WEBVTT

1
00:04:08.545 --> 00:04:08.792
<v Loretta Smith>Mr.

2
00:04:08.856 --> 00:04:10.479
<v Loretta Smith>Chair, this is Councilor Smith.

3
00:04:12.134 --> 00:04:12.774
<v Loretta Smith>I am online.

4
00:04:13.187 --> 00:04:14.323
<v Steve Novick>Good morning, Councilor.

5
00:04:14.745 --> 00:04:19.545
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

6
00:04:34.281 --> 00:04:39.865
<v Steve Novick>And let's see, um, I think I see Councilor Kanal.

7
00:04:43.538 --> 00:04:45.464
<v Steve Novick>What about— what about Councilor Zimmerman?

8
00:05:19.201 --> 00:05:21.028
<v Unidentified speaker>Just one.

9
00:05:21.478 --> 00:05:25.519
<v Steve Novick>All right, um, hopefully Councilor Zimmerman will show up.

10
00:05:26.370 --> 00:05:31.533
<v Steve Novick>Um, good morning, it is Tuesday, September 1st.

11
00:05:31.661 --> 00:05:35.290
<v Steve Novick>I call this meeting of the Committee and Public Safety Committee to order.

12
00:05:37.670 --> 00:05:38.574
<v Steve Novick>Whoops.

13
00:05:38.687 --> 00:05:41.985
<v Steve Novick>Oh, I forgot that my dog barks when I hear— when it hears a sound like a door knocking.

14
00:05:42.615 --> 00:05:43.584
<v Steve Novick>Uh, Barley, hush.

15
00:05:43.843 --> 00:05:44.247
<v Steve Novick>It's okay.

16
00:05:45.766 --> 00:05:50.620
<v Steve Novick>Um, um, so I apologize for being virtual today.

17
00:05:51.103 --> 00:05:53.199
<v Steve Novick>I got COVID, so you wouldn't want me there.

18
00:05:54.408 --> 00:06:01.492
<v Steve Novick>Um, this meeting of the Committee and Public Safety Committee will take on 2 subjects: updates Portland Fire Code and Fee Schedule.

19
00:06:02.247 --> 00:06:11.608
<v Steve Novick>And pursuant to a request from Councilor Murillo, we're going to have a discussion of Portland Police response times with a presentation from PPB and one from Portland Parole.

20
00:06:12.362 --> 00:06:17.709
<v Steve Novick>We had intended to have a 3rd item, which was report on cost of police staffing from Councilor Smith's resolution earlier in this year.

21
00:06:18.319 --> 00:06:22.670
<v Steve Novick>At the request of Councilor Smith, we'll look to a future meeting for that discussion.

22
00:06:22.975 --> 00:06:23.987
<v Steve Novick>Clerk, could you please call the roll?

23
00:06:24.100 --> 00:06:25.735
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Good morning.

24
00:06:26.170 --> 00:06:26.509
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

25
00:06:27.218 --> 00:06:27.490
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

26
00:06:28.166 --> 00:06:28.553
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

27
00:06:29.536 --> 00:06:29.841
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

28
00:06:34.526 --> 00:06:34.656
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

29
00:06:36.077 --> 00:06:36.401
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

30
00:06:36.545 --> 00:06:36.819
<v Lauren Johnson>Kanal?

31
00:06:37.192 --> 00:06:37.255
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

32
00:06:38.031 --> 00:06:38.355
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

33
00:06:39.048 --> 00:06:39.500
<v Steve Novick>Here.

34
00:06:41.891 --> 00:06:43.894
<v Steve Novick>Kevin, could you please read the statement of conduct?

35
00:06:45.350 --> 00:06:48.038
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome to the meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee.

36
00:06:48.458 --> 00:06:54.449
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council.

37
00:06:56.449 --> 00:07:04.230
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

38
00:07:04.230 --> 00:07:07.970
<v Unidentified speaker>Public testimony is available online at portland.gov/council/agenda/community-and-public-safety-committee or by calling 311.

39
00:07:07.970 --> 00:07:11.230
<v Unidentified speaker>Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

40
00:07:11.689 --> 00:07:15.250
<v Unidentified speaker>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

41
00:07:15.250 --> 00:07:18.649
<v Unidentified speaker>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

42
00:07:18.910 --> 00:07:25.850
<v Unidentified speaker>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

43
00:07:26.055 --> 00:07:28.333
<v Unidentified speaker>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

44
00:07:28.798 --> 00:07:29.887
<v Unidentified speaker>The chair preserves order.

45
00:07:30.144 --> 00:07:38.867
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

46
00:07:39.620 --> 00:07:41.689
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

47
00:07:42.009 --> 00:07:44.800
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

48
00:07:45.473 --> 00:07:48.920
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

49
00:07:49.418 --> 00:07:53.346
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

50
00:07:53.540 --> 00:07:56.199
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

51
00:07:56.199 --> 00:07:58.829
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, one, state your name for the record.

52
00:07:59.240 --> 00:08:02.279
<v Unidentified speaker>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

53
00:08:02.279 --> 00:08:06.319
<v Unidentified speaker>And 2, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

54
00:08:06.319 --> 00:08:08.500
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

55
00:08:08.500 --> 00:08:10.420
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

56
00:08:10.420 --> 00:08:12.879
<v Steve Novick>Could the clerk read the first item?

57
00:08:12.879 --> 00:08:15.899
<v Steve Novick>And actually, I think that fire plans to sort of address both together.

58
00:08:15.899 --> 00:08:17.839
<v Steve Novick>So could you read the first and second items?

59
00:08:18.660 --> 00:08:19.980
<v Unidentified speaker>Happy to.

60
00:08:19.980 --> 00:08:32.802
<v Unidentified speaker>Item number 1, document number 2026-300, amend fire department fire regulations fee schedule, amend Portland policy document FIR-12.01.

61
00:08:33.870 --> 00:08:47.620
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, item number 2, document number 2026-301, amend fire regulations code to adopt current Oregon Fire Code with city amendments, amend Code Title 31.

62
00:08:49.600 --> 00:08:50.086
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

63
00:08:53.885 --> 00:08:57.412
<v Steve Novick>Chief Johnson, Marshal Schimmel, take it away.

64
00:08:58.596 --> 00:08:59.110
<v Lauren Johnson>Hey, good morning.

65
00:08:59.173 --> 00:08:59.591
<v Lauren Johnson>Thank you.

66
00:09:00.360 --> 00:09:05.760
<v Lauren Johnson>For the record, I'm Lauren Johnson and I'm the fire chief, and Kerry Schimmel, our fire marshal, is joining me.

67
00:09:06.625 --> 00:09:16.208
<v Lauren Johnson>We're here today to explain the proposed changes to Title 31, which involves updating our city code to the current state code and updating certain city amendments.

68
00:09:16.625 --> 00:09:17.410
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

69
00:09:18.259 --> 00:09:21.336
<v Lauren Johnson>I'll start by sharing some background on fire codes.

70
00:09:21.994 --> 00:09:23.900
<v Lauren Johnson>Oregon has statewide fire codes.

71
00:09:24.253 --> 00:09:31.191
<v Lauren Johnson>This means that the Oregon Fire Code is the state's official set of standards for fire prevention, protection, and emergency preparedness.

72
00:09:32.024 --> 00:09:36.799
<v Lauren Johnson>The statewide code must be adopted by all local jurisdictions as a minimum standard.

73
00:09:37.552 --> 00:09:43.160
<v Lauren Johnson>Local jurisdictions can then make their own code more stringent, but not less, than the state's fire code.

74
00:09:44.205 --> 00:09:53.806
<v Lauren Johnson>The City of Portland is designated as an exempt jurisdiction, which means that Portland Fire and Rescue is responsible for administering and enforcing the fire code within our city boundaries.

75
00:09:54.705 --> 00:10:04.291
<v Lauren Johnson>The state adopts a new code about every 3 years, and as it is currently written, our city code lists the adopted state fire code by noting the year.

76
00:10:05.061 --> 00:10:11.948
<v Lauren Johnson>For example, the state made a change in 2022 and the city adopted it, and it was called the 2023 Portland Fire Code.

77
00:10:12.606 --> 00:10:19.659
<v Lauren Johnson>That meant that the 2023 Portland Fire Code made many references to the 2022 Oregon Code.

78
00:10:20.476 --> 00:10:28.989
<v Lauren Johnson>And it means that now that we're ready to adopt the 2025 Oregon Fire Code, we need to bring you an ordinance each time the state updates their code.

79
00:10:29.774 --> 00:10:30.624
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

80
00:10:31.875 --> 00:10:34.727
<v Lauren Johnson>So that brings us to our proposed amendments.

81
00:10:35.065 --> 00:10:41.091
<v Lauren Johnson>One thing you'll notice is that today's proposed amendments remove references to the specific years of the adopted code.

82
00:10:41.797 --> 00:10:50.417
<v Lauren Johnson>They add references to the Oregon State Statute Statutes and administrative rules that define which code editions we need to use, and it specifies effective dates.

83
00:10:51.143 --> 00:11:01.264
<v Lauren Johnson>This will eliminate the need for staff to bring ordinances to council with each update of the state fire code, so that this amendment will streamline and simplify our compliance process.

84
00:11:01.929 --> 00:11:02.655
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

85
00:11:04.381 --> 00:11:11.496
<v Lauren Johnson>Here are the specifics on the other proposed amendments, all of which are designed to remove outdated code references or obsolete language.

86
00:11:12.594 --> 00:11:16.381
<v Lauren Johnson>We need to update the administrative rule you see there to the correct OAR.

87
00:11:16.927 --> 00:11:25.370
<v Lauren Johnson>This corrects a citation error and preserves Portland's ability to allow approved alternative fire protection methods for one and two-family dwellings.

88
00:11:26.575 --> 00:11:35.836
<v Lauren Johnson>Some of the National Fire Protection Association codes have been changed and/or consolidated, so we needed to correct our reference from Chapter 45 to Chapter 80.

89
00:11:36.573 --> 00:11:39.849
<v Lauren Johnson>The subject here hasn't changed, but the code reference number has.

90
00:11:41.158 --> 00:11:44.761
<v Lauren Johnson>Next, we want to delete the inspection record card requirement.

91
00:11:44.956 --> 00:11:49.208
<v Lauren Johnson>This is an old practice that's no longer in place, and we have a new system that we use now.

92
00:11:51.350 --> 00:11:57.929
<v Lauren Johnson>We also recommend deleting the lease agreement language for billing the building owner because we deal directly with the property owner.

93
00:11:58.335 --> 00:12:05.788
<v Lauren Johnson>This simplifies billing responsibility and removes our need to track private lease agreements that the city does not administer or enforce.

94
00:12:07.163 --> 00:12:16.234
<v Lauren Johnson>Next, we need to update or remove outdated reference to the Administrative Review Board and replace it with current information on appeals.

95
00:12:17.221 --> 00:12:23.193
<v Lauren Johnson>And finally, we need to remove the section referring to the retail sales of fireworks because it's no longer allowed.

96
00:12:24.049 --> 00:12:30.610
<v Lauren Johnson>Bans on fireworks sales are noted in a separate ordinance, and that makes this language unnecessary and potentially confusing.

97
00:12:31.274 --> 00:12:32.067
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

98
00:12:33.278 --> 00:12:42.749
<v Lauren Johnson>So that covers the proposed amendments for Title 31, and I want to pause and give time for questions and discussion before moving to the proposed fee changes.

99
00:12:47.159 --> 00:12:48.456
<v Lauren Johnson>Okay, all good.

100
00:12:49.038 --> 00:12:49.751
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

101
00:12:50.984 --> 00:12:57.806
<v Lauren Johnson>So this next section covers our amendments to the fire fee schedule, which was proposed as part of this fiscal year's budget process.

102
00:12:58.432 --> 00:13:05.373
<v Lauren Johnson>I'd like to invite Angela Wright from the Financial Office of the Public Safety Service Area to join me for this part of our presentation.

103
00:13:06.350 --> 00:13:10.823
<v Lauren Johnson>Angela did the majority of the research and calculations associated with the fee changes.

104
00:13:12.313 --> 00:13:18.518
<v Lauren Johnson>So it's important to note that the majority of our fire fees have not been comprehensively updated since before 2012.

105
00:13:19.254 --> 00:13:21.532
<v Lauren Johnson>Only a few fees have been changed since that time.

106
00:13:22.621 --> 00:13:32.335
<v Lauren Johnson>These fee changes were developed after an evaluation of actual service delivery, a comparison to peer jurisdictions, and with consideration next slide, please.

107
00:13:33.922 --> 00:13:37.418
<v Lauren Johnson>So on this slide, you'll see the services that the fire fees pay for.

108
00:13:38.018 --> 00:13:54.626
<v Lauren Johnson>They include permit reviews and application processing, fire and life safety inspections, responding to customer inquiries, fire protection systems oversight, the regulation of hazardous materials, enforcement of the fire code, and community risk reduction outreach and activities.

109
00:13:54.706 --> 00:13:55.173
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilmember Herbold.

110
00:13:56.023 --> 00:14:03.878
<v Lauren Johnson>When Council approved this year's budget in June, it included fire fee increases as an offset to additional reductions to the Fire Bureau's budget.

111
00:14:04.759 --> 00:14:14.393
<v Lauren Johnson>The amendments only revise fees associated with existing services and do not change existing fire code requirements or create new regulatory obligations.

112
00:14:15.484 --> 00:14:28.658
<v Lauren Johnson>The customers that these fees impact include property owners, business owners, contractors, builders, and developers, and other members of the public who apply for special permits or are responsible for complying with the city's fire code.

113
00:14:29.923 --> 00:14:35.500
<v Lauren Johnson>And when we briefed council staff on this item, we received questions about community outreach regarding the fee increases.

114
00:14:35.933 --> 00:14:43.033
<v Lauren Johnson>I want to note that this was done as part of the budget town hall series, and to my knowledge, we did not receive any comments or questions.

115
00:14:44.331 --> 00:14:45.196
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

116
00:14:47.456 --> 00:14:54.905
<v Lauren Johnson>So on this slide, we're showing you the year-over-year difference between our revenues from fire fees and our personnel expenses since 2020.

117
00:14:55.740 --> 00:15:06.948
<v Lauren Johnson>You've seen the primary drivers of the city's personnel costs in other presentations, and they include changes in salary, pension, and benefits obligations, along with materials and services inflation.

118
00:15:07.927 --> 00:15:11.878
<v Lauren Johnson>Since 2020, our personnel expenses have increased by 43%.

119
00:15:13.162 --> 00:15:19.980
<v Lauren Johnson>And you will surely notice the stair-step increase since 2023, which marked the beginning of the current firefighter labor agreement.

120
00:15:20.767 --> 00:15:24.730
<v Lauren Johnson>This CBA included annual raises, and those increases are visible here.

121
00:15:25.755 --> 00:15:32.302
<v Lauren Johnson>Across these years, revenue from fire fees has covered less and less of the personnel costs associated with the Fire Marshal's Office.

122
00:15:33.376 --> 00:15:42.297
<v Lauren Johnson>It's important to note that there are a number of different fire department models that have varying amounts of cost recovery for fire inspection and fire code enforcement activities.

123
00:15:42.745 --> 00:15:44.734
<v Lauren Johnson>So it makes precise comparisons hard.

124
00:15:45.951 --> 00:15:52.043
<v Lauren Johnson>Even within our own office, some inspectors are at 100% cost recovery because of the kind of work that they do.

125
00:15:52.701 --> 00:15:59.208
<v Lauren Johnson>And then there are other inspectors that have assignments that involve a smaller amount of cost recovery or no cost recovery at all.

126
00:15:59.833 --> 00:16:05.974
<v Lauren Johnson>An example of that, of the no cost recovery positions, are our fire and arson investigators.

127
00:16:07.432 --> 00:16:14.197
<v Lauren Johnson>So during recent years, fees accounted for up to 57% of personnel costs on average for the fire marshal's staff.

128
00:16:15.285 --> 00:16:17.658
<v Lauren Johnson>This is what it was in FY21.

129
00:16:18.350 --> 00:16:22.142
<v Lauren Johnson>However, in FY26, these fees only cover 42%.

130
00:16:23.528 --> 00:16:29.837
<v Lauren Johnson>So in order to return to the 57% cost recovery, we would need to increase our fees by 36%.

131
00:16:31.240 --> 00:16:36.556
<v Lauren Johnson>However, our proposals represent an increase of less than that, 27%.

132
00:16:37.057 --> 00:16:42.902
<v Lauren Johnson>This increase is the right amount to help cover more of our costs by providing these for providing these services.

133
00:16:43.340 --> 00:16:46.147
<v Lauren Johnson>It aligns us more closely to comparable jurisdictions.

134
00:16:47.115 --> 00:16:56.908
<v Lauren Johnson>It addresses the inflationary increase to our costs that have taken place since our last major fee adjustment, and it supports the long-term financial stability of our inspection program.

135
00:16:57.765 --> 00:16:58.491
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

136
00:17:00.659 --> 00:17:04.228
<v Lauren Johnson>So as I mentioned, part of our process included a comparison to peer cities.

137
00:17:04.811 --> 00:17:07.876
<v Lauren Johnson>On this slide, you can see a list of cities and their corresponding fees.

138
00:17:08.726 --> 00:17:12.913
<v Lauren Johnson>Which are shown with a cost of living adjustment to make the comparison easier to understand.

139
00:17:14.240 --> 00:17:23.989
<v Lauren Johnson>On average, our current fees are $146 below these cities, and with our proposed increases, we would still be on average $53 below.

140
00:17:25.799 --> 00:17:26.711
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

141
00:17:28.420 --> 00:17:33.635
<v Lauren Johnson>And finally, we've heard from some councilors' offices specifically about public assembly occupancy.

142
00:17:34.076 --> 00:17:37.191
<v Lauren Johnson>And we wanted to provide more detail about these fees specifically.

143
00:17:38.089 --> 00:17:41.285
<v Lauren Johnson>In Portland, public assembly fees are based on square footage.

144
00:17:41.733 --> 00:17:47.096
<v Lauren Johnson>Some comparison cities have different methods for pricing that include flat fees or hourly rates.

145
00:17:47.900 --> 00:17:53.165
<v Lauren Johnson>You can see some examples on this slide of how Portland prices compare to others on like items.

146
00:17:53.983 --> 00:17:59.796
<v Lauren Johnson>This chart does have a cost of living adjustment added so that the comparison will be meaningful and easier to understand.

147
00:17:59.844 --> 00:18:00.020
<v Lauren Johnson>Thank you.

148
00:18:02.570 --> 00:18:03.436
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

149
00:18:04.751 --> 00:18:12.079
<v Lauren Johnson>As I mentioned, Portland fees are based on square footage, and this chart shows you the proposed changes specifically for public assembly costs.

150
00:18:12.769 --> 00:18:16.826
<v Lauren Johnson>And I want to note that we offer fee waivers to nonprofit organizations.

151
00:18:18.142 --> 00:18:18.991
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide, please.

152
00:18:20.403 --> 00:18:36.877
<v Lauren Johnson>So this is the last slide we have for you, and I want to emphasize that we plan to evaluate our cost structures more regularly and to continue to do so in a way that supports life safety for all of Portland, and also improves our ability to process applications and provide timely responses to our customers.

153
00:18:37.874 --> 00:18:44.022
<v Lauren Johnson>The actual revenue generated will vary depending on development activity, permit volume, and inspection demands.

154
00:18:44.778 --> 00:18:52.821
<v Lauren Johnson>And many of the fees you see in the schedule are not applied every year, and several others come into play only after repeated warnings and violations.

155
00:18:53.913 --> 00:18:59.759
<v Lauren Johnson>The fee increases are tied to real changes in our cost, which stem primarily from increases in personnel costs.

156
00:18:59.807 --> 00:18:59.934
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

157
00:19:00.115 --> 00:19:02.717
<v Lauren Johnson>And also from materials and services increases.

158
00:19:04.180 --> 00:19:15.588
<v Lauren Johnson>Finally, we expect these fee changes to have minimal impact on overall project costs because fire prevention fees generally represent a very small amount of total development costs.

159
00:19:16.298 --> 00:19:18.634
<v Lauren Johnson>We're happy to take your questions and comments at this point.

160
00:19:19.919 --> 00:19:20.516
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Chief.

161
00:19:20.662 --> 00:19:21.275
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

162
00:19:23.326 --> 00:19:24.117
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Chief.

163
00:19:24.359 --> 00:19:25.878
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, thank you for bringing this forward.

164
00:19:27.883 --> 00:19:44.105
<v Loretta Smith>Going back to what you said, you said if we make these changes that it will allow us to serve our public faster, and that would basically mean that we would be able to hire new people.

165
00:19:44.234 --> 00:19:52.352
<v Loretta Smith>And then you back it up and say, no, this is going to be for the increases in employee FTE costs.

166
00:19:52.513 --> 00:20:00.392
<v Loretta Smith>So are we are we going to hire more folks, or are we just going to maintain the, the people that we have with the new increases?

167
00:20:01.226 --> 00:20:02.590
<v Lauren Johnson>Thanks for that question, Councilor.

168
00:20:02.671 --> 00:20:04.451
<v Lauren Johnson>I'm sorry, I didn't mean to be confusing.

169
00:20:04.676 --> 00:20:08.416
<v Lauren Johnson>These fees are not intended to let us add employees.

170
00:20:09.556 --> 00:20:17.067
<v Lauren Johnson>It's, it's really meant to improve the percentage of cost recovery that's happening for inspectors that are in the Fire Marshal's Office.

171
00:20:17.741 --> 00:20:24.280
<v Lauren Johnson>And it's important to note that as development, as permit demands, like shrink and increase throughout a year.

172
00:20:24.570 --> 00:20:38.063
<v Lauren Johnson>The Fire Marshal's Office makes adjustments based on that need so that sometimes we have more people working on that work when there's more demand, and then we assign them to other duties when the demand isn't as high.

173
00:20:39.560 --> 00:20:45.144
<v Loretta Smith>So have we increased the amount of development that's happening in the City of Portland in this past year?

174
00:20:46.752 --> 00:20:48.395
<v Lauren Johnson>What do you— do you have a feeling for that?

175
00:20:50.278 --> 00:20:54.659
<v Lauren Johnson>Councilor, I don't know that we've got a good answer for that right now.

176
00:20:54.950 --> 00:20:56.905
<v Lauren Johnson>I would like to check with Permitting and Development.

177
00:20:58.292 --> 00:20:58.550
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

178
00:20:58.923 --> 00:20:59.973
<v Lauren Johnson>And get back to you.

179
00:21:01.040 --> 00:21:07.638
<v Loretta Smith>Because, so that I'm clear, so a lot of these, and I apologize for not being there in person, I will be there shortly.

180
00:21:09.929 --> 00:21:20.462
<v Loretta Smith>So are these fees, Based on the new development that's happening and existing buildings that you have to go out and check?

181
00:21:21.852 --> 00:21:33.107
<v Lauren Johnson>Yes, it's to address existing demand and things that we do every year in terms of fire inspections, systems maintenance, assembly and occupancy permits.

182
00:21:34.240 --> 00:21:35.486
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay.

183
00:21:37.688 --> 00:21:39.855
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for, um, thank you for bringing this forward.

184
00:21:40.699 --> 00:21:41.167
<v Lauren Johnson>Yes, ma'am.

185
00:21:41.265 --> 00:21:41.750
<v Lauren Johnson>Thank you.

186
00:21:44.353 --> 00:21:44.951
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal.

187
00:21:46.778 --> 00:21:47.376
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair Novick.

188
00:21:47.425 --> 00:21:49.575
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks everybody for being here and for the presentation.

189
00:21:50.154 --> 00:21:52.075
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, generally supportive of the fee increases.

190
00:21:52.348 --> 00:21:56.672
<v Unidentified speaker>I've been talking, uh, since the mayor's first meeting on budget last year in February.

191
00:21:56.785 --> 00:22:00.296
<v Unidentified speaker>We've been talking about this, and I'm excited to see that, uh, develop here.

192
00:22:00.816 --> 00:22:09.468
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I'm not particularly concerned about having a code update ordinance every 3 years, but given that we're obligated to have It has to reflect the state law anyway.

193
00:22:09.579 --> 00:22:25.102
<v Unidentified speaker>It doesn't concern me particularly, and I just wanted to note that for the record because I don't think this is actually taking something outside of public view that is a city decision so much as it's just making administrative an administrative function, which is reflecting state law.

194
00:22:25.936 --> 00:22:32.053
<v Unidentified speaker>On the subject of the code, I was— this was in the reverse order, so I was finding my notes.

195
00:22:32.534 --> 00:22:34.749
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll have one question on that, and then most is on the fees.

196
00:22:36.126 --> 00:22:40.037
<v Unidentified speaker>The building owner text, it's in 3150.50.

197
00:22:41.414 --> 00:22:52.855
<v Unidentified speaker>It removes the phrase, the building owner will be billed in situations where the document shows the fire marshal a lease agreement or some other legal arrangement with the building owner that places the responsibility for fire inspection and the payment of fees on the building owner.

198
00:22:53.929 --> 00:22:55.818
<v Unidentified speaker>Correct me if I'm wrong, I want to make sure I understand correctly.

199
00:22:55.931 --> 00:22:58.895
<v Unidentified speaker>You're saying it's always on the building owner now, or it's never?

200
00:22:59.215 --> 00:23:02.916
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you— I'm not sure what the change is given what the description was.

201
00:23:03.205 --> 00:23:21.553
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so the, um, most of our structure is for the tenants in a building, but for example, the fire systems, the alarms, the sprinklers, which is throughout the whole building, which we consider like the core of the building, that's where we usually deal with the building owners because it's throughout the whole building and not on a specific tenant.

202
00:23:21.665 --> 00:23:29.388
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're taking out that language to make it clear that it's both parties' responsibility, but right now we're just having a tough time because of that language.

203
00:23:30.542 --> 00:23:33.586
<v Unidentified speaker>Being able to, you know, be in compliance.

204
00:23:34.051 --> 00:23:40.814
<v Unidentified speaker>So, so that language is allowing people to try to effectively— the tenant and the owner— to point fingers at each other, or?

205
00:23:41.021 --> 00:23:41.886
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, potentially.

206
00:23:41.983 --> 00:23:44.419
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't— we actually don't have a problem.

207
00:23:44.482 --> 00:23:50.941
<v Unidentified speaker>We have this language that is not really looked at, or it's been brought up by tenants or owners, so we're just trying to make it more current.

208
00:23:52.013 --> 00:23:53.648
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, appreciate that.

