WEBVTT

1
00:05:49.930 --> 00:05:50.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

2
00:05:50.956 --> 00:05:54.036
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm now calling to order this meeting of the Portland City Council.

3
00:05:54.100 --> 00:05:56.654
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is Wednesday, June 24th.

4
00:05:57.721 --> 00:05:58.757
<v Jamie Dunphy>Rebecca, can you please call the roll?

5
00:06:02.269 --> 00:06:02.752
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good morning.

6
00:06:03.815 --> 00:06:04.572
<v Rebecca Dobert>There, thank you.

7
00:06:06.312 --> 00:06:07.055
<v Rebecca Dobert>Canal.

8
00:06:07.199 --> 00:06:07.505
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

9
00:06:07.601 --> 00:06:07.714
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

10
00:06:09.067 --> 00:06:09.600
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

11
00:06:09.937 --> 00:06:10.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

12
00:06:11.065 --> 00:06:11.370
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan.

13
00:06:11.564 --> 00:06:11.661
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

14
00:06:12.127 --> 00:06:12.737
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane.

15
00:06:13.011 --> 00:06:13.107
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

16
00:06:13.572 --> 00:06:13.959
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo.

17
00:06:14.199 --> 00:06:14.264
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

18
00:06:14.778 --> 00:06:15.115
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick.

19
00:06:15.646 --> 00:06:15.774
<v Steve Novick>Here.

20
00:06:16.370 --> 00:06:16.803
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark.

21
00:06:18.235 --> 00:06:18.603
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

22
00:06:19.038 --> 00:06:19.151
<v Mitch Green>Here.

23
00:06:21.589 --> 00:06:21.865
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman.

24
00:06:21.928 --> 00:06:22.317
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos.

25
00:06:23.223 --> 00:06:24.016
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Present online.

26
00:06:25.910 --> 00:06:26.687
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

27
00:06:28.175 --> 00:06:28.548
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy.

28
00:06:29.064 --> 00:06:29.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

29
00:06:30.343 --> 00:06:32.836
<v Jamie Dunphy>And will the attorney please read the rules of decorum for the chamber?

30
00:06:33.980 --> 00:06:34.380
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good morning.

31
00:06:37.048 --> 00:06:37.322
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good morning.

32
00:06:37.788 --> 00:06:39.137
<v Rebecca Dobert>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

33
00:06:39.396 --> 00:06:45.363
<v Rebecca Dobert>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

34
00:06:47.858 --> 00:06:49.754
<v Rebecca Dobert>Information on engaging with the council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

35
00:06:51.740 --> 00:06:55.108
<v Rebecca Dobert>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

36
00:06:55.156 --> 00:06:57.353
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

37
00:06:57.932 --> 00:06:59.487
<v Rebecca Dobert>The presiding officer preserves order.

38
00:06:59.776 --> 00:07:06.915
<v Rebecca Dobert>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

39
00:07:07.877 --> 00:07:09.706
<v Rebecca Dobert>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

40
00:07:09.899 --> 00:07:12.257
<v Rebecca Dobert>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

41
00:07:12.625 --> 00:07:15.656
<v Rebecca Dobert>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

42
00:07:15.834 --> 00:07:18.641
<v Rebecca Dobert>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

43
00:07:19.185 --> 00:07:21.382
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

44
00:07:21.605 --> 00:07:23.305
<v Rebecca Dobert>When testifying, state your name for the record.

45
00:07:23.369 --> 00:07:24.779
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your address is not necessary.

46
00:07:25.357 --> 00:07:27.937
<v Rebecca Dobert>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

47
00:07:28.161 --> 00:07:31.624
<v Rebecca Dobert>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

48
00:07:31.704 --> 00:07:32.105
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

49
00:07:32.745 --> 00:07:33.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

50
00:07:33.610 --> 00:07:35.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, our first item is the agenda approval.

51
00:07:36.112 --> 00:07:41.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any requests to amend the agenda, to reorder items, or reschedule an item for future meeting date?

52
00:07:42.041 --> 00:07:45.071
<v Jamie Dunphy>Looking around, seeing nobody excited.

53
00:07:45.166 --> 00:07:47.411
<v Jamie Dunphy>So do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

54
00:07:48.791 --> 00:07:49.713
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have unanimous consent.

55
00:07:49.762 --> 00:07:51.298
<v Jamie Dunphy>The agenda is approved.

56
00:07:52.365 --> 00:07:53.788
<v Jamie Dunphy>Rebecca, can we please move to public communications?

57
00:07:55.494 --> 00:07:57.423
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 2, public communications.

58
00:07:59.220 --> 00:08:19.122
<v Rebecca Dobert>First up, we have, uh, Christopher Olson, followed by Lisa Stein, Mark Porras, Welcome folks.

59
00:08:19.185 --> 00:08:20.901
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you are here, come on down.

60
00:08:20.966 --> 00:08:21.495
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you're online—.

61
00:08:22.072 --> 00:08:23.177
<v Rebecca Dobert>Mark is online.

62
00:08:24.237 --> 00:08:29.350
<v Rebecca Dobert>Mark, if you want to go ahead while we, uh, see if any of the other folks are in the room, you can go ahead.

63
00:08:30.425 --> 00:08:30.505
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yep.

64
00:08:30.889 --> 00:08:31.548
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, can you hear me?

65
00:08:31.851 --> 00:08:32.975
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, go right ahead, Mark.

66
00:08:33.552 --> 00:08:34.208
<v Jamie Dunphy>Fantastic.

67
00:08:34.273 --> 00:08:35.572
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, Council.

68
00:08:35.620 --> 00:08:36.566
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Mark Porras.

69
00:08:36.677 --> 00:08:38.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>I use he/him pronouns and I'm with the group Portland Cop Watch.

70
00:08:39.467 --> 00:08:51.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, 4 months ago you passed Resolution 37738 Introduced by Councilors Smith and Clark, directing the DCA of Public Safety to provide a report by June 1st on the timeline and cost of adding 400 new armed officers.

71
00:08:52.469 --> 00:09:01.413
<v Jamie Dunphy>The number 400 appears out of thin air and matches the Portland Police Association's cynical proposed ballot measure to steal money intended for climate resilience and justice for more armed officers.

72
00:09:02.168 --> 00:09:07.826
<v Jamie Dunphy>The resolution seems to reference an average number of sworn officers per 1,000 residents from a 2019 FBI publication.

73
00:09:08.418 --> 00:09:14.285
<v Jamie Dunphy>The FBI themselves caution about drawing comparisons based on their data and say it should not be interpreted as a recommendation of officer staffing levels.

74
00:09:14.350 --> 00:09:14.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have a question.

75
00:09:15.634 --> 00:09:24.331
<v Jamie Dunphy>The per capita benchmark is even more useless, as there are many agencies that overlap with PPB, and all sworn officers in the state of Oregon have arrest powers anywhere in the state.

76
00:09:25.118 --> 00:09:28.408
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's also useless to compare current PPB staffing to that of 10 years ago.

77
00:09:28.793 --> 00:09:35.581
<v Jamie Dunphy>Portland Street Response, CHAD, and the Ceasefire Program have all come into existence in the past 5 years, and they all reduce any perceived need for armed officers.

78
00:09:36.254 --> 00:09:46.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick's requested call allocation study was presented to the Community and Public Safety Committee on June 2nd and found that Thousands of armed officer hours each year spent on welfare checks could instead be handled by PSR.

79
00:09:47.407 --> 00:09:56.214
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's disheartening that PSR is not running 24/7 yet, and it's dangerous for Portlanders in mental health crisis who are often still met by cops with guns in response to welfare checks.

80
00:09:56.951 --> 00:10:01.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>Damon Lamar Johnson's death at the hands of 3 sworn officers almost exactly a year ago must not be in vain.

81
00:10:02.486 --> 00:10:06.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>Since PSR was not available, Project Respond certainly should have been requested by the officers.

82
00:10:07.154 --> 00:10:11.503
<v Jamie Dunphy>No matter how you spin it, 400 new officers will add at least $12 million to the FPDR levy.

83
00:10:11.551 --> 00:10:11.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

84
00:10:12.096 --> 00:10:14.807
<v Jamie Dunphy>Which covers all PERS contributions for cops and firefighters.

85
00:10:15.320 --> 00:10:25.039
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much to Councilor Kanal for getting on the record FPDR's taxing rate of $3.19 per, uh, $1,000 assessed value this year, which is approaching that of the general fund levy.

86
00:10:25.585 --> 00:10:29.995
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please commission a study of alternative funding sources for police and fire pensions before they bankrupt the city.

87
00:10:31.182 --> 00:10:34.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>32 Cops retired last month, taking advantage of the 27-pay-period loophole.

88
00:10:35.032 --> 00:10:40.197
<v Jamie Dunphy>Officer Jimmy Price, who was on his 4th leave of absence, chose to retire while under investigation for domestic violence.

89
00:10:40.245 --> 00:10:40.341
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

90
00:10:40.822 --> 00:10:43.467
<v Jamie Dunphy>He pled guilty in Clackamas County Court and will be sentenced next week.

91
00:10:43.965 --> 00:10:47.027
<v Jamie Dunphy>I hope the former officer's family is safe and the police bureau will learn from this.

92
00:10:47.219 --> 00:10:53.456
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, Directive 330 says the bureau has no jurisdiction once an employee retires, so they will likely drop the investigation.

93
00:10:53.552 --> 00:10:54.017
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's maddening.

94
00:10:54.691 --> 00:10:58.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>PPB's only chance of becoming a learning institution is to get the new oversight system up and running.

95
00:10:59.421 --> 00:11:04.118
<v Jamie Dunphy>It sounds like there may be some new misguided efforts to defy the charter and steal from the OCPA's budget.

96
00:11:04.775 --> 00:11:09.312
<v Jamie Dunphy>The CBPA has a 2-hour executive session tomorrow to discuss options for a director of the office.

97
00:11:09.360 --> 00:11:09.504
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

98
00:11:10.148 --> 00:11:16.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>Once the director is hired, they will begin hiring investigators and support staff, and they're going to need every dollar if we ever want a shot at police accountability.

99
00:11:17.469 --> 00:11:21.965
<v Jamie Dunphy>As long as we have police, it's not possible to have public safety for all without police accountability.

100
00:11:22.591 --> 00:11:25.883
<v Jamie Dunphy>And finally, I submitted a public records request for that report 5 days ago.

101
00:11:26.365 --> 00:11:30.121
<v Jamie Dunphy>I received it at 8:18 this morning, got on my bike, and I haven't had a chance to read it yet.

102
00:11:30.250 --> 00:11:32.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I look forward to that, and I hope you do too.

103
00:11:32.240 --> 00:11:32.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

104
00:11:33.831 --> 00:11:34.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for being here.

105
00:11:36.259 --> 00:11:39.278
<v Rebecca Dobert>And welcome, Lisa.

106
00:11:39.440 --> 00:11:40.836
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can go ahead at the testimony table.

107
00:11:42.820 --> 00:11:46.456
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm actually here for the Lloyd Center issue.

108
00:11:46.782 --> 00:11:48.509
<v Jamie Dunphy>Am I in the right docket spot?

109
00:11:49.032 --> 00:11:53.902
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, no, this is the public communications spot, which you're welcome to use to—.

110
00:11:53.950 --> 00:11:55.308
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, I'm happy to wait.

111
00:11:55.486 --> 00:11:55.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

112
00:11:56.376 --> 00:11:56.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

113
00:11:56.780 --> 00:11:57.283
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

114
00:11:58.836 --> 00:12:02.297
<v Jamie Dunphy>And let's make sure you are signed up for the— for that item with the council clerk, please.

115
00:12:02.950 --> 00:12:04.635
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah, are you Lisa Stein?

116
00:12:04.993 --> 00:12:05.462
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah.

117
00:12:06.030 --> 00:12:09.013
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay, we'll get you signed up in the— for the right item.

118
00:12:11.619 --> 00:12:12.331
<v Rebecca Dobert>Christopher Olson.

119
00:12:14.306 --> 00:12:18.455
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next then we have Phuc, me, Tony Greiner.

120
00:12:18.986 --> 00:12:19.631
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's me.

121
00:12:21.328 --> 00:12:24.864
<v Rebecca Dobert>Go ahead.

122
00:12:26.356 --> 00:12:26.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

123
00:12:27.475 --> 00:12:27.783
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good morning.

124
00:12:28.474 --> 00:12:29.249
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

125
00:12:30.008 --> 00:12:31.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Tony Greiner.

126
00:12:31.219 --> 00:12:32.672
<v Jamie Dunphy>I live in District Number 2.

127
00:12:34.916 --> 00:12:44.927
<v Jamie Dunphy>On January 6th, 2021, a mob disdainful of rule of law attacked the United States Capitol in an attempt to overthrow our republic, and they almost succeeded.

128
00:12:46.159 --> 00:12:53.514
<v Jamie Dunphy>4 Years later, that mob was issued a pardon, a decision that legally at least recasts that violence as legitimate protest.

129
00:12:55.460 --> 00:13:01.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>In October of 2020, another mob, also disdainful of the rule of law, attacked the memory of Abraham Lincoln.

130
00:13:02.480 --> 00:13:10.544
<v Jamie Dunphy>They did so by toppling our statue of that most honored president and then pouring paint upon it to finish the degradation.

131
00:13:12.099 --> 00:13:18.172
<v Jamie Dunphy>For over 5 years, the city's government has tolerated that vandalism by delaying the repair and restoration of the statue.

132
00:13:18.639 --> 00:13:20.184
<v Jamie Dunphy>But now, finally, we're close.

133
00:13:20.232 --> 00:13:20.378
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

134
00:13:20.730 --> 00:13:22.442
<v Jamie Dunphy>To restoring it to its proper place.

135
00:13:23.990 --> 00:13:35.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>But there are people in city government who, perhaps unintentionally, are planning to legitimize the desecration by advancing a plan to belittle the memory of the man who freed millions from slavery and preserved the Republic.

136
00:13:37.331 --> 00:13:46.205
<v Jamie Dunphy>If they have their way, they will do so by literally taking Lincoln off his pedestal and placing him on ground level, debasing him both figuratively and literally.

137
00:13:46.254 --> 00:13:46.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>I second that.

138
00:13:47.673 --> 00:13:56.085
<v Jamie Dunphy>At ground level, we will not be able to look up to him, and he'll be the target of every crackpot and troublemaker who equates destruction with fun.

139
00:13:58.019 --> 00:14:04.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>2 Weeks ago, an official from the Office of Arts and Culture met with members of the Historic Landmarks Commission to discuss this plan.

140
00:14:05.957 --> 00:14:16.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>When members expressed concern that placing the statue at ground level would allow for future vandalism, the response they received was, quote, there are always people who express themselves with paint.

141
00:14:16.328 --> 00:14:16.458
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's right.

142
00:14:18.649 --> 00:14:22.511
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is not what I want from my city government, and I hope you agree.

143
00:14:23.778 --> 00:14:28.123
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is my request to you: order the statue to be returned to its original location.

144
00:14:28.827 --> 00:14:38.543
<v Jamie Dunphy>Show your support for rule of law, reject the actions of a mob, and assert that in Portland, Abraham Lincoln remains worthy of public honor and respect.

145
00:14:39.424 --> 00:14:39.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

146
00:14:40.868 --> 00:14:41.589
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

147
00:14:48.505 --> 00:14:50.634
<v Rebecca Dobert>Christopher Olson or Phuc, me.

148
00:14:52.639 --> 00:14:53.876
<v Rebecca Dobert>That concludes public comment.

149
00:14:54.294 --> 00:14:56.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you, colleagues.

150
00:14:56.287 --> 00:14:58.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Next item on our agenda, item 3, is the presidential update.

151
00:14:58.857 --> 00:15:06.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're going to hear from City Administrator Lee on the status of any ongoing responses to federal interventions in the city.

152
00:15:06.982 --> 00:15:07.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator.

153
00:15:08.028 --> 00:15:09.381
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Council President.

154
00:15:09.543 --> 00:15:12.304
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, there's no new updates from my previous update of last week.

155
00:15:12.356 --> 00:15:19.503
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Uh, we're steady monitoring the situation, and we will update council as we get new information.

156
00:15:20.022 --> 00:15:20.864
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, sir.

157
00:15:24.153 --> 00:15:24.688
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

158
00:15:25.451 --> 00:15:27.041
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just have a point of information.

159
00:15:27.169 --> 00:15:29.472
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's not about this agenda item, it's about the previous one.

160
00:15:29.667 --> 00:15:30.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is an alternate.

161
00:15:30.883 --> 00:15:32.014
<v Jamie Dunphy>Did they get called?

162
00:15:32.900 --> 00:15:36.491
<v Rebecca Dobert>Apologies, I just got a message that, yeah, there is an alternate online.

163
00:15:38.200 --> 00:15:40.519
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, apologies, that was, uh, I missed.

164
00:15:41.352 --> 00:15:42.166
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good catch, Councilor.

165
00:15:45.169 --> 00:15:46.059
<v Rebecca Dobert>So, Aubrey Russell.

166
00:15:48.749 --> 00:15:50.094
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, hi, can you hear me?

167
00:15:50.402 --> 00:15:50.937
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can.

168
00:15:51.440 --> 00:15:52.072
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can go ahead.

169
00:15:52.673 --> 00:15:52.932
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

170
00:15:52.996 --> 00:15:53.873
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Aubrey Russell.

171
00:15:54.610 --> 00:16:02.774
<v Jamie Dunphy>The decision to remove Lincoln from his pedestal was made in July of 2025 by the City Arts Program, Office of Arts and Culture, and WRAC.

172
00:16:03.437 --> 00:16:08.274
<v Jamie Dunphy>The idea to place Lincoln on the ground, as they spoke about it, was not revealed to the public.

173
00:16:08.821 --> 00:16:09.543
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was a secret.

174
00:16:10.009 --> 00:16:15.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>The secrecy was revealed recently only by— only because of a public records request.

175
00:16:16.369 --> 00:16:18.248
<v Jamie Dunphy>The public will only gradually become aware.

176
00:16:18.842 --> 00:16:25.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yet Darian Jones of Arts and Culture explains in the city's justification that there has been public engagement.

177
00:16:25.909 --> 00:16:28.287
<v Jamie Dunphy>He points to the South Park Blocks Master Plan.

178
00:16:28.976 --> 00:16:34.967
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yet that plan from many years ago notes that there were only 9 public comments relating to statues.

179
00:16:35.033 --> 00:16:35.160
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

180
00:16:35.866 --> 00:16:43.822
<v Jamie Dunphy>Also, Darian lists the Lewis and Clark Monuments document, yet there were just 9 authors and 4 readers and no public involvement.

181
00:16:45.089 --> 00:16:53.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is an impressive-looking list to justify this decision, but the list is thin on substance and serves more to mislead than to inform.

182
00:16:54.808 --> 00:17:06.426
<v Jamie Dunphy>The entire justification also serves to distract, to distract from the fact that none of the public engagement cited as justification for removing Lincoln from his pedestal Even related to this plan.

183
00:17:07.027 --> 00:17:07.982
<v Jamie Dunphy>How could it have been?

184
00:17:08.241 --> 00:17:09.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Remember that the plan was a secret.

185
00:17:11.720 --> 00:17:14.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>This cannot be public engagement because the public was ignorant.

186
00:17:14.892 --> 00:17:29.465
<v Jamie Dunphy>Portland's public involvement principles say that the public should be given sufficient advance notice of decisions to— so that they can participate in a meaningful way, and that the public should understand the decision-making process in advance, and that city staff should be accountable for these principles.

187
00:17:29.529 --> 00:17:29.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

188
00:17:30.585 --> 00:17:36.737
<v Jamie Dunphy>Instead of honoring the idea of public involvement, Mr. Jones and Arts and Culture and RACC chose the route of secrecy.

189
00:17:37.332 --> 00:17:48.304
<v Jamie Dunphy>In July of 2025, Darian Jones's supervisor, Charity Montez, asked Darian about public engagement relating to Lincoln and asked about notifying the Portland Historic Landmarks Commission.

190
00:17:48.817 --> 00:17:52.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>No effort was made to do either since last July.

191
00:17:53.058 --> 00:17:57.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>The Landmarks Commission asked Darian to brief them ASAP on Lincoln 9 days ago.

192
00:17:57.412 --> 00:18:05.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>Darrin again stressed the public engagement activities of a few years ago, which reached almost no one and which did not relate to removing Lincoln from his pedestal.

193
00:18:06.481 --> 00:18:21.892
<v Jamie Dunphy>Darrin did not relate that the city's website had said for a long time that, quote, Lincoln will return to his original location in the South Park blocks, or that the city's website had been quietly changed to say that Lincoln would be, quote, reinstalled, end quote.

194
00:18:22.294 --> 00:18:24.492
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is very subtle and enough to avoid attention.

195
00:18:25.086 --> 00:18:27.173
<v Jamie Dunphy>Also to avoid public awareness.

196
00:18:27.736 --> 00:18:37.193
<v Jamie Dunphy>The city's publicly avowed plan to, quote, return Lincoln to its original location and provide interpretation should be how the city now proceeds.

197
00:18:37.626 --> 00:18:47.775
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lincoln is one of the most highly ranked, rank 1, of our publicly owned historic resources and is protected under city code as, quote, a significant resource, end quote.

198
00:18:48.224 --> 00:18:49.236
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for your attention.

199
00:18:49.348 --> 00:18:49.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

200
00:18:50.457 --> 00:18:51.083
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

201
00:18:52.948 --> 00:18:54.731
<v Rebecca Dobert>And that now concludes public testimony.

202
00:18:54.779 --> 00:18:57.143
<v Rebecca Dobert>Apologies to Aubrey and City Administrator Lee.

203
00:18:57.367 --> 00:18:57.769
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

204
00:18:58.186 --> 00:18:58.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

205
00:18:59.680 --> 00:19:02.008
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, we're gonna move to item 4, our consent agenda.

206
00:19:02.688 --> 00:19:06.084
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, has any— have any items been removed from the consent agenda?

207
00:19:07.596 --> 00:19:07.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

208
00:19:08.256 --> 00:19:11.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any objections to this, colleagues?

209
00:19:11.936 --> 00:19:12.130
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

210
00:19:13.223 --> 00:19:15.586
<v Jamie Dunphy>Becca, can we please call the roll on item 4, consent agenda?

211
00:19:19.541 --> 00:19:19.848
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal.

212
00:19:21.090 --> 00:19:21.123
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

213
00:19:21.978 --> 00:19:22.509
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

214
00:19:24.075 --> 00:19:24.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

215
00:19:25.026 --> 00:19:25.413
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan.

216
00:19:25.688 --> 00:19:25.736
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

217
00:19:27.430 --> 00:19:27.673
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane.

218
00:19:28.094 --> 00:19:28.272
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

219
00:19:28.645 --> 00:19:29.148
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo.

220
00:19:29.554 --> 00:19:29.603
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

221
00:19:30.057 --> 00:19:30.478
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick.

222
00:19:30.689 --> 00:19:30.738
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

223
00:19:31.500 --> 00:19:31.807
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

224
00:19:32.960 --> 00:19:33.009
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

225
00:19:33.932 --> 00:19:34.321
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos.

226
00:19:35.473 --> 00:19:35.652
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

227
00:19:36.349 --> 00:19:36.678
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

228
00:19:37.105 --> 00:19:37.153
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

229
00:19:37.778 --> 00:19:38.189
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy.

230
00:19:38.500 --> 00:19:38.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

231
00:19:41.435 --> 00:19:44.038
<v Rebecca Dobert>Consent agenda is adopted with 10 aye and 2 absent.

232
00:19:44.327 --> 00:19:44.682
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

233
00:19:44.746 --> 00:19:46.240
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 5?

234
00:19:46.898 --> 00:20:05.214
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 5, consider appeals of the Design Commission's approval of a voluntary Central City Master Plan review and adjustment review for the Lloyd Center Central City Master Plan, LU-25-091308, CCMSAD, document number 2026-217.

235
00:20:08.366 --> 00:20:11.451
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just want to confirm, this, uh, is listed as a time certain.

236
00:20:11.516 --> 00:20:14.825
<v Jamie Dunphy>Was it listed at 9:50 or 9:45?

237
00:20:15.049 --> 00:20:15.740
<v Rebecca Dobert>9:45.

238
00:20:16.013 --> 00:20:17.412
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great, look at that, we're on time.

239
00:20:17.523 --> 00:20:18.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's do this thing.

240
00:20:18.200 --> 00:20:24.598
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, colleagues, first the city attorney is going to make some announcements about today's hearing.

241
00:20:24.727 --> 00:20:26.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I will look to Lauren.

242
00:20:30.582 --> 00:20:32.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>I can read through my script first too if you'd like.

243
00:20:33.498 --> 00:20:33.803
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

244
00:20:34.540 --> 00:20:36.852
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, okay, this is an evidentiary hearing.

245
00:20:37.204 --> 00:20:40.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>This means you may submit new evidence to council in support of your arguments.

246
00:20:41.137 --> 00:20:47.124
<v Rebecca Dobert>For an evidentiary hearing, we'll begin with the staff report by Portland Permitting and Development Bureau staff for approximately 10 minutes.

247
00:20:47.300 --> 00:20:51.039
<v Rebecca Dobert>Following the staff report, City Council will hear from interested persons in the following order.

248
00:20:52.132 --> 00:20:55.003
<v Rebecca Dobert>Appellant 1 will go first and will have 10 minutes to present their case.

249
00:20:55.116 --> 00:20:57.138
<v Rebecca Dobert>Appellant 2 will then have 10 minutes.

250
00:20:57.653 --> 00:21:00.863
<v Rebecca Dobert>Following the appellants, Persons who support the appeal will go next.

251
00:21:01.039 --> 00:21:03.736
<v Rebecca Dobert>The council president will announce the time allowed for that.

252
00:21:04.651 --> 00:21:10.799
<v Rebecca Dobert>The principal opponent, the applicant, will have 30 minutes to address council and rebut the appellant's presentations.

253
00:21:11.217 --> 00:21:17.348
<v Rebecca Dobert>If the— after the principal opponent, the council will hear from persons who oppose the appeal.

254
00:21:17.413 --> 00:21:21.025
<v Rebecca Dobert>Again, council president will announce the time allotted for each testifier.

255
00:21:21.201 --> 00:21:21.346
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay.

256
00:21:21.666 --> 00:21:25.936
<v Rebecca Dobert>And finally, the appellants will have 5 minutes each to rebut the presentation of the opponents of the appeal.

257
00:21:26.342 --> 00:21:29.413
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council may then close the hearing, deliberate, and take a vote on the appeal.

258
00:21:29.782 --> 00:21:34.234
<v Rebecca Dobert>If the vote is tentative, the council will set a future date for the adoption of findings and final vote on the appeal.

259
00:21:37.470 --> 00:21:40.921
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'd like to announce several guidelines for those who will be addressing City Council today.

260
00:21:42.349 --> 00:21:50.276
<v Rebecca Dobert>Submit— for submitting evidence into the record, any letters or documents you wish to be part— you wish to have become part of the record should be given to the council clerk after you testify.

261
00:21:50.970 --> 00:22:01.712
<v Rebecca Dobert>Similarly, the original or copy of any slides, Photographs, drawings, maps, videos, or other items you show the council during your testimony, including PowerPoint presentations, should be given to the council clerk to make sure they become part of the record.

262
00:22:02.467 --> 00:22:05.660
<v Rebecca Dobert>Testimony must be addressed— directed to the approval criteria.

263
00:22:05.757 --> 00:22:16.153
<v Rebecca Dobert>Any testimony, arguments, or evidence you present must be directed toward the applicable approval criteria for this land use review or other criteria in the city's comprehensive plan or zoning code that you believe apply to this decision.

264
00:22:16.988 --> 00:22:21.240
<v Rebecca Dobert>PP&D staff will identify the applicable approval criteria as a part of their staff report to council.

265
00:22:21.305 --> 00:22:21.528
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

266
00:22:22.588 --> 00:22:24.178
<v Rebecca Dobert>Issues must be raised with specificity.

267
00:22:24.369 --> 00:22:28.366
<v Rebecca Dobert>You must raise an issue clearly enough to give the council and the parties an opportunity to respond.

268
00:22:28.944 --> 00:22:32.942
<v Rebecca Dobert>If you do not, you will be precluded from appealing to the Lane Use Board of Appeals based on that issue.

269
00:22:34.066 --> 00:22:37.692
<v Rebecca Dobert>Applicants must identify any constitutional challenges to conditions of approval.

270
00:22:38.239 --> 00:22:49.282
<v Rebecca Dobert>If the applicant fails to raise constitutional or other issues relating to the proposed conditions of approval without— with enough specificity to allow the council to respond, the applicant will be precluded from bringing an action for damages in circuit court.

271
00:22:49.330 --> 00:22:49.442
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

272
00:22:50.054 --> 00:22:50.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

273
00:22:51.660 --> 00:22:52.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Lauren.

274
00:22:52.366 --> 00:23:01.057
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, there are about 90 people, uh, signed up to testify for the appellant and 50 people signed up to testify for the applicant.

275
00:23:01.683 --> 00:23:05.122
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, we've already given notice that oral testimony is going to be limited to 90 seconds.

276
00:23:05.315 --> 00:23:14.358
<v Jamie Dunphy>That means that it will take just over 3 hours from now to get to the beginning of the applicant's presentation and another 2 hours from that point until council deliberations begin.

277
00:23:15.097 --> 00:23:16.848
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, so we have 2 options at this point, council.

278
00:23:17.748 --> 00:23:23.992
<v Jamie Dunphy>First, we can proceed as planned, most likely recess this meeting after hearing all of the appellant testimony.

279
00:23:24.586 --> 00:23:29.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>We would then most likely continue testimony tomorrow and return for council deliberations on July 8th.

280
00:23:30.446 --> 00:23:34.428
<v Jamie Dunphy>The driver's resource center item would probably have to be carried over as well.

281
00:23:35.166 --> 00:23:43.578
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our second option is that we could limit testimony to the first 50 people signed up for each side and ask those who signed up in excess of that to submit written testimony.

282
00:23:44.265 --> 00:23:50.919
<v Jamie Dunphy>In that world, we could stretch to hear all testimony today and do tomorrow's agenda as post, and we will still return on July 8th for deliberations.

283
00:23:51.847 --> 00:23:56.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm only open to limiting testimony if there's unanimous consent on this body.

284
00:23:56.765 --> 00:24:09.316
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'd like to sort of look around and see, would we rather proceed forward with as many people signed up and adjourn at the end of the appellant's testimony and proceed tomorrow, or limit it to 50 people apiece?

