WEBVTT

1
00:03:22.561 --> 00:03:24.448
<v Candace Avalos>All right, good afternoon.

2
00:03:24.561 --> 00:03:31.566
<v Candace Avalos>I am going to call the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee to order at 2:01 PM on Tuesday, July 7th.

3
00:03:32.326 --> 00:03:33.314
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, please call the roll.

4
00:03:33.849 --> 00:03:34.400
<v Diego>Good afternoon.

5
00:03:34.984 --> 00:03:35.533
<v Diego>Koyama Lane?

6
00:03:37.251 --> 00:03:37.752
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Absent.

7
00:03:37.931 --> 00:03:38.384
<v Diego>Novick?

8
00:03:40.420 --> 00:03:40.550
<v Steve Novick>Here.

9
00:03:40.760 --> 00:03:40.972
<v Diego>Green?

10
00:03:42.608 --> 00:03:42.737
<v Mitch Green>Here.

11
00:03:43.662 --> 00:03:44.050
<v Diego>Pirtle-Guiney?

12
00:03:44.877 --> 00:03:45.006
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

13
00:03:45.848 --> 00:03:46.157
<v Diego>Avalos?

14
00:03:46.350 --> 00:03:46.756
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

15
00:03:47.711 --> 00:03:49.087
<v Candace Avalos>Claire, please read the statement of conduct.

16
00:03:49.895 --> 00:03:50.395
<v Claire>Thank you, Chair.

17
00:03:50.718 --> 00:03:53.269
<v Claire>Good afternoon and welcome to the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

18
00:03:54.188 --> 00:04:04.872
<v Claire>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at portland.gov/council/agenda/housingandpermittingcommittee or by calling 311.

19
00:04:05.757 --> 00:04:08.872
<v Claire>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

20
00:04:09.531 --> 00:04:12.453
<v Claire>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

21
00:04:13.256 --> 00:04:18.505
<v Claire>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

22
00:04:19.165 --> 00:04:21.074
<v Claire>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

23
00:04:21.733 --> 00:04:22.728
<v Claire>The chair preserves order.

24
00:04:22.889 --> 00:04:30.468
<v Claire>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

25
00:04:31.125 --> 00:04:32.791
<v Claire>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

26
00:04:33.209 --> 00:04:35.403
<v Claire>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

27
00:04:35.949 --> 00:04:38.944
<v Claire>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

28
00:04:39.538 --> 00:04:42.646
<v Claire>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

29
00:04:43.543 --> 00:04:45.418
<v Claire>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

30
00:04:45.482 --> 00:04:47.403
<v Claire>When testifying, please state your name for the record.

31
00:04:47.949 --> 00:04:50.656
<v Claire>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

32
00:04:51.009 --> 00:04:54.437
<v Claire>And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

33
00:04:54.694 --> 00:04:55.110
<v Claire>Thank you.

34
00:04:55.896 --> 00:04:56.392
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Claire.

35
00:04:57.322 --> 00:04:59.500
<v Candace Avalos>Today we have 4 items on our agenda.

36
00:04:59.805 --> 00:05:03.153
<v Candace Avalos>We will have time for public comment as we always do at the top of the meeting.

37
00:05:04.067 --> 00:05:10.846
<v Candace Avalos>We will then have a presentation on the North and Northeast Neighborhood Housing Strategy Annual Report from the North Northeast Oversight Committee.

38
00:05:11.519 --> 00:05:21.629
<v Candace Avalos>And for the second half of the meeting, we will have a discussion with Urban Alchemy and Portland Solutions staff on the city's partnerships and oversight of shelter operations, including time for public comment.

39
00:05:22.014 --> 00:05:24.129
<v Candace Avalos>So we will open those up at the same time.

40
00:05:24.257 --> 00:05:27.189
<v Candace Avalos>We'll have some presentations, some comment, and then committee discussion.

41
00:05:28.088 --> 00:05:29.920
<v Candace Avalos>With that, please call item 1.

42
00:05:31.221 --> 00:05:34.226
<v Diego>Item 1, Housing and Permitting Community Feedback.

43
00:05:35.077 --> 00:05:44.302
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, this is an opportunity for community members to share any of their concerns, ideas, or feedback regarding housing and permitting issues, and each testifier will have 3 minutes each.

44
00:05:44.413 --> 00:05:47.435
<v Candace Avalos>So Diego, please call up the first and only person.

45
00:05:47.627 --> 00:05:48.110
<v Candace Avalos>One person?

46
00:05:48.415 --> 00:05:49.009
<v Diego>That's correct.

47
00:05:49.137 --> 00:05:49.475
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

48
00:05:50.504 --> 00:05:52.947
<v Diego>Our individual signed up, Lacey Sutton.

49
00:05:56.925 --> 00:05:57.663
<v Candace Avalos>Welcome, go ahead.

50
00:05:58.930 --> 00:05:59.557
<v Lacey Sutton>Lacey Sutton.

51
00:06:00.937 --> 00:06:08.028
<v Lacey Sutton>Um, I wanted to say thank you to Councilors Koyama Lane and Green for your encouraging words at the last committee meeting.

52
00:06:08.492 --> 00:06:13.418
<v Lacey Sutton>You asked for examples of follow-up pre-application requirements in other cities, and I emailed those to all of you.

53
00:06:14.189 --> 00:06:16.964
<v Lacey Sutton>You also asked for examples of systems of accountability.

54
00:06:17.317 --> 00:06:22.178
<v Lacey Sutton>I've been looking, but what keeps coming up are the kinds of systems we already have.

55
00:06:22.773 --> 00:06:26.432
<v Lacey Sutton>So for now, I thought I'd share more about how impossible it's been to utilize them.

56
00:06:27.346 --> 00:06:38.148
<v Lacey Sutton>Recently at a public safety meeting, Fire Chief Johnson refused to answer my questions about Cherry Blossom again and assured the audience that anyone concerned about fire safety could lodge a complaint with the fire marshal's office.

57
00:06:38.805 --> 00:06:41.709
<v Lacey Sutton>But I did that 1,009 days ago.

58
00:06:42.673 --> 00:06:48.451
<v Lacey Sutton>And when a fire inspector came out and told me our homes were built wrong and we weren't safe, they told him to shut up.

59
00:06:49.341 --> 00:06:51.677
<v Lacey Sutton>He's the one who sued the city for racial discrimination.

60
00:06:53.372 --> 00:06:54.706
<v Lacey Sutton>And when a fire inspect— sorry.

61
00:06:55.704 --> 00:06:57.569
<v Lacey Sutton>I filed a complaint with PP&D too.

62
00:06:58.341 --> 00:07:12.084
<v Lacey Sutton>Former Director David Kuhnhausen met with Habitat for Humanity CEO Steve Messinetti to discuss things Habitat did and the city missed, like leaving huge holes in the firewalls and installing horizontal balcony railings.

63
00:07:12.845 --> 00:07:17.798
<v Lacey Sutton>The Design Commission had made vertical railings a legally binding condition of approval, citing children's safety.

64
00:07:17.846 --> 00:07:24.807
<v Lacey Sutton>I've lost track of the number of times I've had to stand under a balcony with my arms up yelling for the parents of a climbing baby.

65
00:07:25.482 --> 00:07:37.569
<v Lacey Sutton>So when I heard Habitat was given directives to replace the railings, I was thrilled, and I told Koin News, which allegedly angered PP&D, and they said they wouldn't require replacement railings after all.

66
00:07:37.747 --> 00:07:39.045
<v Lacey Sutton>At least that's what I heard.

67
00:07:39.494 --> 00:07:40.937
<v Lacey Sutton>They refused to talk to me after that.

68
00:07:42.235 --> 00:07:49.627
<v Lacey Sutton>And then there's the ombudsman, Rose City's watchdog, who rolled over like a lapdog as soon as Habitat said the word.

69
00:07:50.252 --> 00:07:57.896
<v Lacey Sutton>The morning after KOIN News aired an interview with Deputy Ombudsman Tony Green, Steve Messinetti asked to meet with him, and they did that day.

70
00:07:58.425 --> 00:08:01.637
<v Lacey Sutton>At that point, Tony had been investigating this for 5 months.

71
00:08:02.038 --> 00:08:09.199
<v Lacey Sutton>He'd already written and was about to publish his findings, which contained fire officials' admissions of failure.

72
00:08:09.841 --> 00:08:17.838
<v Lacey Sutton>But after this meeting, he deleted them and rewrote the report to exonerate Habitat, which would be bad enough for a city ombudsman to do.

73
00:08:17.903 --> 00:08:17.999
<v Diego>Thank you.

74
00:08:18.271 --> 00:08:21.769
<v Lacey Sutton>But it's actually worse because the story they came up with is pure fiction.

75
00:08:22.524 --> 00:08:26.519
<v Lacey Sutton>I assure you I'm not saying anything I can't back up with a pile of evidence.

76
00:08:27.002 --> 00:08:29.504
<v Lacey Sutton>But just last week I got a letter from risk management.

77
00:08:30.067 --> 00:08:35.971
<v Lacey Sutton>The city yet again investigated itself and determined it did nothing wrong and isn't liable for anything.

78
00:08:36.870 --> 00:08:41.139
<v Lacey Sutton>Well, I'm really looking forward to finally getting some answers now.

79
00:08:41.941 --> 00:08:45.359
<v Lacey Sutton>I mean, if the city did everything right, surely they'll have no problem explaining.

80
00:08:45.440 --> 00:08:46.514
<v Lacey Sutton>Thank you.

81
00:08:47.717 --> 00:09:02.208
<v Lacey Sutton>So while I like the idea of some kind of comment system where regular people can leave feedback about housing, particularly subsidized housing, I also like the idea of an ombudsman, of plan review, inspections, code compliance, codes, laws.

82
00:09:03.124 --> 00:09:08.259
<v Lacey Sutton>We already have these things, but they're overseen by people looking out for themselves and their friends.

83
00:09:09.381 --> 00:09:18.394
<v Lacey Sutton>My problem is I've been asking them to investigate them Hold them accountable, and they're not doing it.

84
00:09:18.798 --> 00:09:19.381
<v Lacey Sutton>They never will.

85
00:09:20.029 --> 00:09:23.931
<v Lacey Sutton>So now I'm asking you, please enforce the systems we already have.

86
00:09:24.496 --> 00:09:24.933
<v Marlene Howell>Thank you.

87
00:09:27.229 --> 00:09:28.263
<v Diego>That concludes testimony.

88
00:09:29.184 --> 00:09:29.557
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

89
00:09:31.511 --> 00:09:32.173
<v Candace Avalos>Please read item 2.

90
00:09:34.265 --> 00:09:38.434
<v Diego>Item 2, North Northeast Oversight Committee Annual Report.

91
00:09:39.809 --> 00:09:43.162
<v Candace Avalos>All right, we've got some folks coming on up.

92
00:09:43.884 --> 00:09:58.479
<v Candace Avalos>So, um, the North and Northeast Neighborhood Housing Strategy is a strategy to address displacement in North and Northeast Portland, specifically of Black households, through housing investments, homeownership, and home retention programs for longtime residents.

93
00:09:58.879 --> 00:10:07.589
<v Candace Avalos>The council approved the North and Northeast Housing Strategy in 2015, and in 2015, $20 million in interstate TIF was allocated to create the housing strategy.

94
00:10:08.182 --> 00:10:13.933
<v Candace Avalos>Since that time, over $120 million of TIF have been utilized to fund the 4 strategy areas.

95
00:10:14.511 --> 00:10:21.724
<v Candace Avalos>The Portland Housing Bureau reports that it has 975 affordable units open or in development under the North and Northeast Housing Strategy.

96
00:10:22.624 --> 00:10:30.157
<v Candace Avalos>So today's presentation will include data through December of '25 from all 4 strategies, as well as an update on the preference policy.

97
00:10:30.815 --> 00:10:41.099
<v Candace Avalos>And the preference policy continues to be a race-neutral national model for addressing Excuse me.

98
00:10:41.585 --> 00:10:46.750
<v Candace Avalos>As they continue to seek guidance and technical assistance on the mechanics and structure of the North and Northeast Preference Policy.

99
00:10:47.350 --> 00:10:54.884
<v Candace Avalos>So when we think about this policy, we naturally think of D2 communities, but this is particularly important to my constituents in East Portland as well.

100
00:10:55.029 --> 00:11:02.563
<v Candace Avalos>Many Black Portlanders living in East Portland were displaced from North and Northeast Portland based on specific actions that previous city leadership took.

101
00:11:03.015 --> 00:11:05.192
<v Candace Avalos>And these are the families that this policy is intended to help.

102
00:11:05.245 --> 00:11:24.833
<v Candace Avalos>So I wanna offer my personal appreciation for the North and Northeast Housing Neighborhood Housing Strategy Oversight Committee's dedication and perseverance in this work to ensure that Portland's most displaced populations continue to have opportunities in North and Northeast Portland, especially given the current context of the federal administration that is actively working to dismantle programs like ours.

103
00:11:25.412 --> 00:11:36.730
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you, Dr. Stephen Holt, uh, the Oversight Committee Chair, who's going to lead us off with some opening remarks, followed by PHB's Equity and Business Operations Manager Leslie Goodlow, who will report on the data.

104
00:11:37.275 --> 00:11:37.533
<v Candace Avalos>Take it away.

105
00:11:37.998 --> 00:11:39.264
<v Stephen Holt>Well, thank you, Councilor.

106
00:11:39.763 --> 00:11:41.672
<v Stephen Holt>It is good to be here this afternoon.

107
00:11:41.847 --> 00:11:48.889
<v Stephen Holt>As said, I'm Dr. Stephen Holt, and I haven't had the privilege or opportunity to get to know, uh, the new councilors.

108
00:11:49.147 --> 00:11:52.676
<v Stephen Holt>Uh, Councilor Avalos, we have had one opportunity to sit together.

109
00:11:53.157 --> 00:11:54.168
<v Stephen Holt>I look forward to having more.

110
00:11:54.681 --> 00:12:04.789
<v Stephen Holt>And then, um, Councilor Green, Councilor Novick, and Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, we saw one another just a couple of weeks ago, and I appreciated your comments at the opening Thank you.

111
00:12:04.789 --> 00:12:04.789
<v Stephen Holt>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

112
00:12:04.789 --> 00:12:06.169
<v Stephen Holt>Thank you, Councilor Smith, and thank you to all of the members of the Strong Property family.

113
00:12:06.169 --> 00:12:20.950
<v Stephen Holt>As I start, I want to say that I appreciate the work of the committee, that this committee has been in place for 10 years, and there have been a host of people who have given their time and given their efforts and given their commitments to this work.

114
00:12:20.950 --> 00:12:30.929
<v Stephen Holt>They've not only been a part of the ongoing strategy itself, they've been a part of reviewing NOFAs, they've been a part of helping to strategize how the work gets done.

115
00:12:35.981 --> 00:12:38.600
<v Stephen Holt>Appreciation for those who've been in that space.

116
00:12:38.775 --> 00:12:41.216
<v Stephen Holt>I won't read the names of the current committee.

117
00:12:41.265 --> 00:12:49.183
<v Stephen Holt>We've got a new group of individuals who are engaged in this work and who are extremely excited about what is going on.

118
00:12:50.500 --> 00:12:56.057
<v Stephen Holt>Opening my comments, uh, I'm excited about the report and what we have a chance to share.

119
00:12:56.956 --> 00:12:57.711
<v Stephen Holt>It's been 10 years.

120
00:12:58.692 --> 00:12:59.719
<v Stephen Holt>10 Years.

121
00:13:00.490 --> 00:13:03.494
<v Stephen Holt>And a lot can happen in 10 years.

122
00:13:03.991 --> 00:13:04.778
<v Stephen Holt>We've had 3 mayors.

123
00:13:05.515 --> 00:13:06.061
<v Stephen Holt>In 10 years.

124
00:13:06.638 --> 00:13:10.710
<v Stephen Holt>6 Different housing bureau directors in 10 years.

125
00:13:12.183 --> 00:13:18.644
<v Stephen Holt>Many changes in values and things that have been emphasized or important.

126
00:13:20.118 --> 00:13:24.205
<v Stephen Holt>But the interesting thing is that through those 10 years, the work of this committee hasn't changed.

127
00:13:24.910 --> 00:13:33.149
<v Stephen Holt>This committee has been absolutely dedicated to one thing and one thing only, and that's providing opportunities for people who don't necessarily get them.

128
00:13:34.004 --> 00:13:39.924
<v Stephen Holt>Being a voice for those who don't get the chance to sit in spaces like this and have conversations like this.

129
00:13:40.279 --> 00:13:44.582
<v Stephen Holt>People don't even know the public process of how to get engaged and get involved.

130
00:13:44.711 --> 00:13:48.552
<v Stephen Holt>This has been both a calling and a cost of 10 years.

131
00:13:49.211 --> 00:13:51.832
<v Stephen Holt>And sometimes I have to admit, I feel like a dinosaur.

132
00:13:52.870 --> 00:13:53.158
<v Stephen Holt>I do.

133
00:13:54.253 --> 00:14:00.269
<v Stephen Holt>I am— we started this, I was 49 years old, and now I sit here 60, just about 61.

134
00:14:01.009 --> 00:14:17.652
<v Stephen Holt>I was raised at a time where who you were mattered, where character was a big deal, where what you do outweighs what you say, where you were held in a position of accountability with the decisions that you made.

135
00:14:17.700 --> 00:14:25.541
<v Stephen Holt>My family owned a property on Williamson Killingsworth, and I used to go and pump gas in the summers.

136
00:14:25.894 --> 00:14:33.407
<v Stephen Holt>At 8 years old, I learned a very expensive lesson, and the lesson I learned is back when gas stations weren't quite What they are today.

137
00:14:33.552 --> 00:14:41.288
<v Stephen Holt>You could get some cigarettes, you could get some pop, or you get some bubble gum or that kind of thing if you'd go in and, and purchase it.

138
00:14:42.105 --> 00:14:48.308
<v Stephen Holt>I used to pump the gas and I would run and do errands for folks that wanted something out of the, the station.

139
00:14:49.433 --> 00:14:58.611
<v Stephen Holt>Well, what I learned at 8 years old was that you don't pump the gas first and then go get the goodies before people pay, because sometimes they pull off.

140
00:14:59.847 --> 00:15:07.227
<v Stephen Holt>And what my dad taught me was that their pulling off and the cost of the gas came out of my check at 8.

141
00:15:08.190 --> 00:15:20.254
<v Stephen Holt>So I learned very early something called choice consequence, responsibility and oversight, and standing in the place of being careful of what you do more than what you say.

142
00:15:21.601 --> 00:15:37.692
<v Stephen Holt>I feel like a dinosaur because the day we live in, you can get canceled In a second over something that is reported or something that is captured or something that someone is impressed with, and they forget what you've done, your action.

143
00:15:37.965 --> 00:15:39.312
<v Stephen Holt>10 Years is a long time.

144
00:15:39.793 --> 00:15:51.184
<v Stephen Holt>And as I sit here and look at today's presentation and the information that Ms. Goodlow is going to go over and the data that's presented, the work we've done speaks.

145
00:15:51.986 --> 00:15:59.567
<v Stephen Holt>What has been accomplished speaks more than words, more than opinions, more than perspectives, more than what's said about you.

146
00:16:00.096 --> 00:16:01.812
<v Stephen Holt>Consider what is done.

147
00:16:02.341 --> 00:16:06.589
<v Stephen Holt>I, I just kind of long for the days of yesterday.

148
00:16:07.534 --> 00:16:14.058
<v Stephen Holt>Bring back the days of yay and nay where it mattered how you showed up and it mattered what you produced.

149
00:16:14.106 --> 00:16:28.417
<v Stephen Holt>And I think for the people that have had a chance to move back into the houses For the people who've had a chance to move back into the apartments, who will never know those who stood in front of them or those who fought for them, who will never be aware of it.

150
00:16:28.865 --> 00:16:32.172
<v Stephen Holt>What matters most is the product that's happened.

151
00:16:33.279 --> 00:16:37.613
<v Stephen Holt>I look forward to getting to know you and your commitment in this space.

152
00:16:37.933 --> 00:16:45.428
<v Stephen Holt>You sit in an incredible place of responsibility and accountability, and you probably know better than I do how much opinion Thank you.

153
00:16:45.493 --> 00:16:48.073
<v Stephen Holt>What you do about who you are can impact how people think about you.

154
00:16:49.259 --> 00:16:52.626
<v Stephen Holt>But what an opportunity to demonstrate who you are by what you do.

155
00:16:53.427 --> 00:17:10.484
<v Stephen Holt>And I think this testimony is a testimony of 10 years of work, of a labor of love, of a guy who grew up on Williams and Wygant, whose family lost their business on Killingsworth and Williams, the old Rocket Fuel Station, and who stayed showing up month after month.

156
00:17:11.888 --> 00:17:15.455
<v Stephen Holt>Year after year because of a community that needed help.

157
00:17:16.116 --> 00:17:18.117
<v Stephen Holt>So, uh, we'll look at the data.

158
00:17:18.214 --> 00:17:21.280
<v Stephen Holt>Ms. Goodloe, thank you very much for your commitment over the past 10 years.

159
00:17:21.346 --> 00:17:26.428
<v Stephen Holt>You've been also one of those consistent voices to advocate for those who haven't had them.

160
00:17:26.895 --> 00:17:27.573
<v Stephen Holt>Here's the report.

161
00:17:27.653 --> 00:17:28.912
<v Stephen Holt>I'm super excited about it.

162
00:17:28.977 --> 00:17:32.074
<v Stephen Holt>If you've got a chance to look at it, I'm sure you're hyped also.

163
00:17:33.993 --> 00:17:34.623
<v Leslie Goodloe>Good afternoon.

164
00:17:34.736 --> 00:17:37.720
<v Leslie Goodloe>Leslie Goodloe, Equity and Business Operations for the Portland Housing Bureau.

165
00:17:38.528 --> 00:17:44.165
<v Leslie Goodloe>I'm going to start off on talking about the expenditures over the last 10 years.

166
00:17:45.079 --> 00:17:52.913
<v Leslie Goodloe>We, through December of 2025, have spent $121.8 million in tax increment financing.

167
00:17:54.480 --> 00:18:01.516
<v Leslie Goodloe>That we— the total amount we've spent is more than that, but that is the TIF dollars.

168
00:18:01.775 --> 00:18:12.507
<v Leslie Goodloe>This dollar amount does not include Metro Housing Bond, construction excise tax, short-term rental funds, PSEP, and other funding sources that have also gone in to supplement the strategy.

169
00:18:13.606 --> 00:18:20.695
<v Leslie Goodloe>The sustained investment demonstrates the city's long-term commitment to repairing the impacts of displacement in North and Northeast Portland.

170
00:18:21.132 --> 00:18:34.944
<v Leslie Goodloe>And what began as a $20 million initiative in 2014 by Mayor Charlie Hales and Commissioner Dan Saltzman has grown into Portland's largest and longest-running anti-displacement investment.

171
00:18:36.824 --> 00:18:40.749
<v Leslie Goodloe>This map shows you the investments across the Interstate District.

172
00:18:41.148 --> 00:18:55.118
<v Leslie Goodloe>You can see we have 12 rental properties that are either open or in development, and then we have 4 homeownership projects that are either open or in development.

173
00:18:55.728 --> 00:19:08.853
<v Leslie Goodloe>We do have one other project that you all funded earlier this year, the Monarca, that will fall under the housing strategy and the preference policy, and we look forward to Working with Hacienda on that project.

174
00:19:10.645 --> 00:19:21.137
<v Leslie Goodloe>We also want to stress that while the projects were all within one district, we did try to space them out so that they are across a variety of neighborhoods.

175
00:19:21.876 --> 00:19:27.330
<v Leslie Goodloe>We've created opportunities for families to have options near parks and other businesses.

176
00:19:28.490 --> 00:19:33.528
<v Leslie Goodloe>Today, these investments represent hundreds of affordable homes and a pipeline that continues to grow.

177
00:19:37.154 --> 00:19:38.270
<v Leslie Goodloe>Oh, go back, Leslie.

178
00:19:41.378 --> 00:19:42.090
<v Leslie Goodloe>Back, back, back.

179
00:19:46.125 --> 00:19:47.236
<v Leslie Goodloe>Sorry, I don't have my glasses.

180
00:19:47.347 --> 00:19:49.005
<v Leslie Goodloe>I should have grabbed my glasses.

181
00:19:49.182 --> 00:19:49.681
<v Stephen Holt>It helps.

182
00:19:49.986 --> 00:19:50.115
<v Leslie Goodloe>Yes.

183
00:19:50.548 --> 00:19:50.934
<v Leslie Goodloe>All right.

184
00:19:51.465 --> 00:19:54.231
<v Leslie Goodloe>So preventing displacement is strategy number 1.

185
00:19:54.521 --> 00:19:59.675
<v Leslie Goodloe>And this is primarily home repair loans and grants going to homeowners within the district.

186
00:20:00.243 --> 00:20:03.557
<v Leslie Goodloe>When we started the project in 2015, we had a goal of 80 households getting loans.

187
00:20:05.281 --> 00:20:07.414
<v Leslie Goodloe>And 160 households getting grants.

188
00:20:08.025 --> 00:20:17.710
<v Leslie Goodloe>To date, we have served 192— well, through the end of December, 192 households with loans and 1,245 households with grants.

189
00:20:18.511 --> 00:20:26.577
<v Leslie Goodloe>The loans are forgivable after 15 years, and the grants are— there's no, no lien or anything.

190
00:20:26.625 --> 00:20:45.961
<v Leslie Goodloe>It is an actual grant up to $10,000, and Those are able to be reapplied for, but this count is the number of unduplicated households that we've served for a total of $13 million in TIF dollars spent.

191
00:20:48.109 --> 00:20:50.046
<v Leslie Goodloe>Creating new homeowners is goal number 2.

192
00:20:50.949 --> 00:20:59.907
<v Leslie Goodloe>This has been a cornerstone of the strategy, as this was the strongest issue raised during the forums in 2014.

193
00:20:59.973 --> 00:21:06.383
<v Leslie Goodloe>Families and And participants were very concerned about replacing homeownership with homeownership.

194
00:21:07.472 --> 00:21:11.992
<v Leslie Goodloe>We had an original goal of 40 households being served with down payment assistance.

195
00:21:12.105 --> 00:21:13.867
<v Leslie Goodloe>To date, we have served 86.

196
00:21:14.990 --> 00:21:20.230
<v Leslie Goodloe>32 Households through development of affordable homeownership.

197
00:21:20.776 --> 00:21:24.638
<v Leslie Goodloe>We have 57 units that we've contributed to.

198
00:21:25.503 --> 00:21:29.398
<v Leslie Goodloe>36 Of those were sold to preference policy families.

199
00:21:29.751 --> 00:21:35.090
<v Leslie Goodloe>The remaining were sold to folks in either Habitat or Proud Grounds pipeline.

200
00:21:36.244 --> 00:21:44.134
<v Leslie Goodloe>And additionally, we've been able to assist 12 homeowners to be— 12 people to become homeowners without any subsidy from PHB.

201
00:21:44.567 --> 00:21:52.150
<v Leslie Goodloe>They were able to purchase a family home or a neighbor home, but they did benefit from the counseling that the bureau pays for.

202
00:21:53.560 --> 00:22:03.616
<v Leslie Goodloe>We've spent about $14 million in TIF dollars and then another $3 million in other resources for homeownership.

203
00:22:05.940 --> 00:22:14.817
<v Leslie Goodloe>This slide shows you how and which funding source, which color of money has gone in to support our homeowners.

204
00:22:16.488 --> 00:22:20.560
<v Leslie Goodloe>North Northeast TIF, that's Interstate TIF 39.

205
00:22:20.997 --> 00:22:24.278
<v Leslie Goodloe>Prosper Portland, that's also TIF dollars.

206
00:22:24.885 --> 00:22:29.454
<v Leslie Goodloe>Those were awarded by Prosper Portland, CDI, or APLC.

207
00:22:30.416 --> 00:22:31.218
<v Leslie Goodloe>APLC, yes.

208
00:22:31.378 --> 00:22:32.772
<v Stephen Holt>Yes, Action Plan Leadership Committee.

209
00:22:32.902 --> 00:22:38.464
<v Leslie Goodloe>To support folks that made between 80% and 120% of AMI.

210
00:22:39.153 --> 00:22:48.949
<v Leslie Goodloe>We found that we had a lot of people that would fall at that 81%, 82%, and we couldn't serve them with our interstate TIF because of the requirements around the set-aside.

211
00:22:49.671 --> 00:22:54.640
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so we've been able to serve 20 families to become homeowners through Prosper Portland.

212
00:22:55.346 --> 00:22:57.893
<v Leslie Goodloe>2 Folks bought in Lentz, used Lentz TIF.

213
00:22:58.893 --> 00:23:01.858
<v Leslie Goodloe>Short-term rental was $100,000.

214
00:23:02.685 --> 00:23:05.894
<v Leslie Goodloe>15 Families were able to purchase outside the district.

215
00:23:06.266 --> 00:23:09.346
<v Leslie Goodloe>CET, construction excise tax, another 10.

216
00:23:10.022 --> 00:23:18.544
<v Leslie Goodloe>And then Olin, Kenton, both phases of Kenton, and then Culley Place were all subsidies that we put in.

217
00:23:18.737 --> 00:23:23.958
<v Leslie Goodloe>Those are permanently affordable projects that we were able to support people becoming homeowners.

218
00:23:26.280 --> 00:23:33.595
<v Leslie Goodloe>Additionally, with the projects and the homeownership, we created an asset preservation program.

219
00:23:34.381 --> 00:23:51.432
<v Leslie Goodloe>This was developed on a recommendation from the Oversight Committee to assist seniors and homeowners at 80% AMI and below to preserve generational wealth by providing wills, trusts, estate planning, and other legal services to keep homes in their families.

220
00:23:52.189 --> 00:23:59.673
<v Leslie Goodloe>The program is administered through AAH, African American Alliance for Homeownership, and the Commons Law Center.

221
00:24:00.970 --> 00:24:13.798
<v Leslie Goodloe>Additionally, Portland Housing Center created a post-purchase support program that provides ongoing education, coaching, and resources to new homeowners, helping families successfully sustain homeownership long after closing.

222
00:24:16.241 --> 00:24:20.890
<v Leslie Goodloe>This map shows where our preference policy buyers have been able to purchase.

223
00:24:20.971 --> 00:24:29.169
<v Leslie Goodloe>You can see we have folks There's a concentration within the district, but also people that have been able to purchase in Southeast and in Lentz.

224
00:24:30.859 --> 00:24:36.743
<v Leslie Goodloe>Creating rental homes, by far the largest funds— amount of funds that we've spent.

