WEBVTT

1
00:05:59.480 --> 00:06:00.144
<v Candace Avalos>Good afternoon.

2
00:06:02.315 --> 00:06:11.925
<v Candace Avalos>I am going to call the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee to order, order on Tuesday, September Councilor Tiffany Koyama Lane.

3
00:06:15.036 --> 00:06:15.148
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

4
00:06:15.855 --> 00:06:16.240
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick.

5
00:06:18.103 --> 00:06:18.473
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

6
00:06:18.665 --> 00:06:19.502
<v Mitch Green>Here.

7
00:06:20.031 --> 00:06:20.482
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney.

8
00:06:21.043 --> 00:06:21.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

9
00:06:21.944 --> 00:06:22.249
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos.

10
00:06:22.505 --> 00:06:22.843
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

11
00:06:23.406 --> 00:06:24.754
<v Candace Avalos>Claire, please read the statement of conduct.

12
00:06:26.300 --> 00:06:26.656
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair.

13
00:06:26.817 --> 00:06:29.297
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon and welcome to the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

14
00:06:29.879 --> 00:06:40.548
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at portland.gov /council/agenda/housing-and-permitting-committee or by calling 311.

15
00:06:41.303 --> 00:06:44.261
<v Unidentified speaker>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

16
00:06:44.838 --> 00:06:47.458
<v Unidentified speaker>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

17
00:06:48.199 --> 00:06:53.673
<v Unidentified speaker>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

18
00:06:54.187 --> 00:06:56.185
<v Unidentified speaker>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

19
00:06:56.759 --> 00:06:57.672
<v Unidentified speaker>The chair preserves order.

20
00:06:57.851 --> 00:07:05.894
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, Or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

21
00:07:06.598 --> 00:07:08.571
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

22
00:07:09.083 --> 00:07:11.776
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

23
00:07:12.449 --> 00:07:15.382
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

24
00:07:16.120 --> 00:07:18.988
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

25
00:07:19.822 --> 00:07:21.841
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

26
00:07:22.225 --> 00:07:24.069
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, state your name for the record.

27
00:07:24.485 --> 00:07:27.115
<v Unidentified speaker>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

28
00:07:27.435 --> 00:07:30.961
<v Unidentified speaker>And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

29
00:07:31.170 --> 00:07:31.444
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

30
00:07:31.670 --> 00:07:32.285
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Claire.

31
00:07:32.899 --> 00:07:34.904
<v Candace Avalos>We have 3 items on our agenda today.

32
00:07:35.083 --> 00:07:39.175
<v Candace Avalos>We will first have time for public comment on housing and permitting issues.

33
00:07:39.531 --> 00:07:51.302
<v Candace Avalos>Then I will give a brief update on community engagement for the Unified Housing Strategy, and we will discuss a resolution on nondisclosure agreements related to data centers that is being brought forward by Councilor Koyama Lane and Vice Chair Green.

34
00:07:52.120 --> 00:07:53.708
<v Candace Avalos>With that, Wendy, please read the first item.

35
00:07:55.944 --> 00:08:03.004
<v Unidentified speaker>Item number 1, Housing and Permitting Community Feedback, item number 2026-296.

36
00:08:03.725 --> 00:08:07.283
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so we will hear from community members on their concerns, ideas, or feedback.

37
00:08:07.346 --> 00:08:13.853
<v Candace Avalos>And just also a reminder to folks that this, uh, time is open for any kind of commentary you want to make.

38
00:08:13.901 --> 00:08:15.983
<v Candace Avalos>Doesn't have to be anything that is on the agenda.

39
00:08:16.305 --> 00:08:20.439
<v Candace Avalos>So please do continue to sign up and share your experiences and your thoughts with us.

40
00:08:21.192 --> 00:08:23.019
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, Wendy, go ahead and please call up our testifiers.

41
00:08:24.338 --> 00:08:26.449
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, Amber Cook is joining us online.

42
00:08:29.600 --> 00:08:29.889
<v Candace Avalos>Welcome, Amber.

43
00:08:29.954 --> 00:08:30.324
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

44
00:08:31.663 --> 00:08:32.921
<v Amber Cook>Okay, thank you.

45
00:08:33.888 --> 00:08:35.886
<v Amber Cook>Yeah, greetings to the committee members.

46
00:08:36.015 --> 00:08:37.192
<v Amber Cook>My name is Amber Cook.

47
00:08:38.993 --> 00:08:47.609
<v Amber Cook>This does relate to both the proposed ban on the NDAs for data center negotiations and the unified housing strategy.

48
00:08:48.384 --> 00:08:55.648
<v Amber Cook>This is just a short bit from an article by Rob Davis, ProPublica, that was put on OregonLive August 21st.

49
00:08:55.969 --> 00:09:00.812
<v Amber Cook>Some Oregon spending on low-income housing has exploded in the past 5 years.

50
00:09:01.229 --> 00:09:07.740
<v Amber Cook>The state has given developers an unprecedented $1.4 billion, and the cost of developing each apartment is nearly doubled.

51
00:09:08.061 --> 00:09:10.049
<v Amber Cook>That's like $540,000 each.

52
00:09:10.466 --> 00:09:15.485
<v Amber Cook>Dozens of projects are lined up for an additional $850 million in future state funding.

53
00:09:15.839 --> 00:09:20.778
<v Amber Cook>And then just aside, and the city has $35 million coming up for, you know, the same kind of dispersal.

54
00:09:20.875 --> 00:09:20.986
<v Amber Cook>Thank you.

55
00:09:22.254 --> 00:09:23.952
<v Amber Cook>But one thing has remained constant in Oregon.

56
00:09:24.000 --> 00:09:28.186
<v Amber Cook>The public isn't allowed to see the details of how these dollars are being spent.

57
00:09:29.629 --> 00:09:49.591
<v Amber Cook>So, in, in, for those who don't know, in like 1997, state legislatures passed a law that prevents our government from disclosing the financial details of subsidized housing projects, thwarting researchers, advocates, and journalists trying to examine their cost and understand why things aren't improving and Oregon's homeless population continues to grow.

58
00:09:50.538 --> 00:10:00.984
<v Amber Cook>Transacting public money behind closed doors allows for abuse and misuse that we can clearly see has gone too far and must be curbed by public pressure and elected official action.

59
00:10:01.929 --> 00:10:17.158
<v Amber Cook>We saw a few meetings ago where the Portland Housing Bureau did a slide presentation on kind of the public's reaction to, you know, taxes and spending, where it said, you know, basically the public is generally okay with the taxation.

60
00:10:17.639 --> 00:10:22.336
<v Amber Cook>For housing, but not when it isn't getting results, and it isn't.

61
00:10:22.480 --> 00:10:31.072
<v Amber Cook>Anyone living in low-income housing can tell you that conditions across the board have deteriorated sharply since the housing crisis started 14 years ago.

62
00:10:32.003 --> 00:10:49.123
<v Amber Cook>Although landlord developers like to blame COVID, the degradation of housing started a few years before that, as their private— as their higher profit extraction demands made their property management companies have to stop necessary and normal business expenses.

63
00:10:49.490 --> 00:10:57.501
<v Amber Cook>To To save money to generate those higher profits, which sadly works because no one will hold them accountable to landlord-tenant laws and city codes.

64
00:10:57.966 --> 00:11:09.517
<v Amber Cook>While no one is, of course, an exaggeration, it's not based on years of lived experience trying to get anyone to hold slumlords here accountable for violations and ongoing negligence.

65
00:11:10.317 --> 00:11:22.784
<v Amber Cook>So please, before you open up the public coffers and start pouring millions more into these for-profit developers' pockets, you'll want to understand— you'll want to demand financial transparency.

66
00:11:23.684 --> 00:11:32.628
<v Amber Cook>Insist on the bailouts producing lower, more wage-affordable rents rather than just giving them the money with no expectation of what comes out of it.

67
00:11:33.077 --> 00:11:35.485
<v Amber Cook>And then, of course, hear from a wide range of renters.

68
00:11:36.208 --> 00:11:45.472
<v Amber Cook>Um, it's not proven useful to just listen to the lobbying narratives of property owners who are costing us millions and not producing sufficient affordable and safe housing.

69
00:11:46.019 --> 00:11:46.163
<v Amber Cook>Thank you.

70
00:11:46.244 --> 00:11:46.356
<v Amber Cook>Thank you.

71
00:11:47.821 --> 00:11:49.091
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Amber, for your testimony.

72
00:11:51.149 --> 00:11:52.535
<v Candace Avalos>Do we have others on the list today?

73
00:11:52.714 --> 00:11:54.326
<v Keelan McClymont>That concludes public input.

74
00:11:54.890 --> 00:11:56.745
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you.

75
00:11:57.133 --> 00:11:59.293
<v Candace Avalos>Um, let's go ahead and call item 2.

76
00:12:02.547 --> 00:12:08.466
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 2, document number 2026-297, Unified Housing Strategy Engagement Update.

77
00:12:09.842 --> 00:12:19.846
<v Candace Avalos>All right, colleagues, so this is just a little, uh, verbal update for you on what's been going on with the UHS, or Unified Housing Strategy, um, where we are with the engagement.

78
00:12:20.649 --> 00:12:34.582
<v Candace Avalos>And so as a reminder, council adopted the Unified Housing Strategy resolution last year with the goal of bringing the city's housing work into one coordinated strategy with clearer priorities, measurable outcomes, and stronger alignment across bureaus and with our community partners.

79
00:12:35.177 --> 00:12:48.389
<v Candace Avalos>So over the last several months, I've been working closely with the Housing Bureau and the CEDSA, the Community and Economic Development Service Area bureaus, and their staff to help plan and lead the engagement process that is going to inform that strategy.

80
00:12:48.966 --> 00:12:59.889
<v Candace Avalos>So what we have done so far has largely taken the form of World Cafe-style stakeholder discussions with subject matter experts from across Portland's housing ecosystem.

81
00:13:00.434 --> 00:13:12.048
<v Candace Avalos>This includes the stakeholder list that we shared with committee a couple months ago, and committee members had the opportunity to review and provide some feedback and identify additional people and organizations who should be invited to those conversations.

82
00:13:12.785 --> 00:13:23.523
<v Candace Avalos>The goal of these sessions has been to bring together people with deep experience experience in different parts of the housing system and give them space to work through the actual policy and implementation questions in small group discussions.

83
00:13:24.019 --> 00:13:28.177
<v Candace Avalos>So on August 10th, we held our first session focused on housing preservation.

84
00:13:28.947 --> 00:13:34.567
<v Candace Avalos>So that is on how we sustain the housing we already have, protect affordability, and prevent the loss of existing units.

85
00:13:35.177 --> 00:13:43.828
<v Candace Avalos>On August 11th, we held a second session focused on housing production, including how Portland can support the development of more housing across different types and income levels.

86
00:13:44.504 --> 00:13:54.427
<v Candace Avalos>Our 3rd session took place yesterday on August 31st, and we focused on funding, specifically how we build a more sustainable and durable funding strategy for Portland's housing goals.

87
00:13:55.246 --> 00:14:10.729
<v Candace Avalos>In all of the sessions, participants were reviewing city actions, existing city actions, discussing which strategies should be prioritized, identified implementation barriers, and talked about where the city can lead versus where success will require shared ownership with other partners.

88
00:14:12.027 --> 00:14:22.831
<v Candace Avalos>I have really appreciated the depth of those conversations and the willingness of participants to move beyond just identifying challenges, but actually starting to grapple with the trade-offs and priorities and what implementation actually requires.

89
00:14:23.183 --> 00:14:34.822
<v Candace Avalos>We have been very diligent in these meetings to say that we want people to come to the table to be part of those solutions and be those partners that we need, that the city needs in order to move these goals forward.

90
00:14:35.030 --> 00:14:38.284
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm very grateful that folks have leaned into that.

91
00:14:39.215 --> 00:14:44.866
<v Candace Avalos>We have— we decided we needed a little bit more engagement on production and preservation.

92
00:14:44.931 --> 00:14:48.664
<v Candace Avalos>So we have planned 2 additional opportunities in September.

93
00:14:49.682 --> 00:14:58.923
<v Candace Avalos>Currently, those are scheduled for September 22nd for production and September 25th for preservation, and they will be virtual to maximize participation.

94
00:14:59.929 --> 00:15:09.927
<v Candace Avalos>We also have an event or another forum on September 8th, and that one is focused on Goal 3 of the strategy, which is largely around social housing and innovation.

95
00:15:10.812 --> 00:15:17.817
<v Candace Avalos>So now what we're going to do is work to schedule engagement in each council district open to all members of the public.

96
00:15:17.883 --> 00:15:22.644
<v Candace Avalos>So the district-based conversations are going to look different from the subject matter expert sessions.

97
00:15:22.740 --> 00:15:30.243
<v Candace Avalos>These are intended to be broader community conversations that are accessible to all community members, not just people who work professionally in housing.

98
00:15:30.916 --> 00:15:41.326
<v Candace Avalos>And that is an important part of the process because lived experience, as we know, and neighborhood experience need to sit alongside technical expertise as we are deciding what strategy we should prioritize.

99
00:15:41.759 --> 00:16:02.188
<v Candace Avalos>So we will take everything that we've consolidated through the help of our partners and stakeholders, package that in a way that the public can digest and get their feedback again on where we need to be putting our prioritization, which is a big part of this goal because we have lots of objectives and goals and ideas, but we have to prioritize them with our limited resources.

100
00:16:02.461 --> 00:16:08.089
<v Candace Avalos>And decide again how we are— what's the goal we're working towards and the strategy to get there.

101
00:16:08.990 --> 00:16:17.102
<v Candace Avalos>PHB has also created a public-facing website where the public can learn more about the Unified Housing Strategy and these upcoming engagement dates.

102
00:16:17.215 --> 00:16:18.729
<v Candace Avalos>So that website is portland.gov/phb/unified-housing-strategy.

103
00:16:24.009 --> 00:16:33.115
<v Candace Avalos>So in closing, ultimately the goal is not simply to produce another long list of housing policies, It is to develop a strategy that helps us make choices.

104
00:16:33.389 --> 00:16:34.799
<v Candace Avalos>So what are we prioritizing?

105
00:16:35.312 --> 00:16:36.081
<v Candace Avalos>What are we measuring?

106
00:16:36.514 --> 00:16:37.621
<v Candace Avalos>Where should the city lead?

107
00:16:37.701 --> 00:16:38.648
<v Candace Avalos>Where do we need partners?

108
00:16:39.081 --> 00:16:42.495
<v Candace Avalos>And how are we organizing our resources around the outcomes that we're trying to achieve?

109
00:16:42.703 --> 00:16:46.567
<v Candace Avalos>So there's a lot of work ahead, but I'm very encouraged by the engagement so far.

110
00:16:46.856 --> 00:16:54.360
<v Candace Avalos>We have had very fruitful conversations, and again, grateful to staff and our partners and everyone who has contributed their time and expertise.

111
00:16:54.970 --> 00:17:04.071
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to continue to keep the committee updated as we move through this next phase of engagement and begin translating that feedback into the draft unified housing strategy.

112
00:17:04.569 --> 00:17:14.178
<v Candace Avalos>As you know, it is my intent to bring something back to this committee and then to council about, uh, us making a decision on what is our unified housing strategy vision.

113
00:17:15.607 --> 00:17:17.021
<v Candace Avalos>So that is the update.

114
00:17:17.343 --> 00:17:22.950
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, I will pause and open it up for any questions or reflections on what I've shared.

115
00:17:23.047 --> 00:17:34.721
<v Candace Avalos>And, um, also will say one thing that I have been talking with the city attorneys as it relates to, you know, we've been dealing with all these quorum-related things due to the new public meeting laws.

116
00:17:36.025 --> 00:17:42.932
<v Candace Avalos>And so essentially they are saying that, like, there's all these restrictions on who can come to these sessions.

117
00:17:43.913 --> 00:17:44.396
<v Candace Avalos>Complicated.

118
00:17:44.895 --> 00:17:46.280
<v Candace Avalos>But let's keep talking about that.

119
00:17:46.345 --> 00:17:48.791
<v Candace Avalos>I would love for councilors to be involved.

120
00:17:48.839 --> 00:17:53.372
<v Candace Avalos>I think if we can try to do it in where people can come to sessions and it not be a quorum thing, that would be ideal.

121
00:17:53.435 --> 00:17:54.776
<v Candace Avalos>But just know that it is my intent for those conversations to continue.

122
00:17:54.953 --> 00:17:55.115
<v Lynn Handlin>Thank you.

123
00:17:57.452 --> 00:18:04.482
<v Candace Avalos>To be open for councilors and also for councilors to, you know, invite their district community members to participate in that discussion.

124
00:18:04.612 --> 00:18:07.291
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

125
00:18:08.047 --> 00:18:08.448
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

126
00:18:08.511 --> 00:18:10.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think you started to get at my question right there.

127
00:18:10.855 --> 00:18:18.576
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was hoping to get a little bit more information about those district-level conversations and who would be planning those, what they would look like.

128
00:18:18.641 --> 00:18:28.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that something that you will request that each district plan and the councilors from that district will organize them, or something that you are planning on organizing across the city?

129
00:18:28.240 --> 00:18:28.480
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>City?

130
00:18:28.977 --> 00:18:30.242
<v Candace Avalos>What, what is this?

131
00:18:30.660 --> 00:18:33.353
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, so it's technically the Housing Bureau is organizing it.

132
00:18:33.401 --> 00:18:38.130
<v Candace Avalos>So like, I am a partner to the Housing Bureau, but they are organizing the, the events.

133
00:18:38.210 --> 00:18:44.059
<v Candace Avalos>Obviously would look to guidance of the councilors in each district, of course, and plan to, uh, reach out.

134
00:18:44.125 --> 00:19:01.192
<v Candace Avalos>And again, just trying to navigate the complicated laws, uh, meetings laws that the lawyers have cautioned me about, because in an ideal world, I would have wanted all the councilors and all the districts to just kind of participate, but Yes, Housing Bureau is the main, you know, person helping to organize this, obviously with my help.

135
00:19:01.609 --> 00:19:09.316
<v Candace Avalos>They've put together the format, pretty straightforward, but we definitely welcome thoughts and we will be sharing that.

136
00:19:09.364 --> 00:19:16.814
<v Candace Avalos>And that's also what the website is for, is so that as we're developing the vision for that, that can be easily accessible, not just to councilors but to the public.

137
00:19:17.007 --> 00:19:24.904
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it would be really helpful to make sure that councilors have an opportunity to be there, to make sure that the bureau is reaching out directly to the 3 councilors in each district.

138
00:19:25.948 --> 00:19:31.338
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Both to ensure that the dates work and to check in about the format.

139
00:19:31.419 --> 00:19:48.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because I know with, for example, our budget conversations, different districts decided to go about those in different ways, and it would be helpful to bring in the expertise of the 3 people who live in the district to help think about where those should be, when those should be, how they would work best for the communities that we represent.

140
00:19:49.451 --> 00:19:49.709
<v Candace Avalos>Absolutely.

141
00:19:51.681 --> 00:19:51.875
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

142
00:19:51.923 --> 00:19:54.329
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Green.

143
00:19:54.523 --> 00:19:54.863
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

144
00:19:55.234 --> 00:19:56.203
<v Mitch Green>And thanks for the update.

145
00:19:56.365 --> 00:20:00.837
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, offering my support for the District 4 scheduling.

