councilors, city administrator, thank you for this opportunity.

629
01:08:12.148 --> 01:08:14.148
<v Melvin Broadus>I'm quite proud to be sitting among these brothers.

630
01:08:15.298 --> 01:08:21.085
<v Melvin Broadus>Supporting an organization that is going to do something good for Black Portland.

631
01:08:22.399 --> 01:08:23.287
<v Melvin Broadus>I grew up in this city.

632
01:08:23.480 --> 01:08:25.287
<v Melvin Broadus>I was born and raised right here.

633
01:08:25.966 --> 01:08:27.515
<v Melvin Broadus>I wasn't— I'm not a transplant.

634
01:08:27.740 --> 01:08:29.564
<v Melvin Broadus>I was born and raised right here.

635
01:08:30.338 --> 01:08:32.167
<v Melvin Broadus>I've seen Portland make a lot of changes.

636
01:08:32.770 --> 01:08:37.612
<v Melvin Broadus>I've been an entrepreneur with my dad from childhood.

637
01:08:39.728 --> 01:08:41.712
<v Melvin Broadus>And yes, we were displaced.

638
01:08:42.976 --> 01:08:49.695
<v Melvin Broadus>We grew— I grew up on Missouri Avenue during the time— pardon me— during the time they put I-5 in.

639
01:08:50.449 --> 01:08:55.069
<v Melvin Broadus>We played in the dirt while they were doing that construction as kids.

640
01:08:56.543 --> 01:09:03.295
<v Melvin Broadus>And I remember what we call today Portland Black Wall Street up and down Williams Avenue.

641
01:09:03.615 --> 01:09:03.807
<v Melvin Broadus>Uh-huh.

642
01:09:03.856 --> 01:09:08.426
<v Melvin Broadus>So I remember those businesses that were there.

643
01:09:09.292 --> 01:09:14.055
<v Melvin Broadus>I went in, I visited them and bought food from them.

644
01:09:14.380 --> 01:09:15.514
<v Melvin Broadus>We went to the cleaners there.

645
01:09:19.337 --> 01:09:25.425
<v Melvin Broadus>So I'm excited to see the redevelopment of Black Wall Street in Portland.

646
01:09:25.939 --> 01:09:28.725
<v Melvin Broadus>And I thank AVT for being involved.

647
01:09:29.144 --> 01:09:41.166
<v Melvin Broadus>And on behalf of PCRI, I will say we look forward for the opportunity to participate in this development and those others that are available in future.

648
01:09:41.520 --> 01:09:43.300
<v Melvin Broadus>So congratulations to AVT.

649
01:09:44.335 --> 01:09:45.305
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

650
01:09:45.725 --> 01:09:46.064
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

651
01:09:53.938 --> 01:09:58.180
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, um, sorry, just, um, let's see here.

652
01:09:59.746 --> 01:10:09.930
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Anthony Sai Arakaki, Mark Jackson, I have to go again?

653
01:10:10.106 --> 01:10:11.220
<v Keelan McClymont>Mark.

654
01:10:12.430 --> 01:10:12.738
<v Keelan McClymont>Sorry.

655
01:10:13.319 --> 01:10:14.465
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

656
01:10:16.449 --> 01:10:28.365
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, next up we have James Posey, John Washington, Andrea Bontemps, Lakeitha Elliott, Justice Reggie.

657
01:10:50.707 --> 01:10:55.247
<v Justice Rajee>Well, I guess before I go, I will say thank you for the consideration, and I appreciate that.

658
01:10:55.311 --> 01:10:55.730
<v Justice Rajee>I understand.

659
01:10:56.037 --> 01:10:56.615
<v Justice Rajee>Absolutely welcome.

660
01:10:59.962 --> 01:11:04.655
<v Justice Rajee>Uh, well, in absence of some of my other community friends that I know are here, give me just a second.

661
01:11:08.770 --> 01:11:10.252
<v Justice Rajee>Uh, for the record, my name is Justice Rajee.

662
01:11:10.301 --> 01:11:13.636
<v Justice Rajee>I'm the Director of Advocacy and Civic Engagement for the Urban League of Portland.

663
01:11:14.136 --> 01:11:19.637
<v Justice Rajee>I'm also a registered lobbyist on behalf of the Urban League with the City of Portland, and I'm here in that capacity today.

664
01:11:20.203 --> 01:11:23.131
<v Justice Rajee>Um, just so it's known, I am also a board chair of the Williams-Russell CDC.

665
01:11:23.197 --> 01:11:23.536
<v Justice Rajee>Thank you.

666
01:11:24.564 --> 01:11:26.914
<v Justice Rajee>The Urban League supports the resolution as written.

667
01:11:27.774 --> 01:11:33.414
<v Justice Rajee>Albina Vision Trust is the right partner for the city to negotiate with on the Rose Quarter and VMC parcels.

668
01:11:33.914 --> 01:11:47.993
<v Justice Rajee>AVT has spent nearly a decade building the community-led 94-acre restorative vision for Lower Albina, and the city has already adopted those thoughts in the Community Investment Plan, in the North Northeast Quadrant Plan, and the Central City 2035.

669
01:11:48.283 --> 01:11:52.976
<v Justice Rajee>So this resolution is honoring the work of a vetted public partner.

670
01:11:53.027 --> 01:11:53.141
<v Justice Rajee>Thank you.

671
01:11:57.014 --> 01:12:13.546
<v Justice Rajee>With that, the long-range development planning that honors the current ambition of the descendants and the relations of those displaced who experienced the disrespect and the disregard and economic harm of past public planning is key to making right where wrong prevailed and building the opportunity for healing.

672
01:12:14.140 --> 01:12:18.707
<v Justice Rajee>Any vision for prosperity that does not root these people in the soil is bereft of credibility.

673
01:12:18.756 --> 01:12:18.885
<v Justice Rajee>Thank you.

674
01:12:19.868 --> 01:12:34.189
<v Justice Rajee>In community work over the recent decades, there has been a centering of bringing and the appointment of alignment and voice and shared visions across different organizations, those who have interest in seeing Albina restored and seeing our region restored in a place for prosperity for all.

675
01:12:34.576 --> 01:12:42.122
<v Justice Rajee>And by supporting this work, this council takes a step of supporting that external work that has led to this moment, as it was shared in the past.

676
01:12:43.069 --> 01:12:47.548
<v Justice Rajee>Organizations and community will not be left with nothing to show by fighting for favor.

677
01:12:48.046 --> 01:12:53.480
<v Justice Rajee>Over resources and opportunity, and there's sufficient opportunity to make an impact in this city across the board.

678
01:12:54.057 --> 01:12:56.671
<v Justice Rajee>And the talent is there and the ability to execute is there.

679
01:12:57.119 --> 01:12:59.972
<v Justice Rajee>Backing and support today, you can be part of that story.

680
01:13:00.711 --> 01:13:09.640
<v Justice Rajee>Council should honor that and take the next step and show their commitment to the community and show trust and build trust by supporting this resolution as written.

681
01:13:10.248 --> 01:13:10.506
<v Michael Alexander>Thank you.

682
01:13:11.131 --> 01:13:11.676
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

683
01:13:14.095 --> 01:13:15.731
<v John Washington>Hi, my name is John Washington.

684
01:13:15.811 --> 01:13:25.787
<v John Washington>I'm the executive director of the Soul District Business Association, which is in the Albina District and the oldest— one of the oldest business districts in the city.

685
01:13:26.782 --> 01:13:29.909
<v John Washington>I appreciate you guys allowing me to come here and say hello to you today.

686
01:13:30.295 --> 01:13:32.925
<v John Washington>Hello, each of you councilors.

687
01:13:33.597 --> 01:13:40.319
<v John Washington>Boy, I'll tell you, and as Melvin said earlier, it's always like a hot seat looking at all y'all, you know, in this panel.

688
01:13:40.735 --> 01:13:49.003
<v John Washington>But I come to express my support for any of the restorative types of things that are going on in our district.

689
01:13:49.725 --> 01:13:51.154
<v John Washington>I mean, it's been long overdue.

690
01:13:51.492 --> 01:13:58.975
<v John Washington>It's been long overdue to see some real revenue hit the streets in Northeast, and especially around the business sector.

691
01:13:59.905 --> 01:14:02.458
<v John Washington>It's been a challenge over the last 20 years.

692
01:14:03.118 --> 01:14:07.789
<v John Washington>And just for most of you, I've been around long enough to see a lot of these things start.

693
01:14:09.059 --> 01:14:15.494
<v John Washington>And that calls me— that makes for me to be this thing my professor used to say to me in college, called me a phenomenologist.

694
01:14:16.440 --> 01:14:22.967
<v John Washington>A phenomenologist is when you see some stuff leave the station, but you're alive long enough to see where it landed.

695
01:14:24.057 --> 01:14:29.413
<v John Washington>You know, I'm excited about this because now something is really beginning to happen.

696
01:14:30.167 --> 01:14:47.945
<v John Washington>There are some aspects of this that I struggle with from time to time because this whole notion around fair and equitable distribution of wealth sort of is a challenge, making sure that we all be able to participate in these opportunities.

697
01:14:48.395 --> 01:14:55.591
<v John Washington>So community is really important to me in these situations, and oversight is also another important aspect of this.

698
01:14:56.154 --> 01:15:05.952
<v John Washington>So I appreciate y'all allowing me to come in and let y'all know that we fully support any development that goes into our district that moves us in the right direction and moves the needle.

699
01:15:06.354 --> 01:15:06.690
<v John Washington>Thank you.

700
01:15:07.078 --> 01:15:07.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

701
01:15:10.073 --> 01:15:12.079
<v Lakeitha Elliott>Hello, good afternoon, councilors.

702
01:15:12.127 --> 01:15:14.604
<v Lakeitha Elliott>My name is Lakeitha Elliott, E-L-L-I-O-T-T.

703
01:15:15.655 --> 01:15:22.988
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I am a 4th generation Black Portlander, a person who is deeply involved in the community across a lot of sectors.

704
01:15:23.551 --> 01:15:33.225
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I'm also the grandmother of a 6-year-old who spends a lot of time in and near the Rose Quarter because he's the biggest Portland Trail Blazers and Portland Fire and even Portland Winterhawks fan.

705
01:15:33.698 --> 01:15:35.930
<v Lakeitha Elliott>So we spend a lot of days there near the Rose Quarter.

706
01:15:39.890 --> 01:16:02.037
<v Lakeitha Elliott>For me, it's— I believe that this work will ensure that the future for him is bright, that his story about Portland and Black Portland will be a beautiful one, that his stories will be about a place that was designed with him in mind, where he can thrive and he can prosper and he can see people who look like him in a community, again, that was built for him and with him in mind.

707
01:16:02.439 --> 01:16:03.417
<v Lakeitha Elliott>Councilor Smith.

708
01:16:04.266 --> 01:16:07.409
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I appreciate the work that you all are doing to advance this work.

709
01:16:08.036 --> 01:16:15.349
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I especially wanna thank Councilors Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, and Ryan for your leadership in this matter and for the ways that you all continually show up in community.

710
01:16:15.493 --> 01:16:17.001
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I see you all at the Black parties.

711
01:16:17.434 --> 01:16:21.203
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I see you all at the, you know, all of the community events.

712
01:16:21.427 --> 01:16:26.061
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I see Commissioner Pirtle-Guiney coaching baseball in the community.

713
01:16:26.671 --> 01:16:30.425
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I saw Dan Ryan flipping burgers and doing the Electric Slide at Unthank Park.

714
01:16:30.537 --> 01:16:33.150
<v Lakeitha Elliott>So I appreciate the way that you all show up.

715
01:16:33.402 --> 01:16:42.159
<v Lakeitha Elliott>Genuinely in the community and the way that you all show up to be accountable to making sure that the city is gonna be a good steward of the lands in District 2.

716
01:16:43.605 --> 01:16:53.840
<v Lakeitha Elliott>It's important to note that the organizations that showed up here, including 1803 Fund, SEI, Kollas Constructions, William& Russell, are all valued members of our community and valued business.

717
01:16:53.904 --> 01:16:59.479
<v Lakeitha Elliott>And it's important to note the way that they work together and that we show up together because they have the voices of the community behind them.

718
01:17:00.475 --> 01:17:10.354
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I wanna say that your, your resolution specifically says that the development partners should have a community-oriented mission and leadership.

719
01:17:10.500 --> 01:17:11.364
<v Lakeitha Elliott>AVT does.

720
01:17:12.038 --> 01:17:14.538
<v Lakeitha Elliott>It says that they should have the ability to bring investment.

721
01:17:14.667 --> 01:17:15.453
<v Lakeitha Elliott>AVT does.

722
01:17:16.847 --> 01:17:19.748
<v Lakeitha Elliott>And experience advancing the community voice.

723
01:17:19.877 --> 01:17:21.064
<v Lakeitha Elliott>And they do that particularly well.

724
01:17:21.271 --> 01:17:32.396
<v Lakeitha Elliott>I see them show up and engage everyone across sectors in the community, neighbors, new folks, old folks, all of the people who need to be involved and engaged in these conversations.

725
01:17:32.476 --> 01:17:38.000
<v Lakeitha Elliott>And so I urge you to say yes because they are the only organization that is capable of doing this work.

726
01:17:38.096 --> 01:17:38.421
<v Lakeitha Elliott>Thank you.

727
01:17:39.219 --> 01:17:39.886
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

728
01:17:43.649 --> 01:17:44.261
<v Andrea Bon Temps>Oh, I guess it's me.

729
01:17:44.390 --> 01:17:44.648
<v Andrea Bon Temps>Okay.

730
01:17:45.436 --> 01:17:47.000
<v Andrea Bon Temps>Hi, I'm Andrea Bon Temps.

731
01:17:47.127 --> 01:17:49.287
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I'm the owner of Les Bon Temps Cafe and Catering.

732
01:17:49.865 --> 01:17:53.618
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I am a Portland native, an Albina District native all my life.

733
01:17:55.342 --> 01:18:08.442
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I just want— what everybody is doing is great, and I'm glad to see— the last time I seen this much camaraderie was I'm dating myself now, probably the '90s, the very beginning of the '90s.

734
01:18:09.243 --> 01:18:13.064
<v Andrea Bon Temps>And I want to feel— I feel empowered by what's going on.

735
01:18:13.192 --> 01:18:28.615
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I just want to make sure that Black businesses have a chance as well to sit at the table and make sure that Black businesses are also included in this expansion, because I think that's a very vital part of small businesses.

736
01:18:28.712 --> 01:18:28.856
<v Andrea Bon Temps>Thank you.

737
01:18:29.162 --> 01:18:36.595
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I have a business on MLK, and, and I know for years we weren't on MLK, and now I'm on MLK.

738
01:18:36.645 --> 01:18:45.989
<v Andrea Bon Temps>So I just want, um, ABT— I know them very well, they're doing a good job— and, um, and all the other groups that are included.

739
01:18:46.327 --> 01:18:50.998
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I just think it's— I think it's a really good idea, and I think we can all come together, and I hope you guys vote yes.

740
01:18:52.427 --> 01:18:53.247
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

741
01:18:53.889 --> 01:18:54.338
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

742
01:18:56.306 --> 01:18:56.470
<v Ed Washington>Yep.

743
01:18:56.975 --> 01:18:58.979
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, James Posey.

744
01:19:02.699 --> 01:19:14.796
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Herman Green, Steven Green, JT Flowers, Lakita Landford, and Mike Schmidt.

745
01:19:29.202 --> 01:19:29.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All right.

746
01:19:31.314 --> 01:19:31.507
<v Sameer Kanal>Yep.

747
01:19:31.604 --> 01:19:33.805
<v Herman Greene>I was trying to give everybody else a chance to get up here.

748
01:19:33.951 --> 01:19:37.979
<v Herman Greene>As a Black preacher, I got to figure out how I'm going to get this done in 2 minutes, so I'm just going to read.

749
01:19:40.122 --> 01:19:42.798
<v Herman Greene>My name is Herman Greene, last name G-R-E-E-N-E.

750
01:19:43.041 --> 01:19:46.976
<v Herman Greene>I want to say good afternoon, council members, council president, and our city administrator.

751
01:19:47.605 --> 01:19:49.944
<v Herman Greene>There are moments when leadership is called upon to talk about what is possible.

752
01:19:51.072 --> 01:19:55.092
<v Herman Greene>And then there are moments when leadership is called upon to make what is possible become reality.

753
01:19:55.702 --> 01:19:57.239
<v Herman Greene>Council, this is one of those moments.

754
01:19:57.720 --> 01:20:01.020
<v Herman Greene>For decades, we've talked about the displacement of Portland's Black community.

755
01:20:01.086 --> 01:20:06.773
<v Herman Greene>We've studied it, we've acknowledged it, we've even had some self-half-baked attempts to apologize for it.

756
01:20:07.094 --> 01:20:12.077
<v Herman Greene>And we've talked about equity, inclusion, economic opportunity, and repairing the harm of the past.

757
01:20:12.461 --> 01:20:17.395
<v Herman Greene>But there comes a time when the talking has to stop and we have to become a people of action.

758
01:20:17.492 --> 01:20:19.511
<v Herman Greene>And I believe that that time is now.

759
01:20:19.606 --> 01:20:19.798
<v Herman Greene>Thank you.

760
01:20:20.296 --> 01:20:23.694
<v Herman Greene>This land development partnership is so much bigger than a transaction.

761
01:20:23.759 --> 01:20:31.662
<v Herman Greene>It's an opportunity to demonstrate what happens when a city has the courage to move from acknowledging inequity to actually creating opportunity.

762
01:20:32.029 --> 01:20:34.194
<v Herman Greene>This is about more than just this partnership.

763
01:20:34.323 --> 01:20:40.029
<v Herman Greene>This is about ownership and who we believe should be a part of shaping what the future of our city looks like.

764
01:20:40.430 --> 01:20:44.470
<v Herman Greene>It's about jobs, businesses, housing, entrepreneurship, wealth creation.

765
01:20:44.518 --> 01:20:52.516
<v Herman Greene>It's about Black families and Black children being able to see themselves not as simply living in Portland, but helping to own buildings, shape Portland.

766
01:20:52.756 --> 01:20:58.382
<v Herman Greene>And if I dare say it, it's about restoring something that has been broken for generations— trust.

767
01:20:58.798 --> 01:20:59.167
<v Herman Greene>Mm-hmm.

768
01:20:59.247 --> 01:21:00.819
<v Herman Greene>Albina Vision Trust has earned that.

769
01:21:01.251 --> 01:21:04.488
<v Herman Greene>They have built relationships in Portland and across this country.

770
01:21:04.856 --> 01:21:08.527
<v Herman Greene>They have developed a restorative vision that lives beyond the visionaries themselves.

771
01:21:08.800 --> 01:21:13.735
<v Herman Greene>And most importantly, they've demonstrated when they say they're going to do something, that they actually do it.

772
01:21:14.185 --> 01:21:16.476
<v Herman Greene>So now we're urging this council to do the same.

773
01:21:17.198 --> 01:21:21.636
<v Herman Greene>Council, you were not elected to simply describe the Portland we hope to become.

774
01:21:22.487 --> 01:21:32.358
<v Herman Greene>You were elected to help us build it, and leadership is ultimately measured by what we are willing to do when the opportunity to make a difference is sitting directly in front of us like it is today.

775
01:21:32.662 --> 01:21:42.052
<v Herman Greene>So for those of us who have been marginalized, underrepresented, displaced, or unheard for decades, this moment says to us, we see you, we hear you, and this time we're prepared to act.

776
01:21:42.356 --> 01:21:47.180
<v Herman Greene>So I'm urging this council to have the courage to move this forward, not someday, but now.

777
01:21:47.244 --> 01:21:55.833
<v Herman Greene>Councilmember let Portland become a national model, not because we talked about what could be, but because we had the courage to act and produce what we all know should be.

778
01:21:56.217 --> 01:21:56.635
<v Herman Greene>Thank you.

779
01:21:57.756 --> 01:21:58.381
<v John Washington>Thank you.

780
01:21:59.182 --> 01:22:05.064
<v Stephen Green>All right, following that, um, good afternoon, Council President Dunphy, council members, and Administrator Lee.

781
01:22:05.608 --> 01:22:06.537
<v Stephen Green>My name is Stephen Green.

782
01:22:06.649 --> 01:22:09.903
<v Stephen Green>My family and I have lived in District 2 for the past 3 decades.

783
01:22:10.560 --> 01:22:14.164
<v Stephen Green>I own Vanport Studio, a business dedicated to helping Black founders reach new heights.

784
01:22:14.438 --> 01:22:22.101
<v Stephen Green>I'm here today in support of the resolution to have Albina Vision serve as the city's development partner for the city-owned properties surrounding the Moda Center.

785
01:22:22.761 --> 01:22:29.332
<v Stephen Green>For decades, we've talked about what was taken from Albina— homes, businesses, wealth, community, and connection.

786
01:22:29.990 --> 01:22:34.184
<v Stephen Green>But this decision gives us an opportunity to talk about what we're going to build next.

787
01:22:35.292 --> 01:22:40.979
<v Stephen Green>At a Portland City Club event in 1994, Albina Bank's, uh, thank you.

788
01:22:41.077 --> 01:22:52.304
<v Stephen Green>Council President Leon Smith remarked that as he looked over north and northeast Portland, including the then under-construction Rose Garden, he saw an enormous economic opportunity.

789
01:22:53.122 --> 01:22:58.551
<v Stephen Green>He said the question wasn't whether redevelopment would happen, it was who would benefit from it.

790
01:22:59.788 --> 01:23:02.583
<v Stephen Green>30 Years later, that question is back before us.

791
01:23:03.259 --> 01:23:10.768
<v Stephen Green>The redevelopment of the Moda Center, Rose Quarter, and surrounding properties may be one of the largest economic development opportunities Portland will see in a generation.

792
01:23:11.664 --> 01:23:14.984
<v Stephen Green>The question is what we want that investment to leave behind.

793
01:23:15.930 --> 01:23:29.043
<v Stephen Green>Albina Vision Trust has spent the last decade answering that with a vision for housing, education, businesses, public spaces, and opportunities for Black Portlanders to once again build wealth in a place where they lost so much.

794
01:23:30.421 --> 01:23:33.292
<v Stephen Green>And they didn't arrive at it yesterday with a development proposal.

795
01:23:33.725 --> 01:23:40.858
<v Stephen Green>They've spent years building relationships, assembling resources, and earning trust around a vision Portland has already said it supports.

796
01:23:41.819 --> 01:23:43.806
<v Stephen Green>We don't need another plan for Lower Albina.

797
01:23:44.224 --> 01:23:47.077
<v Stephen Green>We need a partner capable of carrying the vision forward.

798
01:23:48.230 --> 01:23:55.091
<v Stephen Green>Leon Smith later on in the speech said Albina is the land of possibilities, not limitations.

799
01:23:56.005 --> 01:24:00.012
<v Stephen Green>This is one of those moments where Portland gets to decide whether we still believe that.

800
01:24:00.717 --> 01:24:04.693
<v Stephen Green>Choose Albina Trust— Albina Vision Trust, and let's carry that vision forward.

801
01:24:04.740 --> 01:24:04.885
<v Stephen Green>Thank you.

802
01:24:05.127 --> 01:24:05.432
<v Stephen Green>Thank you.

803
01:24:06.673 --> 01:24:07.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

804
01:24:08.108 --> 01:24:11.315
<v Ed Washington>Greens, greens.

805
01:24:12.702 --> 01:24:15.096
<v Laquita Lanford>Good afternoon, council and community.

806
01:24:15.289 --> 01:24:26.673
<v Laquita Lanford>My name is Laquita Lanford, and I am very honored today to be sitting here in this space exactly, and especially with these, with all of our community and with this group right here.

807
01:24:26.804 --> 01:24:33.204
<v Laquita Lanford>Like everyone in this room, I'm the new kid on the block, but I've also been in Portland for about 25 years.

808
01:24:33.333 --> 01:24:42.940
<v Laquita Lanford>I left and I came back to a city that had changed changed very much in the 10 years that I was gone from Portland, from 2005 until 2014.

809
01:24:43.438 --> 01:24:53.921
<v Laquita Lanford>I am the founder and executive director of Afro Village at PDX, and I'm here today because I believe in the restoration of Albina and the opportunity before our city.

810
01:24:54.578 --> 01:24:57.929
<v Laquita Lanford>I believe in the work that Albina Vision Trust has been doing.

811
01:24:58.282 --> 01:25:04.917
<v Laquita Lanford>Wynter has been such an amazing young leader and a sister to follow.

812
01:25:05.078 --> 01:25:10.448
<v Laquita Lanford>And when I had my own issues and conversations We have conversations around our housing crisis.

813
01:25:10.945 --> 01:25:20.083
<v Laquita Lanford>Wynton and I, when she was the policy advisor for Chloe Eudaly, would sit and walk and talk about today, a moment like today.

814
01:25:21.350 --> 01:25:30.712
<v Laquita Lanford>I believe in the restoration what urban renewal, displacement, and public policy took away from Portland's Black community.

815
01:25:31.050 --> 01:25:33.278
<v Laquita Lanford>But restoration must be more than development.

816
01:25:33.534 --> 01:25:47.024
<v Laquita Lanford>As Portland makes major policy, major public investments in the future of Lower Albina, we must we must be intentional about who has access to the economic opportunities those invested— those investments create.

817
01:25:47.587 --> 01:26:01.756
<v Laquita Lanford>That means Black contractors, Black-owned businesses, worker entrepreneurs, young people, community-based organizations like Afro Village should have a real pathway in participation, not to discuss after it had— decisions have already been made.

818
01:26:02.270 --> 01:26:05.238
<v Laquita Lanford>I wanted to ask myself this question, and I did yesterday.

819
01:26:07.019 --> 01:26:10.188
<v Laquita Lanford>What would it look like in 20 years from now?

820
01:26:11.201 --> 01:26:14.595
<v Laquita Lanford>What will Black Portland own because of this investment?