225
00:24:37.853 --> 00:24:40.265
<v Leslie Goodloe>We originally had a goal of 40 to 80 units.

226
00:24:40.346 --> 00:24:53.201
<v Leslie Goodloe>We had 2 pieces of property originally called the Grant Warehouse, which is where Beatrice Morrow is, and then the project of King Parks was The other piece of property that we were able to build.

227
00:24:54.880 --> 00:24:59.144
<v Leslie Goodloe>And today we have 965 units in production or open.

228
00:25:00.019 --> 00:25:18.920
<v Leslie Goodloe>We've spent $55 million in interstate TIF, $111, almost $112 million in total sources of PHB subsidy, which has produced— or total financing for 965 units, $414 million.

229
00:25:18.968 --> 00:25:19.371
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

230
00:25:19.890 --> 00:25:27.903
<v Leslie Goodloe>So the city's funds have gone— have leveraged a significant amount of revenue from other places.

231
00:25:31.223 --> 00:25:35.057
<v Leslie Goodloe>This is an overview of the rental homes that we've purchased or built.

232
00:25:35.788 --> 00:25:39.198
<v Leslie Goodloe>We have 12 buildings right now, 975 units.

233
00:25:39.603 --> 00:25:43.135
<v Leslie Goodloe>740 Of those units are preference policy units.

234
00:25:44.301 --> 00:25:53.730
<v Leslie Goodloe>Bedrooms, we have 105 studios, 349 1-bedroom, 357 2-bedroom, and 154 3-bedrooms.

235
00:25:54.548 --> 00:26:03.426
<v Leslie Goodloe>When we started the strategy, we wanted to ensure that we were building family-sized units, as that was a significant priority of the people that participated in the forums.

236
00:26:04.325 --> 00:26:08.715
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so 53% of the units built to date have— are 2 or 3 bedrooms.

237
00:26:10.095 --> 00:26:19.076
<v Leslie Goodloe>Income— rent and income levels, we have 202 units at 30%, 109 units at 50%, And 631 units at 60%.

238
00:26:20.143 --> 00:26:25.219
<v Leslie Goodloe>Additionally, we have 108 project-based vouchers in the buildings.

239
00:26:27.757 --> 00:26:29.243
<v Leslie Goodloe>I'm not going to go into a lot of detail.

240
00:26:29.356 --> 00:26:42.945
<v Leslie Goodloe>This just gives you an individual overview of each building, how much PHB funds went in, what was leveraged, the total development cost, and then the number of units of each size and AMI.

241
00:26:43.171 --> 00:26:43.299
<v Stephen Holt>Thank you.

242
00:26:46.442 --> 00:26:56.614
<v Leslie Goodloe>One of the biggest issues that we found over the course, particularly of the last 5 years and since COVID is that the area median income continues to increase in Portland.

243
00:26:57.272 --> 00:27:05.097
<v Leslie Goodloe>Part of the biggest issue is that they include homeowners and renters in the creation of the AMI across the country.

244
00:27:05.226 --> 00:27:09.628
<v Leslie Goodloe>But in Portland, there's a significant difference between homeowners' and renters' incomes.

245
00:27:11.170 --> 00:27:17.576
<v Leslie Goodloe>The first chart, you can see that blue line, that's 100% of the area median income through 2025.

246
00:27:18.490 --> 00:27:23.500
<v Leslie Goodloe>The kind of goldish-greenish color, uh, that is the 80% line.

247
00:27:24.896 --> 00:27:34.673
<v Leslie Goodloe>The, um, gray-blue line is the 60% AMI, and then the orange line is the median income for Black and African American households in Portland.

248
00:27:35.508 --> 00:27:46.655
<v Leslie Goodloe>So you can see that folks that qualify for the most preference points are not even able to afford a 60% unit, which is primarily what we have built.

249
00:27:48.119 --> 00:27:57.958
<v Leslie Goodloe>The second chart shows the— the bars across show the income available for rent.

250
00:27:58.765 --> 00:28:03.673
<v Leslie Goodloe>The orange line shows what the AMI rent would be for a household of 3.

251
00:28:03.866 --> 00:28:03.914
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

252
00:28:04.606 --> 00:28:16.534
<v Leslie Goodloe>And then that bottom blue-gray shows the amount of rent burden that African American families are currently experiencing, given the current AMI and the rents.

253
00:28:16.971 --> 00:28:19.290
<v Stephen Holt>Give them a specific example on one of those.

254
00:28:20.948 --> 00:28:21.663
<v Leslie Goodloe>Let me see.

255
00:28:22.509 --> 00:28:33.125
<v Leslie Goodloe>So in 2024, the rent was— the average rent was a little more— was about $1,250 a month.

256
00:28:33.895 --> 00:28:42.663
<v Leslie Goodloe>The average income was less than that, and their rent burden about $400 a month.

257
00:28:43.765 --> 00:28:45.256
<v Leslie Goodloe>So that was for 2025.

258
00:28:46.536 --> 00:28:49.224
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you.

259
00:28:51.277 --> 00:28:52.213
<v Leslie Goodloe>Land acquisition.

260
00:28:52.407 --> 00:28:57.931
<v Leslie Goodloe>We're very proud to say we were able to purchase several piece— couple piece of property.

261
00:28:57.979 --> 00:28:59.674
<v Leslie Goodloe>We had one donated by Kaiser.

262
00:29:00.205 --> 00:29:03.909
<v Leslie Goodloe>All of these properties have been developed or are in development.

263
00:29:04.374 --> 00:29:07.627
<v Leslie Goodloe>Dr. Darrell Milner was a property that opened last year.

264
00:29:08.237 --> 00:29:11.363
<v Leslie Goodloe>The Strong site, we just did the grand opening a couple of weeks ago.

265
00:29:12.404 --> 00:29:20.324
<v Leslie Goodloe>The Water Bureau property, formerly known as Cary Boulevard, True North, they just financially closed last week.

266
00:29:21.045 --> 00:29:27.601
<v Leslie Goodloe>And the Kaiser Permanente site, we are doing the grand opening for that project later in the summer.

267
00:29:28.273 --> 00:29:35.001
<v Leslie Goodloe>We spent just over $12 million purchasing land For the first— in the first 10 years.

268
00:29:35.355 --> 00:29:39.203
<v Leslie Goodloe>We don't have any plans to purchase anymore because we're running out of TIF money right now.

269
00:29:40.170 --> 00:29:45.778
<v Leslie Goodloe>But if something were to come along and we had funds available, we would continue to support land banking.

270
00:29:48.780 --> 00:29:51.282
<v Leslie Goodloe>So the preference policy, there are 2 pieces to it.

271
00:29:51.412 --> 00:29:59.488
<v Leslie Goodloe>One is the rental portion, which is open continuous, so anyone can go into the portal and apply at any particular time.

272
00:30:00.057 --> 00:30:12.436
<v Leslie Goodloe>They're able to adjust, pick from different addresses based on their parent, grandparent, or guardian, where they lived, and then also where the applicant has lived.

273
00:30:13.778 --> 00:30:21.023
<v Leslie Goodloe>For example, we moved— I moved 11 times between the time we moved to Portland and when I graduated from high school.

274
00:30:22.915 --> 00:30:40.038
<v Leslie Goodloe>And using any one of those addresses for my parents' address and then my address, which I live in the district, I could get up to 6 If you've had a home taken or your family had a home taken by eminent domain, you have top priority and basically you have 7 points.

275
00:30:40.391 --> 00:30:41.913
<v Leslie Goodloe>So you always would be at the top.

276
00:30:42.619 --> 00:30:52.465
<v Leslie Goodloe>So the first chart shows the applications in 2025, the racial demographics of the folks that applied in 2025.

277
00:30:53.042 --> 00:31:01.538
<v Leslie Goodloe>And then the second chart shows overall the racial demographics of folks that have applied Total.

278
00:31:02.118 --> 00:31:13.058
<v Leslie Goodloe>And then for homeownership, we have had the portal open 4 times to select folks to be in the pipeline to become new homeowners.

279
00:31:13.897 --> 00:31:21.576
<v Leslie Goodloe>We've had just about 4,000 people apply, and of those, everyone didn't certify.

280
00:31:22.380 --> 00:31:26.805
<v Leslie Goodloe>So for example, in 2024, we opened the portal, we had about 1,000 people apply.

281
00:31:27.063 --> 00:31:27.095
<v Steve Novick>Wow.

282
00:31:27.637 --> 00:31:33.858
<v Leslie Goodloe>Only about 400 of those people verified their preference points by bringing the documentation.

283
00:31:34.865 --> 00:31:37.511
<v Leslie Goodloe>So 400 folks went into the pipeline.

284
00:31:37.900 --> 00:31:50.340
<v Leslie Goodloe>We have 600 people that we are likely going to reach back out to this year and see— give them another opportunity to verify their preference points before we would open the list up again.

285
00:31:53.546 --> 00:32:00.739
<v Leslie Goodloe>One of the things that was a collaboration between the preference policy team and our renter services team was a moving assistance program.

286
00:32:02.215 --> 00:32:14.000
<v Leslie Goodloe>Funds were allocated out of RSO dollars to assist families moving into preference policy buildings with moving costs that sometimes are a burden for people to be able to move.

287
00:32:14.112 --> 00:32:27.529
<v Leslie Goodloe>So those things like paying deposits, security deposits, pet deposits, Trucks, moving assistance, childcare, paying old light bills, those kinds of things to help people move.

288
00:32:27.609 --> 00:32:30.433
<v Leslie Goodloe>So we were able to give up to $1,000.

289
00:32:31.670 --> 00:32:33.018
<v Leslie Goodloe>We served 48 families.

290
00:32:33.289 --> 00:32:37.301
<v Leslie Goodloe>75% Of them were at 30% AMI or below.

291
00:32:38.039 --> 00:32:44.538
<v Leslie Goodloe>60% Had families— families had a female head of household, and 89% identified as BIPOC.

292
00:32:45.566 --> 00:32:52.391
<v Leslie Goodloe>And you can see that How the, the program allocated funds.

293
00:32:53.134 --> 00:33:10.092
<v Leslie Goodloe>For the most part, because we were having some challenges with our rental partners, a lot of funds went to rent as opposed to security deposits because they weren't able to do it quick enough to before people moved in.

294
00:33:10.189 --> 00:33:13.813
<v Leslie Goodloe>So we were able to provide credits on folks' rent.

295
00:33:13.862 --> 00:33:14.038
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you.

296
00:33:14.582 --> 00:33:17.594
<v Leslie Goodloe>Role as opposed to the moving expenses.

297
00:33:19.352 --> 00:33:21.007
<v Leslie Goodloe>And right, and we've ended the pilot.

298
00:33:21.167 --> 00:33:29.528
<v Leslie Goodloe>We're going to be working on evaluating it for the rest of this year and deciding whether or not we want to reinstitute it next year.

299
00:33:32.076 --> 00:33:33.578
<v Leslie Goodloe>Communications and outreach.

300
00:33:34.579 --> 00:33:36.388
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thanks to Gwen, who's in the room.

301
00:33:36.501 --> 00:33:39.780
<v Leslie Goodloe>She has done an amazing job with our North Northeast newsletter.

302
00:33:39.829 --> 00:33:39.959
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you.

303
00:33:41.376 --> 00:33:42.630
<v Leslie Goodloe>We publish it quarterly.

304
00:33:43.852 --> 00:33:48.736
<v Leslie Goodloe>We're reaching on average 4,000 people with 3 issues.

305
00:33:48.833 --> 00:33:51.323
<v Leslie Goodloe>We also have a great team doing social media.

306
00:33:51.420 --> 00:33:54.038
<v Leslie Goodloe>Gabriel's also in the room.

307
00:33:54.457 --> 00:34:01.382
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so we reached about 2,000 folks during 2025 on our social media posts.

308
00:34:02.088 --> 00:34:17.025
<v Leslie Goodloe>And then we have PHB staff that regularly attend community events Sharing information about the housing strategy, the preference policy, our home repair programs, and renter services, and a variety of other programs.

309
00:34:18.690 --> 00:34:25.018
<v Leslie Goodloe>And now I'm going to turn it back over to Dr. Holt to wrap up and then have time for questions.

310
00:34:25.869 --> 00:34:26.322
<v Stephen Holt>Thank you very much.

311
00:34:26.402 --> 00:34:29.652
<v Stephen Holt>If you'd bring up my recommendations page.

312
00:34:30.170 --> 00:34:31.253
<v Stephen Holt>Yes, thank you very much.

313
00:34:32.528 --> 00:34:36.219
<v Stephen Holt>Just want to emphasize 975 doors for rental opportunities.

314
00:34:36.880 --> 00:34:37.605
<v Stephen Holt>That's pretty phenomenal.

315
00:34:38.329 --> 00:34:44.016
<v Stephen Holt>And then 130 homeowners, people who now own their homes who would not have been able to.

316
00:34:44.402 --> 00:34:49.516
<v Stephen Holt>And by the time the strategy is done, there will be 200 homeowners out of the strategy.

317
00:34:49.972 --> 00:34:51.744
<v Stephen Holt>That feels to me like something worth celebrating.

318
00:34:52.199 --> 00:34:52.704
<v Stephen Holt>I'm going to clap.

319
00:34:56.313 --> 00:34:57.086
<v Stephen Holt>I think it's amazing.

320
00:34:57.507 --> 00:34:57.748
<v Stephen Holt>I do.

321
00:34:57.846 --> 00:35:01.492
<v Stephen Holt>I think it's phenomenal what has happened in 10 years.

322
00:35:01.541 --> 00:35:01.976
<v Stephen Holt>A lot can happen.

323
00:35:02.871 --> 00:35:03.481
<v Stephen Holt>In 10 years.

324
00:35:04.219 --> 00:35:06.079
<v Stephen Holt>And this is pretty big.

325
00:35:06.143 --> 00:35:17.273
<v Stephen Holt>I think it's the kind of thing that offers a blueprint for strategy, an authentic example that now has been proven through testing and time that it produces.

326
00:35:18.170 --> 00:35:24.137
<v Stephen Holt>We can talk about ideas and come up with theories and concepts, but we don't know that they'll work.

327
00:35:24.922 --> 00:35:28.610
<v Stephen Holt>We've got something that has grit, that has data.

328
00:35:28.675 --> 00:35:28.835
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

329
00:35:29.175 --> 00:35:34.985
<v Stephen Holt>That's moved families, that's moved people, and the issue has not by any means began to abate.

330
00:35:35.099 --> 00:35:39.414
<v Stephen Holt>It's not getting better, it's becoming more challenging.

331
00:35:39.527 --> 00:35:40.965
<v Stephen Holt>The Delta has only increased.

332
00:35:41.384 --> 00:36:01.059
<v Stephen Holt>And as Councilor Avalos started by talking about our current federal leadership— I'm sitting here patriotic today— as we talk about our federal leadership, we here locally have to do Something intentional, strategic, purposeful, and we have a blueprint that we could use.

333
00:36:01.608 --> 00:36:07.027
<v Stephen Holt>I'd love to be a part of strategy and love to be a part of something that builds for long term.

334
00:36:07.606 --> 00:36:13.278
<v Stephen Holt>So we recommend aligning affordability with actual household conditions.

335
00:36:13.538 --> 00:36:18.121
<v Stephen Holt>You heard, you saw the data, especially for folks who look like me.

336
00:36:18.476 --> 00:36:21.409
<v Stephen Holt>The numbers of— in terms of revenue is decreasing.

337
00:36:21.458 --> 00:36:21.539
<v Stephen Holt>Yes.

338
00:36:22.393 --> 00:36:23.884
<v Stephen Holt>While expense is increasing.

339
00:36:24.557 --> 00:36:25.793
<v Stephen Holt>30% Units, great.

340
00:36:25.920 --> 00:36:31.581
<v Stephen Holt>We almost need 20% units, 10%, 40% for sure units.

341
00:36:31.853 --> 00:36:32.655
<v Stephen Holt>How do we do that?

342
00:36:33.360 --> 00:36:35.909
<v Stephen Holt>Requires some strategy, some thinking, some intentionality.

343
00:36:36.985 --> 00:36:39.646
<v Stephen Holt>Expanding and adapting pathways to homeownership.

344
00:36:39.710 --> 00:36:49.235
<v Stephen Holt>One of the biggest things that creates wealth or creates opportunity or creates family stability, health, wellness for the community is homeownership.

345
00:36:49.572 --> 00:36:50.583
<v Stephen Holt>It reduces crime.

346
00:36:51.885 --> 00:36:54.742
<v Stephen Holt>It encourages and increases educational retention.

347
00:36:55.514 --> 00:36:58.532
<v Stephen Holt>It improves and empowers people around careers.

348
00:36:58.726 --> 00:37:06.594
<v Stephen Holt>We know, those of us who live or spend any time in this space, the significance of what happens when people can actually own versus rent.

349
00:37:07.541 --> 00:37:10.994
<v Stephen Holt>Now, we've done a great job with 975 rental units.

350
00:37:11.652 --> 00:37:16.230
<v Stephen Holt>I'm excited about 200 homeowners, but I think we need to bolster that.

351
00:37:16.293 --> 00:37:16.407
<v Stephen Holt>Thank you.

352
00:37:17.418 --> 00:37:26.545
<v Stephen Holt>Finding ways to help people secure what is, I think, a human right— stable housing, safe housing, affordable housing.

353
00:37:27.699 --> 00:37:31.389
<v Stephen Holt>I think that's something that we should spend some real time thinking through.

354
00:37:32.577 --> 00:37:35.047
<v Stephen Holt>Strengthening and recalibrating our retention programs.

355
00:37:35.320 --> 00:37:38.143
<v Stephen Holt>It's great enough to get people in, but we got to keep folks there.

356
00:37:38.753 --> 00:37:40.693
<v Stephen Holt>How do we create some pathways around them?

357
00:37:40.757 --> 00:37:43.710
<v Stephen Holt>When, when Mayor Hales and I began this conversation Yes.

358
00:37:43.806 --> 00:37:47.956
<v Stephen Holt>Years ago, one of the things I talked about wasn't just getting people in space.

359
00:37:48.565 --> 00:37:54.525
<v Stephen Holt>It was also those who had the opportunity to build the spaces or be involved in the renovation of those spaces.

360
00:37:54.878 --> 00:37:56.447
<v Stephen Holt>Those are economic drivers.

361
00:37:56.545 --> 00:37:58.050
<v Stephen Holt>Those are possibilities.

362
00:37:58.563 --> 00:38:01.543
<v Stephen Holt>And then how do we engage with community around these spaces?

363
00:38:01.608 --> 00:38:07.905
<v Stephen Holt>What good is it to move people into a neighborhood where the neighborhood doesn't want them, where they can't shop, they can't live?

364
00:38:08.898 --> 00:38:11.579
<v Stephen Holt>It's so much more than just Place.

365
00:38:11.713 --> 00:38:13.014
<v Stephen Holt>It's also space.

366
00:38:14.688 --> 00:38:18.117
<v Stephen Holt>Then establish clear accountability for building operations.

367
00:38:18.181 --> 00:38:19.518
<v Stephen Holt>We've run into some challenges.

368
00:38:19.614 --> 00:38:20.516
<v Stephen Holt>We talked about that.

369
00:38:20.757 --> 00:38:22.608
<v Stephen Holt>You've seen it in the report.

370
00:38:22.994 --> 00:38:37.827
<v Stephen Holt>How do we make sure that the people who are moving in benefit from the investment so that they're safe, so that their stuff that's delivered to them is safe, no one is stealing their items, and other people aren't getting into these protected, uh, communities?

371
00:38:38.539 --> 00:38:39.797
<v Stephen Holt>How do we think about that?

372
00:38:39.911 --> 00:38:47.916
<v Stephen Holt>What are the other support systems that can be put in place to ensure that when the family goes home, they're safe being home?

373
00:38:49.847 --> 00:38:53.648
<v Stephen Holt>Increase Black workforce participation with measurable outcomes.

374
00:38:53.695 --> 00:38:56.385
<v Stephen Holt>That's such a big conversation.

375
00:38:56.498 --> 00:39:00.621
<v Stephen Holt>That is such a broad and nuanced kind of concentration.

376
00:39:00.976 --> 00:39:07.277
<v Stephen Holt>There's so much associated with the trades and perspectives around the trades or understanding or lack of understanding.

377
00:39:07.592 --> 00:39:08.748
<v Stephen Holt>As it goes to the trades.

378
00:39:08.797 --> 00:39:17.534
<v Stephen Holt>And it's something that we've seen as we've done this work trying to create opportunities to sustain and bolster and build these young business owners.

379
00:39:18.036 --> 00:39:24.505
<v Stephen Holt>And then the barriers that they have to overcome from insurance, from procurement, from— the list goes on and on.

380
00:39:25.159 --> 00:39:30.509
<v Stephen Holt>We've got to figure out some ways to help people grow and be successful with this incredible investment.

381
00:39:32.135 --> 00:39:35.443
<v Stephen Holt>And then maintain and strengthen the North Northeast Preference Policy.

382
00:39:36.945 --> 00:39:38.920
<v Stephen Holt>I don't know of any other strategy.

383
00:39:39.114 --> 00:39:45.407
<v Stephen Holt>In fact, there is no other strategy in the nation that has accomplished what this has accomplished.

384
00:39:45.697 --> 00:39:57.369
<v Stephen Holt>There is no other example in the nation, right here in Portland, a preference policy upheld by HUD as an example of an equitable process for restorative investment.

385
00:39:58.702 --> 00:40:00.228
<v Stephen Holt>We got to strengthen that and expand it.

386
00:40:00.469 --> 00:40:07.639
<v Stephen Holt>We have An incredible opportunity, and I'm excited about what we can do if we'll use the blueprint.

387
00:40:07.800 --> 00:40:10.235
<v Stephen Holt>We'll dig in and go to work.

388
00:40:13.157 --> 00:40:15.900
<v Stephen Holt>Um, questions, comments, thoughts?

389
00:40:18.329 --> 00:40:18.362
<v Vicki Payne>Hi.

390
00:40:19.150 --> 00:40:20.275
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you all.

391
00:40:20.628 --> 00:40:23.717
<v Candace Avalos>So yes, it looks like we've got some folks in the queue.

392
00:40:24.536 --> 00:40:28.302
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I had my hand up, but I'm going to put it at the end.

393
00:40:28.351 --> 00:40:30.554
<v Candace Avalos>So let's just hear from committee, and then I'll offer my questions and comments.

394
00:40:30.603 --> 00:40:31.155
<v Candace Avalos>So let's kick it off with Councilor Novick.

395
00:40:34.277 --> 00:40:34.967
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

396
00:40:35.480 --> 00:40:43.478
<v Steve Novick>I've got some questions about the rental end of things, one of which is we've heard a lot about vacancies in affordable rental housing.

397
00:40:44.311 --> 00:40:52.262
<v Steve Novick>Do you know what the vacancy rate is of rental properties established under the preference policy compared to vacancies in affordable rental housing citywide?

398
00:40:53.224 --> 00:40:55.018
<v Leslie Goodloe>It's probably about the same.

399
00:40:55.291 --> 00:41:07.521
<v Leslie Goodloe>We have had same kinds of issues in getting people into units As I mentioned earlier, 60% unit is just— it's about market rate, and particularly in Northeast Portland.

400
00:41:08.594 --> 00:41:18.981
<v Leslie Goodloe>It's— if you can get a studio for $1,000 on the market, why would you pay $1,000 at an affordable building and have to jump through 99 hoops in order to get it?

401
00:41:19.719 --> 00:41:21.914
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so there's, there's a couple of pieces there.

402
00:41:21.978 --> 00:41:30.347
<v Leslie Goodloe>Again, the rents are just high, and then the amount of work that you have to do to get into an affordable building is just It's just a lot of work.

403
00:41:30.492 --> 00:41:34.123
<v Leslie Goodloe>So it's about equivalent to other places in town.

404
00:41:34.894 --> 00:41:38.639
<v Stephen Holt>And if I could jump in, I would say the other item I just was talking to, it's affordability.

405
00:41:39.393 --> 00:41:43.458
<v Stephen Holt>It's just the reality of what folks are genuinely making.

406
00:41:44.373 --> 00:41:53.612
<v Stephen Holt>And so our issue is how do we help create economic opportunities for those who have been impacted?

407
00:41:53.693 --> 00:41:58.666
<v Stephen Holt>And I will just, for the sake of Making— landing my plane with, with data.

408
00:41:59.467 --> 00:42:12.445
<v Stephen Holt>There are 400,000 individuals who've lost jobs that once held jobs because of the removal of DEI in our nation.

409
00:42:12.766 --> 00:42:22.108
<v Stephen Holt>That has had direct impact here in our city, and I won't go into specific detail, but it's had direct impact on my own business with that adjustment.

410
00:42:22.172 --> 00:42:22.909
<v Stephen Holt>So it's affordability.

411
00:42:22.972 --> 00:42:23.085
<v Diego>Thank you.

412
00:42:24.806 --> 00:42:36.007
<v Steve Novick>Along the lines of like the hoops, what's the average length of time it takes for an applicant for rental housing under the preference policy to get into an apartment from initial application submission to moving in?

413
00:42:38.597 --> 00:42:46.914
<v Leslie Goodloe>I think it will vary based on what kinds of requirements each building has, whether they're LIHTC, whether they have HUD requirements.

414
00:42:47.710 --> 00:42:49.405
<v Leslie Goodloe>So each of those are going to be slightly different.

415
00:42:49.876 --> 00:42:52.726
<v Leslie Goodloe>If the— depending upon what the requirements are.

416
00:42:53.355 --> 00:42:56.913
<v Leslie Goodloe>But once somebody gets on the list, we make referrals.

417
00:42:56.976 --> 00:43:05.068
<v Leslie Goodloe>So if, like today, I sent out a list for M. Carter Commons, 22 names, they have several units available that they're still trying to get leased.

418
00:43:05.617 --> 00:43:16.525
<v Leslie Goodloe>It will take anywhere from 2 weeks to a month for someone to get through the process of getting into a unit where they're fully approved.

419
00:43:16.934 --> 00:43:19.402
<v Leslie Goodloe>It just depends on if they've got all their documentation together.

420
00:43:19.467 --> 00:43:19.597
<v Steve Novick>Right.

421
00:43:20.771 --> 00:43:25.204
<v Leslie Goodloe>You know, their income statements, if they don't have anything bad on their credit.

422
00:43:26.030 --> 00:43:31.317
<v Leslie Goodloe>So there's a variety of factors that go into how long it takes someone to get into an affordable unit.

423
00:43:32.806 --> 00:43:39.813
<v Steve Novick>Actually, do you refer people to just one provider or do you just give them sort of like a referral that could be used with any?

424
00:43:40.393 --> 00:43:50.762
<v Leslie Goodloe>So once you get on the list and you would specify that you would like So, Councilor Novick, you say, I want a 2-bedroom, there's 3 of us.

425
00:43:51.260 --> 00:43:55.905
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so anytime there's a 2-bedroom unit available, you would get referred.

426
00:43:56.371 --> 00:44:04.719
<v Leslie Goodloe>And based on where you are on the list, they may get to you or they may not, because there may be 100 people ahead of you on the list that are also looking for a 2-bedroom.

427
00:44:05.360 --> 00:44:21.958
<v Leslie Goodloe>So when they get to you, then they say, hey Steve, you're interested in a 2-bedroom, here's all the things, here's the application, all the things that you would need to So it's both how many preference points you have and then where you are on the list that determine when you get referred to a building.

428
00:44:22.103 --> 00:44:26.876
<v Leslie Goodloe>But you would get referred, continue to get referred until you get into a building that you want to be in.

429
00:44:27.054 --> 00:44:32.148
<v Leslie Goodloe>We have had people start out in one preference policy building and then move into another.

430
00:44:33.541 --> 00:44:40.608
<v Leslie Goodloe>When Dr. Daryl Milner opened, they have washers and dryers in the units, and most affordable rental buildings don't.

431
00:44:40.751 --> 00:44:40.992
<v Leslie Goodloe>Mm-hmm.

432
00:44:41.072 --> 00:44:52.494
<v Leslie Goodloe>But because that was originally a condo project, They were built with washers and dryers, so we had a lot of people move from other buildings into Dr. Darryl Milner so that they'd have their own washer and dryer.

433
00:44:53.963 --> 00:44:56.666
<v Steve Novick>Do you know how many households are on the waitlist for rental housing?

434
00:44:57.405 --> 00:44:57.952
<v Leslie Goodloe>On ours?

435
00:44:58.146 --> 00:45:00.351
<v Leslie Goodloe>Yeah.

436
00:45:02.978 --> 00:45:06.989
<v Leslie Goodloe>6-Point households to 0-point.

437
00:45:07.054 --> 00:45:09.295
<v Leslie Goodloe>So 0-point households are probably the largest.

438
00:45:10.556 --> 00:45:16.552
<v Leslie Goodloe>And let me see, I have it here in my book somewhere, through 2025.

439
00:45:16.969 --> 00:45:23.365
<v Steve Novick>And if you could remind us what zero-point household means.

440
00:45:23.574 --> 00:45:24.327
<v Leslie Goodloe>So, oh, I'm sorry.

441
00:45:24.423 --> 00:45:30.643
<v Leslie Goodloe>A zero-point household is somebody that lived outside of the area that you get points for.

442
00:45:31.076 --> 00:45:31.204
<v Leslie Goodloe>Okay.

443
00:45:31.268 --> 00:45:35.052
<v Leslie Goodloe>So there are 3 particular areas that you could get points for.

444
00:45:35.644 --> 00:45:48.501
<v Leslie Goodloe>One is the Interstate URA, one is the Albina Community Plan, and the other one is the There was an area that was designated as blighted by the city.

445
00:45:49.003 --> 00:45:56.411
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so depending upon where you lived within those 3 areas, you could get 3 points for yourself and up to 3 points for your parent, grandparent, or guardian.

446
00:45:57.072 --> 00:46:02.791
<v Leslie Goodloe>If you never lived in anywhere in Northeast Portland, you can still apply, but you would have 0 points.

447
00:46:02.969 --> 00:46:04.722
<v Leslie Goodloe>And of course, you're going to be at the bottom of the list.

448
00:46:04.802 --> 00:46:11.273
<v Leslie Goodloe>So we're going to continue to feed in 6 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 households before we get to the 0-point households.

449
00:46:11.961 --> 00:46:18.016
<v Leslie Goodloe>So for 2025, we had 1,639 people apply.

450
00:46:19.043 --> 00:46:28.494
<v Leslie Goodloe>So some of those folks have gotten into units, so they're not currently on the list, but we have somewhere between 1,000 and 1,500 people on the list at any given time on an active waitlist.

