WEBVTT

1
00:06:44.834 --> 00:06:45.846
<v Candace Avalos>Good afternoon.

2
00:06:46.103 --> 00:06:47.485
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

3
00:06:47.790 --> 00:06:51.922
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to call the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee to order.

4
00:06:52.934 --> 00:06:54.692
<v Candace Avalos>It is Tuesday, July 21st.

5
00:06:54.956 --> 00:06:56.187
<v Candace Avalos>At 2:02 PM.

6
00:06:56.413 --> 00:06:57.482
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, please call the roll.

7
00:06:58.613 --> 00:06:59.213
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

8
00:06:59.827 --> 00:07:00.362
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

9
00:07:00.701 --> 00:07:00.992
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

10
00:07:01.687 --> 00:07:02.093
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

11
00:07:02.821 --> 00:07:03.127
<v Steve Novick>Here.

12
00:07:03.759 --> 00:07:03.952
<v Selita Holt>Green?

13
00:07:04.372 --> 00:07:04.630
<v Mitch Green>Here.

14
00:07:05.567 --> 00:07:06.019
<v Unidentified speaker>Hertel-Guinea?

15
00:07:06.521 --> 00:07:07.214
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

16
00:07:07.812 --> 00:07:08.119
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

17
00:07:08.394 --> 00:07:08.797
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

18
00:07:09.524 --> 00:07:11.283
<v Candace Avalos>Claire, can you please read the statement of conduct?

19
00:07:12.120 --> 00:07:12.540
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair.

20
00:07:12.944 --> 00:07:15.435
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon and welcome to the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

21
00:07:15.857 --> 00:07:26.348
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at portland.gov /council/agenda/housing-and-permitting-committee or by calling 311.

22
00:07:27.166 --> 00:07:30.124
<v Unidentified speaker>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

23
00:07:30.783 --> 00:07:33.577
<v Unidentified speaker>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

24
00:07:34.372 --> 00:07:39.572
<v Unidentified speaker>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

25
00:07:40.168 --> 00:07:42.036
<v Unidentified speaker>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

26
00:07:42.699 --> 00:07:43.644
<v Unidentified speaker>The chair preserves order.

27
00:07:43.807 --> 00:07:51.476
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

28
00:07:52.151 --> 00:07:53.882
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

29
00:07:54.459 --> 00:07:56.593
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

30
00:07:57.201 --> 00:08:00.040
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

31
00:08:00.713 --> 00:08:03.423
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

32
00:08:04.322 --> 00:08:06.069
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

33
00:08:06.502 --> 00:08:08.298
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, please state your name for the record.

34
00:08:08.812 --> 00:08:11.201
<v Unidentified speaker>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

35
00:08:11.619 --> 00:08:14.665
<v Unidentified speaker>And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

36
00:08:14.762 --> 00:08:15.163
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

37
00:08:16.935 --> 00:08:17.449
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Claire.

38
00:08:18.141 --> 00:08:25.112
<v Candace Avalos>We have 4 main items on today's agenda, although it might look a little wonky because one of those items is a lot of things.

39
00:08:26.252 --> 00:08:30.574
<v Candace Avalos>We're going to first start with public comment on housing permitting issues.

40
00:08:30.670 --> 00:08:35.807
<v Candace Avalos>Then Councilor Green and I will share with the committee a letter to the Planning Commission that we're hoping to have your support on.

41
00:08:36.148 --> 00:08:37.052
<v Candace Avalos>We'll talk more about that.

42
00:08:37.538 --> 00:08:40.789
<v Candace Avalos>Then we will welcome Metro Council President, who I see is already in the audience.

43
00:08:40.855 --> 00:08:41.696
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for being here.

44
00:08:42.375 --> 00:08:52.793
<v Candace Avalos>And the Director of Government Relations, Andy Shaw, for a conversation on regional housing and And then after our short break, we will go through that list of foreclosure properties to consider.

45
00:08:52.889 --> 00:08:57.366
<v Candace Avalos>And we do have to do them all individually, so everyone's just going to have to bear with us procedurally today.

46
00:08:58.509 --> 00:09:00.544
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, please read item 1, Diego.

47
00:09:02.907 --> 00:09:06.458
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 1, housing and permitting community feedback.

48
00:09:07.184 --> 00:09:12.505
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so we are going to hear from community members on their ideas regarding housing and permitting issues.

49
00:09:12.931 --> 00:09:13.977
<v Candace Avalos>They have 3 minutes each.

50
00:09:14.173 --> 00:09:15.368
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, go ahead and call them up.

51
00:09:16.292 --> 00:09:20.823
<v Unidentified speaker>First, Amber Cook, followed by Brianne Whitaker.

52
00:09:28.751 --> 00:09:29.352
<v Amber Cook>We sit here?

53
00:09:29.481 --> 00:09:29.660
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Yes.

54
00:09:30.130 --> 00:09:31.964
<v Amber Cook>Okay, thank you.

55
00:09:34.442 --> 00:09:36.609
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead and introduce yourself and you can get started.

56
00:09:36.868 --> 00:09:47.692
<v Amber Cook>Hi, my name is Amber Cook, and I apologize Just, um, I was going to have it printed out and instead I'm doing it on my phone.

57
00:09:50.623 --> 00:09:50.817
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

58
00:09:51.225 --> 00:09:52.886
<v Amber Cook>Okay, um, greetings to the committee.

59
00:09:54.620 --> 00:10:00.522
<v Amber Cook>Housing is subject to the same rich people, big business phenomena happening everywhere in every industry.

60
00:10:01.427 --> 00:10:10.317
<v Amber Cook>Millionaires and shareholders have decided to extract higher profit margins from their industries and so demand both higher prices and bigger government bailouts.

61
00:10:11.493 --> 00:10:30.527
<v Amber Cook>Developers and bigger landlords work together to keep their rents higher than the market rate with their real page dealings and hold Oregon and Portland hostage, claiming they are going under financially and can't make it without being allowed to overcharge rents while saving money, neglecting their legal obligation to their renters and properties.

62
00:10:31.681 --> 00:10:39.067
<v Amber Cook>In addition, they receive billions in rent assistance and are getting additional billions in a huge number of subsidies and bailouts.

63
00:10:39.777 --> 00:10:43.734
<v Amber Cook>And now they're asking you for even more, for debt buydown bailouts.

64
00:10:44.804 --> 00:10:47.447
<v Amber Cook>Let's look at this through a non-landlord lobby lens.

65
00:10:48.159 --> 00:10:51.975
<v Amber Cook>If a business can't make it financially, someone else buys the business who can.

66
00:10:53.182 --> 00:10:59.610
<v Amber Cook>Yes, landlords have created a multifamily Northwest narrative threatening they will fold and sell, and then you'll be sorry.

67
00:11:00.270 --> 00:11:05.125
<v Amber Cook>But ask yourself, has there in the course of history ever been a shortage of landlords?

68
00:11:05.173 --> 00:11:05.333
<v Amber Cook>Yes.

69
00:11:06.604 --> 00:11:11.171
<v Amber Cook>Landlording is making unearned investment income on a commodity everyone needs.

70
00:11:12.251 --> 00:11:22.182
<v Amber Cook>Isn't the truth that if landlords who want to make unreasonable profit leave, new landlords will take over who are content with a more reasonable and sustainable amount of unearned income?

71
00:11:23.895 --> 00:11:33.658
<v Amber Cook>The fallacy that low-income property landlords can't make enough to stay in business must be questioned by those who, who are giving out the public funds.

72
00:11:34.547 --> 00:11:42.355
<v Amber Cook>Um, and prove with comprehensive company financial documentation before more of our public money goes to these rich for-profit entities.

73
00:11:43.461 --> 00:12:02.828
<v Amber Cook>From rent subsidies, federal tax credits, a variety of state tax credits and city tax credits, and 100 other handouts they get that you and the public don't know about, along with bonds, incredibly low-rate loans, um, large developer fees, real page collective price fixing, unaffordable rents charged, developer landlords are not suffering.

74
00:12:03.998 --> 00:12:19.938
<v Amber Cook>Um, they are failing by overcharging and providing such harmful housing for low to moderate income and PSH that they can't even keep their properties rented out with thousands unhoused and desperate to be housed.

75
00:12:24.470 --> 00:12:25.073
<v Amber Cook>Sorry about this.

76
00:12:25.841 --> 00:12:26.364
<v Kevin Foster>Um, wow.

77
00:12:28.591 --> 00:12:29.763
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, got 30 more seconds.

78
00:12:29.812 --> 00:12:30.120
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

79
00:12:30.316 --> 00:12:30.673
<v Amber Cook>Thank you.

80
00:12:31.113 --> 00:12:44.024
<v Amber Cook>Bailouts and debt buydowns reward them for failing while still allowing them to The housing industry is bleeding public funds out in such high amounts, it's time to start demanding accountability and stop the abuse.

81
00:12:44.950 --> 00:12:56.201
<v Amber Cook>They can afford to run their properties better and for less rents at a more moderate profit margin, so they'll fill back up with renters and become self-sustaining like we expect from every other industry.

82
00:12:59.149 --> 00:13:00.471
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you for—.

83
00:13:00.671 --> 00:13:01.562
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for your feedback.

84
00:13:03.931 --> 00:13:04.254
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up.

85
00:13:08.308 --> 00:13:09.309
<v Candace Avalos>Hi, Council.

86
00:13:10.796 --> 00:13:11.765
<v Bree Whittaker>My name is Bree Whittaker.

87
00:13:12.105 --> 00:13:18.966
<v Bree Whittaker>I'm a longtime, uh, Portland resident, a grad school— a grad student at Portland State University, and a resident of District 3.

88
00:13:19.674 --> 00:13:47.855
<v Bree Whittaker>I just want to ask you to take a closer look at the, um, NPLTE tax loophole in which for-profit property owners like, um, Community Development Partners, I think they're called, um, are able to tack on just an itty-bitty tiny little nonprofit, like 1/200th of an interest, and receive a huge tax break on their property taxes.

89
00:13:48.447 --> 00:13:55.481
<v Bree Whittaker>As you already know, we are faced with all kind of budget deficits here at the We have them at the university.

90
00:13:55.530 --> 00:13:56.659
<v Bree Whittaker>We have them at the state.

91
00:13:57.288 --> 00:14:01.177
<v Bree Whittaker>It's an issue that we have to start closing these loopholes up on.

92
00:14:02.515 --> 00:14:05.913
<v Bree Whittaker>I think this is a major, a major one that is going overlooked.

93
00:14:06.139 --> 00:14:37.889
<v Bree Whittaker>In fact, I know that when my husband got on the phone with one of Councilor Dunphy's staff members, that staff member let him know that it's Intentional or possibly a nice aside fact that a for-profit company, like a huge privately owned international hedge fund that helps people in far-off places retire while the rest of us just kind of stew in our own juices.

94
00:14:41.601 --> 00:14:53.416
<v Bree Whittaker>It lets them get things like an $84,000 Property tax break on one property, one property, Milepost 5 in Northeast Portland, that is basically a cesspool.

95
00:14:53.847 --> 00:15:05.422
<v Bree Whittaker>It's, um, I don't know if you've ever seen, um, Call the Midwife, but it looks like a tenement house from Call the Midwife because they don't run it, they don't manage it.

96
00:15:05.791 --> 00:15:09.044
<v Bree Whittaker>They say they have nonprofits that manage it and provide services.

97
00:15:09.461 --> 00:15:10.230
<v Bree Whittaker>They do not.

98
00:15:10.615 --> 00:15:29.243
<v Bree Whittaker>The nonprofits And that they have come in and take care of the problems that are happening in the building and take care of the services that are supposed to support the tenants that they have in the building never show up because there's 800 layers of administrative fees and administrators and this and that before it ever gets to the frontline.

99
00:15:29.740 --> 00:15:31.038
<v Bree Whittaker>So why are they getting a tax break?

100
00:15:31.503 --> 00:15:33.779
<v Bree Whittaker>Where's— what is this tax break even doing for them?

101
00:15:34.325 --> 00:15:35.317
<v Bree Whittaker>They don't need it.

102
00:15:35.750 --> 00:15:38.732
<v Bree Whittaker>They already have multiple kinds of tax credits.

103
00:15:38.972 --> 00:15:43.109
<v Bree Whittaker>They're already part of huge portfolios of properties.

104
00:15:43.157 --> 00:15:43.284
<v Bree Whittaker>Thank you.

105
00:15:43.850 --> 00:15:49.129
<v Bree Whittaker>That don't need help, that are luxury buildings that are just benefiting from these tax breaks.

106
00:15:49.921 --> 00:15:52.649
<v Bree Whittaker>But the community doesn't benefit from the tax break.

107
00:15:53.556 --> 00:15:58.552
<v Bree Whittaker>The community doesn't benefit from these loopholes, all loopy and holey and flapping about.

108
00:15:59.966 --> 00:16:03.075
<v Bree Whittaker>We have to be better than past councils.

109
00:16:03.123 --> 00:16:04.701
<v Bree Whittaker>We have to be better than past cities.

110
00:16:05.039 --> 00:16:08.745
<v Bree Whittaker>We have to look to, quite frankly, New York and Mondani at this point.

111
00:16:14.008 --> 00:16:19.047
<v Unidentified speaker>That concludes testimony.

112
00:16:20.909 --> 00:16:23.134
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you both for your very passionate testimony.

113
00:16:23.471 --> 00:16:30.927
<v Candace Avalos>And I'll just say I agree with a lot of what you're saying, and it is my intention to move forward policies to address these issues.

114
00:16:31.360 --> 00:16:34.918
<v Candace Avalos>I think that we do need to get serious about making changes.

115
00:16:35.039 --> 00:16:37.476
<v Candace Avalos>To how our housing market works.

116
00:16:38.022 --> 00:16:48.427
<v Candace Avalos>That is why we have proposed several alternatives, but really grateful for your feedback and know that I am going to be going on a big tour in the fall to talk specifically to renters.

117
00:16:48.556 --> 00:16:49.902
<v Candace Avalos>So keep an eye on that.

118
00:16:50.222 --> 00:16:53.765
<v Candace Avalos>We will be bringing rental ripoffs to Portland just like Mom and Donnie.

119
00:16:53.831 --> 00:16:56.283
<v Candace Avalos>So we'll stay tuned.

120
00:16:56.635 --> 00:16:57.004
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

121
00:16:58.303 --> 00:16:59.907
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, please go ahead and read item 2.

122
00:17:00.965 --> 00:17:03.658
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 2, committee letter to Planning Commission.

123
00:17:05.279 --> 00:17:13.854
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so, um, this is an exciting yet an unconventional, uh, opportunity here to do something different in committee.

124
00:17:14.029 --> 00:17:16.663
<v Candace Avalos>I'm really looking forward to this discussion.

125
00:17:16.920 --> 00:17:25.815
<v Candace Avalos>Um, we as chair and vice chair Green are seeking the committee's support to transmit a letter on behalf of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

126
00:17:26.409 --> 00:17:34.563
<v Candace Avalos>The letter reflects the committee's interest in pursuing the Planning Commission Oh, ensuring, sorry, the Planning Commission is aware of our perspective as they continue their work.

127
00:17:35.030 --> 00:17:40.736
<v Candace Avalos>And so I'll go ahead and turn it over to Vice Chair Green to introduce the letter, walk us through the purpose, and explain why we're bringing it forward.

128
00:17:41.090 --> 00:17:45.252
<v Candace Avalos>And after that, we'll open it up for committee discussion to consider how we move that forward.

129
00:17:45.300 --> 00:17:46.961
<v Candace Avalos>So Vice Chair Green, take it away.

130
00:17:47.869 --> 00:17:49.000
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much, Chair Avalos.

131
00:17:49.178 --> 00:18:18.038
<v Mitch Green>Just for context here, I recently had a meeting with Michael Henderson at the Sightline Institute, some other kind of pro-housing sort of agenda, kind of housing policy-focused constituents of mine and, you know, developers as well in my office to sort of say, look, we have an opportunity right now in flight with an item that's before the Planning Commission.

132
00:18:18.411 --> 00:18:23.451
<v Mitch Green>It's the housing bonus alignment project that is currently under consideration by the Planning Commission.

133
00:18:24.193 --> 00:19:09.123
<v Mitch Green>And in reading the the proposed draft, they're really appreciative of the direction, but they think given how long it takes to move through those land use items and given the scale of the crisis that we have in the City of Portland with failing to provide enough housing at a reasonable cost, and given that we have a shortage of funds to directly subsidize things, we have to get creative about how we change our zoning approaches and land use approaches We have an opportunity to use that action that's in flight to appeal to the Planning Commission to make some amendments to their project before it heads to council to save us some time, frankly.

134
00:19:10.056 --> 00:19:14.819
<v Mitch Green>And so I was talking to them, you know, kind of— and I'll go through what these 3 asks are.

135
00:19:15.594 --> 00:19:24.903
<v Mitch Green>But the idea was, well, if we wait to receive it from the Planning Commission to the body, that We can have that debate and we will have it either way.

136
00:19:26.268 --> 00:19:33.445
<v Mitch Green>But how do we envision the relationship between the Housing Committee of the City of Portland and the Planning Commission?

137
00:19:33.574 --> 00:19:46.886
<v Mitch Green>And I think the chair and I have thought that we really want this to be an opportunity to minimize the time it takes to get to an end objective so we can move our housing production along as quickly as possible.

138
00:19:47.016 --> 00:19:53.935
<v Mitch Green>Later, we'll have a conversation about where voters are at on the state of paying for For housing finance.

139
00:19:53.983 --> 00:20:03.383
<v Mitch Green>And so anything that we can do to demonstrate to voters that we're using our time as wisely as possible and as efficiently as possible, I think it's important to strike while the iron's hot.

140
00:20:03.431 --> 00:20:20.128
<v Mitch Green>And so the thinking was there's not time to draft a resolution, there's not time to consider kind of a new legislative action item from this committee, but we can always transmit a letter to say, Maybe consider this before you adopt something Planning Commission.

141
00:20:20.484 --> 00:20:24.465
<v Mitch Green>I think that's an opportunity that we might want to try out in this committee.

142
00:20:24.513 --> 00:20:33.508
<v Mitch Green>And so there are 3 basic asks of the Planning Commission in this letter that are focused on the RM-3 base zoning framework.

143
00:20:34.236 --> 00:20:46.737
<v Mitch Green>The first is to increase the base floor area ratio from 2 to 2.5, just in the base zone, to make it easier for some of these mid-density Yes.

144
00:20:47.075 --> 00:20:53.958
<v Mitch Green>Projects to pencil out given a shortage of other capital that can make the difference for this project to kind of get over the line.

145
00:20:54.869 --> 00:20:59.522
<v Mitch Green>Things like single stair projects would be easier to build in a framework like this.

146
00:21:00.761 --> 00:21:05.184
<v Mitch Green>It fits more easily with the Inner Eastside for All type of envisioning that we're doing as well.

147
00:21:06.849 --> 00:21:11.463
<v Mitch Green>The second is to apply the 5-foot front setback reduction universally to the base zone.

148
00:21:11.804 --> 00:21:13.488
<v Mitch Green>So that's just built into the base zone.

149
00:21:14.165 --> 00:21:18.682
<v Mitch Green>To make it much easier to get to yes on using as much of your property.

150
00:21:23.265 --> 00:21:30.128
<v Mitch Green>And then finally, adjust the deeper housing affordability criteria to align with state-defined bonus criteria for affordable cooperative housing.

151
00:21:30.210 --> 00:21:43.826
<v Mitch Green>So I think the instinct or the intention behind this piece is in some sense to bring— You know, let me get my notes here right.

152
00:21:46.240 --> 00:21:54.160
<v Mitch Green>Um, the commission should make any necessary tweaks to the deeper housing affordability bonus criteria to just bring more in line with the state's 90-year moderate income cooperative housing framework.

153
00:21:54.224 --> 00:22:07.557
<v Mitch Green>So if we line these up, it ensures that our zoning code as we adopt it is sort of in some sense future-proofing a little bit other, um, cooperative forms, limited equity co-op forms of housing that we might want to consider, as well as any future social housing work that we might want to Yes.

154
00:22:07.623 --> 00:22:16.118
<v Mitch Green>So it kind of provides a little bit more flexibility so we don't wait to react to a policy choice that we might make as council, and we're instead ready to go.

155
00:22:17.483 --> 00:22:19.877
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, those are the top 3.

156
00:22:19.925 --> 00:22:33.384
<v Mitch Green>I think the sort of nice to have and please consider it, but it wasn't really one of the top 3, was as you're doing this discussed draft and working towards adopting a recommendation to council, consider raising the step-down height from 35 to 45 feet.

157
00:22:34.058 --> 00:22:48.661
<v Mitch Green>So we can move away from these kind of like this corridor-based approach to density and not concentrate housing on some of the busiest roads in the city of Portland and really kind of upzone a little bit more.

158
00:22:48.788 --> 00:22:53.116
<v Mitch Green>So the idea here is this is not a binding thing from the committee.

159
00:22:53.340 --> 00:22:54.816
<v Mitch Green>This isn't a policy directive.

160
00:22:54.895 --> 00:23:00.761
<v Mitch Green>This is a letter from the committee to the Planning Commission to say, before you send it our way, these are things we would love to see there.

161
00:23:00.971 --> 00:23:01.242
<v Mitch Green>And so—.

162
00:23:01.242 --> 00:23:01.434
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

163
00:23:01.692 --> 00:23:16.576
<v Mitch Green>The ask from us is because we can't talk to you guys, we can't talk to a third between meetings, and this could potentially be a policy under consideration by the council, you would violate public meetings law by asking any one of you guys to sign on.

164
00:23:16.640 --> 00:23:19.690
<v Mitch Green>So this is the place to ask if you want to sign this letter or not.

165
00:23:19.898 --> 00:23:30.506
<v Mitch Green>And so no hard feelings if you won't, but we think that it'd be great if all of us signed on to this letter today and we sent it to the Planning Commission With some asks here.

166
00:23:31.146 --> 00:23:35.040
<v Mitch Green>So I think I'll shut up there and we can kind of get into this conversation.

167
00:23:36.259 --> 00:23:37.092
<v Candace Avalos>All right, sounds good.

168
00:23:37.477 --> 00:23:38.486
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Novick, go ahead.

169
00:23:39.159 --> 00:23:39.913
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

170
00:23:40.538 --> 00:23:45.023
<v Steve Novick>So I have to say, some of these concepts are things that I learn once a year and then I probably forget them.

171
00:23:45.568 --> 00:23:52.844
<v Steve Novick>So what does the— what is the base— what is changing the base FAR of 2.0 to 2.5?

172
00:23:52.941 --> 00:23:53.484
<v Steve Novick>What does that practically mean?

173
00:23:56.153 --> 00:23:59.406
<v Mitch Green>That is a great question, and I am going to do my best.

174
00:23:59.972 --> 00:24:04.099
<v Mitch Green>But, um, because I always have to ask this, I always have to retrain myself on these acronyms as well.

175
00:24:04.164 --> 00:24:12.830
<v Mitch Green>But in talking to developers, um, uh, my understanding is if we do that, it gives them more solution space to engineer and architect.

176
00:24:13.138 --> 00:24:26.554
<v Mitch Green>Um, given some of the lot sizes in some of our, um, inner east side, it makes it easier to contemplate more mid-rise development projects with that FAR ratio than otherwise would happen.

177
00:24:26.617 --> 00:24:39.278
<v Mitch Green>But I don't know, Director Engstrom, I'm going to put you on the spot here, but maybe you can give a plain English explanation to the councilor on what that, the practical impact of such a thing would be.

178
00:24:40.673 --> 00:24:41.820
<v Mitch Green>And he's not working for me right now.

179
00:24:41.868 --> 00:24:43.064
<v Mitch Green>He's working for the committee.

180
00:24:43.113 --> 00:24:44.566
<v Mitch Green>So thank you.

181
00:24:45.906 --> 00:24:46.230
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

182
00:24:46.488 --> 00:25:10.210
<v Eric Engstrom>For the record, Eric Engstrom, Director of the Bureau of Planning and So floor area ratio is the measure— it's a measure of development intensity of buildings, and it really literally just means a floor area ratio of 1 to 1 means that you can have a floor area— if you had a 10,000-square-foot lot, you can have a 10,000-square-foot floor plate, and that could be stacked however many stories the height limit would allow.

183
00:25:10.589 --> 00:25:18.450
<v Eric Engstrom>So a 2 to 1 floor area ratio would mean for a 10,000-square-foot lot, you'd get 20,000 square feet of floor area to stack.

184
00:25:22.705 --> 00:25:31.861
<v Steve Novick>May I ask the director a couple of questions?

185
00:25:32.529 --> 00:25:32.627
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

186
00:25:33.051 --> 00:25:47.385
<v Steve Novick>So let's see, one question I have is, my understanding is the Planning Commission was sort of working on adjustments to the bonus criteria and this is sort of about the base FAR.

187
00:25:47.836 --> 00:25:53.234
<v Steve Novick>Would they be freaked out about being asked to sort of incorporate changes that aren't about bonuses?

188
00:25:55.422 --> 00:26:00.467
<v Eric Engstrom>You know, whenever we scope a planning project, there is some consideration for what's the project about.

189
00:26:00.515 --> 00:26:09.315
<v Eric Engstrom>And we do want to avoid, from a public engagement perspective, we want to avoid a situation where we market a project as about A and then we do Z.

190
00:26:10.760 --> 00:26:12.096
<v Eric Engstrom>This is not quite A and Z.

191
00:26:12.208 --> 00:26:16.406
<v Eric Engstrom>It's maybe A and So there's some wiggle room there in terms of how you interpret that.

192
00:26:16.550 --> 00:26:29.851
<v Eric Engstrom>And if this was adopted, because again, as you're right, the project was about bonus provisions, it might prompt us to do a little bit more engagement to make sure that the public is aware of the change.

193
00:26:30.667 --> 00:26:33.729
<v Steve Novick>So is there— would there be time to do that additional engagement?

194
00:26:34.979 --> 00:26:39.161
<v Steve Novick>Or are we asking them to like add something on after they've already done all the engaging they're going to do?

195
00:26:41.623 --> 00:26:47.080
<v Eric Engstrom>The Planning Commission, I suppose, could ask us to do that before they vote, or they could just say before you go to council, do that.

196
00:26:47.128 --> 00:26:52.540
<v Eric Engstrom>It might stretch the timeline of the project overall a tiny bit, but it's not off the table.

197
00:26:53.465 --> 00:26:53.644
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

198
00:26:54.259 --> 00:27:02.759
<v Steve Novick>I actually have the same kind of question about what a 5-foot front setback reduction means.

199
00:27:02.825 --> 00:27:03.165
<v Steve Novick>Councilor?

200
00:27:09.523 --> 00:27:13.263
<v Steve Novick>And what it means to apply it universally to the base zone as opposed to non-universally?

201
00:27:15.900 --> 00:27:39.590
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, my under— so again, I might ask the director to help me out here, but when I talked to the developer and I talked to the folks in the room with me, they said if we were to adopt this rule, it would allow them to have, a little more creativity in how they contemplate how to approach, um, the development projects that are waiting in their pipeline that they have investors ready to go on.

202
00:27:39.784 --> 00:27:48.022
<v Mitch Green>And given, uh, given these setback rules, oftentimes they're in a situation where something doesn't quite hit the line because they can't configure the lot the way that they would prefer.

203
00:27:49.711 --> 00:27:56.525
<v Eric Engstrom>Councilor, my understanding that the multifamily zones, the front setback is typically either 5 or 10 feet.

