WEBVTT

1
00:05:05.879 --> 00:05:05.992
<v Sue Pack>Ready.

2
00:05:06.122 --> 00:05:06.980
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good afternoon.

3
00:05:07.093 --> 00:05:10.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 2:01 PM on Tuesday, July 28th.

4
00:05:10.834 --> 00:05:15.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am calling to order this meeting of the City Life Diego, could you please call the roll?

5
00:05:15.795 --> 00:05:16.406
<v Donny Oliveira>Good afternoon.

6
00:05:16.824 --> 00:05:17.163
<v Melissa Finkel>Morillo?

7
00:05:19.480 --> 00:05:19.610
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

8
00:05:21.122 --> 00:05:21.476
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman?

9
00:05:21.976 --> 00:05:22.089
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

10
00:05:22.624 --> 00:05:22.850
<v Sue Pack>Avalos?

11
00:05:25.454 --> 00:05:25.875
<v Candace Avalos>Absent.

12
00:05:26.278 --> 00:05:26.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan?

13
00:05:26.829 --> 00:05:26.959
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

14
00:05:27.718 --> 00:05:28.107
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney?

15
00:05:28.543 --> 00:05:28.819
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

16
00:05:29.903 --> 00:05:32.105
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Christopher, could you please read the statement of conduct?

17
00:05:33.062 --> 00:05:34.716
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome to the meeting of the City Life Committee.

18
00:05:34.781 --> 00:05:48.389
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/city-life-committee or by calling through Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

19
00:05:48.639 --> 00:05:51.319
<v Unidentified speaker>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

20
00:05:51.319 --> 00:05:54.389
<v Unidentified speaker>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

21
00:05:54.560 --> 00:05:59.139
<v Unidentified speaker>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

22
00:05:59.139 --> 00:06:00.980
<v Unidentified speaker>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

23
00:06:01.220 --> 00:06:02.339
<v Unidentified speaker>The chair preserves order.

24
00:06:02.339 --> 00:06:08.459
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

25
00:06:08.459 --> 00:06:10.220
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

26
00:06:10.220 --> 00:06:12.480
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption results in ejection from the meeting.

27
00:06:12.480 --> 00:06:15.019
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

28
00:06:15.019 --> 00:06:17.744
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess reconvene virtually.

29
00:06:18.807 --> 00:06:20.625
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

30
00:06:20.673 --> 00:06:22.300
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, state your name for the record.

31
00:06:22.348 --> 00:06:24.778
<v Unidentified speaker>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

32
00:06:25.019 --> 00:06:27.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

33
00:06:27.514 --> 00:06:27.805
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

34
00:06:29.591 --> 00:06:30.348
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Christopher.

35
00:06:30.478 --> 00:06:45.565
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I am going to save most of my introductory remarks to our meeting, um, for the beginning of agenda items 3 and 4, uh, but we do have one big topic on our agenda today, 2 agenda items that will address that topic.

36
00:06:45.629 --> 00:06:51.002
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll be looking at City-owned performing arts spaces broadly.

37
00:06:51.466 --> 00:07:02.142
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But before we get there, we do need to approve our June committee minutes and hear from a couple of folks about other important topics that they'd like to make sure we consider.

38
00:07:02.608 --> 00:07:05.562
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Donny, I don't want— we're going to make you move in a minute, Donny.

39
00:07:05.915 --> 00:07:07.360
<v Donny Oliveira>I got it.

40
00:07:08.178 --> 00:07:11.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sorry, we'll get you quickly, I promise.

41
00:07:11.855 --> 00:07:13.749
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But Diego, could you please read agenda item 1?

42
00:07:14.536 --> 00:07:20.074
<v Donny Oliveira>Item 1, June 9th to June 23rd, 2026, City Life Committee meeting minutes.

43
00:07:22.161 --> 00:07:25.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, is there unanimous consent to approve the minutes?

44
00:07:25.519 --> 00:07:25.600
<v Donny Oliveira>Yes.

45
00:07:26.375 --> 00:07:28.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Murillo, any objections?

46
00:07:30.805 --> 00:07:31.259
<v Melissa Finkel>None at all.

47
00:07:31.858 --> 00:07:32.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

48
00:07:34.675 --> 00:07:36.245
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have approved the minutes.

49
00:07:36.310 --> 00:07:38.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Diego, could you please read agenda item number 2?

50
00:07:39.536 --> 00:07:45.819
<v Donny Oliveira>Item 2, document number 2026-268, public input on City Life Committee topics.

51
00:07:46.588 --> 00:07:47.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

52
00:07:47.629 --> 00:08:03.723
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, we open up this time every meeting to hear from Portlanders about topics related to the work of our committee, but not related to agenda— to items on that meeting's agenda, to make sure that there's nothing that we're missing going on.

53
00:08:03.819 --> 00:08:05.439
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think we have 2 people signed up today.

54
00:08:05.519 --> 00:08:10.882
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So Diego, if you could please call up First up, Melissa Finkel.

55
00:08:15.718 --> 00:08:16.055
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

56
00:08:16.119 --> 00:08:17.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here with us today.

57
00:08:17.485 --> 00:08:18.288
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

58
00:08:20.120 --> 00:08:20.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Should I go ahead?

59
00:08:21.004 --> 00:08:21.357
<v Dan Ryan>All right.

60
00:08:21.422 --> 00:08:23.848
<v Melissa Finkel>Good afternoon, Chair and members of the City Life Committee.

61
00:08:23.911 --> 00:08:27.050
<v Melissa Finkel>My name is Melissa Finkel and I am a Parkrose business owner.

62
00:08:27.615 --> 00:08:34.544
<v Melissa Finkel>Over the past month, I've personally called many businesses and property owners who would have been required to pay the ESD assessment.

63
00:08:35.126 --> 00:08:45.142
<v Melissa Finkel>The overwhelming response was that of surprise, Most had no idea this proposal existed or that they could be required to pay an annual fee for the next 10 years.

64
00:08:45.816 --> 00:08:52.067
<v Melissa Finkel>That raises an important question: how did the city determine this proposal had broad community support?

65
00:08:52.788 --> 00:08:58.318
<v Melissa Finkel>At the July 14th hearing, the city ESD coordinator pointed to mailers, public meetings, and an online survey.

66
00:08:58.783 --> 00:09:01.926
<v Melissa Finkel>But mailers only provide notice; they don't demonstrate support.

67
00:09:02.471 --> 00:09:07.585
<v Melissa Finkel>The city survey received just 5 responses, all opposing the proposal.

68
00:09:08.081 --> 00:09:15.267
<v Melissa Finkel>Meanwhile, Protect Parkrose has identified pairs presenting— representing more than 55% of the proposed assessment base who oppose it.

69
00:09:15.797 --> 00:09:28.841
<v Melissa Finkel>We simply ask the city to explain what objective criteria it uses to determine that an ESD has sufficient community support before advancing a proposal involving millions of dollars in mandatory fees.

70
00:09:29.433 --> 00:09:40.792
<v Melissa Finkel>There is also growing concern among business and property owners about Historic Parkrose's financial condition based on its publicly available IRS form 990 filings.

71
00:09:41.144 --> 00:09:58.783
<v Melissa Finkel>Before any nonprofit is entrusted with managing millions of dollars in mandatory assessments, the city should be conducting independent financial due diligence to ensure the organization is financially stable and capable of managing a long-term public contract.

72
00:09:59.489 --> 00:10:04.888
<v Melissa Finkel>These issues extend beyond Parkrose and is going to District 3 and 4 here real soon.

73
00:10:05.496 --> 00:10:17.759
<v Melissa Finkel>We respectfully ask the committee to strengthen the city standard ordinances for evaluating both community support and the financial qualifications of organizations seeking to manage ESD funds.

74
00:10:17.985 --> 00:10:18.599
<v Melissa Finkel>Thank you for your time.

75
00:10:20.370 --> 00:10:21.261
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here.

76
00:10:22.990 --> 00:10:26.201
<v Donny Oliveira>Next is Ghalib bin Imhotep.

77
00:10:31.090 --> 00:10:31.833
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good afternoon.

78
00:10:37.907 --> 00:10:38.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead when you're ready.

79
00:10:39.351 --> 00:10:41.182
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Yes, this happens twice.

80
00:10:41.455 --> 00:10:45.839
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>This is— first, I'm in a quasi-judicial, uh, meeting or hearing.

81
00:10:46.594 --> 00:10:48.456
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Now there's a packed house.

82
00:10:48.585 --> 00:10:51.716
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I thought this would be a little bit more, uh, personable.

83
00:10:52.759 --> 00:10:54.461
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I need you to really speak into that mic.

84
00:10:54.605 --> 00:10:56.484
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm very nervous.

85
00:10:56.613 --> 00:11:03.847
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Let me begin this speech by paying homage to Zinzula Maat, One of the strongest women I will ever meet in my life.

86
00:11:04.923 --> 00:11:09.779
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>What she helped me become, I can only offer my utmost appreciation for.

87
00:11:10.360 --> 00:11:13.216
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Today she celebrates her 47th turn around the sun.

88
00:11:14.269 --> 00:11:21.421
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I love you, sister, with all my heart and soul, and I will that your 47th rotation be abundant.

89
00:11:22.850 --> 00:11:23.600
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Enjoy yourself.

90
00:11:24.663 --> 00:11:25.595
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Good afternoon, councilors.

91
00:11:26.649 --> 00:11:30.549
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I am Ghalib bin Imhotep El, and I am domiciled in District 4.

92
00:11:31.807 --> 00:11:43.488
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I will be brief because in matters of this nature, I have— I often have a hard time finding words to convey what I am thinking, attempting to achieve, and the motivations for them.

93
00:11:44.985 --> 00:11:53.099
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>So I'll state for the public record the answers to those 3 questions, backed by the trust that I have sworn an oath-bound duty to uphold.

94
00:11:54.294 --> 00:11:57.326
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Whenever I ask myself these 3 questions, the answers, they don't change.

95
00:11:58.164 --> 00:11:59.131
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>What am I thinking about?

96
00:11:59.455 --> 00:12:00.197
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>What am I thinking about?

97
00:12:01.605 --> 00:12:06.105
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Orion Stewart McFarland, Zaire James McFarland, and Cyrus Armstrong McFarland.

98
00:12:09.347 --> 00:12:11.153
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>What am I attempting to achieve?

99
00:12:12.047 --> 00:12:12.942
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>A legacy for them.

100
00:12:15.393 --> 00:12:16.312
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>What are my motivations?

101
00:12:18.995 --> 00:12:24.493
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Orion Stewart McFarland, Zaire James McFarland, And Cyrus Armstrong McFarland.

102
00:12:26.825 --> 00:12:28.621
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I think you can understand the difficulty now.

103
00:12:30.029 --> 00:12:35.754
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I have an extensive background, but I also have something else, something that will greatly benefit Portland.

104
00:12:36.850 --> 00:12:44.890
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>The moment that I shared outside of the Roseland with Councilor Avalos— I wish she could be here— but that moment, I don't know if she shared with you, I'll cherish that moment for the rest of my life.

105
00:12:45.118 --> 00:12:49.212
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I have a picture of it, and I can smile about it, and I know I will forever.

106
00:12:49.278 --> 00:12:49.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

107
00:12:51.844 --> 00:13:03.226
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Before that happened, there was a woman that came from Councilor Green's campaign kickoff, I guess, and she was trying to solicit for a vote saying that he supported street dogs.

108
00:13:03.274 --> 00:13:06.004
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>And I'm thinking to myself, well, if he does, then I would definitely support him.

109
00:13:06.068 --> 00:13:08.397
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>And I told him the same thing that I'm going to tell you guys today.

110
00:13:08.942 --> 00:13:12.121
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I met him, I shook his hand, I spoke to him, and I love the guy.

111
00:13:13.534 --> 00:13:15.284
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I'm asking for a small amount of support.

112
00:13:15.332 --> 00:13:15.445
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

113
00:13:16.495 --> 00:13:21.139
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>To boost this concept to the answer of what it is that I am attempting to achieve.

114
00:13:22.447 --> 00:13:23.495
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>And I think it's highly feasible.

115
00:13:24.529 --> 00:13:27.205
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>The documents that I have submitted to the council clerk are for your review.

116
00:13:28.798 --> 00:13:38.886
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>There would be no greater irony than to have a street dog vendor in Boston hand a guy a Portlander after the Trail Blazers put the Celtics out of the NBA Finals.

117
00:13:41.034 --> 00:13:47.942
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>I do not allow any decision or action made by any one person or group of people decide how I feel about them.

118
00:13:48.919 --> 00:13:58.780
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Whatever I agree with or disagree— whenever I agree with or disagree with things as I perceive them, it doesn't change the fact that I love you all unconditionally.

119
00:13:58.846 --> 00:13:59.493
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Thank you.

120
00:13:59.735 --> 00:14:01.400
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here today with us.

121
00:14:02.630 --> 00:14:03.715
<v Donny Oliveira>That concludes testimony.

122
00:14:05.730 --> 00:14:10.341
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, that moves us to agenda item 3.

123
00:14:10.407 --> 00:14:18.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Diego, I'll have you open agenda item 3 and And then I wanna make a few comments about agenda items 3 and 4.

124
00:14:19.182 --> 00:14:19.585
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

125
00:14:19.986 --> 00:14:21.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Open it together?

126
00:14:21.195 --> 00:14:22.339
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, just agenda item 3.

127
00:14:22.966 --> 00:14:23.288
<v Sue Pack>Thank you.

128
00:14:23.530 --> 00:14:28.908
<v Donny Oliveira>Item 3, document number 2026-269, Performing Arts Venues Discussion.

129
00:14:30.677 --> 00:14:31.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

130
00:14:31.681 --> 00:14:36.649
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, over the last year, we have had a lot of conversation about city assets.

131
00:14:37.677 --> 00:14:48.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Some more notable high-profile conversations recently, but also about things like Bathrooms and parks and office buildings and generally how the city maintains what we own.

132
00:14:49.539 --> 00:14:55.996
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Some, but not all Portlanders may know that we as a city own a number of performing arts venues.

133
00:14:56.894 --> 00:15:05.962
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That ownership means that we're in a position to think strategically about our arts ecosystem and how we support and have space for the different players in that ecosystem.

134
00:15:07.325 --> 00:15:19.202
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are entering into what has been about a 10-year conversation about some of the needs in that ecosystem, including the future of what is now our largest venue, the Keller, and what that looks like moving forward.

135
00:15:20.149 --> 00:15:25.649
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's also a lot happening outside of that conversation, though, that relates to our venues.

136
00:15:26.580 --> 00:15:43.739
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So today we're going to start a conversation about the city's venues broadly, what we own, the transfer and management of those venues, which were previously managed by Metro, and, and other broad broad pieces of background around our city-owned performing arts venues.

137
00:15:45.456 --> 00:15:54.263
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As always, we'll have an opportunity for councilors to ask questions so that we can have a strong shared understanding of what the city-owned performing arts ecosystem looks like.

138
00:15:55.215 --> 00:16:15.114
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a conversation that the Arts and Economy Committee stepped into last year, but multiple councilors on and off this committee, as well as a number of stakeholders, have asked that we have this conversation today in this committee so that we all have that background about our broader venue ecosystem.

139
00:16:16.123 --> 00:16:24.360
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The second half of our meeting, we will be specifically talking about the work around the future of our large-scale performing arts venues.

140
00:16:25.577 --> 00:16:36.812
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There has been a 10-year process, including substantial work not only by the previous City Commission, but also in our own Arts and Economy Committee last year around this topic.

141
00:16:36.972 --> 00:16:47.697
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that work culminated in a workgroup that met over the last 6 months and which released a report of its recommendations just a few weeks ago.

142
00:16:48.674 --> 00:17:07.756
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to thank Councilors Clark and Dunphy, who sat on that workgroup, for being a part of that work and bringing council's voice, or the voice at least of The workgroup report, which came out last month, looks at the future of large-scale performing arts venues in our city.

143
00:17:08.736 --> 00:17:16.493
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We now have a resolution before us that includes the mayor's recommendation on how to move forward with those workgroup recommendations.

144
00:17:17.634 --> 00:17:33.266
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>During that second portion of the meeting, we'll hear from both supporters of the recommendation as well as folks who may have a few concerns but were a part of the process, as well as representatives of the workers who will be affected directly by any changes in our performing arts spaces.

145
00:17:34.180 --> 00:17:40.241
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll also have an opportunity to hear a significant amount of public testimony during that part of the meeting.

146
00:17:41.172 --> 00:17:47.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Depending on time, we will have council discussion today and consider any possible amendments.

147
00:17:47.170 --> 00:17:58.538
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if we don't have time, because I do want to make sure we hear as much public testimony as possible, We will plan to carry the agenda item over to our next meeting, which will be Tuesday, August 11th.

148
00:17:59.907 --> 00:18:03.290
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to say a word before we dive in about the importance of this topic.

149
00:18:04.257 --> 00:18:12.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've heard from some who have asked why this conversation about spaces the city owns and invests in is so critical.

150
00:18:13.499 --> 00:18:17.268
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're not talking about our streets, our public safety, our parks and pools.

151
00:18:18.377 --> 00:18:35.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But the City of Portland has made a longstanding commitment, truly over decades, to say that as a city, we value having a robust arts ecosystem, that it's good for Portland's economy, that it's good for our arts and culture scene, and that it's good for Portlanders.

152
00:18:36.923 --> 00:18:42.929
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As a city, we've always made sure that there's space not only for our larger performing arts companies, but also for the smaller ones.

153
00:18:43.843 --> 00:18:55.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To the extent that I recently learned that we have over 700 nonprofit arts organizations, roughly twice the size as many other cities have.

154
00:18:56.425 --> 00:19:14.858
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Now, we can have varying opinions about whether that's a good or a bad thing for our city, but what I know is that it creates opportunities for artists to try creative things they might not otherwise be able to do and creates opportunities for Portlanders to engage with art that's speaks to them, that represents them in ways that they might not otherwise experience.

155
00:19:16.112 --> 00:19:23.415
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That happens in part because our city has made this concerted commitment, not just through our venues, but through a host of programs to support the arts ecosystem.

156
00:19:24.988 --> 00:19:36.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So as we dive into the conversation today, I hope that we can spend this first half thinking about our commitment through our venues, just one part of that commitment to the arts more broadly, and what that looks like.

157
00:19:37.054 --> 00:19:46.565
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then we'll dive into the more specific question before us around the workgroups that we've seen over the past few years and this most recent recommendation.

158
00:19:48.413 --> 00:19:51.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So with that, we're going to jump into agenda item 3.

159
00:19:51.455 --> 00:20:01.093
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to ask our DCA for Community and Economic Development, Donny Oliveira, and Sue Pack from our Arts and Culture Office— are you all in office?

160
00:20:01.271 --> 00:20:01.434
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Yes.

161
00:20:02.016 --> 00:20:03.538
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, the Arts and Culture Office.

162
00:20:03.634 --> 00:20:04.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

163
00:20:04.836 --> 00:20:13.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To come forward so that we can hear some background on the state of our performing arts venues in Portland right now.

164
00:20:14.134 --> 00:20:14.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

165
00:20:14.615 --> 00:20:15.913
<v Donny Oliveira>Okay, thank you, Chair.

166
00:20:16.762 --> 00:20:17.627
<v Donny Oliveira>Good afternoon, councilors.

167
00:20:18.557 --> 00:20:20.240
<v Donny Oliveira>For the record, my name is Donny Oliveira.

168
00:20:20.465 --> 00:20:24.553
<v Donny Oliveira>I'm the Deputy City Administrator with the Community and Economic Development Service Area.

169
00:20:25.499 --> 00:20:28.896
<v Donny Oliveira>I'm joined by Supak from the Office of Arts and Culture.

170
00:20:29.665 --> 00:20:34.137
<v Donny Oliveira>Who's not here with us right now is Director Montez, who's on personal leave.

171
00:20:34.875 --> 00:20:42.938
<v Donny Oliveira>And I want to first start by saying, Charity, I hope you're not watching this, and if you are, we're sending you good vibes and, uh, get well soon.

172
00:20:44.092 --> 00:20:49.011
<v Donny Oliveira>All right, um, so some of the content, um, that we're going to share with you today is very familiar.

173
00:20:49.540 --> 00:21:07.446
<v Donny Oliveira>It's been presented at the committee meetings or shared in memos over the past year and a half, but we know that this topic, uh, is understandably of high interest to our community members, our, our aficionados, the people that come to Portland from the broader region and state that are passionate about the arts.

174
00:21:08.249 --> 00:21:12.953
<v Donny Oliveira>Our civic arts facilities are a source of pride and culture, and they contribute to our local creative economy.

175
00:21:13.483 --> 00:21:16.182
<v Donny Oliveira>So today's discussion will survey a lot of topics on this issue.

176
00:21:16.680 --> 00:21:23.151
<v Donny Oliveira>We'll do our best to hit the key points and can pause for questions along the way, but we're in for a bit of content.

177
00:21:23.199 --> 00:21:24.661
<v Donny Oliveira>So let's, uh, let's get into it.

178
00:21:24.709 --> 00:21:25.318
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

179
00:21:26.788 --> 00:21:28.748
<v Donny Oliveira>Real quick, just want to cover what we're going to talk about.

180
00:21:28.910 --> 00:21:35.385
<v Donny Oliveira>The chair did a great job of outlining this, but we're really going to focus on the Portland 5 Center for the Arts transition first.

181
00:21:36.140 --> 00:21:41.657
<v Donny Oliveira>We'll dive into what's going on there and then really then speak to the large-scale performing arts venue conversations.

182
00:21:42.161 --> 00:21:42.631
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

183
00:21:45.567 --> 00:21:46.195
<v Donny Oliveira>Yeah, thank you.

184
00:21:46.759 --> 00:21:48.224
<v Donny Oliveira>All right, so what are we talking about here?

185
00:21:48.272 --> 00:21:51.396
<v Donny Oliveira>First and foremost, let's set the stage, no pun intended.

186
00:21:51.444 --> 00:21:52.097
<v Donny Oliveira>So there are Yes.

187
00:21:52.145 --> 00:21:54.778
<v Donny Oliveira>So we have 5 performing arts facilities owned by the City of Portland.

188
00:21:55.757 --> 00:21:58.388
<v Donny Oliveira>Currently, they're all operated by Metro in 3 buildings.

189
00:21:58.999 --> 00:22:01.116
<v Donny Oliveira>They range in size, in age.

190
00:22:01.775 --> 00:22:06.782
<v Donny Oliveira>Obviously, we have the larger Keller Auditorium, which is 109 years old.

191
00:22:07.407 --> 00:22:11.628
<v Donny Oliveira>And then we also have the Hauptfeld Hall built in the '80s that contains the 3 smaller theaters.

192
00:22:12.384 --> 00:22:23.051
<v Donny Oliveira>These facilities are home to some of our most well-known performing arts organizations and host both large— larger commercial productions like Broadway, as well as smaller nonprofit performances and events like Councilor Pirtle-Guiney alluded to.

193
00:22:23.941 --> 00:22:24.653
<v Donny Oliveira>Uh, next slide, please.

194
00:22:28.279 --> 00:22:33.078
<v Donny Oliveira>Uh, these facilities are important cultural assets and contribute significantly to our local economy and civic life.

195
00:22:33.779 --> 00:22:39.597
<v Donny Oliveira>They draw visitors to Portland, create jobs and other economic spending, and host hundreds of public events each year.

196
00:22:40.626 --> 00:22:41.093
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

197
00:22:43.969 --> 00:23:02.926
<v Donny Oliveira>So first and foremost, as I said, we're going to focus at 2 bodies of work that the Arts and Office of Culture and many city employees had supported, uh, first, uh, the process of how we got to the, the transition plan for Portland 5, and then the port— uh, the future of the large-scale performing arts contemplation between renovating Keller and a potential new venue at PSU.

198
00:23:04.057 --> 00:23:04.443
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide.

199
00:23:06.355 --> 00:23:07.001
<v Eric Zimmerman>Again, thank you.

200
00:23:07.744 --> 00:23:11.797
<v Donny Oliveira>All right, let's do some background here for the public's FYI, just to set the stage here.

201
00:23:12.652 --> 00:23:23.949
<v Donny Oliveira>Um, so currently, um, the city's relationship with Metro is that we are The owners of the facilities, but have an existing IGA with Metro for the operations of the P5 venues.

202
00:23:24.285 --> 00:23:26.175
<v Donny Oliveira>That's been in place since the late '80s.

203
00:23:27.170 --> 00:23:38.740
<v Donny Oliveira>It's been updated several times, the IGA, but ultimately where we're at today is we are looking at a scenario where Metro's made a decision that's going to be changing that come 2027.

204
00:23:39.828 --> 00:23:46.818
<v Donny Oliveira>In 2022, there was an audit contemplated by Metro That identified issues with the existing model.

205
00:23:47.693 --> 00:23:52.800
<v Donny Oliveira>And one of the key themes that was addressed was the challenges of addressing the facility's capital needs and the current structure.

206
00:23:54.195 --> 00:23:54.818
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

207
00:23:57.720 --> 00:24:06.461
<v Donny Oliveira>Simultaneously, in 2024, City Council adopted a resolution that created the Performing Arts Venue Workgroup.

208
00:24:07.234 --> 00:24:11.361
<v Donny Oliveira>This made up— was made up of key stakeholders to evaluate the manage of the facilities.

209
00:24:11.571 --> 00:24:22.941
<v Donny Oliveira>So on one hand, we had Metro as the operator doing an audit, and then as the owner, we sort of dove into what would be the optimal setting for efficiency and management of our facilities.

210
00:24:23.535 --> 00:24:35.057
<v Donny Oliveira>The resolution directed the creation of this workgroup to really identify those, those questions, um, do some assessments, um, and ultimately, uh, bring together recommendations or ideas for a future state of operations.

211
00:24:35.651 --> 00:24:36.180
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

212
00:24:37.576 --> 00:24:42.615
<v Donny Oliveira>Just want to take a moment to, uh, name but also appreciate and acknowledge the folks that contributed to that working group.

213
00:24:43.738 --> 00:24:46.404
<v Donny Oliveira>They convened between January and June in 2025.

214
00:24:47.432 --> 00:24:53.612
<v Donny Oliveira>And ultimately, this group was thinking about advancing the directive of that work resolution.

215
00:24:54.147 --> 00:25:00.827
<v Donny Oliveira>Specifically, they considered the opportunities and challenges to both the immediate and long-term operations and ultimately the planning for the future of the venues.

216
00:25:01.934 --> 00:25:02.424
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

217
00:25:04.779 --> 00:25:08.367
<v Donny Oliveira>One of the issues the workgroup looked at was the capital needs of the P5 facilities.

218
00:25:09.113 --> 00:25:13.445
<v Donny Oliveira>They emphasized that funding capital needs through operating budget is a poor practice and should be discontinued.

219
00:25:14.249 --> 00:25:22.161
<v Donny Oliveira>And they recommended building a capital fund and beginning capital planning immediately, starting with facility condition assessments, which Metro actually completed this spring.

220
00:25:22.433 --> 00:25:23.526
<v Donny Oliveira>And we have some details on those.

221
00:25:24.359 --> 00:25:37.568
<v Donny Oliveira>But ultimately, what we're looking at is if the city is going to operate— or excuse me, manage these facilities and operate them for the long term, we had to address head-on the deferred backlog of maintenance necessary to not just keep the buildings running, but to modernize them.

222
00:25:37.858 --> 00:25:44.125
<v Donny Oliveira>And keep them fresh, fresh for the needs of the modern artists and visitors.

223
00:25:44.885 --> 00:25:45.500
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

224
00:25:47.250 --> 00:25:52.093
<v Donny Oliveira>So at a high level, the group recommended changing the 2-government model.

225
00:25:53.808 --> 00:25:59.519
<v Donny Oliveira>Fundamentally, that's unique to our setup and not recommended or seen across the country.

226
00:26:00.890 --> 00:26:04.050
<v Donny Oliveira>The working group recommended that the city and Metro start preparing to dissolve the IGA.

227
00:26:04.133 --> 00:26:04.346
<v Melissa Finkel>Thank you.

228
00:26:05.039 --> 00:26:10.857
<v Donny Oliveira>And that the city, as the owner of these facilities, ultimately decide what new operating model for the facilities would be the most effective.

229
00:26:12.674 --> 00:26:13.173
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

230
00:26:16.180 --> 00:26:21.714
<v Donny Oliveira>During that, uh, that working group convening, they contemplated several different scenarios to further explore.

231
00:26:22.148 --> 00:26:23.001
<v Donny Oliveira>Those are all listed here.

232
00:26:23.913 --> 00:26:30.757
<v Donny Oliveira>And while they didn't recommend a specific alternative model, they did provide some options that we would consider and that needed further investigation.