451
00:46:28.735 --> 00:46:30.481
<v Diego>Okay.

452
00:46:30.961 --> 00:46:38.090
<v Steve Novick>Do you have any way to have a direct connection between rent assistance funding and rental residents under the preference policy?

453
00:46:38.748 --> 00:46:39.840
<v Leslie Goodloe>No, we don't.

454
00:46:40.416 --> 00:46:46.320
<v Leslie Goodloe>We did— well, we did during COVID We had some HOME money that we designated for preference policy buildings.

455
00:46:46.737 --> 00:46:54.101
<v Leslie Goodloe>But since COVID and those federal dollars went away, we don't have any specific designation for funds for preference policy buildings.

456
00:46:54.454 --> 00:46:55.594
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

457
00:46:56.284 --> 00:47:02.572
<v Steve Novick>And do you track sort of outcomes for rental tenants under the preference policy, like evictions and turnover and things like that?

458
00:47:03.438 --> 00:47:20.597
<v Leslie Goodloe>We do through our— both through RSO tracks Evictions, and then our risk analysis team can track turnovers, but that's annually, and it's usually, you know, by the time we get the information, it's 15 to 16 months after.

459
00:47:20.855 --> 00:47:24.463
<v Leslie Goodloe>So it's not real live data.

460
00:47:25.809 --> 00:47:45.519
<v Leslie Goodloe>Once we are up and running with our community services database, we'll have better data of people moving out because we're going to be able to track units that people Thank you.

461
00:47:45.519 --> 00:47:48.179
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you, Councilor.

462
00:47:48.480 --> 00:47:52.550
<v Candace Avalos>Up next, uh, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

463
00:47:52.739 --> 00:47:57.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair, and thank you for making sure this was on the agenda today.

464
00:47:57.139 --> 00:48:15.358
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is such an important, um, program for us to elevate and make sure that sure we're doing the best we can to make sure that we're we don't just receive a report, but actually have a conversation about, you know, you've talked, Dr. Holt, about what will happen by the time the plan is done.

465
00:48:17.054 --> 00:48:19.731
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it was a little jarring for me to hear you say it that way.

466
00:48:19.829 --> 00:48:21.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I recognize this is a 10-year plan.

467
00:48:22.940 --> 00:48:28.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the strategy itself, that initial plan is done, or we're rounding it out.

468
00:48:28.688 --> 00:48:28.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

469
00:48:30.556 --> 00:48:31.568
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But the work can't be done, right?

470
00:48:32.547 --> 00:48:32.739
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right.

471
00:48:32.884 --> 00:48:34.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The work absolutely can't be done.

472
00:48:34.972 --> 00:49:01.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think those recommendations you had up there are so important because I hope that this is an opportunity for this council to recommit to the preference policy, to the North and Northeast Housing Strategy, and to the 1,000 people on the rental list, but also how many hundreds who still qualify to return to the opportunity for homeownership that was taken away from them.

473
00:49:03.762 --> 00:49:07.806
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I remember the events that created this work.

474
00:49:08.998 --> 00:49:20.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I was living very close to the lot under question that led to the real call for change and investment in the community and—.

475
00:49:20.748 --> 00:49:20.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

476
00:49:20.956 --> 00:49:24.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's been incredible to watch it come to realization.

477
00:49:24.824 --> 00:49:33.864
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know there was a lot of concern that that initial commitment would fizzle, that even with an oversight body, we wouldn't really see the results.

478
00:49:33.960 --> 00:49:42.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And to see those numbers that are 2, 3, 10 times the original goals in terms of the outcomes is incredible.

479
00:49:42.342 --> 00:49:50.914
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So thank you both, and thank you to everybody who's on that committee for pushing for this to stay part of the work that the city does.

480
00:49:51.268 --> 00:49:52.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

481
00:49:52.960 --> 00:49:54.378
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do have a couple of questions.

482
00:49:56.306 --> 00:50:11.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, the report itself says somewhere near the beginning that this didn't start as a housing solution, that this started as a way to prevent displacement, to restore wealth, right?

483
00:50:11.269 --> 00:50:15.518
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I forget the exact words, but it says very clearly that it didn't start as a housing solution.

484
00:50:15.568 --> 00:50:18.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And yet in many ways it has become a housing solution.

485
00:50:19.347 --> 00:50:29.728
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And when you put the slides up, I think it was slide 6 showed that almost half of the funding has been spent on rental development, which is very much a housing solution.

486
00:50:30.418 --> 00:50:33.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, it is in many ways anti-displacement.

487
00:50:33.231 --> 00:50:37.536
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, it is in many ways space-making and community-building.

488
00:50:37.795 --> 00:50:37.907
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

489
00:50:39.739 --> 00:50:41.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But it's not a restoration of wealth.

490
00:50:41.601 --> 00:50:43.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's not a repair for wealth that was taken away.

491
00:50:44.119 --> 00:50:44.568
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

492
00:50:44.952 --> 00:51:02.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I'm wondering if you can speak to the decision around the distribution of funding between the 4 strategies, looking at rentals, at homeownership, at the repair grants, and at the land banking.

493
00:51:03.561 --> 00:51:14.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How are decisions made about how much money is spent on each of those strategies, and why was the distribution of funds spent the way that it was?

494
00:51:15.447 --> 00:51:16.268
<v Stephen Holt>Excellent question.

495
00:51:16.431 --> 00:51:20.038
<v Stephen Holt>I'll respond first, and then, Ms. Galindo, unless you want to go first.

496
00:51:20.103 --> 00:51:20.746
<v Leslie Goodloe>Let me go first.

497
00:51:20.907 --> 00:51:21.166
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, let's—.

498
00:51:21.166 --> 00:51:24.001
<v Leslie Goodloe>Because I can give the technical part.

499
00:51:24.146 --> 00:51:24.324
<v Leslie Goodloe>Okay.

500
00:51:24.791 --> 00:51:40.778
<v Leslie Goodloe>So initially, when we had the $20 million, we asked the community to help us prioritize And the first priority was affordable rental because there was very little in Northeast Portland at that point.

501
00:51:41.641 --> 00:51:49.514
<v Leslie Goodloe>And then second was the homeowner, creating new homeowners, and then the retention.

502
00:51:50.726 --> 00:51:57.668
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so the first plan had no land banking, and the community came back and was like, no, you got to put some money in.

503
00:51:58.478 --> 00:52:04.280
<v Leslie Goodloe>Out of this $20 million to help to buy land now to develop it later.

504
00:52:04.764 --> 00:52:16.755
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so it was really just a kind of a proportional based on what it costs to build affordable rental and then what we could shape into.

505
00:52:16.820 --> 00:52:26.105
<v Leslie Goodloe>So it was originally $5 million for homeownership, $3 million for rental— I mean, for home repair.

506
00:52:26.643 --> 00:52:33.150
<v Leslie Goodloe>We put $3 million into the land banking, and then the remaining amount went into rental.

507
00:52:33.875 --> 00:52:42.532
<v Leslie Goodloe>Because again, we thought we were only going to do 2 buildings, and we could do 2 buildings with about $10, $12 million at that point.

508
00:52:44.536 --> 00:52:52.552
<v Leslie Goodloe>When the TIF lift happened, Commissioner Saltzman was like, nope, all of that money is going to go into the strategy.

509
00:52:52.648 --> 00:52:53.438
<v Leslie Goodloe>We're not going to separate.

510
00:52:54.663 --> 00:52:57.338
<v Leslie Goodloe>Buildings that may be across the street from each other.

511
00:52:57.889 --> 00:53:02.168
<v Leslie Goodloe>Anything that comes into interstate in the set-aside is now going to go into the housing strategy.

512
00:53:03.030 --> 00:53:10.887
<v Leslie Goodloe>So as we got additional funds, we worked with the committee to allocate how much more would go into each of those pools.

513
00:53:12.927 --> 00:53:20.139
<v Leslie Goodloe>The director at the time had promised some funds on the what's now Renaissance Commons.

514
00:53:20.186 --> 00:53:20.268
<v Leslie Goodloe>Yes.

515
00:53:21.958 --> 00:53:31.719
<v Leslie Goodloe>TriMet was doing an RFP for affordable housing, and we promised $10 million, which was a significant portion of the TIF lift.

516
00:53:31.784 --> 00:53:33.117
<v Leslie Goodloe>So it was $35 million.

517
00:53:34.179 --> 00:53:42.396
<v Leslie Goodloe>And then when we did the maximum indebtedness, we got another $35 million or so.

518
00:53:42.719 --> 00:53:44.059
<v Leslie Goodloe>You know, it's always estimated.

519
00:53:44.414 --> 00:53:49.708
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so we try to do kind of proportional based on those original goals and guidelines.

520
00:53:51.210 --> 00:53:53.617
<v Leslie Goodloe>Of, of how we were allocating the money.

521
00:53:56.780 --> 00:54:07.420
<v Leslie Goodloe>As part of that, we didn't think about, which now I know it's been a big issue with council, is how much goes into personnel, how much goes into M&S and to internal services.

522
00:54:08.003 --> 00:54:13.737
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so, you know, all of that comes off the top and then the remaining amount goes into programming.

523
00:54:14.536 --> 00:54:18.626
<v Leslie Goodloe>So that was the thought and how we at the bureau kind of looked at things.

524
00:54:18.690 --> 00:54:18.838
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

525
00:54:19.266 --> 00:54:27.088
<v Leslie Goodloe>We worked with the Oversight Committee to allocate those dollars in the best way that we could based on what the needs were at the time.

526
00:54:27.217 --> 00:54:28.900
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so I'll let Dr. Holt—.

527
00:54:29.300 --> 00:54:29.621
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

528
00:54:29.862 --> 00:54:33.838
<v Stephen Holt>Thanks for giving us the background and some of the technical pieces.

529
00:54:34.014 --> 00:54:35.440
<v Stephen Holt>I think that's an excellent question.

530
00:54:35.873 --> 00:54:42.398
<v Stephen Holt>From the onset, our heartbeat has been around wealth creation and creating opportunities.

531
00:54:42.510 --> 00:54:46.503
<v Stephen Holt>When I say wealth creation, that wasn't just Homeownership.

532
00:54:46.811 --> 00:54:58.858
<v Stephen Holt>I mentioned it kind of in passing, but it was also who had the opportunities to build the housing, who were the people that were the plumbers that were hired, the electricians that were hired, who was the general contractor, etc.

533
00:54:59.003 --> 00:55:02.777
<v Stephen Holt>All of the investment created a significant opportunity.

534
00:55:03.132 --> 00:55:04.324
<v Stephen Holt>And for us, it was trade-offs.

535
00:55:04.900 --> 00:55:05.670
<v Stephen Holt>And what I mean is trade-off.

536
00:55:05.798 --> 00:55:14.920
<v Stephen Holt>When I say that part of the affordable rental versus homeownership, which where the dollars get allocated, we have a host of people that want to move back into community.

537
00:55:14.960 --> 00:55:15.400
<v Stephen Holt>Right.

538
00:55:16.331 --> 00:55:26.778
<v Stephen Holt>They've lost a sense of connectivity, lost a sense of space, lost a sense of driving down the street and saying hi to your neighbors and being known in the areas where you grew up and played.

539
00:55:26.842 --> 00:55:28.094
<v Stephen Holt>That was my experience.

540
00:55:28.447 --> 00:55:30.663
<v Stephen Holt>We knew everybody in the neighborhood.

541
00:55:30.775 --> 00:55:37.643
<v Stephen Holt>And so if we think about the investment, what can we do that's going to get the most impact with the minimal dollars?

542
00:55:37.916 --> 00:55:42.938
<v Stephen Holt>And at that time, all we had in the initial space was the amount that was allocated.

543
00:55:43.679 --> 00:55:48.978
<v Stephen Holt>When the increase happened, we advocated for more homeownership opportunities.

544
00:55:49.396 --> 00:55:59.003
<v Stephen Holt>Now, based in leadership and, and who was in the space of decision-making, voices weren't always heard, but we certainly advocated for more opportunity.

545
00:55:59.083 --> 00:56:03.148
<v Stephen Holt>I mentioned in 10 years, 6, or is it 7 bureau directors?

546
00:56:03.684 --> 00:56:06.751
<v Stephen Holt>So different priorities with different leadership.

547
00:56:07.172 --> 00:56:08.032
<v Stephen Holt>So great question though.

548
00:56:08.903 --> 00:56:11.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let me follow up, if I may, Chair.

549
00:56:11.239 --> 00:56:14.572
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have a few more questions on a piece you just said there.

550
00:56:15.168 --> 00:56:15.940
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

551
00:56:17.681 --> 00:56:23.672
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That oversight committee and the community voices, even beyond the oversight committee.

552
00:56:23.978 --> 00:56:24.141
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

553
00:56:24.625 --> 00:56:36.329
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we were to ask you today, we've done the 10-year plan, we need to keep doing this moving forward, is our investment split right or do we need It's a great question.

554
00:56:36.554 --> 00:56:40.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you capture, at least from your perspective, what you think we'd hear?

555
00:56:40.945 --> 00:56:56.521
<v Stephen Holt>I think, uh, you would hear the same kind of thing that we heard initially, uh, and now that there's such a chasm, such a delta when it comes to affordability and income, the need for ownership has only, uh, increased.

556
00:56:57.050 --> 00:56:58.396
<v Stephen Holt>It's, it's expanded.

557
00:56:59.052 --> 00:57:10.882
<v Stephen Holt>Um, I think the work of Any group stepping into this space, you're challenged by resources, we're challenged by need, and we're challenged by a creative way to meet the two.

558
00:57:11.331 --> 00:57:12.777
<v Stephen Holt>What is the answer?

559
00:57:12.938 --> 00:57:19.617
<v Stephen Holt>And I know there's a lot of conversation around social housing and I don't want to diminish it and/or poo-poo it.

560
00:57:20.083 --> 00:57:31.532
<v Stephen Holt>It does not though, from my perspective, accomplish what really is a pressing need, and that is The stability of households, the stability of families, and the opportunity in front.

561
00:57:31.726 --> 00:57:37.523
<v Stephen Holt>So how we get there, no simple solutions, but I think it's certainly something that, that has to be prioritized.

562
00:57:37.844 --> 00:57:46.036
<v Stephen Holt>And I will say this, I have not always been the most popular guy because we've taken seriously promises made need to be promises kept.

563
00:57:46.775 --> 00:57:49.811
<v Stephen Holt>And so there are times when the challenge has been directed at the city.

564
00:57:50.052 --> 00:57:51.128
<v Stephen Holt>Wait a minute, this is what you said.

565
00:57:51.659 --> 00:57:52.237
<v Stephen Holt>This is what we do.

566
00:57:52.797 --> 00:57:54.333
<v Stephen Holt>This is what we're expecting to see happen.

567
00:57:54.592 --> 00:57:56.405
<v Stephen Holt>At times there's been challenge with the providers.

568
00:57:56.762 --> 00:57:58.315
<v Stephen Holt>You're going to have to do business differently.

569
00:57:59.050 --> 00:58:02.746
<v Stephen Holt>Things are there in terms of stepping up and caring for the back end.

570
00:58:03.405 --> 00:58:15.923
<v Stephen Holt>My goal and my commitment is that the people who don't have the voice, the people who haven't had the opportunity to be in this space of advocacy, are getting the opportunity to be cared for the way we should.

571
00:58:15.987 --> 00:58:17.275
<v Stephen Holt>It's just the right thing to do.

572
00:58:17.985 --> 00:58:31.476
<v Leslie Goodloe>So Councilor, I'll just add, I think one of the most important things is, as the TIF dollars are going away in Interstate, all of the other districts, the new districts are working on their plan.

573
00:58:31.590 --> 00:58:32.766
<v Leslie Goodloe>We just finished the Culley plan.

574
00:58:33.360 --> 00:58:36.862
<v Leslie Goodloe>They have prioritized homeownership in the first 5-year plan.

575
00:58:37.554 --> 00:59:03.389
<v Leslie Goodloe>But having other resources that can be used outside the districts has been And paramount to this, us being successful, and I will credit Shannon Callahan, who was the director back in 2018, who decided to use some construction excise tax and the short-term rental to provide opportunity for preference policy households to be able to purchase outside the district.

576
00:59:04.003 --> 00:59:07.873
<v Leslie Goodloe>Interstate is one of the most expensive neighborhoods in Portland.

577
00:59:08.391 --> 00:59:08.489
<v Leslie Goodloe>Yeah.

578
00:59:10.237 --> 00:59:16.695
<v Leslie Goodloe>I purchased my house in 1995 for $77,000, and now it appraises at $715,000.

579
00:59:16.775 --> 00:59:21.467
<v Leslie Goodloe>It's the same 1,190-square-foot house on a 5,000-square-foot lot.

580
00:59:22.367 --> 00:59:27.106
<v Leslie Goodloe>And, you know, my homeowner taxes, you know, of course are ridiculous.

581
00:59:27.443 --> 00:59:37.969
<v Leslie Goodloe>But just that shows you how much has changed in that neighborhood where the average price when we started was like $300,000 less than $300,000.

582
00:59:37.969 --> 00:59:42.670
<v Leslie Goodloe>Now it's $600,000 or $700,000 to purchase within the district.

583
00:59:42.670 --> 00:59:49.590
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so, um, to combat that, we have increased the, um, down payment assistance 4 times.

584
00:59:49.590 --> 00:59:59.550
<v Leslie Goodloe>It increased from $60,000, now it's $150,000 within the district to help people have a little more to be able to combat, you know, cash offers on houses.

585
00:59:59.789 --> 01:00:12.224
<v Leslie Goodloe>Um, so I'll, I'll just say having Resources available out of whatever funding sources we've got to be able to support homeownership is really the key to continuing this.

586
01:00:14.213 --> 01:00:23.443
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to ask about one other piece of the work, and before I do that, I'll say I really appreciate your frankness about where we're at and what we need.

587
01:00:25.469 --> 01:00:32.101
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The repair grants, that's a piece that I think I heard a lot about when this work started.

588
01:00:32.280 --> 01:00:32.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mm-hmm.

589
01:00:33.217 --> 01:00:39.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I don't actually know how much funding we're still putting toward that at this point in the program.

590
01:00:40.021 --> 01:00:42.168
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that still an active part of the program?

591
01:00:42.362 --> 01:00:43.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is it enough?

592
01:00:44.057 --> 01:00:50.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is it a part of the program that could also benefit from further investment, or are we at the right level?

593
01:00:51.730 --> 01:01:04.601
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And are we doing enough to prioritize The jobs, the work, the things that will help fewer people need the supports of the program in the future as we do the repair grant side.

594
01:01:05.590 --> 01:01:12.326
<v Leslie Goodloe>So we still have TIF money available for home repair grants and loans in the district.

595
01:01:12.585 --> 01:01:14.739
<v Leslie Goodloe>We've probably got enough for the next couple years.

596
01:01:16.766 --> 01:01:24.210
<v Leslie Goodloe>And one of the things that the oversight committee has considered is whether to increase the grant amount Because things cost a lot more.

597
01:01:24.210 --> 01:01:31.610
<v Leslie Goodloe>It's been $10,000 for the entire time that we've been doing this, and $10,000 can do a lot.

598
01:01:31.610 --> 01:01:39.739
<v Leslie Goodloe>But if your roof needs to be repaired, if you've got significant electrical, if you've got plumbing issues, you know, you're not going to get that done with $10,000.

599
01:01:40.110 --> 01:01:42.369
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm looking at a roof repair right now on my house.

600
01:01:42.369 --> 01:01:44.190
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know you will not get that done with $10,000.

601
01:01:44.929 --> 01:01:48.190
<v Leslie Goodloe>But we have been able to keep a lot of seniors in their homes.

602
01:01:48.190 --> 01:01:59.505
<v Leslie Goodloe>My neighbor, for example, She's 88 years old, and through a home repair grant, they replaced her front steps because she could not get out of her house because the steps were rotten.

603
01:02:00.003 --> 01:02:07.614
<v Leslie Goodloe>They fixed her sidewalk so she didn't get fines from the city for having cracked sidewalk, as we know happens with people.

604
01:02:08.594 --> 01:02:12.190
<v Leslie Goodloe>They were able to weatherize so that her house will stay warm.

605
01:02:13.668 --> 01:02:21.885
<v Leslie Goodloe>There's— those are the kinds of things that are keeping seniors in home and not having to go into way more expensive care.

606
01:02:24.302 --> 01:02:32.786
<v Leslie Goodloe>The story I told last year of the lady who was living in the house that her father built, and she was wearing all of her clothes to stay warm.

607
01:02:32.835 --> 01:02:34.780
<v Leslie Goodloe>She had no heat, she had no running water.

608
01:02:35.472 --> 01:02:44.411
<v Leslie Goodloe>And through our home repair program and partnering with Multnomah County and a variety of other things, we were able to make her house habitable.

609
01:02:44.478 --> 01:02:44.614
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you.

610
01:02:45.336 --> 01:02:49.474
<v Leslie Goodloe>And now she's living in this house that her father built and doing very well.

611
01:02:50.018 --> 01:03:02.911
<v Leslie Goodloe>So to say that— that's all that to say, of course we could use more money, particularly outside the districts, because right now most of that funding is resourced within TIF districts.

612
01:03:03.313 --> 01:03:11.635
<v Leslie Goodloe>We do have some CDBG that we're able to use, but that gets eaten up pretty quickly because there's always a waiting list for folks outside of TIF districts.

613
01:03:12.436 --> 01:03:19.253
<v Leslie Goodloe>At one point, we did have some general fund that went into home repair, but we haven't had that in a while.

614
01:03:19.349 --> 01:03:26.597
<v Leslie Goodloe>So again, the new TIF districts— Culley put home repair funds in their first 5-year plan.

615
01:03:27.351 --> 01:03:43.103
<v Leslie Goodloe>I know the other districts are considering it, but if you live outside a district, it's— you have to wait until that next year, or if you're lucky enough to get into a program that's funded by other dollars, then you can get the services.

616
01:03:43.568 --> 01:03:45.864
<v Leslie Goodloe>I know a lot of PCF has gone into this as well.

617
01:03:46.699 --> 01:03:51.402
<v Stephen Holt>Well, I'm just going to talk about one portion of that, and that is you haven't heard much.

618
01:03:52.237 --> 01:04:05.289
<v Stephen Holt>And that's really something that I've been harping on the entire time we've been doing this work, is it seems like this committee, for whatever reason— my words, my feelings— was treated like the redhead stepchild.

619
01:04:06.123 --> 01:04:08.161
<v Stephen Holt>We just did not get the capture.

620
01:04:08.532 --> 01:04:15.802
<v Stephen Holt>We didn't get the, the kind of media coverage, the kind of exposure so that families could know, so that we could promote.

621
01:04:16.155 --> 01:04:29.702
<v Stephen Holt>We initially started with 77,000 postcards being sent out, and I wanted to do lawn signs that communicated this house has been repaired by some way so we knew and could help people know what's available.

622
01:04:30.119 --> 01:04:31.981
<v Stephen Holt>So it's been quiet until recently.

623
01:04:32.045 --> 01:04:38.108
<v Stephen Holt>So thanks to Gary Barlow and thanks to To Gwen for her work of beginning to advertise and help to get the word out.

624
01:04:38.284 --> 01:04:45.112
<v Stephen Holt>But I think the work of this committee should be shouted from the rooftops, not just because I'm the chair, but because of what it accomplished.

625
01:04:46.251 --> 01:04:47.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, I appreciate that.

626
01:04:47.902 --> 01:04:50.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm always happy to help shout.

627
01:04:51.284 --> 01:04:53.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it's incredibly important work.

628
01:04:53.432 --> 01:05:04.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And like I said, appreciate both of your frankness about where we're at, what's working, and where we might need a little bit Chair, I will stop there so I don't take up all our time.

629
01:05:05.135 --> 01:05:05.472
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

630
01:05:06.257 --> 01:05:06.673
<v Stephen Holt>Thank you.

631
01:05:07.635 --> 01:05:08.164
<v Candace Avalos>Vice Chair Green.

632
01:05:09.143 --> 01:05:11.210
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

633
01:05:12.445 --> 01:05:15.057
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Dr. Holt, and thank you, Leslie, for the presentation.

634
01:05:15.233 --> 01:05:22.320
<v Mitch Green>I couldn't agree more that I think one of the urgent needs is to shout the good work here from the rooftops.

635
01:05:22.384 --> 01:05:26.454
<v Mitch Green>I'm a big believer in like this sign, this work was brought to you by Expolus.

636
01:05:27.139 --> 01:05:37.880
<v Mitch Green>And that your tax dollars, whether we think about TIF dollars in that way or direct dollars, are the things that made this possible because that's how voters connect with the good deeds.

637
01:05:37.927 --> 01:05:39.849
<v Mitch Green>And so hearing that loud and clear.

638
01:05:39.947 --> 01:05:40.673
<v Mitch Green>So thank you so much.

639
01:05:40.737 --> 01:05:44.235
<v Mitch Green>And I want to thank you guys for the work that you've put into getting us here.

640
01:05:44.786 --> 01:05:47.219
<v Mitch Green>I think that we're seeing some great outcomes here.

641
01:05:47.527 --> 01:05:56.264
<v Mitch Green>And I think what you're hearing up here at the dais is, you know, at the risk of speaking for everyone, like a firm commitment to keep this going.

642
01:05:56.601 --> 01:05:57.003
<v Mitch Green>Awesome.

643
01:05:57.099 --> 01:06:06.862
<v Mitch Green>And to make sure that we are continuing to double down and make sure that we are preserving what we built and then looking for opportunities to do more of this.

644
01:06:07.456 --> 01:06:20.125
<v Mitch Green>I think Councilor Avalos actually last year in the budget amendment process brought forward amendments to try to provide cash infusions to the North Northeast preference policies that had some vacancy issues so we don't lose that.

645
01:06:20.447 --> 01:06:23.829
<v Mitch Green>And I supported that at that time, and I think that that's the right direction to be thinking.

646
01:06:24.364 --> 01:06:30.896
<v Mitch Green>So that's going to be continued, sort of the spirit that I'm going to kind of bring to this work, whether I'm on this committee or not, whether I'm on this body or not.

647
01:06:31.527 --> 01:06:34.471
<v Mitch Green>I think that this is transformational work.

648
01:06:34.534 --> 01:06:36.137
<v Mitch Green>So I just want to say thank you for that.

649
01:06:36.297 --> 01:06:54.108
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate the concise kind of list of recommendations at the end that kind of aligns with what I've just generally been feeling is So the North-Northwest preference policy work is not unique in the challenges.

650
01:06:54.704 --> 01:06:54.961
<v Mitch Green>Right.

651
01:06:55.025 --> 01:06:59.016
<v Mitch Green>I think a lot about, you know, at the end of the day, we have scarce dollars, right?

652
01:06:59.340 --> 01:07:00.748
<v Mitch Green>There's only so many dollars to go around.

653
01:07:00.797 --> 01:07:02.789
<v Mitch Green>And so how do you spend it wisely to get the best outcome?

654
01:07:04.719 --> 01:07:11.639
<v Mitch Green>I think aligning affordability with the actual concerns, I don't know if you intentionally put that at the top of the list, but that to me is the first priority.

655
01:07:12.067 --> 01:07:22.206
<v Mitch Green>The flashing kind of red light in all of our housing work right now, which is that what does it mean to say something's affordable by name, but it's not actually affordable?

656
01:07:22.447 --> 01:07:22.753
<v Mitch Green>Correct.

657
01:07:22.849 --> 01:07:24.748
<v Mitch Green>You're not serving the folks that you want to serve.

658
01:07:25.135 --> 01:07:25.440
<v Mitch Green>Correct.

659
01:07:25.827 --> 01:07:29.561
<v Mitch Green>And so I think about that in the context of just the broad committee work that we have ahead of us.

660
01:07:30.780 --> 01:07:39.545
<v Mitch Green>I have been talking a lot and thinking a lot lately about— and the Bureau leadership has heard this from me, and it's also a big driver of the social housing study work.

661
01:07:40.528 --> 01:07:42.552
<v Mitch Green>Mm-hmm.

662
01:07:43.771 --> 01:07:49.777
<v Mitch Green>Do we need to decouple from those HUD definitions and move towards something that's more cost-based?

663
01:07:50.500 --> 01:08:10.760
<v Mitch Green>Because if you can do that, then you can decouple the question of whether you want to provide an opportunity for someone to live in a place that they should be able to live in by their choice, that they have been displaced from, from the question of whether or not you want to Some sort of formula rate about whether they deserve to keep staying there or meet that threshold to begin with.

664
01:08:10.826 --> 01:08:19.525
<v Mitch Green>So like I have been pushing as part of the social housing work for us to think about what is the new generation of how we fund, how do we sustain affordable housing?

665
01:08:19.814 --> 01:08:20.554
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

666
01:08:20.956 --> 01:08:22.144
<v Mitch Green>In a cost-based approach.

667
01:08:22.481 --> 01:08:32.720
<v Mitch Green>And so once you've figured out that, then you can talk about how to subsidize those who are having some difficulty kind of hitting that average.

668
01:08:33.158 --> 01:08:35.396
<v Mitch Green>What does that average rent need to be to sustain this building?

669
01:08:35.445 --> 01:08:36.954
<v Mitch Green>Like, if we need to subsidize, let's subsidize.

670
01:08:37.380 --> 01:08:45.337
<v Mitch Green>But this moving target of AMIs over time is, is creating a, a game that we continuously have to try to catch up to.

671
01:08:45.434 --> 01:08:46.953
<v Stephen Holt>And it's a losing one for us.

672
01:08:47.050 --> 01:08:48.610
<v Mitch Green>It's a losing one for all the providers.

673
01:08:48.724 --> 01:08:49.787
<v Mitch Green>It's losing one for the city.

674
01:08:49.867 --> 01:08:55.485
<v Mitch Green>It's losing for every single jurisdiction because as the rich get richer, it pulls those AMIs levels up.

675
01:08:55.726 --> 01:08:56.210
<v Mitch Green>Correct.

676
01:08:56.354 --> 01:09:02.021
<v Mitch Green>And the bottom of the distribution doesn't We are outpaced.

677
01:09:02.599 --> 01:09:03.273
<v Mitch Green>Sorry, go ahead.

678
01:09:03.385 --> 01:09:04.685
<v Stephen Holt>No, I just said we are outpaced.

679
01:09:04.974 --> 01:09:18.963
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, so, so I think, um, when we were having conversations earlier in this year about how to spend housing money in various different venues, um, some of us brought forward proposals for rent buydowns or debt buydowns.

680
01:09:19.011 --> 01:09:21.001
<v Mitch Green>We did adopt some legislation that has some of that.

