WEBVTT

1
00:06:07.985 --> 00:06:25.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, good afternoon.

2
00:06:25.415 --> 00:06:28.201
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm calling to order this work session of the Portland City Council.

3
00:06:28.283 --> 00:06:32.132
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is 2 o'clock on Wednesday, June 24th.

4
00:06:36.190 --> 00:06:37.968
<v Jamie Dunphy>We don't take roll in work sessions, do we?

5
00:06:38.283 --> 00:06:39.942
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, here you go, please take the roll.

6
00:06:41.418 --> 00:06:43.447
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sorry, that was a yes, you do not.

7
00:06:44.300 --> 00:06:45.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>Cool, I just looked down.

8
00:06:46.232 --> 00:06:47.278
<v Jamie Dunphy>Look at all these wonderful people.

9
00:06:47.358 --> 00:06:50.869
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great colleagues, this is the first of what will be several work sessions.

10
00:06:52.108 --> 00:06:54.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>Cool, I'm gonna start over.

11
00:06:55.182 --> 00:06:55.567
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's all good.

12
00:06:56.529 --> 00:07:05.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the first of what will be several work sessions on the city's role in the renovation of the Moda Center, our investment, our expectations, and our questions.

13
00:07:06.737 --> 00:07:12.257
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today's meeting will primarily be led by Kristen Dennis, who's on special assignment to my office from Metro.

14
00:07:12.595 --> 00:07:14.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Metro President Juan Carlos Gonzalez.

15
00:07:15.708 --> 00:07:22.672
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Kristen is taking an acting role as a project manager capacity on this issue to help us try and land this.

16
00:07:22.720 --> 00:07:23.553
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you, Kristen.

17
00:07:24.290 --> 00:07:30.944
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ms. Dennis will be here beginning the— Ms. Dennis will begin the hearing with an articulation of the goals for today's work.

18
00:07:31.346 --> 00:07:38.255
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll then receive an update from our administration partners who helped facilitate the council-led community engagement process and survey over the last 2 weeks.

19
00:07:38.896 --> 00:07:53.696
<v Jamie Dunphy>And finally, I'll note that while many offices have reached out and received detailed briefings from the administration on technical and financial details, I have received consistent feedback that there are more questions to be asked and more information needed for council and the public to be able to engage effectively.

20
00:07:54.209 --> 00:08:02.514
<v Jamie Dunphy>To that end, City Administrator Lee, DCA Oliveira, and Spectator Venues Manager Carl Lyle are here and will be able to provide information throughout the discussion.

21
00:08:02.930 --> 00:08:10.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>But it is worth noting that there are certain things we simply don't know yet, and this conversation today is intended to help us frame those questions for the future.

22
00:08:10.658 --> 00:08:13.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>So with no further ado, I'm gonna turn it over to Kristen Dennis.

23
00:08:14.475 --> 00:08:16.221
<v Kristen Dennis>Great, thank you so much, Council President Dunphy.

24
00:08:16.574 --> 00:08:17.312
<v Kristen Dennis>Happy to be here.

25
00:08:17.440 --> 00:08:19.509
<v Kristen Dennis>For the record, again, my name is Kristen Dennis.

26
00:08:20.406 --> 00:08:22.250
<v Kristen Dennis>And I am the Chief of Staff to the Metro Council.

27
00:08:22.812 --> 00:08:26.870
<v Kristen Dennis>Again, as Council President Dunphy said, I'm on loan here.

28
00:08:27.302 --> 00:08:31.103
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm not representing Metro, so I want to make sure that that is clear.

29
00:08:31.312 --> 00:08:38.111
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm working for council, and really my directive is to assist the city council— thank you so much— as you go through this process.

30
00:08:39.604 --> 00:08:50.639
<v Kristen Dennis>So for the benefit of the public watching at home, and in particular, I wanted to start by generally talking about where we're at and center the council's role in, in the process moving forward.

31
00:08:51.938 --> 00:08:53.110
<v Kristen Dennis>The city owns several venues.

32
00:08:53.222 --> 00:09:01.567
<v Kristen Dennis>This includes P5— that's Keller, Schnitz, Newmark, Winningstad, and Brunish Theaters— Veterans Memorial Coliseum, Providence Park, and Moda Center.

33
00:09:02.610 --> 00:09:13.616
<v Kristen Dennis>And I'll take the liberty of adding that they are part of a larger ecosystem of visitor venues within the Portland city limits, which are owned and operated by Metro, which include the Oregon Convention Center, the Expo Center, and the Oregon Zoo.

34
00:09:14.553 --> 00:09:22.365
<v Kristen Dennis>Across the board with publicly owned venues, there's a serious challenge as public ownership requires us to balance competing interests.

35
00:09:23.129 --> 00:09:25.410
<v Kristen Dennis>They're both a business and a community asset.

36
00:09:27.090 --> 00:09:30.551
<v Kristen Dennis>The Moda Center occupies a unique space in this visitor venues ecosystem.

37
00:09:31.226 --> 00:09:38.585
<v Kristen Dennis>It generates a large amount of economic activity that has both direct and indirect revenue implications for both the public sector and the private sector.

38
00:09:39.932 --> 00:09:50.833
<v Kristen Dennis>But it's also, of course, a community asset, both as an arena where Portlanders and visitors have access to incredible, memorable events, and as part of our cityscape, neighborhood, and infrastructure.

39
00:09:52.115 --> 00:09:53.029
<v Kristen Dennis>So that brings us to where we're at.

40
00:09:53.879 --> 00:10:02.135
<v Kristen Dennis>There have been a lot of conversations about the Moda Center and what it needs, and this is the first time that the Portland City Council has really gotten a chance to have that conversation as a whole.

41
00:10:03.562 --> 00:10:10.705
<v Kristen Dennis>And in just a few very short weeks, I'm going to be sitting here again trying to give you something specific to discuss and vote on.

42
00:10:13.669 --> 00:10:17.799
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm of course talking about a funding proposal and term sheet for a lease agreement.

43
00:10:18.586 --> 00:10:24.482
<v Kristen Dennis>And when I come back at that time, my directive is to have something that most of you— that reflects where you all are at.

44
00:10:26.102 --> 00:10:27.043
<v Kristen Dennis>That's a tall order.

45
00:10:28.614 --> 00:10:30.784
<v Kristen Dennis>My goal here today is, though, is pretty simple.

46
00:10:31.998 --> 00:10:34.466
<v Kristen Dennis>I need to get to understand your scoring rubrics.

47
00:10:35.149 --> 00:10:37.245
<v Kristen Dennis>Trying to get a Venn diagram of where you all are at.

48
00:10:38.940 --> 00:10:41.849
<v Kristen Dennis>When I bring a funding proposal to you, how are you going to grade it?

49
00:10:42.365 --> 00:10:43.110
<v Kristen Dennis>What are you looking for?

50
00:10:43.966 --> 00:10:46.552
<v Kristen Dennis>What does the right balance look like between competing interests?

51
00:10:47.360 --> 00:10:54.315
<v Kristen Dennis>Ultimately, I'm trying to get a passing grade from as many of you as possible on whatever I'm able to— we're able to bring you.

52
00:10:55.700 --> 00:10:58.964
<v Kristen Dennis>So the most critical first step here today is for you to talk to each other.

53
00:11:00.153 --> 00:11:09.081
<v Kristen Dennis>I will track what you are telling me and probably ask some follow-up questions, but what I'm asking you to do is discuss what you expect from the arena on behalf of your constituents.

54
00:11:09.995 --> 00:11:13.538
<v Kristen Dennis>What are the outcomes you expect from any city investment in the arena?

55
00:11:14.644 --> 00:11:20.831
<v Kristen Dennis>Now, before that convo though, I want to turn it over to Laura, who will be talking about the community outreach survey results.

56
00:11:21.697 --> 00:11:22.644
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you, Kristen.

57
00:11:22.755 --> 00:11:25.176
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thanks everyone for the opportunity to join you.

58
00:11:25.400 --> 00:11:27.644
<v Laura Oppenheimer>For the record, my name is Laura Oppenheimer.

59
00:11:27.948 --> 00:11:29.216
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I use she and her pronouns.

60
00:11:29.873 --> 00:11:31.075
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I am the city's chief communications officer.

61
00:11:31.716 --> 00:11:37.455
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I am also our interim Chief Engagement Officer, and that's the hat that I am wearing this afternoon.

62
00:11:38.690 --> 00:11:52.812
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Uh, it was a little over 3 weeks ago when the Council President's team reached out to me asking for some help from the administration in coordinating a unified council-wide and really citywide engagement initiative around the Moda Center.

63
00:11:52.908 --> 00:11:57.269
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I had to check my calendar to make sure it was really only 3 weeks, um, but it was.

64
00:11:58.166 --> 00:12:12.615
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Uh, during that time, the Council Chairs Group has invited DCA Oliveira, Spectator Venues Program and myself into that space every Monday morning for dedicated time to this to make sure we could move forward in lockstep.

65
00:12:13.193 --> 00:12:20.443
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Super grateful to that group for the shared direction, which has really been invaluable in being able to advance this engagement initiative quickly.

66
00:12:21.278 --> 00:12:32.847
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I think by working across the legislative and executive branches, we've been able to create a highly visible and highly accessible opportunity for Portlanders weigh in on a potential Moda Center renovation.

67
00:12:33.580 --> 00:12:36.672
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I'm here today to share some initial results from that effort.

68
00:12:37.210 --> 00:12:46.892
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Just want to express my gratitude to Council for being willing to try something new, and gratitude to Portlanders for really showing up and making their voices heard, as you'll hear about.

69
00:12:47.101 --> 00:12:53.344
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I'm confident we're going to learn from this experience as we consider innovative and effective ways to engage Portlanders.

70
00:12:53.941 --> 00:12:54.876
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next slide, please.

71
00:12:56.317 --> 00:12:57.157
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

72
00:12:57.238 --> 00:13:01.312
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So at the start of the process, we really outlined what council wanted to achieve.

73
00:13:02.315 --> 00:13:08.265
<v Laura Oppenheimer>At the heart of it, meaningfully informing council decisions by understanding public perspectives.

74
00:13:08.961 --> 00:13:16.460
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Certainly we wanted to provide some community education knowing that while some Portlanders have dived deeply into this issue, to others it's new.

75
00:13:18.472 --> 00:13:24.687
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Focus on not just the Blazers, but the building and the community around the building that uses it.

76
00:13:25.876 --> 00:13:33.394
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We wanted to reach a broad cross-section of Portlanders and literally and figuratively reach them where they are, reducing barriers to participation.

77
00:13:34.148 --> 00:13:34.918
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next slide, please.

78
00:13:36.312 --> 00:13:41.105
<v Laura Oppenheimer>In service of those goals, we took a two-pronged approach to engagement over the past couple weeks.

79
00:13:41.666 --> 00:13:43.957
<v Laura Oppenheimer>One part was our parks pop-up tour.

80
00:13:44.405 --> 00:13:46.057
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We'll talk more about that in a minute.

81
00:13:46.409 --> 00:13:52.708
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And then the second was an online survey where we were really trying to pull in as many people as possible to hear their perspectives.

82
00:13:53.647 --> 00:13:54.342
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next slide, please.

83
00:13:56.332 --> 00:14:00.797
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So I know many of you were there with me sweating through the parks pop-up tour.

84
00:14:01.493 --> 00:14:01.897
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

85
00:14:01.977 --> 00:14:04.515
<v Laura Oppenheimer>It was really, really hot, a lot like today.

86
00:14:06.847 --> 00:14:15.937
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I appreciated that councilors really asked to make sure we were at not one but two parks per district over that weekend to be as accessible as possible to where people are in their neighborhoods.

87
00:14:16.604 --> 00:14:22.130
<v Laura Oppenheimer>The goal of this session was to thank you.

88
00:14:22.196 --> 00:14:31.470
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Provide that in-person engagement with councilors and some kind of real-time conversations that you just can't have through a survey.

89
00:14:31.549 --> 00:14:38.929
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Additionally, we were hoping to reach people who didn't hear about the survey, weren't familiar with the issue, but just happened to be out at the park.

90
00:14:41.594 --> 00:14:47.140
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I would say broadly how these turned out was almost like informal outdoor town halls.

91
00:14:47.238 --> 00:14:49.778
<v Laura Oppenheimer>At most of the sites, we had a couple dozen people.

92
00:14:50.004 --> 00:14:53.791
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Many of them had come to have conversations with councilors thank you.

93
00:14:53.840 --> 00:14:54.243
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

94
00:14:54.292 --> 00:15:02.677
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I thought it was really heartening to hear people on various sides of the issue with different perspectives having respectful dialogue with city councilors.

95
00:15:02.774 --> 00:15:03.445
<v Laura Oppenheimer>That was really nice.

96
00:15:06.091 --> 00:15:16.128
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I do want to note that the folks who took the survey as a result of the parks pop-up tours represent a small proportion of the overall people who took the survey.

97
00:15:16.551 --> 00:15:20.854
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I think it was complementary rather than kind of a driving force for the survey.

98
00:15:21.590 --> 00:15:26.225
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Let's see if we can go back one slide.

99
00:15:26.370 --> 00:15:27.091
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

100
00:15:27.717 --> 00:15:35.498
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So then, giving a little overview of the survey itself, I want to be really clear about what this is and what it isn't.

101
00:15:36.379 --> 00:15:42.926
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We drafted a survey really aimed at getting at topics where the city has influence and leverage.

102
00:15:43.022 --> 00:15:48.027
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We want to ask people things that can lead to meaningful results and input into the process.

103
00:15:48.798 --> 00:16:00.342
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We drafted a survey that was reviewed by the 6 council offices and the council chairs group and vetted by the Spectator Venues Program for accuracy and consistency with the facts on the matter.

104
00:16:01.274 --> 00:16:12.224
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So I would characterize this as a civic engagement exercise, providing a big tent to bring in as many people as possible to share their opinions about the Moda Center.

105
00:16:12.448 --> 00:16:13.589
<v Kristen Dennis>Councilor Smith.

106
00:16:14.008 --> 00:16:18.886
<v Laura Oppenheimer>As you know, there's not a specific funding package or term sheet on the table right now.

107
00:16:19.724 --> 00:16:22.606
<v Laura Oppenheimer>As such, we weren't asking people about a specific package.

108
00:16:22.703 --> 00:16:28.315
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We were really gauging their values and their priorities to inform how you all go about making decisions.

109
00:16:31.073 --> 00:16:32.815
<v Laura Oppenheimer>There's a lot of things that this is not.

110
00:16:33.186 --> 00:16:36.201
<v Laura Oppenheimer>It's not statistically valid public opinion research.

111
00:16:36.556 --> 00:16:38.700
<v Laura Oppenheimer>It's not proportional representation.

112
00:16:39.682 --> 00:16:45.018
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And I feel pretty confident in saying we're missing a range of more moderate opinions on the topic.

113
00:16:45.145 --> 00:16:51.399
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Groups that are really passionate about this did a great job encouraging people to turn out and share their opinions, and that's great.

114
00:16:51.495 --> 00:16:56.225
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We just need to be careful in terms of the context in which you consider these results.

115
00:16:57.107 --> 00:17:00.971
<v Laura Oppenheimer>With that, let's move on, and I'll share a little bit about who participated in the survey.

116
00:17:01.918 --> 00:17:04.451
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We had over 18,000 responses.

117
00:17:04.627 --> 00:17:11.848
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I do not have a historical record, but I think it's safe to say that this was very robust participation for a city engagement process.

118
00:17:13.480 --> 00:17:14.944
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Probably highly unusual.

119
00:17:15.287 --> 00:17:18.493
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And that speaks, I think, to the passion that Portlanders have on this issue.

120
00:17:19.912 --> 00:17:25.884
<v Laura Oppenheimer>It was literally yesterday morning that we received the detailed data set from the survey platform.

121
00:17:27.079 --> 00:17:29.557
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We had the basic results prior to that.

122
00:17:29.623 --> 00:17:33.008
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So today we're going to be focusing mostly on the aggregate results.

123
00:17:33.185 --> 00:17:33.282
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

124
00:17:33.842 --> 00:17:44.766
<v Laura Oppenheimer>My commitment to all of you is that next week we will deliver a report that provides detailed demographic breakdowns and detailed crosstabs showing full results by council district.

125
00:17:44.829 --> 00:17:46.467
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And I hope that will be helpful as well.

126
00:17:47.092 --> 00:17:54.182
<v Laura Oppenheimer>If there are things you want to prioritize in that, I really welcome the feedback about what you want to be most sure that you get out of that.

127
00:17:54.439 --> 00:18:04.401
<v Laura Oppenheimer>A majority of participants actually did not provide their location-based information, but of those who did, you can see the breakdown here across council districts and those who live outside of Portland.

128
00:18:04.449 --> 00:18:04.545
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

129
00:18:07.406 --> 00:18:11.823
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Moving on then to the kind of top-line results.

130
00:18:13.309 --> 00:18:25.458
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I want to make clear that in the introduction to the survey, we did provide a couple paragraphs of context about this venue, the ownership state of the venue, the age of the venue, current situation.

131
00:18:25.555 --> 00:18:29.938
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Again, all of this was vetted by our subject matter experts and our council representatives.

132
00:18:30.018 --> 00:18:30.229
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

133
00:18:30.672 --> 00:18:35.000
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We tried to provide as much context as we could within the confines of a survey.

134
00:18:35.705 --> 00:18:43.306
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And yet, that being said, we know that people taking the survey probably had a wide range of understanding levels of the nuances of the situation.

135
00:18:44.058 --> 00:18:46.655
<v Laura Oppenheimer>For every question, brief context was provided.

136
00:18:46.944 --> 00:18:57.815
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We started out by asking people the baseline questions of how important is it for the Moda Center to be renovated, and do you support the city contributing up to $120 million?

137
00:18:58.231 --> 00:19:09.648
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We felt it was important to ask those separately, because there might be folks who are saying, yes, it's very important to be renovated, but not necessarily at a comfort level with the city making that contribution.

138
00:19:10.380 --> 00:19:25.925
<v Laura Oppenheimer>What you're going to see in the results here was echoed throughout the survey, and that's what I would call a U-shaped curve, kind of the opposite of a bell curve, where we see very strong, passionate opinions on both ends of the spectrum and a much smaller proportion of people in the middle.

139
00:19:26.894 --> 00:19:36.641
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Um, So on this, taken at the aggregate level, you can see those results and they were actually pretty similar across both questions, just some slight variations there.

140
00:19:37.513 --> 00:19:47.853
<v Laura Oppenheimer>But moving to the next slide, this is where I do wanna provide a sneak preview of how that district-by-district data is going to really add some richness to what you all are able to see.

141
00:19:49.458 --> 00:19:52.957
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I'm gonna take a moment to just kind of walk you through this and what you're seeing.

142
00:19:53.376 --> 00:19:56.795
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This is folks who did indicate which district they live in.

143
00:19:56.923 --> 00:19:57.005
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Yeah.

144
00:19:58.576 --> 00:20:07.855
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And it— you'll see that the results are similar overall in that most people gravitated to a 1 or a 5 on this and far fewer responses in between.

145
00:20:08.306 --> 00:20:12.319
<v Laura Oppenheimer>But there are some really distinct differences among districts.

146
00:20:12.865 --> 00:20:18.710
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You'll see that in D4, there was a significantly higher level of support for renovation.

147
00:20:18.967 --> 00:20:21.663
<v Laura Oppenheimer>In D1, a slight lean toward renovation.

148
00:20:21.952 --> 00:20:27.058
<v Laura Oppenheimer>D2, look where the Moda Center is located, looking almost evenly split.

149
00:20:27.894 --> 00:20:32.885
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And then in D3, a significant majority saying not important to renovate.

150
00:20:32.965 --> 00:20:43.077
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So, you know, again, not statistically valid representative sample, but really interesting to see how different sections of our city are sharing different perspectives.

151
00:20:43.607 --> 00:20:52.403
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And I know that when we analyze each question through this district-by-district lens, you'll probably get a lot more insight and have a lot more questions as well.

152
00:20:53.558 --> 00:20:54.795
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Moving on to the next question.

153
00:20:54.891 --> 00:20:55.228
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

154
00:20:56.943 --> 00:21:04.719
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We asked people on a 10-point scale to gauge how important is each of these potential outcomes if a renovation is pursued.

155
00:21:05.584 --> 00:21:08.342
<v Laura Oppenheimer>People were not having to choose or rank things here.

156
00:21:08.645 --> 00:21:11.307
<v Laura Oppenheimer>They could say 1 on all of them or 10 on all of them.

157
00:21:11.386 --> 00:21:13.439
<v Laura Oppenheimer>It's just how important is this to you.

158
00:21:14.817 --> 00:21:22.881
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We did see some of the U-shape, but I think this set of questions is where we start to get into more nuance and you really can see how things stack up differently.

159
00:21:23.394 --> 00:21:38.073
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You'll see the top 3, which stood out, yeah, pretty significantly above the other seeking additional private dollars, providing living wage jobs and supporting local businesses, and making sure there are community benefits to a renovation.

160
00:21:40.809 --> 00:21:41.342
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next slide.

161
00:21:41.712 --> 00:21:54.625
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Well, we had a couple of ranked choice questions where we provided a list of choices and similar to our new election system for the city, asked people to rank those in order from most important to least important.

162
00:21:55.417 --> 00:22:04.505
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This first one, again, making sure each of these things is realistic, asking people what they most want to see out of a renovation if it moves forward.

163
00:22:06.616 --> 00:22:13.078
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You will see that structural technology and operating upgrades were number one on the list.

164
00:22:13.143 --> 00:22:15.531
<v Laura Oppenheimer>That was, I think, by a pretty significant margin.

165
00:22:15.969 --> 00:22:19.737
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So clearly people are looking at that City venue through that lens.

166
00:22:20.173 --> 00:22:35.968
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And as you go down the list, you move on down to high-end details such as our next question used a similar ranking system and scale, and this is on a potential community benefits agreement.

167
00:22:36.404 --> 00:22:41.652
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Again, we provided some baseline information about what that is and how it could work.

168
00:22:44.009 --> 00:22:51.811
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And again, asked people to rank choices, although on this one we allowed an other option if there are things maybe we didn't think of yet that people would like you all to know they're thinking of.

169
00:22:51.875 --> 00:22:52.279
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I think that's a great idea.

170
00:22:53.337 --> 00:23:03.718
<v Laura Oppenheimer>The top choices here were investing in neighborhood development, living wage jobs for local people, and supporting the right to unionize, and addressing neighborhood impacts of large events.

171
00:23:04.298 --> 00:23:11.186
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Did want to make note we included on this slide, and we'll have more details in the full report, what some of those other responses were.

172
00:23:11.476 --> 00:23:19.638
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You'll see here people mentioned affordable housing, homelessness services, business support, public schools, and citywide transportation.

173
00:23:20.327 --> 00:23:20.790
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And roads.

174
00:23:21.319 --> 00:23:23.436
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I know those are things you all hear a lot about frequently.

175
00:23:26.089 --> 00:23:29.794
<v Laura Oppenheimer>The next question is related to potential funding sources.

176
00:23:30.308 --> 00:23:42.949
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And we all need to be clear that this is a complex topic that will likely require a mix of different sources, and we cannot possibly adequately and fully explain those in a short survey.

177
00:23:43.449 --> 00:23:54.829
<v Laura Oppenheimer>What we did do, however, for each of these potential sources that's been identified, is provide a short blurb explaining where that money comes from, what it can be used for, and what it typically goes to.

178
00:23:55.311 --> 00:23:58.888
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And we ask people, what is your comfort level with each of these sources?

179
00:23:59.321 --> 00:24:03.348
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Again, I'm going to give you the disclaimer, we saw a lot of U-curve stuff going on here.

180
00:24:03.959 --> 00:24:16.022
<v Laura Oppenheimer>But you do see some real variation in people's comfort level, with the highest level of comfort with the spectator venues and visitor activities fund moving on down to bonding as the lowest level.

181
00:24:16.086 --> 00:24:23.750
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So it at least provides a rough gauge of where people are with just kind of very minimal basic information about these potential sources.

182
00:24:24.439 --> 00:24:26.538
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next slide.

183
00:24:26.827 --> 00:24:30.144
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This is the last section, and I have several slides here.

184
00:24:31.298 --> 00:24:38.255
<v Laura Oppenheimer>My favorite part of the, the survey— maybe it's because I work in communications and engagement, but I thought it was fascinating— the open-ended questions.

185
00:24:38.528 --> 00:24:39.569
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We asked 2 of them.

186
00:24:40.515 --> 00:24:46.173
<v Laura Oppenheimer>What's the most important thing for city councilors to keep in mind as they make a decision about the Moda Center?

187
00:24:47.007 --> 00:24:54.203
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And what information do you need to better understand and decide on the Moda Center renovation as the public process continues?

188
00:24:54.861 --> 00:24:55.903
<v Laura Oppenheimer>People had a lot to say.

189
00:24:55.999 --> 00:24:58.804
<v Laura Oppenheimer>There were almost 27,000 comments.

190
00:24:59.141 --> 00:25:02.666
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So if you need some light weekend reading, highly recommend it.

191
00:25:02.730 --> 00:25:04.125
<v Laura Oppenheimer>It's actually really fascinating.

192
00:25:04.238 --> 00:25:13.358
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And I think people were so thoughtful and shared a whole lot of insight and passion that does to me go beyond what you can get just from the numbers.

193
00:25:13.471 --> 00:25:13.567
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

194
00:25:14.224 --> 00:25:18.771
<v Laura Oppenheimer>What we've been able to do today with the time that we had— sorry, if you can move to the next slide for this one.

195
00:25:20.432 --> 00:25:32.176
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We did distill this by skimming the 27,000 and using some tech support to help us sort into 5 themes that seem to be emerging across these.

196
00:25:32.434 --> 00:25:34.516
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Oh, sorry, I think we went the wrong direction.

197
00:25:34.628 --> 00:25:35.032
<v Laura Oppenheimer>There we go.

198
00:25:35.355 --> 00:25:35.678
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

199
00:25:35.903 --> 00:25:40.342
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So I'm just going to briefly touch on kind of those 5 themes that emerged to us.

200
00:25:40.412 --> 00:25:40.603
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

201
00:25:41.272 --> 00:25:46.346
<v Laura Oppenheimer>In each case, we just picked 2 illustrative quotes on different perspectives in the issue.

202
00:25:46.554 --> 00:25:52.832
<v Laura Oppenheimer>They certainly do not represent the full breadth of what's being said, but just want to give you a sneak preview of your reading material.

203
00:25:53.875 --> 00:26:00.617
<v Laura Oppenheimer>The first one, certainly people had a lot to say about whether it is important to them to keep the Blazers in Portland or not.

204
00:26:01.885 --> 00:26:06.011
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You know, you'll see some really impassioned arguments on both sides of this.

205
00:26:06.718 --> 00:26:07.553
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next slide, please.

206
00:26:11.537 --> 00:26:17.290
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This topic, a lot of commentary about who should be responsible for renovation.

207
00:26:17.355 --> 00:26:30.863
<v Laura Oppenheimer>To what extent is this an obligation of the city as the owner of the Moda Center versus to what extent is it the obligation of the primary tenant or others?

208
00:26:31.765 --> 00:26:32.893
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So you'll find that.

209
00:26:33.311 --> 00:26:36.228
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Third category is city spending priorities.

210
00:26:36.356 --> 00:26:38.776
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I think, you know, we're coming right on the heels of thank you.

211
00:26:38.856 --> 00:26:49.751
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We are in the middle of budget season, and certainly those conversations about city spending priorities are top of mind, and you will see that come through as you wade through the comments that we received here.

212
00:26:51.579 --> 00:26:57.136
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next one, PCF, the Portland Community Benefits Clean Energy Fund.

213
00:26:57.490 --> 00:27:02.229
<v Laura Oppenheimer>We did receive a lot of commentary about that as a potential use of funding.

214
00:27:03.548 --> 00:27:13.142
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You'll see there are some comments that are quite a few comments, I think, with concerns about using it, and then some with some nuance there.

215
00:27:13.366 --> 00:27:27.159
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You'll see the comment on the right, for example, suggesting that there are some potential obligations that could be part of the deal that would make them have more comfort with particular funding sources.

216
00:27:28.670 --> 00:27:33.089
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And then the last one, I'm going to end on a note of unity thank you.

217
00:27:33.089 --> 00:27:33.089
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Councilor Smith.

218
00:27:33.089 --> 00:27:33.089
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you, Mayor.

219
00:27:33.089 --> 00:27:40.000
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I just wanted to echo some of the comments that have been made because there is one area where I think Portlanders broadly agreed, and that is around transparency and accountability.

