WEBVTT

1
00:08:47.115 --> 00:08:47.566
<v Steve Novick>Good morning.

2
00:08:48.388 --> 00:08:51.690
<v Sameer Kanal>I call this meeting of the Portland City Council's Committee of the Whole to order.

3
00:08:51.770 --> 00:08:54.918
<v Sameer Kanal>It is Thursday, August 13th at 9:30 AM.

4
00:08:56.427 --> 00:08:58.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Diego, will you please call the roll?

5
00:08:59.070 --> 00:08:59.524
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning.

6
00:08:59.799 --> 00:09:00.318
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

7
00:09:00.756 --> 00:09:00.967
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

8
00:09:01.486 --> 00:09:01.811
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

9
00:09:02.860 --> 00:09:02.923
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

10
00:09:03.538 --> 00:09:03.942
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick.

11
00:09:04.493 --> 00:09:04.623
<v Steve Novick>Here.

12
00:09:04.735 --> 00:09:05.416
<v Chad Robison>Clark.

13
00:09:07.485 --> 00:09:07.712
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

14
00:09:08.634 --> 00:09:09.394
<v Mitch Green>Here.

15
00:09:10.139 --> 00:09:10.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman.

16
00:09:13.138 --> 00:09:13.412
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos.

17
00:09:13.621 --> 00:09:14.121
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

18
00:09:14.846 --> 00:09:15.250
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy.

19
00:09:15.379 --> 00:09:15.525
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

20
00:09:16.126 --> 00:09:17.167
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

21
00:09:20.580 --> 00:09:22.105
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney.

22
00:09:22.283 --> 00:09:22.491
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

23
00:09:23.408 --> 00:09:23.712
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan.

24
00:09:26.076 --> 00:09:26.494
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal.

25
00:09:27.264 --> 00:09:27.553
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

26
00:09:27.746 --> 00:09:30.100
<v Sameer Kanal>And Vice Chair Ryan will be joining us in just a couple minutes.

27
00:09:30.330 --> 00:09:31.082
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Diego.

28
00:09:35.298 --> 00:09:37.702
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome to the meeting of the Finance and Governance Committee of the Whole.

29
00:09:37.798 --> 00:09:47.774
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/committee-whole or by calling 311.

30
00:09:47.822 --> 00:09:50.129
<v Unidentified speaker>Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

31
00:09:50.533 --> 00:09:53.178
<v Unidentified speaker>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

32
00:09:53.292 --> 00:09:56.009
<v Unidentified speaker>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

33
00:09:56.302 --> 00:10:00.836
<v Unidentified speaker>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

34
00:10:01.552 --> 00:10:03.283
<v Unidentified speaker>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

35
00:10:03.797 --> 00:10:04.614
<v Unidentified speaker>The Chair preserves order.

36
00:10:04.662 --> 00:10:10.865
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

37
00:10:10.929 --> 00:10:12.660
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

38
00:10:12.774 --> 00:10:14.905
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

39
00:10:15.177 --> 00:10:17.774
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

40
00:10:18.399 --> 00:10:20.917
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

41
00:10:21.350 --> 00:10:23.289
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

42
00:10:23.337 --> 00:10:24.972
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, state your name for the record.

43
00:10:25.020 --> 00:10:27.297
<v Unidentified speaker>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

44
00:10:27.522 --> 00:10:29.974
<v Unidentified speaker>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

45
00:10:30.230 --> 00:10:30.486
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

46
00:10:31.705 --> 00:10:32.827
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Christopher.

47
00:10:34.094 --> 00:10:38.581
<v Sameer Kanal>Today we have 4, 5 as-filed items on the agenda.

48
00:10:38.663 --> 00:10:56.279
<v Sameer Kanal>We have the committee chair updates, we have appointments to the new Portlanders Policy Commission, we have a presentation on public health impacts of chemical weapons, and then we have 2 items together after our break, one of which is a presentation, the other is public hearing on the annual budget process.

49
00:10:56.360 --> 00:11:12.134
<v Sameer Kanal>This is part 2 of the process we initiated back in late June and will be leading into some work with the administration starting in September on improving our budget process and hopefully eventually the content of the budget as well.

50
00:11:15.193 --> 00:11:16.623
<v Sameer Kanal>Diego, will you please call the first item?

51
00:11:17.370 --> 00:11:22.292
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 1, document number 2026-288, committee chair updates.

52
00:11:23.100 --> 00:11:24.004
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, thanks everybody.

53
00:11:24.070 --> 00:11:27.883
<v Sameer Kanal>There is a printed copy out for every councilor and there is also one filed online.

54
00:11:27.980 --> 00:11:32.301
<v Sameer Kanal>Couple quick things that have been updated in here.

55
00:11:32.669 --> 00:11:35.510
<v Sameer Kanal>I won't go through everything, but I did want to flag 3 things.

56
00:11:35.639 --> 00:11:45.783
<v Sameer Kanal>One, that this is our last meeting for 3 weeks, so our next meeting after this will be September 3rd because we've got the City Council recess for the second half of August.

57
00:11:46.489 --> 00:11:52.764
<v Sameer Kanal>When we pick back up, we are going to have a pretty significant agenda starting in September.

58
00:11:52.812 --> 00:11:54.642
<v Sameer Kanal>There's quite a few things to get through.

59
00:11:55.220 --> 00:12:00.943
<v Sameer Kanal>I think Council President may be able to correct me if this is anything other than tentative.

60
00:12:00.993 --> 00:12:12.115
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's still tentative that the CEI Hub zoning comprehensive plan and drawdown plan are all coming in mid-September, mid to late September to this committee.

61
00:12:14.792 --> 00:12:26.504
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other thing I wanted to flag is that in October we're picking up, there'll be an oversight hearing and we will be having public testimony on that topic as well, which is not yet locked in, but it will be as soon as we get back from the break.

62
00:12:26.570 --> 00:12:26.833
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

63
00:12:30.404 --> 00:12:31.586
<v Sameer Kanal>That's pretty much it for part 1.

64
00:12:32.412 --> 00:12:34.517
<v Sameer Kanal>Nothing really to update on parts 2 and 3.

65
00:12:34.630 --> 00:12:40.616
<v Sameer Kanal>So I will pass it over for the committee update to Chair of the Public Safety Committee, Chair Steve Novick.

66
00:12:41.634 --> 00:12:44.635
<v Steve Novick>And Chair Steve Novick forgot that he would be asked to do this today.

67
00:12:44.878 --> 00:12:50.508
<v Steve Novick>And I confess I'm a little uncertain of which of the things we have coming up will be the next meeting and the meeting after that.

68
00:12:52.234 --> 00:13:05.735
<v Steve Novick>The last Public Safety Committee hearing, had a presentation from Denise Peña, the head of the Department of Community Justice at Multnomah County, and comments from people at, you know, the Police Bureau and Ceasefire about the relationship.

69
00:13:05.799 --> 00:13:14.539
<v Steve Novick>That's something that I want to do continually is talk about the intersection between the city and the county and public safety issues, which of course occurs repeatedly.

70
00:13:15.535 --> 00:13:18.042
<v Steve Novick>There's the DA's office, there's the sheriff's office.

71
00:13:18.105 --> 00:13:21.736
<v Steve Novick>I was meeting the sheriff yesterday to talk about having the same conversation with her.

72
00:13:23.090 --> 00:13:28.706
<v Steve Novick>And there's also the issue of the interaction between fire and the county ambulances.

73
00:13:31.169 --> 00:13:39.590
<v Steve Novick>We passed out an amended version of the psychedelics ordinance stripping out the advisory committee last week.

74
00:13:39.654 --> 00:13:45.520
<v Steve Novick>We have not— did not get to the concealed carry legislation.

75
00:13:46.054 --> 00:13:53.179
<v Steve Novick>I actually need to ask the administration to try to brief each of the I'm going to talk to the CAAPS members separately about that in advance.

76
00:13:53.293 --> 00:13:58.392
<v Steve Novick>The administration has indicated that's a priority, so I expect that to come up next time.

77
00:13:59.626 --> 00:14:05.480
<v Steve Novick>And here is where we get to what I'm not sure whether we have nailed down for next meeting as opposed to the meeting after that.

78
00:14:06.378 --> 00:14:10.145
<v Steve Novick>We at some point need to— we're supposed to get a report from the PSR committee.

79
00:14:11.332 --> 00:14:13.866
<v Steve Novick>We've got fire code amendments to do.

80
00:14:15.100 --> 00:14:28.065
<v Steve Novick>And we are going to— at Councilor Morillo's suggestion, I've asked Chief Day to be prepared to explain why it is that response times have gotten worse even though call volume has gone down.

81
00:14:29.907 --> 00:14:32.256
<v Steve Novick>And Chief Day said that he's going to address that.

82
00:14:32.402 --> 00:14:37.985
<v Steve Novick>And I think that Vice Chair Morillo is going to suggest some other participants in that conversation.

83
00:14:39.450 --> 00:14:57.188
<v Steve Novick>So that's— Oh, and at some point, We're going to get a presentation on fireworks and the fact that we do not enforce the fireworks law and have some discussion about whether we can do any level of enforcement just to send the message that if you break the law, you might be caught.

84
00:14:59.523 --> 00:15:00.327
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

85
00:15:00.393 --> 00:15:04.538
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I failed to take questions for myself on the other parts, but I'm going to start since you just wrapped up.

86
00:15:04.682 --> 00:15:07.413
<v Sameer Kanal>Chair Novick, anyone have questions for Councilor Novick?

87
00:15:09.592 --> 00:15:11.625
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney and Councilor Reiner, you were both in the queue.

88
00:15:11.690 --> 00:15:13.142
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My question is for you, Chair Cannell.

89
00:15:13.303 --> 00:15:13.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

90
00:15:13.788 --> 00:15:14.320
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan.

91
00:15:16.029 --> 00:15:16.547
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair.

92
00:15:16.676 --> 00:15:18.611
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, thank you, uh, Councilor Novick.

93
00:15:19.047 --> 00:15:21.424
<v Dan Ryan>I want to applaud that you're bringing in the county.

94
00:15:22.250 --> 00:15:28.543
<v Dan Ryan>The, um, in my 6 years here, I've often asked our mayors if we could have joint sessions on public safety with the county.

95
00:15:29.221 --> 00:15:58.075
<v Dan Ryan>We've done it, um, with limited success on homelessness issues, but the fact is, on public safety, they're half of our public And so as you said, it's the DA, it's the sheriff, it's the public defenders, our backlog that forces the quick release sometimes of criminality that no one can understand why, which is really difficult for our first responders who do that hard work.

96
00:15:58.221 --> 00:15:59.934
<v Dan Ryan>And then hours later they're released.

97
00:16:00.470 --> 00:16:04.037
<v Dan Ryan>Much of that is because of the county's defunding of public safety for the last 20 years.

98
00:16:04.133 --> 00:16:04.956
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that's a really important point.

99
00:16:05.533 --> 00:16:13.246
<v Dan Ryan>When you compare Multnomah County to Clackamas County, our budget in Multnomah County for public safety is 40% of the budget.

100
00:16:13.808 --> 00:16:15.100
<v Dan Ryan>In Clackamas County, it's 70%.

101
00:16:16.863 --> 00:16:18.739
<v Dan Ryan>Washington County is similar to Clackamas County.

102
00:16:19.871 --> 00:16:21.278
<v Dan Ryan>And I just want to keep daylighting that.

103
00:16:21.553 --> 00:16:21.990
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

104
00:16:24.477 --> 00:16:25.221
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

105
00:16:25.269 --> 00:16:32.533
<v Sameer Kanal>I also had a question for Councilor Ciaranovic on the response times topic.

106
00:16:32.581 --> 00:16:33.214
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd love to coordinate.

107
00:16:33.263 --> 00:16:44.620
<v Sameer Kanal>We have something on here as well coming that may be one of the topics of a hearing, but specifically for your conversation, I would love it if you, and I can help, connected with somebody in Baltimore.

108
00:16:45.211 --> 00:17:03.995
<v Sameer Kanal>They have had a 20% reduction in police staffing levels and achieved a 68% reduction in homicide in the last few years, 6 years, as well as, and it's not because of authorized staffing, it's because of vacancy, which is similar to us with our 80 vacancies roughly.

109
00:17:04.653 --> 00:17:07.604
<v Sameer Kanal>So just wanted to suggest that as a reference point.

110
00:17:08.053 --> 00:17:08.775
<v Steve Novick>I'd be happy to do that.

111
00:17:08.823 --> 00:17:15.093
<v Steve Novick>Actually, my office is reaching out to the mayor of Baltimore to see if we can get interest in my smart guns idea.

112
00:17:15.173 --> 00:17:17.337
<v Steve Novick>So we're already in touch with Baltimore.

113
00:17:17.643 --> 00:17:19.278
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

114
00:17:19.358 --> 00:17:26.640
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it was ProPublica that came out with it, but yeah, I'll get you that article too and the information I have there.

115
00:17:27.520 --> 00:17:29.125
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, you had something for me, I think.

116
00:17:29.751 --> 00:17:29.833
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do.

117
00:17:30.089 --> 00:17:46.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm wondering if you can just share with us a little bit as you're building out your agendas, how you're thinking about the balance between policy work, which could have homes in other committees but could come here, right?

118
00:17:46.221 --> 00:17:54.665
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've talked about how some of the larger issues, including today's issue, it's broader than just public safety, but it could go to public safety as well.

119
00:17:55.134 --> 00:18:11.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You just mentioned response times, which it sounds like public safety is taking up, but you're interested in taking up here, and how you're balancing that with the budget and— I guess not budget, but the finance work and the governance work.

120
00:18:11.344 --> 00:18:18.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've noticed that the 3.02 policy is listed as possible, but still not even in a tentative spot.

121
00:18:18.875 --> 00:18:27.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We had a discussion on Murillo 11 on the agenda of meeting or 2 ago, and that had to get bumped, and I haven't seen it show back up on the agenda.

122
00:18:27.980 --> 00:18:39.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just want to make sure that we have a space to do the governance work since this is the only space to do that, whereas some of these policy items, there's flexibility.

123
00:18:39.616 --> 00:18:44.688
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We could move them around depending on what committee has capacity for them.

124
00:18:45.394 --> 00:18:47.865
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so that's— I'll kind of break— thanks for that question.

125
00:18:47.913 --> 00:18:58.480
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll break that up into sort of 2 So our issue area for the Committee of the Whole includes finance, governance, oversight, and emergency response.

126
00:18:58.545 --> 00:19:01.126
<v Sameer Kanal>And emergency response is defined as including federal response.

127
00:19:01.590 --> 00:19:11.531
<v Sameer Kanal>And then sort of in parallel to that, there's the things that fit into no other committee or things that fit into too many other committees, which is something that we generally discuss at the leadership team.

128
00:19:12.108 --> 00:19:24.875
<v Sameer Kanal>If it's something that could go into— and I think often it's housing and permitting and city life and Committee of the Whole that theoretically could take it, that seems to be the place that the overlap often is perceived.

129
00:19:25.690 --> 00:19:37.969
<v Sameer Kanal>So in that situation, I think we've been prioritizing those first 4 things, the things that we're directly assigned to do, unless there's a deadline from the administration or Council President, which is rare.

130
00:19:39.471 --> 00:19:54.747
<v Sameer Kanal>And then in terms of the, the items that, I guess the caveat to that, the items that are not a legislative item, but are part of the reason why we created the Committee of the Whole in the first place.

131
00:19:54.954 --> 00:20:07.303
<v Sameer Kanal>So for example, the downtown discussion, which is penciled in right now for September 10th, is something that we talked about when we decided whether or not to create a Committee of the Whole, as here's something that fits into so many different issue areas.

132
00:20:07.351 --> 00:20:11.926
<v Sameer Kanal>It's housing and homelessness related, it's public safety related, it's economic development related.

133
00:20:11.974 --> 00:20:12.055
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

134
00:20:12.471 --> 00:20:14.523
<v Sameer Kanal>And so wanted to make sure I put that in.

135
00:20:15.823 --> 00:20:37.576
<v Sameer Kanal>The other thing in the agenda setting, I would say, and there's exceptions to this one, but we're trying to get the appointments to eventually land on the meeting that we do on Wednesday afternoons because it's a little hard to do high cognitive load things in the afternoon right before we go into an evening council meeting and feel like it's 6 straight hours of—.

136
00:20:37.576 --> 00:20:37.656
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

137
00:20:37.882 --> 00:20:38.346
<v Sameer Kanal>Of stuff.

138
00:20:38.762 --> 00:20:40.557
<v Sameer Kanal>So there's, there's that element as well.

139
00:20:41.631 --> 00:20:54.564
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the second question, which with relation to making sure we get through those kind of core finance and governance things, um, with relation to— you said 2 of them.

140
00:20:54.644 --> 00:20:59.323
<v Sameer Kanal>There's 3.02, which I know our offices are— I have an email I need to send you on that.

141
00:20:59.740 --> 00:21:07.182
<v Sameer Kanal>And then there's also the council president election process, which is a workgroup we haven't had a chance to get landed on the calendar with 5 of us.

142
00:21:07.761 --> 00:21:11.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As well as the conversation around Murillo 11 got bumped.

143
00:21:11.633 --> 00:21:11.825
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

144
00:21:12.034 --> 00:21:14.861
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A meeting or 2 ago, and I don't see it back on this list.

145
00:21:14.924 --> 00:21:19.005
<v Sameer Kanal>That was an administration request to give it that a little bit more time.

146
00:21:19.583 --> 00:21:23.085
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't know what exactly yet, and I actually should follow up with Council President on that one.

147
00:21:24.144 --> 00:21:25.541
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously, I put that on there.

148
00:21:25.606 --> 00:21:26.473
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's really important.

149
00:21:26.569 --> 00:21:29.557
<v Sameer Kanal>Murillo 11, for those that don't know, is about how we communicate between Yes.

150
00:21:29.622 --> 00:21:30.747
<v Sameer Kanal>Between the branches of our government.

151
00:21:31.292 --> 00:21:39.665
<v Sameer Kanal>And there was a report proposed from the executive branch to us, I think is kind of how I would frame that.

152
00:21:40.069 --> 00:21:50.166
<v Sameer Kanal>I wasn't part of the workgroup that set that up, but that's how it's been described to me of how the administration would like to see that work, which everybody I've talked to was not the most excited about.

153
00:21:50.508 --> 00:21:53.333
<v Sameer Kanal>And so the idea of having a discussion on that is vital to me.

154
00:21:53.413 --> 00:21:54.535
<v Sameer Kanal>They asked for a little extra time.

155
00:21:54.960 --> 00:21:59.344
<v Sameer Kanal>So it hasn't landed on here, but it's still in the ether waiting to get scheduled.

156
00:22:00.131 --> 00:22:02.717
<v Sameer Kanal>That one, but I think it's really important.

157
00:22:02.861 --> 00:22:03.069
<v Sameer Kanal>This is—.

158
00:22:03.904 --> 00:22:04.241
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, tell me.

159
00:22:04.290 --> 00:22:05.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, I appreciate the overview.

160
00:22:05.816 --> 00:22:32.382
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just am seeing a lot of policy conversations that, like I said, could land elsewhere, and I'm seeing a lot of core work, especially around governance, which I think still has work to be done, not moving as quickly as We were led to believe it might, and I understand each case has its individual explanation, but I hope that we can make sure that this committee is getting through that core work.

161
00:22:34.761 --> 00:22:46.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I understand that some of these pieces on public safety are really important to you, but we need to make sure we're getting to the pieces that only this committee can take on as well.

162
00:22:46.901 --> 00:22:49.157
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, federal response is one of those things too.

163
00:22:49.557 --> 00:22:54.285
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll just note, like, I, I, I— there's been an error that was in the resolution from the beginning.

164
00:22:54.333 --> 00:22:57.441
<v Sameer Kanal>That's why we keep hearing it described as Finance and Governance Committee of the Whole.

165
00:22:58.034 --> 00:23:08.224
<v Sameer Kanal>But if you read the resolution's actual description, it says Finance, Governance, Government Oversight, um, which is why I mentioned to Councilor Novick a moment ago about the, uh, response times.

166
00:23:08.288 --> 00:23:16.188
<v Sameer Kanal>I've been asked to do an oversight hearing on that, um, by colleagues, um, and that's, that's a, a request.

167
00:23:16.284 --> 00:23:23.919
<v Sameer Kanal>It hasn't been considered, but, uh, and then the emergency response, including federal response, which admittedly there is some overlap there.

168
00:23:27.044 --> 00:23:27.544
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

169
00:23:29.061 --> 00:23:31.289
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, and then Councilor Ryan.

170
00:23:31.483 --> 00:23:43.446
<v Steve Novick>Um, yes, uh, in terms of topics for the Committee of the Whole, I want to reiterate a request I've made before, which is I really want to go into next year's budget having taken a deeper dive into the issue of span of control.

171
00:23:44.051 --> 00:23:51.861
<v Steve Novick>And I think a good place to start would be to have a session where we go through the, I think, the 50-odd people who supervise fewer than 4 people.

172
00:23:52.535 --> 00:23:55.885
<v Steve Novick>And I think in the course of 3 hours, you could actually talk a little bit about each of them.

173
00:23:56.318 --> 00:24:03.102
<v Steve Novick>'Cause, and I mean, I know that in each case, the Bureau said, here's why this person needs to be in this classification regardless.

174
00:24:03.694 --> 00:24:06.534
<v Steve Novick>But I still think it's the best place to start.

175
00:24:07.126 --> 00:24:13.910
<v Steve Novick>And because I just do not want to go into next year's budget situation where We're arguing about span of control.

176
00:24:14.182 --> 00:24:15.450
<v Steve Novick>We haven't had that kind of deep dive.

177
00:24:16.138 --> 00:24:37.194
<v Steve Novick>The other thing I wanted to mention, this is a new suggestion, is I know frankly that one of the things that Chief Day will say about response times is that they're dealing with more complicated situations, partly because of they're dealing with people who have more severe mental health and addiction issues than we're used to dealing with in the past.

178
00:24:37.836 --> 00:24:41.992
<v Steve Novick>And I met— when I met with the sheriff spontaneously, she said the same thing.

179
00:24:42.666 --> 00:24:57.701
<v Steve Novick>And I've also been hearing the same thing from housing providers and shelter providers, that they are dealing with, you know, high, high acuity issues with mental health and addiction that is beyond what they were dealing with 6 years ago.

180
00:24:58.248 --> 00:25:04.602
<v Steve Novick>So I was thinking that that would be a worthwhile thing to explore, you know, in public safety and housing, but also here.

181
00:25:04.650 --> 00:25:04.826
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

182
00:25:05.439 --> 00:25:10.595
<v Steve Novick>Just to sort of talk about the high acuity population and how that affects services across the board.

183
00:25:11.678 --> 00:25:12.356
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thanks for that.

184
00:25:12.470 --> 00:25:18.732
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there was a— there's another angle to that last piece, which is also the state side.

185
00:25:20.054 --> 00:25:26.319
<v Sameer Kanal>And we were going to have a work session with the Office of Government Relations on behavioral health going into the 2027 session.

186
00:25:26.416 --> 00:25:27.175
<v Sameer Kanal>That got bumped.

187
00:25:27.819 --> 00:25:31.792
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think Council President mentioned yesterday it's landing in September, if I recall correctly.

188
00:25:32.953 --> 00:25:41.378
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think connecting those 4 different dots, because you're right, public safety here, housing and permitting, and on that side all kind of makes sense.

189
00:25:41.442 --> 00:25:50.430
<v Sameer Kanal>And I can talk to Council President about that work session run of shows so that we're not overlapping too much content area.

190
00:25:50.846 --> 00:26:02.336
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the response times piece, yeah, I think it's a little unique with the sheriff and housing providers, shelter providers in terms of I don't know that they necessarily have people to offload that to.

191
00:26:02.721 --> 00:26:13.148
<v Sameer Kanal>I know that your committee has the right responder to each call piece and certainly an agency ready and willing to take on those calls in at least a low acuity sense.

192
00:26:13.470 --> 00:26:21.026
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, although, I mean, one thing that I would obviously ask Chief Day is how many of these calls are things that could go to PSR?

193
00:26:21.089 --> 00:26:29.050
<v Steve Novick>Are there calls that PSR would not want to take 'cause they have a, you know, A criminal or at least a dangerous element that they wouldn't wanna do on their own.

194
00:26:29.374 --> 00:26:33.076
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I also hope you'd ask that question of PSR and of the PSR committee.

195
00:26:34.049 --> 00:26:35.373
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

196
00:26:35.598 --> 00:26:35.777
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

197
00:26:35.856 --> 00:26:40.151
<v Sameer Kanal>And by the way, span of control is also on the part 2 of the report.

198
00:26:40.215 --> 00:26:40.942
<v Sameer Kanal>It is coming up.

199
00:26:41.038 --> 00:26:43.670
<v Sameer Kanal>It just hasn't been, it hasn't gotten even penciled in for a place yet.

200
00:26:44.234 --> 00:26:45.348
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's just a question.

201
00:26:45.945 --> 00:26:50.919
<v Sameer Kanal>For those who don't know, this also applies to the advisory bodies conversation.

202
00:26:51.906 --> 00:26:58.906
<v Sameer Kanal>There's been some administrative leadership rotation, and that has caused a little difficulty in scheduling.

203
00:27:00.192 --> 00:27:04.575
<v Sameer Kanal>So in both of those 2 cases specifically, Councilor Ryan and then Councilor Green.

204
00:27:04.768 --> 00:27:06.357
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Chair Connolly.

205
00:27:06.438 --> 00:27:16.858
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate the conversation you and Councilor Pirtle-Guiney were having about agendas and where they could maybe go to committees that are focused on policy.

206
00:27:17.276 --> 00:27:24.354
<v Dan Ryan>I think with item 3, I'd like to hear the reason why it's— for example, item 3 today is a good example of that.

207
00:27:24.674 --> 00:27:29.088
<v Dan Ryan>Why is it being in— why is it in this committee and not in Public Safety?

208
00:27:29.651 --> 00:27:34.465
<v Sameer Kanal>Because the federal government is teargassing people around the city, and this committee deals with federal response.

209
00:27:34.883 --> 00:27:39.104
<v Dan Ryan>So you're repeating that part about the federal response element of this committee?

210
00:27:39.617 --> 00:27:39.923
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

211
00:27:40.243 --> 00:27:42.377
<v Sameer Kanal>Emergency response, including federal response.

212
00:27:42.490 --> 00:27:50.194
<v Dan Ryan>All right, I'll wait till we get to item 3 to hear how we've been working with our public Safety, um, of units, um, to prepare for this meeting today.

213
00:27:50.422 --> 00:27:50.680
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

214
00:27:52.942 --> 00:27:55.011
<v Sameer Kanal>This is an external stakeholder conversation.

215
00:27:55.108 --> 00:27:57.291
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll leave that, uh, I'll explain that when we get to that.

216
00:27:57.534 --> 00:27:58.375
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Councilor Green.

217
00:27:59.152 --> 00:28:00.493
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

218
00:28:00.769 --> 00:28:08.030
<v Mitch Green>Um, Councilor Novick, you, uh, your, your, um, request about the span of control is timely.

219
00:28:08.127 --> 00:28:13.256
<v Mitch Green>I, I was like literally talking about that, uh, with the city administrator right before I walked into this room.

220
00:28:14.104 --> 00:28:23.435
<v Mitch Green>Because there was a budget note that sort of got stranded from the connected amendment and my sort of chop from the top thing that failed.

221
00:28:23.500 --> 00:28:25.476
<v Mitch Green>But then the budget note itself survived.

222
00:28:26.792 --> 00:28:28.833
<v Mitch Green>And so he's working on that right now.

223
00:28:28.961 --> 00:28:34.535
<v Mitch Green>And so I just, I want to make sure we're not, we don't have multiple span of control conversations happening simultaneously.

224
00:28:34.583 --> 00:28:39.128
<v Mitch Green>And so I don't know if it's this committee or if it's a work session after he's done.

225
00:28:39.210 --> 00:28:42.165
<v Mitch Green>Kind of done that work, but, um, I welcome that.

226
00:28:42.936 --> 00:28:48.030
<v Mitch Green>I, I want to say we— if we go into the next budget not having that conversation, we'll have done ourselves a disservice.

227
00:28:48.865 --> 00:28:51.308
<v Mitch Green>Um, so thanks, thanks for bringing that up.

228
00:28:51.759 --> 00:28:58.652
<v Mitch Green>And also, I'm eager to get to City Code 3-02 at some point soon.

229
00:28:59.086 --> 00:29:05.852
<v Mitch Green>So I see that it's penciled in for September, but I, but I really want to vote for something that makes it so you can't do floor amendments 'Cause I'm tired of them.

230
00:29:06.787 --> 00:29:09.896
<v Mitch Green>So let's, let's get, let's get that one going as soon as we can.

231
00:29:10.026 --> 00:29:10.622
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

232
00:29:11.878 --> 00:29:12.749
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, Councilor Green.

233
00:29:15.769 --> 00:29:18.238
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing no one else in the queue, thank you everybody.

234
00:29:18.351 --> 00:29:19.884
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, we'll move on to item 2.

235
00:29:19.949 --> 00:29:21.223
<v Sameer Kanal>Diego, could you please call item 2?

236
00:29:22.740 --> 00:29:35.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 2, document number 2026-289, appoint members to the New Portlanders Policy Commission for terms beginning September thank you.

237
00:29:35.843 --> 00:29:38.730
<v Sameer Kanal>And we'll invite up presenting from the administration.

238
00:29:38.795 --> 00:29:49.556
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe we have Interim Chief Engagement Officer Laura Oppenheimer, as well as our Immigrant and Refugee Coordinator Wafa Almutairi, and the Secretary of the New Portlanders Policy Commission, Jorge Sanchez-Bautista.