146
00:20:00.903 --> 00:20:12.286
<v Mitch Green>I think one of the nice things about the committee being just one person from every district, each— there's a member of the committee that can kind of bottom line the interaction with the Portland Housing Bureau.

147
00:20:13.919 --> 00:20:17.250
<v Mitch Green>You mentioned lived experience a lot there, and I just tuned into that.

148
00:20:18.006 --> 00:20:20.792
<v Mitch Green>My district is more than half renters.

149
00:20:21.625 --> 00:20:23.180
<v Mitch Green>And so 53% are renters.

150
00:20:23.229 --> 00:20:38.625
<v Mitch Green>And so we're going to be very interested in making sure that the Portland Housing Bureau thinks about not scheduling these during a period of time where people are at work, scheduling them in a part of the city that tenants actually can attend to.

151
00:20:38.689 --> 00:20:43.527
<v Mitch Green>And so, and of course, the other councilors will be welcome to shape that as well.

152
00:20:43.654 --> 00:20:45.450
<v Mitch Green>But I really appreciate that.

153
00:20:45.561 --> 00:20:48.045
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a really important piece of the council-led engagement part.

154
00:20:48.125 --> 00:20:48.285
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

155
00:20:48.430 --> 00:20:50.132
<v Unidentified speaker>So just offering my partnership in that.

156
00:20:52.269 --> 00:20:52.702
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, thank you.

157
00:20:52.784 --> 00:20:53.394
<v Candace Avalos>Absolutely.

158
00:20:53.570 --> 00:21:01.720
<v Candace Avalos>And, um, I think, you know, again, trickily navigating some of the restrictions that I have been told are barriers.

159
00:21:01.800 --> 00:21:08.180
<v Candace Avalos>So, um, trying to figure out what's the best way to make sure that people can be as involved and we're following those tricky laws.

160
00:21:08.838 --> 00:21:17.872
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but yes, uh, right now the goal is for those to be scheduled Um, probably in early October is the goal.

161
00:21:18.131 --> 00:21:22.923
<v Candace Avalos>Like, the timeline has kept shifting, but we're looking at trying to get through all of those in October.

162
00:21:22.971 --> 00:21:26.950
<v Candace Avalos>So just a general time frame, but more info will be coming.

163
00:21:28.721 --> 00:21:30.153
<v Candace Avalos>Any other questions or thoughts?

164
00:21:32.913 --> 00:21:33.942
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, great.

165
00:21:34.923 --> 00:21:36.546
<v Candace Avalos>With that, let's go ahead and move to item 3.

166
00:21:36.625 --> 00:21:37.671
<v Candace Avalos>If you could please call that, Wendy.

167
00:21:39.019 --> 00:21:39.260
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

168
00:21:39.326 --> 00:21:56.573
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, item 3, document number 2026. urge the city administrator to refrain from signing data center nondisclosure agreements, notify City Council of inquiries for data center deals, and engage in transparent public processes related to data centers.

169
00:21:57.391 --> 00:21:57.888
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Wendy.

170
00:21:57.984 --> 00:22:08.944
<v Candace Avalos>So Councilor Koyama Lane and Vice Chair Green have brought to us a resolution in response to emerging concerns surrounding data center facilities, and so I will hand it off to the sponsors for opening remarks.

171
00:22:09.041 --> 00:22:17.678
<v Candace Avalos>And then I— we have staff from the Bureau of Planning Sustainability, followed by an invited panel, and then we'll open it up to public testimony and committee discussion.

172
00:22:17.773 --> 00:22:19.123
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, Councilor Koyama Lane.

173
00:22:20.021 --> 00:22:26.667
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so much, Chair Avalos, for this time on the agenda to consider this resolution that I'm co-sponsoring with Councilor Green.

174
00:22:27.742 --> 00:22:31.066
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We know that data centers are a big topic right now, and for good reason.

175
00:22:31.901 --> 00:22:36.058
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm thankful that we have the space to talk about how this affects us here in Portland.

176
00:22:36.332 --> 00:22:37.590
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's maybe one of the first questions.

177
00:22:37.785 --> 00:22:39.335
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can this affect us in Portland?

178
00:22:39.544 --> 00:22:41.707
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'll answer that really shortly.

179
00:22:42.046 --> 00:22:42.288
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes.

180
00:22:42.401 --> 00:22:45.193
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to pass around this map that's also listed as an exhibit.

181
00:22:46.880 --> 00:22:55.991
<v Unidentified speaker>This map in the online also shows that there are at least 10 sites that can accommodate a hyperscale data center in our city limits.

182
00:22:56.346 --> 00:23:01.530
<v Unidentified speaker>So if you're trying to look at the map, find the black and yellow outlines around sites.

183
00:23:01.643 --> 00:23:05.910
<v Unidentified speaker>They're in places like Hayden Island near OHSU, South Waterfront, and on both sides of the Willamette River.

184
00:23:06.006 --> 00:23:22.762
<v Unidentified speaker>And while I could go on and on about how data centers consume air, water, and land that our future generations will depend on long after a company's contract ends, as well as associated environmental health impacts.

185
00:23:23.003 --> 00:23:28.351
<v Unidentified speaker>This resolution is ultimately about good governance and protecting our process and democracy.

186
00:23:29.025 --> 00:23:37.819
<v Unidentified speaker>We need to be pushing for strong protections, and I think all of the advocates out there pushing hard for things like bans and moratoriums.

187
00:23:38.317 --> 00:23:39.855
<v Unidentified speaker>I can assure you I hear you.

188
00:23:39.936 --> 00:23:50.826
<v Unidentified speaker>I wholeheartedly agree, and I support doing what makes sense and what it takes at the state level, local level, to go as far as we can to protect ourselves and communities and our planets.

189
00:23:51.163 --> 00:23:54.660
<v Unidentified speaker>Chair, I also have an amendment that you can let me know when I should introduce that.

190
00:23:55.349 --> 00:23:55.942
<v Unidentified speaker>So I hope that—.

191
00:23:55.942 --> 00:23:57.066
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Tiffany Koyama Lane.

192
00:23:57.162 --> 00:23:58.798
<v Unidentified speaker>I hope that we can pass this swiftly.

193
00:23:59.006 --> 00:24:01.428
<v Unidentified speaker>This is— I want this to be seen as a first step.

194
00:24:01.893 --> 00:24:09.855
<v Unidentified speaker>It tells our City leadership, the executive side, not to sign secret nondisclosure agreements with data center companies.

195
00:24:10.240 --> 00:24:11.810
<v Unidentified speaker>This resolution is about transparency.

196
00:24:11.939 --> 00:24:14.886
<v Unidentified speaker>Secrecy erodes trust within our city government.

197
00:24:15.270 --> 00:24:21.983
<v Unidentified speaker>We especially don't want that with an industry that touches our drinking water, electricity, and air quality.

198
00:24:22.432 --> 00:24:26.902
<v Unidentified speaker>So normalizing transparency in our decisions is really important.

199
00:24:27.445 --> 00:24:29.961
<v Unidentified speaker>And we still are a new-ish council.

200
00:24:30.105 --> 00:24:34.575
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't feel like we're new-new, but we're still new-ish, and we are setting precedents.

201
00:24:34.832 --> 00:24:41.587
<v Unidentified speaker>And so sound, transparent processes now are really important for preventing harm in the future.

202
00:24:42.213 --> 00:24:51.008
<v Unidentified speaker>So this, I see this as a high-integrity first step that pairs well with a next important step of a moratorium or ban on hyperscale data centers.

203
00:24:52.307 --> 00:25:06.230
<v Unidentified speaker>We are monitoring what is happening with the different moratoria efforts in Hillsboro and Salem, have had a lot of conversations with our land use attorney, Attorney King, and she's been great and has— I've learned a lot already.

204
00:25:06.652 --> 00:25:07.786
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your support.

205
00:25:08.191 --> 00:25:18.490
<v Unidentified speaker>And based on conversations, you know, we— it's important to know which efforts are expected to face appealable land use decisions that may or may not be held up in court.

206
00:25:18.971 --> 00:25:25.751
<v Unidentified speaker>And you've also probably— folks have seen that Governor Kotek is leading state processes and encouraging local action.

207
00:25:26.025 --> 00:25:33.648
<v Unidentified speaker>We also need to follow what's happening at the state level to To figure out what our next steps— what makes sense for our next steps.

208
00:25:34.226 --> 00:25:39.805
<v Unidentified speaker>So, but for this today, it literally costs the city nothing to commit to being transparent.

209
00:25:40.301 --> 00:25:42.818
<v Unidentified speaker>I hope that my colleagues will vote to support this resolution.

210
00:25:43.171 --> 00:25:47.019
<v Unidentified speaker>Also open to co-sponsors if anyone is helping to leading this.

211
00:25:47.419 --> 00:26:07.609
<v Unidentified speaker>And the amendment that is listed, Koyama Lane Green 1, just to share a little bit about it, it adds a be it further resolved, that clause that states City Council intends to pursue moratorium or zoning restrictions on all hyperscale data centers at the earliest time and to consider additional approaches for large load data centers.

212
00:26:08.028 --> 00:26:12.506
<v Unidentified speaker>There's, you know, different information on vocabulary and definitions.

213
00:26:12.762 --> 00:26:17.595
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, we're seeing Washington County and Clackamas County have some movement in this area.

214
00:26:17.675 --> 00:26:29.876
<v Unidentified speaker>So this might be something that, as the City of Portland, we reach out to our colleagues in Multnomah County to see what is a good way forward and how we might want to work on that together.

215
00:26:30.502 --> 00:26:37.989
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to make sure to really thank BPS, PP&D, DC Oliveira, and Christina Gann for working with our team.

216
00:26:38.777 --> 00:26:49.394
<v Unidentified speaker>You're doing a lot of work in this area and appreciate your research looking at code trends, laying the groundwork for responsible policy and practice in this area.

217
00:26:49.797 --> 00:26:51.836
<v Unidentified speaker>And Claire Adamsick, you're amazing.

218
00:26:52.270 --> 00:26:55.805
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your research and coordination over the last couple months on this topic.

219
00:26:56.366 --> 00:26:59.238
<v Unidentified speaker>And Alan, Aubrey, and Sabatino on my team.

220
00:26:59.286 --> 00:27:03.873
<v Unidentified speaker>Sabatino is our amazing Summer Works Program intern.

221
00:27:03.922 --> 00:27:04.451
<v Unidentified speaker>We loved him.

222
00:27:04.626 --> 00:27:05.509
<v Unidentified speaker>We love him so much.

223
00:27:05.766 --> 00:27:08.300
<v Unidentified speaker>He's back at college now, but he spent a lot of time on this policy.

224
00:27:08.750 --> 00:27:09.711
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, I know it was a lot.

225
00:27:09.759 --> 00:27:17.957
<v Unidentified speaker>I could have maybe said some of that later, but now I will hand things over to my co-sponsor, Vice Chair Green, if you want to make any additional comments.

226
00:27:18.838 --> 00:27:22.319
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much, Councilor Koyama Lane, and thank you for leading on this.

227
00:27:22.432 --> 00:27:35.484
<v Unidentified speaker>This was a thing that I, would sometimes lie awake at night thinking about, you know, looking at other jurisdictions, looking at what's happening in Hillsboro, and frankly all around the state, and wondering how do we take proactive action on this.

228
00:27:35.837 --> 00:27:42.453
<v Unidentified speaker>And when I found out that you were working on this, I was excited to have the opportunity to join you and support this.

229
00:27:42.518 --> 00:27:43.721
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it is a good first step.

230
00:27:45.103 --> 00:28:03.602
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that, you know, in this new form of government, when we have A city administrator and a sort of council's a legislative body and a quasi-judicial body and an oversight body, using resolutions to sort of express council's will on how we expect the city administrator to move is a great first step.

231
00:28:04.707 --> 00:28:10.508
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think there are many cases where budget notes and other resolutions are honored in that way.

232
00:28:11.277 --> 00:28:15.105
<v Unidentified speaker>And just had an interaction with the city administrator today talking about one of my budget notes.

233
00:28:15.442 --> 00:28:20.970
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think that this is a great way to interact as a good faith partnership with the city administration.

234
00:28:21.567 --> 00:28:31.097
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, the way that you've constructed it with the early assistance piece, we'll find out if that doesn't happen because we do get the public notice on early assistance.

235
00:28:31.162 --> 00:28:37.124
<v Unidentified speaker>And so if we find that there's— that this is inadequate down the road, then maybe we move to codification of something like this.

236
00:28:37.188 --> 00:28:47.385
<v Unidentified speaker>But I really appreciate you taking this nimble approach because it doesn't cost a lot and it sends a clear signal to to our community that, that the public opinion matters.

237
00:28:48.282 --> 00:28:52.113
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, it's not about necessarily whether I want data centers or not in my neighborhood.

238
00:28:52.161 --> 00:29:03.634
<v Unidentified speaker>It's about whether we want the public to know that we understand that this is an urgent moment and we want them to have as much information as possible so we can engage in this, in the land use process.

239
00:29:03.939 --> 00:29:09.563
<v Unidentified speaker>So I thank you for bringing this forward, and I'm glad you drafted the amendment because I was also like, should we say something about moratoriums?

240
00:29:09.611 --> 00:29:11.167
<v Unidentified speaker>So Uh, support that as well.

241
00:29:11.231 --> 00:29:13.319
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't think I've got much more to add than that.

242
00:29:13.400 --> 00:29:18.119
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to say thanks to the staff who've helped, uh, prepare this and the city attorneys who've advised on this.

243
00:29:18.345 --> 00:29:20.144
<v Unidentified speaker>And, uh, and Claire, of course, you're a rock star.

244
00:29:20.753 --> 00:29:22.326
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, all right, that's it for me, Chair.

245
00:29:23.564 --> 00:29:23.820
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

246
00:29:23.964 --> 00:29:29.151
<v Candace Avalos>And so you have previewed the amendment, so we'll— we can move and second it later if that's fine.

247
00:29:29.826 --> 00:29:31.366
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and then is this Sandra?

248
00:29:32.555 --> 00:29:33.005
<v Sandra Wood>Yes, I am.

249
00:29:33.213 --> 00:29:33.631
<v Candace Avalos>Wonderful.

250
00:29:33.791 --> 00:29:35.285
<v Candace Avalos>So Sandra, you are up.

251
00:29:44.835 --> 00:29:47.804
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, thank you very much for having me, councilors, for inviting me.

252
00:29:47.901 --> 00:29:54.272
<v Sandra Wood>And I have to echo how wonderful Claire is because, um, we only sing her praises in our office.

253
00:29:54.786 --> 00:29:56.599
<v Sandra Wood>Um, good afternoon, my name is Sandra Wood.

254
00:29:56.663 --> 00:29:59.104
<v Sandra Wood>I'm with the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

255
00:29:59.200 --> 00:30:05.429
<v Sandra Wood>I use she/her pronouns, and we're of course in the Community and Economic Development Service area.

256
00:30:05.750 --> 00:30:17.997
<v Sandra Wood>I'm a principal planner, so I'll be principally speaking to you today about the land use implications of data centers, how they're classified in the zoning code, and where they're currently allowed.

257
00:30:18.720 --> 00:30:21.874
<v Sandra Wood>The city's building official is also here, Natalie Didion.

258
00:30:22.553 --> 00:30:26.759
<v Sandra Wood>She works for Portland Permitting and Development.

259
00:30:27.082 --> 00:30:45.924
<v Sandra Wood>So if you have any questions about permitting and how data centers As was mentioned, the rapid growth of large-scale data centers has generated nationwide concerns regarding the impacts on infrastructure, environment, nearby communities, and local economies.

260
00:30:46.587 --> 00:30:53.786
<v Sandra Wood>In Oregon, the Governor at COTEC has convened the Data Center Advisory Committee to develop recommendations for a regulatory framework.

261
00:30:54.125 --> 00:30:58.528
<v Sandra Wood>By the end of September, they should be looking at their preliminary findings, and they have a listening session scheduled on September 23rd-ish, I wanna say.

262
00:30:58.576 --> 00:30:59.596
<v Sandra Wood>And then we have a public comment session scheduled on October 4th.

263
00:31:02.425 --> 00:31:04.577
<v Sandra Wood>For a regulatory framework at the state level.

264
00:31:06.720 --> 00:31:07.763
<v Sandra Wood>So what are data centers?

265
00:31:08.102 --> 00:31:20.799
<v Sandra Wood>They're characterized as physical centralized facilities storing network servers, data storage drives, computing equipment, and the supporting equipment, including power storage generators and cooling systems.

266
00:31:21.477 --> 00:31:23.478
<v Sandra Wood>They're composed of server racks.

267
00:31:23.896 --> 00:31:29.262
<v Sandra Wood>These racks are typically just over 6 feet tall, about 19 inches wide and 40 inches deep.

268
00:31:29.327 --> 00:31:29.425
<v Sandra Wood>Wow.

269
00:31:29.994 --> 00:31:30.396
<v Sandra Wood>Or so.

270
00:31:30.961 --> 00:31:34.070
<v Sandra Wood>A full rack can weigh about 200— 2,000 pounds.

271
00:31:34.747 --> 00:31:42.644
<v Sandra Wood>The racks need to have space between them to keep the servers cool and for workers to access them for maintenance.

272
00:31:44.980 --> 00:31:52.490
<v Sandra Wood>The data center debates, as has been mentioned, are dominated by concerns over the hyperscale data centers that are shown on the right of this slide.

273
00:31:52.940 --> 00:31:56.284
<v Sandra Wood>They serve millions of users and are often used to train AI.

274
00:31:57.262 --> 00:32:04.809
<v Sandra Wood>Some literature calls these cloud data centers because they're owned by cloud service providers like Amazon, Google, or Microsoft.

275
00:32:05.273 --> 00:32:11.250
<v Sandra Wood>Others refer to them as AI data centers because they can be devoted to AI-related systems.

276
00:32:12.244 --> 00:32:19.663
<v Sandra Wood>In contrast, there are 2 other scales of data centers that are more common and already operate in most cities, including in Portland.

277
00:32:20.240 --> 00:32:25.086
<v Sandra Wood>Colocation of data centers serve multiple organizations and are small or mid-scale.

278
00:32:25.792 --> 00:32:31.147
<v Sandra Wood>The enterprise data centers on the left of the screen serve a single organization and can fit into a closet.

279
00:32:34.237 --> 00:32:38.315
<v Sandra Wood>Portland zoning code regulates land uses using broad use categories.

280
00:32:38.830 --> 00:32:42.506
<v Sandra Wood>This slide lists the commercial and industrial use categories.

281
00:32:43.170 --> 00:32:46.086
<v Sandra Wood>Data centers are not an explicit use category currently.

282
00:32:46.587 --> 00:32:53.334
<v Sandra Wood>However, they match the characteristics of one of the office subcategories.

283
00:32:53.527 --> 00:32:55.994
<v Sandra Wood>Data centers are classified as industrial office.

284
00:32:56.737 --> 00:33:02.125
<v Sandra Wood>They're characterized by activities that focus on technology, and they're associated with the production of digital goods.

285
00:33:02.643 --> 00:33:08.096
<v Sandra Wood>Data centers provide products to other businesses and do not have customers or clients visiting the site.

286
00:33:09.698 --> 00:33:20.458
<v Sandra Wood>In addition, the inclusion of data processing and hosting services in the examples of industrial office provides a strong basis for categorizing data centers as industrial office.

287
00:33:22.420 --> 00:33:25.151
<v Sandra Wood>So what does that mean about where they can locate?

