WEBVTT

1
00:05:16.468 --> 00:05:17.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

2
00:05:17.591 --> 00:05:23.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>Before council officially gavels in, we have a pre-gavel, uh, recognition, and I'm turning it over to Councilor Ryan.

3
00:05:23.987 --> 00:05:24.980
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

4
00:05:25.045 --> 00:05:25.894
<v Dan Ryan>Good morning, everyone.

5
00:05:26.552 --> 00:05:35.031
<v Dan Ryan>Um, this morning we have a special privilege of recognizing and celebrating the Portland Fashion Institute and its 16th anniversary.

6
00:05:35.865 --> 00:05:39.295
<v Dan Ryan>I want to welcome Director Sharon Blair and her team to join us.

7
00:05:40.120 --> 00:05:46.132
<v Dan Ryan>If you could, you could just come sit up here in these lovely 5 chairs so you can all be seen and recognized.

8
00:05:47.220 --> 00:05:48.105
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks, Sharon.

9
00:05:48.540 --> 00:05:57.252
<v Dan Ryan>She's joined by Board President Jean Nesbitt, Registrar Candace Friedman, Instructor Amber Roberts, and Gala Manager Kay Strobecker.

10
00:05:57.656 --> 00:06:00.377
<v Dan Ryan>I bet I missed some name, or have there been any changes in the lineup?

11
00:06:01.836 --> 00:06:03.399
<v Sharon Blair>We don't have Jenna here yet, so—.

12
00:06:03.415 --> 00:06:03.790
<v Dan Ryan>Pardon me?

13
00:06:04.132 --> 00:06:05.110
<v Sharon Blair>Jenna is not here.

14
00:06:05.435 --> 00:06:07.490
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, well, Thanks for being here this morning.

15
00:06:07.555 --> 00:06:08.468
<v Dan Ryan>It's really wonderful.

16
00:06:09.062 --> 00:06:22.843
<v Dan Ryan>I have to say, I didn't know much about the Portland Fashion Institute, and I had the pleasure along with fashionista Councilor Smith to be judges at Rossi Farms Red Barn.

17
00:06:23.982 --> 00:06:26.997
<v Dan Ryan>Imagine a fashion show out at Rossi Farms Red Barn.

18
00:06:27.045 --> 00:06:27.526
<v Dan Ryan>It was great.

19
00:06:27.752 --> 00:06:29.564
<v Dan Ryan>And I didn't know what I was doing.

20
00:06:29.612 --> 00:06:35.721
<v Dan Ryan>I was a judge, and I turned to this person who I didn't know very well, Sharon, I could tell she knew what was up.

21
00:06:36.509 --> 00:06:38.555
<v Dan Ryan>And I said, can you give me any pointers?

22
00:06:38.699 --> 00:06:40.197
<v Dan Ryan>And she just used the word construction.

23
00:06:42.119 --> 00:06:46.314
<v Dan Ryan>I didn't really know exactly what that meant, but I started looking at all the, like, hemlines and all the details.

24
00:06:46.442 --> 00:06:47.555
<v Dan Ryan>And anyway, thank you.

25
00:06:47.603 --> 00:06:52.528
<v Dan Ryan>I felt like I, I was a much better judge because of your, um, because of your tutelage.

26
00:06:52.740 --> 00:06:58.641
<v Dan Ryan>And, uh, I also want to say how sometimes in Portland you can kind of starve for fashion.

27
00:06:58.901 --> 00:07:06.242
<v Dan Ryan>You're like, It's almost like an oxymoron that we have such a robust fashion industry in our city.

28
00:07:06.353 --> 00:07:10.617
<v Dan Ryan>And it's because of the ecosystem.

29
00:07:10.682 --> 00:07:17.367
<v Dan Ryan>And all ecosystems, economic ecosystems, have a higher education system that supports them.

30
00:07:18.040 --> 00:07:27.529
<v Dan Ryan>And so it's not lost on me that because we keep winning that Project Runway reality show, that probably a lot of those are your students.

31
00:07:27.593 --> 00:07:28.379
<v Sharon Blair>Yes, they are.

32
00:07:28.475 --> 00:07:28.877
<v Dan Ryan>All right.

33
00:07:28.973 --> 00:07:40.290
<v Dan Ryan>So anyway, just know that Portland, Small market city really punches up in, in one of those areas is fashion and the connection with the, with sport, obviously sportswear.

34
00:07:40.899 --> 00:07:45.692
<v Dan Ryan>And so this is, um, it's important for us to keep lifting these economic ecosystems that make our city special.

35
00:07:46.173 --> 00:07:51.576
<v Dan Ryan>So here's the formal, uh, the formal reading of what we will present to you in a plaque.

36
00:07:51.800 --> 00:08:00.649
<v Dan Ryan>And I look so forward to everyone celebrating you this Saturday when you have your big 16th birthday party at the Portland Art Museum.

37
00:08:01.274 --> 00:08:09.786
<v Dan Ryan>So on behalf of the Portland City Council, I'm so proud to present this formal recognition to the Portland Fashion Institute, PFI.

38
00:08:10.074 --> 00:08:11.853
<v Dan Ryan>Is it okay if I call it PFI the rest of the way?

39
00:08:11.916 --> 00:08:12.045
<v Loretta Smith>Please.

40
00:08:12.317 --> 00:08:12.607
<v Dan Ryan>All right.

41
00:08:13.038 --> 00:08:35.086
<v Dan Ryan>To celebrate 16 years of educational leadership, creative innovation, and community impact in Portland as the only private nonprofit accredited fashion design college in the state of Oregon, And a cornerstone institution in Portland's Hollywood neighborhood, PFI has played an instrumental role in shaping the region's fashion, apparel, and creative industries.

42
00:08:35.782 --> 00:08:45.058
<v Dan Ryan>Since its founding, PFI has taught more than 8,000 students and currently serves over 600 aspiring apparel professionals.

43
00:08:45.658 --> 00:08:50.234
<v Dan Ryan>From day one, it has upheld a powerful commitment to provide a debt-free—.

44
00:08:51.296 --> 00:08:51.745
<v Sameer Kanal>Catch that.

45
00:08:52.097 --> 00:08:55.993
<v Dan Ryan>A debt-free, affordable, and accessible education.

46
00:08:56.682 --> 00:09:05.980
<v Dan Ryan>As a nonprofit determined to remove financial barriers, PFI has ensured that creativity and opportunity remain within reach for all.

47
00:09:06.524 --> 00:09:15.663
<v Dan Ryan>Portland Fashion Institute faculty, all active professionals in the apparel industry, bring real-world experience into every classroom.

48
00:09:16.144 --> 00:09:23.902
<v Dan Ryan>Their expertise equips students with practical skills, strong career pathways, and the confidence to excel in the evolving industry.

49
00:09:24.559 --> 00:09:35.684
<v Dan Ryan>This commitment to applied hands-on learning reflects core founding values and reinforces the mission of fostering meaningful, lasting economic opportunity.

50
00:09:36.677 --> 00:09:42.096
<v Dan Ryan>PFI fills a vital workforce need for Portland's 41 apparel manufacturers.

51
00:09:43.090 --> 00:09:43.619
<v Dan Ryan>41.

52
00:09:43.796 --> 00:09:44.052
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah.

53
00:09:44.277 --> 00:09:46.248
<v Dan Ryan>And many more across the region.

54
00:09:46.857 --> 00:09:52.836
<v Dan Ryan>PFI's steady growth over the past 16 years demonstrates how deeply you are each fulfilling that mission.

55
00:09:53.109 --> 00:09:58.961
<v Dan Ryan>More than training students, PFI changes lives and helps make fashion dreams come true.

56
00:09:59.907 --> 00:10:02.054
<v Dan Ryan>Congratulations on this significant milestone.

57
00:10:02.327 --> 00:10:11.514
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for your ongoing contributions to Portland's creative economy and for enriching our city through education, innovation, and community engagement.

58
00:10:12.187 --> 00:10:18.760
<v Dan Ryan>The Portland Fashion Institute remains a vital and visionary part of Portland's arts, culture, and apparel ecosystem.

59
00:10:19.947 --> 00:10:25.302
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you all for what you're doing for Portland, for District 2, and for inspiring Apparel professionals.

60
00:10:25.639 --> 00:10:26.940
<v Dan Ryan>You really do inspire us all.

61
00:10:27.421 --> 00:10:35.328
<v Dan Ryan>And again, the upcoming Lumen Essence grad and gala show is this Saturday, July 11th, at the Portland Art Museum.

62
00:10:35.986 --> 00:10:37.895
<v Dan Ryan>It marks your Sweet 16 anniversary.

63
00:10:38.426 --> 00:10:40.927
<v Dan Ryan>I hope that, um, it's a smashing success.

64
00:10:41.618 --> 00:10:45.788
<v Dan Ryan>And Sharon, if you and your team would like to just share a few words, we'd love to hear from you at this time.

65
00:10:46.591 --> 00:10:48.003
<v Sharon Blair>Thank you so much, Councilor Ryan.

66
00:10:48.115 --> 00:10:51.530
<v Sharon Blair>So nice of you to honor us with this Thank you, Mayor, for that proclamation.

67
00:10:52.124 --> 00:11:01.437
<v Sharon Blair>Yeah, I think you hit all the highlights there, that we're proud to be the bulwark, the catalyst for driving people into a new career.

68
00:11:01.501 --> 00:11:14.166
<v Sharon Blair>We have so many people who already have a bachelor's degree elsewhere but decided that they wanted to live a more creative life, and we're the ones, because of our great staff, who are able to do that for them.

69
00:11:14.966 --> 00:11:28.130
<v Sharon Blair>We've had nearly 100% graduation and placement rate, and that's because of our partners on the board, our board, who come from Adidas, Nike, Columbia Sportswear, Pendleton.

70
00:11:29.126 --> 00:11:37.210
<v Sharon Blair>They are quite anxious to get new talent, and they know that lives here in this creative city of Portland.

71
00:11:37.804 --> 00:11:48.085
<v Sharon Blair>You hit on a couple of our key points, that we want to give people real skills so they can get real jobs, and we want to do that by giving them a debt-free education.

72
00:11:49.188 --> 00:12:02.857
<v Sharon Blair>In the meanwhile, because we have people who are involved, who are currently working in the apparel industry, who are happy to share what they know, we're able to offer classes not only for careers but, what we say, for fun.

73
00:12:03.451 --> 00:12:09.803
<v Sharon Blair>So we're able to do this for children clear up to— from 8 to 80, that's what we like to say.

74
00:12:10.525 --> 00:12:16.028
<v Sharon Blair>So thank you very much for having us here today and for celebrating this milestone for us.

75
00:12:16.284 --> 00:12:17.278
<v Sharon Blair>We hope to have many more.

76
00:12:18.129 --> 00:12:19.059
<v Dan Ryan>Well, you're so welcome.

77
00:12:19.316 --> 00:12:30.606
<v Dan Ryan>And I think when you hear words like debt-free and 100% placement after graduation, those are amazing data points for you to shout out to everyone who's listening.

78
00:12:31.039 --> 00:12:44.239
<v Dan Ryan>And again, when you list off the different places where they've been getting jobs, whether it's Adidas, Nike, Columbia Sportswear, Pendleton, it's a reminder that our sportswear ecosystem is a really big part of our economy in Portland.

79
00:12:44.591 --> 00:12:50.226
<v Dan Ryan>And so it's so— we're so grateful that we have the Portland Fashion Institute to build that ecosystem.

80
00:12:50.452 --> 00:12:51.322
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you so much.

81
00:12:51.756 --> 00:12:52.770
<v Sharon Blair>No, you're the only one.

82
00:12:52.835 --> 00:12:57.635
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks for allowing me to have this time with this important institution that needs to be amplified.

83
00:12:58.158 --> 00:12:58.730
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks so much.

84
00:13:00.136 --> 00:13:01.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for being here, everybody.

85
00:13:01.510 --> 00:13:02.142
<v Unidentified speaker>Congratulations.

86
00:13:02.336 --> 00:13:06.283
<v Dan Ryan>Let me give them a— we don't, we don't clap in here, right, Council President?

87
00:13:06.379 --> 00:13:08.336
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll suspend the rules and give a round of applause.

88
00:13:08.400 --> 00:13:09.177
<v Dan Ryan>Let's give a round of applause.

89
00:13:12.369 --> 00:13:15.120
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for your leadership.

90
00:13:15.591 --> 00:13:16.221
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

91
00:13:16.659 --> 00:13:20.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>And with that, I am officially calling this meeting of the Portland City Council to order.

92
00:13:21.750 --> 00:13:22.472
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, could we please call the roll?

93
00:13:22.826 --> 00:13:23.438
<v Keelan McClymont>Good morning.

94
00:13:23.856 --> 00:13:24.340
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

95
00:13:25.802 --> 00:13:26.269
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo.

96
00:13:27.557 --> 00:13:27.942
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

97
00:13:29.408 --> 00:13:29.506
<v Steve Novick>Here.

98
00:13:29.653 --> 00:13:30.075
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

99
00:13:31.130 --> 00:13:31.828
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

100
00:13:32.818 --> 00:13:33.078
<v Mitch Green>Here.

101
00:13:33.419 --> 00:13:33.875
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

102
00:13:34.134 --> 00:13:34.264
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

103
00:13:36.376 --> 00:13:39.091
<v Candace Avalos>Present virtually.

104
00:13:40.024 --> 00:13:40.378
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

105
00:13:41.197 --> 00:13:41.485
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

106
00:13:43.284 --> 00:13:43.558
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

107
00:13:43.943 --> 00:13:44.394
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

108
00:13:44.667 --> 00:13:44.844
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

109
00:13:45.907 --> 00:13:46.038
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

110
00:13:46.102 --> 00:13:46.217
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

111
00:13:46.447 --> 00:13:46.741
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

112
00:13:47.085 --> 00:13:47.216
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

113
00:13:47.658 --> 00:13:49.654
<v Jamie Dunphy>And can we please read the rules of decorum for the chamber?

114
00:13:51.371 --> 00:13:51.581
<v Robert Taylor>Yes.

115
00:13:52.015 --> 00:13:52.629
<v Robert Taylor>Good morning.

116
00:13:53.207 --> 00:13:53.466
<v Claire Adamsick>Good morning.

117
00:13:54.094 --> 00:13:55.399
<v Robert Taylor>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

118
00:13:55.639 --> 00:14:01.400
<v Robert Taylor>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

119
00:14:04.653 --> 00:14:07.913
<v Robert Taylor>Information on engaging with the council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

120
00:14:08.427 --> 00:14:10.226
<v Robert Taylor>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes.

121
00:14:11.062 --> 00:14:15.014
<v Robert Taylor>Unless the presiding officer states otherwise, your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

122
00:14:15.254 --> 00:14:17.038
<v Robert Taylor>The presiding officer preserves order.

123
00:14:17.118 --> 00:14:24.538
<v Robert Taylor>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

124
00:14:25.278 --> 00:14:27.350
<v Robert Taylor>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

125
00:14:27.446 --> 00:14:29.759
<v Robert Taylor>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

126
00:14:29.951 --> 00:14:32.871
<v Robert Taylor>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

127
00:14:33.562 --> 00:14:36.417
<v Robert Taylor>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

128
00:14:37.091 --> 00:14:39.384
<v Robert Taylor>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

129
00:14:39.577 --> 00:14:41.471
<v Robert Taylor>When testifying, state your name for the record.

130
00:14:41.519 --> 00:14:42.914
<v Robert Taylor>Your address is not necessary.

131
00:14:43.268 --> 00:14:45.754
<v Robert Taylor>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

132
00:14:46.539 --> 00:14:49.764
<v Robert Taylor>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

133
00:14:49.990 --> 00:14:50.230
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

134
00:14:50.871 --> 00:14:51.962
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, colleagues.

135
00:14:52.010 --> 00:14:54.754
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our first item on the agenda is the approval of the agenda.

136
00:14:54.802 --> 00:14:59.519
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any requests to amend the agenda, reorder items, or reschedule an item to a future meeting date?

137
00:15:00.720 --> 00:15:06.826
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one moving their head in any sort of excited way, do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

138
00:15:08.200 --> 00:15:09.375
<v Jamie Dunphy>The agenda is approved.

139
00:15:09.847 --> 00:15:11.138
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, could we please move to public communications?

140
00:15:12.340 --> 00:15:14.186
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Micah Goldstein.

141
00:15:17.139 --> 00:15:18.157
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome to come on up.

142
00:15:18.206 --> 00:15:19.934
<v Jamie Dunphy>You, uh, please introduce yourself for the record.

143
00:15:19.999 --> 00:15:22.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're welcome to share your pronouns, and you have 3 minutes.

144
00:15:22.326 --> 00:15:24.556
<v Micah Goldstein>I am Micah Goldstein from District 3.

145
00:15:25.153 --> 00:15:26.123
<v Dan Ryan>Um, That's about it.

146
00:15:26.702 --> 00:15:27.201
<v Keelan McClymont>Great, come on.

147
00:15:28.070 --> 00:15:29.341
<v Micah Goldstein>Uh, should I sit, stand?

148
00:15:29.437 --> 00:15:30.836
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sit, uh, sit so the mics can hear you.

149
00:15:30.902 --> 00:15:31.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, okay.

150
00:15:33.904 --> 00:15:40.158
<v Micah Goldstein>My first neighborhood in Portland was a dumping ground for stolen cars and the site of a shootout where police found 140 shell casings.

151
00:15:40.600 --> 00:15:44.129
<v Micah Goldstein>My security cameras regularly captured the sound and one time the flash of gunfire.

152
00:15:44.599 --> 00:15:48.240
<v Micah Goldstein>Luckily, my family was never harmed, but the city has done nothing to address that gun violence.

153
00:15:48.726 --> 00:15:52.802
<v Micah Goldstein>Now I'm near 82nd, near the block with the highest recorded gun violence in the city.

154
00:15:53.317 --> 00:16:00.932
<v Micah Goldstein>At least the city added speeding cameras to ticket all those cars with no plates, But they don't ticket speeding bullets and they don't help the young women and children being trafficked on those blocks nearby.

155
00:16:02.009 --> 00:16:03.615
<v Micah Goldstein>Does it sound like I'm describing things police fix?

156
00:16:04.097 --> 00:16:05.046
<v Micah Goldstein>Police don't stop crime.

157
00:16:05.158 --> 00:16:06.250
<v Micah Goldstein>Police don't stop shootings.

158
00:16:06.363 --> 00:16:10.684
<v Micah Goldstein>Police are reactive and only after a minimum of 20 minutes sometimes respond to crimes that have already happened.

159
00:16:11.182 --> 00:16:13.480
<v Micah Goldstein>This is why so many people in this country, in the city, have guns.

160
00:16:13.899 --> 00:16:17.658
<v Micah Goldstein>Yes, people in this left-leaning city have guns, some of them lawfully, others not so much.

161
00:16:17.947 --> 00:16:18.702
<v Micah Goldstein>Do you know the difference?

162
00:16:19.442 --> 00:16:22.109
<v Micah Goldstein>Or do you assume that everybody with a gun is just a crook who hasn't been caught?

163
00:16:22.157 --> 00:16:22.606
<v Micah Goldstein>I think that's a good question.

164
00:16:23.152 --> 00:16:29.741
<v Micah Goldstein>Portland being left-leaning has left-leaning gun owners, and tens of thousands of us in Multnomah County alone have carry permits.

165
00:16:29.885 --> 00:16:31.798
<v Micah Goldstein>So, you know, we're not all moonbat right-wingers.

166
00:16:32.460 --> 00:16:35.787
<v Micah Goldstein>Most of— more of us than you think are politically aligned with you, but we don't feel safe.

167
00:16:36.110 --> 00:16:38.225
<v Micah Goldstein>Nothing you've done or proposing to do changes that.

168
00:16:38.774 --> 00:16:41.344
<v Micah Goldstein>The council has said gun violence poses a safety risk in all spaces.

169
00:16:41.393 --> 00:16:42.399
<v Micah Goldstein>Your word, all spaces.

170
00:16:43.471 --> 00:16:43.763
<v Micah Goldstein>All spaces.

171
00:16:43.812 --> 00:16:44.168
<v Micah Goldstein>What is this?

172
00:16:44.298 --> 00:16:44.835
<v Micah Goldstein>Are we in a space?

173
00:16:45.354 --> 00:16:45.874
<v Micah Goldstein>Do you feel safe?

174
00:16:46.572 --> 00:16:48.682
<v Micah Goldstein>I feel safer outside the space where I can still carry.

175
00:16:49.250 --> 00:16:52.424
<v Micah Goldstein>The council named itself— itself named political violence as a concern.

176
00:16:52.474 --> 00:16:52.554
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

177
00:16:53.422 --> 00:17:01.418
<v Micah Goldstein>Well, in the past decade, with the rise of fascism in this country, LGBTQ, religious, ethnic, and racial minorities, we've increasingly chosen to exercise our right to bear arms.

178
00:17:01.530 --> 00:17:05.849
<v Micah Goldstein>We've made informed, educated decisions, gone through legal processes, trained, and jumped through all the hoops.

179
00:17:06.171 --> 00:17:09.093
<v Micah Goldstein>You're not restricting the people you think you are with this or any gun ordinance.

180
00:17:09.462 --> 00:17:12.898
<v Micah Goldstein>Gun control is historically classist, racist, and disproportionately affects minorities.

181
00:17:13.557 --> 00:17:18.037
<v Micah Goldstein>Most gun crimes are committed with stolen guns, and statistically, most guns are stolen from vehicles.

182
00:17:18.501 --> 00:17:23.978
<v Micah Goldstein>The ordinance you are proposing will result in more guns stashed in more cars, And therefore stolen from cars.

183
00:17:24.330 --> 00:17:25.631
<v Micah Goldstein>Do you want more violent gun crime?

184
00:17:25.680 --> 00:17:27.541
<v Micah Goldstein>Because that's how you get more violent gun crime.

185
00:17:27.846 --> 00:17:32.102
<v Micah Goldstein>You're proposing to criminalize behavior that was never a problem and make the most vulnerable among us less safe.

186
00:17:32.519 --> 00:17:35.023
<v Micah Goldstein>The ordinance will waste taxpayer money when it's litigated.

187
00:17:35.104 --> 00:17:36.532
<v Micah Goldstein>I promise you it will be litigated.

188
00:17:36.934 --> 00:17:42.280
<v Micah Goldstein>But if you gotta tilt at windmills, maybe include mandatory provisions for gun lockers in the spaces you wanna prohibit guns from.

189
00:17:42.714 --> 00:17:44.738
<v Micah Goldstein>Look at how Kaiser Permanente does this for an example.

190
00:17:44.801 --> 00:17:46.295
<v Micah Goldstein>Please educate yourselves.

191
00:17:46.729 --> 00:17:47.531
<v Micah Goldstein>Come to the range.

192
00:17:48.094 --> 00:17:52.990
<v Micah Goldstein>Engage family, coworkers, friends, About guns, learn gun safety and what guns are really about.

193
00:17:53.086 --> 00:17:59.653
<v Micah Goldstein>If you don't have those people in your life, if you've never taken a gun class, if you've never fired a gun, what are you even doing trying to make up rules about things you know nothing about?

194
00:18:00.071 --> 00:18:05.385
<v Micah Goldstein>A 2021 study directly correlated knowledge and education on the matter of guns with a general distaste for gun control.

195
00:18:06.156 --> 00:18:07.843
<v Micah Goldstein>Please don't legislate your ignorance.

196
00:18:08.147 --> 00:18:09.336
<v Micah Goldstein>Don't be afraid to learn.

197
00:18:10.491 --> 00:18:11.375
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for being here.

198
00:18:16.115 --> 00:18:18.946
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Alex Garcia joining us online.

199
00:18:21.460 --> 00:18:22.385
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Alex.

200
00:18:23.019 --> 00:18:24.141
<v Alex Garcia>Hey, how's it going?

201
00:18:24.662 --> 00:18:26.513
<v Jamie Dunphy>Go ahead and introduce yourself for the record, and you have 3 minutes.

202
00:18:27.736 --> 00:18:28.558
<v Alex Garcia>I'm Alex Garcia.

203
00:18:29.431 --> 00:18:32.951
<v Alex Garcia>Um, so I think we're missing the mark on graffiti and the street takeovers.

204
00:18:33.000 --> 00:18:35.439
<v Alex Garcia>These kids don't have a place to go.

205
00:18:35.503 --> 00:18:37.074
<v Alex Garcia>I grew up here skateboarding.

206
00:18:37.673 --> 00:18:38.989
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, skateboarding was a crime.

207
00:18:39.702 --> 00:18:43.258
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, I've got attacked by police, security guards, everything you could think of.

208
00:18:43.787 --> 00:18:50.240
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, but at some point the parents stood up and started making us places to go so we don't skateboard on your streets.

209
00:18:50.770 --> 00:18:52.039
<v Alex Garcia>It's the same thing with graffiti.

210
00:18:52.152 --> 00:19:01.159
<v Alex Garcia>If you don't make public spaces where kids can be seen and their graffiti could be seen, then they're going to paint anywhere that they want to.

211
00:19:01.304 --> 00:19:02.219
<v Alex Garcia>They want to be seen.

212
00:19:02.347 --> 00:19:04.000
<v Alex Garcia>They want their art to be seen.

213
00:19:04.451 --> 00:19:11.916
<v Alex Garcia>If you don't make their art visible, they will find the places, the overpasses, the places where people could see their art and make it visible.

214
00:19:11.980 --> 00:19:14.807
<v Alex Garcia>Councilor Same thing with street takeovers.

215
00:19:14.871 --> 00:19:25.163
<v Alex Garcia>If you don't make burnout boxes, you don't make places where these kids can, can race on the streets where people could see them, you close down streets, they're going to close the streets down anyway.

216
00:19:25.243 --> 00:19:27.202
<v Alex Garcia>So you might as well close the streets down on your own.

217
00:19:28.358 --> 00:19:29.819
<v Alex Garcia>I mean, use your imagination.

218
00:19:30.045 --> 00:19:31.473
<v Alex Garcia>These kids need a place to go.

219
00:19:31.569 --> 00:19:32.147
<v Alex Garcia>I grew up here.

220
00:19:32.693 --> 00:19:32.934
<v Douglas McLeod>The—.

221
00:19:33.078 --> 00:19:37.527
<v Alex Garcia>We had the Quest, we had, uh, cruising on Broadway until the police shut it down.

222
00:19:37.903 --> 00:19:41.087
<v Alex Garcia>There's a lot of stuff that we used to be able to do that these kids can't do anymore.

223
00:19:42.575 --> 00:19:47.083
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, second of all, no money for MOTA, no bonds, no diverting funds.

224
00:19:47.824 --> 00:19:49.209
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, if you have to leave, leave.

225
00:19:49.354 --> 00:19:50.208
<v Alex Garcia>That costs money too.

226
00:19:50.804 --> 00:19:51.769
<v Alex Garcia>That's not my problem.

227
00:19:51.866 --> 00:19:54.766
<v Alex Garcia>If you don't— if you're a billionaire and you got money, spend it.

228
00:19:54.911 --> 00:19:55.943
<v Alex Garcia>Spend money to make money.

229
00:19:57.012 --> 00:20:03.236
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, we should have police oversight board without the interference of the police union, and they should have criminal prosecution.

230
00:20:03.285 --> 00:20:03.414
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

231
00:20:04.028 --> 00:20:15.720
<v Alex Garcia>We just had a guy on 82nd get attacked by the police, and they said that he broke their ankle when we got a video of the police officer stepping out and falling on the ground like a dummy and breaking his own ankle.

232
00:20:16.298 --> 00:20:18.096
<v Alex Garcia>And they tried to get him for that.

233
00:20:18.289 --> 00:20:19.076
<v Alex Garcia>That's crazy.

234
00:20:20.135 --> 00:20:23.733
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, homelessness— there's no dignity in Dignity Village.

235
00:20:24.712 --> 00:20:27.250
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, make it housing and make housing affordable.

236
00:20:27.845 --> 00:20:30.542
<v Alex Garcia>Uh, house the homeless or just stop talking about it.

237
00:20:30.590 --> 00:20:30.686
<v Alex Garcia>Thank you.

238
00:20:31.376 --> 00:20:41.652
<v Alex Garcia>It's starting to become an, uh, a recurring stupid point that everybody tries to make, and it's not working out.

239
00:20:42.037 --> 00:20:42.614
<v Alex Garcia>House them.

240
00:20:43.095 --> 00:20:44.313
<v Alex Garcia>Give them a place to be.

241
00:20:44.939 --> 00:20:47.711
<v Alex Garcia>We have plenty of places to put people.

242
00:20:48.930 --> 00:20:56.464
<v Alex Garcia>If you don't have the political will and the people don't have the, the want for people to have free housing, then what are we gonna do?

243
00:20:56.560 --> 00:20:59.849
<v Alex Garcia>Councilor I mean, somebody's got to do something at this point.

244
00:21:00.092 --> 00:21:03.304
<v Alex Garcia>It is, it's overrunning our city.

245
00:21:04.046 --> 00:21:04.691
<v Alex Garcia>And what do we do?

246
00:21:04.788 --> 00:21:27.914
<v Alex Garcia>Do we pay to have people be housed, or do we pay to have them on the street and pay to have police come after them and pay to have ambulances come and save them and pay for tents and pay for dignity villages and give nonprofits money that's Scam us and take our money and don't give us services.

247
00:21:29.584 --> 00:21:32.940
<v Alex Garcia>It's starting to become a quagmire.

248
00:21:36.279 --> 00:21:37.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for being here today.

249
00:21:39.920 --> 00:21:46.884
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, next up, next up we have Addie Smith joining us online.

250
00:21:49.981 --> 00:21:51.152
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Addie.

251
00:21:51.424 --> 00:21:52.818
<v Jamie Dunphy>Go ahead and introduce yourself for the record.

252
00:21:54.067 --> 00:21:55.911
<v Candace Avalos>Hello, thanks for having me.

253
00:21:56.007 --> 00:21:57.240
<v Candace Avalos>My name is Addie Smith.

254
00:21:57.432 --> 00:21:59.564
<v Candace Avalos>Today is July 9th, 2026.

255
00:21:59.612 --> 00:22:03.842
<v Candace Avalos>I'm gonna try to wrap this up under 3 minutes, but just give me a little leeway, please.

256
00:22:04.547 --> 00:22:06.919
<v Candace Avalos>I'm speaking before the Portland City Council.

257
00:22:07.528 --> 00:22:12.863
<v Candace Avalos>Home Forward's Board of Commissioners acts as the housing authority for Multnomah County.

258
00:22:13.375 --> 00:22:33.582
<v Candace Avalos>Because the housing authority was originally incorporated by Portland, Gresham— I'm sorry, uh, Portland's recommended appointees are officially appointed by the mayor of Portland and confirmed by the Portland City Council per ORS 456.095 and ORS 456.100.

259
00:22:34.260 --> 00:22:40.997
<v Candace Avalos>The port— the city of Portland will recommend 4 members, the city of Gresham recommends 2 members, and Multnomah County recommends 2 members.

260
00:22:41.451 --> 00:22:53.411
<v Candace Avalos>You must remove and replace Home Forward's active Board of Commissioners Matthew Gephardt, Damian Hall, Jenny Kim, Jesse Ledezma, Brianne Preston, and Gresham City Councilor Kathy Keithley.

261
00:22:54.019 --> 00:22:59.278
<v Candace Avalos>A forensic audit of Home Forward and the Portland Housing Bureau must be conducted immediately.

262
00:22:59.790 --> 00:23:05.258
<v Candace Avalos>Recently, I spoke with the Deputy Director in the City Attorney's— in the City Administrator's Office.

263
00:23:05.962 --> 00:23:10.227
<v Candace Avalos>The Portland Housing Bureau Director Michael Buonocore reports to him.

264
00:23:10.917 --> 00:23:22.622
<v Candace Avalos>Mr. Donald Oliveira informed me that Michael left him scrambling after quitting and providing only 3 days' notice at Portland Housing Bureau to go work at Home Forward.

265
00:23:23.119 --> 00:23:24.580
<v Candace Avalos>What professional does this?

266
00:23:24.965 --> 00:23:32.656
<v Candace Avalos>How is it possible that someone can be respected and trusted who turned his back on his job and didn't leave it in a position to succeed?

267
00:23:32.930 --> 00:23:38.823
<v Candace Avalos>He left a mess at the Portland Housing Bureau, and the director who took his place is only there in an interim capacity.

268
00:23:38.871 --> 00:23:38.967
<v Ben Henson>Thank you.

269
00:23:39.288 --> 00:23:44.752
<v Candace Avalos>Ms. Light, Queesha Light, which means the city administrator intends to bring Michael Buonocore back.

270
00:23:45.682 --> 00:23:59.000
<v Candace Avalos>In the years that he spent at the Portland Housing Bureau, Michael Buonocore could have established SOPs wherein the bureau could have been responsible for disbursing the millions of dollars in funding to vulnerable renters in Portland and Multnomah County.

271
00:23:59.144 --> 00:24:03.134
<v Candace Avalos>He has not established any SOPs to make the Portland Housing Bureau better.

272
00:24:03.311 --> 00:24:09.017
<v Candace Avalos>Michael Buonocore is not fit to lead Home Forward, nor has he been fit to lead Portland Housing Bureau.

273
00:24:09.176 --> 00:24:09.354
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

274
00:24:09.481 --> 00:24:10.619
<v Candace Avalos>He should be terminated.

275
00:24:10.988 --> 00:24:20.105
<v Candace Avalos>His contract should be terminated at Home Forward before any further damage can be done and before he hires someone who will do his and the current board's bidding.

276
00:24:20.603 --> 00:24:27.348
<v Candace Avalos>Also keep in mind that he was hired— he also hired Ivory Matthews and the current staff at Home Forward.

277
00:24:27.814 --> 00:24:31.596
<v Candace Avalos>Why is he being trusted to bring in a new CEO and CFO?

278
00:24:32.540 --> 00:24:35.249
<v Candace Avalos>What's clear is that there is a scandal happening at Home Forward.

279
00:24:36.190 --> 00:24:45.930
<v Candace Avalos>Keep in mind, the Board of Commissioners approved all the networking events the previous CEO, Ivory Matthews, attended.

280
00:24:45.930 --> 00:24:51.230
<v Candace Avalos>Let me also advise you that Ian Davies was responsible for the operations at HomeForward.

281
00:24:51.230 --> 00:25:01.970
<v Candace Avalos>The Chief Operating Officer, or COO, is responsible for overseeing the mid- and long-term operations of HomeForward's real estate portfolio, making strategic recommendations on sales, and overseeing the operations of the company.

282
00:25:01.970 --> 00:25:02.009
<v Doug Wade>Thank you.

283
00:25:02.028 --> 00:25:04.617
<v Candace Avalos>Capital issues, and most importantly, cash flow.

284
00:25:05.266 --> 00:25:13.675
<v Candace Avalos>The COO should analyze property performance to balance financial returns with improving housing stability and the tenant's experience, integrate safety standards—.

285
00:25:13.675 --> 00:25:15.517
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Addie.

286
00:25:15.855 --> 00:25:16.421
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

287
00:25:16.518 --> 00:25:16.807
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry.

288
00:25:17.470 --> 00:25:17.939
<v Candace Avalos>I want you—.

289
00:25:18.940 --> 00:25:19.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

290
00:25:20.644 --> 00:25:23.093
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, next up we have Anne Casper.

291
00:25:25.593 --> 00:25:25.843
<v Sameer Kanal>Welcome.

292
00:25:27.940 --> 00:25:30.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Introduce yourself for the record, and you have 3 minutes.

293
00:25:30.539 --> 00:25:32.119
<v Ann Casper>Good morning, I'm Ann Casper.

294
00:25:32.119 --> 00:25:40.720
<v Ann Casper>I'm a student at the University of Oregon, and virtual reality, augmented reality, and XR— we are so far behind in that compared to other cities, but hopefully we'll catch up.

295
00:25:40.720 --> 00:25:46.259
<v Ann Casper>Um, I'd like to talk to you today, Ann Casper, she/her, about the politics of belonging or disconnect.

296
00:25:46.299 --> 00:25:50.099
<v Ann Casper>And I'd also like to thank you for leading the city in the middle of this mess.

297
00:25:50.099 --> 00:25:51.319
<v Ann Casper>It is a mess.

298
00:25:51.319 --> 00:25:53.099
<v Ann Casper>We're changing systems now.

299
00:25:53.099 --> 00:25:57.380
<v Ann Casper>You've heard of other systems that don't work, and, um, I'm going to tell you about a few about today.

300
00:25:57.380 --> 00:26:03.400
<v Ann Casper>But thank you Thank you again, because it's not an easy time to be here, and we'll make it through because we're Portland.

301
00:26:03.400 --> 00:26:05.259
<v Ann Casper>My family's been here 156 years.

302
00:26:05.259 --> 00:26:06.309
<v Ann Casper>I know we'll make it through.

303
00:26:06.640 --> 00:26:12.319
<v Ann Casper>First of all, I have not had water or sewer at my house for 6 years because I had a house fire.

304
00:26:12.319 --> 00:26:17.859
<v Ann Casper>It went illegal, and I'm asked to pay $400 in fees, uh, for nothing.

305
00:26:17.859 --> 00:26:21.680
<v Ann Casper>I pee in a bucket and I put it in my garden, and I get water.

306
00:26:21.680 --> 00:26:29.299
<v Ann Casper>And now I can't get water because easily in my neighborhood because the Walgreens has closed, um, the Dollar Tree is closed, 4 restaurants have closed.

307
00:26:29.299 --> 00:26:32.863
<v Ann Casper>I would really like to Be careful when you think about Lloyd.

308
00:26:33.118 --> 00:26:37.431
<v Ann Casper>Please save Lloyd because that whole area is going down right now economically.

309
00:26:37.928 --> 00:26:46.248
<v Ann Casper>But in any case, I hope you can work out this, um, snafu with the Water Bureau because why should I be paying, uh, $400 for services I don't receive?

310
00:26:46.584 --> 00:26:49.453
<v Ann Casper>And can I just cut off until I get water restored to my house?

311
00:26:50.270 --> 00:26:52.386
<v Ann Casper>And to cut off water right now would cost me $700.

312
00:26:52.692 --> 00:26:53.509
<v Ann Casper>That doesn't make sense.

313
00:26:53.653 --> 00:26:56.507
<v Ann Casper>I think we can change policies to make sure people can stay in their housing.

314
00:26:57.244 --> 00:26:59.664
<v Ann Casper>I'm on the Ellet Neighbor Association board.

315
00:27:00.130 --> 00:27:01.924
<v Ann Casper>Um, there are about, I think, 18 members.

316
00:27:02.054 --> 00:27:03.673
<v Ann Casper>17 Of them live by Dawson Park.

317
00:27:03.833 --> 00:27:05.516
<v Ann Casper>I'm the one that lives by 7th Avenue.

318
00:27:05.916 --> 00:27:13.145
<v Ann Casper>They actually wrote a letter saying that we on 7th Avenue wanted our, our street blocked down for bikes, which is not true.

319
00:27:13.290 --> 00:27:15.358
<v Ann Casper>There's hundreds of us not very happy about it.

320
00:27:15.920 --> 00:27:17.875
<v Ann Casper>I would like you to look at the neighbor associations.

321
00:27:17.939 --> 00:27:19.926
<v Ann Casper>I've been on them since 1996.

322
00:27:20.423 --> 00:27:22.700
<v Ann Casper>I've never seen such strangeness in them.

323
00:27:22.813 --> 00:27:29.690
<v Ann Casper>Maybe we have to relook how to do them so it's not 18 or 17 versus 1 speaking up for parts of the neighborhood.

324
00:27:30.426 --> 00:27:36.982
<v Ann Casper>Um, again, please save the Lloyd District because we're really worried they don't have the funding yet set to rebuild.

325
00:27:37.559 --> 00:27:38.266
<v Ann Casper>What happens?

326
00:27:38.682 --> 00:27:42.000
<v Ann Casper>You destroy the buildings, you take things down, and they don't get rebuilt.

327
00:27:42.849 --> 00:27:44.003
<v Ann Casper>What happens to my neighborhood?

328
00:27:45.335 --> 00:27:46.457
<v Ann Casper>I'd like you to think about that.

329
00:27:47.178 --> 00:27:51.522
<v Ann Casper>Um, I'd like to invite you— we used to have a thing called Town Hall on Channel 2.

330
00:27:52.228 --> 00:27:54.344
<v Ann Casper>I'm doing a town hall at Open Signal.

331
00:27:54.471 --> 00:28:01.269
<v Ann Casper>I've been producing TV shows for 20 years with the chairs, uh, candidates for the commissioners of Multnomah County.

332
00:28:01.846 --> 00:28:05.517
<v Ann Casper>And I think it's time the city and the county start working together on mental health.

333
00:28:05.644 --> 00:28:05.869
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

334
00:28:06.190 --> 00:28:06.575
<v Claire Adamsick>That's it.

