WEBVTT

1
00:06:53.855 --> 00:07:00.338
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, good afternoon.

2
00:07:01.321 --> 00:07:08.391
<v Sameer Kanal>Welcome to the, uh, June 17th, 2026 meeting of the Committee of the Whole.

3
00:07:09.247 --> 00:07:11.124
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, if we could please do the roll call.

4
00:07:11.189 --> 00:07:11.514
<v Dan Ryan>Rebecca.

5
00:07:13.225 --> 00:07:13.762
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney.

6
00:07:15.588 --> 00:07:15.701
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

7
00:07:18.170 --> 00:07:18.250
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan.

8
00:07:18.346 --> 00:07:19.055
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane.

9
00:07:19.490 --> 00:07:19.762
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

10
00:07:20.295 --> 00:07:20.778
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo.

11
00:07:21.019 --> 00:07:21.341
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

12
00:07:22.146 --> 00:07:22.548
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick.

13
00:07:23.273 --> 00:07:23.449
<v Steve Novick>Here.

14
00:07:24.223 --> 00:07:24.867
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark.

15
00:07:25.269 --> 00:07:25.543
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

16
00:07:26.300 --> 00:07:26.540
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

17
00:07:27.038 --> 00:07:27.168
<v Mitch Green>Here.

18
00:07:27.713 --> 00:07:28.228
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman.

19
00:07:29.129 --> 00:07:29.514
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos.

20
00:07:29.740 --> 00:07:30.189
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

21
00:07:30.994 --> 00:07:31.363
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy.

22
00:07:31.492 --> 00:07:32.216
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm over here.

23
00:07:32.697 --> 00:07:33.293
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

24
00:07:34.579 --> 00:07:35.100
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal.

25
00:07:35.668 --> 00:07:35.783
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

26
00:07:38.418 --> 00:07:41.053
<v Sameer Kanal>And Christopher, if you could please read the statement of conduct.

27
00:07:42.139 --> 00:07:44.464
<v Christopher>Welcome to the meeting of the Finance and Governance Committee of the Whole.

28
00:07:44.577 --> 00:07:55.519
<v Christopher>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/committee-whole or by calling 311.

29
00:07:55.519 --> 00:07:57.699
<v Christopher>Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

30
00:07:57.939 --> 00:08:00.699
<v Christopher>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

31
00:08:00.699 --> 00:08:03.519
<v Christopher>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

32
00:08:03.639 --> 00:08:08.430
<v Rebecca Dobert>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

33
00:08:08.779 --> 00:08:10.790
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

34
00:08:10.920 --> 00:08:12.139
<v Rebecca Dobert>The chair preserves order.

35
00:08:12.139 --> 00:08:18.319
<v Rebecca Dobert>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

36
00:08:18.319 --> 00:08:18.360
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

37
00:08:18.641 --> 00:08:20.233
<v Rebecca Dobert>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

38
00:08:20.314 --> 00:08:22.637
<v Rebecca Dobert>Further disruption results in ejection from the meeting.

39
00:08:23.012 --> 00:08:25.432
<v Rebecca Dobert>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

40
00:08:26.009 --> 00:08:28.348
<v Rebecca Dobert>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

41
00:08:28.785 --> 00:08:30.656
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

42
00:08:30.737 --> 00:08:32.302
<v Rebecca Dobert>When testifying, state your name for the record.

43
00:08:32.350 --> 00:08:34.609
<v Christopher>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

44
00:08:34.899 --> 00:08:37.201
<v Christopher>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

45
00:08:37.410 --> 00:08:37.652
<v Christopher>Thank you.

46
00:08:39.807 --> 00:08:40.304
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

47
00:08:42.235 --> 00:08:52.073
<v Sameer Kanal>Today's agenda, we have the built-out committee chair updates that I've as promised for a couple meetings now, we then have a report from the Auditor's Office.

48
00:08:52.330 --> 00:08:54.509
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll be having the auditor join us in a moment.

49
00:08:54.927 --> 00:09:04.224
<v Sameer Kanal>And then we also have a discussion on the mayor's proposed members to be appointed or reappointed to the Portland Clean Energy Community Benefits Fund Committee.

50
00:09:04.850 --> 00:09:16.230
<v Sameer Kanal>One thing that I wanted to just flag, we do this reading of the statement of conduct before every meeting, and in the oversight hearing I talked about that there should probably be some other things that are norms for our committee.

51
00:09:16.311 --> 00:09:18.860
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think it's not just exclusive to thank you.

52
00:09:19.197 --> 00:09:29.054
<v Sameer Kanal>This is not related to the oversight hearings, but I think it actually relates to many of the topics that I see coming up on our agendas, not only today, but in the future, accepting non-closure.

53
00:09:29.711 --> 00:09:39.554
<v Sameer Kanal>This committee is often a place where we're gonna take on some big issues that haven't been discussed, what our former council president referred to as the big conversations and framing it that way.

54
00:09:39.634 --> 00:09:45.149
<v Sameer Kanal>And so those don't all get resolved in a single 3-hour meeting, especially when they're not even the whole 3-hour meeting.

55
00:09:45.261 --> 00:09:48.548
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think that's an important thing to keep in mind as we go through today.

