WEBVTT

1
00:06:08.949 --> 00:06:10.790
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, uh, good morning everyone.

2
00:06:11.209 --> 00:06:17.040
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I'm going to call the, um, meeting of the Public Works Committee to order.

3
00:06:17.120 --> 00:06:21.569
<v Olivia Clark>It is Tuesday, August the 11th at 9:33 AM.

4
00:06:21.827 --> 00:06:22.701
<v Mitch Green>No problem.

5
00:06:23.009 --> 00:06:24.886
<v Olivia Clark>Diana, will you please call the roll?

6
00:06:25.699 --> 00:06:26.185
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning.

7
00:06:26.689 --> 00:06:27.321
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

8
00:06:28.634 --> 00:06:30.062
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Hi, I am here.

9
00:06:30.175 --> 00:06:32.024
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I apologize that I can't be in person.

10
00:06:32.365 --> 00:06:46.370
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am kind of embarrassingly I'm nursing my leg because I got an injury at the Brentwood-Darlington Potato Sack Race, which reminds me that an age-friendly Portland is really important because we are all aging.

11
00:06:47.115 --> 00:06:47.697
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I am here.

12
00:06:49.214 --> 00:06:49.586
<v Olivia Clark>Green.

13
00:06:51.382 --> 00:06:54.910
<v Mitch Green>I also hurt my knee just bending over the other day, so I'm here.

14
00:06:55.281 --> 00:06:55.557
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

15
00:06:56.091 --> 00:06:56.463
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

16
00:06:57.788 --> 00:06:58.016
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

17
00:07:01.557 --> 00:07:03.129
<v Sameer Kanal>Dodgeball strengthens the joints.

18
00:07:03.259 --> 00:07:04.704
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here.

19
00:07:05.651 --> 00:07:06.694
<v Olivia Clark>Here, and I'm in great shape.

20
00:07:07.079 --> 00:07:11.495
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, uh, we, uh, let's see.

21
00:07:11.656 --> 00:07:14.401
<v Olivia Clark>Claire, can you please read the statement of conduct?

22
00:07:14.963 --> 00:07:15.365
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair.

23
00:07:15.927 --> 00:07:18.062
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning and welcome to the meeting of the Public Works Committee.

24
00:07:18.255 --> 00:07:25.401
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at portland.gov/council/agenda.

25
00:07:25.947 --> 00:07:28.148
<v Unidentified speaker>Public Works Committee or by calling 311.

26
00:07:28.774 --> 00:07:31.793
<v Unidentified speaker>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

27
00:07:32.228 --> 00:07:35.184
<v Unidentified speaker>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

28
00:07:35.697 --> 00:07:40.709
<v Nancy Thorington>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

29
00:07:41.144 --> 00:07:43.007
<v Nancy Thorington>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

30
00:07:43.634 --> 00:07:44.661
<v Nancy Thorington>Chair preserves order.

31
00:07:44.999 --> 00:07:52.822
<v Nancy Thorington>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

32
00:07:53.528 --> 00:07:55.535
<v Nancy Thorington>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

33
00:07:56.064 --> 00:07:58.119
<v Nancy Thorington>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

34
00:07:58.728 --> 00:08:01.745
<v Nancy Thorington>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

35
00:08:02.420 --> 00:08:05.276
<v Nancy Thorington>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

36
00:08:06.110 --> 00:08:07.925
<v Nancy Thorington>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

37
00:08:08.100 --> 00:08:09.898
<v Nancy Thorington>When testifying, please state your name for the record.

38
00:08:10.363 --> 00:08:12.658
<v Nancy Thorington>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

39
00:08:13.252 --> 00:08:16.398
<v Unidentified speaker>And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

40
00:08:16.607 --> 00:08:16.927
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

41
00:08:17.569 --> 00:08:18.163
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Claire.

42
00:08:18.870 --> 00:08:21.228
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, uh, we have a very full agenda today.

43
00:08:21.774 --> 00:08:22.769
<v Olivia Clark>We have 4 items.

44
00:08:22.961 --> 00:08:24.276
<v Olivia Clark>Most of which we've asked for.

45
00:08:25.367 --> 00:08:31.817
<v Olivia Clark>The first one is a continuation of the PBOT bus bench advertising ordinance that we're hoping to move out today.

46
00:08:32.971 --> 00:08:34.879
<v Olivia Clark>We'll get into that in more depth.

47
00:08:35.394 --> 00:08:43.142
<v Olivia Clark>Then we have an update that we've asked for on the Bull Run filtration plant and really fulfilling our oversight responsibility.

48
00:08:44.039 --> 00:08:54.115
<v Olivia Clark>Then we're going to have a presentation on Vision Zero where we really asked to dig in to learn more about what really works and what doesn't.

49
00:08:54.600 --> 00:08:59.193
<v Olivia Clark>And finally, we'll get a very brief update on the redevelopment work at the Waterfront Park.

50
00:08:59.291 --> 00:08:59.938
<v Olivia Clark>We asked for that.

51
00:09:00.732 --> 00:09:04.735
<v Olivia Clark>So let's see, Diana, can you please call the first item?

52
00:09:06.220 --> 00:09:18.727
<v Unidentified speaker>Item number 1, document number 2026-212, amend Advertising on Bus Benches Code to allow advertising on city streetcar benches and shelters.

53
00:09:19.244 --> 00:09:23.342
<v Olivia Clark>Amend City Code Chapter 10, 17.45.

54
00:09:24.416 --> 00:09:25.216
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Diana.

55
00:09:25.682 --> 00:09:30.297
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, colleagues, this is a continuation of an ordinance that we heard way back in June.

56
00:09:30.664 --> 00:09:31.802
<v Olivia Clark>I think June the 23rd.

57
00:09:31.866 --> 00:09:32.731
<v Olivia Clark>Seems so long ago.

58
00:09:33.613 --> 00:09:44.365
<v Olivia Clark>And, uh, as Diana said, it, uh, amends, um, the code to allow the city to advertise on bus benches and bus shelters owned and operated and maintained by the city, um, for the Portland Streetcar.

59
00:09:45.070 --> 00:09:53.076
<v Olivia Clark>So as you recall, back in June we had quite a few questions about advertising generally, questions from the committee.

60
00:09:53.671 --> 00:09:55.936
<v Olivia Clark>And we received a memo from PBOT.

61
00:09:56.000 --> 00:10:00.144
<v Olivia Clark>I thought it was excellent, a great dive into answering all those questions.

62
00:10:00.722 --> 00:10:05.477
<v Olivia Clark>And I know the memo has been posted to the committee webpage for public reference.

63
00:10:06.216 --> 00:10:09.349
<v Olivia Clark>So with us today, I'll let you all introduce yourself.

64
00:10:09.397 --> 00:10:21.561
<v Olivia Clark>I'm not sure who's going to kick it off, but I think you're going to give us a little bit of a reset just to remind us what we're talking about since it's It's been almost 2 months, and then we'll, we'll see if there are any more questions about the memo.

65
00:10:22.062 --> 00:10:22.402
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

66
00:10:22.450 --> 00:10:23.567
<v Olivia Clark>Who's going to kick it off for us?

67
00:10:24.437 --> 00:10:25.152
<v Caitlin Reff>That sounds good.

68
00:10:25.476 --> 00:10:25.947
<v Nancy Thorington>That would be me.

69
00:10:26.125 --> 00:10:28.365
<v Caitlin Reff>Thank you, councilors, and good morning.

70
00:10:28.479 --> 00:10:29.386
<v Caitlin Reff>My name is Caitlin Reff.

71
00:10:29.469 --> 00:10:30.442
<v Caitlin Reff>I'm with PBOT.

72
00:10:30.490 --> 00:10:32.482
<v Caitlin Reff>I manage our major projects in Transit Division.

73
00:10:34.211 --> 00:10:43.316
<v Caitlin Reff>And yes, as Councilor Clark mentioned, we are here for the code amendment to Chapter 17.45 related to the Portland Streetcar.

74
00:10:45.349 --> 00:10:49.308
<v Caitlin Reff>This code amendment, as mentioned, was continued from June 23rd.

75
00:10:49.677 --> 00:10:52.754
<v Caitlin Reff>The memo has been provided, and I'm joined here by the team.

76
00:10:52.802 --> 00:10:54.038
<v Caitlin Reff>We're happy to answer any questions.

77
00:10:54.101 --> 00:10:58.717
<v Caitlin Reff>I'm going to go over a few slides and then let each of them introduce themselves.

78
00:10:59.392 --> 00:11:09.778
<v Caitlin Reff>As a quick refresher and summary, the amendment is to allow the city to include Portland Streetcar benches and shelters in future advertising contracts.

79
00:11:10.440 --> 00:11:11.826
<v Caitlin Reff>It is a code cleanup.

80
00:11:12.389 --> 00:11:15.081
<v Caitlin Reff>It does not create a new program or change streetcar service.

81
00:11:16.899 --> 00:11:26.894
<v Caitlin Reff>The city owns Portland Streetcar and the related assets, and this update allows those city-owned assets to be included in future advertising opportunities.

82
00:11:28.919 --> 00:11:36.715
<v Caitlin Reff>The cleanup is needed now because it was— the city code was actually written before the Portland Streetcar system existed.

83
00:11:36.812 --> 00:11:36.926
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, okay.

84
00:11:38.544 --> 00:11:45.905
<v Caitlin Reff>So currently, our city code only authorizes TriMet for this type of transit bench and shelter advertising.

85
00:11:47.788 --> 00:11:58.681
<v Caitlin Reff>Also, the current streetcar and TriMet advertising contracts are ending, so now is the time to update the code and before the next contract is put in place.

86
00:12:01.899 --> 00:12:02.942
<v Olivia Clark>Actually, back to this one.

87
00:12:03.740 --> 00:12:10.355
<v Caitlin Reff>So just for clarity, the amendment is limited to city-owned Portland Streetcar benches and shelters.

88
00:12:10.852 --> 00:12:15.011
<v Caitlin Reff>It adds the city as an authorized entity for Portland Streetcar advertising.

89
00:12:15.669 --> 00:12:27.215
<v Caitlin Reff>It clarifies, I think that one, yeah, it clarifies that streetcar shelters are included and it also keeps TriMet's existing authority in place.

90
00:12:30.038 --> 00:12:40.522
<v Caitlin Reff>And as we started to discuss last June, we are pursuing a joint solicitation with TriMet for a future advertising contract for efficiencies.

91
00:12:40.859 --> 00:12:48.183
<v Caitlin Reff>And the joint RFP was issued with TriMet on June 12th, 2026, and closed just days ago.

92
00:12:48.905 --> 00:13:02.837
<v Caitlin Reff>So this is included in the RFP and is consistent with past TriMet advertising contracts, as well as the past streetcar vehicle wrap advertising contract that has been held by Portland Streetcar Inc., our nonprofit operating partner.

93
00:13:03.544 --> 00:13:13.365
<v Caitlin Reff>We are going to continue to utilize TriMet-adopted advertising policies and procedures to define any applicable restrictions on advertising content.

94
00:13:14.375 --> 00:13:19.110
<v Caitlin Reff>Ultimately, the city and TriMet will hold their own contracts with the successful bidder.

95
00:13:20.330 --> 00:13:22.224
<v Caitlin Reff>So that concludes our slides.

96
00:13:22.480 --> 00:13:27.519
<v Caitlin Reff>I could quickly let the team up here introduce themselves, and then we're happy to answer any questions.

97
00:13:27.951 --> 00:13:28.304
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

98
00:13:29.138 --> 00:13:29.715
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Caitlin.

99
00:13:30.902 --> 00:13:31.815
<v Mitch Green>I guess I'll start.

100
00:13:31.943 --> 00:13:33.674
<v Mitch Green>I'm Ken McGare from the City Attorney's Office.

101
00:13:33.947 --> 00:13:42.027
<v Mitch Green>I've been in contact with my counterpart at TriMet about the First Amendment Article 1, Section 8 kind of limitations on this.

102
00:13:42.075 --> 00:13:44.158
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm here to answer any questions that you might have.

103
00:13:45.408 --> 00:13:45.985
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi everybody.

104
00:13:46.129 --> 00:13:47.524
<v Rich Eisenhower>Rich Eisenhower with PBOT.

105
00:13:47.605 --> 00:13:51.403
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm with our Office of the Director of our Policy Resources and Partnerships team.

106
00:13:52.142 --> 00:13:52.365
<v Olivia Clark>Rich.

107
00:13:53.360 --> 00:14:05.580
<v Dan Bauer>Dan Bauer, Director of Portland Streetcar Inc. We are the nonprofit partner between the city and TriMet on assisting in management great.

108
00:14:05.580 --> 00:14:08.639
<v Olivia Clark>We appreciate your being here today in case there are any additional questions.

109
00:14:08.639 --> 00:14:17.639
<v Olivia Clark>I thought that your memo was pretty thorough and answered all the questions that we had, but just as a follow-up, I wanted to see if our members had any other questions.

110
00:14:17.639 --> 00:14:23.929
<v Olivia Clark>I know that TriMet in the past, many, many years ago when I was there, had all kinds of First Amendment issues on the buses.

111
00:14:24.320 --> 00:14:28.360
<v Olivia Clark>They were all wrestled to the ground and cared for, but I don't know if we have any other kinds of Councilor issues.

112
00:14:28.360 --> 00:14:28.440
<v Nancy Thorington>I don't think so.

113
00:14:30.351 --> 00:14:35.149
<v Olivia Clark>Kanal, you had quite a few of the questions were yours and I think they were all answered.

114
00:14:36.129 --> 00:14:37.879
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, yeah, I think they were too.

115
00:14:37.927 --> 00:14:38.970
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you for the memo.

116
00:14:39.177 --> 00:14:40.591
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate all the information.

117
00:14:41.024 --> 00:14:43.576
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to follow up just quickly on 2 of those.

118
00:14:43.751 --> 00:14:45.822
<v Sameer Kanal>One was a question, one's a comment.

119
00:14:46.176 --> 00:14:51.648
<v Sameer Kanal>Question was E about promoting other resources including 311 and immigration rights.

120
00:14:51.793 --> 00:14:57.715
<v Sameer Kanal>The response I think really covered the 311 piece, but doesn't explicitly say anything about immigration.

121
00:14:58.207 --> 00:15:01.990
<v Sameer Kanal>So I guess the question is, I think the example we were using was basically PERC.

122
00:15:02.330 --> 00:15:05.126
<v Sameer Kanal>Can we advertise the PERC hotline on there?

123
00:15:06.179 --> 00:15:11.883
<v Sameer Kanal>And in the event that that's a city priority or there's just a gap in advertising at a specific location, is that something that we can do?

124
00:15:13.232 --> 00:15:18.464
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to give the chance to put a finer point on it or be more explicit if that's something you can answer.

125
00:15:20.120 --> 00:15:20.544
<v Nancy Thorington>That's the answer.

126
00:15:24.206 --> 00:15:32.629
<v Dan Bauer>I just will say from my experience that the city owns these assets and you can place virtually whatever you want on there as the owner of the asset.

127
00:15:33.110 --> 00:15:37.121
<v Dan Bauer>Just today we're rolling out a new wrap that is designed by the city and by PSI.

128
00:15:37.715 --> 00:15:44.115
<v Dan Bauer>Some of our trains have really poor paint jobs on them, and so instead of just running them around like that, we designed our own wrap and it's advertising the streetcar system.

129
00:15:44.373 --> 00:15:45.928
<v Olivia Clark>Dan, do you want to explain what a wrap is?

130
00:15:46.138 --> 00:15:50.615
<v Dan Bauer>I'm sorry, the wrap is when you're wrapping the streetcar vehicle in its entirety with A vinyl wrap.

131
00:15:52.480 --> 00:15:53.979
<v Dan Bauer>So we have opportunities for that on the horizon.

132
00:15:54.027 --> 00:16:00.932
<v Dan Bauer>We have several new cars coming into the system that don't— they're branded from somebody else's system, or they're new cars, or they have cars with bad paint jobs.

133
00:16:01.109 --> 00:16:02.658
<v Dan Bauer>There are a lot of opportunities to do that.

134
00:16:03.143 --> 00:16:05.273
<v Dan Bauer>I will say this is a revenue-generating program.

135
00:16:05.321 --> 00:16:07.482
<v Dan Bauer>The reason we do this is to make money to run the streetcar.

136
00:16:07.741 --> 00:16:12.779
<v Dan Bauer>So if the city wants to make this choice to advertise city assets or city programs, that's fine.

137
00:16:12.844 --> 00:16:13.408
<v Dan Bauer>I think that's great.

138
00:16:14.442 --> 00:16:17.399
<v Dan Bauer>We just need to recognize that we're probably foregoing a little bit of revenue each time we do that.

139
00:16:18.158 --> 00:16:21.192
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, and I think that makes sense to weigh against.

140
00:16:21.288 --> 00:16:25.206
<v Sameer Kanal>But also if there, like I said, if there's a gap in advertising or something like that.

141
00:16:25.495 --> 00:16:26.250
<v Sameer Kanal>Which there often is.

142
00:16:26.538 --> 00:16:34.326
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I think I'm interpreting at least the first sentence where you said the city can do that in terms of the design of a wrap to mean the administrative side.

143
00:16:34.375 --> 00:16:42.869
<v Sameer Kanal>So I will direct this comment to the empty chairs to my right and say I would love it if that is something that was considered in those times.

144
00:16:45.385 --> 00:16:46.443
<v Sameer Kanal>But that's solid for me.

145
00:16:46.508 --> 00:16:47.629
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for answering that.

146
00:16:48.110 --> 00:17:17.142
<v Sameer Kanal>About D, which is the other question about when can things be excluded, I both appreciate this information and the initiative for the question ended up being mooted between June and now because a demonstrably, I think the quote you said is 2.2.1.1 DA, which says TriMet can exclude advertising if it is, quote, demonstrably false, misleading, deceptive, libelous, defamatory, or infringes upon protected intellectual property or privacy rights, end quote.

147
00:17:17.671 --> 00:17:21.886
<v Sameer Kanal>And this doesn't affect anything besides those first 3 of demonstrably false, misleading, and deceptive.

148
00:17:21.934 --> 00:17:32.482
<v Sameer Kanal>But the campaign that I was thinking about that might be an advertising campaign, uh, is now a moot point because, uh, the, the good voters of the city of Portland, um, did not, did not, uh, keep that going.

149
00:17:32.739 --> 00:17:40.787
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, I, uh, both from your memo and from, you know, events that occurred between June and now have, have, uh, made that not a concern.

150
00:17:40.851 --> 00:17:42.633
<v Sameer Kanal>But thank you so Thank you, Madam Chair.

151
00:17:42.778 --> 00:17:44.240
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

152
00:17:44.304 --> 00:17:52.675
<v Olivia Clark>I think that we can actually mention the first part of that to the mayor's office and to the mayor's staff that have a responsibility in that area, although she may have moved.

153
00:17:52.723 --> 00:17:56.130
<v Olivia Clark>But, um, yeah, I think that's a good issue to bring up there.

154
00:17:56.836 --> 00:17:57.448
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Green?

155
00:17:57.978 --> 00:18:01.336
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just want to say thanks for providing the memo.

156
00:18:01.883 --> 00:18:02.911
<v Mitch Green>Uh, it was comprehensive.

157
00:18:03.328 --> 00:18:04.759
<v Mitch Green>It cleared up all my questions.

158
00:18:05.096 --> 00:18:23.452
<v Mitch Green>Um, I think at this point I just I'd like to voice my support for the amendment and the ordinance here, but also make an appeal again to the empty chairs over there that we don't run advertisements that try to convince people to buy cars, even if they're electric cars.

159
00:18:23.565 --> 00:18:27.287
<v Mitch Green>I think that that's counterproductive to what we're trying to do.

160
00:18:27.335 --> 00:18:33.159
<v Mitch Green>And I understand at the end of the day, you're putting out bids for solicitation for people to pay for advertising.

161
00:18:34.074 --> 00:18:40.220
<v Mitch Green>But to the extent that we can use some discretion to think about what it does to the ridership, let's keep that top of mind.

162
00:18:40.798 --> 00:18:48.243
<v Mitch Green>I also think that, if I'm not mistaken, there's nothing to prohibit the city from purchasing ad space on these things.

163
00:18:48.676 --> 00:18:58.224
<v Mitch Green>And so one thing that comes to my mind is when I talk to my constituents about the Portland Clean Energy Fund, they like it, but they want to hear more about it.

164
00:18:58.320 --> 00:19:04.500
<v Mitch Green>They want to hear more about what we are doing with it and what What the opportunities are and how to engage in the amendment process itself as a community member.

165
00:19:04.579 --> 00:19:17.868
<v Mitch Green>And so, you know, if BPS wants to be in the business of purchasing some ad space on the Portland Streetcar system to talk about what PSF's doing in our community, I think that'd be a big win for Portlanders.

166
00:19:19.114 --> 00:19:26.901
<v Mitch Green>So just putting that on the record here, that I think it's also an opportunity for us to sort of sell our wins when we have them.

167
00:19:26.950 --> 00:19:27.306
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

168
00:19:27.936 --> 00:19:29.508
<v Mitch Green>And give folks some confidence.

169
00:19:30.583 --> 00:19:32.652
<v Dan Bauer>We did submit a grant for PSF funding.

170
00:19:32.700 --> 00:19:37.542
<v Dan Bauer>It was a little bit of a stretch, but it was to basically replace the advertising program with PSF-controlled messaging.

171
00:19:37.960 --> 00:19:38.152
<v Mitch Green>That's—.

172
00:19:38.376 --> 00:19:38.970
<v Dan Bauer>We're open to that.

173
00:19:39.018 --> 00:19:40.221
<v Mitch Green>So it sounds like you're already on it.

174
00:19:40.365 --> 00:19:43.155
<v Dan Bauer>It's— again, it's just a money thing, and we're not making that much money.

175
00:19:43.284 --> 00:19:45.817
<v Dan Bauer>So I, I think it's worth conversation.

176
00:19:46.219 --> 00:19:46.539
<v Unidentified speaker>I love it.

177
00:19:46.619 --> 00:19:46.875
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

178
00:19:47.340 --> 00:19:48.576
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, Councilor Green, that was prescient.

179
00:19:48.704 --> 00:19:49.410
<v Olivia Clark>That was very good.

180
00:19:49.618 --> 00:19:50.259
<v Olivia Clark>Yes, yes.

181
00:19:50.709 --> 00:19:51.398
<v Nancy Thorington>Thank you.

182
00:19:52.554 --> 00:19:53.259
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith.

183
00:19:54.317 --> 00:19:54.781
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

184
00:19:55.038 --> 00:19:56.512
<v Loretta Smith>Um, thank you all for the presentation.

185
00:19:56.642 --> 00:20:14.819
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I'm concerned when we start identifying which businesses can market on our public dollar when all of the citizens and residents in this city they pay taxes to, and to, um, marginalize and, and minimize certain industries.

186
00:20:15.492 --> 00:20:23.715
<v Loretta Smith>I think that that is not something that I am interested in doing, but I want to go and have a conversation with you, Councilor Green.

187
00:20:24.309 --> 00:20:32.243
<v Loretta Smith>Were you saying that that Is that what you wanted them to put in, that they couldn't advertise car companies, or is that somewhere in the language?

188
00:20:33.771 --> 00:20:39.986
<v Mitch Green>I was just putting my hope and dream here as just a person with some opinions, because there's nothing in here that says you can't.

189
00:20:40.391 --> 00:20:48.189
<v Mitch Green>I just think it'd be a big own goal if we were like, stop taking transit and start driving a car for the thing that we're trying to run here.

190
00:20:48.757 --> 00:20:55.840
<v Loretta Smith>Right, but I don't think that that is the messaging that we get from the streetcar, that it is just for folks who are only going to use transit.

191
00:20:56.820 --> 00:21:03.950
<v Loretta Smith>Again, I am going to say thank you for your comments, and I too have some too, because I have to represent all businesses.

192
00:21:04.046 --> 00:21:05.170
<v Loretta Smith>So what's next?

193
00:21:05.490 --> 00:21:13.711
<v Loretta Smith>If you start eliminating the car companies, what is next in terms of the private sector who actually pay the bills here?

194
00:21:14.867 --> 00:21:16.778
<v Loretta Smith>We don't really pay the bills here.

195
00:21:17.374 --> 00:21:22.115
<v Loretta Smith>We get business licensing tax money.

196
00:21:23.626 --> 00:21:26.026
<v Loretta Smith>We get property tax money from everybody.

197
00:21:26.527 --> 00:21:31.607
<v Loretta Smith>And those property tax monies from people in the city of Portland, they own businesses.

198
00:21:32.415 --> 00:21:39.006
<v Loretta Smith>And to eliminate their businesses wholesale— and I get what you're—.

199
00:21:39.247 --> 00:21:40.276
<v Dan Bauer>Which direction you're going.

200
00:21:40.387 --> 00:21:40.726
<v Dan Bauer>Let's clarify.

201
00:21:40.789 --> 00:21:41.455
<v Dan Bauer>That's not happening.

202
00:21:42.161 --> 00:21:46.060
<v Loretta Smith>No, I'm just saying because someone put on the record that that's what they wanted.

203
00:21:46.708 --> 00:21:46.819
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

204
00:21:46.915 --> 00:21:57.876
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm saying to you, when you think about this, do not marginalize your opportunity to only get PSF money so you can, so you can push PSF messaging.

205
00:21:58.388 --> 00:21:58.469
<v Dan Bauer>Yeah.

206
00:21:58.710 --> 00:22:00.601
<v Loretta Smith>I don't think that's cool, and I don't think it's right.

207
00:22:01.498 --> 00:22:17.194
<v Loretta Smith>I'm saying that the people in this city who pay the bills, the property tax owners and the business licensing tax people, if we try to eliminate one of them, Then we're gonna— what's gonna happen to the rest of the business community?

208
00:22:17.612 --> 00:22:25.578
<v Loretta Smith>So that will not fly with me if that's your intention on putting, adding some language to this, because it's not gonna fly with me.

209
00:22:26.702 --> 00:22:35.038
<v Loretta Smith>Because I'll bring in every single business chamber of commerce in here and they will fight that like nobody's business.

210
00:22:35.681 --> 00:22:38.717
<v Loretta Smith>And we can't, I mean, I'm sorry.

211
00:22:38.894 --> 00:22:39.247
<v Loretta Smith>Councilwoman.

212
00:22:39.849 --> 00:22:46.319
<v Loretta Smith>Madam Chair, but I'm not going to allow this kind of conversation without me speaking up.

213
00:22:46.319 --> 00:22:47.099
<v Loretta Smith>It's okay.

214
00:22:47.099 --> 00:22:47.490
<v Loretta Smith>And saying something about it.

215
00:22:47.720 --> 00:22:49.960
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate people expressing their opinions here.

216
00:22:49.960 --> 00:22:50.740
<v Olivia Clark>That's what we do.

217
00:22:50.740 --> 00:22:51.480
<v Loretta Smith>That's what we do.

218
00:22:51.480 --> 00:22:52.700
<v Loretta Smith>We have to get into the weeds.

219
00:22:52.859 --> 00:22:53.559
<v Olivia Clark>That's fine.

220
00:22:53.559 --> 00:22:54.500
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

221
00:22:54.500 --> 00:22:55.539
<v Olivia Clark>You bet.

222
00:22:55.539 --> 00:22:57.200
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Kanal, I think you want to—.

223
00:22:57.200 --> 00:22:57.619
<v Nancy Thorington>Yeah.

224
00:22:57.619 --> 00:22:59.180
<v Olivia Clark>Maybe, and maybe you're ready to make a motion.

225
00:22:59.579 --> 00:23:00.710
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I will at the end.

226
00:23:00.720 --> 00:23:02.559
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, 3 quick things and then I'll make the motion.

227
00:23:02.960 --> 00:23:04.900
<v Sameer Kanal>First, I agree with Councilor Green.

228
00:23:05.430 --> 00:23:05.541
<v Loretta Smith>I agree.

229
00:23:05.605 --> 00:23:06.070
<v Sameer Kanal>Completely.

230
00:23:07.065 --> 00:23:11.137
<v Sameer Kanal>PCF advertising, PCF is both cool and right.

231
00:23:11.250 --> 00:23:13.943
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm definitely supportive of that.

232
00:23:14.986 --> 00:23:22.073
<v Sameer Kanal>I would love to work with Councilor Smith on something because I agree that parts of the business community should not be excluded.

233
00:23:22.136 --> 00:23:26.306
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you go down, I read 2.2.1.1.da.

234
00:23:26.867 --> 00:23:33.249
<v Sameer Kanal>If you go down to Part F of that, 5 lines below, promotes the sale or use of any Schedule I controlled substance.

235
00:23:36.778 --> 00:23:38.971
<v Sameer Kanal>And marijuana is a Schedule I controlled substance.

236
00:23:39.050 --> 00:23:49.252
<v Sameer Kanal>So Green Muse cannot advertise, Nectar can't advertise, all these different folks, you know, Floyd's, whoever, they can't advertise right now with that text.

237
00:23:49.787 --> 00:23:53.160
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think they pay taxes and they should be allowed to advertise.

238
00:23:53.435 --> 00:23:55.858
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think we should talk about that together.

239
00:23:56.118 --> 00:23:57.306
<v Sameer Kanal>And I would love to work on that.

240
00:23:57.355 --> 00:23:58.703
<v Sameer Kanal>I know you've worked with many of those businesses.

241
00:23:58.752 --> 00:23:58.948
<v Dan Bauer>Thank you.

242
00:23:59.039 --> 00:24:02.234
<v Sameer Kanal>Businesses already, and probably some of my other colleagues have as well.

243
00:24:02.989 --> 00:24:14.646
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, yeah, so, uh, with that, I will move to refer this item on to the full council with a do pass recommendation and ask for a second.

244
00:24:15.112 --> 00:24:15.625
<v Loretta Smith>Terrific.

245
00:24:15.994 --> 00:24:16.299
<v Mitch Green>Second.

246
00:24:17.200 --> 00:24:18.644
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

247
00:24:18.724 --> 00:24:22.321
<v Olivia Clark>Motion to move by Councilor Kanal and seconded by Councilor Green.

248
00:24:22.433 --> 00:24:23.926
<v Olivia Clark>Is there any further discussion?

249
00:24:25.541 --> 00:24:25.721
<v Olivia Clark>Great.

250
00:24:25.853 --> 00:24:27.673
<v Olivia Clark>Will the clerk please call the roll?