288
00:33:26.050 --> 00:33:31.707
<v Sandra Wood>Office uses are largely prohibited in residential zones, so we didn't even show it on this slide.

289
00:33:32.980 --> 00:33:38.154
<v Sandra Wood>Offices, including industrial offices, are allowed in the commercial mixed-use zones shown on the left.

290
00:33:38.717 --> 00:33:41.739
<v Sandra Wood>Employment zones in the middle also allow office uses.

291
00:33:42.405 --> 00:33:49.555
<v Sandra Wood>And industrial zones offer— allow 4 office uses per site, but a maximum of 3,000 square feet.

292
00:33:50.217 --> 00:33:52.554
<v Sandra Wood>More or larger require a conditional use.

293
00:33:52.603 --> 00:33:57.445
<v Sandra Wood>So they're largely limited in the industrial zones citywide.

294
00:33:59.329 --> 00:34:01.981
<v Sandra Wood>This map shows where data centers are allowed in Portland.

295
00:34:02.352 --> 00:34:07.785
<v Sandra Wood>As I described, they're allowed in mostly commercial and employment centers like Central City, Gateway, and Lents.

296
00:34:08.226 --> 00:34:13.148
<v Sandra Wood>And along the corridors of Sandy, Martin Luther King Jr., 122nd Avenue.

297
00:34:15.333 --> 00:34:24.914
<v Sandra Wood>Zooming into the Central City, like the rest of the city, offices in the Central City are allowed in the commercial and employment and institutional zones.

298
00:34:24.963 --> 00:34:27.664
<v Sandra Wood>Those are the red, orange, and pink zones on this map.

299
00:34:28.393 --> 00:34:34.074
<v Sandra Wood>There are 2 extra allowances that are interesting in the Central City that pertain to industrial office uses.

300
00:34:34.427 --> 00:34:47.309
<v Sandra Wood>Specifically, first, the industrial zones inside the Central Eastside Subdistrict allow industrial offices, whereas all offices are limited outside the subdistrict or in the rest of the city.

301
00:34:47.951 --> 00:34:54.119
<v Sandra Wood>In this area, industrial offices, and therefore data centers, are allowed up to 3 times the size of the lot.

302
00:34:55.177 --> 00:35:06.815
<v Sandra Wood>Second, whereas residential zones normally prohibit office uses, in the Central Residential Zone, and that's the white area between 405 and the park blocks.

303
00:35:06.978 --> 00:35:11.443
<v Sandra Wood>And I think it's Market and Taylor on this map.

304
00:35:11.927 --> 00:35:14.364
<v Sandra Wood>A limited amount of office uses is allowed.

305
00:35:18.659 --> 00:35:23.693
<v Sandra Wood>So switching gears here a little bit, I just summarized what the zoning code currently says.

306
00:35:27.137 --> 00:35:30.246
<v Sandra Wood>Data centers aren't the first large footprint land use.

307
00:35:30.545 --> 00:35:32.056
<v Sandra Wood>To spark widespread concern.

308
00:35:33.132 --> 00:35:37.952
<v Sandra Wood>Big box retailers and e-commerce warehouses generated similar conversations in the past.

309
00:35:38.596 --> 00:35:49.135
<v Sandra Wood>But data centers— but whether data centers are serving artificial intelligence or serving businesses and residents, they are increasingly necessary pieces of modern infrastructure.

310
00:35:49.682 --> 00:35:56.398
<v Sandra Wood>With that in mind, there are many policy considerations that need further explanation— exploration to support a full conversation.

311
00:35:57.072 --> 00:35:59.175
<v Sandra Wood>One consideration is the available land.

312
00:35:59.639 --> 00:36:06.539
<v Sandra Wood>Smaller data centers find space in vacant and underutilized office and retail buildings today, and we expect that to continue.

313
00:36:07.099 --> 00:36:14.561
<v Sandra Wood>Hyperscale data center sites must be large enough, have robust infrastructure connectivity to the power grid and fiber networks.

314
00:36:15.025 --> 00:36:27.391
<v Sandra Wood>The available land, real estate market, and small lot sizes of Portland is not very conducive to hyperscale data centers with few large lots in the areas of the city where industrial use— office use is permitted.

315
00:36:30.206 --> 00:36:32.268
<v Sandra Wood>Another consideration is economic development.

316
00:36:32.686 --> 00:36:37.467
<v Sandra Wood>While most debates are focused on AI companies using data centers, the truth is that we all use them.

317
00:36:37.855 --> 00:36:41.422
<v Sandra Wood>Online retailers need to run their websites and coordinate logistics.

318
00:36:41.568 --> 00:36:46.143
<v Sandra Wood>Remote workers rely on data centers to store files and provide cloud-based services.

319
00:36:47.065 --> 00:36:52.239
<v Sandra Wood>Fast and reliable data services are often used As a criteria by companies looking for space to lease.

320
00:36:53.244 --> 00:37:00.242
<v Sandra Wood>In cities such as Portland, repurposing vacant downtown offices into marketable properties could drive economic recovery.

321
00:37:01.159 --> 00:37:09.253
<v Sandra Wood>Proponents note that data centers generate substantial economic activity during construction and provide a not insignificant number of new permanent jobs.

322
00:37:11.449 --> 00:37:14.443
<v Sandra Wood>Job density and transit service is another consideration.

323
00:37:14.702 --> 00:37:23.625
<v Sandra Wood>Portland's land use and transportation goals aim for job densities and use that support active streets and generate transit users in the city's centers and corridors.

324
00:37:24.349 --> 00:37:28.148
<v Sandra Wood>Data centers have a much lower job density than many office users.

325
00:37:28.666 --> 00:37:38.496
<v Sandra Wood>Therefore, a proliferation of data centers in the central city and in the city's transit-served centers and corridors could be counter to our long-term land use and transportation goals.

326
00:37:42.101 --> 00:37:51.601
<v Sandra Wood>A 4th concern, concern or consideration is the large part of the policy debate related to data centers Um, around energy use and who pays the higher cost of energy.

327
00:37:52.195 --> 00:38:02.500
<v Sandra Wood>Locations that have access to cheap renewable energy are desirable for data center development, and including our utility partners in the policy conversation would be essential.

328
00:38:03.030 --> 00:38:09.771
<v Sandra Wood>In 2025, Portland signed up to the Global Urban Centers Pact, which includes a principle of cost security and shared prosperity.

329
00:38:10.574 --> 00:38:27.329
<v Sandra Wood>When the Oregon legislature passed the Power Act in 2025, it followed through on this principle and establish a new electricity rate class for data centers that ensures they pay, they pay their fair share for electricity and related infrastructure and not pass the cost on to residents.

330
00:38:27.829 --> 00:38:30.510
<v Sandra Wood>Oregon is the only state so far to enact this tool.

331
00:38:32.135 --> 00:38:37.534
<v Sandra Wood>And of course, any policy debate about data centers would not be complete with the consideration of water.

332
00:38:38.240 --> 00:38:46.478
<v Sandra Wood>And although many might think that the concern isn't as big in Portland as it is in Eastern Oregon, it still should be part of the conversation.

333
00:38:48.869 --> 00:38:51.376
<v Sandra Wood>To summarize, there are 3 scales of data centers.

334
00:38:51.813 --> 00:39:03.346
<v Sandra Wood>They're currently allowed as industrial office uses in Portland and are largely limited to the commercial mixed-use and employment zones, with the exception of the Central City, which also allows them in industrial zones.

335
00:39:04.090 --> 00:39:13.324
<v Sandra Wood>Finally, a policy conversation would need to be informed by exploring multiple considerations such as land use, economic development, Jobs, transit, energy, climate, and water.

336
00:39:14.226 --> 00:39:18.300
<v Sandra Wood>Thank you to Councilor Koyama Lane and Councilor Green for inviting us to speak today.

337
00:39:19.119 --> 00:39:22.126
<v Sandra Wood>Natalie and I are available for questions after the public testimony.

338
00:39:26.257 --> 00:39:27.050
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you very much.

339
00:39:27.954 --> 00:39:30.764
<v Candace Avalos>And then I understand we have some invited speakers.

340
00:39:31.023 --> 00:39:33.786
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, so let's go ahead and bring on that panel.

341
00:39:33.865 --> 00:39:34.318
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Sandra.

342
00:39:40.422 --> 00:39:42.757
<v Candace Avalos>I have on my notes a TBD of all the people.

343
00:39:42.856 --> 00:39:43.601
<v Candace Avalos>So who are the people?

344
00:39:43.666 --> 00:39:43.974
<v Candace Avalos>Emily—.

345
00:39:44.251 --> 00:39:53.514
<v Unidentified speaker>We have Emily Waldron from the Oregon Data Center Defiance Group, and then Ali Finn, Director of Community Partnerships at AI Now Institute.

346
00:39:56.132 --> 00:39:56.664
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

347
00:39:57.744 --> 00:39:58.534
<v Candace Avalos>Is Ali virtual?

348
00:39:58.614 --> 00:39:59.146
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, great.

349
00:39:59.581 --> 00:40:04.233
<v Candace Avalos>Do you have a particular order you want them to speak in, or okay, go ahead.

350
00:40:04.619 --> 00:40:05.244
<v Emily Waldron>Okay, perfect.

351
00:40:05.405 --> 00:40:08.217
<v Emily Waldron>This is a little fancier than my usual North Plains City Council meetings.

352
00:40:09.277 --> 00:40:14.079
<v Emily Waldron>My name is Emily Waldron, and I am here on behalf of Oregon Data Center Defiance.

353
00:40:14.737 --> 00:40:20.391
<v Emily Waldron>We are a newer coalition of individuals and organizations throughout the state of Oregon.

354
00:40:21.306 --> 00:40:35.070
<v Emily Waldron>We have members from here in Portland all the way down to Southern Oregon in Talent, just north of Ashland, as far east As Central Oregon with Redmond, Boardman, La Pine, and as far west as the Oregon coast.

355
00:40:35.215 --> 00:40:52.684
<v Emily Waldron>So our membership encompasses a lot of space, and we are a coalition that gathered together in order to pass statewide regulations as well as support local initiatives and make it easier for people to enact grassroots movements in their own counties and cities.

356
00:40:54.385 --> 00:40:56.309
<v Emily Waldron>So I'm going down my list of what I was asked to talk about.

357
00:40:56.822 --> 00:41:00.847
<v Emily Waldron>So an overview to begin on the data center trends in Oregon.

358
00:41:02.003 --> 00:41:03.253
<v Emily Waldron>They keep popping up everywhere.

359
00:41:03.461 --> 00:41:05.034
<v Emily Waldron>I feel like it's daisies in my backyard.

360
00:41:05.483 --> 00:41:13.115
<v Emily Waldron>So first of all, there's the water concerns, how much water they're using, but also what's being emitted afterwards in pollution.

361
00:41:13.789 --> 00:41:25.574
<v Emily Waldron>I know there's been discussion about using closed-loop data center systems without the discussion that closed-loop is more likely to include more PFAS and higher concentrations of nitrates in the water that they do release.

362
00:41:26.297 --> 00:41:30.487
<v Emily Waldron>As well as the fact that closed-loop systems require more energy and output more heat.

363
00:41:31.034 --> 00:41:36.012
<v Emily Waldron>A closed-loop microchip requires 2.5 times the energy as a non-closed-loop chip.

364
00:41:36.123 --> 00:41:37.875
<v Emily Waldron>So there's still a lot of water usage.

365
00:41:37.971 --> 00:41:42.771
<v Emily Waldron>It's just moving into a different spot in the pipeline to where energy is being produced.

366
00:41:43.815 --> 00:41:46.481
<v Emily Waldron>Another concern with data centers is the heat output.

367
00:41:47.347 --> 00:41:53.610
<v Emily Waldron>Recent studies show that they increase the heat by anywhere from 9 to 16 degrees at a single data center.

368
00:41:53.690 --> 00:41:53.722
<v Emily Waldron>Wow.

369
00:41:54.155 --> 00:41:59.431
<v Emily Waldron>And I'm sure— I live just outside of Hillsboro where we have Huffman, which is covered in data centers.

370
00:41:59.608 --> 00:42:03.409
<v Emily Waldron>It's a lot higher because they all start feeding off of each other and growing with that.

371
00:42:04.356 --> 00:42:06.681
<v Emily Waldron>For power, these things are using a lot of power.

372
00:42:06.840 --> 00:42:17.346
<v Emily Waldron>We don't have the numbers for 2026 yet, but in 2025, EcoTrust Northwest reported that data centers used 23% of the energy generated for the entire state.

373
00:42:17.987 --> 00:42:28.965
<v Emily Waldron>And I am sure with more data centers, Including the hyper or the closed-loop system chips, I wouldn't be surprised if they start moving closer to 50% of all of the water that we're using in the state of Oregon.

374
00:42:30.916 --> 00:42:32.251
<v Emily Waldron>They're using land.

375
00:42:32.625 --> 00:42:43.349
<v Emily Waldron>And I know in Portland people say you don't have a lot of space for a hyperscale, but I know organizers who are in Kansas City that are fighting a hyperscale data center in the middle of downtown because they're just building it vertically.

376
00:42:43.820 --> 00:42:49.699
<v Emily Waldron>So this building that they're fighting is proposed to be 20 stories tall for a single hyperscale data center.

377
00:42:50.358 --> 00:42:52.188
<v Emily Waldron>That's nothing but a big box going upwards.

378
00:42:53.505 --> 00:42:57.777
<v Emily Waldron>These data centers emit sound, both audible and also infrasonic sound.

379
00:42:58.164 --> 00:43:05.487
<v Emily Waldron>And there's research going all the way back to the '70s showing the physical harms on a body when it comes to infrasonic sound.

380
00:43:05.873 --> 00:43:07.815
<v Emily Waldron>It increases your likelihood of a heart attack.

381
00:43:08.282 --> 00:43:11.782
<v Emily Waldron>It increases issues with depression and anxiety and mental health.

382
00:43:12.378 --> 00:43:13.228
<v Emily Waldron>There's a lot of different things.

383
00:43:14.047 --> 00:43:18.717
<v Emily Waldron>Um, so it's— Oregon has all of these going on, and we're also adding so many.

384
00:43:18.813 --> 00:43:35.742
<v Emily Waldron>So right now there's over 9,000 acres of land across the entire state that is slated for data center development, whereas— and this is from a Business Oregon report that they gave to the Data Center Advisory Committee— our data centers are averaging 6 people permanently working per data center in the entire state.

385
00:43:36.304 --> 00:43:40.893
<v Emily Waldron>So they're using all of our power, they're using up all of our clean water because it has to be very clean for them.

386
00:43:41.284 --> 00:43:51.018
<v Emily Waldron>They're using up all of our land and all of our space for 6 jobs per building, which doesn't really have the impact economically that people would be hoping for.

387
00:43:52.769 --> 00:43:55.431
<v Emily Waldron>And this is from an industry report on data centers.

388
00:43:55.706 --> 00:43:59.416
<v Emily Waldron>By 2030, over 70% of these buildings are going to be for AI.

389
00:43:59.996 --> 00:44:06.128
<v Emily Waldron>So any of the things that people are talking about of like, oh, you're on Facebook, you're using a data center, those aren't the data centers we're talking about.

390
00:44:06.226 --> 00:44:09.028
<v Emily Waldron>And those don't even make up a quarter of the data centers that we're talking about.

391
00:44:09.077 --> 00:44:09.175
<v Emily Waldron>Thank you.

392
00:44:09.742 --> 00:44:15.768
<v Emily Waldron>Most of these centers are for AI training, whether it's for generative AI like Claude.

393
00:44:16.731 --> 00:44:24.411
<v Emily Waldron>They're seeing in other states AI usage for things like nuclear weapons development or military surveillance, flock cameras.

394
00:44:24.588 --> 00:44:27.047
<v Emily Waldron>All of these are requiring this AI computing.

395
00:44:27.577 --> 00:44:35.914
<v Emily Waldron>And so as that grows, these data centers are a part of, like, I wanna say the military-industrial complex almost against our own citizens in the United States.

396
00:44:37.311 --> 00:44:44.827
<v Emily Waldron>So there's— in light of all these things going on, there are a variety of different moratorium proposals across the state.

397
00:44:45.469 --> 00:44:50.159
<v Emily Waldron>Right now we have what's called a moratorium on our urban enterprise zones.

398
00:44:50.882 --> 00:44:52.840
<v Emily Waldron>So these are zones in urban areas.

399
00:44:53.193 --> 00:44:59.344
<v Emily Waldron>It pretty much only applies to Hillsboro that says that they don't qualify for a tax break inside that zone.

400
00:44:59.858 --> 00:45:07.532
<v Emily Waldron>But the way the governor and her advisors wrote that bill, It does not include any of the rural enterprise zones.

401
00:45:07.885 --> 00:45:13.599
<v Emily Waldron>It does not include the SIP tax breaks, which are the strategic investment ones that cities can individually give.

402
00:45:14.065 --> 00:45:15.974
<v Emily Waldron>It doesn't include any other sort of break.

403
00:45:16.536 --> 00:45:27.516
<v Emily Waldron>And what's concerning is that there's evidence that because schools can opt out of fees, data centers are beginning to be a part of funding different people to run for school boards.

404
00:45:28.012 --> 00:45:37.967
<v Emily Waldron>So that way the school board chooses to opt out of fees saying they're just going to get it from tax but then that creates a further tax burden on the state's available money for education.

405
00:45:40.110 --> 00:45:45.349
<v Emily Waldron>So with all of that, in Hillsboro, they are the only place that has successfully and currently passed a moratorium.

406
00:45:45.480 --> 00:45:46.956
<v Emily Waldron>It can last for 120 days.

407
00:45:47.590 --> 00:45:51.945
<v Emily Waldron>That's a state regulation that for city— cities and counties, they only can do 120 days.

408
00:45:52.686 --> 00:45:58.815
<v Emily Waldron>In Woodburn, in Clackamas County, Washington County, and there's one other town I'm forgetting.

409
00:45:59.025 --> 00:46:01.108
<v Emily Waldron>They've discussed— Salem.

410
00:46:01.431 --> 00:46:05.128
<v Emily Waldron>They've discussed doing a moratorium, but nothing's actually been voted on or put into place.

411
00:46:06.635 --> 00:46:11.666
<v Emily Waldron>And then I will say my own little town in North Plains has discussed doing a flat-out data center ban.

412
00:46:12.211 --> 00:46:17.237
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're working that through the planning committee to just completely prevent data centers from entering there at all.

413
00:46:19.380 --> 00:46:27.074
<v Unidentified speaker>And then with ORDCD and our work with different legislators, different organizations throughout the state, We are pushing for a statewide moratorium.

414
00:46:27.476 --> 00:46:36.543
<v Unidentified speaker>So our goal is to have a statewide construction moratorium for the next 3 years, as well as implementing different regulations and areas for citizen involvement.

415
00:46:37.010 --> 00:46:46.557
<v Unidentified speaker>So regulations on the different types of pollution with noise, heat, water, air, wind— or not wind, uh, light— all— there's so many different types of pollution that comes off of them.

416
00:46:46.960 --> 00:46:48.179
<v Unidentified speaker>We want to regulate all of that.

417
00:46:48.244 --> 00:46:50.795
<v Unidentified speaker>We want to change it so they're not eligible for these tax breaks.

418
00:46:51.516 --> 00:46:55.175
<v Unidentified speaker>And just set up a better system for all Oregonians if they're going to be here.