239
00:29:49.605 --> 00:29:53.859
<v Sameer Kanal>But as you start, please introduce yourself the first time you speak.

240
00:29:53.990 --> 00:29:54.250
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

241
00:29:55.061 --> 00:29:56.248
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Good morning, councilors.

242
00:29:56.579 --> 00:29:58.234
<v Laura Oppenheimer>For the record, I'm Laura Oppenheimer.

243
00:29:58.298 --> 00:29:59.873
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I use she and her pronouns.

244
00:30:00.131 --> 00:30:16.503
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I'm the city's Chief Communications Officer, but today I am proud to be wearing my hat as the Chief Engagement Officer, which means that I have the pleasure of introducing the recommended reappointments and appointments to the New Portlanders Policy Commission.

245
00:30:17.131 --> 00:30:22.464
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Just want to take a moment to reflect that we have now had this commission for a decade.

246
00:30:23.262 --> 00:30:36.257
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This is a really lovely opportunity, I think, to reflect back on some of the accomplishments and achievements of the committee, but also to look forward at the opportunities we have with some new members.

247
00:30:38.016 --> 00:30:50.930
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Given the national climate right now and some of the commitments this council and the city have made to our immigrant and refugee communities, this commission provides a really vital resource in terms of the expertise thank you.

248
00:30:50.930 --> 00:30:50.930
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you, Councilor Smith, for the introduction.

249
00:30:50.930 --> 00:30:57.849
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I wanna thank all of our members for the expertise and lived experience they bring and being here to advise us and help us move that work forward.

250
00:30:58.990 --> 00:31:09.079
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You'll hear today about the 17 members who are being recommended to either remain on the commission or join the commission.

251
00:31:09.250 --> 00:31:11.799
<v Laura Oppenheimer>That is a significant reset.

252
00:31:12.509 --> 00:31:25.439
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And you'll hear that we wound up doing this recruitment in a 2-phase process to really ensure that we had an applicant pool reflecting of the city as a whole and the geography.

253
00:31:25.550 --> 00:31:28.934
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And that's what our team will be able to bring you here today.

254
00:31:30.201 --> 00:31:41.058
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Wafa Almaghtari is the amazing coordinator who leads this work as our immigrant and refugee coordinator within Civic Life.

255
00:31:41.172 --> 00:31:43.127
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This commission is an important part of that.

256
00:31:43.271 --> 00:31:50.280
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And then Jorge Sanchez-Bautista is the secretary of the New Portlanders Policy Commission.

257
00:31:51.451 --> 00:31:54.051
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You will see also recommended for reappointment.

258
00:31:54.116 --> 00:31:58.284
<v Laura Oppenheimer>He has graciously agreed to stay on and continue serving the city.

259
00:31:58.413 --> 00:32:00.915
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I'll turn it to Wafa.

260
00:32:02.916 --> 00:32:08.645
<v Wafa Almutairi>Good morning, Committee Chair Kanal, Vice Chair Dan, Vice Chair Tiffany, and members of the committee.

261
00:32:08.887 --> 00:32:09.613
<v Wafa Almutairi>Y'all hear me okay?

262
00:32:09.837 --> 00:32:10.545
<v Wafa Almutairi>Is my mic working?

263
00:32:11.123 --> 00:32:11.718
<v Loretta Smith>I can't hear you.

264
00:32:12.746 --> 00:32:13.356
<v Wafa Almutairi>Now it's on.

265
00:32:14.835 --> 00:32:15.526
<v Wafa Almutairi>But good morning.

266
00:32:16.827 --> 00:32:18.017
<v Wafa Almutairi>My name is Wafa Almaghdari.

267
00:32:18.193 --> 00:32:21.317
<v Wafa Almutairi>I am the Immigrant and Refugee Coordinator for the Office of Community and Civic Life.

268
00:32:22.066 --> 00:32:26.933
<v Wafa Almutairi>I'm also the staff liaison for the Newport-Lander Policy Commission, NPPC for short.

269
00:32:27.500 --> 00:32:31.575
<v Wafa Almutairi>Today, I am pleased to present the recommended appointment and reappointments to the commission.

270
00:32:31.834 --> 00:32:35.537
<v Wafa Almutairi>For today's agenda, we'll begin with a brief overview of the commission.

271
00:32:36.054 --> 00:32:46.086
<v Wafa Almutairi>Then we'll share the recruitment selection process, introduce the individuals recommended for appointment and reappointment, highlight the collective strengths they bring, and conclude with the action requested today.

272
00:32:47.624 --> 00:32:51.494
<v Wafa Almutairi>Here's some photos of the Newport-Lander Policy Commission leaders in action.

273
00:32:53.457 --> 00:32:57.949
<v Wafa Almutairi>On the left is Golzar, who has passed away and no longer with us.

274
00:32:58.045 --> 00:32:59.056
<v Wafa Almutairi>May she rest in peace.

275
00:32:59.568 --> 00:33:11.954
<v Wafa Almutairi>But she was one of the NPPC leaders who brought the Turkish community to the city and truly connected immigrant and refugee communities from Türkiye to explore what the city has to offer for them.

276
00:33:12.067 --> 00:33:17.153
<v Wafa Almutairi>We even turned the City of Portland building first floor in 2024 like a Turkish festival.

277
00:33:17.376 --> 00:33:18.517
<v Wafa Almutairi>Felt like a mini Istanbul.

278
00:33:19.125 --> 00:33:20.041
<v Wafa Almutairi>And it was beautiful.

279
00:33:20.330 --> 00:33:27.798
<v Wafa Almutairi>I can talk forever about all the amazing things that the leaders have accomplished, but now we want to transition to recruitment.

280
00:33:27.878 --> 00:33:33.692
<v Wafa Almutairi>And before we do that, it's my honor to introduce Jorge, who is the current secretary for the NPPC.

281
00:33:34.078 --> 00:33:38.672
<v Wafa Almutairi>He'll walk us through the next few slides and provide some context about the NPPC and the work.

282
00:33:39.779 --> 00:33:43.121
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Good morning, Chair Kanal, Vice Chairs Ryan and Koyama Lane, and members of the committee.

283
00:33:43.377 --> 00:33:45.112
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>It's a privilege to be before you again.

284
00:33:45.642 --> 00:33:47.424
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>For the record, Jorge Sanchez-Bautista.

285
00:33:47.554 --> 00:33:53.464
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>And as Wafa had mentioned, I have the privilege of serving as the Secretary of the New Portland Energy Policy Commission, or MPPC.

286
00:33:53.609 --> 00:33:57.079
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>I'm stepping in for our current chair who couldn't make it here today in person.

287
00:33:57.931 --> 00:34:04.147
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>But alongside Wafa, I'm here to present the recent work of the MPPC as well as our recommended nominees for council approval.

288
00:34:05.642 --> 00:34:08.099
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Should have known this was happening.

289
00:34:08.436 --> 00:34:27.507
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>And as Director Oppenheimer mentioned, in 2016, during the first term of the first term of President Trump, the city alongside community organizations and community leaders established the New Portlanders Policy Commission to bring the voices, priorities, and experiences of immigrant and refugee communities into local policies and services.

290
00:34:28.260 --> 00:34:35.811
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Under Chapter 3.131 of City Code, the NPPC advises the mayor, city council, city administrator, and city bureaus.

291
00:34:36.661 --> 00:34:44.693
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>And I would like to also take a moment to recognize the Office of Community and Civic Life for its continued support and work over the past decade.

292
00:34:45.320 --> 00:34:52.199
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Even aimed— or due services and funding, they have continued to show up for and support Portland's immigrant and refugee communities.

293
00:34:53.050 --> 00:34:53.563
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Next slide, please.

294
00:34:54.717 --> 00:35:02.385
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Since the beginning of 2026, the MPPC has worked on several initiatives to support Portland's immigrant and refugee communities.

295
00:35:02.432 --> 00:35:19.318
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>As you can see on the slide, we have collaborated with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney to allocate $150,000 to SOAR legal services, supported the planning of Welcoming Week and its many community events, and has— and have been working with the League of Women Voters to organize a voter registration and civic education event.

296
00:35:20.126 --> 00:35:28.862
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>We hope to encourage newly naturalized citizens to participate in the upcoming November election and strengthen civic engagement within our immigrant communities.

297
00:35:29.521 --> 00:35:32.157
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Next slide.

298
00:35:32.253 --> 00:35:42.333
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>And on behalf of the commission, we continue to extend an invitation to you all to attend our meetings and use the New Portlanders Policy Commission as a resource and advisory body.

299
00:35:43.264 --> 00:36:00.878
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Our leadership team, which includes myself and our chair Marita Kritz, who unfortunately couldn't make it today, has been coordinating with WFAA and Civic Life staff to bring elected officials, CBOs, community-based organizations, and government agencies before us to the commission.

300
00:36:01.858 --> 00:36:13.793
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>This is the work of the commission by collaborating with elected officials, CBOs, government agencies to create a direct connection between city government and the communities we represent.

301
00:36:14.788 --> 00:36:22.614
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>We bring information and resources back to our communities while also bringing their experiences and concerns and priorities back to the city.

302
00:36:23.833 --> 00:36:32.335
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Ultimately, that is the purpose of having this advisory body like the MPPC to create a meaningful bridge between our communities and city government.

303
00:36:33.043 --> 00:36:42.496
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>If we are not engaging with one another and creating those connections, I just have to say, like, then we have to ask ourselves, what is the purpose of having this body?

304
00:36:45.003 --> 00:36:45.342
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Next slide, please.

305
00:36:46.650 --> 00:36:53.898
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>The creation of the new immigrant affairs liaison within the Office of the Mayor has been an incredible resource for the commission.

306
00:36:54.280 --> 00:36:57.518
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>We have now a direct line of communication to the mayor's office.

307
00:36:58.106 --> 00:37:05.153
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>With the Immigrant Affairs liaison providing monthly updates, answering questions, and working to ensure that information reaches our communities.

308
00:37:06.228 --> 00:37:13.918
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>This has been a clear demonstration of how strong— stronger communication between city leadership and immigrant communities can work in practice.

309
00:37:15.396 --> 00:37:17.193
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Next slide.

310
00:37:17.788 --> 00:37:24.802
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>The commission can now consist of 25 members, with each member serving a 3-year term with option to renew once.

311
00:37:24.900 --> 00:37:25.108
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Yes.

312
00:37:25.333 --> 00:37:26.664
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>For a maximum of 6 years.

313
00:37:27.563 --> 00:37:46.003
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Commissioners are responsible for attending, as it states right there, monthly meetings, supporting the coordination and planning of Welcoming Week, representing the commission at events, and advising the city on issues affecting immigrant and refugee communities, and serving on committees and work groups as needed.

314
00:37:47.320 --> 00:37:54.396
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>In accordance with city code, commissioners must live, work, volunteer, worship, or attend an educational institution within city limits.

315
00:37:55.262 --> 00:38:02.605
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>In addition, bringing of lived experience and a commitment to Portland's immigrant and refugees communities.

316
00:38:03.599 --> 00:38:08.311
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Lastly, I will say that these responsibilities are more than just filling seats.

317
00:38:08.648 --> 00:38:15.878
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>They are about ensuring that voices, experiences, and priorities of our immigrant communities have a direct path to City Hall.

318
00:38:16.664 --> 00:38:19.021
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>And I'll pass it back to Wafa.

319
00:38:20.449 --> 00:38:25.811
<v Wafa Almutairi>Our initial recruitment began end of 2024 and continued into 2025.

320
00:38:25.891 --> 00:38:33.117
<v Wafa Almutairi>One of the gaps we identified in the original applicant pool was geographic representation, particularly from District 1 and District 2.

321
00:38:33.599 --> 00:38:43.907
<v Wafa Almutairi>Because representation matters for the commission, we made a decision to relaunch recruitment in April 2026 rather than simply move forward with the pool we had.

322
00:38:44.293 --> 00:38:53.059
<v Wafa Almutairi>From May through June, we conducted additional outreach through community-based organizations, partner networks, uh, with intentional outreach focused on District 1 and District 2.

323
00:38:53.751 --> 00:39:00.385
<v Wafa Almutairi>Um, applications were then reviewed by current NPPC commissioners in July, and recommendations were developed for appointment.

324
00:39:00.916 --> 00:39:04.849
<v Wafa Almutairi>Today brings us to the final step, council consideration and confirmation.

325
00:39:08.684 --> 00:39:13.851
<v Wafa Almutairi>Um, across the 2 recruitment periods, we reviewed a total of 38 applications.

326
00:39:13.967 --> 00:39:22.309
<v Wafa Almutairi>We received 29 applications to end of 2024-2025 recruitment, additional 9 applications through the 2026 recruitment.

327
00:39:22.710 --> 00:39:37.918
<v Wafa Almutairi>The applicant pool reflected significant racial, ethnic, cultural, professional, and lived experience diversity, including applicants identify as Asian, African, Hispanic or Latino, Pacific Islander, Middle Eastern, multicultural, and diverse backgrounds.

328
00:39:38.335 --> 00:39:56.047
<v Wafa Almutairi>That diversity is important because NPPC is intended to bring perspective when it comes to the selection process, current NPPC commissioner participated directly in reviewing the applications and developing the recommendations before you today.

329
00:39:56.934 --> 00:40:09.960
<v Wafa Almutairi>The selection process considered several factors, including lived experience, connection to immigrant refugee communities, community involvement, professional volunteer experience, geographic representation, and interest in contributing to the work.

330
00:40:10.137 --> 00:40:10.233
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you.

331
00:40:10.378 --> 00:40:12.889
<v Wafa Almutairi>Councilmember And the mission of the NPPC.

332
00:40:13.530 --> 00:40:17.721
<v Wafa Almutairi>From the 38 applications reviewed, 17 individuals are being recommended.

333
00:40:17.784 --> 00:40:20.900
<v Wafa Almutairi>That includes 13 new appointments and 4 reappointments.

334
00:40:21.862 --> 00:40:25.251
<v Wafa Almutairi>Geographic representation was an important consideration through this process.

335
00:40:26.036 --> 00:40:32.298
<v Wafa Almutairi>Of the 17 nominees, 15 reside within Portland with representation across all 4 city council districts.

336
00:40:32.378 --> 00:40:37.179
<v Wafa Almutairi>2 Nominees reside outside of Portland but meet the commission's eligibility requirements.

337
00:40:37.599 --> 00:40:43.882
<v Wafa Almutairi>Through another qualifying connection to Portland, such as working, attending school, owning business, or worshiping within the city.

338
00:40:45.413 --> 00:40:48.327
<v Wafa Almutairi>This allows us to maintain a strong geographic representation.

339
00:40:50.135 --> 00:40:50.603
<v Wafa Almutairi>Next slide, please.

340
00:40:51.666 --> 00:40:56.838
<v Wafa Almutairi>At this point, I would like to recognize individuals being recommended for appointment and reappointment.

341
00:40:56.902 --> 00:41:04.773
<v Wafa Almutairi>The following slides show the names of the nominees along a short quote of each person about why they want to serve on the NPPC.

342
00:41:05.307 --> 00:41:15.184
<v Wafa Almutairi>I'm going to move through these slides as we hear from nominees, giving them the opportunity to introduce themselves and speak for themselves about how— who they are and why they want to serve.

343
00:41:15.634 --> 00:41:20.307
<v Wafa Almutairi>We want to provide nominees— we wanted to provide nominees with different ways to participate today.

344
00:41:20.724 --> 00:41:27.822
<v Wafa Almutairi>So some are joining us virtually, some are here with us in person, and others have provided pre-recorded introductions.

345
00:41:27.936 --> 00:41:34.728
<v Wafa Almutairi>We'll begin with those joining us live virtually, followed by our in-person nominees, and then the pre-recorded introductions.

346
00:41:35.389 --> 00:41:45.273
<v Wafa Almutairi>Um, to the nominees, as you introduce yourself, please briefly share your name, um, whether you are being appointed or reappointed, and a little about yourself and why you're interested in serving on NPPC.

347
00:41:45.565 --> 00:41:49.253
<v Wafa Almutairi>Virtual speakers can speak.

348
00:41:54.356 --> 00:41:58.143
<v Unidentified speaker>We have Marita Kritz online as well as Mary Karam.

349
00:42:02.282 --> 00:42:03.693
<v Mary Karam>Good morning, Council.

350
00:42:03.742 --> 00:42:08.943
<v Mary Karam>My name is Mary Karam, and I am a domestic relations attorney in the Tri-County area.

351
00:42:09.360 --> 00:42:11.173
<v Mary Karam>I'm also a resident of District 1.

352
00:42:11.833 --> 00:42:23.438
<v Mary Karam>More importantly, I am a Syrian immigrant who moved to Portland with my family many years ago, and we've continued to make Portland our home, and Portland has allowed us to, to feel at home here.

353
00:42:24.193 --> 00:42:27.853
<v Mary Karam>I am seeking reappointment to the new Portlanders Policy Commission.

354
00:42:28.222 --> 00:42:41.275
<v Mary Karam>Because I deeply value the opportunities to serve and help ensure— serve and help ensure that Portland's policies and services reflect the experiences, needs, and contributions of immigrants and refugee communities.

355
00:42:41.934 --> 00:42:48.902
<v Mary Karam>As an immigrant myself, I have personally experienced how meaningful it is to feel welcomed, heard, and included in community.

356
00:42:49.561 --> 00:42:58.280
<v Mary Karam>I'm especially grateful for Portland's commitment to engaging with immigrant communities in creating opportunities for new Portlanders to participate in civic life.

357
00:42:58.889 --> 00:43:12.023
<v Mary Karam>Portland has given me a sense of belonging and made me feel that I have a home away from home, and I hope to continue contributing my professional experience as an attorney, my lived experience, and my commitment to equity and inclusion to the commission.

358
00:43:12.362 --> 00:43:15.443
<v Mary Karam>I would be honored to continue this work through a reappointment.

359
00:43:15.829 --> 00:43:16.166
<v Mary Karam>Thank you.

360
00:43:27.849 --> 00:43:28.876
<v Stacy Harper>Good morning, councilors.

361
00:43:28.989 --> 00:43:37.445
<v Stacy Harper>My name is Maritza Kritz, and I'm honored to be reappointed to the New Portlanders Policy Commission, where I currently serve as chair.

362
00:43:38.280 --> 00:43:47.184
<v Stacy Harper>My background is in social services and behavioral health, and throughout my career, I've worked alongside diverse communities and seen firsthand the impact of systemic racism.

363
00:43:47.282 --> 00:43:54.619
<v Stacy Harper>Hand how language, culture, and access can create barriers to services, resources, and opportunities.

364
00:43:55.356 --> 00:44:08.608
<v Stacy Harper>I'm also the founder of Latino Outdoors Portland Chapter, where I've worked to create welcoming spaces for Latino families, build community connections, and help ensure people feel a sense of belonging.

365
00:44:09.617 --> 00:44:21.684
<v Stacy Harper>I want to continue serving as NPPC because Portland's Immigrant and refugee communities deserve to have a meaningful voice in the decisions that affect their lives.

366
00:44:22.427 --> 00:44:33.014
<v Stacy Harper>As chair, I am committed to bringing people together, strengthening community voices, and helping ensure Portland is a city where everyone feels welcome, represented, and heard.

367
00:44:33.402 --> 00:44:35.942
<v Stacy Harper>Thank you for the opportunity to continue serving.

368
00:44:38.530 --> 00:44:40.224
<v Unidentified speaker>We also have Devin Tao online.

369
00:44:42.248 --> 00:44:43.637
<v Sameer Kanal>Good morning to the council members.

370
00:44:43.702 --> 00:44:43.960
<v Sameer Kanal>Ni hao.

371
00:44:44.268 --> 00:44:49.166
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is Devon Pei Fan Tao, and I'm honored to be appointed to the New Portlanders Policy Commission.

372
00:44:49.764 --> 00:44:54.530
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm a gay filmmaker, small business owner, and longtime Portlander in District 4.

373
00:44:55.016 --> 00:45:03.219
<v Sameer Kanal>Much of my work has been focused on storytelling, community engagement, and creating space for people whose voices and experiences are often underrepresented.

374
00:45:04.202 --> 00:45:12.585
<v Sameer Kanal>As an Asian immigrant myself, I understand how important belonging, access, and representation can be when building a life in a new city and a new country.

375
00:45:13.420 --> 00:45:21.416
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm interested in serving on the MPPC because I believe immigrant and refugee communities should have a meaningful voice in the decisions that affect them.

376
00:45:22.315 --> 00:45:31.612
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope to bring my experience in storytelling, coalition building, and civic engagement to the commission while also listening and learning from the many communities that make Portland home.

377
00:45:32.126 --> 00:45:32.351
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

378
00:45:37.655 --> 00:45:38.012
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you.

379
00:45:38.467 --> 00:45:44.697
<v Wafa Almutairi>Um, now I would like to invite our first 3 in-person nominees to come forward to the podium.

380
00:45:45.811 --> 00:45:49.684
<v Wafa Almutairi>Um, so it's gonna be Alejandro, Cindy, and Jorge.

381
00:45:55.722 --> 00:45:56.677
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

382
00:45:59.407 --> 00:45:59.873
<v Luciani>Should I begin?

383
00:46:00.048 --> 00:46:00.322
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

384
00:46:00.788 --> 00:46:05.333
<v Yamungo Seraya>Okay, well, good morning, uh, Chair and, and, uh, councilors.

385
00:46:05.766 --> 00:46:08.014
<v Yamungo Seraya>Well, my name is Alejandro Martinez Ubieda.

386
00:46:08.239 --> 00:46:11.548
<v Yamungo Seraya>I am, um, not only an immigrant but a refugee.

387
00:46:12.175 --> 00:46:15.820
<v Yamungo Seraya>I've been here in Portland for a pretty short time.

388
00:46:15.900 --> 00:46:20.639
<v Yamungo Seraya>I came in 2024, um, uh, from Venezuela.

389
00:46:21.329 --> 00:46:25.264
<v Yamungo Seraya>Um, uh, my ground is I'm, I'm a political scientist.

390
00:46:25.521 --> 00:46:27.192
<v Yamungo Seraya>With a master's in environment.

391
00:46:27.753 --> 00:46:47.230
<v Yamungo Seraya>And I'm really very happy to be here, as many years in my life I've been linked to parliamentary institutions, because I worked for a long time in the parliament of my country, of Venezuela, as director of international relations, and also worked at the city council in Caracas.

392
00:46:47.278 --> 00:47:02.420
<v Yamungo Seraya>So I'm, uh, well, I'm very interested in, in bringing my experience in contributing to this city that we've, me and my family have made our home since the last 2 years.

393
00:47:02.516 --> 00:47:10.496
<v Yamungo Seraya>And it is a place in which I think we will stay for a very, very long time and a place that we like and we're happy to be here.

394
00:47:10.672 --> 00:47:14.911
<v Yamungo Seraya>So thank you very much for inviting us to be part of this committee.

395
00:47:18.088 --> 00:47:19.083
<v Cindy Chen>Good morning, Council.

396
00:47:19.307 --> 00:47:22.594
<v Cindy Chen>My name is Cindy Chen, and I am a Chinese immigrant.

397
00:47:22.916 --> 00:47:35.231
<v Cindy Chen>I came to the United States at the age of 5, and I was an avid participant in the Sun School program, which is Schools Uniting Communities program run by ERCCO in Multnomah County Schools.

398
00:47:35.824 --> 00:47:44.900
<v Cindy Chen>Through my experiences, I have been so honored to be able to give back to my community by tutoring students.

399
00:47:45.510 --> 00:47:58.371
<v Cindy Chen>And through my experiences, I've also been— I am incredibly interested in serving on the New Portlanders Policy Commission in order to advocate for language education opportunities in Portland.

400
00:47:58.579 --> 00:48:11.454
<v Cindy Chen>And when I first came to the United States, I found that, um, being pulled out of my classroom was incredibly isolating, and I want to make sure that people don't feel that same isolation anymore once they're trying to learn a new language.

401
00:48:11.842 --> 00:48:19.085
<v Cindy Chen>And so on my time, I hope to be an advocate— during my time, I hope to be an advocate for education and language learning opportunities.

402
00:48:19.670 --> 00:48:25.807
<v Cindy Chen>And I am honored to be appointed to serve on the New Portlanders Policy Commission.

403
00:48:26.181 --> 00:48:26.568
<v Cindy Chen>Thank you.

404
00:48:28.505 --> 00:48:29.182
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you all.

405
00:48:29.554 --> 00:48:33.297
<v Wafa Almutairi>Uh, now I would like to invite our next group of nominees to come forward.

406
00:48:52.514 --> 00:48:53.380
<v Wafa Almutairi>Who wants to start?

407
00:48:54.280 --> 00:48:55.130
<v Wafa Almutairi>Breena, you go ahead.

408
00:48:55.483 --> 00:48:57.153
<v Breena Bolans>Hi, my name is Breena Bolans.

409
00:48:57.266 --> 00:48:58.358
<v Breena Bolans>I'm a 28-year-old—.

410
00:48:58.534 --> 00:48:58.726
<v Breena Bolans>20—.

411
00:48:58.726 --> 00:49:01.777
<v Breena Bolans>Not 28-year-old, definitely not 28-year-old.

412
00:49:02.097 --> 00:49:03.202
<v Breena Bolans>28-Year Portlander.

413
00:49:04.516 --> 00:49:11.284
<v Breena Bolans>When I graduated college a long time ago, obviously a long time ago, I did the Europe backpacker thing.

414
00:49:11.623 --> 00:49:16.688
<v Breena Bolans>I was your average middle-class white girl, and I'd never even been out of the country before.

415
00:49:18.150 --> 00:49:25.550
<v Breena Bolans>But the urge to understand the world stuck with me, and I spent many years after that traveling and living and working in a whole host of different countries.

416
00:49:26.289 --> 00:49:27.159
<v Breena Bolans>And it taught me 2 things.

417
00:49:27.992 --> 00:49:31.108
<v Breena Bolans>One, being in an unfamiliar culture is not an easy thing.

418
00:49:31.867 --> 00:49:35.079
<v Breena Bolans>Second, it seems basic, but people everywhere are really the same.

419
00:49:35.402 --> 00:49:40.809
<v Breena Bolans>There's small differences in details, but they have the same needs and fears and joys.

420
00:49:40.923 --> 00:49:43.324
<v Breena Bolans>And I truly wish that all Americans understood this.

421
00:49:45.039 --> 00:49:49.137
<v Breena Bolans>Over the years, a focus of mine has become the importance of housing, of stable housing.

422
00:49:50.860 --> 00:49:55.155
<v Breena Bolans>Growing up, I helped my parents with their rent, their little rental properties, and I now own a rental property myself.

423
00:49:56.257 --> 00:49:59.949
<v Breena Bolans>I've been a volunteer for Habitat for Humanity for over a decade.

424
00:50:01.211 --> 00:50:10.318
<v Breena Bolans>Back when the Ukraine war started, I had friends and I, we organized donations and were able to house Ukrainian refugees' families and help them get jobs.

425
00:50:12.556 --> 00:50:21.878
<v Breena Bolans>More recently, I was a manager in multifamily low-income housing downtown, and as you can imagine, many of the residents were from all different countries.

426
00:50:22.327 --> 00:50:27.346
<v Breena Bolans>And I spent a lot of time in my office sitting with them, helping them navigate their new life.

427
00:50:28.336 --> 00:50:38.713
<v Breena Bolans>I've seen the trauma that people have gone through, through problems with housing, and how stable housing plus a welcoming and supportive community helps newcomers thrive.

428
00:50:40.702 --> 00:50:46.559
<v Breena Bolans>So I'm excited to join this commission and all of you to develop the best supports possible for our newest neighbors.

429
00:50:46.916 --> 00:50:47.157
<v Yamungo Seraya>Thank you.

430
00:50:50.867 --> 00:50:51.257
<v Yamungo Seraya>Good morning.

431
00:50:52.425 --> 00:50:53.625
<v Yamungo Seraya>My name is Yamungo Seraya.

432
00:50:55.199 --> 00:50:58.293
<v Yamungo Seraya>I'm being appointed to the New Portland City Commission.

433
00:51:00.199 --> 00:51:01.487
<v Yamungo Seraya>I live in District 1.

434
00:51:03.034 --> 00:51:14.559
<v Yamungo Seraya>As an immigrant from the Republic Democratic of Congo, located in Central Africa, I understand the experience and challenges many immigrant and refugees community face.

435
00:51:16.409 --> 00:51:28.541
<v Yamungo Seraya>I've been involved in, uh, my community, community leadership, serving as a, uh, president or leaders of African community, uh, coalition.

436
00:51:32.958 --> 00:51:39.518
<v Yamungo Seraya>I've been involved in the community leadership and engaged and advocate— advocated for my community.

437
00:51:40.766 --> 00:51:44.153
<v Yamungo Seraya>Helping connect the community with local government.

438
00:51:45.454 --> 00:52:03.786
<v Yamungo Seraya>I'm interested in serving in this NPPC because I want to ensure that the voice and lived experience of new Portlanders are represented in Portland policies and decisions.

439
00:52:05.199 --> 00:52:12.581
<v Yamungo Seraya>I'm honored to serve and look forward to contributing to a more welcoming and inclusive Portland.

440
00:52:13.371 --> 00:52:13.612
<v Yamungo Seraya>Thank you.

441
00:52:17.300 --> 00:52:17.702
<v Marisa Tapia>Good morning.

442
00:52:18.844 --> 00:52:24.521
<v Marisa Tapia>My name is Marisa Tapia, and I'm honored to be appointed to the new Portlanders Policy Commission.

443
00:52:25.775 --> 00:52:35.981
<v Marisa Tapia>As a first-generation Mexican-American born to immigrant parents, I have witnessed firsthand both the challenges and resilience of immigrant communities.