251
00:24:30.869 --> 00:24:31.272
<v Olivia Clark>Koyama Lane?

252
00:24:32.500 --> 00:24:32.549
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

253
00:24:35.327 --> 00:24:35.376
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

254
00:24:36.152 --> 00:24:36.442
<v Council Clerk>Smith?

255
00:24:36.863 --> 00:24:36.912
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

256
00:24:37.605 --> 00:24:38.172
<v Council Clerk>Kanal?

257
00:24:38.558 --> 00:24:38.607
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

258
00:24:39.221 --> 00:24:39.384
<v Council Clerk>Clark?

259
00:24:39.771 --> 00:24:39.819
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

260
00:24:40.661 --> 00:24:49.883
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, with a vote of 5 ayes, the motion to refer the ordinance document number 2026-212 to the City Council with a recommendation it be passed has passed.

261
00:24:50.162 --> 00:24:51.461
<v Olivia Clark>Terrific.

262
00:24:51.766 --> 00:24:56.755
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you all for being here today, and thank you for all the work that you put in to answer all the questions that we had earlier.

263
00:24:56.818 --> 00:24:57.605
<v Olivia Clark>Really appreciate it.

264
00:24:58.663 --> 00:24:59.161
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

265
00:24:59.384 --> 00:25:03.732
<v Olivia Clark>And thanks to my colleagues for, um, really teasing this out a little bit.

266
00:25:04.742 --> 00:25:06.202
<v Olivia Clark>Um, let's see.

267
00:25:06.443 --> 00:25:08.497
<v Olivia Clark>Diana, can you please read the next item?

268
00:25:09.652 --> 00:25:16.871
<v Unidentified speaker>Item number 2, document number 2026-281, Bull Run Filtration Projects.

269
00:25:17.336 --> 00:25:21.698
<v Olivia Clark>Owner's representative and independent financial oversight panel update.

270
00:25:21.761 --> 00:25:24.296
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, uh, colleagues.

271
00:25:24.407 --> 00:25:29.731
<v Olivia Clark>We had a great tour, uh, of the facility, uh, under construction on Friday.

272
00:25:29.827 --> 00:25:32.249
<v Olivia Clark>It was a little hot, but we all learned a lot.

273
00:25:32.810 --> 00:25:38.086
<v Olivia Clark>Um, we— I think you learn so much more by being on site than just getting a presentation here in committee.

274
00:25:38.743 --> 00:25:42.593
<v Olivia Clark>We learned that there are 400 to 600 employees on site every day.

275
00:25:42.848 --> 00:25:43.747
<v Olivia Clark>That was remarkable.

276
00:25:44.308 --> 00:25:46.575
<v Olivia Clark>I think we're spending probably $1 million a day.

277
00:25:46.768 --> 00:25:47.651
<v Olivia Clark>I think I heard that.

278
00:25:48.213 --> 00:25:55.491
<v Olivia Clark>We also learned about how the sort of the land use restrictions have increased the cost of the project, but we understand that better now.

279
00:25:56.681 --> 00:26:10.113
<v Olivia Clark>So you're here today because we're exercising our oversight function, and we wanted to hear more about the owner's rep function and the independent financial oversight panel that you created.

280
00:26:10.161 --> 00:26:10.209
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

281
00:26:10.786 --> 00:26:19.199
<v Olivia Clark>And I would also add something that I talked to Director Liu on the bus was the hacking that's going on around the country.

282
00:26:19.295 --> 00:26:28.828
<v Olivia Clark>It's been in the news quite a bit, and I asked her to also address that today, what precautions we're taking so that our system is not hacked and damaged.

283
00:26:29.085 --> 00:26:33.251
<v Olivia Clark>So with that, turn over to DCA Danapal to kick it off.

284
00:26:33.957 --> 00:26:37.691
<v Nancy Thorington>Good morning, Chair Clark, Vice Chair Smith, and members of the Public Works Committee.

285
00:26:38.347 --> 00:26:48.376
<v Nancy Thorington>Uh, as Council Clerk mentioned, we have an important update on the largest and most consequential infrastructure investment the city is making, the Boulder Infiltration Project.

286
00:26:49.179 --> 00:26:54.730
<v Nancy Thorington>Um, and first of all, I want to thank the committee, uh, for joining us at the construction site last Friday.

287
00:26:55.355 --> 00:27:10.626
<v Nancy Thorington>Um, having you all take the time to see the project firsthand, walk the site, and hear directly from the people doing the work is incredibly valuable, and it gives a much better sense of the scale and complexity of what we are building, and I know the Water Bureau team appreciated the opportunity to share the work with you.

288
00:27:11.957 --> 00:27:17.744
<v Nancy Thorington>As many of you saw firsthand, this is no longer a project that exists primarily on paper.

289
00:27:18.162 --> 00:27:27.171
<v Nancy Thorington>Significant construction is already underway, and the scale and complexity of what the city is building is substantial, not just for the city but for our region as a whole.

290
00:27:27.763 --> 00:27:35.147
<v Nancy Thorington>And I have immense confidence in Director Lu and our Chief Engineer Muriel and the Water Bureau team that is leading this work.

291
00:27:35.790 --> 00:27:41.632
<v Nancy Thorington>They're managing an extraordinary complex project with a tremendous amount of work happening every day to keep construction moving.

292
00:27:42.295 --> 00:27:47.096
<v Nancy Thorington>They're trying to manage risk, control costs, and deliver the critical piece of drinking water infrastructure.

293
00:27:48.119 --> 00:27:52.347
<v Nancy Thorington>At the same time, the project is at an important point.

294
00:27:53.619 --> 00:28:06.385
<v Nancy Thorington>The current program estimate is at about $2.56 billion, and the project has experienced significant delays and cost increases, including impacts from associated with the land use permitting process.

295
00:28:07.854 --> 00:28:19.688
<v Nancy Thorington>Given the scale of this investment and its impact on ratepayers, it is also important that we have strong governance and accountability structures in place to support the team and give council confidence in how this project is being managed.

296
00:28:20.759 --> 00:28:26.794
<v Nancy Thorington>At the previous— at a previous Public Works Committee, we looked backwards to understand why the costs and timelines have changed.

297
00:28:27.259 --> 00:28:35.912
<v Nancy Thorington>And today we are focusing on looking, uh, how do we make sure the city is positioned to finish this project successfully, safely, and with as much cost certainty as possible?

298
00:28:36.509 --> 00:28:43.536
<v Nancy Thorington>And so we are focusing on 2 important pieces of that framework, which is the owner's representative and the independent financial oversight panel.

299
00:28:45.136 --> 00:28:49.682
<v Nancy Thorington>And with that, I will turn it over to the Water Bureau team for the update.

300
00:28:50.151 --> 00:28:50.473
<v Nancy Thorington>Thank you.

301
00:28:51.021 --> 00:28:52.804
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much, DC Downepaw.

302
00:28:52.949 --> 00:28:55.164
<v Ting Lu>Good morning, members of Public Works Committee.

303
00:28:55.260 --> 00:28:59.049
<v Ting Lu>For the record, my name is Ting Lu, Portland Public Utilities Director.

304
00:28:59.596 --> 00:29:10.210
<v Ting Lu>We are very pleased to present to you an update on the filtration project, focus on our progress, owners' representative, and establish of an independent financial oversight panel.

305
00:29:10.530 --> 00:29:11.349
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

306
00:29:20.651 --> 00:29:21.250
<v Ting Lu>Next slide.

307
00:29:21.315 --> 00:29:23.030
<v Ting Lu>This looks like it's a little slow.

308
00:29:23.160 --> 00:29:28.872
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, before we get started, we'll provide an update on the cybersecurity and the SCADA system.

309
00:29:29.632 --> 00:29:36.211
<v Ting Lu>As Councilor Clark mentioned, um, we'll get into the ride on the representative of financial oversight from there.

310
00:29:37.271 --> 00:29:38.366
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

311
00:29:39.929 --> 00:29:53.892
<v Ting Lu>And before I get started, I also want to express my sincere gratitude for this committee's guidance and support, and thank you so much for taking the time on the Friday afternoon, very hot weather, to visit our filtration construction site.

312
00:29:54.374 --> 00:29:58.080
<v Ting Lu>Your perspective and feedback are very valuable to our project.

313
00:29:58.465 --> 00:30:04.469
<v Ting Lu>As you saw last Friday, we have made great progress on site and it's accelerating very rapidly.

314
00:30:05.047 --> 00:30:14.338
<v Ting Lu>As of June 30th, 2026, the project is 37% complete and we are on track to deliver filtered water by September 29th.

315
00:30:16.856 --> 00:30:32.942
<v Ting Lu>During our tour, I also want to just recap about— we stopped at the finished water intertie site, where this is a new underground vault connects one incoming conduit and from the plant and to 3 outgoing conduit in our distribution system, providing finished water to town.

316
00:30:33.777 --> 00:30:51.303
<v Ting Lu>We also visited the complex filtration process, including multiple robust treatment trains designed to increase redundancy and efficiencies, as well as the 237-foot pipeline shaft where raw water is going to enter to the filtration facility.

317
00:30:52.361 --> 00:30:58.195
<v Ting Lu>And then with that, I'm going to share first about the cybersecurity and what the measures we're taking.

318
00:30:58.805 --> 00:31:02.556
<v Ting Lu>And I know this, many people's mind, that's the national alert.

319
00:31:03.277 --> 00:31:16.005
<v Ting Lu>So like many utilities for SCADA system, the supervisory control and data acquisition, this is called the SCADA system, as a core technology used to monitor and control our water infrastructure.

320
00:31:16.117 --> 00:31:16.631
<v Ting Lu>System.

321
00:31:17.080 --> 00:31:21.607
<v Ting Lu>And protecting this critical system is one of our highest priorities.

322
00:31:22.185 --> 00:31:39.185
<v Ting Lu>And we are using an integrated approach from continuous monitoring, advanced threat detection, as well as proactive risk mitigation to ensure that we are compliant and stay on top of the cybersecurity.

323
00:31:39.700 --> 00:31:53.798
<v Ting Lu>And we maintain a very close partnership with the City BTS as well as the US Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, CISA, and also FBI to remain aligned with the top industry security practices.

324
00:31:54.074 --> 00:31:57.002
<v Ting Lu>And our operators are fully trained with the system here.

325
00:31:59.839 --> 00:32:03.067
<v Ting Lu>With that, we'll move into the project governance and accountability.

326
00:32:03.583 --> 00:32:11.826
<v Ting Lu>Now, to see that we maintain a robust multiple layers of accountability, this slide shows the current layers of a project accountability.

327
00:32:11.909 --> 00:32:12.055
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

328
00:32:12.251 --> 00:32:26.895
<v Ting Lu>That has been shared with the committee and council members in the past, including conducting value engineering, establishing project delivery advisory team, as well as an independent claims analyst for the last few months.

329
00:32:27.265 --> 00:32:39.854
<v Ting Lu>We have also launched a new internal reporting framework in March 2026 to enhance transparency, which has provided professional project delivery expertise and transparency to the public.

330
00:32:40.271 --> 00:32:52.258
<v Ting Lu>As the committee directed, since April this year, we have been focusing on developing additional owners' representative function and continue to advance independent panel framework, which I will share in the next slide.

331
00:32:55.071 --> 00:33:16.832
<v Ting Lu>And this is going to be the enhanced project accountability framework with multiple layers, including the existing financial audits, bond and WIFIA reporting, city auditor's oversight, as well as a regular monthly pub briefings while we are transitioning from our project delivery advisory team to an independent financial oversight panel.

332
00:33:17.442 --> 00:33:29.655
<v Ting Lu>Following committee's direction from April 14th, we have moved forward, forward with establishing the owner's representative function, and Muriel will share more updates in the next slide.

333
00:33:30.201 --> 00:33:40.337
<v Ting Lu>In addition, I want to share with the committee that our project team is developing an expanded KPIs to track project performance, which will be coming this fall.

334
00:33:40.839 --> 00:33:48.201
<v Ting Lu>All of these measures are aiming at proactively managing project risk and ensure we remain on schedule and on budget.

335
00:33:51.413 --> 00:33:57.454
<v Ting Lu>With that, I will turn over to Muriel to provide an update on the project progress and owner's representative progress.

336
00:34:00.163 --> 00:34:01.262
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Thank you, Director Lu.

337
00:34:01.327 --> 00:34:02.984
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>For the record, my name is Muriel Geisa Teufel.

338
00:34:03.034 --> 00:34:04.656
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>I'm the chief engineer for the Water Bureau.

339
00:34:06.727 --> 00:34:11.356
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And, uh, before I start in the presentation, I also want to express gratitude for the visit.

340
00:34:11.403 --> 00:34:15.503
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>It's really appreciated by staff and the workers on site when people show up.

341
00:34:15.891 --> 00:34:18.172
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Um, it, it, it has a lot of weight.

342
00:34:18.398 --> 00:34:22.458
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Um, so thank you for that and spending the time on a very hot Friday.

343
00:34:24.086 --> 00:34:25.103
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Next slide, please.

344
00:34:26.588 --> 00:34:41.806
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So first, um, because costs are so important on this project and tracking, um, so at As of the end of June, we are now $881 million spent on the 2 remaining— well, on the total program.

345
00:34:42.271 --> 00:34:47.148
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And I'm going to bring a clarification here at the bottom for consistency.

346
00:34:47.742 --> 00:34:55.443
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Our total program budget is $2.58 billion, but that includes financing and indirect costs.

347
00:34:55.925 --> 00:34:58.394
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Moving forward, we're using the figure $2.

348
00:34:58.940 --> 00:35:05.750
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>$2.46 Billion because it's the 2 remaining open projects, which are filtration and pipelines.

349
00:35:06.152 --> 00:35:12.425
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So I apologize if there's been a little confusion between the numbers, but those are the numbers we're moving forward.

350
00:35:12.472 --> 00:35:17.686
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So on performance reporting, we're going to use the $2.46 billion.

351
00:35:18.467 --> 00:35:20.943
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So that clarifies that gap between some numbers.

352
00:35:22.659 --> 00:35:31.621
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So 881, one Huge progress is that last month we spent $54 million.

353
00:35:31.684 --> 00:35:36.501
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>That's the biggest productivity we've had on the project to date.

354
00:35:36.967 --> 00:35:46.938
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And it links to the efforts we've been putting in place as far as owner's rep, as far as closing out claims and restarting the project in earnest.

355
00:35:47.340 --> 00:35:55.898
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So that's really, you know, once you see the money being spent, That means we are in better chance to staying on schedule.

356
00:35:56.349 --> 00:35:58.025
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>That's a good leading indicator.

357
00:36:01.480 --> 00:36:02.302
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Next slide, please.

358
00:36:06.737 --> 00:36:18.485
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>In terms of other metrics or numbers that are proving the progress, and we will continue to improve our reporting, as Director Lew mentioned, but we do have a couple of numbers here.

359
00:36:18.534 --> 00:36:18.782
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Thank you.

360
00:36:19.275 --> 00:36:28.222
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>I will not read them all, but I will lead you to item 6, which is the shaft, which you have visited on site.

361
00:36:28.286 --> 00:36:29.315
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>You've seen the shaft.

362
00:36:29.876 --> 00:36:31.981
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>It's a massive project.

363
00:36:32.061 --> 00:36:38.373
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>It's a deep excavation to connect our raw water tunnels to the facility.

364
00:36:38.952 --> 00:36:43.786
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And we are now, in this report, as end of June, we were at 200 feet deep.

365
00:36:44.509 --> 00:36:49.282
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Last week, I believe we were at 205 feet deep out of the 270.

366
00:36:49.411 --> 00:36:53.106
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>237 Is when we're gonna reach the bottom of the shaft.

367
00:36:53.153 --> 00:36:58.327
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So we're really making good progress on construction, on high-risk items also.

368
00:37:00.099 --> 00:37:01.221
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Next slide, please.

369
00:37:03.032 --> 00:37:09.684
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>One more slide on the progress to date and some of the metrics we're tracking is the number of craft labor on site.

370
00:37:10.038 --> 00:37:13.110
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>That's also a really good indicator of work being done.

371
00:37:13.920 --> 00:37:18.552
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So craft labor are the people doing the work, active hands-on.

372
00:37:20.425 --> 00:37:27.072
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>DCA Donna Paul mentioned that we have about 400, 600 people on staff, or maybe you have mentioned this.

373
00:37:27.844 --> 00:37:32.440
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So last month we had 418 craft labor on site.

374
00:37:32.760 --> 00:37:43.148
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So you can see that trend line since March, which was after the restart, but also when we experienced this major subcontractor change that was on a critical path.

375
00:37:43.327 --> 00:37:52.364
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So we had a— the concrete contractor was let go, and that had a huge impact on the overall schedule, and we're still recovering from that.

376
00:37:53.246 --> 00:37:55.809
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>But you could see it with the labor increase.

377
00:37:56.193 --> 00:37:58.581
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We have brought back new contractors.

378
00:37:58.677 --> 00:38:03.548
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We're catching up to that delay, and you can see it with that labor.

379
00:38:04.606 --> 00:38:10.039
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So those are examples of KPIs we're tracking to see progress other than dollars.

380
00:38:10.135 --> 00:38:10.246
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

381
00:38:12.699 --> 00:38:13.554
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Next slide, please.

382
00:38:16.411 --> 00:38:26.885
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>As Director Lew mentioned, we, in April, I believe, we went to council and wondered about the owner's representative on the project.

383
00:38:27.485 --> 00:38:33.445
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>This is a mega project, and it's standard practice to implement owner's rep on these projects.

384
00:38:34.655 --> 00:38:40.380
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>It's typically for alternative delivery, which means an alternative to a low-bid approach.

385
00:38:40.862 --> 00:38:44.759
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So it's very standard, a standard approach.

386
00:38:45.577 --> 00:38:47.244
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Peer utilities use that model.

387
00:38:47.436 --> 00:38:53.467
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Industry practice has guidance documents on what to include, how to select, and how to move forward.

388
00:38:54.108 --> 00:39:04.324
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So we looked at different options because we realized we didn't entirely apply that model in place.

389
00:39:04.501 --> 00:39:06.489
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So we looked at different options at this time.

390
00:39:07.498 --> 00:39:18.628
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Since we were back then already at 30% construction, we looked at different options and we had sent you a technical memorandum that was looking at alternatives evaluated.

391
00:39:19.126 --> 00:39:24.257
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So, and it comes in different names, owner advisor or program management and support.

392
00:39:24.722 --> 00:39:32.324
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And they usually have a variety of service that keeps them independent from the engineer and independent from the construction manager, the construction—.

393
00:39:32.324 --> 00:39:32.548
<v Nancy Thorington>Supervisor.

394
00:39:32.853 --> 00:39:36.577
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Contractor and really as an extension of city staff.

395
00:39:36.625 --> 00:39:44.858
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So their goal is really to provide advice, to support the owner in delivering projects on schedule and on budget.

396
00:39:44.956 --> 00:39:54.585
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>But it's also intended to marry with the city's own resources and own skillset and supplement that model.

397
00:39:56.056 --> 00:39:58.271
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So the role evolves as the project progresses.

398
00:39:58.853 --> 00:40:20.088
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And especially now that we're in construction, it's going to be really— what we need is really heavy expertise in construction management, contract management, what we call commercial control, to evaluate claims or notice of change and the impact of change and the risks.

399
00:40:20.592 --> 00:40:27.079
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So it's got a very big focus on cost and schedule analysis and control.

400
00:40:30.005 --> 00:40:31.050
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Next slide, please.

401
00:40:40.369 --> 00:40:45.331
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So maybe this is a little bit repeating, but the cost control is a big factor.

402
00:40:45.556 --> 00:40:47.182
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>I believe it's a big factor for us here.

403
00:40:49.010 --> 00:40:53.918
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And there's many tools utilized for budgeting and earned value forecasting.

404
00:40:54.911 --> 00:40:56.130
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Scheduling management.

405
00:40:56.195 --> 00:41:01.693
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We do have some sophisticated tool with a synchro model that we use for pay application reviews.

406
00:41:02.768 --> 00:41:05.382
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And also risk management, trying to look ahead.

407
00:41:05.623 --> 00:41:18.737
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So a big part of the owner's rep role is to be looking ahead and forecasting the risks ahead of us to see how that compares with the remaining contingencies and how we can finish strong on time and on schedule.

408
00:41:18.818 --> 00:41:22.088
<v Olivia Clark>Muriel, do you mind if we interrupt you just for a second?

409
00:41:22.152 --> 00:41:26.172
<v Olivia Clark>I think Councilor Smith has a, question wants to dive in a little bit on the owner's rep.

410
00:41:26.494 --> 00:41:26.672
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

411
00:41:26.963 --> 00:41:27.882
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

412
00:41:28.335 --> 00:41:30.369
<v Loretta Smith>It was great to go on the tour last week too.

413
00:41:30.675 --> 00:41:31.320
<v Loretta Smith>I enjoyed it.

414
00:41:31.967 --> 00:41:37.172
<v Loretta Smith>But is it common to have an owner's rep who also is a subcontractor as well?

415
00:41:39.137 --> 00:41:44.394
<v Loretta Smith>Because our owner's rep has a contract and he's our owner's representative.

416
00:41:44.916 --> 00:41:46.942
<v Loretta Smith>And so is there— is that a conflict of interest?

417
00:41:49.802 --> 00:41:56.161
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>The owner's rep, so Brown and Caldwell is a separate consultant on a team.

418
00:41:56.226 --> 00:42:05.362
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>They have many subcontracts also to provide support, but they're not constructing and they're not engineering either.

419
00:42:05.682 --> 00:42:13.326
<v Loretta Smith>But even if they still have a contract on, they have contracts on the project.

420
00:42:15.144 --> 00:42:16.570
<v Loretta Smith>Who's going to check the checker?

421
00:42:18.835 --> 00:42:19.980
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We check the checker.

422
00:42:20.059 --> 00:42:23.088
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So the owner's rep reports to us and they have—.

423
00:42:23.088 --> 00:42:25.615
<v Loretta Smith>I know, but what I'm saying is you can't check the checker.

424
00:42:25.681 --> 00:42:31.510
<v Loretta Smith>That's why we have an owner's rep to check the checker because you all can't do it in a holistic way.

425
00:42:32.061 --> 00:42:53.538
<v Loretta Smith>And what I'm saying is there, I think there needs to be a line drawn between our owner's rep and you may feel comfortable about how that's working, but I just see that there is a, a little bit of a conflict of interest when they have several contracts and they're our owner's rep as well.

426
00:42:55.748 --> 00:42:59.846
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, I can also add additional context here, Councilor Smith.

427
00:43:00.023 --> 00:43:06.688
<v Ting Lu>So when we look at owner's representative, first we're looking really about the scope of work, what they are focusing on.

428
00:43:06.992 --> 00:43:11.293
<v Ting Lu>Which is the construction activities and construction inspections and change orders.

429
00:43:11.710 --> 00:43:17.230
<v Ting Lu>Those are the biggest items that we need to maintain and control for during this construction phase.

430
00:43:17.824 --> 00:43:20.648
<v Ting Lu>And then there's multiple ways we can look into that.

431
00:43:21.032 --> 00:43:27.981
<v Ting Lu>One is looking to completely a separate external consultant who haven't done any work on the filtration side.

432
00:43:28.398 --> 00:43:37.900
<v Ting Lu>The second is because the current— the consultant Brown Caldwell Wong has an existing scope of work as a project and program management.

433
00:43:38.300 --> 00:43:42.539
<v Ting Lu>So some of these roles is already being part of that scope of work.

434
00:43:43.003 --> 00:43:49.570
<v Ting Lu>And then the third option is we look at the piecemeal, looking to— we have the claim analyst, we have other ways to do things.

435
00:43:50.083 --> 00:43:57.996
<v Ting Lu>And based on the risk and also the schedule for the construction schedule and also where the project is.

436
00:43:58.365 --> 00:44:09.396
<v Ting Lu>So there is a memo we provided to the council members saying at this stage we recommend for the enhanced owner's rep activity, which is utilizing Brown Caldwell.

437
00:44:09.733 --> 00:44:13.105
<v Ting Lu>But we are holding them accountable for what they are going to do.

438
00:44:13.603 --> 00:44:17.505
<v Ting Lu>And this is where they are going to look into the construction activities.

439
00:44:18.001 --> 00:44:27.219
<v Ting Lu>And from the project standpoint, we are evaluating from a KPI standpoint, making sure they are effective in serving as an owner's rep role.

440
00:44:27.572 --> 00:44:31.635
<v Ting Lu>We worked this with the DC and also Cully at this approach.

441
00:44:32.068 --> 00:44:38.025
<v Ting Lu>And this is the least disruptive and the least risk from a delay in construction.

442
00:44:38.088 --> 00:44:46.646
<v Ting Lu>'Cause if you are bringing a new company for looking to the owner's rep, we're looking at least 3 to 6 months with getting the company on board.

443
00:44:46.840 --> 00:44:47.547
<v Loretta Smith>No, I like that.

444
00:44:47.643 --> 00:44:49.376
<v Loretta Smith>I like keeping that expertise.

445
00:44:49.489 --> 00:45:03.471
<v Loretta Smith>But I'm just saying from an outside look, We're paying a person twice to do the same thing if they're the program manager and they're the— and they are the, um, uh, owner's representative.

446
00:45:04.751 --> 00:45:06.925
<v Loretta Smith>It just— it, it's— it just seems weird to me.

447
00:45:07.021 --> 00:45:08.967
<v Loretta Smith>I've done these before at Multnomah County.

448
00:45:09.048 --> 00:45:15.454
<v Loretta Smith>We've never had an owner's rep that had contracts on our projects, on our bridge projects.

449
00:45:17.528 --> 00:45:25.420
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm just saying, it's it's— I don't know who's going to be watching Brown and what they're doing and who's going to check the checker.

450
00:45:25.996 --> 00:45:33.512
<v Loretta Smith>You said that you'll check the checker, but I don't know how well you can check the checker because you're getting the owner's rep to check the whole thing.

451
00:45:33.721 --> 00:45:36.139
<v Loretta Smith>So I, I, I'm just—.

452
00:45:37.134 --> 00:45:38.480
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith, let me ask you a question.

453
00:45:39.217 --> 00:45:47.394
<v Olivia Clark>Um, would it be helpful if we had— I don't think, um, Ken, um, McGare was— he was here earlier, but I think he's left.

454
00:45:47.476 --> 00:45:54.637
<v Olivia Clark>Would it be helpful to ask the attorney to get back to us on a conflict of interest or something around those lines?

455
00:45:54.717 --> 00:45:54.909
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

456
00:45:55.182 --> 00:45:55.856
<v Olivia Clark>Would that be helpful?

457
00:45:56.226 --> 00:45:56.981
<v Olivia Clark>We can do that.

458
00:45:57.045 --> 00:46:01.590
<v Olivia Clark>We can ask, um, the city attorney to just clarify this a little bit for us.

459
00:46:02.407 --> 00:46:17.806
<v Nancy Thorington>And Councilor Clark, if I may add, it might be also helpful to provide from a procurement standpoint what are the risks and benefits of using an existing contract not connected to construction activities as opposed to going through—.

460
00:46:18.143 --> 00:46:18.673
<v Loretta Smith>I like that.

461
00:46:18.865 --> 00:46:30.378
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, that's a plus in my book that helps me digest this a little bit better, that he doesn't have a construction contract, that it's a professional services contract.

462
00:46:30.940 --> 00:46:32.065
<v Loretta Smith>So I do.

463
00:46:32.193 --> 00:46:37.635
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just telling you that, you know, That, that is concerning.

464
00:46:37.827 --> 00:46:45.639
<v Olivia Clark>Well, I think you raise a legitimate concern, and we can, we can delve deeper into that maybe offline with the City Attorney's Office and maybe with procurement as well.

465
00:46:45.831 --> 00:46:45.927
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

466
00:46:46.248 --> 00:46:47.050
<v Olivia Clark>Would that be possible?

467
00:46:47.356 --> 00:46:47.628
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

468
00:46:47.869 --> 00:46:48.014
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

469
00:46:48.880 --> 00:46:51.061
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not trying to hold up anything or anything like that.

470
00:46:51.141 --> 00:46:55.713
<v Loretta Smith>Just know I'm— I, I, I just wanted to— No, it's legitimate.

471
00:46:55.793 --> 00:47:02.498
<v Loretta Smith>See if that was common, because I haven't known it to be common on any of the projects that I was on at Multnomah County.

472
00:47:03.333 --> 00:47:09.936
<v Loretta Smith>We did a couple bridge projects and we had a totally separate, uh, owner's rep.

473
00:47:10.722 --> 00:47:14.271
<v Olivia Clark>I think we also heard that this, this came in rather later in the process.

474
00:47:14.336 --> 00:47:15.990
<v Olivia Clark>We didn't have an owner's rep in the beginning.

475
00:47:16.666 --> 00:47:23.476
<v Olivia Clark>This is a switch that we made, um, a little late, and we didn't want to take the extra time is what I heard you say.

476
00:47:23.958 --> 00:47:25.773
<v Olivia Clark>So let me— we'll come back to this.

477
00:47:25.885 --> 00:47:29.463
<v Olivia Clark>I think, um, Councilor Koyama Lane may have a related Question.

478
00:47:29.561 --> 00:47:31.346
<v Olivia Clark>Is that right, Councilor?

479
00:47:32.077 --> 00:47:32.822
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I can wait.

480
00:47:33.682 --> 00:47:35.614
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I can, because I can wait till the presentation's done.

481
00:47:35.889 --> 00:47:36.052
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

482
00:47:36.280 --> 00:47:36.880
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you.

483
00:47:36.929 --> 00:47:38.047
<v Olivia Clark>Great, thank you so much.

484
00:47:39.443 --> 00:47:41.536
<v Olivia Clark>Sorry, Mariolda, let's proceed.

485
00:47:42.039 --> 00:47:42.688
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>No problem.

486
00:47:43.094 --> 00:47:45.268
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>I'd be happy to help with clarifications.

487
00:47:49.063 --> 00:47:57.125
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So the functions we've added here are cost control, so overall program cost control, schedule management, risk management, progress and then progress reporting.

488
00:47:57.221 --> 00:48:03.661
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And what we did really is adding expertise that was new to the project.

489
00:48:03.918 --> 00:48:10.215
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So within Brown and Caldwell, but new to the project that we hired them to provide these functions.