821
01:26:14.980 --> 01:26:19.761
<v Laquita Lanford>Not just what we build, what receive— who will receive contracts?

822
01:26:20.132 --> 01:26:21.323
<v Laquita Lanford>Who will start businesses?

823
01:26:21.436 --> 01:26:23.176
<v Laquita Lanford>Who will build careers?

824
01:26:23.529 --> 01:26:26.966
<v Laquita Lanford>And who will gain property in the Lower Albina District?

825
01:26:28.789 --> 01:26:46.131
<v Laquita Lanford>I currently have an investment of $1.9 million, and we're under construction right now at 1701 North Larrabee, and I'm I'm happy and I'm proud to be one of the first developers in the Lower Albina District, and I am in all support of this resolution for the Albina Vision Trust.

826
01:26:46.532 --> 01:26:59.810
<v Laquita Lanford>And I say big up to what it is that we do and to continue to, uh, support all of these individuals in this space because we have championed, uh, for so long, uh, what has been a displacement and disparity in Black Portland.

827
01:26:59.859 --> 01:27:01.046
<v Laquita Lanford>So thank you guys very much.

828
01:27:01.385 --> 01:27:01.625
<v Laquita Lanford>Peace.

829
01:27:02.091 --> 01:27:02.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

830
01:27:05.140 --> 01:27:05.927
<v JT Flowers>Good afternoon.

831
01:27:06.039 --> 01:27:06.858
<v JT Flowers>My name is J.T.

832
01:27:06.922 --> 01:27:13.470
<v JT Flowers>Flowers, and this is the first time in a very long time that I'm not officially representing the Albina Vision Trust in any type of capacity.

833
01:27:13.519 --> 01:27:15.444
<v JT Flowers>So please bear with me on timing here.

834
01:27:16.873 --> 01:27:26.632
<v JT Flowers>When I started working for the incomparable Wynter Johannes at the Albina Vision Trust as our second full-time employee, we did not have a single square foot of land to our name.

835
01:27:27.291 --> 01:27:41.788
<v JT Flowers>As an organization birthed of a multigenerational effort to reposition Black folks working folks and historically displaced folks as agents in the lives they live and owners of the soil beneath their toes, we didn't actually own a thing.

836
01:27:42.686 --> 01:27:54.215
<v JT Flowers>This history of dispossession, of lack, of going without, of forced impermanence is a legacy our city has chosen for Black people.

837
01:27:54.262 --> 01:27:54.567
<v JT Flowers>Mm-hmm.

838
01:27:54.728 --> 01:28:03.403
<v JT Flowers>For it was folks who sat in these very seats who made the decision to carve up our neighborhood and parcel it off to the highest bidder.

839
01:28:04.029 --> 01:28:16.353
<v JT Flowers>It was voters who approved public bonds to build highways and sports arenas on top of our businesses, our homes, our churches, and our places of sacred safety.

840
01:28:16.930 --> 01:28:39.488
<v JT Flowers>It was planners who said, we know best, while slamming doors in our faces and using blight as a scythe to hack our legs from out underneath us, to scatter us like vermin to the furthest reaches of our city and convince us that our collective future was somebody else's to define and ours to unwittingly live out.

841
01:28:40.208 --> 01:29:06.550
<v JT Flowers>We are here today because we reject that premise, because we know that together we have everything we need to make ourselves, our city, and our collective spirit whole, because we believe that every working-class neighborhood can and should also be a world-class neighborhood, and because we are born, as Mr. Broadus and Mr. Collis just said, from a legacy of builders.

842
01:29:07.207 --> 01:29:22.011
<v JT Flowers>We stand before you today as a movement of wayward villagers who have poured 70 years into building a trusted community-led institution that understands what it means to actually execute on a vision.

843
01:29:22.587 --> 01:29:31.657
<v JT Flowers>As an entity that has brought $850 million in direct investment to our neighborhood and to our city.

844
01:29:32.283 --> 01:29:43.408
<v JT Flowers>As an effort that is now nationally recognized as the largest community-led development, not just in the city of Portland, but in the United States of America.

845
01:29:43.536 --> 01:29:43.840
<v JT Flowers>Mm-hmm.

846
01:29:43.984 --> 01:29:54.997
<v JT Flowers>The Albina Vision Trust was founded to crack open and fundamentally redefine our relationship with the land, with the world, and with one another.

847
01:29:55.606 --> 01:30:02.833
<v JT Flowers>As an effort to lead a people towards possibility, towards power, and towards political agency.

848
01:30:03.412 --> 01:30:09.738
<v JT Flowers>We are here to move our children and their children after them closer to a tomorrow unburdened.

849
01:30:09.979 --> 01:30:11.393
<v JT Flowers>I gotta wrap my time up.

850
01:30:12.067 --> 01:30:14.105
<v JT Flowers>Okay, thank you so much.

851
01:30:14.171 --> 01:30:16.546
<v JT Flowers>Well, let me just chop all of this down.

852
01:30:16.836 --> 01:30:19.838
<v JT Flowers>I'll say this really quickly if you'll give me 30 more seconds.

853
01:30:20.193 --> 01:30:22.585
<v JT Flowers>The Albina Vision Trust was founded as a freedom dream.

854
01:30:23.065 --> 01:30:40.127
<v JT Flowers>Freedom looks like many things, but today it manifests itself simply as a decision sitting on your desk while a village of your neighbors look on to see how this group of 12 citizens will choose to etch your names into the history books.

855
01:30:40.577 --> 01:30:45.452
<v JT Flowers>So yes, of course, we are here today to urge your wholehearted support for this resolution.

856
01:30:46.012 --> 01:30:53.998
<v JT Flowers>But more so, we are here to remind you that this building, that this neighborhood is situated in a community.

857
01:30:54.078 --> 01:30:54.175
<v JT Flowers>Thank you.

858
01:30:54.655 --> 01:31:08.243
<v JT Flowers>That this community is ours to rebuild, that this partnership is about reimagining what power looks like, and that power reimagined can transform who benefits from what we build and how we build it.

859
01:31:08.805 --> 01:31:11.230
<v JT Flowers>Thank you so much, and I'm sorry for going so far over my time.

860
01:31:11.279 --> 01:31:12.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

861
01:31:13.126 --> 01:31:13.864
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

862
01:31:13.929 --> 01:31:17.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I was, I was not going to be the one to stop Mr.

863
01:31:17.398 --> 01:31:25.791
<v Jamie Dunphy>Flowers from cooking, but I will remind all right, folks, we do unfortunately have so many people to testify, we can try to stick to 2 minutes, but that was pretty great.

864
01:31:27.637 --> 01:31:37.715
<v Keelan McClymont>So next up we have Raina Casey, Kimberly Horner, Santina Juarez, Fawn Aberson, Ed Washington.

865
01:31:46.301 --> 01:31:49.367
<v Jamie Dunphy>Reina, you're online if you want to go.

866
01:31:49.591 --> 01:31:52.480
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're waiting for folks to get to the testimony table down here.

867
01:31:52.962 --> 01:32:02.430
<v Andrea Bon Temps>Yes, my name is Reina Casey, uh, common spelling starts with a C, and I am not coming to testify as a business owner.

868
01:32:02.832 --> 01:32:21.427
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I'm coming to testify as a community member and a community leader to endorse this, um, move for Albina Vision Trust I have seen the work that they have done in Lower Albina, and not just Lower Albina, but all the way across the community, and it's been nothing but enlightening.

869
01:32:21.541 --> 01:32:28.118
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I ask that you guys please endorse this and you go ahead and you push this through, because it's not— because it's needed.

870
01:32:28.279 --> 01:32:32.773
<v Andrea Bon Temps>It's needed for Portland, it's needed for Black Portland, and it's needed for the future of Portland.

871
01:32:34.694 --> 01:32:35.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

872
01:32:42.384 --> 01:32:43.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect timing.

873
01:32:43.537 --> 01:32:44.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on down.

874
01:32:47.600 --> 01:32:47.823
<v Andrea Bon Temps>Welcome.

875
01:32:49.688 --> 01:32:50.057
<v Kimberly Horner>Thank you.

876
01:32:51.295 --> 01:32:55.824
<v Kimberly Horner>Good afternoon, Mayor, City Council, and members of the public.

877
01:32:56.291 --> 01:33:02.368
<v Kimberly Horner>My name is Kimberly Horner, and I am the executive director for the Portland Community Reinvestment Initiatives.

878
01:33:02.962 --> 01:33:04.747
<v Kimberly Horner>We go by the acronym PCRI.

879
01:33:06.319 --> 01:33:09.557
<v Kimberly Horner>Our organization has been around since 1991.

880
01:33:10.216 --> 01:33:17.095
<v Kimberly Horner>It was formed as a result of historic discrimination and displacement of Black people in Portland.

881
01:33:17.849 --> 01:33:28.225
<v Kimberly Horner>Our organization has done a lot of work to uplift the Black community and make sure that people have a place to stay in this community and call it home.

882
01:33:28.978 --> 01:33:36.019
<v Kimberly Horner>I am here today to say I support the work that Albina Vision Trust is doing, and they're doing great work.

883
01:33:36.211 --> 01:33:36.354
<v Kimberly Horner>Thank you.

884
01:33:36.612 --> 01:33:40.756
<v Kimberly Horner>And they are wonderful people who are dedicated to this cause.

885
01:33:41.496 --> 01:34:10.061
<v Kimberly Horner>What I would like to say, though, is I would like for the city to make sure that they are still recognizing organizations like PCRI who have been developers in this community and standing shoulder to shoulder with the city in order to keep historically displaced Black people in decent living conditions and providing them with economic opportunity to grow, to grow their families, and to grow their livelihoods.

886
01:34:10.654 --> 01:34:13.427
<v Kimberly Horner>We have a document called Pathway 1000.

887
01:34:14.085 --> 01:34:18.478
<v Kimberly Horner>Our goal is to build 1,000 units in a 10-year time span.

888
01:34:19.390 --> 01:34:21.523
<v Kimberly Horner>We have delivered on those promises.

889
01:34:21.699 --> 01:34:40.063
<v Kimberly Horner>We've built King and Parks, Beatrice Morrow during COVID we are asking simply for the city to reconsider their efforts in delivering land and making sure that there's equitable distribution to the city's assets so that some of us can continue to do this good work.

890
01:34:40.881 --> 01:34:49.201
<v Kimberly Horner>Our organization has given other companies that you've seen come up here earlier today their first contracts.

891
01:34:49.297 --> 01:34:52.573
<v Kimberly Horner>We have uplifted people in economic opportunities.

892
01:34:52.751 --> 01:34:55.224
<v Kimberly Horner>This has nothing to do with them.

893
01:34:55.721 --> 01:35:04.217
<v Kimberly Horner>It has more to do with the city making sure that you are being fair and equitable in your distribution of assets when the time comes.

894
01:35:04.331 --> 01:35:04.426
<v Kimberly Horner>Thank you.

895
01:35:05.041 --> 01:35:12.462
<v Kimberly Horner>We support this, but we say please do not forget the organizations that have been the legacy organizations.

896
01:35:12.819 --> 01:35:14.675
<v Kimberly Horner>And we're here to support the effort.

897
01:35:14.916 --> 01:35:24.060
<v Kimberly Horner>We support Albina Vision Trust, but please recognize the work we do and please don't forget us when opportunity exists.

898
01:35:24.356 --> 01:35:24.966
<v Kimberly Horner>Thank you.

899
01:35:25.444 --> 01:35:26.038
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

900
01:35:27.579 --> 01:35:28.951
<v Fawn Aberson>It's weird that I'm the last person.

901
01:35:29.305 --> 01:35:33.212
<v Fawn Aberson>I didn't mean that to happen, but I will say that my name is Fawn Albertson.

902
01:35:33.324 --> 01:35:33.777
<v Fawn Aberson>I work for Flosson Media.

903
01:35:33.826 --> 01:35:42.757
<v Fawn Aberson>We're a nearly 24-year-old we are a 25-year-old media and marketing agency that has been based in Northeast Portland for its entire existence.

904
01:35:43.623 --> 01:35:54.081
<v Fawn Aberson>It is a Black-owned and operated firm, and we have documented so much historical stuff over that 25 years, especially around North, Northeast Portland.

905
01:35:54.594 --> 01:35:59.389
<v Fawn Aberson>We've been around when the Black Lives Matter movement came along and we covered that.

906
01:35:59.484 --> 01:36:12.167
<v Fawn Aberson>We saw when the Trader Joe's debacle, we call it, and the Portland African American Leadership Forum put a, uh, basically a foot down and said no more, no more displacement.

907
01:36:12.712 --> 01:36:17.921
<v Fawn Aberson>We saw 40 Black organizations come together and meet with the mayor and change that.

908
01:36:18.146 --> 01:36:28.341
<v Fawn Aberson>They did a historic $33 million, uh, re— um, investment into affordable housing, which led to this insane movement that we've seen today.

909
01:36:28.966 --> 01:36:34.833
<v Fawn Aberson>We were around when, uh, Legacy Emanuel met with Dr. Brown and they did that Land Back.

910
01:36:34.978 --> 01:36:42.427
<v Fawn Aberson>We watched 40 organizations come together, and Black organizations, and submit representation.

911
01:36:42.845 --> 01:36:45.832
<v Fawn Aberson>And you can see where that process has unfolded today.

912
01:36:46.072 --> 01:36:51.899
<v Fawn Aberson>Now AVT is doing it again with expanding opportunities for the Rose Quarter.

913
01:36:52.478 --> 01:37:08.354
<v Fawn Aberson>I would just invite you to say that as we begin to expand these opportunities, that we make sure that we're not having any unintended consequences of contraction, because there is a formula that's working here in Northeast Portland.

914
01:37:08.402 --> 01:37:11.323
<v Fawn Aberson>There's a formula that's working for these groups coming together.

915
01:37:11.791 --> 01:37:17.876
<v Fawn Aberson>So your leadership right now will ensure that it stays that formula for successful living.

916
01:37:21.170 --> 01:37:21.814
<v Fawn Aberson>Thank you very much.

917
01:37:26.632 --> 01:37:26.827
<v Fawn Aberson>Good evening.

918
01:37:28.282 --> 01:37:30.092
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, yeah, go ahead.

919
01:37:30.837 --> 01:37:44.658
<v Ed Washington>All right, hi, my name is Ed Washington and I'm an almost lifelong resident of Portland, and I'm here to speak on behalf of this resolution.

920
01:37:46.309 --> 01:37:54.414
<v Ed Washington>This is probably one of the greatest things that's ever happened, not only for the African-American community in Portland but for the city of Portland.

921
01:37:54.976 --> 01:37:59.740
<v Ed Washington>And it's an opportunity that hopefully we will not miss in any way.

922
01:38:01.007 --> 01:38:15.989
<v Ed Washington>Some years ago, I had the opportunity to go to Boston, and I remember going into the Back Bay of Boston, and someone pointed out to me, they said, this used to be the Italian neighborhood until they decided to run— put the first freeway through.

923
01:38:16.952 --> 01:38:20.609
<v Ed Washington>And my family moved here, and we lived in Vanport.

924
01:38:21.270 --> 01:38:34.612
<v Ed Washington>We were there during the floods of 1948, and we were bounced around from 1948 to 1950 before my mother could find a place for the family of 6.

925
01:38:35.564 --> 01:38:54.810
<v Ed Washington>And I think that as I've had the opportunity to get to know what the— this organization is doing, please do not this is an organization that knows what it's doing.

926
01:38:55.551 --> 01:38:58.345
<v Ed Washington>They know how to do it, and they will do it well.

927
01:38:59.189 --> 01:39:04.305
<v Ed Washington>And Portland, don't mess this one up.

928
01:39:04.889 --> 01:39:05.667
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you very much.

929
01:39:07.203 --> 01:39:07.783
<v Jamie Dunphy>Heard.

930
01:39:07.831 --> 01:39:08.636
<v Ed Washington>That's all I have to say.

931
01:39:09.617 --> 01:39:10.470
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

932
01:39:12.030 --> 01:39:13.735
<v Keelan McClymont>Just a quick comment.

933
01:39:14.363 --> 01:39:17.417
<v Keelan McClymont>Just checking to see if Santino Juarez is here.

934
01:39:22.059 --> 01:39:23.350
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, that completes testimony.

935
01:39:23.640 --> 01:39:24.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you very much.

936
01:39:25.061 --> 01:39:29.712
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we are now into both technical and clarifying questions as well as council discussion.

937
01:39:30.760 --> 01:39:34.122
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, feel free to jump into the queue if anybody wants to say anything.

938
01:39:34.412 --> 01:39:35.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green, kick us off.

939
01:39:36.896 --> 01:39:37.546
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

940
01:39:37.644 --> 01:39:39.608
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you to everyone who provided testimony.

941
01:39:39.672 --> 01:39:40.858
<v Mitch Green>That was extremely moving.

942
01:39:41.546 --> 01:39:46.119
<v Mitch Green>And before I ask my questions, I just want to say wholeheartedly, I am 100% on board.

943
01:39:46.393 --> 01:39:47.551
<v Mitch Green>I can't wait to vote yes on this.

944
01:39:48.640 --> 01:40:06.725
<v Mitch Green>But the thing I want to make sure I understand is in the resolution at the very end, it says, be it further resolved, the binding agreement shall return to City Council for consideration on a concurrent timeline as long as the long-term lease for the Moda Center and for a period to not exceed 12 months.

945
01:40:06.993 --> 01:40:07.162
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

946
01:40:08.394 --> 01:40:21.787
<v Mitch Green>I guess what I want to know is, as we go down this road, are we committed to being, you know, exploring this development partnership relation even if other things related to the Motor Center get sideways?

947
01:40:22.500 --> 01:40:24.096
<v Mitch Green>Because I would like that to be the case.

948
01:40:24.710 --> 01:40:24.952
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

949
01:40:25.420 --> 01:40:28.259
<v Sameer Kanal>And we see that as the case as well, Councilor.

950
01:40:28.404 --> 01:40:43.020
<v Sameer Kanal>We don't see anything happen on this site that would change this agreement from the standpoint of our willingness to work with AVT and having a partnership with ATV with the development of this property.

951
01:40:43.613 --> 01:40:54.894
<v Sameer Kanal>We know whatever happens with Motor can change some of the dynamics of the money that's associated with the site that'll be developed there, but we have a commitment to do that with AVT.

952
01:40:55.935 --> 01:40:56.399
<v Mitch Green>Thanks so much.

953
01:40:56.496 --> 01:40:59.828
<v Mitch Green>And I just want to acknowledge— thanks for acknowledging that.

954
01:40:59.957 --> 01:41:09.462
<v Mitch Green>And I just want to sort of lift up a lot of what I heard, which was there are always going to be distributional winners and losers when you do development work in the city of Portland.

955
01:41:09.510 --> 01:41:13.815
<v Mitch Green>And we have put our thumb on the scale in the past that has harmed Black Portlanders.

956
01:41:14.490 --> 01:41:25.192
<v Mitch Green>And so I want to thank the sponsors of this resolution for saying we have an opportunity to put our thumb on the scale in a different way and, you know, provide some opportunity here.

957
01:41:25.256 --> 01:41:26.140
<v Mitch Green>And that's how I see it.

958
01:41:27.345 --> 01:41:28.567
<v Mitch Green>These are public lands.

959
01:41:30.219 --> 01:41:37.378
<v Mitch Green>This is a partner who has been, I think, a good faith steward, I think is the best way to put it.

960
01:41:37.426 --> 01:41:39.143
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm supportive.

961
01:41:39.449 --> 01:41:39.869
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

962
01:41:40.516 --> 01:41:41.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

963
01:41:41.729 --> 01:41:42.278
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

964
01:41:42.795 --> 01:41:44.832
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

965
01:41:45.591 --> 01:41:49.136
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you so much to everybody who came and delivered such a beautiful testimony today.

966
01:41:49.360 --> 01:41:51.921
<v Angelita Morillo>It's really a privilege to get to hear from all of you.

967
01:41:52.743 --> 01:41:56.092
<v Angelita Morillo>And I want to give special thanks to Winta.

968
01:41:57.962 --> 01:42:11.699
<v Angelita Morillo>Because Wynta and I know each other from my first day at City Hall when I was doing constituent services a few years ago, and I knew absolutely nothing about how City Hall worked before I stepped into this place.

969
01:42:11.859 --> 01:42:15.282
<v Angelita Morillo>I come from, you know, my mom's, uh, she was a single mother.

970
01:42:15.652 --> 01:42:16.390
<v Angelita Morillo>We're immigrants.

971
01:42:16.519 --> 01:42:23.411
<v Angelita Morillo>We aren't normally invited into this space and understand how to navigate it, and I didn't know anyone in the building, and it was very Intimidating.

972
01:42:23.925 --> 01:42:35.351
<v Angelita Morillo>And Wynta was the first person who came to say hello to me, and she gave me all the tools that she had developed doing constituent work and just showed me the ropes about what it was like to be in City Hall.

973
01:42:36.027 --> 01:42:41.724
<v Angelita Morillo>And she had no reason to do that, to come and help someone new who wasn't in her office, but that's how she approaches the work.

974
01:42:41.805 --> 01:42:47.293
<v Angelita Morillo>And she always engages people, uh, no matter who they are or where they come from or their perspective.

975
01:42:47.358 --> 01:42:49.572
<v Angelita Morillo>She just does it with such wisdom and grace.

976
01:42:50.390 --> 01:42:54.867
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm very grateful for everything that AVT has done in the community.

977
01:42:55.685 --> 01:43:10.268
<v Angelita Morillo>We had a really great conversation about the development and housing projects that AVT has already worked on, the fact that the vast majority of people that are housed in those spaces are single mothers, and how significant and important that is.

978
01:43:10.460 --> 01:43:14.149
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's exactly the type of thing that I really value and care about.

979
01:43:15.015 --> 01:43:17.998
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm just very grateful for everyone coming here today and talking about it.

980
01:43:18.064 --> 01:43:25.472
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm really excited to vote yes on this, and I hope that you guys have a big celebration in chambers, outside of chambers, wherever.

981
01:43:25.680 --> 01:43:30.587
<v Angelita Morillo>I wish we could step out and skip the rest of the meeting and join, but we got other important topics.

982
01:43:30.733 --> 01:43:34.068
<v Angelita Morillo>And so yeah, thank you so much and appreciate you.

983
01:43:34.261 --> 01:43:35.030
<v Angelita Morillo>I am excited to vote yes.

984
01:43:35.543 --> 01:43:36.666
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

985
01:43:37.805 --> 01:43:39.697
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor— oh, jumping around in the queue there, y'all.

986
01:43:40.050 --> 01:43:40.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

987
01:43:43.091 --> 01:43:56.867
<v Steve Novick>Uh, I just, I wanted to thank WINTA and ABC for the tour they gave me of the area a few weeks ago, and also to thank you for giving us something to feel good about today before we get into the Keller-PSU knife fight that's going to follow.

988
01:43:59.976 --> 01:44:00.818
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

989
01:44:00.865 --> 01:44:02.014
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

990
01:44:03.613 --> 01:44:05.505
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thanks everybody for being here.

991
01:44:05.569 --> 01:44:06.829
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to all the testifiers.

992
01:44:07.492 --> 01:44:24.788
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, next time any of y'all hear that there's no Black Portland or Black Portlanders, um, just, uh, remember that, you know, if you look and if you have reasons to bring people out, um, for issues that matter to them, people show up in this space.

993
01:44:24.885 --> 01:44:26.426
<v Sameer Kanal>It's more for the city employee side.

994
01:44:27.020 --> 01:44:36.909
<v Sameer Kanal>And also, thank you for the reminders of the legacy of why there are fewer Black Portlanders than there used to be, and, and the reminders throughout that of the history of the city and of specifically Albina.

995
01:44:37.856 --> 01:44:50.829
<v Sameer Kanal>I've been really— I think many of us get emotional when we think about the history of this, in particular our individual relationships with Winta actually, and with JT and so many of the other folks who've been involved and are involved as well.

996
01:44:51.680 --> 01:45:02.565
<v Sameer Kanal>I did want to just make one point because I made my main argument earlier, and it's kind of piggybacking off of something that Councilor Green mentioned with relation to distributional winners and losers.

997
01:45:02.679 --> 01:45:03.385
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

998
01:45:03.529 --> 01:45:03.930
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Dan Ryan.

999
01:45:04.042 --> 01:45:17.628
<v Sameer Kanal>In the history of this country, city after city, county after county, state after state, and certainly at the national level, we've seen government attempt to divide communities of color against themselves through both intentional and unintentional actions that create 2 things.

1000
01:45:17.805 --> 01:45:20.112
<v Sameer Kanal>First, scarcity, and then competition.

1001
01:45:20.849 --> 01:45:22.738
<v Sameer Kanal>Which Latino group is going to speak for Latinos?

1002
01:45:22.787 --> 01:45:26.359
<v Sameer Kanal>Which Asian American group is going to get the funding to run the only museum in town?

1003
01:45:26.697 --> 01:45:29.581
<v Sameer Kanal>Which immigrants are going to get to speak at that one event for it?

1004
01:45:29.900 --> 01:45:33.088
<v Sameer Kanal>Which Black-led organizations are going to get the only money that we award?

1005
01:45:33.764 --> 01:45:36.542
<v Sameer Kanal>And the way out of that is to stop doing the only.

1006
01:45:37.056 --> 01:45:41.603
<v Sameer Kanal>The way out of that is to get rid of the scarcity and to stop making it where there can only be one.

1007
01:45:42.261 --> 01:46:05.618
<v Sameer Kanal>And so what I'm really excited about, given that no organization speaks for any community as a whole and that this is not the only opportunity— in fact, it's not the only opportunity we've taken so far at this council to partner with organizations that are rooted in Black communities in Portland— is to get away from that scarcity and say that anybody here with a vision can win.

1008
01:46:06.132 --> 01:46:10.488
<v Sameer Kanal>Anybody here can benefit as long as you are serving the community as AVT is.