220
00:27:41.009 --> 00:28:02.490
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I think regardless of which side of this issue people were on or where on the spectrum they were, we did see a lot of comments around the importance of having a public process, of being accountable, and having Portlanders really understand how this so I will end on that note.

221
00:28:02.555 --> 00:28:06.306
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Happy to answer any questions and look forward to giving you the full report next week.

222
00:28:09.684 --> 00:28:12.587
<v Kristen Dennis>Excellent.

223
00:28:13.233 --> 00:28:14.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

224
00:28:16.170 --> 00:28:19.471
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, Kristen, at this point, should we just jump into—.

225
00:28:20.019 --> 00:28:23.473
<v Mitch Green>Oh, do we— if we have technical questions on that presentation, do you think?

226
00:28:23.699 --> 00:28:27.298
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's jump into some questions for either the framing or also for Laura's presentation.

227
00:28:27.811 --> 00:28:32.070
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Council President.

228
00:28:32.328 --> 00:28:33.715
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for the presentation, Laura.

229
00:28:34.698 --> 00:28:51.435
<v Mitch Green>I want to go back to the results of the distribution of strong support, strong opposition, whether we're looking at the question of whether the thing should be renovated at all or the question of whether or not to use $120 million in public funds.

230
00:28:51.773 --> 00:28:56.807
<v Mitch Green>I do want to note that I think it was right to divide those 2 types of inquiry because those are 2 different things.

231
00:28:56.855 --> 00:28:56.984
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

232
00:28:57.814 --> 00:29:06.111
<v Mitch Green>This is a complicated public opinion matter, and so you might support redevelopment without necessarily supporting the public funds being used.

233
00:29:06.160 --> 00:29:08.198
<v Mitch Green>But I want to make sure I'm clarifying something.

234
00:29:08.246 --> 00:29:22.898
<v Mitch Green>So when you said that this is perhaps not picking up moderate opinions, are you talking about the politically moderate opinion or the sort of folks who are maybe less interested in— they don't feel strongly either way?

235
00:29:23.092 --> 00:29:23.749
<v Laura Oppenheimer>The latter.

236
00:29:24.357 --> 00:29:25.096
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Okay.

237
00:29:25.400 --> 00:29:37.777
<v Laura Oppenheimer>It was clear to us that groups that have strong passionate opinions on the topic were very effective at mobilizing people to fill out the survey, which is great as a civic engagement exercise, right?

238
00:29:37.825 --> 00:29:39.557
<v Laura Oppenheimer>It's a way to express their opinion.

239
00:29:40.006 --> 00:29:49.689
<v Laura Oppenheimer>But we could literally see when there was a particularly effective social media push, you know, in the early parts of the survey results kind of swinging one direction or the other.

240
00:29:49.800 --> 00:29:52.590
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Additionally, we did ask how people got to the survey.

241
00:29:53.231 --> 00:29:58.760
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I can't quote you the number off the top of my head, but a very large proportion came to it through social media.

242
00:29:59.321 --> 00:30:06.451
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And so what that tells me is that a lot of people came to it with a passion on this issue, and I do think that shows up in the results.

243
00:30:07.334 --> 00:30:12.829
<v Laura Oppenheimer>But of course, the same would be true if you held a listening session or a lot of other modes of engagement.

244
00:30:12.877 --> 00:30:27.063
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I think statistically valid public opinion research through a firm that does that would probably be the one surefire way to know that you're getting a full cross-section of the population coming at it without strong opinions.

245
00:30:27.126 --> 00:30:27.174
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Right.

246
00:30:27.222 --> 00:30:27.960
<v Mitch Green>No, I appreciate that.

247
00:30:28.313 --> 00:30:32.641
<v Mitch Green>And it is not a statistically valid method, and we all recognize that.

248
00:30:33.538 --> 00:30:35.926
<v Mitch Green>I will note that this is a Likert scale.

249
00:30:36.279 --> 00:30:40.143
<v Mitch Green>So rank from 1 to 5 your feelings about a thing.

250
00:30:40.207 --> 00:30:45.608
<v Mitch Green>So that scale is pretty standard, and it's designed to gauge kind of the nuance of range of opinions.

251
00:30:45.801 --> 00:30:49.862
<v Mitch Green>Position, but those are almost always distributed with those same extreme polars.

252
00:30:50.455 --> 00:30:57.163
<v Mitch Green>So it's— and those are in randomized unbiased samples or general good unbiased estimates of the total population.

253
00:30:57.211 --> 00:31:01.415
<v Mitch Green>So the nature of that style of questioning will produce those.

254
00:31:01.463 --> 00:31:10.467
<v Mitch Green>So it's not that it's necessarily, you know, I want to be careful that we don't dismiss those responses because it was not a statistically significant outcome.

255
00:31:10.515 --> 00:31:19.404
<v Mitch Green>You'll likely see the same thing with the A Likert scale is just ordinal, which means you say what you prefer over the other.

256
00:31:19.873 --> 00:31:24.173
<v Mitch Green>You cannot say how much more I prefer the other thing over the other, which is where you would get the more nuance.

257
00:31:24.938 --> 00:31:32.829
<v Mitch Green>So as we're working through that, I think it's really important to clarify that piece, which is just a statistical matter of interest.

258
00:31:32.894 --> 00:31:33.221
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

259
00:31:33.546 --> 00:31:34.164
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

260
00:31:34.344 --> 00:31:35.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

261
00:31:37.375 --> 00:31:38.344
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks, Council President.

262
00:31:39.385 --> 00:31:40.241
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you to both of you.

263
00:31:40.742 --> 00:31:49.720
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am grateful that Metro Council President has offered to provide some support by having you help.

264
00:31:49.945 --> 00:31:52.592
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And thank you, Laura, for your work too.

265
00:31:52.786 --> 00:32:02.067
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I see you working really hard and being thrown into this and just want to be clear that if there's ever any tension or spiciness, it's not about you all.

266
00:32:02.148 --> 00:32:05.460
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's that this is a charged topic in case you haven't noticed.

267
00:32:06.347 --> 00:32:13.480
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I wanted to clarify, did I hear correctly that 60% of respondents were removed from the data because they didn't share their location?

268
00:32:14.780 --> 00:32:23.759
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Every single response that you saw other than that one graph by council district includes all participants regardless if they shared their location.

269
00:32:24.193 --> 00:32:24.756
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Okay.

270
00:32:24.980 --> 00:32:34.211
<v Laura Oppenheimer>However, in order to provide you with district-specific results, of course, we can only include the people who who did state their location within the district results.

271
00:32:34.692 --> 00:32:46.571
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So all of the overall results apply to the entire 18,000 people, and then we'll provide those council district-specific ones, and, you know, you can analyze those for what they're worth without the other participants in there.

272
00:32:47.116 --> 00:32:47.212
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

273
00:32:48.255 --> 00:32:53.513
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can you clarify a bit about the creation of the survey and the shaping of it?

274
00:32:54.090 --> 00:33:02.941
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciate the using of the 6 councilors who hold gavels that weekly meeting, using that sort of leadership team.

275
00:33:03.967 --> 00:33:09.916
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I heard mixed things that some were like, I don't remember actually seeing that, or we got it really last minute.

276
00:33:09.980 --> 00:33:11.777
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So where did the questions start from?

277
00:33:12.130 --> 00:33:14.519
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How much workshopping was there back and forth?

278
00:33:15.257 --> 00:33:16.587
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Yeah, I can briefly describe.

279
00:33:16.717 --> 00:33:25.585
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I will also say that 3 weeks from ideation to completion is not the optimal timeline and does not allow for the review loops that would typically—.

280
00:33:25.890 --> 00:33:26.996
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Totally fair.

281
00:33:28.536 --> 00:33:30.265
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Be used in this kind of process.

282
00:33:30.490 --> 00:33:36.564
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So at each Monday meeting, we took one kind of major step because of that exceptionally tight timeline.

283
00:33:36.612 --> 00:33:44.713
<v Laura Oppenheimer>At the first one, we had to talk about what sorts of topics would be included in the survey within a couple business days, got a draft done based on that.

284
00:33:45.212 --> 00:33:50.131
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And then I think we had one or two business days turnaround time for feedback.

285
00:33:50.307 --> 00:33:51.712
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Again, not optimal.

286
00:33:52.229 --> 00:33:52.843
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Yeah.

287
00:33:54.547 --> 00:34:01.323
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And I think typically you would want to see more iterations and more time in those review loops.

288
00:34:02.173 --> 00:34:10.876
<v Laura Oppenheimer>That being said, we were able to incorporate the vast majority of comments that we received from council offices in the survey.

289
00:34:12.289 --> 00:34:24.402
<v Laura Oppenheimer>And then in any case where there was maybe conflicting feedback or something that, that felt hard to implement, we worked directly with the council president's office to figure out how to handle that.

290
00:34:25.266 --> 00:34:27.030
<v Laura Oppenheimer>That was only a couple of instances, though.

291
00:34:27.606 --> 00:34:33.217
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Understand the tight timeline, and ideally we would have started this engagement 6 months ago or even a year ago.

292
00:34:33.601 --> 00:34:37.527
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think you're doing the best you can with what you have been thrown into.

293
00:34:38.168 --> 00:34:49.956
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will be honest that I have— I heard from a lot of constituents that it felt like a push-pull, that it didn't feel like there was information to explain a lot of those pieces and that there was It was pushing people in a certain direction.

294
00:34:50.393 --> 00:34:57.378
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so just a few days ago, I put out— yeah, I know, Councilor Ryan, you're making little comments over here, but I have the floor.

295
00:34:57.943 --> 00:34:59.282
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Got it.

296
00:35:01.057 --> 00:35:03.251
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I did put one out just a few days ago.

297
00:35:03.315 --> 00:35:05.929
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I did not get as many responses, but I did get almost 2,000.

298
00:35:05.978 --> 00:35:08.045
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I don't think that's anything to sneeze at.

299
00:35:08.983 --> 00:35:13.637
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Most were in District 3, 58%, but I got thank you.

300
00:35:13.717 --> 00:35:16.610
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Folks from every— all of your districts.

301
00:35:17.253 --> 00:35:21.913
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I understand, I mean, we're District 3, so it's, it's a little different.

302
00:35:22.010 --> 00:35:22.702
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You can see that.

303
00:35:22.797 --> 00:35:29.945
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I heard from 109 people from District 1, 183 from District 2, and 220 from District 4.

304
00:35:31.688 --> 00:35:45.797
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>To share with my colleagues, because I think it is important to hear, the vast majority did say fund only the necessary renovations for things like accessibility, safety, and standard maintenance.

305
00:35:46.023 --> 00:35:48.052
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And don't do the deal even if the Blazers leave.

306
00:35:48.389 --> 00:35:53.246
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Not saying that those are things that I want, but that's the results that I also got.

307
00:35:53.358 --> 00:35:57.505
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I would've loved a chance to help get a little bit more data.

308
00:35:58.250 --> 00:35:59.356
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'll leave it there.

309
00:36:00.641 --> 00:36:01.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

310
00:36:02.041 --> 00:36:02.724
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

311
00:36:04.755 --> 00:36:05.871
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

312
00:36:06.032 --> 00:36:35.521
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I just have a request that I know I have mentioned to you, but I want to make in a more formal way, which is that when you get us the complete results and you're looking at the crosstabs and, and how we separate this and how we understand it, I would like to be able to see as closely as we can approximate the people who filled out the survey at the parks, whether that's looking at people who filled it out that weekend, or if we can go more granular and say filled it out that weekend at an event.

313
00:36:36.228 --> 00:36:45.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am very curious because I've heard you say before that you saw swings as different organizations and different individuals pushed this out.

314
00:36:46.280 --> 00:36:47.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a really good thing.

315
00:36:47.483 --> 00:36:54.179
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's a really important thing where we have passionate groups of Portlanders who are talking about something for us to hear that.

316
00:36:54.789 --> 00:36:55.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I also Councilor Smith.

317
00:36:55.672 --> 00:37:09.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also want to be able to understand where those Portlanders who didn't proactively come to us, who aren't on our lists, who we don't reach normally, but who one of us or one of our team members walked up to in a park and said, hey, we want to know what you think.

318
00:37:10.347 --> 00:37:13.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had a few people at the park say, oh, well, I don't, I don't really know.

319
00:37:13.414 --> 00:37:21.876
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I said, that's exactly why I'm here, because we want to know what you think without having already been passionate about this.

320
00:37:22.471 --> 00:37:33.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to see where those folks are as best as we can approximate, knowing that it's not scientific, um, but reflecting the important conversations that we had that weekend.

321
00:37:34.032 --> 00:37:39.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if you can make sure that we have some way of pulling that out when you get us the crosstabs, I would really appreciate it.

322
00:37:39.827 --> 00:37:41.900
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Yeah, well, we have that on our list.

323
00:37:42.059 --> 00:37:42.333
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

324
00:37:43.039 --> 00:37:43.440
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

325
00:37:43.666 --> 00:37:44.485
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

326
00:37:44.644 --> 00:37:45.175
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

327
00:37:46.893 --> 00:37:56.561
<v Candace Avalos>All right, well, I was told, you know, we would have some time to just kind of put on the record our thoughts, and so I have, um, some of those comments to share, and then if I have time left over, I've got some questions.

328
00:37:56.914 --> 00:37:57.235
<v Candace Avalos>Sound good?

329
00:37:58.101 --> 00:38:00.778
<v Candace Avalos>Um, thank you again, Council Pres— is there an issue?

330
00:38:01.003 --> 00:38:01.324
<v Candace Avalos>No, you're good.

331
00:38:01.485 --> 00:38:01.693
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

332
00:38:02.190 --> 00:38:04.355
<v Candace Avalos>Um, thank you again, Council President.

333
00:38:04.434 --> 00:38:10.400
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks, Kristen, for jumping in to help, um, and for just facilitating this process and doing the pop-ups.

334
00:38:11.010 --> 00:38:17.394
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, thank you to the thousands of Portlanders that took the time to complete the survey and, um, just engage in the conversation.

335
00:38:17.443 --> 00:38:20.813
<v Candace Avalos>Your participation is really important, and I just wanted to name that directly.

336
00:38:21.456 --> 00:38:26.623
<v Candace Avalos>So for me, looking at the results, uh, it's clear to me that Portlanders are not speaking with one voice.

337
00:38:27.233 --> 00:38:34.070
<v Candace Avalos>People are divided on whether the Moda Center should be renovated, or even more skeptical about committing significant public dollars.

338
00:38:34.135 --> 00:38:42.273
<v Candace Avalos>And so to me, what that means is that we just have an obligation to slow down, ask good questions, Make sure that the public understands the choices that are in front of us.

339
00:38:43.027 --> 00:38:48.646
<v Candace Avalos>I am excited that this is our first public conversation about the future of the Moda Center.

340
00:38:48.726 --> 00:38:53.302
<v Candace Avalos>I think it is definitely happening a lot later than many of us wanted to, but let's seize the moment.

341
00:38:54.184 --> 00:39:02.324
<v Candace Avalos>And I think the goal here is to not argue for a particular outcome, but what I want to say first on the record is that we do have options.

342
00:39:02.452 --> 00:39:08.713
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's the thing that keeps getting muddled, and I really want Portlanders to understand that.

343
00:39:08.762 --> 00:39:09.099
<v Kristen Dennis>Councilor Smith.

344
00:39:09.612 --> 00:39:17.416
<v Candace Avalos>We have the power to decide what goes into the deal, that there's not just one deal structure available to us, one financing model, all of that.

345
00:39:17.543 --> 00:39:21.902
<v Candace Avalos>So, and then there's also not one definition of what people consider a fair deal.

346
00:39:21.965 --> 00:39:30.121
<v Candace Avalos>So I think that's obviously what you're seeing in the tension around like how all of our opinions are showing up on the dais and in the public.

347
00:39:30.922 --> 00:39:38.744
<v Candace Avalos>So as these negotiations are continuing, I think that the city has the ability to to pursue a bunch of different options.

348
00:39:38.793 --> 00:39:45.224
<v Candace Avalos>And I wanted to name some of those so I could just put into the record what Portlanders could expect, at least that I plan to talk about.

349
00:39:45.833 --> 00:39:48.271
<v Candace Avalos>But I think just to lay out what is available.

350
00:39:48.318 --> 00:39:57.362
<v Candace Avalos>So one I think is a meaningful private capital contribution from ownership consistent with many arena deals around the country.

351
00:39:57.523 --> 00:40:00.170
<v Candace Avalos>That is probably my number one issue.

352
00:40:01.452 --> 00:40:06.985
<v Candace Avalos>I am going to have a hard time agreeing to give public money if I'm not seeing a private investment.

353
00:40:07.722 --> 00:40:12.518
<v Candace Avalos>That is what public-private investment means, and I will be demanding that that comes true.

354
00:40:13.255 --> 00:40:18.867
<v Candace Avalos>Number 2, rent or other financial payments recognizing the value of operating a publicly owned facility.

355
00:40:18.965 --> 00:40:22.076
<v Candace Avalos>So I definitely want to make sure we're negotiating those payments.

356
00:40:23.518 --> 00:40:28.217
<v Candace Avalos>Requirements that the private operator cover ongoing maintenance and capital responsibilities.

357
00:40:28.409 --> 00:40:31.889
<v Candace Avalos>It's my understanding that they currently cover half of the cost of maintenance.

358
00:40:32.659 --> 00:40:33.445
<v Candace Avalos>That is the floor.

359
00:40:33.782 --> 00:40:38.590
<v Candace Avalos>So I will not accept anything less than half of their responsibility on maintenance.

360
00:40:39.632 --> 00:40:44.088
<v Candace Avalos>A longer lease term and stronger relocation protections to provide certainty for Portlanders.

361
00:40:45.483 --> 00:40:47.054
<v Candace Avalos>I know we've been talking a lot about 20 years.

362
00:40:47.632 --> 00:40:50.117
<v Candace Avalos>It sounds like there is an option to extend that.

363
00:40:50.998 --> 00:40:57.987
<v Candace Avalos>I think pushing for 30 would be great, but I wanna make sure that that's available to us to extend that possible lease.

364
00:40:59.094 --> 00:41:13.317
<v Candace Avalos>As it relates to labor standards, including things like labor peace agreements, and also important that we are looking looking at prevailing wages, not just for the construction, but also living wages for the employees that will operate the Moda Center.

365
00:41:13.847 --> 00:41:19.637
<v Candace Avalos>And, you know, having local hiring and opportunities for workers to organize is going to be really critical to me.

366
00:41:20.985 --> 00:41:24.530
<v Candace Avalos>Obviously, we all keep talking about community investments and community benefits.

367
00:41:25.010 --> 00:41:27.304
<v Candace Avalos>And so that's things like in the surrounding neighborhood.

368
00:41:27.561 --> 00:41:32.806
<v Candace Avalos>I think other things that I've heard that we should talk about are improved transit access.

369
00:41:32.855 --> 00:41:32.951
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

370
00:41:33.523 --> 00:41:38.606
<v Candace Avalos>Public use opportunities and partnerships that create lasting value beyond just game day, right?

371
00:41:38.686 --> 00:41:51.476
<v Candace Avalos>The whole— if this conversation is beyond the Blazers, then I want to make sure that the negotiation is not limited to what the Blazers need, but what this Moda Center needs, because it is an important part of not just our city, but our state.

372
00:41:53.039 --> 00:41:54.222
<v Candace Avalos>Revenue sharing opportunities.

373
00:41:54.271 --> 00:42:02.315
<v Candace Avalos>So whether that's parking, premium seating, concessions, naming rights, or other sources that will allow the public to share in the success of an asset that they own.

374
00:42:02.893 --> 00:42:05.746
<v Candace Avalos>If we own it, they share the success in that asset.

375
00:42:06.659 --> 00:42:08.775
<v Candace Avalos>And then lastly, strong accountability measures.

376
00:42:08.905 --> 00:42:12.143
<v Candace Avalos>As you ended with, Laura, that is definitely common across the board.

377
00:42:12.592 --> 00:42:24.983
<v Candace Avalos>And so to me, that looks like including independent cost analyses, transparent financial reporting, audit rights, enforceable performance metrics, and clear consequences if commitments are not met.

378
00:42:25.063 --> 00:42:25.175
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

379
00:42:25.431 --> 00:42:28.530
<v Candace Avalos>So any kind of accountability measures need to have teeth.

380
00:42:28.643 --> 00:42:31.773
<v Candace Avalos>They need to have a way to hold them accountable if they're not met.

381
00:42:32.559 --> 00:42:39.351
<v Candace Avalos>And so, and yeah, I think that we also have the option to negotiate longer or differently if that's what it takes to secure a better outcome.

382
00:42:39.463 --> 00:42:40.699
<v Candace Avalos>That's some of the questions that I have.

383
00:42:40.762 --> 00:42:47.634
<v Candace Avalos>But, you know, I have always felt that artificial urgency should not substitute for careful stewardship of public resources.

384
00:42:48.452 --> 00:42:57.322
<v Candace Avalos>I know that there's been a lot of rhetoric in recent weeks suggesting that I completely reject that premise.

385
00:42:57.851 --> 00:43:01.458
<v Candace Avalos>I think that supporting the Moda Center and scrutinizing the Moda Center are not opposites.

386
00:43:01.538 --> 00:43:05.673
<v Candace Avalos>In fact, because it is a publicly owned asset, I think scrutiny is part of our responsibility.

387
00:43:06.411 --> 00:43:09.503
<v Candace Avalos>I've also heard the argument that criticism is easy, negotiation is hard.

388
00:43:09.936 --> 00:43:11.010
<v Candace Avalos>You're right, it is hard.

389
00:43:11.396 --> 00:43:19.666
<v Candace Avalos>And that is exactly why we should negotiate from a position of strength, armed with good data, clear expectations, and a firm understanding of what Portlanders deserve in return.

390
00:43:19.731 --> 00:43:24.931
<v Candace Avalos>Councilmember Wilson, So for me, this conversation comes down to a couple of expectations that I want to lay on the table.

391
00:43:25.735 --> 00:43:30.936
<v Candace Avalos>I expect transparent cost estimates and an independent understanding of what this renovation requires.

392
00:43:31.771 --> 00:43:36.476
<v Candace Avalos>I expect meaningful private participation alongside any public investment.

393
00:43:37.295 --> 00:43:40.731
<v Candace Avalos>I expect enforceable community benefits and strong protections for workers.

394
00:43:41.726 --> 00:43:44.360
<v Candace Avalos>I expect accountability and measurable public return.

395
00:43:44.617 --> 00:43:49.514
<v Candace Avalos>And lastly, I expect to use funding sources that are appropriate for this type of investment.

396
00:43:50.460 --> 00:43:51.489
<v Candace Avalos>I love the Blazers.

397
00:43:51.664 --> 00:43:57.766
<v Candace Avalos>I understand the importance of the Moda Center to our city, and I understand that deferred maintenance can become more expensive over time.

398
00:43:58.489 --> 00:44:01.315
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but I also represent Portlanders who are worried about paying rent.

399
00:44:01.396 --> 00:44:02.327
<v Candace Avalos>They're worried about housing.

400
00:44:02.438 --> 00:44:06.501
<v Candace Avalos>They're worried about heat deaths, behavioral health issues, worried about making ends meet.

401
00:44:07.320 --> 00:44:12.168
<v Candace Avalos>Those realities don't make this investment impossible, but it does make it our responsibility to negotiate the best deal possible.

402
00:44:12.344 --> 00:44:13.755
<v Candace Avalos>So my goal is not to say no.

403
00:44:14.157 --> 00:44:18.516
<v Candace Avalos>My goal is to define the conditions under which Portland can confidently say yes.

404
00:44:19.751 --> 00:44:29.579
<v Candace Avalos>I have just 2 questions that I'll ask for now, and I think the main thing around these questions are understanding what kind of information we're going to be getting and when.

405
00:44:30.204 --> 00:44:43.710
<v Candace Avalos>So can you walk us through the range of potential city funding sources that are still under consideration and explain thank you.

406
00:44:43.710 --> 00:44:45.309
<v Kristen Dennis>Great question, Councilor.

407
00:44:45.309 --> 00:44:47.139
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm actually going to share a PowerPoint.

408
00:44:47.929 --> 00:44:54.130
<v Kristen Dennis>You got ahead of me a little bit, but you're exactly where we need to get going, so thank you for leading the charge on that.

409
00:44:56.280 --> 00:45:02.710
<v Kristen Dennis>I— part of the conversation, right, because as you said, this is the first time that you all have had a conversation to have these conversations about what are the outcomes.

410
00:45:02.739 --> 00:45:07.179
<v Kristen Dennis>Thank you.

411
00:45:07.179 --> 00:45:12.380
<v Kristen Dennis>And I want to differentiate between that and some of the tools that we're talking about.

412
00:45:12.380 --> 00:45:23.530
<v Kristen Dennis>And so the way that we assess those and that we can assess those as staff for council to make sure they meet council direction is to first figure out what are you looking for, what are your values, and then we can figure out if those tools reflect those values.

413
00:45:25.099 --> 00:45:38.019
<v Kristen Dennis>And so we'll be able to get you some of those, and I will make sure that Mayor Wilson and I Deputy City Administrator Raymond C. can Lee walk you through exactly what we're able to get you, which will be narrowed down based on what we believe can actually achieve some of the— thank you.

414
00:45:38.489 --> 00:45:43.690
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Kristen, before we get ahead, we actually have a couple councilors who still have a few more technical questions and some questions for Laura as well.

415
00:45:43.690 --> 00:45:51.789
<v Kristen Dennis>Yeah, yeah, if we could do the Laura questions and then, because we're gonna get into some of the tools too here, and then we'll probably definitely need the other city staff to come up and go over that.

416
00:45:51.789 --> 00:45:52.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, that was my fault.

417
00:45:52.909 --> 00:45:53.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>I—.

418
00:45:53.449 --> 00:45:54.050
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

419
00:45:54.050 --> 00:45:54.309
<v Candace Avalos>That was all me.

420
00:45:54.615 --> 00:45:54.889
<v Candace Avalos>My bad.

421
00:45:55.097 --> 00:45:55.916
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm glad to be here.

422
00:45:56.014 --> 00:45:58.503
<v Candace Avalos>Now you know what my question is, so you can prepare to answer that.

423
00:45:58.568 --> 00:46:10.505
<v Candace Avalos>And then let me give you another question that you can noodle on, which is, I guess I just want to understand what aspects of the current timeline are driven by legal requirements versus policy choices.

424
00:46:11.018 --> 00:46:16.079
<v Candace Avalos>And if council believed that additional negotiation time would lead to a better deal, what flexibility exists?

425
00:46:16.159 --> 00:46:19.661
<v Candace Avalos>So the sources of money, the flexibility of the timeline are my main questions.

426
00:46:19.759 --> 00:46:26.880
<v Candace Avalos>I have a million more that I'm sure my colleagues thank you, Councilor Avalos.

427
00:46:27.137 --> 00:46:28.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor Morillo.

428
00:46:29.393 --> 00:46:40.911
<v Jamie Dunphy>And colleagues, just to be super clear, let's get technical questions out and then we will do— we'll let Kristen do another quick PowerPoint and then we will get to lay out very similar to how Councilor Avalos just did, which was perfect.

429
00:46:40.976 --> 00:46:41.284
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you.

430
00:46:41.431 --> 00:46:42.228
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo, thank you.

431
00:46:45.757 --> 00:46:48.170
<v Angelita Morillo>I mean, I'm not even sure I'm sorry.

432
00:46:48.266 --> 00:46:48.394
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes, ma'am.

433
00:46:48.443 --> 00:46:48.570
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm sorry.

434
00:46:48.619 --> 00:46:52.514
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not sure how anyone has any technical questions based on the information that we're receiving today.

435
00:46:53.090 --> 00:47:04.199
<v Angelita Morillo>No offense to you guys, you guys are great, but this is— I am trying not to be extremely livid right now because we are under an extremely compressed timeline as city councilors.

436
00:47:04.552 --> 00:47:07.661
<v Angelita Morillo>We are being forced to negotiate this in a couple of months.

437
00:47:08.463 --> 00:47:11.893
<v Angelita Morillo>These community listening sessions were put out with 4 days' notice.

438
00:47:12.581 --> 00:47:22.405
<v Angelita Morillo>My own staffer who has an LCL tear uh, struggled to find the event that was posted in Laurelhurst Park, which is a ginormous park.

439
00:47:22.728 --> 00:47:27.833
<v Angelita Morillo>She walked for 30 minutes on her injured knee in 90-degree weather to try to find the event.

440
00:47:28.527 --> 00:47:36.215
<v Angelita Morillo>As a staffer, she didn't have any more details about where it was, so I'm assuming other people with different abilities were not able to find the event.