490
00:48:10.891 --> 00:48:23.628
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And the intent really is to improve predictability, identify issues and trends early, and support corrective actions, and just increase stakeholder confidence through transparency and transparent reporting.

491
00:48:24.141 --> 00:48:28.981
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And ultimately reduce surprises so that we can finish on time and on schedule.

492
00:48:30.233 --> 00:48:31.563
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Next slide, please.

493
00:48:32.717 --> 00:48:48.793
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Some of the positive trends we've already seen to date is we did finally, we reached agreement on the construction costs and schedule impacts that resulted from the land use-related delays.

494
00:48:50.043 --> 00:48:55.418
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We've added 198 days to the scheduled milestone for the filtration facility.

495
00:48:55.467 --> 00:48:59.931
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And what that really does is that it helps establish a new baseline that we can report on.

496
00:49:00.365 --> 00:49:03.320
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And that's when— how we can negotiate other change.

497
00:49:03.369 --> 00:49:06.132
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So that was a pretty big milestone to reach.

498
00:49:06.871 --> 00:49:13.681
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We've agreed to the cost of the suspension as well, both retrospective and prospective.

499
00:49:13.728 --> 00:49:26.715
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And again, this allows us to clean the slate and move forward with the remaining risks and negotiate them as they show up, but not with these other unresolved risks.

500
00:49:27.759 --> 00:49:32.396
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We've also made good progress on tunnel work.

501
00:49:32.494 --> 00:49:33.985
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So sometimes risks happen.

502
00:49:34.659 --> 00:49:45.074
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>In this case, we have significant tunneling activities where we had limited geotechnical data due to limited access or no access to the site.

503
00:49:45.396 --> 00:49:46.748
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Prior to construction.

504
00:49:47.505 --> 00:49:55.657
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>You can see a picture here of the boulders encountered during tunneling, and those had not been expected, and it impacted the productivity of the machines.

505
00:49:56.141 --> 00:50:18.380
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So working together on mitigating that risk, we essentially agreed to spend $3.5 million to mitigate a $15 million risk that would've been incurred if— had we not So this is an example of looking ahead and mitigating forward to minimize the risk to the city.

506
00:50:19.690 --> 00:50:24.030
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We also have good improvements on reducing backlogs.

507
00:50:24.079 --> 00:50:33.018
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Those are all activities and things that we had started seeing that were possibly a cause of delay.

508
00:50:34.407 --> 00:50:37.501
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And so notice of changes, unresolved items, and paperwork.

509
00:50:37.567 --> 00:50:38.505
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And I think that's a good thing.

510
00:50:39.213 --> 00:50:43.117
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>They do accumulate and they impact our ability to meet schedules.

511
00:50:43.166 --> 00:50:47.007
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So clearing those backlogs, there's significant improvement so far.

512
00:50:49.400 --> 00:50:50.400
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Next slide, please.

513
00:50:54.681 --> 00:51:04.480
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Those are other examples, and in the benefit of time, I will move shortly on these things, but we are working hard on forecasting risks.

514
00:51:04.577 --> 00:51:21.027
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So there's pretty significant effort in the schedule analysis to make sure that we can run scenarios to see how best to mitigate impacts of certain changes and how to stay within our overall schedule.

515
00:51:22.110 --> 00:51:29.045
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So that requires a lot of work of thinking ahead, but again, it's thinking ahead, looking ahead, not looking backwards.

516
00:51:31.829 --> 00:51:32.737
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Next slide, please.

517
00:51:36.009 --> 00:51:38.969
<v Ting Lu>Thank you, Muriel, and all the team members and partners.

518
00:51:39.081 --> 00:51:44.856
<v Ting Lu>So I will be continuing to provide an update on the Independent Financial Oversight Panel.

519
00:51:47.039 --> 00:51:48.494
<v Ting Lu>So next slide, please.

520
00:51:50.322 --> 00:51:54.994
<v Ting Lu>This slide shows the overview of the Independent Financial Oversight Panel.

521
00:51:55.398 --> 00:52:09.650
<v Ting Lu>So the purpose for this panel is to provide a truly independent physical oversight and public transparency as we continue to move forward with the construction progress towards the September 2029 water delivery mandate.

522
00:52:10.132 --> 00:52:17.726
<v Ting Lu>The scope of work for this panel will include reviewing existing documents, including project scope, contract, and pricing.

523
00:52:18.384 --> 00:52:34.617
<v Ting Lu>What we will be looking for the experts and feedback on assessment is regarding change management practices, monthly project updates, A risk mitigation practice, cost avoidance, and how can we proactively managing this project moving forward.

524
00:52:35.402 --> 00:52:39.777
<v Ting Lu>At the same time, we want to recognize and align with other governing bodies.

525
00:52:40.449 --> 00:52:47.900
<v Ting Lu>For instance, Portland Utility Board is a key role as part of the community-focused utility budget review.

526
00:52:48.380 --> 00:52:55.702
<v Ting Lu>We'll look for transitioning one or two PAB members from the Project Delivery Advisory Team, PDAT, to the panel.

527
00:52:56.152 --> 00:53:07.244
<v Ting Lu>Once the PDET concludes in October 2026, this will also ensure that institutional memory while we are beginning a fresh independent technical perspective.

528
00:53:09.599 --> 00:53:15.556
<v Ting Lu>This panel will report to the director with the findings shared directly to the PAB, city, and council members.

529
00:53:17.139 --> 00:53:17.969
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

530
00:53:19.672 --> 00:53:23.175
<v Ting Lu>So this is showing the recruitment timeline and the process.

531
00:53:23.793 --> 00:53:31.715
<v Ting Lu>We're looking for 5 volunteering members, including 1 to 2 members transitioning from the PUP board.

532
00:53:32.454 --> 00:53:36.615
<v Ting Lu>Recruitment will take place through August and September timeframe.

533
00:53:37.451 --> 00:53:56.777
<v Ting Lu>Given the technical complexity of the project and our focus on financial oversight, we're targeting professionals in public works finance, construction management, large capital project delivery to provide that rigorous review for the project cost and accounting documents.

534
00:53:58.190 --> 00:53:58.916
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

535
00:54:00.971 --> 00:54:06.097
<v Ting Lu>This shows additional details about desired qualifications and candidate profile.

536
00:54:06.695 --> 00:54:13.514
<v Ting Lu>We're proposing to target qualified peer volunteers who bridge the community perspective with the technical auditing.

537
00:54:14.271 --> 00:54:27.288
<v Ting Lu>Since this is a truly independent panel, The best way to identify qualified peer volunteers and ensure this is unbiased oversight is going to be volunteering perspective.

538
00:54:27.753 --> 00:54:32.722
<v Ting Lu>And panel members will disclose all relevant financial interests.

539
00:54:33.300 --> 00:54:41.284
<v Ting Lu>Members are prohibited from having current contracting relationship with the city or any contractors associated with the project.

540
00:54:42.164 --> 00:54:53.579
<v Ting Lu>Candidates we are looking for that will be regional peer volunteers in the public Pacific Northwest with hands-on mega project and the capital accounting experience.

541
00:54:53.981 --> 00:55:00.331
<v Ting Lu>They will bring that independent technical expertise without financial ties to the city or the water bureau.

542
00:55:03.039 --> 00:55:03.603
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

543
00:55:05.487 --> 00:55:21.146
<v Ting Lu>So this shows you our planned outreach and recruitment strategy, which will focus leveraging regional industry associations direct executive outreach and also trade media to attract qualified, non-conflicted candidates.

544
00:55:21.612 --> 00:55:56.592
<v Ting Lu>We're going to targeting utility leaders, project managers, financial construction professionals with deep expertise in mega project schedule risk, capital accounting, coordinating candidate selection closely with the city CFO's office well, to reach top talents, we're going to engage networks like Pacific Northwest AWWA and some of the water associations while also conducting direct outreach to non-conflicted executives from peer regional utilities.

545
00:55:57.733 --> 00:56:03.869
<v Ting Lu>And then we'll also having a dedicated landing page and application portal on the Bureau's public website.

546
00:56:04.398 --> 00:56:15.655
<v Ting Lu>There will be a formal process press release and as well as the public Rose City Connection e-newsletter to announce this recruitment.

547
00:56:16.297 --> 00:56:22.159
<v Ting Lu>So I'm looking for any additional feedback regarding this recruitment strategy.

548
00:56:23.427 --> 00:56:29.835
<v Ting Lu>The last slide is showing the recruitment timeline, implementation timeline.

549
00:56:30.108 --> 00:56:30.880
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

550
00:56:31.891 --> 00:56:46.342
<v Ting Lu>So we're planning to launch this recruitment in August 2026, followed by a candidate screening in mid-September, and having members transition in mid-October once the PDAT formally closes here.

551
00:56:47.094 --> 00:56:56.219
<v Ting Lu>Onboarding is planned to take place in October 2026, with the regular monthly cost and risk evaluations beginning in November.

552
00:56:56.572 --> 00:57:00.469
<v Ting Lu>So this will be annual work for— from November to September.

553
00:57:00.532 --> 00:57:00.644
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

554
00:57:01.045 --> 00:57:08.182
<v Ting Lu>And we'll provide the monthly update to the committee and council members, as well as upon the annual assessment.

555
00:57:08.295 --> 00:57:12.239
<v Ting Lu>And we'll look for what the committee and panel will look like for the next year.

556
00:57:13.715 --> 00:57:25.407
<v Ting Lu>With that, before we start the Q&A, we also have this area overview at the next slides, which captures the full scale of the current site activities.

557
00:57:25.518 --> 00:58:05.139
<v Ting Lu>And we would like to show you thank you so much.

558
00:58:06.519 --> 00:58:08.992
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, thank you very much for the presentation.

559
00:58:09.409 --> 00:58:12.282
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I know we have a lot of questions.

560
00:58:12.378 --> 00:58:18.318
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very impressed, um, by, uh, the degree that you've, um, zeroed in thank you.

561
00:58:18.367 --> 00:58:19.157
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Mayor.

562
00:58:19.302 --> 00:58:20.476
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney, for your presentation on oversight.

563
00:58:20.525 --> 00:58:24.278
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that, and I appreciate the update on the oversight panel.

564
00:58:24.342 --> 00:58:26.887
<v Olivia Clark>I know some of us may have some suggestions of names.

565
00:58:28.800 --> 00:58:40.608
<v Olivia Clark>For me, especially from having built light rail systems, there are some great people in this community that— nothing this big, but there's a lot of expertise out there.

566
00:58:40.672 --> 00:58:44.034
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know, I don't foresee how— you're not compensating these people.

567
00:58:44.135 --> 00:58:50.539
<v Olivia Clark>So is this something that in the industry people do between utilities for each other?

568
00:58:50.650 --> 00:58:51.646
<v Olivia Clark>Is that common?

569
00:58:52.577 --> 00:58:58.884
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, I mean, from an independent perspective, like a Blue Ribbon Panel or things, it's to maintain objectivity.

570
00:58:59.157 --> 00:59:06.876
<v Ting Lu>There is a— just a volunteering, it's the best way, um, from that unbiased perspective.

571
00:59:06.923 --> 00:59:07.228
<v Olivia Clark>That's good.

572
00:59:08.047 --> 00:59:10.614
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, uh, Councilor Koyama Lane, you have your hand up.

573
00:59:11.273 --> 00:59:12.413
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

574
00:59:13.103 --> 00:59:16.458
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, thanks for being here today for these presentations.

575
00:59:16.715 --> 00:59:20.648
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I like hearing about especially the independent financial oversight panel.

576
00:59:20.842 --> 00:59:24.132
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm wondering if that's a panel that council has to confirm.

577
00:59:25.561 --> 00:59:25.753
<v Ting Lu>Yes.

578
00:59:26.429 --> 00:59:57.463
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, we will be looking to the review and the screening initially, and before appointment, we'll provide council update on where we are and the, the names before and just to add to your outreach and recruitment strategy, I'm not sure how many people are qualified who subscribe to my newsletter or follow some of us on social media, but if you send out to all of the councilors a little blurb also, I'm happy to put that into my, um, my comms.

579
00:59:58.456 --> 01:00:05.019
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am wondering if it's okay with you, Chair, if I, um, if I'm wondering if this oversight panel.

580
01:00:05.581 --> 01:00:24.239
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciated Vice Chair Smith, some of her questioning, and would be interested in hearing from her now or later if this is a bit of when she was saying like who's going to be having another check on the project, if this kind of gives her any more sense of ease or—.

581
01:00:24.304 --> 01:00:24.545
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

582
01:00:25.251 --> 01:00:27.161
<v Olivia Clark>Let's have Councilor Smith respond.

583
01:00:27.418 --> 01:00:40.329
<v Loretta Smith>No, that is a common thing to have this This oversight that they're talking about, but we have to have a paid, experienced person who is our owner's rep. And they're not cheap.

584
01:00:40.746 --> 01:00:41.581
<v Loretta Smith>And I understand that.

585
01:00:41.932 --> 01:00:42.253
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Gotcha.

586
01:00:42.429 --> 01:00:52.452
<v Loretta Smith>But this is good to have this oversight committee, but I am talking about the paid guy, the guy at the end of the day who is responsible for watching our back.

587
01:00:53.157 --> 01:00:56.413
<v Loretta Smith>And that is what solely, that's their sole job.

588
01:00:57.648 --> 01:00:58.289
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, thank you.

589
01:00:58.610 --> 01:01:06.884
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know you've experienced more projects than me, and so thank you for breaking that down and appreciate your attention to that.

590
01:01:07.429 --> 01:01:28.704
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'll say I want to thank the Water Bureau, One Water, for working on how can we build accountability, public accountability, have it be public of public dollars, have that be built into this sorry, can you guys see me okay?

591
01:01:29.139 --> 01:01:30.186
<v Olivia Clark>Hear me?

592
01:01:30.847 --> 01:01:34.311
<v Olivia Clark>We can hear you.

593
01:01:34.619 --> 01:01:35.101
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

594
01:01:35.860 --> 01:01:36.842
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think it's really important.

595
01:01:38.081 --> 01:01:42.918
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We are hearing a lot about, you know, concerns about transparency, cost controls.

596
01:01:42.981 --> 01:01:45.456
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I appreciate that there is work in this area.

597
01:01:45.552 --> 01:01:57.896
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's thoughtfulness and just want to make it abundantly clear to the staff That, you know, members of the public really are hurting, and rising bills are a huge concern for many households.

598
01:01:58.442 --> 01:02:30.105
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so, you know, my expectation is that costs are managed, that the Water Bureau is actively working to think about strategies to not only manage costs but also to be reviewing rates and how they impact constituents, and that we're continuing to examine how we can be making Portland more affordable for and I'm wondering if, if you can speak a bit to how rate design connects to this or what that timeline is, if, if that relates at all.

599
01:02:30.201 --> 01:02:32.192
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think hearing about that could be helpful.

600
01:02:34.525 --> 01:02:40.284
<v Olivia Clark>I think, Councilor Koyama Lane, that's opening up a whole other can of worms here or another issue.

601
01:02:40.349 --> 01:02:42.947
<v Olivia Clark>It's important, but I think— and we can come back to that.

602
01:02:43.010 --> 01:02:44.728
<v Olivia Clark>Today was really just to look at the oversight.

603
01:02:45.376 --> 01:02:46.130
<v Olivia Clark>And cost controls.

604
01:02:46.193 --> 01:02:52.851
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate you mentioning that, but I would just suggest that maybe we come back to rate design and rate control a little bit later.

605
01:02:52.932 --> 01:02:59.429
<v Olivia Clark>I know Councilor Green has a big interest in that topic as well, but is it okay with you if we take that up a little bit later?

606
01:03:00.472 --> 01:03:08.831
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I also just know starting July 1st that we— that Ting has been part of leading kind of a rate design, like looking into that.

607
01:03:08.896 --> 01:03:15.172
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I think if, if at at some point we can hear how that's happening alongside this, I think that would be really important.

608
01:03:15.541 --> 01:03:15.847
<v Olivia Clark>Excellent.

609
01:03:16.201 --> 01:03:18.079
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Green, do you have any comment on that?

610
01:03:18.192 --> 01:03:19.331
<v Olivia Clark>I mean, I know you're working on that.

611
01:03:20.519 --> 01:03:45.545
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I mean, I just— I think it's a relevant question, um, and I understand that we could get deep into the details, but I think what we need to hear is— because they— the rates are going to be a function of the cost of this project, and so the rates that we've already talked about, that we've already communicated, that were a function of what the bonds that we issued assume that we don't have any cost escalation.

612
01:03:45.610 --> 01:03:48.773
<v Mitch Green>And so it's gonna be really important to kind of connect these pieces.

613
01:03:48.822 --> 01:03:55.382
<v Mitch Green>That can happen at a different meeting and we should, but I just wanted to, 'cause I was actually gonna ask some questions that are similar.

614
01:03:55.447 --> 01:04:00.985
<v Mitch Green>So I think it's germane that when we build this oversight panel, Yeah.

615
01:04:02.362 --> 01:04:10.007
<v Mitch Green>That we are putting people on it who understand that their job is to make sure that we're controlling costs so we can control rates.

616
01:04:10.233 --> 01:04:15.713
<v Mitch Green>I think that's kind of— Councilor, is that your interest in making sure we're not—.

617
01:04:15.713 --> 01:04:16.003
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Exactly.

618
01:04:16.275 --> 01:04:16.501
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

619
01:04:16.838 --> 01:04:17.094
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

620
01:04:18.445 --> 01:04:18.766
<v Olivia Clark>Terrific.

621
01:04:19.472 --> 01:04:20.460
<v Olivia Clark>I think we got the point across.

622
01:04:22.043 --> 01:04:23.913
<v Olivia Clark>Did you want to say something, DCA?

623
01:04:24.161 --> 01:04:34.369
<v Nancy Thorington>Yes, I just want to quickly, respecting the time here, the water bureau takes the Water Bureau takes the rate design and rate conversations very seriously.

624
01:04:34.865 --> 01:04:41.518
<v Nancy Thorington>And Director Lu and team are working together, and we look forward to coming back to the Public Works Committee to share more details on that.

625
01:04:41.918 --> 01:04:58.894
<v Nancy Thorington>And that being said, relevant to this conversation, I know the Water Bureau is using a wide range of tools to help achieve with cost control for this project as well, including value engineering, financing strategy, risk identification, and risk mitigation that was discussed in the previous Public Works Committee presentation.

626
01:04:59.423 --> 01:05:01.347
<v Nancy Thorington>So I want to make sure that we mention that.

627
01:05:01.380 --> 01:05:01.539
<v Nancy Thorington>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

628
01:05:01.539 --> 01:05:01.539
<v Nancy Thorington>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney Nancy Thorington.

629
01:05:01.539 --> 01:05:02.400
<v Nancy Thorington>I just wanted to mention that as well.

630
01:05:02.400 --> 01:05:07.780
<v Nancy Thorington>And I also want to take the opportunity to address one of a comment that Councilor Smith made.

631
01:05:08.300 --> 01:05:15.039
<v Nancy Thorington>The contracts for the program management and the owner's representation are not 2 separate contracts.

632
01:05:15.039 --> 01:05:16.050
<v Nancy Thorington>They're not going to be paid twice.

633
01:05:16.599 --> 01:05:18.929
<v Nancy Thorington>It is just an amendment to an existing contract.

634
01:05:19.119 --> 01:05:24.139
<v Nancy Thorington>So it is, it is just an extension of scope of the existing contract that they have.

635
01:05:24.139 --> 01:05:37.139
<v Nancy Thorington>That being said, we hear your concerns about who's going to check the checker and whether there's going to be conflict of interest, and we can get back to you thank you, Chair, and thank you, DCA Donipal.

636
01:05:37.202 --> 01:05:41.253
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's kind of what I was hoping to hear and give you a chance to say.

637
01:05:41.929 --> 01:05:43.268
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can I ask one last question?

638
01:05:43.317 --> 01:05:43.737
<v Unidentified speaker>Of course.

639
01:05:44.123 --> 01:05:44.349
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure.

640
01:05:44.768 --> 01:05:50.094
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm wondering, when we look at the costs, there was a slide about how much has been spent.

641
01:05:50.905 --> 01:06:16.739
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>If we have a number, if we know how much of that is, is because of delays or lawsuits or the slow pace of the process, Yeah, we currently have change orders and amendments in progress, and they total about—.

642
01:06:16.739 --> 01:06:18.619
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>They total $202 million.

643
01:06:18.619 --> 01:06:23.300
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>That includes construction impacts and that includes support cost impacts.

644
01:06:23.300 --> 01:06:25.119
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So we're extending everybody's contracts.

645
01:06:25.119 --> 01:06:25.139
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

646
01:06:25.556 --> 01:06:26.983
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>As a result of the delays.

647
01:06:27.514 --> 01:06:33.514
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So that's people tending to construction, that's our own time, staff.

648
01:06:34.090 --> 01:06:35.438
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>So those are the amendments.

649
01:06:35.663 --> 01:06:43.235
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>They include— they're not all related to the delay, but the major portion is associated with the delay.

650
01:06:43.443 --> 01:06:55.139
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And those costs were all included within the amount that we asked council last spring for the $450 million increase in associated bond sales.

651
01:06:55.251 --> 01:06:55.298
<v Nancy Thorington>Okay.

652
01:06:59.827 --> 01:07:01.400
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You say $202 million?

653
01:07:02.717 --> 01:07:03.487
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>That's what I said.

654
01:07:03.922 --> 01:07:05.478
<v Olivia Clark>And that, that's as a result of the delay?

655
01:07:06.570 --> 01:07:19.802
<v Olivia Clark>And then there are other pieces that came with that, and, and we experienced some of those— the slow speed, uh, the limit on the number of, I guess, vehicles, the limit on the hours that you can work.

656
01:07:20.202 --> 01:07:24.730
<v Olivia Clark>There are a lot of constraints that have increased the cost as well.

657
01:07:24.873 --> 01:07:25.918
<v Olivia Clark>Am I right on that?

658
01:07:26.110 --> 01:07:28.085
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Thank you, Councilor Clark.

659
01:07:28.565 --> 01:07:38.005
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Yes, there are land use condition of approvals that came as a part of the outcome of closing the land use remand.

660
01:07:38.438 --> 01:07:43.702
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And so condition of approval imposed additional constraints to construction.

661
01:07:44.119 --> 01:07:56.550
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>For example, traffic limitations, hours of work limitations, And so those, those are increasing costs that were not foreseen when signing the contracts.

662
01:07:59.054 --> 01:08:14.315
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I just think as we're talking about cost overrun and how it's impacting Portlanders, that we are transparent about different things that are bringing the bill up, even if they are, you know, we have to do them or they're important to answer certain questions.

663
01:08:14.362 --> 01:08:18.462
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do think we need to be open with the public about what those costs are.

664
01:08:18.819 --> 01:08:19.369
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

665
01:08:19.532 --> 01:08:19.840
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's it.

666
01:08:20.163 --> 01:08:21.136
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor.

667
01:08:22.815 --> 01:08:24.393
<v Olivia Clark>Um, let's see who's next in the queue.

668
01:08:25.115 --> 01:08:26.923
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith, are you next?

669
01:08:28.020 --> 01:08:28.068
<v Loretta Smith>Yep.

670
01:08:30.532 --> 01:08:32.012
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Madam Chair.

671
01:08:32.786 --> 01:08:37.359
<v Loretta Smith>Um, just so that I'm clear, I don't know it in, in the back of my head again, could you tell me what the GMP is?

672
01:08:39.837 --> 01:08:41.377
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>We have 2 GMPs.

673
01:08:43.315 --> 01:08:48.055
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>And I'd have to get back to you because it depends if it's amended yet or not amended yet.

674
01:08:48.698 --> 01:08:52.890
<v Loretta Smith>So the one that we've already approved, what's that GMP?

675
01:08:53.068 --> 01:09:02.738
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>I believe it was $1.3 billion for the filtration facility and around $400 million for the pipelines.

676
01:09:02.850 --> 01:09:03.880
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>But I would have to—.

677
01:09:03.895 --> 01:09:07.220
<v Loretta Smith>Which is the guaranteed maximum price.

678
01:09:07.510 --> 01:09:08.426
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Guaranteed maximum.

679
01:09:08.474 --> 01:09:08.844
<v Loretta Smith>Of a project.

680
01:09:08.891 --> 01:09:09.855
<v Loretta Smith>It's called GMP.

681
01:09:10.220 --> 01:09:10.918
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Mm-hmm.

682
01:09:10.984 --> 01:09:15.097
<v Loretta Smith>For those of you who don't know what that is, I try not to use acronyms.

683
01:09:17.350 --> 01:09:18.676
<v Loretta Smith>So $1.3—.

684
01:09:19.729 --> 01:09:26.014
<v Ting Lu>I want to add that during the 2024, the latest GMP is $2.13 billion.

685
01:09:26.922 --> 01:09:28.204
<v Loretta Smith>$2.13 Billion?

686
01:09:29.033 --> 01:09:29.779
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, perfect.

687
01:09:30.574 --> 01:09:30.963
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

688
01:09:32.782 --> 01:09:34.386
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

689
01:09:35.154 --> 01:09:36.430
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Green.

690
01:09:38.849 --> 01:09:39.346
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you.

691
01:09:39.395 --> 01:09:51.671
<v Mitch Green>Just briefly, I like what I'm seeing with the kind of process you've outlined for recruiting and just building this independent oversight panel.

692
01:09:52.346 --> 01:09:57.328
<v Mitch Green>I want to offer a suggestion on places to recruit.

693
01:09:57.488 --> 01:10:21.305
<v Mitch Green>I think the electric utility industry in the Pacific Northwest has a a very robust and deep bench of people who have a lot of experience with integrated capital plans and really understanding how to, to Councilor Koyama Lane's concerns, really connect that with the long-run rate pressure and sort of ratepayer stewardship of funds.

694
01:10:21.882 --> 01:10:33.073
<v Mitch Green>And so local organizations would include the Public Power Association, which is a trade association for municipally owned public utilities who are customers of the Bonneville Power Administration.

695
01:10:33.203 --> 01:10:46.819
<v Mitch Green>I've sat on the other side of the table from these organizations who have critiqued my rate proposal and my analysis and method, and I know they've got the stuff and they've got an interest in kind of public stewardship of funds.

696
01:10:46.867 --> 01:10:47.829
<v Mitch Green>And so that's one org.

697
01:10:47.926 --> 01:10:49.869
<v Mitch Green>Northwest Requirements Utilities as well.

698
01:10:50.382 --> 01:10:53.033
<v Mitch Green>These are all boards of folks.

699
01:10:53.113 --> 01:10:53.738
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Herbold.

700
01:10:54.774 --> 01:10:56.578
<v Mitch Green>In their public service, their civil servants.

701
01:10:58.591 --> 01:11:04.320
<v Mitch Green>Northwest Requirements Utilities tend to represent the really small, tiny utilities in Oregon and Washington.

702
01:11:05.560 --> 01:11:15.251
<v Mitch Green>They might also have just a vested interest in the Water Bureau because they might also serve electricity to some of our wholesale customers on the water side.

703
01:11:15.332 --> 01:11:18.835
<v Mitch Green>So I think there's just an opportunity there to kind of look locally at some of these trade-offs.

704
01:11:18.899 --> 01:11:19.109
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

705
01:11:19.381 --> 01:11:30.750
<v Mitch Green>Associations and see if they'd be interested in having anyone apply to be on that panel, even though their book of business is not water utilities, but electric utilities.

706
01:11:30.862 --> 01:11:32.194
<v Mitch Green>They have the same problems that we face.

707
01:11:32.708 --> 01:11:33.061
<v Dan Bauer>Thanks.

708
01:11:33.430 --> 01:11:34.411
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, that would be great.

709
01:11:34.475 --> 01:11:38.377
<v Ting Lu>We'll provide additional follow-up on the blurbs and for other council members.

710
01:11:38.488 --> 01:11:42.775
<v Ting Lu>And feel free, if you have any association, we can reach out and I would love to hear that.

711
01:11:45.055 --> 01:11:45.891
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Green.

712
01:11:46.100 --> 01:11:49.828
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I'm going to intervene here and let myself ask a couple questions.

713
01:11:49.877 --> 01:11:54.087
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm going to go down to the 5,000-foot level, um, and some really simple questions.

714
01:11:54.778 --> 01:12:03.278
<v Olivia Clark>Um, can you explain to me how the— what the city auditor's role is through the project, or is it at the end of the project?

715
01:12:04.579 --> 01:12:10.524
<v Ting Lu>The, uh, city auditor's office has always been selecting large projects as part of the audit.

716
01:12:10.942 --> 01:12:17.935
<v Ting Lu>Because of the nature of the filtration project, this has been selected for the last couple years as being always part of the audit.

717
01:12:17.984 --> 01:12:21.496
<v Ting Lu>So it's going to be the audit for next year as well.

718
01:12:22.185 --> 01:12:26.885
<v Olivia Clark>So they're following through monitoring the entire construction process?

719
01:12:26.980 --> 01:12:28.072
<v Olivia Clark>Is that what's happening?

720
01:12:28.970 --> 01:12:39.139
<v Ting Lu>They are monitoring from more of a higher-level project or accounting kind of a level, not directly on the construction activities side of things.

721
01:12:39.572 --> 01:12:41.932
<v Olivia Clark>And when can we expect their audit report?

722
01:12:42.238 --> 01:12:46.300
<v Ting Lu>Yes, we can provide that link to you for the past reports.

723
01:12:46.877 --> 01:12:49.576
<v Olivia Clark>When you, when you think the next one is, is really the prospective one?

724
01:12:50.731 --> 01:12:52.032
<v Olivia Clark>You said next year, or—.

725
01:12:52.417 --> 01:12:58.904
<v Ting Lu>I need to check on the schedule when they will be done with their report, but we can provide the existing ones and follow up on the new schedule.

726
01:12:59.242 --> 01:12:59.658
<v Olivia Clark>That's great.

727
01:12:59.724 --> 01:13:00.863
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Director Ting.

728
01:13:01.715 --> 01:13:10.088
<v Olivia Clark>Um, this is a very Small issue, but, you know, you mentioned the concrete contractor, that you had to change contractors.

729
01:13:11.609 --> 01:13:15.546
<v Olivia Clark>We had a problem at Darcel Plaza with a concrete contractor.

730
01:13:15.963 --> 01:13:18.020
<v Olivia Clark>I just wonder what's going on with that industry.

731
01:13:18.375 --> 01:13:24.181
<v Olivia Clark>Can you say anything more about the— what the issue was with the concrete contractor, or is that privileged?