1009
01:46:10.873 --> 01:46:18.698
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciate that we're talking not only about the organization Albina Vision Trust, but we're talking about the Albina vision and about the trust we can create here.

1010
01:46:19.310 --> 01:46:21.511
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that, thank you so much, and I encourage everyone to vote yes.

1011
01:46:22.684 --> 01:46:23.568
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1012
01:46:23.970 --> 01:46:24.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1013
01:46:28.988 --> 01:46:30.304
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. President.

1014
01:46:34.546 --> 01:46:42.935
<v Loretta Smith>I've been thinking about this for a long time, and I think it's so important that we support this resolution.

1015
01:46:44.310 --> 01:47:05.893
<v Loretta Smith>We support restoring connections, replacing isolated parking lots with a street grid it helps to stitch together neighborhoods that were historically divided, improving walkability and access for residents in Lower Albina.

1016
01:47:07.320 --> 01:47:19.408
<v Loretta Smith>I believe the vision includes plazas, parks, and pedestrian-friendly thoroughfares, and to be able to transform a transit hub into a true community destination.

1017
01:47:20.164 --> 01:47:23.042
<v Loretta Smith>Not just a place to park.

1018
01:47:24.649 --> 01:47:32.387
<v Loretta Smith>If we're going to truly improve transit integration, we need a modern redevelopment.

1019
01:47:33.703 --> 01:47:40.393
<v Loretta Smith>And that modern redevelopment is AVT in partnership with the City of Portland.

1020
01:47:40.993 --> 01:47:41.948
<v Loretta Smith>And I like it.

1021
01:47:43.733 --> 01:47:46.635
<v Loretta Smith>I think that we have endless thank you.

1022
01:47:46.682 --> 01:47:51.387
<v Loretta Smith>This is an enormous opportunity for housing stabilization, housing opportunities.

1023
01:47:51.902 --> 01:48:13.837
<v Loretta Smith>Developing the site, it will create an opportunity to incorporate multifamily housing, including affordable housing units, directly adjacent to high-capacity transit that will support the city's density and equity goals.

1024
01:48:14.460 --> 01:48:14.475
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1025
01:48:15.779 --> 01:48:30.721
<v Loretta Smith>New construction allows for the implementation of the modern green building standards, sustainable stormwater management, and energy-efficient systems that aging infrastructure often lacks.

1026
01:48:31.462 --> 01:48:32.318
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm excited.

1027
01:48:33.787 --> 01:48:51.003
<v Loretta Smith>I'm excited about reducing urban heat islands, transitioning from vast expanses of asphalt parking to landscaped urban environment significantly reduces the heat island effect, and it improves local air quality.

1028
01:48:51.756 --> 01:48:55.011
<v Loretta Smith>I have a respiratory problem, so I need great air quality.

1029
01:48:55.764 --> 01:49:01.663
<v Loretta Smith>I need to make sure that we're supporting those projects that produce these kinds of outcomes.

1030
01:49:02.480 --> 01:49:12.644
<v Loretta Smith>And a world-class destination— upgrading the surroundings of the Moda Center, it will elevate the visitor experience in the city of Portland.

1031
01:49:13.301 --> 01:49:19.681
<v Loretta Smith>And matching the quality of the thank you.

1032
01:49:20.649 --> 01:49:31.353
<v Loretta Smith>I want to make sure that we support and spend our public dollars on year-round utilization by creating a lively district.

1033
01:49:32.253 --> 01:49:42.125
<v Loretta Smith>The area becomes a destination of non-event days, ensuring the district remains active, safe, and vibrant throughout the year.

1034
01:49:42.721 --> 01:49:46.765
<v Loretta Smith>Rather than solely during games or during concerts.

1035
01:49:47.690 --> 01:50:01.453
<v Loretta Smith>And with all of that said, Mr. President, I support this project wholeheartedly, and I would like to put a vote to this today as an emergency.

1036
01:50:02.166 --> 01:50:05.029
<v Loretta Smith>If we have 9 votes, let's do it and not come back.

1037
01:50:05.238 --> 01:50:06.043
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a resolution.

1038
01:50:06.204 --> 01:50:06.671
<v Jamie Dunphy>We don't need to—.

1039
01:50:06.671 --> 01:50:07.346
<v Loretta Smith>It's a resolution.

1040
01:50:07.636 --> 01:50:08.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will be voting on this.

1041
01:50:08.296 --> 01:50:09.085
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, well, let's vote on this.

1042
01:50:09.695 --> 01:50:12.372
<v Jamie Dunphy>As soon as, uh, councilors have their say, we're going to a vote and then take a break.

1043
01:50:12.420 --> 01:50:14.583
<v Loretta Smith>All right, all right, all right, I hear you.

1044
01:50:15.000 --> 01:50:15.337
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1045
01:50:15.465 --> 01:50:20.032
<v Loretta Smith>And thank you for, um, for the sponsors, the 3 sponsors in District 2.

1046
01:50:21.474 --> 01:50:24.712
<v Loretta Smith>Many people think I'm the councilor for District 2.

1047
01:50:25.657 --> 01:50:26.506
<v Loretta Smith>I am too, kind of.

1048
01:50:26.635 --> 01:50:29.215
<v Loretta Smith>I'm that ghost councilor that walks around.

1049
01:50:29.823 --> 01:50:38.043
<v Loretta Smith>But I appreciate you all pulling this together and getting the language that makes sense and that's meaningful.

1050
01:50:38.701 --> 01:50:40.769
<v Loretta Smith>And I appreciate all that you have done.

1051
01:50:41.360 --> 01:50:43.317
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, are you on?

1052
01:50:44.166 --> 01:50:45.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>She is, yes.

1053
01:50:45.688 --> 01:50:47.371
<v Angelita Morillo>I am here, Councilor, yes.

1054
01:50:47.851 --> 01:50:56.072
<v Loretta Smith>You know I have much love for you, so thank you so much for getting this together and making sure we had the, the right language.

1055
01:50:56.809 --> 01:51:05.938
<v Loretta Smith>And Councilor Ryan, Councilor Kanal, I'm very proud of you all and the representation that you do in District 2.

1056
01:51:07.319 --> 01:51:16.181
<v Loretta Smith>I have many family members and friends in that district, so I am always looking for opportunities to help uplift District 2.

1057
01:51:16.261 --> 01:51:17.402
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you very much.

1058
01:51:17.530 --> 01:51:31.069
<v Loretta Smith>And thank you, Ms. Winter, for giving us a platform to be able to do something not just like like Lakitha said, not just to survive, but for us to thrive.

1059
01:51:31.488 --> 01:51:35.488
<v Loretta Smith>And this is what's going to happen in this community when we come together.

1060
01:51:35.585 --> 01:51:38.635
<v Loretta Smith>We can thrive in a way that's world-class.

1061
01:51:38.747 --> 01:51:41.394
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you so much for leading this effort.

1062
01:51:42.829 --> 01:51:43.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1063
01:51:43.988 --> 01:51:44.761
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1064
01:51:46.469 --> 01:51:47.451
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1065
01:51:47.693 --> 01:51:50.574
<v Sameer Kanal>Several times this afternoon we heard, I have to follow that.

1066
01:51:52.127 --> 01:51:52.798
<v Sameer Kanal>You were all that good.

1067
01:51:53.065 --> 01:51:53.547
<v Sameer Kanal>You really were.

1068
01:51:53.661 --> 01:51:59.877
<v Sameer Kanal>There were so many moments where your truth, your knowledge, your wisdom, your vision, your passion, your love was spoken.

1069
01:52:00.872 --> 01:52:03.250
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm just delighted to follow up and say yes, of course.

1070
01:52:03.988 --> 01:52:07.024
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Alpine Vision Trust, you continue to live out your name.

1071
01:52:07.682 --> 01:52:08.935
<v Sameer Kanal>You really named yourself well.

1072
01:52:09.627 --> 01:52:20.673
<v Sameer Kanal>The vision that got you here with a steady decade of dialogue and building relationships— I see you, Michael Alexander— and the trust that you've cultivated in that decade.

1073
01:52:21.396 --> 01:52:22.055
<v Sameer Kanal>I see you, Winta.

1074
01:52:23.565 --> 01:52:27.083
<v Sameer Kanal>And I heard you also, all of you today say that enough words, it's time for action.

1075
01:52:27.341 --> 01:52:27.743
<v Sameer Kanal>Let's go.

1076
01:52:28.161 --> 01:52:29.430
<v Sameer Kanal>Let's vote on this and move it along.

1077
01:52:29.789 --> 01:52:30.002
<v Burke Nelson>Thanks.

1078
01:52:31.015 --> 01:52:31.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1079
01:52:32.305 --> 01:52:34.184
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos, last word and we're gonna move to a vote.

1080
01:52:39.162 --> 01:52:40.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, let's see, we can't hear you.

1081
01:52:45.128 --> 01:52:46.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Try muting and just unmuting again.

1082
01:52:46.551 --> 01:52:47.163
<v Jamie Dunphy>Something's going on.

1083
01:52:55.492 --> 01:52:57.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, we can hear it, but it's like fuzzy.

1084
01:52:58.091 --> 01:52:59.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>She's trying.

1085
01:52:59.715 --> 01:53:02.944
<v Loretta Smith>She's good, kind of.

1086
01:53:10.639 --> 01:53:12.578
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I got nothing to say.

1087
01:53:12.981 --> 01:53:13.644
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh wait, no, there you go.

1088
01:53:13.788 --> 01:53:14.113
<v Jamie Dunphy>There we go.

1089
01:53:14.176 --> 01:53:14.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>We got you that time.

1090
01:53:15.243 --> 01:53:16.988
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's lean a little closer to the microphone.

1091
01:53:17.118 --> 01:53:17.796
<v Angelita Morillo>Closer and louder.

1092
01:53:21.201 --> 01:53:23.382
<v Andrea Bon Temps>I'm sorry, so many tech problems today.

1093
01:53:23.770 --> 01:53:25.064
<v Andrea Bon Temps>Totally kills the vibe.

1094
01:53:25.533 --> 01:53:29.269
<v Candace Avalos>Um, thank you again to everybody who, uh, spoke today.

1095
01:53:29.350 --> 01:53:36.724
<v Candace Avalos>What I said was that we had quite a star-studded day in City Hall with so many community leaders, um, coming to support an important project.

1096
01:53:37.417 --> 01:53:43.634
<v Candace Avalos>I want to thank Wynta for your work and in particular for working with me on our amendments.

1097
01:53:43.875 --> 01:53:55.439
<v Candace Avalos>I'm really grateful for getting that passed and feeling really good about the overall— the way that the resolution has landed and securing that we are making this commitment with ABT.

1098
01:53:56.064 --> 01:53:59.326
<v Candace Avalos>We're protecting the city and ABT and the community.

1099
01:53:59.904 --> 01:54:05.011
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm really eager to see what comes back and to help you all enact your vision.

1100
01:54:05.091 --> 01:54:05.349
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1101
01:54:05.559 --> 01:54:07.581
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you for your service and your leadership.

1102
01:54:08.292 --> 01:54:08.908
<v Candace Avalos>Let's get to voting.

1103
01:54:09.814 --> 01:54:10.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1104
01:54:11.512 --> 01:54:13.261
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call the roll on this?

1105
01:54:19.168 --> 01:54:25.954
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, um, calling the roll on document 2026-285.

1106
01:54:26.020 --> 01:54:27.047
<v Keelan McClymont>This is a resolution.

1107
01:54:27.310 --> 01:54:27.871
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

1108
01:54:29.302 --> 01:54:30.042
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Proud to vote aye.

1109
01:54:32.149 --> 01:54:32.198
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1110
01:54:34.655 --> 01:54:34.704
<v John Washington>Aye.

1111
01:54:36.515 --> 01:54:36.564
<v Ed Washington>Aye.

1112
01:54:37.099 --> 01:54:37.309
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

1113
01:54:37.810 --> 01:54:37.971
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1114
01:54:38.457 --> 01:54:38.845
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

1115
01:54:39.104 --> 01:54:39.265
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1116
01:54:40.171 --> 01:54:43.121
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

1117
01:54:43.217 --> 01:54:43.636
<v Jamie Dunphy>That was an aye.

1118
01:54:43.943 --> 01:54:43.990
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1119
01:54:45.247 --> 01:54:45.618
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

1120
01:54:46.844 --> 01:54:46.957
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1121
01:54:48.439 --> 01:54:49.050
<v Keelan McClymont>Canell.

1122
01:54:49.194 --> 01:54:49.226
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1123
01:54:49.837 --> 01:54:50.287
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

1124
01:54:51.588 --> 01:54:51.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1125
01:54:52.713 --> 01:54:53.019
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

1126
01:54:53.436 --> 01:54:53.516
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1127
01:54:54.256 --> 01:54:54.626
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

1128
01:54:55.043 --> 01:54:55.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>Congratulations.

1129
01:54:55.846 --> 01:54:55.863
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1130
01:54:56.586 --> 01:54:59.657
<v Keelan McClymont>The resolution is adopted with a vote of 12 ayes.

1131
01:55:00.555 --> 01:55:01.283
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

1132
01:55:01.605 --> 01:55:03.497
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, the time is currently 3:50.

1133
01:55:03.546 --> 01:55:10.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to give us until 4:00 to come back for, uh, at which point we will take up the Keller item, uh, the performing arts venue item.

1134
01:55:10.662 --> 01:55:15.257
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will not— we will certainly not make it to the Zenith item today, and that will be continued to a future hearing.

1135
01:55:15.680 --> 01:55:15.907
<v Lakeitha Elliott>Thank you.

1136
01:55:16.118 --> 01:55:16.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>See you in 10 minutes.

1137
01:55:19.481 --> 01:55:22.902
<v JT Flowers>Thank you.

1138
02:10:22.931 --> 02:10:24.101
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm calling us back to order.

1139
02:10:24.167 --> 02:10:26.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for your patience while we experience a little bit of humanity.

1140
02:10:28.239 --> 02:10:29.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, can we please call item number 9, Keelan?

1141
02:10:31.413 --> 02:10:45.368
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-270, Accept the Future of Large-Scale Performing Arts, Recommendations to Advance a New Broadway-Capable Venue as Part of the Proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center at Portland State University.

1142
02:10:48.359 --> 02:10:51.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1143
02:10:51.229 --> 02:10:53.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is a resolution.

1144
02:10:53.670 --> 02:10:57.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Christopher Hare from Council Operations is here with a committee staff summary report.

1145
02:10:57.250 --> 02:10:58.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, Christopher.

1146
02:10:58.670 --> 02:11:00.550
<v Christopher Hare>Good afternoon, Council President, Councilors.

1147
02:11:00.550 --> 02:11:08.390
<v Christopher Hare>For the record, my name is Christopher Hare, and I'm reading on behalf of Kevin Alvarez, who serves as staff to the City Life Committee and prepared this committee staff summary.

1148
02:11:08.710 --> 02:11:16.170
<v Christopher Hare>The resolution before you, document number 2026-270, was first heard in the City Life Committee on July 28th, 2026, and again on August 11th, where it was approved unanimously.

1149
02:11:18.181 --> 02:11:19.929
<v Christopher Hare>Yes.

1150
02:11:21.387 --> 02:11:37.962
<v Christopher Hare>This resolution accepts the recommendations of the city's future of large-scale performing arts work and supports advancing planning and pre-development for a potential new city-owned, approximately 3,000-seat Broadway-capable venue as part of the proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center at Portland State University, PSU.

1151
02:11:38.860 --> 02:11:57.215
<v Christopher Hare>The resolution directs the Deputy City Administrator to stand up a staff project team of technical experts with PSU to complete pre-development functions, including a detailed financial plan with a fully defined capital stack and a comprehensive philanthropic strategy and a project commitment agreement with PSU by December 1st, 2026.

1152
02:11:57.667 --> 02:12:13.170
<v Christopher Hare>As amended in committee, the resolution does not authorize, appropriate, or commit city funds for development or construction beyond funding previously authorized by City Council and requires the Deputy City Administrator to return to council with a detailed financial plan before executing any agreement that financially obligates the city.

1153
02:12:15.307 --> 02:12:19.724
<v Christopher Hare>4 Amendments were approved in the City Life Committee on August 11th, the full effects of which can be read online.

1154
02:12:21.192 --> 02:12:22.604
<v Christopher Hare>In the posted committee staff summary.

1155
02:12:23.279 --> 02:12:34.158
<v Christopher Hare>The full impact statements on this item includes financial and budgetary impacts, economic and real estate development impacts, community impacts and community involvement, 100% renewable goals, and economic and real estate development analysis.

1156
02:12:35.154 --> 02:12:40.738
<v Christopher Hare>53 People provided verbal testimony in committee on July 28th, and 68 submitted written testimony prior to committee action.

1157
02:12:41.237 --> 02:12:58.757
<v Christopher Hare>General themes of testimony included divided testimony on whether the city should commit to the project before a vetted budget, capital stack, and financial plan exists, with opponents citing deferred maintenance, at Portland's 5 venues and recent budget reductions and supporters seeing that the public commitment is what unlocks philanthropic and private investments.

1158
02:12:58.822 --> 02:13:13.067
<v Christopher Hare>Conditions of the Keller Auditorium with supporters describing seismic, acoustic, sightline accessibility, and backstage deficiencies that renovation would not resolve, and opponents describing the revenue as operational and revenue generating and renovations as less expensive and more environmentally sound course.

1159
02:13:13.820 --> 02:13:21.729
<v Christopher Hare>Interest in avoiding a prolonged closure of the Keller with ArtsWork and Ayatze Local 28 members supporting construction of a new venue before renovation.

1160
02:13:22.407 --> 02:13:24.186
<v Christopher Hare>To preserve touring revenue and employment.

1161
02:13:24.591 --> 02:13:39.993
<v Christopher Hare>Issues of location and partnership with supporters citing PSU's land development experience and educational role alongside downtown revitalization benefits, revitalization benefits, and opponents citing the university's own financial conditions and the effects on hotels, restaurants, and businesses near the existing site.

1162
02:13:40.583 --> 02:13:41.929
<v Christopher Hare>That concludes the committee staff summary.

1163
02:13:41.978 --> 02:13:42.305
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

1164
02:13:43.192 --> 02:13:43.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1165
02:13:46.738 --> 02:13:48.417
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, this came out of your committee.

1166
02:13:48.609 --> 02:13:49.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any opening remarks?

1167
02:13:51.677 --> 02:13:52.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It did, colleagues.

1168
02:13:52.975 --> 02:14:05.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This resolution came out of the Future of Large-Scale Performing Arts Ex officio table, which was convened by the mayor as part of the effort to help us determine what the future of our venues in our city should look like.

1169
02:14:05.539 --> 02:14:15.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The mayor invited stakeholders from across the performing arts ecosystem to provide guidance to the city as we consider the future of the Keller Auditorium and the potential.

1170
02:14:18.210 --> 02:14:32.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Broadly speaking, the group recommendation from this table was to advance the PSU Performing Arts Center and to maintain programming at the Keller to avoid economic disruption as development is undertaken, as Christopher Hare noted.

1171
02:14:32.600 --> 02:14:41.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was also recommended that concurrently planning for Keller's future should be initiated to allow for construction to begin there following the opening of a PSU venue.

1172
02:14:41.199 --> 02:14:41.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator Nancy Thorington.

1173
02:14:41.582 --> 02:14:44.472
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those 2 things are both captured in the resolution before us today.

1174
02:14:45.516 --> 02:15:00.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The resolution was heard over 2 meetings to ensure that we had sufficient time to hear from a significant number of testifiers and to do the work of deliberation and adoption of amendments, as was noted in the committee staff summary.

1175
02:15:01.412 --> 02:15:06.487
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to thank Councilors Zimmerman and Avalos for bringing amendments forward.

1176
02:15:06.935 --> 02:15:11.849
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Clark, who does not sit on the City Life Committee but sponsored one of those amendments.

1177
02:15:12.251 --> 02:15:28.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There was a significant amount of work and engagement done in committee, and though the recommendations that came forward were not unanimous, I think that we worked hard to capture both the majority recommendation and some of the concerns that were raised in the item that you have before you today.

1178
02:15:29.175 --> 02:15:34.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Making sure I didn't miss anything here.

1179
02:15:34.087 --> 02:15:35.984
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize, Council President.

1180
02:15:36.802 --> 02:15:41.154
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would note that the vote came out of committee on a 4 to 1 vote.

1181
02:15:41.797 --> 02:15:47.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as we move forward, if there are questions about the amendments or the work done, I'm happy to answer them.

1182
02:15:47.113 --> 02:15:52.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know my fellow committee members can as well, but we seek your support today in moving this forward.

1183
02:15:53.362 --> 02:16:08.360
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a resolution which ultimately at the end of the day is directing the administration To start conversations, to take the next step, and to see what is possible in advancing the recommendations that came out of the convenings that the mayor pulled together.

1184
02:16:09.082 --> 02:16:13.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'd like to see that work move forward, and we hope we have the full council support in that today.

1185
02:16:13.515 --> 02:16:14.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1186
02:16:14.960 --> 02:16:15.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1187
02:16:16.163 --> 02:16:17.945
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, there are 53 people signed up.

1188
02:16:17.994 --> 02:16:21.012
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's nice that all 53 who testified at committee signed up again.

1189
02:16:21.158 --> 02:16:23.036
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's good to see you again.

1190
02:16:24.015 --> 02:16:29.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>And also, I will note that it is 4:15 right now, and we are technically scheduled here until 5:00.

1191
02:16:29.225 --> 02:16:35.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is my priority to hear testimony of everybody who is here, so I have asked staff to prepare to be here as late as 6:00.

1192
02:16:35.876 --> 02:16:37.832
<v Jamie Dunphy>6:00 Will be my absolute drop-dead time.

1193
02:16:37.879 --> 02:16:40.268
<v Jamie Dunphy>If we can't get through it, sorry, that's the end of our testimony.

1194
02:16:40.363 --> 02:16:41.823
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will not get to council discussion today.

1195
02:16:41.903 --> 02:16:46.343
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will not get to a final vote today, and we will not be getting to the following item.

1196
02:16:47.015 --> 02:16:48.522
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I want to hear all of your voices.

1197
02:16:48.619 --> 02:16:52.081
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we will hold our technical clarifying questions and council discussion for later.

1198
02:16:52.225 --> 02:16:54.945
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Keelan, can we please call our first panel of testifiers?

1199
02:16:56.690 --> 02:16:56.882
<v Keelan McClymont>Yep.

1200
02:16:57.592 --> 02:17:00.752
<v Keelan McClymont>And I will just give a very quick reminder.

1201
02:17:01.091 --> 02:17:03.235
<v Keelan McClymont>I'll call up testifiers in groups of 5.

1202
02:17:03.397 --> 02:17:05.799
<v Keelan McClymont>Each individual will have 90 seconds.

1203
02:17:06.290 --> 02:17:11.575
<v Keelan McClymont>For those testifying in person, you'll see the timer countdown displayed on the monitor in front of the testimony table.

1204
02:17:11.623 --> 02:17:14.531
<v Keelan McClymont>For those testifying virtually, the timer is displayed in Zoom.

1205
02:17:15.222 --> 02:17:21.076
<v Keelan McClymont>You will hear the timer sound twice, once when there are 30 seconds left then a second time when your time is up.

1206
02:17:21.702 --> 02:17:24.977
<v Keelan McClymont>Before you begin your testimony, please state your name for the record.

1207
02:17:26.117 --> 02:17:37.512
<v Keelan McClymont>Our first panel of testifiers includes Anne Cudd, Duke Castle, Sarah Schwartz, AJ Romero-Gemmel, and Julie Vigeland.

1208
02:17:38.796 --> 02:17:40.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on down, folks, and welcome.

1209
02:17:41.058 --> 02:17:42.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>Feel free to jump in.

1210
02:17:42.423 --> 02:17:43.001
<v Jamie Dunphy>President Cudd.

1211
02:17:43.386 --> 02:17:43.851
<v Anne Cudd>Thank you.

1212
02:17:44.429 --> 02:17:44.959
<v Anne Cudd>Good afternoon.

1213
02:17:45.376 --> 02:17:50.939
<v Anne Cudd>Council President Dunphy, Council Vice President Clark, and members of Portland City Council.

1214
02:17:51.308 --> 02:17:57.064
<v Anne Cudd>For the record, my name is Anne Cudd, and I proudly serve as president of Portland State University.

1215
02:17:57.800 --> 02:18:04.534
<v Anne Cudd>I'm pleased to testify in support of the resolution to advance a new Broadway-capable venue on the PSU campus.

1216
02:18:05.737 --> 02:18:21.765
<v Anne Cudd>In 2023, as I was just assuming my presidency, PSU responded to a city request to submit a proposal in, in a public process exploring an alternative location for the city's Broadway-capable auditorium.

1217
02:18:23.162 --> 02:18:25.747
<v Anne Cudd>We are a willing and enthusiastic partner.

1218
02:18:26.212 --> 02:18:36.488
<v Anne Cudd>We are here to serve students and the university's signature performing arts programs, to serve the city, and to benefit Portland's arts ecosystem.

1219
02:18:37.596 --> 02:18:43.789
<v Anne Cudd>We are here also because we know that our city, community, and campus have a bright future.

1220
02:18:44.975 --> 02:18:53.102
<v Anne Cudd>We see opportunity with this resolution to generate a deeper, broader, inclusively dynamic vision for downtown Portland.

1221
02:18:54.272 --> 02:19:01.599
<v Anne Cudd>We envision a thriving Halperin sequence filled with storefronts, restaurants, and most importantly, people.

1222
02:19:02.463 --> 02:19:09.406
<v Anne Cudd>As a public university, we are operating from a position of mission, and vision, not as a bottom-line corporation.

1223
02:19:10.225 --> 02:19:21.820
<v Anne Cudd>As you know, we've also done our homework and we bring resources to the table, including the largest developable piece of property downtown and bond financing, philanthropy financing, and more.

1224
02:19:22.832 --> 02:19:31.460
<v Anne Cudd>We're excited about this resolution because at PSU, we always see ourselves as a partner in tackling the big issues facing our city.