444
00:52:36.976 --> 00:52:50.083
<v Marisa Tapia>As a clinical social worker with a background in mental health and social justice, my work has been driven by a passion for creating more equitable and culturally responsive systems.

445
00:52:51.237 --> 00:52:59.778
<v Marisa Tapia>In my current role, I support unaccompanied minors, helping them navigate complex systems, trauma, and the challenges of rebuilding their lives.

446
00:53:00.853 --> 00:53:22.248
<v Marisa Tapia>Given the heightened, um, sorry, given the heightened social and political climate affecting immigrant, refugee, and asylum-seeking communities, I felt a strong call to action to bring that experience to the local level and continue contributing to the Portland community.

447
00:53:23.467 --> 00:53:35.733
<v Marisa Tapia>I applied to the NPPC Because I believe immigrant and refugee communities deserve not only representation but a meaningful voice in the policies that affect their lives.

448
00:53:36.648 --> 00:53:51.148
<v Marisa Tapia>I look forward to working alongside such a diverse and passionate group of community members— excuse me— community members who are committed to centering the voices and needs of these communities and ensuring they are meaningfully represented in local action.

449
00:53:52.065 --> 00:53:53.885
<v Marisa Tapia>Thank you for the opportunity to serve.

450
00:53:54.545 --> 00:54:01.351
<v Marisa Tapia>I look forward to the work ahead and to contributing to a more inclusive, equitable, and welcoming Portland.

451
00:54:03.050 --> 00:54:18.369
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>And while Wafa transitions to our recorded videos, again, Jorge, and I'm seeking reappointment to the commission as my background consists of a son of Mexican immigrants as well as a supporter and advocate of Portland Public Schools.

452
00:54:19.873 --> 00:54:30.181
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>Which assists newly arrived students from different parts of the world adapt to the US education system and prepare them for their academic journey throughout high school.

453
00:54:31.639 --> 00:54:44.833
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>And I believe in the important work of equity and experience, especially when it comes to young people in Hispanic communities during this current political, social, economic, I can go on, but this current climate right now.

454
00:54:45.521 --> 00:54:56.268
<v Jorge Sanchez-Bautista>And I hope to work alongside a diverse group of people in ensuring this body brings in all these experiences and to support and have these people heard and represented.

455
00:54:57.760 --> 00:54:58.597
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you all so much.

456
00:55:00.320 --> 00:55:09.768
<v Wafa Almutairi>For nominees who are unable to join us live today, we also provided an opportunity to submit a, a brief pre-recorded, um, introduction, so we'll hear from them now.

457
00:55:12.231 --> 00:55:13.349
<v Luciani>Good afternoon, councilors.

458
00:55:14.110 --> 00:55:19.204
<v Luciani>My name is Luciani, and I'm honored to be recommended for the new Portlanders Policy Commission.

459
00:55:20.039 --> 00:55:27.393
<v Luciani>I was born in Brazil to a family with European and Afro-Brazilian roots, and I came into Portland as an immigrant myself.

460
00:55:28.293 --> 00:55:36.673
<v Luciani>I know how difficult it can be to rebuild a life in a new country and to figure out systems that were not designed with foreigners in mind.

461
00:55:37.606 --> 00:55:53.661
<v Luciani>Professionally, I received my master's degree at Portland State University and Engineering Technology Management, and I have spent many years working for IT and HR departments at Oregon companies like Nike and Corvo.

462
00:55:55.143 --> 00:56:05.588
<v Luciani>Portland has given me a beautiful place to live and work, and I would like to help the city make this easier for those that are going through a similar experience as myself.

463
00:56:06.690 --> 00:56:18.820
<v Luciani>For me personally, it's important to create a place where people feel All Portlanders should feel safe and supported, no matter what their race, country of birth, gender, or the way they speak.

464
00:56:19.878 --> 00:56:27.621
<v Luciani>There is lots of tension in our nation right now, and I hope I can help somehow to reduce it in our community.

465
00:56:28.278 --> 00:56:29.706
<v Luciani>Thank you for your consideration.

466
00:56:30.668 --> 00:56:32.590
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Hello, my name is Tiffany Koyama Lane.

467
00:56:33.329 --> 00:56:51.967
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm currently on the Commission for New Portlander Policy And I would like to continue to serve on this commission because I bring relevant experiences as an immigrant and as an ABE ESL teacher, and I also bring the passion to move things forward.

468
00:56:52.144 --> 00:56:54.661
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And the last 2 years, I think, were productive.

469
00:56:55.391 --> 00:56:59.650
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'd like to continue to contribute, and I look forward to doing so.

470
00:57:01.393 --> 00:57:01.992
<v Stacy Harper>Hi everyone.

471
00:57:02.572 --> 00:57:10.679
<v Stacy Harper>My name is Linda Lee, and I'm interested in joining the Newport Lenders Policy Commission because of where I come from.

472
00:57:11.608 --> 00:57:17.168
<v Sameer Kanal>I grew up in a low-income immigrant community, and I came to America as a refugee.

473
00:57:18.195 --> 00:57:35.632
<v Sameer Kanal>Today I have a career in finance, but growing up, no one in my community had access to that kind of knowledge, so I want to give back by educating and encouraging basic financial literacy That's the impact I hope to make on this commission.

474
00:57:36.228 --> 00:57:36.648
<v Erica Moseson>Thank you.

475
00:57:39.617 --> 00:57:43.402
<v Dan Ryan>Hi, my name is Evan Ripple, and I'm a North Portland resident.

476
00:57:43.481 --> 00:57:44.429
<v Dan Ryan>I live in St. Johns.

477
00:57:45.329 --> 00:57:54.998
<v Dan Ryan>I'm interested in joining the New Portlanders Policy Commission or committee because as a regular Oregon Food Bank volunteer, I've seen the impact that food insecurity has on people.

478
00:57:55.389 --> 00:58:02.213
<v Dan Ryan>I've witnessed firsthand just how barriers can affect people, and I would like to turn those frustrations into policy change.

479
00:58:02.630 --> 00:58:02.952
<v Erica Moseson>Thank you.

480
00:58:03.851 --> 00:58:06.516
<v Sameer Kanal>Hello, my name is Jeada Jefferson Fehmoifiafi.

481
00:58:06.902 --> 00:58:13.614
<v Sameer Kanal>I grew up in Portland, and I've been a therapist in the community in Portland for the last 27 years.

482
00:58:14.271 --> 00:58:34.938
<v Wafa Almutairi>I'm married to an immigrant, and I'm very eager to both understand and help affect And, um, I have one video to play that we were not able to embed in the PowerPoint because this was last minute, but I would like to take a moment to do it.

483
00:58:35.018 --> 00:58:35.744
<v Wafa Almutairi>Just give me one second.

484
00:58:41.800 --> 00:58:42.364
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Good morning.

485
00:58:42.784 --> 00:58:46.414
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am Jeljka Karol-Kekez, and I was born and raised in Split, Croatia.

486
00:58:47.195 --> 00:58:49.166
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And arrived in Portland in 2002.

487
00:58:50.159 --> 00:58:56.297
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Over the past 24 years, Portland has been my home, my community, and the place where I built my life and a career.

488
00:58:57.226 --> 00:59:07.577
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm urban designer and the founder of PLACE, a global landscape architecture design studio with Galleria, committed to social impact through community stewardship and art.

489
00:59:08.346 --> 00:59:19.362
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Our partnerships locally include Portland Mercado, PDX Main Terminal, Nike Headquarters, North Park Blocks, PSU iTech, Willamette Falls Trust, and Gateway Discovery Park.

490
00:59:20.052 --> 00:59:33.684
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>However, my greatest passion is the next generation, and for past 15 years I've taught at Portland State University School of Architecture, and I also serve on governor-appointed Oregon State Landscape Architects Board and am involved with the immigrant story.

491
00:59:34.697 --> 00:59:44.847
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm especially honored to join the new Portlanders Policy Commission and help ensure newcomers have a voice opportunity to lead and a meaningful role in shaping Portland's future.

492
00:59:45.298 --> 00:59:46.088
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for the opportunity.

493
00:59:54.373 --> 00:59:55.476
<v Wafa Almutairi>Now we're at the beginning.

494
00:59:56.059 --> 00:59:59.056
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you everyone who shared their introductions with us today.

495
00:59:59.219 --> 01:00:06.153
<v Wafa Almutairi>I also want to specifically recognize the 4 commissioners being recommended for reappointment.

496
01:00:06.219 --> 01:00:07.980
<v Wafa Almutairi>They have already contributed their Thank you.

497
01:00:07.980 --> 01:00:07.980
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

498
01:00:07.980 --> 01:00:07.980
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

499
01:00:07.980 --> 01:00:15.460
<v Wafa Almutairi>Council members, thank you for your service and your time, lived experience, and expertise to NPPC, and we greatly appreciate their willingness to continue serving.

500
01:00:15.519 --> 01:00:32.559
<v Wafa Almutairi>I also want to take a moment to recognize and thank Carrie, Bernal, Sahar, Kalini, Mia, Mahad, Gulzar— may she rest in peace— Demet, Dr. Bahar, Masara, and Sankar for their services to the New Portlander Policy Commission.

501
01:00:32.559 --> 01:00:43.157
<v Wafa Almutairi>On behalf of the City of Portland and the Office of On behalf of the Committee on Civic Life, I want to express our sincere appreciation for the time, energy, lived experience, and leadership you have contributed to NPPC.

502
01:00:43.655 --> 01:00:47.297
<v Wafa Almutairi>Serving on a volunteer commission requires a real commitment.

503
01:00:47.425 --> 01:00:56.746
<v Wafa Almutairi>It means showing up, sharing your perspective, representing community voices, and helping the city think differently about how we engage and serve immigrant and refugee communities.

504
01:00:58.865 --> 01:01:01.306
<v Wafa Almutairi>Taken together— sorry, let me go back.

505
01:01:01.534 --> 01:01:07.146
<v Wafa Almutairi>Taken together, these nominees bring a broad and valuable range of experiences to the commission.

506
01:01:07.338 --> 01:01:21.583
<v Wafa Almutairi>They include people with immigrant refugee, first-gen, uh, lived experience, as well as experience in youth engagement, education, social work, mental health, housing, business, public administration, community organizing, advocacy, and community engagement.

507
01:01:21.632 --> 01:01:28.121
<v Wafa Almutairi>They also bring a multilingual and multicultural perspective and experiences working directly with communities in Portland.

508
01:01:28.827 --> 01:01:38.780
<v Wafa Almutairi>Most importantly, they share a commitment to equity, belonging, civic engagement, and strengthen the relationship between immigrant and refugee communities and city government.

509
01:01:39.389 --> 01:01:41.715
<v Wafa Almutairi>Our goal was not to simply fill seats.

510
01:01:42.291 --> 01:01:50.804
<v Wafa Almutairi>Our goal was to build a commission whose collective lived experience, knowledge, and perspective strengthens the quality of advice NPPC provides to the city.

511
01:01:51.588 --> 01:01:55.853
<v Wafa Almutairi>These commissioners will have an opportunity to begin engaging with the community very soon.

512
01:01:56.461 --> 01:02:11.664
<v Wafa Almutairi>Portland's Welcoming Week takes place September 10th through September 19th, and NPPC will be actively participating Throughout the week, commissioners will have opportunities to engage directly with immigrant refugee communities, community organizations, city leaders, and partners.

513
01:02:12.407 --> 01:02:19.487
<v Wafa Almutairi>This is one example of how NPPC commissioners move beyond monthly meetings and serve as an important bridge between community and city government.

514
01:02:20.967 --> 01:02:22.967
<v Wafa Almutairi>That brings to the action requested today.

515
01:02:23.630 --> 01:02:30.942
<v Wafa Almutairi>We respectfully request the committee approve the recommended 13 appointments and 4 reappointments to the Newport Under Policy Commission.

516
01:02:30.990 --> 01:02:33.137
<v Wafa Almutairi>These appointments will bring the commission to 17 members.

517
01:02:33.186 --> 01:02:33.365
<v Wafa Almutairi>Second.

518
01:02:36.639 --> 01:02:47.550
<v Wafa Almutairi>We want to thank our current NPPC commissioners who dedicated significant time reviewing applications and supporting this process.

519
01:02:47.679 --> 01:02:56.360
<v Wafa Almutairi>And most importantly, we want to thank all of the applicant— applicants and nominees who expressed an interest in serving their community and the city of Portland.

520
01:02:56.960 --> 01:03:02.059
<v Wafa Almutairi>We are grateful for their willingness to step forward, share their experience, and contribute their voices to city business.

521
01:03:02.059 --> 01:03:02.099
<v Wafa Almutairi>Councilmember Herbold.

522
01:03:03.043 --> 01:03:08.869
<v Wafa Almutairi>With that, we respectfully request the committee's approval of the recommended appointments and reappointments.

523
01:03:09.130 --> 01:03:09.340
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you.

524
01:03:12.039 --> 01:03:12.913
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Wafa.

525
01:03:13.235 --> 01:03:13.721
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Laura.

526
01:03:13.802 --> 01:03:15.128
<v Sameer Kanal>I also know Ocean's back there.

527
01:03:15.193 --> 01:03:21.451
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to everyone who supports, and thank you so much to the, the current members as well as the prospective new members.

528
01:03:22.030 --> 01:03:31.021
<v Sameer Kanal>Before we, uh, discuss the potential referral of this item onto the, the council, Um, I did want to note a couple things, and then we may have testimony.

529
01:03:31.599 --> 01:03:38.166
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, there are, uh, the, the— actually, are there testifiers?

530
01:03:39.177 --> 01:03:39.965
<v Sameer Kanal>No one has signed up.

531
01:03:40.222 --> 01:03:41.956
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, okay.

532
01:03:42.438 --> 01:03:57.172
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so colleagues, I have put up an amendment to this, and the reason for it is that, um, we learned earlier this week that this agenda item was submitted without the reappointed members noted on there.

533
01:03:57.237 --> 01:03:58.679
<v Sameer Kanal>It only had the appointees.

534
01:03:59.306 --> 01:04:08.126
<v Sameer Kanal>And so, uh, my office worked with Immigrant Refugee Coordinator Wafa Almutari at Civic Life to update this report with the amendment that you received by email and which is filed online.

535
01:04:08.751 --> 01:04:14.878
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, all names are now updated and presented in the, the sort of standard table which includes the start and end dates.

536
01:04:15.021 --> 01:04:19.862
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, after— I guess since we don't have testimony, I was going to float this and then take testimony.

537
01:04:21.219 --> 01:04:31.476
<v Sameer Kanal>Just in terms of this sort of technical addition of the 4 people we've heard from, I will move Canal 1 and ask for a second on that.

538
01:04:31.523 --> 01:04:31.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

539
01:04:32.054 --> 01:04:34.824
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, seconded by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

540
01:04:37.222 --> 01:04:39.327
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there any discussion on the amendment?

541
01:04:39.635 --> 01:04:42.454
<v Sameer Kanal>And then we'll have, as soon as the amendment is resolved, we'll have the broader discussion.

542
01:04:42.920 --> 01:04:44.817
<v Sameer Kanal>But this is just on the amendment.

543
01:04:46.686 --> 01:04:48.594
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing none, Diego, will you please call the roll?

544
01:04:50.210 --> 01:04:51.851
<v Sameer Kanal>Koyama Lane?

545
01:04:52.155 --> 01:04:52.204
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

546
01:04:53.186 --> 01:04:53.539
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

547
01:04:54.570 --> 01:04:54.697
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

548
01:04:55.775 --> 01:04:56.130
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

549
01:04:56.338 --> 01:04:56.387
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

550
01:04:57.481 --> 01:04:58.311
<v Dan Ryan>Clark?

551
01:04:58.458 --> 01:04:59.679
<v Unidentified speaker>Oops, sorry, absent.

552
01:05:00.166 --> 01:05:00.378
<v Chad Robison>Green?

553
01:05:01.532 --> 01:05:01.630
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

554
01:05:03.485 --> 01:05:03.679
<v Luciani>Avalos?

555
01:05:08.166 --> 01:05:08.601
<v Candace Avalos>Absent.

556
01:05:08.666 --> 01:05:09.038
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

557
01:05:09.619 --> 01:05:09.666
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

558
01:05:12.561 --> 01:05:12.577
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

559
01:05:14.161 --> 01:05:14.210
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

560
01:05:15.148 --> 01:05:16.184
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, we have to add the reappointments.

561
01:05:18.177 --> 01:05:18.193
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

562
01:05:18.739 --> 01:05:18.869
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

563
01:05:19.961 --> 01:05:27.706
<v Unidentified speaker>With 8 ayes and 2 absent votes, the motion to amend the report to add the 4 reappointments as shown in Kanal 1 is approved.

564
01:05:29.360 --> 01:05:30.106
<v Sameer Kanal>Great, thank you.

565
01:05:30.365 --> 01:05:39.583
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll now open this up to questions to staff or appointees or reappointees or members general discussion from the council or from the committee, I apologize.

566
01:05:39.822 --> 01:05:42.313
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney followed by Councilor Smith.

567
01:05:43.454 --> 01:05:44.530
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

568
01:05:44.755 --> 01:05:51.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>First of all, thank you to everybody who's stepping into this role either as a reappointee or for the first time.

569
01:05:51.902 --> 01:05:59.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate everything that you are bringing to the city and the way in which you will help us do a better job serving all Portlanders.

570
01:06:00.335 --> 01:06:06.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While I do have one question, It looks like your entire commission is up for appointment today.

571
01:06:08.266 --> 01:06:14.721
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Often we see rolling appointments to make sure that there is continuity of work, things like that.

572
01:06:15.572 --> 01:06:17.065
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is this intentional?

573
01:06:17.257 --> 01:06:19.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You all prefer to have everybody up at the same time?

574
01:06:20.726 --> 01:06:27.822
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is this kind of backlogged because you had to start the process of recruitment over, so things just backed up and this is where we are?

575
01:06:28.833 --> 01:06:32.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or is this something that we should expect to see drawn out?

576
01:06:32.672 --> 01:06:48.036
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the reason that I'm asking is if you want to move to more staggered appointments, there will need to be some discussion between you all and the mayor as the person who nominates people around whether you nominate people early or extend people's appointments.

577
01:06:48.101 --> 01:06:55.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it's helpful for us to know what to expect so that if we see people being held over, we don't ask I can answer.

578
01:07:00.666 --> 01:07:13.121
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Yeah, I would say, um, there was a more protracted period with the recruitment having been relaunched, so that did back things up and require almost entirely new recruitments.

579
01:07:13.492 --> 01:07:18.710
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Meanwhile, we are going through the advisory bodies reset, which we'll be coming back to you on in the fall.

580
01:07:19.222 --> 01:07:29.204
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So I think that's an opportunity to to kind of have a broader discussion on how do we want to stagger those appointments when you do wind up with this kind of backlog.

581
01:07:29.268 --> 01:07:32.795
<v Laura Oppenheimer>If you want to say anything more specific about this commission, please feel free.

582
01:07:32.940 --> 01:07:44.275
<v Wafa Almutairi>I can add specifically, I joined the city 2023, and at that time we had NPPC members who have— they were still— they had term to like serve.

583
01:07:44.820 --> 01:07:54.458
<v Wafa Almutairi>And so I was onboarding and getting to know, and then we recruited, and That's when we had Jorge, Maritza, Mary, and 4 join.

584
01:07:54.619 --> 01:08:01.438
<v Wafa Almutairi>So most of who are on the list, they've exceeded their limit to renew or be reappointed.

585
01:08:02.047 --> 01:08:12.329
<v Wafa Almutairi>And 6 of them are able to be reappointed, but only 4 because 2 of them are, you know, life and kids and work.

586
01:08:13.115 --> 01:08:23.854
<v Wafa Almutairi>So from the 6 who were able to serve again because they haven't maxed their limit have decided to be reappointed.

587
01:08:23.951 --> 01:08:25.814
<v Wafa Almutairi>I don't know if that answered your question, Councilor.

588
01:08:25.957 --> 01:08:26.503
<v Wafa Almutairi>I hope it did.

589
01:08:26.761 --> 01:08:27.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's helpful context.

590
01:08:28.045 --> 01:08:33.761
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think what I'm hearing is there may be a conversation internally about how to stagger things in the future.

591
01:08:33.921 --> 01:08:44.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you come back and folks have over— have been held over on their first term, or you're reappointing early, we should expect to maybe see correct.

592
01:08:44.301 --> 01:08:45.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, perfect.

593
01:08:45.260 --> 01:08:45.536
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

594
01:08:45.600 --> 01:08:46.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's really helpful.

595
01:08:48.279 --> 01:08:53.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and incredible work on this group of Portlanders who you're bringing forward to us.

596
01:08:53.287 --> 01:09:15.073
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's clear that you've not only really leaned into making sure that we have a diversity of experiences in how people ended up in Portland and where in Portland they live and where they came here from, But also a huge diversity of experience in what people have done since they've been here.

597
01:09:15.349 --> 01:09:20.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think we will gain so much from all of the voices that are on the commission.

598
01:09:22.427 --> 01:09:27.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I really look forward to the insight and energy and leadership that this body will bring.

599
01:09:27.671 --> 01:09:37.801
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do just want to say to everybody in the room and any of your appointees who are still online with us, Please don't hesitate to bring things forward to council.

600
01:09:38.747 --> 01:09:40.850
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You do a lot of work.

601
01:09:40.930 --> 01:09:44.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know what the administration advising the day-to-day implementation of things.

602
01:09:45.408 --> 01:09:52.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If there is work that this council needs to be doing that you're seeing that we're not seeing, please bring it forward quickly.

603
01:09:52.951 --> 01:10:02.530
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We want to make sure that your time here is really serving our whole community, and that means that we have to be ready to hear from you about what changes we need to make.

604
01:10:02.610 --> 01:10:11.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just, I'd like to extend that invitation to all of you as you serve on the commission to make sure that you are letting us know what we need to be doing better as well.

605
01:10:12.221 --> 01:10:12.639
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you all.

606
01:10:14.067 --> 01:10:15.365
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

607
01:10:15.430 --> 01:10:20.162
<v Sameer Kanal>Before I continue with the queue, Council Clerk wanted to just update something real quick.

608
01:10:20.708 --> 01:10:21.221
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Chair.

609
01:10:21.430 --> 01:10:23.404
<v Keelan McClymont>Apologies, I misspoke on the roll earlier.

610
01:10:23.917 --> 01:10:26.708
<v Keelan McClymont>The motion was approved with 9 ayes and 3 absent.

611
01:10:27.061 --> 01:10:27.912
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

612
01:10:28.569 --> 01:10:28.875
<v Luciani>Thank you.

613
01:10:29.453 --> 01:10:31.859
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll continue with the, uh, queue.

614
01:10:31.939 --> 01:10:33.608
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Smith followed by Councilor Green.

615
01:10:35.003 --> 01:10:35.436
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr.

616
01:10:35.484 --> 01:10:35.677
<v Loretta Smith>Chair.

617
01:10:36.110 --> 01:10:36.896
<v Loretta Smith>Congratulations.

618
01:10:38.036 --> 01:10:43.042
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate the work that you do, and I just want to piggyback on what, uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said.

619
01:10:43.105 --> 01:10:52.203
<v Loretta Smith>If there's anything that we can do from District 1, which is the furthest district in the city, I, I consider it our, our new front door.

620
01:10:52.877 --> 01:10:53.824
<v Loretta Smith>For the city of Portland.

621
01:10:54.418 --> 01:11:03.297
<v Loretta Smith>It begins at 82nd all the way out to 162nd, to the north from Marine Drive all the way out to the, uh, city line.

622
01:11:04.197 --> 01:11:23.283
<v Loretta Smith>And we have one of the most, um, diverse districts, and I would dare say one of the most dynamic districts in the city, because we are trying to, from our office, make sure that everyone feels like they have a voice in City Hall.

623
01:11:24.181 --> 01:11:29.186
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, we put up a district office last year on Halsey and 105th.

624
01:11:29.234 --> 01:11:33.229
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know if, if you all are familiar with it, but we do have a district office.

625
01:11:33.967 --> 01:11:44.378
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Melinda Valentine, um, who runs that office, she just got promoted to, uh, District Manager and Constituent Services, uh, Director, uh, in that office.

626
01:11:44.876 --> 01:11:48.131
<v Loretta Smith>And we, we are there every day.

627
01:11:48.886 --> 01:11:52.430
<v Loretta Smith>And if you do need something, please do not hesitate to call.

628
01:11:52.750 --> 01:11:56.855
<v Loretta Smith>But I had a question because I was looking at your, um, your previous notes.

629
01:11:57.224 --> 01:12:00.640
<v Loretta Smith>How many folks are actually on the commission at one time?

630
01:12:01.810 --> 01:12:06.189
<v Wafa Almutairi>They can be, um, according to city code, it could be up to 25.

631
01:12:06.782 --> 01:12:07.471
<v Loretta Smith>Up to 25?

632
01:12:07.648 --> 01:12:07.792
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

633
01:12:08.850 --> 01:12:15.203
<v Loretta Smith>And I was looking at the average about between 9 and 10 people who attend the meetings, um, monthly.

634
01:12:15.947 --> 01:12:20.523
<v Loretta Smith>Um, couple things that I think that are important.

635
01:12:20.570 --> 01:12:24.716
<v Loretta Smith>I sit on the, um, the Public Works Committee, and I'm the vice chair.

636
01:12:25.650 --> 01:12:41.326
<v Loretta Smith>And one of the things that I find that is very difficult for, uh, communities, uh, underserved communities, period, no matter where you come from, the ability to to interface with government and get government contracts.

637
01:12:42.463 --> 01:12:48.938
<v Loretta Smith>And there's been such an uproar on the national level about DBEs and those kinds of things.

638
01:12:49.451 --> 01:13:03.039
<v Loretta Smith>We want to put together a forum that will teach businesses, new Portlanders, Black and brown folks, how to become certified so that you can yes.

639
01:13:03.087 --> 01:13:08.510
<v Loretta Smith>You can actually compete for some of the city contracts.

640
01:13:09.552 --> 01:13:13.980
<v Loretta Smith>And particularly, we have big contracts that are out there.

641
01:13:14.045 --> 01:13:16.113
<v Loretta Smith>There's still work available.

642
01:13:16.707 --> 01:13:17.445
<v Loretta Smith>We have Bull Run.

643
01:13:17.493 --> 01:13:19.323
<v Loretta Smith>It's a $2.2 billion project.

644
01:13:19.756 --> 01:13:23.685
<v Loretta Smith>We have other city projects that we have underway.

645
01:13:24.391 --> 01:13:29.332
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that people have been discouraged from getting their DBE designation.

646
01:13:30.006 --> 01:13:31.002
<v Loretta Smith>And that's one piece.

647
01:13:31.067 --> 01:13:54.506
<v Loretta Smith>But the other piece that is, that is really important too is getting COBID certified with the state of Oregon so that you can have access to state and local contracts that, that you can get a— actually, you can get extra points for being a DBE because they own some of these contracts, particularly transportation projects.

648
01:13:56.016 --> 01:13:58.070
<v Loretta Smith>You, you can get some advantage on that.

649
01:13:58.118 --> 01:14:06.993
<v Loretta Smith>So we're going to do that, and we want to make sure that we're contacting new Portlanders, because at the end of the day, I mean, we're talking about livability.

650
01:14:07.587 --> 01:14:15.820
<v Loretta Smith>If we can't help the folks in our community be more successful economically, then what are we doing?

651
01:14:16.012 --> 01:14:19.496
<v Loretta Smith>We want you to have a voice here, but we also want you to make a living.

652
01:14:20.170 --> 01:14:30.652
<v Loretta Smith>And to share with you ways in which that you can do business with the City of Portland in addition to giving us feedback on our policies.

653
01:14:31.168 --> 01:14:31.948
<v Loretta Smith>We want y'all working.

654
01:14:32.305 --> 01:14:36.239
<v Loretta Smith>I want y'all working because I want a Social Security check when it's time for me to get my Social Security check.

655
01:14:36.630 --> 01:14:38.304
<v Loretta Smith>So I want people to be into the system.

656
01:14:38.979 --> 01:14:47.515
<v Loretta Smith>But at any rate, it is so good to see all of you here online and in person wanting to do this work because it is honorable work.

657
01:14:47.786 --> 01:14:54.532
<v Loretta Smith>And it is necessary, and we have to be deliberate about when we're serving folks and intentional about what we do.

658
01:14:55.012 --> 01:14:59.916
<v Loretta Smith>So, um, uh, I think— where is— is Promise King in here?

659
01:15:00.765 --> 01:15:02.479
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, Promise King, can you raise your hand?

660
01:15:03.009 --> 01:15:05.524
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, he's in the back and he's on my staff.

661
01:15:05.653 --> 01:15:20.389
<v Loretta Smith>And if you all could, uh, give him your contact information so we can follow back up with you, because I want to make sure that we have folks from your group, and so that you can go out into your communities and tell them about our, uh, forum that's going to be coming up.

662
01:15:21.037 --> 01:15:21.393
<v Wafa Almutairi>Amazing.

663
01:15:21.569 --> 01:15:21.893
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you.

664
01:15:22.134 --> 01:15:22.569
<v Wafa Almutairi>Thank you.

665
01:15:23.037 --> 01:15:23.923
<v Wafa Almutairi>We'll make it happen.

666
01:15:24.890 --> 01:15:26.243
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Green, followed by Novick.

667
01:15:27.909 --> 01:15:28.328
<v Yamungo Seraya>Thank you.

668
01:15:28.488 --> 01:15:31.934
<v Mitch Green>Um, I just, I just want to say thank you for, for volunteering.

669
01:15:32.207 --> 01:15:39.630
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for, um, thank you for bringing that forward, Jorge, bringing forward these, um, great nominees and people who've re-upped again.