732
01:13:26.350 --> 01:13:30.095
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>It was quality issue, if you want to put it in a big bucket.

733
01:13:30.305 --> 01:13:44.770
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>It was quality issues, and they were let go even though we were right on the it's the same issue that slowed down the opening of the Durcell Plaza, by the way.

734
01:13:46.310 --> 01:13:49.497
<v Olivia Clark>And a question on the boulders that look like a dinosaur egg.

735
01:13:49.948 --> 01:13:53.796
<v Olivia Clark>Are we— when we come across those boulders, what do we sell them?

736
01:13:53.989 --> 01:13:54.167
<v Olivia Clark>Do we—.

737
01:13:54.715 --> 01:13:56.295
<v Olivia Clark>What do we do with all those boulders?

738
01:13:57.537 --> 01:13:58.975
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>I don't know.

739
01:13:59.636 --> 01:14:00.090
<v Olivia Clark>I should—.

740
01:14:00.525 --> 01:14:01.979
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>I could follow up on that.

741
01:14:02.140 --> 01:14:03.980
<v Olivia Clark>There's probably a market for those rocks.

742
01:14:04.046 --> 01:14:04.256
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know.

743
01:14:06.033 --> 01:14:07.694
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, Councilor Kanal.

744
01:14:09.725 --> 01:14:11.997
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, thank you, Chair Clark.

745
01:14:12.141 --> 01:14:16.472
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so as we get to, uh, the panel, I had a couple questions here.

746
01:14:18.046 --> 01:14:19.444
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, 5 seems to be the standard.

747
01:14:19.492 --> 01:14:21.243
<v Sameer Kanal>I know we do that for the, the parks levy.

748
01:14:21.756 --> 01:14:22.850
<v Sameer Kanal>Why is it 5?

749
01:14:23.106 --> 01:14:47.622
<v Ting Lu>Um, it seems like if the point is to have a, a diversity of perspectives, that a larger number makes that's just the typical process and to ensure that there is active discussion and engagement and providing feedback for the project in a timely manner.

750
01:14:48.515 --> 01:14:52.350
<v Ting Lu>And also it's numbers at 5 versus 4 or 6.

751
01:14:52.399 --> 01:14:53.320
<v Ting Lu>So sure.

752
01:14:53.837 --> 01:14:54.033
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

753
01:14:54.824 --> 01:14:56.265
<v Sameer Kanal>But I mean, is there a reason it's 5 and not 10?

754
01:14:56.515 --> 01:14:56.837
<v Sameer Kanal>7.

755
01:14:57.319 --> 01:14:58.925
<v Sameer Kanal>I understand the odd number issue, but—.

756
01:14:59.421 --> 01:14:59.567
<v Ting Lu>Right.

757
01:15:01.028 --> 01:15:02.488
<v Ting Lu>We can look into that.

758
01:15:02.537 --> 01:15:18.738
<v Ting Lu>I think that just because of the numbers and things, and that we are open if we have more qualified expertise, but I think beyond 7 will be probably too big for the panel to having that discussion and engagement.

759
01:15:19.252 --> 01:15:21.613
<v Ting Lu>But we can look into that structure.

760
01:15:22.143 --> 01:15:22.899
<v Ting Lu>And numbers there.

761
01:15:23.430 --> 01:15:23.640
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

762
01:15:23.737 --> 01:15:29.484
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'd obviously love to see at least one of the people on it, whether it's 5 or 7, be from District 2.

763
01:15:31.689 --> 01:15:35.978
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of information access, do you— what's the plan?

764
01:15:36.592 --> 01:15:40.234
<v Sameer Kanal>How do you intend to get this panel the information they need?

765
01:15:40.942 --> 01:15:51.823
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm noting that, and this has nothing to do with Public Works at all, but there are other parts of the city that commission audits and then don't even, don't make that available to anybody else.

766
01:15:52.161 --> 01:15:58.782
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm trying to understand how does the information that you have about what's going well, what's not going well, how does it get to them?

767
01:15:58.829 --> 01:15:59.935
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you have a plan for that?

768
01:16:00.817 --> 01:16:06.556
<v Ting Lu>Yes, we are in the active process of developing the plan here at Councilor Kanal.

769
01:16:06.604 --> 01:16:14.492
<v Ting Lu>So, you know, it's based on the scope of work, what they are going to be focusing on, and what are going, what are the things they are going to delivering.

770
01:16:14.925 --> 01:16:29.796
<v Ting Lu>And then based on that information, it will be compiling all the background information, and as well as having a dedicated 2-day— probably going to be orientation for them to understand the project before they jump in and having that active discussion.

771
01:16:30.310 --> 01:16:37.890
<v Ting Lu>And we will be having dedicated resource from the bureau to support as part of this, serving and supporting the panel as well.

772
01:16:38.337 --> 01:16:42.680
<v Ting Lu>So there will be additional details about this information as we move forward.

773
01:16:43.675 --> 01:16:44.139
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

774
01:16:46.162 --> 01:16:55.170
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I think the main thing I'd be interested in knowing is the direct access to the data and financials, not to the narrative around it.

775
01:16:55.636 --> 01:16:56.117
<v Ting Lu>Mm-hmm.

776
01:16:56.198 --> 01:17:05.511
<v Sameer Kanal>I think, you know, again, looking at the seats that are empty to my right, we have a challenge at the highest levels of the city with narrative as opposed to spreadsheets being provided.

777
01:17:05.847 --> 01:17:09.412
<v Sameer Kanal>I know that doesn't exist in this, that problem does not exist in Public Works.

778
01:17:09.750 --> 01:17:12.086
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm mostly encouraging you to keep doing what you do well.

779
01:17:14.966 --> 01:17:18.413
<v Sameer Kanal>For the folks who serve on it, will there be stipends available?

780
01:17:18.913 --> 01:17:19.493
<v Ting Lu>Of course.

781
01:17:19.800 --> 01:17:24.136
<v Ting Lu>That's going to be one of the first orientations to be a part of the site visit.

782
01:17:25.204 --> 01:17:25.399
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

783
01:17:26.661 --> 01:17:42.073
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I would just ask, as you develop the particular mechanism by which people apply, designate interest, however you decide to do it, just to share that with our offices so that we can help boost and get folks out.

784
01:17:42.154 --> 01:17:55.234
<v Sameer Kanal>I think obviously there will need to be some industry expertise on the panel, but every now and then it is nice to have folks who don't have that expertise but just are coming at it as a ratepayer, coming at it as a person who experiences the end goals of it.

785
01:17:55.689 --> 01:17:59.233
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think we can help a lot with helping to circulate those opportunities.

786
01:17:59.427 --> 01:17:59.525
<v Ting Lu>Yeah.

787
01:18:01.225 --> 01:18:01.451
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

788
01:18:01.787 --> 01:18:01.965
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

789
01:18:02.206 --> 01:18:03.569
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

790
01:18:03.715 --> 01:18:13.573
<v Olivia Clark>And perhaps there will be an openness to expanding that to 7 as a possibility so that we can include, um, more of a person on the street.

791
01:18:14.230 --> 01:18:15.627
<v Olivia Clark>Um, thank you.

792
01:18:15.997 --> 01:18:17.859
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I don't see any other hands up.

793
01:18:18.083 --> 01:18:19.626
<v Olivia Clark>Um, this has been terrific.

794
01:18:19.770 --> 01:18:19.962
<v Ting Lu>We—.

795
01:18:20.091 --> 01:18:22.885
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very confident in the work that you're doing.

796
01:18:23.141 --> 01:18:24.409
<v Olivia Clark>I feel really good about it.

797
01:18:24.587 --> 01:18:28.069
<v Olivia Clark>Um, and, and seeing it firsthand was very meaningful.

798
01:18:28.132 --> 01:18:36.145
<v Olivia Clark>But we'll have you back to talk about, uh, the next iteration and the oversight committee, perhaps later in the fall, I think.

799
01:18:36.402 --> 01:18:39.525
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know what we're scheduled right now, but we'll, we'll look into that.

800
01:18:39.639 --> 01:18:57.582
<v Olivia Clark>But, um, thank you so much for all the work that you do, um, everything that you've had to put up with out there, the delays that have cost us so much, um, both from, uh, the worker standpoint as well as So thank you.

801
01:18:57.663 --> 01:19:00.822
<v Olivia Clark>We'll have you back, and we always appreciate having you here.

802
01:19:01.712 --> 01:19:02.572
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you very much.

803
01:19:03.479 --> 01:19:03.721
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

804
01:19:03.819 --> 01:19:04.725
<v Ting Lu>Thank you for your support.

805
01:19:06.359 --> 01:19:08.250
<v Olivia Clark>Diana, can you please read the next item?

806
01:19:10.100 --> 01:19:19.282
<v Olivia Clark>Item number 3, document number 2026-282, Vision Zero Data Analysis and Intersection Safety.

807
01:19:19.346 --> 01:19:19.493
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

808
01:19:20.023 --> 01:19:21.131
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

809
01:19:21.228 --> 01:19:23.204
<v Olivia Clark>Um, colleagues, I hope we're okay plowing through.

810
01:19:23.783 --> 01:19:27.301
<v Olivia Clark>Um, um, if we need a break later, let me know, but I think we can do this.

811
01:19:28.202 --> 01:19:33.456
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I had asked that we have a discussion of Vision Zero.

812
01:19:33.520 --> 01:19:43.819
<v Olivia Clark>I know it was in the Committee of the Whole very recently, but what I would like to do today was really have a deeper dive and get a better sense for what works and what doesn't.

813
01:19:44.430 --> 01:19:47.998
<v Olivia Clark>Um, where do we get the biggest bang for the buck in Vision Zero.

814
01:19:48.770 --> 01:19:54.091
<v Olivia Clark>Um, so that's why I, um, scheduled this today to really go in a little bit deeper.

815
01:19:54.840 --> 01:19:58.134
<v Olivia Clark>So Director Williams, would you like to kick off this conversation?

816
01:19:58.326 --> 01:19:58.728
<v Olivia Clark>Welcome.

817
01:20:00.158 --> 01:20:00.944
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you so much.

818
01:20:01.042 --> 01:20:01.507
<v Millicent Williams>Good morning.

819
01:20:03.211 --> 01:20:07.226
<v Millicent Williams>Good morning, Council Vice President Clark and members of the committee.

820
01:20:07.323 --> 01:20:10.698
<v Millicent Williams>For the record, I'm Millicent Williams, Director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

821
01:20:11.470 --> 01:20:16.494
<v Millicent Williams>I appreciate the opportunity today for PBOT to share more about the bureau's Vision Zero program.

822
01:20:17.989 --> 01:20:29.087
<v Millicent Williams>The City Council's commitment to Vision Zero has been consistent and heartening, starting with your September 2025 resolution recommitting to the goal of eliminating traffic deaths and serious injuries.

823
01:20:30.073 --> 01:20:55.528
<v Millicent Williams>This resolution also ensured that the commitment to Vision Zero is not PBOT's alone and acknowledges that a number of bureaus and partner agencies that said, we recognize that the Portland Bureau of Transportation is the entity that often provides the most visible realization of what Vision Zero translates into from an infrastructure and policy perspective.

824
01:20:56.234 --> 01:21:06.996
<v Millicent Williams>I want to thank you not just for that resolution, but also for your very recent work on the No Turn on Red ordinance, which will help us to continue advancing a key intersection safety tool.

825
01:21:07.060 --> 01:21:07.509
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you, Councilor Loretta Smith.

826
01:21:08.247 --> 01:21:11.792
<v Millicent Williams>Today we are here to share more about PBOT's role in Vision Zero.

827
01:21:12.289 --> 01:21:21.563
<v Millicent Williams>Staff from across the bureau play a role in advancing this goal, from our work with speed cameras to people-focused programs to large and small capital projects.

828
01:21:22.060 --> 01:21:45.091
<v Millicent Williams>To support the ongoing implementation work, we have several staff that are fully dedicated to the work and a significant number of subject matter experts and technical experts that spend time planning, designing, constructing, today, you will hear from some members of this core Vision Zero team who will focus primarily on our approach to making intersections safer.

829
01:21:45.880 --> 01:21:49.314
<v Millicent Williams>Making streets safer often means making changes to streets.

830
01:21:49.846 --> 01:21:53.298
<v Millicent Williams>When we change streets, we are also asking people to use them differently.

831
01:21:54.039 --> 01:21:57.171
<v Millicent Williams>Frankly, this kind of change is not always welcome.

832
01:21:57.805 --> 01:21:59.055
<v Millicent Williams>This is not work that can be done quickly.

833
01:21:59.104 --> 01:21:59.557
<v Millicent Williams>I think that's a great point.

834
01:22:00.328 --> 01:22:06.895
<v Millicent Williams>Even relatively small changes like the intersection safety work that the team will be focusing on today can take many, many years.

835
01:22:07.810 --> 01:22:25.599
<v Millicent Williams>We also work on larger street transformations, which only come about after years of planning, designing, seeking funding, and building, all the while working with a wide variety of stakeholders to develop projects that reflect community input and needs while meaningfully addressing safety.

836
01:22:26.595 --> 01:22:34.655
<v Millicent Williams>While we can't satisfy everyone, these careful and collaborative processes are designed to ensure that we've addressed concerns as well as we can.

837
01:22:35.426 --> 01:22:43.152
<v Millicent Williams>This is difficult work, and as Clay often says, it's not just hard work, it is heart work, but it's also critically important work.

838
01:22:43.632 --> 01:22:55.815
<v Millicent Williams>So again, I want to thank you for the support of this council, uh, that this council has shown, and I will now turn it over to City Traffic Engineer Wendy Cully and Vision Zero Section Manager Thank you, Director.

839
01:22:55.975 --> 01:22:57.145
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning, councilors.

840
01:22:57.242 --> 01:22:59.932
<v Wendy Cully>I'm Wendy Cully, City Traffic Engineer for PBOT.

841
01:23:01.182 --> 01:23:05.077
<v Clay Vacca>And good morning, I'm Clay Vacca, Vision Zero Section Manager for PBOT.

842
01:23:05.349 --> 01:23:06.646
<v Clay Vacca>Thank you for having us here today.

843
01:23:07.976 --> 01:23:16.052
<v Clay Vacca>Um, we'll share the following, uh, as part of a presentation and then look forward to a conversation after the presentation.

844
01:23:16.725 --> 01:23:26.686
<v Clay Vacca>We're going to jump in with an overview of PBOT's Vision Zero program, Then look at PBOT's approach to traffic safety data analysis specifically.

845
01:23:27.509 --> 01:23:37.677
<v Clay Vacca>We'll then look at intersection safety risk and really use an example of Southeast Division and 148th to kind of understand more about that topic.

846
01:23:39.340 --> 01:23:46.599
<v Clay Vacca>Then we'll jump in to talk about data-driven treatments and end with a look at current areas of focus to advance intersection safety.

847
01:23:49.617 --> 01:23:52.429
<v Clay Vacca>Vision Zero is fundamentally about human life.

848
01:23:53.231 --> 01:23:57.152
<v Clay Vacca>It is built on the belief that no person should be killed trying to get where they are going.

849
01:23:58.148 --> 01:24:05.730
<v Clay Vacca>This slide displays the name of the 39 community members who died in traffic crashes in Portland in 2025.

850
01:24:06.807 --> 01:24:13.458
<v Clay Vacca>Each of these people were loved ones— parents, elders, children, siblings, friends, neighbors, and colleagues.

851
01:24:14.618 --> 01:24:19.744
<v Clay Vacca>Their loss impacts their loved ones profoundly and has ripple impacts into our community.

852
01:24:20.645 --> 01:24:25.246
<v Clay Vacca>We also believe that these traffic deaths are preventable, which is partly what we're here to talk about today.

853
01:24:29.105 --> 01:24:33.805
<v Clay Vacca>Over the last couple of weeks, you've heard about different facets of Portland's Vision Zero work.

854
01:24:34.439 --> 01:24:42.520
<v Clay Vacca>Dana Dickman has recently been here to talk about the citywide Vision Zero effort that City Council initiated with the Vision Zero resolution last year.

855
01:24:43.537 --> 01:24:49.788
<v Clay Vacca>That effort is bringing together many bureaus to identify opportunities each has to advance traffic safety.

856
01:24:50.685 --> 01:24:52.417
<v Clay Vacca>PBOT is part of that effort.

857
01:24:52.913 --> 01:24:58.444
<v Clay Vacca>PBOT has also been the lead bureau working on Vision Zero since its inception in 2015.

858
01:24:59.421 --> 01:25:04.840
<v Clay Vacca>Today we are drilling down on PBOT's Vision Zero efforts, which are guided by the Vision Zero Action Plan.

859
01:25:05.898 --> 01:25:11.252
<v Clay Vacca>We are implementing the 4th action plan that Portland has developed since 2016.

860
01:25:12.405 --> 01:25:25.833
<v Clay Vacca>There are 33 actions in the current plan, and the actions are organized into the 4 safe system action areas over which we have influence: safe speeds, safe streets, safe people, and safe vehicles.

861
01:25:26.747 --> 01:25:31.587
<v Clay Vacca>We track implementation and report on progress at the conclusion of each calendar year.

862
01:25:32.740 --> 01:25:43.305
<v Clay Vacca>While Vision Zero is a key commitment within our bureau, and most of the nearly 1,000 employees do work to support it, we have 7 core Vision Zero team members.

863
01:25:44.122 --> 01:26:05.238
<v Clay Vacca>The team has multifold functions, including data analysis, education and outreach, project planning, engineering, and evaluation, supporting policy development, working with partners on safety from the local to the regional, state, and national levels, and reducing speed limits, to name some of the core functions.

864
01:26:09.246 --> 01:26:14.162
<v Clay Vacca>Now I want to jump into talking about PBOT's approach to delivering traffic safety infrastructure.

865
01:26:14.889 --> 01:26:23.619
<v Clay Vacca>With limited resources and significant needs, we use a data-driven approach to identify where and how we get the most safety benefit for the investment.

866
01:26:24.779 --> 01:26:36.320
<v Clay Vacca>Our data analysis starts with identifying the top safety hotspots, which we do in a couple of ways that I'll talk about next, so that we can prioritize where to invest.

867
01:26:37.493 --> 01:26:43.981
<v Clay Vacca>Next, we follow national research and local data to ensure that we are delivering treatments with known safety benefits.

868
01:26:45.042 --> 01:26:53.569
<v Clay Vacca>We focus on reducing serious injury risk by lowering exposure, the severity, and the likelihood of a serious crash.

869
01:26:53.634 --> 01:26:53.730
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

870
01:26:54.069 --> 01:26:57.122
<v Clay Vacca>So those are kind of 3, 3 areas that we're focused on.

871
01:27:01.909 --> 01:27:03.845
<v Clay Vacca>Vision Zero data guides our work.

872
01:27:04.247 --> 01:27:09.953
<v Clay Vacca>A key data source is statewide traffic crash data, which ODOT collects and publishes.

873
01:27:10.453 --> 01:27:13.873
<v Clay Vacca>It is comprised of police reports and self-reporting.

874
01:27:15.119 --> 01:27:22.042
<v Clay Vacca>PBOT then takes that data from ODOT, geocodes the data, and analyzes it in 5 and 10-year ranges.

875
01:27:22.863 --> 01:27:29.296
<v Clay Vacca>We use the data to identify the highest injury hotspots in the city, looking at the data in a few different ways.

876
01:27:33.027 --> 01:27:41.252
<v Clay Vacca>We develop an annual high-crash intersection list, which has helped PBOT prioritize projects and funding for safety for over a decade.

877
01:27:42.395 --> 01:27:46.408
<v Clay Vacca>These are the intersections with the highest rate of serious injury crashes in the city.

878
01:27:46.783 --> 01:27:53.837
<v Clay Vacca>About 2/3 of those intersections are on PBOT streets and about a third are on state facilities or at interchanges.

879
01:27:55.909 --> 01:28:01.640
<v Clay Vacca>We also identified the 30 streets with the highest number of serious crashes in the city.

880
01:28:01.996 --> 01:28:11.766
<v Clay Vacca>That makes up this kind of high-crash network, which are the 8% of Portland streets that account for about 70% of traffic deaths.

881
01:28:16.407 --> 01:28:29.877
<v Clay Vacca>To get more nuanced, kind of going beyond the high crash network, which is looking at, you know, entire street lengths annually, we zoom in on our serious crash hotspots to further refine that focus area.

882
01:28:30.520 --> 01:28:36.605
<v Clay Vacca>These hotspots show the 150 miles of street segments with the highest number of serious injury crashes.

883
01:28:37.905 --> 01:28:46.710
<v Clay Vacca>With these analyses, we have a clear idea of where to seek grant funds, spend local funds, prioritize maintenance activities, and invest in education.

884
01:28:47.463 --> 01:28:53.926
<v Clay Vacca>We also prioritize work in communities that have an overrepresentation of traffic violence.

885
01:28:55.016 --> 01:29:03.805
<v Clay Vacca>I'm going to get just a little mathy on us for a second.

886
01:29:05.648 --> 01:29:15.967
<v Clay Vacca>We know that intersections are like real conflict points for crash risk in the city and that big intersections are particularly risky.

887
01:29:16.817 --> 01:29:21.497
<v Clay Vacca>64% Of serious crashes in Portland occur at intersections.

888
01:29:22.024 --> 01:29:25.502
<v Clay Vacca>So intersection safety is really a key Vision Zero strategy.

889
01:29:26.801 --> 01:29:29.845
<v Clay Vacca>The physics of injury risk entails 3 components.

890
01:29:30.905 --> 01:29:36.801
<v Clay Vacca>Looking at kind of serious injury risk, including exposure, severity, and likelihood.

891
01:29:36.850 --> 01:29:43.805
<v Clay Vacca>So exposure is really how often and how far people travel in motor vehicles.

892
01:29:45.268 --> 01:29:53.237
<v Clay Vacca>The kind of fewer miles traveled in motor vehicles, kind of the the less exposure for kind of crashes to occur.

893
01:29:54.682 --> 01:29:56.755
<v Clay Vacca>Severity is really looking at how fast.

894
01:29:57.317 --> 01:30:00.207
<v Clay Vacca>And how heavy cars and trucks are when crashes happen.

895
01:30:01.106 --> 01:30:07.015
<v Clay Vacca>And then likelihood is looking at how often users meet in the same space at the same time.

896
01:30:08.315 --> 01:30:14.079
<v Clay Vacca>And so a safe system approach really focuses on reducing all 3 of these.

897
01:30:14.979 --> 01:30:22.189
<v Clay Vacca>Exposure focuses on approaches like changing the land use patterns to improve walkability and support 20-minute neighborhoods.

898
01:30:22.625 --> 01:30:28.662
<v Clay Vacca>Investing in transit service that is fast and reliable, providing tools to travel without a vehicle.

899
01:30:30.305 --> 01:30:40.246
<v Clay Vacca>In the severity space, we're— yeah, yeah, in the severity space, we're really focused on slowing speeds down in every way possible.

900
01:30:41.082 --> 01:30:50.652
<v Clay Vacca>And then in likelihood, we're really focused on implementing measures that limit people colliding in the same space and at the same time with each other.

901
01:30:51.346 --> 01:30:55.774
<v Clay Vacca>So use this framework in thinking about intersection safety opportunities.

902
01:30:57.420 --> 01:30:58.207
<v Wendy Cully>Great, thanks, Clay.

903
01:30:58.479 --> 01:31:06.240
<v Wendy Cully>And I'm going to pivot now and talk about intersection safety and specifically safety infrastructure that we implement at intersections.

904
01:31:06.288 --> 01:31:14.692
<v Wendy Cully>And I'm going to use Southeast Division and 148th as an example of our efforts to prioritize based on data analysis yes.

905
01:31:15.333 --> 01:31:16.698
<v Wendy Cully>That Clay mentioned earlier.

906
01:31:17.355 --> 01:31:24.434
<v Wendy Cully>Now, this intersection was flagged in our first high-crash intersection listing in 2013, and at that time it ranked at number 13.

907
01:31:25.444 --> 01:31:38.461
<v Wendy Cully>That same year, a school bus driver tragically hit and killed Renee Jean Bates, who was crossing the street with her husband to the nearby grocery store, leaving her husband, her 10-year-old child, and loved ones behind.

908
01:31:39.408 --> 01:31:47.320
<v Wendy Cully>In 2015, Southeast Division was flagged as a high-crash street for all modes, pedestrians, people riding bikes, and people driving.

909
01:31:48.140 --> 01:31:52.043
<v Wendy Cully>And this aerial image shows that intersection in 2013.

910
01:31:53.844 --> 01:31:57.127
<v Wendy Cully>This is the 2013 street view of the same intersection.

911
01:31:57.483 --> 01:31:59.786
<v Wendy Cully>This is facing westbound toward downtown.

912
01:32:00.606 --> 01:32:05.211
<v Wendy Cully>You can see the risks that were described earlier in physics of injury risk.

913
01:32:05.935 --> 01:32:07.255
<v Wendy Cully>The exposure is high here.

914
01:32:07.930 --> 01:32:10.184
<v Wendy Cully>This is a car and truck dominated space.

915
01:32:10.247 --> 01:32:10.408
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>Thank you.

916
01:32:11.237 --> 01:32:14.317
<v Wendy Cully>The severity of injury due to speed is something to be aware of.

917
01:32:14.943 --> 01:32:28.145
<v Wendy Cully>The likelihood of collision is concern, and the expansive asphalt here leads to more time during which a crash can occur and more potential crash places than smaller, tighter intersections.

918
01:32:29.283 --> 01:32:33.904
<v Wendy Cully>In 2013, the pedestrian crossing was almost 120 feet long.

919
01:32:34.753 --> 01:32:36.904
<v Wendy Cully>Pedestrians had to cross 6 lanes of traffic.

920
01:32:37.859 --> 01:32:41.752
<v Wendy Cully>Sorry, 6 lanes of traffic, and travel speeds were likely high.

921
01:32:43.850 --> 01:32:49.514
<v Wendy Cully>This is the same view of Southeast Division at 148th in 2019.

922
01:32:50.338 --> 01:32:56.266
<v Wendy Cully>You can see that we've started to minimize the risks through some mitigations.

923
01:32:56.800 --> 01:33:04.184
<v Wendy Cully>The space for people walking and bicycling begins to be defined with those concrete islands and curb extensions at the intersection.

924
01:33:04.935 --> 01:33:10.079
<v Wendy Cully>This also slows drivers down as they turn onto Division and from Division.

925
01:33:10.823 --> 01:33:18.726
<v Wendy Cully>Collision opportunities between all modes are reduced with fewer travel lanes, shorter crossing distances, and more protected bike facilities.

926
01:33:19.836 --> 01:33:24.662
<v Wendy Cully>Its ranking on the 2019 high-crash intersection list dropped to number 47.

927
01:33:24.774 --> 01:33:26.645
<v Wendy Cully>So we're already making progress there.

928
01:33:28.113 --> 01:33:33.322
<v Wendy Cully>The next slide is a westbound view of Division and 148th in 2024.

929
01:33:33.371 --> 01:33:33.484
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

930
01:33:35.005 --> 01:33:39.030
<v Wendy Cully>At this point, this intersection design has minimized serious crash risks.

931
01:33:39.560 --> 01:33:41.951
<v Wendy Cully>All of the pedestrian crossings are shorter.

932
01:33:42.689 --> 01:33:45.319
<v Wendy Cully>This particular one was 120 feet long.

933
01:33:45.576 --> 01:33:47.003
<v Wendy Cully>It's now 45 feet long.

934
01:33:47.516 --> 01:33:54.511
<v Wendy Cully>That means crossing times for pedestrians have reduced from 35 to 40 seconds to 13 to 15 seconds to cross the street.

935
01:33:54.560 --> 01:33:58.265
<v Wendy Cully>So we've seriously limited exposure for pedestrians.

936
01:33:59.228 --> 01:34:00.542
<v Wendy Cully>There is physical protection.

937
01:34:00.912 --> 01:34:02.983
<v Wendy Cully>And markings for people riding bikes.

938
01:34:03.560 --> 01:34:09.707
<v Wendy Cully>The street design is slower with narrower travel space and tighter turns, making slower turns for vehicles.

939
01:34:10.542 --> 01:34:14.283
<v Wendy Cully>We have high visibility markings for pedestrians and people riding bicycles.

940
01:34:14.940 --> 01:34:28.569
<v Wendy Cully>And you can also see, though it's hard in this slide, I have another slide later, but you can see that the signals have been upgraded, including separate phases for different modes, for bicyclists, transit, and drivers.

941
01:34:29.359 --> 01:34:30.869
<v Wendy Cully>The signal heads are more visible.

942
01:34:31.390 --> 01:34:33.875
<v Wendy Cully>We've restricted some movements, including no turn on red.

943
01:34:35.061 --> 01:34:41.158
<v Wendy Cully>And at this point, Division N 148th has dropped now to number 65 on the high crash intersection list.

944
01:34:42.761 --> 01:34:51.875
<v Wendy Cully>The next slide shows side-by-side aerial images of the north leg of the intersection with 2013 at the top and 2024 at the bottom.

945
01:34:52.469 --> 01:34:57.712
<v Wendy Cully>It highlights many of the safety features I just talked about, but I want to point out the red circle in that image.

946
01:34:57.778 --> 01:34:57.923
<v Wendy Cully>Oh, yeah.

947
01:34:58.372 --> 01:35:06.408
<v Wendy Cully>This is where Renee Bates was hit and killed in 2013, and that you can see that by 2024, she would've been well out of harm's way.

948
01:35:07.675 --> 01:35:15.149
<v Wendy Cully>I also wanna talk about the sustained commitment to Vision Zero, and this requires— that is required to move the needle on safety.

949
01:35:16.015 --> 01:35:20.105
<v Wendy Cully>People often ask us at PBOT why it takes so long to make change.

950
01:35:20.828 --> 01:35:32.988
<v Wendy Cully>Portland, like most US cities, built up a lot of infrastructure with the intention of moving cars quickly, And generally providing priority for car movement over the movement of people outside of cars.

951
01:35:33.582 --> 01:35:42.118
<v Wendy Cully>I also want to point out at a location like Division and 148, this was much more rural as we were developing infrastructure back in the '60s and '70s.

952
01:35:42.470 --> 01:35:44.942
<v Wendy Cully>This wasn't even part of the City of Portland at that time.