285
00:24:09.366 --> 00:24:10.205
<v Jamie Dunphy>Anybody have— I think we should do 50 people apiece.

286
00:24:10.390 --> 00:24:12.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any other council members have particular opinions?

287
00:24:12.250 --> 00:24:13.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal?

288
00:24:13.390 --> 00:24:18.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I don't think we should limit, um, especially given that the numbers who signed up are not proportional.

289
00:24:18.970 --> 00:24:22.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>It doesn't make sense to me to limit only— that's limiting one side.

290
00:24:22.369 --> 00:24:23.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't think that would make it a fair process.

291
00:24:24.109 --> 00:24:24.869
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

292
00:24:24.869 --> 00:24:26.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney?

293
00:24:26.190 --> 00:24:30.529
<v Rebecca Dobert>I had a clarifying question, but I think it's moot if, uh, Councilor Kanal objects.

294
00:24:30.650 --> 00:24:31.250
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay.

295
00:24:31.250 --> 00:24:33.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane?

296
00:24:33.150 --> 00:24:47.044
<v Rebecca Dobert>I would like to see unanimous consent for the folks I mean, one thing you can also do is when someone's speaking and it's representing what you're saying, something powerful you can do is standing up to show that you also agree.

297
00:24:48.969 --> 00:24:55.960
<v Rebecca Dobert>So that's how I would only feel comfortable if folks who are here and took time off work and got childcare are all down with that.

298
00:24:56.709 --> 00:24:57.031
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, absolutely.

299
00:24:57.242 --> 00:24:57.582
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

300
00:24:57.663 --> 00:24:58.358
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

301
00:24:59.750 --> 00:25:03.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we should proceed as Councilor Kanal suggests and hear all the testimony.

302
00:25:03.664 --> 00:25:03.858
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Councilor Smith.

303
00:25:04.082 --> 00:25:04.321
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes.

304
00:25:05.202 --> 00:25:12.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, uh, since there's not limit— there's not unanimous consent to limit testimony, the hearing is going to proceed with all testimony to be heard.

305
00:25:12.637 --> 00:25:16.804
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, we anticipate recessing at the end of testimony by supporters of the appellant.

306
00:25:17.605 --> 00:25:24.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, additionally, I will be taking a— I will be giving us a 10-minute recess at 11 o'clock to use the restroom.

307
00:25:25.375 --> 00:25:31.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, before we begin with testimony and the presentations, do any members of council wish to declare a conflict of interest?

308
00:25:33.683 --> 00:25:35.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, before we get to that, Councilor Murillo.

309
00:25:35.749 --> 00:25:36.823
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sorry, I just had a clarification.

310
00:25:38.190 --> 00:25:45.057
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, so are we gonna proceed past the 12:30 mark for testimony, or are we stopping it and then hearing more later?

311
00:25:45.153 --> 00:25:46.378
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll stop and then hear more later.

312
00:25:46.442 --> 00:25:47.217
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, thank you.

313
00:25:48.957 --> 00:25:51.757
<v Jamie Dunphy>Either 12:30 or when we get to the end of the appellate testimony.

314
00:25:52.882 --> 00:25:53.125
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

315
00:25:53.675 --> 00:25:55.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, back to my, uh, script.

316
00:25:55.814 --> 00:25:58.486
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do any members of council wish to declare a conflict of interest?

317
00:26:01.851 --> 00:26:09.287
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing none, do any members of the council have ex parte contacts to declare or information gathered outside of the hearing to disclose?

318
00:26:09.479 --> 00:26:13.133
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to start by noting that on this— Yeah, you—.

319
00:26:13.164 --> 00:26:13.212
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

320
00:26:13.390 --> 00:26:14.207
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, did I screw something up?

321
00:26:14.366 --> 00:26:15.698
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, no, no, she just raised her hand.

322
00:26:16.355 --> 00:26:17.236
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, Councilor—.

323
00:26:17.316 --> 00:26:19.784
<v Rebecca Dobert>I was messaging the attorney when I need to say what I need to say.

324
00:26:19.961 --> 00:26:20.201
<v Jamie Dunphy>Understood.

325
00:26:20.280 --> 00:26:21.145
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane, please.

326
00:26:21.563 --> 00:26:25.313
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay, um, first, welcome back, Attorney Lauren King.

327
00:26:25.409 --> 00:26:25.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>I missed you.

328
00:26:25.922 --> 00:26:26.403
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm glad you're here.

329
00:26:27.172 --> 00:26:33.122
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, I want to say that I know and respect that land use requires that we make fair and impartial decisions.

330
00:26:33.654 --> 00:26:36.645
<v Rebecca Dobert>I take, uh, my quasi-judicial role very seriously.

331
00:26:38.651 --> 00:26:42.826
<v Rebecca Dobert>Many know that I am pretty obsessed with the Lloyd Center.

332
00:26:43.487 --> 00:26:58.114
<v Rebecca Dobert>I see it as— I see it as a place where we can learn a lot of lessons from it, um, and see how small businesses can really thrive and be supported when the rent is cheaper.

333
00:27:00.153 --> 00:27:05.067
<v Rebecca Dobert>I, I think we should be looking at it and thinking like, how can we be doing small business incubators downtown?

334
00:27:05.914 --> 00:27:07.518
<v Rebecca Dobert>Like, maybe we, we buy a place.

335
00:27:07.566 --> 00:27:09.622
<v Rebecca Dobert>How can we be replicating what's happened there?

336
00:27:10.642 --> 00:27:17.492
<v Rebecca Dobert>These little cool businesses that have opened up in Lloyd Center really are what make Portland Portland.

337
00:27:18.412 --> 00:27:27.348
<v Rebecca Dobert>Before I knew this was going to be a land use issue, I was already broadcasting my I think we have a point of order.

338
00:27:28.278 --> 00:27:32.913
<v Benjamin Nielsen>I'm experiencing you giving your point of view on the actual decision.

339
00:27:33.748 --> 00:27:34.277
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Was it the—.

340
00:27:34.292 --> 00:27:37.661
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have the floor and I'm about to declare a conflict of interest.

341
00:27:37.916 --> 00:27:39.135
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, just— I hope you get to that.

342
00:27:39.215 --> 00:27:39.520
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thanks.

343
00:27:40.482 --> 00:27:43.385
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I would— I was talking to all my colleagues.

344
00:27:43.433 --> 00:27:45.069
<v Rebecca Dobert>I was talking to a lot of community members.

345
00:27:45.134 --> 00:27:53.337
<v Rebecca Dobert>The Save Lloyd people reached out to me because they saw me posting a lot of posts that I'm just pretty obsessed with that place and have a lot of personal connections.

346
00:27:53.769 --> 00:28:03.367
<v Rebecca Dobert>The owners of Stupid Burger went to Fabian and they came and met with my class and talked to them about being small business owners and gave them each a burger.

347
00:28:03.464 --> 00:28:08.269
<v Rebecca Dobert>My kid opted for his only present last year to be a lightsaber from that cool lightsaber store.

348
00:28:08.480 --> 00:28:13.234
<v Rebecca Dobert>So especially when I walked in, a lot of my friends and neighbors are here, including—.

349
00:28:13.285 --> 00:28:13.596
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mayor?

350
00:28:14.175 --> 00:28:15.363
<v Rebecca Dobert>2 Kids, Sam and Eli.

351
00:28:15.940 --> 00:28:18.250
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yay for youth engagement.

352
00:28:18.906 --> 00:28:22.500
<v Rebecca Dobert>And my heart is broken about the idea of losing Lloyd Center.

353
00:28:22.612 --> 00:28:24.584
<v Rebecca Dobert>I talked to Attorney Lauren King.

354
00:28:24.696 --> 00:28:30.148
<v Rebecca Dobert>She's helped walk me through this process, and I am concerned about making an impartial decision myself.

355
00:28:30.405 --> 00:28:33.885
<v Rebecca Dobert>So for that reason, I'm going to recuse myself and not participate in today's hearing.

356
00:28:34.173 --> 00:28:34.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

357
00:28:35.280 --> 00:28:36.211
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

358
00:28:40.173 --> 00:28:45.343
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, do any members have— of the council have any ex parte contacts to disclose?

359
00:28:45.391 --> 00:28:46.419
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, there's a bunch of folks in the queue.

360
00:28:46.515 --> 00:28:46.675
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good.

361
00:28:47.382 --> 00:28:56.711
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to start by just noting that on December 17th, 2025, I met with Matthew Henderson of Save Lloyd and discussed the pending closure of Lloyd and their group's effort to keep the community together.

362
00:28:56.935 --> 00:29:00.291
<v Jamie Dunphy>On December 2nd, I have a communication from Mr. Henderson to schedule that meeting.

363
00:29:00.965 --> 00:29:05.237
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am prepared to make a decision today based on the evidence on the record and the testimony that will be presented.

364
00:29:06.059 --> 00:29:07.140
<v Jamie Dunphy>To the queue, Councilor Green.

365
00:29:08.720 --> 00:29:09.589
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, thank you.

366
00:29:09.768 --> 00:29:16.624
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, my office I think has received a large volume of emails that goes to sort of a folder that I don't necessarily see.

367
00:29:16.704 --> 00:29:18.013
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just wanted to acknowledge that.

368
00:29:18.240 --> 00:29:31.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I think I was at a 350 PDX candidate event and a couple people came up and asked me about this land use decision, and I said, look, I'm in ex parte communication, but I wanted to disclose that.

369
00:29:32.563 --> 00:29:39.517
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then on Monday, I received a call from a political rep with SEIU asking me to support the hearing officer's decision.

370
00:29:39.580 --> 00:29:45.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>So those are my, those are my contacts that I can disclose, and I'm prepared to make my decision based upon the evidence in the record.

371
00:29:46.385 --> 00:29:46.722
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

372
00:29:46.963 --> 00:29:47.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

373
00:29:48.153 --> 00:29:48.859
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

374
00:29:50.901 --> 00:29:52.116
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Council President.

375
00:29:52.522 --> 00:30:00.642
<v Rebecca Dobert>My office responded to roughly 25 emails in support of the Lloyd Ice Rink prior to to April 2nd when we learned that this would be appealed to us.

376
00:30:00.787 --> 00:30:02.215
<v Rebecca Dobert>I did not read each and every one.

377
00:30:02.311 --> 00:30:22.880
<v Rebecca Dobert>However, up until the Design Commission's decision was appealed, my staff summarized their general sentiment to me and sent a form response on my behalf saying that I agreed the loss of the rink would be significant for our city and that I did not know why the developer had decided to eliminate the possibility of a rink in preservation, but that I was meeting directly with the developer to learn more.

378
00:30:23.507 --> 00:30:28.981
<v Rebecca Dobert>My office responded to roughly 3 emails in support of retaining the Lloyd Center prior to April 2nd.

379
00:30:29.383 --> 00:30:31.198
<v Rebecca Dobert>Again, I did not read each and every one.

380
00:30:31.535 --> 00:30:39.130
<v Rebecca Dobert>However, up until the Design Commission's decision was appealed, my staff summarized their general sentiment and sent a response on my behalf.

381
00:30:39.980 --> 00:30:48.410
<v Rebecca Dobert>My office responded to roughly 3 emails in support of the Lloyd Center— in support, I'm sorry, of removing the Lloyd Center prior to April 2nd.

382
00:30:48.811 --> 00:30:54.029
<v Rebecca Dobert>And again, while I did not read each and every one, my staff summarized them for me and sent a response on my behalf.

383
00:30:54.896 --> 00:31:06.217
<v Rebecca Dobert>My office received a letter from Jerry and Tally Leonard, a well-known couple in the Portland skating community, sharing their support for the Lloyd Ice Rink, which my staff summarized for me and sent a similar response on my behalf.

384
00:31:07.099 --> 00:31:20.689
<v Rebecca Dobert>After the commission's decision was approved on April 2nd, my staff stopped summarizing emails we received to me and responded themselves, informing Portlanders about the constraints of ex parte contact.

385
00:31:21.251 --> 00:31:28.499
<v Rebecca Dobert>I will also note that on Wednesday, March 3rd, I took a meeting with the Save Lloyd Ice Coalition here at City Hall at their request.

386
00:31:28.964 --> 00:31:38.733
<v Rebecca Dobert>A member of my staff was also in the room, and we discussed ways to reach a compromise with Urban Renaissance Group and if and how the city could help get the parties in communication together.

387
00:31:39.506 --> 00:31:40.101
<v Rebecca Dobert>On Tuesday, Thank you.

388
00:31:40.148 --> 00:31:49.816
<v Rebecca Dobert>On March 17th, I met with URG Managing Director Tom Kilbane along with 2 other members of his team at City Hall at my office's request.

389
00:31:50.474 --> 00:31:56.290
<v Rebecca Dobert>A member of my staff along with a member of Councilor Kanal and Councilor Ryan's staff were also in the room.

390
00:31:56.820 --> 00:32:03.032
<v Rebecca Dobert>Tom gave us a brief update on the status of the application and answered questions we had about timeline and about the ice rink.

391
00:32:05.470 --> 00:32:10.576
<v Rebecca Dobert>On May 17th, I met with Matt Henderson from Save Lloyd Campaign, also in City Hall, at Matt's request.

392
00:32:11.025 --> 00:32:25.123
<v Rebecca Dobert>A member of my staff was present, and Matt told me that collectively the Save Lloyd Ice Co— they and the Save Lloyd Ice Coalition had about 10,000 signatures and 100,000 substantive comments from community for their petition.

393
00:32:25.717 --> 00:32:33.854
<v Rebecca Dobert>He shared his ideas for partial preservation of Lloyd Center, and we discussed how to make future activation of spaces available elsewhere in Portland.

394
00:32:34.675 --> 00:32:36.030
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm sorry, there's just a few more.

395
00:32:36.799 --> 00:32:53.787
<v Rebecca Dobert>On Thursday, March 19th, 2 members of my team met with Tom Kilbane at a coffee shop across from City Hall at Tom's request, and he provided my staff with an update on the application, which had been officially approved by the Design Commission that day, and shared his concerns about the potential for an appeal.

396
00:32:55.634 --> 00:33:02.248
<v Rebecca Dobert>My staff emphasized our office interest in helping to convene parties to find paths forward collectively.

397
00:33:03.163 --> 00:33:14.660
<v Rebecca Dobert>On Monday, March 30th, my staff took a call from William Ross, a field representative for Representative Maxine Dexter's office, who were also meeting with many interested groups regarding the Lloyd Ice Rink.

398
00:33:15.190 --> 00:33:22.414
<v Rebecca Dobert>My staff passed along the information we had learned in our aforementioned meetings and offered to be helpful in any capacity possible in the work that they were doing.

399
00:33:23.394 --> 00:33:32.277
<v Rebecca Dobert>Additionally, I've had many casual conversations that I don't believe are ex parte communication on the needs, opportunities, and future of the neighborhood with neighborhood residents and other Portlanders.

400
00:33:33.096 --> 00:33:42.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I should note, because I believe it is one of the questions we are asked, that I do frequent the area and have seen the site and been to and through and in the site numerous times.

401
00:33:42.990 --> 00:33:52.190
<v Rebecca Dobert>I am prepared today to make a decision— or July 8th, it sounds like— to make a decision based on evidence in the record and the testimony presented over the next few days.

402
00:33:52.623 --> 00:33:53.586
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Council President.

403
00:33:53.891 --> 00:33:54.836
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

404
00:33:54.949 --> 00:33:55.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

405
00:33:56.634 --> 00:33:57.516
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mr. President.

406
00:33:57.692 --> 00:34:05.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>Similar to Councilor Green, I've seen a large volume of emails, subject headings flash across my screen related to this topic.

407
00:34:05.521 --> 00:34:13.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have not read them in order to restrict myself to hearing the, the record and the testimony today, and that is what I'll base my decision on.

408
00:34:14.282 --> 00:34:15.083
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

409
00:34:15.485 --> 00:34:16.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

410
00:34:16.992 --> 00:34:18.469
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Council President.

411
00:34:18.934 --> 00:34:20.394
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah, similar feedback from me.

412
00:34:20.603 --> 00:34:26.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>We've received hundreds of emails at my office, and my staff has summarized what those emails said to me.

413
00:34:27.021 --> 00:34:30.695
<v Rebecca Dobert>Some of them were to save the Lloyd, some of them were to not save the Lloyd.

414
00:34:31.112 --> 00:34:38.653
<v Rebecca Dobert>So there was some conflict there in the community about this decision, although overwhelmingly, I think vast majority of the emails were to save the Lloyd District.

415
00:34:39.617 --> 00:34:42.536
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have been there in person and seen it numerous times and walked through there.

416
00:34:43.206 --> 00:34:53.141
<v Rebecca Dobert>I will also say I had folks come to various constituent coffees and events that I've had in the district to come and tell me about it and to tell me specifically about preserving the ice rink.

417
00:34:53.190 --> 00:34:55.148
<v Rebecca Dobert>That was a top priority that was given to me.

418
00:34:56.038 --> 00:35:09.309
<v Rebecca Dobert>But after we were told that this would become a land use issue and that we couldn't engage in ex parte communications, I stopped, you know, I let people know that that was a boundary that we had to make sure that we were impartial in this decision-making.

419
00:35:10.585 --> 00:35:13.385
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

420
00:35:13.514 --> 00:35:14.028
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

421
00:35:17.440 --> 00:35:18.307
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Council President.

422
00:35:18.485 --> 00:35:28.083
<v Rebecca Dobert>I just want to put on for the record, I don't know if it's a conflict of interest of sorts, but I have received several emails and telephone calls in regards to this issue.

423
00:35:28.148 --> 00:35:29.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>My staff have met with people.

424
00:35:29.760 --> 00:35:33.442
<v Rebecca Dobert>I haven't met with anyone personally on this, but I just wanted to put that on the record.

425
00:35:34.199 --> 00:35:34.458
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

426
00:35:34.764 --> 00:35:35.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

427
00:35:35.806 --> 00:35:36.351
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Ryan.

428
00:35:37.009 --> 00:35:44.626
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Yes, um, I've been in communication with Tom Kilbane, Urban Renaissance Group, and that dates back to when I was on the last council.

429
00:35:45.106 --> 00:35:48.378
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, this, uh, has been in motion for many, many years.

430
00:35:49.197 --> 00:35:52.612
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I've received numerous random opinions about the issue.

431
00:35:52.981 --> 00:35:56.043
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it's, um, pretty much proximity-based.

432
00:35:56.509 --> 00:35:57.887
<v Benjamin Nielsen>I work out at Lloyd Athletic Club.

433
00:35:57.952 --> 00:35:59.235
<v Benjamin Nielsen>My cleaners is in the area.

434
00:35:59.780 --> 00:36:01.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm, I'm around that part of town all the time.

435
00:36:02.346 --> 00:36:11.753
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so I've heard very passionate opinions about this, and I just wanted to make sure that that was said to me.

436
00:36:11.960 --> 00:36:12.538
<v Dan Ryan>I also—.

437
00:36:12.634 --> 00:36:13.596
<v Jamie Dunphy>It was said out loud.

438
00:36:13.659 --> 00:36:19.155
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also have done the mall walking thing on Sunday a couple times, so, which was quite fun.

439
00:36:20.471 --> 00:36:23.755
<v Benjamin Nielsen>But I'm really prepared to make a decision based on the evidence in the record.

440
00:36:23.996 --> 00:36:24.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

441
00:36:24.797 --> 00:36:25.565
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

442
00:36:25.983 --> 00:36:26.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

443
00:36:28.228 --> 00:36:32.726
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hey, um, yeah, my office also received communication regarding the Lloyd Center.

444
00:36:32.806 --> 00:36:36.791
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have not read them and I've directed my staff not to forward those communications to me.

445
00:36:37.159 --> 00:36:43.199
<v Rebecca Dobert>My staff responded letting them know that because this is a land use decision, the councilor would not be able to engage on the matter, and so I did not.

446
00:36:43.746 --> 00:36:44.726
<v Rebecca Dobert>That is my disclosure.

447
00:36:44.871 --> 00:36:45.239
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

448
00:36:45.594 --> 00:36:46.621
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Councilor.

449
00:36:47.184 --> 00:36:48.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor Kanal.

450
00:36:49.512 --> 00:36:51.231
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Council President.

451
00:36:51.440 --> 00:36:53.320
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I have ex parte contacts to disclose.

452
00:36:53.369 --> 00:36:57.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know if they— how many of these meet the legal definition, but abundance of caution, so I'll disclose them.

453
00:36:57.862 --> 00:37:01.471
<v Jamie Dunphy>On December 19th, 2025, I held a town hall at Afro Village in Lloyd Center.

454
00:37:01.550 --> 00:37:07.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>I met with several people involved in various sides of this who participated in, and in a couple cases discussed the issue.

455
00:37:08.047 --> 00:37:19.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>On March 16th, I spoke at the Sullivan's Gulch Neighborhood Association meeting following Tom Kilbane from Urban Renaissance Group and had a short interaction with him after that, um, at the location of that neighborhood association, uh, meeting.

456
00:37:20.157 --> 00:37:25.914
<v Jamie Dunphy>On March 17th, as noted by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, there was a meeting with D2 Council staff at City Hall, which my team attended.

457
00:37:26.347 --> 00:37:31.929
<v Jamie Dunphy>On March 17th as well, I had a casual conversation at a loud and crowded St. Patrick's Day celebration when I ran into Tom Kilbane.

458
00:37:32.362 --> 00:37:34.721
<v Jamie Dunphy>At that time, we both acknowledged we couldn't talk about this issue.

459
00:37:35.315 --> 00:37:39.677
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've had what feels like hundreds of emails flash across my screen, but I've not read them.

460
00:37:39.742 --> 00:37:45.083
<v Jamie Dunphy>My staff has not summarized them for me other than to say these emails existed and they go into a folder that I don't look at.

461
00:37:45.581 --> 00:37:51.275
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've also seen but not engaged with what feels like hundreds, but it's probably a high number of dozens of social media posts.

462
00:37:52.094 --> 00:38:09.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've received several communications from the businesses affected as well, and I've engaged with them, as has my office, about relocation possibilities and business support, while noting that because this is a quasi-judicial matter, I can't talk about whether or not that would happen, but saying here is the opportunities the city can provide to assist with business.

463
00:38:10.878 --> 00:38:17.208
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also received a call, but I missed it, from SEIU earlier this week regarding it and directed that to my staff for follow-up.

464
00:38:17.255 --> 00:38:17.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

465
00:38:17.545 --> 00:38:23.574
<v Jamie Dunphy>And have not received any updates on if it happened, if that call occurred with them, or what the nature of it was.

466
00:38:24.969 --> 00:38:29.561
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am prepared to make a decision today based on the evidence in the record and the testimony we're about to receive.

467
00:38:30.061 --> 00:38:30.320
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

468
00:38:30.887 --> 00:38:31.646
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

469
00:38:33.748 --> 00:38:35.414
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, have any— thank you.

470
00:38:35.559 --> 00:38:38.242
<v Jamie Dunphy>Some colleagues have already answered this question, but— oh, go ahead, Councilor Kanal.

471
00:38:38.775 --> 00:38:41.023
<v Jamie Dunphy>I forgot we also have to talk about site visits.

472
00:38:41.072 --> 00:38:41.880
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Is that— I was just going to ask.

473
00:38:42.041 --> 00:38:42.461
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, yeah.

474
00:38:43.012 --> 00:38:47.641
<v Jamie Dunphy>The next part of this is, have any members of the council made Any visits to the site involved in this matter?

475
00:38:47.722 --> 00:38:49.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>A couple of councilors have already said that.

476
00:38:49.885 --> 00:38:54.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I have not personally visited the site in— or been to the Lloyd Center in more than a year.

477
00:38:54.563 --> 00:38:58.507
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, but I will note that when I was 16, I worked at the Jamba Juice at the Lloyd Center.

478
00:39:01.918 --> 00:39:05.588
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor, uh, Smith, is that Legacy or is he—.

479
00:39:07.351 --> 00:39:07.594
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

480
00:39:07.820 --> 00:39:08.855
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor Smith.

481
00:39:13.619 --> 00:39:14.213
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

482
00:39:14.918 --> 00:39:20.813
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I mean, I, I've— I can't remember the date, but I've been there once, uh, since the, um, since the appeal was filed.

483
00:39:20.862 --> 00:39:26.742
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I've been to Wood Center like, I don't know, several hundreds of times probably in my life, uh, since I grew up here.

484
00:39:26.791 --> 00:39:32.351
<v Jamie Dunphy>So yeah, that Express Store is probably a lot of— a lot of— bought a lot of stuff there over the years.

485
00:39:32.463 --> 00:39:32.784
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

486
00:39:33.007 --> 00:39:33.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

487
00:39:34.289 --> 00:39:34.914
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

488
00:39:35.331 --> 00:39:40.976
<v Rebecca Dobert>Who among us has not shopped at that Express Yes.

489
00:39:41.217 --> 00:39:45.219
<v Rebecca Dobert>Do you need details of why and when, or do you just need to know that the answer is yes?

490
00:39:45.637 --> 00:39:48.947
<v Jamie Dunphy>You can say yes, and we can ask further questions if we'd like.

491
00:39:49.106 --> 00:39:49.347
<v Rebecca Dobert>Great.

492
00:39:49.492 --> 00:39:54.391
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm going to say yes, and if we need to get into every single time, I will try to do that.

493
00:39:54.733 --> 00:39:55.451
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

494
00:39:58.298 --> 00:40:02.373
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any further disclosures or, or questions for your colleagues?

495
00:40:03.311 --> 00:40:03.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

496
00:40:03.976 --> 00:40:11.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just to clarify, Mr. President, is it any site visits in the past few months or any time you visited the Lloyd Center ever?

497
00:40:12.733 --> 00:40:17.376
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, I think it's related to this appeal specifically, to this decision.

498
00:40:17.664 --> 00:40:19.094
<v Jamie Dunphy>So yeah.

499
00:40:20.284 --> 00:40:23.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>But obviously most of us have been to the Lloyd Center a dozen times or more.

500
00:40:23.994 --> 00:40:27.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, we are now ready to move forward towards testimony.

501
00:40:28.476 --> 00:40:30.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will be calling for testimony in the following order.

502
00:40:30.981 --> 00:40:38.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>First, we'll receive the staff report, which I understand is a bit over 10 minutes, with brief remarks from a design commissioner to follow.

503
00:40:39.077 --> 00:40:41.451
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then the presentation for the appellant, which is 10 minutes.

504
00:40:41.802 --> 00:40:44.096
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then the second appellant, which is another 10 minutes.

505
00:40:44.833 --> 00:40:46.932
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then supporters of the appellant, 90 seconds each.

506
00:40:47.655 --> 00:40:49.947
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then the presentation of the applicant, 30 minutes.

507
00:40:50.619 --> 00:40:52.913
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then supporters of the applicant, 90 seconds each.

508
00:40:53.105 --> 00:40:56.375
<v Jamie Dunphy>And finally, rebuttal by the appellant together for 5 minutes total.

509
00:40:56.440 --> 00:40:57.869
<v Jamie Dunphy>Total.

510
00:40:58.784 --> 00:41:04.001
<v Jamie Dunphy>As I mentioned earlier, we'll be taking a brief break at 11 o'clock to give everybody a quick bio break.

511
00:41:04.563 --> 00:41:11.934
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are only here until 12:30, so we will probably— we will certainly not be able to get through all testimony.

512
00:41:11.981 --> 00:41:16.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>So plan for additional testimony tomorrow and council deliberations on July 8th.

513
00:41:16.864 --> 00:41:19.528
<v Jamie Dunphy>With that, I'm gonna turn it over to staff for a presentation.

514
00:41:25.030 --> 00:41:26.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, it is not.

515
00:41:26.550 --> 00:41:26.920
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor?

516
00:41:27.583 --> 00:41:27.793
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

517
00:41:28.407 --> 00:41:28.682
<v Rebecca Dobert>Can I—.

518
00:41:29.764 --> 00:41:30.201
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

519
00:41:30.331 --> 00:41:47.340
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ask you just briefly to go back to, as far as all of the ex parte communications and the site visits that council disclosed, to just make an announcement for the room and those online that if any party objects and wants to respond to those, that opportunity has been made clearly.

520
00:41:49.003 --> 00:41:49.181
<v Rebecca Dobert>Absolutely.

521
00:41:49.228 --> 00:41:49.342
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

522
00:41:49.407 --> 00:41:49.487
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

523
00:41:49.552 --> 00:41:49.682
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

524
00:41:49.958 --> 00:41:50.831
<v Rebecca Dobert>I see no objections.

525
00:41:51.106 --> 00:41:51.867
<v Jamie Dunphy>Anybody objecting?

526
00:41:51.916 --> 00:41:52.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

527
00:41:52.322 --> 00:41:53.324
<v Jamie Dunphy>I see no hands online.

528
00:41:53.373 --> 00:41:54.135
<v Jamie Dunphy>I see no one in the room.

529
00:41:54.815 --> 00:41:55.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all very much.

530
00:41:55.721 --> 00:41:57.146
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Lauren, for your patience with us.

531
00:41:59.001 --> 00:42:02.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I see your microphone is on at the table, so take it away.

532
00:42:02.789 --> 00:42:03.793
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you, President Dunphy.

533
00:42:04.585 --> 00:42:05.686
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Good morning, councilors.

534
00:42:05.961 --> 00:42:07.306
<v Benjamin Nielsen>My name is Benjamin Nielsen.

535
00:42:07.565 --> 00:42:10.376
<v Benjamin Nielsen>I'm a city planner with Portland Permitting and Development.

536
00:42:10.972 --> 00:42:17.349
<v Benjamin Nielsen>I facilitated the Central City Master Plan review for Lloyd Center with the Design Commission, and I apologize, this will run slightly longer than 10 minutes.

537
00:42:18.481 --> 00:42:22.827
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

538
00:42:22.907 --> 00:42:35.748
<v Benjamin Nielsen>I'll provide some background about the Central City Master Plan review process, a brief look at the context of the site, and a high-level overview of the proposal and the project's history before moving on to the findings of the Design Commission.

539
00:42:37.096 --> 00:43:00.396
<v Benjamin Nielsen>A Central City Master Plan is intended to result in the following urban design outcomes: a development that has strong orientation towards transit and multimodal transportation alternatives and towards a network of open spaces, a safe and vibrant public realm supported by active ground floor uses, open spaces, and an internal circulation system that connects to public streets and other modes of transportation.