419
00:46:56.009 --> 00:47:11.713
<v Unidentified speaker>And I can just say, like, with my own perspective on data centers and impacts, living in a— outside a small town in rural Washington County, even in Little North Plains, it's amazing how many secret things occur in order to set up development for data centers.

420
00:47:12.306 --> 00:47:17.824
<v Unidentified speaker>And things that I can only get through public records requests, and I still am waiting on some public records requests from back in April.

421
00:47:18.483 --> 00:47:20.295
<v Unidentified speaker>Because people don't want to share it.

422
00:47:20.489 --> 00:47:28.398
<v Unidentified speaker>It's so hard for the public to find out who is entering a data center contract because they do all these shell companies and fronts for whoever actually is going in.

423
00:47:29.297 --> 00:47:43.112
<v Unidentified speaker>It's so hard to find out how much energy or water is being used because even if you pull up the city reports, they do things like this, this half of the street gets it from the city, this half gets it from the county, so we don't count what the county's giving out for water.

424
00:47:43.514 --> 00:47:45.568
<v Unidentified speaker>And it's really hard to get accurate information.

425
00:47:46.081 --> 00:47:51.231
<v Unidentified speaker>And I— what all you all can do about NDAs to prevent that, I think, is going to be really helpful.

426
00:47:51.922 --> 00:48:06.023
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, at this moment in our country, I think there's a lot of erosion in faith of our democratic establishments, and getting rid of NDAs is part of healing that and a part of showing that we do care about our citizen involvement and we want to be transparent to serve our communities.

427
00:48:06.842 --> 00:48:16.411
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, and I think anything you can do to consider a moratorium, uh, to put protections in place would be good because I know, you know, right now you have them zoned as office buildings.

428
00:48:16.972 --> 00:48:18.563
<v Unidentified speaker>A data center is 24/7.

429
00:48:19.045 --> 00:48:22.001
<v Unidentified speaker>It doesn't end at 5 o'clock like an office building does.

430
00:48:22.579 --> 00:48:24.041
<v Unidentified speaker>It's all day, every single day.

431
00:48:24.137 --> 00:48:29.231
<v Unidentified speaker>So even if the noise isn't that loud, it's all day, every single day that you have a constant sound.

432
00:48:29.664 --> 00:48:33.842
<v Unidentified speaker>Even if the light isn't that bad, the lights never turn off outside the building because it's all day, every day.

433
00:48:34.387 --> 00:48:38.387
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's something that's very unique to these, that they just keep going and going and going.

434
00:48:38.485 --> 00:48:38.628
<v Emily Waldron>Thank you.

435
00:48:39.061 --> 00:48:40.971
<v Unidentified speaker>Until, I don't know, they're decommissioned.

436
00:48:41.467 --> 00:48:46.280
<v Unidentified speaker>And then when they're decommissioned, you have a whole pile of waste that you have to figure out what to do with.

437
00:48:46.425 --> 00:48:48.894
<v Unidentified speaker>If they're closed loop, they're using refrigerants and chemicals.

438
00:48:49.311 --> 00:48:50.579
<v Unidentified speaker>What are you going to do with all of those?

439
00:48:50.916 --> 00:48:56.802
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I know there's already a lot of people acting on the oil tanks in North Portland.

440
00:48:57.268 --> 00:48:59.289
<v Unidentified speaker>And so what would you do with all of the e-waste?

441
00:48:59.338 --> 00:49:01.903
<v Unidentified speaker>What would you do with all of the leftover remnants from this?

442
00:49:02.706 --> 00:49:04.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, it's just, there's a lot.

443
00:49:05.592 --> 00:49:16.153
<v Unidentified speaker>And something that I keep seeing, and I laugh at, with the Data Center Advisory Committee that the governor assembled, is in all of their meetings they keep saying, oh, this is a thing over here, but we don't have time to learn about that.

444
00:49:16.266 --> 00:49:17.324
<v Unidentified speaker>We only have so much time.

445
00:49:17.387 --> 00:49:19.150
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't have time to learn more about the water.

446
00:49:19.550 --> 00:49:21.250
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't have time to learn more about the energy.

447
00:49:21.297 --> 00:49:23.092
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't have time to learn more about all of this stuff.

448
00:49:23.701 --> 00:49:26.409
<v Unidentified speaker>And I keep just thinking, isn't this why we want a moratorium?

449
00:49:26.538 --> 00:49:26.730
<v Emily Waldron>Mm-hmm.

450
00:49:27.001 --> 00:49:33.139
<v Emily Waldron>So you can pause instead of adding more and take the time to figure out what's going on and what you want.

451
00:49:33.639 --> 00:49:37.795
<v Emily Waldron>And then you can begin again with the controls in place that you desire.

452
00:49:38.686 --> 00:49:39.639
<v Emily Waldron>So thank you for your time.

453
00:49:41.940 --> 00:49:44.623
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

454
00:49:44.947 --> 00:49:46.257
<v Candace Avalos>Allie, take it away.

455
00:49:46.498 --> 00:49:46.726
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

456
00:49:47.130 --> 00:49:47.565
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you hear me?

457
00:49:48.836 --> 00:49:49.014
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

458
00:49:49.420 --> 00:49:49.889
<v Unidentified speaker>Wonderful.

459
00:49:50.778 --> 00:49:53.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much to the committee for the opportunity to testify.

460
00:49:54.030 --> 00:49:58.893
<v Unidentified speaker>For context, I'm the Director of Community Partnerships at the AI Now Institute.

461
00:49:59.146 --> 00:50:05.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Which is an independent organization producing policy research on artificial intelligence, including data center infrastructure.

462
00:50:06.300 --> 00:50:22.056
<v Unidentified speaker>We focus on policy strategies to shape AI in the public interest and redirect the AI industry away from its current path, unbridled commercial surveillance, concentration of power in a few dominant tech companies, and deployment of AI on the public instead of with and by us.

463
00:50:22.842 --> 00:50:34.050
<v Unidentified speaker>My role includes advising local, state, and federal officials across the country on the reality of the AI industry I'm going to testify today about 3 points.

464
00:50:34.309 --> 00:50:38.630
<v Unidentified speaker>The first is the role of big tech in driving data center expansion and who this serves.

465
00:50:39.110 --> 00:50:42.340
<v Unidentified speaker>The second are the immense impacts of the hyperscale data center buildout.

466
00:50:42.809 --> 00:50:51.420
<v Unidentified speaker>And third, the urgent need to protect Portland from corporate secrecy and nondisclosure agreements as one critical step towards broader safeguards.

467
00:50:51.869 --> 00:50:55.170
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland residents deserve a future that centers their interests and their well-being, and we need to make sure that we're doing our part to rather ensure that.

468
00:50:55.170 --> 00:50:55.210
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

469
00:50:55.427 --> 00:51:05.980
<v Unidentified speaker>Than corporate speculation that introduces unacceptable risk into our economy, drains local budgets, and threatens our water, air, energy grid, public budgets, and local democracy.

470
00:51:07.532 --> 00:51:19.838
<v Unidentified speaker>So on big tech's role in driving this buildout, the explosive growth that we're seeing across the country is directly linked to the ambitions and business model of big tech and the broader ecosystem of AI and tech companies.

471
00:51:20.442 --> 00:51:24.748
<v Unidentified speaker>These companies are driving demand for computation across the supply chain.

472
00:51:25.331 --> 00:51:29.394
<v Unidentified speaker>They are pushing AI technologies across all aspects of society.

473
00:51:30.213 --> 00:51:31.690
<v Unidentified speaker>This role of big tech is circular.

474
00:51:31.996 --> 00:51:45.532
<v Unidentified speaker>It dominates ownership of data center infrastructure in the US and globally finances much of the buildout through quite shaky practices, and then manufactures an AI boom that seemingly requires skyrocketing data center capacity.

475
00:51:46.606 --> 00:51:50.525
<v Unidentified speaker>These companies are rapidly building out this capacity to fuel their AI investments.

476
00:51:50.862 --> 00:51:56.128
<v Unidentified speaker>With immense consequences for both neighboring communities and, as I said, the stability of our economy as a whole.

477
00:51:56.802 --> 00:52:06.293
<v Unidentified speaker>Just for a sense of scale, in the first 9 months of 2025, Amazon, Microsoft, Meta, and Google spent an estimated $360 billion on capital expenditures.

478
00:52:06.340 --> 00:52:08.701
<v Unidentified speaker>That's primarily building data centers in the U.S.

479
00:52:09.391 --> 00:52:16.039
<v Unidentified speaker>This eye-watering investment is based on projected future demand rather than demonstrated need and evidence of the benefits.

480
00:52:17.579 --> 00:52:28.952
<v Unidentified speaker>And this, they're facing ratcheted up pressure to show a return on investment for their shareholders and investors, incentivizing these AI firms to adopt increasingly toxic business models.

481
00:52:30.347 --> 00:52:35.929
<v Unidentified speaker>Big tech, along with other data center developers, cloak much of their development in secrecy.

482
00:52:36.523 --> 00:52:43.789
<v Unidentified speaker>This impedes local democratic processes and public awareness of data center projects, development, and extractive land, water, and energy implications.

483
00:52:44.463 --> 00:52:57.913
<v Unidentified speaker>And these tactics of obfuscation show up in many ways, but most apparently in the development of backdoor deals facilitated not only through NDAs, but also project code names, selective community engagement, and use of shell companies.

484
00:52:58.121 --> 00:53:05.246
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to speak a little bit to the impacts, and there's, you know, hours to say here, but I'll focus on a few things.

485
00:53:05.793 --> 00:53:13.110
<v Unidentified speaker>We have more than a decade of evidence of existing data center development that shows the supposed gains from data centers' trickle-down approach.

486
00:53:13.577 --> 00:53:17.333
<v Unidentified speaker>Fail to materialize, but communities are left paying a steep price.

487
00:53:18.731 --> 00:53:20.994
<v Unidentified speaker>This falls on our democratic processes first.

488
00:53:21.621 --> 00:53:38.528
<v Unidentified speaker>Big tech firms, data center developers, the data center lobby engage tactics that steamroll our local democratic processes, including taking advantage of outdated regulatory and zoning policies like data centers fitting into office code zoning and violating environmental laws.

489
00:53:39.474 --> 00:53:54.123
<v Unidentified speaker>Private equity firms are increasingly moving into public utilities through acquisitions and partnerships that enable them to exploit our public utility and grid system, putting all rate classes on the hook in order to access cheaper electricity for their data centers.

490
00:53:55.565 --> 00:54:08.387
<v Unidentified speaker>And corporate lobbying, which operates, as we know, largely without spending limits and campaign contributions from super PACs, further exacerbate this dynamic as tech companies are pouring millions into shaping our elections and the outcome of legislation, including on data centers.

491
00:54:08.702 --> 00:54:09.451
<v Unidentified speaker>To their benefit.

492
00:54:10.980 --> 00:54:13.246
<v Unidentified speaker>The energy and grid stability impacts are also immense.

493
00:54:13.807 --> 00:54:20.384
<v Unidentified speaker>By 2030, data centers are expected to use 12% of the country's electricity consumption, triple what it is currently.

494
00:54:21.449 --> 00:54:26.445
<v Unidentified speaker>Even in low estimates, this exceeds the amount of electricity needed to power 26 million households.

495
00:54:27.260 --> 00:54:40.878
<v Unidentified speaker>And this energy grab is already destabilizing our grid with NERC, the North American Electric Reliability Corporation, itself citing data center growth as one of the greatest reliability challenges for U.S. power grids at this moment.

496
00:54:41.458 --> 00:54:48.492
<v Unidentified speaker>What that does is that increases the risk of power outages and brings higher risks of energy shortfalls to virtually the whole country.

497
00:54:49.072 --> 00:54:51.528
<v Unidentified speaker>Near misses of blackouts are already increasingly common.

498
00:54:51.898 --> 00:55:02.628
<v Unidentified speaker>And to me, I think about what this means in reality is people's insulin going bad in the fridge when there's a power outage, no AC for elders, no electricity for disabled communities.

499
00:55:04.893 --> 00:55:10.353
<v Unidentified speaker>Data center expansion is also returning communities to reliance on fossil fuels and reversing our limited climate progress.

500
00:55:11.413 --> 00:55:14.014
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll save details on that.

501
00:55:14.865 --> 00:55:24.291
<v Unidentified speaker>But these carbon emissions, you know, don't only threaten our planet's future, they also have immediate health consequences for communities, with air pollution leading to rising cancer and asthma rates.

502
00:55:24.965 --> 00:55:29.976
<v Unidentified speaker>By 2030, air pollution from data centers alone can cause nationally an additional 60,000 premature deaths.

503
00:55:30.025 --> 00:55:30.137
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

504
00:55:30.250 --> 00:55:33.070
<v Unidentified speaker>600,000 asthma cases annually.

505
00:55:34.048 --> 00:55:35.827
<v Unidentified speaker>And that is not something that we should accept.

506
00:55:37.253 --> 00:55:43.266
<v Unidentified speaker>As the wealthiest corporations in the world demand exponentially more power, they are not paying the costs.

507
00:55:43.346 --> 00:55:46.599
<v Unidentified speaker>It's everyday people regularly subsidizing these companies.

508
00:55:47.128 --> 00:55:50.190
<v Unidentified speaker>Across the country, energy bills have gone up for regular ratepayers.

509
00:55:50.237 --> 00:55:57.195
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not just individual households, but also small businesses directly attributable to the expansion of this data center infrastructure.

510
00:55:57.838 --> 00:56:09.025
<v Unidentified speaker>And despite voluntary commitments and promises to pay their fair share, the industry has fought against obligations to ensure its costs aren't passed along to ratepayers in places like Georgia and Ohio.

511
00:56:11.278 --> 00:56:15.105
<v Unidentified speaker>Just lastly here, data centers are also using up precious water resources.

512
00:56:15.168 --> 00:56:17.333
<v Unidentified speaker>The previous speaker spoke about this, right?

513
00:56:17.672 --> 00:56:24.275
<v Unidentified speaker>What I want to emphasize here is industry claims around efficiencies, closed-loop systems, water positivity.

514
00:56:24.637 --> 00:56:29.632
<v Unidentified speaker>Even if they are genuine, they are currently not deployed at a scale that would make a difference in these impacts.

515
00:56:31.719 --> 00:56:36.876
<v Unidentified speaker>So to conclude, I just want to talk for a moment about corporate secrecy and the importance of ending NDAs.

516
00:56:37.911 --> 00:56:45.565
<v Unidentified speaker>Strong oversight and transparency mechanisms ensure that data centers cannot hide critical information from communities or local governments.

517
00:56:46.034 --> 00:56:51.434
<v Unidentified speaker>At the local level, this includes banning the use of nondisclosure agreements, and we have examples of this.

518
00:56:51.967 --> 00:57:01.760
<v Unidentified speaker>In one strong case, Big Rapids, Michigan approved a policy prohibiting employees and elected officials from signing NDAs around issues pertaining to the public interest or taxpayer funding.

519
00:57:01.807 --> 00:57:04.088
<v Unidentified speaker>So broader than data centers alone.

520
00:57:05.027 --> 00:57:17.898
<v Unidentified speaker>We're also seeing communities institute sunshine periods that require public release of documents related to data center development or broader economic development and requiring community hearings as a central part of data center approval processes.

521
00:57:18.762 --> 00:57:43.938
<v Unidentified speaker>There are other transparency mechanisms available as well, including using permitting and approval processes to mandate transparency requirements both pre- and post-approval, rejecting data center development or expansion proposals that do not adhere to these transparency measures, and establishing robust enforcement mechanisms to ensure that data centers abide by the requirements contingent on approval, which can include the right to revoke permits.

522
00:57:44.195 --> 00:57:53.583
<v Unidentified speaker>And I want to end by saying that transparency, while critical, is the floor and not the ceiling.

523
00:57:54.101 --> 00:58:08.418
<v Unidentified speaker>Communities desperately need comprehensive protections, the ability to decide for themselves if, when, and how data center development happens, and an economic development agenda that prioritizes everyday people's needs rather than the interests of these corporations.

524
00:58:08.465 --> 00:58:09.382
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney Nancy Thorington.

525
00:58:09.771 --> 00:58:16.246
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you both for your testimony.

526
00:58:17.226 --> 00:58:20.478
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and with that, we can move into public testimony.

527
00:58:20.543 --> 00:58:21.755
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, sound good?

528
00:58:21.931 --> 00:58:22.416
<v Unidentified speaker>Sounds great.

529
00:58:22.561 --> 00:58:28.570
<v Candace Avalos>All right, and then I think we will do public testimony, and then we'll take a quick break, and then we'll come back and do committee discussion.

530
00:58:29.686 --> 00:58:33.148
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, let's go ahead, Wendy, and call up our first group.

531
00:58:34.873 --> 00:58:36.780
<v Unidentified speaker>So we have 13 people signed up.

532
00:58:36.829 --> 00:58:47.748
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll call you up in groups so starting off with Alice Christine Walker, Zach White, Deneen Crowe, Nick Caleb.

533
00:58:48.887 --> 00:58:51.181
<v Unidentified speaker>And Zach is joining us online.

534
00:58:52.414 --> 00:58:57.755
<v Unidentified speaker>Please, uh, when you start your testimony, just go ahead and state your name for the record.

535
00:58:59.070 --> 00:59:01.701
<v Unidentified speaker>You'll hear the timer chime twice.

536
00:59:01.797 --> 00:59:03.336
<v Unidentified speaker>The first time will indicate you have 30 seconds.

537
00:59:03.385 --> 00:59:03.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

538
00:59:03.869 --> 00:59:08.481
<v Candace Avalos>All right, whoever would like to kick us off.

539
00:59:10.710 --> 00:59:10.887
<v Alice Christine Walker>I'll go.

540
00:59:10.985 --> 00:59:12.498
<v Alice Christine Walker>Good, good morning, councilors.

541
00:59:12.612 --> 00:59:17.376
<v Alice Christine Walker>My name is Alice Christine Walker, and I'm here on behalf of East Columbia Neighborhood Association.

542
00:59:18.925 --> 00:59:27.708
<v Alice Christine Walker>East Columbia strongly supports this resolution to eliminate developer NDAs, mandate early notifications, and restore transparency to land use decisions.

543
00:59:28.577 --> 00:59:33.507
<v Alice Christine Walker>Our neighborhood is in the direct crosshairs of heavy industrial expansion along the Columbia River corridor.

544
00:59:34.554 --> 00:59:43.673
<v Alice Christine Walker>Right now, high-impact developments are utilizing non-disclosure agreements and early assistance reviews to lock in projects behind closed doors.

545
00:59:44.509 --> 00:59:51.702
<v Alice Christine Walker>When municipal NDAs shield early project planning from the public, communities are shut off before we even know what is coming.

546
00:59:52.376 --> 01:00:11.414
<v Alice Christine Walker>Combined with administrative by-right reviews under Title 33, this leaves impacted neighbors with zero notice zero public hearings and no venue to address the cumulative impacts like 24/7 noise pollution, diesel emissions, and the strain on our utility grid and our roads.

547
01:00:12.201 --> 01:00:25.376
<v Alice Christine Walker>I will say industry does abut residential in Portland, and we are that lived experience, and we deal with 24/7 trucking sounds, and it is unlivable.

548
01:00:27.351 --> 01:00:33.838
<v Alice Christine Walker>We appreciate that this resolution recognizes how frontline neighborhoods like East Columbia disproportionately shoulder industrial burdens.

549
01:00:34.449 --> 01:00:38.590
<v Alice Christine Walker>Non-disclosure agreements have no place in municipal land use.