681
01:09:21.738 --> 01:09:32.829
<v Mitch Green>I think, I think about the North Northeast portfolio of AMI units as being a prime candidate to buy down the cost structure of those buildings so you can then lower the rents, right?

682
01:09:32.909 --> 01:09:40.393
<v Mitch Green>Because I think that there's a vacancy problem, and there's also folks who are lining up to try to get in, and that mismatch is something that can be solved with some policy and some dollars.

683
01:09:40.921 --> 01:09:42.972
<v Mitch Green>And that's probably the least expensive way to close that gap.

684
01:09:43.373 --> 01:09:43.550
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

685
01:09:43.694 --> 01:09:45.537
<v Mitch Green>Certainly less expensive than building something new.

686
01:09:45.856 --> 01:09:47.444
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

687
01:09:48.100 --> 01:09:49.189
<v Mitch Green>So I just wanted your reaction.

688
01:09:49.238 --> 01:09:50.023
<v Mitch Green>Am I on track?

689
01:09:50.199 --> 01:09:50.648
<v Stephen Holt>I think so.

690
01:09:50.984 --> 01:09:52.042
<v Stephen Holt>I like it, I like it.

691
01:09:52.283 --> 01:09:56.898
<v Stephen Holt>And I would say, uh, careful, Councilor, you're starting to color outside the lines.

692
01:09:57.795 --> 01:10:03.226
<v Mitch Green>So I think, uh, I think I've made a reputation for myself that I'm willing to do that sometimes.

693
01:10:03.563 --> 01:10:06.560
<v Leslie Goodloe>Um, Councilor, I just wanted to jump in real quick.

694
01:10:06.847 --> 01:10:15.725
<v Leslie Goodloe>Um, we've been fortunate that in, um, that Metro has supported us being able to buy down rents in several buildings.

695
01:10:15.981 --> 01:10:18.323
<v Leslie Goodloe>Um, um, Albina Vision Trust Yeah.

696
01:10:18.403 --> 01:10:19.463
<v Leslie Goodloe>Was able to fundraise.

697
01:10:19.528 --> 01:10:27.256
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so even though the rents are advertised at 60%, they're really more like 45, 50%, depending upon the building.

698
01:10:27.320 --> 01:10:29.842
<v Leslie Goodloe>And the 30% are more like 25 or 27%.

699
01:10:30.679 --> 01:10:38.101
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so it does make a difference in being able to rent units when the rents are lower.

700
01:10:38.471 --> 01:10:52.444
<v Leslie Goodloe>And thankfully, Metro had some additional interest money that they've been able to put into strong Dr. Darrell Milner into M. Carter Commons, and they're able to bring those rents down.

701
01:10:52.636 --> 01:11:01.515
<v Leslie Goodloe>So it's the perfect example of what we can do with a small amount of money that will have long-term impact on helping people.

702
01:11:01.837 --> 01:11:02.720
<v Mitch Green>That's exactly right.

703
01:11:02.817 --> 01:11:09.623
<v Mitch Green>And it puts the city, it puts the jurisdiction in a situation where we can change the pace of the game a little bit by buying down that cost structure.

704
01:11:09.784 --> 01:11:17.452
<v Mitch Green>You sort to reset your cost basis so that way you're not always chasing a little bit behind inflation, right?

705
01:11:17.613 --> 01:11:24.722
<v Mitch Green>So I'm glad to hear that there's other conversations here and that Metro is supporting you in that regard.

706
01:11:24.932 --> 01:11:26.448
<v Mitch Green>I don't know how much time I have.

707
01:11:27.561 --> 01:11:31.277
<v Mitch Green>I don't want to burn up the rest of our time with my questions, but I wanted to get to some homeownership.

708
01:11:31.520 --> 01:11:33.360
<v Candace Avalos>We're going until 3:20, so you got some time.

709
01:11:33.619 --> 01:11:34.539
<v Candace Avalos>Just leave me a couple minutes.

710
01:11:34.588 --> 01:11:34.814
<v Steve Novick>All right, awesome.

711
01:11:36.520 --> 01:11:48.779
<v Mitch Green>I wanted to ask if y'all have been involved at all by the Portland Housing Bureau as part of the social housing study, because there's some little meetings happening about the development of what that looks like.

712
01:11:48.844 --> 01:11:56.619
<v Mitch Green>And a lot of the folks on the technical advisory panels are speaking to homeownership.

713
01:11:57.167 --> 01:12:10.319
<v Mitch Green>They're speaking to sort of other forms of ownership, limited equity co-ops, other other pieces, because I think as we designed this resolution, we did want to recognize that if you're going to do social housing in Portland, it needs to fit Portland.

714
01:12:10.738 --> 01:12:12.054
<v Mitch Green>It needs to fit our problems.

715
01:12:12.134 --> 01:12:15.747
<v Mitch Green>It needs to be connected to our institutions that we already have.

716
01:12:15.810 --> 01:12:20.452
<v Mitch Green>We should bring along the providers that have been in this space for a long period of time trying to do this work.

717
01:12:21.350 --> 01:12:27.099
<v Mitch Green>And so that way it's something that folks can say, yes, this meets a solution, this meets— it fills a gap that we have been trying to fill.

718
01:12:27.693 --> 01:12:34.078
<v Mitch Green>And so question is, if you haven't been involved or consulted in that, let me know, because I think you should.

719
01:12:34.752 --> 01:12:51.278
<v Mitch Green>I would love to hear from, from, from the committee, but also, you know, you know, you as well, Leslie, in this work to see if that study is going to contemplate and incorporate this policy as part of a broader vision, or if it's just completely disconnected, because I don't want it to be disconnected.

720
01:12:51.838 --> 01:12:53.813
<v Stephen Holt>Well, let me say 2 things.

721
01:12:54.390 --> 01:12:59.970
<v Stephen Holt>I have been involved anecdotally but not directly and worth the conversations.

722
01:13:00.159 --> 01:13:06.789
<v Stephen Holt>I would say I'd love to invite you to the Oversight Committee itself and be part of this conversation with the committee.

723
01:13:07.020 --> 01:13:08.020
<v Stephen Holt>We meet this Thursday.

724
01:13:08.020 --> 01:13:09.920
<v Stephen Holt>I'm sure that's too short of notice.

725
01:13:09.920 --> 01:13:10.640
<v Leslie Goodloe>No, we don't.

726
01:13:10.640 --> 01:13:12.180
<v Stephen Holt>Isn't it the second Thursday?

727
01:13:12.180 --> 01:13:13.460
<v Leslie Goodloe>No, remember we met quarterly.

728
01:13:13.619 --> 01:13:14.159
<v Stephen Holt>Oh, we canceled that.

729
01:13:14.159 --> 01:13:16.039
<v Stephen Holt>So we're not gonna meet until October.

730
01:13:16.039 --> 01:13:16.800
<v Leslie Goodloe>We're not meeting until October.

731
01:13:16.800 --> 01:13:17.039
<v Mitch Green>What?

732
01:13:17.039 --> 01:13:17.960
<v Stephen Holt>I've got July off.

733
01:13:17.960 --> 01:13:18.899
<v Stephen Holt>Oh, that's amazing.

734
01:13:19.500 --> 01:13:24.579
<v Stephen Holt>So I'd love to have you come and make that part of the conversation.

735
01:13:24.840 --> 01:13:32.751
<v Stephen Holt>I think that, again, we've got a blueprint, It's not the— we have a— it'll be great to look at how we expand and engage.

736
01:13:32.895 --> 01:13:34.865
<v Stephen Holt>So I appreciate that further conversation.

737
01:13:35.025 --> 01:13:35.458
<v Stephen Holt>Absolutely.

738
01:13:35.506 --> 01:13:38.230
<v Mitch Green>If it's that far out, I'm sure I have no excuses why I can't attend.

739
01:13:38.728 --> 01:13:49.801
<v Leslie Goodloe>Well, I just— I will say that I— that the perception of social housing, um, particularly in the Black and brown community, is not necessarily something that people think is for them.

740
01:13:50.666 --> 01:13:57.768
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so having someone or a couple of you come and have that conversation with the Oversight Committee would be amazing.

741
01:13:58.922 --> 01:14:08.627
<v Leslie Goodloe>One of the struggles we've had is that people, you know, when they have in their head homeownership, they're thinking of, you know, a 3-bedroom house with a picket fence and a driveway and a yard.

742
01:14:09.172 --> 01:14:13.439
<v Leslie Goodloe>And we know that homeownership is not that anymore.

743
01:14:13.583 --> 01:14:22.069
<v Leslie Goodloe>You know, that there's, there's not enough land for us to build everybody a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom house with a, with a, with a driveway and a yard.

744
01:14:22.502 --> 01:14:26.145
<v Leslie Goodloe>We've been fortunate that we're partnering with Williams and Russell.

745
01:14:26.676 --> 01:14:27.542
<v Leslie Goodloe>20 Units.

746
01:14:27.944 --> 01:14:29.212
<v Leslie Goodloe>Everybody's going to have a driveway.

747
01:14:29.261 --> 01:14:31.701
<v Leslie Goodloe>Everybody's going to have at least a little bit of yard.

748
01:14:32.054 --> 01:14:32.663
<v Leslie Goodloe>True North.

749
01:14:32.792 --> 01:14:34.157
<v Leslie Goodloe>Everybody's going to have a parking space.

750
01:14:34.220 --> 01:14:35.873
<v Leslie Goodloe>Everybody's going to have a little bit of yard.

751
01:14:36.613 --> 01:14:40.032
<v Leslie Goodloe>And those are the things that we've heard from people.

752
01:14:40.641 --> 01:14:40.881
<v Leslie Goodloe>The—.

753
01:14:41.926 --> 01:14:45.265
<v Leslie Goodloe>We struggled with Kenton and with Olin because those were flats.

754
01:14:46.581 --> 01:14:49.774
<v Leslie Goodloe>And people on the preference policy list were not interested in buying an apartment.

755
01:14:50.819 --> 01:15:08.712
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so really wanting to change kind of that narrative of what does homeownership mean, and through the social housing, what does that look like through social housing to become a homeowner for BIPOC families, and how do we support them in their vision?

756
01:15:09.050 --> 01:15:11.684
<v Leslie Goodloe>Because what was lost was houses.

757
01:15:12.037 --> 01:15:12.278
<v Leslie Goodloe>Correct.

758
01:15:12.359 --> 01:15:13.851
<v Leslie Goodloe>It was not townhomes.

759
01:15:13.948 --> 01:15:15.088
<v Leslie Goodloe>It was not apartments.

760
01:15:15.490 --> 01:15:17.557
<v Leslie Goodloe>It was homes that were lost.

761
01:15:17.895 --> 01:15:28.149
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so when people think about Northeast Portland in particular, they think about, my grandma's house was right there, and my grandma's best friend lived right there, and I used to go to that house and we'd get ice cream every day.

762
01:15:28.614 --> 01:15:35.168
<v Leslie Goodloe>That's what you hear when you talk to people that show up at our meetings that came and gave testimony.

763
01:15:35.521 --> 01:15:41.707
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so I think it would be fabulous for folks to come and for us to have that conversation at the Oversight Committee.

764
01:15:41.770 --> 01:15:41.899
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you.

765
01:15:42.255 --> 01:15:50.802
<v Leslie Goodloe>And invite our partners to come in and talk about how we can make this work for the population that benefits from the preference policy.

766
01:15:51.011 --> 01:15:52.957
<v Mitch Green>I really appreciate that.

767
01:15:53.327 --> 01:15:54.627
<v Mitch Green>And I hear that too.

768
01:15:54.934 --> 01:15:56.717
<v Mitch Green>And that's one of the things I've been worried about.

769
01:15:56.797 --> 01:16:05.230
<v Mitch Green>It's like if I miss an opportunity to talk directly to folks who I haven't been able to speak directly to on the question of social housing is very important to me.

770
01:16:07.605 --> 01:16:11.346
<v Mitch Green>So we'll put it on our calendar and we'll come out to that.

771
01:16:12.278 --> 01:16:20.242
<v Mitch Green>But I think for me, just from the kind of what I think about what homeownership provides you that rental stock does not, it has some characteristics.

772
01:16:20.707 --> 01:16:27.259
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, we can't turn back the clock and like reproduce the population level and, you know, put back all those single-family homes.

773
01:16:27.837 --> 01:16:32.637
<v Mitch Green>But we can think about how we want to build the outcomes that we want as we develop as a city.

774
01:16:33.457 --> 01:16:36.203
<v Mitch Green>It's, you know, you don't get displaced.

775
01:16:36.685 --> 01:16:41.729
<v Mitch Green>You know, you're not kicked out because the landlord changed their mind and raised the rent.

776
01:16:42.452 --> 01:16:51.078
<v Mitch Green>It's the fact that you've got a fairly fixed-rate mortgage that over time, as your income grows, your housing burden falls as a share of your income.

777
01:16:51.141 --> 01:16:52.234
<v Mitch Green>Like, that's the other big piece.

778
01:16:52.346 --> 01:16:53.278
<v Mitch Green>That's how you build wealth.

779
01:16:53.327 --> 01:16:56.154
<v Mitch Green>And of course, there is the ability to hand it down to another generation.

780
01:16:56.747 --> 01:16:59.622
<v Mitch Green>It's the ability to sell a house and realize some capital gains in that.

781
01:16:59.671 --> 01:17:02.850
<v Mitch Green>Those are all the desirable pro— and it's the placemaking, of course, as well.

782
01:17:03.573 --> 01:17:04.265
<v Mitch Green>A lot of us—.

783
01:17:04.265 --> 01:17:09.596
<v Stephen Holt>So if I could say, Councilor, right here, what you just did is socialize the concept.

784
01:17:10.014 --> 01:17:11.057
<v Stephen Holt>So how do we talk about it?

785
01:17:11.283 --> 01:17:13.130
<v Stephen Holt>How do we inform and educate people about it?

786
01:17:13.386 --> 01:17:18.060
<v Stephen Holt>And then how do we couple that with specific places of strategic investment?

787
01:17:18.430 --> 01:17:21.626
<v Stephen Holt>So here is the concept of it, and here's the real possibility.

788
01:17:21.802 --> 01:17:25.158
<v Stephen Holt>Here are the things that are associated with it so that we're not selling a pipe dream.

789
01:17:25.672 --> 01:17:25.769
<v Stephen Holt>Right.

790
01:17:25.865 --> 01:17:30.296
<v Stephen Holt>So that new promises aren't being made that potentially you're not in space to then enforce.

791
01:17:31.115 --> 01:17:33.797
<v Stephen Holt>And now someone with new priorities steps into a place.

792
01:17:34.182 --> 01:17:37.682
<v Stephen Holt>That's been the lived experience over and over and over again.

793
01:17:38.037 --> 01:17:42.532
<v Stephen Holt>And that's been what's made the difference for this work is there's been continuity.

794
01:17:42.854 --> 01:17:45.310
<v Stephen Holt>That's why I emphasize 3 different mayors.

795
01:17:45.582 --> 01:17:50.529
<v Stephen Holt>I can't tell you how many different people in positions of elected leadership and priorities shift.

796
01:17:51.028 --> 01:17:51.917
<v Stephen Holt>On a regular basis.

797
01:17:52.176 --> 01:17:56.512
<v Stephen Holt>And so if we can put policies in place that outlive personalities, that helps us.

798
01:17:57.256 --> 01:17:58.502
<v Mitch Green>That's great.

799
01:17:58.568 --> 01:18:03.337
<v Mitch Green>And I am looking at the time and I don't want to rob the chair of some airtime as well.

800
01:18:03.418 --> 01:18:08.770
<v Mitch Green>So I think what I'll do is I do have some questions about some of the numbers and the costs.

801
01:18:08.917 --> 01:18:10.627
<v Mitch Green>I can email those and get those offline.

802
01:18:10.774 --> 01:18:16.908
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, you can send me— And we'll make a point to look forward to that committee hearing meeting.

803
01:18:16.957 --> 01:18:17.250
<v Stephen Holt>Awesome.

804
01:18:17.706 --> 01:18:18.583
<v Stephen Holt>We can meet prior to that.

805
01:18:18.926 --> 01:18:19.390
<v Mitch Green>I would love to.

806
01:18:19.743 --> 01:18:20.591
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thanks so much.

807
01:18:20.769 --> 01:18:20.993
<v Stephen Holt>Thank you.

808
01:18:21.088 --> 01:18:21.729
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you, Councilor.

809
01:18:23.188 --> 01:18:23.524
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

810
01:18:23.974 --> 01:18:24.966
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, thank you, colleagues.

811
01:18:25.030 --> 01:18:30.623
<v Candace Avalos>What a great discussion, and I'm grateful that we had this time to kind of just have a back and forth and react to the report.

812
01:18:31.104 --> 01:18:38.859
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, really appreciate the presentation and of course all of the work that the committee is doing to make sure that we're addressing these historic injustices in our city.

813
01:18:39.037 --> 01:18:43.811
<v Candace Avalos>And it's really good to see as well that, uh, we exceeded those 2015 goals.

814
01:18:43.859 --> 01:18:52.747
<v Candace Avalos>That's awesome to hear those stories and see how this policy is increasing belonging and preventing displacement, increasing homeownership.

815
01:18:53.229 --> 01:18:55.460
<v Candace Avalos>Um, obviously lots of work to do.

816
01:18:55.668 --> 01:19:03.483
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, I think, uh, also appreciate that slide of just like kind of your next steps or what you think is important for us to know as policymakers.

817
01:19:03.980 --> 01:19:07.703
<v Candace Avalos>Um, the affordability and AMI thing, I mean, it's, it's an issue.

818
01:19:08.233 --> 01:19:09.869
<v Candace Avalos>It, it's going to continue to be an issue.

819
01:19:10.238 --> 01:19:10.335
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

820
01:19:10.496 --> 01:19:23.548
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that is why, um, you know, people like Councilor Green and I are so adamant about things like social housing because one of the most important components of that to me is not only people aging in place, but also waging in place.

821
01:19:23.788 --> 01:19:23.997
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

822
01:19:24.206 --> 01:19:36.007
<v Candace Avalos>We do not want people to be forced out of these programs just because they make $1 above whatever amount is too much and they clearly don't have enough to make that next level.

823
01:19:36.072 --> 01:19:37.595
<v Candace Avalos>That gap is just enormous.

824
01:19:37.996 --> 01:19:47.109
<v Candace Avalos>And so I think a lot of, you know, what we learned about when we went and studied that more intently was that people are able to wage and grow their life, right?

825
01:19:47.172 --> 01:19:49.307
<v Candace Avalos>They get their first job and then they get their second job.

826
01:19:49.372 --> 01:19:50.471
<v Candace Avalos>They get a little bit of a pay bump.

827
01:19:50.569 --> 01:19:51.282
<v Candace Avalos>They have a family.

828
01:19:51.801 --> 01:19:55.867
<v Candace Avalos>And as time goes on, they're only means tested the first time, right?

829
01:19:55.948 --> 01:19:59.787
<v Candace Avalos>They're only like just to get in and then you can start to build your life.

830
01:19:59.949 --> 01:20:05.715
<v Candace Avalos>So that's the kind of housing we need, especially for, I mean, for all kinds of people, but I think a lot about our young people.

831
01:20:05.795 --> 01:20:05.908
<v Candace Avalos>Mm-hmm.

832
01:20:06.697 --> 01:20:13.507
<v Candace Avalos>And what's available to them, you know, the housing, job prospects, it's bleak for young people right now.

833
01:20:14.038 --> 01:20:26.675
<v Candace Avalos>And if we can create housing where they can be stable, stable and not have to worry about, you know, if their economic situation gets better, that that is going to make their housing situation get worse.

834
01:20:26.739 --> 01:20:31.471
<v Candace Avalos>That is just a horrible juxtaposition that we continue to face here in the country, frankly.

835
01:20:31.552 --> 01:20:31.617
<v Candace Avalos>But—.

836
01:20:31.617 --> 01:20:31.907
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith.

837
01:20:32.386 --> 01:20:33.891
<v Candace Avalos>Obviously talking about the city.

838
01:20:34.484 --> 01:20:47.465
<v Candace Avalos>And I think too, next meeting, just so you all know, and I was going to announce it at the end, but we're going to have Metro Council President come to talk to us about the polling that they did on the supportive housing measure.

839
01:20:47.545 --> 01:20:55.524
<v Candace Avalos>But what stood out to me and why I'm raising it is they polled about social housing, and what most people said was they just didn't know what it was.

840
01:20:55.860 --> 01:20:56.086
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

841
01:20:56.261 --> 01:20:59.466
<v Candace Avalos>Largest percentage was they just had no idea what Yes.

842
01:20:59.819 --> 01:21:07.479
<v Candace Avalos>So I think there is a lot of work to do to socialize social housing, to make sure people understand, you know, what, um, what the benefits are.

843
01:21:07.560 --> 01:21:18.649
<v Candace Avalos>Because also we know that I think the negative perceptions come from, um, the many decades that the government stood up all this housing and they're like, look, we did our job, and then they packed up and left.

844
01:21:18.936 --> 01:21:25.125
<v Candace Avalos>And all of that housing, you know, went to crap and then people were displaced and then it was just like, And now what?

845
01:21:25.364 --> 01:21:25.557
<v Candace Avalos>Right?

846
01:21:25.670 --> 01:21:27.114
<v Candace Avalos>And then you've got this private market.

847
01:21:27.194 --> 01:21:31.672
<v Candace Avalos>When 92% of our housing is the private market, it's just, it's not working.

848
01:21:32.185 --> 01:21:36.230
<v Candace Avalos>So I think that's why we want to like understand what is the government's role here.

849
01:21:36.904 --> 01:21:41.350
<v Candace Avalos>Obviously, you know, we have many kinds of philosophies of what the government's role is.

850
01:21:41.494 --> 01:21:44.545
<v Candace Avalos>My personal philosophy is that we should be housing people.

851
01:21:44.625 --> 01:21:47.320
<v Candace Avalos>That should be our number one role, in my opinion.

852
01:21:47.449 --> 01:21:51.252
<v Candace Avalos>So I think that's kind of where that falls into the conversation.

853
01:21:51.365 --> 01:21:53.194
<v Candace Avalos>But I would love to follow up with you on that.

854
01:21:53.595 --> 01:21:53.820
<v Candace Avalos>You should.

855
01:21:54.012 --> 01:21:55.617
<v Candace Avalos>I've got some questions, but I'll just follow up.

856
01:21:56.113 --> 01:22:09.280
<v Candace Avalos>I think the main question I'll just throw out and we can continue to talk about— I just wanted to understand, um, you know, what are the— are you hearing from families that are saying they still haven't been able to return?

857
01:22:09.488 --> 01:22:14.653
<v Candace Avalos>And what are the barriers that the program isn't addressing that is still prohibiting their return?

858
01:22:14.780 --> 01:22:16.337
<v Candace Avalos>Anything you want to share on that front?

859
01:22:17.411 --> 01:22:23.564
<v Leslie Goodloe>Well, I think there are a lot of people would like to move back, but again, the rent is just— the rents are just too high.

860
01:22:24.259 --> 01:22:28.164
<v Leslie Goodloe>We have these beautiful new buildings that people can't afford to move into.

861
01:22:30.207 --> 01:22:37.189
<v Leslie Goodloe>And then on the other side, we've got folks that have been displaced out to Southeast and other parts of town that now want a place to make where they are.

862
01:22:37.543 --> 01:22:37.608
<v Leslie Goodloe>Right.

863
01:22:38.043 --> 01:22:39.417
<v Leslie Goodloe>And how do we support them there?

864
01:22:39.970 --> 01:22:42.314
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so that's where the new districts come in.

865
01:22:42.426 --> 01:22:48.074
<v Leslie Goodloe>How do we support folks that have been displaced out into East Portland and other parts of town.

866
01:22:48.266 --> 01:23:03.605
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so how do we utilize the things that we've learned through Interstate, which was handled poorly for 20 years, and then over the last 10 years we've been able to try to, you know, create something better.

867
01:23:04.456 --> 01:23:16.451
<v Leslie Goodloe>And I think between PHBM Prosper and council ensuring that those districts and those plans are created by the community and that We do what those plans are written to do.

868
01:23:17.045 --> 01:23:19.229
<v Leslie Goodloe>I think that's what's most important.

869
01:23:20.337 --> 01:23:34.551
<v Leslie Goodloe>I think that the biggest benefit for us has been the oversight committee being able to come and bring questions from the community and cause us to have to think about what we're doing and how we're doing it.

870
01:23:35.033 --> 01:23:46.975
<v Leslie Goodloe>Because our— the initial goal by Tracy Manning, who was our director at the time, she was like, we're going to do things And this caused us to do things differently, not just in Northeast Portland, but with everything that we do in the bureau.

871
01:23:47.634 --> 01:23:48.725
<v Leslie Goodloe>We changed how we do loans.

872
01:23:48.854 --> 01:24:01.404
<v Leslie Goodloe>We changed how we do our NOFAs, you know, looking at other things other than, hey, Councilor Avalos, we like you and we're going to give you some money because we like you.

873
01:24:02.382 --> 01:24:06.314
<v Leslie Goodloe>And a lot of that was due to, you know, Commissioner Salter's leadership.

874
01:24:06.362 --> 01:24:06.506
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you.

875
01:24:06.811 --> 01:24:12.868
<v Leslie Goodloe>Just really wanting to change how the city did— built housing, how we awarded funds.

876
01:24:13.524 --> 01:24:28.570
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so I know that was a long kind of winding road of an answer, but, um, I think we need to be able to support people where they are, as well as if they want to move back into Northeast Portland, that they have that opportunity.

877
01:24:29.484 --> 01:24:32.944
<v Stephen Holt>I think there are 3, and I agree with everything that, that Ms. Goodloe just said.

878
01:24:32.993 --> 01:24:35.542
<v Stephen Holt>I think there are 3 things that Are kind of repeated.

879
01:24:36.216 --> 01:24:40.807
<v Stephen Holt>One of the things that's been lost by families is a sense of community.

880
01:24:41.354 --> 01:24:44.484
<v Stephen Holt>So it's not just a place, it's not just, et cetera.

881
01:24:44.547 --> 01:24:47.645
<v Stephen Holt>That's why people will drive in from Gresham to hang out at Dawson Park.

882
01:24:48.641 --> 01:24:51.435
<v Stephen Holt>We've lost a sense of connectivity in space.

883
01:24:51.948 --> 01:24:54.195
<v Stephen Holt>I think that's a repeated idea.

884
01:24:54.516 --> 01:24:59.461
<v Stephen Holt>And when I say that, that's also a place that's welcoming and inviting.

885
01:25:00.070 --> 01:25:03.904
<v Stephen Holt>So not just for the folks who are showing up, But even the neighborhood around them.

886
01:25:04.305 --> 01:25:16.019
<v Stephen Holt>I think there's some work that is required of us to socialize and interact with the people who don't know the history, don't know what once was, and really don't care.

887
01:25:16.228 --> 01:25:19.625
<v Stephen Holt>I'm here now and this is my, et cetera, and I don't see the value in it.

888
01:25:19.689 --> 01:25:20.667
<v Stephen Holt>I think there's some work.

889
01:25:21.114 --> 01:25:25.521
<v Stephen Holt>I don't have a simple answer for that, but I think there's some work associated with it.

890
01:25:25.939 --> 01:25:34.947
<v Stephen Holt>I think the biggest one though, is just real opportunity and not possibilities, but real opportunity.

891
01:25:35.315 --> 01:25:42.064
<v Stephen Holt>People are desiring to connect to something that's going to make a difference that they can count on.

892
01:25:42.305 --> 01:25:51.895
<v Stephen Holt>If that's growth where I'm at, or if that's returning to where grandma, uncle, et cetera, where I was, or the school I went to.

893
01:25:52.007 --> 01:26:02.524
<v Stephen Holt>And that's, you know, if you've been around any Jeffersonians, You have heard demos and the heartbeat associated with that, or we Grantonians, Generals.

894
01:26:02.960 --> 01:26:06.631
<v Stephen Holt>There's something about place and something about significance.

895
01:26:06.680 --> 01:26:09.015
<v Stephen Holt>So ways that we can get there is very important.

896
01:26:10.655 --> 01:26:10.770
<v Stephen Holt>Thanks.

897
01:26:10.818 --> 01:26:11.609
<v Stephen Holt>It was a great question.

898
01:26:11.949 --> 01:26:12.613
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much.

899
01:26:12.693 --> 01:26:20.761
<v Candace Avalos>And yes, I think to one of the points you made in there around how it is affecting East Portland is that people are getting pushed out into my district and they're trying to create place.

900
01:26:21.036 --> 01:26:23.957
<v Candace Avalos>And, and so it's very much top of mind for me.

901
01:26:24.037 --> 01:26:24.712
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you.

902
01:26:25.610 --> 01:26:27.359
<v Candace Avalos>Really appreciate this discussion.

903
01:26:27.953 --> 01:26:32.384
<v Candace Avalos>We have lots of work to do, but it sounds like we got something on the calendar for October.

904
01:26:32.512 --> 01:26:39.640
<v Candace Avalos>And let's plan to discuss more how we can continue to implement the values and vision of this into all of our policymaking in the Housing Committee.

905
01:26:40.056 --> 01:26:40.603
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for your time.

906
01:26:40.795 --> 01:26:41.341
<v Stephen Holt>Well, thank you.

907
01:26:41.903 --> 01:26:42.480
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you so much.

908
01:26:42.545 --> 01:26:52.171
<v Leslie Goodloe>I just want to do one last shout out to the staff at PHB and all of our development partners, all of our community partners that We wouldn't be here without them.

909
01:26:52.412 --> 01:26:56.067
<v Leslie Goodloe>And this is a passion project for me.

910
01:26:56.500 --> 01:26:57.765
<v Leslie Goodloe>I grew up in Northeast Portland.

911
01:26:58.262 --> 01:26:59.881
<v Leslie Goodloe>My kids were raised in Northeast Portland.

912
01:27:00.283 --> 01:27:04.756
<v Leslie Goodloe>It has nothing whatsoever to do with being the business operations manager for the Portland Housing Bureau.

913
01:27:05.317 --> 01:27:14.838
<v Leslie Goodloe>But I took this on because Tracy asked me to, and I have not retired because I wanted to see projects break ground.

914
01:27:15.271 --> 01:27:24.380
<v Leslie Goodloe>And so it's— I just want you to understand the dedication of the staff and that bureau to move this work forward over the last 11 years has been significant.

915
01:27:24.427 --> 01:27:26.993
<v Leslie Goodloe>So I couldn't leave without putting that on the record.

916
01:27:27.056 --> 01:27:27.987
<v Leslie Goodloe>So thank you so much.