204
00:27:56.766 --> 00:27:57.615
<v Eric Engstrom>Depending on the zone.

205
00:27:58.127 --> 00:28:01.636
<v Eric Engstrom>The more lower-density zones are the 10 feet and the higher density are 5.

206
00:28:01.765 --> 00:28:07.453
<v Eric Engstrom>And in this case, I believe the bonus language says that if you're using that bonus, you can go to the 5.

207
00:28:07.501 --> 00:28:14.936
<v Eric Engstrom>And as I understand the letter, you're asking for us to switch the base standard in that zone from 10 to 5.

208
00:28:15.450 --> 00:28:19.711
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, and I just want to be clear, and I really appreciate the questions you're asking.

209
00:28:20.817 --> 00:28:23.526
<v Mitch Green>The folks in the room are like, look, there's going to be some pushback Yes.

210
00:28:23.767 --> 00:28:26.205
<v Mitch Green>On like, well, why don't we just do this outside?

211
00:28:26.269 --> 00:28:27.376
<v Mitch Green>This is a bonus alignment.

212
00:28:27.424 --> 00:28:30.266
<v Mitch Green>So these sorts of questions would be reasonable questions to ask.

213
00:28:30.747 --> 00:28:53.693
<v Mitch Green>And I think the argument was like, it doesn't seem to serve any good purpose to not have that in the base zone if we want to encourage densification on the timelines that we're trying to do beyond just saying, well, if we're going to do this bonus project, maybe we're starting to veer into something that's closer to the Z and Just be aware of that sort of concern.

214
00:28:54.291 --> 00:29:07.376
<v Mitch Green>And I think the shared understanding is, well, if we were to hit, take this letter off the table, go forward and do great things, and then contemplate trying to do this later, it might take years to take this up on a different process, 'cause these are staff-intensive, lengthy processes.

215
00:29:07.424 --> 00:29:12.660
<v Mitch Green>So striking while the iron's hot is sort of the play here.

216
00:29:13.464 --> 00:29:18.143
<v Steve Novick>And how does the staff How do the setbacks work again?

217
00:29:18.480 --> 00:29:27.038
<v Steve Novick>Is it you can build up to 10, within 10 feet of the property line, and this means you could build within up to 5 feet away from the property line?

218
00:29:28.179 --> 00:29:37.201
<v Eric Engstrom>The front setback is measured from the right-of-way edge, so which in many zones is at the back of the sidewalk or a couple feet back from the sidewalk.

219
00:29:37.282 --> 00:29:41.376
<v Eric Engstrom>So yeah, there are minor projections allowed into that setback.

220
00:29:41.763 --> 00:29:43.634
<v Eric Engstrom>In many cases, like balconies and things.

221
00:29:43.762 --> 00:29:49.955
<v Eric Engstrom>But yeah, it would just allow the building to be slightly closer to the street in that zone.

222
00:29:51.930 --> 00:29:52.106
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

223
00:29:52.525 --> 00:29:57.032
<v Steve Novick>And I have to say, the third one, I think I don't understand the least.

224
00:29:57.999 --> 00:30:03.161
<v Steve Novick>What does it mean to adjust deeper housing affordability criteria to align with state-defined bonus criteria?

225
00:30:05.008 --> 00:30:26.069
<v Mitch Green>I think the idea is, Folks like Sightline, folks like Portland Neighbors Welcome, some of these developers who are building kind of mid-rise, single stair, you know, 4 to 6 floors, are anticipating that we might adopt something like a limited equity co-op model or a social housing type of framework.

226
00:30:26.652 --> 00:30:39.701
<v Mitch Green>And they want the planning committee to, and it may already be compatible, but to sort of consider that if we were to adopt something like that, that we have already trued up and future-proofed our definition.

227
00:30:39.749 --> 00:30:47.664
<v Mitch Green>So we're not waiting on a later policy action that would be able to put to use some of those bonuses that are already in state law.

228
00:30:47.761 --> 00:30:53.017
<v Mitch Green>So it's kind of future-proofing against maybe future council action on that.

229
00:30:53.564 --> 00:30:55.267
<v Steve Novick>Director, do you have any thoughts to add on that?

230
00:30:56.553 --> 00:31:00.913
<v Eric Engstrom>That's the one that I frankly have not done my homework on either.

231
00:31:00.979 --> 00:31:05.076
<v Eric Engstrom>So we'd have to do more research to Okay.

232
00:31:05.287 --> 00:31:08.001
<v Steve Novick>On the other 2, I have another question for— actually, for both of you.

233
00:31:08.502 --> 00:31:10.619
<v Steve Novick>Who will be mad if we sent this letter?

234
00:31:11.680 --> 00:31:16.096
<v Steve Novick>Who would be— what would be the objections to the change in the setback rule and the change in the base FAR?

235
00:31:23.845 --> 00:31:27.339
<v Mitch Green>I mean, I, I don't know.

236
00:31:27.827 --> 00:31:37.916
<v Steve Novick>I just kind of— From a public engagement standpoint, if I'm voting on something, I sort of wanna know who'll be mad to see if maybe I should check in with them first.

237
00:31:37.997 --> 00:31:39.109
<v Steve Novick>Just sort of a general rule.

238
00:31:39.772 --> 00:31:41.922
<v Mitch Green>I do wanna clear that this isn't up for a vote.

239
00:31:42.019 --> 00:31:43.990
<v Mitch Green>So we're just asking folks to sign up for it.

240
00:31:44.038 --> 00:31:44.830
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I see what you're— right.

241
00:31:44.880 --> 00:31:45.186
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah.

242
00:31:45.364 --> 00:31:50.542
<v Mitch Green>So you can always say, well, you know, I wasn't the first signer on it.

243
00:31:52.755 --> 00:31:57.198
<v Steve Novick>Let's see, the other question is, I mean, Except for the third one, which I don't understand at all.

244
00:31:57.551 --> 00:32:00.278
<v Steve Novick>The other things seem to me to be consistent with my biases.

245
00:32:01.289 --> 00:32:15.472
<v Steve Novick>So, but one thing I would wonder about is, doo doo doo, the, we're urging them to adopt 3 critical amendments.

246
00:32:16.651 --> 00:32:26.974
<v Steve Novick>I think that in dealing with one of our commissions, I feel more comfortable urging them to consider adopting them rather than saying we want you to do this.

247
00:32:29.875 --> 00:32:33.588
<v Steve Novick>So, um, okay, yeah, that's my sort of instinctive reaction.

248
00:32:33.814 --> 00:32:34.087
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

249
00:32:34.650 --> 00:32:38.026
<v Candace Avalos>Appreciate it.

250
00:32:38.380 --> 00:32:39.511
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

251
00:32:40.417 --> 00:32:40.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

252
00:32:41.243 --> 00:33:04.946
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, I just want to start by saying that I think for places where we have had robust conversations as a committee and there's a sense of where the committee and maybe even where council more broadly wants to head, using this approach, writing a letter early on, being clear about where council is, is a very good one.

253
00:33:05.846 --> 00:33:10.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I appreciate you daylighting this as a tool that we have in our toolbox to use.

254
00:33:10.948 --> 00:33:12.969
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That said, I'm concerned about the timing.

255
00:33:13.049 --> 00:33:15.576
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm concerned with this one for a couple of reasons.

256
00:33:17.009 --> 00:33:20.385
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm leaning toward not putting my name on it.

257
00:33:20.515 --> 00:33:22.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do want to ask a couple of questions.

258
00:33:23.730 --> 00:33:29.624
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a reason, a policy reason, that this is focused on the RM-3 zone?

259
00:33:29.737 --> 00:33:37.017
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The underlying work of the alignment project is affecting about 5 different residential and 5 different commercial zones.

260
00:33:39.334 --> 00:34:05.864
<v Mitch Green>In my conversations with the developer, and Neil Heller is his name, just for full disclosure, and Michael Anderson, who many of us know or know of, the idea is most of the action in the Inner Eastside for All project, and frankly, if we were to move towards something like a single stair framework of production, housing production, Yes.

261
00:34:06.057 --> 00:34:09.960
<v Mitch Green>Would be in the RM-3 zoning base.

262
00:34:10.456 --> 00:34:38.237
<v Mitch Green>And so the idea was taking this step now, recognizing that this is a bonus alignment project and not a base zone project, would allow us to move in the direction that some cities, frankly, very close to us, like Vancouver, Washington, are moving, where they're basically taking almost, frankly, a maximalist approach to saying we really can't afford to sit on our hands and we would like to upzone and remove as many restrictions as possible.

263
00:34:38.318 --> 00:34:44.208
<v Mitch Green>And so we don't— we're not going to do that in the City of Portland because we have different rules and institutions and we can't move that fast.

264
00:34:45.074 --> 00:34:57.398
<v Mitch Green>But the idea here is knowing that RM-3 is going to be the zone where these projects would be envisioned, let's address it in the base zone while this process is underway and see if we can make hay while the sun shines.

265
00:35:00.635 --> 00:35:05.699
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The bonus alignment project, though, isn't focused just on the Inner Eastside for All area.

266
00:35:05.764 --> 00:35:07.206
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's focused citywide.

267
00:35:07.271 --> 00:35:14.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And when I looked at the map that they include on the areas that will be affected by that project, it truly is all across the city.

268
00:35:14.097 --> 00:35:22.766
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it, interestingly, it seems to be very corridor-focused, which is something that I've heard you a few times this afternoon say you don't support.

269
00:35:22.831 --> 00:35:22.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

270
00:35:23.489 --> 00:35:47.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I guess I'm still trying to square, not only are we looking at 2 changes that are to the base, which is a pretty significant policy change, I would say, even if it's only small here, to change our base zoning without a robust conversation and inviting stakeholders to weigh in feels big.

271
00:35:49.443 --> 00:36:03.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we're talking about changes that I hear you saying are necessary for a small part of the city that we've already fast-tracked the process on in a project that affects the whole city.

272
00:36:03.329 --> 00:36:05.226
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So help me square those things.

273
00:36:05.501 --> 00:36:11.590
<v Mitch Green>This letter is not intended to be limited to the Inner Eastside for All project.

274
00:36:13.559 --> 00:36:23.699
<v Mitch Green>This letter is intended to speak to This idea that if we're gonna hit our housing production goals, we kind of need to use every tool that we have at our disposal citywide.

275
00:36:24.389 --> 00:36:37.228
<v Mitch Green>And one of those tools is recognizing that we have zoning map update projects in flight all the time, and we have this brokered procedural process that takes years.

276
00:36:38.208 --> 00:36:45.222
<v Mitch Green>And so we have one underway that's already considering some opportunities to make some adjustments.

277
00:36:45.286 --> 00:37:05.139
<v Mitch Green>And I think the idea is not that we want to focus the work just on the areas of the map that would likely benefit from the InterEast Side for All work, but to make sure we're clearing any bottlenecks in advance as there's efforts to develop within this space, wherever they may be.

278
00:37:05.315 --> 00:37:06.548
<v Mitch Green>It could be on the east side as well.

279
00:37:06.693 --> 00:37:10.242
<v Mitch Green>It could be in my, you know, in Southwest Portland as well.

280
00:37:11.501 --> 00:37:21.284
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm using that as an example because those are the areas where you're likely to see a lot of work because of the nature of the grid in that part of the city and, you know, the infrastructure that exists.

281
00:37:21.364 --> 00:37:35.108
<v Mitch Green>But I think the spirit behind this is to say you look at some other cities that are meeting the moment by removing height restrictions, by basically doing a bunch of by-right development change, and we're not.

282
00:37:36.038 --> 00:37:38.543
<v Mitch Green>And so we can't do that from this committee.

283
00:37:39.827 --> 00:37:46.184
<v Mitch Green>But what we can do from this committee is urge slightly more bold action when we do take some of these update steps.

284
00:37:46.233 --> 00:37:47.340
<v Mitch Green>So that's the spirit behind it.

285
00:37:47.918 --> 00:37:51.706
<v Mitch Green>I'm not sure if that addresses your concern or not.

286
00:37:52.590 --> 00:37:55.190
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It at least provides some explanation, and I appreciate that.

287
00:37:55.655 --> 00:38:03.474
<v Mitch Green>And the last piece though, just on the corridor piece, the step-down stuff is a direct callback to the corridors.

288
00:38:03.891 --> 00:38:20.335
<v Mitch Green>The reason why we have these These density corridors on streets like Division, Interstate, some of the kind of bigger, newer development spaces where you've got a lot of density right on the street, but then not— and then single-family homes right behind it is because of that step-down structure.

289
00:38:20.994 --> 00:38:29.184
<v Mitch Green>And I think the recognition is we— it didn't make it into the top 3 because it's sort of not as— that's a big step.

290
00:38:29.681 --> 00:38:41.081
<v Mitch Green>The idea here is like, while you're at it, maybe consider So that's, that's why that's called out on a different approach, and that's why I mentioned something about corridor density.

291
00:38:41.788 --> 00:38:56.382
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I read through the summary of the report and a few of the, the detailed pieces of the report as well last night so that I could understand the context here, and there are some really important changes that will be coming to us.

292
00:38:56.494 --> 00:39:23.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are also some things in there that I have some concerns and additional questions about, and I think looking at changes to one area of zoning based on a conversation you had with a developer without a broader conversation about what it is we are trying to do across our zoning structures isn't something that I'm comfortable putting my name on.

293
00:39:24.496 --> 00:39:34.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm also not comfortable saying these are the things we want you to change when I may have other concerns as we learn more about the proposal that I'd like to be able to have the opportunity to weigh in on.

294
00:39:35.833 --> 00:39:39.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I really do appreciate you all bringing this tool forward.

295
00:39:40.329 --> 00:39:49.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do think that as we have things that the committee has discussed, things that we have said are priorities for us, this is a really important tool we should be using.

296
00:39:52.269 --> 00:40:07.132
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We certainly need to be moving toward more density in significant swaths of our city, but we should be having the policy conversations about how to do that in a way that works with what Portland has done.

297
00:40:07.358 --> 00:40:18.338
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have robust processes, and for us to end run those without a discussion about how it fits in with the broader policy agenda— I think that's a good point.

298
00:40:19.923 --> 00:40:22.065
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Isn't something that I am comfortable doing.

299
00:40:22.338 --> 00:40:37.358
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to— we need to speed up the process, but we need to not get rid of all opportunity to think about how the different pieces of our zoning work together to create the city that Portlanders want to be in.

300
00:40:37.809 --> 00:40:45.014
<v Mitch Green>So, you know, I respect that feedback, but I would push back that this is not an end run around The process.

301
00:40:45.224 --> 00:40:50.434
<v Mitch Green>This is literally designed to engage directly in the process, which is the Planning Commission is considering a zoning map.

302
00:40:51.237 --> 00:40:58.019
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so the Planning Commission would receive this letter and say thanks but no thanks, or they'll say that's interesting, let's incorporate this.

303
00:40:58.068 --> 00:41:13.755
<v Mitch Green>So this is actually squarely in line with the process, and I think what Portlanders are asking for is for us to think creatively on how we can help that process move as quickly as possible towards the outcome that we need, which is Thank you.

304
00:41:14.831 --> 00:41:30.414
<v Mitch Green>So I just, you know, this would— an example of end-running the process would be bringing forward an ordinance or a resolution to say disregard, I'm going to bring a floor amendment to the ordinance that comes out of this and do all that.

305
00:41:30.461 --> 00:41:36.373
<v Mitch Green>And so my desire, our desire was to sort of say that's actually not the preferred method.

306
00:41:36.583 --> 00:41:38.574
<v Mitch Green>We do want to use the procedure and this is how we want to use it.

307
00:41:39.264 --> 00:41:43.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, I'll take your point on the word choice.

308
00:41:43.853 --> 00:41:52.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was responding to hearing that this might be able to be a part of public comment and feedback, but that work has already begun.

309
00:41:56.155 --> 00:42:04.065
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think there is, as you have said, broad agreement across council that we need to diligently work to make sure we have enough housing in the city.

310
00:42:04.128 --> 00:42:04.594
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a good point.

311
00:42:04.679 --> 00:42:04.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

312
00:42:04.936 --> 00:42:08.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a really important thing that we're seeing in our city.

313
00:42:09.074 --> 00:42:19.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I will always ask for us to approach that work by making sure that changes we make in one place fit with what we're trying to do in other places and that this work is seamless.

314
00:42:21.152 --> 00:42:40.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, I'm not sure that making a change to one, one base floor area in one zone structure in a process that isn't looking at the base at all is a— is the comprehensive way to do that work that I'd like to do.

315
00:42:41.954 --> 00:42:51.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I understand that you two will probably move forward with this boldly with your names on it and anybody else who wants it, but I would ask that it not come from the committee as a whole.

316
00:42:53.253 --> 00:42:54.025
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Koyama Lane.

317
00:42:56.534 --> 00:42:57.130
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair.

318
00:42:57.275 --> 00:43:00.010
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair and Vice Chair, for bringing this letter.

319
00:43:00.699 --> 00:43:01.719
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

320
00:43:01.929 --> 00:43:16.371
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to highlight the 3rd recommendation, 3rd recommended amendment in here in the letter that suggests adjusting deeper housing affordability criteria to align with state-defined bonus criteria for affordable cooperative housing.

321
00:43:17.128 --> 00:43:36.190
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I agree that it's important that we line up incentives in the zoning code so that the city is compatible with alternative equity models, community-led land trusts, And, you know, other flavors of things that might come, like social housing.

322
00:43:36.639 --> 00:43:40.099
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So thank you, Chair and Vice Chair, for including that language, especially in the third one.

323
00:43:41.494 --> 00:43:50.516
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I hear what Councilor Novick was saying about the use of language that's a little bit more like, please consider, or for consideration.

324
00:43:50.563 --> 00:43:55.146
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think with some changes there, I would be happy to add.

325
00:43:55.242 --> 00:43:55.387
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

326
00:43:55.612 --> 00:43:55.952
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My name.

327
00:43:57.068 --> 00:43:57.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

328
00:44:01.119 --> 00:44:02.677
<v Steve Novick>Um, thank you, Madam Chair.

329
00:44:02.820 --> 00:44:04.588
<v Steve Novick>I mean, I'm not prepared to sign this today.

330
00:44:04.684 --> 00:44:07.641
<v Steve Novick>That doesn't mean I might not be prepared to sign it or some version of it next week.

331
00:44:07.882 --> 00:44:22.918
<v Steve Novick>One thing I wanted to mention is that I'd like to have a conversation at some point about a whole— the whole concept of things that are allowed as a bonus for doing something else, because I kind of wonder, okay, if something's okay, why is it only okay in this one circumstance as opposed to It's just being okay.

332
00:44:23.610 --> 00:44:28.853
<v Steve Novick>So that's an aspect of your second bullet that I think is worth a broader discussion, actually.

333
00:44:29.746 --> 00:44:30.135
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

334
00:44:34.563 --> 00:44:36.023
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, are you back in the queue?

335
00:44:37.213 --> 00:45:12.507
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am, Chair, because Councilor Novick actually said something that was on my list of thoughts as I was reading through this all, that I figured because he brought it up, I would just mention, which is that the reason that we have bonuses and these allowances right now in our, in our code is to incentivize certain types of development, to incentivize in this project family-sized units and more accessible units and inclusionary housing in units.

336
00:45:12.655 --> 00:45:24.447
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if we start to put all of these pieces into the base, then we do lose our ability to incentivize the type of construction we want.

337
00:45:24.623 --> 00:45:27.835
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And given that there's a push and pull, right?

338
00:45:27.916 --> 00:45:35.876
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The market will develop what there is a market for, what there is a desire for in a perfect market.

339
00:45:36.590 --> 00:46:04.210
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But there's a delay and there are cost pressures and there are Um, gambles on what you might be able to sell when people get desperate enough, or lease when people get desperate enough, that if we want to have the type of housing that I think many of us have talked about needing in our city— that accessible housing, family-sized housing units that really work for the people in our city— we've got to keep some of those, um, those bonuses.

340
00:46:04.307 --> 00:46:05.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

341
00:46:06.039 --> 00:46:06.302
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

342
00:46:09.103 --> 00:46:12.523
<v Mitch Green>Just also, the Planning Commission meeting's next week, I believe.

343
00:46:13.038 --> 00:46:19.010
<v Mitch Green>And so this is the moment that we have to ask publicly if anyone wants to sign it.

344
00:46:19.057 --> 00:46:29.847
<v Mitch Green>And so I don't know, you've expressed some interest maybe potentially signing a little bit later, and you've expressed some interest, Councilor Koyama Lane, of maybe potentially signing it if there's a subtle change.

345
00:46:29.894 --> 00:46:35.217
<v Mitch Green>I don't know how that works in the serial Like a public meetings law if we can't do it here.

346
00:46:35.297 --> 00:46:35.635
<v Mitch Green>And so I—.

347
00:46:35.878 --> 00:46:36.152
<v Steve Novick>It feels—.

348
00:46:36.425 --> 00:46:38.519
<v Candace Avalos>Let me start by asking this to you, Councilor Green, though.

349
00:46:38.826 --> 00:46:49.315
<v Candace Avalos>Um, do you— I would be down with changing the language to just add— hold on, where does it say— to consider adopting 3 critical amendments.

350
00:46:49.396 --> 00:46:52.237
<v Mitch Green>I mean, I'd be comfortable with that if it meant we had more signatories today.

351
00:46:52.478 --> 00:46:56.528
<v Candace Avalos>At a minimum, let's change that because, yeah, we're not trying to force it.

352
00:46:56.594 --> 00:47:00.291
<v Candace Avalos>We are saying that we want them to consider it, but it's not literally saying consider.

353
00:47:00.342 --> 00:47:01.432
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm happy to add that.

354
00:47:02.119 --> 00:47:03.068
<v Candace Avalos>If you feel good with that.

355
00:47:04.032 --> 00:47:04.193
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

356
00:47:04.289 --> 00:47:06.699
<v Candace Avalos>So I just wanted to get that out of the way because that's an easy fix.

357
00:47:06.762 --> 00:47:10.362
<v Candace Avalos>But yeah, like Vice Chair Green said, this is our opportunity.

358
00:47:10.764 --> 00:47:13.318
<v Candace Avalos>You don't have to decide in this moment, I don't believe.

359
00:47:13.527 --> 00:47:18.445
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, I think we're just trying to balance the legal guidance we've been given.

360
00:47:19.681 --> 00:47:25.257
<v Candace Avalos>Would it be like, do you think we could receive the people sign-on later?

361
00:47:25.884 --> 00:47:35.311
<v Mitch Green>I think if everything that We talked about today was what happened in here, then the public has heard all about it and there's no privacy happening.

362
00:47:35.824 --> 00:47:39.766
<v Mitch Green>And then as long as we got it out by tomorrow, I think there's still some timeliness to it.

363
00:47:39.831 --> 00:47:48.324
<v Mitch Green>And so that would— and I just, just to clarify, this is not a committee— this is not a letter of the committee because this is not something we had voted on or doesn't have unanimous consent.

364
00:47:48.467 --> 00:47:52.778
<v Mitch Green>So just to assuage any concerns that it's— it'd be coming from the signatories of the letter, not the committee as a whole.

365
00:47:52.842 --> 00:47:53.018
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

366
00:47:53.849 --> 00:47:54.514
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, yeah.

367
00:47:54.920 --> 00:47:55.990
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, sounds like—.

368
00:47:55.990 --> 00:47:58.878
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So does that mean it will no longer be on committee letterhead?

369
00:47:58.960 --> 00:48:00.728
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because right now it is on committee letterhead.

370
00:48:02.807 --> 00:48:04.219
<v Candace Avalos>Sure, that's fine.

371
00:48:04.445 --> 00:48:05.547
<v Mitch Green>We can take it off committee letterhead.

372
00:48:08.898 --> 00:48:11.114
<v Candace Avalos>All right, well, sounds like we'll get some information.

373
00:48:11.324 --> 00:48:11.403
<v Unidentified speaker>We—.

374
00:48:11.548 --> 00:48:15.436
<v Candace Avalos>People are able to reach out to us offline, and we are going to send it by tomorrow.

375
00:48:15.501 --> 00:48:17.862
<v Candace Avalos>So if you want to sign on, let us know by tomorrow.

376
00:48:18.807 --> 00:48:20.411
<v Candace Avalos>At noon.

377
00:48:21.722 --> 00:48:25.059
<v Candace Avalos>All right, with that, Diego, go ahead and call the next item.

378
00:48:26.757 --> 00:48:31.230
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 3, Regional Housing and Homelessness Strategies: Looking to the Future.

379
00:48:33.101 --> 00:48:34.487
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so come on up.

380
00:48:34.536 --> 00:48:36.518
<v Candace Avalos>Our guests are gonna get seated here.

381
00:48:37.436 --> 00:48:49.806
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so this agenda item is a discussion with our new Metro Council President, Juan Carlos Gonzalez, on the past, present, and future of regional collaboration to address housing affordability and homelessness.

382
00:48:50.369 --> 00:49:04.809
<v Candace Avalos>Over the last decade, our region has made historic investments through the Metro Affordable Housing Bond and the Supportive Housing Services Program, and those investments have created thousands of affordable homes, expanded supportive services, and helped thousands of people access housing and avoid homelessness.

383
00:49:05.291 --> 00:49:08.034
<v Candace Avalos>At the same time, we all know that the work is far from finished.

384
00:49:08.500 --> 00:49:17.338
<v Candace Avalos>Housing costs remain high, homelessness continues to be one of the region's greatest challenges, And communities are asking important questions about results, accountability, and what comes next.

385
00:49:17.882 --> 00:49:22.052
<v Candace Avalos>So today's conversation is an opportunity to take a step back and look at the bigger picture.

386
00:49:22.614 --> 00:49:33.775
<v Candace Avalos>We'll hear about what these regional investments have accomplished, what lessons have been learned, how public perception has evolved, and what it will take for the city and Metro to continue working together to meet this moment.

387
00:49:34.545 --> 00:49:39.628
<v Candace Avalos>As chair of this committee, I think this conversation is especially important because housing affordability and homelessness Mm-hmm.

388
00:49:39.692 --> 00:49:41.186
<v Candace Avalos>Do not stop at the city's boundaries.

389
00:49:41.780 --> 00:49:50.338
<v Candace Avalos>The challenges that we face and the solutions that we pursue require strong partnerships across jurisdictions, along with the shared commitment to delivering results and maintaining the public's trust.

390
00:49:50.514 --> 00:49:59.891
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm really looking forward to discussing how we can continue building on this partnership and how we ensure that future investments are both effective and responsive to the communities that we serve.

391
00:50:00.501 --> 00:50:06.264
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, I'd like to go ahead and welcome Metro Council President Gonzalez, and I I believe this is Andy Shaw.

392
00:50:06.344 --> 00:50:09.951
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, correct, Director of Metro Government Relations, and I'll turn it over to you.

393
00:50:10.416 --> 00:50:10.672
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

394
00:50:11.378 --> 00:50:14.807
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you, Chair Avalos, and hello, committee.

395
00:50:15.706 --> 00:50:25.291
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Just a delight to spend some time with you this afternoon to talk about, like the chair mentioned, one of the most important pressing issues of our region.

396
00:50:26.365 --> 00:50:28.561
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Last time I was here, I spoke with the whole council.

397
00:50:28.610 --> 00:50:30.885
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We were talking about the Future Vision Project.

398
00:50:30.949 --> 00:50:31.543
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It was a lot of fun.