550
01:00:39.250 --> 01:00:46.427
<v Alice Christine Walker>We thank the councilors Koyama Lane, Green, for sponsoring this critical resolution, and we urge the full council to support it.

551
01:00:47.036 --> 01:00:50.858
<v Alice Christine Walker>Please ensure strict enforcement comes across for all city bureaus.

552
01:00:51.599 --> 01:00:59.315
<v Alice Christine Walker>East Columbia and all Portland deserves open processes, not backroom development that shuts out the very communities that live with these consequences.

553
01:01:05.760 --> 01:01:09.389
<v Deneen Crowe>Good afternoon, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, and members of the committee.

554
01:01:10.309 --> 01:01:16.643
<v Deneen Crowe>My name is Deneen Crowe, and I'm the campaign director with 350 PDX, and I live in District 2.

555
01:01:17.717 --> 01:01:27.753
<v Deneen Crowe>On behalf of our thousands of supporters across the Portland region, I urge you to pass this resolution out of committee and support this when it comes to full council vote.

556
01:01:29.135 --> 01:01:41.802
<v Deneen Crowe>Refraining from nondisclosure agreements, requiring prompt council notification for data center inquiries, and committing the city to transparency around public processes is simply common sense governance.

557
01:01:42.686 --> 01:01:49.543
<v Deneen Crowe>The rapid, unvetted buildout of hyperscale data centers is becoming one of the single largest threats to Oregon's future.

558
01:01:50.490 --> 01:01:53.847
<v Deneen Crowe>Data centers operate 24/7 at immense scale.

559
01:01:54.184 --> 01:02:01.650
<v Deneen Crowe>Meeting this massive load threatens to derail our clean energy mandates by providing an excuse for new polluting gas infrastructure.

560
01:02:02.293 --> 01:02:12.427
<v Deneen Crowe>And every gigawatt of this energy diverted to these greedy, power-hungry facilities is energy taken away from electrifying our homes, our workplaces, and our transit.

561
01:02:13.856 --> 01:02:20.807
<v Deneen Crowe>Grid expansions and substation upgrades carry massive price tags that are frequently passed along to everyday ratepayers.

562
01:02:21.547 --> 01:02:30.650
<v Deneen Crowe>With Oregonians already facing skyrocketing utility bills, working-class ratepayers should not be forced to subsidize billion-dollar tech corporations.

563
01:02:31.838 --> 01:02:38.052
<v Deneen Crowe>These hyperscale facilities can also consume millions of gallons of water per day for this evaporative cooling.

564
01:02:38.648 --> 01:02:53.137
<v Deneen Crowe>As we continue living in the largest wildfire season in Oregon's recorded history, allocating any drop of municipal water to cool computer servers, especially without public review or oversight, is absolutely delusional.

565
01:02:54.766 --> 01:03:01.242
<v Deneen Crowe>Right now, our organization is one of many fighting for this 3-year moratorium of any new data centers in the state.

566
01:03:01.791 --> 01:03:03.539
<v Deneen Crowe>This is the direction we must be headed in.

567
01:03:03.898 --> 01:03:15.972
<v Deneen Crowe>Forcing any conversations about possible data centers to be out in the open and transparent to the public is secret deals inhibit democracy.

568
01:03:16.554 --> 01:03:32.286
<v Deneen Crowe>When tech giants are negotiating behind closed doors and force public officials to sign nondisclosure agreements, the public— we're left carrying the burden of this increased energy and water costs from these facilities and we're kept behind closed doors.

569
01:03:33.512 --> 01:03:39.851
<v Deneen Crowe>We can't plan a transition, a just transition from the fossil fuel industry to clean energy in the dark.

570
01:03:39.900 --> 01:03:40.045
<v Deneen Crowe>Thank you.

571
01:03:40.867 --> 01:03:42.875
<v Deneen Crowe>Please vote yes on this resolution.

572
01:03:42.989 --> 01:03:43.344
<v Deneen Crowe>Thank you.

573
01:03:49.284 --> 01:03:50.320
<v Nick Caleb>Good afternoon, councilors.

574
01:03:50.579 --> 01:03:51.663
<v Nick Caleb>Uh, my name is Nick Caleb.

575
01:03:51.742 --> 01:03:55.108
<v Nick Caleb>I'm the climate energy attorney at Breach Collective, a local nonprofit.

576
01:03:55.204 --> 01:03:56.789
<v Nick Caleb>I'm registered a lobbyist with the city.

577
01:03:57.614 --> 01:04:02.197
<v Nick Caleb>Uh, we support the underlying resolution and the amendment that's been offered for it.

578
01:04:02.715 --> 01:04:07.893
<v Nick Caleb>Um, honestly, there's not a lot in addition to what I could say that already been said.

579
01:04:08.172 --> 01:04:09.518
<v Nick Caleb>Excellent testimony that covers a lot of issues.

580
01:04:09.568 --> 01:04:13.519
<v Nick Caleb>I just think from my specific area of expertise.

581
01:04:13.568 --> 01:04:22.235
<v Nick Caleb>I'll comment briefly on the climate impacts, um, and from a utility perspective, the bill impacts.

582
01:04:22.380 --> 01:04:32.858
<v Nick Caleb>Um, I think there's a misconception or a hopeful conception that's been going around that the POWER Act is going to solve a lot of the ratepayer issues related to data centers.

583
01:04:33.434 --> 01:04:34.427
<v Nick Caleb>I don't think that's true.

584
01:04:34.811 --> 01:04:43.338
<v Nick Caleb>It will reduce the burden on residential ratepayers as a class, but it doesn't fully send those to the data centers.

585
01:04:43.387 --> 01:04:51.362
<v Nick Caleb>It doesn't put them— so there's still a portion of that that's subsidized by residential ratepayers, which is highly inequitable given that we get very little out of this.

586
01:04:52.614 --> 01:04:57.603
<v Nick Caleb>And our rates have gone up over 50% in the last 5 years, so we're already rate burdened.

587
01:04:58.389 --> 01:05:09.028
<v Nick Caleb>And, you know, I don't think this is necessarily the job of City Council, but I want my, you know, check for the last 5 years of data centers that I've subsidized out of my pocket.

588
01:05:09.092 --> 01:05:09.188
<v Nick Caleb>Thank you.

589
01:05:09.269 --> 01:05:10.568
<v Nick Caleb>Paying my energy bills, right?

590
01:05:10.744 --> 01:05:13.166
<v Nick Caleb>Like, they don't go down just because we've kind of kept it here.

591
01:05:13.246 --> 01:05:18.411
<v Nick Caleb>So there's— we're already inheriting inequities that have been built into this development that we need to remedy.

592
01:05:19.726 --> 01:05:20.849
<v Nick Caleb>People are really burdened.

593
01:05:21.329 --> 01:05:35.043
<v Nick Caleb>And from a climate perspective, there's another mythology that we can just kind of hitch our renewable energy strategy to data centers and they'll kind of like build the infrastructure we need and all the rest.

594
01:05:35.588 --> 01:05:37.817
<v Nick Caleb>This is delusional, as Deneen was saying.

595
01:05:37.994 --> 01:05:38.411
<v Nick Caleb>Yeah.

596
01:05:39.518 --> 01:05:42.391
<v Nick Caleb>First of all, they eat up all the renewable energy that we already have on the grid.

597
01:05:42.440 --> 01:05:44.559
<v Nick Caleb>It goes to serving these data centers.

598
01:05:44.735 --> 01:05:46.695
<v Nick Caleb>Anything new goes to serving these data centers.

599
01:05:46.742 --> 01:05:49.280
<v Nick Caleb>So we never actually get off of fossil fuels.

600
01:05:49.327 --> 01:05:53.309
<v Nick Caleb>We're just adding more energy and more renewables in the same amount of fossil fuels.

601
01:05:54.208 --> 01:06:09.217
<v Nick Caleb>And across the country, gas infrastructure is actually being built to directly service these new data centers, like massive— second largest gas facility in the country is being built in southern Ohio to serve a hyperscale data center.

602
01:06:09.715 --> 01:06:18.467
<v Nick Caleb>And our gas industry here is salivating to change the laws to be able to supply the gas-powered electricity to power data centers moving forward.

603
01:06:18.516 --> 01:06:22.025
<v Nick Caleb>And so this is a gold rush type moment that we're seeing.

604
01:06:22.523 --> 01:06:28.806
<v Nick Caleb>Everybody who wants to make a buck is diving in and trying to claw as much as they possibly can until this bubble bursts.

605
01:06:29.431 --> 01:06:38.746
<v Nick Caleb>And our job as Portlanders is to do what we've done in the past, which is to hold the line, to resist the seduction, the siren call of money here.

606
01:06:38.954 --> 01:06:48.773
<v Nick Caleb>And, and can you hear me?

607
01:06:49.972 --> 01:06:50.246
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

608
01:06:52.175 --> 01:06:52.954
<v Zach White>Thank you, councilors.

609
01:06:53.001 --> 01:06:53.893
<v Zach White>My name is Zach White.

610
01:06:54.023 --> 01:06:55.514
<v Zach White>I was born in District 1.

611
01:06:55.579 --> 01:06:57.170
<v Zach White>I just moved to District 3.

612
01:06:57.461 --> 01:07:03.996
<v Zach White>I'm a field organizer with Next Step Action Fund, a political home to build upon the collective power and leadership of diverse young people.

613
01:07:04.900 --> 01:07:06.961
<v Zach White>Here's a headline from Willamette Week.

614
01:07:07.362 --> 01:07:13.481
<v Zach White>In June, data center backlash decided an Oregon Senate race in the Silicon Forest.

615
01:07:14.411 --> 01:07:19.393
<v Zach White>This spring, I got to canvass voters in Hillsboro for that race and can confirm.

616
01:07:20.402 --> 01:07:21.989
<v Zach White>Um, here's OPB in January.

617
01:07:23.143 --> 01:07:29.552
<v Zach White>As Google's water demands grow, the Dalles aims to put more— pull more from Mount Hood Forest.

618
01:07:30.657 --> 01:07:36.648
<v Zach White>Last week's Economist YouGov poll reported that 61% of respondents said they'd oppose data center construction.

619
01:07:38.528 --> 01:07:47.860
<v Zach White>Republican respondents were more divided, but still 47%, a clear plurality, were opposed to data centers in their communities, out of step with President Trump.

620
01:07:49.050 --> 01:07:57.739
<v Zach White>The specter of AI takeover, data centers, and driverless cars often reminds me of the dystopian Terminator films.

621
01:07:58.833 --> 01:08:04.518
<v Zach White>But I also think of a scene in one of The Matrix movies when humans wake up from a computer simulation and realize that they've been living in a simulation.

622
01:08:10.619 --> 01:08:16.856
<v Zach White>Growing up here in these sacred forests, I thank God that they are still vast beyond my comprehension.

623
01:08:17.893 --> 01:08:25.976
<v Zach White>Maybe it's hyperbolic to evoke Neo and machine Earth, but living here has also taught me how fast our forests can burn.

624
01:08:27.939 --> 01:08:31.416
<v Zach White>Portlanders voted for the charter reform because they wanted transparency in government.

625
01:08:31.480 --> 01:08:31.938
<v Zach White>I think that's a good thing.

626
01:08:32.819 --> 01:08:41.154
<v Zach White>As citizens watching the Moda Center negotiations, the mere mention of city officials signing nondisclosure agreements eroded public trust.

627
01:08:42.099 --> 01:08:47.051
<v Zach White>When backroom deals become part of policymaking, the will of the people becomes an afterthought.

628
01:08:48.014 --> 01:08:59.875
<v Zach White>I'm reminded of a 1912 quote from a former U.S. president: Behind the ostensible government sits enthroned an invisible government, owing no allegiance and acknowledging no responsibility to the people.

629
01:08:59.922 --> 01:09:00.034
<v Zach White>Thank you.

630
01:09:00.694 --> 01:09:10.115
<v Zach White>To destroy this invisible government, to befoul the unholy alliance between corrupt business and corrupt politics, is the first task of the statesmanship of today.

631
01:09:10.920 --> 01:09:13.780
<v Zach White>Passing this resolution feels like a step in that direction.

632
01:09:14.054 --> 01:09:14.310
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

633
01:09:18.391 --> 01:09:18.819
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you all.

634
01:09:19.953 --> 01:09:20.957
<v Candace Avalos>Our next round.

635
01:09:22.234 --> 01:09:23.054
<v Unidentified speaker>Call the next group.

636
01:09:23.201 --> 01:09:37.541
<v Unidentified speaker>Benjamin Gilbert, Leslie Cocken, Go ahead.

637
01:09:41.167 --> 01:09:52.666
<v Ben Gilbert>My name is Ben Gilbert, and I'm a volunteer lobbyist for the Portland Democratic Socialists of America, the largest socialist organization in the history of the United States, with over 3,700 members in the Portland metro area.

638
01:09:53.949 --> 01:09:58.818
<v Ben Gilbert>DSA and our members are really worried about data center development in Portland and across the state.

639
01:09:59.668 --> 01:10:03.814
<v Ben Gilbert>We have heard concerning rumors of data centers being built within the city of Portland.

640
01:10:04.649 --> 01:10:07.524
<v Ben Gilbert>We need accountability from this administration on this issue.

641
01:10:08.328 --> 01:10:14.850
<v Ben Gilbert>There has been a pattern of backroom deals under code names, and Portlanders deserve transparency, not NDAs.

642
01:10:15.878 --> 01:10:19.605
<v Ben Gilbert>We have seen cities like Hillsboro and Salem move towards moratoriums on data centers.

643
01:10:19.654 --> 01:10:19.846
<v Ben Gilbert>Thank you.

644
01:10:20.313 --> 01:10:21.966
<v Ben Gilbert>And we should be moving in the same direction.

645
01:10:23.186 --> 01:10:30.332
<v Ben Gilbert>However, we have seen in Hillsboro efforts to ram through permits for data centers to the dismay of the public before moratoriums can take effect.

646
01:10:31.311 --> 01:10:35.421
<v Ben Gilbert>We're grateful for this excellent legislation as a first step towards that— to that end.

647
01:10:36.128 --> 01:10:46.454
<v Ben Gilbert>To make sure we aren't let down, I want to commend Councilor Koyama Lane and Councilor Green for bringing this legislation forward, and to the members of the Housing and Permitting Committee who will support it.

648
01:10:47.532 --> 01:10:53.484
<v Ben Gilbert>We are eager to provide support towards a data center moratorium in the city of Portland and across the state.

649
01:10:53.548 --> 01:10:53.855
<v Ben Gilbert>Thank you.

650
01:10:56.456 --> 01:10:57.731
<v Unidentified speaker>Leslie is joining us online.

651
01:10:57.845 --> 01:10:59.234
<v Unidentified speaker>Leslie, go ahead and unmute.

652
01:11:04.298 --> 01:11:05.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, can you hear me okay?

653
01:11:07.100 --> 01:11:07.229
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

654
01:11:08.331 --> 01:11:10.712
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, yeah, I'm Leslie Kochen.

655
01:11:10.905 --> 01:11:17.153
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm with Extinction Rebellion PDX as well as the Oregon Data Center Defiance Coalition.

656
01:11:17.810 --> 01:11:26.288
<v Unidentified speaker>And first, I do want to thank Councilor Koyama Lane and Green for bringing this forward, as well as your staff for working on this.

657
01:11:27.426 --> 01:11:36.979
<v Unidentified speaker>Massive data center build-out by big tech and its investors has sparked resistance in communities most impacted and beyond.

658
01:11:37.363 --> 01:11:53.878
<v Unidentified speaker>The resistance is to the damage to the local environment and public health, the added emissions fueling the climate crisis, increased utility costs, and whether unlimited AI development is necessary or desired.

659
01:11:54.537 --> 01:12:06.247
<v Unidentified speaker>Non-disclosure agreements stymie this resistance by hiding the initial stages of deal-making between government entities and real estate developers, investors, and tech companies.

660
01:12:07.710 --> 01:12:18.818
<v Unidentified speaker>In case after case, local residents learn about data center proposals only after months or years of secret negotiations, and sometimes even after initial development has occurred.

661
01:12:19.283 --> 01:12:26.069
<v Unidentified speaker>Big tech knows that information is power, and they do everything possible to stop the flow of information.

662
01:12:26.904 --> 01:12:34.172
<v Unidentified speaker>This blocks residents from meaningful participation in decisions that will have enormous impacts on their communities.

663
01:12:34.751 --> 01:12:39.885
<v Unidentified speaker>For these reasons, I support the City of Portland's proposal to prevent the use of nondisclosure.

664
01:12:40.286 --> 01:12:41.872
<v Unidentified speaker>Agreements for data centers.

665
01:12:42.369 --> 01:12:52.453
<v Unidentified speaker>I would also encourage the city to consider whether there may be other large-scale development projects in Portland that use NDAs to prevent transparency.

666
01:12:53.206 --> 01:13:06.319
<v Unidentified speaker>In addition, I recommend that rather than urge the city administrator and any city leadership to refrain from signing NDAs, the word urge be replaced with prohibit.

667
01:13:06.817 --> 01:13:12.630
<v Unidentified speaker>And city leadership be defined to include elected officials, city staff, etc.

668
01:13:13.320 --> 01:13:33.635
<v Unidentified speaker>Lastly, I suggest adding the requirement that public notice occur when city officials receive any data center proposals or applications, or consider actions for expansion, zoning, or tax abatements related to current data center— centers operating within the City of Portland.

669
01:13:34.358 --> 01:13:47.319
<v Unidentified speaker>I also support the recommendation made by AI Now in its toolkit under specify minimum transparency requirements as part of the application process.

670
01:13:47.930 --> 01:14:02.418
<v Unidentified speaker>I've listed these in my written testimony, but I'll note that they include the name of all companies involved in data center— in a data center project, including developers, shell companies, data center operators and financiers.

671
01:14:02.900 --> 01:14:08.363
<v Unidentified speaker>Our communities have the right to know who will really benefit from these data center developments.

672
01:14:08.814 --> 01:14:13.653
<v Unidentified speaker>And I also urge the city to move towards a ban on hyperscale data centers.

673
01:14:14.009 --> 01:14:14.430
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

674
01:14:14.819 --> 01:14:17.780
<v Unidentified speaker>Sarah, go ahead.

675
01:14:18.715 --> 01:14:19.118
<v Amber Cook>Sure.

676
01:14:19.810 --> 01:14:28.555
<v Sarah Taylor>Hi, my name is Sarah Taylor and I live in District 4, and I have been in my life a midwife and an educator.

677
01:14:29.101 --> 01:14:32.755
<v Sarah Taylor>And I'm here to advocate for mothers and children and families.

678
01:14:33.572 --> 01:14:41.677
<v Sarah Taylor>I wanna start by saying I absolutely support this resolution and I oppose all non-disclosure agreements.

679
01:14:43.023 --> 01:14:51.417
<v Sarah Taylor>I don't believe that you— I believe they are in violation of state land use laws.

680
01:14:52.091 --> 01:14:56.224
<v Sarah Taylor>Number one, state land use law says you have to have community involvement.

681
01:14:56.271 --> 01:15:00.261
<v Sarah Taylor>So first of all, an NDA would right off the bat violate that.

682
01:15:00.324 --> 01:15:00.436
<v Sarah Taylor>Thank you.

683
01:15:01.130 --> 01:15:07.051
<v Sarah Taylor>As well, it is impossible to honor tribal treaties and have NDAs.