209
00:23:54.000 --> 00:24:04.259
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, on the fee side, I'm supportive of it, but I have questions because I'm not sure if it's enough, uh, is, is my ultimate, uh, like underlying question here.

210
00:24:04.340 --> 00:24:10.076
<v Unidentified speaker>So, um, my first question is, you mentioned it's, it's 42% of cost recovery now.

211
00:24:10.612 --> 00:24:11.568
<v Unidentified speaker>It was at 57%.

212
00:24:12.153 --> 00:24:18.567
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the increases you're push— putting forward would bring it up to about 53%, roughly.

213
00:24:21.601 --> 00:24:22.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, one second.

214
00:24:25.540 --> 00:24:28.692
<v Unidentified speaker>I can get, uh, it, uh, I can get that.

215
00:24:28.758 --> 00:24:29.080
<v Unidentified speaker>One second.

216
00:24:29.178 --> 00:24:30.923
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, it's, it's somewhere in between.

217
00:24:31.182 --> 00:24:34.238
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, what is the target?

218
00:24:34.286 --> 00:24:47.493
<v Unidentified speaker>So you mentioned it's not 100 because fire investigators, that's generally not a good— it makes sense to not have that be— yeah, but what is the, what is the portion of the work that could have fees, um, recover the cost for them?

219
00:24:49.528 --> 00:24:50.636
<v Unidentified speaker>The maximum.

220
00:24:51.215 --> 00:24:57.785
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so historically we have always had the target of 55% cost recovery.

221
00:24:58.443 --> 00:25:03.439
<v Unidentified speaker>And of course, this is going back 20 years or beyond that.

222
00:25:03.519 --> 00:25:09.237
<v Unidentified speaker>But my understanding, it's more because our office is also— we're dual certified, so to speak.

223
00:25:09.286 --> 00:25:10.955
<v Unidentified speaker>So they're inspectors and firefighters.

224
00:25:11.229 --> 00:25:16.914
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're not really looking at getting the cost recovery for the firefighter aspect of it, just the inspector.

225
00:25:17.431 --> 00:25:20.094
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's just historically, it's been 55%.

226
00:25:21.192 --> 00:25:37.933
<v Unidentified speaker>So would 55% then be roughly— would it be accurate to say that's the portion of your time that is not doing firefighting and not doing investigations, but is doing, for lack of a better phrase, marshal stuff?

227
00:25:38.563 --> 00:25:42.048
<v Lauren Johnson>On average across the office, the fire marshal's office.

228
00:25:42.273 --> 00:25:42.338
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

229
00:25:42.832 --> 00:25:43.526
<v Unidentified speaker>That makes sense.

230
00:25:43.623 --> 00:25:44.057
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

231
00:25:45.895 --> 00:25:49.170
<v Unidentified speaker>Is there anything in here, I didn't see it, about alarm fees?

232
00:25:50.833 --> 00:26:00.921
<v Unidentified speaker>I know that one of the challenges that is often faced, and I think that's more on the firefighting side, and that's probably why it's not in here, but I wanted to ask about cost recovery on that piece.

233
00:26:01.195 --> 00:26:03.219
<v Unidentified speaker>Are you referring to false alarms?

234
00:26:03.526 --> 00:26:03.962
<v Sameer Kanal>False alarms.

235
00:26:04.011 --> 00:26:05.565
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, we do have that in our fee schedule.

236
00:26:06.018 --> 00:26:06.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

237
00:26:06.843 --> 00:26:09.221
<v Unidentified speaker>Is it just not in the exhibit then, or?

238
00:26:09.983 --> 00:26:10.821
<v Unidentified speaker>It's in the exhibit.

239
00:26:11.257 --> 00:26:11.513
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

240
00:26:11.932 --> 00:26:13.704
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, I'll go back and look.

241
00:26:13.834 --> 00:26:29.565
<v Unidentified speaker>I, um, I think I might— okay, uh, I, I wanted to ask about this because it's not who actually is going and doing it and responding to the false call or the false alarm.

242
00:26:29.724 --> 00:26:30.497
<v Unidentified speaker>That, that's normally—.

243
00:26:31.333 --> 00:26:42.627
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that your office or is that just whoever's on duty and sort of yeah, so usually who's going to those calls is our EOPS personnel, but the follow-up, they refer it back to the prevention office to do the follow-up.

244
00:26:42.692 --> 00:26:51.462
<v Unidentified speaker>So the inspectors actually go out and so-called, um, like investigate the alarm itself to determine if it was false or did what it was supposed to do.

245
00:26:51.929 --> 00:26:52.298
<v Unidentified speaker>Got it.

246
00:26:52.571 --> 00:26:55.398
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, uh, okay, 2 more questions.

247
00:26:55.527 --> 00:26:59.366
<v Unidentified speaker>One, what is the proposed cadence then of looking at these?

248
00:26:59.784 --> 00:27:09.880
<v Lauren Johnson>Is it going to be annual through the budget fee schedules, or So we've received, like, direction from the mayor's office to make sure that annually we are just keeping tabs.

249
00:27:09.991 --> 00:27:19.988
<v Lauren Johnson>But then there is city direction that provides kind of an every 3-year cadence and/or requests requires an every 3-year cadence.

250
00:27:20.101 --> 00:27:31.058
<v Lauren Johnson>So we definitely felt like 5 years was too long and planned to have this annual review and then stick to the every 3 years that's required as part of the City Budget Office.

251
00:27:31.733 --> 00:27:41.564
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, and then my last question is, why are these both emergency ordinances, um, if these are things that are regularly planned?

252
00:27:41.612 --> 00:27:47.315
<v Unidentified speaker>The, the code was adopted in 2020— or sorry, the, the— yeah, the code was adopted in 2025 of the state, right?

253
00:27:48.198 --> 00:27:49.853
<v Unidentified speaker>So we saw this coming.

254
00:27:49.964 --> 00:27:51.040
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not 100% sure how.

255
00:27:51.153 --> 00:27:53.788
<v Lauren Johnson>No, so I would say we certainly saw this coming.

256
00:27:53.884 --> 00:28:01.460
<v Lauren Johnson>I think this was more of a growing pains process with service areas communicating to council to get on your calendar.

257
00:28:02.502 --> 00:28:08.038
<v Lauren Johnson>It was a process thing on our end, kind of on city's end.

258
00:28:08.502 --> 00:28:10.203
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

259
00:28:10.828 --> 00:28:21.787
<v Unidentified speaker>I think we're— I know we're working on that, and I don't know how much has gotten sent to the bureau level yet in terms of timelines and filing for things.

260
00:28:23.006 --> 00:28:32.510
<v Unidentified speaker>I, I'm hoping we move towards— and I'm more directing this at Administrator Lee— moving towards a situation where the, the council calendar should not be the reason for an emergency ordinance.

261
00:28:33.157 --> 00:28:40.451
<v Unidentified speaker>I doubt this is going to be something that a lot of people want to testify on at the full council, but having those additional days is helpful for that.

262
00:28:40.500 --> 00:28:43.143
<v Unidentified speaker>That's my concern around emergency ordinances, but I appreciate that.

263
00:28:43.391 --> 00:28:44.133
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair Novick.

264
00:28:47.498 --> 00:28:48.609
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

265
00:28:51.890 --> 00:28:52.938
<v Lauren Johnson>Um, if you guys—.

266
00:28:52.971 --> 00:28:54.115
<v Steve Novick>Maria, were you about to say something?

267
00:28:55.133 --> 00:28:56.343
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, this is Angela.

268
00:28:56.503 --> 00:29:03.215
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I had that number of the cost recovery that we're anticipating with the fee updates would be between 53% and 56%.

269
00:29:04.249 --> 00:29:10.364
<v Unidentified speaker>The challenge is we don't anticipate all of the fees being charged equally.

270
00:29:10.622 --> 00:29:18.390
<v Unidentified speaker>So for example, we will see hopefully fewer third citations for people, um, but more hourly rates.

271
00:29:18.454 --> 00:29:23.114
<v Unidentified speaker>And there's a jump in the hourly rate for a lot of the composite rates.

272
00:29:23.726 --> 00:29:24.836
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, thank you.

273
00:29:25.546 --> 00:29:25.819
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

274
00:29:26.448 --> 00:29:27.059
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

275
00:29:35.642 --> 00:29:38.616
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith, I think that's a new hand for you, or is it a legacy hand?

276
00:29:47.823 --> 00:29:50.284
<v Steve Novick>Uh, Councilor Smith, you're still muted if you're with us.

277
00:29:53.500 --> 00:29:54.536
<v Steve Novick>All right, maybe she's on her way.

278
00:29:54.616 --> 00:29:55.314
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman?

279
00:29:56.155 --> 00:29:56.641
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair.

280
00:29:56.980 --> 00:30:01.061
<v Unidentified speaker>Just a real quick clarification, the hazardous occupancy fee is what again?

281
00:30:04.535 --> 00:30:05.948
<v Lauren Johnson>Like, what's the cost, or what is it?

282
00:30:06.013 --> 00:30:06.901
<v Unidentified speaker>No, sorry, not the cost.

283
00:30:07.082 --> 00:30:07.854
<v Unidentified speaker>What does it represent?

284
00:30:07.903 --> 00:30:08.116
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

285
00:30:09.214 --> 00:30:11.750
<v Unidentified speaker>I see that it will move to $250, but what are we talking about?

286
00:30:11.798 --> 00:30:12.857
<v Unidentified speaker>What kind of situation?

287
00:30:13.131 --> 00:30:14.431
<v Unidentified speaker>What type of occupancy are we talking about?

288
00:30:14.736 --> 00:30:20.770
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I know what hazardous waste is, I know what a fee is, I know what occupancy is, but as together, I'd like to know what are we talking about?

289
00:30:21.155 --> 00:30:29.325
<v Unidentified speaker>We're, we're talking those type of, uh, occupancies obviously have a higher hazard to them because of what, what's stored inside and what the process is.

290
00:30:29.422 --> 00:30:40.711
<v Unidentified speaker>This is like an industrial place with chemicals and welding gases, things So it's our inspection for those type of occupancies and sometimes extra permitting for those type of processes.

291
00:30:41.279 --> 00:30:42.922
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

292
00:30:44.387 --> 00:30:50.861
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so I see that, um, that one I am generally in favor of.

293
00:30:51.054 --> 00:31:05.530
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know that we can really, in one hand, be raising fees for additional plan review hours, so going from— so it's tripling the cost of the plan review when we spend a lot of time at this council talking about reducing permitting costs.

294
00:31:06.173 --> 00:31:13.378
<v Unidentified speaker>So either we split the question or I'll be a whole no today, because I think we've got to put our money where our mouth is at.

295
00:31:13.603 --> 00:31:19.541
<v Unidentified speaker>And this is one of those areas where $50, $100 seems small and it creeps in at every point.

296
00:31:19.653 --> 00:31:30.343
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm trying to send a message of if we're serious about permit reform, permit cost reform, and all forms of development reform, this is one of those areas I'm going to kind of draw a line here.

297
00:31:30.391 --> 00:31:31.971
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember But I do appreciate it.

298
00:31:32.037 --> 00:31:32.618
<v Unidentified speaker>It's very clear.

299
00:31:32.683 --> 00:31:33.250
<v Unidentified speaker>It's laid out.

300
00:31:33.330 --> 00:31:35.223
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm just making a values judgment here.

301
00:31:35.758 --> 00:31:36.242
<v Unidentified speaker>But thank you.

302
00:31:36.324 --> 00:31:36.808
<v Unidentified speaker>That's all, Chair.

303
00:31:39.064 --> 00:31:39.729
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

304
00:31:39.892 --> 00:31:40.508
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith?

305
00:31:42.391 --> 00:31:44.127
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, thank you so much, Mr.

306
00:31:44.175 --> 00:31:44.371
<v Loretta Smith>Chair.

307
00:31:44.582 --> 00:31:45.458
<v Loretta Smith>I have a question.

308
00:31:46.702 --> 00:31:50.644
<v Loretta Smith>Does fire have mandatory overtime?

309
00:31:52.712 --> 00:31:58.857
<v Lauren Johnson>Yes, mandatory backfill if there's a vacancy for fire station positions.

310
00:32:00.106 --> 00:32:04.549
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, and I'm not sure, um, does police have mandatory overtime?

311
00:32:09.503 --> 00:32:10.991
<v Sameer Kanal>No, Councilor.

312
00:32:12.921 --> 00:32:13.819
<v Loretta Smith>No, they don't?

313
00:32:15.282 --> 00:32:15.509
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

314
00:32:16.480 --> 00:32:18.422
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay, thank you.

315
00:32:18.502 --> 00:32:19.667
<v Loretta Smith>I have some, some more questions.

316
00:32:19.732 --> 00:32:25.103
<v Loretta Smith>I'm trying to figure a couple things out, but I just needed to know those 2 questions.

317
00:32:25.666 --> 00:32:25.959
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

318
00:32:30.501 --> 00:32:31.362
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

319
00:32:33.144 --> 00:32:39.559
<v Steve Novick>So, um, all of these fees, we in effect approved all of these fees in the budget.

320
00:32:39.608 --> 00:32:40.160
<v Steve Novick>Is that right?

321
00:32:40.876 --> 00:32:41.104
<v Lauren Johnson>Yes.

322
00:32:43.228 --> 00:32:51.498
<v Steve Novick>Um, I have to say, I'm a little concerned about, uh, and we didn't do any outreach other than, you know, through the norm— through the normal budget process.

323
00:32:53.693 --> 00:32:55.155
<v Lauren Johnson>That's correct.

324
00:32:55.960 --> 00:33:05.829
<v Steve Novick>I'm kind of a little worried that anything that's sort of lumped together with everything else in the budget, it might tend to get lost.

325
00:33:05.894 --> 00:33:17.618
<v Steve Novick>I mean, if you were to do specific outreach related to these changes, particularly the fees, this is, I realize, a hypothetical question, but what can you imagine it would have been?

326
00:33:18.261 --> 00:33:21.776
<v Steve Novick>Like, what are the most affected organizations that you might have tried to contact?

327
00:33:26.483 --> 00:33:26.896
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know.

328
00:33:29.920 --> 00:33:34.500
<v Lauren Johnson>I, I, yeah, Councilor, I, I certainly appreciate the question.

329
00:33:34.613 --> 00:33:57.936
<v Lauren Johnson>And other than those, um, budget town halls where we, you know, make notifications through council offices and neighborhood associations, I I think probably some outreach could go to a business, kind of a, yeah, Chamber of Commerce, something like that.

330
00:33:58.421 --> 00:34:04.900
<v Lauren Johnson>There's probably some unions that would be good to outreach.

331
00:34:05.097 --> 00:34:07.131
<v Lauren Johnson>I'm certainly open to suggestions.

332
00:34:09.501 --> 00:34:10.864
<v Lauren Johnson>And receive your point.

333
00:34:11.436 --> 00:34:11.789
<v Lauren Johnson>Agreed.

334
00:34:11.934 --> 00:34:13.188
<v Lauren Johnson>Thank you.

335
00:34:13.766 --> 00:34:14.393
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, just one.

336
00:34:14.489 --> 00:34:22.396
<v Steve Novick>Um, I mean, do you have any guess as to which kind of entities will be most affected and might be most concerned?

337
00:34:22.443 --> 00:34:30.976
<v Steve Novick>Like, would it be the entertainment venues, or those increases, um, such that you wouldn't expect to see much pushback?

338
00:34:31.523 --> 00:34:43.960
<v Steve Novick>Um, again, I'm asking, I'm asking you to guess, but I'm just trying to calculate, um, Are there folks that, you know, that if we had our druthers, we would have reached out to directly?

339
00:34:44.217 --> 00:34:49.490
<v Steve Novick>And might there be some reason to delay until we've had some more direct outreach?

340
00:34:51.092 --> 00:34:53.969
<v Lauren Johnson>Do you feel like you get pushback on any fees?

341
00:34:56.659 --> 00:35:09.686
<v Lauren Johnson>Um, and if we do— just sorry, Councilor, I'm asking questions because I don't have direct knowledge of where we're yeah, um, it's a tough question.

342
00:35:09.815 --> 00:35:22.081
<v Unidentified speaker>Our, our fee schedule is pretty complex, so when you talk about the increase in fees, it really depends on the size, the type of occupancy, if there's violations noted.

343
00:35:22.778 --> 00:35:33.141
<v Unidentified speaker>So there's a wide range of how somebody's fee may increase because there's so many ins and outs and deductions and what goes into it.

344
00:35:33.206 --> 00:35:47.110
<v Unidentified speaker>So obviously the larger the complex and higher risk, like what was brought up, a hazardous material facility that might be thousands of— have thousands of square feet, is going to have a higher fee.

345
00:35:47.271 --> 00:35:51.992
<v Unidentified speaker>So those possibly would be more of the conversation and pushback.

346
00:35:52.795 --> 00:36:06.269
<v Lauren Johnson>I mean, I would also just add, I think it's notable that we don't typically get thank you.

347
00:36:11.043 --> 00:36:11.722
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Knoll.

348
00:36:13.405 --> 00:36:13.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

349
00:36:14.034 --> 00:36:17.059
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm gonna kind of do a little tangent first.

350
00:36:17.123 --> 00:36:22.222
<v Unidentified speaker>I noticed we've got some folks in the back, and I just wanted to, uh, take a chance to welcome them.

351
00:36:22.286 --> 00:36:24.994
<v Unidentified speaker>I just got a message from Councilor Koyama Lane's office.

352
00:36:25.139 --> 00:36:27.538
<v Unidentified speaker>It's the Intercultural Academy of Municipalities.

353
00:36:28.072 --> 00:36:28.409
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

354
00:36:28.490 --> 00:36:29.197
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that correct?

355
00:36:30.626 --> 00:36:30.996
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

356
00:36:31.286 --> 00:36:32.811
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much for being here.

357
00:36:33.117 --> 00:36:37.896
<v Unidentified speaker>And I hope we're not talking too much about your area of work in this meeting, I don't think.

358
00:36:38.043 --> 00:36:42.407
<v Unidentified speaker>But I am really grateful that you've joined us and I hope you enjoy your time here.

359
00:36:44.351 --> 00:36:54.907
<v Unidentified speaker>I will say this is relevant in one sense because outreach to neighborhood associations is actually part of their work as well as some of the conversation we just had around engagement.

360
00:36:55.715 --> 00:37:09.686
<v Unidentified speaker>And I hope that as we get our engagement structure fully built out as a city, that this is something where we're not necessarily counting on the bureaus to do all the work directly, but to have the support, um, for that.

361
00:37:10.248 --> 00:37:15.041
<v Unidentified speaker>I do think this relates as well to the question about length of time that people can give input.

362
00:37:15.409 --> 00:37:29.764
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm not going to ask about in terms of delay of the policy, in terms of like pulling it back and refiling it, but in terms of giving that extra week or 2 for folks to, to do a first reading, second reading, if that's something that would cause Uh, a problem.

363
00:37:29.827 --> 00:37:37.771
<v Unidentified speaker>And, and I'll, I'll note it's not just the first reading, second reading, but then also the 30 days of, um, implementation time after the second reading.

364
00:37:38.208 --> 00:37:44.969
<v Unidentified speaker>Would— if those were added back in, so 37 additional days, would it cause— what, what would be the problems that would be caused, if any?

365
00:37:46.699 --> 00:37:49.090
<v Unidentified speaker>Do you want to—.

366
00:37:49.106 --> 00:37:51.641
<v Lauren Johnson>Would it be an option to move forward with the state?

367
00:37:51.706 --> 00:37:55.387
<v Lauren Johnson>I mean, the, the downside, right, is that we're not compliant with state fire code.

368
00:37:56.155 --> 00:37:57.418
<v Lauren Johnson>Since we haven't updated.

369
00:37:58.277 --> 00:38:01.032
<v Lauren Johnson>So I don't know if it's an option to split those 2.

370
00:38:02.311 --> 00:38:09.871
<v Lauren Johnson>Yeah, there's just not an issue with state fire code adoption and updating the Portland City Code.

371
00:38:10.731 --> 00:38:20.293
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I would like to consult with the city attorney too, to see what are the ramifications for us not complying with the state fire code.

372
00:38:20.342 --> 00:38:25.697
<v Sameer Kanal>I know in different states, the state can send down fines for not being in compliance.

373
00:38:27.311 --> 00:38:40.677
<v Sameer Kanal>With their code, but I'm not 100% sure what the state of Oregon does as it relates to not quite being in compliance, or if we're in the process of becoming compliant and have a compliance schedule to come into compliance, what that means.

374
00:38:40.869 --> 00:38:45.652
<v Sameer Kanal>So I probably need to consult with our legal counsel to kind of see what that means for us.

375
00:38:46.148 --> 00:38:46.485
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

376
00:38:46.952 --> 00:38:51.396
<v Unidentified speaker>To be clear, in terms of splitting, um, there are 2 legislative items here, right?

377
00:38:51.460 --> 00:38:54.076
<v Unidentified speaker>So one is the code piece, the other is the fee piece.

378
00:38:54.172 --> 00:39:15.661
<v Unidentified speaker>I think our conversation around okay, I, I think our conversation around the engagement question is more on the fee side, so I have no concern on the— and then the other question, uh, relatedly, uh, and this isn't something we necessarily have to do in this meeting because, um, for us it's a one-meeting referral or not anyway, but at the full council is where that would be relevant.

379
00:39:16.239 --> 00:39:31.347
<v Unidentified speaker>But the, the other question I had, and this goes back to Councilor— to Chair Novick's point, we my understanding is that we approved a budget that was dependent upon increasing these fees in order to keep the Fire Bureau solvent.

380
00:39:31.572 --> 00:39:31.827
<v Steve Novick>Correct.

381
00:39:32.052 --> 00:39:34.911
<v Unidentified speaker>At the level of service that we authorize on the expenses side.

382
00:39:35.264 --> 00:39:35.521
<v Sameer Kanal>Correct.

383
00:39:36.083 --> 00:39:38.909
<v Unidentified speaker>But that was a dollar amount increase.

384
00:39:38.974 --> 00:39:53.429
<v Unidentified speaker>And so how we got from here to there, the details of, of which thing is going up, for example, is something that probably Angela sort of modeled out and, and said if we make this one go up by this much and that one go up by that much, it'll add up to what we need.

385
00:39:53.717 --> 00:39:53.943
<v Unidentified speaker>Correct.

386
00:39:54.023 --> 00:39:57.726
<v Unidentified speaker>So there are some— so to some degree we have to do this because we already did it.

387
00:39:58.143 --> 00:39:58.398
<v Sameer Kanal>Mhm.

388
00:39:58.688 --> 00:40:01.380
<v Unidentified speaker>And but the how we do it is what we're discussing right now.

389
00:40:02.293 --> 00:40:12.873
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, and so I, I just wanted to make that clear that there is a— to some degree we already— the, the, the opportunity for engagement should have been in at that exactly as you said, Chief.

390
00:40:13.034 --> 00:40:15.903
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, In the budget because we approved the fee increases.

391
00:40:16.416 --> 00:40:33.005
<v Unidentified speaker>Having said that, when we do this process this way, and this is— we did this last year as well— if you are a person who might pay one of these particular fees but not all of them, you're not sure during the budget process if this increase is going to matter to you or not.

392
00:40:33.485 --> 00:40:37.092
<v Unidentified speaker>And so it's not an ideal process for that.

393
00:40:37.413 --> 00:40:38.567
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not on anyone here.

394
00:40:38.759 --> 00:40:40.425
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that has to do with the budget side.

395
00:40:40.922 --> 00:40:52.371
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, but in terms of going forward, I think transparency and clarity around which things are being increased is really helpful at the time that the actual decision happens, which was the budget.

396
00:40:53.108 --> 00:40:53.478
<v Unidentified speaker>This is the how.

397
00:40:53.846 --> 00:40:55.449
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just wanted to get that on the record too.

398
00:40:55.931 --> 00:40:57.934
<v Sameer Kanal>And I agree with you 100% on that, Councilor.

399
00:40:57.998 --> 00:41:09.416
<v Sameer Kanal>I think what we're discussing now is more of a process question as it relates to our budgeting process and how do we get engagement and feedback as it relates to fees or additional revenue.

400
00:41:09.625 --> 00:41:17.302
<v Sameer Kanal>I items that may come for council to vote upon, for council to be able to have that process to hear that feedback a part of that process.

401
00:41:17.976 --> 00:41:22.753
<v Sameer Kanal>Hearing it now on the tail end of it is kind of backwards in this.

402
00:41:23.250 --> 00:41:30.494
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, and we'll be talking about— this is not a pitch, I swear— but, uh, in the Committee of the Whole on Thursday, we will be continuing our budget process conversation.

403
00:41:30.543 --> 00:41:32.579
<v Unidentified speaker>So I, I'd be happy to bring that up there for next year.

404
00:41:32.963 --> 00:41:43.248
<v Unidentified speaker>But for this year, I think it's a question of would the emergency or another tool be able to help us get opportunities for the public to weigh in, whether they're the directly affected fee payers or not.

405
00:41:43.311 --> 00:41:44.356
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair.

406
00:41:44.581 --> 00:41:44.885
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, sorry.

407
00:41:45.061 --> 00:41:47.132
<v Lauren Johnson>Councilor, just to thank you.

408
00:41:47.485 --> 00:41:56.043
<v Lauren Johnson>Fire Marshal mentioned that on our fee schedule, there are some fees that are also on PP&D's fee schedule.

409
00:41:56.878 --> 00:41:59.976
<v Lauren Johnson>Those were approved by council in June, for what that's worth.

410
00:42:00.393 --> 00:42:03.909
<v Lauren Johnson>Just that you'll see fees in the same place or in 2 different places.

411
00:42:04.824 --> 00:42:11.135
<v Unidentified speaker>And in the future, do you— is your intention that that's the, the time, whether it's 1 year or 3 years?

412
00:42:11.505 --> 00:42:17.561
<v Lauren Johnson>Okay, yes, so much of this was done just going off of what PP&D has done.

413
00:42:17.657 --> 00:42:27.759
<v Lauren Johnson>And then, as I think you all are aware, that there's certainly the city's interest in improving that process, the permitting and development process, the plan review process.

414
00:42:27.855 --> 00:42:38.989
<v Lauren Johnson>And I think even in the last 6 months, our Um, process with that group has gotten much tighter, and so it's going to be just much more natural for these fee schedules to flow together.

415
00:42:39.956 --> 00:42:40.777
<v Unidentified speaker>Got it, got it.

416
00:42:40.827 --> 00:42:41.103
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

417
00:42:42.693 --> 00:42:43.277
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair Novick.

418
00:42:44.170 --> 00:42:44.869
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman.