441
00:47:38.317 --> 00:47:41.501
<v Angelita Morillo>So we're getting data that's not statistically relevant.

442
00:47:42.244 --> 00:47:49.539
<v Angelita Morillo>From a survey that was pushed around in NBA forums as well, from people who are not necessarily from Portland.

443
00:47:50.682 --> 00:47:51.664
<v Angelita Morillo>Great, we have that.

444
00:47:52.164 --> 00:47:52.905
<v Angelita Morillo>Not that helpful.

445
00:47:53.757 --> 00:48:01.458
<v Angelita Morillo>We have been asking in executive session for weeks now for basic comparisons to other cities.

446
00:48:01.657 --> 00:48:03.219
<v Angelita Morillo>What deals have other cities gotten?

447
00:48:04.829 --> 00:48:04.960
<v Angelita Morillo>Why—.

448
00:48:06.014 --> 00:48:15.831
<v Angelita Morillo>Like, the, the fact that we're having a conversation about how to have a conversation today is honestly mind-boggling given the timeline that we have to make this decision.

449
00:48:18.489 --> 00:48:26.362
<v Angelita Morillo>The, the questions that I have, I will just list out the things that I not only expect but demand that we have later.

450
00:48:26.940 --> 00:48:28.614
<v Angelita Morillo>Mr. Oliveira, I hope you're listening.

451
00:48:29.596 --> 00:48:32.302
<v Angelita Morillo>The negotiator, wherever he is, maybe at the Moda Center.

452
00:48:32.576 --> 00:48:33.059
<v Angelita Morillo>Where is he?

453
00:48:33.235 --> 00:48:33.606
<v Donnie Oliveira>He's in the room.

454
00:48:36.802 --> 00:48:38.568
<v Angelita Morillo>Is he at the Moda Center with Tom Dundon?

455
00:48:38.929 --> 00:48:39.632
<v Angelita Morillo>Is that what's happening?

456
00:48:39.730 --> 00:48:40.237
<v Angelita Morillo>Where is he?

457
00:48:41.539 --> 00:48:42.507
<v Angelita Morillo>Nobody wants to work these days?

458
00:48:42.605 --> 00:48:42.847
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

459
00:48:43.929 --> 00:48:47.190
<v Angelita Morillo>The questions I have are, what do we currently pay for in maintenance?

460
00:48:48.273 --> 00:48:51.324
<v Angelita Morillo>How does that compare to what we might be paying in the future?

461
00:48:54.753 --> 00:48:57.422
<v Angelita Morillo>Are we going to use the spectator venues fund?

462
00:48:58.070 --> 00:49:00.318
<v Angelita Morillo>And if so, does that eat into our reserves?

463
00:49:02.900 --> 00:49:08.505
<v Angelita Morillo>Can we get a 20-year forecast to figure out if that's going to harm any other sources of revenue?

464
00:49:08.922 --> 00:49:13.130
<v Angelita Morillo>I mean, I'm just asking for basic information so that we can make this decision.

465
00:49:13.402 --> 00:49:19.264
<v Angelita Morillo>And I— we're going to be here till 5 PM having another discussion about how to have a discussion.

466
00:49:19.360 --> 00:49:22.460
<v Angelita Morillo>I feel like I'm going to lose my mind, honestly.

467
00:49:23.280 --> 00:49:24.516
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I don't know.

468
00:49:24.581 --> 00:49:27.940
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't know if I have anything more substantive to add given the Thank you.

469
00:49:27.940 --> 00:49:27.940
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Herbold, I'm sorry.

470
00:49:27.940 --> 00:49:27.940
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm sorry.

471
00:49:27.940 --> 00:49:27.940
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Herbold, I'm sorry.

472
00:49:27.940 --> 00:49:31.829
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm sorry for the minuscule information that has been submitted in this.

473
00:49:34.340 --> 00:49:35.599
<v Angelita Morillo>This is not public engagement.

474
00:49:36.980 --> 00:49:39.750
<v Angelita Morillo>This is not getting statistically helpful data.

475
00:49:40.380 --> 00:49:46.130
<v Angelita Morillo>And in every single executive session, I have asked over and over and over again for the same thing.

476
00:49:46.239 --> 00:49:49.190
<v Angelita Morillo>We need comparisons about what other cities have gotten.

477
00:49:49.300 --> 00:49:52.559
<v Angelita Morillo>We need to know what regular deals are in other places.

478
00:49:52.719 --> 00:49:54.519
<v Angelita Morillo>We need to know what the cost comparisons are.

479
00:49:54.659 --> 00:49:56.382
<v Angelita Morillo>If they are saying, Councilor Smith.

480
00:49:56.447 --> 00:49:59.657
<v Angelita Morillo>We bring in this much money for the city, so you guys better do something about it.

481
00:50:00.074 --> 00:50:02.161
<v Angelita Morillo>Where is the evidence for that?

482
00:50:03.349 --> 00:50:04.938
<v Angelita Morillo>I have gotten zero evidence for anything.

483
00:50:05.050 --> 00:50:11.759
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm being told that we're going to have a magical, uh, electrification plan for the Albina neighborhood.

484
00:50:11.952 --> 00:50:14.101
<v Angelita Morillo>I said, awesome, that sounds lit.

485
00:50:14.824 --> 00:50:16.012
<v Angelita Morillo>Where is the information?

486
00:50:16.461 --> 00:50:17.858
<v Angelita Morillo>Is there an architecture plan?

487
00:50:18.773 --> 00:50:46.420
<v Angelita Morillo>Is there anything that is proving to me that we are actually going to be able to electrify the Albina neighborhood, or are they pitting thank you, Council President.

488
00:50:46.420 --> 00:50:49.679
<v Dan Ryan>I will go back to technical questions, so this will come to you, Laura.

489
00:50:49.679 --> 00:50:52.286
<v Dan Ryan>Before that, I apologize, Councilor Councilor Koyama Lane.

490
00:50:52.885 --> 00:51:02.992
<v Dan Ryan>We were having a little moment over here about the push-pull comment because we experienced that on— I've experienced that on both sides of the U, as you call it.

491
00:51:03.170 --> 00:51:08.119
<v Dan Ryan>So depending on your perspective, it was a push-pull that was not favorable to your side.

492
00:51:08.750 --> 00:51:10.141
<v Dan Ryan>So I just wanted to put that out.

493
00:51:11.420 --> 00:51:20.643
<v Dan Ryan>Speaking of swings, you mentioned swings based on promotional social promotional emails that came out from different organizations.

494
00:51:20.690 --> 00:51:20.755
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

495
00:51:21.503 --> 00:51:23.621
<v Dan Ryan>Probably from council offices as well.

496
00:51:24.375 --> 00:51:32.059
<v Dan Ryan>I would like to see some datasets on how you could attribute any influence of those push-pulls to those swings.

497
00:51:32.668 --> 00:51:36.951
<v Dan Ryan>So what groups were the ones that pushed it to one side or the other?

498
00:51:37.143 --> 00:51:37.849
<v Dan Ryan>That would be helpful.

499
00:51:38.266 --> 00:51:40.929
<v Dan Ryan>So we don't have to just pretend we know.

500
00:51:41.394 --> 00:51:43.496
<v Dan Ryan>So any data on that would be really, really helpful.

501
00:51:44.025 --> 00:51:44.731
<v Dan Ryan>Is that possible?

502
00:51:46.192 --> 00:51:48.132
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Well, it is certainly possible to do that.

503
00:51:48.181 --> 00:51:51.277
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Well, you made the statement, so that's why I thought.

504
00:51:51.742 --> 00:51:55.418
<v Laura Oppenheimer>The survey through social media in general.

505
00:51:55.739 --> 00:52:03.753
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I don't know after the fact if we can tell which ones came from which social media, but I'll have the team look into what's possible.

506
00:52:03.864 --> 00:52:10.641
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I thought your comment was very important to take in, and so I just wanted some actually data behind that.

507
00:52:11.010 --> 00:52:11.331
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

508
00:52:11.556 --> 00:52:16.277
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I'll save my statements and parameter stuff after we're done with the technical questions.

509
00:52:16.630 --> 00:52:16.887
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

510
00:52:18.085 --> 00:52:18.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

511
00:52:18.878 --> 00:52:19.313
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

512
00:52:20.347 --> 00:52:23.806
<v Mitch Green>I mean, I'm just back in the queue for the broad discussion, so maybe I'll just pull my hand off.

513
00:52:23.967 --> 00:52:24.291
<v Steve Novick>Okay, great.

514
00:52:24.389 --> 00:52:26.942
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll turn it over back to, to Kristen.

515
00:52:27.297 --> 00:52:27.864
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, okay.

516
00:52:28.753 --> 00:52:31.018
<v Kristen Dennis>Sorry, Mayor.

517
00:52:31.260 --> 00:52:32.489
<v Kristen Dennis>Our way back up.

518
00:52:34.780 --> 00:52:41.594
<v Kristen Dennis>Uh, all right, so quickly, um, sorry, moving forward.

519
00:52:41.692 --> 00:52:50.139
<v Kristen Dennis>Okay, uh, Councilor Avalos, you asked the question earlier about the timeline, and, um, sorry, sorry, I need to get back.

520
00:52:50.722 --> 00:52:51.012
<v Kristen Dennis>I skipped ahead.

521
00:52:51.108 --> 00:52:51.398
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm sorry.

522
00:52:51.913 --> 00:53:03.059
<v Kristen Dennis>Um, so, uh, as you all discussed, uh, the City of Portland, uh, y'all are venue operators, and the City Council gets to set policy direction under which the venues operate.

523
00:53:03.849 --> 00:53:12.264
<v Kristen Dennis>Like any building, and really any business based on providing a facility, the Moda Center will need funding for maintenance and improvements in order to get it booked and sell tickets to the event.

524
00:53:13.559 --> 00:53:21.206
<v Kristen Dennis>Now, this is not the first time that the city has undergone some of these investments for facilities.

525
00:53:21.302 --> 00:53:28.168
<v Kristen Dennis>For instance, funds out of the Visitor Development Fund, which were used to finance the Veterans Memorial Coliseum.

526
00:53:30.434 --> 00:53:35.844
<v Kristen Dennis>Any of these different funding sources are going to have of opportunities and also limitations.

527
00:53:37.440 --> 00:53:44.751
<v Kristen Dennis>Then you also have buildings like the Keller Auditorium, which the council is currently discussing and making investments in as well.

528
00:53:46.360 --> 00:53:53.188
<v Kristen Dennis>For buildings like the Keller, they can have extensive years-long processes with stakeholders envisioning and many competing studies.

529
00:53:54.007 --> 00:54:00.418
<v Kristen Dennis>And so there's a lot of different ways that you all, and just like Metro and other public organizations, Councilor Smith.

530
00:54:00.706 --> 00:54:01.349
<v Kristen Dennis>Thank you, Mayor.

531
00:54:01.429 --> 00:54:03.452
<v Kristen Dennis>I have a question for the city staff.

532
00:54:03.501 --> 00:54:10.806
<v Kristen Dennis>So I understand that the city council gets to decide what route and what process you all take.

533
00:54:11.159 --> 00:54:13.744
<v Kristen Dennis>So you could do a longer process or you can do a shorter process.

534
00:54:14.371 --> 00:54:19.766
<v Kristen Dennis>The reason that we're having this conversation right now, as you all already know, obviously a very unique situation.

535
00:54:24.760 --> 00:54:24.760
<v Kristen Dennis>Thank you.

536
00:54:24.760 --> 00:54:32.250
<v Kristen Dennis>Councilmember Herbold, the ordinance passed earlier this year authorized the issuance of bonds sufficient to yield $365 million to renovate and modernize the Moda Center.

537
00:54:32.300 --> 00:54:39.539
<v Kristen Dennis>The requirements to unlock that state funding are— there's quite a few, but I will just highlight the 3 salient ones.

538
00:54:39.539 --> 00:54:40.880
<v Kristen Dennis>The first, establish a joint authority.

539
00:54:42.139 --> 00:54:45.550
<v Kristen Dennis>Second, local funding commitment.

540
00:54:46.219 --> 00:54:49.849
<v Kristen Dennis>My understanding at this point is that this is approximately $120 million.

541
00:54:50.434 --> 00:54:50.594
<v Kristen Dennis>Thank you.

542
00:54:50.641 --> 00:54:59.382
<v Kristen Dennis>Though, Councilor Morillo, to your earlier points, I don't have any details around exactly what that would be funding yet, but I wanna just highlight that.

543
00:55:00.007 --> 00:55:03.568
<v Kristen Dennis>And then the third piece is a 20-year lease agreement.

544
00:55:03.777 --> 00:55:12.949
<v Kristen Dennis>And as a lot of you know, but I wanna make sure the public knows, the reason for that is because the backing for this debt is from income from the Moda Center itself.

545
00:55:13.414 --> 00:55:15.965
<v Kristen Dennis>And so you need to have the guarantee of that income.

546
00:55:16.061 --> 00:55:18.519
<v Kristen Dennis>In order to be able to back those bonds.

547
00:55:18.568 --> 00:55:22.085
<v Kristen Dennis>And so there's going to be some bond counsel interest in how that lease agreement is set up as well.

548
00:55:26.210 --> 00:55:41.429
<v Kristen Dennis>So in any— as we look at how to make investments in the auditorium, or sorry, in the arena, the city is ultimately responsible for answering the question of what improvement, what those improvements are and how they get funded.

549
00:55:44.090 --> 00:55:44.335
<v Kristen Dennis>Um, the—.

550
00:55:44.335 --> 00:55:46.588
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm sorry, I lost where I'm at.

551
00:55:50.291 --> 00:55:59.168
<v Kristen Dennis>All right, uh, so I want to differentiate here between outcomes and, um, uh, outcomes and tools.

552
00:55:59.697 --> 00:56:04.061
<v Kristen Dennis>Here you have the different, uh, places where the council is being asked to take action.

553
00:56:04.175 --> 00:56:07.943
<v Kristen Dennis>We have the investment decision that is related to the $120 million dollars.

554
00:56:08.072 --> 00:56:15.878
<v Kristen Dennis>You also can do this on a different timeline that is likely going to be a larger amount, but that's a different timeline.

555
00:56:16.547 --> 00:56:19.387
<v Kristen Dennis>Obviously a lease agreement and then other council actions.

556
00:56:23.050 --> 00:56:29.306
<v Kristen Dennis>Now, why I want to differentiate, like, why it's important for us to talk about outcomes and having direction driven by outcomes and what the tools are.

557
00:56:29.355 --> 00:56:32.394
<v Kristen Dennis>We've talked a lot about tools, and those are some of the terms that you see in lease agreements.

558
00:56:33.612 --> 00:56:38.307
<v Kristen Dennis>But to determine whether or not those work for Portland, that gets due to what Portlanders deserve.

559
00:56:38.740 --> 00:56:41.257
<v Kristen Dennis>We need to understand what your priorities are.

560
00:56:42.025 --> 00:56:58.114
<v Kristen Dennis>Some of those have already been highlighted now, but why it's important to get the full picture of that is because, like for instance, if if if the priorities were only updating the pipes, creating updating the bathrooms, creating more access, and then minimizing city contract.

561
00:56:58.179 --> 00:57:06.657
<v Kristen Dennis>Contributions, the deal on the table from the state is very compelling right now because there is a large amount of money that would not otherwise be available to you all.

562
00:57:07.266 --> 00:57:14.507
<v Kristen Dennis>That said, you all need to balance whether or not that is worth the tightened timeline that you are all working through.

563
00:57:14.748 --> 00:57:27.286
<v Kristen Dennis>And so there's going to be a lot of trade-offs in figuring out if we can put enough tools into the investment decisions, into the lease agreements, and then obviously council has other council options that I want to make sure that we can kind of talk about broader as well.

564
00:57:28.351 --> 00:57:33.862
<v Kristen Dennis>Certainly the focus is going to be on the arena, and that is the focus in order to unlock those state dollars.

565
00:57:34.300 --> 00:57:37.976
<v Kristen Dennis>But there are other discussions and other powers that the council has that are broader as well.

566
00:57:40.230 --> 00:57:48.800
<v Kristen Dennis>So for the discussion today, and I'm happy to answer a lot of questions, I know that there are a lot, I would like you all to think about the council values and objectives.

567
00:57:48.994 --> 00:57:55.985
<v Kristen Dennis>What does success What do your constituents expect from this arena?

568
00:57:56.032 --> 00:57:57.559
<v Kristen Dennis>So what are we looking for?

569
00:57:57.623 --> 00:58:04.784
<v Kristen Dennis>So when staff brings stuff to you, brings some of this detailed information to you, what is the information they should bring to you?

570
00:58:04.864 --> 00:58:13.947
<v Kristen Dennis>There are going to be things that— tools that staff could bring to you based on some of your values that are frankly antithetical to what some of your other values are.

571
00:58:14.365 --> 00:58:14.929
<v Kristen Dennis>For instance, Councilor Smith.

572
00:58:14.994 --> 00:58:15.106
<v Kristen Dennis>Yes.

573
00:58:15.521 --> 00:58:24.240
<v Kristen Dennis>If the value is just generating as much revenue for the city as possible, we could have an 800% tax on concessions.

574
00:58:24.514 --> 00:58:37.246
<v Kristen Dennis>Now, that is antithetical to, I think, some of the values that I've certainly heard from the city council in terms of making the arena accessible and a place that people can go and bring their families.

575
00:58:37.583 --> 00:58:39.559
<v Kristen Dennis>And so there's a balancing that has to happen there.

576
00:58:40.844 --> 00:58:44.527
<v Kristen Dennis>So that is kind of the important discussion for you all to have with each other.

577
00:58:47.059 --> 00:58:50.601
<v Kristen Dennis>And this allows us to actually bring in craft because we're on a very tight timeline for this.

578
00:58:51.280 --> 00:58:57.472
<v Kristen Dennis>Again, it's up to council to decide whether or not you want to move forward with this timeline or not.

579
00:58:59.777 --> 00:59:04.101
<v Kristen Dennis>My goal is to, in good faith, try to get as far on this timeline as possible.

580
00:59:05.300 --> 00:59:13.371
<v Kristen Dennis>Ultimately, council Council will decide if what we're able to bring matches what you're looking for and if we're able to get you some of the more detailed information that you have been asking for as well.

581
00:59:14.969 --> 00:59:22.472
<v Kristen Dennis>So the outcome topics that I put together for you all to discuss, I've heard some of them already, are listed here.

582
00:59:22.552 --> 00:59:27.405
<v Kristen Dennis>I won't read them all, but this reflects some of what I've heard from you, some of the public statements that you've had.

583
00:59:29.871 --> 00:59:34.016
<v Kristen Dennis>The important here is this is both for providing staff direction.

584
00:59:34.210 --> 00:59:44.775
<v Kristen Dennis>So as staff figures out how do we respond to what we're hearing from council, also how are we communicating this with folks at large?

585
00:59:45.449 --> 00:59:57.331
<v Kristen Dennis>So if there are particular terms in a lease agreement, we've heard a lot, been talking about some very interesting lease agreement terms that could be put forward, or what are the things we might buy with some of these investments?

586
00:59:57.460 --> 01:00:06.199
<v Kristen Dennis>You know, being able to figure out whether or not those actually reflect the values that we have.

587
01:00:07.193 --> 01:00:17.393
<v Kristen Dennis>So with that, I will— oh, one other thing I wanted to add to this is another thing that I've heard, obviously, are lessons learned from other cities as well that you would want to make sure are reflected in what we bring back to you.

588
01:00:18.436 --> 01:00:21.947
<v Kristen Dennis>So with that, I'll turn it back over to Council President Dunphy.

589
01:00:22.027 --> 01:00:22.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Kristen.

590
01:00:22.829 --> 01:00:23.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Excellent.

591
01:00:23.215 --> 01:00:23.358
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

592
01:00:23.440 --> 01:00:25.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, so we've got some framing, colleagues, some opportunities.

593
01:00:25.398 --> 01:00:27.697
<v Jamie Dunphy>We also have some staff in the room if there are questions.

594
01:00:28.516 --> 01:00:32.677
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as has been noted, we have more questions than answers at this time.

595
01:00:32.853 --> 01:00:36.387
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this is about an opportunity to help us frame those questions and get them back.

596
01:00:36.869 --> 01:00:41.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am also paying very close attention to the questions that are being asked and making sure that we get those answers back.

597
01:00:41.706 --> 01:00:44.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm going to start by heading to jumping into the queue.

598
01:00:45.063 --> 01:00:45.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

599
01:00:46.911 --> 01:00:48.436
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

600
01:00:48.693 --> 01:00:50.155
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for the framing, Kristen.

601
01:00:51.905 --> 01:00:57.429
<v Mitch Green>I want to start by— I want to start by saying here's what I want to see in a deal.

602
01:00:57.865 --> 01:01:01.865
<v Mitch Green>I think part of this, the expectation of the work session is like, where are councilors at?

603
01:01:02.461 --> 01:01:10.768
<v Mitch Green>So I can start by saying like I have some minimum expectations that I want to see in a term sheet, and if I don't see those in the term sheet, then it's like, what are we doing?

604
01:01:12.557 --> 01:01:13.567
<v Mitch Green>I'll just list them in order.

605
01:01:14.168 --> 01:01:15.813
<v Mitch Green>Private capital contributions to the project.

606
01:01:15.878 --> 01:01:16.007
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

607
01:01:16.903 --> 01:01:22.755
<v Mitch Green>Peer cities have private capital contributions that range between 20% and 60%.

608
01:01:24.543 --> 01:01:27.465
<v Mitch Green>I want to see the team pay rent to the City of Portland.

609
01:01:27.690 --> 01:01:28.806
<v Mitch Green>And I think there's a caveat on this.

610
01:01:28.903 --> 01:01:30.422
<v Mitch Green>I want that rent to flow to the general fund.

611
01:01:31.264 --> 01:01:43.938
<v Mitch Green>I want some of these revenue streams to flow to the general fund because I am worried that we are going to encumber all of any incremental revenue from this deal into a fund that is only servicing the debt on this fund.

612
01:01:43.985 --> 01:01:46.717
<v Mitch Green>And so we don't really capture any of that to to support our city.

613
01:01:47.217 --> 01:01:49.538
<v Mitch Green>So flexible rent that we receive.

614
01:01:50.858 --> 01:01:54.128
<v Mitch Green>Property taxes or equivalents, so payments in lieu of taxes.

615
01:01:54.630 --> 01:01:56.172
<v Mitch Green>We heard this from the county's work session.

616
01:01:56.690 --> 01:02:07.885
<v Mitch Green>You know, if the county's gonna be expected to put up some money that's gonna come at the expense of their services, they wanna see sort of a bill back in some sense of payments in lieu of taxes.

617
01:02:11.472 --> 01:02:14.614
<v Mitch Green>Try to get a city share of any incremental premium revenue.

618
01:02:14.679 --> 01:02:19.632
<v Mitch Green>So if there's— if these dollars are going towards premium things, we should also get some of that.

619
01:02:19.711 --> 01:02:32.280
<v Mitch Green>Because I think what you do is when you look at the actual scholarly literature, colleagues, on this stuff, what we find is it's actually quite common for municipalities to fund stadiums.

620
01:02:32.472 --> 01:02:52.349
<v Mitch Green>But oftentimes when the public shows up with that funding, you find that the cost of the project gets and so when people say, well, we don't want to give handouts to a billionaire, we're talking about creating an incremental value with public dollars for upside private value that would not otherwise exist.

621
01:02:52.755 --> 01:02:54.186
<v Mitch Green>And so being able to capture that back.

622
01:02:54.235 --> 01:02:55.063
<v Mitch Green>So that's where that comes from.

623
01:02:55.112 --> 01:02:56.184
<v Mitch Green>And I've got the citations here.

624
01:02:58.969 --> 01:03:02.166
<v Mitch Green>Event parking revenue, I think that we should not just give that away.

625
01:03:02.344 --> 01:03:03.108
<v Mitch Green>I think that we should.

626
01:03:04.286 --> 01:03:05.411
<v Mitch Green>And those are just a short list.

627
01:03:08.998 --> 01:03:10.190
<v Mitch Green>So that's my position.

628
01:03:11.030 --> 01:03:11.351
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

629
01:03:11.755 --> 01:03:15.028
<v Mitch Green>I also would like to see— I kind of want to talk about this timeline.

630
01:03:16.554 --> 01:03:23.623
<v Mitch Green>I don't see anywhere in the state Senate bills, the 2 bills that create this package, that says this must be done by December.

631
01:03:23.686 --> 01:03:27.617
<v Mitch Green>And so if there's anyone who has an answer to why this has to happen by December, I would love an answer to that.

632
01:03:27.666 --> 01:03:28.637
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think it's because the governor has said it has to be done by December.

633
01:03:30.208 --> 01:03:33.945
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm happy to answer it, and then— but I'll let actual city staff answer.

634
01:03:34.800 --> 01:03:35.106
<v Kristen Dennis>Sorry.

635
01:03:38.601 --> 01:03:39.251
<v Mitch Green>Anyone?

636
01:03:39.657 --> 01:03:39.949
<v Mitch Green>Oh, Donnie.

637
01:03:40.128 --> 01:03:42.791
<v Kristen Dennis>Oh, Donnie.

638
01:03:44.853 --> 01:03:45.503
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Okay.

639
01:03:46.007 --> 01:03:46.931
<v Donnie Oliveira>All right, thank you, councilors.

640
01:03:47.351 --> 01:03:49.628
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, good afternoon, Council President.

641
01:03:49.710 --> 01:03:50.760
<v Donnie Oliveira>Donnie Oliveira, for the record.

642
01:03:51.550 --> 01:03:52.568
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, there's a lot of questions asked.

643
01:03:52.617 --> 01:03:57.989
<v Donnie Oliveira>I've been taking notes, and I'm, I'm happy to go back and answer your Questions, Councilor Avalos and Councilor Murillo.

644
01:03:58.262 --> 01:04:11.927
<v Donnie Oliveira>Starting with your question, Councilor Green, the timeline right now is based on a couple of premises that started way back even before there was a sale, which is that we had renovations that we'd like to get done by the spring of 2030.

645
01:04:12.007 --> 01:04:16.182
<v Donnie Oliveira>For this is when we're gonna be hosting the Final Four Championship at the Moda Center.

646
01:04:16.423 --> 01:04:20.148
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that was the, like, that's like the North Star for renovations.

647
01:04:20.646 --> 01:04:27.286
<v Donnie Oliveira>So working backwards from that, the next, Major milestone is unlocking those state dollars, those bonding dollars.

648
01:04:27.784 --> 01:04:47.322
<v Donnie Oliveira>Since that's the most substantial tranche of resources that are going into the renovation, the state needs us to have definitive confirmation about our contribution, one of those requirements that Kristen had mentioned, so that they can start the underwriting of the bond so that they can issue the bond in the spring of '27 so we can start renovations essentially in the summer of '27.

649
01:04:47.532 --> 01:04:48.958
<v Mitch Green>But that's not in the statute.

650
01:04:49.021 --> 01:04:49.664
<v Mitch Green>That's not in the law.

651
01:04:49.856 --> 01:04:50.657
<v Mitch Green>It's just a practice.

652
01:04:50.961 --> 01:04:51.858
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's the administrative.

653
01:04:51.938 --> 01:04:59.070
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that's like the— that's the state's Department of Administrative Services and Department of Justice administering that bond.

654
01:04:59.199 --> 01:05:01.505
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's the requirement for them to do that on that timeline.

655
01:05:02.018 --> 01:05:04.327
<v Mitch Green>I'd like to see a citation to that at some point.

656
01:05:04.407 --> 01:05:04.471
<v Mitch Green>Sure.

657
01:05:04.663 --> 01:05:15.784
<v Kristen Dennis>And if I can jump in there as well, part of that is it needs to go through the process, obviously, with the lease is gonna need to be looked at by bond counsel to see if it's appropriately backed up.

658
01:05:16.827 --> 01:05:22.376
<v Kristen Dennis>And then we open up the bond sales generally in the spring as well.

659
01:05:22.601 --> 01:05:23.556
<v Kristen Dennis>So that would be the timeline.

660
01:05:23.621 --> 01:05:24.867
<v Kristen Dennis>And so then working backwards.

661
01:05:24.914 --> 01:05:35.164
<v Kristen Dennis>Now that could be technically, and I've had some conversations with the state, some of it can be compressed, but we have to be really careful because your risk increases the longer we wait.

662
01:05:35.889 --> 01:05:42.244
<v Kristen Dennis>And then after we miss that window, and I don't know, I don't think there is like a day where, you know, on Tuesday it's okay, on Wednesday it's not.