953
01:35:45.391 --> 01:35:54.457
<v Wendy Cully>It was a county and less dense that, you know, as things change, we need to relook at our infrastructure and start making some of the changes that you see that we've made here.

954
01:35:55.949 --> 01:35:58.503
<v Wendy Cully>We're now redesigning our streets to move people safely.

955
01:35:59.177 --> 01:36:08.860
<v Wendy Cully>However, this transformation does take time and funding, and it involves significant change, which means we often have to move slowly and work through changes with community.

956
01:36:09.631 --> 01:36:18.735
<v Wendy Cully>Taking a layered approach and starting with things we can do today and moving toward a more significant design change is one way to start making progress on our safety goals.

957
01:36:19.796 --> 01:36:27.904
<v Wendy Cully>This also gives us time to budget for the larger projects and work with communities to ensure that the project not only meets safety goals, but meets community goals.

958
01:36:29.149 --> 01:36:34.783
<v Wendy Cully>This intersection is an example of incremental changes that started small and then became significant.

959
01:36:35.725 --> 01:36:43.198
<v Wendy Cully>Each change brought some safety benefit and gave us time to seek funding, develop designs, and work with community on the change to come.

960
01:36:45.322 --> 01:36:49.069
<v Wendy Cully>I want to talk a little bit more about the signal safety improvements that I mentioned earlier.

961
01:36:49.801 --> 01:36:58.939
<v Wendy Cully>Today, the signal at Division and 148th and many of the signals, or most of the signals along Division now, is much more advanced than it was a decade ago.

962
01:36:59.725 --> 01:37:05.479
<v Wendy Cully>This signal prioritizes buses, pedestrians, and bicyclists and separates users.

963
01:37:06.474 --> 01:37:07.948
<v Wendy Cully>We have bus priority here.

964
01:37:08.140 --> 01:37:11.570
<v Wendy Cully>You can see, maybe you can see, there's a specific signal for buses.

965
01:37:12.148 --> 01:37:16.974
<v Wendy Cully>We have bike separation with a separate bike phase that you can see on the far right there.

966
01:37:17.534 --> 01:37:22.153
<v Wendy Cully>We have pedestrian priority phasing through leading pedestrian intervals or pedestrian head starts.

967
01:37:22.409 --> 01:37:29.057
<v Wendy Cully>Those are interchangeable terms for the same thing that gets pedestrians out in the intersection before autos even start moving.

968
01:37:29.957 --> 01:37:31.899
<v Wendy Cully>And we also have a no turn on red sign here.

969
01:37:33.007 --> 01:37:34.404
<v Wendy Cully>Also, the signals are more visible.

970
01:37:35.176 --> 01:37:39.783
<v Wendy Cully>We have larger signal lenses, reflective backplates.

971
01:37:39.849 --> 01:37:43.637
<v Wendy Cully>That's the yellow strip or the yellow backing on the signal that make them more visible.

972
01:37:44.328 --> 01:37:48.615
<v Wendy Cully>And bigger reflective street name signs, which are important for people that are new to the area.

973
01:37:48.663 --> 01:37:48.824
<v Millicent Williams>Yeah.

974
01:37:49.167 --> 01:37:51.033
<v Wendy Cully>At nighttime when it's hard to see where you're going.

975
01:37:55.029 --> 01:37:55.775
<v Wendy Cully>Let's see.

976
01:37:55.953 --> 01:38:01.275
<v Wendy Cully>PBOT safety investments are data-driven, grounded in national research and local studies.

977
01:38:02.189 --> 01:38:08.057
<v Wendy Cully>Many treatments we deploy at intersections throughout the city are what the industry refers to as proven safety countermeasures.

978
01:38:08.869 --> 01:38:16.755
<v Wendy Cully>These countermeasures do have crash reduction factors that we utilize when we're looking at what we're going to implement, and they are identified through national research.

979
01:38:16.819 --> 01:38:16.948
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

980
01:38:17.563 --> 01:38:20.738
<v Wendy Cully>Of effectiveness in treatments and locations across the country.

981
01:38:21.171 --> 01:38:24.509
<v Wendy Cully>And these are based on many, many locations across different cities.

982
01:38:25.503 --> 01:38:26.802
<v Wendy Cully>We have implemented many of these.

983
01:38:26.868 --> 01:38:30.188
<v Wendy Cully>We are seeing very similar crash reductions when we implement here.

984
01:38:30.782 --> 01:38:38.578
<v Wendy Cully>And so we use this as we go through our design process to determine what is the best treatment, what will be most effective.

985
01:38:39.444 --> 01:38:46.653
<v Wendy Cully>At Division and 148th, we— this table shows the mitigations that we used at that intersection.

986
01:38:47.391 --> 01:38:53.158
<v Wendy Cully>It includes curb extensions that reduce the crossing distance for pedestrians and people on bicycles.

987
01:38:53.592 --> 01:39:02.716
<v Wendy Cully>It also reduces the severity and likelihood of all crashes, and we expect a crash reduction of about 30% for all crashes when we use curb extensions.

988
01:39:03.471 --> 01:39:10.380
<v Wendy Cully>We also have improved intersection illumination, new lighting at the intersection that of course reduces nighttime crashes.

989
01:39:10.427 --> 01:39:10.636
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

990
01:39:11.332 --> 01:39:18.694
<v Wendy Cully>And in this case, at about 42% for pedestrians and bicyclists when we add new lighting at intersections.

991
01:39:19.601 --> 01:39:26.386
<v Wendy Cully>Larger signal heads are great for reducing the angle crashes or, you know, red light running that results in T-bone crashes.

992
01:39:28.131 --> 01:39:30.329
<v Wendy Cully>It reduces those types of crashes by 42%.

993
01:39:31.606 --> 01:39:37.088
<v Wendy Cully>The retroreflective backplates that I pointed out has a reduction of 15% for all crash types.

994
01:39:37.774 --> 01:39:49.382
<v Wendy Cully>No turn on red, as we talked about last week at the Committee of the Whole, has a 9% reduction in all crashes, but probably more importantly, a 41% reduction for people walking and bicycling.

995
01:39:50.523 --> 01:39:54.118
<v Wendy Cully>Leading pedestrian intervals have a 37% crash reduction.

996
01:39:54.391 --> 01:40:00.462
<v Wendy Cully>This, as I mentioned before, allows people to get out into the intersection before autos even start moving.

997
01:40:00.814 --> 01:40:02.548
<v Wendy Cully>And then we also have the green bike lanes.

998
01:40:03.127 --> 01:40:06.896
<v Wendy Cully>That reduces bicycle crashes at about 39%.

999
01:40:07.347 --> 01:40:17.020
<v Wendy Cully>So all of these things, when layered together, really start to have a significant reduction on crashes at all of the intersections where we're implementing these types of treatments.

1000
01:40:18.630 --> 01:40:24.972
<v Wendy Cully>PBOT's intersection— or sorry, making intersection safety improvements will continue to be a high priority for PBOT's safety work.

1001
01:40:25.649 --> 01:40:29.296
<v Wendy Cully>Big changes can make a big difference, as we've seen at Division and 148th.

1002
01:40:29.362 --> 01:40:29.444
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

1003
01:40:30.042 --> 01:40:32.354
<v Wendy Cully>They can take time and money and political support.

1004
01:40:32.771 --> 01:40:41.167
<v Wendy Cully>We'll continue to make these big changes like the recently completed roundabout at Halcyon 80th that reduces both severity and the likelihood of crashes.

1005
01:40:42.082 --> 01:40:46.640
<v Wendy Cully>We'll also continue to make smaller, faster improvements that make a safety difference.

1006
01:40:47.619 --> 01:40:57.139
<v Wendy Cully>PBOT is replacing the LED units in our traffic signals for red, yellow, and green lenses, and we're going to be doing that over the next 5 years.

1007
01:40:58.055 --> 01:41:09.737
<v Wendy Cully>The Vision Zero program is partnering with our signals and street lighting teams to stretch council-designated TUF funds for safety and support deployment of the recently adopted no-turn-on-red ordinance.

1008
01:41:10.587 --> 01:41:31.807
<v Wendy Cully>While traffic control is in place and the aerial bucket truck is deployed, we will deliver no-turn-on-red at high-crash intersections that meet PBOT guidelines, and we will install reflective backplates simultaneously, we are working to advance pedestrian head starts at many of these signals as well.

1009
01:41:32.498 --> 01:41:34.654
<v Wendy Cully>And I'll turn it back to Clay to wrap us up here.

1010
01:41:36.061 --> 01:41:37.081
<v Clay Vacca>Thanks, Wendy.

1011
01:41:37.354 --> 01:41:40.168
<v Clay Vacca>This is our last slide, and then, then we'll, we'll turn it over.

1012
01:41:41.301 --> 01:41:47.838
<v Clay Vacca>And really, we want to thank you for your strong commitment to Vision Zero and your leadership in prioritizing safety treatments.

1013
01:41:48.337 --> 01:41:55.847
<v Clay Vacca>The recent no-turn-on-red ordinance will support us in continuing to deliver on some of the kind of small systemic work that we know is needed.

1014
01:41:56.715 --> 01:42:08.559
<v Clay Vacca>We also appreciate your continued support in making some of the bigger moves that have more noticeable impacts on how people travel and where we can get a little bit more pushback, but are extremely important for saving lives.

1015
01:42:09.859 --> 01:42:21.347
<v Clay Vacca>Um, please be in touch with the DCA's office if you want more information about the traffic safety data or best practices, or if you want to explore opportunities to support the work.

1016
01:42:22.149 --> 01:42:25.518
<v Clay Vacca>We really welcome the collaboration and appreciate your leadership.

1017
01:42:26.384 --> 01:42:27.297
<v Olivia Clark>Great, thank you.

1018
01:42:27.523 --> 01:42:28.661
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, all of you.

1019
01:42:28.966 --> 01:42:31.194
<v Olivia Clark>That's— this is exactly what I was looking for.

1020
01:42:31.386 --> 01:42:34.082
<v Olivia Clark>It's just where, where the investments pay off.

1021
01:42:34.177 --> 01:42:35.332
<v Olivia Clark>What are we actually getting for that?

1022
01:42:35.926 --> 01:42:40.993
<v Olivia Clark>I have lots of questions, but first I'm going to turn it over to Councilor Green, who has his hand up.

1023
01:42:41.555 --> 01:42:42.917
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much, Chair Clark.

1024
01:42:43.061 --> 01:42:53.814
<v Mitch Green>Um, can you go can we go back to the slide, please, that had the data, the sort of percent reductions on the margin concepts there?

1025
01:42:54.204 --> 01:42:54.514
<v Ting Lu>Yes.

1026
01:42:54.871 --> 01:42:55.033
<v Nancy Thorington>Thanks.

1027
01:42:55.667 --> 01:42:57.208
<v Olivia Clark>Give me just a sec to get there.

1028
01:42:57.274 --> 01:42:58.637
<v Mitch Green>I just want to clarify a few things there.

1029
01:43:05.765 --> 01:43:06.476
<v Clay Vacca>We're working on it.

1030
01:43:06.671 --> 01:43:13.604
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, we, you know, 20 is plenty, and that also applies to slides.

1031
01:43:14.603 --> 01:43:15.020
<v Clay Vacca>Thank you.

1032
01:43:16.452 --> 01:43:19.814
<v Mitch Green>Okay, I just wanna make sure everyone— thanks for laughing at my dumb joke.

1033
01:43:22.516 --> 01:43:27.557
<v Mitch Green>I just wanna make sure everyone understands what this slide is saying.

1034
01:43:27.605 --> 01:43:34.869
<v Mitch Green>So you've used it in the context of Southeast Division and 148th, which I think is a great success story, by the way.

1035
01:43:36.444 --> 01:43:38.247
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for showing the before and after.

1036
01:43:39.164 --> 01:43:47.253
<v Mitch Green>That is a transformed intersection that has had meaningful safety improvements there, and it's a good model, so I appreciate that.

1037
01:43:47.319 --> 01:43:54.780
<v Mitch Green>But when I see this, I see that this is sourced from the Oregon Department of Transportation's crash reduction factor manual.

1038
01:43:54.845 --> 01:44:03.001
<v Mitch Green>So these coefficients, these parameters are designed to think about being applicable basically anywhere, is that right?

1039
01:44:03.048 --> 01:44:07.011
<v Mitch Green>It's not just localized to Southeast Division at 148th?

1040
01:44:07.780 --> 01:44:08.422
<v Ting Lu>Correct.

1041
01:44:08.743 --> 01:44:15.625
<v Wendy Cully>And most of the reduction factors in ODOT's manual are from the FHWA.

1042
01:44:16.057 --> 01:44:22.569
<v Wendy Cully>They have a website called Crash Modification Clearinghouse or Factor Clearinghouse that has many of these.

1043
01:44:22.634 --> 01:44:24.814
<v Wendy Cully>So they'll cite that in their manual.

1044
01:44:24.960 --> 01:44:29.578
<v Wendy Cully>But they've come up with some things that we do in Oregon that maybe other jurisdictions aren't doing.

1045
01:44:30.176 --> 01:44:30.515
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1046
01:44:30.596 --> 01:44:55.515
<v Mitch Green>So that means that even if we're looking at, you know, downtown Portland, Southwest 4th Avenue, if you will, if I'm looking at the first line curb extensions, I should expect that the data would suggest that on average, putting in a curb extension as an improvement would reduce all crashes by 30%, controlling for all other factors.

1047
01:44:55.564 --> 01:44:55.677
<v Mitch Green>Correct.

1048
01:44:56.533 --> 01:44:56.983
<v Wendy Cully>That's correct.

1049
01:44:57.175 --> 01:45:13.667
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so I just needed to say that because I— you'll hear sometimes at this dais that, and I think it channels some sort of a kind of grumpiness out there around changing how we do things and seeing— I think it's been described before as the Taj Mahals of intersections.

1050
01:45:14.341 --> 01:45:27.630
<v Mitch Green>But I think that if that grumpiness sort of translates into retrograde policymaking, then we would be basically saying, We were willing to tolerate 30% more crashes because we don't want to have the Taj Mahal of intersections.

1051
01:45:28.046 --> 01:45:29.636
<v Mitch Green>That's the way that I interpret that slide.

1052
01:45:29.733 --> 01:45:30.310
<v Mitch Green>Is that correct?

1053
01:45:31.176 --> 01:45:32.798
<v Wendy Cully>Yeah, it could be interpreted that way.

1054
01:45:32.943 --> 01:45:33.167
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1055
01:45:33.585 --> 01:45:35.206
<v Wendy Cully>I'll just add just a smidge more.

1056
01:45:35.270 --> 01:45:43.681
<v Wendy Cully>You can see under the crash type, like, we don't— the studies are very specific and they get very specific about the type of crash it will prevent.

1057
01:45:43.729 --> 01:45:47.341
<v Wendy Cully>So installing lighting isn't going to do much for daytime crashes, obviously, right?

1058
01:45:47.390 --> 01:45:48.994
<v Wendy Cully>So it's very specific about nighttime.

1059
01:45:49.396 --> 01:45:50.747
<v Wendy Cully>Pedestrian and bicycle crashes.

1060
01:45:51.244 --> 01:45:54.762
<v Wendy Cully>The bigger signal heads are very specific to the T-bone angle crashes, right?

1061
01:45:54.810 --> 01:45:57.381
<v Wendy Cully>So you can get very nuanced and layered.

1062
01:45:57.993 --> 01:46:06.251
<v Wendy Cully>And just for the wonks in the room, that these factors, you know, a lot of people will say like, well, that adds up to more than 100, so we shouldn't have any crashes.

1063
01:46:06.685 --> 01:46:07.712
<v Wendy Cully>It's multiplicative.

1064
01:46:08.114 --> 01:46:10.106
<v Mitch Green>Like, well, it's a holistic approach.

1065
01:46:10.604 --> 01:46:16.002
<v Mitch Green>Um, you're taking a systems approach on this, which kind of leads me to the other thing I wanted to sort of say thank you.

1066
01:46:16.148 --> 01:46:22.345
<v Mitch Green>We've had a lot of recent conversations around Vision Zero, which I think is extremely welcome.

1067
01:46:23.051 --> 01:46:37.293
<v Mitch Green>And the through line that I just want to emphasize here is if we're going to be successful in our Vision Zero goals and our reaffirmation as a body, then it's this holistic systems thinking that needs to be at every point in our planning process.

1068
01:46:37.840 --> 01:46:56.175
<v Mitch Green>And I'm encouraged that I'm hearing that you guys are thinking about it that way, and that our job up here is to make sure that we are reflecting that back out and uplifting the importance of that work and holding the line when we do it well and being willing to talk to this council when we need more support.

1069
01:46:56.847 --> 01:47:00.744
<v Millicent Williams>Councilor Green, if I may add, thanks, Wendy, for that explanation.

1070
01:47:01.819 --> 01:47:26.091
<v Millicent Williams>To your point around some perception of excess It is informed by the folks around this table and others about what is not just a best practice, but what is most practical in the spaces that you see those improvements being made in.

1071
01:47:27.182 --> 01:47:32.288
<v Millicent Williams>To the naked eye, to an untrained resident who's walking along or using it, it may not look like much.

1072
01:47:32.801 --> 01:47:35.063
<v Millicent Williams>And I'll use the ADA ramps as an example.

1073
01:47:35.448 --> 01:47:36.506
<v Millicent Williams>It may seem excessive.

1074
01:47:37.131 --> 01:47:48.564
<v Millicent Williams>There's a reason why it chases back as far down the block as it does, because the slope is important for a person who is trying to use a mobility device to mount a curb and be able to move about the city safely.

1075
01:47:48.613 --> 01:48:17.532
<v Millicent Williams>So we recognize that sometimes our work is perceived as being excessive and that our process is onerous, but it is not without and it is not without intentionality in our effort to ensure that we're providing the best experience for system users and that we're providing the greatest clarity about how these improvements actually do impact the quality of life for Portlanders.

1076
01:48:18.126 --> 01:48:19.088
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

1077
01:48:19.314 --> 01:48:22.622
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, change is hard.

1078
01:48:23.184 --> 01:48:30.826
<v Mitch Green>I know that the first time I tried to take a left turn on Jefferson after the completed concrete barrier bike lane was there.

1079
01:48:30.875 --> 01:48:33.828
<v Unidentified speaker>It was a little bit of a, am I doing this right?

1080
01:48:33.940 --> 01:48:34.921
<v Mitch Green>Am I gonna screw this up?

1081
01:48:35.001 --> 01:48:37.377
<v Mitch Green>Am I gonna get written about in the Willamette Week about this one?

1082
01:48:37.618 --> 01:48:39.962
<v Mitch Green>Yes, all of those kinds of things.

1083
01:48:40.106 --> 01:48:40.814
<v Mitch Green>All those things.

1084
01:48:41.167 --> 01:48:43.961
<v Mitch Green>I know as a cyclist when I'm there, I feel much safer.

1085
01:48:44.698 --> 01:48:46.819
<v Mitch Green>And so thank you for this.

1086
01:48:47.670 --> 01:48:49.243
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for the presentation and keep them coming.

1087
01:48:49.515 --> 01:48:49.837
<v Nancy Thorington>Thanks.

1088
01:48:50.078 --> 01:48:50.929
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1089
01:48:51.010 --> 01:48:56.444
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Green, I shared the same experience since I drive that every single day.

1090
01:48:57.009 --> 01:48:58.524
<v Olivia Clark>In fact, I've been meaning to talk to you about that.

1091
01:49:01.064 --> 01:49:03.244
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Kanal, I think you're next in the queue.

1092
01:49:04.036 --> 01:49:04.649
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1093
01:49:04.779 --> 01:49:06.118
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks everybody for the presentation.

1094
01:49:06.529 --> 01:49:14.043
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I first, I don't have a lot of questions about it, but I just wanted to say I really appreciate the walkthrough of that intersection and everything that was done there, but also how clear it was.

1095
01:49:15.967 --> 01:49:19.431
<v Sameer Kanal>My questions are more on a couple of the other things related to the action plan.

1096
01:49:20.141 --> 01:49:25.337
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and but before I get to that, I'll just say, um, note for on Reddit, I think it's actually this week technically.

1097
01:49:25.402 --> 01:49:27.112
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think we've voted on the final vote.

1098
01:49:27.176 --> 01:49:28.240
<v Sameer Kanal>Is tomorrow the after?

1099
01:49:28.305 --> 01:49:28.451
<v Sameer Kanal>Tomorrow.

1100
01:49:28.869 --> 01:49:29.032
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1101
01:49:29.579 --> 01:49:34.371
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so, uh, I, I love the, the, uh, initiative and the, the, uh, support.

1102
01:49:34.420 --> 01:49:38.090
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted, for anyone who's wondering if they missed it online, I just wanted to get that out of the way.

1103
01:49:40.532 --> 01:49:41.695
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I wanted to ask 3 things.

1104
01:49:41.744 --> 01:49:47.618
<v Sameer Kanal>So first off, you on slide 8, you talk I just wanted to talk about a couple things related to safe vehicles.

1105
01:49:47.667 --> 01:49:48.773
<v Sameer Kanal>There's nothing there about weight.

1106
01:49:49.092 --> 01:49:51.208
<v Sameer Kanal>Everything, like the solution is all about speed.

1107
01:49:51.978 --> 01:49:55.135
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is going to lead into a different question I have on the speed side.

1108
01:49:55.198 --> 01:49:59.909
<v Sameer Kanal>But on the weight side, I think this is mirrored in the action plan itself.

1109
01:50:00.470 --> 01:50:05.582
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's page 40 of the action plan, the '23-'25 update.

1110
01:50:06.176 --> 01:50:15.744
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a lot there about under the safe vehicles section about how Washington, D.C. raised the annual registration fee for heavier vehicles.

1111
01:50:17.510 --> 01:50:26.466
<v Sameer Kanal>We have pickups bigger than some apartments in this city rolling around in parts of my district, and those have much higher safety risks in a collision.

1112
01:50:28.385 --> 01:50:31.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Higher, heavier, larger, et cetera, et cetera.

1113
01:50:32.182 --> 01:50:35.488
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm just curious what the— I understand that state's got to be involved in this.

1114
01:50:35.554 --> 01:50:49.457
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not something we can do solo, but what is the current status of conversation either through the ODOT side or through the state legislature side on anything with relation to weight and size of vehicles?

1115
01:50:51.216 --> 01:50:51.900
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

1116
01:50:52.046 --> 01:50:53.136
<v Clay Vacca>I'd be happy to take that.

1117
01:50:53.430 --> 01:50:56.163
<v Clay Vacca>And Shoshana, you may want to also join.

1118
01:50:57.555 --> 01:51:01.011
<v Clay Vacca>As a Vision Zero team, we— I really appreciate that.

1119
01:51:01.180 --> 01:51:02.557
<v Clay Vacca>Thank you for that question, Councilor Kanal.

1120
01:51:03.038 --> 01:51:09.931
<v Clay Vacca>It's, um, weight and size of vehicles is something that we as a city of Portland don't have a lot of influence over.

1121
01:51:10.493 --> 01:51:20.577
<v Clay Vacca>Um, we do have kind of a short wish list of safety measures, um, that would, would be wonderful for the state legislature to take on.

1122
01:51:21.090 --> 01:51:43.170
<v Clay Vacca>One of those is looking at kind of DC-style, um, kind of funding structure for registration of heavier, bigger vehicles and making some, some kind of monetary disincentives for that, of course, with considerations for large vehicles that are necessary for, for kind of particular functions.

1123
01:51:44.880 --> 01:52:05.407
<v Clay Vacca>And so it's, it's kind of identified as a hope at some point, but hasn't quite made it onto a more concrete I do want to say that within the safe vehicle space, places that we as a city do have more agency are with our own city fleet.

1124
01:52:05.568 --> 01:52:30.743
<v Clay Vacca>And we have a really great city fleet kind of program that is kind of exploring with us right now how to use the new telematics that were recently installed on all city vehicles to consider intelligent speed assistance, Or kind of monitoring safe driving behaviors and helping encourage kind of following the speed limit, limiting hard braking.

1125
01:52:31.979 --> 01:52:46.488
<v Clay Vacca>We've also done a little bit of exploring of the kind of visibility impediments in large cabs, and is there an opportunity for some kind of higher visibility cabs as we look at electrification?

1126
01:52:46.617 --> 01:52:50.373
<v Clay Vacca>So So there's kind of some explorations underway in that space.

1127
01:52:50.488 --> 01:53:03.988
<v Clay Vacca>And then finally, the federal government through the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration regulates vehicle safety and has kind of that 5-star rating system.

1128
01:53:04.037 --> 01:53:32.296
<v Clay Vacca>And so over the years, including recently just a couple of weeks ago, we've had the opportunity to submit comments about being able to kind of improve what safety requirements there are in order to get that 5-star rating that tells customers who are interested in a vehicle, this is kind of a, you know, kind of a really safe vehicle choice for your purchase.

1129
01:53:32.956 --> 01:53:38.399
<v Clay Vacca>And so those are different ways that we've either explored or directly engaged in vehicle safety.

1130
01:53:40.534 --> 01:53:42.078
<v Wendy Cully>Shoshana Cohen, PBOT Chief of Staff.

1131
01:53:42.221 --> 01:53:47.490
<v Millicent Williams>I'll just add very briefly that, as you know, the vehicle registration fee is set by the state.

1132
01:53:47.988 --> 01:54:00.729
<v Wendy Cully>And in this next conversation about a 2027 legislative transportation package, there are going to be conversations about changing the vehicle registration fee and basing it on something like size or weight.

1133
01:54:01.243 --> 01:54:03.090
<v Sameer Kanal>It is something that comes up perennially.

1134
01:54:03.185 --> 01:54:16.710
<v Sameer Kanal>So far it hasn't gained that much traction, but there are Yeah, I appreciate both answers and thanks for coming up, Shoshana.

1135
01:54:16.710 --> 01:54:22.560
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I think for me, the cost element of it is the compromise.

1136
01:54:22.989 --> 01:54:31.869
<v Sameer Kanal>I would prefer to just get every overcompensator 5,000 off the road just in general and get to that place unless there's a unless way to do it in there's a more efficient way.

1137
01:54:31.869 --> 01:54:31.890
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1138
01:54:31.997 --> 01:54:33.345
<v Sameer Kanal>A legitimate business need, of course.

1139
01:54:34.421 --> 01:54:38.002
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think that's a broader conversation.

1140
01:54:38.579 --> 01:54:51.393
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also think that the bottom left of this slide has fast, reliable transit, which is another thing, because often we're stuck in the position of we're just gonna talk about walking and biking and because we don't have control.

1141
01:54:51.440 --> 01:54:57.109
<v Sameer Kanal>But transit is the thing that can, for every human being out there, actually achieve that regardless of income.

1142
01:54:57.189 --> 01:55:02.916
<v Sameer Kanal>Regardless of their mobility or anything else, I do note a lot.

1143
01:55:02.980 --> 01:55:04.855
<v Sameer Kanal>Similarly, a lot of what we're talking about is tech.

1144
01:55:05.002 --> 01:55:12.036
<v Sameer Kanal>I have absolutely no concern about putting those sorts of things on city vehicles, but in terms of private vehicles, I have concerns about that.

1145
01:55:12.180 --> 01:55:13.912
<v Sameer Kanal>Automatic braking is one of the things mentioned.

1146
01:55:14.042 --> 01:55:14.738
<v Sameer Kanal>Great, love it.

1147
01:55:15.595 --> 01:55:21.751
<v Sameer Kanal>But a lot of the rest of it is just basically backdoors to surveillance, and I'm trying to there are trade-offs to every policy, right?

1148
01:55:21.931 --> 01:55:22.608
<v Sameer Kanal>Some of them is just.

1149
01:55:23.193 --> 01:55:26.567
<v Sameer Kanal>And you're weighing like, oh, it's $40,000 to do this, or it's a human life.

1150
01:55:26.631 --> 01:55:27.610
<v Sameer Kanal>That's an easy trade-off.

1151
01:55:28.092 --> 01:55:31.997
<v Sameer Kanal>There is a cost, which is money, but a human life is worth way more, obviously.

1152
01:55:32.720 --> 01:55:42.458
<v Sameer Kanal>Some of the rest of it, I think where we start talking about, you know, how are we creating a surveillance state, is a— is to me a much larger cost than I want to avoid.

1153
01:55:44.681 --> 01:55:45.720
<v Sameer Kanal>So that was the long one.

1154
01:55:46.157 --> 01:55:49.252
<v Sameer Kanal>The other 2 questions I had, one is, and I've asked this before.

1155
01:55:49.396 --> 01:55:53.265
<v Sameer Kanal>Do we have the rate by VMT on these streets?

1156
01:55:53.907 --> 01:56:04.868
<v Sameer Kanal>Every— as you look at the maps of all the higher injury, high crash corridors, whatever terminology, it is also very similar to the heaviest trafficked roads total.

1157
01:56:05.319 --> 01:56:20.199
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm interested in understanding if we do the type of infrastructure that gets people off of those roads, for example, the road diet that happened west of I-5 on Lombard moved a lot of traffic off that road to Willamette.

1158
01:56:21.099 --> 01:56:27.184
<v Sameer Kanal>And with that traffic came greater levels of, or higher levels of crashes.

1159
01:56:28.180 --> 01:56:33.527
<v Sameer Kanal>Now with more bicyclists involved because Willamette is a heavily biked road.

1160
01:56:34.055 --> 01:56:43.804
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm trying to understand, is it because of the design exclusively or is it because of the nature of of, um, just heavier traffic means more, um, likelihood.

1161
01:56:44.542 --> 01:56:49.939
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and also, how do we fix it without moving it?

1162
01:56:50.983 --> 01:56:52.364
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I'm trying to understand that.

1163
01:56:52.444 --> 01:56:56.845
<v Sameer Kanal>Do we have VMT-based rates for the, the high crash network?

1164
01:56:57.905 --> 01:57:01.953
<v Wendy Cully>I mean, hey, uh, we can both tackle it.

1165
01:57:02.612 --> 01:57:21.030
<v Wendy Cully>What I was gonna, uh, share is that we used to do rate-based we did the crash rates on our high crash— at that time it wasn't called the High Crash Network, but we did provide or produce a high crash intersection listing based on crash rates.

1166
01:57:21.528 --> 01:57:29.555
<v Wendy Cully>Many of those intersections that showed up 20 years ago based on the rate analysis still show up based on the severity analysis that we're looking at now.