399
00:50:32.007 --> 00:50:38.387
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Since then, you know, won an election, now appointed to be your Metro Council president, and happy to have a 6-month head start in this work.

400
00:50:38.949 --> 00:50:54.882
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I, you know, alongside Andy and the Metro Council, believe that conversations like this are so important, and I think is why Metro exists, because, you know, we're here to solve big problems that no one city or one county can do alone.

401
00:50:54.996 --> 00:51:12.501
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So I'm here today to spark a discussion about how we as elected leaders at Metro in Portland, along with all the other partners in the region, can meet this moment as we look to the next phase of addressing our most pressing and chronic challenges, which are housing affordability and homelessness.

402
00:51:13.190 --> 00:51:19.284
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>My presentation is going to tell a bit of a story— how we got here, where we are, what could be next.

403
00:51:20.309 --> 00:51:26.867
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Then I want to invite all of us to grapple with how we lead in this specific moment that we are in.

404
00:51:28.103 --> 00:51:36.329
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The last 10 years have been a time of great change for the region, and at Metro, we built a department basically overnight for supportive housing services.

405
00:51:36.826 --> 00:51:40.420
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>In homelessness as we implemented a mandate from the region in 2020.

406
00:51:41.094 --> 00:51:45.027
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And Portland is a— the city of Portland, Portland is a critical partner in this work.

407
00:51:45.507 --> 00:51:50.981
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>You know, Portland is the heart of the region, a barometer by which the health of the region is judged.

408
00:51:51.527 --> 00:51:57.208
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>In short, the region needs Portland to succeed to help lift all of us to our full potential.

409
00:51:57.849 --> 00:52:02.054
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So we're grateful for the many ways that we've partnered with Portland, and we know that there's still yet more to come.

410
00:52:02.840 --> 00:52:05.938
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We are in a time of both great potential and deep concern.

411
00:52:06.003 --> 00:52:06.179
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you.

412
00:52:06.998 --> 00:52:11.768
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Which is why this city— which way is this city and the region going to go?

413
00:52:12.378 --> 00:52:15.800
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>What can we control and what do we have to respond to that's beyond our control?

414
00:52:16.474 --> 00:52:22.594
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>What message does it send to our communities and our businesses as well as the broader nation and the globe?

415
00:52:23.317 --> 00:52:25.677
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I look forward to our conversation today as we present.

416
00:52:26.128 --> 00:52:39.762
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We're gonna take any clarifying questions that you have at any point, so just signal to us and we're gonna try and move through this quickly, but it's a rich, substantive presentation, and I'm lucky to be flanked by Andy, who's one of the region's best.

417
00:52:40.340 --> 00:52:41.190
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Slide 2, please.

418
00:52:42.250 --> 00:53:03.885
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So if you will hop into a time machine with me and go not too far back to the mid-2010s, Greater Portland was booming, a darling of the national and international press for our quality of life, Our culture, our balance of urban and nature, employers were moving and growing here.

419
00:53:04.494 --> 00:53:07.699
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But underneath this, there were some very dark clouds.

420
00:53:08.164 --> 00:53:14.240
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Our population was growing quickly, but coming against housing construction that had stalled since the Great Recession.

421
00:53:14.914 --> 00:53:25.641
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And seemingly overnight, working-class people, seniors, people with disabilities, and other vulnerable populations saw their housing security pulled out from under them.

422
00:53:26.606 --> 00:53:37.675
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The seeds for a spike in homelessness, long a concern for Portlanders and Oregonians, were planted, and there was very limited funding for services outside of Portland and Multnomah County.

423
00:53:38.349 --> 00:53:48.728
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>In fact, Washington and Clackamas County had almost zero funding for affordable housing or homeless services before Metro's investments.

424
00:53:49.193 --> 00:53:53.260
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So the city and Multnomah County were primed for a full-blown crisis.

425
00:53:53.956 --> 00:54:04.592
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>By 2015, the problem was becoming more and more acute, enough that the City of Portland declared a housing emergency and the legislature put housing on the top of its agenda for this session.

426
00:54:05.126 --> 00:54:07.596
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It was clear that action was needed.

427
00:54:08.161 --> 00:54:09.887
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So that was our 2010s.

428
00:54:10.715 --> 00:54:11.197
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Next slide.

429
00:54:12.902 --> 00:54:14.932
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And let me tell you, action was taken.

430
00:54:15.400 --> 00:54:18.378
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>In November of 2016, voters in Portland passed Yes.

431
00:54:18.523 --> 00:54:25.235
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The largest ever, largest ever general obligation bond to fund affordable housing.

432
00:54:26.150 --> 00:54:33.715
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We often credit voters for their support, and it's right to thank them for stepping up because we all know that it took a lot of leadership in advance.

433
00:54:34.181 --> 00:54:39.289
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And that leadership came from City Hall, from leaders like Nick Fish, among many others.

434
00:54:39.802 --> 00:54:59.057
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And it came from those outside of these halls too, with groups like the Welcome Home Coalition, Street Roots, and others developing the political will to carry a successful campaign and convince voters to tax ourselves for something that they had never had before, helping their neighbors find stability in order to support a more whole community.

435
00:54:59.655 --> 00:55:05.876
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But even as leaders and advocates celebrated the passage of Portland's housing bond, it was widely known that there was still more to do.

436
00:55:06.043 --> 00:55:06.760
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Next slide, please.

437
00:55:08.920 --> 00:55:14.141
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Because, and we've touched on this, housing and homelessness are not just a City of Portland problem.

438
00:55:14.190 --> 00:55:14.286
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you.

439
00:55:15.077 --> 00:55:19.628
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Once again, leaders and advocates came together to find a similar conclusion.

440
00:55:20.222 --> 00:55:22.418
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>People across the region have been struggling.

441
00:55:23.027 --> 00:55:29.920
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>They shouldn't have to go to Portland to get help, and Portland shouldn't be alone in addressing what is inherently a regional challenge.

442
00:55:30.481 --> 00:55:45.467
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Once again, a combination of inside-outside leadership, electeds, community advocates, business leaders, community leaders, they came together to propose a bold vision for Vote to to the voters for the broader region on change.

443
00:55:46.108 --> 00:56:06.764
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>First, what was at that point the country, the US's largest ever bond for affordable housing, a $652.8 million investment to house neighbors across the region, and also at the same time, a constitutional amendment to make that housing investment go even further.

444
00:56:07.438 --> 00:56:21.536
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Second, a couple of years later, that coalition proposed a supportive housing services measure, at the time estimated to be the nation's largest ever per capita investment in services to build long-term housing stability and also help people escape or avoid homelessness.

445
00:56:22.195 --> 00:56:37.875
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>By placing a marginal income tax on those doing the best in our city, in our region, in times of a booming economy, we could make sure that thousands of people would not get left behind and would get to participate Next slide.

446
00:56:38.052 --> 00:56:51.454
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I was elected to the Metro Council on that same ballot as that housing bond, and it was a time of great optimism and hope, like we were getting a handle on these challenges by investing in locally driven solutions driving towards regional outcomes.

447
00:56:52.442 --> 00:56:52.927
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Next slide.

448
00:56:54.706 --> 00:57:00.338
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I have to admit, I do think the region has delivered on promises of these late 2010 measures.

449
00:57:00.856 --> 00:57:03.103
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>In fact, I think we have more than delivered.

450
00:57:03.760 --> 00:57:26.998
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Together with both bonds, the Portland Housing Bond and the Metro Housing Bond, and our regional partners, we're on track to create more than 7,000 affordable homes across the region, including more than 3,000 family-sized units and nearly 2,700 deeply affordable homes, which was the focus of the Metro Housing Bond.

451
00:57:27.672 --> 00:57:40.778
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>There are a number— there are numbers we could never achieve without the combination of bonds, SHS-funded rental assistance and supportive services, and also a statewide movement to change the Constitution of Oregon.

452
00:57:41.692 --> 00:57:44.416
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>What should be— we should be very proud of these accomplishments.

453
00:57:44.800 --> 00:57:57.746
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>For about $82 a year for the average household, we're talking about well over 15,000 people finding homes and 2,300 jobs supported at an average salary of $92,000.

454
00:57:58.440 --> 00:58:00.228
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>That's a great return on investment.

455
00:58:01.619 --> 00:58:01.893
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Next slide.

456
00:58:03.414 --> 00:58:06.873
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And these impacts have been felt across the region.

457
00:58:07.391 --> 00:58:12.809
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We've been able to combine forces to create affordable homes in communities that have never had them before.

458
00:58:12.956 --> 00:58:22.313
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And in front of you, you see a map that shows the constellation of affordable housing bond investments happening on every single corner of our region.

459
00:58:23.255 --> 00:58:23.728
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Next slide.

460
00:58:25.391 --> 00:58:31.554
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And when you add the incredible, mostly unseen impact of SHS, it's more than doubly so.

461
00:58:32.204 --> 00:58:42.773
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>SHS was launched with the goal of placing and sustaining 5,000 households in permanent supportive housing and helping 10,000 more avoid or end their homelessness.

462
00:58:43.434 --> 00:58:52.697
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Halfway through the program's 10-year lifespan, which we're right now, we're at that halfway point, We've already more than doubled the goals that we had promised voters in 2020.

463
00:58:53.148 --> 00:59:00.806
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Again, we should be very proud of this work and grateful to all the partners who've made it possible in the face of extraordinary challenges.

464
00:59:01.014 --> 00:59:05.608
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Of course, we had a once-in-a-100-years pandemic, let's not forget.

465
00:59:06.253 --> 00:59:07.027
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Next slide, please.

466
00:59:09.137 --> 00:59:14.637
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And at the same time, you know, I'm talking about some of the exceptional successes that the region has faced.

467
00:59:15.353 --> 00:59:21.375
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But I do not ignore also the challenges that we all face.

468
00:59:22.161 --> 00:59:34.572
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And as important as it is for us to celebrate the successes that we've had, I think we have to work even harder to acknowledge that there's so much more to do with these tools and beyond of what they can do.

469
00:59:35.728 --> 00:59:40.047
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The bonds and SHS are truly transformational tools in the Portland region.

470
00:59:40.545 --> 00:59:45.148
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>They are a magic power that other regions have not had, and I think wish they could have.

471
00:59:45.612 --> 00:59:52.507
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>These are resources that cannot be taken away by a regime in DC or legislated away in a budget in Salem.

472
00:59:52.813 --> 00:59:57.302
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>This is our money to address the problems that we've been charged to.

473
00:59:58.119 --> 00:59:59.963
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But they have not kept up with the problem.

474
01:00:00.766 --> 01:00:01.007
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Why?

475
01:00:01.889 --> 01:00:05.400
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Because many things fuel homelessness and housing costs, as you know.

476
01:00:06.074 --> 01:00:10.903
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Some of those things are, are in our control, but many of them, they are not.

477
01:00:11.900 --> 01:00:16.251
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And many have gotten worse during the pandemic and the aftermath of the pandemic.

478
01:00:16.974 --> 01:00:31.311
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We know them all by now: inflation, evictions, layoffs, restructurings, struggling state budgets, the collapse of a safety net that the federal government once provided for those in need.

479
01:00:31.746 --> 01:00:39.335
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And many, many people in our great city, in our great cities in this region, are one misfortune away from the trauma of homelessness.

480
01:00:39.768 --> 01:00:42.815
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I think everyday Oregonians, they understand that.

481
01:00:43.456 --> 01:00:52.440
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>At times we've been— we have not been fully honest with ourselves about the limitations of the tools that we have, or we've placed too much hope or celebration in what they can deliver.

482
01:00:52.905 --> 01:00:59.449
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And yet without them, I believe we would be in a much worse shape than even where we are now.

483
01:00:59.818 --> 01:01:01.309
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So it's critical that we keep going.

484
01:01:02.047 --> 01:01:12.389
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>In the next part of the presentation, we're gonna discuss what it will take to help keep these investments going to the future and what Metro and the Metro Council is prioritizing in this moment.

485
01:01:12.887 --> 01:01:19.539
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So I'm going to hand the mic to Andy Shaw, Metro's Director of Government Affairs and Policy Development.

486
01:01:20.099 --> 01:01:31.016
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>He will begin with what we know about where our voters are, and since they are going to be the ones determining whether these critical funding tools continue.

487
01:01:31.097 --> 01:01:32.090
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So Andy, please.

488
01:01:32.347 --> 01:01:33.373
<v Andy Shaw>Great, thank you, President Gonzalez.

489
01:01:34.126 --> 01:01:36.322
<v Andy Shaw>So again, Andy Shaw, Director of Government Affairs at Metro.

490
01:01:37.094 --> 01:01:43.853
<v Andy Shaw>Metro conducts public opinion polls on a regular basis to understand where— what are our voters' perceptions and concerns.

491
01:01:44.398 --> 01:01:48.686
<v Andy Shaw>It's not the same as engagement, as you were talking about earlier on that earlier item.

492
01:01:49.697 --> 01:01:56.248
<v Andy Shaw>Opinion research really helps the council inform decision-making and how we structure effective communication strategies.

493
01:01:56.362 --> 01:02:01.949
<v Andy Shaw>So I'm going to walk through just a few slides summarizing what we've heard in recent surveys and focus groups.

494
01:02:02.688 --> 01:02:11.068
<v Andy Shaw>I know committee members have been briefed individually on the full suite of results, so glad we got a chance to do that earlier.

495
01:02:11.213 --> 01:02:20.237
<v Andy Shaw>A key thing to note is that voter perception is not always the same as reality, in that data may show improvements, but voters aren't perceiving them.

496
01:02:21.233 --> 01:02:27.351
<v Andy Shaw>This can be frustrating as policymakers when we know the world of good that's coming from public investments.

497
01:02:28.152 --> 01:02:30.431
<v Andy Shaw>But we really need to meet people where they are.

498
01:02:31.025 --> 01:02:38.568
<v Andy Shaw>Convincing folks to believe something different is enormously challenging and quite expensive from just a communications campaign point of view.

499
01:02:39.387 --> 01:02:42.501
<v Andy Shaw>The good news is voters are aligned on some key points.

500
01:02:42.581 --> 01:02:49.547
<v Andy Shaw>First, there's near universal agreement that homelessness, the cost of housing, the cost of living are the region's top concerns.

501
01:02:50.302 --> 01:02:53.496
<v Andy Shaw>And second, nearly 2/3 of voters, as you see on this slide, Aye.

502
01:02:53.835 --> 01:02:57.686
<v Andy Shaw>Agree that public funding is necessary to help alleviate the crisis.

503
01:02:57.815 --> 01:02:58.755
<v Andy Shaw>If you could just go to the next slide.

504
01:03:01.059 --> 01:03:04.297
<v Andy Shaw>So a lot of policy discussions about housing get into the weeds.

505
01:03:04.652 --> 01:03:08.992
<v Andy Shaw>You were, you were talking about FAR earlier, all really important conversations.

506
01:03:10.072 --> 01:03:11.413
<v Andy Shaw>What's the right policy approach?

507
01:03:11.606 --> 01:03:12.706
<v Andy Shaw>What's the right financing model?

508
01:03:12.804 --> 01:03:13.983
<v Andy Shaw>What's the best philosophy to bring?

509
01:03:14.661 --> 01:03:16.262
<v Andy Shaw>This is not where voters start.

510
01:03:16.360 --> 01:03:24.342
<v Andy Shaw>This is not where they spend their time thinking about the challenges are worrying about things that you are legitimately worrying about.

511
01:03:25.143 --> 01:03:32.050
<v Andy Shaw>And the results on these slides and the next one are pretty similar to work we've done across issues at Metro.

512
01:03:32.594 --> 01:03:44.197
<v Andy Shaw>When it comes to how potential funding is spent, voters value housing for people such as older adults living on fixed incomes, veterans, low-income individuals, low-income families.

513
01:03:44.726 --> 01:03:49.751
<v Andy Shaw>It's not the process It's not the philosophy or approach that they're thinking about on a daily basis.

514
01:03:49.943 --> 01:03:52.561
<v Andy Shaw>So it's not how they respond to a funding proposal.

515
01:03:53.541 --> 01:04:03.369
<v Andy Shaw>Beyond that, voters tell us they're most concerned with taking care of what we've built first, and then thinking about that housing being relied upon for a very, very long time.

516
01:04:03.514 --> 01:04:09.168
<v Andy Shaw>If we go to the next slide, this is a continuation of some of these areas of interest.

517
01:04:09.938 --> 01:04:15.668
<v Andy Shaw>So you can see as these go down, voters spend far less time thinking about specific policies or approaches.

518
01:04:16.501 --> 01:04:25.418
<v Andy Shaw>They might be familiar with a local affordable housing project in their area or a shelter site, but it's just not something they're concerning themselves on a day-to-day basis.

519
01:04:25.481 --> 01:04:29.331
<v Andy Shaw>And so it's not something they react to when we approach them with a proposal.

520
01:04:30.117 --> 01:04:44.143
<v Andy Shaw>This slide is from the same January poll on a theoretical affordable housing bond, and more or less every specific example of how funding might be Rates as less important to most voters than who you're serving and what outcomes you're achieving.

521
01:04:45.235 --> 01:04:50.809
<v Andy Shaw>So approaches that we all discuss regularly are just not things that voters are necessarily engaging with daily.

522
01:04:51.659 --> 01:04:58.840
<v Andy Shaw>So we really feel like we need to focus in on describing and demonstrating who our efforts are serving and not how we're serving them.

523
01:04:59.353 --> 01:05:01.056
<v Andy Shaw>Next slide.

524
01:05:01.105 --> 01:05:18.273
<v Andy Shaw>For the harder news, you all know, I think, that Metro spent the greater portion of 18 months recently exploring a potential measure to extend the Supportive Housing Services Program, including strengthening accountability and having a more clear tie to funding for affordable housing.

525
01:05:18.949 --> 01:05:26.063
<v Andy Shaw>At our council's direction, we're now exploring potential ways to continue affordable housing funding through a new affordable housing bond.

526
01:05:26.641 --> 01:05:32.728
<v Andy Shaw>We've seen, though, a lot of headwinds when we looked closer at the potential for both of these ideas, both an extension and a bond.

527
01:05:33.675 --> 01:05:39.108
<v Andy Shaw>A key reason is the growing skepticism voters have about whether our approaches are working as described.

528
01:05:39.670 --> 01:05:44.173
<v Andy Shaw>And that's the red line that you see on this chart that's going up over a series of polls.

529
01:05:44.222 --> 01:05:49.403
<v Andy Shaw>I think we started asking this question, do you not believe something's happening, back in 2023.

530
01:05:50.032 --> 01:05:55.637
<v Andy Shaw>We were getting some strange results and so started adding this question in and have been surprised to see it grow over time.

531
01:05:57.606 --> 01:05:59.081
<v Andy Shaw>It's specifically about SHS.

532
01:05:59.269 --> 01:05:59.318
<v Andy Shaw>Yes.

533
01:05:59.365 --> 01:06:02.289
<v Andy Shaw>But it applies to the broader question of housing funding as well.

534
01:06:02.916 --> 01:06:09.440
<v Andy Shaw>So recent focus groups that we conducted specifically to dive in on some of these questions helped illustrate why voters feel this way.

535
01:06:10.052 --> 01:06:21.525
<v Andy Shaw>Even when presented with data about successes in both programs and about benefits in investments, there's a skepticism because they're seeing something different out on the street or hearing something different in their community.

536
01:06:22.295 --> 01:06:35.260
<v Andy Shaw>So frustration is that main reason that we're getting this skepticism, largely what people are seeing in their own— with their own eyes, as well as the drumbeat of headlines and social media that confirm their existing worries and fears.

537
01:06:36.239 --> 01:06:46.503
<v Andy Shaw>And again, we can't expect voters to be experts in all the things that are contributing to homelessness and suffering in our communities, but it makes them far less likely to believe that anything's working.

538
01:06:47.163 --> 01:06:57.985
<v Andy Shaw>So when you combine that with the increasingly precarious financial situation that many voters find themselves in, Voters are even more reluctant to approve new or extended taxes to fund these programs.

539
01:06:58.659 --> 01:07:04.615
<v Andy Shaw>Having said that, when we push on it, most voters would rather continue investing than let it all go away.

540
01:07:05.242 --> 01:07:15.965
<v Andy Shaw>They're telling us we need to be more accountable and transparent, but fundamentally, they tell us they won't believe things are getting better until they see it themselves in their community or they're hearing that from their neighbors.

541
01:07:17.201 --> 01:07:20.474
<v Andy Shaw>Connecting with voters can be quite challenging and expensive.

542
01:07:21.293 --> 01:07:25.458
<v Andy Shaw>But I'm going to hand it back to Council President now to talk about some potential further steps.

543
01:07:26.179 --> 01:07:27.110
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you, Andy.

544
01:07:27.782 --> 01:07:31.916
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>All right, we're in the home stretch here, and then we can have a robust conversation.

545
01:07:32.012 --> 01:07:32.925
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you again, committee.

546
01:07:33.775 --> 01:07:38.630
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So to sum up, voters know that this is a problem that we cannot stop working on.

547
01:07:38.983 --> 01:07:42.974
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>They want to help their neighbors live dignified, affordable lives here in our region.

548
01:07:43.887 --> 01:07:46.755
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Majorities are potentially still willing to invest.

549
01:07:47.331 --> 01:07:50.152
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But they're placing the bar much higher than ever before.

550
01:07:51.001 --> 01:07:57.315
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>A key reason, they aren't sure that government has the same commitment or focus that they do on the problem.

551
01:07:57.827 --> 01:08:04.398
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>A point that Metra heard in recent focus groups was that voters are tired of hearing only bad news about local government.

552
01:08:04.943 --> 01:08:10.070
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And when they hear one news about one local government, they think it applies to all local government.

553
01:08:10.150 --> 01:08:13.498
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>They're not necessarily discerning between layers or jurisdictions.

554
01:08:14.157 --> 01:08:16.101
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So what can we do to change the narrative?

555
01:08:16.181 --> 01:08:28.119
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think that is the question that we need to be asking ourselves because, and I'm guilty of this, it's more than glowing social media tooting our horn about openings and numbers on dashboards, though we do need to share our successes.

556
01:08:28.554 --> 01:08:35.109
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Those kind of stories are more— they're mostly about shoring up people who already believe that our approach is working.

557
01:08:35.703 --> 01:08:39.929
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So we want to, we need to broaden support for continuing these vital funding sources.

558
01:08:40.283 --> 01:08:47.203
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And that means that every day we have to demonstrate focus on what people are telling us they care about most, and that's their neighbors.

559
01:08:49.409 --> 01:08:51.069
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So next slide, I think.

560
01:08:52.631 --> 01:08:53.966
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think that we should get caught trying.

561
01:08:55.149 --> 01:09:00.060
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Let's get caught collaborating to improve our systems and to deliver on the opportunities before us.

562
01:09:00.720 --> 01:09:06.002
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Let's ensure that our affordable housing investments are as stable and as reliable as possible.

563
01:09:06.621 --> 01:09:16.934
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>In Portland, this means working across every bureaucracy and community group to deliver big opportunities and community-driven visions like the Albina Vision Trust and the OMSI District.

564
01:09:17.399 --> 01:09:31.914
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It also means broad results, doing all we can to increase the creation of housing across the board, not the kind of stuff that gets big headlines and groundbreakings, but the honest day-to-day work that will make the difference more lasting and more broad-based.

565
01:09:32.555 --> 01:09:38.280
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think on communication, it means using our limited resources in new ways, First, we must meet people where they are.

566
01:09:38.795 --> 01:09:44.881
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We must acknowledge frustration and connect to the real emotion and experience that Portlanders are living with.

567
01:09:45.314 --> 01:09:48.735
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And that also connects our personal experiences and those of our neighbors.

568
01:09:49.331 --> 01:09:54.550
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We can't be afraid to be real with people because in reality, I think that's the only way to connect.

569
01:09:55.256 --> 01:10:03.030
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And we need to boost coordination of how we deliver messages across all of our governments from the constellations of messengers we have today Thank you.

570
01:10:03.159 --> 01:10:04.938
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Or something more like a single movement.

571
01:10:05.470 --> 01:10:12.148
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It was the singularity of purpose and message that delivered the Portland and the Metro housing bonds, and then ultimately SHS.

572
01:10:12.845 --> 01:10:18.411
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So I think it's time to develop and spread connective messages that resonate and resound across the region.

573
01:10:19.210 --> 01:10:20.414
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So last slide here.

574
01:10:23.430 --> 01:10:26.146
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Here is what Metro is doing as we look to the future.

575
01:10:27.025 --> 01:10:32.841
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Above all, we are working to continue to deliver The benefits of the investments that voters have entrusted us with.

576
01:10:33.661 --> 01:10:41.365
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thousands of families will have a safe and stable home tonight, thanks to what voters have chosen to create with these programs.

577
01:10:41.912 --> 01:10:46.215
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We honor that choice and its potential when we deliver results with competence and with compassion.

578
01:10:46.969 --> 01:10:52.298
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I believe that together we are doing a great job at this, though, as I've said, there is still so much more to do.

579
01:10:53.293 --> 01:10:59.715
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We don't believe that a future bond or SHS extension measure is going to look exactly like what we built in the past.

580
01:11:00.292 --> 01:11:06.667
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Those measures were built for a different time, and as we've discussed, the region and that context have moved on.

581
01:11:07.582 --> 01:11:15.673
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Our staff is undertaking a big look at the impacts and lessons learned from the implementation of these bonds, as well as the evolving nature of need and service delivery.

582
01:11:16.412 --> 01:11:27.826
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Again, it's less fun than new openings and projects, but we are working with our public and provider partners to explore every angle that we can to make sure we ensure system performance, stability, and resilience for decades to come.

583
01:11:28.467 --> 01:11:33.472
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>There are also new ideas and opportunities emerging that we are going to be looking a little bit deeper into.

584
01:11:34.226 --> 01:11:45.552
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We need to find ways to build more sustainable financial models to make sure that affordable housing delivers where the need is greatest today and for the long term.

585
01:11:46.259 --> 01:11:52.211
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I know that Portland's brilliant staff are also going to dig into this, as are many other partners across the region.

586
01:11:52.612 --> 01:11:58.355
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But ultimately, the details aren't where most voters will find their reasons for supporting continued investment.

587
01:11:58.868 --> 01:12:01.323
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>That's where I believe that we as elected officials come in.

588
01:12:01.917 --> 01:12:09.586
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We have to embody the collaboration that demonstrates our focus on these problems while also holding ourselves to the highest standard of accountability.

589
01:12:10.340 --> 01:12:16.805
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It's not whether my government is doing better or your government is doing better or another government is doing better.

590
01:12:17.238 --> 01:12:22.337
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>When we point fingers, Voters don't really see a difference between levels and layers of government.

591
01:12:22.689 --> 01:12:29.197
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Instead, we have to acknowledge our challenges, admit our struggles, and show that together we're fighting to set things right.

592
01:12:29.261 --> 01:12:34.278
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Because if we appear divided, uncoordinated, and unfocused, we will all fail.

593
01:12:35.655 --> 01:12:51.002
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>There's one— that's one reason we're reforming our approach with the Regional Policy Oversight Committee, the new Supportive Housing Services Oversight Group, introducing new clear metrics and goals that will set our collective regional sights and hold ourselves accountable for reaching them.

594
01:12:51.707 --> 01:13:04.194
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And finally, Metro is working to invest in broader messengers and tools for sharing this work with a public that we know is desperate for reasons for hope about the future of the city and the region that we love.