663
01:05:42.356 --> 01:05:42.536
<v Kristen Dennis>Okay.

664
01:05:42.603 --> 01:05:43.902
<v Kristen Dennis>And then the next day it's not.

665
01:05:43.952 --> 01:05:45.514
<v Kristen Dennis>So it's just going to get riskier and riskier.

666
01:05:47.596 --> 01:05:56.625
<v Kristen Dennis>At some point, though, the state will not have authorization under the bill to actually issue that debt anymore.

667
01:05:56.704 --> 01:06:07.715
<v Kristen Dennis>So it has to happen within that window, and the state would have to issue— or the legislature would have to pass another bill authorizing if we don't get the authorization.

668
01:06:08.170 --> 01:06:09.371
<v Mitch Green>That's helpful.

669
01:06:09.563 --> 01:06:16.340
<v Mitch Green>So just to recap, the prime mover here is to get these investments done in time for the NCAA tournament.

670
01:06:16.998 --> 01:06:18.119
<v Donnie Oliveira>The renovations.

671
01:06:18.199 --> 01:06:18.905
<v Mitch Green>The renovations.

672
01:06:19.577 --> 01:06:27.476
<v Mitch Green>My understanding also is we're going to have that tournament no matter if we do those renovations or not because we're contractually entitled to that.

673
01:06:28.070 --> 01:06:30.713
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yes, we— yes, just answered correctly.

674
01:06:30.873 --> 01:06:41.780
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so for folks following along, I did have the council clerk attached to the work session a scholarly paper by an associate editor of the Journal of Sports Economics.

675
01:06:42.262 --> 01:06:47.465
<v Mitch Green>And the paper's called The Economics of Stadium Subsidies, and it's a policy retrospective.

676
01:06:47.963 --> 01:06:51.382
<v Mitch Green>And this is really important because we're gonna make a really big decision here.

677
01:06:52.282 --> 01:06:58.561
<v Mitch Green>And there's a whole section in this paper that describes the empirical economic impacts of special one-off events.

678
01:06:59.123 --> 01:07:01.016
<v Mitch Green>And they don't really bring in that much.

679
01:07:02.077 --> 01:07:04.409
<v Mitch Green>Relative to what they would've otherwise brought in.

680
01:07:04.456 --> 01:07:08.599
<v Mitch Green>So we need to be reading that kind of stuff so we can evaluate this stuff with critical eye.

681
01:07:10.039 --> 01:07:20.737
<v Mitch Green>I wanna also note that in my reading of SB 1501, in part of the kind of negotiations to get to final passage, there was a -11 amendment.

682
01:07:21.320 --> 01:07:26.617
<v Mitch Green>And that -11 amendment created a clause called Section 62A, I think 2A2 maybe.

683
01:07:26.715 --> 01:07:26.927
<v Mitch Green>62A2.

684
01:07:27.382 --> 01:07:37.293
<v Mitch Green>But basically, it created funding and a requirement for the State of Oregon to pay for and supply an independent analyst to evaluate the terms of this deal.

685
01:07:37.420 --> 01:07:40.119
<v Mitch Green>And so have we gotten that work done?

686
01:07:40.199 --> 01:07:41.934
<v Mitch Green>Have they hired anyone yet?

687
01:07:42.159 --> 01:07:43.701
<v Donnie Oliveira>They're closing in on that hire.

688
01:07:44.023 --> 01:07:47.106
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so they're closing on the hire, but they won't have the results of the study?

689
01:07:47.860 --> 01:07:50.077
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, we can follow up with the state on the timeline for that.

690
01:07:50.126 --> 01:07:51.202
<v Kristen Dennis>I believe it's coming pretty quickly.

691
01:07:51.556 --> 01:07:57.166
<v Mitch Green>Okay, but the thing is, is like we In 3 weeks, we're to start having a council deliberation.

692
01:07:57.311 --> 01:07:57.603
<v Mitch Green>Mm-hmm.

693
01:07:57.943 --> 01:08:14.298
<v Mitch Green>There's no way we can evaluate the economics of this deal pursuant to even the state's own suggestion that we should do that in that timeline, colleagues.

694
01:08:15.135 --> 01:08:24.458
<v Mitch Green>And so I think that if it's— if you're able to get the state legislature in the short session to ram together a $365 million bonding package.

695
01:08:24.458 --> 01:08:26.828
<v Mitch Green>I think the total lobbying spend is about $130,000.

696
01:08:27.298 --> 01:08:28.658
<v Mitch Green>So that's a pretty good return on investment.

697
01:08:29.548 --> 01:08:32.738
<v Mitch Green>I think you can do it again in the long session, frankly.

698
01:08:32.738 --> 01:08:36.729
<v Mitch Green>And I think that we owe it to Portlanders to at least get the data back.

699
01:08:37.139 --> 01:08:40.219
<v Mitch Green>We're also going to be doing a refreshed analysis on the economic impact.

700
01:08:40.219 --> 01:08:40.819
<v Mitch Green>Is that correct?

701
01:08:40.819 --> 01:08:41.259
<v Mitch Green>That's correct.

702
01:08:41.259 --> 01:08:42.259
<v Mitch Green>Do you know when that's going to happen?

703
01:08:42.958 --> 01:08:49.439
<v Donnie Oliveira>We're aiming for the— to bring that data back to you all no later than the next work session on July 22nd.

704
01:08:49.984 --> 01:08:53.688
<v Donnie Oliveira>But ideally, the executive session that happens the week before is our target.

705
01:08:54.204 --> 01:08:54.511
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

706
01:08:56.032 --> 01:09:15.070
<v Mitch Green>I know that I'm probably burning a lot of time here, but I just, I want to say that the paper I cited, which had a bunch of citations, basically the entire literature in the last 30 years, does have a section that talks about the validity and the shortcomings of economic impact analyses that were commissioned.

707
01:09:15.720 --> 01:09:25.408
<v Mitch Green>And so I think I heard Julia Brim Edwards, Commissioner Julia Brim Edwards, say yesterday that the CrossPoints Consulting report, not very compelling and was pretty thin on details.

708
01:09:25.456 --> 01:09:27.880
<v Mitch Green>And so we're using them again, is my understanding.

709
01:09:28.554 --> 01:09:32.920
<v Mitch Green>And I would hope that they would have a published list of assumptions.

710
01:09:32.967 --> 01:09:34.074
<v Mitch Green>What are their multipliers?

711
01:09:34.573 --> 01:09:36.001
<v Mitch Green>How do they get to those multipliers?

712
01:09:36.418 --> 01:09:39.146
<v Mitch Green>What proportion of income stays in the region versus goes out?

713
01:09:40.430 --> 01:09:50.338
<v Mitch Green>How much of this player salary is a result of the net new like how much of that flows back into the Oregon Arena Fund and all that?

714
01:09:50.420 --> 01:09:51.631
<v Mitch Green>Because that's all really important.

715
01:09:51.729 --> 01:09:53.636
<v Mitch Green>And if we don't have that, we're basically running on vibes.

716
01:09:55.005 --> 01:09:59.729
<v Mitch Green>And there's a lot of opportunity from this investment.

717
01:10:00.789 --> 01:10:10.243
<v Mitch Green>And I think the response we've seen from the public is a recognition that we don't really know at all whether this pencils out, except for like the common—.

718
01:10:10.356 --> 01:10:10.405
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

719
01:10:11.048 --> 01:10:18.632
<v Mitch Green>Assertions of boosters of these deals that goes back decades that sports economists have written about and said, be on the lookout, municipalities.

720
01:10:18.680 --> 01:10:20.304
<v Mitch Green>So that's it for now.

721
01:10:20.753 --> 01:10:23.645
<v Mitch Green>I don't know if we'll have more time, but I can get back into it to engage in the dialogue.

722
01:10:23.726 --> 01:10:27.614
<v Mitch Green>But thanks for your answers and thanks for taking notes.

723
01:10:27.984 --> 01:10:28.466
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

724
01:10:28.627 --> 01:10:29.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, please go ahead.

725
01:10:29.430 --> 01:10:32.097
<v Kristen Dennis>Sorry, Councilor Green, if I may.

726
01:10:32.306 --> 01:10:36.306
<v Kristen Dennis>First, I want to say that the timeline consideration is not lost on me, as you know.

727
01:10:36.789 --> 01:10:38.744
<v Kristen Dennis>I think I've been working on this for now a full 2 weeks.

728
01:10:39.128 --> 01:10:44.673
<v Kristen Dennis>And so, you know, getting up to speed and getting all that information, this is not the ideal process, just period.

729
01:10:45.859 --> 01:10:52.204
<v Kristen Dennis>What we're going to do is try in good faith to get you the information that you need in order to be able to take a vote.

730
01:10:52.286 --> 01:10:53.680
<v Kristen Dennis>And that might be a yes or a no vote.

731
01:10:53.728 --> 01:11:01.756
<v Kristen Dennis>We might not be able to get you what you need in time, but we're gonna do our best to actually be able to respond to the offer on the table from the state.

732
01:11:02.012 --> 01:11:02.877
<v Kristen Dennis>Councilor Smith.

733
01:11:03.184 --> 01:11:09.204
<v Kristen Dennis>I also just want to note that you talked about the one-off events and the economic impacts of the one-off events.

734
01:11:09.670 --> 01:11:15.868
<v Kristen Dennis>I think it's also going to be important as we look at what tools we have available to look at how do you activate that as much as possible.

735
01:11:16.012 --> 01:11:20.220
<v Kristen Dennis>So if we're only looking at the one-off events, I think you're completely correct.

736
01:11:20.283 --> 01:11:22.097
<v Kristen Dennis>We have that same issue at Expo Center.

737
01:11:23.014 --> 01:11:33.864
<v Kristen Dennis>But being able to activate the site more, and so I have heard from you and others around interest in activating the site and making sure that that is a requirement as well in order to gain some of the economic impacts.

738
01:11:33.961 --> 01:11:34.395
<v Kristen Dennis>So thank you.

739
01:11:34.971 --> 01:11:41.006
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that, and I did neglect to say street-level pricing is something I very much see as needing to be in this deal.

740
01:11:41.070 --> 01:11:46.221
<v Mitch Green>And I recognize it may be difficult to do both street-level pricing and also food and beverage revenue share.

741
01:11:46.671 --> 01:11:49.256
<v Mitch Green>So if we have to give on that, it's street-level pricing for me.

742
01:11:49.479 --> 01:11:49.720
<v Kristen Dennis>Thanks.

743
01:11:49.978 --> 01:11:50.234
<v Kristen Dennis>Thank you.

744
01:11:51.261 --> 01:11:52.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

745
01:11:53.011 --> 01:11:54.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, I put myself in the thank you.

746
01:11:55.259 --> 01:11:57.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have a couple of things I want to say.

747
01:11:57.942 --> 01:11:59.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, I really appreciate the comments from my colleagues so far.

748
01:12:00.239 --> 01:12:01.541
<v Jamie Dunphy>I haven't heard anything that I disagree with.

749
01:12:01.621 --> 01:12:28.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to just note that my values include that this is going to be a, you know, as Councilor Green was saying, as Dr. Green was saying, a fiscally responsible deal for the city, that we are seeing a real return in, and that there are measurable family wage employment benefits to workers that we engage in fair pricing where families from my district can afford to see events in a city-owned facility without feeling fleeced or excluded.

750
01:12:29.083 --> 01:12:41.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I also just want to mention that I want to see meaningful progress on the reunification of Albina and the correction to the crimes committed against Black Portlanders via urban renewal in the '50s and '60s.

751
01:12:44.608 --> 01:12:50.984
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also, as I've heard the mayor say, a relatively gross term, but I do also want to see this asset sweat.

752
01:12:52.171 --> 01:13:03.403
<v Jamie Dunphy>This building should be active more than it's not, and I look forward to some of the renovations that are completely independent of the Blazers because, as everyone knows, I'm the music guy on council.

753
01:13:03.466 --> 01:13:07.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to see bigger and badder concerts coming to Portland that simply cannot come here.

754
01:13:07.493 --> 01:13:13.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also want to see things like rodeos and circuses, even if they are slightly lower return on investment.

755
01:13:13.912 --> 01:13:17.136
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need more opportunities for families and for fun things to define our city.

756
01:13:17.185 --> 01:13:17.345
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

757
01:13:17.832 --> 01:13:18.792
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we have the building.

758
01:13:18.905 --> 01:13:19.833
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's sitting right there.

759
01:13:19.963 --> 01:13:21.997
<v Jamie Dunphy>If it's empty, it's doing none of us any good.

760
01:13:22.795 --> 01:13:23.917
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have a couple of quick questions.

761
01:13:24.710 --> 01:13:26.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think they might partially be for Carl.

762
01:13:26.751 --> 01:13:27.587
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm not totally sure.

763
01:13:27.698 --> 01:13:38.863
<v Jamie Dunphy>But first, I just wanted to ask, you know, when the city purchased the Moda for a dollar back in 2024, we signed a bridge lease through 2030.

764
01:13:39.282 --> 01:13:43.113
<v Jamie Dunphy>When the building became public property, it also became exempt from property taxes.

765
01:13:43.185 --> 01:13:43.436
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's correct.

766
01:13:45.033 --> 01:13:55.682
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we know how much annual revenue was lost in that deal and how much the operator is now saving from not having to pay taxes?

767
01:13:56.578 --> 01:13:58.710
<v Carl Lyle>We believe it's about $1 million a year.

768
01:13:59.596 --> 01:14:02.206
<v Carl Lyle>And with the investments, that would then go up, right?

769
01:14:02.432 --> 01:14:03.940
<v Carl Lyle>Because you'd have a more valuable asset.

770
01:14:04.216 --> 01:14:04.296
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

771
01:14:04.377 --> 01:14:05.108
<v Jamie Dunphy>Of course.

772
01:14:07.296 --> 01:14:19.787
<v Jamie Dunphy>And from the— as Councilor Avalos was saying earlier, we currently have a 50/50 split on maintenance going forward, and that is a question for the future.

773
01:14:20.463 --> 01:14:24.453
<v Jamie Dunphy>Prior to us taking ownership, did we have a maintenance obligation with there?

774
01:14:24.519 --> 01:14:25.103
<v Dan Ryan>Did we use—.

775
01:14:25.896 --> 01:14:26.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

776
01:14:26.805 --> 01:14:29.268
<v Carl Lyle>So yeah, let me talk about that a little bit.

777
01:14:29.872 --> 01:14:32.701
<v Carl Lyle>And I'm Carl Lyle, Spectator Venues Program Manager.

778
01:14:34.680 --> 01:14:39.337
<v Carl Lyle>So yeah, so prior to the current agreements that went into effect in 2024, the building was still private.

779
01:14:39.605 --> 01:14:44.368
<v Carl Lyle>Owned on city-owned land subject to the terms of the 30-year-old land lease, right?

780
01:14:44.417 --> 01:14:49.997
<v Carl Lyle>So no, the city was not obligated to spend anything on ongoing upkeep at Moda Center.

781
01:14:51.393 --> 01:14:54.855
<v Carl Lyle>We were spending on the Coliseum and, you know, other city-owned venues, but not Moda Center.

782
01:14:55.402 --> 01:14:55.658
<v Jamie Dunphy>Gotcha.

783
01:14:56.765 --> 01:15:10.139
<v Carl Lyle>What changed— one of the things that changed with the 5-year bridge agreements was that we agreed to— the city agreed to reinvest Blazers-derived revenue that the city was collecting from Blazers games only.

784
01:15:10.252 --> 01:15:18.413
<v Carl Lyle>So not the concert revenue, not, not things at the Coliseum, not other Rose Quarter revenues, but parking and ticket user fees on Blazer events.

785
01:15:18.511 --> 01:15:27.923
<v Carl Lyle>We agreed to reinvest those dollars back into identified capital projects at Moda if matched by Rip City Management.

786
01:15:28.372 --> 01:15:35.465
<v Carl Lyle>So it's a 50/50 match up to the total amount of funds Received by the city from Blazers events in a year.

787
01:15:35.609 --> 01:15:44.725
<v Carl Lyle>So in the year we're just finishing, we spent $4.5 million approximately, which was matched and then some by the team.

788
01:15:45.207 --> 01:15:52.171
<v Carl Lyle>And the primary project that was accomplished during the last fiscal year is— was the new scoreboard and video board project.

789
01:15:52.220 --> 01:15:56.506
<v Carl Lyle>So the city did pay for a portion of that under the terms of the 2024 lease.

790
01:15:56.761 --> 01:15:57.661
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great, thank you.

791
01:15:59.068 --> 01:16:11.103
<v Jamie Dunphy>And just briefly, when we— it appears from the facility condition assessment that the prior owners of the Moda allowed a backlog of maintenance to amass, and we were aware of that when we took over ownership.

792
01:16:11.167 --> 01:16:11.818
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that correct?

793
01:16:12.288 --> 01:16:12.532
<v Carl Lyle>Yes.

794
01:16:12.711 --> 01:16:13.426
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

795
01:16:16.050 --> 01:16:19.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Carl, a question about the spectator venue and visitor activities fund.

796
01:16:20.106 --> 01:16:22.216
<v Jamie Dunphy>How much does that fund take in every year?

797
01:16:24.814 --> 01:16:30.195
<v Carl Lyle>So yeah, I can pull up real numbers if we want to get into those weeds right now.

798
01:16:30.404 --> 01:16:31.319
<v Carl Lyle>We can get them to you.

799
01:16:31.625 --> 01:16:41.890
<v Carl Lyle>But I mean, the primary sources of revenues are the ticket user fees from events at the Rose Quarter and a portion of the ticket user fees from events at Providence Park.

800
01:16:42.613 --> 01:16:43.770
<v Carl Lyle>That's a little bit more complicated.

801
01:16:43.835 --> 01:16:56.619
<v Carl Lyle>We can talk about that more, but it doesn't seem like— and then also parking revenues from parking at the Rose Quarter in 2 of the 4 garages, which were, you know, they're sort of called the city garages, the east and west garages.

802
01:16:56.667 --> 01:16:58.417
<v Carl Lyle>The city collects the revenue from those garages.

803
01:16:59.237 --> 01:17:03.395
<v Carl Lyle>Revenue if you park in the garden garage or the annex garage goes to Rip City Management.

804
01:17:03.444 --> 01:17:05.338
<v Carl Lyle>So be careful where you park at the Rose Quarter, right?

805
01:17:05.418 --> 01:17:07.667
<v Carl Lyle>You want to go into the east and west garages if possible.

806
01:17:08.390 --> 01:17:21.048
<v Carl Lyle>And then we also receive, you know, some interest on fund balance, right, investments, which actually has been significant recently because we've been spending down the bond proceeds on the Coliseum renovation project, which is almost done.

807
01:17:21.096 --> 01:17:24.335
<v Carl Lyle>So there's actually quite a bit of that in the last couple years.

808
01:17:24.511 --> 01:17:31.212
<v Carl Lyle>That's all required because of the bonding requirements to go into the Coliseum project, so it doesn't really help the other projects, although it's good for that, for that one.

809
01:17:31.820 --> 01:17:42.529
<v Carl Lyle>And then we get a small allocation from the Visitor Facility Intergovernmental Agreement, which comes from the Visitor Facility Trust account, which is funded by a portion of the transient lodging taxes and vehicle rental car fees.

810
01:17:42.672 --> 01:17:42.784
<v Kristen Dennis>Thank you.

811
01:17:43.908 --> 01:17:45.192
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, that's great.

812
01:17:45.432 --> 01:17:47.662
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's really helpful just to give us sort of a rough estimate.

813
01:17:47.711 --> 01:17:52.796
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I, I, I have a, a lingering concern about the, the specific funding thing.

814
01:17:52.845 --> 01:17:54.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry, point of order.

815
01:17:54.753 --> 01:17:55.845
<v Sameer Kanal>Was there a number in any of that?

816
01:17:57.000 --> 01:17:57.159
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

817
01:17:58.027 --> 01:17:59.791
<v Sameer Kanal>Was there a single number in that answer?

818
01:18:01.234 --> 01:18:02.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, the visitors—.

819
01:18:02.278 --> 01:18:03.368
<v Carl Lyle>Here, let's, let's, let's do it.

820
01:18:03.578 --> 01:18:03.979
<v Carl Lyle>Let's do it.

821
01:18:04.059 --> 01:18:04.539
<v Carl Lyle>Let's do it right now.

822
01:18:04.621 --> 01:18:08.086
<v Carl Lyle>So in fiscal year '24-'25, uh, I'll go down my list.

823
01:18:08.293 --> 01:18:25.719
<v Carl Lyle>Um, we received, uh, $2.9 million in Blazers user fees, and we received $4.3 million in, uh, user fees for non-Blazers events at Moda Center.

824
01:18:26.524 --> 01:18:32.250
<v Carl Lyle>And this is an interesting trend because this is something that's changed since, since COVID just to go down a rabbit hole for a second.

825
01:18:33.137 --> 01:18:48.391
<v Carl Lyle>Up until 2019 or so, the Blazers user fees were a larger portion than the non-Blazers events, but in the last 5 to 6 years, we've seen so much growth in the concert business and other events that we now see considerably more coming in from non-Blazers user fees.

826
01:18:48.457 --> 01:18:49.318
<v Carl Lyle>So that's kind of interesting.

827
01:18:50.500 --> 01:18:59.876
<v Carl Lyle>Coliseum user fees were only $650,000 for, let's see, a total amount of user fees at the Rose Quarter of $7.9 million.

828
01:18:59.945 --> 01:19:00.140
<v Carl Lyle>Thank you.

829
01:19:01.310 --> 01:19:14.454
<v Carl Lyle>Blazers-related parking revenue was $1.4 million, and non-Blazers-related parking revenue— and this is combined, this isn't Moda only, but all the other things at Rose Quarter— were $2.5, almost $2.6 million.

830
01:19:16.274 --> 01:19:16.677
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

831
01:19:17.064 --> 01:19:17.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's great.

832
01:19:18.014 --> 01:19:18.932
<v Jamie Dunphy>I really appreciate the—.

833
01:19:19.060 --> 01:19:21.625
<v Carl Lyle>We also got $1.2 million in rents and reimbursements.

834
01:19:21.689 --> 01:19:24.966
<v Carl Lyle>So there's a profit-sharing deal and some rent on the office building.

835
01:19:25.484 --> 01:19:29.488
<v Carl Lyle>The profit-sharing applies to the Coliseum only, but that was $1.2 million.

836
01:19:30.230 --> 01:19:36.211
<v Carl Lyle>And then $531,000 from the Visitor Facilities Intergovernmental Agreement allocation that I mentioned.

837
01:19:36.891 --> 01:19:40.273
<v Jamie Dunphy>This will be my last question 'cause I'm taking up too much space.

838
01:19:41.462 --> 01:19:49.407
<v Jamie Dunphy>But on the survey that we sent out, we included different— a conversation about different pots of money.

839
01:19:49.454 --> 01:19:52.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I noticed that in the results, one of them said, oh yeah, use the Spectator Venue Fund.

840
01:19:52.859 --> 01:19:53.717
<v Jamie Dunphy>That makes a lot of sense.

841
01:19:56.052 --> 01:20:00.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've heard you say in conversation that the Moda Center is subsidizing all the rest of the facilities.

842
01:20:01.726 --> 01:20:10.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that until last year, or 2024, I guess, rather, when we took ownership, we weren't in an ongoing way contributing out of that spectator fund into the maintenance.

843
01:20:12.065 --> 01:20:18.942
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there specific concerns about using that spectator fund in the next 5 years?

844
01:20:19.054 --> 01:20:22.467
<v Jamie Dunphy>What happens if the city assumes full responsibility for maintenance?

845
01:20:22.564 --> 01:20:23.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that's a great question.

846
01:20:23.286 --> 01:20:32.332
<v Jamie Dunphy>If the city assumes 50% maintenance, what could we be looking at in terms of support for the Providence Park or other spectator venues?

847
01:20:33.328 --> 01:20:34.434
<v Jamie Dunphy>There are some tradeoffs, I guess.

848
01:20:34.530 --> 01:20:43.609
<v Carl Lyle>Yeah, so I mean, so basically the team's perspective is that all of the revenues generated by Moda Center should be going back into Moda Center, right?

849
01:20:44.139 --> 01:20:51.784
<v Carl Lyle>And understandably, from their perspective, it's not great that, you know, that we've been spending, you know, and it's the city's dollars to To do whatever we want with, right?

850
01:20:51.865 --> 01:20:54.988
<v Carl Lyle>But they've been spent on other activities within the program.

851
01:20:55.360 --> 01:21:05.137
<v Carl Lyle>So that is how we've paid for the debt service at Providence Park, for example, and other projects at— some of the projects at Veterans Memorial Coliseum and at, you know, other obligations of the fund.

852
01:21:06.368 --> 01:21:08.166
<v Carl Lyle>Administration, whatever, all of that.

853
01:21:09.438 --> 01:21:15.957
<v Carl Lyle>The more we put the available resources in the fund into motor projects, the less there is available for the other facilities.

854
01:21:16.006 --> 01:21:16.055
<v Carl Lyle>Okay.

855
01:21:16.261 --> 01:21:16.791
<v Carl Lyle>Absolutely.

856
01:21:17.304 --> 01:21:17.543
<v Carl Lyle>Right?

857
01:21:17.720 --> 01:21:29.470
<v Carl Lyle>So, you know, we have done— and we don't know exactly where this is going to end up yet, so it's hard to say with any sort of clarity, you know, exactly what the implications of where we end up on a proposed deal will be because we haven't negotiated it.

858
01:21:29.630 --> 01:21:40.835
<v Carl Lyle>But yeah, I would say from my perspective anyway, there is some concern that we would, you know, overcommit those dollars to make the Moda thing happen, and then we're creating additional problems, you know, around Providence Park or the Coliseum or other obligations.

859
01:21:40.882 --> 01:21:45.724
<v Carl Lyle>So I think it's a valid concern, one that we just don't really have thank you, Carl.

860
01:21:46.134 --> 01:21:47.002
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

861
01:21:49.739 --> 01:21:50.494
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks, Council President.

862
01:21:50.591 --> 01:21:53.210
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I have a question and then I can list some of the things that I care about.

863
01:21:53.627 --> 01:22:08.833
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So it's— I'm not sure if folks, the public knows that it says in the bridge lease, this lease that we're under right now, specifically that the arena operator, which is Rip City Management, is the one in charge of keeping the arena first class.

864
01:22:10.036 --> 01:22:14.032
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So do we know how much the team currently owes?

865
01:22:14.693 --> 01:22:18.319
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How far are we today from first class?

866
01:22:19.123 --> 01:22:23.403
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And what will happen to that owed money in a possible future lease?

867
01:22:26.608 --> 01:22:28.266
<v Carl Lyle>Yeah, so that's a great question.

868
01:22:29.909 --> 01:22:37.319
<v Carl Lyle>One of the strongest provisions in the original 1995 ground lease was this what we call the first-class standard.

869
01:22:38.105 --> 01:22:50.529
<v Carl Lyle>And it essentially— and actually, it's worth mentioning at this point also that that original ground lease, if it's not clear to folks already, it stated that because the city owns the land, the arena was privately developed.

870
01:22:50.594 --> 01:22:57.597
<v Carl Lyle>But at the end of that lease, if not extended or otherwise amended, the ownership of the building would revert to the city for a dollar.

871
01:22:57.646 --> 01:23:01.125
<v Carl Lyle>So that deal was actually set in 1995.

872
01:23:01.189 --> 01:23:01.255
<v Carl Lyle>Okay.

873
01:23:01.442 --> 01:23:08.768
<v Carl Lyle>We actually did it a couple years, one year early, 'cause we accepted the building in 2024 instead of waiting for the lease to expire in 2025.

874
01:23:08.832 --> 01:23:11.533
<v Carl Lyle>But that construct was there from the very beginning.

875
01:23:12.610 --> 01:23:22.118
<v Carl Lyle>An additional piece in that original lease was that there's a requirement for the team to keep the building in a first-class operating standard for facilities of its age.

876
01:23:23.640 --> 01:23:34.006
<v Carl Lyle>That's legally a little bit unclear exactly what that would mean in a situation where we tried to enforce that term because the building is now over 30 years old.

877
01:23:35.256 --> 01:23:40.354
<v Carl Lyle>And, you know, many buildings of that age have been majorly renovated or, you know, replaced even.

878
01:23:40.738 --> 01:23:43.863
<v Carl Lyle>So, you know, there's some conversation that would have to happen there.

879
01:23:43.992 --> 01:23:56.063
<v Carl Lyle>But I do think it's fair to say that there are some things identified in the facility condition assessment that are items that would need to be addressed in order to say that the facility is truly meeting that first-class standard.