1225
02:19:32.199 --> 02:19:34.668
<v Anne Cudd>Figuring out the financing for this project is no different.

1226
02:19:34.733 --> 02:19:34.908
<v Anne Cudd>Thank you.

1227
02:19:35.343 --> 02:19:45.956
<v Anne Cudd>We look forward to getting in a room, rolling up our sleeves with city staff to find creative solutions and to support our city's growth-ready creative sector.

1228
02:19:46.486 --> 02:19:50.114
<v Anne Cudd>Thank you for your time and consideration of this important step forward.

1229
02:19:50.500 --> 02:19:58.143
<v Anne Cudd>I appreciate your service to the city, and I hope you will let knowledge serve the city in Portland's next great era.

1230
02:19:58.689 --> 02:19:58.930
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Thank you.

1231
02:19:59.412 --> 02:20:00.038
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1232
02:20:02.058 --> 02:20:03.373
<v Duke Castle>Hi, I'm Duke Castle.

1233
02:20:03.438 --> 02:20:04.063
<v Carl Abbott>Can you hear me?

1234
02:20:04.399 --> 02:20:05.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yep, go ahead.

1235
02:20:05.361 --> 02:20:06.130
<v Duke Castle>Oh, great, thank you.

1236
02:20:06.789 --> 02:20:11.824
<v Duke Castle>Um, well, I'm here to strongly recommend, recommend that you do not pass this resolution.

1237
02:20:12.416 --> 02:20:14.277
<v Duke Castle>We all know how this is going to turn out.

1238
02:20:14.742 --> 02:20:23.609
<v Duke Castle>A plan will be developed for the PSU venue that will be more expensive than upgrading the Keller at a time when we don't have the money, and with a new venue that we really don't need.

1239
02:20:24.281 --> 02:20:37.592
<v Duke Castle>A plan to modernize the Keller was presented to the previous City Council that showed how all the Keller concerns can be successfully addressed at a cost significantly less than what we're going to find out, uh, it's going to cost us at PSU.

1240
02:20:38.233 --> 02:20:47.694
<v Duke Castle>Why would we continue to put staff time and resources into a project that we can't afford and will make us in many ways worse off?

1241
02:20:48.496 --> 02:20:51.432
<v Duke Castle>Some feel that this project will revitalize the city.

1242
02:20:52.265 --> 02:20:54.558
<v Duke Castle>Frankly, I believe that's speculative fantasy.

1243
02:20:54.622 --> 02:20:54.799
<v Duke Castle>Thank you.

1244
02:20:55.233 --> 02:21:00.418
<v Duke Castle>The PSU project will draw business away from restaurants and hotels in the central part of our city.

1245
02:21:01.076 --> 02:21:04.818
<v Duke Castle>The hospitality industry is struggling to fill the rooms they have now.

1246
02:21:05.573 --> 02:21:08.254
<v Duke Castle>They don't need another competitor to make things worse.

1247
02:21:09.105 --> 02:21:13.906
<v Duke Castle>And this project also, I don't believe, is going to solve PSU's problems.

1248
02:21:14.340 --> 02:21:23.281
<v Duke Castle>Written student testimony indicates that they feel making PSU more affordable with additional student housing will have a greater impact than this project.

1249
02:21:24.057 --> 02:21:28.608
<v Duke Castle>Unions have a legitimate concern about theatrical skills being lost.

1250
02:21:28.656 --> 02:21:33.355
<v Duke Castle>However, other cities have solved this problem by investing in temporary venues.

1251
02:21:33.550 --> 02:21:34.496
<v Duke Castle>We should do the same.

1252
02:21:36.370 --> 02:21:46.174
<v Duke Castle>The real need for our community is to bring more businesses to the downtown core, to continue to deal with homelessness, and to fill the missing gaps in our police force.

1253
02:21:46.225 --> 02:21:46.391
<v Duke Castle>Thank you.

1254
02:21:47.069 --> 02:21:55.083
<v Duke Castle>Councilor Dan Ryan made it very clear in his City Life test comments that it's time to end this.

1255
02:21:55.164 --> 02:21:55.567
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1256
02:21:55.698 --> 02:21:58.040
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, we are out of time at this point.

1257
02:21:58.104 --> 02:21:58.443
<v Duke Castle>Okay.

1258
02:21:59.058 --> 02:21:59.252
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1259
02:21:59.316 --> 02:22:00.720
<v Duke Castle>I would just, I would just say—.

1260
02:22:02.787 --> 02:22:03.076
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>Sorry.

1261
02:22:03.449 --> 02:22:04.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right.

1262
02:22:04.546 --> 02:22:05.272
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1263
02:22:07.880 --> 02:22:08.512
<v Sarah Schwartz>Good afternoon.

1264
02:22:08.706 --> 02:22:09.967
<v Sarah Schwartz>My name is Sarah Schwarz.

1265
02:22:10.145 --> 02:22:15.058
<v Sarah Schwartz>I'm the president of the PSU Foundation and the project lead for the Performing Arts and Culture Center.

1266
02:22:16.474 --> 02:22:38.891
<v Sarah Schwartz>3 years ago, when the city asked Portland State to explore what a Broadway-capable theater on our campus might make possible for Portland, we answered with a bold vision: a cultural campus that goes beyond a Broadway theater to create opportunities for audiences, artists, students, and community organizations while strengthening Portland's entire arts ecosystem.

1267
02:22:39.742 --> 02:22:45.152
<v Sarah Schwartz>Since then, the proposal has undergone extensive technical analysis, and scrutiny of advisory groups.

1268
02:22:45.906 --> 02:22:54.229
<v Sarah Schwartz>And we have had thousands of conversations with artists, arts organizations, business leaders, donors, students, investors, and community partners.

1269
02:22:55.370 --> 02:23:02.217
<v Sarah Schwartz>The result is this: PSU has identified funding for the academic and community spaces it will own and operate.

1270
02:23:02.779 --> 02:23:04.835
<v Sarah Schwartz>Development partners are at the table.

1271
02:23:05.334 --> 02:23:13.307
<v Sarah Schwartz>The state of Oregon and early philanthropic donors have stepped forward, and $230 million has already been aligned with the project.

1272
02:23:13.996 --> 02:23:19.191
<v Sarah Schwartz>What is critical now is understanding how the city can best fund the Broadway theater it will own.

1273
02:23:20.103 --> 02:23:23.854
<v Sarah Schwartz>Today's resolution does not commit the city to any particular path.

1274
02:23:24.433 --> 02:23:32.014
<v Sarah Schwartz>It authorizes city staff to work with PSU to evaluate funding strategies and provide council with the information it's requested.

1275
02:23:32.929 --> 02:23:34.227
<v Sarah Schwartz>We must move swiftly forward.

1276
02:23:34.790 --> 02:23:39.461
<v Sarah Schwartz>Councilors, your partners are at the table, and we're excited to start building this vision with you.

1277
02:23:40.041 --> 02:23:43.248
<v Sarah Schwartz>Thank you for your consideration, and we hope you will support the resolution.

1278
02:23:44.100 --> 02:23:44.666
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1279
02:23:44.844 --> 02:23:46.126
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good timing.

1280
02:23:48.412 --> 02:23:52.385
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of the council, thank you for letting me speak today.

1281
02:23:52.936 --> 02:23:58.041
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>For the record, my name is AJ Romero-Gimmel, and I serve as the PSU Graduate Student Trustee on the Board of Trustees.

1282
02:23:59.577 --> 02:24:07.527
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>I'm here today in strong support of the resolution to advance a new Broadway-capable venue as part of the proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center at Portland State University.

1283
02:24:08.510 --> 02:24:13.675
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>In my role on the board, I represent the voice of students across all disciplines, backgrounds, and areas of study.

1284
02:24:14.260 --> 02:24:15.880
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>You're going to hear from a lot of people today.

1285
02:24:16.368 --> 02:24:20.695
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>I don't think there are a lot of students registered, so take that into mind.

1286
02:24:22.412 --> 02:24:29.114
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>From a governance and student perspective, this project is a transformative generational opportunity for our entire university community and region.

1287
02:24:30.103 --> 02:24:35.242
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>This center will not just transform downtown, it'll be a powerful engine for student recruitment and enrollment.

1288
02:24:35.885 --> 02:24:40.106
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>Today's students are looking for vibrant, connected campuses with state-of-the-art resources.

1289
02:24:40.845 --> 02:24:54.638
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>Hosting a premier Broadway-capable facility right on campus gives PSU a unique competitive edge, attracting top talent locally, nationally, and internationally, not only in the performing arts, but across business, technical, and creative fields.

1290
02:24:55.552 --> 02:25:02.083
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>Integrating a world-class venue into our campus directly enhances the overall student experience and catalyzes downtown revitalization.

1291
02:25:02.756 --> 02:25:10.040
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>It expands academic and workforce development opportunities across campus, creating high-value internships, technical jobs, and venue and event management roles.

1292
02:25:10.698 --> 02:25:20.805
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>Beyond these broader impacts of having a Broadway-capable venue on our campus, provides access to training facilities and mentorship opportunities that our students would benefit from and might not have otherwise have access to.

1293
02:25:21.212 --> 02:25:24.243
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>This matters especially because PSU is Oregon's access institution.

1294
02:25:25.729 --> 02:25:33.198
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>With Portland State having multiple designations for serving underrepresented communities, this helps PSU advance our mission as Oregon's access institution.

1295
02:25:33.809 --> 02:25:39.744
<v AJ Romero-Gemmel>Locating academic space next to professional theater space will give PSU performing arts students a direct view into potential careers following graduation.

1296
02:25:41.350 --> 02:25:42.031
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1297
02:25:42.439 --> 02:25:42.665
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

1298
02:25:43.738 --> 02:25:44.324
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1299
02:25:45.670 --> 02:25:49.487
<v Julie Vigeland>Chair Dunphy and council members, for the record, my name is Julie Vigeland.

1300
02:25:49.976 --> 02:25:56.451
<v Julie Vigeland>I'm a South Waterfront resident, a lifelong advocate, patron, volunteer, and supporter of arts and culture in Portland.

1301
02:25:57.060 --> 02:26:00.027
<v Julie Vigeland>Simply, thank you for your extraordinary work.

1302
02:26:00.811 --> 02:26:07.031
<v Julie Vigeland>The recommendations before you reflect years of study, public engagement, and thoughtful deliberation.

1303
02:26:08.009 --> 02:26:17.822
<v Julie Vigeland>I have spent much of my life championing the arts because they enrich our communities, they strengthen our economy, and create the shared experiences that help cities thrive.

1304
02:26:18.593 --> 02:26:27.735
<v Julie Vigeland>That is why I am encouraged by the recommendation to move forward with planning for the Performing Arts and Culture Center with a Broadway theater at its heart.

1305
02:26:28.730 --> 02:26:31.397
<v Julie Vigeland>What excites me is not simply a new venue.

1306
02:26:32.168 --> 02:26:42.997
<v Julie Vigeland>It is the opportunity to welcome new audiences, connect students to the arts, strengthen artists and arts organizations across our region, and inspire philanthropy.

1307
02:26:43.061 --> 02:26:43.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1308
02:26:43.832 --> 02:26:55.297
<v Julie Vigeland>I know from my personal experience in fundraising for major projects that donors are drawn to bold visions, strong partnerships, and projects that can make a lasting difference.

1309
02:26:55.939 --> 02:26:58.391
<v Julie Vigeland>This is that kind of opportunity.

1310
02:26:59.386 --> 02:27:04.084
<v Julie Vigeland>At some point, every generation becomes a steward rather than a beneficiary.

1311
02:27:05.061 --> 02:27:14.208
<v Julie Vigeland>Our responsibility is not only to preserve what we inherited, but to widen the circle of opportunity I believe this project can do just that.

1312
02:27:16.200 --> 02:27:23.648
<v Julie Vigeland>Let's let future generations look back and say that we had the vision to invest in what Portland could become.

1313
02:27:24.456 --> 02:27:26.646
<v Julie Vigeland>I urge you to vote yes on this resolution.

1314
02:27:28.334 --> 02:27:28.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all very much.

1315
02:27:30.572 --> 02:27:42.787
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Leroy Bynum, Daniel Pollock-Pelsner, Linda McKim-Bell, Amy Donahue, Chuck Dillard.

1316
02:27:47.263 --> 02:27:47.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, folks.

1317
02:27:47.718 --> 02:27:48.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on down.

1318
02:27:50.559 --> 02:27:51.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Reminder, you have 90 seconds apiece.

1319
02:27:52.057 --> 02:27:53.981
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please make sure to introduce yourselves for the record.

1320
02:27:55.436 --> 02:27:56.128
<v Leroy Bynum>Good afternoon.

1321
02:27:56.320 --> 02:28:06.718
<v Leroy Bynum>I'm LaRoy Bynum, the Dean of PSU's extraordinary College of the Arts, and I am again excited to speak to you on behalf of the Performing Arts and Culture Center proposed for PSU's campus.

1322
02:28:08.843 --> 02:28:23.757
<v Leroy Bynum>As a career-long lover of the stage and a lifelong champion of diversity and access, for me, the process of developing this proposal has been all about serving and uplifting Portland's entire performing arts ecosystem.

1323
02:28:24.560 --> 02:28:41.882
<v Leroy Bynum>At the same time, the arts educator and administrator in me know all too well the transformative power of performance venues to elevate the arts and the artists, while also bringing cultural, economic, and social vibrancy to the communities they serve.

1324
02:28:42.654 --> 02:28:47.823
<v Leroy Bynum>Moreover, for performers like myself, there are 2 unassailable certainties.

1325
02:28:48.320 --> 02:28:53.555
<v Leroy Bynum>First, all artists need venues that allow them to look and sound their best.

1326
02:28:54.037 --> 02:29:01.067
<v Leroy Bynum>And second, all audience members need and deserve to see and hear clearly what is being presented on the stage.

1327
02:29:01.117 --> 02:29:01.308
<v Leroy Bynum>Thank you.

1328
02:29:01.968 --> 02:29:13.063
<v Leroy Bynum>This requires the intentional creation of state-of-the-art tunable acoustics for complementary sightlines, achievable with certainty only when a performance hall is built from the ground up.

1329
02:29:13.784 --> 02:29:16.835
<v Leroy Bynum>PSU excels in training amazing performing artists.

1330
02:29:17.156 --> 02:29:25.635
<v Leroy Bynum>We also have leaned in with intention to building the talent pipeline for the backstage professionals Portland so desperately needs.

1331
02:29:26.004 --> 02:29:26.647
<v Leroy Bynum>So thank you.

1332
02:29:26.694 --> 02:29:32.764
<v Leroy Bynum>Councilmember for inviting us to propose building Portland's Broadway Theater on PSU's campus.

1333
02:29:33.135 --> 02:29:38.290
<v Leroy Bynum>We remain honored to partner with you in creating a center for everyone.

1334
02:29:39.605 --> 02:29:40.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1335
02:29:41.880 --> 02:29:42.416
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>Good afternoon.

1336
02:29:42.466 --> 02:29:43.376
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>My name is Daniel Pollack-Pelsner.

1337
02:29:44.451 --> 02:29:46.075
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>I teach theater at PSU.

1338
02:29:46.218 --> 02:29:55.253
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>I grew up in Portland where my folks took me and my sister to see shows at the Keller, and my wife and I are delighted to be back in the city taking our kids to shows alongside their grandparents.

1339
02:29:55.835 --> 02:29:58.593
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>But what drew us back here was not a single building.

1340
02:29:58.656 --> 02:30:01.237
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>It was a whole performing arts network.

1341
02:30:01.381 --> 02:30:05.726
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>And I write about performing arts across the country for the New York Times and the New Yorker.

1342
02:30:06.174 --> 02:30:16.834
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>And what we find in every city that creates a center that truly transforms a neighborhood, that truly galvanizes a city, is that it's never a standalone structure.

1343
02:30:17.347 --> 02:30:27.222
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>It's always a partnership between commercial theater, universities, city government, private philanthropy, local arts organizations, and the business community.

1344
02:30:27.271 --> 02:30:27.495
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>Thank you.

1345
02:30:28.137 --> 02:30:33.859
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>That's what can uplift a whole city, and that's what can change the story around Portland.

1346
02:30:33.906 --> 02:30:36.055
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>And I think we all know we need a new story for Portland.

1347
02:30:36.407 --> 02:30:42.387
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>When national arts editors ask me to write about the Portland arts scene, it's almost always to answer the question, what went wrong?

1348
02:30:43.060 --> 02:30:53.929
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>And I can understand the impulse to kind of hobble along with the status quo or to have a fantasy that the Keller could be redeemed, even though every study has showed that it's physically impossible in its current space.

1349
02:30:54.361 --> 02:30:57.855
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>But I think we don't want to pass up the opportunity to change the narrative.

1350
02:30:58.272 --> 02:31:03.309
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>If we can lift up students If we can lift up arts organizations, we can lift up arts organizations.

1351
02:31:03.887 --> 02:31:08.138
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>This is our chance for our kids to tell the story of how we got it right.

1352
02:31:08.635 --> 02:31:08.956
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>Thank you.

1353
02:31:09.677 --> 02:31:10.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1354
02:31:10.800 --> 02:31:20.875
<v Linda McKim-Bell>I'm Linda McKim-Bell, a PSU alum, neighbor, and Volunteer Advisory Council chair for the Senior Adult Learning Center at Portland State.

1355
02:31:21.372 --> 02:31:26.153
<v Linda McKim-Bell>I urge you to approve the PSU Performing Arts Center Auditorium Complex.

1356
02:31:26.522 --> 02:31:33.716
<v Linda McKim-Bell>To keep our beloved city on an upward trajectory and to make a bold statement that will empower our urban renaissance.

1357
02:31:34.277 --> 02:31:40.797
<v Linda McKim-Bell>I live at Terwilliger Plaza Retirement Community, a stone's throw from the proposed project.

1358
02:31:41.085 --> 02:31:49.560
<v Linda McKim-Bell>For me and many Portlanders, the wounds of a massive and ill-advised urban removal project are still palpable.

1359
02:31:50.875 --> 02:31:55.281
<v Linda McKim-Bell>The PSU Performing Arts Center complex would breathe new life into the area.

1360
02:31:56.147 --> 02:32:09.111
<v Linda McKim-Bell>We seniors living in the forest of high-rises and retirement communities near there need places to meet, places to enjoy the arts, and gathering spots to get together.

1361
02:32:09.640 --> 02:32:14.492
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Right now it's just a wasteland, and it's time for Portland to think big.

1362
02:32:14.958 --> 02:32:17.575
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Remember in the past when city—.

1363
02:32:17.592 --> 02:32:20.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>You got 30 more seconds, don't stop.

1364
02:32:21.449 --> 02:32:29.613
<v Linda McKim-Bell>When city fathers invited Frederick Law Olmsted here to plan out the parks, they were thinking big.

1365
02:32:30.340 --> 02:32:36.131
<v Linda McKim-Bell>A little town on the river inviting people from New York to come out and fix our parks up.

1366
02:32:36.792 --> 02:32:39.131
<v Linda McKim-Bell>And wow, what a treasure for us.

1367
02:32:39.681 --> 02:32:41.838
<v Linda McKim-Bell>This will be your treasure for the future.

1368
02:32:45.495 --> 02:32:46.163
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1369
02:32:46.471 --> 02:32:49.708
<v Amy Donahue>Good afternoon, President Dunphy and members of the City Council.

1370
02:32:49.772 --> 02:32:50.748
<v Amy Donahue>For the record, my name is Amy Donahue.

1371
02:32:50.798 --> 02:32:55.815
<v Amy Donahue>I am an I'm an architect and a partner with Bora Architecture and Interiors.

1372
02:32:56.150 --> 02:33:02.242
<v Amy Donahue>Thank you for this opportunity to testify on behalf of this important resolution, which I wholeheartedly support.

1373
02:33:03.059 --> 02:33:13.447
<v Amy Donahue>40 Years ago, civic and arts leaders brought an audacious vision to life, the Portland Center for the Performing Arts, boosting the creative scene and exposing the community to a broad set of art forms.

1374
02:33:14.120 --> 02:33:17.406
<v Amy Donahue>Today, we have the chance to make another bold step forward.

1375
02:33:18.191 --> 02:33:25.659
<v Amy Donahue>The PACC will increase access to the arts It will be an economic driver in the downtown core and beyond.

1376
02:33:26.445 --> 02:33:34.603
<v Amy Donahue>It will be a resilient facility that can safely accommodate audiences and the back-of-house operations required to stage a wide variety of productions.

1377
02:33:35.662 --> 02:33:38.691
<v Amy Donahue>My career has been focused on design for the performing arts.

1378
02:33:39.363 --> 02:33:48.659
<v Amy Donahue>While our Portland block size makes for a really wonderful pedestrian experience, a 200 by 200 block cannot accommodate a 3,000-seat hall and its programmatic needs.

1379
02:33:48.709 --> 02:33:49.189
<v Amy Donahue>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1380
02:33:50.104 --> 02:33:53.204
<v Amy Donahue>The PSU property will offer a gracious welcome to the community.

1381
02:33:53.782 --> 02:33:56.738
<v Amy Donahue>Performers will have adequate dressing and support spaces.

1382
02:33:56.851 --> 02:34:00.834
<v Amy Donahue>Production crews will have easy load-in as well as storage capacity.

1383
02:34:01.670 --> 02:34:08.560
<v Amy Donahue>A venue with these capabilities will attract more productions for a Portland community that is really hungry for the arts and for a new story.

1384
02:34:09.540 --> 02:34:14.440
<v Amy Donahue>We have the opportunity— you all have the opportunity tonight to do something remarkable for our city.

1385
02:34:15.003 --> 02:34:27.509
<v Amy Donahue>Like our new airport and East County Flagship Library, this project can be a civic triumph, a place that draws audiences from near and far to visit our dear city and be part of its exciting revitalization.

1386
02:34:28.190 --> 02:34:28.384
<v Sarah Schwartz>Thank you.

1387
02:34:28.772 --> 02:34:29.111
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1388
02:34:30.793 --> 02:34:32.960
<v Chuck Dillard>Good afternoon, President Dunphy, members of the council.

1389
02:34:33.300 --> 02:34:39.069
<v Chuck Dillard>For the record, my name is Dr. Chuck Dillard, and I am proud to be the director of the School of Music and Theater at Portland State University.

1390
02:34:39.622 --> 02:34:48.288
<v Chuck Dillard>I strongly support advancing the PACC because I see daily How our current facilities limit our students and our ability to serve Portland.

1391
02:34:48.914 --> 02:34:54.987
<v Chuck Dillard>Our students study, rehearse, and perform in a converted high school, not a purpose-built arts facility.

1392
02:34:55.582 --> 02:35:00.772
<v Chuck Dillard>Our award-winning choral program rehearses in a lecture hall because we have no suitable space.

1393
02:35:01.671 --> 02:35:08.403
<v Chuck Dillard>Our 3 bands rehearse in a room so small that it is an actual OSHA violation for hearing safety.

1394
02:35:09.399 --> 02:35:19.319
<v Chuck Dillard>And yet as fall term approaches, our classes in our popular Sonic Arts and Music Production program and in Theater Arts are beyond capacity, and I am forced to turn students away.

1395
02:35:19.959 --> 02:35:26.915
<v Chuck Dillard>While other areas struggle on campus with declining enrollment, the College of the Arts is experiencing growth and vitality.

1396
02:35:27.492 --> 02:35:34.365
<v Chuck Dillard>What is happening in the arts at PSU is clearly on the right track, but our facilities cannot keep pace with our successes.

1397
02:35:35.343 --> 02:35:36.753
<v Chuck Dillard>The PACC could change that.

1398
02:35:37.041 --> 02:35:40.698
<v Chuck Dillard>Preparing Portland's next generation of performers, educators, and arts leaders.

1399
02:35:41.211 --> 02:35:44.146
<v Chuck Dillard>PSU's motto is, let knowledge serve the city.

1400
02:35:44.884 --> 02:35:46.407
<v Chuck Dillard>Let me offer an amendment.

1401
02:35:46.825 --> 02:35:59.718
<v Chuck Dillard>Let art serve the city too, because the creatives, thespians, scholars, artists, and musicians who will study at the PACC are exactly who will keep Portland's weird spirit alive.

1402
02:35:59.975 --> 02:36:00.343
<v Julie Vigeland>Thank you.

1403
02:36:00.681 --> 02:36:02.316
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>Thank you all very much.

1404
02:36:06.757 --> 02:36:14.352
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Carol Morse, Charlene Hannibal, Mark Raggett, Christine Vernier, Helen Ying.

1405
02:36:22.097 --> 02:36:24.587
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're first seated, you get to go first.

1406
02:36:24.847 --> 02:36:25.399
<v Christine Vernier>Okay, good.

1407
02:36:26.797 --> 02:36:27.917
<v Christine Vernier>Uh, hello, councilors.

1408
02:36:28.877 --> 02:36:30.513
<v Christine Vernier>My name is Christine Vernier.

1409
02:36:30.899 --> 02:36:41.947
<v Christine Vernier>My husband David and I co-founded Vernier Science Education, and for many years we've been proud supporters of education, the arts, and organizations that strengthen our community.

1410
02:36:43.102 --> 02:36:50.858
<v Christine Vernier>First of all, I have to thank you so much for voting to approve the Albina Vision Trust resolution.

1411
02:36:51.950 --> 02:36:53.908
<v Christine Vernier>That's transformative for our city.

1412
02:36:54.666 --> 02:37:06.645
<v Christine Vernier>And I really feel that the performing arts center and culture at Portland State is transformative for our city.

1413
02:37:09.087 --> 02:37:12.399
<v Christine Vernier>We appreciate the thoughtful work that has brought us to this point.

1414
02:37:13.413 --> 02:37:20.068
<v Christine Vernier>After years of study, advisory committee work, and community input, the recommendation has been consistent.