684
01:15:08.163 --> 01:15:11.332
<v Sarah Taylor>Aside from that, I would like to tell you about my last week.

685
01:15:13.108 --> 01:15:15.689
<v Sarah Taylor>I helped the people in Lloyd Center move out.

686
01:15:17.141 --> 01:15:19.029
<v Sarah Taylor>I will try not to cry right now.

687
01:15:19.900 --> 01:15:20.997
<v Sarah Taylor>I am exhausted.

688
01:15:22.326 --> 01:15:34.516
<v Sarah Taylor>I watched yesterday 8 people, the same number that a data center, I guess, employs, who had worked at Lloyd Center for 30 years be laid off.

689
01:15:35.657 --> 01:15:37.006
<v Sarah Taylor>Nobody shook their hand.

690
01:15:38.051 --> 01:15:41.971
<v Sarah Taylor>Nobody thanked them for their years of picking up our popcorn.

691
01:15:42.904 --> 01:15:47.756
<v Sarah Taylor>So Jan Zuckerman and I, we had a little ceremony for them in our empty gallery.

692
01:15:48.976 --> 01:15:57.884
<v Sarah Taylor>I have watched people with 30 years at that place, 70 years old, pushing their things out alone.

693
01:15:58.743 --> 01:16:00.904
<v Sarah Taylor>And so we stayed and we helped them.

694
01:16:02.485 --> 01:16:15.412
<v Sarah Taylor>I believe that had that project required transparency, that this would never have happened.

695
01:16:16.462 --> 01:16:19.444
<v Sarah Taylor>So I believe that we hurt our families.

696
01:16:19.622 --> 01:16:21.128
<v Sarah Taylor>And I want to ask you one thing.

697
01:16:21.873 --> 01:16:26.250
<v Sarah Taylor>You are closing 10 to 20 schools in this city.

698
01:16:26.844 --> 01:16:28.193
<v Sarah Taylor>They're meeting tonight.

699
01:16:29.091 --> 01:16:42.431
<v Sarah Taylor>Your first priority has to be asking, why would a city that is losing 10 to 20 schools not making that your top priority?

700
01:16:43.122 --> 01:16:57.953
<v Sarah Taylor>Your relationship with corporations is destroying this city, and the way you do that is no nondisclosure agreements with anybody who is going to take taxpayer dollars.

701
01:16:58.963 --> 01:17:09.298
<v Sarah Taylor>So if they want all this stuff, TIFs and RIFs and all that stuff, right away they say it right up front to the public.

702
01:17:10.326 --> 01:17:12.845
<v Sarah Taylor>And there are models throughout this country that do that.

703
01:17:12.909 --> 01:17:13.728
<v Sarah Taylor>So thank you.

704
01:17:14.016 --> 01:17:18.766
<v Sarah Taylor>And, and I'm just gonna tell you, I am heartbroken about what I saw at Lloyd Center.

705
01:17:19.328 --> 01:17:26.869
<v Sarah Taylor>And this morning, I drove here on Highway 30 and watched little kids at the bus stop standing next to fuel tanks.

706
01:17:27.439 --> 01:17:28.742
<v Sarah Taylor>Should not be happening.

707
01:17:28.939 --> 01:17:30.310
<v Sarah Taylor>Thank you very much.

708
01:17:32.300 --> 01:17:34.637
<v Unidentified speaker>Lynn, go ahead and unmute and begin your testimony.

709
01:17:37.844 --> 01:17:38.134
<v Lynn Handlin>Thanks.

710
01:17:38.425 --> 01:17:46.819
<v Lynn Handlin>Um, my name is Lynn Handlin, and first I want to say thank you to Councilor Koyama Lane and Councilor Green Thank you.

711
01:17:46.948 --> 01:17:49.568
<v Lynn Handlin>Thank you, Councilor Tiffany Koyama Lane, for bringing this resolution.

712
01:17:49.792 --> 01:17:51.979
<v Lynn Handlin>I fully support this resolution.

713
01:17:52.975 --> 01:17:56.204
<v Lynn Handlin>I would like there to be a few adjustments.

714
01:17:56.527 --> 01:18:00.029
<v Lynn Handlin>Leslie pointed out one, and those are language things.

715
01:18:00.126 --> 01:18:06.048
<v Lynn Handlin>Rather than urge leaders to refrain from NDAs, how about require?

716
01:18:06.970 --> 01:18:16.315
<v Lynn Handlin>And in the third part, it says City of Portland officials are encouraged to engage in transparent public processes for all decisions relating to data centers, etc.

717
01:18:19.064 --> 01:18:20.283
<v Lynn Handlin>It should be required.

718
01:18:20.814 --> 01:18:32.512
<v Lynn Handlin>And honestly, shouldn't, shouldn't this just be true throughout all city government activity, that, that it be— that there be transparent public processes?

719
01:18:33.653 --> 01:18:41.902
<v Lynn Handlin>Um, I, I— yeah, this— it's, it's a little bit shocking that that's not just already a thing.

720
01:18:42.560 --> 01:18:55.475
<v Lynn Handlin>Um, I would also like to add or have your next step be a moratorium on all new data centers long enough to get some kind of guardrails in place.

721
01:18:57.467 --> 01:19:11.091
<v Lynn Handlin>I do appreciate that this not only establishes a ban on NDAs regarding data centers, and it also requires city administrators to notify council when they receive requests for early assistance.

722
01:19:11.302 --> 01:19:18.497
<v Lynn Handlin>Um, It's really too bad that this was not in place for previous activity with fossil fuel and other fuel companies.

723
01:19:19.122 --> 01:19:21.734
<v Lynn Handlin>We would be a much safer city if that had been the case.

724
01:19:21.846 --> 01:19:25.387
<v Lynn Handlin>So I'm super glad you're doing this now for data centers.

725
01:19:25.452 --> 01:19:27.663
<v Lynn Handlin>I would like to expand it for all activity.

726
01:19:28.818 --> 01:19:30.148
<v Lynn Handlin>We don't need more data centers.

727
01:19:30.260 --> 01:19:32.470
<v Lynn Handlin>You've heard enough excellent testimony.

728
01:19:32.807 --> 01:19:37.935
<v Lynn Handlin>And I'm also with Extinction Rebellion PDX and the Data Center Defiance Alliance.

729
01:19:38.127 --> 01:19:41.739
<v Lynn Handlin>Speaking for myself today, we don't need more data centers.

730
01:19:41.805 --> 01:19:52.337
<v Lynn Handlin>We have enough and then some to do all the things we need and want, and we have a lot more to do the things we don't need and really don't want.

731
01:19:52.546 --> 01:19:56.063
<v Lynn Handlin>This NDA resolution is about good government.

732
01:19:57.042 --> 01:20:03.385
<v Lynn Handlin>It introduces transparency in, in this one area, which is really excellent.

733
01:20:05.731 --> 01:20:26.774
<v Lynn Handlin>And that transparency has been sorely lacking, especially with prior city councils and especially with other aspects of city government, the administrators and bureau directors, and even at times, unfortunately, the city attorneys, a lack of transparency that, you know, borders on really, really wrong.

734
01:20:27.368 --> 01:20:30.743
<v Lynn Handlin>So thank you very much for bringing this resolution.

735
01:20:30.841 --> 01:20:32.823
<v Lynn Handlin>Please pass it and make it stronger.

736
01:20:32.872 --> 01:20:32.970
<v Lynn Handlin>Thank you.

737
01:20:33.036 --> 01:20:33.363
<v Lynn Handlin>Thank you.

738
01:20:35.989 --> 01:20:37.390
<v Unidentified speaker>Sam is joining us online.

739
01:20:37.568 --> 01:20:38.791
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead and unmute, Sam.

740
01:20:41.609 --> 01:20:49.782
<v Sam Schillinger>Hi, my name is Sam Schillinger, and I am a District 3 resident and the campaign director for Pro Animal Oregon.

741
01:20:50.782 --> 01:20:55.610
<v Sam Schillinger>And I want to thank Councilor Koyama Lane and Councilor Green for sponsoring this resolution.

742
01:20:56.454 --> 01:21:03.460
<v Sam Schillinger>As a resident who cares deeply about animal welfare and environmental stewardship, I strongly urge you to support this resolution.

743
01:21:04.134 --> 01:21:08.677
<v Sam Schillinger>Data centers require immense land, power, and water resources.

744
01:21:09.207 --> 01:21:20.896
<v Sam Schillinger>It drives up fossil fuel reliance, drains natural watersheds, and generates continuous industrial noise and heat that disrupt local habitats, migratory birds, and native wildlife.

745
01:21:21.539 --> 01:21:31.595
<v Sam Schillinger>When these massive developments are negotiated behind closed doors through non-disclosure agreements, The public loses any chance to evaluate their ecological impact or protect sensitive ecosystems.

746
01:21:32.500 --> 01:21:43.539
<v Sam Schillinger>Ending these secret deals and committing to complete transparency is critical to ensuring our city's growth doesn't come at the tragic expense of the animals and environments that depend on us to protect them.

747
01:21:44.328 --> 01:21:46.001
<v Sam Schillinger>Please support this resolution.

748
01:21:46.676 --> 01:21:46.997
<v Sam Schillinger>Thank you.

749
01:21:50.710 --> 01:21:52.274
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll call our next group up.

750
01:21:52.828 --> 01:21:53.188
<v Unidentified speaker>Nathan.

751
01:21:56.194 --> 01:21:58.011
<v Unidentified speaker>Katrina, Tammy, and Jordan.

752
01:22:09.158 --> 01:22:11.364
<v Unidentified speaker>Feel free to get started and state your name.

753
01:22:12.386 --> 01:22:13.393
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Good afternoon, councilors.

754
01:22:13.457 --> 01:22:14.966
<v Nathan Ong Norris>My name is Nathan Ong Norris.

755
01:22:15.323 --> 01:22:17.760
<v Nathan Ong Norris>I am a candidate for Multnomah County Commissioner for District 2.

756
01:22:18.557 --> 01:22:19.697
<v Nathan Ong Norris>I've made the statement elsewhere.

757
01:22:19.793 --> 01:22:20.738
<v Nathan Ong Norris>I'm going to read it now for the record.

758
01:22:21.904 --> 01:22:24.869
<v Nathan Ong Norris>I support restrictions and a moratorium on data center development.

759
01:22:25.671 --> 01:22:29.376
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Oregon is going to be on the forefront of the data center discussion for the foreseeable future.

760
01:22:30.145 --> 01:22:35.533
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Currently, there are at least 4 data centers operating in Multnomah County and additional sites being considered for development.

761
01:22:36.416 --> 01:22:47.689
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Now is the time to develop regulations and standards to protect Oregonians' land, air, and water, to ensure the integrity of our energy grid, and to keep costs down for utility ratepayers.

762
01:22:47.784 --> 01:22:53.391
<v Nathan Ong Norris>councilmember as Oregonians, we have to be focused on the long-term health of our state and the people who live here.

763
01:22:54.162 --> 01:23:00.301
<v Nathan Ong Norris>If data centers are going to be a part of that, we have to make sure they're contributing positively and paying their fair share in taxes.

764
01:23:01.442 --> 01:23:01.747
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Thank you.

765
01:23:02.646 --> 01:23:10.279
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Finally, I want to add that this kind of common-sense governance is the antidote to the corporate greed-driven capitalist dystopia we're living through.

766
01:23:11.018 --> 01:23:14.859
<v Nathan Ong Norris>It is obvious to me and to my comrades and allies that a transparent thank you.

767
01:23:14.859 --> 01:23:14.859
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Thank you.

768
01:23:14.859 --> 01:23:14.859
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

769
01:23:14.859 --> 01:23:14.859
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Thank you, members of council.

770
01:23:14.859 --> 01:23:19.510
<v Nathan Ong Norris>A transparent process with accountability to the people is the most basic requirement we have of our government.

771
01:23:20.220 --> 01:23:23.340
<v Nathan Ong Norris>Thank you to Councilors Koyama Lane and Green for bringing it forward.

772
01:23:23.920 --> 01:23:24.819
<v Nathan Ong Norris>See you out there.

773
01:23:27.239 --> 01:23:29.460
<v Tammy Carpenter>Hi, councilors.

774
01:23:29.460 --> 01:23:34.079
<v Tammy Carpenter>My name is Tammy Carpenter, for the record, and I sit on the Beaverton School Board.

775
01:23:34.079 --> 01:23:35.939
<v Tammy Carpenter>I am speaking on my own behalf today.

776
01:23:35.939 --> 01:23:42.225
<v Tammy Carpenter>I am also the Democratic nominee for House District 27, which has a small sliver in District 4.

777
01:23:42.609 --> 01:24:04.756
<v Tammy Carpenter>Um, and I want to express deep appreciation for all of the experts that have been working so hard on this— Oregon Data Center Defiance, um, other climate orgs, uh, unions that are very interested in ensuring that we are getting, um, good return on investments, uh, in the form of good jobs.

778
01:24:04.899 --> 01:24:17.060
<v Tammy Carpenter>And, um, And the, the voice, uh, that is also important is the, the Portland chapter of DSA has been really important in helping us understand, um, the problem and how we move forward.

779
01:24:17.557 --> 01:24:20.510
<v Tammy Carpenter>And I want to speak, um, from my experience as a school board member.

780
01:24:20.605 --> 01:24:25.403
<v Tammy Carpenter>We have very similar, maybe the same, um, rules around public meetings.

781
01:24:25.900 --> 01:24:35.927
<v Tammy Carpenter>Um, and I say that, uh, because we are able to meet in executive session or very limited number of items, you know, labor negotiations, land purchases.

782
01:24:36.426 --> 01:25:03.765
<v Tammy Carpenter>And to hear about NDAs that are outside of those rules, that are outside of public meeting rules in general, gives me— I'm just very curious about how you think about that happening as an elected official responsible for governance and to have NDAs happening Um, that aren't subject to the, the public meeting rules.

783
01:25:04.021 --> 01:25:12.532
<v Tammy Carpenter>Um, I would strongly encourage you to continue to build, um, public trust in your work that you have been doing all along over these many months.

784
01:25:12.932 --> 01:25:17.542
<v Tammy Carpenter>Um, and one of those ways is to ensure that the public— the work of the public is done in the public.

785
01:25:17.605 --> 01:25:19.243
<v Tammy Carpenter>So really appreciate you guys tackling this.

786
01:25:19.628 --> 01:25:20.110
<v Tammy Carpenter>senator—.

787
01:25:20.416 --> 01:25:24.751
<v Tammy Carpenter>Uh, Councilor Koyama Lane and Councilor Green, really appreciate your leadership on this.

788
01:25:29.104 --> 01:25:30.469
<v Unidentified speaker>Katrina's joined us online.

789
01:25:30.831 --> 01:25:32.952
<v Unidentified speaker>Katrina, go ahead and unmute and begin your testimony.

790
01:25:37.180 --> 01:25:40.713
<v Katrina>Hello, um, my name is Katrina.

791
01:25:40.908 --> 01:25:42.877
<v Katrina>I've lived in St. Johns for 5 years.

792
01:25:42.942 --> 01:25:48.069
<v Katrina>I'm a lifelong resident of Portland, a restaurant owner, and a new mom to a wonderful 4-month-old daughter.

793
01:25:48.681 --> 01:25:52.770
<v Katrina>I wanted to share my opinion on data centers transparency legislation today.

794
01:25:55.009 --> 01:26:03.087
<v Katrina>Thank you for bringing this piece of legislation, Councilors Koyama Lane and Green, and thank you to the other testimonials in favor of this resolution.

795
01:26:04.546 --> 01:26:09.100
<v Katrina>I agree that emphatically, yes, of course there should be transparency in data center decisions.

796
01:26:10.557 --> 01:26:13.972
<v Katrina>What I really want to point out is the absurdity of this discussion in the first place.

797
01:26:14.582 --> 01:26:19.759
<v Katrina>Why are clandestine backdoor deals and the existence of NDAs even on the table at all?

798
01:26:20.595 --> 01:26:21.587
<v Katrina>How is this even happening?

799
01:26:23.680 --> 01:26:26.993
<v Katrina>We are really discussing whether city leadership needs to answer to the public.

800
01:26:28.159 --> 01:26:30.670
<v Katrina>I mean, where do they even get off considering NDAs in the first place?

801
01:26:31.747 --> 01:26:36.768
<v Katrina>It's extremely hard as a regular person to keep track of how this even happens.

802
01:26:38.159 --> 01:26:45.157
<v Katrina>Anybody who does engage in secret deals and NDAs with taxpayer money around data centers or anything else should lose their job entirely.

803
01:26:45.301 --> 01:26:45.479
<v Katrina>Second.

804
01:26:46.077 --> 01:26:48.788
<v Katrina>The data centers don't contribute to the betterment of society.

805
01:26:49.463 --> 01:26:50.650
<v Katrina>They don't make our children safer.

806
01:26:50.811 --> 01:26:56.461
<v Katrina>They don't make anybody's life more affordable, and they blatantly destroy the environment and use up clean drinking water for what?

807
01:26:57.103 --> 01:26:59.381
<v Katrina>So a few creepy nerdy losers can make more money?

808
01:26:59.912 --> 01:27:03.923
<v Katrina>So people can voluntarily rot their brains and destroy their own creativity with AI?

809
01:27:04.533 --> 01:27:10.456
<v Katrina>So private companies can use the data and AI to build more and more advanced weapons to use on innocent people around the world?

810
01:27:10.569 --> 01:27:10.649
<v Katrina>Nay!

811
01:27:10.826 --> 01:27:19.170
<v Katrina>So we can stare— so we can store data for private companies' surveillance cameras I mean, what are we doing?

812
01:27:19.170 --> 01:27:20.210
<v Katrina>Why are we even talking about this?

813
01:27:20.210 --> 01:27:21.409
<v Katrina>It's beyond insane.

814
01:27:22.149 --> 01:27:27.310
<v Katrina>We could and should be so far ahead as a city than doing any business with the soulless perpetrators of these data centers.

815
01:27:27.609 --> 01:27:31.869
<v Katrina>For example, using green energy for all public transit, investing in wind and solar statewide.

816
01:27:32.229 --> 01:27:36.069
<v Katrina>The science already exists, and we could set such a positive example for the rest of the country.

817
01:27:36.470 --> 01:27:43.390
<v Katrina>We could and should be focused on returning land to— returning land to its rightful stewards, native tribes who know how to take care of the land and treat it with respect.

818
01:27:43.390 --> 01:27:43.430
<v Katrina>Thank you.

819
01:27:44.626 --> 01:27:48.337
<v Katrina>We all breathe air and drink the water, no matter how rich and how much data you have stored.

820
01:27:48.867 --> 01:27:58.247
<v Katrina>The owners of these AI data centers should be laughed out of society for even proposing that we use any land for their hideous data centers, which only serve their own greedy and antisocial purposes.

821
01:27:58.841 --> 01:28:07.162
<v Katrina>So they just get to invent a product and then also decide that that product needs a huge percentage of all existing energy and water, and we're just going to give it to them?

822
01:28:08.158 --> 01:28:11.179
<v Katrina>These are sociopaths who see no value in any kind of life whatsoever.

823
01:28:11.810 --> 01:28:14.640
<v Katrina>And only care about their own bank accounts at the expense of everything else.

824
01:28:16.640 --> 01:28:17.914
<v Katrina>The climate crisis is already here.

825
01:28:18.850 --> 01:28:19.899
<v Katrina>Skip past this part.