233
00:26:30.821 --> 00:26:30.934
<v Sue Pack>Thank you.

234
00:26:31.845 --> 00:26:40.025
<v Donny Oliveira>For example, the city could contract with another operator outside, whether it be nonprofit or for-profit or university, to take over the functions currently managed by Metro.

235
00:26:40.609 --> 00:26:49.648
<v Donny Oliveira>The city could take on the work of managing the facilities themselves, or there could be a mix-match of different ways we could break up the facilities to be managed.

236
00:26:49.713 --> 00:26:52.688
<v Donny Oliveira>The point being is lots of ideas that needed further exploration.

237
00:26:53.809 --> 00:26:54.344
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

238
00:26:56.503 --> 00:26:59.979
<v Donny Oliveira>And just for context, just to kind of paint the further picture of what we're solving for here.

239
00:27:00.732 --> 00:27:07.003
<v Donny Oliveira>This is a very complex system that we're talking about, and that complexity adds to the challenges identifying next steps.

240
00:27:07.662 --> 00:27:16.853
<v Donny Oliveira>So the programming is driven by resident companies such as Oregon Symphony, Portland Opera, Oregon Ballet, plus Broadway Across America, which, which together make up much of the content.

241
00:27:16.932 --> 00:27:25.755
<v Donny Oliveira>But we also make the spaces available for nonprofit arts organizations and commercial presenters who rent out on some of those open dates when the resident companies aren't active.

242
00:27:26.671 --> 00:27:33.688
<v Donny Oliveira>There's a $25 million annual operating budget that across the whole portfolio essentially breaks even, and we'll talk about that in a second.

243
00:27:34.666 --> 00:27:38.038
<v Donny Oliveira>P5 has 450 employees, all of which are currently Metro staff.

244
00:27:38.842 --> 00:27:43.515
<v Donny Oliveira>Those staff are represented by 6 collective bargaining agreements, 4 of which are being negotiated this year.

245
00:27:44.478 --> 00:27:49.584
<v Donny Oliveira>Metro also supports the central services for those staff in the venues more broadly to the tune about $4 million.

246
00:27:50.259 --> 00:27:57.855
<v Donny Oliveira>So when we think about that, it's important to contemplate what the city of Portland would look like If we were going to be managing those central services on behalf of the, the P5 employees.

247
00:27:58.547 --> 00:28:06.428
<v Donny Oliveira>I'm also— just to add flavor to this, there are approximately 150 vendor and partner agreements that make up the ecosystem of how those venues are run today.

248
00:28:08.380 --> 00:28:08.913
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

249
00:28:11.492 --> 00:28:16.457
<v Donny Oliveira>So the process of dissolving the IGA really picked up in earnest, um, this past year.

250
00:28:17.377 --> 00:28:21.803
<v Donny Oliveira>On December 31st, Metro notified the city of their intent to withdraw from P5 operations.

251
00:28:22.896 --> 00:28:25.627
<v Donny Oliveira>That was completely within the realm of the IGA, so it was totally appropriate.

252
00:28:25.708 --> 00:28:28.776
<v Donny Oliveira>There was no surprises, so we were aware that that was happening.

253
00:28:29.176 --> 00:28:37.175
<v Donny Oliveira>And then per the IGA, that set off an 18-month preparation window, which means that the transfer of the management would go into effect on July 1st, 2027.

254
00:28:38.251 --> 00:28:45.077
<v Donny Oliveira>So that gives us about a year to figure out what operating structure we would want and to ensure that we have that in place ready to go on July 1st.

255
00:28:45.544 --> 00:28:48.259
<v Donny Oliveira>If Charity Woods was here, she could tell you the exact days remaining.

256
00:28:48.307 --> 00:28:48.419
<v Dan Ryan>I'm here.

257
00:28:48.705 --> 00:28:49.653
<v Donny Oliveira>As she tracks that every day.

258
00:28:51.099 --> 00:28:53.961
<v Donny Oliveira>So given this very aggressive timeline, we didn't waste any time.

259
00:28:54.730 --> 00:29:06.422
<v Donny Oliveira>And due to the complexity of the system, which we covered just in the last slide, over the past several months we've been collecting information and data to best inform the next steps of what it will look like for the city to take over this body of work.

260
00:29:07.500 --> 00:29:08.038
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

261
00:29:10.596 --> 00:29:17.199
<v Donny Oliveira>So first and foremost, we wanted to understand what types of options we had on the table beyond the obvious of the city taking over operations.

262
00:29:17.740 --> 00:29:23.019
<v Donny Oliveira>So in January, Arts and Culture put out an RFI to get ideas for how we might approach this decision.

263
00:29:23.750 --> 00:29:25.608
<v Donny Oliveira>We wanted to understand the concepts for operating models.

264
00:29:25.787 --> 00:29:32.157
<v Donny Oliveira>We wanted to understand potential partners, who was out there, who was potentially in the market to take on our venues.

265
00:29:33.730 --> 00:29:35.423
<v Donny Oliveira>The responses we got back— oh, next slide, please.

266
00:29:37.228 --> 00:29:41.194
<v Donny Oliveira>The responses we got back from the RFI were very helpful in illustrating the range of options.

267
00:29:41.984 --> 00:29:42.775
<v Donny Oliveira>We got 9 responses.

268
00:29:43.342 --> 00:29:47.769
<v Donny Oliveira>Including existing nonprofits, existing for-profits, and a proposal to create new— a new entity.

269
00:29:48.797 --> 00:29:57.508
<v Donny Oliveira>Several respondents had experience in large-scale venue management, and a few specifically in large-scale venue development, which is relevant to the— given the capital needs of our P5 facilities.

270
00:29:58.598 --> 00:30:06.942
<v Donny Oliveira>Most would integrate venue, um, current venue users into their programming models while filling the calendar with more commercial and community center events.

271
00:30:07.006 --> 00:30:09.058
<v Donny Oliveira>The idea there is getting more out of the venues we have.

272
00:30:09.251 --> 00:30:10.344
<v Donny Oliveira>That was very exciting to us.

273
00:30:11.162 --> 00:30:19.864
<v Donny Oliveira>All respondents addressed capital investments, indicating that either the city holds responsibility for deferred maintenance and capital improvements, or the city works in partnership with the venue operator.

274
00:30:19.943 --> 00:30:35.548
<v Donny Oliveira>So the idea here is, as we're contemplating a new operator, potentially a third-party operator, what the role the city would have in that operator and identifying the needs, investing in the needs, generating the revenue for those investments to keep those facilities up and running.

275
00:30:36.144 --> 00:30:36.755
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

276
00:30:38.797 --> 00:30:48.460
<v Donny Oliveira>As I alluded to earlier, Metro conducted the facility condition assessments that were really fundamental in helping us understand the need of our venues.

277
00:30:50.061 --> 00:30:55.868
<v Donny Oliveira>In short, we have a significant backlog of investments needed to maintain current service level.

278
00:30:56.595 --> 00:31:02.958
<v Donny Oliveira>And of course, that's trying to get us out as many years as possible, but we have aging facilities that demand investment soon.

279
00:31:03.634 --> 00:31:09.349
<v Donny Oliveira>For example, the Keller was constructed in 1918 and its last major renovation was in 1968.

280
00:31:10.155 --> 00:31:17.255
<v Donny Oliveira>So investments are needed in the theatrical and building envelope systems to keep the facility running to maintain current service levels for the next 10 years.

281
00:31:19.446 --> 00:31:26.545
<v Donny Oliveira>The Schnitzer Concert Hall is already a designated historic landmark, originally constructed in 1927 and last renovated in 1984.

282
00:31:27.990 --> 00:31:35.463
<v Donny Oliveira>So many of the assemblies and systems there are now or approaching end of useful life due to age and heavy use.

283
00:31:36.519 --> 00:31:40.922
<v Donny Oliveira>The Hatfield Hall was constructed in 1987 and has been well maintained and is showing normal wear and tear.

284
00:31:41.454 --> 00:31:47.196
<v Donny Oliveira>But nonetheless, it's a space that we want to ensure that we continue to invest in to maximize its usefulness.

285
00:31:48.435 --> 00:31:48.990
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

286
00:31:50.871 --> 00:31:52.006
<v Donny Oliveira>So here we are today.

287
00:31:53.699 --> 00:31:58.960
<v Donny Oliveira>As we move towards July 27th, the next key step is honing in on the operating model.

288
00:31:59.900 --> 00:32:04.867
<v Donny Oliveira>We heard from our working group last year that an operating partner should no longer be Metro, so we're working through that.

289
00:32:05.640 --> 00:32:13.825
<v Donny Oliveira>We learned from our RFI this spring that there might be folks with the right set of skills interested in taking on the work, and we're aware of the limited capacity we have at the city to take over management.

290
00:32:15.623 --> 00:32:31.270
<v Donny Oliveira>What we did was we worked with the service area, the business operations service area, with DCA Tracy Warren And her team looked at procurement, BHR, excuse me, human resources, technology service to understand the impact to the city to take on those operations.

291
00:32:32.073 --> 00:32:45.265
<v Donny Oliveira>They were able to provide some real clear and durable information for us to balance the weight of taking on the operations and the financial burden and capacity limitations of existing staff versus the third-party operative.

292
00:32:46.275 --> 00:32:53.713
<v Donny Oliveira>And so with all that in mind, we determined that the best path forward was to move forward with a request for proposal to identify a third-party operator.

293
00:32:54.660 --> 00:33:10.632
<v Donny Oliveira>And what that looks like is, um, in August, the Arts and Culture Office will be launching an RFP that will invite professional venue operators to propose improved and sustainable operating models, uh, for contemplation for us to decide by the end of this calendar year.

294
00:33:11.513 --> 00:33:16.051
<v Donny Oliveira>We've talked with existing operators and consultants about this timeline.

295
00:33:16.099 --> 00:33:24.569
<v Donny Oliveira>It's incredibly aggressive, but we do believe if we're to stay on track and have somebody on board by December, they would be in place ready to go on July 1st.

296
00:33:24.618 --> 00:33:27.355
<v Donny Oliveira>So we'd have no disruption of services or operations at the venues.

297
00:33:30.977 --> 00:33:37.573
<v Donny Oliveira>And I'm going to stop there before moving on to the large-scale venues, if there's any questions about P5.

298
00:33:39.464 --> 00:33:51.232
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, any questions about the venues we own, the transfer of operation, the RFI that's out there, or other things related into this first part of our time today.

299
00:33:53.849 --> 00:33:56.010
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, you look like you might have something.

300
00:33:56.628 --> 00:33:59.489
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I just want to actually compliment the fact that we're here.

301
00:34:00.165 --> 00:34:11.402
<v Dan Ryan>I think in this conversation about the capital, we, we haven't had as much dialogue about the operations, and I think this simplifies it, that, that there's one government entity.

302
00:34:11.746 --> 00:34:20.514
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm— so congratulations that you've been able to work that out I think what I'm interested in is what are we hoping for when we put out the RFP?

303
00:34:21.623 --> 00:34:29.670
<v Dan Ryan>What are we going to tolerate in terms of— this would be a big change going from a government entity being the hands-on manager.

304
00:34:29.766 --> 00:34:40.302
<v Dan Ryan>And if I'm hearing it right, it looks different going forward in terms of this RFP that's asking for a private entity to be— that we'd subcontract with.

305
00:34:40.351 --> 00:34:40.478
<v Sue Pack>Correct.

306
00:34:41.233 --> 00:34:42.518
<v Dan Ryan>That would be managing the entity.

307
00:34:43.335 --> 00:34:46.097
<v Dan Ryan>So am I tracking what you're saying?

308
00:34:46.289 --> 00:34:46.884
<v Donny Oliveira>That's correct, yeah.

309
00:34:46.931 --> 00:34:47.172
<v Donny Oliveira>Okay.

310
00:34:47.878 --> 00:34:53.030
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm trying to guess who the, you know, the people are that are bidding, but that's not what I'm supposed to do up here.

311
00:34:53.978 --> 00:34:56.963
<v Dan Ryan>But when will I not have to guess and when will those be revealed?

312
00:34:57.766 --> 00:34:59.693
<v Donny Oliveira>Well, we haven't released the RFP yet.

313
00:35:00.253 --> 00:35:00.608
<v Dan Ryan>There's that.

314
00:35:00.655 --> 00:35:03.802
<v Donny Oliveira>And so our RFP will be released in mid-August.

315
00:35:04.492 --> 00:35:08.568
<v Donny Oliveira>And once we have received submissions, then we'll run through a selection process.

316
00:35:09.306 --> 00:35:11.039
<v Donny Oliveira>Uh, to determine, you know, the outcome.

317
00:35:11.248 --> 00:35:17.603
<v Donny Oliveira>And I'm, I'm sure we'll work with procurement to find the most appropriate time to daylight those that submitted, you know, their, their letters of interest.

318
00:35:18.454 --> 00:35:20.621
<v Donny Oliveira>Um, but that's the— that'll be the pathway.

319
00:35:20.860 --> 00:35:26.333
<v Dan Ryan>When you look at better practices around the country, um, are we just catching up with them by looking at this model?

320
00:35:27.054 --> 00:35:40.342
<v Donny Oliveira>Yeah, as a part of the evaluation running up to the RFI, through the RFI, and through the selection process, we've been working with subject matter experts around the country to just get a sense of what's the right model, right, where Where is it successful?

321
00:35:40.922 --> 00:35:51.103
<v Donny Oliveira>And we've seen a lot of success around the country with a third-party operator model, often blended between it like a nonprofit-for-profit sort of dynamic that does several things.

322
00:35:51.360 --> 00:36:00.579
<v Donny Oliveira>First, there's strong examples around the country of these third-party operators having strong relationships— always can be improved— but working with labor organizations.

323
00:36:01.028 --> 00:36:08.702
<v Donny Oliveira>So that was something of a priority to us to make sure that our RFP is clear that we want to maintain the labor contracts that are currently— that currently exist at Metro.

324
00:36:08.815 --> 00:36:13.981
<v Donny Oliveira>Obviously, the devil's in the details of how those transfer, but maintaining our labor partnerships is a high priority.

325
00:36:14.590 --> 00:36:18.875
<v Donny Oliveira>Second, we want to make sure we're maximizing every night possible at the venues.

326
00:36:19.228 --> 00:36:25.918
<v Donny Oliveira>So right now, we, we rely on our resident companies who do a great job at filling the nights that they have access to, but is there potential for more nights?

327
00:36:26.030 --> 00:36:29.512
<v Donny Oliveira>Is there more commercial opportunities, uh, that we can activate those venues?

328
00:36:29.815 --> 00:36:37.246
<v Donny Oliveira>And of course, as alluded to multiple times already, How are we ensuring that those spaces are available for our local smaller nonprofits to take advantage of the spaces?

329
00:36:37.985 --> 00:36:42.302
<v Donny Oliveira>All that has to be balanced to ensure that the venues are at cost recovery.

330
00:36:42.719 --> 00:36:44.949
<v Donny Oliveira>I alluded to it earlier, but I want to just say it for the record.

331
00:36:46.025 --> 00:36:53.023
<v Donny Oliveira>Right now, the Colorado Torium's performance is so largely Broadway, those revenues are subsidizing the other operations.

332
00:36:53.552 --> 00:36:57.548
<v Donny Oliveira>We can get to the point though where the other venues are at least at cost recovery.

333
00:36:58.047 --> 00:37:04.257
<v Donny Oliveira>And we shouldn't— we don't have to squint very hard to see an opportunity or a scenario where the venues are actually starting to generate revenue.

334
00:37:04.545 --> 00:37:05.411
<v Donny Oliveira>That seems very viable.

335
00:37:06.150 --> 00:37:12.938
<v Donny Oliveira>We have some work to do to get there, but I think that that should be something that the city sets as a North Star and we work for an operator that can help us do that.

336
00:37:14.092 --> 00:37:16.563
<v Dan Ryan>And another— thank you, that was really helpful.

337
00:37:16.612 --> 00:37:29.755
<v Dan Ryan>So one problem we're trying to solve is that when I've talked to nonprofit leaders over the decades, if you will, they've said that our current operation model they said makes it really difficult for them to be in the black every year.

338
00:37:30.139 --> 00:37:32.291
<v Dan Ryan>Like, it's one of their— they call it out constantly.

339
00:37:32.981 --> 00:37:40.186
<v Dan Ryan>So was feedback from both large and smaller venues part of this decision to do this RFP?

340
00:37:40.411 --> 00:37:40.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

341
00:37:41.855 --> 00:37:44.230
<v Dan Ryan>I'm really grateful that we're at this moment in time.

342
00:37:44.518 --> 00:37:44.728
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Sorry.

343
00:37:44.967 --> 00:37:48.353
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I kind of was mentioning this a few years ago, so this is great.

344
00:37:48.755 --> 00:37:48.916
<v Ghalib bin Imhotep>Yeah.

345
00:37:49.317 --> 00:37:52.222
<v Sue Pack>If I may just add some larger context, Yes.

346
00:37:52.385 --> 00:38:08.927
<v Sue Pack>So of comparable large-scale multi-venue performing arts centers around the country, about a third are publicly owned, but 90% are run by third-party operators.

347
00:38:09.521 --> 00:38:14.150
<v Sue Pack>That this, our two-government system is a unicorn.

348
00:38:15.452 --> 00:38:22.893
<v Sue Pack>And even being a single government-owned and government-operated would also be a unicorn.

349
00:38:26.398 --> 00:38:45.789
<v Sue Pack>And there, as DC Oliveira noted, there are a lot of opportunities within our current model to make improvements in the areas of increasing venue utilization, ticketing strategy, improving our food and beverage program.

350
00:38:46.014 --> 00:39:19.759
<v Sue Pack>And this is where there are a good number of pro-professional venue operators who work nationally and globally that could help us fast-track to an improved sustainable system, given that they will be providing for us lessons learned, best practices, and If the city were to try to figure it out, we would in effect be reinventing the wheel.

351
00:39:22.309 --> 00:39:22.568
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

352
00:39:22.666 --> 00:39:23.929
<v Dan Ryan>These numbers are compelling.

353
00:39:24.365 --> 00:39:28.057
<v Dan Ryan>So we're— 30% are publicly owned, is that what you said?

354
00:39:29.789 --> 00:39:29.918
<v Sue Pack>Yeah.

355
00:39:29.983 --> 00:39:32.498
<v Dan Ryan>And 90% are privately operated.

356
00:39:33.773 --> 00:39:37.288
<v Sue Pack>And largely nonprofits, but yes, nonprofit and commercial.

357
00:39:37.336 --> 00:39:37.385
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

358
00:39:37.731 --> 00:39:39.755
<v Dan Ryan>When I say that, I mean nonprofits usually.

359
00:39:39.871 --> 00:39:40.115
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

360
00:39:40.344 --> 00:39:40.605
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

361
00:39:41.340 --> 00:39:42.762
<v Dan Ryan>Well, let's stop being a unicorn, right?

362
00:39:43.489 --> 00:39:44.333
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, great.

363
00:39:44.494 --> 00:39:44.851
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

364
00:39:45.614 --> 00:39:46.864
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

365
00:39:46.929 --> 00:39:47.708
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

366
00:39:49.606 --> 00:39:50.157
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, thank you.

367
00:39:51.157 --> 00:39:52.809
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Ryan got a lot of my questions in there.

368
00:39:53.521 --> 00:39:54.608
<v Eric Zimmerman>Don, you mentioned one of them.

369
00:39:54.737 --> 00:39:58.657
<v Eric Zimmerman>The last time I went through a structural re-whatever was 1984.

370
00:40:00.067 --> 00:40:01.547
<v Eric Zimmerman>Which location was that?

371
00:40:02.094 --> 00:40:03.914
<v Donny Oliveira>Are you referring to the last renovation?

372
00:40:04.815 --> 00:40:05.009
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

373
00:40:05.235 --> 00:40:06.248
<v Donny Oliveira>That was the Schnitzer.

374
00:40:07.338 --> 00:40:14.664
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, that was the same year I went through my last structural renovation as well, so I'm feeling a lot of kinship with the schnitz.

375
00:40:16.380 --> 00:40:19.438
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, and we need a little work, so I get it.

376
00:40:19.695 --> 00:40:39.746
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, on this last point that we were just on with Councilor Ryan, of the 90% that are being run by a third party, are, are they also markets with as much Unionized workforce as we have for our stagehands and engineers and lighting?

377
00:40:40.983 --> 00:40:46.427
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because it is compelling, 90%, but I also want to understand like how that fits into the workforce.

378
00:40:46.476 --> 00:40:58.715
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because Donnie mentioned that many have a record of being able to work with a unionized workforce, but I want to get a sense out of that 90%, is that the norm across the market or are we a unicorn in that sense as well?

379
00:41:00.166 --> 00:41:10.641
<v Sue Pack>We know that in general, large performing arts centers use labor, work with labor unions, especially stagehands.

380
00:41:12.590 --> 00:41:17.710
<v Sue Pack>The fact that we have 6 labor unions, I don't have that information.

381
00:41:17.806 --> 00:41:22.110
<v Sue Pack>That's something we could certainly provide for you, how that relates to other markets.

382
00:41:22.239 --> 00:41:25.960
<v Sue Pack>But 6 unions, It does seem like a lot.

383
00:41:27.882 --> 00:41:32.601
<v Sue Pack>But again, union labor in performing arts centers is the norm.

384
00:41:33.201 --> 00:41:33.378
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

385
00:41:34.655 --> 00:41:40.507
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I've mentioned to my colleagues on this topic, there's a lot of governing that comes to instinct based on my career.

386
00:41:40.652 --> 00:41:48.931
<v Eric Zimmerman>But this is one of those areas that I've got a lot of like dumbbell guy in the corner questions on because I don't know a lot about the right size of different places.

387
00:41:48.996 --> 00:41:50.862
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've said this to many of the people in the audience.

388
00:41:51.251 --> 00:41:52.568
<v Eric Zimmerman>I need help on this topic.

389
00:41:52.650 --> 00:41:54.233
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'll probably have a lot of these types of questions.

390
00:41:54.474 --> 00:41:56.043
<v Eric Zimmerman>Of questions as we go through.

391
00:42:03.045 --> 00:42:27.606
<v Eric Zimmerman>The— I guess in terms of going to a third party managing that, Donny, if that was to be the case, what type of mechanism would we have to keep our approach with that unionized workforce instead of a recycling out or a slow recycling out to 10 years later, you just don't see that face and who the workers are?

392
00:42:27.800 --> 00:42:30.802
<v Eric Zimmerman>What kind of— how does an RFP get structured in order to do that?

393
00:42:31.251 --> 00:42:32.472
<v Donny Oliveira>Yeah, thanks for the question, Councilor.

394
00:42:32.552 --> 00:42:36.068
<v Donny Oliveira>I'll start and Sue, please refine my response.

395
00:42:36.710 --> 00:42:51.335
<v Donny Oliveira>It's one of the priorities as we're developing the RFP process to ensure that there's a smooth transition, both just in the operations, but also in ensuring that the Metro's— currently Metro staff who work on this, who are represented, that their Well taken care of in this new structure.

396
00:42:51.416 --> 00:42:57.188
<v Donny Oliveira>Our RFP, without getting ahead of our procurement colleagues, will be designed to capture that information, that requirement.

397
00:42:57.510 --> 00:42:58.840
<v Donny Oliveira>It's our facilities.

398
00:42:58.952 --> 00:43:03.860
<v Donny Oliveira>We get to determine the structure by which those facilities are managed, including this labor component.

399
00:43:03.907 --> 00:43:05.735
<v Donny Oliveira>So that's one piece that I'll add.

400
00:43:06.088 --> 00:43:20.726
<v Donny Oliveira>And the second thing that's fundamental to this is that we haven't done a great job yet as a city, as the manager of facilities, looking at opportunities for improvement, efficiencies, And on labor staff, like, how do we, you know, Sue brought up the food and beverage element.

401
00:43:20.822 --> 00:43:23.769
<v Donny Oliveira>Are we, are we getting the most equity out of these facilities?

402
00:43:24.282 --> 00:43:29.217
<v Donny Oliveira>And so there's opportunity for growth, uh, that I think would just be a boon for everybody, including our labor partners.

403
00:43:29.425 --> 00:43:29.987
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

404
00:43:30.916 --> 00:43:44.679
<v Sue Pack>The other thing I would say is, uh, the intention would be that our operating agreement with the third-party group, um, the city would still have decision-making authority in many areas.

405
00:43:45.112 --> 00:44:01.940
<v Sue Pack>And so things like pricing or employment or our goals and values, budget authority, things like that, the city would be collaboratively involved in and would ultimately need to approve.

406
00:44:03.000 --> 00:44:03.963
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks.

407
00:44:04.123 --> 00:44:04.702
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's all I have for now.

408
00:44:05.889 --> 00:44:07.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

409
00:44:08.570 --> 00:44:16.697
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So Councilor Zimmerman touched some on a couple of the questions that I had written down about labor.

410
00:44:17.291 --> 00:44:30.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As we're looking at the RFP that will be going out, it sounds like next month, you know, it's, it's clear to me that there are a lot of upsides to having the public management.

411
00:44:30.382 --> 00:44:39.039
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're able to ensure that we have that, that hands-on relationship with our, our workforce there and making sure that those are high-quality jobs.

412
00:44:39.858 --> 00:44:53.157
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are able to ensure space for the small companies and protect the small venues that are sometimes hard to keep afloat if they're not part of a system with larger venues.

413
00:44:54.554 --> 00:45:04.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It also occurs to me that as we move to a potential for a third-party operator, there are other upsides, both programmatic and financial.

414
00:45:05.623 --> 00:45:17.449
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How are we ensuring through the language in the RFP that we're able to maintain the current upsides and that the city can also capture some of the future upside?

415
00:45:18.041 --> 00:45:38.655
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That we're not entering into a situation where the city is maintaining venues that we have less control over and a private entity is gaining all of the Take a first stab at the RFP.

416
00:45:39.757 --> 00:45:49.472
<v Sue Pack>Yeah, I mean, there are many ways we could structure a deal with a third-party operator.

417
00:45:50.389 --> 00:46:02.358
<v Sue Pack>One approach is to have a flat management fee plus a Percentage revenue share that is incentive to increase revenue.

418
00:46:03.842 --> 00:46:11.474
<v Sue Pack>So that is typically the model for operating agreements with third-party venue operators.

419
00:46:11.621 --> 00:46:18.255
<v Sue Pack>So that's, that's something that is kind of a base that we're refining and massaging.

420
00:46:18.855 --> 00:46:20.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great, thank you.

421
00:46:20.489 --> 00:46:33.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I appreciate hearing a little bit more detail, like I said, to To Councilor Zimmerman's questions around the labor agreements and ensuring that we do have that continued upside moving forward as it relates to labor.

422
00:46:33.353 --> 00:46:39.731
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it sounds like from what you said previously, also a continued commitment to the upside for our smaller theater companies as well.

423
00:46:40.568 --> 00:46:42.641
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, did you have one more question before we move on?

424
00:46:42.981 --> 00:46:43.726
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, good evening.

425
00:46:43.789 --> 00:46:44.809
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks, Chair.

426
00:46:46.248 --> 00:46:48.431
<v Dan Ryan>It says 30% are publicly owned.

427
00:46:48.900 --> 00:46:49.775
<v Dan Ryan>That's what you said, correct?

428
00:46:50.326 --> 00:46:50.744
<v Sue Pack>1/3, Yes.

429
00:46:50.905 --> 00:46:51.646
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, 1/3.

430
00:46:52.048 --> 00:46:56.349
<v Dan Ryan>So 70% are privately owned in other cities.

431
00:46:57.347 --> 00:46:59.978
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to see— I just want more information.

432
00:47:00.157 --> 00:47:02.210
<v Dan Ryan>So I'd like to see like examples of that.

433
00:47:02.844 --> 00:47:08.996
<v Dan Ryan>Um, and then I want to get to P5, which is currently under Metro or under MERC?

434
00:47:10.585 --> 00:47:12.626
<v Donny Oliveira>Metro governed by MERC.

435
00:47:13.574 --> 00:47:19.463
<v Dan Ryan>So I think what we're trying to do with this action is get rid of some Clutter up at the high end.

436
00:47:20.007 --> 00:47:23.264
<v Dan Ryan>I don't think that's really benefited everyone on the ground.

437
00:47:24.081 --> 00:47:25.637
<v Dan Ryan>And so what does that look like?

438
00:47:25.701 --> 00:47:27.273
<v Dan Ryan>So what happens to P5?

439
00:47:27.545 --> 00:47:31.956
<v Dan Ryan>What happens to MERC when we become the operator?

440
00:47:32.581 --> 00:47:33.157
<v Donny Oliveira>Well, MERC—.

441
00:47:33.157 --> 00:47:34.168
<v Dan Ryan>I get ahead of my skis.

442
00:47:34.585 --> 00:47:35.643
<v Donny Oliveira>MERC will continue to exist.