1415
02:37:20.707 --> 02:37:25.863
<v Christine Vernier>The Performing Arts and Culture Center at Portland State is the strongest path forward.

1416
02:37:26.891 --> 02:37:32.209
<v Christine Vernier>What excites us about this project is that it's much more than a Broadway theater.

1417
02:37:32.851 --> 02:37:43.291
<v Christine Vernier>It is an opportunity to support students, artists, and arts organizations while contributing to the economic and cultural vitality of downtown Portland.

1418
02:37:43.837 --> 02:37:47.757
<v Christine Vernier>This is an opportunity that Portland cannot afford to pass by.

1419
02:37:47.822 --> 02:37:48.094
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1420
02:37:49.663 --> 02:38:01.211
<v Christine Vernier>Today's vote sends an important signal to philanthropists, private partners, and other funders that Portland is serious about realizing the vision of this resolution.

1421
02:38:01.456 --> 02:38:03.768
<v Christine Vernier>I encourage you to approve this resolution.

1422
02:38:04.754 --> 02:38:08.584
<v Christine Vernier>I thank you for your time and consideration and for all that you do for our city.

1423
02:38:09.808 --> 02:38:10.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1424
02:38:12.838 --> 02:38:15.657
<v Mark Raggett>Good afternoon, Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark.

1425
02:38:15.932 --> 02:38:16.882
<v Mark Raggett>My name is Mark Raggett.

1426
02:38:16.979 --> 02:38:21.200
<v Mark Raggett>I'm with Associate Principal at GBD Architects, Our office is in downtown Portland.

1427
02:38:21.489 --> 02:38:29.700
<v Mark Raggett>We strongly support this resolution as it will advance the new performing arts and culture center at Portland State University at a time when our city needs new attractions.

1428
02:38:29.889 --> 02:38:44.329
<v Mark Raggett>Adopting this resolution will allow the current Keller Auditorium to continue operating, bringing the signature Broadway plays and musical events to downtown, as it has done for years, while the planning, design, and engineering can continue on a next-generation mixed-use facility just a few blocks to the south.

1429
02:38:44.329 --> 02:38:58.202
<v Mark Raggett>We support investments that will bring more activity, energy, and vibrancy back to we recognize that Portland continues to lag behind other American cities in its recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic, and that what is needed are more reasons for more people to come visit and stay longer in downtown.

1430
02:38:58.716 --> 02:39:07.959
<v Mark Raggett>This resolution will enable city staff to continue to do the work necessary to ensure that this project meets the city's expectations for successful new regional and cultural attraction in Portland.

1431
02:39:08.569 --> 02:39:13.255
<v Mark Raggett>We are also excited about the potential of the new performing arts and culture center to catalyze new development in downtown.

1432
02:39:13.304 --> 02:39:13.754
<v Mark Raggett>Thank you, Councilor Mitch Green.

1433
02:39:13.690 --> 02:39:26.989
<v Mark Raggett>Our firm has a long history designing and developing some of the largest development projects in and around Portland, each of which is anchored by a cultural, institutional, and/or employment center, including the Brewery Blocks, Hassel Yates, Slabtown, and multiple blocks in South Waterfront.

1434
02:39:27.209 --> 02:39:39.829
<v Mark Raggett>We see potential for the creation of a compelling new district around the PSU Center and believe that the facility can serve as a new anchor in downtown, creating demand and attracting outside investments for new housing near Portland State University, the South Park Blocks, and the Willamette River.

1435
02:39:40.379 --> 02:39:46.552
<v Mark Raggett>In conclusion, we strongly support and encourage the Portland City Council to support this resolution moving the significant project for Portland forward.

1436
02:39:46.923 --> 02:39:47.954
<v Mark Raggett>Thank you for your time and consideration.

1437
02:39:49.073 --> 02:39:51.888
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good timing.

1438
02:39:52.853 --> 02:39:56.763
<v Helen Ying>President Dunphy and members of the Portland City Council, my name is Helen Ying.

1439
02:39:57.020 --> 02:40:05.575
<v Helen Ying>I'm a former educator, Portland State University alumna, longtime community leader, and a neighbor of the site where the proposed PACC would be located.

1440
02:40:06.201 --> 02:40:14.108
<v Helen Ying>In 2024, I testified because I believe accessible arts and cultural spaces strengthen individuals, families, and neighborhoods.

1441
02:40:14.524 --> 02:40:27.417
<v Helen Ying>Since then, serving on the city's FOSPA steering committee in a technical role reviewing data and evaluating options has further affirmed my support for PSU's PACC.

1442
02:40:28.733 --> 02:40:33.761
<v Helen Ying>Today I speak as a community member who understands what this Aye.

1443
02:40:34.782 --> 02:40:39.718
<v Helen Ying>This resolution is good for PSU, good for Portland, and good for the community.

1444
02:40:40.389 --> 02:40:49.772
<v Helen Ying>For PSU, the new venue strengthens its mission as an urban-serving university and creates meaningful opportunities for students, faculty, and families.

1445
02:40:50.365 --> 02:40:56.488
<v Helen Ying>It also builds on significant state and philanthropic commitments already secured.

1446
02:40:56.890 --> 02:41:15.772
<v Helen Ying>For Portland, this approach protects the economic activity generated by Turing Productions supports downtown recovery and activates the Halperin sequence year-round while allowing the city to reimagine the Keller without shutting down our large-scale performing arts ecosystem.

1447
02:41:16.444 --> 02:41:25.574
<v Helen Ying>And for the community, this plan expands access for artists of color, community-based arts groups, and young people who struggle to find affordable venues.

1448
02:41:26.006 --> 02:41:33.799
<v Helen Ying>It supports small businesses and reflects Portlanders' values: inclusion, accessibility, creativity, and cultural vibrancy.

1449
02:41:34.344 --> 02:41:36.611
<v Helen Ying>I respectfully urge you to adopt this resolution.

1450
02:41:37.299 --> 02:41:37.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1451
02:41:40.159 --> 02:41:40.801
<v Charlene Hannibal>Good afternoon.

1452
02:41:41.059 --> 02:41:42.233
<v Charlene Hannibal>My name is Charlene Hannibal.

1453
02:41:42.987 --> 02:41:52.415
<v Charlene Hannibal>I'm a 4th-generation Portlander, former Oregon Ballet Theatre dancer and PSU student, and co-founder of Open Space, a nonprofit professional dance company and school.

1454
02:41:53.367 --> 02:41:57.521
<v Charlene Hannibal>I grew up in local public schools at OBT and in many ways at the Keller Auditorium.

1455
02:41:58.051 --> 02:42:03.207
<v Charlene Hannibal>My generation had opportunities to perform throughout our city at the Schnitz, Newmark, and Lincoln Hall.

1456
02:42:04.162 --> 02:42:05.457
<v Charlene Hannibal>We weren't just learning to dance.

1457
02:42:06.201 --> 02:42:08.532
<v Charlene Hannibal>We were participating in the civic life of Portland.

1458
02:42:09.226 --> 02:42:13.379
<v Charlene Hannibal>Those experiences told us that these theaters in the city belonged to us.

1459
02:42:14.957 --> 02:42:15.697
<v Charlene Hannibal>I love the Keller.

1460
02:42:16.389 --> 02:42:21.075
<v Charlene Hannibal>From the color-coded dressing room floors to the smell of the green room to those red velvet seats.

1461
02:42:21.654 --> 02:42:22.632
<v Charlene Hannibal>I know it by heart.

1462
02:42:23.403 --> 02:42:29.245
<v Charlene Hannibal>That stage holds an outsized place in my life and in the cultural memory of this city.

1463
02:42:30.304 --> 02:42:31.299
<v Charlene Hannibal>But it's time for a change.

1464
02:42:32.148 --> 02:42:38.952
<v Charlene Hannibal>The Performing Arts and Culture Center, alongside a reimagined Keller, is a once-in-a-generation investment in Portland's performing arts ecosystem.

1465
02:42:40.012 --> 02:42:45.291
<v Charlene Hannibal>For organizations like Open Space, the proposed smaller community theater at PSU is essential.

1466
02:42:46.110 --> 02:42:50.876
<v Charlene Hannibal>Portlanders need affordable and accessible spaces where local companies and schools can perform again.

1467
02:42:50.924 --> 02:42:51.245
<v Charlene Hannibal>Councilmember Herbold.

1468
02:42:51.983 --> 02:42:56.759
<v Charlene Hannibal>Children become students, students become artists, artists become teachers and arts leaders.

1469
02:42:57.496 --> 02:42:59.644
<v Charlene Hannibal>I had the privilege to grow up in these theaters.

1470
02:42:59.996 --> 02:43:02.129
<v Charlene Hannibal>I chose to come home and invest in this city.

1471
02:43:02.786 --> 02:43:05.174
<v Charlene Hannibal>Please give the next generation that same opportunity.

1472
02:43:05.511 --> 02:43:05.831
<v Charlene Hannibal>Thank you.

1473
02:43:06.327 --> 02:43:06.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1474
02:43:08.075 --> 02:43:11.281
<v Carol Morse>Hi, I'm Carol Morris, and I reside in District 4.

1475
02:43:12.083 --> 02:43:21.126
<v Carol Morse>I'm the retired president of the PGE Foundation, and I've been active in arts advocacy, fundraising, and grantmaking for 25 years in this city.

1476
02:43:21.944 --> 02:43:25.976
<v Carol Morse>Portland is ripe for a state-of-the-art performing arts center.

1477
02:43:26.361 --> 02:43:35.177
<v Carol Morse>Our city now has a cutting-edge airport, an art museum, and soon a renovated major sports arena for our beloved Trail Blazers.

1478
02:43:36.093 --> 02:43:39.834
<v Carol Morse>The performing arts deserves the same attention.

1479
02:43:41.297 --> 02:43:50.863
<v Carol Morse>I have been impressed with PSU's track record of fundraising and building major facilities through public-private partnerships On time and on budget.

1480
02:43:51.728 --> 02:44:07.176
<v Carol Morse>The proposed performing arts center at PSU already has $250 million in commitments through state bonds and PSU philanthropy, with more in the pipeline once City Council gives PSU the go-ahead to proceed.

1481
02:44:08.251 --> 02:44:12.690
<v Carol Morse>This project would be transformative for arts and culture in the region.

1482
02:44:13.459 --> 02:44:14.740
<v Carol Morse>Don't pass it up.

1483
02:44:14.980 --> 02:44:15.076
<v Carol Morse>Thank you.

1484
02:44:15.286 --> 02:44:26.558
<v Carol Morse>Please vote yes today so the City of Portland and PSU can officially begin to determine the cost and timeline of the Performing Arts and Culture Center at PSU.

1485
02:44:27.006 --> 02:44:27.488
<v Carol Morse>Thank you.

1486
02:44:28.147 --> 02:44:28.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1487
02:44:28.950 --> 02:44:29.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

1488
02:44:30.716 --> 02:44:40.157
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Earl Blumenauer, Jen Hartmann Luck, Carl Abbott, Nancy Courtney, Jean-Pierre Villette.

1489
02:44:43.336 --> 02:44:44.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on down, folks.

1490
02:45:03.430 --> 02:45:04.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Everyone wants to go first?

1491
02:45:04.959 --> 02:45:06.272
<v Jamie Dunphy>Jump on in, Congressman.

1492
02:45:07.420 --> 02:45:08.130
<v Earl Blumenauer>Ex-Congressman.

1493
02:45:08.179 --> 02:45:08.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Former congressman.

1494
02:45:08.728 --> 02:45:09.634
<v Earl Blumenauer>Careful now.

1495
02:45:10.683 --> 02:45:12.753
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well-deserved former.

1496
02:45:12.947 --> 02:45:14.143
<v Earl Blumenauer>My heart almost stopped.

1497
02:45:16.430 --> 02:45:18.717
<v Earl Blumenauer>Thank you very much, Mr. President, members of the council.

1498
02:45:19.102 --> 02:45:26.461
<v Earl Blumenauer>I've had great fun listening to the testimony here before and watching what's happening with the momentum here.

1499
02:45:27.569 --> 02:45:34.833
<v Earl Blumenauer>For— I would like to begin, if I could, by just acknowledging I appreciated Councilor Clark's reference to Gloria Steinem.

1500
02:45:35.618 --> 02:45:46.310
<v Earl Blumenauer>I'd like to reference Judith Ramaley, who was a transformative president of Portland State, who just passed away and was trustee until she passed.

1501
02:45:47.459 --> 02:45:51.337
<v Earl Blumenauer>I'm delighted to work with Anne Cudd, the right president for the right time.

1502
02:45:53.819 --> 02:45:59.593
<v Earl Blumenauer>I helped start the fight against the Mount Hood Freeway in Southeast Portland.

1503
02:46:00.125 --> 02:46:01.915
<v Earl Blumenauer>I was today with the Thank you.

1504
02:46:01.962 --> 02:46:09.606
<v Earl Blumenauer>Metropolitan Study leading a tour of the waterfront and a plan to revitalize it.

1505
02:46:12.969 --> 02:46:20.378
<v Earl Blumenauer>I am excited about the prospect here to showcase the work that we can do going forward.

1506
02:46:20.635 --> 02:46:25.272
<v Earl Blumenauer>The arts and education are going to lead the revitalization of our city.

1507
02:46:25.932 --> 02:46:30.149
<v Earl Blumenauer>I'd like to dedicate my testimony today to the memory of Bill Nadeau.

1508
02:46:30.215 --> 02:46:33.015
<v Earl Blumenauer>I think I've given all of you a copy of his biography.

1509
02:46:35.156 --> 02:46:37.335
<v Earl Blumenauer>And it wasn't just that he convinced me to wear a bow tie.

1510
02:46:38.700 --> 02:46:45.046
<v Earl Blumenauer>Bill Nadeau involved that notion of how to deal with creativity and get things done.

1511
02:46:46.041 --> 02:46:50.884
<v Earl Blumenauer>And I have a feeling I'd know how Bill would respond to the challenge that you're facing today.

1512
02:46:51.656 --> 02:46:53.090
<v Earl Blumenauer>He'd say, do both.

1513
02:46:54.411 --> 02:47:01.711
<v Earl Blumenauer>Build the center at Portland State and think creatively about what to do with that marvelous space that is going to be available.

1514
02:47:02.273 --> 02:47:22.873
<v Earl Blumenauer>Next month, you're going to be invited to Portland State University for the opening of our new art center, a mass timber structure that is an example of why Portland State has been the major developer since 2010 in downtown Portland— over $1 billion.

1515
02:47:23.227 --> 02:47:23.853
<v Earl Blumenauer>Thank you.

1516
02:47:24.753 --> 02:47:31.384
<v Earl Blumenauer>Well, I don't think we have to make false choices or be competing against one another.

1517
02:47:32.041 --> 02:47:38.817
<v Earl Blumenauer>I think there is the vision, the resources, the opportunity to take advantage of this.

1518
02:47:39.829 --> 02:47:40.102
<v Daniel Pollock-Pelsner>Thank you.

1519
02:47:40.230 --> 02:47:41.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're out of time.

1520
02:47:41.435 --> 02:47:49.769
<v Earl Blumenauer>Let me just say, I would volunteer at any point to give you the rest of the story, uh, if you would give me that.

1521
02:47:50.188 --> 02:47:52.676
<v Earl Blumenauer>But thank you for your courtesy and what you are doing.

1522
02:47:53.193 --> 02:47:54.164
<v Earl Blumenauer>Thank you very much.

1523
02:47:54.325 --> 02:47:54.648
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, sir.

1524
02:47:56.430 --> 02:47:57.399
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I gotta follow that.

1525
02:47:57.643 --> 02:47:59.923
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>Okay, great.

1526
02:48:01.022 --> 02:48:03.188
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>Good afternoon, Council President and councilors.

1527
02:48:03.382 --> 02:48:04.675
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>My name is Jean-Pierre Veillette.

1528
02:48:05.079 --> 02:48:05.594
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I was born here.

1529
02:48:06.206 --> 02:48:07.121
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I went to the schools here.

1530
02:48:07.572 --> 02:48:08.504
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I paid the taxes.

1531
02:48:08.761 --> 02:48:10.834
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I've done business in Portland for over 40 years.

1532
02:48:11.815 --> 02:48:14.540
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I've won and I have lost in the cycles of Portland's economy.

1533
02:48:15.295 --> 02:48:17.986
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I have— I travel with the Chamber on best practice trips.

1534
02:48:18.275 --> 02:48:27.289
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I've served as a trustee on boards, sat on many public committees, sponsored scholarships, run youth sports, and taught classes at the art school, all while raising a family.

1535
02:48:28.299 --> 02:48:31.442
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I say all that so you understand I'm not a bystander.

1536
02:48:31.827 --> 02:48:43.119
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I have skin in this city's future, and I am asking you to invest in the Performing Arts and Culture Center because I have seen with my own eyes what this city can become when we choose culture over decline.

1537
02:48:44.016 --> 02:48:47.689
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I am here because my mentors were the people who built this culture out of almost nothing.

1538
02:48:48.586 --> 02:48:54.228
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>Michelle Rousseau and Sally Haley came to Portland not long after the war that had taken so much from this country.

1539
02:48:54.837 --> 02:48:57.851
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>They didn't arrive in a city with galleries and stages waiting for them.

1540
02:48:58.363 --> 02:49:00.448
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>They arrived to very little, and they built it.

1541
02:49:01.104 --> 02:49:07.243
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>Rousseau taught at the Museum Art School right as returning soldiers on the GI Bill filed— filled its classrooms.

1542
02:49:07.899 --> 02:49:16.299
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>He spent his life fighting for artists to be treated as professionals in this city, advocacy that helped lay the foundation for the public art now woven into Portland's identity.

1543
02:49:16.362 --> 02:49:16.475
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>Thank you.

1544
02:49:16.659 --> 02:49:21.859
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>The Museum Art School took people broken by war and gave them purpose and strength when they needed it.

1545
02:49:23.891 --> 02:49:25.013
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I'm going to skip through.

1546
02:49:26.896 --> 02:49:34.219
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>We have inherited a legacy, and right now the Schnitz is selling out its shows, and there is a real appetite to grow what Broadway means for the city.

1547
02:49:34.898 --> 02:49:37.845
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>That driving force of what we inherited did not disappear.

1548
02:49:38.541 --> 02:49:41.102
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>It is telling us something if we are willing to listen.

1549
02:49:41.701 --> 02:49:49.619
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>Culture is how a city remembers who it is, It is how Portland made these investments before and benefited greatly when it mattered then, and it matters now.

1550
02:49:50.340 --> 02:49:53.685
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>The Performing Arts and Culture Center is our turn to do the work.

1551
02:49:54.962 --> 02:49:56.450
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>It is not a luxury project.

1552
02:49:56.756 --> 02:49:58.809
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>It is a kind of investment that grows the whole pie.

1553
02:49:59.569 --> 02:50:01.420
<v Jean-Pierre Villette>I am asking you to support this project.

1554
02:50:01.719 --> 02:50:02.536
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1555
02:50:04.212 --> 02:50:10.346
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>Hello, my name is Jen Hartman Luck, the producing artistic director of the newly unpaused Oregon Children's Theatre.

1556
02:50:11.218 --> 02:50:17.795
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>And when I was in 8th grade, I saw my first professional musical at Gammage Auditorium at Arizona State University.

1557
02:50:18.245 --> 02:50:19.449
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>It was Phantom of the Opera.

1558
02:50:20.058 --> 02:50:24.619
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>I was in the back row of the third balcony, and that night I became an arts person.

1559
02:50:25.373 --> 02:50:27.460
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>Gammage became an anchor in my life.

1560
02:50:27.541 --> 02:50:29.661
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>I went on to major in theater at Arizona State.

1561
02:50:30.094 --> 02:50:31.813
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>I worked in that venue, performed there.

1562
02:50:31.877 --> 02:50:34.109
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>I got my diploma on that stage.

1563
02:50:34.927 --> 02:50:36.468
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>That building helped launch my career.

1564
02:50:36.516 --> 02:50:39.710
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>For me, there was no Arizona State without Gammage Auditorium.

1565
02:50:40.224 --> 02:50:47.837
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>Years later, as a graduate student at the University of Texas at Austin, another building came into my life to become an anchor— Bass Concert Hall.

1566
02:50:48.318 --> 02:50:51.444
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>That building shaped me as an educator and an arts leader.

1567
02:50:51.604 --> 02:50:52.663
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>And then something else happened.

1568
02:50:52.968 --> 02:50:56.365
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>I became a patron, a season subscriber, a donor.

1569
02:50:57.199 --> 02:51:01.639
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>That is the power of a performing arts center on a university campus.

1570
02:51:02.361 --> 02:51:10.038
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>It can take that kid in the back row and turn them into a student An artist, an educator, a donor, and a nonprofit leader.

1571
02:51:10.824 --> 02:51:21.112
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>I'm here today as I begin my 4th season in Portland as producing artistic director of Oregon Children's Theatre, and I am here advocating for the Performing Arts and Culture Center at Portland State University.

1572
02:51:21.817 --> 02:51:33.790
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>A yes vote is investment in the infrastructure that helps a city attract and retain students, artists, educators, families, businesses, and cultural organizations like Oregon Children's Theatre.

1573
02:51:34.061 --> 02:51:43.666
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>The PACC will become an anchor for local arts orgs, for the generations of PSU students, and it will invite young people to imagine a future here in downtown Portland.

1574
02:51:44.134 --> 02:51:44.504
<v Jen Hartmann Luck>Thank you.

1575
02:51:44.923 --> 02:51:45.584
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1576
02:51:46.963 --> 02:51:47.385
<v Keelan McClymont>Carl.

1577
02:51:53.846 --> 02:51:55.101
<v Carl Abbott>Good afternoon.

1578
02:51:55.438 --> 02:51:58.396
<v Carl Abbott>I'm Carl Abbott, a retired educator and historian.

1579
02:51:59.554 --> 02:52:05.941
<v Carl Abbott>In my life before retirement, I taught a course on downtown development for urban planning students.

1580
02:52:06.824 --> 02:52:14.056
<v Carl Abbott>We explored the factors that make downtowns vital and viable, and PACC ticks the boxes.

1581
02:52:15.243 --> 02:52:22.716
<v Carl Abbott>Now, rather than to go through that familiar list, I decided I want to point to something similar in the city of Birmingham, England.

1582
02:52:23.823 --> 02:52:27.287
<v Carl Abbott>That city combined a new symphony hall with a conference center.

1583
02:52:27.351 --> 02:52:27.478
<v Carl Abbott>Thank you.

1584
02:52:28.397 --> 02:52:32.822
<v Carl Abbott>Connected them with a concourse in the city core to a historic canal network.

1585
02:52:32.903 --> 02:52:34.725
<v Carl Abbott>It's been a smashing success.

1586
02:52:36.079 --> 02:52:39.759
<v Carl Abbott>Spillover effects on the urban center— of course, they spell it funny over there.

1587
02:52:40.791 --> 02:52:42.906
<v Carl Abbott>If they can do it in Britain, we can do it here.

1588
02:52:44.659 --> 02:52:48.675
<v Carl Abbott>Portland has sometimes settled for small or convenient half measures.

1589
02:52:48.885 --> 02:52:58.920
<v Carl Abbott>At a time when we want the arts and education to help revitalize downtown, We need to invest in purpose-built, world-class facilities.

1590
02:53:00.183 --> 02:53:09.888
<v Carl Abbott>The PSU proposal, rather than beginning with compromise, advances Portland's highest aspirations for the arts, their audiences, and the community.

1591
02:53:10.969 --> 02:53:13.369
<v Carl Abbott>I urge you to move this resolution forward.

1592
02:53:13.796 --> 02:53:14.618
<v Carl Abbott>Thanks for your time.

1593
02:53:16.332 --> 02:53:16.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1594
02:53:18.610 --> 02:53:21.541
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, uh, checking to see if Nancy Courtney is here.

1595
02:53:24.414 --> 02:53:32.800
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Rosetta Venitucci, Bob Naito, Emily Horton, Charlotte Rich, Terry Goldman.

1596
02:53:33.319 --> 02:53:35.007
<v Anne Cudd>Hey, Bob.

1597
02:53:35.185 --> 02:53:36.322
<v Anne Cudd>Hey, how are you?

1598
02:53:36.501 --> 02:53:37.311
<v Anne Cudd>I'm good, how are you?

1599
02:53:39.790 --> 02:53:40.557
<v Christine Vernier>You want to sit between us?

1600
02:53:41.976 --> 02:53:43.183
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ladies first.

1601
02:53:45.462 --> 02:53:47.974
<v Julie Vigeland>Hi, uh, my name is Rosetta Venitucci.

1602
02:53:48.478 --> 02:53:50.907
<v Amy Donahue>Good afternoon, President Dunphy, councilors, um,.

1603
02:53:53.549 --> 02:53:57.888
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Thank you for giving professional problem solvers the opportunity to weigh in.

1604
02:53:58.579 --> 02:54:07.858
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Stagehands solve problems every day, and we do it effectively and efficiently because the curtain has a time certain to go up.

1605
02:54:09.871 --> 02:54:26.843
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>IATSE has worked in the building since 1917, and we are all in support of a new city building on the PSU site with a later 1,800-seat renovation at the current Keller site, which supports your goal of resurgence and renewal.

1606
02:54:27.504 --> 02:54:30.307
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>The entertainment industry has been bringing people back downtown.

1607
02:54:30.912 --> 02:54:33.627
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Today, I appeal to you with words from Broadway.

1608
02:54:34.322 --> 02:54:36.390
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Because the sun should come out tomorrow.

1609
02:54:36.888 --> 02:54:45.147
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>You can't stop the motion of the ocean or the rain from above, but you can ease on down the road and get this project started.

1610
02:54:45.789 --> 02:54:55.570
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Let's ease on down the road, the Halperin sequence, together, because now is the time to seize the day, to stare down the odds and seize the day.

1611
02:54:55.987 --> 02:54:59.900
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>It's too late for second-guessing, too late to go back to sleep.

1612
02:55:00.046 --> 02:55:02.114
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>It's time to try defying gravity.