595
01:13:04.853 --> 01:13:07.645
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So we're gonna be partnering with anyone and everyone that is willing.

596
01:13:08.238 --> 01:13:12.059
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And with that, Council, one more slide actually, sorry.

597
01:13:12.430 --> 01:13:13.225
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you.

598
01:13:14.198 --> 01:13:22.412
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Lastly, we should not feel daunted, even worried about whether we can continue and build on the success that we've had.

599
01:13:22.961 --> 01:13:30.305
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Let's not run from that concern, but instead see it as a fuel to reach for the kind of leadership that envisioned, shaped, and delivered the measures of the past.

600
01:13:30.789 --> 01:13:38.496
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Metro and the city are not alone in that discussion, but we are 2 governments in the region with the potential to reach hundreds of thousands of people.

601
01:13:39.096 --> 01:13:45.768
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We also together share in both the responsibilities and the successes of many of the investments we've made and what we could make in the future.

602
01:13:46.313 --> 01:13:50.787
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>As we shift to this discussion, I'm going to urge us to stay out of the policy weeds.

603
01:13:50.899 --> 01:13:56.706
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think that conversation should be for another day and for our expert staff to help us inform.

604
01:13:57.458 --> 01:14:08.190
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I would love for us to focus on what we're demonstrating as leaders charged by our voters with progress, with some good leadership, So as elected leaders, my question: how can we be better?

605
01:14:08.367 --> 01:14:16.967
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>How can we show better collaboration to build and sustain support for these investments that will benefit this city and communities across the region today and for decades to come?

606
01:14:17.770 --> 01:14:25.569
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And what voices, partnerships, and perspectives should we bring into this conversation to boost, to boost our shared understanding and improve that outlook?

607
01:14:26.018 --> 01:14:28.729
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think we've shared some ideas, but I really want to hear yours.

608
01:14:29.243 --> 01:14:31.682
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And thank you for, uh, continuing to lean into our partnership.

609
01:14:31.730 --> 01:14:31.859
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you.

610
01:14:33.640 --> 01:14:34.603
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Chair Avalos, to you.

611
01:14:35.822 --> 01:14:36.270
<v Candace Avalos>Gracias.

612
01:14:37.088 --> 01:14:41.131
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, thank you so much for being here, so much for that presentation as well.

613
01:14:41.421 --> 01:14:46.618
<v Candace Avalos>And, um, just committee, so you have a little bit more of why I wanted to do this.

614
01:14:46.731 --> 01:14:52.811
<v Candace Avalos>I think what this presentation showed us, uh, one, we cannot solve this alone, as you said.

615
01:14:52.908 --> 01:14:58.988
<v Candace Avalos>And so this was an opportunity since we were already getting briefed on the information to kind of just Bring it to the public.

616
01:14:59.405 --> 01:15:02.421
<v Candace Avalos>And I really like what you said, uh, let's get caught trying.

617
01:15:02.599 --> 01:15:07.300
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, that really stuck with me because I think that's part of the, the point here.

618
01:15:07.507 --> 01:15:13.989
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's the concept I'm trying to bring forward, is that what we're seeing in the polling is that people, they just don't trust us.

619
01:15:14.086 --> 01:15:15.273
<v Candace Avalos>They don't believe us.

620
01:15:15.914 --> 01:15:21.113
<v Candace Avalos>And we can point to all of our success, we can point to all the numbers, and that clearly is not working.

621
01:15:21.690 --> 01:15:23.583
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, but I think us being Thank you.

622
01:15:23.632 --> 01:15:24.452
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's a really important point.

623
01:15:24.500 --> 01:15:37.738
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that us being honest about the challenges, us being honest about like looking at this feedback and saying, yeah, this is hard feedback for us to take and we need to take it seriously, and having that conversation in public to just start to build some of that trust.

624
01:15:37.836 --> 01:15:57.336
<v Candace Avalos>Obviously, this one conversation is not going to build back all the trust, but this is an attempt to start figuring out how we are working together in public to kind of dispel some of those fears that people have that we're, you know, we're not working together, we're not, you know, trying, or we're not looking for solutions.

625
01:15:58.091 --> 01:16:10.823
<v Candace Avalos>And so this is a communications issue, it's a narrative issue, it's helping to process or describe what these wins mean, what these investments mean to the public.

626
01:16:11.256 --> 01:16:14.484
<v Candace Avalos>And so again, this is just kind of an intro conversation.

627
01:16:14.548 --> 01:16:18.981
<v Candace Avalos>It is definitely my intent over the coming months to keep doing this and figuring out other ways.

628
01:16:19.046 --> 01:16:28.587
<v Candace Avalos>And I think part of it too is that I'm sure we all get tugged in all kinds of directions from various community groups or elected leaders who are like, let's talk about it, let's figure out a plan.

629
01:16:28.988 --> 01:16:35.798
<v Candace Avalos>And so I'm just trying to figure out, okay, as Portland, you know, we are the biggest city, we are a leader here, and we need to show that we're leading.

630
01:16:36.216 --> 01:16:37.051
<v Candace Avalos>How are we doing that?

631
01:16:37.115 --> 01:16:49.319
<v Candace Avalos>By saying we're going to convene these conversations, we're going to put this out in the public, Be honest about what voters are, um, are seeing from us, and, um, just be transparent, uh, about our intentions to fix that.

632
01:16:49.399 --> 01:16:51.530
<v Candace Avalos>So that's the, the goal for today.

633
01:16:51.707 --> 01:16:53.550
<v Candace Avalos>It is obviously very open-ended.

634
01:16:54.015 --> 01:16:59.606
<v Candace Avalos>Um, we have, you know, these questions that are up on the screen, um, to kind of guide the conversation.

635
01:17:00.039 --> 01:17:12.095
<v Candace Avalos>But again, just wanted this to be a chance for all of us as policymakers to, um, talk openly about, you know, some opportunities that we have to continue building Portlanders, uh, and frankly the region's trust.

636
01:17:12.336 --> 01:17:17.766
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, I will, uh, open it up to some discussion.

637
01:17:17.944 --> 01:17:22.341
<v Candace Avalos>Um, maybe we can put those questions back up, or I guess they're, they're up on our screens.

638
01:17:22.470 --> 01:17:22.713
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

639
01:17:23.279 --> 01:17:32.057
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so the questions again: how can collaboration between Metro and the city build and sustain support for continued regional investment in affordable housing and supportive services?

640
01:17:32.493 --> 01:17:37.403
<v Candace Avalos>And what voices, partnerships, and perspectives can broaden our shared understanding and improve our outlook of success?

641
01:17:37.498 --> 01:17:39.055
<v Candace Avalos>You don't need to feel limited to those questions.

642
01:17:39.104 --> 01:17:40.868
<v Candace Avalos>Those are just to kind of get the conversation started.

643
01:17:41.734 --> 01:17:43.805
<v Candace Avalos>Kick it off, Vice Chair Green.

644
01:17:44.560 --> 01:17:45.844
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much, Chair Avalos.

645
01:17:45.923 --> 01:17:50.947
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much, Council President, for, I think, recognizing the moment that we're in.

646
01:17:52.262 --> 01:18:10.501
<v Mitch Green>I think at least for a year now, I have felt this kind of lurking anxiety that, you know, you hear from voters, you hear from the press about what voters think, and then you hear from voters about what those other voters think, and it all kind of points It's the same direction that, like, if you put this thing up tomorrow, it's not clear people would say yes again.

647
01:18:11.872 --> 01:18:15.493
<v Mitch Green>And I actually feel that across all of our policy areas.

648
01:18:15.591 --> 01:18:24.042
<v Mitch Green>But for me, it's really about SHS and the next housing bond because that is at the crux of so much of— I mean, it's the top issue for Portlanders.

649
01:18:24.171 --> 01:18:24.524
<v Unidentified speaker>Mm-hmm.

650
01:18:24.797 --> 01:18:31.844
<v Mitch Green>And so I really appreciate the polling that y'all did, but also making sure that we understood that polling in depth in our office.

651
01:18:32.436 --> 01:18:37.056
<v Mitch Green>I just got my brief like right before this committee meeting, but I'd been hearing about it.

652
01:18:38.387 --> 01:18:42.510
<v Mitch Green>But then also taking that next step to say, let's have this conversation together.

653
01:18:42.798 --> 01:19:05.265
<v Mitch Green>Let's be a little bit vulnerable here because the top-line result that I took away from the rather depressing set of polling data was that it's not that Portlanders don't recognize we need to spend public dollars on supporting affordable housing and It's that they just don't have any confidence that we'll hold ourselves accountable when we do it.

654
01:19:06.170 --> 01:19:18.536
<v Mitch Green>And my feeling has always been that the only way to cure that is to be radically transparent, is to say, hey, here are the missteps that we've had, how can we cure that?

655
01:19:19.670 --> 01:19:25.518
<v Mitch Green>Lay our cards on the table and say, you know, this approach we took in the past, well-intentioned, didn't quite work out as we planned.

656
01:19:25.634 --> 01:19:25.963
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a good point.

657
01:19:26.171 --> 01:19:26.636
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

658
01:19:26.893 --> 01:19:30.547
<v Mitch Green>But here are some interesting new ways we're thinking about doing this, and come along with us.

659
01:19:30.659 --> 01:19:34.922
<v Mitch Green>So this idea of like, let's get caught trying, I think applies in a lot of different ways.

660
01:19:35.307 --> 01:19:48.500
<v Mitch Green>I think when you— if you look back at periods of American history where people had a lot of faith in the administrative state and the administrative capacity of our governments, it was during a period where we were trying a lot of stuff to address like the Great Depression.

661
01:19:49.957 --> 01:20:12.706
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, this isn't at that scale, and we have limited tools at local level, But to address your questions, Council President, I think it would be really interesting for voters to see fairly frequent work sessions perhaps between our governments to have informal conversations that are all publicly noticed to say, hey, here is something that my office is working on or here is something this committee is working on.

662
01:20:13.458 --> 01:20:19.679
<v Mitch Green>We think there might be some legs here, but we, as Portland being the largest jurisdiction in the region, we want to make sure we are rowing in the same direction.

663
01:20:20.578 --> 01:20:35.735
<v Mitch Green>And vice versa, because I do think that this is a regional problem that we're dealing with, and Portland can adopt any number of policies it wants to adopt to solve this issue, but it won't work if we don't have the rest of our regional partners at least kind of not working against us.

664
01:20:36.250 --> 01:20:37.502
<v Mitch Green>And that's true in reverse.

665
01:20:38.112 --> 01:20:55.667
<v Mitch Green>So I think it takes time, it takes resources for us to kind of make time of our schedules to go have those work sessions, but You know, something more elevated from a fireside chat could go a long way to, you know, broadcasting to Portlanders to say, these are what your elected officials are talking about right now.

666
01:20:55.796 --> 01:20:56.868
<v Mitch Green>This is their highest priority.

667
01:20:57.030 --> 01:20:59.157
<v Mitch Green>And by the way, it's connected to your highest priority.

668
01:20:59.302 --> 01:21:00.471
<v Mitch Green>I think that's step one.

669
01:21:02.010 --> 01:21:06.074
<v Mitch Green>The other piece I want us to think about, and I know that you don't want us to get too deep in the policy weeds, but I can't—.

670
01:21:06.074 --> 01:21:06.396
<v Mitch Green>Go ahead.

671
01:21:06.622 --> 01:21:07.527
<v Mitch Green>I cannot help myself.

672
01:21:08.655 --> 01:21:28.877
<v Mitch Green>If you look at the data today on rent If you look at rents across all qualities of the housing stock, whether they are affordable housing or they are market rate, and you look at wages, with the exception of the first 2 deciles of the income distribution, we are in a position where housing is relatively affordable, but it won't stay that way.

673
01:21:29.265 --> 01:21:31.998
<v Mitch Green>And so the idea of being here, we have a soft rent period.

674
01:21:32.484 --> 01:21:40.172
<v Mitch Green>So if we're thinking differently, we're thinking about opportunities to provide that long-term affordability that's That those respondents said is one of their highest priorities.

675
01:21:41.722 --> 01:21:58.235
<v Mitch Green>And to support what we have, we might want to contemplate acquisitions of those to then transfer from the private market into some semblance of the non-private sector to say we are securing this while it's on sale and we are doing this together as a region.

676
01:21:58.283 --> 01:22:11.564
<v Mitch Green>So having a conversation about maybe spending our money in that kind of a way, we might— it'd be interesting to see how voters might respond to the formation of that type of exploratory thinking to say, actually, I might support that instead of new housing production.

677
01:22:11.612 --> 01:22:14.213
<v Mitch Green>So a couple quick reactions to this.

678
01:22:15.225 --> 01:22:18.519
<v Mitch Green>Really looking forward to the conversation we're going to have up here today.

679
01:22:18.662 --> 01:22:26.886
<v Mitch Green>And I don't know if you want, like, I don't know how you— do you want to jump in at any point and respond, or is it kind of like we all get in the queue and we do it that way?

680
01:22:27.738 --> 01:22:29.618
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I think very open-ended.

681
01:22:29.681 --> 01:22:31.899
<v Candace Avalos>So I think Metro President, if you want to react.

682
01:22:32.653 --> 01:22:34.673
<v Candace Avalos>Anything any, any of us say, I say go for it.

683
01:22:34.738 --> 01:22:37.207
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, I think— thank you, Chair Avalos, so gracious.

684
01:22:37.529 --> 01:22:39.358
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Uh, I, I agree, uh, Councilor Green.

685
01:22:40.015 --> 01:22:45.309
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, on the, on the acquisition side, the Metro Bond, uh, had a, a few pilots.

686
01:22:45.404 --> 01:22:47.939
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We had a regional land banking acquisition fund.

687
01:22:48.596 --> 01:22:57.194
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Uh, we know that there's a, a pretty extraordinary size of affordable housing stock that is expiring or it's losing its affordability credits.

688
01:22:57.819 --> 01:23:03.807
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Uh, we, we— this region does not have remotely the scale of tools to even keep what is affordable affordable.

689
01:23:04.481 --> 01:23:16.427
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And, and then on top of that, I think there is an opportunity to look at, you know, fire sale real estate or something like that to, to what you're— I think those tools are all under the umbrella of what should we be exploring.

690
01:23:16.604 --> 01:23:18.113
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Andy, I'm not sure if you want to add anything.

691
01:23:19.189 --> 01:23:19.399
<v Candace Avalos>It is—.

692
01:23:19.735 --> 01:23:30.684
<v Andy Shaw>Acquisition is the tool we have used, and, um, it, uh, it has resonated more with voters in, in recent polls that we've done, just because there's a sense of using what we have, sort of going back to basics.

693
01:23:31.293 --> 01:23:36.814
<v Andy Shaw>Um, it— again, the, the mechanism is not what motivates folks, the, the people we're serving.

694
01:23:37.024 --> 01:23:39.735
<v Andy Shaw>So connecting it in with, uh, who— that—.

695
01:23:39.735 --> 01:23:39.832
<v Andy Shaw>Who—.

696
01:23:39.961 --> 01:23:47.970
<v Andy Shaw>What kind of folks that might serve in the community, um, I think strengthens the messaging around, uh, a new tool, a different tool, or leaning into a space.

697
01:23:49.029 --> 01:24:02.746
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that because I think that these numbers If they then wait 6 months down the road, once a lot of these providers start to fail and we get these balance sheets start to fail, like, you take that experience and connect to this, and I think we're in a much worse place.

698
01:24:02.795 --> 01:24:07.625
<v Mitch Green>So that's kind of also what I'm anticipating is like shoring up and preserving and kind of holding what we have.

699
01:24:08.206 --> 01:24:09.400
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yes, brilliant.

700
01:24:11.596 --> 01:24:11.871
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

701
01:24:12.015 --> 01:24:12.984
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

702
01:24:14.421 --> 01:24:19.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Council President and Andy, for being here.

703
01:24:19.279 --> 01:24:26.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for being here today and sharing this with us, but also with Portlanders who are, who are watching today.

704
01:24:28.180 --> 01:24:44.717
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, as I was watching the presentation, I was thinking about our collective work on the Future Vision Committee and just the, the way that affordability has stood out in some of the feedback that we've gotten from Portlanders.

705
01:24:44.899 --> 01:24:45.108
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

706
01:24:45.171 --> 01:24:56.733
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm really excited about the work that Portlander is there, right, building this robust community with all of the things people love about our region, all of the assets people want close by in an affordable way.

707
01:24:57.520 --> 01:25:08.519
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the fact that this work, this tangible work, is what will drive some of the realization of the visions that we know members of our community have.

708
01:25:09.481 --> 01:25:25.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And You know, seeing the numbers that show that people are ready to figure out the next step in helping our neighbors, but aren't ready for us to take that on yet, is a hard juxtaposition to figure out how do we get there.

709
01:25:28.425 --> 01:25:47.259
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it occurred to me as I was thinking about the fact that we hit double our goals and people still We need to figure out how to talk about the fact that it is working, and yet simultaneously it is not fixing the problem.

710
01:25:48.515 --> 01:26:08.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And how do we tell folks, yes, it is working in that we're hitting double our goals, we are doing meaningful work, while validating their very legitimate concerns and concerns about the astute perception that it is not fixing the problem because the problem keeps growing.

711
01:26:09.518 --> 01:26:15.132
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that feels like part of our collective challenge, right?

712
01:26:15.197 --> 01:26:25.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ensuring folks feel heard and seen around the fact that it's not fixing the problem, but separating that from whether we are meeting our goals and the solutions are working.

713
01:26:26.306 --> 01:26:26.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just—.

714
01:26:26.795 --> 01:26:26.942
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

715
01:26:27.546 --> 01:26:29.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wanted to offer that up.

716
01:26:31.640 --> 01:26:49.969
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am— well, I'll also say before I move on to the question I have, when you ask how we work together to meet this moment, I think Metro is in many ways how we work together to meet this moment.

717
01:26:50.050 --> 01:26:50.212
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mm-hmm.

718
01:26:50.666 --> 01:26:50.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right?

719
01:26:51.006 --> 01:26:54.752
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've formed an entity that is a convener.

720
01:26:55.121 --> 01:27:04.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Metro, at your best, is not another layer in the work, but is a convener of all parts of the region to make sure that we're in this work together.

721
01:27:05.003 --> 01:27:10.073
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I also think that telling that story is part of what we need to do collectively.

722
01:27:10.217 --> 01:27:23.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think about half of the councilors at the City of Portland sit on one of the Metro committees or commissions and/or advisory boards.

723
01:27:23.925 --> 01:27:39.087
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And how do we make sure that we are telling the story of the collaborative work that we're doing in those positions with all of you and with our colleagues, leaders from cities and counties around the region, on a whole number of different topics, right?

724
01:27:39.135 --> 01:27:40.372
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not just housing.

725
01:27:41.351 --> 01:27:56.328
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To help tell the story that we can work together, that it's not just the the fights between the city and the county that folks see in the paper here in Portland and the fights between other cities and counties in other parts of the region as well.

726
01:27:58.055 --> 01:28:01.152
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To that end, I do have 2 questions.

727
01:28:01.216 --> 01:28:27.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is, I'm assuming that as this has been rolled out, we are well behind a rollout to RPAC, to the Regional Policy And I'm wondering what the reception has been there, or if that's not the right committee, if it's a different group within Metro that has been looking at this, and how it's been received in those rooms where there are representatives from cities and counties across the region.

728
01:28:30.015 --> 01:28:31.104
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you, Councilor.

729
01:28:31.706 --> 01:28:36.175
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Just to understand your question, you mean like the general tenor of this presentation to ARPAQ?

730
01:28:36.759 --> 01:28:40.032
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would say less the presentation and more the reality of the facts.

731
01:28:40.627 --> 01:28:55.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The fact that voters, that our residents, even beyond folks who are voting, are skeptical of the work and yet still hold the values.

732
01:28:56.277 --> 01:28:57.500
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, yeah.

733
01:28:57.742 --> 01:29:04.673
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think we haven't had the time with ARPAWOC yet to have a kind of conversation like this.

734
01:29:04.887 --> 01:29:15.336
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I mean, we've been razor-focused at establishing really, really intentional and aggressive goals and really taking the measure into the 2.0 phase.

735
01:29:16.472 --> 01:29:30.863
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>That being said, a lot of the people around the table and around the SHS measure have been a part of multiple tables that Metro set over the last 18 months that was asking some really deep questions around the region's SHS system.

736
01:29:31.376 --> 01:29:37.841
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>You know, how do we make it truly regional rather than 3 siloed county systems that are kind of operating under an umbrella?

737
01:29:38.547 --> 01:29:52.282
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Some of those limitations and barriers to regionalization are baked into the language that the voters adopted and cannot be changed without a change from the voters, which kind of urged us to explore this question.

738
01:29:53.131 --> 01:29:56.822
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So we have had explored this general Yeah.

739
01:29:57.367 --> 01:30:02.798
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>You know, public attitude and also the need for us to be more urgent in our reforms and our accountability.

740
01:30:03.712 --> 01:30:08.454
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But we ultimately determined that a path to the voters is not viable.

741
01:30:09.144 --> 01:30:17.588
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And instead, what I heard really clearly as a policymaker was, don't ask me for more money until, like, you do harder work on what we've already given you.

742
01:30:18.134 --> 01:30:26.702
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So we've used that animus to kind of re— Reorient the entire attitude of the measure.

743
01:30:26.798 --> 01:30:28.854
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We had 2 different oversight committees, now we have one.

744
01:30:29.452 --> 01:30:32.252
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It's been a lot of really deep work on that front.

745
01:30:32.300 --> 01:30:47.810
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So to answer your question, I think people understand, but it's going to be another major step that that committee needs to take when we step into a deeper policy development and just try and be less ambiguous.

746
01:30:48.213 --> 01:30:57.140
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Right now, the goal of the ARPOC is to make sure that we're implementing the measure to its highest and best use without necessarily asking them to think about what are we building for the future.

747
01:30:57.315 --> 01:31:02.172
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>They will contribute to that, but right now we really need to do more with what we have.

748
01:31:03.311 --> 01:31:03.520
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Heard.

749
01:31:03.568 --> 01:31:11.648
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I appreciate hearing— I know this has been happening, but hearing about the work to think about in the future.

750
01:31:11.728 --> 01:31:18.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Obviously, we need to sit with the measure we have right now, but in the future, how do we create that more regional approach?

751
01:31:18.079 --> 01:31:38.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think a regional approach that doesn't just rely on 3 buckets that look different in different counties, but that also looks at how our counties and our cities and Metro provide services in a, in a seamless way, and how we make sure that the measure supports that seamless work across all bodies within the region but toward a singular goal.

752
01:31:39.498 --> 01:31:40.060
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, I agree.

753
01:31:40.157 --> 01:32:03.034
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>One of the things that our region has not had the ability to form since the creation of SHS, and actually something that I think we do very well in other aspects of policy, transportation transit especially being kind of the gold standard of what I think about, is the region does not have a unified housing agenda from what we need for the state and our federal partners.

754
01:32:03.500 --> 01:32:23.572
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It's a little fragmented, different partners saying what they need, all good things, but There are a few, to me, very glaring gaps in our system that can only be impacted by state leadership, and that is funding and reforming our behavioral health system and our addiction recovery services or triage or transition.

755
01:32:23.701 --> 01:32:32.590
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>That entire ecosystem of funding and services to people is not working at the same level of performance that our SHS program.

756
01:32:33.328 --> 01:32:34.868
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I'll go even a step further.

757
01:32:35.012 --> 01:32:54.658
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think when people When I talk with everyday folks, you know, in town halls or out in community, I think people are really upset and frustrated about our government's inability to care for people that are experiencing psychosis or that are, you know, clearly struggling with substance abuse disorder.

758
01:32:54.819 --> 01:33:03.001
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Even those folks that want help, that want to exit, I mean, it's 7, 8-month waiting periods and I mean, you've seen the data.

759
01:33:03.161 --> 01:33:06.278
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, it's, it's just unacceptable, and that is a state problem.

760
01:33:06.695 --> 01:33:08.318
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We really need the state to fix that.

761
01:33:08.783 --> 01:33:18.213
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, right now, um, you know, for, for one person that we move into housing with SHS, 3 more are asking for SHS services for the first time ever.

762
01:33:18.520 --> 01:33:37.680
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So we have this broken economy, broken behavioral health system, and what we need is the, the courage and the political will to, to, to grab, to grab those by the horns and, and ask So I think there's a lot— that is a very clear actionable thing for us to collaborate and to work on and to ask from our legislators.

763
01:33:37.777 --> 01:33:40.779
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Like, this is just not, not going to, not going to do it for us.

764
01:33:41.502 --> 01:33:50.060
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm looking past you to the back of the room for our government affairs folks as you say that, and I might get in trouble for saying this here, but I'm going to take the risk and do it anyway.

765
01:33:50.140 --> 01:33:54.251
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I love hearing your interest in collaborating on some asks.

766
01:33:54.380 --> 01:33:56.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Asks to the state around behavioral health.

767
01:33:58.188 --> 01:34:07.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A couple of my colleagues and I have been having conversations with providers in the region around how we as the city can make some asks around behavioral health.

768
01:34:08.856 --> 01:34:18.724
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not a service that we provide, not a service that, that we've been heavily involved in in the past, but something that's so critical to meeting our community's needs across the board.

769
01:34:19.318 --> 01:34:27.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we'll be having a conversation as a full council next month around how we move forward with a potential ask around behavioral health.

770
01:34:27.572 --> 01:34:45.538
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And depending on where our conversations as a body land, if that's something that your body at Metro Council is interested in partnering on, I'm sure that— well, I'll just speak for myself and say I would love to extend that conversation to something we could collaborate on potentially.

771
01:34:45.876 --> 01:34:46.613
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, great.

772
01:34:46.837 --> 01:34:53.618
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And this is something that I'm also hoping that the RPOC, the Regional Policy Oversight Committee, helps steward and put together for the region.

773
01:34:54.228 --> 01:34:58.621
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Another ask that I will have is, you know, the City of Portland has 2 seats on RPOC.

774
01:34:59.341 --> 01:35:00.944
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We still need an alternate filled.

775
01:35:01.603 --> 01:35:07.886
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The mayor is the primary, and we've yet to get a second from the City Council.

776
01:35:08.319 --> 01:35:11.092
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So I'd love to have some city leadership on RPOC as well.

777
01:35:11.766 --> 01:35:14.673
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And just, you know, to be tracking the work and understanding what's happening.

778
01:35:14.738 --> 01:35:16.262
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think that table's very important.

779
01:35:16.744 --> 01:35:21.979
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And so anyway, I just wanted to put that out there and have real tangible asks for you.

780
01:35:22.444 --> 01:35:28.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those are appointments that the mayor and council president generally collaborate on.

781
01:35:28.225 --> 01:35:28.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Correct.

782
01:35:28.466 --> 01:35:37.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if we don't have somebody coming forward, I'm happy, and I'm guessing some of my colleagues would be as well, to put a bug in the council president's ear about Making sure we have someone there.

783
01:35:38.112 --> 01:35:38.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

784
01:35:38.694 --> 01:35:39.586
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much.

785
01:35:39.731 --> 01:35:40.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you, Chair.

786
01:35:42.453 --> 01:35:43.082
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Novick.

787
01:35:43.824 --> 01:35:44.326
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Chair.

788
01:35:44.956 --> 01:35:51.481
<v Steve Novick>So the polling you presented, by the way, Mr. President, I haven't said it before, congratulations on your presidency.