419
00:42:48.244 --> 00:42:48.568
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

420
00:42:48.858 --> 00:42:57.038
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I think we're in desperate need of a city administrator for public safety.

421
00:42:57.177 --> 00:43:03.789
<v Eric Zimmerman>Now, let's say this, We've turned the mundane into a complicated situation here because of the lack of just coming in and talking.

422
00:43:04.224 --> 00:43:08.751
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so this is a couple in a row now, and so I'm growing a little frustrated, Mr.

423
00:43:08.800 --> 00:43:09.362
<v Eric Zimmerman>Administrator.

424
00:43:10.806 --> 00:43:13.505
<v Eric Zimmerman>What is normal and mundane should be normal and mundane.

425
00:43:13.762 --> 00:43:16.186
<v Eric Zimmerman>It just takes a brief amount of effort.

426
00:43:16.588 --> 00:43:25.693
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's nothing overly complicated in these documents, but the manner in which they come, or the manner in which Public Safety has been working now for a while, is a little frustrating.

427
00:43:25.740 --> 00:43:25.836
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

428
00:43:26.909 --> 00:43:33.985
<v Eric Zimmerman>I had a very regular opportunity with the previous DCA on this type of stuff, and it would've come up.

429
00:43:34.067 --> 00:43:35.202
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is not something that's come up.

430
00:43:36.072 --> 00:43:46.590
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I plan to vote to adopt the fire code, and I'm not prepared at this moment to adopt the fee schedule.

431
00:43:48.010 --> 00:43:59.717
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I would— Councilor Kanal talked a lot about engagement, but I think on the mundane, I'm comfortable with the engagement also just to councilors, right?

432
00:43:59.766 --> 00:44:10.407
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like, I'm in community all the time, I can ask these questions, but to bring something forward, um, that— I don't mean this as a pejorative, like the rubber stamp.

433
00:44:10.454 --> 00:44:17.465
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think some things are appropriate for a rubber stamp, but they require that we're a little bit read in ahead of time, and, and that hasn't occurred today.

434
00:44:18.242 --> 00:44:25.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, that's kind of where I'm, I'm struggling a little bit, and I'm seeing a trend, so I'm addressing a trend so we can nip it now.

435
00:44:25.590 --> 00:44:28.838
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and so that— I'll just, I'll just say that in terms of where I'm at.

436
00:44:29.403 --> 00:44:37.682
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm, I'm looking for, uh— I know that the service area is without, uh, the senior leader at this point, but I, I'm looking for that improvement.

437
00:44:37.746 --> 00:44:38.070
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

438
00:44:41.936 --> 00:44:42.632
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

439
00:44:42.989 --> 00:44:55.605
<v Steve Novick>Um, Councilor Kanal, were you suggesting earlier that we perhaps remove the emergency clause from the fee schedule in order to allow for more opportunity for public input?

440
00:44:57.146 --> 00:44:57.277
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

441
00:44:57.746 --> 00:44:58.603
<v Steve Novick>At the council level?

442
00:44:59.411 --> 00:45:09.771
<v Steve Novick>Um, and would you want to— would you want to do that here in committee or just sort of, uh, leave that or send it along as is and raise that as a possibility at the full council?

443
00:45:10.382 --> 00:45:12.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Either, either would be okay, Chair Novick.

444
00:45:13.130 --> 00:45:18.541
<v Unidentified speaker>With me, I think, um, it's a little more transparent to do it now, but only A small amount.

445
00:45:18.766 --> 00:45:25.188
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know if there's interest in doing that here, but I'm happy to propose it or second it if you propose it.

446
00:45:25.894 --> 00:45:25.911
<v Loretta Smith>I—.

447
00:45:25.974 --> 00:45:33.393
<v Steve Novick>Well, we'll see what the rest of the committee is, but personally, I rather like the idea.

448
00:45:33.456 --> 00:45:38.193
<v Steve Novick>So if you were going to propose it, I think you might get a second.

449
00:45:44.871 --> 00:45:45.163
<v Brian Hughes>Should I—.

450
00:45:46.507 --> 00:45:51.498
<v Unidentified speaker>You still have the floor, but I'll—.

451
00:45:51.596 --> 00:45:52.389
<v Steve Novick>I withdraw my hand.

452
00:45:52.503 --> 00:45:53.864
<v Steve Novick>I no longer have the floor.

453
00:45:53.960 --> 00:46:12.771
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so in that case, without making any changes to document number 2026-301, I would move to amend Ordinance 2026-300 to remove Section, um, 2.

454
00:46:17.777 --> 00:46:18.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

455
00:46:18.887 --> 00:46:28.753
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, any discussion of Councilor Kanal's proposed amendment?

456
00:46:29.525 --> 00:46:30.009
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor—.

457
00:46:30.121 --> 00:46:30.844
<v Steve Novick>Sorry, Chair.

458
00:46:30.909 --> 00:46:34.141
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Kanal, um, Angelita and I were being like the bad kids in the back here.

459
00:46:34.224 --> 00:46:35.476
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can you repeat what you're saying?

460
00:46:35.541 --> 00:46:36.077
<v Eric Zimmerman>We missed what you said.

461
00:46:36.789 --> 00:46:45.550
<v Unidentified speaker>It was a proposal to remove the emergency clause from the fee one, but not the code one, to allow for additional engagement at the full council level.

462
00:46:50.143 --> 00:46:53.860
<v Unidentified speaker>I would just like to state that I was skillfully listening to both at the same time.

463
00:46:54.036 --> 00:46:54.844
<v Unidentified speaker>Skill issue.

464
00:46:59.588 --> 00:47:04.454
<v Steve Novick>All right, if there's no discussion, could the clerk please call the roll of the amendment?

465
00:47:06.498 --> 00:47:12.570
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, uh, vote on the motion to amend the ordinance to remove the Section 2 emergency clause.

466
00:47:13.309 --> 00:47:13.646
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

467
00:47:14.514 --> 00:47:14.530
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

468
00:47:15.349 --> 00:47:15.750
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

469
00:47:15.974 --> 00:47:16.119
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

470
00:47:17.115 --> 00:47:17.548
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

471
00:47:18.143 --> 00:47:18.367
<v Loretta Smith>No.

472
00:47:19.509 --> 00:47:19.525
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

473
00:47:20.873 --> 00:47:21.210
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

474
00:47:22.239 --> 00:47:22.255
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

475
00:47:23.684 --> 00:47:24.599
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you confirm, was that aye?

476
00:47:25.677 --> 00:47:25.724
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

477
00:47:26.414 --> 00:47:26.753
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

478
00:47:27.282 --> 00:47:33.065
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, with 3 ayes and 2 nays, the motion to amend the ordinance has been approved.

479
00:47:35.471 --> 00:47:35.905
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

480
00:47:36.994 --> 00:47:54.994
<v Steve Novick>And, uh, since Councilors Brio and Zimmerman have been being bad kids in the back, I will, um, make the comment that I meant to make earlier, which is that if we had a reasonable organized crime organization in this city, then we'd know who the arsonists were and we could charge them fees for investigations.

481
00:47:55.443 --> 00:47:59.487
<v Steve Novick>Um, so it's one of the— one of the downfalls of not having an organized crime organization.

482
00:47:59.550 --> 00:47:59.646
<v Lauren Johnson>Thank you.

483
00:48:01.349 --> 00:48:07.606
<v Steve Novick>Is there any further discussion on either of the two items substantively?

484
00:48:13.181 --> 00:48:20.309
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll move to refer Ordinance 2026-301 to the full council with a do pass recommendation.

485
00:48:23.896 --> 00:48:24.648
<v Steve Novick>Do we hear a second?

486
00:48:25.202 --> 00:48:25.577
<v Angelita Morillo>Second.

487
00:48:27.867 --> 00:48:28.467
<v Steve Novick>Any discussion?

488
00:48:32.181 --> 00:48:33.268
<v Steve Novick>Could the clerk please call the roll?

489
00:48:34.860 --> 00:48:40.630
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, on document number 2026-301— or sorry, Morillo?

490
00:48:41.907 --> 00:48:41.956
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

491
00:48:42.619 --> 00:48:42.862
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

492
00:48:43.929 --> 00:48:44.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

493
00:48:44.608 --> 00:48:44.963
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

494
00:48:46.030 --> 00:48:46.079
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

495
00:48:47.583 --> 00:48:47.695
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

496
00:48:48.293 --> 00:48:48.713
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

497
00:48:49.507 --> 00:48:49.635
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

498
00:48:50.637 --> 00:49:00.228
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, with 5 ayes, the motion to refer the ordinance document number 2026-301 2026-301 to City Council with a recommendation it be passed has passed.

499
00:49:04.590 --> 00:49:08.268
<v Steve Novick>And could I get a motion on the next item?

500
00:49:12.141 --> 00:49:19.614
<v Unidentified speaker>Move to refer Ordinance 2026-300 to the full council, the do pass recommendation.

501
00:49:25.413 --> 00:49:25.672
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

502
00:49:26.253 --> 00:49:26.965
<v Steve Novick>Any discussion?

503
00:49:28.838 --> 00:49:32.458
<v Unidentified speaker>Can I confirm, was that Smith or Murillo who did the second?

504
00:49:33.009 --> 00:49:34.139
<v Unidentified speaker>Murillo, thank you so much.

505
00:49:35.570 --> 00:49:41.972
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, all right, so motion to refer the ordinance document number 2026-300.

506
00:49:43.025 --> 00:49:43.204
<v Unidentified speaker>Murillo?

507
00:49:44.565 --> 00:49:44.751
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

508
00:49:45.275 --> 00:49:45.730
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

509
00:49:46.000 --> 00:49:46.168
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

510
00:49:48.295 --> 00:49:48.634
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

511
00:49:48.891 --> 00:49:49.005
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

512
00:49:50.119 --> 00:49:50.780
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

513
00:49:51.474 --> 00:49:51.523
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

514
00:49:52.282 --> 00:49:52.637
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

515
00:49:54.380 --> 00:49:54.429
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

516
00:49:55.108 --> 00:49:55.414
<v Christy Butcher>The—.

517
00:49:55.641 --> 00:50:06.025
<v Unidentified speaker>With 4 ayes and 1 nay, the motion to refer the ordinance as amended, document number 2026-300, to the City Council with a recommendation it be passed has passed.

518
00:50:09.875 --> 00:50:10.349
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

519
00:50:11.103 --> 00:50:26.581
<v Steve Novick>Well, Um, we normally don't take a break after 45 minutes, but since there's only one further item and we do have to have a break at some point, um, let's reconvene to hear the next item at 10:30.

520
00:50:32.420 --> 00:50:33.096
<v Steve Novick>Any recess?

521
00:50:33.163 --> 00:50:33.737
<v Steve Novick>I'll get there.

522
01:05:14.655 --> 01:05:16.255
<v Steve Novick>Welcome back, everyone.

523
01:05:16.512 --> 01:05:17.981
<v Steve Novick>Are we still waiting on Councilor Zimmerman?

524
01:05:18.465 --> 01:05:19.014
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

525
01:05:22.275 --> 01:05:23.284
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, but we have quorum.

526
01:05:24.342 --> 01:05:28.380
<v Steve Novick>Okay, uh, let's give the councilor another 30 seconds.

527
01:05:29.710 --> 01:05:31.266
<v Unidentified speaker>He, he just walked in the room.

528
01:05:32.034 --> 01:05:34.309
<v Steve Novick>All right, here we all are.

529
01:05:34.679 --> 01:05:36.201
<v Steve Novick>Um, welcome back.

530
01:05:37.003 --> 01:05:41.121
<v Steve Novick>Uh, I think it's— I can't see him, but I think it's Chief Yu.

531
01:05:41.264 --> 01:05:56.614
<v Steve Novick>Oh, actually, okay, again, I think that all of us, um, Have seen the stories saying that, although in recent years, police calls for service have gone down, response times have gone up.

532
01:05:56.681 --> 01:06:00.295
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Murillo suggested that as a topic for discussion, and I agreed.

533
01:06:01.539 --> 01:06:08.641
<v Steve Novick>We're going to have PPB here to address that issue, and Councilor Murillo has invited Portland for All to also address that issue.

534
01:06:09.670 --> 01:06:10.699
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Murillo.

535
01:06:10.954 --> 01:06:13.987
<v Steve Novick>Do you have anything further to add before we proceed to the presentations?

536
01:06:14.998 --> 01:06:18.400
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, thank you, Chair Novick, and thank you so much to all the folks that are presenting today.

537
01:06:18.929 --> 01:06:33.677
<v Unidentified speaker>I think after this report came out, there was a lot of media interest and public interest in it as well, so I think it's just good for us to have a discussion and get clarity on some of the information that came out so that we can better make decisions about budgeting and staffing throughout the city.

538
01:06:34.190 --> 01:06:41.552
<v Unidentified speaker>I also think that there are some options that are listed from different groups about having the auditor maybe look into the report as well.

539
01:06:42.614 --> 01:06:46.704
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think that this will hopefully be a very fruitful discussion and we'll get a lot of information out of it.

540
01:06:46.849 --> 01:06:48.148
<v Unidentified speaker>So thanks everyone for being here today.

541
01:06:49.827 --> 01:06:50.815
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

542
01:06:50.880 --> 01:07:03.117
<v Steve Novick>We've asked both PBB and Portland for All to have 15-minute presentations in order to leave a bunch of time for council questions and discussions.

543
01:07:04.548 --> 01:07:07.309
<v Steve Novick>Chief Hughes, I don't see you, but I think you're the one there.

544
01:07:07.791 --> 01:07:08.175
<v Steve Novick>Take it away.

545
01:07:08.882 --> 01:07:09.235
<v Brian Hughes>I am here.

546
01:07:09.380 --> 01:07:11.322
<v Brian Hughes>Good morning, Chair Novick and members of the CAPS Committee.

547
01:07:11.385 --> 01:07:14.610
<v Brian Hughes>For the record, I'm Brian Hughes, Deputy Chief of the Portland Police Bureau.

548
01:07:14.675 --> 01:07:15.429
<v Unidentified speaker>Chief, before—.

549
01:07:15.557 --> 01:07:19.297
<v Unidentified speaker>Or sorry, Captain, before you start, I need to read it in the record officially.

550
01:07:19.570 --> 01:07:19.954
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

551
01:07:20.132 --> 01:07:21.030
<v Lauren Johnson>And you have to open the item.

552
01:07:21.175 --> 01:07:22.266
<v Steve Novick>I'm so sorry.

553
01:07:22.523 --> 01:07:23.005
<v Lauren Johnson>That's okay.

554
01:07:23.164 --> 01:07:24.753
<v Steve Novick>Forgot the basic committee.

555
01:07:24.849 --> 01:07:26.648
<v Steve Novick>Could the clerk please read the next item?

556
01:07:26.711 --> 01:07:27.193
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

557
01:07:27.659 --> 01:07:29.793
<v Unidentified speaker>Item number 3, document number 2026.

558
01:07:30.065 --> 01:07:31.862
<v Unidentified speaker>Take it away.

559
01:07:32.487 --> 01:07:34.590
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

560
01:07:34.958 --> 01:07:37.494
<v Portland Police Bureau>All right, good morning again.

561
01:07:37.862 --> 01:07:40.574
<v Portland Police Bureau>Deputy Chief Brian Hughes, for the record, Portland Police Bureau.

562
01:07:41.072 --> 01:07:43.269
<v Portland Police Bureau>Thank you for the opportunity to speak with you this morning.

563
01:07:43.798 --> 01:07:46.815
<v Portland Police Bureau>We've been asked to provide some information related to call response times.

564
01:07:47.088 --> 01:07:52.398
<v Portland Police Bureau>As you'll hear today, there are a myriad of factors that affect our ability to respond to calls across the city.

565
01:07:52.847 --> 01:07:54.981
<v Portland Police Bureau>Staffing is certainly part of that conversation.

566
01:07:55.815 --> 01:08:00.244
<v Portland Police Bureau>But so too is how the resources we have available are being used at any given moment.

567
01:08:00.965 --> 01:08:04.945
<v Portland Police Bureau>Today's presentation attempts to highlight one part of that larger ecosystem.

568
01:08:05.795 --> 01:08:12.918
<v Portland Police Bureau>A single high-risk incident can require a significant number of patrol officers to establish containment, protect the public, and manage the initial response.

569
01:08:13.320 --> 01:08:21.020
<v Portland Police Bureau>At the same time, it can require specialized personnel to leave their regular assignments or respond to home— or from home while off duty.

570
01:08:21.743 --> 01:08:31.186
<v Portland Police Bureau>Those incidents can last hours, and while they are underway, they have a very real impact on the resources available to respond to other emergencies across the city.

571
01:08:32.181 --> 01:08:36.405
<v Portland Police Bureau>You'll first hear from Lieutenant Christy Butcher, who leads our Special Emergency Reaction Team.

572
01:08:37.161 --> 01:08:51.072
<v Portland Police Bureau>Lieutenant Butcher will walk you through what one of those incidents looks like operationally, the resources required to safely resolve it, and the impacts those incidents can have on both staff— patrol staffing and the specialized personnel who respond on call.

573
01:08:51.713 --> 01:09:03.730
<v Portland Police Bureau>Following Lieutenant Butcher, Christian Peterson from our Strategic Services Division will broaden the lens and provide a longer-term perspective on Bureau staffing, call demand, and our response to high-priority incidents over the past decade.

574
01:09:04.694 --> 01:09:14.284
<v Portland Police Bureau>Our hope is that these 2 presentations together provide some additional context around the complexity of call response times and the many competing demands placed on a finite number of police resources.

575
01:09:14.349 --> 01:09:14.798
<v Portland Police Bureau>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney.

576
01:09:15.792 --> 01:09:17.961
<v Portland Police Bureau>Thank you again for the opportunity to present this morning.

577
01:09:18.253 --> 01:09:20.177
<v Portland Police Bureau>And with that, I'll turn it over to Lieutenant Butcher.

578
01:09:22.859 --> 01:09:23.716
<v Christy Butcher>Good morning, councilors.

579
01:09:23.765 --> 01:09:28.050
<v Christy Butcher>I'm Christy Butcher, Lieutenant of the Specialized Resources Division for the Portland Police Bureau.

580
01:09:28.648 --> 01:09:40.635
<v Christy Butcher>I'm here to talk about PPB's specialized responses to incidents throughout the city and how, although highly beneficial for the community, some of these incident responses can impact overall staffing and citywide resources.

581
01:09:41.287 --> 01:09:43.563
<v Christy Butcher>Therefore impacting emergency response times.

582
01:09:44.332 --> 01:10:00.988
<v Christy Butcher>I will highlight some of our specialized response teams, talk about why some incidents require hours and not minutes to resolve, explain how patrol, specialized resources, and investigators work together to provide a coordinated response, and why life safety drives every operational decision.

583
01:10:02.286 --> 01:10:12.051
<v Christy Butcher>Then I will give an example of one extended specialized tactical response in our city and explain how the resources work together over many hours to safely resolve the incident.

584
01:10:13.079 --> 01:10:18.123
<v Christy Butcher>Critical incidents are dynamic, resource-intensive, and driven by life safety, not by the clock.

585
01:10:21.381 --> 01:10:21.637
<v Christian Peterson>Next.

586
01:10:21.863 --> 01:10:28.542
<v Christy Butcher>Portland's specialized response teams provide capabilities beyond routine patrol operations.

587
01:10:28.867 --> 01:10:36.844
<v Christy Butcher>Continued investment strengthens public safety, protects constitutional rights, reduces liability, and improves outcomes for the community.

588
01:10:37.742 --> 01:10:42.853
<v Christy Butcher>As you can see on this slide, there's a number of our specialized response teams.

589
01:10:43.045 --> 01:10:44.279
<v Christy Butcher>Not all of them are listed.

590
01:10:44.567 --> 01:10:46.858
<v Christy Butcher>I just grabbed a few to highlight some of the differences.

591
01:10:47.595 --> 01:10:53.635
<v Christy Butcher>The numbers listed on the slides indicate the number of responses that team had in the year of 2025.

592
01:10:54.355 --> 01:11:01.838
<v Christy Butcher>Specialized teams bring specialized training, experience, and equipment that aren't practical for every patrol officer to maintain.

593
01:11:01.951 --> 01:11:02.255
<v Lauren Johnson>Thank you.

594
01:11:02.896 --> 01:11:05.769
<v Christy Butcher>Here are a few examples of our specialized response teams.

595
01:11:06.346 --> 01:11:09.779
<v Christy Butcher>First up is the Metropolitan Explosive Disposal Unit.

596
01:11:10.052 --> 01:11:18.364
<v Christy Butcher>This unit consists of 8 agencies, and they respond to suspicious devices, explosive threats, and are responsible for the disposal of explosives.

597
01:11:19.021 --> 01:11:24.269
<v Christy Butcher>This is one of the teams that you saw respond earlier in the year to the Multnomah Athletic Club incident.

598
01:11:24.895 --> 01:11:30.639
<v Christy Butcher>Next up is the Enhanced Community Safety Team, which responds to and investigates crimes involving gun violence.

599
01:11:30.912 --> 01:11:34.496
<v Christy Butcher>And is primarily responsible for injury shooting investigations.

600
01:11:35.716 --> 01:11:45.100
<v Christy Butcher>Homicide is responsible for major investigations including homicides, suspicious deaths, officer-involved shootings, and missing person investigations.

601
01:11:46.403 --> 01:11:50.805
<v Christy Butcher>The Major Crash Team responds to fatal and complex crash investigations.

602
01:11:51.479 --> 01:12:06.447
<v Christy Butcher>And the Rapid Response Team, they provide specialty tactical response to all hazards that require a high level of technical competence, knowledge, and skill, such as public assemblies, civil disturbances, and natural or man-made disasters.

603
01:12:07.530 --> 01:12:19.654
<v Christy Butcher>The Specialized Emergency Reaction Team, they provide high tactical response such as responding to hostage rescue events, barricaded persons, and serving high-risk arrest and search warrants.

604
01:12:21.448 --> 01:12:24.404
<v Christy Butcher>All these teams these teams do not operate in isolation.

605
01:12:24.663 --> 01:12:28.618
<v Christy Butcher>They are brought together based on what each unique incident resolve requires.

606
01:12:29.800 --> 01:12:32.235
<v Christy Butcher>Many of these incidents are fluid and complex.

607
01:12:32.658 --> 01:12:37.109
<v Christy Butcher>By providing specialized responses such as these, this improves community outcomes.

608
01:12:37.840 --> 01:12:38.162
<v Loretta Smith>Next slide.

609
01:12:39.792 --> 01:12:43.167
<v Christy Butcher>In a critical incident, time is a consideration for many reasons.

610
01:12:43.655 --> 01:12:49.614
<v Christy Butcher>We have to consider the amount of resources on a given, given incident that are tied up for the duration of that incident.

611
01:12:50.222 --> 01:13:05.788
<v Christy Butcher>We have to consider the wellness of our officers for that entire incident, and we also have to consider the overall impact to uninvolved persons, such as keeping people from their places of work or having to reroute traffic around a certain closed area.

612
01:13:06.735 --> 01:13:11.453
<v Christy Butcher>But oftentimes, time itself is a resource that allows us to make the safest decision.

613
01:13:12.913 --> 01:13:27.501
<v Christy Butcher>What may look like a delay from the outside may actually be a deliberate risk management tool, creating time to gather information, establish containment of the problem, communicate, develop a plan, and bring the appropriate resources together.

614
01:13:28.398 --> 01:13:34.166
<v Christy Butcher>Every decision is therefore evaluated against questions such as: is anyone in immediate danger?

615
01:13:34.565 --> 01:13:36.313
<v Christy Butcher>Can we create time and distance?

616
01:13:36.649 --> 01:13:38.524
<v Christy Butcher>Can we safely contain that situation?

617
01:13:39.292 --> 01:13:41.359
<v Christy Butcher>Can we communicate with the persons involved?

618
01:13:42.016 --> 01:13:45.109
<v Christy Butcher>Can we evacuate or protect uninvolved community members?

619
01:13:45.623 --> 01:13:48.087
<v Christy Butcher>And do we have enough information to act safely?

620
01:13:49.311 --> 01:13:51.953
<v Christy Butcher>What additional resources may we need to bring?

621
01:13:52.854 --> 01:13:58.021
<v Christy Butcher>And can we accomplish the objective without unnecessarily increasing the risk?

622
01:13:58.926 --> 01:13:59.298
<v Christy Butcher>Next slide.

623
01:14:01.448 --> 01:14:07.894
<v Christy Butcher>So let's look at some incidents and see what is happening after the 911 call is placed.

624
01:14:09.331 --> 01:14:09.685
<v Christy Butcher>Next slide.

625
01:14:10.719 --> 01:14:13.189
<v Christy Butcher>So here's an example of a typical call response.

626
01:14:14.188 --> 01:14:23.188
<v Christy Butcher>It usually always begins with the call being made to BOEC, the dispatcher having to create the call, and then dispatching the appropriate units to that call.

627
01:14:23.734 --> 01:14:26.283
<v Christy Butcher>Patrol always responds to each incident first.

628
01:14:26.702 --> 01:14:34.675
<v Christy Butcher>Containment is usually established, followed by incident command, having one person in charge of each decision that is made on that incident.

629
01:14:35.301 --> 01:14:39.247
<v Christy Butcher>Communication and negotiations are attempted with the subjects involved in the call.

630
01:14:40.514 --> 01:14:42.614
<v Christy Butcher>We may need to call in specialized teams.

631
01:14:43.480 --> 01:14:49.958
<v Christy Butcher>Investigators might need to apply for a search warrant, and tactical and medical planning take place.

632
01:14:50.680 --> 01:14:54.032
<v Christy Butcher>The call usually resolves, and the investigation continues.

633
01:14:54.930 --> 01:15:01.247
<v Christy Butcher>It's important to note that a lot of these activities I just described occur simultaneously and often behind the scenes.

634
01:15:02.065 --> 01:15:05.962
<v Christy Butcher>Also, it's important to understand that patrol responds first to everything.

635
01:15:06.011 --> 01:15:06.234
<v Lauren Johnson>Thank you.

636
01:15:06.429 --> 01:15:07.641
<v Christy Butcher>It doesn't matter the call type.

637
01:15:07.932 --> 01:15:14.109
<v Christy Butcher>Patrol is always the first to get dispatched, arrive on scene, evaluate, and decide what else is needed, if anything.

638
01:15:15.840 --> 01:15:16.242
<v Christy Butcher>Next slide.

639
01:15:18.109 --> 01:15:22.360
<v Christy Butcher>One incident can involve dozens of employees across multiple bureau functions.