335
00:28:06.750 --> 00:28:07.010
<v Ann Casper>Invite too.

336
00:28:07.060 --> 00:28:07.751
<v Ann Casper>I'd like to see you there.

337
00:28:07.883 --> 00:28:08.525
<v Steve Novick>Thank you very much.

338
00:28:09.462 --> 00:28:10.087
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

339
00:28:12.513 --> 00:28:14.189
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, next up we have Ray Dawn.

340
00:28:20.039 --> 00:28:21.070
<v Keelan McClymont>Ray Dawn.

341
00:28:23.423 --> 00:28:26.500
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, our alternate today is John Hollister.

342
00:28:33.365 --> 00:28:35.098
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, that completes communications.

343
00:28:35.372 --> 00:28:37.573
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you very much everybody for being here.

344
00:28:38.038 --> 00:28:41.315
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our next item on the agenda is our City Administrator's update.

345
00:28:41.780 --> 00:28:42.134
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr.

346
00:28:42.199 --> 00:28:44.077
<v Jamie Dunphy>Administrator, update us.

347
00:28:45.314 --> 00:28:46.904
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you, Council President, councilors.

348
00:28:47.241 --> 00:29:10.751
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, before I dive into the City Administrator's report, I would like to give a brief update on the city's federal response initiatives as it relates to the detention, uh, facility impact The public comment period is currently open to provide feedback on the permanent administrative rule for the detention facility impact fee legislation.

349
00:29:11.266 --> 00:29:17.415
<v Raymond C. Lee>The public comment period will end at the end of this month on July the 26th.

350
00:29:18.153 --> 00:29:26.489
<v Raymond C. Lee>As a reminder, these rules address the detention facility impact fee legislation that council adopted in December.

351
00:29:27.951 --> 00:29:33.172
<v Raymond C. Lee>We have had a temporary rule in place since February, uh, the 27th.

352
00:29:33.750 --> 00:29:46.038
<v Raymond C. Lee>The temporary rule also allows the city to take enforcement action relating to the use of chemical munitions at detention facilities while a permanent rule is being developed.

353
00:29:46.520 --> 00:29:57.035
<v Raymond C. Lee>It establishes an enforcement framework, including a citation process, fine schedule, service requirements, and appeal procedures.

354
00:29:57.950 --> 00:30:05.538
<v Raymond C. Lee>Under city code, that temporary rule can only be in place for 6 months, and it is set to expire in late August.

355
00:30:06.710 --> 00:30:24.525
<v Raymond C. Lee>Members of the public can view the draft rule and learn how to provide comments by visiting Portland's permitting and development website at portland.gov/ the public notice is listed under recent news.

356
00:30:25.358 --> 00:30:35.028
<v Raymond C. Lee>As it pertains to the ICE facility land use decision appeal update, to date, the building owner has filed 5 writs of review to the county circuit court.

357
00:30:35.765 --> 00:30:46.492
<v Raymond C. Lee>These writs challenge the hearings officer's procedures and seek to stop the hearing officers, uh, from issuing a decision on the notice of the violations at the ICE facility.

358
00:30:47.166 --> 00:30:53.951
<v Raymond C. Lee>The city is seeking to dismiss these writs so the hearing officer can issue a decision.

359
00:30:54.931 --> 00:31:04.940
<v Raymond C. Lee>A hearing is set for Friday, uh, this week, uh, July 10th, at the County Circuit Court on the motions to dismiss filed by the city.

360
00:31:06.256 --> 00:31:14.344
<v Raymond C. Lee>If the motions to dismiss are granted, then we can expect the hearing officer to issue a decision on the notice of violation.

361
00:31:15.753 --> 00:31:24.814
<v Raymond C. Lee>If the motions to dismiss are denied, the city will continue to challenge the writ in circuit court with a follow-up hearing on August the 14th.

362
00:31:26.767 --> 00:31:41.288
<v Raymond C. Lee>As it relates to the report itself, uh, I'm happy, uh, to share that the city manager report to council for this, uh, new fiscal year— the theme of the report this month is community, the folks we work with and serve every day.

363
00:31:42.032 --> 00:31:45.883
<v Raymond C. Lee>A few items I wanted to highlight in this month's report.

364
00:31:46.347 --> 00:31:58.713
<v Raymond C. Lee>There are updates about several new murals across the city, some developed in partnership with PMO and others with the Office of Arts and Culture in partnership with people across the city.

365
00:31:59.757 --> 00:32:09.605
<v Raymond C. Lee>The city and WISE PDX will be hosting an event at Pacific Northwest Climate— for Pacific Northwest Climate Week on July 21st.

366
00:32:09.862 --> 00:32:25.164
<v Raymond C. Lee>The proposed draft of the Housing Bonus Alignment Project is available for public review through July the 28th and will be considered by the Planning Commission during a hearing on July the 28th.

367
00:32:25.726 --> 00:32:42.400
<v Raymond C. Lee>The Portland Police Bureau helped develop and launch the Portland Framework: Guidance for Dialogue Policing in the United States, a new national resource aimed at improving communication, public trust and legitimacy during demonstrations and other public events.

368
00:32:43.522 --> 00:32:58.803
<v Raymond C. Lee>The Trust for Public, uh, Lands released an annual, uh, Park Score Index for 2026 ranking Portland's park system 9th nationally among the 100 most populated cities in United States.

369
00:32:59.412 --> 00:33:05.473
<v Raymond C. Lee>This is the 4th year in a row that Portland's park system has been amongst the top 10 nationally.

370
00:33:06.932 --> 00:33:13.471
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'll also note that Appendix A has been updated with the budget notes passed as part of the fiscal year's budget.

371
00:33:14.144 --> 00:33:27.684
<v Raymond C. Lee>The spreadsheet shows the note title, sponsors and co-sponsors, service area, primary contact for implementation, and the timeline that was noted in the note itself.

372
00:33:27.732 --> 00:33:27.845
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

373
00:33:28.584 --> 00:33:35.440
<v Raymond C. Lee>The shaded boxes show when we anticipate the work to take place, and the status shows the current status as of today.

374
00:33:36.130 --> 00:33:42.826
<v Raymond C. Lee>You'll see that many of them are still to be determined as we are very newly into this new fiscal year.

375
00:33:43.500 --> 00:33:48.285
<v Raymond C. Lee>We'll continue to provide updates in this format throughout the course of the year.

376
00:33:49.201 --> 00:34:08.086
<v Raymond C. Lee>Lastly, and you'll see this in shoutouts throughout the report, I want to take a moment to acknowledge the many staff and leaders who contributed to the annual budget process, both during the last few weeks, in the months, and throughout the course of the year.

377
00:34:08.826 --> 00:34:14.719
<v Raymond C. Lee>I also want to acknowledge that some people's positions were not reflected in the adopted budget.

378
00:34:15.153 --> 00:34:25.730
<v Raymond C. Lee>While conversations are ongoing, I wanted to take a moment to thank staff, for their good work and acknowledge their many contributions to the city.

379
00:34:26.458 --> 00:34:33.880
<v Raymond C. Lee>The work that you do every day means a lot to the Portlanders and the people that we serve on a daily basis.

380
00:34:34.619 --> 00:34:45.192
<v Raymond C. Lee>I just want to thank everyone from the bottom of my heart, all our staff, all the council staff that I know have been working hard as we've come through this budget year, and we have a little rest period for a month.

381
00:34:45.663 --> 00:34:48.681
<v Raymond C. Lee>And then we'll be right back in the swing of things again.

382
00:34:49.050 --> 00:34:52.326
<v Raymond C. Lee>So just thank you and looking forward to the work that we'll be doing together.

383
00:34:53.047 --> 00:34:54.092
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mr. City Administrator.

384
00:34:54.413 --> 00:34:54.894
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

385
00:34:55.762 --> 00:34:56.981
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

386
00:34:57.126 --> 00:34:58.202
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you, Mr. Lee.

387
00:34:58.570 --> 00:35:02.472
<v Mitch Green>Uh, appreciate the update on the detention facility impact fee rulemaking process.

388
00:35:02.826 --> 00:35:09.295
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I, I want to acknowledge a lot of work went into that across all the bureaus that are impacted on that.

389
00:35:09.425 --> 00:35:16.916
<v Mitch Green>So I appreciate the lift that kind of went into scrambling for the temporary rule and also recognizing that we need We needed to get out there and put something permanent in place.

390
00:35:17.867 --> 00:35:23.221
<v Mitch Green>My office and Councilor Morillo's office were kind of working behind the scenes supporting that because we were sponsoring that legislation.

391
00:35:23.268 --> 00:35:28.027
<v Mitch Green>So really important that we share that now for the public so they can weigh in on that administrative rulemaking.

392
00:35:28.690 --> 00:35:32.284
<v Mitch Green>So thanks for letting that sort of listing where to find it, letting those links.

393
00:35:32.364 --> 00:35:36.155
<v Mitch Green>We'll be sharing that out as well to make sure folks see that as an opportunity.

394
00:35:37.909 --> 00:35:39.827
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I think that's all I wanted to note.

395
00:35:39.907 --> 00:35:41.355
<v Mitch Green>I just wanted to provide some gratitude.

396
00:35:41.436 --> 00:35:41.565
<v Matt Henderson>Thanks.

397
00:35:41.614 --> 00:35:41.744
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

398
00:35:42.021 --> 00:35:42.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

399
00:35:42.985 --> 00:35:43.516
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

400
00:35:44.351 --> 00:35:46.023
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

401
00:35:46.199 --> 00:35:46.987
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Administrator Lee.

402
00:35:47.083 --> 00:35:50.474
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, I had a couple, um, comments and then a couple questions as well.

403
00:35:50.539 --> 00:35:55.327
<v Sameer Kanal>So I, I really appreciate the shout out to PBEM and PSR for their work during the June heat dome.

404
00:35:55.905 --> 00:36:04.695
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, for those who haven't read the report, uh, or haven't seen it, there is a survey going on, especially for people in Elliott and Portsmouth, being run, um, out of Safe Blocks that you should take.

405
00:36:04.744 --> 00:36:06.543
<v Sameer Kanal>And you can follow, uh, their social media.

406
00:36:06.590 --> 00:36:07.443
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll be posting it as well.

407
00:36:07.735 --> 00:36:10.237
<v Sameer Kanal>To talk about how to make— improve those neighborhoods.

408
00:36:11.619 --> 00:36:13.103
<v Sameer Kanal>There was a couple things in there.

409
00:36:13.233 --> 00:36:24.452
<v Sameer Kanal>Shout out to the folks who completed the CVI certificate program and to the Portland Parks Bureau for getting back into the top 10 nationally in the ranking for the— from the Trust for Public Land, as you mentioned.

410
00:36:25.277 --> 00:36:31.324
<v Sameer Kanal>We're gonna have a Vision Zero report update in the Committee of the Whole later this month, July 22nd, I wanna say.

411
00:36:31.476 --> 00:36:32.141
<v Ben Henson>Yes.

412
00:36:33.405 --> 00:36:44.056
<v Sameer Kanal>It's gonna be an interesting topic in general, but I did wanna point out our year-to-date numbers have gone up for the first time in several years in terms of number of traffic deaths.

413
00:36:45.050 --> 00:36:50.246
<v Sameer Kanal>Don't yet have the district-by-district information on that, but I know that last year District 2 was the highest.

414
00:36:50.407 --> 00:36:55.251
<v Sameer Kanal>I imagine it's the same because we haven't made those transformational investments yet that we've been seeking.

415
00:36:55.460 --> 00:36:57.864
<v Sameer Kanal>But I did wanna just flag that is coming up.

416
00:36:58.443 --> 00:37:01.954
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate including the fiscal year '26-'27 budget notes.

417
00:37:02.608 --> 00:37:07.061
<v Sameer Kanal>In the Appendix A, but I had budget notes that weren't completed from the previous year.

418
00:37:07.545 --> 00:37:16.958
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I'd ask that those be included until they are completed so that we're still able to track those from the previous fiscal year.

419
00:37:17.829 --> 00:37:24.630
<v Sameer Kanal>And I've been bringing them up every month on this, and a couple of them were marked as incomplete, but a couple were also marked as complete erroneously.

420
00:37:24.697 --> 00:37:27.161
<v Sameer Kanal>So I can follow up with the specific ones if that's helpful.

421
00:37:27.226 --> 00:37:27.324
<v Jeff Fish>Thank you.

422
00:37:28.289 --> 00:37:30.201
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, questions.

423
00:37:30.458 --> 00:37:42.092
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the murals you mentioned across the city, and I think that's the case for the Arts and Culture, uh, Office, but PMO's, uh, are all in downtown or the southeast, inner, inner southeast based on the pictures.

424
00:37:42.349 --> 00:37:45.867
<v Sameer Kanal>Has PMO done any mural work outside of those areas?

425
00:37:46.880 --> 00:37:52.585
<v Raymond C. Lee>I don't know if we have PMO staff in it, but I know that's something that we could potentially look at.

426
00:37:53.034 --> 00:37:55.407
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think I think they have, but I'm not 100% sure.

427
00:37:55.519 --> 00:38:02.588
<v Raymond C. Lee>I would like to follow up on that one just to confirm where we've done all the murals throughout the city, and we can get that to you before the end of day.

428
00:38:03.213 --> 00:38:10.570
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I'd love to see, you know, I know that this is work that has historically been done out of Safe Blocks, which does focus geographically in other parts of the city.

429
00:38:10.764 --> 00:38:18.409
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I think the PMO-ification of this work is likely to lead to more, uh, less attention going to District 2, and I'm, I'm very concerned about that.

430
00:38:18.762 --> 00:38:22.882
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I think that's the case for just about Everything we've PMO-ified.

431
00:38:23.431 --> 00:38:34.773
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the ITM Hub work that was highlighted in there, you mentioned it supports the fire— Portland Fire and Rescue's Prevention Division, but it doesn't explain how.

432
00:38:34.998 --> 00:38:40.000
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you get us some information on, on what exactly they're doing for Portland Fire and Rescue?

433
00:38:40.226 --> 00:38:40.902
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yeah, most definitely.

434
00:38:41.030 --> 00:38:46.728
<v Raymond C. Lee>We, we've actually had some conversations about that, and we can prepare a memo to go to the full council on the details of that as well.

435
00:38:47.755 --> 00:38:48.590
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, great.

436
00:38:49.023 --> 00:38:52.188
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is the inspection, test, and maintenance.

437
00:38:52.251 --> 00:38:52.317
<v Alex Garcia>Yep.

438
00:38:52.396 --> 00:38:54.452
<v Sameer Kanal>Try not to use all the acronyms there.

439
00:38:55.208 --> 00:39:03.271
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate, by the way, I forgot to mention this, the good news about the Elections Commission locking in 100% match caps.

440
00:39:03.576 --> 00:39:07.494
<v Sameer Kanal>That's really, really important, and I'll save the folks on that side from having to mention it.

441
00:39:08.795 --> 00:39:12.635
<v Sameer Kanal>So 3 other questions, but actually I'll focus on just one.

442
00:39:13.141 --> 00:39:25.858
<v Sameer Kanal>Appendix B has the claims, and it has a claim that is the lawsuit that we settled last year with the EDPA 2 group and the people who were displaced by the proposed expansion of Legacy.

443
00:39:26.472 --> 00:39:29.798
<v Sameer Kanal>It was previously listed in a different category.

444
00:39:29.847 --> 00:39:31.253
<v Sameer Kanal>It's now listed as a council claim.

445
00:39:32.855 --> 00:39:34.581
<v Sameer Kanal>They didn't file that complaint against us.

446
00:39:35.259 --> 00:39:36.775
<v Sameer Kanal>They filed it, I mean, it was to the city.

447
00:39:37.291 --> 00:39:39.389
<v Sameer Kanal>I think historically that's been listed as a mayor's office claim.

448
00:39:39.469 --> 00:39:39.599
<v Michael Harrison>Yeah.

449
00:39:40.518 --> 00:39:42.349
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I had 2 questions on that.

450
00:39:42.445 --> 00:39:44.085
<v Sameer Kanal>One, why is it now listed as us?

451
00:39:44.710 --> 00:39:53.304
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other is, why is the whole thing listed as us as paid when our anticipation was that half of that was gonna get paid by Prosper?

452
00:39:53.851 --> 00:39:56.534
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think that, has the money been paid out?

453
00:39:56.597 --> 00:40:00.693
<v Sameer Kanal>'Cause it says $7.5 million has been paid in terms of, it says settlements paid as the header.

454
00:40:01.320 --> 00:40:04.228
<v Sameer Kanal>And my understanding was that we were still in progress on that part.

455
00:40:04.534 --> 00:40:07.088
<v Raymond C. Lee>Let's see if Jonas is in the room.

456
00:40:08.041 --> 00:40:09.097
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes, he's coming up now.

457
00:40:16.050 --> 00:40:17.090
<v Jonas Biery>Hey, good morning, Council.

458
00:40:17.139 --> 00:40:19.384
<v Jonas Biery>For the record, Chief Financial Officer Jonas Biery.

459
00:40:20.067 --> 00:40:22.018
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you for the questions, Councilor.

460
00:40:22.742 --> 00:40:28.512
<v Jonas Biery>We had done a little due diligence and this question is a little different than the question we anticipated, so I'm probably going to need to go back and do a little bit more digging.

461
00:40:29.804 --> 00:40:33.411
<v Jonas Biery>To answer a couple of your questions, my understanding is yes, the payment has been made.

462
00:40:33.751 --> 00:40:38.335
<v Jonas Biery>I think as we've discussed previously, sometimes those show up a little Delayed into these reports.

463
00:40:38.382 --> 00:40:41.298
<v Jonas Biery>So it's reflective of that payment having been fully processed.

464
00:40:42.269 --> 00:40:52.126
<v Jonas Biery>You are correct that it was partially paid from city, essentially general fund, and partially covered, I forget the exact dollar amounts, but partially covered by a contribution from Prosper.

465
00:40:52.978 --> 00:40:54.954
<v Jonas Biery>I don't know why that indicator was changed.

466
00:40:55.003 --> 00:40:56.773
<v Jonas Biery>And so we can follow up with you on that.

467
00:40:57.641 --> 00:41:00.103
<v Jonas Biery>Generally, it's a general fund obligation.

468
00:41:00.217 --> 00:41:03.527
<v Jonas Biery>And so that indicator, this is a very unique settlement.

469
00:41:03.592 --> 00:41:06.056
<v Jonas Biery>Typically settlements are pointed to a specific bureau.

470
00:41:06.121 --> 00:41:06.186
<v Michael Harrison>Right.

471
00:41:07.717 --> 00:41:08.891
<v Jonas Biery>Transportation, parks, et cetera.

472
00:41:09.228 --> 00:41:11.396
<v Jonas Biery>This settlement doesn't have that bureau nexus.

473
00:41:11.621 --> 00:41:21.318
<v Jonas Biery>And so it's likely just a system factor of it has to point somewhere in the system and that's where it pointed.

474
00:41:21.384 --> 00:41:22.748
<v Jonas Biery>But we'll do a little more digging.

475
00:41:23.650 --> 00:41:27.632
<v Jonas Biery>I'm not familiar with what it was referenced previously, but we'll do a little more digging on that and get back to you.

476
00:41:28.760 --> 00:41:29.164
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

477
00:41:29.309 --> 00:41:53.831
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think this is maybe less a, CFO question, but just to follow up, I'd love to get an update on, um, especially as I know there's, um, Prosper Portland board of, uh, directors, uh, appointments that are becoming forward in the next couple months, trying to understand what the progress is on getting not a million but half of the $8.5 million total paid for by Prosper, as was discussed when that settlement was approved.

478
00:41:54.697 --> 00:42:07.768
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I know that that will be— and I want to be very clear about this— that will be A very important part of my decision on whether to vote yes or no on appointing anybody to the Prosper board, um, or reappointing, um, is whether or not they're willing to, to pay their fair share of it.

479
00:42:08.409 --> 00:42:11.969
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, last question I had, there are 2 contract questions.

480
00:42:12.034 --> 00:42:23.836
<v Sameer Kanal>And in Appendix D, there is a, uh, a contract for $3.63 million to— through BTS to ViaWest for new FlexCentral data center colocation services contract.

481
00:42:23.965 --> 00:42:26.771
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wanted to get more information on that.

482
00:42:26.931 --> 00:42:27.092
<v Ben Henson>Are we—.

483
00:42:28.150 --> 00:42:29.161
<v Sameer Kanal>What are we doing with data centers?

484
00:42:30.139 --> 00:42:35.414
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other one, just to parallel, we have a $100 million contract with Travel Portland for 5 years.

485
00:42:36.248 --> 00:42:38.782
<v Sameer Kanal>It's in Appendix F for convention business and tourism.

486
00:42:39.119 --> 00:42:53.302
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a lack of kind of commas in there, so I'm not 100% sure if it's all for convention business and convention tourism or if it's convention business tourism, and just trying to get an understanding of what that looks like and I know we're halfway through that 5-year term, but I wanted to get that.

487
00:42:53.820 --> 00:42:56.525
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I'm pro-Travel Portland, so don't take this as a negative of them.

488
00:42:56.606 --> 00:42:58.065
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just trying to understand what's going on there.

489
00:43:03.804 --> 00:43:06.054
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I'm—.

490
00:43:09.831 --> 00:43:10.201
<v Elise Rosenberg>Good morning.

491
00:43:10.940 --> 00:43:11.871
<v Elise Rosenberg>I'm Elise Rosenberg.

492
00:43:11.983 --> 00:43:15.440
<v Elise Rosenberg>I'm the Chief Information Officer and the Director of the Bureau of Technology Services.

493
00:43:15.554 --> 00:43:17.186
<v Elise Rosenberg>Councilor Kanal, thanks so much for your question.

494
00:43:17.251 --> 00:43:19.481
<v Elise Rosenberg>Surprisingly, I'm not here to talk about Travel Portland.

495
00:43:19.530 --> 00:43:21.956
<v Elise Rosenberg>I'll hear all of I'll do my best with your data center question.

496
00:43:23.530 --> 00:43:29.052
<v Elise Rosenberg>So Flexential provides what we call data center colocation services for the city.

497
00:43:29.115 --> 00:43:37.731
<v Elise Rosenberg>So what that basically means is we are leasing space within a purpose-built data center to place city-owned hardware and connectivity.

498
00:43:38.278 --> 00:43:49.266
<v Elise Rosenberg>And so the advantages of doing that, and we actually started doing that as a precursor project to the Portland Building renovation when the city's primary data center was in the Portland Building, which was—.

499
00:43:49.266 --> 00:43:49.331
<v Steve Novick>Oh, wow.

500
00:43:49.449 --> 00:43:55.317
<v Elise Rosenberg>That's not really a great practice from a power redundancy security perspective.

501
00:43:55.413 --> 00:44:02.851
<v Elise Rosenberg>We do not own facilities as a city that are built for data centers that have that level of security and connectivity.

502
00:44:02.963 --> 00:44:14.456
<v Elise Rosenberg>So what we do is lease space with Flexential to provide that much more purpose-built facility that has a lot more powerful connectivity.

503
00:44:15.114 --> 00:44:20.018
<v Elise Rosenberg>And through that contract, we also have an out-of-area backup for disaster recovery.

504
00:44:20.195 --> 00:44:20.804
<v Steve Novick>So they—.

505
00:44:21.349 --> 00:44:23.275
<v Elise Rosenberg>We have a space in a Colorado data center.

506
00:44:23.324 --> 00:44:28.076
<v Elise Rosenberg>So should there be a Cascadia-type event, we have some disaster resilience built in.

507
00:44:29.472 --> 00:44:48.206
<v Elise Rosenberg>And so that, through that contract, we host hardware that gives the city its internet connectivity, that gives us access to SAP, to CAD, to 911, and provides that in a much more, again, secure, professionally managed environment.

508
00:44:48.253 --> 00:44:48.382
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

509
00:44:49.141 --> 00:44:59.311
<v Elise Rosenberg>They also have a commitment to, you know, to low power usage, to cooling, to minimizing or not using water cooling.

510
00:44:59.425 --> 00:45:04.117
<v Elise Rosenberg>And this is different from, say, a hyperscale AI data center, which we're hearing a lot about in the media.

511
00:45:04.344 --> 00:45:05.117
<v Elise Rosenberg>That is not this.

512
00:45:05.980 --> 00:45:07.605
<v Elise Rosenberg>This is renting space.

513
00:45:07.914 --> 00:45:09.490
<v Elise Rosenberg>Does that help?

514
00:45:09.751 --> 00:45:10.547
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thank you.

515
00:45:10.597 --> 00:45:10.873
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

516
00:45:16.576 --> 00:45:20.288
<v Sameer Kanal>Excuse me.

517
00:45:20.481 --> 00:45:22.353
<v Sameer Kanal>All right.

518
00:45:22.822 --> 00:45:26.286
<v Donnie Oliveira>Good morning, councilors, Council President, Vice President.

519
00:45:27.153 --> 00:45:28.278
<v Donnie Oliveira>Donnie Oliveira, for the record.

520
00:45:28.375 --> 00:45:33.635
<v Donnie Oliveira>So, councilor, related to the current contract we have with Travel Portland and what that's capturing.

521
00:45:33.684 --> 00:45:44.099
<v Donnie Oliveira>So first, just for situational awareness, that the capacity of that contract includes both their transient lodging tax, 1%, and it includes a 3% tourism improvement district.

522
00:45:46.188 --> 00:45:47.545
<v Donnie Oliveira>Which is essentially a self-tax.

523
00:45:47.673 --> 00:45:55.128
<v Donnie Oliveira>So they're basically— the industry's taxing themselves like an enhanced service district, and we're collecting that for them and passing that through to Travel Portland.

524
00:45:55.601 --> 00:45:58.670
<v Donnie Oliveira>And then your question essentially is, what is Travel Portland doing within that contract?

525
00:45:59.682 --> 00:46:03.362
<v Donnie Oliveira>Essentially, they are our boosters, our cheerleaders.

526
00:46:03.572 --> 00:46:10.085
<v Donnie Oliveira>Their responsibility is to draw tourism, whether through conventions, through events.

527
00:46:10.487 --> 00:46:14.902
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so those dollars are being put to work through a variety of different marketing, actually hosting events.

528
00:46:14.967 --> 00:46:15.603
<v Donnie Oliveira>We had our biggest conference ever last year.

529
00:46:15.652 --> 00:46:15.684
<v Robert Taylor>Wow.

530
00:46:17.802 --> 00:46:21.672
<v Donnie Oliveira>With the National Education Conference that was hosted at the convention center.

531
00:46:21.751 --> 00:46:28.463
<v Donnie Oliveira>So really what you're seeing there is just the full volume of a contract, of a 5-year contract that we pay out roughly $20 million annually to.

532
00:46:29.346 --> 00:46:29.666
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

533
00:46:29.762 --> 00:46:33.166
<v Sameer Kanal>So just to be clear, the tourism is citywide and then convention business is—.

534
00:46:33.166 --> 00:46:34.114
<v Donnie Oliveira>Citywide, yeah.

535
00:46:34.242 --> 00:46:38.190
<v Donnie Oliveira>And we're capturing everything from events beyond just convention center events.

536
00:46:39.235 --> 00:46:39.378
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

537
00:46:40.117 --> 00:46:41.690
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

538
00:46:41.947 --> 00:46:43.777
<v Jamie Dunphy>Put myself in the queue for a very quick question.

539
00:46:44.228 --> 00:46:55.422
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator, we have done some work on reforming our advisory boards and commissions, and there was a requirement in there to report out if there have been any new boards or commissions appointed within the 30-day period.

540
00:46:55.471 --> 00:47:01.268
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just wanted to see, I didn't find that in the report, and I was just thinking, have there been any new appointed boards or commissions?

541
00:47:03.807 --> 00:47:10.695
<v Raymond C. Lee>By the time we did this report, I think it'll be the ones that we have appointed will be in the next month's report, but I can go back and clarify that.

542
00:47:11.157 --> 00:47:18.518
<v Raymond C. Lee>If not, yeah, 'cause I know we have done some appointments, but the timing of it and when this report is produced might have been lagged in that.

543
00:47:18.695 --> 00:47:19.273
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, great.

544
00:47:19.481 --> 00:47:20.251
<v Jamie Dunphy>That was my only question.

545
00:47:21.246 --> 00:47:22.351
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

546
00:47:22.431 --> 00:47:22.608
<v Christy White>Sure.

547
00:47:23.170 --> 00:47:24.405
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

548
00:47:24.452 --> 00:47:26.041
<v Dan Ryan>Good to see you, CA Lee.

549
00:47:26.280 --> 00:47:27.244
<v Dan Ryan>I love these reports.

550
00:47:27.324 --> 00:47:27.996
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you very much.

551
00:47:28.141 --> 00:47:29.119
<v Dan Ryan>They keep improving too.

552
00:47:29.521 --> 00:47:32.807
<v Dan Ryan>I just wanted to notice that, especially the procurement report.

553
00:47:32.889 --> 00:47:36.688
<v Dan Ryan>It was so easy to read and gives us a lot of information.

554
00:47:37.280 --> 00:47:41.833
<v Dan Ryan>So if the public really wants to see where we're spending our money, just look at the procurement report.

555
00:47:43.342 --> 00:47:50.840
<v Dan Ryan>I really want to say that I enjoyed seeing the tangible and important steps that are taking place with our shelter services report.

556
00:47:51.389 --> 00:48:02.306
<v Dan Ryan>The vision of that, which I played a big part in, was always about making certain that people, while they're going through that transition, the most difficult transition from chronic homelessness to stability, includes access to housing.

557
00:48:02.916 --> 00:48:09.405
<v Dan Ryan>Access to workforce and access to sobering— access to treatment programs.

558
00:48:10.626 --> 00:48:17.034
<v Dan Ryan>When those two are in place and a participant is using them, then their transition is successful.

559
00:48:17.532 --> 00:48:19.876
<v Dan Ryan>And so we need to keep looking at the data.

560
00:48:20.262 --> 00:48:25.980
<v Dan Ryan>We need to keep offering those services, and we need to keep using that as an incentive.

561
00:48:26.445 --> 00:48:30.041
<v Dan Ryan>And they should be at the front of the line when we place people into to our public housing.

562
00:48:30.489 --> 00:48:33.469
<v Dan Ryan>So I hope that we continue to see that vision through.

563
00:48:33.679 --> 00:48:39.608
<v Dan Ryan>I think the city is a better oversight of that than the county because we tend to look at such accountability and results.

564
00:48:40.472 --> 00:48:43.614
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I'm excited to go to Bull Run this Friday.

565
00:48:43.775 --> 00:48:49.190
<v Dan Ryan>I think there's some other colleagues going, and I just wanted to say thank you for that request being delivered for us.

566
00:48:49.527 --> 00:49:00.782
<v Dan Ryan>Um, there's nothing like on-the-ground insight to help us look at something that's very I just wanted to give some more flavor to that new program created by Portland firefighters.

567
00:49:00.911 --> 00:49:03.286
<v Dan Ryan>They visit burn victims while recovering in the hospital.

568
00:49:03.751 --> 00:49:08.594
<v Dan Ryan>It just shows so much empathy and human-focused work that our public safety employees are doing.

569
00:49:09.188 --> 00:49:10.568
<v Dan Ryan>So I want to lift that.

570
00:49:11.032 --> 00:49:18.876
<v Dan Ryan>The program was created by the firefighters themselves to provide some human interaction and support the burn victims who have long-term stays in the hospital.

571
00:49:19.454 --> 00:49:21.748
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm just very heartened by that follow-through that we're showing.

572
00:49:21.813 --> 00:49:21.956
<v Jeff Fish>Thank you.

573
00:49:22.460 --> 00:49:25.987
<v Dan Ryan>From what I think are our social workers and public safety.

574
00:49:26.199 --> 00:49:27.061
<v Dan Ryan>I really appreciate that.

575
00:49:28.690 --> 00:49:32.360
<v Dan Ryan>I do have a question about the— oh, one more thing I wanted to lift.

576
00:49:32.489 --> 00:49:34.969
<v Dan Ryan>The Darcel Plaza opening was just amazing.

577
00:49:35.646 --> 00:49:39.958
<v Dan Ryan>I went to 2 of them, but I don't think we understand how big that was.

578
00:49:40.215 --> 00:49:47.949
<v Dan Ryan>To take something from idea to actual opening in 3 years was— I'll just say I haven't witnessed that very often since I've been here.

579
00:49:48.010 --> 00:49:48.289
<v Christy White>Thank you.

580
00:49:48.556 --> 00:49:52.887
<v Dan Ryan>And it took a lot of cat herding, took a lot of persistence.

581
00:49:53.449 --> 00:49:56.657
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to acknowledge a couple people.

582
00:49:57.701 --> 00:50:04.583
<v Dan Ryan>Ross Swanson from Parks Bureau was just amazing with his patience and his persistence to keep that moving along.

583
00:50:05.161 --> 00:50:10.070
<v Dan Ryan>And the other person that did that was Kelly Torres in the Parks Bureau that helped us bring in the partnerships.

584
00:50:10.295 --> 00:50:18.579
<v Dan Ryan>And one reason I think it was done in 3 years is because we had a really active active partnership with Clean and Safe and also the local businesses in the area.

585
00:50:18.900 --> 00:50:21.054
<v Dan Ryan>They were helpful to see this through.

586
00:50:21.472 --> 00:50:26.219
<v Dan Ryan>So I hope Portlanders can have some fun this summer and enjoy Darsill Plaza.

587
00:50:26.541 --> 00:50:29.278
<v Dan Ryan>I hear someone might be performing there on Saturday night.

588
00:50:30.469 --> 00:50:31.217
<v Dan Ryan>Hi, Councilor Clark.

589
00:50:31.947 --> 00:50:32.338
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, yes.

590
00:50:32.597 --> 00:50:32.726
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

591
00:50:32.856 --> 00:50:33.003
<v Christy White>Yeah.

592
00:50:33.085 --> 00:50:33.507
<v Olivia Clark>Are you nervous?

593
00:50:34.990 --> 00:50:35.039
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

594
00:50:35.106 --> 00:50:36.186
<v Dan Ryan>But I also want to—.

595
00:50:36.186 --> 00:50:37.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You should be there with me.

596
00:50:37.217 --> 00:50:37.398
<v Dan Ryan>I know.

597
00:50:37.480 --> 00:50:39.132
<v Dan Ryan>You want me to— I don't— I can't sing.

598
00:50:39.197 --> 00:50:39.248
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yeah.

599
00:50:39.851 --> 00:50:42.003
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You don't have to have a badge.

600
00:50:42.324 --> 00:50:43.061
<v Dan Ryan>I don't know what to do.

601
00:50:43.126 --> 00:50:43.510
<v Dan Ryan>You're singing.

602
00:50:44.827 --> 00:50:48.905
<v Dan Ryan>But I wanted to acknowledge the grant report too.

603
00:50:49.385 --> 00:50:50.574
<v Dan Ryan>But I have a question.

604
00:50:50.621 --> 00:50:56.126
<v Dan Ryan>I don't see the general fund grants that are going out to the private nonprofits.

605
00:50:56.865 --> 00:50:57.588
<v Dan Ryan>Is that somewhere?

606
00:50:57.668 --> 00:51:00.059
<v Dan Ryan>And I just— it's just not in the one that was published?

607
00:51:00.717 --> 00:51:01.632
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yeah, we do track that.

608
00:51:01.681 --> 00:51:08.021
<v Raymond C. Lee>That is something we could potentially, like our PCF grants and different things that we have that go out to the community.

609
00:51:08.342 --> 00:51:09.527
<v Raymond C. Lee>We can look at that.

610
00:51:10.505 --> 00:51:12.061
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think at one point we did have it in there.

611
00:51:12.108 --> 00:51:15.202
<v Raymond C. Lee>So if it's not in there, I can most definitely make sure we have it in there.

612
00:51:15.251 --> 00:51:25.864
<v Dan Ryan>I think Children's Levy and PCF do a pretty good job of transparency with those restricted designated gifts that the public is completely aware of 'cause it was part of a ballot initiative.

613
00:51:26.313 --> 00:51:33.974
<v Dan Ryan>I think it's the ones that weren't part of any ballot initiative, but it's what we chose to do and they go out from our general fund.

614
00:51:34.311 --> 00:51:45.108
<v Dan Ryan>To— and I'm not saying good or bad, I just need that information so I can track how much money we're spending on our general fund to those nonprofits to enhance the delivery of services.

615
00:51:45.382 --> 00:51:48.894
<v Dan Ryan>And of course, I keep asking for what we're measuring success by.

616
00:51:49.313 --> 00:51:55.697
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm fine with those sending out money as long as we know exactly what we're getting with that, just like we do in procurement.

617
00:51:56.050 --> 00:51:58.425
<v Dan Ryan>I see granting is very similar to procurement.

618
00:51:58.777 --> 00:52:00.045
<v Dan Ryan>I know when I was on that side of it, I see.

619
00:52:00.365 --> 00:52:09.021
<v Dan Ryan>Of my career, if we did not deliver on what the foundation wanted us to deliver on, about year 2 of a 3-year grant, they'd pull the funding.

620
00:52:09.389 --> 00:52:13.403
<v Dan Ryan>So there needs to— I just wanna see that transparency, which would bring about more accountability.

621
00:52:13.548 --> 00:52:13.869
<v Dan Ryan>That's all.

622
00:52:14.496 --> 00:52:20.534
<v Dan Ryan>And I know I've been a broken record on this for about 6 years, so I appreciate that we're getting closer to that type of transparency.

623
00:52:20.757 --> 00:52:21.818
<v Raymond C. Lee>We can get that information in there.

624
00:52:22.219 --> 00:52:23.070
<v Dan Ryan>All right, thanks so much.

625
00:52:23.583 --> 00:52:24.755
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

626
00:52:26.525 --> 00:52:27.510
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, City Administrator.

627
00:52:28.166 --> 00:52:30.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please move to item number 4?

628
00:52:33.420 --> 00:52:50.056
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 4, document 2026-217, consider appeals of the Design Commission's approval of a voluntary Central City Master Plan review and adjustment review for the Lloyd Center, uh, Lloyd Center Central City Master Plan LU25-09.

629
00:52:55.489 --> 00:52:55.847
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

630
00:52:55.929 --> 00:53:00.755
<v Jamie Dunphy>First thing first, I'm going to turn it to our city attorney to make some announcements about the rest of today's hearing on this item.

631
00:53:02.101 --> 00:53:07.458
<v Robert Taylor>So this is a continuation of last week, 2 weeks ago's land use review.

632
00:53:09.610 --> 00:53:19.469
<v Robert Taylor>Councilor Zimmerman has some declarations to make, and then I— if any of the other councilors also have had any ex parte contact in the interim, this would be the time to make those.

633
00:53:21.802 --> 00:53:25.295
<v Robert Taylor>Otherwise, I think we're just picking up with council deliberations.

634
00:53:25.684 --> 00:53:26.217
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

635
00:53:26.492 --> 00:53:27.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

636
00:53:27.851 --> 00:53:28.385
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, colleagues.

637
00:53:28.434 --> 00:53:30.018
<v Eric Zimmerman>I reviewed the record from last time.

638
00:53:30.132 --> 00:53:30.876
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for that.

639
00:53:31.577 --> 00:53:43.202
<v Eric Zimmerman>And from an ex parte perspective, the— I'm not sure if it's owner or developer— called me only one time to announce or to let me know that the announcement of shutting down was going to occur.

640
00:53:43.364 --> 00:53:47.472
<v Eric Zimmerman>I consider it a courtesy call, and I believe that's the extent we discussed the project whatsoever.

641
00:53:47.521 --> 00:53:47.637
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

642
00:53:48.168 --> 00:53:49.815
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

643
00:53:50.945 --> 00:53:54.288
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue to make any additional disclosures.

644
00:53:55.449 --> 00:54:03.077
<v Robert Taylor>And just invite the opportunity if anyone in the council chambers wishes to ask Councilor Zimmerman about the ex parte contact, now would be the opportunity.

645
00:54:05.869 --> 00:54:05.983
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

646
00:54:09.807 --> 00:54:13.130
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, do we need to disclose that we've received additional emails?

647
00:54:13.195 --> 00:54:21.027
<v Robert Taylor>Because I know that you'll need to disclose those emails if you've read those emails.

648
00:54:21.384 --> 00:54:27.958
<v Robert Taylor>If you have not read or reviewed those emails, they are not something that would be part of—.

649
00:54:28.737 --> 00:54:29.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

650
00:54:29.565 --> 00:54:31.481
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, if anybody— I know my office has received some.

651
00:54:31.659 --> 00:54:32.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have not read any of them.

652
00:54:33.496 --> 00:54:36.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>If anybody else, my colleagues, want to declare, you're welcome to do the same.

653
00:54:36.768 --> 00:54:36.815
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

654
00:54:36.864 --> 00:54:38.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we're doing okay.

655
00:54:38.949 --> 00:54:39.257
<v Ben Henson>Councilor Smith.