56
00:09:49.028 --> 00:09:51.760
<v Sameer Kanal>And with that, I will ask if Rebecca, If you can call the first item, please.

57
00:09:53.056 --> 00:09:58.294
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 1, Committee Chair Updates, document number 2026-206.

58
00:09:59.178 --> 00:10:05.537
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, so as promised, I have a more built-out Committee of the Whole Chair Update.

59
00:10:05.618 --> 00:10:14.683
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm actually erring on the side of maybe more information, and we'll see if, given that a lot of this is tentative, we'll see if that comes back to bite me a little bit in the future.

60
00:10:14.813 --> 00:10:17.678
<v Sameer Kanal>And in that case, we'll scale back to only what's confirmed.

61
00:10:18.153 --> 00:10:20.417
<v Sameer Kanal>But I wanted to put up some information here, and there's a 4-part Committee Chair Update.

62
00:10:22.419 --> 00:10:23.039
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

63
00:10:23.039 --> 00:10:23.039
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that clarification.

64
00:10:23.039 --> 00:10:23.039
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, thank you, Councilor Zuercher.

65
00:10:23.039 --> 00:10:23.299
<v Sameer Kanal>So this is our 4th part of our budget year update.

66
00:10:23.299 --> 00:10:27.500
<v Sameer Kanal>The 4th part is new and is at the suggestion of our Council Vice President.

67
00:10:27.500 --> 00:10:28.659
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll get to that in a moment.

68
00:10:28.659 --> 00:10:31.620
<v Sameer Kanal>But first, just a couple updates on the meeting calendar.

69
00:10:31.860 --> 00:10:43.129
<v Sameer Kanal>We didn't get a chance to announce that we were going to cancel the June 11th meeting, but working with Council President to make sure there was more time for the first reading of the adopted budget, we canceled the June 11th meeting to allow for that.

70
00:10:43.419 --> 00:10:51.039
<v Sameer Kanal>And then we have an upcoming set of meetings here with agenda items that are penciled in, or I guess in some cases penned in.

71
00:10:51.720 --> 00:10:54.427
<v Sameer Kanal>So If it says it's confirmed, that's going to be on the agenda.

72
00:10:54.475 --> 00:10:58.691
<v Sameer Kanal>You're going to see the June 25th agenda post tomorrow.

73
00:11:00.070 --> 00:11:07.924
<v Sameer Kanal>If it's tentative, that's we're hoping for more information or some last dot the i's, cross the t's type of information before locking it in.

74
00:11:08.645 --> 00:11:11.803
<v Sameer Kanal>And then if it's possible, as you can see, there's a couple where it's just a big agenda.

75
00:11:11.851 --> 00:11:14.192
<v Sameer Kanal>We're trying to figure out what to prioritize there.

76
00:11:14.738 --> 00:11:21.278
<v Sameer Kanal>I will also note, although he's not in the room right now, we did move the Home Forward item later at the request of Councilor Zimmerman.

77
00:11:21.743 --> 00:11:23.024
<v Sameer Kanal>So that'll be on July 9th.

78
00:11:23.184 --> 00:11:23.794
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

79
00:11:24.259 --> 00:11:24.419
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

80
00:11:24.484 --> 00:11:26.331
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's the only one that's pending as of right now.

81
00:11:26.380 --> 00:11:33.386
<v Sameer Kanal>And we have also— I wanted to just note that the other big appointments that are coming forward are on July 23rd.

82
00:11:33.451 --> 00:11:34.703
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the Prosper Portland board.

83
00:11:35.700 --> 00:11:42.352
<v Sameer Kanal>Finally, I'm just going to update something that I just got more information on from Council President, which is the Moda Center term sheet.

84
00:11:42.529 --> 00:11:44.634
<v Sameer Kanal>It says confirmed for July 30th.

85
00:11:44.698 --> 00:11:45.775
<v Sameer Kanal>That remains the same.

86
00:11:46.065 --> 00:11:47.302
<v Sameer Kanal>It will be discussed here.

87
00:11:47.735 --> 00:11:56.850
<v Sameer Kanal>But it also says if needed for August 6th, And so I am assuming that that will still be needed and we'll revise August 6th accordingly for the future.

88
00:11:59.721 --> 00:12:06.979
<v Sameer Kanal>The next page is just unscheduled potential agenda items, and I organized those in terms of the areas of work that this committee was tasked with for the future.

89
00:12:07.058 --> 00:12:11.488
<v Sameer Kanal>You'll notice several oversight topics are listed under Part 3.

90
00:12:11.600 --> 00:12:17.668
<v Sameer Kanal>Some of these other things we haven't really mentioned in the past or mentioned in the context of Committee of the Whole.

91
00:12:18.115 --> 00:12:20.836
<v Sameer Kanal>Feel free to review those and get back to me if you have any questions.

92
00:12:21.416 --> 00:12:27.163
<v Sameer Kanal>Part 3 at the bottom of that second page is, again, referencing Councilor Zimmerman.