540
00:43:01.418 --> 00:43:14.795
<v Benjamin Nielsen>A development site that has adequate urban services such as a street network, water, stormwater, sewers, etc., and building bulk, height, orientation, and programming that protects public views and preserves light and air within the public realm.

541
00:43:14.876 --> 00:43:14.893
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Aye.

542
00:43:15.293 --> 00:43:21.414
<v Benjamin Nielsen>And is oriented to active and passive public gathering spaces, including public open spaces and transit stations.

543
00:43:24.440 --> 00:43:43.710
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The zoning code requires central city master plans to include a number of components, such as a proposed urban design and development framework that provides clear visual information about the proposal, a narrative that describes the project and identifies how the central city master plan is consistent with the Thank you.

544
00:43:44.751 --> 00:43:51.913
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Specific information about the proposed range and density of land uses and the proposed phasing of development must also be included.

545
00:43:52.746 --> 00:43:57.744
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Information about the amount of floor area to be transferred and retained at each site must be included as well.

546
00:43:58.675 --> 00:44:01.253
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The adequacy of infrastructure must be addressed.

547
00:44:01.719 --> 00:44:10.594
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The public— the master plan must identify and link the development of each phase of the project to the provision of services necessary to meet the infrastructure needs of the proposed development.

548
00:44:10.708 --> 00:44:12.916
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Of the development associated with that phase.

549
00:44:13.737 --> 00:44:18.074
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The master plan does not include specific proposals for new buildings.

550
00:44:23.820 --> 00:44:23.900
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Sorry.

551
00:44:24.561 --> 00:44:30.427
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Um, an improved Central City Master Plan review allows additional flexibility in the following situations.

552
00:44:31.340 --> 00:44:46.447
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Floor area may be transferred among sites within the master plan boundary without having to meet the prioritization requirements in the zoning code The minimum floor area ratio standard in the zoning code may be met for the master plan area as a whole rather than on a site-by-site basis.

553
00:44:47.233 --> 00:44:53.585
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Bonus height limits in the zoning code may be achieved without having to provide the bonuses or transfers that are otherwise required.

554
00:44:54.693 --> 00:45:05.728
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Master plans afford opportunities for phasing and development of the transportation network and underground infrastructure in ways that may vary from standard requirements in the zoning code in Title 17.

555
00:45:06.708 --> 00:45:14.717
<v Benjamin Nielsen>And master plans afford opportunities for development of an open— a network of open spaces for public use around which new development can occur.

556
00:45:16.869 --> 00:45:19.440
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Central City Master Plans provide benefits to the city.

557
00:45:20.197 --> 00:45:24.617
<v Benjamin Nielsen>At least 20% of the master plan area must be developed as open space.

558
00:45:25.099 --> 00:45:26.405
<v Benjamin Nielsen>This is a code requirement.

559
00:45:27.034 --> 00:45:32.054
<v Benjamin Nielsen>There are no open space requirements with development outside of a master plan in the Central City.

560
00:45:32.103 --> 00:45:32.248
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

561
00:45:33.505 --> 00:45:42.717
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Design Commission's decision in this case included conditions of approval to ensure that the proposed open spaces in the Lloyd Center master plan will be open to use by the public.

562
00:45:43.954 --> 00:45:53.936
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Central city master plans also facilitate the planning and development of transportation and underground service infrastructure in ways that are difficult to accomplish through other processes.

563
00:45:55.172 --> 00:45:57.804
<v Benjamin Nielsen>And this new infrastructure will be paid for by the developer.

564
00:45:57.853 --> 00:45:57.949
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

565
00:46:00.063 --> 00:46:04.599
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Central City Master Plans are required for redevelopment on 6 sites in the Central City.

566
00:46:05.672 --> 00:46:08.284
<v Benjamin Nielsen>These sites are shown in gray on the map on your screen.

567
00:46:09.277 --> 00:46:25.172
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Redevelopment at the Lloyd Center site, shown in orange on the map, does not require a Central City Master Plan, but the zoning code allows for the development of a voluntary master plan at Lloyd Center since the total site area exceeds 160,000 square feet.

568
00:46:25.221 --> 00:46:25.429
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you, Mayor.

569
00:46:27.469 --> 00:46:31.148
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Next, I'll provide a brief overview of the site and zoning context.

570
00:46:31.969 --> 00:46:36.628
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The master plan area is located in the Lloyd subdistrict of the Central City Plan District.

571
00:46:37.271 --> 00:46:40.148
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The site has commercial base zoning and the design overlay.

572
00:46:40.630 --> 00:46:47.266
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The maximum floor area ratio on most of the site is 6 to 1, with a bonus of an additional 3 to 1 possible.

573
00:46:47.940 --> 00:46:51.025
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Maximum height allowed with the master plan is 225 feet.

574
00:46:51.090 --> 00:46:51.331
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

575
00:46:52.190 --> 00:46:57.927
<v Benjamin Nielsen>And the zoning code has no restrictions or discretionary review for demolitions of development on the site.

576
00:46:58.590 --> 00:47:05.407
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The only zoning code restrictions on demolition apply to designated historic sites, and the Lloyd Center has no historic designation.

577
00:47:08.800 --> 00:47:16.742
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The site consists of the current Lloyd Center Mall and the Regal Cinema site, and the master plan area anchors the east end of the Lloyd District.

578
00:47:16.903 --> 00:47:20.177
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Holiday Park and the MAX station lie to the south of the site.

579
00:47:20.643 --> 00:47:23.172
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The future Green Loop is 2 blocks to the east.

580
00:47:23.987 --> 00:47:25.862
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Numerous superblocks surround the site.

581
00:47:26.650 --> 00:47:34.409
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Those to the west and southwest have private streets and passageways that allow for movement through— more movement through the area.

582
00:47:36.849 --> 00:47:41.085
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Pedestrian realm around the current building is uncomfortable, to say the least.

583
00:47:41.717 --> 00:47:46.114
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Structured parking and inactive uses front nearly all sides of the existing mall site.

584
00:47:46.163 --> 00:47:46.309
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

585
00:47:47.987 --> 00:47:52.503
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Regal Cinemas portion of the master plan site has similar inactive street frontage.

586
00:47:54.992 --> 00:48:09.224
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Inactive uses generally surround the master plan area as well, although as you can see on the top right slide, uh, image on this slide, uh, development at Hasselow on 8th has retail space that faces the southwest corner of the master plan area.

587
00:48:11.268 --> 00:48:15.449
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Holiday Park also lies immediately to the south of the master plan area.

588
00:48:16.375 --> 00:48:24.563
<v Benjamin Nielsen>And the 12th Avenue pedestrian way to the north of the Lloyd Center will be extended through the site to connect to and help activate the park.

589
00:48:27.570 --> 00:48:40.820
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The master plan comprises approximately 27.1 acres and divides the site into 14 development areas and about 6.2 acres of publicly accessible open spaces, accessways, and new public rights-of-way.

590
00:48:41.657 --> 00:48:48.826
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Up to 6.8 million square feet of development can be accommodated within the master plan area, and redevelopment will occur in phases.

591
00:48:49.780 --> 00:49:00.914
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The master plan is intended to function as a flexible and inclusive design framework for the buildings, streets, open spaces, and infrastructure necessary for the redevelopment of this large site.

592
00:49:04.487 --> 00:49:09.505
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The master plan had 2 design advice request meetings before the Design Commission at the end of 2023.

593
00:49:10.753 --> 00:49:21.148
<v Benjamin Nielsen>These design advice meetings are required for Central City Master Plans and provide early opportunities for public comment in addition to receiving preliminary advice from the Design Commission.

594
00:49:22.791 --> 00:49:29.266
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The formal Central City Master Plan review hearing before the Design Commission was held on February 5th of this year.

595
00:49:29.958 --> 00:49:41.534
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Design Commission heard testimony from 44 testifiers and considered written testimony from 86 Testifiers, in addition to reviewing the staff report and materials presented by the development team.

596
00:49:42.630 --> 00:49:48.028
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The commission did not begin deliberations at that hearing, and the record was held open to allow for additional testimony.

597
00:49:49.902 --> 00:50:00.025
<v Benjamin Nielsen>An additional 252 pieces of written public testimony were received and provided to the Design Commission, along with the applicant's proposed edits to conditions of approval and a written rebuttal.

598
00:50:01.056 --> 00:50:15.396
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Design Commission reconvened with a closed record on March 5th, To consider all evidence, and after deliberations, they voted 5 to 0 to approve the staff report, staff-recommended conditions of approval, and therefore the proposed master plan.

599
00:50:17.320 --> 00:50:22.059
<v Benjamin Nielsen>2 Appeals were filed seeking to overturn the Design Commission's decision of approval.

600
00:50:23.019 --> 00:50:27.873
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Appeal number 1 was filed by the Save Lloyd Ice Coalition and Jennifer Gilmore Robinson.

601
00:50:31.251 --> 00:50:55.947
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The appeal argues that the Design Commission failed to give consideration to the preservation of the ice rink at Lloyd Center with regard to several Central City 2035 policies that must be considered under approval criterion H1 for the master plan, and with regard to several, several guidelines in the Central City Fundamental Design Guidelines and the Lloyd District Design Guidelines that must be considered under approval criterion H2.

602
00:50:56.253 --> 00:50:56.545
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

603
00:50:58.465 --> 00:51:02.221
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Appeal number 2 was filed by Matthew Henderson and the Save Lloyd campaign.

604
00:51:03.311 --> 00:51:14.166
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The appeal says the Design Commission failed to uphold the spirit of the master plan approval criteria and cites similar Central City 2035 policies and design, design guidelines as being unmet.

605
00:51:15.108 --> 00:51:20.516
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The appeal also says the Design Commission failed to meaningfully respond to abundant public testimony.

606
00:51:23.672 --> 00:51:38.057
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Design Commission evaluated the Central City Master Plan proposal against the approval criteria found in Zoning Code Section 33.510.255.H1 through 11, the text of which is presented on the following slides.

607
00:51:39.190 --> 00:51:53.880
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For Criterion H1, the Design Commission found that the overall master plan is consistent with the applicable subdistrict goals and policies of the Central City 2035 plan, with conditions related to ensuring open spaces are open to public access.

608
00:51:55.920 --> 00:52:13.152
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For Criterion H2, the Design Commission found that the master plan demonstrates how future development will comply with applicable guidelines from the Central City Fundamental Design Guidelines and the Lloyd District Design Guidelines, with a condition of approval related to the design of proposed open spaces.

609
00:52:13.266 --> 00:52:13.396
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

610
00:52:14.677 --> 00:52:26.717
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Criterion H3 only applies to master plan areas that have river frontage, and Criterion H4 only applies to master plan areas that contain or are within 500 feet of industrial uses.

611
00:52:28.690 --> 00:52:52.708
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For Criterion H5, the Design Commission found that the master plan proposes required ground floor active uses, required building lines, and main entrances on the south frontages of development areas 10 and 11, which will help the development engage Holiday Park through its massing and active uses at the ground floor rather than creating an abrupt edge, and proposed development will not excessively shade the park.

612
00:52:54.661 --> 00:52:59.275
<v Benjamin Nielsen>There are no transit stations within or immediately adjacent to the master plan area.

613
00:52:59.485 --> 00:53:23.186
<v Benjamin Nielsen>However, with regard to criterion H6, the Design Commission found that the proposed master plan will strengthen the Northeast 11th Avenue and Northeast 13th Avenue connections through the master plan area, which will help to provide easier access for residents and pedestrians located north of the master plan area to the Lloyd Center Northeast 11th Avenue MAX station on the south side of Holiday Park.

614
00:53:25.407 --> 00:53:44.324
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For Criterion H7, the Design Commission found that the open spaces for the master plan area are proposed as a network of interlaced plazas and gardens, and they are proposed to be developed in conjunction with adjacent development areas as specified in the infrastructure capabilities section of the main master plan document.

615
00:53:45.079 --> 00:53:51.619
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The 7 major open areas are intentionally scaled to accommodate a variety of uses and events.

616
00:53:52.278 --> 00:54:09.014
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Since public access to the proposed open space network is critical to ensuring that the open spaces are accessible within the master plan, provide connections to surrounding neighborhoods and open spaces, and serve as functional and equitable organizing framework for future development in the master plan area, Yes.

617
00:54:10.574 --> 00:54:20.469
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Design Commission found that public access easements should be placed on all proposed open spaces and passageways within the master plan area as a condition of approval.

618
00:54:22.619 --> 00:54:35.114
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For Criterion H8, extensive findings related to the applicant's transportation impact study were drafted by PP&D transportation review staff and PBOT engineering staff.

619
00:54:35.795 --> 00:54:56.101
<v Benjamin Nielsen>They evaluated street capacity, level of service, connectivity, availability of and impacts on circulation in pedestrian and bicycle networks, transit availability and impacts on transit circulation, access restrictions, neighborhood impacts, and safety, among other issues, as part of their review.

620
00:54:57.065 --> 00:55:07.802
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Design Commission agreed with the proposed findings, which show that the transportation system is capable of supporting the proposed uses in addition to existing uses in the master plan area.

621
00:55:09.440 --> 00:55:22.777
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Design Commission also adopted the numerous conditions which balance the applicant's desire for flexibility in development with the phasing needed for transportation and underground infrastructure to support proposed development.

622
00:55:24.679 --> 00:55:35.777
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For criterion H9, which deals with multimodal street connections, the Design Commission found that the street grid surrounding the master plan area is interrupted with superblock development.

623
00:55:36.498 --> 00:55:45.719
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The proposed streets and private accessways in the master plan tie together the public rights-of-way that, that are offset from each other to the north and south of the site.

624
00:55:46.521 --> 00:56:02.177
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Pedestrian and bicycle access is provided at roughly 200-foot intervals throughout the master plan area, and the Design Commission also adopted conditions of approval to ensure that all internal accessways that are not public streets will have public access easements.

625
00:56:04.239 --> 00:56:27.840
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For Criterion H10, which works to ensure that there will be adequate and timely infrastructure capacity for new development, PP&D Public Works staff reviewed the proposed phasing plans for development of new streets, accessways, open space, and infrastructure, and staff proposed findings and conditions regarding the phasing of their construction that were adopted by the Design Commission in their decision.

626
00:56:27.889 --> 00:56:27.985
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

627
00:56:28.980 --> 00:56:41.918
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Most of the conditions of approval are organized into an infrastructure phasing table to ensure that all necessary infrastructure is timely delivered for the respective infrastructure zones and development areas in the master plan.

628
00:56:44.175 --> 00:57:00.297
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For criterion H-11, which deals with ensuring that inactive uses are consolidated within the master plan area, the Design Commission found that parking and loading access has been consolidated to have a minimal presence on public streets And no presence along proposed open spaces.

629
00:57:01.135 --> 00:57:05.338
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Where possible, parking and loading access is combined into one access point.

630
00:57:05.806 --> 00:57:13.677
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Back of house and other inactive functions can share these points of access, subject to future design and evaluation through the design review process.

631
00:57:16.260 --> 00:57:20.440
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The proposal also includes 2 adjustments to zoning code development standards.

632
00:57:21.034 --> 00:57:37.565
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Adjustment review approval criteria can be found in zoning code section Section 33.805.040A through F. Both adjustments are related to the required building line standard in the zone— in Zoning Code Chapter 33.510.

633
00:57:38.403 --> 00:57:51.784
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The first adjustment request provides additional flexibility for the design of future buildings at the northeast and northwest corners of the master plan area and at Development Area 9 in the center of the master plan.

634
00:57:52.715 --> 00:58:02.536
<v Benjamin Nielsen>In these areas, buildings may be set back from the sidewalk edge rather than abutting the sidewalk, allowing space for additional plazas, landscaping, and courtyards.

635
00:58:03.434 --> 00:58:21.860
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The second adjustment request resolves a technicality with the zoning code and will result in typical urban-type buildings with strong sidewalk presence, while maintaining the desired landscaped character in the zoning code along Northeast 9th Avenue and Northeast 15th and 16th Avenue frontages.

636
00:58:23.583 --> 00:58:31.536
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The Design Commission found that the purpose of the standards would be equally met and that the desired character of the area would still be achieved with each of these adjustments.

637
00:58:32.293 --> 00:58:35.753
<v Benjamin Nielsen>So wrapping up, there are 3 options before City Council today.

638
00:58:36.989 --> 00:58:43.757
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Council may deny both appeals and uphold the Design Commission's decision and conditions of approval with revised findings.

639
00:58:44.920 --> 00:59:01.641
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Deny both appeals and uphold the Design Commission's decision, but with revised conditions of approval and findings, or grant one or both of the appeals and overturn the Design Commission's decision to approve the application with revised findings.

640
00:59:03.510 --> 00:59:09.608
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Should the council deny the appeals, staff will introduce a request for minor technical amendments to the conditions of approval.

641
00:59:10.177 --> 00:59:12.465
<v Benjamin Nielsen>For the phasing of underground infrastructure.

642
00:59:13.751 --> 00:59:18.576
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Testimony has been submitted under numbers 71 and 92 for if you need additional details.

643
00:59:19.579 --> 00:59:21.085
<v Benjamin Nielsen>This concludes my presentation.

644
00:59:22.360 --> 00:59:33.840
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Design Commission Chair Chandra Robinson should also be available to provide brief testimony on the Design Commission's decision, if the council clerk can help facilitate that.

645
00:59:36.481 --> 00:59:37.896
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you, and sorry for going over.

646
00:59:38.043 --> 00:59:39.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

647
00:59:41.829 --> 00:59:45.407
<v Jamie Dunphy>And do we have Design Commissioner here, or are they online?

648
00:59:45.568 --> 00:59:46.998
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, the commissioner is online.

649
00:59:47.096 --> 00:59:48.076
<v Rebecca Dobert>We're promoting her.

650
00:59:48.380 --> 00:59:48.621
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect.

651
00:59:48.702 --> 00:59:49.103
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

652
00:59:53.829 --> 00:59:54.106
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello.

653
00:59:55.632 --> 00:59:58.894
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, I apologize that I can't be with you in person today.

654
00:59:59.121 --> 01:00:00.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>I would have so loved to be there.

655
01:00:01.554 --> 01:00:08.213
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you for making time for me to provide some brief comments after Ben's intro to the project.

656
01:00:08.759 --> 01:00:13.235
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Chandra Robinson, and I am the chair of the Portland Design Commission.

657
01:00:13.893 --> 01:00:19.543
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I'm here to testify on behalf of the Design Commission who voted to approve the Lloyd Center Master Plan.

658
01:00:20.105 --> 01:00:27.630
<v Rebecca Dobert>So through review of the documents, the applicant and staff presentations, and all the public testimony we heard, we did unanimously vote to approve the master plan.

659
01:00:28.070 --> 01:00:30.260
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's a voluntary master plan.

660
01:00:30.260 --> 01:00:38.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>The applicant definitely could have demolished and rebuilt without going through this process, but they did it intentionally so that they could have more flexibility in the development.

661
01:00:38.920 --> 01:00:46.880
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I really appreciate that they did so, so that the public has the opportunity to come and share their thoughts publicly about the development.

662
01:00:46.880 --> 01:00:52.269
<v Rebecca Dobert>The design of the master plan meets the criteria set forth in the design guidelines, and it adheres to the zoning code.

663
01:00:52.619 --> 01:00:57.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Our thinking and process are all on the record and publicly available, so I'm not intending to review all that today.

664
01:00:57.739 --> 01:00:57.960
<v Rebecca Dobert>I just want to talk a little bit about public testimony.

665
01:00:57.960 --> 01:00:58.000
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

666
01:01:00.719 --> 01:01:06.449
<v Rebecca Dobert>We approved the master plan after having heard hours of public testimony and read through hundreds of pieces of written testimony.

667
01:01:07.059 --> 01:01:13.608
<v Rebecca Dobert>We spent several hours in, in just one hearing listening to public testimony, which is what you are going to do with your process as well.

668
01:01:14.282 --> 01:01:21.568
<v Rebecca Dobert>And we knew the community was passionate about the Lloyd Center in its current phase, and we didn't want to rush that deliberation after having heard so much testimony.

669
01:01:21.617 --> 01:01:23.414
<v Rebecca Dobert>So we sat with it until the following hearing.

670
01:01:24.152 --> 01:01:31.554
<v Rebecca Dobert>And in my role as chair, I really set the tone for the meeting, and I made clear to all attendees What the Design Commission has purview over and what it does not.

671
01:01:31.635 --> 01:01:36.101
<v Rebecca Dobert>So, as members of the public testified, I welcome their testimony.

672
01:01:36.534 --> 01:01:39.923
<v Rebecca Dobert>I thank them for participating in this really important democratic process.

673
01:01:40.389 --> 01:01:45.016
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I also reminded them that the Design Commission does not have the power to stop demolition of a property.

674
01:01:45.530 --> 01:01:50.717
<v Rebecca Dobert>Our purview is evaluating the design of the master plan for its response to the design guidelines.

675
01:01:51.311 --> 01:02:01.237
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I shared that even though the issues the community members brought forth were not in our power to vote on, We as a commission absolutely value their participation and their input into the process.

676
01:02:01.990 --> 01:02:11.913
<v Rebecca Dobert>Land use hearings are where people come to publicly share their opinions and ask questions about development in their communities, and that is a right that's upheld on a larger scale in the Constitution.

677
01:02:12.490 --> 01:02:25.077
<v Rebecca Dobert>Design commission members took time after public testimony to allow for the applicant to address issues brought up by the public, and the commission then asked additional questions as well about their work with community members and how they were assisting the current tenants.

678
01:02:25.143 --> 01:02:25.271
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

679
01:02:25.740 --> 01:02:26.619
<v Rebecca Dobert>Into new places.

680
01:02:26.961 --> 01:02:30.655
<v Rebecca Dobert>So in the next scheduled hearing, we deliberated without any additional verbal testimony.

681
01:02:31.099 --> 01:02:35.449
<v Rebecca Dobert>But as Ben said, there were hundreds of additional pieces of written testimony we reviewed prior to that.

682
01:02:36.242 --> 01:02:47.786
<v Rebecca Dobert>So staff across all bureaus put in hundreds of hours evaluating the master plan for its adherence to code and work through all of the very complex details of the plan before the Design Commission ever sees it.

683
01:02:48.206 --> 01:02:51.773
<v Rebecca Dobert>So there's a ton of work that goes into it, and all the design commissioners are really passionate about.

684
01:02:52.336 --> 01:03:16.079
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, looking at things that improve the public realm, and we really did see that this project met the criteria, um, set forth in the design guidelines and, um, and really was a master plan that we could clearly see would change the district and create a better public realm, which is one of our main focuses, is about how, how projects impact the public realm for people.

685
01:03:16.128 --> 01:03:21.875
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I just want to share that part about the testimony with you about how important it is and how it's something that we really appreciate.

686
01:03:21.922 --> 01:03:22.018
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

687
01:03:22.498 --> 01:03:30.813
<v Rebecca Dobert>And you will see that as well today, that there are a lot of people who are really passionate, but we do stand by our decision to approve the master plan.

688
01:03:31.250 --> 01:03:36.175
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I thank Ben and all the staff who worked on this for all their great work to get us there.

689
01:03:37.532 --> 01:03:37.936
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

690
01:03:39.405 --> 01:03:40.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

691
01:03:44.079 --> 01:03:47.753
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, that concludes the staff report.

692
01:03:48.902 --> 01:03:52.197
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe the next presentation is the, uh, the first appellant.

693
01:03:52.293 --> 01:03:53.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that correct?

694
01:03:53.385 --> 01:03:53.498
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

695
01:03:53.563 --> 01:03:58.632
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, welcome up, folks.

696
01:04:00.737 --> 01:04:01.027
<v Jamie Dunphy>Morning.

697
01:04:01.206 --> 01:04:01.708
<v Jamie Dunphy>Morning.

698
01:04:06.282 --> 01:04:07.561
<v Jamie Dunphy>And introduce yourselves for the record.

699
01:04:07.625 --> 01:04:11.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>And you have, uh, I believe you actually get a little bit extra because the time ran over.

700
01:04:11.619 --> 01:04:12.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that right, or how's that work?

701
01:04:12.815 --> 01:04:13.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>Not from staff time.

702
01:04:13.786 --> 01:04:14.385
<v Jamie Dunphy>Not from the staff time.

703
01:04:14.432 --> 01:04:14.853
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, great.

704
01:04:14.902 --> 01:04:17.157
<v Jamie Dunphy>So you have 10 minutes.

705
01:04:17.817 --> 01:04:18.235
<v Jamie Dunphy>Take it away.

706
01:04:18.317 --> 01:04:18.735
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

707
01:04:19.186 --> 01:04:19.653
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

708
01:04:19.766 --> 01:04:21.103
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Jeff Kleinman.

709
01:04:21.442 --> 01:04:25.298
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am the attorney for Save Lloyd Ice Coalition.

710
01:04:25.961 --> 01:04:33.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>With me is Jenny Gilmore Robinson, who is a member of the coalition and one of the appellants.

711
01:04:35.719 --> 01:05:00.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>The coalition consists of users of the ice rink, family members of users of the ice rink, And just, you know, wanna point out that this is the only publicly available and accessible link, excuse me, rink in the city for those learning to skate, for recreational users, and for aspiring professional skaters, unless they wanna play ice hockey.

712
01:05:02.443 --> 01:05:09.088
<v Jamie Dunphy>My clients are not opposed to any of the housing elements of the proposed master plan.

713
01:05:10.090 --> 01:05:16.304
<v Jamie Dunphy>Whenever those eventually get built up, whenever the market will support it.

714
01:05:16.692 --> 01:05:22.681
<v Jamie Dunphy>They're concerned about preserving a unique community resource that already exists.

715
01:05:23.713 --> 01:05:34.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>They ask that the matter be remanded to the Design Commission for this purpose, or that the appropriate condition of approval be added by the city.

716
01:05:34.253 --> 01:05:34.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>Second.

717
01:05:35.056 --> 01:05:35.606
<v Jamie Dunphy>The Council.

718
01:05:37.579 --> 01:05:47.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>The Design Commission was directed that since the rink does not have a historic designation, there is no argument for preserving it.

719
01:05:48.599 --> 01:05:59.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>In our appeal document, we listed several code criteria which are in fact directly applicable regardless and did not receive due consideration.

720
01:06:01.193 --> 01:06:03.092
<v Jamie Dunphy>By the Design Commission.

721
01:06:03.929 --> 01:06:12.981
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll note that in a letter that was filed on Monday, the applicant's attorney came up with other reasons for denying the appeal.

722
01:06:13.579 --> 01:06:17.628
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we've responded to that in a letter filed last night.

723
01:06:19.550 --> 01:06:23.536
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we attached to it the original grounds for the appeal, which are complete.

724
01:06:24.119 --> 01:06:26.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>So you could have all that in one place.

725
01:06:26.681 --> 01:06:26.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

726
01:06:27.356 --> 01:06:33.137
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will reserve further comments on the applicant's statement until rebuttal time.

727
01:06:36.532 --> 01:06:49.518
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to identify certain of the Master Plan review criteria that are directly applicable, have nothing to do with whether it's a— there's a historic resource or not.

728
01:06:50.211 --> 01:06:52.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>And these include—.

729
01:06:52.726 --> 01:06:53.177
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry.

730
01:06:53.978 --> 01:07:02.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>Regarding community building, encourage public spaces, public art, and activities that celebrate the history of the district.

731
01:07:03.268 --> 01:07:10.277
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, this was the last vestige of the history of the district of the rest of the— if the rest of the center goes.

732
01:07:12.539 --> 01:07:18.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>Foster more intense development in the Central Lloyd area and Rose Quarter while strengthening the distinct character.

733
01:07:19.050 --> 01:07:19.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

734
01:07:19.190 --> 01:07:20.150
<v Jamie Dunphy>What's the purpose of this ordinance?

735
01:07:20.215 --> 01:07:21.177
<v Jamie Dunphy>To enhance the character of the existing Lloyd subareas.

736
01:07:23.306 --> 01:07:24.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Rip out the rink.

737
01:07:27.942 --> 01:07:33.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>Embellish an area by integrating elements in new development that build on the area's character.

738
01:07:34.369 --> 01:07:40.291
<v Jamie Dunphy>Identify an area's special features or qualities by integrating them into new development.

739
01:07:41.168 --> 01:07:51.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>And encourage the inclusion of features in the design of projects That give projects identity and a sense of place or significance within the district.

740
01:07:52.224 --> 01:07:59.094
<v Jamie Dunphy>The rink does all that, but these criteria received short shrift from the Design Commission.

741
01:08:01.297 --> 01:08:12.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's been quite a bit of chatter since the Design Commission met and made its decision regarding possible alternative sites for the rink.

742
01:08:13.862 --> 01:08:17.043
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I just want to make a couple of points on that for you.

743
01:08:19.592 --> 01:08:30.644
<v Jamie Dunphy>Number one, there would've been a lot of time to do that had my clients not been continuously sandbagged by the applicant's representatives.

744
01:08:32.652 --> 01:08:43.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Who up to the time of the Design Commission hearings, reiterated that the rink would be preserved within the project.

745
01:08:44.306 --> 01:08:51.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it was only at design commission that those representatives walked away.

746
01:08:52.545 --> 01:08:56.055
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now, since that time, my clients have been—.

747
01:08:56.957 --> 01:08:57.698
<v Jamie Dunphy>Whoop.

748
01:08:58.181 --> 01:09:04.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>My clients have been actually conferring with various agencies about the possibility of relocation.

749
01:09:04.796 --> 01:09:14.555
<v Jamie Dunphy>And what I wanna say about that is that they've received very nice listening and they've been encouraged to talk to other agencies.

750
01:09:14.603 --> 01:09:16.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so it's all very circular.

751
01:09:16.751 --> 01:09:29.185
<v Jamie Dunphy>If there must be a relocation, it's gonna require you folks to designate an individual at City Hall with responsibility to get the darn thing done.

752
01:09:29.250 --> 01:09:29.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

753
01:09:30.676 --> 01:09:36.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>And for the benefit— folks, I'm sorry, can we please halt with the clapping?

754
01:09:37.166 --> 01:09:38.737
<v Jamie Dunphy>Other ways to show, to display.

755
01:09:39.489 --> 01:09:47.822
<v Jamie Dunphy>For the benefit of the users, continuity is critical, especially for the kids learning to skate.

756
01:09:48.143 --> 01:09:56.171
<v Jamie Dunphy>So however that relocation process is conducted, there needs to be no interruption in the availability of a rink.

757
01:09:57.152 --> 01:09:58.082
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

758
01:10:00.216 --> 01:10:02.139
<v Rebecca Dobert>For the record, my name is Jenny Gilmore Robinson.