789
01:35:52.309 --> 01:35:53.492
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

790
01:35:54.091 --> 01:35:56.863
<v Steve Novick>The polling you presented was on an affordable housing measure.

791
01:35:58.510 --> 01:36:06.185
<v Steve Novick>Is that because that's more recent and we've already had, I think we probably have had a chance to see polling on a supportive housing services measure before?

792
01:36:06.896 --> 01:36:08.900
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, that's correct.

793
01:36:09.221 --> 01:36:29.493
<v Andy Shaw>We've done 5 or 6 polls over the last 3 years on supportive housing services and affordable housing as a combined concept, because the work of that period of time was, can we get back to reaffirming the supportive housing services measure by reforming it and combining it with affordable housing more explicitly?

794
01:36:30.487 --> 01:36:35.027
<v Andy Shaw>The timing of the bonds was interesting in that The city passed its first bond, then Metro passed a bond.

795
01:36:35.380 --> 01:36:46.903
<v Andy Shaw>Those were before we had resources to more robustly address homeless services, so they weren't constructed to think about specifically like supportive housing services, PSH-type housing.

796
01:36:47.320 --> 01:36:54.847
<v Andy Shaw>So at any rate, that whole process earlier was about can we re-extend SHS, connect it with affordable housing?

797
01:36:55.827 --> 01:36:58.618
<v Andy Shaw>Those efforts did not lead to a successful measure proposal.

798
01:36:58.971 --> 01:37:03.704
<v Andy Shaw>And so the latest poll was looking at what if we just considered affordable housing as a bond by itself.

799
01:37:04.506 --> 01:37:04.859
<v Steve Novick>Gotcha.

800
01:37:05.212 --> 01:37:05.405
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

801
01:37:06.511 --> 01:37:24.689
<v Steve Novick>In terms of like city, metro, county collaboration, I mean, this might sort of go without saying, and I'm not going to give any specifics, but I think that as you forge the next supportive housing measure, we need to make sure that it includes, you know, so that money is fungible, it needs to include reference to services the city provides.

802
01:37:25.363 --> 01:37:35.770
<v Steve Novick>That the counties or metro might not, and that any metrics for success that you adopt should also include metrics for success of things the city might be uniquely doing.

803
01:37:36.949 --> 01:37:37.592
<v Steve Novick>A question—.

804
01:37:38.188 --> 01:37:40.954
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Councilor, can I ask, do you have any examples in mind?

805
01:37:41.969 --> 01:37:44.546
<v Steve Novick>Well, let's see.

806
01:37:47.476 --> 01:37:49.104
<v Steve Novick>I will have some.

807
01:37:51.876 --> 01:37:54.953
<v Steve Novick>I hesitate to say what I'm about to say, but I will have some.

808
01:37:55.162 --> 01:37:56.774
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

809
01:37:59.739 --> 01:38:15.536
<v Steve Novick>So one number that always sort of raises my hackles is number of people prevented from, you know, saved from going into homelessness, because I wonder if we can really quantify that.

810
01:38:15.600 --> 01:38:20.356
<v Steve Novick>Do we absolutely know with certainty that somebody was going to become homeless without the intervention.

811
01:38:20.981 --> 01:38:25.740
<v Steve Novick>And I wonder if talking— using that terminology turns people off.

812
01:38:25.805 --> 01:38:29.217
<v Steve Novick>It's just like, well, hell, are you saying there'd be a million people homeless without you?

813
01:38:29.345 --> 01:38:35.082
<v Steve Novick>I mean, could you just give your thoughts on how that metric is forged and how you think we need to talk about it?

814
01:38:35.963 --> 01:38:36.862
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, thanks, Andy.

815
01:38:37.006 --> 01:38:40.274
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I, I, I'm pretty sure I, I, I know it, but if you know it 100%—.

816
01:38:40.323 --> 01:38:40.884
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>No, go, go.

817
01:38:41.268 --> 01:38:41.556
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Great.

818
01:38:41.685 --> 01:38:48.753
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So that number, uh, is measured through eviction prevention and other kind of similar spending programs that the counties have.

819
01:38:49.536 --> 01:38:56.618
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And typically those services are made available to someone that is facing an imminent eviction.

820
01:38:56.909 --> 01:38:57.087
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Okay.

821
01:38:57.153 --> 01:39:07.774
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And does not have a clear plan or income or something that would allow them to rebound quickly and would result in a type of homelessness.

822
01:39:08.023 --> 01:39:17.809
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And so, It is a large number more comparatively to the more supportive, deeply services that someone might— that is already living homeless.

823
01:39:18.002 --> 01:39:19.449
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I'm sure you've seen the data, right?

824
01:39:19.595 --> 01:39:28.864
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Keeping someone housed is a much more cost-effective tool than having to help someone that has stacked acuity on top of that.

825
01:39:28.993 --> 01:39:34.662
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So I think we're trying to build a system that makes homelessness rare, brief, and non-reoccurring.

826
01:39:36.158 --> 01:39:41.454
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And there's a lot of inputs into that, but generally that's how that number is identified.

827
01:39:41.567 --> 01:40:01.034
<v Steve Novick>Okay, that's reassuring because I was hoping that you're going to say that it's people who are immediately facing eviction, because I think that there's research showing that people who are evicted have a really high likelihood of becoming homeless, whereas people further up the chain, even if they're severely rent burdened, you can't say that giving them rent assistance prevented them from becoming homeless because they might not have anyway.

828
01:40:02.725 --> 01:40:14.148
<v Steve Novick>Do you have some sort of initial thoughts of following up on what Councilor Green said about what we think we've learned over the last few years and how we might, you know, do things differently?

829
01:40:15.934 --> 01:40:31.680
<v Steve Novick>I mean, can we say that, well, okay, we've spent a bunch of supportive services money on X, and we think that that was well-intentioned and it has some benefits, but maybe not as targeted as they should be, so we think we might be moving towards why?

830
01:40:34.789 --> 01:40:37.644
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think, um, I think we have learned a lot.

831
01:40:40.168 --> 01:40:40.265
<v Unidentified speaker>I—.

832
01:40:40.314 --> 01:40:54.840
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Some of the primary things that I think come up to me is, um, you can't address homelessness without a more dedicated upstream strategy that is like living wage jobs, like people-focused economic development.

833
01:40:55.179 --> 01:41:02.043
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It's the housing production work and, and the decades of underbuilding that we have had I think it's a full layer of things.

834
01:41:02.621 --> 01:41:13.806
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>At the same time, I think what I am taking from this moment is, you know, we can't take voter support for granted, and we really have to show people every single day the little things and the big things of what we do.

835
01:41:14.640 --> 01:41:17.636
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Andy, is there anything that comes to mind?

836
01:41:17.957 --> 01:41:21.658
<v Andy Shaw>I mean, again, the order of these measures is a lesson.

837
01:41:22.108 --> 01:41:30.113
<v Andy Shaw>It was a little out of order in terms of having a robust homeless services measure come after affordable housing bonds, which were aimed at primarily low-income families.

838
01:41:30.690 --> 01:41:36.036
<v Andy Shaw>And so we have a dearth of places for people to receive additional services in housing.

839
01:41:36.083 --> 01:41:45.569
<v Andy Shaw>It's housing that's built with staff spaces and places for the provision of services that would better suit a robust homeless services program.

840
01:41:45.698 --> 01:42:00.243
<v Andy Shaw>I guess also, don't launch a program like this at the beginning of a pandemic that none of us saw Like, that has caused such a challenge for us and the entire country, and that is a part of what we're struggling with.

841
01:42:00.372 --> 01:42:12.574
<v Andy Shaw>I think also just the depth of challenges that we need the state's help and others helping us with from a behavioral health point of view and other services that are beyond what was envisioned in this measure.

842
01:42:13.394 --> 01:42:23.372
<v Andy Shaw>We're now— we've done amazing work to provide an array of services and lay out programs Especially in the 2 suburban counties, which had almost no resource in this program before.

843
01:42:24.126 --> 01:42:30.554
<v Andy Shaw>And so now we're into the space of some incredibly hard work to build out the rest of the program.

844
01:42:31.179 --> 01:42:31.659
<v Andy Shaw>Yeah, I love that.

845
01:42:31.739 --> 01:42:32.172
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I mean, that's true.

846
01:42:32.237 --> 01:42:47.850
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I mean, you know, for generations, the homeless plan that Washington and Clackamas County had, I mean, not for a lack of trying, for a lack of caring, was a bus ticket to downtown Portland, in that there's just no way to build a regional housing continuum that cares for people.

847
01:42:49.052 --> 01:43:17.376
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>You know, I think, I think too, one of the big takeaways that I have, Councilor, is, um, uh, you know, with the pandemic and then now the, the administration in the White House and just the general nature of, of like, uh, sequence crises that we're facing, um, from funding availability and focus, uh, from partners above us is, you know, I think that we need to be, uh, probably a little bit more focused as to what it is that we want Uh-huh.

848
01:43:17.471 --> 01:43:19.716
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>These measures to do because the need is so great.

849
01:43:20.100 --> 01:43:44.806
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The economics are so, so, so wildly entangled that, um, I think that was one of the, um, real, real, um, like ribbons of, of, of success from the Metro Affordable Housing Bond was that it focused on, uh, deep affordability in family-sized units, which is something that in most cases the private market cannot truly address, um, without some kind of, uh, investment.

850
01:43:44.871 --> 01:43:46.091
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I'll give some examples.

851
01:43:46.139 --> 01:43:52.979
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I need to get better about talking about deep affordability or 30% AMI, and, and I think sharing it in a number that actually people understand.

852
01:43:53.461 --> 01:44:05.132
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So last week, you know, we, we opened a, a new affordable housing community in Hillsboro, um, called Dolores with Hacienda CDC, and, uh, majority of those units are, uh, um, deeply affordable.

853
01:44:05.662 --> 01:44:13.783
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>There's some, uh, blending with SHS, really cool stuff, but basically a deeply affordable unit is Like $600, $700 for a 2-bedroom unit.

854
01:44:14.250 --> 01:44:15.100
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I mean, that's significant.

855
01:44:15.212 --> 01:44:22.958
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I mean, that is not something you can find on the market, especially for someone that is living in poverty in the Portland metro area.

856
01:44:23.006 --> 01:44:26.600
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So that's kind of what we're talking about when we're talking about that level of affordability.

857
01:44:26.680 --> 01:44:28.926
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>That's probably the most significant gap.

858
01:44:30.208 --> 01:44:42.045
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>You know, one of the mandates that the state's kind of housing rules imposed on Metro was the Regional Housing Coordination Strategy, which I know All of our cities have a local housing coordination strategy.

859
01:44:42.702 --> 01:44:48.167
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It kind of asks us to look at a more regional outlook on housing unit shortage.

860
01:44:48.344 --> 01:44:52.976
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think for the last 20 years, we've underbuilt by around like 110,000 units.

861
01:44:53.778 --> 01:44:58.122
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>About half of those 110,000 units are 30% AMI and lower.

862
01:44:58.650 --> 01:45:01.328
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And that's, I mean, it's just such a major gap.

863
01:45:01.456 --> 01:45:06.216
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The need is so significant and why I feel public investment is essential.

864
01:45:06.265 --> 01:45:06.377
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Thank you.

865
01:45:06.987 --> 01:45:10.278
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, is because we need to really chase after that goal.

866
01:45:11.000 --> 01:45:19.283
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Uh, and then also the work that you're doing is help to, uh, alleviate housing and missing middle in other ways, other strategies, and other parts of the continuum as well.

867
01:45:20.471 --> 01:45:20.841
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

868
01:45:21.033 --> 01:45:29.413
<v Steve Novick>And, um, I'll, I'll send you this, Andy, but I just wanted to let you know that, um, Councilor Kanal and I did a poll recently that was mostly about other things.

869
01:45:29.478 --> 01:45:35.304
<v Steve Novick>We threw in a question about tools to address homelessness, and we asked people, you know, What do you think is most effective?

870
01:45:35.657 --> 01:45:39.876
<v Steve Novick>Building shelters, giving people rent assistance, or building affordable housing?

871
01:45:40.390 --> 01:45:45.764
<v Steve Novick>And it was shelters at the bottom, rent assistance above that, building new housing a bit above that.

872
01:45:45.828 --> 01:45:56.480
<v Steve Novick>So finally, I just want to say that I was interested in the, you know, there weren't great numbers for social housing because I suppose people don't know exactly what that is.

873
01:45:56.529 --> 01:46:04.242
<v Steve Novick>And I really would like to see what would happen if we Like, asked about anti-social housing and see if that might have a stronger appeal.

874
01:46:05.716 --> 01:46:08.859
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We can certainly look into the questions that we put out to folks, for sure.

875
01:46:09.002 --> 01:46:09.980
<v Andy Shaw>Great minds think alike.

876
01:46:10.126 --> 01:46:12.787
<v Andy Shaw>I made the same joke just the other day.

877
01:46:13.106 --> 01:46:23.222
<v Andy Shaw>We did try to add some questions in that describe what we perceive social housing is trying to achieve, and it is similar to acquisition of existing.

878
01:46:23.287 --> 01:46:25.002
<v Andy Shaw>It's similar to construction of new.

879
01:46:25.515 --> 01:46:29.506
<v Andy Shaw>It's just not the level at which voters are interested in engaging.

880
01:46:30.243 --> 01:46:39.845
<v Andy Shaw>And so, yeah, I think we had a couple councilors that were very curious about if you just use social housing, if you used other ways of describing what you're trying to accomplish with what we've seen in some of the social housing models.

881
01:46:40.679 --> 01:46:43.082
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, and I think, again, polls are snapshots in time.

882
01:46:43.948 --> 01:46:47.458
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And also they help us understand, I think, where our electorate is.

883
01:46:48.212 --> 01:46:52.813
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And it should be a data point that we use to inform our policy development, our policy framing, right?

884
01:46:53.118 --> 01:46:55.628
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>As I'm sure you, you, you, uh, fully embrace there.

885
01:46:56.466 --> 01:47:04.002
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I do think there's still a need for us at a policy level to really rigorously examine what are the things that we want to prioritize.

886
01:47:04.099 --> 01:47:11.046
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I don't see why, you know, a different set of mix of social housing investments could be a part of this new affordable housing bond.

887
01:47:11.367 --> 01:47:19.385
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think we just need to, to Andy's point, kind of work backwards and say, what are the things people are going to feel once these investments are complete?

888
01:47:20.042 --> 01:47:28.713
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And then that helps us really tailor the bond framework and frankly the coalition that I think we need to build to secure more resources for us.

889
01:47:29.180 --> 01:47:33.305
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So I hope that's— it's not necessarily saying social housing is not something that we should consider.

890
01:47:33.369 --> 01:47:34.734
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It's just a snapshot in time.

891
01:47:35.039 --> 01:47:44.899
<v Andy Shaw>If I could add one more piece, I mean, I think social housing is a continuum of different approaches depending on the model, and we are absolutely using various aspects of what other social housing models use.

892
01:47:45.155 --> 01:47:47.693
<v Andy Shaw>In some of the developments and some of the programs we're working on.

893
01:47:48.463 --> 01:47:54.323
<v Andy Shaw>Not quite the Vienna model, which is a much more robust public ownership model, but it does incorporate aspects.

894
01:47:54.710 --> 01:47:55.063
<v Andy Shaw>Thanks, Andy.

895
01:47:55.190 --> 01:47:55.752
<v Andy Shaw>Good point.

896
01:47:55.850 --> 01:48:01.725
<v Steve Novick>To contradict what I said earlier, I actually was surprised that social housing scored that high because I assumed nobody knew what it meant.

897
01:48:01.806 --> 01:48:03.154
<v Steve Novick>So I think we've made progress.

898
01:48:03.315 --> 01:48:04.215
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

899
01:48:04.744 --> 01:48:05.033
<v Steve Novick>Thanks.

900
01:48:05.868 --> 01:48:07.457
<v Steve Novick>You're welcome.

901
01:48:07.828 --> 01:48:08.180
<v Baz Epley>Exactly.

902
01:48:09.176 --> 01:48:10.108
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Koyama Lane.

903
01:48:11.726 --> 01:48:13.827
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair, and thank you so much for being here today.

904
01:48:13.907 --> 01:48:22.769
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I couldn't agree more that everyday Portlanders really want to see us working across jurisdictions, want to, want to see alignment, want to see coalition building.

905
01:48:23.280 --> 01:48:29.819
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was, um, really pleased to hear how much I was hearing you all talk about older adults and people with disabilities.

906
01:48:30.556 --> 01:48:42.193
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, in the data you presented, I think it said 69% of respondents noted That providing affordable housing for older adults living on fixed incomes was extremely or very important.

907
01:48:42.546 --> 01:48:47.118
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So that's top priority identified in the data.

908
01:48:47.667 --> 01:49:01.771
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm wondering if you can speak a bit more to what's being done to address the needs of that population and if there's engagement with groups like Northwest Pilot Project and Multnomah County's Aging, Disability, and Veterans Services Division.

909
01:49:03.579 --> 01:49:04.194
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, thanks.

910
01:49:05.782 --> 01:49:08.908
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We have a lot of really certified smart people behind us.

911
01:49:10.177 --> 01:49:31.435
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, I do, I do know that across both SHS and our affordable housing bond program, uh, on the affordable housing front, uh, the, the, the projects have kind of been put together by different project partners, often focusing on, on different, um, target populations that Uh, data shows there's a kind of some disparity.

912
01:49:32.173 --> 01:49:48.594
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Uh, one of the really, really, um, frequent themes that I've seen is like a focus on senior housing that then, um, the developers and the kind of the community partner providers, uh, will then, uh, uh, collaborate to provide wraparound services that are really tailored to that community.

913
01:49:49.332 --> 01:49:54.961
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, I'm sure we can get you way more, uh, really concrete examples about that if, if you would like.

914
01:49:55.041 --> 01:49:56.002
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We would look to follow up.

915
01:49:56.469 --> 01:50:03.835
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, and with SHS, I, I feel pretty confident as well that, that similar work is happening with the different providers.

916
01:50:04.493 --> 01:50:18.279
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Uh, with the supportive housing services across the 3 counties, we have 100— over 100 different homeless services providers, some of them specializing in youth, some of them specializing in veterans, some of them specializing in elders.

917
01:50:18.777 --> 01:50:28.929
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, and there's just different, uh, different kinds of wraparound care services that we've tried to build a system that is resilient, and there's like no wrong door.

918
01:50:30.082 --> 01:50:34.765
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So I would love to get more detail, but also trying to answer to the best of my ability, Councilor.

919
01:50:34.831 --> 01:50:40.529
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I would love to continue this conversation and continue to partner in this area.

920
01:50:41.510 --> 01:50:51.064
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Another thing I was wondering is if there's anything being done specific to address housing insecurity for families with Yeah, I—.

921
01:50:51.354 --> 01:51:04.140
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>One of the most, uh, and I can't really take credit for this because this work was done way before I was ever on the Metro Council, with the development of the first Metro Affordable Housing Bond was again a focus on, uh, family-sized units.

922
01:51:04.545 --> 01:51:10.051
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So it's like 2, 3, 4-bedroom units, and many of them in the deep affordability level.

923
01:51:10.646 --> 01:51:20.313
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, I try and, uh, spend as much time as possible in community rooms with affordable housing, uh, communities, uh, that have been funded by the Metro Affordable Housing Bond, meeting with folks.

924
01:51:20.713 --> 01:51:22.270
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I see a lot of kids running around.

925
01:51:22.574 --> 01:51:24.420
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I see multi-generational households.

926
01:51:24.948 --> 01:51:30.355
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And that to me is, is, uh, the success that can't be demonstrated by the, the data, right?

927
01:51:30.404 --> 01:51:31.993
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The joy of, of people's stability.

928
01:51:32.569 --> 01:51:54.399
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, and at the same time, there are too many young, young people, there are too many families that are, you know, one small thing away from Sounds great.

929
01:51:54.399 --> 01:51:55.079
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so much.

930
01:51:55.079 --> 01:51:56.659
<v Andy Shaw>I would just add one, one comment.

931
01:51:56.800 --> 01:52:08.340
<v Andy Shaw>In the, in the, in the buildup to building the 2018 regional measure, uh, we did deep, deep engagement in communities and trying to understand both just from a mathematical point of view the, the, the lack of housing supply and housing the impact of that on people's lives.

932
01:52:08.525 --> 01:52:14.487
<v Andy Shaw>In, in the affordability, in the deep affordability range, but also what were the kind of things that, that communities needed.

933
01:52:14.952 --> 01:52:20.256
<v Andy Shaw>And that was how we identified focusing in on that deep affordability, focusing in on family-sized units.

934
01:52:20.784 --> 01:52:24.198
<v Andy Shaw>In order to do that, it meant building fewer units.

935
01:52:24.470 --> 01:52:36.140
<v Andy Shaw>In order— we could have built more units that served individuals with that same money, but the commitment of really learning what was it that communities needed, uh, led to a decision.

936
01:52:36.509 --> 01:52:48.337
<v Andy Shaw>And it was, it was a, it was a process with community groups to say, you know, this much money could buy you this many units, or this many family-sized units, or this many deeply affordable units, because it, it, it costs more to build those units.

937
01:52:48.386 --> 01:53:08.465
<v Andy Shaw>So that, that was a part of the development of that bond at the time, and I'm sure we would, uh, engage in that same kind of process to figure out today what are the specific gaps today, what are the community needs that the market or Thank you so much for sharing all of that, and I look forward to continued conversation.

938
01:53:09.210 --> 01:53:09.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's it for now, Chair.

939
01:53:10.135 --> 01:53:10.849
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Of course.

940
01:53:11.255 --> 01:53:11.645
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

941
01:53:13.689 --> 01:53:16.530
<v Candace Avalos>All right, I have some thoughts.

942
01:53:19.832 --> 01:53:21.365
<v Candace Avalos>Trying to think of how to organize my thoughts.

943
01:53:21.591 --> 01:53:22.559
<v Candace Avalos>First of all, thank you.

944
01:53:22.720 --> 01:53:28.189
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, I think what this conversation is illuminating is just how important this issue is.

945
01:53:28.643 --> 01:53:38.292
<v Candace Avalos>It is for not only us— for us— not only for us to get on the same page and have a shared vision, but also be clear about who is responsible for what, right?

946
01:53:38.436 --> 01:53:51.779
<v Candace Avalos>Because I think that's part of, um, the issue and what, you know, people are experiencing is they're like, well, they don't care who is technically in charge of doing whatever aspect of addressing the problem.

947
01:53:51.845 --> 01:53:56.185
<v Candace Avalos>They don't— they care that they are struggling to just keep that roof over their head, right?

948
01:53:56.734 --> 01:54:11.792
<v Candace Avalos>And one of the reasons that I've been leading the Unified Housing Strategy, UHS, is because we cannot keep operating in these disconnected plans and investments, and we need a roadmap that really articulates the city's role.

949
01:54:11.921 --> 01:54:33.740
<v Candace Avalos>So I've been spending time kind of focused internally at the city, and that is by design because I just don't I don't feel that we can show up well at any table where we're having this cross-jurisdictional conversation about solutions if we don't even know our own role, what our resources are, what we feel is within our jurisdiction.

950
01:54:33.932 --> 01:54:39.172
<v Candace Avalos>And so I really am excited to continue that work this fall.

951
01:54:39.845 --> 01:54:53.942
<v Candace Avalos>And one thing that I'm noticing as we're planning to do some public engagement in the coming, uh, month is that we just have to remember the different, um, expertise that different groups of people bring.

952
01:54:54.086 --> 01:55:01.018
<v Candace Avalos>Because I think sometimes we get really stuck in like, oh, we're talking to housing providers and developers and advocates and service providers and all that.

953
01:55:01.097 --> 01:55:02.895
<v Candace Avalos>And, you know, they are useful, right?

954
01:55:02.943 --> 01:55:09.585
<v Candace Avalos>Because they help us understand what's feasible, what barriers exist, what are, um, challenges to implementation.

955
01:55:10.082 --> 01:55:19.341
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but everyday people and what we're hearing in this poll, they, they're bringing something different Because they tell us whether we're solving the right problem, right?

956
01:55:19.405 --> 01:55:34.811
<v Candace Avalos>That is the feedback we get from everyday people and why I want to make sure that we're also doing a good job of not just staying so high level in the grass tops, because it's easy to point to a number and, you know, to say this, this is what, you know, feasibility looks like.

957
01:55:34.891 --> 01:55:45.284
<v Candace Avalos>But what— how are we showing that our priorities are reflecting everyday people's lived experience And whether the policies are making a difference in their lives directly.

958
01:55:45.332 --> 01:55:54.578
<v Candace Avalos>So I just— I, as it relates to like how we partner, I just want to keep elevating how important it is that we take that voice seriously.

959
01:55:54.675 --> 01:55:58.184
<v Candace Avalos>It's clear by the evidence that they don't feel like we're taking them seriously.

960
01:55:59.096 --> 01:56:04.784
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that also points to this like values versus expectations conflict we're seeing in the data.

961
01:56:05.250 --> 01:56:08.246
<v Candace Avalos>And frankly, I see it in my own neighborhood.

962
01:56:08.310 --> 01:56:09.962
<v Candace Avalos>We deal with this on the daily.

963
01:56:10.862 --> 01:56:25.779
<v Candace Avalos>You know, I have an HOA, we've got like a little group chat, and I monitored it all through like my campaign, and it truly was a microcosm of Portland because I could see all the things that we conceptually talk about are happening right in this WhatsApp group chat with my HOA neighbors.

964
01:56:26.100 --> 01:56:27.319
<v Candace Avalos>Which one of the group chats?

965
01:56:27.416 --> 01:56:28.685
<v Candace Avalos>Trust me, they got opinions.

966
01:56:28.845 --> 01:56:30.082
<v Candace Avalos>They got lots of opinions.

967
01:56:30.868 --> 01:56:40.145
<v Candace Avalos>But it's been really helpful to also see that That sense of tension of like, I'm frustrated because I want us to help this person.

968
01:56:40.658 --> 01:56:42.970
<v Candace Avalos>I want you to get this person off the street.

969
01:56:43.451 --> 01:56:51.923
<v Candace Avalos>I'm also frustrated because it's affecting my quality of life when there's, you know, campers and there's, you know, people on the street and it's creating chaos.

970
01:56:52.036 --> 01:56:53.657
<v Candace Avalos>There's all these traffic things that occur.

971
01:56:54.203 --> 01:56:55.582
<v Candace Avalos>So we're always having this drama.

972
01:56:56.047 --> 01:57:01.889
<v Candace Avalos>And, um, you know, it's been very heartening though to end those conversations even with all that frustration.

973
01:57:01.953 --> 01:57:02.048
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

974
01:57:02.225 --> 01:57:07.627
<v Candace Avalos>To know that their value is truly that they care about these humans and want to get them help.

975
01:57:08.478 --> 01:57:15.451
<v Candace Avalos>We have an unhoused man who's ended up on our street, and we're all trying to find a way to help him.

976
01:57:15.547 --> 01:57:16.396
<v Candace Avalos>I'm a city councilor.

977
01:57:16.605 --> 01:57:24.140
<v Candace Avalos>I'm supposed to have supposedly all of the resources at my fingertips, and it's been weeks and I can't figure it out, you know.

978
01:57:24.429 --> 01:57:26.305
<v Candace Avalos>And obviously I can't do it for him.

979
01:57:26.368 --> 01:57:27.458
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's also part of it.