656
00:54:39.637 --> 00:54:52.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, so, uh, we left off last week having concluded and closed the record to further testimony, what with the evidentiary record still open to allow for council to ask questions of staff, the applicant, and the appellants.

657
00:54:53.387 --> 00:54:55.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we are now going to move into that council discussion.

658
00:54:55.742 --> 00:55:11.588
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, um, the appellant and the applicant are both here, uh, and are available to ask any questions, and we are in active debate of this, uh, So everyone's feeling shy this morning, unless there's no further discussion.

659
00:55:16.768 --> 00:55:18.552
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green, brave first.

660
00:55:19.501 --> 00:55:21.478
<v Mitch Green>You know, I'm not shy.

661
00:55:21.784 --> 00:55:22.539
<v Mitch Green>I think you know that.

662
00:55:23.429 --> 00:55:24.349
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thanks, Council President.

663
00:55:24.512 --> 00:55:38.998
<v Mitch Green>Um, I do want to ask the question, um, just so I'm clear, because the decision before us is whether or not to, um, Well, actually, Lauren, can you please remind us what the decision before us is?

664
00:55:39.775 --> 00:55:40.065
<v Robert Taylor>I can.

665
00:55:40.195 --> 00:55:45.684
<v Robert Taylor>And it's also helpful sometimes if staff wants to throw up a slide with the options before council.

666
00:55:45.750 --> 00:55:51.407
<v Robert Taylor>But I think the— do you have that slide ready pretty quick or do you want me to talk about it?

667
00:55:51.505 --> 00:55:52.538
<v Unidentified speaker>Give me 30 seconds.

668
00:55:54.458 --> 00:55:54.706
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

669
00:55:55.494 --> 00:56:06.625
<v Mitch Green>And while you're pulling that up, I just, You know, as a— in my quasi-judicial role here as a city councilor in a land use hearing, it's about— it's not necessarily what I want to do.

670
00:56:06.867 --> 00:56:08.820
<v Mitch Green>It's not about my own intentions or plans.

671
00:56:08.884 --> 00:56:10.547
<v Mitch Green>It's about the decision before us.

672
00:56:10.659 --> 00:56:16.204
<v Mitch Green>And so we need to be talking about what are the consequences of the decision before us.

673
00:56:16.302 --> 00:56:20.594
<v Mitch Green>And so that's kind of where my questions are going to go as soon as we get the slide up here.

674
00:56:21.014 --> 00:56:21.338
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, okay.

675
00:56:27.938 --> 00:56:33.684
<v Mitch Green>And if Councilor Novick has a joke at this time to fill the airspace, we will entertain it.

676
00:56:33.911 --> 00:56:36.599
<v Mitch Green>I'll allow you to speak over my mic, Councilor.

677
00:56:46.764 --> 00:56:58.458
<v Mitch Green>I guess what I'll say is I, I think that the decision before us is whether or not to deny the Or approve the appeal, deny the appeal, and some variation of those with some changes or suggest changes.

678
00:56:58.505 --> 00:56:58.940
<v Olivia Clark>That's right.

679
00:56:58.987 --> 00:57:03.677
<v Robert Taylor>So approve the appeal, which would overturn the Design Commission's decision.

680
00:57:03.934 --> 00:57:04.239
<v Douglas McLeod>Right.

681
00:57:04.978 --> 00:57:07.755
<v Robert Taylor>And deny the master plan.

682
00:57:08.447 --> 00:57:22.621
<v Robert Taylor>Deny the appeal would affirm the Design Commission's decision with the conditions that the Design Commission included, or council has the option to deny the appeal and add its own conditions.

683
00:57:23.840 --> 00:57:24.159
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

684
00:57:24.257 --> 00:57:29.918
<v Mitch Green>And so then this is really about whether or not to deny the appeal to the master plan.

685
00:57:30.173 --> 00:57:33.221
<v Mitch Green>It's not about the future plans of this development project?

686
00:57:33.878 --> 00:57:40.389
<v Robert Taylor>No, and staff can speak more specifically, but the site— the future development of the site will have additional design review.

687
00:57:40.759 --> 00:57:43.068
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's outside the scope of this hearing.

688
00:57:45.188 --> 00:57:51.579
<v Robert Taylor>Yes, this hearing is about whether or not the voluntary master plan meets the applicable criteria.

689
00:57:52.489 --> 00:57:52.621
<v Doug Wade>Thank you.

690
00:57:53.244 --> 00:57:55.527
<v Mitch Green>Do we have the applicants on?

691
00:58:01.110 --> 00:58:02.240
<v Mitch Green>Oh yeah, please come on up.

692
00:58:02.289 --> 00:58:02.579
<v Ben Henson>You can share.

693
00:58:02.693 --> 00:58:02.887
<v Steve Novick>Sorry.

694
00:58:03.889 --> 00:58:04.842
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

695
00:58:05.003 --> 00:58:09.204
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Green, I have the options on the screen finally for you.

696
00:58:09.561 --> 00:58:10.541
<v Mitch Green>Okay, thank you.

697
00:58:10.621 --> 00:58:16.161
<v Mitch Green>So just reading those out before I ask the applicant, um, some questions here.

698
00:58:17.012 --> 00:58:52.097
<v Mitch Green>The options before council— there's 3 options: deny both appeals and uphold the Design Commission's decision and conditions of approval with revised findings, uh, deny both appeals and uphold the Design Commission's decision but with revised conditions and findings, and then grant one or both of the appeals and overturn the Design And so I think, I guess my question, because this is about a master plan application, and so I guess my question to the applicant is, if council were to grant one or both of the appeals, would that change anything about your plans for development of the use there?

699
00:58:53.050 --> 00:58:53.277
<v Christy White>Yes.

700
00:58:54.990 --> 00:59:30.646
<v Christy White>If you were to grant either one of the appeals, there wouldn't be a central city However, we would be able to proceed with demolition since it's a separate decision process than the CCMP, and then we would be able to redevelop the whole of Lloyd Center, the 27 acres, without being subject to any of the CCMP approval criteria, including that we would no longer be required to dedicate any park space or open area, which now amounts to about 6 acres of open space.

701
00:59:30.695 --> 00:59:30.838
<v Christy White>Thank you.

702
00:59:30.967 --> 00:59:31.239
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

703
00:59:31.833 --> 00:59:33.644
<v Christy White>That would no longer be a requirement.

704
00:59:33.996 --> 00:59:35.103
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for clarifying that.

705
00:59:35.184 --> 00:59:40.362
<v Mitch Green>I think that's what I heard last week or last couple weeks, but I wanted to make sure that was clear here.

706
00:59:41.628 --> 00:59:50.733
<v Mitch Green>So the council decision today is not— there's no decision by which we can force the preservation of this mall?

707
00:59:51.550 --> 00:59:52.112
<v Christy White>That's correct.

708
00:59:52.255 --> 00:59:52.432
<v Douglas McLeod>Okay.

709
00:59:53.137 --> 00:59:55.190
<v Mitch Green>I think that's all the questions I have right now at this time.

710
00:59:55.318 --> 00:59:56.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

711
00:59:56.519 --> 00:59:56.985
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

712
00:59:57.449 --> 00:59:58.931
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor President.

713
00:59:59.092 --> 01:00:07.059
<v Olivia Clark>I just want to build off of Councilor Green's question, but first I just want to say how much I appreciated the community being here and the testimony.

714
01:00:07.141 --> 01:00:09.588
<v Olivia Clark>I found it compelling.

715
01:00:09.652 --> 01:00:22.664
<v Olivia Clark>I actually learned a lot about skate culture that I didn't know about, and the positivity of skate culture, and I learned that this kind of endeavor really requires subsidies as well, if we think about that into the future.

716
01:00:22.820 --> 01:00:31.695
<v Olivia Clark>But my question, I think, is really to legal, is, um, what are the consequences of, uh, of upholding the appeal?

717
01:00:31.759 --> 01:00:33.652
<v Olivia Clark>What would the consequences be to this city?

718
01:00:33.764 --> 01:00:37.182
<v Olivia Clark>Are we liable for any kind of action?

719
01:00:37.922 --> 01:00:39.429
<v Olivia Clark>Is this— does this trigger Dolan?

720
01:00:39.543 --> 01:00:41.420
<v Olivia Clark>What— can you talk a little bit about that?

721
01:00:41.644 --> 01:00:47.936
<v Robert Taylor>So, Councilor Clark, you're asking if the council were to uphold the appeal and reverse the Design Commission's decision?

722
01:00:48.208 --> 01:00:52.119
<v Robert Taylor>I mean, the immediate the consequence would be that the applicant would no longer have a master plan.

723
01:00:53.181 --> 01:00:56.596
<v Robert Taylor>And then a party could— any party could appeal that decision.

724
01:00:56.740 --> 01:01:06.365
<v Robert Taylor>Presumably the applicant might appeal that decision arguing that their application did comply with the applicable master plan.

725
01:01:06.820 --> 01:01:08.559
<v Robert Taylor>But if the question is whether or not denying it would trigger a constitutional claim, I'm not sure.

726
01:01:08.641 --> 01:01:14.235
<v Robert Taylor>I think the question is whether or not denying it would trigger a constitutional claim.

727
01:01:17.422 --> 01:01:24.405
<v Robert Taylor>I'm off— not— the constitutional claims will usually come if council imposes additional conditions, approves with conditions.

728
01:01:27.215 --> 01:01:39.818
<v Olivia Clark>I just— I guess my question is really if we deny or if we uphold the appeal, are we vulnerable to suit by the applicant?

729
01:01:40.288 --> 01:01:44.478
<v Robert Taylor>I would imagine that the applicant— the applicant is entitled to challenge that at the Land Use Board of Appeals.

730
01:01:44.570 --> 01:01:46.228
<v Olivia Clark>Yes, yes, that's the next step.

731
01:01:46.391 --> 01:01:47.302
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, that would be a step.

732
01:01:47.432 --> 01:01:47.938
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, thank you.

733
01:01:48.003 --> 01:01:49.059
<v Olivia Clark>That's what I wanted to know.

734
01:01:51.070 --> 01:01:51.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

735
01:01:52.320 --> 01:01:55.034
<v Jamie Dunphy>I put myself in the queue to make a just a brief comment.

736
01:01:56.701 --> 01:02:10.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I, I also want to just echo that I, I— the, the truly heartfelt nature of, of all the folks who came to testify and fight to preserve something that is so deeply important to your experience of being a Portlander.

737
01:02:10.380 --> 01:02:11.135
<v Jamie Dunphy>I I hear you.

738
01:02:11.764 --> 01:02:17.757
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mentioned at the beginning of this, our first hearing, one of my first jobs was working in the Lloyd Center.

739
01:02:17.820 --> 01:02:22.125
<v Jamie Dunphy>I absolutely have my own deep connections to this space.

740
01:02:23.768 --> 01:02:28.429
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was a ruffian teenager in the late '90s hanging out in there and playing in the arcade.

741
01:02:31.177 --> 01:02:33.101
<v Jamie Dunphy>But that's not the question before us, unfortunately.

742
01:02:33.851 --> 01:02:37.240
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the question before us isn't, you know, isn't yes.

743
01:02:37.420 --> 01:02:40.422
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can the city council force a property owner to run a business?

744
01:02:42.320 --> 01:02:44.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we force them to use their property in a specific way?

745
01:02:45.708 --> 01:02:49.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>Understanding that, that, you know, there's not really any sort of example of that ever happening anywhere else.

746
01:02:49.822 --> 01:02:52.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>We can't force a business to suddenly decide they're going to be a McDonald's.

747
01:02:53.108 --> 01:02:55.297
<v Jamie Dunphy>We can't force them to continue to do what they want.

748
01:02:55.800 --> 01:02:57.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that's not the question before us.

749
01:02:57.728 --> 01:03:00.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, I heard something that I was extremely interested in last time.

750
01:03:01.632 --> 01:03:19.963
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it was a question about the future of using the Veterans Memorial Coliseum, I you know, we are having a lot of conversations right now about the future of the Moda Center and the Rose Quarter broadly, and there's going to be a massive investment, hopefully, in that area to focus on activation and entertainment and recreation.

751
01:03:20.463 --> 01:03:27.146
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know the answer about whether or not the Memorial Coliseum could be a recreational facility of some sort in the offseason.

752
01:03:27.583 --> 01:03:31.668
<v Jamie Dunphy>I heard that ice rinks require a public subsidy.

753
01:03:31.782 --> 01:03:32.315
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, we already own the building.

754
01:03:32.362 --> 01:03:32.735
<v Dan Ryan>I think that's a great point.

755
01:03:33.965 --> 01:03:35.023
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perhaps we need an operator.

756
01:03:35.152 --> 01:03:39.117
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know what is between there and here, but I'm very interested in looking into that.

757
01:03:39.164 --> 01:03:46.452
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so my office will be looking further into that conversation about whether or not there are additional recreational opportunities in a city-owned facility.

758
01:03:47.913 --> 01:03:51.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>And because, as was mentioned, there just aren't any other options like this in the city of Portland.

759
01:03:51.876 --> 01:03:53.786
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm very interested in that.

760
01:03:53.867 --> 01:04:06.112
<v Jamie Dunphy>But as to the question before us, colleagues, I really— I don't see a path to supporting the appeals, and I will be, uh, uh, moving— I will be supportive of denying the appeals.

761
01:04:07.090 --> 01:04:08.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

762
01:04:09.128 --> 01:04:11.039
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, I'm sorry, Councilor Kanal.

763
01:04:11.119 --> 01:04:12.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>Actually, they changed order on my thing.

764
01:04:13.510 --> 01:04:15.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>Wait, no, nope, I'm wrong again.

765
01:04:15.612 --> 01:04:16.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney is correct.

766
01:04:16.800 --> 01:04:18.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That came to me very quickly.

767
01:04:18.820 --> 01:04:20.266
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I thought there were people ahead of me.

768
01:04:20.746 --> 01:04:22.030
<v Dan Ryan>He went to the last floor.

769
01:04:22.271 --> 01:04:23.217
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm, I'm in the middle.

770
01:04:23.331 --> 01:04:24.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, it just, it changed order.

771
01:04:25.079 --> 01:04:27.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>It just keeps I, I apologize.

772
01:04:28.275 --> 01:04:29.704
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to say— oh, okay, Kanal.

773
01:04:29.831 --> 01:04:32.353
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to go with Kanal then, because this is how it's going.

774
01:04:32.561 --> 01:04:32.833
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry.

775
01:04:33.427 --> 01:04:33.942
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thanks.

776
01:04:34.809 --> 01:04:35.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, everybody.

777
01:04:35.900 --> 01:04:38.581
<v Sameer Kanal>I had a lot of questions that are mostly legal.

778
01:04:38.726 --> 01:04:51.795
<v Sameer Kanal>I asked one of them last week, or yeah, 2 weeks ago, and it was because Mr. Klein with the first appellant asked for us to either remand the item back to the Design Commission or add an appropriate condition to save the ice rink.

779
01:04:52.757 --> 01:05:00.927
<v Sameer Kanal>I asked last time if we could legally remand the item back to the Design Commission, and zoning code does not, um, consider that as an option we have.

780
01:05:01.425 --> 01:05:05.630
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I asked that for clarity primarily, just to, to understand what our options are.

781
01:05:05.679 --> 01:05:09.306
<v Sameer Kanal>And I really appreciate the further clarification of that, uh, Councilor Green brought up.

782
01:05:10.429 --> 01:05:14.762
<v Sameer Kanal>There are 2 additional ones that came, uh, that relate to this, and I'll just ask them together.

783
01:05:15.324 --> 01:05:17.588
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, um, the idea of adding a Yeah.

784
01:05:17.639 --> 01:05:27.304
<v Sameer Kanal>Condition to, I guess it wouldn't be preserve this ice rink, but add a condition in that there be an ice rink in future development.

785
01:05:28.199 --> 01:05:33.326
<v Sameer Kanal>The other one, I think that we are all familiar with what that question is, so I think I don't need to give more detail there.

786
01:05:33.391 --> 01:05:56.056
<v Sameer Kanal>But the other one that I wanted to mention, which has come up in some of the previous meetings prior to this land use, was the importance of the 5K and the idea of That the current building is uniquely able and is popularly used to allow people to walk in 20 blocks of dry climate-controlled indoor space.

787
01:05:57.309 --> 01:06:15.730
<v Sameer Kanal>And so the question was whether or not we are able to add a condition of use to require the new development to have some sort of maintenance of that, either through a covered walkway, a skyway, a tunnel, the question that I got asked, uh, back when I had a, um, town hall there last year was about a skyway.

788
01:06:16.340 --> 01:06:19.579
<v Sameer Kanal>And, um, so I'll just— I'll ask these 2 questions.

789
01:06:19.949 --> 01:06:23.302
<v Sameer Kanal>Are those things that are within the scope of what this conversation is?

790
01:06:24.039 --> 01:06:25.869
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and then I have a couple other follow-ups.

791
01:06:27.248 --> 01:06:27.954
<v Robert Taylor>Okay, Councilor.

792
01:06:28.001 --> 01:06:32.797
<v Robert Taylor>So I think your question was, can we add conditions regarding an ice rink or Skyway?

793
01:06:33.744 --> 01:06:34.097
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

794
01:06:34.483 --> 01:06:37.867
<v Robert Taylor>And under Oregon land use law and the zoning code, the city can attach yes.

795
01:06:37.931 --> 01:06:44.164
<v Robert Taylor>Council will attach conditions only to ensure that the proposal will conform with the applicable approval criteria, and that's codified.

796
01:06:45.336 --> 01:06:52.644
<v Robert Taylor>So none of the applicable approval criteria identified by staff expressly requires an ice rink or a skyway.

797
01:06:53.271 --> 01:07:03.550
<v Robert Taylor>Council, in order to impose such a criteria or condition, council would need to find that a relevant approval criteria cannot be met without requiring the ice rink or the skyway.

798
01:07:04.336 --> 01:07:09.695
<v Robert Taylor>And I would just note that the applicant has asserted that requiring an ice rink would be an unconstitutional taking.

799
01:07:11.027 --> 01:07:12.983
<v Sameer Kanal>So that opens a second question.

800
01:07:13.096 --> 01:07:28.175
<v Sameer Kanal>You mentioned without expressly requiring, which means that, as I interpret it, what your response is here, that if a criteria is met in a certain way, we don't have the authority here to say you should meet it a different way.

801
01:07:28.737 --> 01:07:33.539
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll kind of, by By way of illustrating it, there was another question.

802
01:07:33.974 --> 01:07:40.041
<v Sameer Kanal>The other appellant, Mr. Henderson, mentioned community building, which is Policy 2LD3.

803
01:07:40.710 --> 01:08:01.224
<v Sameer Kanal>In light of how it is currently used and talking about maintaining that particular— the current ways in which that criteria is met by the current uses, and the application asserts that it will be met in other ways by the way in which the master plan is being proposed.

804
01:08:01.608 --> 01:08:13.543
<v Sameer Kanal>My question is effectively, are we, one, are we looking at the current, or are we just looking at, 'cause there's no master plan now, are we looking at how the master plan would meet or not meet these criteria?

805
01:08:13.945 --> 01:08:21.922
<v Sameer Kanal>And again, are we able to say you're meeting it in a way we don't prefer in the context of this hearing?

806
01:08:22.292 --> 01:08:30.609
<v Robert Taylor>So the question before the council is whether or not the current, the application, It's not whether the current development meets the approval criteria.

807
01:08:30.609 --> 01:08:32.649
<v Robert Taylor>It's what the applicant has applied for.

808
01:08:33.609 --> 01:08:42.048
<v Robert Taylor>And then council, it's within council's authority to interpret the applicable approval criteria.

809
01:08:42.048 --> 01:08:47.689
<v Robert Taylor>The standard before the Land Use Board of Appeals on appeal would be whether or not that interpretation was plausible.

810
01:08:49.429 --> 01:08:53.548
<v Robert Taylor>And so again, conditions are— council can impose conditions if they're necessary to ensure necessary that the development meets the approval criteria.

811
01:08:53.548 --> 01:08:56.039
<v Robert Taylor>So if the applicant is not meeting the approval criteria, to satisfy approval criteria.

812
01:08:56.119 --> 01:09:02.108
<v Robert Taylor>Council would have to interpret that approval criteria cannot be met but for that condition.

813
01:09:03.423 --> 01:09:03.761
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

814
01:09:04.547 --> 01:09:08.095
<v Sameer Kanal>Another question that came up, uh, I have 2 left on this.

815
01:09:08.400 --> 01:09:11.724
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, um, you know, there's a, there's a park next door.

816
01:09:12.094 --> 01:09:16.765
<v Sameer Kanal>There's, there's Holiday Park, uh, right there, which has had a lot of work put into it fairly recently.

817
01:09:16.989 --> 01:09:23.849
<v Sameer Kanal>And there was a question about, is there a necessity to create new space that, that could be considered in some ways redundant?

818
01:09:25.086 --> 01:09:39.733
<v Sameer Kanal>Or is there an ability to count that as part of the sort of green space that's being created so that some of the land that is currently being dedicated in this proposed master plan for green space could theoretically be used for another purpose?

819
01:09:40.716 --> 01:09:45.332
<v Sameer Kanal>And my understanding is that the master plan does not look at the things that are neighboring it.

820
01:09:45.654 --> 01:09:46.347
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to that a little bit?

821
01:09:46.395 --> 01:09:46.444
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

822
01:09:47.418 --> 01:09:53.301
<v Robert Taylor>Yeah, so the application, again, is for the site owned by the applicant.

823
01:09:53.766 --> 01:10:02.378
<v Robert Taylor>They're requesting approval for their property, and the zoning code lays out the master plan requirement for the 20% open area.

824
01:10:03.342 --> 01:10:08.806
<v Robert Taylor>The code does not specify a way that that standard could be met offsite.

825
01:10:09.144 --> 01:10:10.895
<v Robert Taylor>It's written to be met onsite.

826
01:10:11.314 --> 01:10:26.720
<v Robert Taylor>If council were to ignore the criterion and decide that it would need to be— it could be met offsite, this takings analysis would still apply in terms of things that we're asking of the applicant.

827
01:10:27.431 --> 01:10:27.609
<v Raymond C. Lee>Great.

828
01:10:28.384 --> 01:10:50.382
<v Sameer Kanal>And last question, I'm not sure if it's for you or for staff, but there's been a lot of commentary about meaningful engagement, and I wanted to understand what the legal requirements we have there in terms, uh, not us, meaningful, uh, engagement requirements that exist on the applicant, um, and how those are defined and to the degree to which we're being asked to assess that or not.

829
01:10:52.954 --> 01:10:54.561
<v Unidentified speaker>I can answer that, Councilor.

830
01:10:54.707 --> 01:11:01.882
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so there, the zoning code specifies notice requirements that the city has to fulfill.

831
01:11:02.720 --> 01:11:10.127
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, they— the zoning code specifies posting requirements that the applicant has to fulfill on the site.

832
01:11:10.932 --> 01:11:18.514
<v Unidentified speaker>But that's kind of the extent of the public engagement that is required other than attending the hearing.

833
01:11:18.595 --> 01:11:24.755
<v Unidentified speaker>So they were required to do the design advice, which they did in 2023.

834
01:11:25.550 --> 01:11:30.671
<v Unidentified speaker>They were required to post the site with posting boards all around the perimeter of the site.

835
01:11:31.572 --> 01:11:35.050
<v Unidentified speaker>And then the city mailed out public notice as required by the zoning code.

836
01:11:35.097 --> 01:11:35.226
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

837
01:11:36.914 --> 01:11:37.076
<v Jonas Biery>Okay.

838
01:11:37.123 --> 01:11:39.320
<v Unidentified speaker>That's the extent of the zoning code requirements.

839
01:11:39.801 --> 01:11:43.890
<v Sameer Kanal>And that, that's inclusive of not just requirements on us, but on the applicant as well?

840
01:11:44.148 --> 01:11:44.628
<v Robert Taylor>Exactly.

841
01:11:44.949 --> 01:11:46.873
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, thank you.

842
01:11:46.938 --> 01:11:47.692
<v Dan Ryan>That concludes my questions.

843
01:11:47.965 --> 01:11:48.671
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

844
01:11:48.863 --> 01:11:49.552
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

845
01:11:50.546 --> 01:11:51.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

846
01:11:51.829 --> 01:12:12.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I will just note, because Councilor Kanal asked the question about engagement, that broadly, not just in our land use process, We call things engagement that are not engagement, and we call things notification when they are happening so late that neighbors do not actually have an opportunity to provide meaningful input.

847
01:12:12.619 --> 01:12:19.801
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that is something that I hope we as a council can address broadly and not just in this process.

848
01:12:20.573 --> 01:12:32.516
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we are going to say we are a city that takes our people's concerns seriously in a city that wants Portlanders to have a say in our city's future, we need to actually create that opportunity.

849
01:12:32.775 --> 01:12:34.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if we don't, we need to stop saying we do.

850
01:12:36.550 --> 01:12:41.335
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Neither here nor there for this process, but Councilor Kanal, you brought it up and it needed to be said.

851
01:12:43.457 --> 01:12:43.960
<v Claire Adamsick>Thank you.

852
01:12:44.430 --> 01:12:50.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I want to start by thanking the appellants for stepping forward.

853
01:12:52.929 --> 01:13:02.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will not control the city of our future, that the future of our city, unless we assert what the future of our city could be, should be what we think we need.

854
01:13:03.536 --> 01:13:26.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And even though you have heard from many of my colleagues and will likely hear from many more today that in a land use process we have narrow paths that we can move forward on, bringing forward these appeals allows the space for conversation about what our city should and could be that won't happen otherwise.

855
01:13:27.568 --> 01:13:29.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So thank you for bringing this to us.

856
01:13:31.069 --> 01:13:38.458
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Legally, it is very clear, as some of my colleagues have established, that we cannot prevent the demolition of Lloyd Center or of the ice rink.

857
01:13:39.636 --> 01:13:43.233
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those paths just do not exist, whether or not we want them to.

858
01:13:44.497 --> 01:13:50.885
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The question then is, does the master plan before us meet the conditions that are required in the master planning process?

859
01:13:51.952 --> 01:14:05.440
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If it does not, do we think we will better meet those conditions without a master plan through denial, which we have heard will lead to not a new draft of a master plan but demolition without a master plan?

860
01:14:07.649 --> 01:14:15.355
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if it does mostly meet the conditions but leaves some concerns, are there revisions that would allow Allow the plan to meet the conditions more fully.

861
01:14:17.154 --> 01:14:25.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I want to ask some questions about a few of the conditions which have been appealed to better understand if the conditions have been fully met.

862
01:14:26.828 --> 01:14:32.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I want to start with a question broadly about the conditions within the master plan process, Lauren.

863
01:14:34.119 --> 01:14:45.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are a whole lot of requirements laid out in the master plan process, or what we call requirements, but they don't in the language in our master plan documents.

864
01:14:45.945 --> 01:14:50.996
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The documents that guide this process appear to all be individually binding.

865
01:14:52.328 --> 01:14:53.083
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that the case?

866
01:14:54.000 --> 01:15:04.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does our applicant need to meet every single condition thoroughly, or does the applicant need to meet the generality of all of the conditions?

867
01:15:05.845 --> 01:15:09.993
<v Robert Taylor>The applicant has to satisfy all conditions of approval.

868
01:15:10.768 --> 01:15:13.381
<v Robert Taylor>I guess I'm not totally sure what you're—.

869
01:15:13.528 --> 01:15:14.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I think the language—.

870
01:15:15.770 --> 01:15:16.610
<v Robert Taylor>And I'm gonna pull up—.

871
01:15:16.610 --> 01:15:29.149
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In the documents that create the master plan process and the language that the Design Commission used talked about the applicant encouraging certain types of development.

872
01:15:32.506 --> 01:15:34.909
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But there are a whole lot of conditions in it.

873
01:15:35.409 --> 01:15:50.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess what I'm getting at is when I look at the appeals, there is a lot of concern raised by the appellants about the extent to which each condition has been met.

874
01:15:51.565 --> 01:15:56.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm trying to understand, I'll try to pull one out as an example.

875
01:15:56.792 --> 01:15:57.020
<v Doug Wade>Okay.

876
01:15:57.170 --> 01:16:03.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll take Policy 1 LV3, Tourism, Retail, and Entertainment.

877
01:16:04.412 --> 01:16:14.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Support the continued success of Rose Quarter and Convention Center and encourage new development and businesses that complement and balance the episodic nature of event activity.

878
01:16:15.069 --> 01:16:34.877
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the master plan clearly creates opportunity for that, but there were concerns raised by the appellants that it doesn't create enough opportunity or that it doesn't create opportunity that is different from what exists elsewhere.

879
01:16:34.925 --> 01:16:41.204
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I guess I'm trying to understand to what degree do we need to be looking at here?

880
01:16:41.269 --> 01:16:46.016
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is this a, you do this to some extent, great, check the box, we move to the next one?

881
01:16:46.765 --> 01:16:48.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or is there— I think that's a great question.

882
01:16:50.738 --> 01:16:58.469
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there legally a higher bar for what extent to which each of these individually have to be met?

883
01:16:59.527 --> 01:17:05.019
<v Robert Taylor>Okay, so the criteria of approval, I guess, is what you're referring to.

884
01:17:05.100 --> 01:17:08.739
<v Robert Taylor>And the applicant application does have to meet all of the criteria of approval.

885
01:17:09.609 --> 01:17:16.788
<v Robert Taylor>It is within council's authority to interpret what those criteria of approval require.

886
01:17:17.417 --> 01:17:25.693
<v Robert Taylor>And so to the extent the extent of whether or not they've been met by the application is something that council has to decide based on the evidence presented before them.

887
01:17:26.127 --> 01:17:26.385
<v Sharon Blair>Okay.

888
01:17:27.046 --> 01:17:41.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So where our ability to make some determinations, because as we've established, there are some limitations there, is within to what extent we think these criteria have been met and need to be met.

889
01:17:41.725 --> 01:17:52.770
<v Robert Taylor>So council would interpret what the criteria requires what council thinks is necessary to satisfy that criteria and would conclude based on the evidence in the record whether that criteria has been met.

890
01:17:53.143 --> 01:17:53.466
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

891
01:17:55.454 --> 01:17:59.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I think that's important just to have said as we think about some of these pieces.

892
01:17:59.917 --> 01:18:03.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I wanna ask about 2 or 3 in particular.

893
01:18:05.640 --> 01:18:13.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is 5LD1, which is the ordinance which is the distinct— the diverse and distinctive urban places.

894
01:18:14.711 --> 01:18:30.675
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that was raised by the appellants, um, who essentially say this is not diverse or distinct, that this looks like many other urban places.

895
01:18:31.286 --> 01:18:49.877
<v Robert Taylor>So can you help me understand the language in 5L So, Councilor, I'm working on pulling up the approval criteria, although I would also like to turn to staff to speak a little bit about what the Design Commission found.

896
01:18:49.974 --> 01:18:52.896
<v Robert Taylor>So do you have the approval criteria that we can put up on the screen?

897
01:18:54.118 --> 01:18:59.610
<v Unidentified speaker>I have the Central City policies that I can put up on the screen if that's what we're talking about.

898
01:18:59.658 --> 01:18:59.997
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I'll be—.

899
01:18:59.997 --> 01:19:01.168
<v Robert Taylor>Yeah, I'll be happy to take a look at that.

900
01:19:05.774 --> 01:19:11.423
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think either the policies or the— I know there was a kind of a chart put together for us.

901
01:19:14.430 --> 01:19:15.444
<v Unidentified speaker>I can share that as well.

902
01:19:15.653 --> 01:19:35.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just want to make sure that we are truly doing our due diligence and being thorough in our work here, because there were some pieces that were raised where I think that question of to what extent is an if I can be helpful with a response, let me know, but I won't jump in unless asked.

903
01:19:35.854 --> 01:19:49.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm happy to hear from staff about what, what is required, but I'm also happy to hear from the applicant about how you think you're meeting these pieces, if that— if there are pieces you'd like to add.

904
01:19:49.841 --> 01:19:58.056
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, the Design Commission's findings for Policy 5 LD1, Diverse and Distinct Urban Places, are on the screen right now.

905
01:19:58.811 --> 01:19:59.197
<v Ann Casper>Mm-hmm.

906
01:19:59.324 --> 01:20:09.898
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, Design Commission found that development in the Lloyd Center master plan area is likely to be of higher intensity than exist— than the existing shopping mall and parking uses that are— that currently predominate on the site.

907
01:20:10.699 --> 01:20:22.139
<v Unidentified speaker>The master plan area anticipates and can accommodate between 2.2 million and 6.8 million square feet of development, which is significantly more than the 1.18 million square feet of development currently on the site.

908
01:20:22.492 --> 01:20:37.875
<v Unidentified speaker>The master plan provides opportunities for mixed-use development with a hierarchy of block sizes that can accommodate a range of uses and serve to strengthen the emerging mixture of residential neighborhoods interspersed with commercial offices and major regional attractors.

909
01:20:38.389 --> 01:20:57.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think part of the challenge here is that this policy is titled Diverse and Distinct Urban Places, but the information underneath that in the yellow that you have up there is that it fosters more intense development and strengthens the district character, which is different from diverse and distinct urban places.

910
01:20:57.980 --> 01:21:11.212
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have appeals that are focused on diverse and distinct urban places, and I think very rightfully point out that this development may be less distinct in its nature than Lloyd Center.

911
01:21:11.260 --> 01:21:11.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It may not be.

912
01:21:11.981 --> 01:21:12.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't know yet.

913
01:21:12.960 --> 01:21:15.413
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That will happen through the development process.

914
01:21:16.729 --> 01:21:26.158
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But the argument that was made through the Design Commission is about that subtext— more intense development, more development, more space.

915
01:21:27.136 --> 01:21:37.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I've been trying to parse the fact that we have an appeal on a very different piece of language than what it sounds like we actually have to meet.

916
01:21:37.159 --> 01:21:39.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That subtext sounds like what we actually have to meet.

917
01:21:40.305 --> 01:21:41.654
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that appears to be met here.

918
01:21:41.734 --> 01:21:49.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't know from the applicant if there's anything you want to add about the diverse and distinct piece, or if you really have been focused on that intensity of development piece.

919
01:21:49.831 --> 01:21:51.324
<v Christy White>Yes, thank you for the opportunity.

920
01:21:51.404 --> 01:21:54.279
<v Christy White>Again, it's Christy White, legal counsel for the applicant.

921
01:21:54.987 --> 01:22:07.034
<v Christy White>I would take a step back before you get right to the language of the design guideline, which is the design guidelines are not prescriptive standards, so they can't dictate or— and don't intend to dictate a specific use.

922
01:22:07.612 --> 01:22:15.338
<v Christy White>And then the master plan itself is an urban design framework, which doesn't then again dictate specific uses.

923
01:22:15.386 --> 01:22:28.467
<v Christy White>So what the Design Commission is looking at when it looks at Policy 5LD-1, it looks at both the title, distinct, diverse and distinct urban places, which is how the city has decided to title that subtext.

924
01:22:28.932 --> 01:22:33.149
<v Christy White>And then it goes to the subtext and looks at the urban framework standpoint.

925
01:22:33.662 --> 01:22:36.113
<v Christy White>And not at specific future uses.

926
01:22:36.610 --> 01:22:49.527
<v Christy White>And when it looked at that, it said, okay, we as a city have a code we've developed for the Central City and the Lloyd District that intentionally puts heights, density, and open spaces in this area.

927
01:22:49.686 --> 01:22:55.664
<v Christy White>Does this urban framework better accommodate that under this design guideline than the current mall?

928
01:22:56.096 --> 01:22:58.469
<v Christy White>And the answer was yes, unequivocally.

929
01:22:58.581 --> 01:22:58.676
<v Dori Hellyer>Thank you.

930
01:22:59.289 --> 01:23:10.332
<v Christy White>And this language that you see here is a summary of much greater findings in the Central City Master Plan about how that accommodates it.

931
01:23:10.430 --> 01:23:11.952
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we've seen those greater findings.

932
01:23:12.001 --> 01:23:23.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think this is part of what I've been looking at as I've looked through here and thought about the appellant's arguments is that we do have these abbreviated headers.

933
01:23:25.787 --> 01:23:26.046
<v Loretta Smith>Sure.

934
01:23:26.368 --> 01:23:35.018
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And a whole lot that you are looking to meet below that, which are met even if the language of the header is perhaps not.

935
01:23:36.466 --> 01:23:42.237
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I did have some questions about 1LD3 and 2LD3.

936
01:23:42.398 --> 01:23:58.545
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the appellant's arguments on these were interesting to me because these are the policies that look at Activation, the one that I read actually as an example previously, and community building.

937
01:23:58.962 --> 01:24:06.765
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it appeared to me that the Design Commission relied a lot on the inclusion of open space to meet those criteria.

938
01:24:07.744 --> 01:24:14.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm struggling with that because a master plan requires open space by its nature.

939
01:24:14.729 --> 01:24:15.097
<v Ann Casper>Mm-hmm.

940
01:24:16.141 --> 01:24:27.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so if we're meeting our community building requirements and our space activation requirements through something that is already necessarily required.

941
01:24:28.260 --> 01:24:41.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess I'm wondering why those policies— and I think this is a question for staff— why are those policies included if they can be met just by the nature of having your 20% open space?

942
01:24:41.788 --> 01:24:45.231
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Generally, legally, if something is written out, it means something different is required.

943
01:24:45.313 --> 01:24:45.878
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a great question.

944
01:24:46.960 --> 01:24:58.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so what is it that we should be looking for under activation and community building in a plan which doesn't have details yet?

945
01:24:58.356 --> 01:24:59.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It doesn't have to.

946
01:24:59.231 --> 01:25:00.497
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's not a criticism.

947
01:25:00.773 --> 01:25:02.492
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're not at that place yet.

948
01:25:04.724 --> 01:25:11.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In order to meet those requirements, because I struggle with meeting that just by the inclusion of open space that is already required to be included.

949
01:25:13.029 --> 01:25:19.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So what have previous councils looked at there, and what should we be looking for?

950
01:25:23.032 --> 01:25:33.993
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't believe the previous councils have actually evaluated these Central City 2035 policies before in the context of a Central City Master Plan.

951
01:25:36.118 --> 01:25:41.695
<v Unidentified speaker>These policies were adopted, I want to say, in 2018, and the master plan process hasn't come before the City Council since then.

952
01:25:43.891 --> 01:25:46.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we're really setting the precedent here.

953
01:25:46.654 --> 01:25:49.416
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't have precedent on how to interpret these that we should be looking at.

954
01:25:49.771 --> 01:25:54.300
<v Unidentified speaker>The Design Commission has set its precedent, but the council has not.

955
01:25:55.238 --> 01:25:55.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

956
01:25:56.757 --> 01:26:08.154
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there— I'm trying to choose my words carefully given the limitations in what is required in a master plan.

957
01:26:12.412 --> 01:26:21.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there plans that can be shared around the activation of spaces or the creation of year-round active spaces?

958
01:26:21.622 --> 01:26:42.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because what I'm seeing is that we are supposed to be meeting community building standards through open space, which in a city that Where it rains half the year is an interesting way of meeting that requirement.

959
01:26:44.452 --> 01:27:02.292
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And when we're moving from active spaces, meaning spaces with active activities, to open space, which can be activated but is not necessarily activated, I also Wonder about the community building.

960
01:27:02.405 --> 01:27:25.154
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I wonder if there's anything that I can hear about what the plans are that might help us feel confident that that requirement is in fact going to be met in a way beyond just having the already required 20% open spaces that we may not be seeing right now.

961
01:27:25.461 --> 01:27:27.292
<v Christy White>Yeah, great question, and I'm happy to answer it.

962
01:27:28.399 --> 01:27:32.126
<v Christy White>The open space, you're correct, is a requirement of the code.

963
01:27:32.253 --> 01:27:37.859
<v Christy White>The question under this design guideline is how the rest of the plan interacts with that open space.

964
01:27:38.373 --> 01:27:44.525
<v Christy White>And so what we have now is a large concrete mall surrounded by parking structures.

965
01:27:44.637 --> 01:28:20.092
<v Christy White>And so the question for the Design Commission was, does the new grid system that's going to be introduced into this 27-acre area Connecting it to the neighborhoods on both sides and requiring very specific locations for ground floor active uses, ground floor window treatments, ground floor entrances that are reflective of the surrounding public right-of-way and public spaces, as well as the open space and park areas, is a good response to LD3.

966
01:28:20.204 --> 01:28:22.599
<v Christy White>And the Design Commission unequivocally found so.

967
01:28:23.033 --> 01:28:38.426
<v Christy White>Because what you're doing is creating a new community at the ground floor that allows people to pass through, around, between blocks, and creating ground floor active uses that can spill out onto all of those public spaces.

968
01:28:38.876 --> 01:28:40.658
<v Christy White>So it isn't just the open space.

969
01:28:41.092 --> 01:29:02.028
<v Christy White>The master plan also goes through a parcelization with, as Ben said, a tiered block size that accommodates different And then on top of all of that, you have the CX zoning, which allows outright many of those uses, if not all of those uses, that have been contemplated in the public conversation.