443
00:47:35.708 --> 00:47:38.289
<v Donny Oliveira>MERC is a committee of— at Metro, so they'll stay.

444
00:47:38.369 --> 00:47:39.974
<v Dan Ryan>And it's beyond performing arts.

445
00:47:40.134 --> 00:47:45.170
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I know that it oversees the convention center and expo center.

446
00:47:46.036 --> 00:47:46.324
<v Unidentified speaker>The zoo?

447
00:47:46.693 --> 00:47:46.822
<v Donny Oliveira>Correct.

448
00:47:46.871 --> 00:47:48.347
<v Donny Oliveira>Uh, I don't, I don't believe the zoo.

449
00:47:48.396 --> 00:47:49.342
<v Donny Oliveira>I think it's just expo.

450
00:47:49.438 --> 00:47:49.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It'll be—.

451
00:47:50.289 --> 00:47:52.632
<v Donny Oliveira>Currently still manages P5, oversees P5.

452
00:47:53.195 --> 00:47:56.340
<v Donny Oliveira>But so once the operations of P5 Leave Metro.

453
00:47:57.112 --> 00:48:00.793
<v Donny Oliveira>Merck will remain doing Metro, you know, functional responsibilities.

454
00:48:01.532 --> 00:48:08.184
<v Donny Oliveira>And the P5 staff— in this particular case, we are making the recommendation to move forward with a third-party operator.

455
00:48:08.231 --> 00:48:17.021
<v Donny Oliveira>So the staff of Metro that do that work will move to this new operating entity that the city will oversee through contract.

456
00:48:18.242 --> 00:48:20.670
<v Dan Ryan>It could be privately managed.

457
00:48:21.376 --> 00:48:23.126
<v Donny Oliveira>That is the model that we're proposing.

458
00:48:23.945 --> 00:48:24.153
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

459
00:48:25.471 --> 00:48:29.356
<v Unidentified speaker>And Murk's scope of work might narrow and not include performing arts venues?

460
00:48:29.983 --> 00:48:34.559
<v Donny Oliveira>Well, it would no longer include the performing arts venues because they'd be fully under our—.

461
00:48:35.425 --> 00:48:37.047
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so we're not inheriting Murk?

462
00:48:37.192 --> 00:48:37.898
<v Donny Oliveira>You're not inheriting Murk.

463
00:48:37.978 --> 00:48:40.195
<v Unidentified speaker>I think I just needed to hear that in the public record.

464
00:48:40.724 --> 00:48:41.222
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, great.

465
00:48:42.250 --> 00:48:43.309
<v Unidentified speaker>Nothing against Murk.

466
00:48:43.389 --> 00:48:46.360
<v Unidentified speaker>I just hope that we're moving towards some efficiency here.

467
00:48:47.324 --> 00:49:07.795
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd like to add also, as a part of the RFP and an operating agreement, we will state an intention to form an advisory body that will provide some oversight so that there'd be community and stakeholder representatives who also have a voice in how we operate.

468
00:49:07.940 --> 00:49:08.726
<v Unidentified speaker>That makes a lot of sense.

469
00:49:09.545 --> 00:49:11.007
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thanks.

470
00:49:12.244 --> 00:49:14.262
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor.

471
00:49:15.079 --> 00:49:20.510
<v Unidentified speaker>DCA Oliveira, I believe that you have more presentation for this agenda item before we move to the next.

472
00:49:20.557 --> 00:49:21.086
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that correct?

473
00:49:21.182 --> 00:49:21.518
<v Donny Oliveira>Correct.

474
00:49:21.728 --> 00:49:24.659
<v Donny Oliveira>And this really just tees up the next item, so we'll just— we can move through this.

475
00:49:26.052 --> 00:49:26.822
<v Donny Oliveira>So we're going to shift—.

476
00:49:26.934 --> 00:49:32.284
<v Unidentified speaker>We'll hear the rest of this presentation and then we'll take a quick break before we open the next agenda item.

477
00:49:32.396 --> 00:49:32.733
<v Donny Oliveira>Perfect.

478
00:49:33.021 --> 00:49:33.181
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

479
00:49:33.342 --> 00:49:33.581
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you.

480
00:49:33.630 --> 00:49:43.706
<v Donny Oliveira>So we'll shift now to focus on one of our facilities, the Keller Auditorium, and the work over the past few years to ensure that we continue to have a Broadway-capable venue in Portland.

481
00:49:45.239 --> 00:49:47.684
<v Donny Oliveira>So the Keller plays a crucial role in our local economy.

482
00:49:48.360 --> 00:49:57.063
<v Donny Oliveira>The commercial events at Keller, such as Broadway performances, bring in revenue that supports the whole P5 system, and the Keller is the only Broadway-capable venue in Portland and our region.

483
00:49:57.619 --> 00:49:58.210
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

484
00:50:01.572 --> 00:50:07.536
<v Donny Oliveira>Um, this is— there's been a lot of activity, uh, contemplating, uh, the Keller Auditorium over the last 6 years.

485
00:50:08.320 --> 00:50:15.996
<v Donny Oliveira>It's really important for us to take this time to acknowledge that The City of Portland has been looking at the Keller and the future of it for quite some time.

486
00:50:17.226 --> 00:50:38.103
<v Donny Oliveira>As we approach the end of its current useful life, we started doing some evaluations, starting with a report in 2020 focused on seismic issues that determined that the Keller needs some interventions to ensure that we don't have a major impact due to a potential, you know, seismic event.

487
00:50:38.702 --> 00:50:39.744
<v Donny Oliveira>And so we need to address that.

488
00:50:40.387 --> 00:50:51.215
<v Donny Oliveira>In 2022, conversations began in earnest around renovating the Keller to address those issues, other deferred maintenance, and also to bring the facility up to modern standards for a performance venue of its type.

489
00:50:52.257 --> 00:51:02.653
<v Donny Oliveira>The city and Metro at the time contributed resources to support those conversations, with external partners taking the lead to develop a concept to renovate the Keller Auditorium.

490
00:51:03.568 --> 00:51:18.114
<v Donny Oliveira>In 2023, The city began exploring options for a new facility as a parallel to that conversation, with the goal of having a full suite of information needed to determine the best next steps for both the performing arts venue and activities in Portland, but also for the Keller as a city asset.

491
00:51:19.815 --> 00:51:28.563
<v Donny Oliveira>At that time, there was an RFP that was run, and PSU— Portland State University, excuse me— put their name in the hat as a potential alternative location for a public facility.

492
00:51:29.244 --> 00:51:34.639
<v Donny Oliveira>And after a competitive process, they were selected as the best alternative location given the other options.

493
00:51:36.849 --> 00:51:44.119
<v Donny Oliveira>At the time, just want to name it, that Lloyd Sinner had submitted a proposal as well, and you just contemplated their master plan that did not include a venue.

494
00:51:45.572 --> 00:51:50.351
<v Donny Oliveira>They've since gotten a private sector venue that's under construction right now.

495
00:51:50.759 --> 00:51:51.311
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

496
00:51:55.440 --> 00:52:04.346
<v Donny Oliveira>So before we get into some of the next steps, I just wanted to take a moment to just really emphasize what would happen if we chose to renovate the Keller, which would require closure.

497
00:52:05.340 --> 00:52:13.753
<v Donny Oliveira>One of the important pieces of conversation that happened in this, in this contemplation of the future large performing arts venue was concerns around a temporary closure during the renovation.

498
00:52:14.731 --> 00:52:27.766
<v Donny Oliveira>Um, we've got some help pulling some information together, but, and we did a study, but what we showed was that closing the Keller for 2 years without finding another venue that could host Broadway shows during that time would be a significant economic hit to our region.

499
00:52:28.550 --> 00:52:37.284
<v Donny Oliveira>There would be lost income for those workers who would expect to, to be in the facility for those 2 years, and they need to move on to new jobs during that time.

500
00:52:37.429 --> 00:52:41.076
<v Donny Oliveira>So we also have loss of workforce in a, you know, in our region.

501
00:52:41.976 --> 00:52:47.949
<v Donny Oliveira>There'd be lost public revenues from those events, of course, noting the role that Broadway plays in supporting the whole P5 portfolio.

502
00:52:49.487 --> 00:53:01.362
<v Donny Oliveira>And there would also be broader impacts of impact related to the indirect economic Benefits that go from the venue's existence, including local area businesses, et cetera.

503
00:53:02.405 --> 00:53:08.523
<v Donny Oliveira>But most importantly perhaps is that the resident companies at the Keller, the Oregon Ballet Theatre, and the Portland Opera would be affected.

504
00:53:09.614 --> 00:53:15.219
<v Donny Oliveira>And the report identified the risk of long-term impacts as attendees shift to other entertainment venues, including outside the region.

505
00:53:15.893 --> 00:53:38.032
<v Donny Oliveira>The long story short is, and we started to contemplate the future of Keller, Taking the time to renovate and pausing operations there, performances there, was a non-starter both for our economy, the sustenance of Broadway and our other resident companies, but also fundamentally our ability to continue to drive the benefits of our downtown from that venue.

506
00:53:38.579 --> 00:53:39.001
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

507
00:53:41.753 --> 00:53:51.893
<v Donny Oliveira>In October of 2024, the City Council adopted a resolution That directed the city to contemplate a strategy for 2 Broadway-capable venues.

508
00:53:53.400 --> 00:54:04.036
<v Donny Oliveira>This was— the goal of this was to prevent the prolonged closure at the Keller, but was also to take advantage of an opportunity for us to partner with one of our anchor institutions, Portland State University.

509
00:54:05.005 --> 00:54:18.704
<v Donny Oliveira>It directed staff to better understand the opportunities, do some more analysis, the pros and cons of a 2-venue strategy, and to determine the appropriate seat count for Broadway-capable venues And potentially additional details that we'll talk about in a second that we did undertake.

510
00:54:20.329 --> 00:54:20.731
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

511
00:54:24.010 --> 00:54:29.088
<v Donny Oliveira>So briefly, just want to talk about the 2 projects that were contemplated in that 2-venue scenario that we were looking at.

512
00:54:29.849 --> 00:54:34.190
<v Donny Oliveira>The idea for the Keller would be to renovate the city-owned facility.

513
00:54:35.041 --> 00:54:46.594
<v Donny Oliveira>This was originally proposed by the Halpern Landscape Conservancy, who was the— took the lead in that 2022 Renovation concept that I shared earlier that was financed by Metro and the city.

514
00:54:48.190 --> 00:54:52.512
<v Donny Oliveira>The concept included, you know, a new facade over Southwest 3rd Avenue.

515
00:54:53.057 --> 00:55:02.650
<v Donny Oliveira>It was targeting that 2,700 to 3,000-seat range that the Keller currently hosts and had an estimated cost of about $290 million.

516
00:55:04.063 --> 00:55:07.851
<v Donny Oliveira>At the same time, the PSU facility would be introduced in a brand new facility.

517
00:55:07.900 --> 00:55:17.858
<v Donny Oliveira>Of course, it'd be a part of a larger Condo structure that would include a smaller academic theater, a conference center, a hotel on a 4-acre site on the PSU campus.

518
00:55:18.788 --> 00:55:25.568
<v Donny Oliveira>Had a little bit of larger target seat count for that larger facility, and it had estimated costs of about $447 million.

519
00:55:26.563 --> 00:55:43.726
<v Donny Oliveira>This is an opportunity for me just to acknowledge that at this time we were sincerely looking and partnering both with Halperin and PSU to sequence out a scenario where we built a PSU facility And we contemplated a future Keller venue that was still thriving and meeting the demands of our arts ecosystem.

520
00:55:44.545 --> 00:55:45.878
<v Donny Oliveira>But we had more details to discover.

521
00:55:46.456 --> 00:55:47.163
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

522
00:55:49.289 --> 00:55:58.657
<v Donny Oliveira>One of the requests of the resolution that we thought was material was to do a transportation study for both the renovation at the Keller site, but also the construction of the new PSU site.

523
00:56:00.028 --> 00:56:04.443
<v Donny Oliveira>That study was completed last summer, and it helped to identify opportunities and challenges for both sites.

524
00:56:05.184 --> 00:56:06.293
<v Donny Oliveira>But there were no fatal flaws.

525
00:56:06.831 --> 00:56:15.003
<v Donny Oliveira>It was also difficult to do a complete study of the PSU site because we were working with, naturally, without complete information because the PSU concept isn't as fully developed.

526
00:56:15.471 --> 00:56:29.282
<v Donny Oliveira>But what we did learn was that, you know, there was a significant opportunity here for us to work with both our Transportation Bureau and the state's Department of Transportation to contemplate further details as future phases of the project evolved.

527
00:56:30.375 --> 00:56:30.648
<v Donny Oliveira>Next.

528
00:56:31.402 --> 00:56:31.773
<v Sue Pack>Slide, please.

529
00:56:31.967 --> 00:56:36.239
<v Donny Oliveira>What we also undertook was a market feasibility study.

530
00:56:36.929 --> 00:56:41.534
<v Donny Oliveira>The goal of this was to determine the market demand for a 2-venue scenario.

531
00:56:42.275 --> 00:56:57.547
<v Donny Oliveira>I just want to note that when the original 2-venue scenario was contemplated starting in 2023 and into 2024, we were not predicting that there'd be 2 privately owned music venues being built on the east side.

532
00:56:58.293 --> 00:57:04.949
<v Donny Oliveira>And that had a material impact on the market feasibility, given what we knew in '23 versus what we know today.

533
00:57:06.088 --> 00:57:12.375
<v Donny Oliveira>The study was completed by Hunden Partners, who is a nationally recognized real estate team with expertise for these types of facilities.

534
00:57:13.369 --> 00:57:18.003
<v Donny Oliveira>The study found ultimately that the Portland market could really only support one Broadway-capable venue.

535
00:57:18.998 --> 00:57:26.536
<v Donny Oliveira>They targeted a 3,200-seat as the sweet spot for us, which is currently larger than the current Keller can realistically host.

536
00:57:27.338 --> 00:57:35.077
<v Donny Oliveira>And ultimately, given some of the data that they discovered, they made a recommendation that the city pursue a Broadway-capable venue at PSU.

537
00:57:36.110 --> 00:57:36.594
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

538
00:57:39.684 --> 00:57:45.684
<v Donny Oliveira>Following up on that, we asked the Hundon Partners to do a further study related to the economic impact.

539
00:57:46.797 --> 00:57:48.777
<v Donny Oliveira>And ultimately, the key takeaways are here.

540
00:57:50.518 --> 00:57:53.869
<v Donny Oliveira>A new venue at PSU would yield more attendance because of the size.

541
00:57:54.342 --> 00:57:56.456
<v Donny Oliveira>There'd be operating venue efficiencies.

542
00:57:58.393 --> 00:57:59.994
<v Donny Oliveira>Than a renovated Keller.

543
00:58:00.641 --> 00:58:12.306
<v Donny Oliveira>I think I'll just go ahead and editorialize that, say that a renovated Keller would also be an excellent venue, but when comparing the two, there was slight benefit to the PSU project.

544
00:58:13.014 --> 00:58:13.465
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

545
00:58:17.777 --> 00:58:31.813
<v Donny Oliveira>One last note, because it's come up in the past, just want to acknowledge it, that in the full session in 2025, the Oregon Legislature adopted Senate Bill 5505, which allocated Bond dollars to the PSU project.

546
00:58:32.913 --> 00:58:42.722
<v Donny Oliveira>This is material because a chunk of those bonds would go towards the construction of that larger condo project on the 4 acres that I mentioned, focused on the community and academic theater on the site.

547
00:58:43.657 --> 00:58:51.967
<v Donny Oliveira>But a portion of it would also go to broader infrastructure, whether it be parking or infrastructure on the site that would directly benefit the Broadway-capable venue.

548
00:58:53.338 --> 00:58:53.806
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

549
00:58:55.818 --> 00:59:04.934
<v Donny Oliveira>As a part of the resolution that was adopted in 2024, The service area was directed to stand up a technical advisory committee.

550
00:59:06.519 --> 00:59:07.693
<v Donny Oliveira>And so we will— next slide, please.

551
00:59:09.099 --> 00:59:19.005
<v Donny Oliveira>And so what we did here was we put out a request for qualifications for 11 professionals to be a part of this steering committee.

552
00:59:19.521 --> 00:59:34.902
<v Donny Oliveira>We were looking for expertise in architecture, construction, finance, et cetera, really asking folks who had less, um, skin in the game, so to speak, but more technical expertise to provide us with, um, an objective perspective on this decision.

553
00:59:35.400 --> 00:59:44.143
<v Donny Oliveira>We were looking for their, um, subject matter expertise not just on the market at a whole but specific to the sites that were being contemplated.

554
00:59:44.865 --> 00:59:46.134
<v Donny Oliveira>Um, it was a great group to work with.

555
00:59:46.326 --> 00:59:48.893
<v Donny Oliveira>I was very fond of their commitment and their diligence.

556
00:59:49.518 --> 00:59:55.150
<v Donny Oliveira>Um, and, uh, they met, um, 6 times over, over the course of spring of 2026.

557
00:59:55.472 --> 00:59:56.090
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

558
00:59:57.764 --> 00:59:58.576
<v Donny Oliveira>Oh, 8 times, excuse me.

559
01:00:00.327 --> 01:00:06.318
<v Donny Oliveira>Um, ultimately, um, the committee was provided with presentations, studies, reports that ultimately informed their recommendation.

560
01:00:07.159 --> 01:00:15.760
<v Donny Oliveira>Uh, the body did engage with both the project proposers, Halperin Landscape Conservancy and PSU, to get more details on, um, the specifics of those projects.

561
01:00:16.164 --> 01:00:21.077
<v Donny Oliveira>And we also invited Broadway Across America to come in and answer questions from the, the technical, uh, team.

562
01:00:21.967 --> 01:00:29.623
<v Donny Oliveira>Uh, they went on site tours And ultimately, they completed their work last month, and we'll talk about that in the next presentation.

563
01:00:30.155 --> 01:00:30.673
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

564
01:00:33.000 --> 01:00:37.110
<v Donny Oliveira>Parallel to that was another group that was called by Mayor Keith Wilson.

565
01:00:37.867 --> 01:00:50.797
<v Donny Oliveira>This was a parallel group that was convened of elected officials, our cultural and downtown leaders, labor representatives, and stakeholders who had more direct skin in the game, so to speak, related to the venues.

566
01:00:51.657 --> 01:01:05.947
<v Donny Oliveira>Many of the folks here will be part of the conversation later, but I want to just share that I was very grateful for the time these folks took to provide the mayor and the Office of Arts and Culture with their guidance, their wisdom, their experience on these 2 topics.

567
01:01:06.445 --> 01:01:17.268
<v Donny Oliveira>They brought a lot of dynamic information to these proceedings that allowed us to have a rich conversation about the pros and cons of moving forward with a PSU facility or the renovation.

568
01:01:18.597 --> 01:01:19.152
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

569
01:01:23.800 --> 01:01:28.101
<v Donny Oliveira>Similar to the steering committee, we had meetings through the spring of 2026.

570
01:01:28.764 --> 01:01:33.985
<v Donny Oliveira>We covered a lot of the, the same details of the steering committee, but in a tighter timeline.

571
01:01:34.807 --> 01:01:38.322
<v Donny Oliveira>They received all the studies that the steering committee did as well.

572
01:01:38.918 --> 01:01:39.385
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

573
01:01:42.059 --> 01:01:45.465
<v Donny Oliveira>And that, I believe, wraps it for this particular presentation.

574
01:01:45.728 --> 01:01:49.242
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Thank you, DCA Oliveira.

575
01:01:49.307 --> 01:01:52.768
<v Unidentified speaker>Are there any questions on this second part of the presentation?

576
01:01:54.559 --> 01:02:01.293
<v Unidentified speaker>We're going to hold off on questions about the recommendations themselves, but about the workgroups, the studies, the work that went into that.

577
01:02:04.817 --> 01:02:04.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No?

578
01:02:06.204 --> 01:02:07.737
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, right ahead, Councilor Ryan.

579
01:02:07.998 --> 01:02:08.585
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair.

580
01:02:09.302 --> 01:02:10.427
<v Unidentified speaker>You mentioned the 2 tables.

581
01:02:11.686 --> 01:02:17.197
<v Unidentified speaker>There was one that had less people with special interest, if you will, transactional interest.

582
01:02:17.710 --> 01:02:21.315
<v Unidentified speaker>And the other one was the mayor's table, which clearly had more of that.

583
01:02:21.940 --> 01:02:23.126
<v Unidentified speaker>Did they agree with each other?

584
01:02:24.505 --> 01:02:26.282
<v Donny Oliveira>We're going to talk a little bit about that in the next slide.

585
01:02:26.427 --> 01:02:30.577
<v Donny Oliveira>I think there was shared ideas and principles in those conversations.

586
01:02:31.074 --> 01:02:31.153
<v Karen Whitman>Yeah.

587
01:02:31.650 --> 01:02:31.891
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

588
01:02:32.597 --> 01:02:34.070
<v Unidentified speaker>And that, I got ahead of myself.

589
01:02:34.119 --> 01:02:35.159
<v Unidentified speaker>You didn't tell us what they thought.

590
01:02:35.257 --> 01:02:37.867
<v Donny Oliveira>Yeah, we're doing another, the next item has the next slide.

591
01:02:37.916 --> 01:02:38.188
<v Donny Oliveira>Sorry.

592
01:02:38.590 --> 01:02:39.646
<v Donny Oliveira>Sorry for the suspense, Councilor.

593
01:02:40.768 --> 01:02:49.083
<v Unidentified speaker>And when you said the transportation study was approved, if you will, or that there didn't seem to be any, is that with both of the sites?

594
01:02:49.900 --> 01:03:03.824
<v Donny Oliveira>Yeah, the study was done both at the renovation site for the Keller Auditorium and related to the construction of the PSU site, acknowledging that the PSU site will have more phases that will need more information to have a more robust detailing.

595
01:03:03.871 --> 01:03:11.563
<v Donny Oliveira>But the key takeaway from both of those studies were there were no fatal flaws On a theater or venue, excuse me, at either one of those sites.

596
01:03:12.273 --> 01:03:21.132
<v Unidentified speaker>And finally, did the estimates of cost for $290 million, $440 million with the PSU one, who fact-checked those figures?

597
01:03:22.039 --> 01:03:23.771
<v Unidentified speaker>That was an independent consulting firm.

598
01:03:24.889 --> 01:03:26.233
<v Unidentified speaker>The independent consulting firm?

599
01:03:27.550 --> 01:03:28.411
<v Unidentified speaker>Who's that?

600
01:03:31.545 --> 01:03:33.884
<v Unidentified speaker>We could get you the name of the—.

601
01:03:35.920 --> 01:03:36.130
<v Dan Ryan>What's that?

602
01:03:37.215 --> 01:03:44.369
<v Unidentified speaker>We can— I don't have the name of the firm at the moment, but I'd be happy to get that for you.

603
01:03:44.498 --> 01:03:44.969
<v Unidentified speaker>They're pretty independent.

604
01:03:48.442 --> 01:03:49.117
<v Unidentified speaker>All right.

605
01:03:50.626 --> 01:03:56.351
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we make sure we get that from the office to all committee members just in case folks have additional questions about their background and work?

606
01:03:56.722 --> 01:03:56.835
<v Dan Ryan>Yep.

607
01:03:57.367 --> 01:03:57.675
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

608
01:03:59.161 --> 01:04:00.210
<v Unidentified speaker>Any other questions, Councilor?

609
01:04:01.579 --> 01:04:04.338
<v Unidentified speaker>No, I look— I do look forward to looking at the studies that were mentioned.

610
01:04:04.563 --> 01:04:08.222
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, but it sounds like we're going to get more information in the— is there another presentation?

611
01:04:09.201 --> 01:04:09.505
<v Unidentified speaker>There is.

612
01:04:09.891 --> 01:04:14.014
<v Unidentified speaker>So we are going to, in just a moment, take a 15-minute break.

613
01:04:14.416 --> 01:04:23.418
<v Unidentified speaker>When we come back, we will open up agenda item 4, and we'll hear a presentation specifically about the recommendations of those 2 workgroups.

614
01:04:23.963 --> 01:04:37.621
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm hoping that in that presentation we'll hear a little bit about the The, the places where the recommendations were aligned and the places where there may have been some dissension in one of the workgroups and not in the other.

615
01:04:38.311 --> 01:04:49.016
<v Unidentified speaker>We'll then hear from 3 panels, one from folks who had some concerns with the recommendation, one from folks who supported the recommendation, and one from workers who are directly impacted by this.

616
01:04:49.864 --> 01:04:53.855
<v Unidentified speaker>And then we will hopefully have about 45 minutes for public testimony.

617
01:04:54.083 --> 01:04:55.474
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, thank you, Chair.

618
01:04:55.927 --> 01:05:05.271
<v Unidentified speaker>So we are going to take a 14-minute break, and we will get started right at 3:15 so that we can get through the rest of our work today.

619
01:05:05.599 --> 01:05:06.963
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry, yeah, 3:15.

620
01:05:07.242 --> 01:05:07.585
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

621
01:19:59.939 --> 01:20:02.652
<v Unidentified speaker>Calling the meeting back to order.

622
01:20:03.765 --> 01:20:07.496
<v Unidentified speaker>If everyone can take your seats, we can go ahead and get started.

623
01:20:09.869 --> 01:20:10.033
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

624
01:20:11.697 --> 01:20:12.430
<v Lejeune Thorson>Do it again, baby.

625
01:20:12.512 --> 01:20:13.313
<v Donny Oliveira>Hit that sucker.

626
01:20:15.153 --> 01:20:31.947
<v Unidentified speaker>And I will just note, um, as we get back in, that we do have Councilor Morillo joining us So she is listening in on our proceedings today as well.

627
01:20:33.939 --> 01:20:37.152
<v Unidentified speaker>Diego, could you please open agenda item 4?

628
01:20:38.168 --> 01:20:58.795
<v Donny Oliveira>Item 4, document number 2026-270, accept the future of large-scale performing arts recommendations to advance a new Broadway-capable venue as part of the proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center at Portland State University and initiate planning for the future of the Thank you.

629
01:20:59.436 --> 01:21:03.947
<v Unidentified speaker>So this will hopefully flow seamlessly from our last conversation.

630
01:21:03.994 --> 01:21:18.198
<v Unidentified speaker>We heard about the process that led up to and the work of a couple of work groups over the last 6 or so months, and we will hear now about the recommendations out of those work groups.

631
01:21:18.680 --> 01:21:27.092
<v Unidentified speaker>We have a resolution before us with recommendations from the mayor's office on how we implement those next steps.

632
01:21:27.671 --> 01:21:35.362
<v Unidentified speaker>We will then hear from a couple of panels to get a little bit more background on the recommendations themselves and the work of the workgroups.

633
01:21:36.020 --> 01:21:43.694
<v Unidentified speaker>We will hear from a panel with a few of our colleagues who have been involved in this work, and then we will move to public testimony.

634
01:21:44.128 --> 01:21:47.484
<v Unidentified speaker>Before we jump into the presentation, Councilor Murillo, your hand is raised.

635
01:21:47.581 --> 01:21:47.661
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

636
01:21:49.970 --> 01:21:51.332
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh yeah, thank you so much, Chair.

637
01:21:51.492 --> 01:21:55.564
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I just wanted to say for folks in the audience that I'm here and I'm listening.

638
01:21:55.820 --> 01:22:01.046
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, my cat had to go to the vet and I'm just kind of monitoring him today, so apologies for that.

639
01:22:01.127 --> 01:22:02.185
<v Unidentified speaker>But I am very cognizant.

640
01:22:02.313 --> 01:22:07.667
<v Unidentified speaker>I know these, uh, 2 options are a really big deal for our community, so just wanted to say that for anyone in the audience.

641
01:22:07.859 --> 01:22:08.083
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

642
01:22:08.980 --> 01:22:09.943
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

643
01:22:10.006 --> 01:22:19.175
<v Unidentified speaker>And I know it's hard sometimes when you're remote making sure folks know that That you are— that you do care about the really important points before the committee today.

644
01:22:19.256 --> 01:22:23.578
<v Unidentified speaker>We appreciate you making sure to still be a part of this conversation with us.

645
01:22:25.619 --> 01:22:29.539
<v Unidentified speaker>TCA Oliveira, I think we turn this back over to you at this point.

646
01:22:29.668 --> 01:22:30.201
<v Donny Oliveira>All right, thank you, Chair.

647
01:22:30.248 --> 01:22:34.039
<v Donny Oliveira>Real quick, we want to answer Councilor Ryan's question about the consultant.

648
01:22:34.960 --> 01:22:42.399
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, so your question regarding who did the costing analysis for the 2 venue proposals, and that is Venue Consulting Group.