670
01:15:41.278 --> 01:15:51.393
<v Mitch Green>It's such an important interface with the city government and largely our immigrant community, but also just this broader sense that the city works for people in community.

671
01:15:51.472 --> 01:15:56.411
<v Mitch Green>And so I want to continue to lend my support for this work.

672
01:15:56.458 --> 01:16:06.157
<v Mitch Green>And Councilor Knoll, thanks for really taking this stuff seriously and making sure that we're giving the due time and consideration to our volunteer bodies.

673
01:16:07.127 --> 01:16:18.613
<v Mitch Green>And, uh, I'm going to take a risk here, but some of you guys have used some Mandarin this morning, so I want to try and offer a, a xie xie ni bang ju wo men de chong shi, which is, um, thank you for helping our city.

674
01:16:19.338 --> 01:16:19.579
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

675
01:16:20.224 --> 01:16:20.707
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

676
01:16:22.318 --> 01:16:23.010
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Green.

677
01:16:23.106 --> 01:16:24.297
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, followed by Ryan.

678
01:16:25.090 --> 01:16:25.885
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

679
01:16:26.729 --> 01:16:32.474
<v Steve Novick>I wanted to say, I mean, really appreciate the experience and the commitment of these nominees.

680
01:16:32.587 --> 01:16:37.993
<v Steve Novick>I also just wanted to say that I've rarely seen so much information conveyed in so little time.

681
01:16:38.832 --> 01:16:44.094
<v Steve Novick>To have these incredibly meaningful, although brief, statements from each of the nominees was just wonderful.

682
01:16:44.306 --> 01:16:47.143
<v Steve Novick>So thanks so much for organizing that.

683
01:16:50.327 --> 01:16:50.877
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan.

684
01:16:52.288 --> 01:16:53.164
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair Knoll.

685
01:16:55.060 --> 01:16:56.399
<v Dan Ryan>I was doing some thinking there.

686
01:16:56.480 --> 01:16:58.163
<v Dan Ryan>First, thank you for this item.

687
01:16:59.095 --> 01:17:00.279
<v Dan Ryan>I had one year as a Commissioner.

688
01:17:00.359 --> 01:17:03.942
<v Dan Ryan>It was 2023, overseeing civic life.

689
01:17:04.264 --> 01:17:11.301
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm not going to lie, you coming on board, Wafa, was one of the big bright spots of that year.

690
01:17:11.814 --> 01:17:16.618
<v Dan Ryan>And in 2023, when I inherited it and you came on, we kind of came on at the same time.

691
01:17:17.599 --> 01:17:21.439
<v Dan Ryan>It was in a, you know, we needed to do some rebuilding at that time.

692
01:17:21.856 --> 01:17:26.740
<v Dan Ryan>And quite frankly, the New Portlanders Commission was ignored, I'll just say, by previous Commissioners.

693
01:17:27.399 --> 01:17:33.198
<v Dan Ryan>And, um, so I'm very connected to, um, this, and it feels good to see you.

694
01:17:33.743 --> 01:17:34.787
<v Dan Ryan>It's just great to see you, Wafa.

695
01:17:35.284 --> 01:17:43.845
<v Dan Ryan>So, um, in fact, I was nudging my staff when you first got up here to make sure that I got to a welcoming week, um, activity because they're always so uplifting.

696
01:17:44.905 --> 01:17:53.176
<v Dan Ryan>Um, you answered— you answered, uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's question well, and yet I just wanted to add that you did so much work thank you.

697
01:17:53.274 --> 01:17:57.577
<v Dan Ryan>In 2023 to clean things up, if you will, with of course Ocean.

698
01:17:58.234 --> 01:18:02.328
<v Dan Ryan>But I want to just say this maybe for you, and I don't think it's off.

699
01:18:02.649 --> 01:18:07.210
<v Dan Ryan>It's not because of your leadership that things got backlogged.

700
01:18:07.707 --> 01:18:13.423
<v Dan Ryan>It was the government and political transitions taking place since then, starting in '24 till this moment.

701
01:18:13.761 --> 01:18:15.126
<v Dan Ryan>So it had nothing to do with you.

702
01:18:15.255 --> 01:18:17.149
<v Dan Ryan>It had everything to do with us, if you will.

703
01:18:17.614 --> 01:18:19.702
<v Dan Ryan>So I just wanted to acknowledge that.

704
01:18:19.783 --> 01:18:21.114
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you for your great work.

705
01:18:21.515 --> 01:18:22.944
<v Dan Ryan>And I really do appreciate it.

706
01:18:24.323 --> 01:18:41.289
<v Dan Ryan>I also appreciate that you've lifted up the, let's just call 'em the OGs, like Ms. Lynette, who put in so many hours, so many hours to hold it together and build it in spite of, in my opinion, being ignored by the political governance body above them.

707
01:18:41.979 --> 01:18:47.095
<v Dan Ryan>And so shout out to her and the others that finished their terms and persevered during a difficult time.

708
01:18:47.143 --> 01:18:47.270
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

709
01:18:50.547 --> 01:18:53.823
<v Dan Ryan>Jorge, I want to acknowledge I really appreciate what you said about the dot connection.

710
01:18:53.920 --> 01:18:55.542
<v Dan Ryan>You also came in in 2023.

711
01:18:55.686 --> 01:18:55.944
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

712
01:18:56.587 --> 01:19:05.725
<v Dan Ryan>The dot connection that you talked about between your placement as a student that's connected to— you're a student at PSU, but you're connected to the K-12 system.

713
01:19:06.287 --> 01:19:13.418
<v Dan Ryan>And it's such a big deal to make sure that the new arrivals in our schools and their families feel welcomed.

714
01:19:13.838 --> 01:19:16.927
<v Dan Ryan>And it's something that the school districts have always been challenged with.

715
01:19:17.396 --> 01:19:19.920
<v Dan Ryan>And, and so thank you for being that voice.

716
01:19:21.430 --> 01:19:22.702
<v Dan Ryan>I did have one question.

717
01:19:24.380 --> 01:19:29.690
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I'm curious, I recall at least one appointee not having lived refugee or immigrant experience.

718
01:19:29.738 --> 01:19:31.059
<v Dan Ryan>So is that not a requirement?

719
01:19:32.095 --> 01:19:33.225
<v Wafa Almutairi>It's not a requirement.

720
01:19:33.452 --> 01:19:46.363
<v Wafa Almutairi>Um, the requirements, I think there was a slide, it has to do, um, Qualifying connection to Portland, such as working, attending school, owning business, or worshiping within the city.

721
01:19:46.891 --> 01:19:50.083
<v Wafa Almutairi>So being a resident is not a requirement.

722
01:19:50.484 --> 01:19:52.921
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, that's not what I meant, but thank you for clarifying that.

723
01:19:53.113 --> 01:20:03.841
<v Dan Ryan>It's more that most of the people that I've ever connected with on the commission are— they had a lived experience as an immigrant or a refugee, or they were a child of one.

724
01:20:04.996 --> 01:20:07.225
<v Dan Ryan>And so, and also, is that not a requirement?

725
01:20:07.787 --> 01:20:08.172
<v Wafa Almutairi>It is.

726
01:20:08.364 --> 01:20:13.149
<v Wafa Almutairi>So, and also work with immigrant and refugee communities.

727
01:20:13.583 --> 01:20:16.601
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, so if you have a job, you become an ally of this body?

728
01:20:16.779 --> 01:20:17.051
<v Wafa Almutairi>Correct.

729
01:20:17.180 --> 01:20:17.518
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

730
01:20:18.801 --> 01:20:21.500
<v Dan Ryan>I like it better when everyone has the lived experience, my bias.

731
01:20:22.640 --> 01:20:25.546
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to continue to support your good work.

732
01:20:26.252 --> 01:20:34.634
<v Dan Ryan>And I'll just always say it, I love when I connect with the communities in the immigrant and refugee communities because They're exactly what Portland needs.

733
01:20:35.099 --> 01:20:36.431
<v Dan Ryan>They tend to get it done.

734
01:20:36.784 --> 01:20:43.207
<v Dan Ryan>They're resilient, obviously, because of their life experience, and they're so grateful to be here, and they're ready to, to go.

735
01:20:43.913 --> 01:20:52.729
<v Dan Ryan>And a lot of them, of course, dive into the private sector, which I really appreciate because Portland really needs to create more revenue and more business license taxes.

736
01:20:53.145 --> 01:20:56.952
<v Dan Ryan>And so I just love the entrepreneur spirit of the communities that arrive.

737
01:20:57.079 --> 01:20:58.332
<v Dan Ryan>That's always been the secret sauce.

738
01:20:58.381 --> 01:20:58.524
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

739
01:21:00.539 --> 01:21:07.010
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor.

740
01:21:07.010 --> 01:21:07.930
<v Sameer Kanal>That's Councilor Ryan.

741
01:21:07.930 --> 01:21:10.630
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go to Councilor Morillo, followed by Council President Dunphy.

742
01:21:12.750 --> 01:21:13.770
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, hi everyone.

743
01:21:13.770 --> 01:21:14.668
<v Angelita Morillo>Sorry I'm virtual today.

744
01:21:14.668 --> 01:21:21.069
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not feeling very well, but, uh, I really appreciate you all being here and to get to hear some of your stories and background.

745
01:21:21.489 --> 01:21:37.046
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, as a— as an immigrant in this time, I think it can feel very isolating and lonely, so Just getting to see how many people in our community are stepping up for our own community and also the people that are stepping up to fight alongside us, I think is really special.

746
01:21:37.127 --> 01:21:41.801
<v Angelita Morillo>And I don't take that for granted at all, just the courage that people display every single day doing this work.

747
01:21:42.750 --> 01:21:53.498
<v Angelita Morillo>And I just wanted to open things up to you and let you know that my office is always available to have a conversation if there's a policy change that's coming up, if there's a community group you want to engage with.

748
01:21:53.851 --> 01:22:01.582
<v Angelita Morillo>If there's something we can help promote on our social media, our newsletter, I would love to help amplify the work that you're doing and the outreach.

749
01:22:02.190 --> 01:22:18.067
<v Angelita Morillo>I think oftentimes in this work, especially in policy, we— I actually disagree with Councilor Ryan a little bit in this, I think, because I do want people that aren't immigrants to be in these spaces fighting for us, because it's going to take people of all types to be doing this work.

750
01:22:18.612 --> 01:22:30.698
<v Angelita Morillo>And our lived Um, a belief that we truly do all deserve to be liberated from these systems.

751
01:22:31.536 --> 01:22:34.780
<v Angelita Morillo>And, uh, you know, our communities are not a monolith.

752
01:22:35.265 --> 01:22:40.333
<v Angelita Morillo>There are organizations that don't agree with one another on the things the city or the policies that are coming up.

753
01:22:40.960 --> 01:22:51.416
<v Angelita Morillo>There are people that don't agree with one another within our own community about the best ways to address the harm that is coming at us from the federal government and sometimes even the local government.

754
01:22:51.886 --> 01:23:14.104
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I would just encourage you to really do broad outreach and to develop a political analysis that is your own, because this time is going to require a discipline from all of us that is beyond what's personal and into what is actually going to be functional for us to survive this.

755
01:23:14.792 --> 01:23:31.976
<v Angelita Morillo>So, uh, just saying that and opening that up to you, as well as noting that there have been times where there has been tension between, I would say, the executive branch and the legislative branch here at the City Council about what policies we want to pass for our immigrant communities and why, and which groups we are listening to and why.

756
01:23:32.603 --> 01:23:45.029
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I hope that in the work that you're doing, that you will take all of that into account and then bring all of that assessment and that wisdom back to us as recommendations that we can really So thank you so much for your work.

757
01:23:45.079 --> 01:23:49.680
<v Angelita Morillo>My office is always open to you, and solidarity with my fellow immigrants.

758
01:23:49.680 --> 01:23:51.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

759
01:23:51.319 --> 01:23:53.479
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

760
01:23:53.479 --> 01:23:56.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Council President Dunphy, and then Councilor Koyama Lane.

761
01:23:56.180 --> 01:23:57.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

762
01:23:57.680 --> 01:24:03.800
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to echo what my colleagues have said to everybody who's willing to step up right now.

763
01:24:03.800 --> 01:24:09.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a moment where we really need all voices to step up and proactively defend what kind of community we are.

764
01:24:09.460 --> 01:24:10.859
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm just really grateful to everybody.

765
01:24:10.859 --> 01:24:11.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also really want to thank the committee for their work.

766
01:24:12.006 --> 01:24:14.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for this recruitment process.

767
01:24:14.523 --> 01:24:20.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>First, as Councilor Novick said earlier, I loved that we also got just the little video clips from folks.

768
01:24:21.081 --> 01:24:27.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is so much of a more full experience for us to actually be able to hear from folks directly rather than seeing an Excel spreadsheet.

769
01:24:27.511 --> 01:24:29.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you for making that extra effort.

770
01:24:29.563 --> 01:24:31.038
<v Jamie Dunphy>I know that's hard and extra work.

771
01:24:31.583 --> 01:24:53.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also wanna just very, you know, echo what Councilor Smith said, which is that, you know, District 1, I just, I really appreciate the extra effort to try and find voices from our community because District 1 is different than the rest of the city, but the challenges are also very different and the population is very different.

772
01:24:53.221 --> 01:25:01.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we really need, you know, just because it's hard to find people to sign up to volunteer from District 1 doesn't mean we don't try a little harder.

773
01:25:02.221 --> 01:25:05.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>It means we improvise and we try to find different ways to find those voices.

774
01:25:05.880 --> 01:25:07.408
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm thrilled to be supportive of this.

775
01:25:07.456 --> 01:25:10.833
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm thrilled to support every single member who is willing to step up right now.

776
01:25:11.123 --> 01:25:13.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>And thank you for taking the extra effort.

777
01:25:15.520 --> 01:25:15.689
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

778
01:25:15.757 --> 01:25:16.625
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Koyama Lane.

779
01:25:19.033 --> 01:25:26.073
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so, so much for your work with immigrants, refugees, their families, with allies.

780
01:25:27.377 --> 01:25:33.932
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I loved slide— I think it was slide 18 that was talking about the collective strengths of the appointees.

781
01:25:35.101 --> 01:25:46.539
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And what I thought Immediately is that those collective strengths really align with the core values of our city of equity, collaboration, communication, anti-racism.

782
01:25:47.037 --> 01:25:49.876
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This group of appointees truly is amazing.

783
01:25:50.003 --> 01:25:53.644
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I teared up multiple times hearing those who spoke today.

784
01:25:54.413 --> 01:26:01.310
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You all truly represent some of the best that our city has to offer, and I'm so excited to support these appointments today.

785
01:26:01.405 --> 01:26:01.791
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

786
01:26:03.765 --> 01:26:05.082
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

787
01:26:05.180 --> 01:26:06.868
<v Sameer Kanal>I am last in the queue, I think.

788
01:26:07.092 --> 01:26:10.599
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, first, I'm very grateful for everyone being here.

789
01:26:10.887 --> 01:26:16.275
<v Sameer Kanal>Absolutely going to support the nominations and the referral to the full council.

790
01:26:16.436 --> 01:26:20.197
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to just kind of follow up on something that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said.

791
01:26:20.713 --> 01:26:23.037
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, in code it says there are 25 members.

792
01:26:23.295 --> 01:26:27.635
<v Sameer Kanal>And so there's 8 vacancies after this that I'd love to be supportive of and filling.

793
01:26:28.296 --> 01:26:30.681
<v Sameer Kanal>And in addition to any policy needs that may ever come up, Yes.

794
01:26:30.729 --> 01:26:32.721
<v Sameer Kanal>Come up, which I agree, please bring them to us.

795
01:26:33.315 --> 01:26:40.609
<v Sameer Kanal>Any appointments, I prioritize them on our calendar, and I want to make sure that we get a chance to get you at your full strength.

796
01:26:41.363 --> 01:27:01.559
<v Sameer Kanal>With relation to the dates, my suggestion would be, because I imagine as you're rebuilding, and as a side note, I've seen WFAA doing this work to rebuild and to get everything from my literal seat, maybe 30 feet from her when I worked at the Portland Building, her and Ocean as well.

797
01:27:02.395 --> 01:27:07.662
<v Sameer Kanal>So watched that work happen, as Councilor Ryan mentioned it, since he started.

798
01:27:09.921 --> 01:27:18.314
<v Sameer Kanal>But as that work goes forward and when it is at full strength, it may be helpful to look at the end of September so that folks are finishing their term with Welcoming Week.

799
01:27:18.706 --> 01:27:19.442
<v Steve Novick>Mm-hmm.

800
01:27:19.523 --> 01:27:21.451
<v Sameer Kanal>And also to stagger it year over year.

801
01:27:22.618 --> 01:27:34.148
<v Sameer Kanal>So maybe with, if the next 8 spots are for a term ending in like September 2029 and can kind of get to that point just with alignment with best practices.

802
01:27:35.623 --> 01:27:38.140
<v Sameer Kanal>And that also I think will help with institutional knowledge retention.

803
01:27:38.189 --> 01:27:44.380
<v Sameer Kanal>You mentioned an amazing group of people who have cycled off and who we are all grateful for as well.

804
01:27:44.604 --> 01:27:47.618
<v Sameer Kanal>I've spoken with Sankar and Mia and so many of the other folks.

805
01:27:47.877 --> 01:27:50.775
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and really appreciate the work that they've done, um, on this.

806
01:27:50.970 --> 01:27:53.448
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I want to make sure that that continues into the future.

807
01:27:54.238 --> 01:28:12.894
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I think we have, um, seen that this commission has had relevance not only in this building but out in the public in terms of making folks feel and actually be represented in government decisions now as well as in the past.

808
01:28:13.421 --> 01:28:17.654
<v Sameer Kanal>That function is among the most important parts of this work.

809
01:28:18.792 --> 01:28:23.844
<v Sameer Kanal>Beyond what's in the code, being a part of our government and being seen is incredibly vital.

810
01:28:24.324 --> 01:28:29.296
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciate that both as a councilor and as an advisory board staffer, and of course as a child of immigrants myself.

811
01:28:30.002 --> 01:28:34.939
<v Sameer Kanal>I also do appreciate the policy work we saw last year.

812
01:28:35.869 --> 01:28:44.465
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney brought forward legislation that was based on conversations and recommendations from the NBPC about the immigration legal services funding.

813
01:28:44.529 --> 01:28:48.442
<v Sameer Kanal>And so, uh, definitely want to continue that work and broaden that as much as possible.

814
01:28:49.323 --> 01:28:55.162
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so to new appointees, what you do matters, and we take what you, uh, advise us on very seriously.

815
01:28:55.738 --> 01:28:57.006
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I do want to add one other thing.

816
01:28:57.101 --> 01:29:03.356
<v Sameer Kanal>You mentioned Gulzar, and, um, I worked with the Focus Intervention Team Community Oversight Group when Chanel Thomas passed away.

817
01:29:03.997 --> 01:29:06.595
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and it mattered to every other volunteer who was on that.

818
01:29:06.676 --> 01:29:13.664
<v Sameer Kanal>It mattered to the staff, it mattered to the focus intervention team officers who worked with that community oversight group, and it was really, really difficult.

819
01:29:14.051 --> 01:29:26.390
<v Sameer Kanal>And so for the 4 reappointees, for everybody who served, and for all the staff, um, yes, may she rest in peace, and also my support and solidarity with you because I know how hard that is, and I appreciate how you've managed to keep going with that.

820
01:29:27.210 --> 01:29:33.975
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, with that, I welcome a motion to refer this item on to the full So moved.

821
01:29:34.150 --> 01:29:34.632
<v Dan Ryan>Second.

822
01:29:36.305 --> 01:29:39.984
<v Sameer Kanal>Moved by Councilor Ryan, seconded by Councilor Novick.

823
01:29:40.259 --> 01:29:41.945
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there any further discussion on this item?

824
01:29:43.961 --> 01:29:45.845
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing none, Diego, will you please call the roll?

825
01:29:48.780 --> 01:29:51.609
<v Unidentified speaker>Moved by Ryan, seconded by Councilor Novick.

826
01:29:52.256 --> 01:29:52.724
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

827
01:29:53.225 --> 01:29:53.386
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

828
01:29:54.194 --> 01:29:54.518
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

829
01:29:55.488 --> 01:29:55.536
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

830
01:29:56.393 --> 01:29:56.798
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

831
01:29:57.025 --> 01:29:57.189
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

832
01:29:58.585 --> 01:29:58.877
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

833
01:29:59.622 --> 01:29:59.800
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

834
01:30:00.981 --> 01:30:01.288
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos.

835
01:30:01.710 --> 01:30:01.757
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

836
01:30:02.697 --> 01:30:02.956
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy.

837
01:30:03.328 --> 01:30:03.457
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

838
01:30:04.234 --> 01:30:04.606
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

839
01:30:05.270 --> 01:30:05.448
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

840
01:30:07.298 --> 01:30:07.347
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

841
01:30:08.456 --> 01:30:08.831
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan.

842
01:30:10.069 --> 01:30:10.248
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

843
01:30:10.983 --> 01:30:11.405
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal.

844
01:30:13.430 --> 01:30:13.445
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

845
01:30:14.335 --> 01:30:16.518
<v Unidentified speaker>With— oh, I'm sorry, was that an aye?

846
01:30:16.873 --> 01:30:17.342
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye, yes.

847
01:30:17.569 --> 01:30:17.844
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

848
01:30:19.122 --> 01:30:32.313
<v Unidentified speaker>With 10 ayes and 2 absent votes, the motion to refer the report as amended Document number 2026-289 to City Council with a recommendation it be accepted, um, is approved.

849
01:30:33.409 --> 01:30:34.203
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you very much.

850
01:30:34.318 --> 01:30:37.068
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll keep you in the loop as soon as it's scheduled at the full council.

851
01:30:39.018 --> 01:30:42.344
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, colleagues, we were going to do part of the next item and then take a break.

852
01:30:42.425 --> 01:30:48.862
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it may make sense to just take the break now, so we're going to, uh, resume, uh, with item 3 when we return in about 10 minutes.

853
01:30:48.911 --> 01:30:50.358
<v Sameer Kanal>See you back at 11:06.

854
01:30:51.180 --> 01:30:51.533
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

855
01:30:52.805 --> 01:31:02.917
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

856
01:44:09.132 --> 01:44:12.667
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, thank you.

857
01:44:13.150 --> 01:44:15.296
<v Sameer Kanal>We're gonna resume our meeting now.

858
01:44:25.418 --> 01:44:27.195
<v Sameer Kanal>Diego, could you please call item 3?

859
01:44:28.060 --> 01:44:34.612
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 3, document number 2026-290, Public Health Impacts of Chemical Weapons.

860
01:44:34.981 --> 01:44:35.993
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much.

861
01:44:36.331 --> 01:44:42.463
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to invite up our panel today, and as they're coming up, I'll just give a little intro on this.

862
01:44:42.543 --> 01:44:42.704
<v Sameer Kanal>It's—.

863
01:44:43.492 --> 01:44:45.755
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think we have 3 folks in the room and 1 online.

864
01:44:45.819 --> 01:44:48.228
<v Sameer Kanal>Please feel free to come on up to the front.

865
01:44:48.854 --> 01:44:55.548
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, today, colleagues, we're going to hear a brief presentation on the public health impacts of chemical weapons usage here in Portland.

866
01:44:55.596 --> 01:45:02.259
<v Sameer Kanal>Again, this relates specifically to the health side of it, and so it's substances appropriately addressed by those with thank you.

867
01:45:03.220 --> 01:45:10.729
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm excited to get this conversation started as it's been a topic that's come up in public testimony as well as in communications with my office.

868
01:45:10.938 --> 01:45:21.155
<v Sameer Kanal>One of the goals of, you know, our ability to do these presentations is to start conversations and inform the public as well as ourselves about things that are of interest to the public and that we're hearing about.

869
01:45:21.301 --> 01:45:22.809
<v Sameer Kanal>So I appreciate it.

870
01:45:23.434 --> 01:45:30.537
<v Sameer Kanal>And with that, I'm gonna welcome Dr. Charisse Bach, Dr. Erica Moseson, Stacy Harp, who I believe is online, and Chad Robison.

871
01:45:30.975 --> 01:45:32.322
<v Sameer Kanal>And I believe we're going in that order.

872
01:45:32.596 --> 01:45:34.835
<v Sameer Kanal>So thanks so much, and take it away, Dr. Bach.

873
01:45:37.475 --> 01:45:38.534
<v Charisse Bach>Good morning, councilors.

874
01:45:38.585 --> 01:45:39.511
<v Charisse Bach>It's good to be with you.

875
01:45:40.909 --> 01:45:47.045
<v Charisse Bach>Thanks for the opportunity to share information about environmental impact of chemical weapons.

876
01:45:47.255 --> 01:45:52.145
<v Charisse Bach>I think I am going to have some slides on the screen any moment now.

877
01:45:53.488 --> 01:46:13.895
<v Charisse Bach>So I'll just start by saying, um, I wasn't yet on staff at 350 PDX in 2020 to 2021, but many of our staff in their personal capacity and I myself were exercising our rights of speech and assembly then and again in the last couple years opposing police brutality, kidnapping of immigrants, and other intersecting injustices.

878
01:46:14.231 --> 01:46:22.470
<v Charisse Bach>There haven't been a lot of incidents using tear gas against climate activists in Portland, but There have been many such incidents in other places.

879
01:46:24.510 --> 01:46:28.586
<v Charisse Bach>So you'll hear from other presenters about the impact on people.

880
01:46:29.520 --> 01:46:44.636
<v Charisse Bach>And I will note, because I don't know that anybody else is covering this particular piece, that although tear gas is designed to impact the respiratory system, a Portland study of people who menstruate shows a likely linkage to reproductive health as well.

881
01:46:45.871 --> 01:46:49.676
<v Charisse Bach>So before I go any further, I'll see if we're gonna be able to get some slides going.

882
01:46:49.853 --> 01:46:50.688
<v Charisse Bach>Should I keep going or?

883
01:46:51.796 --> 01:46:54.702
<v Charisse Bach>Okay, you can refer to the slides later, I guess.

884
01:46:56.114 --> 01:47:09.328
<v Charisse Bach>And so what got us involved as 350 PDX as an organization in the issue of chemical weapons was when our then forest defense manager, Brenna, experienced being tear gassed by a tree.

885
01:47:10.984 --> 01:47:18.270
<v Charisse Bach>She started reacting to the tear gas still drifting around midday and noticed it had accumulated on nearby trees.

886
01:47:20.311 --> 01:47:29.618
<v Charisse Bach>Though we use the term tear gas, the chemical agents against Portland protesters have often been in powder form, thrown or fired via grenades and canisters.

887
01:47:30.136 --> 01:47:33.913
<v Charisse Bach>The powder drifts on the wind, then lands on far-flung surfaces.

888
01:47:35.355 --> 01:47:41.935
<v Charisse Bach>The main type of chemical weapon of environmental concern used is what's commonly referred to as CS gas.

889
01:47:42.755 --> 01:47:46.720
<v Charisse Bach>There are other types, but that's one that has the most research about it.

890
01:47:46.849 --> 01:47:48.310
<v Charisse Bach>It's a white crystalline solid.

891
01:47:48.695 --> 01:47:54.619
<v Charisse Bach>The powder occurs in a pyrotechnic mixture that can be aerosolized as a smoke or fog.

892
01:47:55.439 --> 01:47:57.318
<v Charisse Bach>It's considered explosive and flammable.

893
01:47:58.168 --> 01:48:04.350
<v Charisse Bach>Because CS is so harmful, it's illegal to use in international warfare according to the Geneva Conventions.

894
01:48:10.356 --> 01:48:19.586
<v Charisse Bach>Exposure to 2 milligrams per meter cubed of CS is in the category of immediately dangerous to life and health, but much higher concentrations were deployed.

895
01:48:20.425 --> 01:48:22.087
<v Charisse Bach>Toxic particles are indiscriminate.

896
01:48:22.685 --> 01:48:32.831
<v Charisse Bach>They stay in the air and spread, meaning not only the people attending a protest experience the effects, but many people over a large area who were not at a protest are exposed.

897
01:48:32.927 --> 01:48:33.395
<v Charisse Bach>Councilmember Herbold.

898
01:48:33.914 --> 01:48:43.341
<v Charisse Bach>As well as all the trees, wildlife, rivers, and other animals and plants living in a large dispersion area around places that are gassed.

899
01:48:45.298 --> 01:48:47.175
<v Charisse Bach>Looks like we're catching up with the slides here.

900
01:48:53.923 --> 01:48:58.431
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

901
01:48:59.502 --> 01:49:02.385
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks for bearing with us as we get the, uh, the tech set up.

902
01:49:04.948 --> 01:49:08.238
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

903
01:49:14.456 --> 01:49:23.305
<v Charisse Bach>All right, there you can see impact on the reproductive system, all the trees in that image, the dispersal pattern.

904
01:49:25.524 --> 01:49:26.033
<v Charisse Bach>Yeah.

905
01:49:26.100 --> 01:49:27.596
<v Charisse Bach>Particles floating through the air.

906
01:49:30.515 --> 01:49:31.512
<v Charisse Bach>And we'll do one more.

907
01:49:31.641 --> 01:49:36.003
<v Charisse Bach>You can see the disperse— dispersal into the river area.

908
01:49:37.710 --> 01:49:38.610
<v Charisse Bach>So we'll stay with that one.

909
01:49:40.300 --> 01:49:50.305
<v Charisse Bach>According to a study of Tear Gas Tuesday, 2 kilograms of toxins would have ended up in the Willamette just on June 2nd, 2020, from particles spreading through the air.