1613
02:55:02.612 --> 02:55:04.408
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Everyone deserves the chance to fly.

1614
02:55:05.114 --> 02:55:08.115
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>It's a tale as old as time, true as it can be.

1615
02:55:08.806 --> 02:55:12.623
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Barely even friends, but then somebody bends unexpectedly.

1616
02:55:13.314 --> 02:55:14.260
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>So let's let it go.

1617
02:55:14.981 --> 02:55:16.298
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Let's not hold back anymore.

1618
02:55:16.987 --> 02:55:21.239
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Please vote yes today and let's ease this down the road.

1619
02:55:21.704 --> 02:55:22.522
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>Thank you.

1620
02:55:26.531 --> 02:55:27.211
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to sing it now.

1621
02:55:27.325 --> 02:55:27.843
<v Dana West>You're going to sing it?

1622
02:55:27.891 --> 02:55:35.036
<v Bob Nadeau>President Dunphy, councilors, my name is Bob Nadeau.

1623
02:55:36.056 --> 02:55:42.077
<v Bob Nadeau>Actually, I'm Bill Nadeau's son, but I'm also the chair of the Halpern Landscape Conservancy.

1624
02:55:44.557 --> 02:55:53.072
<v Bob Nadeau>On behalf of tens of thousands of Portlanders who want to save the Keller, I urge you today to reject This resolution.

1625
02:55:54.130 --> 02:55:58.286
<v Bob Nadeau>If PSU wants to build a new theater on their campus, they should do it on their own.

1626
02:55:59.601 --> 02:56:02.376
<v Bob Nadeau>The proposed location of the new theater is lousy.

1627
02:56:03.193 --> 02:56:10.670
<v Bob Nadeau>It's isolated from downtown and requires a new parking structure, subsidized— and a subsidized hotel.

1628
02:56:11.777 --> 02:56:18.162
<v Bob Nadeau>With downtown struggling, don't take 400,000 people a year away from the Keller, the fountain, and downtown.

1629
02:56:18.273 --> 02:56:18.674
<v Bob Nadeau>Thank you.

1630
02:56:19.557 --> 02:56:24.784
<v Bob Nadeau>This plan is financially reckless and risky for both the city and PSU.

1631
02:56:25.586 --> 02:56:30.237
<v Bob Nadeau>And interestingly, in all the testimony up to now, nobody has talked about what it costs.

1632
02:56:31.601 --> 02:56:50.667
<v Bob Nadeau>A total price tag of close to $1 billion with no funding in sight, no evidence that a market exists for a reduced Keller, and with $300 million in deferred maintenance for the existing 5 venues, and this plan offers no guarantee that the Keller will ever be renovated.

1633
02:56:52.272 --> 02:56:54.505
<v Bob Nadeau>The Keller is popular and profitable.

1634
02:56:55.389 --> 02:56:56.450
<v Bob Nadeau>Let's build on that.

1635
02:56:57.109 --> 02:57:05.676
<v Bob Nadeau>If the Keller were as dangerous and outdated as some claim, why would Broadway Across America have just renewed their contract for 7 years?

1636
02:57:06.742 --> 02:57:09.340
<v Bob Nadeau>Put a full-scale Keller renovation on hold.

1637
02:57:09.986 --> 02:57:20.448
<v Bob Nadeau>Instead, approve the Keller Affordable Fix, a 5-year, $15 million plan to improve and maintain Portland's largest theater while supporting downtown's recovery.

1638
02:57:21.091 --> 02:57:27.162
<v Bob Nadeau>Let's invest in what Portlanders already own, and it has worked for more than 100 years.

1639
02:57:27.611 --> 02:57:28.060
<v Bob Nadeau>Thank you.

1640
02:57:28.944 --> 02:57:31.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1641
02:57:32.236 --> 02:57:35.161
<v Emily Horton>Good afternoon, Council, and every other hardworking person in this room.

1642
02:57:35.450 --> 02:57:38.980
<v Emily Horton>My name is Emily Horton, And I am a District 1 working stiff.

1643
02:57:39.782 --> 02:57:45.783
<v Emily Horton>I am not lucky enough to have name recognition or a family legacy, but I am lucky enough to be a proud union stagehand.

1644
02:57:46.298 --> 02:57:50.677
<v Emily Horton>I am a wardrobe worker in IATSE Local 28, and I have worked in the performing arts for over 30 years.

1645
02:57:51.255 --> 02:58:00.978
<v Emily Horton>I grew up here in Rockwood, taking field trips to Oregon Children's Theater, attending shows like the opera's Porgy and Bess and Broadway's Sunday in the Park with George, and of course OBT's The Nutcracker.

1646
02:58:01.684 --> 02:58:05.263
<v Emily Horton>I graduated on stage at the Keller Auditorium, and now I proudly work for these companies.

1647
02:58:05.310 --> 02:58:05.406
<v Emily Horton>Thank you.

1648
02:58:06.031 --> 02:58:08.532
<v Emily Horton>And while I grew up in Portland, I did not go to college here.

1649
02:58:08.902 --> 02:58:20.972
<v Emily Horton>I had to leave the state to find a university that offered a theatrical education where I could work side by side with professionals in the industry, studying university-level academics while building a professional resume and earning a degree.

1650
02:58:21.726 --> 02:58:27.961
<v Emily Horton>I left the state to find a program like the one Portland State is building, a program that I know leads to success in the industry.

1651
02:58:28.475 --> 02:58:37.130
<v Emily Horton>My work-study job was for an award-winning regional theater, allowing me to graduate with minimal debt and a professional resume that allowed me to transition into a full-time career seamlessly.

1652
02:58:37.179 --> 02:58:37.290
<v Emily Horton>Thank you.

1653
02:58:38.798 --> 02:58:43.670
<v Emily Horton>My peers and I have health insurance, retirement dignity, and most of us have safe, stable places to live.

1654
02:58:44.086 --> 02:58:47.388
<v Emily Horton>We love our jobs and have worked tirelessly for decades to excel and thrive in them.

1655
02:58:47.869 --> 02:58:56.379
<v Emily Horton>These are skills that are built over a lifetime, and there are no other jobs in Portland that require or hire workers with our skills in the number that these performances do.

1656
02:58:57.068 --> 02:58:59.088
<v Emily Horton>These are our jobs that you are voting on today.

1657
02:58:59.809 --> 02:59:12.040
<v Emily Horton>Growing up in Rockwood in the '90s and going into the performing arts took intelligence, courage, investment, and commitment, and I'm asking you all for the same investment Please vote yes on the PSU project.

1658
02:59:12.088 --> 02:59:12.332
<v Emily Horton>Thank you.

1659
02:59:12.981 --> 02:59:13.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1660
02:59:15.149 --> 02:59:18.059
<v Terry Goldman>Good afternoon, Council President and Council Vice President and councilors.

1661
02:59:18.641 --> 02:59:29.079
<v Terry Goldman>My name is Terry Goldman, and I am the general manager of the Porter Hotel, located one block from Keller Auditorium, a frequent patron of events at Keller, and a parent of a professional musical theater actor.

1662
02:59:30.709 --> 02:59:35.136
<v Terry Goldman>I'm here as someone who has— who sees firsthand the economic impact that Keller has on the Portland area.

1663
02:59:35.531 --> 02:59:37.968
<v Terry Goldman>And it's current in the businesses surrounding it.

1664
02:59:38.897 --> 02:59:44.493
<v Terry Goldman>When there's a show at Keller, the restaurants in my hotel are busy, the bars are busy, and our hotel rooms fill up.

1665
02:59:44.974 --> 02:59:45.887
<v Terry Goldman>Guests make a night of it.

1666
02:59:46.255 --> 02:59:52.171
<v Terry Goldman>They dine downtown, stay overnight, and support the businesses that have invested in this part of the city.

1667
02:59:52.844 --> 03:00:07.078
<v Terry Goldman>The Keller isn't just a theater; it's an anchor that brings people downtown and creates activity that benefits hotels, restaurants, retailers, and the people who work in those businesses, including the employees who work at the Keller in a variety of different roles.

1668
03:00:07.304 --> 03:00:11.040
<v Terry Goldman>Like many Portlanders, I recognize that Keller needs investment.

1669
03:00:11.441 --> 03:00:22.104
<v Terry Goldman>It's an older facility and it deserves attention, but there's a big difference between improving something that works and spending an extraordinary amount of money that we don't have to build something entirely new.

1670
03:00:22.825 --> 03:00:25.280
<v Terry Goldman>As a business leader, I look at this through a practical lens.

1671
03:00:25.327 --> 03:00:33.009
<v Terry Goldman>If I have a profitable asset that is attracting customers and generating economic activity, I would invest in maintaining and improving it.

1672
03:00:33.329 --> 03:00:38.269
<v Terry Goldman>I would not spend hundreds of millions of dollars to relocate it and hope that the same success follows.

1673
03:00:38.864 --> 03:00:48.020
<v Terry Goldman>I respectfully ask you to focus on preserving and improving Portland's Broadway theater, the Keller, instead of investing in a new project at this time.

1674
03:00:48.489 --> 03:00:49.736
<v Terry Goldman>Thank you for your time and consideration.

1675
03:00:49.963 --> 03:00:50.645
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1676
03:00:50.854 --> 03:00:51.325
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

1677
03:00:56.734 --> 03:01:00.493
<v Keelan McClymont>Charlotte Rich.

1678
03:01:06.717 --> 03:01:16.257
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Terri Goldman, Diana Stewart, LeJune Thorson, Tom Reichert, John Russell.

1679
03:01:17.242 --> 03:01:18.128
<v Ernest Munch>You called me twice.

1680
03:01:18.306 --> 03:01:19.725
<v Terry Goldman>I already went to the last retarget.

1681
03:01:20.386 --> 03:01:21.014
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, thank you.

1682
03:01:23.367 --> 03:01:24.799
<v Keelan McClymont>And then Cynthia Hampton.

1683
03:01:26.585 --> 03:01:28.211
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome folks, jump right in.

1684
03:01:28.679 --> 03:01:29.757
<v Diana Stewart>Good afternoon, Council.

1685
03:01:29.822 --> 03:01:31.207
<v Diana Stewart>My name is Diana Stewart.

1686
03:01:31.271 --> 03:01:33.250
<v Diana Stewart>You have heard a myriad of reasons to vote no on this resolution.

1687
03:01:33.299 --> 03:01:45.925
<v Diana Stewart>The unknown cost, The lack of a clear plan, countless unknown, unmet competing city needs, including the Albina District projects that you voted on just now.

1688
03:01:46.454 --> 03:01:55.175
<v Diana Stewart>If city money goes to the PSU projects, which programs, which city employees, and which nonprofits will be sacrificed in exchange?

1689
03:01:55.528 --> 03:01:58.093
<v Diana Stewart>But there's one issue that no one has addressed.

1690
03:01:58.414 --> 03:02:12.327
<v Diana Stewart>Last week, the city posted an RFP seeking a qualified P5 management entity to replace Metro, who will be turning over management of the P5 venues on June 31st, 2027.

1691
03:02:12.681 --> 03:02:18.290
<v Diana Stewart>This will be one of the biggest determinants for future success of arts organizations in Portland.

1692
03:02:18.915 --> 03:02:26.273
<v Diana Stewart>The city already has responses by a number of qualified firms to last year's RFI, which tell a consistent story.

1693
03:02:26.707 --> 03:02:39.804
<v Diana Stewart>For example, ATG Entertainment, the 3rd largest Broadway theater operator in the country, states plainly in their RFI response that Keller is Portland's only Broadway-capable venue and yes.

1694
03:02:39.852 --> 03:02:45.608
<v Diana Stewart>Preferring Broadway is the primary venue driver for the entire P5 portfolio.

1695
03:02:46.024 --> 03:02:51.027
<v Diana Stewart>In fact, 4 of the 5 national firms who responded are telling you the same thing.

1696
03:02:51.556 --> 03:02:56.511
<v Diana Stewart>P5's financial sustainability depends on Broadway staying at the Keller.

1697
03:02:56.927 --> 03:03:09.966
<v Diana Stewart>Approving a competing 3,000-seat venue at PSU before you've even chosen a P5 manager risks pulling the foundation out from underneath the arts systems you're attempting to preserve.

1698
03:03:10.239 --> 03:03:11.252
<v Diana Stewart>Please vote no.

1699
03:03:11.299 --> 03:03:11.750
<v Joyce Follingstad>Thank you.

1700
03:03:12.408 --> 03:03:15.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd just like to very quickly note the RFP has not actually been released yet.

1701
03:03:16.264 --> 03:03:18.193
<v Diana Stewart>I think the RFP went out last week.

1702
03:03:18.290 --> 03:03:19.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, it was—.

1703
03:03:19.542 --> 03:03:20.620
<v Diana Stewart>Oh, it was held back?

1704
03:03:21.310 --> 03:03:21.359
<v Russell Benton>Ah.

1705
03:03:21.664 --> 03:03:25.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the RFI from last year was a more narrow scope, but the RFP has not been released yet.

1706
03:03:26.211 --> 03:03:27.400
<v Diana Stewart>Ah, soon?

1707
03:03:28.253 --> 03:03:31.627
<v Diana Stewart>We were told it would be last Tuesday, so that's what I was relying on.

1708
03:03:31.674 --> 03:03:31.852
<v John Russell>Thank you.

1709
03:03:31.996 --> 03:03:32.896
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's government.

1710
03:03:34.646 --> 03:03:34.870
<v Donna Bauer>Please.

1711
03:03:35.143 --> 03:03:39.565
<v LeJune Thorson>Hi, I'm LeJune Thorson, president of the Downtown Neighborhood Association.

1712
03:03:40.174 --> 03:03:41.711
<v LeJune Thorson>We're asking you to vote no.

1713
03:03:42.192 --> 03:03:47.128
<v LeJune Thorson>Before taking on another expensive project, let's take stock of what we already own.

1714
03:03:47.864 --> 03:03:50.252
<v LeJune Thorson>Let's figure out whether the city needs a new venue.

1715
03:03:50.844 --> 03:03:55.058
<v LeJune Thorson>Let's look at all our current venues and the improvements and maintenance each needs.

1716
03:03:55.796 --> 03:04:04.704
<v LeJune Thorson>Let's develop a maintenance strategy, and let's find ways to improve the revenue potential of each venue Through new management of P5.

1717
03:04:05.650 --> 03:04:09.433
<v LeJune Thorson>Only then should we even contemplate building a new performing arts center.

1718
03:04:10.299 --> 03:04:12.462
<v LeJune Thorson>There are other reasons why this is a bad idea.

1719
03:04:12.863 --> 03:04:19.628
<v LeJune Thorson>First, the city's loss of decision-making autonomy in the commercial condominium financial structure.

1720
03:04:20.076 --> 03:04:25.237
<v LeJune Thorson>Compare that with the control the city has by virtue of owning the Keller and the land outright.

1721
03:04:25.943 --> 03:04:29.967
<v LeJune Thorson>If you don't know what this is about, you should do some research about the Vanport Building.

1722
03:04:30.014 --> 03:04:30.191
<v LeJune Thorson>Thank you.

1723
03:04:30.971 --> 03:04:38.075
<v LeJune Thorson>Second, the real possibility that the Keller will become another subsidized venue instead of the profit generator it is now.

1724
03:04:39.166 --> 03:04:43.809
<v LeJune Thorson>And third, the financial losses to the hotels, garages, restaurants, bars, coffee shops.

1725
03:04:44.406 --> 03:04:46.148
<v LeJune Thorson>These are real businesses and real jobs.

1726
03:04:46.940 --> 03:04:49.617
<v LeJune Thorson>This is real money we're talking about with real trade-offs.

1727
03:04:50.279 --> 03:04:52.746
<v LeJune Thorson>We're cutting basic city services.

1728
03:04:54.296 --> 03:04:56.296
<v LeJune Thorson>Let's not be distracted by the state money.

1729
03:04:56.361 --> 03:04:56.554
<v LeJune Thorson>Thank you.

1730
03:04:56.912 --> 03:04:58.036
<v LeJune Thorson>That's real money too.

1731
03:04:58.372 --> 03:04:59.931
<v LeJune Thorson>Support the affordable fix.

1732
03:05:00.123 --> 03:05:06.272
<v LeJune Thorson>Make the necessary improvements at the Keller without a shutdown, and the Keller will serve us for many more years.

1733
03:05:06.963 --> 03:05:11.507
<v LeJune Thorson>Taxpayers are paying attention and seeing the real costs and trade-offs of this commitment.

1734
03:05:12.085 --> 03:05:15.986
<v LeJune Thorson>Show us, the taxpayers, you can be good stewards of our money.

1735
03:05:16.405 --> 03:05:16.742
<v LeJune Thorson>Vote no.

1736
03:05:17.560 --> 03:05:19.230
<v LeJune Thorson>Support the affordable fix.

1737
03:05:19.936 --> 03:05:20.290
<v LeJune Thorson>Thank you.

1738
03:05:20.739 --> 03:05:21.013
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1739
03:05:23.469 --> 03:05:24.322
<v Cynthia Hampton>Good afternoon.

1740
03:05:24.594 --> 03:05:25.927
<v Cynthia Hampton>I'm Cynthia Hampton.

1741
03:05:26.860 --> 03:05:30.201
<v Cynthia Hampton>Members of council, President Dunphy, and community.

1742
03:05:31.664 --> 03:05:34.395
<v Cynthia Hampton>I am a third-generation Portlander.

1743
03:05:35.600 --> 03:05:38.201
<v Cynthia Hampton>I am a community activist.

1744
03:05:38.411 --> 03:05:43.054
<v Cynthia Hampton>I've served on Symphony Board and others here for many years.

1745
03:05:44.113 --> 03:05:49.093
<v Cynthia Hampton>I am a believer in community and responsible partnership.

1746
03:05:49.222 --> 03:05:49.334
<v Cynthia Hampton>Thank you.

1747
03:05:50.879 --> 03:05:56.538
<v Cynthia Hampton>I'm privileged to be on the Halperin Landscape Conservancy.

1748
03:05:58.211 --> 03:06:09.004
<v Cynthia Hampton>So it's our collective responsibility to work together to ensure municipal coherency and careful urban planning.

1749
03:06:10.234 --> 03:06:18.177
<v Cynthia Hampton>The Keller is truly downtown in an existing neighborhood with more than enough parking, hotel rooms, and residences.

1750
03:06:18.888 --> 03:06:21.031
<v Cynthia Hampton>The waterfront project is right there.

1751
03:06:24.250 --> 03:06:34.980
<v Cynthia Hampton>The Keller plan includes a public plaza that extends from the entrance to the renowned, cherished Halperin Fountain, revivifying the Fountain District.

1752
03:06:37.693 --> 03:06:56.782
<v Cynthia Hampton>This is all done as a brand new building, totally redoing the Keller, more seating, Backstage fix, no trucks in the street, and half the cost of the PSU.

1753
03:06:58.280 --> 03:07:00.805
<v Cynthia Hampton>Please consider voting no.

1754
03:07:01.352 --> 03:07:12.752
<v Cynthia Hampton>Please be responsible with our monies and restore our trust in our public government by voting no on this.

1755
03:07:12.799 --> 03:07:13.185
<v Cynthia Hampton>Thank you.

1756
03:07:14.824 --> 03:07:15.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1757
03:07:17.879 --> 03:07:19.963
<v John Russell>Go ahead.

1758
03:07:20.707 --> 03:07:29.699
<v Tom Reichert>Hi, I'm Tom Reichert, and I have the great fortune of living in one of the Harvard Harrison Towers on Harrison Street.

1759
03:07:29.780 --> 03:07:30.799
<v Tom Reichert>Been there for 9 years.

1760
03:07:31.861 --> 03:07:34.129
<v Tom Reichert>I am an MD-PhD.

1761
03:07:34.434 --> 03:07:41.396
<v Tom Reichert>I was head of biomedical engineering at Carnegie Mellon, so I know a lot about modeling and And about building things.

1762
03:07:42.963 --> 03:08:07.038
<v Tom Reichert>I had the extraordinary good fortune to wake up, having moved, knowing nothing about Portland except that it had more friendly people than any other place I'd ever been, to find that I lived at the very edge of what is probably one of the great developments in, in any city in the United States, and that's the Halperin Open Sequence.

1763
03:08:07.086 --> 03:08:07.150
<v Tom Reichert>Yes.

1764
03:08:08.128 --> 03:08:24.834
<v Tom Reichert>I'm sure you all know that last year it was named by the American Society for Landscape Architecture as the most successful and most wonderful redevelopment program, uh, in the 20th century in the world.

1765
03:08:26.135 --> 03:08:38.358
<v Tom Reichert>So what we have is a world, world-famous development that immediately borders the The Keller Auditorium, and it has been successful quite a long time.

1766
03:08:40.262 --> 03:08:45.261
<v Tom Reichert>None of us really know the details for the proposal that you're asked to consider today.

1767
03:08:46.129 --> 03:09:02.248
<v Tom Reichert>We haven't seen where the buildings are going to be exactly, but if you walk down there, which I hope every council member will do, if you walk down there, it's an extraordinary experience because you're right aside of the 405.

1768
03:09:02.377 --> 03:09:16.262
<v Tom Reichert>If you take a sound meter, which I did, you find yourself in a barely tolerable— you find the sound level higher than the city of Portland will approve by 10 dB, which means more than twice as loud.

1769
03:09:16.390 --> 03:09:16.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1770
03:09:16.807 --> 03:09:18.265
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, we are at time.

1771
03:09:18.570 --> 03:09:19.742
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're over time there.

1772
03:09:19.917 --> 03:09:20.703
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for your testimony.

1773
03:09:21.361 --> 03:09:21.665
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

1774
03:09:22.804 --> 03:09:24.166
<v John Russell>Good afternoon, members of council.

1775
03:09:24.246 --> 03:09:24.871
<v John Russell>John Russell.

1776
03:09:25.065 --> 03:09:38.721
<v John Russell>For the record, I asked my friend JT Flowers to read my I hope you know that several years ago, the city and Metro each contributed $200,000 to redevelop the Keller.

1777
03:09:39.796 --> 03:09:45.998
<v John Russell>And what was— what came out of that was a dream team, an international dream team.

1778
03:09:46.063 --> 03:09:53.725
<v John Russell>And I can say that having developed PacWest Center across the street with Hugh Stubbins, the 4th winner of the AIA Annual Award.

1779
03:09:53.836 --> 03:09:55.120
<v John Russell>There was 100 given since.

1780
03:09:55.247 --> 03:09:55.407
<v John Russell>That's right.

1781
03:09:55.456 --> 03:10:04.905
<v John Russell>And I can tell you that It was Michael Curry, undoubtedly the best artist in this city, and Stew Fish of London.

1782
03:10:05.049 --> 03:10:06.604
<v John Russell>All they do are performance buildings.

1783
03:10:08.016 --> 03:10:15.220
<v John Russell>But I think there seemed to be 3 obstacles to council approval for renovating the Keller the way those geniuses have done.

1784
03:10:16.376 --> 03:10:22.055
<v John Russell>One, the head of Broadway Across America took us to dinner and said what I need was a staggered construction.

1785
03:10:22.135 --> 03:10:22.199
<v John Russell>Yeah.

1786
03:10:22.889 --> 03:10:26.698
<v John Russell>So that it doesn't interrupt my 8 or 9 month season.

1787
03:10:26.970 --> 03:10:28.931
<v John Russell>We said, we think we can do it.

1788
03:10:28.978 --> 03:10:31.823
<v John Russell>We talked to Hoffman and Hoffman said, yes, we can.

1789
03:10:32.979 --> 03:10:39.599
<v John Russell>Secondly, we were told by the city staff when that work was done to invite— we weren't told to invite the stagehands.

1790
03:10:41.029 --> 03:10:46.731
<v John Russell>When the issue came up, I talked to my friend Tim Nesbitt, who, as you know, was head of the Oregon AFL-CIO.

1791
03:10:47.213 --> 03:10:48.709
<v John Russell>He said, the solution is simple, John.

1792
03:10:48.789 --> 03:10:48.885
<v John Russell>Yes.

1793
03:10:49.208 --> 03:10:53.443
<v John Russell>You put them on unemployment, you support that, and you may have to supplement it.

1794
03:10:53.509 --> 03:11:06.712
<v John Russell>But that basically— and 3, PSU is head over— has had, short of Damocles, the deadline on the state funding.

1795
03:11:07.390 --> 03:11:11.197
<v John Russell>Everybody I talk to says there's no doubt that that funding would get extended.

1796
03:11:12.309 --> 03:11:13.736
<v John Russell>So here's my summary.

1797
03:11:14.266 --> 03:11:14.863
<v John Russell>No urgency.

1798
03:11:14.914 --> 03:11:15.013
<v John Russell>Thank you.

1799
03:11:15.639 --> 03:11:18.643
<v John Russell>Half the cost, lots of critical unknowns.

1800
03:11:19.433 --> 03:11:22.453
<v John Russell>Please don't commit taxpayer dollars until you know the facts.

1801
03:11:23.520 --> 03:11:23.702
<v John Russell>Thank you.

1802
03:11:23.886 --> 03:11:24.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1803
03:11:24.620 --> 03:11:25.136
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

1804
03:11:27.020 --> 03:11:36.177
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Donna Bauer, Jane Taylor, Julie Bunker, Dean Barnett, Louise Roman.

1805
03:11:41.597 --> 03:11:43.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>Almost halfway there.

1806
03:11:43.813 --> 03:11:45.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, we're a little bit more than half done.

1807
03:11:58.282 --> 03:11:58.781
<v Donna Bauer>Do I begin?

1808
03:11:58.828 --> 03:11:59.407
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, yeah.

1809
03:11:59.665 --> 03:12:00.950
<v Donna Bauer>Okay, my name's Donna Bauer.

1810
03:12:01.078 --> 03:12:13.287
<v Donna Bauer>I just asked the gentleman who just spoke if I could concede my time To him, and he said he didn't think so, because he seemed to be somebody who was knowledgeable in this.