649
01:22:42.784 --> 01:23:03.634
<v Donny Oliveira>That was conducted in May 2024, and the information is available Okay, so real quick, we're going to pick up from the conversation from the last presentation to talk about the recommendations from the 2 committees and then discuss the directives and the proposed resolution.

650
01:23:03.835 --> 01:23:04.555
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

651
01:23:07.619 --> 01:23:08.832
<v Donny Oliveira>All right, starting with the steering committee.

652
01:23:08.929 --> 01:23:13.277
<v Donny Oliveira>Again, this was the— our technical advisory committee that met over the 7 months.

653
01:23:13.326 --> 01:23:13.439
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

654
01:23:13.572 --> 01:23:14.341
<v Donny Oliveira>8 Times.

655
01:23:15.255 --> 01:23:25.721
<v Donny Oliveira>As we shared, they culminated their meetings in June of 2026 and made the recommendation to, to the Deputy City Administrator of Community Economic Development.

656
01:23:25.770 --> 01:23:26.091
<v Donny Oliveira>That's me.

657
01:23:27.037 --> 01:23:28.768
<v Donny Oliveira>The group recommended a 2-pronged approach.

658
01:23:29.506 --> 01:23:38.145
<v Donny Oliveira>First, they recommend that we build a new Broadway-capable venue at PSU and make that as part of their larger campus concepts around the Performing Arts and Cultural Center.

659
01:23:39.059 --> 01:23:43.748
<v Donny Oliveira>And simultaneously They wanted us to create an actionable plan to reimagine the Keller Auditorium.

660
01:23:44.615 --> 01:23:56.761
<v Donny Oliveira>So the thinking at a very high level is we begin the planning for the new PSU site with the Portland State University team, but simultaneously begin to contemplate the future of the Keller site.

661
01:23:57.115 --> 01:24:06.095
<v Donny Oliveira>So when the PSU site's live and those Broadway acts move over to PSU, we are prepared to reimagine the Keller in that new iteration, whatever it may be.

662
01:24:07.225 --> 01:24:07.921
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

663
01:24:09.993 --> 01:24:14.398
<v Donny Oliveira>The ex officio table met and had a very spirited conversation.

664
01:24:15.300 --> 01:24:20.694
<v Donny Oliveira>And while not consensus like the steering committee, a majority of the ex officio table did make a recommendation.

665
01:24:21.130 --> 01:24:27.925
<v Donny Oliveira>And their recommendation is as such: they recommended that we take a similar two-pronged approach advancing the PSU Performing Arts Center.

666
01:24:28.671 --> 01:24:31.707
<v Donny Oliveira>They want to ensure that we maintain Broadway show at the Keller while this is in development.

667
01:24:32.707 --> 01:24:37.421
<v Donny Oliveira>And they want us to initiate planning for the Keller's future as a modern 1,200 to 1,800-seat venue.

668
01:24:38.560 --> 01:24:41.398
<v Donny Oliveira>The same concept applies here to the steering committee.

669
01:24:41.462 --> 01:24:56.824
<v Donny Oliveira>When the PSU venue becomes operational, the city should be prepared to transition Broadway productions there and immediately begin the renovation of the Keller into a venue tailored to that particular midside market that the Portland city needs and our arts, performing culture needs.

670
01:24:57.658 --> 01:24:58.347
<v Donny Oliveira>All right, next slide, please.

671
01:25:01.731 --> 01:25:03.800
<v Donny Oliveira>So the overview of the proposed resolution.

672
01:25:04.875 --> 01:25:09.283
<v Donny Oliveira>The resolution in front of you today advances those aligned recommendations for a 2-pronged strategy.

673
01:25:09.909 --> 01:25:20.461
<v Donny Oliveira>First, it would direct the city to advance a new Broadway-capable venue at PSU, capitalizing on the state's funding commitment and the prior work that the PSU team had done.

674
01:25:21.712 --> 01:25:25.287
<v Donny Oliveira>This would include initiating planning for the future of the Kellup Auditorium as well.

675
01:25:26.270 --> 01:25:28.610
<v Donny Oliveira>It would contain specific next steps for both of those facilities.

676
01:25:29.601 --> 01:25:30.154
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

677
01:25:32.250 --> 01:25:47.823
<v Donny Oliveira>So specific to the PSU venue, first we would stand up a staff project team of technical experts to work with PSU to complete the pre-development work, including a detailed financial plan, the philanthropic strategy, and the initial phases of the project and the project construction management.

678
01:25:49.186 --> 01:26:01.970
<v Donny Oliveira>We would develop a project commitment agreement with PSU by December 1st of this year that establishes the scope, schedule, and governance framework For the project and a shared commitment between the city and PSU to develop and implement this full capital funding strategy.

679
01:26:02.645 --> 01:26:06.546
<v Donny Oliveira>And of course, we would designate a pre-development steering committee to participate in the process as needed.

680
01:26:07.220 --> 01:26:14.252
<v Donny Oliveira>I want to take a moment here just to really emphasize the opportunity here with the city and one of our key anchor institutions of downtown.

681
01:26:15.569 --> 01:26:25.139
<v Donny Oliveira>Not only is PSU a vibrant placemaking space in our downtown, but they represent The southern part of our downtown's economic vitality.

682
01:26:25.668 --> 01:26:34.805
<v Donny Oliveira>And this is an opportunity for us to leverage their pre-work they've done at the state, the pre-work they've done on design, to really partner with one of our key institutions in our central city.

683
01:26:35.543 --> 01:26:42.978
<v Donny Oliveira>I want to just also offer that to this point, PSU has been a great partner, not just on this topic, but on many projects that we've worked on with them.

684
01:26:43.572 --> 01:26:52.756
<v Donny Oliveira>And we continue to want to emphasize that this is what it looks like for Portland to rebound in our downtown, is investing in the anchor institutions that are going to be here for a very long time.

685
01:26:52.819 --> 01:26:53.029
<v Sue Pack>Thank you.

686
01:26:54.024 --> 01:26:54.554
<v Donny Oliveira>Next slide, please.

687
01:26:55.871 --> 01:26:59.788
<v Donny Oliveira>As a part of the proposed resolution, we do contemplate next steps for the Keller.

688
01:27:00.912 --> 01:27:05.953
<v Donny Oliveira>It was clear that programming will continue while development of the Broadway-capable venue at PSU is ongoing.

689
01:27:06.371 --> 01:27:17.193
<v Donny Oliveira>So we want to make sure that we keep that venue up to date and running effectively and efficiently with our new operating team come 2027.

690
01:27:18.108 --> 01:27:24.630
<v Donny Oliveira>We also want to begin the process for planning for the future of Keller so we have a clear Thank you.

691
01:27:25.619 --> 01:27:37.409
<v Donny Oliveira>We want to ensure we're conducting community engagement, the market study and financial analysis necessary to do some of that design work to ensure that the next version of Keller is the thing that our performing arts ecosystem needs.

692
01:27:37.789 --> 01:27:42.170
<v Donny Oliveira>And whether that's 1,200 seats or 1,800 seats, that's something we want to do some more research on.

693
01:27:42.930 --> 01:27:46.020
<v Donny Oliveira>I really want to emphasize this, that the Keller is a city-owned facility.

694
01:27:46.590 --> 01:27:48.270
<v Donny Oliveira>We don't want to see it mothballed.

695
01:27:48.270 --> 01:27:52.050
<v Donny Oliveira>We have no intention of letting this thing get into disarray or disrepair.

696
01:27:52.050 --> 01:27:57.475
<v Donny Oliveira>We have a responsibility to maintain it to keep it, uh, an exceptional venue to date.

697
01:27:57.942 --> 01:28:07.484
<v Donny Oliveira>And we have an opportunity to really reimagine not just the Keller but that whole, that whole ecosystem of the district from where the Keller locates— located, the Schnitz, including the PSU facilities.

698
01:28:08.079 --> 01:28:16.000
<v Donny Oliveira>That sort of performing arts venue ecosystem has a real opportunity to be a district of, of play and activity and economic vitality.

699
01:28:16.273 --> 01:28:18.265
<v Donny Oliveira>And I think that's something we should lean into holistically.

700
01:28:19.341 --> 01:28:24.943
<v Donny Oliveira>The resolution also reflects That we have an opportunity here to work with PSU but maintain our own assets.

701
01:28:25.505 --> 01:28:29.484
<v Donny Oliveira>And I hope this is taken seriously, not just by you all in this committee, but by our partners.

702
01:28:30.077 --> 01:28:31.778
<v Donny Oliveira>This was never an either-or option for us.

703
01:28:31.841 --> 01:28:33.671
<v Donny Oliveira>We always knew that we were going to invest in Keller.

704
01:28:34.072 --> 01:28:43.201
<v Donny Oliveira>This was an opportunity to look at the Keller in a different light and simultaneously partner with the Portland State University team on a future central cultural center.

705
01:28:44.100 --> 01:28:45.703
<v Donny Oliveira>And I believe that wraps it up.

706
01:28:45.961 --> 01:28:50.027
<v Donny Oliveira>And I I wanna make sure we leave time for our esteemed colleagues, but happy to take questions if necessary.

707
01:28:51.470 --> 01:29:05.015
<v Unidentified speaker>So colleagues, we do have a few panels, but if there are questions about some of the technicalities, the specifics here that are relevant before we get a little bit of color commentary from others, let's get those now.

708
01:29:07.858 --> 01:29:10.815
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, seeing— yes, Councilor Ryan.

709
01:29:11.515 --> 01:29:14.067
<v Unidentified speaker>Did you say the Keller's 1200, 1800, right?

710
01:29:14.239 --> 01:29:15.186
<v Unidentified speaker>That's the estimate.

711
01:29:15.796 --> 01:29:17.899
<v Donny Oliveira>It's really an idea, Councilor.

712
01:29:17.948 --> 01:29:31.788
<v Donny Oliveira>I don't— I'd want to— I'm sharing that as an example of the range that a new Keller might look like, but we want to do the feasibility study and really do an assessment of what our market needs to ensure that the next Keller is meeting the demand that we have.

713
01:29:32.720 --> 01:29:35.145
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I think we can agree that we don't want it mothballed.

714
01:29:36.332 --> 01:29:37.729
<v Unidentified speaker>How big is Newmark right now?

715
01:29:37.795 --> 01:29:39.304
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that— did you say 800?

716
01:29:39.368 --> 01:29:39.609
<v Unidentified speaker>880.

717
01:29:41.510 --> 01:29:42.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>$880,000.

718
01:29:42.109 --> 01:29:46.170
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, thanks.

719
01:29:46.170 --> 01:29:56.550
<v Unidentified speaker>DC Oliveira, was the, the $1,200,000 to $1,800,000 range, if I'm remembering from previous conversations, is kind of the, the gap where we don't have any other public venues?

720
01:29:56.550 --> 01:29:57.369
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that correct?

721
01:29:57.430 --> 01:29:58.029
<v Donny Oliveira>That's correct.

722
01:29:58.029 --> 01:29:59.949
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, thank you.

723
01:29:59.949 --> 01:30:12.497
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, if there are no other questions, we are going to move to our first panel, and in doing that, I want to thank you both for all of the background and also just flag that we may have other questions later when we get into our committee discussion.

724
01:30:13.409 --> 01:30:19.070
<v Unidentified speaker>That probably won't be until our next committee meeting, but we might get to it by the end today, so please don't go too far.

725
01:30:20.649 --> 01:30:46.905
<v Unidentified speaker>The first panel that we are going to call up is Karen Whitman from the Halpern Landscape Conservancy and Lejeune Thorson from the Downtown Neighborhood Association, who have been part of the conversation Around the Keller Auditorium specifically and what that part of our, both our downtown core and our theater ecosystem, our performing arts ecosystem look like.

726
01:30:47.548 --> 01:30:49.011
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you both for being here today.

727
01:30:49.091 --> 01:30:49.573
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome.

728
01:30:49.798 --> 01:30:52.765
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm not sure who wants to go first, but jump right in.

729
01:30:53.185 --> 01:30:53.347
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

730
01:30:54.966 --> 01:30:56.488
<v Lejeune Thorson>Hi, I'm LeJune Thorson.

731
01:30:57.234 --> 01:31:02.462
<v Lejeune Thorson>Thank you for inviting me to speak on behalf of the Downtown Neighborhood Association as its president.

732
01:31:03.194 --> 01:31:12.881
<v Lejeune Thorson>After much research, about 3 years ago, the DNA took a position supporting refurbishing the Keller because we believed it was the best decision from an urban planning perspective.

733
01:31:13.380 --> 01:31:16.704
<v Lejeune Thorson>Our commitment is even stronger now from a fiscal perspective.

734
01:31:17.653 --> 01:31:19.131
<v Lejeune Thorson>Our commitment is even stronger now.

735
01:31:19.581 --> 01:31:29.444
<v Lejeune Thorson>We are asking you to reject the mayor's resolution to build a performing arts center at PSU while redesigning and preparing to build a smaller auditorium at the Keller.

736
01:31:30.087 --> 01:31:32.444
<v Lejeune Thorson>It is the wrong plan and this is the wrong time.

737
01:31:33.376 --> 01:31:35.203
<v Lejeune Thorson>There are just too many unanswered questions.

738
01:31:35.957 --> 01:31:49.273
<v Lejeune Thorson>Would there be demand enough for 3 venues, a Broadway-capable venue at PSU, the smaller venue that they're also proposing on their site, in addition to a 1,200 to 800-seat auditorium at the Keller?

739
01:31:50.380 --> 01:32:04.168
<v Lejeune Thorson>How much would the PSU concept really cost, not just the cost of design and construction at taxpayer expense, But also the ongoing cost to the city's annual budget of the condominium financial arrangement.

740
01:32:05.210 --> 01:32:10.644
<v Lejeune Thorson>How will the 2 new privately owned venues currently under construction impact demand for performance space?

741
01:32:11.782 --> 01:32:18.239
<v Lejeune Thorson>And would the PSU concept subsidize the other publicly owned P5 venues like the Keller does now?

742
01:32:19.635 --> 01:32:20.500
<v Lejeune Thorson>We need answers.

743
01:32:21.510 --> 01:32:25.788
<v Lejeune Thorson>Support for PSU by the mayor's ex officio table was not a majority.

744
01:32:25.853 --> 01:32:25.948
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you.

745
01:32:26.847 --> 01:32:27.713
<v Lejeune Thorson>I was on that committee.

746
01:32:27.970 --> 01:32:33.908
<v Lejeune Thorson>Of the 14 members who submitted their culminating questionnaires, only 7 endorsed building at PSU.

747
01:32:34.485 --> 01:32:40.920
<v Lejeune Thorson>Of the remaining 7, 6 stated that more information about cost and funding is needed, and the 7th abstained.

748
01:32:41.626 --> 01:32:42.573
<v Lejeune Thorson>This is public record.

749
01:32:43.407 --> 01:32:49.167
<v Lejeune Thorson>The city owns the Keller and its fountain park, and the city must maintain them regardless of the decision the council makes.

750
01:32:50.033 --> 01:32:59.171
<v Lejeune Thorson>The Keller already has a coexisting neighborhood of residents, coffee shops, businesses, offices, cafes, bars, restaurants, hotels, and parking facilities.

751
01:33:00.070 --> 01:33:04.506
<v Lejeune Thorson>We are asking you to reject the mayor's resolution, but I don't like the word no.

752
01:33:05.872 --> 01:33:17.119
<v Lejeune Thorson>Before committing the city and the taxpayers to this complex project of unknown cost and unknown funding, please say yes to an affordable future for the Keller Auditorium and the fountain.

753
01:33:17.779 --> 01:33:19.690
<v Lejeune Thorson>Say yes to the affordable fix.

754
01:33:20.661 --> 01:33:26.445
<v Lejeune Thorson>Spending $10 to $15 million to complete deferred maintenance and extend the life of the Keller.

755
01:33:27.916 --> 01:33:32.845
<v Lejeune Thorson>This affordable fix will not disrupt performances and the income they generate.

756
01:33:33.556 --> 01:33:34.688
<v Lejeune Thorson>That's very important.

757
01:33:35.658 --> 01:33:38.787
<v Lejeune Thorson>Then when the city is healthier financially, refurbish the Keller.

758
01:33:39.532 --> 01:33:39.887
<v Lejeune Thorson>Thank you.

759
01:33:42.542 --> 01:33:42.850
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

760
01:33:42.930 --> 01:33:43.206
<v Unidentified speaker>Go right ahead.

761
01:33:44.960 --> 01:33:45.724
<v Karen Whitman>Good afternoon.

762
01:33:45.771 --> 01:33:56.759
<v Karen Whitman>My name is Karen Whitman, and I'm representing the Halpern Landscape Conservancy and all of those advocating to renovate We oppose the expensive, impractical recommendation.

763
01:33:57.592 --> 01:34:06.243
<v Karen Whitman>It's about the total price tag, about $1 billion for both projects, and it could take a decade to become a reality.

764
01:34:06.981 --> 01:34:12.439
<v Karen Whitman>The city has no money at this time to commit to full funding for the PSU project.

765
01:34:13.161 --> 01:34:21.331
<v Karen Whitman>The Keller is now headed for a 1,200 to 1,800 seat reduction, Again, no study and no cost estimate.

766
01:34:22.346 --> 01:34:31.305
<v Karen Whitman>Pay attention because taxpayers are asked to make a commitment without answering the most basic questions first: who's paying for it and how?

767
01:34:32.814 --> 01:34:40.993
<v Karen Whitman>No public discussion has explained how the city would absorb this commitment as we struggle to maintain our infrastructure and services.

768
01:34:41.671 --> 01:34:50.707
<v Karen Whitman>If the Keller is left behind, it will bring with it significant damage to downtown, the neighborhood, and the world-famous Keller Fountain.

769
01:34:51.460 --> 01:34:58.494
<v Karen Whitman>We respectfully ask you to vote no on the resolution, but we have a few amendments if you choose to move forward.

770
01:35:00.359 --> 01:35:09.778
<v Karen Whitman>If this is truly a 2-theater proposal, proceeding with planning should be for both projects, both for PSU and the Keller.

771
01:35:10.596 --> 01:35:15.314
<v Karen Whitman>Create a public oversight and advisory committee should be undertaken for both.

772
01:35:16.069 --> 01:35:19.488
<v Karen Whitman>The city must appropriate funding for both.

773
01:35:20.242 --> 01:35:24.703
<v Karen Whitman>Without a commitment to fund, none of this is a reality.

774
01:35:25.842 --> 01:35:30.176
<v Karen Whitman>Include a feasibility study of a temporary venue during the Keller.

775
01:35:31.444 --> 01:35:32.327
<v Karen Whitman>Why, you ask?

776
01:35:32.407 --> 01:35:36.645
<v Karen Whitman>Because it's the most cost-effective solution for our issue.

777
01:35:37.689 --> 01:35:43.823
<v Karen Whitman>Lastly, when seeking funding for the PSU project, again, include the Keller.

778
01:35:45.252 --> 01:35:46.841
<v Karen Whitman>Now, this point is critical.

779
01:35:48.463 --> 01:35:59.329
<v Karen Whitman>5 Years down the road, we believe and will forecast for you, there won't be the political will nor the financial wallet to also fund the Keller's future.

780
01:36:00.261 --> 01:36:06.505
<v Karen Whitman>Right now, as it stands, that is exactly what this proposal allows to have happen.

781
01:36:07.564 --> 01:36:26.087
<v Karen Whitman>Years from now, the promises being made today will be worth nothing without the actions by the City Council and city government Now, responsible investment starts by asking whether a project is necessary, affordable, and supported by evidence.

782
01:36:27.003 --> 01:36:30.641
<v Karen Whitman>On all 3 counts, this proposal falls short.

783
01:36:31.381 --> 01:36:33.940
<v Karen Whitman>Don't let the Keller be left behind.

784
01:36:34.474 --> 01:36:35.006
<v Karen Whitman>Thank you.

785
01:36:36.873 --> 01:36:37.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

786
01:36:37.841 --> 01:36:40.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And you had some recommendations there for language changes.

787
01:36:40.659 --> 01:36:45.873
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If that's something that you'd like us to consider, if you could either get it to our offices or make sure it's posted in the written testimony.

788
01:36:47.859 --> 01:36:49.027
<v Karen Whitman>The amendments will follow.

789
01:36:49.350 --> 01:36:49.903
<v Emily Horton>Perfect.

790
01:36:50.323 --> 01:36:50.664
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

791
01:36:50.729 --> 01:36:51.541
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

792
01:36:52.027 --> 01:36:53.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both for being here with us today.

793
01:36:56.760 --> 01:37:08.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our second panel is— I'm sorry, our second panel is PSU President Cudd and PSU Foundation President Sarah Schwartz.

794
01:37:14.514 --> 01:37:15.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both.

795
01:37:15.636 --> 01:37:16.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

796
01:37:16.663 --> 01:37:24.461
<v Anne Cudd>Good afternoon, and for the record, my name is Anne Cudd, and I'm the president of Portland State University, and I'm thrilled to be here today.

797
01:37:25.729 --> 01:37:32.804
<v Anne Cudd>Long before I became the president of PSU, Portland was a place that I hoped that someday I could make my home.

798
01:37:33.622 --> 01:37:38.885
<v Anne Cudd>So when I was given the opportunity to lead this university, I considered myself very lucky indeed.

799
01:37:39.926 --> 01:37:50.516
<v Anne Cudd>One of the first ideas I encountered when I arrived was the possibility of creating a performing arts and culture center right on campus with a Broadway theater at its heart.

800
01:37:51.158 --> 01:37:58.127
<v Anne Cudd>And I remember thinking, this is what great cities and great universities do together in partnership.

801
01:37:59.474 --> 01:38:09.722
<v Anne Cudd>I've spent my career at urban universities across the country, and I've seen what can happen when institutions and civic leaders partner together on a bold vision.

802
01:38:10.899 --> 01:38:17.216
<v Anne Cudd>Those partnerships create opportunity, they create energy, and they really make cities thrive.

803
01:38:18.989 --> 01:38:22.143
<v Anne Cudd>This year, Portland State celebrates its 80th anniversary.

804
01:38:22.823 --> 01:38:30.483
<v Anne Cudd>Throughout our history, we've grown right alongside Portland, and we've always believed that our future is tied to the future of the city.

805
01:38:31.262 --> 01:38:33.065
<v Anne Cudd>Serving the city is in our DNA.

806
01:38:33.146 --> 01:38:33.407
<v Anne Cudd>Thank you.

807
01:38:34.252 --> 01:38:37.590
<v Anne Cudd>And that's how Portland State has approached this opportunity.

808
01:38:38.649 --> 01:39:04.027
<v Anne Cudd>For 3 years, we've brought our time, our talent, our expertise, our partnerships, and our resources to the table because we believe in what this project can mean for Portland, for downtown, for students from district— all the districts across the city, for artists and art organizations, and for the future citizens who will live, learn, create, and work here.

809
01:39:04.091 --> 01:39:04.186
<v Anne Cudd>Thank you.

810
01:39:05.516 --> 01:39:07.103
<v Anne Cudd>We are all in, councilors.

811
01:39:08.016 --> 01:39:16.988
<v Anne Cudd>We are proud to be your partner and excited to engage this work with you as we help to write the next chapter for Portland and Portland State.

812
01:39:17.789 --> 01:39:18.511
<v Anne Cudd>So thank you.

813
01:39:18.686 --> 01:39:24.567
<v Anne Cudd>I'm gonna now hand it over to Sarah Schwarz, who has led this project for PSU from the very beginning.

814
01:39:25.784 --> 01:39:26.185
<v Sarah Schwarz>Thank you.

815
01:39:26.905 --> 01:39:27.931
<v Sarah Schwarz>Good afternoon, councilors.

816
01:39:28.380 --> 01:39:33.490
<v Sarah Schwarz>Sarah Schwarz, President of the PSU Foundation, and I'm grateful to be here with you again today.

817
01:39:34.640 --> 01:39:44.375
<v Sarah Schwarz>As Anne mentioned, 3 years ago, the City of Portland asked PSU to explore what a Broadway-capable theater at PSU might make possible in Portland.

818
01:39:45.248 --> 01:39:55.747
<v Sarah Schwarz>We accepted that invitation enthusiastically, and in fact, Anne and I just compared notes, and it was our first meeting on her first time on campus in that spring that we talked about this project.

819
01:39:57.358 --> 01:40:00.858
<v Sarah Schwarz>We enthusiastically wanted to be in on this for a few reasons.

820
01:40:01.442 --> 01:40:06.095
<v Sarah Schwarz>We believe that PSU is uniquely positioned to serve the city at this very moment.

821
01:40:06.738 --> 01:40:10.719
<v Sarah Schwarz>We own the largest developable parcel in downtown Portland.

822
01:40:11.457 --> 01:40:15.100
<v Sarah Schwarz>We bring the experience of delivering on major capital projects.

823
01:40:15.725 --> 01:40:19.546
<v Sarah Schwarz>We have academic programs that will activate and strengthen these facilities.

824
01:40:20.702 --> 01:40:26.046
<v Sarah Schwarz>We are fundraising experts, and we have a mission that is rooted in service to the city.

825
01:40:27.010 --> 01:40:47.248
<v Sarah Schwarz>So we proposed something bold— an arts and culture hub with a Broadway theater at its heart, surrounded by smaller venues, classrooms, collaborative spaces, a conference center, and a hotel, intentionally designed to maximize benefits for downtown Portland, the cultural community, and the university.

826
01:40:48.515 --> 01:41:00.582
<v Sarah Schwarz>We've continued to refine that proposal through hundreds of conversations with artists, arts organizations, business leaders, Broadway representatives, community leaders, city staff, faculty and students, and donors.

827
01:41:01.336 --> 01:41:01.944
<v Sarah Schwarz>And guess what?

828
01:41:02.121 --> 01:41:03.868
<v Sarah Schwarz>Over 3 years, we've learned a lot.

829
01:41:05.261 --> 01:41:08.836
<v Sarah Schwarz>Meanwhile, a significant coalition has been assembling behind this effort.

830
01:41:09.829 --> 01:41:16.271
<v Sarah Schwarz>Portland State has identified funding for the academic and community spaces the university will own and operate.

831
01:41:17.282 --> 01:41:22.747
<v Sarah Schwarz>Coloss Development Group has been selected to negotiate development of the hotel and conference center.

832
01:41:23.837 --> 01:41:32.835
<v Sarah Schwarz>Together, these pieces represent more than $250 million in commitments, financing, and resources already connected to this project.

833
01:41:33.894 --> 01:41:37.390
<v Sarah Schwarz>So that brings us to today and the resolution that is before you.

834
01:41:38.192 --> 01:41:43.902
<v Sarah Schwarz>Importantly, this is not a resolution to approve financing for the city-owned Broadway Theatre.

835
01:41:44.623 --> 01:41:47.912
<v Sarah Schwarz>It is a resolution to authorize the next phase of work.

836
01:41:48.858 --> 01:42:02.557
<v Sarah Schwarz>It allows the city and PSU to get in the room together, With a lot of sharpened pencils and probably a few erasers and dig deeply into the financing strategy, answer outstanding questions, and build the information needed for future decisions.

837
01:42:03.615 --> 01:42:10.627
<v Sarah Schwarz>It also authorizes the city to begin an official planning process for the future of Keller, something I know all of us are glad to see.

838
01:42:11.895 --> 01:42:17.958
<v Sarah Schwarz>This is a significant undertaking, and it's important to recognize that we are not starting from scratch.

839
01:42:18.632 --> 01:42:21.893
<v Sarah Schwarz>There have been 3 years of diligent work and investigation.

840
01:42:23.291 --> 01:42:43.947
<v Sarah Schwarz>To stay on schedule for a 2030 opening of the Broadway-capable theater, we ask City Council to consider committing to building the Broadway-capable theater at Portland State, putting a project agreement in place by December 1st of this year, and also by December 1st, making an initial city commitment to invest.

841
01:42:45.158 --> 01:42:51.274
<v Sarah Schwarz>Let's talk a minute about the initial city investment to commit, or initial city commitment to invest.

842
01:42:52.693 --> 01:42:54.350
<v Sarah Schwarz>I want to be real about the numbers.

843
01:42:54.867 --> 01:43:04.085
<v Sarah Schwarz>Many big numbers are mentioned with all of these projects, but what I do want to say clearly is that the city and PSU will never need to solve for $1 billion.

844
01:43:05.588 --> 01:43:13.292
<v Sarah Schwarz>In the near term, meaning by December 1st, the ideal number for the city to identify towards this project is $44 million.

845
01:43:13.408 --> 01:43:13.609
<v Sarah Schwarz>Thank you.

846
01:43:14.421 --> 01:43:24.121
<v Sarah Schwarz>Which is about 10% of the Broadway Theater cost that was just identified in the city documents from the budget note that actually just came out in May.