759
01:10:02.559 --> 01:10:08.975
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm a District 3 resident and the mom to a 9-year-old who fell in love with skating the first time she stepped on the ice at the Lloyd Center.

760
01:10:10.260 --> 01:10:20.287
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm also representative of Save Lloyd Ice Coalition, and as council said, we're here today to urge you to preserve, replace, or relocate the ice rink so that future generations can continue to skate.

761
01:10:20.761 --> 01:10:22.011
<v Rebecca Dobert>Without your intervention, Aye.

762
01:10:22.171 --> 01:10:22.461
<v Rebecca Dobert>Motion passes.

763
01:10:22.573 --> 01:10:24.420
<v Rebecca Dobert>In 2023, Portland will lose its only ice rink.

764
01:10:25.287 --> 01:10:29.605
<v Rebecca Dobert>For more than 65 years, the Lloyd Center Ice Rink has been woven into Portland's cultural identity.

765
01:10:30.039 --> 01:10:35.305
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's introduced generations of Portlanders to skating, trained Olympians, and created memories for countless families.

766
01:10:35.804 --> 01:10:38.131
<v Rebecca Dobert>But its importance goes beyond nostalgia.

767
01:10:38.550 --> 01:10:43.993
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink's location in a shopping mall made skating accessible in a way that no area skating facility can match.

768
01:10:44.426 --> 01:10:50.506
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's where beginners felt comfortable trying the sport for the first time, Where many went on to take classes, perform, and compete.

769
01:10:50.988 --> 01:10:56.278
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's also the place where people who have historically been excluded from skating feel genuinely welcome.

770
01:10:56.903 --> 01:11:04.261
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is where our LGBTQ skaters, our adaptive skaters, and our Black and brown skaters have found community where they belong.

771
01:11:04.438 --> 01:11:05.448
<v Rebecca Dobert>And you're going to hear that today.

772
01:11:06.296 --> 01:11:07.965
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink is also uniquely accessible.

773
01:11:08.364 --> 01:11:11.811
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's the only rink Portlanders can reasonably reach by public transit or bike.

774
01:11:12.149 --> 01:11:17.381
<v Rebecca Dobert>Rinks in Washington County or Vancouver are difficult to visit for families and virtually impossible for those without a car.

775
01:11:18.087 --> 01:11:22.984
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center also offers significantly more affordable public skating lessons and training compared to other rinks.

776
01:11:23.466 --> 01:11:32.426
<v Rebecca Dobert>And when that accessibility disappears, families who rely on this rink will be pushed out of the sport, and even more Portlanders will never get the opportunity to step on the ice at all.

777
01:11:33.180 --> 01:11:38.367
<v Rebecca Dobert>Skating shouldn't be an activity reserved for the wealthy or a sport in which only the privileged can succeed.

778
01:11:39.170 --> 01:11:49.917
<v Rebecca Dobert>That is why the community reacted so strongly when we learned the rink was excluded from the master plan, because for years the applicant publicly represented that a skating rink would remain part of the Lloyd Center vision.

779
01:11:50.350 --> 01:11:55.932
<v Rebecca Dobert>As shown in my written testimony, those commitments appeared in the media, presentations, community materials.

780
01:11:56.286 --> 01:12:20.474
<v Rebecca Dobert>As late as 2025— sorry, December of 2025— project materials continued to depict or reference an ice rink, and even city staff still believed that a rink was included in the I raise this not to shame anyone, but to explain why our community felt blindsided, because it was less than a week before the February 5th Design Commission hearing that most of us learned through news coverage that the rink was no longer included in the plan.

781
01:12:21.228 --> 01:12:22.706
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's not meaningful engagement.

782
01:12:23.235 --> 01:12:25.948
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's when our community began mobilizing to find a solution.

783
01:12:26.462 --> 01:12:34.860
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so in the 4 months since then, volunteers from the skating community have reached out to public officials, agencies, developers, nonprofits, and private funders.

784
01:12:35.278 --> 01:12:42.760
<v Rebecca Dobert>We've met with the applicant, explored alternative locations, and identified philanthropic partners who are willing to support a future rink.

785
01:12:43.242 --> 01:12:45.136
<v Rebecca Dobert>These efforts were all community-led.

786
01:12:45.810 --> 01:12:53.887
<v Rebecca Dobert>Through that work, we've learned that obstacles— the obstacle isn't a lack of community support or operational expertise or financial viability.

787
01:12:54.546 --> 01:12:59.054
<v Rebecca Dobert>To be clear, we are not asking the city to fund or operate a rink.

788
01:12:59.711 --> 01:13:07.884
<v Rebecca Dobert>If a location can be secured, we have the user base, the expertise, and the philanthropic partners that are needed to make a permanent ice rink successful.

789
01:13:08.493 --> 01:13:13.091
<v Rebecca Dobert>But the challenge, as council has stated, is that no public entity has helped by taking the lead.

790
01:13:13.621 --> 01:13:17.226
<v Rebecca Dobert>Throughout our outreach, we found widespread support for retaining a permanent ice rink.

791
01:13:17.483 --> 01:13:23.301
<v Rebecca Dobert>What we haven't found yet is a public entity that will help carry this work forward towards a permanent solution.

792
01:13:24.280 --> 01:13:31.188
<v Rebecca Dobert>Had the applicant informed the skating community that the rink would be excluded from the plan, this work could have begun years earlier.

793
01:13:31.604 --> 01:13:37.661
<v Rebecca Dobert>Instead, volunteers have been forced to compress what should have been long-term planning into 4 exhausting months.

794
01:13:38.110 --> 01:13:42.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>That falls short of the meaningful community engagement envisioned by Portland's design guidelines.

795
01:13:43.090 --> 01:13:47.635
<v Rebecca Dobert>Remanding the master plan back to the Design Commission doesn't send a negative signal to investors.

796
01:13:48.132 --> 01:13:48.969
<v Rebecca Dobert>It reinforces Councilmember Herbold.

797
01:13:49.016 --> 01:13:56.868
<v Rebecca Dobert>This ordinance subverts Portland's longstanding expectation that major redevelopment projects will engage affected communities early and meaningfully.

798
01:13:57.527 --> 01:14:01.122
<v Rebecca Dobert>Had that happened here, we would already be closer to a solution.

799
01:14:02.118 --> 01:14:07.979
<v Rebecca Dobert>In closing, we respectfully ask City Council to ensure that Portland retains a permanent year-round ice rink.

800
01:14:08.381 --> 01:14:14.658
<v Rebecca Dobert>Either remand this matter back to the Design Commission for effective community engagement and solution finding, or designate someone at Councilmember Wilson.

801
01:14:14.722 --> 01:14:18.448
<v Rebecca Dobert>I urge City Hall to convene the necessary partners and take ownership of identifying a rink solution.

802
01:14:19.042 --> 01:14:27.247
<v Rebecca Dobert>There is still time to protect something that has served Portland families for generations, but once it's gone, it will be extraordinarily difficult to bring back.

803
01:14:27.953 --> 01:14:33.926
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I want my daughter and her friends and every Portlander to have the chance to keep skating in our city.

804
01:14:34.537 --> 01:14:36.046
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you for your kind consideration.

805
01:14:40.934 --> 01:14:42.275
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for your presentation.

806
01:14:42.390 --> 01:14:47.402
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe we're now moving to the second appellant for an additional 10-minute presentation.

807
01:14:47.886 --> 01:14:48.421
<v Jamie Dunphy>Point of order.

808
01:14:48.841 --> 01:14:50.118
<v Rebecca Dobert>Do, do we get to ask questions?

809
01:14:50.369 --> 01:14:50.668
<v Rebecca Dobert>Not yet.

810
01:14:50.966 --> 01:14:51.143
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Okay.

811
01:15:07.569 --> 01:15:10.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have our second appellant coming up.

812
01:15:14.886 --> 01:15:16.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okey-dokey.

813
01:15:17.251 --> 01:15:18.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, they're upstairs.

814
01:15:19.244 --> 01:15:19.631
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect.

815
01:15:19.728 --> 01:15:20.225
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, great.

816
01:15:20.435 --> 01:15:20.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

817
01:15:21.336 --> 01:15:22.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll wait just a moment then.

818
01:15:28.329 --> 01:15:29.890
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Smith.

819
01:15:58.502 --> 01:16:05.592
<v Rebecca Dobert>There he is.

820
01:16:18.573 --> 01:16:18.836
<v Rebecca Dobert>Welcome.

821
01:16:18.984 --> 01:16:19.082
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Hey.

822
01:16:29.658 --> 01:16:36.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can I make one request before I start?

823
01:16:37.488 --> 01:16:37.893
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

824
01:16:38.636 --> 01:16:39.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I was taking some notes.

825
01:16:40.042 --> 01:16:49.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, much of the proceedings so far feel almost choreographed to, uh, crush our spirits as 10,000 community members strong.

826
01:16:49.988 --> 01:17:06.475
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm referring specifically to Benjamin Nielsen's context overview, reading a bit like an advertisement for the developer's plan and using language that presumes the inevitability of the master plan's implementation despite 2 pending appeals still being heard.

827
01:17:07.832 --> 01:17:14.878
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the postponement of the testimony from the appellants, is that what's being proposed?

828
01:17:14.926 --> 01:17:14.975
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

829
01:17:15.600 --> 01:17:16.681
<v Jamie Dunphy>Postponed until tomorrow?

830
01:17:18.038 --> 01:17:19.056
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, of the applicants.

831
01:17:19.105 --> 01:17:21.287
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll get through the appellants today.

832
01:17:21.448 --> 01:17:32.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, because I think in, uh, I may have misheard, but, um, Councilor Dunphy, I thought you had said that, uh, we would just be hearing from the supporters of the master plan today.

833
01:17:32.721 --> 01:17:35.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>Nope, we will get through the supporters of the appellants today.

834
01:17:35.154 --> 01:17:38.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, um, thank you.

835
01:17:38.505 --> 01:17:39.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's a relief.

836
01:17:39.069 --> 01:17:48.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>That was actually going to be my request, is if we could have a mix All right, excuse me.

837
01:17:57.369 --> 01:17:58.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've been in a few times recently.

838
01:17:59.525 --> 01:18:04.177
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Matt Henderson, and I'm a lead organizer with the Save Lloyd campaign.

839
01:18:06.243 --> 01:18:11.274
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as we've stated, over 10,000 concerned citizens have now signed our petition opposing the planned demolition of Lloyd Center.

840
01:18:11.338 --> 01:18:11.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

841
01:18:14.252 --> 01:18:29.262
<v Jamie Dunphy>Additionally, hundreds and hundreds of people took the time to give substantive responses to an open-ended survey about the mall, sharing moving stories from their own lives, but also highlighting how the mall was evolving and their dreams for its future.

842
01:18:31.239 --> 01:18:41.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>Again and again, people describe Lloyd Center as something increasingly rare, a place where they can gather, connect, exercise, create, and participate in community life.

843
01:18:43.162 --> 01:18:56.404
<v Jamie Dunphy>They describe it as one of Portland's last great third spaces, one of the few year-round accessible indoor environments where people from all walks of life can meet and engage in healthy in-person social activity.

844
01:18:58.429 --> 01:19:08.064
<v Jamie Dunphy>We hope you'll accept the testimony today as evidence that shows Lloyd Center functions as civic infrastructure, a regional recreation destination.

845
01:19:08.578 --> 01:19:15.658
<v Jamie Dunphy>A small business and arts ecosystem, a transit-accessible gathering place, teen hangout, and so much more.

846
01:19:17.805 --> 01:19:20.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>And importantly, it's a landmark tied to Portland's memory.

847
01:19:22.542 --> 01:19:27.884
<v Jamie Dunphy>And even as more and more businesses are forced out, memories are still being made at Lloyd Center every day.

848
01:19:30.063 --> 01:19:33.972
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are asking Council to help us as a city to recognize this living place.

849
01:19:34.676 --> 01:19:45.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>A place that was actively becoming something hopeful again, something creative and useful, and something Portland and the developers should be proud to protect and build upon.

850
01:19:48.020 --> 01:19:57.942
<v Jamie Dunphy>One community member put it this way: I encourage you to think ahead to the city's long-term financial benefit of having another jewel in Portland's crown, one of a— one of a kind attraction.

851
01:20:00.243 --> 01:20:06.877
<v Jamie Dunphy>Preserving the Lloyd Center's present iteration makes long-term fiscal, cultural, social, and infrastructural sense.

852
01:20:07.858 --> 01:20:13.123
<v Jamie Dunphy>All you need to do is continue to invest in this place to reap incredible benefits on literally all fronts.

853
01:20:15.246 --> 01:20:20.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>Up until recently, our city was widely seen as a bastion of creativity and environmental leadership.

854
01:20:22.118 --> 01:20:27.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>The dream of the '90s is alive in Portland, was the famous refrain from the 2010s era Portlandia.

855
01:20:28.752 --> 01:20:29.845
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keep Portland weird.

856
01:20:31.019 --> 01:20:33.992
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's the very brand that Portland's modern image was built on.

857
01:20:34.537 --> 01:20:35.518
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's part of our DNA.

858
01:20:36.483 --> 01:20:42.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>And no place in Portland has embodied this spirit or this ethos more than Lloyd Center in recent years.

859
01:20:45.157 --> 01:20:51.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>And yet the public is being asked to accept that the only way to move Portland forward is to wipe this place clean.

860
01:20:53.302 --> 01:20:57.037
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this is the false choice at the heart of this developer's proposal.

861
01:20:58.490 --> 01:21:14.854
<v Jamie Dunphy>We can support housing, we can support density, we can support reinvestment in Lloyd District, but we do not have to accept that those goals require the complete destruction of one of Portland's most useful, beloved, and proven public spaces.

862
01:21:16.460 --> 01:21:33.354
<v Jamie Dunphy>We reject the idea that the only path to those goals is the full demolition of a place that already serves the public, already contains beautiful reusable structure and already holds the foundation to the kind of community life that this master plan would only hope to create.

863
01:21:36.579 --> 01:21:45.213
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now, before I begin detailing our refutations of the approval criteria, we'll ask a simple question, which is the overarching basis of our appeal.

864
01:21:47.640 --> 01:21:58.311
<v Jamie Dunphy>How can a proposal be said to advance the goals of the city's design criteria While simultaneously dismantling one of the most shining examples of those very goals and criteria.

865
01:22:00.731 --> 01:22:10.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>Under Policy 2LD3, Community Building, the public record shows that Lloyd Center is already capable of excelling at the work this policy asks for.

866
01:22:11.305 --> 01:22:26.445
<v Jamie Dunphy>Portland creatives, small businesses, skaters, artists, youth programs, mall walkers, Families, special needs communities, neighbors, we're all actively building one of the most vital and diverse mixed-use hubs in the city.

867
01:22:28.319 --> 01:22:36.692
<v Jamie Dunphy>The master plan will dismantle it while talking about future gathering spaces, but it does not adequately address the community that is here now.

868
01:22:39.199 --> 01:22:54.675
<v Jamie Dunphy>Under Policy 1LD2, Sustainability Innovation, The master plan does not meaningfully address adaptive reuse, embodied carbon, or the environmental impacts of cutting short the lifespan of a recently renovated super large structure.

869
01:22:56.710 --> 01:23:04.676
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lloyd Center received a major $50 million renovation just 10 years ago, including energy efficiency and structural upgrades.

870
01:23:05.869 --> 01:23:13.737
<v Jamie Dunphy>The greenest building is often the one left standing, and yet this plan presents itself as sustainable While treating demolition as the starting point.

871
01:23:15.970 --> 01:23:22.293
<v Jamie Dunphy>Policy 1LD1, Employment Core, supporting new and existing retail development.

872
01:23:23.100 --> 01:23:28.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>This one's a little bit personal for me as someone who's been actively leasing space at Lloyd Center for the past 3 years.

873
01:23:30.265 --> 01:23:38.548
<v Jamie Dunphy>Reimagining community was the ad campaign slogan chosen by Urban Renaissance Group to help lure local businesses into the mall.

874
01:23:39.922 --> 01:23:55.087
<v Jamie Dunphy>It turned out to work a little too well, but primarily due to the businesses within the mall bootstrapping their own PR, grabbing headlines, and steadily increasing foot traffic for themselves, putting big pristine smiles on people's faces, by the way.

875
01:23:55.167 --> 01:23:59.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've witnessed it daily for all, all 3 years I've been there.

876
01:24:00.983 --> 01:24:18.613
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now imagine the biting irony of the owners then bringing in community partners To help empty out the mall with taglines like, we're creating a thriving business community in Lloyd, with the subtext being anywhere in Lloyd District that isn't in this upward-trending mall.

877
01:24:22.050 --> 01:24:29.157
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thousands of Portlanders have offered their vote of confidence that Lloyd Center was on track to becoming a regional attraction again.

878
01:24:30.649 --> 01:24:42.565
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because it was becoming something new, When we think of places that define cities, we often think of places that were similarly threatened with demolition.

879
01:24:43.438 --> 01:24:51.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seattle's Pike Place Market, New York's Grand Central Station were both rescued from the brink only to become enduring landmarks in those cities.

880
01:24:54.609 --> 01:24:57.524
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's 2 remaining guidelines that we feel are woefully unmet.

881
01:24:58.023 --> 01:25:03.354
<v Jamie Dunphy>Guideline A2, emphasizing Portland themes, and Guideline A3, This is an outright affront.

882
01:25:03.564 --> 01:25:07.367
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lloyd Center has been a cornucopia of the qualities that define Portland.

883
01:25:08.154 --> 01:25:18.795
<v Jamie Dunphy>The real question is whether the master plan can hope to replace 65 years of history and manage to recapture this rare form of cultural revitalization we've seen at the mall in the past few years.

884
01:25:20.271 --> 01:25:26.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lastly, Guideline A6, reuse, rehabilitate, and restore existing structures where feasible.

885
01:25:27.493 --> 01:25:29.452
<v Jamie Dunphy>This one fails most spectacularly.

886
01:25:29.500 --> 01:25:29.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Dan Ryan.

887
01:25:30.944 --> 01:25:37.496
<v Jamie Dunphy>In Lloyd Eco District, of all places, with the owner's claim that Lloyd Center is incapable of being adapted.

888
01:25:38.652 --> 01:25:41.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>Again, thousands of Portlanders have testified the opposite.

889
01:25:41.686 --> 01:25:53.457
<v Jamie Dunphy>They have seen and described the reuse potential in detailed visions, as if their minds just can't help from coloring in all the amazing possibilities inherent to this magical structure.

890
01:25:53.505 --> 01:25:53.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

891
01:25:57.953 --> 01:26:14.954
<v Jamie Dunphy>We feel our case is straightforward and strong, that City Council should act to uphold the spirit and the letter of the criteria by which the master plan was meant to be evaluated, keeping Portland's values and existing communities closely in mind.

892
01:26:15.951 --> 01:26:33.548
<v Jamie Dunphy>We ask our elected officials to listen to the public testimony and to consider the more than 10,000 Portlanders, and I'm not including the Lloyd Center ice rinks petition, which has 5,500, who called for meaningful preservation of Lloyd Center and its historic rink.

893
01:26:34.030 --> 01:26:39.894
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please ask yourselves, how can we encourage the ownership to invest in this landmark?

894
01:26:40.600 --> 01:26:44.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>How can we work together to make something incredible happen through this process?

895
01:26:45.498 --> 01:26:52.826
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are we really going to ignore the collective enthusiasm and protective instincts of such a large cross-section of our local community.

896
01:26:55.192 --> 01:27:09.846
<v Jamie Dunphy>Imagine 5 years from now if Portland were able to retain and nurture this civic asset into an expression of what our city is capable of, promoting livability and pride of place, attracting visitors, and serving as a model for other cities.

897
01:27:14.131 --> 01:27:16.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're not asking you, Council, to answer Thank you.

898
01:27:16.702 --> 01:27:21.246
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll get to other larger questions about the potentials and possibilities at Lloyd Center in this hearing.

899
01:27:21.600 --> 01:27:24.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>But for today, our immediate ask is clear.

900
01:27:24.328 --> 01:27:26.385
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do not approve this master plan as is.

901
01:27:26.801 --> 01:27:33.127
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's risky, destructive, and it's an insult to the history and continued significance of Lloyd Center to this community.

902
01:27:33.305 --> 01:27:33.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

903
01:27:45.463 --> 01:27:46.238
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

904
01:27:48.269 --> 01:27:55.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're now moving to testimony from the— actually, uh, before we begin testimony, I'm going to go ahead and give us our 10-minute break right now.

905
01:27:55.231 --> 01:28:00.712
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, and then when we get back, we will get into public testimony of some supporters of the appellant.

906
01:28:00.761 --> 01:28:07.238
<v Jamie Dunphy>So folks, please be back here at, uh, 11:05.

907
01:28:07.404 --> 01:45:47.628
<v Jamie Dunphy>They go after the Okay, we're coming back to order, folks.

908
01:45:48.801 --> 01:46:03.055
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, as we are coming back, I'd like to note that Vice President Clark has joined us, and I'm going to, uh, at the very beginning here, as we did with everybody else, ask President— Vice President Clark to declare if there are any conflicts of interest, ex parte communications, or any visits to the site.

909
01:46:03.345 --> 01:46:03.987
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

910
01:46:05.449 --> 01:46:05.835
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

911
01:46:06.569 --> 01:46:09.721
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council President, no ex parte contacts.

912
01:46:10.126 --> 01:46:12.890
<v Rebecca Dobert>I did receive about 20 emails which I didn't read.

913
01:46:13.537 --> 01:46:19.534
<v Rebecca Dobert>I inadvertently read one from a former colleague, but there are no conflicts of interest, no site visits.

914
01:46:20.310 --> 01:46:20.601
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect.

915
01:46:21.621 --> 01:46:21.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

916
01:46:22.090 --> 01:46:22.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

917
01:46:22.672 --> 01:46:23.141
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome back.

918
01:46:23.724 --> 01:46:27.007
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're now going to move towards public testimony from the appellants.

919
01:46:29.095 --> 01:46:40.965
<v Jamie Dunphy>Rebecca, just to make sure that everyone in the room has an opportunity Oh yeah, if there's anybody in the room, on the dais, or in the audience who wants to object about what Councilor Clark just said?

920
01:46:45.679 --> 01:46:49.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing none.

921
01:46:52.702 --> 01:46:54.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, objection noted for the record.

922
01:46:54.975 --> 01:46:55.301
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

923
01:46:58.149 --> 01:47:01.356
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Rebecca, do you wanna start us on public testimony?

924
01:47:03.516 --> 01:47:11.935
<v Rebecca Dobert>Quick, before we call the first name, for those signed up to testify today, reminder that each testifier has 90 seconds.

925
01:47:12.448 --> 01:47:14.757
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm gonna call you up in groups of 5.

926
01:47:15.599 --> 01:47:21.792
<v Rebecca Dobert>For those in person, you're gonna see a timer displayed in the monitor in front of the table where you're testifying.

927
01:47:22.390 --> 01:47:25.673
<v Rebecca Dobert>You will have a chime to let you know when you have 30 seconds left.

928
01:47:25.876 --> 01:47:28.382
<v Rebecca Dobert>And then a second chime to let you know when your time is up.

929
01:47:32.056 --> 01:47:32.636
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have a question.

930
01:47:32.702 --> 01:47:35.815
<v Rebecca Dobert>After the second chime, do you stop recording and stop record?

931
01:47:37.203 --> 01:47:38.737
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, everything is recorded.

932
01:47:40.123 --> 01:47:51.363
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay, our first 5 testifiers are Matt Kelly, Stephanie Winningham, Jerry Leonard, Anna Horowitz, and Una Sawyer.

933
01:47:55.390 --> 01:47:56.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on up, folks.

934
01:47:56.484 --> 01:47:59.144
<v Jamie Dunphy>Make sure to introduce yourselves for the record, and you'll have 90 seconds apiece.

935
01:47:59.515 --> 01:48:02.833
<v Jamie Dunphy>And whoever sits down first gets to go first if they want.

936
01:48:03.284 --> 01:48:05.581
<v Rebecca Dobert>And please state your name for the record when you begin.

937
01:48:08.356 --> 01:48:11.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, Council President Dunphy and Portland City Council.

938
01:48:11.277 --> 01:48:12.136
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Matt Kelly.

939
01:48:12.395 --> 01:48:15.787
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am a volunteer organizer alongside the Save Lloyd campaign.

940
01:48:16.252 --> 01:48:19.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>I support more housing and thoughtful change that meets Portland's responsibilities.

941
01:48:20.582 --> 01:48:25.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>During this climate crisis and demonstrates real sustainability innovation.

942
01:48:25.965 --> 01:48:31.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>The master plan fails to describe how it will meet the city's goal of innovation in waste reduction.

943
01:48:32.471 --> 01:48:39.476
<v Jamie Dunphy>It also fails to explain how the applicant will account for its demolition-first premise in light of Portland's waste reduction goals.

944
01:48:40.827 --> 01:48:46.690
<v Benjamin Nielsen>When crews demolished the Nordstrom building, they sent waste to Coffin Butte landfill 75 miles away.

945
01:48:47.556 --> 01:48:51.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is significant public opposition to the proposed expansion of that landfill.

946
01:48:52.542 --> 01:48:56.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our region is quite literally running out of room for more waste.

947
01:48:57.752 --> 01:49:05.815
<v Jamie Dunphy>The master plan asserts that, quote, none of the existing buildings are planned to remain because they're aging, single-use, and auto-oriented structures.

948
01:49:06.649 --> 01:49:11.137
<v Benjamin Nielsen>These conditions are not proof that adaptation is impossible.

949
01:49:12.404 --> 01:49:20.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>They are These are design and policy challenges, and all of them can be addressed through adaptive reuse strategies, just like the airport, I might add.

950
01:49:21.483 --> 01:49:30.432
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The authors of the master plan employ passive voice to make demolition sound like a condition of the buildings rather than a choice that they have made.

951
01:49:31.364 --> 01:49:43.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>That framing places far too much burden on the Lloyd Center itself and far too little responsibility on the technical Policy, financial, and civic tools at our disposal.

952
01:49:43.908 --> 01:49:46.475
<v Benjamin Nielsen>This is not a choice between the past and the future.

953
01:49:47.021 --> 01:49:52.654
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Let's make Lloyd Center a place that the city is proud to have adapted, not a place it regrets having erased.

954
01:49:53.055 --> 01:49:54.148
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Please uphold the appeals.

955
01:49:54.661 --> 01:50:03.552
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do not approve the plan without adequate findings on waste reduction, adaptive reuse, accessible ice skating, and Portland's responsibilities.

956
01:50:03.600 --> 01:50:04.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

957
01:50:05.889 --> 01:50:06.228
<v Jamie Dunphy>Go right ahead.

958
01:50:07.744 --> 01:50:14.846
<v Jamie Dunphy>And again, folks, I, I appreciate the shows of support, but we have to, uh, please try and use less, less audible ones.

959
01:50:15.011 --> 01:50:15.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

960
01:50:16.618 --> 01:50:17.176
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please go ahead.

961
01:50:18.760 --> 01:50:19.875
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hi, my name is Anna Horvitz.

962
01:50:19.923 --> 01:50:20.813
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm an adult skater.

963
01:50:21.863 --> 01:50:24.579
<v Rebecca Dobert>The Lloyd Center ice rink has been a second home to me for years.

964
01:50:24.838 --> 01:50:30.978
<v Rebecca Dobert>With affordable access to 50 hours of public skating per week, a sport I've loved for decades has become a part of my lifestyle.

965
01:50:31.752 --> 01:50:35.811
<v Rebecca Dobert>Other rinks are farther away, more expensive, and have limited public skate times.

966
01:50:36.550 --> 01:50:40.658
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ice skating opportunities for Portlanders will be severely limited if we lose our year-round rink.

967
01:50:41.940 --> 01:50:51.984
<v Rebecca Dobert>At the Lloyd Center Ice Rink, a highly diverse population of skaters, instructors, and staff come together to skate and to play, to laugh, to learn, to grow, and to support one another.

968
01:50:52.690 --> 01:50:55.675
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is quirky and welcoming in a way that is so very Portland.

969
01:50:56.140 --> 01:51:00.118
<v Rebecca Dobert>To lose this community center would mean losing an historic piece of Portland's unique charm.

970
01:51:01.595 --> 01:51:07.505
<v Rebecca Dobert>Being self-employed, self-supporting, and perpetually broke, I fully appreciate the importance of low-income housing.

971
01:51:08.243 --> 01:51:10.796
<v Rebecca Dobert>But it's not just the roof over one's head that makes a home.

972
01:51:11.246 --> 01:51:14.168
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's the neighborhood and community to which that home grants access.

973
01:51:15.100 --> 01:51:24.814
<v Rebecca Dobert>I ask that the City Council please return the master plan to the Design Commission, deferring approval until there is a binding agreement that preserves, replaces, or relocates our beloved Rink.

974
01:51:24.878 --> 01:51:25.087
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

975
01:51:25.439 --> 01:51:25.649
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

976
01:51:26.001 --> 01:51:26.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

977
01:51:30.350 --> 01:51:33.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi, I'm Jerry Leonard, adult skater with my wife Tally.

978
01:51:33.902 --> 01:51:50.622
<v Jamie Dunphy>In 2023, following significant community pushback and recognition of the iconic rink's importance, URG publicly committed to ensuring an ice rink remains a central feature in new plans, stating, and I quote, it's a non-negotiable element for the property's future.

979
01:51:50.703 --> 01:52:05.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>The new rink will likely be smaller and oval-shaped But the goal is to maintain its role as a community hub visible from all levels of the reimagined development with potential for affordable housing and other amenities surrounding it.

980
01:52:05.675 --> 01:52:10.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>Later, URG indicated it may be necessary to relocate the rink from its current location.

981
01:52:11.189 --> 01:52:15.436
<v Jamie Dunphy>The public outcry for the rink to remain in the redevelopment is still present.

982
01:52:15.934 --> 01:52:20.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is definitely a request that URG honor its own words of Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

983
01:52:20.590 --> 01:52:23.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would like to thank the City of Portland for its commitment to retaining a permanent ice rink.

984
01:52:23.029 --> 01:52:30.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>Historically, it has always provided great public relations, fostered community, and has promoted Lloyd Center.

985
01:52:30.050 --> 01:52:32.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's provided so much more than a place to skate.

986
01:52:32.829 --> 01:52:42.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>It has provided an atmosphere of goodwill and well-being, a place to escape the distractions in life while at the same time enjoying great physical exercise.