1811
03:12:14.040 --> 03:12:19.876
<v Donna Bauer>And it seems like there's a lot of people speaking today who have no idea about the Keller, how it's run.

1812
03:12:20.452 --> 03:12:31.194
<v Donna Bauer>I've been a volunteer for 20 years, and it was just 2 weeks ago that I got to put input into this, and 3 days ago where I was asked to sign up and speak today.

1813
03:12:31.852 --> 03:12:36.164
<v Donna Bauer>And one night, last night, I was told instead of 3 minutes, I'd have 90 seconds.

1814
03:12:36.212 --> 03:12:36.516
<v Donna Bauer>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1815
03:12:37.126 --> 03:12:41.599
<v Donna Bauer>Which I no longer have time to say, read my speech.

1816
03:12:42.192 --> 03:12:45.287
<v Donna Bauer>But I want you to know, I beg you to vote no on this.

1817
03:12:46.361 --> 03:12:47.852
<v Donna Bauer>20 Years of volunteering.

1818
03:12:48.109 --> 03:12:54.889
<v Donna Bauer>The person who spoke about Oregon Children's Theater, we're the people, 250 of us, who went in the snow and kept it going.

1819
03:12:55.338 --> 03:12:56.975
<v Donna Bauer>We're the people during the recession.

1820
03:12:57.343 --> 03:12:59.492
<v Donna Bauer>Remember when symphonies were being lost?

1821
03:13:00.132 --> 03:13:01.913
<v Donna Bauer>The Oregon Symphony, we kept it.

1822
03:13:02.297 --> 03:13:08.311
<v Donna Bauer>We kept it 'cause of volunteers, because of the business community, 'cause everybody work together.

1823
03:13:08.808 --> 03:13:12.274
<v Donna Bauer>Now Portland State is coming in, it's like a competition.

1824
03:13:12.323 --> 03:13:16.753
<v Donna Bauer>They already have a name for it, and did I hear they're breaking ground on it in a week?

1825
03:13:16.800 --> 03:13:19.239
<v Donna Bauer>I think so.

1826
03:13:19.496 --> 03:13:23.620
<v Donna Bauer>I mean, so real fast, it won't work because of the location.

1827
03:13:24.615 --> 03:13:37.197
<v Donna Bauer>You can't have 40 buses, school buses, on Broadway and 405 coming and going to drop them off load in 20 minutes, take them out and get the next group in.

1828
03:13:37.470 --> 03:13:40.773
<v Donna Bauer>40 Buses, 3,000 people on that road.

1829
03:13:43.139 --> 03:13:45.713
<v Donna Bauer>Cost, the gentleman went over it, and the need.

1830
03:13:45.971 --> 03:13:47.387
<v Donna Bauer>We have 5 theaters now.

1831
03:13:48.159 --> 03:13:49.528
<v Donna Bauer>We do not need 6.

1832
03:13:49.688 --> 03:13:52.602
<v Donna Bauer>People are struggling to keep their theaters open now.

1833
03:13:53.859 --> 03:13:55.325
<v Donna Bauer>Thank you for listening to me.

1834
03:13:55.566 --> 03:13:56.066
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1835
03:13:56.114 --> 03:13:56.518
<v Donna Bauer>Vote no.

1836
03:13:57.082 --> 03:13:57.355
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1837
03:13:59.443 --> 03:14:00.038
<v Dana West>Good afternoon.

1838
03:14:00.086 --> 03:14:05.773
<v Dana West>My name is Jane Taylor, and I'm a downtown resident, an actor, a singer, and a director.

1839
03:14:06.656 --> 03:14:14.915
<v Dana West>The best way to revitalize downtown is to significantly lessen homelessness and drug addiction.

1840
03:14:16.216 --> 03:14:25.742
<v Dana West>If we can succeed at that, besides that being the right thing to do and the place for our budget dollars, if we can succeed at that, people will come.

1841
03:14:27.414 --> 03:14:27.834
<v Dana West>Downtown.

1842
03:14:28.127 --> 03:14:36.950
<v Dana West>If they aren't worried about crime and open-air drug dealing, they'll come to our restaurants and our vibrant performing arts spaces, and that includes the Keller.

1843
03:14:37.816 --> 03:14:46.543
<v Dana West>And renovating that not only helps make the Keller a better venue but also continues to support and provide money to Portland Five.

1844
03:14:47.540 --> 03:15:07.403
<v Dana West>Building a facility at PSU not only threatens the vibrancy of our other performing arts It will cost far too much and take precious resources away from actual solutions to our city's most pressing problems.

1845
03:15:08.065 --> 03:15:10.436
<v Dana West>Please do not approve this resolution.

1846
03:15:10.888 --> 03:15:11.210
<v Dana West>Thank you.

1847
03:15:11.613 --> 03:15:12.153
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1848
03:15:18.444 --> 03:15:22.914
<v Julie Bunker>My name is Julie Bunker, and I'm a certified venue executive currently working as a spectator venue consultant.

1849
03:15:25.002 --> 03:15:36.025
<v Julie Bunker>I was Director of Operations for Portland Five from 2017 until 2020, and I participated in the Keller seismic study and early Keller remodel planning.

1850
03:15:36.538 --> 03:15:38.829
<v Julie Bunker>I am testifying against this resolution.

1851
03:15:39.406 --> 03:15:51.712
<v Julie Bunker>While I'm grateful for all the hard work of the committees that— all the hard work that went into the resolution, of particular concern for me is page 2 of the City Life Committee document dated 8/11.

1852
03:15:52.240 --> 03:15:52.481
<v Julie Bunker>It Thank you.

1853
03:15:52.561 --> 03:15:58.101
<v Julie Bunker>The agreement states, clearly states that the proposed venue is not part of the P5 Centers for the Arts portfolio.

1854
03:15:58.663 --> 03:16:16.082
<v Julie Bunker>A 3,000-seat venue designed specifically for commercial events, if not included in that portfolio, will cause a significant loss of revenue, have a negative effect on maintaining P5's existing venues, and harm local arts groups that rely on subsidized nonprofit rates.

1855
03:16:16.483 --> 03:16:23.191
<v Julie Bunker>Removing commercial revenue from the P5 portfolio makes a management agreement less attractive for potential operators.

1856
03:16:23.943 --> 03:16:39.182
<v Julie Bunker>The management agreement should be, of the current venue, should be the number one priority with potential operators deserve the opportunity to make suggestions regarding the revenue impact if the new venue is not part of the portfolio.

1857
03:16:39.406 --> 03:16:46.343
<v Julie Bunker>PSU is part of the national trend of colleges planning event venues to offset enrollment drops.

1858
03:16:46.456 --> 03:16:49.788
<v Julie Bunker>Lewis and Clark is working on a new performing arts center themselves.

1859
03:16:49.979 --> 03:16:50.189
<v Julie Bunker>Thank you.

1860
03:16:50.846 --> 03:16:57.004
<v Julie Bunker>Who will own the building, how it is operated and funded, and what PSU expects out of it are questions that need to be answered.

1861
03:17:02.614 --> 03:17:02.855
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1862
03:17:04.724 --> 03:17:06.527
<v Jamie Dunphy>So yeah, go ahead.

1863
03:17:07.202 --> 03:17:07.493
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, you—.

1864
03:17:07.670 --> 03:17:08.475
<v Dean Barnett>Yeah.

1865
03:17:10.084 --> 03:17:13.113
<v Dean Barnett>I am Dean Barnett.

1866
03:17:13.439 --> 03:17:43.906
<v Dean Barnett>I'm I'm here as a very interested taxpayer, and what I would like to do is summarize what I can't cover here, and much of it has been, but what I would like to summarize it with is that apparently in '25, there was—.

1867
03:17:43.906 --> 03:17:44.506
<v Sarah Sofer>Councilor Smith.

1868
03:17:45.574 --> 03:17:45.847
<v John Russell>Yes.

1869
03:17:46.637 --> 03:18:12.066
<v Dean Barnett>A survey of clientele at the Keller, and that was used to characterize the direction that the various parts— and that's a third of them are from the south and roughly 20% from each of the other directions.

1870
03:18:14.047 --> 03:18:21.827
<v Dean Barnett>You look at all that and you generate the numbers on how many cars, how many people, and you can get kind of a modeling.

1871
03:18:22.806 --> 03:18:34.707
<v Dean Barnett>That has been used to do a lot of things, and it has generated the no fatal flaws thing that we have all heard from.

1872
03:18:35.647 --> 03:18:45.761
<v Dean Barnett>But what I would like to talk about is the less than fatal flaws of the 2 offerings.

1873
03:18:46.577 --> 03:19:19.775
<v Dean Barnett>The worst of those is traffic-related, and for the PSU offering, it requires a traffic— what is called a high-level traffic study because it increases traffic on Lincoln by more More than 100 cars, actually several hundred at the time of a performance.

1874
03:19:20.336 --> 03:19:20.865
<v Dean Barnett>That—.

1875
03:19:20.914 --> 03:19:24.039
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, we're 30 seconds over already, so I gotta stop you there.

1876
03:19:24.119 --> 03:19:32.566
<v Dean Barnett>Okay, so what I end up with is all of these were generated in 2025.

1877
03:19:33.559 --> 03:19:40.099
<v Dean Barnett>That requires a traffic study, and there has been no request for it yet.

1878
03:19:40.781 --> 03:19:42.430
<v Dean Barnett>They're not serious.

1879
03:19:42.739 --> 03:19:43.702
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1880
03:19:44.940 --> 03:19:45.127
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1881
03:19:45.212 --> 03:19:45.605
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

1882
03:19:48.478 --> 03:19:50.811
<v Keelan McClymont>Checking to see if Louise Roman is here.

1883
03:19:53.000 --> 03:20:00.246
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Erica Thompson, Chris Finks, Jesse Wolf, Kate Dixon, Joel Thorson.

1884
03:20:19.129 --> 03:20:22.505
<v Jamie Dunphy>Whoever wants to go first, jump on in.

1885
03:20:24.399 --> 03:20:24.560
<v Carl Abbott>Go ahead.

1886
03:20:25.144 --> 03:20:25.790
<v Terry Goldman>Um, Joel—.

1887
03:20:25.968 --> 03:20:35.399
<v Joel Thorson>I'm Joel Thorson, and I'm, uh, here testifying, uh, in favor of, uh, Saving the Keller, turning down the PSU request.

1888
03:20:36.813 --> 03:20:40.250
<v Joel Thorson>I'm testifying on my own behalf, incidentally.

1889
03:20:41.308 --> 03:20:49.546
<v Joel Thorson>And there are 2 major concerns, both of them very urgent, that are not very evident to the naked eye.

1890
03:20:50.220 --> 03:20:56.498
<v Joel Thorson>I'd like to call attention to City Administrator Lee, and I think his staffer is still here.

1891
03:20:56.578 --> 03:20:57.045
<v Joel Thorson>Is that right?

1892
03:20:57.140 --> 03:20:57.204
<v John Russell>Yes.

1893
03:20:58.007 --> 03:20:58.234
<v Joyce Follingstad>No.

1894
03:20:58.427 --> 03:20:59.736
<v Jamie Dunphy>DCA Donnie Oliveira.

1895
03:20:59.799 --> 03:21:00.673
<v Kate Dixon>That's Donnie Oliveira.

1896
03:21:00.753 --> 03:21:01.787
<v Joel Thorson>Okay, I'm sorry.

1897
03:21:01.915 --> 03:21:02.384
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that correct?

1898
03:21:02.707 --> 03:21:14.427
<v Joel Thorson>Yeah, so he's not here, but I hope that he and his staff will take a good hard look at my written testimony because it deals with my 2 main concerns.

1899
03:21:14.886 --> 03:21:22.828
<v Joel Thorson>One is the potentially serious risk, financial risk to the city of this project.

1900
03:21:23.250 --> 03:21:50.493
<v Joel Thorson>2 of the categories of risk, borrowing cost increases due to surging bond rates in the bond market right now, and construction cost increases due to the absence of 20 or more percent of the foreign-born labor force, are enough to almost ensure that this project will cost the city a lot more than it's estimated at a mere $448 million.

1901
03:21:52.370 --> 03:21:55.721
<v Joel Thorson>And I hope that it and the other issue is governance.

1902
03:21:56.672 --> 03:22:21.748
<v Joel Thorson>I think the city administrator needs to exercise full due diligence in looking over all the documents presented from the cooperation document to all of the foundation documents of the governing body and not sign any of them until they ensure Portland City of getting a good deal.

1903
03:22:21.799 --> 03:22:21.933
<v John Russell>Thank you.

1904
03:22:22.207 --> 03:22:23.093
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1905
03:22:26.899 --> 03:22:31.941
<v Chris Finks>Good afternoon, Council President, Vice President, and councilors.

1906
03:22:32.328 --> 03:22:37.136
<v Chris Finks>My name is Chris Finks, and I am a board member of the Halperin Landscape Conservancy.

1907
03:22:37.654 --> 03:22:46.188
<v Chris Finks>I've also professionally been a man who's dedicated himself to urban vitality through destination marketing for nearly 30 years, including Portland.

1908
03:22:46.984 --> 03:22:48.414
<v Chris Finks>So this is near and dear to my heart.

1909
03:22:50.037 --> 03:22:50.843
<v Chris Finks>My position is no.

1910
03:22:53.345 --> 03:23:00.774
<v Chris Finks>I don't think we should advance this proposal until the financial, economic, and civic case has been fully demonstrated, which it has not.

1911
03:23:01.439 --> 03:23:03.688
<v Chris Finks>It's fiscally irresponsible to advance now.

1912
03:23:03.850 --> 03:23:13.962
<v Chris Finks>The city does not have a complete capital stack, a clearly defined contribution, identified funding sources, long-term operating obligations, or a full assessment of taxpayer exposure.

1913
03:23:14.027 --> 03:23:14.495
<v Chris Finks>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1914
03:23:15.316 --> 03:23:16.727
<v Chris Finks>The timing is troubling to me.

1915
03:23:17.336 --> 03:23:27.790
<v Chris Finks>PSU is under great financial distress, falling enrollment, and Portland, the city of Portland, similar issues with budget issues.

1916
03:23:27.840 --> 03:23:29.570
<v Chris Finks>We know what we're facing.

1917
03:23:30.388 --> 03:23:31.608
<v Chris Finks>The Keller already works.

1918
03:23:32.504 --> 03:23:40.635
<v Chris Finks>It's a proven cultural and economic asset that brings hundreds of thousands of people every year into downtown restaurants, hotels, and surrounding businesses.

1919
03:23:41.066 --> 03:23:41.965
<v Chris Finks>Location matters.

1920
03:23:42.430 --> 03:23:51.381
<v Chris Finks>Moving the primary Broadway venue away between the I-405 and a major transit hub is troubling to me.

1921
03:23:51.445 --> 03:23:52.735
<v Chris Finks>It's basically an island.

1922
03:23:53.300 --> 03:23:56.325
<v Chris Finks>Credible renovation alternative already exists.

1923
03:23:56.534 --> 03:23:58.248
<v Chris Finks>The work has been done by private sector.

1924
03:23:58.475 --> 03:24:03.191
<v Chris Finks>We had talked about some of the renovation, and that has been vetted and done over the last several years.

1925
03:24:04.700 --> 03:24:11.315
<v Chris Finks>A big one for me is protect property values and tax base, and I think the impact would be pretty dramatic around those areas there.

1926
03:24:11.396 --> 03:24:15.966
<v Chris Finks>We already have had declining property values and then in turn tax revenues.

1927
03:24:16.789 --> 03:24:17.740
<v Chris Finks>So the question is simple.

1928
03:24:17.837 --> 03:24:20.431
<v Chris Finks>We're advancing— we, I think, don't advance.

1929
03:24:20.575 --> 03:24:21.638
<v Chris Finks>I'd say no.

1930
03:24:22.846 --> 03:24:23.345
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1931
03:24:23.409 --> 03:24:23.652
<v Chris Finks>Yeah.

1932
03:24:24.119 --> 03:24:24.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1933
03:24:26.777 --> 03:24:27.326
<v Erica Thompson>All right.

1934
03:24:27.504 --> 03:24:29.168
<v Erica Thompson>Good afternoon, city councilors.

1935
03:24:29.217 --> 03:24:34.694
<v Erica Thompson>My name is Erica Thompson and I'm a Portland resident and principal architect at Hinneberry Eddy Architects.

1936
03:24:35.202 --> 03:24:38.304
<v Erica Thompson>I've also served on the Planning Commission for more than 5 years.

1937
03:24:38.802 --> 03:24:45.373
<v Erica Thompson>I am not here on the commission's behalf today, but through that work, I deeply understand the city's efforts to revitalize downtown.

1938
03:24:46.129 --> 03:24:55.898
<v Erica Thompson>Downtown's strongest asset is its public realm, the civic rooms, parks, and green spaces that together make a uniquely beautiful and livable city.

1939
03:24:56.654 --> 03:25:00.156
<v Erica Thompson>I fear the PSU proposal threatens the vitality of these spaces.

1940
03:25:00.254 --> 03:25:00.558
<v Erica Thompson>Councilor Smith.

1941
03:25:01.297 --> 03:25:07.164
<v Erica Thompson>Authorize $44 million now and we trap ourselves in a sunk cost we cannot escape.

1942
03:25:07.949 --> 03:25:13.543
<v Erica Thompson>Given how little detail the plan offers, the real cost will probably be higher than what you've been shown.

1943
03:25:14.297 --> 03:25:24.523
<v Erica Thompson>It's unrealistic to believe the PSU project gets built and that any funding or will to make the Keller something meaningful remains.

1944
03:25:25.182 --> 03:25:29.445
<v Erica Thompson>I'm usually an optimist, but picture what happens if the Keller goes dark.

1945
03:25:29.765 --> 03:25:33.292
<v Erica Thompson>The businesses that depend on it struggle, vacancies mount, Yes.

1946
03:25:33.373 --> 03:25:34.465
<v Erica Thompson>Property values fall.

1947
03:25:35.058 --> 03:25:42.503
<v Erica Thompson>The revitalized Tom McCall Waterfront Bowl and its new venue are undermined because the blocks beside it go lifeless.

1948
03:25:43.144 --> 03:25:44.091
<v Erica Thompson>Now the alternative.

1949
03:25:44.683 --> 03:25:53.316
<v Erica Thompson>Through more modest investment, the Keller stays open, drawing steady crowds to what is already one of the largest Broadway touring venues in the country.

1950
03:25:53.909 --> 03:25:59.540
<v Erica Thompson>It creates real synergy with the reimagined waterfront venue just 3 blocks to the east.

1951
03:26:00.005 --> 03:26:05.144
<v Erica Thompson>Together they deliver activation, support for local businesses and investment in the arts.

1952
03:26:05.763 --> 03:26:08.191
<v Erica Thompson>Vision does not have to cost $1 billion.

1953
03:26:08.951 --> 03:26:16.379
<v Erica Thompson>We need a vision that sees our city clearly and by leveraging the assets we already have delivers a tremendous return at a price we can afford.

1954
03:26:16.523 --> 03:26:17.153
<v Erica Thompson>Please vote no.

1955
03:26:18.000 --> 03:26:18.334
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1956
03:26:18.703 --> 03:26:19.373
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1957
03:26:20.860 --> 03:26:22.798
<v Jesse Wolf>Hi there, I'm, I'm Jesse Wolf.

1958
03:26:22.879 --> 03:26:26.998
<v Jesse Wolf>I'm a partner with Grummel Engineering, and I'm here to speak to the Keller structure.

1959
03:26:28.102 --> 03:26:32.606
<v Jesse Wolf>In 2019, we were hired to perform a seismic evaluation of the Keller Auditorium.

1960
03:26:33.313 --> 03:26:42.404
<v Jesse Wolf>We reviewed historic documents, performed a seismic analysis, oversaw material testing of structural components, and reviewed a previously incomplete report.

1961
03:26:43.173 --> 03:26:48.272
<v Jesse Wolf>We followed the procedures of ASCE 41, a deficiency-based evaluation procedure for existing buildings.

1962
03:26:48.944 --> 03:26:52.120
<v Jesse Wolf>We compared the Keller Auditorium to the performance objective of a new building.

1963
03:26:52.792 --> 03:26:55.968
<v Jesse Wolf>What we found was a highly resilient structure with few deficiencies.

1964
03:26:56.031 --> 03:26:56.159
<v Jesse Wolf>Thank you.

1965
03:26:56.690 --> 03:27:05.270
<v Jesse Wolf>In 1966, the original 1916 building underwent a structural overhaul with an intentional focus on seismic lateral upgrades.

1966
03:27:05.469 --> 03:27:09.540
<v Jesse Wolf>Heavily reinforced concrete foundations, walls, and floors were installed in the building.

1967
03:27:09.950 --> 03:27:12.260
<v Jesse Wolf>The remaining structure was tied to the new lateral system.

1968
03:27:12.770 --> 03:27:20.770
<v Jesse Wolf>After our initial review, findings were confirmed by a peer review from another structural firm and through meetings with senior city engineers.

1969
03:27:20.770 --> 03:27:26.389
<v Jesse Wolf>We then joined a design team tasked with developing a plan to upgrade the Keller to meet the standards of a high-performance arts center, the likes of Broadway.

1970
03:27:26.389 --> 03:27:26.430
<v Jesse Wolf>Thank you.

1971
03:27:29.023 --> 03:27:36.987
<v Jesse Wolf>We devised a plan to upgrade the seating, ADU access, stage enlargements, and enhanced loading with minimal impacts to the existing structure.

1972
03:27:37.774 --> 03:27:42.639
<v Jesse Wolf>The remaining deficiencies to meet the performance objective largely involve out-of-plane bracing.

1973
03:27:43.137 --> 03:27:46.814
<v Jesse Wolf>As part of the architectural facelift, a new skin was proposed for the building.

1974
03:27:47.407 --> 03:27:54.119
<v Jesse Wolf>This would involve the removal of the existing precast cladding, which adds unnecessary seismic mass and is exhibiting signs of deterioration.

1975
03:27:54.845 --> 03:27:59.826
<v Jesse Wolf>The key to the upgrade is that the new cladding would double as a seismic bracing to resolve the seismic deficiencies.

1976
03:28:01.313 --> 03:28:07.298
<v Jesse Wolf>And I guess in short, given our findings, we find that the fiscally responsible thing to do is to upgrade the Keller.

1977
03:28:08.252 --> 03:28:08.915
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1978
03:28:10.953 --> 03:28:11.551
<v Kate Dixon>Good afternoon.

1979
03:28:11.665 --> 03:28:15.966
<v Kate Dixon>I'm Kate Dixon, and I live in beautiful downtown Portland.

1980
03:28:16.595 --> 03:28:22.448
<v Kate Dixon>And I want to begin by thanking you for taking the time and making the effort to listen to all of us today.

1981
03:28:23.704 --> 03:28:28.781
<v Kate Dixon>We believe in what we're saying, as you know, and we care very much about the future of our city.

1982
03:28:29.407 --> 03:28:34.709
<v Kate Dixon>Today, I'm here to implore you to vote no on the resolution before you.

1983
03:28:35.287 --> 03:28:42.467
<v Kate Dixon>Start with what we have as— as what we— you have and we have as taxpayers.

1984
03:28:42.739 --> 03:28:44.763
<v Kate Dixon>The Keller is not a failing building.

1985
03:28:44.988 --> 03:28:46.594
<v Kate Dixon>Thank you very much for your testimony.

1986
03:28:47.157 --> 03:28:55.069
<v Kate Dixon>In a recent year, it hosted 178 performances, and it presented for nearly 400,000 people in our downtown.

1987
03:28:55.984 --> 03:28:58.838
<v Kate Dixon>It is time to invest and restore the Keller.

1988
03:28:59.433 --> 03:29:13.273
<v Kate Dixon>It is not the time for a PSU concept performing arts project, which is a $450 million theater with no answer for who pays for construction, operations, management, or long-term maintenance.

1989
03:29:14.333 --> 03:29:25.361
<v Kate Dixon>At this time, when the arts sector is struggling to stay solvent and the city budget is shrinking, This resolution sets the stage for the largest, riskiest art investment this city has known.

1990
03:29:25.890 --> 03:29:27.941
<v Kate Dixon>You are the stewards of our city assets.

1991
03:29:28.118 --> 03:29:36.643
<v Kate Dixon>Renovating the Keller keeps a city-owned building under your control and supports our existing downtown infrastructure.

1992
03:29:37.332 --> 03:29:41.881
<v Kate Dixon>My simple ask is vote no on this premature resolution.

1993
03:29:42.555 --> 03:29:45.006
<v Kate Dixon>Fix and invest in what we already own.

1994
03:29:45.615 --> 03:29:46.385
<v Kate Dixon>Keep the Keller.

1995
03:29:46.787 --> 03:29:47.368
<v Emily Horton>Thank you.

1996
03:29:47.691 --> 03:29:48.013
<v Ernest Munch>Thank you.

1997
03:29:48.094 --> 03:29:48.967
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all very much.

1998
03:29:49.144 --> 03:29:49.725
<v Donna Bauer>Thank you.

1999
03:29:51.162 --> 03:30:04.806
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Sarah Sofer, Anjane Banuelos-Bolanos, Andrew Kolas, Bea Marston, Kyle Huth.

2000
03:30:16.461 --> 03:30:16.783
<v Dean Barnett>Welcome.

2001
03:30:17.170 --> 03:30:17.426
<v Dean Barnett>Thank you.

2002
03:30:19.502 --> 03:30:20.933
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're all welcome to— whoever wants to jump in.

2003
03:30:21.351 --> 03:30:22.091
<v Sarah Sofer>Oh, hi.

2004
03:30:23.635 --> 03:30:24.566
<v Sarah Sofer>My name is Sarah Sofer.

2005
03:30:24.968 --> 03:30:33.798
<v Sarah Sofer>I'm here as a member of the Unite Here Local 8 Union and as a concession worker employed by Levy Restaurants at the P5 Theaters.