910
01:49:51.170 --> 01:49:53.578
<v Charisse Bach>This could even affect wildlife and farms downriver.

911
01:49:55.539 --> 01:50:04.587
<v Charisse Bach>Instructions on use of CS gas say not to let it enter water systems and drains, stating it's likely harmful to fish and other parts of aquatic ecosystems.

912
01:50:05.412 --> 01:50:18.637
<v Charisse Bach>Chemical weapons other than CS have been used on peaceful demonstrators, such as HC gas, and it's often difficult for the public to know what has been released unless someone collects and analyzes the spent canisters.

913
01:50:18.685 --> 01:50:18.814
<v Charisse Bach>Thank you.

914
01:50:19.493 --> 01:50:24.929
<v Charisse Bach>Various toxic pollutants were found in samples such as barium, copper, lead, and zinc.

915
01:50:25.649 --> 01:50:26.114
<v Charisse Bach>Next slide.

916
01:50:27.350 --> 01:50:39.664
<v Charisse Bach>With the possible exception of battle sites during World War I, to the best of our knowledge, no one had ever used so much tear gas over such a long time in such a concentrated place as we experienced in Portland in 2020 to 2021.

917
01:50:40.403 --> 01:50:47.957
<v Charisse Bach>There were also many tactical herbicides such as Agent Orange sprayed on countries in Southeast Asia, But that's a different type of compound.

918
01:50:48.503 --> 01:50:56.756
<v Charisse Bach>There's not a wealth of information regarding the environmental impacts of tear gas and these kinds of chemical weapons, but what information there is is not good.

919
01:50:57.655 --> 01:50:58.042
<v Charisse Bach>Next slide.

920
01:50:59.358 --> 01:51:06.856
<v Charisse Bach>A study about impacts of CS on aquatic creatures shows that very small concentrations of it in the water can be lethal to rainbow trout.

921
01:51:08.109 --> 01:51:11.448
<v Charisse Bach>It likely has similar effects on other fish and aquatic organisms.

922
01:51:13.724 --> 01:51:23.899
<v Charisse Bach>Even the destruction of chemical weapons may cause harm to wildlife, and studies of sea-dumped chemical weapons show there is likely risk and harm to fish and wildlife, and more research is needed.

923
01:51:24.524 --> 01:51:34.858
<v Charisse Bach>A UN environmental program study cautions that chemical weapons cause concentrations in the environment that far exceed safe levels, and that more research is needed to know the full impacts.

924
01:51:35.930 --> 01:51:41.766
<v Charisse Bach>CS powder is already not supposed to be washed into storm drains, but of course It's difficult to avoid.

925
01:51:42.634 --> 01:51:54.614
<v Charisse Bach>Even if Portland increases filtering on storm drains, due to the dispersal range of the airborne particles, much of it can still land in the river and waterways depending on the direction of the wind.

926
01:51:55.337 --> 01:51:55.787
<v Charisse Bach>Next slide.

927
01:51:57.265 --> 01:51:58.679
<v Charisse Bach>A great deal is unknown.

928
01:51:59.112 --> 01:52:04.653
<v Charisse Bach>We don't know what happens if toxins from chemical weapons accumulate and build up in the soil or water.

929
01:52:05.697 --> 01:52:07.703
<v Charisse Bach>We don't know their effects councilmember Herbold.

930
01:52:07.864 --> 01:52:08.409
<v Charisse Bach>Thank you, Mayor.

931
01:52:08.570 --> 01:52:18.747
<v Charisse Bach>We don't know the long-term effects on aquatic organisms, birds, or other animals, or about how trees and plants may be impacted if the CS leaches into the soil or leaves.

932
01:52:19.421 --> 01:52:24.525
<v Charisse Bach>We don't know the impact of unknown compounds that are being released into the ecosystem with various munitions.

933
01:52:25.841 --> 01:52:31.621
<v Charisse Bach>What we do know is that when Portlanders are sprayed with tear gas, the trees, other plants, and soil are also sprayed.

934
01:52:32.327 --> 01:52:37.234
<v Charisse Bach>And we know that wildlife, including birds, utilize those spaces The situations are never far from the river.

935
01:52:38.378 --> 01:52:38.750
<v Charisse Bach>Next slide.

936
01:52:40.395 --> 01:52:57.234
<v Charisse Bach>350 PDX, along with several other local organizations and represented by the ACLU, filed a complaint against the Department of Homeland Security in 2020, claiming law enforcement's repeated deployment of so many chemical weapons was a violation of NEPA, the National Environmental Policy Act.

937
01:52:58.122 --> 01:53:08.020
<v Charisse Bach>The lawsuit cites the federal agency's failure to analyze the potentially severe human health and environmental impacts before deploying chemical munitions as required by NEPA.

938
01:53:09.322 --> 01:53:17.417
<v Charisse Bach>We sought a court order forcing DHS to halt their use of chemical munitions until they perform a thorough analysis and make the information available to the public.

939
01:53:18.800 --> 01:53:28.149
<v Charisse Bach>An appeal to the Ninth Circuit Court was dismissed because chemical weapons were no longer being deployed in Portland on a daily basis, but of course, we— as we've seen, that doesn't mean they never will again.

940
01:53:29.161 --> 01:53:31.506
<v Charisse Bach>No court has yet heard the case on its merits.

941
01:53:31.569 --> 01:53:31.730
<v Charisse Bach>Thank you.

942
01:53:32.439 --> 01:53:42.934
<v Charisse Bach>We continue to believe this level of toxins being released into the environment, landing on trees, plants, rivers, and impacting wildlife is a likely violation of NEPA.

943
01:53:44.328 --> 01:53:44.846
<v Charisse Bach>Next slide.

944
01:53:46.500 --> 01:53:58.753
<v Charisse Bach>So in addition to all the harm to human health you'll hear about next, because of the environmental damage we know from chemical weapons and everything that is unknown, we recommend City Council bans the use of chemical weapons in Portland.

945
01:53:58.819 --> 01:53:58.917
<v Charisse Bach>Thank you.

946
01:53:59.203 --> 01:53:59.541
<v Charisse Bach>Thank you.

947
01:54:02.006 --> 01:54:02.988
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Dr. Bach.

948
01:54:03.069 --> 01:54:05.341
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we're going to Dr. Moseson next.

949
01:54:05.405 --> 01:54:06.018
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much.

950
01:54:06.845 --> 01:54:06.894
<v Angelita Morillo>Hi.

951
01:54:07.264 --> 01:54:10.509
<v Erica Moseson>Thank you so much for the opportunity to speak about health impacts of tear gas.

952
01:54:10.717 --> 01:54:15.890
<v Erica Moseson>I'm a pulmonary and critical care physician who cares for people in the clinic as well as in the intensive care unit.

953
01:54:16.340 --> 01:54:27.305
<v Erica Moseson>And I'm here as a member of the Oregon Thoracic Society, which is our state society of pulmonary and critical care physicians, as well as respiratory therapists, thoracic surgeons, and all of those who care for people with respiratory illnesses.

954
01:54:28.202 --> 01:54:35.944
<v Erica Moseson>We are the state chapter of the American Thoracic Society, which is comprised of over 22,000 members engaging in care of patients and science related to respiratory health and threats to it.

955
01:54:36.600 --> 01:54:48.751
<v Erica Moseson>The ATS section on terrorism and inhalational disasters contains a specific locus of expertise regarding the impact of CS and OC, which has now also been partially replaced by PAVA, a synthetic variant.

956
01:54:49.024 --> 01:54:51.860
<v Erica Moseson>And they study this both from cell culture to mouse models to studies in humans.

957
01:54:52.485 --> 01:55:01.716
<v Erica Moseson>The ATS has called for a complete moratorium on the use of these chemicals, collectively known as tear gas agents, for use on civilian populations in alignment with their prohibition on the battlefield.

958
01:55:02.324 --> 01:55:18.011
<v Erica Moseson>As has been stated, tear gas is not actually a gas but an aerosolized powder generally mixed into a pyrotechnical charge, um, and the ignition of these when used in munition forms such as pepper balls and grenade varieties combine to generate other highly concerning chemicals such as hexavalent chromium, a known carcinogen.

959
01:55:18.668 --> 01:55:27.550
<v Erica Moseson>Our own military has conducted research on the resulting chemical clouds from deployment of tear gas agents and found a host of known inhalational and liver toxins as well as cyanide formation.

960
01:55:28.623 --> 01:55:29.682
<v Erica Moseson>So how do these chemicals work?

961
01:55:29.747 --> 01:55:31.253
<v Erica Moseson>Like, why do they hurt and why do they affect us?

962
01:55:32.072 --> 01:55:41.261
<v Erica Moseson>They actually— we've found the receptors for at least 2 of them, TRPV1 and TRPA1, and these actually activate nerves in the eyes and the skin, the respiratory tract, and throughout the body.

963
01:55:42.319 --> 01:55:48.895
<v Erica Moseson>And I think there was— there's a thought that they just cause pain, but actually when these ion channels are activated, they actually generate this entire inflammatory cascade.

964
01:55:48.960 --> 01:55:49.055
<v Erica Moseson>Yeah.

965
01:55:49.458 --> 01:55:54.837
<v Erica Moseson>Which is why you can get skin burns, and you can see similar things in the respiratory tract, which is where I kind of have my area of expertise.

966
01:55:57.028 --> 01:56:07.279
<v Erica Moseson>And the other, like, when you study even models for the development of asthma and the maintenance of asthma, some of these actual receptors are actually essential to maintaining bad airway diseases like asthma.

967
01:56:07.894 --> 01:56:14.438
<v Erica Moseson>And I would say, as a lung doctor, you know, I've had to send patients to the ER for exacerbations from far less noxious compounds.

968
01:56:15.202 --> 01:56:18.181
<v Erica Moseson>I've had a patient almost arrest in my office when someone was there with perfume.

969
01:56:19.271 --> 01:56:34.637
<v Erica Moseson>And with more than 1 in 10 Oregonians suffering from asthma, this is very dangerous to our population, whether the individual targeted for deployment of agents, the surrounding community, and often the law enforcement officers themselves who often end up being more regularly exposed to these agents.

970
01:56:35.615 --> 01:56:40.951
<v Erica Moseson>You know, I have a patient with obstructive lung disease who lived in a building where tear gas was being used nearby.

971
01:56:41.079 --> 01:56:45.849
<v Erica Moseson>It infiltrated her building as As we discussed, and she almost couldn't live in her own home.

972
01:56:45.978 --> 01:56:52.828
<v Erica Moseson>I mean, just continuously exacerbating, multiple visits, multiple medications, and I don't think we ever really got her control back where it was.

973
01:56:54.810 --> 01:57:05.524
<v Erica Moseson>For one, you know, it's hard to study these things in these exact contexts because, you know, what's needed to actually deploy an entire study, you kind of have to know where these agents are gonna be deployed and when.

974
01:57:05.947 --> 01:57:08.211
<v Erica Moseson>But the studies that have been done have been pretty concerning.

975
01:57:08.390 --> 01:57:09.774
<v Erica Moseson>A lot of it comes from our own military.

976
01:57:10.426 --> 01:57:16.431
<v Erica Moseson>On healthy recruits who've actually passed, you know, the muster to, you know, join the military.

977
01:57:16.608 --> 01:57:35.506
<v Erica Moseson>And with even just one exposure, which was this like masked trust study of over 6,000 of our soldiers, they found that they actually stopped doing those, that training exercise in that event because they doubled the rate of bronchitis symptoms, of respiratory infections, of significant respiratory complications.

978
01:57:36.550 --> 01:57:48.372
<v Erica Moseson>So, and then we also have known from other studies like in Turkey, similarly we start to see obstruction in the lungs, that the ratios of the lungs indicating a progression towards potential obstructive lung disease.

979
01:57:49.029 --> 01:57:55.831
<v Erica Moseson>And so these, and I can't even imagine what it means when you're in these clouds of agents all the time with these repeated exposures.

980
01:57:55.878 --> 01:58:02.889
<v Erica Moseson>So these really are potentially lethal and there is mortality to them that people, it is not just cough and irritation.

981
01:58:03.338 --> 01:58:08.533
<v Erica Moseson>It's wheeze, it's constriction in the lungs, it's, um, you know, filling the lungs with fluid and potentially death.

982
01:58:09.275 --> 01:58:19.287
<v Erica Moseson>Um, so, um, I guess the Oregon Thoracic Society would also advocate for a moratorium on their use in civilian populations in alignment with, um, our recommendations in war.

983
01:58:22.105 --> 01:58:23.256
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Dr. Moses.

984
01:58:23.385 --> 01:58:23.546
<v Sameer Kanal>I—.

985
01:58:24.387 --> 01:58:28.628
<v Sameer Kanal>So, Chad, I'm not sure if we're going to Stacy next, or— I think we— I think we are going to Stacy.

986
01:58:29.011 --> 01:58:30.966
<v Chad Robison>Sorry, I didn't quite hear that.

987
01:58:31.158 --> 01:58:34.685
<v Sameer Kanal>We have a 4th panelist, and I think if you— I think you're 4th.

988
01:58:34.877 --> 01:58:38.899
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just making sure that— yeah, so, um, see nods from my team back here.

989
01:58:38.947 --> 01:58:45.518
<v Sameer Kanal>So sorry, uh, a little awkward to switch back and forth, but I want to welcome up, uh, Stacy Harper, uh, who's OSU toxicologist.

990
01:58:45.774 --> 01:58:48.466
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll let her introduce herself.

991
01:58:48.802 --> 01:58:50.085
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

992
01:58:50.292 --> 01:58:50.997
<v Stacy Harper>Hi, thank you.

993
01:58:51.350 --> 01:58:53.721
<v Stacy Harper>Um, I am sorry I can't be there in person.

994
01:58:53.786 --> 01:58:57.827
<v Stacy Harper>It was, uh, late last night that the decision was kind of made that I was going to be on.

995
01:58:58.404 --> 01:59:04.962
<v Stacy Harper>Um, so good morning, and I am a professor here at Oregon State University in toxicology and environmental engineering.

996
01:59:05.699 --> 01:59:18.158
<v Stacy Harper>Um, I was asked to provide an overview of the toxic effects, um, for, for on humans, um, of the different, uh, crowd control and detention sprays that have been used in Portland.

997
01:59:18.688 --> 01:59:32.269
<v Stacy Harper>I'm going to focus a little bit more heavily on the reproductive effects that we've, we've heard a little bit about, but both through inhalation and through ingestion of contaminated water exposure.

998
01:59:32.525 --> 01:59:34.340
<v Stacy Harper>So I'm going to start with the CS gas.

999
01:59:34.435 --> 01:59:44.264
<v Stacy Harper>It's already been introduced, but it's the one that we know the most about, although the evolving picture of safety on this particular chemical agent has shifted.

1000
01:59:44.391 --> 01:59:56.520
<v Stacy Harper>So in the '70s, they had studies with a pretty small number of women, maybe 30 women, Um, and did exposures, found no birth defects and no adverse pregnancy outcomes.

1001
01:59:56.984 --> 02:00:09.712
<v Stacy Harper>But some of the newer data that we're getting that focuses more on menstrual and uterine effects, so not contradicting the, the prior studies, but just looking at more nuanced differences and effects.

1002
02:00:10.273 --> 02:00:28.761
<v Stacy Harper>Um, this new human data is showing, um, from a peer-reviewed paper in 2023, They surveyed over 1,200 tear gas exposed people that had a uterus, and 83% of those had reported at least one adverse symptom.

1003
02:00:28.826 --> 02:00:39.279
<v Stacy Harper>So these symptoms can range from uterine cramping, breast tenderness, either early or delayed menstrual bleeding, and those effects scaled with the amount of exposure.

1004
02:00:39.328 --> 02:00:43.824
<v Stacy Harper>Like most toxicants, the longer you're exposed to it, the harsher the effects.

1005
02:00:44.002 --> 02:00:54.783
<v Stacy Harper>And so those that were exposed for more than 5 days had a 2.5 times likelier adverse outcome compared to just a single-day exposure.

1006
02:00:54.993 --> 02:00:58.061
<v Stacy Harper>So those repeated exposures make an impact.

1007
02:00:59.426 --> 02:01:03.252
<v Stacy Harper>Dr. Bach covered a little bit of the Portland protesters.

1008
02:01:03.621 --> 02:01:17.273
<v Stacy Harper>So for those that were surveyed at those protests of women who menstruate, 54.5% of them reported a change in their menstrual cycle after being exposed.

1009
02:01:17.337 --> 02:01:24.369
<v Stacy Harper>So we should be careful to say this isn't causation, right, because the stress of that event alone can disrupt cycles.

1010
02:01:24.787 --> 02:01:32.478
<v Stacy Harper>But it should be noted that stress doesn't typically explain the altered or heavier bleeding that was reported.

1011
02:01:32.573 --> 02:01:35.769
<v Stacy Harper>And so this is a concern for, you know, reproductive-age Portlanders.

1012
02:01:36.346 --> 02:01:42.351
<v Stacy Harper>Um, for certain, the CS gas is not just, you know, exposed through inhalation.

1013
02:01:42.706 --> 02:01:45.451
<v Stacy Harper>We heard that it gets widely distributed.

1014
02:01:45.980 --> 02:02:03.046
<v Stacy Harper>Um, in fact, after the 2020 protests, um, the Portland Bureau of Environmental Services vacuumed out the residue from 6 drains, and they were looking for, you know, hexavalent chromium, perchlorate, barium, cyanide, all of these nasty chemicals that are associated with the CS gas.

1015
02:02:04.521 --> 02:02:11.270
<v Stacy Harper>Hexavalent chromium, for instance, is listed as developmental and reproductive toxicant by the EPA.

1016
02:02:11.511 --> 02:02:14.636
<v Stacy Harper>Perchlorate is one that is also found in fireworks.

1017
02:02:15.599 --> 02:02:31.509
<v Stacy Harper>Perchlorate can cross the placenta and disrupts fetal thyroid hormone and can produce brain malformations that persist even when maternal thyroid levels Go back to normal, so after the exposure has resided in mom.

1018
02:02:32.262 --> 02:02:46.958
<v Stacy Harper>Also noted are some of these fetal and hormonal effects on thyroid, sperm, testosterone, and those are typically associated more with the metals and the other chemical contaminants that are part of the CS formulation, not the CS itself.

1019
02:02:47.858 --> 02:03:01.470
<v Stacy Harper>The CS itself, though, can hydrolyze in water within 15 minutes at neutral pH, so That first rain event can certainly carry that straight into the Willamette River or other water sources.

1020
02:03:02.449 --> 02:03:27.234
<v Stacy Harper>Um, when we talk about OC pepper spray, there, um, this does cause the same kind of acute breathing distress that was described by Dr. Bach, but it is specifically flagged for pregnant women, children, and then people with asthma and heart disease because they're the most vulnerable to There's no dedicated reproductive toxicity of capsaicin.

1021
02:03:27.282 --> 02:03:34.301
<v Stacy Harper>It's mostly an irritant and an inflammatory agent for mostly eyes, nose, throat, lungs.

1022
02:03:35.216 --> 02:03:39.680
<v Stacy Harper>But enough ingestion can lead to nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain.

1023
02:03:40.501 --> 02:03:45.496
<v Stacy Harper>So think about when you're inhaling stuff, it's also being ingested as well.

1024
02:03:46.604 --> 02:03:49.494
<v Stacy Harper>Then we have hexachloroethane smoke, the HCC.

1025
02:03:49.560 --> 02:03:52.994
<v Stacy Harper>Smoke that is very persistent and severe.

1026
02:03:54.247 --> 02:03:58.469
<v Stacy Harper>It is comprised of hexachloroethane and zinc chloride.

1027
02:03:59.224 --> 02:04:21.747
<v Stacy Harper>The EPA classifies that hexachloroethane as a possible human carcinogen, and it is listed as developmental and reproductive toxicant, and high doses in animal studies— not humans— but high doses lead to maternal toxicity and Reduced fetal weight, skeletal abnormalities, and reduced implantation.

1028
02:04:21.796 --> 02:04:23.948
<v Stacy Harper>So reduced fertility overall.

1029
02:04:24.590 --> 02:04:34.431
<v Stacy Harper>There's also some evidence there's reduced sperm counts in males, although the National Toxicology Program did do its own study and wasn't able to replicate these findings.

1030
02:04:34.479 --> 02:04:37.016
<v Stacy Harper>So that one is kind of contingent.

1031
02:04:37.257 --> 02:04:44.868
<v Stacy Harper>Um, but the zinc chloride smoke is one that has a documented case report of a fatality.

1032
02:04:45.367 --> 02:04:48.594
<v Stacy Harper>Um, through acute respiratory distress syndrome.

1033
02:04:49.060 --> 02:05:00.525
<v Stacy Harper>So this was published in 2008 in Clinical Toxicology, where a 21-year-old student inhaled HH smoke during a fire safety demonstration at a school.

1034
02:05:01.520 --> 02:05:03.175
<v Stacy Harper>It doesn't break down quickly.

1035
02:05:03.368 --> 02:05:07.863
<v Stacy Harper>It's persistent and bioaccumulates and can have a lag time after exposure.

1036
02:05:07.961 --> 02:05:12.231
<v Stacy Harper>So this lag time can range from 10 to 32 days.

1037
02:05:12.279 --> 02:05:12.360
<v Stacy Harper>Okay.

1038
02:05:13.306 --> 02:05:15.457
<v Stacy Harper>Depending on how much was actually inhaled.

1039
02:05:15.970 --> 02:05:19.001
<v Stacy Harper>And then there's a couple of other notable ones that I just want to bring up.

1040
02:05:19.096 --> 02:05:25.079
<v Stacy Harper>Barium is one that results in reduced newborn birth weight in animal studies.

1041
02:05:25.978 --> 02:05:29.506
<v Stacy Harper>Reproductive studies in humans is sparse on that one though.

1042
02:05:30.083 --> 02:05:37.557
<v Stacy Harper>And then the last one that I'd like to bring up that's, you know, a component of some of these gases is the cyanide.

1043
02:05:38.328 --> 02:05:58.905
<v Stacy Harper>It has the most detailed male-specific data, so if If that's of interest, these— they did a 90-day rat study and showed drops in sperm motility and count, along with significant alterations in hormone levels and testicular atrophy and degeneration.

1044
02:05:59.082 --> 02:06:01.630
<v Stacy Harper>All the hormone levels were suppressed in those.

1045
02:06:01.823 --> 02:06:07.494
<v Stacy Harper>And then in a separate animal study, they found fetal malformations and low fetal birth weights.

1046
02:06:07.671 --> 02:06:10.079
<v Stacy Harper>From maternal exposure.

1047
02:06:10.867 --> 02:06:13.435
<v Stacy Harper>I will leave it there and move to the next person.

1048
02:06:13.917 --> 02:06:14.302
<v Stacy Harper>Thank you.

1049
02:06:15.219 --> 02:06:16.229
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much, Stacy.

1050
02:06:16.341 --> 02:06:27.518
<v Sameer Kanal>And, um, I believe Chad, uh, who is a retired firefighter and volunteer medic, uh, wanted to have you close us out because of how your experience is more, um, immediate and on the ground.

1051
02:06:27.582 --> 02:06:28.609
<v Sameer Kanal>So please take it away.

1052
02:06:28.689 --> 02:06:29.363
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks for being here.

1053
02:06:29.509 --> 02:06:32.094
<v Chad Robison>Yeah, no, I hope everyone's doing well.

1054
02:06:32.382 --> 02:06:34.877
<v Chad Robison>Um, My name's Chad Robison.

1055
02:06:35.219 --> 02:06:48.520
<v Chad Robison>I'm a retired firefighter paramedic, and since late 2025, I have spent every weekend volunteering outside the Portland ICE facility providing medical first aid and decontamination.

1056
02:06:49.021 --> 02:06:49.524
<v Chad Robison>Thank you.

1057
02:06:52.826 --> 02:06:56.194
<v Chad Robison>Providing medical decontamination to anyone who needs it.

1058
02:06:57.329 --> 02:07:08.568
<v Chad Robison>During that time, I've had the opportunity to see firsthand the medical impacts the exposure of chemical weapons can have on people and the challenges of providing care in that environment.

1059
02:07:10.014 --> 02:07:18.396
<v Chad Robison>I first got involved on my own because I care about people, all people, regardless of which side of the political aisle they may be on.

1060
02:07:19.569 --> 02:07:22.475
<v Chad Robison>That has been at the center of my efforts from the beginning.

1061
02:07:23.503 --> 02:07:30.715
<v Chad Robison>One of the basic requirements for anyone volunteering with us is that they must be willing to provide care to any— everyone who needs it.

1062
02:07:30.877 --> 02:07:35.427
<v Chad Robison>Regardless of their beliefs, politics, or reasons for being there.

1063
02:07:37.020 --> 02:07:47.845
<v Chad Robison>From the start, I saw the need to organize and coordinate our medical efforts so we could respond effectively to the overwhelming number of people needing decontamination and first aid.

1064
02:07:48.930 --> 02:08:02.479
<v Chad Robison>When I go down to the ICE facility, we work together bringing our own medical supplies, and by coordinating, we organize into teams positioned positioned around the area so we can respond quickly wherever help is needed.

1065
02:08:04.090 --> 02:08:06.931
<v Chad Robison>We wait and listen for someone to call out medic.

1066
02:08:09.609 --> 02:08:32.920
<v Chad Robison>These on-site group of volunteers and I have decontaminated countless people exposed when ICE indiscriminately deployed tear gas, affecting anyone who just happened to be in the area This includes not only protesters but media, legal observers, clergy, local residents, and others simply going about their daily lives.

1067
02:08:34.319 --> 02:08:38.899
<v Chad Robison>It broke my heart to see the indiscriminate use of chemical weapons on these people.

1068
02:08:41.743 --> 02:09:00.823
<v Chad Robison>Those we have decontaminated include peaceful protesters on a march with their children, When I asked one of our volunteer medics what ages he was seeing while pulling families out of the gas cloud, he broke down and said there were strollers.

1069
02:09:03.027 --> 02:09:07.643
<v Chad Robison>While deploying tear gas indiscriminately, there were also a lot of directed attacks.

1070
02:09:08.850 --> 02:09:14.801
<v Chad Robison>In fact, medics were typically the first to be hit in an attempt to make our role of decontaminating people more difficult.

1071
02:09:14.849 --> 02:09:15.043
<v Chad Robison>Thank you.

1072
02:09:16.930 --> 02:09:20.622
<v Chad Robison>The first canister was often thrown into our triage location.

1073
02:09:21.788 --> 02:09:31.032
<v Chad Robison>In addition to medics, I've repeatedly witnessed vulnerable and marginalized people, particularly transgender individuals, being subjected to attacks.

1074
02:09:32.899 --> 02:09:36.609
<v Chad Robison>Our ability to fully decontaminate someone in the field is limited.

1075
02:09:37.270 --> 02:09:40.382
<v Chad Robison>We start by flushing their eyes until they're able to see again.

1076
02:09:41.166 --> 02:09:47.417
<v Chad Robison>Then rinse their face and any other exposed skin to remove as much of the remaining irritant as we can.

1077
02:09:49.710 --> 02:10:05.228
<v Chad Robison>Some of the injuries I've personally treated are physical injuries caused by people unable to see while running out of tear gas clouds, blisters on faces when decontamination wasn't done well enough, and asthma attacks, which can be life-threatening.

1078
02:10:07.939 --> 02:10:15.828
<v Chad Robison>My time is limited, but I could stand here or sit here, uh, and talk a lot longer about all the harm I've seen from the use of tear gas.

1079
02:10:17.774 --> 02:10:23.132
<v Chad Robison>My own experience with the effects of tear gas has gone well beyond any immediate exposure.

1080
02:10:24.215 --> 02:10:31.202
<v Chad Robison>I teach protest safety classes, and for 4 months I dealt with a persistent cough and difficulty speaking clearly.

1081
02:10:32.342 --> 02:10:34.529
<v Chad Robison>Even today, I continue to notice the effects.

1082
02:10:34.626 --> 02:10:34.787
<v Chad Robison>Thank you.

1083
02:10:35.256 --> 02:10:38.920
<v Chad Robison>By the end of a class, speaking can become more difficult for me.

1084
02:10:40.157 --> 02:10:48.645
<v Chad Robison>The impact of repeated tear gas exposure hasn't simply ended when I left the area or when the immediate burning and irritation went away.

1085
02:10:51.256 --> 02:11:00.698
<v Chad Robison>Looking back at the time I've spent outside that facility, I struggle to think of a single time when the use of tear gas resulted in anything positive.

1086
02:11:02.238 --> 02:11:09.387
<v Chad Robison>I repeatedly watched canisters thrown behind groups of protesters and then in front of them, leaving them with nowhere to go.

1087
02:11:10.489 --> 02:11:12.810
<v Chad Robison>It wasn't an attempt to disperse a crowd.

1088
02:11:13.591 --> 02:11:14.873
<v Chad Robison>It was to cause pain.

1089
02:11:16.689 --> 02:11:20.537
<v Chad Robison>After seeing what I've seen, I have one question for everyone: why?

1090
02:11:22.137 --> 02:11:22.574
<v Chad Robison>I was there.

1091
02:11:23.673 --> 02:11:25.000
<v Chad Robison>I saw that pain firsthand.

1092
02:11:25.047 --> 02:11:25.177
<v Chad Robison>Thank you.

1093
02:11:27.740 --> 02:11:28.613
<v Chad Robison>I saw the injuries.

1094
02:11:29.454 --> 02:11:35.372
<v Chad Robison>I saw people unable to open their eyes, struggling to breathe, frightened and coughing.

1095
02:11:36.390 --> 02:11:38.148
<v Chad Robison>I saw it in their faces while we tried to—.

1096
02:11:39.050 --> 02:11:39.275
<v Chad Robison>Sorry—.