970
01:29:04.630 --> 01:29:07.751
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It looks like you have somebody up there who might want to respond as well.

971
01:29:07.798 --> 01:29:10.710
<v Christy White>The lead architect is probably better suited to answer the question.

972
01:29:10.791 --> 01:29:15.033
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the director of planning and urban design with CGF, and we prepared the Central City Master Plan.

973
01:29:15.627 --> 01:29:19.412
<v Unidentified speaker>I just, well, for the AIA, I wanna point out I'm not an architect.

974
01:29:19.604 --> 01:29:20.438
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, sorry.

975
01:29:20.679 --> 01:29:21.015
<v Unidentified speaker>Just so I—.

976
01:29:21.159 --> 01:29:21.945
<v Christy White>Our lead designer.

977
01:29:22.154 --> 01:29:22.443
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

978
01:29:23.228 --> 01:29:37.868
<v Unidentified speaker>But there's something sort of high level that I thought might be helpful context, and that is that the CCMP language states that the Central City Master Plan is consistent with applicable subdistrict goals and policies of the Central City 2035 Plan.

979
01:29:39.342 --> 01:29:45.511
<v Unidentified speaker>But the Central City 2035 Plan goals and policies were not written specifically to be applied to CCMP.

980
01:29:45.609 --> 01:29:57.680
<v Unidentified speaker>They're written to guide the city's review of everything— your own planning, your own street design, all the way down to buildings and the design of a sidewalk.

981
01:29:58.145 --> 01:30:03.643
<v Unidentified speaker>And so it's hard for these to be written at a level that applies to those things equally.

982
01:30:03.771 --> 01:30:12.635
<v Unidentified speaker>And so as you— as the Design Commission reviews a district versus a building versus a plaza, It's gotta interpret them at a different level of detail.

983
01:30:13.020 --> 01:30:17.853
<v Unidentified speaker>And so as Kristi said, what we're reviewing is a design framework.

984
01:30:18.333 --> 01:30:21.546
<v Unidentified speaker>It's about the size and scale of streets, what they can accommodate.

985
01:30:21.947 --> 01:30:33.170
<v Unidentified speaker>And we've assigned streets and open spaces and building sites responsibilities, which we've described in terms of how they will contribute to the district and to the other parts of the plan.

986
01:30:33.251 --> 01:30:33.443
<v Sarah Heinecke>And so I think—.

987
01:30:33.443 --> 01:30:34.599
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's a good point.

988
01:30:34.680 --> 01:30:52.916
<v Unidentified speaker>I think, you know, if I look at this community building, what we've done with the open space system is to provide diversity of scale, diversity of orientation and relationship to the private building locations and to the other public realm and to the public streets that pass through the district.

989
01:30:54.372 --> 01:31:02.279
<v Unidentified speaker>So the buildings and plazas and parks that follow will have more detail that can be judged against these criteria.

990
01:31:02.327 --> 01:31:02.472
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

991
01:31:03.570 --> 01:31:08.123
<v Unidentified speaker>But we think that at the urban design framework level that we've addressed it.

992
01:31:10.521 --> 01:31:10.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

993
01:31:10.862 --> 01:31:11.898
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate hearing that.

994
01:31:12.059 --> 01:31:30.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am still struggling a little bit with this policy that says encourage public spaces and the public space requirement being met with public space that is already required elsewhere and design that allows the use of that space.

995
01:31:33.020 --> 01:31:47.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, I started by saying it's clear that we can't prevent the demolition of Lloyd Center or the ice rink, and it really is clear to me that the master plan does mostly meet the conditions that are laid out.

996
01:31:50.337 --> 01:31:57.521
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But there are a few of these policies where I think the plan has has left something to be desired.

997
01:31:57.747 --> 01:32:07.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Knoll, you asked a question about conditions and a condition of an ice rink specifically.

998
01:32:07.162 --> 01:32:12.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We heard that that would most certainly be appealed as a taking.

999
01:32:13.510 --> 01:32:24.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am wondering what a condition around year-round active use spaces, Not just open spaces, which would not necessarily require an ice rink.

1000
01:32:24.710 --> 01:32:29.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to be very clear that could be met in any number of ways.

1001
01:32:31.909 --> 01:32:47.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But whether it would be appropriate under this community building item to have a condition around the inclusion of some sort of active space usable year-round.

1002
01:32:49.038 --> 01:32:59.872
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For community building in addition to what is laid out already in the design as part of the approval that council moves forward.

1003
01:32:59.921 --> 01:33:02.442
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Lauren, I don't know if you have any comments on that.

1004
01:33:06.564 --> 01:33:16.797
<v Robert Taylor>I would just say that if council wants to draft such a condition, then I would definitely want to have a sidebar with staff to make Sure that it works with the other conditions.

1005
01:33:18.154 --> 01:33:21.784
<v Robert Taylor>So I'm hesitant to try to write a condition on the fly.

1006
01:33:22.252 --> 01:33:22.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Understood.

1007
01:33:23.835 --> 01:33:24.206
<v Robert Taylor>From here.

1008
01:33:27.385 --> 01:33:46.471
<v Robert Taylor>And just so I understand, Policy 2, LD 3, Community Building, Encourage Public Spaces, what you're asking is whether council could interpret that criteria to require an active some sort of active public space.

1009
01:33:46.907 --> 01:33:48.159
<v Sameer Kanal>Recreation.

1010
01:33:48.417 --> 01:34:08.122
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And some sort of public, some sort of active recreation public space that moves us beyond where I think the Design Commission relied pretty heavily, which is the open space that is already required in the plan separate from this community building policy.

1011
01:34:13.572 --> 01:34:15.078
<v Robert Taylor>I don't know if staff wants to comment.

1012
01:34:15.271 --> 01:34:18.229
<v Robert Taylor>I guess I have some thoughts, but—.

1013
01:34:18.327 --> 01:34:20.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, we're at 15 minutes.

1014
01:34:20.271 --> 01:34:21.146
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Done after this.

1015
01:34:21.390 --> 01:34:21.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1016
01:34:21.634 --> 01:34:23.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the last thing I'm going to say, I promise.

1017
01:34:24.130 --> 01:34:24.372
<v Micah Goldstein>Thank you.

1018
01:34:28.515 --> 01:34:32.868
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor, I'm trying to think of, uh, how to answer this question.

1019
01:34:34.270 --> 01:34:43.345
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the river placement yeah, in terms of crafting a condition of approval, I agree with Lauren.

1020
01:34:43.395 --> 01:34:45.211
<v Unidentified speaker>That's something we wouldn't want to do on the fly.

1021
01:34:50.555 --> 01:35:02.289
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't necessarily see the direct nexus to the year-round part of your condition, and that's maybe where I'm struggling just a little bit.

1022
01:35:02.372 --> 01:35:02.858
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's where we're struggling.

1023
01:35:05.922 --> 01:35:17.203
<v Christy White>I think I might be helpful in that the word encourage has been interpreted under the Riverplace Master Plan to— at a framework level.

1024
01:35:17.332 --> 01:35:20.184
<v Christy White>So it might be really important to refer to those findings.

1025
01:35:20.280 --> 01:35:24.916
<v Christy White>That's in our legal argument in the brief provided to council.

1026
01:35:25.368 --> 01:35:28.002
<v Christy White>But it means facilitate through an urban framework.

1027
01:35:28.051 --> 01:35:28.908
<v Christy White>It doesn't mean, you know, encourage development.

1028
01:35:28.956 --> 01:35:29.005
<v Ben Henson>Okay.

1029
01:35:30.801 --> 01:35:41.195
<v Christy White>And I would just emphasize, to impose a condition of approval, it must be tied to a development standard that requires that condition, or you can't meet the development standard.

1030
01:35:41.260 --> 01:35:44.600
<v Christy White>And we don't have a development standard here that requires a community building.

1031
01:35:45.581 --> 01:35:56.471
<v Christy White>Although, having said that, I just want to again emphasize that all of these ground floors are ground floors that can be activated by any uses that are allowed in the CA.

1032
01:35:56.520 --> 01:35:56.649
<v Christy White>Thank you.

1033
01:35:59.362 --> 01:36:12.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Certainly, though, we should presume that they'll probably be developed in a way that maximizes profit for whatever groups purchase those from the current owner.

1034
01:36:12.729 --> 01:36:20.747
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I don't think that's a bad thing by any means, but the only way that we as a council ensure certain things are done is to make sure that we have a process in place.

1035
01:36:21.431 --> 01:36:21.953
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

1036
01:36:22.372 --> 01:36:27.536
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Conditions are met beyond that is by stating that they need to be met.

1037
01:36:27.875 --> 01:36:41.394
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I hear you, and I know that we've heard from the current property owner that they are very open to the development of some of the things that have been brought forward, which would be competing with everything else bidding on those properties.

1038
01:36:42.976 --> 01:36:52.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do note the word encourage, and I remember in your presentation and in the documents that you submitted talking about that other case.

1039
01:36:53.215 --> 01:36:58.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I've also heard that each piece of this does need to be met.

1040
01:36:59.832 --> 01:37:02.682
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have to encourage.

1041
01:37:03.520 --> 01:37:08.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't have to do the thing, but we are required to ensure that this encourages.

1042
01:37:11.422 --> 01:37:18.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think there's some question there about whether that means this is actually a true requirement or not, though we heard from staff that these things are requirements.

1043
01:37:22.412 --> 01:37:31.524
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hear staff not wanting to develop something on the fly, and that's fine, but I also think it's important that I say out loud that I wonder if there is something we should do there.

1044
01:37:31.720 --> 01:37:32.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't vote today.

1045
01:37:33.016 --> 01:37:40.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My colleagues will have an opportunity to weigh in, and they may or may not be interested in in moving in that direction, and that's okay.

1046
01:37:41.055 --> 01:37:52.997
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I do think it's important to, to point out these pieces where there may still be some weaknesses in how the policies are met, and we can determine if we want to apply conditions or not.

1047
01:37:53.960 --> 01:37:59.922
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do think that for the most part, the application meets the requirements.

1048
01:38:00.051 --> 01:38:05.292
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are just some pieces where we might be able to have it meet those requirements in an even stronger way.

1049
01:38:05.341 --> 01:38:05.436
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

1050
01:38:06.384 --> 01:38:07.845
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, I'll stop there.

1051
01:38:08.471 --> 01:38:17.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Folks have heard my thoughts and can either express interest or not as we move forward with our deliberations over the next few weeks, I think it is.

1052
01:38:18.024 --> 01:38:18.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1053
01:38:18.972 --> 01:38:26.422
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I didn't want to interrupt Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, but our rules of decorum in the chamber require non-audible shows of support or disapproval.

1054
01:38:26.600 --> 01:38:30.998
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was hoping to sort of let the snapping fly, but then I heard boos and hissing.

1055
01:38:31.496 --> 01:38:36.735
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm going to ask the council— the people in the audience, please continue with non-audible shows of support.

1056
01:38:36.800 --> 01:38:41.814
<v Jamie Dunphy>Jazz hands, thumbs down, all good options, but let's not let this become a distraction, please.

1057
01:38:41.912 --> 01:38:42.456
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1058
01:38:42.889 --> 01:38:43.417
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1059
01:38:43.689 --> 01:38:44.971
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

1060
01:38:45.389 --> 01:38:48.609
<v Dan Ryan>First, I do want to thank all the people who have come out to share their thoughts.

1061
01:38:48.673 --> 01:38:50.467
<v Dan Ryan>It's been really heartfelt testimony.

1062
01:38:51.381 --> 01:38:57.998
<v Dan Ryan>It's great to see this type of engagement in Portland and especially in the district that I represent along with my colleagues to the right of me.

1063
01:38:58.353 --> 01:38:59.926
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1064
01:39:00.264 --> 01:39:03.042
<v Dan Ryan>I also just really enjoyed hearing the stories and all the positive experiences.

1065
01:39:03.155 --> 01:39:13.628
<v Dan Ryan>I noticed that everyone talked about their positive experiences of Lloyd Center, even if they thought it was dead and needs to move forward, and those that are activating it at this time.

1066
01:39:13.756 --> 01:39:22.704
<v Dan Ryan>There was no debate over Portlanders' love affair with the Lloyd Center since it's been a big part of our history and since the '60s.

1067
01:39:23.411 --> 01:39:24.166
<v Dan Ryan>I grew up with it.

1068
01:39:24.359 --> 01:39:32.467
<v Dan Ryan>I was born and raised near So I just thought there was only one mall in the entire world and it was Lloyd Center.

1069
01:39:33.063 --> 01:39:40.368
<v Dan Ryan>So, and I've cheered for every attempt to stop the exits of flagship stores that was taking place.

1070
01:39:40.497 --> 01:39:50.114
<v Dan Ryan>I went to the opening when Tom Cobain worked with people to lease out the spots in— was that?

1071
01:39:50.291 --> 01:39:50.805
<v Sameer Kanal>Lloyd Center.

1072
01:39:50.885 --> 01:39:51.238
<v Sameer Kanal>Lloyd Center.

1073
01:39:52.233 --> 01:39:54.574
<v Dan Ryan>When was that, 2021 or 2022?

1074
01:39:55.744 --> 01:39:56.418
<v Doug Wade>2022.

1075
01:39:56.884 --> 01:39:57.942
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, it was so festive.

1076
01:39:57.989 --> 01:39:58.969
<v Dan Ryan>It was a beautiful affair.

1077
01:39:59.033 --> 01:40:06.521
<v Dan Ryan>And I remember even people that had leased it saying, I know this is only temporary, but it's really a wonderful opportunity to learn how to run a storefront.

1078
01:40:06.649 --> 01:40:08.831
<v Dan Ryan>And it brought a lot of energy back.

1079
01:40:08.911 --> 01:40:10.403
<v Dan Ryan>And so I've been rooting for it.

1080
01:40:11.556 --> 01:40:15.854
<v Dan Ryan>I go to the Lloyd Athletic Club, don't go as much as I should, since 1997.

1081
01:40:16.144 --> 01:40:20.926
<v Dan Ryan>So I've been able to see all of these The ex parte was kind of odd.

1082
01:40:21.006 --> 01:40:26.483
<v Dan Ryan>I felt like I could have been talking about my relationship with Lloyd Center for way too long, so I tried to summarize it.

1083
01:40:27.365 --> 01:40:34.832
<v Dan Ryan>Anyway, I miss the vitality and vibrancy it once had, and I'm trying to be respectful for those that still experience it.

1084
01:40:35.378 --> 01:40:37.546
<v Dan Ryan>But big picture, I really, really miss it.

1085
01:40:38.270 --> 01:40:42.621
<v Dan Ryan>I have seen a very long time since the space was utilized to its potential.

1086
01:40:43.503 --> 01:40:45.688
<v Dan Ryan>And I really want to thank Urban Renaissance Group and the Thank you, Mayor.

1087
01:40:45.735 --> 01:40:45.864
<v Micah Goldstein>Thank you.

1088
01:40:45.912 --> 01:40:49.570
<v Dan Ryan>I'd like to thank the architects and urban planners for working with the city on our master plan.

1089
01:40:50.148 --> 01:40:52.297
<v Dan Ryan>That is something that doesn't always happen.

1090
01:40:53.516 --> 01:40:56.742
<v Dan Ryan>Gee, thanks for giving the sign that they could do gestures like this.

1091
01:40:57.207 --> 01:40:58.137
<v Dan Ryan>I'll look over here.

1092
01:40:59.550 --> 01:41:01.411
<v Dan Ryan>No, just having fun with all of you.

1093
01:41:01.796 --> 01:41:03.529
<v Dan Ryan>You got to make light of this stuff sometimes.

1094
01:41:04.684 --> 01:41:10.587
<v Dan Ryan>There are 2 primary concerns I've heard are preserving an ice rink and objections to the demolition.

1095
01:41:11.421 --> 01:41:14.789
<v Dan Ryan>Neither of these items are applicable to the city's master plan criteria and scope.

1096
01:41:14.869 --> 01:41:25.725
<v Dan Ryan>The applicant will be able to demolish the mall without the master plan, and they were not able to require that a party in the future build an ice rink as part of the master plan.

1097
01:41:26.416 --> 01:41:33.198
<v Dan Ryan>That would have been a separate conversation and agreement between interested parties elsewhere outside of this hearing.

1098
01:41:33.471 --> 01:41:34.979
<v Dan Ryan>I want to ditto everything you said.

1099
01:41:35.059 --> 01:41:47.341
<v Dan Ryan>You kind of— I was real excited to announce that I think we should We should work with the people at Rip City Management and Winterhawks to figure this out.

1100
01:41:47.551 --> 01:41:49.354
<v Dan Ryan>Like, why couldn't there be lessons there?

1101
01:41:49.420 --> 01:41:50.692
<v Dan Ryan>How could we get a shared agreement?

1102
01:41:51.175 --> 01:41:53.783
<v Dan Ryan>We're the landlords of the Memorial Coliseum.

1103
01:41:53.847 --> 01:41:56.262
<v Dan Ryan>It's by far a better ice rink, if you will.

1104
01:41:56.664 --> 01:41:58.530
<v Dan Ryan>And then imagine family skate night.

1105
01:41:58.578 --> 01:42:01.730
<v Dan Ryan>Open up the curtains, have some great music, do some light show.

1106
01:42:02.036 --> 01:42:03.257
<v Dan Ryan>How playful, how wonderful, how Portlandia.

1107
01:42:03.323 --> 01:42:03.805
<v Dan Ryan>I think the city should be the landlord.

1108
01:42:04.396 --> 01:42:05.827
<v Dan Ryan>And see the view of the city.

1109
01:42:06.019 --> 01:42:15.140
<v Dan Ryan>Like, let's— we have options, City Council, that aren't a part of this decision that can allow us to bring vibrancy to that very important part of our city.

1110
01:42:16.072 --> 01:42:19.042
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you for mentioning that, President Dunphy.

1111
01:42:19.188 --> 01:42:21.868
<v Dan Ryan>I'm on the working group with you about that.

1112
01:42:22.238 --> 01:42:26.012
<v Dan Ryan>But today, let's get back to our reality, the reality of our decision today.

1113
01:42:27.136 --> 01:42:36.467
<v Dan Ryan>Today, our tentative decision is about recognizing the process and the work completed by the applicant, city staff, and the hardworking volunteers at the Design Commission.

1114
01:42:37.158 --> 01:42:43.278
<v Dan Ryan>They completed the process and determined that the applicant sufficiently met criteria of a master plan.

1115
01:42:44.001 --> 01:42:50.394
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate the due diligence of the Design Commission, and after review and consideration, I think they arrived at a very sound decision.

1116
01:42:51.068 --> 01:42:56.706
<v Dan Ryan>Unless there is clear evidence and reason that the criteria are not met, we need to uphold the findings of the Design Commission.

1117
01:42:56.770 --> 01:42:56.914
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1118
01:42:58.934 --> 01:42:59.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1119
01:43:00.055 --> 01:43:00.761
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1120
01:43:01.962 --> 01:43:02.796
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor President.

1121
01:43:02.859 --> 01:43:04.927
<v Olivia Clark>I think some of these questions have been excellent.

1122
01:43:05.024 --> 01:43:10.921
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate, uh, the digging in, but I just have one really simple question, and it might be for the attorneys.

1123
01:43:11.738 --> 01:43:15.936
<v Olivia Clark>Um, this is a well-put-together master plan.

1124
01:43:16.001 --> 01:43:33.006
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate, uh, and I appreciate your answering the questions so well, but I was just curious that, um, There's nothing that requires that this master plan be implemented, that someone could swoop in and buy up this property and do something else with it.

1125
01:43:33.362 --> 01:43:33.929
<v Olivia Clark>Is that true?

1126
01:43:34.738 --> 01:43:39.315
<v Jamie Dunphy>Folks, I'm gonna again ask to not with snapping.

1127
01:43:39.510 --> 01:43:39.865
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1128
01:43:41.500 --> 01:43:46.797
<v Robert Taylor>Councilor Clark, you're asking whether a future property owner is bound by the master plan?

1129
01:43:47.152 --> 01:43:47.489
<v Sarah Heinecke>Right.

1130
01:43:48.037 --> 01:43:58.621
<v Robert Taylor>No, the future property owners are bound by, well, They could come in and get a new master plan or they could decide not to pursue the master plan in terms of how they developed.

1131
01:43:58.685 --> 01:44:01.029
<v Robert Taylor>Yes, they, go ahead if you have more to add.

1132
01:44:01.335 --> 01:44:07.981
<v Christy White>Yeah, if the master plan is approved, it's a vested land use decision that's recorded against and runs with the land.

1133
01:44:08.141 --> 01:44:17.020
<v Christy White>And any successor in interest, if there is one ever, to this property owner would be required to comply with all of the conditions of approval.

1134
01:44:18.514 --> 01:44:19.444
<v Christy White>Within the master plan.

1135
01:44:19.957 --> 01:44:28.381
<v Christy White>There are also provisions in the code if somebody came in and wanted to amend the master plan because some use came along that needed a bigger block size, for example.

1136
01:44:28.703 --> 01:44:35.170
<v Christy White>They would have to come in either through a Type 3 process again or a Type 2, depending on the level of the modification.

1137
01:44:35.764 --> 01:44:50.208
<v Christy White>So the master plan also has a term of 10 years, and so it would terminate after 10 years and somebody would have to Okay.

1138
01:44:50.289 --> 01:44:59.216
<v Olivia Clark>So what you're saying in lay terms is that someone could come in and would have to go through a process to do something differently.

1139
01:44:59.280 --> 01:44:59.409
<v Christy White>Yes.

1140
01:44:59.604 --> 01:45:01.528
<v Christy White>Otherwise, they would just comply with the master plan.

1141
01:45:01.576 --> 01:45:02.417
<v Christy White>It happens all the time.

1142
01:45:02.465 --> 01:45:05.164
<v Christy White>Somebody gets a land use approval, they sell their property.

1143
01:45:05.520 --> 01:45:08.106
<v Christy White>You have to build according to that land use approval.

1144
01:45:08.252 --> 01:45:11.384
<v Christy White>If you want to modify it, you have to come in again through a public process.

1145
01:45:11.448 --> 01:45:11.497
<v Claire Adamsick>Okay.

1146
01:45:12.060 --> 01:45:13.270
<v Olivia Clark>So there is a public process.

1147
01:45:13.336 --> 01:45:13.609
<v Sharon Blair>Yes.

1148
01:45:13.658 --> 01:45:14.851
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for answering that question.

1149
01:45:14.932 --> 01:45:15.529
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate it.

1150
01:45:15.594 --> 01:45:16.948
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

1151
01:45:17.029 --> 01:45:18.014
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1152
01:45:18.109 --> 01:45:18.643
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1153
01:45:20.514 --> 01:45:21.903
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

1154
01:45:22.113 --> 01:45:37.114
<v Mitch Green>Um, I really appreciated kind of this dialogue around the Veterans Memorial Coliseum as being a potential, um, solution to a problem that would be created, um, irrespective of the decision we made today, frankly.

1155
01:45:39.652 --> 01:45:41.310
<v Mitch Green>Both of those impacts are in District 2, I'll note.

1156
01:45:41.858 --> 01:45:44.371
<v Mitch Green>So there's some interesting symmetry there as well.

1157
01:45:45.240 --> 01:45:47.689
<v Mitch Green>So I'm supportive of that kind of thinking in that direction.

1158
01:45:48.989 --> 01:46:03.164
<v Mitch Green>I just think that before we get into the bigger decision here, I want to note that there is a real lack of affordable rent for commercial tenancy in the city of Portland.

1159
01:46:03.213 --> 01:46:03.327
<v Doug Wade>Yes.

1160
01:46:04.024 --> 01:46:04.894
<v Mitch Green>Like, that is real.

1161
01:46:05.296 --> 01:46:11.564
<v Mitch Green>And that is what the Lloyd Center has been able to provide during this period of its basic, like, near insolvency.

1162
01:46:11.917 --> 01:46:17.472
<v Mitch Green>I mean, like, in economics, you have firms that are not bankrupt but are insolvent.

1163
01:46:18.054 --> 01:46:20.849
<v Mitch Green>And the Lloyd Center property is more or less insolvent.

1164
01:46:21.265 --> 01:46:24.028
<v Mitch Green>And so it's at its end of economic life.

1165
01:46:24.738 --> 01:46:29.568
<v Mitch Green>And in that space, you're able to offer essentially deeply, deeply discounted rents.

1166
01:46:29.615 --> 01:46:29.664
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah.

1167
01:46:30.033 --> 01:46:34.466
<v Mitch Green>That have created the opportunity for, in some sense, some flourishment.

1168
01:46:35.255 --> 01:46:36.780
<v Mitch Green>That's actually the Portland I grew up in.

1169
01:46:37.262 --> 01:46:45.791
<v Mitch Green>Like, the Portland that I grew up in had a bunch of really cheap rent, whether that was residential housing stock or it was also commercial housing stock.

1170
01:46:45.872 --> 01:46:49.894
<v Mitch Green>And that enabled artists to do really cool things that then created cultural production.

1171
01:46:50.817 --> 01:47:14.850
<v Mitch Green>And so what, irrespective of this specific land case, I want us to look at the challenge that we're in right now, which is that there is There's a glut of commercial and office vacancy space in the city of Portland, and we have an opportunity to use the tools, the levers that are appropriate to use to help unlock those spaces so people can get into a much lower barrier to entry.

1172
01:47:15.045 --> 01:47:19.118
<v Mitch Green>This is something that we talked about a lot, I think, in the Arts and Economy Committee when that was still a thing.

1173
01:47:20.987 --> 01:47:26.828
<v Mitch Green>That, I think, is the future vision that I see for economic development and allowing that cultural production to happen.

1174
01:47:26.880 --> 01:47:27.032
<v Greg Fox>Thank you.

1175
01:47:29.145 --> 01:47:30.764
<v Mitch Green>The Lloyd Center is not that.

1176
01:47:31.233 --> 01:47:34.938
<v Mitch Green>There is no future for that use in this case.

1177
01:47:35.373 --> 01:47:38.440
<v Mitch Green>That doesn't mean we give up on the dream of building that for Portlanders.

1178
01:47:40.130 --> 01:48:01.465
<v Mitch Green>And so I think that, you know, that's a hard pill to swallow, but the land use decision that we have before us is whether or not we're going to allow a master plan to be used as a tool to have a much more, I think, Promising development opportunity for this set of parcels that would exist, that would happen with or without the master plan.

1179
01:48:01.739 --> 01:48:08.676
<v Mitch Green>But without the master plan, we don't get the ancillary benefits to the city of Portland that come from the infrastructure that's going to be developed as part of this.

1180
01:48:09.096 --> 01:48:11.300
<v Mitch Green>That's a big piece of this, and that's something that we need to know.

1181
01:48:12.976 --> 01:48:22.180
<v Mitch Green>I do have a question, though, for Councilor Pearl Guinea, because you kind of went on for about 20 minutes and There were some important stuff that you were laying in there, and I didn't catch all of it.

1182
01:48:22.456 --> 01:48:24.204
<v Mitch Green>So I just want to make sure I have your intent clearly.

1183
01:48:25.912 --> 01:48:34.265
<v Mitch Green>Are you trying— are you sort of envisioning that we would have a condition that created, like, covered year-round active space?

1184
01:48:34.541 --> 01:48:34.912
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't—.

1185
01:48:35.024 --> 01:48:36.350
<v Mitch Green>I wasn't really fully following that.

1186
01:48:36.802 --> 01:48:46.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, so I asked about a number of things, some of which I think were important to just get on the record as clearly not a place where we have space to intervene.

1187
01:48:48.001 --> 01:49:08.081
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am interested in this community building policy because right now, predominantly, that requirement, encourage public spaces, and I understand that it's encourage, is being met through the open space and the way that buildings orient toward the open space.

1188
01:49:08.420 --> 01:49:09.774
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1189
01:49:10.127 --> 01:49:19.297
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Having spent a lot of time around lawyers, though I am certainly not a lawyer, and a lot of time on policy work and interpretation, I know that words matter.

1190
01:49:19.652 --> 01:49:21.953
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if something is included, it matters.

1191
01:49:22.485 --> 01:49:54.052
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So when I see a policy requirement for community building separate from a requirement to have 20% open space, I am struggling with explaining Accepting that we can meet that encouragement of public space simply by saying, well, there is a requirement for 20% open space, and therefore that's public space, and we're going to orient the buildings for people to use that, and therefore we've met the condition.

1192
01:49:57.319 --> 01:50:35.039
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So given that, I was asking the question of whether there could be some condition around public space and ensuring that there is some sort of public space that is usable beyond that 20%, presumably something usable year-round so that it is separate from that 20% and offers a different, a different niche to be met than that open space, which certainly meets a need.

1193
01:50:36.039 --> 01:50:41.474
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Now, because the word is encourage, I don't know if we can do that or not.

1194
01:50:43.295 --> 01:50:51.119
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I'm stuck in a bit of a hiccup because we're being told that one of the things we need to make sure this plan does is encourage public space.

1195
01:50:51.604 --> 01:51:05.140
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're being told it does so with the use of this open space in the orientation If the words are here separate from here, generally that means it's a separate requirement.

1196
01:51:06.220 --> 01:51:10.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And yet I don't know if we could add that condition because of the word encourage.

1197
01:51:10.720 --> 01:51:17.239
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that is the legal hiccup that I think we may be in that I was trying to ask some questions about.

1198
01:51:17.939 --> 01:51:18.319
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1199
01:51:18.319 --> 01:51:18.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does that help?

1200
01:51:18.920 --> 01:51:19.859
<v Mitch Green>It does.

1201
01:51:19.859 --> 01:51:20.659
<v Mitch Green>And thanks for clarifying.

1202
01:51:20.659 --> 01:51:30.443
<v Mitch Green>So I guess I'm not taking away from that, like, the like intent of the ordinance is to encourage that you're trying to create a sort of ad hoc land use requirement on top of this for big covered year-round space, right?

1203
01:51:34.819 --> 01:51:35.483
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

1204
01:51:35.742 --> 01:51:37.376
<v Mitch Green>Because I was— thank you.

1205
01:51:37.440 --> 01:51:43.671
<v Mitch Green>Because that's— I think a reasonable observer who maybe missed some of this might have caught that, or maybe that was the takeaway.

1206
01:51:43.752 --> 01:51:46.251
<v Mitch Green>And I don't think that was your sort of intent.

1207
01:51:46.300 --> 01:51:51.693
<v Mitch Green>And I wanted to make sure I understood what was maybe coming down the pike in a couple because I don't support something like that.

1208
01:51:51.885 --> 01:51:57.140
<v Mitch Green>I do think it's good and right for us to sort of press on these conditions and ask the questions.

1209
01:51:57.221 --> 01:52:00.234
<v Mitch Green>That's the purpose of this body, to be convened as a quasi-judicial.

1210
01:52:00.698 --> 01:52:02.157
<v Mitch Green>And so I appreciate the dialogue on that.

1211
01:52:02.220 --> 01:52:11.435
<v Mitch Green>I think for me, as the City of Portland, it's a pretty moderate kind of weather temperate area.

1212
01:52:11.997 --> 01:52:18.930
<v Mitch Green>I think that in the context of our broader land use goals and planning documents.

1213
01:52:19.818 --> 01:52:31.542
<v Mitch Green>I think the— for me, we can encourage active and open and community space without that piece of infrastructure attached to it necessarily.

1214
01:52:31.639 --> 01:52:35.895
<v Mitch Green>But we'll see what staff comes up with over the next couple weeks.

1215
01:52:38.403 --> 01:53:05.725
<v Mitch Green>I think when I read these documents and I looked at the plan, The articulation of the, the egress and ingress of the, of the buildings and the lots and the kind of open space and how the streets and the kind of interior streets are faced, to me that felt a lot like a European-style superblock where you have, um, sort of a high degree of pedestrianization and you've got inward sort of park-facing, uh, maybe ground floor retail.

1216
01:53:05.789 --> 01:53:09.118
<v Mitch Green>Maybe there's a preschool for all facility as the ground floor of this thing.

1217
01:53:09.181 --> 01:53:15.536
<v Mitch Green>Maybe there's I see a lot of potential there for community building and active space.

1218
01:53:15.890 --> 01:53:24.863
<v Mitch Green>And so I don't necessarily see the— perhaps the gap that you're identifying there, or maybe the mutual exclusivity piece.

1219
01:53:25.216 --> 01:53:26.506
<v Mitch Green>I'm not sure how to describe it there.

1220
01:53:26.586 --> 01:53:36.002
<v Mitch Green>But I guess, colleagues, I'm prepared to— you know, when we take this vote, I'm prepared to reject the appeals.

1221
01:53:36.119 --> 01:53:36.390
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1222
01:53:42.989 --> 01:53:51.220
<v Jamie Dunphy>Point of order.

1223
01:53:51.220 --> 01:53:54.720
<v Loretta Smith>Do we have a time certain at 11 o'clock of an agenda item?

1224
01:53:55.800 --> 01:54:00.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, yes, but we couldn't have it before then, but we can move those items after.

1225
01:54:00.659 --> 01:54:03.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry, but yes, we have the, the recap item.

1226
01:54:03.079 --> 01:54:04.260
<v Loretta Smith>I must have been out when you said that.

1227
01:54:04.260 --> 01:54:04.319
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, we do.

1228
01:54:05.837 --> 01:54:10.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, it's just part of the agenda approval, but time certainties are always the, the earliest we could do it, not the latest we can start it.

1229
01:54:11.081 --> 01:54:12.448
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay, thanks.

1230
01:54:14.810 --> 01:54:15.648
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1231
01:54:15.712 --> 01:54:16.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1232
01:54:17.099 --> 01:54:18.034
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1233
01:54:18.372 --> 01:54:23.787
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, just a couple quick questions, and then I have— I'll just do my comments all together here.

1234
01:54:23.900 --> 01:54:35.076
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I, um, there's a demolition permit that has to be, uh, applied for in order to demolish this that's outside the scope of this, but my question for legal is, that's its own land use process, right?

1235
01:54:35.606 --> 01:54:36.670
<v Sameer Kanal>The demolition permit?

1236
01:54:39.134 --> 01:54:40.328
<v Robert Taylor>It's an administrative process.

1237
01:54:41.247 --> 01:54:44.702
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so somebody could theoretically appeal that, and there's a whole process, right?

1238
01:54:45.444 --> 01:54:45.637
<v Olivia Clark>There—.

1239
01:54:46.476 --> 01:54:57.192
<v Robert Taylor>It is not a land use decision that's appealable to this body, but yes, I mean, someone could challenge whether the non-discretionary criteria have been met, standards have been okay, but it's—.

1240
01:54:57.224 --> 01:54:57.479
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's—.

1241
01:54:57.479 --> 01:54:59.420
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just— I'm illustrating it's a separate conversation.

1242
01:54:59.532 --> 01:55:02.081
<v Robert Taylor>Yes, yes, it is a separate application and process.

1243
01:55:02.176 --> 01:55:02.305
<v Douglas McLeod>Yes.

1244
01:55:03.251 --> 01:55:05.367
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, my 2 questions for the applicants.

1245
01:55:06.520 --> 01:55:14.344
<v Sameer Kanal>One is just following up on Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's questions about this open space piece, and your response was about open ground floors, right?

1246
01:55:14.615 --> 01:55:19.087
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's something that we can guarantee in terms of requirements for design to have windows and things like that.

1247
01:55:19.425 --> 01:55:19.680
<v Claire Adamsick>Oh yeah.

1248
01:55:19.746 --> 01:55:32.354
<v Sameer Kanal>But in terms of accessibility, if someone comes along, a different Land developer buys one of these parcels, builds a building with open ground floors, but then they just lock the doors, say only higher floor tenants can enter the building, et cetera.

1249
01:55:32.452 --> 01:55:34.337
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there anything that prevents that from happening?

1250
01:55:37.150 --> 01:55:40.287
<v Christy White>Yes, there's several things.

1251
01:55:40.497 --> 01:55:52.011
<v Christy White>So the way the zoning code works, right, and layered in with the master plan, there's certain streets that are primary streets that require Councilor Smith.

1252
01:55:52.060 --> 01:56:03.581
<v Christy White>So there are, like you said, active ground floor uses, and the zoning code requires main entrances that are open to the public and ADA accessible on those main entrances.

1253
01:56:04.432 --> 01:56:13.832
<v Christy White>So yes, the zoning code would require that kind of fluid accessibility, ground floor windows measured from a certain height by a certain percentage.

1254
01:56:14.202 --> 01:56:22.055
<v Christy White>And the Design Commission, I can say from 30 years of experience would never let you get away with not complying with those standards.

1255
01:56:22.167 --> 01:56:23.949
<v Christy White>That's for certain as you look around.

1256
01:56:24.175 --> 01:56:34.128
<v Christy White>But if a tenant went— I mean, I can't tell you that if there's a vacancy like we're seeing all around town that there would be inactivity for some period of the vacancy.

1257
01:56:34.529 --> 01:56:43.569
<v Christy White>But hopefully as we emerge out of this economy and somebody decides to invest in one of these parcels and develop it, we won't be in that situation.

1258
01:56:44.002 --> 01:57:00.323
<v Christy White>But I can assure you that the design commission process for each one of these buildings will ensure that there are active spaces, active ground floor windows, main entrances, and they evaluate that all in the context of the rest of the parcels.

1259
01:57:01.012 --> 01:57:04.965
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I'm not concerned about ADA accessibility and things like that.

1260
01:57:05.109 --> 01:57:08.354
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's— I have faith that the process would account for that.

1261
01:57:08.402 --> 01:57:16.592
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm more concerned about the security sort of element of it, like human security, private owners saying we're just going to lock up and not let anybody in.

1262
01:57:16.929 --> 01:57:23.931
<v Sameer Kanal>I also don't think it's reasonable to hold anyone here accountable for if there's an inactive space or an unrented space at first in the context of this question.

1263
01:57:24.765 --> 01:57:28.530
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think that's what I'm asking about there.

1264
01:57:28.996 --> 01:57:42.814
<v Sameer Kanal>The other question was around diversity, and I want to be clear to Mr. Leinhardt, you said that the plan provides Diversity of scale, diversity of orientation, relationship to the private building locations and the other public realm and public streets that pass through the district.

1265
01:57:43.264 --> 01:57:49.551
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that that to me meets with the the actual text of it, and it seems compliant with that.

1266
01:57:49.599 --> 01:57:52.292
<v Sameer Kanal>So I don't think that there's necessarily a concern there.

1267
01:57:52.822 --> 01:57:57.729
<v Sameer Kanal>But I also think it makes clear that the title of this criterion is a joke, and something we need to fix.

1268
01:57:57.777 --> 01:58:01.225
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not what I think anybody here would think of when they think of what the word diversity means.

1269
01:58:02.783 --> 01:58:13.939
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think just in terms of the layperson's understanding, and I'm interested in working with staff on the future of that because I think there is a disconnect here.

1270
01:58:14.895 --> 01:58:24.564
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think Councilor Pirtle-Guiney mentioned between the title and the text, but also between I think just the title and public understanding of those words.

1271
01:58:25.750 --> 01:58:29.015
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I think this is less about— I think that's a technical requirement versus how it's perceived.

1272
01:58:29.640 --> 01:58:33.423
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't know if I'm missing anything on that, but I wanted to just mention that.

1273
01:58:34.529 --> 01:58:37.688
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so I want to just restate what I heard.

1274
01:58:37.975 --> 01:58:58.970
<v Sameer Kanal>I heard there's a current plan to demolish Lloyd Center, which is parallel to this process and has its own criteria, parallel plan to do master planning, and that today we're only working on master plan consideration, that the existence of a master plan relative to not having one has specific benefits to the city in terms of Better to have it than to not, um, if separate from the question of what should be in it or not.

1275
01:58:59.747 --> 01:59:02.743
<v Sameer Kanal>I heard that we can't remand this to the Planning Commission under current land use law.

1276
01:59:03.162 --> 01:59:16.538
<v Sameer Kanal>I've heard that we can't exercise our independent judgment in the context of our preference as to the preferred outcome, but instead do our quasi-judicial duty and apply existing law and plan to see if the proposed master plan meets them or not, regardless of how, which I think is a really important distinction.

1277
01:59:17.363 --> 01:59:21.244
<v Sameer Kanal>That the requirements proposed include interpretation of criteria, but also things that aren't required.

1278
01:59:21.293 --> 01:59:21.408
<v Michael Harrison>Yes.

1279
01:59:22.167 --> 01:59:27.529
<v Sameer Kanal>And that the absence of a requirement for meaningful engagement is problematic, as Councilor Pirtle-Guiney noted.

1280
01:59:28.043 --> 01:59:35.636
<v Sameer Kanal>I've also heard their concerns, which we can all individually assess, about the risk of demolition absent a master plan, about the risk of being sued under the takings clause, and so forth.

1281
01:59:36.055 --> 01:59:40.100
<v Sameer Kanal>So what I took away from that is I don't think we can apply conditions that require an ice rink.