847
01:43:25.403 --> 01:43:35.951
<v Sarah Schwarz>This initial investment, or this initial commitment to invest, I should say, would support the efficient sequencing of the immediate pre-development and pre-construction work ahead.

848
01:43:36.864 --> 01:43:46.851
<v Sarah Schwarz>But perhaps more importantly, it would signal confidence to donors and other potential funding partners, unlocking private philanthropy and investment.

849
01:43:48.006 --> 01:43:49.912
<v Sarah Schwarz>And I just want to take a quick moment on this.

850
01:43:50.409 --> 01:43:57.078
<v Sarah Schwarz>We currently have 3 donors that very early on stepped forward to make commitments totaling $12.6 million.

851
01:43:58.489 --> 01:44:03.908
<v Sarah Schwarz>These folks self-identified and were willing to jump in early because they believed in this bold vision.

852
01:44:04.421 --> 01:44:17.635
<v Sarah Schwarz>They believed it was a great opportunity for Portland, and because they also hoped that their commitment would show signs of confidence to the city and to the state that there is a community of supporters willing to be partners in this project.

853
01:44:18.960 --> 01:44:26.284
<v Sarah Schwarz>Finally, an initial commitment to invest from the city will ensure access to the bond financing that has already been authorized by the state of Portland.

854
01:44:27.855 --> 01:44:36.326
<v Sarah Schwarz>The Performing Arts and Culture Center is a chance to create something Portland has never had before, a Broadway-capable theater at the heart of a larger cultural campus.

855
01:44:37.445 --> 01:44:40.936
<v Sarah Schwarz>And this vision supports downtown's recovery while we build its future.

856
01:44:41.521 --> 01:44:43.957
<v Sarah Schwarz>The Keller stays open until the new center opens.

857
01:44:44.487 --> 01:44:46.057
<v Sarah Schwarz>Broadway keeps coming to Portland.

858
01:44:46.635 --> 01:44:55.612
<v Sarah Schwarz>Audiences keep filling downtown restaurants and hotels, and the city avoids the disruption that would come from a years-long closure with no alternative Broadway venue.

859
01:44:57.055 --> 01:44:59.891
<v Sarah Schwarz>We at PSU are all in on this project.

860
01:45:00.100 --> 01:45:05.198
<v Sarah Schwarz>As President Cudd said, we are a committed, capable, and solutions-oriented partner.

861
01:45:05.807 --> 01:45:12.845
<v Sarah Schwarz>If the City Council chooses to move forward, we stand ready to continue this work alongside you, turning a bold vision into a workable plan.

862
01:45:12.925 --> 01:45:13.052
<v Anne Cudd>Thank you.

863
01:45:14.140 --> 01:45:20.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both for being here and for all of the information today.

864
01:45:23.989 --> 01:45:30.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, our 3rd panel is representatives of the individuals who work in our venues.

865
01:45:30.306 --> 01:45:41.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have Lori Wimmer from the Northwest Oregon Labor Council, Randall Friesen from the Columbia Pacific Building Trades, Emily Horton from IATSE Local 28, and I believe Rosetta Venetucci from the Port Authority of Oregon.

866
01:45:41.609 --> 01:45:44.728
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The executive vice chair from IATSE is with us online as well.

867
01:45:49.326 --> 01:45:49.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right ahead.

868
01:45:50.242 --> 01:45:52.444
<v Lori Wimmer>Good afternoon, uh, committee members.

869
01:45:52.541 --> 01:46:15.273
<v Lori Wimmer>For your record, Laurel Wimmer, executive secretary-treasurer of the Northwest Oregon Labor Council, uh, here, honored to be here today to speak in support of a path forward for the development of a large Broadway-capable theater as a part of the Portland State University Arts and Culture Complex, because we believe it will save, create, and expand good union jobs in this city.

870
01:46:15.881 --> 01:46:23.319
<v Lori Wimmer>It will boost PSU's enrollment, it'll improve the city's arts inventory, and it will ultimately help revitalize our city.

871
01:46:24.442 --> 01:46:48.006
<v Lori Wimmer>Your predecessors on the former commission originally had just one vision to address the inadequacies of the Keller Auditorium, which was to close for 2 or more years to expand and seismically improve it, thereby costing hundreds of jobs and walking away from millions in economic activity and potentially driving off Broadway across America its most lucrative tenant.

872
01:46:48.792 --> 01:46:59.997
<v Lori Wimmer>We stepped forward then and asked that the commission consider a different path, one that could be staged over time, benefit the larger community, and save as many as 1,000 jobs.

873
01:47:00.510 --> 01:47:01.712
<v Lori Wimmer>That commission listened.

874
01:47:01.855 --> 01:47:06.810
<v Lori Wimmer>Thank you, Councilor Ryan, for your vote to look at these other options.

875
01:47:07.948 --> 01:47:09.502
<v Lori Wimmer>Fast forward to this hearing today.

876
01:47:10.207 --> 01:47:19.153
<v Lori Wimmer>You have before you the work product of 2 years of meetings, studies, fundraising, and planning for an approach that meets An array of needs, as you've heard.

877
01:47:19.890 --> 01:47:30.422
<v Lori Wimmer>A significant sum of money has already been raised or pledged for the Portland State Plan, which would be situated on the largest developable parcel in downtown, just 2 blocks from the Keller.

878
01:47:31.529 --> 01:47:38.806
<v Lori Wimmer>We believe that as Portland continues to build back from the challenges of the past 6 years, we must play to our strengths.

879
01:47:39.688 --> 01:47:45.363
<v Lori Wimmer>The inter-institutional partnership envisioned by the PAC Plan Plays uniquely to the Portland we love.

880
01:47:46.180 --> 01:48:00.640
<v Lori Wimmer>We're proud of our excellent arts facilities— excuse me, our excellent arts faculty at PSU, some of whose students must rehearse in stairwells, and others who've led the university's choir to international fame for its excellence.

881
01:48:01.489 --> 01:48:40.081
<v Lori Wimmer>Today, we're thrilled to say that not only would this path enable our IATSE members to maintain their employment by moving to the new larger theater once completed, but that the Keller too can still be renovated and offer smaller venue for smaller-scale arts Most especially, we'd like to point out that as PSU struggles to reverse its downward enrollment trends and its resulting financial crisis, we see the PAC as part of a turnaround effort the university can employ, along with effective marketing of its excellent academic programs, to ensure that they're never again in a position to lay off a shameful huge hunk of their faculty.

882
01:48:41.123 --> 01:48:49.797
<v Lori Wimmer>PSU and the building trades have entered into an agreement Not even a week old, to deploy a project workforce development agreement for this project as well.

883
01:48:50.663 --> 01:48:55.072
<v Lori Wimmer>And Northwest Oregon Labor Council was proud to have served as a catalyst for this to occur.

884
01:48:55.872 --> 01:49:01.771
<v Lori Wimmer>We thank President Cudd for her willingness to sign on to a labor-friendly approach to the development of the arts complex.

885
01:49:02.685 --> 01:49:12.912
<v Lori Wimmer>We also anticipate ongoing work for various other trades once the project is up and running, including operating engineers, electricians, Security, and so on.

886
01:49:14.128 --> 01:49:19.001
<v Lori Wimmer>We're grateful to this committee for its often expressed union values as city leaders.

887
01:49:19.898 --> 01:49:24.448
<v Lori Wimmer>Your support for this proposal is the best demonstration of those values we could imagine.

888
01:49:25.202 --> 01:49:29.898
<v Lori Wimmer>We urge the committee to send this proposal to the full council with a do pass recommendation.

889
01:49:30.394 --> 01:49:30.747
<v Lori Wimmer>Thank you.

890
01:49:31.195 --> 01:49:37.364
<v Lori Wimmer>And now I'd like to hand it off to Rosetta Venitucci, who is on your computer screen.

891
01:49:38.650 --> 01:49:39.545
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, Rosetta.

892
01:49:39.788 --> 01:49:45.037
<v Rosetta Venetucci>Good afternoon, Chair Pirtle-Guiney and members of the committee.

893
01:49:45.869 --> 01:49:56.927
<v Rosetta Venetucci>For the record, my name is Roseetta Venitucci, and I am the business representative for IATSE Local 28, on stage in Portland since 1895, before any of these venues were built.

894
01:49:57.914 --> 01:50:08.609
<v Rosetta Venetucci>I represent entertainment industry workers not only at P5 but also at RCM, which is the Moda and the VMC, As well as many other sites in Southwest Washington and Oregon.

895
01:50:09.523 --> 01:50:17.055
<v Rosetta Venetucci>Local 28 has enthusiastically endorsed the Performing Arts and Culture Center project to be built on the new site at PSU.

896
01:50:18.032 --> 01:50:31.622
<v Rosetta Venetucci>We believe this, this protects the long-term financial security of the many workers who make Broadway shows possible, the potential to transform and advance the entertainment industry workforce, in Portland.

897
01:50:32.439 --> 01:50:34.157
<v Rosetta Venetucci>We need Broadway without closure.

898
01:50:34.622 --> 01:50:43.574
<v Rosetta Venetucci>We need Broadway to grow, and we need the continued support for local nonprofit community as well as many of the small local companies here in Portland.

899
01:50:44.569 --> 01:50:53.201
<v Rosetta Venetucci>I recognize the city has limited resources, and I really appreciate the careful consideration you give to how you allocate these resources.

900
01:50:54.019 --> 01:51:05.951
<v Rosetta Venetucci>As someone who has worked in the entertainment industry for 43 years, including touring, 36 years as an IATSE member here in Portland, and all of the current and previous city venues.

901
01:51:06.623 --> 01:51:18.922
<v Rosetta Venetucci>I want to urge you to invest in our future by creating a true pipeline to a thriving arts and cultural workforce, which pays dividends in the economic impact we see for decades to come.

902
01:51:19.934 --> 01:51:23.301
<v Rosetta Venetucci>IATSE represents workers across the U.S. and Canada.

903
01:51:23.862 --> 01:51:25.304
<v Rosetta Venetucci>Canada, where I'm here today.

904
01:51:26.185 --> 01:51:29.295
<v Rosetta Venetucci>We know what access to education does for our workforce.

905
01:51:30.015 --> 01:51:31.793
<v Rosetta Venetucci>This is about building for the future.

906
01:51:32.435 --> 01:51:38.429
<v Rosetta Venetucci>A Broadway theater at the center can be built without the renovation constraints of a smaller site.

907
01:51:39.149 --> 01:51:48.957
<v Rosetta Venetucci>It will include state-of-the-art stage and technical capabilities, ample backstage working areas, and yes, an adequate amount of restrooms for workers.

908
01:51:49.020 --> 01:51:49.197
<v Rosetta Venetucci>Thank you.

909
01:51:50.302 --> 01:51:55.158
<v Rosetta Venetucci>A lobby that would not just get by, but actually capable of serving the audience size.

910
01:51:55.814 --> 01:52:01.889
<v Rosetta Venetucci>With a fully capable venue, this would ensure shows that Oregonians want to see can come to Oregon.

911
01:52:02.865 --> 01:52:14.868
<v Rosetta Venetucci>The large site at PSU means there's plenty of room to meet modern safety and operational standards, reducing compromises, and would improve load-in, load-out, and run-of-show backstage conditions.

912
01:52:15.542 --> 01:52:23.250
<v Rosetta Venetucci>There would literally be enough room to fit all of the pieces and larger shows, and we wouldn't have to take them back out on the street and store them in trucks.

913
01:52:24.358 --> 01:52:35.180
<v Rosetta Venetucci>A staged process for reconstructing the Keller after the center opens its doors avoids a 3 to 5 year Broadway disruption, the loss of 300+ permanent jobs.

914
01:52:35.759 --> 01:52:44.286
<v Rosetta Venetucci>The impacts of job loss often include a loss of change to healthcare, which then changes your current doctor that knows you and your family.

915
01:52:44.863 --> 01:53:00.074
<v Rosetta Venetucci>It delays the ability for people to retire, people who are within years of retirement, the loss of needed paid time off for mental health breaks, the loss of hours we need to make our rent or mortgage payments, and it could also be more loss of housing.

916
01:53:00.427 --> 01:53:01.264
<v Rosetta Venetucci>The list goes on.

917
01:53:02.355 --> 01:53:14.274
<v Rosetta Venetucci>So now I'd like to turn it over to my colleague Emily Horton to discuss more of Please provide specifics regarding why a prolonged closure would be devastating and have a devastating impact on entertainment industry workforce.

918
01:53:15.524 --> 01:53:15.974
<v Karen Whitman>Thank you.

919
01:53:17.256 --> 01:53:23.685
<v Emily Horton>Chair Pirtle-Guiney and members of the committee, my name is Emily Horton and I am a wardrobe worker and a member of IATSE Local 28.

920
01:53:24.711 --> 01:53:32.404
<v Emily Horton>As someone who works in the Keller day in and day out, I am intimately aware of the fact that our skills are unique and live event specific.

921
01:53:33.287 --> 01:53:40.978
<v Emily Horton>The livelihood of the hundreds of people who work in the creative arts supporting Broadway and other shows are contingent upon the decision you make at this committee.

922
01:53:42.454 --> 01:53:55.347
<v Emily Horton>I will not spend time discussing the fact that every city-supported study has pointed towards advancing a Broadway-capable venue as part of the Performing Arts and Culture Center, but I will just leave you with this: my personal experience and that of my colleagues.

923
01:53:56.663 --> 01:54:01.704
<v Emily Horton>I attended a university that has a curriculum where I worked side by side with industry professionals.

924
01:54:02.506 --> 01:54:06.145
<v Emily Horton>Studying university-level academics while building a professional resume.

925
01:54:07.171 --> 01:54:18.680
<v Emily Horton>My work-study job was for an award-winning regional theater, allowing me to graduate with minimum debt and a fully developed professional resume that allowed me to transition into a full-time career seamlessly.

926
01:54:19.675 --> 01:54:25.045
<v Emily Horton>My peers and I love our jobs and have worked tirelessly for decades to excel and thrive at them.

927
01:54:25.911 --> 01:54:34.726
<v Emily Horton>These are skills that are built over a lifetime, and there are no other jobs in Portland that require or hire workers with our skills in the numbers that these performances do.

928
01:54:35.849 --> 01:54:40.770
<v Emily Horton>Our skills are unique, live event specific, and in demand nationwide.

929
01:54:41.538 --> 01:54:49.457
<v Emily Horton>We have careers, health insurance, retirement with dignity, and safe, stable places to live because of these good union jobs.

930
01:54:50.130 --> 01:54:54.233
<v Emily Horton>And we only have this because of the many different union employers we work for.

931
01:54:54.858 --> 01:54:58.159
<v Emily Horton>No one venue or one employer provides us with full-time work.

932
01:54:58.801 --> 01:55:02.567
<v Emily Horton>It's only through the full ecosystem that we thrive as a community.

933
01:55:03.577 --> 01:55:05.898
<v Emily Horton>Thank you for your time and consideration of this resolution.

934
01:55:08.380 --> 01:55:11.939
<v Randall Friesen>All right, good afternoon, uh, Chair Pirtle-Guiney and members of the committee.

935
01:55:12.846 --> 01:55:17.814
<v Randall Friesen>For the record, my name is Randall Friesen, Executive Director of the Columbia Pacific Building and Construction Trades Council.

936
01:55:18.362 --> 01:55:28.136
<v Randall Friesen>The Columbia Pacific Building Trades Council proudly represents over 20,000 construction professionals and their families across 22 local unions in the Portland metropolitan and Southwest Washington region.

937
01:55:29.162 --> 01:55:36.905
<v Randall Friesen>We are here today to give public support to the proposed 4-acre development of Portland State University's new performing arts venue and hotel development.

938
01:55:37.658 --> 01:55:53.112
<v Randall Friesen>We are happy to announce that late last week, PSU and the Columbia Pacific Building Trades Council reached an agreement to ensure the PSU-owned portions of this project will have excellent labor standards, ensuring our community will reach maximum return on their investment to this project.

939
01:55:53.849 --> 01:55:59.940
<v Randall Friesen>This project will create an estimated 2,000 construction jobs and 400 permanent jobs, including operations and maintenance.

940
01:56:00.020 --> 01:56:00.117
<v Randall Friesen>Thank you.

941
01:56:02.425 --> 01:56:15.667
<v Randall Friesen>It will also help achieve— excuse me, activate 7 blocks of developable proximate property with spillover investment potential of around $1 billion beyond the center construction.

942
01:56:16.742 --> 01:56:21.328
<v Randall Friesen>We have an opportunity to put Portland back on the map as a destination, and that starts with this project.

943
01:56:21.729 --> 01:56:29.527
<v Randall Friesen>The fact that we have a project workforce development agreement with PSU, which they proactively negotiated with our council, is indicative of a future-focused, forward-thinking city.

944
01:56:29.576 --> 01:56:29.689
<v Rosetta Venetucci>Thank you.

945
01:56:30.117 --> 01:56:33.488
<v Randall Friesen>Visionary commitment to collaboratively shaping the future of downtown Portland.

946
01:56:34.547 --> 01:56:37.646
<v Randall Friesen>This project is unlike any other the city has considered in recent years.

947
01:56:38.256 --> 01:56:50.412
<v Randall Friesen>It has the potential to drive foot traffic to downtown and put cranes in the air for decades to come, all while advancing a commitment to workforce development, business development, and labor engagement— values I know this committee shares.

948
01:56:51.391 --> 01:56:55.180
<v Randall Friesen>At the council, we work with a lot of developers, but very few like PSU.

949
01:56:55.842 --> 01:57:09.850
<v Randall Friesen>PSU shares our commitment to working with high-road contractors, advancing minority, women, emerging veteran, and small emerging businesses, and they care about the workers putting their sweat into building this campus of the future.

950
01:57:11.789 --> 01:57:20.969
<v Randall Friesen>In closing, when I think about our city's future, I imagine it with a Broadway-capable venue situated as part of the Performing Arts and Culture Center on the PSU campus.

951
01:57:21.587 --> 01:57:24.213
<v Randall Friesen>I hope you will share this vision by advancing this resolution.

952
01:57:25.340 --> 01:57:29.831
<v Randall Friesen>Together, we can do things for our city, our workers, and our collective future.

953
01:57:30.255 --> 01:57:31.768
<v Randall Friesen>Thank you all very much for your careful consideration.

954
01:57:33.699 --> 01:57:36.587
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for being part of our conversation today.

955
01:57:39.800 --> 01:57:43.962
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we are going to hear from a few of our fellow councilors now.

956
01:57:44.912 --> 01:57:49.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors Clark, Council President Dunphy, and Councilor Knoll.

957
01:57:50.435 --> 01:57:51.376
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe are here.

958
01:57:57.659 --> 01:58:07.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, Councilor— Council President Dunphy and Council Vice President Clark sat on one of the work groups that was holding these conversations.

959
01:58:07.905 --> 01:58:12.042
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I think it is important for us to hear from them today.

960
01:58:12.833 --> 01:58:13.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilors, go right ahead.

961
01:58:14.045 --> 01:58:14.998
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

962
01:58:15.301 --> 01:58:15.958
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

963
01:58:16.023 --> 01:58:16.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

964
01:58:17.144 --> 01:58:19.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Chair Pirtle-Guiney, members of the City Life Committee.

965
01:58:19.532 --> 01:58:20.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>For the record, my name is Jamie Dunphy.

966
01:58:21.213 --> 01:58:24.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>I serve as the City Council President and proudly represent District 1.

967
01:58:25.796 --> 01:58:30.171
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've been a big supporter of the vision for the new Broadway Theater in collaboration with PSU.

968
01:58:31.229 --> 01:58:38.006
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've been anything but shy about my opinion about this, and my job today is to tell you why and what I think this moment is about.

969
01:58:39.497 --> 01:58:54.244
<v Jamie Dunphy>Like many of the core problems that this City Council faces, The City of Portland owns a deeply neglected and wildly outdated building that no longer meets the needs of our modern economy, and decades of city councilors have kicked the can down the road on doing something about it.

970
01:58:54.421 --> 01:58:58.162
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's no capital maintenance fund for the Keller, nor any of the theaters that we own.

971
01:58:59.238 --> 01:59:02.145
<v Jamie Dunphy>The Keller is 100 years old and will fall down if there's an earthquake.

972
01:59:02.546 --> 01:59:04.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>It doesn't meet ADA accessibility requirements.

973
01:59:04.938 --> 01:59:06.109
<v Jamie Dunphy>There aren't enough bathrooms.

974
01:59:06.302 --> 01:59:07.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>It has terrible acoustics.

975
01:59:08.631 --> 01:59:18.012
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is Extremely low merchandise sales by national standards, not because there aren't theater nerds in Portland who are looking for a t-shirt, but because the lobby layout is just bad.

976
01:59:18.958 --> 01:59:24.972
<v Jamie Dunphy>Unlike every— nearly every major Broadway-capable theater in the country, the Keller has no loading dock.

977
01:59:25.246 --> 01:59:34.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>To load in The Phantom of the Opera, parked trucks literally circle the block and one by one pull up to this little hole on the side of the building with half of their truck sticking out into Clay Street.

978
01:59:35.412 --> 01:59:42.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>On the inside of the theater, they stack scenery 3 layers deep in the wings because the building footprint is too small for modern touring productions.

979
01:59:44.127 --> 01:59:55.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>3 Years ago, when there was a first round of conversations about whether to renovate the Keller in place or build a new theater at PSU, at that time, I was a board member of the local nonprofit Music Portland.

980
01:59:56.064 --> 02:00:03.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>And with our friends at IATSE and the Federation of Musicians, AFM Local 99, we led a campaign to support the PSU project.

981
02:00:03.979 --> 02:00:04.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

982
02:00:05.359 --> 02:00:05.488
<v Jamie Dunphy>Why?

983
02:00:06.019 --> 02:00:12.654
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because then, as now, the reality was that to renovate the Keller in place meant that you would have to close it down for years.

984
02:00:13.314 --> 02:00:17.251
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is nowhere else in Portland that can accommodate a touring Broadway theater.

985
02:00:17.733 --> 02:00:23.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if the Keller closes without a replacement already in hand, for over 5 years, there would be no Broadway in Portland.

986
02:00:23.935 --> 02:00:25.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>There would be no work for our stagehands.

987
02:00:25.863 --> 02:00:29.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the funding that the Keller generates, which supports the rest of P5, would disappear.

988
02:00:29.961 --> 02:00:30.088
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

989
02:00:30.762 --> 02:00:35.368
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it's not just that we would lose those jobs, we would lose those actual human beings that do the work.

990
02:00:35.912 --> 02:00:40.117
<v Jamie Dunphy>They would move to cities like Seattle, LA, or Boise where there's actual work happening.

991
02:00:41.271 --> 02:00:47.898
<v Jamie Dunphy>A generation of our workforce would leave the city and the P5 would either close or move immediately to privatization.

992
02:00:48.957 --> 02:00:51.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that's a bad, expensive, and damaging outcome for the city.

993
02:00:53.047 --> 02:01:11.672
<v Jamie Dunphy>As has been said, the ex officio table, which Vice President Clark and I both sat on, and the steering committee have both independently come to recommending— to come— have both independently come to recommending building a new Broadway-capable venue in Portland at PSU and developing the Keller into a smaller venue.

994
02:01:12.832 --> 02:01:15.644
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's no scenario in which anybody supported mothballing the Keller.

995
02:01:17.170 --> 02:01:25.328
<v Jamie Dunphy>Additionally, the theater arts program at PSU is growing and attracting high-quality faculty and an increasing number of students, right at the same time that other colleges in our area are reducing these kinds of services.

996
02:01:25.426 --> 02:01:25.623
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

997
02:01:28.639 --> 02:01:35.929
<v Jamie Dunphy>It should not be the case that young artists in Portland have to leave the city they grew up in to have the opportunity to access professional facilities and practitioners.

998
02:01:36.443 --> 02:01:50.943
<v Jamie Dunphy>This project offers real opportunities for apprenticeship and workforce development initiatives in stage design and technology, a grounding for the development of competitive performing arts programs, and offers another step towards PSU turning into a regional powerhouse for arts education.

999
02:01:52.162 --> 02:01:55.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, the city has spent a decade trying to figure out what we should do with this theater.

1000
02:01:56.529 --> 02:01:59.398
<v Jamie Dunphy>The basic realities of the situation have been clear for the whole time.

1001
02:02:00.182 --> 02:02:14.301
<v Jamie Dunphy>Despite all the media and some naysayers, all professional analysis that the city has commissioned, the recommendations before you are what people in this city who have actually touched these buildings with their hands every day have been saying was obvious years ago.

1002
02:02:15.422 --> 02:02:20.728
<v Jamie Dunphy>After a decade of analysis and study groups, the city of Portland has yet to say exactly what it is they want to do.

1003
02:02:21.432 --> 02:02:26.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>Pick your metaphor, whether we're kicking the can down the road or trying to split the baby, the city needs a direction.

1004
02:02:26.400 --> 02:02:26.545
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1005
02:02:27.283 --> 02:02:29.418
<v Jamie Dunphy>This resolution gives us a direction.

1006
02:02:29.932 --> 02:02:31.345
<v Jamie Dunphy>It does not commit us to a price.

1007
02:02:32.037 --> 02:02:36.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>It says there is enough clear direction for you to actually develop a price.

1008
02:02:37.560 --> 02:02:52.027
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I understand that there are some amendments being proposed, and I'm supportive of the changes that are— I think that the language moves us towards clarity because we have to have the courage to be clear and the intention to take care of our broken stuff.

1009
02:02:52.880 --> 02:02:54.957
<v Jamie Dunphy>I urge you all, please move this forward.

1010
02:02:55.069 --> 02:02:59.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Make an affirmative decision and stop tormenting the community by delaying definitive action.

1011
02:02:59.416 --> 02:03:00.109
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need a decision.

1012
02:03:00.739 --> 02:03:02.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>I urge you to vote yes on this resolution.

1013
02:03:03.100 --> 02:03:03.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1014
02:03:07.141 --> 02:03:08.112
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1015
02:03:10.618 --> 02:03:11.037
<v Olivia Clark>Thanks.

1016
02:03:11.782 --> 02:03:14.627
<v Olivia Clark>It's really a pleasure to be on this side of the dais.

1017
02:03:16.092 --> 02:03:16.997
<v Olivia Clark>I'm Olivia Clark.

1018
02:03:17.046 --> 02:03:18.467
<v Olivia Clark>I represent District 4.

1019
02:03:18.904 --> 02:03:33.916
<v Olivia Clark>I'm also the council vice president, and I did participate in the mayor's And while I did not agree with my esteemed colleague here, there was not a consensus on the ex officio committee.

1020
02:03:34.125 --> 02:03:40.837
<v Olivia Clark>There was a vote, and it was a majority for the PSU proposal.

1021
02:03:41.592 --> 02:03:47.969
<v Olivia Clark>So at that point, I recommended that we have some addendum to this.

1022
02:03:49.125 --> 02:03:53.300
<v Olivia Clark>So I agree with my colleague that we need to bring this chapter to a close.

1023
02:03:53.364 --> 02:03:53.524
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1024
02:03:54.488 --> 02:03:59.851
<v Olivia Clark>It's been a long, long road and arduous process with lots of committees and lots of talking.

1025
02:04:00.927 --> 02:04:04.670
<v Olivia Clark>But today, this is really not an either/or decision.

1026
02:04:05.746 --> 02:04:08.813
<v Olivia Clark>From my perspective, we can be a partner with PSU.

1027
02:04:09.359 --> 02:04:13.502
<v Olivia Clark>At the same time, we have to protect the city's interests and the Keller.

1028
02:04:14.721 --> 02:04:18.560
<v Olivia Clark>I know PSU needs an academic replacement facility, perhaps to the Smith.

1029
02:04:19.154 --> 02:04:26.768
<v Olivia Clark>My own choir director says that, who came out of PSU, says they really need a 800 to 900-seat academic facility.

1030
02:04:28.496 --> 02:04:40.090
<v Olivia Clark>And you have heard me repeatedly, colleagues, say that we have a history of chasing shiny objects in this city and not caring for what we own, our owned assets.

1031
02:04:40.139 --> 02:04:43.108
<v Olivia Clark>In fact, 3 auditors have made that criticism of us.

1032
02:04:44.155 --> 02:04:58.976
<v Olivia Clark>However, I would echo some of the comments that have been made by the previous panels that we are not in a position to financially commit to PSU's 3,000-seat facility or to upgrade the Keller.

1033
02:04:59.779 --> 02:05:03.757
<v Olivia Clark>We do not have the resources for either of these, and I'm concerned about that.

1034
02:05:04.335 --> 02:05:08.009
<v Olivia Clark>So I would like to offer a few potential amendments.

1035
02:05:08.056 --> 02:05:14.234
<v Olivia Clark>I'm sorry I didn't file anything, but I think there's a copy of my amendments with each of you.