880
01:23:56.110 --> 01:23:56.222
<v Carl Lyle>Thank you.

881
01:23:56.577 --> 01:23:58.055
<v Carl Lyle>Even for a 30-year-old facility.

882
01:23:58.425 --> 01:24:00.127
<v Carl Lyle>Not all of it, right?

883
01:24:00.288 --> 01:24:01.510
<v Carl Lyle>I don't think it's everything in there.

884
01:24:01.573 --> 01:24:12.029
<v Carl Lyle>But I do think that that first-class standard has an expectation that those systems, while old, are operating at a fully functional first-class level.

885
01:24:12.368 --> 01:24:22.841
<v Carl Lyle>So this is a term that, frankly, new ownership and the team is seeking to replace with a new operating lease, right?

886
01:24:22.890 --> 01:24:30.230
<v Carl Lyle>So there isn't a lot of consideration that— They would, you know, bring it to a standard and then we would enter a new lease and do the renovation project.

887
01:24:30.328 --> 01:24:42.606
<v Carl Lyle>So this is— I think you can think of the city, if we choose to, you know, enter a new lease and sort of forgive that previous requirement, that is another sort of a give.

888
01:24:43.027 --> 01:24:52.747
<v Carl Lyle>In a situation where the Blazers were to, you know, end the lease and perhaps relocate eventually, I think the city, the program would certainly then—.

889
01:24:52.747 --> 01:24:52.863
<v Carl Lyle>Right.

890
01:24:56.229 --> 01:25:03.810
<v Carl Lyle>Is that a number that we can get at some point or a ballpark?

891
01:25:05.189 --> 01:25:07.090
<v Carl Lyle>Not really.

892
01:25:07.090 --> 01:25:13.750
<v Kristen Dennis>Councilor, if I might, my guess, and I can say this as not a city employee, is that it would be the subject of litigation.

893
01:25:13.869 --> 01:25:15.170
<v Kristen Dennis>So I think it would depend on who you ask.

894
01:25:16.109 --> 01:25:17.550
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

895
01:25:17.550 --> 01:25:18.489
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All right.

896
01:25:18.489 --> 01:25:20.409
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Appreciate the councilors' leadership on I this.

897
01:25:20.395 --> 01:25:20.590
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>See I a think lot we're going to move forward with this.

898
01:25:20.716 --> 01:25:23.994
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Of questions that are asking for some more details and information.

899
01:25:24.814 --> 01:25:35.069
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It sounds a lot— very similar to what I heard in the meeting with the county and heard from especially Commissioners Moyer and Brim Edwards.

900
01:25:37.511 --> 01:25:46.354
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The need for more information, and Brim Edwards focused on the lack of any robust type of economic impacts analysis of the proposal.

901
01:25:46.418 --> 01:25:46.935
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's a good point.

902
01:25:47.516 --> 01:25:57.636
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And Commissioner Moyer heard her talking about frustration with the loss of property tax revenue, loss of services at the county, and really emphasized the need to fill that gap.

903
01:25:57.974 --> 01:26:07.916
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I agree with my colleagues that are saying, you know, we really can't talk about, like, compare and decide trade-offs unless we have those comps in a really detailed way.

904
01:26:08.591 --> 01:26:15.528
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I, first, every NBA deal I've looked at has Councilor Smith.

905
01:26:16.426 --> 01:26:18.689
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think we should be holding to that same standard.

906
01:26:19.074 --> 01:26:31.288
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also like the idea of paying— them paying rent, naming rights for us, payment in lieu of tax, rock-solid, high-paying union jobs that allow arena workers to live a dignified life here in Portland.

907
01:26:31.465 --> 01:26:33.086
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I don't think we just need 4,000 jobs.

908
01:26:33.135 --> 01:26:34.787
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think we need 4,000 good jobs.

909
01:26:35.525 --> 01:26:42.605
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am committed to doing the work and investing to repair historical harm caused upon those in the Albina neighborhood.

910
01:26:43.167 --> 01:26:56.220
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then this one is a little more like my personal hat on, and I don't think this is one that you negotiate as much until the end, but street pricing, ticket and concession prices being fair and for everyday Portlanders.

911
01:26:56.734 --> 01:27:00.395
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I took my kids to the NCAA thing recently.

912
01:27:00.444 --> 01:27:04.248
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It was very fun, and my kids— I couldn't afford to buy my kids a box of candy.

913
01:27:04.329 --> 01:27:04.971
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It was like $12.

914
01:27:06.030 --> 01:27:13.239
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So wanting families to be able to enjoy games, concerts without breaking the bank on a box of candy or a bag of popcorn.

915
01:27:13.351 --> 01:27:13.657
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

916
01:27:15.021 --> 01:27:15.904
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

917
01:27:16.225 --> 01:27:16.804
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

918
01:27:17.286 --> 01:27:19.501
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

919
01:27:20.110 --> 01:27:26.645
<v Angelita Morillo>So I expect moving forward for these work sessions that Carl Hirsch is going to be here in the room with us ready to answer questions.

920
01:27:26.822 --> 01:27:28.716
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's unacceptable that he is not here today.

921
01:27:29.149 --> 01:27:30.738
<v Angelita Morillo>I expect Mayor Wilson to be here as well.

922
01:27:30.948 --> 01:27:38.073
<v Angelita Morillo>Since he's the executive and will be implementing this, he needs to be able to answer our questions too, especially since he's getting information we are not.

923
01:27:38.859 --> 01:27:46.466
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I expect that we are going to be— I at least plan to send follow-up emails with all of my questions written down.

924
01:27:47.221 --> 01:27:55.454
<v Angelita Morillo>I want a public FAQ of all of the questions the councilors are asking, which councilors ask which questions, and answers to all of that.

925
01:27:55.872 --> 01:27:58.873
<v Angelita Morillo>Who do I direct those questions sure, Ms.

926
01:27:58.938 --> 01:27:59.259
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor.

927
01:27:59.579 --> 01:28:08.296
<v Donnie Oliveira>And Councilor, if I can just quickly acknowledge, Carl Hirsch is watching, and I think our intent with this session was to do more listening than talking.

928
01:28:08.793 --> 01:28:17.398
<v Donnie Oliveira>But absolutely, at the exec session on the 16th and the next work session on the 22nd, our full team will be here to present information and answer your questions.

929
01:28:18.121 --> 01:28:18.762
<v Angelita Morillo>That's great.

930
01:28:18.988 --> 01:28:26.443
<v Angelita Morillo>I have already been to 50 extremely vague executive sessions where I have stated the things that I need To get information to make decisions.

931
01:28:26.619 --> 01:28:28.778
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't need another public work session to do that.

932
01:28:28.890 --> 01:28:30.212
<v Angelita Morillo>I need information now.

933
01:28:30.969 --> 01:28:39.268
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm telling you right now, I am not doing this timeline by the end of the summer with the lack of information that we are receiving right now.

934
01:28:41.395 --> 01:28:45.449
<v Angelita Morillo>So now I will move into the things that I want and then some of the value statements.

935
01:28:46.322 --> 01:28:47.662
<v Angelita Morillo>And I hope that you're taking a lot of notes.

936
01:28:48.666 --> 01:28:52.627
<v Angelita Morillo>I definitely want the information on the spectator venues and the visitor funds.

937
01:28:53.324 --> 01:28:58.356
<v Angelita Morillo>Specifically how the use of those funds will impact our commitments on other maintenance needs.

938
01:28:58.907 --> 01:29:00.800
<v Angelita Morillo>And I will send all this in a follow-up email as well.

939
01:29:02.149 --> 01:29:12.715
<v Angelita Morillo>I want confirmation of the figures on the impact on property taxes that President Dunphy asked about across local government jurisdictions following the transfer of Moda ownership to the city.

940
01:29:14.498 --> 01:29:25.121
<v Angelita Morillo>I want more information on what Councilor Koyama Lane was asking about, and specifically whether the city is considering proposal of that clause in a future lease about the first-class clause.

941
01:29:27.199 --> 01:29:36.359
<v Angelita Morillo>And I want to just reemphasize everything that Councilors Koyama Lane and Green have brought up for inclusion in the contract, specifically the rent and private capital aspects.

942
01:29:37.807 --> 01:29:42.298
<v Angelita Morillo>I especially want to flag the necessity of private capital contribution.

943
01:29:43.975 --> 01:29:58.835
<v Angelita Morillo>If the owners put up just 25% of the $600 million price tag on this renovation and agreed to pay rent equivalent to what the Hurricanes pay in Raleigh, that alone would cover the upfront costs being asked of the city and the county.

944
01:30:00.909 --> 01:30:05.454
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's unacceptable that we're not having that discussion right now.

945
01:30:07.457 --> 01:30:12.318
<v Angelita Morillo>We are talking about a project with a total cost of nearly $900 million.

946
01:30:14.806 --> 01:30:21.360
<v Angelita Morillo>Add to that $300 million in interest, and the public will be paying north of $1 billion for this renovation.

947
01:30:22.819 --> 01:30:28.764
<v Angelita Morillo>A substantial portion of that cost, probably about half, is not advancing life and safety for the arena.

948
01:30:29.068 --> 01:30:37.784
<v Angelita Morillo>It is largely upgrades that put revenue directly in the pockets of a billionaire, unless the city decides to invest in these luxuries and demands return on that investment.

949
01:30:39.099 --> 01:30:43.153
<v Angelita Morillo>That includes $100 million in luxury suite renovations.

950
01:30:44.323 --> 01:30:50.365
<v Angelita Morillo>Regardless, we have heard about how these costs aren't so bad because the state is contributing $365 million.

951
01:30:51.583 --> 01:30:57.497
<v Angelita Morillo>It's been common in the last decade or so for the owners and the public to split construction costs and the like 50/50.

952
01:30:58.011 --> 01:31:17.372
<v Angelita Morillo>The state is already offering 60% upfront while the city is being asked to fund another $285 million ongoing for the next 20 years and asking for the city and county to cover the remaining 40% strikes me as wanting a better-than-market deal, and I'm not looking for a better-than-market deal for anyone who's not a Portlander.

953
01:31:18.766 --> 01:31:20.914
<v Angelita Morillo>And this isn't just about getting a fair deal, though.

954
01:31:21.572 --> 01:31:30.228
<v Angelita Morillo>The hundreds of millions of dollars that the owners would normally pay for in a deal like this, but that the public is being asked to pay for here, means service cuts.

955
01:31:31.012 --> 01:31:42.390
<v Angelita Morillo>As Commissioner Moyer pointed out at the county this week, the county is being asked to put $35 million towards this deal despite the projected general fund deficit of $78 million over the next 4 years.

956
01:31:43.128 --> 01:31:47.295
<v Angelita Morillo>That's going to force cuts in school-based mental health during a mental health epidemic among youth.

957
01:31:47.731 --> 01:31:50.851
<v Angelita Morillo>It'll force cuts in domestic violence shelters and victim services.

958
01:31:51.676 --> 01:32:03.849
<v Angelita Morillo>And here on this dais, we just made huge cuts to our core services and to, to nearly 100 city employees who do absolutely critical work for the city.

959
01:32:04.911 --> 01:32:15.175
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think I can speak for everyone when I say that I am not happy, and we are not happy, to have to make cuts in public safety, in parks, and everywhere else that we are being forced to make.

960
01:32:15.962 --> 01:32:20.572
<v Angelita Morillo>And we're going to be looking at difficult deficits in the future if we don't find a way to raise revenue.

961
01:32:21.054 --> 01:32:22.932
<v Angelita Morillo>So that means even more cuts to core services.

962
01:32:24.234 --> 01:32:32.104
<v Angelita Morillo>The options on the table here, at least from the limited information that I have been given, are shaky at best and fiscally irresponsible at worst.

963
01:32:32.899 --> 01:32:35.527
<v Angelita Morillo>And it seems absurd to tout this as a good deal.

964
01:32:36.525 --> 01:32:46.840
<v Angelita Morillo>A good deal would be substantially diversifying our sources of funding to include private investment and to ensure at least a break-even return on investment for the public.

965
01:32:47.016 --> 01:32:48.418
<v Angelita Morillo>That's the bare minimum.

966
01:32:49.193 --> 01:32:58.168
<v Angelita Morillo>If the owners put up just 25%, that again is going to cover the upfront costs that— for the city and county.

967
01:32:58.974 --> 01:33:00.469
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's what's been done in other cities.

968
01:33:01.287 --> 01:33:09.707
<v Angelita Morillo>There are numerous other terms that are both common and fair, and it's time for people who are making these decisions and gathering this data to give that to us councilors.

969
01:33:10.301 --> 01:33:19.798
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't ever want to come to a council session again where you are rattling off numbers to us that are not in a public presentation or a spreadsheet that are publicly accessible.

970
01:33:21.051 --> 01:33:29.555
<v Angelita Morillo>I should not be scrambling to take down notes and chicken scratch On the little pieces of data that we receive here and there incidentally because we happen to ask the right question.

971
01:33:30.229 --> 01:33:32.577
<v Angelita Morillo>I need that all written out in a spreadsheet.

972
01:33:33.609 --> 01:33:35.324
<v Angelita Morillo>I want the spreadsheet of all spreadsheets.

973
01:33:36.150 --> 01:33:41.184
<v Angelita Morillo>And then I want a presentation that makes that simple for the public so they know what they can ask for too.

974
01:33:42.746 --> 01:33:52.337
<v Angelita Morillo>And I am sorry if I'm being really stern right now, but I'm also not that sorry because apart from you who just joined our team.

975
01:33:52.417 --> 01:33:54.506
<v Angelita Morillo>Sorry you're here when I'm very angry.

976
01:33:54.957 --> 01:33:55.487
<v Angelita Morillo>You're wonderful.

977
01:33:56.579 --> 01:34:01.015
<v Angelita Morillo>But we have been asking for this in every single executive session thus far.

978
01:34:01.336 --> 01:34:03.328
<v Angelita Morillo>So I don't think I'm bringing anything crazy.

979
01:34:04.195 --> 01:34:07.635
<v Angelita Morillo>And the people that we were told were presenting today did not come to present.

980
01:34:08.631 --> 01:34:12.101
<v Angelita Morillo>We were not— I didn't know that we were going to be having a discussion about a discussion.

981
01:34:12.167 --> 01:34:13.997
<v Angelita Morillo>I thought we were really going to get into the meat of it today.

982
01:34:14.078 --> 01:34:15.588
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm— Councilor Loretta Smith.

983
01:34:15.942 --> 01:34:17.496
<v Angelita Morillo>So those are the things I will be asking for.

984
01:34:18.104 --> 01:34:22.929
<v Angelita Morillo>DCA Oliveira, I will be sending you a follow-up email, or my staff will be, with all of these questions.

985
01:34:22.993 --> 01:34:24.996
<v Angelita Morillo>And again, I want that public Q&A.

986
01:34:25.396 --> 01:34:25.716
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

987
01:34:26.983 --> 01:34:28.121
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

988
01:34:28.345 --> 01:34:28.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

989
01:34:29.627 --> 01:34:33.985
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President, and thank you, uh, the 3 of you that are up here right now.

990
01:34:34.194 --> 01:34:35.524
<v Dan Ryan>I think it's probably good you're staying there.

991
01:34:36.229 --> 01:34:38.345
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate that we're having this conversation, colleagues.

992
01:34:38.778 --> 01:34:41.149
<v Dan Ryan>We really haven't had a conversation like this yet.

993
01:34:41.279 --> 01:34:42.399
<v Dan Ryan>So this is really awesome.

994
01:34:44.845 --> 01:34:52.541
<v Dan Ryan>It should be our priority to reach an agreement on a term sheet where we as a council are united on what we consider success looks like.

995
01:34:53.251 --> 01:35:02.176
<v Dan Ryan>And I think by listening to my colleagues today, I'm getting a better sense of that for the first time, both for Portland taxpayers and for Blazer fans everywhere.

996
01:35:03.069 --> 01:35:07.416
<v Dan Ryan>In my opinion, success looks like the following: Portland earns revenue.

997
01:35:09.538 --> 01:35:14.149
<v Dan Ryan>We should see a return on our investment, and we should have that specced out.

998
01:35:15.259 --> 01:35:17.894
<v Dan Ryan>We should have the best-in-show NBA-caliber arena.

999
01:35:18.537 --> 01:35:26.126
<v Dan Ryan>We're investing in our arena, and again, it should be best-in-show with NBA arenas around the country.

1000
01:35:28.140 --> 01:35:29.601
<v Dan Ryan>Blazers must stay in Portland.

1001
01:35:31.257 --> 01:35:34.037
<v Dan Ryan>That means bound to Portland for 30 years.

1002
01:35:36.015 --> 01:35:36.314
<v Dan Ryan>Not—.

1003
01:35:36.314 --> 01:35:37.327
<v Dan Ryan>20 Is not enough.

1004
01:35:39.210 --> 01:35:45.405
<v Dan Ryan>There should be no opportunity for a buyout and no chance to simply pay a penalty to get that buyout.

1005
01:35:48.663 --> 01:35:54.389
<v Dan Ryan>An agreement with the NBA owners and Commissioner Silver considers— that they consider as reasonable.

1006
01:35:55.502 --> 01:36:02.613
<v Dan Ryan>We need an NBA Board of Governors and the commissioner on our side in support of the terms The term sheet that we come up with.

1007
01:36:03.655 --> 01:36:07.789
<v Dan Ryan>We don't want Texas Tom to say that he just couldn't work with us.

1008
01:36:08.542 --> 01:36:08.912
<v Dan Ryan>Got it.

1009
01:36:10.386 --> 01:36:12.484
<v Dan Ryan>Jobs, jobs, jobs.

1010
01:36:13.270 --> 01:36:18.719
<v Dan Ryan>Neighborhood activation from the river to Moda Center through the Lloyd Center, including areas of Lower Albina.

1011
01:36:19.680 --> 01:36:20.898
<v Dan Ryan>Big District 2 bias here.

1012
01:36:21.363 --> 01:36:22.966
<v Dan Ryan>Big picture Portland bias as well.

1013
01:36:23.606 --> 01:36:30.065
<v Dan Ryan>Speaking of big pictures, we need something Portland can be proud of Just like we're all so proud of the airport.

1014
01:36:30.716 --> 01:36:35.699
<v Dan Ryan>We have an international airport, a brand that really helps us a lot.

1015
01:36:36.104 --> 01:36:37.881
<v Dan Ryan>Everyone loves our airport.

1016
01:36:38.122 --> 01:36:39.899
<v Dan Ryan>We feel pride about that airport.

1017
01:36:40.655 --> 01:36:43.542
<v Dan Ryan>When you land there, you have the great first impression of Portland.

1018
01:36:44.444 --> 01:36:53.912
<v Dan Ryan>Let's follow it up with having that same experience when you see an international brand called NBA and us having that type of arena.

1019
01:36:53.978 --> 01:36:54.158
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1020
01:36:57.248 --> 01:37:10.547
<v Dan Ryan>Colleagues, when I play this forward, I can't see one scenario where having an international brand, the Portland Trail Blazers— again, we only have 2— leave our city, and that's going to be good for the long term for my hometown.

1021
01:37:10.966 --> 01:37:13.628
<v Dan Ryan>That's where I'm coming from.

1022
01:37:13.853 --> 01:37:20.574
<v Dan Ryan>I look forward to us continuing to figure out what success looks like and for us to get together on what our terms are like so we can take this seriously.

1023
01:37:20.622 --> 01:37:20.734
<v Kristen Dennis>Thank you.

1024
01:37:21.735 --> 01:37:21.912
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks.

1025
01:37:22.137 --> 01:37:23.037
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1026
01:37:23.342 --> 01:37:25.222
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, colleagues, it is 3:33.

1027
01:37:25.384 --> 01:37:28.548
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to give us a 12-minute bathroom break— 11-minute bathroom break.

1028
01:37:28.596 --> 01:37:29.416
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's 3:34 now.

1029
01:37:30.011 --> 01:37:32.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, everybody please be back here at 3:45.

1030
01:37:34.484 --> 01:37:34.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry.

1031
01:51:47.257 --> 01:51:49.136
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, we are coming back.

1032
01:51:49.201 --> 01:51:53.216
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for your patience while we took a quick human break.

1033
01:51:53.841 --> 01:51:59.573
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, we're going to start with Councilor Novick and then Pirtle-Guiney and then Koyama.

1034
01:52:00.377 --> 01:52:02.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, Councilor Novick.

1035
01:52:02.448 --> 01:52:03.332
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1036
01:52:04.520 --> 01:52:17.515
<v Steve Novick>Um, so one of the more valuable things I've seen in the last few weeks was something that basically said here's how much we would have to spend in order to keep the arena in its current condition over the next 20 years.

1037
01:52:18.927 --> 01:52:24.769
<v Steve Novick>And then here's how much that we'd have in ongoing maintenance if this renovation happened.

1038
01:52:25.074 --> 01:52:27.947
<v Steve Novick>And here's how much the state and the county are putting in.

1039
01:52:29.485 --> 01:52:38.564
<v Steve Novick>And that wound up sort of looking like the— we wind up saving more money in maintenance costs even after putting out the $120 million.

1040
01:52:38.645 --> 01:52:38.805
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1041
01:52:39.005 --> 01:52:40.869
<v Steve Novick>Than if we took on all the maintenance costs ourselves.

1042
01:52:41.216 --> 01:52:41.743
<v Steve Novick>Is that right?

1043
01:52:44.130 --> 01:52:47.336
<v Carl Lyle>Yes, I think you're referring to the facility condition assessment, right?

1044
01:52:47.385 --> 01:52:59.372
<v Carl Lyle>Which kind of looked at a 20-year spending plan to keep the building operating, you know, in its sort of current configuration, absent the major transformative renovation, but keeping everything going, you know, in tip-top shape.

1045
01:52:59.694 --> 01:53:02.939
<v Carl Lyle>And that estimated between $400 and $500 million worth of work.

1046
01:53:03.988 --> 01:53:11.242
<v Carl Lyle>And you're absolutely right that that those are costs that would need to be invested in the building.

1047
01:53:11.417 --> 01:53:18.761
<v Carl Lyle>And the city as the owner of the building without— it's hard to know, like, do we have an operator in that scenario who's contributing or not?

1048
01:53:19.274 --> 01:53:19.610
<v Carl Lyle>We don't know.

1049
01:53:19.692 --> 01:53:21.439
<v Carl Lyle>But it's possible we wouldn't.

1050
01:53:21.534 --> 01:53:24.229
<v Carl Lyle>And then those would essentially be city costs to keep the building running.

1051
01:53:24.565 --> 01:53:24.757
<v Kristen Dennis>Okay.

1052
01:53:26.009 --> 01:53:32.166
<v Steve Novick>And I mean, that's something I think that should be on like a very public website saying, you know, here is the value of what the state is offering.

1053
01:53:34.533 --> 01:53:48.881
<v Steve Novick>Another question is, I mean, I think we need to spell out for people, and most of my question is about things that I want myself, but I also want the public to know, like what exactly is the $400 million we need to spend to keep the building in its current condition?

1054
01:53:49.091 --> 01:53:51.378
<v Steve Novick>Sort of like list out some of the things that are necessary.

1055
01:53:52.122 --> 01:53:56.957
<v Steve Novick>And also, at what point would we have to just shut the building down?

1056
01:53:57.006 --> 01:53:58.676
<v Steve Novick>Do things start like falling on people's heads?

1057
01:53:59.577 --> 01:54:00.765
<v Steve Novick>Is that 2032?

1058
01:54:01.198 --> 01:54:01.664
<v Steve Novick>When is it?

1059
01:54:02.247 --> 01:54:07.873
<v Steve Novick>And another thing I think we need to get at is, is this building always going to be a money pit?

1060
01:54:08.595 --> 01:54:23.716
<v Steve Novick>Because my impression is if we're only making like, you know, $6 million a year that we get in revenues from the building or something to that effect, then we, you know, the building will always be costing us some money.

1061
01:54:24.564 --> 01:54:26.393
<v Steve Novick>So I think that should sort of be spelled out.

1062
01:54:26.618 --> 01:54:34.831
<v Steve Novick>And I think another thing I think would be useful is, Ranges of types of revenues we could get based on different assumptions.

1063
01:54:35.600 --> 01:54:39.243
<v Steve Novick>Like, what do we get if we get revenues from concessions?

1064
01:54:40.255 --> 01:54:42.565
<v Steve Novick>How much revenue do we get if we have street pricing?

1065
01:54:42.742 --> 01:54:47.347
<v Steve Novick>How much revenue do we get if we have labor guarantees at a living wage?

1066
01:54:48.520 --> 01:54:50.637
<v Steve Novick>What are the impacts of those things?

1067
01:54:50.685 --> 01:54:53.445
<v Steve Novick>I mean, Councilor Green was talking about what his priorities are.

1068
01:54:53.493 --> 01:54:58.784
<v Steve Novick>I think my priorities would probably be for living wages for employees, would take precedence over prices.

1069
01:54:58.898 --> 01:55:09.596
<v Steve Novick>But I'd like to see sort of some gradations of, based on these assumptions, here's, you know, how much money the city makes, here's how much people have to pay.

1070
01:55:15.310 --> 01:55:31.639
<v Steve Novick>All of us have said we'd like to see how much of the grand Blazer vision, how much money is for Blazer-specific 'cause I think that we should be pushing to get the Blazers to pay for things that are Blazer-specific.

1071
01:55:35.640 --> 01:55:56.990
<v Steve Novick>Another thing that I think that we need to— I mean, if we need to contemplate the possibility that we do just shut the arena down at some point, and we should say, okay, if we don't put any renovations in, then the building shuts down in 2032, But that saves us from having to spend $400 million or $200 million or whatever it is in maintenance.

1072
01:55:59.670 --> 01:56:07.079
<v Steve Novick>And I do think that it'd be useful to see— I mean, one question I have is actually, that's a very basic question.

1073
01:56:07.985 --> 01:56:09.713
<v Steve Novick>Are we getting any money from the naming rights now?

1074
01:56:10.810 --> 01:56:10.972
<v Carl Lyle>No.

1075
01:56:11.618 --> 01:56:11.747
<v Steve Novick>What?

1076
01:56:12.184 --> 01:56:12.345
<v Carl Lyle>No.

1077
01:56:12.603 --> 01:56:12.748
<v Steve Novick>No.

1078
01:56:13.636 --> 01:56:16.849
<v Steve Novick>So have we— I mean, have we put it out to bid for somebody else?

1079
01:56:17.997 --> 01:56:25.954
<v Carl Lyle>No, I mean, that was a negotiated term at the beginning of the deal, which was that the naming rights were the rights of the operator.

1080
01:56:26.670 --> 01:56:27.265
<v Steve Novick>Oh, okay.

1081
01:56:27.587 --> 01:56:31.193
<v Carl Lyle>Yeah, and actually, so stadium is the same thing, for example.

1082
01:56:31.274 --> 01:56:37.091
<v Steve Novick>All right, so we would need to, I mean, but okay, is the operator getting money from the naming rights right now?

1083
01:56:37.158 --> 01:56:37.435
<v Carl Lyle>Oh yes.

1084
01:56:37.532 --> 01:56:37.907
<v Donnie Oliveira>From Moda?

1085
01:56:37.988 --> 01:56:38.363
<v Steve Novick>How much?

1086
01:56:39.211 --> 01:56:39.537
<v Carl Lyle>We don't know.

1087
01:56:40.270 --> 01:56:40.645
<v Steve Novick>We don't know?

1088
01:56:40.694 --> 01:56:41.394
<v Carl Lyle>It's not public.

1089
01:56:42.645 --> 01:56:43.068
<v Steve Novick>Interesting.

1090
01:56:43.671 --> 01:56:45.921
<v Steve Novick>I mean, do we— it's not public.

1091
01:56:46.949 --> 01:56:52.315
<v Steve Novick>So do we have an idea of what naming rights are worth in other jurisdictions, you know, similarly?

1092
01:56:52.814 --> 01:56:55.565
<v Carl Lyle>Sure, we can get that.

1093
01:56:56.515 --> 01:56:56.628
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1094
01:56:57.239 --> 01:57:05.996
<v Steve Novick>And I mean, one thing I'd be interested in is how much could we expect to get for naming rights, assuming we're the ones getting them, if the Blazers are there as opposed to if they're not?

1095
01:57:07.426 --> 01:57:09.213
<v Steve Novick>What we expect to get if it's just a music arena.

1096
01:57:11.149 --> 01:57:11.534
<v Carl Lyle>Much less.

1097
01:57:11.792 --> 01:57:11.952
<v Carl Lyle>Yeah.

1098
01:57:12.193 --> 01:57:12.673
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I bet.

1099
01:57:12.755 --> 01:57:15.016
<v Steve Novick>But I think it would be nice to know that.