1282
01:59:40.149 --> 01:59:45.527
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think that we can apply conditions that create specific spaces for things like the 5K through this process.

1283
01:59:46.104 --> 01:59:47.743
<v Sameer Kanal>I do want to speak to 2 of the other criteria.

1284
01:59:47.791 --> 01:59:47.903
<v Christy White>Thank you.

1285
01:59:48.000 --> 01:59:48.448
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yeah.

1286
01:59:48.497 --> 01:59:50.197
<v Sameer Kanal>They're 2LD3 and 5LD1.

1287
01:59:50.613 --> 02:00:06.880
<v Sameer Kanal>I asked the question about applying community building to current use, which we can't, but I do think that they serve as important context because the current community use and the current existence of community shows the lowest possible ceiling for what the space can provide for in the future.

1288
02:00:07.907 --> 02:00:12.141
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a way of saying we can expect what we already have.

1289
02:00:13.537 --> 02:00:14.965
<v Sameer Kanal>That's a fair expectation to hold.

1290
02:00:16.104 --> 02:00:20.615
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I think the technical requirement is met not in the same way that it's currently being met.

1291
02:00:21.082 --> 02:00:27.935
<v Sameer Kanal>That indicates to me a failure of a high enough bar more than it indicates that we are seeing grounds for an appeal.

1292
02:00:28.609 --> 02:00:39.574
<v Sameer Kanal>On the other one though, 5LD1, we talked about diversity, but I also want to recognize the concern that citywide we're losing something distinctive if Lloyd Center goes away, right?

1293
02:00:39.703 --> 02:00:41.677
<v Sameer Kanal>It is a thing that doesn't exist anywhere else in the city.

1294
02:00:41.725 --> 02:00:44.403
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a thing that That will not be replaced with something else.

1295
02:00:44.755 --> 02:00:47.815
<v Sameer Kanal>And so the overall breadth of what exists in the city will be reduced.

1296
02:00:48.296 --> 02:00:51.277
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a tension there that can't be met.

1297
02:00:51.565 --> 02:00:56.389
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that this relates to the title not being backed up as well in the actual text.

1298
02:00:56.917 --> 02:01:01.837
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do want to use those to talk about the potential condition.

1299
02:01:02.381 --> 02:01:05.859
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to support Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's comment about year-round activation.

1300
02:01:05.908 --> 02:01:09.596
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there are some communities which are seasonal, you know, Summer camps, things like that.

1301
02:01:09.676 --> 02:01:16.599
<v Sameer Kanal>But again, the degree of our expectation should be shaped by the existing usage, which includes year-round community at the ice rink.

1302
02:01:16.887 --> 02:01:17.305
<v Sameer Kanal>That's fair.

1303
02:01:18.333 --> 02:01:23.152
<v Sameer Kanal>And also, most communities include active use and not just the possibility of active use.

1304
02:01:23.634 --> 02:01:26.283
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's a really important distinction as well.

1305
02:01:26.685 --> 02:01:38.018
<v Sameer Kanal>I can't say I'd vote for the condition absent reading it, and I think we'd all want to see it, but I think it's fair to ask for some option to be presented that is Detailed enough to consider in an up or down way.

1306
02:01:38.487 --> 02:01:42.893
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's my request, and I want to back that up.

1307
02:01:43.859 --> 02:01:54.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Speaking more broadly, one of the clear lessons from Lloyd Center's recent history is that lower rents and flexible space create room for innovation, especially for small businesses and community-serving organizations that are often priced out elsewhere.

1308
02:01:55.453 --> 02:02:01.304
<v Sameer Kanal>While the city has limited authority over the future of a privately owned property, as we're all seeing with the limits of this quasi-due diligence process.

1309
02:02:01.706 --> 02:02:12.274
<v Sameer Kanal>I am focused on supporting the people, the people and businesses who've made Lloyd Center what it's been, not just in the last few years but even prior to that, because as Council President mentioned, we all have history with this building.

1310
02:02:12.932 --> 02:02:28.480
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the conditions that precipitated this, this, uh, gap are underutilized and underactivated spaces, and we have a failure of, um, building more multi-use than we can, uh, reasonably create affordability for businesses to have access to in the commercial sector here.

1311
02:02:29.234 --> 02:02:31.644
<v Sameer Kanal>Some of that has to do with just our requirements.

1312
02:02:31.707 --> 02:02:32.912
<v Sameer Kanal>Some of that has to do with overbuilding.

1313
02:02:33.762 --> 02:02:37.296
<v Sameer Kanal>Some levers are outside of the scope of our land use item to address it.

1314
02:02:37.439 --> 02:02:50.912
<v Sameer Kanal>And for those who aren't already aware, I am interested in and have started the process of examining separate residential and commercial vacancy fees as a tool to create pressure on long-term vacancy and drive rent down citywide.

1315
02:02:51.313 --> 02:02:51.859
<v Dan Ryan>The encourages—.

1316
02:02:52.195 --> 02:03:05.463
<v Sameer Kanal>The intent is to better understand how the city can discourage prolonged vacancy and encourage productive community benefiting use of existing buildings at an affordable level without losing sight of the real financial and legal constraints that the city operates under.

1317
02:03:06.490 --> 02:03:10.310
<v Sameer Kanal>We obviously need to make sure our stated goals make sense to the public and not just to lawyers.

1318
02:03:11.144 --> 02:03:14.898
<v Sameer Kanal>No offense intended to the lawyers, but it needs to meet both criteria.

1319
02:03:15.460 --> 02:03:16.774
<v Sameer Kanal>And that includes titling better.

1320
02:03:16.838 --> 02:03:17.079
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1321
02:03:17.738 --> 02:03:22.198
<v Sameer Kanal>Titling better the particular criteria, but also making sure what's required and what's not.

1322
02:03:22.293 --> 02:03:33.957
<v Sameer Kanal>I also think Mr. Leinhardt's point about— actually, you both made it— about applying these differently in the context of a framework versus an individual building is helpful, and I'd like more clarity on that for the public as well.

1323
02:03:34.485 --> 02:03:40.085
<v Sameer Kanal>And also ensuring real engagement, not conflating one-way communication, mailers, et cetera.

1324
02:03:40.181 --> 02:03:43.085
<v Sameer Kanal>Even if those mailers were on time, they're not enough to constitute engagement.

1325
02:03:43.149 --> 02:03:43.711
<v Dan Ryan>Councilmember Herbold.

1326
02:03:43.920 --> 02:03:45.110
<v Sameer Kanal>Engagement is co-creation.

1327
02:03:45.643 --> 02:03:47.832
<v Sameer Kanal>Engagement is listening and requiring.

1328
02:03:47.881 --> 02:03:53.228
<v Sameer Kanal>And it appears clear that, that, that's not actually a real requirement in our current rules, that it, it just needs to be.

1329
02:03:54.081 --> 02:04:01.679
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I won't repeat everything everyone said about the Rose Quarter and the ice rink except to say that I agree, but I want to make one big picture comment here.

1330
02:04:02.050 --> 02:04:21.198
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, this is a private business operating within rules about private uses of land in our city and state, and so we're limited as I also think we're being asked to ensure that capitalism and capitalists provide a social benefit, and that's not realistic the way the law currently is.

1331
02:04:22.842 --> 02:04:38.185
<v Sameer Kanal>We can argue about whether the solution should be a broad conversation about democratic socialism or simply a government use like an ice rink run by Portland Parks or the city-owned Veterans Memorial Coliseum, but I think we need to be realistic about the world we're in as we simultaneously try to build the better world we want.

1332
02:04:38.376 --> 02:04:38.953
<v Sameer Kanal>Of the future.

1333
02:04:40.078 --> 02:04:41.667
<v Sameer Kanal>And I do want to build that better world.

1334
02:04:41.747 --> 02:04:45.216
<v Sameer Kanal>We can have nice things, including an ice rink, and Portland deserves them.

1335
02:04:45.698 --> 02:04:50.996
<v Sameer Kanal>But it's not going to be because large developers choose to build them altruistically, nor should it be.

1336
02:04:51.140 --> 02:04:52.440
<v Sameer Kanal>That's just not how it works.

1337
02:04:53.324 --> 02:05:01.192
<v Sameer Kanal>It's our responsibility to either build requirements noting what limitations that that might create, or better yet, provide a public service as the government.

1338
02:05:01.673 --> 02:05:03.376
<v Sameer Kanal>We haven't done that as a government.

1339
02:05:03.520 --> 02:05:03.697
<v Jeff Fish>Thank you.

1340
02:05:04.492 --> 02:05:07.708
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's our job to do, and we, we need to meet that requirement.

1341
02:05:07.756 --> 02:05:09.007
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to get that on the record.

1342
02:05:09.985 --> 02:05:11.220
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thanks, appreciate it.

1343
02:05:11.381 --> 02:05:12.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Councilor Kanal.

1344
02:05:13.639 --> 02:05:15.328
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, there's no one else in queue for discussion.

1345
02:05:16.109 --> 02:05:21.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Lauren, our staff, I got— could we, could we pull up the 3 options before the council again, please?

1346
02:05:22.311 --> 02:05:23.122
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, just a moment.

1347
02:05:26.579 --> 02:05:27.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith?

1348
02:05:27.539 --> 02:05:28.956
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, okay, okay.

1349
02:05:35.500 --> 02:05:39.886
<v Matt Henderson>Jamie, if possible, I'd like to ask a question of counsel.

1350
02:05:41.658 --> 02:05:41.917
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

1351
02:05:44.466 --> 02:05:45.032
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1352
02:05:45.145 --> 02:05:46.082
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, no.

1353
02:05:47.163 --> 02:05:48.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, he's welcome to ask.

1354
02:05:51.637 --> 02:05:55.894
<v Matt Henderson>Um, Matt Henderson with the Save Lloyd campaign, uh, representing one of the appellants.

1355
02:05:57.203 --> 02:06:14.817
<v Matt Henderson>So there's one guideline that hasn't come up in discussion that I don't want to gloss over, and I don't think the city wants to gloss over, and that is guideline A6, reuse, rehabilitate, and restore existing structures where feasible.

1356
02:06:17.278 --> 02:06:31.510
<v Matt Henderson>The city's own website for the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability talks about embodied carbon in the built environment, and I'll, I'll quote briefly from it.

1357
02:06:32.426 --> 02:06:41.976
<v Matt Henderson>Building materials account for 13% of annual global emissions, so reducing embodied carbon in the built environment is a priority to reach net-zero carbon by 2050.

1358
02:06:42.557 --> 02:06:45.555
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're kind of pushing into a territory of relitigating this.

1359
02:06:46.201 --> 02:06:49.511
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was open to a question, but full reading off that's a little bit—.

1360
02:06:49.896 --> 02:07:05.667
<v Matt Henderson>It's all here in the city priorities publicly that reusing existing buildings is a crucial part of how we advance the city's climate goals.

1361
02:07:07.063 --> 02:07:17.619
<v Matt Henderson>And this Guideline A6 feels like one of the most woefully undermet criteria that the master plan is being assessed by.

1362
02:07:19.368 --> 02:07:24.981
<v Matt Henderson>It feels like there was not enough accountability.

1363
02:07:25.978 --> 02:07:29.144
<v Jamie Dunphy>Again, this— we're pushing into the relitigating territory.

1364
02:07:29.193 --> 02:07:31.283
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it's got to be— if you have a question, I'm happy to answer it.

1365
02:07:31.427 --> 02:07:44.984
<v Matt Henderson>The question is, has council given consideration particularly to this guideline A6, which was one of our 6 Criteria or guidelines that we specified in our appeal letter.

1366
02:07:45.724 --> 02:07:49.786
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll just say that I am familiar with this criteria.

1367
02:07:49.979 --> 02:07:55.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was considered in my consideration of it and will be a part of what I am considering as we move towards a vote.

1368
02:07:55.774 --> 02:07:56.095
<v Matt Henderson>Thank you.

1369
02:07:56.337 --> 02:07:56.979
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1370
02:07:58.198 --> 02:08:03.947
<v Jamie Dunphy>So before us right now on the screen, colleagues, you see that there are 3 options that we are able to do.

1371
02:08:04.909 --> 02:08:09.757
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lauren, can you can you help me understand the difference between the 2 middle, or the first and the second?

1372
02:08:09.902 --> 02:08:12.052
<v Jamie Dunphy>They seem very similar.

1373
02:08:12.984 --> 02:08:26.561
<v Robert Taylor>So the first option is to approve the Design Commission's decision with all of the conditions that the Design Commission included, and then the findings would be revised to reflect the council hearing.

1374
02:08:26.658 --> 02:08:30.895
<v Robert Taylor>We would return, we would make a tentative vote and return, council would, and return with revised findings.

1375
02:08:31.890 --> 02:08:35.470
<v Robert Taylor>But it would uphold everything that the Design Commission found, including all of their conditions.

1376
02:08:35.567 --> 02:08:43.546
<v Robert Taylor>The second option upholds the Design Commission's decision, but revises the conditions and adds any new conditions.

1377
02:08:43.610 --> 02:08:53.453
<v Robert Taylor>And I will note that there is a technical amendment to one of the conditions that staff has requested should council proceed with upholding the Design Commission's decision.

1378
02:08:54.270 --> 02:08:54.448
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1379
02:08:55.251 --> 02:08:55.813
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1380
02:08:56.037 --> 02:08:57.210
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Council President.

1381
02:08:57.819 --> 02:09:07.166
<v Dan Ryan>I move that I submit a motion to the first option, deny both appeals and uphold the Design Commission's decision and conditions of approval with revised findings.

1382
02:09:07.662 --> 02:09:08.095
<v Doug Wade>Second.

1383
02:09:08.784 --> 02:09:17.217
<v Jamie Dunphy>Before we move into that, as Lauren just said, there is a technical change that is required, that does require an update to a revised condition.

1384
02:09:17.362 --> 02:09:23.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>If the body is moving towards denying the appeal, I would ask that we move the second option, that with revised condition.

1385
02:09:24.030 --> 02:09:24.414
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that correct?

1386
02:09:24.966 --> 02:09:27.469
<v Robert Taylor>Yeah, Ben, do you have the revised condition that you could—.

1387
02:09:27.469 --> 02:09:28.761
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's a technical amendment there.

1388
02:09:28.858 --> 02:09:30.828
<v Robert Taylor>It's a technical revision that—.

1389
02:09:31.248 --> 02:09:35.725
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a revision to the text of Condition of Approval 8C.

1390
02:09:37.893 --> 02:09:39.317
<v Unidentified speaker>I can show it on the screen briefly.

1391
02:09:41.119 --> 02:09:42.832
<v Dan Ryan>I'll take a second.

1392
02:09:47.250 --> 02:09:51.161
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's just changing some of the language that was adopted by the Design Commission.

1393
02:09:52.945 --> 02:09:58.015
<v Unidentified speaker>Public Works staff, Brianna Lovell, is up here if you have any questions for her on this.

1394
02:09:58.721 --> 02:10:05.028
<v Unidentified speaker>Public Works staff at PP&D has worked with the development team on revising these conditions.

1395
02:10:05.396 --> 02:10:08.670
<v Unidentified speaker>It just corrected a couple technical things that were in error.

1396
02:10:09.488 --> 02:10:09.649
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1397
02:10:10.819 --> 02:10:11.204
<v Douglas McLeod>Yeah, can you—.

1398
02:10:11.301 --> 02:10:14.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we get some more specification of that?

1399
02:10:14.591 --> 02:10:14.895
<v Jamie Dunphy>Which of those?

1400
02:10:15.393 --> 02:10:15.681
<v Keelan McClymont>Sure.

1401
02:10:16.051 --> 02:10:19.548
<v Elise Rosenberg>Brianna Lovell, Portland Permitting and Development, Public Works Development.

1402
02:10:20.515 --> 02:10:40.355
<v Elise Rosenberg>So the change that we're making is related to the fact that the applicant's materials originally indicated that the full demolition of the mall would impact the private connection, sewer connection to properties to the north of the Lloyd Center.

1403
02:10:40.501 --> 02:10:52.862
<v Elise Rosenberg>And so we wrote a condition that sort of offered us some guarantees about how that How that transition would be managed so that those northern properties get reconnected in a timely manner.

1404
02:10:53.087 --> 02:11:06.864
<v Elise Rosenberg>Ultimately, it's a private agreement between 2 private parties, but we wanted to make sure that there was no risk to the city that something go awry and that an emergency connection to the public system be required.

1405
02:11:07.859 --> 02:11:15.824
<v Elise Rosenberg>But we have now understood that the demolition of the mall could be completed without disrupting that service to the northern properties.

1406
02:11:15.985 --> 02:11:16.564
<v Elise Rosenberg>So we—.

1407
02:11:18.695 --> 02:11:20.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1408
02:11:21.442 --> 02:11:22.717
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, so Councilor Ryan?

1409
02:11:23.686 --> 02:11:26.189
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, so I, I moved and it was seconded.

1410
02:11:26.529 --> 02:11:30.672
<v Dan Ryan>Are you saying that we need to do this technical amendment, which still seems to be in the first bullet?

1411
02:11:33.731 --> 02:11:35.101
<v Dan Ryan>The attorney can weigh in, of course.

1412
02:11:35.649 --> 02:11:36.569
<v Steve Novick>Um, you can do—.

1413
02:11:36.778 --> 02:11:40.920
<v Robert Taylor>If there's no objection, you can do a friendly revision to your motion.

1414
02:11:40.984 --> 02:11:41.935
<v Robert Taylor>But yes, I think that the amendment is appropriate.

1415
02:11:42.078 --> 02:11:47.970
<v Robert Taylor>Staff is requesting that one of the— it's Condition 8C, I think, is revised.

1416
02:11:48.019 --> 02:11:48.645
<v Christy White>So it could—.

1417
02:11:48.725 --> 02:11:59.948
<v Robert Taylor>The motion could be, I move to tentatively deny the appeal, uphold the Design Commission's decision with the change to Condition 8C as proposed by staff.

1418
02:12:00.606 --> 02:12:01.635
<v Dan Ryan>That's what I want to say right now.

1419
02:12:02.197 --> 02:12:02.356
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1420
02:12:03.079 --> 02:12:05.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan moves what Lauren just said.

1421
02:12:05.488 --> 02:12:05.551
<v Douglas McLeod>Yeah.

1422
02:12:05.600 --> 02:12:06.002
<v Douglas McLeod>Second.

1423
02:12:06.065 --> 02:12:07.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick seconds.

1424
02:12:10.734 --> 02:12:14.167
<v Jamie Dunphy>In a land use appeal, is this a debatable motion or do we just move to a vote at that point?

1425
02:12:14.872 --> 02:12:16.122
<v Robert Taylor>You can move to a vote.

1426
02:12:16.475 --> 02:12:16.893
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1427
02:12:16.972 --> 02:12:17.293
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we're—.

1428
02:12:17.454 --> 02:12:18.417
<v Robert Taylor>I mean, yeah.

1429
02:12:18.738 --> 02:12:22.474
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, then we are moving to a vote on Councilor Ryan's motion.

1430
02:12:23.148 --> 02:12:24.671
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick seconded.

1431
02:12:25.457 --> 02:12:26.354
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, Councilor Brynjolfsson speaks.

1432
02:12:26.403 --> 02:12:27.092
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Point of information.

1433
02:12:28.456 --> 02:12:30.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's not discussion on this motion?

1434
02:12:31.006 --> 02:12:32.706
<v Robert Taylor>Well, it's a call for a vote.

1435
02:12:32.753 --> 02:12:37.354
<v Robert Taylor>So this is— It's, it's, there's not a, um, it's not a motion to amend.

1436
02:12:37.418 --> 02:12:39.021
<v Robert Taylor>It's basically just a call for the vote.

1437
02:12:39.327 --> 02:12:42.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's generally discussion though on a call for a vote, correct?

1438
02:12:43.029 --> 02:12:45.082
<v Jamie Dunphy>On legislative things, but we're in a land use hearing.

1439
02:12:46.380 --> 02:12:47.518
<v Robert Taylor>I would—.

1440
02:12:47.518 --> 02:12:49.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>We like— yeah, is there—.

1441
02:12:49.922 --> 02:12:52.087
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm just noting that we do have 2 colleagues in the queue.

1442
02:12:52.792 --> 02:12:59.588
<v Robert Taylor>Yeah, I don't have any reason to say that council cannot have a discussion if there is interest, if the body is interested in further discussion before voting.

1443
02:12:59.863 --> 02:13:03.176
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, then before we move to a vote, I'm going to, uh, get to Councilor Knoll.

1444
02:13:04.328 --> 02:13:05.481
<v Sameer Kanal>Just a question here.

1445
02:13:06.890 --> 02:13:15.578
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, would we have, uh, expressed it— at least 2 of us have expressed an interest in seeing what a condition would look like.

1446
02:13:16.770 --> 02:13:22.725
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there— I, I don't under— this is a preliminary vote, so it doesn't really seem to matter if there's going to be revised conditions anyway.

1447
02:13:22.871 --> 02:13:30.186
<v Sameer Kanal>It seems like we would be able to add something later, but But I'm just curious about how we could get to a place where we could at least consider something.

1448
02:13:30.685 --> 02:13:33.591
<v Robert Taylor>Okay, I just want to make sure to clarify for the record.

1449
02:13:34.233 --> 02:13:37.122
<v Robert Taylor>So typically, Council makes a tentative vote.

1450
02:13:37.268 --> 02:13:41.297
<v Robert Taylor>It reflects all of the conditions and what Council wants the final decision to be.

1451
02:13:42.662 --> 02:13:47.399
<v Robert Taylor>That was Commissioner Ryan's motion for that tentative vote.

1452
02:13:47.704 --> 02:13:57.283
<v Robert Taylor>Staff then will return at a future date with revised findings to reflect what happened at the hearing, the testimony, and in council's discussion.

1453
02:13:59.220 --> 02:14:02.722
<v Robert Taylor>Ordinarily, the condition would not be further amended at that future vote.

1454
02:14:02.770 --> 02:14:11.289
<v Robert Taylor>So if there is a proposal for a condition, council should identify what that is before making a tentative vote.

1455
02:14:12.880 --> 02:14:18.890
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, well, I mean, I've made clear, and I think Councilor Pirtle-Guiney made clear, a desire to consider another condition.

1456
02:14:19.243 --> 02:14:31.037
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think there's been other colleagues have necessarily expressed an opinion either way, except I'm going to implicitly assume that Councilors Ryan and Novick, by virtue of this amendment or this motion and second, are not interested in that.

1457
02:14:31.117 --> 02:14:34.086
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to put that on the table before we vote.

1458
02:14:34.407 --> 02:14:34.646
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1459
02:14:35.032 --> 02:14:36.091
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1460
02:14:36.315 --> 02:14:37.101
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1461
02:14:37.935 --> 02:14:38.417
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1462
02:14:38.962 --> 02:14:42.877
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate that, and I appreciate the further explanation.

1463
02:14:43.536 --> 02:14:56.242
<v Loretta Smith>And before I take this vote, I want to say to my fellow Portlanders neighbors, and the passionate advocates who have spoken out to protect the Lloyd Center, I hear you, and I heard you.

1464
02:14:58.010 --> 02:15:08.926
<v Loretta Smith>I have listened closely to the hours of public testimony and felt the deep love this community holds for the Lloyd Center, especially the iconic ice rink—.

1465
02:15:09.136 --> 02:15:09.493
<v Micah Goldstein>Shame on you!

1466
02:15:09.557 --> 02:15:12.992
<v Loretta Smith>That has anchored generations of family memories.

1467
02:15:13.837 --> 02:15:17.332
<v Loretta Smith>First dates and community gatherings.

1468
02:15:19.082 --> 02:15:28.007
<v Loretta Smith>Please know that my vote— Council President, thank you.

1469
02:15:28.056 --> 02:15:31.244
<v Loretta Smith>Can you give order, folks, if I can finish my statement?

1470
02:15:31.293 --> 02:15:32.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've been very clear.

1471
02:15:32.565 --> 02:15:37.221
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please, with the snapping and the clapping, please, I will consider it a disruption and ask you to leave.

1472
02:15:38.052 --> 02:15:38.411
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1473
02:15:38.542 --> 02:15:50.962
<v Loretta Smith>So please know that my vote to approve the Central the proposed city master plan is not to dismantle that rich history, nor is it a validation of losing something that we all love.

1474
02:15:51.862 --> 02:15:59.533
<v Loretta Smith>It is instead a difficult but necessary step towards securing a viable future to Northeast Portland.

1475
02:16:00.688 --> 02:16:08.101
<v Loretta Smith>The reality we face is that the current structure of the mall is severely dilapidated and economically unsustainable.

1476
02:16:08.149 --> 02:16:08.407
<v Douglas McLeod>Thank you.

1477
02:16:09.515 --> 02:16:25.662
<v Loretta Smith>While land use law does not legally allow the City Council to force a private developer to rebuild or maintain an ice rink, voting no on this demolition and redevelopment plan would not save the rink.

1478
02:16:27.011 --> 02:16:31.527
<v Loretta Smith>It would simply trap the Lloyd Center in a state of continued decay.

1479
02:16:32.395 --> 02:16:33.149
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1480
02:16:33.310 --> 02:16:37.659
<v Loretta Smith>So I will be supporting the master plan.

1481
02:16:39.072 --> 02:16:46.242
<v Loretta Smith>My vote to support this path forward is rooted in an appeal to what Portland can become in the future.

1482
02:16:47.333 --> 02:16:48.985
<v Loretta Smith>Economic revitalization.

1483
02:16:49.643 --> 02:16:58.289
<v Loretta Smith>Our city is navigating a significant budgetary shortfall, and we desperately need to rebuild our tax base.

1484
02:16:59.186 --> 02:17:12.654
<v Loretta Smith>A revitalized Lloyd District will breathe economic life back into the area, creating an ecosystem where local small businesses could not only just survive, but they can thrive.

1485
02:17:13.875 --> 02:17:15.753
<v Loretta Smith>Housing and infrastructure.

1486
02:17:16.620 --> 02:17:27.924
<v Loretta Smith>This redevelopment represents a generational opportunity to build a much-needed housing and modern infrastructure right in the heart of the city.

1487
02:17:29.049 --> 02:17:31.040
<v Loretta Smith>A renewed gathering space.

1488
02:17:32.180 --> 02:17:49.344
<v Loretta Smith>While the physical space will change, the goal is to transform a dying, hollowed-out property into a very vibrant, active neighborhood where Portlanders can once again gather, work, and live safely.

1489
02:17:50.405 --> 02:17:53.279
<v Loretta Smith>And I know that change is incredibly hard.

1490
02:17:54.084 --> 02:17:59.359
<v Loretta Smith>Especially when it touches places that hold our history, my history.

1491
02:18:01.161 --> 02:18:04.462
<v Loretta Smith>But as your city councilor, I must look towards tomorrow.

1492
02:18:05.270 --> 02:18:15.926
<v Loretta Smith>I am committed to working alongside the developers and community advocates to ensure that the spirit of community space remains central to whatever is built next.

1493
02:18:17.182 --> 02:18:27.534
<v Loretta Smith>And let us use this moment not to divide ourselves over what is being taken down, but to collaborate on what we can build up together.

1494
02:18:28.559 --> 02:18:33.066
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for your fierce advocacy and dedication to our city.

1495
02:18:33.888 --> 02:18:39.206
<v Loretta Smith>And I want to thank the developers for the work that they put in.

1496
02:18:39.551 --> 02:18:46.904
<v Loretta Smith>This has been a long road, and, you know, we're going to have some, some winners here.

1497
02:18:46.968 --> 02:18:47.097
<v Sarah Heinecke>Thank you.

1498
02:18:47.635 --> 02:18:49.316
<v Loretta Smith>And I think all of us can win on this.

1499
02:18:49.816 --> 02:18:50.156
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1500
02:18:50.447 --> 02:18:51.238
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1501
02:18:51.578 --> 02:18:52.290
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1502
02:18:53.129 --> 02:18:54.148
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1503
02:18:55.996 --> 02:19:02.484
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, you know, many of us started by saying that it was clear that there's going to be a demolition here no matter what.

1504
02:19:02.693 --> 02:19:09.534
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The question is whether a master plan is the best option, and if so, if the criteria are being met.

1505
02:19:09.583 --> 02:19:12.537
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I do think that predominantly they are.

1506
02:19:13.001 --> 02:19:14.891
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that asterisk of the concerns I raised.

1507
02:19:14.987 --> 02:19:34.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I also am hearing loud and clear from my colleagues that there's not an interest in, in conditions that would address those concerns and address perhaps some pieces where, where there are places where the plan could be a bit stronger, both in terms of meeting the criteria and for our community.

1508
02:19:35.370 --> 02:19:38.832
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just want to acknowledge that as we move forward.

1509
02:19:38.879 --> 02:19:38.976
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

1510
02:19:40.004 --> 02:19:44.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's sometimes there are places where we could do better, but the will isn't there to do so.

1511
02:19:44.501 --> 02:19:46.426
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have to do the best that we can.

1512
02:19:46.507 --> 02:19:54.022
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And clearly moving forward with a master plan is better than moving forward without one for this part of our community.

1513
02:19:54.697 --> 02:19:55.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1514
02:19:55.885 --> 02:19:56.752
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1515
02:19:57.425 --> 02:19:58.228
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1516
02:19:59.433 --> 02:20:01.889
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to echo everything that Councilor Smith said.

1517
02:20:02.243 --> 02:20:03.495
<v Sameer Kanal>I cannot improve on what she said.

1518
02:20:03.833 --> 02:20:04.555
<v Dan Ryan>I totally agree with it.

1519
02:20:06.004 --> 02:20:06.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1520
02:20:08.644 --> 02:20:12.120
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, can we please move to a roll call vote?

1521
02:20:13.989 --> 02:20:16.325
<v Keelan McClymont>Noting Koyama Lane and Murillo are absent.

1522
02:20:16.488 --> 02:20:16.828
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1523
02:20:17.542 --> 02:20:31.634
<v Jamie Dunphy>Before we start, just to clarify for colleagues, a yes vote, an aye vote, is to vote to deny both appeals, uphold the Design Commission's decision with revised conditions and findings.

1524
02:20:32.093 --> 02:20:36.101
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you vote— if you want to deny the appeal, a vote is a yes.

1525
02:20:36.278 --> 02:20:38.209
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you want to uphold the appeal, the vote is a no.

1526
02:20:39.620 --> 02:20:40.005
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that correct?

1527
02:20:42.020 --> 02:20:42.181
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1528
02:20:42.536 --> 02:20:42.843
<v Michael Harrison>Okay.

1529
02:20:43.165 --> 02:20:50.380
<v Robert Taylor>Yes, Councilor Ryan's motion was to deny the appeal and uphold the Design Commission's decisions with the revised condition by staff.

1530
02:20:50.444 --> 02:20:52.925
<v Robert Taylor>So a vote for yes would deny the appeals.

1531
02:20:53.363 --> 02:20:53.623
<v Doug Wade>Thank you.

1532
02:20:53.997 --> 02:20:56.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, please call the roll.

1533
02:20:56.676 --> 02:20:57.018
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

1534
02:20:57.768 --> 02:20:57.816
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1535
02:20:58.105 --> 02:20:59.005
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1536
02:21:00.261 --> 02:21:00.308
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1537
02:21:01.240 --> 02:21:01.531
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1538
02:21:02.271 --> 02:21:02.351
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1539
02:21:02.945 --> 02:21:03.363
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1540
02:21:04.281 --> 02:21:04.328
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1541
02:21:05.325 --> 02:21:05.631
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1542
02:21:07.174 --> 02:21:07.191
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1543
02:21:08.011 --> 02:21:08.364
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1544
02:21:09.345 --> 02:21:09.394
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1545
02:21:10.149 --> 02:21:10.536
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1546
02:21:11.291 --> 02:21:12.031
<v Sameer Kanal>Begrudgingly, aye.

1547
02:21:13.190 --> 02:21:13.466
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1548
02:21:14.992 --> 02:21:15.171
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1549
02:21:16.371 --> 02:21:16.600
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1550
02:21:17.022 --> 02:21:17.200
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1551
02:21:17.995 --> 02:21:18.305
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1552
02:21:20.029 --> 02:21:20.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1553
02:21:20.486 --> 02:21:26.218
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, the tentative vote is approved with 10 ayes and 2 absent.

1554
02:21:26.605 --> 02:21:33.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>The motion to appeal has— to deny the appeal has passed with— I'm sorry, what was the vote count?

1555
02:21:34.036 --> 02:21:34.132
<v Jamie Dunphy>9?

1556
02:21:34.198 --> 02:21:34.568
<v Mitch Green>10.

1557
02:21:34.763 --> 02:21:36.586
<v Jamie Dunphy>10 To 0.

1558
02:21:36.781 --> 02:21:38.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>The appeal is tentatively denied.

1559
02:21:39.459 --> 02:21:45.606
<v Jamie Dunphy>Council Clerk and City Attorney, do we have a date and time certain for this matter to return to council for a final vote and adoption of findings?

1560
02:21:47.057 --> 02:21:54.088
<v Robert Taylor>So the zoning code requires that the prevailing attorney Provide draft findings and then we'll return.

1561
02:21:54.218 --> 02:21:59.659
<v Robert Taylor>I think staff has a tentative hold for July 29th.

1562
02:21:59.933 --> 02:22:03.843
<v Robert Taylor>Can I just sidebar with the attorney to see if that's sufficient or whether we need—.

1563
02:22:04.502 --> 02:22:04.870
<v Christy White>We can do it.

1564
02:22:05.819 --> 02:22:10.127
<v Robert Taylor>Okay, so we'll need that at least a week before— how long filing is?

1565
02:22:11.623 --> 02:22:12.790
<v Keelan McClymont>We will need it.

1566
02:22:23.120 --> 02:22:23.247
<v Dori Hellyer>Okay.

1567
02:22:23.715 --> 02:22:23.860
<v Olivia Clark>All right.

1568
02:22:24.615 --> 02:22:24.711
<v Claire Adamsick>Okay.

1569
02:22:25.227 --> 02:22:30.648
<v Robert Taylor>Yeah, I'll coordinate with, um, council for the applicant to identify when to get them to our office.

1570
02:22:30.713 --> 02:22:31.440
<v Robert Taylor>But yeah.

1571
02:22:33.037 --> 02:22:33.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1572
02:22:33.860 --> 02:22:44.597
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, um, I understand that this matter is returning to council on Wednesday, July 29th, 9:45 AM for the adoption of the findings and the final vote.

1573
02:22:45.229 --> 02:22:45.358
<v Robert Taylor>Yes.

1574
02:22:45.469 --> 02:22:46.466
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you very much.

1575
02:22:47.525 --> 02:22:50.433
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, the time is currently 11:48.

1576
02:22:50.530 --> 02:22:52.087
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to give us a restroom break.

1577
02:22:52.136 --> 02:22:52.730
<v Jamie Dunphy>11:49.

1578
02:22:53.164 --> 02:22:54.898
<v Jamie Dunphy>Everybody please be back here at noon.

1579
02:22:55.011 --> 02:23:00.712
<v Jamie Dunphy>We still have a number of items, but I will preview that we almost certainly will not complete the full agenda today.

1580
02:23:01.420 --> 02:23:03.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll see you all in 10 minutes.

1581
02:23:04.391 --> 02:23:05.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>Shame on all of you.

1582
02:23:05.997 --> 02:23:06.559
<v Dan Ryan>Shame.

1583
02:23:08.022 --> 02:23:10.046
<v Sameer Kanal>Shame.

1584
02:38:58.577 --> 02:39:00.441
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, and we are back.

1585
02:39:00.762 --> 02:39:03.138
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call item number 5?

1586
02:39:08.868 --> 02:39:23.470
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 5, document 2026-189, amend city code and improve land use regulations through the Regulatory Improvement Code Amendment Package 11, amend code titles 32 and 33.

1587
02:39:24.578 --> 02:39:26.858
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1588
02:39:26.986 --> 02:39:30.066
<v Jamie Dunphy>Claire Adamsick with Council Operations is here for a committee staff summary report.

1589
02:39:30.676 --> 02:39:31.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>Claire, take it away.

1590
02:39:31.960 --> 02:39:33.549
<v Claire Adamsick>Thank you, Council President and councilors.

1591
02:39:33.646 --> 02:39:37.610
<v Claire Adamsick>For the record, Claire Adamsick, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Housing and Permitting Committee.

1592
02:39:38.477 --> 02:39:47.175
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance before you, document number 2026-189, was heard in the Housing and Permitting Committee on June 2nd, where it was referred to full council with a recommendation to pass.

1593
02:39:48.027 --> 02:39:56.468
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance amends Portland City Code Title 33, Planning and Zoning, and Title 32, Signs and Related Regulations, Sorry.

1594
02:39:57.094 --> 02:40:06.039
<v Claire Adamsick>And adopts the legislative intent and findings as shown in the Regulatory Improvement Code Amendment Package 11, or RECAP 11, which is found in Exhibit B.

1595
02:40:06.872 --> 02:40:12.879
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance also directs the adoption of the findings of fact report in Exhibit A as additional findings.

1596
02:40:13.858 --> 02:40:17.245
<v Claire Adamsick>The code amendments clarify regulations and aim to remove barriers to development.

1597
02:40:18.049 --> 02:40:21.549
<v Claire Adamsick>RECAP 11 amendments are grouped under the following themes in the recommended draft.

1598
02:40:22.440 --> 02:40:30.248
<v Claire Adamsick>Parking and loading, including access to bike parking, bike parking requirements with a change of use, and allowing parking in residential setbacks with a garage conversion.

1599
02:40:31.450 --> 02:40:40.235
<v Claire Adamsick>Exterior areas, including clarifying requirements related to structures or covers for common outdoor areas and aligning definitions for exterior activities throughout the code.

1600
02:40:41.796 --> 02:41:02.930
<v Claire Adamsick>Regulatory improvements, including updating regulations for outdoor shelters to align with current allowances through the city's housing emergency, clarifying that a sobering center is an allowed temporary activity in response to a health and safety emergency declaration, and extending the timeline to set up or tear down a major public gathering to align with the timeline in a permit issued by Portland Fire and Rescue.

1601
02:41:03.475 --> 02:41:11.704
<v Claire Adamsick>And finally, sign code amendments, including allowing greater flexibility around the use of larger freestanding and/or small changing image signs in local and regional parks.

1602
02:41:12.796 --> 02:41:20.485
<v Claire Adamsick>The full impact statement on this item includes information on economic and real estate development impacts, and analysis, and community impacts and community involvement.

1603
02:41:21.449 --> 02:41:24.468
<v Claire Adamsick>No one provided verbal testimony during the committee meeting on June 2nd.

1604
02:41:24.823 --> 02:41:30.477
<v Claire Adamsick>5 People submitted written testimony on this item via the MAP app prior to committee action.

1605
02:41:31.505 --> 02:41:55.397
<v Claire Adamsick>The general themes of this testimony included support for clear and efficient permitting rules and definitions that help to reduce delays and expand housing options, concerns regarding allowing and expanding use for safe rest villages and daycare facilities by rights request for greater flexibility for schools and universities by allowing multifamily housing as a permitted use in the campus institutional zone.

1606
02:41:56.610 --> 02:42:02.637
<v Claire Adamsick>Request to add a definition in the zoning code for a structure that replaces an existing structure with the same footprint.

1607
02:42:03.342 --> 02:42:08.259
<v Claire Adamsick>And finally, highlighting the need for clarification of short-term bicycle parking accessibility requirements.

1608
02:42:08.663 --> 02:42:10.001
<v Claire Adamsick>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

1609
02:42:10.113 --> 02:42:10.259
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1610
02:42:10.307 --> 02:42:11.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Claire.

1611
02:42:11.754 --> 02:42:13.762
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos, this came from the Housing and Permitting Committee.

1612
02:42:13.825 --> 02:42:15.995
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can I turn it to you for opening remarks?

1613
02:42:17.296 --> 02:42:18.870
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, thank you, President Dunphy.

1614
02:42:19.480 --> 02:42:22.854
<v Candace Avalos>So Recap 11 came before the Housing and Permitting Committee on June 2nd.

1615
02:42:22.934 --> 02:42:31.481
<v Candace Avalos>Staff presented the package, which, which includes a series of technical and minor policy amendments intended to clarify and improve the city's zoning and sign codes.

1616
02:42:32.075 --> 02:42:34.663
<v Candace Avalos>During the committee hearing, no members of the public testified.

1617
02:42:34.968 --> 02:42:42.395
<v Candace Avalos>The committee closed oral testimony, left the written record open, And voted to advance the package to the full council for consideration today.

1618
02:42:43.025 --> 02:42:52.716
<v Candace Avalos>Following the committee hearing, council offices received a letter from several higher education institutions expressing concerns about the proposed definition of mechanical equipment.

1619
02:42:53.137 --> 02:43:05.951
<v Candace Avalos>So city staff subsequently met with those stakeholders to better understand their concerns, and as a result of those discussions, Council President Dunphy, Councilor Koyama Lane, and I are introducing an amendment for council's consideration.