640
01:15:22.698 --> 01:15:28.341
<v Christy Butcher>The tactical incident I will explain next more in depth involved all of these listed units on this slide.

641
01:15:28.925 --> 01:15:43.918
<v Christy Butcher>Patrol responds first, then specialized teams such as CERT and CNT, which is our Crisis Negotiation Team, which I should note always responds with the CERT team to spontaneous patrol-initiated events.

642
01:15:44.913 --> 01:15:57.646
<v Christy Butcher>K-9 units, our UAS team, which is our drone team, our Metropolitan Explosive Disposal Unit, investigators, EMS, which is Emergency Medical Services.

643
01:15:57.823 --> 01:15:58.128
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

644
01:15:58.641 --> 01:16:07.399
<v Christy Butcher>And Portland Fire and Rescue responded to this scene, as well as partner agencies such as our East Metro SWAT partners from Multnomah County and Gresham.

645
01:16:08.664 --> 01:16:16.363
<v Christy Butcher>A lot of these specialized response teams that I mentioned earlier rely on detached members, meaning that this is not their primary full-time job.

646
01:16:16.458 --> 01:16:24.189
<v Christy Butcher>So if their team gets called to a scene, they are likely responding from home or from another full-time position such as patrol or investigation.

647
01:16:26.030 --> 01:16:26.484
<v Christy Butcher>Next slide.

648
01:16:27.408 --> 01:16:31.443
<v Christy Butcher>So now we'll take a look at an extended tactical response within our city.

649
01:16:33.069 --> 01:16:39.347
<v Christy Butcher>I've laid out the timeline here just so you could follow along, and I'll describe some of the activities that are occurring during this timeline.

650
01:16:40.369 --> 01:16:47.229
<v Christy Butcher>At 5:35 AM, Boeck received a call from a third party saying that her mom was being held at gunpoint at the call location.

651
01:16:48.130 --> 01:16:56.421
<v Christy Butcher>At 5:38, patrol units were dispatched and minutes later, 5:44, patrol arrives and begins to establish containment of the problem.

652
01:16:57.384 --> 01:17:07.884
<v Christy Butcher>I should note that this takes several resources to keep people out of the danger area and also to keep the potential suspect in the area contained.

653
01:17:08.845 --> 01:17:14.583
<v Christy Butcher>For the next 75 minutes, patrol gathers resources and tries to communicate with the persons inside the location.

654
01:17:15.819 --> 01:17:22.327
<v Christy Butcher>This call, however, quickly outgrew the capabilities of patrol and required specialized responses from our CERT and CBRN teams.

655
01:17:22.390 --> 01:17:22.487
<v Christy Butcher>Thank you.

656
01:17:22.600 --> 01:17:28.448
<v Christy Butcher>C&T team at 0700 based on the high risk and complexity of this incident.

657
01:17:29.902 --> 01:17:40.990
<v Christy Butcher>As those teams began to arrive, many responding from home from this— for this incident, uh, at 7:57 AM, resources began to evacuate nearby residents.

658
01:17:41.636 --> 01:17:48.337
<v Christy Butcher>Our C&T team worked with patrol and investigators to gather as much intelligence about the location and the persons involved.

659
01:17:49.328 --> 01:18:05.127
<v Christy Butcher>At 8:00 AM, the, the potential victim who was in harm's way from the— look, came outside the location and was held nearby in safety by police, therefore redefining this incident as a solo barricaded person.

660
01:18:05.480 --> 01:18:13.637
<v Christy Butcher>We believed just one person was inside, and investigators began to apply for a search warrant at 8:35 for the location.

661
01:18:14.471 --> 01:18:17.243
<v Christy Butcher>In this case— oh, sorry.

662
01:18:17.917 --> 01:18:27.578
<v Christy Butcher>In case we could not get the suspect inside, whom we knew— whom we now had probable cause for coercion, menacing with a firearm, to come outside the location.

663
01:18:28.796 --> 01:18:33.828
<v Christy Butcher>And plus, eventually we needed that search warrant to enter and search for evidence of the crimes.

664
01:18:34.725 --> 01:18:41.519
<v Christy Butcher>At 9:15, we were able to deploy technology such as our drones and robots both inside and outside the location.

665
01:18:43.479 --> 01:18:51.720
<v Christy Butcher>11:25, We continued with crisis negotiations, and in this incident, the suspect just kept disconnecting the line.

666
01:18:52.539 --> 01:19:00.667
<v Christy Butcher>At 12:17, tactical planning was ongoing, and we were trying to figure out how we could safely resolve this incident.

667
01:19:01.777 --> 01:19:08.765
<v Christy Butcher>At 1:04 PM, medical contingency planning was happening if we needed to get medical aid into the suspect.

668
01:19:09.166 --> 01:19:14.471
<v Christy Butcher>Inside or officers or community members outside, how were we going to safely do that?

669
01:19:15.256 --> 01:19:22.149
<v Christy Butcher>And this involves staging medical resources nearby in order to provide a safe and quick response.

670
01:19:22.631 --> 01:19:32.632
<v Christy Butcher>If they're not staged, depending on where they are and what call they are currently assigned to, it could take a much longer time to respond and provide medical resources to those in need.

671
01:19:33.211 --> 01:19:41.242
<v Christy Butcher>This is important to note, much like patrol response, These, these incidents can impact other citywide resources as well.

672
01:19:42.735 --> 01:19:47.965
<v Christy Butcher>All these things previously mentioned are often occurring simultaneously and in multiple variations.

673
01:19:48.627 --> 01:20:00.356
<v Christy Butcher>At 5:32 PM, the suspect is safely apprehended after he climbed onto the rooftop and tried to swing across to another rooftop but fell while trying to grab onto a tree branch.

674
01:20:01.534 --> 01:20:03.940
<v Christy Butcher>When he landed on the ground, he was safely taken into custody.

675
01:20:03.989 --> 01:20:04.088
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

676
01:20:04.622 --> 01:20:06.332
<v Christy Butcher>However, this incident is not over.

677
01:20:06.720 --> 01:20:14.454
<v Christy Butcher>Now the investigation continues, and there still is a need to hold the perimeter for the crime scene in order to provide a safe and thorough investigation.

678
01:20:16.131 --> 01:20:27.581
<v Christy Butcher>6:30 PM, evidence collection and scene processing took place, and after the scene was released, per policy, officers still have to write their reports prior to ending their shift.

679
01:20:28.176 --> 01:20:31.059
<v Christy Butcher>This includes all the patrol members that responded to the scene.

680
01:20:32.583 --> 01:20:36.202
<v Christy Butcher>All these events are happening continuously and simultaneously.

681
01:20:36.541 --> 01:20:38.996
<v Christy Butcher>The time is spent reducing risk, not just waiting.

682
01:20:40.010 --> 01:20:45.876
<v Christy Butcher>Specialized resources can create time, distance, containment, communication, and negotiation opportunities.

683
01:20:46.551 --> 01:20:54.154
<v Christy Butcher>These long hours represent risk reduction and problem solving, but can also impact our ability to respond to emergency calls.

684
01:20:55.750 --> 01:20:56.131
<v Lauren Johnson>Next slide.

685
01:20:57.315 --> 01:21:04.190
<v Christy Butcher>This slide just highlights that every incident is different, even if they begin with similar fact patterns.

686
01:21:04.319 --> 01:21:13.163
<v Christy Butcher>So Incident A that I put up here, it could take 2 hours to serve a search warrant where you encounter a cooperative suspect and you take them into custody.

687
01:21:13.661 --> 01:21:25.680
<v Christy Butcher>Incident B is much like the 18 hours that I described on this one, where it involved a barricaded subject, several negotiations, evacuations, And deployments of tech— of technology.

688
01:21:26.827 --> 01:21:34.266
<v Christy Butcher>And then Incident C, it could be even longer with a multiple-day investigation coordinating arrest and search warrant service.

689
01:21:35.238 --> 01:21:38.135
<v Christy Butcher>Rarely do 2 incidents follow the same timeline.

690
01:21:39.203 --> 01:21:39.833
<v Christy Butcher>And last slide.

691
01:21:41.439 --> 01:21:47.731
<v Christy Butcher>So every decision balances life safety, constitutional rights, investigative needs, and available resources.

692
01:21:48.328 --> 01:21:52.480
<v Christy Butcher>Most critical incidents are resolved without the public ever seeing the complexity behind them.

693
01:21:52.529 --> 01:21:52.694
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

694
01:21:53.229 --> 01:21:55.793
<v Christy Butcher>The public often sees only the final outcome.

695
01:21:56.404 --> 01:22:08.255
<v Christy Butcher>Each successful resolution represents hours of coordination among patrol officers, specialized units, investigators, dispatchers, and command staff working together under constantly changing conditions.

696
01:22:08.992 --> 01:22:13.948
<v Christy Butcher>So today I've explained the benefits of providing specialized response to certain incidents throughout our city.

697
01:22:14.604 --> 01:22:28.344
<v Christy Butcher>I've also pointed out how these incidents can have an overall impact on our ability to and now Christian's going to describe a more longitudinal view to things impacting PPB responding to incidents.

698
01:22:28.604 --> 01:22:28.997
<v Christy Butcher>Thank you.

699
01:22:32.100 --> 01:22:33.277
<v Christian Peterson>Hello, everybody, and thank you.

700
01:22:35.488 --> 01:22:35.569
<v Christy Butcher>This—.

701
01:22:35.569 --> 01:22:37.921
<v Christian Peterson>Thank you for the opportunity to share some information today.

702
01:22:38.405 --> 01:22:43.435
<v Christian Peterson>I'm going to walk you through a reason for optimism and hopefully provide some insights along the way.

703
01:22:44.048 --> 01:22:53.448
<v Christian Peterson>The first 5 graphs that I'm going to be showing you all depict the last 10 fiscal years on the x-axis and have data labels indicating their frequency count on the bar graph.

704
01:22:54.328 --> 01:23:01.559
<v Christian Peterson>The first graph gives a reason for optimism, showing a slight upward trend in the available officers over the last few fiscal years.

705
01:23:02.119 --> 01:23:05.774
<v Christian Peterson>Now, I want to caveat that this is not the number of officers assigned to patrol.

706
01:23:06.368 --> 01:23:16.358
<v Christian Peterson>This includes all officers that are in an academy, trainees, officers assigned to specialty assignments like Neighborhood Response Team, Community Engagement Unit, and Investigative Support, and many others.

707
01:23:17.351 --> 01:23:20.175
<v Christian Peterson>However, with this optimism, there is also insight.

708
01:23:20.496 --> 01:23:29.430
<v Christian Peterson>If you look at the fiscal year '17-'18 compared to the most recent fiscal year, the number of officers available is down approximately 11%, 70 officers.

709
01:23:30.007 --> 01:23:35.782
<v Christian Peterson>This insight is only the beginning when you realize that at least 90 officers are in training status right now.

710
01:23:36.439 --> 01:23:42.676
<v Christian Peterson>The reasons I highlighted fiscal year 2017-'18 will be highlighted again on multiple other slides.

711
01:23:42.935 --> 01:23:43.242
<v Christian Peterson>Next.

712
01:23:46.170 --> 01:23:48.353
<v Christian Peterson>The next graph continues the theme of optimism.

713
01:23:48.960 --> 01:23:53.408
<v Christian Peterson>Fiscal year '25-'26 had the highest total call volume in the last 6 fiscal years.

714
01:23:54.153 --> 01:23:57.243
<v Christian Peterson>I want to take the time to identify what makes up the total call volume.

715
01:23:57.712 --> 01:23:59.582
<v Christian Peterson>First is dispatch calls for service.

716
01:23:59.969 --> 01:24:04.171
<v Christian Peterson>These are all calls that are generated from the community asking for assistance.

717
01:24:04.510 --> 01:24:07.037
<v Christian Peterson>The second component is self-initiated calls for service.

718
01:24:07.868 --> 01:24:09.618
<v Christian Peterson>These are calls initiated by officers.

719
01:24:09.730 --> 01:24:18.550
<v Christian Peterson>They include following up on crime incidents, proactive interventions, stops, community engagement, walking patrol, the officer getting flagged down or witnessing an incident.

720
01:24:18.645 --> 01:24:19.850
<v Loretta Smith>Mr. Chairman, point of order.

721
01:24:20.091 --> 01:24:25.858
<v Loretta Smith>I'm, I'm sorry, I didn't get your name and what department in the police are you with?

722
01:24:26.114 --> 01:24:26.805
<v Loretta Smith>Are you representing?

723
01:24:27.015 --> 01:24:32.154
<v Christian Peterson>Sorry, uh, my name is Christian Peterson for the record, and I am part of the Strategic Services Division of the Portland Police Bureau.

724
01:24:32.604 --> 01:24:32.748
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

725
01:24:33.087 --> 01:24:33.716
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, perfect.

726
01:24:34.152 --> 01:24:34.539
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

727
01:24:36.475 --> 01:24:49.631
<v Christian Peterson>Uh, the second component was, uh, was the, uh, self-initiated calls for service, um, which included proactive intervention stops, community engagement, walking patrol officers getting flagged down, and witnesses witnessing an incident or other things.

728
01:24:50.215 --> 01:25:01.587
<v Christian Peterson>Although we have reason for optimism, insights also show us that we have still not reached the levels of service we experienced in fiscal year 2017-18 or fiscal year next slide, please.

729
01:25:03.792 --> 01:25:07.222
<v Christian Peterson>The next graph isolates just self-initiated calls for service.

730
01:25:07.658 --> 01:25:10.255
<v Christian Peterson>The optimism I spoke of before is even more pronounced.

731
01:25:10.564 --> 01:25:14.945
<v Christian Peterson>In the graphs, you can see a dashed line that— this is the 10-year average.

732
01:25:15.043 --> 01:25:24.292
<v Christian Peterson>In fiscal year '25-'26, this was the first time we were above that since COVID The last 6 years in a row, the PPBE has experienced increases in documented self-initiated activity.

733
01:25:24.789 --> 01:25:28.023
<v Christian Peterson>As I mentioned earlier, this is proactive activity and follow-up work.

734
01:25:28.362 --> 01:25:32.682
<v Christian Peterson>However, the same trend mentioned earlier that this activity is below the pre-COVID numbers.

735
01:25:33.666 --> 01:25:34.215
<v Christian Peterson>Next slide, please.

736
01:25:35.840 --> 01:25:40.770
<v Christian Peterson>Moving on to the second part of total calls for service, I am now showing you dispatch calls for service.

737
01:25:41.288 --> 01:25:46.381
<v Christian Peterson>This is the community-generated calls for service, and again, the first thing I see is a cause for optimism.

738
01:25:46.948 --> 01:25:49.341
<v Christian Peterson>Last fiscal year was the highest in 4 fiscal years.

739
01:25:49.922 --> 01:25:52.784
<v Christian Peterson>The last 2 fiscal years have increased by over 5% each year.

740
01:25:53.250 --> 01:26:04.106
<v Christian Peterson>However, although I have optimism about the recent increases in call volume, the insight shows that we still have a long way to get to the high-water mark of fiscal year 2017-2018.

741
01:26:04.171 --> 01:26:05.445
<v Christian Peterson>We're still over 30,000 calls below that.

742
01:26:05.930 --> 01:26:06.430
<v Christian Peterson>Next slide.

743
01:26:08.270 --> 01:26:15.588
<v Christian Peterson>The last graph here is the— sorry, this last graph is the formatted places of all the previous graphs together.

744
01:26:15.832 --> 01:26:20.992
<v Christian Peterson>It highlights the reasons for optimism that although we have less officers available by at least 11%.

745
01:26:21.521 --> 01:26:22.438
<v Christian Peterson>We are still doing more.

746
01:26:22.871 --> 01:26:25.875
<v Christian Peterson>We're responding to more community calls for service, and we are being more proactive.

747
01:26:26.501 --> 01:26:33.583
<v Christian Peterson>Although— however, although there is reason for optimism, we are still not reaching previous heights in community-generated calls for service.

748
01:26:33.953 --> 01:26:41.760
<v Christian Peterson>So again, I want to look for insights, and so I focus on the high-water mark of 2017-18 versus last fiscal year.

749
01:26:42.001 --> 01:26:42.466
<v Christian Peterson>Next slide.

750
01:26:45.462 --> 01:26:53.019
<v Christian Peterson>So the first thing I want to do here on this page is to provide some clarity on the 2 graphs, and I apologize ahead of time, there's a lot going on here.

751
01:26:53.840 --> 01:26:59.475
<v Christian Peterson>These graphs represent only the top 10 Priority 1 calls for service in each of the indicated fiscal years.

752
01:26:59.989 --> 01:27:06.818
<v Christian Peterson>They are activities occurring— Priority 1 are activities that are occurring and imminent danger incidents.

753
01:27:08.387 --> 01:27:12.015
<v Christian Peterson>I believe there was a handout that was provided that translates each of these call types.

754
01:27:12.350 --> 01:27:14.600
<v Christian Peterson>However, I want to provide some additional clarity.

755
01:27:14.975 --> 01:27:17.944
<v Christian Peterson>The W behind these call types indicate a weapon was involved.

756
01:27:19.279 --> 01:27:22.502
<v Christian Peterson>The bar graph depicts the volume of calls represented by the Portland Police Bureau.

757
01:27:23.324 --> 01:27:27.273
<v Christian Peterson>The line graph indicates the number of officers on average responding to this type of incident.

758
01:27:28.020 --> 01:27:41.713
<v Christian Peterson>Before we get into the specific call types, I want to highlight this one insight: all Priority 1 dispatch calls for service have increased by almost 1,000 calls in fiscal year '25-'26 compared to fiscal year 2017-2018.

759
01:27:42.534 --> 01:27:43.597
<v Christian Peterson>That's an increase in over 20%.

760
01:27:44.805 --> 01:27:48.878
<v Christian Peterson>So although calls for service are down, Priority 1 calls are up.

761
01:27:49.280 --> 01:27:52.260
<v Christian Peterson>Now let's focus on a few specific call types.

762
01:27:52.355 --> 01:27:57.475
<v Christian Peterson>The last 3 call types in fiscal year '17-'18 of the top 10.

763
01:27:58.070 --> 01:28:03.814
<v Christian Peterson>We're going to jump into the first one, Shoot W. The first call type is shooting with a weapon.

764
01:28:04.253 --> 01:28:04.921
<v Christian Peterson>We have all seen the rise—.

765
01:28:04.921 --> 01:28:05.213
<v Loretta Smith>Excuse me, sir.

766
01:28:05.832 --> 01:28:06.761
<v Steve Novick>Can I just interrupt?

767
01:28:06.858 --> 01:28:08.074
<v Steve Novick>Can you go back to that slide?

768
01:28:08.619 --> 01:28:15.381
<v Steve Novick>Just explain what the numbers mean, like in the last— what, what 7.4 jumps up to 14.8?

769
01:28:15.605 --> 01:28:16.182
<v Steve Novick>What does that mean?

770
01:28:16.631 --> 01:28:20.541
<v Christian Peterson>So that's exactly what I'm going to be, be following through and explaining on each one, each one of these.

771
01:28:20.636 --> 01:28:33.679
<v Christian Peterson>So the, the bar graph, like I said, is the frequency count of the number of incidents that occurred for, for that specific call type, and the line graph is the average number of people that are, uh, officers that are responding to each one of those calls.

772
01:28:33.855 --> 01:28:35.604
<v Christian Peterson>In the 2 fiscal year comparisons.

773
01:28:35.877 --> 01:28:38.380
<v Christian Peterson>And then I'm going to highlight that specifically with 3 call types.

774
01:28:39.069 --> 01:28:39.407
<v Christian Peterson>Thank you.

775
01:28:39.487 --> 01:28:44.733
<v Steve Novick>You're way over 15 minutes, um, so we're going to give some more time to the second presenters as well.

776
01:28:46.208 --> 01:28:47.395
<v Christian Peterson>Sorry, I apologize.

777
01:28:47.845 --> 01:28:48.760
<v Sameer Kanal>Go ahead.

778
01:28:49.257 --> 01:28:50.926
<v Christian Peterson>Uh, the first call type is shooting with a weapon.

779
01:28:51.118 --> 01:28:54.936
<v Christian Peterson>We have all seen a rise in gun violence that thankfully is going down in recent years.

780
01:28:55.128 --> 01:29:05.534
<v Christian Peterson>However, the number of shootings with a weapon call type has almost doubled, increased by 78 calls Uh, in these 2 comparisons, the number of personnel responding to this has also increased by 2 officers on average.

781
01:29:06.033 --> 01:29:10.266
<v Christian Peterson>This increase is directly correlated to examples that Lieutenant Butcher just provided.

782
01:29:11.850 --> 01:29:13.466
<v Christian Peterson>The next example is stabbing with a weapon.

783
01:29:13.644 --> 01:29:20.546
<v Christian Peterson>This call type, much like shootings, have increased, although at a lower scale, increasing by 28 incidents and roughly 29%.

784
01:29:20.917 --> 01:29:27.172
<v Christian Peterson>The big difference here is the increase in personnel responding to this— these incidents, on average increasing by 3.6 officers per call.

785
01:29:27.238 --> 01:29:27.496
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

786
01:29:28.552 --> 01:29:36.729
<v Christian Peterson>The final call type I'm going to highlight is suicide and web— with a weapon, and compared with enhanced crisis intervention team with a weapon call types.

787
01:29:37.033 --> 01:29:41.025
<v Christian Peterson>First, I want to acknowledge these call types are not an apple-to-apple comparison.

788
01:29:41.474 --> 01:29:45.675
<v Christian Peterson>The ECITW call type didn't exist in 2017-2018.

789
01:29:45.947 --> 01:29:53.208
<v Christian Peterson>This call type came out of the DOJ settlement and is supposed to have an enhanced crisis intervention team officer responding.

790
01:29:53.626 --> 01:29:55.663
<v Christian Peterson>These officers have more training than other officers.

791
01:29:56.050 --> 01:30:04.457
<v Christian Peterson>The ECIT call type, although is a, is a high acuity incident that involves a weapon, it may not involve someone attempting suicide.

792
01:30:04.859 --> 01:30:10.539
<v Christian Peterson>These call types have seen a slight decrease in the number of officers that are responding on average.

793
01:30:11.518 --> 01:30:20.680
<v Christian Peterson>However, there has been a 3 times increase in the number, 350 more of these types of calls this last fiscal year compared to the suicide W calls.

794
01:30:20.729 --> 01:30:20.824
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

795
01:30:21.162 --> 01:30:22.944
<v Christian Peterson>In 2017-2018.

796
01:30:23.314 --> 01:30:25.626
<v Christian Peterson>And I know I'm— we're already over our time, so I apologize.

797
01:30:26.060 --> 01:30:26.590
<v Christian Peterson>Next slide.

798
01:30:27.247 --> 01:30:29.801
<v Christian Peterson>Finally, I want to end with both insights and optimism.

799
01:30:29.993 --> 01:30:37.507
<v Christian Peterson>The PPB is going to more Priority 1 calls for service with less officers, with more requirements, while still prioritizing life in the community.

800
01:30:37.860 --> 01:30:52.103
<v Christian Peterson>These insights show that calls that have potentially higher complexity are on the rise, and although we have less resources available, the PPB is still striving thank you.

801
01:30:59.039 --> 01:31:05.378
<v Steve Novick>Can we, um, let's see, let's, let's hold questions for everybody until after both presentations.

802
01:31:06.996 --> 01:31:10.657
<v Steve Novick>Um, uh, do we have the Portland for All folks ready to present?

803
01:31:14.048 --> 01:31:15.956
<v Andres Oswalt>Yep, this is Andres from Portland for All.

804
01:31:17.333 --> 01:31:18.984
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, thank you, Andres, for being here.

805
01:31:19.256 --> 01:31:24.849
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to be attempting to share my screen, and if I don't, I've heard that we have backup.

806
01:31:24.976 --> 01:31:30.168
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you, um, and bear with me because technology is not my strong suit.

807
01:31:30.649 --> 01:31:32.461
<v Loretta Smith>Point of order, um, Mr. Chairman.

808
01:31:33.597 --> 01:31:34.944
<v Loretta Smith>Um, this is Councilor Smith.

809
01:31:36.403 --> 01:31:47.505
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not sure we have a Portland for All panel about our, uh, response time.

810
01:31:47.618 --> 01:31:56.548
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not sure why is the political action committee— why is the political action committee, um, actually up here giving a presentation?

811
01:31:57.181 --> 01:31:58.182
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not clear about that.

812
01:31:59.345 --> 01:32:00.087
<v Loretta Smith>We didn't have—.

813
01:32:00.087 --> 01:32:00.167
<v Loretta Smith>Well—.

814
01:32:00.167 --> 01:32:09.382
<v Loretta Smith>There was a, there was a press conference last week with the pastors, the Black pastors and no one brought that up, and they had concerns about this same report.

815
01:32:10.122 --> 01:32:16.954
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm, I'm not understanding why we have a political action committee talking about this.

816
01:32:17.020 --> 01:32:19.444
<v Loretta Smith>We should be talking to our public safety folks.

817
01:32:19.859 --> 01:32:23.630
<v Loretta Smith>We should be talking to our police unions about this.

818
01:32:23.775 --> 01:32:25.021
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not understanding this.

819
01:32:27.220 --> 01:32:28.884
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Morillo, these were your invitees.

820
01:32:28.984 --> 01:32:29.666
<v Steve Novick>Do you want to respond to that?

821
01:32:31.318 --> 01:32:33.690
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you, Councilor Smith, for bringing that up.

822
01:32:33.770 --> 01:32:38.838
<v Unidentified speaker>So, you know, the police did their analysis and gave us a report.

823
01:32:39.323 --> 01:32:48.637
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a community analysis that was done based on volunteer time, so there is not a conflict of interest.

824
01:32:48.766 --> 01:32:57.942
<v Unidentified speaker>We've had a lot of different people come and present before us who do endorsements, who engage in political work, and this is not well, I'm—.

825
01:32:57.974 --> 01:33:01.036
<v Loretta Smith>Can I answer her?

826
01:33:01.404 --> 01:33:08.331
<v Loretta Smith>I, I'm concerned because Andres came as Andres Aswell with Portland for All.

827
01:33:08.378 --> 01:33:09.661
<v Loretta Smith>He didn't come as himself.

828
01:33:10.238 --> 01:33:13.621
<v Loretta Smith>And if he would have come as himself, then I would have thought, okay, he's a community member.

829
01:33:13.685 --> 01:33:17.292
<v Loretta Smith>But he came as a political action committee, and I have a problem with that.

