WEBVTT

1
00:08:15.259 --> 00:08:16.353
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, all right.

2
00:08:32.350 --> 00:08:33.173
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor.

3
00:08:33.254 --> 00:08:33.803
<v Dan Ryan>Is this working?

4
00:08:34.062 --> 00:08:35.033
<v Queesha Light>You can pre-gavel.

5
00:08:35.615 --> 00:08:36.003
<v David Straub>Go for it.

6
00:08:36.421 --> 00:08:37.850
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, Councilor Ryan.

7
00:08:38.105 --> 00:08:40.947
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, Sameer, it's like coming from outer space, like, hi.

8
00:08:42.038 --> 00:08:47.577
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Kanal, um, thank you for the honor of having a moment to do a little important recap today.

9
00:08:47.962 --> 00:09:01.511
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I think some of you now know that, uh, someone is leaving City Hall after over 2 decades of service, and that person, um, has been my chief of staff since, um, the beginning of 2025.

10
00:09:02.571 --> 00:09:04.562
<v Dan Ryan>Actually, we started In that, in December.

11
00:09:05.461 --> 00:09:11.705
<v Dan Ryan>And so I have the privilege of reading the mayor's proclamation about this important moment in time.

12
00:09:13.020 --> 00:09:15.894
<v Dan Ryan>So first of all, Kezia, thank you for coming to the meeting today.

13
00:09:17.033 --> 00:09:19.761
<v Dan Ryan>Now you know why I was insistent that you had to be here at 2 o'clock.

14
00:09:20.003 --> 00:09:20.692
<v Kezia Warner>Oh, it's a surprise?

15
00:09:20.885 --> 00:09:23.100
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, it's a surprise.

16
00:09:24.240 --> 00:09:25.587
<v Dan Ryan>And so here it is.

17
00:09:26.903 --> 00:09:55.649
<v Dan Ryan>Whereas Kezia Warner, has devoted more than 2 decades, 2 decades to the City of Portland, serving with exceptional leadership, integrity, and unwavering dedication across numerous bureaus, including the Portland Bureau of Transportation, the City Budget Office, Portland Police Bureau, Portland Fire and Rescue, and the City Council Office of Councilor Dan Ryan.

18
00:09:56.563 --> 00:10:08.038
<v Dan Ryan>Whereas, during her tenure in the City Budget Office, she strengthened the city's budgeting practices through her skilled financial analysis and practical resource management.

19
00:10:09.081 --> 00:10:22.384
<v Dan Ryan>Whereas, in the Portland Police Bureau, she efficiently oversaw core budget and procurement functions and supported key administrative and operational needs with clarity and professionalism.

20
00:10:23.220 --> 00:10:24.552
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry, I had to smile at clarity.

21
00:10:25.836 --> 00:10:26.735
<v Dan Ryan>She's so good at clarity.

22
00:10:27.282 --> 00:10:42.758
<v Dan Ryan>Whereas within the budget, the Portland Bureau of Transportation, Kezia served as the Parking Enforcement Division Manager, providing steady leadership and operational oversight that improved division performance and supported bureau-wide priorities.

23
00:10:44.154 --> 00:11:02.816
<v Dan Ryan>Whereas as Deputy Director of Portland Fire and Rescue, she delivered impactful executive leadership, guiding administrative services, logistics, personnel, communications, technology, data analytics, and major strategic initiatives for Oregon's largest fire agency.

24
00:11:03.330 --> 00:11:16.322
<v Dan Ryan>Whereas across every role, Kezia led with grace, humility, and a deep commitment to serving Portland wherever her expertise and steady leadership were needed.

25
00:11:17.509 --> 00:11:29.110
<v Dan Ryan>Whereas her insight, collaboration, and genuine care for the city and its employees made her an invaluable asset whose presence will be deeply missed by the City of Portland.

26
00:11:30.505 --> 00:11:43.309
<v Dan Ryan>Now therefore, the City of Roses does hereby proclaim July 15th, 2026 to be Kezia Warner Day in Portland, and we encourage all residents to observe this very special day.

27
00:11:43.710 --> 00:11:46.514
<v Dan Ryan>Let's hear it for Kezia.

28
00:11:55.601 --> 00:11:57.580
<v Kezia Warner>Thank you so much.

29
00:11:57.933 --> 00:11:58.528
<v Kezia Warner>Oh, do I have to say—.

30
00:11:58.642 --> 00:12:02.292
<v Dan Ryan>Would you like to say a couple things and introduce your special guest?

31
00:12:02.822 --> 00:12:03.433
<v Kezia Warner>Oh, sure.

32
00:12:05.732 --> 00:12:07.903
<v Kezia Warner>This is a surprise for sure.

33
00:12:08.788 --> 00:12:12.986
<v Kezia Warner>Thank you so much, Kezia Warner, uh, Chief of Staff, Councilor Dan Ryan.

34
00:12:13.475 --> 00:12:17.576
<v Kezia Warner>As you know, and I have my family and friends here in the audience.

35
00:12:18.282 --> 00:12:21.741
<v Kezia Warner>I'm so surprised and touched by this.

36
00:12:22.607 --> 00:12:23.408
<v Kezia Warner>Had no idea.

37
00:12:24.866 --> 00:12:28.038
<v Kezia Warner>But everything that you say, I did things.

38
00:12:28.150 --> 00:12:29.159
<v Kezia Warner>I did things for the city.

39
00:12:29.832 --> 00:12:31.578
<v Kezia Warner>I did things for the people of Portland.

40
00:12:32.797 --> 00:12:34.399
<v Kezia Warner>I loved every minute of it.

41
00:12:34.943 --> 00:12:43.691
<v Kezia Warner>I believe in service to the city, and it's been a great honor to be able to serve in those roles and to serve alongside all of you.

42
00:12:43.754 --> 00:12:43.979
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

43
00:12:44.759 --> 00:12:47.668
<v Kezia Warner>So thank you for this recognition.

44
00:12:48.250 --> 00:12:59.456
<v Kezia Warner>There's so many good, hard-working employees that are out in the city buildings right now that are doing the work every day, and I was one of them, and I was proud to be one of them.

45
00:13:00.604 --> 00:13:03.744
<v Kezia Warner>So with this, I say farewell and not goodbye.

46
00:13:04.822 --> 00:13:10.755
<v Kezia Warner>You know where to find me if you would like to continue the relationship, but thank you for your service too.

47
00:13:12.159 --> 00:13:13.113
<v Kezia Warner>So thank you.

48
00:13:21.422 --> 00:13:23.714
<v Dan Ryan>And thank you, family, for coordinating that surprise.

49
00:13:24.267 --> 00:13:28.495
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I was worried she's going to see your text messages, Chris.

50
00:13:28.658 --> 00:13:28.916
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

51
00:13:30.129 --> 00:13:31.552
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, Chair, it's all yours.

52
00:13:34.086 --> 00:13:35.754
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much, uh, Councilor Ryan.

53
00:13:36.028 --> 00:13:40.965
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll just join in by saying I, I've appreciated having the opportunity to work with Kezia in your office, in our district office, for the last year and a half.

54
00:13:43.303 --> 00:13:43.964
<v Sameer Kanal>And you'll be missed.

55
00:13:44.416 --> 00:13:48.250
<v Sameer Kanal>And, um, with that, I will officially gavel this meeting to order.

56
00:13:48.524 --> 00:13:51.294
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I don't know if one of my vice chairs would like to actually hit the gavel.

57
00:13:51.504 --> 00:13:57.071
<v Sameer Kanal>It's 2:08 PM on July 15th, 2026.

58
00:13:57.168 --> 00:13:59.264
<v Sameer Kanal>And with that, Rebecca, if you could please call the roll.

59
00:14:02.389 --> 00:14:02.809
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

60
00:14:03.133 --> 00:14:03.261
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

61
00:14:03.860 --> 00:14:04.264
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo?

62
00:14:06.607 --> 00:14:06.736
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

63
00:14:07.592 --> 00:14:08.077
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

64
00:14:08.224 --> 00:14:08.498
<v Steve Novick>Here.

65
00:14:08.951 --> 00:14:09.225
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

66
00:14:10.970 --> 00:14:11.130
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

67
00:14:11.229 --> 00:14:11.357
<v Mitch Green>Here.

68
00:14:12.038 --> 00:14:12.427
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

69
00:14:14.144 --> 00:14:14.533
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

70
00:14:15.440 --> 00:14:16.315
<v Candace Avalos>Present virtually.

71
00:14:17.157 --> 00:14:17.529
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

72
00:14:17.870 --> 00:14:17.982
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

73
00:14:18.452 --> 00:14:18.825
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

74
00:14:19.149 --> 00:14:19.214
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

75
00:14:19.744 --> 00:14:20.354
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

76
00:14:23.359 --> 00:14:23.727
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

77
00:14:23.985 --> 00:14:24.114
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

78
00:14:24.948 --> 00:14:25.254
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

79
00:14:27.615 --> 00:14:27.729
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

80
00:14:28.725 --> 00:14:28.918
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

81
00:14:28.966 --> 00:14:31.392
<v Sameer Kanal>And Christopher, if you could please read the statement of conduct.

82
00:14:32.515 --> 00:14:35.360
<v Christopher>Welcome to the meeting of the Finance and Governance Committee of the Whole.

83
00:14:35.552 --> 00:14:49.230
<v Christopher>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

84
00:14:49.590 --> 00:14:52.620
<v Christopher>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

85
00:14:53.049 --> 00:14:55.889
<v Christopher>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

86
00:14:56.090 --> 00:15:00.789
<v Rebecca Dobert>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

87
00:15:00.929 --> 00:15:02.960
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

88
00:15:03.149 --> 00:15:04.230
<v Rebecca Dobert>The chair preserves order.

89
00:15:04.230 --> 00:15:10.610
<v Rebecca Dobert>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

90
00:15:10.610 --> 00:15:10.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Councilor If Dan Ryan.

91
00:15:10.732 --> 00:15:12.383
<v Rebecca Dobert>You cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

92
00:15:12.495 --> 00:15:14.663
<v Rebecca Dobert>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

93
00:15:15.019 --> 00:15:17.738
<v Rebecca Dobert>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

94
00:15:18.158 --> 00:15:20.643
<v Rebecca Dobert>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

95
00:15:20.996 --> 00:15:23.020
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

96
00:15:23.068 --> 00:15:24.821
<v Rebecca Dobert>When testifying, state your name for the record.

97
00:15:25.077 --> 00:15:27.438
<v Christopher>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

98
00:15:27.825 --> 00:15:30.315
<v Christopher>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

99
00:15:30.539 --> 00:15:30.797
<v Christopher>Thank you.

100
00:15:33.192 --> 00:15:34.461
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Christopher.

101
00:15:35.120 --> 00:15:39.470
<v Sameer Kanal>Colleagues, today we have 5 items on our agenda, 2 of which will be read together.

102
00:15:39.568 --> 00:15:40.485
<v Sameer Kanal>We have our committee chair updates as per usual.

103
00:15:42.381 --> 00:15:45.879
<v Sameer Kanal>We have a proposed appointment of voting members to the Portland Utility Board.

104
00:15:46.778 --> 00:15:48.654
<v Sameer Kanal>Items 3 and 4 will be read together.

105
00:15:48.879 --> 00:15:53.692
<v Sameer Kanal>They are a discussion on Home Forward and public input on Home Forward.

106
00:15:54.254 --> 00:16:18.761
<v Sameer Kanal>I will note that this is based off of a discussion that has occurred in part already at the Housing and Permitting Committee, and we'll hear from Chair Avalos to help frame the content there, but also that this was originally filed alongside Proposed appointments to the Home Forward Board of Directors, which were then— I'm not sure if they were not filed formally or withdrawn by the administration.

107
00:16:19.275 --> 00:16:21.172
<v Sameer Kanal>We've decided to keep that conversation.

108
00:16:21.220 --> 00:16:22.618
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll talk more about that as we're going.

109
00:16:23.518 --> 00:16:34.096
<v Sameer Kanal>And then with time that may be remaining, we'll go into discussion of the follow-up of the fiscal year '25-'26 budget note, Murillo 11, on transparency and information access framework.

110
00:16:34.888 --> 00:16:38.376
<v Sameer Kanal>I guess I'll ask if Rebecca, if you can please call the first item.

111
00:16:39.697 --> 00:16:43.854
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 1, committee chair updates, document number 2026-237.

112
00:16:46.928 --> 00:16:47.524
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, colleagues.

113
00:16:47.590 --> 00:16:59.950
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a relatively short committee update on my end, although we will be hearing from Councilor Avalos as part of the recurring and rotating committee updates.

114
00:17:00.923 --> 00:17:04.884
<v Sameer Kanal>Just for transparency, last week there was going to be a committee meeting scheduled.

115
00:17:04.933 --> 00:17:05.794
<v Sameer Kanal>It was scheduled Thursday morning, July 9th.

116
00:17:08.212 --> 00:17:18.031
<v Sameer Kanal>We had anticipated and seen notices of absence, and so the meeting was canceled because we did not believe we would have enough people here to have a meeting.

117
00:17:19.223 --> 00:17:31.740
<v Sameer Kanal>Coming up, we've got next week Prosper Portland Board of Directors Vision Zero updates and a proposed transfer of the franchise agreement currently given to Zenith to I Squared.

118
00:17:33.443 --> 00:17:51.269
<v Sameer Kanal>On July 30th, there may be a little bit of adjustments to these next but MOTA is coming to the Committee of the Whole on July 30th and August 6th in anticipation of a full council consideration in early August, culminating in a scheduled vote on, I believe, August 12th.

119
00:17:51.381 --> 00:17:51.973
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, 12th.

120
00:17:53.400 --> 00:18:02.211
<v Sameer Kanal>After that, we do take— we have one meeting August 13th where we'll be clearing a lot of other items, as you can see there, to take 2 weeks off and then pick back up.

121
00:18:02.565 --> 00:18:13.551
<v Sameer Kanal>The only other thing I wanted to mention is that the the full CEI Hub conversation, which is not— is a lot broader than the Zenith conversation, is coming in mid to late September.

122
00:18:14.035 --> 00:18:20.471
<v Sameer Kanal>And that the fall technical adjustment ordinances schedule, we've now got a tentative schedule for October 15th.

123
00:18:21.054 --> 00:18:26.518
<v Sameer Kanal>Item 2, you can see all the other items that have been potentially proposed for the Committee of the Whole.

124
00:18:27.196 --> 00:18:31.865
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to get to mentioning, just acknowledging in part 3, the existing workgroups.

125
00:18:31.932 --> 00:18:34.176
<v Sameer Kanal>There's nothing actionable on that yet.

126
00:18:34.226 --> 00:18:34.273
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

127
00:18:34.938 --> 00:18:35.939
<v Sameer Kanal>There will be some work.

128
00:18:36.391 --> 00:18:38.923
<v Sameer Kanal>You probably will hear some more about those next week.

129
00:18:39.553 --> 00:18:47.923
<v Sameer Kanal>And finally, the committee update to the Committee of the Whole from the other 4 committees of this week is Chair Avalos of Housing and Permitting.

130
00:18:47.971 --> 00:18:53.508
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that, I'm going to first ask if there are any questions on my part, and then I'll pass it over to Councilor Avalos.

131
00:18:57.074 --> 00:18:59.500
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing none, Chair Avalos, take it away.

132
00:18:59.548 --> 00:18:59.856
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mr.

133
00:18:59.953 --> 00:19:00.035
<v Candace Avalos>Chair.

134
00:19:07.276 --> 00:19:11.167
<v Michael Bonacore>Okay, one second.

135
00:19:12.057 --> 00:19:13.057
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Chair.

136
00:19:14.140 --> 00:19:18.205
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so, um, let's talk about the Housing and Permitting Committee.

137
00:19:18.287 --> 00:19:22.827
<v Candace Avalos>So as many of you know, the Housing and Homelessness Committee transitioned into Housing and Permitting.

138
00:19:23.326 --> 00:19:36.644
<v Candace Avalos>So while the committee scope has expanded and our committee membership has changed, our focus remains the same on helping Portland build more housing, improving our permitting system, strengthening accountability, and ensuring our policies reflect the needs of our community.

139
00:19:37.720 --> 00:19:42.392
<v Candace Avalos>As it relates to community engagement, throughout our work we've made public engagement a priority.

140
00:19:42.472 --> 00:19:50.534
<v Candace Avalos>So at every meeting we've reserved time for public testimony, giving Portlanders an opportunity to bring forward concerns, share ideas, and help shape our discussions.

141
00:19:50.968 --> 00:20:03.194
<v Candace Avalos>We've also created dedicated opportunities for community voices including a renters feedback forum that we're going to be hosting in the fall where tenants can share their experiences and recommendations directly with the committee.

142
00:20:04.884 --> 00:20:08.492
<v Candace Avalos>And actually, we had a renters feedback forum and we're going to do more of those in the fall.

143
00:20:08.573 --> 00:20:09.684
<v Candace Avalos>So we did one in committee.

144
00:20:09.798 --> 00:20:11.665
<v Candace Avalos>We'll do more in community in the coming months.

145
00:20:13.130 --> 00:20:20.865
<v Candace Avalos>For homelessness and shelter services, so the committee has spent significant time examining both long-term policy and immediate operational issues related to homelessness.

146
00:20:21.451 --> 00:20:36.088
<v Candace Avalos>We received regular updates from the Homelessness Response System Steering and Oversight Committee, reviewed new research on the 2025 Point-in-Time Count, and discussed the mayor's proposed budget and its impacts on homeless services and shelter operations.

147
00:20:36.602 --> 00:20:46.669
<v Candace Avalos>We also held a public discussion last week with Portland Solutions and Urban Alchemy focused on shelter oversight, complaint processes, contract accountability, and how shelter guests can safely report concerns.

148
00:20:48.227 --> 00:20:53.413
<v Candace Avalos>On housing production and affordability, the committee continued advancing several major housing policy initiatives.

149
00:20:53.925 --> 00:20:59.914
<v Candace Avalos>So we worked on the Unified Housing Strategy and the Social Housing Study, 2 efforts that will help shape Portland's long-term housing strategy.

150
00:21:00.429 --> 00:21:12.694
<v Candace Avalos>We've received the 10-year update on the North-Northeast Neighborhood Housing Strategy and Preference Policy, highlighting ongoing investments in homeownership, housing preservation, and home repair programs that support Black households displaced from North and Northeast Portland.

151
00:21:13.257 --> 00:21:19.776
<v Candace Avalos>The committee also discussed proposed state legislation related to inclusionary zoning and its potential impacts on housing production in Portland.

152
00:21:20.096 --> 00:21:25.284
<v Candace Avalos>We explored the growing use of algorithmic devices in rental housing and their role in price fixing.

153
00:21:25.717 --> 00:21:38.209
<v Candace Avalos>In addition, we convened nonprofit affordable housing providers and property managers to better understand the financial pressures that they're facing in maintaining affordable housing, retaining resident services staff, and supporting tenants with increasingly complex needs.

154
00:21:38.787 --> 00:21:48.319
<v Candace Avalos>We also approved Portland's participation in the state's moderate income revolving loan program, allowing the city to leverage additional state financing for moderate income housing developments.

155
00:21:48.994 --> 00:21:50.743
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

156
00:21:50.824 --> 00:21:56.906
<v Candace Avalos>On permitting and development, improving Portland's permitting system has remained a major focus of the committee.

157
00:21:57.339 --> 00:22:04.144
<v Candace Avalos>We consider the Affordable Housing Opportunity Zones Project, or AHOP, to help advance affordable housing development across the city.

158
00:22:04.226 --> 00:22:13.769
<v Candace Avalos>City and authorized the transfer of city-owned property to Habitat for Humanity for the True North Affordable Housing Project, supporting the development of additional affordable homeownership opportunities.

159
00:22:14.347 --> 00:22:22.509
<v Candace Avalos>The committee also advanced a supplemental budget for unspent Portland Housing Bureau funds, which ultimately informed amendments adopted through the spring technical adjustment ordinance.

160
00:22:23.521 --> 00:22:29.226
<v Candace Avalos>The committee— and also led to the Keep Portland Housed ordinance, which we passed.

161
00:22:29.708 --> 00:22:44.878
<v Candace Avalos>The committee passed updates the committee also advanced RECAP 11, the Code Alignment Project 1, and the second phase of the Code Alignment Project, or CAP 2.

162
00:22:45.506 --> 00:22:54.605
<v Candace Avalos>Together, these initiatives reduce unnecessary barriers, improve coordination across bureaus, modernize city code, and make it easier to deliver housing and other community-serving projects.

163
00:22:55.210 --> 00:23:12.930
<v Candace Avalos>We also considered updates looking ahead, the committee will continue building on this work over the coming months.

164
00:23:13.059 --> 00:23:19.960
<v Candace Avalos>Next week, we're going to be hosting Metro Council President Gonzalez for a discussion on regional strategies to address housing and homelessness.

165
00:23:20.180 --> 00:23:26.420
<v Candace Avalos>Later this year, we'll begin work on climate and health standards, a policy focused on reducing emissions from Portland's largest buildings while supporting the growth of clean energy jobs.

166
00:23:26.420 --> 00:23:26.460
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

167
00:23:29.161 --> 00:23:34.565
<v Candace Avalos>Last night we had our first workshop with me, and it was great.

168
00:23:34.628 --> 00:23:41.269
<v Candace Avalos>We had about 40 people there, and it was an opportunity for folks to actually help develop the policy.

169
00:23:41.429 --> 00:23:43.946
<v Candace Avalos>So expect that to be coming in early September.

170
00:23:44.557 --> 00:23:56.455
<v Candace Avalos>I am very proud of the breadth of the work that this committee has taken over the past several months, and whether we're listening to community members or improving accountability, expanding housing opportunities, or modernizing our permitting system, our goal remains the same.

171
00:23:56.633 --> 00:23:56.825
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

172
00:23:57.083 --> 00:24:05.659
<v Candace Avalos>Which is helping Portland become a city where it's easier to build housing, easier to navigate local regulations, and easier for people to find and keep a place to call home.

173
00:24:06.607 --> 00:24:08.765
<v Candace Avalos>That is what's going on in H&P.

174
00:24:09.075 --> 00:24:09.385
<v Lorraine Wilson>Thank you.

175
00:24:11.630 --> 00:24:12.904
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much, Chair Avalos.

176
00:24:13.082 --> 00:24:16.954
<v Sameer Kanal>Any questions for Chair Avalos before we wrap up the, uh, the chair's update?

177
00:24:17.561 --> 00:24:27.284
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, seeing none, that concludes the chair's update, and we'll move into agenda item Rebecca, could you please call the next agenda item?

178
00:24:28.257 --> 00:24:34.576
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 2, appoint voting members to the Portland Utility Board, document number 2026-238.

179
00:24:36.981 --> 00:24:38.047
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much.

180
00:24:38.192 --> 00:24:52.737
<v Sameer Kanal>As our presenters are coming up, I believe we'll have over the course of this, in addition to our 3 appointees, we'll have Amy Archer Masters, the PUD analyst, as well as Kyle Chipman and Lorraine Wilson, who are the co-chairs of the Portland Utility Board.

181
00:24:53.319 --> 00:24:55.953
<v Sameer Kanal>And I am not sure who's starting, so I'll pass it over to you.

182
00:24:56.117 --> 00:24:56.625
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much.

183
00:25:01.000 --> 00:25:05.000
<v Amy Archer Masters>Uh, just make sure that the slides are pulling up, and it looks like they are.

184
00:25:05.369 --> 00:25:06.607
<v Amy Archer Masters>My name is Amy Archer Masters.

185
00:25:06.655 --> 00:25:14.636
<v Amy Archer Masters>I'm the analyst with the City Budget Office that provides support to the Portland Utility Board, or as you'll commonly hear us refer to it, as the PUB.

186
00:25:15.509 --> 00:25:32.680
<v Amy Archer Masters>What we plan to cover today, very briefly, Uh, is a short overview of the Portland Utility Board and their purpose, a little bit about the recruitment process, and most importantly, introduce you to the appointees that we have here today.

187
00:25:32.903 --> 00:25:37.792
<v Amy Archer Masters>I'll be available for questions, uh, but I will pass it to the co-chairs to cover the first 2 items.

188
00:25:38.963 --> 00:25:39.251
<v Kyle Chipman>Beautiful.

189
00:25:39.299 --> 00:25:39.990
<v Kyle Chipman>Thanks so much, Amy.

190
00:25:40.487 --> 00:25:41.800
<v Kyle Chipman>Uh, greetings, a pleasure.

191
00:25:41.848 --> 00:25:42.747
<v Kyle Chipman>My name is Kyle Chipman.

192
00:25:42.971 --> 00:25:52.463
<v Kyle Chipman>I've been serving on the Portland Utility Board since July 2024, uh, serving as co-chair over the past year, and I'm filling out my, uh, final year on on my initial term as co-chair this coming year.

193
00:25:52.993 --> 00:26:02.851
<v Kyle Chipman>It's a pleasure to address council today to present the 3 candidates we have for you and more in a heartfelt way alongside Amy Archer Masters, John Lin, our other staff representative, and my co-chair Lorraine Wilson.

194
00:26:03.605 --> 00:26:03.863
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Lovely.

195
00:26:04.007 --> 00:26:04.248
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

196
00:26:04.970 --> 00:26:07.057
<v Kyle Chipman>First up, I'm actually going to read verbatim.

197
00:26:07.137 --> 00:26:11.407
<v Kyle Chipman>This is the historical reference of why our board was formed.

198
00:26:12.098 --> 00:26:16.979
<v Kyle Chipman>The PUB was formed in 2015 in response to legal challenges and public ratepayer concerns.

199
00:26:17.910 --> 00:26:22.750
<v Kyle Chipman>Subsequently defined with extensive public process plus recommendations from a blue ribbon commission.

200
00:26:23.460 --> 00:26:29.880
<v Kyle Chipman>PUB's purpose is to ensure accountability and transparency of ratepayer funds and provide oversight of the public utilities.

201
00:26:29.880 --> 00:26:31.599
<v Kyle Chipman>So that's like super clean language.

202
00:26:31.599 --> 00:26:38.279
<v Kyle Chipman>And the reason I wanted to start with that is it underpins all of our decisions, our consensus, and our driving agenda moving forward.

203
00:26:38.279 --> 00:26:47.119
<v Kyle Chipman>Functionally, what that means is that we are a collection of impassioned volunteers spread across the city who are here to provide independent oversight of the Portland Water Bureau and the Bureau of Environmental Services.

204
00:26:47.119 --> 00:26:47.140
<v Kyle Chipman>Yeah.

205
00:26:48.991 --> 00:26:52.330
<v Kyle Chipman>As it pertains to water, sewer, stormwater, and natural resources delivery.

206
00:26:52.907 --> 00:26:56.584
<v Kyle Chipman>We also serve in an ongoing capacity as the Budget Advisory Committee for the bureaus.

207
00:26:57.564 --> 00:26:59.057
<v Kyle Chipman>We also are pulled into special projects.

208
00:26:59.105 --> 00:27:10.823
<v Kyle Chipman>We have 2 of our board members serving on the Project Delivery Advisory Team for Bull Run, technical folks who are not only helping to provide and pull that project to successful completion, but also relaying updates to the public.

209
00:27:11.127 --> 00:27:16.249
<v Kyle Chipman>Additionally, we have 1 representative per month joining the monthly Administrative Review Committee.

210
00:27:17.047 --> 00:27:20.887
<v Kyle Chipman>Which is where our community members can appeal their water and sewer bills.

211
00:27:22.833 --> 00:27:30.048
<v Kyle Chipman>Yes, we meet twice a month, first Tuesday of every month, third Thursday, hour and a half per meeting, about 2 hours read ahead, a little more for certain folks.

212
00:27:30.160 --> 00:27:33.872
<v Kyle Chipman>And the reason I want to share that, just like last time, is to say it's wide open to the public.

213
00:27:34.161 --> 00:27:35.721
<v Kyle Chipman>We love it when the community shows up.

214
00:27:35.800 --> 00:27:37.603
<v Kyle Chipman>There is public comment at the start of every meeting.

215
00:27:37.778 --> 00:27:44.557
<v Kyle Chipman>And as representatives, as members of the community, we want to hear everyone's concerns and just work together to deliver clean drinking water for all.

216
00:27:44.655 --> 00:27:45.196
<v Kyle Chipman>That is our mission.

217
00:27:46.299 --> 00:28:02.904
<v Kyle Chipman>The second bubbled point you see with all those bullets, I'm not gonna read it out, but it provides a wonderful entry point to define and share that we are in the midst of crafting not only our annual report for '25-'26, but our work plan for '26-'27.