1620
02:43:06.001 --> 02:43:06.145
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

1621
02:43:06.368 --> 02:43:11.315
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, I'll turn it back to you, Council President, and let me know when you'd like me to introduce the amendment.

1622
02:43:11.667 --> 02:43:12.310
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

1623
02:43:12.359 --> 02:43:19.538
<v Jamie Dunphy>That'll be just a moment here because, as my notes say, there are 2 pre-filed amendments to this item, both filed responsive to written testimony.

1624
02:43:20.325 --> 02:43:27.922
<v Jamie Dunphy>If those amendments are adopted today, we will be continuing this item to a time certain later in the month to allow staff to update the findings.

1625
02:43:29.302 --> 02:43:35.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>Additionally, my amendment, Dunphy 1, will also require additional technical Technical amendments from staff to be operationalized if we adopt it today.

1626
02:43:36.284 --> 02:43:41.674
<v Jamie Dunphy>Altogether, we're looking to concluding this legislative action in August or possibly early September.

1627
02:43:42.620 --> 02:43:52.066
<v Jamie Dunphy>As Councilor Avalos said, but, you know, before public testimony, we want to introduce but not move our amendments so that the public, if there is testimony, can speak to them.

1628
02:43:52.115 --> 02:43:56.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Councilor Avalos, would you be willing to introduce Avalos, Dunphy, Koyama Lane 1?

1629
02:43:58.129 --> 02:43:58.835
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, absolutely.

1630
02:43:58.915 --> 02:44:03.813
<v Candace Avalos>So we are introducing this amendment To remove the definition of mechanical equipment.

1631
02:44:04.230 --> 02:44:18.962
<v Candace Avalos>Several major institutions, including professionals at Portland State University, University of Oregon, and OHSU, raised concerns about potential unintended consequences regarding the definition of mechanical equipment and setback and screening requirements under Recap 11.

1632
02:44:19.333 --> 02:44:27.606
<v Candace Avalos>So the introduced amendment was crafted by BPS staff and removes the Section MP7 regarding the definition of mechanical equipment.

1633
02:44:27.847 --> 02:44:32.132
<v Candace Avalos>So that the issue can be further examined by BPS with additional community engagement.

1634
02:44:32.261 --> 02:44:34.700
<v Candace Avalos>And then, so we're not moving it, we're just stating it?

1635
02:44:34.972 --> 02:44:35.566
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, please, for now.

1636
02:44:35.614 --> 02:44:36.320
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1637
02:44:36.513 --> 02:44:38.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you very much, Councilor Avalos.

1638
02:44:38.647 --> 02:44:40.156
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Avalos, Dunphy, Koyama Lane.

1639
02:44:40.494 --> 02:44:44.088
<v Jamie Dunphy>And, uh, I will also take the opportunity to introduce Dunphy 1.

1640
02:44:44.826 --> 02:44:49.175
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, this concept for, uh, this update came from testimony from Warner Pacific.

1641
02:44:49.656 --> 02:44:59.126
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, they have been trying for years to change a zoning code to allow residential uses with within the Campus Institution 1 zone by right, CI-1.

1642
02:45:00.248 --> 02:45:15.398
<v Jamie Dunphy>They own several properties that could be sold for housing, but currently they cannot because they are bound up by a complicated nonconforming situation that essentially makes them unable to be sold because banks will not loan on a property that can't be rebuilt should the existing house burn down, for example.

1643
02:45:16.699 --> 02:45:24.418
<v Jamie Dunphy>Permitting household living would mean— would give meaningful zoning flexibility to utilize adjacent there we go.

1644
02:45:27.299 --> 02:45:33.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>And universities better serve their communities while maximizing the use of existing campus land at a time when Portland's housing needs remain pressing.

1645
02:45:33.957 --> 02:45:42.166
<v Jamie Dunphy>This amendment simply aligns the CI-1 zone with other campus institution zones by allowing household living by right.

1646
02:45:42.297 --> 02:45:51.578
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if passed, my team will work with staff to ensure that related technical changes to impacted codes are updated to be included in the final package— passage of Recap 11.

1647
02:45:51.869 --> 02:45:56.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that is, uh, and the text for that has been pre-filed and is available on there.

1648
02:45:56.668 --> 02:46:07.843
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, with that, uh, I'd like to— before we move to technical— actually, are there technical or clarifying questions before we move to public testimony?

1649
02:46:08.568 --> 02:46:09.067
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1650
02:46:10.423 --> 02:46:12.792
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, uh, Mr. Council President.

1651
02:46:13.003 --> 02:46:14.613
<v Mitch Green>Uh, just Clarifying, so you—.

1652
02:46:14.806 --> 02:46:15.014
<v Ben Henson>Are you—.

1653
02:46:16.412 --> 02:46:18.868
<v Mitch Green>Both of these amendments, you're introducing them but not moving them?

1654
02:46:19.125 --> 02:46:22.175
<v Jamie Dunphy>Not moving them yet so that the public can respond to them.

1655
02:46:22.224 --> 02:46:28.195
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so we— so we're basically— we're also being familiarized with it, so we're just— okay, great, perfect, thanks.

1656
02:46:28.275 --> 02:46:28.693
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, sir.

1657
02:46:29.994 --> 02:46:32.594
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, is there public— oh, Councilor Ryan.

1658
02:46:33.414 --> 02:46:37.603
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I think this might be for— well, I don't know who it's for, but someone can answer it.

1659
02:46:37.748 --> 02:46:42.814
<v Dan Ryan>Um, this is, uh, the recap 11, and when did we do Recap 10?

1660
02:46:43.747 --> 02:46:46.436
<v Dan Ryan>I'm just kind of curious when Recap 12 will take place.

1661
02:46:53.013 --> 02:46:54.924
<v Steve Novick>Good afternoon, uh, councilors.

1662
02:46:55.200 --> 02:46:56.609
<v Steve Novick>Patricia Dievender, for the record.

1663
02:46:56.657 --> 02:47:00.316
<v Steve Novick>I believe Council Recap 10 was adopted in 2024.

1664
02:47:01.190 --> 02:47:02.209
<v JP McNeill>2020.

1665
02:47:03.373 --> 02:47:04.037
<v Dan Ryan>What year is it?

1666
02:47:04.102 --> 02:47:04.879
<v JP McNeill>Yeah, 2024.

1667
02:47:05.527 --> 02:47:11.216
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, so we tend to try to do these, um, every year or so.

1668
02:47:11.584 --> 02:47:17.859
<v Steve Novick>It sometimes takes a little bit longer than a year, but it is a regular and ongoing program as we discussed, um, previously.

1669
02:47:17.939 --> 02:47:19.532
<v Dan Ryan>It's good to see you, Patricia, while you're up here.

1670
02:47:19.677 --> 02:47:26.843
<v Dan Ryan>So I think when I had authority over BTS, we— I think we called this, uh, I called it code clutter cleanup.

1671
02:47:28.006 --> 02:47:28.282
<v Steve Novick>That's correct.

1672
02:47:28.332 --> 02:47:29.889
<v Dan Ryan>Is that a fair statement to make?

1673
02:47:30.199 --> 02:47:30.897
<v Christy White>Yes, this is a—.

1674
02:47:31.334 --> 02:47:38.960
<v Steve Novick>You can think of this code maintenance, code cleanup, just ensuring that the code continues to be responsive to evolving situations.

1675
02:47:39.024 --> 02:47:42.349
<v Dan Ryan>I think it's more active than it used to be, this process.

1676
02:47:42.558 --> 02:47:44.837
<v Dan Ryan>I think it— I know it wasn't happening for a while.

1677
02:47:45.271 --> 02:47:50.746
<v Dan Ryan>When I inherited BDS, the permitting snafus were much worse than they even are today.

1678
02:47:51.051 --> 02:47:57.602
<v Dan Ryan>And partly what we discovered in the task force was that we had a lot of clatter will pass things up here.

1679
02:47:58.052 --> 02:48:03.387
<v Dan Ryan>But we don't look at the impacts of the older codes that might not need to be there any longer.

1680
02:48:03.917 --> 02:48:12.497
<v Dan Ryan>And it was really hard on the customers or even a staff member that would start to go back to one that probably isn't pertinent anymore because another one was passed.

1681
02:48:12.594 --> 02:48:19.343
<v Dan Ryan>So I just want to lift that this is part of that practice and it helps streamline our permitting process when we do this work.

1682
02:48:19.889 --> 02:48:20.886
<v Steve Novick>That's correct.

1683
02:48:21.014 --> 02:48:22.011
<v Dan Ryan>All right, now I know what we're talking about.

1684
02:48:22.075 --> 02:48:28.288
<v Dan Ryan>When you're not in a committee, Sure.

1685
02:48:28.531 --> 02:48:28.840
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1686
02:48:28.936 --> 02:48:29.814
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1687
02:48:30.479 --> 02:48:32.167
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Keelan, can we please call public testimony?

1688
02:48:34.145 --> 02:48:36.914
<v Keelan McClymont>We have 6 folks signed up for testimony.

1689
02:48:36.978 --> 02:48:49.963
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Michael Harrison, Douglas Wade, Peter Finley Frye, Scott McClain, and Sid Haraharan Gopinath.

1690
02:48:51.886 --> 02:48:53.316
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome folks, come on down.

1691
02:48:53.998 --> 02:48:55.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Whoever's sitting first, Michael, looks like you get to go first.

1692
02:48:56.030 --> 02:48:56.972
<v Jamie Dunphy>Introduce yourself for the record.

1693
02:48:57.022 --> 02:48:58.613
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're welcome to share your pronouns and you have 3 minutes.

1694
02:48:59.409 --> 02:48:59.554
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

1695
02:48:59.602 --> 02:49:05.873
<v Michael Harrison>Hi, I'm— first, President Dunphy and members of the council, thanks so much for the opportunity to be here today.

1696
02:49:06.341 --> 02:49:07.209
<v Michael Harrison>I'm Michael Harrison.

1697
02:49:07.665 --> 02:49:09.149
<v Michael Harrison>I'm with OHSU.

1698
02:49:12.262 --> 02:49:20.985
<v Michael Harrison>After several years of losses, financial losses, OHSU has been seeing improvement and we hope that that improvement will continue.

1699
02:49:23.149 --> 02:49:42.302
<v Michael Harrison>However, we still have a significant maintenance backlog of $700 million, which has increased by $200 million since COVID We also have $1.3 million— $1.3, sorry, billion dollars of debt and $600 million additional of pension liabilities.

1700
02:49:42.921 --> 02:49:55.709
<v Michael Harrison>So, you know, sort of watching some of the budget conversations at council, I think you We are sort of acutely aware of those kinds of financial challenges and how they make you really prioritize what you do.

1701
02:49:57.520 --> 02:50:06.541
<v Michael Harrison>So specifically in this space we're talking about today with Recap 11, it has a direct connection to our capital programming.

1702
02:50:07.137 --> 02:50:16.036
<v Michael Harrison>And right now our capital repair and improvement budget is pretty small and it comes out of our reserve funds 'cause we don't have regular revenues.

1703
02:50:16.086 --> 02:50:16.172
<v Doug Wade>Right.

1704
02:50:16.692 --> 02:50:17.495
<v Michael Harrison>That can cover them.

1705
02:50:18.361 --> 02:50:22.921
<v Michael Harrison>And our reserve funds are really intended to keep our doors open during a crisis.

1706
02:50:23.915 --> 02:50:36.742
<v Michael Harrison>Because 2/3 of our patients are on either Medicaid or Medicare programs that face significant federal headwinds, solutions to our budget challenges aren't, you know, going to be solved by passing on costs to patients.

1707
02:50:37.078 --> 02:50:41.123
<v Michael Harrison>You know, we don't really control the Medicaid budget, the Medicare budget, and those are where most of our patients are.

1708
02:50:42.376 --> 02:50:56.300
<v Michael Harrison>So we need to be extremely vigilant in prioritizing our spending generally on keeping our buildings open and keeping our staff paid so that we can provide medical care to those in the community and continue to provide education.

1709
02:50:57.199 --> 02:51:02.283
<v Michael Harrison>And because of that, I wanted to say thank you, feeding off what Councilor Ryan was mentioning.

1710
02:51:02.653 --> 02:51:10.851
<v Michael Harrison>Thank you for efforts like Recap 11 to really right-size the regulations that the city has for this moment.

1711
02:51:10.947 --> 02:51:11.091
<v Dori Hellyer>Thank you.

1712
02:51:11.888 --> 02:51:15.548
<v Michael Harrison>In time, which is a pretty challenging moment in time.

1713
02:51:18.139 --> 02:51:28.796
<v Michael Harrison>We also appreciate and support Councilor Avalos, Dunphy, and Koyama Lane's amendment taking out the definition of mechanical equipment.

1714
02:51:29.117 --> 02:51:37.423
<v Michael Harrison>It's a pretty technical issue, but by taking that amendment out of this particular piece of legislation, it just gives it more time to be worked on.

1715
02:51:37.787 --> 02:51:39.040
<v Michael Harrison>In, in a future process.

1716
02:51:39.329 --> 02:51:50.470
<v Michael Harrison>So happy to talk about technicalities, but mostly I'm here just to say thank you for your efforts to help focus the code and minimize costs.

1717
02:51:50.634 --> 02:51:50.941
<v Michael Harrison>Thank you.

1718
02:51:51.023 --> 02:51:52.242
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1719
02:51:55.441 --> 02:51:56.746
<v Doug Wade>I guess I'm next, right?

1720
02:51:58.165 --> 02:51:58.695
<v Doug Wade>Good afternoon.

1721
02:51:58.808 --> 02:52:03.175
<v Doug Wade>My name is Doug Wade, interim president and CFO of Warner Pacific University.

1722
02:52:03.389 --> 02:52:04.350
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

1723
02:52:04.350 --> 02:52:04.569
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator Tracy Warren.

1724
02:52:04.569 --> 02:52:10.790
<v Doug Wade>Ward Pacific has been a part of the Mount Tabor neighborhood for 90 years.

1725
02:52:11.510 --> 02:52:18.170
<v Doug Wade>We own several residential buildings on campus, apartments and single-family homes.

1726
02:52:18.170 --> 02:52:19.030
<v Doug Wade>These are not dorms.

1727
02:52:19.409 --> 02:52:25.290
<v Doug Wade>They are well-maintained apartments and single-family homes you find throughout Portland.

1728
02:52:25.930 --> 02:52:34.727
<v Doug Wade>Our tenants include first-generation college students for whom affordable housing close to our campus makes a difference in finishing their degree.

1729
02:52:36.296 --> 02:52:37.363
<v Doug Wade>So here's the problem.

1730
02:52:38.123 --> 02:52:50.904
<v Doug Wade>When the city changed our zoning to campus institutional, household living became prohibited and our buildings became legally nonconforming.

1731
02:52:53.069 --> 02:52:54.313
<v Doug Wade>Our buildings did not change.

1732
02:52:54.361 --> 02:52:55.523
<v Doug Wade>The code changed around them.

1733
02:52:57.202 --> 02:53:01.156
<v Doug Wade>These properties were legally constructed, and properly permitted.

1734
02:53:02.078 --> 02:53:06.331
<v Doug Wade>We were renting these homes without even knowing household living had become prohibited.

1735
02:53:08.877 --> 02:53:19.345
<v Doug Wade>That classification creates real consequences for financing, renovation, long-term planning, and it affects our ability to keep these properties available for housing.

1736
02:53:21.100 --> 02:53:23.316
<v Doug Wade>Warner Pacific did not create this situation.

1737
02:53:23.595 --> 02:53:24.877
<v Doug Wade>The change in zoning did.

1738
02:53:26.852 --> 02:53:27.799
<v Doug Wade>Portland needs housing.

1739
02:53:28.634 --> 02:53:31.252
<v Doug Wade>We have housing in existing buildings.

1740
02:53:32.407 --> 02:53:38.477
<v Doug Wade>This amendment is a targeted correction that reflects reality and supports Portland's housing goals.

1741
02:53:39.778 --> 02:53:41.672
<v Doug Wade>The zoning code was changed around us.

1742
02:53:42.442 --> 02:53:46.665
<v Doug Wade>Our legally constructed buildings became nonconforming through no action of our own.

1743
02:53:47.645 --> 02:53:48.945
<v Doug Wade>The code now expects them to disappear.

1744
02:53:49.186 --> 02:53:50.390
<v Doug Wade>Councilmember Wilson, you have 2 minutes.

1745
02:53:51.895 --> 02:53:55.041
<v Doug Wade>That's not good policy, is not good for Portland housing.

1746
02:53:56.459 --> 02:54:03.561
<v Doug Wade>We ask you to amend the text during this council meeting to allow housing to be outright permitted in the CI-1 zone.

1747
02:54:04.805 --> 02:54:05.514
<v Doug Wade>Thank you for listening.

1748
02:54:06.599 --> 02:54:07.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1749
02:54:08.700 --> 02:54:09.634
<v Peter Finley Frye>Good morning.

1750
02:54:09.859 --> 02:54:11.180
<v Peter Finley Frye>My name is Peter Finley Frye.

1751
02:54:11.227 --> 02:54:14.706
<v Peter Finley Frye>I'm a nationally certified land use planner.

1752
02:54:14.867 --> 02:54:19.088
<v Peter Finley Frye>I want to begin by apologizing to Councilor Avalos Yes.

1753
02:54:19.185 --> 02:54:26.138
<v Peter Finley Frye>The navigating the new City Council processes is a little complex, and we're learning.

1754
02:54:26.797 --> 02:54:30.876
<v Peter Finley Frye>And we should have been in front of their committee, but we're learning.

1755
02:54:31.406 --> 02:54:32.240
<v Peter Finley Frye>I apologize.

1756
02:54:33.380 --> 02:54:38.905
<v Peter Finley Frye>We're asking— the zoning code literally has a million or more letters in it.

1757
02:54:39.403 --> 02:54:44.494
<v Peter Finley Frye>We're asking you to change one letter in Table 150-1.

1758
02:54:44.558 --> 02:54:55.119
<v Peter Finley Frye>We're asking you to change N to Y, no to yes, to allow household living on CI-1 campuses.

1759
02:54:55.215 --> 02:55:00.606
<v Peter Finley Frye>This includes Warner Pacific, Concordia, Reed, Lewis and Clark.

1760
02:55:01.474 --> 02:55:05.920
<v Peter Finley Frye>And we can't really find any opposition to this idea.

1761
02:55:06.786 --> 02:55:07.829
<v Peter Finley Frye>Thank you for your time.

1762
02:55:08.069 --> 02:55:10.204
<v Peter Finley Frye>We're here to answer any technical questions.

1763
02:55:11.183 --> 02:55:11.648
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1764
02:55:13.027 --> 02:55:14.102
<v Sameer Kanal>Hi, I'm Scott McClain.

1765
02:55:14.152 --> 02:55:15.613
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm a commercial real estate broker.

1766
02:55:15.854 --> 02:55:17.959
<v Sameer Kanal>I was involved in the sale of Concordia University.

1767
02:55:18.007 --> 02:55:26.031
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm currently in the process of marketing the Multnomah University campus, and I'm here on behalf of the owners of the Multnomah University campus to support this.

1768
02:55:27.532 --> 02:55:30.975
<v Mitch Green>What we're seeing is more students learning online.

1769
02:55:31.638 --> 02:55:36.924
<v Jamie Dunphy>About 26% of undergrads and 36% of graduate students are now getting their education online.

1770
02:55:36.989 --> 02:55:39.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's a lot of advantages to It's more convenient.

1771
02:55:40.154 --> 02:55:46.322
<v Sameer Kanal>We're seeing nontraditional students, but we're also seeing housing on campus is not being utilized like it had previously.

1772
02:55:46.370 --> 02:55:49.425
<v Mitch Green>So we support this amendment change.

1773
02:55:51.884 --> 02:55:52.511
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1774
02:55:52.688 --> 02:55:53.411
<v Sharon Blair>Thank you.

1775
02:55:55.113 --> 02:55:56.528
<v Keelan McClymont>Sid is joining us online.

1776
02:56:01.409 --> 02:56:01.799
<v Ben Henson>Welcome.

1777
02:56:03.136 --> 02:56:03.474
<v Sid Hariharangat>Thank you.

1778
02:56:04.297 --> 02:56:05.916
<v Sid Hariharangat>Good afternoon, members of City Council.

1779
02:56:06.061 --> 02:56:11.644
<v Sid Hariharangat>Thanks for the opportunity to testify this afternoon on this productive and proactive code update package.

1780
02:56:11.709 --> 02:56:16.152
<v Sid Hariharangat>I really want to thank staff for the diligent work they've done to get this recap project to where it is.

1781
02:56:17.130 --> 02:56:18.606
<v Sid Hariharangat>My name is Sid Hariharangat.

1782
02:56:18.686 --> 02:56:22.842
<v Sid Hariharangat>I'm a land use planner with a local engineering and architecture firm, McKenzie.

1783
02:56:24.045 --> 02:56:26.644
<v Sid Hariharangat>The request I have this afternoon is quite simple.

1784
02:56:27.270 --> 02:56:36.797
<v Sid Hariharangat>Staff have written a minor code change to section of code about land division on sites with floodplains to allow more flexibility of— in developing these sites.

1785
02:56:37.679 --> 02:56:46.097
<v Sid Hariharangat>Now, this code change has been placed in the Columbia Corridor Industrial Lands Environmental Zone project, known as the CCIL project.

1786
02:56:46.963 --> 02:56:54.405
<v Sid Hariharangat>And we recently learned that the CCIL project is unlikely for adoption until early 2027 or later.

1787
02:56:55.078 --> 02:57:07.845
<v Sid Hariharangat>And since this code change regarding the land divisions in the floodplain does not have anything to do with environmental zones, and its impact is not limited to industrial zones, but also applies to sites in residential zones.

1788
02:57:08.861 --> 02:57:16.930
<v Sid Hariharangat>We believe that the RECAP project is the more appropriate vehicle for this change compared to where it currently lives in that CCIL project.

1789
02:57:19.186 --> 02:57:26.184
<v Sid Hariharangat>Implementing this change now could prevent further delays for development, including residential projects, which are a focus in the city right now.

1790
02:57:27.549 --> 02:57:43.661
<v Sid Hariharangat>Now, getting to that language that's currently in the CCIL zone project, that language is already written, and the ask from City Council and staff here would be for this language to be moved from that CCIL proposed draft to the RECAP final draft.

1791
02:57:44.784 --> 02:57:53.518
<v Sid Hariharangat>Additionally, this language has been reviewed and approved by Planning Commission and does not change any existing environmental natural resource area policies.

1792
02:57:55.301 --> 02:58:00.787
<v Sid Hariharangat>Now, staff has directed us to come to City Council with this change because it is so late in the process.

1793
02:58:01.823 --> 02:58:16.030
<v Sid Hariharangat>And we really ask for City Council's consideration to— for an amendment to RECAP language to move the land division floodplain code change from the CCIL E-Zone project into the RECAP 11 project.

1794
02:58:16.930 --> 02:58:20.022
<v Sid Hariharangat>I'm happy to answer any technical questions this afternoon.

1795
02:58:20.519 --> 02:58:26.138
<v Sid Hariharangat>Um, but again, we believe that this is a straightforward change relocating where this text would be.

1796
02:58:26.897 --> 02:58:27.528
<v Sid Hariharangat>Thank you for your time.

1797
02:58:28.296 --> 02:58:29.028
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1798
02:58:29.938 --> 02:58:32.182
<v Keelan McClymont>Our last testifier is Sarah Heinecke.

1799
02:58:37.239 --> 02:58:38.542
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Sarah.

1800
02:58:45.039 --> 02:58:47.996
<v Sarah Heinecke>Council President Dunphy and members of the City Council.

1801
02:58:48.506 --> 02:58:50.290
<v Sarah Heinecke>For the record, my name is Sarah Heinecke.

1802
02:58:51.076 --> 02:58:58.530
<v Sarah Heinecke>I serve as the Director of Planning and Sustainability in the Division of Planning, Construction, and Real Estate at Portland State University.

1803
02:58:59.429 --> 02:59:01.468
<v Sarah Heinecke>Thank you for the opportunity to testify.

1804
02:59:02.255 --> 02:59:13.950
<v Sarah Heinecke>Portland State University, alongside OHSU, Portland Community College, and the University of Oregon's Portland campus, applauds the city's— city council, Mayor Wilson, Planning Commission, thank you.

1805
02:59:13.950 --> 02:59:14.549
<v Sarah Heinecke>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

1806
02:59:14.549 --> 02:59:20.329
<v Sarah Heinecke>I'd like to thank the mayor, city council, city staff, and city administration for your ongoing efforts to reduce regulatory burden and to help rein in costs.

1807
02:59:21.590 --> 02:59:25.500
<v Sarah Heinecke>These efforts directly benefit institutions like ours.

1808
02:59:25.530 --> 02:59:29.879
<v Sarah Heinecke>Portland State is the most affordable 4-year university in Oregon.

1809
02:59:29.909 --> 02:59:34.739
<v Sarah Heinecke>We exist to serve this region, its students, its workforce, and its neighborhoods.

1810
02:59:35.090 --> 02:59:40.000
<v Sarah Heinecke>We are doing that work right now under conditions of serious financial strain.

1811
02:59:40.753 --> 02:59:56.093
<v Sarah Heinecke>Every capital dollar we commit to compliance requirements that provide limited public benefit is a dollar that does not go toward a classroom, an advising appointment, a mental health resource, or a community partnership.

1812
02:59:57.168 --> 03:00:07.174
<v Sarah Heinecke>Unanticipated screening requirements for equipment such as transformers and backflow devices would compound across multiple buildings, projects, and budget cycles.

1813
03:00:07.753 --> 03:00:12.396
<v Sarah Heinecke>The cumulative effect is felt directly by the students and communities who depend on us.

1814
03:00:13.230 --> 03:00:37.513
<v Sarah Heinecke>We ask that council direct the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability to revisit this definition, whether that be as part of approval of Recap 11 or instead striking the definition from Recap 11 and folding it into the upcoming Code Alignment Project 2, giving the Planning Commission the opportunity to weigh these concerns before the matter returns to council in 2027.

1815
03:00:37.789 --> 03:00:46.984
<v Sarah Heinecke>Getting this definition right matters not only for universities but for small businesses, housing developers, and others across Portland who would bear these same costs.

1816
03:00:47.789 --> 03:00:51.882
<v Sarah Heinecke>On behalf of our students and our community, thank you for all you do for our city.

1817
03:00:52.888 --> 03:00:53.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1818
03:00:54.833 --> 03:00:55.935
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

1819
03:00:56.227 --> 03:00:58.968
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, we are now moving into discussion.

1820
03:00:59.113 --> 03:01:03.414
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Avalos, would you like to move your— move our amendment?

1821
03:01:05.739 --> 03:01:06.143
<v Candace Avalos>Absolutely.

1822
03:01:06.320 --> 03:01:11.780
<v Candace Avalos>I would formally move Avalos-Dunphy TKL1.

1823
03:01:13.120 --> 03:01:14.251
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos moves.

1824
03:01:14.558 --> 03:01:15.236
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will second.

1825
03:01:16.399 --> 03:01:20.881
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there— colleagues, is there any discussion or debate of the amendment?

1826
03:01:21.108 --> 03:01:21.800
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1827
03:01:22.945 --> 03:01:24.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1828
03:01:25.211 --> 03:01:28.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, I saw the letter come in with this request as well.

1829
03:01:29.302 --> 03:01:31.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate you all addressing it.

1830
03:01:32.014 --> 03:01:43.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I heard from Councilor Avalos that there was some work done between staff and the institutions, and I'd just like the opportunity for us to hear from staff whether they have any concerns about where this ended.

1831
03:01:44.064 --> 03:01:48.025
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There was a change proposed, and this now makes an additional change to that section.

1832
03:01:49.021 --> 03:01:56.772
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If there's anything we should be aware of that, um, that could come to us as a problem later for doing this?

1833
03:01:57.782 --> 03:02:00.671
<v Steve Novick>Thank you for the question, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1834
03:02:00.751 --> 03:02:02.532
<v Steve Novick>Patricia Diefenter, for the, for the record.

1835
03:02:02.596 --> 03:02:13.156
<v Steve Novick>We did work with the council offices and the institutions, and the published or the posted amendment, um, staff's evaluation is that that is fine.

1836
03:02:13.429 --> 03:02:20.942
<v Steve Novick>What it does is essentially take out the definition, which was intended to be a clarification of what mechanical equipment is.

1837
03:02:21.522 --> 03:02:27.338
<v Steve Novick>The other red lines that you see in the posted document actually just restore the existing language of the code.

1838
03:02:27.579 --> 03:02:35.864
<v Steve Novick>So this allows us the opportunity to take that issue kind of offline from this project and investigate it further at another time.

1839
03:02:37.643 --> 03:02:52.093
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There was a proposal, though, to add this language to provide clarification should we have any concerns Since we're not providing clarification, was there a different problem that you were trying to fix that we're now not fixing that council should be aware of?

1840
03:02:52.382 --> 03:02:53.328
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I appreciate it.

1841
03:02:53.377 --> 03:02:55.363
<v Steve Novick>Sorry, did you want to jump in there?

1842
03:02:55.653 --> 03:02:55.909
<v JP McNeill>Sure.

1843
03:02:56.710 --> 03:02:59.949
<v JP McNeill>Yeah, the problem that we were trying to solve was more around clarity.

1844
03:03:00.174 --> 03:03:09.279
<v JP McNeill>So the proposed amendment would have just clarified— right now in the code, there's a lot of different just areas where mechanical equipment comes up.

1845
03:03:09.376 --> 03:03:11.331
<v JP McNeill>Up in different sections of the code.

1846
03:03:11.459 --> 03:03:20.704
<v JP McNeill>We were trying to just define it in a definition so that it was in one area to make it easier for PP&D staff when they're explaining it to folks and implementing the code.

1847
03:03:21.090 --> 03:03:24.903
<v JP McNeill>It wouldn't have resulted in any actual change to the policy.

1848
03:03:25.255 --> 03:03:34.759
<v JP McNeill>How they— how it's reviewed and how mechanical equipment is treated with permits that come in would stay the same regardless of whether we changed the definition.

1849
03:03:34.854 --> 03:03:49.931
<v Steve Novick>It was more of a I think that, um, it will be good for us to clarify it in the future, but I don't think there's any harm in waiting to kind of drill down on that and get it more— get it correct.

1850
03:03:50.500 --> 03:03:55.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So should we expect in the next package of revisions that we'll see different language to clarify this?

1851
03:03:56.141 --> 03:03:56.287
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1852
03:03:56.720 --> 03:03:57.493
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1853
03:03:58.810 --> 03:03:59.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1854
03:03:59.853 --> 03:04:00.408
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1855
03:04:02.566 --> 03:04:11.477
<v Sameer Kanal>I guess this last piece might have just answered that, but I, I, I'm looking for something other than like a more numerical response to that in terms of how long.

1856
03:04:13.281 --> 03:04:16.975
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, like, I assume it's when, when we will come back with that.

1857
03:04:17.846 --> 03:04:22.105
<v Steve Novick>Um, honestly, I don't have an answer to how long at this moment.

1858
03:04:22.218 --> 03:04:34.978
<v Steve Novick>I think that, um, we have to figure out which project this could— it could come in the Cap 2 project potentially, or some other code amendment project that the, uh, that BPS would be undertaking.

1859
03:04:36.289 --> 03:04:37.175
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that was my only question.

1860
03:04:37.320 --> 03:04:37.450
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1861
03:04:37.563 --> 03:04:37.805
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1862
03:04:38.209 --> 03:04:38.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1863
03:04:39.418 --> 03:04:39.837
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1864
03:04:41.516 --> 03:04:41.709
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1865
03:04:41.823 --> 03:05:04.450
<v Mitch Green>I, I just want to say thanks to those of the carriers of the kind of proposed amendments today for picking up this, um, request from— I had heard directly from Mr. Harrison, I think, and others who were, um, uh, understanding I think, you know, that our form of government has changed and, you know, some of the kind of like committee structures have changed, uh, but still kind of like, I think we missed this, how can we get plugged in?

1866
03:05:04.498 --> 03:05:05.993
<v Mitch Green>So you guys caught that, you brought it in.

1867
03:05:06.040 --> 03:05:07.808
<v Mitch Green>So that's, that's laudable and I appreciate that.

1868
03:05:08.498 --> 03:05:10.989
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm supportive of, of the amendments today.

1869
03:05:11.085 --> 03:05:19.648
<v Mitch Green>I do have a question though, um, uh, and I, I, I just, I just missed it, but there was a second to last testifier, uh, Sid, I believe.

1870
03:05:19.762 --> 03:05:26.549
<v Mitch Green>I wonder if they're still on and would be able to sort of Remind me again what their particular ask was today.

1871
03:05:27.372 --> 03:05:28.503
<v Mitch Green>Is that permissible, Chair?

1872
03:05:29.050 --> 03:05:30.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd be happy to if they're still online to—.

1873
03:05:31.165 --> 03:05:31.406
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

1874
03:05:31.504 --> 03:05:32.213
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know if they are.

1875
03:05:34.600 --> 03:05:34.889
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah.

1876
03:05:35.440 --> 03:05:38.106
<v Steve Novick>Councilor, we're aware of that testimony.

1877
03:05:38.172 --> 03:05:40.693
<v Steve Novick>We can provide some information on that if you'd like.

1878
03:05:40.854 --> 03:05:41.664
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, please do.

1879
03:05:41.744 --> 03:05:42.375
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, that'd be great.

1880
03:05:42.979 --> 03:05:51.250
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, so the speaker, the testifier was referencing the Columbia Corridor and industrial land Yes.

1881
03:05:51.361 --> 03:05:59.198
<v Steve Novick>Environmental Zone Project, which is another project that has— that will be coming to council probably in the early next year timeframe.

1882
03:06:00.032 --> 03:06:09.555
<v Steve Novick>That project essentially really deals largely with updating the location of the environmental zoning in the industrial areas.

1883
03:06:10.790 --> 03:06:18.995
<v Steve Novick>One of the things that it does is also bring regulations into conformance with floodplain Federal floodplain considerations.

1884
03:06:19.123 --> 03:06:32.799
<v Steve Novick>And one, one of the amendments that's proposed is just a fairly minor, minor technical code amendment that addresses land divisions in floodplains and actually does make attempt to make them more flexible.

1885
03:06:33.200 --> 03:06:54.873
<v Steve Novick>So I think what the caller or what the testifier was requesting is that that particular code provision that's proposed for change in that project be brought into the recap project at this time to accelerate, to, you know, to have it become effective sooner because this project will be coming to council at a later time.

1886
03:06:55.756 --> 03:06:56.254
<v Mitch Green>I understand.

1887
03:06:56.302 --> 03:06:58.519
<v Mitch Green>And that's— and who are they representing?

1888
03:06:58.791 --> 03:06:59.353
<v Mitch Green>I missed that piece.

1889
03:06:59.433 --> 03:07:03.222
<v Steve Novick>They were Affirm McKenzie, a small planning engineering firm.

1890
03:07:03.288 --> 03:07:03.625
<v Mitch Green>Gotcha.

1891
03:07:03.833 --> 03:07:04.010
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1892
03:07:04.331 --> 03:07:06.370
<v Sameer Kanal>And I am— thank you, Councilor, for that question.

1893
03:07:06.418 --> 03:07:14.611
<v Sameer Kanal>I am available on the call if there's any technical questions, but I want to confirm that Staff's explanation there is in line with what we were asking for.

1894
03:07:15.111 --> 03:07:16.416
<v Mitch Green>Okay, thank you so much.

1895
03:07:16.480 --> 03:07:17.222
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that.

1896
03:07:17.432 --> 03:07:21.726
<v Mitch Green>I think that clarifies— that fills in the gap that I kind of missed in the testimony when listening.

1897
03:07:23.813 --> 03:07:26.673
<v Mitch Green>No, I have no concerns with the amendments, both of them.

1898
03:07:27.090 --> 03:07:28.085
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to support them today.

1899
03:07:28.149 --> 03:07:28.551
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1900
03:07:29.033 --> 03:07:29.725
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1901
03:07:29.981 --> 03:07:30.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1902
03:07:32.183 --> 03:07:32.424
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1903
03:07:32.504 --> 03:07:35.698
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just— I apologize for seeking some clarity here.

1904
03:07:36.213 --> 03:07:45.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is a strange amendment to be reading because it's new red language that looks exactly the same as the striked out.

1905
03:07:45.234 --> 03:07:48.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're just restoring fully in terms of the language.

1906
03:07:48.308 --> 03:07:49.134
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's what we're seeing here?

1907
03:07:49.458 --> 03:07:52.789
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman, yes, restoring existing code language.

1908
03:07:53.479 --> 03:07:53.656
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1909
03:07:57.898 --> 03:08:08.474
<v Eric Zimmerman>I guess I— what confused me there was this was said it was intended to provide more clarity but by getting rid of the language, I didn't see more clarity coming out.

1910
03:08:08.619 --> 03:08:10.095
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm missing something here.

1911
03:08:10.144 --> 03:08:14.334
<v Steve Novick>One of the red lines is of the definition itself.

1912
03:08:14.479 --> 03:08:15.058
<v Ben Henson>Maybe we could—.

1913
03:08:15.827 --> 03:08:18.012
<v Steve Novick>And that's what is being removed.

1914
03:08:18.735 --> 03:08:24.113
<v Steve Novick>That was the new language that was being proposed that is now being removed as a result of this amendment.

1915
03:08:25.397 --> 03:08:29.138
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because a definition is a set, whereas the rest were used as examples.

1916
03:08:29.573 --> 03:08:29.684
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1917
03:08:29.734 --> 03:08:34.698
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's the question, is does an example constitute all, but a definition does constitute all?

1918
03:08:34.875 --> 03:08:35.034
<v Micah Goldstein>Okay.

1919
03:08:35.100 --> 03:08:35.275
<v Sarah Heinecke>Yes.

1920
03:08:35.983 --> 03:08:36.851
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for the clarification.

1921
03:08:37.525 --> 03:08:38.264
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1922
03:08:38.328 --> 03:08:38.859
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1923
03:08:39.935 --> 03:08:40.868
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

1924
03:08:40.979 --> 03:08:46.314
<v Dan Ryan>First, I want to acknowledge that it's great to have OHSU, PSU, and Warner Pacific here.

1925
03:08:47.325 --> 03:08:52.805
<v Dan Ryan>Last time I looked, Warner Pacific is the most racially diverse higher education institute in the state.

1926
03:08:53.351 --> 03:08:55.808
<v Dan Ryan>And so that's walking the talk of equity.

1927
03:08:56.082 --> 03:08:56.772
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you very much.

1928
03:08:58.234 --> 03:09:00.064
<v Dan Ryan>How did you determine— I'm just curious.

1929
03:09:00.272 --> 03:09:05.667
<v Dan Ryan>So when you come to us with these things, it's a chance for legislators to understand how operations are moving along.

1930
03:09:06.503 --> 03:09:09.424
<v Dan Ryan>How do you determine the scope of the current iteration of these updates?

1931
03:09:09.504 --> 03:09:10.997
<v Dan Ryan>I mean, I'm sure it's a long list.

1932
03:09:11.479 --> 03:09:14.627
<v Dan Ryan>How do you discipline yourself to focus on what you think is next?

1933
03:09:15.494 --> 03:09:18.769
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, so that's a great question.

1934
03:09:19.540 --> 03:09:26.220
<v Steve Novick>There is a database which people can enter their ideas about code amendments in.

1935
03:09:26.976 --> 03:09:29.674
<v Steve Novick>And that is the starting point staff use for recaps.

1936
03:09:29.721 --> 03:09:45.397
<v Steve Novick>So we review all of the entries in the database, and JP can speak to this a little better, but essentially we look for those topics that we think will have the kind of the most wide application and therefore the most impact.

1937
03:09:45.846 --> 03:09:55.222
<v Steve Novick>And if we make that change, it will Uh, you know, have, have some impact as opposed to a change that maybe only would affect a couple, a few or limited properties within the city.

1938
03:09:56.154 --> 03:10:06.252
<v Steve Novick>So, um, that is, that is one of the primary ways that we kind of sort through that database and try to identify, um, amendments to include in the package.

1939
03:10:06.493 --> 03:10:14.566
<v Steve Novick>I think we— there are hundreds of entries in that database, and for example, I believe there are 50-something amendments in this package.

1940
03:10:14.695 --> 03:10:20.947
<v Steve Novick>So we kind of take them by the most— the ones that are most impactful and start with those.

1941
03:10:22.010 --> 03:10:24.947
<v Dan Ryan>And does the DRAC board get heavily involved at the early stage?

1942
03:10:25.012 --> 03:10:32.899
<v Dan Ryan>Because in my recollection, what I experienced is that's the governing body that has the most consumers and the most clients, if you will.

1943
03:10:34.004 --> 03:10:46.494
<v Steve Novick>I know that we do present to DRAC and do give them information about the work plan as we're developing it so that there is an opportunity for them to provide some input And I don't know if JP, if you want to—.