1100
01:57:15.561 --> 01:57:27.899
<v Steve Novick>I mean, I think I've implicitly said this earlier, but I'd like to know what parking revenues we might get depending on different levels of what we're charging for parking and how that compares to other arenas.

1101
01:57:28.076 --> 01:57:29.648
<v Steve Novick>And do we— so we sort of have a choice.

1102
01:57:30.096 --> 01:57:39.608
<v Steve Novick>Do we want to make more money by charging the highest anybody charges for parking, or do we make less by charging a small amount for yeah, the—.

1103
01:57:39.817 --> 01:57:45.329
<v Carl Lyle>I mean, the garages generally fill for large events, so you're obviously making more by charging more.

1104
01:57:46.619 --> 01:57:51.078
<v Kristen Dennis>Sorry, and Councilor Novick, if I can further complicate this for you.

1105
01:57:51.222 --> 01:57:51.351
<v Kristen Dennis>Sure.

1106
01:57:51.561 --> 01:57:57.077
<v Kristen Dennis>You talked earlier about— I mean, for these venues, we certainly are experiencing this at Metro, it's a depreciating asset.

1107
01:57:57.158 --> 01:58:04.997
<v Kristen Dennis>And so having to— there are always going to be new costs that are going to come forward, and it all just depends on what the values are and what the trade-offs are.

1108
01:58:06.458 --> 01:58:13.813
<v Kristen Dennis>You know, for the Expo Center, for instance, that model, that business model has changed quite a bit over the decades that it's been in operation.

1109
01:58:13.925 --> 01:58:19.320
<v Kristen Dennis>And so Metro's had to spend a lot of time in research and trying to figure out, okay, well, what does that next piece look like?

1110
01:58:20.154 --> 01:58:23.527
<v Kristen Dennis>Similar conversations obviously around the P5 venues.

1111
01:58:24.362 --> 01:58:26.914
<v Kristen Dennis>Keller looking at what types of events do you want?

1112
01:58:26.979 --> 01:58:27.108
<v Kristen Dennis>Right.

1113
01:58:27.171 --> 01:58:28.488
<v Kristen Dennis>How often do you want to have it in there?

1114
01:58:28.921 --> 01:58:36.721
<v Kristen Dennis>And then that all, depending on the type of events, that tells you the types of investments and the types of structural changes you need to make.

1115
01:58:37.186 --> 01:58:41.070
<v Kristen Dennis>And some of that creates more, again, more venues and then more parking revenue.

1116
01:58:41.216 --> 01:58:43.029
<v Kristen Dennis>And then, you know, it kind of keeps going.

1117
01:58:43.462 --> 01:58:48.149
<v Kristen Dennis>We've had— we've talked about this with improvements at the concession stands in the Keller.

1118
01:58:48.278 --> 01:58:50.733
<v Kristen Dennis>And so you can, you can complicate this quite a bit.

1119
01:58:51.006 --> 01:58:55.550
<v Kristen Dennis>And so as we have some of those inputs, and I I think I'll work with staff to try to get you some of these answers.

1120
01:58:55.886 --> 01:59:07.896
<v Kristen Dennis>But what I want to make clear for the public too is that that's going to be— all of these things interact with each other, and it really just depends on what the vision for the arena is and where do you want to do— do you want it to be first in class?

1121
01:59:07.961 --> 01:59:10.145
<v Kristen Dennis>Do you want it to be open and available all the time?

1122
01:59:10.514 --> 01:59:13.581
<v Kristen Dennis>Do you want to have subsidized events for the public to be able to use it?

1123
01:59:13.869 --> 01:59:15.171
<v Kristen Dennis>You know, these are all these questions.

1124
01:59:15.251 --> 01:59:16.247
<v Kristen Dennis>And then do you want to get—.

1125
01:59:16.520 --> 01:59:33.643
<v Steve Novick>And then what other revenue another question I have, although let's be honest, this might be sort of academic interest, is, is there anybody anywhere who actually makes money off facilities like these?

1126
01:59:36.539 --> 01:59:41.896
<v Steve Novick>And if there is, why does it appear like there's no real prospect of Arbor making money off it?

1127
01:59:41.978 --> 01:59:42.511
<v Steve Novick>It is a revenue bond.

1128
01:59:42.738 --> 01:59:43.806
<v Steve Novick>So the revenue bond is a revenue bond.

1129
01:59:44.192 --> 01:59:47.710
<v Steve Novick>Is it that we took a building with hundreds of millions of dollars in deferred maintenance?

1130
01:59:47.791 --> 01:59:48.774
<v Steve Novick>Have they been up to snuff?

1131
01:59:48.855 --> 01:59:50.533
<v Steve Novick>Then we could be making money off it.

1132
01:59:51.067 --> 01:59:58.409
<v Kristen Dennis>So I'm not the expert on this, but what I can say from the limited information that I have is obviously it depends on who the operator is and what the values are.

1133
01:59:58.489 --> 02:00:11.215
<v Kristen Dennis>So if it's a fully private operator that's running it as a business, which is not the case here, they're not going to want to have street-level pricing, for instance, or high-wage jobs, family wage jobs.

1134
02:00:11.408 --> 02:00:16.914
<v Kristen Dennis>And so there are some trade-offs there that the public and the public sector— this is also the case for Metro Venues.

1135
02:00:17.396 --> 02:00:23.819
<v Kristen Dennis>We've made decisions which really kind of hurt our bottom line because of the values that we have.

1136
02:00:23.948 --> 02:00:33.453
<v Kristen Dennis>Now, I don't know that every deal is different for some of these venues, but that is the challenge, unfortunately, or fortunately for public sector venue operators.

1137
02:00:33.565 --> 02:00:36.389
<v Steve Novick>I think it is worth, you know, spelling that out for people.

1138
02:00:36.485 --> 02:00:42.766
<v Steve Novick>So if we have an example of a similar arena that's privately run that actually makes money, I'd like to see what the differences are.

1139
02:00:42.880 --> 02:00:44.161
<v Steve Novick>Why are they making money and we're not?

1140
02:00:44.289 --> 02:00:47.606
<v Donnie Oliveira>I mean, Councilor, like, that's what we're contemplating right now with the P5 venues, right?

1141
02:00:47.654 --> 02:00:49.145
<v Donnie Oliveira>They've been managed publicly right now.

1142
02:00:49.354 --> 02:00:50.346
<v Donnie Oliveira>We have to subsidize them.

1143
02:00:50.811 --> 02:00:58.680
<v Donnie Oliveira>Is there a model where we have a third-party operator, nonprofit or private, we'll figure that out, that can run it at cost recovery at a minimum and perhaps even make revenue?

1144
02:00:59.305 --> 02:01:00.859
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we're looking at that for P5.

1145
02:01:01.509 --> 02:01:03.911
<v Donnie Oliveira>We'll have to consider that with Providence Park as well.

1146
02:01:04.122 --> 02:01:06.118
<v Donnie Oliveira>And then of course you're asking the question about the arenas.

1147
02:01:06.653 --> 02:01:07.416
<v Candace Avalos>So we can look into that.

1148
02:01:08.640 --> 02:01:18.271
<v Steve Novick>I mean, I think that it's, 'cause I think the public is gonna want, is largely gonna share our values as to things like pricing and labor agreements, et cetera.

1149
02:01:18.483 --> 02:01:22.751
<v Steve Novick>But the public is also gonna want to know, no, wait a minute, why if you own this building, can't you make some money off it?

1150
02:01:23.235 --> 02:01:27.149
<v Steve Novick>So I think it's gonna be helpful to like explain what the trade-offs are.

1151
02:01:27.547 --> 02:01:32.898
<v Steve Novick>And to be able to say possibly, well, we could make money off it except we don't want to screw workers and consumers.

1152
02:01:34.162 --> 02:01:34.761
<v Donnie Oliveira>What are the trade-offs?

1153
02:01:34.890 --> 02:01:35.197
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's the—.

1154
02:01:35.197 --> 02:01:35.454
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah.

1155
02:01:35.681 --> 02:01:35.779
<v Steve Novick>Yep.

1156
02:01:37.233 --> 02:01:37.621
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1157
02:01:38.832 --> 02:01:39.738
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1158
02:01:40.126 --> 02:01:40.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1159
02:01:42.000 --> 02:01:43.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1160
02:01:43.993 --> 02:02:12.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am, as I hear my colleagues and think about my own list that I've written down, I'm, very aware of this odd dynamic where some of what we are talking about is related to the venue and what we do with the venue, and some is related to Rip City Management as the property manager, and some is related to the Blazers as our primary tenant.

1161
02:02:13.708 --> 02:02:24.546
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And some of the things that we are asking for are things that we actually, as the city control that frankly we should not give the Blazers or Rip City Management or anybody else any bargaining power over.

1162
02:02:24.724 --> 02:02:28.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should just do them.

1163
02:02:29.220 --> 02:02:36.654
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Some of them are things we need to talk to our manager, currently Rip City Management, about, and some are things that have more to do with the Blazers.

1164
02:02:37.408 --> 02:02:49.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I just— I want to note that because I don't want us to put things on the table in a lease negotiation that we could just do or say we are doing.

1165
02:02:49.451 --> 02:02:56.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't want us to come to the table with free items, and by free I don't mean cost.

1166
02:02:57.061 --> 02:03:07.595
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I mean things that are easy yeses for the other side and therefore allow them to say we gave you these wins when they actually did not give us anything at all.

1167
02:03:08.863 --> 02:03:32.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I I just want to start with that framing because I am very worried that as we conflate all of these different things that we need for the community, for Portlanders, in how Moda ultimately operates, that we're conflating pieces that we should be getting in different spaces and ways.

1168
02:03:33.798 --> 02:03:34.377
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1169
02:03:35.020 --> 02:03:42.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To that end, I think it's really important to ask the questions about should we be doing this renovation?

1170
02:03:42.621 --> 02:03:44.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If so, what does that look like?

1171
02:03:44.719 --> 02:03:47.222
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then if so, what does the lease agreement look like?

1172
02:03:48.046 --> 02:03:58.484
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I will just say from my perspective as a District 2 councilor, this arena is in my district, we need to renovate it.

1173
02:03:58.842 --> 02:04:15.737
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The idea that Moda has fewer and fewer active nights a year moving forward because there are just fewer events it can support is not a future that I want us to be moving toward.

1174
02:04:16.639 --> 02:04:20.164
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So then I ask the question, okay, then what does that look like?

1175
02:04:21.056 --> 02:04:22.403
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What are the sources of funding?

1176
02:04:22.596 --> 02:04:23.828
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What are we putting it toward?

1177
02:04:24.689 --> 02:04:26.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And when I think about the bottom lines there.

1178
02:04:30.311 --> 02:04:39.850
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is a bottom line for me that we are paying to upgrade the arena for accessibility, right?

1179
02:04:39.913 --> 02:04:43.850
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are parts of the arena you can only get to right now through one elevator.

1180
02:04:45.136 --> 02:04:46.533
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's not acceptable.

1181
02:04:48.573 --> 02:04:53.988
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to be looking at upgrades that make life easier for the people who work there.

1182
02:04:54.935 --> 02:05:13.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The fact that the loading docks and rigging are such that our crews that work on events at Moda have to put in significantly more work to do the same thing compared to what happens in other arenas is not acceptable.

1183
02:05:17.140 --> 02:05:22.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are pieces like that that I think are bottom lines around what are we funding.

1184
02:05:23.149 --> 02:05:41.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And to that end, there's a very distinct line for me, maybe not a clear one, but a distinct one between upgrades that are about usability for many users of the arena, the functionality of the arena.

1185
02:05:41.865 --> 02:05:42.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, like the roof.

1186
02:05:42.670 --> 02:05:44.597
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The sustainability of the arena.

1187
02:05:46.909 --> 02:05:56.488
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those are things that I am very comfortable talking about public dollars for because this is a facility we own and we are making it a more usable facility.

1188
02:05:58.170 --> 02:06:30.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are things that are about a better arena for basketball, locker rooms that are more functional for the fire, not just the blazers, that are about specific users, but about us having good lease agreements with those users that I think are important for us to talk about public dollars for, but perhaps the space for those more expansive conversations that some of my colleagues have noted.

1189
02:06:31.305 --> 02:06:33.586
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I'm not uncomfortable talking about public dollars there.

1190
02:06:34.938 --> 02:06:49.145
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then there are things like owner suites and pieces like that that I very much think we need to be looking at the users who are asking for those to fund.

1191
02:06:49.516 --> 02:06:56.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So as you think about what are the bottom lines, I'm going to be looking at what funds are going toward.

1192
02:06:57.070 --> 02:07:00.042
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I also think there's a really important piece of transparency transparency here.

1193
02:07:00.829 --> 02:07:14.376
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know that there are many Portlanders who don't trust this process right now, and so I think that information—what funds are going to what parts of the project—is going to be really important to be clear on for transparency's sake too.

1194
02:07:16.457 --> 02:07:24.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to talk about a couple of things that I want to see, some of which might fall into a lease agreement with Rip City Management or with the Blaze.

1195
02:07:24.789 --> 02:07:39.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Blazers and some of which might not, but all of which have to do less with what happens with the arena remodel and more about what happens with the use of the arena and the involvement of Blazers and Rip City Management moving forward.

1196
02:07:40.396 --> 02:07:42.820
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, I recognize that I'm blurring that line.

1197
02:07:42.868 --> 02:07:48.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I asked us to separate some in these, but they're all in that kind of after the renovation category.

1198
02:07:50.755 --> 02:07:52.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is jobs.

1199
02:07:53.239 --> 02:08:04.164
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In the trifecta of lower costs, revenue for the city, and good jobs, there need to be good jobs in this arena.

1200
02:08:04.792 --> 02:08:15.962
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The City of Portland has no business funding low-wage jobs that require Portlanders yes.

1201
02:08:16.363 --> 02:08:18.322
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To be reliant on public supports.

1202
02:08:19.639 --> 02:08:26.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as long as we own this arena, that statement extends to the jobs in this arena.

1203
02:08:27.747 --> 02:08:29.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that can look a lot of different ways.

1204
02:08:30.877 --> 02:08:33.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You had asked us not to get too deep into tools.

1205
02:08:33.608 --> 02:08:34.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I won't.

1206
02:08:34.747 --> 02:08:35.519
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need good jobs.

1207
02:08:36.193 --> 02:08:38.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They're not necessarily all full-time jobs.

1208
02:08:38.440 --> 02:08:39.034
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are events.

1209
02:08:39.243 --> 02:08:40.078
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I understand that.

1210
02:08:40.529 --> 02:08:41.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But they need to be high quality.

1211
02:08:41.636 --> 02:08:41.685
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1212
02:08:43.404 --> 02:08:52.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The second thing is a strong commitment to be a proactive neighbor and for Moda to be a neighborhood asset.

1213
02:08:53.140 --> 02:09:03.029
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know that there is going to be significant change through the work of Albina Vision Trust, through the work of 1803 Fund, in the areas directly adjacent to Moda Center.

1214
02:09:04.126 --> 02:09:27.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And either we have a manager of Moda Center and core tenants there who say, hey, great to see you over there, thanks for the work you're doing, and frankly reap the benefit of those investments because activation of the spaces around Moda will be nothing but good for the users of Moda.

1215
02:09:28.440 --> 02:09:34.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or we have a manager and tenants who say, hey, We are invested in you.

1216
02:09:35.747 --> 02:09:39.826
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are invested in your success because we know it contributes to our success.

1217
02:09:40.579 --> 02:09:43.872
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are invested in your success because we bring this city up together.

1218
02:09:44.675 --> 02:09:57.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we absolutely must see a strong commitment to be not just a, hey, how you doing, neighbor, but a proactive, involved neighbor adding value to the neighborhood.

1219
02:09:58.707 --> 02:10:01.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>From our manager and our main tenants at Moda.

1220
02:10:03.155 --> 02:10:04.793
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Again, that can look a lot of different ways.

1221
02:10:04.890 --> 02:10:13.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I won't get into the specific tools, but I know that there are some really interesting ideas that Albina Vision Trust has floated.

1222
02:10:14.139 --> 02:10:29.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that there are some incredible creative thinkers in the community looking at how Moda, just given the space that it takes up, up and the opportunity that comes with that square footage could provide value to the surrounding areas.

1223
02:10:30.405 --> 02:10:32.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe that we need to be taking those very seriously.

1224
02:10:37.192 --> 02:10:43.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think enough people have said this yet, so I will say we need a clear commitment from the Blazers to stay in Portland for the long haul.

1225
02:10:46.224 --> 02:10:58.515
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we are investing in an arena arena that is optimized for both concerts and basketball, as well as other events, which I assume we are going to do, though I guess that's a question we should probably ask.

1226
02:10:58.579 --> 02:11:02.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we want this to be a concert venue, a sports venue, a something else?

1227
02:11:03.786 --> 02:11:12.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we are making investments specifically for basketball, we need our basketball teams to be committed to being here for the, the payoff term of those investments.

1228
02:11:13.719 --> 02:11:23.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if they are not then we need a payout for those investments, and we need to see more.

1229
02:11:23.456 --> 02:11:25.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think just no three more things.

1230
02:11:25.483 --> 02:11:26.114
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

1231
02:11:27.320 --> 02:11:29.326
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We need to see more activation of that space.

1232
02:11:30.814 --> 02:11:37.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have not taken full advantage of that space, and I hear a lot of my colleagues talking about revenue from the facility.

1233
02:11:38.368 --> 02:11:39.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The way that we get more revenue from the facility.

1234
02:11:40.090 --> 02:11:46.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The only way we're going to get more revenue out of the facility, if we want to focus on things like good jobs or street pricing, is by having more activation of the facility.

1235
02:11:47.750 --> 02:11:56.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if we are talking about an external property manager, they need to be committed to optimizing activation of that space.

1236
02:11:59.626 --> 02:12:05.509
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have had— well, related to that, I guess I'll go next to self-generating revenue.

1237
02:12:05.619 --> 02:12:05.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1238
02:12:05.891 --> 02:12:06.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1239
02:12:06.840 --> 02:12:07.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1240
02:12:07.434 --> 02:12:09.393
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I have a question about self-generating revenue for ongoing needs at the facility.

1241
02:12:09.440 --> 02:12:13.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know we've had a lot of conversations about the different ways that revenue can be generated at the facility.

1242
02:12:13.760 --> 02:12:16.779
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>One of my colleagues asked for revenue back to the general fund.

1243
02:12:17.436 --> 02:12:26.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would much rather see us limit our ongoing investment needs because there is self-generating revenue at the facility.

1244
02:12:27.070 --> 02:12:39.210
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How are we making sure that the dollars generated there are not going to somebody else's bottom line but are going into the facility, into the ongoing maintenance?

1245
02:12:39.515 --> 02:12:57.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And how are we using this point in time while we make a very large potential investment to think about the next end-of-life conversation, whether that's another remodel or saying that this arena has yes.

1246
02:12:59.157 --> 02:13:02.868
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When you start planning for those things 5 years in advance, you're already in a crisis.

1247
02:13:03.840 --> 02:13:07.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When you plan for that 15 or 20 years in advance, you have a plan.

1248
02:13:09.079 --> 02:13:18.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So how are we making sure that that self-generating revenue is part of building toward a conversation about whatever happens next?

1249
02:13:21.408 --> 02:13:32.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have had a lot of conversations with community members about community access, and I want to put that on the list that you have also, knowing that community access can mean a lot of different things.

1250
02:13:32.662 --> 02:13:44.817
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I've been trying to avoid tools, but I want to name 3 things that I've heard from community members, all of which I think are really interesting, none of which I am specifically tied to being the answer.

1251
02:13:45.443 --> 02:13:53.583
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I think we do need to show Portland Portlanders that there is some level of community space in this community place.

1252
02:13:54.739 --> 02:13:57.051
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it could look like a lot of different things.

1253
02:13:57.871 --> 02:14:04.502
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have had community members suggest that there be a minimum number of community events a year.

1254
02:14:05.354 --> 02:14:09.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And there would be applications to the city on what those are.

1255
02:14:09.143 --> 02:14:11.648
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Maybe we prioritize school events.

1256
02:14:12.337 --> 02:14:19.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could look a lot of different ways, but that there be 10 or 12 or some number of nights reserved for community events.

1257
02:14:20.591 --> 02:14:48.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have had community members ask about dedicating one of the boxes to community organizations, and I've had conversations with a few people about specifically prioritizing youth organizations to put into get access one event a year for each organization to a box for, for community groups for free access.

1258
02:14:49.573 --> 02:14:58.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had a really interesting conversation with a Portlander who said, you know, on Broadway there are raffled-off cheap tickets every night for shows.

1259
02:15:00.010 --> 02:15:16.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What if we reserved a certain number of tickets, half a section for a raffle for every event, not just basketball, for everything we do at Moda, for highly affordable seats for community members.

1260
02:15:17.561 --> 02:15:36.981
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am not tied to any of those 3 things being the answer, but I do think we need to have a conversation about what it means for the community to have access to this space and how that is part of what we and again, depending on our setup, that could be something that we just say we own this building, that is a part of it.

1261
02:15:37.029 --> 02:15:41.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It could be a part of a negotiation with a property manager.

1262
02:15:41.777 --> 02:15:44.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think it's related to the Blazers as a tenant at all.

1263
02:15:45.452 --> 02:15:50.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So as we think about our bargaining power, let's make sure we're being careful with that one.

1264
02:15:50.967 --> 02:15:51.895
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I think there's a there there.

1265
02:15:53.680 --> 02:16:11.237
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Finally, Finally, I just want to come back to the idea of accountability and transparency that I stated at the beginning, because how we move forward with the information that we talk about in this space and that you share with us is really important.

1266
02:16:11.318 --> 02:16:20.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And not every Portlander is able to watch our meetings, but we can share things that are publicly available online quite easily with far more people.

1267
02:16:21.095 --> 02:16:38.950
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so as we start getting into conversations about what are we actually paying for, what are the different dollar sources, and what is each dollar source going to, I think it's really important to have that information, at least at a high level, very available.

1268
02:16:40.138 --> 02:16:44.314
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The state has said that there's money available if certain conditions are met.

1269
02:16:45.679 --> 02:16:48.385
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Presumably there money goes first to meeting those conditions.

1270
02:16:50.370 --> 02:16:54.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are some things that I think if we do, like I said, there needs to be private money for.

1271
02:16:55.077 --> 02:16:56.566
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's be clear about that.

1272
02:16:57.389 --> 02:17:02.058
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What is it that city dollars have to go toward, and therefore what are the most responsible sources of funding?

1273
02:17:03.362 --> 02:17:05.343
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just think that needs to be a very clear conversation.

1274
02:17:06.061 --> 02:17:12.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while I'm talking about the state dollars, I will just note that if we are going to optimize this arena, Thank you.

1275
02:17:12.180 --> 02:17:12.180
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Herbold, I have a question for you.

1276
02:17:12.180 --> 02:17:13.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think you mentioned that you were going to be talking to the city attorney about the arena for basketball.

1277
02:17:13.260 --> 02:17:17.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's make sure we do it on a timeline where we can take advantage of those state dollars.

1278
02:17:17.280 --> 02:17:25.799
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't want to be talking about $300 million more city dollars because we didn't take advantage of the state dollars on the table.

1279
02:17:26.329 --> 02:17:28.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we still need to answer that question.

1280
02:17:29.040 --> 02:17:32.459
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we doing this in a way that meets the conditions they've laid out?

1281
02:17:32.459 --> 02:17:37.360
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if we are, let's take that money and use it as part of what we're doing.

1282
02:17:39.814 --> 02:17:45.058
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, I'm trying to stick to just the questions at hand, so I'm going to stop there.

1283
02:17:45.427 --> 02:17:45.894
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1284
02:17:46.086 --> 02:17:46.618
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1285
02:17:47.542 --> 02:17:48.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1286
02:17:48.792 --> 02:17:49.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1287
02:17:51.906 --> 02:17:52.295
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1288
02:17:54.333 --> 02:18:03.567
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>A kind of basic question that Commissioner Brim Edwards was asking yesterday that I think would be helpful for us is to get an itemized list of improvements.

1289
02:18:04.823 --> 02:18:07.483
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>To know what is the $600 million for.

1290
02:18:09.690 --> 02:18:12.162
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And because without that, it's really hard to make a decision going forward.

1291
02:18:12.290 --> 02:18:13.664
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I am going to go back.

1292
02:18:14.245 --> 02:18:19.763
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know I asked, I kind of felt a little drowned in legalese, but Councilor Novick and I were talking about this a little more.

1293
02:18:20.379 --> 02:18:26.395
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There is a bridge lease right now that says the team is in charge of keeping the arena first class.

1294
02:18:26.963 --> 02:18:41.387
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So how can we figure out, even if it's ballpark, how much the team currently owes and how far we are from first class and, you know, what has happened to that, what's going to happen to that owed money.

1295
02:18:41.840 --> 02:18:47.693
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I would like to put that question out there again and hope that I can get answers to both of those.

1296
02:18:53.197 --> 02:18:55.137
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Right now or someday?

1297
02:18:55.540 --> 02:18:56.754
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, what those are?

1298
02:18:56.956 --> 02:19:02.640
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's a very complex question, but we'll definitely dive in with our team and see what we can come up with even to give you a range.

1299
02:19:03.459 --> 02:19:07.507
<v Donnie Oliveira>But I think as Kristen said, opinions may vary on that answer.

1300
02:19:08.952 --> 02:19:12.245
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's the case with a lot of this.

1301
02:19:12.614 --> 02:19:13.386
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Opinions vary.

1302
02:19:14.380 --> 02:19:19.584
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Very different opinions around what the economic impact is around almost all of these.

1303
02:19:20.003 --> 02:19:20.581
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah.

1304
02:19:20.661 --> 02:19:30.552
<v Kristen Dennis>Well, and what I would say about that specific need is that Portland City staff may come up with an amount that they say is an owed part, which I think is an important data point for you all.

1305
02:19:31.323 --> 02:19:36.558
<v Kristen Dennis>What I want to recognize is that the other party may not agree that that is the actual amount.

1306
02:19:36.638 --> 02:19:38.275
<v Kristen Dennis>And so then it might be somewhere in the middle.

1307
02:19:38.324 --> 02:19:40.138
<v Kristen Dennis>Those are both important data points for you.

1308
02:19:40.235 --> 02:19:42.226
<v Kristen Dennis>So we can make sure to get 'em for you.

1309
02:19:42.273 --> 02:19:43.606
<v Kristen Dennis>I just wanna make clear about that.

1310
02:19:43.863 --> 02:19:45.677
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that happens a lot just in negotiations.

1311
02:19:45.790 --> 02:19:46.255
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Sure.

1312
02:19:46.834 --> 02:19:47.171
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That happens.

1313
02:19:47.235 --> 02:19:53.969
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But even to have Yeah, absolutely.

1314
02:19:53.969 --> 02:19:55.290
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1315
02:19:55.610 --> 02:19:58.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1316
02:19:58.090 --> 02:19:59.090
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

1317
02:19:59.829 --> 02:20:02.670
<v Mitch Green>Just wanted to come back in with some additional comments and questions.

1318
02:20:03.290 --> 02:20:10.489
<v Mitch Green>I neglected earlier, I didn't get through my full list of things I'd like to see in here because I just sort of got spun up on other ideas in my head.

1319
02:20:10.510 --> 02:20:13.549
<v Mitch Green>But a labor peace agreement is very important to me.

1320
02:20:13.549 --> 02:20:14.750
<v Dan Ryan>I know that's something that's been talked about in the past.

1321
02:20:14.827 --> 02:20:15.086
<v Laura Oppenheimer>That's—.

1322
02:20:15.086 --> 02:20:21.032
<v Mitch Green>You're hearing that across the dais, and I just wanted to make sure that I was explicitly expressing that, um, that perspective.

1323
02:20:21.082 --> 02:20:22.782
<v Mitch Green>That's in addition to the project labor agreement.

1324
02:20:23.738 --> 02:20:28.064
<v Mitch Green>Um, I know that that's going in a negotiation.

1325
02:20:28.129 --> 02:20:32.745
<v Mitch Green>That means that you might give up on some other areas, but I don't want to give up on that.

1326
02:20:33.630 --> 02:20:47.566
<v Mitch Green>Um, the, uh— I know we're not supposed to talk about tools today, but I think what I'd like to yeah.

1327
02:20:47.629 --> 02:21:02.078
<v Mitch Green>And so I think if we're trying to indicate today how to be prepared with a term sheet, um, the thing that's sort of elephant in the room is the Portland Clean Energy Fund.