980
01:57:27.506 --> 01:57:36.498
<v Candace Avalos>It's like There's all these systems that, you know, you have that this combination of like what government can deliver, and then of course the person has to do— take their own steps.

981
01:57:36.627 --> 01:57:44.847
<v Candace Avalos>But I think that's the issue, is that, that though that step is missing, and this is where supportive services come in, right?

982
01:57:44.912 --> 01:57:47.738
<v Candace Avalos>This is where proactivity is important, right?

983
01:57:47.802 --> 01:57:52.780
<v Candace Avalos>Because often our systems are just so responsive to, well, he's already unhoused, right?

984
01:57:53.487 --> 01:57:58.659
<v Candace Avalos>What are the steps that could have been happening when this person who has a full-time job, right?

985
01:57:58.820 --> 01:57:59.898
<v Candace Avalos>It's not that they're not working.

986
01:58:00.010 --> 01:58:03.207
<v Candace Avalos>I'm really tired of people saying that, oh, we just need to make sure everybody gets a job.

987
01:58:03.448 --> 01:58:11.668
<v Candace Avalos>First of all, there are plenty of people who are housing insecure who cannot have a job, whether they're disabled, whether they're— they are a senior and they've paid their damn dues.

988
01:58:11.782 --> 01:58:19.966
<v Candace Avalos>And that really makes me angry, actually, um, because I just feel like we're really missing, um, this wide swath of people who cannot age in place.

989
01:58:20.707 --> 01:58:26.815
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and, uh, that's You know, we know by the numbers that the highest rates of homeless people are our seniors.

990
01:58:27.409 --> 01:58:38.921
<v Candace Avalos>And so, you know, this is again why we like get so disconnected with like, oh well, if we just provide workforce opportunities and if we just like— that's not how it's really being experienced by people.

991
01:58:39.371 --> 01:58:40.863
<v Candace Avalos>People already have jobs.

992
01:58:41.280 --> 01:58:48.248
<v Candace Avalos>They already have, you know, certain things that supposedly would be the parts of an equation to keep them housed, and yet they're still not.

993
01:58:48.329 --> 01:58:48.859
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

994
01:58:49.485 --> 01:59:00.427
<v Candace Avalos>And so I just say that because I really want us as leaders to just take more seriously that voice and connect those dots.

995
01:59:00.493 --> 01:59:07.112
<v Candace Avalos>And I know we're all trying to, but again, I just, I hear this frustration from my neighbors and I'm just like trying to figure it out.

996
01:59:07.161 --> 01:59:10.935
<v Candace Avalos>And they look to me because I'm the city councilor in their neighborhood and they're like, Candace, what are you going to do?

997
01:59:11.001 --> 01:59:14.229
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm like, I'm trying, I swear I'm trying, but it's not good enough.

998
01:59:14.712 --> 01:59:16.333
<v Candace Avalos>You know, that's one individual person.

999
01:59:16.381 --> 01:59:17.779
<v Candace Avalos>We're talking about a system, right?

1000
01:59:17.827 --> 01:59:23.752
<v Candace Avalos>Like, I'm going to do everything I can to help my neighbor, but the system is broken, obviously.

1001
01:59:23.863 --> 01:59:33.931
<v Candace Avalos>So I think that ultimately, you know, what I define as success would be moving beyond these individual crises and building a durable system.

1002
01:59:33.979 --> 01:59:35.039
<v Candace Avalos>I know we all want that.

1003
01:59:35.104 --> 01:59:39.969
<v Candace Avalos>I want to have a shared regional strategy where everyone understands what their role is.

1004
01:59:40.787 --> 01:59:47.671
<v Candace Avalos>And an important part of what we're about to do with UHS is we're going to have engagement in 2 phases.

1005
01:59:47.847 --> 01:59:54.765
<v Candace Avalos>One phase is going to be kind of with the grasstops, like where the experts, the developers, the housing providers, we're going to get their feedback.

1006
01:59:54.828 --> 02:00:01.904
<v Candace Avalos>And one thing that we're going to get from them, or what I'm going to emphasize, is you also need to tell me how you're going to help, right?

1007
02:00:01.985 --> 02:00:04.985
<v Candace Avalos>Because I think also we've got a lot of people are like, government, do things.

1008
02:00:05.034 --> 02:00:16.261
<v Candace Avalos>And it's like, if this is supposedly an ecosystem that involves involves all of these public-private partners, then we need to create the conditions in which we can say, okay, private partners, like, what's your role in this?

1009
02:00:16.582 --> 02:00:26.493
<v Candace Avalos>One way that we're approaching it is, you know, essentially the UHS, we've got these objectives, uh, all of these, you know, goals under these objectives, and I plan to go to these people and say, where do you fit in?

1010
02:00:26.829 --> 02:00:29.122
<v Candace Avalos>Like, do you— oh, you're already working on that?

1011
02:00:29.332 --> 02:00:30.791
<v Candace Avalos>You have dollars that could help that?

1012
02:00:30.838 --> 02:00:30.998
<v Candace Avalos>You're—.

1013
02:00:31.079 --> 02:00:38.524
<v Candace Avalos>Or you're, you know, you can, you can put some of your capital, whether political or literal capital, into this solution.

1014
02:00:39.359 --> 02:00:49.920
<v Candace Avalos>And so yeah, I'm really looking forward to that conversation because I think that's part of the work that we have to do is like, what are we doing to secure those private-public— we just hear it, I hear it all the time and I'm like, what does that mean?

1015
02:00:50.353 --> 02:00:51.363
<v Candace Avalos>What does that really mean?

1016
02:00:52.262 --> 02:00:55.264
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm hoping to kind of test out that concept through this process.

1017
02:00:55.328 --> 02:01:14.364
<v Candace Avalos>But then the second phase of engagement is going to be with everyday Portlanders to again, Make sure that, like, we're not just staying all high level in wonky land and we're actually bringing it down to what are you experiencing, what do you need right now, does this long list of objectives make sense to what you think we should be prioritizing, right?

1018
02:01:14.430 --> 02:01:21.882
<v Candace Avalos>So as we move forward and we start collaborating together again, I really want to focus on getting the city's house in order.

1019
02:01:22.256 --> 02:01:22.530
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1020
02:01:22.757 --> 02:01:26.109
<v Candace Avalos>Before I feel like we're ready to show up as the right partner.

1021
02:01:26.158 --> 02:01:27.775
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, we're going to And it's gonna show up in other ways, obviously.

1022
02:01:27.855 --> 02:01:35.948
<v Candace Avalos>But that is a huge importance to me because I think we'll be more prepared to have a thorough discussion about what our role is after that.

1023
02:01:36.430 --> 02:01:42.676
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm hoping again that what does it look like for us to do some— I mean, I heard work sessions.

1024
02:01:42.788 --> 02:01:47.734
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's a good idea, like having more public work sessions, more public opportunities.

1025
02:01:48.231 --> 02:01:57.854
<v Candace Avalos>Because even when people— even if, in my experience, When I'm talking to East Portlanders now, East Portlanders, obviously they, they're just glad to have anybody there representing them.

1026
02:01:58.448 --> 02:02:03.092
<v Candace Avalos>The bar is really low in an unfortunate way because they have been so used to people not listening to them.

1027
02:02:03.591 --> 02:02:06.210
<v Candace Avalos>But they, they know it's hard.

1028
02:02:06.547 --> 02:02:09.198
<v Candace Avalos>They know that I have impossible situations in front of me.

1029
02:02:09.279 --> 02:02:19.818
<v Candace Avalos>And but they— the fact that I just come to listen makes a big difference in their trust and in their, like, the let's get caught trying, which I'm gonna tattoo on my body because I love that philosophy.

1030
02:02:19.978 --> 02:02:28.114
<v Candace Avalos>Not really, um, because I, I really think that could make a big difference in helping, um, Portlanders feel confident that we are actively doing it.

1031
02:02:28.162 --> 02:02:29.286
<v Candace Avalos>But we got to show it, you know.

1032
02:02:29.367 --> 02:02:38.016
<v Candace Avalos>These committee meetings, I mean, nobody's— hi, you know, 5 people who are maybe watching this right now— but like, these are not the places to have that dialogue with community.

1033
02:02:38.658 --> 02:02:48.494
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and so I would really urge us, um, to think about how we're, uh, going beyond the dais I think we just need to do an intentional effort there.

1034
02:02:48.948 --> 02:02:51.447
<v Candace Avalos>And obviously that costs money, that takes time.

1035
02:02:52.391 --> 02:02:55.386
<v Candace Avalos>But frankly, I don't see, I don't see a choice, right?

1036
02:02:55.451 --> 02:03:06.931
<v Candace Avalos>We have no choice but to put in the time and money that it's going to take to be amongst people and understand their priorities more personally, and then reflect that back in the policies we're suggesting.

1037
02:03:06.979 --> 02:03:07.204
<v Candace Avalos>So—.

1038
02:03:07.204 --> 02:03:07.913
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks, Chair.

1039
02:03:07.994 --> 02:03:11.037
<v Candace Avalos>That's a long rant to just give you my thoughts and appreciation for the work that you're doing.

1040
02:03:11.332 --> 02:03:23.326
<v Candace Avalos>And I really am looking forward to seeing how Metro, you know, will kind of guide in this discussion, especially because Metro has been kind of the holder of some of the important pieces of this.

1041
02:03:24.322 --> 02:03:28.881
<v Candace Avalos>And I feel really encouraged to hear the direction you're going.

1042
02:03:28.978 --> 02:03:31.001
<v Candace Avalos>And obviously we have a lot of work to do.

1043
02:03:31.064 --> 02:03:35.833
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll leave it at that and we'll close it out with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1044
02:03:35.899 --> 02:03:36.556
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1045
02:03:37.247 --> 02:03:37.858
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1046
02:03:37.987 --> 02:03:49.686
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm sorry to go so granular after that fantastic high-level overview, but as Councilor Koyama Lane was asking questions, it sparked a question for me.

1047
02:03:52.189 --> 02:04:27.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know that there are so many people in our community who need some support with affordable housing, and we know from Have we had any conversations, we being the groups broadly that have been pulled together on this work, about what it would look like to say, hey, we are going to specifically address the needs of this group, we're going to specifically address the needs on this next iteration of a housing bond or a revenue bond or a capital improvement bond?

1048
02:04:28.046 --> 02:04:28.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

1049
02:04:29.935 --> 02:04:43.640
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Of our seniors or of our families with young kids focusing on family-sized housing and whether that is— whether that helps us build more trust that the results are there or not.

1050
02:04:44.845 --> 02:04:50.310
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, I spent a lot of time thinking about this and living through it in terms of the policymaking space.

1051
02:04:51.065 --> 02:05:04.661
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>If I have to be really, really honest, I think that The kind of the government partners that were building SHS, implementing SHS, we were in such a period of, you know, trying to get the money out the door.

1052
02:05:04.949 --> 02:05:06.523
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Urgency, urgency, urgency.

1053
02:05:07.181 --> 02:05:15.193
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>There was a bit of a gap, I think, in terms of understanding of trust amongst each other and also roles and role clarity.

1054
02:05:15.690 --> 02:05:22.305
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>As a result, it created sometimes gaps between what would feel like really simple opportunities to collaborate.

1055
02:05:23.436 --> 02:05:41.649
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I can tell you though that in the last 12 months, especially with some of my leadership and those on the council, I mean, we're having all of the housing teams across the region meet together, coordinate on messaging, coordinate on those kind of key examples of what you're talking about.

1056
02:05:42.117 --> 02:05:44.587
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And, you know, could it have been happening sooner?

1057
02:05:44.862 --> 02:05:44.990
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1058
02:05:45.670 --> 02:05:47.364
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>The conditions were not there at that time.

1059
02:05:48.046 --> 02:06:01.635
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, but I do think that that is— again, I see so many of these like little green sprouts, these green shoots of things that are starting to go in the right direction, that when things are really performing, we're going to be like, wow, look at all these things getting there.

1060
02:06:02.146 --> 02:06:06.297
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, from my vantage point, I feel like I get to pull up the hood and see some of those things happening.

1061
02:06:06.954 --> 02:06:22.420
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Um, and, uh, I do think the region acknowledges that Metro has a really important role to help kind of coordinate and to, and to tell that that broader story and, and those concrete examples that, that show people and that try and change the, the, that belief question.

1062
02:06:22.837 --> 02:06:24.587
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>We're really, really focused on that.

1063
02:06:24.699 --> 02:06:30.707
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>That is a gap that I do not feel comfortable seeing, and I know it's part of my job, and I think it's all of our jobs to address.

1064
02:06:30.787 --> 02:06:46.536
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But I wanted to share a little bit of what also I saw as some of the, um, uh, kind of, uh, distance between our government partnerships that we have had to fix and that we're fixing and that I think are working so much better to our credit.

1065
02:06:46.666 --> 02:06:48.305
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And long may it continue.

1066
02:06:49.842 --> 02:06:50.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1067
02:06:50.488 --> 02:06:53.282
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I know there's a lot to do there and a lot that's been done.

1068
02:06:53.975 --> 02:07:15.856
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it would be really interesting to look at what it would take and what it would mean to be able to say any family that is at risk of homelessness, we regionally have a solution You will not fall into homelessness, or any senior who is at risk of falling into homelessness, we have a solution.

1069
02:07:15.936 --> 02:07:18.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We together as a region will make sure that you don't fall into homelessness.

1070
02:07:19.100 --> 02:07:27.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And to really think about those people that we're serving and how we have— how we might lean in.

1071
02:07:27.905 --> 02:07:32.408
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I know the politics of choosing who do you serve first is always really challenging.

1072
02:07:33.533 --> 02:07:40.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But how might we lean in to really be able to make that promise, that promise to people in our community?

1073
02:07:40.567 --> 02:07:41.912
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Yeah, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, thank you.

1074
02:07:42.185 --> 02:07:44.315
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I, I think I misunderstood your question originally.

1075
02:07:44.412 --> 02:07:48.050
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I went more of a comms to like show, uh, to the, to folks.

1076
02:07:48.658 --> 02:07:54.331
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Uh, to your point, I think your question is also asking us to think, uh, a little bit bigger about a theory of change.

1077
02:07:54.908 --> 02:08:01.060
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And like in a perfect system, these are the people that we want to make sure never fall into these circumstances.

1078
02:08:01.798 --> 02:08:07.796
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I think that is absolutely one of the responsibilities that we have to continue to focus on and deliver on.

1079
02:08:07.844 --> 02:08:08.309
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>So thank you.

1080
02:08:08.470 --> 02:08:11.676
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Just want to acknowledge my last answer was not quite hitting what you were asking.

1081
02:08:11.740 --> 02:08:15.476
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But your last answer was fantastic and really great information to have as well.

1082
02:08:15.926 --> 02:08:16.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1083
02:08:16.310 --> 02:08:17.001
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Of course.

1084
02:08:17.753 --> 02:08:26.990
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>If I could share one last thing, you know, in my office I kind of have a whiteboard, and I'm sure we all love to whiteboard and have different things up there.

1085
02:08:28.260 --> 02:08:40.479
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>I put, you know, as I do this job every day, I write down a data point that I find interesting, alarming, shocking, and I want to share one that kind of hit all of those 3 for me.

1086
02:08:41.842 --> 02:08:52.569
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>In 2025, in Multnomah County, 1 in 4 of all units built, housing units built in all of Multnomah County, were funded by the Metro Affordable Housing Bond.

1087
02:08:53.002 --> 02:08:56.773
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>That's incredible because, wow, Metro Affordable Housing Bond investment.

1088
02:08:57.253 --> 02:09:02.837
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>But also we're not building housing anywhere close to the scale of what we need to be building.

1089
02:09:03.189 --> 02:09:06.399
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I see that number and I'm like, I feel pride and also shock.

1090
02:09:07.762 --> 02:09:13.891
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>And I just share that number with you about this kind of production slow phase that we're in right now.

1091
02:09:15.302 --> 02:09:18.175
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>It's just a number that's really stuck out with me and I share it with you too.

1092
02:09:19.779 --> 02:09:26.164
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, yeah, I'm gonna have to let that one cook a little bit, but that's very insightful.

1093
02:09:26.358 --> 02:09:30.353
<v Candace Avalos>Um, thank you for sharing that, and thank you, uh, committee, for the discussion.

1094
02:09:30.529 --> 02:09:41.375
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, again, this is just the beginning, but I really appreciate us just putting out on the public, um, you know, what we're thinking about, being vulnerable a bit and just being honest.

1095
02:09:41.454 --> 02:09:46.720
<v Candace Avalos>I, I think that goes a long way with the public, so thank for helping us to start that today, and we'll be in touch.

1096
02:09:47.297 --> 02:09:48.132
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, absolutely.

1097
02:09:48.261 --> 02:09:48.453
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1098
02:09:48.518 --> 02:09:48.952
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you all.

1099
02:09:49.947 --> 02:09:52.018
<v Candace Avalos>All right, colleagues, we're going to take a quick 10-minute break.

1100
02:09:52.114 --> 02:09:55.310
<v Candace Avalos>We'll be back at 4:15 and get through all of our foreclosure items.

1101
02:23:27.679 --> 02:23:31.126
<v Candace Avalos>All right, we are going to call this meeting back to order.

1102
02:23:32.409 --> 02:23:36.632
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, go ahead and please read items 4 through 18 together.

1103
02:23:41.229 --> 02:23:41.668
<v Unidentified speaker>Here I go.

1104
02:23:43.690 --> 02:23:58.930
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 4, document number 2026-247, initiate foreclosure action on 7545 Northeast Aye.

1105
02:23:58.930 --> 02:24:14.329
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 4, document number 2026-248, initiate foreclosure action on 7545 WI/Northeast Sandy Boulevard for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1106
02:24:14.329 --> 02:24:27.149
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 5, document number 2026-249, initiate foreclosure action on 6307 North Montana Avenue for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1107
02:24:28.145 --> 02:24:39.906
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 7, document number 2026-250, initiate foreclosure action on North Columbia Boulevard for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1108
02:24:40.742 --> 02:24:47.587
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 8, document number 2026-251, initiate foreclosure action on 110 Southeast Aye.

1109
02:24:47.975 --> 02:24:48.748
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Opposed?

1110
02:24:49.989 --> 02:24:51.085
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Abstain.

1111
02:24:51.360 --> 02:24:52.376
<v Unidentified speaker>Motion passes.

1112
02:24:52.971 --> 02:25:05.120
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 8, document number 2026-252, initiate foreclosure action on 7250 Northeast Lombard Street for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1113
02:25:05.654 --> 02:25:19.388
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 10, document number 2026-253, initiate foreclosure action on 7101- 7103 Southeast Division Street for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1114
02:25:20.292 --> 02:25:32.709
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 11, document number 2026-254, initiate foreclosure action on 1625 Southeast 35th Ave for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1115
02:25:33.306 --> 02:25:40.268
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 12, document number 2026-255, initiate foreclosure action on 2706 Yes.

1116
02:25:40.799 --> 02:25:40.961
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1117
02:25:41.299 --> 02:25:41.638
<v Unidentified speaker>Opposed?

1118
02:25:41.718 --> 02:25:41.735
<v Baz Epley>Aye.

1119
02:25:41.847 --> 02:25:43.331
<v Unidentified speaker>Motion passes.

1120
02:25:43.620 --> 02:26:01.566
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 12, document number 2026-256, initiate foreclosure action on 2734-2738 Northeast Alberta Street for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1121
02:26:02.373 --> 02:26:05.790
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 14, document number 2026-257, Yes.

1122
02:26:05.790 --> 02:26:07.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1123
02:26:07.030 --> 02:26:07.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Motion carries.

1124
02:26:07.030 --> 02:26:07.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1125
02:26:07.030 --> 02:26:15.379
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 14, document number 2026-258, initiate foreclosure action on 6627 Southeast Woodstock Boulevard for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1126
02:26:15.829 --> 02:26:28.620
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 15, document number 2026-259, initiate foreclosure action on 6627 Southeast Woodstock Boulevard for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1127
02:26:28.770 --> 02:26:31.549
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 16, document number 2026-269, initiate foreclosure action on 6627 Southeast Woodstock Boulevard for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1128
02:26:31.549 --> 02:26:32.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 17, document number 2026-269, initiate foreclosure action on 6627 Southeast Woodstock Boulevard for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1129
02:26:32.030 --> 02:26:32.510
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 18, document number 2026-269, initiate foreclosure action on 6627 Southeast Woodstock Boulevard for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1130
02:26:35.719 --> 02:26:36.620
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1131
02:26:36.620 --> 02:26:41.760
<v Juan Carlos Gonzalez>Opposed?

1132
02:26:41.760 --> 02:26:42.239
<v Kevin Foster>Abstain.

1133
02:26:42.239 --> 02:26:42.239
<v Unidentified speaker>Motion passes.

1134
02:26:42.239 --> 02:26:55.370
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 16, document number 2026-260, initiate foreclosure action on 5706 Southeast Lambert Street for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1135
02:26:55.500 --> 02:27:10.046
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 18, document number 2026-271, Thank you, Diego.

1136
02:27:10.110 --> 02:27:10.594
<v Candace Avalos>Great job.

1137
02:27:10.658 --> 02:27:13.159
<v Candace Avalos>That was a mouthful.

1138
02:27:14.078 --> 02:27:27.450
<v Candace Avalos>So one quick note, I missed a cue to say that we received a request from the mayor's office to withdraw item 8, item 2026-251, Which is the property at 110 Southeast 24th Avenue.

1139
02:27:27.932 --> 02:27:34.948
<v Candace Avalos>Our understanding is that the owner has satisfied the balance owed on the lien, so we do not need to move forward with foreclosure action on this property.

1140
02:27:34.996 --> 02:27:40.712
<v Candace Avalos>So without objection, we will remove item 8 from today's agenda and refer it back to the mayor's office.

1141
02:27:42.109 --> 02:27:42.896
<v Candace Avalos>Seeing no objections?

1142
02:27:43.073 --> 02:27:43.200
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

1143
02:27:44.132 --> 02:27:53.523
<v Candace Avalos>All right, um, so now we've got our, uh, fabulous presenters here to, um, talk to us more about these proceedings.

1144
02:27:53.603 --> 02:28:01.452
<v Candace Avalos>The other thing I wanted to note, I mentioned this at the beginning, we are going to be able to, uh, vote on all of them as a bulk.

1145
02:28:01.692 --> 02:28:06.075
<v Candace Avalos>Um, we got some, uh, information from the city attorneys that we can do that.

1146
02:28:06.507 --> 02:28:12.638
<v Candace Avalos>Um, if anyone wants to take out one particular one to vote separately, you can just let me know.

1147
02:28:13.088 --> 02:28:16.556
<v Candace Avalos>Otherwise, we'll move forward at the end with voting on all of them as a set.

1148
02:28:17.342 --> 02:28:20.231
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and with that, please take it away.

1149
02:28:20.712 --> 02:28:21.611
<v Selita Holt>Yeah, I'll get us started.

1150
02:28:21.772 --> 02:28:24.469
<v Selita Holt>I'm Selita Holt, the Audit and Accounting Manager with the Revenue Division.

1151
02:28:25.368 --> 02:28:38.498
<v Selita Holt>Councilors, each ordinance begins foreclosure proceeding— proceedings on the property with delinquent city liens that are eligible for foreclosure under City Code 530 and Administrative Rule 1410, Collections and Foreclosure Process.

1152
02:28:39.270 --> 02:28:44.293
<v Selita Holt>The liens were placed against the property by Portland Permitting and Development for code enforcement violations.

1153
02:28:45.129 --> 02:28:48.051
<v Selita Holt>The liens are delinquent and the violations have not been corrected.

1154
02:28:49.304 --> 02:29:02.935
<v Selita Holt>Each property comes before council as part of a coordinated effort by the CFO, Permitting and Development, City Treasurer, City Attorney, the Revenue Division to actively pursue remedies including foreclosure for vacant and distressed properties.

1155
02:29:03.834 --> 02:29:12.875
<v Selita Holt>These properties have been identified as causing significant problems for neighbors and are subject of multiple and frequent police calls and numerous enforcement activities.

1156
02:29:14.111 --> 02:29:20.148
<v Selita Holt>The Foreclosure Prevention Manager in the Revenue Division has reviewed each case to ensure it meets criteria for foreclosure.

1157
02:29:20.918 --> 02:29:33.861
<v Selita Holt>The Foreclosure Prevention Manager has also reviewed whether any aggravating or mitigating conditions exist within the case history that would prevent the city from moving forward with foreclosure or warrant and adjustment of lien amounts.

1158
02:29:35.065 --> 02:29:40.138
<v Selita Holt>The property owner and parties of interest have received notification of pending foreclosure action.

1159
02:29:41.005 --> 02:29:46.144
<v Selita Holt>This is our last resort, and all property owners were given extensive opportunities to rectify the issue.

1160
02:29:47.413 --> 02:29:55.472
<v Selita Holt>Today we will hear from Kevin Foster, the Foreclosure Prevention Manager, about the properties recommended to be included on a foreclosure list of properties for sale.

1161
02:29:56.581 --> 02:29:58.299
<v Selita Holt>I will now invite Kevin Foster to begin the presentation.

1162
02:29:58.346 --> 02:29:59.343
<v Selita Holt>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney Nancy Thorington.

1163
02:30:01.623 --> 02:30:06.341
<v Kevin Foster>Right, good afternoon, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, and committee.

1164
02:30:07.579 --> 02:30:09.318
<v Kevin Foster>For the record, I'll go ahead and state my name again.

1165
02:30:09.719 --> 02:30:13.932
<v Kevin Foster>My name is Kevin Foster, Foreclosure Prevention Manager for the City of Portland.

1166
02:30:22.843 --> 02:30:25.278
<v Kevin Foster>This is the team that works on foreclosures.

1167
02:30:26.290 --> 02:30:32.868
<v Kevin Foster>Portland Permitting and Development, they recommend properties to the Revenue Division for foreclosure consideration.

1168
02:30:34.149 --> 02:30:38.552
<v Kevin Foster>Our City Attorney works with us on legal matters related to the foreclosure.

1169
02:30:40.085 --> 02:30:50.808
<v Kevin Foster>In the Revenue Division, I review the delinquent accounts, work with PP&D and the City Attorney to determine which properties to submit to Council for consideration.

1170
02:30:52.195 --> 02:30:54.674
<v Kevin Foster>And our city treasurer conducts the foreclosure sale.

1171
02:30:58.513 --> 02:31:02.236
<v Kevin Foster>I want to start by giving an overview of the city foreclosure program.

1172
02:31:03.353 --> 02:31:06.381
<v Kevin Foster>Our program is not your typical foreclosure program.

1173
02:31:07.415 --> 02:31:15.364
<v Kevin Foster>Usually with foreclosure programs, there's an amount owed and everything is— the foreclosure proceedings are based off the amount owed.

1174
02:31:17.310 --> 02:31:22.022
<v Kevin Foster>Our foreclosure program started back in 2016 with the mayor's office.

1175
02:31:23.379 --> 02:31:27.861
<v Kevin Foster>This is a focused effort on vacant and distressed properties.

1176
02:31:29.665 --> 02:31:31.968
<v Kevin Foster>This is about safer communities.

1177
02:31:33.531 --> 02:31:35.933
<v Kevin Foster>And I want to also state vacant.

1178
02:31:36.742 --> 02:31:44.164
<v Kevin Foster>Our foreclosure process does not displace any legal tenant or any legal occupant in the property.