1167
01:57:29.731 --> 01:57:35.340
<v Wendy Cully>So there is somewhat of a correlation, and Clay, you can speak to this a little bit more.

1168
01:57:35.404 --> 01:57:40.243
<v Wendy Cully>And then as far as like, how do we make safety improvements without shifting people?

1169
01:57:40.917 --> 01:57:44.922
<v Wendy Cully>I'd say that that doesn't happen most of the time.

1170
01:57:45.034 --> 01:57:55.690
<v Wendy Cully>It can happen, but we've done other road diets like on Division between 60th and 80th where volumes actually went up on Division after we did the lane reduction from 4 to 3.

1171
01:57:56.716 --> 01:57:59.617
<v Wendy Cully>And we try to analyze that before we make the changes.

1172
01:57:59.680 --> 01:57:59.777
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

1173
01:58:00.082 --> 01:58:02.168
<v Wendy Cully>And say, like, where do we think people will go?

1174
01:58:02.346 --> 01:58:03.332
<v Wendy Cully>What do our models show?

1175
01:58:03.462 --> 01:58:04.253
<v Wendy Cully>Are they diverting?

1176
01:58:04.787 --> 01:58:10.805
<v Wendy Cully>If we do think they are diverting, what can we do to either prevent that or mitigate that by slowing people down?

1177
01:58:10.917 --> 01:58:11.519
<v Wendy Cully>Things like that.

1178
01:58:11.582 --> 01:58:21.212
<v Wendy Cully>So I would say for the most part, we don't see much migration when we do our safety improvements, but it just depends on what the treatment is.

1179
01:58:23.275 --> 01:58:29.319
<v Clay Vacca>And to answer your question directly, we don't do much rate-based crash analysis work.

1180
01:58:29.788 --> 01:58:32.694
<v Clay Vacca>The one place where that shows up is in our high-crash intersections.

1181
01:58:33.590 --> 01:58:36.930
<v Clay Vacca>Those do take ADT into account.

1182
01:58:38.505 --> 01:59:10.619
<v Clay Vacca>And on our kind of corridors and segments, I think Wendy mentioned we used to— we've shifted away from that because we're really looking at— we're really wanting to know what are the segments recognizing that that's really kind of saving lives and reducing those injuries, where can we get the most kind of safety benefit for the investment?

1183
01:59:11.329 --> 01:59:46.832
<v Unidentified speaker>So if we have a street that has, you know, 5,000 ADT and 3 serious injuries, and then we compare it to a street that street has 1,000 ADT and 10 serious injuries, with 20,000 ADT and maybe, you know, 8 serious injuries and a traffic death, we would not want to necessarily kind of have the street that has had more injury and death get kind of lower on a priority list and have a street with lower ADT kind of get that bump up for prioritization.

1184
01:59:47.506 --> 01:59:50.942
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we've done some recently.

1185
01:59:51.600 --> 02:00:03.122
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't use that as a practice, but would be, you know, very amenable to kind of understanding what you would like to know more and doing some work to get you the answers you're looking for.

1186
02:00:03.652 --> 02:00:04.823
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, I appreciate that.

1187
02:00:04.872 --> 02:00:08.707
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's a really good example, those numbers that you just gave.

1188
02:00:08.948 --> 02:00:27.323
<v Sameer Kanal>I think what I'm trying to get at is, Is if we were to reduce the ADT on the heavier traffic street by moving it to the more risky but lower traffic street, are we actually, like, I don't care where the names on the map show up.

1189
02:00:27.386 --> 02:00:29.551
<v Sameer Kanal>I just don't want the names on the map, right?

1190
02:00:29.872 --> 02:00:30.465
<v Sameer Kanal>I know we all do.

1191
02:00:30.753 --> 02:00:32.837
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not a unique thing to me.

1192
02:00:32.902 --> 02:00:33.960
<v Sameer Kanal>That's, we all believe that.

1193
02:00:34.904 --> 02:00:36.877
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm trying to figure that part out.

1194
02:00:38.351 --> 02:00:40.338
<v Sameer Kanal>I also appreciate the comment about division.

1195
02:00:40.613 --> 02:00:42.170
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe you.

1196
02:00:42.234 --> 02:00:43.305
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't represent that area.

1197
02:00:43.434 --> 02:00:48.248
<v Sameer Kanal>I do represent and I live off of that stretch of Lombard, so I've experienced this.

1198
02:00:49.931 --> 02:00:53.179
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also think it's a pretty big difference between going from 4 to 3 and 2 to 1.

1199
02:00:53.869 --> 02:01:04.145
<v Sameer Kanal>That getting where you can't change lanes and people start looking for the less trafficked street to go and get where they need to go, that's the concern I have.

1200
02:01:04.354 --> 02:01:06.078
<v Sameer Kanal>If you go from 3 lanes in a single direction, Yeah.

1201
02:01:06.382 --> 02:01:13.609
<v Sameer Kanal>4 To 3, you can still do what you gotta do, but there's that feeling of the sort of driver psychology of, I'm gonna get around this traffic.

1202
02:01:13.752 --> 02:01:20.672
<v Sameer Kanal>And for people on Lombard, it has historically been going to either Columbia or Willamette.

1203
02:01:22.037 --> 02:01:25.265
<v Sameer Kanal>And Willamette is not, although I will say historically has not been built for that.

1204
02:01:25.314 --> 02:01:28.894
<v Sameer Kanal>There's actually been a lot done on Willamette recently, and I do wanna credit you for that.

1205
02:01:30.050 --> 02:01:41.337
<v Sameer Kanal>Last thing, Has traffic circles been a conversation recently, and specifically on Prescott, 60th, Cully, that 5-way intersection?

1206
02:01:42.011 --> 02:01:46.813
<v Sameer Kanal>I am very interested in the conversation of how to make that intersection work better.

1207
02:01:47.470 --> 02:01:54.118
<v Sameer Kanal>I get a lot of input into my office about it, among thousands of other things, of course, but that one I think gets a lot.

1208
02:01:54.213 --> 02:02:00.072
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm curious, not only from the perspective of that intersection, But just in general where the traffic circle conversation has been.

1209
02:02:02.041 --> 02:02:03.462
<v Wendy Cully>Yeah, traffic circles.

1210
02:02:03.655 --> 02:02:08.597
<v Wendy Cully>I assume you mean the bigger ones that are like roundabouts, like at Halsey and 80th, the picture we showed?

1211
02:02:09.065 --> 02:02:12.347
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I don't know if it would actually be round per se in that one.

1212
02:02:12.461 --> 02:02:12.783
<v Sameer Kanal>It can be.

1213
02:02:12.864 --> 02:02:16.889
<v Sameer Kanal>This one would be more of an oval, I feel like, just looking at that, the map on it and as you drive around.

1214
02:02:16.969 --> 02:02:17.243
<v Sameer Kanal>But yeah.

1215
02:02:17.613 --> 02:02:20.532
<v Wendy Cully>Yeah, yeah, they can be different shapes for sure.

1216
02:02:20.773 --> 02:02:24.965
<v Wendy Cully>But yeah, the bigger ones, we would like to do more of those in the city.

1217
02:02:25.029 --> 02:02:28.082
<v Wendy Cully>It's a little bit challenging sometimes to be able Small right-of-ways.

1218
02:02:28.130 --> 02:02:32.050
<v Wendy Cully>We have buildings built to back of sidewalk, but we would like to do more of those.

1219
02:02:32.145 --> 02:02:36.949
<v Wendy Cully>They're safer than traffic signals and a lot of the other treatments that we put in.

1220
02:02:37.864 --> 02:02:40.452
<v Wendy Cully>I don't know specifically about the intersection that you're talking about.

1221
02:02:40.515 --> 02:02:48.323
<v Wendy Cully>That doesn't— I don't know of anything in my head about a project there, but it is something that we want to consider.

1222
02:02:48.387 --> 02:02:53.962
<v Wendy Cully>And Clay and I have been talking about creating guidance for roundabouts and when to consider roundabouts.

1223
02:02:54.011 --> 02:02:54.139
<v Clay Vacca>Thank you.

1224
02:02:54.412 --> 02:02:59.403
<v Wendy Cully>We have looked at them at multiple intersections, trying to again install more.

1225
02:03:00.189 --> 02:03:01.472
<v Wendy Cully>Did you want to add anything else?

1226
02:03:01.778 --> 02:03:02.034
<v Olivia Clark>Great.

1227
02:03:02.340 --> 02:03:16.046
<v Millicent Williams>Councilor, we can go back and, and see if there are any current plans to do work in the location that you've identified, uh, to determine if there's a potential path forward for us to consider doing something alternative to what we have historically done.

1228
02:03:16.639 --> 02:03:18.757
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, and it doesn't need to be a traffic circle there either.

1229
02:03:18.805 --> 02:03:20.217
<v Sameer Kanal>These are 2 separate but related questions.

1230
02:03:20.314 --> 02:03:20.555
<v Millicent Williams>Absolutely.

1231
02:03:20.957 --> 02:03:21.390
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1232
02:03:21.438 --> 02:03:22.176
<v Olivia Clark>I'm glad you brought that up.

1233
02:03:22.256 --> 02:03:22.722
<v Olivia Clark>That's great.

1234
02:03:23.204 --> 02:03:25.002
<v Olivia Clark>A couple quick questions from me.

1235
02:03:25.453 --> 02:03:29.242
<v Olivia Clark>Um, the— thank you so much for giving us the example.

1236
02:03:29.787 --> 02:03:31.409
<v Olivia Clark>Um, how much did that cost?

1237
02:03:31.569 --> 02:03:36.354
<v Olivia Clark>Can you give us the cumulative cost of all of those improvements on that example?

1238
02:03:37.350 --> 02:03:40.882
<v Wendy Cully>I don't know if I could give you a cost of all of them because they were phased in.

1239
02:03:41.108 --> 02:03:54.082
<v Wendy Cully>I will just say the very first thing we did that we didn't even talk about was that slip lane where Renee was killed was— there wasn't even a stop sign there when she was killed.

1240
02:03:54.130 --> 02:04:02.978
<v Wendy Cully>So we put in a stop sign, we added a marked crosswalk, and that was something that we did within like 2 months and probably cost at the time $2,000.

1241
02:04:03.701 --> 02:04:06.029
<v Wendy Cully>So that was the very first thing we did in response.

1242
02:04:06.092 --> 02:04:17.597
<v Wendy Cully>And then we got a grant from ODOT for maybe $200,000, I think it was, to install some of the concrete that you saw in the 2019 slide.

1243
02:04:18.940 --> 02:04:20.657
<v Wendy Cully>The next part was much more involved.

1244
02:04:20.738 --> 02:04:25.957
<v Wendy Cully>It was part of the Outer Division Safety Project and also Division Transit, and that was millions of dollars probably.

1245
02:04:26.070 --> 02:04:35.425
<v Wendy Cully>We rebuilt the signal, we added a lot of communication and fiber, and separated everything not only in space but in time with the traffic signal.

1246
02:04:36.949 --> 02:04:50.409
<v Wendy Cully>So, but a lot of the substantial improvements were made prior to that multimillion-dollar investment at the intersection, probably less than $1 million for sort of the first 2 levels of treatment that we installed.

1247
02:04:50.457 --> 02:04:59.824
<v Olivia Clark>We don't have a total figure for 148th, but I think it would be interesting for us to know what the price tags are generally on each of these kinds of improvements, just what they cost.

1248
02:05:00.619 --> 02:05:00.877
<v Wendy Cully>Yeah.

1249
02:05:01.391 --> 02:05:06.490
<v Olivia Clark>Second, we didn't talk at all about— I know what you call the speed cameras.

1250
02:05:06.779 --> 02:05:17.524
<v Olivia Clark>Did they play into anything that I know we want to do more of them in the high crash corridors, but where do they fit in Vision Zero?

1251
02:05:18.448 --> 02:05:20.814
<v Clay Vacca>They're a really key component to Vision Zero.

1252
02:05:20.895 --> 02:05:28.797
<v Clay Vacca>They've been a part of our kind of action plan process since the inception in 2015.

1253
02:05:29.234 --> 02:05:44.980
<v Clay Vacca>The City of Portland was successful at the legislature to get the very first speed cameras And since then, kind of expansion of the speed camera program is one of the kind of safe speed actions that we've really leaned into.

1254
02:05:46.122 --> 02:05:53.854
<v Clay Vacca>The kind of one of our colleagues manages that program and in close partnership with the Portland Police Bureau.

1255
02:05:55.474 --> 02:05:59.940
<v Clay Vacca>So it's an important component and we'd be happy to provide more information.

1256
02:05:59.988 --> 02:06:00.086
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

1257
02:06:00.560 --> 02:06:01.354
<v Olivia Clark>Didn't see it listed.

1258
02:06:01.452 --> 02:06:06.739
<v Olivia Clark>I just wonder where it fit, and, um, it seems like it should be an important component to Vision Zero.

1259
02:06:08.340 --> 02:06:09.609
<v Olivia Clark>Um, next question.

1260
02:06:10.429 --> 02:06:26.469
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I'm— I don't want to speak for Councilor Green, but in our district I get a lot of concerns about, um, lack of sidewalks and speed and, um, folks feeling unsafe and how come you guys don't do something about it.

1261
02:06:26.543 --> 02:06:28.148
<v Olivia Clark>Well, we have We haven't had any deaths here.

1262
02:06:28.777 --> 02:06:35.052
<v Olivia Clark>We're all, we're all waiting for somebody to die so that we can get an improvement from PBOT, which is really kind of sad.

1263
02:06:36.627 --> 02:06:46.039
<v Olivia Clark>But I'm just wondering, you know, I don't know, what is the likelihood that residents could actually do something there?

1264
02:06:46.282 --> 02:06:46.475
<v Olivia Clark>Or—.

1265
02:06:46.912 --> 02:06:50.503
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm thinking of the, you know, Vista way out.

1266
02:06:51.319 --> 02:06:53.975
<v Olivia Clark>You know, I like your, your transition from rural to urban.

1267
02:06:54.472 --> 02:06:57.170
<v Olivia Clark>That's kind of what's going on in some places in District 4.

1268
02:06:58.181 --> 02:07:05.247
<v Olivia Clark>But I mean, how do we respond to these people that have asked for help, have asked for one of those— what's it called?

1269
02:07:06.274 --> 02:07:06.371
<v Loretta Smith>The—.

1270
02:07:07.238 --> 02:07:07.622
<v Nancy Thorington>What's it called?

1271
02:07:07.751 --> 02:07:08.457
<v Wendy Cully>Speed reader board?

1272
02:07:08.698 --> 02:07:09.292
<v Unidentified speaker>Speed reader.

1273
02:07:09.806 --> 02:07:12.439
<v Olivia Clark>Get the speed reader up to try to slow people down.

1274
02:07:12.938 --> 02:07:17.914
<v Olivia Clark>I know, how do we respond to these folks that, well, we haven't had anybody die yet, so we're not getting any attention?

1275
02:07:20.203 --> 02:07:28.552
<v Wendy Cully>Yeah, I, I think, uh, one of the ways that we respond is with the systemic treatments that we're, um, layering out throughout the system.

1276
02:07:29.149 --> 02:07:33.036
<v Wendy Cully>Um, a really great example is the flashing yellow arrows.

1277
02:07:33.394 --> 02:07:37.797
<v Wendy Cully>I don't know, you know, when you're waiting to turn left, usually there's a red arrow or a green arrow.

1278
02:07:38.104 --> 02:07:39.783
<v Wendy Cully>Sometimes there's a flashing yellow arrow.

1279
02:07:39.945 --> 02:07:51.345
<v Wendy Cully>We have taken those almost exclusively out of the system because It's very hard to eliminate pedestrian conflicts, right?

1280
02:07:51.409 --> 02:07:54.838
<v Wendy Cully>When pedestrians are crossing, you have a flashing yellow arrow, that's not a good thing.

1281
02:07:56.090 --> 02:07:58.917
<v Wendy Cully>So we're doing those, taking those out of the system.

1282
02:07:59.176 --> 02:08:05.154
<v Wendy Cully>Again, we're doing the systemic improvements where we're relamping our signals, putting in the reflective backplates.

1283
02:08:05.630 --> 02:08:07.953
<v Wendy Cully>Those don't, you know, we're doing those proactively.

1284
02:08:08.019 --> 02:08:09.904
<v Wendy Cully>We're not only doing those where there are—.

1285
02:08:10.131 --> 02:08:10.521
<v Nancy Thorington>Yeah.

1286
02:08:11.356 --> 02:08:13.185
<v Wendy Cully>Crashes or serious injuries.

1287
02:08:13.377 --> 02:08:20.576
<v Wendy Cully>I think sidewalks is harder, a harder thing to address because they're so expensive, um, that, that's hard to do systemically.

1288
02:08:21.377 --> 02:08:25.082
<v Olivia Clark>Um, does painting stripes, or does that help?

1289
02:08:25.546 --> 02:08:26.813
<v Wendy Cully>Um, it can depending.

1290
02:08:26.909 --> 02:08:43.457
<v Wendy Cully>We do have in Southwest in Motion, um, some treatments in there for striped shoulders for pedestrians that have either plastic delineators or concrete curbing that kind of creates just a separate we've done a little bit of that on Southwest Barber as you approach downtown.

1291
02:08:43.521 --> 02:08:56.081
<v Wendy Cully>We've done it on BH Highway where it would have been a very expensive project to get in full proper sidewalks, but we did create a concrete separated space for pedestrians by narrowing traffic lanes.

1292
02:08:56.225 --> 02:09:05.752
<v Wendy Cully>So we are looking at that more often, and we know in Southwest in particular where you have grades and lack of drainage, those are really important treatments to lean into.

1293
02:09:05.815 --> 02:09:07.420
<v Wendy Cully>So Southwest in Motion really has some really good examples.

1294
02:09:07.469 --> 02:09:07.805
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1295
02:09:08.382 --> 02:09:15.088
<v Wendy Cully>Good information in there about how we can make pedestrian improvements without having to go to full sidewalks.

1296
02:09:15.265 --> 02:09:18.296
<v Olivia Clark>I think folks in District 4 are pretty familiar with Southwest in Motion.

1297
02:09:18.345 --> 02:09:20.671
<v Olivia Clark>It's just the implementation they're concerned about.

1298
02:09:20.735 --> 02:09:22.788
<v Olivia Clark>And what you did on Barber was fabulous.

1299
02:09:23.046 --> 02:09:24.201
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that.

1300
02:09:24.569 --> 02:09:25.180
<v Millicent Williams>Council, I just—.

1301
02:09:25.292 --> 02:09:34.099
<v Millicent Williams>I'd like to share that I think we've discussed the ways that our projects have heretofore been funded, especially those that are more transformational in nature.

1302
02:09:34.773 --> 02:09:36.824
<v Millicent Williams>That that funding comes from outside sources.

1303
02:09:37.016 --> 02:09:37.514
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1304
02:09:37.643 --> 02:09:55.695
<v Millicent Williams>Given that we now have the TUF and the street damage restoration fee and the dedication of that funding, some of that funding to SIP and other initiatives, we might be able to address some of the things that your community members, your constituents are calling you about.

1305
02:09:56.320 --> 02:09:57.667
<v Millicent Williams>We also receive the calls.

1306
02:09:58.725 --> 02:10:05.206
<v Millicent Williams>And inasmuch as I hate for our response to be, well, we don't have any money, to do the very basic thing.

1307
02:10:05.318 --> 02:10:10.567
<v Millicent Williams>That has been the heart of what has been the problem for us.

1308
02:10:11.320 --> 02:10:19.876
<v Millicent Williams>I agree that we should not have to wait for someone to be injured or worse on our streets or in our communities before we do something.

1309
02:10:20.470 --> 02:10:50.203
<v Millicent Williams>Unfortunately, we have not been able to have a proactive stance, and I'm looking forward to us being able to swing the pendulum in the opposite direction because we will be able to make thoughtful investment in areas regardless as to whether or not it is high crash, regardless as to whether or not it is in one part of town or another, but rather because there are people and human beings that are living, working, navigating in those spaces and deserve to have comfortable spaces in which to do that.

1310
02:10:51.359 --> 02:10:51.631
<v Olivia Clark>Well, thank you.

1311
02:10:51.695 --> 02:10:54.247
<v Olivia Clark>You gave me a couple of ideas to go back with.

1312
02:10:54.648 --> 02:11:13.422
<v Olivia Clark>Last question from me, and then I'll turn it over to Councilor Smith, is we've been having some conversations about autonomous vehicles here, and I just wonder if your team is involved in those conversations, because safety, I think, ranked as the number one issue when people were queried about autonomous vehicles.

1313
02:11:13.519 --> 02:11:16.828
<v Olivia Clark>And is this a part of your conversations as well?

1314
02:11:16.908 --> 02:11:18.481
<v Olivia Clark>Are you involved in those conversations?

1315
02:11:19.237 --> 02:11:19.542
<v Millicent Williams>Yes.

1316
02:11:20.024 --> 02:11:20.313
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

1317
02:11:20.537 --> 02:11:20.971
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, good.

1318
02:11:21.485 --> 02:11:22.819
<v Olivia Clark>All right, glad— good to know that.

1319
02:11:23.509 --> 02:11:33.744
<v Olivia Clark>Now I'm going to turn to Councilor Smith, and then we're going to— if we're done, we have a couple more hands up, we need to take a 10-minute break before we go to the next topic.

1320
02:11:34.338 --> 02:11:35.284
<v Olivia Clark>So just a heads up.

1321
02:11:35.605 --> 02:11:36.216
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith.

1322
02:11:36.552 --> 02:11:36.858
<v Nancy Thorington>Thank you.

1323
02:11:37.595 --> 02:11:42.617
<v Loretta Smith>I'm trying to get used to this microphone on the left, left-hand side.

1324
02:11:43.547 --> 02:11:48.859
<v Loretta Smith>So I just wanted to say thank you for giving that very expansive Thank you.

1325
02:11:48.908 --> 02:11:49.087
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mayor.

1326
02:11:49.153 --> 02:11:51.823
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to say thank you for the comprehensive definition of Vision Zero and all the things.

1327
02:11:53.605 --> 02:12:02.492
<v Loretta Smith>It's something that we have been very supportive of since day one that we started this new council.

1328
02:12:04.403 --> 02:12:14.052
<v Loretta Smith>And I think, you know, living in District 1 and seeing that we have a lot of the high Hi.

1329
02:12:14.118 --> 02:12:14.152
<v Ting Lu>Hi.

1330
02:12:14.201 --> 02:12:15.506
<v Loretta Smith>I'm a member of the Bike Crash Network in our district.

1331
02:12:16.735 --> 02:12:20.234
<v Loretta Smith>It has started me to think about different things that we can do.

1332
02:12:20.798 --> 02:12:27.442
<v Loretta Smith>So I just wanted to have a conversation about a couple of things that me and the chairwoman have talked about.

1333
02:12:27.717 --> 02:12:32.516
<v Loretta Smith>And she's been on my case because I haven't given her an updated ordinance on this.

1334
02:12:33.779 --> 02:12:46.391
<v Loretta Smith>But there were 4 things that we thought were would reduce the number of lives, fatalities, crash fatalities in District 1.

1335
02:12:47.229 --> 02:12:48.935
<v Loretta Smith>Right turn on red restrictions.

1336
02:12:49.000 --> 02:12:49.918
<v Loretta Smith>And so we worked on that.

1337
02:12:51.420 --> 02:12:57.002
<v Loretta Smith>The automatic walk cycles to implement automated default walk signals.

1338
02:12:57.131 --> 02:13:02.686
<v Loretta Smith>I know this is really expensive, but I can see Director Williams looking at me like, that's a lot of money.

1339
02:13:02.815 --> 02:13:03.720
<v Sameer Kanal>No, I'm searching my brain.

1340
02:13:03.769 --> 02:13:04.836
<v Millicent Williams>I'm searching my brain.

1341
02:13:05.417 --> 02:13:06.563
<v Millicent Williams>Yeah, but it is, yes.

1342
02:13:06.966 --> 02:13:12.414
<v Loretta Smith>And then the updated— to update the code on curb extensions.

1343
02:13:13.652 --> 02:13:18.627
<v Loretta Smith>And that's our next one that we're going to release that we'll be talking about in September.

1344
02:13:19.614 --> 02:13:38.462
<v Loretta Smith>Because we already have this mandate for the ADA mandates that we're doing on the curbs, and since we The code says that the curb extensions are not mandatory.

1345
02:13:39.440 --> 02:13:48.289
<v Loretta Smith>And so we want to change it to making it— it's voluntary, but you all do it more than not, but you don't have to.

1346
02:13:49.140 --> 02:13:59.622
<v Loretta Smith>And so we want to make sure that those curb extensions are put on, particularly now that we're doing the work for the ADA stuff that that we got approved for last year that we voted on.

1347
02:14:00.439 --> 02:14:01.819
<v Loretta Smith>And that's an issue.

1348
02:14:01.899 --> 02:14:09.591
<v Loretta Smith>And the lighting requirements mandating enhanced lighting for all the crosswalks to improve lighting citywide.

1349
02:14:10.006 --> 02:14:13.131
<v Loretta Smith>So that's a big, big deal.

1350
02:14:13.932 --> 02:14:21.000
<v Loretta Smith>But we thought that we would start with the curb extensions in light of the lawsuit that was put out.

1351
02:14:21.512 --> 02:14:21.786
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

1352
02:14:23.355 --> 02:14:29.274
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know when the lawsuit was, but I know we had to pay for it and we had to do an ordinance to do bonding on it.

1353
02:14:29.965 --> 02:14:30.686
<v Loretta Smith>Are you familiar with it?

1354
02:14:30.734 --> 02:14:30.911
<v Loretta Smith>I know—.

1355
02:14:31.552 --> 02:14:32.435
<v Millicent Williams>The Creek settlement?

1356
02:14:32.819 --> 02:14:33.011
<v Nancy Thorington>Yes.

1357
02:14:33.060 --> 02:14:33.846
<v Millicent Williams>The ADA settlement, yes.

1358
02:14:33.958 --> 02:14:34.889
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, yes, yes, yes.

1359
02:14:34.969 --> 02:14:39.588
<v Millicent Williams>That happened in 2017, and so we've been working to fulfill those expectations.

1360
02:14:39.636 --> 02:14:40.439
<v Loretta Smith>Exactly.

1361
02:14:40.487 --> 02:14:54.377
<v Millicent Williams>Since that time, many of the projects that we work on that are dedicated to us improving the ramps, there are instances when it is, the first path to include curb extensions.

1362
02:14:54.489 --> 02:14:54.682
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1363
02:14:55.275 --> 02:15:01.965
<v Millicent Williams>I would— I look forward to continuing to work with your office and with this committee on the language.

1364
02:15:02.029 --> 02:15:02.109
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1365
02:15:02.686 --> 02:15:08.814
<v Millicent Williams>Because I do think that there's some feasibility that needs to be considered as we talk about doing bump-outs and curb extensions.

1366
02:15:08.909 --> 02:15:18.085
<v Millicent Williams>There are places where, based on the amount of space, it may not be the option that we would need to go with.

1367
02:15:19.192 --> 02:15:26.731
<v Millicent Williams>I will say that generally speaking, our team leans in to do as much as is possible.

1368
02:15:26.957 --> 02:15:27.470
<v Muriel Geisa Teufel>I know you do.

1369
02:15:27.533 --> 02:15:28.144
<v Millicent Williams>To ensure the safety.

1370
02:15:28.512 --> 02:15:48.394
<v Millicent Williams>So I am not afraid of the language in terms of the mandate or the direction, as much as I want to make sure that we aren't overpromising Right.

1371
02:15:48.652 --> 02:15:52.215
<v Millicent Williams>So I would want to talk about the language there a little bit more.

1372
02:15:52.328 --> 02:15:52.586
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1373
02:15:52.730 --> 02:16:01.567
<v Loretta Smith>And that's what I wanted to talk about to see if we needed to put something— I'll give you the baseline ordinance that we've drafted.

1374
02:16:02.322 --> 02:16:05.855
<v Loretta Smith>We were going to put them out in like a group of 3.

1375
02:16:06.162 --> 02:16:09.925
<v Loretta Smith>And so we decided let's start with the no-turn-on-red first.

1376
02:16:10.872 --> 02:16:23.636
<v Loretta Smith>To get— make sure that we get it right and that we're able to talk to the community about it too, so that they can see, just like you had up here, you know, what does that do in terms of saving lives in our city.

1377
02:16:23.895 --> 02:16:27.257
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that's my goal.

1378
02:16:29.641 --> 02:16:31.703
<v Millicent Williams>And I appreciate the layered approach as well.

1379
02:16:31.766 --> 02:16:39.909
<v Millicent Williams>Just as we used the 148th Avenue example, we were able to layer on and so you talk about the curb extensions, you talk about the additional lighting.

1380
02:16:40.406 --> 02:16:46.105
<v Millicent Williams>All of those things are components that we know not just create safety, but make people actually feel safer.

1381
02:16:46.523 --> 02:16:46.828
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1382
02:16:47.084 --> 02:16:54.870
<v Millicent Williams>And safety in a lot of ways is about how a person feels, not just about what they physically experience in the right-of-way.

1383
02:16:54.967 --> 02:17:12.099
<v Millicent Williams>So we are excited about the opportunity to continue to talk about how we can help to inform that strategy, uh, and, uh, help to, uh, realize what I believe your goal is in terms of creating that safety and community.

1384
02:17:12.452 --> 02:17:16.434
<v Loretta Smith>And, and who in your office should I talk to, or should I send it to you first and you can—.

1385
02:17:16.852 --> 02:17:17.623
<v Millicent Williams>You can send it to me.

1386
02:17:17.816 --> 02:17:28.318
<v Millicent Williams>Uh, it'll be any number of us either around this table, uh, our planning team, so, uh, Kristen Hull, our engineering staff, uh, as well would need to be involved, and then our project manager.

1387
02:17:28.367 --> 02:17:29.572
<v Millicent Williams>So it's, it's a number of folks.

1388
02:17:29.636 --> 02:17:33.933
<v Millicent Williams>You can send it to me and we'll, we'll get it out So when are we doing the bonding?

1389
02:17:35.152 --> 02:17:38.934
<v Loretta Smith>When is that going to be on the docket to vote on that?

1390
02:17:39.559 --> 02:17:40.810
<v Millicent Williams>You've already approved—.

1391
02:17:40.859 --> 02:17:42.236
<v Loretta Smith>Did we do— so much is going on.

1392
02:17:42.286 --> 02:17:44.433
<v Loretta Smith>Is the $550— how much?