1328
02:21:03.138 --> 02:21:22.174
<v Mitch Green>And I think— I know that there's going to be a PCF committee conversation coming up, but, um, For me, you know, this facility conditions assessment, which is $500-some-odd million, there's probably things in that itemized list that are weatherization projects and the like.

1329
02:21:22.254 --> 02:21:29.930
<v Mitch Green>But I think I've been hearing a lot about transformational investments, things like district heating, district cooling, rooftop solar.

1330
02:21:30.011 --> 02:21:37.843
<v Mitch Green>And so if we're doing big piece-effable concepts, does that not add to the cost?

1331
02:21:39.031 --> 02:21:56.918
<v Mitch Green>And then so then if PCF, if the $75 million that kind of the mayor put down in March to get the state legislature to say, cool, we'll meet you there, if that's the play, doesn't that not just get eaten up by all this extra new stuff that would be part of it?

1332
02:21:56.967 --> 02:21:58.781
<v Mitch Green>So we're still left with a funding gap?

1333
02:21:59.440 --> 02:22:12.471
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, that is such an important question, and thank you for bringing up PCF in particular to, to name this, because we are still very much like prepared to enter into the negotiations, those requirements.

1334
02:22:12.536 --> 02:22:20.608
<v Donnie Oliveira>I think Councilor Koyama just mentioned it as well, like what are the things that we're prioritizing in the range of options that you might do to improve an arena?

1335
02:22:21.104 --> 02:22:22.292
<v Donnie Oliveira>Like what is this today?

1336
02:22:22.388 --> 02:22:25.854
<v Donnie Oliveira>You are telling us a long list of things that you want us to contemplate.

1337
02:22:26.706 --> 02:22:27.218
<v Donnie Oliveira>This is helpful.

1338
02:22:27.363 --> 02:22:36.520
<v Donnie Oliveira>This helps us start to prepare for our term sheet, including hey, if we're going to put in $575 million of public dollars, and I'm representing the county and the state here for one second, these are our priorities.

1339
02:22:36.520 --> 02:22:37.959
<v Donnie Oliveira>These are where the investments need to be.

1340
02:22:37.959 --> 02:22:40.309
<v Donnie Oliveira>We don't want to prioritize owner suites.

1341
02:22:40.600 --> 02:22:44.600
<v Donnie Oliveira>We want to prioritize investments in battery storage or climate resiliency.

1342
02:22:44.840 --> 02:22:49.969
<v Donnie Oliveira>That is what you are arming us with as directive to go negotiate for on terms.

1343
02:22:50.139 --> 02:22:59.225
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so the ideal would be that we're targeting this $575 million number, $75 million of which, again, to be determined is PCEF, but that's part of the $575 million.

1344
02:22:59.273 --> 02:23:01.835
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's not $75 million on top of whatever the Blazers want.

1345
02:23:02.077 --> 02:23:03.898
<v Donnie Oliveira>We have agency in that negotiation.

1346
02:23:05.340 --> 02:23:10.075
<v Donnie Oliveira>And you're seating us right now essentially, I mean, not just the only time, of course, with some of that directive.

1347
02:23:10.933 --> 02:23:11.370
<v Mitch Green>Appreciate that.

1348
02:23:11.433 --> 02:23:23.234
<v Mitch Green>I think that's— but I think some folks have been sold on this idea that PCEF can be this big transformational clean energy boon, but I don't see that in the facility condition assessment.

1349
02:23:24.078 --> 02:23:31.549
<v Kristen Dennis>So, and if I might, there, there's a lot of conversation that still needs to happen that will come back in, in what we bring you, bring forward to you.

1350
02:23:31.596 --> 02:23:33.729
<v Kristen Dennis>And there's a lot of, as we talked about, there's a lot of different pieces.

1351
02:23:33.778 --> 02:23:40.702
<v Kristen Dennis>There's the arena, there's the neighborhood, there's a bunch of different things that are together, and they all relate to each other, but there are different deals.

1352
02:23:41.136 --> 02:23:42.627
<v Kristen Dennis>So there is going to be a conversation.

1353
02:23:42.818 --> 02:23:52.225
<v Kristen Dennis>So when we're talking about the state money, what, what the state statute looks at is a kind of a meaningful I can't remember what the amount, but, you know, meaningful local investment.

1354
02:23:52.774 --> 02:23:56.415
<v Kristen Dennis>Their aim at that right now seems to be at about $120 million.

1355
02:23:57.167 --> 02:24:08.266
<v Kristen Dennis>It is unclear whether those— and it's not in the state statute itself— whether that has to be in the arena itself, whether it can be around the area.

1356
02:24:08.315 --> 02:24:16.753
<v Kristen Dennis>And so that is a separate piece of negotiation that we're going to have to do in our relationship with the state as well to kind of define what types of the scope of the project.

1357
02:24:16.945 --> 02:24:22.677
<v Kristen Dennis>So both for kind of the immediate investments and then kind of the scope of, you know, future projects as well.

1358
02:24:22.726 --> 02:24:33.290
<v Kristen Dennis>So this is— this is— we have an immediate issue in front of us in terms of these investments, but there are further conversations that council is going to need to have around, you know, additional investments that happen later.

1359
02:24:33.354 --> 02:24:34.527
<v Mitch Green>Yep, thank you for that.

1360
02:24:34.575 --> 02:24:40.033
<v Mitch Green>And I— so what I'm hearing is there's some potential for the scope of this to grow if council chooses to?

1361
02:24:40.129 --> 02:24:40.274
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

1362
02:24:40.757 --> 02:25:00.102
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, and so I guess what I'm really worried about here is we adopt a term sheet that provides some discussion and some indication around one scope, and then we say yes to that scope, and then the scope then grows, and then the cost then grows, and then taxpayers are watching all that happen.

1363
02:25:00.296 --> 02:25:03.354
<v Mitch Green>So that's important.

1364
02:25:03.579 --> 02:25:16.109
<v Kristen Dennis>Yeah, and I'm hearing that very clearly, and particularly as some of the lessons learned, a lot of the Information that's been around around other terms in other stadiums, in other places have been where that same thing has happened.

1365
02:25:16.173 --> 02:25:25.802
<v Kristen Dennis>And I'm hearing very clearly from council wanting to be very clear about which pots of money go to which pieces of the infrastructure.

1366
02:25:25.851 --> 02:25:26.603
<v Mitch Green>Okay, thank you.

1367
02:25:26.667 --> 02:25:35.929
<v Mitch Green>And then will the term sheet contemplate things like district taxing district stuff, kind of, you know, that those sort of those other tools?

1368
02:25:36.010 --> 02:25:43.500
<v Donnie Oliveira>If that's something that council is interested in us contemplating, or if another party like the state or the Blazers want to talk about it, that would be negotiated.

1369
02:25:44.250 --> 02:25:45.229
<v Donnie Oliveira>But that is not necessarily something—.

1370
02:25:45.229 --> 02:25:47.370
<v Mitch Green>You're not going to bring that necessarily in a few weeks?

1371
02:25:47.370 --> 02:25:48.190
<v Donnie Oliveira>Not necessarily.

1372
02:25:48.190 --> 02:25:49.010
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1373
02:25:49.010 --> 02:25:49.690
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you.

1374
02:25:49.690 --> 02:26:04.090
<v Donnie Oliveira>And council, if— I don't know if you saw the memo that Carl had, uh, produced that sort of tried to kind of give you all an example of like what's in the FCA— sorry, the Facilities Condition Assessment— versus like what the, like, the Blazers ask was, or basketball-centric, whatever you want to say.

1375
02:26:04.754 --> 02:26:20.320
<v Donnie Oliveira>There's also this reality that there are— there's a punch list in the FCA, but there's just a larger— like when you upgrade any facility, in this case an arena, you're making broader investments in things that might not be as obvious as a punch list, like an elevator or a loading dock.

1376
02:26:20.788 --> 02:26:24.009
<v Donnie Oliveira>It might be expanding the concourse as an example.

1377
02:26:24.314 --> 02:26:30.721
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's more, you know, less functionally required, but it just improves the arena experience for fans.

1378
02:26:30.770 --> 02:26:30.867
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1379
02:26:31.556 --> 02:26:32.542
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1380
02:26:33.237 --> 02:26:47.425
<v Mitch Green>And my last question is, um, so Councilor Novick, you actually raised a really good line of questioning, which was sort of like the long-term liability cost of the thing that we agreed to enter into in 2024 before most of us were on the City Council.

1381
02:26:49.288 --> 02:26:50.558
<v Mitch Green>Um, we do have to think about that.

1382
02:26:50.622 --> 02:26:53.227
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, you also raised similar questions.

1383
02:26:53.291 --> 02:26:55.204
<v Mitch Green>We have to be planning for that.

1384
02:26:55.686 --> 02:27:09.058
<v Mitch Green>Um, is part of this conversation Although this is the worst-case scenario, but if the Blazers were to leave, are we trying to price in, do some sort of market comps for what it would look like to do a competitive bid for a new operator?

1385
02:27:09.747 --> 02:27:12.586
<v Mitch Green>Because in Seattle they did that and they paid for an upgrade.

1386
02:27:12.876 --> 02:27:15.923
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, thank you for just naming this for one second.

1387
02:27:15.987 --> 02:27:33.661
<v Donnie Oliveira>So I just want to use the moment to say for Council, one of the important stage gates of this August moment is that if we don't land on a term sheet with with you all that you agree to, that the Blazers sign off on, which you're also signaling to us, is that we pivot into a future without an NBA franchise.

1388
02:27:33.709 --> 02:27:34.665
<v Donnie Oliveira>We still have a WNBA franchise.

1389
02:27:35.280 --> 02:27:41.770
<v Donnie Oliveira>We still have, you know, an arena that needs to have, you know, but that's— we have to start thinking about that world.

1390
02:27:41.834 --> 02:27:42.656
<v Donnie Oliveira>I don't think that's going to happen.

1391
02:27:42.703 --> 02:27:48.101
<v Donnie Oliveira>I'm just saying that is part of this process, is understanding what the direction of the Moda Center.

1392
02:27:48.504 --> 02:27:48.697
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1393
02:27:48.761 --> 02:27:54.051
<v Mitch Green>And I just think, as, you know, as the state's doing their independent economic analysis and we're refreshing ours.

1394
02:27:54.806 --> 02:28:02.940
<v Mitch Green>That does seem like part of the broad stack of cost-benefit analysis when we think about the discounted cash flow, the long-term total cost and benefits.

1395
02:28:02.987 --> 02:28:04.864
<v Mitch Green>So I hope that's part of the consideration.

1396
02:28:04.913 --> 02:28:05.329
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1397
02:28:06.356 --> 02:28:07.127
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1398
02:28:07.239 --> 02:28:08.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1399
02:28:09.388 --> 02:28:10.432
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1400
02:28:10.673 --> 02:28:14.331
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thanks for getting this scheduled as well.

1401
02:28:14.442 --> 02:28:15.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, CA Lee, thanks for being here.

1402
02:28:15.502 --> 02:28:17.459
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, Mayor Wilson, uh, for coming back.

1403
02:28:17.731 --> 02:28:20.459
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Chris and Laura, Appreciate the information.

1404
02:28:20.540 --> 02:28:24.968
<v Sameer Kanal>And Kristen, I really appreciate you taking this work on, uh, in support of, of the council here on this.

1405
02:28:25.754 --> 02:28:28.095
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'm a District 2 councilor.

1406
02:28:28.256 --> 02:28:29.138
<v Sameer Kanal>This is in District 2.

1407
02:28:29.379 --> 02:28:30.439
<v Sameer Kanal>I support public ownership.

1408
02:28:30.566 --> 02:28:32.587
<v Sameer Kanal>I support public investment in public assets.

1409
02:28:32.668 --> 02:28:35.476
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm a Blazer fan who's gone to Moda since the Rose Garden was new.

1410
02:28:36.038 --> 02:28:42.599
<v Sameer Kanal>I also strongly defend, defend the will of the voters to determine what PSF dollars go to, and I don't believe an elected official should overturn that.

1411
02:28:42.951 --> 02:28:44.509
<v Sameer Kanal>I also know the fiscal crisis we're in as a city.

1412
02:28:44.573 --> 02:28:44.717
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1413
02:28:45.246 --> 02:28:47.638
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other spending priorities we could spend this money on.

1414
02:28:47.832 --> 02:28:54.656
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also know that one of the reasons our commercial spaces sit empty around the city is that commercial landlords in this city expect tenants to improve their own spaces too.

1415
02:28:55.941 --> 02:29:08.834
<v Sameer Kanal>Put another way, I'm aware of the nuances and complexities of this conversation decision point, and I'm approaching this issue with interest in the details and not big picture statements because I want to come up with the best possible option and then determine if I can support it or not.

1416
02:29:08.962 --> 02:29:10.038
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1417
02:29:10.792 --> 02:29:12.576
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a publicly owned arena in the district.

1418
02:29:12.656 --> 02:29:21.165
<v Sameer Kanal>It's situated near to 2 other parts of our district which have potential large-scale changes and historical underinvestment too, Lloyd and the convention center.

1419
02:29:21.554 --> 02:29:25.210
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's all contextualized by them being historically underinvested in Albina.

1420
02:29:26.731 --> 02:29:39.344
<v Sameer Kanal>The activities across not just Moda but the Rose Quarter are core parts of the community, from El Grito in mid-September on the plaza celebrating Mexican heritage to the Winterhawks at VMC to professional basketball as well as Uh, concerts inside Moda itself.

1421
02:29:39.394 --> 02:29:50.484
<v Sameer Kanal>And so different parts of the community access different types of events, not just Portlanders but people from across the whole region, which in theory should be able to— we should be able to build a situation where that's money flowing in.

1422
02:29:51.317 --> 02:30:01.621
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the building does have needs to keep it as is, to keep up with the evolving needs of the activities that use it, or to be up to the level of a new venue that would host professional basketball as well as concerts.

1423
02:30:01.670 --> 02:30:04.494
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I think that that's a third tier that That hasn't been discussed here.

1424
02:30:04.815 --> 02:30:11.790
<v Sameer Kanal>We're comparing the, the FCA, which is really keep the arena the way it is, and we're talking about like a wish list from one tenant.

1425
02:30:11.870 --> 02:30:18.444
<v Sameer Kanal>But there is also that the needs evolve over time, and so keeping the arena as, as it is is falling behind.

1426
02:30:18.701 --> 02:30:26.976
<v Sameer Kanal>It's maybe not as much as it would be to do the, the as good as a brand new arena, but there is a middle place that we have to navigate as well.

1427
02:30:27.825 --> 02:30:36.881
<v Sameer Kanal>And the needs that we know of are in bathrooms and cracks cement and accessibility and rigging, moving away from the diesel generators that unionized IATSE members have to work and breathe around.

1428
02:30:37.859 --> 02:30:39.878
<v Sameer Kanal>There are also some parts that are more publicly visible as well.

1429
02:30:40.791 --> 02:30:42.281
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously, we can't bankrupt the city to do it.

1430
02:30:42.329 --> 02:30:44.109
<v Sameer Kanal>We can't overturn election outcomes to do it.

1431
02:30:44.236 --> 02:30:49.333
<v Sameer Kanal>We can't have this not be a good financial investment or not good for the community beyond just the governmental balance sheets.

1432
02:30:50.085 --> 02:30:53.852
<v Sameer Kanal>We can't set ourselves up for failure on future conversations because we tied our hands here.

1433
02:30:54.509 --> 02:30:56.063
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think those are consensus positions in the city.

1434
02:30:56.111 --> 02:30:56.238
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1435
02:30:56.415 --> 02:30:57.007
<v Sameer Kanal>What I just said.

1436
02:30:57.073 --> 02:30:58.547
<v Sameer Kanal>It's just about, does this apply here?

1437
02:30:58.834 --> 02:31:00.277
<v Sameer Kanal>And if so, what do we do about it?

1438
02:31:01.398 --> 02:31:06.190
<v Sameer Kanal>But separate from the content, I just have to say this process has been terrible for city councilors and for the public.

1439
02:31:07.326 --> 02:31:11.700
<v Sameer Kanal>Mr. Mayor, we should have been brought in last year, ideally by early November when Project Mount Hood was convened.

1440
02:31:12.358 --> 02:31:30.174
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't love reading in the paper that an executive in residence at Oregon State University's College of Business, representatives from other governments, and more were brought in, but not city councilors, especially those who represent the area were on the council when we bought the Moda, chair the committee that deals with our economy, and/or have PhDs in economics.

1441
02:31:30.351 --> 02:31:33.163
<v Sameer Kanal>I think all of those are pretty valuable skill sets to have here.

1442
02:31:33.772 --> 02:31:39.878
<v Sameer Kanal>We need time to do this, and we would need that time even if this was a backroom conversation with just the people on this side of the dais.

1443
02:31:40.295 --> 02:31:48.135
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't think that we really have the time to do that right now, let alone the actual responsibility we have, which is to do this conversation in public and bring our community into the conversation.

1444
02:31:48.729 --> 02:32:00.493
<v Sameer Kanal>And just to put a finer point on that, I'm frustrated when I hear that in August, if we don't land on a term sheet with you all that you agreed to, that the Blazers sign off on, that it would signal to us that we pivot to a future without an NBA franchise.

1445
02:32:01.246 --> 02:32:02.481
<v Sameer Kanal>That is putting a gun to our head.

1446
02:32:03.236 --> 02:32:12.043
<v Sameer Kanal>And I really, really do not appreciate that because the clock for y'all has started, but it hasn't started for us because we still don't have the information we need.

1447
02:32:13.183 --> 02:32:15.989
<v Sameer Kanal>We don't have the information necessary to start the clock.

1448
02:32:16.406 --> 02:32:18.845
<v Sameer Kanal>And so what I'm calling for here is a reset.

1449
02:32:19.119 --> 02:32:23.433
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm asking for us to start from the top because this is the first time today the council is discussing this.

1450
02:32:24.253 --> 02:32:31.343
<v Sameer Kanal>Recently, a colleague of ours said good process means sitting down, figuring out the math, and keeping the public informed and empowered every step of the way.

1451
02:32:31.888 --> 02:32:32.995
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, let's do that.

1452
02:32:33.092 --> 02:32:34.777
<v Sameer Kanal>Please, God, let's do that.

1453
02:32:35.483 --> 02:32:47.403
<v Sameer Kanal>And the best way to do that is to center the city council within this government on this issue, because public trust in, quote, the city has been hurt immensely by what's been done so far by one part of this government, up to and including an email yesterday.

1454
02:32:49.281 --> 02:32:58.358
<v Sameer Kanal>Pivoting back, it's hard for me to describe my goals because I know saying I support an arena renovation absent context will be spun as saying I support defunding PSF or something.

1455
02:32:58.438 --> 02:33:03.593
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm not going to call it as goals in that way, but I'm going to describe a realistic vision and also not a perfect world.

1456
02:33:04.139 --> 02:33:07.931
<v Sameer Kanal>I want a first-class publicly owned arena with the Blazers, the Fire, and big concerts.

1457
02:33:08.316 --> 02:33:11.095
<v Sameer Kanal>I want it and the plaza activated 300+ days a year.

1458
02:33:11.449 --> 02:33:13.006
<v Sameer Kanal>I want it to benefit the uppercase city.

1459
02:33:13.457 --> 02:33:15.158
<v Sameer Kanal>Through supporting our broader budget.

1460
02:33:15.737 --> 02:33:18.740
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to benefit the lowercase city through good jobs that build our tax base.

1461
02:33:19.495 --> 02:33:24.972
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to support the local community and businesses, including through the rebuilding of a historically Black neighborhood in Albina.

1462
02:33:25.423 --> 02:33:27.816
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to not bankrupt, literally or figuratively, the city.

1463
02:33:28.411 --> 02:33:32.394
<v Sameer Kanal>I want any money we use to honor the restrictions voters gave us in ballot measures.

1464
02:33:32.907 --> 02:33:36.875
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want people to look at this deal and see a good deal for the city and our tenants.

1465
02:33:37.084 --> 02:33:45.180
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's possible for both of us because it is It's time we stop talking about Portland like we have to tolerate being here.

1466
02:33:45.677 --> 02:33:48.328
<v Sameer Kanal>We love being here, and I think everybody should too.

1467
02:33:49.356 --> 02:33:51.430
<v Sameer Kanal>And, and if I think as people dig into it, they will.

1468
02:33:52.425 --> 02:33:54.400
<v Sameer Kanal>So yeah, councilors need more information.

1469
02:33:54.497 --> 02:34:01.197
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's frankly astonishing that we've been talking about a potential renovation for more than 6 months and still haven't received the detailed list of what the city's money would pay for.

1470
02:34:01.727 --> 02:34:06.048
<v Sameer Kanal>I've been asking for several months in executive sessions, and I want to be clear, I do not want renderings.

1471
02:34:06.111 --> 02:34:06.289
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1472
02:34:07.269 --> 02:34:08.537
<v Sameer Kanal>I do not want narratives.

1473
02:34:09.114 --> 02:34:10.897
<v Sameer Kanal>I want numbers and I want spreadsheets.

1474
02:34:11.282 --> 02:34:11.603
<v Sameer Kanal>That's it.

1475
02:34:11.877 --> 02:34:13.594
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not asking for big fancy drawings.

1476
02:34:14.574 --> 02:34:19.841
<v Sameer Kanal>We need to keep doing engagement because like the council, the public has not felt informed nor empowered through this process.

1477
02:34:20.434 --> 02:34:25.219
<v Sameer Kanal>We had to fight to get the public survey open longer than a week, and I'm very grateful that Laura was able to do that.

1478
02:34:25.990 --> 02:34:27.323
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not how you empower Portlanders.

1479
02:34:27.435 --> 02:34:37.888
<v Sameer Kanal>In the absence of transparent leadership from the administration, members of council have communicated directly with constituents through newsletters, town halls, and social media because smart communicators reach people where they already spend their time.

1480
02:34:38.659 --> 02:34:54.122
<v Sameer Kanal>So I expect to see more transparency and community outreach from the administration over the coming months because it's a very big decision involving very big sums of money, and the public has made it clear that they care deeply about it and want their voices not only heard in the sense of it entered our ears, but that it informed decision-making.

1481
02:34:55.118 --> 02:35:00.079
<v Sameer Kanal>An artificially compressed timeline does not increase the likelihood of support, it diminishes it.

1482
02:35:01.236 --> 02:35:10.195
<v Sameer Kanal>We've heard that the state has a December deadline, and I, I want to pursue the question of, is there potential for the state to secure that funding on a different timeline that gives us a little more flexibility?

1483
02:35:10.275 --> 02:35:12.412
<v Sameer Kanal>We're not talking about years, we're talking about months here.

1484
02:35:13.038 --> 02:35:17.388
<v Sameer Kanal>We should have a conversation about to what degree having more time might facilitate a better outcome.

1485
02:35:18.817 --> 02:35:27.677
<v Sameer Kanal>On the content, I have 4 big concerns: financial return, PSF, maintaining public ownership of assets beyond just the Moda, and I agree with the mayor.

1486
02:35:27.806 --> 02:35:30.018
<v Sameer Kanal>The future of the Moda Center must be decided on the numbers.

1487
02:35:30.450 --> 02:35:32.326
<v Sameer Kanal>The investment would need to see a monetary return.

1488
02:35:32.375 --> 02:35:38.418
<v Sameer Kanal>We're not in the financial position of the city to move forward with a 9-figure deal that doesn't generate or free up substantial revenue.

1489
02:35:38.611 --> 02:35:40.149
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with Councilor Green on this.

1490
02:35:40.470 --> 02:35:45.648
<v Sameer Kanal>We must retain some of the money this brings in, not just put it all back into investments made in the Moda over time.

1491
02:35:46.162 --> 02:35:48.518
<v Sameer Kanal>The level of private contributions need to be made clear.

1492
02:35:49.288 --> 02:35:50.939
<v Sameer Kanal>Just people need to understand that, including us.

1493
02:35:51.003 --> 02:35:51.259
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1494
02:35:51.340 --> 02:35:53.940
<v Sameer Kanal>And have incredible economic impact analysis.

1495
02:35:53.940 --> 02:35:58.079
<v Sameer Kanal>And by the way, I'm not as pessimistic as some of my colleagues are, I think, on that particular thing.

1496
02:35:58.079 --> 02:36:01.030
<v Sameer Kanal>But regardless of whether we're optimistic or pessimistic, we just need the numbers.

1497
02:36:02.719 --> 02:36:04.280
<v Sameer Kanal>Secondly, we must honor the will of the voters.

1498
02:36:04.280 --> 02:36:09.840
<v Sameer Kanal>If an expense is not PCF-able, there's no conversation here for me about using PCF dollars for it, in my view.

1499
02:36:09.840 --> 02:36:13.819
<v Sameer Kanal>And if they are PCF-able, there's a conversation, but that's not necessarily a yes.

1500
02:36:13.819 --> 02:36:20.920
<v Sameer Kanal>We need to have the conversation about trade-offs and the opportunity costs of funding sources because those dollars are currently spoken for in the climate investment plan.

1501
02:36:20.920 --> 02:36:20.959
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1502
02:36:21.175 --> 02:36:29.559
<v Sameer Kanal>And whether you're hearing this issue or someone on a street corner is trying to get you to sign something, people need to know that every dollar of PSEF is committed.

1503
02:36:29.929 --> 02:36:31.647
<v Sameer Kanal>It is not just sitting there unused.

1504
02:36:32.498 --> 02:36:33.686
<v Sameer Kanal>That doesn't mean we can't move it around.

1505
02:36:34.763 --> 02:36:36.256
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think we should have that conversation.

1506
02:36:36.369 --> 02:36:42.631
<v Sameer Kanal>The mayor said this week that if the PSEF committee doesn't support using PSEF resources for the renovation, we should find another funding source.

1507
02:36:42.953 --> 02:36:44.977
<v Sameer Kanal>I really appreciate him arriving at that position.

1508
02:36:45.024 --> 02:36:45.683
<v Sameer Kanal>It's one I share.

1509
02:36:46.727 --> 02:36:50.261
<v Sameer Kanal>Third, we must retain majority ownership of the Moda Center even as we continue to expand it.

1510
02:36:50.308 --> 02:36:50.405
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1511
02:36:50.469 --> 02:36:52.637
<v Sameer Kanal>Continue to negotiate with the state on the joint authority.

1512
02:36:53.230 --> 02:36:59.990
<v Sameer Kanal>And we can't tie our hands in this arrangement by committing financial streams here that we will need for Providence Park in the future.

1513
02:37:00.761 --> 02:37:10.988
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just want to make that clear because right now more money goes into Providence Park than it generates, and that is made up for by this fund, the Spectator Venues Fund.

1514
02:37:11.439 --> 02:37:13.461
<v Sameer Kanal>And then there must, of course, be robust community benefits.

1515
02:37:13.525 --> 02:37:16.047
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think we could go through all of those, and I'll mention a couple.

1516
02:37:16.977 --> 02:37:20.649
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the best deal does share costs with our regional partners.

1517
02:37:21.387 --> 02:37:25.108
<v Sameer Kanal>I think this building is going to need renovations at some point no matter what.

1518
02:37:25.653 --> 02:37:34.087
<v Sameer Kanal>A proposal at a larger scale that splits those costs with the state and county could actually save the city government money as compared to a smaller scale proposal where the city foots the bill alone.

1519
02:37:34.552 --> 02:37:35.514
<v Sameer Kanal>Colleagues have mentioned that.

1520
02:37:36.958 --> 02:37:45.497
<v Sameer Kanal>An agreement is good for the city if it has meaningful benefit for the surrounding area and for all Portlanders, not just just those who patronize or patronize the Moda Center.

1521
02:37:47.305 --> 02:37:56.075
<v Sameer Kanal>So I mentioned not giving up a majority ownership stake, having a strong ROI, jobs, strong union jobs, not only through construction.

1522
02:37:56.125 --> 02:37:58.697
<v Sameer Kanal>And by the way, we need to make sure that the contractors are local.

1523
02:37:59.522 --> 02:38:04.182
<v Sameer Kanal>That hasn't really been mentioned yet, I don't think, in this space, but I know it's been mentioned behind the scenes.

1524
02:38:04.619 --> 02:38:11.209
<v Sameer Kanal>Also for ongoing employment and labor peace, prioritizing necessary improvements, not using public dollars to to fund premium perks and upgrades.

1525
02:38:11.886 --> 02:38:15.625
<v Sameer Kanal>And the survey results make that clear that that's a community position as well.

1526
02:38:16.784 --> 02:38:20.516
<v Sameer Kanal>Not violating the will of the voters by using PCF dollars that aren't for things that aren't PCF-able.

1527
02:38:21.224 --> 02:38:22.766
<v Sameer Kanal>Committing the team to staying at the Moda Center.