218
00:28:04.142 --> 00:28:09.474
<v Kyle Chipman>And we're really, really excited and hopeful to schedule and coordinate with your staff a working session with Council.

219
00:28:09.896 --> 00:28:10.950
<v Kyle Chipman>Committee of the Whole's great.

220
00:28:11.128 --> 00:28:12.604
<v Kyle Chipman>Public Works Committee also super cool.

221
00:28:12.669 --> 00:28:12.733
<v Kyle Chipman>Yes.

222
00:28:13.526 --> 00:28:31.461
<v Kyle Chipman>And I think the point of excitement for me personally is that in the June 25th, the annual budget process discussion that happened last month, there were some really great points raised by Council members and there's a lot of natural crossover on how we as a Board can really align and collaborate with the bureaus to help to deliver to these needs.

223
00:28:31.766 --> 00:28:34.945
<v Kyle Chipman>Some specific ones, Council President Dunphy, budget mapping.

224
00:28:35.619 --> 00:28:43.898
<v Kyle Chipman>We are super pumped on how to integrate GIS, to explore and reflect deferred maintenance in the asset backlog.

225
00:28:44.883 --> 00:28:52.494
<v Kyle Chipman>Council Member Pirtle-Guiney, KPIs is a natural fit for the bureaus and how to actually leverage the website to deliver not only Bull Run updates, but just all these wonderful metrics.

226
00:28:52.883 --> 00:29:04.192
<v Kyle Chipman>And then Council Member Avalos, the really exciting one is not viewing cuts as a— through the prism of money saved, but people managing programs to deliver service to community members.

227
00:29:04.693 --> 00:29:08.693
<v Kyle Chipman>That's a critical point of how to connect people, program, and service to our community when it comes to full-time employees.

228
00:29:10.779 --> 00:29:12.529
<v Kyle Chipman>Just a couple of points that jumped out.

229
00:29:12.939 --> 00:29:13.855
<v Kyle Chipman>We want to hit it the next year.

230
00:29:14.001 --> 00:29:15.294
<v Kyle Chipman>We'd love to work with you to make that happen.

231
00:29:16.660 --> 00:29:16.788
<v Kyle Chipman>Wonderful.

232
00:29:16.836 --> 00:29:19.859
<v Kyle Chipman>The last point I do want to raise— oh, one more on that last slide.

233
00:29:19.907 --> 00:29:20.134
<v Kyle Chipman>Sorry.

234
00:29:20.652 --> 00:29:26.891
<v Kyle Chipman>The PUB core value, it's that commitment to clean water as a right that really does underpin all of our decisions as a board.

235
00:29:28.474 --> 00:29:36.378
<v Kyle Chipman>The specific point as well is that every person requires clean and affordable drinking water and sanitation for healthy communities and healthy watersheds.

236
00:29:36.811 --> 00:29:44.599
<v Kyle Chipman>And it's our balance and our responsibility for regulation, infrastructure, and staffing with environmental, community, and ratepayer impacts.

237
00:29:44.743 --> 00:29:46.474
<v Kyle Chipman>So that's the mission and nature of our board.

238
00:29:47.548 --> 00:29:49.887
<v Kyle Chipman>Now the fun part, and this is actually, I love this next slide.

239
00:29:50.176 --> 00:29:56.089
<v Kyle Chipman>All those smiling faces, these are all the Portlanders, the wonderful Portlanders that comprise our Portland Utility Board.

240
00:29:56.843 --> 00:29:59.055
<v Kyle Chipman>This was actually from last November.

241
00:29:59.230 --> 00:30:06.906
<v Kyle Chipman>It was a site visit we made alongside Director Ting Lu to the plant in Northeast with Bureau of Environmental Services.

242
00:30:07.339 --> 00:30:15.148
<v Kyle Chipman>And just a quick aside, It's always so rewarding to visit in person to appreciate the technical people that make this happen beyond just numbers on a screen.

243
00:30:15.278 --> 00:30:18.211
<v Kyle Chipman>It's so many committed team members working in collaboration.

244
00:30:18.981 --> 00:30:31.748
<v Kyle Chipman>So of those folks, we have 10 community members who are full-time volunteers and one labor representative who actually, it's a designated employee in the utility bureaus who is a perpetual bargaining unit.

245
00:30:32.277 --> 00:30:39.792
<v Kyle Chipman>This unit, this position has remained vacant while I was recruited by the utilities over the past year, but we have a great candidate today for confirmation in front of council.

246
00:30:41.010 --> 00:30:45.000
<v Kyle Chipman>They are staggered 3-year terms with a maximum of 2 full terms per board member.

247
00:30:45.641 --> 00:30:52.836
<v Kyle Chipman>And it's also comprised of 3 total non-voting ex officio members, 1 labor, 2 non-represented, all utility employees.

248
00:30:53.491 --> 00:30:56.712
<v Kyle Chipman>And those are appointed annually by the mayor.

249
00:30:56.936 --> 00:31:02.432
<v Kyle Chipman>All of these, we also have a little bit of give just in case people have extenuating circumstances or life situations that crop up.

250
00:31:02.769 --> 00:31:05.531
<v Kyle Chipman>But today is the confirmation of our 3 candidates.

251
00:31:06.173 --> 00:31:14.092
<v Kyle Chipman>This next one is also to provide a cross-section and a representation of the skills pursuant by each of our board members.

252
00:31:14.750 --> 00:31:19.761
<v Kyle Chipman>And every time we go through a selection cycle, we have a ton of candidates come through.

253
00:31:20.050 --> 00:31:31.402
<v Kyle Chipman>We're also very thoughtful and deliberate about gaps or chasms of expertise within our board so that we're trying to infill and create a cross-section of experience while also So those, I mean, straight up, I have deficiencies.

254
00:31:31.530 --> 00:31:35.282
<v Kyle Chipman>I had very little experience when it came to filtration or water treatment before I came on.

255
00:31:35.490 --> 00:31:39.901
<v Kyle Chipman>I was heavily invested in project and program management and kind of organizational management.

256
00:31:39.964 --> 00:31:48.510
<v Kyle Chipman>But that's the wonderful thing is that each of us comes, and you can read through this list, each of us comes with this specific point of entry, point of orientation, point of expertise.

257
00:31:49.328 --> 00:31:55.165
<v Kyle Chipman>And it's not just us working in concert, but also receiving information as a layperson to then communicate to the public ideally.

258
00:31:56.144 --> 00:32:00.671
<v Kyle Chipman>So with that, I turn over to Lorraine to key up our candidates for today.

259
00:32:00.993 --> 00:32:01.188
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

260
00:32:01.576 --> 00:32:02.384
<v Lorraine Wilson>Thank you, Kyle.

261
00:32:03.015 --> 00:32:05.747
<v Lorraine Wilson>Lorraine Wilson, voting member, Public Utility Board.

262
00:32:06.890 --> 00:32:07.967
<v Lorraine Wilson>A little bit about myself.

263
00:32:09.758 --> 00:32:13.858
<v Lorraine Wilson>I was reelected or reappointed.

264
00:32:13.955 --> 00:32:16.289
<v Lorraine Wilson>Reappointed, that's the term, last year.

265
00:32:16.403 --> 00:32:18.136
<v Lorraine Wilson>So you all would've heard a lot about me then.

266
00:32:19.421 --> 00:32:21.343
<v Lorraine Wilson>I've been a pub member since 2022.

267
00:32:22.717 --> 00:32:33.326
<v Lorraine Wilson>Um, and I want to take this opportunity to briefly recognize and appreciate the board members ending their service on PUB because, as we can't emphasize enough, we are a volunteer board.

268
00:32:35.509 --> 00:32:47.933
<v Lorraine Wilson>A voting member, Julie DeCroix, completed her second and final term last month, bringing valuable legislative and environmental nonprofit sector expertise to PUB's project.

269
00:32:48.758 --> 00:32:51.070
<v Lorraine Wilson>And discussion over 5 and a half years.

270
00:32:52.067 --> 00:33:12.756
<v Lorraine Wilson>Ex officio member Joanne Johnson, a former colleague of mine when I worked at the City of Portland in her former life, the accessibility analyst on Water's Equity Policy Team, contributed her deep knowledge and commitment to community engagement, government systems, and advancing equity for the past 3 years.

271
00:33:14.394 --> 00:33:24.519
<v Lorraine Wilson>We learned just last week that voting member Brooke Bernahue's recent job transition would require that he step down for his role on PUB next month.

272
00:33:25.386 --> 00:33:32.624
<v Lorraine Wilson>Brooke is a water resource engineer that moved from Austin to Portland in 2024 and joined PUB last year.

273
00:33:33.329 --> 00:33:40.199
<v Lorraine Wilson>With a research and civil engineering background, he brought a depth of knowledge and experience in water efficiency.

274
00:33:41.109 --> 00:33:43.182
<v Lorraine Wilson>Reuse, and long-term resilience.

275
00:33:44.039 --> 00:33:56.638
<v Lorraine Wilson>Brooke quickly engaged in the Filtration Project Delivery Advisory Team, or PDAT, as we like to use a lot of acronyms here at the city, to help lead PWB's engagement in the oversight of this major capital project.

276
00:33:57.666 --> 00:34:01.521
<v Lorraine Wilson>Though sad to lose him, we're really sad because Brooke was a champion.

277
00:34:02.267 --> 00:34:14.021
<v Lorraine Wilson>We were lucky to work with him this past year and, and are glad he will continue to contribute time and energy towards a sustainable water future here locally in Portland.

278
00:34:15.246 --> 00:34:21.458
<v Lorraine Wilson>We appreciate the time and dedication these members and others have contributed to the city and PUB's work.

279
00:34:23.949 --> 00:34:26.820
<v Lorraine Wilson>So we're going to share a little bit of our recruitment process.

280
00:34:26.951 --> 00:34:34.668
<v Lorraine Wilson>I think this was revised a few years ago, Amy, where we came up with this new process, and it seems to be working really well.

281
00:34:36.472 --> 00:34:43.739
<v Lorraine Wilson>Each year the POP forms a recruitment subcommittee including current board members such as myself and city staff.

282
00:34:44.686 --> 00:34:59.568
<v Lorraine Wilson>This year, to fill just one community voting member vacancy, it ended up being 2 with the unexpected, um, with Brooke stepping down while the unions identified their appointee for the labor vacancy.

283
00:35:01.146 --> 00:35:16.889
<v Lorraine Wilson>A key goal in our recruitment remains to diversify and balance the skills, experience, interests, and perspectives of the POP to ensure rich conversations that help inform our feedback to leadership.

284
00:35:18.239 --> 00:35:28.422
<v Lorraine Wilson>Equity remains a particular area of focus and emphasis for the board's work and in our recruitment, including outreach, interviews, and considerations.

285
00:35:29.737 --> 00:35:43.391
<v Lorraine Wilson>The POP held an open application process in March with outreach through notice, social media, and personal contacts of board members and staff, resulting in 18 applicants.

286
00:35:44.416 --> 00:35:56.012
<v Lorraine Wilson>POP staff facilitated group interviews which allowed the recruitment, recruitment committee to evaluate candidates in a format similar to regular pub meeting.

287
00:35:56.541 --> 00:36:03.702
<v Lorraine Wilson>So it wasn't a question and answer interview, it was a forum where they spoke among themselves, and that was very interesting.

288
00:36:03.798 --> 00:36:16.199
<v Lorraine Wilson>You learn a lot when people are engaging with other, um, other interviewees, where board members considered an issue, share ideas, and engagement dynamically in conversation.

289
00:36:17.592 --> 00:36:25.961
<v Lorraine Wilson>We were very impressed with all 13 candidates interviewed and ultimately recommended the appointees before you today.

290
00:36:27.556 --> 00:36:41.271
<v Lorraine Wilson>We also identified strong alternatives, one of which we are already bringing forward today, and others that we would bring forward before you later if another vacancy arises before the next full recruitment.

291
00:36:42.144 --> 00:36:53.855
<v Lorraine Wilson>The appointment recommendation, along with the recommended appointee identified by the unions, unions were approved by the PUB in a public meeting in June.

292
00:36:57.938 --> 00:37:07.952
<v Lorraine Wilson>Particularly with the governance structure changes, we understand there is interest in ensuring adequate representation from all districts in Portland.

293
00:37:08.873 --> 00:37:12.715
<v Lorraine Wilson>The chart on the right shows current distribution of PUB members.

294
00:37:13.539 --> 00:37:18.965
<v Lorraine Wilson>All districts are represented though some more heavily represented than others.

295
00:37:20.201 --> 00:37:29.434
<v Lorraine Wilson>The chart on the left documents the distribution of applicants by district, with District 2 providing the most applicants.

296
00:37:30.204 --> 00:37:34.981
<v Lorraine Wilson>One recommended appointee for the committee vacancy resides in District 1.

297
00:37:35.333 --> 00:37:41.056
<v Lorraine Wilson>The other resides in District 4 but works in District 2 and citywide.

298
00:37:42.164 --> 00:38:00.847
<v Lorraine Wilson>Portland City Code focuses on skills, experience, and perspectives identified to serve the board well, ranging from technical knowledge of utilities and conservation to more generalized area of financial analysis, group process, and communications.

299
00:38:01.827 --> 00:38:12.655
<v Lorraine Wilson>As we discussed, there's a wide range of expertise on PUB, but we also are very conscious of making sure all are considered whether present or not.

300
00:38:14.222 --> 00:38:28.222
<v Lorraine Wilson>Although district distribution is not part of code, the board will continue to identify potential district gaps and target outreach for volunteers in coordination with relevant council and partners.

301
00:38:32.219 --> 00:38:42.027
<v Lorraine Wilson>What we bring initially before you today is are the 2 recommended appointees bringing experience and perspective to complement the existing board members?

302
00:38:43.945 --> 00:38:59.199
<v Lorraine Wilson>If approved, as it will— as, as it has been amended by Council Clerk today, we also bring one additional appointee for the unplanned vacancy that emerged last week.

303
00:38:59.894 --> 00:39:06.278
<v Lorraine Wilson>This candidate was the first alternate selected by the recruitment committee and was supported by the full PAB.

304
00:39:06.989 --> 00:39:29.385
<v Lorraine Wilson>You will see from the materials and discussion that all 3 recommended appointees have a depth of technical knowledge and expertise, awareness of issues facing utilities, thoughtfulness about equity, and commitment to engaging in challenging, challenging discussions regarding utility needs, priorities, and trade-offs.

305
00:39:31.297 --> 00:39:41.215
<v Lorraine Wilson>The brief highlight on these 2 slides on the appointees provides some basic information, but it is much more interesting to hear directly from the appointees.

306
00:39:41.889 --> 00:39:55.355
<v Lorraine Wilson>Let me introduce Al Haig, Joe Robinson, and Rose Pouton, and she'll be, um, joining us virtually by recording because she has a conflict because of the short notice.

307
00:39:57.199 --> 00:39:57.762
<v Lorraine Wilson>Thank you.

308
00:39:59.516 --> 00:40:01.369
<v Lorraine Wilson>Thanks.

309
00:40:02.012 --> 00:40:02.931
<v Al Haag>Uh, good afternoon, Council.

310
00:40:02.994 --> 00:40:04.606
<v Al Haag>My name is Al Haag.

311
00:40:04.702 --> 00:40:07.550
<v Al Haag>Uh, I live in the Hazelwood neighborhood, that's District 1.

312
00:40:08.976 --> 00:40:13.938
<v Al Haag>I've been working at the City of Gresham as a civil engineer for coming on 7 years now.

313
00:40:15.206 --> 00:40:21.614
<v Al Haag>My free time is spent with local conservation groups like Nature Conservancy and Bird Alliance of Oregon.

314
00:40:22.853 --> 00:40:30.994
<v Al Haag>Community building organizations like my local tool library in East Portland and, you know, 350 PDX, which is a kind of a climate justice organization.

315
00:40:31.282 --> 00:40:34.070
<v Al Haag>I'm excited to join— oh, mostly with my 3-year-old baby too.

316
00:40:35.032 --> 00:40:52.655
<v Al Haag>But I'm excited to join the pub as the community member volunteer to provide oversight and focus on transparency, affordability, and climate resilience efforts, and to solicit input, keep my ear to the ground, listen to Portland community members at large and amplify their priorities and their concerns.

317
00:40:54.440 --> 00:40:56.606
<v Al Haag>So yeah, I'm happy to answer any questions you may have.

318
00:40:57.688 --> 00:40:58.869
<v Al Haag>Otherwise, just thank you for the consideration.

319
00:41:02.793 --> 00:41:04.447
<v Joe Robinson>Hi, my name is Joe Robinson.

320
00:41:04.864 --> 00:41:10.730
<v Joe Robinson>I'm the District 4 resident and a planner coordinator in BES operations and maintenance.

321
00:41:11.244 --> 00:41:22.460
<v Joe Robinson>So I work primarily in District 2 at the Columbia Boulevard wastewater treatment plant, But my scope control goes all across around 100 pump stations and the plant in Lake Oswego as well.

322
00:41:23.873 --> 00:41:28.708
<v Joe Robinson>I've had the pleasure of being a CPBW represented member for about the last year.

323
00:41:29.880 --> 00:41:38.842
<v Joe Robinson>Beyond my life as a Portland resident and a daily user of our utility services, I'm well integrated within BES professionally and local water groups as a volunteer.

324
00:41:39.597 --> 00:41:48.856
<v Joe Robinson>These include the Columbia Slough Wastewater— or sorry, Columbia Slough Watershed Council and Water for People, both volunteer organizations.

325
00:41:49.385 --> 00:41:52.096
<v Joe Robinson>You may have seen me dressed up as Seymour the Salmon at one of those.

326
00:41:53.427 --> 00:42:09.467
<v Joe Robinson>I'm engaged through scholarships, volunteerism, and speaking assignments in multiple water industry groups, giving me access to world-leading insights for municipal utilities, following best practices for generating community buy-in, ensuring social equity in public utility decision-making.

327
00:42:09.530 --> 00:42:09.690
<v Joe Robinson>Thank you.

328
00:42:10.253 --> 00:42:20.673
<v Joe Robinson>And developing sustainable climate resiliency plans in line with the circular water economy model, I'm eager to include thousands of labor-represented Portlanders as members of an engaged public.

329
00:42:21.347 --> 00:42:31.255
<v Joe Robinson>I'm excited to continue to develop positive relationships with the Portland Utility Board, with bureau and service area leadership, and to advocate on behalf of my neighbors, my peers, and my represented colleagues.

330
00:42:31.913 --> 00:42:35.221
<v Joe Robinson>Thank you for your consideration, and any questions, feel free to ask.

331
00:42:37.148 --> 00:42:51.326
<v Amy Archer Masters>And if you'll give me just a moment, I will, uh, share a short video from Rose Podin, who was unable to join us today but did record a greeting.

332
00:43:05.820 --> 00:43:07.753
<v Angelita Morillo>Hi everyone, my name is Rose Podin.

333
00:43:07.849 --> 00:43:17.893
<v Angelita Morillo>I am the Water Justice Associate at Verde, a Portland-based nonprofit focused on building environmental wealth through social enterprise, advocacy, and organizing.

334
00:43:18.637 --> 00:43:25.782
<v Angelita Morillo>I also lead the Oregon Water Futures Collaborative's annual Water Justice Leadership Institute, which is in its 4th year.

335
00:43:26.668 --> 00:43:40.523
<v Angelita Morillo>This is a virtual multilingual collaborative space for all Oregonians who are interested in learning about water, water justice, and mobilizing around critical environmental issues relating to water.

336
00:43:42.070 --> 00:43:50.927
<v Angelita Morillo>Prior to my role at Verde, I worked for many years as a licensed nurse in Oregon, so I approached a lot of these water issues with a healthcare lens.

337
00:43:51.940 --> 00:44:09.280
<v Angelita Morillo>I also hold a master's in conflict and dispute resolution specializing in environmental conflicts involving water from the University of Oregon, and I am also a PhD student right now at Oregon State University studying water sciences.

338
00:44:10.099 --> 00:44:13.375
<v Angelita Morillo>I apologize for not being there at the meeting.

339
00:44:13.952 --> 00:44:35.632
<v Angelita Morillo>I am at work right now, so I appreciate you all Hi everyone, sorry about that.

340
00:44:38.976 --> 00:44:44.132
<v Amy Archer Masters>So the recommendation before you the slides back up.

341
00:44:57.768 --> 00:45:07.695
<v Amy Archer Masters>Uh, is to confirm the appointments of Al Haig and Joe Robinson, and if amended as we hope, uh, also Rose Poden, uh, to the Portland Utility Board.

342
00:45:08.378 --> 00:45:23.398
<v Amy Archer Masters>These impressive appointees will join the members' continuing service along with the 3 As you've seen, we have some amazing volunteers stepping in where others have set high standards.

343
00:45:23.806 --> 00:45:27.851
<v Amy Archer Masters>We share deep appreciation for all past and future PUB members for their willingness to serve.

344
00:45:28.590 --> 00:45:32.166
<v Amy Archer Masters>Thank you, Chair Kanal, Council, for your consideration today.

345
00:45:32.327 --> 00:45:34.067
<v Amy Archer Masters>We're all available for any questions.

346
00:45:37.431 --> 00:45:38.077
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you very much.

347
00:45:38.697 --> 00:45:39.536
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Amy, thank you.

348
00:45:39.601 --> 00:45:40.425
<v Sameer Kanal>Co-chairs, thank you.

349
00:45:40.554 --> 00:45:43.490
<v Sameer Kanal>Our, our, uh, prospective appointees as well.

350
00:45:43.782 --> 00:45:52.344
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, before we get into, uh, councilor discussion, I wanted to ask, um, Rebecca, is there any, uh, registered people for testimony?

351
00:45:53.347 --> 00:45:54.090
<v Rebecca Dobert>No one has signed up.

352
00:45:55.809 --> 00:45:55.954
<v Michael Bonacore>Okay.

353
00:45:56.423 --> 00:46:04.179
<v Sameer Kanal>Well, in that case, we'll open it up for technical questions to staff, to the appointees, to, um, uh, proposed amendments as well.

354
00:46:04.728 --> 00:46:05.436
<v Sameer Kanal>And to discussion.

355
00:46:06.112 --> 00:46:10.476
<v Sameer Kanal>And I believe Councilor Clark was first, followed by Novick.

356
00:46:13.050 --> 00:46:13.579
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Mr.

357
00:46:13.996 --> 00:46:14.623
<v Clark>Chair.

358
00:46:14.753 --> 00:46:21.083
<v Clark>Thank you so much for your service and your willingness to serve, the new folks.

359
00:46:21.195 --> 00:46:22.159
<v Clark>I really appreciate it.

360
00:46:22.222 --> 00:46:28.682
<v Clark>As the chair of the Public Works Committee, I'm really, really interested in what you have to say and just appreciate your service.

361
00:46:28.827 --> 00:46:34.378
<v Clark>And I think Lorraine Wilson really outlined what happened with the, um, the vacancy.

362
00:46:34.635 --> 00:46:35.860
<v Clark>I won't repeat all of that.

363
00:46:36.760 --> 00:46:48.135
<v Clark>So, Mr. Chairman, I would like to move Amendment 1, which everybody should have had, and that would add Rose as a 3rd appointee to the PUB.

364
00:46:48.523 --> 00:46:48.847
<v Mitch Green>Second.

365
00:46:49.380 --> 00:46:49.833
<v Clark>Thank you.

366
00:46:51.583 --> 00:46:53.996
<v Clark>Clearly, this was because of a resignation.

367
00:46:54.175 --> 00:46:55.583
<v Clark>We're really sorry to see him go.

368
00:46:56.443 --> 00:46:57.398
<v Clark>Thank you for those comments.

369
00:46:58.101 --> 00:47:14.050
<v Clark>I just also want to add that I don't think that Rose mentioned this, but she participated in the same open recruitment and the review process that all the other candidates and was recommended by the PUV Recruitment Subcommittee and supported by the full board for this appointment.

370
00:47:14.132 --> 00:47:15.318
<v Clark>Just wanted to clarify that.

371
00:47:16.391 --> 00:47:29.731
<v Clark>So then this amendment would change the item from 2 appointments to 3 appointments, with Rose filling the vacancy created by the resignation of Brooke so I would respect— respectfully ask for your support for that amendment.

372
00:47:30.068 --> 00:47:32.893
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Clark.

373
00:47:32.972 --> 00:47:35.331
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that was Councilor Green who seconded that motion.

374
00:47:36.807 --> 00:47:38.188
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, great.

375
00:47:38.652 --> 00:47:42.054
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we'll move into discussion of the amendment.

376
00:47:42.295 --> 00:47:52.438
<v Sameer Kanal>So I have, um, on the main, uh, list we have stack, we have Novick, then, um, Dunphy, then Sorry, Novick, Green, Pirtle-Guiney, then Dunphy.

377
00:47:52.503 --> 00:47:56.568
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, I'll just ask you if you are interested in speaking to the amendment as we go.

378
00:47:56.793 --> 00:47:59.335
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Councilor Novick, are you interested in speaking to the amendment?

379
00:48:00.518 --> 00:48:01.440
<v Sameer Kanal>Good amendment, should pass.

380
00:48:03.657 --> 00:48:03.934
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

381
00:48:04.467 --> 00:48:05.179
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Councilor Green?

382
00:48:08.762 --> 00:48:10.791
<v Mitch Green>I don't have— I'm not speaking to the amendment.

383
00:48:10.873 --> 00:48:10.889
<v Mitch Green>I—.

384
00:48:11.068 --> 00:48:12.286
<v Mitch Green>My hand is in the queue for the broader.

385
00:48:13.840 --> 00:48:15.072
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'll just withdraw my hand for now.

386
00:48:15.422 --> 00:48:16.206
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to take a vote.

387
00:48:17.260 --> 00:48:17.454
<v Lorraine Wilson>Great.

388
00:48:17.945 --> 00:48:20.885
<v Sameer Kanal>Are there any, any other discussion on the amendment?

389
00:48:24.706 --> 00:48:27.195
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing none, Rebecca, will you please call the roll?

390
00:48:29.431 --> 00:48:35.112
<v Rebecca Dobert>Calling the roll on the amendment, uh, moved by Councilor Clark, seconded by Councilor Green.

391
00:48:35.788 --> 00:48:36.318
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

392
00:48:42.670 --> 00:48:44.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, aye.

393
00:48:45.918 --> 00:48:46.271
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

394
00:48:47.204 --> 00:48:47.318
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

395
00:48:48.588 --> 00:48:49.054
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aren't I—.

396
00:48:49.054 --> 00:48:50.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry, I was unprepared.

397
00:48:50.260 --> 00:48:51.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I thought we were starting with District 3 now.

398
00:48:55.110 --> 00:48:55.561
<v Rebecca Dobert>Oh, pardon me.

399
00:48:55.641 --> 00:48:58.869
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm sorry, my tracker, my tracker is not updated.

400
00:48:58.916 --> 00:48:59.579
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sorry about that.

401
00:48:59.885 --> 00:49:00.192
<v Rebecca Dobert>It happens.

402
00:49:00.289 --> 00:49:00.626
<v Rebecca Dobert>Folks.

403
00:49:01.336 --> 00:49:02.322
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks, Rebecca.

404
00:49:02.708 --> 00:49:03.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was like, wait, was that my name?

405
00:49:04.322 --> 00:49:05.742
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, that was, that was our fault.

406
00:49:05.791 --> 00:49:06.349
<v Rebecca Dobert>Apologies.

407
00:49:07.054 --> 00:49:08.726
<v Rebecca Dobert>If it's okay with council, I'll proceed with this.

408
00:49:09.021 --> 00:49:10.630
<v Rebecca Dobert>Before we reorder for next time.

409
00:49:10.773 --> 00:49:12.204
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Ryan.

410
00:49:13.137 --> 00:49:17.380
<v Rebecca Dobert>Oh, sorry, Councilor Ryan, that would put you next for this vote only.

411
00:49:18.929 --> 00:49:23.331
<v Dan Ryan>I'll go with the flow, but actually it— your order's a little off, you know that, right?

412
00:49:23.427 --> 00:49:23.815
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

413
00:49:23.896 --> 00:49:24.123
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah.

414
00:49:24.237 --> 00:49:24.561
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

415
00:49:25.192 --> 00:49:25.612
<v Dan Ryan>Anyway, aye.

416
00:49:27.829 --> 00:49:28.231
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane.