830
01:33:17.756 --> 01:33:35.529
<v Loretta Smith>And I think there is a conflict of interest, particularly if Andres Oswalt is, is a consultant for any of our, um, for any of our council members, if he is a consultant for any ballot measures that, that are up right now, this is highly inappropriate.

831
01:33:40.735 --> 01:33:43.140
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, um, Andres, I see you've unmuted yourself.

832
01:33:43.237 --> 01:33:46.786
<v Unidentified speaker>Would you like the opportunity to address any of that or clarify?

833
01:33:46.850 --> 01:33:50.635
<v Unidentified speaker>I think there's been some misinformation about your role here at the city.

834
01:33:51.373 --> 01:34:04.327
<v Unidentified speaker>Although I will again emphasize that at other committees, we've had plenty of people show up to testify and present who are involved in endorsement processes, involved in independent expenditures, and this has never come up as an issue.

835
01:34:04.470 --> 01:34:05.851
<v Unidentified speaker>So Andres, I'll pass it to you.

836
01:34:06.814 --> 01:34:11.582
<v Andres Oswalt>Of course, happy to respond and happy to respect the decision of the chair and the committee.

837
01:34:12.416 --> 01:34:14.984
<v Andres Oswalt>For the record, my name is Andres Oswalt.

838
01:34:15.064 --> 01:34:17.038
<v Andres Oswalt>I use he, they, and el pronouns.

839
01:34:17.881 --> 01:34:22.369
<v Andres Oswalt>I'm a volunteer board member and registered lobbyist for Portland for All.

840
01:34:23.127 --> 01:34:24.548
<v Andres Oswalt>Portland for All is a 501.

841
01:34:25.537 --> 01:34:31.716
<v Andres Oswalt>It has a separate political action committee, but I'm here today representing the volunteer organization that is a .

842
01:34:33.614 --> 01:34:45.216
<v Andres Oswalt>We are made up entirely of volunteers, and in a city as small as Portland, people wear lots of different hats, and we are clear that when we are here in our Portland for All roles, we are only wearing that.

843
01:34:46.930 --> 01:34:53.417
<v Andres Oswalt>For the record, I am not working on any ballot measures or with any political candidates for the City of Portland this election cycle.

844
01:34:54.637 --> 01:34:57.399
<v Andres Oswalt>And the work was done as Portland for All.

845
01:34:57.528 --> 01:35:03.212
<v Andres Oswalt>Volunteers from Portland for All did the data scraping, have done some of the analysis and the presentation.

846
01:35:03.340 --> 01:35:10.694
<v Andres Oswalt>And so in honor of the work done under the name Portland for All, that was the kind of like hat to wear in this.

847
01:35:10.742 --> 01:35:10.998
<v Andres Oswalt>Thank you.

848
01:35:11.079 --> 01:35:36.465
<v Andres Oswalt>Space, um, and we are not here to push an agenda, but we're here to share some of the data analysis that we did with the publicly available information in response to community members being really concerned about response times, uh, and to just share some of how far we got in what we were able to access, uh, to make sure that council has that information and can then continue their conversations as they explore this important issue.

849
01:35:37.773 --> 01:35:38.112
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

850
01:35:39.972 --> 01:35:40.311
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

851
01:35:41.331 --> 01:35:41.913
<v Steve Novick>Please proceed.

852
01:35:44.096 --> 01:35:44.291
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

853
01:35:45.940 --> 01:35:49.295
<v Andres Oswalt>Um, I think Councilor Murillo is trying to share slides.

854
01:35:51.028 --> 01:35:54.354
<v Andres Oswalt>Um, I'll wait to see if we can get that.

855
01:35:55.653 --> 01:35:56.935
<v Andres Oswalt>You're sharing your entire screen.

856
01:35:57.600 --> 01:35:57.844
<v Unidentified speaker>I know.

857
01:35:58.346 --> 01:35:58.688
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, well.

858
01:36:04.725 --> 01:36:06.282
<v Andres Oswalt>And appreciate all of your patience.

859
01:36:06.828 --> 01:36:21.520
<v Andres Oswalt>We did our best to meet the timeline, but coming back from council recess and making sure we understood kind of how we could best help today, we missed the deadline for the clerk, and so have Councilor Murillo sharing slides for us.

860
01:36:21.680 --> 01:36:23.301
<v Andres Oswalt>Thank you.

861
01:36:28.810 --> 01:36:29.226
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

862
01:36:29.788 --> 01:36:30.399
<v Andres Oswalt>We can work with this.

863
01:36:30.623 --> 01:36:32.920
<v Andres Oswalt>So I'll go ahead and start.

864
01:36:34.109 --> 01:36:38.475
<v Andres Oswalt>Again, Andres Azuel, volunteer board member and one of the lobbyists for Portland for All.

865
01:36:39.583 --> 01:36:41.333
<v Andres Oswalt>In my work, I'm a policy wonk.

866
01:36:41.671 --> 01:36:46.552
<v Andres Oswalt>So my role as part of our team is to help make meaning and communicate what we found in our work.

867
01:36:46.890 --> 01:36:48.431
<v Andres Oswalt>I am not a data scientist.

868
01:36:48.479 --> 01:36:49.411
<v Andres Oswalt>I want to be clear about that.

869
01:36:50.020 --> 01:36:55.577
<v Andres Oswalt>I do have Thomas Cavanaugh, another Portland for All volunteer who led our data work on this call.

870
01:36:55.721 --> 01:37:07.282
<v Andres Oswalt>If there are data-specific questions that I can't field, and I wanted to start by thanking Thomas and Nikhara, another volunteer, for the hours of work and their patience during the months that we've been working on this.

871
01:37:08.390 --> 01:37:13.063
<v Andres Oswalt>I think as we frame the conversation, we're really starting from a place of shared desire.

872
01:37:13.222 --> 01:37:17.734
<v Andres Oswalt>We all agree that Portlanders deserve faster police response times.

873
01:37:18.360 --> 01:37:29.712
<v Andres Oswalt>We followed the growing response time delays along with the general public, watching with concern as the amount of time it takes to reliably respond to an emergency call grew without a clear explanation of why.

874
01:37:30.707 --> 01:37:36.698
<v Andres Oswalt>We've known that staffing has been the go-to answers for response times, and we wanted to check if that matched the data.

875
01:37:37.449 --> 01:37:46.347
<v Andres Oswalt>So our team spent hours reviewing the publicly available data from the Police Bureau to try to understand why response times have been skyrocketing over the past years.

876
01:37:47.090 --> 01:37:47.476
<v Andres Oswalt>Next slide.

877
01:37:51.637 --> 01:37:56.960
<v Andres Oswalt>So in terms of our methodology, we used Portland Police Bureau data whenever it was publicly available.

878
01:37:57.612 --> 01:38:02.259
<v Andres Oswalt>There were some times we had to supplement that with news coverage that cited bureau statements and reports.

879
01:38:03.123 --> 01:38:12.930
<v Andres Oswalt>And we were mainly focused on call volume, officer staffing levels, both sworn and unsworn, and response time, though we did look at some other datasets.

880
01:38:12.994 --> 01:38:20.172
<v Andres Oswalt>Something that's important to note is that we used P90 response time, not averages.

881
01:38:21.103 --> 01:38:24.259
<v Andres Oswalt>So this is consistent with how fire measures response times.

882
01:38:24.452 --> 01:38:29.958
<v Andres Oswalt>And it uses the amount of time that 9 out of 10 calls have to wait for a response to their emergency.

883
01:38:30.698 --> 01:38:38.662
<v Andres Oswalt>It's a common emergency response metric because it is so critical that help arrives quickly when lives are at stake.

884
01:38:39.385 --> 01:38:41.247
<v Andres Oswalt>So that is just the context.

885
01:38:41.310 --> 01:38:47.461
<v Andres Oswalt>And in each of the slides, there's more reference to the data we use to try to show our work and help folks follow along.

886
01:38:48.457 --> 01:38:48.905
<v Andres Oswalt>Next slide.

887
01:38:51.007 --> 01:38:57.070
<v Andres Oswalt>So the first piece that we saw that I think now everyone's very familiar with is that call volume overall has been going down.

888
01:38:57.761 --> 01:38:59.461
<v Andres Oswalt>We know that crime is going down.

889
01:39:00.310 --> 01:39:06.774
<v Andres Oswalt>And what we're seeing in this chart is columns for each of the year and the total count of dispatch calls to police for that year.

890
01:39:08.105 --> 01:39:18.418
<v Andres Oswalt>And we've seen a consistent decline over the past 6 years, which at the beginning of this conversation was surprising given that response time has been growing so much.

891
01:39:18.952 --> 01:39:19.356
<v Loretta Smith>Next slide.

892
01:39:22.417 --> 01:39:28.047
<v Andres Oswalt>So the next thing we looked at is that the trend becomes more stark when we're just looking at high priority calls.

893
01:39:28.806 --> 01:39:30.921
<v Andres Oswalt>They have decreased more significantly.

894
01:39:31.954 --> 01:39:35.311
<v Andres Oswalt>So what you're seeing here is only looking at high priority calls.

895
01:39:35.747 --> 01:39:36.457
<v Andres Oswalt>Those are the bars.

896
01:39:37.118 --> 01:39:42.381
<v Andres Oswalt>And then the line is it's layering in the wait time for the average for each call.

897
01:39:43.783 --> 01:39:47.917
<v Andres Oswalt>So it mirrors national trends that have shown that crime has continued to decrease.

898
01:39:48.301 --> 01:39:53.086
<v Andres Oswalt>Across the board, Portland is seeing less crime and having fewer calls come in.

899
01:39:53.618 --> 01:40:00.104
<v Andres Oswalt>But paradoxically, the amount of time it takes for Portlanders to receive a response to a high-priority call has continued to rise.

900
01:40:01.670 --> 01:40:01.880
<v Andres Oswalt>Next slide.

901
01:40:04.534 --> 01:40:13.207
<v Andres Oswalt>So then, starting in 2019, we looked at both all levels of calls coming in, total officer staff levels, and response times together.

902
01:40:13.988 --> 01:40:15.130
<v Andres Oswalt>So there's a few lines here.

903
01:40:15.659 --> 01:40:20.368
<v Andres Oswalt>In blue, you have the officer staffing levels down at the bottom.

904
01:40:21.203 --> 01:40:25.283
<v Andres Oswalt>In gray underneath that, you'll see the call volume.

905
01:40:26.368 --> 01:40:30.753
<v Andres Oswalt>And then the purple line shows the call per officer ratio.

906
01:40:32.314 --> 01:40:37.878
<v Andres Oswalt>The last line here in orange shows response times during that same period of time.

907
01:40:38.945 --> 01:40:42.663
<v Andres Oswalt>And so what we've seen is we know there have been fluctuations in staffing.

908
01:40:42.782 --> 01:40:43.452
<v Andres Oswalt>We know that calls have decreased.

909
01:40:45.304 --> 01:40:52.056
<v Andres Oswalt>But after the dip in 2020, staffing levels for officers have been relatively stable.

910
01:40:52.265 --> 01:40:58.394
<v Andres Oswalt>And during that same period of time, we could see that the calls per officer also remained pretty steady.

911
01:40:59.323 --> 01:41:04.216
<v Andres Oswalt>But that's the same period of time where call response time starts to grow and grows drastically.

912
01:41:04.873 --> 01:41:11.257
<v Andres Oswalt>And it kept growing even as the total number of calls went down, even as the calls per officer ratio held steady.

913
01:41:11.371 --> 01:41:11.658
<v Christy Butcher>Thank you.

914
01:41:12.399 --> 01:41:22.046
<v Andres Oswalt>So what we're seeing in this chart is that staffing and call volume alone cannot explain the continuous and concerning rise in longer and longer response times.

915
01:41:22.627 --> 01:41:28.898
<v Andres Oswalt>And I think this was really like the thing that we found when we dug into the data that was both surprising and concerning.

916
01:41:30.307 --> 01:41:30.819
<v Andres Oswalt>Next slide.

917
01:41:30.868 --> 01:41:32.963
<v Andres Oswalt>We looked at a couple more things just for context.

918
01:41:35.399 --> 01:41:37.386
<v Andres Oswalt>So one of the things we looked at was precincts.

919
01:41:39.765 --> 01:41:42.570
<v Andres Oswalt>To see what else we could learn from the publicly available data.

920
01:41:43.676 --> 01:41:53.889
<v Andres Oswalt>Unsurprisingly, one of the things we saw is that this slowdown was most impactful in East Portland, where we've seen the highest increase in delays for response times.

921
01:41:53.953 --> 01:42:02.385
<v Andres Oswalt>We did see longer delays for all of the precincts, but we did want to call out specifically that that concern has been more significant in East Portland.

922
01:42:03.122 --> 01:42:03.618
<v Andres Oswalt>Next slide.

923
01:42:08.305 --> 01:42:12.668
<v Andres Oswalt>We also see that the cost that Portlanders are paying for a call has grown.

924
01:42:13.118 --> 01:42:23.500
<v Andres Oswalt>So when we looked at the total budget for the Portland Police Bureau and divided it by the number of calls that are coming in, we can see that the cost per call has continued to grow each year.

925
01:42:24.350 --> 01:42:31.250
<v Andres Oswalt>And then at the bottom is just a pullout of the response time for high priority calls, which, like we've mentioned, has seen a consistent increase.

926
01:42:31.314 --> 01:42:31.635
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

927
01:42:36.069 --> 01:42:36.606
<v Loretta Smith>Next slide.

928
01:42:38.592 --> 01:42:45.399
<v Andres Oswalt>So the last insight, and again, one of our biggest limitations is just data we could access that we could find publicly and reputably.

929
01:42:46.377 --> 01:42:58.613
<v Andres Oswalt>But the last insight that we found and a potential hint on where to go next in the conversation and in understanding why response times have grown is this is showing what happens after a call has been answered and assigned for police response.

930
01:42:58.978 --> 01:43:01.399
<v Andres Oswalt>So there's 2 pieces in here.

931
01:43:01.768 --> 01:43:13.747
<v Andres Oswalt>The blue is travel time, so the amount of time it takes for an officer to head to a call, and the red is the time spent waiting for an officer to respond before they actually go to a call.

932
01:43:14.677 --> 01:43:19.457
<v Andres Oswalt>So travel time, the blue, how long it takes them to get to a site, has increased modestly.

933
01:43:20.033 --> 01:43:22.295
<v Andres Oswalt>But what we've seen balloon is queue time.

934
01:43:22.680 --> 01:43:24.908
<v Andres Oswalt>So this is after 911 has answered a call.

935
01:43:24.972 --> 01:43:25.069
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

936
01:43:25.279 --> 01:43:26.751
<v Andres Oswalt>Assigned it for police response.

937
01:43:27.430 --> 01:43:33.756
<v Andres Oswalt>This is the time that calls are waiting in that queue for officer response before an officer is actually on their way to a call.

938
01:43:36.112 --> 01:43:36.530
<v Andres Oswalt>Next slide.

939
01:43:39.817 --> 01:43:45.202
<v Andres Oswalt>And that is unfortunately is as far as we were able to get as volunteers with publicly available information.

940
01:43:46.027 --> 01:43:55.046
<v Andres Oswalt>So why we're here today and what we've been focusing on in our advocacy is wanting city leaders to really take a hard look at the data and determine what's going on based off of that data and facts.

941
01:43:57.212 --> 01:43:58.400
<v Andres Oswalt>This is not political.

942
01:43:58.979 --> 01:44:05.095
<v Andres Oswalt>This is about ensuring that each Portlander has a timely and appropriate response during one of the worst moments of their life.

943
01:44:06.203 --> 01:44:12.047
<v Andres Oswalt>And so our role today, and why I'm here today, is really to ask the council and auditor to dig deeper.

944
01:44:12.947 --> 01:44:24.154
<v Andres Oswalt>We've done what we can as volunteers cobbling together the data we have access to, but we're asking for council and the auditor to use their position to really dig and find real answers to these questions.

945
01:44:24.363 --> 01:44:25.310
<v Andres Oswalt>So the first one is.

946
01:44:25.359 --> 01:44:25.502
<v Christian Peterson>Thank you.

947
01:44:26.096 --> 01:44:35.442
<v Andres Oswalt>Despite our best efforts, we really can't definitively answer why we've seen a meaningful number of calls have to wait longer and longer for police responses.

948
01:44:36.051 --> 01:44:40.740
<v Andres Oswalt>There could be data that we don't have access to that could help answer that.

949
01:44:40.885 --> 01:44:45.301
<v Andres Oswalt>And as our city's elected officials, you have the ability to access information that we can't.

950
01:44:46.039 --> 01:44:50.663
<v Andres Oswalt>So we're asking for you to try to find the root causes to the call response crisis.

951
01:44:51.242 --> 01:44:59.744
<v Andres Oswalt>And address it not with politically expedient solutions, but with interventions that really address the specific roots that are causing those growing delays year over year.

952
01:45:01.109 --> 01:45:07.462
<v Andres Oswalt>The next thing that came up for us is we had a lot of questions that came up as we dug into the data and found what we could.

953
01:45:08.152 --> 01:45:16.878
<v Andres Oswalt>One we didn't have enough information to answer is if there's something about absenteeism or officers covering each other's shifts that's contributing to longer responses.

954
01:45:17.472 --> 01:45:23.431
<v Andres Oswalt>We didn't have fully satisfying data on this, but it's one of the questions we'd like to see the city explore further.

955
01:45:24.925 --> 01:45:28.185
<v Andres Oswalt>And then the last is really just a big question for the CAPS Committee as a whole.

956
01:45:28.956 --> 01:45:33.548
<v Andres Oswalt>You are tasked with setting up the policy direction for our city's emergency response system.

957
01:45:34.319 --> 01:45:41.128
<v Andres Oswalt>And there's a systems-level question here about how the city prioritizes our emergency responders' time across various activities.

958
01:45:42.140 --> 01:45:46.396
<v Andres Oswalt>The data we have doesn't allow us to understand how police officers' time is spent.

959
01:45:47.037 --> 01:45:49.603
<v Andres Oswalt>Or other factors that could influence response time.

960
01:45:50.453 --> 01:46:01.016
<v Andres Oswalt>And Portland for All believes that it's critical for calls to be sent to the appropriate responder and that police time really be reserved for calls that they are best suited to respond to.

961
01:46:02.011 --> 01:46:10.603
<v Andres Oswalt>That means prioritizing non-emergency calls to unarmed responders like Portland Street Response and ensuring that we're using officer time for the most appropriate responses.

962
01:46:11.948 --> 01:46:14.402
<v Andres Oswalt>So this is the end of our part of the presentation.

963
01:46:14.755 --> 01:46:18.088
<v Andres Oswalt>We think it's really critical to get to the bottom of why response times have been so long.

964
01:46:18.153 --> 01:46:18.313
<v Andres Oswalt>Thank you.

965
01:46:19.213 --> 01:46:22.668
<v Andres Oswalt>Skyrocketing based off of the police data that we were able to access.

966
01:46:22.796 --> 01:46:25.658
<v Andres Oswalt>It can't be attributed to staffing levels alone.

967
01:46:26.332 --> 01:46:29.859
<v Andres Oswalt>And so we're asking you to do the work to continue the conversation.

968
01:46:30.733 --> 01:46:31.822
<v Andres Oswalt>And thank you for your time today.

969
01:46:34.287 --> 01:46:34.625
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

970
01:46:34.706 --> 01:46:35.332
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

971
01:46:36.876 --> 01:46:37.421
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

972
01:46:38.805 --> 01:46:47.534
<v Loretta Smith>DCA Lee, um, there was a report that I asked for in a resolution, me and, uh, Councilor Olivia Clark.

973
01:46:48.176 --> 01:46:52.444
<v Loretta Smith>And we had a report that came from the previous DCA.

974
01:46:52.605 --> 01:46:52.750
<v Loretta Smith>You—.

975
01:46:52.750 --> 01:47:03.645
<v Loretta Smith>I know you're the acting DCA— that identifies those issues that contribute to the, um, you know, police officers not getting there in a timely fashion.

976
01:47:04.304 --> 01:47:10.145
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that, um, this, this conversation also links into that.

977
01:47:10.193 --> 01:47:17.969
<v Loretta Smith>It would have been better for us to have I think we should have that report gone through at the same time that we're having this conversation because I think it's more work.

978
01:47:18.449 --> 01:47:26.298
<v Loretta Smith>I think many of the questions that were brought up with the previous presentation can be answered in that report.

979
01:47:27.497 --> 01:47:31.426
<v Loretta Smith>It's, it's, you know, we can't keep reinventing the wheel.

980
01:47:32.778 --> 01:47:45.145
<v Loretta Smith>This council voted, I believe, 12-0 to have this report done, and we have a report back to the DCA, from the DCA, and I think that that needs to go instead of having this.

981
01:47:45.386 --> 01:47:56.212
<v Loretta Smith>This was out of order, and I think we should have had the report read and then all of these entities come together to see what, you know, they could ask the questions of, of the police.

982
01:47:56.324 --> 01:48:04.082
<v Loretta Smith>So this is— I'm thinking this is, this is not done in a timely fashion, and, and the sequencing wasn't correct.

983
01:48:04.162 --> 01:48:04.355
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

984
01:48:04.921 --> 01:48:13.194
<v Loretta Smith>And so to ask, I want to be responsive to community, and I appreciate Portland for All bringing up some of those questions.

985
01:48:13.257 --> 01:48:23.278
<v Loretta Smith>But I think that I can send you— I will send you a copy of the report, Andras, that was done by the City of Portland already so that you can look through that report.

986
01:48:23.341 --> 01:48:26.226
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know if you've seen it at all or if you've gone through it.

987
01:48:27.204 --> 01:48:28.743
<v Andres Oswalt>Thank you, Councilor.

988
01:48:28.807 --> 01:48:30.314
<v Andres Oswalt>Yeah, happy to take a closer look.

989
01:48:30.572 --> 01:48:34.168
<v Andres Oswalt>And always happy to come back to council or this committee to help further.

990
01:48:34.426 --> 01:48:34.988
<v Loretta Smith>Perfect.

991
01:48:35.068 --> 01:48:50.048
<v Loretta Smith>So I need some direction from you, CA Lee, in regards to this conversation, because, um, uh, your department did a lot of work on this over the course of a few months, um, and I think many of those questions have been answered already.

992
01:48:50.627 --> 01:49:11.404
<v Loretta Smith>And to, um, have this committee go back in and try to do something different because maybe people don't like the, um, the outcome that was brought up in the report, and if they want you to do a different report or have some different, um, different, um, ways in which we can come to those, to those answers again.

993
01:49:11.661 --> 01:49:15.417
<v Loretta Smith>But I, I, I think this is— I don't— I'm sorry, Mr. Chairman.

994
01:49:15.675 --> 01:49:26.029
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I wish you would have put this out together because it's, it's kind of It's putting us in a bad situation when we've already answered these questions.

995
01:49:27.670 --> 01:49:32.926
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith, actually, that was my intent to have them together, to have both items today.

996
01:49:34.292 --> 01:49:50.342
<v Steve Novick>I think that I didn't do enough coordination with you, and you were actually— there was a mix-up with the clerk, and we asked for 4/5 to put it back on the agenda, and you said that you needed more time, and I think that that's that's on me for not having consulted with you before it happened.

997
01:49:50.390 --> 01:50:01.868
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not sure when those conversations took place, but we have been trying to get on this agenda for the longest about that report since the beginning, and we've been pushed off and pushed back.

998
01:50:02.094 --> 01:50:08.250
<v Loretta Smith>And I had to finally release the report at my annual Coffee with the Cop and Community.

999
01:50:08.762 --> 01:50:15.783
<v Loretta Smith>So this— if you don't have the whole shebang to make the sound, which you don't just do half of the sandwich, right?

1000
01:50:16.520 --> 01:50:22.965
<v Steve Novick>So again, we had, um, we had scheduled both items for today.

1001
01:50:23.493 --> 01:50:32.599
<v Steve Novick>There was a mix-up with the clerk's office, and the report item was not formally scheduled, uh, which we learned last week.

1002
01:50:32.726 --> 01:50:38.353
<v Steve Novick>So we asked for a forfait to be able to put it back on the agenda, and we couldn't get that.

1003
01:50:38.514 --> 01:50:38.898
<v Steve Novick>So—.

1004
01:50:39.059 --> 01:50:40.372
<v Loretta Smith>When was the forfait asked for?

1005
01:50:41.546 --> 01:50:41.787
<v Steve Novick>What?

1006
01:50:42.590 --> 01:50:52.649
<v Steve Novick>To place the, um, to place the, uh, to place the report item back on the agenda, which had been inadvertently dropped through miscommunication with the clerk's office.

1007
01:50:53.018 --> 01:50:53.645
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, I'm sorry.

1008
01:50:53.774 --> 01:51:09.895
<v Loretta Smith>I'm sorry that you had miscommunication with them, um, but I didn't have any communication with anyone about doing a 4/5, uh, but I, I, but at any rate, at any rate, Mr. Chairman, You have to admit that you can't have one without the other.

1009
01:51:10.882 --> 01:51:31.981
<v Steve Novick>Well, uh, Councilor, I mean, we definitely need to straighten out what the communication was between our offices the past few days, but I do think that the Police Bureau should be prepared to answer the question of, you know, why response times are down, are down even though, even though, up even though call times are down.

1010
01:51:32.506 --> 01:51:33.247
<v Loretta Smith>You're right.

1011
01:51:34.842 --> 01:51:36.051
<v Loretta Smith>And I—.

1012
01:51:36.695 --> 01:51:41.918
<v Loretta Smith>We have the Police Bureau here, and we— I would have loved to have the chief here at a time when the chief could be here, Mr. Chairman.

1013
01:51:42.663 --> 01:51:45.608
<v Loretta Smith>Um, so I, I'm just so confused by this whole thing.

1014
01:51:45.657 --> 01:51:50.744
<v Loretta Smith>It's going to confuse the public when we're not in coordination and we're doing things out of sequence.

1015
01:51:51.582 --> 01:51:54.123
<v Unidentified speaker>Chair Novick, I— can I add some clarification?

1016
01:51:55.362 --> 01:52:04.680
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the 4/5 was requested on August 26th, I think many of us were out of the office for council closure, so I think that's what happened.

1017
01:52:04.728 --> 01:52:07.917
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't think it's a conspiracy to get one perspective over the other.

1018
01:52:08.270 --> 01:52:14.010
<v Unidentified speaker>That's why we invited the police bureau experts to come and present, and they have the fine details.

1019
01:52:14.105 --> 01:52:15.532
<v Unidentified speaker>They got a half-hour presentation.

1020
01:52:16.029 --> 01:52:21.993
<v Unidentified speaker>That's double the length that the other group was given and more time than these volunteers had to prepare.