826
01:28:20.626 --> 01:28:25.807
<v Katrina>We need to be amping up every single effort to protect the beautiful earth, people, plants, and animals and ecosystems who live on it.

827
01:28:26.838 --> 01:28:32.123
<v Katrina>I never even heard of data centers until like 6 months ago, and they're everywhere now against everybody's wishes.

828
01:28:32.640 --> 01:28:36.016
<v Katrina>I've lived for 32 years without needing data centers and AI.

829
01:28:36.100 --> 01:28:36.421
<v Katrina>I'm sorry, I'm sorry.

830
01:28:37.068 --> 01:28:39.841
<v Katrina>Why are we acting like they're a normal and inevitable part of life?

831
01:28:39.939 --> 01:28:40.332
<v Katrina>They're not.

832
01:28:40.497 --> 01:28:41.072
<v Katrina>We do not need them.

833
01:28:42.350 --> 01:28:46.779
<v Katrina>Uh, okay, thank you.

834
01:28:47.520 --> 01:28:48.212
<v Jordan Lewis>Jordan Lewis.

835
01:28:51.161 --> 01:28:52.212
<v Jordan Lewis>That concludes testimony.

836
01:28:54.185 --> 01:28:55.118
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you folks.

837
01:28:55.311 --> 01:28:59.796
<v Candace Avalos>So we're going to go ahead and take a quick 10-minute break, and then we'll come back and have committee discussion.

838
01:28:59.894 --> 01:29:01.485
<v Candace Avalos>Please be here at 3:35.

839
01:29:02.145 --> 01:29:02.225
<v Candace Avalos>Got it.

840
01:29:02.757 --> 01:29:04.136
<v Candace Avalos>It's 11 minutes.

841
01:42:45.971 --> 01:42:50.753
<v Candace Avalos>All right, I will go ahead and bring us welcome back into our meeting at 3:38 PM.

842
01:42:50.865 --> 01:42:53.865
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you to all of our testifiers.

843
01:42:54.524 --> 01:43:01.774
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, we're going to move into committee discussion, and I want to kick it off with a quick procedural, um, ask.

844
01:43:01.840 --> 01:43:11.288
<v Candace Avalos>So because of, you know, city quorum laws, etc., um, I have to end this meeting formally, uh, ask to become a co-sponsor.

845
01:43:11.337 --> 01:43:15.507
<v Candace Avalos>I'm definitely supportive of the resolution, but have to do it publicly in the meeting.

846
01:43:15.555 --> 01:43:20.896
<v Candace Avalos>So I am formally requesting to be added as a co-sponsor of this resolution.

847
01:43:21.170 --> 01:43:21.346
<v Katrina>Woohoo!

848
01:43:21.876 --> 01:43:22.131
<v Lynn Handlin>Yeah.

849
01:43:22.292 --> 01:43:26.141
<v Candace Avalos>I don't know, is it— do I just— I think the city attorney just said as long as you get a thumbs up.

850
01:43:26.768 --> 01:43:27.201
<v Candace Avalos>Thumbs up?

851
01:43:27.569 --> 01:43:28.002
<v Candace Avalos>Thumbs up?

852
01:43:28.146 --> 01:43:28.579
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, great.

853
01:43:29.189 --> 01:43:30.617
<v Candace Avalos>Officially on the resolution.

854
01:43:30.698 --> 01:43:31.099
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

855
01:43:31.659 --> 01:43:35.123
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so yeah, let's go ahead and hop into committee discussion.

856
01:43:35.189 --> 01:43:39.887
<v Candace Avalos>I know I have a couple of questions too, but let's kick it off with Councilor Koyama Lane.

857
01:43:39.935 --> 01:43:41.940
<v Candace Avalos>Let's also, um, formally move the amendment.

858
01:43:42.069 --> 01:43:43.481
<v Katrina>Great.

859
01:43:43.546 --> 01:43:44.524
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair.

860
01:43:44.814 --> 01:44:00.898
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So we are advancing this resolution now because addressing, you know, stopping NDAs is an important first step, and it is really important that we are continuing to look at additional approaches to address negative consequences of data centers.

861
01:44:01.363 --> 01:44:03.578
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And we need to keep looking into those.

862
01:44:03.770 --> 01:44:11.201
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We need to look into restrictions on hyperscale data centers, better understand how large load centers impact our community.

863
01:44:11.713 --> 01:44:20.500
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That can be through a moratorium, but as we also have heard, that's a very long process that local jurisdictions can only do for 120 days.

864
01:44:20.612 --> 01:44:23.945
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so, um, another option is also looking into a ban.

865
01:44:24.523 --> 01:44:34.686
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, this is an amendment that would be in the resolution to just add the be it further resolved that as a council, we intend to keep looking into this.

866
01:44:34.863 --> 01:44:38.389
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We intend to keep pursuing what our different options are.

867
01:44:38.484 --> 01:44:40.215
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There will need to be some more discussions.

868
01:44:40.712 --> 01:44:51.814
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I have already texted, um, some colleagues at Multnomah County to see where they are at because it is, um, we're seeing Washington County, Clackamas County, um, leading on some of this.

869
01:44:52.087 --> 01:44:57.662
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so with that, I would like to formally move Koyama Lane Green 1.

870
01:44:58.032 --> 01:44:58.399
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Second.

871
01:44:59.873 --> 01:45:02.774
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so we will enter discussion on the amendment.

872
01:45:02.822 --> 01:45:03.030
<v Candace Avalos>Is there—.

873
01:45:03.462 --> 01:45:04.216
<v Candace Avalos>I see hands in the queue.

874
01:45:04.279 --> 01:45:04.984
<v Candace Avalos>Is it for the amendment?

875
01:45:05.658 --> 01:45:06.365
<v Ben Gilbert>Councilor Green?

876
01:45:07.025 --> 01:45:07.219
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

877
01:45:07.509 --> 01:45:07.895
<v Mitch Green>Go ahead.

878
01:45:08.796 --> 01:45:11.935
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for bringing the amendment and drafting this.

879
01:45:12.256 --> 01:45:13.046
<v Mitch Green>I support this.

880
01:45:15.362 --> 01:45:35.311
<v Mitch Green>I think it was important to be responsive to community concerns and sort of wondering why we're not just bringing forward a fully baked moratorium and understanding that there is a careful balance You have to navigate this very carefully with land use law, and so we want to make sure we do it right.

881
01:45:35.393 --> 01:45:42.904
<v Mitch Green>So, and putting this in here, um, fits in the spirit of the resolution, which signals council's intent on how we want to move forward on this.

882
01:45:43.179 --> 01:45:47.658
<v Mitch Green>And so, um, I think it's a good and welcome addition and an improvement to the underlying.

883
01:45:47.932 --> 01:45:48.948
<v Mitch Green>So I support it for that reason.

884
01:45:51.280 --> 01:45:51.636
<v Katrina>Great.

885
01:45:51.860 --> 01:45:53.199
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Koyama Lane?

886
01:45:53.537 --> 01:45:54.440
<v Candace Avalos>Oh no, you're not in the queue anymore.

887
01:45:54.698 --> 01:45:56.907
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, uh, any further discussion then?

888
01:45:57.020 --> 01:45:58.439
<v Candace Avalos>If not, we'll move forward with a vote.

889
01:46:00.930 --> 01:46:06.100
<v Candace Avalos>So, um, hold on, let me get my notes up.

890
01:46:07.082 --> 01:46:08.050
<v Candace Avalos>Lost my notes.

891
01:46:10.100 --> 01:46:15.247
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, yeah, I guess we just— it was moved and seconded by Councilor Koyama Lane, uh, seconded by Councilor Green.

892
01:46:15.310 --> 01:46:16.832
<v Candace Avalos>So we will go ahead and call the roll.

893
01:46:19.385 --> 01:46:24.198
<v Unidentified speaker>Roll call on the motion to amend the resolution as shown in Koyama Lane-Green 1.

894
01:46:27.000 --> 01:46:27.048
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

895
01:46:27.908 --> 01:46:28.247
<v Sarah Taylor>Novick?

896
01:46:29.220 --> 01:46:29.252
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

897
01:46:30.257 --> 01:46:30.550
<v Katrina>Green?

898
01:46:31.701 --> 01:46:31.750
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

899
01:46:32.819 --> 01:46:33.060
<v Nancy Thorington>Pirtle-Guiney?

900
01:46:41.091 --> 01:46:42.461
<v Candace Avalos>Pirtle-Guiney's not, not here right now.

901
01:46:42.509 --> 01:46:42.703
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

902
01:46:43.427 --> 01:46:43.895
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Avalos?

903
01:46:44.234 --> 01:46:44.314
<v Tammy Carpenter>Aye.

904
01:46:46.006 --> 01:46:54.002
<v Deneen Crowe>Uh, with 3 ayes, the motion to amend the resolution as shown in Koyama-Green Koyama Lane Green 1 has been approved.

905
01:46:54.260 --> 01:46:55.319
<v Candace Avalos>Great, thank you.

906
01:46:55.818 --> 01:46:59.225
<v Candace Avalos>So we'll move back into the now amended resolution discussion.

907
01:46:59.963 --> 01:47:01.923
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I don't see any hands.

908
01:47:01.988 --> 01:47:04.929
<v Candace Avalos>Let me get— oh, Councilor Green, go ahead, and then I'll ask some questions.

909
01:47:05.587 --> 01:47:06.054
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you.

910
01:47:06.230 --> 01:47:21.104
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I wanted to address, uh, one thing that kind of came up as a theme in the testimony, which was the, the question of, well, why, why is the language and there's a specific reason for that.

911
01:47:21.346 --> 01:47:23.738
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I wanted to kind of share that with the public.

912
01:47:24.760 --> 01:47:29.730
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, Councilor Koyama Lane, you can correct me if I steer off track here in terms of the intent here.

913
01:47:29.796 --> 01:47:40.728
<v Unidentified speaker>But per the charter, the charter reserves the rights for the mayor and assigns the duties to the mayor to execute contracts.

914
01:47:40.840 --> 01:47:40.969
<v Mitch Green>And so—.

915
01:47:41.001 --> 01:47:42.078
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's correct.

916
01:47:43.506 --> 01:47:49.386
<v Unidentified speaker>Council cannot direct the mayor or the city administrator on how to exercise that charter authority.

917
01:47:49.434 --> 01:47:52.293
<v Unidentified speaker>We can signal, we can say we want you to do this thing.

918
01:47:52.889 --> 01:47:57.130
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, we can demand of the mayor, we can urge of the mayor, and that's what we can do by resolution.

919
01:47:57.966 --> 01:48:04.230
<v Unidentified speaker>Elsewhere in other resolutions, if we're trying to compel a report or information from the city administrator, we can use the language require.

920
01:48:05.581 --> 01:48:09.034
<v Unidentified speaker>But that's the limit of power by a resolution by council.

921
01:48:10.480 --> 01:48:14.481
<v Unidentified speaker>Now, if we wanted to change the law, we do that by ordinance.

922
01:48:14.675 --> 01:48:27.256
<v Unidentified speaker>And it might be the case down the road that we want to contemplate a codification on limits to the mayor's scope in executing contracts, which is actually not well defined in the charter by my read.

923
01:48:27.996 --> 01:48:30.277
<v Unidentified speaker>It just says as long as it's consistent with the budget.

924
01:48:30.324 --> 01:48:32.092
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, I don't know what that means, right?

925
01:48:32.286 --> 01:48:33.972
<v Unidentified speaker>That could be widely interpreted.

926
01:48:34.600 --> 01:48:56.631
<v Unidentified speaker>And so So this is a resolution that is narrowly focused on a specific land use idea, which is about making sure that in the context of data centers, we're signaling council's intent that we expect and we hope, we urge the city administrator and the mayor to not be signing these things, because that's also what we're hearing in our communities.

927
01:48:56.984 --> 01:49:08.953
<v Unidentified speaker>Like when, when the reporting broke last year on NDAs being used as part of the Moda Center deal, I got a lot of emails from my constituents about like how outrageous that was and then question of like how deep does that go.

928
01:49:09.724 --> 01:49:19.798
<v Unidentified speaker>And so taking a proactive stance here to say we don't want that happening in the context of of any data center deals going on here, I think is a really reasonable way to start this.

929
01:49:20.152 --> 01:49:28.846
<v Unidentified speaker>And it might be the case that we have to down the road follow this up with some codification language by ordinance that cleans that up more broadly because I actually.

930
01:49:29.087 --> 01:49:36.197
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't think that we should have NDAs of any kind in the City of Portland among government officials, elected or otherwise.

931
01:49:37.511 --> 01:49:39.697
<v Unidentified speaker>But we can't compel that by resolution.

932
01:49:39.761 --> 01:49:43.048
<v Unidentified speaker>But what we can do right here is provide council's intent here.

933
01:49:44.416 --> 01:49:56.038
<v Unidentified speaker>I also want to say there was some testimony about the interaction between these hyperscale data centers and its effect on our grid.

934
01:49:56.722 --> 01:50:00.793
<v Unidentified speaker>And our electric utility system writ large.

935
01:50:02.636 --> 01:50:05.899
<v Unidentified speaker>And I, you know, it's— there's a deep— there's an interconnectedness.

936
01:50:05.947 --> 01:50:18.377
<v Unidentified speaker>There were some themes raised around affordability and rate, you know, rate pressure more broadly, but also a less discussed part is about, and it's a little more technical, but it's about the reliability of the grid, right?

937
01:50:18.442 --> 01:50:24.444
<v Unidentified speaker>So if your local utility— well, your local utility is required to engage in a long-term planning process.

938
01:50:24.493 --> 01:50:24.573
<v Mitch Green>Right.

939
01:50:25.484 --> 01:50:33.238
<v Unidentified speaker>Where they evaluate the suitability of their system in meeting its load obligation in a range of scenarios.

940
01:50:33.286 --> 01:50:36.529
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's a probabilistic statistical approach to that.

941
01:50:37.186 --> 01:50:51.859
<v Unidentified speaker>And Portland General Electric has some modeling in their long-term plan that they file with the Oregon Public Utility Commission and that they're required to file with NERC that shows increasing probability of brownouts and lack of system reliability.

942
01:50:52.677 --> 01:51:05.747
<v Unidentified speaker>And while in the context of that, you know, certain actions related to distribution lines, they'll say, well, I can't tell you who— what load is driving that because that's protected by contract.

943
01:51:05.796 --> 01:51:14.257
<v Unidentified speaker>If you just go look at the annual report on the first page for the last 3, 4 years, it said our growth is driven by data centers, particularly in Washington County.

944
01:51:15.092 --> 01:51:17.036
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the public is connecting those dots.

945
01:51:17.083 --> 01:51:17.229
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

946
01:51:17.725 --> 01:51:48.478
<v Unidentified speaker>And so it's really important that, um, that we as a body, we as a city, say we're going to do the right thing and decline to sign NDAs because what we don't want there to be any shadow of a doubt that the city is participating in actions that then result in, um, impacts on our communities through, you know, whether it be Forest Park or our our rate pressure that we, that we had some kind of control over or some hand in.

947
01:51:48.978 --> 01:51:51.667
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, so it's public trust is paramount here.

948
01:51:51.731 --> 01:51:57.481
<v Unidentified speaker>So I wanted to lift that piece up and just say I think this is the start.

949
01:51:57.546 --> 01:52:02.490
<v Unidentified speaker>I think we need to go bigger and contemplate prohibitions on NDAs more broadly.

950
01:52:02.893 --> 01:52:03.086
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

951
01:52:03.777 --> 01:52:06.364
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor.

952
01:52:08.020 --> 01:52:10.449
<v Candace Avalos>I have a couple of just staff questions.

953
01:52:10.729 --> 01:52:12.521
<v Candace Avalos>I know we have some staff in the room.

954
01:52:12.819 --> 01:52:14.087
<v Candace Avalos>To help answer.

955
01:52:16.359 --> 01:52:17.523
<v Candace Avalos>Um, if you could come on up.

956
01:52:17.655 --> 01:52:18.420
<v Candace Avalos>Great, thank you.

957
01:52:22.216 --> 01:52:31.787
<v Candace Avalos>So, uh, I guess I just wanted to know if you could walk us through what happens today if a company approaches the city about a large data center.

958
01:52:32.173 --> 01:52:35.626
<v Candace Avalos>At what point would council ordinarily become aware of that project?

959
01:52:35.707 --> 01:52:42.908
<v Candace Avalos>Tell me about what we're trying to solve for and help us understand the current you want me to take a stab at this?

960
01:52:43.390 --> 01:52:43.631
<v Katrina>Sure.

961
01:52:43.775 --> 01:52:48.030
<v Natalie Didion>So Natalie Didion representing Portland Permitting and Development.

962
01:52:49.091 --> 01:53:06.306
<v Natalie Didion>So if we're asking about the large-scale projects, any of those of any type, not just a data center, we have our process management team where the larger-scale projects go through and get extra assistance for the permitting.

963
01:53:07.000 --> 01:53:16.408
<v Natalie Didion>So they may set up an early assistance meeting, they may set up a life safety preliminary meeting, um, and then they have someone kind of tracking the project throughout.

964
01:53:16.971 --> 01:53:19.850
<v Natalie Didion>And so any large mega—.

965
01:53:19.867 --> 01:53:21.139
<v Candace Avalos>Whatever you were calling them now—.

966
01:53:21.865 --> 01:53:26.246
<v Natalie Didion>Data, uh, center would be going through those, um, channels right now.

967
01:53:27.944 --> 01:53:37.408
<v Natalie Didion>And, and to answer your question, correct me if I'm wrong, Natalie, but there is no direct communication with City Council about what permits are coming into the system.

968
01:53:37.457 --> 01:53:43.560
<v Natalie Didion>As you might imagine, there is, you know, thousands of permits coming in for electrical, trade, mechanical permits.

969
01:53:44.860 --> 01:53:51.398
<v Natalie Didion>They are all online, so through Portland Maps one can also view them by their neighborhood associations.

970
01:53:51.510 --> 01:53:55.975
<v Natalie Didion>I know many neighborhood associations look at them that way to see what permits have come in.

971
01:53:56.344 --> 01:54:01.173
<v Natalie Didion>You can subscribe to PP&Ds subscription services, um, to find out.

972
01:54:01.238 --> 01:54:12.239
<v Natalie Didion>I subscribe and I every day I get an email from like, here are, um, 4 or 5 new, um, early assistance that have come in and say what neighborhood association, what the proposal is, and then you can click through.

973
01:54:13.170 --> 01:54:18.413
<v Natalie Didion>Um, but there isn't a report that is coming to City Council for what permits come in.

974
01:54:18.557 --> 01:54:19.359
<v Natalie Didion>Is that accurate?

975
01:54:19.503 --> 01:54:19.984
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, thank you.

976
01:54:20.225 --> 01:54:20.481
<v Lynn Handlin>Yes.

977
01:54:20.962 --> 01:54:21.283
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

978
01:54:21.989 --> 01:54:34.474
<v Candace Avalos>And, um, could you talk to us about the 20 megawatts As the threshold, what, what, um, would that capture the type and scale facilities we're most concerned about without pulling ordinary commercial data operations into this process?

979
01:54:34.554 --> 01:54:36.577
<v Candace Avalos>Just want to understand what the threshold, where that came from.

980
01:54:37.731 --> 01:54:43.462
<v Natalie Didion>Yeah, I am not an expert on that, um, and maybe, um, Councilor Koyama Lane can speak to that.