917
01:27:28.243 --> 01:27:28.581
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

918
01:27:28.725 --> 01:27:30.039
<v Candace Avalos>And that goes right back to you.

919
01:27:30.184 --> 01:27:32.444
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for all of your service and your work here.

920
01:27:32.750 --> 01:27:32.957
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

921
01:27:33.775 --> 01:27:42.979
<v Stephen Holt>I was just going to say that this has been, for me, obviously not only a passion project, but just something that had to be stewarded.

922
01:27:44.015 --> 01:27:47.403
<v Stephen Holt>Because of the benefit of the community and the people who are impacted.

923
01:27:47.984 --> 01:27:48.791
<v Stephen Holt>I'll end with this.

924
01:27:48.871 --> 01:28:09.411
<v Stephen Holt>I started by saying sometimes I feel like a dinosaur, and, um, the concern in my heart is as time changes and as values fluctuate, there's this constant thread of humanity and how we handle people and how we take care of folks.

925
01:28:09.740 --> 01:28:14.435
<v Stephen Holt>And so that the promises that we've made to people become the promises that we keep.

926
01:28:14.564 --> 01:28:17.408
<v Stephen Holt>I'm excited about what I've heard from the councilors today.

927
01:28:17.569 --> 01:28:17.908
<v Stephen Holt>Thank you.

928
01:28:18.216 --> 01:28:18.748
<v Stephen Holt>Thanks for caring.

929
01:28:19.539 --> 01:28:20.185
<v Stephen Holt>Thanks for investing.

930
01:28:20.282 --> 01:28:21.332
<v Stephen Holt>Thanks for taking the risk.

931
01:28:21.734 --> 01:28:24.738
<v Stephen Holt>Thanks for taking the hits, because that's what goes with both of them.

932
01:28:25.619 --> 01:28:26.123
<v Stephen Holt>Appreciate your time.

933
01:28:26.385 --> 01:28:27.118
<v Candace Avalos>Appreciate you.

934
01:28:28.730 --> 01:28:29.805
<v Candace Avalos>All right, committee.

935
01:28:30.212 --> 01:28:36.059
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, so we're gonna, we're gonna go ahead and take a break, so that will be perfect timing.

936
01:28:36.479 --> 01:28:38.841
<v Candace Avalos>So let us take a quick 10-minute break.

937
01:28:38.905 --> 01:28:42.600
<v Candace Avalos>We'll see you at Oh no, math.

938
01:28:43.291 --> 01:28:44.431
<v Candace Avalos>3:36.

939
01:28:44.784 --> 01:28:44.864
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

940
01:28:45.025 --> 01:28:45.908
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

941
01:40:11.405 --> 01:40:15.555
<v Candace Avalos>All right, we are back from our little recess.

942
01:40:16.400 --> 01:40:19.185
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, go ahead and call the next 2 items together.

943
01:40:20.756 --> 01:40:25.675
<v Diego>Item 3, Urban Alchemy and shelter operations oversight discussion.

944
01:40:26.435 --> 01:40:30.523
<v Diego>Item 4, public testimony on shelter oversight and operations.

945
01:40:31.279 --> 01:40:31.631
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

946
01:40:32.579 --> 01:40:45.234
<v Candace Avalos>So today the committee will be receiving presentations from Portland Solutions and Urban Alchemy regarding the city's oversight of contracted shelter providers and the processes in place to respond to complaints and allegations of misconduct.

947
01:40:46.117 --> 01:41:02.551
<v Candace Avalos>Over the past several months, serious allegations involving Urban Alchemy employees have been brought forward publicly, and these reports have raised understandable concerns from shelter participants, employees, community members, and all of us who have a responsibility to ensure city-funded shelter programs are safe and accountable.

948
01:41:03.274 --> 01:41:07.314
<v Candace Avalos>Portland Solutions has already provided council with information about its oversight and response.

949
01:41:07.844 --> 01:41:17.212
<v Candace Avalos>The purpose of today's discussion is to bring that information into a public forum so community members can better understand understand how these systems work and for committee members to ask questions.

950
01:41:17.984 --> 01:41:31.101
<v Candace Avalos>Our goal today is to understand the processes that exist today, how complaints are received and investigated, what oversight tools the city has available, what improvements have already been made, and where additional improvements may be needed.

951
01:41:32.016 --> 01:41:43.720
<v Candace Avalos>We want the public to understand what happens when concerns are reported, who is responsible for taking action, and how the city works to ensure accountability for organizations entrusted with with operating our shelter system.

952
01:41:44.539 --> 01:41:52.002
<v Candace Avalos>Following the presentations, committee members will have an opportunity to ask some questions before we open it up for public testimony.

953
01:41:52.082 --> 01:41:55.324
<v Candace Avalos>I believe we have about 7 or 8 folks so far.

954
01:41:56.015 --> 01:41:58.181
<v Candace Avalos>That's why I opened both of the items together.

955
01:41:58.261 --> 01:42:07.698
<v Candace Avalos>So we'll do presentations, short technical questions, give some space for 20 minutes worth of public testimony, and then we'll go back into committee discussion and more questions.

956
01:42:08.694 --> 01:42:09.030
<v Candace Avalos>Understood?

957
01:42:10.057 --> 01:42:10.297
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

958
01:42:10.956 --> 01:42:15.047
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, let's go ahead and start with Portland Solutions and take it away.

959
01:42:15.833 --> 01:42:15.993
<v Louis Hammonds>Great.

960
01:42:16.234 --> 01:42:16.492
<v Hank Smith>Thank you.

961
01:42:17.117 --> 01:42:20.694
<v Hank Smith>Good afternoon, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, councilors.

962
01:42:20.887 --> 01:42:26.069
<v Hank Smith>Thank you for the opportunity to be here today to speak about the grievance process at City of Portland shelters.

963
01:42:26.728 --> 01:42:36.707
<v Hank Smith>I'm Hank Smith, Deputy Director of Portland Solutions, and my colleague here is Brandy Westerman, our Emergency Humanitarian Operations Director, who manages the city shelter services team.

964
01:42:37.546 --> 01:42:42.148
<v Hank Smith>We also have Margie Sackett, our Shelter Operations Manager, in the audience today.

965
01:42:43.072 --> 01:42:47.484
<v Hank Smith>And Portland Solutions Director Skyler Brockenkamp is out of office and unable to attend this meeting.

966
01:42:51.899 --> 01:43:01.204
<v Hank Smith>Today we want to take a few minutes to update you on where we are at in providing you with the information you requested about contract oversight of Urban Alchemy.

967
01:43:02.192 --> 01:43:10.052
<v Hank Smith>We will also outline what happens when a shelter participant files a complaint which we also refer to as a grievance throughout this presentation.

968
01:43:11.204 --> 01:43:14.449
<v Hank Smith>And finally, we will share how this process has changed over time.

969
01:43:17.829 --> 01:43:28.100
<v Hank Smith>Before we talk about policies and processes, first and foremost, we want this committee to know that the City of Portland holds all our contracted service providers to a high standard.

970
01:43:28.868 --> 01:43:36.213
<v Hank Smith>We work hands-on with our shelter operators And have regular ongoing oversight of shelter management and activities.

971
01:43:36.969 --> 01:43:42.844
<v Hank Smith>Every complaint is investigated and people are held accountable whenever we find they have fallen below our expectations.

972
01:43:43.854 --> 01:43:49.184
<v Hank Smith>There is zero tolerance for identified harassment, intimidation, violence, or illegal behavior.

973
01:43:50.275 --> 01:43:59.328
<v Hank Smith>We built our shelters and day centers to provide a stable place for individuals as they work through the challenging journey of moving from unsheltered homelessness to permanent housing.

974
01:44:00.541 --> 01:44:05.528
<v Hank Smith>The safety and well-being of the people we serve at our shelters and day centers is our number one priority.

975
01:44:09.985 --> 01:44:18.039
<v Hank Smith>To set some context, the city's shelter services team is comprised of 10 individuals who manage 16 different shelter and day center locations throughout our city.

976
01:44:19.430 --> 01:44:24.779
<v Hank Smith>As of today, the shelters provide a cumulative 1,609 beds for individuals each night.

977
01:44:25.608 --> 01:44:32.216
<v Hank Smith>About 52% of those beds are alternative shelters, meaning locations that provide 24/7 services.

978
01:44:33.206 --> 01:44:40.747
<v Hank Smith>This is the kind of shelter we ask Urban Alchemy to help operate, and they operate about 700 beds or 84% of our alternative shelter.

979
01:44:43.199 --> 01:44:54.117
<v Hank Smith>On June 24th, CA Lee shared the memo from Chair Avalos and Committee of the Whole Chair Kanal asking for these items on this slide related to the city's work with Urban Alchemy.

980
01:44:54.853 --> 01:45:00.657
<v Hank Smith>Responding is a priority for us, and we will provide these records as requested on a rolling basis.

981
01:45:01.699 --> 01:45:11.501
<v Hank Smith>But today, in the following slides, Brandy will give a high-level overview of our grievance process, the shelter operator's contractual obligations, and how we have changed that process over time.

982
01:45:13.460 --> 01:45:16.622
<v Brandy Westerman>Good afternoon, Chair Avalos and Vice Chair Green, councilors.

983
01:45:17.206 --> 01:45:18.162
<v Brandy Westerman>I'm Brandy Westerman.

984
01:45:18.260 --> 01:45:20.837
<v Brandy Westerman>I'm the Emergency Humanitarian Operations Director.

985
01:45:21.703 --> 01:45:25.953
<v Brandy Westerman>The protection of Portland's most vulnerable is at the forefront of the humanitarian response.

986
01:45:26.033 --> 01:45:34.501
<v Brandy Westerman>The shelter system is designed first and foremost to provide safety off the streets and the opportunity to pursue stability and permanence in housing.

987
01:45:35.494 --> 01:45:43.560
<v Brandy Westerman>Requiring shelter operators to have a clear, well-publicized grievance system is a key component of ensuring our shelters are safe, welcoming spaces.

988
01:45:44.234 --> 01:45:49.900
<v Brandy Westerman>Expectations for grievance management are baked into our contracts and scope of work documents for all shelter operators.

989
01:45:50.720 --> 01:46:01.014
<v Brandy Westerman>Urban Alchemy, like the other 8 service organizations we work with, posts signs with grievance process information and makes feedback forms readily available for guests.

990
01:46:01.753 --> 01:46:12.118
<v Brandy Westerman>Urban Alchemy also outlines the grievance process in their community guidelines, which are informational documents given to and signed by every guest who stays at an Urban Alchemy-run site.

991
01:46:13.610 --> 01:46:27.000
<v Brandy Westerman>Our hope is that participants find shelters helpful in their journey towards housing, but we understand that some will experience wrongdoing and/or have complaints, and we're committed to managing a shelter system that investigates every grievance.

992
01:46:29.279 --> 01:46:31.606
<v Brandy Westerman>We are active managers of our shelter contracts.

993
01:46:32.172 --> 01:46:36.150
<v Brandy Westerman>Our team has a regular presence at the Urban Alchemy alternative shelter sites.

994
01:46:36.716 --> 01:46:42.387
<v Brandy Westerman>For shelter usage and outcomes, we rely on the Homeless Management Information System managed by Multnomah County.

995
01:46:42.469 --> 01:46:42.597
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you.

996
01:46:44.766 --> 01:46:52.134
<v Brandy Westerman>When critical incidents occur, such as an overdose or police response to a shelter, they must be reported to us immediately after the incident.

997
01:46:53.497 --> 01:47:01.506
<v Brandy Westerman>Our team maintains daily contact with shelter operators to coordinate entries and exits, site maintenance, general challenges and opportunities.

998
01:47:02.100 --> 01:47:10.173
<v Brandy Westerman>But we also maintain standing meetings to ensure contractual obligations are met and that shelters are adequately resourced to carry out their work.

999
01:47:11.234 --> 01:47:29.349
<v Brandy Westerman>Pertinent to today's conversation, my team maintains a weekly meeting with Urban Alchemy to review the status of grievance investigations, a biweekly meeting with the city ombudsman to sync on grievances they may have received, and biannual reviews with Urban Alchemy executive leadership about the status of their work in Portland.

1000
01:47:34.252 --> 01:47:37.488
<v Brandy Westerman>Here we have outlined the high-level grievance process for our shelters.

1001
01:47:38.113 --> 01:47:43.264
<v Brandy Westerman>The detailed grievance process for each shelter operator is posted online on our webpage.

1002
01:47:44.210 --> 01:47:52.569
<v Brandy Westerman>In general, when a participant has a complaint, we encourage them to notify the shelter operator first so that appropriate action may be taken quickly.

1003
01:47:53.260 --> 01:48:01.346
<v Brandy Westerman>If an individual is not satisfied with the resolution of that complaint, they may contact my team through email, an online form, or phone.

1004
01:48:02.164 --> 01:48:05.567
<v Brandy Westerman>We will then investigate the complaint and work with the shelter operators to find a resolution.

1005
01:48:05.614 --> 01:48:05.726
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you.

1006
01:48:06.612 --> 01:48:10.454
<v Brandy Westerman>If still not satisfied, an individual may reach out to the city ombudsman.

1007
01:48:13.935 --> 01:48:18.131
<v Brandy Westerman>Contact information for the city ombudsman is also posted at every site.

1008
01:48:19.000 --> 01:48:26.355
<v Brandy Westerman>In practice, many people don't follow this process in exact order, either coming to my team first or the ombudsman, or sometimes all 3 at once.

1009
01:48:27.131 --> 01:48:33.506
<v Brandy Westerman>We have set up shared spreadsheets with the city ombudsman and Urban Alchemy to coordinate complaints, investigations, and responses.

1010
01:48:33.604 --> 01:48:33.865
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you.

1011
01:48:38.204 --> 01:48:41.657
<v Brandy Westerman>When a grievance comes in, we immediately log it in a Smartsheet tracker.

1012
01:48:42.203 --> 01:48:48.335
<v Brandy Westerman>We created this tracker in March 2025 in recognition of a growing need to improve data.

1013
01:48:49.443 --> 01:48:55.734
<v Brandy Westerman>For awareness, when the Smartsheet was created, we merged it with a previous tracker that dated back to mid-2024.

1014
01:48:56.345 --> 01:49:01.128
<v Brandy Westerman>In that timeframe, the tracker had logged 83 complaints across our shelter system.

1015
01:49:02.188 --> 01:49:06.391
<v Brandy Westerman>After receiving the complaint, we categorize its severity on a scale of 1 to 5.

1016
01:49:06.936 --> 01:49:12.087
<v Brandy Westerman>These categories were formalized in May of this year when we updated our grievance investigation policy.

1017
01:49:12.809 --> 01:49:22.868
<v Brandy Westerman>Since May, we have logged 22 complaints, 18 of which were graded 1 through 3, 2 that were graded a 4, and 2 that went ungraded because they were about non-city shelters.

1018
01:49:23.702 --> 01:49:28.814
<v Brandy Westerman>Many of these overlap with grievances received by the city ombudsman, and/or the shelter operator.

1019
01:49:29.847 --> 01:49:34.018
<v Brandy Westerman>After logging the complaint, we will acknowledge its receipt to the participant who filed it.

1020
01:49:34.534 --> 01:49:43.774
<v Brandy Westerman>We then assign the complaint to one of my team for the investigation process, which includes seeking additional information from the shelter operator and, if needed, the participant themselves.

1021
01:49:44.891 --> 01:49:52.389
<v Brandy Westerman>My team works together and usually in coordination with the shelter operator to decide a course of action, which we then communicate to the participant.

1022
01:49:52.819 --> 01:49:56.954
<v Brandy Westerman>We encourage participants with grievances alleging illegal activity to be reported directly to law enforcement.

1023
01:50:02.442 --> 01:50:11.128
<v Brandy Westerman>As you're aware, the Shelter Services program at the city is relatively new, started in late 2021 and opening its first shelters in 2022.

1024
01:50:11.529 --> 01:50:18.774
<v Brandy Westerman>Shelter Services began as the Safe Rest Village program, focused on developing small village-style shelters.

1025
01:50:19.367 --> 01:50:27.908
<v Brandy Westerman>We've evolved to building shelters that are designed to serve more people, be lower barrier, and provide safety and basic care to homeless Portlanders with the most acute needs.

1026
01:50:27.972 --> 01:50:28.085
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you.

1027
01:50:29.130 --> 01:50:30.255
<v Brandy Westerman>This is challenging work.

1028
01:50:30.752 --> 01:50:42.369
<v Brandy Westerman>We have had to learn and adapt considerably, and we've been asked to pivot many times, standing up new shelter models rapidly and venturing into new services we've never offered, sometimes in a matter of months.

1029
01:50:43.206 --> 01:50:49.922
<v Brandy Westerman>We are committed to improvement and welcoming feedback in the spirit of improving outcomes for the vulnerable Portlanders who rely on our shelters.

1030
01:50:50.742 --> 01:50:53.715
<v Brandy Westerman>Improving our grievance process is an example of this commitment.

1031
01:50:54.372 --> 01:50:59.673
<v Brandy Westerman>Improvements we've made included expanding our reporting channels and formalizing our grievance policy.

1032
01:51:00.380 --> 01:51:07.929
<v Brandy Westerman>Notably, Urban Alchemy recently assigned one person to serve as the coordinator of grievance communication and response across their sites.

1033
01:51:09.213 --> 01:51:16.442
<v Brandy Westerman>Our Smartsheet upgraded our previous tracker, and we have established regular sync meetings where necessary to make sure nothing falls through the cracks.

1034
01:51:17.324 --> 01:51:27.429
<v Brandy Westerman>Our plans for improvement include better tracking, And by requiring shelter operators to report grievance response metrics on a quarterly basis.

1035
01:51:28.023 --> 01:51:33.693
<v Brandy Westerman>We are working to coordinate complaints that come into Urban Alchemy, the Ombudsman's Office, and ourselves.

1036
01:51:34.511 --> 01:51:40.327
<v Brandy Westerman>And with the '26-'27 fiscal year, we are rolling out a new appeals process that will be managed by our team.

1037
01:51:41.371 --> 01:51:47.828
<v Brandy Westerman>The City Auditor has also initiated a performance audit of all Portland Solutions programs to help us find areas for improvement.

1038
01:51:47.877 --> 01:51:48.005
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you.

1039
01:51:48.926 --> 01:51:57.470
<v Brandy Westerman>We also remain open to meeting with city councilors and/or their staff to keep them updated about our shelter operations, including any grievances that may come in.

1040
01:51:59.197 --> 01:52:00.391
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you for this time today.

1041
01:52:00.649 --> 01:52:02.716
<v Brandy Westerman>We're happy to answer any questions that you may have.

1042
01:52:06.152 --> 01:52:06.586
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1043
01:52:07.036 --> 01:52:13.944
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so we're gonna have a presentation by Urban Alchemy next, and then I'll open it up to questions for the both of you, and then we'll do public comment.

1044
01:52:14.604 --> 01:52:14.975
<v Candace Avalos>Testimony.

1045
01:52:15.377 --> 01:52:15.587
<v Candace Avalos>Sound good?

1046
01:52:15.877 --> 01:52:17.956
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, and I think you all can stay up there if you'd like.

1047
01:52:18.907 --> 01:52:19.824
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, Urban Alchemy, come on up.

1048
01:52:31.684 --> 01:52:34.936
<v Candace Avalos>All right, like I mentioned, we had Portland Solutions, now we have Urban Alchemy.

1049
01:52:35.001 --> 01:52:37.787
<v Candace Avalos>I don't think you have a, um, presentation, a formal one.

1050
01:52:37.899 --> 01:52:38.318
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, great.

1051
01:52:38.784 --> 01:52:39.719
<v Candace Avalos>Please go ahead and take it away.

1052
01:52:40.423 --> 01:52:41.551
<v Candace Avalos>And please introduce yourselves.

1053
01:52:42.974 --> 01:52:44.085
<v Bayron Wilson>My name is Bayron Wilson.

1054
01:52:44.182 --> 01:52:44.771
<v Bayron Wilson>I am the—.

1055
01:52:45.097 --> 01:52:45.637
<v Bayron Wilson>I am a practitioner.

1056
01:52:46.060 --> 01:52:47.998
<v Bayron Wilson>That means someone who can still do the work at a high level.

1057
01:52:48.046 --> 01:52:53.087
<v Bayron Wilson>I'm also the Chief Operating Officer and co-founder alongside of Dr. Elena Miller.

1058
01:52:54.880 --> 01:52:56.216
<v Louis Hammonds>Hello, my name is Louis Hammonds.

1059
01:52:56.539 --> 01:52:59.474
<v Louis Hammonds>I'm the Vice President of Operations, Urban Alchemy.

1060
01:53:00.054 --> 01:53:00.972
<v Louis Hammonds>It's a privilege to be here.

1061
01:53:01.037 --> 01:53:01.376
<v Louis Hammonds>Thank you.

1062
01:53:02.810 --> 01:53:03.676
<v Ian Clark>Good afternoon, committee.

1063
01:53:04.349 --> 01:53:05.363
<v Ian Clark>Uh, so grateful to be here.

1064
01:53:05.494 --> 01:53:06.462
<v Ian Clark>Thank you for your time.

1065
01:53:06.805 --> 01:53:11.774
<v Ian Clark>Ian Clark, Mark Johnson, practitioner with Urban Alchemy, currently supporting as the Chief of Human Resource.

1066
01:53:13.510 --> 01:53:16.020
<v Bayron Wilson>So I'll get started with, um, it's called the 1-2-3 model.

1067
01:53:16.520 --> 01:53:35.087
<v Bayron Wilson>We have one objective, that is to hire members that are formerly incarcerated, that have served long sentences, that has been justice impacted, formerly incarcerated, formerly homeless, um, maybe suffering or recovering from addiction.

1068
01:53:36.323 --> 01:53:37.414
<v Bayron Wilson>That is the objective.

1069
01:53:38.087 --> 01:53:47.506
<v Bayron Wilson>It's 2 objectives we are attempting to address: those falling through the safety nets and those men and women who have been locked out of the job market for periods of time.

1070
01:53:48.197 --> 01:53:49.560
<v Bayron Wilson>We have 3 lines of business.

1071
01:53:50.186 --> 01:53:59.476
<v Bayron Wilson>Our 3 lines are, we obviously have house communities, which we are provider, whether we provide houses for tiny homes, villages, safe parking.

1072
01:54:00.215 --> 01:54:03.136
<v Bayron Wilson>And of course, we have what we call connected communities.

1073
01:54:03.199 --> 01:54:08.172
<v Bayron Wilson>We operate What we call an oasis, where it's a place to be for our people experiencing homelessness.

1074
01:54:08.817 --> 01:54:11.601
<v Bayron Wilson>It's a way they can connect with no judgment.

1075
01:54:12.052 --> 01:54:17.835
<v Bayron Wilson>And of course, last but not least, we have what we call Safe Communities, which is we have a leading outreach through valued engagement.

1076
01:54:20.645 --> 01:54:30.685
<v Louis Hammonds>Urban Alchemy's mission is to transform people and urban spaces with respect and compassion and to heal communities at the intersection of extreme poverty, addiction, and mental illness.

1077
01:54:33.310 --> 01:54:43.457
<v Louis Hammonds>Speaking about the operational model, we hold ourselves and our partners to high standards, along with the city, the ombudsman, and even the support in the requests coming from you.

1078
01:54:44.845 --> 01:54:51.595
<v Louis Hammonds>We work hands-on with our shelter operating partners and maintain regular ongoing oversight of shelter management and activities.

1079
01:54:52.256 --> 01:55:03.970
<v Louis Hammonds>We believe all neighbors deserve pathways and I'd like to talk a little bit about our staff hiring, training, and supervision.

1080
01:55:07.240 --> 01:55:17.832
<v Louis Hammonds>Generally, all of our training comes from the esteemed Dr. Lena Miller, which is also our co-founder, as well as Dr. Lisa Delarue.

1081
01:55:18.619 --> 01:55:24.721
<v Louis Hammonds>And when a practitioner— it's what we call each other's practitioners— we say we're not guards, We're safety and service.

1082
01:55:25.331 --> 01:55:30.685
<v Louis Hammonds>Our practitioners are generally orientated into what our work will be out in the streets.

1083
01:55:31.246 --> 01:55:37.865
<v Louis Hammonds>We'll do de-escalation, conflict resolution, victim awareness, motivational interviewing.

1084
01:55:38.137 --> 01:55:43.587
<v Louis Hammonds>I think motivation is a big part of it, especially when we're working with people that are trying to work through change.

1085
01:55:44.470 --> 01:55:47.643
<v Louis Hammonds>Trauma-informed care and leadership training.

1086
01:55:47.756 --> 01:55:48.926
<v Louis Hammonds>That's the first beginning.

1087
01:55:49.021 --> 01:55:57.475
<v Louis Hammonds>Usually you're going to be in training for about 2 weeks, and then you'll be in on-the-job training for up to 90 days before the decision is made if you're going to become a practitioner.

1088
01:56:00.350 --> 01:56:11.615
<v Louis Hammonds>Oversight investigations are managed by employee relations investigators, with HR operations supporting operational follow-up, case readouts, and corrective implementations.

1089
01:56:12.100 --> 01:56:18.204
<v Louis Hammonds>And usually, if we do have a case readout, we will turn that over to the city as well as the ombudsman or anyone who's making that request.

1090
01:56:19.202 --> 01:56:20.090
<v Louis Hammonds>Corrective actions.

1091
01:56:20.976 --> 01:56:28.854
<v Louis Hammonds>Corrective actions range from employees' retraining to separation, depending on the nature of the allegation and substantiated findings.

1092
01:56:28.953 --> 01:56:35.166
<v Louis Hammonds>And I would say, as it was said earlier, we do practice a zero tolerance of any form of abuse.

1093
01:56:35.442 --> 01:56:37.251
<v Louis Hammonds>You will be terminated.

1094
01:56:37.332 --> 01:56:39.545
<v Louis Hammonds>We'll have to cease our operations at that point.

1095
01:56:41.621 --> 01:56:44.121
<v Ian Clark>And I'll talk about a lot of our work here in Portland.

1096
01:56:44.542 --> 01:56:47.854
<v Ian Clark>Currently, we're operating 4 interim housing shelter sites, tiny home sites.

1097
01:56:47.935 --> 01:56:56.422
<v Ian Clark>We also operate A downtown oasis where we're serving over 500 people a day coming in just to access kind of day services and respite.

1098
01:56:56.985 --> 01:57:01.948
<v Ian Clark>Our shelter, we currently serve over 6— about 660 people every night.

1099
01:57:02.961 --> 01:57:04.777
<v Ian Clark>You know, it's a privilege to do this work.

1100
01:57:04.936 --> 01:57:15.363
<v Ian Clark>And as there became kind of a demand and an opportunity for us to expand, we expanded rapidly, you know, recruiting people to come work for us and started receiving a number of grievances.

1101
01:57:15.475 --> 01:57:22.824
<v Ian Clark>And we've had a grievance policy You know, I'll say that there was a lapse on our end as it relates to the policy.

1102
01:57:23.578 --> 01:57:26.466
<v Ian Clark>We had a policy, we were utilizing it, but we stopped.

1103
01:57:27.011 --> 01:57:33.028
<v Ian Clark>You know, we had— we were starting to lose some of those grievances as they came through and we weren't tracking them adequately.

1104
01:57:33.076 --> 01:57:35.242
<v Ian Clark>So we want to take responsibility for that today.

1105
01:57:35.996 --> 01:57:40.215
<v Ian Clark>I know we've had the privilege to meet with some of you one-on-one, but just want to call that out head on.

1106
01:57:41.449 --> 01:57:44.934
<v Ian Clark>You heard Ms. Westman talk about some some of the changes that we've made.

1107
01:57:44.997 --> 01:57:46.782
<v Ian Clark>And so we've had to enhance that policy.

1108
01:57:46.829 --> 01:57:50.542
<v Ian Clark>And what that looks like is, number one, it's posted up at all sites.

1109
01:57:50.846 --> 01:57:51.601
<v Ian Clark>It's big.

1110
01:57:52.229 --> 01:57:55.862
<v Ian Clark>We kind of, we have 6 ways now to receive grievances from guests.

1111
01:57:56.978 --> 01:58:02.975
<v Ian Clark>It could be a QR code that they could hit and they could put it in, kind of a, it takes 'em to a sheet and it goes straight to 'em.

1112
01:58:03.444 --> 01:58:06.064
<v Ian Clark>Or they can get an actual form from leadership.

1113
01:58:06.130 --> 01:58:08.426
<v Ian Clark>They could fill it out, give it to a care coordinator.

1114
01:58:08.960 --> 01:58:09.898
<v Ian Clark>They could drop it in a box.

1115
01:58:09.945 --> 01:58:09.994
<v Ian Clark>Okay.

1116
01:58:10.751 --> 01:58:12.484
<v Ian Clark>They also have a number that they could call.

1117
01:58:12.792 --> 01:58:16.809
<v Ian Clark>They could call one of our main offices and kind of, you know, give whatever the grievance is.

1118
01:58:16.921 --> 01:58:17.731
<v Ian Clark>We record it.

1119
01:58:18.121 --> 01:58:22.373
<v Ian Clark>And then also lastly, there's an email address.

1120
01:58:22.519 --> 01:58:26.207
<v Ian Clark>So there's a grievance email address where folks, if they have something, they could send it.

1121
01:58:26.270 --> 01:58:30.121
<v Ian Clark>We made it a bunch of different ways because we know some folks have phones, some don't.

1122
01:58:30.604 --> 01:58:35.018
<v Ian Clark>Also, if they give it to us verbally, we can help them kind of fill it out and we'll create a ticket based on that.

1123
01:58:35.114 --> 01:58:36.435
<v Ian Clark>And so the ticket is in Zendesk.

1124
01:58:36.484 --> 01:58:36.564
<v Ian Clark>Okay.

1125
01:58:37.210 --> 01:58:38.880
<v Ian Clark>It'll go through our Zendesk system.

1126
01:58:38.880 --> 01:58:39.880
<v Ian Clark>It creates a ticket.

1127
01:58:39.920 --> 01:58:42.699
<v Ian Clark>We, part of our process now is 5 business days.

1128
01:58:42.699 --> 01:58:43.939
<v Ian Clark>Someone will reach out to you.

1129
01:58:43.939 --> 01:58:49.960
<v Ian Clark>We picked our best care coordinator manager to kind of receive it, sit down, understand the grievance.

1130
01:58:49.960 --> 01:58:58.949
<v Ian Clark>It's ranging from anything from cold food to some of the most serious accusations that you all, you know, heard about in the media over the last few months.

1131
01:58:59.739 --> 01:59:02.180
<v Ian Clark>When that grievance comes in, I'll go backwards too.