417
00:49:28.650 --> 00:49:28.746
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

418
00:49:29.711 --> 00:49:30.161
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo.

419
00:49:31.224 --> 00:49:31.271
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

420
00:49:32.510 --> 00:49:32.913
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick.

421
00:49:33.235 --> 00:49:33.282
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

422
00:49:34.199 --> 00:49:34.617
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark.

423
00:49:35.019 --> 00:49:35.036
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

424
00:49:36.501 --> 00:49:36.887
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

425
00:49:37.226 --> 00:49:37.273
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

426
00:49:38.304 --> 00:49:38.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

427
00:49:39.014 --> 00:49:39.045
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

428
00:49:39.820 --> 00:49:40.190
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

429
00:49:41.414 --> 00:49:41.576
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

430
00:49:43.010 --> 00:49:43.202
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

431
00:49:43.588 --> 00:49:43.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

432
00:49:44.184 --> 00:49:44.617
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

433
00:49:49.137 --> 00:49:49.717
<v Loretta Smith>Absent.

434
00:49:51.579 --> 00:49:52.768
<v Rebecca Dobert>And Kanal?

435
00:49:55.208 --> 00:49:55.224
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

436
00:49:55.612 --> 00:50:02.016
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the motion is approved with 11 aye, 1 absent, to amend the report.

437
00:50:05.112 --> 00:50:05.713
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Rebecca.

438
00:50:05.762 --> 00:50:06.297
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, everyone.

439
00:50:06.492 --> 00:50:12.255
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll continue on with, uh, discussion of the underlying, starting with Councilor Novick, followed by Councilor Green.

440
00:50:15.322 --> 00:50:16.193
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

441
00:50:16.452 --> 00:50:21.985
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say I'm incredibly impressed with the qualifications of the nominees and the process that you followed to get them here.

442
00:50:22.679 --> 00:50:24.467
<v Steve Novick>And I also have 2 extraneous comments to make.

443
00:50:24.596 --> 00:50:25.418
<v Steve Novick>One is to Al.

444
00:50:25.965 --> 00:50:32.775
<v Steve Novick>Um, as you probably know, your name fills those of us of the Cold War era with nostalgia because although you say spell the name differently.

445
00:50:33.275 --> 00:50:37.369
<v Steve Novick>Al Haig was a general and a major figure in several Cold War Republican administrations.

446
00:50:38.402 --> 00:51:05.228
<v Steve Novick>And Kyle, I just wanted to supplement your account of the formation of the pub by saying my recollection is that Bob Jenks of the Citizens Utility Board came to see me and Nick Fish because he knew me and because Nick was the water and sewer commissioner and said, don't you think that particularly in light of all these lawsuits you guys are drawing, you should have a public That's a much more colorful accounting thing.

447
00:51:08.679 --> 00:51:09.724
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

448
00:51:09.773 --> 00:51:11.512
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go to Councilor Green, followed by Pirtle-Guiney.

449
00:51:13.052 --> 00:51:13.914
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

450
00:51:14.335 --> 00:51:18.628
<v Mitch Green>Um, again, I echo everything Councilor Novick said about the process and the qualifications.

451
00:51:19.436 --> 00:51:25.202
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm very impressed by your backgrounds, but also your interest and, uh, your willingness to serve and step up.

452
00:51:25.282 --> 00:51:42.719
<v Mitch Green>I do have an I do have basically one big question, and I would invite both of the present appointees or nominees to answer it, and however you think is best given your own experience and your own kind of, you know, approach to this.

453
00:51:43.356 --> 00:51:52.148
<v Mitch Green>But broadly speaking, how would you respond to a public that is worried about affordability Mm-hmm.

454
00:51:52.213 --> 00:51:56.916
<v Mitch Green>And rate pressure on the one hand, but we know that we need to invest in infrastructure on the other.

455
00:51:57.429 --> 00:51:58.376
<v Mitch Green>That's a tension, right?

456
00:51:58.617 --> 00:52:07.925
<v Mitch Green>And it's not an irreconcilable tension, but I think from what I've read from either of your backgrounds, you probably have some smart things to say on that.

457
00:52:08.246 --> 00:52:13.014
<v Mitch Green>And there's probably some— there's some labor issues involved, there's some environmental stewardship issues involved.

458
00:52:13.061 --> 00:52:17.509
<v Mitch Green>And so I ask this question because it's going to be important for this thank you.

459
00:52:17.572 --> 00:52:21.735
<v Mitch Green>I think it's a good time for us as a board, I think, to grapple with that because City Council is going to grapple with that.

460
00:52:22.331 --> 00:52:39.264
<v Mitch Green>A number of us have advocated for overhauling our approach to setting rates in the City of Portland to be a more robust and a more sort of thoroughgoing process that might consider rate design questions more broadly than we do it currently.

461
00:52:39.378 --> 00:52:51.742
<v Mitch Green>And so I'll start with you, Al, and I wonder if you have a response to that, or you can give me some kind of indications on how you might show up for that kind of a question in the future.

462
00:52:51.902 --> 00:52:52.144
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

463
00:52:53.512 --> 00:52:54.768
<v Al Haag>Gosh, yeah, it's a huge question.

464
00:52:56.615 --> 00:53:22.005
<v Al Haag>I think having the public be aware of how the rates are set, right, the structure of it, just being super transparent and presenting it in a clear fashion, kind of like meeting people where they can understand it, you know, so they can participate more in the process, right, and get their concerns about affordability out, if they have ideas about, you know, some kind of like financial assistance or discounts that we haven't considered yet, right?

465
00:53:22.184 --> 00:53:29.911
<v Al Haag>Like just soliciting that input and really listening to folks and incorporating that, I guess, into our decision-making, right?

466
00:53:30.460 --> 00:53:32.822
<v Al Haag>So yeah, seeing how folks are heard is important.

467
00:53:33.614 --> 00:53:34.099
<v Mitch Green>Thanks, Alan.

468
00:53:34.164 --> 00:53:35.166
<v Mitch Green>Just a quick follow-up.

469
00:53:36.360 --> 00:53:40.764
<v Mitch Green>You've got an interest in groups and conservation, I think, is a kind of thoroughgoing interest in you.

470
00:53:40.844 --> 00:53:50.510
<v Mitch Green>Do you have any views on the role of the Portland Clean Energy Fund as a source to help on the infrastructure side of these questions?

471
00:53:50.559 --> 00:53:55.864
<v Mitch Green>I mean, it's currently in a strategic investment plan for VES-related investments.

472
00:53:56.072 --> 00:54:00.849
<v Mitch Green>And so, you know, watersheds more broadly, tree cover, and that sort of thing.

473
00:54:01.764 --> 00:54:02.677
<v Mitch Green>Do you have any views on that?

474
00:54:03.831 --> 00:54:05.818
<v Al Haag>Yeah, I think it's like a perfect fit for those funds.

475
00:54:06.076 --> 00:54:13.081
<v Al Haag>Right, for PSF funds is, you know, BES projects and tree canopy projects, stuff like that, like dispersed stormwater infrastructure.

476
00:54:13.177 --> 00:54:15.545
<v Al Haag>Like, that fits right in with what PSF was created for.

477
00:54:15.608 --> 00:54:18.621
<v Al Haag>So I'm a proponent of considering funds for that.

478
00:54:19.364 --> 00:54:19.798
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

479
00:54:20.184 --> 00:54:24.052
<v Mitch Green>Joe, why don't you jump in here and give me any thoughts you have there?

480
00:54:24.842 --> 00:54:25.277
<v Joe Robinson>Certainly.

481
00:54:25.599 --> 00:54:31.206
<v Joe Robinson>So I encourage you to attend one of our future meetings where I'll probably have a more robust answer.

482
00:54:31.706 --> 00:54:44.492
<v Joe Robinson>For right now, I will just point out that yes, it is not an irreconcilable difference, and that is aided by the fact that the cost of these infrastructure upgrades is only going to increase over time.

483
00:54:45.021 --> 00:54:52.184
<v Joe Robinson>And this is a big consideration in the acceptance of bonds and financing programs for some of our CIP projects.

484
00:54:53.068 --> 00:54:58.865
<v Joe Robinson>Obviously, STEP and the Bull Run Water Filtration Project are very expensive.

485
00:54:58.963 --> 00:54:59.074
<v Joe Robinson>Thank you.

486
00:54:59.588 --> 00:55:01.532
<v Joe Robinson>It's very time-consuming, long processes.

487
00:55:01.902 --> 00:55:05.646
<v Joe Robinson>That does impact the rates that ratepayers have to contribute.

488
00:55:06.786 --> 00:55:11.349
<v Joe Robinson>However, if we put that off, we will no longer be compliant regulatory.

489
00:55:11.847 --> 00:55:15.300
<v Joe Robinson>We will no longer be providing the services to our constituents that we're supposed to be.

490
00:55:15.943 --> 00:55:21.389
<v Joe Robinson>And that to me is not an acceptable alternative.

491
00:55:21.983 --> 00:55:34.255
<v Joe Robinson>So while we do have to strike this balance, it's important to remember that these are going to a good these are going to city employees who will disburse them through the CIP projects in appropriate venues.

492
00:55:34.304 --> 00:55:41.572
<v Joe Robinson>And these are all very motivated people working for their neighbors and for the cleanliness of our local ecosystem.

493
00:55:42.311 --> 00:55:49.289
<v Joe Robinson>I will also point out that we do have other opportunities to offset some of the cost of these infrastructure upgrades.

494
00:55:49.822 --> 00:55:52.275
<v Joe Robinson>As you mentioned, there is PSUF available.

495
00:55:52.340 --> 00:55:52.405
<v Joe Robinson>Yes.

496
00:55:52.655 --> 00:55:56.043
<v Joe Robinson>Whether or not that is applicable is outside of my scope as an engineer.

497
00:55:56.606 --> 00:56:11.152
<v Joe Robinson>But we also have— and teams that I work with closely— the Energy Trust of Oregon, who help offset these electrical improvements, finding rebates at the state level that can make it even more cost-effective to introduce them now.

498
00:56:11.956 --> 00:56:22.755
<v Joe Robinson>If you look at something like the RNG program at Columbia Boulevard Wastewater Treatment Plant, that's a tremendous upgrade over the last few years, and it's a tremendous expense as well, and that does impact ratepayers.

499
00:56:23.108 --> 00:56:25.849
<v Joe Robinson>But at the end of the day, that's also a revenue-generating source.

500
00:56:26.172 --> 00:56:38.063
<v Joe Robinson>And if we didn't take that initial investment, if we didn't take that initial burden of having to increase rates to offset that, we wouldn't have this long-running revenue-generating source that is also a benefit for the environment.

501
00:56:39.690 --> 00:56:42.980
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate those responses, and I'll look forward to a future meeting.

502
00:56:43.737 --> 00:56:58.039
<v Mitch Green>One quick follow-up for Joe is, as the labor representative, do you see a role through the board to connect labor to the Bureau when we have to have some of those conversations around how to really control the cost of these big projects?

503
00:56:59.467 --> 00:57:00.110
<v Joe Robinson>Of course, yeah.

504
00:57:01.570 --> 00:57:09.969
<v Joe Robinson>That may be challenged as labor's presence within the utilities shifts with core realignment work ongoing.

505
00:57:11.603 --> 00:57:19.411
<v Joe Robinson>The voice is always going to be fluctuating, but I believe it's a two-way street, and that's why we have existing contracts that are in bargaining.

506
00:57:19.458 --> 00:57:24.989
<v Joe Robinson>That's why we have opportunities to speak before council directly, and that's why I'm hoping to join the Portland Utility Board.

507
00:57:25.871 --> 00:57:26.192
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

508
00:57:26.271 --> 00:57:27.041
<v Candace Avalos>You'll have my support.

509
00:57:27.538 --> 00:57:27.666
<v Candace Avalos>Chris?

510
00:57:28.130 --> 00:57:31.849
<v Kyle Chipman>I just wanted to build off of the points raised by our prospective board members.

511
00:57:32.427 --> 00:57:36.739
<v Kyle Chipman>It's wonderful because this, this is the same energy and spirit of conversation we've had over the past few months.

512
00:57:37.492 --> 00:57:56.690
<v Kyle Chipman>The nature of the cascading nature of cost felt by everyone that is amplified through public response and public comment, seeing these massive price tags that come on right now when I can barely afford X, Y, or Z, and to defer these costs and defer this investment the way that that only creates greater risk amplification.

513
00:57:56.802 --> 00:58:09.438
<v Kyle Chipman>So the technical nature of the response and the open broadcast of our sessions, I just wanted to reinforce 2 points for anyone listening, anyone who provided public testimony to our Board or to City Council.

514
00:58:09.710 --> 00:58:11.027
<v Kyle Chipman>They are truly open sessions.

515
00:58:11.074 --> 00:58:20.380
<v Kyle Chipman>We want to engage and involve everyone, and they're both technical and layperson equipped to really understand what the implications of these investments, not just cost, but investment are right now.

516
00:58:21.728 --> 00:58:21.936
<v Kyle Chipman>The—.

517
00:58:22.369 --> 00:58:24.887
<v Kyle Chipman>Oh, the second point too is brief timing.

518
00:58:25.032 --> 00:58:37.235
<v Kyle Chipman>It also builds upon the point of interest we as a Board have in really defining a working session with Council to, in good faith, really dive into these points and be ready to communicate them to the public, that it is about generational investment.

519
00:58:38.659 --> 00:58:43.445
<v Kyle Chipman>Just another quick note, I forgot to mention it in my notes, but September's a great point of alignment.

520
00:58:43.559 --> 00:58:46.097
<v Kyle Chipman>Our annual report and work plan's due September 30th.

521
00:58:46.679 --> 00:58:53.896
<v Kyle Chipman>And also just a thank you to Council Member Koyama Lane and her office for reaching out and coordinating a visit from her to our board meeting.

522
00:58:53.960 --> 00:58:54.815
<v Kyle Chipman>And that's looking at September.

523
00:58:54.864 --> 00:58:56.945
<v Kyle Chipman>So it feels like that's a timeframe when it can work.

524
00:58:57.041 --> 00:58:59.306
<v Kyle Chipman>So it's just, Heartfelt energy.

525
00:58:59.371 --> 00:58:59.628
<v Kyle Chipman>Thank you.

526
00:59:00.351 --> 00:59:01.684
<v Lorraine Wilson>Can I just say something too?

527
00:59:02.262 --> 00:59:05.889
<v Lorraine Wilson>I like to say I'm the least of lay members on the POP, okay?

528
00:59:06.387 --> 00:59:13.597
<v Lorraine Wilson>So when technical information come to me, I ask questions because I challenge the technocrats, okay?

529
00:59:14.239 --> 00:59:27.856
<v Lorraine Wilson>And I think that is important, and for council to understand the intentional work we have been doing over the years to dive into what does it mean for rate increase.

530
00:59:28.851 --> 00:59:30.666
<v Lorraine Wilson>And I said, I'm the least of late members.

531
00:59:31.405 --> 00:59:32.675
<v Lorraine Wilson>I don't want to see rate increase.

532
00:59:32.931 --> 00:59:47.128
<v Lorraine Wilson>However, I want to ensure that the infrastructure, the support we have from staff, that when those things come together, that we ensure that Portland has resilience in its public utilities.

533
00:59:47.722 --> 01:00:00.914
<v Lorraine Wilson>And when we come and we, and we do the work and we propose a rate increase or not, it is intentional and it's well-informed because we ask the questions up front.

534
01:00:01.364 --> 01:00:17.338
<v Lorraine Wilson>So I really would like you all to lean on us as a board that is putting in the work, putting in the time, volunteering their time, asking the hard questions, hoping that we start getting the information that we need once again so that we can provide that input.

535
01:00:17.434 --> 01:00:17.626
<v Lorraine Wilson>Thank you.

536
01:00:17.771 --> 01:00:24.563
<v Lorraine Wilson>So that you all can rely on us and that we can work collaboratively as we share that information with you during budget time.

537
01:00:24.900 --> 01:00:29.797
<v Lorraine Wilson>So you understand that we are not proposing rate increases or not for rate increase's sake.

538
01:00:30.150 --> 01:00:35.561
<v Lorraine Wilson>I don't want to see an increase in my water or sewer bill.

539
01:00:35.690 --> 01:00:37.521
<v Lorraine Wilson>So I just wanted to share that with you.

540
01:00:37.746 --> 01:00:39.239
<v Lorraine Wilson>So we look forward to working with you all.

541
01:00:40.170 --> 01:00:40.860
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

542
01:00:43.269 --> 01:00:44.920
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Green.

543
01:00:44.985 --> 01:00:46.637
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, followed by Councilor Dunphy.

544
01:00:48.016 --> 01:00:49.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

545
01:00:49.219 --> 01:00:58.536
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you to the, the board leadership for the robust process that you went through, and to our appointees for being willing to step up and serve and for being with us here today.

546
01:00:59.418 --> 01:01:04.358
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first part of what I was going to ask, I think you covered in Councilor Green's question.

547
01:01:04.454 --> 01:01:11.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm curious about that tension between the investments we need to make And the rising utility rates.

548
01:01:12.168 --> 01:01:19.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I want to ask about the visibility to that tension and the transparency piece of the work of the board.

549
01:01:20.576 --> 01:02:00.481
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm wondering what you see— the board already does a lot of good work— but what you see as your role, not just as the board, but as an individual, in helping to increase that transparency and that visibility so that Portlanders understand that tension we're dealing with between the need for investment and the way that that can lead to cost increases and the need to be careful about the cost increases for our utilities and how can you as a board member help us to make sure that Portlanders understand that tension and also know what to expect well before we get to budget season?

550
01:02:00.947 --> 01:02:05.972
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm happy to hear from either of you first, whoever wants to jump in.

551
01:02:06.422 --> 01:02:07.900
<v Al Haag>Yeah, I mean, that's great.

552
01:02:08.333 --> 01:02:31.199
<v Al Haag>I feel like Kyle covered it really well in making sure that we're giving opportunities, right, for the public to provide feedback to us at every opportunity, whether we're inviting them to our Portland Utility Board sessions or we're ourselves or representatives are going to, like, trusted community organizations that people are already involved in, right, that they participate in, that they've been with for years.

553
01:02:32.023 --> 01:02:50.134
<v Al Haag>And explaining that dynamic that you touched on about the tension between rate hikes and affordability, the why behind it, and just making time at these places, neighborhood organizations, associations, nonprofits, things like that, right?

554
01:02:51.056 --> 01:02:54.827
<v Al Haag>Cultural organizations to kind of meet people where they're already going to.

555
01:02:55.605 --> 01:02:55.847
<v Angelita Morillo>Cool.

556
01:02:57.309 --> 01:02:58.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great, thank you.

557
01:02:59.815 --> 01:03:14.605
<v Joe Robinson>And I can only build off of that great answer already by offering again to the general public, the councilors who are present, that we have tours available of the wastewater treatment plant, of Bull Run Filtration Area.

558
01:03:15.081 --> 01:03:19.721
<v Joe Robinson>It's a great idea to get folks involved and engaged in their local projects and their water.

559
01:03:20.155 --> 01:03:34.612
<v Joe Robinson>I think if you don't go out of your way to see what the tremendous amount of infrastructure is that's being built with those rates, it's easy to just look at that as some arbitrary cost that is being assigned sort of prescriptively.

560
01:03:35.204 --> 01:03:48.076
<v Joe Robinson>But getting a firsthand look and descending into the Swan Island CSO facility, for example, it's tremendous, and it's seriously a titanic undertaking that public servants have been doing for decades now.

561
01:03:48.684 --> 01:04:14.141
<v Joe Robinson>Obviously, there have been some issues with thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

562
01:04:14.255 --> 01:04:16.077
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Dunphy, followed by Councilor Ryan.

563
01:04:16.867 --> 01:04:17.478
<v Dunphy>Thank you, Chair.

564
01:04:17.992 --> 01:04:25.496
<v Dunphy>You know, most of my questions were mostly already taken, so I really wanted to focus in on about affordability and rates and going on.

565
01:04:25.625 --> 01:04:31.777
<v Dunphy>I had the— I've had the pleasure of attending many PUB meetings in my old job when I worked for Commissioner Nick Fish.

566
01:04:31.905 --> 01:04:33.742
<v Dunphy>I attended dozens of them.

567
01:04:34.257 --> 01:04:41.688
<v Dunphy>I found them incredibly boring, but because the folks were so incredibly laser-focused on the bottom line.

568
01:04:41.927 --> 01:04:44.878
<v Dunphy>They were— these were not meetings about having icebreakers.

569
01:04:44.927 --> 01:04:47.204
<v Dunphy>This was about digging into Excel spreadsheets.

570
01:04:47.909 --> 01:05:07.103
<v Dunphy>And I really ask all of you to make sure that we are keeping the bottom line in focus on this, that you all are not a rubber stamp, a simple body to review documents that the Bureau brings to you, but rather that you are the last line of defense between the public and the government when it comes to this.

571
01:05:07.152 --> 01:05:12.820
<v Dunphy>Because I have really deep concerns I'm really worried about rates.

572
01:05:12.840 --> 01:05:16.059
<v Dunphy>I'm really worried about some of these big projects that we are taking on.

573
01:05:16.260 --> 01:05:25.920
<v Dunphy>The water filtration plant is a goliath of a project, and it's quintupled in size since I got— I was last in this building.

574
01:05:26.179 --> 01:05:32.230
<v Dunphy>I'm really worried about that, and I'm worried about the direction of where rates are going over the next 10 years.

575
01:05:32.500 --> 01:05:34.440
<v Dunphy>Al, specifically, I'm worried about our neighbors in East Portland.

576
01:05:34.440 --> 01:05:34.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm worried about the future of the city.

577
01:05:35.498 --> 01:05:41.068
<v Dunphy>Folks who have been paying into the system broadly but not receiving the same level of benefits.

578
01:05:41.454 --> 01:05:50.313
<v Dunphy>And we know that on our side of town, as tight— as budgets get tight, families get desperate and things can spiral out of control.

579
01:05:50.362 --> 01:05:52.692
<v Dunphy>So I'm going to ask you all to just be really intentional about that.

580
01:05:53.097 --> 01:05:59.748
<v Dunphy>And the city has also really historically gone through ebbs and flows about the seriousness of ratepayer dollars.

581
01:06:00.885 --> 01:06:09.088
<v Dunphy>There have been periods where we were very loose about using ratepayer dollars for things, and then we got sued over and over again, and then we were incredibly tight.

582
01:06:09.282 --> 01:06:12.889
<v Dunphy>And I— and it's my opinion that we've sort of come back to the looser side of things.

583
01:06:13.552 --> 01:06:24.929
<v Dunphy>I hope that you will make sure that that is part of your ethos as you are approaching this, that ratepayer dollars are precious and that there are people who are ready to sue and are watching every step that we all take.

584
01:06:26.085 --> 01:06:26.197
<v Dunphy>Thank you.

585
01:06:26.342 --> 01:06:28.882
<v Dunphy>I want you to be brave and firm as you are thinking about this.

586
01:06:31.324 --> 01:06:40.922
<v Dunphy>It is a sometimes difficult position to be in as you are not necessarily equipped with the tools that a lot of the staff who will come to you are.

587
01:06:41.969 --> 01:06:47.833
<v Dunphy>A lot of the— you all have incredible experience, but also these processes can be confusing.

588
01:06:48.010 --> 01:06:54.509
<v Dunphy>And please take the moment to ask for more information and stop and really understand these things thank you.

589
01:06:54.630 --> 01:06:55.460
<v Dunphy>And not just assume.

590
01:06:56.949 --> 01:07:04.065
<v Dunphy>And then last, I want to make sure that you all are keeping a firm hand as the Bureau moves into— from 2 bureaus to one.

591
01:07:04.824 --> 01:07:06.507
<v Dunphy>That process has not yet completed yet.

592
01:07:06.605 --> 01:07:12.429
<v Dunphy>We're moving there towards changing some logos and changing some people's signatures and their email threads.

593
01:07:14.110 --> 01:07:22.681
<v Dunphy>But please, you know, recognize that this is an incredible moment of change while the Bureau is also trying to build the largest infrastructure project that we've built.

594
01:07:23.164 --> 01:07:28.914
<v Dunphy>There's an opportunity for really good things to happen, and there's an opportunity for some bad things to happen if we don't keep on it.

595
01:07:28.961 --> 01:07:42.405
<v Dunphy>So I'm really incredibly thankful to you for stepping up to public service in a moment right now, especially knowing that this particular role is not glamorous but incredibly necessary.

596
01:07:42.663 --> 01:07:47.476
<v Dunphy>And especially right now, as part of the broader conversation of what we are we're having in this community.

597
01:07:48.300 --> 01:07:56.688
<v Dunphy>Everybody is feeling the pinch and it is on to you guys to help us make sure that the information that comes to us for decisions has already been through your hands.

598
01:07:56.784 --> 01:07:58.106
<v Dunphy>So thank you guys for the opportunity.

599
01:07:58.153 --> 01:08:02.677
<v Dunphy>I look forward to supporting your nominations and working with you in the future.

600
01:08:02.983 --> 01:08:03.532
<v Dunphy>So thank you.

601
01:08:03.644 --> 01:08:04.289
<v Dunphy>Thank you, Chair.

602
01:08:06.452 --> 01:08:07.306
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy.

603
01:08:07.740 --> 01:08:09.641
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan.

604
01:08:09.898 --> 01:08:11.025
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

605
01:08:11.362 --> 01:08:12.474
<v Dan Ryan>It's good to see all of you.

606
01:08:12.554 --> 01:08:13.391
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks for being here.

607
01:08:13.456 --> 01:08:15.677
<v Dan Ryan>First of all, I'm supportive of the nominees, so I'm gonna dive into a couple other things.

608
01:08:18.137 --> 01:08:22.637
<v Dan Ryan>I want to underscore the tenor out there about the rate increases.

609
01:08:23.154 --> 01:08:29.795
<v Dan Ryan>I've been going to neighborhood association meetings now for about 6 years, and you always have PBOT concerns.

610
01:08:30.720 --> 01:08:34.342
<v Dan Ryan>PBOT, sorry, that's just what it's like when you go to a neighborhood association meeting.

611
01:08:35.752 --> 01:08:38.219
<v Dan Ryan>And there's other things that pop up now and then.

612
01:08:38.895 --> 01:08:43.603
<v Dan Ryan>But the anger, it's like anger about the rate increases is real.

613
01:08:44.166 --> 01:08:52.002
<v Dan Ryan>And so I know we had a discussion about that earlier, and we're on the inside and we understand how important it is to meet the regulatory.

614
01:08:52.819 --> 01:09:04.644
<v Dan Ryan>Translating that to people who are experiencing an increase in service— not increase, in their perception, a decrease in services and an increase in cost is real for Portlanders right now.

615
01:09:05.557 --> 01:09:08.377
<v Dan Ryan>And they're not used to seeing such big rate increases.

616
01:09:08.939 --> 01:09:10.220
<v Dan Ryan>So I just want you to—.

617
01:09:10.237 --> 01:09:10.685
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

618
01:09:10.942 --> 01:09:11.890
<v Dan Ryan>Understand that.

619
01:09:12.292 --> 01:09:15.715
<v Dan Ryan>I know that they might come to your meeting, but they definitely come at us.

620
01:09:16.083 --> 01:09:21.917
<v Dan Ryan>And so I just wanted to make sure you really understood how important this issue is and that tension.

621
01:09:22.817 --> 01:09:33.277
<v Dan Ryan>I had the pleasure with Councilor Zimmerman, we went on a field trip, an insight trip to the water filtration construction site this last Friday, and it was very helpful.

622
01:09:33.453 --> 01:09:35.606
<v Dan Ryan>It was actually lovely to see so many cranes up.

623
01:09:36.265 --> 01:09:40.407
<v Dan Ryan>It looked like Portland circa 2016, just in this one spot.

624
01:09:40.502 --> 01:09:41.402
<v Dan Ryan>There were cranes everywhere.

625
01:09:41.449 --> 01:09:42.252
<v Dan Ryan>It's a big project.

626
01:09:43.391 --> 01:09:51.239
<v Dan Ryan>It was helpful for me to be there and to ask serious questions to have better insight into the complexity of that project.

627
01:09:51.993 --> 01:09:54.899
<v Dan Ryan>So this I guess would be for both the co-chairs, Lorraine and Kyle.

628
01:09:55.091 --> 01:09:59.296
<v Dan Ryan>Have you all had an opportunity recently to go on a trip?

629
01:10:00.467 --> 01:10:01.479
<v Kyle Chipman>Not directly to Bull Run.