987
01:52:42.750 --> 01:52:50.292
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is essential that the City Council listen to their local constituents as well as what Urban Renaissance Group previously committed to.

988
01:52:51.081 --> 01:52:55.837
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is our hope that there will be a Lloyd Center Ice Arena for future generations to come.

989
01:52:55.902 --> 01:52:56.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

990
01:52:57.108 --> 01:52:57.717
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

991
01:52:59.753 --> 01:53:01.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sound be drawn up upstairs?

992
01:53:01.605 --> 01:53:02.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can it be louder up here?

993
01:53:02.905 --> 01:53:03.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's really hard.

994
01:53:04.204 --> 01:53:05.162
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll see what we can do.

995
01:53:07.126 --> 01:53:11.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>Point of information, can we ask whoever has that bird chirp thing to shut it up, please?

996
01:53:11.726 --> 01:53:13.068
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thanks.

997
01:53:15.387 --> 01:53:15.645
<v Jamie Dunphy>Go ahead.

998
01:53:15.869 --> 01:53:16.063
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

999
01:53:16.769 --> 01:53:21.201
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Lydia Finch, U.S. figure skating gold medalist, coach, and academy director.

1000
01:53:21.730 --> 01:53:25.262
<v Rebecca Dobert>Unlike many sports, figure skating is year-round, not seasonal.

1001
01:53:25.583 --> 01:53:36.166
<v Rebecca Dobert>Other rinks in the area such as Vancouver, Beaverton, and Sherwood facilities have turned away outside coaches, significantly increased costs, and have new policies that make it nearly impossible for many of our families to transition.

1002
01:53:36.823 --> 01:53:40.100
<v Rebecca Dobert>As the only Black figure skating coach in Portland, I have worked Thank you.

1003
01:53:40.100 --> 01:53:40.100
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilmember Smith.

1004
01:53:40.100 --> 01:53:40.100
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Mayor.

1005
01:53:40.100 --> 01:53:46.159
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have worked tirelessly to make this sport more welcoming, accessible for children that have never seen themselves represented on the ice.

1006
01:53:46.159 --> 01:53:52.850
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have watched young Black skaters walk into the rink, see someone who looks like them coaching, and believe that they belong in this sport too.

1007
01:53:53.199 --> 01:54:01.199
<v Rebecca Dobert>Losing Lloyd Center doesn't just eliminate a rink, it removes one of the few places where diversity in figure skating has been intentionally fostered in our city.

1008
01:54:01.199 --> 01:54:04.220
<v Rebecca Dobert>The impact of this closure extends far beyond the ice.

1009
01:54:04.220 --> 01:54:06.391
<v Rebecca Dobert>Many coaches will lose their careers and already have.

1010
01:54:06.583 --> 01:54:07.917
<v Rebecca Dobert>Employees will lose their jobs.

1011
01:54:08.109 --> 01:54:11.385
<v Rebecca Dobert>Young athletes may be forced to quit the sport entirely and already have.

1012
01:54:11.882 --> 01:54:18.996
<v Rebecca Dobert>Families will have to drive outside Portland hours just to find a rink, if that they can afford the travel and higher rink fees.

1013
01:54:19.430 --> 01:54:23.475
<v Rebecca Dobert>A vibrant, diverse skating community that has taken decades to build will disappear overnight.

1014
01:54:23.926 --> 01:54:31.135
<v Rebecca Dobert>We often talk about investing into youth, creating healthy communities, and preserving spaces that bring people together, and Lloyd Center already does that.

1015
01:54:31.472 --> 01:54:34.719
<v Rebecca Dobert>Once it is gone, we cannot build another community like this overnight.

1016
01:54:35.042 --> 01:54:39.917
<v Rebecca Dobert>I urge you to consider alternatives that preserve this historic rink while allowing Lloyd Center to evolve and thrive.

1017
01:54:40.439 --> 01:54:44.899
<v Rebecca Dobert>Progress should not come by sacrificing one of Portland's most beloved and diverse spaces.

1018
01:54:45.239 --> 01:54:45.628
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1019
01:54:49.555 --> 01:54:52.711
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can go ahead online, Una.

1020
01:54:53.131 --> 01:54:54.715
<v Rebecca Dobert>For the record, my name is Una Sawyer.

1021
01:54:55.135 --> 01:54:59.256
<v Rebecca Dobert>One afternoon in 2022, a new friend and I took a trip to Lloyd Center Ice Rink.

1022
01:54:59.578 --> 01:55:01.194
<v Rebecca Dobert>What was supposed to be a one-time activity quickly became much more.

1023
01:55:02.351 --> 01:55:07.565
<v Rebecca Dobert>A man taught us a proper 2-foot spin, recruited us into skate school, and from there our investment in the community spiraled.

1024
01:55:08.112 --> 01:55:12.506
<v Rebecca Dobert>If Lloyd Center Ice Rink cannot be preserved or built or replaced, our beloved community will be ruptured.

1025
01:55:13.197 --> 01:55:15.716
<v Rebecca Dobert>Our rink at Lloyd Center is no ordinary sheet of ice.

1026
01:55:16.052 --> 01:55:19.743
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's a place where people can start skating no matter who they are or how good they are.

1027
01:55:20.304 --> 01:55:24.538
<v Rebecca Dobert>When I started skating at age 13, it was one of the few places I felt a sense of belonging.

1028
01:55:24.876 --> 01:55:28.244
<v Rebecca Dobert>There I learned to push past perfectionism and try something I knew I wouldn't be great at right away.

1029
01:55:28.838 --> 01:55:31.278
<v Rebecca Dobert>Advanced skaters lifted me up rather than viewing me as competition.

1030
01:55:31.791 --> 01:55:36.106
<v Rebecca Dobert>Some of us with money and cars will be able to endure drives to further rinks, but I know that won't work for everyone.

1031
01:55:36.524 --> 01:55:41.947
<v Rebecca Dobert>For the friend I've grown closer to ever since that night we came to the Lloyd, the closure of the rink might be the end of her skating journey.

1032
01:55:42.380 --> 01:55:45.877
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've also made friendships with people who inspire me to live freely and dream riskfully.

1033
01:55:45.989 --> 01:55:48.284
<v Rebecca Dobert>These friendships are ones I cannot afford to lose.

1034
01:55:49.038 --> 01:55:53.177
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center is our home, a home of inclusivity, diversity, accessibility, and acceptance.

1035
01:55:53.690 --> 01:56:09.713
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink is a valuable asset to our city because it unites all sorts of people from Thank you very much.

1036
01:56:11.265 --> 01:56:21.568
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next, next up we have Alice Robinson, Eleanor Price, Ada Price, Jesse Rapoport, and Helen Gundlach.

1037
01:56:24.409 --> 01:56:25.445
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on up, folks.

1038
01:56:27.880 --> 01:56:31.859
<v Jamie Dunphy>Make sure to introduce yourself, and whoever sat down first can go.

1039
01:56:32.164 --> 01:56:32.744
<v Jamie Dunphy>You want to go first?

1040
01:56:33.533 --> 01:56:35.128
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hi, my name is Alice Robinson.

1041
01:56:35.819 --> 01:56:41.557
<v Rebecca Dobert>I am the daughter of Jennifer Gilmore Robinson, my— and I'm 9 years old.

1042
01:56:42.121 --> 01:56:45.692
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've skated at Lloyd Center Ice Rink since I was 5.

1043
01:56:45.774 --> 01:56:53.442
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd has always stood out to me because it was always more inviting and was home to the most welcoming community.

1044
01:56:54.329 --> 01:56:57.345
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's also the only rink that lets anyone skate there.

1045
01:56:58.314 --> 01:57:02.380
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink is— the rink is like a second home to me.

1046
01:57:04.126 --> 01:57:08.395
<v Rebecca Dobert>A single chance of losing the rink is devastating to me and all my skating friends.

1047
01:57:09.011 --> 01:57:27.158
<v Rebecca Dobert>So as members of the City Council in a position that serves this In a position that serves the city's people, I ask you that you either send back the plans that determines Lloyd's future or help us relocate our community.

1048
01:57:27.639 --> 01:57:28.453
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you for this opportunity.

1049
01:57:29.716 --> 01:57:32.501
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1050
01:57:33.997 --> 01:57:39.279
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hi, my name is Eleanor Price, and I have skated at Lloyd Center for 10 years.

1051
01:57:39.533 --> 01:57:40.248
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1052
01:57:40.314 --> 01:57:44.779
<v Rebecca Dobert>If Lloyd weren't there, I wouldn't have had the opportunity to become the skater and community member that I am today.

1053
01:57:45.681 --> 01:57:48.884
<v Rebecca Dobert>12 Years ago at Lloyd Center, I was inspired to start my figure skating journey.

1054
01:57:49.564 --> 01:57:54.335
<v Rebecca Dobert>It was shortly before the mall closed for remodeling, and my mom had taken me with her to go shopping at the Macy's.

1055
01:57:54.722 --> 01:57:59.560
<v Rebecca Dobert>When we finished our shopping, I begged her to walk back via the skybridge so that I could look down at the ice rink below.

1056
01:58:01.311 --> 01:58:04.511
<v Rebecca Dobert>As I walked across, I looked down over the railing and saw a skater doing a spin.

1057
01:58:05.029 --> 01:58:08.904
<v Rebecca Dobert>It was a very simple spin, legs crossed, arms above her head, and she was wearing a red dress.

1058
01:58:09.166 --> 01:58:10.884
<v Rebecca Dobert>With a skirt that twirled around her as she spun.

1059
01:58:11.654 --> 01:58:13.051
<v Rebecca Dobert>I was immediately enthralled.

1060
01:58:13.195 --> 01:58:15.363
<v Rebecca Dobert>I turned to my mom and said, I want to do that!

1061
01:58:16.006 --> 01:58:19.104
<v Rebecca Dobert>And 2 years later, I was enrolled in my first learn-to-skate lessons at Lloyd.

1062
01:58:19.618 --> 01:58:25.204
<v Rebecca Dobert>Now, 10 years since I first stepped foot on the ice, I get to be the skater who inspires kids watching me skate.

1063
01:58:26.280 --> 01:58:32.590
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have long surpassed my original goal of a simple scratchman, today pursuing competitive jumps and spins and pushing my physical limits.

1064
01:58:33.890 --> 01:58:52.302
<v Rebecca Dobert>Now that I am growing into a coach and mentor figure at Lloyd, I'm heartbroken that I will not This community is just so supportive and wonderful, and I wouldn't have wanted to nor have been able to come as far as I have with skating if it weren't for them.

1065
01:58:52.966 --> 01:59:01.912
<v Rebecca Dobert>I beseech the City Council to send the proposed master plan back to the Design Commission and make approval contingent upon a binding agreement to preserve, replace, or relocate the year-round ice rink.

1066
01:59:02.206 --> 01:59:03.577
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, and please help us save our community.

1067
01:59:03.658 --> 01:59:03.805
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1068
01:59:03.854 --> 01:59:04.148
<v Rebecca Dobert>Any further discussion?

1069
01:59:04.957 --> 01:59:05.824
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1070
01:59:09.724 --> 01:59:13.342
<v Rebecca Dobert>I am Ada Price, and I started skating 10 years ago at Lloyd Center.

1071
01:59:13.761 --> 01:59:21.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>Now I'm a highly competitive and dedicated figure skater, and one of the reasons I started skating was of how central Lloyd is in the Portland area.

1072
01:59:22.509 --> 01:59:28.750
<v Rebecca Dobert>I and many others here started skating because of how close we were and this— and how easy it was for us to get there.

1073
01:59:29.157 --> 01:59:31.568
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is why I want you to help us save skating in Portland.

1074
01:59:32.122 --> 01:59:34.860
<v Rebecca Dobert>So everyone has an equal opportunity to be a skater.

1075
01:59:38.262 --> 01:59:38.587
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1076
01:59:38.733 --> 01:59:39.445
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1077
01:59:41.287 --> 01:59:42.029
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think I'm last.

1078
01:59:42.641 --> 01:59:42.884
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Go ahead.

1079
01:59:43.368 --> 01:59:43.932
<v Jamie Dunphy>Whoever wants to go.

1080
01:59:44.497 --> 01:59:45.014
<v Rebecca Dobert>Oh, okay.

1081
01:59:46.046 --> 01:59:47.595
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Helen Gundlach.

1082
01:59:47.805 --> 01:59:52.831
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm 75 years old and took up ice skating after a 35-year absence.

1083
01:59:53.542 --> 01:59:58.042
<v Rebecca Dobert>The lessons at Lloyd Center Ice Rink are affordable and the coaches phenomenal.

1084
01:59:58.769 --> 02:00:01.484
<v Rebecca Dobert>This rink is a marvel of intergenerational inclusiveness.

1085
02:00:02.983 --> 02:00:04.797
<v Rebecca Dobert>From toddlers to seniors.

1086
02:00:05.391 --> 02:00:09.376
<v Rebecca Dobert>It would be a tremendous loss to the community if the ice rink was gone.

1087
02:00:10.051 --> 02:00:15.351
<v Rebecca Dobert>Architecturally, it is a unique structure, an icon that has touched millions of lives.

1088
02:00:15.898 --> 02:00:20.860
<v Rebecca Dobert>Its contribution to the livability and vitality of the city is immeasurable.

1089
02:00:21.921 --> 02:00:30.403
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is the crown jewel of the mall, which should not be demolished because it no longer radiates the same sparkle as 65 years ago.

1090
02:00:31.493 --> 02:00:39.157
<v Rebecca Dobert>Like Grandma's diamond engagement ring, it has value, even if its setting is tarnished and old-fashioned.

1091
02:00:39.734 --> 02:00:42.524
<v Rebecca Dobert>Would we toss a family heirloom into the dustbin?

1092
02:00:43.198 --> 02:00:43.998
<v Rebecca Dobert>Of course not.

1093
02:00:44.399 --> 02:00:46.452
<v Rebecca Dobert>We would reimagine it in a new setting.

1094
02:00:47.206 --> 02:00:50.780
<v Rebecca Dobert>I urge City Council to reject URG's master plan.

1095
02:00:51.375 --> 02:00:54.740
<v Rebecca Dobert>Its only commitment is to demolition, not development.

1096
02:00:55.447 --> 02:00:59.167
<v Rebecca Dobert>Imagine 27 acres of empty space within the city limits.

1097
02:00:59.215 --> 02:00:59.519
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1098
02:00:59.989 --> 02:01:02.414
<v Rebecca Dobert>Attracting homeless camps and vagrancies.

1099
02:01:03.319 --> 02:01:11.139
<v Rebecca Dobert>I challenge you to create a new vision that showcases the ice rink in a repurposed Lloyd Center Mall.

1100
02:01:11.368 --> 02:01:12.250
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1101
02:01:12.837 --> 02:01:13.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1102
02:01:16.787 --> 02:01:17.595
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, Council.

1103
02:01:17.711 --> 02:01:18.684
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Jesse Rapoport.

1104
02:01:19.819 --> 02:01:23.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today I want to talk to you about the waste of demolishing a building such as this one.

1105
02:01:23.881 --> 02:01:26.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're going to focus on the glass beneath the handrails.

1106
02:01:27.009 --> 02:01:37.792
<v Jamie Dunphy>So to get one pane of glass to Lloyd Center, firstly, excavators, bulldozers, freight trains, barges, semi-trucks, and more are used to mine and transport just the main ingredient, silica sand.

1107
02:01:38.145 --> 02:01:42.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then similar processes occur for the other ingredients like soda ash and limestone.

1108
02:01:42.863 --> 02:01:50.904
<v Jamie Dunphy>Once all of this is transported cross-country into one place, it's mixed and heated to 2,700 degrees Fahrenheit and laid out into large sheets.

1109
02:01:51.305 --> 02:01:53.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then they're broken up into panes such as this one.

1110
02:01:53.872 --> 02:01:55.911
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then the edges are ground and then polished.

1111
02:01:56.279 --> 02:02:00.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>And after a lot of oil-burning transportation, eventually they make it into Lloyd Center Mall.

1112
02:02:01.094 --> 02:02:15.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then this repeats 20 times on the left, 20 times on the right, and then another 40 times behind that, and another 40 times behind that, and then do that again for the next floor up, and then do that again for the other half of the mall.

1113
02:02:16.518 --> 02:02:19.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>It comes out to a lot of money and a lot of resources.

1114
02:02:20.689 --> 02:02:30.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now, imagine bulldozers smashing all of these functioning panes of glass and sending the smithereens to a landfill, just throwing in the trash all of that hard work and environmental sacrifice.

1115
02:02:31.717 --> 02:02:40.118
<v Jamie Dunphy>In your heart of hearts, do you really believe that this qualifies as environmental adaptation, water conservation, waste reduction?

1116
02:02:40.871 --> 02:02:47.662
<v Jamie Dunphy>If not, then by definition, it does not satisfy the 6LD1 subpolicy requirement for this master plan.

1117
02:02:48.341 --> 02:02:51.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>And don't even get me started on the part of the mall that's not hand-railed glass.

1118
02:02:52.043 --> 02:02:52.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1119
02:02:56.720 --> 02:03:11.323
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next we have Amer Ainam, Alec Schmidt, Georgia Kruegel, Sarah Price, Sequoia Meyer.

1120
02:03:11.628 --> 02:03:12.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, folks.

1121
02:03:12.368 --> 02:03:16.275
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on up, introduce yourselves for the record, and whoever's sitting down first gets to go first.

1122
02:03:17.936 --> 02:03:18.208
<v Rebecca Dobert>Should I go?

1123
02:03:18.497 --> 02:03:18.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please.

1124
02:03:18.930 --> 02:03:19.475
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay, thank you.

1125
02:03:20.181 --> 02:03:22.202
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council, my name is Emer Inam.

1126
02:03:22.523 --> 02:03:25.024
<v Rebecca Dobert>My wife and our 2 kids skate at Lloyd Center.

1127
02:03:25.713 --> 02:03:27.365
<v Rebecca Dobert>Eli dreams of becoming an Olympian.

1128
02:03:27.751 --> 02:03:29.434
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sam is his biggest supporter.

1129
02:03:30.220 --> 02:03:34.309
<v Rebecca Dobert>What this community is pouring its heart out for is what makes Portland special.

1130
02:03:34.871 --> 02:03:38.126
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is a land use decision with real civic consequences.

1131
02:03:38.639 --> 02:03:39.841
<v Rebecca Dobert>The demolition is real.

1132
02:03:40.403 --> 02:03:41.942
<v Rebecca Dobert>The community loss is real.

1133
02:03:42.150 --> 02:03:44.171
<v Rebecca Dobert>The promised benefits are speculative.

1134
02:03:45.293 --> 02:03:47.829
<v Rebecca Dobert>The public was told the ice rink would remain.

1135
02:03:48.103 --> 02:03:53.253
<v Rebecca Dobert>The public trust was earned on promises eliminated 3 days before the Design Commission hearing.

1136
02:03:53.880 --> 02:03:55.292
<v Rebecca Dobert>Public trust deserves better.

1137
02:03:56.046 --> 02:03:58.310
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is not opposition to development.

1138
02:03:58.533 --> 02:03:59.432
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is stewardship.

1139
02:04:00.219 --> 02:04:03.188
<v Rebecca Dobert>A demand for development worthy of the community it reshapes.

1140
02:04:03.604 --> 02:04:06.012
<v Rebecca Dobert>Approvals must be earned, not assumed.

1141
02:04:06.703 --> 02:04:09.927
<v Rebecca Dobert>Today the charter asks you to make that judgment for yourselves.

1142
02:04:10.009 --> 02:04:10.875
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilmember Smith, I would ask you to conclude.

1143
02:04:11.757 --> 02:04:13.829
<v Rebecca Dobert>The council has the authority here.

1144
02:04:14.729 --> 02:04:15.917
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is not a done deal.

1145
02:04:17.136 --> 02:04:24.619
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council, Portland remembers leaders with the courage to protect what made this city livable while demanding progress.

1146
02:04:25.020 --> 02:04:26.048
<v Rebecca Dobert>Tom McCall did this.

1147
02:04:26.851 --> 02:04:27.926
<v Rebecca Dobert>Vera Katz did that.

1148
02:04:28.618 --> 02:04:36.197
<v Rebecca Dobert>You have the opportunity today to create your own legacy in this city, not to stop change, but to demand a better version of it.

1149
02:04:36.728 --> 02:04:41.752
<v Rebecca Dobert>Make the world come to Portland to see what responsible community-driven development looks like.

1150
02:04:42.076 --> 02:04:49.773
<v Rebecca Dobert>Granting the appeal brings the community, the applicant, and the city back to the table for a plan that is investable and worthy of Portland.

1151
02:04:49.951 --> 02:04:50.873
<v Rebecca Dobert>Please grant the appeal.

1152
02:04:51.020 --> 02:04:51.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1153
02:04:51.813 --> 02:04:52.783
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1154
02:04:55.287 --> 02:05:09.046
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, my name is Alex Schmidt, and I have been the figure skating director of Southern Oregon Ice in Medford and the Winterhawks Ice at Beaverton Bringing both skate school programs to record numbers, former coach for Special Olympics Washington, and I'm now co-director of Pacific Ice Academy at Lloyd Center.

1155
02:05:09.528 --> 02:05:13.011
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've dedicated my life to supporting all kinds of skaters from beginner to international.

1156
02:05:13.525 --> 02:05:15.115
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ice skating is alive and thriving.

1157
02:05:15.774 --> 02:05:20.654
<v Jamie Dunphy>I read through every written testimony to understand those that support Lloyd Center and those that support the design commission.

1158
02:05:21.168 --> 02:05:23.914
<v Jamie Dunphy>This conversation is important, but the common theme is trust.

1159
02:05:24.461 --> 02:05:27.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>The Portland City Council is elected and appointed to serve the community.

1160
02:05:27.993 --> 02:05:45.404
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those in support of the appellant have heartfelt testimonies, whether citing policies or Portland values, including the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association and a former member of the Portland Landmarks Commission, while those in support of the applicant have submitted a generic form testimony with the overwhelming majority coming from real estate brokers, developers, architecture firms, et cetera.

1161
02:05:45.948 --> 02:05:50.828
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lloyd Center has seen what happens when an overly ambitious developer comes in and gets free rein to spruce up the place.

1162
02:05:51.244 --> 02:05:54.823
<v Jamie Dunphy>We end up with a tacky marble staircase and an appeal hearing because the money has run out.

1163
02:05:55.353 --> 02:05:56.122
<v Jamie Dunphy>Trust is broken.

1164
02:05:56.716 --> 02:06:00.005
<v Jamie Dunphy>URG promised a rink in their project, and this isn't the last promise they'll break.

1165
02:06:00.310 --> 02:06:07.032
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sprinker Recreation Center in Tacoma was on the brink of closure in 2011 before the community rallied to get the Parks Department to save it.

1166
02:06:07.466 --> 02:06:08.475
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today it's thriving.

1167
02:06:08.908 --> 02:06:14.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm asking the council to step in to work with the Save Lloyd Ice group to ensure preservation of Portland ice skating.

1168
02:06:14.524 --> 02:06:17.974
<v Jamie Dunphy>Portlanders on both sides of the aisle would love to see this rink exist.

1169
02:06:18.375 --> 02:06:25.453
<v Jamie Dunphy>Listen to us, help us, and please attend the Please attend our gala this Friday, 5:00 PM.

1170
02:06:25.551 --> 02:06:26.342
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1171
02:06:31.618 --> 02:06:33.210
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hello, my name is Sarah Price.

1172
02:06:34.030 --> 02:06:38.005
<v Rebecca Dobert>I guess I want to tell you just how we fell into the Lloyd Center.

1173
02:06:38.069 --> 02:06:46.009
<v Rebecca Dobert>So 10 years ago, I was looking for lessons for my children, and we settled on figure skating because it was affordable, the most affordable lessons I could find.

1174
02:06:46.536 --> 02:06:47.529
<v Rebecca Dobert>And it was really convenient.

1175
02:06:47.594 --> 02:06:51.265
<v Rebecca Dobert>We could get there before school and after school without, you know, traffic.

1176
02:06:51.345 --> 02:06:52.291
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's hard in Portland.

1177
02:06:53.284 --> 02:06:57.581
<v Rebecca Dobert>But once we got there, we discovered not just lessons that we enjoyed, but these shows.

1178
02:06:57.693 --> 02:06:59.408
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center does 2 shows a year.

1179
02:07:00.161 --> 02:07:02.037
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the visual here is the costumes.

1180
02:07:02.100 --> 02:07:03.720
<v Rebecca Dobert>The girls get a really great costume.

1181
02:07:03.847 --> 02:07:05.466
<v Rebecca Dobert>Any skater can be in the show.

1182
02:07:05.546 --> 02:07:08.801
<v Rebecca Dobert>They learn a routine and then they perform in front of the whole mall crowd.

1183
02:07:09.395 --> 02:07:10.212
<v Rebecca Dobert>My kids loved it.

1184
02:07:10.292 --> 02:07:11.189
<v Rebecca Dobert>It was so much fun.

1185
02:07:11.734 --> 02:07:12.856
<v Rebecca Dobert>So we kept taking lessons.

1186
02:07:12.904 --> 02:07:13.048
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1187
02:07:13.242 --> 02:07:16.206
<v Rebecca Dobert>And they kept getting better and they kept doing more shows.

1188
02:07:16.911 --> 02:07:24.715
<v Rebecca Dobert>And today I have the parent of 2 really pretty darn decent skaters, and we still choose to skate at Lloyd.

1189
02:07:24.842 --> 02:07:26.510
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is still the same reasons.

1190
02:07:26.622 --> 02:07:27.840
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's pretty darn affordable.

1191
02:07:27.984 --> 02:07:30.756
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can fit it in our budget, and it's really convenient.

1192
02:07:30.868 --> 02:07:32.359
<v Rebecca Dobert>The girls can get there before school.

1193
02:07:32.470 --> 02:07:34.136
<v Rebecca Dobert>They can get there after school to train.

1194
02:07:35.338 --> 02:07:36.604
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's an amazing community.

1195
02:07:36.877 --> 02:07:37.854
<v Rebecca Dobert>My girls' friends are there.

1196
02:07:38.015 --> 02:07:39.153
<v Rebecca Dobert>My girls' coaches are there.

1197
02:07:39.201 --> 02:07:39.345
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1198
02:07:49.770 --> 02:07:51.136
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Georgia Kruegel.

1199
02:07:51.231 --> 02:07:55.622
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm 12 years old, and I've been skating at the Lloyd Center for more than half of my life.

1200
02:07:56.220 --> 02:07:59.034
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have a strong connection to this mall and to all the gifts inside.

1201
02:07:59.681 --> 02:08:02.432
<v Rebecca Dobert>And by gifts, I'm talking about more than the ice rink.

1202
02:08:02.983 --> 02:08:04.925
<v Rebecca Dobert>There's a sense of home and community here.

1203
02:08:05.578 --> 02:08:07.923
<v Rebecca Dobert>My testimony today is not just for me.

1204
02:08:08.551 --> 02:08:12.101
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's for the hundreds of skaters who take lessons at Lloyd Center every week.

1205
02:08:12.744 --> 02:08:16.680
<v Rebecca Dobert>Nothing is more meaningful to me than this rink and the community we have here.

1206
02:08:17.323 --> 02:08:26.113
<v Rebecca Dobert>Young skaters learning how to swizzle, adult skater friends who support me with every jump and spin, and my wonderful coaches who have been there for me since day one.

1207
02:08:26.965 --> 02:08:30.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>For my family, this is also the only affordable local place for me to pursue Thank you.

1208
02:08:30.710 --> 02:08:30.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm Councilor Mitch Green.

1209
02:08:30.710 --> 02:08:30.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm a 5th grade student from the Lower East Side.

1210
02:08:30.710 --> 02:08:30.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm here today to speak out against the proposed master plan for the Lloyd Center.

1211
02:08:30.710 --> 02:08:30.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>I grew up in the Lower East Side, and I've been coming to the Lloyd Center since I was 5 years old.

1212
02:08:30.710 --> 02:08:32.140
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've been skating here since I was 3 years old, and I'm here to pursue my love of ice skating.

1213
02:08:32.789 --> 02:08:38.090
<v Rebecca Dobert>Every chance I get to be at Lloyd Center feels like a gift, a gift that every Portlander should get to experience.

1214
02:08:38.909 --> 02:08:42.340
<v Rebecca Dobert>I look at the proposed master plan and it is unimaginative.

1215
02:08:43.130 --> 02:08:48.909
<v Rebecca Dobert>There's already a green space and a huge vacant lot across the street from the Lloyd Center that you can invest in.

1216
02:08:49.170 --> 02:08:52.180
<v Rebecca Dobert>There are business spaces for lease in every neighborhood.

1217
02:08:52.390 --> 02:08:55.149
<v Rebecca Dobert>There's not another ice rink where we can go.

1218
02:08:55.289 --> 02:08:57.604
<v Rebecca Dobert>The developers say that They say that they surveyed the community.

1219
02:08:57.944 --> 02:09:00.938
<v Rebecca Dobert>However, nobody ever asked our skating community for feedback.

1220
02:09:01.520 --> 02:09:04.078
<v Rebecca Dobert>I believe that kids and youth should have a voice in the decision.

1221
02:09:04.509 --> 02:09:06.975
<v Rebecca Dobert>We will be impacted by your vote for years to come.

1222
02:09:07.525 --> 02:09:10.560
<v Rebecca Dobert>We were promised an indoor rink, but where is that rink now?

1223
02:09:11.310 --> 02:09:14.627
<v Rebecca Dobert>Please retain, replace, or relocate our beloved ice rink.

1224
02:09:15.167 --> 02:09:15.967
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you for your time.

1225
02:09:20.713 --> 02:09:22.712
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hi, I'm Sequoia.

1226
02:09:23.162 --> 02:09:24.301
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I'm a skater at Lloyd.

1227
02:09:24.909 --> 02:09:29.256
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is such a special place because it is so welcoming and like no other.

1228
02:09:30.282 --> 02:09:36.872
<v Rebecca Dobert>For example, I've only been skating for 2 years and I already have a whole team of skaters that are my friends.

1229
02:09:37.755 --> 02:09:42.550
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I know for a fact we would all be devastated to lose each other.

1230
02:09:43.448 --> 02:09:51.533
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is why I'm asking you, City Council representatives, to retain or relocate At the Lloyd Ice Rink.

1231
02:09:52.032 --> 02:10:04.010
<v Rebecca Dobert>There are so many different types of skaters at Lloyd, from new beginners all the way to national skaters, 2-year-olds all the way to 80-year-olds, and we all represent Lloyd together.