1179
02:31:44.228 --> 02:31:44.454
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1180
02:31:45.869 --> 02:31:52.034
<v Kevin Foster>Yes, there are times that there are unlawful occupants on site at these properties, and you'll see that through my presentation.

1181
02:31:53.250 --> 02:31:56.162
<v Kevin Foster>And what we do is we send out— we work with Human Solutions.

1182
02:31:57.003 --> 02:32:08.677
<v Kevin Foster>They have an outreach team that they can actually send to the property to meet with the unlawful occupants to try to connect them with services to get them into some type of housing.

1183
02:32:12.852 --> 02:32:17.444
<v Kevin Foster>These properties create livability issues in the neighborhoods that they are in.

1184
02:32:19.709 --> 02:32:27.605
<v Kevin Foster>We use foreclosure as a way to prompt the owner into getting engaged to resolve the issues at the property.

1185
02:32:29.221 --> 02:32:33.548
<v Kevin Foster>This is used as a last resort when all other options have been exhausted.

1186
02:32:39.485 --> 02:32:45.056
<v Kevin Foster>When properties are referred to foreclosure, I make several attempts to prevent the property from moving forward.

1187
02:32:45.739 --> 02:32:49.519
<v Kevin Foster>I do extensive outreach by phone trying to get a hold of the owner.

1188
02:32:51.896 --> 02:32:56.881
<v Kevin Foster>I send out letters just to get their owner— get the owner's attention and to bring some engagement.

1189
02:32:58.280 --> 02:33:05.199
<v Kevin Foster>When owners are willing to resolve the issue and their case is closed, We can review them for programs to assist them.

1190
02:33:06.424 --> 02:33:09.566
<v Kevin Foster>We can see if they qualify for the lien reduction review program.

1191
02:33:10.629 --> 02:33:11.568
<v Kevin Foster>We can offer waivers.

1192
02:33:12.979 --> 02:33:14.568
<v Kevin Foster>We can work with them on payment plans.

1193
02:33:14.843 --> 02:33:17.049
<v Kevin Foster>We can do a hardship temporary payment plan.

1194
02:33:18.000 --> 02:33:23.701
<v Kevin Foster>And lastly, we can also come up with an amicable resolution to resolve the issues at the property.

1195
02:33:25.541 --> 02:33:29.134
<v Kevin Foster>And of course, if they pay the liens off in full, we'll remove them from the list.

1196
02:33:31.337 --> 02:33:35.500
<v Kevin Foster>The list I'm going to present to you originally came over with 20 properties.

1197
02:33:36.238 --> 02:33:40.827
<v Kevin Foster>Using these tools, I've been able to reduce the list by 6 properties.

1198
02:33:41.709 --> 02:33:42.889
<v Kevin Foster>3 Of them paid off.

1199
02:33:44.379 --> 02:33:50.246
<v Kevin Foster>One closed their open case and qualified for the lien reduction plan and is now on a payment plan.

1200
02:33:51.612 --> 02:33:54.637
<v Kevin Foster>One we, uh, one we're working with on an agreement.

1201
02:33:55.780 --> 02:33:57.745
<v Kevin Foster>And then the last one, they filed for bankruptcy.

1202
02:34:01.770 --> 02:34:04.009
<v Kevin Foster>We are always looking at ways to improve our program.

1203
02:34:07.569 --> 02:34:08.793
<v Kevin Foster>Sorry, one second.

1204
02:34:13.558 --> 02:34:31.899
<v Kevin Foster>We are always looking at ways to improve our program, so I want to highlight some admin rule changes regarding foreclosure that went into effect The admin rule 1410 and Section 60, we changed our name from the Collection Committee.

1205
02:34:31.899 --> 02:34:35.159
<v Kevin Foster>Now we call ourselves the Foreclosure Finance Committee.

1206
02:34:35.280 --> 02:34:44.969
<v Kevin Foster>That committee consists of people from the team— PB&D, City Attorney, Revenue, and the City Treasury's Office.

1207
02:34:44.969 --> 02:34:45.010
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1208
02:34:47.188 --> 02:34:49.617
<v Kevin Foster>We also changed some of the criteria.

1209
02:34:50.084 --> 02:34:51.323
<v Kevin Foster>I wouldn't say we changed the criteria.

1210
02:34:51.387 --> 02:34:53.849
<v Kevin Foster>I just hope we made it more concise.

1211
02:34:55.209 --> 02:34:58.028
<v Kevin Foster>Prior to the rewrite, it was pretty wordy.

1212
02:35:03.309 --> 02:35:07.052
<v Kevin Foster>Section 120, foreclosure properties purchased by city.

1213
02:35:09.170 --> 02:35:12.400
<v Kevin Foster>Properties that aren't— that don't receive bids at the foreclosure sale.

1214
02:35:13.063 --> 02:35:16.645
<v Kevin Foster>The city, with council approval, can bid on those properties.

1215
02:35:17.880 --> 02:35:20.739
<v Kevin Foster>And then the major one is Section 175.

1216
02:35:21.638 --> 02:35:31.003
<v Kevin Foster>What we're running across is in some cases properties aren't selling at our foreclosure sale because the lien balance is higher than what the property is, is valued at.

1217
02:35:32.271 --> 02:35:40.846
<v Kevin Foster>So this section now allows us to get an appraisal and base the sale price Off that appraisal.

1218
02:35:45.024 --> 02:35:49.986
<v Kevin Foster>Today I'm going to present to you 14 properties, combined total of 44 liens.

1219
02:35:50.422 --> 02:35:57.561
<v Kevin Foster>Most of the liens are code enforcement and nuisance liens, roughly combined total of $1.5 million owed.

1220
02:36:00.143 --> 02:36:04.682
<v Kevin Foster>And then this is just the property summary, um, height in bold text.

1221
02:36:04.730 --> 02:36:06.227
<v Kevin Foster>You can see the ones that are commercial properties.

1222
02:36:06.291 --> 02:36:06.436
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1223
02:36:08.625 --> 02:36:13.218
<v Kevin Foster>Uh, all of the properties— we ran what's called a police calls for service report.

1224
02:36:14.007 --> 02:36:19.604
<v Kevin Foster>All of the properties had some type of police involvement either at the property or within 200 feet of the property.

1225
02:36:22.648 --> 02:36:27.268
<v Kevin Foster>The first property is located at 7545 Northeast Sandy Boulevard.

1226
02:36:27.977 --> 02:36:29.457
<v Kevin Foster>Property is in District 3.

1227
02:36:29.907 --> 02:36:32.935
<v Kevin Foster>There are 5 liens against the property, delinquent since Yes.

1228
02:36:33.015 --> 02:36:37.853
<v Kevin Foster>Since 2024, $27,000 is owed.

1229
02:36:39.782 --> 02:36:47.990
<v Kevin Foster>Unlawful occupants are on site, overgrown yard, excessive trash and debris being dumped at the property.

1230
02:36:48.913 --> 02:36:51.113
<v Kevin Foster>And as you can see, this property is covered in graffiti.

1231
02:36:55.218 --> 02:36:59.540
<v Kevin Foster>The next property is located at 7545 W-I.

1232
02:36:59.637 --> 02:37:03.425
<v Kevin Foster>W-I, which means within Northeast Sandy Boulevard.

1233
02:37:03.554 --> 02:37:05.577
<v Kevin Foster>Again, properties in District 3.

1234
02:37:05.947 --> 02:37:10.218
<v Kevin Foster>There are 2 liens against the property, delinquent since 2025.

1235
02:37:10.924 --> 02:37:12.577
<v Kevin Foster>$9,800 Is owed.

1236
02:37:13.959 --> 02:37:24.202
<v Kevin Foster>Uh, the property has been found open to entry, or the garage has been found open to entry, and there are unlawful occupants believed to be camping in the garage.

1237
02:37:25.188 --> 02:37:28.200
<v Kevin Foster>And you can see there's excessive trash and debris at the site as well.

1238
02:37:31.363 --> 02:37:35.817
<v Kevin Foster>This next property is located at 6307 North Montana Avenue.

1239
02:37:36.543 --> 02:37:38.206
<v Kevin Foster>Property is located in District 2.

1240
02:37:38.721 --> 02:37:42.861
<v Kevin Foster>There are 5 liens against the property, delinquent since 2023.

1241
02:37:43.735 --> 02:37:46.290
<v Kevin Foster>Roughly $335,000 is owed.

1242
02:37:48.983 --> 02:37:56.926
<v Kevin Foster>The current owner of this property was actually the lender for the former developer for this property, for the prior owner.

1243
02:37:58.395 --> 02:38:07.317
<v Kevin Foster>The prior owner stopped the project, quit paying, and so eventually they had to foreclose on the prior owner.

1244
02:38:08.090 --> 02:38:11.229
<v Kevin Foster>They've had no— so, okay, sorry.

1245
02:38:12.084 --> 02:38:22.507
<v Kevin Foster>But we're currently— the new owner is trying to restore the property, finish the work, and their plan is to sell the property once the work has been completed.

1246
02:38:23.760 --> 02:38:32.084
<v Kevin Foster>The complaints on the property are for unlawful occupants, excessive trash and debris, and then there was some fire damage caused to the property by the unlawful occupants.

1247
02:38:32.551 --> 02:38:43.488
<v Kevin Foster>I am in touch with the owner's attorney and we are working on an agreement, and I expect this property to be pulled before we go to— before we go in front of full council.

1248
02:38:48.336 --> 02:38:57.079
<v Kevin Foster>Right, the, the next property is located at 7250 Northeast Lombard Street.

1249
02:38:57.774 --> 02:39:06.685
<v Kevin Foster>This property is located in District 2, 3 liens against the property, delinquent since 2025, $24,000 is owed.

1250
02:39:07.834 --> 02:39:14.909
<v Kevin Foster>The complaints are, as you can see, there's from the pictures, there's People camping on the property, excessive trash and debris.

1251
02:39:15.700 --> 02:39:19.896
<v Kevin Foster>This property was originally supposed to be an apartment complex.

1252
02:39:20.040 --> 02:39:26.846
<v Kevin Foster>The owner is in litigation with the contractor, so this property has not— the completion of the work has not moved forward.

1253
02:39:27.649 --> 02:39:33.115
<v Kevin Foster>This property has a long history of code history violations dating back to 2005.

1254
02:39:39.036 --> 02:39:42.924
<v Kevin Foster>This property is located at North Columbia Boulevard.

1255
02:39:44.038 --> 02:39:46.441
<v Kevin Foster>This is a vacant lot with no property number.

1256
02:39:47.353 --> 02:39:48.600
<v Kevin Foster>First time I've ever ran across that.

1257
02:39:49.781 --> 02:39:58.683
<v Kevin Foster>This property has a long history of nuisance complaints dating back to 1993, but they would get resolved because the owner would resolve them before going forward.

1258
02:40:00.373 --> 02:40:02.001
<v Kevin Foster>Both owners are now deceased.

1259
02:40:02.083 --> 02:40:02.412
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1260
02:40:03.184 --> 02:40:05.158
<v Kevin Foster>And I have not been able to locate a next of kin.

1261
02:40:06.486 --> 02:40:10.870
<v Kevin Foster>And this is kind of a result— revolving cycle because we keep getting complaints.

1262
02:40:10.935 --> 02:40:14.662
<v Kevin Foster>The city is incurring fees by having to go out there and clear the property.

1263
02:40:19.575 --> 02:40:26.005
<v Kevin Foster>The next property is located at 7101 and 7103 Southeast Division Street.

1264
02:40:26.683 --> 02:40:32.313
<v Kevin Foster>This property is located in District 3 2 liens against the property, delinquent since 2009.

1265
02:40:32.828 --> 02:40:34.927
<v Kevin Foster>$430,000 Is owed.

1266
02:40:37.479 --> 02:40:41.335
<v Kevin Foster>Um, the property, you can see, has trash debris on site.

1267
02:40:41.481 --> 02:40:45.290
<v Kevin Foster>It's open to entry, uh, and there's unlawful occupants.

1268
02:40:45.968 --> 02:40:52.147
<v Kevin Foster>The property owner is not engaged and hasn't responded to any of my phone calls or emails or any of our letters sent out.

1269
02:40:52.436 --> 02:40:53.938
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1270
02:40:56.022 --> 02:41:00.402
<v Kevin Foster>The next property is located at 1625 Southeast 35th Avenue.

1271
02:41:01.112 --> 02:41:03.004
<v Kevin Foster>Property is located in District 3.

1272
02:41:03.698 --> 02:41:09.753
<v Kevin Foster>2 Liens against the property, delinquent since 2024, amount owed $24,000.

1273
02:41:16.959 --> 02:41:24.275
<v Kevin Foster>Uh, the neighbors have reached out to me on this property complaining about There's large sinkholes on the property.

1274
02:41:25.254 --> 02:41:27.643
<v Kevin Foster>The roof on the garage is deteriorating.

1275
02:41:29.132 --> 02:41:30.288
<v Kevin Foster>The yard is overgrown.

1276
02:41:31.522 --> 02:41:40.066
<v Kevin Foster>At one point, they were considering suing the owner of the property for the condition of the— for being left in this condition.

1277
02:41:41.364 --> 02:41:45.277
<v Kevin Foster>I have spoken with the owner, and the property is now under contract.

1278
02:41:46.495 --> 02:41:51.609
<v Kevin Foster>I spoke with him as recently as last week, and he said it should be— the sale should be final within 45 days.

1279
02:41:51.704 --> 02:41:51.833
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1280
02:41:52.684 --> 02:41:59.487
<v Kevin Foster>Now, the reason why we're keeping this property on this list is because the property owner has defaulted on prior agreements.

1281
02:42:03.148 --> 02:42:10.916
<v Kevin Foster>The next property is located at 2706 Southeast 126th— Southeast 122nd Avenue.

1282
02:42:11.826 --> 02:42:13.661
<v Kevin Foster>Property is located in District 1.

1283
02:42:14.019 --> 02:42:17.525
<v Kevin Foster>There are 8 liens against the property, delinquent since 2023.

1284
02:42:19.264 --> 02:42:21.856
<v Kevin Foster>Roughly $74,000 is owed.

1285
02:42:24.239 --> 02:42:29.460
<v Kevin Foster>The property does have a prior code enforcement history which dates back to 2016.

1286
02:42:30.059 --> 02:42:33.115
<v Kevin Foster>There's trash and debris being left on site.

1287
02:42:33.454 --> 02:42:36.770
<v Kevin Foster>There's also unlawful occupants camping at the property.

1288
02:42:37.805 --> 02:42:39.727
<v Kevin Foster>This property owner is engaged.

1289
02:42:41.522 --> 02:42:43.704
<v Kevin Foster>They're working to close their open case.

1290
02:42:44.404 --> 02:42:49.412
<v Kevin Foster>And I— and by the time we get to full council, I expect this one to be removed as well.

1291
02:42:53.603 --> 02:42:59.105
<v Kevin Foster>This next property, 2734 and 2738 Northeast Alberta Street.

1292
02:43:00.141 --> 02:43:01.870
<v Kevin Foster>Property is located in District 2.

1293
02:43:02.657 --> 02:43:04.396
<v Kevin Foster>There are 4 lanes against the property.

1294
02:43:05.779 --> 02:43:12.411
<v Kevin Foster>Delinquent since 2025, roughly Roughly $106,000 is owed.

1295
02:43:14.371 --> 02:43:19.118
<v Kevin Foster>This property has a long history of code violations and nuisance complaints.

1296
02:43:20.328 --> 02:43:29.213
<v Kevin Foster>This property was also part of a prior city foreclosure action in 2024, which the council did approve this property for foreclosure.

1297
02:43:30.801 --> 02:43:34.155
<v Kevin Foster>The property was later removed because the owner paid off the liens.

1298
02:43:36.605 --> 02:43:40.804
<v Kevin Foster>This property has garnered several complaints for several years.

1299
02:43:44.342 --> 02:43:53.184
<v Kevin Foster>One of the neighbors uses a wheelchair and cannot access the sidewalk because of the debris and the— that are covering the sidewalk and the fence and what have you.

1300
02:43:55.610 --> 02:43:58.997
<v Kevin Foster>Um, the owner is engaged.

1301
02:44:00.225 --> 02:44:02.596
<v Kevin Foster>I've spoken with them as recently as yesterday.

1302
02:44:03.675 --> 02:44:07.963
<v Kevin Foster>But there's no action plan to resolve the issues at the property.

1303
02:44:10.220 --> 02:44:10.301
<v Unidentified speaker>We—.

1304
02:44:10.415 --> 02:44:19.577
<v Kevin Foster>I've been copied on emails from PP&D detailing what needs to be done, and nothing is moving forward at this time.

1305
02:44:23.538 --> 02:44:28.113
<v Kevin Foster>The next property is located at 4324 Southeast 65th Avenue.

1306
02:44:28.884 --> 02:44:30.972
<v Kevin Foster>This property is located in District 3.

1307
02:44:31.536 --> 02:44:35.441
<v Kevin Foster>There are 3 liens against the property, delinquent since 2020.

1308
02:44:36.100 --> 02:44:37.744
<v Kevin Foster>$38,000 Is owed.

1309
02:44:40.713 --> 02:44:43.132
<v Kevin Foster>This property's had extensive fire damage.

1310
02:44:43.326 --> 02:44:47.737
<v Kevin Foster>There's also roof damage from the firefighters battling the blaze.

1311
02:44:48.799 --> 02:44:54.456
<v Kevin Foster>I have spoken with the owner, and his plan is to, um, demo the property and rebuild it.

1312
02:44:54.521 --> 02:44:54.665
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1313
02:44:55.684 --> 02:45:00.644
<v Kevin Foster>And then he plans to sell it and then use those profits to pay off our liens.

1314
02:45:02.450 --> 02:45:08.926
<v Kevin Foster>The owner, the owner, the owner was paid by insurance for the fire damage to the property.

1315
02:45:10.049 --> 02:45:20.513
<v Kevin Foster>The last time I spoke with the owner, they were engaged with their contractor, so this one may possibly come off the list depending on what we're able to work out within the next couple of weeks.

1316
02:45:20.582 --> 02:45:20.700
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1317
02:45:24.555 --> 02:45:35.345
<v Kevin Foster>The next property is located at 6627 Southeast Woodstock, property located in District 3.

1318
02:45:38.484 --> 02:45:40.495
<v Kevin Foster>Sorry, give me one sec.

1319
02:45:49.454 --> 02:45:51.403
<v Kevin Foster>Okay, property is located in District 3.

1320
02:45:51.611 --> 02:45:55.379
<v Kevin Foster>There are 3 liens against the property, delinquent since 2025.

1321
02:45:55.894 --> 02:46:04.004
<v Kevin Foster>$5,800 Is owed, and this property has a long history of complaints dating back to the early 2000s.

1322
02:46:04.584 --> 02:46:11.777
<v Kevin Foster>This was also part of a prior foreclosure action in 2024, which was later removed because the owner paid off the liens.

1323
02:46:13.311 --> 02:46:14.834
<v Kevin Foster>Uh, the property is open to entry.

1324
02:46:15.498 --> 02:46:17.361
<v Kevin Foster>Unlawful occupants are on site.

1325
02:46:18.041 --> 02:46:20.747
<v Kevin Foster>Trash and debris on site, and the yard is overgrown.

1326
02:46:21.791 --> 02:46:26.834
<v Kevin Foster>Um, I've had no engagement with the— I've been unable to reach the owner by phone.

1327
02:46:27.334 --> 02:46:28.849
<v Kevin Foster>He has not responded to any of our letters.

1328
02:46:31.018 --> 02:46:34.176
<v Kevin Foster>And so we're moving this property forward.

1329
02:46:36.513 --> 02:46:41.784
<v Kevin Foster>The next property is located at 10 104 Southeast Herald Street.

1330
02:46:42.593 --> 02:46:44.740
<v Kevin Foster>Property is located in District 1.

1331
02:46:45.338 --> 02:46:49.420
<v Kevin Foster>There's one lien against the property, delinquent since 2016.

1332
02:46:50.966 --> 02:46:54.976
<v Kevin Foster>Roughly $117,000 is owed on the, on the lien.

1333
02:46:57.465 --> 02:47:01.533
<v Kevin Foster>This property suffered extensive fire damage in 2017.

1334
02:47:02.675 --> 02:47:04.268
<v Kevin Foster>The property is open to entry.

1335
02:47:05.993 --> 02:47:09.263
<v Kevin Foster>There are reports that there are unlawful occupants living in the garage.

1336
02:47:11.415 --> 02:47:18.191
<v Kevin Foster>There was an occupied RV on site as of the most recent housing inspection.

1337
02:47:18.754 --> 02:47:29.146
<v Kevin Foster>That RV, which believed to be the owner— the owner is deceased— his son was living in the RV on site as of the most recent housing inspection.

1338
02:47:29.810 --> 02:47:31.815
<v Kevin Foster>There There was no one living in the RV.

1339
02:47:33.802 --> 02:47:38.668
<v Kevin Foster>And we've received reports that the person living in the garage is someone connected to the family.

1340
02:47:43.445 --> 02:47:57.048
<v Kevin Foster>The next property is located at 5706 Southeast Lambert Street, property located in District 1, 3 liens against the property, delinquent since 2023, amount owed $24,000.

1341
02:47:57.095 --> 02:47:57.209
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1342
02:47:58.900 --> 02:48:01.487
<v Kevin Foster>There are trash and debris being left on site.

1343
02:48:02.311 --> 02:48:03.879
<v Kevin Foster>We have unlawful occupants.

1344
02:48:04.430 --> 02:48:07.502
<v Kevin Foster>And as you can see, this house has extensive fire damage.

1345
02:48:09.639 --> 02:48:22.354
<v Kevin Foster>The owners are believed to be deceased, and I— I'm sorry, the owners are deceased, and I cannot— I cannot— the son was engaged at one point, um, but I cannot get a hold of him.

1346
02:48:22.403 --> 02:48:23.838
<v Kevin Foster>I cannot get him to return my calls.

1347
02:48:27.885 --> 02:48:32.534
<v Kevin Foster>The last property is located at 855 Northeast Church Street.

1348
02:48:33.176 --> 02:48:35.422
<v Kevin Foster>This property is located in District 2.

1349
02:48:35.998 --> 02:48:40.297
<v Kevin Foster>There are 2 liens against the property, delinquent since 2009.

1350
02:48:41.130 --> 02:48:44.257
<v Kevin Foster>The total amount owed is $266,000.

1351
02:48:45.524 --> 02:48:53.072
<v Kevin Foster>This property has suffered roof damage, extensive roof damage that now on the inside There is a mold issue inside the property.

1352
02:48:54.641 --> 02:48:57.118
<v Kevin Foster>Trash and debris were accumulating at the property.

1353
02:48:57.861 --> 02:48:59.465
<v Kevin Foster>Property also has electrical issues.

1354
02:49:00.145 --> 02:49:09.825
<v Kevin Foster>This owner is engaged, and her plan is to rehab the whole property and turn it into adult foster care.

1355
02:49:11.814 --> 02:49:25.602
<v Kevin Foster>For the next 2 weeks prior to us going in front of full council, I'm going to work with this property owner to see if she can get into— she can provide some type of plan path forward so that we're able to remove, remove her from the list.

1356
02:49:26.041 --> 02:49:28.373
<v Kevin Foster>Since she is engaged, we want to give her that opportunity.

1357
02:49:31.899 --> 02:49:37.425
<v Kevin Foster>All right, the next steps in the process will be to present the properties to full council.

1358
02:49:39.835 --> 02:49:50.341
<v Kevin Foster>Properties that are approved For full council, properties that are approved on council ordinance authorize the city treasurer to conduct the foreclosure sale.

1359
02:49:51.359 --> 02:49:55.754
<v Kevin Foster>Property owners still have the right to pay off the liens up to the sale date.

1360
02:49:57.061 --> 02:50:06.459
<v Kevin Foster>If a property is sold and goes to a third party at our sale date, at our auction, at our foreclosure sale, the property owner will have a 90-day redemption period.

1361
02:50:08.189 --> 02:50:17.042
<v Kevin Foster>I plan to continue working with each and every property owner that's on this list to try and get some type of engagement prior to the council vote.

1362
02:50:18.415 --> 02:50:19.899
<v Kevin Foster>That will conclude my presentation.

1363
02:50:20.754 --> 02:50:25.772
<v Kevin Foster>I am available and our team is available to answer any questions that you may have.

1364
02:50:28.081 --> 02:50:28.825
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much.

1365
02:50:29.700 --> 02:50:31.674
<v Candace Avalos>Um, let's start with, um, Diego.

1366
02:50:31.724 --> 02:50:33.221
<v Candace Avalos>Do we have anybody signed up to testify?

1367
02:50:34.023 --> 02:50:35.450
<v Unidentified speaker>We have 2 individuals signed up.

1368
02:50:36.188 --> 02:50:36.908
<v Candace Avalos>All right, let's call them up.

1369
02:50:38.095 --> 02:50:53.950
<v Unidentified speaker>First, for document number 2026-249, initiate foreclosure action on 6307 North Montana Ave for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property, is Andy Chopkanyan.

1370
02:50:55.248 --> 02:50:56.594
<v Unidentified speaker>And Andy's online.

1371
02:50:56.852 --> 02:51:01.807
<v Unidentified speaker>Feel free to unmute yourself and begin your Thank you, Council.

1372
02:51:02.096 --> 02:51:05.050
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Uh, I represent the lender, Center Street Lending.

1373
02:51:05.245 --> 02:51:06.987
<v Andy Chopkanyan>They're actually the current property owner.

1374
02:51:07.810 --> 02:51:10.996
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Uh, I'm an attorney representing them, so I'm just speaking on their behalf.

1375
02:51:11.853 --> 02:51:15.558
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Um, I just want to introduce my client and give them some quick background on them.

1376
02:51:16.139 --> 02:51:19.552
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Uh, they are indeed a real estate and construction lender.

1377
02:51:20.264 --> 02:51:40.136
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Uh, what makes them different, however, is, uh, they saw an opportunity where there was a— there's a significant housing shortage, and part of the problem is that a lot of these banks will not lend to developers or property owners in order to improve these properties and increase the housing supply.

1378
02:51:40.826 --> 02:51:49.256
<v Andy Chopkanyan>My client saw an opportunity there, and now they've made a business out of loaning money to people for properties that the banks won't touch.

1379
02:51:49.915 --> 02:52:01.972
<v Andy Chopkanyan>So in essence, They're trying to be part of the solution rather than contribute to the problem that is plaguing a lot of the West Coast, including Portland.

1380
02:52:03.001 --> 02:52:10.450
<v Andy Chopkanyan>So what happened here was that my client lent money to the prior owner when the property was nearly complete.

1381
02:52:11.397 --> 02:52:16.375
<v Andy Chopkanyan>It burned down, and then my and that he just disappeared.

1382
02:52:16.859 --> 02:52:18.361
<v Andy Chopkanyan>He left the liens in place.

1383
02:52:18.506 --> 02:52:19.523
<v Andy Chopkanyan>He never paid anything.

1384
02:52:19.620 --> 02:52:21.236
<v Andy Chopkanyan>He never paid my client.

1385
02:52:22.123 --> 02:52:25.481
<v Andy Chopkanyan>When my client foreclosed, they discovered the property had been burned down.

1386
02:52:26.788 --> 02:52:33.950
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Rather than simply leaving it as is, as a lot of those other properties on that list were, they developed the property.

1387
02:52:34.079 --> 02:52:39.515
<v Andy Chopkanyan>It is now a 19-unit— so it's a 19-unit apartment building.