1021
01:52:23.002 --> 01:52:34.095
<v Unidentified speaker>I would, I believe that the report that you're talking about was on the recruitment of the additional 400 officers, but I'm unclear about what other things you're referring to.

1022
01:52:34.161 --> 01:52:40.706
<v Unidentified speaker>But I would like for us to get into the substance of this, especially while we have a community member here, because they're volunteering their time.

1023
01:52:40.753 --> 01:52:43.793
<v Unidentified speaker>They're not paid to sit in committee the way that the rest of us are.

1024
01:52:46.069 --> 01:52:47.466
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1025
01:52:48.359 --> 01:53:02.657
<v Steve Novick>I would— I put myself in the queue to ask the Police Bureau the question, it seems to me that you were saying that there's certain— if I could follow it, it seems there might be 3 factors at work.

1026
01:53:03.908 --> 01:53:06.395
<v Steve Novick>1, A reduction in available staff.

1027
01:53:07.118 --> 01:53:11.805
<v Steve Novick>2, An increase in the number of calls that require more time.

1028
01:53:12.350 --> 01:53:19.139
<v Steve Novick>And 3, perhaps an increase in the amount of time that the bureau has decided to devote to particular calls.

1029
01:53:19.219 --> 01:53:19.363
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1030
01:53:19.796 --> 01:53:21.787
<v Steve Novick>Based on perhaps changes in policy.

1031
01:53:22.525 --> 01:53:34.649
<v Steve Novick>So what I kind of anticipated was that in your presentation you would say, here's the extent to which increases in response times is driven by the lack of staff.

1032
01:53:35.131 --> 01:53:41.713
<v Steve Novick>Here's the extent to which it is driven by an increase in the number of calls which require a bunch of time.

1033
01:53:42.131 --> 01:53:50.265
<v Steve Novick>And here's the extent to which the increase is driven by Police Bureau changes in policy which dedicate more staff and more time to particular types of calls.

1034
01:53:51.868 --> 01:53:56.461
<v Steve Novick>Can you provide some sort of approximation of that response today?

1035
01:53:57.746 --> 01:53:59.207
<v Brian Hughes>I can, Chair Novick.

1036
01:53:59.273 --> 01:54:01.764
<v Brian Hughes>For the record, Brian Hughes, Deputy Chief of the Portland Police Bureau.

1037
01:54:03.002 --> 01:54:06.248
<v Brian Hughes>I appreciate the chance to come up and answer some of those questions.

1038
01:54:07.190 --> 01:54:18.399
<v Brian Hughes>And first, I'd like to highlight that the previous presentation where we talked about, or where The Portland for All spoke about priority call response and high priority calls.

1039
01:54:19.137 --> 01:54:24.051
<v Brian Hughes>That, I believe, is the priorities 1, 2, and 3 put together.

1040
01:54:24.838 --> 01:54:33.300
<v Brian Hughes>And we broke it down into just the priority 1 analysis as those call types that were up there with the weapon involved are the most serious calls we respond to.

1041
01:54:34.311 --> 01:54:37.490
<v Brian Hughes>And we classify priority 1 calls as a danger to life right now.

1042
01:54:38.502 --> 01:54:42.845
<v Brian Hughes>The other 2 categories, priority 2, is someone could get hurt.

1043
01:54:43.134 --> 01:54:46.180
<v Brian Hughes>That's the metric used for that call priority.

1044
01:54:46.275 --> 01:54:50.747
<v Brian Hughes>And then priority 3 is a crime happening now with no immediate threat to life.

1045
01:54:50.939 --> 01:54:54.578
<v Brian Hughes>So those are all 3 put together for high priority calls.

1046
01:54:54.690 --> 01:55:01.792
<v Brian Hughes>And when we break out the priority 1, I think it gives you a better idea of the more serious nature of the calls we respond to.

1047
01:55:01.887 --> 01:55:05.878
<v Brian Hughes>And it does show an increase in the priority 1 calls only when you look at that metric.

1048
01:55:06.552 --> 01:55:15.461
<v Brian Hughes>It's a 23.4% increase from fiscal year 2017 to 2018 to the previous fiscal year.

1049
01:55:16.182 --> 01:55:31.798
<v Brian Hughes>And as we mentioned in our presentation, those calls are requiring more officers to respond to in order to de-escalate and do everything we can to prioritize life safety and resolve those calls safely.

1050
01:55:32.954 --> 01:55:34.672
<v Brian Hughes>So that's one area I wanted to highlight.

1051
01:55:35.266 --> 01:55:42.313
<v Brian Hughes>The other area I want to talk about is the nature of the calls that we've been responding to since 2020.

1052
01:55:42.521 --> 01:55:46.005
<v Brian Hughes>I think it's no secret here, and you can look at our open data dashboard.

1053
01:55:46.054 --> 01:55:50.579
<v Brian Hughes>I'm told that we're one of the most transparent agencies with regard to data in the country.

1054
01:55:51.399 --> 01:55:54.913
<v Brian Hughes>And on the dashboard, you can see a pretty significant increase in homicides.

1055
01:55:55.989 --> 01:55:59.231
<v Brian Hughes>Many of you were here during the period of 2020 and '21 and '22.

1056
01:55:59.922 --> 01:56:13.122
<v Brian Hughes>When that number spiked and the actual number tripled in the city of Portland without a matching response or increase in police staff to handle those calls.

1057
01:56:13.871 --> 01:56:31.012
<v Brian Hughes>And for all of those homicides, those require, as the lieutenant mentioned, officers on scene to contain the crime scene, officers on scene to investigate, and then at times officers from the Special Emergency Reaction Team to go and capture those responsible for those homicides.

1058
01:56:31.690 --> 01:56:33.546
<v Brian Hughes>And it's ongoing work that continues today.

1059
01:56:34.890 --> 01:56:43.733
<v Brian Hughes>So there are significant increases on the demand for police nowadays versus 10 years ago, and I want to highlight that.

1060
01:56:44.265 --> 01:56:49.019
<v Brian Hughes>I also want to point out that the number of officers we have available to respond today is actually less.

1061
01:56:49.617 --> 01:56:53.690
<v Brian Hughes>We lost a significant amount of officers in 2020 and 2021 and have been building back.

1062
01:56:53.771 --> 01:56:53.885
<v Christian Peterson>Thank you.

1063
01:56:54.618 --> 01:56:57.461
<v Brian Hughes>The staffing levels under the direction of Chief Bob Day.

1064
01:56:58.408 --> 01:57:01.363
<v Brian Hughes>That results in new officers joining the force.

1065
01:57:01.845 --> 01:57:12.172
<v Brian Hughes>And when we have approximately 100 of them with field training officers or in some form of training during their 18-month probation, they're not available to answer calls for service.

1066
01:57:12.606 --> 01:57:30.306
<v Brian Hughes>So while you may see I have officers, a high officer count, 100 of those right off the top are taken away because of chief, you mentioned homicides.

1067
01:57:30.484 --> 01:57:35.569
<v Steve Novick>Homicides are down, thankfully, significantly over the past couple of years.

1068
01:57:35.666 --> 01:57:42.443
<v Steve Novick>I think right now we're on pace to have about 30 this year, and in 2022, I believe we had over 90.

1069
01:57:43.996 --> 01:57:47.237
<v Steve Novick>How much of an impact do you think the reduction in homicides might have on response times?

1070
01:57:47.287 --> 01:57:47.836
<v Steve Novick>Well, I think that's a great question.

1071
01:57:49.634 --> 01:57:50.877
<v Brian Hughes>It's just one piece of the puzzle.

1072
01:57:52.710 --> 01:58:00.768
<v Brian Hughes>The homicide reduction is, you know, I will acknowledge here on the dais that one homicide is too many for the families that have lost somebody in our community.

1073
01:58:01.488 --> 01:58:05.958
<v Brian Hughes>So whether it's one or 30, all of them are equally important to me.

1074
01:58:06.914 --> 01:58:15.796
<v Brian Hughes>But where we're not seeing a reduction is the priority one call response or calls that we receive, the calls with a weapon that were highlighted earlier.

1075
01:58:15.935 --> 01:58:24.037
<v Brian Hughes>So short answer to your question, it's one piece of the puzzle, but there are other pieces of the puzzle that are still driving call response times.

1076
01:58:25.096 --> 01:58:45.025
<v Steve Novick>Can you give an example of an event where 10 years ago you would've responded with X number of officers and expected to take Y amount of time, and now you require— now you respond with more officers, Expecting to take more time because of your commitment to de-escalation, etc.?

1077
01:58:45.493 --> 01:58:47.201
<v Steve Novick>Just sort of walk us through a hypothetical example.

1078
01:58:49.510 --> 01:58:58.126
<v Brian Hughes>Well, I've been with the Bureau almost 25 years now, very long time, grandfatherly-like, as one councilor referred to me at one point.

1079
01:58:59.622 --> 01:59:06.768
<v Brian Hughes>But back in the beginning of my career, there was not as much de-escalation used on calls for service.

1080
01:59:07.814 --> 01:59:15.618
<v Brian Hughes>And to me, that increased the likelihood that force events would occur, made it unsafer for the public, made it unsafer for our employees.

1081
01:59:16.939 --> 01:59:30.082
<v Brian Hughes>And times have changed, and we have the addition of the demonstration liaison officers that now work to de-escalate crowd control situations to the point where we haven't had to use chemical munitions in 6 years.

1082
01:59:31.859 --> 01:59:32.340
<v Steve Novick>The—.

1083
01:59:33.582 --> 01:59:35.409
<v Brian Hughes>Behavioral health aspects of this job.

1084
01:59:35.506 --> 01:59:51.423
<v Brian Hughes>I would not have thought back in 1998 when I started that we would be pairing mental health clinicians with police officers to go out to de-escalate the most vulnerable and mentally ill people that we interact with to avoid dangerous outcomes.

1085
01:59:52.018 --> 01:59:55.784
<v Brian Hughes>So things have changed considerably over time, Councilor Novick.

1086
01:59:56.024 --> 02:00:08.545
<v Brian Hughes>I think just the more intentional thank you.

1087
02:00:08.739 --> 02:00:11.219
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Morillo?

1088
02:00:11.788 --> 02:00:14.317
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick, and thanks for your answers.

1089
02:00:16.050 --> 02:00:26.029
<v Unidentified speaker>I have a few questions for you guys, and then I think one question up on methodology for Andres, just for my own knowledge, because I did not know what a P90 assessment is, and I'm very curious about it.

1090
02:00:26.128 --> 02:00:27.634
<v Unidentified speaker>So prepping you to answer that later.

1091
02:00:28.261 --> 02:00:28.701
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mayor.

1092
02:00:28.797 --> 02:00:32.585
<v Unidentified speaker>But I, I had similar questions to what Councilor Novick laid out as well.

1093
02:00:33.641 --> 02:00:43.608
<v Unidentified speaker>I would love to see a more precise breakdown of how much the additional time spent is attributable to each potential source of the increase.

1094
02:00:43.704 --> 02:00:51.430
<v Unidentified speaker>So if that's staff, increased response time to certain types of calls, which types of calls it is for and why.

1095
02:00:53.162 --> 02:01:02.567
<v Unidentified speaker>It's great to have This anecdotal discussion, and I think it paints a picture for those of us who are less technical in our knowledge, but these are very technical questions.

1096
02:01:02.663 --> 02:01:16.729
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I would want this trend to be quantified in a future report or maybe in an assessment by the auditor if we want someone who's separate from the Bureau, separate from the political scene to be doing that sort of engagement.

1097
02:01:18.894 --> 02:01:22.440
<v Unidentified speaker>And I was very curious in some of the data as well.

1098
02:01:24.890 --> 02:01:37.858
<v Unidentified speaker>It looks like CERT, which is the high-risk tactical operations, and MEDU, the explosive— dealing with explosions and bombs, I'm assuming— are the highest.

1099
02:01:38.648 --> 02:01:39.572
<v Unidentified speaker>That was really interesting to me.

1100
02:01:39.702 --> 02:01:41.436
<v Unidentified speaker>Why is that going up so much more?

1101
02:01:42.069 --> 02:01:45.198
<v Unidentified speaker>I was surprised to see those being the highest out of all the other calls that we're getting.

1102
02:01:46.444 --> 02:02:03.189
<v Brian Hughes>Well, with the Special Emergency Reaction Team, there's they're constantly going out not only on tactical calls, but the increase in shootings and injury shootings and homicides that we saw resulted in a backend work of investigators determining who did those crimes.

1103
02:02:04.007 --> 02:02:10.255
<v Brian Hughes>And in order to go safely take those people into custody, oftentimes we'll use the Special Emergency Reaction Team to do that.

1104
02:02:10.912 --> 02:02:12.872
<v Brian Hughes>So that's where you would see an increase in callouts.

1105
02:02:12.920 --> 02:02:18.342
<v Brian Hughes>That's a combination of correct me if I'm wrong, Lieutenant Butcher, warrants and callouts, is that right?

1106
02:02:22.512 --> 02:02:24.148
<v Christy Butcher>Christy Butcher, back for the record.

1107
02:02:24.373 --> 02:02:43.939
<v Christy Butcher>Um, that number that you saw on the slide is the total operations for 2025, and that includes everything from large event support, so, um, supporting like a public order event in an emergency type situation, um, all the way to the, the arrest, the search warrant service, Dignitary protection.

1108
02:02:44.131 --> 02:02:47.969
<v Christy Butcher>Oftentimes dignitaries come to Portland and they request special services.

1109
02:02:48.323 --> 02:02:50.698
<v Christy Butcher>That's what CERT provides, some of those services.

1110
02:02:51.470 --> 02:02:53.027
<v Christy Butcher>So that's the total operations.

1111
02:02:53.524 --> 02:02:58.020
<v Christy Butcher>And that's not always like a full-blown callout or a full-blown high-risk warrant service.

1112
02:02:58.341 --> 02:03:07.814
<v Christy Butcher>That can be a smaller number of CERT folks going to assist patrol on a breaching operation or rescuing a kid off a 162nd overpass.

1113
02:03:08.216 --> 02:03:10.369
<v Christy Butcher>Those are all considered CERT operations.

1114
02:03:10.948 --> 02:03:25.390
<v Christy Butcher>And additionally, for the MEDU operations, if you have some explosives that your grandfather stored in a shed and now you don't know what to do with them, MEDU gets called out to, to properly dispose of those.

1115
02:03:25.887 --> 02:03:32.860
<v Christy Butcher>And it's important to note that MEDU responds tri-countywide, including Clark County.

1116
02:03:33.198 --> 02:03:36.202
<v Christy Butcher>So that number is not just gotcha.

1117
02:03:36.346 --> 02:03:39.849
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, that's super helpful information.

1118
02:03:39.961 --> 02:03:40.604
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks for that.

1119
02:03:41.149 --> 02:03:52.024
<v Unidentified speaker>And for whoever wants to answer this, I'm not sure who the best person is to direct this to, but I'm curious about, you know, police are struggling to respond to our 911 calls.

1120
02:03:52.474 --> 02:03:54.449
<v Unidentified speaker>The call response time has gotten a lot longer.

1121
02:03:55.220 --> 02:03:58.079
<v Unidentified speaker>You're saying you're too understaffed to answer those calls.

1122
02:03:58.514 --> 02:04:12.828
<v Unidentified speaker>So how have self-initiated calls gone up if people If your team is unable to respond to 911 calls that are going through the system right now, and what types of self-initiated calls are people taking on?

1123
02:04:14.311 --> 02:04:17.408
<v Brian Hughes>Provide some context.

1124
02:04:21.500 --> 02:04:22.961
<v Christian Peterson>Hello, Christian Peterson, for the record.

1125
02:04:23.724 --> 02:04:28.238
<v Christian Peterson>The type of calls that they are taking on can range from a lot of, a lot of different types of calls.

1126
02:04:28.462 --> 02:04:32.404
<v Christian Peterson>They can be them self-initiating and doing follow-up on investigations.

1127
02:04:32.469 --> 02:04:35.996
<v Christian Peterson>Like, like earlier mentioned, homicide, you have to do a lot of follow-up.

1128
02:04:36.396 --> 02:04:47.475
<v Christian Peterson>Any kind of follow-up that— for burglary, for example, we don't— we just recently started, uh, standing up a burglary task force, but prior to that, that would all be done by officers responding and doing follow-up.

1129
02:04:47.538 --> 02:04:53.229
<v Christian Peterson>So any kind of follow-up activity, any kind of activity where we're trying to interdict crime behavior.

1130
02:04:53.310 --> 02:05:02.104
<v Christian Peterson>So if we're doing enforcement missions, walking patrols, engaging with high-crime areas, all of that would be in that bucket of self-initiated.

1131
02:05:02.153 --> 02:05:19.037
<v Christian Peterson>So the goal, and Chief Day brought this up when he first got back, was to bring back the, uh, the thought of getting out of your car and getting back and engaging with the community, being part of the community, and really focusing on trying to stop crime before it occurs.

1132
02:05:19.534 --> 02:05:22.649
<v Christian Peterson>So being, being actively engaged instead of just responding.

1133
02:05:22.729 --> 02:05:28.936
<v Christian Peterson>So therefore, by doing that, we eventually will drive down our demand and therefore be able to respond to calls faster.

1134
02:05:29.643 --> 02:05:29.914
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1135
02:05:30.140 --> 02:05:50.895
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think what I'm asking of you moving forward, and maybe you'll come back and do another presentation, is that I want to know exactly what the self-initiated calls are, because my understanding is that the top self-initiated calls tend to be traffic stops, and traffic stops tend to disproportionately impact Black Portlanders and people of color within the City of Portland.

1136
02:05:51.632 --> 02:06:00.100
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm just very curious about what the different types of self-initiated calls are when you are saying that you are unable to respond to 911 emergency crisis calls.

1137
02:06:00.195 --> 02:06:16.457
<v Unidentified speaker>We need a breakdown of that and a breakdown of which types of officers and police bureau members are answering calls, because I'm assuming that the detectives who are doing follow-up on a homicide are not the same people that are assigned to do 911 call responses.

1138
02:06:16.634 --> 02:06:20.215
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm assuming they're are going to the scene and doing other types of things, right?

1139
02:06:20.279 --> 02:06:22.721
<v Unidentified speaker>So we wouldn't be talking about the same pool of people.

1140
02:06:23.734 --> 02:06:27.703
<v Unidentified speaker>So having that breakdown is gonna be really critical in my opinion.

1141
02:06:28.618 --> 02:06:30.965
<v Unidentified speaker>Not all of the deployments are created equal.

1142
02:06:31.029 --> 02:06:34.774
<v Unidentified speaker>There are obviously different issues that impact the city differently and people differently.

1143
02:06:35.786 --> 02:06:47.201
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's one thing to say that someone like CERT is getting deployed and more, More frequently, more often, all the things, but we need to understand why.

1144
02:06:48.355 --> 02:06:52.572
<v Unidentified speaker>And they might not always be the right responders for those calls, right?

1145
02:06:52.684 --> 02:06:57.077
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's something that I'm curious about.

1146
02:06:57.909 --> 02:07:08.715
<v Unidentified speaker>Can I get any information from you, even if it's— I know this is not going to be official data because it's not in the presentation and we clearly need to do a follow-up, but can we get a breakdown of these types of deployments?

1147
02:07:09.850 --> 02:07:14.213
<v Unidentified speaker>So, um, moving forward, Councilor, we're happy to provide that to your office.

1148
02:07:15.279 --> 02:07:15.456
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1149
02:07:16.661 --> 02:07:26.002
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, yeah, I think I— yeah, I have a lot of just follow-up questions on what types of calls we're doing and why.

1150
02:07:28.188 --> 02:07:43.903
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, because it's still— maybe I'm being a simpleton about the data, but it's not mathing to me as far as our 911 calls are going down police call response times are going up, and then on top of that, self-initiated calls are going up, but we don't know what types of self-initiated calls there are.

1151
02:07:44.914 --> 02:07:53.817
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that is all very nebulous to me in a way that I'm going to need more of that data before I draw any conclusions on the types of calls.

1152
02:07:55.279 --> 02:08:01.225
<v Unidentified speaker>And now I'm going to address Andres because I had a question about methodology for the Portland for All analysis.

1153
02:08:02.300 --> 02:08:12.582
<v Unidentified speaker>If you're still online with us, I was just curious about what the P90 analysis was and if you could explain that in lay terms for us non-data experts.

1154
02:08:14.110 --> 02:08:14.882
<v Andres Oswalt>Of course, Councilor.

1155
02:08:14.996 --> 02:08:15.864
<v Andres Oswalt>Happy to do my best.

1156
02:08:16.645 --> 02:08:20.404
<v Andres Oswalt>But did want to start with first speaking to the Police Bureau presentation.

1157
02:08:20.677 --> 02:08:25.386
<v Andres Oswalt>I think the level of detail they shared today is new and really appreciated.

1158
02:08:25.563 --> 02:08:26.783
<v Andres Oswalt>We'd love to see more of it.

1159
02:08:27.716 --> 02:08:39.649
<v Andres Oswalt>Like the Police Bureau mentioned, we used high priority calls in our analysis, which mirrors the categorization in the report that Councilor Smith requested of high, medium, and low priority calls.

1160
02:08:40.323 --> 02:08:46.176
<v Andres Oswalt>And even there, you see that the response time to high priority calls in that report has continued to go up.

1161
02:08:47.523 --> 02:08:50.842
<v Andres Oswalt>We used P90, so 90th percentile.

1162
02:08:51.467 --> 02:08:59.761
<v Andres Oswalt>And so what that is saying is What amount of time are 90% of calls responded to by?

1163
02:09:00.530 --> 02:09:02.775
<v Andres Oswalt>And this comes from FHIR.

1164
02:09:02.936 --> 02:09:09.850
<v Andres Oswalt>There's a national standard that I think you're all familiar with, I believe, of FHIR calls should be responded ideally within 6.5 minutes.

1165
02:09:09.913 --> 02:09:13.346
<v Andres Oswalt>And the idea is that in an emergency, every second counts.

1166
02:09:14.005 --> 02:09:20.277
<v Andres Oswalt>And so the thought was to apply the consistent application that exists in FHIR to police with the same rationale.

1167
02:09:20.324 --> 02:09:20.501
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1168
02:09:21.207 --> 02:09:26.949
<v Andres Oswalt>Of when people are having a true emergency, when 911 dispatch is assigning a call to police.

1169
02:09:27.542 --> 02:09:31.729
<v Andres Oswalt>It's really critical that every call that is high priority be responded to quickly.

1170
02:09:31.890 --> 02:09:33.221
<v Andres Oswalt>And again, I'm using high priority.

1171
02:09:33.478 --> 02:09:39.476
<v Andres Oswalt>The actual specific level of call might be a more helpful way for this council to have the conversation.

1172
02:09:40.070 --> 02:09:50.470
<v Andres Oswalt>But the rationale and the reason we focused on P90 is because if a call truly is critical, if it is important, then A timely response has to happen consistently.

1173
02:09:50.904 --> 02:09:59.764
<v Andres Oswalt>And so using that same standard from FHIR, making sure that 90% of calls are responded to in a timely way, was the methodology that we used for tracking time.

1174
02:10:03.337 --> 02:10:04.826
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much for that clarification.

1175
02:10:05.198 --> 02:10:08.528
<v Unidentified speaker>And I see we have more hands in the queue, so I will stop talking now.

1176
02:10:08.609 --> 02:10:08.997
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1177
02:10:11.534 --> 02:10:12.247
<v Steve Novick>Sorry to interrupt.

1178
02:10:12.554 --> 02:10:13.641
<v Steve Novick>I've lost sound.

1179
02:10:13.804 --> 02:10:15.314
<v Steve Novick>Is that the system or is it me?

1180
02:10:18.902 --> 02:10:19.253
<v Unidentified speaker>It's you.

1181
02:10:19.421 --> 02:10:20.612
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you hear me saying that?

1182
02:10:23.698 --> 02:10:30.365
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, we will teams chat you, and I can take over facilitating if that's helpful.

1183
02:10:31.800 --> 02:10:33.368
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, Councilor Kanal, I see your hand is up.

1184
02:10:33.529 --> 02:10:44.208
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, while we work to get— and hopefully, uh, Councilor Novick can get the transcript, or, or at least in the interim while the sound's getting thank you, everybody, for being here.

1185
02:10:44.273 --> 02:10:45.779
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks to the presenters.

1186
02:10:48.189 --> 02:10:53.349
<v Unidentified speaker>I wanted to start with just an opinion, and this is an opinion on agenda setting.

1187
02:10:54.010 --> 02:10:58.615
<v Unidentified speaker>And I stress it's an opinion because it's not a rule, and you can only point of order a rule statement.

1188
02:10:58.698 --> 02:11:00.358
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to get that out of the way ahead of time.

1189
02:11:00.881 --> 02:11:06.225
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it's really important that we resolve the question of do we need to have staffing changes?

1190
02:11:06.306 --> 02:11:06.372
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1191
02:11:06.692 --> 02:11:10.978
<v Unidentified speaker>Before we start talking about reports on what staffing changes might require.

1192
02:11:11.572 --> 02:11:36.792
<v Unidentified speaker>And so in terms of the causality, I think this is the correct order to talk about, because if you listen through the presentation from Andres, you will see a lot of disproving of some of the assumptions that have been put forward about what staffing looks like because of that consideration being necessary before determining not only what it would take to change the staffing levels, but also what the target staffing number would be.

1193
02:11:37.659 --> 02:11:40.743
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so I, I appreciate the order that was, that was drawn here.

1194
02:11:41.354 --> 02:11:44.454
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, and that's the, uh, non-rules opinion I wanted to get out there.

1195
02:11:44.904 --> 02:11:51.136
<v Unidentified speaker>In terms of the content of this, I really appreciate, um, the content here of both presentations.

1196
02:11:51.731 --> 02:12:01.354
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the Strategic Services Division is, as, uh, Deputy Chief mentioned, one of the most transparent in the country in terms of data.

1197
02:12:01.434 --> 02:12:10.632
<v Unidentified speaker>I would love to see see that data presented here a little bit more when we continue this conversation, because there wasn't actually in the police presentation as much on the times.

1198
02:12:10.828 --> 02:12:14.104
<v Unidentified speaker>There was a lot on complexity, which I appreciate as one of the responses here.

1199
02:12:15.319 --> 02:12:16.564
<v Unidentified speaker>As we go through the, the, the—.

1200
02:12:17.048 --> 02:12:18.068
<v Steve Novick>Both presentations.

1201
02:12:18.115 --> 02:12:19.748
<v Steve Novick>Staffing conversation.