1232
02:10:04.154 --> 02:10:08.810
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's not the walls or even the ice itself that make Lloyd matter.

1233
02:10:09.469 --> 02:10:12.390
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's the people around that make Lloyd Ice Rink matter.

1234
02:10:13.451 --> 02:10:20.684
<v Rebecca Dobert>There have been so many help Full moments where having such a marvelous team has been so helpful and fun.

1235
02:10:21.233 --> 02:10:26.149
<v Rebecca Dobert>For example, before I compete, my teammates help me calm me down.

1236
02:10:27.572 --> 02:10:34.581
<v Rebecca Dobert>And today we found out the ice rink wasn't in the plans like we had been promised.

1237
02:10:34.645 --> 02:10:36.220
<v Rebecca Dobert>We supported each other in our tears.

1238
02:10:36.996 --> 02:10:40.497
<v Rebecca Dobert>Now we are doing our best to make the most out of the time we have left.

1239
02:10:40.546 --> 02:10:40.675
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1240
02:10:41.515 --> 02:10:46.826
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I ask you, please, please don't take our community away.

1241
02:10:48.739 --> 02:10:52.368
<v Rebecca Dobert>Make the construction company include a new rink in their plans.

1242
02:10:52.432 --> 02:10:53.704
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1243
02:10:58.703 --> 02:11:14.096
<v Rebecca Dobert>Matt Price, Nick Fox, Shani Bender, Anna Johnson, Parker Welcome, folks.

1244
02:11:14.145 --> 02:11:16.426
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on up and take it away.

1245
02:11:16.896 --> 02:11:17.609
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1246
02:11:18.109 --> 02:11:23.707
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Matt Price, and I'm not much of a skater, but I am a big fan of the Lloyd Rink.

1247
02:11:24.743 --> 02:11:28.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've discovered that the Lloyd Rink is a common thread for Portlanders.

1248
02:11:29.123 --> 02:11:40.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>Everyone who's had to listen to me talk about the situation with the rink has had a story to tell about their time there, whether it's the holiday tradition or a way to beat summer heat.

1249
02:11:41.380 --> 02:11:47.448
<v Jamie Dunphy>Almost all of us have spent some time at the ice there, and there's nothing that replaces that if it closes.

1250
02:11:48.587 --> 02:12:02.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>I do spend a lot of time at the rink because my children are skaters, and they got that chance to learn to skate, to perform, to compete, because there is a year-round rink close to home where that could happen.

1251
02:12:02.474 --> 02:12:02.650
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1252
02:12:03.518 --> 02:12:22.127
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm amazed by the tricks that they perform balanced on a knife edge on this slippery surface, but I'm even more impressed by how hard they work mastering those tricks and how, what, how they've learned to pick themselves up and keep going every time they fall down.

1253
02:12:22.865 --> 02:12:29.528
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm most impressed by the way that they support and are supported by The people around them.

1254
02:12:30.250 --> 02:12:37.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>The group of skaters, coaches, and workers there welcomes and encourages everyone who wants to skate.

1255
02:12:38.204 --> 02:12:46.832
<v Jamie Dunphy>My children have skating friends of all ages, all different backgrounds, and all skill levels who cheer each other on unreservedly.

1256
02:12:47.987 --> 02:12:53.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>The children and their friends, they deserve the chance to keep learning and doing what they love.

1257
02:12:53.680 --> 02:12:53.777
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1258
02:12:54.693 --> 02:13:00.622
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1259
02:13:04.127 --> 02:13:06.753
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Shaney Bender and I live in the Cully neighborhood.

1260
02:13:07.171 --> 02:13:14.947
<v Rebecca Dobert>My family has lived in Portland for decades, staying for the quality of life the city offers, and the Lloyd Center ice rink is a big part of that.

1261
02:13:15.783 --> 02:13:19.436
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink is our third space, a place to share joy, connect with others, and find community.

1262
02:13:19.676 --> 02:13:22.115
<v Rebecca Dobert>Families and skaters and to recharge.

1263
02:13:22.886 --> 02:13:27.864
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's buzzing with activity, vibrant and accessible to Portlanders of all stripes.

1264
02:13:28.523 --> 02:13:33.789
<v Rebecca Dobert>Within this community, my teenager has made a group of friends they call their skating siblings.

1265
02:13:35.090 --> 02:13:42.926
<v Rebecca Dobert>On February 2nd, after years of public statements that a new rink would be part of the redevelopment, URG broke that commitment.

1266
02:13:43.471 --> 02:13:51.050
<v Rebecca Dobert>Since then, our community has organized, launched a nonprofit, and is preparing a capital campaign.

1267
02:13:51.949 --> 02:13:55.305
<v Rebecca Dobert>We are confident we will be able to raise the funds to build a new facility.

1268
02:13:56.204 --> 02:14:08.069
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yet URG and KKR are unwilling to share even a small corner of their 29-acre project, a project with no other interested tenants, in order for this community to continue thriving.

1269
02:14:09.002 --> 02:14:10.158
<v Rebecca Dobert>Now the city has a choice.

1270
02:14:10.511 --> 02:14:16.051
<v Rebecca Dobert>Do we Do we want to be a city where people stay, or a stopover city of shiny plans and vacant lots?

1271
02:14:16.796 --> 02:14:29.479
<v Rebecca Dobert>I urge the City Council, send this back to the Design Commission and direct the developers to work with the city and community to find a mutually beneficial solution that preserves, replaces, or relocates our rink.

1272
02:14:34.307 --> 02:14:36.033
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good morning, councilors, Council President.

1273
02:14:36.842 --> 02:14:40.485
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Anna Johnson, and I live in District 1 in the Centennial neighborhood.

1274
02:14:41.801 --> 02:14:49.230
<v Rebecca Dobert>Place shapes us for better or worse, and I know this council is invested in making Portland the kind of place that draws people in.

1275
02:14:50.001 --> 02:14:54.766
<v Rebecca Dobert>We've had a rough few years, but those of us who are here know this place is worth fighting for.

1276
02:14:55.600 --> 02:14:58.537
<v Rebecca Dobert>However, it's a lot to revitalize the whole city at once.

1277
02:14:58.746 --> 02:15:03.881
<v Rebecca Dobert>You have to start with pieces, and one of those pieces for me is the Lloyd Center ice rink.

1278
02:15:04.443 --> 02:15:10.880
<v Rebecca Dobert>I never thought I'd be fighting for a skating rink amid all the things that are amiss in our society and have been for centuries.

1279
02:15:11.506 --> 02:15:15.167
<v Rebecca Dobert>But also, maybe this little rink represents all the other things.

1280
02:15:15.841 --> 02:15:21.989
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's the fight for inclusivity, for affordability, for community, and for our joy all wrapped in one.

1281
02:15:22.743 --> 02:15:26.484
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I do believe it supports the goals you have for the city and our community.

1282
02:15:27.479 --> 02:15:33.275
<v Rebecca Dobert>Even before I became obsessed with figure skating over the last year, The rink at Lloyd Center meant something to me.

1283
02:15:33.822 --> 02:15:38.930
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've skated there throughout the years as I and the rink and the mall around it changed over time.

1284
02:15:39.604 --> 02:15:49.530
<v Rebecca Dobert>From my first time on ice as a grade schooler in 2000 to one of my first dates with my now husband, this rink has been part of the backdrop of Portland and my life.

1285
02:15:50.286 --> 02:15:56.485
<v Rebecca Dobert>Learning to really skate as an adult has reminded me how exhilarating it is to prove to yourself that you can do hard things.

1286
02:15:56.550 --> 02:15:56.759
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1287
02:15:57.192 --> 02:16:03.890
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I'm just one of countless people who have lived and loved and fallen and gotten up again on Lloyd Ice in the last 65 years.

1288
02:16:04.868 --> 02:16:10.332
<v Rebecca Dobert>While it is inevitable for cities to change over time, we do make choices about what is precious and should be preserved.

1289
02:16:10.653 --> 02:16:22.141
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I'm proud to be a lifelong Oregonian adding my voice and calling for council to send the master plan back to the Design Commission and make approval contingent upon a binding agreement that preserves, replaces, or relocates the ice rink.

1290
02:16:22.189 --> 02:16:22.287
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1291
02:16:22.430 --> 02:16:22.766
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1292
02:16:23.761 --> 02:16:24.369
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1293
02:16:28.020 --> 02:16:32.685
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Parker Doty, and I'm a 12-year-old Portland resident and a student of Lloyd Ice Rink.

1294
02:16:33.700 --> 02:16:40.930
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink at Lloyd is a place where everyone can go, whatever your race, culture, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity— it doesn't matter.

1295
02:16:41.604 --> 02:16:45.647
<v Rebecca Dobert>No matter your age, experience, physical or mental ability, you can skate.

1296
02:16:46.379 --> 02:16:54.405
<v Rebecca Dobert>If the rink at Lloyd is not preserved, rebuilt, or relocated, A place of joy, exercise, fun, and community will be destroyed.

1297
02:16:55.620 --> 02:17:04.154
<v Rebecca Dobert>Even though there are other rinks outside our city, our rink at Lloyd is in the heart of Portland, on public— and on public transit.

1298
02:17:04.524 --> 02:17:09.114
<v Rebecca Dobert>So if you bring a good attitude and love, you can rent a pair of skates for the day and go home.

1299
02:17:10.631 --> 02:17:12.679
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink at Lloyd is more than a building.

1300
02:17:12.968 --> 02:17:15.887
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is community and a second home.

1301
02:17:16.597 --> 02:17:22.956
<v Rebecca Dobert>To let the ice rink be erased from our physical plane is to take a part of our rose and bridge-covered Portland away from us.

1302
02:17:23.930 --> 02:17:28.065
<v Rebecca Dobert>So please, City Council, preserve, rebuild, or relocate the Lloyd Center ice rink.

1303
02:17:28.869 --> 02:17:29.254
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1304
02:17:29.915 --> 02:17:30.575
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1305
02:17:38.690 --> 02:17:38.981
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Brad.

1306
02:17:40.672 --> 02:17:41.127
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Good morning.

1307
02:17:41.565 --> 02:17:42.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Nick Fox.

1308
02:17:42.540 --> 02:17:45.203
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm here to testify against the approval of the redevelopment plan.

1309
02:17:45.867 --> 02:17:54.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lloyd Center is a unique community and business hub full of potential that should not be wastefully demolished, but should live on in the spirit of adaptive reuse.

1310
02:17:55.099 --> 02:18:13.307
<v Benjamin Nielsen>The redevelopment plan goes against multiple City Council design guidelines, which include promoting sustainability, encouraging green practices, reuse of existing buildings, fostering community building and public spaces, supporting local businesses and employment, emphasizing Portland themes, building on local character and the identity of a place.

1311
02:18:13.370 --> 02:18:13.498
<v Benjamin Nielsen>Thank you.

1312
02:18:14.236 --> 02:18:20.120
<v Jamie Dunphy>The mall is an existing indoor climate-controlled space where communities and businesses have thrived.

1313
02:18:20.441 --> 02:18:21.034
<v Jamie Dunphy>It continues—.

1314
02:18:21.611 --> 02:18:29.084
<v Jamie Dunphy>Its continued existence and evolution satisfies the mentioned guidelines, while demolish— demolition actively defies them.

1315
02:18:29.581 --> 02:18:36.266
<v Jamie Dunphy>The failure to reuse the building and its destruction's climate impact and waste would be glaring examples of that defiance.

1316
02:18:37.021 --> 02:18:49.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>Furthermore, a plan which will demolish a historically cherished and recently renovated space, uh, leaving another large dirt lot in our city for an undeterminate amount of time, uh, is irresponsible and wasteful.

1317
02:18:50.013 --> 02:18:54.552
<v Jamie Dunphy>For instance, the lot across the street from Lloyd Center, which has been empty for a decade.

1318
02:18:55.066 --> 02:19:02.013
<v Jamie Dunphy>I ask that you reevaluate the redevelopment plan and ask, uh, if it really follows the city's own guidelines and values.

1319
02:19:02.686 --> 02:19:02.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1320
02:19:02.992 --> 02:19:03.986
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1321
02:19:07.828 --> 02:19:16.402
<v Rebecca Dobert>Chelsea Meyer, Justin Doty, Kathleen Rice, Emily Higgins, Melanie Throckmorton.

1322
02:19:20.462 --> 02:19:21.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, folks.

1323
02:19:21.445 --> 02:19:24.701
<v Jamie Dunphy>Introduce yourself for the records, and whoever's sitting down first gets to go first.

1324
02:19:27.305 --> 02:19:30.700
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, City Council members, thank you for the chance to speak.

1325
02:19:30.781 --> 02:19:31.784
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Chelsea Meyer.

1326
02:19:31.865 --> 02:19:32.754
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm from the Kelly neighborhood.

1327
02:19:33.593 --> 02:19:34.074
<v Rebecca Dobert>Speak up.

1328
02:19:35.195 --> 02:19:37.040
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I'm here as a concerned parent.

1329
02:19:37.923 --> 02:19:45.459
<v Rebecca Dobert>Like many children today, my skater struggles with anxiety that can make everyday activities like going to school difficult.

1330
02:19:46.037 --> 02:19:53.125
<v Rebecca Dobert>Since she began skating 2 years ago, her self-confidence and ability to face challenges has improved dramatically.

1331
02:19:54.424 --> 02:19:59.218
<v Rebecca Dobert>She often says, Mama, when I get on the ice, my mind just goes blank.

1332
02:19:59.412 --> 02:20:00.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I can be.

1333
02:20:00.944 --> 02:20:06.447
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is a rare and special thing, and the Lloyd Center ice rink does that for many children.

1334
02:20:07.319 --> 02:20:10.317
<v Rebecca Dobert>Over 500 skaters a week skate at Lloyd Center.

1335
02:20:10.640 --> 02:20:10.978
<v Rebecca Dobert>A week.

1336
02:20:11.123 --> 02:20:12.575
<v Rebecca Dobert>500 Skaters a week.

1337
02:20:13.719 --> 02:20:14.977
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is a big deal, you guys.

1338
02:20:20.213 --> 02:20:29.166
<v Rebecca Dobert>That is why we are asking you, City Council, to send URG's plans back to the Design Commission and demand that the Lloyd Center ice rink be retained, replaced, or relocated.

1339
02:20:31.867 --> 02:20:33.596
<v Rebecca Dobert>Child anxiety is increasing.

1340
02:20:33.806 --> 02:20:34.655
<v Rebecca Dobert>We all know this.

1341
02:20:35.791 --> 02:20:46.720
<v Rebecca Dobert>And regular physical activity like ice skating reduces anxiety while improving mood, concentration, and social connection— benefits that matter for young people navigating the world stress that we have today.

1342
02:20:47.250 --> 02:20:55.004
<v Rebecca Dobert>Removing this rink without guaranteeing an equivalent local replacement would strip hundreds of skaters a week with this much-needed space for connection.

1343
02:20:55.597 --> 02:20:57.393
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm asking you all, where are we gonna go?

1344
02:20:57.441 --> 02:20:57.808
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Smith.

1345
02:20:58.167 --> 02:21:01.595
<v Rebecca Dobert>If you remove this, if you don't step in, where are we going to go?

1346
02:21:03.370 --> 02:21:04.609
<v Rebecca Dobert>Please step in.

1347
02:21:05.880 --> 02:21:06.442
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1348
02:21:08.958 --> 02:21:09.845
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Justin Doty.

1349
02:21:09.911 --> 02:21:12.786
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm a Portland citizen living in 97214.

1350
02:21:13.399 --> 02:21:18.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>For many families, the rink has been one of the few affordable year-round places for kids to be active and connected.

1351
02:21:19.216 --> 02:21:23.308
<v Jamie Dunphy>For years, we were told the rink would remain, but now we find ourselves fighting for yet another civic institution.

1352
02:21:23.420 --> 02:21:23.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1353
02:21:23.819 --> 02:21:23.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

1354
02:21:23.819 --> 02:21:23.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a historic moment in Portland's history.

1355
02:21:23.819 --> 02:21:25.399
<v Benjamin Nielsen>We are witnessing a beloved institution being ripped from the city.

1356
02:21:25.399 --> 02:21:34.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>The loss of this community hub would be devastating, not just to those of us in the skating community, but to the population of Portland at large, and no temporary seasonal pop-up could ever restore that.

1357
02:21:34.899 --> 02:21:44.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Some will point to the hockey rinks in Beaverton or Sherwood or Vancouver and come to the conclusion that any sheet of ice will satisfy what is unfairly painted as a niche by those with little interest in the culture of our city.

1358
02:21:45.049 --> 02:21:48.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thousands of Portlanders take to the ice rink at Lloyd every year.

1359
02:21:48.579 --> 02:21:49.262
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hundreds Thank you.

1360
02:21:49.326 --> 02:21:53.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hundreds of students are learning to skate each week just 2.5 miles from where we're sitting, just off the MAX.

1361
02:21:54.322 --> 02:21:58.402
<v Jamie Dunphy>The rink at Lloyd hosts a cadre of uniquely skilled coaches who face displacement.

1362
02:21:58.819 --> 02:22:03.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>The Winterhawk Center, 7 miles down the highway in Beaverton, will not absorb thousands of Portlanders.

1363
02:22:04.200 --> 02:22:08.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>The Sherwood Rink, another 10 miles from there, isn't going to carve time into their hockey league schedules.

1364
02:22:09.084 --> 02:22:12.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>16 Miles away in another state, in Mountain View, will not serve us.

1365
02:22:13.260 --> 02:22:16.936
<v Benjamin Nielsen>When they turn off the lights on August 8th, Portland loses another defining feature of our city.

1366
02:22:17.274 --> 02:22:26.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>The city turns its back on its stated goals and guidelines and abandons the community that already exists for developmental hope casting, but most assuredly years of a vacant hole in the ground.

1367
02:22:27.245 --> 02:22:36.943
<v Jamie Dunphy>I urge the City Council to send the proposed master plan back to the Design Commission and require a binding agreement to preserve, replace, or relocate the year-round ice rink as a condition of its approval.

1368
02:22:37.281 --> 02:22:37.602
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1369
02:22:38.227 --> 02:22:38.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1370
02:22:42.960 --> 02:22:43.954
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Emily Higgins.

1371
02:22:44.163 --> 02:22:46.039
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm a resident of District 3.

1372
02:22:47.065 --> 02:22:51.441
<v Rebecca Dobert>The skating community is here today because of 2 failures by the developers.

1373
02:22:51.938 --> 02:22:53.878
<v Rebecca Dobert>First, a failure of honesty.

1374
02:22:54.664 --> 02:23:02.759
<v Rebecca Dobert>For 4 years, the developers consistently, enthusiastically, and unequivocally promised an ice rink in the redevelopment.

1375
02:23:03.480 --> 02:23:08.469
<v Rebecca Dobert>The truth did not emerge until just 3 Days before the Design Commission hearing.

1376
02:23:09.416 --> 02:23:15.934
<v Rebecca Dobert>I ask, is misleading the public over and over again an acceptable part of the process in Portland?

1377
02:23:17.156 --> 02:23:19.113
<v Rebecca Dobert>Second, a failure of creative thinking.

1378
02:23:19.933 --> 02:23:27.029
<v Rebecca Dobert>If the applicant had truly wanted to solve the ice rink issue, they certainly have the experience and connections to do it.

1379
02:23:27.735 --> 02:23:34.091
<v Rebecca Dobert>A good faith partnership formed earlier could have had us skating on new ice by the time Lloyd closes.

1380
02:23:35.342 --> 02:23:37.956
<v Rebecca Dobert>But this is still a solvable problem.

1381
02:23:38.740 --> 02:23:47.111
<v Rebecca Dobert>Our newly formed nonprofit is already working hard, putting the community first, and building partnerships capable of funding a replacement facility.

1382
02:23:47.945 --> 02:23:49.822
<v Rebecca Dobert>We just need a place.

1383
02:23:50.688 --> 02:23:57.486
<v Rebecca Dobert>Members of the City Council, I ask you to find a way to retain, replace, or relocate our beloved ice rink.

1384
02:23:58.129 --> 02:24:01.902
<v Rebecca Dobert>If not at Lloyd, Please help us find a new home.

1385
02:24:08.870 --> 02:24:10.227
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Melanie Throckmorton.

1386
02:24:11.227 --> 02:24:14.956
<v Rebecca Dobert>The best path forward for the Moda Center is a parallel investment in the Lloyd Center.

1387
02:24:15.550 --> 02:24:17.143
<v Rebecca Dobert>The Moda Center can be high-tech and posh.

1388
02:24:17.545 --> 02:24:19.088
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center can be funky and free.

1389
02:24:19.748 --> 02:24:22.933
<v Rebecca Dobert>Synergy will create an awesome cultural and entertainment district.

1390
02:24:24.135 --> 02:24:26.819
<v Rebecca Dobert>With Save Lloyd, I found myself on a magical adventure.

1391
02:24:27.587 --> 02:24:30.174
<v Rebecca Dobert>I met amazing people who represent the spirit of Portland.

1392
02:24:30.816 --> 02:24:32.310
<v Rebecca Dobert>They work for free with no backers.

1393
02:24:32.727 --> 02:24:35.522
<v Rebecca Dobert>They are inclusive, diverse, equitable, and accessible.

1394
02:24:36.423 --> 02:24:52.468
<v Rebecca Dobert>They are activists saving a world on fire, creatives sharing their work, historians weaving the threads of history, houseless activists treasuring a third space, disabled and neurodiverse people with fresh perspectives, marginalized folks creating a refuge in Portland.

1395
02:24:53.368 --> 02:24:59.260
<v Rebecca Dobert>We created writings, graphics, songs, web pages, posts, analysis, documentation, and outreach.

1396
02:24:59.886 --> 02:25:02.054
<v Rebecca Dobert>Everything Lloyd touched came to life.

1397
02:25:03.096 --> 02:25:05.361
<v Rebecca Dobert>I had a third place to go and people to go there with.

1398
02:25:06.308 --> 02:25:09.599
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center reignited my Metro pride and inspired hope for the future.

1399
02:25:10.466 --> 02:25:15.218
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center gave me a reason to go to Portland and volunteer, shop, dine, and to spend.

1400
02:25:16.021 --> 02:25:18.558
<v Rebecca Dobert>City Council, please use your power to be Metro heroes.

1401
02:25:18.654 --> 02:25:18.911
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1402
02:25:19.792 --> 02:25:20.787
<v Rebecca Dobert>Reject the master plan.

1403
02:25:21.459 --> 02:25:23.672
<v Rebecca Dobert>Mandate adaptive reuse of the Lloyd Center core.

1404
02:25:24.441 --> 02:25:28.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>Promote economic development and sustain the habitat of your funky people.

1405
02:25:29.170 --> 02:25:32.631
<v Rebecca Dobert>They have a little of that old light that made Portland a beacon to the world.

1406
02:25:33.657 --> 02:25:37.264
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Lloyd Center owners and operators, for the space you held for me.

1407
02:25:37.729 --> 02:25:39.845
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you for giving me a reason to invest in Portland.

1408
02:25:40.309 --> 02:25:42.265
<v Rebecca Dobert>I will never forget my Lloyd Center adventure.

1409
02:25:43.676 --> 02:25:44.525
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1410
02:25:47.186 --> 02:25:53.789
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hello, my name is Kathleen, or Libby, Rice, and I'm here today in support of the appeals to save Lloyd Center.

1411
02:25:55.215 --> 02:26:12.745
<v Rebecca Dobert>Rather than approving a master plan that wastefully demolishes the entire mall, I would urge that the appeals be granted in order for— to give time for careful consideration of an alternative route to build housing while also preserving a meaningful portion of the mall, including the ice rink.

1412
02:26:12.841 --> 02:26:13.065
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1413
02:26:14.364 --> 02:26:26.289
<v Rebecca Dobert>Design Policy 2.LD-3 requires the master plan to encourage public spaces, public art, and activities that celebrate the history of the district and that help build a community.

1414
02:26:27.283 --> 02:26:35.806
<v Rebecca Dobert>Demolishing Lloyd Center would not only destroy a historic building, it would displace the already vibrant community that has come to call the mall their home.

1415
02:26:36.753 --> 02:27:00.681
<v Rebecca Dobert>Groups like the viral all-inclusive mall walking group Food Court 5000, whose members include marginalized folks with mobility challenges and developmental disabilities, is just one example of what magic can happen when accessible indoor climate-controlled safe space is available to people in search of public activities that foster human connection.

1416
02:27:01.850 --> 02:27:12.969
<v Rebecca Dobert>Total demolition would rob us all of an invaluable space that could be so vibrant Thank you very much.

1417
02:27:15.950 --> 02:27:23.861
<v Rebecca Dobert>Julie, Julie Weber, Tara Kruegel, Elias Inam, Samuel Inam, Sienna Church.

1418
02:27:32.420 --> 02:27:34.552
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I can get the mic?

1419
02:27:34.635 --> 02:27:34.814
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah.

1420
02:27:35.058 --> 02:27:36.361
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes, thank you.

1421
02:27:36.523 --> 02:27:38.251
<v Rebecca Dobert>I need help getting to the mic.

1422
02:27:46.093 --> 02:27:52.617
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, my name is Eli Anam, and these are the reasons I love Lloyd Ice Rink.

1423
02:27:53.342 --> 02:27:55.936
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is the first rink I ever skated at.

1424
02:27:56.646 --> 02:27:58.719
<v Rebecca Dobert>I don't want my coach to move away.

1425
02:27:59.731 --> 02:28:01.561
<v Rebecca Dobert>I like skating with my friends.

1426
02:28:02.300 --> 02:28:04.163
<v Rebecca Dobert>I want to keep competing there.

1427
02:28:04.790 --> 02:28:07.134
<v Rebecca Dobert>I don't want to skate at colder rinks.

1428
02:28:07.921 --> 02:28:13.122
<v Rebecca Dobert>I like watching the really good skaters, having a lesson with the best coaches.

1429
02:28:14.279 --> 02:28:21.873
<v Rebecca Dobert>These are the reasons I love Lloyd Ice Rink, and I want everybody to have the same opportunities.

1430
02:28:22.371 --> 02:28:31.108
<v Rebecca Dobert>Help preserve Thank you very much.

1431
02:28:32.770 --> 02:28:34.074
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Sam Anam.

1432
02:28:34.620 --> 02:28:35.698
<v Rebecca Dobert>I am 11 years old.

1433
02:28:36.227 --> 02:28:37.818
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have been skating for 5 years.

1434
02:28:38.316 --> 02:28:45.070
<v Rebecca Dobert>The best thing about living in a city is that there are opportunities to visit new places, learn things, and have fun.

1435
02:28:45.816 --> 02:28:50.738
<v Rebecca Dobert>When I'm a teenager, I look forward to being able to take the bus and do things like skating with my friends.

1436
02:28:51.849 --> 02:28:56.415
<v Rebecca Dobert>If activities and culture get pushed to the suburbs, there will be nothing to do here.

1437
02:28:56.879 --> 02:29:02.825
<v Rebecca Dobert>Portland will become boring, and it will be difficult for my generation and our families to want to stay here.

1438
02:29:03.352 --> 02:29:04.699
<v Rebecca Dobert>This master plan is boring.

1439
02:29:05.435 --> 02:29:07.791
<v Rebecca Dobert>The city needs to put the community first.

1440
02:29:08.320 --> 02:29:14.104
<v Rebecca Dobert>My ask is for the City Council to please help preserve, replace, or relocate our special rink.

1441
02:29:14.986 --> 02:29:16.556
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1442
02:29:20.210 --> 02:29:21.141
<v Jamie Dunphy>Tough act to follow.

1443
02:29:21.622 --> 02:29:22.297
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Council.

1444
02:29:22.441 --> 02:29:23.371
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Tara Kruegel.

1445
02:29:23.709 --> 02:29:29.725
<v Rebecca Dobert>I am a parent of ice skaters, a mall walker 5000, and a gold status rewards customer at the Lloyd Center Hot Topic.

1446
02:29:30.447 --> 02:29:33.271
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've spent— and I need it to stay there.

1447
02:29:33.672 --> 02:29:44.308
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've spent hundreds of hours of my life chaperoning my kids at the ice rink and watching the life cycle of the Lloyd Center, and I believe it would be a mistake to completely demolish this unique local hub of commerce, recreation, and community.

1448
02:29:44.422 --> 02:29:57.495
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm here in solidarity with both appellants who have made great cases with the technical and legal arguments for why the ice rink and a portion of the current Lloyd structure should remain, while also supporting the goal of developing the housing in the area.

1449
02:29:58.200 --> 02:30:02.351
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have a hard time believing the narrative put in the media by private equity that we can't have both.

1450
02:30:03.231 --> 02:30:11.949
<v Rebecca Dobert>After many years of being assured that the ice rink would be part of any future plans on the site, the rug was pulled out from under us this past winter when the master plan was dropped on Lloyd Center users.

1451
02:30:12.013 --> 02:30:14.898
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilmember Denying us any chance for input on the design.

1452
02:30:15.974 --> 02:30:19.325
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe this lack of community outreach is one good reason to reopen the process.

1453
02:30:20.158 --> 02:30:28.465
<v Rebecca Dobert>A big topic in our country right now is affordability, and I want to say as a parent that Lloyd Center ice skating lessons are one of the most affordable activities my kids can do in Portland.

1454
02:30:28.737 --> 02:30:34.350
<v Rebecca Dobert>Enrolling them in reasonably priced weekly lessons gives them unlimited access to all public skating at the Lloyd Rink.

1455
02:30:34.671 --> 02:30:39.449
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is many hours a day of year-round climate-controlled exercise and recreation that is centrally located.

1456
02:30:39.658 --> 02:30:47.218
<v Rebecca Dobert>And accessible by transit, an amenity for families the city should want to retain rather than pushing more and more of us out to the suburbs to find these opportunities.

1457
02:30:47.969 --> 02:30:50.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>I ask you to please support these appeals so that we can get this design right.

1458
02:30:51.130 --> 02:30:51.452
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1459
02:30:51.808 --> 02:30:52.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1460
02:30:54.666 --> 02:30:57.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>Julie Weber or Sienna Church?

1461
02:31:00.793 --> 02:31:01.807
<v Rebecca Dobert>Keith Adamson?

1462
02:31:02.868 --> 02:31:04.218
<v Rebecca Dobert>Julie Strawitz?

1463
02:31:05.332 --> 02:31:10.885
<v Rebecca Dobert>Nicholas Prim, Wendy May, Amanda Bowman Mejia.

1464
02:31:11.815 --> 02:31:14.688
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, Council President and councilors.