93
00:12:27.227 --> 00:12:45.953
<v Sameer Kanal>When he was Chair of the Finance Committee last year, I thought one of the really good ideas was building a workgroup where it's a smaller group of councilors that can help ensure that when we have a proposal here, it's fully, it's at least baked enough to be worthy of our discussion instead of we're kind of asking questions around it and we're not 100% sure what we're debating.

94
00:12:46.471 --> 00:12:54.883
<v Sameer Kanal>So I mentioned 2 things in here that are, Items where we know we have to have a conversation, but we don't necessarily know where that conversation could go yet.

95
00:12:56.006 --> 00:13:03.778
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I might ask next week for folks to volunteer if they're interested in being a part of helping prepare that agenda item, the run of show and things like that.

96
00:13:04.179 --> 00:13:13.541
<v Sameer Kanal>And obviously in one particular case, there's a lot of people who have a direct vested interest and experience in council president elections, and I'll certainly be prioritizing those folks.

97
00:13:14.504 --> 00:13:14.697
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

98
00:13:14.793 --> 00:13:18.581
<v Sameer Kanal>And then last but not least, I'll get to the new item.

99
00:13:18.950 --> 00:13:24.841
<v Sameer Kanal>Council Vice President Olivia Clark asked if we could start hearing what's going on in the other committees.

100
00:13:25.772 --> 00:13:32.402
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I think we are just kind of determining if this is gonna work or not, and if so, how many we can do at a time.

101
00:13:32.916 --> 00:13:45.019
<v Sameer Kanal>But I thought we'll start with having a report for the benefit of not only the other 7 councilors who are not in the committee, but for the public, 'cause I think we might have slightly higher viewership, especially on a Wednesday meeting.

102
00:13:45.355 --> 00:13:49.275
<v Sameer Kanal>To hear from Councilor Clark about what's going on in the Public Works Committee.

103
00:13:49.323 --> 00:13:54.833
<v Sameer Kanal>So we're going to probably put a few minutes towards this every time, and I've kind of put a tentative rotation up down below.

104
00:13:55.331 --> 00:13:59.316
<v Sameer Kanal>But, uh, first I'd like to pass it over to Councilor Clark to update us.

105
00:13:59.830 --> 00:13:59.958
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

106
00:14:00.054 --> 00:14:00.730
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, thank you, Mr.

107
00:14:00.793 --> 00:14:00.986
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Chair.

108
00:14:01.275 --> 00:14:05.179
<v Unidentified speaker>And I want to compliment you on this, um, work plan.

109
00:14:05.227 --> 00:14:08.102
<v Unidentified speaker>I really appreciate getting it and knowing what's coming in advance.

110
00:14:08.183 --> 00:14:08.857
<v Unidentified speaker>I really appreciate that.

111
00:14:09.403 --> 00:14:18.725
<v Unidentified speaker>So, um, just— and I'll be very brief, um, and Just give you a quick update on what we did at the Public Works— the last meeting of the Public Works Committee.

112
00:14:18.773 --> 00:14:30.748
<v Unidentified speaker>We did a deep dive into the ODOT, the Rose Quarter closure, which everybody should have on their radar screen and make everyone in your mailing list aware of what's coming.

113
00:14:30.812 --> 00:14:35.974
<v Unidentified speaker>It's going to be pretty intense, a closure for 4 to 5 weeks on I-5.

114
00:14:36.630 --> 00:14:38.379
<v Unidentified speaker>It's very complicated for our city.

115
00:14:39.212 --> 00:14:41.427
<v Unidentified speaker>But in the long run, it's going to help everyone.

116
00:14:42.022 --> 00:14:47.559
<v Unidentified speaker>But I know there'll be a lot of questions and you'll probably hear more about it as ODOT gears up.

117
00:14:48.700 --> 00:14:50.980
<v Unidentified speaker>So that was the main thing that we talked about at the last meeting.

118
00:14:51.091 --> 00:15:00.658
<v Unidentified speaker>But in— for the coming attractions at the next meeting, we're going to be getting an update on the City Asset Management Plan, which is due to come to all of us in September.

119
00:15:00.724 --> 00:15:03.629
<v Unidentified speaker>But we're going to get a little update on how it's going.

120
00:15:03.692 --> 00:15:05.283
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm really looking forward to that.

121
00:15:05.346 --> 00:15:06.166
<v Unidentified speaker>It's very important.

122
00:15:06.422 --> 00:15:13.822
<v Unidentified speaker>And I noticed it actually dovetails with something that's in the and the city auditor's report today, particularly in regards to parks.

123
00:15:14.289 --> 00:15:26.868
<v Unidentified speaker>We're also going to hear an ordinance from Councilors Koyama Lane and Councilor Smith to evaluate and implement a no-turn-on-red restriction at signalized intersections within the high-crash network.

124
00:15:27.368 --> 00:15:28.950
<v Unidentified speaker>This is going to be an interesting conversation.

125
00:15:29.595 --> 00:15:33.467
<v Unidentified speaker>We'll also hear something on bus benches.

126
00:15:34.065 --> 00:15:35.807
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a glitch in the code.

127
00:15:36.226 --> 00:15:42.690
<v Unidentified speaker>We need to change it to allow the Portland Streetcar to advertise on bus not a high priority.

128
00:15:43.075 --> 00:15:46.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Then in the coming months, just some of the highlights that we anticipate coming.