1944
03:10:46.686 --> 03:10:51.549
<v Dan Ryan>Would you say part of permit reforms was to do a better job of listening to those who are using the systems?

1945
03:10:51.742 --> 03:10:55.240
<v Dan Ryan>And so I just wanted to make sure that was still part of the system that we're building.

1946
03:10:55.737 --> 03:10:59.846
<v JP McNeill>Yeah, the— so as Patricia— oh, I'm— for the record, I'm JP McNeill.

1947
03:10:59.911 --> 03:11:00.922
<v JP McNeill>I'm a planner with BPS.

1948
03:11:01.595 --> 03:11:09.412
<v JP McNeill>Um, we start with the database, and the vast majority of the things that go in there actually start with PP&D.

1949
03:11:09.476 --> 03:11:17.483
<v JP McNeill>The public also puts them in there, And so we work with the PP&D staff and we have a process for— we try to sort of rate things.

1950
03:11:17.563 --> 03:11:25.681
<v JP McNeill>We have a ranking system to figure out what's going to have the biggest impact and which are going to bring the most bang for the buck.

1951
03:11:26.066 --> 03:11:33.237
<v JP McNeill>But then we put together a work plan, a scoping work plan, and that is released publicly for comment.

1952
03:11:33.317 --> 03:11:39.433
<v JP McNeill>So that's when we take that to DRAC and we bring that around so that folks can comment on that.

1953
03:11:39.721 --> 03:11:54.574
<v JP McNeill>We also publish along with that the work plan of what we are proposing to include with RECAP, and then there's also an appendix that has everything that we didn't include so that folks can see the things that we left out and comment on that as well.

1954
03:11:55.200 --> 03:11:55.730
<v Dan Ryan>That makes sense.

1955
03:11:55.779 --> 03:12:03.509
<v Dan Ryan>I think the smart people at permitting, the smart people at BPS, there was a time where they weren't coordinating very well, and I think that got us into the problem.

1956
03:12:03.574 --> 03:12:10.648
<v Dan Ryan>So this is an example where the new government and having work areas and a DCA overseeing that, I think, allows us to have a better system.

1957
03:12:11.409 --> 03:12:13.014
<v Dan Ryan>At least that's what I'm hearing right now.

1958
03:12:14.510 --> 03:12:22.469
<v Dan Ryan>Were there any changes that were left off the table that you want to talk about that were— that there was a lot of tension and do you think that we'll keep exploring that?

1959
03:12:22.695 --> 03:12:24.210
<v Dan Ryan>Is there any one that you'd like to discuss?

1960
03:12:25.929 --> 03:12:29.387
<v JP McNeill>Anything that— any items that we didn't include because—.

1961
03:12:29.387 --> 03:12:34.809
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, like it needed more time even though it's nothing's come to mind.

1962
03:12:34.906 --> 03:12:38.457
<v JP McNeill>It's been a while since we did the scoping.

1963
03:12:39.350 --> 03:12:40.656
<v JP McNeill>Nothing is coming to mind.

1964
03:12:40.737 --> 03:12:47.177
<v JP McNeill>We brought the most salient ones, and then as things come— as the process goes along, things get added.

1965
03:12:47.290 --> 03:12:56.702
<v JP McNeill>And so things that become issues or become more salient with time, they often find their way into a recap project.

1966
03:12:56.799 --> 03:12:56.929
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1967
03:12:57.030 --> 03:12:58.170
<v Dan Ryan>It's such a fluid process.

1968
03:12:58.218 --> 03:12:58.924
<v Dan Ryan>So yeah, yeah.

1969
03:12:59.454 --> 03:13:03.790
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to thank my colleagues on the committee for listening to the feedback.

1970
03:13:03.887 --> 03:13:08.801
<v Dan Ryan>And it seems like these 2 amendments are friendly amendments to all of you.

1971
03:13:09.027 --> 03:13:09.925
<v Dan Ryan>Am I missing something?

1972
03:13:10.150 --> 03:13:13.587
<v Dan Ryan>Because there was a reason why they didn't show up.

1973
03:13:13.667 --> 03:13:14.905
<v Dan Ryan>I mean, no one's perfect.

1974
03:13:14.968 --> 03:13:17.746
<v Dan Ryan>So these are good, good changes, good edits.

1975
03:13:18.004 --> 03:13:21.023
<v Steve Novick>These are— yeah, we're— staff is supportive of these amendments.

1976
03:13:21.377 --> 03:13:41.604
<v Steve Novick>Um, the— I think the, the the campus institutional zone issue didn't really surface until this stage, but it's, it's, you know, given the conditions that everyone described, it's reasonable to consider that there may be some, you know, changes to the uses that should be permitted in that zone.

1977
03:13:42.022 --> 03:13:47.388
<v Dan Ryan>Well, it's wonderful to have the campus's lobby come together to help create these amendments.

1978
03:13:47.646 --> 03:13:48.289
<v Dan Ryan>All right, sounds good.

1979
03:13:48.386 --> 03:13:48.561
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

1980
03:13:49.059 --> 03:13:49.735
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1981
03:13:51.504 --> 03:13:55.843
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue to discuss, uh, Avalos, Dunphy, Koyama Lane 1.

1982
03:13:56.134 --> 03:13:57.494
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call the roll?

1983
03:13:59.277 --> 03:14:01.521
<v Keelan McClymont>Moved by Avalos, seconded by Dunphy.

1984
03:14:01.941 --> 03:14:03.152
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane absent.

1985
03:14:03.200 --> 03:14:04.040
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo absent.

1986
03:14:04.120 --> 03:14:04.459
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1987
03:14:06.703 --> 03:14:06.752
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1988
03:14:08.075 --> 03:14:08.173
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1989
03:14:08.477 --> 03:14:08.638
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1990
03:14:09.138 --> 03:14:09.346
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1991
03:14:10.006 --> 03:14:10.167
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1992
03:14:10.649 --> 03:14:11.068
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1993
03:14:11.213 --> 03:14:11.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1994
03:14:11.792 --> 03:14:12.163
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1995
03:14:13.064 --> 03:14:13.192
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1996
03:14:14.045 --> 03:14:14.254
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1997
03:14:14.834 --> 03:14:14.881
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1998
03:14:15.602 --> 03:14:15.795
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1999
03:14:16.308 --> 03:14:16.341
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2000
03:14:16.870 --> 03:14:17.255
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

2001
03:14:17.593 --> 03:14:17.721
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2002
03:14:18.155 --> 03:14:18.459
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2003
03:14:18.637 --> 03:14:18.684
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

2004
03:14:19.215 --> 03:14:19.584
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2005
03:14:19.922 --> 03:14:19.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2006
03:14:20.500 --> 03:14:24.191
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with a vote of 10 ayes and 2 absent.

2007
03:14:24.433 --> 03:14:25.332
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2008
03:14:26.263 --> 03:14:29.379
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I will formally move Dunphy 1.

2009
03:14:29.570 --> 03:14:35.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a reminder, this is to allow housing in the Campus Institution 1 zone by right.

2010
03:14:35.994 --> 03:14:36.877
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I would ask for a second.

2011
03:14:37.454 --> 03:14:37.808
<v Micah Goldstein>Second.

2012
03:14:39.028 --> 03:14:40.136
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm gonna— I think that was Councilor Smith.

2013
03:14:41.691 --> 03:14:45.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, is, uh, discussion of this amendment now?

2014
03:14:45.698 --> 03:14:46.755
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman, is that a—.

2015
03:14:47.316 --> 03:14:51.514
<v Eric Zimmerman>So it's an easy one, but I guess my question—.

2016
03:14:51.771 --> 03:14:52.203
<v Doug Wade>I, I'm—.

2017
03:14:52.412 --> 03:14:54.031
<v Eric Zimmerman>Staff, you should probably just stay up here the whole time.

2018
03:14:54.415 --> 03:14:55.377
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not sure what we're doing here.

2019
03:14:55.697 --> 03:15:07.282
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, the— I guess I'm, I'm going to use this amendment as, as a mechanism just to kind of talk overall about Recap 11.

2020
03:15:07.506 --> 03:15:16.093
<v Eric Zimmerman>So Housing on a campus seems about as basic as a pumpkin spice latte, right?

2021
03:15:16.174 --> 03:15:17.619
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what am I missing here?

2022
03:15:17.666 --> 03:15:19.465
<v Eric Zimmerman>How did we like not get this?

2023
03:15:20.091 --> 03:15:23.477
<v Steve Novick>I'll start us out and then maybe JP can—.

2024
03:15:23.477 --> 03:15:27.908
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, help me out because it has a bigger impact to other questions I've got regarding the presentation.

2025
03:15:28.663 --> 03:15:34.425
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I mean, generally speaking, housing is allowed if it's for like student housing.

2026
03:15:34.619 --> 03:15:35.197
<v Steve Novick>So if it's a—.

2027
03:15:35.245 --> 03:15:35.823
<v Dan Ryan>Faculty.

2028
03:15:36.319 --> 03:15:38.439
<v Steve Novick>Student, faculty, it's accessory to the university.

2029
03:15:38.697 --> 03:15:39.729
<v Steve Novick>To the university use.

2030
03:15:40.649 --> 03:16:02.201
<v Steve Novick>And I think the reason for that at the time was to ensure that, you know, there was— campuses were growing and we wanted to make sure that the land that were associated with campuses would be able to support the growing needs of the campuses while allowing housing that's essentially accessory to the university.

2031
03:16:02.958 --> 03:16:05.771
<v Steve Novick>I think what we're hearing now, some of that testimony was that—.

2032
03:16:05.771 --> 03:16:05.818
<v Jeff Fish>Yes.

2033
03:16:06.165 --> 03:16:08.237
<v Steve Novick>You know, there's some changes.

2034
03:16:08.575 --> 03:16:10.613
<v Steve Novick>Campuses are not kind of growing in the same way.

2035
03:16:10.838 --> 03:16:16.345
<v Steve Novick>There's, for a variety of reasons, online learning or what, you know, and there's not the same need for housing.

2036
03:16:17.165 --> 03:16:25.016
<v Steve Novick>Meanwhile, these campuses have land that they may want to be able to sell or, you know, have be separate from the university.

2037
03:16:25.273 --> 03:16:30.878
<v Steve Novick>And that's where the household living uses that are separate from the university are not allowed in the zone currently.

2038
03:16:31.166 --> 03:16:39.076
<v Eric Zimmerman>So okay, so I needed some help in terms of definitions because it was allowable in, I think it's, is it CI-2 and 3 but not 1?

2039
03:16:39.174 --> 03:16:40.209
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what are those definitions?

2040
03:16:40.700 --> 03:16:44.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>What was the line in the sand that existed for the no instead of the yes?

2041
03:16:47.132 --> 03:16:56.841
<v JP McNeill>Well, I think the difference between the zones is that CI-1 is intended to be basically adjacent, less intense residential zones.

2042
03:16:57.231 --> 03:17:00.009
<v JP McNeill>So it's like around R-5, the single dwelling zones.

2043
03:17:00.586 --> 03:17:17.826
<v JP McNeill>But a little more context about the campus institutional zones is that they were created with part of the comp plan update in 2018 as a response to requests from the institutions that were often in residential zones and zoned residentially.

2044
03:17:18.003 --> 03:17:22.000
<v JP McNeill>And so as a result, they were generally conditional uses in that situation.

2045
03:17:22.513 --> 03:17:27.957
<v JP McNeill>And so when they wanted to do anything to their campus, expand, they would have to go through the conditional use process.

2046
03:17:28.359 --> 03:17:36.709
<v JP McNeill>And so they approached the city around a campus institutional zone that would allow them to do what they want to do without having to go through conditional use all the time.

2047
03:17:37.224 --> 03:17:39.055
<v JP McNeill>And so that's how it came about.

2048
03:17:39.119 --> 03:17:48.577
<v JP McNeill>And then with the lower, I don't know the exact machinations of, I wasn't involved with the project, or why they decided to make that a no in CI-1.

2049
03:17:49.092 --> 03:17:55.694
<v JP McNeill>But the thinking at the time was I think that the universities were growing and it wasn't— they're not nonconforming.

2050
03:17:55.759 --> 03:17:58.908
<v JP McNeill>Housing isn't nonconforming for the use of the university.

2051
03:17:59.004 --> 03:18:08.067
<v JP McNeill>So the housing that's on the site and that the universities own that could be used for faculty, staff, administration housing, that's not a nonconforming use.

2052
03:18:08.131 --> 03:18:11.506
<v JP McNeill>It becomes nonconforming when they want to sell it off to a private developer.

2053
03:18:11.907 --> 03:18:17.066
<v JP McNeill>And so I don't think that was contemplated at the time because the universities were growing and now we see we're in a different world.

2054
03:18:17.114 --> 03:18:17.227
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2055
03:18:18.030 --> 03:18:23.730
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in terms of a practicality, in terms of what this feels— I went to the University of Portland, right?

2056
03:18:23.860 --> 03:18:29.144
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's a point in which I feel like I'm on campus, and then there's a point in which I feel like I'm off campus.

2057
03:18:29.319 --> 03:18:35.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I think that university owns a whole lot of the housing that is along Willamette Boulevard.

2058
03:18:35.824 --> 03:18:54.179
<v Eric Zimmerman>I suspect that at Warm Pacific, some of those adjacent north-south running streets are probably owned by, in this case, for the definition of normal guy here, just rental homes that look like single-family residences?

2059
03:18:54.307 --> 03:18:56.375
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that what we're talking about in large part?

2060
03:18:56.855 --> 03:18:58.586
<v JP McNeill>We're talking about that largely.

2061
03:18:58.779 --> 03:19:00.046
<v JP McNeill>There's a Warner Pacific.

2062
03:19:00.542 --> 03:19:04.038
<v JP McNeill>They also own what essentially looks like an apartment complex.

2063
03:19:04.085 --> 03:19:04.309
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

2064
03:19:04.486 --> 03:19:06.441
<v JP McNeill>And so there's both of those things.

2065
03:19:07.114 --> 03:19:10.225
<v JP McNeill>Another piece of it is that what we're talking about is a really small percentage of the homes in the city.

2066
03:19:10.290 --> 03:19:25.175
<v JP McNeill>Small universe of properties where there's any sort of housing that doesn't look like a dormitory, which looks like a single-family home or apartment that is zoned CI-1, where it's a very small universe of.

2067
03:19:25.416 --> 03:19:29.106
<v JP McNeill>So it's not the University of Portland.

2068
03:19:29.155 --> 03:19:32.587
<v JP McNeill>I don't even think there's really— there's— they own—.

2069
03:19:32.843 --> 03:19:36.518
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's a large expansion over the last 20 years since I've been there.

2070
03:19:36.613 --> 03:19:36.998
<v Unidentified speaker>It looks quite different.

2071
03:19:37.079 --> 03:19:41.299
<v JP McNeill>The housing that you see across Willamette is not zoned CI-1.

2072
03:19:41.299 --> 03:19:42.620
<v JP McNeill>That's R-5.

2073
03:19:42.620 --> 03:19:44.370
<v JP McNeill>So generally, same with Lewis Clark.

2074
03:19:44.379 --> 03:19:51.239
<v JP McNeill>They might own some housing that's adjacent to their campus, but that's zoned R-10 and R-20.

2075
03:19:51.239 --> 03:19:59.909
<v JP McNeill>This situation where there's housing that could be sold off to the private market, but it's zoned CI-1, is only in a handful of cases.

2076
03:19:59.909 --> 03:20:03.040
<v JP McNeill>At Warner Pacific, the— I'm sorry, I forget what it is now.

2077
03:20:03.040 --> 03:20:08.697
<v JP McNeill>The The former Multnomah Bible College, and I think that's it.

2078
03:20:08.745 --> 03:20:13.093
<v JP McNeill>There might be a third where there's a— so we're talking about a small number of properties.

2079
03:20:15.068 --> 03:20:16.807
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm going to save other comments for the rest.

2080
03:20:16.904 --> 03:20:18.385
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think obviously we should pass this.

2081
03:20:18.674 --> 03:20:19.689
<v Eric Zimmerman>For me, this is an easy one.

2082
03:20:19.881 --> 03:20:20.123
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

2083
03:20:20.445 --> 03:20:21.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2084
03:20:21.556 --> 03:20:22.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2085
03:20:23.424 --> 03:20:24.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

2086
03:20:25.888 --> 03:20:29.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman asked a lot of the questions I had.

2087
03:20:29.148 --> 03:20:38.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm trying to figure out I'm not going to pick up on the basicness of a pumpkin spice latte.

2088
03:20:38.420 --> 03:20:39.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

2089
03:20:42.608 --> 03:20:52.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm trying to understand whether there are unintended consequences for future construction of making this change.

2090
03:20:53.112 --> 03:21:02.110
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I understand that we have institutions that have properties that are no longer serving the purpose that they were, and they need to be able to do something with those properties.

2091
03:21:02.207 --> 03:21:10.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And one solution is to make a change in what's allowed under the zoning, and another solution would be to change the zoning of those individual properties.

2092
03:21:12.480 --> 03:21:20.338
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are getting a proposal to change what's allowed under the zoning, but that means we're not just affecting those properties, we're affecting everything in CI-1.

2093
03:21:21.095 --> 03:21:25.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So what Is there a risk in the future?

2094
03:21:25.657 --> 03:21:35.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we risking pressure on our institutions to develop housing unrelated to campuses that will then push students further away from the campus?

2095
03:21:35.750 --> 03:21:44.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there things that we should know are a concern that we're weighing against the benefit in the proposal before us?

2096
03:21:47.362 --> 03:21:52.040
<v JP McNeill>Well, I was going to say that in terms of unintended consequences, one the only one— the only one.

2097
03:21:52.472 --> 03:22:03.129
<v JP McNeill>Sort of asterisk on this is that the amendment that was filed was filed— we've been working with staff in Councilor Dunphy's office.

2098
03:22:03.531 --> 03:22:28.086
<v JP McNeill>And so we talked to them about maybe that there was a little bit more work that needed to be done around that than just changing that to a Y in the table that says, yes, this is allowed, because there are different development standards for it which are setbacks, height, FAR bonuses, exterior things that are different for, say, a residential zone rather than what the campus is allowed.

2099
03:22:28.152 --> 03:22:42.168
<v JP McNeill>So it could create unintended consequences for if those properties are sold off to what they can do with the types of standards that they'd be subject to under CI-1 rather than if they were just being treated as a residential zone.

2100
03:22:42.585 --> 03:23:04.313
<v JP McNeill>And so our proposal, our friendly amendment to the amendment that we've worked out would be to allow the household and group living as a limited use with the caveat being that they meet the development standards of the RM-1 zone, which is a lower density multi-dwelling zone, so that that way they're subject, they're treated the same as if it was RM-1.

2101
03:23:04.408 --> 03:23:09.736
<v JP McNeill>And so that is essentially the alternative to not rezoning them as RM-1 and RM-2.

2102
03:23:09.799 --> 03:23:10.057
<v JP McNeill>Thank you.

2103
03:23:12.386 --> 03:23:14.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not the amendment that's before us.

2104
03:23:14.957 --> 03:23:16.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The amendment before us is just the simple change.

2105
03:23:16.994 --> 03:23:24.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a reason that it would be difficult for these institutions to rezone those properties?

2106
03:23:25.217 --> 03:23:30.888
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Like, is there a reason that we need this change as opposed to using the tools that we already have to meet the goals at hand?

2107
03:23:31.262 --> 03:23:32.045
<v JP McNeill>That is an option.

2108
03:23:32.158 --> 03:23:36.746
<v JP McNeill>I mean, that was the sort of the original— through the quasi-judicial process, the city has the ability to rezone properties.

2109
03:23:37.593 --> 03:23:49.075
<v JP McNeill>Process, they could go through PP&D and apply through a land use review for a map change and a comprehensive map plan change, or comprehensive plan map change and a zoning map change.

2110
03:23:49.477 --> 03:23:57.474
<v JP McNeill>The issue with that is that then that's a— it's a larger— it's a $40,000 land use review that takes time and money.

2111
03:23:57.585 --> 03:23:57.810
<v JP McNeill>And so—.

2112
03:23:57.810 --> 03:23:58.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's a money aspect.

2113
03:23:59.416 --> 03:23:59.674
<v Claire Adamsick>Yeah.

2114
03:23:59.915 --> 03:24:14.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just— it strikes me that we are making a change here that could create more complication, to your point about what's allowed and what's not, in a document that is supposed to streamline our code and clear up complication.

2115
03:24:17.316 --> 03:24:31.475
<v Steve Novick>I think, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, that's the reason why we are going to continue to work on the other aspects of this change and have that for the council on July 30th.

2116
03:24:32.184 --> 03:24:36.037
<v Steve Novick>So I think what's— what we're discussing now is the general interest.

2117
03:24:36.135 --> 03:24:59.904
<v Steve Novick>There seems to be interest in making that change, and then we would work with the council offices staff to work out some of those details, with the hope that— or the expectation that we would not be creating some additional complication, but that understanding that this is— we are taking a zone that was intended for a different purpose and trying to you know, figure out how to make it have this purpose.

2118
03:25:00.322 --> 03:25:09.225
<v Steve Novick>Um, but I, I would return to what JP said about the limited instances, and I, you know, limited instances of this zone.

2119
03:25:10.063 --> 03:25:19.967
<v Steve Novick>I think the fact that there are limited instances of this zone makes this, um, this solution, I think, an acceptable solution.

2120
03:25:21.032 --> 03:25:35.128
<v Steve Novick>But there is the option of doing zone changes too, and the property owners can ask for a zone change, or we could, as a, you know, we could look at future map changes and whether they would be appropriate or not through some other project.

2121
03:25:35.272 --> 03:25:38.628
<v Steve Novick>But that's not something we can accomplish in the context of the recap project.

2122
03:25:39.060 --> 03:25:39.591
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Understood.

2123
03:25:39.847 --> 03:25:57.537
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We just, um, regularly wring our hands at the fact that we make small changes to accommodate immediate needs without looking at the broader effects, and it seems to me that we are making a change to accommodate an immediate need without thinking about what the broader, most effective way to achieve the goal would be.

2124
03:26:00.338 --> 03:26:03.438
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I haven't heard anything dissuade me from feeling that way.

2125
03:26:04.379 --> 03:26:05.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks, Council President.

2126
03:26:05.513 --> 03:26:06.552
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2127
03:26:07.945 --> 03:26:13.795
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue to discuss Dunphy 1, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

2128
03:26:14.951 --> 03:26:21.082
<v Keelan McClymont>Moved by Dunphy, seconded by Smith, Noting Koyama Lane and Murillo are absent.

2129
03:26:21.227 --> 03:26:21.532
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

2130
03:26:23.962 --> 03:26:30.523
<v Steve Novick>First of all, I'd like to thank Councilor Zimmerman for letting me know that, that the history of pumpkin spice latte is a basic drink.

2131
03:26:30.604 --> 03:26:32.827
<v Steve Novick>Apparently it's a rich literature on it I've discovered in the past few minutes.

2132
03:26:33.248 --> 03:26:33.425
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2133
03:26:34.797 --> 03:26:35.135
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2134
03:26:35.441 --> 03:26:35.619
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2135
03:26:36.022 --> 03:26:36.231
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2136
03:26:38.907 --> 03:26:38.957
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2137
03:26:40.956 --> 03:26:41.343
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2138
03:26:41.729 --> 03:26:41.891
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2139
03:26:46.566 --> 03:26:46.745
<v Claire Adamsick>Aye.

2140
03:26:47.941 --> 03:26:47.990
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2141
03:26:49.559 --> 03:26:49.656
<v Raymond C. Lee>Aye.

2142
03:26:51.111 --> 03:26:51.352
<v Olivia Clark>No.

2143
03:26:53.989 --> 03:26:54.038
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2144
03:26:54.551 --> 03:26:54.600
<v Micah Goldstein>Aye.

2145
03:26:55.451 --> 03:27:01.944
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, the amendment is approved with a vote of 9 ayes, 1 no, and 2 absent.

2146
03:27:02.587 --> 03:27:03.054
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

2147
03:27:03.150 --> 03:27:08.325
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are through our amendments, and now to discussion of the underlying now amended non-emergency ordinance.

2148
03:27:08.388 --> 03:27:08.854
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

2149
03:27:09.639 --> 03:27:10.494
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

2150
03:27:11.591 --> 03:27:14.718
<v Eric Zimmerman>I would encourage the staff to stay up as we go through discussion.

2151
03:27:17.042 --> 03:27:28.251
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, you know, in reviewing all of the documents and the presentation that went forward, I think what I've gathered is that there are 56 items that are being changed in this.

2152
03:27:29.621 --> 03:27:34.315
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in the slideshow that went forward to the committee, it looks like 12 of those items were discussed.

2153
03:27:34.427 --> 03:27:34.541
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

2154
03:27:35.311 --> 03:27:48.799
<v Eric Zimmerman>And when I go into the exhibit, while it's all there, I can't particularly say it's clear or that it comes off the page of what are the 56.

2155
03:27:49.314 --> 03:27:58.281
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and I think we've— I have, I have some concern here, um, for a few reasons.

2156
03:27:59.369 --> 03:28:09.433
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm, I'm very much I'm much in favor of streamlining our code to be more practical and applicable and user-friendly.

2157
03:28:11.530 --> 03:28:16.826
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the mindset that is being used to develop these recap projects is what I have some concern around.

2158
03:28:16.875 --> 03:28:21.593
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm just going to use the— I'm just going to use one of them that was in the presentation.

2159
03:28:21.643 --> 03:28:24.853
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's like about parking in the residential setback.

2160
03:28:25.095 --> 03:28:25.144
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

2161
03:28:27.379 --> 03:28:28.716
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm like, okay, what does that mean?

2162
03:28:31.681 --> 03:28:44.111
<v Eric Zimmerman>It means that we have a law on the books that says you can't park on your own driveway, and we're changing that this time, but you can't park on your own driveway, which in practical sense, everybody would go, well, that's bonkers.

2163
03:28:45.341 --> 03:28:49.191
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we had something, at least based on the way the materials are written, and we had something there.

2164
03:28:50.472 --> 03:28:56.278
<v Eric Zimmerman>The reason I bring it up is I was hoping to see more in these recaps that just say, yeah, we shouldn't have that law anymore.

2165
03:28:56.824 --> 03:29:13.907
<v Eric Zimmerman>And instead, we kind of get the, can we convolute ourselves or shoehorn ourselves into a solution through code as that the City of Portland is doing this greatness by allowing the residents of Portland to do these things versus maybe we just don't weigh in on them.

2166
03:29:14.021 --> 03:29:16.300
<v Eric Zimmerman>Maybe we shouldn't have code that weighs in on certain stuff.

2167
03:29:16.429 --> 03:29:33.163
<v Eric Zimmerman>So given that, and given that the exhibit even in itself does not particularly line out what exactly is changing, you've got to really read every paragraph with an English teacher's specificity to understand what is changing.

2168
03:29:34.221 --> 03:29:42.869
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, with 56 changes coming and 12 being highlighted, uh, I feel like this is a bit of a vote on faith.

2169
03:29:44.184 --> 03:29:53.706
<v Eric Zimmerman>About what the changes are, because we have not provided, or at least I haven't seen one, provided a just a bullet-pointed list of this, this, this, this of the 56 items.

2170
03:29:56.492 --> 03:30:02.305
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and, and I, I want to have faith in this project.

2171
03:30:03.130 --> 03:30:08.468
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I want to have faith that we're working from a perspective that is getting the City of Portland out of the way of Portlanders.

2172
03:30:09.387 --> 03:30:10.540
<v Eric Zimmerman>When it comes to permitting.

2173
03:30:12.216 --> 03:30:13.378
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in some of that, I think we're doing it.

2174
03:30:13.425 --> 03:30:14.926
<v Eric Zimmerman>In others, I feel like we're missing the mark.

2175
03:30:15.072 --> 03:30:25.174
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm having a tough time without being an expert on all of these items themselves trying to understand the impact of all the 56 items that you've brought forward.

2176
03:30:27.719 --> 03:30:33.967
<v Eric Zimmerman>There are no specific questions there, but I guess I'm looking for your reaction or what your goal is in these types of recap projects.

2177
03:30:34.049 --> 03:30:46.073
<v Eric Zimmerman>What do aim to achieve in them, and how do you best want to convey what's being achieved and change to us, to the public, etc.?

2178
03:30:47.406 --> 03:30:49.558
<v Steve Novick>Thank you for the question, Councilor Zimmerman.

2179
03:30:49.896 --> 03:31:01.244
<v Steve Novick>Um, first, I'll just share that there is a table at the beginning of the report that describes all of the amendments, and it tries to do so in thank you.

2180
03:31:01.389 --> 03:31:05.343
<v Steve Novick>Brief way, but paint an overarching picture of what the issue is.

2181
03:31:06.104 --> 03:31:24.137
<v Steve Novick>And they are also thematically bundled so that there's an understanding of, you know, this package, for example, is dealing with some minor, relatively minor tweaks to parking-related provisions, exterior activities, and so on and so forth.

2182
03:31:24.217 --> 03:31:30.657
<v Steve Novick>So I think that is— perhaps we could do a better job of that storytelling, but that is what this is attempting to do.

2183
03:31:30.737 --> 03:31:43.791
<v Steve Novick>As far as the, the impact of each of these, I think what we have— what we typically say about RECAP is that, you know, each of these— this is meant to be minor code cleanup, not major policy changes.

2184
03:31:44.129 --> 03:31:47.983
<v Steve Novick>Major policy changes are reserved for other projects.

2185
03:31:48.255 --> 03:31:53.345
<v Steve Novick>So for example, CAP could be one of those major, more major policy changes.

2186
03:31:53.522 --> 03:32:00.945
<v Steve Novick>When we undertake Code projects that are, you know, for example, the Central City Code Amendment Project that we're going to be bringing to you soon.

2187
03:32:01.475 --> 03:32:06.764
<v Steve Novick>Those are, those are meant to be more, more major changes that are hopefully more impactful.

2188
03:32:07.085 --> 03:32:17.762
<v Steve Novick>The idea about with these is that each individual change is perhaps not super impactful in and of itself, but it just makes for greater legibility with the code, easier to implement.

2189
03:32:17.825 --> 03:32:20.486
<v Steve Novick>It helps the— our permitting bureau.

2190
03:32:20.534 --> 03:32:20.647
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2191
03:32:21.679 --> 03:32:28.775
<v Steve Novick>You know, review projects and permits, and it helps the public better understand the regulations.

2192
03:32:29.243 --> 03:32:29.905
<v Steve Novick>That's the goal.

2193
03:32:30.760 --> 03:32:37.225
<v Steve Novick>So again, each of these is not particularly monumental in and of itself, but they're meant to just make the code a little bit clearer.

2194
03:32:37.930 --> 03:32:46.417
<v JP McNeill>Just to tack on to that, about the larger goal, I think we've moved away a little bit from the goal of RECAP when it's the original thank you.

2195
03:32:46.466 --> 03:32:57.647
<v JP McNeill>The thought was that these are minor technical things that either folks out in the community or at PP&D realize, oh, we're stumbling over this minor thing, we need to fix it.

2196
03:32:57.695 --> 03:33:03.327
<v JP McNeill>And as you, I'm sure, all know, the legislative process to change the zoning code takes a lot of time and effort.

2197
03:33:03.407 --> 03:33:08.109
<v JP McNeill>And so the idea is to package these little things together that we can move through quickly.

2198
03:33:08.605 --> 03:33:12.247
<v JP McNeill>And historically, when things got a little bit— when something got a little bit I see.

2199
03:33:12.391 --> 03:33:16.323
<v JP McNeill>And drew some attention, we would jettison it because that was slowing down the project.

2200
03:33:16.644 --> 03:33:25.725
<v JP McNeill>We've moved away from that to some degree because often this becomes sort of the Christmas tree of projects where everyone has their ornament that they want to put on it.

2201
03:33:25.789 --> 03:33:28.034
<v JP McNeill>And so then that delays the project more.

2202
03:33:28.131 --> 03:33:34.581
<v JP McNeill>So our goal, we've moved a little bit away from that where recap now looks a little bit in between of what the technical thing is.

2203
03:33:35.094 --> 03:33:41.078
<v JP McNeill>But that's what our goal is with this, is to try to do it within a year with just the minor things that are tripping folks up.

2204
03:33:42.460 --> 03:33:46.773
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really appreciate those explanations.

2205
03:33:46.903 --> 03:33:58.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that that is what I was hoping to kind of— I want people and ours, everybody's expectations to be, you know, founded in what's achievable and what's appropriate for each thing.

2206
03:33:58.878 --> 03:34:02.808
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm glad that you both were able to share that in terms of, are we doing minor?

2207
03:34:02.888 --> 03:34:03.789
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are we doing technical?

2208
03:34:03.853 --> 03:34:05.317
<v Eric Zimmerman>What is— what are we trying to get at?

2209
03:34:05.382 --> 03:34:06.621
<v Eric Zimmerman>And how do we— how do we do that impactfully?

2210
03:34:06.670 --> 03:34:06.799
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2211
03:34:08.284 --> 03:34:13.885
<v Eric Zimmerman>The— so I think that, you know, the table, Patricia, that you showed is helpful.

2212
03:34:13.949 --> 03:34:17.525
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's the kind of thing that I want to always like highlight that first, right?

2213
03:34:17.575 --> 03:34:31.804
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you for that because I think sometimes in the planning world and trying to meet the different goals, the initiatives that you're making adjustments to get lost in the verbiage to, I think, probably conform with land use laws and all that.

2214
03:34:31.869 --> 03:34:32.157
<v Eric Zimmerman>But there's—.

2215
03:34:32.271 --> 03:34:32.318
<v Micah Goldstein>Yeah.

2216
03:34:32.851 --> 03:34:34.744
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's the normal person speak, if you will.

2217
03:34:35.002 --> 03:34:38.996
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's where I think you guys have done a really good thing in this.

2218
03:34:39.546 --> 03:34:41.292
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to highlight that.

2219
03:34:41.422 --> 03:34:47.157
<v Eric Zimmerman>So just appreciation to it because I look forward to whatever recap 12, 13, and 14 look like.

2220
03:34:47.933 --> 03:34:49.031
<v Eric Zimmerman>And you have my support in that.

2221
03:34:50.938 --> 03:34:53.932
<v Eric Zimmerman>So this is always 56 items, 12 get highlighted.

2222
03:34:53.979 --> 03:34:55.226
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's always like dicey.

2223
03:34:55.452 --> 03:34:56.019
<v Eric Zimmerman>Where do we go?

2224
03:34:56.100 --> 03:34:56.974
<v Eric Zimmerman>What's the right time?

2225
03:34:57.055 --> 03:34:57.751
<v Eric Zimmerman>Where's the right place to push?

2226
03:34:57.799 --> 03:34:57.896
<v Jeff Fish>Thank you.

2227
03:34:58.211 --> 03:35:06.737
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks both for your work, your team's work, I'm sure, others in the Planning Commission, but you certainly will have my support here.

2228
03:35:06.818 --> 03:35:07.798
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks a lot for that.

2229
03:35:08.407 --> 03:35:15.568
<v JP McNeill>I just have to say, as having done the second recap now, trying to present— this is one of the hardest projects to try to present.

2230
03:35:15.634 --> 03:35:22.665
<v JP McNeill>Like, neighborhood groups want to hear about it, and if you go out there and list off the 56 changes, people's eyes glaze over immediately.

2231
03:35:23.825 --> 03:35:30.295
<v JP McNeill>The balance is trying to find the ones that maybe will keep folks' attention the most when presenting it and have the biggest impacts.

2232
03:35:31.245 --> 03:35:31.989
<v Eric Zimmerman>I love that point.

2233
03:35:32.054 --> 03:35:39.243
<v Eric Zimmerman>And with 12 people who spend a lot of time at neighborhood associations for all sorts of reasons, I think we all feel that.

2234
03:35:40.009 --> 03:35:41.119
<v Eric Zimmerman>Sometimes we're there with you.

2235
03:35:41.771 --> 03:36:19.662
<v Eric Zimmerman>The last point I'll make is, you know, whatever we can do to, I guess, instill the the mindset of opening opportunity instead of squelching opportunity or questioning why something is restricted in our community, is that really a founded reason to have something restricted, is one of those old lessons that I have from the first time I made the transition from county land use, which is all about protecting certain types of open, open, green space, you know, farm, forest, et cetera.

2236
03:36:19.709 --> 03:36:21.507
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's about protecting it versus the city.

2237
03:36:21.587 --> 03:36:27.816
<v Eric Zimmerman>Our job is to build, baby, build so that we can continue to protect those green and environmental areas.

2238
03:36:27.914 --> 03:36:39.906
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so this is always a struggle, and I hope that the city's always on the forefront of we are in the business of allowable so long as it's safe, neighborly, seismic, fire, et cetera.

2239
03:36:39.969 --> 03:36:40.949
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks a lot for your work.

2240
03:36:41.013 --> 03:36:48.388
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know it's not an easy task, particularly when you thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2241
03:36:48.792 --> 03:36:49.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2242
03:36:51.059 --> 03:36:51.998
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

2243
03:36:52.909 --> 03:36:55.049
<v Mitch Green>I really want to thank you both for presenting this.

2244
03:36:56.450 --> 03:37:07.181
<v Mitch Green>I'm glad you said the very thing at the end saying, you know, this is a really difficult thing to present because I was kind of thinking through how impossible that would be to try to do that job myself.

2245
03:37:08.645 --> 03:37:18.682
<v Mitch Green>I wanted to pick up a little bit on the comments that were made about the on Councilor Zimmerman's questions, I think we struggled with some of that same stuff in the committee because it's— there's 50-some-odd pieces.

2246
03:37:18.730 --> 03:37:19.728
<v Mitch Green>We're highlighting 11.

2247
03:37:21.371 --> 03:37:23.272
<v Mitch Green>There's not enough time to go line by line with them.

2248
03:37:23.465 --> 03:37:29.486
<v Mitch Green>I think for me, I was deferring a lot to the Planning Commission who came and said, hey, we support this.

2249
03:37:29.761 --> 03:37:31.387
<v Mitch Green>This is something that we vetted and looked at.

2250
03:37:31.450 --> 03:37:34.606
<v Mitch Green>And so that also takes a certain amount of leap of faith.

2251
03:37:34.671 --> 03:37:44.442
<v Mitch Green>But I think the chair and I have kind of talked about for that committee thinking Like, how do we want the Housing and Permitting Committee to function vis-à-vis the Planning Commission?

2252
03:37:44.539 --> 03:37:46.061
<v Mitch Green>And we wanted it to not be a roadblock.

2253
03:37:46.943 --> 03:37:52.028
<v Mitch Green>And so I kind of, in that spirit, we're thinking like, how do we make that a smooth handoff?

2254
03:37:52.092 --> 03:37:53.855
<v Mitch Green>And then we can have these dialogue moments.

2255
03:37:55.202 --> 03:37:56.677
<v Mitch Green>But I think it's a fair question to ask.

2256
03:37:58.170 --> 03:38:03.125
<v Mitch Green>I think those are the 2 different public venues where we have to have those conversations and those deep dives.

2257
03:38:03.477 --> 03:38:08.462
<v Mitch Green>There's probably always going to be some corner piece of it though that's like not going to get as much airtime, and that's okay.

2258
03:38:09.471 --> 03:38:13.478
<v Mitch Green>Uh, we can continue to think about how to be, um, uh, more comprehensive on that.

2259
03:38:13.638 --> 03:38:16.411
<v Mitch Green>Um, I, I support the underlying.

2260
03:38:16.796 --> 03:38:18.510
<v Mitch Green>I support the amended underlying.

2261
03:38:18.926 --> 03:38:20.577
<v Mitch Green>Um, I really appreciate that.

2262
03:38:21.171 --> 03:38:26.570
<v Mitch Green>I, I want to close the loop a little bit on something that did come up in committee but didn't kind of move forward.

2263
03:38:26.619 --> 03:38:38.871
<v Mitch Green>I had raised a bunch of questions around the, um, there were zoning, uh, Parcels, some kind of— I forget exactly what the classifications are, but some zoning considerations for shelter sites.

2264
03:38:39.690 --> 03:38:58.881
<v Mitch Green>And I was concerned about the proposal in this recap project to kind of increase the capacity by right, more or less, rather than go through conditional land use appeals or conditional land use approval process, in particular for the kind of North Portland Uh, site.

2265
03:38:59.427 --> 03:39:06.209
<v Mitch Green>Um, I, I think that I got— I think I realized it'd be a little bit difficult and kludgy to try to amend that at this time.

2266
03:39:06.289 --> 03:39:10.628
<v Mitch Green>It was possible, but, um, I backed off of that a little bit.

2267
03:39:10.691 --> 03:39:24.968
<v Mitch Green>So, um, my concerns with Urban Alchemy, my concerns with our sheltering system felt like more appropriately to be dealt with in an oversight capacity or, or policy space, not through the recap I just wanted to explain that's why I sort of backed off that piece.