1465
02:31:14.879 --> 02:31:22.117
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Keith Adamson, uh, Vice Chair of the Solomons Gulch Neighborhood Association, and this testimony is offered on behalf of said organization.

1466
02:31:22.888 --> 02:31:24.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, we support the appeals.

1467
02:31:25.149 --> 02:31:28.905
<v Jamie Dunphy>We ask council to sustain them and send the plan back for further review.

1468
02:31:29.547 --> 02:31:31.617
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lloyd Center is more than an aging mall.

1469
02:31:31.906 --> 02:31:32.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is a civic Aye.

1470
02:31:32.559 --> 02:31:32.559
<v Rebecca Dobert>Opposed?

1471
02:31:32.559 --> 02:31:32.559
<v Rebecca Dobert>Nay.

1472
02:31:32.559 --> 02:31:32.559
<v Rebecca Dobert>Motion carries.

1473
02:31:32.559 --> 02:31:32.559
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1474
02:31:32.559 --> 02:31:32.559
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next item on the agenda is Council Bill 2023-1.

1475
02:31:32.559 --> 02:31:36.010
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is a proposed ordinance to establish a new zoning district for the downtown historic space, a home for small business, and part of the city's identity.

1476
02:31:37.040 --> 02:31:47.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>The approved framework appears to assume wholesale demolition without showing meaningful reuse was fully explored as called for by Guideline A-6.

1477
02:31:47.000 --> 02:31:53.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>This poor consideration of reuse also abuses the notion of sustainability, 1.LD-2.

1478
02:31:53.280 --> 02:32:08.713
<v Jamie Dunphy>While the applicant touts the benefits of future green development, it gives too little weight to the environmental costs of demolition in direct opposition to the city's Bureau of Planning and Sustainability acknowledgment of the need to address embodied carbon to meet our climate goals.

1479
02:32:09.788 --> 02:32:22.147
<v Jamie Dunphy>The removal of such a valuable community space with no serious prospect for its replacement calls into question how this master plan can possibly adhere to the criteria around community building 2.LD-3.

1480
02:32:22.789 --> 02:32:29.996
<v Jamie Dunphy>We support reinvestment housing, open space, and a stronger Lloyd District, but council should not approve a demolition-first plan.

1481
02:32:30.655 --> 02:32:44.191
<v Jamie Dunphy>And to be clear, the demolition is implicitly required by this plan, even if not filed, without clear assurance that the public benefits will be built and that the site will not sit vacant for years as nearby parcels already have.

1482
02:32:44.784 --> 02:32:54.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please uphold the appeals and require a revised plan that seriously evaluates reuse protects community-serving uses, and provides a credible and accountable path to real public benefit.

1483
02:32:54.519 --> 02:32:54.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1484
02:32:55.326 --> 02:32:55.877
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1485
02:32:58.250 --> 02:32:59.878
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hi, my name is Julie Strawitz.

1486
02:32:59.975 --> 02:33:03.215
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm a skater and costumer for the Lloyd Center ice shows.

1487
02:33:04.010 --> 02:33:07.013
<v Rebecca Dobert>I moved to inner southeast Portland from Vermont 15 years ago.

1488
02:33:07.720 --> 02:33:13.136
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm an avid skater and was thrilled to find a wonderful community of diverse people who use the Lloyd Center ice rink.

1489
02:33:13.770 --> 02:33:19.031
<v Rebecca Dobert>I became, became involved in taking classes, performing in shows, and also costuming.

1490
02:33:20.111 --> 02:33:28.010
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have never experienced the unique community that the Lloyd Center Rink offers at any of the other rinks I've skated at, and I've skated at a lot of rinks.

1491
02:33:29.846 --> 02:33:42.114
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have seen very young children as well as older adults and everyone in between enjoy the facility, skating together in the many classes that are offered as well as performing in the fantastic shows that entertain the wider Portland community.

1492
02:33:43.018 --> 02:33:49.019
<v Rebecca Dobert>I will be turning 70 in August, and I will sorely miss this wonderful, safe place to pursue the sport that I love.

1493
02:33:49.852 --> 02:33:53.077
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've seen a lot of changes in Portland over the last 15 years.

1494
02:33:53.639 --> 02:33:58.004
<v Rebecca Dobert>So many businesses, retail establishments, and individuals have left the city.

1495
02:33:58.933 --> 02:34:06.683
<v Rebecca Dobert>The only ice rink in Portland Metro leaving forever would be yet another blow to this formerly vibrant and very special place.

1496
02:34:07.647 --> 02:34:11.963
<v Rebecca Dobert>The year-round ice rink is too important a community asset to leave its future uncertain.

1497
02:34:12.381 --> 02:34:20.915
<v Rebecca Dobert>I ask that the City Council remand the master plan to the Design Commission and require an agreement to preserve, replace, or relocate the rink.

1498
02:34:21.950 --> 02:34:23.712
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1499
02:34:26.493 --> 02:34:27.393
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Wendy May.

1500
02:34:28.244 --> 02:35:05.352
<v Rebecca Dobert>As a 69-year-old figure skater, I'm getting close to ending my time on the ice, so I will deal just fine with the closure of the I'm here mainly because the vibrant voices of the Lloyd skating community were never included in discussions when creating the master plan, an odd omission when the developer described years of input from neighbors and community groups.

1501
02:35:06.106 --> 02:35:17.924
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, City Council, for allowing the skaters the opportunity today to at least feel like we are contributing to deliberative processes that affect the lives of Portland residents.

1502
02:35:19.048 --> 02:35:27.781
<v Rebecca Dobert>My ask today is for the City Council to remand the master plan back to the Design Commission to address the elimination of the iconic Lloyd rink.

1503
02:35:28.503 --> 02:35:36.915
<v Rebecca Dobert>If the council decides it cannot do this, I ask it to empower a public-private partnership along the lines of what is happening with the Portland Tennis Center.

1504
02:35:37.958 --> 02:35:46.659
<v Rebecca Dobert>The Lloyd Skaters have already formed a nonprofit which has the creation of a city year-round rink as its primary mission, and it has already begun fundraising.

1505
02:35:47.108 --> 02:35:59.550
<v Rebecca Dobert>Certainly there are city organizations that could assist this project so that Portland does not end up being the only Very much.

1506
02:36:02.620 --> 02:36:10.665
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, my name is Amanda Bowman Mejia, and I am here to testify in support of the appeal of the Lloyd Center master plan.

1507
02:36:11.165 --> 02:36:16.379
<v Rebecca Dobert>As a mother and a school social worker, I'm concerned about the lack of third spaces for youth in Portland.

1508
02:36:16.788 --> 02:36:18.665
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center demonstrates what is Aye.

1509
02:36:18.713 --> 02:36:25.308
<v Rebecca Dobert>This plan is only possible when rent is affordable and accessible for small businesses as well as youth-led and community-led organizations.

1510
02:36:25.903 --> 02:36:31.149
<v Rebecca Dobert>While the plan looks appealing, there is no promise of any developers actually going through with it.

1511
02:36:31.824 --> 02:36:40.072
<v Rebecca Dobert>I support a phased redevelopment as I am also very concerned about the heat island effect that will accompany a full demolition.

1512
02:36:40.665 --> 02:36:47.245
<v Rebecca Dobert>As temperatures continue to rise, it seems like a bad idea to tear down all the buildings at once and leave a A concrete parking lot.

1513
02:36:47.727 --> 02:36:51.308
<v Rebecca Dobert>Look across the street to the empty theater parking lot that is fenced off.

1514
02:36:51.742 --> 02:36:57.248
<v Rebecca Dobert>Having empty and unpromising spaces like this do not make the city look inviting or thriving.

1515
02:36:57.683 --> 02:37:03.816
<v Rebecca Dobert>There are numerous already empty buildings in this area as well that could be better targets for redevelopment.

1516
02:37:03.929 --> 02:37:07.845
<v Rebecca Dobert>I encourage city councilors to appeal the Lloyd Center master plan.

1517
02:37:08.762 --> 02:37:11.170
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1518
02:37:13.237 --> 02:37:21.154
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, I am Nicholas Prim, uh, an advisor to the Save Lloyd campaign and the author of a real alternative plan called the Lloyd Commons Proposal.

1519
02:37:21.970 --> 02:37:26.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>As you have heard today, um, and we'll continue here, we all want the same thing.

1520
02:37:26.938 --> 02:37:33.987
<v Jamie Dunphy>We want housing development, we want the site revitalized, we want an eco-Lloyd district that actually works for the port— for Portland's next chapter.

1521
02:37:34.726 --> 02:37:56.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>What we do not want is for a 1 million square foot building that has served this city both The mall has served Portland both civically and economically for over 60 years and was recently remodeled for $50 million to be chucked into our local landfills in exchange for what is currently planned, a Central Park, a planned park that will initially sit at the center of a 27-acre demolition site for an undetermined number of years.

1522
02:37:56.941 --> 02:38:14.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>The current core structure, or the mall, and its surrounding site is capable of providing the housing, the open space, and the affordable housing opportunities The master plan promises, and most of this is already built—a three-story civic-style building ready to evolve past a mall into the Portland community landmark it has always been.

1523
02:38:15.148 --> 02:38:28.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>We all we are asking is that this council channel the creative and community resilience that clearly courses through the city and this room today, and find a way to make the master plan work for everyone.

1524
02:38:28.884 --> 02:38:30.361
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's practice what we preach.

1525
02:38:30.425 --> 02:38:31.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's ensure the findings reflect.

1526
02:38:31.860 --> 02:38:39.443
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sustainable, adaptive, and climate-honest urban planning, and that, that is core to this city's stated values and to its own code.

1527
02:38:39.764 --> 02:38:42.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Remanding under adequate findings is how this council does that.

1528
02:38:43.078 --> 02:38:46.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Demolish the wall of parking, save the civic core, and build the new block around it.

1529
02:38:47.170 --> 02:38:47.588
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1530
02:38:47.959 --> 02:38:48.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1531
02:38:52.155 --> 02:39:00.798
<v Rebecca Dobert>Olive Eldridge, Brenda Arwen Rose Niedert, Liz Hardy, Roman Ruddick, Kellen Embry.

1532
02:39:05.094 --> 02:39:09.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome folks, come on down, uh, introduce yourselves and take it away.

1533
02:39:09.634 --> 02:39:11.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, I am Oliver Eldridge.

1534
02:39:12.149 --> 02:39:16.554
<v Jamie Dunphy>What the Lloyd Center has become in recent years represents the heart of Portland's identity.

1535
02:39:17.056 --> 02:39:22.724
<v Jamie Dunphy>It represents our answers to a question property developers have asked, like, what's our Pike's Place?

1536
02:39:23.494 --> 02:39:34.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it does so not by trying to recreate Pike's, sinking millions into a financially tumultuous project stuck in development limbo, but instead by allowing itself to be shaped by the people who visit it.

1537
02:39:35.070 --> 02:39:42.906
<v Jamie Dunphy>Instead of becoming a mall that favors large business, Lloyd becomes a community hub that puts local business and city residents first.

1538
02:39:43.468 --> 02:39:46.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>The master plan does not serve our working class.

1539
02:39:46.680 --> 02:39:54.172
<v Jamie Dunphy>The master plan does not exist The master plan exists to appease those who have active disdain towards our city.

1540
02:39:54.846 --> 02:39:59.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>An outdoor shopping center and more beige condos are not going to appease those people.

1541
02:40:00.000 --> 02:40:00.638
<v Jamie Dunphy>They never will.

1542
02:40:03.602 --> 02:40:07.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>The master plan in principle is antisocial.

1543
02:40:07.225 --> 02:40:09.204
<v Jamie Dunphy>It does not address climate crisis.

1544
02:40:09.575 --> 02:40:14.718
<v Jamie Dunphy>It does not address the volume of humanity, community, and art that comes from the Lloyd Center.

1545
02:40:15.601 --> 02:40:18.957
<v Jamie Dunphy>The master plan does not trust us with our own city.

1546
02:40:19.454 --> 02:40:21.413
<v Jamie Dunphy>The master plan keeps Portland timid.

1547
02:40:21.799 --> 02:40:24.656
<v Jamie Dunphy>We do not have the park blocks when we are timid.

1548
02:40:25.315 --> 02:40:29.023
<v Jamie Dunphy>The people here represent more than a property portfolio.

1549
02:40:29.184 --> 02:40:35.575
<v Jamie Dunphy>The people here understand that we can reuse our resources to create something special, something for us and by us.

1550
02:40:36.265 --> 02:40:39.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>The people here know the environmental impact the summer months have on our city.

1551
02:40:40.108 --> 02:40:41.290
<v Jamie Dunphy>We love this city.

1552
02:40:41.710 --> 02:40:42.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>We believe in this city.

1553
02:40:43.573 --> 02:40:48.754
<v Jamie Dunphy>When you go to bed at night, do you think of Zoom calls and ivory towers, or do you think of people?

1554
02:40:55.916 --> 02:40:58.248
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilors, thank you for the opportunity to comment today.

1555
02:40:58.605 --> 02:40:59.627
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Liz Hardy.

1556
02:40:59.967 --> 02:41:03.837
<v Rebecca Dobert>I am a resident of District 3 and an adult member of the Lloyd skating community.

1557
02:41:04.522 --> 02:41:11.220
<v Rebecca Dobert>After having been away from skating since my childhood, Lloyd has allowed me to redevelop my skills in an inclusive and supportive environment.

1558
02:41:11.701 --> 02:41:17.547
<v Rebecca Dobert>But I'd like to focus today on the fact that this isn't really about saving a building or even really just about skating.

1559
02:41:18.060 --> 02:41:21.737
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's about making a choice as a community about what we want our future to look like.

1560
02:41:22.476 --> 02:41:28.320
<v Rebecca Dobert>The new Lloyd renderings we've all seen in local media are just ideas about what these redeveloped plots could look like.

1561
02:41:28.898 --> 02:41:32.415
<v Rebecca Dobert>The reality is that the developers have 10 years to begin redevelopment.

1562
02:41:32.833 --> 02:41:42.750
<v Rebecca Dobert>And while the master plan approval gives the property owner a leg up in courting investors, it doesn't guarantee that they'll materialize in sufficient numbers to make starting construction financially feasible.

1563
02:41:43.488 --> 02:41:51.994
<v Rebecca Dobert>This means that rather than being used for and by the community, there's a non-zero chance the land sits vacant for a decade, a big empty lot surrounded by chain link.

1564
02:41:52.476 --> 02:41:54.690
<v Rebecca Dobert>Then the developers sell it at a loss and take a write-off.

1565
02:41:55.299 --> 02:42:00.805
<v Rebecca Dobert>This would run directly counter to Policy 1LD-3 on tourism, retail, and entertainment.

1566
02:42:01.478 --> 02:42:08.352
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is a centrally Centrally located transit-accessible property with limitless potential as a community resource and draw to our great city.

1567
02:42:08.786 --> 02:42:12.352
<v Rebecca Dobert>And it would be a shame to let it sit, decay, and ultimately benefit no one.

1568
02:42:13.186 --> 02:42:17.827
<v Rebecca Dobert>I would encourage the council to ask the property owners what they have lined up in terms of investment.

1569
02:42:18.182 --> 02:42:21.120
<v Rebecca Dobert>We don't know what the answer to that question is, but I bet it's informative.

1570
02:42:21.860 --> 02:42:30.072
<v Rebecca Dobert>In conclusion, if our community has been meaningfully— if our community had been meaningfully engaged during the master plan process, We would not be here today.

1571
02:42:30.475 --> 02:42:34.907
<v Rebecca Dobert>But because we are, we ask for the council's help to preserve, replace, or relocate our rink.

1572
02:42:35.310 --> 02:42:35.618
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1573
02:42:36.021 --> 02:42:37.983
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1574
02:42:39.333 --> 02:42:45.005
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Brenda Niedert, and I am a licensed mental health professional in the state of Oregon.

1575
02:42:45.279 --> 02:42:57.708
<v Rebecca Dobert>I have a private practice, and I'm here to speak about just how community spaces, and specifically the Lloyd Center ICE community, supports one another.

1576
02:42:58.468 --> 02:43:03.191
<v Rebecca Dobert>And 500 people a week, as someone else mentioned, that's a lot of people.

1577
02:43:03.288 --> 02:43:12.670
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've spoken with people who've come with anxiety, with other trauma, with substance use disorders, and I know we all care about those things in our community.

1578
02:43:14.051 --> 02:43:18.550
<v Rebecca Dobert>And personally speaking, I started skating about 4 years ago.

1579
02:43:19.353 --> 02:43:30.475
<v Rebecca Dobert>I had an only child who was critically ill at the moment, and I found great community support there, and I've continued to skate there almost every day since.

1580
02:43:30.747 --> 02:43:33.537
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think this is a very important community.

1581
02:43:34.113 --> 02:43:36.054
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's— we cannot find anything like this.

1582
02:43:36.134 --> 02:43:42.882
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've been to several different community places, and both young and old, everyone supports each other.

1583
02:43:42.931 --> 02:43:50.096
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I have like parent figures at Lloyd Center, and I've got young adults that I can show my love to when my son's far away.

1584
02:43:50.822 --> 02:44:06.257
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I ask the City Council to, to consider making a plan to preserve, replace, or re— relocate the Lloyd Ice Rink.

1585
02:44:06.418 --> 02:44:06.740
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1586
02:44:07.239 --> 02:44:07.700
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1587
02:44:10.122 --> 02:44:11.752
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hello, my name is Roman Ruddick.

1588
02:44:12.793 --> 02:44:26.368
<v Rebecca Dobert>I ask the council consider that while privately owned, Lloyd Center provides vital public service, and that this master plan site is designated as the anchor of a TIF district, positioning it for future public investment.

1589
02:44:27.492 --> 02:44:35.005
<v Rebecca Dobert>The applicant represents Lloyd Center as aging, single-use, auto-oriented, and disconnected from a neighborhood, but that is far from reality.

1590
02:44:35.921 --> 02:44:41.877
<v Rebecca Dobert>In a district dominated by corporate offices and ticketed venues with no library or community center, Councilor Smith.

1591
02:44:42.663 --> 02:44:52.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center holds hundreds of accessible community events year-round, providing a climate-controlled, pedestrian-oriented public realm even during extreme weather.

1592
02:44:54.203 --> 02:44:59.622
<v Rebecca Dobert>The applicant's claim of reusing existing structures as impractical is unsubstantiated.

1593
02:45:00.520 --> 02:45:08.054
<v Rebecca Dobert>The renovations in the '90s were worth nearly $600 million today, followed by another $50 million investment less than a decade ago.

1594
02:45:08.135 --> 02:45:08.534
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilmember Herbold.

1595
02:45:09.835 --> 02:45:12.532
<v Rebecca Dobert>Including major structural and energy efficiency upgrades.

1596
02:45:13.528 --> 02:45:26.211
<v Rebecca Dobert>Today, not a single housing project is proposed, but Lloyd Center has a long history of adaptive reuse, supporting medical offices, schools, government institutions, recreation, entertainment, and more.

1597
02:45:27.254 --> 02:45:32.859
<v Rebecca Dobert>Vacancy is not evidence that a building is obsolete, and demolition is not a prerequisite to progress.

1598
02:45:33.822 --> 02:45:37.402
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm not asking that you require current owners to continue operating a mall.

1599
02:45:37.450 --> 02:45:37.738
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilmember Smith.

1600
02:45:39.209 --> 02:45:47.301
<v Rebecca Dobert>I am simply asking that you do not approve a framework that lacks a clear path forward or evidence supporting the claims used to satisfy approval criteria.

1601
02:45:47.559 --> 02:45:48.361
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1602
02:45:48.595 --> 02:45:49.281
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1603
02:45:52.760 --> 02:45:54.112
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hello, and thank you for your time.

1604
02:45:54.564 --> 02:45:55.497
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Kellen Embry.

1605
02:45:55.772 --> 02:45:59.960
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm a District 1 resident and for the last 2 years a Lloyd Center skater.

1606
02:46:00.638 --> 02:46:17.225
<v Rebecca Dobert>I want to be clear, I don't oppose housing, I don't oppose redevelopment, And I have a deep respect for the processes that this city has put in place to make development efforts clear and consistent, and would like to see Portland keep pace with other cities that work quickly to enhance the livability of their residents.

1607
02:46:18.042 --> 02:46:24.621
<v Rebecca Dobert>But when those processes leave no opportunity for real, meaningful engagement with the communities they serve, we're in trouble.

1608
02:46:25.504 --> 02:46:41.171
<v Rebecca Dobert>For years, skaters, employees, and coaches were repeatedly told that year-round skating would remain a central attraction in the area, By the time that the public learned that year-round ice skating was no longer part of that proposal, the opportunity for true collaboration had already passed.

1609
02:46:42.438 --> 02:46:53.144
<v Rebecca Dobert>When a project is intended to shape the future of a neighborhood and improve quality of life, the affected communities deserve a meaningful voice in determining what amenities and gathering spaces are worth preserving.

1610
02:46:53.816 --> 02:46:55.805
<v Rebecca Dobert>In this case, that conversation came too late.

1611
02:46:56.461 --> 02:47:01.766
<v Rebecca Dobert>We are asking for accountability, transparency, and for the community to have a seat at the table when decisions affect them.

1612
02:47:01.831 --> 02:47:02.055
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1613
02:47:02.231 --> 02:47:03.165
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thousands of Portlanders.

1614
02:47:04.389 --> 02:47:07.047
<v Rebecca Dobert>Development and community assets are not mutually exclusive.

1615
02:47:07.466 --> 02:47:14.263
<v Rebecca Dobert>I urge you to send the plan back and make approval contingent upon a binding agreement to preserve, replace, or relocate the year-round rink.

1616
02:47:14.492 --> 02:47:14.736
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1617
02:47:15.405 --> 02:47:16.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you all very much.

1618
02:47:19.909 --> 02:47:37.889
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ruth Aquino, Michelle Forbes, Cleo Levine, Zach Newman, Welcome, folks.

1619
02:47:39.750 --> 02:47:40.931
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hello, council members.

1620
02:47:41.593 --> 02:47:42.418
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm Ruth Aquino.

1621
02:47:43.066 --> 02:47:46.075
<v Rebecca Dobert>I began skating at Lloyd Center when I was 5 years old.

1622
02:47:46.629 --> 02:47:50.808
<v Rebecca Dobert>I started coaching at Lloyd Center in the early '90s, and I'm still there.

1623
02:47:51.764 --> 02:47:57.307
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center is a special third space of art and culture The rink is its crowning glory.

1624
02:47:57.739 --> 02:48:04.047
<v Rebecca Dobert>We have a large active adult skating community and aspiring young competitive figure skaters.

1625
02:48:04.319 --> 02:48:10.786
<v Rebecca Dobert>We provide a home for the Sherwood Figure Skating Club and recreational skaters that come just for the fun of it all.

1626
02:48:11.684 --> 02:48:15.761
<v Rebecca Dobert>We have a special needs skater that came to Lloyd Center when he was 12 years old.

1627
02:48:16.514 --> 02:48:18.183
<v Rebecca Dobert>He is now 25 years old.

1628
02:48:18.504 --> 02:48:19.500
<v Rebecca Dobert>He learned to skate.

1629
02:48:20.431 --> 02:48:24.514
<v Rebecca Dobert>His caregivers bring him to the rink Every day he skates for several hours.

1630
02:48:25.335 --> 02:48:26.800
<v Rebecca Dobert>He reacts to the music.

1631
02:48:27.106 --> 02:48:29.795
<v Rebecca Dobert>He speaks to people real and imagined.

1632
02:48:31.216 --> 02:48:31.650
<v Rebecca Dobert>Where will he go?

1633
02:48:32.505 --> 02:48:33.199
<v Rebecca Dobert>What will he do?

1634
02:48:34.134 --> 02:48:40.152
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Center provides physical, mental, and emotional needs every day by ice skating.

1635
02:48:41.239 --> 02:48:47.125
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dear council members, Multnomah County is offering less and less to its citizens.

1636
02:48:47.721 --> 02:48:52.060
<v Rebecca Dobert>You successfully put your heads together to save the duck and geese of Oregon.

1637
02:48:53.709 --> 02:48:58.737
<v Rebecca Dobert>I implore you to use that same energy to save the flocks of skaters at Lloyd Center.

1638
02:49:00.706 --> 02:49:05.902
<v Rebecca Dobert>Please don't ban ice skating from Lloyd Center, from Multnomah County, from Portland.

1639
02:49:06.516 --> 02:49:10.538
<v Rebecca Dobert>I want better for my students, my community, and myself.

1640
02:49:11.118 --> 02:49:17.606
<v Rebecca Dobert>Please demand a new full-size permanent rink in the master plan for the Lloyd redevelopment.

1641
02:49:17.672 --> 02:49:17.864
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1642
02:49:18.479 --> 02:49:24.272
<v Rebecca Dobert>The, the design commission made a mistake, but there's time to turn it around and get it right.

1643
02:49:25.920 --> 02:49:27.713
<v Rebecca Dobert>Don't let the demise of the Lloyd Center—.

1644
02:49:27.891 --> 02:49:32.225
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1645
02:49:35.837 --> 02:49:38.378
<v Rebecca Dobert>Michelle Forbes, Portland resident.

1646
02:49:39.171 --> 02:49:42.779
<v Rebecca Dobert>Lloyd Rink has been the center of so much positivity in our lives.

1647
02:49:43.934 --> 02:49:46.418
<v Rebecca Dobert>We found it when we needed a place for a winter birthday.

1648
02:49:46.757 --> 02:49:49.226
<v Rebecca Dobert>A party in the park in January is not a thing.

1649
02:49:51.090 --> 02:49:52.610
<v Rebecca Dobert>And since then, it's become our town square.

1650
02:49:52.981 --> 02:49:58.546
<v Rebecca Dobert>Every Portlander has fond memories of visiting Lloyd Rink, but it's not just frivolous nostalgia.

1651
02:49:58.981 --> 02:50:03.199
<v Rebecca Dobert>It holds a place in people's hearts because it's more than a physical building.

1652
02:50:03.391 --> 02:50:05.636
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink is a truly inspiring place.

1653
02:50:05.895 --> 02:50:09.075
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's a resource for discovery, connection, and growth.

1654
02:50:09.139 --> 02:50:09.284
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1655
02:50:09.815 --> 02:50:11.621
<v Rebecca Dobert>The best humanity can hope for.

1656
02:50:12.557 --> 02:50:16.510
<v Rebecca Dobert>We have to protect our resources and not allow them to be designed away.

1657
02:50:17.440 --> 02:50:21.611
<v Rebecca Dobert>If the codes can be flexible for a developer, why not for public need?

1658
02:50:23.139 --> 02:50:28.292
<v Rebecca Dobert>The rink is one of the strongest embodiments of so many of the city's own stated values and goals.

1659
02:50:28.825 --> 02:50:34.477
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's a distinctive urban place and a credit to Portland's character, which we all know has been crumbling.

1660
02:50:35.584 --> 02:50:38.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's what Portland truly needs for a real renaissance.

1661
02:50:39.343 --> 02:50:40.853
<v Rebecca Dobert>And miracle, we actually have it.

1662
02:50:41.593 --> 02:50:44.886
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's just about to be disappeared through a bunch of paperwork.

1663
02:50:45.368 --> 02:50:49.737
<v Rebecca Dobert>I really can't believe we're choosing to throw away this essential and beloved piece of Portland.

1664
02:50:50.203 --> 02:50:51.745
<v Rebecca Dobert>Is the White Stag sign next?

1665
02:50:52.468 --> 02:50:57.400
<v Rebecca Dobert>If we sacrifice Lloyd Rink today, it will be remembered as a sad day for the city.

1666
02:50:58.397 --> 02:51:18.843
<v Rebecca Dobert>I urge this City Council to make the Lloyd Plan approval contingent My name is James Mears.

1667
02:51:19.263 --> 02:51:22.637
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've been skating at Lloyd Center for almost 20 years.

1668
02:51:22.895 --> 02:51:32.692
<v Jamie Dunphy>I began skating there with my young son when he wanted to learn, so we both I skate now for exercise and to connect with my friends there.

1669
02:51:33.880 --> 02:51:37.492
<v Jamie Dunphy>The ice rink is a beautiful space, sunlit by overhead skylights.

1670
02:51:37.587 --> 02:51:40.718
<v Jamie Dunphy>Around the rink, there are usually people relaxing or eating lunch.

1671
02:51:41.424 --> 02:51:50.058
<v Jamie Dunphy>On the ice, I see children working on their figure skating lessons, and I see their instructors who teach them with dedication and with love for their sport.

1672
02:51:50.796 --> 02:52:08.345
<v Jamie Dunphy>I see adults who have skated for many years performing moves I see my friends Jerry and Tally, who have skated together for almost 60 years and who perform their dances at Lloyd Center 4 days a week.

1673
02:52:09.880 --> 02:52:14.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've seen them dance dozens of times, and every time there is someone videoing them with their phone.

1674
02:52:15.121 --> 02:52:19.434
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's not an exaggeration to say that those videos have been shared all over the world hundreds of times.

1675
02:52:19.500 --> 02:52:19.727
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1676
02:52:20.790 --> 02:52:29.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>I see Jerry and Tally and all of the Lloyd Center ice skaters as emissaries of joy from Portland to the world.

1677
02:52:30.270 --> 02:52:35.584
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe that what happens at Lloyd Center ice rink is part of the heart and soul of Portland.

1678
02:52:36.252 --> 02:52:44.272
<v Jamie Dunphy>It would be a great sacrifice to see it torn apart without at least some plan to replace it and to try to save the unique community that thrives there.

1679
02:52:44.661 --> 02:52:45.996
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all very much for your time.

1680
02:52:46.047 --> 02:52:47.515
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thanks very much.

1681
02:52:48.847 --> 02:52:50.128
<v Rebecca Dobert>Cleo, go ahead online.

1682
02:52:53.731 --> 02:53:00.623
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hi, my name is Cleo Levine and I'm going into 6th grade at Fabian School in Northeast Portland.

1683
02:53:01.093 --> 02:53:07.850
<v Rebecca Dobert>I've been really into ice skating recently, but the closest rink besides Lloyd Center is an hour away with traffic.

1684
02:53:08.268 --> 02:53:12.512
<v Rebecca Dobert>That makes it harder for me, my family, and other people in our community to skate.

1685
02:53:13.143 --> 02:53:33.212
<v Rebecca Dobert>I understand that Keeping the rink at Lloyd Center might not be an option anymore, but I think I'm speaking for myself and a lot of other people when I say that even though the Lloyd Center development is supposed to attract new people to Portland, we should focus on kids in the community who also love to skate, such as myself.