1036
02:05:14.779 --> 02:05:19.255
<v Olivia Clark>I also did not have the opportunity to see what the Halperin Group has proposed.

1037
02:05:19.335 --> 02:05:19.399
<v Olivia Clark>I did.

1038
02:05:20.957 --> 02:05:23.172
<v Olivia Clark>As far as amendments, and I'm interested in those.

1039
02:05:23.927 --> 02:05:29.275
<v Olivia Clark>But let me just walk through the changes that I would like to see you consider for the resolution.

1040
02:05:29.564 --> 02:05:32.167
<v Olivia Clark>I'll just briefly walk through these, through those.

1041
02:05:33.386 --> 02:05:44.742
<v Olivia Clark>I think that the goal of a 2030 opening date, I don't know if that refers to the academic facility or the larger facility, but I think it may not, it may be unrealistic.

1042
02:05:45.030 --> 02:05:46.139
<v Olivia Clark>And I would— I think it's the academic facility.

1043
02:05:46.572 --> 02:05:50.658
<v Olivia Clark>Urge you to consider removing that unless there's some consequence that I'm not familiar with.

1044
02:05:52.021 --> 02:06:01.125
<v Olivia Clark>There's also no discussion of the operation and maintenance of the facility, along with all the other questions that we have about the city's obligations under the resolution.

1045
02:06:01.783 --> 02:06:07.889
<v Olivia Clark>I'm clearly nervous about the pre-development functions and, and what they mean for us.

1046
02:06:09.155 --> 02:06:14.556
<v Olivia Clark>I think that the December 2026 deadline for a project commitment agreement is very ambitious.

1047
02:06:14.604 --> 02:06:14.748
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1048
02:06:15.646 --> 02:06:32.215
<v Olivia Clark>I'm not going to recommend anything there, but I'm a little worried that— I don't know if this language is necessary for PSU to access the bonds, in which case I appreciate that because I don't want them to lose that opportunity.

1049
02:06:33.207 --> 02:06:42.277
<v Olivia Clark>But lastly, and I think most importantly, and you've already heard this from other panels, we have to include the future of the Keller Auditorium in this effort.

1050
02:06:42.324 --> 02:06:42.389
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

1051
02:06:43.171 --> 02:06:45.293
<v Olivia Clark>The Keller is our city-owned facility.

1052
02:06:46.371 --> 02:06:54.378
<v Olivia Clark>Its performance and ticket sales, you've already heard, support the P5, and it has tremendous support from the people of Portland and across the region.

1053
02:06:55.054 --> 02:06:58.204
<v Olivia Clark>And like the Moda Center, we own the Keller.

1054
02:06:58.912 --> 02:07:05.381
<v Olivia Clark>If we're going to launch a partnership with PSU's conceptual vision— is that for me?

1055
02:07:06.782 --> 02:07:07.603
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

1056
02:07:08.729 --> 02:07:18.494
<v Olivia Clark>If we're going to actually launch a partnership with PSU and their conceptual vision, then we We also must include support for the Keller in tandem.

1057
02:07:18.895 --> 02:07:19.698
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, it's for Michelle.

1058
02:07:19.939 --> 02:07:20.886
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, it's not for me.

1059
02:07:22.091 --> 02:07:24.242
<v Olivia Clark>Um, the Keller is ours.

1060
02:07:25.060 --> 02:07:30.567
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, it sits across, as you all know, from an amazing fountain, and it's in a wonderful neighborhood.

1061
02:07:31.320 --> 02:07:41.578
<v Olivia Clark>Thousands of dollars have been already poured into the redesign and positive activation around the Keller, including a design by Michael Curry, which is pretty amazing.

1062
02:07:42.507 --> 02:07:48.197
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm obviously committed to the Keller and its positive future.

1063
02:07:48.581 --> 02:08:00.889
<v Olivia Clark>I support what you heard LeJune Thorson from the DNA commented earlier regarding some of the improvements that we really should make to the Keller now that are not nearly as expensive and they wouldn't interrupt programs.

1064
02:08:01.081 --> 02:08:02.186
<v Olivia Clark>We should consider that.

1065
02:08:02.667 --> 02:08:11.376
<v Olivia Clark>But our, our council resolution really needs to reflect our commitment to what we own Thank you, colleagues.

1066
02:08:12.869 --> 02:08:14.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

1067
02:08:14.315 --> 02:08:27.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Clark, I suspect we will not get through our discussion today, so if you do have something that you'd like to file— I know we have this in front of us, but so that members of the public can see it too— we should have time to do that before our next committee hearing.

1068
02:08:27.878 --> 02:08:28.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1069
02:08:28.237 --> 02:08:33.113
<v Olivia Clark>And I, I'm interested in any comments or feedback that you have on those proposals as well.

1070
02:08:33.471 --> 02:08:34.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much.

1071
02:08:35.475 --> 02:08:37.525
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And was Councilor Knoll able to join us?

1072
02:08:37.975 --> 02:08:46.114
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I think he had another engagement that was running late, so if he is able to join, we will get him into the mix later.

1073
02:08:46.194 --> 02:09:01.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But in the meantime, we are now going to move to public testimony, and I think we have just over an hour's worth of testimony from folks signed up, so we'll get through as much as we can and roll over the rest of our conversation to our next meeting.

1074
02:09:02.082 --> 02:09:05.761
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Diego, could you please call up the first 5 people signed up to testify?

1075
02:09:06.822 --> 02:09:07.239
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1076
02:09:07.304 --> 02:09:09.520
<v Olivia Clark>And just a few procedural notes for testimony.

1077
02:09:09.810 --> 02:09:15.063
<v Olivia Clark>For those signed up for verbal testimony, a reminder that each testifier will receive 2 minutes each.

1078
02:09:15.801 --> 02:09:18.387
<v Olivia Clark>I will call up folks in groups of 5.

1079
02:09:18.935 --> 02:09:24.541
<v Olivia Clark>For those testifying in person, you'll see a timer countdown displayed on the monitor in front of the testimony table.

1080
02:09:25.055 --> 02:09:28.296
<v Olivia Clark>For those that are testifying virtually, The timer's displayed in Zoom.

1081
02:09:28.970 --> 02:09:31.520
<v Olivia Clark>When testifying, you'll hear the timer chime twice.

1082
02:09:31.778 --> 02:09:36.636
<v Olivia Clark>The first chime is a warning when you have 30 seconds left, then a second time when your time is up.

1083
02:09:37.310 --> 02:09:41.095
<v Olivia Clark>And finally, before you begin your testimony, please state your name for the record.

1084
02:09:41.832 --> 02:09:42.426
<v Olivia Clark>So our first group—.

1085
02:09:42.426 --> 02:09:44.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Miguel, before you call up the first group, I apologize.

1086
02:09:45.088 --> 02:09:47.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just saw Councilor Green poke his head around the corner.

1087
02:09:47.493 --> 02:09:54.846
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had thought he wasn't able to join us today, but Councilor, if you're still here, Nope, I'm not seeing him come back.

1088
02:09:55.945 --> 02:09:59.698
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we'll figure that out, and let's go ahead and get our first panel of public testimony.

1089
02:09:59.761 --> 02:10:00.101
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1090
02:10:02.007 --> 02:10:11.974
<v Olivia Clark>Julie Vigeland, Kimiko Matsuda, AJ Romero-Jamel, Lisa Lipton, Bea Marston.

1091
02:10:15.853 --> 02:10:21.117
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And folks, when you come up to testify, go ahead, and whoever is sitting down and ready first is welcome.

1092
02:10:21.260 --> 02:10:22.962
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome to kick off the, the group.

1093
02:10:25.659 --> 02:10:29.685
<v Julie Vigeland>Chair Pirtle-Guiney and committee members, for the record, my name is Julie Vigeland.

1094
02:10:30.426 --> 02:10:37.412
<v Julie Vigeland>I am a South Waterfront resident and Lifeline advocate, patron, volunteer, and supporter of the arts and culture in Portland.

1095
02:10:38.184 --> 02:10:41.131
<v Julie Vigeland>I'm here today to thank you for your extraordinary work.

1096
02:10:41.899 --> 02:10:47.649
<v Julie Vigeland>The recommendations before you are the result of years of study, public engagement, and thoughtful deliberation.

1097
02:10:48.809 --> 02:10:57.516
<v Julie Vigeland>The public conversation has at times been passionate and challenging, as conversations about the future of important cultural institutions often are.

1098
02:10:58.465 --> 02:11:07.912
<v Julie Vigeland>Through it all, I appreciate council's collective commitment to looking beyond individual interests and focusing on what will be best serving Portland for the generations to come.

1099
02:11:08.971 --> 02:11:23.939
<v Julie Vigeland>I spent much of my life championing and supporting the arts because I believe they are essential to the health of a They inspire us, challenge us, enrich our neighborhoods, strengthen our economy, and create the shared experiences that helps communities thrive.

1100
02:11:24.631 --> 02:11:33.301
<v Julie Vigeland>That is why I am encouraged by such a clear recommendation to move forward with a performing arts and culture center at the— with the Broadway Theater at its heart.

1101
02:11:34.184 --> 02:11:40.029
<v Julie Vigeland>We have an opportunity to think more expansively about what arts and culture can mean for future generations.

1102
02:11:40.462 --> 02:11:52.550
<v Julie Vigeland>And a place that welcomes new audiences, connects students and educators with performing arts, and strengthens artists and arts organizations across our region, and importantly, inspires philanthropy.

1103
02:11:53.368 --> 02:12:01.731
<v Julie Vigeland>I know from personal experience that donors are drawn to bold visions, strong partnerships, and projects that can make a lasting difference.

1104
02:12:02.453 --> 02:12:19.878
<v Julie Vigeland>In front of us, we have that truly unique opportunity that will bring people together As someone who spent decades championing the arts today, I find myself thinking less about my generation and what we enjoyed and more about what we will leave behind.

1105
02:12:20.488 --> 02:12:24.882
<v Julie Vigeland>At some point, every generation becomes a steward rather than a beneficiary.

1106
02:12:25.636 --> 02:12:34.796
<v Julie Vigeland>My hope is that future Portlanders will look back and say we had the vision to invest not only in what Portland was, but what it could become.

1107
02:12:34.940 --> 02:12:38.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Thank you.

1108
02:12:42.024 --> 02:12:44.603
<v Bea Marston>Okay, I guess I'm next.

1109
02:12:46.050 --> 02:12:47.020
<v Bea Marston>Hello, councilors.

1110
02:12:47.764 --> 02:12:49.947
<v Bea Marston>Uh, thank you for this opportunity to speak.

1111
02:12:50.431 --> 02:12:51.952
<v Bea Marston>Uh, my name is Bea Marston.

1112
02:12:52.130 --> 02:12:58.425
<v Bea Marston>I am an out and proud trans woman, she/her pronouns, uh, and proud member of Unite Here Local 8.

1113
02:12:59.131 --> 02:13:04.498
<v Bea Marston>Um, I'm also an employee of Levy Restaurants And I work as a bartender at Portland Five.

1114
02:13:05.774 --> 02:13:08.792
<v Bea Marston>You can see many of my coworkers in red shirts behind me.

1115
02:13:09.001 --> 02:13:10.018
<v Bea Marston>Hope you can see them.

1116
02:13:11.721 --> 02:13:19.134
<v Bea Marston>We want to make sure that y'all know that we are P5 workers, even though we're subcontractors.

1117
02:13:19.877 --> 02:13:26.381
<v Bea Marston>Many of us were here before our current employer, will be here when they leave, if they leave.

1118
02:13:26.527 --> 02:13:27.560
<v Bea Marston>Thank you.

1119
02:13:28.239 --> 02:13:34.917
<v Bea Marston>And, you know, we want to make sure that y'all remember us when you make these decisions, even though we're not directly employed by the city.

1120
02:13:36.920 --> 02:13:46.279
<v Bea Marston>There's been a lot of anxiety from folks that work at P5 about the future of the Keller, and we're glad to hear that y'all moving in a direction that does not involve a closure.

1121
02:13:47.250 --> 02:13:55.643
<v Bea Marston>Yet, you know, we also have anxiety about the city considering the operating model for P5 venues and what that might mean For us.

1122
02:13:56.542 --> 02:14:06.693
<v Bea Marston>I've worked at P5 for 24 years, and I've, you know, I feel like I've served half of Portland by now and probably many of the people in this room.

1123
02:14:07.967 --> 02:14:11.114
<v Bea Marston>And, you know, we build relationships with our guests.

1124
02:14:11.438 --> 02:14:14.140
<v Bea Marston>I have regulars that I've been serving for 10 years.

1125
02:14:15.993 --> 02:14:18.087
<v Bea Marston>Many of us have been there for longer than that.

1126
02:14:19.466 --> 02:14:20.912
<v Bea Marston>You know, there's very little turnover.

1127
02:14:21.042 --> 02:14:21.820
<v Bea Marston>It's a good job.

1128
02:14:21.998 --> 02:14:22.583
<v Bea Marston>It's a really good job.

1129
02:14:22.631 --> 02:14:22.746
<v Bea Marston>Thank you.

1130
02:14:24.742 --> 02:14:31.775
<v Bea Marston>And, you know, I used to be on public assistance, but we have a good contract and we have health insurance.

1131
02:14:32.145 --> 02:14:41.426
<v Bea Marston>We're trying to get more people on it, but if we lose the Keller, if we're closed, then no one's going to be able to get health insurance and our jobs will not be sustainable.

1132
02:14:42.100 --> 02:14:45.761
<v Bea Marston>And we're here today to ask for just a few things.

1133
02:14:46.275 --> 02:14:50.257
<v Bea Marston>We need to know that there is a plan that will prevent disruption of Keller shows.

1134
02:14:50.403 --> 02:14:50.595
<v Bea Marston>Thank you.

1135
02:14:51.157 --> 02:14:55.560
<v Bea Marston>If a PSU venue is built, we need to know that our— we'll have our jobs.

1136
02:14:56.059 --> 02:15:00.386
<v Bea Marston>If PSU builds a hotel, we would like to have a fair process for those workers to join a union.

1137
02:15:00.904 --> 02:15:07.886
<v Bea Marston>We want union labor for construction, and we need to know that we will keep our job— jobs and our union contract regardless of who is the operator.

1138
02:15:08.431 --> 02:15:09.011
<v Bea Marston>And thank you.

1139
02:15:09.560 --> 02:15:10.574
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1140
02:15:12.783 --> 02:15:13.716
<v Olivia Clark>Go ahead.

1141
02:15:17.185 --> 02:15:17.795
<v Kimiko Matsuda>Good afternoon.

1142
02:15:18.453 --> 02:15:19.850
<v Kimiko Matsuda>My name is Kimiko Matsuda.

1143
02:15:20.300 --> 02:15:26.273
<v Kimiko Matsuda>I'm an active supporter of the arts, a member of IATSE Local 28, and the vice chair of Portland Center Stage.

1144
02:15:26.738 --> 02:15:31.523
<v Kimiko Matsuda>I'm here because I believe Portland has an important choice to make about the future we're building.

1145
02:15:32.599 --> 02:15:38.057
<v Kimiko Matsuda>When we consider projects like this, we shouldn't judge them solely by what Portland needs today.

1146
02:15:38.860 --> 02:15:43.099
<v Kimiko Matsuda>We should ask what we want Portland to represent 30 years from now.

1147
02:15:44.140 --> 02:15:50.783
<v Kimiko Matsuda>The cities that admire— that we admire didn't become great by only solving today's problems.

1148
02:15:51.537 --> 02:15:57.761
<v Kimiko Matsuda>They become great because previous generations invested in a future they might never see themselves.

1149
02:15:58.981 --> 02:16:07.708
<v Kimiko Matsuda>For too long, we've operated from a scarcity mindset, asking what we have to cut or what we should— what isn't working.

1150
02:16:08.462 --> 02:16:11.078
<v Kimiko Matsuda>But cities don't become great by managing decline.

1151
02:16:11.832 --> 02:16:21.922
<v Kimiko Matsuda>They become great because we invest in the things that inspire people to stay, inspire people to create, build, and believe in a shared cultural future.

1152
02:16:22.966 --> 02:16:25.435
<v Kimiko Matsuda>This is why the Cultural Center matters.

1153
02:16:26.414 --> 02:16:30.088
<v Kimiko Matsuda>Portland State University isn't a for-profit-driven corporation.

1154
02:16:30.939 --> 02:16:36.105
<v Kimiko Matsuda>It's our urban public university with a mission That serves students and the city.

1155
02:16:36.843 --> 02:16:40.922
<v Kimiko Matsuda>That makes PSU one of Portland's most important civic partners.

1156
02:16:41.756 --> 02:16:44.903
<v Kimiko Matsuda>The Cultural Center at PSU is more than a campus project.

1157
02:16:45.191 --> 02:16:55.962
<v Kimiko Matsuda>It's an investment in Portland's creative ecosystem, a place where students, working artists, entrepreneurs, community members can all collaborate.

1158
02:16:56.620 --> 02:17:01.308
<v Kimiko Matsuda>I often say that the ideas that start here in Portland have the power to change the world.

1159
02:17:01.372 --> 02:17:01.485
<v Kimiko Matsuda>Thank you.

1160
02:17:02.065 --> 02:17:09.987
<v Kimiko Matsuda>People choose where they live, invest, build, and base their futures on what makes them feel great.

1161
02:17:10.600 --> 02:17:13.075
<v Kimiko Matsuda>Great cities become destinations people choose.

1162
02:17:14.304 --> 02:17:16.877
<v Kimiko Matsuda>This project isn't just about today's Portland.

1163
02:17:17.248 --> 02:17:20.515
<v Kimiko Matsuda>It's an investment in Portland as a world-class city.

1164
02:17:21.032 --> 02:17:21.371
<v Kimiko Matsuda>Thank you.

1165
02:17:23.681 --> 02:17:27.378
<v Lisa Lipton>Good afternoon, councilors.

1166
02:17:27.475 --> 02:17:28.427
<v Lisa Lipton>My name is Lisa Lipton.

1167
02:17:29.042 --> 02:17:44.665
<v Lisa Lipton>As an arts leader, entrepreneur, arts funding advocate, and Portlander, I urge the City Life Committee to support projects that strengthen our arts ecosystem, including Portland State University's proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center, while maintaining productive relationships with everyone in the community.

1168
02:17:45.582 --> 02:17:56.709
<v Lisa Lipton>As Portland looks toward the future, building community, revitalizing downtown, and creating opportunities for arts and culture to thrive, we need spaces that actively invest in the people who make this city creative.

1169
02:17:57.769 --> 02:18:07.281
<v Lisa Lipton>The new center at PSU will train students while placing them directly within a working ecosystem of productions, performances, new work, and professional artists.

1170
02:18:08.228 --> 02:18:23.218
<v Lisa Lipton>Portland needs traditions, and it also needs a center of capable— a center capable of accommodating larger productions while remaining accessible to smaller theater and performance ensembles with 250 to 500 seat attendance per production.

1171
02:18:23.908 --> 02:18:30.113
<v Lisa Lipton>PSU has recently made difficult decisions and significant cuts in pursuit of greater long-term sustainability.

1172
02:18:30.868 --> 02:18:46.790
<v Lisa Lipton>The fact that the university continues to invest in the long-term vision and design of this center, even while making challenging changes within its educational programs, speaks to the importance of this project and the future PSU believes it can build alongside Portland's arts and culture community.

1173
02:18:47.929 --> 02:18:50.815
<v Lisa Lipton>I urge the City Life Committee to believe in that future as well.

1174
02:18:51.547 --> 02:18:54.408
<v Lisa Lipton>And to support new projects as it pertains to arts and culture.

1175
02:18:55.184 --> 02:19:00.423
<v Lisa Lipton>I believe we can do this, and I believe that we can do this and also invest in the Keller's future too.

1176
02:19:01.407 --> 02:19:04.494
<v Lisa Lipton>Arts and culture presentations are not one size fits all.

1177
02:19:05.204 --> 02:19:06.869
<v Lisa Lipton>There is room for all of us in the future.

1178
02:19:07.631 --> 02:19:09.495
<v Lisa Lipton>This is the message the community needs right now.

1179
02:19:10.024 --> 02:19:10.281
<v Lisa Lipton>Thank you.

1180
02:19:13.415 --> 02:19:20.856
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Chair Pirtle-Guiney, Vice Chair Zimmerman, and members of the committee, for the record, my name is AJ Romero-Gimmel, and I serve as the PSU Graduate Student Trustee on the Board of Trustees.

1181
02:19:23.167 --> 02:19:30.829
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>I'm here today in strong support of the resolution to advance a new Broadway-capable venue as a part of the proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center at Portland State University.

1182
02:19:31.601 --> 02:19:36.966
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>In my role on the board, I represent the voice of students across all disciplines, backgrounds, and areas of study.

1183
02:19:37.880 --> 02:19:44.996
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>From a governance and student perspective, this project is a transformative generational opportunity for our entire university community and region.

1184
02:19:45.752 --> 02:19:50.699
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>This center will not just transform downtown, it'll be a powerful engine for student recruitment and enrollment.

1185
02:19:51.373 --> 02:19:55.435
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Today's students are looking for vibrant, connected campuses with state-of-the-art resources.

1186
02:19:56.191 --> 02:20:10.450
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Hosting a premier Broadway-capable facility right on campus gives PSU a unique competitive edge, attracting top talent locally, nationally, and internationally, not only in the performing arts, but across business, technical, and creative fields.

1187
02:20:11.671 --> 02:20:18.063
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Integrating a world-class venue into our campus directly enhances the overall student experience and catalyzes downtown revitalization.

1188
02:20:18.111 --> 02:20:18.238
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Thank you.

1189
02:20:18.914 --> 02:20:26.753
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>It expands academic and workforce development opportunities across campus, creating high-value internships, technical jobs, and venue and event management roles.

1190
02:20:27.507 --> 02:20:38.029
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Beyond those broader impacts, having a Broadway-capable venue on our campus provides access to training facilities and mentorship opportunities that our students would benefit from and might not have otherwise have access to.

1191
02:20:38.495 --> 02:20:41.001
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>This especially matters as PSU is an access institution.

1192
02:20:41.868 --> 02:20:55.629
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Locating academic space next to professional theater space will give PSU performing arts students a direct These facilities will also provide necessary upgrades that will impact students across all domains of study at Portland State.

1193
02:20:55.909 --> 02:21:04.889
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>As someone who took language courses in my undergrad at Portland State, having practice rooms next to traditional classrooms made oftentimes for disruptive learning.

1194
02:21:04.889 --> 02:21:11.549
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>The Performing Arts and Culture Center fixes that very problem, improves the student experience, and improves graduation outcomes.

1195
02:21:11.549 --> 02:21:16.170
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>I urge the city to support the new Broadway-capable venue at PSU as part of the Performing Arts and Culture Center.

1196
02:21:16.170 --> 02:21:16.209
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Thank you.

1197
02:21:16.209 --> 02:21:16.250
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Thank you.

1198
02:21:17.020 --> 02:21:21.221
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>This commitment from the city will be a pivotal moment for our region, our community, our programs, and our students.

1199
02:21:21.837 --> 02:21:23.167
<v AJ Romero-Jamel>Thank you for your time and for your leadership.

1200
02:21:25.209 --> 02:21:27.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for sharing your perspectives with us today.

1201
02:21:30.125 --> 02:21:40.245
<v Olivia Clark>Linda McKim-Bell, Carol Morse, Josh Hecht, Chuck Dillard, Leroy Bynum.

1202
02:21:49.399 --> 02:21:49.540
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

1203
02:21:49.700 --> 02:21:50.370
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for coming.

1204
02:21:58.798 --> 02:21:59.236
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1205
02:21:59.302 --> 02:22:00.281
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why don't we start at the end?

1206
02:22:05.399 --> 02:22:05.965
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon.

1207
02:22:06.546 --> 02:22:10.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, my name is LeRoy Bynum, and I am the Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

1208
02:22:10.159 --> 02:22:10.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good evening, everyone.

1209
02:22:10.159 --> 02:22:12.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm honored to be here today as the Dean of PSU's extraordinary College of the Arts.

1210
02:22:13.719 --> 02:22:27.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am beyond excited to speak to you about the Performing Arts and Culture Center, and most especially the large performing hall, and how it most assuredly will elevate performance experiences in Portland for decades to come.

1211
02:22:27.360 --> 02:22:38.699
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a performing artist and lifelong lover of the stage, for me, the process of developing this proposal has been all about serving and uplifting Portland's entire Performance ecosystem.

1212
02:22:39.516 --> 02:22:58.897
<v Jamie Dunphy>At the same time, the arts educator and arts administrator in me are keenly aware of the transformative power of performance venues like the one being proposed to elevate the arts and the artists, while also bringing cultural, economic, and social vibrancy to the communities they serve.

1213
02:23:00.149 --> 02:23:10.968
<v Jamie Dunphy>As part of PSU's Amazing Action Team, Working on this project, I've had hundreds of animated conversations with a wide variety of arts and culture organizations.

1214
02:23:11.549 --> 02:23:14.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's been a tremendous learning experience.

1215
02:23:22.881 --> 02:23:27.647
<v LeRoy Bynum>First, all artists need venues that allow them to look and sound their best.

1216
02:23:28.175 --> 02:23:33.854
<v LeRoy Bynum>And second, all audience members need to see and hear clearly what is being presented on the stage.

1217
02:23:34.754 --> 02:23:47.019
<v LeRoy Bynum>This requires the intentional creation of state-of-the-art tunable acoustics and complementary sightlines achievable with certainty only when a performance hall is built from the ground up in adequate space.

1218
02:23:47.692 --> 02:23:50.968
<v LeRoy Bynum>PSU excels in training amazing performing artists.

1219
02:23:51.548 --> 02:24:00.781
<v LeRoy Bynum>Imagine the synergy generated from curated or chance interactions between PSU stars of tomorrow and the music and theater world's stars of today.

1220
02:24:01.424 --> 02:24:08.539
<v LeRoy Bynum>We are eager to help build the talent pipeline for backstage professionals Portland so desperately needs.

1221
02:24:09.120 --> 02:24:15.738
<v LeRoy Bynum>Thank you for asking us to offer a proposal to build Portland's Broadway theater on campus.

1222
02:24:19.420 --> 02:24:19.808
<v Chuck Dillard>Good afternoon.

1223
02:24:20.326 --> 02:24:21.574
<v Chuck Dillard>My name is Dr. Chuck Dillard.

1224
02:24:21.881 --> 02:24:25.688
<v Chuck Dillard>I am the director of the School of Music and Theater at Portland State University.

1225
02:24:26.435 --> 02:24:36.450
<v Chuck Dillard>I strongly support advancing the Performing Arts and Culture Center because I see every day how our current facilities limit our students, And our ability to serve Portland.

1226
02:24:37.139 --> 02:24:42.735
<v Chuck Dillard>Our students study music and theater in a converted high school, not a purpose-built arts facility.

1227
02:24:43.391 --> 02:24:52.112
<v Chuck Dillard>Our popular Sonic Arts and Music Production program cannot grow beyond its capacity— beyond the capacity of its limited, ill-equipped spaces.

1228
02:24:52.529 --> 02:25:06.476
<v Chuck Dillard>Our 3 bands rehearse in a room with serious hearing safety concerns, and our award-winning chamber choir that just returned from China rehearses in a lecture hall in Cramer Hall because Lincoln Hall has no suitable Aye.

1229
02:25:06.572 --> 02:25:06.700
<v Greta Liu>Opposed?

1230
02:25:06.747 --> 02:25:06.763
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Aye.

1231
02:25:06.843 --> 02:25:07.020
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Motion passes.

1232
02:25:07.067 --> 02:25:07.981
<v Linda McKim-Bell>The PACC is in need of a suitable space.

1233
02:25:08.046 --> 02:25:16.233
<v Chuck Dillard>Sound bleed, elevator noise, streetcar rumblings, and inadequate acoustics prevent professional-quality rehearsals, performances, and recordings.

1234
02:25:16.825 --> 02:25:19.037
<v Chuck Dillard>But these are not merely inconveniences.

1235
02:25:19.533 --> 02:25:29.211
<v Chuck Dillard>They restrict enrollment, weaken morale, and tell talented students that their education has not received the investment— the same investment as other disciplines.

1236
02:25:29.788 --> 02:25:34.547
<v Chuck Dillard>The PACC would change that, but its impact would extend far beyond PSU.

1237
02:25:35.572 --> 02:25:46.440
<v Chuck Dillard>Purpose-built rehearsal rooms, recording facilities, and performance spaces would help us prepare the next generation of Portland's performers, educators, technicians, and arts leaders.

1238
02:25:47.016 --> 02:25:56.650
<v Chuck Dillard>Sharing a home with professional and nonprofit arts organizations would create internships, workforce training, and daily interaction with working artists.