129
00:15:46.847 --> 00:15:49.126
<v Unidentified speaker>We will be talking about autonomous vehicles.

130
00:15:49.192 --> 00:15:51.438
<v Unidentified speaker>I know we're all very interested in that.

131
00:15:51.503 --> 00:15:58.149
<v Unidentified speaker>We all have varied opinions about it, but we'll be looking at the rulemaking and potentially some code updates around autonomous vehicles.

132
00:15:58.969 --> 00:16:12.047
<v Unidentified speaker>We'll have an update on the, the implementation of the, um, transportation utility fee and the street damage restoration fee that we all, um, voted on a while back and just how that's coming along, and always an update on Vision Zero.

133
00:16:12.318 --> 00:16:15.173
<v Unidentified speaker>So just really quickly, that's what we're looking forward to.

134
00:16:16.392 --> 00:16:17.097
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

135
00:16:17.418 --> 00:16:20.642
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair and Vice President Clark.

136
00:16:21.587 --> 00:16:23.014
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Green, you have your hand in the queue.

137
00:16:23.609 --> 00:16:28.820
<v Mitch Green>Just briefly, Chair Kanal, you opened by saying that we should learn to accept non-closure.

138
00:16:28.899 --> 00:16:33.743
<v Mitch Green>I think given the remarks from the Chair of the Public Works Committee, we should also accept closure in the case of the ODOT work.

139
00:16:34.789 --> 00:16:37.139
<v Mitch Green>Sorry, Steve, this is, this is your lane.

140
00:16:37.220 --> 00:16:38.418
<v Unidentified speaker>That's a Novick.

141
00:16:38.580 --> 00:16:40.005
<v Sameer Kanal>That is a Novick, yeah, that's good.

142
00:16:41.919 --> 00:16:43.048
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Rubbing off on you.

143
00:16:43.273 --> 00:16:44.110
<v Unidentified speaker>Any, any other?

144
00:16:44.255 --> 00:16:45.350
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, Councilor Avalos.

145
00:16:46.109 --> 00:16:46.414
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

146
00:16:46.510 --> 00:16:54.528
<v Candace Avalos>So I guess I just wanted to understand, should we expect that this will be a recurring thing from now on?

147
00:16:54.640 --> 00:16:56.028
<v Candace Avalos>It sounds like we're piloting it today.

148
00:16:56.190 --> 00:17:01.376
<v Candace Avalos>So should I be preparing to come with reports from Housing Committee from now on, or what?

149
00:17:02.650 --> 00:17:11.280
<v Sameer Kanal>So my intent was to ask, and I just kind of drew names out of a hat here for the other 3, ask Councilor Novick to do the next meeting and then yourself the following meeting.

150
00:17:11.876 --> 00:17:20.945
<v Sameer Kanal>But I'd welcome any feedback offline after this if this is something that's helpful, and certainly from the public as well, to know if it's helpful for you to hear about what the other 4 committees are doing.

151
00:17:21.767 --> 00:17:28.355
<v Sameer Kanal>This is kind of a good place to do it so we're not taking up full council agenda time if we're going to do any sort of updates to the full council.

152
00:17:28.421 --> 00:17:28.727
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's helpful.

153
00:17:30.210 --> 00:17:30.710
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

154
00:17:30.710 --> 00:17:32.930
<v Sameer Kanal>But it's a pilot.

155
00:17:32.930 --> 00:17:34.349
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll see.

156
00:17:34.349 --> 00:17:36.349
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's a good place to try things out and we'll try it out.

157
00:17:37.109 --> 00:17:39.589
<v Sameer Kanal>So yeah.

158
00:17:41.089 --> 00:17:54.910
<v Sameer Kanal>And for those who don't know, the closure is a 14-hour closure in July and then there's a 5-week closure of I-5 southbound in sort of leading into downtown as you come in from the north.

159
00:17:54.910 --> 00:17:58.609
<v Sameer Kanal>So especially if you live in D2, we definitely will be putting that in our updates, I'm sure.

160
00:17:58.609 --> 00:18:01.833
<v Sameer Kanal>But I just wanted to flag that that's in September into the beginning of October.

161
00:18:03.349 --> 00:18:05.355
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, any other questions, comments, thoughts?

162
00:18:07.748 --> 00:18:09.882
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, um, we'll close that out.

163
00:18:09.994 --> 00:18:11.758
<v Sameer Kanal>And Rebecca, if you could please call the second item.

164
00:18:12.382 --> 00:18:21.585
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 2, presentation of Auditor's Office results from July 2025 through May 2026, document number 2026-207.

165
00:18:22.525 --> 00:18:23.173
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

166
00:18:23.335 --> 00:18:26.996
<v Sameer Kanal>Always a privilege to have our auditor Simone Reddy join us and members of her team.

167
00:18:27.723 --> 00:18:32.113
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, yeah, please take it away whenever you are ready and whatever order you'd like to go in.

168
00:18:36.160 --> 00:18:42.226
<v Loretta Smith>Well, good afternoon, Committee Chair Kanal, Vice Chairs Ryan and Koyama Lane, and committee members.