1393
02:17:45.731 --> 02:17:46.677
<v Loretta Smith>$550?

1394
02:17:47.495 --> 02:17:49.708
<v Millicent Williams>I am not sure about what you're talking about.

1395
02:17:49.755 --> 02:17:53.362
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so yeah, because I don't know what I'm talking about either.

1396
02:17:53.586 --> 02:17:54.195
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, great.

1397
02:17:54.565 --> 02:17:55.174
<v Loretta Smith>No, no, no.

1398
02:17:55.286 --> 02:17:57.513
<v Loretta Smith>So we already voted on that, right?

1399
02:17:58.478 --> 02:17:59.265
<v Loretta Smith>On the bonding?

1400
02:17:59.843 --> 02:18:00.614
<v Millicent Williams>Or the ramps.

1401
02:18:01.483 --> 02:18:02.686
<v Loretta Smith>Not the ramps.

1402
02:18:02.768 --> 02:18:05.561
<v Loretta Smith>No, no, no, no, for the water filtrations.

1403
02:18:05.948 --> 02:18:08.533
<v Millicent Williams>Oh, I bet that's— I don't know.

1404
02:18:09.320 --> 02:18:11.457
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, you're in PBOT.

1405
02:18:11.810 --> 02:18:12.131
<v Millicent Williams>That's right.

1406
02:18:12.405 --> 02:18:12.726
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1407
02:18:13.817 --> 02:18:14.379
<v Millicent Williams>Yes, ma'am.

1408
02:18:14.493 --> 02:18:15.601
<v Olivia Clark>Are you talking about SIP?

1409
02:18:16.260 --> 02:18:16.742
<v Loretta Smith>No, not SIP.

1410
02:18:16.806 --> 02:18:18.299
<v Olivia Clark>We didn't know the water bonds.

1411
02:18:18.476 --> 02:18:19.295
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, the water bonds.

1412
02:18:19.456 --> 02:18:21.399
<v Loretta Smith>We had that a couple weeks ago, didn't we?

1413
02:18:21.864 --> 02:18:22.877
<v Mitch Green>It was during the budget.

1414
02:18:22.989 --> 02:18:23.711
<v Loretta Smith>It was during the Oh, the budget.

1415
02:18:24.418 --> 02:18:24.594
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1416
02:18:24.933 --> 02:18:29.861
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm getting confused because you guys have so much stuff that you have going on in terms of infrastructure.

1417
02:18:30.777 --> 02:18:39.397
<v Loretta Smith>And I am really happy that we turned this into the Public Works Committee instead of just Transportation, even though we did see all the public works through Transportation.

1418
02:18:39.445 --> 02:18:44.551
<v Loretta Smith>But I think it's so important to make sure that we're clear on what's going on.

1419
02:18:45.129 --> 02:18:50.493
<v Loretta Smith>And I know that you all are doing great work, and I appreciate the work that you're doing.

1420
02:18:51.504 --> 02:18:59.183
<v Loretta Smith>If there's something that you think that we need to be doing and that you see that we need to change something, a code or something, let us know.

1421
02:19:00.548 --> 02:19:00.853
<v Olivia Clark>Just—.

1422
02:19:01.512 --> 02:19:02.653
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you, Councilor.

1423
02:19:03.135 --> 02:19:17.478
<v Millicent Williams>We've had in the past year and a half in our opportunity to work with this council more opportunities to provide information about what we're doing and a greater depth of information sharing.

1424
02:19:18.233 --> 02:19:23.356
<v Millicent Williams>So that you can be well-informed about our plans, our projects, our efforts.

1425
02:19:23.516 --> 02:19:23.629
<v Loretta Smith>Yep.

1426
02:19:24.335 --> 02:19:31.404
<v Millicent Williams>What we need most is continued support to be able to lean into and realize the plans that we've developed.

1427
02:19:32.512 --> 02:19:42.373
<v Millicent Williams>And as we shared at the top of this presentation, the changes that are going to be required in our communities are often hard for people to take and understand.

1428
02:19:42.582 --> 02:19:58.548
<v Millicent Williams>And so what we'll need most is your support to be able to engage with your constituencies to help them to understand it's not just about doing this for that, but rather it's really around a broader need to ensure safety for all system users.

1429
02:19:58.996 --> 02:19:59.093
<v Nancy Thorington>Yep.

1430
02:19:59.816 --> 02:20:08.013
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, we're running out of time here, so I'm gonna— if it's okay with you, Councilor Green, I'm gonna let Councilor Koyama Lane— okay, go for it.

1431
02:20:08.077 --> 02:20:09.009
<v Mitch Green>Okay, thanks.

1432
02:20:09.104 --> 02:20:22.092
<v Mitch Green>I just I just want to express support and interest in getting creative under the ORS 810 road authority clause, our existing allowances and authorities.

1433
02:20:22.189 --> 02:20:30.191
<v Mitch Green>I think we've got some pretty broad sweeping powers to regulate certain things on our highways.

1434
02:20:30.272 --> 02:20:33.397
<v Mitch Green>And if we can do it on our highways, it probably affects our surface roads too.

1435
02:20:33.477 --> 02:20:40.398
<v Mitch Green>And so I don't think I don't think that we should tolerate really, really high-lifted vehicles to operate in the City of Portland.

1436
02:20:41.058 --> 02:20:47.368
<v Mitch Green>And also, you know, they get too wide and it's like, you know, now you're taking up 2 parking spaces.

1437
02:20:47.432 --> 02:20:48.620
<v Mitch Green>It's just, it's a nuisance.

1438
02:20:49.165 --> 02:20:50.691
<v Mitch Green>And I think that we gotta do something about it.

1439
02:20:50.772 --> 02:20:53.115
<v Mitch Green>And I don't know that we need to change the law at the state to do it.

1440
02:20:53.292 --> 02:20:53.934
<v Mitch Green>So thanks.

1441
02:20:54.560 --> 02:20:57.210
<v Olivia Clark>Maybe we can ask PBOT to come back with something on that.

1442
02:20:57.789 --> 02:20:58.960
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1443
02:21:01.129 --> 02:21:04.004
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair, and thank you so much to this wonderful team.

1444
02:21:04.115 --> 02:21:09.272
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Director Williams and Shoshana, Clay, Wendy, Dana.

1445
02:21:10.122 --> 02:21:12.659
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Really appreciate all of your commitment and the work you're doing.

1446
02:21:12.852 --> 02:21:18.458
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I just remember a year and a half ago when I was first talking to many of you and I was asking, what does Vision Zero need?

1447
02:21:18.796 --> 02:21:22.699
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There was talk about, you know, needs to— we need support, exactly what you all are saying.

1448
02:21:22.746 --> 02:21:23.726
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We need you to back us up.

1449
02:21:23.790 --> 02:21:31.209
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We also need folks to know it's not just PBOT, and we need the different Oh, shoot.

1450
02:21:31.209 --> 02:21:31.659
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, there we go.

1451
02:21:31.809 --> 02:21:34.879
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Need the different bureaus and service areas to work together.

1452
02:21:35.250 --> 02:21:38.190
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I see us, you know, like, I appreciate what Director Williams said.

1453
02:21:38.200 --> 02:21:41.250
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's— this work takes time and we have to be persistent at it.

1454
02:21:41.250 --> 02:21:44.409
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's— we're seeing improvements, but we have to keep investing.

1455
02:21:45.030 --> 02:21:49.540
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I would love to hear from you all who are with us today.

1456
02:21:49.709 --> 02:21:53.129
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>If you— you know, I want to make sure that staff and subject matter experts are included in this conversation.

1457
02:21:56.059 --> 02:22:03.060
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What are the ways that we can maximize our dollars, our limited resources for traffic safety?

1458
02:22:04.045 --> 02:22:13.398
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What are ways that, that we as council and this committee can be better understanding, like, what to prioritize and what— how we're going to make sure that we're saving the most lives?

1459
02:22:15.370 --> 02:22:17.666
<v Clay Vacca>Really appreciate that question, Councilor.

1460
02:22:18.852 --> 02:22:27.930
<v Clay Vacca>There are systemic safety treatments that make sense across the board that, as Wendy was describing, kind of are just part of what we deliver today.

1461
02:22:28.557 --> 02:22:34.051
<v Clay Vacca>High visibility crossings, retroreflective backplates, leading pedestrian intervals.

1462
02:22:34.115 --> 02:22:42.052
<v Clay Vacca>There's kind of a whole suite of kind of systemic safety investments that don't take analysis to identify where to deliver.

1463
02:22:43.273 --> 02:23:01.531
<v Clay Vacca>And then there are kind of location-specific needs that it ends up needing some traffic safety analysis to identify what's going to be kind of the safest layering kind of suite of treatments that's going to get us the biggest safety benefit.

1464
02:23:02.221 --> 02:23:24.010
<v Clay Vacca>And so kind of leading with safety as the focus and giving some flexibility within the delivery of treatments to ensure that we're layering the right treatments for the right locations is going to be something that will help us kind of do, do the most safety good with the funding that we have.

1465
02:23:24.843 --> 02:23:25.421
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I appreciate it.

1466
02:23:25.468 --> 02:23:30.247
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I could hear Vice Chair Smith kind of asking, you know, how do we connect with you all?

1467
02:23:30.391 --> 02:23:35.316
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is it, is it really just reaching out to you all and saying, hey, can you help us look at some of these lists?

1468
02:23:35.427 --> 02:23:39.097
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can you help make sure that we're doing Making data-driven decisions.

1469
02:23:40.356 --> 02:23:41.050
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is that what I heard?

1470
02:23:41.453 --> 02:23:42.809
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, please do.

1471
02:23:44.435 --> 02:24:04.836
<v Millicent Williams>One of the things I wanted to share, and I know that we often hear from city councilors about constituents coming forward with concerns and needs, they have often come to us as well, and we've already begun to track some of the inquiries, requests, and analyze the needs and how we might be able to be responsive.

1472
02:24:05.816 --> 02:24:16.540
<v Millicent Williams>Um, for each of the districts, I would dare say that there are hundreds of requests for things that come in, and, uh, we have the ability to provide for you that list.

1473
02:24:16.893 --> 02:24:37.468
<v Millicent Williams>I know that in working with, um, at least Councilor Green on a specific, uh, set of needs, um, we shared with him, yes, this is important, but here are the 300 other things that, um, happened, um, uh, in this in the span of a year that— or that not that happened, but that we've heard from folks on.

1474
02:24:37.820 --> 02:24:43.871
<v Millicent Williams>And so this is not to suggest that, you know, it comes in, it goes to the bottom of the list, it's not important.

1475
02:24:43.920 --> 02:24:44.851
<v Millicent Williams>That's not what I'm saying.

1476
02:24:45.284 --> 02:24:52.972
<v Millicent Williams>What I am saying is that there are hundreds, if not more than hundreds, of needs that we're hearing about on a regular basis.

1477
02:24:53.293 --> 02:24:57.049
<v Millicent Williams>And we will need the help in prioritizing.

1478
02:24:57.547 --> 02:25:06.449
<v Millicent Williams>And we do want to be able to lean in to help you as you are thinking about how we can support community most effectively.

1479
02:25:06.545 --> 02:25:09.308
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so much for that, Director Williams.

1480
02:25:09.372 --> 02:25:17.183
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I really appreciate it, and I appreciate that you all have a lot of the staff with that expertise that we can lean on for helping to make some of those decisions.

1481
02:25:17.487 --> 02:25:20.829
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My only other question was around collaboration and communication.

1482
02:25:20.878 --> 02:25:40.075
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was wondering if maybe Director Williams or anyone up there can speak to how PBOT is working with other bureaus and with Dana doing the citywide work on policy, on priorities, having conversations so we can understand what the priorities are from, from the different bureaus, from other disciplines, not just transportation.

1483
02:25:40.171 --> 02:25:46.567
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That is an important one in Vision Zero, and it's not also just all on PBOT too.

1484
02:25:47.322 --> 02:25:58.975
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We have to make sure that there's collaboration and other bureaus' service areas are invested in see themselves as Vision Zero, part of the Vision Zero champions table and teams also.

1485
02:25:59.039 --> 02:26:01.513
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So can you speak a little bit to that?

1486
02:26:02.427 --> 02:26:03.825
<v Clay Vacca>I'll take that one.

1487
02:26:03.922 --> 02:26:04.645
<v Clay Vacca>Thank you, Councilor.

1488
02:26:04.725 --> 02:26:05.495
<v Clay Vacca>Great question.

1489
02:26:06.653 --> 02:26:17.190
<v Clay Vacca>The work that Dana is leading out of the Public Works service area really is, as you know as well as anyone, that is kind of the body of work.

1490
02:26:18.137 --> 02:26:23.458
<v Clay Vacca>And PBOT is a core partner of that citywide effort as well.

1491
02:26:23.682 --> 02:26:31.985
<v Clay Vacca>And so we're kind of developing relationships and partnerships to identify priorities collaboratively.

1492
02:26:32.641 --> 02:26:57.224
<v Clay Vacca>One thing that Dana presented at the Committee of the Whole 2 weeks ago is a safe system approach pyramid that the bottom layer of the pyramid is where we get kind of the most benefit of kind of population-level safety benefits from investments in 20-minute neighborhoods and land use and density and mode shift.

1493
02:26:57.754 --> 02:27:11.605
<v Clay Vacca>And that is a space where many of the bureaus are coming together in collaboration, and we're all saying, hey, this is, this is a way we can make a bigger difference for safety outcomes, and we each have a role to play.

1494
02:27:11.734 --> 02:27:11.975
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1495
02:27:12.072 --> 02:27:17.467
<v Unidentified speaker>Play in this kind of lower level of the socioeconomic land use pyramid.

1496
02:27:19.414 --> 02:27:27.207
<v Unidentified speaker>In addition, we've built partnerships, PBOT, around Vision Zero with several agencies over the last 10 years.

1497
02:27:27.626 --> 02:27:43.656
<v Unidentified speaker>We've worked closely with the Portland Police Bureau on a regular basis with monthly meetings, closely with Fleet when we delivered side guards on all heavy trucks that are owned by the City of Portland and continue to look for those collaborations.

1498
02:27:44.559 --> 02:27:47.516
<v Unidentified speaker>We work with fire on an ongoing basis as well.

1499
02:27:48.047 --> 02:27:57.197
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we, we already have some of those partnerships in place, and through the citywide effort are leaning into and building, building on those with other bureaus.

1500
02:27:58.997 --> 02:27:59.707
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so much.

1501
02:27:59.819 --> 02:28:03.397
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And if there are any ways that councilors or this committee can be more—.

1502
02:28:03.590 --> 02:28:08.933
<v Olivia Clark>Can be supportive Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1503
02:28:09.141 --> 02:28:14.873
<v Olivia Clark>And we are going to take a 10-minute break, but Councilor Kanal guarantees me this is 15 seconds.

1504
02:28:15.581 --> 02:28:22.903
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I just wanted to say I agree with Councilor Green, and if we can ticket the people in SmartParks who park over the lines, that'd be incredible.

1505
02:28:23.111 --> 02:28:23.433
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1506
02:28:24.573 --> 02:28:26.097
<v Olivia Clark>Parking hygiene, I think we call it.

1507
02:28:26.483 --> 02:28:28.073
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much for the presentation.

1508
02:28:28.345 --> 02:28:29.051
<v Olivia Clark>Really appreciate it.

1509
02:28:29.148 --> 02:28:29.790
<v Olivia Clark>And we're going to take a 10-minute break.

1510
02:28:29.920 --> 02:28:30.845
<v Olivia Clark>We'll take a 15-minute break.

1511
02:28:31.334 --> 02:28:31.611
<v Loretta Smith>Let's be—.

1512
02:28:31.611 --> 02:28:31.935
<v Olivia Clark>Let's be back here.

1513
02:28:31.985 --> 02:28:33.903
<v Olivia Clark>I'll be generous at 5 after 12.

1514
02:28:34.977 --> 02:28:35.203
<v Loretta Smith>12.

1515
02:42:47.760 --> 02:42:48.683
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, welcome back.

1516
02:42:49.186 --> 02:42:50.629
<v Olivia Clark>Sorry we're running a little bit late.

1517
02:42:50.744 --> 02:42:52.674
<v Olivia Clark>Diana, would you please read the next item?

1518
02:42:54.649 --> 02:43:02.427
<v Olivia Clark>Item number 4, document number 2026-283, Waterfront Park Redevelopment Update.

1519
02:43:03.154 --> 02:43:03.832
<v Olivia Clark>Great, thank you.

1520
02:43:03.977 --> 02:43:14.494
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, I've asked Parks and Recreation to give us a very brief update on the work that's going on, the progress on the work that's going on, and the redevelopment of the Tom McCall Waterfront Park.

1521
02:43:14.992 --> 02:43:19.200
<v Olivia Clark>So we'll get a little bit of history and then maybe learn about the current design process.

1522
02:43:19.393 --> 02:43:23.793
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm sorry, we only have about 20, 25 minutes to do this, and I know you have a presentation.

1523
02:43:23.906 --> 02:43:25.881
<v Olivia Clark>So let's do it.

1524
02:43:26.075 --> 02:43:26.396
<v Olivia Clark>Thanks.

1525
02:43:26.557 --> 02:43:27.246
<v Olivia Clark>Art Pierce.

1526
02:43:27.440 --> 02:43:28.290
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you so much.

1527
02:43:28.820 --> 02:43:35.084
<v Art Pierce>So Art Pierce, Interim Director for Portland Parks and Rec, with Laura Lillard, who's the project manager for this project.

1528
02:43:35.519 --> 02:43:37.447
<v Art Pierce>We're going to start out with a little bit of fun.

1529
02:43:37.719 --> 02:43:44.395
<v Art Pierce>You might have noticed as we're trying to promote the waterfront park, We put out a video last week to try to show that video.

1530
02:43:44.557 --> 02:43:45.203
<v Art Pierce>We're going to show the video.

1531
02:43:45.252 --> 02:43:46.174
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to share it.

1532
02:43:46.254 --> 02:43:47.549
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so I'm going to start sharing it.

1533
02:43:47.629 --> 02:43:47.969
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1534
02:43:49.560 --> 02:43:50.174
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh my God.

1535
02:43:50.627 --> 02:43:52.693
<v Unidentified speaker>Hopefully that comes in.

1536
02:43:55.239 --> 02:44:03.049
<v Art Pierce>Access, more trees, a picnic shelter— no, 2 picnic shelters, places to swim, more dragon boats, beach, definitely lots of beach.

1537
02:44:03.308 --> 02:44:05.182
<v Art Pierce>What about a playground with a big slide?

1538
02:44:05.264 --> 02:44:10.069
<v Art Pierce>Hoops, definitely What about a place just to sit and read a book?

1539
02:44:10.069 --> 02:44:11.209
<v Art Pierce>Nah, it's not a rescue.

1540
02:44:11.489 --> 02:44:12.489
<v Unidentified speaker>New restaurant?

1541
02:44:12.489 --> 02:44:13.729
<v Sameer Kanal>What's he doing?

1542
02:44:13.729 --> 02:44:14.690
<v Art Pierce>River sauna.

1543
02:44:14.690 --> 02:44:15.940
<v Mitch Green>Definitely need a river sauna.

1544
02:44:15.989 --> 02:44:16.649
<v Art Pierce>Pickleball?

1545
02:44:16.649 --> 02:44:17.649
<v Art Pierce>No, dodgeball.

1546
02:44:17.649 --> 02:44:18.469
<v Art Pierce>Community gardens?

1547
02:44:18.469 --> 02:44:19.510
<v Unidentified speaker>He's workshopping.

1548
02:44:19.510 --> 02:44:21.229
<v Unidentified speaker>Native plants?

1549
02:44:21.229 --> 02:44:22.329
<v Art Pierce>Maybe a dog park?

1550
02:44:22.329 --> 02:44:26.879
<v Art Pierce>Food trucks, local music, art installations all year round.

1551
02:44:28.829 --> 02:44:31.319
<v Art Pierce>A place that people don't want to leave.

1552
02:44:33.582 --> 02:44:35.284
<v Art Pierce>All right, that's good.

1553
02:44:36.715 --> 02:44:38.256
<v Art Pierce>So we thought it'd be fun just to start with that.

1554
02:44:39.621 --> 02:44:46.802
<v Art Pierce>We're in a moment of, I think, a pretty large conversation both about Waterfront Park but also about the future of downtown.

1555
02:44:47.012 --> 02:45:10.422
<v Art Pierce>And so we're really trying to throw the door kind of wide open, and I thought it was a fun idea from the comms team to throw me into the river to try to start the conversation off, but really with design to make sure that you all know and Portlanders know that this is a big moment for us to think about how, as a city, we embrace the waterfront, how we embrace the river, which is one of our greatest assets.

1556
02:45:11.850 --> 02:45:14.109
<v Art Pierce>So we're— I'll give a little bit of framing.

1557
02:45:14.221 --> 02:45:15.480
<v Art Pierce>Laura's pulling up the slides.

1558
02:45:15.819 --> 02:45:16.416
<v Art Pierce>Maybe one more.

1559
02:45:16.480 --> 02:45:16.643
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah.

1560
02:45:18.256 --> 02:45:25.227
<v Art Pierce>One of the grounding premises that we really want to reinforce with this is that we need to understand downtown Portland as a neighborhood.

1561
02:45:26.343 --> 02:45:36.141
<v Art Pierce>And really, while it has always been a neighborhood, it's been one that's been really reliant on commuters working downtown to create its culture, its presence, and its feel.

1562
02:45:36.832 --> 02:45:47.673
<v Art Pierce>And if we want to create a space that more people want to spend, perhaps even decide to live and stay longer, we need to really change the character of downtown Portland in order to do that.

1563
02:45:48.058 --> 02:45:50.929
<v Art Pierce>And the public sector's— Councilor Loretta Smith.

1564
02:45:51.843 --> 02:46:03.632
<v Art Pierce>Really central role is in the convening of the design of our streets, such as the conversation you just had with PBOT, and in our public spaces that is governed largely by Parks and Recreation.

1565
02:46:05.019 --> 02:46:07.033
<v Art Pierce>Hold for one second with a technical adjustment.

1566
02:46:08.786 --> 02:46:10.394
<v Olivia Clark>With sound, yeah, thank you.

1567
02:46:19.191 --> 02:46:19.927
<v Mitch Green>There we go.

1568
02:46:20.190 --> 02:46:21.548
<v Art Pierce>Let's go to the next slide.

1569
02:46:26.278 --> 02:46:26.439
<v Nancy Thorington>Maybe.

1570
02:46:30.965 --> 02:46:49.836
<v Art Pierce>So when we're thinking about how Waterfront Park can help to signal to Portlanders that there's a character shift to downtown Portland, we can look to cities globally and how they have really embraced the presence of a river in their city to really shift people's understanding of of what they would come downtown for, how they would spend that time together.

1571
02:46:51.719 --> 02:47:00.125
<v Art Pierce>And when you think about the possibility of thousands of people living downtown, they will need a place, a day-in and day-out park to visit.

1572
02:47:00.966 --> 02:47:11.218
<v Art Pierce>They will need to have attractions that they will want to use as a resident that also will serve as an anchor destination for people traveling from throughout the world to come to visit Portland.

1573
02:47:12.563 --> 02:47:14.730
<v Art Pierce>And it's important to remember we've done this before.

1574
02:47:14.811 --> 02:47:35.504
<v Art Pierce>While this is a bold proposition, we've done this before in districts such as the Pearl District and my own experience working in South Waterfront, where if we can convene around a really clear and compelling vision, we can bring the resources together and align all of the bureaus and public and private parties together to make a large-scale investment happen.

1575
02:47:36.644 --> 02:47:39.359
<v Art Pierce>So we're really excited to engage with you as council.

1576
02:47:39.698 --> 02:47:51.636
<v Art Pierce>But also engaging with all sorts of constituents who care deeply about Waterfront Park to have a really full and vibrant conversation over the next year as we're entering into the design competition.

1577
02:47:51.747 --> 02:47:59.542
<v Art Pierce>So Laura's here to give a little bit more details into the specifics of the design competition, and we'd love your feedback and ideas to help the process moving forward.

1578
02:48:01.239 --> 02:48:01.567
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1579
02:48:02.093 --> 02:48:03.293
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, councilors.

1580
02:48:03.902 --> 02:48:05.719
<v Unidentified speaker>We are here because Yes.

1581
02:48:06.184 --> 02:48:11.290
<v Unidentified speaker>As you probably know, Metro awarded a planning and development grant to the City of Portland.

1582
02:48:11.868 --> 02:48:18.915
<v Unidentified speaker>Our application was initiated and supported by 2 project partners, the Human Access Project and Portland Waterfront Pavilion.

1583
02:48:19.349 --> 02:48:24.469
<v Unidentified speaker>And the grant is funding an open design competition for Governor Tom McCall Waterfront Park.

1584
02:48:24.871 --> 02:48:33.878
<v Unidentified speaker>The outcome of the grant will be a concept design for the full waterfront park and a deeper and more detailed design for the bowl area.

1585
02:48:33.958 --> 02:48:39.708
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll, I'll show you what that area is, along with cost estimates and funding and implementation strategies.

1586
02:48:40.141 --> 02:48:44.286
<v Unidentified speaker>And this project really lays the groundwork for capital funding.

1587
02:48:45.763 --> 02:48:48.541
<v Unidentified speaker>So just a really quick history.

1588
02:48:48.638 --> 02:48:49.715
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to kind of ground us.

1589
02:48:49.795 --> 02:48:50.100
<v Loretta Smith>It won't—.

1590
02:48:50.100 --> 02:48:52.349
<v Unidentified speaker>We won't dwell here, so buckle up a little bit.

1591
02:48:52.493 --> 02:49:03.238
<v Unidentified speaker>I also just want to recognize that the images don't acknowledge that the park has always been a place for gathering, trading, and river access since time immemorial.

1592
02:49:03.512 --> 02:49:11.271
<v Unidentified speaker>But over the last 120 years, it has seen some transformation and some really big moves, and it's been shaped by people and activities.

1593
02:49:11.880 --> 02:49:15.447
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of the bold moves have been good, and some may be worth rethinking.

1594
02:49:16.281 --> 02:49:23.189
<v Unidentified speaker>In early Portland's trading and shipbuilding era, this was the location of docks and wharves, as you can kind of see in that upper left photo.

1595
02:49:24.297 --> 02:49:25.630
<v Unidentified speaker>And the city frequently flooded.

1596
02:49:26.015 --> 02:49:28.763
<v Unidentified speaker>So in the 1930s, the city built a seawall.

1597
02:49:29.516 --> 02:49:40.891
<v Unidentified speaker>And Harbor Drive, and then it made a very intentional collective civic decision to take down Harbor Drive, which is a very celebrated and bold move, and it's in recent history for many Portlanders.

1598
02:49:41.468 --> 02:49:50.597
<v Unidentified speaker>We replaced it with a park that through the many decades since has offered continuation and hasn't really changed too much over the last 45 years.

1599
02:49:51.095 --> 02:49:54.368
<v Unidentified speaker>The park is a place of regional festivals and events.

1600
02:49:54.480 --> 02:49:54.704
<v Clay Vacca>Thank you.

1601
02:49:55.105 --> 02:50:07.593
<v Unidentified speaker>And though we don't launch hot air balloons necessarily, like in this picture, the grassy lawn is reserved for these events and for the large-scale events that you see at the bowl in this photo on the right-hand side.

1602
02:50:08.266 --> 02:50:12.129
<v Unidentified speaker>And it is also a pass-through for walkers, joggers, cyclists, and the like.

1603
02:50:12.514 --> 02:50:17.531
<v Unidentified speaker>But— and these 3 functions haven't really changed a whole lot over the past few decades.

1604
02:50:18.942 --> 02:50:22.822
<v Unidentified speaker>I just also want to acknowledge that this project is not starting from scratch.

1605
02:50:23.334 --> 02:50:35.346
<v Unidentified speaker>It builds on many different policy documents and projects that have gotten feedback and thinking from many Portlanders over the past few years, previously adopted city efforts.

1606
02:50:35.827 --> 02:50:37.559
<v Unidentified speaker>So our history really grounds us.

1607
02:50:37.849 --> 02:50:43.622
<v Unidentified speaker>These documents guide us, and the public conversations that we're having will help move us forward into the future.

1608
02:50:44.906 --> 02:50:49.750
<v Unidentified speaker>Tom McCall Waterfront Park is approximately 30 acres owned by Portland Parks and Recreation.

1609
02:50:50.343 --> 02:50:54.144
<v Unidentified speaker>We will be asking for a concept design and vision for this entire length of the park.

1610
02:50:54.209 --> 02:51:02.027
<v Unidentified speaker>So the northern end is that Steel Bridge, um, and then it goes all the way down to the bowl, uh, which is Southwest Clay and River Place.

1611
02:51:02.941 --> 02:51:09.349
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we will be asking for a concept design for this whole park, um, and this is the focus of the design competition.

1612
02:51:09.781 --> 02:51:16.156
<v Unidentified speaker>Many of the areas we know are beloved and they work very well, and we aren't thinking that there will be a lot of transformation.

1613
02:51:16.430 --> 02:51:20.748
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm thinking like the Saturday, uh, Market area or Salmon Street Springs.

1614
02:51:21.182 --> 02:51:25.399
<v Unidentified speaker>But there are areas that do need help and transformation.

1615
02:51:26.153 --> 02:51:39.592
<v Unidentified speaker>The bowl area, which is defined from the Salmon Street Springs to that southern end at Harbor Drive and Southwest Clay, will be the focus of the winning design team post-design competition to take that more detailed design and feasibility.

1616
02:51:40.649 --> 02:52:04.745
<v Art Pierce>We also have the opportunity to potentially expand the design of the entire park in a more focused and I think adding one note here, if you look at the illustration of the dashed area of the outline of the design competition, you'll note it also includes the Morrison Bridge ramps and also includes Naito Parkway.

1617
02:52:04.843 --> 02:52:12.514
<v Art Pierce>So we're also inviting designers to help us really, really rethink the character of that connection from downtown and into the park, as well as the park itself.

1618
02:52:12.563 --> 02:52:12.756
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1619
02:52:14.801 --> 02:52:22.852
<v Unidentified speaker>This diagram shows at the top the major stages of the project with a special emphasis on the design competition itself and public engagement.

1620
02:52:23.305 --> 02:52:24.647
<v Unidentified speaker>It's intended to show sequencing.