1239
02:25:57.436 --> 02:26:11.102
<v Chuck Dillard>Right now, I have one foot in optimism with the promise of what PSU could become, and one foot bracing for a future with facilities That cannot accommodate the growth that we are expected to produce.

1240
02:26:11.872 --> 02:26:20.849
<v Chuck Dillard>A yes from this committee would give our students, faculty, arts partners, and this community a reason to plan confidently for the future.

1241
02:26:21.282 --> 02:26:29.375
<v Chuck Dillard>Please advance PACC and help us build a place worthy of Portland students and its extraordinary arts community.

1242
02:26:32.685 --> 02:26:36.846
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Please go right ahead.

1243
02:26:40.117 --> 02:26:41.701
<v Carol Morse>Hello, I am Carol Morse.

1244
02:26:41.831 --> 02:26:48.096
<v Carol Morse>I reside in District 4, and, uh, I'm the retired president of the PGE Foundation.

1245
02:26:48.790 --> 02:26:58.040
<v Carol Morse>I've been an advocate and grantmaker to the arts through a number of volunteer board roles as well— the Oregon Cultural Trust, RACC, and Portland Opera.

1246
02:26:59.558 --> 02:27:04.542
<v Carol Morse>The resolution you are now considering reflects years of study and public engagement.

1247
02:27:05.809 --> 02:27:09.319
<v Carol Morse>I'm encouraged to see such a strong path forward emerging.

1248
02:27:10.154 --> 02:27:21.054
<v Carol Morse>During my years at PGE Foundation, at OCT, and at RACC, I had the privilege of helping direct significant investments in arts and culture throughout our state.

1249
02:27:21.679 --> 02:27:29.373
<v Carol Morse>It taught me that transformative civic projects share one important characteristic: they inspire people to invest.

1250
02:27:30.031 --> 02:27:34.075
<v Carol Morse>Just look at the success of the Rothko Pavilion at the Portland Art Museum.

1251
02:27:35.006 --> 02:27:40.513
<v Carol Morse>The strongest projects create a sense of shared ownership and shared possibility.

1252
02:27:41.108 --> 02:27:45.763
<v Carol Morse>That's what's compelling about the Performing Arts and Culture Center project at PSU.

1253
02:27:46.709 --> 02:27:57.016
<v Carol Morse>Even at this early stage, the project has attracted support from public entities, institutional partners, private developers, and private philanthropy.

1254
02:27:58.042 --> 02:28:05.625
<v Carol Morse>As someone who's closely worked over decades with donors and corporate leaders, I can tell you that that matters profoundly.

1255
02:28:06.362 --> 02:28:14.939
<v Carol Morse>People invest when they see momentum, credible partnerships, and when they believe a project has the potential to make a lasting difference.

1256
02:28:15.691 --> 02:28:26.224
<v Carol Morse>The PSU project has that potential, not only in a venue, but in artists, students, audiences, economic vitality, and the cultural life of our city.

1257
02:28:26.977 --> 02:28:32.717
<v Carol Morse>Portland has been given the chance to make decision that will shape its cultural life for the next century.

1258
02:28:33.309 --> 02:28:35.088
<v Carol Morse>Such opportunities are rare.

1259
02:28:35.795 --> 02:28:38.440
<v Carol Morse>They deserve vision, partnership, and leadership.

1260
02:28:39.065 --> 02:28:46.615
<v Carol Morse>I encourage the City Life Committee to continue moving this current proposal forward to the City Council.

1261
02:28:47.081 --> 02:28:47.481
<v Linda Moss>Thank you.

1262
02:28:47.577 --> 02:28:48.763
<v Linda Moss>Thank you.

1263
02:28:49.662 --> 02:28:50.094
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1264
02:28:50.623 --> 02:28:51.858
<v Josh Hecht>Good afternoon, council members.

1265
02:28:51.906 --> 02:28:52.915
<v Josh Hecht>My name is Josh Hecht.

1266
02:28:53.093 --> 02:28:59.584
<v Josh Hecht>I'm the artistic director of Profile Theater, which at 29 years old is one of the longest running theaters in the state of Portland.

1267
02:28:59.745 --> 02:29:02.700
<v Josh Hecht>In the state of Oregon and a pillar of Portland's theater community.

1268
02:29:03.456 --> 02:29:07.792
<v Josh Hecht>3 Reasons why I am excited about PSU's Performing Arts and Culture Center.

1269
02:29:08.579 --> 02:29:17.831
<v Josh Hecht>One, embedding Portland's Broadway-capable venue within Portland's public university dramatically expands its civic and cultural impact.

1270
02:29:18.313 --> 02:29:32.775
<v Josh Hecht>Placing a major cultural asset at the heart of a university with as profoundly diverse a student body as PSU creates opportunities for students, Thank you.

1271
02:29:33.545 --> 02:29:48.597
<v Josh Hecht>As a director and producer working across the country, I have seen firsthand how powerful the relationship between universities and major arts organizations can be, creating opportunities for collaboration, resource sharing, and education that neither can do alone.

1272
02:29:49.415 --> 02:30:03.055
<v Josh Hecht>That's what I see in this proposal, which will elevate both PSU, attracting students and faculty from across the country, as well as Portland's arts ecosystem with a state-of-the-art art, multi-stage, world-class venue.

1273
02:30:03.775 --> 02:30:12.123
<v Josh Hecht>At Profile, we regularly bring Tony Award, Pulitzer Prize, and Obie-winning playwrights to Portland to develop and premiere new work with local artists.

1274
02:30:12.667 --> 02:30:24.027
<v Josh Hecht>A world-class facility like this one would enhance our ability to attract world-class artists while creating more opportunities for Portland-based performers, designers, technicians, and students.

1275
02:30:24.828 --> 02:30:29.939
<v Josh Hecht>Third, and most importantly, I'm especially encouraged by what this means for the next generation.

1276
02:30:30.516 --> 02:30:41.058
<v Josh Hecht>Profile is partnering with PSU to develop a 2-year certificate program in theater design and production that will help train emerging technical talent right here in Portland.

1277
02:30:41.523 --> 02:30:50.605
<v Josh Hecht>The center would create a direct connection between education and practice, strengthening the workforce that arts organizations in our region depend on.

1278
02:30:51.152 --> 02:30:53.206
<v Josh Hecht>This project is about more than a theater.

1279
02:30:53.638 --> 02:31:04.200
<v Josh Hecht>It's about what becomes possible when Broadway, higher education, and Portland's arts community are all connected in one place Providing extraordinary opportunities for all.

1280
02:31:04.859 --> 02:31:11.623
<v Josh Hecht>I'm convinced that a project of this scope will elevate Portland's reputation as a major center for the arts in this country.

1281
02:31:12.105 --> 02:31:12.411
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Thank you.

1282
02:31:15.881 --> 02:31:29.289
<v Linda McKim-Bell>For the record, my name is Alinda McKim Bell, and I'm an alumna of PSU and a downtown dweller, inventor of the I Love Downtown buttons, and founder of the Goose Hollow Foothills League Neighborhood Association.

1283
02:31:30.121 --> 02:31:45.604
<v Linda McKim-Bell>I volunteer with the PSU Senior Adult Learning Center, and I'm here today in support of the resolution to advance a new Broadway-capable venue as part of the proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center at PSU.

1284
02:31:47.015 --> 02:31:49.965
<v Linda McKim-Bell>This project is so much more than a new auditorium.

1285
02:31:50.621 --> 02:31:55.494
<v Linda McKim-Bell>It provides ample— that provides ample spaces for traveling productions.

1286
02:31:55.926 --> 02:32:06.367
<v Linda McKim-Bell>The larger auditorium will be built on land owned by PSU and gifted to the city at a transportation hub that currently leads to nowhere.

1287
02:32:07.959 --> 02:32:10.212
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Beyond the auditorium, there's another prize.

1288
02:32:10.550 --> 02:32:24.199
<v Linda McKim-Bell>The complex will include a smaller auditorium for local arts events, office space for local arts organizations, classrooms that are tech-equipped and versatile for music practice and small theater performance.

1289
02:32:24.870 --> 02:32:38.515
<v Linda McKim-Bell>There is potential for outdoor events plaza with advanced small businesses, cafes, restaurants, and vending opportunities that will add foot traffic, safety, and places for community.

1290
02:32:39.063 --> 02:32:46.010
<v Linda McKim-Bell>This is what seniors in our community in the surrounding high-rises need.

1291
02:32:48.692 --> 02:32:53.048
<v Linda McKim-Bell>The Performing Arts Center has a potential as an economic engine.

1292
02:32:54.006 --> 02:32:57.504
<v Linda McKim-Bell>To, to make Portland a win-win in every way.

1293
02:33:02.115 --> 02:33:18.174
<v Linda McKim-Bell>The center will bring people from all walks of life to downtown, uplifting students and giving them a step into the workforce, giving our seniors downtown the opportunity for community, volunteering, belonging, even meeting, and more.

1294
02:33:19.211 --> 02:33:25.304
<v Linda McKim-Bell>There's a dearth of cafes and meeting places for— in this area of downtown, and we need this.

1295
02:33:26.551 --> 02:33:33.237
<v Linda McKim-Bell>We need a safe downtown, and I urge the city to support the new Broadway-capable venue at PSU.

1296
02:33:35.536 --> 02:33:44.655
<v Linda McKim-Bell>This, this from the city will be a generational moment for our region and community, an opportunity we cannot afford to pass up.

1297
02:33:45.865 --> 02:33:46.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1298
02:33:46.432 --> 02:33:49.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all very much for being a part of the conversation today.

1299
02:33:54.329 --> 02:34:07.725
<v Carol Morse>Daniel Pollack-Pelsner, Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz, Greta Liu, Diana Stewart, Andy Segrist.

1300
02:34:10.856 --> 02:34:11.209
<v Jane Taylor>Thank you all.

1301
02:34:11.256 --> 02:34:14.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While others come up, why don't you go ahead and get started right there on the end?

1302
02:34:14.719 --> 02:34:16.163
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>Thank you, councilors.

1303
02:34:16.338 --> 02:34:17.829
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>My name is Daniel Pollack-Pelsner.

1304
02:34:17.925 --> 02:34:20.138
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>I teach theater at Portland State University.

1305
02:34:20.650 --> 02:34:26.629
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>I write about performing arts across the nation for the New York Times and the New Yorker, and I'm proud to be here in support of this resolution.

1306
02:34:26.726 --> 02:34:28.474
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>I'm born and raised in Portland.

1307
02:34:28.585 --> 02:34:32.400
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>My wife and I moved back here after graduate school to raise our kids in Portland.

1308
02:34:32.817 --> 02:34:42.099
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>I remember my parents taking me and my sister to see Peter Pan at the Civic Auditorium when I was a kid, and now they take their grandkids to see touring Broadway shows.

1309
02:34:42.291 --> 02:34:44.022
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>It's something we love about Portland.

1310
02:34:44.520 --> 02:34:46.811
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>But what we love is not a specific building.

1311
02:34:47.325 --> 02:34:58.610
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>What we love is the community, and what we love is the entire ecology of the arts in this city that allows our region to blossom through the performing arts.

1312
02:34:59.203 --> 02:35:13.438
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>And what I found when I've researched and written about centers across the country, whether it's in Manhattan or Austin or Tempe, is that the performing arts centers that can really transform a city are never standalone structures.

1313
02:35:13.550 --> 02:35:15.058
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>They're never just a single city block.

1314
02:35:15.138 --> 02:35:25.875
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>They're always partnerships, and they're always collaborations between nonprofit arts organizations, commercial theater, universities, private philanthropy, and government bodies.

1315
02:35:26.308 --> 02:35:29.421
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>And that's why I'm here in support of the Portland Arts and Culture Center.

1316
02:35:29.917 --> 02:35:43.045
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>I am so moved to look around this room and see my students and my colleagues and our colleagues in the performing arts and private donors and our university leaders, all of whom are saying, we're not a billionaire coming to shake you down.

1317
02:35:43.157 --> 02:35:43.799
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>We're not in the Band-Aid business.

1318
02:35:43.847 --> 02:35:44.297
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>We're not in the Band-Aid business.

1319
02:35:44.683 --> 02:35:50.594
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>We are bringing our resources and our time and our expertise because we want to partner with you to change the city.

1320
02:35:51.093 --> 02:35:54.531
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>This is what could galvanize the city, and this is what could change Portland's story.

1321
02:35:54.659 --> 02:35:57.263
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>And I think we all know Portland needs a different story.

1322
02:35:57.761 --> 02:36:05.778
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>When I get national editors asking me to write a story about the arts in Portland, to be honest, in the last 5 years, they're always asking the question, what went wrong?

1323
02:36:06.597 --> 02:36:12.122
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>And we now have an opportunity, and maybe a once-in-a-generation opportunity, to flip that question around.

1324
02:36:12.861 --> 02:36:35.033
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>If we can pursue the option that lifts up potential for students, that lifts up arts education, that lifts up the nonprofit organizations in our community, and that partners those with the thrill of Broadway, then we not only galvanize the city, we get to tell this story, and our grandkids will be able to look back and tell the story of where we went right.

1325
02:36:35.643 --> 02:36:36.364
<v Daniel Pollack-Pelsner>Thanks for supporting.

1326
02:36:38.227 --> 02:36:38.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1327
02:36:38.629 --> 02:36:39.157
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1328
02:36:39.495 --> 02:36:41.084
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Buenas tardes.

1329
02:36:41.181 --> 02:36:45.177
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Good afternoon, Chair Pirtle-Guiney, Vice Chair Zimmerman, and members of the committee.

1330
02:36:45.933 --> 02:36:54.842
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>My name is Gema Nereida Barragan Cruz, and I am a PSU student and singer here in support of the proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center at PSU.

1331
02:36:55.645 --> 02:37:03.718
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>I'm entering my 3rd year at PSU studying music education with an emphasis in voice, and I perform as a mariachi singer across Oregon.

1332
02:37:04.235 --> 02:37:06.817
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Music isn't just my major, but it is my life's work.

1333
02:37:07.479 --> 02:37:18.034
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Singing mariachi allows me to keep our cultural traditions alive and share my heart directly with our community, while my studies at PSU are preparing me to guide our next future generations.

1334
02:37:19.137 --> 02:37:23.602
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>And now I would like to sing a little something, Canción Mixteca by José López Álvarez.

1335
02:37:25.573 --> 02:37:27.852
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Oh, tierra del sol.

1336
02:37:30.584 --> 02:37:33.799
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Suspiro por verte.

1337
02:37:34.924 --> 02:37:42.649
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Y ahora que alejas, yo vivo sin luz, sin amor.

1338
02:37:43.731 --> 02:37:56.921
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Al verme tan sola y triste cual hoja al viento, quisiera llorar, quisiera morir de sentimientos.

1339
02:38:02.485 --> 02:38:08.775
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>As a music student at PSU, I see firsthand how desperately our performing arts program need modern functional space.

1340
02:38:09.129 --> 02:38:12.563
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Right now, students are constantly competing for limited outdated practice space.

1341
02:38:12.979 --> 02:38:18.211
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>As a member of the chamber choir, we practice in a classroom in the same building as the geology and history departments.

1342
02:38:18.596 --> 02:38:21.068
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>The jazz choir practices in a stairwell in Lincoln Hall.

1343
02:38:21.325 --> 02:38:22.704
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Our students deserve better.

1344
02:38:23.025 --> 02:38:25.721
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>This project promises a direct bridge Professional world.

1345
02:38:25.915 --> 02:38:36.876
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Training alongside touring productions and industry professionals gives student artists, technicians, and musicians invaluable real-world experience, mentorship, and networking opportunities right outside, right outside our classrooms.

1346
02:38:37.292 --> 02:38:40.534
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>I urge the city to support the new Broadway-capable venue at PSU.

1347
02:38:40.840 --> 02:38:46.103
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>This commitment from the city will be a generational moment for our region, community programs, and our students.

1348
02:38:46.457 --> 02:38:47.114
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Mil gracias.

1349
02:38:47.179 --> 02:38:47.997
<v Ximena Rada Barragan Cruz>Thank you so much.

1350
02:38:48.864 --> 02:38:50.757
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so very much.

1351
02:38:52.717 --> 02:38:55.528
<v Greta Liu>Thank you, Chair Pirtle-Guiney and members of the Committee on City Life.

1352
02:38:55.833 --> 02:39:05.420
<v Greta Liu>My name is Greta Lau, and I'm testing— testifying in support of the resolution to advance a new Broadway-capable venue as part of the proposed Performing Arts and Culture Center at Portland State University.

1353
02:39:06.271 --> 02:39:10.431
<v Greta Liu>I'm a resident of District 4 and have been living and working in downtown Portland for the past 4 years.

1354
02:39:11.009 --> 02:39:15.103
<v Greta Liu>Just 2 months ago, I graduated from Portland State University with a degree in theater arts.

1355
02:39:15.826 --> 02:39:20.692
<v Greta Liu>I am invested in this project not only for the betterment of the city, but for theater artists and university students alike.

1356
02:39:20.740 --> 02:39:20.885
<v Greta Liu>Thank you.

1357
02:39:21.542 --> 02:39:25.153
<v Greta Liu>Now more than ever, the College of the Arts at PSU is experiencing a renaissance.

1358
02:39:25.634 --> 02:39:33.863
<v Greta Liu>New faculty courses and a growing student body means the next generation of world-class artists and technicians is growing right here in our city.

1359
02:39:34.521 --> 02:39:42.206
<v Greta Liu>Having a space that is made by us for us is a crucial next step towards solidifying Portland as a vibrant and creative city worthy of recognition.

1360
02:39:43.183 --> 02:39:47.418
<v Greta Liu>During my time at PSU, I was taught the ins and outs of what it is like to work in professional arts venues.

1361
02:39:48.077 --> 02:39:50.854
<v Greta Liu>I understand what it takes to produce a show from load-in to load-out.

1362
02:39:51.610 --> 02:39:57.021
<v Greta Liu>I have both sat in the audience and seen the inner workings backstage of nearly every major theater in Portland.

1363
02:39:57.566 --> 02:40:00.313
<v Greta Liu>I can tell you confidently that the Keller as it is is holding us back.

1364
02:40:00.939 --> 02:40:06.558
<v Greta Liu>As the only option for many large-scale touring shows, the space pales in comparison to modern industry standards.

1365
02:40:07.040 --> 02:40:12.564
<v Greta Liu>With so little room to grow in a single city block, the time is now to invest in Portland's thriving performing arts industry.

1366
02:40:13.382 --> 02:40:19.179
<v Greta Liu>If I were to speak only for myself, this project would give me so much hope for the future of performing arts in Portland.

1367
02:40:19.820 --> 02:40:27.913
<v Greta Liu>Knowing that the city has invested in the future of artists like myself would only reaffirm my love of Portland and my desire to stay and work right here in downtown.

1368
02:40:28.716 --> 02:40:35.202
<v Greta Liu>But I know that beyond me, future generations of PSU students deserve a space built with them in mind and with plenty of room to grow.

1369
02:40:35.924 --> 02:40:38.718
<v Greta Liu>Thank you for your service to our city, and I urge you to support this resolution.

1370
02:40:41.063 --> 02:40:41.689
<v Diana Stewart>Good afternoon.

1371
02:40:41.977 --> 02:40:43.293
<v Diana Stewart>My name is Diana Stewart.

1372
02:40:43.870 --> 02:40:50.725
<v Diana Stewart>For over 4 years, I've immersed myself in the city's debate about what to do with our performing arts center issue.

1373
02:40:51.912 --> 02:41:10.818
<v Diana Stewart>As a resident of the core downtown, I believe that ultimately the Keller renovation is a stunning visionary catalyst needed to protect struggling businesses around the Keller and to keep my neighbors who are considering leaving the downtown and leaving the Portland area Due to tax burdens here in Portland.

1374
02:41:11.316 --> 02:41:32.888
<v Diana Stewart>However, having sat through many of your budget meetings, neither project should now capture my tax dollars, which rather should go to the urgent needs of the city that we all love and meet the needs that each of you have advocated for, keeping Portland safe, addressing the crises on our streets, preserving essential livability services.

1375
02:41:33.626 --> 02:41:36.835
<v Diana Stewart>I've been perplexed by what appears to be the city bureaus Thank you.

1376
02:41:36.899 --> 02:41:39.575
<v Diana Stewart>How is the mayor's thumb on the scale performing the PSU concept?

1377
02:41:40.057 --> 02:41:54.319
<v Diana Stewart>The only answer I can come up with is what I've been told by various city council members, that the PSU's PR department is a tsunami of information influencing and attempting to influence each one of you.

1378
02:41:54.800 --> 02:42:06.628
<v Diana Stewart>Instead, polling shows that citizens agree with the mayor when he says Portland doesn't build massively expensive new when we can preserve and renovate what we own.

1379
02:42:07.701 --> 02:42:14.738
<v Diana Stewart>I have forwarded several charts to each of you referencing what I consider to be misinformation that has been coming out to council.

1380
02:42:15.299 --> 02:42:23.827
<v Diana Stewart>Number one shows that PSU recently admitted they have no idea how much the resolution that you may be passing will commit you to.

1381
02:42:24.533 --> 02:42:31.699
<v Diana Stewart>Second, the renovation can address all of President Dunphy's concerns that he articulated today.

1382
02:42:31.906 --> 02:42:36.443
<v Diana Stewart>And third, the period of time is not 3 to 5 years, it's significantly shorter.

1383
02:42:36.957 --> 02:42:52.006
<v Diana Stewart>Passing this resolution will be a massive political Please ensure that the resolution gives you an off-ramp if you decide after the additional study that's being requested that the project is untenable.

1384
02:42:52.248 --> 02:42:53.104
<v Diana Stewart>Thank you very much.

1385
02:42:55.110 --> 02:42:56.995
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all so much for being here today.

1386
02:42:59.909 --> 02:43:01.773
<v Carol Morse>Once more for Andy Seegrist.

1387
02:43:06.009 --> 02:43:06.138
<v Carol Morse>Okay.

1388
02:43:06.236 --> 02:43:18.197
<v Carol Morse>Next, Paul Monheimer, Duke Castle, Javier Stickler, Bob Nadeau, Jane Taylor.

1389
02:43:20.864 --> 02:43:21.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead and begin.

1390
02:43:22.219 --> 02:43:23.183
<v Paul Monheimer>Good afternoon, councilors.

1391
02:43:24.084 --> 02:43:25.128
<v Paul Monheimer>My name is Paul Monheimer.

1392
02:43:25.643 --> 02:43:29.740
<v Paul Monheimer>In 2016, I was honored to be named Oregon's High School Social Studies Teacher of the Year.

1393
02:43:30.463 --> 02:43:34.836
<v Paul Monheimer>Since becoming a Portlander in 1974, I have attended hundreds of performances at theater venues across the city.

1394
02:43:36.703 --> 02:43:43.143
<v Paul Monheimer>As a middle school teacher, I helped lay the groundwork for future arts patrons by arranging matinee field trips to downtown Portland theater performances.

1395
02:43:43.930 --> 02:43:47.847
<v Paul Monheimer>I know you are giving weight to tangible arguments as you consider the decision in front of you.

1396
02:43:48.763 --> 02:43:50.609
<v Paul Monheimer>Art performances aren't always tangible.

1397
02:43:51.058 --> 02:43:54.334
<v Paul Monheimer>Plays, ballets, TEDx events, and musicals tug at our feelings.

1398
02:43:55.153 --> 02:44:00.435
<v Paul Monheimer>In that spirit, and because Kim Stafford was one of my mentors and remains a hero, I offer a poem.

1399
02:44:01.930 --> 02:44:07.245
<v Paul Monheimer>If Pioneer Courthouse Square is Portland's living room, Keller Auditorium is Portland's family room.

1400
02:44:08.161 --> 02:44:09.350
<v Paul Monheimer>Family rooms hold memories.

1401
02:44:09.927 --> 02:44:11.358
<v Paul Monheimer>Memories span generations.

1402
02:44:12.176 --> 02:44:14.505
<v Paul Monheimer>As 5-year-olds, Grandma takes us to The Nutcracker.

1403
02:44:15.147 --> 02:44:20.689
<v Paul Monheimer>Dressed in our finery, we marvel at the fountain for the first time before sinking into our adult-sized seats.

1404
02:44:21.748 --> 02:44:27.403
<v Paul Monheimer>We clap when the show ends, skipping up the aisle to wave goodbye to the Sugar Plum Fairy and the fountain.

1405
02:44:28.494 --> 02:44:31.029
<v Paul Monheimer>As 12-year-olds, Granddad takes us to The Lion King.

1406
02:44:31.942 --> 02:44:36.818
<v Paul Monheimer>Dressed in our finery, we jump the terraces in the fountain before oohing over the view from our balcony seats.

1407
02:44:37.798 --> 02:44:39.530
<v Paul Monheimer>We sing Circle of Life on our way home.

1408
02:44:40.043 --> 02:44:41.486
<v Paul Monheimer>We remember the cool acoustics.

1409
02:44:42.386 --> 02:44:44.534
<v Paul Monheimer>Our memories hang on the walls of the Keller.

1410
02:44:45.577 --> 02:44:48.272
<v Paul Monheimer>We don't need a new house or even an addition.

1411
02:44:49.186 --> 02:45:05.923
<v Paul Monheimer>We carefully remove our memories to paint the walls, patch up the dry rot, re-sand the floors, And then we can hang our memories in Keller Auditorium again and take our grandchildren to The Nutcracker and The Lion King, adding new memories to the walls in Portland's family room.

1412
02:45:06.987 --> 02:45:09.228
<v Paul Monheimer>Thank you for your time and good luck with your decision.

1413
02:45:11.621 --> 02:45:13.086
<v Duke Castle>My name is Duke Castle.

1414
02:45:13.247 --> 02:45:16.340
<v Duke Castle>I'm here to recommend that you do not approve the mayor's resolution.

1415
02:45:17.031 --> 02:45:21.605
<v Duke Castle>If there's any bias in this discussion, it should be in enhancing and retaining the Keller.

1416
02:45:22.311 --> 02:45:31.931
<v Duke Castle>The Keller is easily accessible from I-5, has parking for over 2,000 vehicles, 3 hotels with hundreds of rooms, numerous restaurants within walking distance.

1417
02:45:32.556 --> 02:45:36.628
<v Duke Castle>The seismic issues and other concerns about the Keller are not under dispute.

1418
02:45:37.125 --> 02:45:41.837
<v Duke Castle>However, if they could be successfully dealt with, why would we abandon the Keller?

1419
02:45:42.527 --> 02:45:47.849
<v Duke Castle>Such a plan to successfully resolve those issues was submitted to the city in 2023.

1420
02:45:48.522 --> 02:45:52.389
<v Duke Castle>It showed that the Keller could be upgraded to meet current seismic code.

1421
02:45:53.000 --> 02:46:11.277
<v Duke Castle>And in a statement by Tim Eddy of Hedenberry Eddy Architects, and I quote, the study has concluded that it is feasible to upgrade the Keller Auditorium to the standards of a state-of-the-art 21st century performance venue and to resolve all of the facility's current physical and operational challenges.

1422
02:46:12.111 --> 02:46:15.449
<v Duke Castle>I've seen nothing to invalidate that statement.

1423
02:46:16.122 --> 02:46:22.202
<v Duke Castle>Why then would we set aside a plan that has the potential to resolve all of our concerns about the Keller?

1424
02:46:23.101 --> 02:46:29.532
<v Duke Castle>The only other reason that is cited is concern about the disruption to the community while the Keller is, is renovated.

1425
02:46:29.917 --> 02:46:42.718
<v Duke Castle>That's a very legitimate issue, but to solve it with the significant expense of building a whole new permanent facility and all of the needed supporting infrastructure is an excessive answer to a temporary problem.

1426
02:46:43.618 --> 02:46:52.369
<v Duke Castle>Other cities faced with this problem have developed or created temporary venues at a fraction of the cost of building a new venue.

1427
02:46:52.771 --> 02:46:53.798
<v Duke Castle>We should do the same.

1428
02:46:54.296 --> 02:47:07.013
<v Duke Castle>I would strongly suggest that we revisit and further redefine the Keller feasibility study and invest money in exploring and developing a temporary venue to bridge the time the Keller is being renovated.

1429
02:47:07.221 --> 02:47:07.478
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Thank you.

1430
02:47:10.597 --> 02:47:12.643
<v Bob Naito>Councilors, my name is Bob Naito.

1431
02:47:12.934 --> 02:47:15.677
<v Bob Naito>I'm the chair of the Halpern Landscape Conservancy.

1432
02:47:20.382 --> 02:47:32.905
<v Bob Naito>This proposal to build a replacement for the Keller Auditorium at PSU and then renovate and downsize the Keller to 1,200 to 1,800 seats is flawed.

1433
02:47:33.745 --> 02:47:45.313
<v Bob Naito>The city has offered No funding plan, no studies that prove the need for a smaller Keller, and has no guarantees that the Keller would eventually be renovated.