1202
02:12:20.024 --> 02:12:21.252
<v Christian Peterson>Strategic service.

1203
02:12:24.524 --> 02:12:39.975
<v Unidentified speaker>As we go through the, the conversation around staffing at the at the Police Bureau, and I mention this not to talk about desired staffing levels, but how staff is used, which is in PPB's open data staffing report and is incredibly easy to see, and I appreciate that.

1204
02:12:42.341 --> 02:12:46.078
<v Unidentified speaker>We're talking about, it talks about the number of patrol officers.

1205
02:12:46.141 --> 02:12:50.038
<v Unidentified speaker>So there's 814 sworn officers at police.

1206
02:12:50.087 --> 02:12:53.942
<v Unidentified speaker>This is directly off the website from officer up to chief.

1207
02:12:54.506 --> 02:13:00.362
<v Unidentified speaker>Of which 568 are not supervisors, investigators, specialized units, and command staff.

1208
02:13:00.779 --> 02:13:04.757
<v Unidentified speaker>And within those 568, you have 314 marked as patrol officers.

1209
02:13:05.190 --> 02:13:10.917
<v Unidentified speaker>So a lot of this has to do with how the, the organization is done, who's actually in a position to respond here.

1210
02:13:11.207 --> 02:13:28.828
<v Unidentified speaker>And that excludes the difference between the 314 and the 568 appears to be 98 officers in training, 134 officers assigned to specialized roles, That appears to be the delta between the 314 and the 568.

1211
02:13:29.326 --> 02:13:41.609
<v Unidentified speaker>So my first question is, those officers that are assigned to specialized roles, are they not also responding to some of the calls for service either as secondary support or as the case may be if they're on duty?

1212
02:13:42.427 --> 02:13:57.648
<v Unidentified speaker>I recall when I was doing both sit-alongs at BOEC, and ride-alongs, the idea that maybe there's a second support vehicle coming that might be otherwise— because otherwise, when there's no call related to that specialized role, what would they be doing?

1213
02:13:58.305 --> 02:13:59.622
<v Brian Hughes>Thank you for the question, Councilor Kanal.

1214
02:13:59.670 --> 02:14:00.569
<v Brian Hughes>Brian Hughes, for the record.

1215
02:14:00.632 --> 02:14:05.594
<v Brian Hughes>No, there— we have officers positioned in a variety of different functions in the police bureau, like training.

1216
02:14:05.721 --> 02:14:13.139
<v Brian Hughes>So I have officers right now at the training division that are administering the range for new recruits, teaching them how to use their firearm.

1217
02:14:13.475 --> 02:14:16.845
<v Brian Hughes>And that officer currently training those recruits would not be available.

1218
02:14:16.925 --> 02:14:19.332
<v Brian Hughes>That's a good analysis of that officer.

1219
02:14:19.893 --> 02:14:35.037
<v Brian Hughes>Other officers, as we have one officer assigned to community engagement, would be working towards building relationships with our different advisory communities and assisting officers in figuring out the best community events to attend.

1220
02:14:36.271 --> 02:14:52.243
<v Brian Hughes>In an emergency situation where the police bureau is Is kind of like back in 2020 with all hands on deck for a prolonged period like that, then we're able to pull all the officers in and kind of prioritize what we're gonna be able to do.

1221
02:14:53.511 --> 02:15:03.143
<v Brian Hughes>But you can see already by taking the officer away from doing the training to the new officers, that's gonna push the amount of time that that officer can hit the street out even further.

1222
02:15:03.543 --> 02:15:03.672
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure.

1223
02:15:03.720 --> 02:15:06.819
<v Brian Hughes>And we had to do some of that in 2020, but it was kind of a triaging situation.

1224
02:15:07.315 --> 02:15:07.925
<v Unidentified speaker>That makes sense.

1225
02:15:08.774 --> 02:15:18.248
<v Unidentified speaker>For like the focus intervention team, those types of units, would they be considered part of the officers assigned to specialized roles?

1226
02:15:18.875 --> 02:15:19.274
<v Brian Hughes>They would be.

1227
02:15:19.917 --> 02:15:29.262
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, and at times when a FIT officer is on duty, but there's nothing that directly relates to their particular area of focus, gun violence, right?

1228
02:15:30.081 --> 02:15:37.944
<v Unidentified speaker>If there's a call that's near the area that they are currently stationed around the city, they might be part of the response to that traditional BOEC call, right?

1229
02:15:38.024 --> 02:15:38.682
<v Brian Hughes>Sure, they could be.

1230
02:15:39.164 --> 02:15:51.061
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so that to me implies some but not all, and we can— I'd love to dig into the data as to whether it's 1 out of 134 or 133 out of 134, somewhere in between, um, are available.

1231
02:15:51.207 --> 02:15:56.296
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's helpful to know because obviously they're going to go do the, the FIT stuff when there's a call related to that.

1232
02:15:56.890 --> 02:16:11.105
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, You kind of see, if you go into the report, it talks about the number of patrol officers estimated on the street at any given moment, which obviously takes into account leave and things like that as well, and how you get to the 314 number.

1233
02:16:12.149 --> 02:16:18.757
<v Unidentified speaker>I do agree with Christian that there's cause for optimism because those 98 officers in training are working their way through the pipeline.

1234
02:16:18.805 --> 02:16:24.389
<v Unidentified speaker>There's, I believe, 69 vacancies right now, roughly, which is one of the lowest numbers we've had in years.

1235
02:16:25.319 --> 02:16:34.856
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the net is, I believe, 5 to 10 officers a quarter getting, you know, with, in terms of separations and retirements and things like that and new recruits.

1236
02:16:34.936 --> 02:16:37.233
<v Unidentified speaker>But obviously each new recruit takes time.

1237
02:16:37.826 --> 02:16:39.369
<v Unidentified speaker>So that is good news.

1238
02:16:39.433 --> 02:16:41.777
<v Unidentified speaker>And I just wanted to kind of get that all on the record here.

1239
02:16:42.708 --> 02:16:50.655
<v Unidentified speaker>With relation to self-initiated stops, are they all classified in the Priority 2 area still, or has that changed?

1240
02:16:52.662 --> 02:16:53.609
<v Brian Hughes>For self-initiated?

1241
02:16:54.027 --> 02:16:54.283
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1242
02:16:54.524 --> 02:16:55.183
<v Brian Hughes>Just stops?

1243
02:16:55.246 --> 02:16:56.050
<v Brian Hughes>Like, are we talking traffic?

1244
02:16:56.324 --> 02:16:57.463
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, calls.

1245
02:16:57.914 --> 02:16:58.908
<v Unidentified speaker>Self-initiated calls.

1246
02:16:59.503 --> 02:17:04.691
<v Brian Hughes>No, self-initiated calls can be a variety of different priorities depending on what the officer is self-initiating.

1247
02:17:05.043 --> 02:17:14.761
<v Brian Hughes>One of the things that I took a look at recently for the mayor's office was self-initiated welfare checks for— in kind of in line with his See Care Connect efforts.

1248
02:17:15.387 --> 02:17:30.802
<v Brian Hughes>And we have just in the month of August, 115 different times where officers saw a person in need and went out to take care and help that person and get resources to them, that would be prioritized as a, I think, priority 2?

1249
02:17:31.943 --> 02:17:32.522
<v Brian Hughes>Priority 2.

1250
02:17:32.986 --> 02:17:35.412
<v Brian Hughes>If that was the only thing they were doing is a welfare check.

1251
02:17:35.492 --> 02:17:44.805
<v Brian Hughes>If they see somebody walking around with a gun and the officer initiates the contact with that, that is going to be a person with a weapon call prioritized as probably a priority 1 call.

1252
02:17:45.351 --> 02:17:45.447
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1253
02:17:46.058 --> 02:17:54.173
<v Unidentified speaker>And if someone calls in a welfare check, someone has not been seen in a while, they're probably in their house, but we don't know, that would not normally be a Priority 2 call, would it?

1254
02:17:54.689 --> 02:18:00.046
<v Brian Hughes>I think it depends on the factors I mentioned earlier with what describes a Priority 1, 2, or 3.

1255
02:18:00.804 --> 02:18:07.602
<v Brian Hughes>If there's additional information that they can hear somebody inside that may be struggling, that'd probably increase the priority.

1256
02:18:08.132 --> 02:18:19.460
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so maybe to put a finer point on it, does the fact that a Um, a call, quote unquote, because it is self-initiated, does that change the priority level in and of itself?

1257
02:18:20.520 --> 02:18:21.563
<v Brian Hughes>Not in and of itself, no.

1258
02:18:21.643 --> 02:18:22.444
<v Brian Hughes>Additional factors do.

1259
02:18:22.700 --> 02:18:23.005
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1260
02:18:24.272 --> 02:18:34.635
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I, I'm not— I, I want to— I may have misheard how the SSD presentation was on this particular point.

1261
02:18:34.860 --> 02:18:40.634
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the increase in self-initiated stops, I, I don't think that was intended to be presented as a positive.

1262
02:18:41.775 --> 02:18:43.782
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not 100% sure.

1263
02:18:44.087 --> 02:18:49.516
<v Unidentified speaker>The increase in self-initiated stops seems to be one of the big factors that's contributing to the problem.

1264
02:18:49.966 --> 02:18:59.891
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, unrequested interaction that's being initiated by officers has gone pretty significantly up since the major decline in 2020.

1265
02:19:00.566 --> 02:19:03.618
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I'm not sure how that's a positive.

1266
02:19:04.019 --> 02:19:06.332
<v Unidentified speaker>I may have misheard you, so I just wanted to get that on the record.

1267
02:19:06.412 --> 02:19:15.618
<v Brian Hughes>Councilor, before before Christian talks, I want to hit some points that you just made there about characterizing what that self-initiated activity is as unwanted.

1268
02:19:16.308 --> 02:19:17.060
<v Sameer Kanal>I said unrequested.

1269
02:19:17.174 --> 02:19:18.584
<v Brian Hughes>Or unrequested, excuse me, unrequested.

1270
02:19:19.242 --> 02:19:28.719
<v Brian Hughes>A person down on the street struggling in need of care, for an officer to self-initiate that, that would go into that self-initiated category of work.

1271
02:19:29.344 --> 02:19:34.043
<v Brian Hughes>A person whose car was broken into and the officer comes back the next week to try and find out who did it, Yes.

1272
02:19:34.092 --> 02:19:36.790
<v Brian Hughes>And follow up with a business that may have surveillance footage.

1273
02:19:37.320 --> 02:19:41.449
<v Brian Hughes>It's rare that we're able to do that given our call load right now, but the officers are trying.

1274
02:19:41.962 --> 02:19:44.629
<v Brian Hughes>That would be another self-initiated call for service.

1275
02:19:45.238 --> 02:19:51.888
<v Brian Hughes>Traffic stops in high crash corridors where we're having a record number of traffic deaths, especially this year involving motorcycles.

1276
02:19:52.338 --> 02:19:57.110
<v Brian Hughes>Stopping motorcycles for dangerous driving behavior would also be initiate— a self-initiated activity.

1277
02:19:57.157 --> 02:20:18.157
<v Christian Peterson>So I just want to kind of pinpoint that it's yeah, uh, Christian Peterson, for the record, uh, no, I, I'm sorry if it came across as if I'm saying that stops because I said that all self-initiated activity was a goal and we wanted to see officers engaged.

1278
02:20:18.302 --> 02:20:26.016
<v Christian Peterson>There was a period of time post-COVID where there was, uh, a belief that, that police were being more reserved.

1279
02:20:26.537 --> 02:20:38.718
<v Christian Peterson>The goal was to engage, get out of your car, be more involved, be a conduit to crime prevention, not just be reactive to the needs of the community.

1280
02:20:39.137 --> 02:20:48.270
<v Christian Peterson>And so that is why when I was saying an increase in self-initiated activity is a positive, it's because it's giving more opportunity for us to follow up on crimes.

1281
02:20:48.381 --> 02:20:51.720
<v Christian Peterson>It's giving us more of an opportunity to engage with the community.

1282
02:20:51.833 --> 02:21:01.764
<v Christian Peterson>It's giving us more opportunity to be out there I appreciate that clarification, both parts of that clarification.

1283
02:21:01.861 --> 02:21:05.295
<v Unidentified speaker>I think I would love to see more disaggregation of that data.

1284
02:21:06.112 --> 02:21:10.604
<v Unidentified speaker>When I lived in Portsmouth, there's an OnPoint credit union on the south side of Lombard.

1285
02:21:11.005 --> 02:21:20.376
<v Unidentified speaker>Driving to pick up a pizza one time, and so drove by it, drove right by it maybe 10 minutes later, and as I'm driving by it, the one side, there's a police officer standing there with his gun drawn.

1286
02:21:20.360 --> 02:21:25.501
<v Unidentified speaker>Officer coming in because there's a person who's, uh, sleeping in a sleeping bag kind of on the edge of the thing.

1287
02:21:25.998 --> 02:21:33.036
<v Unidentified speaker>And in the 10 minutes I come back and there are now 4 vehicles there, police officers, uh, from all 4 of them.

1288
02:21:33.101 --> 02:21:34.948
<v Unidentified speaker>I think I counted 7 as I drove by.

1289
02:21:34.995 --> 02:21:36.972
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sure there was an 8th if there are 2 per vehicle.

1290
02:21:37.647 --> 02:21:46.581
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, and I assume from my— from the question I asked at the time, um, not on the dais, that that was a self-initiated call because of just the nature of it coming in.

1291
02:21:46.629 --> 02:21:46.709
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1292
02:21:46.902 --> 02:21:47.495
<v Unidentified speaker>But it may not have been.

1293
02:21:48.167 --> 02:21:53.647
<v Unidentified speaker>Either way, I think it, it highlights something which is, uh, adjacent to this, which is the number of officers.

1294
02:21:53.695 --> 02:22:07.060
<v Unidentified speaker>And I really appreciate that that was in this, this, uh, uh, presentation, because there are times where I, I've, I've had this asked of me in several different, um, public meetings, neighborhood associations, etc.

1295
02:22:07.173 --> 02:22:23.023
<v Unidentified speaker>Why is it that we see 6, 8, 10 police officers, um, responding to something that is depending on one's viewpoint, either not in need of that many, or as I'll say, in the case of a person sleeping in a sleeping bag, not really necessary for a police response at all.

1296
02:22:23.745 --> 02:22:33.796
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think seeing that increase go up, and I'm glad you picked— I'm sure there's a reason why it was 2017-18 and not '16-'17 or '18-'19, you know, why it's that year.

1297
02:22:33.860 --> 02:22:42.371
<v Unidentified speaker>But, but it seems like for the things that are not increasing in complexity, I recognize that there's complexity of higher priority calls.

1298
02:22:42.435 --> 02:22:43.317
<v Unidentified speaker>That makes sense to me.

1299
02:22:43.879 --> 02:22:54.554
<v Unidentified speaker>But for some of the things that are either consistent or just low in the complexity level, it seems like reducing the number of police officers responding to something is— should be a significant priority.

1300
02:22:55.003 --> 02:22:58.561
<v Unidentified speaker>Because what we're seeing here, we're talking about available staffing, right?

1301
02:22:59.586 --> 02:23:07.168
<v Unidentified speaker>Which has to do with the total number of staff, has to do with who's on leave, has to do with how you're applying resources around the city between patrol and non-patrol, between the precincts.

1302
02:23:07.921 --> 02:23:11.413
<v Unidentified speaker>It also has to do with the call volume that comes to the bureau, right?

1303
02:23:11.816 --> 02:23:17.933
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I'm— and then it has to do with how the response is in terms of does this take 2 officers, does it take 8, right?

1304
02:23:18.271 --> 02:23:29.222
<v Unidentified speaker>And I've also been on ride-alongs where I've seen, you know, a gun violence situation where there were 4 or 5 vehicles responding, which makes perfect sense to me in that sort of situation.

1305
02:23:29.304 --> 02:23:44.588
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I'm curious how the what the goal is in terms of reducing the number of officers responding to the things that are either low complexity or are consistent complexity, and we're still seeing the call volume go up.

1306
02:23:44.670 --> 02:23:46.399
<v Unidentified speaker>If you look at your slides, there's a couple of those.

1307
02:23:46.900 --> 02:23:48.888
<v Brian Hughes>Yeah, thank you for the question, Councilor Kanal.

1308
02:23:49.325 --> 02:23:56.531
<v Brian Hughes>Um, I, I hear what you're saying about the people see a lot of police officers on a call and have questions.

1309
02:23:56.629 --> 02:24:05.569
<v Brian Hughes>When I was the commander of Central Precinct, Councilor Zimmerman and Councilor Murillo both had my cell phone to be able to call me at any time and ask, and I tried to be as responsive as possible.

1310
02:24:05.618 --> 02:24:10.444
<v Brian Hughes>And I hope that rings true for you up in North Precinct with Commander Leisure and Captain Burley.

1311
02:24:10.525 --> 02:24:10.590
<v Loretta Smith>Awesome.

1312
02:24:10.894 --> 02:24:15.850
<v Brian Hughes>They should be great resources for you in helping to deconflict kind of what we're doing, what's going on.

1313
02:24:16.506 --> 02:24:23.307
<v Brian Hughes>Oftentimes we can have frank communications with the hope that you can then inform your constituents and kind of bring, you know, fears down in the community.

1314
02:24:24.300 --> 02:24:38.052
<v Brian Hughes>The operational needs surrounding the amount of officers that are on a call, What we typically see is information comes into BOEC and it's not a complete police report that tells us everything that's going to happen.

1315
02:24:38.726 --> 02:24:52.411
<v Brian Hughes>And so with patrol response, what we will often see is a lot of officers responding on unknown or limited information and having to guess at how, how the call could play out.

1316
02:24:52.891 --> 02:25:02.343
<v Brian Hughes>We want to err on the side of safety, both for employee wellness and community wellness and have enough officers there when we can to safely resolve a situation.

1317
02:25:02.471 --> 02:25:05.185
<v Brian Hughes>So I think there's a lot of that going on as well.

1318
02:25:05.747 --> 02:25:15.510
<v Brian Hughes>We do encourage our supervisors to, once the scene has stabilized, to reduce the officer footprint to return them for calls for service.

1319
02:25:15.766 --> 02:25:20.921
<v Brian Hughes>So have you had some successes with interacting with Captain Burley and Commander Leisure, I hope?

1320
02:25:21.242 --> 02:25:24.817
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, more so in the context of North Precinct with Commander Leisure.

1321
02:25:25.492 --> 02:25:27.463
<v Unidentified speaker>Captain Burleigh on previous roles.

1322
02:25:27.800 --> 02:25:28.218
<v Brian Hughes>Okay.

1323
02:25:28.298 --> 02:25:31.393
<v Unidentified speaker>So yeah, but I mean, as recently as yesterday.

1324
02:25:31.441 --> 02:25:39.764
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think I didn't want to— I don't think that that's the most critical component.

1325
02:25:39.844 --> 02:25:41.625
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't think it'll have the biggest impact if fixed.

1326
02:25:41.689 --> 02:25:44.736
<v Unidentified speaker>So I appreciate the response.

1327
02:25:44.880 --> 02:25:46.949
<v Unidentified speaker>I do think it's worth having that conversation.

1328
02:25:47.304 --> 02:25:56.431
<v Unidentified speaker>I did want to note 2 other things, but, um, and just to make sure I understood correctly, I think Lieutenant Blucher said that CERT can also be involved in responding to public order events.

1329
02:25:58.129 --> 02:25:58.664
<v Brian Hughes>They can.

1330
02:25:58.858 --> 02:26:11.816
<v Brian Hughes>We would, uh, you know, public order events, we have a crowd management incident commander that would take a look at the nature of the event, and then they would determine what resources would be needed to appropriately manage and handle that event.

1331
02:26:12.301 --> 02:26:20.022
<v Brian Hughes>It's not uncommon for us to have CERT team members on standby just in case something awful were to happen, just so we can be ready and prepared.

1332
02:26:20.136 --> 02:26:21.329
<v Brian Hughes>So that's what she was referring to.

1333
02:26:21.668 --> 02:26:25.245
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, I understand it in the context of readiness, so I appreciate that.

1334
02:26:26.000 --> 02:26:45.897
<v Unidentified speaker>The other 2 big takeaways I had besides the conversation around self-initiated calls and the number of officers, one is about protest response, and I think we— and the other is about mental health calls and broadly You know, the appropriate responder for each type of call.

1335
02:26:45.961 --> 02:27:02.611
<v Unidentified speaker>I think, um, we've talked about this a million times, so I won't go into a ton of detail, but we need to be moving at a greater level of, of haste to achieve the goals that we all say we want in terms of Portland Street Response and some of the other responders that we're talking about taking on these calls.

1336
02:27:03.125 --> 02:27:09.764
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand there have been just— it keeps being a 2-year plan and we're always in year 1 of it, it feels like.

1337
02:27:10.908 --> 02:27:15.760
<v Unidentified speaker>We need to be at the end of that plan and achieve the goal at some point in the near future.

1338
02:27:17.588 --> 02:27:25.601
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's part of why the council took the action we did last June to really put some pressure to try and achieve it.

1339
02:27:25.699 --> 02:27:32.747
<v Unidentified speaker>And it's been disappointing to see it slow, slowly implemented in terms of the staffing levels and in terms of the call reallocation.

1340
02:27:34.180 --> 02:27:36.745
<v Unidentified speaker>I did— there has been better news on the welfare check.

1341
02:27:36.825 --> 02:27:36.907
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1342
02:27:37.426 --> 02:27:39.450
<v Unidentified speaker>Conversation, and I want to acknowledge that.

1343
02:27:39.995 --> 02:27:41.231
<v Unidentified speaker>I really appreciate that.

1344
02:27:41.297 --> 02:27:45.295
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's— that has an overlap with behavioral health, but they're not the same.

1345
02:27:45.775 --> 02:27:46.772
<v Unidentified speaker>They're not a circle.

1346
02:27:46.819 --> 02:27:47.879
<v Unidentified speaker>They are still a Venn diagram.

1347
02:27:48.264 --> 02:27:56.165
<v Unidentified speaker>So the behavioral health component is definitely broadly there as an important priority that doesn't appear to be going that way.

1348
02:27:56.212 --> 02:28:01.720
<v Unidentified speaker>And I hope that's part of the hiring decisions that are being made for permanent DCA over there as well.

1349
02:28:01.929 --> 02:28:02.058
<v Andres Oswalt>Thank you.

1350
02:28:02.667 --> 02:28:09.859
<v Unidentified speaker>In terms of protest response, I mean, it— I think this is a, a broader conversation we need to have.

1351
02:28:10.479 --> 02:28:38.015
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand RRT does work on natural and man-made disasters in addition to some of the— I was troubled by the way it was described as providing safe public events, um, especially in the context of ICE protests recently, where the RRT's role— or I should say, it's not always clear what team, so I don't want to pin it on that one team— but PPB's role broadly has not been in the protective state of— for folks from the violence they're per— they're receiving from the federal government right now.

1352
02:28:38.704 --> 02:28:41.524
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, they've been documenting it, and that's been very helpful.

1353
02:28:42.085 --> 02:28:59.279
<v Unidentified speaker>But I— the amount of police resources, including evidently CERT, that are going towards people exercising their First Amendment rights is something we should be working on reducing and finding better ways to respond to that.

1354
02:28:59.567 --> 02:29:15.316
<v Unidentified speaker>Not only for its own benefit on First Amendment rights and public safety in those contexts, but also from the perspective of freeing up police resources for the things that I think would have a 99%, uh, polling, you know, result if we asked, should police respond to it?

1355
02:29:15.427 --> 02:29:25.498
<v Unidentified speaker>We obviously— those calls that you went through, um, and I really appreciate the, the 18-hour, like, the, the timestamps on that, those types of calls, ideally someone's responding to that.

1356
02:29:26.115 --> 02:29:31.070
<v Unidentified speaker>And not being taken up with by something that doesn't need a police response at all.

1357
02:29:31.441 --> 02:29:40.628
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think the 2 big places I'm seeing through this data and other data is, is responding to people exercising their First Amendment rights and behavioral health.

1358
02:29:40.903 --> 02:29:41.970
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanted to get that on the record.

1359
02:29:42.036 --> 02:29:42.424
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair.

1360
02:29:45.224 --> 02:29:45.816
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

1361
02:29:45.881 --> 02:29:46.507
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

1362
02:29:52.201 --> 02:29:53.556
<v Loretta Smith>I didn't say legacy.

1363
02:29:56.882 --> 02:29:57.333
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1364
02:29:59.534 --> 02:30:03.407
<v Steve Novick>So I don't think this is the last time we're going to discuss this issue.

1365
02:30:04.018 --> 02:30:19.349
<v Steve Novick>And one thing I want to say is that I don't assume that self-initiated calls being up even while response times are down is bad, because I think that if people are getting out of their cars in areas of high crime, that can prevent crime.

1366
02:30:20.462 --> 02:30:34.772
<v Steve Novick>But I do think that in a follow-up presentation, we should have a discussion about the extent to which— I mean, and also, by the way, I think I've been on the record numerous times saying that I don't think that we should make a religion of response times.

1367
02:30:34.948 --> 02:30:45.667
<v Steve Novick>I think that there are goals that in some cases should be prioritized over response times, like de-escalating a situation.

1368
02:30:46.966 --> 02:30:50.557
<v Steve Novick>And making sure that we have enough people there to handle the situation.

1369
02:30:51.215 --> 02:31:04.745
<v Steve Novick>And I also want to note that I'm certainly willing to believe that the increase in really acute behavioral health situations has been a problem with the police bureau, as it's been a problem for housing providers.

1370
02:31:04.936 --> 02:31:11.911
<v Steve Novick>I mean, I've heard from— I had a separate conversation with Chief Day that sort of initiated this discussion today.

1371
02:31:12.538 --> 02:31:26.280
<v Steve Novick>About 8 weeks ago, he was talking about how we've got more people with severe mental health issues that are simply harder to deal with and take more time to deal with in situations that do require a police response than we did some years ago.

1372
02:31:27.815 --> 02:31:55.261
<v Steve Novick>But I think that in— at some future point, we should have a discussion where maybe we counselors provide some questions to answer in advance where we get sort of a breakdown of here's the extent to which the increase in response times is due to our prioritizing having more people taking more time in certain situations.

1373
02:31:55.927 --> 02:32:06.283
<v Steve Novick>Here's the extent to which we think it can be accounted for by there simply being more complicated situations that require, that require a greater response.

1374
02:32:07.922 --> 02:32:14.565
<v Steve Novick>I think that we've begun to address that a bit today, but I'd like to do it in a more organized fashion in the future.