169
00:18:42.980 --> 00:18:51.785
<v Loretta Smith>I'm City Auditor Simone Reddy, and I'm pleased to share with you some of the results from my office from the period spanning July 2025 to May 2026.

170
00:18:53.684 --> 00:19:10.628
<v Loretta Smith>The results that are going to be highlighted today have already been shared publicly, and this presentation is really an opportunity for you and community to engage with the results in service of my office's mission, which is to ensure an open and accountable city government.

171
00:19:12.281 --> 00:19:22.574
<v Loretta Smith>I'm joined today by the City Ombudsman and my Audit Services Division Director, and I'll also be speaking on behalf of the city archivist who is unavailable to present today.

172
00:19:24.579 --> 00:19:29.961
<v Loretta Smith>First, I'm going to share 2 recent projects from our office's Archives and Records Management Division.

173
00:19:30.316 --> 00:20:02.003
<v Loretta Smith>That's an oral history project that gathered stories from people living outside in Portland and a digital timeline that details the more than 160-year history of the Auditor's Office, which was published to commemorate the 40th anniversary of performance auditing at second, you'll hear from City Ombudsman Jennifer Croft, who will share highlights from the ombudsman's annual report and an investigation of the city's accessory short-term rental rules and enforcement methods.

174
00:20:03.307 --> 00:20:11.280
<v Loretta Smith>And third, Audit Services Director Casey Jones will share details from 2 recent audit reports and give you an update on our audit schedule.

175
00:20:12.646 --> 00:20:19.230
<v Loretta Smith>As a reminder, presentations like this from my office are really meant to engage you and the public in my office's work.

176
00:20:19.888 --> 00:20:22.923
<v Loretta Smith>They do not require any action from council.

177
00:20:23.501 --> 00:20:29.410
<v Loretta Smith>So that said, I wanna make sure that we can inform you about all these results before you ask questions of us.

178
00:20:29.586 --> 00:20:37.117
<v Loretta Smith>So we've allotted some time at the end of this brief presentation to answer your questions, and we can get started with the next slide.

179
00:20:41.556 --> 00:20:42.092
<v Loretta Smith>And one more.

180
00:20:44.971 --> 00:20:45.406
<v Loretta Smith>Another one.

181
00:20:47.307 --> 00:20:47.694
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

182
00:20:49.161 --> 00:20:56.472
<v Loretta Smith>So as I mentioned, I'll be sharing results from Archives and Records Management on behalf of City Archivist Madeline Moya, who is unable to be here today.

183
00:20:57.932 --> 00:21:03.986
<v Loretta Smith>The Archives and Records Management Division operates the Portland Archives and Records Center, also known as PARC.

184
00:21:05.097 --> 00:21:11.737
<v Loretta Smith>And it's responsible for making city administrative and historical records accessible to the public and city employees.

185
00:21:12.906 --> 00:21:16.788
<v Loretta Smith>It's made up of 2 work groups: archives and records management.

186
00:21:17.846 --> 00:21:30.290
<v Loretta Smith>Records management staff provides training and guidance to help city employees comply with Oregon public records law, and they create the city's retention schedules, administer the city's electronic records management system.

187
00:21:30.854 --> 00:21:37.305
<v Loretta Smith>Also known as Content Manager, and they coordinate transfers of physical records to PARC for long-term storage.

188
00:21:39.319 --> 00:21:43.657
<v Loretta Smith>Archives staff preserves and provides access to the city's historical records.

189
00:21:44.654 --> 00:21:55.631
<v Loretta Smith>They arrange and describe historical records so that they are searchable through the archives catalog known as eFiles, and they provide reference services and access to archival materials at PARC.

190
00:21:56.770 --> 00:22:07.064
<v Loretta Smith>They also conduct outreach, create exhibits, and produce oral histories that present Portland history to the public and encourage public use of the city's historical collections.

191
00:22:07.969 --> 00:22:08.438
<v Loretta Smith>Next slide.

192
00:22:12.528 --> 00:22:20.507
<v Loretta Smith>So last year, Archives and Records Management partnered with a community organization called Street Books to collect stories from Portlanders living outside.

193
00:22:21.789 --> 00:22:29.923
<v Loretta Smith>Streetbooks is a street library that provides community resources and advocacy for people living outside or at the margins here in Portland, Oregon.

194
00:22:31.823 --> 00:22:38.182
<v Loretta Smith>Streetbooks operates dozens of bike-based and place-based libraries and librarian services across the city.

195
00:22:39.646 --> 00:22:48.553
<v Loretta Smith>Even though homelessness is a crisis in most major American cities, very few archives document first-person narratives of people experiencing homelessness.

196
00:22:50.368 --> 00:22:58.796
<v Loretta Smith>Archival records may contain reports, policies, and legislation on the topic, but rarely do they capture the perspectives of those directly impacted.

197
00:23:00.519 --> 00:23:11.368
<v Loretta Smith>From February 2024 to March 2025, Archives partnered with Street Books on an oral history project by going to their library shifts to record oral history interviews.

198
00:23:12.688 --> 00:23:21.695
<v Loretta Smith>The archivist leaned on the trusted relationships that Street Books has with their community members when asking people to participate and to speak candidly about their lives.