630
01:10:01.527 --> 01:10:03.934
<v Kyle Chipman>We are scheduling it for the future.

631
01:10:04.095 --> 01:10:10.519
<v Kyle Chipman>We've had our 2 team members on PDAT have taken onsite visits, but that is a board— it's absolutely for our board.

632
01:10:10.855 --> 01:10:13.345
<v Kyle Chipman>It's been more like local sites we've taken to date.

633
01:10:13.506 --> 01:10:17.988
<v Dan Ryan>So, so far you have not as a— as Pub done an onsite trip?

634
01:10:18.149 --> 01:10:22.568
<v Amy Archer Masters>No, but we're currently working with the Bureau to schedule one within the next couple months.

635
01:10:22.663 --> 01:10:27.323
<v Kyle Chipman>It was 2 years ago and like the site was being basically like forecast and projected.

636
01:10:27.387 --> 01:10:28.496
<v Kyle Chipman>But yeah, we're—.

637
01:10:28.577 --> 01:10:28.752
<v Kyle Chipman>It's—.

638
01:10:28.752 --> 01:10:30.296
<v Kyle Chipman>We just sent out a survey like last week.

639
01:10:30.344 --> 01:10:31.323
<v Dan Ryan>That's fair, Kyle.

640
01:10:31.564 --> 01:10:34.180
<v Dan Ryan>I went several years ago and it was quite a different scene.

641
01:10:34.293 --> 01:10:34.502
<v Dan Ryan>Oh yeah.

642
01:10:34.630 --> 01:10:40.865
<v Dan Ryan>So I really can't stress how important it, it's so important for you to do those trips and to stay on top of that.

643
01:10:40.945 --> 01:10:44.729
<v Dan Ryan>So I look forward to hearing that you have those as regularly scheduled.

644
01:10:45.097 --> 01:10:49.024
<v Dan Ryan>And what does oversight look like for you in terms of monitoring that project?

645
01:10:49.603 --> 01:11:12.342
<v Kyle Chipman>Yeah, with turnover of bureau director leadership and the starting of construction, the Project Delivery Advisory Team assembling not only representatives from PUB, but professionals who have managed super projects and these massively scaled, massively budgeted.

646
01:11:12.845 --> 01:11:19.408
<v Kyle Chipman>That is the opening point of access with, I think every 2 to 2.5 months there's a return report.

647
01:11:19.909 --> 01:11:22.685
<v Kyle Chipman>So that's kind of our eyes on the ground, so to speak.

648
01:11:22.750 --> 01:11:38.682
<v Kyle Chipman>And we receive updates around communications, project management, milestone delivery, I know that there's also Director Lew is preparing for the financial advisory team or a specific council of individuals to provide transparency around the management of the funds to run the project.

649
01:11:39.083 --> 01:11:59.682
<v Kyle Chipman>So I would say that I'm not putting like just the same point every time, but I'm really motivated for the working session 'cause a lot of these points we can bring not only here, the points of priority, but those we identify as a board bring them for collaboration, and then ideally find some kind of regular delivery and dissemination, not just to council but to the public as well.

650
01:11:59.877 --> 01:12:08.768
<v Kyle Chipman>Because what you're describing, I felt that intensity from the public even as we're toward the end of budget cycle this past season, from public testimony to our meetings and public testimony to y'all.

651
01:12:10.377 --> 01:12:12.434
<v Kyle Chipman>So that is not a simple thing to communicate.

652
01:12:12.979 --> 01:12:14.201
<v Kyle Chipman>That is our point of access so far.

653
01:12:16.369 --> 01:12:21.291
<v Dan Ryan>I, I realize that we're having a conversation about a priority for PUB, and I know you have quite a few.

654
01:12:21.829 --> 01:12:25.715
<v Dan Ryan>But this, in my opinion, has to really be urgent and frequent.

655
01:12:27.029 --> 01:12:36.385
<v Dan Ryan>It's a project I've been supportive of multiple times on this dais, and it's been rough to continue to support it as it keeps escalating.

656
01:12:36.676 --> 01:12:39.207
<v Dan Ryan>And so, as you know, it's at $2.5 billion now.

657
01:12:39.596 --> 01:12:46.448
<v Dan Ryan>And so I just hope that you have a regular routine of spending time on this topic.

658
01:12:46.496 --> 01:12:46.545
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

659
01:12:46.865 --> 01:12:52.511
<v Dan Ryan>And by scheduling time for all of you to do insight trips together as a, as a PUP board.

660
01:12:52.896 --> 01:12:53.636
<v Dan Ryan>That's my ask of you.

661
01:12:53.957 --> 01:12:54.279
<v Kyle Chipman>Thank you.

662
01:12:54.569 --> 01:12:56.277
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

663
01:12:56.519 --> 01:13:11.827
<v Amy Archer Masters>Councilor Ryan, I would just add to what Kyle shared that currently every month, so at the Tuesday meeting typically, we're getting more hands-on updates about the filtration project specifically.

664
01:13:11.891 --> 01:13:21.243
<v Amy Archer Masters>So on top of there's also full board updates that are led by both the project managers and the director.

665
01:13:21.771 --> 01:13:28.840
<v Dan Ryan>And when we had the work stoppage due to some legal issues, how were you all informed about that work stoppage?

666
01:13:30.042 --> 01:13:40.765
<v Amy Archer Masters>We had ongoing conversations with the bureau, so we were receiving updates, also dialogue around what the next steps were as far as decision-making on the land use issue.

667
01:13:41.262 --> 01:13:50.372
<v Amy Archer Masters>There's still, you know, more time needed as the project moves forward to get into some of the detail.

668
01:13:50.565 --> 01:13:56.479
<v Amy Archer Masters>But there was a lot of dialogue and opportunity for question and answer to understand what the applications were.

669
01:13:56.849 --> 01:13:57.250
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, great.

670
01:13:57.314 --> 01:13:59.404
<v Dan Ryan>You have that lived experience to know that time is money.

671
01:13:59.500 --> 01:14:03.677
<v Dan Ryan>And so the work stoppage has been quite a bruise to this process.

672
01:14:04.239 --> 01:14:06.859
<v Dan Ryan>So you have to do— you all have to do everything you can to ensure that we can get this done.

673
01:14:08.639 --> 01:14:21.981
<v Lorraine Wilson>And I think from direct input from the public, we are now— Director Liu is now raising up this financial team to look at it because we've been asking things about it.

674
01:14:22.671 --> 01:14:33.030
<v Lorraine Wilson>And we always emphasize when we talk about public engagement, we have to make the information digestible for the public.

675
01:14:33.930 --> 01:14:35.809
<v Lorraine Wilson>So that they will understand what it is.

676
01:14:35.921 --> 01:14:37.752
<v Lorraine Wilson>We can't just say, oh, you come to it.

677
01:14:38.233 --> 01:14:40.979
<v Lorraine Wilson>The first question, the public, why is this important to me?

678
01:14:42.344 --> 01:14:46.180
<v Lorraine Wilson>If I'm coming to a meeting and I don't understand what's happening in it, why is it important to me?

679
01:14:46.278 --> 01:14:47.305
<v Lorraine Wilson>I can't contribute it.

680
01:14:47.386 --> 01:14:49.231
<v Lorraine Wilson>I can't ask the questions I need to ask.

681
01:14:49.488 --> 01:14:52.378
<v Lorraine Wilson>I don't understand what the impact is going to be to me.

682
01:14:52.845 --> 01:14:59.962
<v Lorraine Wilson>So there it is where when, when we speak to, um, to the city that's one of the things.

683
01:15:00.027 --> 01:15:05.265
<v Lorraine Wilson>Yes, it's nice to have a financial committee to talk about how people— over people's head.

684
01:15:05.474 --> 01:15:09.581
<v Lorraine Wilson>No, we're requesting information in a digestible form.

685
01:15:09.662 --> 01:15:19.162
<v Lorraine Wilson>We are requesting data in a digestible form so that anyone who comes to the meeting will know why this is important to me and how it will impact me.

686
01:15:20.810 --> 01:15:23.314
<v Dan Ryan>Lorraine, thank you for using such language as digestible.

687
01:15:23.527 --> 01:15:23.609
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

688
01:15:23.707 --> 01:15:30.898
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm counting on you, Lorraine, to I'm the least of Lee members.

689
01:15:31.237 --> 01:15:32.172
<v Lorraine Wilson>I asked the question.

690
01:15:36.789 --> 01:15:37.841
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

691
01:15:38.422 --> 01:15:39.409
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, I'm next in the queue.

692
01:15:39.490 --> 01:15:45.409
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to take the opportunity to thank the staff for doing an excellent recruitment, coming up with great applicants.

693
01:15:45.475 --> 01:15:54.774
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to all 3 applicants for stepping up, and to Councilor Clark for keeping up on this and making sure that we did in fact fill that emerging 3rd vacancy.

694
01:15:55.591 --> 01:16:08.833
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm looking forward to hearing the update, whether it's in Public Works or in this committee in a few months, and I'll be deferring to Councilor Clark, chair of that committee, for scheduling on that.

695
01:16:09.859 --> 01:16:25.926
<v Sameer Kanal>I did want to flag, in addition to saying that I agree with much of the comments being that my colleagues have made, in particular around what we hear as well, I'm looking at the schedule of your meetings, and I'm curious if you receive a lot of public testimony.

696
01:16:25.989 --> 01:16:34.056
<v Sameer Kanal>I know it was mentioned that you hear that you receive public testimony at every meeting, but I'm just curious what the relative level of that is.

697
01:16:34.248 --> 01:16:36.831
<v Sameer Kanal>How frequent is it that there is public testimony?

698
01:16:38.177 --> 01:16:38.707
<v Lorraine Wilson>Depends.

699
01:16:39.043 --> 01:16:43.164
<v Kyle Chipman>I would say infrequent at best, but which is not to say that people don't attend.

700
01:16:43.229 --> 01:16:48.564
<v Kyle Chipman>We have certain members of the public who are regularly attending and predate my time significantly.

701
01:16:51.000 --> 01:16:52.971
<v Kyle Chipman>This is, again, a genuine point.

702
01:16:53.198 --> 01:17:08.944
<v Kyle Chipman>Reflecting as well on Councilmember Ryan's questions and Councilmember Pirtle-Guiney, I think a big challenge which I've even felt as I try to keep pace with City Council is it's difficult for people to carve out time to attend, let alone to become engaged enough to know what question to ask.

703
01:17:09.346 --> 01:17:13.394
<v Kyle Chipman>And the result is the delivery of a fee that is totally disconnected and I see a dollar sign in front of me.

704
01:17:13.896 --> 01:17:33.057
<v Kyle Chipman>So I think not only finding ways, and part of what I hope in the coming work plan is also engaging with the comms teams to understand what is the full spectrum of opportunity we have to relay the technical information we receive and our points of advocacy beyond the expectation that there's the attendance, you know, hour and a half every week, sometimes during the working day.

705
01:17:33.688 --> 01:17:34.962
<v Kyle Chipman>How can we reach people?

706
01:17:35.155 --> 01:17:39.127
<v Kyle Chipman>And then how can we receive points of community engagement in a good faith, open-hearted way?

707
01:17:40.929 --> 01:17:43.365
<v Kyle Chipman>Yes, that has been the extent to date.

708
01:17:43.430 --> 01:17:50.212
<v Kyle Chipman>And I also feel the intensity of response from public around not only rate increases, but the cost of the facility.

709
01:17:50.661 --> 01:17:56.833
<v Kyle Chipman>So this, it's not that we don't have answers right now, but this is a major point of focus for the Board is my response.

710
01:17:56.898 --> 01:17:58.180
<v Kyle Chipman>Any response, Lorena Topp?

711
01:17:59.046 --> 01:18:08.104
<v Lorraine Wilson>I think it depends because just before the budget we had a few people while they came, it was regarding the filtration plant.

712
01:18:08.538 --> 01:18:14.387
<v Lorraine Wilson>So it depends on the topic also, and it goes back to me saying, why should they attend, right?

713
01:18:17.038 --> 01:18:18.390
<v Lorraine Wilson>People's time are limited.

714
01:18:18.568 --> 01:18:21.015
<v Lorraine Wilson>We are undergoing a lot of stresses right now.

715
01:18:21.466 --> 01:18:23.207
<v Lorraine Wilson>People have a lot of things pulling at them.

716
01:18:24.528 --> 01:18:26.783
<v Lorraine Wilson>Why would they want to do so?

717
01:18:26.881 --> 01:18:42.809
<v Lorraine Wilson>So it's all about accessibility and ensuring that we, that the city is providing the information that people want to come and seek in a way that they would understand it.

718
01:18:42.889 --> 01:18:46.158
<v Lorraine Wilson>So that's my take on it.

719
01:18:48.444 --> 01:18:49.314
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that.

720
01:18:49.957 --> 01:18:56.699
<v Sameer Kanal>And I noticed that you do one of the best practices to some degree, which is that you alternate times and days.

721
01:18:56.796 --> 01:19:00.194
<v Sameer Kanal>You have Tuesdays and Thursdays, 11 o'clock and and 3:30.

722
01:19:01.667 --> 01:19:05.921
<v Sameer Kanal>The one thing I'd suggest is to go just one step further.

723
01:19:05.970 --> 01:19:19.573
<v Sameer Kanal>Maybe this is a suggestion to co-chairs and more likely to staff, to put at least one of them outside of a weekday at 9 to 5 in that window to give people the opportunity for that accessibility.

724
01:19:20.154 --> 01:19:22.488
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to put that on the table.

725
01:19:23.132 --> 01:19:39.001
<v Sameer Kanal>The other thing I wanted to say before I pass it off to to my Vice Chair Koyama Lane is that I really appreciate that you've put all the information into this report that we have been asking for about, you know, term lengths and who's being replaced and those sorts of things as well.

726
01:19:39.064 --> 01:19:40.731
<v Sameer Kanal>So just wanted to thank the staff for that.

727
01:19:41.389 --> 01:19:43.666
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll pass it over to Vice Chair Koyama Lane.

728
01:19:45.123 --> 01:19:45.797
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair.

729
01:19:46.743 --> 01:19:55.132
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm not sure who says the Portland Utility Board conversations are boring because this has been very interesting, and I'm really grateful for all of you being here.

730
01:19:55.423 --> 01:19:59.109
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Happy to support these members being appointed.

731
01:20:00.127 --> 01:20:09.385
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I just wanted to comment when there was— we were talking about reaching the public, comms, explaining things in a digestible way.

732
01:20:09.626 --> 01:20:16.400
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do think that part of that work is our job too, as councilors that are supposed to be on the ground connecting with constituents.

733
01:20:16.750 --> 01:20:16.966
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes.

734
01:20:17.672 --> 01:20:26.377
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Information that you want us to be boosting, I can speak for my office, I guess, want me to be boosting in my newsletter, on social media, let me know.

735
01:20:26.472 --> 01:20:33.338
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's a way that we can be working together to share out opportunities and educational information.

736
01:20:33.533 --> 01:20:34.020
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

737
01:20:36.140 --> 01:20:44.578
<v Lorraine Wilson>And just, just to say something, I think it's, as you say, it's the council's responsibility and also the the city's responsible.

738
01:20:44.675 --> 01:21:01.542
<v Lorraine Wilson>As I said, in my former life I worked at the city, and one of the programs that I was working on was, um, in the former government structure, was bringing boroughs to get bureaus together to understand how do we do outreach, right?

739
01:21:01.605 --> 01:21:09.935
<v Lorraine Wilson>Because we'll have a city, one bureau having a meeting right down the street from the other one, and we're going to the same people and we're asking the same questions over and over.

740
01:21:10.273 --> 01:21:12.505
<v Lorraine Wilson>We have the data, nothing is being done with the data.

741
01:21:12.586 --> 01:21:15.943
<v Lorraine Wilson>We're reinventing the wheel every time somebody new comes in and all of that.

742
01:21:16.520 --> 01:21:19.235
<v Lorraine Wilson>And how can we do that in a collaborative?

743
01:21:19.685 --> 01:21:26.625
<v Lorraine Wilson>So we, we convened a lunchtime session with, with all the outreach people, and we would talk about better practices.

744
01:21:26.801 --> 01:21:30.448
<v Lorraine Wilson>I like to say better practices because there's always room for improvement.

745
01:21:30.978 --> 01:21:32.135
<v Lorraine Wilson>There are no best practices.

746
01:21:32.262 --> 01:21:33.805
<v Lorraine Wilson>We live, we learn, we improve.

747
01:21:34.431 --> 01:21:47.948
<v Lorraine Wilson>And hopefully that would be something that is continued at this city as we look as in this new government structure where things are now being, um, brought together, especially the bureaus, the utility bureaus, other bureaus.

748
01:21:47.996 --> 01:22:01.662
<v Lorraine Wilson>And how do we do outreach as a city and that we do it in a way that, that the residents of Portland are not once again burdened by this ongoing outreach?

749
01:22:01.774 --> 01:22:03.521
<v Lorraine Wilson>And how could they come to PAB?

750
01:22:03.601 --> 01:22:05.155
<v Lorraine Wilson>And how could they be involved?

751
01:22:05.203 --> 01:22:08.314
<v Lorraine Wilson>And what they need to get So that we can do— we can work together.

752
01:22:08.409 --> 01:22:15.671
<v Lorraine Wilson>I'm all for having a meeting on a weekend, but I'm not going to commit to having a meeting on a weekend for having a weekend.

753
01:22:15.720 --> 01:22:23.863
<v Lorraine Wilson>We have to do the work to get to that point where we're ensuring that we are doing what we're doing, all these intermediary steps to get to that point.

754
01:22:24.073 --> 01:22:25.403
<v Lorraine Wilson>So that's what I wanted to share.

755
01:22:25.819 --> 01:22:31.639
<v Lorraine Wilson>Let's work together to get Portland residents involved in city government.

756
01:22:36.952 --> 01:22:38.128
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

757
01:22:38.386 --> 01:22:55.222
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that last point, Lorraine, and having been in many of those same conversations myself in the last few years in my previous role, I really do acknowledge the need for the staff side to really promote these sorts of things and help with those, as you put it, those first steps.

758
01:22:56.716 --> 01:22:59.444
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing no one else in the queue, We do need a motion.

759
01:22:59.492 --> 01:23:01.466
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a report proposed by Mayor Wilson.

760
01:23:01.903 --> 01:23:07.659
<v Sameer Kanal>We do need a motion to refer this item on to the full council with a recommendation that it be passed.

761
01:23:08.224 --> 01:23:08.899
<v Loretta Smith>So moved.

762
01:23:09.158 --> 01:23:09.625
<v Olivia Clark>Second.

763
01:23:12.394 --> 01:23:15.114
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that was Councilor Clark.

764
01:23:15.775 --> 01:23:18.027
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't— I didn't catch who made the second.

765
01:23:20.024 --> 01:23:20.894
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

766
01:23:21.320 --> 01:23:21.518
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

767
01:23:22.222 --> 01:23:22.814
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

768
01:23:23.893 --> 01:23:25.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there any further discussion on this item?

769
01:23:27.202 --> 01:23:28.912
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing none, Rebecca, will you please call the roll?

770
01:23:30.279 --> 01:23:39.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>Calling the roll on, uh, document 2026-238, uh, moved by Councilor Clark, seconded by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

771
01:23:39.939 --> 01:23:43.699
<v Rebecca Dobert>And beginning correctly with District 3, Koyama Lane.

772
01:23:44.296 --> 01:23:45.055
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks for stepping up.

773
01:23:45.185 --> 01:23:45.314
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

774
01:23:46.460 --> 01:23:46.800
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo.

775
01:23:47.480 --> 01:23:47.854
<v Rebecca Dobert>Morillo.

776
01:23:49.231 --> 01:23:49.280
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

777
01:23:52.800 --> 01:23:53.100
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

778
01:23:55.000 --> 01:23:56.340
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

779
01:23:56.340 --> 01:23:56.340
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

780
01:23:56.340 --> 01:23:57.619
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

781
01:23:57.619 --> 01:23:58.119
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

782
01:23:58.119 --> 01:23:58.979
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman.

783
01:23:58.979 --> 01:24:00.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

784
01:24:00.100 --> 01:24:01.939
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos.

785
01:24:03.520 --> 01:24:04.560
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

786
01:24:04.560 --> 01:24:05.140
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy.

787
01:24:05.140 --> 01:24:05.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

788
01:24:05.979 --> 01:24:06.840
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

789
01:24:06.840 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

790
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark.

791
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

792
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

793
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

794
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman.

795
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

796
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos.

797
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

798
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy.

799
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

800
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

801
01:24:07.739 --> 01:24:07.800
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

802
01:24:07.800 --> 01:24:08.439
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

803
01:24:08.439 --> 01:24:09.359
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

804
01:24:09.359 --> 01:24:10.060
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan.

805
01:24:10.060 --> 01:24:11.079
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

806
01:24:11.079 --> 01:24:12.859
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal.

807
01:24:12.930 --> 01:24:14.220
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you all for being willing to serve.

808
01:24:14.220 --> 01:24:14.520
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

809
01:24:15.412 --> 01:24:19.412
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the motion is approved, uh, with 12 aye votes.

810
01:24:19.493 --> 01:24:25.395
<v Rebecca Dobert>The report is, uh, referred as amended to City Council with a recommendation that it be accepted.

811
01:24:27.277 --> 01:24:28.542
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, everyone.

812
01:24:29.222 --> 01:24:33.065
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Rebecca, will you please call the next 2 items together?

813
01:24:35.618 --> 01:24:40.158
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item, item 3, discussion on Home Forward, document number 2026-239.

814
01:24:41.859 --> 01:24:47.000
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 4, public input on Home Forward document number 2026-240.

815
01:24:50.158 --> 01:24:50.578
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

816
01:24:50.658 --> 01:25:00.654
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to give some introductory remarks while our presenters shift out and back in, um, and then I'm going to pass it over to talk to, um, to, to Chair Avalos before we go to our presenters.

817
01:25:01.314 --> 01:25:08.671
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, today we're going to first hear from Chair Avalos, then we're going to have, uh, Home Forward Executive Director Michael Bonacore, City Attorney Adrian Del Coto.

818
01:25:09.057 --> 01:25:25.458
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we're going to have The director, I believe, but certainly leadership from the Portland Housing Bureau, as well as Portland Solutions Director Skylar Brocker-Knapp, is going to be talking primarily about the strike team, which relates to the part that relates to Home Forward.

819
01:25:26.775 --> 01:25:26.889
<v Dan Ryan>Our—.

820
01:25:27.980 --> 01:25:29.395
<v Sameer Kanal>The purpose behind this has shifted.

821
01:25:29.443 --> 01:25:34.921
<v Sameer Kanal>As I mentioned, we had a parallel item that was not filed to appoint members to the Home Forward board.

822
01:25:34.970 --> 01:25:38.338
<v Sameer Kanal>However, we will have future appointments to the Home Forward board.

823
01:25:38.756 --> 01:25:57.398
<v Sameer Kanal>And we've heard many different opinions from different councilors expressed in public for what the Home Forward should do in light of some recent reporting and some recent challenges at that organization, as well as, of course, the leadership change, ranging from we should look at this one or 2 types of people being on it to we should start over with the entire board.

824
01:25:57.975 --> 01:26:07.466
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think it's important that we use this time to showcase what council priorities We would like to see those appointees be able to meet.

825
01:26:07.530 --> 01:26:11.234
<v Sameer Kanal>What's the profile, as well as what can they be prepared to address when they come forward?

826
01:26:11.300 --> 01:26:20.247
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's fairer to potential future appointees than surprising them or having an unknown sort of standard that they'd have to meet.

827
01:26:20.841 --> 01:26:29.324
<v Sameer Kanal>We are discussing Home Forward specifically among affordable housing providers more broadly because of Home Forward's public role as a housing authority and its uniqueness.

828
01:26:30.051 --> 01:26:33.350
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to also be clear that this is not an oversight hearing.

829
01:26:34.434 --> 01:26:36.876
<v Sameer Kanal>We may have an oversight conversation in the future.

830
01:26:37.184 --> 01:26:39.186
<v Sameer Kanal>I know it's been proposed, but this is not that.

831
01:26:39.266 --> 01:26:51.247
<v Sameer Kanal>Today is about information gathering and about communication to not only the presenters, but also to the mayor and city administrator about what council will be looking for in future appointees.

832
01:26:53.390 --> 01:27:00.788
<v Sameer Kanal>So as Executive Director Bonaccor, City Attorney Del Coto, Director Light, I hope, and Director Brockenapper come forward.

833
01:27:00.837 --> 01:27:10.046
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to pass it over to Chair Avalos to give us some insight not only into this conversation broadly, but the conversations that have happened at the Housing and Permitting Committee already.

834
01:27:10.382 --> 01:27:11.009
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

835
01:27:11.842 --> 01:27:12.548
<v Michael Bonacore>Great.

836
01:27:12.869 --> 01:27:13.447
<v Queesha Light>Thank you, Chair.

837
01:27:14.329 --> 01:27:27.810
<v Candace Avalos>So yeah, when this topic— when this topic came before the Housing and Permitting Committee in May, we intentionally broadened the conversation organization and looked at the overall state of Portland's affordable housing system.

838
01:27:28.436 --> 01:27:40.255
<v Candace Avalos>So we convened a panel that included the Portland Housing Bureau, Home Forward, nonprofit housing providers, housing finance experts, and affordable housing advocates to better understand the challenges that they're seeing across the system.

839
01:27:41.137 --> 01:27:47.704
<v Candace Avalos>While Home Forward was part of that discussion, what became clear was that many of the issues we've been reading about are not unique to one provider, but are common across the system.

840
01:27:48.106 --> 01:27:51.863
<v Candace Avalos>Panelists consistently described a system under significant strain.

841
01:27:52.440 --> 01:27:57.257
<v Candace Avalos>The committee heard that the financial model supporting affordable housing has changed dramatically since the pandemic.

842
01:27:57.738 --> 01:28:04.787
<v Candace Avalos>Operating costs including insurance, maintenance, utilities, security, and labor have risen substantially while funding has not kept pace.

843
01:28:05.381 --> 01:28:11.449
<v Candace Avalos>At the same time, providers were serving residents with increasingly complex behavioral health and supportive service needs.

844
01:28:12.284 --> 01:28:14.902
<v Candace Avalos>We also spent considerable time discussing vacancies.

845
01:28:15.416 --> 01:28:25.900
<v Candace Avalos>Providers explained that vacancy rates are influenced by a combination of affordability, geography, unit size, neighborhood conditions, financing requirements, and market trends.

846
01:28:26.430 --> 01:28:38.761
<v Candace Avalos>Several emphasized that the issue is more complex than simply lowering rents because affordable housing providers also have to generate enough revenue to maintain buildings, provide resident services, and remain financially viable.

847
01:28:39.981 --> 01:28:44.054
<v Candace Avalos>Another major theme was the importance of resident services and property management.

848
01:28:44.470 --> 01:28:56.220
<v Candace Avalos>Panelists consistently described those services as essential to housing stability, community safety, and successful tenancy, while also noting that they are increasingly difficult to sustain under current funding models.

849
01:28:57.038 --> 01:29:15.201
<v Candace Avalos>Finally, the committee discussed opportunities moving forward, including preserving existing affordable housing, recapitalizing aging properties, improving coordination across governments, and ensuring future investments support both the long-term sustainability of buildings and the services residents need to remain successfully housed.

850
01:29:15.891 --> 01:29:28.737
<v Candace Avalos>Overall, the takeaway from the committee was that these are system-wide challenges affecting affordable housing providers across Portland, and addressing them will require coordinated policy, sustainable funding, and long-term investment.

851
01:29:29.251 --> 01:29:30.631
<v Candace Avalos>So that is my report.

852
01:29:30.984 --> 01:29:31.145
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

853
01:29:34.037 --> 01:29:35.533
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

854
01:29:35.646 --> 01:29:43.140
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe we're going to hear the presentations first, so I'll start with Director Bonacore.

855
01:29:43.286 --> 01:29:44.270
<v Sameer Kanal>Please take it away.

856
01:29:44.997 --> 01:29:47.385
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you, Chair Kanal, Commissioners.

857
01:29:47.481 --> 01:29:48.095
<v Michael Bonacore>Michael Bonacore.

858
01:29:48.368 --> 01:29:50.905
<v Michael Bonacore>I'm the interim executive director for Home Forward.

859
01:29:50.989 --> 01:29:52.323
<v Michael Bonacore>Thanks for having me here today.

860
01:29:55.002 --> 01:29:58.228
<v Michael Bonacore>We are going to— next slide, please.