1132
01:59:02.180 --> 01:59:06.619
<v Ian Clark>Before it gets to the care coordinator, it's kind of triaged to see if we feel like it's something very serious.

1133
01:59:06.619 --> 01:59:06.779
<v Ian Clark>And then go to our ER team employee.

1134
01:59:08.539 --> 01:59:15.556
<v Ian Clark>Employee relations team, which is independent of operations to where they will do a follow-up and investigation of it.

1135
01:59:15.943 --> 01:59:23.314
<v Ian Clark>And then if it's even, if it's concerning an employee, we'll put that employee on paid leave while we kind of go through that investigation.

1136
01:59:23.810 --> 01:59:26.926
<v Ian Clark>It's tracked so that we have some fidelity to the timeline.

1137
01:59:27.199 --> 01:59:30.507
<v Ian Clark>We work to solve all grievances within 10 working days now.

1138
01:59:31.520 --> 01:59:36.356
<v Ian Clark>So we feel like we're able to hit that now that we have dedicated staff to it.

1139
01:59:36.663 --> 01:59:40.738
<v Ian Clark>We're not relying on our shelter leadership team solely to address these grievances.

1140
01:59:40.802 --> 01:59:47.149
<v Ian Clark>We have multiple kind of leadership in, but we have a dedicated staff member to do that and work towards a resolution.

1141
01:59:47.261 --> 01:59:55.907
<v Ian Clark>And if someone doesn't like the resolution, they are encouraged to go to the Ombudsman, who we— I know Louie had talked about— we meet with biweekly to kind of work through some of these cases as well.

1142
01:59:57.676 --> 02:00:04.063
<v Bayron Wilson>One thing I want to say, and I wanted to say thank you, Councilor For meeting with us one-on-one and allowing us to say what we need.

1143
02:00:04.144 --> 02:00:05.490
<v Bayron Wilson>And we take full responsibility.

1144
02:00:06.051 --> 02:00:08.938
<v Bayron Wilson>And I just shared with you then, I'll share with you now, this ain't like Johnson just said.

1145
02:00:09.243 --> 02:00:11.070
<v Bayron Wilson>When something is done wrong, we move swiftly.

1146
02:00:11.663 --> 02:00:18.046
<v Bayron Wilson>We move with a sense of urgency to separate, as our VP indicated.

1147
02:00:18.399 --> 02:00:21.814
<v Bayron Wilson>And we also worked with the city to make sure those things doesn't happen again.

1148
02:00:22.311 --> 02:00:24.060
<v Bayron Wilson>Now, let's be honest, we have bad actors.

1149
02:00:24.332 --> 02:00:25.261
<v Bayron Wilson>There have been bad actors.

1150
02:00:25.774 --> 02:00:30.630
<v Bayron Wilson>And when we have had bad actors, we wanted to make sure Those bad actors were notified.

1151
02:00:30.694 --> 02:00:37.568
<v Bayron Wilson>And we went as far as in terms of notifying law enforcement, including meeting with law enforcement to make sure we go to the fullest extent.

1152
02:00:38.457 --> 02:00:46.193
<v Bayron Wilson>Being that we are formerly incarcerated, being that we are formerly homeless, justice impacted, we're not ex-cons.

1153
02:00:46.951 --> 02:00:50.791
<v Bayron Wilson>We're fathers, we're husbands, we're men, we're women.

1154
02:00:51.469 --> 02:00:55.537
<v Bayron Wilson>We served our time and we wanna make sure those things are addressed in real time.

1155
02:00:55.599 --> 02:00:55.725
<v Bayron Wilson>Thank you.

1156
02:00:56.476 --> 02:01:09.145
<v Bayron Wilson>And because of that, you know, we understand that how we are looked upon as— but at the end of the day, what we, we want to make sure the guests have a better experience and they're treated— they're our number one priority.

1157
02:01:09.563 --> 02:01:11.856
<v Bayron Wilson>Because once upon a time, we were in some of their shoes.

1158
02:01:12.048 --> 02:01:12.947
<v Bayron Wilson>So I just want to address that.

1159
02:01:13.011 --> 02:01:16.090
<v Bayron Wilson>And I just want to say thank you all for, for meeting with us and talking about that.

1160
02:01:17.020 --> 02:01:27.765
<v Louis Hammonds>Thank you, B. Yeah, and kind of reference to that, it's not us versus them, it's just We're all together in this together, from our housed neighbors to our unhoused neighbors to our guests.

1161
02:01:28.470 --> 02:01:38.045
<v Louis Hammonds>Speaking with the coordination with Portland Solutions, we are in constant communication, and it's appreciative, the communication that we have and the guidance that we receive.

1162
02:01:38.574 --> 02:01:50.652
<v Louis Hammonds>We maintain a regular communication cadence with Portland Solutions, as was indicated earlier, with weekly operational meetings, biweekly shelter services, And we do meet also, as he said, with the ombudsman.

1163
02:01:50.699 --> 02:01:58.594
<v Louis Hammonds>It's actually a team of ombudsmen that bring certain grievances that people need support in, and we've been very supportive of that.

1164
02:01:58.643 --> 02:02:04.963
<v Louis Hammonds>I think it's a blessing to have an ombudsman that's going to help somebody kind of walk through the process and be with them.

1165
02:02:05.783 --> 02:02:11.895
<v Louis Hammonds>We do also turn over— we have a great camera system, and we turn over the cameras whenever there is a camera.

1166
02:02:11.960 --> 02:02:25.034
<v Louis Hammonds>We've also turned over a section of where the pods are that identify If there is a camera there so that the city or an ombudsman would know if there's availability of some kind of additional information that may need to be received.

1167
02:02:25.820 --> 02:02:26.286
<v Louis Hammonds>Reporting.

1168
02:02:26.479 --> 02:02:40.162
<v Louis Hammonds>We adhere to the HMIS reporting requirements, critical incident reporting requirements, and we notify by telephone immediately if there is any serious violation or anything has anything to do with emergency.

1169
02:02:40.900 --> 02:02:53.806
<v Ian Clark>We call the city, we call our Yeah, and we take all complaints seriously, grievances, whether they come from guests, and we have received some from the community.

1170
02:02:53.871 --> 02:02:57.793
<v Ian Clark>We have a good neighbor policy where we take care of not just the inside but the outside of our facilities.

1171
02:02:58.698 --> 02:03:05.707
<v Ian Clark>We also understand that, you know, what we aim for and why we're grateful that we're still receiving grievances is there's trust in the process.

1172
02:03:06.630 --> 02:03:16.190
<v Ian Clark>Some of us coming from marginalized situations, me formerly incarcerated, It's really about, we do believe and we model that those closest to the problem are closest to the solution.

1173
02:03:16.801 --> 02:03:27.015
<v Ian Clark>You know, we wanna build interpersonal relationships that are built with, you know, trust with folks so we can kind of walk 'em through that rehousing process, share some of our experiences and, you know, get to know them.

1174
02:03:27.064 --> 02:03:31.555
<v Ian Clark>But also just build an environment where, you know, rooted in love and respect.

1175
02:03:32.436 --> 02:03:40.359
<v Ian Clark>And a big part of that respect is folks trusting the process, knowing that they can go to leadership, they can put in a grievance, and they have a voice and will be heard.

1176
02:03:40.590 --> 02:03:45.100
<v Ian Clark>Not only by Urban Alchemy staff and leadership, but also by city leadership.

1177
02:03:45.100 --> 02:03:48.840
<v Ian Clark>And they have kind of multiple levels that they, that they could submit those.

1178
02:03:48.840 --> 02:03:51.100
<v Ian Clark>And we're grateful that we're continuing to receive those.

1179
02:03:51.100 --> 02:03:52.300
<v Ian Clark>And we have a feedback loop.

1180
02:03:52.300 --> 02:03:56.539
<v Ian Clark>We have community meetings where we're able to kind of meet with folks and hear back from them.

1181
02:03:56.539 --> 02:03:59.060
<v Ian Clark>So sometimes it doesn't even take getting to a grievance process.

1182
02:03:59.520 --> 02:04:02.050
<v Ian Clark>And we really look to illuminate community.

1183
02:04:03.680 --> 02:04:05.619
<v Ian Clark>Transparency.

1184
02:04:05.619 --> 02:04:06.869
<v Ian Clark>We really just want to have transparency.

1185
02:04:07.140 --> 02:04:08.859
<v Ian Clark>We're grateful for this opportunity to come speak.

1186
02:04:09.944 --> 02:04:20.431
<v Ian Clark>We invite council to, you know, reach out to us, you know, personally or our staff, and sometimes just pop up like they're, you know, and talk to guests, talk to staff, see, see the work that we're doing, see the impact that we're making.

1187
02:04:21.186 --> 02:04:25.523
<v Ian Clark>And also, you know, you know, with over 660 guests, we know it's not gonna be perfect.

1188
02:04:26.485 --> 02:04:32.653
<v Ian Clark>We can't, you know, we have folks with backgrounds and we can't necessarily guarantee what they've done before they work for us.

1189
02:04:32.909 --> 02:04:36.088
<v Ian Clark>But while they work for us, if it's brought to us, we're gonna hold them accountable.

1190
02:04:36.581 --> 02:04:40.228
<v Ian Clark>And it ranges anywhere from retraining all the way to separation.

1191
02:04:42.764 --> 02:04:46.791
<v Louis Hammonds>I want to talk a little bit about the lessons learned and the priorities that we have.

1192
02:04:47.338 --> 02:04:51.496
<v Louis Hammonds>Our number one priority is the safety and well-being of all of our guests.

1193
02:04:52.738 --> 02:04:55.904
<v Louis Hammonds>Lessons learned, we're forever students.

1194
02:04:56.936 --> 02:05:18.797
<v Louis Hammonds>I think it was important that we did continue to improve everything that we were working with, be it the grievance process, Be it who we had at certain sites, be it all of the different groups that we run to make sure that our guests are prepared for long-term housing, from NA to AA to art and all the other things that come through.

1195
02:05:19.248 --> 02:05:22.988
<v Louis Hammonds>It really helps to just bring a community together.

1196
02:05:23.682 --> 02:05:29.104
<v Louis Hammonds>Just recently for 4th of July, you know, I think it was one of the best.

1197
02:05:29.587 --> 02:05:32.028
<v Louis Hammonds>Sometimes I forget what I'm doing or why I'm doing it.

1198
02:05:32.078 --> 02:05:34.190
<v Louis Hammonds>I'm gonna be honest with with you, there's a lot of trauma that we're seeing.

1199
02:05:34.965 --> 02:05:46.055
<v Louis Hammonds>It's one reason why one of our values is self-care, because the trauma is real and you can very easily fall into compassion fatigue or burnout.

1200
02:05:47.390 --> 02:05:58.640
<v Louis Hammonds>But one thing Urban Download believes in is something that saved my life, is that we do believe that we can and we will care for others more than they may care for themselves at that time, because that's what turned my life around.

1201
02:05:59.463 --> 02:06:07.497
<v Louis Hammonds>And that's the mission and the vision that we have, is to treat everybody as human beings and to recognize that if we are the ones that did wrong, then we're going to hold ourselves accountable.

1202
02:06:08.220 --> 02:06:17.153
<v Louis Hammonds>And that's going to come straight from our mouths to the city, to you here, because we believe that that's what's most important, is the priority of our guests and keeping people safe.

1203
02:06:18.261 --> 02:06:19.274
<v Louis Hammonds>Lesson learned.

1204
02:06:19.932 --> 02:06:20.591
<v Louis Hammonds>Lesson learned.

1205
02:06:21.073 --> 02:06:23.145
<v Ian Clark>Oh, my bad.

1206
02:06:23.627 --> 02:06:36.420
<v Ian Clark>Just continue improvement, tracking it, You know, our oversight leadership, it's going through, you know, not only, you know, weekly and biweekly with the city, but with ourselves going through and making sure that we're checking our boxes.

1207
02:06:36.484 --> 02:06:41.121
<v Ian Clark>And when I mean checking our boxes, going through our Zendesk system, you know, has this been seen by HR?

1208
02:06:41.202 --> 02:06:41.506
<v Ian Clark>Yes.

1209
02:06:41.923 --> 02:06:42.998
<v Ian Clark>Has this been addressed?

1210
02:06:43.448 --> 02:06:44.170
<v Ian Clark>Is there closure?

1211
02:06:44.250 --> 02:06:47.042
<v Ian Clark>Are we communicating with the guests what the disposition was?

1212
02:06:47.539 --> 02:06:49.449
<v Ian Clark>And then accountability for ourselves.

1213
02:06:50.027 --> 02:06:54.453
<v Ian Clark>I'll just also say, you know, Intent versus impact.

1214
02:06:55.238 --> 02:06:59.949
<v Ian Clark>Sometimes there's policies, there's community guidelines that are meant to keep people safe.

1215
02:07:00.382 --> 02:07:04.164
<v Ian Clark>They have a negative impact sometimes on the individual who is in there.

1216
02:07:04.212 --> 02:07:13.203
<v Ian Clark>So sometimes really just giving folks a voice, explaining the why behind some of the policies that the facility may have, and it goes a long way.

1217
02:07:13.587 --> 02:07:21.114
<v Ian Clark>And really dedicating the resources, which in this instance really has been manpower of having people dedicated to hold this space of grievances.

1218
02:07:22.033 --> 02:07:25.420
<v Ian Clark>The guest experience, we strive for that 5-star experience for our guests.

1219
02:07:26.140 --> 02:07:30.036
<v Ian Clark>And so really putting people in position to hold that space and deliver that.

1220
02:07:32.819 --> 02:07:33.109
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1221
02:07:34.707 --> 02:07:36.319
<v Candace Avalos>Are we good?

1222
02:07:36.480 --> 02:07:37.158
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

1223
02:07:37.594 --> 02:07:39.304
<v Candace Avalos>I saw a natural close, but just—.

1224
02:07:39.304 --> 02:07:40.319
<v Louis Hammonds>People over policy.

1225
02:07:40.449 --> 02:07:41.934
<v Louis Hammonds>It's people over policy.

1226
02:07:42.127 --> 02:07:44.771
<v Louis Hammonds>It has to be that we got to critically think about what we're looking at.

1227
02:07:44.869 --> 02:07:48.221
<v Louis Hammonds>Our secret sauce is interpersonal relationships.

1228
02:07:49.072 --> 02:07:50.564
<v Louis Hammonds>That's how we're going to get everything done.

1229
02:07:50.676 --> 02:07:56.483
<v Louis Hammonds>And the stakeholders, you guys included, we appreciate all the work that you're doing, and we appreciate this oversight and insight.

1230
02:07:56.931 --> 02:07:57.637
<v Louis Hammonds>Makes us all better.

1231
02:07:58.615 --> 02:07:59.097
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1232
02:07:59.804 --> 02:08:03.220
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you again for your presentation and for setting the stage here.

1233
02:08:03.974 --> 02:08:13.375
<v Candace Avalos>Um, colleagues, I don't see hands in here, and if it's okay, I'm going to move to testimony just so we can get that out of the way, and then we can bring you all back up and have Further discussion.

1234
02:08:13.905 --> 02:08:14.453
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you all.

1235
02:08:16.260 --> 02:08:18.525
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so Diego, why don't we go ahead and call up testimony?

1236
02:08:20.539 --> 02:08:27.060
<v Diego>First we have Peggy McDaniel, Lori Lang, Robert Powers.

1237
02:08:29.960 --> 02:08:31.442
<v Candace Avalos>Welcome, please state your name and go ahead.

1238
02:08:31.844 --> 02:08:33.502
<v Brandy Westerman>Hi, I'm Peggy McDaniel.

1239
02:08:34.646 --> 02:08:38.738
<v Brandy Westerman>Um, I am a homeowner and I live 3 blocks from the Clinton Triangle Shelter.

1240
02:08:39.578 --> 02:08:46.653
<v Brandy Westerman>I have served on its community oversight committee for the past 3 years and actually led yoga classes in the wellness program there.

1241
02:08:47.760 --> 02:08:53.872
<v Brandy Westerman>I urge you to continue supporting Urban Alchemy as a shelter service provider across multiple sites.

1242
02:08:54.578 --> 02:09:02.296
<v Brandy Westerman>I recognize there have been complaints from individuals who have received services through Urban Alchemy, and those concerns should be heard and addressed.

1243
02:09:02.680 --> 02:09:04.301
<v Brandy Westerman>Accountability really does matter.

1244
02:09:04.685 --> 02:09:08.646
<v Brandy Westerman>And every organization receiving public funds should be held to the highest standard.

1245
02:09:09.432 --> 02:09:16.856
<v Brandy Westerman>But we should evaluate Urban Alchemy based on the totality of its work and its built relationships, including those with its neighbors.

1246
02:09:18.011 --> 02:09:23.078
<v Brandy Westerman>Urban Alchemy serves people experiencing homelessness, which you all know, addiction, mental illness, and trauma.

1247
02:09:23.543 --> 02:09:25.837
<v Brandy Westerman>This is some of the most difficult work in our community.

1248
02:09:26.752 --> 02:09:36.427
<v Brandy Westerman>They do a great job de-escalating conflict, building relationships, and creating truly safer shelter environments, and I've seen them move people towards stability.

1249
02:09:36.942 --> 02:09:37.551
<v Brandy Westerman>And—.

1250
02:09:37.664 --> 02:09:38.868
<v Brandy Westerman>Oh, I'm out of time almost.

1251
02:09:39.494 --> 02:09:46.463
<v Brandy Westerman>Um, let me just finish with saying their model reflects something that we say we believe in— second chances.

1252
02:09:47.137 --> 02:09:51.280
<v Brandy Westerman>And so I'd like to see us continue to support them and the work that they do here in Portland.

1253
02:09:52.355 --> 02:09:53.319
<v Leslie Goodloe>Thank you.

1254
02:09:53.720 --> 02:09:54.748
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1255
02:09:55.648 --> 02:09:55.936
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

1256
02:09:57.654 --> 02:09:58.234
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good afternoon.

1257
02:09:58.297 --> 02:09:59.470
<v Mitch Green>My name is Robert Powers.

1258
02:09:59.646 --> 02:10:05.284
<v Mitch Green>I am a guest at the Urban Alchemy North Safe Rest Village.

1259
02:10:05.990 --> 02:10:08.224
<v Mitch Green>I have been there since February.

1260
02:10:08.994 --> 02:10:13.314
<v Mitch Green>Since that time, I've gotten my documentation squared away.

1261
02:10:13.701 --> 02:10:15.259
<v Mitch Green>I've become employed.

1262
02:10:15.948 --> 02:10:20.752
<v Mitch Green>I'm about 2 weeks away from hopefully being permanently housed.

1263
02:10:26.394 --> 02:10:41.671
<v Mitch Green>Was illegally evicted in October of last year and spent two weeks in a two-man tent on the Springwater Trail, followed by two and a half months in a car.

1264
02:10:43.086 --> 02:10:48.453
<v Mitch Green>When the city came to take the car away, I thought I was going back to the tent.

1265
02:10:48.876 --> 02:10:49.261
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Smith.

1266
02:10:49.679 --> 02:10:50.658
<v Mitch Green>I was homeless for a little bit.

1267
02:10:50.867 --> 02:10:54.769
<v Mitch Green>One of the PBOT employees asked me if I had looked into shelter.

1268
02:10:55.073 --> 02:11:03.006
<v Mitch Green>I have post-traumatic stress disorder, so dorm-style shelters are not something I can do.

1269
02:11:04.291 --> 02:11:10.006
<v Mitch Green>He made a phone call and got me in and out at Urban Alchemy, and I'm really pleased to be there.

1270
02:11:10.712 --> 02:11:11.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you.

1271
02:11:15.127 --> 02:11:15.546
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1272
02:11:16.983 --> 02:11:18.564
<v Diego>Once more for Lori Lang.

1273
02:11:23.029 --> 02:11:30.375
<v Diego>Okay, next up is Marlene Howell, Vicki Payne, Tatiana Prieto.

1274
02:11:31.338 --> 02:11:32.841
<v Diego>Marlene and Vicki are online.

1275
02:11:33.828 --> 02:11:37.407
<v Diego>Marlene, you're welcome to begin your testimony and unmute yourself when you're ready.

1276
02:11:45.556 --> 02:11:46.466
<v Marlene Howell>Hello, councilors.

1277
02:11:46.530 --> 02:11:47.100
<v Vicki Payne>Can you hear me?

1278
02:11:48.707 --> 02:11:48.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1279
02:11:50.412 --> 02:11:50.689
<v Marlene Howell>Okay.

1280
02:11:50.738 --> 02:11:52.654
<v Marlene Howell>Hello, I'm, I'm Marlene Howell.

1281
02:11:56.109 --> 02:11:59.011
<v Marlene Howell>And I thank you for the opportunity to share with you today.

1282
02:12:00.398 --> 02:12:29.311
<v Marlene Howell>I work with Southwest Outreach, an organization which addresses some of the basic needs of neighbors living outside in the general areas of Hillsdale, Multnomah Village, Ash Creek, Crestwood, With Urban Alchemy facing allegations of both civil and criminal offenses, how does Portland Solutions and other city offices assure that within a robust due process that those making the allegations are taken seriously and held safe from retribution?

1283
02:12:29.666 --> 02:12:32.532
<v Marlene Howell>I didn't hear much about that today in the earlier presentation.

1284
02:12:33.127 --> 02:12:36.994
<v Marlene Howell>Are those who allege violations really expected to first go to a member of Urban Alchemy?

1285
02:12:37.047 --> 02:12:37.528
<v Marlene Howell>I think that's a very good question.

1286
02:12:37.818 --> 02:12:38.845
<v Marlene Howell>To make a complaint.

1287
02:12:39.167 --> 02:12:40.547
<v Marlene Howell>I'd like to have that clarified.

1288
02:12:41.173 --> 02:12:48.046
<v Marlene Howell>Which neighbors in the Multnomah Village do the mayor and some of the District 4 councilors take most seriously?

1289
02:12:48.881 --> 02:12:54.694
<v Marlene Howell>It's important to note that the loudest and most connected neighbors do not necessarily represent the neighborhood overall.

1290
02:12:55.640 --> 02:13:02.497
<v Marlene Howell>Some of their concerns are valid, and while others are clearly grounded in ruling class politics, it's important to make that distinguished.

1291
02:13:02.594 --> 02:13:02.753
<v Marlene Howell>Thank you.

1292
02:13:04.635 --> 02:13:07.918
<v Marlene Howell>Many of us welcome the MSRV, and we do want it to succeed.

1293
02:13:08.743 --> 02:13:16.555
<v Marlene Howell>Where will those who are not ready for a high-barrier shelter really go, given that so many county and city shelters are closing?

1294
02:13:16.603 --> 02:13:19.368
<v Marlene Howell>And how about microvillages as a part of social housing?

1295
02:13:19.432 --> 02:13:24.600
<v Marlene Howell>They are less costly, they are self-governed, and we know that they deserve more serious attention from the city.

1296
02:13:24.827 --> 02:13:25.180
<v Marlene Howell>Thank you.

1297
02:13:28.627 --> 02:13:28.966
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1298
02:13:30.335 --> 02:13:30.623
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

1299
02:13:31.685 --> 02:13:38.061
<v Brandy Westerman>Hello, my name is Tatiana Prieto, and I, um, basically am working at Oasis right now.

1300
02:13:38.367 --> 02:13:43.716
<v Brandy Westerman>But before all that, I was a resident at Urban Alchemy in Clinton Triangle.

1301
02:13:44.375 --> 02:13:46.976
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I felt so safe there.

1302
02:13:47.507 --> 02:13:49.130
<v Brandy Westerman>Um, I love the whole experience.

1303
02:13:49.354 --> 02:14:04.323
<v Brandy Westerman>Um, currently right now, I actually got my housing too through them, so I'm, I'm perfectly safe, and, and I'm enjoying I really hope that they go strong and for a very long time.

1304
02:14:07.109 --> 02:14:09.185
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, I'm sorry, that's all.

1305
02:14:11.149 --> 02:14:11.393
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1306
02:14:12.479 --> 02:14:13.664
<v Diego>Next is Vicki Payne.

1307
02:14:14.185 --> 02:14:17.139
<v Diego>Vicki, you can unmute yourself and begin your testimony when you're ready.

1308
02:14:19.289 --> 02:14:20.578
<v Vicki Payne>Hi, my name is Vicki Payne.

1309
02:14:20.756 --> 02:14:26.948
<v Vicki Payne>I'm speaking on my own behalf, once again urging you to not single out Urban Alchemy as a provider when the issue is the model.

1310
02:14:27.170 --> 02:14:27.570
<v Vicki Payne>Councilor Smith.

1311
02:14:27.747 --> 02:14:40.194
<v Vicki Payne>Low barrier sites with peers in recovery in charge are asking for sketchy situation— situations to occur, and we've seen similar incidents play out with several county vendors using this model as well.

1312
02:14:40.853 --> 02:14:53.908
<v Vicki Payne>If this council has an issue, you need to take it up with the county, but I know Councilor Green has somewhat hypocritically been outspoken about not converting an SRV in his district to high barrier, something hundreds of clients have asked for so they can meet requirements to enter supportive housing.

1313
02:14:54.985 --> 02:15:03.097
<v Vicki Payne>Urban Alchemy's Clinton Triangle task site has pushed the most clients through to supportive housing faster than any other provider in Multnomah County.

1314
02:15:03.725 --> 02:15:12.720
<v Vicki Payne>While other providers have been in the news with clients saying they've lived in their pod for 1 to 3 years, many UA clients move on to housing within 2 to 3 months.

1315
02:15:13.234 --> 02:15:21.059
<v Vicki Payne>Of course, we need oversight and accountability of complaints, but we need to understand one size does not fit all in this extremely difficult behavioral health work.

1316
02:15:21.492 --> 02:15:26.161
<v Vicki Payne>Also, when are you going to be scheduling the public comments on Home Forward?

1317
02:15:26.369 --> 02:15:31.247
<v Vicki Payne>Let's focus on the issues there and that much more important next step in our homeless neighbors' path forward.

1318
02:15:31.743 --> 02:15:41.145
<v Vicki Payne>The mismanagement issues have continued to be ignored by certain members of this committee, and we need a public hearing on that before the Trump administration starts cutting more funding to this much-needed resource.

1319
02:15:41.530 --> 02:15:46.198
<v Vicki Payne>We are not treating our low-income housed neighbors with the dignity they deserve by ignoring this widespread issue.

1320
02:15:46.520 --> 02:15:46.856
<v Vicki Payne>Thank you.

1321
02:15:49.328 --> 02:15:50.418
<v Diego>That concludes testimony.

1322
02:15:51.670 --> 02:15:52.744
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you so much.

1323
02:15:53.579 --> 02:15:54.045
<v Marlene Howell>Thank you.

1324
02:15:54.926 --> 02:15:58.072
<v Candace Avalos>Um, go ahead and come back on up.

1325
02:15:58.216 --> 02:16:05.740
<v Candace Avalos>And just want to say to the testifiers who shared their experience and also shared that they're on their way to housing, congratulations.

1326
02:16:05.997 --> 02:16:10.554
<v Candace Avalos>And really good to hear, um, that that is a service that has benefited you.

1327
02:16:10.618 --> 02:16:11.740
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you for sharing that.

1328
02:16:14.018 --> 02:16:14.854
<v Louis Hammonds>It's important.

1329
02:16:16.881 --> 02:16:21.497
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so colleagues, now is the time to ask some questions.

1330
02:16:21.560 --> 02:16:22.927
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, we got someone in the chat.

1331
02:16:23.475 --> 02:16:24.350
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead, Vice Chair Green.

1332
02:16:24.627 --> 02:16:25.536
<v Mitch Green>I'll kick us off.

1333
02:16:25.600 --> 02:16:27.677
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much, Chair Avalos.

1334
02:16:27.792 --> 02:16:33.415
<v Mitch Green>And I want to just give a warm moment of gratitude, particularly to Urban Alchemy.

1335
02:16:33.463 --> 02:16:34.836
<v Mitch Green>You're not required to come here.

1336
02:16:34.902 --> 02:16:36.516
<v Mitch Green>We didn't compel your attendance.

1337
02:16:37.001 --> 02:16:40.085
<v Mitch Green>We asked if you would like to join this and be a little bit vulnerable here.

1338
02:16:40.551 --> 02:16:41.101
<v Mitch Green>And you said yes.

1339
02:16:41.716 --> 02:16:42.862
<v Mitch Green>And I think that that's laudable.

1340
02:16:44.884 --> 02:16:51.041
<v Mitch Green>You had a meeting with my office, and I heard basically everything, everything you shared with me, you shared with the public.

1341
02:16:51.734 --> 02:16:52.764
<v Mitch Green>And that's a good thing.

1342
02:16:53.763 --> 02:16:58.304
<v Mitch Green>That for me is a big piece that I think has been missing for a lot of Portlanders.

1343
02:16:58.352 --> 02:16:59.816
<v Mitch Green>And it's not necessarily about you.

1344
02:17:00.444 --> 02:17:05.646
<v Mitch Green>Well, it is about Urban Alchemy, but it is, it's just about this gap in transparency.

1345
02:17:05.838 --> 02:17:06.096
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

1346
02:17:06.422 --> 02:17:08.459
<v Mitch Green>I'm very encouraged to hear that you're committed to that.

1347
02:17:09.244 --> 02:17:11.538
<v Mitch Green>So thank you for kind of showing up the way that you've shown up.

1348
02:17:12.179 --> 02:17:14.537
<v Mitch Green>I think most of my comments will be for Portland Solutions.

1349
02:17:15.226 --> 02:17:29.049
<v Mitch Green>There may be some areas where we need to ask around committee to kind of weigh in on that, but I wanted to make sure right up front I gave you guys due credit for kind of showing up in this space, which could potentially be a little unknown and a little hostile.

1350
02:17:29.113 --> 02:17:36.022
<v Mitch Green>And so I just, you know, and I can tell you guys are feeling I'm feeling your work up there, and I want to acknowledge that.

1351
02:17:36.266 --> 02:17:36.938
<v Mitch Green>So thank you for that.

1352
02:17:38.328 --> 02:17:42.467
<v Mitch Green>I think that I just kind of want to start by contextualizing this a little bit.

1353
02:17:44.202 --> 02:17:46.037
<v Mitch Green>I want to recognize that this is an enormous challenge.

1354
02:17:47.004 --> 02:18:03.751
<v Mitch Green>Like, the contract that we have signed to do this work tries to do an awful lot, and it's responding to basically a series of failures in our society that have— that people have dropped through the cracks because of.

1355
02:18:04.869 --> 02:18:09.842
<v Mitch Green>We generate poverty by underinvesting from, like, you know, cradle to grave, basically.