199
00:23:23.728 --> 00:23:40.085
<v Loretta Smith>Archives recorded 24 interviews with Street Books and their staff, as well as patrons who talked about their work building the library program, its challenges, and the transformative relationships that they've developed through this work.

200
00:23:41.528 --> 00:23:46.643
<v Loretta Smith>The interviews reflect the experiences of Portlanders living outside and their interactions with city services.

201
00:23:47.701 --> 00:24:08.721
<v Loretta Smith>There are stories such as Kevin, a Vietnam veteran who finds comfort in nature and birds and trees in our cities— in our city, and Lee, a poet who found community through arts and literature, as well as Carrie, who struggled to find long-term housing due to her marital status but is now in an apartment with her husband and dog through new narratives.

202
00:24:09.107 --> 00:24:09.949
<v Loretta Smith>And home forward.

203
00:24:10.578 --> 00:24:11.030
<v Loretta Smith>Next slide.

204
00:24:14.862 --> 00:24:26.336
<v Loretta Smith>So after recording, archive staff transcribed the interviews and they added the transcripts to the city archives alongside the recordings, making them part of the city's official record.

205
00:24:27.162 --> 00:24:35.522
<v Loretta Smith>And those are available for listening and viewing in the research room at PARC as well as through the Archives and Records Public Access portal eFiles.

206
00:24:36.356 --> 00:24:38.611
<v Loretta Smith>It's also published on the division's website.

207
00:24:40.279 --> 00:24:47.895
<v Loretta Smith>The division also published a bound book of transcripts and interview photographs titled Keeping the Flame of Love and Creativity Alive.

208
00:24:48.801 --> 00:24:58.218
<v Loretta Smith>And that book is meant to expand access so that all Portlanders, including those who are reflected in the oral histories that they— that we collected, can engage with those histories.

209
00:24:59.880 --> 00:25:12.566
<v Loretta Smith>Copies of the book are available in the Park Research Room on Portland State University's campus, in Street Books mobile libraries, and they're also in circulation at all Multnomah County Library branches.

210
00:25:13.228 --> 00:25:17.248
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm pleased to share that the books have been checked out regularly.

211
00:25:18.163 --> 00:25:25.936
<v Loretta Smith>I also have copies of the books to share with you today, and there's also a digital copy that's linked in this committee agenda item.

212
00:25:27.500 --> 00:25:33.920
<v Loretta Smith>Finally, I want to recognize outreach archivist Devin Busby, who's here today.

213
00:25:34.420 --> 00:25:44.148
<v Loretta Smith>She spearheaded the project from City Archives, as well as street librarian Diana Rempe, who worked with us on this project and is also with us today.

214
00:25:46.509 --> 00:25:47.023
<v Loretta Smith>Next slide.

215
00:25:50.237 --> 00:26:06.230
<v Loretta Smith>We also celebrated the 40th anniversary of performance auditing at the City of Portland on May 20th, which is the date that voters approved Ballot Measure 51 in 1986, and that measure amended city charter to allow the auditor to conduct performance audits.

216
00:26:07.612 --> 00:26:20.858
<v Loretta Smith>Archives and Records Management and Audit Services published a webpage detailing the history of our nationally recognized audit function, which has conducted more than 250 performance audits in its lifetime.

217
00:26:22.063 --> 00:26:30.846
<v Loretta Smith>To celebrate, Archives created a digital timeline of the Auditor's Office dating back to the establishment of the City Auditor position in 1864.

218
00:26:32.082 --> 00:26:39.067
<v Loretta Smith>And the timeline details more than 160 years of the Auditor's evolving duties and its growing independence.

219
00:26:39.965 --> 00:26:42.807
<v Loretta Smith>So I encourage you to take a look at that online.

220
00:26:42.855 --> 00:26:47.095
<v Loretta Smith>It's at portland.gov/auditor under the news tab.

221
00:26:48.076 --> 00:26:50.951
<v Loretta Smith>And now I'll hand it over to City Ombudsman Jennifer Croft.

222
00:26:52.740 --> 00:26:53.047
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

223
00:26:53.482 --> 00:26:55.002
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, good afternoon, councilors.

224
00:26:55.099 --> 00:26:56.619
<v Rebecca Dobert>My name is Jennifer Croft.

225
00:26:56.732 --> 00:27:05.647
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm the City Ombudsman and glad to be here today to tell you a little bit about what my office has been up to since my last presentation to you.

226
00:27:06.829 --> 00:27:07.624
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide, please.

227
00:27:09.636 --> 00:27:15.803
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, as a quick recap, we are an independent, impartial advocate for fairness and justice in city government.

228
00:27:16.817 --> 00:27:32.578
<v Rebecca Dobert>We take complaints or concerns from anyone who feels the city has harmed them or treated them unfairly, and we may informally resolve those complaints where possible, or we may conduct investigations to determine whether the complaint is substantiated.

229
00:27:34.190 --> 00:27:40.167
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can also do investigations and investigate matters at our own initiative, even in the absence of a complaint.

230
00:27:41.738 --> 00:27:55.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>Depending on the outcome of our investigations, we may recommend that city bureaus make changes Either to address an individual case or to a broader policy or practice or process if we've identified a systemic problem.