2006
03:30:34.719 --> 03:30:39.602
<v Sarah Sofer>And my stance on today's topic is please don't close the Keller Auditorium for a remodel.

2007
03:30:40.056 --> 03:30:46.796
<v Sarah Sofer>And please, whatever operating model you choose, make sure that you keep Thank you.

2008
03:30:48.255 --> 03:30:55.164
<v Sarah Sofer>Closing the Keller for the remodel would gravely impact so many employees with good union jobs who make the P5 theaters run smoothly.

2009
03:30:56.548 --> 03:31:01.236
<v Sarah Sofer>We depend on the Broadway series, the ballet, the opera, and other shows to make ends meet.

2010
03:31:01.397 --> 03:31:03.329
<v Sarah Sofer>Without that, jobs would be unsustainable.

2011
03:31:04.809 --> 03:31:18.001
<v Sarah Sofer>The spectrum of workers affected by these choices include people with disabilities, retired folks, those who simply can't retire, people who are supplementing their income with a second job and so on.

2012
03:31:18.468 --> 03:31:23.859
<v Sarah Sofer>We've developed a beautiful ecosystem of employees who make this operation something special.

2013
03:31:24.359 --> 03:31:33.903
<v Sarah Sofer>It's not just stand workers and bartenders, but it's stage crew, ushers, security, house managers, custodians, all of them.

2014
03:31:34.048 --> 03:31:36.505
<v Sarah Sofer>Collectively, we make this customer experience wonderful.

2015
03:31:36.586 --> 03:31:43.858
<v Sarah Sofer>So again, please consider our jobs and our union contract when making changes to the operating model because it will affect our livelihoods.

2016
03:31:43.913 --> 03:31:44.058
<v Sarah Sofer>Thank you.

2017
03:31:44.816 --> 03:31:47.236
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2018
03:31:48.038 --> 03:31:48.968
<v Bea Marston>Hello, councilors.

2019
03:31:49.640 --> 03:31:50.875
<v Bea Marston>My name is Bea Marston.

2020
03:31:51.708 --> 03:31:57.622
<v Bea Marston>I am a member of Unite Here Local 8 and an employee of Levy Restaurants working at the P5 venues.

2021
03:31:58.680 --> 03:32:03.280
<v Bea Marston>Um, I'm here to ask you, please do not close the Keller for a remodel.

2022
03:32:04.226 --> 03:32:05.652
<v Bea Marston>Our jobs won't survive that.

2023
03:32:07.094 --> 03:32:18.500
<v Bea Marston>As you— and as you move forward with a new operator, please ensure that we are able to keep working at all the cities City-owned venues and keep our pay, our benefits, and our union contract.

2024
03:32:19.447 --> 03:32:22.240
<v Bea Marston>Closing the Keller for a remodel would be disastrous.

2025
03:32:23.300 --> 03:32:25.388
<v Bea Marston>There's no way we would be able to make it through that.

2026
03:32:25.485 --> 03:32:29.498
<v Bea Marston>And it's not just about our pay, but it's also about our health insurance.

2027
03:32:29.579 --> 03:32:33.000
<v Bea Marston>Without making the hours to qualify, we would all lose our health insurance.

2028
03:32:34.139 --> 03:32:38.459
<v Bea Marston>I want to make sure you know that the food and beverage workers at P5 are P5 workers.

2029
03:32:39.038 --> 03:32:47.638
<v Bea Marston>And even if we are not directly employed by the city, 12 of our 36 current employees were employed there before COVID and came back after being laid off for 18 months.

2030
03:32:48.280 --> 03:32:49.564
<v Bea Marston>There's very little turnover.

2031
03:32:49.708 --> 03:32:53.782
<v Bea Marston>Over the years, we have fought through contract bargaining to make these really good union jobs.

2032
03:32:54.200 --> 03:32:58.995
<v Bea Marston>Our pay and benefits are much better than our levy workers at Moda who are fighting to have a union.

2033
03:32:59.831 --> 03:33:05.574
<v Bea Marston>Please make sure that the progress is not erased and we can continue to build on our wins.

2034
03:33:06.086 --> 03:33:11.911
<v Bea Marston>We are here again to ask you as you make decisions about the Keller to keep the workers in mind.

2035
03:33:12.120 --> 03:33:12.753
<v Bea Marston>Thank you very much.

2036
03:33:13.255 --> 03:33:13.645
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2037
03:33:16.512 --> 03:33:25.172
<v Andrew Kolas>Okay, um, uh, President Dunphy, um, VP Clark, um, Administrator, thank you for the moment, the time today.

2038
03:33:25.735 --> 03:33:38.463
<v Andrew Kolas>I come back, um, in, uh, support of the proposal that PSU has put forth, and I come forth, um, as the I run Colas Family Companies.

2039
03:33:38.559 --> 03:33:40.066
<v Andrew Kolas>We have a development and construction company.

2040
03:33:40.483 --> 03:33:49.600
<v Andrew Kolas>We were selected to be the exclusive developer of the hotel that would be adjacent to the new performing arts and culture center.

2041
03:33:49.808 --> 03:33:51.924
<v Andrew Kolas>I do want to correct the record.

2042
03:33:52.500 --> 03:33:55.849
<v Andrew Kolas>There's no subsidy that we are requesting at this time.

2043
03:33:56.265 --> 03:33:58.413
<v Andrew Kolas>However, if you want to provide one, I would love one.

2044
03:33:59.887 --> 03:34:01.521
<v Andrew Kolas>But I need to correct that record.

2045
03:34:01.648 --> 03:34:05.018
<v Andrew Kolas>We went after this project Because I talked about it earlier.

2046
03:34:05.340 --> 03:34:06.977
<v Andrew Kolas>I'm a Portlander, born and raised here.

2047
03:34:07.265 --> 03:34:08.037
<v Andrew Kolas>I love this city.

2048
03:34:08.534 --> 03:34:13.174
<v Andrew Kolas>And as Congressman Blumenauer talked about, this is about vision.

2049
03:34:13.528 --> 03:34:22.615
<v Andrew Kolas>This is about revisioning the way that we can have people come, the vibrancy that can partake when we reimagine what this looks like.

2050
03:34:22.922 --> 03:34:27.995
<v Andrew Kolas>That doesn't mean that we can't reimagine the way that Keller will live and work as well.

2051
03:34:28.043 --> 03:34:32.009
<v Andrew Kolas>Councilor I also am here because of the people that are next to me.

2052
03:34:33.197 --> 03:34:40.486
<v Andrew Kolas>I've done the analysis on the construction side of the renovation, and contrary to what everybody says, it's about net neutral.

2053
03:34:40.984 --> 03:34:45.527
<v Andrew Kolas>But we cannot forget about these people and their employment and these jobs.

2054
03:34:46.200 --> 03:34:46.763
<v Andrew Kolas>We cannot.

2055
03:34:47.228 --> 03:34:57.030
<v Andrew Kolas>It's very important to the vibrancy of our city, our state, and I fully support this, and I recommend that you move forward in Thank you.

2056
03:34:57.837 --> 03:34:58.209
<v Bob Nadeau>Thank you.

2057
03:35:02.877 --> 03:35:04.066
<v Kyle Huth>Hello, my name is Kyle Huth.

2058
03:35:04.820 --> 03:35:09.143
<v Kyle Huth>I am a PSU graduate and a proud member of the IATSE Local 28.

2059
03:35:10.188 --> 03:35:20.838
<v Kyle Huth>I come here to speak in positivity of the PSU option because just 5 blocks south where the Keller sits is an opportunity.

2060
03:35:20.940 --> 03:35:44.254
<v Kyle Huth>It is a project combining private capital to a hotel and retail and public funding to realize a space that can both accommodate modern touring shows and also a space that can be available to smaller community events, which are sorely overlooked, and in cooperation with PSU and provides exceptional access to the next generation of theater professionals in our city.

2061
03:35:45.472 --> 03:35:46.898
<v Kyle Huth>It is a bold and ambitious plan.

2062
03:35:47.252 --> 03:35:50.769
<v Kyle Huth>And one that comes with a century-long roadmap to carry Portland brightly into the future.

2063
03:35:51.667 --> 03:35:58.748
<v Kyle Huth>The PSU proposal is an investment in Portland and its culture, and also an investment in preserving the living wage jobs these venues provide.

2064
03:35:59.279 --> 03:35:59.504
<v Kyle Huth>Thank you.

2065
03:36:00.563 --> 03:36:01.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all very much.

2066
03:36:02.168 --> 03:36:02.505
<v Ernest Munch>Thank you.

2067
03:36:03.228 --> 03:36:03.709
<v Keelan McClymont>On the agenda.

2068
03:36:14.147 --> 03:36:18.645
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>Uh, good evening, President Dunphy and members of Portland City Council.

2069
03:36:19.367 --> 03:36:23.029
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>My name is Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos and I live in District 1.

2070
03:36:23.927 --> 03:36:26.932
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>I am also a business representative for La Unión 737.

2071
03:36:27.156 --> 03:36:38.929
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>We represent approximately 2,800 union members across Oregon and 178 registered apprentices, with another 100 people who are waiting to begin their first union dispatch.

2072
03:36:39.682 --> 03:36:45.979
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>I urge you to support this resolution moving the Portland State University Performing Arts and Culture Center forward.

2073
03:36:46.172 --> 03:36:49.584
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>This project is, is about more than constructing a new building.

2074
03:36:49.697 --> 03:36:55.112
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>It is an investment in Portland's workers, students, creativity, community, and downtown economy.

2075
03:36:55.865 --> 03:37:08.579
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>The project would bring a modern, seismic-safe, 3,000-seat performance venue to downtown Portland while creating classrooms, rehearsals, studios, community spaces, An opportunity for local art organization.

2076
03:37:09.559 --> 03:37:17.899
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>Most importantly, projects like this is— this are creating family wage jobs and family-supporting careers.

2077
03:37:18.414 --> 03:37:25.692
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>They give apprentices the hand-on experience needed to build stable futures while strengthening our local economy.

2078
03:37:26.513 --> 03:37:31.397
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>Portland has the opportunity to create something that will serve the community for generations.

2079
03:37:31.445 --> 03:37:31.575
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>Thank you.

2080
03:37:31.993 --> 03:37:50.318
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>Please vote yes on this important, important project and move it forward, but do so with a strong community labor agreement and strong labor standards that protect the workers and create equitable opportunities to ensure that this is a public investment benefits our community, and that is during construction and operation.

2081
03:37:51.260 --> 03:37:52.052
<v Anjanette Benuelos-Balanos>Thank you for your time.

2082
03:37:53.095 --> 03:37:53.657
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2083
03:37:56.743 --> 03:37:59.097
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Andrew Smith.

2084
03:38:00.023 --> 03:38:08.828
<v Keelan McClymont>Joyce Follingstad, Anthony Samperio— Samperio, excuse me— Russell Benton, Ernest Munch.

2085
03:38:21.108 --> 03:38:22.693
<v Keelan McClymont>Andrew, go ahead.

2086
03:38:31.454 --> 03:38:31.584
<v John Russell>Hi.

2087
03:38:31.952 --> 03:38:32.884
<v Andrew Smith>Hello, City Councilors.

2088
03:38:33.397 --> 03:38:34.488
<v Andrew Smith>My name is Andrew Smith.

2089
03:38:35.163 --> 03:38:38.933
<v Andrew Smith>I'm a resident of District 4 and a principal at Hinneberry Eddy Architects.

2090
03:38:40.121 --> 03:38:52.722
<v Andrew Smith>Having led the comprehensive feasibility study for modernizing the Keller completed in 2023, I can say with confidence that every challenge currently facing the Keller Has an achievable solution.

2091
03:38:53.468 --> 03:38:59.175
<v Andrew Smith>It can be comparable to a new 3,000-seat theater, and it can be done for far less cost.

2092
03:39:01.352 --> 03:39:09.209
<v Andrew Smith>We're very quickly approaching a point in our world where building new square footage is becoming the last resort compared to adapting existing buildings.

2093
03:39:09.950 --> 03:39:11.629
<v Andrew Smith>It's a simple matter of sustainability.

2094
03:39:13.860 --> 03:39:18.897
<v Andrew Smith>In difficult economic times, it's more important than ever to leverage the assets that we already have.

2095
03:39:18.978 --> 03:39:19.174
<v Andrew Smith>Thank you.

2096
03:39:19.933 --> 03:39:22.997
<v Andrew Smith>In that sense, Keller is a bird in the hand.

2097
03:39:24.168 --> 03:39:28.050
<v Andrew Smith>Broadway has committed to be at the Keller for many more years, and for good reason.

2098
03:39:28.997 --> 03:39:47.262
<v Andrew Smith>Instead of committing $44 million towards a new theater on PSU's campus, I urge you to invest a third of that, just $15 million, into the Keller to make things even better for audiences, performers, stagehands, concession workers, and others for the next 7 years.

2099
03:39:48.786 --> 03:40:02.782
<v Andrew Smith>If you proceed with this resolution, I feel confident that we'll be back here in 2 years having this conversation again with very little progress made towards what to me seems like an unachievable new theater development.

2100
03:40:02.927 --> 03:40:03.171
<v Jesse Wolf>Thank you.

2101
03:40:04.300 --> 03:40:04.947
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2102
03:40:10.977 --> 03:40:12.281
<v Joyce Follingstad>I'm Joyce Fallingstead.

2103
03:40:14.000 --> 03:40:15.861
<v Joyce Follingstad>Good afternoon, city councilors.

2104
03:40:17.027 --> 03:40:19.908
<v Joyce Follingstad>I'm a nurse and a psychologist and a concerned citizen.

2105
03:40:21.432 --> 03:40:37.334
<v Joyce Follingstad>I'm testifying to oppose the proposal for the Portland City Council to finance, build, and operate a new Broadway theater on the south end of the PSU campus, requiring a new parking garage and other supporting infrastructure.

2106
03:40:38.438 --> 03:40:53.113
<v Joyce Follingstad>I'm here to encourage the approval of the Keller affordable fix to complete the deferred maintenance and to make improvements that would include a retrofitting in preparation for the earthquake for which we are all preparing.

2107
03:40:54.254 --> 03:41:02.506
<v Joyce Follingstad>I have many wonderful memories of attending events at the Keller Auditorium and enjoying the beautiful forecourt fountain.

2108
03:41:02.620 --> 03:41:02.908
<v Joyce Follingstad>Thank you.

2109
03:41:04.127 --> 03:41:13.279
<v Joyce Follingstad>Currently, you have authorized a 7-year agreement with Broadway Across America to continue presenting shows at the Keller until 2033.

2110
03:41:14.240 --> 03:41:20.861
<v Joyce Follingstad>At the same time, other venues across the city have presentations that do not always fill to capacity.

2111
03:41:21.518 --> 03:41:34.626
<v Joyce Follingstad>I do not think we need to increase theater seats, nor do I think it's wise to undertake new construction given our city's current financial undertaking with the Moda Center and the increased cost of fuel and building materials.

2112
03:41:37.379 --> 03:41:45.087
<v Joyce Follingstad>Let us not move with haste to commit $44 million to the PSU plan when we have no details about how the money would be used.

2113
03:41:45.620 --> 03:41:53.881
<v Joyce Follingstad>We have no studies that a new theater is actually needed, would be financially viable, or is in the best location at 4th and Lincoln.

2114
03:41:54.689 --> 03:42:11.472
<v Joyce Follingstad>Let us invest in the Keller affordable fixed plan, investing just $15 million to improve this, our beloved largest theater, which will continue to advantage downtown businesses and support the ongoing revitalization of Portland's downtown.

2115
03:42:12.070 --> 03:42:12.459
<v Joyce Follingstad>Thank you.

2116
03:42:12.573 --> 03:42:13.188
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2117
03:42:15.850 --> 03:42:16.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, please.

2118
03:42:18.231 --> 03:42:19.058
<v Ernest Munch>My name is Ernie Munch.

2119
03:42:19.122 --> 03:42:37.120
<v Ernest Munch>I'm an architect, urban planner, hoping to retire moving this venue to the edge of the core next to I-405 would be a step back from the plate and from our needed efforts to revitalize downtown.

2120
03:42:37.856 --> 03:42:41.254
<v Ernest Munch>You need concentration of activity and investment.

2121
03:42:41.494 --> 03:42:50.498
<v Ernest Munch>It's a step back from the private investments of like the Forecourt Fountain, the public investment, the parking structures, the hotels, the restaurants.

2122
03:42:50.563 --> 03:42:50.754
<v Ernest Munch>Thank you.

2123
03:42:51.415 --> 03:42:54.490
<v Ernest Munch>That would have to be recreated at the PSU venue.

2124
03:42:55.055 --> 03:43:03.097
<v Ernest Munch>If PSU needs these facilities that they've talked about, and I don't doubt that they do, they should build it on their site.

2125
03:43:03.824 --> 03:43:17.292
<v Ernest Munch>But the Keller Auditorium is, you've heard, structurally sound, more sound than we thought it was, and it can be remodeled in stages to prevent closing and the unemployment that the actors feel.

2126
03:43:17.342 --> 03:43:17.519
<v Ernest Munch>Thank you.

2127
03:43:18.668 --> 03:43:23.852
<v Ernest Munch>And it would cost approximately $165 million less.

2128
03:43:24.783 --> 03:43:31.781
<v Ernest Munch>And that is not including all the things that have to be recreated at the PSU site.

2129
03:43:32.246 --> 03:43:43.449
<v Ernest Munch>The environment— what we're walking away from environmentally is a whole bunch of existing building which would have to be torn down perhaps or recreated.

2130
03:43:43.963 --> 03:43:51.736
<v Ernest Munch>It's much better, much more sound to remodel and reuse what you have than it is to recreate and tear it down.

2131
03:43:52.729 --> 03:43:59.416
<v Ernest Munch>You know that the city cannot afford to have 2 of these venues.

2132
03:44:00.590 --> 03:44:02.030
<v Ernest Munch>So splitting it apart might be good.

2133
03:44:02.612 --> 03:44:07.094
<v Ernest Munch>And we have a proposal that's been priced out by Hedeberry Eddy.

2134
03:44:07.144 --> 03:44:13.513
<v Ernest Munch>You've heard from them, which will Thank you very much.

2135
03:44:16.070 --> 03:44:16.377
<v Keelan McClymont>Anthony.

2136
03:44:18.804 --> 03:44:23.049
<v Anthony Samperio>Good evening, Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of the City Council.

2137
03:44:23.709 --> 03:44:35.206
<v Anthony Samperio>My name is Anthony Samperio, and I am a political organizer with the Oregon Laborers District Council, representing over 4,000 union members, including over 2,800 with Local 737, who are primarily construction craft laborers.

2138
03:44:35.823 --> 03:44:42.865
<v Anthony Samperio>In addition, our state-registered apprenticeship program has over 175 apprentices, with more than half being women and people of color.

2139
03:44:43.058 --> 03:44:46.860
<v Anthony Samperio>I'm asking that you support the agenda item before you this, this evening.

2140
03:44:47.389 --> 03:44:53.358
<v Anthony Samperio>I'm also a delegate of the Columbia Pacific Building Trades Council and a board member of the Metro Alliance for Workforce Equity.

2141
03:44:54.014 --> 03:45:01.506
<v Anthony Samperio>Portland State University's commitment to labor standards allows for several different standards that add value.

2142
03:45:01.876 --> 03:45:12.406
<v Anthony Samperio>To public contracting, such as state-registered apprenticeship and utilization goals, local hire requirements, and advancing minority, women, veteran emerging business enterprises.

2143
03:45:12.951 --> 03:45:39.398
<v Anthony Samperio>Projects with apprenticeship utilization requirements, which can include demographic goals by race and gender, provide historically underrepresented populations in our industry with jobs that build their careers, earn family-sustaining wages, contribute to their employer-sponsored pensions, Please support this proposal with strong labor standards during both building and, uh, throughout operations for the lifetime of the venue.

2144
03:45:39.931 --> 03:45:40.478
<v Anthony Samperio>Thank you for your time.

2145
03:45:42.229 --> 03:45:42.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2146
03:45:49.763 --> 03:45:56.834
<v Russell Benton>Thank you, Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of the council and city administrator.

2147
03:45:57.221 --> 03:45:57.606
<v Russell Benton>Thank you, Mayor.

2148
03:45:57.703 --> 03:45:59.292
<v Russell Benton>Thank you for your time today.

2149
03:45:59.469 --> 03:46:00.882
<v Russell Benton>For the record, my name is Russell Benton.

2150
03:46:00.995 --> 03:46:04.093
<v Russell Benton>I'm a regional representative for the Sheet Metal Workers of SMART Local 16.

2151
03:46:04.672 --> 03:46:13.807
<v Russell Benton>We are proud to give our public support for the proposal 4-acre development of the Portland State University, PSU, new performing arts venue and hotel development.

2152
03:46:14.224 --> 03:46:52.333
<v Russell Benton>We are happy to announce that the PSU and Columbia Pacific Building Trades Council reached an agreement to ensure that PSU-owned portions of this The fact that the, the project workforce development agreement with PSU, which they proactively negotiated with the Columbia Pacific Building Trades Council, is indicative of an equity-centered commitment to collaboratively building economic justice in downtown Portland.

2153
03:46:52.879 --> 03:46:57.102
<v Russell Benton>This project is unlike any other in the city of Portland has considered in recent years.

2154
03:46:57.600 --> 03:47:20.191
<v Russell Benton>It has the potential to increase foot traffic downtown and put cranes in the air for decades to come, all while advancing the commitment to the workforce development, business development, and labor engagement through compliance pathways approach, ensuring supporting for high-roads responsible contractors skilled trained workforce utilization and project labor agreements.

2155
03:47:20.560 --> 03:47:30.739
<v Russell Benton>Many studies have shown that PLAs expand local hire opportunities and to the workforce, just, and also to the disadvantaged folks that live in those areas.

2156
03:47:31.752 --> 03:47:33.951
<v Russell Benton>So please support these.

2157
03:47:34.641 --> 03:47:39.877
<v Russell Benton>So please, please support the working families of Portland and beyond.

2158
03:47:39.924 --> 03:47:40.423
<v Russell Benton>Thank you so much.

2159
03:47:43.317 --> 03:47:46.250
<v Keelan McClymont>Our last testifier today is Dana West.

2160
03:47:52.520 --> 03:47:56.284
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dana, you don't have to run, but take your— I can see you.

2161
03:47:56.431 --> 03:47:57.584
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll wait for a second.

2162
03:47:58.120 --> 03:47:58.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr. Q.

2163
03:48:02.927 --> 03:48:03.412
<v Jamie Dunphy>Fire pole.

2164
03:48:03.637 --> 03:48:04.218
<v Emily Horton>A fire pole.

2165
03:48:04.346 --> 03:48:06.541
<v Rose Etta Venitucci>You could have her, you know, propel in with a rigging rope.

2166
03:48:06.783 --> 03:48:07.638
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mean, you guys do rigging.

2167
03:48:11.176 --> 03:48:11.403
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

2168
03:48:11.806 --> 03:48:13.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, corny dad joke.

2169
03:48:14.484 --> 03:48:16.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, where does King Arthur keep his armies?

2170
03:48:18.823 --> 03:48:19.613
<v Jamie Dunphy>In his sleevies.

2171
03:48:25.188 --> 03:48:26.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>His armies in his sleevies.

2172
03:48:31.868 --> 03:48:33.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>Nine votes to remove President Dusty.

2173
03:48:33.531 --> 03:48:36.537
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll vote yes.

2174
03:48:42.659 --> 03:48:45.336
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mean, honestly, let it go.

2175
03:48:52.100 --> 03:48:52.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

2176
03:48:52.760 --> 03:48:53.066
<v Dana West>Thank you.

2177
03:48:55.576 --> 03:48:56.769
<v Dana West>Uh, good evening, council members.

2178
03:48:56.880 --> 03:48:58.733
<v Dana West>For the record, my name is Dana West.

2179
03:48:59.280 --> 03:49:01.694
<v Dana West>I'm an executive board officer with IATSE Local 28.

2180
03:49:02.268 --> 03:49:10.445
<v Dana West>I've been working as a stagehand in Portland for over 20 years, and I have been attending events at Portland Five venues for my entire life.

2181
03:49:11.683 --> 03:49:20.279
<v Dana West>I'm here speaking in favor of the new PSU Performing Arts Center, followed by a renovation of the Keller into a modern 1,800-seat venue.

2182
03:49:21.628 --> 03:49:43.825
<v Dana West>This guarantees continuity for our largest events, such as touring Broadway shows, and protects good-paying union jobs while also creating a valuable intermediate venue for other productions and protects our artistic legacy while opening up new artistic, economic, and educational opportunities for the future.

2183
03:49:45.451 --> 03:49:53.674
<v Dana West>I believe that our path forward can best be summed up with these words from Stephen Sondheim's Sunday in the Park with George.

2184
03:49:55.770 --> 03:50:01.650
<v Dana West>Bit by bit, putting it together, only way to make a work of art.

2185
03:50:02.691 --> 03:50:04.263
<v Dana West>Every moment makes a contribution.

2186
03:50:05.079 --> 03:50:06.859
<v Dana West>Every little detail plays a part.

2187
03:50:08.125 --> 03:50:10.352
<v Dana West>Having just the visions, no solution.

2188
03:50:11.170 --> 03:50:13.718
<v Dana West>Everything depends on execution.

2189
03:50:14.790 --> 03:50:17.548
<v Dana West>Putting it together, that's what counts.

2190
03:50:18.477 --> 03:50:19.165
<v Dana West>Thank you all for your time.

2191
03:50:20.239 --> 03:50:21.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2192
03:50:22.084 --> 03:50:23.014
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

2193
03:50:23.369 --> 03:50:29.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, I'm always happy to keep staff late in order to hear public testimony, but I'm not willing to keep staff later to hear us argue.

2194
03:50:29.807 --> 03:50:36.744
<v Jamie Dunphy>So with that, we are going to carry these 2 items over to a future council meeting, and we are adjourned.