1434
02:47:46.899 --> 02:47:54.590
<v Bob Naito>The combined capital cost of the full PSU complex plus a renovated Keller is approaching $1 billion.

1435
02:47:56.536 --> 02:48:05.225
<v Bob Naito>And I brought a chart since that number doesn't show up Anywhere in the resolution, and I'll leave copies with the clerk.

1436
02:48:10.974 --> 02:48:19.170
<v Bob Naito>This is all happening in a city that remains deeply divided over how we pay for another city-owned asset, the Moda Center.

1437
02:48:20.189 --> 02:48:34.077
<v Bob Naito>And in this city where Portland 5 Centers for the Performing Arts buildings need about $336 million in deferred capital maintenance, and that's a study recently published by Metro.

1438
02:48:35.739 --> 02:48:42.028
<v Bob Naito>The city's marketing consultants found insufficient market demand for 2 large Broadway theaters in Portland.

1439
02:48:42.806 --> 02:48:48.777
<v Bob Naito>Why were they not tasked with studying the very proposal this administration is bringing forward?

1440
02:48:50.086 --> 02:49:06.018
<v Bob Naito>No plans or cost estimate for a downsized Keller exists, and no analysis exists of whether a 1,200 to 1,800 seat Keller would generate sufficient operating revenue to cover its own costs, let alone contribute to the P5 system it currently subsidizes.

1441
02:49:07.157 --> 02:49:10.416
<v Bob Naito>Don't kick the can down the road yet again.

1442
02:49:11.251 --> 02:49:19.068
<v Bob Naito>Have the courage to demand answers to the fundamental questions before committing the city to a billion-dollar boondoggle.

1443
02:49:19.599 --> 02:49:21.894
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Thank you.

1444
02:49:23.066 --> 02:49:24.157
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Good afternoon, councilors.

1445
02:49:24.495 --> 02:49:27.640
<v Xavier D. Stickler>My name is Xavier D. Stickler, and I'm a student at PSU.

1446
02:49:28.509 --> 02:49:30.421
<v Xavier D. Stickler>We've heard a lot today about vision.

1447
02:49:30.967 --> 02:49:32.316
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Don't get me wrong, vision is good.

1448
02:49:32.444 --> 02:49:35.145
<v Xavier D. Stickler>As an aspiring urban planner, I am all about vision.

1449
02:49:35.995 --> 02:49:38.342
<v Xavier D. Stickler>But I'm here to bring you all back down to reality a little bit.

1450
02:49:38.872 --> 02:49:41.185
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Put simply, we don't have the money for this, you guys.

1451
02:49:41.844 --> 02:49:48.208
<v Xavier D. Stickler>While it's easy to say we'll investigate funding mechanisms later on, let's be clear, the city's budget deficit is structural.

1452
02:49:48.674 --> 02:49:53.414
<v Xavier D. Stickler>The tough choices with the budget you all have faced in the last 2 years are going to persist for the foreseeable future.

1453
02:49:53.461 --> 02:49:53.622
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Thank you.

1454
02:49:55.278 --> 02:50:04.611
<v Xavier D. Stickler>It pains me to say this, but we do not have the dollars even to complete the renovation of the Keller while maintaining it at a 3,000-seat capacity, estimated at a cost of $236 million.

1455
02:50:05.077 --> 02:50:06.522
<v Xavier D. Stickler>That's the cheapest option here.

1456
02:50:07.165 --> 02:50:15.745
<v Xavier D. Stickler>That means we certainly don't have the money for a new venue at PSU, which is almost double that cost to the city, let alone the pursuit of both theaters, which is nearly a $1 billion commitment.

1457
02:50:16.564 --> 02:50:20.468
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Unfortunately, this resolution is a whole lot of dollars and not very much sense.

1458
02:50:20.611 --> 02:50:20.772
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Thank you.

1459
02:50:21.606 --> 02:50:24.927
<v Xavier D. Stickler>While it's true we will eventually need a 21st century Keller, no one's disputing that.

1460
02:50:25.056 --> 02:50:40.198
<v Xavier D. Stickler>At a time when transit is being slashed, essential employees are being let go from both the city and PSU, and our public infrastructure maintenance backlog is ballooning, it makes no sense to prioritize this project in the context of so many more critical life-saving needs.

1461
02:50:40.790 --> 02:50:58.264
<v Xavier D. Stickler>It makes no sense to be adding a new— a whole new theater to the city's portfolio, especially while at the same time renovating what is currently a profit-generating venue into one which will need deep public subsidies, will be a smaller size, and the reconstruction of which will cost very nearly what it would take to maintain it at 3,000 seats.

1462
02:50:58.441 --> 02:51:10.490
<v Xavier D. Stickler>It makes no sense for PSU, an institution laying off my instructors with declining enrollment and where 1 in 5 students are housing insecure or homeless, to be prioritizing getting into the entertainment business.

1463
02:51:11.180 --> 02:51:23.067
<v Xavier D. Stickler>The only responsible choice here is for council to find the $10 to $15 million needed to Broadway has already renewed their contract at the Keller until 2033.

1464
02:51:23.439 --> 02:51:32.500
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Give the economy a chance to recover, for PSU to stabilize, for the bond market to improve, for the city to actually study the feasibility of a temporary venue.

1465
02:51:32.579 --> 02:51:33.436
<v Xavier D. Stickler>It has been done.

1466
02:51:33.856 --> 02:51:35.619
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Then will be the right time to pursue this vision.

1467
02:51:36.000 --> 02:51:39.454
<v Xavier D. Stickler>And so I urge you to make the very difficult choice to vote no on this resolution.

1468
02:51:39.871 --> 02:51:40.306
<v Xavier D. Stickler>Thank you.

1469
02:51:43.487 --> 02:51:44.822
<v Jane Taylor>Hello, my name is Jane Taylor.

1470
02:51:44.870 --> 02:51:50.027
<v Jane Taylor>I'm a resident of I'm an actor, singer, director, and a resident of downtown Portland.

1471
02:51:51.461 --> 02:51:58.786
<v Jane Taylor>I am going to ask you not to consider this proposal and not to approve this proposal for specifically financial reasons.

1472
02:51:59.530 --> 02:52:04.222
<v Jane Taylor>I love all of the passion that's been shown for improving the arts community here in Portland.

1473
02:52:04.744 --> 02:52:18.849
<v Jane Taylor>However, it's clear that the costs, $290,000 to renovate the Keller versus $447,000 to build a new 3,000-seat auditorium at Portland State, Isn't— doesn't make sense to me.

1474
02:52:19.264 --> 02:52:29.106
<v Jane Taylor>There are costs that aren't in the proposal with regards to utilities, traffic, and the infrastructure that the city would be required to adjust in order to accommodate this.

1475
02:52:29.603 --> 02:52:36.640
<v Jane Taylor>And in addition, there are costs for the hotel that's being proposed in addition to the auditorium.

1476
02:52:37.058 --> 02:52:39.477
<v Jane Taylor>I don't think we have all of the facts yet.

1477
02:52:40.183 --> 02:52:45.568
<v Jane Taylor>Portland State is an incredibly viable part of the downtown Thank you.

1478
02:52:46.338 --> 02:52:49.031
<v Jane Taylor>And it's one that I've enjoyed as I've taken classes there.

1479
02:52:49.704 --> 02:52:54.625
<v Jane Taylor>However, they've recently announced a $35 million budget deficit.

1480
02:52:55.411 --> 02:53:02.672
<v Jane Taylor>They've taken away 2 complete academic programs and let go of a number of instructors.

1481
02:53:03.344 --> 02:53:20.510
<v Jane Taylor>To me, investing in this economically doesn't make sense for them because it jeopardizes their positive impact on the community spending millions and millions of dollars in things that don't make sense to the community or for academics.

1482
02:53:20.992 --> 02:53:36.694
<v Jane Taylor>Spending more money to get less value would be a sad act for a university who would fail their students and their community and a mayor of city council that would be viewed as being out of step of the economic needs of this community.

1483
02:53:37.289 --> 02:53:37.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1484
02:53:39.154 --> 02:53:43.828
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here and being part of the conversation today.

1485
02:53:48.976 --> 02:54:01.349
<v Carol Morse>Next is Ian Walton, Claire Blaylock, Linda Moss, Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan, and Joel Thorson.

1486
02:54:04.888 --> 02:54:07.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead on the end there while we wait for others to make their way up.

1487
02:54:08.707 --> 02:54:09.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Please go right ahead.

1488
02:54:11.700 --> 02:54:12.263
<v Ian Walton>Good afternoon.

1489
02:54:13.181 --> 02:54:14.275
<v Ian Walton>My name is Ian Walton.

1490
02:54:15.016 --> 02:54:17.093
<v Ian Walton>I have been a Portland resident for 25 years.

1491
02:54:18.173 --> 02:54:25.341
<v Ian Walton>Prior to retiring, I was a consulting partner with PricewaterhouseCoopers, and I have experience in reviewing high-value capital projects.

1492
02:54:26.691 --> 02:54:32.993
<v Ian Walton>With the world's renewed interest in ancient Greece, you'll forgive me if I describe this as a financial Trojan horse.

1493
02:54:33.996 --> 02:54:40.343
<v Ian Walton>My wife and I have volunteered at Portland Five for many years, and I support public involvement in the arts scene.

1494
02:54:41.209 --> 02:54:46.754
<v Ian Walton>However, in the current climate, such projects must be at the lowest cost and the lowest project risks.

1495
02:54:47.700 --> 02:54:49.655
<v Ian Walton>The PSU proposal is neither.

1496
02:54:50.680 --> 02:54:55.792
<v Ian Walton>The Keller project, with or without a temporary location, meets this requirement.

1497
02:54:56.931 --> 02:54:58.261
<v Ian Walton>The cost will be well-earned.

1498
02:54:58.452 --> 02:55:03.132
<v Ian Walton>Both will escalate, but the differential between the two is quite clear and will remain that way.

1499
02:55:04.143 --> 02:55:06.546
<v Ian Walton>What I will concentrate on is project risks.

1500
02:55:07.492 --> 02:55:12.556
<v Ian Walton>The Keller project has a single stakeholder, clear objectives, and a well-understood site.

1501
02:55:13.421 --> 02:55:20.567
<v Ian Walton>The PSU project has multiple stakeholders, including Oregon State and whoever runs the parking structure and the hotel.

1502
02:55:21.225 --> 02:55:32.360
<v Ian Walton>It has multiple complex objectives, one of which appears to be transition— to transition a challenged academic institution into the vaudeville and hotel business.

1503
02:55:33.888 --> 02:55:40.824
<v Ian Walton>The consultant's argument, which rules out the temporary option on page 27, is almost laughably flawed on its face.

1504
02:55:42.487 --> 02:55:47.065
<v Ian Walton>I am familiar with some of the temporary sites in London, and I think I should say they are great fun.

1505
02:55:47.897 --> 02:55:51.525
<v Ian Walton>If you are thinking folding chairs in tents, then think again.

1506
02:55:52.703 --> 02:56:01.102
<v Ian Walton>I would urge you to reject this proposal and initiate a sensible reconsideration of the temporary facility as part of a plan to refurbish the Keller.

1507
02:56:01.920 --> 02:56:10.869
<v Ian Walton>You will then be in a position to put a price on the retention of the Broadway shows during the Keller's closure and its real impacts on the situation.

1508
02:56:11.286 --> 02:56:11.605
<v Ian Walton>Thank you.

1509
02:56:12.968 --> 02:56:13.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1510
02:56:13.867 --> 02:56:14.364
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1511
02:56:15.134 --> 02:56:16.048
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Good evening, councilors.

1512
02:56:16.176 --> 02:56:17.893
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>My name is Jordan Del Valle Tinoyan.

1513
02:56:18.052 --> 02:56:19.272
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>I use he/him pronouns.

1514
02:56:19.384 --> 02:56:23.873
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>I'm a South Downtown resident, and I hold a bachelor's in community development from Portland State University.

1515
02:56:24.067 --> 02:56:27.388
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>I have a background in technical theater and have won awards for stage management.

1516
02:56:27.966 --> 02:56:32.843
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>And I urge you to vote no on this resolution because it represents the wrong priorities for a public university.

1517
02:56:33.371 --> 02:56:35.889
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>A university's primary mission should be to educate.

1518
02:56:36.179 --> 02:56:38.825
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>It exists to teach students, support faculty, and serve the public.

1519
02:56:39.290 --> 02:56:54.643
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Yet while PSU is laying off faculty and eliminating academic programs, most recently 36 faculty members and programs like conflict resolution and university studies, the school's general education pathway, it's pursuing a massive new capital project that does not address the urgent needs of its students.

1520
02:56:54.691 --> 02:56:54.818
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Thank you.

1521
02:56:55.413 --> 02:56:57.192
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>The city should not reward this behavior.

1522
02:56:57.577 --> 02:57:00.994
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Students are struggling with the basic conditions necessary to succeed.

1523
02:57:01.426 --> 02:57:08.338
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>I personally knew students who struggled with housing insecurity while trying to complete their education, living in their cars, working multiple jobs just to make ends meet.

1524
02:57:08.884 --> 02:57:14.834
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>The university has a tremendous opportunity to use its land in this transit-rich, amenity-filled part of the city to address those challenges.

1525
02:57:15.315 --> 02:57:39.739
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Student housing, affordable housing, workforce housing, market-rate housing even would directly support the university, Despite her testimony today about the vision she saw for PSU upon her hiring, President Cudd has already identified these priorities in her report from the Governor's participation in the Governor's Portland City's Central City Task Force focused on addressing future economic growth and immediate challenges facing the Central City.

1526
02:57:40.174 --> 02:57:51.516
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>In 2023, she wrote, highlighting things that the University could do to help downtown, rethinking educational spaces to make them more connected to the community, expanding childcare access, Supporting affordable housing for students in the downtown core.

1527
02:57:52.286 --> 02:57:57.654
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>And the outcomes also explicitly reference improving and renovating existing buildings, including seismic retrofits.

1528
02:57:58.375 --> 02:58:01.500
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>These are concrete actions that would directly serve the students and Portland residents.

1529
02:58:01.644 --> 02:58:06.193
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Yet instead of advancing those priorities, PSU is moving forward with major new performing arts facility.

1530
02:58:06.787 --> 02:58:10.023
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>A public university should not expand its footprint while shrinking its classrooms.

1531
02:58:10.391 --> 02:58:16.753
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>It should not have spent money lobbying for a new prestige project while students struggle to afford housing and faculty positions are being eliminated.

1532
02:58:16.800 --> 02:58:16.929
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Thank you.

1533
02:58:17.525 --> 02:58:23.704
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Portland deserves a thriving arts community, but it also deserves a public university focused first on teaching, learning, and serving its community.

1534
02:58:24.204 --> 02:58:24.447
<v Jordan Del Valle-Tinuan>Thank you.

1535
02:58:26.690 --> 02:58:29.684
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead, please.

1536
02:58:29.960 --> 02:58:30.219
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go ahead.

1537
02:58:30.608 --> 02:58:30.851
<v Linda Moss>Me?

1538
02:58:31.013 --> 02:58:31.158
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1539
02:58:31.968 --> 02:58:33.977
<v Linda Moss>Um, good afternoon, council members.

1540
02:58:34.333 --> 02:58:35.694
<v Linda Moss>My name is Linda Moss.

1541
02:58:36.344 --> 02:58:41.847
<v Linda Moss>I live in District 4 here in Portland, 4 years in Portland.

1542
02:58:42.912 --> 02:58:46.101
<v Linda Moss>20 Years with grandchildren here and spending a lot of time here.

1543
02:58:46.421 --> 02:58:47.382
<v Linda Moss>I'm here before you.

1544
02:58:47.542 --> 02:58:50.971
<v Linda Moss>I was one of the 12 members on the steering committee.

1545
02:58:51.405 --> 02:59:01.404
<v Linda Moss>My background, I am a chair emeritus of the Northwest Area Foundation, a large foundation that funds in Oregon as well as 8 other states.

1546
02:59:02.125 --> 02:59:08.118
<v Linda Moss>I am a former state senator and majority whip in Montana, so have some policy work as well.

1547
02:59:08.503 --> 02:59:08.790
<v Linda Moss>Thank you.

1548
02:59:09.272 --> 02:59:15.209
<v Linda Moss>And also I've worked in local government as an executive director of a large regional history museum.

1549
02:59:15.834 --> 02:59:21.515
<v Linda Moss>So with those different perspectives, I came to the steering committee with open eyes.

1550
02:59:22.254 --> 02:59:26.314
<v Linda Moss>And I— we've read multiple reports, you've seen them.

1551
02:59:26.602 --> 02:59:33.470
<v Linda Moss>And I just want to encourage you to really look at the report that came from this 12-member steering committee.

1552
02:59:33.920 --> 02:59:39.584
<v Linda Moss>It was a unanimous decision to support our recommendation to move forward with this project.

1553
02:59:39.632 --> 02:59:39.745
<v Linda Moss>Thank you.

1554
02:59:40.468 --> 02:59:42.505
<v Linda Moss>And we had multiple discussions.

1555
02:59:42.650 --> 02:59:49.585
<v Linda Moss>And I want to say to all of the people that have testified, especially the people who have concerns, we had those same concerns.

1556
02:59:49.698 --> 02:59:50.773
<v Linda Moss>We asked questions.

1557
02:59:50.981 --> 03:00:03.520
<v Linda Moss>And I have to say the arts and cultural commit— staff members were excellent in answering our question, providing additional information that may not even be in the reports that are on the website.

1558
03:00:04.018 --> 03:00:06.698
<v Linda Moss>So it's a thorough examination of this.

1559
03:00:06.810 --> 03:00:06.906
<v Joel Thorson>Thank you.

1560
03:00:12.548 --> 03:00:19.085
<v Linda Moss>It's a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for the city of Portland.

1561
03:00:20.227 --> 03:00:22.251
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Thank you.

1562
03:00:22.459 --> 03:00:22.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1563
03:00:24.479 --> 03:00:25.290
<v Joel Thorson>Joel Thorson.

1564
03:00:26.801 --> 03:00:32.518
<v Joel Thorson>It's, it's my community, the residents, taxpayers, and voters of Portland that I'm representing.

1565
03:00:36.721 --> 03:01:12.472
<v Joel Thorson>I approach this as both a former journalist and a veteran of 34 years developing software, a career that I could not have undertaken or found satisfaction in with very culminating careers— career assignments at Amazon and Bonneville Power toward the end, in which I was involved in Critical software systems development using tools, intellectual and skills, tools and skills that I gained from Portland State's System Science Program.

1566
03:01:12.969 --> 03:01:15.618
<v Joel Thorson>I'm very grateful to the education that I got there.

1567
03:01:15.843 --> 03:01:17.047
<v Joel Thorson>It set me on my path.

1568
03:01:17.111 --> 03:01:20.577
<v Joel Thorson>I'm a very devoted PSU supporter.

1569
03:01:21.123 --> 03:01:33.183
<v Joel Thorson>However, I'm puzzled by The change in the voice that I hear, and I'm wondering who or what is the real PSU.

1570
03:01:33.733 --> 03:01:37.858
<v Joel Thorson>The voice, its public voice today doesn't seem to match the PSU that I knew.

1571
03:01:38.505 --> 03:01:51.210
<v Joel Thorson>I've concluded there are 2, not one, organizations, the university I love and the relentless PR and fundraising juggernaut that is in the process of dictating Portland's future, nothing less.

1572
03:01:51.261 --> 03:01:51.393
<v Joel Thorson>Thank you.

1573
03:01:52.340 --> 03:02:02.117
<v Joel Thorson>With a project that rivals Portland's biennial budget in size, the money to be laid on the backs of Portland taxpayers.

1574
03:02:05.000 --> 03:02:10.513
<v Joel Thorson>They're presumed to answer— number 2 is they presume to answer the question, what becomes of the Keller?

1575
03:02:11.141 --> 03:02:11.818
<v Joel Thorson>Think about it.

1576
03:02:11.882 --> 03:02:27.334
<v Joel Thorson>Have you ever heard of a renovation project, public or private, To make a facility less capable of performing the same function that it was— has been serving up to now.

1577
03:02:29.700 --> 03:02:35.879
<v Joel Thorson>That's doomed to be tantamount to replacing a cash cow with one more drain on the city's finances.

1578
03:02:36.247 --> 03:02:38.799
<v Joel Thorson>It's financially laughable.

1579
03:02:40.643 --> 03:02:44.938
<v Joel Thorson>It's empire building, and it's not worthy of the slogan, let knowledge serve the people.

1580
03:02:45.019 --> 03:02:45.115
<v Joel Thorson>Thank you.

1581
03:02:46.908 --> 03:02:54.968
<v Joel Thorson>It's in fact a blatant attempt to fund a financially preposterous engineering— visioneering adventure at the public's expense.

1582
03:02:56.016 --> 03:02:56.356
<v Joel Thorson>Thank you.

1583
03:02:57.247 --> 03:02:59.968
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all so much for being here and sharing your perspectives.

1584
03:03:02.299 --> 03:03:05.926
<v Carol Morse>Ramin Farahmandpour, Kate Mira.

1585
03:03:20.989 --> 03:03:25.141
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Chair and members of the committee, my name is Ramin Farahmandpour.

1586
03:03:25.575 --> 03:03:31.698
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>I'm a tenured professor and former faculty senator at Portland State University where I've taught for 23 years.

1587
03:03:32.308 --> 03:03:34.840
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>I'm also under an active layoff notice.

1588
03:03:35.352 --> 03:03:37.292
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>I speak today only for myself.

1589
03:03:37.998 --> 03:03:44.203
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>I'm not here to oppose a strong future for performing arts, nor to defend a building with serious seismic flaws.

1590
03:03:44.652 --> 03:03:49.606
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>I'm here because this institution is speaking to 2 different rooms at the same time.

1591
03:03:50.391 --> 03:03:56.532
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>In this room, Portland State is the lead developer of a project estimated at more than $600 million.

1592
03:03:57.382 --> 03:04:01.760
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>In another room, the same institution has declared a fiscal emergency.

1593
03:04:02.433 --> 03:04:11.459
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Its enrollment has fallen 23% since 2019, And it is retrenching faculty and staff and cutting academic programs.

1594
03:04:12.131 --> 03:04:14.906
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>I understand capital bonds cannot pay salaries.

1595
03:04:15.418 --> 03:04:16.540
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>This is not the point.

1596
03:04:17.085 --> 03:04:27.889
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>You are being asked to tie the city's arts future to an institution that is shrinking and cutting its core, even as it takes on a project of this size.

1597
03:04:28.804 --> 03:04:30.295
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Consider the city's own position.

1598
03:04:30.951 --> 03:04:37.667
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>It already owns 3 downtown performing arts halls that need as much as $336 million in deferred maintenance.

1599
03:04:37.733 --> 03:04:38.021
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Thank you.

1600
03:04:38.838 --> 03:04:51.647
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Today, it is asked to commit to a new city-owned theater estimated at more than $350 million with no funding source named, and the cost deferred to December.

1601
03:04:52.320 --> 03:04:55.932
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>The impact statement lists it as, quote unquote, to be determined.

1602
03:04:56.541 --> 03:04:58.307
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>PSU's share is secured.

1603
03:04:58.628 --> 03:04:59.672
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>The city's is not.

1604
03:05:00.088 --> 03:05:03.395
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Before you affirm this commitment, demand the numbers first.

1605
03:05:03.523 --> 03:05:03.796
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Thank you.

1606
03:05:03.861 --> 03:05:04.068
<v Ramin Farahmandpour>Thank you.

1607
03:05:06.253 --> 03:05:07.072
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

1608
03:05:07.313 --> 03:05:07.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1609
03:05:09.143 --> 03:05:10.989
<v Kate Mira>Hi, my name is Kate Mira.

1610
03:05:11.069 --> 03:05:15.742
<v Kate Mira>I use she/her pronouns and am a constituent in 97215.

1611
03:05:16.208 --> 03:05:23.915
<v Kate Mira>I am testifying with my 20-year experience in IATSE Local 28 and, and as an extant founding member of Fuse Theater Ensemble.

1612
03:05:24.172 --> 03:05:26.981
<v Kate Mira>I speak for neither organization and only for myself.

1613
03:05:27.784 --> 03:05:35.077
<v Kate Mira>2 Years ago, I submitted an Oregon Arts Watch opinion piece on remembering the stagehands when contemplating the fate of the Keller Auditorium.

1614
03:05:35.640 --> 03:05:41.634
<v Kate Mira>What I wrote then remains true now: Broadway in Portland must always have a good, appropriate home.

1615
03:05:42.084 --> 03:05:43.417
<v Kate Mira>Just ask a stagehand.

1616
03:05:44.156 --> 03:05:55.516
<v Kate Mira>I agree with the feasibility study focusing on maximizing Broadway content and min and maintaining theater-style commercial content, while also being an accessible home to resident companies.

1617
03:05:55.967 --> 03:05:58.150
<v Kate Mira>And nonprofits and students.

1618
03:05:58.311 --> 03:05:58.954
<v Kate Mira>It's important.

1619
03:05:59.661 --> 03:06:21.490
<v Kate Mira>The PSU construction and Keller renovation plan provides this, including a full performing arts campus, support amenities available and achievable at PSU, no downtime in hosting large-scale shows which support other P5 venues and many people's livelihoods, plus opportunities for audience and subscription growth.

1620
03:06:21.924 --> 03:06:23.209
<v Kate Mira>I do want to highlight a gap.

1621
03:06:23.306 --> 03:06:23.531
<v Kate Mira>Yes.

1622
03:06:24.076 --> 03:06:31.819
<v Kate Mira>In the study, which primarily focused on audiences and existing rentals while ignoring another revenue driver.

1623
03:06:32.445 --> 03:06:48.478
<v Kate Mira>A second Broadway capacity house would be a prime location for upcoming Broadway tours to rehearse and prepare, and for existing tours to update and repair their equipment, as Portland and the stagehands of Local 28 did for Lion King.

1624
03:06:49.218 --> 03:06:56.977
<v Kate Mira>Numerous tours have wished that they could prep their high shows in Portland due to our highly skilled stagehands and lack of sales tax.

1625
03:06:57.490 --> 03:07:02.745
<v Kate Mira>They can save money and time working here while investing in our local economy.

1626
03:07:03.114 --> 03:07:10.677
<v Kate Mira>It's unfortunate that formal research here seems not to have happened via contacting tours or speaking with local stagehands.

1627
03:07:11.367 --> 03:07:18.545
<v Kate Mira>Still, please support and accept the recommendations to advance a new Broadway-capable theater at PSU.

1628
03:07:19.102 --> 03:07:22.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both very much.

1629
03:07:22.468 --> 03:07:23.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, that concludes testimony.

1630
03:07:25.450 --> 03:07:31.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you so much to everybody who joined us today and was able to share your perspectives.

1631
03:07:31.119 --> 03:07:36.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know there is a fair amount of written testimony posted online also, which we'll make sure to take a look at.

1632
03:07:37.865 --> 03:07:50.158
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At this point, we are a few minutes after 5 o'clock, so we won't have time to deliberate today, colleagues, but we will hold this over to our next committee meeting, which will be on— what is that, August 11th?

1633
03:07:51.231 --> 03:07:52.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that right?

1634
03:07:53.155 --> 03:07:55.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm looking to Christopher to confirm that date.

1635
03:07:56.040 --> 03:08:01.552
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, on August 11th, we will bring this back to have council deliberation.

1636
03:08:02.129 --> 03:08:31.295
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It sounds like we may have an amendment coming from Councilor Clark similar to what she went over today, but possibly incorporating a few other items as We are also going to learn about some upcoming legislation on August— on August 11th, we will also learn about some upcoming legislation looking at worker representation in stores in our community, and we will hear a PFAS ordinance as well as our normal public input period.

1637
03:08:31.504 --> 03:08:33.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We also have the pricing.

1638
03:08:35.118 --> 03:08:36.001
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have pricing as well.

1639
03:08:37.045 --> 03:08:38.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, sounds good.

1640
03:08:38.555 --> 03:08:41.060
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will check our agenda, but I think you're probably right there.

1641
03:08:42.024 --> 03:08:59.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to give thanks to our professional staff who were willing to wait an extra few minutes so we could get those last 2 panels in and make sure to hear from everybody today, and also to the 2 panels, 3 panels that we started with to provide some additional feedback on the presentations from our city staff.

1642
03:08:59.886 --> 03:09:00.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all.

1643
03:09:00.272 --> 03:09:01.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And with that, we will adjourn.

1644
03:09:01.524 --> 03:09:01.668
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1645
03:09:01.781 --> 03:09:03.307
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, we will close today's hearing.

1646
03:09:08.195 --> 03:09:08.551
<v Linda McKim-Bell>Thank you.