1356
02:18:11.568 --> 02:18:17.961
<v Mitch Green>We have failed to invest in the public health institutions that we need to give folks an opportunity to stay healthy in our community.

1357
02:18:18.027 --> 02:18:22.438
<v Mitch Green>And so— and also we've failed to build the housing and to have the affordable housing that we need.

1358
02:18:22.712 --> 02:18:27.157
<v Mitch Green>And so we're seeing the sort of Conjoint outcome of those cumulative failures.

1359
02:18:27.207 --> 02:18:40.304
<v Mitch Green>And so addressing folks experiencing a variety of complicated issues in through like a sheltering model is not the best tool, but it is the tool that we've chosen to do at this point in time.

1360
02:18:40.916 --> 02:18:44.406
<v Mitch Green>And so I just want to recognize that that's the work ahead of us.

1361
02:18:46.323 --> 02:18:48.933
<v Mitch Green>That doesn't then take away though the need to ask questions.

1362
02:18:49.471 --> 02:19:05.102
<v Mitch Green>To engage in some very public conversation around what controls we have on the city side that we can either improve and what the public understands that their dollars are being used for in connection to those outcomes.

1363
02:19:05.229 --> 02:19:07.237
<v Mitch Green>So that's kind of the spirit that I'm bringing here.

1364
02:19:07.800 --> 02:19:37.621
<v Mitch Green>I'd also note that in the budget, I brought forward some amendments that were reacting to some reporting that was also reacting to My feeling that I kind of took a leap of faith actually when I entered this job, because I entered this job knowing that in 2023 there was already concerns, or maybe as early as 2022 perhaps, there was already concerns that if we were going to go down this road instead of a different model, we were going to expose ourselves to some issues that some other jurisdictions had faced.

1365
02:19:38.119 --> 02:19:42.182
<v Mitch Green>And so didn't kind of take it up right away because it's like, I'm going to trust the process.

1366
02:19:42.935 --> 02:19:51.417
<v Mitch Green>And now we're at the point now, a year and a half later, where, okay, I have to intervene as councilor as part of a budget committee.

1367
02:19:51.611 --> 02:20:05.993
<v Mitch Green>And so my budget amendment really was entering into the space to say, like, how can I as a councilor say yes to a budget that provides another year without knowing that we've tried to have some of these crucial accountability questions addressed?

1368
02:20:06.120 --> 02:20:10.738
<v Mitch Green>That amendment wasn't— it didn't have the support it needed to pass in that moment.

1369
02:20:11.496 --> 02:20:13.093
<v Mitch Green>But the need to do oversight didn't go away.

1370
02:20:13.674 --> 02:20:17.144
<v Mitch Green>And so I was thinking about how do I want to continue this work?

1371
02:20:17.934 --> 02:20:23.905
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, I'd had some— I had some colleagues with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney when she was the council president on like, what does oversight look like?

1372
02:20:24.405 --> 02:20:36.157
<v Mitch Green>I approached the chair of the Housing Committee to say, is this appropriate for us to have a very informal, actually, conversation here that's not a resolution that I file to start to kind of like—.

1373
02:20:36.157 --> 02:20:36.222
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

1374
02:20:36.685 --> 02:20:39.763
<v Mitch Green>Have that same spirit that we had in the housing context.

1375
02:20:40.308 --> 02:20:44.361
<v Mitch Green>I think that I wanted to start at a very low level of temperature, right?

1376
02:20:44.458 --> 02:20:45.963
<v Mitch Green>I want to ask questions in good faith.

1377
02:20:46.236 --> 02:21:11.351
<v Mitch Green>I don't want this to feel adversarial at all because I want us to get to a place where Portlanders feel very good about this idea that if we're going to spend a lot of public money on trying to solve an issue and that there are reasonable concerns about that, that City Council is, is going to ask the tough questions and give you an opportunity, Mayor, City Administrator, Portland Solutions staff, to engage in that dialogue with us, the provider with us.

1378
02:21:12.925 --> 02:21:14.404
<v Mitch Green>So that's the spirit I'm showing up in.

1379
02:21:15.560 --> 02:21:24.587
<v Mitch Green>I'm really, you know, I sort of asked my staff to help prep me on this, and I said I don't want any sort of like, you know, where did you know this by that, you know, like none of that energy today.

1380
02:21:24.750 --> 02:21:29.408
<v Mitch Green>Really, for me, it's like I want to kind of ground, level set some assumptions that we have.

1381
02:21:31.068 --> 02:21:41.540
<v Mitch Green>What we have done since, and you've laid out some of that in your presentation, Brandy, but, you know, what we have done since and what we can expect ahead of the next budget decision, frankly.

1382
02:21:42.945 --> 02:21:52.388
<v Mitch Green>And so because I did start this as a councilor through the budget, I'd want to start through procurement, actually, when I start my questioning here.

1383
02:21:54.863 --> 02:22:12.541
<v Mitch Green>One of the things that One of the things that I was informed of, or one of the responses I got from Director Brokernapp during the budget amendment process, was that it's really not feasible to try to find a different vendor, or that we did try to find potentially a different vendor and that there were not any takers at that time.

1384
02:22:12.621 --> 02:22:20.281
<v Mitch Green>And so really Urban Alchemy stepped into this space and we're, you know, there is no alternative for Urban Alchemy, which was kind of the message.

1385
02:22:20.344 --> 02:22:21.308
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a fair statement.

1386
02:22:21.020 --> 02:22:21.726
<v Mitch Green>That's the message that I received.

1387
02:22:21.774 --> 02:22:22.915
<v Mitch Green>So I want to make sure that that's true.

1388
02:22:22.979 --> 02:22:31.944
<v Mitch Green>But also, I want to understand a little bit more about the RFP process that the city went through, which I think precedes a lot of us, certainly precedes all the elected officials.

1389
02:22:32.861 --> 02:22:36.829
<v Mitch Green>But it might— I mean, surely Portland Solutions has some continuity of knowledge there.

1390
02:22:36.958 --> 02:22:45.394
<v Mitch Green>And so help me understand that RFP process that probably began in 2022 that led to awarding the contract to UA.

1391
02:22:45.796 --> 02:22:52.462
<v Mitch Green>And then what would it look like if we had Do you want to speak to 2022?

1392
02:22:52.543 --> 02:22:53.001
<v Hank Smith>The first one, right.

1393
02:22:53.212 --> 02:22:54.681
<v Hank Smith>I'll speak to '24.

1394
02:22:55.530 --> 02:22:56.495
<v Hank Smith>So we're on the same page.

1395
02:22:56.609 --> 02:22:56.948
<v Hank Smith>That's good.

1396
02:22:57.012 --> 02:23:00.443
<v Hank Smith>Yeah, thank you for the question, Vice Chair Green.

1397
02:23:01.426 --> 02:23:11.568
<v Hank Smith>You know, I actually started my work with the City of Portland right in the midst of that first RFP in which Urban Alchemy applied for that and then got the contract.

1398
02:23:12.956 --> 02:23:27.893
<v Hank Smith>And I think that's where Director Brokernapp was referring to during that That RFP, there weren't a lot of applicants and there weren't a lot of— and of those applicants, not very many were qualified, especially to handle sites as large as we were planning at the time.

1399
02:23:28.566 --> 02:23:31.827
<v Hank Smith>And that was a pretty rigorous process still.

1400
02:23:31.940 --> 02:23:42.379
<v Hank Smith>I was here in this room when we had upwards of 8 hours of public testimony about that kind of— that contract to be transparent, to get questions out.

1401
02:23:43.022 --> 02:23:44.595
<v Hank Smith>Thank you.

1402
02:23:45.511 --> 02:23:48.818
<v Hank Smith>In that RFP, we're asking for shelter provider to do something very hard.

1403
02:23:48.882 --> 02:23:56.510
<v Hank Smith>And I think you put it eloquently about folks slipping through the cracks because of decades of underinvestment in a wider service net.

1404
02:23:56.895 --> 02:24:01.760
<v Hank Smith>And those folks are on the streets of Portland and require a high level of care.

1405
02:24:02.193 --> 02:24:11.292
<v Hank Smith>They're high acuity folks that might need a certain level of behavioral Healthcare service that isn't there right now.

1406
02:24:11.596 --> 02:24:13.808
<v Hank Smith>But to stay on the streets is only to make it worse.

1407
02:24:13.921 --> 02:24:21.647
<v Hank Smith>And so we're asking a shelter operator to take that kind of population in and care for them and help them navigate to a better place.

1408
02:24:22.816 --> 02:24:27.817
<v Hank Smith>And that first RFP is where— that sentiment is where that RFP was coming from.

1409
02:24:28.090 --> 02:24:32.256
<v Hank Smith>And then the number of folks applying to do that work was relatively low.

1410
02:24:33.299 --> 02:24:39.516
<v Hank Smith>And Director Brocker-Knapp was involved in kind of researching and traveling around and got to know Urban Alchemy at that time.

1411
02:24:40.831 --> 02:24:45.959
<v Hank Smith>And they submitted a package that did ultimately earn that contract.

1412
02:24:46.070 --> 02:24:55.364
<v Hank Smith>Subsequently, we've had another RFP that's had wider, a wider variety of applicants and kind of, I think, a wider variety of needs outlined in the RFP.

1413
02:24:55.429 --> 02:24:56.422
<v Hank Smith>And Brandy can speak to that.

1414
02:24:57.415 --> 02:24:58.745
<v Brandy Westerman>Yeah, thank you for that question.

1415
02:24:58.858 --> 02:25:01.245
<v Brandy Westerman>And I also just want to say thank you for that framing.

1416
02:25:01.502 --> 02:25:04.579
<v Brandy Westerman>I think that's a really important framing that you provided Thank you, Mr.

1417
02:25:04.628 --> 02:25:04.756
<v Brandy Westerman>Chair.

1418
02:25:04.805 --> 02:25:05.816
<v Brandy Westerman>So I appreciate that.

1419
02:25:06.168 --> 02:25:13.170
<v Brandy Westerman>So a year and a half ago, approximately, we ran a second RFP process for 3 different types of shelter.

1420
02:25:13.716 --> 02:25:18.933
<v Brandy Westerman>And this was with standing up the mayor's plan to address unsheltered homelessness.

1421
02:25:19.013 --> 02:25:29.834
<v Brandy Westerman>We were looking for providers for overnight shelter, for day centers, and we included the alternative shelter 24/7 provision in that RFP process.

1422
02:25:29.899 --> 02:25:30.012
<v Brandy Westerman>Yes.

1423
02:25:30.347 --> 02:25:33.361
<v Brandy Westerman>So this was an open applicant process.

1424
02:25:33.856 --> 02:25:38.103
<v Brandy Westerman>We received just 4 applications in total for alternative shelter.

1425
02:25:39.129 --> 02:25:44.593
<v Brandy Westerman>Those, all 4 of those organizations that applied were awarded contracts.

1426
02:25:44.914 --> 02:25:50.329
<v Brandy Westerman>So that included Urban Alchemy, Sunstone Way, the Salvation Army, and Cultivate Initiatives.

1427
02:25:50.779 --> 02:25:56.083
<v Brandy Westerman>So those have been our 4 partners working in alternative shelter, as you know.

1428
02:25:56.548 --> 02:26:02.524
<v Brandy Westerman>Sunstone Way has had some problems of their own and has recently closed their doors as of last week.

1429
02:26:03.918 --> 02:26:08.582
<v Brandy Westerman>Salvation Army was running the Sunderland RV park site for us.

1430
02:26:09.575 --> 02:26:12.379
<v Brandy Westerman>They continue to be an operator with us for overnight shelter.

1431
02:26:12.459 --> 02:26:14.702
<v Brandy Westerman>They're not currently operating alternative shelter.

1432
02:26:15.183 --> 02:26:19.975
<v Brandy Westerman>Cultivate Initiatives continues to successfully operate the Menlo Park Shelter in East Portland.

1433
02:26:21.289 --> 02:26:21.690
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1434
02:26:21.834 --> 02:26:22.586
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that.

1435
02:26:23.670 --> 02:26:36.548
<v Mitch Green>Would you say that it's— is it fair to say that the number of respondents to the RFP is really a function of the scope and what you've tried to put into this one big contract?

1436
02:26:38.439 --> 02:26:49.359
<v Brandy Westerman>Well, I think we have to go through a process of actually checking that assumption, right, and asking the providers in our metro area why or why not.

1437
02:26:50.117 --> 02:26:55.040
<v Brandy Westerman>In terms of whether they applied for the RFP to really understand what's at play.

1438
02:26:55.504 --> 02:26:56.932
<v Brandy Westerman>I do think it's a big ask.

1439
02:26:57.172 --> 02:27:00.411
<v Brandy Westerman>What we're asking in these alternative shelter sites is big.

1440
02:27:00.459 --> 02:27:10.754
<v Brandy Westerman>We are asking folks to care for individuals who are coming from potentially decades of sleeping outdoors, and that can be a really, really hard task.

1441
02:27:11.395 --> 02:27:16.862
<v Brandy Westerman>Some of the sites are very large, and I think we also have to acknowledge the complexity with serving a large population.

1442
02:27:16.911 --> 02:27:17.006
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you.

1443
02:27:18.420 --> 02:27:19.143
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for that.

1444
02:27:20.201 --> 02:27:23.638
<v Mitch Green>If I'm not mistaken, so the master contract was for $90 million.

1445
02:27:23.702 --> 02:27:27.540
<v Mitch Green>That's what we get in the City Administrator's report.

1446
02:27:28.295 --> 02:27:32.887
<v Mitch Green>And in this last budget, I think there was only about $33 million of headroom left on that contract.

1447
02:27:33.031 --> 02:27:34.540
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's what we appropriate in this budget.

1448
02:27:34.588 --> 02:27:37.719
<v Mitch Green>So this contract is expired.

1449
02:27:37.783 --> 02:27:41.092
<v Mitch Green>It would need to be re-upped in the next fiscal year.

1450
02:27:41.156 --> 02:27:54.370
<v Mitch Green>And so— I think I raised that question only, one, to check my assumption on that, but then also, two, to say, you know, if like the path before us is kind of— there's like a twofold path here.

1451
02:27:54.451 --> 02:27:54.532
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1452
02:27:54.694 --> 02:28:01.231
<v Mitch Green>One is to sort of say, do we seek money to refresh that master contract and continue doing the same thing that we've been doing?

1453
02:28:01.975 --> 02:28:15.865
<v Mitch Green>Or when we think about preparing for the next budget, preparing for the next RFP cycle, are we going to think about a different scope that we're I'm wondering if Portland Solutions— Mayor, feel free to weigh in on that.

1454
02:28:15.945 --> 02:28:21.141
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate your attendance today, but these are the kind of questions that I'd really like to understand at this juncture.

1455
02:28:21.317 --> 02:28:29.384
<v Mitch Green>Because I think what I learned in the budget process is despite my best efforts, I don't think that I necessarily had enough time to make my case to my colleagues.

1456
02:28:29.496 --> 02:28:39.731
<v Mitch Green>But also I heard from folks, I think I heard from Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, that like, I'm with you on the need to have this conversation, Let's have a longer conversation around this, and this isn't the space for it.

1457
02:28:39.780 --> 02:28:41.289
<v Mitch Green>So this is the time to have that.

1458
02:28:41.385 --> 02:28:43.166
<v Mitch Green>So I'm curious if you have a response to that.

1459
02:28:44.500 --> 02:28:45.093
<v Brandy Westerman>I can respond.

1460
02:28:45.141 --> 02:28:46.907
<v Brandy Westerman>Did you want to share something first?

1461
02:28:47.051 --> 02:28:47.228
<v Brandy Westerman>Okay.

1462
02:28:48.416 --> 02:28:52.558
<v Brandy Westerman>I think a couple of things that I'd just like to raise into the conversation.

1463
02:28:52.671 --> 02:29:00.842
<v Brandy Westerman>I don't think I have a direct answer for you at this time because I think that that decision is really a decision that all of you are going to also need to work with us on.

1464
02:29:01.435 --> 02:29:04.430
<v Brandy Westerman>I think we are ready to implement What gets decided.

1465
02:29:05.530 --> 02:29:23.560
<v Brandy Westerman>I will say that what we've been trying to do is balance a need to provide a high level of service that helps people move to the next best step for them from shelter, which is really meant to be a transitional space for growth and, and kind of further momentum and stability.

1466
02:29:25.118 --> 02:29:27.004
<v Brandy Westerman>And we're trying to work at scale.

1467
02:29:27.412 --> 02:29:49.661
<v Brandy Westerman>So we, we know that what we've What we've seen is a rising number of people experiencing homelessness in our community, and we're trying to ensure that we have a bed for everybody every night and that they have that opportunity to then get into a high-service shelter like those being operated by Urban Alchemy, where they can work with a care coordinator and find connection to services that are going to help them on that journey.

1468
02:29:50.094 --> 02:30:02.345
<v Brandy Westerman>And I think those are the things that we find challenging to weigh when we look at other shelter models and shelter options is being able to ensure that we have that high service possibility and we can serve everybody who needs a bed.

1469
02:30:03.502 --> 02:30:03.968
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1470
02:30:04.209 --> 02:30:06.825
<v Mitch Green>I'm— oh, oh, go ahead.

1471
02:30:06.873 --> 02:30:07.468
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, let me—.

1472
02:30:07.581 --> 02:30:09.041
<v Dan Ryan>And Brandy, thank you.

1473
02:30:09.426 --> 02:30:17.149
<v Dan Ryan>First of all, Brandy, Hank, Bayron, Louie, and Ian, thank you for being here and for your comments.

1474
02:30:17.215 --> 02:30:20.217
<v Dan Ryan>And a heavy conversation but a lighthearted moment.

1475
02:30:20.605 --> 02:30:23.440
<v Dan Ryan>Is it required that you're bald if you work for Urban Alchemy?

1476
02:30:25.069 --> 02:30:30.235
<v Louis Hammonds>You must be big, you must be ugly, and you must be kind.

1477
02:30:33.224 --> 02:30:34.594
<v Louis Hammonds>Bald is not a requirement.

1478
02:30:34.659 --> 02:30:35.305
<v Louis Hammonds>Look at Jeff.

1479
02:30:36.531 --> 02:30:39.725
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate Brandy's point, and she talks about the, the global.

1480
02:30:40.726 --> 02:30:45.715
<v Dan Ryan>And when we're contemplating next year, we have to also think in terms of not dollars but outcomes.

1481
02:30:46.807 --> 02:30:51.843
<v Dan Ryan>And when I look at Urban Alchemy and I look at the other providers, they're all good.

1482
02:30:51.907 --> 02:30:53.867
<v Dan Ryan>I think Brandy has done a really good job.

1483
02:30:53.932 --> 02:30:57.612
<v Dan Ryan>Her and her team have really shown sort of how we provide care.

1484
02:30:58.636 --> 02:31:05.316
<v Dan Ryan>I stopped by an Urban Alchemy site and all of our shelters at least once a week, and I visit in particular Dennis at Oasis.

1485
02:31:06.010 --> 02:31:08.834
<v Dan Ryan>We had 31 reunifications in the last 2 weeks.

1486
02:31:09.625 --> 02:31:12.385
<v Dan Ryan>And so reunifications are when we help people get back home.

1487
02:31:12.530 --> 02:31:16.672
<v Dan Ryan>And so far we've We've helped people in like 45, 46 states.

1488
02:31:17.378 --> 02:31:25.194
<v Dan Ryan>Of those 31, of all of our shelters, 15 of them came from the Oasis by Urban Alchemy.

1489
02:31:25.965 --> 02:31:30.971
<v Dan Ryan>I always quantify that based on, you know, if we did rental assistance, how much are we saving?

1490
02:31:31.037 --> 02:31:38.965
<v Dan Ryan>If we did a housing, right, $300,000 per doorknob is our average, you know, that's $4.5 million we saved in housing in Portland.

1491
02:31:39.110 --> 02:31:39.433
<v Dan Ryan>Mm-hmm.

1492
02:31:39.627 --> 02:31:43.505
<v Dan Ryan>We provided that person with their social network, their mom, their brother, whatever the case.

1493
02:31:43.586 --> 02:31:45.138
<v Dan Ryan>That's outcome-based.

1494
02:31:45.284 --> 02:32:07.645
<v Dan Ryan>When I look at shelter to housing and I look at our, how effective are we at housing, when Brandy talked about 2 to 3 months is our velocity versus other shelter providers when it's sometimes 2 years, I look at the outcomes of the providing that we're getting from Urban Outreach.

1495
02:32:08.324 --> 02:32:17.208
<v Dan Ryan>And so I really wanna make sure that we're not only looking at the dollar figure, but we're looking at, you know, the guests that we're helping into housing and to their loved ones as well.

1496
02:32:17.255 --> 02:32:19.102
<v Dan Ryan>So that's that sort of other part of the equation.

1497
02:32:19.150 --> 02:32:20.581
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate your framing.

1498
02:32:21.014 --> 02:32:28.019
<v Dan Ryan>I think we need to constantly be, you know, I always say our assets need to sweat, but that means saving lives at the same time.

1499
02:32:28.066 --> 02:32:29.384
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you.

1500
02:32:29.850 --> 02:32:34.959
<v Mitch Green>And thank you for adding that additional context there and intention.

1501
02:32:35.136 --> 02:32:38.652
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to wrap up my questions and yield the time here in a second.

1502
02:32:38.747 --> 02:32:44.753
<v Mitch Green>But council's always sort of in a bit of a catch-22, which is like, okay, we're responding to your budget.

1503
02:32:45.010 --> 02:32:45.941
<v Mitch Green>We don't have a lot of time.

1504
02:32:46.085 --> 02:32:47.724
<v Mitch Green>Is this the time to do new policy?

1505
02:32:48.381 --> 02:32:54.579
<v Mitch Green>But then when we're in the offseason, is it appropriate to get ahead of your budget?

1506
02:32:55.061 --> 02:32:57.583
<v Mitch Green>Do you see the sort of like catch-22 there?

1507
02:32:57.630 --> 02:33:00.457
<v Mitch Green>And so this conversation, I think, is part of that.

1508
02:33:00.504 --> 02:33:00.772
<v Mitch Green>And I Thank you.

1509
02:33:00.859 --> 02:33:01.729
<v Mitch Green>And I hope you see it that way.

1510
02:33:03.809 --> 02:33:15.825
<v Mitch Green>The other piece that I want to switch to, some maybe slightly more difficult questions, and I, you know, I wanted to frame it up in the spirit of collegiality here, but I want to go to the KATU reporting a little bit.

1511
02:33:17.370 --> 02:33:23.575
<v Mitch Green>KATU report had reported that at least one resident was sexually assaulted by an employee but who didn't report it.

1512
02:33:24.558 --> 02:33:31.547
<v Mitch Green>And so that made me wonder, I really appreciate your emphasis on your grievance lifecycle and the lessons learned and all that and your commitment to it.

1513
02:33:31.595 --> 02:33:47.538
<v Mitch Green>But one of the things that I worry about, and I hope that there's a response to this on either side, actually, I would like this response from Portland Solutions in particular, but how do we know that we're not creating a sort of disincentive to report, right?

1514
02:33:47.797 --> 02:33:51.156
<v Mitch Green>Because of fear of reprisal, fear of kind of—.

1515
02:33:51.156 --> 02:33:51.318
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

1516
02:33:52.615 --> 02:34:08.966
<v Mitch Green>You know, as I think one of the, one of the people who testified earlier was concerned that, are we setting up a system that disincentivizes folks to reach out to say, hey, I'm not being served by this system, because their first contact is the folks who they've had the bad experience with, right?

1517
02:34:10.079 --> 02:34:15.516
<v Mitch Green>And so during the kind of records request process, the Oregonian did records requests.

1518
02:34:15.596 --> 02:34:16.259
<v Mitch Green>I got some of that.

1519
02:34:16.451 --> 02:34:25.871
<v Mitch Green>And there was a a guest who had suggested that it was policy that there's no photographing, no videotaping, none of that of staff members.

1520
02:34:26.065 --> 02:34:31.639
<v Mitch Green>And so I think for them, they felt like, how do we know that we don't have— that we have proper and due recourse?

1521
02:34:31.994 --> 02:34:40.229
<v Mitch Green>So I'd like a response to the sort of idea that we might be having some underreporting going on in our system.

1522
02:34:41.104 --> 02:34:41.380
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you.

1523
02:34:41.542 --> 02:34:42.596
<v Brandy Westerman>Thank you for that question.

1524
02:34:42.645 --> 02:34:53.104
<v Brandy Westerman>And I really appreciated hearing that in the testimony as well, that concern about Thank you, Councilor Smith, for that clarification, because that's a concern that I think we all need to carry when we're thinking about the grievance process.

1525
02:34:53.522 --> 02:34:56.700
<v Brandy Westerman>I do want to clarify one point from our presentation.

1526
02:34:57.280 --> 02:35:03.493
<v Brandy Westerman>A participant is always welcome to reach out to the city first or to the ombudsman first.

1527
02:35:03.815 --> 02:35:21.242
<v Brandy Westerman>So while we encourage reporting to Urban Alchemy because we believe that we can resolve the majority of complaints through that system fastest, There will be times when a complaint may be ultra-sensitive and that that's not the appropriate channel for that individual.

1528
02:35:21.450 --> 02:35:28.940
<v Brandy Westerman>And in those cases, law enforcement, the ombudsman's office, or our office may be a better first stop, and that is welcome.

1529
02:35:29.486 --> 02:35:31.970
<v Brandy Westerman>So I— yeah, go ahead.

1530
02:35:32.034 --> 02:35:32.676
<v Mitch Green>Cut you off.

1531
02:35:32.902 --> 02:35:34.953
<v Mitch Green>I am running out of time, so thanks for that response.

1532
02:35:35.002 --> 02:35:35.916
<v Mitch Green>That's what I needed to hear.

1533
02:35:36.109 --> 02:35:38.834
<v Mitch Green>I think what we'll need to do is make sure that's crystal clear to our guests.

1534
02:35:40.391 --> 02:35:42.739
<v Mitch Green>That reminds me, one last question, then I'll yield.

1535
02:35:45.477 --> 02:35:50.834
<v Mitch Green>Ian, I may have heard it from you, but Bayron, I think I also— we had this conversation in my office too.

1536
02:35:53.057 --> 02:35:58.110
<v Mitch Green>One of the indications was if there's a criminal complaint, you reach out to law enforcement straight away.

1537
02:35:58.840 --> 02:36:04.836
<v Mitch Green>Do we have— can we verify that that's— how do I verify that law enforcement has been contacted?

1538
02:36:04.886 --> 02:36:04.934
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

1539
02:36:06.020 --> 02:36:07.953
<v Mitch Green>Because that's the piece that I think I need to bridge.

1540
02:36:08.229 --> 02:36:26.384
<v Mitch Green>So I think as part of this kind of request from the chairs, Avalos and Kanal, for some more information, I would love to see some sort of reporting on like, yeah, we actually have been receiving those police— those requests to law enforcement, and here's what we're doing about it.

1541
02:36:26.513 --> 02:36:28.959
<v Mitch Green>That would be a great thing for me to get some access to.

1542
02:36:29.268 --> 02:36:29.737
<v Louis Hammonds>Absolutely.

1543
02:36:29.996 --> 02:36:30.515
<v Candace Avalos>We can get you that information.

1544
02:36:30.881 --> 02:36:31.445
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1545
02:36:32.476 --> 02:36:32.734
<v Louis Hammonds>Thank you.

1546
02:36:32.911 --> 02:36:33.378
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1547
02:36:34.263 --> 02:36:35.115
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1548
02:36:36.259 --> 02:36:37.852
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair, and Councilor Green.

1549
02:36:37.966 --> 02:36:40.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for taking a chance on this type of oversight.

1550
02:36:40.444 --> 02:36:42.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it's a really important piece of what committees do.

1551
02:36:45.641 --> 02:37:20.618
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, I look at the spaces where we can prevent and address The types of allegations that we heard about in the press, because frankly, you're, you're going to get complaints about the operations day to day that should go to Urban Alchemy, that you should figure out how to address internally, that probably unless you're receiving so many of them that there's a clear pattern of services not being provided in the way that they are supposed to in the contract, aren't things that Portland Solutions is going to step in on.

1552
02:37:22.127 --> 02:37:25.594
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we're here today because we've heard that there are some high-level allegations as well.

1553
02:37:26.799 --> 02:37:34.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so as I think about how to prevent and address those, I see kind of 4 places where we need to make sure that we are doing things right.

1554
02:37:35.549 --> 02:37:37.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is in the recruitment.

1555
02:37:37.959 --> 02:37:42.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What does recruitment look like to minimize, to minimize these issues?

1556
02:37:42.534 --> 02:37:45.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I have a question or 2 about that that I'll get to.

1557
02:37:46.131 --> 02:37:52.302
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The second is in what What happens after— what happens to file a complaint?

1558
02:37:52.943 --> 02:38:05.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I have some concerns that we have stepped up the outreach to folks who are in our shelters now because there have been these high-level allegations that have made the news.

1559
02:38:05.780 --> 02:38:32.522
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I want to ask a couple of questions about how we're making sure that when somebody has a grievance, has a And what the processes are, and for Portland Solutions, what the requirements are, what the expectations are for our shelter providers 8 months from now when this hopefully is not in the news because we've resolved issues and there haven't been other high-profile issues.

1560
02:38:34.595 --> 02:38:38.727
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The third is what we do after that allegation is submitted, that grievance is submitted.

1561
02:38:38.792 --> 02:38:38.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1562
02:38:38.953 --> 02:38:57.155
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have a And how both providers and Portland Solutions are— our staff at the city are making sure that somebody who has filed a grievance is not face-to-face with the person who they believe they were aggrieved by.

1563
02:38:57.316 --> 02:39:02.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we also have a fair process for staff and what that looks like.

1564
02:39:04.558 --> 02:39:09.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then what What repair happens, what the fixes are, how we prevent in the future.

1565
02:39:09.828 --> 02:39:13.853
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just, I lay that out because I want to ask a couple of questions about each step of the process.

1566
02:39:14.688 --> 02:39:27.902
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the first is on recruitment, because other than hearing that you work hard to provide second chance employment for people, which is something that I think is very important, I didn't hear anything about your screening.

1567
02:39:28.960 --> 02:40:03.489
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How are you recruiting people, not just training them for 2 weeks and then overseeing them for 90 days, but going through the process of offering somebody that position to begin with to try to minimize the high-profile conflicts that we've seen in the news, the allegations of abuse, mistreatment, the things nobody should experience when frankly they're in a very vulnerable place, not just Just because, you know, we sometimes talk about people who need service and support as vulnerable.