1375
02:32:15.760 --> 02:32:23.290
<v Steve Novick>And again, I don't think it's a bad idea for this committee to spend more than one session talking about police response times, given that it's a pretty big deal.

1376
02:32:25.139 --> 02:32:26.863
<v Steve Novick>Mr. Oswald, I see you have your hand up.

1377
02:32:28.813 --> 02:32:29.917
<v Andres Oswalt>Yeah, thank you, Chair.

1378
02:32:30.115 --> 02:32:32.013
<v Andres Oswalt>Just one more contribution to this conversation.

1379
02:32:32.438 --> 02:32:44.784
<v Andres Oswalt>In particular, uh, 2 pieces of data that Portland for All did not have access to or know if it existed that we thought would be helpful, one of which has been shown today, which is the number of officers by response time.

1380
02:32:45.266 --> 02:32:53.986
<v Andres Oswalt>And I think digging into that data of how many police officers are responding to each type of call and looking at that year over year will be helpful to the conversation.

1381
02:32:54.900 --> 02:33:00.555
<v Andres Oswalt>And then the other was, uh, how long officers are spending on different call types.

1382
02:33:01.427 --> 02:33:04.353
<v Andres Oswalt>There are states like California that require that reporting.

1383
02:33:04.888 --> 02:33:11.013
<v Andres Oswalt>And so those were just 2 specific pieces of information that we didn't have that we thought would help paint a fuller picture.

1384
02:33:11.128 --> 02:33:17.027
<v Andres Oswalt>And it sounds like one of those does exist and might be helpful to council, and the other one might be worth exploring as well.

1385
02:33:18.700 --> 02:33:18.878
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1386
02:33:18.959 --> 02:33:42.424
<v Steve Novick>And following up on that, Chief Hughes, do you think that it would be possible to uh, come up with something like, in 2019, we had X number of calls that took up X amount of officer hours, and in 2025, we had Y number of calls that took Y amount of officer hours, for patrol officers in particular?

1387
02:33:44.458 --> 02:33:46.012
<v Brian Hughes>Sure, we could come up with that number.

1388
02:33:46.674 --> 02:33:47.079
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1389
02:33:48.989 --> 02:33:50.236
<v Steve Novick>Uh, Councilor Kanal, you had something else?

1390
02:33:50.706 --> 02:33:51.078
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thanks.

1391
02:33:51.683 --> 02:33:55.290
<v Unidentified speaker>I forgot to note 2 things, 3 things, 2 for Andreas.

1392
02:33:55.370 --> 02:33:59.268
<v Unidentified speaker>One, I appreciate the P90 conversation.

1393
02:34:00.022 --> 02:34:11.407
<v Unidentified speaker>We had a recent conver— well, not recent, a few months ago about, it's not just fire that uses a similar stat, but the 90% of calls answered within 15 seconds at BOEC, which is also relevant to this.

1394
02:34:11.487 --> 02:34:16.972
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think we didn't really dig into the part about waiting for an officer to be available.

1395
02:34:17.021 --> 02:34:17.068
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1396
02:34:17.663 --> 02:34:19.329
<v Unidentified speaker>Which I think is, is relevant.

1397
02:34:19.489 --> 02:34:22.391
<v Unidentified speaker>You, you character— categorized it into 2 parts.

1398
02:34:23.176 --> 02:34:39.625
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I've seen BOEC's data where they've categorized it into 4 parts, where it's the amount of time that the caller's waiting, the amount of time that BOEC is engaged with them before the, the dispatch starts, then there's the, the part you're talking about, then there's the part of, of getting there.

1399
02:34:39.945 --> 02:34:50.667
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that, that would be really— I would love to, to have that I think we should have that conversation again, Chair, in the future, because I think there's— that helps disaggregate the part that is about staffing availability.

1400
02:34:52.316 --> 02:34:57.406
<v Unidentified speaker>And if so, whether it's BOEC staffing availability or PPB as well.

1401
02:34:57.761 --> 02:34:59.004
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's just a helpful thing.

1402
02:34:59.522 --> 02:35:09.094
<v Unidentified speaker>I did want to ask you, the cost per call thing, that's not— I don't think that's adjusted for inflation.

1403
02:35:09.144 --> 02:35:09.257
<v Loretta Smith>Correct.

1404
02:35:09.809 --> 02:35:11.156
<v Unidentified speaker>Please advise me if I'm wrong on that.

1405
02:35:11.611 --> 02:35:16.090
<v Unidentified speaker>It looks like there's a 43% increase in 6 years, which sounds like a lot.

1406
02:35:16.155 --> 02:35:19.824
<v Unidentified speaker>There's about 29% increase in inflation as well.

1407
02:35:20.602 --> 02:35:21.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Do we have data?

1408
02:35:21.577 --> 02:35:22.665
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that inflation adjusted?

1409
02:35:22.730 --> 02:35:25.395
<v Unidentified speaker>And do we have data on how much of that is related to overtime usage?

1410
02:35:27.691 --> 02:35:28.371
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1411
02:35:29.650 --> 02:35:35.609
<v Andres Oswalt>Yeah, I do not have the answer to if we adjusted for inflation, and I think Thomas had to hop off.

1412
02:35:36.248 --> 02:35:38.317
<v Andres Oswalt>So I'm not sure is the answer.

1413
02:35:38.542 --> 02:35:40.323
<v Andres Oswalt>I do think it's worth looking into.

1414
02:35:40.965 --> 02:35:46.643
<v Andres Oswalt>We were just taking a raw cut of what information can we find publicly available and taking the total budget.

1415
02:35:47.204 --> 02:35:51.680
<v Andres Oswalt>In the total budget, that of course includes the money that council has authorized for overtime.

1416
02:35:52.112 --> 02:35:56.974
<v Andres Oswalt>And so it's really just reflecting total expenses on the police bureau divided by the number of calls.

1417
02:35:58.289 --> 02:36:05.364
<v Andres Oswalt>And then to your first point on P90 and bullet response time, That is accurate and helpful.

1418
02:36:05.413 --> 02:36:11.209
<v Andres Oswalt>We were piecing together information from different places, and the Police Bureau data lived in a different place than the BOIC data.

1419
02:36:12.092 --> 02:36:28.838
<v Andres Oswalt>But part of what we wanted to illustrate is since there have been such longstanding conversations about BOIC and 911 staffing and 911 turnaround time, we wanted to remove that from the equation and say if we just looked at once a call is handed to police, what happens?

1420
02:36:29.335 --> 02:36:31.691
<v Andres Oswalt>Because we think that that is a conversation that is newer.

1421
02:36:32.557 --> 02:36:39.911
<v Andres Oswalt>But I agree that displaying it in those 4 parts would probably be the best way to have an apples-to-apples comparison and look at the whole thing together.

1422
02:36:41.129 --> 02:36:41.530
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1423
02:36:41.994 --> 02:36:49.429
<v Unidentified speaker>And then finally, in the previous topic, there was a question Councilor Smith asked about if fire and then if police had mandatory overtime.

1424
02:36:49.925 --> 02:36:52.088
<v Unidentified speaker>And I wanted to just kind of revisit that for a second.

1425
02:36:53.050 --> 02:37:01.417
<v Unidentified speaker>When the response came that police does not have mandatory overtime, Can you speak to, is that a statement about what is allowed or a statement about what's being used?

1426
02:37:01.547 --> 02:37:03.904
<v Unidentified speaker>How, talk, can you explain a little bit more about that?

1427
02:37:04.272 --> 02:37:04.385
<v Brian Hughes>Sure.

1428
02:37:04.593 --> 02:37:09.451
<v Brian Hughes>And I apologize to the councilor, to the council and the city administrator for blurting that out in the back of the room.

1429
02:37:09.500 --> 02:37:11.441
<v Brian Hughes>I just, the question came up and I wanted it answered.

1430
02:37:11.504 --> 02:37:20.084
<v Brian Hughes>So to put some clarity around that, the way the context that you were discussing it up here would be mandatory overtime to fill shifts.

1431
02:37:20.629 --> 02:37:23.578
<v Brian Hughes>And we are one of the few agencies that does not do that.

1432
02:37:24.093 --> 02:37:34.423
<v Brian Hughes>We do have the ability to hold police officers over in an emergency situation or to cancel their days off in an emergency situation, but in the traditional sense of mandatory overtime, we don't do that.

1433
02:37:35.595 --> 02:37:39.966
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, and can you maybe define what you mean by the traditional sense just for clarity for everyone?

1434
02:37:40.398 --> 02:37:40.688
<v Brian Hughes>You bet.

1435
02:37:41.925 --> 02:37:49.041
<v Brian Hughes>Where we're short, for example, on a patrol shift this afternoon, if our minimums, we believe that we should have 18 officers.

1436
02:37:49.332 --> 02:37:56.827
<v Brian Hughes>If we're only able to get 12 officers to fill that shift, we wouldn't force 6 people off their days off to come in to get us to the mandatory.

1437
02:37:57.261 --> 02:38:00.584
<v Brian Hughes>We would just be in triage mode for that shift, which we have been for quite some time.

1438
02:38:00.808 --> 02:38:03.022
<v Brian Hughes>We're getting better, but that's what it looks like for us.

1439
02:38:03.440 --> 02:38:11.480
<v Unidentified speaker>And so when the 6 officers that would otherwise not be on that shift are on that shift, it's because you basically put the call out and 6 people volunteer?

1440
02:38:11.947 --> 02:38:12.363
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that—.

1441
02:38:13.069 --> 02:38:18.094
<v Brian Hughes>That's correct, in alignment with union contract rules and, you know, Seniority, things like that.

1442
02:38:18.352 --> 02:38:18.704
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1443
02:38:18.753 --> 02:38:40.981
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, and on that subject, I do, I do want to note a lot of what we're talking about here about the, the desired future status should be noted will require conversations that relate to the, the labor side of this, um, obviously with PPA, PPCOA, but also with, uh, Pro-Tech and, and, you know, CPBW, all the other unions that are involved in, in not just this, um, uh, bureau but also the relevant other bureaus.

1444
02:38:41.030 --> 02:38:42.395
<v Unidentified speaker>And we haven't mentioned that yet.

1445
02:38:42.459 --> 02:38:44.650
<v Unidentified speaker>I wanted to get that Thank you, Councilor.

1446
02:38:46.299 --> 02:38:47.592
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman.

1447
02:38:48.626 --> 02:38:48.965
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Chair.

1448
02:38:49.272 --> 02:39:00.914
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, this topic of mandatory overtime and, and of, I'll say, like, manning of posts is one I want to spend a little bit of time here on.

1449
02:39:01.870 --> 02:39:07.940
<v Eric Zimmerman>So as you mentioned, Chief, you said, you know, we've got an afternoon patrol where we say we need to have 18 officers on it.

1450
02:39:08.037 --> 02:39:13.507
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are we talking about are you talking about across the city or in one of our precincts when you say that type of number?

1451
02:39:14.022 --> 02:39:15.004
<v Brian Hughes>That'd be one precinct.

1452
02:39:15.068 --> 02:39:17.176
<v Brian Hughes>I think Central Precinct is right around that number.

1453
02:39:18.441 --> 02:39:18.715
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1454
02:39:19.326 --> 02:39:27.272
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to take some time here because I think this is an important distinction for the public to understand and one that really gets lost in some nuance.

1455
02:39:27.566 --> 02:40:01.652
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so what we're saying in the Fire Bureau side of things is, in order to have every fire station appropriately staffed so that they can meet their goals for response when a 911 call comes in, they have said that they are willing to tell their employees, their firefighters, that we must fill a post, and a post being a position that has to have an employee in it who's ready to respond in order to meet that public safety aspect.

1456
02:40:03.572 --> 02:40:15.657
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and I think generally as a community we have accepted that because all of us want the fire station that is closest to us to be prepared to get in the truck and to get to our home if we such need the call.

1457
02:40:17.538 --> 02:40:24.054
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have found it strange in this community that we have not done the same thing for police.

1458
02:40:24.377 --> 02:40:28.950
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I've been on ride-alongs where I was a little shocked at the staffing number on a given day.

1459
02:40:31.979 --> 02:40:36.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>And getting to the point, I mean, I am a big proponent of filling all of our vacancies.

1460
02:40:36.916 --> 02:40:38.805
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we have been on the gas on that.

1461
02:40:38.869 --> 02:40:45.122
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think the Bureau is doing a great job of making Portland Police an employer of choice for those who want to go into law enforcement.

1462
02:40:45.171 --> 02:40:46.443
<v Eric Zimmerman>So hats off there.

1463
02:40:47.072 --> 02:41:02.851
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I do think that this is an important part of the community conversation when it comes to available units, available Officers, and why do we accept a different standard for our non-fire first responders?

1464
02:41:02.898 --> 02:41:15.279
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think this is a robust part of where the conversation should actually go, because everything else we talk about is slightly skewed to a lesser outcome if we have set a minimum, right?

1465
02:41:15.343 --> 02:41:18.619
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've never been a part of any organization who strived for the minimum.

1466
02:41:19.518 --> 02:41:19.629
<v Steve Novick>Right.

1467
02:41:19.677 --> 02:41:22.263
<v Eric Zimmerman>A minimum is worst-case scenario, you can do the job.

1468
02:41:23.049 --> 02:41:28.251
<v Eric Zimmerman>Anything below that is failure, and you're trying to prevent tragedy.

1469
02:41:29.085 --> 02:41:41.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>So we've set a minimum because somewhere in the bureau or somewhere in the city leadership, we've said this is the minimum to be an effective agency, and yet we allow the agency to continually not meet the minimum because of this, this issue.

1470
02:41:42.315 --> 02:41:51.370
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that is healthy for a robust conversation about where do we want to go, both with our employees who are police officers, but with the command staff, with the, with the mayor's team.

1471
02:41:52.431 --> 02:41:59.449
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because if you're, if you're seeking the minimum, that isn't where I want to be, right?

1472
02:42:00.139 --> 02:42:06.819
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think about that in terms of we often get into the, did we spend a lot of money on overtime, did we not?

1473
02:42:07.462 --> 02:42:12.538
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to spend more time knowing how many days did we not meet the minimum?

1474
02:42:12.602 --> 02:42:14.850
<v Eric Zimmerman>How many shifts a day did we not meet the minimum?

1475
02:42:14.898 --> 02:42:15.027
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1476
02:42:16.293 --> 02:42:28.284
<v Eric Zimmerman>When I was at Multnomah County a long time ago, before matrixing was the norm, the sheriff used to almost like red alert the county commissioners every time the jail moved into a matrixing situation.

1477
02:42:28.364 --> 02:42:36.972
<v Eric Zimmerman>A matrixing is basically, by law, people who should be held, but because of capacity reasons, the sheriff has to make a judgment call about who gets released.

1478
02:42:37.774 --> 02:42:48.869
<v Eric Zimmerman>Nobody would describe that as anything but a terrible situation because it means pretty serious folks who should be behind bars for a certain amount of time are being released so that we can get more serious people fit into the system.

1479
02:42:49.513 --> 02:42:57.720
<v Eric Zimmerman>That used to be so rare in our community that the sheriff would send an alert to the county commissioners and their chiefs of staff saying we're about to matrix.

1480
02:42:59.468 --> 02:43:04.456
<v Eric Zimmerman>Today it happens on any day that ends in Y, and that is a change.

1481
02:43:04.504 --> 02:43:05.983
<v Eric Zimmerman>We've gotten used to this norm.

1482
02:43:06.129 --> 02:43:07.680
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm afraid we've gotten used councilmember Herbold.

1483
02:43:07.760 --> 02:43:10.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're used to this norm of always being below the minimum staffing.

1484
02:43:11.862 --> 02:43:30.181
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I would deeply be in support of let's start advertising and tracking for the greater Portland public, for our city administrator as he's getting his feet under him in terms of what is Portland like, for our public, for our advisory boards, everybody.

1485
02:43:31.014 --> 02:43:42.945
<v Eric Zimmerman>How often, how many shifts per day, or how many shifts per week does Portland Police— is Portland Police not able to meet minimum staffing requirements because we don't have a mandatory overtime standard.

1486
02:43:44.423 --> 02:43:48.643
<v Eric Zimmerman>That at least would help us understand the severity of the concern.

1487
02:43:48.772 --> 02:43:52.157
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is this a once-a-month thing or is it a once-a-day thing?

1488
02:43:52.447 --> 02:43:56.074
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think the public has some vested interest in that answer.

1489
02:43:56.218 --> 02:43:57.165
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know I certainly do.

1490
02:43:57.759 --> 02:44:06.200
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I don't know where we could go with that, Mr. City Administrator, with the chief, but I would deeply be interested in how many times are we not meeting the minimum?

1491
02:44:06.248 --> 02:44:16.326
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because that at least allows me to have a reasonable conversation with you and the command staff, with the police union leadership whose workers will be deeply affected if something were to change.

1492
02:44:16.680 --> 02:44:20.484
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what would this look like and why have we accepted a difference from fire?

1493
02:44:20.691 --> 02:44:27.079
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because these are our 2 first responding agencies that we have seen a big difference for.

1494
02:44:27.128 --> 02:44:29.262
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just think this is an important topic.

1495
02:44:29.310 --> 02:44:30.225
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm glad that it came up.

1496
02:44:30.775 --> 02:44:39.093
<v Eric Zimmerman>In terms of the difference in the question, I'm very interested in where we can go from there, and I've appreciated what you've brought forward for the rest of the day.

1497
02:44:39.157 --> 02:44:40.662
<v Eric Zimmerman>And keep, keep the work up there, Chief.

1498
02:44:40.727 --> 02:44:41.059
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1499
02:44:45.519 --> 02:44:46.117
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

1500
02:44:46.182 --> 02:44:46.779
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

1501
02:44:47.458 --> 02:44:47.828
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1502
02:44:48.200 --> 02:44:53.854
<v Loretta Smith>I want to thank you, Councilor Zimmerman, for reminding me of that process and what we had to go through at Multnomah County.

1503
02:44:53.935 --> 02:44:54.959
<v Loretta Smith>I was going to say the same thing.

1504
02:44:55.630 --> 02:45:04.088
<v Loretta Smith>Why is it that the fire bureau has automatic overtime and the police, they don't.

1505
02:45:04.168 --> 02:45:12.545
<v Loretta Smith>I know that there's an issue around staffing that we just don't have the staff to do it as well.

1506
02:45:13.238 --> 02:45:20.727
<v Loretta Smith>But if we had something put in the budget like fire does, fire has overtime money put in their budget as overtime.

1507
02:45:21.426 --> 02:45:28.043
<v Loretta Smith>And so I agree, and I think you said it more eloquently than I did, Councilor Zimmerman.

1508
02:45:28.702 --> 02:45:37.014
<v Loretta Smith>I agree that I think that we need to look into some of those opportunities about the how, the mechanics of it.

1509
02:45:38.611 --> 02:45:39.682
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

1510
02:45:41.631 --> 02:45:42.281
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

1511
02:45:42.346 --> 02:45:43.077
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Morillo.

1512
02:45:45.045 --> 02:45:45.954
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair Novick.

1513
02:45:47.237 --> 02:45:51.233
<v Unidentified speaker>I really appreciate the conversation that we had today, and I think it's a good ongoing conversation to have.

1514
02:45:51.298 --> 02:46:05.683
<v Unidentified speaker>So I agree with you, Chair, that we should because we have to make staffing and budgeting decisions with very rare resources, and so we have to have those tough discussions with all our bureaus and all our city employees and all of our services.

1515
02:46:06.421 --> 02:46:22.495
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think a question that has sort of arisen for me out of this conversation as well is that you talked about the mayor's, you know, making sure that there is— if there's any person who is laying down on the street, that city employees are stopping and intervening and helping that person.

1516
02:46:22.543 --> 02:46:23.040
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I think that's a great point.

1517
02:46:23.763 --> 02:46:26.170
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that that is a lovely concept.

1518
02:46:26.730 --> 02:46:49.799
<v Unidentified speaker>But unfortunately, I also think that if the police bureau is getting directives to do what should be social work, to me that indicates that we are sending our most expensive employees who are the least trained in handling mental health calls and doing engagement for unhoused neighbors to respond to those calls.

1519
02:46:50.538 --> 02:47:05.385
<v Unidentified speaker>To me, that actually indicates that we need to expand Portland Street Response so that they can handle most of those calls for service, and then the police bureau can handle violent crime, theft, following up on if someone's car was stolen, that type of thing.

1520
02:47:05.882 --> 02:47:09.965
<v Unidentified speaker>Because it doesn't make sense that our police should be everything to everyone.

1521
02:47:10.462 --> 02:47:17.835
<v Unidentified speaker>You can't be service workers and addressing mental health crisis and right.

1522
02:47:18.752 --> 02:47:34.212
<v Unidentified speaker>There has to be a balance, and I think that it does concern me to hear that we are potentially sending our most expensive employees who don't necessarily always have the training to do that type of work to engage with some of our most vulnerable populations.

1523
02:47:34.325 --> 02:47:35.272
<v Unidentified speaker>That doesn't add up to me.

1524
02:47:36.186 --> 02:47:40.153
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would love more clarity on those self-initiated calls.

1525
02:47:40.264 --> 02:47:41.998
<v Unidentified speaker>I would love more clarity on if that directive is going to be rescinded.

1526
02:47:42.095 --> 02:47:51.728
<v Unidentified speaker>Coming from the mayor's office, uh, because to me, we have Portland Street Response for a reason, and we need to make sure that we're utilizing them to their full potential.

1527
02:47:52.099 --> 02:47:52.404
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1528
02:47:55.313 --> 02:47:56.164
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

1529
02:47:56.436 --> 02:48:02.968
<v Steve Novick>I put myself in the queue just to address the question of why the police expansion cost report wasn't on the agenda today.

1530
02:48:03.595 --> 02:48:07.236
<v Steve Novick>I referred to it earlier as a miscommunication with the clerk's office.

1531
02:48:07.381 --> 02:48:08.316
<v Steve Novick>That's not actually true.

1532
02:48:08.460 --> 02:48:09.234
<v Steve Novick>It's a technical issue.

1533
02:48:10.069 --> 02:48:13.870
<v Steve Novick>I'm reading the email that Kevin Alvarez sent to all of us last week.

1534
02:48:14.191 --> 02:48:17.638
<v Steve Novick>The item missed the filing deadline because of a system error on eCouncil.

1535
02:48:19.139 --> 02:48:24.765
<v Steve Novick>The revision log showed it moved from elected review straight to draft under an anonymous user, which pulled it out of the normal filing path.

1536
02:48:25.368 --> 02:48:30.738
<v Steve Novick>So there was a request for 4/5 agreement to put it on the agenda, which it should have been.

1537
02:48:30.933 --> 02:48:32.761
<v Steve Novick>And for whatever reason, we did not get 4/5.

1538
02:48:33.585 --> 02:48:34.737
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to clarify that.

1539
02:48:34.984 --> 02:48:37.015
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal, do you have some closing thoughts?

1540
02:48:37.605 --> 02:48:39.048
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I just wanted to respond to Councilor Zimmerman's point.

1541
02:48:39.096 --> 02:48:39.474
<v Unidentified speaker>I really appreciate that.

1542
02:48:41.957 --> 02:48:43.158
<v Unidentified speaker>And I would like to do it.

1543
02:48:43.335 --> 02:48:56.292
<v Unidentified speaker>I did want to note, I think when we talk about staffing shortages or overages, not that we're talking about that here, it's a comparison between, as I think the phrase was, minimum staffing requirements and what actually is.

1544
02:48:56.726 --> 02:49:03.909
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think there's an importance to look at also what the minimum staffing requirements are as well and where that number came from.

1545
02:49:04.424 --> 02:49:07.790
<v Unidentified speaker>There was a police staffing study that was initiated a couple years ago.

1546
02:49:08.255 --> 02:49:11.111
<v Unidentified speaker>And was not finished in the Public Safety Service area.

1547
02:49:11.479 --> 02:49:13.870
<v Unidentified speaker>I would love to revisit that and get back into that.

1548
02:49:14.351 --> 02:49:23.012
<v Unidentified speaker>Part of that relates to the conversation about who's the right responder for each type of call, because you can't set the minimum staffing levels until you know what they're responding to in any bureau.

1549
02:49:23.510 --> 02:49:36.485
<v Unidentified speaker>But part of it also, you know, we did talk about it a little bit with Chief Day several months ago, and primarily the source for what— when we ask how many officers do you need at a time in a place, right.

1550
02:49:37.047 --> 02:49:37.238
<v Sameer Kanal>Right.

1551
02:49:37.287 --> 02:49:38.891
<v Unidentified speaker>What's the math that goes into that?

1552
02:49:39.227 --> 02:49:47.779
<v Unidentified speaker>And as we were talking about it, one of the primary factors, if not the primary factor, and this is what Chief Day said on the record here, is historical staffing patterns.

1553
02:49:48.195 --> 02:49:53.040
<v Unidentified speaker>That obviously how it's been done historically is going to influence what happens now.

1554
02:49:53.505 --> 02:49:55.030
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's fair that that's a factor.

1555
02:49:55.287 --> 02:50:02.859
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not disputing that, but I also think it's important for us to, to look at how we can update that given that there's now a Portland Street Response.

1556
02:50:03.375 --> 02:50:10.172
<v Unidentified speaker>Given that there's now a chat, given that there's now more complexity to some types of calls and, and, you know, different, um, teams that used to exist.

1557
02:50:10.542 --> 02:50:22.747
<v Unidentified speaker>So I, I hope that we're able to, when we're comparing those 2 numbers in the discussion Councilor Zimmerman requested, which I do support having, that we're able to look at both, uh, independently and then compare the 2.

1558
02:50:23.415 --> 02:50:23.615
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1559
02:50:27.206 --> 02:50:28.015
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

1560
02:50:28.112 --> 02:50:29.539
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith, is that a legacy hand?

1561
02:50:36.713 --> 02:50:36.778
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1562
02:50:37.909 --> 02:50:38.329
<v Steve Novick>All right.

1563
02:50:38.799 --> 02:50:44.149
<v Steve Novick>Um, thank you everybody for your participation and your comments and thoughts today.

1564
02:50:45.022 --> 02:50:55.091
<v Steve Novick>Um, I think that at this point, um, I can give everybody 14 minutes back in their day and bring this meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee to a close.

1565
02:50:55.813 --> 02:50:56.665
<v Steve Novick>Thank you all very much.

1566
02:50:56.779 --> 02:50:58.711
<v Steve Novick>I will not rap a gavel because that'll freak my dog out.

1567
02:51:00.403 --> 02:51:02.709
<v Steve Novick>Take care, everybody.

1568
02:51:18.997 --> 02:51:20.466
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