1097
02:11:40.581 --> 02:11:42.917
<v Chad Robison>While we tried to wash the chemicals from their eyes and skin.

1098
02:11:43.577 --> 02:11:49.552
<v Chad Robison>What I never saw was tear gas making the situation safer, calmer, or better.

1099
02:11:51.168 --> 02:11:55.050
<v Chad Robison>So after everything I've witnessed and everyone I've treated, I keep coming back to that same question.

1100
02:11:58.765 --> 02:12:02.677
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Jen.

1101
02:12:02.726 --> 02:12:08.975
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to all 4 of our panelists for coming in and for sharing these stories and for your experience and expertise in this.

1102
02:12:10.600 --> 02:12:14.515
<v Sameer Kanal>Quick housekeeping note, and then we'll start the queue with Councilor Novick and then Councilor Koyama Lane.

1103
02:12:14.984 --> 02:12:18.529
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe, Councilor Smith, your hand is a legacy hand, but feel free to jump back in the queue.

1104
02:12:19.735 --> 02:12:27.546
<v Sameer Kanal>The presentation was added to the, um, the documents online so you can all go look at that if you want to refer back to the slides at any point.

1105
02:12:27.644 --> 02:12:31.229
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll go to Councilor Novick if you have any questions, followed by Councilor Koyama Lane.

1106
02:12:31.422 --> 02:12:31.664
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1107
02:12:33.605 --> 02:12:34.365
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

1108
02:12:34.640 --> 02:12:41.117
<v Steve Novick>Um, on the issue of fatalities from the use of chemical weapons, uh, we heard about— we heard about one in particular.

1109
02:12:41.215 --> 02:12:43.738
<v Steve Novick>Are there other instances that we can talk about?

1110
02:12:44.047 --> 02:12:53.738
<v Erica Moseson>One of the largest areas put out a 0.03% But again, these things are— they're hard to study in the way it's being used now with these kind of repeated exposures.

1111
02:12:54.315 --> 02:12:57.091
<v Erica Moseson>Another one, the dissipation really matters.

1112
02:12:57.140 --> 02:13:05.980
<v Erica Moseson>So ATS, the terrorism section, has recommendations if you can't avoid it, one of which is specifically avoiding kettling tactics.

1113
02:13:06.606 --> 02:13:14.677
<v Erica Moseson>There was 26— I think, sorry, 34 individuals in Egypt who died all at one time from deployment of a tear gas agent into a vehicle.

1114
02:13:14.725 --> 02:13:15.175
<v Erica Moseson>I think that's a lot.

1115
02:13:16.457 --> 02:13:17.612
<v Erica Moseson>And they died.

1116
02:13:17.676 --> 02:13:19.087
<v Erica Moseson>I think 34 or 45 died.

1117
02:13:20.240 --> 02:13:26.461
<v Erica Moseson>And so it really does have to do with the ability to escape ventilation and getting away from these things.

1118
02:13:26.813 --> 02:13:30.148
<v Erica Moseson>And when you see the clouds, I have to say, like, that was— those are pretty shocking images.

1119
02:13:31.061 --> 02:13:38.323
<v Erica Moseson>But I can get you— this was 5 minutes, and I apologize, I didn't have time to put everything together, but I can— I'm happy to share other references.

1120
02:13:38.997 --> 02:13:40.887
<v Erica Moseson>The ATS has a wide—.

1121
02:13:40.984 --> 02:13:43.710
<v Steve Novick>When you say 0.03%, is that—.

1122
02:13:43.710 --> 02:13:48.670
<v Erica Moseson>That was from one study of heavily— like, I want to say it was 5,000 individuals.

1123
02:13:49.949 --> 02:13:57.270
<v Erica Moseson>And I, I don't want to be giving incorrect information, so I'm happy to provide those references to you guys and staff.

1124
02:13:57.270 --> 02:13:59.489
<v Erica Moseson>But that— and I'm happy to follow up.

1125
02:13:59.529 --> 02:14:01.630
<v Steve Novick>And that's like a worldwide study?

1126
02:14:01.630 --> 02:14:03.310
<v Erica Moseson>No, no, no, no, that— no, it wasn't a worldwide study.

1127
02:14:03.310 --> 02:14:04.470
<v Erica Moseson>It was a study.

1128
02:14:04.470 --> 02:14:11.023
<v Erica Moseson>So the way these things work is you— and again, I'm a clinician, I'm a full-time doc, I'm not a I'm not a researcher, but once upon a time I did do research.

1129
02:14:11.841 --> 02:14:24.998
<v Erica Moseson>This was a study of people who were exposed in an area, and then they looked at how many of those people exposed, what we call a cohort that they followed, like how many seemed to have died from the exposure.

1130
02:14:25.635 --> 02:14:30.207
<v Erica Moseson>And then there's lots of case reports where someone is exposed, comes in with fulminant respiratory failure.

1131
02:14:31.100 --> 02:14:39.689
<v Erica Moseson>But so there's many counts of people dying after tear gas exposure, but if you're trying to get like a rate of how many people exposed from one instance will die.

1132
02:14:39.962 --> 02:14:42.829
<v Erica Moseson>That's, that's kind of a— that's a hard thing to get as a number.

1133
02:14:42.942 --> 02:14:43.359
<v Erica Moseson>Does that make sense?

1134
02:14:43.407 --> 02:14:48.037
<v Erica Moseson>But there's, there's a lot of case reports of people dying, which means that someone was heavily exposed and then died.

1135
02:14:48.694 --> 02:14:52.091
<v Erica Moseson>Um, but trying to get like put a number on it is, is a challenge.

1136
02:14:52.237 --> 02:14:55.586
<v Steve Novick>And, um, could we see some of those just individual case reports?

1137
02:14:55.905 --> 02:14:56.274
<v Erica Moseson>Oh, absolutely.

1138
02:14:56.323 --> 02:14:57.541
<v Erica Moseson>Yeah, yeah, no, those I could send you.

1139
02:14:57.604 --> 02:15:01.305
<v Erica Moseson>They're, um, I can, I can get you that later today.

1140
02:15:02.091 --> 02:15:02.655
<v Erica Moseson>Thank you.

1141
02:15:02.735 --> 02:15:03.300
<v Erica Moseson>Yeah, of course.

1142
02:15:03.622 --> 02:15:14.350
<v Steve Novick>I might be jumping the gun here, Mr. Chairman, but we had a lot of back and forth about the capacity of the local government to force ICE to unmask.

1143
02:15:14.738 --> 02:15:20.923
<v Steve Novick>What do we— without breaching any attorney-client privilege, what do the lawyers say about our ability?

1144
02:15:22.087 --> 02:15:39.867
<v Steve Novick>We've gone to court to limit the use of tear gas, but what about the ability of the city just by there will be upcoming information on that, but I think I will—.

1145
02:15:39.867 --> 02:15:41.779
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm happy to get you connected to the lawyers we've been talking to.

1146
02:15:42.037 --> 02:15:42.993
<v Erica Moseson>Okay, thank you.

1147
02:15:43.252 --> 02:15:44.677
<v Sameer Kanal>A little outside the scope of the health conversation.

1148
02:15:47.176 --> 02:15:47.418
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1149
02:15:47.467 --> 02:15:48.356
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1150
02:15:48.436 --> 02:15:49.908
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Koyama Lane, followed by Green.

1151
02:15:50.377 --> 02:15:51.395
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair.

1152
02:15:51.751 --> 02:15:54.126
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciate your focus on public health.

1153
02:15:54.865 --> 02:16:00.126
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And the impacts of federal overreach and the use of chemical agents.

1154
02:16:00.658 --> 02:16:11.164
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will share that in early February during that, during and after that Labor Against ICE march, I had a lot of my former students reaching out.

1155
02:16:12.984 --> 02:16:31.014
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>In broad daylight, they were with their parents peacefully marching at a march that even my own teachers union was supporting and was at and were met with force, and tear gas was deployed on them without any warning.

1156
02:16:31.288 --> 02:16:35.265
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And those kids were really, really scared and hurt.

1157
02:16:36.718 --> 02:16:39.575
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was so angry to hear about that.

1158
02:16:43.005 --> 02:17:07.872
<v Erica Moseson>And as a mom and teacher, I'm interested in hearing a little bit more if I'm an adult lung doctor, so I apologize, I don't have that information, but I can reach out to people who study this more in depth and get that and try to supply that.

1159
02:17:11.397 --> 02:17:14.336
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's incredibly important for us to get more information on.

1160
02:17:14.876 --> 02:17:27.471
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>As we're talking about specifically federal overreach and how this, you know, we saw in February a willingness to cross the line and hurt children.

1161
02:17:28.004 --> 02:17:38.522
<v Erica Moseson>I can say with other forms of inhalational toxins, children are at a particularly vulnerable time because they breathe more than adults and then they inhale more, and then you're also hitting a critical developmental window.

1162
02:17:38.925 --> 02:17:43.379
<v Erica Moseson>So anything that stunts lung growth early, and this includes, you know, air pollution exposure while yeah.

1163
02:17:43.909 --> 02:17:57.541
<v Erica Moseson>So if children are being born premature because of exposures, they are born with lower lung function, and then that just increases their likelihood over time to develop asthma, COPD, other forms of obstructive lung disease, or stunted lungs.

1164
02:17:57.590 --> 02:18:10.046
<v Erica Moseson>So I think, I imagine that if there is data out there, it would show exactly the same thing, but the degree and specificity related to tear gas, I would have to just provide you later if there is anything.

1165
02:18:10.880 --> 02:18:12.376
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for sharing your expertise.

1166
02:18:12.471 --> 02:18:24.816
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And as a mom of a kiddo who needs an inhaler and has asthma, and someone who's supported a lot of kids who need inhalers and have asthma, I think this is something we should maybe try to get an expert on to talk more specifically about this.

1167
02:18:25.024 --> 02:18:25.346
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1168
02:18:26.379 --> 02:18:26.555
<v Luciani>Heard.

1169
02:18:26.716 --> 02:18:27.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1170
02:18:27.923 --> 02:18:30.272
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Councilor Green followed by Councilor Ryan.

1171
02:18:31.800 --> 02:18:32.814
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

1172
02:18:33.152 --> 02:18:44.876
<v Mitch Green>Um, thank you so much to the panelists today for thank you, Deputy City Attorney, for sharing this kind of environmental and health-related presentation on the impacts of tear gas in our communities.

1173
02:18:45.772 --> 02:18:47.520
<v Mitch Green>I wanted to follow up on a question.

1174
02:18:47.952 --> 02:18:49.731
<v Mitch Green>Is Dr. Moses right?

1175
02:18:50.021 --> 02:18:53.915
<v Mitch Green>You had made reference to some training activity that is no longer used.

1176
02:18:53.963 --> 02:18:54.764
<v Mitch Green>Can you say that?

1177
02:18:55.004 --> 02:18:56.255
<v Erica Moseson>Can you clarify that?

1178
02:18:56.623 --> 02:19:02.619
<v Erica Moseson>So there's a— the US military did a study, and I have that one.

1179
02:19:02.683 --> 02:19:03.996
<v Erica Moseson>I do have the reference for it, so I can give it to you.

1180
02:19:04.110 --> 02:19:12.108
<v Erica Moseson>Because it was helpful, where it was common practice— and I think they've lowered the exposure— to do this chamber study which was called like a mask confidence study.

1181
02:19:12.172 --> 02:19:25.356
<v Erica Moseson>And again, I have worked at a couple VAs but never served in the military, so I don't want to be saying this incorrectly— where they would actually expose— part of basic training camp was being exposed to tear gas, and you would put on a mask, um, to kind of, you know, trust the mask sort of thing.

1182
02:19:25.422 --> 02:19:27.236
<v Erica Moseson>But then part of it was also that it would be removed.

1183
02:19:27.284 --> 02:19:32.564
<v Erica Moseson>So they had a cohort of 6,000 young healthy guys who definitely You're not supposed to have asthma to join the Army, right?

1184
02:19:33.140 --> 02:19:39.439
<v Erica Moseson>So didn't have known lung disease, were exposed as part of this exercise at a level that was considered safe.

1185
02:19:40.079 --> 02:19:42.594
<v Erica Moseson>And when they followed them, they found that it was not safe at all, right?

1186
02:19:42.644 --> 02:19:46.922
<v Erica Moseson>That they were actually causing pretty significant lung damage even after one exposure.

1187
02:19:47.707 --> 02:19:52.242
<v Erica Moseson>And speaking to the point of kids and asthma, like increased wheezing and increased risk of respiratory infection.

1188
02:19:52.433 --> 02:19:56.968
<v Erica Moseson>So with other inhalational toxins, we actually know you can dramatically alter the immune system of the lung.

1189
02:19:57.947 --> 02:20:02.739
<v Erica Moseson>Which makes you, you know, more prone to infections, pneumonias, you know, lung failures of different kinds.

1190
02:20:03.894 --> 02:20:14.395
<v Erica Moseson>And so that, my understanding from people I know who do research with the Department of Defense and the military is that that had changed that practice in a pretty significant way.

1191
02:20:14.475 --> 02:20:17.376
<v Erica Moseson>But I could follow up on what that specific, that means.

1192
02:20:18.146 --> 02:20:19.012
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that.

1193
02:20:19.139 --> 02:20:20.389
<v Mitch Green>I used to be in the Army myself.

1194
02:20:20.647 --> 02:20:22.986
<v Mitch Green>I went through that exposure chamber.

1195
02:20:24.079 --> 02:20:28.477
<v Mitch Green>I'm also holding my government inhaler that I got from the VA.

1196
02:20:28.527 --> 02:20:30.315
<v Erica Moseson>Symbicort from the VA, probably, right?

1197
02:20:30.379 --> 02:20:32.490
<v Erica Moseson>I've been fighting to change that formula.

1198
02:20:33.040 --> 02:20:35.708
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, it's, you know, it's better than not having it.

1199
02:20:35.949 --> 02:20:39.308
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, but I remember that experience acutely.

1200
02:20:40.290 --> 02:20:41.431
<v Erica Moseson>And you didn't have it going in, right?

1201
02:20:41.860 --> 02:20:41.907
<v Mitch Green>No.

1202
02:20:42.520 --> 02:20:42.697
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Uh-huh.

1203
02:20:43.100 --> 02:20:43.341
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1204
02:20:43.968 --> 02:20:55.804
<v Mitch Green>And so, yeah, I'm encouraged to hear that the military has acknowledged that this This is even too much for its recruits and folks to be exposed to.

1205
02:20:56.781 --> 02:21:02.665
<v Mitch Green>I was, one of my additional duties in the Army was the nuclear biological chemical NCO for my unit.

1206
02:21:02.728 --> 02:21:11.690
<v Mitch Green>And so I had to do the thing where I, you know, dust it up, put folks through the chamber, and breathe a lot of that stuff.

1207
02:21:12.731 --> 02:21:17.460
<v Mitch Green>But I breathed a lot more of it on Tear Gas Tuesday in downtown Portland.

1208
02:21:18.363 --> 02:21:28.648
<v Mitch Green>I was at that event in South Waterfront in February, and I remember, and I just, I'm with you on getting choked up about this, because I remember seeing the strollers.

1209
02:21:29.037 --> 02:21:30.620
<v Mitch Green>So I just want to validate that.

1210
02:21:31.090 --> 02:21:31.218
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1211
02:21:31.266 --> 02:21:38.447
<v Mitch Green>It's kind of hard to not feel that emotion from the parents who are scared.

1212
02:21:38.868 --> 02:21:49.005
<v Mitch Green>Their children are, I mean, their babies in strollers being exposed to tear gas, and there's no, It's a canyon through there with the apartment buildings, and there was no wind that day.

1213
02:21:49.165 --> 02:21:49.439
<v Mitch Green>Oh yeah.

1214
02:21:49.647 --> 02:21:59.913
<v Mitch Green>And the feds were just launching tear gas, and it was a thick cloud of tear gas that was just hanging around, and you can't get out of it, and you can't get away.

1215
02:21:59.994 --> 02:22:01.468
<v Mitch Green>And I remember seeing folks—.

1216
02:22:01.998 --> 02:22:05.897
<v Chad Robison>These were families who didn't know about protesting.

1217
02:22:06.009 --> 02:22:06.585
<v Chad Robison>They were just there.

1218
02:22:07.355 --> 02:22:13.566
<v Chad Robison>One of my medics was— he didn't have time to put his PPE on, And he just kept going in because families didn't know.

1219
02:22:13.630 --> 02:22:15.075
<v Chad Robison>They just stood there in the gas.

1220
02:22:15.156 --> 02:22:16.247
<v Chad Robison>They didn't know to get out of it.

1221
02:22:17.629 --> 02:22:19.957
<v Chad Robison>And he would just go and start grabbing people and go back.

1222
02:22:20.069 --> 02:22:23.393
<v Chad Robison>And I got a picture of him and he's just— it's horrible.

1223
02:22:23.441 --> 02:22:24.532
<v Chad Robison>He's just so messed up.

1224
02:22:24.629 --> 02:22:27.712
<v Chad Robison>But he just kept going back in to grab families and pull them out.

1225
02:22:28.387 --> 02:22:28.548
<v Luciani>Yeah.

1226
02:22:29.365 --> 02:22:31.774
<v Mitch Green>No, that's a level of bravery.

1227
02:22:31.838 --> 02:22:32.465
<v Mitch Green>I think that—.

1228
02:22:32.737 --> 02:22:33.123
<v Chad Robison>I agree.

1229
02:22:33.316 --> 02:22:39.037
<v Mitch Green>Folks, it's hard to It's hard to respect and appreciate unless you see it yourself.

1230
02:22:40.579 --> 02:22:41.578
<v Mitch Green>So kudos to those folks.

1231
02:22:44.739 --> 02:23:16.031
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, so we, you know, Councilor Morillo and I brought forward an ordinance to place an impact fee on detention facilities, you know, with the intention here that recognizing that we can't, you know, necessarily direct the federal government on how to behave, we can require that landlords who lease to such an entity and allow toxins to be emitted in that fashion pay some sort of cost because of it.

1232
02:23:16.752 --> 02:23:28.759
<v Mitch Green>And I just want to note that for folks who are watching this presentation today, the city is still in rulemaking on the specific manner in which those impact fees will be administered.

1233
02:23:29.352 --> 02:23:33.623
<v Mitch Green>I think that's due on August 26th, is kind of when the final rulemaking will be published.

1234
02:23:34.073 --> 02:23:43.320
<v Mitch Green>But the intention behind that law was to really capture the impacts in almost like an externality sort of way.

1235
02:23:43.386 --> 02:23:57.627
<v Mitch Green>And so this type of presentation is extremely helpful for us bringing in a universe of social costs that are not borne by, you know, the landlord of the ice facility or any other actor the federal government in particular, but the rest of us.

1236
02:23:58.093 --> 02:23:59.264
<v Mitch Green>We all bear that cost.

1237
02:23:59.377 --> 02:24:07.181
<v Mitch Green>And so as we do this rulemaking and as we adjust that over time, our impact fees need to be commensurate with those costs.

1238
02:24:07.549 --> 02:24:10.471
<v Mitch Green>And they are significant and they are sometimes hard to measure.

1239
02:24:10.697 --> 02:24:11.900
<v Mitch Green>But thanks for coming today.

1240
02:24:12.447 --> 02:24:20.395
<v Mitch Green>I really appreciate the difficult conversation and sharing of perspective or experiences here and your expertise in this.

1241
02:24:20.492 --> 02:24:22.465
<v Mitch Green>Work, and thanks for scheduling this, Councilor.

1242
02:24:23.426 --> 02:24:24.308
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1243
02:24:24.649 --> 02:24:26.036
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan, followed by Novick.

1244
02:24:27.299 --> 02:24:28.091
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

1245
02:24:28.365 --> 02:24:29.899
<v Dan Ryan>First of all, I, I have the floor.

1246
02:24:30.141 --> 02:24:32.759
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to ask you, Chair, this meeting ends at 12:30.

1247
02:24:32.807 --> 02:24:36.052
<v Dan Ryan>We have one more item, so how many more minutes do we have for this item?

1248
02:24:38.063 --> 02:24:39.558
<v Sameer Kanal>The previous item went over.

1249
02:24:39.896 --> 02:24:41.873
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, this one was scheduled for 1 hour.

1250
02:24:42.308 --> 02:24:45.668
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so, and we started at 11:07, so 12:07.

1251
02:24:46.038 --> 02:24:47.415
<v Sameer Kanal>16 minutes.

1252
02:24:47.478 --> 02:24:49.099
<v Dan Ryan>My question was, what about the next item?

1253
02:24:49.261 --> 02:24:50.637
<v Dan Ryan>Are we going to get to that today?

1254
02:24:50.960 --> 02:24:51.284
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1255
02:24:51.365 --> 02:24:54.086
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, so how many more minutes are left on this item?

1256
02:24:54.917 --> 02:24:55.272
<v Dan Ryan>16.

1257
02:24:55.626 --> 02:24:56.190
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, thanks.

1258
02:24:56.898 --> 02:25:02.761
<v Dan Ryan>Um, so I understand and appreciate this issue, and thank you to those who are presenting this morning.

1259
02:25:02.808 --> 02:25:03.421
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate it.

1260
02:25:05.229 --> 02:25:07.469
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I have my own tear gas stories.

1261
02:25:07.599 --> 02:25:09.028
<v Dan Ryan>I think we all do.

1262
02:25:09.304 --> 02:25:15.293
<v Dan Ryan>And so it does impact us emotionally when we listen to such testimony.

1263
02:25:15.375 --> 02:25:21.274
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I'm surprised we haven't talked about— I didn't hear the current state and federal restrictions that are in place.

1264
02:25:21.355 --> 02:25:22.309
<v Dan Ryan>That would have been helpful.

1265
02:25:22.358 --> 02:25:25.279
<v Dan Ryan>Did someone talk about that and I just missed it?

1266
02:25:27.876 --> 02:25:28.457
<v Erica Moseson>I'm a lung doctor.

1267
02:25:28.505 --> 02:25:31.863
<v Erica Moseson>My, my understanding is of the chemical impacts of these agents.

1268
02:25:31.912 --> 02:25:32.251
<v Erica Moseson>I don't—.

1269
02:25:32.251 --> 02:25:32.590
<v Erica Moseson>I'm not—.

1270
02:25:32.718 --> 02:25:35.109
<v Erica Moseson>I don't know much about federal law specifically.

1271
02:25:35.992 --> 02:25:36.322
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry.

1272
02:25:36.799 --> 02:25:38.301
<v Dan Ryan>Because anyway, that's helpful.

1273
02:25:39.876 --> 02:25:44.356
<v Dan Ryan>I just think everyone should understand what they are as we dive into this issue.

1274
02:25:44.854 --> 02:25:53.977
<v Dan Ryan>But maybe that's my confusion at the moment, Chair, is what do we— I listened to a presentation, it was gripping, but where's this going?

1275
02:25:54.411 --> 02:25:55.278
<v Dan Ryan>What are we doing today?

1276
02:25:56.578 --> 02:26:00.048
<v Sameer Kanal>We're hearing a presentation on the public health impacts of chemical weapons usage.

1277
02:26:00.416 --> 02:26:07.031
<v Sameer Kanal>And if there's questions as to the expertise of all 4 presenters on health, I think that's a great opportunity to do it.

1278
02:26:07.096 --> 02:26:12.583
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, but today we're not hearing about the current state and federal restrictions that are currently in place?

1279
02:26:13.770 --> 02:26:14.075
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

1280
02:26:14.476 --> 02:26:14.781
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1281
02:26:15.343 --> 02:26:17.027
<v Sameer Kanal>Outside of the scope of public health impacts.

1282
02:26:17.588 --> 02:26:20.653
<v Dan Ryan>Well, I think it's— I think a lot of things are outside of scope.

1283
02:26:20.958 --> 02:26:21.760
<v Dan Ryan>That's what I'm trying to get at.

1284
02:26:21.855 --> 02:26:31.176
<v Dan Ryan>And are we not— are we going to hear from the Portland Police Bureau, who's often mentioned because they're here, and were they engaged in this?

1285
02:26:32.702 --> 02:26:36.559
<v Sameer Kanal>No, this is an external stakeholder panel with public health experts.

1286
02:26:37.427 --> 02:26:37.668
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1287
02:26:38.310 --> 02:26:48.627
<v Dan Ryan>I think sometimes I get confused when we don't lean into the experts that are within our own city staff on an item that seems to be connected to them as well.

1288
02:26:49.060 --> 02:26:53.431
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm hearing you'd like a presentation with the users of chemical weapons in the future.

1289
02:26:53.495 --> 02:27:00.418
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I think when we hear implications and we don't have a chance to have balanced dialogue, it just doesn't feel right.

1290
02:27:01.060 --> 02:27:03.742
<v Dan Ryan>So it feels like we're not doing objective democracy.

1291
02:27:04.159 --> 02:27:09.459
<v Dan Ryan>So I just was confused about what the scope of this was in this committee at this time.

1292
02:27:09.780 --> 02:27:09.891
<v Luciani>Yeah.

1293
02:27:09.956 --> 02:27:10.486
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you—.

1294
02:27:10.679 --> 02:27:12.574
<v Dan Ryan>I really am just a little lost on what we're doing.

1295
02:27:12.926 --> 02:27:13.969
<v Sameer Kanal>No, I appreciate that.

1296
02:27:14.034 --> 02:27:18.112
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm happy to bring this discussion back with different panelists.

1297
02:27:18.161 --> 02:27:22.174
<v Sameer Kanal>If you have other users of chemical weapons you'd like me to invite, I'd also welcome that.

1298
02:27:23.186 --> 02:27:26.143
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mr.

1299
02:27:26.415 --> 02:27:26.592
<v Loretta Smith>Chair.

1300
02:27:27.925 --> 02:27:41.707
<v Steve Novick>Dr. Moses, you brought up wildfire, and this might be an unfair question, but also since we have lung people here, and I want to take the opportunity kind of to warn people not to go out when there's a lot of smoke in the air.

1301
02:27:42.782 --> 02:27:58.959
<v Steve Novick>So my unfair question is, is there like any comparisons of one exposure to tear gas as opposed to 4 hours of being out in the air that, you know, the 160 unhealthy level we had last week.

1302
02:27:59.260 --> 02:28:05.649
<v Steve Novick>And if you can't answer that, I just, I wouldn't want to give the opportunity to talk about going out in really unhealthy air and why it's bad and why you shouldn't do it.

1303
02:28:05.780 --> 02:28:09.620
<v Erica Moseson>Actually, I do know a lot more about wildfire smoke living here than I do necessarily about tear gas.

1304
02:28:09.620 --> 02:28:13.680
<v Erica Moseson>But, you know, a head-to-head comparison I think would be challenging because all these things have to do with dose.

1305
02:28:14.680 --> 02:28:24.791
<v Erica Moseson>You know, we do know that elevating levels of the particulate matter PM2.5 in the air you know, also can increase your risk of, you know, asthma, you know, pneumonias, that sort of thing.

1306
02:28:25.161 --> 02:28:39.486
<v Erica Moseson>I think the scale, if I'm remembering the studies, it seems like the scale for one exposure for healthy men, I can't think of a— I don't believe it's as high as doubling your rate of subsequent pneumonias and bronchitis.

1307
02:28:39.583 --> 02:28:41.441
<v Erica Moseson>Like, that seems pretty high.

1308
02:28:41.889 --> 02:28:46.681
<v Erica Moseson>I'd have to be thinking about what level the PM2.5 would be able to get to, but I Now you're making me curious.

1309
02:28:46.792 --> 02:28:50.013
<v Erica Moseson>I could dive into the results section of a few papers and get back to you.

1310
02:28:51.263 --> 02:28:58.825
<v Erica Moseson>But yes, you know, breathing these— this particulate matter and everything is very unhealthy because the lungs are basically designed to bring things into the venous system.

1311
02:28:58.952 --> 02:29:02.286
<v Erica Moseson>I think people think of the lungs as keeping things out of our body, and that is just not true.

1312
02:29:02.894 --> 02:29:15.486
<v Erica Moseson>The lungs, when you inhale whatever's in the air, including these toxins— hexavalent chromium, cyanide, all these carcinogens— they go straight across the bloodstream, across a one-cell-thick barrier, and into the bloodstream, and they circulate all around the body.

1313
02:29:15.566 --> 02:29:25.550
<v Erica Moseson>So that's That's why inhaling wildfires and particulate matter and air pollution cause things like heart attacks, strokes, dementia, and cognitive changes in children's brains, all these different things, right?

1314
02:29:25.615 --> 02:29:28.908
<v Erica Moseson>So, um, that's— I think people misunderstand.

1315
02:29:28.988 --> 02:29:30.489
<v Erica Moseson>They think the lungs are like skin, and they're not.

1316
02:29:30.764 --> 02:29:35.082
<v Erica Moseson>So basically, if you're breathing something, you're essentially— it's in your bloodstream instantly.

1317
02:29:35.130 --> 02:29:37.120
<v Erica Moseson>It's why, like, people like to inhale drugs, you know?

1318
02:29:37.251 --> 02:29:39.028
<v Erica Moseson>It's because it's like doing an IV injection.

1319
02:29:40.718 --> 02:29:48.819
<v Steve Novick>Um, actually, just to warn you, I might ask you to come to the Public Safety Committee and talk about the impact of wildfire smoke on people's lungs?

1320
02:29:48.819 --> 02:29:54.819
<v Steve Novick>Because I, I think we're going to have these events over and over, and I think you take the opportunity to tell people you really should not go outside.

1321
02:29:54.819 --> 02:29:57.989
<v Steve Novick>I spent last week arguing with my dog about how long walks we should take.

1322
02:29:58.479 --> 02:30:00.100
<v Erica Moseson>Okay, yeah, absolutely.