861
01:29:59.372 --> 01:30:10.117
<v Michael Bonacore>We're going to— I know the thrust of your conversation is around the appointment of commissioners to the Home Forward board.

862
01:30:10.726 --> 01:30:12.282
<v Michael Bonacore>I'll touch lightly on that.

863
01:30:12.618 --> 01:30:20.204
<v Michael Bonacore>And as Chair Kanal said, Adrian Delgado is here as the city's expert on the legal considerations there.

864
01:30:20.412 --> 01:30:21.600
<v Michael Bonacore>So I'll touch on it.

865
01:30:21.936 --> 01:30:27.886
<v Michael Bonacore>Chair Kanal asked me to give a little bit of a status update on the housing portfolio, so I'll do that.

866
01:30:27.951 --> 01:30:28.046
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

867
01:30:29.951 --> 01:30:39.735
<v Michael Bonacore>Share a little bit about our voucher program as perspective relative to the housing portfolio, and then just a quick update on where we're at organizationally.

868
01:30:40.081 --> 01:30:41.458
<v Michael Bonacore>So that should all move pretty briskly.

869
01:30:43.340 --> 01:30:43.873
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide, please.

870
01:30:47.371 --> 01:30:49.268
<v Michael Bonacore>So a quick bit of history.

871
01:30:50.012 --> 01:30:59.934
<v Michael Bonacore>HomeForward was formed in 1941, passed by resolution from City Council establishing it as an independent entity.

872
01:31:00.993 --> 01:31:09.432
<v Michael Bonacore>And then in 1992, the City of Portland, Multnomah County, and the City of Gresham and Home Forward entered into 2 IGAs.

873
01:31:10.460 --> 01:31:20.231
<v Michael Bonacore>So one IGA defined the area of the housing authority operations, which had originally extended 10 miles beyond city boundaries.

874
01:31:20.810 --> 01:31:31.083
<v Michael Bonacore>And so with the establishment of this Agreement, it established Home Forward service area as all of Multnomah County.

875
01:31:31.439 --> 01:31:32.216
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide, please.

876
01:31:33.930 --> 01:31:40.141
<v Michael Bonacore>And then importantly for this conversation, the other IGA defines commissioner appointments.

877
01:31:40.320 --> 01:31:47.417
<v Michael Bonacore>So the board was expanded to 9 members, all of whom are appointed via the City of Portland.

878
01:31:49.662 --> 01:31:57.643
<v Michael Bonacore>So of the 9, 5 commissioners are selected and appointed from the City of Portland, 2 from Gresham, and 2 from Multnomah County.

879
01:31:58.557 --> 01:32:13.217
<v Michael Bonacore>And so while all of the appointments move through the City of Portland, both Multnomah County and Gresham select their own candidates, and the City of Portland sort of supports those jurisdictions' selection.

880
01:32:15.945 --> 01:32:25.914
<v Michael Bonacore>Among the 5 members that the City of Portland appoints, one has to be a member of one of our housing programs.

881
01:32:26.028 --> 01:32:28.886
<v Michael Bonacore>So a voucher participant or a resident of one of our properties.

882
01:32:30.899 --> 01:32:34.926
<v Michael Bonacore>So that's my brief overview.

883
01:32:35.139 --> 01:32:41.280
<v Michael Bonacore>And now, next slide, we'll talk a little bit about The portfolio.

884
01:32:41.524 --> 01:32:51.595
<v Michael Bonacore>So this map shows the distribution of properties across the county representing over 110 apartment communities.

885
01:32:53.082 --> 01:33:01.726
<v Michael Bonacore>These— this presentation was put together pretty quickly for today, but we'll make sure to circulate it for your reference after the meeting.

886
01:33:02.653 --> 01:33:03.189
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

887
01:33:06.572 --> 01:33:12.010
<v Michael Bonacore>So an overview of the portfolio and our property management structure.

888
01:33:12.570 --> 01:33:29.301
<v Michael Bonacore>There are about 2,600 apartments that our in-house Home Forward property management company or department manages, and then about 4,300 are managed by third-party property management companies.

889
01:33:30.135 --> 01:33:36.061
<v Michael Bonacore>We have a team of asset management professionals who oversee the entire housing portfolio.

890
01:33:36.173 --> 01:33:39.261
<v Michael Bonacore>So both our in-house and third-party property management companies.

891
01:33:39.774 --> 01:34:01.528
<v Michael Bonacore>That asset management function involves long-term planning and financial monitoring of the properties, evaluating property management performance, including occupancy levels, leasing, marketing strategies, property conditions, regulatory compliance, and stakeholder communication, and long-term capital and rehabilitation.

892
01:34:03.166 --> 01:34:03.697
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

893
01:34:06.396 --> 01:34:12.890
<v Michael Bonacore>So there's been a lot of emphasis on occupancy in the Home Forward portfolio this winter.

894
01:34:13.774 --> 01:34:21.939
<v Michael Bonacore>It was at a rate that was low enough that there was a lot of press coverage that you all saw.

895
01:34:23.770 --> 01:34:34.212
<v Michael Bonacore>This graph shows the trend line for occupancy since 2018. the beginning of this calendar year, and you can see that it is trending in the right direction.

896
01:34:34.813 --> 01:34:35.510
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide, please.

897
01:34:38.569 --> 01:34:59.349
<v Michael Bonacore>So as, um, uh, Councilor Avalos pointed out in her remarks, we, like other providers, are not seeing, uh, occupancy issues necessarily equally distributed across the portfolio, but A significant concentration of vacancies in the urban core.

898
01:35:00.202 --> 01:35:10.338
<v Michael Bonacore>So you can see here that 8 properties account for 47% of the portfolio vacancies in that urban core area.

899
01:35:11.864 --> 01:35:15.423
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide.

900
01:35:16.460 --> 01:35:28.286
<v Michael Bonacore>So steps that HomeForward is taking to address those occupancy and habitability issues, which can Sort of impact our ability to lease up and overall occupancy.

901
01:35:28.735 --> 01:35:43.863
<v Michael Bonacore>So community safety efforts, which have included, you know, sort of tailoring responses to what particular properties need, but can include security presences, desk monitors, cameras, lighting, and public space management.

902
01:35:46.622 --> 01:36:01.466
<v Michael Bonacore>Categorically addressing revenues and costs by reducing rents where it is feasible, particularly for the urban core properties, at which in most cases we're already charging well below the maximum rents at those properties.

903
01:36:02.606 --> 01:36:16.158
<v Michael Bonacore>Move-in concessions for properties with higher vacancy rates, pursuing debt relief to reduce fixed costs, and exploring additional rent subsidy opportunities, primarily through— Through the tax credit.

904
01:36:16.576 --> 01:36:17.925
<v Michael Bonacore>Our federal funding partners.

905
01:36:19.386 --> 01:36:31.653
<v Michael Bonacore>And then finally, leasing and property management supports include accountability and expectation setting around lease enforcement, community safety, and operational challenges.

906
01:36:32.310 --> 01:36:41.270
<v Michael Bonacore>We've hired leasing agents and engaged targeted marketing campaigns, use of the Housing Connector tool.

907
01:36:43.823 --> 01:36:51.506
<v Michael Bonacore>Which is an initiative that came forward from the mayor's strike team process.

908
01:36:51.715 --> 01:36:55.270
<v Michael Bonacore>And we are now, we have almost all of our apartments on that platform.

909
01:36:56.550 --> 01:37:00.978
<v Michael Bonacore>And then longevity incentives and bonuses to maintain a consistent site presence.

910
01:37:01.091 --> 01:37:09.728
<v Michael Bonacore>And so something we've experienced, and I think probably something you all have heard in conversation with other providers, is that turnover in property management.

911
01:37:10.595 --> 01:37:13.719
<v Michael Bonacore>And overall performance in property management is an issue.

912
01:37:13.832 --> 01:37:24.561
<v Michael Bonacore>So we are— we're having some early success in trying to incentivize staff to stay and sort of establish and then maintain relationships with residents.

913
01:37:25.519 --> 01:37:26.233
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide, please.

914
01:37:28.514 --> 01:37:40.677
<v Michael Bonacore>So as I said, I want to just touch on our rent assistance program, which is largely the Housing Choice Voucher Program, although there are other Rent subsidies that we administer.

915
01:37:41.368 --> 01:38:03.265
<v Michael Bonacore>We understandably have a lot of attention on our physical properties, as we should, but our administration of rent assistance supports a significant number of families and represents a very significant portion of our budget, about $227 million federal and local funding revenue.

916
01:38:04.841 --> 01:38:08.938
<v Michael Bonacore>As compared with about $66 million in our affordable housing portfolio.

917
01:38:08.985 --> 01:38:18.203
<v Michael Bonacore>So our overall subsidy program is diverse physical apartments as well as subsidies that are attached to folks in the community.

918
01:38:18.880 --> 01:38:19.702
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide, please.

919
01:38:22.130 --> 01:38:24.061
<v Michael Bonacore>So a bit of an update on what is happening now.

920
01:38:24.354 --> 01:38:29.487
<v Michael Bonacore>I am now almost at the 2-month mark as interim executive director.

921
01:38:29.747 --> 01:38:30.087
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

922
01:38:30.539 --> 01:38:30.925
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

923
01:38:31.143 --> 01:38:31.561
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you for that.

924
01:38:33.110 --> 01:38:38.302
<v Michael Bonacore>And our new interim CFO is just about 1 month in her role.

925
01:38:40.381 --> 01:38:51.587
<v Michael Bonacore>We have made some initial organizational structural shifts to sort of support our ability to recognize the urgency of the moment that we're in.

926
01:38:53.069 --> 01:38:57.885
<v Michael Bonacore>We are— our fiscal year runs differently than the city, so we have a calendar fiscal year.

927
01:38:57.948 --> 01:39:03.412
<v Michael Bonacore>So we are now entering to our budget development process for FY27.

928
01:39:04.070 --> 01:39:24.881
<v Michael Bonacore>And so there's the immediate need to develop next year's budget in the face of a significant deficit of about $30 million, which means beyond even just this next year, we need a long-term financial stabilization plan, and that work is underway.

929
01:39:27.213 --> 01:39:48.887
<v Michael Bonacore>In the context of that longer-term plan, thinking strategically about our whole portfolio and what sorts of opportunity there is around financial repositioning, potential sales, programming properties differently to better respond to the needs of different populations.

930
01:39:50.832 --> 01:39:56.161
<v Michael Bonacore>You all probably remember that in April, before the prior executive director left, Yes.

931
01:39:56.210 --> 01:39:59.514
<v Michael Bonacore>That Home Forward announced that there would be an organizational assessment.

932
01:40:01.283 --> 01:40:04.240
<v Michael Bonacore>So that RFP is now out on the street.

933
01:40:05.270 --> 01:40:14.320
<v Michael Bonacore>We anticipate having a consultant team selected and up and going by September and the work completed by January.

934
01:40:16.975 --> 01:40:23.037
<v Michael Bonacore>We are in the process of sort of resetting our board calendar and agendas.

935
01:40:23.171 --> 01:40:34.975
<v Michael Bonacore>So that we are responsive to the call for the board to be more visible and engaged and that more robust business is done sort of with public visibility.

936
01:40:36.199 --> 01:40:45.884
<v Michael Bonacore>And then we are in the process of oversight monitoring both by the state, the Oregon Housing and Community Services, and by HUD as well.

937
01:40:47.011 --> 01:40:47.786
<v Michael Bonacore>Next slide, please.

938
01:40:49.015 --> 01:41:04.167
<v Michael Bonacore>So the previous slide of what happened, what's happening now, as I said, recognizes that there is urgency to start the process of stabilizing Home Forward and restoring trust and accountability with our community.

939
01:41:05.162 --> 01:41:12.192
<v Michael Bonacore>That can't wait for the recruitment process of a permanent executive director or for the completion of work by an organizational consultant.

940
01:41:12.239 --> 01:41:23.569
<v Michael Bonacore>So all of those steps that I described and more are being taken to sort of meet this moment and recognize that there is sort of this longer-term planning that needs to happen.

941
01:41:23.634 --> 01:41:33.135
<v Michael Bonacore>So the recruitment of a permanent executive director and a permanent CFO, the completion of the organizational assessment and implementation of those recommendations.

942
01:41:33.247 --> 01:41:48.782
<v Michael Bonacore>And I'll just say the focus of the organizational assessment is around structure, leadership structure, And a particular deep dive into the financial situation of the organization.

943
01:41:49.921 --> 01:41:56.229
<v Michael Bonacore>And as I said, that work is underway now with the new team that is in place.

944
01:41:56.935 --> 01:42:06.452
<v Michael Bonacore>So we will sort of bring the consultant alongside that work and have them again sort of develop, help us develop sort of a longer-term strategy for the overall health of the organization.

945
01:42:06.948 --> 01:42:10.296
<v Michael Bonacore>And then the process of onboarding new commissioners.

946
01:42:10.409 --> 01:42:21.001
<v Michael Bonacore>And we currently have 3 vacant positions, 2 from the City of Portland, one of which is the resident commissioner that I described, and one from the City of Gresham.

947
01:42:21.145 --> 01:42:26.715
<v Michael Bonacore>City of Gresham just, I believe last week, voted to advance their candidate.

948
01:42:26.796 --> 01:42:33.234
<v Michael Bonacore>So that should come to City Council once it's back on the agenda.

949
01:42:34.703 --> 01:42:39.872
<v Michael Bonacore>So with that, I'll stop and let my pals take over.

950
01:42:41.989 --> 01:42:43.363
<v Sameer Kanal>So actually going to pause.

951
01:42:44.350 --> 01:42:46.291
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much, Michael.

952
01:42:46.453 --> 01:42:48.426
<v Sameer Kanal>I failed to take a break.

953
01:42:48.587 --> 01:42:59.309
<v Sameer Kanal>So at the risk of being anticlimactic with the timing here, I am going to put us in a 10-minute break and have us come back with the other presentations and questions.

954
01:42:59.409 --> 01:43:02.247
<v Sameer Kanal>Questions for other presenters as well as yourself, Michael.

955
01:43:02.891 --> 01:43:04.842
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so with that, thank you.

956
01:43:04.922 --> 01:43:08.614
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll come back at 3:48 PM and pick up with the queue from there.

957
01:43:14.409 --> 01:43:14.971
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

958
01:56:49.984 --> 01:56:57.386
<v Michael Bonacore>All right, looks like we have quorum.

959
01:57:01.590 --> 01:57:05.242
<v Sameer Kanal>So we will, um, we take a break.

960
01:57:05.386 --> 01:57:05.981
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh my gosh.

961
01:57:06.127 --> 01:57:14.048
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll pick back up here and, um, we'll pass it over to— I believe City Attorney Adrian Del Coto is next.

962
01:57:15.949 --> 01:57:17.184
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, I'm sorry.

963
01:57:18.177 --> 01:57:18.546
<v Adrian Delgado>Great.

964
01:57:19.444 --> 01:57:21.542
<v Adrian Delgado>Adrian Delgado with the City Attorney's Office.

965
01:57:21.686 --> 01:57:22.969
<v Adrian Delgado>Thank you for having me today.

966
01:57:23.449 --> 01:57:27.921
<v Adrian Delgado>Um, I was asked to come and speak on the city's legal role in relation to Home Forward.

967
01:57:28.658 --> 01:57:35.180
<v Adrian Delgado>I drafted a memo, a legal memo, and emailed it to all of your inboxes today, um, this afternoon.

968
01:57:35.243 --> 01:57:36.398
<v Adrian Delgado>Hopefully you've got it.

969
01:57:36.445 --> 01:57:47.556
<v Adrian Delgado>I'm not sure if you had time to read it, so I thought I would just kind of go through speaking, um, and highlight a few of the main points that I think, um, are worth noting.

970
01:57:48.935 --> 01:57:52.961
<v Adrian Delgado>And then if you have questions, I'm happy to answer them, um, during the Q&A.

971
01:57:54.180 --> 01:58:02.918
<v Adrian Delgado>So the housing authority— housing authorities are created statutorily, and they're independent public bodies, um, pursuant to state law.

972
01:58:03.944 --> 01:58:08.418
<v Adrian Delgado>The city maintains some limited oversight Over the housing authority.

973
01:58:09.324 --> 01:58:23.608
<v Adrian Delgado>And that first oversight authority is, as Michael mentioned in his presentation, the city must adopt a resolution to activate the housing authority.

974
01:58:24.185 --> 01:58:30.470
<v Adrian Delgado>And it can choose in that resolution to form the commission structure, or council can act as the housing authority.

975
01:58:31.051 --> 01:58:33.202
<v Adrian Delgado>And as Michael mentioned in night Thank you.

976
01:58:33.574 --> 01:58:41.091
<v Adrian Delgado>So in 1941, the City Council adopted a resolution activating the housing authority and establishing Home Forward.

977
01:58:43.109 --> 01:58:52.715
<v Adrian Delgado>The City Council, after activation— let me just go back— after activation, the housing authority has the full authority statutorily to act as a housing authority.

978
01:58:52.828 --> 01:59:05.771
<v Adrian Delgado>So state law outlines all the things a housing authority can do, and once City Council adopts the resolution and activates the housing authority, um, Home Forward in this case can act on all of that statutory authority.

979
01:59:06.927 --> 01:59:12.708
<v Adrian Delgado>The City Council's primary role is to appoint Home Forward's commissioners pursuant to state law.

980
01:59:13.576 --> 01:59:24.077
<v Adrian Delgado>Um, Michael outlined that structure with the nominations, um, and that's pursuant to an IGA between Multnomah County and the City of Gresham and the City of Portland.

981
01:59:25.315 --> 01:59:30.775
<v Adrian Delgado>The mayor maintains some authority as well, and that's the removal authority for commissioners.

982
01:59:31.372 --> 01:59:37.627
<v Adrian Delgado>They can be removed by the mayor for inefficiency or neglect of duty or misconduct in office.

983
01:59:39.300 --> 01:59:42.300
<v Adrian Delgado>Removal requires notice and an opportunity to be heard.

984
01:59:44.368 --> 01:59:50.774
<v Adrian Delgado>And next, council may at any time pass a resolution to transfer back the powers of the authority.

985
01:59:51.368 --> 01:59:52.935
<v Adrian Delgado>And to act as the housing authority.

986
01:59:52.998 --> 01:59:59.505
<v Adrian Delgado>So that would just be switching to that other form of housing authority structure that's statutory.

987
02:00:00.542 --> 02:00:05.644
<v Adrian Delgado>And upon that transfer, council could also vote to dissolve the housing authority.

988
02:00:05.822 --> 02:00:09.498
<v Adrian Delgado>So once it's acting as the housing authority, it could also dissolve the housing authority.

989
02:00:11.228 --> 02:00:20.904
<v Adrian Delgado>One other point to note is that HomeForward provides an audit to The City Council once a year, and that is also a statutory requirement.

990
02:00:23.176 --> 02:00:27.353
<v Adrian Delgado>And I'm happy— I'm not sure if we're doing questions now or reserving for the Q&A time.

991
02:00:29.409 --> 02:00:30.251
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, thank you so much.

992
02:00:30.445 --> 02:00:36.238
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we're trying to ensure we have everyone get a chance to present first, which I know is, is a little challenging.

993
02:00:37.159 --> 02:00:42.073
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, pass it over to our Portland Housing Bureau next.

994
02:00:48.104 --> 02:00:51.106
<v Queesha Light>All right, good afternoon, Chair Kanal and council members.

995
02:00:51.186 --> 02:00:52.006
<v Queesha Light>I'm Queesha Light.

996
02:00:52.054 --> 02:01:01.768
<v Queesha Light>I'm the interim director of the Portland Housing Bureau, and I'm here to provide a high-level overview of how funding flows between the Portland Housing Bureau and Home Forward.

997
02:01:02.345 --> 02:01:16.306
<v Queesha Light>So today I'll briefly explain the distinct roles of our 2 organizations, where our funding and responsibilities intersect, And the key point is that the relationship is not simply a one-way transfer of funding.

998
02:01:16.822 --> 02:01:29.074
<v Queesha Light>PHB provides capital funding and long-term regulatory oversight, while Home Forward owns and operates housing and brings critical rental assistance resources into both its own properties and the broader PHB-funded portfolio.

999
02:01:29.702 --> 02:01:30.311
<v Queesha Light>Next slide.

1000
02:01:32.288 --> 02:01:36.259
<v Queesha Light>So PHB's primary role is to assemble and invest public funding in the production of affordable housing.

1001
02:01:37.909 --> 02:01:46.315
<v Queesha Light>Our funding comes from several sources, including HUD, local tax increment finance, or TIF, and Portland Metro and housing bond funds.

1002
02:01:47.069 --> 02:01:55.060
<v Queesha Light>Then we award funding typically through competitive solicitations to nonprofit affordable housing owners and developers.

1003
02:01:55.877 --> 02:02:16.801
<v Queesha Light>And to date, PHB has invested approximately $470 million in Portland from the Portland and Metro Home Forward is just one of the organizations eligible to receive those investments, and PHB generally provides this funding as project-level loans that help finance acquisition, construction, rehabilitation, or preservation.

1004
02:02:17.962 --> 02:02:26.984
<v Queesha Light>Once we invest in a property, PHB places long-term affordability requirements on the housing and provides ongoing regulatory and portfolio oversight.

1005
02:02:27.194 --> 02:02:28.497
<v Queesha Light>So in other words, we're not just writing checks.

1006
02:02:28.595 --> 02:02:28.675
<v Queesha Light>Yes.

1007
02:02:29.021 --> 02:02:36.020
<v Queesha Light>The funding helps make the housing financially possible, and our agreements help ensure it remains affordable for the long term.

1008
02:02:36.726 --> 02:02:39.087
<v Queesha Light>Home Forward plays a different but complementary role.

1009
02:02:39.439 --> 02:02:45.283
<v Queesha Light>As the public housing authority for Multnomah County, Home Forward owns, develops, and operates affordable rental housing.

1010
02:02:45.893 --> 02:02:52.747
<v Queesha Light>It's responsible for the day-to-day financial and physical operation of the properties it owns, including properties that have received PHA funding.

1011
02:02:53.742 --> 02:03:01.237
<v Queesha Light>Home Forward also administers rental assistance primarily funded by HUD and Multnomah County, and I'll discuss this in an upcoming slide.

1012
02:03:01.417 --> 02:03:02.132
<v Queesha Light>Next slide, please.

1013
02:03:04.600 --> 02:03:10.152
<v Queesha Light>So PHB has provided loans to HomeForward to create and preserve permanently affordable housing.

1014
02:03:10.908 --> 02:03:20.145
<v Queesha Light>As of 2025, HomeForward owned and operated more than 3,000 of the 19,000+ units regulated by PHB, which is about 17% of our portfolio.

1015
02:03:21.252 --> 02:03:29.621
<v Queesha Light>More than 750 of those units serve households at 30% of AMI or below, which are the most rent burdened and hardest to house.

1016
02:03:30.376 --> 02:03:36.319
<v Queesha Light>This is also the largest number of deeply affordable units operated by any owner in our portfolio.

1017
02:03:37.282 --> 02:03:44.413
<v Queesha Light>Home Forward also has 5 projects that are in pre-development, construction, and conversion, which are funded by Metro bonds and TIF.

1018
02:03:45.136 --> 02:03:49.954
<v Queesha Light>Now, and those 5 projects were initially awarded funds between 2021 and 2023.

1019
02:03:51.239 --> 02:03:51.787
<v Queesha Light>Next slide.

1020
02:03:55.038 --> 02:03:58.500
<v Queesha Light>The funding also flows in the other direction through rental assistance.

1021
02:03:58.644 --> 02:04:09.967
<v Queesha Light>Over the past 10 years, Home Forward has made more than 1,300 project-based vouchers available for PHB to allocate through our funding solicitations to Home Forward and other affordable housing owners.

1022
02:04:10.876 --> 02:04:34.815
<v Queesha Light>Altogether, nearly 2,800 households living in PHB-regulated properties These vouchers are an important tool in stabilizing very low-income residents because residents are only paying 30% of their actual income, which allows an owner to then leverage the vouchers to carry more debt, thereby decreasing public funding needed.

1023
02:04:35.890 --> 02:04:39.872
<v Queesha Light>PSHB also has an IGA with Home Forward for asset management services.

1024
02:04:40.305 --> 02:04:41.606
<v Queesha Light>Through that IGA, Home Forward administers the vouchers.

1025
02:04:41.654 --> 02:04:41.832
<v Queesha Light>Thank you.

1026
02:04:41.800 --> 02:04:46.500
<v Queesha Light>Asset manages just over 400 units at 3 sites along with a vacant lot right now.

1027
02:04:48.220 --> 02:04:53.533
<v Queesha Light>For fiscal year '26-'27, we approximate this IGA to be around $217,000.

1028
02:04:55.271 --> 02:05:01.079
<v Queesha Light>And like other nonprofit affordable housing providers, Home Forward may also apply for other grants that we offer.

1029
02:05:01.579 --> 02:05:07.118
<v Queesha Light>For instance, Home Forward received a safety and security grant in fiscal year '25-'26 for the Selwood Center.

1030
02:05:07.762 --> 02:05:08.373
<v Queesha Light>Next slide.

1031
02:05:10.559 --> 02:05:11.747
<v Queesha Light>I just want to close with this.

1032
02:05:11.796 --> 02:05:25.717
<v Queesha Light>It's something that Chair Avalos— I mean, that Councilor Avalos started with as she gave her report, because we want to ensure council understands the fund— that these funding relationships really matter a lot right now.

1033
02:05:27.152 --> 02:05:34.850
<v Queesha Light>Affordable housing providers are facing significant challenges, and, and those operating pressures are not increasing.

1034
02:05:35.911 --> 02:05:42.720
<v Queesha Light>The rents that extremely low-income households can afford are often not enough to cover the full cost of operating and maintaining housing.

1035
02:05:43.877 --> 02:05:55.699
<v Queesha Light>At the same time, insurance, utilities, labor, security, maintenance, and other operating expenses have increased far faster than the assumptions used when many of these properties were originally financed.

1036
02:05:56.728 --> 02:06:09.511
<v Queesha Light>Providers are also experiencing vacancies, unpaid rent, behavioral health and community safety challenges, property management capacity constraints, significant capital repair needs, and in some cases senior loans that are reaching maturity.

1037
02:06:10.538 --> 02:06:22.760
<v Queesha Light>These pressures affect Home Forward and other housing providers across the entire PHB portfolio, and that's why the combination of capital funding, rental assistance, and sound property operations is so critical.

1038
02:06:23.466 --> 02:06:33.051
<v Queesha Light>And our goal is not simply to finance buildings, it's to keep those buildings financially stable, physically sound, and able to keep residents in Portland stably housed over the long term.

1039
02:06:34.529 --> 02:06:43.641
<v Queesha Light>These same challenges are also connected to the work underway through the Mayor's Housing Strike Team, which you will hear about in a moment, and we can talk about that some more.

1040
02:06:43.965 --> 02:06:46.676
<v Queesha Light>Otherwise, that is the end of my presentation.

1041
02:06:46.788 --> 02:06:47.176
<v Queesha Light>Thank you.

1042
02:06:49.354 --> 02:06:53.231
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Director Light, and I believe this is your first time with us at this Committee.

1043
02:06:53.279 --> 02:06:54.537
<v Sameer Kanal>So thank you so much for being here.

1044
02:06:54.860 --> 02:06:55.264
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1045
02:06:56.233 --> 02:06:59.524
<v Sameer Kanal>Last but not least, we'll go to Director Brocker-Knapp of Portland Solutions.

1046
02:07:00.202 --> 02:07:00.395
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>All right.

1047
02:07:00.507 --> 02:07:01.427
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

1048
02:07:01.637 --> 02:07:05.198
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>And I apologize, I'm running my own slides, so I'm going to be a little all over the place.

1049
02:07:05.761 --> 02:07:16.045
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Director Skyler Brocker-Knapp of Portland Solutions, and I'll be presenting with Director Light just on the housing strike team that the mayor set up, what it is, who participates, and what it's aiming to achieve.

1050
02:07:16.479 --> 02:07:17.689
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>We'll run through these pretty quickly.

1051
02:07:19.210 --> 02:07:26.117
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>So the housing strike team is an incident command emergency management style meeting that began in early 2025 with a shelter group.

1052
02:07:26.518 --> 02:07:30.427
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>We provided, um, a graphic here just to help you understand the different components.