1388
02:52:39.629 --> 02:52:41.774
<v Andy Chopkanyan>It was originally simply a 4-bedroom house.

1389
02:52:41.888 --> 02:52:43.112
<v Andy Chopkanyan>They've turned it into a 19-bedroom.

1390
02:52:44.268 --> 02:52:53.077
<v Andy Chopkanyan>19 Apartments, and they're, I believe by next week, should have an occupancy permit.

1391
02:52:53.530 --> 02:52:55.585
<v Andy Chopkanyan>And so they're going to try and start to lease these properties.

1392
02:52:56.971 --> 02:53:09.343
<v Andy Chopkanyan>What I'd be asking the city council— I've tried to negotiate and maybe come to some kind of solution with the city to stop this foreclosure so that my client and the city can come to some arrangement.

1393
02:53:09.391 --> 02:53:09.505
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Thank you.

1394
02:53:10.847 --> 02:53:14.170
<v Andy Chopkanyan>So far, I've not heard back.

1395
02:53:17.250 --> 02:53:22.846
<v Andy Chopkanyan>The city's taken quite a rigid stance despite these circumstances to foreclose on the property.

1396
02:53:23.539 --> 02:53:36.424
<v Andy Chopkanyan>And if you were to move with foreclosure today, it would not— it would essentially preclude my client and the city from coming to some kind of solution to resolve this issue.

1397
02:53:41.274 --> 02:54:01.505
<v Andy Chopkanyan>By taking this aggressive, aggressive stance in favor of foreclosure rather than coming to some kind of resolution on these liens and helping my client help the City of Portland, I'd ask the city to not allow foreclosure, uh, to move forward and, uh, to allow us to come to some resolution to allow, uh, my client to help the city of Portland.

1398
02:54:01.569 --> 02:54:01.906
<v Andy Chopkanyan>Thank you.

1399
02:54:02.147 --> 02:54:05.808
<v Andy Chopkanyan>To come to some resolution with the city regarding these liens.

1400
02:54:10.579 --> 02:54:25.370
<v Boz Epley>Next we have for document number 2026-256, initiate foreclosure action on 2734-2738 Northeast Alberta Street for the collection of delinquent city liens placed against the property.

1401
02:54:26.211 --> 02:54:27.103
<v Boz Epley>Boz Epley.

1402
02:54:28.067 --> 02:54:29.415
<v Boz Epley>Baz is joining us online.

1403
02:54:29.691 --> 02:54:32.031
<v Boz Epley>Feel free to unmute and begin your testimony when you're ready.

1404
02:54:43.078 --> 02:54:46.085
<v Baz Epley>Good afternoon again, Chair, members of the committee, Kevin.

1405
02:54:46.441 --> 02:54:51.209
<v Baz Epley>Thank you for allowing me to testify regarding 2734 to 2738 Northeast Alberta Street.

1406
02:54:51.938 --> 02:54:53.361
<v Baz Epley>My name is Baz Epley, District 2.

1407
02:54:53.742 --> 02:54:56.538
<v Baz Epley>I'm here as the custodian for the minor owner of this property.

1408
02:54:57.342 --> 02:55:02.579
<v Baz Epley>Although the property records identify DJE Building LLC as the reported owner, the owner of this asset is a minor.

1409
02:55:03.384 --> 02:55:06.853
<v Baz Epley>The minor owner has not personally participated in communications regarding this matter.

1410
02:55:07.159 --> 02:55:11.594
<v Baz Epley>I've been the individual communicating with the city and acting in my legal and fiduciary capacity as custodian.

1411
02:55:12.204 --> 02:55:19.099
<v Baz Epley>Throughout my testimony, when I refer to actions taken for the property owner, I'm referring to actions I have taken on the minor owner's behalf in that custodial capacity.

1412
02:55:20.430 --> 02:55:32.759
<v Baz Epley>To preserve and protect the minor owner's asset, I understand the purpose of the city's foreclosure program, and I understand the need to address properties that create health, safety, and neighborhood concerns.

1413
02:55:33.680 --> 02:55:39.268
<v Baz Epley>However, I respectfully ask the committee to consider that this property presents circumstances different from the typical distressed property case.

1414
02:55:39.364 --> 02:55:44.309
<v Baz Epley>I'd like to address the city's own evaluation criteria point by point.

1415
02:55:44.682 --> 02:55:45.879
<v Baz Epley>First, I recognize that there are outstanding.

1416
02:55:45.989 --> 02:55:49.277
<v Baz Epley>Outstanding liens and that the property has been subject to code enforcement concerns.

1417
02:55:49.566 --> 02:55:51.923
<v Baz Epley>I'm not asking the committee to disregard those concerns.

1418
02:55:52.579 --> 02:55:58.032
<v Baz Epley>The question is whether foreclosure is the appropriate next step given the circumstances and the efforts that have been made to resolve them.

1419
02:55:58.995 --> 02:56:05.875
<v Baz Epley>The city's own report recognizes that steps were taken to correct the violations and that the property owner was cooperative in making efforts towards resolution.

1420
02:56:06.628 --> 02:56:20.219
<v Baz Epley>Those efforts included obtaining engineering assessments, addressing safety concerns, communicating with city staff, and completing demolition The demolition of the above-grade structure was a significant part of addressing the city's safety concerns.

1421
02:56:21.250 --> 02:56:24.729
<v Baz Epley>The report also states that the property owner did not have a plan in place to correct the violations.

1422
02:56:25.430 --> 02:56:28.649
<v Baz Epley>I respectfully believe the record does not fully reflect the efforts undertaken.

1423
02:56:29.049 --> 02:56:31.219
<v Baz Epley>The challenge has not been a lack of effort or cooperation.

1424
02:56:31.850 --> 02:56:39.829
<v Baz Epley>The challenge has been navigating a complex situation involving flood damage, required demolition, limited resources, and a process where the remaining obligations were not fully understood.

1425
02:56:39.829 --> 02:56:39.870
<v Baz Epley>Thank you.

1426
02:56:40.979 --> 02:56:58.286
<v Baz Epley>To continue advancing the city's requirements and preserve the minor owner's asset, I sold my own property and devoted approximately half a million dollars toward expenses associated with this property, including paying for contractors, legal expenses, taxes, title expenses, and city-related obligations, which were referenced by Kevin.

1427
02:56:59.120 --> 02:57:00.902
<v Baz Epley>Those resources have now been exhausted.

1428
02:57:01.745 --> 02:57:05.375
<v Baz Epley>Despite these efforts, the remaining lien burden has become the primary obstacle to resolution.

1429
02:57:05.760 --> 02:57:15.559
<v Baz Epley>Multiple potential buyers have expressed concern about the outstanding liens, making it difficult to transfer the property to someone who could resolve the outstanding obligations and return the property to productive use.

1430
02:57:15.959 --> 02:57:19.799
<v Baz Epley>I respectfully believe this case is closer to resolution than to abandonment.

1431
02:57:20.340 --> 02:57:28.819
<v Baz Epley>The city's materials state that foreclosure is a last resort and identify other tools including resolution agreements, fee waivers for engaged owners, and lien reduction review after case closure.

1432
02:57:29.280 --> 02:57:32.940
<v Baz Epley>Throughout this process, I've attempted to work with the city to understand and resolve the outstanding liens.

1433
02:57:32.940 --> 02:57:32.979
<v Baz Epley>Thank you.

1434
02:57:33.129 --> 02:57:48.100
<v Baz Epley>I did not understand that additional resolution tools, including fee waivers, payment arrangements, or agreements for resolution, were available until reviewing the materials for this hearing.

1435
02:57:48.299 --> 02:57:53.799
<v Baz Epley>I respectfully ask the committee to allow this matter to continue through the city's remaining resolution pathway, authorizing our pledge.

1436
02:57:53.799 --> 02:57:55.079
<v Baz Epley>Thank you for your time and consideration.

1437
02:57:57.120 --> 02:57:58.329
<v Unidentified speaker>That concludes testimony.

1438
02:57:59.066 --> 02:58:03.539
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, uh, colleagues.

1439
02:58:04.532 --> 02:58:05.638
<v Candace Avalos>So it is 4:53.

1440
02:58:05.718 --> 02:58:07.049
<v Candace Avalos>I know we're running close on time.

1441
02:58:07.096 --> 02:58:11.040
<v Candace Avalos>Let's get through these questions and see if we're able to complete this by 5.

1442
02:58:11.088 --> 02:58:19.376
<v Candace Avalos>I know some folks have some hard outs, um, and I'm waiting to get confirmation on the timing urgency as well in case we do have to move it forward.

1443
02:58:19.424 --> 02:58:20.707
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll work on getting that answer.

1444
02:58:21.347 --> 02:58:23.448
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, go ahead and start.

1445
02:58:24.073 --> 02:58:24.665
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1446
02:58:24.890 --> 02:58:29.924
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will I'll limit myself to the 2 properties that I had the most questions about.

1447
02:58:30.662 --> 02:58:36.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is the property at 10104 Southeast Herald Street.

1448
02:58:37.379 --> 02:58:45.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You said that there was somebody who was related to the owner who had passed away who had been living on site and wasn't there anymore.

1449
02:58:45.555 --> 02:59:06.244
<v Kevin Foster>And did you say that the person who is inhabiting the garage is related to the family, or is Yes, I received information earlier today that, um, the executor of the trust had actually reached out to PP&D to try and get that person that is living in the garage out of the property.

1450
02:59:06.981 --> 02:59:09.423
<v Kevin Foster>And the information I have is they're just somehow connected.

1451
02:59:09.550 --> 02:59:14.191
<v Kevin Foster>I don't know if they're an actual family member, but they're somehow connected to that family.

1452
02:59:14.786 --> 02:59:15.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1453
02:59:15.266 --> 02:59:27.566
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I You know, I know that the city as an entire entity takes this work really seriously and that there's a lot of steps we go through to try to ensure we're not foreclosing on people.

1454
02:59:30.209 --> 02:59:50.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think when there has been an owner who is deceased, I pause as I look at these because I wonder how much of the lack of movement is because things are caught up in probate or in determining next of kin and ownership after somebody is deceased.

1455
02:59:51.240 --> 02:59:55.144
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you know, in the case of this property, you said you've been in touch with an executor.

1456
02:59:56.219 --> 03:00:18.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is this a case where things have been delayed because there are complications having to do with the owner's death and ensuring that the, the person who inherits this property knows that it is in their possession and has and gets it legally in their possession, or has there been an unwillingness to work on this one?

1457
03:00:19.500 --> 03:00:23.793
<v Kevin Foster>I actually have not spoken with any of the relatives to the property.

1458
03:00:24.227 --> 03:00:31.085
<v Kevin Foster>The executor of the estate actually reached out to— had a conversation with the housing inspector, and this is the information that I'm getting from them.

1459
03:00:31.597 --> 03:00:35.278
<v Kevin Foster>And they are aware that we are Moving to foreclosure.

1460
03:00:35.592 --> 03:00:36.816
<v Kevin Foster>They have received our notices.

1461
03:00:38.153 --> 03:00:40.614
<v Kevin Foster>They just— I just have not been able to get ahold of anyone.

1462
03:00:41.756 --> 03:00:52.703
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so this may be a case where foreclosure is a tool to obtain the cash for the probate or whatever is happening with the estate.

1463
03:00:53.323 --> 03:00:53.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that—.

1464
03:00:54.049 --> 03:00:56.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm trying to understand what's happening with this property.

1465
03:01:00.174 --> 03:01:12.975
<v Kevin Foster>You know, as far as I can see, it's just pretty much an abandoned property because there is— because once they— because they're aware just from what I read from the housing inspector that the property is going to foreclosure.

1466
03:01:14.467 --> 03:01:21.268
<v Kevin Foster>And I'm sure the housing inspector gave them my contact information and I have not heard from anyone from the property, any of the ownership.

1467
03:01:21.668 --> 03:01:22.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1468
03:01:22.310 --> 03:01:24.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's helpful information and background to have.

1469
03:01:25.263 --> 03:01:27.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>On 855 Northeast Church Street.

1470
03:01:27.690 --> 03:01:27.834
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1471
03:01:28.173 --> 03:01:33.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This again is a property where we have an individual who owns it, not a company.

1472
03:01:35.835 --> 03:01:37.969
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's somebody who's local in the community.

1473
03:01:39.117 --> 03:01:41.251
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you help us understand?

1474
03:01:41.299 --> 03:01:47.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You said that you were in touch with this individual, but you didn't list this as a property that you thought would likely be coming off the list.

1475
03:01:47.620 --> 03:01:49.753
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you help us understand what's happening here?

1476
03:01:50.512 --> 03:01:51.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've got some concerns on this one.

1477
03:01:51.899 --> 03:02:06.390
<v Kevin Foster>So this property has suffered extensive, extensive damage, and I, you know, the property owner is engaged, and I want to give her an opportunity to— I want to give her an opportunity to see if she's able to follow through with her plan.

1478
03:02:06.440 --> 03:02:11.889
<v Kevin Foster>And her plan is to rehab the whole property and put it into adult foster care.

1479
03:02:12.450 --> 03:02:17.067
<v Kevin Foster>So I'm going to focus on reaching out to her to see if she can come up with a plan that we can all agree on.

1480
03:02:17.180 --> 03:02:17.661
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1481
03:02:20.369 --> 03:02:26.211
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if we don't move a property forward, when is the next time that foreclosure lists come to this committee?

1482
03:02:28.272 --> 03:02:30.909
<v Kevin Foster>Well, we don't have a date set yet for the next time.

1483
03:02:31.185 --> 03:02:34.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we're not on a cadence yet of like quarterly or something like that?

1484
03:02:35.068 --> 03:02:36.783
<v Kevin Foster>That's our ultimate goal, is to come quarterly.

1485
03:02:37.091 --> 03:02:38.141
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1486
03:02:39.338 --> 03:02:43.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, you had said we might be able to remove things from the list to vote separately.

1487
03:02:43.090 --> 03:02:43.608
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not sure what that means.

1488
03:02:43.832 --> 03:02:48.699
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm happy to follow your lead as a D1 councilor on if you have concerns on that Southeast Herald property or not.

1489
03:02:49.479 --> 03:03:04.753
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not sure if I'm comfortable moving forward the Northeast Church Street property today if it sounds like there's going to be more time needed than just the few weeks between now and when this gets to full council for that property owner, but that there is engagement.

1490
03:03:05.270 --> 03:03:07.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'd ask that we vote on that one separately.

1491
03:03:07.967 --> 03:03:08.144
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1492
03:03:09.329 --> 03:03:11.605
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And happy to stop with questions there.

1493
03:03:14.309 --> 03:03:16.156
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, let me get the num— the item number for you.

1494
03:03:16.204 --> 03:03:18.683
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just have the address in front of me, but I'll, I'll shoot that to you.

1495
03:03:21.505 --> 03:03:22.038
<v Candace Avalos>Vice Chair Green.

1496
03:03:23.909 --> 03:03:25.572
<v Mitch Green>I just wanted to thank you, uh, Chair.

1497
03:03:25.845 --> 03:03:27.912
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I wanted clarification.

1498
03:03:27.959 --> 03:03:33.725
<v Mitch Green>There was a gentleman who was the, uh, I think is Andy, um, was speaking to a property.

1499
03:03:33.773 --> 03:03:42.713
<v Mitch Green>I can't remember, I couldn't piece together which property that was because they were describing something like 19-unit building, but I didn't see something that looked like a 19-unit property in your slide deck.

1500
03:03:42.778 --> 03:03:44.891
<v Mitch Green>So do you have an indication of what they were speaking to?

1501
03:03:45.198 --> 03:03:48.841
<v Kevin Foster>Yes, that's the property at 6307 North Montana Avenue.

1502
03:03:49.227 --> 03:03:49.566
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1503
03:03:51.257 --> 03:03:52.578
<v Mitch Green>And do you have a response to that testimony?

1504
03:03:53.599 --> 03:04:03.390
<v Kevin Foster>Yes, I actually spoke with him yesterday because we've been talking pretty regularly the last couple of weeks and we're working on some type of payment plan to come up with So we can get this removed.

1505
03:04:03.439 --> 03:04:05.713
<v Kevin Foster>He was supposed to actually meet with his client today.

1506
03:04:08.255 --> 03:04:09.497
<v Kevin Foster>And again, I'll follow up with him tomorrow.

1507
03:04:09.547 --> 03:04:13.757
<v Mitch Green>So this is already slated to be sort of potentially be removed from this consideration?

1508
03:04:13.887 --> 03:04:14.031
<v Kevin Foster>Yes.

1509
03:04:14.612 --> 03:04:14.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1510
03:04:15.193 --> 03:04:18.451
<v Mitch Green>Well, I'm prepared to pull off the other one there, Councilor.

1511
03:04:18.536 --> 03:04:19.963
<v Mitch Green>I thought your line of questioning was fair.

1512
03:04:21.700 --> 03:04:22.652
<v Mitch Green>The Herald Street property.

1513
03:04:24.360 --> 03:04:25.931
<v Mitch Green>I think other than that, I'm—.

1514
03:04:26.626 --> 03:04:32.662
<v Candace Avalos>Just to clarify that So what you told me was the Church Street one, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, but you're saying the Herald Street one.

1515
03:04:32.727 --> 03:04:33.324
<v Candace Avalos>Those are 2 different ones.

1516
03:04:33.371 --> 03:04:34.694
<v Candace Avalos>So do you also want that one to be pulled off?

1517
03:04:34.744 --> 03:04:37.582
<v Mitch Green>No, I just want to pull off— I just want to support what you're trying to support.

1518
03:04:37.727 --> 03:04:48.368
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had questions about the Herald Street property, but was not at the level of concern that I would go above what our colleagues who represent that district would do.

1519
03:04:48.449 --> 03:04:56.656
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The Church Street property felt like we had a situation where somebody was acting in good faith but might not be able to act in time for the council meeting.

1520
03:04:56.769 --> 03:05:02.662
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if we're— if that— if pulling it off would delay action by a year, I would not do so.

1521
03:05:02.726 --> 03:05:22.713
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if pulling it off and voting separately, if it doesn't move forward, would delay action by 2 or 3 months, it seems reasonable to give this person a little more than just a couple of weeks, but to ensure that the process continues forward so that if we're not able to reach some resolution, it comes back to us in the next batch.

1522
03:05:24.889 --> 03:05:27.628
<v Candace Avalos>Process-wise, let me understand.

1523
03:05:27.806 --> 03:05:33.832
<v Candace Avalos>So could it be that we just don't vote on one?

1524
03:05:34.349 --> 03:05:38.100
<v Candace Avalos>You know, like, I guess I'm trying to figure out— it sounds like you want to vote no on it, right?

1525
03:05:38.536 --> 03:05:43.158
<v Candace Avalos>And, but if we— yeah, can we continue it to another time or postpone it?

1526
03:05:43.224 --> 03:06:00.770
<v Unidentified speaker>What's the process for I mean, from a procedural perspective, you can make that change, though I think it would be worth having staff verify just in terms of their timelines or potential other notice, what would need to happen or what would happen with those properties that you did not take action on today.

1527
03:06:01.573 --> 03:06:03.018
<v Candace Avalos>Could you answer that question then, staff?

1528
03:06:04.398 --> 03:06:09.922
<v Kevin Foster>So I'm real hesitant about taking this property off the list just because of the delinquency.

1529
03:06:10.163 --> 03:06:12.459
<v Kevin Foster>This case has been open since 2009.

1530
03:06:14.159 --> 03:06:29.314
<v Kevin Foster>The property owner, you know, there's a lot— this, this was actually, um, part of a prior foreclosure as well back in 2024 that we removed from to allow time for the property owner to resolve the issues.

1531
03:06:30.073 --> 03:06:32.738
<v Kevin Foster>And, you know, here we are to date in the same stance.

1532
03:06:33.370 --> 03:06:38.551
<v Kevin Foster>Also, another thing is that the property is also creating a rodent issue.

1533
03:06:38.648 --> 03:06:38.729
<v Kevin Foster>Yes.

1534
03:06:39.298 --> 03:06:39.925
<v Kevin Foster>For the neighbors.

1535
03:06:41.488 --> 03:06:44.565
<v Kevin Foster>And I just— I'm pretty reluctant about removing it from the list.

1536
03:06:47.167 --> 03:06:47.378
<v Kevin Foster>Okay.

1537
03:06:47.539 --> 03:06:53.308
<v Kevin Foster>But I think— I mean, this may help her know— the property owner knowing that this is the next step.

1538
03:06:54.146 --> 03:06:55.725
<v Kevin Foster>We're at this stage now.

1539
03:06:56.575 --> 03:06:57.717
<v Kevin Foster>We're serious about this.

1540
03:06:57.781 --> 03:07:04.674
<v Kevin Foster>We're serious about moving this forward if they're not— if she's not able to get into some type of resolution for this property.

1541
03:07:05.588 --> 03:07:12.818
<v Jonas Biery>And Chair, if I may just add some color, I think to answer your question, for the record, Jonas Berry, Chief Financial Officer.

1542
03:07:13.397 --> 03:07:28.870
<v Jonas Biery>From a process perspective, so as Kevin identified, what happens next is anything that moves past this committee will go to Council, I believe in 2 weeks for a first reading and then for a second reading, which eventually will put this on the foreclosure list.

1543
03:07:30.202 --> 03:07:31.119
<v Jonas Biery>So those will move as a batch.

1544
03:07:31.377 --> 03:07:33.431
<v Jonas Biery>That then move as a batch to the next sale.

1545
03:07:34.628 --> 03:07:50.218
<v Jonas Biery>If one property were to not go forward from this committee, it would essentially be out of the queue for that next council action, and it would continue to marinate out in whatever form it is to come back to eventually a committee again in the future.

1546
03:07:50.299 --> 03:07:54.354
<v Jonas Biery>I know, as Kevin said, we're targeting starting to get back on a quarterly-ish cadence.

1547
03:07:55.459 --> 03:07:58.263
<v Jonas Biery>So procedurally, what would happen if that did not proceed from committee today?

1548
03:07:58.343 --> 03:07:58.408
<v Jonas Biery>Okay.

1549
03:07:59.227 --> 03:08:04.093
<v Jonas Biery>Is it would probably not be on a path to stay aligned with the current properties and it would essentially force a delay.

1550
03:08:04.605 --> 03:08:17.162
<v Jonas Biery>There is an option, should committee choose, to move it forward from committee and then take that action to pull it out of the council queue when that vote comes in a couple weeks.

1551
03:08:17.226 --> 03:08:19.378
<v Jonas Biery>But that's at the discretion of the committee, obviously.

1552
03:08:19.876 --> 03:08:35.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Chair, I know we're on a tight timeline today and I was actually about to get back into the queue I would like to suggest that if we move this forward today, I'm comfortable having the conversation about pulling it potentially from the batch at full council.

1553
03:08:35.854 --> 03:08:36.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All right.

1554
03:08:36.338 --> 03:08:49.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would ask that— I'd ask that you put in a request to the council president that we have the opportunity to look at these and not have them just end up on a consent agenda.

1555
03:08:54.094 --> 03:09:00.838
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If the easy ones do, sure, but to make sure that they're not on consent as a batch where it's hard to pull just one thing out.

1556
03:09:01.320 --> 03:09:04.307
<v Candace Avalos>I have one other suggestion, and let's hear from you all too.

1557
03:09:05.174 --> 03:09:09.926
<v Candace Avalos>Just because we are at the end, this sounds like there's lots of questions, and it might not just be those properties.

1558
03:09:09.975 --> 03:09:11.565
<v Candace Avalos>I know I have questions for other things too.

1559
03:09:12.304 --> 03:09:15.578
<v Candace Avalos>Do we want to move this to August 4th?

1560
03:09:15.932 --> 03:09:28.414
<v Candace Avalos>Would that be okay timeline if we just take all of these and just put them to August 4th, just delay it by committee action by 2 weeks, and then hopefully we can get some decisions in committee then, have more time, and then from there it can move on.

1561
03:09:28.462 --> 03:09:33.789
<v Candace Avalos>So it's just really just a 2-week delay instead of taking things out and putting them on different timelines like you're saying.

1562
03:09:33.900 --> 03:09:37.656
<v Candace Avalos>And I wanted to gauge how people feel about that, but what is your response to that?

1563
03:09:37.736 --> 03:09:40.431
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, Councilor, I think, I mean, that's doable.

1564
03:09:40.478 --> 03:09:42.870
<v Jonas Biery>I think the couple of Questions?

1565
03:09:43.031 --> 03:09:55.459
<v Jonas Biery>I don't know whether— I think if it's a decision for Council President, I don't know procedurally whether something going to a committee on the 4th allows space with public notification, et cetera, to get it on an agenda for the 6th.

1566
03:09:55.556 --> 03:10:01.078
<v Jonas Biery>So I think it would punt that first reading to the 13th if I'm thinking of these dates correctly.

1567
03:10:01.433 --> 03:10:11.620
<v Jonas Biery>And then my understanding is Council's on recess for a couple of weeks, so that would functionally kick the decision out 3 weeks, 3 or 4 weeks, which might be manageable.

1568
03:10:11.684 --> 03:10:14.539
<v Jonas Biery>Again, at the discretion of the committee and the council to decide.

1569
03:10:15.067 --> 03:10:19.556
<v Jonas Biery>We do have also noticing requirements that we have to provide related to this.

1570
03:10:19.700 --> 03:10:27.988
<v Jonas Biery>So we just need to make sure that we have some clarity about that timeline so we can meet those reporting notification requirements.

1571
03:10:28.373 --> 03:10:35.909
<v Candace Avalos>I think because time is an issue that people have, That might actually be helpful because then it doesn't delay it too far down.

1572
03:10:35.959 --> 03:10:41.271
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, 3, 2, 3, even a month delay I'm okay with if we feel okay with that.

1573
03:10:41.760 --> 03:10:44.674
<v Candace Avalos>Um, that August, we— it wouldn't be for August 6th, right?

1574
03:10:44.724 --> 03:10:46.548
<v Candace Avalos>We would have to move it one more council meeting.

1575
03:10:47.209 --> 03:10:56.180
<v Candace Avalos>But just given the timing and the discomfort that we're having with making the decision now, I would personally rather just move this to the next committee meeting and go from there.

1576
03:10:56.503 --> 03:10:57.637
<v Candace Avalos>Does that feel doable for staff?

1577
03:10:58.537 --> 03:10:59.531
<v Jonas Biery>I think it's manageable.

1578
03:10:59.578 --> 03:11:05.525
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, I'll have to, I think, renotice folks about those timelines, but we can technically administer that.

1579
03:11:05.846 --> 03:11:16.861
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, well then I will go ahead and say we are going to continue items 4 through 18 minus item 8 to the August 4th committee meeting and we'll pick it up from there.

1580
03:11:17.469 --> 03:11:17.727
<v Candace Avalos>Sound good?

1581
03:11:18.288 --> 03:11:18.784
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1582
03:11:19.234 --> 03:11:20.644
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you so much for your time.

1583
03:11:20.756 --> 03:11:21.286
<v Kevin Foster>Thank you.

1584
03:11:22.360 --> 03:11:33.343
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, colleagues, then with that, and part of why I said that is 'cause the August 4th agenda is still a little bit, So I, I think we have some time to fit that in, um, and I'll let you know what else is on that agenda.

1585
03:11:33.585 --> 03:11:35.950
<v Candace Avalos>Otherwise, we are adjourned at 5:07 PM.

1586
03:11:37.315 --> 03:11:38.971
<v Baz Epley>Thank you.