981
01:54:43.590 --> 01:55:01.318
<v Natalie Didion>We have been talking about, um, we are in our discussion yesterday, we're talking about watts versus amps versus from a land use perspective, we would want to know what 20 megawatts would translate to for like what size of a building are we talking about, because that's what of course we would be permitting.

982
01:55:03.171 --> 01:55:10.251
<v Natalie Didion>And what size of a building would fit on what size of a lot so we can get a handle on where these land uses could be.

983
01:55:11.560 --> 01:55:17.056
<v Natalie Didion>So there's kind of some translation, some metrics that we need to wrap our heads around that I haven't quite done myself.

984
01:55:17.122 --> 01:55:17.234
<v Natalie Didion>Thank you.

985
01:55:19.277 --> 01:55:21.365
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I, I have the same question.

986
01:55:21.706 --> 01:55:27.744
<v Natalie Didion>The 20 megawatts, I am not familiar with that as a particular threshold for the scale.

987
01:55:28.519 --> 01:55:30.760
<v Candace Avalos>So, okay, thank you.

988
01:55:30.921 --> 01:55:32.806
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, um, great.

989
01:55:32.872 --> 01:55:35.015
<v Candace Avalos>Well, I think those are all my questions for you all.

990
01:55:35.193 --> 01:55:40.469
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate, um, obviously just the efforts here for this resolution.

991
01:55:40.581 --> 01:55:43.137
<v Candace Avalos>We have clearly heard a need from community for more transportation options.

992
01:55:43.203 --> 01:55:43.314
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

993
01:55:43.485 --> 01:55:44.032
<v Candace Avalos>Transparency.

994
01:55:44.609 --> 01:55:58.690
<v Candace Avalos>And importantly, you know, what we're seeing today is just ensuring good governance in how we're approaching this, especially as this continues to be an emerging problem and we want to protect Portlanders ahead of time.

995
01:55:58.739 --> 01:56:01.436
<v Candace Avalos>So again, grateful to my colleagues for this.

996
01:56:02.287 --> 01:56:14.807
<v Candace Avalos>I think that our— there are obviously some larger policy questions that are emerging from this, and I believe this is an important first step, um, to talk about, um, what that looks like in broader land use, um, situations.

997
01:56:14.872 --> 01:56:22.444
<v Candace Avalos>But this one is very particular and necessary to be called out, um, and so I'm glad that we're, um, being intentional about data centers in this resolution.

998
01:56:22.493 --> 01:56:24.787
<v Candace Avalos>So those are my questions for now.

999
01:56:25.060 --> 01:56:25.363
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1000
01:56:26.182 --> 01:56:28.091
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, let's see, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1001
01:56:29.070 --> 01:56:37.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair, and apologies, I had to step out for a quick other meeting, and I will I will hopefully not repeat questions that have been asked.

1002
01:56:37.335 --> 01:56:39.966
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If I do, please just tell me and I will move on.

1003
01:56:40.545 --> 01:56:53.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It sounds, Chair, like you were asking about what a 20-megawatt facility meant as we think about the scale we heard before about enterprise size, colocation size, and hyperscale size.

1004
01:56:53.177 --> 01:56:53.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1005
01:56:54.301 --> 01:56:55.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1006
01:56:55.489 --> 01:56:58.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it— we don't know which of those that falls into?

1007
01:56:59.181 --> 01:57:02.055
<v Natalie Didion>We haven't done the crosswalk and we aren't experts on that.

1008
01:57:02.712 --> 01:57:17.333
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, councilors who brought this forward, is 20 megawatt hyperscale or does that get us into some of those smaller-sized data centers that many companies probably have onsite?

1009
01:57:17.958 --> 01:57:25.421
<v Unidentified speaker>So 20 megawatt threshold is used to determine large load customers, but not necessarily hyperscale.

1010
01:57:25.567 --> 01:57:38.087
<v Unidentified speaker>And I can share a little bit that there was a Thousand Friends of Oregon report that Claire shared with us, and we've been working with and learning from AI Now Institute, the national research advocacy organization.

1011
01:57:38.585 --> 01:57:48.171
<v Unidentified speaker>And when we started our background research process, we asked which types of facilities should we look at, focus on, and they suggested looking at energy consumption.

1012
01:57:48.765 --> 01:57:54.368
<v Unidentified speaker>And the 20-megawatt threshold was suggested for large load customers.

1013
01:57:55.027 --> 01:58:13.368
<v Unidentified speaker>And that also aligns with HB 3546's definition, large energy use facility, means a facility that uses or is able to use 20 megawatts or more and is primarily engaged in providing a service described under Code 518-210, so on.

1014
01:58:13.465 --> 01:58:26.239
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so this gets us out, at least out of that enterprise level, you have something on site, into probably the larger colocation facilities and the hyperscale facilities.

1015
01:58:26.319 --> 01:58:29.029
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that how I should be understanding what we're talking about here?

1016
01:58:29.509 --> 01:58:30.054
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Absolutely, yes.

1017
01:58:30.310 --> 01:58:30.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1018
01:58:31.256 --> 01:58:45.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And on the NDA language, we've heard in a variety of other spaces recently that there are times where NDAs may be necessary to be able to get details about a business's operation.

1019
01:58:45.694 --> 01:59:11.591
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What you're focused on here though, it looks like, are NDAs about what So am I correct to understand that this doesn't touch on those NDAs where we say, hey, in order to better understand a business's operation model so that they can share details they wouldn't share publicly, we need to sign an NDA?

1020
01:59:11.655 --> 01:59:16.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This only focuses on those NDAs where we're saying, hey, a company doesn't want the public to know about their business model.

1021
01:59:16.377 --> 01:59:16.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's correct.

1022
01:59:21.122 --> 01:59:25.903
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, this resolution is specifically about NDAs tied to public decisions.

1023
01:59:26.670 --> 01:59:33.748
<v Unidentified speaker>So siting, permitting, utility rates, fees, any use of shared resources or public engagement.

1024
01:59:33.814 --> 01:59:38.912
<v Unidentified speaker>And so it's not about like internal business model engineering.

1025
01:59:40.003 --> 01:59:43.555
<v Unidentified speaker>It's more about decisions that are about shared infrastructure, public resources.

1026
01:59:43.604 --> 01:59:45.483
<v Unidentified speaker>So if you're talking about a new hotel, Great.

1027
01:59:46.296 --> 01:59:47.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for clarifying that.

1028
01:59:47.368 --> 01:59:49.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's an important piece to have out there.

1029
01:59:49.872 --> 01:59:50.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for asking.

1030
01:59:51.836 --> 01:59:55.990
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think those were my 2 questions.

1031
01:59:56.055 --> 02:00:03.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do want to take an opportunity just while I'm here to say that I believe the amendment passed while I was out.

1032
02:00:04.051 --> 02:00:12.793
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so with the addition of that amendment, just out of an abundance of caution, I want to declare a potential conflict of interest.

1033
02:00:12.992 --> 02:00:15.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My wife works for Microsoft Corporation.

1034
02:00:15.154 --> 02:00:19.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Part of their business includes the development of data centers.

1035
02:00:19.881 --> 02:00:22.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And without the amendment, I didn't think there was any conflict.

1036
02:00:23.070 --> 02:00:35.762
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But the fact that we're saying we are looking at pursuing a moratorium on data centers, I just want to be overly cautious and make sure I don't— that I don't risk not declaring something where there could be a potential conflict of interest.

1037
02:00:35.810 --> 02:00:37.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'd like to put that on the record.

1038
02:00:37.990 --> 02:00:38.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

1039
02:00:39.104 --> 02:01:09.011
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, you know, as I look at the language we have before us and the impact of data centers on communities, um, it— we're looking in the spaces where we saw that these could be located in our community at some large commercial areas with a lot of job potential, yes, but also some industrial areas in that Central Industrial East Side where these types of uses could be located.

1040
02:01:09.189 --> 02:01:40.743
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as a city that is completely surrounded by other cities, we don't have the luxury of using our land base, especially our job-creating land base, particularly those industrial areas, for uses that don't create and so I think that the conversations we have in Portland have to take that into account.

1041
02:01:41.225 --> 02:01:57.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When we talk about data centers, when we talk about these uses, we have to be thinking about what the trade-off costs are and what else we need that land for in order to have enough high-wage jobs in our community that folks who live here can get a decent living.

1042
02:01:57.064 --> 02:01:57.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Herbold.

1043
02:02:00.449 --> 02:02:04.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I think this is an important conversation for us to be having.

1044
02:02:04.773 --> 02:02:12.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it is an important conversation for us to be having in a transparent manner, and I appreciate folks bringing this forward and allowing us to delve into this.

1045
02:02:12.898 --> 02:02:13.381
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1046
02:02:15.780 --> 02:02:16.345
<v Candace Avalos>Vice Chair Green.

1047
02:02:17.488 --> 02:02:18.037
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you.

1048
02:02:19.266 --> 02:02:36.167
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney was engaging in some questions that I have a technical and nerdy interest in and also some expertise, and so I wanted to I would just like note that in just a utility regulatory rate-making, it's pretty common to have like large load tariffs that have thresholds.

1049
02:02:36.439 --> 02:02:49.168
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think across the United States, those thresholds generally begin around 20 megawatts with some exceptions for lower if it's a specific type of use and can range up to about 150 megawatts.

1050
02:02:49.328 --> 02:02:56.707
<v Unidentified speaker>Just really depends upon the grid and what their Overall, um, rate-making problem is to be solved.

1051
02:02:56.819 --> 02:03:05.595
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, um, 20 is a natural cut point because that's the point at which you're like, okay, this is a sustained— this is basically a neighborhood-scale thing.

1052
02:03:05.787 --> 02:03:13.296
<v Unidentified speaker>Just, just to give you a sense of scale, um, the Moda Center is about a 10-megawatt load, right?

1053
02:03:13.344 --> 02:03:20.131
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's like— and I, I got thinking around that because, because the community benefits agreement is part of the You know, contemplated turn sheet, right?

1054
02:03:20.292 --> 02:03:21.448
<v Unidentified speaker>Like electrification and all that.

1055
02:03:21.512 --> 02:03:26.845
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's a lot of power, and it's sustained, um, like basically 24/7 power.

1056
02:03:26.894 --> 02:03:31.520
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's not just data centers, it's utilities contemplating these large point loads.

1057
02:03:31.953 --> 02:03:35.293
<v Unidentified speaker>And so this would place it in the category of like a major industrial operation.

1058
02:03:35.390 --> 02:03:43.469
<v Unidentified speaker>So to your point, um, it's very much not about, um, even like one floor in an office building of having some server farms.

1059
02:03:43.518 --> 02:03:44.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Like, that wouldn't even get there.

1060
02:03:44.353 --> 02:03:44.448
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1061
02:03:45.346 --> 02:04:19.967
<v Mitch Green>I do think— so downtown's in my district, and while you're right, like, we can't afford to use our space like horizontally this way for data centers, I'm also a little concerned about us pursuing a development strategy that tries to use our downtown towers for that, because that doesn't get people downtown walking and engaging in commerce and engaging in this kind of broader waterfront, you know, what's the future of downtown type So I don't know that that's going to happen in downtown, but I'm kind of wanting to cover that too.

1062
02:04:20.353 --> 02:04:22.131
<v Mitch Green>So I'm glad that you raised it.

1063
02:04:22.533 --> 02:04:25.225
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1064
02:04:25.563 --> 02:04:26.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1065
02:04:26.701 --> 02:04:31.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor, you went there, so I'll ask another question.

1066
02:04:31.990 --> 02:04:39.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I don't know if you— I don't know if you know the answer to this, but we do have We do have some server farms downtown.

1067
02:04:40.274 --> 02:04:52.291
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know if they're data centers or not, or if they're doing other processing, but we do have some buildings downtown that are either solely or predominantly devoted to data processing and storage right now.

1068
02:04:53.144 --> 02:04:59.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In terms of size of what a 20-megawatt— is that what this said?

1069
02:05:00.346 --> 02:05:01.493
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1070
02:05:04.801 --> 02:05:12.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Looks like in terms of the space that that takes up, which I assume will change over years as processing gets more efficient.

1071
02:05:12.259 --> 02:05:13.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But let's operate in the right now.

1072
02:05:14.668 --> 02:05:22.846
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What does that mean in terms of a single city block tower located downtown?

1073
02:05:25.613 --> 02:05:27.265
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know the precise answer for you.

1074
02:05:27.411 --> 02:05:29.905
<v Unidentified speaker>That's something I'd need to kind of research a little bit.

1075
02:05:30.002 --> 02:05:44.372
<v Unidentified speaker>But we did hear some testimony from one of the panelists that was arguing that right now in Kansas City, Missouri, they're contemplating basically a tower downtown.

1076
02:05:44.435 --> 02:05:52.628
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think the idea is to make efficient use of the land, because land's expensive, maybe less so in Portland right now than it used to be, downtown at least.

1077
02:05:54.149 --> 02:05:56.282
<v Unidentified speaker>You got to go kind of like pretty high up on this.

1078
02:05:56.346 --> 02:05:56.444
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

1079
02:05:56.734 --> 02:06:06.918
<v Unidentified speaker>And once you get into the The point of hyperscale, uh, your cost efficiencies would— you'd need to, you know, because all that cooling infrastructure needs to be spread out a lot around a lot of compute power.

1080
02:06:06.984 --> 02:06:14.193
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I would imagine a full-blown tower, not just like a few floors of a downtown, uh, commercial property.

1081
02:06:14.273 --> 02:06:15.943
<v Unidentified speaker>But I, but I don't know off the top of my head.

1082
02:06:16.231 --> 02:06:16.311
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1083
02:06:16.360 --> 02:06:19.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But 20 megawatts is, is a very large amount of load.

1084
02:06:19.426 --> 02:06:21.771
<v Unidentified speaker>Like, that's, that's like an Intel processing set.

1085
02:06:21.836 --> 02:06:27.247
<v Unidentified speaker>It's like one part of an Intel so it would have to be a big tower, I would imagine.

1086
02:06:28.728 --> 02:06:29.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

1087
02:06:30.832 --> 02:06:40.328
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I may try to find this out before this comes to council, just because I do think it's important to help folks understand what scale we are talking about.

1088
02:06:40.394 --> 02:06:44.403
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know we have folks in the community who oppose all data centers.

1089
02:06:44.500 --> 02:06:59.819
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know we have folks in the community who have more nuanced views about data centers, and to be able to all right, folks, we have—.

1090
02:06:59.948 --> 02:07:01.248
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, Councilor Koyama Lane, go ahead.

1091
02:07:02.920 --> 02:07:29.588
<v Unidentified speaker>I wanted to say that I appreciate this conversation and the many different questions and things that have been brought up, and also just appreciate and want to give a nod to the statewide organizing that's happening, to the folks that also came I know I got an email in my inbox just last night that a week, week from today, next Tuesday, there will be folks doing a rally and lobby day at the state capitol building about a 3-year moratorium.

1092
02:07:29.636 --> 02:07:34.614
<v Unidentified speaker>So this— there is energy around that, and folks want to know more about that.

1093
02:07:34.663 --> 02:07:42.902
<v Unidentified speaker>I got that email from 350 PDX, and our own governor has said, quote, local governments are doing the right thing in calling for a pause until we can get this right.

1094
02:07:42.949 --> 02:07:43.127
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1095
02:07:43.287 --> 02:07:50.481
<v Unidentified speaker>So I appreciate community pushing for just that and encouraging a pause and to make sure we're really thinking this through.

1096
02:07:51.347 --> 02:07:59.328
<v Unidentified speaker>And I want to be clear that this resolution is really setting an expectation, a policy expectation that we can have on record.

1097
02:07:59.760 --> 02:08:06.314
<v Unidentified speaker>So city leadership and the public are very clear about what council's expectations and intent is.

1098
02:08:06.747 --> 02:08:09.759
<v Unidentified speaker>And I just really think that public commitments are important.

1099
02:08:10.257 --> 02:08:11.452
<v Unidentified speaker>They create accountability.

1100
02:08:11.628 --> 02:08:16.439
<v Unidentified speaker>People can point back to them, and they also signal what kind of a city we are.

1101
02:08:16.712 --> 02:08:23.322
<v Unidentified speaker>And my hope is that Portland is a city that really values transparency and being open with the community.

1102
02:08:23.677 --> 02:08:26.765
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you for considering a yes vote.

1103
02:08:26.814 --> 02:08:28.448
<v Unidentified speaker>I hope you all will support.

1104
02:08:32.747 --> 02:08:33.038
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

1105
02:08:33.168 --> 02:08:35.850
<v Candace Avalos>So we don't have any other folks in the queue.

1106
02:08:37.505 --> 02:08:47.395
<v Candace Avalos>Therefore, I would like to entertain a motion to move resolution as amended, document number 2026-299, to the full council with a recommendation it be adopted.

1107
02:08:50.210 --> 02:08:51.134
<v Candace Avalos>Someone has to move it and second.

1108
02:08:51.182 --> 02:08:51.636
<v Mitch Green>So moved.

1109
02:08:52.333 --> 02:08:53.210
<v Candace Avalos>Moved by Councilor Green.

1110
02:08:53.890 --> 02:08:54.506
<v Candace Avalos>Do I have a second?

1111
02:08:54.880 --> 02:08:55.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

1112
02:08:55.658 --> 02:08:57.588
<v Candace Avalos>Seconded by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1113
02:08:58.739 --> 02:09:00.698
<v Candace Avalos>All right, with that, uh, please call the roll.

1114
02:09:04.210 --> 02:09:04.225
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1115
02:09:04.756 --> 02:09:05.046
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

1116
02:09:05.949 --> 02:09:05.997
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1117
02:09:06.851 --> 02:09:07.302
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney.

1118
02:09:07.640 --> 02:09:07.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1119
02:09:08.704 --> 02:09:09.074
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos.

1120
02:09:09.413 --> 02:09:09.430
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1121
02:09:11.588 --> 02:09:25.108
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, motion to refer the resolution as amended, document number 2026-299, to the City Council with the recommendation it be adopted is approved with 4 aye and 1 absent.

1122
02:09:25.911 --> 02:09:26.923
<v Candace Avalos>Great, thank you, Wendy.

1123
02:09:27.984 --> 02:09:28.626
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, thank you, committee.

1124
02:09:28.867 --> 02:09:35.180
<v Candace Avalos>We are about to wrap up but wanted to do a quick I just wanted to circle back on what we were discussing around UHS earlier.

1125
02:09:35.326 --> 02:09:41.634
<v Candace Avalos>So just wanted to— I messaged with some folks at Housing Bureau per the conversation we had on planning.

1126
02:09:42.131 --> 02:09:47.797
<v Candace Avalos>I was informed that, uh, PHB did reach out to all the council offices but did not hear back.

1127
02:09:48.070 --> 02:09:49.739
<v Candace Avalos>And so she's going to reach out again.

1128
02:09:50.398 --> 02:09:58.408
<v Candace Avalos>And if, um, especially the committee member council offices, if you can respond, uh, she's got specific questions for, you know, the planning.

1129
02:09:58.520 --> 02:10:02.204
<v Candace Avalos>But just know that you will get another ping, um, so that we can get that moving.

1130
02:10:03.353 --> 02:10:09.746
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, otherwise, we've got our next meeting on the 15th, and, uh, stay tuned for updates on that meeting's agenda.

1131
02:10:10.168 --> 02:10:13.712
<v Candace Avalos>And I will adjourn today's meeting of Housing and Permitting at 4:05 PM.

1132
02:10:17.322 --> 02:10:18.173
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