1621
02:52:24.792 --> 02:52:29.497
<v Unidentified speaker>So the first phase has really been about getting us to this moment, all of the preparation.

1622
02:52:30.115 --> 02:52:40.123
<v Unidentified speaker>Listening sessions is an umbrella term for one-on-one conversations, stakeholder interviews, open house, survey, webinar, et cetera.

1623
02:52:40.206 --> 02:52:45.956
<v Unidentified speaker>We've done a deep dive into some existing conditions data, looking topography, soil stability, land use zoning.

1624
02:52:46.468 --> 02:52:58.388
<v Unidentified speaker>We've had conversations with the stewards who are actively involved in the memorials and monuments, of all of the many memorials and monuments in the park, event producers.

1625
02:52:58.740 --> 02:53:07.146
<v Unidentified speaker>We've also done— we've worked with BES on environmental studies, and we are also doing an economic analysis for the park.

1626
02:53:07.963 --> 02:53:10.658
<v Unidentified speaker>We have hired a design competition manager to run the competition.

1627
02:53:11.397 --> 02:53:12.906
<v Unidentified speaker>Which is Malcolm Redding Consulting.

1628
02:53:13.113 --> 02:53:19.837
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's, that's led us to this orange phase where we are in, in the thick of this design competition.

1629
02:53:19.902 --> 02:53:25.373
<v Unidentified speaker>We're at this moment where we have issued an RFQ, and we'll talk about that a little bit later.

1630
02:53:25.453 --> 02:53:38.467
<v Unidentified speaker>But beyond getting through the design competition, we'll land on a finalist who will then take it to the next phase, the design development in pink, and produce that schematic design for the bowl area.

1631
02:53:39.174 --> 02:53:45.861
<v Unidentified speaker>We do recognize that we'd like to come and have some touchpoints with you all in these different stages.

1632
02:53:45.925 --> 02:53:54.250
<v Unidentified speaker>So when there are 3 shortlisted teams that will be producing concept designs, that would be a good moment to have a touchpoint with you.

1633
02:53:54.345 --> 02:53:59.198
<v Unidentified speaker>And then at the end for this project, when we wrap up the design development.

1634
02:54:01.593 --> 02:54:10.140
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, we've been engaging with a lot of different people who have interest in the park, and we just wanted to highlight some of those organizations that we've engaged.

1635
02:54:10.189 --> 02:54:14.426
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not a complete list, but it does represent the broad reach of this park and this project.

1636
02:54:14.780 --> 02:54:25.067
<v Unidentified speaker>And we placed an asterisk on the organizations that have representation on our Project Advisory Committee, which has been helping us develop some of the project aims, goals, and objectives.

1637
02:54:25.773 --> 02:54:35.948
<v Unidentified speaker>So speaking of the Project Advisory Committee, this is an 18-member group, and we are also convening a Technical Advisory Group with many of our agency staff as well as the county and metro.

1638
02:54:36.909 --> 02:54:44.989
<v Unidentified speaker>We've had several meetings to help hone in what it is that we're looking for from design teams in this competition.

1639
02:54:45.583 --> 02:54:48.501
<v Unidentified speaker>We've done several site tours to just give a lay of the land.

1640
02:54:48.549 --> 02:54:55.796
<v Unidentified speaker>We've had focus group discussions about events, accessibility, and river access and river use.

1641
02:54:55.987 --> 02:55:02.513
<v Unidentified speaker>We hosted a community-wide workshop at the end of June, and we have this community survey, which you saw that video has a link to.

1642
02:55:02.576 --> 02:55:03.907
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're really excited about that.

1643
02:55:03.956 --> 02:55:07.099
<v Unidentified speaker>We've received Over 1,000 responses to date.

1644
02:55:07.711 --> 02:55:09.342
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're getting some really good feedback.

1645
02:55:11.649 --> 02:55:17.468
<v Unidentified speaker>The design competition calls for qualifications at this stage, not design responses.

1646
02:55:18.147 --> 02:55:22.886
<v Unidentified speaker>It opened on July 8th and received, as you can see, 50 responses.

1647
02:55:23.064 --> 02:55:24.797
<v Unidentified speaker>It just closed a week ago.

1648
02:55:25.914 --> 02:55:27.404
<v Unidentified speaker>And we are in active review.

1649
02:55:27.841 --> 02:55:31.391
<v Unidentified speaker>And we're extremely excited about this turnout and interested— and interest.

1650
02:55:31.441 --> 02:55:31.541
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1651
02:55:32.117 --> 02:55:32.486
<v Unidentified speaker>In Portland.

1652
02:55:32.534 --> 02:55:38.443
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a really great showing of both local talent and national and international excitement that's building.

1653
02:55:39.262 --> 02:55:43.903
<v Unidentified speaker>The RFQ, again, is part 1 of the competition where no design work is required.

1654
02:55:44.239 --> 02:56:04.000
<v Unidentified speaker>This will result in a shortlist of 3 design teams which will be invited to participate in the next stage, which is a request for proposals, and they will be developing those 3 different design concepts for Waterfront Park, and we will host a public exhibition for folks to view it, as well as an online gallery.

1655
02:56:04.354 --> 02:56:06.386
<v Unidentified speaker>And those details will be announced shortly.

1656
02:56:07.906 --> 02:56:10.042
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanted to flash in front of you the vision statement.

1657
02:56:10.092 --> 02:56:13.306
<v Unidentified speaker>This was in co-creation with our Project Advisory Committee.

1658
02:56:13.852 --> 02:56:27.236
<v Unidentified speaker>It really calls for this bold intergenerational waterfront park that reflects who we are as Portlanders, reflects our culture, our landscape, our identity, and really centers the river in its transformation.

1659
02:56:27.975 --> 02:56:37.277
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a key piece of downtown revitalization, as Interim Director Pierce mentioned, and also long-term economic vitality.

1660
02:56:37.325 --> 02:56:39.397
<v Unidentified speaker>So it really starts with this statement.

1661
02:56:40.602 --> 02:56:45.310
<v Unidentified speaker>I just also want to mention the themes that were developed with our project advisory committee.

1662
02:56:45.584 --> 02:56:48.844
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, thinking about defined areas for events and civic gathering.

1663
02:56:48.958 --> 02:56:53.284
<v Unidentified speaker>We know that this is to many of our beloved community festivals.

1664
02:56:54.271 --> 02:56:58.926
<v Unidentified speaker>River access is a very key piece of this design competition.

1665
02:56:58.976 --> 02:57:05.012
<v Unidentified speaker>The bowl is the only area that is not bounded by the seawall and is an opportunity to touch the water.

1666
02:57:06.675 --> 02:57:21.880
<v Unidentified speaker>Integration of neighbor— nature and habitat will be really important, not only along the river edge and the riparian, restored riparian habitat, but also upland and diversity of canopy and habitat upland in the park itself.

1667
02:57:22.540 --> 02:57:31.110
<v Unidentified speaker>We recognize that this park, because it is used for events, it sometimes lacks that everyday use and really sticking power.

1668
02:57:31.270 --> 02:57:34.640
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a pass-through space much of the year.

1669
02:57:34.736 --> 02:57:54.027
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we're really looking at how design teams will respond to this opportunity to hold people there as a neighborhood destination that works for residents and then of course we have our Willamette River Greenway Trail that's very important for folks that continue to use the, the park, and it needs to be maintained and improved.

1670
02:57:55.962 --> 02:57:58.308
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's what I wanted to bring to you today.

1671
02:57:58.453 --> 02:58:02.888
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a lot of community-supported dreaming, and we know it will be a balance with all these themes.

1672
02:58:02.952 --> 02:58:11.188
<v Unidentified speaker>We're so excited to see what clever designers will come up with to inspire us and reflect great.

1673
02:58:11.333 --> 02:58:11.829
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Laura.

1674
02:58:11.909 --> 02:58:12.471
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Art.

1675
02:58:13.097 --> 02:58:14.123
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for the presentation.

1676
02:58:14.477 --> 02:58:16.242
<v Olivia Clark>You really brought us up to date, I think.

1677
02:58:16.467 --> 02:58:18.808
<v Olivia Clark>We only have about 10 more minutes if we have any questions.

1678
02:58:18.872 --> 02:58:29.254
<v Olivia Clark>I'll just kick it off by asking you on the RFQ, do the respondents actually reveal other projects that they've worked on as a part of the RFQ?

1679
02:58:29.381 --> 02:58:32.045
<v Olivia Clark>Here's what I've done in other parts of the country?

1680
02:58:32.447 --> 02:58:46.682
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, the RFQ The RFQ asked for, um, the lead, the lead design team as well as their, uh, design team makeup, and they asked them to reflect on, um, projects that they had worked on similar to this.

1681
02:58:47.115 --> 02:58:52.379
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, and they also, uh, asked for their methodology— how would they approach a project like that.

1682
02:58:52.668 --> 02:58:53.952
<v Unidentified speaker>That was the 4 criteria.

1683
02:58:54.032 --> 02:58:54.273
<v Olivia Clark>Great.

1684
02:58:54.498 --> 02:58:54.738
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1685
02:58:55.300 --> 02:58:56.327
<v Olivia Clark>Um, and one other question.

1686
02:58:56.504 --> 02:59:04.290
<v Olivia Clark>Um, Councilor Green and I were down on the waterfront this morning as a matter We had a pretty good group of, I don't know, maybe 40, 50 people.

1687
02:59:04.772 --> 02:59:04.885
<v Millicent Williams>Hmm.

1688
02:59:05.093 --> 02:59:10.231
<v Olivia Clark>And you could tell that it is a pass-through area.

1689
02:59:10.712 --> 02:59:18.485
<v Olivia Clark>And when we had to cross to go over into the Ann Kinney Alley, that connection with downtown really needs to be improved.

1690
02:59:18.581 --> 02:59:25.388
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm hoping that whatever project gets selected, that we can really increase that connection.

1691
02:59:25.662 --> 02:59:26.352
<v Olivia Clark>Connection.

1692
02:59:26.448 --> 02:59:27.875
<v Olivia Clark>It's, it's just really awkward.

1693
02:59:28.003 --> 02:59:30.441
<v Olivia Clark>It doesn't feel like it's a part of the downtown, really.

1694
02:59:30.488 --> 02:59:31.531
<v Olivia Clark>It's quite separated.

1695
02:59:32.461 --> 02:59:35.413
<v Olivia Clark>Um, so hopefully we'll look forward to seeing those.

1696
02:59:36.085 --> 02:59:40.513
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, do you have any questions or comments for Lauren?

1697
02:59:40.640 --> 02:59:42.084
<v Olivia Clark>Sure, Councilor Green.

1698
02:59:42.726 --> 02:59:44.618
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you so much for the presentation.

1699
02:59:44.729 --> 02:59:46.655
<v Mitch Green>I've been really excited about this work.

1700
02:59:46.815 --> 02:59:56.559
<v Mitch Green>Um, I think we're all going to have questions when, when it's appropriate to talk about yeah, I think we're all thinking about how to pay for such a thing and what the implications of change and design commitments are.

1701
02:59:57.010 --> 03:00:04.336
<v Mitch Green>But I think speaking— I think I speak for all of us when our constituents are really hungry for some activation down there.

1702
03:00:05.140 --> 03:00:11.905
<v Mitch Green>And I've seen some models around the world that we could almost sort of get inspiration from.

1703
03:00:12.917 --> 03:00:19.551
<v Mitch Green>Top of mind for me as we go through this is— and I'm glad I I see on the slide about flexible everyday park use.

1704
03:00:19.695 --> 03:00:33.584
<v Mitch Green>I think that's so critical, but also having an opportunity to have a little commercial experience as well, like get a cafe, get a coffee, get a beer, and have a safe place to sit and watch your kid play in the park.

1705
03:00:33.649 --> 03:00:40.103
<v Mitch Green>I mean, that seems like a really good thing for families right now to be a reason to come downtown.

1706
03:00:40.554 --> 03:00:51.860
<v Mitch Green>If we're kind of thinking about the family experience, But also recognizing that sometimes you gotta sit there and take a beat and you're tired and you need like a snack and a glass of wine.

1707
03:00:52.650 --> 03:00:54.216
<v Mitch Green>That's, we should acknowledge that, embrace it.

1708
03:00:55.861 --> 03:00:57.555
<v Mitch Green>And I know you guys are thinking about it, so thank you.

1709
03:00:57.652 --> 03:01:03.378
<v Mitch Green>And then I think that we should bring in maybe Randy Gragg or some of those folks to give us the other side of this thinking.

1710
03:01:04.549 --> 03:01:07.490
<v Mitch Green>There's some kind of bigger Design Portland ideas.

1711
03:01:07.980 --> 03:01:08.161
<v Art Pierce>Yeah.

1712
03:01:08.432 --> 03:01:24.917
<v Mitch Green>Charette type of learnings come into this committee, because I think, um, motivating this to the other districts is key, because there's, there's other thinking that's going to be part of the broader Green Loop, which is a Central City District 2, 3, and 4 kind of, um, shared interest.

1713
03:01:24.966 --> 03:01:26.748
<v Mitch Green>So that's— I'd be interested in that.

1714
03:01:26.989 --> 03:01:27.311
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1715
03:01:27.424 --> 03:01:27.632
<v Olivia Clark>Great.

1716
03:01:27.953 --> 03:01:28.934
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1717
03:01:29.078 --> 03:01:29.754
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Kanal.

1718
03:01:30.846 --> 03:01:32.518
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, and thank you for the presentation.

1719
03:01:32.597 --> 03:01:35.263
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously, we've talked about dodgeball and how much I think that's a great idea.

1720
03:01:35.311 --> 03:01:37.540
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll figure out how to do it in the water or up there.

1721
03:01:38.375 --> 03:01:50.466
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the big takeaway for me, and I hope we get a chance to talk about this more in October at the Committee of the Whole when we have the broader downtown conversation, is slide 2, downtown is a neighborhood.

1722
03:01:50.563 --> 03:01:50.674
<v Sameer Kanal>Yep.

1723
03:01:50.738 --> 03:02:00.504
<v Sameer Kanal>There is, I think, no single bigger thing we could do with relation to not only downtown, but frankly our budget, than get people to live downtown.

1724
03:02:01.147 --> 03:02:12.484
<v Sameer Kanal>And we've seen post-COVID how the arts and culture districts and the actual neighborhoods have both recovered in terms of downtowns nationwide much better than business districts.

1725
03:02:13.768 --> 03:02:18.842
<v Sameer Kanal>We are not going back to not— by the way, the pre-2020 is not when people came downtown.

1726
03:02:18.889 --> 03:02:24.959
<v Sameer Kanal>It's pre-2018 where people would come down to work at the higher levels before we got to so much telework.

1727
03:02:25.393 --> 03:02:25.970
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1728
03:02:26.935 --> 03:02:28.488
<v Sameer Kanal>But yeah, I just wanted to talk about that.

1729
03:02:28.538 --> 03:02:32.549
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the other piece, you talked about placemaking tool.

1730
03:02:32.760 --> 03:02:35.800
<v Sameer Kanal>It's kind of a little bit of our fairgrounds as a city.

1731
03:02:36.139 --> 03:02:38.882
<v Sameer Kanal>And, you know, we've talked about this.

1732
03:02:39.140 --> 03:02:45.093
<v Sameer Kanal>There's, you know, another thing being constructed every few weeks in the summertime, which I think is great.

1733
03:02:45.174 --> 03:02:49.716
<v Sameer Kanal>These are all important activations, are all economic drivers too.

1734
03:02:50.546 --> 03:03:02.971
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think the physical landscape of the park, and we've talked about turf and things like that, that piece is so inextricably connected to whether or not it's easy to attend and do events there.

1735
03:03:03.918 --> 03:03:13.144
<v Sameer Kanal>Last year, many of us did the dragon boat race, and it did not rain that weekend, but the sprinklers had gone off beforehand.

1736
03:03:13.304 --> 03:03:15.918
<v Sameer Kanal>And so just, it doesn't drain well.

1737
03:03:16.433 --> 03:03:17.010
<v Sameer Kanal>Right.

1738
03:03:17.572 --> 03:03:22.407
<v Sameer Kanal>It's June, it's hot, and we're slipping on the grass, well, the mud, I guess.

1739
03:03:22.792 --> 03:03:28.361
<v Sameer Kanal>And those sorts of things, I think just ensuring it's a slope, it's right by the water, whatever we can do there is vital.

1740
03:03:28.411 --> 03:03:31.148
<v Sameer Kanal>And I hope that that's a part of the decision-making process.

1741
03:03:33.843 --> 03:03:42.725
<v Sameer Kanal>I really appreciate that you included the city block on each side of the Morrison Bridge as a place that we can talk about doing something with.

1742
03:03:43.599 --> 03:03:46.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Instead of just a ramp and parking lots down there.

1743
03:03:48.645 --> 03:03:59.724
<v Sameer Kanal>I would be remiss if I didn't bring up having seasonal or permanent ice rinks there as a District 2 councilor, but also just knowing the love that that has gotten in the past.

1744
03:04:02.583 --> 03:04:05.448
<v Sameer Kanal>The other piece, where did it go?

1745
03:04:05.577 --> 03:04:06.846
<v Sameer Kanal>Gotta find my notes here.

1746
03:04:07.531 --> 03:04:07.790
<v Wendy Cully>Yeah.

1747
03:04:09.898 --> 03:04:16.925
<v Sameer Kanal>I think Councilor Green brought up the idea of this being something that affects multiple districts.

1748
03:04:16.975 --> 03:04:17.407
<v Sameer Kanal>That's true.

1749
03:04:18.884 --> 03:04:34.013
<v Sameer Kanal>Not only in the way that you mentioned with the Green Loop and the sort of transportation elements of how we get people out to it, but also in the sense of if downtown works, and I'm channeling my District 2 colleague, Councilor Ryan here, that it's where the prosperity is.

1750
03:04:34.110 --> 03:04:36.680
<v Sameer Kanal>Property tax revenues come in that fund all the programs elsewhere.

1751
03:04:36.727 --> 03:04:41.387
<v Sameer Kanal>So I love that this is being connected with— I appreciate the shout out of who to include in it.

1752
03:04:41.515 --> 03:04:48.538
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, I know PMC has had a lot of ideas here in general, and so I'm very appreciative of that conversation.

1753
03:04:50.708 --> 03:05:00.862
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the activations that are not giant events, so not just the daily use in terms of coming in, but in terms— and also not like Like city fair level.

1754
03:05:01.441 --> 03:05:15.154
<v Sameer Kanal>What is the— I mean, this is obviously coming not only from the dodgeball side, but like, what are the— what's the plan there in terms of— this isn't a design thing alone, so I don't know if it's a parallel conversation about how do you get those small activations.

1755
03:05:15.731 --> 03:05:17.209
<v Art Pierce>I actually really appreciate you asked the question.

1756
03:05:17.352 --> 03:05:25.236
<v Art Pierce>We didn't give an update, but I think we will in October with the rest of our city colleagues about the work that Parks is doing together with PBOT and Prosper.

1757
03:05:25.541 --> 03:05:35.611
<v Art Pierce>And arts and culture to look for near-term opportunities this winter into next summer of what are some smaller-scale engagements that we can embrace.

1758
03:05:36.157 --> 03:05:44.781
<v Art Pierce>So the, you know, the work happening at the Pink Light District, how can we echo some of that type of activation as we're heading into the waterfront and those adjacent areas?

1759
03:05:45.216 --> 03:05:58.475
<v Art Pierce>So we actually have a meeting this afternoon with staff to start looking ahead to next summer and what are the ways that we can really embrace Some smaller level engagement either put on by parks or enabled for a partner to take on.

1760
03:05:59.052 --> 03:06:00.209
<v Art Pierce>And I agree, it's critical.

1761
03:06:00.259 --> 03:06:04.479
<v Art Pierce>It's going to take us a number of years to get to a capital investment scale of what we're conceiving of.

1762
03:06:04.786 --> 03:06:07.788
<v Art Pierce>So we have a number of years of temporary activations that are essential.

1763
03:06:07.852 --> 03:06:08.272
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1764
03:06:08.578 --> 03:06:09.353
<v Sameer Kanal>Great.

1765
03:06:11.081 --> 03:06:14.976
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of— Councilor Green also mentioned the ability to get a beer.

1766
03:06:15.490 --> 03:06:17.792
<v Sameer Kanal>I definitely would love to hear more about that.

1767
03:06:18.299 --> 03:06:22.404
<v Sameer Kanal>Building stuff that attaches to the Waterfront Park is not the only place.

1768
03:06:22.451 --> 03:06:25.328
<v Sameer Kanal>I know Salmon Street Springs, that whole area, there's been discussion.

1769
03:06:26.273 --> 03:06:35.076
<v Sameer Kanal>But I, it would be nice to know if Parks is more open to that conversation than maybe a few years ago.

1770
03:06:36.040 --> 03:06:37.213
<v Art Pierce>I think we certainly are.

1771
03:06:37.584 --> 03:06:43.818
<v Art Pierce>Right now, one of the things we're looking into is whether there's adjustments to Parks policy or city code that might need to be enabled by council.

1772
03:06:44.015 --> 03:06:46.440
<v Art Pierce>To make that more ready for us to do, right?

1773
03:06:46.906 --> 03:06:47.404
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1774
03:06:47.869 --> 03:06:47.997
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1775
03:06:48.769 --> 03:06:49.426
<v Sameer Kanal>Happy to help.

1776
03:06:49.490 --> 03:06:49.877
<v Sameer Kanal>Bring it up.

1777
03:06:50.198 --> 03:06:52.879
<v Art Pierce>You know, when someone says council has to authorize it, well, we know those folks.

1778
03:06:52.942 --> 03:06:54.003
<v Art Pierce>We can bring something over to them.

1779
03:06:54.066 --> 03:06:54.291
<v Olivia Clark>Sure.

1780
03:06:54.468 --> 03:06:57.985
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a lot of interest, I would say, in that.

1781
03:06:58.146 --> 03:07:02.079
<v Sameer Kanal>And then finally, in terms of Naito, you mentioned that too.

1782
03:07:02.319 --> 03:07:08.710
<v Sameer Kanal>I know there's some challenges with having 2-way bike lanes on the water side and some of the safety issues there.

1783
03:07:09.673 --> 03:07:15.049
<v Sameer Kanal>Crossings and especially where the ramps are as you get further north to get onto the bridges.

1784
03:07:18.162 --> 03:07:23.120
<v Sameer Kanal>Are we in a position, I mean, has there been, you mentioned talking to PBOT.

1785
03:07:23.670 --> 03:07:26.213
<v Sameer Kanal>It's been redone but not very recently.

1786
03:07:26.279 --> 03:07:33.540
<v Sameer Kanal>I feel it's, there isn't, are you experiencing any sort of resistance in terms of we've done it too recently to redo it?

1787
03:07:34.346 --> 03:07:38.061
<v Art Pierce>No, in fact, the great benefit of having come a month ago from PBOT Yes.

1788
03:07:38.525 --> 03:07:42.899
<v Art Pierce>I was sort of already supporting this process previously from my PBOT role.

1789
03:07:43.413 --> 03:07:55.397
<v Art Pierce>And the transportation planning team is already doing modeling right now to better understand broader traffic and circulation patterns to make sure we're supplying to the design competition what might be possible in terms of ambitions they could bring.

1790
03:07:55.909 --> 03:07:58.938
<v Art Pierce>One of the ideas is also that there might be time-based changes.

1791
03:07:59.049 --> 03:08:07.045
<v Art Pierce>So there may be that the Naito functions as a festival street and is actually a place for some events that may take some of the pressure off the park itself.

1792
03:08:07.546 --> 03:08:11.397
<v Art Pierce>Depending on how we structure the design together of those 2 facilities.

1793
03:08:11.688 --> 03:08:11.834
<v Unidentified speaker>Right.

1794
03:08:11.915 --> 03:08:12.415
<v Sameer Kanal>I love that.

1795
03:08:12.480 --> 03:08:13.986
<v Sameer Kanal>Just one last comment and I'm done.

1796
03:08:15.506 --> 03:08:21.611
<v Sameer Kanal>I would love to see more asterisks added on that slide 9, in particular to the culturally specific community groups.

1797
03:08:22.013 --> 03:08:22.093
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

1798
03:08:22.254 --> 03:08:28.689
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm noticing a lot of them on the list, but in terms of direct access to the decision-making processes.

1799
03:08:28.801 --> 03:08:28.979
<v Sameer Kanal>Great.

1800
03:08:29.045 --> 03:08:29.465
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1801
03:08:29.530 --> 03:08:29.950
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor.

1802
03:08:30.013 --> 03:08:30.628
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith.

1803
03:08:32.180 --> 03:08:32.600
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1804
03:08:34.314 --> 03:08:36.684
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm going to keep this really short question.

1805
03:08:36.861 --> 03:08:45.818
<v Loretta Smith>Um, what have you done to get more folks of color to, um, to participate in this RFQ process?

1806
03:08:46.813 --> 03:08:48.863
<v Art Pierce>Do you want to speak to the meeting last week?

1807
03:08:49.361 --> 03:08:49.777
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, sure.

1808
03:08:50.257 --> 03:08:54.568
<v Unidentified speaker>We, um, we've done a number of, um, briefings with folks.

1809
03:08:54.728 --> 03:09:08.879
<v Unidentified speaker>Our most recent was a partner briefing that brought together all of the different River-related developments and organizations that are creating places along the river within our central city.

1810
03:09:08.959 --> 03:09:16.343
<v Unidentified speaker>So Albina Vision Trust, 1803, Williams and Russell, thank you.

1811
03:09:16.632 --> 03:09:25.765
<v Unidentified speaker>And then some of the other organizations as well, just to talk about OMSI with the Central Center of Tribal Nations.

1812
03:09:25.879 --> 03:09:41.180
<v Unidentified speaker>So just to talk about some of this, our shared vision and our shared goals with our projects, and also not to duplicate or ask folks the same questions as we're all doing these sort of big transformative efforts along, along the river.

1813
03:09:41.228 --> 03:09:43.412
<v Unidentified speaker>So that was a very productive conversation.

1814
03:09:43.459 --> 03:09:51.745
<v Unidentified speaker>I know there's a lot of collective energy around the city to do really good things and, and, and show up together in these spaces.

1815
03:09:51.809 --> 03:10:17.468
<v Art Pierce>So we're and I would add that the park's community involvement team has also been really targeting its outreach to try to bring in voices from a broader geographic area, in particular because I think currently Waterfront Park has great significance for cultural events and seasonal events, and wanting to make sure that we're really recognizing that and sort of bringing that, that into the conversation.

1816
03:10:17.549 --> 03:10:17.676
<v Art Pierce>Thank you.

1817
03:10:19.041 --> 03:10:19.990
<v Loretta Smith>Perfect, perfect.

1818
03:10:20.329 --> 03:10:21.149
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

1819
03:10:22.261 --> 03:10:23.677
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1820
03:10:24.820 --> 03:10:28.620
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for a great presentation, bringing us up to speed.

1821
03:10:28.781 --> 03:10:30.870
<v Olivia Clark>I know we have more questions, but we'll have you back.

1822
03:10:30.951 --> 03:10:43.224
<v Olivia Clark>And I think Councilor Green's recommendation, maybe we bring Randy Gregg or some of the other players that are also working on things like the Morrison Bridgehead and other connections to downtown, would be terrific.

1823
03:10:43.449 --> 03:10:45.539
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you both for being here.

1824
03:10:45.781 --> 03:10:46.963
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for the presentation.

1825
03:10:47.481 --> 03:10:48.066
<v Olivia Clark>Really appreciate it.

1826
03:10:48.113 --> 03:10:52.049
<v Olivia Clark>We'll see you again when it comes to that point.

1827
03:10:52.760 --> 03:10:52.844
<v Nancy Thorington>Great.

1828
03:10:52.947 --> 03:10:53.528
<v Art Pierce>Thank you so much.

1829
03:10:55.239 --> 03:11:01.331
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, this is our only August meeting, and the next time we're going to be back together is in September, September 8th.

1830
03:11:01.476 --> 03:11:08.873
<v Olivia Clark>And at that time, I plan to have a discussion of public-private partnerships with a variety of panels on public-private partnerships.

1831
03:11:08.969 --> 03:11:12.655
<v Olivia Clark>Partnerships looking across, uh, the city, um, where that's happening.

1832
03:11:12.912 --> 03:11:19.032
<v Olivia Clark>And, um, we'll also be bringing back the auto— automated— the— I want to say Waymo, but that's not right.

1833
03:11:19.417 --> 03:11:29.320
<v Olivia Clark>It's the automated vehicles, um, to discuss that again as we, um, maybe hone in on some action that we want to take before the end of the year, hopefully.

1834
03:11:30.075 --> 03:11:33.968
<v Olivia Clark>And then we'll want to get an update on, uh, local transportation funding one more time.

1835
03:11:34.400 --> 03:11:40.068
<v Olivia Clark>And And at some point, we're also going to revisit— hopefully we're getting very close to the final asset management plan.

1836
03:11:40.262 --> 03:11:45.512
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know if that will be done by the end of the year as it's supposed to be, but we'll come back to that as well.

1837
03:11:46.266 --> 03:11:49.959
<v Olivia Clark>And let me know if you have any other suggestions or issues that you want to bring up.

1838
03:11:50.120 --> 03:11:51.501
<v Olivia Clark>I know we're pretty time-limited.

1839
03:11:51.983 --> 03:11:52.239
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah?

1840
03:11:52.384 --> 03:11:57.650
<v Mitch Green>Just for your public-private partnership panel, do you have anyone from labor coming?

1841
03:11:58.148 --> 03:11:59.787
<v Olivia Clark>I'm not putting it all together.

1842
03:12:00.075 --> 03:12:00.981
<v Olivia Clark>Asking for help.

1843
03:12:01.289 --> 03:12:02.648
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, so that would be good.

1844
03:12:02.762 --> 03:12:03.829
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, yeah, sure.

1845
03:12:04.121 --> 03:12:08.637
<v Mitch Green>I, I would, I would extend an invitation to some public sector unions.

1846
03:12:09.090 --> 03:12:09.559
<v Nancy Thorington>Okay, thanks.

1847
03:12:10.029 --> 03:12:10.692
<v Olivia Clark>All right, super.

1848
03:12:11.163 --> 03:12:15.406
<v Olivia Clark>Without further ado, I will adjourn the meeting of the Public Works Committee.

1849
03:12:17.084 --> 03:12:17.503
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