1568
02:40:04.211 --> 02:40:10.650
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Coming to a shelter requires asking for help, and asking for help requires any of us to be vulnerable.

1569
02:40:11.148 --> 02:40:13.299
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we have people who are asking for help.

1570
02:40:14.504 --> 02:40:28.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How are you making sure in your recruitment and hiring process that you're hiring people who are not going to take advantage of the fact that somebody's in a Thank you for that question.

1571
02:40:29.399 --> 02:40:35.100
<v Ian Clark>First and foremost, we have a full kind of applicant tracking system where, you know, we prioritize based on resume.

1572
02:40:35.100 --> 02:40:40.260
<v Ian Clark>We have our talent development team where we'll reach out to a candidate if they express interest.

1573
02:40:40.459 --> 02:40:42.819
<v Ian Clark>You know, we'll look at— we'll vet that, kind of look at the resume.

1574
02:40:42.979 --> 02:40:45.469
<v Ian Clark>And again, we have some folks, this might be their first job.

1575
02:40:45.819 --> 02:40:47.500
<v Ian Clark>So a big part of it is in the interview.

1576
02:40:47.540 --> 02:40:47.700
<v Ian Clark>I think that's There's a great question.

1577
02:40:48.609 --> 02:40:50.599
<v Ian Clark>A 30-minute interview process minimum.

1578
02:40:50.727 --> 02:40:55.174
<v Ian Clark>Sometimes there's a 2-step interview process where, you know, someone will sit across from you.

1579
02:40:55.271 --> 02:41:04.132
<v Ian Clark>Either it's a director of one of our programs, either it's someone from our training team, and we also have a recruiting team as well, where they'll sit down, have a conversation with you.

1580
02:41:04.662 --> 02:41:19.685
<v Ian Clark>In that, we're gonna ask kind of what's your lived experience, what's your experience, you know, what drives you, but also get to some scenario-based kind of conversations where we're in a, To be honest, we're gonna attempt to trigger you in a sense to see how you react in certain situations.

1581
02:41:19.751 --> 02:41:21.163
<v Ian Clark>We're gonna challenge your value system.

1582
02:41:21.210 --> 02:41:22.751
<v Ian Clark>We're gonna ask your value system.

1583
02:41:23.441 --> 02:41:28.304
<v Ian Clark>With that, a decision is made either to hire or not hire at this time.

1584
02:41:28.977 --> 02:41:31.576
<v Ian Clark>There can also be a decision to maybe there's a second interview.

1585
02:41:32.362 --> 02:41:36.744
<v Ian Clark>Sometimes folks have gone through, you know, up to 3 interviews to get hired by us.

1586
02:41:36.856 --> 02:41:48.634
<v Ian Clark>And we've actually, one of our learnings from some of the most recent things is to be a little more, you know, meticulous in that process and a little more thorough in that process.

1587
02:41:49.291 --> 02:41:51.906
<v Ian Clark>Beyond that, there's also, we do a background check.

1588
02:41:52.036 --> 02:41:53.592
<v Ian Clark>So there's a background check for everybody.

1589
02:41:54.345 --> 02:41:56.399
<v Ian Clark>We believe in second chances for all.

1590
02:41:57.876 --> 02:42:09.236
<v Ian Clark>Unfortunately, because of the population we serve and the sensitivity of the environment, anyone that has a sexual offense is unfortunately filtered out of our hiring process.

1591
02:42:09.332 --> 02:42:10.085
<v Ian Clark>So I do need to say that.

1592
02:42:10.134 --> 02:42:10.406
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1593
02:42:11.177 --> 02:42:13.394
<v Ian Clark>And so that's how we address it.

1594
02:42:13.441 --> 02:42:18.692
<v Ian Clark>I think that there is a— and I know that there's an introductory period of 90 days, which you heard Louie kind of speak about.

1595
02:42:19.560 --> 02:42:27.139
<v Ian Clark>So we believe that not only is the interview kind of the one-on-one or the two-on-one, it's also the interview is still going on during training.

1596
02:42:27.253 --> 02:42:29.388
<v Ian Clark>It's still going on during your introductory period.

1597
02:42:30.368 --> 02:42:32.005
<v Ian Clark>And we have gotten tighter in that.

1598
02:42:32.054 --> 02:42:37.497
<v Ian Clark>If we see things that are outside of our training within that introductory period, we will.

1599
02:42:37.594 --> 02:42:37.691
<v Vicki Payne>Thank you.

1600
02:42:40.486 --> 02:42:45.754
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And are you screening for current substance use during that process as well?

1601
02:42:46.365 --> 02:42:47.297
<v Ian Clark>We are visually.

1602
02:42:48.132 --> 02:42:50.349
<v Ian Clark>We're not drug testing folks when they come in.

1603
02:42:51.489 --> 02:42:58.558
<v Ian Clark>A lot of us, because we have lived experience, if we see those cues, we know some of those cues, we're not going to move forward with hiring you.

1604
02:42:59.763 --> 02:43:06.427
<v Ian Clark>I will say, you know, one thing unfortunately that we've had to, especially in the last couple months, kind of look at Yeah.

1605
02:43:06.941 --> 02:43:21.644
<v Ian Clark>For us, you know, if you asked me a year ago what was the biggest success story for Urban Alchemy, for me it's the, the individual that comes through the shelter, stabilizes their life, maybe lives in the shelter a couple months, gets a job, gets housing, and then comes work for us.

1606
02:43:22.076 --> 02:43:24.049
<v Ian Clark>You heard the young lady speak earlier, right?

1607
02:43:24.096 --> 02:43:25.572
<v Ian Clark>And those are still success stories.

1608
02:43:26.165 --> 02:43:36.480
<v Ian Clark>For us, we've kind of had to look at that a little more stringent, to be honest, because we know if someone has lived in our shelter system that there are There are potential triggers within the shelter system.

1609
02:43:36.915 --> 02:43:40.899
<v Ian Clark>There are preexisting relationships within the current shelter system.

1610
02:43:40.948 --> 02:43:49.174
<v Ian Clark>And so we've even learned over the last couple months to look at that a little stronger as well, which is some of our learnings from some of the most recent things that have happened.

1611
02:43:49.704 --> 02:43:51.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate hearing about some changes.

1612
02:43:52.662 --> 02:44:01.915
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For Portland Solutions, have we looked at best practices in hiring quite as much So I'll answer that question.

1613
02:44:02.077 --> 02:44:17.021
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think the direct answer is no.

1614
02:44:27.388 --> 02:44:33.944
<v Brandy Westerman>I think we don't get involved in the direct human resource practices of our contracted providers.

1615
02:44:34.458 --> 02:45:04.145
<v Brandy Westerman>At the same time, what we do do is have a regular ongoing sort of peer learning series where we bring together our partners, our operators on a monthly basis to cover certain topics where they're able to share their own learning and experience and things that are working well within one And that's an area we can explore, kind of doing something like that around the topic of hiring individuals, for sure.

1616
02:45:04.707 --> 02:45:18.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to ask that we do that and especially look to providers who have not had some of the challenging allegations that I know not just Urban Alchemy but others have faced as well, share some of their best practices.

1617
02:45:19.190 --> 02:45:23.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1618
02:45:28.952 --> 02:45:39.143
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to ask about the process when somebody does have a complaint, and I have 2 questions for Portland Solutions here.

1619
02:45:39.288 --> 02:45:55.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is, I know that there have been a lot of postings in our shelters recently And I assume that's not just within Urban Alchemy, but that those are in all of our shelters, those run by all of our providers.

1620
02:45:57.907 --> 02:45:59.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those posters aren't going to stay up forever.

1621
02:46:00.593 --> 02:46:08.810
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So what is the plan, whether it is replacement of those posters, requiring in a contract that information be given, requiring that information be given to the public?

1622
02:46:08.891 --> 02:46:09.833
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a great question.

1623
02:46:10.121 --> 02:46:13.316
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To every single individual specifically when they enter a shelter.

1624
02:46:14.075 --> 02:46:25.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What is our plan moving forward to ensure that people who are staying in a shelter know how they can share a concern?

1625
02:46:26.602 --> 02:46:33.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Like I said, 8 months from now when those posters have come down in the rain and the filing of grievances isn't in the news.

1626
02:46:34.250 --> 02:46:35.200
<v Brandy Westerman>Yeah, thank you.

1627
02:46:35.458 --> 02:46:36.004
<v Brandy Westerman>And it's all of these.

1628
02:46:36.128 --> 02:46:36.448
<v Brandy Westerman>All of the above.

1629
02:46:36.528 --> 02:46:36.784
<v Brandy Westerman>Okay.

1630
02:46:37.298 --> 02:46:44.689
<v Brandy Westerman>That the process of getting the word out to participants about how they can file grievances did not start with the news coverage.

1631
02:46:44.769 --> 02:46:46.115
<v Brandy Westerman>I wanna be clear about that.

1632
02:46:46.532 --> 02:46:58.349
<v Brandy Westerman>That's a requirement under the contract from the very beginning and something that our team regularly monitors when they're on site to ensure that that information is visible and available to participants.

1633
02:46:59.760 --> 02:47:19.364
<v Brandy Westerman>We hosted the Ombudsman's Office at each of the alternative shelters to come join community meetings with participants to talk about their role and what they can do to ensure individuals are treated fairly, or in the event that they feel that they've not been treated fairly, how they can raise those concerns.

1634
02:47:19.413 --> 02:47:29.879
<v Brandy Westerman>And we'll continue to work with them to get more of those sessions scheduled, as well as having our own team onsite on a regular basis available and interacting with folks.

1635
02:47:30.632 --> 02:47:41.514
<v Brandy Westerman>Our general kind of site monitoring includes checking to be sure that that information is available for participants to see so that they know how to file a grievance.

1636
02:47:43.185 --> 02:47:50.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And is that part of the contract with all of our providers that they give access to the ombudsman and have that information posted?

1637
02:47:51.235 --> 02:47:56.072
<v Brandy Westerman>That they have the information posted and they have a clearly communicated grievance policy, yes.

1638
02:47:58.791 --> 02:48:03.864
<v Brandy Westerman>Specified in the contract that they need to provide access to the ombudsman, but that's never been an issue.

1639
02:48:04.510 --> 02:48:06.909
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, um, I'm going to limit myself to one more question.

1640
02:48:07.150 --> 02:48:07.924
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm cognizant of the time.

1641
02:48:08.764 --> 02:48:29.617
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I share the concern that my colleague raised about, um, underreporting, and I worry that if somebody believes that their first line of reporting is to organization that they think will have the back of their employee, they may not bother to report something.

1642
02:48:30.389 --> 02:48:49.888
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also worry that saying to somebody, go report it to the police, when that person may be either experiencing substance use disorder or mental health challenges that make executive function difficult, that follow-up doesn't always happen.

1643
02:48:51.325 --> 02:48:56.236
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Additionally, we have a system where somebody files a complaint and then they're reached back out to.

1644
02:48:56.916 --> 02:49:06.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we also know that for many people within our houseless population, consistent access to email, cell phone, etc., isn't— it just isn't consistent.

1645
02:49:08.247 --> 02:49:15.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So what is our plan to do better than we currently are?

1646
02:49:15.302 --> 02:49:17.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not just what do we do now, but what is our plan?

1647
02:49:17.600 --> 02:49:17.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1648
02:49:18.683 --> 02:50:12.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In ensuring that the grievance process that exists encourages people, not the small concerns that I think people can report or not, but with the large concerns— drug dealing, drug access, um, abuse— what is our plan to make sure that people are encouraged, empowered to report, feel safe reporting, are not asked to jump through hoops at a level of executive function that they may not be able to muster right now, and that that follow-up on investigating doesn't rely on being able to reach somebody who might have left the shelter because they felt unsafe and who we might not Can I jump in?

1649
02:50:12.534 --> 02:50:12.775
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sure.

1650
02:50:13.417 --> 02:50:13.563
<v Candace Avalos>It's—.

1651
02:50:13.643 --> 02:50:24.063
<v Hank Smith>That's a good question, Councilor, and how we capture more of possible complaints that go unreported is a challenging question.

1652
02:50:25.379 --> 02:50:30.566
<v Hank Smith>But I do want to point out that the shelter services team is not alone within Portland Solutions managing this.

1653
02:50:31.335 --> 02:50:37.738
<v Hank Smith>Many of the guests who go into our alternative shelters are referred there by our street outreach team.

1654
02:50:37.868 --> 02:50:39.523
<v Hank Smith>So that's about 10 folks.

1655
02:50:39.765 --> 02:50:44.075
<v Hank Smith>And it's not unusual for them to maintain contact with that outreach team.

1656
02:50:44.123 --> 02:50:46.301
<v Hank Smith>So there's a lot of trust built out there on the street.

1657
02:50:46.365 --> 02:50:50.695
<v Hank Smith>Somebody's living on the street and they're not necessarily saying yes to going into a shelter right away.

1658
02:50:51.659 --> 02:50:52.623
<v Hank Smith>Trust is built over time.

1659
02:50:52.736 --> 02:50:58.537
<v Hank Smith>And so we do rely on that street outreach team to communicate things they hear.

1660
02:50:58.617 --> 02:51:02.654
<v Hank Smith>It might not be an official grievance, it might be something they hear about, and then we can address it.

1661
02:51:02.736 --> 02:51:03.854
<v Hank Smith>And I think that just speaks to—.

1662
02:51:03.854 --> 02:51:03.904
<v Hank Smith>Yeah.

1663
02:51:04.459 --> 02:51:14.305
<v Hank Smith>The multiple channels of— you present to somebody multiple pathways to let somebody know something might be wrong.

1664
02:51:14.722 --> 02:51:18.120
<v Hank Smith>Even if they say, I don't want to make this official, but I want to say this, right?

1665
02:51:18.426 --> 02:51:19.907
<v Hank Smith>I think that's important.

1666
02:51:19.957 --> 02:51:21.147
<v Hank Smith>The street outreach team does it.

1667
02:51:21.583 --> 02:51:26.575
<v Hank Smith>We have a really high staff-to-participant ratio at our shelters with Urban Alchemy.

1668
02:51:27.430 --> 02:51:32.147
<v Hank Smith>So there's many individuals and maybe one there is more Trusted by a participant than another.

1669
02:51:32.825 --> 02:51:37.110
<v Hank Smith>And I know early on, that is why we folded the ombudsman into the process.

1670
02:51:37.191 --> 02:51:44.842
<v Hank Smith>We said, how can we— all of our thinking about the flows for the complaint kind of fall within the city structure, right?

1671
02:51:46.308 --> 02:51:50.355
<v Hank Smith>We hold the contract, we work with Urban Alchemy.

1672
02:51:50.405 --> 02:51:54.422
<v Hank Smith>And so how can we have a flow outside of that process for somebody to complain?

1673
02:51:54.469 --> 02:51:57.130
<v Hank Smith>And of course, the ombudsman has a different— Yeah.

1674
02:51:57.824 --> 02:51:57.840
<v Hank Smith>Oh.

1675
02:51:58.933 --> 02:52:00.009
<v Hank Smith>Authority, right?

1676
02:52:00.700 --> 02:52:04.395
<v Hank Smith>Although it might still be perceived as government, a city of Portland.

1677
02:52:04.492 --> 02:52:13.472
<v Hank Smith>And so that it does present a challenge, but there's a sort of overt way of getting into the spaces and maintaining contact with folks to solicit some of that.

1678
02:52:13.810 --> 02:52:18.759
<v Hank Smith>And I'll just note our outreach team, their offices were at the Clinton Triangle Shelter for a couple years.

1679
02:52:18.888 --> 02:52:19.995
<v Hank Smith>Now they're at a different shelter.

1680
02:52:21.040 --> 02:52:27.144
<v Hank Smith>But Brandy's staff is at shelters Almost on a different shelter, almost on a daily basis.

1681
02:52:27.191 --> 02:52:31.331
<v Hank Smith>So just being present and having a diverse array of folks, I think, can help with that.

1682
02:52:32.349 --> 02:52:35.722
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate hearing about the folding in of the outreach team in some of this work.

1683
02:52:35.802 --> 02:52:42.613
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think there might be opportunity for us to do follow-up better by using that team.

1684
02:52:43.370 --> 02:53:03.445
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we don't have the time today to get into it, but I'd like to hear in the future future some ideas for how we can make sure that folks feel safe reporting and that those reports can be followed up on when we can't reach somebody or that we have the outreach team working with us to ensure that we can.

1685
02:53:05.262 --> 02:53:09.457
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Again, I'm not worried about those lower-level complaints that you all talked about.

1686
02:53:09.618 --> 02:53:18.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to make sure that we're preventing and when they do happen, doing the right type of work to allow people to report the, the more egregious concerns.

1687
02:53:19.346 --> 02:53:19.605
<v Hank Smith>Thank you.

1688
02:53:19.736 --> 02:53:31.724
<v Hank Smith>And, and I might also add, um, our 311 call service rep colleagues receive calls from all the shelters, not just our own, um, and are in daily contact with Portland Solutions.

1689
02:53:31.996 --> 02:53:33.683
<v Hank Smith>It's often for somebody looking for help.

1690
02:53:34.390 --> 02:53:38.521
<v Hank Smith>They're on the streets looking for help, uh, but occasionally it's feedback about a shelter.

1691
02:53:38.584 --> 02:53:46.296
<v Hank Smith>And if it's ours, we pass it to the shelter team, and if it's Thank you.

1692
02:53:47.613 --> 02:53:48.015
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1693
02:53:49.445 --> 02:53:57.863
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I appreciate that line of questioning, um, because I am deeply concerned about, um, the allegations of abuse.

1694
02:53:58.234 --> 02:53:59.152
<v Candace Avalos>It's very serious.

1695
02:53:59.505 --> 02:54:06.219
<v Candace Avalos>Um, it takes a lot of courage and vulnerability for somebody to even report it, and most people don't report that kind of thing.

1696
02:54:06.284 --> 02:54:07.194
<v Candace Avalos>So, um, I do appreciate that line of questioning.

1697
02:54:07.308 --> 02:54:07.406
<v Hank Smith>Thank you.

1698
02:54:07.886 --> 02:54:09.811
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to zero in on that a little bit.

1699
02:54:10.245 --> 02:54:13.261
<v Candace Avalos>I'll pause to just give your— because we don't have much time.

1700
02:54:13.421 --> 02:54:17.736
<v Candace Avalos>I will second all of the framing that my vice chair stated at the beginning.

1701
02:54:17.784 --> 02:54:27.700
<v Candace Avalos>I'm really grateful that you all are here and taking this opportunity to not only talk to us but to the public about how the standards you all hold yourselves to and the ways that you're trying to improve.

1702
02:54:27.796 --> 02:54:40.743
<v Candace Avalos>Because again, residents of Portland want to feel secure that the people we've put in charge of working with vulnerable populations are doing so in a way that is, you know, meets our standards as a city.

1703
02:54:41.500 --> 02:54:43.712
<v Candace Avalos>So I want to zero in on this.

1704
02:54:43.795 --> 02:54:46.350
<v Candace Avalos>This is very specific, but it is really important to me.

1705
02:54:47.299 --> 02:54:56.956
<v Candace Avalos>So, you know, you all, as far as the hiring process and all that, you all were saying that anyone that has a sexual offense is unfortunately filtered out of your hiring.

1706
02:54:57.555 --> 02:54:57.870
<v Candace Avalos>Your words.

1707
02:54:58.404 --> 02:54:58.637
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1708
02:54:59.968 --> 02:55:14.243
<v Candace Avalos>In 2024, an Urban Alchemy staffer was accused of some serious sexual assault harassment while working in California, and they were transferred to Oregon according to a lawsuit that was filed in California state court.

1709
02:55:14.595 --> 02:55:17.533
<v Candace Avalos>That staffer, Tracy Webb, relocated to the Clinton Triangle.

1710
02:55:18.064 --> 02:55:23.988
<v Candace Avalos>So how are accusations handled in the hiring process if this is somebody that's internal from Urban Alchemy coming from another state?

1711
02:55:24.037 --> 02:55:24.614
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's a great question.

1712
02:55:24.680 --> 02:55:24.952
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1713
02:55:25.835 --> 02:55:27.827
<v Candace Avalos>How are you filtering them through?

1714
02:55:27.924 --> 02:55:40.485
<v Candace Avalos>Because I would assume you would have known ahead of them being transferred that they had such a serious allegation, and yet per this process, seemed like they were able to transfer.

1715
02:55:41.399 --> 02:55:58.610
<v Candace Avalos>I guess I'm curious what happened in that transfer, and obviously I understand that people are, you know, deserve their due process, but is there a policy in place for when someone is facing a criminal or civil litigation related to an alleged crime happening in our shelters, like sexual harassment?

1716
02:55:58.657 --> 02:56:00.393
<v Candace Avalos>What's your process for filtering those people out?

1717
02:56:02.556 --> 02:56:03.568
<v Ian Clark>Thank you for the question.

1718
02:56:04.243 --> 02:56:14.288
<v Ian Clark>I'll start off by saying the sexual harassment allegation was not out before the individual moved to Oregon to work for Urban Alchemy.

1719
02:56:14.336 --> 02:56:15.614
<v Ian Clark>So I want to start there.

1720
02:56:16.602 --> 02:56:25.127
<v Ian Clark>Secondly, because the person that made the allegation was separated from the alleged perpetrator, I'll call him a perpetrator in this instance.

1721
02:56:27.487 --> 02:56:28.992
<v Ian Clark>It was independently investigated.

1722
02:56:29.185 --> 02:56:35.386
<v Ian Clark>We brought in kind of 2 sets of different independent investigations in California to look into it.

1723
02:56:36.228 --> 02:56:38.204
<v Ian Clark>There was zero evidence that it did happen.

1724
02:56:38.253 --> 02:56:39.646
<v Ian Clark>It became civil litigation.

1725
02:56:40.430 --> 02:56:44.129
<v Ian Clark>That individual was afforded due process while that process happened.

1726
02:56:46.409 --> 02:56:48.691
<v Ian Clark>I'll say that individual is no longer with Urban Alchemy.

1727
02:56:48.739 --> 02:56:50.727
<v Ian Clark>It was still not founded to be true.

1728
02:56:51.433 --> 02:56:55.219
<v Ian Clark>Based on what was seen through the independent investigations.

1729
02:56:55.909 --> 02:56:57.658
<v Ian Clark>We also have to give folks due process.

1730
02:56:57.772 --> 02:57:02.505
<v Ian Clark>We also have to— we're gonna lift up any victim that brings anything forward.

1731
02:57:02.585 --> 02:57:08.876
<v Ian Clark>We're gonna stay victim aware, restorative justice, make sure that they're sound.

1732
02:57:08.924 --> 02:57:18.039
<v Ian Clark>But when they brought that up after the individual was moved to Oregon to work, which is not uncommon, we transfer people that are in director positions to go do work in other spaces.

1733
02:57:18.629 --> 02:57:22.967
<v Ian Clark>We're going to do our due diligence internally and let the process play out.

1734
02:57:24.322 --> 02:57:35.566
<v Louis Hammonds>And can I add also that relative to the recruitment, a background check was also done on this individual and there was no crimes or cases relative to that type of situation.

1735
02:57:37.076 --> 02:57:38.041
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for clearing that up.

1736
02:57:38.685 --> 02:57:44.941
<v Candace Avalos>As you can imagine, that was an alarming thing to read that news story about and Absolutely.

1737
02:57:45.614 --> 02:57:52.014
<v Candace Avalos>Because it ties to the broader issues that we're here to address, right, of allegations of abuse and how we're protecting residents of it.

1738
02:57:52.512 --> 02:57:53.586
<v Candace Avalos>We're going to run out of time soon.

1739
02:57:53.715 --> 02:58:12.386
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to leave you with a question for Portland Solutions, which is, as we're continuing to exercise this oversight, and as I mentioned to you all before this, expect that this is the beginning of broader discussions and oversight, but what information do you think council should be receiving on a routine basis Yes.

1740
02:58:12.737 --> 02:58:17.897
<v Candace Avalos>So that we're not waiting to hear something in the media to understand how these systems are functioning.

1741
02:58:18.010 --> 02:58:34.564
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll leave that as a lingering question that I'd love to get an answer to in the future, but I think it speaks to the broader question that we have about how we can exercise our oversight powers by— but we can't exercise those if we don't know what's happening, and we want to make sure that we're not hearing about it in the news.

1742
02:58:35.013 --> 02:58:39.415
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll leave it at that, and then I'll have Councilor Novick, close us out.

1743
02:58:40.671 --> 02:58:41.426
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1744
02:58:41.572 --> 02:58:50.865
<v Steve Novick>First of all, I have to respond to the mayor's question to Urban Alchemy about a baldness requirement, and I will note that actually the voters of Portland adopted something of such requirement.

1745
02:58:50.962 --> 02:58:56.796
<v Steve Novick>They're so committed to diversity that when they elected 6 men to the council, they insisted that 3 of them be bald and 3 of them have hair.

1746
02:58:58.394 --> 02:59:00.816
<v Steve Novick>So that's a principle that the voters have adopted.

1747
02:59:02.327 --> 02:59:09.076
<v Steve Novick>Following up for a second on people's Concerns about where people lodge a complaint first.

1748
02:59:10.022 --> 02:59:11.962
<v Steve Novick>Just a question from Portland Solutions.

1749
02:59:12.027 --> 02:59:20.430
<v Steve Novick>I mean, it seems to me, and maybe this is repetitive, that you said that you encourage people to use the Urban Alchemy complaint system.

1750
02:59:20.525 --> 02:59:20.734
<v Steve Novick>Mm-hmm.

1751
02:59:20.846 --> 02:59:26.411
<v Steve Novick>But what I'd want to be sure is that you're telling people, hey, there's an Urban Alchemy system.

1752
02:59:27.004 --> 02:59:36.992
<v Steve Novick>You can also call the cops about something illegal, but you should not hesitate to contact the city If there's something that you have a complaint about and you're not comfortable contacting law enforcement or Urban Alchemy.

1753
02:59:37.495 --> 02:59:39.427
<v Steve Novick>I just want to be sure that that conversation is happening.

1754
02:59:41.316 --> 02:59:42.698
<v Steve Novick>I can confirm, absolutely.

1755
02:59:43.004 --> 02:59:43.180
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1756
02:59:44.048 --> 03:00:16.782
<v Steve Novick>And second, and again, I'm not suggesting that we're here at Urban Alchemy, but I think people would want to know, I want to know, have you thought about what threshold of complaints and founded complaints there would be before you might make a decision that Even though it's really hard to find other contractors, like, have you sort of established a, if something reaches this level, then we would terminate the contract, or we would like take the contract into receivership and have the city exert more direct control over the operations of a contractor?

1757
03:00:18.601 --> 03:00:29.316
<v Brandy Westerman>Yeah, I will say if we find a situation— well, first of all, we see a repeated complaint that's not being addressed through changes within the organization, that would be a major red flag.

1758
03:00:30.836 --> 03:00:46.579
<v Brandy Westerman>If Urban Alchemy stops coming to the table to work with us on continuous improvement and policy changes that provide protection and safety and ensure that there's fairness when an allegation is raised, that would be a major red flag.

1759
03:00:47.269 --> 03:00:58.486
<v Brandy Westerman>I do think that there's the option of, you know, always going back and requesting additional organizations to, to to step forward and to bid on contracts with the city.

1760
03:00:59.244 --> 03:01:02.206
<v Brandy Westerman>There's always the option of the city taking on the work directly as well.

1761
03:01:02.639 --> 03:01:04.748
<v Brandy Westerman>So there are options there.

1762
03:01:05.264 --> 03:01:16.263
<v Brandy Westerman>One thing that I will say is I've really appreciated that Urban Alchemy leadership and staff have been willing to come to the table when things aren't going well and work with us on those solutions.

1763
03:01:16.441 --> 03:01:20.075
<v Brandy Westerman>And we've seen real change be implemented in those occasions.

1764
03:01:21.408 --> 03:01:38.970
<v Steve Novick>I mean, this might be like really hard to do, but I would— I think it might be useful for you to sort of spell out to all contractors, listen, we wanna work with you, but there are circumstances under which we would need to take steps to terminate the contract and sort of outline what those circumstances might be.

1765
03:01:39.630 --> 03:01:40.448
<v Steve Novick>Maybe you've already done that.

1766
03:01:42.364 --> 03:01:42.693
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1767
03:01:43.087 --> 03:01:43.647
<v Steve Novick>That's all I had.

1768
03:01:46.291 --> 03:01:47.469
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you, Committee.

1769
03:01:48.211 --> 03:01:51.033
<v Candace Avalos>So as far as what next steps look like, again, really appreciate your time.

1770
03:01:53.412 --> 03:01:58.244
<v Candace Avalos>Just for the public to understand the role, the couple steps I will be taking after this.

1771
03:01:58.503 --> 03:02:04.300
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Kanal and I sent another memo over to the city administrator requesting more information.

1772
03:02:04.865 --> 03:02:13.091
<v Candace Avalos>We're currently getting a slow trickle of that as makes sense and is good for the timing.

1773
03:02:13.912 --> 03:02:24.129
<v Candace Avalos>The plan is for us to continue this discussion possibly at a committee of the whole and bring the whole council along to discuss, but I need to figure that out with Councilor Kanal.

1774
03:02:24.594 --> 03:02:27.832
<v Candace Avalos>And overall, you know, we want to keep in communication with you.

1775
03:02:28.441 --> 03:02:43.808
<v Candace Avalos>And like I said in my question, let's figure out what are the things that we can continue to provide council so they can be up to speed and feel like they're not being surprised in the media about anything related to operations of a very important resource that we offer to vulnerable communities.

1776
03:02:44.146 --> 03:02:45.977
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you so much again for your time.

1777
03:02:46.489 --> 03:02:46.971
<v Candace Avalos>Appreciate you.

1778
03:02:47.438 --> 03:02:47.694
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1779
03:02:48.641 --> 03:02:58.709
<v Candace Avalos>Committee members, our next meeting is Tuesday, July 21st, and at that meeting we will have a presentation from Metro on public polling related to the supportive housing services measure.

1780
03:02:58.837 --> 03:03:08.841
<v Candace Avalos>And my intention in doing that is for us to have a discussion about our role as government to start to build back confidence in the public that we are working towards solutions on homelessness.

1781
03:03:09.676 --> 03:03:14.206
<v Candace Avalos>After that, we'll also have an ordinance on some city finance, uh, on foreclosure properties.

1782
03:03:14.834 --> 03:03:18.605
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, with that, I will adjourn the meeting of Housing and Permitting Committee at 5:01 PM.

1783
03:03:19.664 --> 03:03:19.781
<v Vicki Payne>Thank you.