231
00:27:57.182 --> 00:27:57.700
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

232
00:28:00.903 --> 00:28:05.776
<v Rebecca Dobert>In April, we released our annual report that covered the calendar year 2025.

233
00:28:06.310 --> 00:28:11.871
<v Rebecca Dobert>This report highlights complaints, complaint trends, and gives examples of our work during the year.

234
00:28:12.288 --> 00:28:25.817
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'll go into a couple of the data points in upcoming slides, but first I'd like to mention one development that stood out, which was an increase in people who contacted our office who were experiencing homelessness.

235
00:28:26.844 --> 00:28:42.298
<v Rebecca Dobert>Of complainants who provided information about their housing status, the percentage who said they were experiencing homelessness was 36%, compared to 15% the year before, which was the first year that we began collecting this information.

236
00:28:43.417 --> 00:28:58.203
<v Rebecca Dobert>And this included people staying at the city's alternative shelters or 24/7 shelters who contacted us with a variety of concerns, including exits from shelters, staff conduct, and issues related to shelter facilities, among others.

237
00:29:00.084 --> 00:29:09.126
<v Rebecca Dobert>We also use our annual report to share the outcomes that we've helped complainants achieve, or instances when our recommendations have helped contribute to systemic change.

238
00:29:10.404 --> 00:29:22.414
<v Rebecca Dobert>For example, we helped individual community members save more than $300,000 in city fines or fees and helped others regain access to shelter or to their property.

239
00:29:24.195 --> 00:29:33.873
<v Rebecca Dobert>In a systemic example, our recommendations led the Water Bureau to take steps to better respond to the needs of domestic violence survivors who may be experiencing financial crisis.

240
00:29:35.557 --> 00:29:36.089
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

241
00:29:39.420 --> 00:29:41.845
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'll move to a couple of the data points from the report.

242
00:29:42.501 --> 00:29:50.267
<v Rebecca Dobert>Here you can see that our office continued to see increased complaint numbers with a 32% increase compared to 2024.

243
00:29:52.421 --> 00:30:00.707
<v Rebecca Dobert>Of these 617 complaints that fell under our authority to investigate, we accepted 60% of those for assistance.

244
00:30:01.085 --> 00:30:12.336
<v Rebecca Dobert>Which means that we either investigated or what was more often the case, we made another type of intervention such as facilitating communication or providing the complainant with more information.

245
00:30:13.769 --> 00:30:14.347
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

246
00:30:17.295 --> 00:30:29.863
<v Rebecca Dobert>The list of bureaus that generated the most complaints or that the most complaints referred to was similar to previous years, although this was the first time that Portland Solutions appears on our chart.

247
00:30:29.928 --> 00:30:34.392
<v Rebecca Dobert>We began tracking it separately In mid-2024.

248
00:30:35.960 --> 00:30:47.796
<v Rebecca Dobert>And complaints related to the city's homeless services or livability functions made up a greater share of complaints than in past years, which was connected to the increase in complaints from shelter guests that I mentioned earlier.

249
00:30:48.710 --> 00:30:49.191
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

250
00:30:53.160 --> 00:31:05.242
<v Rebecca Dobert>In addition to our work on individual cases, and as part of that work, we're always keeping an eye out for any trends or patterns that may point to the city causing more systemic harm or unfairness.

251
00:31:06.230 --> 00:31:17.751
<v Rebecca Dobert>And an example of a systemic review that we completed during a recent period is a report we published in March about accessory short-term rental rules and enforcement.

252
00:31:19.336 --> 00:31:29.413
<v Rebecca Dobert>We undertook this investigation after receiving individual complaints from short-term rental operators who had inadvertently run afoul of the rules and been hit with huge fines.

253
00:31:30.449 --> 00:31:30.980
<v Loretta Smith>Next slide.

254
00:31:33.784 --> 00:31:38.164
<v Rebecca Dobert>Our investigation found that Portland's enforcement is more punitive than other cities.

255
00:31:38.825 --> 00:31:45.632
<v Rebecca Dobert>For example, the maximum fine for first-time violator is at least 27 times higher than any other city that we surveyed.

256
00:31:46.925 --> 00:31:59.105
<v Rebecca Dobert>We also learned that more than half of operators in Portland who were fined particularly high amounts may have been people of color, have a recent history of immigration, or belong to the LGBTQ+ community.

257
00:32:00.441 --> 00:32:12.714
<v Rebecca Dobert>That may be linked to the city's reliance on complaints from the public to identify violators, and my office has previously raised concerns about the inequitable impacts of complaint-based enforcement.

258
00:32:14.385 --> 00:32:19.961
<v Rebecca Dobert>Data we reviewed also suggests that that heavy reliance on complaints is ultimately inefficient.

259
00:32:21.296 --> 00:32:27.788
<v Rebecca Dobert>In addition, Portland's rules are more complex than what we saw in other cities and are difficult to enforce.

260
00:32:29.036 --> 00:32:36.817
<v Rebecca Dobert>Based on our findings, we recommended changes in the city's rules and enforcement methods to reduce harm and increase equity and effectiveness.