1053
02:07:30.908 --> 02:07:37.943
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Um, it later expanded to include an affordable housing group, which has 2 components: the Tenant Safety Team and the Vacancy Reduction Team.

1054
02:07:38.680 --> 02:07:43.070
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Um, the overriding goal of these groups is to ensure that the homeless can find appropriate housing.

1055
02:07:43.182 --> 02:07:53.452
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>So we do this by maintaining a stable and effective shelter system, uh, fostering stability and safety at affordable housing communities and working through the challenges of filling the available rooms and maintaining residency.

1056
02:07:53.548 --> 02:07:56.849
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>You've heard some of those examples already stated here today in presentations.

1057
02:08:01.039 --> 02:08:06.215
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>The mayor formed the Shelter Strike Team shortly after assuming office in January of 2025.

1058
02:08:06.311 --> 02:08:13.855
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>The Shelter Strike Team is spearheaded by Portland Solutions, but attendees include personnel from other bureaus and jurisdictions like PBOT and others.

1059
02:08:14.561 --> 02:08:17.846
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>We used principles of the incident command system to organize the shelter group.

1060
02:08:18.311 --> 02:08:22.814
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Our first objective was to build 1,500 overnight shelter beds, which you all know about.

1061
02:08:23.135 --> 02:08:31.034
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>The shelter group continues as a weekly touchpoint for priority projects with the mayor and his team, many that require careful coordination with other partners.

1062
02:08:31.082 --> 02:08:40.488
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>So examples of projects include changes to the shelter system, campsite cleanup efforts, the reunification program, and managing the impact of derelict vessels and vehicles.

1063
02:08:41.194 --> 02:08:42.082
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>On the City of Portland.

1064
02:08:42.810 --> 02:08:46.658
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Like the entire strike team, we are data-driven and track metrics on a weekly or monthly basis.

1065
02:08:47.170 --> 02:08:50.780
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>A few examples of such metrics are in the graphic that you see on the screen.

1066
02:08:54.261 --> 02:08:58.359
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>The tenant safety meeting grew out of existing work by Portland Solutions PMO office.

1067
02:08:59.423 --> 02:09:05.110
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>We conducted outreach with affordable housing building managers, asked how we could help and what we could do to support them.

1068
02:09:05.550 --> 02:09:13.640
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Folks showed up in problem solver meetings and reached out to the city for support, so we developed relationships with those individuals and their management structures.

1069
02:09:14.395 --> 02:09:19.743
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>This group is currently spearheaded by Portland Solutions and meets on a biweekly basis and focuses on key properties.

1070
02:09:20.240 --> 02:09:22.393
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>You can see the map of these properties on the slide.

1071
02:09:22.681 --> 02:09:24.304
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>It's not a bad list to be on.

1072
02:09:24.431 --> 02:09:26.841
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>We see it as properties we want to support.

1073
02:09:26.921 --> 02:09:32.622
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Many of these operators and owners actually asked to be on this list to really get some resources and help from the City of Portland.

1074
02:09:33.344 --> 02:09:37.904
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>We track public safety metrics on a monthly basis and plan action items around how we can help.

1075
02:09:38.658 --> 02:09:42.024
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>So it's a pretty active table with a lot of internal personnel.

1076
02:09:42.104 --> 02:09:44.939
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>So that includes fire, police, PHB, and others.

1077
02:09:45.934 --> 02:09:53.673
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Of note, we hosted a listening session with property managers to learn more about their successes and challenges and use these insights to drive our efforts forward.

1078
02:09:54.283 --> 02:09:56.510
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>I'll now pass it over to Director Light.

1079
02:09:57.872 --> 02:09:58.128
<v Queesha Light>All right.

1080
02:09:58.193 --> 02:10:02.840
<v Queesha Light>So the 3rd meeting within the mayor's housing strike team is the vacancy reduction team.

1081
02:10:03.962 --> 02:10:07.559
<v Queesha Light>This group is spearheaded by PHB, and we meet biweekly.

1082
02:10:08.762 --> 02:10:16.149
<v Queesha Light>Through this team, we're tracking vacancies across PHB-regulated properties and moving specific actions forward as they come up.

1083
02:10:16.743 --> 02:10:22.538
<v Queesha Light>Our goal is to reduce the vacancy rate across the portfolio to 5.4% by the end of the year.

1084
02:10:23.792 --> 02:10:29.314
<v Queesha Light>The chart on the slide is updated biweekly to help us track this goal and identify where additional attention may be needed.

1085
02:10:30.533 --> 02:10:43.201
<v Queesha Light>This group brings together housing providers, city staff, other city partners, county partners, anyone who can help us drive towards our objective and address the barriers that keep vacant units from being leased.

1086
02:10:43.922 --> 02:10:53.751
<v Queesha Light>The group also serves as a community of practice table where providers can share what is working, learn from one another, and help us identify practices that may be replicated across the portfolio.

1087
02:10:54.970 --> 02:11:30.082
<v Queesha Light>And one of the specific things that we will be doing next week actually, is getting with providers, property managers, and doing a process mapping around the lease-up process so that we can really dig in and understand it better, understand where the challenges are, where there's an opportunity for the city to intervene and perhaps offer some assistance and resources, but also just to understand, as I'll go with what Lorraine said, some better practices that we can but so the process mapping session is something that will be taking place next week.

1088
02:11:31.270 --> 02:11:32.418
<v Queesha Light>And I think that's it for us.

1089
02:11:33.082 --> 02:11:33.454
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>Thank you.

1090
02:11:35.752 --> 02:11:37.259
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to all of our presenters.

1091
02:11:37.858 --> 02:11:39.734
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate all of you making the time.

1092
02:11:40.909 --> 02:11:48.090
<v Sameer Kanal>We do have, I believe, one person, maybe more now, Rebecca, if you could confirm, signed up in the public hearing portion.

1093
02:11:50.862 --> 02:11:51.215
<v Rebecca Dobert>We do.

1094
02:11:51.585 --> 02:11:52.659
<v Rebecca Dobert>We have one person.

1095
02:11:52.708 --> 02:11:57.670
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm just refreshing to make sure, but we had one person signed up and we remain at one.

1096
02:11:58.761 --> 02:12:00.993
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so we'll do that then, and then we'll get to the queue.

1097
02:12:01.073 --> 02:12:04.092
<v Sameer Kanal>I see everyone in the queue and I appreciate your patience, colleagues.

1098
02:12:04.204 --> 02:12:07.480
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll just do one more and, uh, then we'll get to you.

1099
02:12:08.139 --> 02:12:10.386
<v Sameer Kanal>So if you could please call public testimony, Rebecca.

1100
02:12:11.832 --> 02:12:12.570
<v Rebecca Dobert>David Straub.

1101
02:12:18.878 --> 02:12:19.863
<v David Straub>Good afternoon, councilors.

1102
02:12:19.927 --> 02:12:20.780
<v David Straub>My name is David Straub.

1103
02:12:22.670 --> 02:12:34.838
<v David Straub>I think we have an opportunity here to stop looking at disparate silos, which kind of seems to be part of the problem, and start to consider the fact that we need a pipeline of which Home Forward is part of that, as well as the shelter services.

1104
02:12:36.327 --> 02:12:40.734
<v David Straub>Rather than building houses and building affordable housing, I think we should start building people.

1105
02:12:42.226 --> 02:12:50.783
<v David Straub>Merely putting people in shelters or affordable housing is not necessarily gonna help them if they don't have the skills that they need to move beyond that.

1106
02:12:52.016 --> 02:12:56.948
<v David Straub>And they may not even know what those skills are, what they need, and we need to provide that guidance.

1107
02:12:58.073 --> 02:13:01.431
<v David Straub>And that's why, I mean, I've been here a couple times talking about behavioral wellness.

1108
02:13:02.029 --> 02:13:05.895
<v David Straub>To me, that's kind of the key, the missing aspect of all of this.

1109
02:13:07.284 --> 02:13:10.386
<v David Straub>Even things such as people who are missing rent and Home Forward.

1110
02:13:10.434 --> 02:13:10.515
<v David Straub>Yeah.

1111
02:13:11.128 --> 02:13:12.988
<v David Straub>Is this person having problem making work?

1112
02:13:13.356 --> 02:13:14.703
<v David Straub>Do they have a problem showing up?

1113
02:13:15.265 --> 02:13:16.899
<v David Straub>Are they getting fired because of whatever?

1114
02:13:17.429 --> 02:13:19.480
<v David Straub>I mean, there's all kinds of, you know, little things that are happening.

1115
02:13:19.545 --> 02:13:26.037
<v David Straub>Or maybe they're, you know, a single mom and they're not able to find, you know, babysitting services so they can get to their job.

1116
02:13:26.966 --> 02:13:36.088
<v David Straub>And what happens is that when we start building people, rather than looking at, well, how many, you know, rent assistance checks do we cut and how many housing units do we— are we offering?

1117
02:13:36.923 --> 02:13:42.000
<v David Straub>Instead, we start to look at what kind of services are we offering these people so we can help them move forward.

1118
02:13:43.091 --> 02:13:45.323
<v David Straub>Are we helping them get extra education?

1119
02:13:45.998 --> 02:13:48.198
<v David Straub>Are we helping ensure that they get to work each day?

1120
02:13:48.873 --> 02:13:51.186
<v David Straub>Are we ensuring that they're eating right and eating well?

1121
02:13:52.488 --> 02:13:53.644
<v David Straub>Are they getting a good night's sleep?

1122
02:13:54.126 --> 02:13:56.551
<v David Straub>Do they know what to do to do that?

1123
02:13:57.627 --> 02:13:58.944
<v David Straub>I rent a house.

1124
02:13:59.009 --> 02:14:04.599
<v David Straub>I rent 4 rooms upstairs, and more or less indirectly, I'm doing behavioral wellness for all 4 of those people.

1125
02:14:04.646 --> 02:14:04.759
<v David Straub>Thank you.

1126
02:14:05.529 --> 02:14:11.390
<v David Straub>I charge about $700 a month, so it's under what the pilot program is talking about.

1127
02:14:11.960 --> 02:14:15.260
<v David Straub>And a lot of my conversations with them are like, why are you smoking?

1128
02:14:15.579 --> 02:14:17.329
<v David Straub>That's a tax that you're paying each month.

1129
02:14:17.760 --> 02:14:19.859
<v David Straub>Why are you filling yourself up on energy drinks?

1130
02:14:19.859 --> 02:14:20.859
<v David Straub>Well, I'm not getting enough sleep.

1131
02:14:21.020 --> 02:14:22.340
<v David Straub>Why are you not getting enough sleep?

1132
02:14:22.460 --> 02:14:27.079
<v David Straub>Well, I'm sitting in my room all day, you know, building models because I'm getting, you know, SSI.

1133
02:14:27.079 --> 02:14:28.539
<v David Straub>Well, that's not good.

1134
02:14:28.560 --> 02:14:35.251
<v David Straub>And at the very least, it's kind of difficult because I'm the landlord and I'm not there like assigned person, which is something you can do with Home Forward.

1135
02:14:35.961 --> 02:14:47.819
<v David Straub>Meaning when someone's going, you know, at Home Forward, you can say, hey, look, as part of your, you know, getting rent assistance and getting affordable housing, take 2 hours a week of some type of educational class.

1136
02:14:48.095 --> 02:14:58.738
<v David Straub>We'll give you a whole array of offerings, you know, how to, you know, how to not hoard, how to eat better, how to, um, yeah, how to maintain your job, how to get along with difficult co-workers.

1137
02:14:59.586 --> 02:15:01.095
<v David Straub>How to better parent, whatever it is.

1138
02:15:01.351 --> 02:15:09.027
<v David Straub>Just other things that they could help them stay in affordable housing and more preferably so they can move beyond it.

1139
02:15:09.702 --> 02:15:19.752
<v David Straub>And that's one thing I really think that we need to look at is not just the metrics of how many people we house, but how many people move out of housing into market rate housing because they can afford more.

1140
02:15:20.636 --> 02:15:21.229
<v David Straub>Thank you for your time.

1141
02:15:21.551 --> 02:15:22.931
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

1142
02:15:26.382 --> 02:15:27.555
<v Rebecca Dobert>That concludes testimony.

1143
02:15:28.488 --> 02:15:30.095
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, thank you, colleagues.

1144
02:15:30.144 --> 02:15:32.185
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll open up questions as well as discussion.

1145
02:15:32.313 --> 02:15:34.707
<v Sameer Kanal>We have Councilor Zimmerman followed by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1146
02:15:40.425 --> 02:15:43.604
<v Eric Zimmerman>Chair, I'm going to help you out, and I think you need to recognize Councilor Smith.

1147
02:15:43.685 --> 02:15:44.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>She was in the queue.

1148
02:15:46.060 --> 02:15:47.292
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, appreciate it.

1149
02:15:47.372 --> 02:15:49.612
<v Sameer Kanal>I thought I saw her in the queue, but seems to have disappeared.

1150
02:15:49.725 --> 02:15:50.033
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, there it is.

1151
02:15:50.229 --> 02:15:50.310
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1152
02:15:51.242 --> 02:15:54.015
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, we'll go to Councilor Smith, then Councilor Zimmerman-Pirtle-Guiney.

1153
02:15:55.949 --> 02:15:56.322
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1154
02:15:57.279 --> 02:15:58.186
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr.

1155
02:15:58.234 --> 02:15:58.430
<v Loretta Smith>Chair.

1156
02:15:58.802 --> 02:16:02.676
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Director Light and Director Bonacar, could you come up please?

1157
02:16:09.210 --> 02:16:10.853
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to get some clarity.

1158
02:16:10.917 --> 02:16:11.502
<v Loretta Smith>How are you?

1159
02:16:12.121 --> 02:16:14.055
<v Loretta Smith>It's good to see you in this, in this new role.

1160
02:16:14.317 --> 02:16:14.951
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Councilor.

1161
02:16:15.000 --> 02:16:16.007
<v Michael Bonacore>Seems like déjà vu.

1162
02:16:16.725 --> 02:16:17.259
<v Loretta Smith>It does.

1163
02:16:19.777 --> 02:16:31.224
<v Loretta Smith>So can you clear up for me, the folks at the housing— how I was going to say Housing Authority of Portland, but it is Home Forward.

1164
02:16:31.724 --> 02:16:33.888
<v Loretta Smith>Are they city employees or federal employees?

1165
02:16:36.277 --> 02:16:38.298
<v Michael Bonacore>They are neither.

1166
02:16:38.765 --> 02:16:41.578
<v Michael Bonacore>They're purely employees of Home Forward.

1167
02:16:41.676 --> 02:16:42.791
<v Loretta Smith>Are they on PERS or FERS?

1168
02:16:42.888 --> 02:16:43.439
<v Loretta Smith>They are on PERS.

1169
02:16:43.945 --> 02:16:45.792
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, that's what I, that's what I needed to find out.

1170
02:16:45.841 --> 02:16:46.066
<v Loretta Smith>Gotcha.

1171
02:16:46.450 --> 02:16:50.947
<v Loretta Smith>But basically they follow the, the HUD rules, correct?

1172
02:16:51.588 --> 02:16:51.781
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1173
02:16:52.697 --> 02:17:01.673
<v Loretta Smith>And when the young lady talked about 1941, Home Forward was established, that wasn't Home Forward, that was the Housing Authority of Portland.

1174
02:17:01.769 --> 02:17:02.121
<v Loretta Smith>Correct.

1175
02:17:02.331 --> 02:17:03.680
<v Loretta Smith>Was established at that time.

1176
02:17:04.498 --> 02:17:19.925
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I wanted to find out which Home Forward properties are located in District 1 and which have the highest vacancy, safety, or deferred maintenance concerns?

1177
02:17:21.992 --> 02:17:25.770
<v Michael Bonacore>Well, we can certainly provide you all—.

1178
02:17:26.045 --> 02:17:26.790
<v Michael Bonacore>And I'll send you a—.

1179
02:17:26.840 --> 02:17:27.763
<v Loretta Smith>By district.

1180
02:17:28.153 --> 02:17:28.477
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1181
02:17:28.719 --> 02:17:29.045
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, yeah.

1182
02:17:31.335 --> 02:17:44.324
<v Loretta Smith>And what I wanted to also find from Director Light Of the partnerships that we have with Home Forward, what is the target vacancy rate that you are striving for?

1183
02:17:45.661 --> 02:17:50.347
<v Queesha Light>Well, the vacancy rate that we're striving for is overall across the entire portfolio.

1184
02:17:50.509 --> 02:17:53.109
<v Queesha Light>So it's 5.4% across the entire portfolio.

1185
02:17:53.352 --> 02:17:57.295
<v Queesha Light>So it's not just for Home Forward, although I will say it has been coming down.

1186
02:17:59.899 --> 02:18:08.195
<v Loretta Smith>Is that because we're dealing with some We're cleaning up some deferred maintenance and they're able to, um, to be rented out.

1187
02:18:09.284 --> 02:18:10.503
<v Michael Bonacore>That's, that's one aspect.

1188
02:18:10.583 --> 02:18:13.548
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, I would say there are multiple components to it.

1189
02:18:14.029 --> 02:18:28.097
<v Loretta Smith>And so the, the tenant safety team that tracks the, the 911 incidents per occupied unit, how is that data adjusted for the property size, the incident severity, and the duplicate calls?

1190
02:18:28.858 --> 02:18:31.750
<v Loretta Smith>Do you have to desegregate that data?

1191
02:18:34.838 --> 02:18:51.593
<v Queesha Light>I do know from the meetings that— I don't know if they're desegregating the data or all those things, but I can tell you just from the conversations, we do have the conversations around, you know, making sure when we're seeing the numbers really high, going back and understanding what is the nature of those calls.

1192
02:18:51.658 --> 02:19:01.466
<v Queesha Light>Like sometimes we get— you get one person that's making 80% of the calls or something in a complex because there are other behavioral health issues going on.

1193
02:19:01.577 --> 02:19:07.161
<v Queesha Light>So I do know that they try to go in and Hank and team try to go in and clean up those things.

1194
02:19:07.337 --> 02:19:07.433
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah.

1195
02:19:07.658 --> 02:19:07.851
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1196
02:19:08.460 --> 02:19:08.653
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1197
02:19:08.781 --> 02:19:12.343
<v Loretta Smith>I was trying to figure out what that looks like.

1198
02:19:12.567 --> 02:19:15.119
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>They do segregate it, Councilor, by call type.

1199
02:19:15.215 --> 02:19:18.440
<v Skylar Brocker-Knapp>And yep, it's pretty— we can get you kind of that breakdown if you're interested.

1200
02:19:18.487 --> 02:19:18.936
<v Loretta Smith>You could do that.

1201
02:19:18.985 --> 02:19:20.444
<v Loretta Smith>And I'll send all of you these questions.

1202
02:19:20.493 --> 02:19:23.159
<v Loretta Smith>I have one last question, um, Director Bonicart.

1203
02:19:23.865 --> 02:19:29.888
<v Loretta Smith>Um, what is Home Forward's current unrestricted operating deficit?

1204
02:19:30.772 --> 02:19:40.425
<v Loretta Smith>I saw 2 numbers in the paper, uh, today or yesterday, separate from the federal voucher payments and the restricted development funds.

1205
02:19:40.489 --> 02:19:44.072
<v Loretta Smith>What are the unrestricted operating deficit that you have?

1206
02:19:44.120 --> 02:19:46.239
<v Loretta Smith>Is it the $30 million, the $13 million?

1207
02:19:46.288 --> 02:19:48.856
<v Michael Bonacore>What, what is that this is the $30 million.

1208
02:19:49.259 --> 02:19:50.191
<v Loretta Smith>It is the $30 million?

1209
02:19:50.287 --> 02:19:50.704
<v Loretta Smith>That's right.

1210
02:19:50.784 --> 02:19:54.078
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you.

1211
02:19:56.246 --> 02:19:57.180
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1212
02:19:57.358 --> 02:19:57.648
<v Clark>Thank you.

1213
02:19:57.940 --> 02:19:58.845
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1214
02:19:58.926 --> 02:20:00.463
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Zimmerman, followed by Pirtle-Guiney.

1215
02:20:02.088 --> 02:20:04.454
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, I appreciate, Michael, you being here.

1216
02:20:04.993 --> 02:20:14.822
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I know that this presentation was framed, colleagues, with some other aspects in the strike teams and whatnot in the system overall.

1217
02:20:14.950 --> 02:20:19.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I think what brought us here was 6 months of really bad numbers and outcomes at Home Forward.

1218
02:20:19.688 --> 02:20:25.262
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I don't want to lose the thread, and I'm not willing to engage in Portland polite to lose that thread.

1219
02:20:25.325 --> 02:20:45.022
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I want to make sure that we keep in mind here that what got us to a position of everybody knowing the name Home Forward and what it does, or in this case what it wasn't doing, was hundreds, if not 1,000 vacant units That was what was reported, and I never saw Home Forward dispute that.

1220
02:20:45.280 --> 02:20:46.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's what I'm working from.

1221
02:20:49.549 --> 02:20:52.697
<v Eric Zimmerman>I find that incredibly challenging.

1222
02:20:55.407 --> 02:21:13.113
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think every Portlander should, because we heard some information today about marketing teams, about leasing agents, but then the next presenter the city has a strike team, which is about placements, and these things don't look very congruent to me.

1223
02:21:13.996 --> 02:21:23.575
<v Eric Zimmerman>That marketing of a unit, if you're having struggles to get people in, I get that, but then we shouldn't have to have a strike team to figure out how to squeeze people into units.

1224
02:21:23.622 --> 02:21:28.210
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's kind of how I think of the strike team, was about a crisis of not being able to get into units.

1225
02:21:28.340 --> 02:21:32.666
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so these things are out of touch with each other a bit in my mind.

1226
02:21:33.505 --> 02:21:45.498
<v Eric Zimmerman>In some of the conversations I've had, I've learned about the role of investors in these affordable developed units.

1227
02:21:46.387 --> 02:22:03.786
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I guess I really would like to get more to some of the brass tacks about what kept the units vacant that long, why wasn't HomeForward aggressively lowering rents to get renters in?

1228
02:22:05.176 --> 02:22:12.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then what has changed in the last 2 months, if anything has, to fix that wrong?

1229
02:22:12.854 --> 02:22:25.986
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say that— I want to say the reason I ask it this way is other landlords are reducing prices As the market changes to make sure they have some vacancy.

1230
02:22:26.066 --> 02:22:33.403
<v Eric Zimmerman>'Cause if your mortgage is $1,000 and you can only get $900 in rent, that's better than feeding the mortgage an extra $1,000.

1231
02:22:33.691 --> 02:22:35.956
<v Eric Zimmerman>You take the $900 and you're like, you're out the $100.

1232
02:22:36.662 --> 02:22:40.403
<v Eric Zimmerman>That wasn't happening here as best I can tell, Mr. Bonaccor.

1233
02:22:40.450 --> 02:22:57.316
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'd like to understand that a little bit because from a public entity perspective, I guess if HomeForward were to come to me as a city councilor and say we are at 100% Occupied, but we are losing money because— but everything's occupied.

1234
02:22:57.924 --> 02:23:04.126
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's a much different conversation for me as a public funding agency, as a public official, about what is the good here.

1235
02:23:04.190 --> 02:23:07.426
<v Eric Zimmerman>Do I do a— you know, are things like bailouts the words we would use?

1236
02:23:07.475 --> 02:23:16.545
<v Eric Zimmerman>And sometimes bailout's not a terrible word here, but to not have that vacancy down to less than 4% and to have money issues is concerning.

1237
02:23:16.610 --> 02:23:28.742
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I want to just kind start there and get a sense for like what the hell was going on and what is changing so that we can have a credible conversation going forward?

1238
02:23:29.699 --> 02:23:29.909
<v Michael Bonacore>Sure.

1239
02:23:30.120 --> 02:23:31.677
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, thank you for the question, Councilor.

1240
02:23:32.472 --> 02:23:39.560
<v Michael Bonacore>I would say, as with many issues, this is multifaceted.

1241
02:23:39.610 --> 02:23:44.722
<v Michael Bonacore>So if I— I'll just sort of slice it into some parts and you tell me if I'm not hitting the mark.

1242
02:23:45.897 --> 02:24:09.007
<v Michael Bonacore>If you think back to the slide in which we sort of highlighted there being 8 downtown properties that sort of skewed, you know, the occupancy numbers, that helps tell, you know, help paint a picture that vacancy issues are not sort of uniform across the portfolio.

1243
02:24:09.153 --> 02:24:17.084
<v Michael Bonacore>And even some of what you all have heard around the issue of 60% rents being so close to market that it's hard to get folks into those.

1244
02:24:18.083 --> 02:24:27.744
<v Michael Bonacore>There are geographical dimensions to that where in some markets within Multnomah County, those occupancy levels are fine.

1245
02:24:28.245 --> 02:24:44.691
<v Michael Bonacore>So it really is an issue of sort of figuring out, in some cases property by property, and in some cases sort of like in geographic clusters, what are the what are the issues that are really complicating things?

1246
02:24:45.112 --> 02:24:57.664
<v Michael Bonacore>In the case of that urban core, there are some properties where we continue to struggle with really high vacancy rates where they were built as SROs.

1247
02:24:58.632 --> 02:25:00.355
<v Michael Bonacore>The rents are really low.

1248
02:25:03.056 --> 02:25:09.304
<v Michael Bonacore>And we and other affordable housing providers are still struggling to get tenants.

1249
02:25:09.352 --> 02:25:09.433
<v Michael Bonacore>Okay.

1250
02:25:09.736 --> 02:25:12.452
<v Michael Bonacore>Folks who want to live.

1251
02:25:12.709 --> 02:25:26.497
<v Michael Bonacore>You know, in some ways we now, we have a legacy portfolio of something that may have been very attractive for a certain market of renters 20 years ago, now is not viable.

1252
02:25:26.626 --> 02:25:33.405
<v Michael Bonacore>And the ability to sort of say, well, like, we'll add a bathroom so everybody has their own bathroom is its own, you know, sort of issue.

1253
02:25:34.177 --> 02:25:51.913
<v Michael Bonacore>So in some cases, You know, the— this idea of leasing agents and retention bonuses for property management companies, you know, there's sort of a set of interventions you can apply that are kind of like, we need to try harder here.

1254
02:25:52.442 --> 02:25:53.774
<v Michael Bonacore>We need to try harder everywhere.

1255
02:25:53.903 --> 02:26:03.418
<v Michael Bonacore>But in some cases, there are sort of these structural challenges that just at the end of the day, no matter what you do, you've still got an SRO in Old Town.

1256
02:26:04.195 --> 02:26:08.284
<v Michael Bonacore>And it's hard to find folks who want to live there.

1257
02:26:09.226 --> 02:26:22.447
<v Michael Bonacore>So again, I appreciate the question because it's hard in a few slides to sort of capture all of the ways that you have to think about what is within our control and how can we move those levers.

1258
02:26:22.719 --> 02:26:28.825
<v Michael Bonacore>And then at the systems level, what are we all kind of grappling with that, you know, is it regulatory relief?

1259
02:26:28.906 --> 02:26:30.630
<v Michael Bonacore>Is it bailouts, you know, at some sort of scale?

1260
02:26:30.693 --> 02:26:30.755
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1261
02:26:33.497 --> 02:26:33.967
<v Loretta Smith>Scale.

1262
02:26:34.031 --> 02:26:53.506
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and again, I think a lot of that makes some sense, but here's where it— the, the wrench is kind of thrown for me in that, is that it doesn't seem logical given a lot of this other conversation that this dais has to have on the number of people who are sitting in our pod villages waiting for a unit.

1263
02:26:54.061 --> 02:27:04.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>So An SRO may not be desirable, but at a certain price point, it sure as well is compared to a current situation.

1264
02:27:05.354 --> 02:27:08.043
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we aren't talking about a Portland without a homeless population.

1265
02:27:08.092 --> 02:27:10.263
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're talking about a Portland who has a homeless population.

1266
02:27:10.361 --> 02:27:22.779
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that's where I struggle with this, because this is— when we talk about a continuum, and I know about a decade ago this community kind of turned its back on SROs, I never did, because from a continuum perspective, I agree.

1267
02:27:22.930 --> 02:27:29.050
<v Eric Zimmerman>Continuum perspective— street to shelter to pod to SRO to apartment.

1268
02:27:29.308 --> 02:27:33.630
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, that is kind of what we talk about in terms of types of units available.

1269
02:27:34.691 --> 02:27:44.391
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I have not felt like those who work in housing for the government have been able to logically have that conversation.