1323
02:30:00.100 --> 02:30:01.500
<v Erica Moseson>No, it's a passion of mine.

1324
02:30:01.500 --> 02:30:04.040
<v Erica Moseson>If I can't come, I'm sure someone else from OTS can come.

1325
02:30:04.040 --> 02:30:05.120
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1326
02:30:05.120 --> 02:30:06.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1327
02:30:06.180 --> 02:30:09.110
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm gonna go to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney and then back to Councilor Koyama Lane.

1328
02:30:09.520 --> 02:30:10.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1329
02:30:10.620 --> 02:30:19.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wasn't sure if I was going to jump in because I didn't know where we stood on time, but I do I have just a couple of questions or clarifications, and if you don't have the answers, that's okay.

1330
02:30:19.819 --> 02:30:22.254
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But before I started digging elsewhere, I figured I'd try.

1331
02:30:23.504 --> 02:30:32.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've heard a lot about the studies and the specifics around CS, around tear gas, but I've also heard you all mention OC, which is pepper spray essentially.

1332
02:30:33.745 --> 02:30:45.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>2, are the studies that you've referenced particular to CS tear gas, or are there studies on the long-term health impacts of repeated exposure of OC, of pepper spray, as well?

1333
02:30:46.021 --> 02:30:47.913
<v Erica Moseson>Yeah, so it's a mix, I would say.

1334
02:30:48.024 --> 02:30:58.109
<v Erica Moseson>So the one— this chamber study for the recruits was in CS, but you have similar— you see kind of similar activation of the receptors, I think, with OC.

1335
02:30:59.246 --> 02:30:59.343
<v Chad Robison>They—.

1336
02:31:00.191 --> 02:31:06.908
<v Erica Moseson>Those kind of ion channels that I talked about before and the kind of the propagation of the inflammation in the airways.

1337
02:31:07.263 --> 02:31:10.201
<v Erica Moseson>Again, human epidemiology can be really challenging on this.

1338
02:31:10.314 --> 02:31:14.891
<v Erica Moseson>The other thing that can be challenging is it's hard to know sometimes what's being sprayed.

1339
02:31:14.987 --> 02:31:36.045
<v Erica Moseson>So when they try to do a study afterwards of, you know, in humans who were heavily exposed, unless you know what it is, like the military is saying we're exposing our soldiers to this and doing this, or there's some in, um, you know, police departments, it can be challenging to know, you know, if you're doing a study like of like the protesters in Turkey, it's hard to know, you know, who was exposed to OC and who was exposed to CS.

1340
02:31:36.816 --> 02:31:46.003
<v Erica Moseson>But the CS, um, uh, my understanding is that CS, OC, and then this new synthetic variant of that tend to be the 3 most common chemicals that are in use.

1341
02:31:46.933 --> 02:31:54.771
<v Erica Moseson>But when you look at the biology of what's going on in terms of the, the neurons in the lungs, they are causing kind of similar activation of the, the concerning channels.

1342
02:31:54.818 --> 02:31:57.180
<v Erica Moseson>So I think probably fairly—.

1343
02:31:58.175 --> 02:31:58.737
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's helpful.

1344
02:31:58.817 --> 02:32:11.398
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then for the the longer-term reproductive health impacts, are those seen with OC also, or are those impacts specific to CS, or do we not know because we don't know?

1345
02:32:11.542 --> 02:32:14.635
<v Erica Moseson>I don't know if the toxicologist has, uh, has information on that.

1346
02:32:14.924 --> 02:32:26.588
<v Erica Moseson>My understanding is a lot of those studies were, um, were again going to probably run into the same problem because they were done on people kind of in this kind of large exposure.

1347
02:32:26.637 --> 02:32:30.730
<v Erica Moseson>So It's hard to know what was the agent deployed, at least as far as I know.

1348
02:32:30.779 --> 02:32:31.597
<v Erica Moseson>I don't know if they have that.

1349
02:32:32.224 --> 02:32:34.327
<v Erica Moseson>The toxicologist could speak to that, or—.

1350
02:32:34.568 --> 02:32:37.907
<v Stacy Harper>I do not have any further insights on that.

1351
02:32:38.422 --> 02:32:38.663
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1352
02:32:39.305 --> 02:32:50.994
<v Erica Moseson>I would say the inhibitory— when people are pregnant, one of the ways— there's this inhibitory peptide that is a way that they respond to kind of mitigate the effects of the activation of one of those receptors.

1353
02:32:51.106 --> 02:32:57.858
<v Erica Moseson>And then people who are pregnant, sometimes their That for whatever reason, that antibody that is used is lower or is destroyed.

1354
02:32:57.922 --> 02:33:08.549
<v Erica Moseson>And so they may not— for that one, there's the kind of the biological concern about a diminished capacity when people are pregnant to respond to decrease the inflammation from pepper spray, from the capsaicin.

1355
02:33:08.742 --> 02:33:09.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1356
02:33:10.024 --> 02:33:17.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then I was going to ask a question specific to non-human animals, but if you have an answer on that question, I'd gladly hear that as well.

1357
02:33:17.718 --> 02:33:29.165
<v Charisse Bach>Yeah, my understanding is that I think that for OC, when it's like an individual is being targeted with a pepper spray or something, it's not as damaging to the broader environment because it's just directed at that one person.

1358
02:33:29.278 --> 02:33:38.350
<v Charisse Bach>But if it's deployed as a gas, first of all, we don't know what else usually is in those compounds unless we have the canister and we can see, or, you know, it's reported by the agency.

1359
02:33:38.766 --> 02:33:45.269
<v Charisse Bach>So we don't necessarily know what is being deployed into the environment in a, you know, gas or powder that is going everywhere.

1360
02:33:45.333 --> 02:33:53.698
<v Charisse Bach>And so that has not been studied as much as CS and needs, you know, the— needs further research to know how all the other things in it are impacting the environment.

1361
02:33:54.691 --> 02:34:04.834
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and while, while you're— while you have the mic, um, do we know if either of these compounds bioaccumulate or biomagnify?

1362
02:34:05.027 --> 02:34:15.834
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And are there any long-term studies in non-human animal populations about population yeah, to my knowledge, we don't know about bioaccumulation or long-term studies.

1363
02:34:15.930 --> 02:34:16.957
<v Charisse Bach>Like, they haven't been done.

1364
02:34:17.132 --> 02:34:21.465
<v Charisse Bach>And so that was one of our concerns with the NEPA lawsuit was we haven't studied this.

1365
02:34:21.560 --> 02:34:25.988
<v Charisse Bach>We don't know how it's going to impact the long-term health of our ecosystems.

1366
02:34:26.052 --> 02:34:29.710
<v Charisse Bach>And so if it does bioaccumulate, that is obviously a problem.

1367
02:34:31.010 --> 02:34:45.745
<v Charisse Bach>It seems like that it's not something that maybe continues past the life of that species, you know, the fish itself, but then it's in the soil and we don't know what happens to it after that.

1368
02:34:47.061 --> 02:34:47.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all.

1369
02:34:47.880 --> 02:34:49.855
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1370
02:34:50.513 --> 02:34:51.461
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, sorry, go for it, Stacy.

1371
02:34:51.735 --> 02:34:52.825
<v Stacy Harper>Can I just add one thing?

1372
02:34:52.875 --> 02:35:01.144
<v Stacy Harper>So that the hexachloroethane is actually bioaccumulative and probably, um, biomagnifiable as well.

1373
02:35:01.850 --> 02:35:03.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So Great.

1374
02:35:03.093 --> 02:35:04.279
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that's that 3rd substance?

1375
02:35:04.960 --> 02:35:05.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1376
02:35:05.611 --> 02:35:06.325
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1377
02:35:08.540 --> 02:35:08.667
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1378
02:35:08.717 --> 02:35:11.004
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go to Councilor Koyama Lane, and then I'll close out the queue.

1379
02:35:11.309 --> 02:35:11.939
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1380
02:35:12.195 --> 02:35:23.073
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair, and thank you for the conversations around what should be on the agenda, what is committee of— should be at Committee of the Whole versus at certain committees.

1381
02:35:23.202 --> 02:35:24.943
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think these are important conversations to have.

1382
02:35:25.010 --> 02:35:27.239
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Committee of the Whole is something that we're new at.

1383
02:35:27.338 --> 02:35:28.648
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's not new in general.

1384
02:35:29.531 --> 02:35:30.511
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Many other bodies have it.

1385
02:35:30.592 --> 02:35:34.108
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I think it's important for us to ask those questions and tease that out.

1386
02:35:34.188 --> 02:35:42.602
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think that's important for me, the focus on it being about federal response, federal overreach, protecting all Portlanders.

1387
02:35:43.195 --> 02:35:44.415
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That does make sense to me.

1388
02:35:44.545 --> 02:35:52.236
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I appreciate that Chair Novick of Community and Public Safety asked questions about what needs to be followed up in that committee.

1389
02:35:52.429 --> 02:35:53.215
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's really important.

1390
02:35:53.280 --> 02:35:53.459
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes.

1391
02:35:53.950 --> 02:35:55.060
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think that should happen.

1392
02:35:56.852 --> 02:36:06.601
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I just want to be clear because I think we've— I've said something like this on the dais, but I've also talked to Chief Day and PPA President Aaron Schmeltz about this.

1393
02:36:07.709 --> 02:36:13.349
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You know, I don't— just to be clear, and I see some of our officers here today, thank you for being here.

1394
02:36:13.574 --> 02:36:18.588
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do not see you tear gassing our children in Portland, and I want to just state that.

1395
02:36:20.176 --> 02:36:27.386
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think when we're talking about how this applies and works within our city with city employees, I think that's an important conversation to have.

1396
02:36:27.738 --> 02:36:37.067
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I've had conversations with the chief and with President Schmaltz about feeling that this— we have changed.

1397
02:36:37.115 --> 02:36:39.909
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Our bureau has changed in the last 6, 7 years.

1398
02:36:40.165 --> 02:36:45.239
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that they want that to be recognized and they want trust to be built back up.

1399
02:36:45.961 --> 02:36:46.490
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We've—.

1400
02:36:46.506 --> 02:36:57.996
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I've recognized that I've even— I started hearing last fall from people who are like leftists being like, wow, our police bureau is showing up, they're surprising us in some like really wonderful ways.

1401
02:36:58.444 --> 02:37:01.779
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that question about like, how do we get that trust?

1402
02:37:01.826 --> 02:37:03.878
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How do we move forward?

1403
02:37:04.470 --> 02:37:07.003
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think some of that is showing up in those ways.

1404
02:37:07.579 --> 02:37:12.220
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, you know, sometimes trust is like 2 steps forward, one step back, and that that happens.

1405
02:37:12.334 --> 02:37:18.585
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I want to acknowledge that there have been shifts over the last 6 years.

1406
02:37:18.716 --> 02:37:20.157
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They're not going unseen.

1407
02:37:21.649 --> 02:37:28.961
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We're talking, even in these specific examples that we're bringing up, we're not talking about our city staff in this moment right now.

1408
02:37:30.102 --> 02:37:31.224
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's going to be overlap.

1409
02:37:31.337 --> 02:37:32.004
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that makes sense.

1410
02:37:32.054 --> 02:37:33.077
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We need to have that conversation.

1411
02:37:35.346 --> 02:37:39.168
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But when I do have those conversations about like, We want that trust.

1412
02:37:39.585 --> 02:37:41.864
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It happens slowly, but I see some of that happening.

1413
02:37:42.395 --> 02:37:52.440
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I mean, I saw a little bit of backsliding with the recent ballot measure that's not gonna go forward around PSF, but I think some of that is just natural and it's gonna happen like that.

1414
02:37:52.504 --> 02:37:58.233
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that's not related to this exactly, but I guess I just want to name that.

1415
02:37:58.746 --> 02:38:07.363
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I wanna name that I see this as really talking about what we're seeing from federal overreach right now, and that it is important to acknowledge.

1416
02:38:07.427 --> 02:38:17.606
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I hear often, from our chief and from President Schmaltz, like, can we recognize that there are shifts and that things are different?

1417
02:38:17.736 --> 02:38:17.945
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes.

1418
02:38:20.065 --> 02:38:20.744
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I see that.

1419
02:38:20.808 --> 02:38:21.552
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I see the change.

1420
02:38:21.618 --> 02:38:23.088
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I see the trust trying to be built.

1421
02:38:23.477 --> 02:38:25.224
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think it is still important.

1422
02:38:25.417 --> 02:38:34.200
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I actually hope, I think it's an opportunity for folks from the police bureau and from PPA to be able to help see some of those differences too.

1423
02:38:34.424 --> 02:38:46.558
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>When we can talk about some of the federal overreach, what we're seeing, And be able to thread that needle and know that it doesn't have to mean that we're targeting anyone in particular.

1424
02:38:46.700 --> 02:38:48.680
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I hope that was okay.

1425
02:38:49.000 --> 02:38:53.000
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That just kind of was a little half-baked, but that's— I wanted to say that.

1426
02:38:53.299 --> 02:38:53.969
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for being here.

1427
02:38:54.979 --> 02:38:55.920
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1428
02:38:55.920 --> 02:38:59.319
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to have Chair Avalos and then I'll close it out.

1429
02:38:59.620 --> 02:39:01.059
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Avalos and then I'll close it out.

1430
02:39:01.180 --> 02:39:01.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

1431
02:39:01.260 --> 02:39:02.200
<v Dan Ryan>Like chair?

1432
02:39:02.200 --> 02:39:03.040
<v Loretta Smith>Well, not here.

1433
02:39:03.040 --> 02:39:03.799
<v Sameer Kanal>On committee.

1434
02:39:03.799 --> 02:39:04.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry.

1435
02:39:04.180 --> 02:39:04.530
<v Sameer Kanal>Go for it.

1436
02:39:04.680 --> 02:39:05.180
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1437
02:39:05.180 --> 02:39:06.159
<v Erica Moseson>Not at the moment, but yes.

1438
02:39:06.180 --> 02:39:07.059
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1439
02:39:07.059 --> 02:39:08.950
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

1440
02:39:10.020 --> 02:39:13.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I have a lot of thoughts, but I'll just say this.

1441
02:39:14.790 --> 02:39:16.040
<v Sameer Kanal>It—.

1442
02:39:16.040 --> 02:39:23.379
<v Candace Avalos>We spent years talking about the impacts of the chemical weapons that were being deployed on our streets.

1443
02:39:23.379 --> 02:39:32.603
<v Candace Avalos>To be clear, Portland Police regularly deployed many chemical weapons that had an enormous impact on our community.

1444
02:39:33.149 --> 02:39:42.960
<v Candace Avalos>I spent years talking to community about it, talking to experts like you all, writing a 40-page report that specifically outlined next steps to how we address that.

1445
02:39:43.586 --> 02:40:04.745
<v Candace Avalos>And because the main reason that we're being told that they're needed for is for crowd control, there are lots of ways to control a crowd that do not include deploying dangerous chemical weapons that are going into our So many people were impacted in the protests of 2020.

1446
02:40:05.004 --> 02:40:15.895
<v Candace Avalos>And so I hear what you're saying, Councilor Koyama Lane, but Portland Police is not— they are not— what am I trying to say?

1447
02:40:15.975 --> 02:40:16.748
<v Candace Avalos>They are part of the conversation.

1448
02:40:18.361 --> 02:40:35.152
<v Candace Avalos>They need to be included in this conversation because I'm concerned as we continue to see political unrest, which naturally comes when you are living in a fascist state, that we're going to keep turning to those old methods instead of seeing how we're going to protect our community and democracy.

1449
02:40:35.407 --> 02:40:38.408
<v Candace Avalos>You can do both, and I don't think tear gas does that.

1450
02:40:39.354 --> 02:40:54.673
<v Candace Avalos>And so, um, I, I think that it is important that we as a city, as we are looking at overall community safety and health, that we are considering the impacts that that has had on our community's health, people's physical health, the actual built environment.

1451
02:40:55.378 --> 02:41:08.683
<v Candace Avalos>And I want to have an honest conversation with our police about what it looks like to change our methods for crowd control so that we're not again relying on these tactics that are having a big impact.

1452
02:41:08.877 --> 02:41:10.768
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you for this conversation.

1453
02:41:10.849 --> 02:41:12.355
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for bringing your expertise.

1454
02:41:13.350 --> 02:41:23.584
<v Candace Avalos>Like I said, I've spent many years talking to people like you all and being growing ever more concerned as More research comes out about the impacts, short-term and long-term.

1455
02:41:24.083 --> 02:41:30.362
<v Candace Avalos>And I think it's very serious that we discuss what we as a city are doing to protect our community and our democracy.

1456
02:41:30.764 --> 02:41:31.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1457
02:41:32.113 --> 02:41:32.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor.

1458
02:41:34.040 --> 02:41:39.582
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so just to close this out, I have so much to follow up on and I appreciate it so much.

1459
02:41:39.662 --> 02:41:45.668
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we've talked a lot about the economic development impact of the river and the economic health of our city.

1460
02:41:46.102 --> 02:42:01.486
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I really appreciated Dr. Bach, among many other things, the conversation with the drainage into the river and frankly the clouds floating over the river, as many of these locations are, as much of Portland is, very close to the river.

1461
02:42:02.320 --> 02:42:08.389
<v Sameer Kanal>We talk a lot about the ICE facility, but there was tear gassing up in North Portland on Fessenden.

1462
02:42:08.647 --> 02:42:13.111
<v Sameer Kanal>And, you know, there's— as this has happened around the city, a lot of it has been near water.

1463
02:42:13.158 --> 02:42:13.736
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilmember Herbold.

1464
02:42:14.450 --> 02:42:16.264
<v Sameer Kanal>Whether it's a river or the slough or something like that.

1465
02:42:17.122 --> 02:42:20.753
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not going to ask the questions, but I'll follow up just for the interest of time.

1466
02:42:21.110 --> 02:42:36.197
<v Sameer Kanal>I, you know, we've talked about the industrial land use and the Portland International Raceway in North Portland and its impacts on asthma development for primarily Black and brown kids, or disproportionately Black and brown kids in that area.

1467
02:42:36.245 --> 02:42:45.627
<v Sameer Kanal>I now live in that area, and I know that that's been something that Industrial land is arm's length, but we have an impact in terms of how we run the Portland International Raceway.

1468
02:42:46.662 --> 02:43:03.381
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I've been thinking about that context as I listened to what you were saying, Dr. Moseson, about the impact that we have and what we can do directly to stop our own contributions to the health impacts on not just youth, but adults as well.

1469
02:43:04.380 --> 02:43:04.897
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1470
02:43:05.906 --> 02:43:19.969
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm very interested in following up with Stacy about the number of exposures and the degree of exposure that causes some of the incredibly concerning things you walked through in terms of reproductive health.

1471
02:43:20.486 --> 02:43:26.429
<v Sameer Kanal>And I really appreciate how candid and how blunt and not euphemistic all of you were in describing everything here.

1472
02:43:28.139 --> 02:43:29.555
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that.

1473
02:43:29.620 --> 02:43:30.824
<v Sameer Kanal>I know it was difficult and—.

1474
02:43:30.921 --> 02:43:31.408
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

1475
02:43:31.691 --> 02:43:34.484
<v Sameer Kanal>It's probably difficult to hear for folks as well, but I appreciate that.

1476
02:43:36.854 --> 02:43:39.001
<v Sameer Kanal>Chad, everything, thank you.

1477
02:43:39.113 --> 02:43:46.639
<v Sameer Kanal>But the indiscriminate nature I thought was really important, and I wanted to fix on this, and this is the question I'll ask.

1478
02:43:50.100 --> 02:43:53.783
<v Sameer Kanal>When you are— like, you can't tear gas one person in this room that we're in right now.

1479
02:43:54.861 --> 02:43:54.974
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1480
02:43:55.102 --> 02:44:02.380
<v Sameer Kanal>You can pepper spray somebody and it might affect the person next But you can't, depending on the nature of the deployment, you can't tear gas just one person in the room.

1481
02:44:02.445 --> 02:44:03.778
<v Sameer Kanal>And you talked about the clouds, right?

1482
02:44:04.479 --> 02:44:19.675
<v Sameer Kanal>So the questions I'll ask first, if you lived in an apartment building where the tear gas occurred directly outside of it, what is the— have you ever worked in a situation where you could see the impact on folks like that?

1483
02:44:19.724 --> 02:44:22.272
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm sorry to not give you a heads up about this question.

1484
02:44:22.467 --> 02:44:36.819
<v Chad Robison>No, no, I am so glad you asked this question Because there's been incidents where they've dumped, ICE has dumped so many canisters at once, it's made such a thick cloud that just, there's no wind, so it would just slowly waft.

1485
02:44:37.444 --> 02:44:42.347
<v Chad Robison>And we would have to go down block by block all the way to Carruthers Park.

1486
02:44:43.693 --> 02:44:44.959
<v Chad Robison>And I saw a lady go down.

1487
02:44:45.377 --> 02:44:50.263
<v Chad Robison>AMR had to come and transport her completely unconscious in the middle of this cloud.

1488
02:44:50.440 --> 02:44:50.697
<v Chad Robison>Wow.

1489
02:44:52.108 --> 02:44:59.905
<v Chad Robison>As going down those blocks, I heard kids coughing and crying because they had windows open, and this is blocks away.

1490
02:45:00.483 --> 02:45:05.906
<v Chad Robison>So it is the opposite of— it is the most indiscriminate weapon I can think of.

1491
02:45:06.980 --> 02:45:07.574
<v Chad Robison>It's horrible.

1492
02:45:08.809 --> 02:45:09.002
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1493
02:45:09.049 --> 02:45:12.755
<v Erica Moseson>I mean, I had patients gassed in their home who were not attending the protest.

1494
02:45:12.820 --> 02:45:19.670
<v Erica Moseson>I mean, who are dependent on DME, they need oxygen, they were not leaving and doing this, and it had infiltrated into their house.

1495
02:45:20.022 --> 02:45:21.081
<v Chad Robison>Yeah, kids in their beds.

1496
02:45:22.028 --> 02:45:25.186
<v Sameer Kanal>I think this affects— so we talked about some committees this affects.

1497
02:45:25.251 --> 02:45:34.183
<v Sameer Kanal>It also affects housing and permitting, because I know that some of the low-income housing providers that are asking us for money right now have increased costs and unmet needs in their buildings.

1498
02:45:34.231 --> 02:45:36.509
<v Sameer Kanal>I met with folks in an apartment building yesterday.

1499
02:45:37.423 --> 02:45:51.726
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the other question, does the same thing apply if, uh, I'm just going to give a specific example, if you're If tear gas is deployed in a backyard of an apartment building where the upstairs floor has people in it because it's a business.

1500
02:45:53.799 --> 02:45:54.444
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm seeing a nod.

1501
02:45:55.300 --> 02:46:03.725
<v Sameer Kanal>So happens in a backyard, 2-floor building, bottom floor is a vacant apartment, upstairs is a business that currently at the time of the deployment has—.

1502
02:46:04.626 --> 02:46:09.119
<v Chad Robison>Yeah, the first time I went down to ICE, I was blocks away and I was sneezing.

1503
02:46:09.744 --> 02:46:10.806
<v Chad Robison>And that's blocks away.

1504
02:46:11.031 --> 02:46:14.766
<v Chad Robison>So yeah, it will go everywhere.

1505
02:46:15.925 --> 02:46:16.763
<v Chad Robison>You can't contain it.

1506
02:46:16.891 --> 02:46:19.371
<v Chad Robison>You can't direct it as much as you think you can.

1507
02:46:19.565 --> 02:46:20.595
<v Chad Robison>You cannot direct it.

1508
02:46:21.352 --> 02:46:21.980
<v Chad Robison>It goes everywhere.

1509
02:46:22.238 --> 02:46:23.720
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so thank you for that.

1510
02:46:23.769 --> 02:46:25.460
<v Sameer Kanal>And I guess I'll close by just a PSA.

1511
02:46:25.524 --> 02:46:38.388
<v Sameer Kanal>If you were in a business on the 1800 block of Northwest Overton yesterday where tear gas was— sorry, chemical munitions of some type were deployed by PPB yesterday in a backyard.

1512
02:46:38.597 --> 02:46:41.841
<v Sameer Kanal>I encourage you to take a look and talk to your doctor about that.

1513
02:46:43.174 --> 02:46:46.015
<v Sameer Kanal>We are 7 minutes past time, so if you wanna close out.

1514
02:46:46.064 --> 02:46:46.610
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can I take 30 seconds?

1515
02:46:46.787 --> 02:46:47.027
<v Candace Avalos>Sure.

1516
02:46:47.604 --> 02:46:52.470
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I just wanna clarify that I agree that the police bureau needs to be part of the conversation.

1517
02:46:52.824 --> 02:47:11.996
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My hope is that we can start from a place of curiosity, and maybe there's even some collaboration, and I would hope that, I mean, when I hear the impacts on Portlanders, I would assume that if we draw a Venn diagram, I would hope that there's places where all of us agree.

1518
02:47:12.317 --> 02:47:15.043
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So that's where, that's what I'm trying to say.

1519
02:47:15.284 --> 02:47:15.605
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1520
02:47:15.829 --> 02:47:16.567
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1521
02:47:17.290 --> 02:47:18.058
<v Loretta Smith>Point of order, Mr.

1522
02:47:18.138 --> 02:47:18.427
<v Loretta Smith>Chair.

1523
02:47:19.519 --> 02:47:19.647
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1524
02:47:19.854 --> 02:47:20.834
<v Loretta Smith>I had my hand up.

1525
02:47:21.299 --> 02:47:22.950
<v Sameer Kanal>I apologize, Councilor Smith.

1526
02:47:23.047 --> 02:47:24.009
<v Sameer Kanal>I thought that was a legacy hand.

1527
02:47:24.120 --> 02:47:24.200
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1528
02:47:24.409 --> 02:47:25.709
<v Sameer Kanal>You'd like to close us out?

1529
02:47:25.789 --> 02:47:26.766
<v Sameer Kanal>We are a little past time.

1530
02:47:26.992 --> 02:47:27.408
<v Steve Novick>But thanks.

1531
02:47:27.474 --> 02:47:27.779
<v Luciani>Thank you.

1532
02:47:28.421 --> 02:47:34.265
<v Loretta Smith>So I, I just want to be clear about something because I'm— I think we're talk— talking around something that I'm not getting.

1533
02:47:34.860 --> 02:47:43.209
<v Loretta Smith>But to my understanding, Portland Police haven't used tear gas since 2020, correct?

1534
02:47:43.593 --> 02:47:45.216
<v Loretta Smith>No, that's not correct.

1535
02:47:45.682 --> 02:47:46.645
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You just said it was used yesterday.

1536
02:47:46.822 --> 02:47:47.222
<v Sameer Kanal>Yesterday.

1537
02:47:48.025 --> 02:47:48.764
<v Loretta Smith>But no, you—.

1538
02:47:48.908 --> 02:47:49.711
<v Loretta Smith>Not tear gas.

1539
02:47:49.888 --> 02:47:52.297
<v Loretta Smith>It was a chemical something.

1540
02:47:52.602 --> 02:48:01.918
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, chemical, according to, and I'm reading the, this is on the Police Bureau's website right now, update 2, armed suspect who assaulted police canine booked into jail.

1541
02:48:02.014 --> 02:48:04.634
<v Sameer Kanal>It talks about chemical munitions, munitions and weapons.

1542
02:48:04.698 --> 02:48:06.593
<v Sameer Kanal>We can argue about the distinction of those particular terms.

1543
02:48:06.691 --> 02:48:07.525
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, so I wanna ask, yeah.

1544
02:48:07.735 --> 02:48:11.100
<v Sameer Kanal>This presentation is about the public health impact of chemical weapons.

1545
02:48:11.601 --> 02:48:12.637
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so chemical weapons.

1546
02:48:12.684 --> 02:48:17.297
<v Loretta Smith>So let's see here, who uses chemical weapons?

1547
02:48:17.361 --> 02:48:19.045
<v Loretta Smith>Is that the federal government or the city government?

1548
02:48:19.493 --> 02:48:19.765
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1549
02:48:20.456 --> 02:48:21.179
<v Loretta Smith>Federal government?

1550
02:48:21.259 --> 02:48:21.468
<v Loretta Smith>Both.

1551
02:48:22.206 --> 02:48:23.281
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, city government.

1552
02:48:23.490 --> 02:48:34.361
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I think we do need to have some clarification by— I know I see Commander here, but we need to have some clarification because I think we're getting confused, and you're confusing the public because you're confusing me.

1553
02:48:35.051 --> 02:48:42.968
<v Loretta Smith>Um, what I thought was going on in the Portland, uh, Police Bureau, you're telling me something different now.

1554
02:48:43.641 --> 02:48:44.236
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not, actually.

1555
02:48:44.316 --> 02:48:44.444
<v Sameer Kanal>It's—.

1556
02:48:44.444 --> 02:48:46.040
<v Sameer Kanal>This is from the Police Bureau's website.

1557
02:48:46.190 --> 02:48:47.690
<v Loretta Smith>I— please feel free to follow up.

1558
02:48:47.690 --> 02:48:50.079
<v Loretta Smith>I need some clarification because I think you're misleading folks.

1559
02:48:50.450 --> 02:48:57.469
<v Loretta Smith>But the reality is we're not supposed to be using tear gas, and we are not supposed to have used it since 2020.

1560
02:48:57.469 --> 02:48:59.750
<v Loretta Smith>That is my understanding.

1561
02:48:59.750 --> 02:49:01.729
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll let you follow up with the Bureau on that.

1562
02:49:01.909 --> 02:49:04.370
<v Sameer Kanal>Again, the presentation is about public health.

1563
02:49:04.530 --> 02:49:05.659
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, point of order.

1564
02:49:05.989 --> 02:49:07.069
<v Loretta Smith>So, just, Chair, could you—.