1686
02:53:33.807 --> 02:53:36.840
<v Rebecca Dobert>The Lloyd Center ice rink has created a real community.

1687
02:53:37.176 --> 02:53:46.531
<v Rebecca Dobert>If the rink cannot stay where it is, I hope the city will help build a new sheet of ice somewhere nearby so that Portland does not lose its ice skating community.

1688
02:53:46.871 --> 02:53:47.827
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you for listening.

1689
02:53:48.829 --> 02:53:49.296
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1690
02:53:51.031 --> 02:53:51.852
<v Rebecca Dobert>Go ahead, Zach.

1691
02:53:53.667 --> 02:53:57.932
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hello, um, my name is Zach Newman and I am a resident of District 3.

1692
02:53:58.659 --> 02:54:03.398
<v Jamie Dunphy>It saddens me to see no commitment to the history of this site almost anywhere within this application.

1693
02:54:03.916 --> 02:54:08.843
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm asking City Council to require the preservation of historic amenities in the site like the ice skating rink.

1694
02:54:09.523 --> 02:54:13.186
<v Jamie Dunphy>The applicant says ad nauseam that the Lloyd Center is not a historic resource.

1695
02:54:13.523 --> 02:54:18.086
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, they failed to mention the several attempts at recognizing the space as such.

1696
02:54:18.922 --> 02:54:42.206
<v Jamie Dunphy>In a 2011 report, Modern Historical Resources in the Central City, Peter Meyer Architects, commissioned by the Portland Bureau of Planning and Sustainability, identified the Lloyd Center as a Rank 2 significant historical resource, quote, a property that retains a high level of integrity and played a crucial role in the community's overall development and is individually eligible for historic landmark status.

1697
02:54:42.686 --> 02:54:48.058
<v Jamie Dunphy>Unfortunately, no meaningful action was taken after this inventory, but that does not mean it does not exist.

1698
02:54:48.379 --> 02:54:50.754
<v Jamie Dunphy>This report is still available in the city's archives.

1699
02:54:51.490 --> 02:54:59.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>Furthermore, in 1995, the Friends of the Lloyd Center Ice Rink petitioned the Landmarks Commission to give this rink historic landmark status, but once again, this effort was fruitless.

1700
02:55:00.263 --> 02:55:01.995
<v Jamie Dunphy>It does not mean the attempt did not occur.

1701
02:55:02.518 --> 02:55:10.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>The fact of the matter is that there have been several attempts at giving this ice rink and building historic status, and once a historic resource is lost, it is lost forever.

1702
02:55:11.579 --> 02:55:18.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please, City Council, respect the history and the culture of our city and require that historical homage be paid in this redevelopment plan.

1703
02:55:19.059 --> 02:55:22.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1704
02:55:24.033 --> 02:55:25.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sienna Church has joined online.

1705
02:55:25.697 --> 02:55:26.488
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can go ahead, Sienna.

1706
02:55:34.198 --> 02:55:35.255
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can't hear you, Sienna.

1707
02:55:35.322 --> 02:55:35.988
<v Rebecca Dobert>You need to unmute.

1708
02:55:37.809 --> 02:55:38.245
<v Rebecca Dobert>There we go.

1709
02:55:38.971 --> 02:55:45.204
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hello, my name is Sienna Church and I live in St. Johns District 2, and I am one of the many adult skaters at the Lloyd Center ice rink.

1710
02:55:46.226 --> 02:55:47.418
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm here to encourage city—.

1711
02:55:47.596 --> 02:55:48.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hey, Sienna, we're having a hard time hearing.

1712
02:55:49.000 --> 02:55:50.596
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you're able to get a little closer to the microphone.

1713
02:55:50.838 --> 02:55:52.032
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yep, how's that?

1714
02:55:53.297 --> 02:55:53.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>A little better.

1715
02:55:54.992 --> 02:55:56.040
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Sienna Church.

1716
02:55:56.557 --> 02:56:01.139
<v Rebecca Dobert>I live in St. Johns District 2, and I'm one of the many adult skaters at the Boys and Girls Club.

1717
02:56:02.092 --> 02:56:09.686
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm here to encourage City Council to appeal the current design plan and maintain our original plan to preserve the skate park.

1718
02:56:09.783 --> 02:56:11.074
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sienna, we can't hear you.

1719
02:56:20.799 --> 02:56:21.252
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, no.

1720
02:56:21.407 --> 02:56:21.998
<v Rebecca Dobert>Do you have 2 microphones?

1721
02:56:23.270 --> 02:56:23.998
<v Rebecca Dobert>I just have one.

1722
02:56:25.229 --> 02:56:26.638
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, you're very, very faint.

1723
02:56:26.769 --> 02:56:28.647
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, the members of the council can't hear you.

1724
02:56:30.709 --> 02:56:32.795
<v Rebecca Dobert>Let me try leaning back and seeing if that works.

1725
02:56:35.409 --> 02:56:36.378
<v Rebecca Dobert>We're still having trouble.

1726
02:56:41.527 --> 02:56:53.623
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council President, is it— the transcript is picking up her test Does it meet the, the needs to take this individual's testimony for us to read the transcript?

1727
02:56:53.849 --> 02:56:57.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>If that is as much as we can get from Sienna, let's, let's barrel through.

1728
02:56:57.779 --> 02:56:58.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

1729
02:56:59.254 --> 02:57:00.619
<v Rebecca Dobert>So, Sienna, you can continue.

1730
02:57:00.683 --> 02:57:03.379
<v Rebecca Dobert>The captions are getting your speech.

1731
02:57:04.212 --> 02:57:04.292
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay.

1732
02:57:04.629 --> 02:57:10.021
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Sienna Church and I live in St. Johns District 2, and I am one of the many adult foster parents in Portland.

1733
02:57:11.031 --> 02:57:12.647
<v Rebecca Dobert>Skaters at the Lloyd Center ice rink.

1734
02:57:13.454 --> 02:57:19.833
<v Rebecca Dobert>I am here to encourage City Council to appeal for the current sign plan and maintain their original promise to preserve our historic ice rink.

1735
02:57:20.620 --> 02:57:30.181
<v Rebecca Dobert>I began skating at Lloyd nearly 2 years ago, and I have since found an irreplaceable community through my fellow skaters, coaches, and staff of all ages, backgrounds, and abilities.

1736
02:57:31.088 --> 02:57:35.983
<v Rebecca Dobert>As a community, we have the chance to preserve and invest in what makes our city unique.

1737
02:57:36.530 --> 02:57:38.309
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is more than simply an ice rink.

1738
02:57:38.309 --> 02:57:42.170
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is acting in ways that honor the values we claim to hold dear.

1739
02:57:42.170 --> 02:57:49.909
<v Rebecca Dobert>Today you've heard folks speak on the personal values of the rink, environmental impacts, local backing and attraction, and many more.

1740
02:57:50.350 --> 02:57:56.309
<v Rebecca Dobert>I urge you to hear the voices of our beautiful city and retain, replace, or relocate the Old Oyster Ice Rink.

1741
02:57:56.350 --> 02:57:57.530
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1742
02:57:57.530 --> 02:57:59.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Siena.

1743
02:58:00.610 --> 02:58:02.200
<v Rebecca Dobert>Tom Sollett.

1744
02:58:03.007 --> 02:58:06.606
<v Rebecca Dobert>Edith Gillis, Stephanie Yarnovich, Chris Yarnovich.

1745
02:58:20.566 --> 02:58:21.640
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can go ahead at the table.

1746
02:58:23.149 --> 02:58:30.988
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, for the record, my name is Tom Sullitt, a future Portland City Councilor for District 3.

1747
02:58:32.334 --> 02:58:39.278
<v Jamie Dunphy>Speaking to you from the future because this moment is too important and you cannot go back in time to show up when it matters.

1748
02:58:40.191 --> 02:58:41.924
<v Jamie Dunphy>Portland needs investment and growth.

1749
02:58:42.581 --> 02:58:46.013
<v Jamie Dunphy>The question is, who are we willing to invest in to achieve both?

1750
02:58:46.702 --> 02:58:52.427
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's time to send the message that we are willing to bet big on the Portlanders who embody the spirit of this city.

1751
02:58:53.101 --> 02:59:03.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>Beautiful renderings and ambitious plans may show us what a place could become, but they cannot recreate the character that makes Portland Portland.

1752
02:59:04.415 --> 02:59:07.722
<v Jamie Dunphy>When others wrote Lloyd Center off, Portlanders refused to walk away.

1753
02:59:08.333 --> 02:59:12.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>They are still here, still investing and still fighting for its future.

1754
02:59:13.085 --> 02:59:22.752
<v Jamie Dunphy>The business owners, the neighbors, and advocates rallying to save it, and the community fighting to preserve the only truly accessible historic ice rink for families, kids, and athletes.

1755
02:59:22.799 --> 02:59:22.929
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1756
02:59:23.602 --> 02:59:29.191
<v Jamie Dunphy>They are proof that Portlanders are our greatest asset and our most important investors.

1757
02:59:30.587 --> 02:59:35.164
<v Jamie Dunphy>We do not have to choose between demolishing what makes Lloyd Center special and the positive things being promised.

1758
02:59:35.325 --> 02:59:36.945
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is always another path forward.

1759
02:59:37.412 --> 02:59:46.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>We should pursue Metro's adaptive reuse mall concept that they have been exploring together, preserving what works today while allowing new housing and development on the surrounding land.

1760
02:59:46.917 --> 02:59:47.415
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1761
02:59:48.739 --> 02:59:49.084
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1762
02:59:49.343 --> 02:59:49.842
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1763
02:59:52.835 --> 02:59:54.111
<v Rebecca Dobert>Edith is joining us online.

1764
02:59:54.691 --> 02:59:55.564
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can go ahead, Edith.

1765
02:59:56.710 --> 02:59:57.921
<v Rebecca Dobert>Edith Gillis, District 3.

1766
02:59:58.018 --> 02:59:58.664
<v Rebecca Dobert>Can you hear me?

1767
02:59:59.131 --> 02:59:59.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>We can.

1768
03:00:01.700 --> 03:00:08.459
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, prohibit demolition of Lloyd Center Mall buildings, parking structure, and ice rink.

1769
03:00:08.604 --> 03:00:17.147
<v Rebecca Dobert>Require ownership of that to maintain it safe and inclusive to all abilities gender and cultural opportunities.

1770
03:00:17.891 --> 03:00:49.897
<v Rebecca Dobert>Expand on the use of the space so that the upper and south-facing parking spaces are community gardens and put in permanent lifelong no-income, low-income housing in the Regal parking lot with a parks on the south-facing highway side and have a forest, food forest, on the east side of the mall.

1771
03:00:50.730 --> 03:01:03.453
<v Rebecca Dobert>Make sure that you expand it to democratic community-led use that is mitigating climate, that has rooftop solar, and that has more education.

1772
03:01:04.208 --> 03:01:17.822
<v Rebecca Dobert>Do not demolish it because because the asbestos, fiberglass fibers, toxic dust and fumes will be harmful to the local community and the environment and the workers and cost too much.

1773
03:01:18.318 --> 03:01:25.174
<v Rebecca Dobert>And there's no guarantee that there will be anything else we need in that time, and we cannot afford the wait and delay.

1774
03:01:25.800 --> 03:01:38.717
<v Rebecca Dobert>We cannot trust this private equity firm because there is no time in history anywhere of them taking care of the environment, and they have not kept their word or taken care of the environment in their demolition so far.

1775
03:01:43.525 --> 03:01:50.961
<v Rebecca Dobert>Charles Manzano, Noah LeCompte, Jennifer Meyer, Autumn Bell, Phil Sano.

1776
03:01:53.404 --> 03:01:56.388
<v Jamie Dunphy>And unfortunately, this will be our last panel of testimony today.

1777
03:01:56.930 --> 03:02:02.042
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, we will be We'll be continuing this hearing tomorrow, but folks who are at the table, please take it away.

1778
03:02:03.989 --> 03:02:05.273
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hi, my name is Charlie Manzano.

1779
03:02:06.766 --> 03:02:11.606
<v Rebecca Dobert>I would like to draw attention to the framing of this plan as being shaped by, quote, community feedback.

1780
03:02:12.510 --> 03:02:17.926
<v Rebecca Dobert>The applicant, Tom Kilbane of Urban Renaissance Group, serves as chair of the Lloyd Enhanced Service District Board.

1781
03:02:18.635 --> 03:02:23.204
<v Rebecca Dobert>The ESD funds the Lloyd Community Association, Lloyd Eco District, and Go Lloyd.

1782
03:02:24.097 --> 03:02:28.825
<v Rebecca Dobert>All of which have represented the, quote, community organizations' ongoing outreach and support for the plan.

1783
03:02:29.740 --> 03:02:32.802
<v Rebecca Dobert>This does not sound like diversified, genuine community input.

1784
03:02:35.155 --> 03:02:39.826
<v Rebecca Dobert>This plan has also been repeatedly mischaracterized to the media and by supporters.

1785
03:02:40.596 --> 03:02:47.468
<v Rebecca Dobert>The most common example is the claim that it will create thousands of housing units, despite the fact that no housing project is being proposed.

1786
03:02:48.959 --> 03:02:58.394
<v Rebecca Dobert>And while the applicant may argue that demolition is not being approved today, Urban Renaissance Group has repeatedly stated that this plan requires complete demolition of the existing mall.

1787
03:02:59.388 --> 03:03:05.370
<v Rebecca Dobert>What council is being asked to approve is demolition without any specific redevelopment, buildings, or uses.

1788
03:03:06.620 --> 03:03:11.513
<v Rebecca Dobert>Supporters claim these appeals are delaying progress, but appeals are part of the public process.

1789
03:03:12.041 --> 03:03:16.195
<v Rebecca Dobert>Nothing is currently being delayed because no redevelopment project has been proposed.

1790
03:03:17.254 --> 03:03:24.912
<v Rebecca Dobert>Finally, Urban Renaissance Group spent years limiting and terminating leases at Lloyd Center, Then announced a closure timeline that drove customers and tenants away.

1791
03:03:25.779 --> 03:03:31.484
<v Rebecca Dobert>Now they point to the resulting vacancy and self-imposed financial losses as evidence that the building should be demolished.

1792
03:03:32.272 --> 03:03:35.936
<v Rebecca Dobert>Vacancy and bad business plans are not evidence that a building is obsolete.

1793
03:03:36.548 --> 03:03:42.290
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council should not approve this master plan until the applicant provides substantial evidence supporting the—.

1794
03:03:43.479 --> 03:03:46.167
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, thank you very much.

1795
03:03:51.275 --> 03:03:56.808
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, hello, my name is Noah Lewer-Lecomte.

1796
03:03:57.674 --> 03:03:59.486
<v Jamie Dunphy>I live in the Alberta neighborhood.

1797
03:04:00.143 --> 03:04:02.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to say thank you for having us.

1798
03:04:02.869 --> 03:04:11.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have cherished memories of the Lloyd Center Mall and have been coming here since I was young.

1799
03:04:12.810 --> 03:04:31.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>As someone on the autism spectrum, Lloyd Center is one of the few safe spaces where I and other differently abled people can independently make friends, hang out, and join community clubs.

1800
03:04:31.989 --> 03:04:40.986
<v Jamie Dunphy>Demolishing this inclusive hub will be a devastating loss to our differently abled peers and community.

1801
03:04:42.221 --> 03:04:47.333
<v Jamie Dunphy>Tearing down the mall will also trigger a dangerous domino effect.

1802
03:04:48.122 --> 03:04:58.174
<v Jamie Dunphy>Leaving a giant dirt lot for years will likely invite illegal camps, drugs, and crime.

1803
03:04:59.592 --> 03:05:14.782
<v Jamie Dunphy>This will make neighborhoods and visitors feel unsafe, decrease tourism, causing nearby local shops and restaurants to lose business and potentially close as well.

1804
03:05:15.715 --> 03:05:29.426
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ultimately, this will lower Lloyd— Lloyd's District residential and commercial property values and harms Portland's overall economy.

1805
03:05:29.941 --> 03:05:32.654
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm giving him my 90 seconds so he can finish.

1806
03:05:33.231 --> 03:05:36.664
<v Jamie Dunphy>Finally, we cannot lose the ice rink.

1807
03:05:37.626 --> 03:05:38.412
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1808
03:05:38.748 --> 03:05:46.992
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is not just recreation, it's a school and a future career for skaters and artists.

1809
03:05:47.665 --> 03:06:02.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>Demolishing it is no different than tearing down the only law school within driving distance of an inspiring attorney of crashing their dreams.

1810
03:06:03.547 --> 03:06:13.693
<v Jamie Dunphy>The rink also in— also is an activity that protects— activity that presents inclusion.

1811
03:06:13.822 --> 03:06:15.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>Practices inclusion.

1812
03:06:15.733 --> 03:06:16.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Practices inclusion.

1813
03:06:17.193 --> 03:06:28.368
<v Jamie Dunphy>Did you know wheelchairs are allowed on the ice and direct support workers can skate with their differently abled clients for free.

1814
03:06:30.063 --> 03:06:31.514
<v Jamie Dunphy>One last important note.

1815
03:06:32.161 --> 03:06:50.927
<v Jamie Dunphy>Most of you probably know about Olympic skater Tonya Harding's connection to the Lloyd Center, but most of you probably don't know that Louis Armstrong actually performed at Lloyd Center Mall.

1816
03:06:51.622 --> 03:06:57.771
<v Jamie Dunphy>The mall should be recognized and protected as an historical landmark.

1817
03:06:58.685 --> 03:07:09.777
<v Jamie Dunphy>The current owners have forced out willing tenants and turned away hundreds of applicants who, who want to fill empty spaces.

1818
03:07:10.627 --> 03:07:19.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please save Lloyd Center Mall and protect what has become a safe, inclusive, citywide community center for all.

1819
03:07:19.808 --> 03:07:26.894
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks to you for listening, and I even wrote a book about it that has to do with saving the Lloyd Center Mall.

1820
03:07:27.728 --> 03:07:31.597
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, and you guys have a wonderful day.

1821
03:07:36.832 --> 03:07:37.944
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1822
03:07:38.282 --> 03:07:38.701
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1823
03:07:40.298 --> 03:07:42.264
<v Rebecca Dobert>Hello, my name is Autumn Bell.

1824
03:07:43.180 --> 03:07:52.788
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, with growing climate instability, it is more important than ever that both in our communities and in our local government we fight to keep spaces alive that can offer respite from these extreme temperatures.

1825
03:07:53.381 --> 03:08:11.414
<v Rebecca Dobert>More than that, newer generations are experiencing a higher rate of loneliness, with over 70% of Gen Z reporting they feel lonely on a daily or consistent basis due to a lack of third spaces created by the economic instability of the pandemic and both our local and federal governments deciding to support corporations over people.

1826
03:08:12.152 --> 03:08:15.793
<v Rebecca Dobert>In the last few years, we have watched the Lloyd Center grow into a much-needed hub Thank you.

1827
03:08:15.842 --> 03:08:19.983
<v Rebecca Dobert>The Lloyd Center is a cultural hub for people with a countless number of local businesses and events occurring on a weekly basis.

1828
03:08:20.560 --> 03:08:39.726
<v Rebecca Dobert>The current plan for the Lloyd Center building does not offer any alternatives to this much-needed free indoor space, replacing them with exclusive outdoor spaces where people are compressed into the primary method of the movement of capital, all the while harming the community, businesses, and environment directly around the Lloyd District during the disruptive multi-year construction process.

1829
03:08:40.255 --> 03:08:42.054
<v Rebecca Dobert>Our city is not built by corporations.

1830
03:08:42.149 --> 03:08:43.627
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is built by the people within them.

1831
03:08:45.112 --> 03:08:48.504
<v Rebecca Dobert>And it is built by the people in Lloyd Center, both past, present, and future.

1832
03:08:48.889 --> 03:08:53.841
<v Rebecca Dobert>No matter who you are in our community, everyone needs a free place to sit down, have water, and use the restroom in peace.

1833
03:08:54.441 --> 03:08:55.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>Everyone needs the Lloyd Center.

1834
03:08:55.886 --> 03:08:56.438
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you for your time.

1835
03:09:03.837 --> 03:09:04.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, councilors.

1836
03:09:05.066 --> 03:09:05.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>My name is Phil Sano.

1837
03:09:06.020 --> 03:09:06.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>I live in Northeast.

1838
03:09:07.005 --> 03:09:08.105
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was born in Oregon City.

1839
03:09:08.849 --> 03:09:16.398
<v Jamie Dunphy>I visited Lloyd before it was enclosed, and I'd very much like to save Lloyd, and I think you're in a position to do it.

1840
03:09:17.532 --> 03:09:25.775
<v Jamie Dunphy>For 6 years, my partner and I had a store inside the Lloyd Center called Animal Plant Mineral, and it was a delight to be able to serve the people of Portland in a profound way.

1841
03:09:27.832 --> 03:09:44.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>One of the things that I'll remember forever was that during an actual smoke storm, some kids came through on roller skates, and their mom was like, well, you could Go to this fashion show thing that's happening here tomorrow, or we could be outside for— during a fun run for several hours in the middle of a smoke storm.

1842
03:09:44.484 --> 03:09:46.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the kids, oh, we can be inside?

1843
03:09:46.652 --> 03:09:56.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it was a great privilege to be able to offer this fun way of taking something that was very painful, of not being able to breathe comfortably outside.

1844
03:09:57.318 --> 03:09:59.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I sat through this process.

1845
03:10:00.531 --> 03:10:10.601
<v Jamie Dunphy>I heard Tom Kilbane— we heard Tom Kilbane say that he sat in Santa's lap when he was a child and that his kids sat in Santa's lap and that with his support, his grandkids would sit in Santa's lap.

1846
03:10:11.451 --> 03:10:17.296
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to believe him, but then sometimes words conflict with actions.

1847
03:10:18.275 --> 03:10:23.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are told— we've been told in this process, I think largely what we need to hear to move the process forward.

1848
03:10:24.713 --> 03:10:32.963
<v Jamie Dunphy>We weren't really invested in, with the exception of this very notepad, which I got from The people at Urban Renaissance, which I'm delighted to still be able to use.

1849
03:10:34.120 --> 03:10:38.532
<v Jamie Dunphy>Meanwhile, Governor Kotek has declared a state of emergency because, of course, this summer is going to be the hottest ever.

1850
03:10:39.647 --> 03:10:50.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>And you get to decide if Portland can keep 3 stories of filtered air, which Santa would very much like to have, as many others, or if we're going to invest in out-of-state.

1851
03:10:50.790 --> 03:10:52.808
<v Jamie Dunphy>And where that money goes is back out of state.

1852
03:10:53.049 --> 03:10:55.183
<v Jamie Dunphy>But we could make this space available to us.

1853
03:10:55.234 --> 03:10:55.367
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1854
03:10:56.765 --> 03:10:57.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1855
03:10:57.168 --> 03:11:01.724
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1856
03:11:02.176 --> 03:11:03.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, folks.

1857
03:11:03.209 --> 03:11:10.566
<v Jamie Dunphy>I had said this was the last panel, but we're going to accommodate one more person who is listed as the 91st on the list.

1858
03:11:10.825 --> 03:11:14.224
<v Jamie Dunphy>But we're going to hear one, one more person, and then we are taking a recess for the day.

1859
03:11:14.547 --> 03:11:16.371
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much, everybody.

1860
03:11:16.566 --> 03:11:17.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're very welcome.

1861
03:11:17.227 --> 03:11:17.954
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Noah.

1862
03:11:18.325 --> 03:11:19.036
<v Rebecca Dobert>Roy Burge.

1863
03:11:19.957 --> 03:11:21.489
<v Rebecca Dobert>Roy, you can approach the testimony table.

1864
03:11:24.275 --> 03:11:30.884
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks, Roy.

1865
03:11:31.271 --> 03:11:33.847
<v Jamie Dunphy>I appreciate you get— letting me get in here today.

1866
03:11:35.184 --> 03:11:36.297
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm Roy Burge.

1867
03:11:37.350 --> 03:11:39.604
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm almost 85 years old.

1868
03:11:39.879 --> 03:11:42.102
<v Rebecca Dobert>Most people think I'm in mid-70s.

1869
03:11:42.215 --> 03:11:47.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>Anyway, hey, Judy and I are in the Portland Rose Society, okay?

1870
03:11:47.788 --> 03:11:49.183
<v Jamie Dunphy>For years we've been there.

1871
03:11:50.393 --> 03:11:53.316
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we have our road shows at the Lloyd Center.

1872
03:11:53.461 --> 03:11:57.387
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, now let's get to the iron of this.

1873
03:11:59.260 --> 03:12:08.306
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've got enough experience to tell you that it's not going to be very hard to leave the ice rink as it stands, roof and all.

1874
03:12:09.298 --> 03:12:14.046
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, take your 2 wings down, do whatever you want, apartments or whatever.

1875
03:12:14.923 --> 03:12:19.718
<v Jamie Dunphy>But you can save the ice rink as it stands, roof and all.

1876
03:12:20.861 --> 03:12:21.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I know it.

1877
03:12:22.152 --> 03:12:25.457
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if nobody knows how to do it, I'll show them how to do it.

1878
03:12:26.407 --> 03:12:26.763
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay?

1879
03:12:28.198 --> 03:12:29.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that's where I'm coming from.

1880
03:12:31.850 --> 03:12:32.093
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1881
03:12:32.190 --> 03:12:35.284
<v Rebecca Dobert>If you got any other questions, get a hold of me.

1882
03:12:35.593 --> 03:12:38.995
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've got the information where I'm at.

1883
03:12:39.319 --> 03:12:40.227
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1884
03:12:45.605 --> 03:12:49.234
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, with that, this hearing will be recessed.

1885
03:12:49.781 --> 03:12:51.167
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

1886
03:12:53.022 --> 03:13:03.434
<v Jamie Dunphy>So this hearing will be recessed and continued on June 25th, 2026 at 2:00 PM, and the testimony sign-up will be closed.

1887
03:13:04.238 --> 03:13:10.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>This means that council will hear more oral testimony tomorrow, and the record will remain open until the conclusion of that.

1888
03:13:10.906 --> 03:13:13.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>Or a future meeting for receipt of additional written testimony.

1889
03:13:14.993 --> 03:13:22.542
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would like to remind council and the public that there is another land use item, Recap 11, scheduled for a time certain at or after 2:00 PM tomorrow.

1890
03:13:23.040 --> 03:13:32.191
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll take Recap 11 following the conclusion of presentations and testimony on the Lloyd Center-related appeal currently before us, most likely between 3:30 and 4:00 PM tomorrow.

1891
03:13:32.960 --> 03:13:38.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is also— there are also 3 second readings scheduled for tomorrow that must be voted on in order to meet other requirements.

1892
03:13:38.780 --> 03:13:39.388
<v Jamie Dunphy>Requirements of law.

1893
03:13:39.933 --> 03:13:49.552
<v Jamie Dunphy>An emergency ordinance correcting an error in the sewer and stormwater rate ordinance, and 2 ordinances related to the dissolution of the Mount Hood Cable Regulatory Commission and its inheritance by the city.

1894
03:13:50.177 --> 03:13:58.737
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am interested in discussing if we could suspend the rules to get those mandatory items taken care of very quickly at the top of tomorrow's meeting to be efficient with our staff's time.

1895
03:13:59.572 --> 03:14:01.063
<v Jamie Dunphy>Quick show of faces.

1896
03:14:01.399 --> 03:14:02.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>Anybody have concerns?

1897
03:14:02.441 --> 03:14:02.698
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1898
03:14:03.243 --> 03:14:08.435
<v Rebecca Dobert>Can we— should we Can we suspend the rules now to reorder the agenda so that it's done?

1899
03:14:09.429 --> 03:14:09.524
<v Jamie Dunphy>Nope.

1900
03:14:09.781 --> 03:14:10.838
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, we'll just take care of it tomorrow.

1901
03:14:10.951 --> 03:14:15.262
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll take care of it tomorrow morning, um, and— or tomorrow afternoon, rather.

1902
03:14:15.422 --> 03:14:20.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, City Attorney, do we have anything else to discuss before we set a date, a time and date certain, and recess?

1903
03:14:20.950 --> 03:14:26.302
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, so I will just reiterate what you heard, kind of, or what you said quickly and simply.

1904
03:14:26.896 --> 03:14:30.292
<v Rebecca Dobert>This item will continue till tomorrow at 2 o'clock, time certain.

1905
03:14:30.646 --> 03:14:35.084
<v Rebecca Dobert>Those who have already signed up to testify will— the clerk will continue to call in that order.

1906
03:14:35.693 --> 03:14:46.221
<v Rebecca Dobert>The written record remains open, so folks can continue to testify, submit testimony as they could previously online through the council clerk's website, as noticed.

1907
03:14:47.631 --> 03:14:50.966
<v Rebecca Dobert>However, the sign-up is closed as of now.

1908
03:14:51.334 --> 03:14:53.032
<v Rebecca Dobert>No additional parties can sign up.

1909
03:14:53.112 --> 03:14:57.635
<v Rebecca Dobert>So if you are signed up and you have not testified yet, You will get to testify tomorrow.

1910
03:14:58.148 --> 03:15:02.291
<v Rebecca Dobert>We will also hear from the applicant and finish the remainder of the proceeding.

1911
03:15:02.646 --> 03:15:06.644
<v Rebecca Dobert>Council will then decide whether or not to close the written record tomorrow.

1912
03:15:07.623 --> 03:15:13.709
<v Rebecca Dobert>What the council president also noticed is there are now 2 items scheduled for a time certain at 2 o'clock tomorrow.

1913
03:15:14.834 --> 03:15:16.922
<v Rebecca Dobert>Obviously, council can't hear 2 things at once.

1914
03:15:17.420 --> 03:15:22.702
<v Rebecca Dobert>I believe the intent is to take up this item first, so if folks are also interested in the second item, it may be delayed.

1915
03:15:22.766 --> 03:15:23.057
<v Rebecca Dobert>We don't know that yet.

1916
03:15:23.104 --> 03:15:23.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1917
03:15:27.283 --> 03:15:27.574
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect.

1918
03:15:27.768 --> 03:15:28.203
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Lauren.

1919
03:15:28.719 --> 03:15:33.772
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, this hearing is in recess, to be continued tomorrow, June 25th, 2026, at 2:00 PM.

1920
03:15:33.997 --> 03:15:34.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>See you then.

1921
03:15:37.052 --> 03:15:39.804
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