1270
02:27:45.254 --> 02:28:03.047
<v Eric Zimmerman>And We are also deeply out of sync if an SRO is— if it's not desirable at the price point a provider is trying to get, then you've got a market problem in terms of lower the price point, right?

1271
02:28:03.111 --> 02:28:20.861
<v Eric Zimmerman>So like, I guess that's where I'm struggling to see is why is the public market not addressing that issue and what is keeping prices at a point where we have vacancies instead of dropping for these less desirable apartments.

1272
02:28:20.941 --> 02:28:28.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think, yeah, less desirable apartment is something I think a lot of people can understand because that is relative to your own situation.

1273
02:28:28.549 --> 02:28:33.813
<v Eric Zimmerman>But there's a point where price and availability and location all kind of convene, and I'm trying to— or converge.

1274
02:28:33.941 --> 02:28:59.454
<v Michael Bonacore>And I'm trying to understand that a little bit about are we being aggressive in that acknowledgment if yeah, and I may tap a friend to come help me if I struggle on this, but I think there are a couple of issues.

1275
02:28:59.566 --> 02:29:23.709
<v Michael Bonacore>And one is the brief presentation didn't touch on the issue of economic vacancy, but what we what we have throughout the portfolio, and I think every other affordable housing provider has, is— I think we may have talked about it a little bit before— like the idea that we have empty apartments and then we have a lot of apartments that are not empty, but folks who can't afford to pay their rent.

1276
02:29:24.527 --> 02:29:35.763
<v Michael Bonacore>In the case of the SROs, those price points are very, very low, and at some point there's the only translation to affordability is a subsidy.

1277
02:29:38.197 --> 02:29:48.653
<v Michael Bonacore>And we collectively, we Home Forward, and we collectively don't have the subsidy that sort of says, let's help you out of this pod village into this apartment.

1278
02:29:48.894 --> 02:29:54.240
<v Michael Bonacore>Like, we can put a human being in there, but they don't have the money to pay the rent.

1279
02:29:54.531 --> 02:29:58.259
<v Michael Bonacore>And on a case-by-case basis, that could be fine, but at scale—.

1280
02:29:58.259 --> 02:29:58.468
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah.

1281
02:29:59.031 --> 02:30:01.146
<v Michael Bonacore>It's just not sustainable.

1282
02:30:02.147 --> 02:30:04.520
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is, so I'm gonna keep going with that example.

1283
02:30:04.617 --> 02:30:16.877
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think that's kind of what I'm talking about with when I think of publicly subsidized units, if they were all full, my willingness to engage in a finance kind of conversation.

1284
02:30:17.054 --> 02:30:25.524
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think I'm gonna look to my colleague right here because I've mentioned to other colleagues, there's an aspect of the social housing here for those in our community who are never gonna be self-sufficient.

1285
02:30:25.711 --> 02:30:26.192
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1286
02:30:26.417 --> 02:30:27.798
<v Eric Zimmerman>That I, I really get.

1287
02:30:28.921 --> 02:30:30.156
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think this is part of it.

1288
02:30:30.204 --> 02:30:33.735
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is where I think some of those policy ideas can come together.

1289
02:30:34.859 --> 02:30:37.683
<v Eric Zimmerman>But getting them in the unit to me is a value, right?

1290
02:30:37.746 --> 02:30:38.629
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is important.

1291
02:30:39.014 --> 02:30:50.697
<v Eric Zimmerman>I wouldn't love it, but I would understand it better if the report from Home Forward every year was, this is how many units were filled, but with people who are not able to pay.

1292
02:30:51.290 --> 02:30:55.878
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so the subsidy that we are requesting is this big to pay for those units.

1293
02:30:55.958 --> 02:31:02.628
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is a more reasonable conversation, frankly, for me, than empty units.

1294
02:31:02.691 --> 02:31:10.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and you use the term economic vacancy, but I guess I'm just using the vacancy in the normal person version of like, there, it's just nobody's in there.

1295
02:31:11.206 --> 02:31:24.095
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's what's so damning for Portlanders when they hear about these, these issues, is that a vacant, a publicly subsidized vacant building is one of those things that just People boil over at that idea.

1296
02:31:24.867 --> 02:31:28.450
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to shift a little bit just for sake of time here.

1297
02:31:28.722 --> 02:31:35.131
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I've been on the website, I've tried to go through and try to understand as a renter, as a person looking for housing to do it.

1298
02:31:35.180 --> 02:31:37.117
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's a challenge, I'll just say.

1299
02:31:37.359 --> 02:31:39.215
<v Eric Zimmerman>And a lot of things are very out of date.

1300
02:31:40.022 --> 02:31:41.135
<v Eric Zimmerman>I went to the safety side.

1301
02:31:46.340 --> 02:31:46.700
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1302
02:31:47.983 --> 02:31:49.219
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm very disappointed there.

1303
02:31:49.604 --> 02:31:58.344
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll just tell you, because what I don't need to see on the Home Forward safety side is air quality or radon right now.

1304
02:31:59.388 --> 02:32:16.432
<v Eric Zimmerman>The fire that's at our feet that we've heard a lot about is the behavior that's been allowed inside of Home Forward units that have then made neighbors say, boy, if the market is only a little bit more to not be in this building with these these tenants, I'm leaving.

1305
02:32:17.602 --> 02:32:21.629
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that largely seems ignored previously.

1306
02:32:21.693 --> 02:32:25.736
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, and I want to give credit to— you are 2 months in and you are not ignoring it.

1307
02:32:26.025 --> 02:32:28.881
<v Eric Zimmerman>But that is what— that is the lane you're swimming in right now.

1308
02:32:29.972 --> 02:32:34.560
<v Eric Zimmerman>In fact, there's even something that says for eligibility everybody has to pass a criminal background check.

1309
02:32:35.171 --> 02:32:39.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>But then I hear you kind of aren't doing that, or, or that you don't really care what comes up in the criminal background check.

1310
02:32:39.775 --> 02:32:40.737
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what is the point.

1311
02:32:40.882 --> 02:32:42.213
<v Eric Zimmerman>And what is a safety standard?

1312
02:32:42.967 --> 02:32:55.106
<v Eric Zimmerman>And what can a resident who is a, who is a member of a Home Forward community expect when it comes to safety, people who they live around, what Home Forward's role is there?

1313
02:32:55.316 --> 02:32:58.426
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I can't get it from your website.

1314
02:32:58.506 --> 02:33:01.265
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's, it's not meeting today's challenge.

1315
02:33:01.394 --> 02:33:06.349
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's meeting some environmental stuff from wildfire eras.

1316
02:33:06.541 --> 02:33:13.724
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I really think that if Home Forward wants to be credible with the public, you've got to address the vacancy issue.

1317
02:33:13.788 --> 02:33:18.736
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if you want to be credible with your own members, your own residents, you've got to really address a safety issue.

1318
02:33:19.207 --> 02:33:20.569
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I see nothing about that.

1319
02:33:22.209 --> 02:33:26.507
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what is the role of a criminal background check for a Home Forward resident?

1320
02:33:29.561 --> 02:33:34.200
<v Michael Bonacore>The role is largely the same as it is throughout the city.

1321
02:33:34.280 --> 02:33:37.661
<v Michael Bonacore>So we have screening screening criteria process.

1322
02:33:38.349 --> 02:33:45.371
<v Michael Bonacore>In a number of cases, it is less stringent than the city's.

1323
02:33:45.872 --> 02:33:53.360
<v Michael Bonacore>But if we deferred to the city's standard, you would get fundamentally the same outcome.

1324
02:33:53.570 --> 02:33:58.894
<v Michael Bonacore>So in some cases, for example, our lookback period might be 3 years and the city's is 5 years.

1325
02:33:59.771 --> 02:34:00.050
<v Michael Bonacore>Okay.

1326
02:34:00.100 --> 02:34:06.879
<v Michael Bonacore>So it's not a wildly divergent process from what the, you know, the city in general applies.

1327
02:34:07.697 --> 02:34:44.115
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would like to offer up maybe the rhetorical permission that if Home Forward needs support from the City Council to reconsider its standards, its safety standards, its background check standards, to make these places a better, safer, livable community, I am all ears because I, from reporting that I've heard, from the interactions, residents I've met with, it is, it is a huge concern that I don't want to lose that thread because these are parallel tracks, the controversies of, of Home Forward.

1328
02:34:44.165 --> 02:34:50.287
<v Eric Zimmerman>But really, I'm talking about vacancies and then the quality of life for Home Forward projects because I want to end on this.

1329
02:34:52.399 --> 02:34:59.998
<v Eric Zimmerman>For these last several months, and I've asked you this question, I'm not sure that I'm in the camp right now that believes Home Forward should exist.

1330
02:35:01.850 --> 02:35:07.242
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not sure that the organization is not broken to its core enough that it can actually recover.

1331
02:35:08.301 --> 02:35:10.118
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that's what I'm evaluating.

1332
02:35:10.615 --> 02:35:12.047
<v Eric Zimmerman>I believe in a housing authority.

1333
02:35:12.319 --> 02:35:17.399
<v Eric Zimmerman>I do not believe that this model has worked or is working right now, and I'm, and I'm questioning that.

1334
02:35:17.480 --> 02:35:19.993
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the attorney briefed on a few options that we have here.

1335
02:35:20.058 --> 02:35:20.219
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1336
02:35:21.018 --> 02:35:30.909
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so what I'm trying to get a sense is, is the leadership, is the, I hope, fully new board coming in ready to take this by the reins and fix it?

1337
02:35:31.055 --> 02:35:34.197
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or do we need to kill it and reimagine it in a whole new era?

1338
02:35:35.183 --> 02:35:50.197
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's where I'm gonna be listening to these questions because these questions that I ask, but also what colleagues are gonna ask, that's what's at the heart of my consideration because the rest, the way that this conversation was framed up today about a system of affordable housing, et cetera, et cetera, I believe that's important.

1339
02:35:50.245 --> 02:35:50.295
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1340
02:35:53.033 --> 02:35:58.970
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I, I looked at Home Forward as our housing authority, as the credible agent and a communicator on these topics.

1341
02:35:59.051 --> 02:36:15.435
<v Eric Zimmerman>And right now you're part of the problem, and I need Home Forward to be part of that solution before I can have the larger conversation about how all of the system is fitting together, because, um, I can't get past where we're at with Home Forward yet.

1342
02:36:15.516 --> 02:36:17.555
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I appreciate you stepping into this role.

1343
02:36:17.746 --> 02:36:18.436
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really do.

1344
02:36:18.629 --> 02:36:29.793
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that I told you from the very beginning I would support whatever heads need to roll that you think are appropriate, and I continue to say that, and that invitation stays wide open from my angle.

1345
02:36:30.020 --> 02:36:30.342
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1346
02:36:33.335 --> 02:36:34.431
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1347
02:36:34.542 --> 02:36:36.523
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, followed by Councilor Green.

1348
02:36:37.683 --> 02:36:38.343
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1349
02:36:39.211 --> 02:36:43.967
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, you know, there's an interesting part of that last conversation with Councilor Zimmerman around SROs.

1350
02:36:44.369 --> 02:36:57.460
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had I have been thinking a lot about the fact that an SRO looks to me pretty similar to our pod shelters in terms of what your living environment and your community are.

1351
02:36:58.182 --> 02:37:01.995
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And one model is free and one model you pay for in an older building.

1352
02:37:03.005 --> 02:37:07.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It does not surprise me that we're struggling to get folks into those buildings.

1353
02:37:07.477 --> 02:37:10.313
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think that looking at the cost of housing and the cost of services, thank you.

1354
02:37:10.489 --> 02:37:10.649
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1355
02:37:10.698 --> 02:37:12.236
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think that cost is a really important piece of the puzzle.

1356
02:37:12.989 --> 02:37:18.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I want to pick up on a different theme from that last conversation.

1357
02:37:20.364 --> 02:37:29.325
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'll start by saying that I found the introduction to this entire item interesting because there certainly are system-wide challenges in our affordable housing system.

1358
02:37:30.000 --> 02:37:30.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right?

1359
02:37:30.239 --> 02:37:36.058
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've talked a lot about that narrow space between rent and income that has become even tighter and started to break down.

1360
02:37:36.139 --> 02:37:36.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1361
02:37:36.413 --> 02:37:45.782
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've heard a lot about the breakdown over the last few years and about the increasing operation expenses, security needs, behavioral health acuity, maturing loans among them.

1362
02:37:46.441 --> 02:37:57.003
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>More importantly, we've talked about the model on which these buildings are built to begin with and the fact that it has never in fact been a sustainable model for the long term.

1363
02:37:59.183 --> 02:38:01.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to address those issues.

1364
02:38:01.405 --> 02:38:15.183
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council certainly began to address some of those issues by including funding to reduce debt and monthly costs and help fund unit turnover and rent buydowns and security costs, among other specific needs.

1365
02:38:15.295 --> 02:38:28.364
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I am very hopeful that Home Forward will take advantage of that pot of money and ensure that you can address some of the systemic needs within your building stock.

1366
02:38:28.782 --> 02:38:29.281
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1367
02:38:30.532 --> 02:38:37.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But there is also a clear breakdown at Home Forward, which is separate from those systemic challenges.

1368
02:38:38.897 --> 02:38:52.032
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so framing this just about systemic challenges, I think, is dishonest to Portlanders who are living in the properties that you own and manage and raising very real concerns to us.

1369
02:38:54.472 --> 02:39:06.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I start in this conversation from a place of believing that we in fact have a higher obligation to our residents in Home Forward properties because you are our public housing authority.

1370
02:39:07.237 --> 02:39:14.191
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That when we say to a Portlander, here is a safe place for you to live, it is with our public housing authority.

1371
02:39:14.769 --> 02:39:19.200
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a place you can afford and you can be and you can be safe.

1372
02:39:20.084 --> 02:39:22.222
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That we have a high standard that comes with that.

1373
02:39:23.139 --> 02:39:32.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I have not seen that standard from previous Home Forward leadership and from the organization over the last year and a half.

1374
02:39:33.708 --> 02:39:35.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This has not yet been explored.

1375
02:39:37.602 --> 02:39:45.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had the opportunity to ask some of the system need questions in committee, so I don't want to repeat those today, and I really appreciate the answers that Thank you.

1376
02:39:45.020 --> 02:39:45.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

1377
02:39:45.020 --> 02:39:45.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for the opportunity to speak.

1378
02:39:45.020 --> 02:39:46.360
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the information that I received.

1379
02:39:46.360 --> 02:39:56.639
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I learned some notable things about the systemic challenges that we're facing and the, the need to build different housing types than we've invested in in the past, which is something that I've spoken to many times.

1380
02:39:57.780 --> 02:40:01.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Today, I truly have just one question for you, and I'll give it a bit of a preamble.

1381
02:40:02.920 --> 02:40:09.950
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are 29 Home Forward properties, about 2,500 units in District 2.

1382
02:40:11.304 --> 02:40:14.209
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hear repeatedly about safety concerns.

1383
02:40:15.093 --> 02:40:22.977
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hear repeatedly about empty commercial spaces in buildings where tenants were promised on-site assets.

1384
02:40:23.731 --> 02:40:26.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a building where there will be things happening below.

1385
02:40:26.236 --> 02:40:29.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You'll have the ability to do some of your shopping right here.

1386
02:40:30.572 --> 02:40:38.111
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the type of building that anybody in our community, whether reliant on some support to meet their rent needs or not would want to live in.

1387
02:40:38.956 --> 02:40:40.467
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And those promises have gone unfulfilled.

1388
02:40:42.634 --> 02:41:04.609
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have heard repeatedly about people who are in recovery being placed in buildings where there are known drug dealers in the building, where leadership, where the on-site property management know that people are dealing drugs out of their publicly owned thank you.

1389
02:41:07.013 --> 02:41:20.549
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I have heard repeatedly about prostitution, not only in the buildings but in the common areas of Home Forward properties— properties, not just one— in my district.

1390
02:41:21.493 --> 02:41:23.804
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are not systemic issues.

1391
02:41:24.726 --> 02:41:30.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are far graver than the systemic issues that have been raised.

1392
02:41:32.119 --> 02:41:34.896
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I hear you, there's money for a consultant and we're going to get a report.

1393
02:41:36.402 --> 02:41:46.244
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Interestingly, residents have been told there's not money to self-manage the properties, and we know that your self-managed properties have better outcomes— less drug dealing, less prostitution.

1394
02:41:48.470 --> 02:42:15.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My constituents cannot wait for a consultant report to have safe places to live, so I am wondering what what have you done and what will occur in the next 3 months to address drug dealing and prostitution in Home Forward-owned properties, to get tenants into the commercial spaces that are currently empty, and to implement the needed security upgrades, some of which council has provided funding for in your buildings?

1395
02:42:15.860 --> 02:42:16.674
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would like specifics.

1396
02:42:18.899 --> 02:42:19.587
<v Michael Bonacore>Sure, Councilor.

1397
02:42:19.760 --> 02:42:20.487
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

1398
02:42:20.665 --> 02:42:30.921
<v Michael Bonacore>First, I'll just say we had not sent you all the PowerPoint that I walked through, but we've— I think it has since been received.

1399
02:42:30.969 --> 02:42:32.293
<v Michael Bonacore>So you all will have that.

1400
02:42:33.198 --> 02:42:40.052
<v Michael Bonacore>As you look back, just to clarify, the information that I provided is about Home Forward and not about systemic issues.

1401
02:42:40.263 --> 02:42:44.458
<v Michael Bonacore>Some of the issues that we're grappling with are, you know, sort of broader than just us.

1402
02:42:45.415 --> 02:42:54.825
<v Michael Bonacore>But I do think it's very important to your point that we are talking about our own accountability and, you know, what our specific issues are and what the steps are that we are taking.

1403
02:42:55.884 --> 02:43:02.799
<v Michael Bonacore>And so, you know, again, at a property-by-property basis, that can look different.

1404
02:43:03.761 --> 02:43:14.799
<v Michael Bonacore>I recently have walked both Louisa Flowers and Dawson Park and have seen and heard that at both of those properties, there are significant strides forward around these issues.

1405
02:43:17.100 --> 02:43:28.950
<v Michael Bonacore>And, you know, I think we have to continue to, you know, press on those issues and find every means that we can.

1406
02:43:29.710 --> 02:43:39.718
<v Michael Bonacore>And sometimes at an organizational level, we can direct resources at a property where it may not have— where the property itself may not have the resources.

1407
02:43:41.031 --> 02:43:49.979
<v Michael Bonacore>But at scale, you know, we really are depending on, you know, at the property level, the property's ability to fund security upgrades.

1408
02:43:50.269 --> 02:43:55.961
<v Michael Bonacore>So I think there are a number of elements that go into how we can address these issues.

1409
02:43:56.025 --> 02:44:00.885
<v Michael Bonacore>And in some cases it's a fence, in some cases it's round-the-clock security.

1410
02:44:01.397 --> 02:44:07.138
<v Michael Bonacore>We have a property not in your district, but in the— In the 18th.

1411
02:44:07.972 --> 02:44:16.586
<v Michael Bonacore>In the Hollywood District, it's a tower building in which we have recently added 24-hour security, and that has made a significant difference.

1412
02:44:17.117 --> 02:44:19.234
<v Michael Bonacore>That price tag is about $1 million a year.

1413
02:44:19.459 --> 02:44:26.340
<v Michael Bonacore>So we do sometimes run into just fiscal realities about what is needed and what are the resources available.

1414
02:44:26.661 --> 02:44:42.280
<v Michael Bonacore>But at the same time, the point you made is correct, and we have to figure out whether it's our own resources or seeking support from the city or you know, coordinating with public safety resources, how we are at a property-by-property level addressing those needs.

1415
02:44:42.793 --> 02:44:54.216
<v Michael Bonacore>In terms of the, you know, the tenant, the commercial spaces, we are working to find folks to lease them.

1416
02:44:54.907 --> 02:44:55.872
<v Michael Bonacore>It's really hard.

1417
02:44:55.968 --> 02:44:56.129
<v Michael Bonacore>It is.

1418
02:44:56.193 --> 02:44:59.894
<v Michael Bonacore>That's not a, you know, that's not an issue that's specific to Home Forward.

1419
02:45:00.038 --> 02:45:01.245
<v Michael Bonacore>These, and I think—.

1420
02:45:01.245 --> 02:45:01.308
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah.

1421
02:45:01.399 --> 02:45:19.835
<v Michael Bonacore>I think in some cases there are questions we all have to ask ourselves around what are the standards that we are defining for when we finance properties, and is ground floor commercial always the right thing to demand of new developments, right?

1422
02:45:19.900 --> 02:45:31.048
<v Michael Bonacore>And so in some cases we're learning lessons that are hard to apply because we, you know, the commercial space has been built out and there have been efforts for years to find, you know, tenants to occupy them.

1423
02:45:31.097 --> 02:45:31.313
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah.

1424
02:45:32.261 --> 02:45:42.725
<v Michael Bonacore>And it's really important because that ground floor activation helps with public safety and it helps with community engagement and, you know, the availability of resources for folks.

1425
02:45:43.534 --> 02:46:09.507
<v Michael Bonacore>So in short, what I'm saying is you're right that we have to take this seriously and treat these safety issues as, have you asked for additional funding either from the city or the state to address some of these specific concerns?

1426
02:46:11.209 --> 02:46:11.531
<v Michael Bonacore>We have.

1427
02:46:11.806 --> 02:46:18.409
<v Michael Bonacore>We have recently, the city paid to install a fence at Dawson Park.

1428
02:46:19.055 --> 02:46:24.548
<v Michael Bonacore>The round of security and safety grants that were provided by PHB last year included funding for a fence at Dawson Park.

1429
02:46:24.649 --> 02:46:28.583
<v Michael Bonacore>Last year, upgraded security at one of our high-rise properties.

1430
02:46:29.240 --> 02:46:35.358
<v Michael Bonacore>So we are sort of turning over the stones that, you know, that we can find to do that work.

1431
02:46:35.759 --> 02:46:45.039
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what work is being done with the property management companies that you contract with to ensure that they are meeting the standards that you have at your self-managed properties?

1432
02:46:46.097 --> 02:46:53.066
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, in some cases that is a targeted changing of property management companies.

1433
02:46:53.177 --> 02:46:54.462
<v Michael Bonacore>In some cases, Yes.

1434
02:46:54.688 --> 02:47:05.509
<v Michael Bonacore>It is our staff sort of working alongside them to support, you know, the level of attention that the property needs.

1435
02:47:05.558 --> 02:47:09.884
<v Michael Bonacore>Sometimes that's a short-term intervention to stabilize things.

1436
02:47:11.709 --> 02:47:30.586
<v Michael Bonacore>You know, again, this is an issue for us to address, and it is also sort of like a community-level issue of, There are not a lot of property management companies available for us to simply say, okay, this isn't working out, we'll go with this property management company.

1437
02:47:30.667 --> 02:47:35.064
<v Michael Bonacore>Like, they're all on rotation between the affordable housing providers in this community.

1438
02:47:36.061 --> 02:47:50.259
<v Michael Bonacore>And so in the case of we have folks who we have to work with, that means, you know, more engagement from our staff in terms of it may look like weekly calls, it may look like walking properties with those companies.

1439
02:47:51.268 --> 02:47:59.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And at what point is it just more affordable to self-manage more of those properties than to have to handhold outside vendors?

1440
02:47:59.792 --> 02:48:03.051
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, it is a question in active conversation.

1441
02:48:03.469 --> 02:48:13.310
<v Michael Bonacore>And part of the answer is it is meaningfully more expensive for us to do that on a property-by-property level.

1442
02:48:13.359 --> 02:48:16.699
<v Michael Bonacore>Sometimes it makes sense and we can figure out how to make that work financially.

1443
02:48:17.638 --> 02:48:22.805
<v Michael Bonacore>And it is significantly more expensive for Home Forward to do that.

1444
02:48:22.997 --> 02:48:33.554
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll point out that it may be more expensive because you are paying people better and therefore able to attract somebody who is more committed to the buildings they're in and going to stick around for longer.

1445
02:48:33.619 --> 02:48:34.118
<v Michael Bonacore>Absolutely.

1446
02:48:34.165 --> 02:48:35.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And sometimes there is a value in that.

1447
02:48:35.792 --> 02:48:37.112
<v Michael Bonacore>Absolutely, yes.

1448
02:48:38.594 --> 02:48:38.900
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

1449
02:48:39.077 --> 02:48:39.496
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you.

1450
02:48:40.864 --> 02:48:43.136
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1451
02:48:43.200 --> 02:48:44.875
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Green followed by Councilor Novick.

1452
02:48:46.353 --> 02:48:46.853
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1453
02:48:46.983 --> 02:48:57.478
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to try to be mindful of time, so I just want to sort of pick up a little bit on where Councilor Pirtle-Guiney left it, and to a certain degree, Councilor Zimmerman left it as well.

1454
02:49:00.947 --> 02:49:05.194
<v Mitch Green>I do want to affirm that it's really important to do oversight.

1455
02:49:05.888 --> 02:49:11.867
<v Mitch Green>This is an oversight conversation, and I've been in the middle of some oversight conversations.

1456
02:49:12.245 --> 02:49:14.173
<v Mitch Green>So I just want to respect that.

1457
02:49:14.815 --> 02:49:16.582
<v Mitch Green>I was probably in the middle of one last week.

1458
02:49:17.385 --> 02:49:34.250
<v Mitch Green>But I think I was careful even in the Urban Alchemy conversation to recognize that while UA has been the center of some media and the specific delivery of a specific service, they're also situated in a broader structural context.

1459
02:49:34.409 --> 02:49:41.234
<v Mitch Green>And so while we can, I think we should and we can have the conversation about teasing out the different parts of the problems that Home Forward faces.

1460
02:49:43.566 --> 02:49:43.953
<v Mitch Green>It's only—.

1461
02:49:44.050 --> 02:49:55.459
<v Mitch Green>We're only going to serve the public if we're able to draw sort of categories to say these are problems associated with poor governance or perhaps choices that didn't work out over time.

1462
02:49:56.246 --> 02:50:00.298
<v Mitch Green>And these over here are problems associated with structural macro problems.

1463
02:50:01.078 --> 02:50:03.716
<v Mitch Green>And that last piece I don't want to get lost.

1464
02:50:04.211 --> 02:50:11.086
<v Mitch Green>Because we can, you know, we can, we can address some of the livability, safety, the drug dealing.

1465
02:50:11.246 --> 02:50:15.765
<v Mitch Green>We can address all that stuff at Home Forward, and, and you will still be left with a balance sheet crisis at the end of the day.

1466
02:50:16.150 --> 02:50:18.522
<v Mitch Green>And that is a fact because every other provider is.

1467
02:50:19.340 --> 02:50:21.375
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm gonna see if I can share my screen.

1468
02:50:21.423 --> 02:50:25.333
<v Mitch Green>I just want colleagues to understand, and I do have some questions, I promise.

1469
02:50:25.670 --> 02:50:32.034
<v Mitch Green>Um, uh, but my team Oh, someone else is sharing.

1470
02:50:32.378 --> 02:50:34.077
<v Mitch Green>I'm just going to click yes and try to take over.

1471
02:50:37.479 --> 02:50:39.022
<v Mitch Green>Um, um, here we go.

1472
02:50:41.118 --> 02:50:50.536
<v Mitch Green>What I'm sharing, if you guys can see it, is a chart that— and this comes from TMG Management, which is a, you know, rental property firm.

1473
02:50:51.134 --> 02:50:54.468
<v Mitch Green>And this data was, I think, current as of February or so.

1474
02:50:55.302 --> 02:51:15.549
<v Mitch Green>And what it shows you is generally CoStar-style data that says that the vacancy rate for the entire United States, all of the United States, all markets across all qualities of properties, rose pretty significantly through the pandemic period and then leveled off.

1475
02:51:16.095 --> 02:51:24.602
<v Mitch Green>And so if you look at Portland's experience, and in particular if you look at the Portland form 5-star ratings, those are our luxury private market units.

1476
02:51:25.147 --> 02:51:26.608
<v Mitch Green>That has the highest vacancy rate.

1477
02:51:27.474 --> 02:51:27.585
<v Mitch Green>Okay?

1478
02:51:28.596 --> 02:51:37.966
<v Mitch Green>So, and our sort of kind of mid-tier and low-tier stuff has vacancy rates that are very similar to our affordable housing properties.

1479
02:51:38.622 --> 02:51:41.591
<v Mitch Green>The difference, though, is those firms can adjust.

1480
02:51:42.184 --> 02:51:44.896
<v Mitch Green>They can attract tenants.