1528
02:38:22.831 --> 02:38:29.105
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wrote down for at least 20 additional years because this 20-year agreement thing has really been floated as 17, right?

1529
02:38:29.185 --> 02:38:33.353
<v Sameer Kanal>We have an agreement through 2030 and it's been about 2027 to 2047.

1530
02:38:33.498 --> 02:38:35.421
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's been floated as 20, but it's been 17.

1531
02:38:35.469 --> 02:38:36.019
<v Sameer Kanal>17.

1532
02:38:37.274 --> 02:38:42.356
<v Sameer Kanal>But actually, I just agree with Councilor Ryan that it should be 30 and we should be done with it and have it go longer.

1533
02:38:42.436 --> 02:38:44.341
<v Sameer Kanal>I just really appreciate that, Councilor Ryan.

1534
02:38:44.388 --> 02:38:45.486
<v Dan Ryan>I'm glad you like the direction though.

1535
02:38:45.584 --> 02:38:45.825
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

1536
02:38:45.906 --> 02:38:46.441
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's great.

1537
02:38:46.700 --> 02:38:47.022
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1538
02:38:47.913 --> 02:38:57.073
<v Sameer Kanal>And obviously I think we've already talked about it, but a penalty for breaching that, you know, for relocating, for example, which is so big as to, you know, stop it in its tracks.

1539
02:38:59.420 --> 02:39:00.840
<v Sameer Kanal>Mentioned the Providence Park trade-offs.

1540
02:39:01.957 --> 02:39:04.043
<v Sameer Kanal>Putting in writing who's responsible for cost overruns.

1541
02:39:04.711 --> 02:39:05.968
<v Sameer Kanal>I know this has been mentioned.

1542
02:39:06.016 --> 02:39:07.484
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to just put that out in the daylight.

1543
02:39:09.628 --> 02:39:11.756
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to host a WNBA All-Star Game.

1544
02:39:12.352 --> 02:39:14.949
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to host an NBA All-Star Game.

1545
02:39:15.013 --> 02:39:17.479
<v Sameer Kanal>Portland is one of two cities that hasn't hosted an NBA All-Star Game.

1546
02:39:17.593 --> 02:39:19.166
<v Sameer Kanal>Two franchises, four cities.

1547
02:39:20.404 --> 02:39:22.764
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think that's an important thing as well.

1548
02:39:23.376 --> 02:39:25.576
<v Sameer Kanal>And then in terms of community benefits, I think we could get into it.

1549
02:39:25.625 --> 02:39:26.829
<v Sameer Kanal>We probably should at some point.

1550
02:39:27.070 --> 02:39:27.199
<v Sameer Kanal>We should.

1551
02:39:27.309 --> 02:39:37.713
<v Sameer Kanal>Talk about all the Albina Vision Trust needs and the things that, that the tenants, the management company, would be providing as a benefit to the AVT and to the neighborhood.

1552
02:39:38.244 --> 02:39:40.235
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we should obviously talk about street-level pricing too.

1553
02:39:40.572 --> 02:39:47.396
<v Sameer Kanal>Access to the ice rink for the public at VMC has not been mentioned, and I think that's something we should, we should explore as well.

1554
02:39:47.958 --> 02:39:52.759
<v Sameer Kanal>And I definitely want to put on the table the conversation around the development rights in the area and the naming rights for the stadium.

1555
02:39:53.576 --> 02:40:00.563
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that we're going to have to have that conversation anyway because Moda may have different priorities now that they're pivoting as a business, the company Moda.

1556
02:40:01.283 --> 02:40:08.479
<v Sameer Kanal>So getting out of the insurance game might mean that they're less interested in, in having those naming rights, so that the timing might be appropriate to have a conversation there.

1557
02:40:09.281 --> 02:40:10.018
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's a lot.

1558
02:40:10.242 --> 02:40:11.476
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to get it all out there.

1559
02:40:11.540 --> 02:40:16.667
<v Sameer Kanal>I apologize, but we've, uh, we've been waiting several months, uh, and, uh, so I wanted to get that on there.

1560
02:40:17.068 --> 02:40:34.281
<v Sameer Kanal>I did want to, um, just I'd like to just for future, not for today, ask if we can get a definitive answer on has there ever been an ask from the city executive or administrative branches to any tenants or management companies to contribute private funding.

1561
02:40:35.034 --> 02:40:38.853
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't— I have not gotten a yes or no on that, if there has been an ask given.

1562
02:40:39.913 --> 02:40:48.898
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd like to know when the economic— the FCA basically is going to— if that's going to be part of the update or if there's a separate thing coming to bring that forward.

1563
02:40:49.638 --> 02:40:58.752
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd like to know how the community benefits agreement, if there's any constraints on your ability to negotiate that based on the mayor's executive order about DEI.

1564
02:41:00.670 --> 02:41:14.577
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'd like to understand the amount of time to me between when we get the itemized list and July 30th, which is the first time we hear it in the Committee of the Whole.

1565
02:41:15.156 --> 02:41:16.199
<v Sameer Kanal>That is our clock.

1566
02:41:17.226 --> 02:41:21.575
<v Sameer Kanal>I feel like we're— I don't know what— this is going to be a terrible metaphor— subbing into the game late.

1567
02:41:21.960 --> 02:41:25.346
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, we're already down, starting the game in the 3rd quarter, whatever metaphor you want to use.

1568
02:41:25.427 --> 02:41:26.390
<v Sameer Kanal>We're starting it late.

1569
02:41:26.791 --> 02:41:30.033
<v Sameer Kanal>But of course, Novick, you appreciate that more.

1570
02:41:31.511 --> 02:41:31.686
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1571
02:41:32.328 --> 02:41:40.027
<v Sameer Kanal>I think just understand, the public should understand this too, the clock starts for us when we get the numbers, and we don't have the numbers yet.

1572
02:41:40.827 --> 02:41:41.165
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1573
02:41:41.388 --> 02:41:42.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1574
02:41:42.912 --> 02:41:43.471
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1575
02:41:44.176 --> 02:41:51.147
<v Steve Novick>First of all, I need to add to Councilor Kanal's comment that, look, we're not the New York Knicks, so we can't afford to start in the 4th quarter.

1576
02:41:51.227 --> 02:41:52.766
<v Steve Novick>We're down by 17 points.

1577
02:41:54.129 --> 02:42:03.762
<v Steve Novick>So I have to express my great appreciation to Councilor Koyama Lane, because to my shame, I was not aware about the provision in the bridge lease that she was talking about.

1578
02:42:04.147 --> 02:42:11.405
<v Steve Novick>But now that I'm looking at it, or at least a document that summarizes— purports to summarize it, my one-word reaction is yowza.

1579
02:42:12.255 --> 02:42:29.837
<v Steve Novick>Because if it's true that Rift City will continue to have full responsibility for operating Moda Center and funding and completing Moda Center capital repair, maintenance, and improvement projects and maintaining the arena in a first-class manner, well, I thought the whole point of this $600 million investment was to make it a first-class arena.

1580
02:42:30.254 --> 02:42:33.177
<v Steve Novick>So why haven't we filed a lawsuit asking for $600 million?

1581
02:42:34.558 --> 02:42:37.209
<v Steve Novick>And I say that playfully but not lightly.

1582
02:42:37.643 --> 02:42:39.843
<v Steve Novick>So forget all the other requests I have.

1583
02:42:39.954 --> 02:42:48.096
<v Steve Novick>My one request is to sit down with whoever in the City Attorney's Office has evaluated the value of that provision and find out why we haven't filed the lawsuit.

1584
02:42:48.627 --> 02:42:52.610
<v Steve Novick>So can you hook up— hook me up with whoever in the City Attorney's Office I should talk to about that?

1585
02:42:53.670 --> 02:42:54.986
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, we will check in.

1586
02:42:55.355 --> 02:42:57.505
<v Donnie Oliveira>Ken McGare is our attorney on this one.

1587
02:42:57.682 --> 02:42:58.596
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1588
02:42:59.527 --> 02:43:17.398
<v Steve Novick>And also I wanted to add that, as I mentioned this to Councilor Green earlier and he thought I should bring it up, one thing that we should consider is a championship reward/penalty that if the city puts any money in, then we should get it back if the team doesn't win the NBA championship in 10 years.

1589
02:43:17.992 --> 02:43:21.408
<v Steve Novick>I mean, Tom Dunant has already proved he can win championships, so he should be able to do it again.

1590
02:43:24.005 --> 02:43:24.904
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1591
02:43:25.609 --> 02:43:27.371
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1592
02:43:27.996 --> 02:43:33.013
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President, and my apologies, colleagues, for being late both this morning and this afternoon.

1593
02:43:33.766 --> 02:43:36.844
<v Olivia Clark>I'm sorry I missed the earlier comments.

1594
02:43:37.453 --> 02:43:39.682
<v Olivia Clark>I thought the results of the survey were really interesting.

1595
02:43:40.274 --> 02:43:45.355
<v Olivia Clark>They were validating in some regards, especially on the renovation priorities and community benefits.

1596
02:43:46.286 --> 02:43:52.751
<v Olivia Clark>But I'm hearing a lot of things here that I really resonate with that are interesting.

1597
02:43:53.007 --> 02:43:54.516
<v Olivia Clark>Others, I'm not as much.

1598
02:43:55.031 --> 02:44:01.453
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm wondering if the staff— are you taking all of this and putting it in some kind of a chart that we can all review?

1599
02:44:01.533 --> 02:44:05.468
<v Olivia Clark>Because there's been a lot of stuff here just in the, you know, last 45 minutes.

1600
02:44:06.575 --> 02:44:07.731
<v Kristen Dennis>Yes, Councilor Clark, thank you.

1601
02:44:08.132 --> 02:44:15.004
<v Kristen Dennis>Yeah, just in terms of process, that's exactly what— I'll be working with the staff, but I'll be responsible for making sure that we have that all together for you.

1602
02:44:15.422 --> 02:44:16.272
<v Kristen Dennis>It's going to do a few things.

1603
02:44:16.319 --> 02:44:20.728
<v Kristen Dennis>One, be a tool for you all, but also for the public to see as we progress.

1604
02:44:20.792 --> 02:44:30.331
<v Kristen Dennis>This is again kind of a starting point where council is going to say this is you're putting out the the goal, and then we're going to figure out how close we can we can get there in the term sheet.

1605
02:44:31.277 --> 02:44:32.879
<v Kristen Dennis>And so that'll be very helpful.

1606
02:44:33.137 --> 02:44:40.655
<v Kristen Dennis>And then you'll be meeting with me quite a bit in the resulting next few weeks as I work with you on some of this.

1607
02:44:40.719 --> 02:44:42.165
<v Kristen Dennis>Specific terms and tools.

1608
02:44:42.212 --> 02:44:47.462
<v Kristen Dennis>Sorry, we weren't able to get into deep into the tools, but we'll be working through that so that I can meet with you all individually.

1609
02:44:47.799 --> 02:44:56.004
<v Kristen Dennis>I want to acknowledge, and I have to do this in my other job at the Metro City Council, the limits that you have in being able to talk to each other.

1610
02:44:56.149 --> 02:44:57.417
<v Kristen Dennis>It makes it very challenging.

1611
02:44:57.514 --> 02:45:03.520
<v Kristen Dennis>So that's an added challenge on top of all the challenges you already discussed in terms of getting working on this timeline.

1612
02:45:04.113 --> 02:45:16.333
<v Kristen Dennis>But that's one of the reasons why I'm the So you'll be spending a lot of time with me, and so I'll be able to have one-on-one conversations with you and then figure out when, how we, how often we need to have you guys all together.

1613
02:45:16.397 --> 02:45:22.193
<v Olivia Clark>Well, I think you're summarizing everything that you've heard here in the list and letting us look at that list.

1614
02:45:22.337 --> 02:45:26.881
<v Olivia Clark>And I don't know if we're going to prioritize things because I don't think we all agree on everything.

1615
02:45:27.299 --> 02:45:30.447
<v Olivia Clark>We agree on a lot of things, but I'll be really interested in seeing that.

1616
02:45:31.378 --> 02:45:31.987
<v Olivia Clark>And I think that's a good way to do it.

1617
02:45:32.132 --> 02:45:35.775
<v Olivia Clark>We— this came up very briefly in our discussion of Public Works.

1618
02:45:36.001 --> 02:45:48.263
<v Olivia Clark>It was just yesterday on asset management, and I've already talked to you, Kristen, about how I feel about this, that, you know, we have so many venues, um, like the Schnitz and the Keller and the Moda that need help.

1619
02:45:48.808 --> 02:45:55.485
<v Olivia Clark>And I think what's unique here is that we're getting outside help to pay for something that we own and that we need to fix up.

1620
02:45:56.063 --> 02:45:59.592
<v Olivia Clark>So having that 3-to-1 match That for me is so important.

1621
02:46:00.538 --> 02:46:05.395
<v Olivia Clark>We're not going to get that in any other assets that we have that need updating.

1622
02:46:06.452 --> 02:46:08.568
<v Olivia Clark>I also don't feel like I have a gun at my head.

1623
02:46:08.632 --> 02:46:16.584
<v Olivia Clark>I just want to say I do feel that this is a challenge and it's an opportunity, and it's one I think we can meet, folks.

1624
02:46:16.888 --> 02:46:21.619
<v Olivia Clark>My colleagues, I really feel like, you know, the public is not smiling on us right now.

1625
02:46:21.843 --> 02:46:22.789
<v Olivia Clark>We've got a pretty low rating.

1626
02:46:22.836 --> 02:46:23.029
<v Olivia Clark>I agree.

1627
02:46:23.927 --> 02:46:26.606
<v Olivia Clark>Our reputation is really suffering out in the public.

1628
02:46:26.671 --> 02:46:39.378
<v Olivia Clark>So I think that, you know, if we can approach this as an opportunity and show the public that we can actually come to a good decision here and we can come to it in the time that we have available, we're going to be winning, you know, in multiple ways.

1629
02:46:39.425 --> 02:46:42.891
<v Olivia Clark>So I'll share my other comments with you later for your chart.

1630
02:46:43.020 --> 02:46:44.399
<v Olivia Clark>But thank you for all the work.

1631
02:46:44.543 --> 02:46:45.298
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for being here.

1632
02:46:45.361 --> 02:46:46.181
<v Olivia Clark>And thank you for the work.

1633
02:46:46.245 --> 02:46:47.384
<v Olivia Clark>And thank you for the survey.

1634
02:46:47.528 --> 02:46:48.506
<v Kristen Dennis>Councilor Smith.

1635
02:46:48.876 --> 02:46:49.853
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1636
02:46:50.094 --> 02:46:50.784
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1637
02:46:51.298 --> 02:46:51.763
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1638
02:46:53.143 --> 02:46:58.388
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Vice President Clark, we still have a higher percentage approval than the last council.

1639
02:46:58.836 --> 02:46:59.494
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Let's remember that.

1640
02:46:59.702 --> 02:46:59.815
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yep.

1641
02:47:01.066 --> 02:47:18.136
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>As folks were talking about the 20-year versus 30 years, making sure the Blazers stay here, that did make me think about, and I heard some murmurings too, of raising the penalty of if they leave and what that could look like if there's an ability to claw back Ideally fully.

1642
02:47:20.924 --> 02:47:28.672
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And also just want to say on the record, I'd be interested in having a briefing, a meeting like this that has the county here too.

1643
02:47:29.028 --> 02:47:30.386
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So just want to put that on the record.

1644
02:47:30.645 --> 02:47:31.502
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, that's it.

1645
02:47:32.472 --> 02:47:33.426
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1646
02:47:33.620 --> 02:47:34.898
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

1647
02:47:35.237 --> 02:47:36.174
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks, Council President.

1648
02:47:36.609 --> 02:47:39.976
<v Angelita Morillo>I have follow-up questions about the bridge lease aspect.

1649
02:47:40.411 --> 02:47:49.158
<v Angelita Morillo>So is the reason that we haven't sued on the first class item because the bridge lease says that we're not holding them to that requirement right now?

1650
02:47:51.931 --> 02:47:59.657
<v Carl Lyle>Yeah, so during the bridge agreement negotiations, the parties agreed to not enforce that at the time of the lease extension.

1651
02:47:59.835 --> 02:48:01.398
<v Carl Lyle>It still remains enforced in the agreement.

1652
02:48:01.462 --> 02:48:09.625
<v Carl Lyle>So, you know, if they, if they, you know, are to— if they break the existing lease or it expires at the end of the lease, it's absolutely enforceable.

1653
02:48:09.881 --> 02:48:10.588
<v Carl Lyle>And I'm not an attorney.

1654
02:48:10.876 --> 02:48:15.019
<v Carl Lyle>This is my understanding, and our attorney is sick today, so we'll get him back up here next time.

1655
02:48:16.031 --> 02:48:29.856
<v Carl Lyle>But, but yeah, we agreed to proceed in good faith through the bridge agreement, and the intention of the bridge agreement was to create that time and space for the parties to bring in additional funding partners to get us to a bigger deal.

1656
02:48:29.921 --> 02:48:42.762
<v Carl Lyle>Because the original ask starting the bridge agreement conversation was for a large city investment in a renovation that was beyond the scope of the okay, and the lease ends when exactly?

1657
02:48:43.456 --> 02:48:44.764
<v Carl Lyle>October of 2030.

1658
02:48:45.507 --> 02:48:49.093
<v Angelita Morillo>So that's when we could technically sue for the first-class requirement?

1659
02:48:50.959 --> 02:48:56.179
<v Carl Lyle>Yeah, actually, I mean, we would need to talk to the attorneys about whether we could choose for some reason to do that at any time.

1660
02:48:56.244 --> 02:48:56.825
<v Angelita Morillo>Just curious.

1661
02:48:56.873 --> 02:48:57.827
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not threatening lawsuits.

1662
02:48:57.876 --> 02:48:58.959
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not very litigious.

1663
02:49:00.319 --> 02:49:02.021
<v Angelita Morillo>Some councilors are, but they're not here right now.

1664
02:49:04.188 --> 02:49:04.703
<v Angelita Morillo>It's true.

1665
02:49:07.251 --> 02:49:18.718
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to state very clearly that I don't have any appetite whatsoever to, you know, change requirements on the first-class maintenance aspect of this.

1666
02:49:19.219 --> 02:49:23.485
<v Angelita Morillo>And I actually hope that we include that in any and all future contracts moving forward.

1667
02:49:25.325 --> 02:49:26.457
<v Angelita Morillo>Mm-hmm.

1668
02:49:26.539 --> 02:49:28.984
<v Angelita Morillo>But I think you've heard a lot of interest on the bridge lease agreement.

1669
02:49:29.557 --> 02:49:36.189
<v Angelita Morillo>And the first-class requirements, because a lot of this discussion is that the building is not at all in first-class condition right now.

1670
02:49:36.995 --> 02:49:40.198
<v Angelita Morillo>So I don't really understand how they're not in violation of that right now.

1671
02:49:44.395 --> 02:49:46.586
<v Angelita Morillo>Do they owe us a bunch of money right now?

1672
02:49:48.040 --> 02:49:49.354
<v Kristen Dennis>We will get you those answers, Councilor.

1673
02:49:50.020 --> 02:49:54.192
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think this is a good conversation we should have with an attorney and perhaps in an executive session.

1674
02:49:54.727 --> 02:49:54.792
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1675
02:49:55.143 --> 02:49:56.565
<v Angelita Morillo>Can we have an attorney present?

1676
02:49:56.613 --> 02:49:58.471
<v Angelita Morillo>I'll keep adding lists of people that I want here.

1677
02:49:58.699 --> 02:50:00.574
<v Angelita Morillo>I think Mayor Wilson should be here the whole time.

1678
02:50:00.783 --> 02:50:03.579
<v Angelita Morillo>I think our negotiator should be here the whole time.

1679
02:50:03.709 --> 02:50:14.379
<v Angelita Morillo>I think the attorney should be here the whole time, 'cause I don't— I cannot sit in another public session where we don't have the people here to answer those questions.

1680
02:50:16.717 --> 02:50:17.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1681
02:50:18.051 --> 02:50:18.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1682
02:50:21.628 --> 02:50:22.238
<v Candace Avalos>Um, thank you.

1683
02:50:22.432 --> 02:50:24.490
<v Candace Avalos>It's been an interesting discussion.

1684
02:50:24.763 --> 02:50:27.755
<v Candace Avalos>I'm just kind of reflecting on what I'm hearing from my colleagues.

1685
02:50:27.819 --> 02:50:42.093
<v Candace Avalos>I obviously share a lot of the goals, um, that they have stated, um, but I think where I want to draw a finer point and get some confirmation is, for me, a top line is private investment.

1686
02:50:42.658 --> 02:50:43.986
<v Candace Avalos>That is my starting place.

1687
02:50:44.277 --> 02:50:51.666
<v Candace Avalos>I am not interested in fully funding anything at the public's expense without people who have a lot of money paying towards something.

1688
02:50:51.843 --> 02:50:52.951
<v Candace Avalos>I don't care that you bought the Blazers.

1689
02:50:53.306 --> 02:50:54.606
<v Candace Avalos>That is not an investment in the city.

1690
02:50:55.314 --> 02:50:57.193
<v Candace Avalos>And so where does that stand?

1691
02:50:57.242 --> 02:51:00.745
<v Candace Avalos>Because that to me is like the starting line of the negotiation.

1692
02:51:01.323 --> 02:51:04.792
<v Candace Avalos>And I don't really know what has already been said.

1693
02:51:05.259 --> 02:51:07.171
<v Candace Avalos>Has that been, you know, floated?

1694
02:51:07.266 --> 02:51:08.728
<v Candace Avalos>Have they said anything about that?

1695
02:51:08.793 --> 02:51:11.429
<v Candace Avalos>Because that to me is the most urgent priority in this lease.

1696
02:51:11.959 --> 02:51:27.316
<v Donnie Oliveira>So, so, Councilor, uh, we have Actively communicated that the city is interested in a private investment from the team, whether it be a capital investment up front for the renovation, whether it be rent, some of the things we've heard today.

1697
02:51:27.912 --> 02:51:30.707
<v Donnie Oliveira>That has been formally disseminated to the team.

1698
02:51:31.622 --> 02:51:33.358
<v Donnie Oliveira>We have not gotten a response from them on that.

1699
02:51:33.694 --> 02:51:36.683
<v Candace Avalos>And to be clear, I am not counting rent as part of that.

1700
02:51:36.827 --> 02:51:37.453
<v Candace Avalos>Rent is a given.

1701
02:51:37.727 --> 02:51:41.148
<v Candace Avalos>So to me, when I say a private investment, I do mean in the renovation.

1702
02:51:41.229 --> 02:51:43.040
<v Donnie Oliveira>That was just being inclusive of the ask.

1703
02:51:43.103 --> 02:51:52.447
<v Donnie Oliveira>We put out a range of questions to them that were centered around a private stake and whether it be renovation, to your question, or more broadly other revenues.

1704
02:51:53.183 --> 02:51:53.441
<v Donnie Oliveira>Mike Renn.

1705
02:51:53.761 --> 02:51:59.466
<v Carl Lyle>If I could just maybe add, so to date, right, they have not— there's not been any confirmation that they're willing to do that, right?

1706
02:51:59.546 --> 02:52:00.924
<v Carl Lyle>So that's where we are right now.

1707
02:52:01.452 --> 02:52:14.691
<v Carl Lyle>Their response has been the ticket user fees and the parking revenues that are generated and paid to the well, my answer to that is absolutely not.

1708
02:52:14.933 --> 02:52:15.111
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure.

1709
02:52:15.416 --> 02:52:26.040
<v Candace Avalos>So I want to make that clear that I do not accept that response from them, and they need to start speaking to us and to our negotiators about their contribution.

1710
02:52:26.170 --> 02:52:27.788
<v Candace Avalos>I'm not willing to move forward a deal without it.

1711
02:52:28.489 --> 02:52:29.265
<v Candace Avalos>So thanks.

1712
02:52:31.271 --> 02:52:32.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1713
02:52:34.838 --> 02:52:37.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, there's no one else in the queue to ask questions.

1714
02:52:37.229 --> 02:52:47.083
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to just note that my chief of staff just sent around an email to everybody asking for every office to please send any further follow-up questions that you would like answered.

1715
02:52:47.515 --> 02:52:54.834
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm hearing from my colleagues that this is not an opportunity for us to privately send you an email that says the answer, but instead to also make that a public thing.

1716
02:52:54.914 --> 02:52:59.343
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I heard a lot of really great requests and feedback on the process.

1717
02:52:59.855 --> 02:53:05.066
<v Jamie Dunphy>I apologize for any missteps that have happened on my part to this point, and we will continue to drive this home.

1718
02:53:05.179 --> 02:53:10.501
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, Kristen, any last reward— any last comments before we part ways?

1719
02:53:10.837 --> 02:53:14.477
<v Kristen Dennis>I will just say, you know, as I said before, this is a tall order.

1720
02:53:15.406 --> 02:53:17.154
<v Kristen Dennis>You guys have put a lot on the table.

1721
02:53:17.411 --> 02:53:20.537
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm energized, though, by it.

1722
02:53:20.632 --> 02:53:25.009
<v Kristen Dennis>It's a tight timeline, but I've really appreciated the vision that you've all laid out.

1723
02:53:25.090 --> 02:53:25.229
<v Kristen Dennis>Thank you.

1724
02:53:25.229 --> 02:53:28.959
<v Kristen Dennis>So we have a lot of questions that we have laid out for the arena, for the public asset, and for the future of the City of Portland.

1725
02:53:29.549 --> 02:53:40.110
<v Kristen Dennis>And we're going to work to get responses to all of those things and make sure that you are feeling confident in having— making sure you have the information to make a decision very soon.

1726
02:53:40.510 --> 02:53:49.700
<v Kristen Dennis>And I will be spending a lot more time with you all individually, and then we'll figure out the— at the chair's discretion, those additional meetings as well.

1727
02:53:50.620 --> 02:53:51.132
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Kristin.

1728
02:53:51.293 --> 02:53:51.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1729
02:53:51.871 --> 02:53:55.274
<v Candace Avalos>Sorry, I didn't mean to steal the last word from you, but I did have one more thought.

1730
02:53:55.371 --> 02:53:55.916
<v Candace Avalos>You can have it.

1731
02:53:55.966 --> 02:54:14.844
<v Candace Avalos>Just based on what you just said, I think we talked about this before, but I would love for the public page to include things like links to this work session, all of the documents that we're receiving being available, the questions that we get answered, having that be in that place.

1732
02:54:14.957 --> 02:54:17.220
<v Candace Avalos>I just want to see that page be a little more dynamic.

1733
02:54:17.461 --> 02:54:23.290
<v Candace Avalos>To be including all the things that are public, you know, information.

1734
02:54:23.724 --> 02:54:30.484
<v Candace Avalos>They should all live in one place so that when we're talking to constituents, we can point them to that and they could easily click on this and view our discussion, right?

1735
02:54:30.531 --> 02:54:32.250
<v Candace Avalos>Like, I just want that to be more dynamic.

1736
02:54:32.314 --> 02:54:33.373
<v Candace Avalos>So that would be my request.

1737
02:54:33.759 --> 02:54:34.015
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1738
02:54:34.402 --> 02:54:35.413
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1739
02:54:35.605 --> 02:54:35.942
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1740
02:54:36.006 --> 02:54:36.424
<v Kristen Dennis>That's right.

1741
02:54:36.488 --> 02:54:38.592
<v Kristen Dennis>I need to take the last word back for Councilor Avalos.

1742
02:54:38.640 --> 02:54:40.599
<v Kristen Dennis>I'm sorry, but that— no, that, that's really helpful.

1743
02:54:40.664 --> 02:54:47.968
<v Kristen Dennis>And I want to underscore, I understand what a difficult position you all are in, um, just because of the, the situation that we're in right now.

1744
02:54:48.370 --> 02:54:54.969
<v Kristen Dennis>And so whatever we can do to make that you more confident in your ability to make the decision, including having stronger communications, we want to do that for you.

1745
02:54:55.500 --> 02:54:57.731
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

1746
02:54:57.843 --> 02:54:59.417
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for the conversation.

1747
02:54:59.466 --> 02:55:01.457
<v Jamie Dunphy>Staff, friends, everybody, thank you.

1748
02:55:01.537 --> 02:55:03.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>Public, thank you for showing up and hanging out.

1749
02:55:03.448 --> 02:55:06.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, there will be more opportunities for, for public dialogue.

1750
02:55:06.112 --> 02:55:08.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>There will be more opportunities for input, and there will be more information Coming.

1751
02:55:08.949 --> 02:55:10.094
<v Jamie Dunphy>With that, we are adjourned.