1565
02:49:07.069 --> 02:49:08.649
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not a point of order, but you have the floor.

1566
02:49:08.649 --> 02:49:09.049
<v Luciani>Not a point of order, but Mr.

1567
02:49:09.049 --> 02:49:20.668
<v Loretta Smith>Chair, what I want you to do is be Be clear on how you state things, because I think you're misleading the public in what you're saying and what we're doing here.

1568
02:49:21.343 --> 02:49:28.427
<v Loretta Smith>Because we're just getting a health update on what chemicals do to a body, and you went real specific.

1569
02:49:28.492 --> 02:49:35.961
<v Loretta Smith>You went, say, if chemical weapons were dropped off in the top floor, could you get contaminated and all that?

1570
02:49:36.025 --> 02:49:39.761
<v Loretta Smith>So it sounds like you were talking about something real specific, like at the facility.

1571
02:49:40.194 --> 02:49:45.040
<v Sameer Kanal>So he's talking about something real specific at the 1800 block of Northwest Overton.

1572
02:49:45.250 --> 02:49:45.314
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1573
02:49:45.411 --> 02:49:48.476
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so just tell me what you're talking about.

1574
02:49:48.540 --> 02:49:49.647
<v Loretta Smith>Don't talk around it.

1575
02:49:50.129 --> 02:49:53.273
<v Loretta Smith>Just make it clear because you're, you're confusing it for me.

1576
02:49:53.675 --> 02:49:58.826
<v Sameer Kanal>Not sure how much clearer it could be about reading the thing, but I'm happy to follow up with more, and I am hearing the request for more clarity.

1577
02:49:59.051 --> 02:49:59.998
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, thank you.

1578
02:50:01.282 --> 02:50:02.229
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to our presenters.

1579
02:50:03.064 --> 02:50:08.988
<v Sameer Kanal>And while we're switching over to our next item, Can you please, Diego, can you please call both items 4 and 5 together?

1580
02:50:10.353 --> 02:50:16.522
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 4, document number 2026-291, Annual Budget Process Discussion Part 2.

1581
02:50:17.100 --> 02:50:23.363
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 5, document number 2026-292, Annual Budget Process Community Input.

1582
02:50:24.086 --> 02:50:25.194
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, colleagues.

1583
02:50:25.243 --> 02:50:33.529
<v Sameer Kanal>At the end of June, we had a conversation around the budget process, and during that time, We asked questions.

1584
02:50:33.577 --> 02:50:37.269
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we went through 3 rounds of questions and allowed anyone to respond.

1585
02:50:37.670 --> 02:50:43.368
<v Sameer Kanal>I was going to reopen some of those questions today because a colleague wasn't there who I know has a lot of interest in it.

1586
02:50:43.432 --> 02:50:46.144
<v Sameer Kanal>That colleague is unavailable today as well, unfortunately.

1587
02:50:46.898 --> 02:50:50.028
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm instead continuing on with the remaining questions.

1588
02:50:50.430 --> 02:50:55.468
<v Sameer Kanal>We also got feedback that we needed to have some public testimony, and I know at least one person signed up.

1589
02:50:55.581 --> 02:50:57.411
<v Sameer Kanal>So I had these 2 items called together.

1590
02:50:57.828 --> 02:51:07.095
<v Sameer Kanal>Just, I'm gonna have a slide shared in a second here about the different steps in the budget process, which might help inform the 3 questions.

1591
02:51:07.466 --> 02:51:21.360
<v Sameer Kanal>So in terms of run a show, and I'm adapting a little bit because of the time, we're going to— I'm gonna tell you what the questions are, we're gonna take the testimony, and then I'm just gonna open up the floor until we're outta time for the meeting today to hear any thoughts that you all have on this.

1592
02:51:21.424 --> 02:51:23.158
<v Sameer Kanal>This is not the only opportunity you'll have.

1593
02:51:23.271 --> 02:51:24.652
<v Sameer Kanal>This is is part 2 of more than 2.

1594
02:51:25.744 --> 02:51:27.926
<v Sameer Kanal>And so we'll definitely circle back.

1595
02:51:28.233 --> 02:51:36.807
<v Sameer Kanal>But the questions are, at what points in the process, and the slide you're gonna see in a moment is the timeline of the process, are you interested in making changes?

1596
02:51:37.400 --> 02:51:40.531
<v Sameer Kanal>And the idea here is sort of process of elimination for the administration.

1597
02:51:40.611 --> 02:51:48.864
<v Sameer Kanal>If there's something that no councilor is interested in weighing in on, I would love them to know about it so they can go do their thing without feeling like they have to come back.

1598
02:51:49.447 --> 02:51:53.005
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1599
02:51:55.028 --> 02:51:58.700
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the 2 things that are specific that we didn't get to last time.

1600
02:51:59.152 --> 02:52:05.745
<v Sameer Kanal>What is council's vision and expectation about community engagement, including the advisory process during the budget development?

1601
02:52:07.209 --> 02:52:12.447
<v Sameer Kanal>What is council's interest in providing budget guidance to the bureaus, meaning how does the guidance work?

1602
02:52:12.674 --> 02:52:18.413
<v Sameer Kanal>At this moment, historically, the mayor has provided guidance, and that has been completely within their wheelhouse.

1603
02:52:18.493 --> 02:52:21.922
<v Sameer Kanal>According to the attorneys, they— there is nothing that says the mayor does that.

1604
02:52:22.002 --> 02:52:23.652
<v Sameer Kanal>That's just a way it's always been.

1605
02:52:24.549 --> 02:52:30.510
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and so I, I framed this question a little bit more leadingly, just to be fully, uh, candid about it.

1606
02:52:30.638 --> 02:52:35.734
<v Sameer Kanal>I have an interest in, uh, council being a part of that process for a reason that I'll get to when we get to that.

1607
02:52:36.166 --> 02:52:37.319
<v Sameer Kanal>But those are the 3 questions.

1608
02:52:37.609 --> 02:52:42.127
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so any technical questions on that before we get started with calling testimony?

1609
02:52:45.128 --> 02:52:47.703
<v Sameer Kanal>Diego, will you please call up our testifier or testifiers?

1610
02:52:48.546 --> 02:52:50.926
<v Unidentified speaker>We have one individual signed up, Terry Harris.

1611
02:52:52.459 --> 02:52:53.468
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much for being here, Terry.

1612
02:52:58.656 --> 02:52:59.725
<v Terry Harris>Um, great, thanks.

1613
02:53:00.210 --> 02:53:00.859
<v Terry Harris>Learned a lot today.

1614
02:53:02.058 --> 02:53:09.424
<v Terry Harris>Um, my name is Terry Harris, uh, from Hillsdale, and always, always appreciate the opportunity to come speak with you all.

1615
02:53:10.130 --> 02:53:19.390
<v Terry Harris>Um, quick credentials relevant to what I'm going to say, but, um, I served on the Government Transition Advisory Committee.

1616
02:53:20.161 --> 02:53:27.078
<v Terry Harris>I chaired the Budget Engagement Workgroup there, which had some recommendations on budget engagement.

1617
02:53:28.426 --> 02:53:41.559
<v Terry Harris>I am also a member of the Community Budget Advisory Committee for Multnomah Counties Um, Departments of Assets and County Management, and formerly the Department of Community Services.

1618
02:53:42.233 --> 02:53:52.537
<v Terry Harris>And I'm currently chair of the Multnomah County Central Community Advisor— Community Budget Advisory Committee.

1619
02:53:53.915 --> 02:54:10.203
<v Terry Harris>All of which to say is I'm here to remind you about the budget advisory committees that the city apparently used to have, um, and that the transition suspended as part of the transition and with the intention to reestablish them.

1620
02:54:11.150 --> 02:54:22.200
<v Terry Harris>Um, this will be going into your 3rd budget since then, and, um, like, sort of urge you to consider those processes again.

1621
02:54:23.659 --> 02:54:46.983
<v Terry Harris>Um, GTAC recommended that these budget advisory committees exist at a service area level, and— but we're willing to put it aside to be part of the advisory committee overhaul that was going to happen.

1622
02:54:47.837 --> 02:54:55.143
<v Terry Harris>That overhaul is now stalled, and it punted on advisory budget advisory committees anyway.

1623
02:54:56.079 --> 02:55:02.045
<v Terry Harris>Um, and I just sort of say, um, currently you've got nothing on that going on.

1624
02:55:03.137 --> 02:55:12.542
<v Terry Harris>And, um, that's why I'm here, with the possible exception of Pub, um, which does some budget work.

1625
02:55:13.031 --> 02:55:14.841
<v Terry Harris>And, um, bless their hearts.

1626
02:55:16.699 --> 02:55:28.922
<v Terry Harris>Um, I would go into some details as to why there are strong reasons to reestablish this But I think it was demonstrated earlier today with the New Portlanders Committee.

1627
02:55:30.471 --> 02:55:33.843
<v Terry Harris>That is a perfect example of why you have these committees.

1628
02:55:34.504 --> 02:55:39.479
<v Terry Harris>You engage great people doing great things.

1629
02:55:39.979 --> 02:55:49.501
<v Terry Harris>You let them rise up the ladder of engagement, and you make a capable citizenry one advisory committee at a time.

1630
02:55:50.109 --> 02:56:02.424
<v Terry Harris>If nothing else, um, the other thing that you do— I'm going to go a little bit over— is that you force the bureaucracy to explain themselves to laypeople.

1631
02:56:03.117 --> 02:56:06.308
<v Terry Harris>And on the budget, that's just really necessary.

1632
02:56:07.049 --> 02:56:08.790
<v Terry Harris>And I'm out of time.

1633
02:56:11.569 --> 02:56:22.263
<v Terry Harris>Wrap up by saying, well, Noma County's got a good model, um, and And I'm willing to work with anybody here to try to deploy that as soon as possible.

1634
02:56:23.129 --> 02:56:23.353
<v Terry Harris>Thanks.

1635
02:56:23.691 --> 02:56:24.879
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Terry.

1636
02:56:25.378 --> 02:56:30.177
<v Sameer Kanal>I have an interest in that as well, as you know, so I'll be looking forward to following up with you and other GTAC members.

1637
02:56:30.852 --> 02:56:32.153
<v Sameer Kanal>Colleagues, I'm going to open this up.

1638
02:56:32.218 --> 02:56:33.518
<v Sameer Kanal>We're going to get this slide shared.

1639
02:56:33.663 --> 02:56:34.818
<v Sameer Kanal>It has just the timeline.

1640
02:56:34.867 --> 02:56:41.209
<v Sameer Kanal>You've all seen it before, but it's the steps along the timeline that, that come from the beginning of the budget process through budget approval in June.

1641
02:56:41.819 --> 02:56:43.342
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, budget adoption in June.

1642
02:56:44.479 --> 02:56:47.316
<v Sameer Kanal>And feel free, we're not going to do one at a time.

1643
02:56:47.363 --> 02:56:51.707
<v Sameer Kanal>Feel free to just jump around and cover as many of these as you're interested in.

1644
02:56:52.106 --> 02:56:57.683
<v Sameer Kanal>But at which points in the process would council like to get involved in discussing potential changes?

1645
02:56:58.261 --> 02:57:04.990
<v Sameer Kanal>What is council's vision and expectation around community engagement, including budget advisory processes during this whole budget process?

1646
02:57:05.631 --> 02:57:24.059
<v Sameer Kanal>And what is your— what are your thoughts on the budget guidance that we give to— that the city leadership gives to bureaus in the starting point of developing the budget requests, which is that sort of top middle over to right center portion of the chart here.

1647
02:57:25.552 --> 02:57:28.426
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll open up the queue and I'll pass it to Council President Dunphy.

1648
02:57:28.988 --> 02:57:29.727
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1649
02:57:29.791 --> 02:57:36.406
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I just wanted to note that there were some significant I think improvements between year 1 and year 2.

1650
02:57:37.352 --> 02:57:41.573
<v Jamie Dunphy>And there were some major changes that we also did specifically.

1651
02:57:42.407 --> 02:57:53.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, we got rid of the city administrator's draft budget recommendation and the work sessions from that, and we pivoted those work sessions to talking about the current allocation level and the current service level.

1652
02:57:54.523 --> 02:58:00.075
<v Jamie Dunphy>We moved the mayor's timeline up for the proposed 2 full weeks, and we added an extra work session on that.

1653
02:58:00.139 --> 02:58:03.372
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then we had We had so many, so many work sessions going bureau by bureau.

1654
02:58:04.990 --> 02:58:09.730
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think a lot of that was really helpful, but I think that it didn't actually serve us that well.

1655
02:58:10.404 --> 02:58:13.305
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think there's some pretty easy ways for us to improve that.

1656
02:58:16.149 --> 02:58:29.468
<v Jamie Dunphy>A lot of the work, as Terry was sort of implying, and also sort of this chart sort of shows, a lot of the work of discussing and identifying the trade-offs happens out of council's purview, out of council, out of the public's view.

1657
02:58:30.862 --> 02:58:34.965
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so when the mayor's proposed comes up, we're sort of spending our time catching up.

1658
02:58:36.006 --> 02:58:41.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will always be catching up to some degree, but that's— it was a steeper learning curve than I think it really had to be.

1659
02:58:42.961 --> 02:58:54.778
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think a tangible recommendation would be that we have earlier in the year a series of baseline service area presentations to start talking about programs and budget allocations.

1660
02:58:54.906 --> 02:58:55.837
<v Jamie Dunphy>What are we doing now?

1661
02:58:56.448 --> 02:59:00.204
<v Jamie Dunphy>What are— what is— how is the bureau spending the dollars as we currently see it?

1662
02:59:01.023 --> 02:59:06.162
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then that gives us the baseline, 'cause we were trying to do that all in one session.

1663
02:59:06.226 --> 02:59:08.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're trying like, what does the fire bureau do?

1664
02:59:08.474 --> 02:59:11.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>And here's the parade of horribles that we're gonna cut from the fire bureau.

1665
02:59:12.327 --> 02:59:21.301
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that would help us to have some dialogue and also maybe give the mayor and the city administrator some time to hear priorities and flag things early.

1666
02:59:23.578 --> 02:59:40.257
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that there's also an opportunity for a forecast hearing about the upcoming budgets so that we could have, and the public can have some better understanding of what these big cuts are gonna look like and where the real, you know, what the real conversation's gonna have.

1667
02:59:41.387 --> 02:59:44.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then lastly, I will say that with regard to thank you.

1668
02:59:44.709 --> 02:59:44.829
<v Luciani>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1669
02:59:44.829 --> 02:59:44.829
<v Luciani>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

1670
02:59:44.829 --> 02:59:46.129
<v Luciani>I just wanted to say a couple of things about outreach.

1671
02:59:46.129 --> 02:59:50.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't think anybody felt great about how outreach happened on the budget.

1672
02:59:50.889 --> 03:00:01.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will flag, though, an example of, I think, a good collaboration between the legislative and executive was the quick work to set up listening sessions around the Moda Center.

1673
03:00:01.190 --> 03:00:21.609
<v Jamie Dunphy>They weren't perfect, and obviously we wish we could have had more time to advertise them and get word out there, but I really appreciated the way that the city administrators Office and the city bureaucracy broadly worked collaboratively to try and get those stood up, centering the city council in a lot of the ways.

1674
03:00:24.913 --> 03:00:28.021
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I also want to give kudos to Director Oppenheimer for the work that she did on that.

1675
03:00:28.069 --> 03:00:29.036
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was on a short timeline.

1676
03:00:29.100 --> 03:00:46.157
<v Jamie Dunphy>So broadly, those are my sort of thoughts is I think that there's more we can do upfront to educate, more to give early input to the, to the, uh, mayor on where to take cuts and what, what, uh, trade-offs might look like.

1677
03:00:46.657 --> 03:00:50.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think that there's some opportunity to be creative around our, our outreach.

1678
03:00:50.690 --> 03:00:51.801
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that's all my thoughts.

1679
03:00:52.673 --> 03:00:53.932
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, colleagues.

1680
03:00:54.110 --> 03:00:58.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, with your permission, I'm going to close the queue if there's no objections.

1681
03:00:59.810 --> 03:01:11.426
<v Steve Novick>Okay, we'll go Councilor Novick, then Green, then Ryan, then Pirtle-Guiney, and I'll I just wanted to say I thoroughly applaud the council president's vision for early briefings on just what the budget is.

1682
03:01:12.559 --> 03:01:17.809
<v Steve Novick>I think that we all need to start off knowing, you know, okay, here's the police budget.

1683
03:01:17.906 --> 03:01:18.825
<v Steve Novick>How much is personnel?

1684
03:01:18.938 --> 03:01:19.727
<v Steve Novick>How much is training?

1685
03:01:19.823 --> 03:01:22.352
<v Steve Novick>How much is external, other external materials and services?

1686
03:01:22.802 --> 03:01:23.834
<v Steve Novick>Here's the parks budget.

1687
03:01:23.947 --> 03:01:26.831
<v Steve Novick>How much goes to maintaining the outdoor parks?

1688
03:01:26.912 --> 03:01:30.199
<v Steve Novick>How much goes to the community centers?

1689
03:01:30.492 --> 03:01:37.316
<v Steve Novick>Actually, we did that in the climate committee 2 years ago, and I think at least we had a pretty good idea of the parks budget.

1690
03:01:37.718 --> 03:01:42.566
<v Steve Novick>And also, I think it's just important to the extent the public is watching, for the public to know, here is what the city does.

1691
03:01:42.614 --> 03:01:48.893
<v Steve Novick>We do police, fire, a couple other public safety things, and parks, and then we do water and sewer.

1692
03:01:49.503 --> 03:01:52.554
<v Steve Novick>And within those, there's sort of limited categories of things you can mess with.

1693
03:01:52.986 --> 03:02:05.097
<v Steve Novick>So I thoroughly agree, we need to sort of instead of talking about what we're going to cut in the context of the mayor's budget, we need to have a— really have a thorough understanding, hopefully have the public have a thorough understanding of what we do now.

1694
03:02:05.418 --> 03:02:07.475
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1695
03:02:07.652 --> 03:02:10.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Quick housekeeping note, we have permission to go a couple minutes over.

1696
03:02:10.864 --> 03:02:14.816
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously, I know not everyone can, but I'll go to Councilor Green followed by Ryan.

1697
03:02:16.430 --> 03:02:23.627
<v Mitch Green>In the interest of brevity, I'm just going to say plus one to the, um, early I agree with the comments from Councilor Dunphy.

1698
03:02:25.023 --> 03:02:26.917
<v Mitch Green>Early base budget conversations, good.

1699
03:02:27.031 --> 03:02:28.668
<v Mitch Green>Let's have them.

1700
03:02:29.182 --> 03:02:43.296
<v Mitch Green>I also think, you know, we're gonna at some point soon hear from the CFO on this financial stabilization workgroup work, which will have some concepts I think will help us think about how to adjust this over time.

1701
03:02:43.713 --> 03:02:48.257
<v Mitch Green>I support reviving the advisory, The budget advisory groups.

1702
03:02:48.722 --> 03:02:50.457
<v Mitch Green>I think, you know, look to Multnomah.

1703
03:02:50.554 --> 03:02:54.841
<v Mitch Green>I'm very interested to seeing what we can draw from Multnomah County there.

1704
03:02:55.595 --> 03:02:59.882
<v Mitch Green>I think part of the reason why we get stuck is we are waiting for this 5-year forecast.

1705
03:03:00.493 --> 03:03:09.676
<v Mitch Green>And it's always nice to have the most recent data, but I think you can— that's just an arbitrary stop in time with a forecast with some uncertainty.

1706
03:03:09.790 --> 03:03:18.542
<v Mitch Green>So we can always just sort of say, based upon what we know now, What can we envision for the next year, 2 years, 3 years to give us a grounding in our priorities?

1707
03:03:18.753 --> 03:03:20.949
<v Mitch Green>And I think we want to do priority-based budgeting.

1708
03:03:20.997 --> 03:03:21.239
<v Mitch Green>I do.

1709
03:03:21.304 --> 03:03:22.742
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'll leave it there.

1710
03:03:24.448 --> 03:03:25.139
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1711
03:03:25.188 --> 03:03:26.314
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan, then Pirtle-Guiney.

1712
03:03:26.620 --> 03:03:30.254
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, Councilor Knoll, I, I will be very brief and I'll have to go right after this.

1713
03:03:30.415 --> 03:03:34.873
<v Dan Ryan>I'm disappointed we didn't have more time for this item, so I'm requesting that we bring it to the next meeting.

1714
03:03:34.923 --> 03:03:42.561
<v Dan Ryan>When we bring it back, let's have the CFO here and let's Have that conversation so it'd be more interactive and fruitful.

1715
03:03:43.611 --> 03:03:44.676
<v Dan Ryan>I want to thank you, Terry Harris.

1716
03:03:44.740 --> 03:03:45.935
<v Dan Ryan>That was great testimony.

1717
03:03:46.049 --> 03:03:48.709
<v Dan Ryan>I agree, I've missed the feedback.

1718
03:03:48.853 --> 03:03:57.890
<v Dan Ryan>I know when I was a commissioner, it was really helpful to listen to the BDS Advisory Committee on the budget, and that's how you would go through the process, and it really helped a lot.

1719
03:03:59.590 --> 03:04:05.268
<v Dan Ryan>I'll just say that I continue to think we have challenges understanding where the revenue comes from.

1720
03:04:05.856 --> 03:04:12.105
<v Dan Ryan>And the general fund is built mostly on business license taxes and also on property taxes.

1721
03:04:12.201 --> 03:04:15.833
<v Dan Ryan>I've really experienced that in the conversations we're having around MOTA.

1722
03:04:15.913 --> 03:04:23.463
<v Dan Ryan>There's a macroeconomic 101 equation that I think we're struggling with, and we need more clarity on that for us to all accept that and understand it.

1723
03:04:23.945 --> 03:04:30.789
<v Dan Ryan>And then we also need to have better dialogue about what our priorities are within the basic services that we oversee.

1724
03:04:31.174 --> 03:04:36.786
<v Dan Ryan>And this council's had a hard time, I think, Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1725
03:04:38.995 --> 03:04:40.978
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, and then I'll close out.

1726
03:04:42.370 --> 03:04:42.779
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1727
03:04:44.370 --> 03:04:55.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Without going into everything, I just want to say I also appreciate President Dunphy's vision around earlier conversations and especially around having a forecast hearing.

1728
03:04:55.156 --> 03:04:58.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's really important for us to start doing in this body.

1729
03:04:59.754 --> 03:05:13.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To the question of some sort of broader public input, I think we need to make sure that we are finding opportunities both for education and feedback about the budget.

1730
03:05:13.299 --> 03:05:25.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are some incredible tools that are used elsewhere to give people the opportunity to actually move the levers to say, what would you cut and what would you keep given the situation that we are in, in the budget.

1731
03:05:26.047 --> 03:05:35.864
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think we could have our team find something or create something like that, maybe not for next year, but in the long run that really helps with the education and feedback piece.

1732
03:05:36.715 --> 03:05:48.890
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then we need to think about the oversight piece and are the proposals that are being developed taking into account all of the different pieces that they should and who should be involved in that.

1733
03:05:49.066 --> 03:06:02.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think in the past we have tried to And we need to have the opportunities in district, which I think we actually did very well this past year.

1734
03:06:03.168 --> 03:06:05.627
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not well enough, I'm sure, but very well.

1735
03:06:06.540 --> 03:06:15.977
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to have the groups that are engaged in the city have an opportunity to say you missed something here in that oversight capacity.

1736
03:06:16.585 --> 03:06:24.472
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we need the feedback and education that can be done on somebody's own time where they're really looking at what would they do and what trade-offs would they make.

1737
03:06:24.537 --> 03:06:34.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I hope we can figure out a system that has all 3 and not just box ourselves into saying we did it this way in the past, of course we need to get back there, otherwise it's not transparent.

1738
03:06:34.540 --> 03:06:36.656
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1739
03:06:36.799 --> 03:06:48.093
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to note for those who are following along that we do still have 7 people here, which is quorum, because we have someone online even though you see 6 So I'll just take my minute and a half here and then wrap up.

1740
03:06:48.415 --> 03:06:57.872
<v Sameer Kanal>For me, there's an L-shape here from mayor's budget guidance to city administrator report or whatever sustains that bureau budget requests that are my most interests for the council to weigh in on.

1741
03:06:58.306 --> 03:07:00.120
<v Sameer Kanal>I love the idea of base budget briefings.

1742
03:07:00.458 --> 03:07:03.075
<v Sameer Kanal>Don't feel I need to do anything different on the general fund forecast.

1743
03:07:03.122 --> 03:07:04.135
<v Sameer Kanal>So I agree with Councilor Green.

1744
03:07:04.888 --> 03:07:07.763
<v Sameer Kanal>Mayor's proposal, I think we have to talk about what that looks like.

1745
03:07:07.811 --> 03:07:07.907
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1746
03:07:08.742 --> 03:07:13.356
<v Sameer Kanal>With relation to the community engagement, I staff budget advisory committees in the public safety space.

1747
03:07:13.452 --> 03:07:17.890
<v Sameer Kanal>I think I put up a proposal for how year-round would work.

1748
03:07:17.956 --> 03:07:19.093
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree completely with that.

1749
03:07:19.220 --> 03:07:25.213
<v Sameer Kanal>And I agree as well with generally the GTAC recommendation around service areas and things like that.

1750
03:07:26.672 --> 03:07:34.315
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that this needs to be separated from the broader ABC project because that has taken longer, not for anyone's fault.

1751
03:07:34.379 --> 03:07:35.612
<v Sameer Kanal>We've had leadership change there.

1752
03:07:36.302 --> 03:07:45.808
<v Sameer Kanal>At the top, which has been, I think, generally a positive thing, but has also— and I'm the council's designee to the ABC project, and we haven't had any motion on it in a while.

1753
03:07:46.273 --> 03:07:51.202
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think it makes sense to separate these out into 2 kind of processes, and I have interest in that.

1754
03:07:51.717 --> 03:07:55.184
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the third thing, I think council should be giving budget guidance to the bureaus.

1755
03:07:55.248 --> 03:07:56.742
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think it should be the mayor alone.

1756
03:07:57.319 --> 03:07:59.199
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to get this on the record.

1757
03:07:59.246 --> 03:08:05.283
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it'd be great if we said, look, if the general fund forecast Or whatever indicator we have is that it's going down by 3%.

1758
03:08:05.989 --> 03:08:08.270
<v Sameer Kanal>That should be a scenario that the Bureau has to give.

1759
03:08:08.799 --> 03:08:14.114
<v Sameer Kanal>A zero base, it's what it was last year with inflation, should be another scenario.

1760
03:08:14.435 --> 03:08:16.811
<v Sameer Kanal>And then at least one in the opposite direction.

1761
03:08:16.861 --> 03:08:18.337
<v Sameer Kanal>So you have an up, down, and a hold.

1762
03:08:18.852 --> 03:08:24.872
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think it's fine if the mayor would like to have a more aggressive cut if it's a bad year or aggressive increase to help inform that.

1763
03:08:25.193 --> 03:08:35.478
<v Sameer Kanal>But giving these scenarios, I think for us, what we struggled with was we have no idea this year what bureau directors would've liked to add because all we gave them was a cut scenario.

1764
03:08:35.863 --> 03:08:43.290
<v Sameer Kanal>And even in good years, we should always be looking at cutting if we can to be fiscally responsible, if there's a place to do that.

1765
03:08:43.789 --> 03:08:46.307
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's also helpful for us to understand the bureau's priorities.

1766
03:08:46.370 --> 03:08:52.387
<v Sameer Kanal>If a bureau has 40 things that they do and they say they'll cut this one thing, they rank it 40th in their priority.

1767
03:08:53.333 --> 03:08:54.055
<v Sameer Kanal>Budgets are very hard.

1768
03:08:54.231 --> 03:08:55.578
<v Sameer Kanal>A priority-based document.

1769
03:08:55.899 --> 03:08:59.010
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think it's always helpful to ask that question to get that information.

1770
03:08:59.827 --> 03:09:01.849
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with Councilor Ryan about the revenue piece.

1771
03:09:01.929 --> 03:09:04.832
<v Sameer Kanal>I also agree with him that we should have this conversation come back again.

1772
03:09:04.896 --> 03:09:12.720
<v Sameer Kanal>So my way of closing this out is to say we wanted to have at least a little time for council before the administration came in and tried to tell us what their recommendation is.

1773
03:09:13.154 --> 03:09:14.501
<v Sameer Kanal>That's why this happened today.

1774
03:09:15.078 --> 03:09:20.611
<v Sameer Kanal>On September 3rd, 10th, and I believe 16th, we have CFO Beery here for various different items.

1775
03:09:20.658 --> 03:09:20.754
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1776
03:09:20.868 --> 03:09:23.141
<v Sameer Kanal>So we'll of course make sure that he's there for that.

1777
03:09:23.254 --> 03:09:26.771
<v Sameer Kanal>And for the budget-specific ones, we'll also have Budget Director Levine, of course.

1778
03:09:27.287 --> 03:09:29.577
<v Sameer Kanal>And I note that they're listening, and I think in the back there.

1779
03:09:29.641 --> 03:09:30.657
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you so much.

1780
03:09:31.920 --> 03:09:34.952
<v Sameer Kanal>With that, I'm going to close out this meeting.

1781
03:09:36.435 --> 03:09:42.106
<v Sameer Kanal>The next meeting of the Committee of the Whole, the Portland City Council, is Thursday, September 3rd at 9:30 AM.

1782
03:09:42.620 --> 03:09:46.376
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks everybody for sticking with us, for going through some heavy presentations, and for being a part of it.

1783
03:09:46.617 --> 03:09:47.474
<v Sameer Kanal>This meeting is adjourned.