1481
02:51:45.040 --> 02:51:52.841
<v Mitch Green>And so we're basically in a situation where there's a there's a surplus of housing stock and there's a limited amount of ability to purchase the housing services.

1482
02:51:52.953 --> 02:51:54.745
<v Mitch Green>And so tenants have options.

1483
02:51:54.793 --> 02:51:55.988
<v Mitch Green>So we've already had some of that conversation.

1484
02:51:56.870 --> 02:52:10.286
<v Mitch Green>I only list this here because I think if we're going to talk about the persistent vacancy rate in the context of Home Forward, it's important that we don't lose the fact that there's multiple stories to explain the Home Forward problem.

1485
02:52:10.628 --> 02:52:11.018
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1486
02:52:11.748 --> 02:52:13.666
<v Mitch Green>There is a pandemic-era story.

1487
02:52:14.364 --> 02:52:18.086
<v Mitch Green>Where costs rose faster than revenues.

1488
02:52:18.216 --> 02:52:20.922
<v Mitch Green>There is the public safety story as well.

1489
02:52:21.050 --> 02:52:24.093
<v Mitch Green>There is the untreated mental health story.

1490
02:52:24.189 --> 02:52:31.631
<v Mitch Green>There is the very specific but very acute extreme weather event story at the Yards.

1491
02:52:32.146 --> 02:52:33.608
<v Mitch Green>That's in my district.

1492
02:52:33.673 --> 02:52:34.540
<v Mitch Green>That's in our district.

1493
02:52:35.054 --> 02:52:38.909
<v Mitch Green>There's a lot of units that were offline because those units were flooded.

1494
02:52:39.215 --> 02:52:41.112
<v Mitch Green>So it wasn't about anyone doing drugs in a unit.

1495
02:52:41.627 --> 02:52:43.200
<v Mitch Green>That wasn't about market rents.

1496
02:52:43.248 --> 02:52:48.755
<v Mitch Green>So the point I'm trying to say here is that there's a whole lot going on here that has contributed to the crisis that we're in.

1497
02:52:50.073 --> 02:53:01.200
<v Mitch Green>And so it will take a systemic approach, even if we do need to have some pointed conversations around oversight and accountability with some specific choices that the board has allowed to happen.

1498
02:53:01.327 --> 02:53:04.154
<v Mitch Green>So just needed to name that, and I'll stop sharing that for now.

1499
02:53:05.550 --> 02:53:06.322
<v Mitch Green>But the 7—.

1500
02:53:06.322 --> 02:53:06.498
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1501
02:53:06.835 --> 02:53:19.013
<v Mitch Green>To— I think it's 7.9% or 7.3%, um, unstabilized vacancy rate, or stabilized vacancy rate in affordable housing sector, is right in line with what other units are experiencing.

1502
02:53:19.381 --> 02:53:24.756
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so I do have some questions though, and I'll try to keep it targeted here.

1503
02:53:25.447 --> 02:53:45.009
<v Mitch Green>Um, I actually really want to go back to the question of what to expect with the, um, with the appointment Because City Council, like, our oversight reach with Home Forward is through the confirmation of the mayor's proposed appointments, right?

1504
02:53:45.814 --> 02:53:50.843
<v Mitch Green>It may go deeper if we choose to go a different direction, which is to sort of change who our housing authority is.

1505
02:53:50.890 --> 02:53:54.750
<v Mitch Green>And that's an interesting conversation that we may need to have.

1506
02:53:54.895 --> 02:53:57.666
<v Mitch Green>Don't want to do it right now, but— I think that's a good point.

1507
02:54:00.199 --> 02:54:06.913
<v Mitch Green>I'd like to know, so we're gonna be faced with a bunch of, a board replacement slate, right?

1508
02:54:07.729 --> 02:54:16.686
<v Mitch Green>And that board needs, in my view, that board needs to have a full holistic view of the problems facing Home Forward.

1509
02:54:16.959 --> 02:54:27.310
<v Mitch Green>So it's not just about responding to sensational reporting, and it's not just about the kind of, Strike team problem and focus.

1510
02:54:27.779 --> 02:54:32.132
<v Mitch Green>It is about understanding the full scope of issues, including the issues facing tenants.

1511
02:54:32.198 --> 02:54:42.552
<v Mitch Green>And so I think the first question I'll ask is, what was the process look— what has the process looked like for the appointment of Home Forward board seats?

1512
02:54:42.971 --> 02:54:50.604
<v Mitch Green>And I know that you're new in the role for individuals that participate in one of Home Forward's programs in particular.

1513
02:54:50.670 --> 02:54:51.620
<v Mitch Green>I'm interested in that.

1514
02:54:52.823 --> 02:54:54.252
<v Mitch Green>So how does that look in the past?

1515
02:54:55.022 --> 02:54:56.835
<v Mitch Green>What were the selection criteria and so on and so forth?

1516
02:54:56.899 --> 02:54:57.638
<v Mitch Green>So how does that go?

1517
02:54:59.050 --> 02:55:11.873
<v Michael Bonacore>Sure, yeah, I'll answer the question by starting at the end, which is fully appreciate the fact that whatever came before, you know, this is a new council and a new form of government and it will look different.

1518
02:55:12.852 --> 02:55:16.704
<v Michael Bonacore>And it has looked a variety of ways in the past.

1519
02:55:17.270 --> 02:55:24.049
<v Michael Bonacore>And so sometimes, depending on the jurisdiction, we'll alert them that there's a vacancy.

1520
02:55:25.389 --> 02:55:29.118
<v Michael Bonacore>They may or may not have someone sort of in the queue that they have in mind.

1521
02:55:29.680 --> 02:55:35.015
<v Michael Bonacore>And so we may, you know, Home Forward may propose that they consider a certain candidate.

1522
02:55:35.289 --> 02:55:39.534
<v Michael Bonacore>Other times they sort of say like, no, we've got someone, you know, waiting.

1523
02:55:41.560 --> 02:56:00.638
<v Michael Bonacore>In the past, it has ranged from Home Forward board appointments being on City Council consent agenda to, you know, folks coming and being present, although I haven't seen a lot of sort of engagement in the way you just did with the utility board.

1524
02:56:02.059 --> 02:56:12.854
<v Michael Bonacore>So I think, you know, clearly in a new era and, you know, What it looks like going forward, I expect you all to sort of put your stamp on that.

1525
02:56:13.676 --> 02:56:14.095
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1526
02:56:14.192 --> 02:56:24.385
<v Mitch Green>So just kind of understanding that past context a little bit, what is the process for this current slate, the seats appointment look like at this time?

1527
02:56:26.681 --> 02:56:38.007
<v Michael Bonacore>In the case of Gresham, we alerted them to the— well, they knew because they actually hired our former Gresham, one of our Gresham appointees to work at the City of Gresham.

1528
02:56:38.299 --> 02:56:41.662
<v Michael Bonacore>And employees of the appointing jurisdictions can't be on our board.

1529
02:56:43.459 --> 02:56:46.531
<v Michael Bonacore>And so, but there was a conversation about the fact that there was a vacancy.

1530
02:56:47.209 --> 02:56:49.602
<v Michael Bonacore>They had someone in the community they were interested in.

1531
02:56:49.941 --> 02:56:53.617
<v Michael Bonacore>It went to Gresham City Council for a vote, and that will be forwarded to us.

1532
02:56:57.177 --> 02:56:58.050
<v Michael Bonacore>In the case of—.

1533
02:56:58.117 --> 02:56:59.368
<v Michael Bonacore>Councilor Smith.

1534
02:57:00.388 --> 02:57:08.790
<v Michael Bonacore>You know, the Portland slots, that is largely living with the mayor at this point to refer folks to City Council.

1535
02:57:09.225 --> 02:57:18.897
<v Michael Bonacore>There has been some, you know, connection to us in terms of candidates who were considered.

1536
02:57:19.028 --> 02:57:24.029
<v Michael Bonacore>Is there any reason we would flag a concern around them?

1537
02:57:24.370 --> 02:57:33.030
<v Michael Bonacore>But it really is we— there are no sort of candidates that are coming before you that Home Forward has referred or recommended.

1538
02:57:34.180 --> 02:57:35.842
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1539
02:57:35.906 --> 02:57:36.454
<v Mitch Green>Um, do you—.

1540
02:57:36.632 --> 02:57:40.941
<v Mitch Green>Can you give us any insight on what the mayor has considered in determining his nominations?

1541
02:57:40.990 --> 02:57:42.153
<v Mitch Green>Like, what's his process been like?

1542
02:57:42.200 --> 02:57:44.119
<v Mitch Green>What kind of questions is he asking these people?

1543
02:57:46.448 --> 02:57:48.024
<v Michael Bonacore>I can't— I, I can't speak to that.

1544
02:57:48.073 --> 02:58:10.004
<v Michael Bonacore>I mean, I— there was a— there was a meeting with the mayor and the county chair and Commissioner Singleton, in which there was some conversation around what sorts of backgrounds might be helpful for Home Forward, like, you know, legal background, finance background, real estate background, but nothing, you know, that the rest of that process really lives with the mayor.

1545
02:58:11.852 --> 02:58:11.998
<v Adrian Delgado>Okay.

1546
02:58:12.438 --> 02:58:20.566
<v Mitch Green>I'm just trying to get a sense of what is changing Relative to our past practices?

1547
02:58:21.229 --> 02:58:27.737
<v Mitch Green>And are there— yeah, I think I'll leave it there for now.

1548
02:58:28.856 --> 02:58:29.132
<v Mitch Green>Sure.

1549
02:58:29.424 --> 02:58:45.745
<v Michael Bonacore>I mean, I would just— to name it, I would say there's an overarching distrust of who might Home Forward recommend, and that the nominating jurisdictions have to sort of find those candidates that feel like they're a match for what they believe is needed for Home Forward.

1550
02:58:46.005 --> 02:58:47.405
<v Michael Bonacore>You know, for oversight for Home Forward.

1551
02:58:47.646 --> 02:58:48.096
<v Lorraine Wilson>Okay.

1552
02:58:49.382 --> 02:58:50.620
<v Mitch Green>All right.

1553
02:58:50.684 --> 02:58:54.382
<v Mitch Green>I think I may have more questions later, but I'll just— I'll make space for others for now.

1554
02:58:54.462 --> 02:58:54.897
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1555
02:58:56.777 --> 02:58:57.564
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1556
02:58:58.238 --> 02:59:04.505
<v Sameer Kanal>Just real quick, for those who are waiting on Murillo 11, which is the next agenda item, I don't think it's— I think it's pretty obvious we're not going to get to it today.

1557
02:59:04.909 --> 02:59:12.266
<v Sameer Kanal>We have about 8 minutes left in this session, so I'll ask our remaining 3 folks in the queue to be discretionary with their time.

1558
02:59:12.735 --> 02:59:14.490
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, followed by Murillo, followed by Ryan.

1559
02:59:15.975 --> 02:59:16.748
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

1560
02:59:17.572 --> 02:59:21.343
<v Steve Novick>And I will accept and in fact encourage really quick answers to my questions.

1561
02:59:21.457 --> 02:59:30.816
<v Steve Novick>But Councilor Smith alluded earlier to the fact that Home Forward had reported that it had a $13 million deficit and now apparently has a $30 million deficit.

1562
02:59:30.977 --> 02:59:38.516
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted you to quickly address, Ms. Brannock, what steps are being taken to make sure that inaccurate information of that sort isn't released in the future?

1563
02:59:40.272 --> 02:59:41.075
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you, Councilor.

1564
02:59:41.236 --> 02:59:47.665
<v Michael Bonacore>Yes, as I said, I recently brought in a new interim CFO.

1565
02:59:48.870 --> 03:00:00.992
<v Michael Bonacore>We are looking at our reporting frequency, what financial information is provided to our board and therefore to the community.

1566
03:00:02.132 --> 03:00:05.574
<v Michael Bonacore>We are looking at all of our internal processes.

1567
03:00:05.686 --> 03:00:10.516
<v Michael Bonacore>So there's a review that's That's happening right now with me and the new CFO.

1568
03:00:11.786 --> 03:00:22.957
<v Michael Bonacore>And then implementing changes to make sure that that particular forecasting error doesn't happen again and looking at our systems really critically.

1569
03:00:24.569 --> 03:00:31.405
<v Michael Bonacore>Errors can happen, but there's a high level of scrutiny that is needed to make sure that—.

1570
03:00:31.823 --> 03:00:32.064
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah.

1571
03:00:32.605 --> 03:00:37.981
<v Michael Bonacore>We're on better footing than we have been around that, and that work's underway.

1572
03:00:40.004 --> 03:00:44.120
<v Steve Novick>Like Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, I was interested in your discussion of the SROs.

1573
03:00:44.747 --> 03:00:49.413
<v Steve Novick>I actually have constituents ask me on a regular basis, why can't we just go back to having SROs?

1574
03:00:49.886 --> 03:00:52.495
<v Steve Novick>And if people aren't going to SROs, that's important to know.

1575
03:00:54.435 --> 03:01:01.422
<v Steve Novick>So maybe this is going to be in your consultant's report, but what I would love to What I would love to see is— you said that there's different factors in different properties.

1576
03:01:02.242 --> 03:01:08.282
<v Steve Novick>What I would love to see is some sort of analysis of here's a property where the biggest factor is people just don't want to go there.

1577
03:01:08.524 --> 03:01:10.894
<v Steve Novick>Here's a property where the biggest factor is people can afford to go there.

1578
03:01:11.408 --> 03:01:17.031
<v Steve Novick>Here's a property where people perceive that it's unsafe because of structural problems with the building.

1579
03:01:17.790 --> 03:01:24.074
<v Steve Novick>Here's a property where people perceive that it's unsafe because of unfortunate activity by residents.

1580
03:01:24.316 --> 03:01:29.430
<v Steve Novick>And if that's the case, What, um, is it possible to evict troublesome residents?

1581
03:01:29.542 --> 03:01:30.949
<v Steve Novick>And if, if not, why not?

1582
03:01:31.563 --> 03:01:53.254
<v Steve Novick>Um, do you think that— I mean, obviously there'll be multiple factors in multiple buildings, but do you think that it might be possible to take a shot at sort of teasing out some of the different factors and then to sort of, um, benchmark by referring to non-Home Forward properties that have similar issues and see if your vacancy rates are any better or worse than those properties?

1583
03:01:56.659 --> 03:02:01.620
<v Michael Bonacore>I do think a portfolio-level analysis is called for.

1584
03:02:02.009 --> 03:02:07.191
<v Michael Bonacore>I'll look to our Director of Asset Management specifically about the analysis that you asked for.

1585
03:02:09.504 --> 03:02:13.996
<v Michael Bonacore>So I would say that kind of analysis is possible and important.

1586
03:02:15.510 --> 03:02:15.978
<v Clark>Yeah.

1587
03:02:16.298 --> 03:02:16.801
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1588
03:02:19.879 --> 03:02:20.888
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1589
03:02:20.953 --> 03:02:21.736
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Murillo.

1590
03:02:23.398 --> 03:02:24.377
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1591
03:02:24.475 --> 03:02:25.518
<v Angelita Morillo>I'll be super quick.

1592
03:02:26.040 --> 03:02:39.013
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to kind of follow along with what Councilor Green had stated earlier and just say that I'm really going to be looking for the specificity around the recruitment stages and the criteria that was considered for these candidates.

1593
03:02:39.615 --> 03:02:47.273
<v Angelita Morillo>And I have a few questions that I'll just read very quickly that I would like answered by them when they come before us, just so we get more information from them.

1594
03:02:48.586 --> 03:02:59.324
<v Angelita Morillo>I would love to know which Home Forward programs these people have participated in, and if they have any lived experience that would help sort of inform how they are approaching this work.

1595
03:03:00.380 --> 03:03:08.713
<v Angelita Morillo>If they are currently participating in any programs and what they have seen has worked for them and what hasn't worked for them.

1596
03:03:09.114 --> 03:03:19.666
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that oftentimes some of the most important experience that we can ask for is people actually using our government services and giving us feedback on, you know, what's working or not working.

1597
03:03:20.245 --> 03:03:28.091
<v Angelita Morillo>We can hire a lot of consultants, and sometimes the best person to answer those questions is actually someone who's gone through these things.

1598
03:03:28.268 --> 03:03:34.300
<v Angelita Morillo>So those are the questions that I will be asking, and I'm hoping people will be able to get back to us with.

1599
03:03:34.942 --> 03:03:36.243
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you so much for your presentation today.

1600
03:03:36.307 --> 03:03:41.248
<v Angelita Morillo>It's really helpful, and this is such an important issue for so many people in our community, so I appreciate your time.

1601
03:03:42.485 --> 03:03:43.207
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you, Councilor.

1602
03:03:44.088 --> 03:03:45.773
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, Councilor Murillo.

1603
03:03:46.094 --> 03:03:46.672
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan?

1604
03:03:47.137 --> 03:03:47.875
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thanks, Chair.

1605
03:03:48.084 --> 03:03:52.479
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I want to first thank Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, uh, for your passionate testimony.

1606
03:03:52.608 --> 03:03:58.479
<v Dan Ryan>It was like testimony and comments, and you and I have been in some of the same spaces hearing that, so I really appreciate that.

1607
03:03:58.609 --> 03:04:02.266
<v Dan Ryan>And also Councilor Zimmerman for your theme of getting to accountability.

1608
03:04:02.924 --> 03:04:04.208
<v Dan Ryan>Um, so we don't have much time.

1609
03:04:04.369 --> 03:04:04.914
<v Dan Ryan>Here it goes.

1610
03:04:05.492 --> 03:04:06.838
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, here's what I think.

1611
03:04:07.096 --> 03:04:14.550
<v Dan Ryan>I think Home Forward does a bad job of screening, and I think your management is unwilling to enforce lease terms equally.

1612
03:04:14.859 --> 03:04:20.105
<v Dan Ryan>That's what I think is happening right now with Home Forward based on what I've been listening to for the last few years.

1613
03:04:21.399 --> 03:04:32.076
<v Dan Ryan>How has the reported board-approved changes to the lease standards from 2022 around criminal activity affected the livability of vac— and the vacancy of your properties?

1614
03:04:32.547 --> 03:04:33.613
<v Queesha Light>Councilor Smith.

1615
03:04:35.165 --> 03:04:36.234
<v Michael Bonacore>I'm not sure.

1616
03:04:36.443 --> 03:04:48.606
<v Michael Bonacore>I mean, I think there is analysis that would need to be done to really dig into that because there are a number of factors that influence those issues.

1617
03:04:49.850 --> 03:04:58.226
<v Michael Bonacore>For example, someone referenced the referral process to fill vacancies.

1618
03:04:58.290 --> 03:05:08.370
<v Michael Bonacore>So in some cases, we and other providers in the community have agreements that folks get referred into our housing.

1619
03:05:08.498 --> 03:05:15.766
<v Michael Bonacore>And sometimes those folks may have significant services needs and they have services that come with them.

1620
03:05:16.200 --> 03:05:20.193
<v Michael Bonacore>And sometimes they have significant services needs and those services don't come with them.

1621
03:05:21.477 --> 03:05:36.132
<v Michael Bonacore>And there's a, you know, so there's a who's sort of like walking in off the street and applying and also, like, what are the processes that we have to help folks move from homelessness into housing?

1622
03:05:37.352 --> 03:05:47.191
<v Michael Bonacore>What are the considerations we're giving to what properties and what, you know, sort of like design and amenities and service supports are there?

1623
03:05:48.240 --> 03:05:55.327
<v Michael Bonacore>So I don't think it's necessarily as black and white as just the screening criteria, although it is a factor.

1624
03:05:55.376 --> 03:05:55.618
<v Mitch Green>Second.

1625
03:05:56.063 --> 03:05:57.495
<v Dan Ryan>You did loosen it in 2022.

1626
03:05:58.012 --> 03:05:58.542
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry?

1627
03:05:58.719 --> 03:06:00.426
<v Dan Ryan>You loosened the criteria.

1628
03:06:00.475 --> 03:06:01.779
<v Michael Bonacore>We did change the screening criteria.

1629
03:06:01.860 --> 03:06:05.599
<v Dan Ryan>Have you had serious conversations about considering changing it again?

1630
03:06:05.647 --> 03:06:07.554
<v Michael Bonacore>We are having conversations about that, yes.

1631
03:06:08.075 --> 03:06:09.623
<v Michael Bonacore>And again, thank you.

1632
03:06:10.031 --> 03:06:19.708
<v Michael Bonacore>If in the City of Portland, if we were to make changes, the default is the city's standard for screening criteria, for which we're not very far off.

1633
03:06:19.885 --> 03:06:27.864
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, I'm glad that you're considering that, because I think the reporting and what I've heard suggests that you need to.

1634
03:06:28.270 --> 03:06:35.391
<v Dan Ryan>And where are you in that process of reconsidering that, those decisions in 2022?

1635
03:06:36.933 --> 03:06:42.018
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, we are in the process of analyzing it.

1636
03:06:42.195 --> 03:06:42.518
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1637
03:06:42.664 --> 03:06:43.534
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1638
03:06:43.793 --> 03:06:47.193
<v Dan Ryan>I think there's 2 very broad— we all know there's 100 people, they're all different.

1639
03:06:47.726 --> 03:06:54.174
<v Dan Ryan>But there's those who are just chronically need the assistance and elderlies on fixed income.

1640
03:06:54.302 --> 03:07:03.254
<v Dan Ryan>Those are where I've been hearing from the most who don't feel safe in their units and those who are differently abled and need long-term stability as well.

1641
03:07:04.007 --> 03:07:20.878
<v Dan Ryan>The other one are those that we are many times are people who are economically disadvantaged temporarily or they've been chronically homeless and they have, they've been suffering for Some time, and I'm looking at you, Sky, because you understand this audience very well, in the SafeRest Villages and the task sites.

1642
03:07:21.022 --> 03:07:29.167
<v Dan Ryan>The whole idea of those was to provide a transition from chronic homelessness to get some stability when it comes to recovery, to get into the workforce.

1643
03:07:29.489 --> 03:07:42.484
<v Dan Ryan>I was hoping they would earn units in places such as Home Forward if they're actually hooked into those services, so they come into the units and they can be a part of that community and they can be added those are the two types.

1644
03:07:42.564 --> 03:07:51.456
<v Dan Ryan>I thought that the testimony we heard from David Swab was so smart because it said, can we please start focusing on outcomes rather than inputs?

1645
03:07:51.936 --> 03:08:03.793
<v Dan Ryan>So when people come into Home Forward that maybe come, say, from a Safe Rest Village, that are currently in rehab, that are in workforce, what do you see as success for them?

1646
03:08:04.514 --> 03:08:22.043
<v Dan Ryan>In other words, what David, I think, was getting at is having them stay there forever wouldn't be It would be for them to continue to keep improving their stability and get their life into a place and have enough agency to have their own apartment someday and not needing to take the public subsidies.

1647
03:08:22.718 --> 03:08:26.753
<v Dan Ryan>Are you talking as a board, as leadership, about outcomes?

1648
03:08:28.265 --> 03:08:28.864
<v Dan Ryan>We are, yes.

1649
03:08:29.801 --> 03:08:42.932
<v Dan Ryan>When will we be able to see that as a council so we could see that type of those reports and that you're really focused on that type of strategic thinking as an organization?

1650
03:08:44.153 --> 03:08:48.213
<v Dan Ryan>And will we have that accountability at the Housing Bureau with all of our public housing?

1651
03:08:51.354 --> 03:08:56.253
<v Michael Bonacore>Yeah, I mean, there's a lot of information that we can provide and report on.

1652
03:08:56.771 --> 03:09:14.609
<v Dan Ryan>And so, you know, if there's something in particular that you all I want us to start seeing outcomes that show that how many people successfully move out of Home Forward because of their success.

1653
03:09:14.771 --> 03:09:20.593
<v Dan Ryan>I want to see those that moved in and are still stable 3 years later.

1654
03:09:20.837 --> 03:09:30.449
<v Dan Ryan>There's so many reports of people going in and out, and then that adds to this embarrassing vacancy rate that we currently have that's unacceptable.

1655
03:09:30.962 --> 03:09:47.862
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think that I couldn't really digest some of the legalese that we received prior to this meeting, but I think we all are just wanting to have more answers to such questions and start to see that we have some new, fresh accountability-type thinking.

1656
03:09:48.617 --> 03:09:53.158
<v Dan Ryan>I think social housing sounds great, but if we can't figure out how to run the current public housing system, Thank you.

1657
03:09:54.825 --> 03:09:59.858
<v Dan Ryan>The current public housing that we have needs a major, major improvement.

1658
03:10:00.326 --> 03:10:12.023
<v Dan Ryan>And if we don't start to see that soon, how are we going to start investing in social housing when we can't figure out current public housing that our city and our county have been working with the providers for some time?

1659
03:10:12.298 --> 03:10:24.305
<v Michael Bonacore>Well, I do think it is important to clarify, Councilor, that public housing is, and other affordable housing providers are not simply housing folks who have low incomes anymore.

1660
03:10:25.541 --> 03:10:30.710
<v Michael Bonacore>It is the backstop of a behavioral health system that is almost nonexistent.

1661
03:10:31.176 --> 03:10:33.601
<v Michael Bonacore>And public housing will never succeed by itself.

1662
03:10:33.906 --> 03:10:34.917
<v Dan Ryan>That's why it's a system.

1663
03:10:35.110 --> 03:10:36.442
<v Dan Ryan>And that's a longer conversation.

1664
03:10:36.539 --> 03:10:36.667
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

1665
03:10:36.957 --> 03:10:37.262
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1666
03:10:37.422 --> 03:10:42.719
<v Dan Ryan>And I think today we're just trying to get at what is Home Forward doing to clean things up?

1667
03:10:42.816 --> 03:10:47.905
<v Dan Ryan>And I appreciate your vulnerability about the report that we just read about this afternoon.

1668
03:10:48.032 --> 03:10:49.683
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks for getting in there and noticing.

1669
03:10:49.813 --> 03:10:54.140
<v Dan Ryan>I'm sure you're discovering how many shoes are dropping, and I've been in your shoes before.

1670
03:10:54.204 --> 03:10:55.150
<v Dan Ryan>That's difficult.

1671
03:10:55.711 --> 03:11:06.756
<v Dan Ryan>But this is just, I think, a taste, Chair, of what we need to have when it comes to dialogue with our system, when it comes to our system of affordable housing and public housing.

1672
03:11:07.270 --> 03:11:12.944
<v Dan Ryan>And I think we wasted a lot of time getting to this meeting, so I'm glad that we're here today.

1673
03:11:13.349 --> 03:11:14.060
<v Dan Ryan>And I appreciate it.

1674
03:11:14.174 --> 03:11:17.700
<v Dan Ryan>I know that we're over time and we have a night meeting that starts at 6 o'clock.

1675
03:11:17.747 --> 03:11:20.836
<v Dan Ryan>So I have people staring at me because I'm keeping them from dinner.

1676
03:11:21.353 --> 03:11:21.612
<v Dan Ryan>Anyway, thank you.

1677
03:11:21.677 --> 03:11:22.260
<v Michael Bonacore>Thank you, Councilor.

1678
03:11:24.082 --> 03:11:25.020
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1679
03:11:25.198 --> 03:11:25.747
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm—.

1680
03:11:26.183 --> 03:11:27.817
<v Sameer Kanal>I know there's others who haven't had a chance to speak.

1681
03:11:27.882 --> 03:11:32.395
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll make sure when we continue this item in a moment that people are prioritized when we bring this back.

1682
03:11:32.870 --> 03:11:38.449
<v Sameer Kanal>One of the key things about our committee is often we're taking on big issues and have to accept non-closure.

1683
03:11:39.269 --> 03:11:41.818
<v Sameer Kanal>As we work through this, I appreciate everybody being here.

1684
03:11:42.980 --> 03:11:48.307
<v Sameer Kanal>I certainly have a lot to say myself about this and my experience going to Louisa Flowers as well, and I'm looking forward to that at a later time.

1685
03:11:48.805 --> 03:11:54.235
<v Sameer Kanal>In the meantime, we do have another meeting of this committee next Thursday morning at 9:30 AM.

1686
03:11:54.509 --> 03:11:59.195
<v Sameer Kanal>That is the 23rd, and we are picking up with a full council meeting tonight at 6:00.

1687
03:11:59.260 --> 03:12:02.093
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that, I will wrap up this meeting at 5:06 PM.

1688
03:12:02.254 --> 03:12:02.513
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1689
03:12:04.197 --> 03:12:04.924
<v Sameer Kanal>And someone could tap the gavel.