2268
03:39:26.627 --> 03:39:28.824
<v Mitch Green>And so close the loop on that.

2269
03:39:29.389 --> 03:39:32.540
<v Mitch Green>We did have a good conversation about that yesterday to start that conversation, by the way.

2270
03:39:33.944 --> 03:39:39.805
<v Mitch Green>So we're not done talking about that, but I'm very much supporting RECAP at this point.

2271
03:39:39.885 --> 03:39:41.076
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much for the work you do.

2272
03:39:41.334 --> 03:39:49.415
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, it takes a lot of time to change our zoning and code books, and we can't really afford to waste that time.

2273
03:39:49.480 --> 03:39:49.529
<v Greg Fox>Yeah.

2274
03:39:49.891 --> 03:39:52.990
<v Mitch Green>In the city of Portland right now, because we don't have an endless pot of subsidy.

2275
03:39:53.890 --> 03:39:57.085
<v Mitch Green>So you can do things through subsidy, or you can do things by changing your zoning code.

2276
03:39:57.343 --> 03:39:59.896
<v Mitch Green>And let's, let's move forward on this.

2277
03:39:59.992 --> 03:40:00.699
<v Mitch Green>So thank you so much.

2278
03:40:01.693 --> 03:40:02.465
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

2279
03:40:03.122 --> 03:40:05.483
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

2280
03:40:06.013 --> 03:40:10.011
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, we are going to continue this to a time and date certain.

2281
03:40:10.685 --> 03:40:11.247
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that correct?

2282
03:40:11.745 --> 03:40:16.248
<v Jamie Dunphy>Still moving this forward to a time and date certain of Thursday, July 30th at thank you.

2283
03:40:17.251 --> 03:40:20.613
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please—.

2284
03:40:21.114 --> 03:40:22.280
<v Robert Taylor>The record is closed.

2285
03:40:22.408 --> 03:40:23.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the record is closed.

2286
03:40:23.718 --> 03:40:24.397
<v Elise Rosenberg>Is that right, or—.

2287
03:40:26.219 --> 03:40:26.558
<v JP McNeill>Yes.

2288
03:40:27.186 --> 03:40:29.461
<v Keelan McClymont>Both written and verbal?

2289
03:40:30.477 --> 03:40:30.606
<v Ben Henson>Yes.

2290
03:40:31.608 --> 03:40:33.063
<v Robert Taylor>Say it again.

2291
03:40:33.256 --> 03:40:33.450
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry.

2292
03:40:33.629 --> 03:40:40.727
<v Robert Taylor>Written and oral record is closed, and we're moving to a time and date certain during which council will vote on amended findings and recommendations.

2293
03:40:40.979 --> 03:40:46.438
<v Robert Taylor>And potentially any revisions to the amendments council already voted on to reflect technical changes.

2294
03:40:46.710 --> 03:40:47.352
<v Robert Taylor>Okay, thank you.

2295
03:40:47.593 --> 03:40:48.524
<v Jamie Dunphy>Wonderful, thank you very much.

2296
03:40:49.745 --> 03:40:52.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please move to the consent agenda?

2297
03:40:53.293 --> 03:40:56.906
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, no items have been pulled from the consent agenda.

2298
03:40:56.969 --> 03:40:57.997
<v Keelan McClymont>We have 2 items.

2299
03:40:59.298 --> 03:41:07.148
<v Keelan McClymont>I will do the roll call vote for the consent agenda, noting Koyama Lane and Murillo are absent.

2300
03:41:07.889 --> 03:41:08.165
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

2301
03:41:08.637 --> 03:41:08.685
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2302
03:41:09.629 --> 03:41:09.953
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2303
03:41:10.425 --> 03:41:10.475
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2304
03:41:11.093 --> 03:41:11.288
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2305
03:41:12.458 --> 03:41:12.620
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2306
03:41:13.206 --> 03:41:13.579
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2307
03:41:14.149 --> 03:41:14.326
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2308
03:41:14.809 --> 03:41:15.197
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2309
03:41:17.968 --> 03:41:18.772
<v Unidentified speaker>Whoops, there you go.

2310
03:41:18.998 --> 03:41:19.047
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2311
03:41:19.965 --> 03:41:20.271
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2312
03:41:20.771 --> 03:41:20.818
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2313
03:41:21.495 --> 03:41:21.881
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

2314
03:41:22.139 --> 03:41:22.220
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2315
03:41:22.930 --> 03:41:23.139
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

2316
03:41:23.512 --> 03:41:23.691
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2317
03:41:24.256 --> 03:41:24.549
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2318
03:41:24.808 --> 03:41:24.855
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

2319
03:41:25.471 --> 03:41:25.843
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2320
03:41:26.507 --> 03:41:26.557
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2321
03:41:27.415 --> 03:41:31.284
<v Keelan McClymont>The consent agenda is approved with a vote of 10 ayes and 2 absent.

2322
03:41:32.165 --> 03:41:34.801
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, and can we please Please move to item number 8.

2323
03:41:35.833 --> 03:41:47.469
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, item 8, document 2026-204, establish 2026 sale price cap for the Homebuyer Opportunity Limited Tax Exemption Program.

2324
03:41:47.872 --> 03:41:51.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll just preview for folks in the room, we will not be able to get to item 9 today.

2325
03:41:52.050 --> 03:41:56.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will come back to the SDC charges item at a future date.

2326
03:41:56.503 --> 03:42:02.684
<v Jamie Dunphy>Claire Adamsick with Council Operations is here for a A committee staff summary report on the HOLTY program.

2327
03:42:03.422 --> 03:42:03.677
<v Jamie Dunphy>Take it away.

2328
03:42:03.998 --> 03:42:05.457
<v Claire Adamsick>Thank you, Council President and councilors.

2329
03:42:05.521 --> 03:42:09.334
<v Claire Adamsick>Again, for the record, Claire Adamsick, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Housing and Permitting Committee.

2330
03:42:10.167 --> 03:42:20.389
<v Claire Adamsick>The resolution before you, document number 2026-204, was heard in the Housing Committee— Housing and Permitting Committee on June 16th, where it was referred to full council with the recommendation to be adopted.

2331
03:42:20.967 --> 03:42:35.656
<v Claire Adamsick>The resolution establishes an annual sale price cap for residential units utilizing the Homebuyer Opportunity Limited Tax Exemption, or HOLTY, program at $455,000 for the 2026 calendar year, effective January 1st, 2026.

2332
03:42:36.361 --> 03:42:44.207
<v Claire Adamsick>The full impact statement on this item includes information on economic and real estate development impacts and analysis, and community impacts and community involvement.

2333
03:42:44.880 --> 03:42:50.623
<v Claire Adamsick>One person provided testimony at the committee meeting on June 16th, and no one submitted written testimony prior to committee action.

2334
03:42:51.201 --> 03:43:02.523
<v Claire Adamsick>The general themes of this testimony Included recognizing that the 10-year exemption clock starts once a unit becomes available, so a new homeowner may benefit from the program for fewer than 10 years depending on when they purchase the home.

2335
03:43:03.566 --> 03:43:12.643
<v Claire Adamsick>And also the opportunity to increase transparency for homebuyers of properties utilizing this program, that their property taxes will increase once the exemption period has ended.

2336
03:43:13.028 --> 03:43:14.454
<v Claire Adamsick>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

2337
03:43:14.536 --> 03:43:14.855
<v Claire Adamsick>Thank you.

2338
03:43:15.096 --> 03:43:15.915
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2339
03:43:16.540 --> 03:43:18.864
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Avalos, this came out of your committee.

2340
03:43:21.288 --> 03:43:22.251
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, thank you.

2341
03:43:23.358 --> 03:43:26.263
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so the resolution came before the committee on June 16th.

2342
03:43:26.326 --> 03:43:31.781
<v Unidentified speaker>As was said, the committee received a presentation from the Housing Bureau on the Holte price cap.

2343
03:43:31.879 --> 03:43:40.238
<v Unidentified speaker>The resolution maintains the maximum sale price for eligible homes at $455,000 for calendar year 2026 as required under state law.

2344
03:43:40.623 --> 03:43:46.415
<v Unidentified speaker>There were no amendments, no members of the public testified on the item, and the committee voted unanimously 5-0 to recommend adoption.

2345
03:43:46.513 --> 03:43:46.656
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2346
03:43:48.935 --> 03:43:49.647
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2347
03:43:51.118 --> 03:43:52.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, are there— is there anyone signed up for testimony?

2348
03:43:57.239 --> 03:43:58.403
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up for this item.

2349
03:43:58.500 --> 03:44:06.557
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, so we are now into both technical or clarifying questions but also discussion of this item.

2350
03:44:10.247 --> 03:44:11.724
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

2351
03:44:11.822 --> 03:44:12.149
<v Douglas McLeod>Thanks.

2352
03:44:12.379 --> 03:44:23.370
<v Sameer Kanal>I had I had 3 questions, and I'm not 100% sure if anyone from PHB can answer them or if we'll just hear back, but I'll just start asking them and you can let me know, Mr. Lee.

2353
03:44:24.445 --> 03:44:39.156
<v Sameer Kanal>One is just, can you— I would like a little more information on how PHB views limitations on family-sized or larger ownership units in the current situation, what we might expect next year if there is any sort of preplanning For that.

2354
03:44:39.221 --> 03:44:41.873
<v Sameer Kanal>I know our deviation from the state is a question.

2355
03:44:42.390 --> 03:44:57.123
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the third thing is my understanding, and I'd love a confirmation— this isn't my, um, committee expertise, so I'm curious— is that the, the program broadly provides a 10-year property tax exemption that starts, um, from the completion of construction.

2356
03:44:58.269 --> 03:45:03.993
<v Sameer Kanal>And that means that developers can enjoy the exemption while the property is unsold and vacant.

2357
03:45:04.074 --> 03:45:04.154
<v Ben Henson>Yes.

2358
03:45:05.602 --> 03:45:19.532
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and wanted to just understand if that was a topic of conversation in committee about changing that, um, to the degree to which we can change that to ensure that the actual resident can enjoy it once it is for 10 years once they are moved in.

2359
03:45:24.596 --> 03:45:25.147
<v Robert Taylor>Hello, Councilor.

2360
03:45:25.325 --> 03:45:26.490
<v Dori Hellyer>My name is Dori Hellyer.

2361
03:45:26.943 --> 03:45:32.806
<v Dori Hellyer>I manage the development incentives programs including the HOLTY program with Uh, the Portland Housing Bureau.

2362
03:45:33.512 --> 03:45:43.831
<v Dori Hellyer>Um, in— to the latter question, it is a 10-year tax exemption that starts, um, the first tax year following our approval.

2363
03:45:44.505 --> 03:45:49.128
<v Dori Hellyer>So it doesn't start based on when the building is completed.

2364
03:45:49.737 --> 03:45:59.977
<v Dori Hellyer>So it does mean that if a developer has a longer timeline for development, that there are times that the full 10 years are not able to benefit the home buyer.

2365
03:46:00.412 --> 03:46:04.154
<v Dori Hellyer>So it is a technicality as to how it is within the state statute.

2366
03:46:04.747 --> 03:46:19.634
<v Dori Hellyer>We are able to extend the availability of the timeline for construction in that the state also limits that to 2 years, but currently the way the statute is written, we aren't able to start the exemption later.

2367
03:46:20.405 --> 03:46:42.077
<v Dori Hellyer>One reason why it's been complicated to contemplate changing that Is because it's also helpful to have the tax exemption in place at the time that the home buyer is purchasing the home so that they're able to, one, be able to use that to help qualify for their mortgage loan, and that otherwise they could have the first year without the exemption.

2368
03:46:42.674 --> 03:46:54.530
<v Dori Hellyer>So we're kind of working from either end of either not potentially having it available when they first purchase the home, or unfortunately meaning they may not have a full 10 years and it may be limited to 8 or 9 years.

2369
03:46:54.647 --> 03:46:54.715
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

2370
03:46:56.797 --> 03:47:02.465
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I, I would be interested in understanding how we can avoid subsidizing vacancy.

2371
03:47:03.684 --> 03:47:19.565
<v Sameer Kanal>That's, that's my concern here, is, is when we're— when a property is built and there are empty units, that— not talking— obviously I have a separate conversation about putting a fee on long-term vacancy, but just anything to not make it easier to leave it vacant, um, and just get it to move.

2372
03:47:19.902 --> 03:47:23.471
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and so I, I I'm— that's sort of my interest in asking this question.

2373
03:47:23.536 --> 03:47:33.185
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd be curious about what we can pursue potentially through the legislative agenda process to make it where this is benefiting the actual purchaser.

2374
03:47:35.314 --> 03:47:39.127
<v Sameer Kanal>And I have no problem with the idea of it remaining that way during the construction process.

2375
03:47:39.175 --> 03:47:44.595
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not, you know, that's fine the way it is, but that interim gap in the middle there.

2376
03:47:45.030 --> 03:47:46.546
<v Sameer Kanal>So I might follow up with staff about that.

2377
03:47:46.612 --> 03:47:46.712
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

2378
03:47:48.157 --> 03:47:52.102
<v Sameer Kanal>What that would take and then follow up on the OGR side as well.

2379
03:47:52.406 --> 03:47:52.583
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

2380
03:47:53.288 --> 03:48:00.181
<v Jamie Dunphy>And very quickly, colleagues, I just learned that there are 4 people signed up to testify and are online for the next item.

2381
03:48:00.293 --> 03:48:06.867
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm going to ask us that we can stick a little bit long and hear the testimony, and then we will continue the item beyond that.

2382
03:48:06.931 --> 03:48:09.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>So if you are online, please don't log off yet.

2383
03:48:10.297 --> 03:48:11.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

2384
03:48:11.500 --> 03:48:15.397
<v Sameer Kanal>Just real quick, Am I going to get a follow-up on the other 2 questions?

2385
03:48:15.834 --> 03:48:17.532
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

2386
03:48:17.693 --> 03:48:17.986
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect.

2387
03:48:18.971 --> 03:48:19.311
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2388
03:48:19.408 --> 03:48:23.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, is there any further discussion of this item?

2389
03:48:26.281 --> 03:48:32.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one in the queue, Keelan, can we please call the roll on item 8?

2390
03:48:37.970 --> 03:48:42.935
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, item 8, Resolution Noting that Koyama Lane and Morillo are absent.

2391
03:48:43.016 --> 03:48:43.353
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

2392
03:48:44.621 --> 03:48:44.782
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2393
03:48:45.361 --> 03:48:45.602
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2394
03:48:46.066 --> 03:48:46.115
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2395
03:48:46.645 --> 03:48:46.853
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2396
03:48:47.673 --> 03:48:47.850
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2397
03:48:48.235 --> 03:48:48.620
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2398
03:48:48.813 --> 03:48:48.974
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2399
03:48:49.295 --> 03:48:49.584
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2400
03:48:50.563 --> 03:48:50.611
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2401
03:48:51.156 --> 03:48:51.430
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2402
03:48:51.847 --> 03:48:51.896
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2403
03:48:52.569 --> 03:48:52.650
<v Micah Goldstein>Hill?

2404
03:48:53.774 --> 03:48:53.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2405
03:48:54.496 --> 03:48:54.881
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

2406
03:48:55.299 --> 03:48:55.347
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2407
03:48:56.039 --> 03:48:56.246
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2408
03:48:56.745 --> 03:48:56.792
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

2409
03:48:57.403 --> 03:48:57.691
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2410
03:48:58.110 --> 03:48:58.157
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2411
03:48:58.688 --> 03:49:02.219
<v Keelan McClymont>Resolution is adopted with a vote of 10 ayes and 2 absent.

2412
03:49:02.444 --> 03:49:03.681
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, colleagues.

2413
03:49:03.745 --> 03:49:05.318
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 9, Keelan?

2414
03:49:06.545 --> 03:49:21.235
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 9, document 2026-205, amend partial and full exemptions of system development charges for affordable housing developments code to temporarily remove income requirements for homeownership units.

2415
03:49:21.673 --> 03:49:25.359
<v Keelan McClymont>Amend code section 30.01.095.

2416
03:49:25.877 --> 03:49:27.995
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

2417
03:49:28.059 --> 03:49:30.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>Claire Adamsick, Council Operations, is here for a committee staff summary report.

2418
03:49:31.661 --> 03:49:32.385
<v Jamie Dunphy>Take it away, Claire.

2419
03:49:32.772 --> 03:49:33.029
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2420
03:49:33.237 --> 03:49:39.467
<v Claire Adamsick>Very quickly here, Council President, councilors, for the record again, Claire Adamczyk, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Housing and Permitting Committee.

2421
03:49:40.149 --> 03:49:49.387
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance before you, document number 2026-205, was heard in the Housing and Permitting Committee on June 16th, where it was referred to full council with recommendation to pass.

2422
03:49:50.989 --> 03:50:18.361
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance amends City Code Chapter 30.01.095 as shown in Exhibit A of the ordinance The code amendments temporarily temporarily remove for applicants utilizing the affordable housing system development charge, SDC exemption program, the income restriction for the initial homebuyer, provided that the homeownership unit was issued a building permit before January first, 2026, and the home is sold before September thirtieth, 2028.

2423
03:50:18.924 --> 03:50:22.055
<v Claire Adamsick>The amended code clarifies that the exception to the income restriction does not.

2424
03:50:22.216 --> 03:50:36.029
<v Claire Adamsick>Apply to applicants receiving exemptions through other specified programs, including the HOLTI program, which you just heard about, the, the local transportation infrastructure charge, or an exemption of tree preservation mitigation payments for affordable housing developments.

2425
03:50:36.896 --> 03:50:47.725
<v Claire Adamsick>The code also clarifies the city may collect penalties and processing fees in the event that an applicant sells to a qualified homebuyer who subsequently fails to meet a requirement of the affordable housing SDC exemption program.

2426
03:50:48.704 --> 03:50:56.171
<v Claire Adamsick>The full impact statement on this item includes information on economic and real estate development impacts and analysis, as well as community impacts and community involvement.

2427
03:50:56.813 --> 03:51:03.027
<v Claire Adamsick>One person provided testimony at the committee meeting on June 16th, and 2 people provided written testimony prior to committee action.

2428
03:51:04.440 --> 03:51:16.081
<v Claire Adamsick>The general themes of the testimony included providing parity for affordable home builders who feel they are at a competitive disadvantage with market-rate homes since the implementation of the temporary SDC exemption program last year.

2429
03:51:16.129 --> 03:51:16.225
<v Micah Goldstein>Thank you.

2430
03:51:16.402 --> 03:51:28.615
<v Claire Adamsick>Year, the value of the SDC exemption in comparison to a homebuilder's profit margin, and finally expanding the potential pool of eligible homebuyers by removing income requirements while retaining other program requirements.

2431
03:51:28.985 --> 03:51:30.284
<v Claire Adamsick>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

2432
03:51:30.430 --> 03:51:30.751
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2433
03:51:30.911 --> 03:51:31.825
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Claire.

2434
03:51:32.451 --> 03:51:34.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos, this came out of your committee.

2435
03:51:34.522 --> 03:51:35.822
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, committee chair remarks.

2436
03:51:36.384 --> 03:51:37.972
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you.

2437
03:51:38.808 --> 03:51:46.608
<v Unidentified speaker>So yes, this ordinance came before the committee on June 16th and was referred, um, with a recommendation that it passed, although we did have have some ample discussion.

2438
03:51:47.138 --> 03:51:55.067
<v Unidentified speaker>This ordinance amends the Affordable Housing SCC Exemption Program to temporarily remove the income requirement for the initial homebuyer for certain homeownership units.

2439
03:51:55.629 --> 03:51:56.784
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a targeted change.

2440
03:51:56.850 --> 03:52:04.811
<v Unidentified speaker>It only applies to homes that received a building permit before January 1st, 2026, and are sold before September 30th, 2028.

2441
03:52:05.759 --> 03:52:09.658
<v Unidentified speaker>Other program requirements, including owner occupancy, remain in place.

2442
03:52:10.334 --> 03:52:20.983
<v Unidentified speaker>The issue discussed in committee was that some affordable home builders had already opted into the existing Affordable Housing SDC exemption program before the city adopted the broader temporary SDC exemption program.

2443
03:52:21.543 --> 03:52:28.818
<v Unidentified speaker>As a result, those builders were facing income restrictions that newer market-rate homes using the temporary exemption do not have.

2444
03:52:29.412 --> 03:52:44.281
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, um, my office worked diligently with local builders, including Justin Fish at Fish Construction, who first raised the issue to get a solution that takes into consideration our need to build more housing with the need to ensure that these homes are actually affordable.

2445
03:52:45.275 --> 03:52:56.941
<v Unidentified speaker>Committee members had a thoughtful discussion about balancing housing production with affordability, including concerns about impacts on lower-income homebuyers, the need for additional data, and ensuring this remains a targeted temporary solution.

2446
03:52:58.000 --> 03:53:05.354
<v Unidentified speaker>Personally, I'll be supporting this ordinance because I believe it addresses a specific unintended consequence created by the interaction of 2 city programs.

2447
03:53:05.787 --> 03:53:16.299
<v Unidentified speaker>Builders who entered this program under one set of rules found themselves At a competitive disadvantage after council adopted the broader temporary SCC exemption, I also appreciate that this is a narrow temporary fix.

2448
03:53:16.747 --> 03:53:25.465
<v Unidentified speaker>It preserves important guardrails, including the sale price cap and owner occupancy requirement, and PHB has committed to tracking the impacts of this change over the next two years.

2449
03:53:26.041 --> 03:53:35.334
<v Unidentified speaker>While I understand the concerns raised by my colleagues, I believe this strikes the right balance between preserving the program's affordability goals and ensuring we don't unintentionally slow housing production for projects already in the pipeline.

2450
03:53:36.088 --> 03:53:40.416
<v Unidentified speaker>So the committee voted 3-2 to advance the ordinance to the full council.

2451
03:53:40.945 --> 03:53:43.013
<v Unidentified speaker>And with that, I'll return it back to council for discussion.

2452
03:53:43.286 --> 03:53:43.525
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

2453
03:53:44.006 --> 03:53:45.001
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

2454
03:53:45.049 --> 03:53:49.361
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, as I mentioned before, we have 4 folks who have signed up to testify and are all online.

2455
03:53:49.457 --> 03:53:54.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have, uh, about 10 minutes left, and I know that there are amendments and some good discussion to be had.

2456
03:53:54.666 --> 03:54:02.408
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I want to let everyone know it is my intention to continue the first reading of this to our next, uh, available date, uh, rather than trying to move this to a second reading.

2457
03:54:03.019 --> 03:54:10.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we will have council discussion and conversation around amendments and probably have to ask Claire to come back up to give us more details when we get back on this.

2458
03:54:10.549 --> 03:54:12.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>But for now, I'd like to move to testimony, please.

2459
03:54:13.665 --> 03:54:15.960
<v Unidentified speaker>And sorry, I meant to say Justin Wood, not Justin Fish.

2460
03:54:16.395 --> 03:54:17.148
<v Unidentified speaker>Got that confused.

2461
03:54:17.212 --> 03:54:17.502
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My bad.

2462
03:54:17.679 --> 03:54:18.145
<v Ben Henson>Thanks.

2463
03:54:18.898 --> 03:54:19.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

2464
03:54:19.862 --> 03:54:20.504
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good clarification.

2465
03:54:21.066 --> 03:54:23.010
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, we have 4 folks signed up.

2466
03:54:23.154 --> 03:54:24.647
<v Keelan McClymont>They are all joining us online.

2467
03:54:25.242 --> 03:54:26.334
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, Michael Harrison.

2468
03:54:32.677 --> 03:54:33.789
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, wait a minute.

2469
03:54:34.238 --> 03:54:35.317
<v Keelan McClymont>Nope, sorry, that's wrong.

2470
03:54:35.575 --> 03:54:36.316
<v Keelan McClymont>Greg Fox.

2471
03:54:41.308 --> 03:54:41.693
<v Sharon Blair>Welcome.

2472
03:54:41.920 --> 03:54:44.242
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi, um, go right ahead.

2473
03:54:44.452 --> 03:54:46.305
<v Greg Fox>Good afternoon.

2474
03:54:46.970 --> 03:54:47.864
<v Greg Fox>Let me mute this computer.

2475
03:54:50.697 --> 03:54:52.058
<v Greg Fox>Uh, good afternoon, Mayor and councilors.

2476
03:54:52.207 --> 03:54:53.208
<v Greg Fox>My name is Greg Fox.

2477
03:54:53.388 --> 03:55:00.520
<v Greg Fox>I'm a realtor with Happy Homes I specialize in helping entry-level homebuyers obtain their dream of homeownership.

2478
03:55:01.430 --> 03:55:06.202
<v Greg Fox>I'm here today in support of removing the income requirement from the system development charge waiver program.

2479
03:55:07.629 --> 03:55:15.360
<v Greg Fox>From what I see daily in the marketplace, buyers who are at or below the median family income now have more choices than they have had in years.

2480
03:55:15.747 --> 03:55:20.427
<v Greg Fox>In North Portland alone, there is roughly an eight-month supply of newly built two-bedroom units.

2481
03:55:21.914 --> 03:55:30.403
<v Greg Fox>The challenge is that buyers can purchase similar homes without income restrictions, paperwork, income verification, nor application fees.

2482
03:55:31.547 --> 03:55:38.996
<v Greg Fox>It is difficult to recommend a home with additional requirements when a home— when a buyer can simply go down the street and purchase one that is unencumbered.

2483
03:55:40.639 --> 03:55:43.067
<v Greg Fox>Most middle housing is built by small local builders.

2484
03:55:44.070 --> 03:55:45.334
<v Greg Fox>They don't have the resources.

2485
03:55:46.158 --> 03:55:49.235
<v Greg Fox>They don't have the resources to carry unsold inventory indefinitely.

2486
03:55:50.634 --> 03:55:55.531
<v Greg Fox>Every home that sits on the market represents capital tied up and another home that isn't being built.

2487
03:55:56.995 --> 03:56:04.323
<v Greg Fox>Removing unnecessary barriers will help these homes sell more quickly and allow builders to keep producing the affordable housing Portland needs.

2488
03:56:05.539 --> 03:56:11.349
<v Greg Fox>This program has always worked because of a strong partnership between the City of Portland, local builders, and realtors.

2489
03:56:13.058 --> 03:56:16.415
<v Greg Fox>Each has played an important role in expanding homeownership opportunities.

2490
03:56:18.658 --> 03:56:22.931
<v Greg Fox>I respectfully ask the council to continue that partnership by approving this amendment.

2491
03:56:24.236 --> 03:56:31.284
<v Greg Fox>It will make the program more effective, help more homes reach the market, and ultimately create more housing for Portland families.

2492
03:56:32.097 --> 03:56:33.138
<v Greg Fox>Thank you for your time and consideration.

2493
03:56:34.850 --> 03:56:35.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2494
03:56:36.173 --> 03:56:37.043
<v Keelan McClymont>Ben Henson.

2495
03:56:39.802 --> 03:56:41.933
<v Ben Henson>Hello, uh, Council President Dunphy and members of the council.

2496
03:56:42.059 --> 03:56:42.100
<v Michael Harrison>Thank you, Mayor.

2497
03:56:42.100 --> 03:56:42.100
<v Michael Harrison>Thank you, Ben.

2498
03:56:42.100 --> 03:56:43.969
<v Ben Henson>Members of the council, my name is Ben Hempson.

2499
03:56:44.200 --> 03:56:47.989
<v Ben Henson>I'm the government affairs director for the Home Building Association of Greater Portland.

2500
03:56:48.659 --> 03:56:52.389
<v Ben Henson>Our members work on housing production across 6 counties and 40 cities.

2501
03:56:52.760 --> 03:57:00.280
<v Ben Henson>In Portland, their work is largely focused on small-scale single-family and multifamily infill development.

2502
03:57:00.280 --> 03:57:03.159
<v Ben Henson>We urge you to support this temporary removal of income limits.

2503
03:57:03.479 --> 03:57:18.944
<v Ben Henson>It's really an important shift that will help a small subset of housing producers to move their product into private ownership and occupancy more quickly and on par with the approximately 900 homes currently sitting on the housing market in Portland at or below $400,000.

2504
03:57:19.779 --> 03:57:24.447
<v Ben Henson>As you've heard from staff, approximately 200 current and future homes would benefit from this change.

2505
03:57:24.912 --> 03:57:27.863
<v Ben Henson>However, a number of requirements would remain in place.

2506
03:57:28.504 --> 03:57:42.084
<v Ben Henson>The homes would continue to be subject to a price cap of $455,000, and I think most importantly, they'd need to be occupied by the homebuyer these homes could not become part of the rental or short-term or vacation rental stock in Portland.

2507
03:57:42.905 --> 03:57:46.308
<v Ben Henson>During the committee discussion, I thought Councilor Green made a really important point.

2508
03:57:46.843 --> 03:57:51.934
<v Ben Henson>Reducing barriers to these homes being sold means the builders can move on to produce more housing.

2509
03:57:52.870 --> 03:57:59.665
<v Ben Henson>This is exactly the goal we should be pursuing right now through 2028 when the current SDC waiver program expires.

2510
03:58:00.408 --> 03:58:03.506
<v Ben Henson>Building a new home at or below $400,000 $250,000 is really hard.

2511
03:58:03.971 --> 03:58:07.775
<v Ben Henson>The profit margin can easily be eclipsed by an SDC charge.

2512
03:58:08.402 --> 03:58:25.898
<v Ben Henson>The choice you have— as councilors have made to temporarily waive SDCs for 3 years is transformative for new home development, but only if the builders best equipped to construct those homes at an attainable price are able to move homes off their books and move on to the next project.

2513
03:58:26.604 --> 03:58:35.690
<v Ben Henson>The folks that built these homes are typically longtime participants in Portland's various Affordable housing programs, and keeping them around and operating provides one other additional benefit.

2514
03:58:36.733 --> 03:58:48.626
<v Ben Henson>When the current SDC waiver program expires in 2028, we'll need them open and operating so they can participate in future affordable housing programs and whatever comes next after that program concludes.

2515
03:58:49.156 --> 03:58:52.590
<v Ben Henson>This change really does help ensure that they'll be here and building when that time comes.

2516
03:58:53.729 --> 03:58:55.478
<v Ben Henson>As always, we really appreciate your partnership.

2517
03:58:56.211 --> 03:59:01.911
<v Ben Henson>Uh, thanks for your time.

2518
03:59:03.959 --> 03:59:04.718
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2519
03:59:12.220 --> 03:59:14.140
<v Jeff Fish>Good afternoon, members of the Portland City Council.

2520
03:59:14.640 --> 03:59:20.978
<v Jeff Fish>Thank you for the opportunity to testify regarding the income limits on system development charge waiver program in the City of Portland.

2521
03:59:21.602 --> 03:59:26.977
<v Jeff Fish>My name is Jeff Fish, and I'm one of the owners of Fish Construction Northwest, along with Justin Wood.

2522
03:59:27.619 --> 03:59:35.369
<v Jeff Fish>You previously heard testimony from Justin, who's unable to join us today, so I'd like to offer a few comments, comments on behalf of our company.

2523
03:59:36.186 --> 03:59:43.920
<v Jeff Fish>I've been building homes in the city of Portland for more than 50 years, and my primary focus has always been on first-time homebuyers and middle-income families.

2524
03:59:44.465 --> 03:59:58.239
<v Jeff Fish>As the cost of housing increased over the years, Programs like the system development charge waiver and the limited tax exemption program become essential tools that allow us to provide much-needed affordable homeownership opportunities.

2525
03:59:59.058 --> 04:00:03.104
<v Jeff Fish>Our company has always taken pride in serving families at or below the median family income.

2526
04:00:03.650 --> 04:00:09.689
<v Jeff Fish>We believe providing attainable housing is not only good business, it's a civic responsibility.

2527
04:00:09.913 --> 04:00:11.904
<v Jeff Fish>For many years, the City of Portland has been a strong partner.

2528
04:00:11.985 --> 04:00:12.129
<v JP McNeill>Thank you.

2529
04:00:12.329 --> 04:00:12.950
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2530
04:00:12.950 --> 04:00:12.950
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mayor.

2531
04:00:12.950 --> 04:00:13.209
<v Jeff Fish>I have a question for the City of Portland.

2532
04:00:13.209 --> 04:00:16.459
<v Jeff Fish>Over the past 10 years, the city has been very supportive of the small number of builders who use these programs to make homeownership possible.

2533
04:00:17.190 --> 04:00:33.770
<v Jeff Fish>Last fall, when the City Council chose to temporarily waive SDCs to encourage housing construction, it left an unintended consequence that has disproportionately affected the builders who have long participated in the affordable housing programs.

2534
04:00:33.770 --> 04:00:50.324
<v Jeff Fish>I know this was never the council's intent, but there's a real, very challenge— While this issue may affect only a few hundred homes citywide, its impact on the handful of affordable home builders who are applying to these programs has been significant.

2535
04:00:50.645 --> 04:01:01.513
<v Jeff Fish>Buyers now have many more homes available within their price range that do not require the income verification, the qualification paperwork, or processing fees.

2536
04:01:02.250 --> 04:01:05.440
<v Jeff Fish>As a result, even income-qualified buyers Thank you, Mayor.

2537
04:01:05.440 --> 04:01:05.440
<v Jeff Fish>Thank you, Mayor.

2538
04:01:05.440 --> 04:01:11.659
<v Jeff Fish>The city has had a number of homeowners who have chosen homes outside the SDC waiver program simply because the purchase process is easier.

2539
04:01:12.260 --> 04:01:17.430
<v Jeff Fish>Those building homes under the program operate on a very modest profit margin.

2540
04:01:17.500 --> 04:01:24.280
<v Jeff Fish>In many cases, the SDC waiver represents the difference between breaking even and losing money.

2541
04:01:24.280 --> 04:01:28.440
<v Jeff Fish>If we cannot sell these homes to qualified buyers, we are forced to sell them at a loss.

2542
04:01:28.620 --> 04:01:42.210
<v Jeff Fish>For years, we've partnered with the City of Portland to help achieve Today, we are simply asking the city to continue that partnership by supporting this temporary ordinance so we can keep building the homes that Portland families need.

2543
04:01:43.126 --> 04:01:44.860
<v Jeff Fish>Thank you for your time and consideration.

2544
04:01:46.079 --> 04:01:46.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2545
04:01:47.765 --> 04:01:48.793
<v Keelan McClymont>Douglas McLeod.

2546
04:01:49.548 --> 04:01:50.030
<v Douglas McLeod>Thanks.

2547
04:01:50.254 --> 04:01:52.534
<v Douglas McLeod>Um, Douglas McLeod.

2548
04:01:52.583 --> 04:01:53.818
<v Douglas McLeod>I've been a realtor for 25 years.

2549
04:01:53.868 --> 04:01:55.890
<v Douglas McLeod>I've worked with about 1,000 families in the Portland area.

2550
04:01:56.518 --> 04:01:59.531
<v Douglas McLeod>10 Different builders over the years, including that guy who just spoke.

2551
04:01:59.594 --> 04:02:00.319
<v Douglas McLeod>Hi, Jeff.

2552
04:02:01.190 --> 04:02:03.268
<v Douglas McLeod>Sold probably 200 new construction homes.

2553
04:02:04.412 --> 04:02:07.284
<v Douglas McLeod>As of 8 years ago, I started developing myself.

2554
04:02:07.333 --> 04:02:10.191
<v Douglas McLeod>I've sold 39 homes, so 5 homes a year.

2555
04:02:10.335 --> 04:02:11.514
<v Douglas McLeod>I'm a small developer.

2556
04:02:13.971 --> 04:02:21.597
<v Douglas McLeod>I only do affordable, or let's say moderately priced homes, starter homes.

2557
04:02:22.195 --> 04:02:27.665
<v Douglas McLeod>Uh, and I was the HBA rep to the residential infill project, which I think was great code.

2558
04:02:28.049 --> 04:02:30.711
<v Douglas McLeod>Anyhow, I just want to talk really quickly about the market.

2559
04:02:30.968 --> 04:02:36.854
<v Douglas McLeod>I'm under the impression that some council people, or maybe their staff, think that the market is pretty good for new construction.

2560
04:02:38.234 --> 04:02:40.061
<v Douglas McLeod>Maybe I'm wrong, but I just want to say this.

2561
04:02:40.351 --> 04:02:42.034
<v Douglas McLeod>It's a horrific market.

2562
04:02:42.404 --> 04:02:45.033
<v Douglas McLeod>It's as bad as it's been since the Great Recession.

2563
04:02:45.611 --> 04:02:46.878
<v Douglas McLeod>I've been doing this 25 years.

2564
04:02:47.520 --> 04:02:49.861
<v Douglas McLeod>Mostly new construction, mostly starter pricing.

2565
04:02:50.074 --> 04:02:51.570
<v Douglas McLeod>It is as bad as it's ever been.

2566
04:02:53.819 --> 04:02:56.316
<v Douglas McLeod>Prices are declining, sales are really slow.

2567
04:02:56.654 --> 04:03:10.548
<v Douglas McLeod>And one thing that's really tricky and hard to get your head around unless you're really intimate with it is that there's a huge hidden inventory of completed, permitted, final permit, C of O homes that are not on the market.

2568
04:03:11.280 --> 04:03:15.039
<v Douglas McLeod>In the past, if you built a house, you know, 5 years ago before RIP, you put it on the market.

2569
04:03:15.087 --> 04:03:15.154
<v Unidentified speaker>Right.

2570
04:03:15.656 --> 04:03:17.296
<v Douglas McLeod>You built a house over here, you put on the market.

2571
04:03:17.360 --> 04:03:22.146
<v Douglas McLeod>Now those same lots, you might be putting on 5, 6, 7, 8 homes.

2572
04:03:22.981 --> 04:03:25.165
<v Douglas McLeod>And in a slow market, you don't put them all on at once.

2573
04:03:25.310 --> 04:03:26.370
<v Douglas McLeod>You put on 1 or 2.

2574
04:03:26.980 --> 04:03:28.572
<v Douglas McLeod>1 Goes pending, you put on another one.

2575
04:03:29.182 --> 04:03:35.591
<v Douglas McLeod>So a lot of projects, when I look around, I see, you know, 1 got sold, 1 is pending, 1's on the market, 2 are on the market.

2576
04:03:35.832 --> 04:03:39.606
<v Douglas McLeod>There's 5 other homes that are in the project, not on the market.

2577
04:03:40.087 --> 04:03:41.984
<v Douglas McLeod>The market is is terrible.

2578
04:03:42.721 --> 04:03:50.929
<v Douglas McLeod>Some of my best builder friends are moving away from doing starter home priced homes, which is kind of heartbreaking because the market's really different— difficult.

2579
04:03:51.394 --> 04:04:04.112
<v Douglas McLeod>So the point of all that is anything you can do to help a few builders move, get their homes sold, and recirculate their money to build some more starter homes, I think is good for the builder, good for the buyer, good for the city.

2580
04:04:04.643 --> 04:04:07.597
<v Douglas McLeod>So really quick, just to contextualize what's on the table.

2581
04:04:07.663 --> 04:04:07.790
<v Micah Goldstein>Thank you.

2582
04:04:08.256 --> 04:04:10.775
<v Douglas McLeod>I think the SDC program made sense.

2583
04:04:10.841 --> 04:04:11.915
<v Douglas McLeod>I think it's super helpful.

2584
04:04:12.380 --> 04:04:14.869
<v Douglas McLeod>I'm not sure I would have applied it to $800,000 homes.

2585
04:04:14.916 --> 04:04:15.783
<v Douglas McLeod>That's another question.

2586
04:04:16.361 --> 04:04:17.195
<v Douglas McLeod>Water over the dam.

2587
04:04:17.822 --> 04:04:21.031
<v Douglas McLeod>But for the starter home pricing, it's incredibly significant.

2588
04:04:21.593 --> 04:04:25.799
<v Douglas McLeod>What is on the table today is not some new policy direction.

2589
04:04:26.023 --> 04:04:27.981
<v Douglas McLeod>It's just correcting an oversight.

2590
04:04:28.495 --> 04:04:45.841
<v Douglas McLeod>There's probably 200 homes that it applied to, which in the end means maybe 100 would, would take advantage of this program if it passes, but there are some of us building the exact same thing as the guy across the street, and we have our arms tied behind our back, um, because of a little oversight.

2591
04:04:45.905 --> 04:04:47.287
<v Douglas McLeod>And I hope the council can correct it.

2592
04:04:47.415 --> 04:04:47.881
<v Douglas McLeod>That's all.

2593
04:04:49.343 --> 04:04:50.147
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2594
04:04:51.289 --> 04:04:52.386
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

2595
04:04:52.595 --> 04:04:55.217
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, as promised, it is now 1:31.

2596
04:04:55.476 --> 04:05:06.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am going to continue this item to the afternoon meeting of Thursday, July 23rd, for a continued first reading of this non-emergency ordinance.

2597
04:05:07.511 --> 04:05:12.135
<v Jamie Dunphy>That concludes our agenda for the day, and we are adjourned.