261
00:32:39.019 --> 00:32:51.079
<v Rebecca Dobert>In response to our report, the city administration agreed to explore issuing warnings before fines, as we recommended, but referred to council for decisions on changing the rules and reducing fines.

262
00:32:52.323 --> 00:33:01.905
<v Rebecca Dobert>My colleague Tony Green, who led the investigation, and I have been having conversations about the report with staff of councilors who serve on the Housing and Permitting Committee.

263
00:33:02.829 --> 00:33:06.528
<v Rebecca Dobert>And we will look forward to council support on the implementation of our recommendations.

264
00:33:08.771 --> 00:33:09.349
<v Rebecca Dobert>I will stop there.

265
00:33:09.977 --> 00:33:11.070
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you for your attention.

266
00:33:11.809 --> 00:33:17.663
<v Rebecca Dobert>Also, for the instances when your office have referred community members to us, we do appreciate those referrals.

267
00:33:18.567 --> 00:33:21.457
<v Rebecca Dobert>I look forward to your questions, and I will hand over to Casey.

268
00:33:23.167 --> 00:33:23.813
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks, Jennifer.

269
00:33:24.959 --> 00:33:25.411
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

270
00:33:26.088 --> 00:33:27.155
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Casey Jones.

271
00:33:27.286 --> 00:33:29.875
<v Unidentified speaker>I use he/him pronouns, and I serve as the Audit Services Director.

272
00:33:31.971 --> 00:33:38.573
<v Unidentified speaker>Today I'll be mentioning work that we've released in the last year with more focus on 2 most recent audits.

273
00:33:39.359 --> 00:33:43.626
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll also remind you of the audits we have underway and look forward to your questions.

274
00:33:44.061 --> 00:33:44.996
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide.

275
00:33:47.588 --> 00:33:50.288
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a quick refresher on Audit Services work.

276
00:33:50.530 --> 00:34:03.180
<v Unidentified speaker>Our division conducts performance audits of city programs, manages a contract with an outside accounting firm for the city's annual financial audit, and administers the city's fraud hotline for tips of fraud, waste, and abuse.

277
00:34:04.449 --> 00:34:12.141
<v Unidentified speaker>We also monitor and report on the status of audit recommendations through our audit impact report and our recommendation dashboard.

278
00:34:12.641 --> 00:34:13.239
<v Mitch Green>Next slide.

279
00:34:15.900 --> 00:34:22.235
<v Unidentified speaker>So this is a run-through of our 4 most recent reports dating back to October 2025.

280
00:34:23.318 --> 00:34:43.297
<v Unidentified speaker>This includes our 2024 audit impact report that summarizes the results So the results of our follow-up work, we found broadly that city bureaus had yet to implement a little over half of our audit recommendations, but the implementation rate did increase over last year, as did the response rate from bureaus.

281
00:34:44.275 --> 00:34:50.864
<v Unidentified speaker>We found that leadership was challenged with prioritization in getting outstanding recommendations implemented.

282
00:34:51.985 --> 00:34:55.608
<v Unidentified speaker>The Parks fiscal management audit was also released in October.

283
00:34:56.217 --> 00:35:00.048
<v Unidentified speaker>We found that Parks does not have enough resources for its existing programs.

284
00:35:00.626 --> 00:35:04.648
<v Unidentified speaker>And maintenance obligations, but continues to invest in new assets.

285
00:35:05.288 --> 00:35:09.934
<v Unidentified speaker>This was released right around the time that the parks levy was up for a vote.

286
00:35:10.159 --> 00:35:12.994
<v Unidentified speaker>And I remember a lot of council discussion around this.

287
00:35:13.059 --> 00:35:20.909
<v Unidentified speaker>And as Councilor Clark mentioned, there's a strong overlap in this project's findings with our asset management audit that predated it.

288
00:35:22.190 --> 00:35:30.168
<v Unidentified speaker>So our audit recommends that parks integrate new investment decisions with existing maintenance obligations and clearly communicate fiscal strategies.

289
00:35:31.101 --> 00:35:37.246
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll get more in depth on our 2 most recent audits released in 2026 in the next 2 slides.

290
00:35:41.521 --> 00:35:48.262
<v Unidentified speaker>So our first audit released in 2026 was our climate justice audit.

291
00:35:48.860 --> 00:35:57.692
<v Unidentified speaker>The city uses a climate justice approach to address climate change, recognizing that climate change impacts the most vulnerable communities first and hardest.

292
00:35:57.742 --> 00:36:04.344
<v Unidentified speaker>Since the transition to a new form of government in 2024, the city has been working to the city took steps to elevate climate work.

293
00:36:04.809 --> 00:36:08.157
<v Unidentified speaker>However, work still remains to make climate actions more effective.

294
00:36:08.893 --> 00:36:14.438
<v Unidentified speaker>Our audit released in February examined how the city prioritized and coordinated its climate work.

295
00:36:15.141 --> 00:36:21.534
<v Unidentified speaker>Actions in the city's climate action plans fall under 2 categories: climate mitigation and climate adaptation.

296
00:36:22.431 --> 00:36:37.485
<v Unidentified speaker>Individual or collaborating bureaus are responsible for completing these actions, and the difference seen here is that climate mitigation focuses on reducing planet-warming emissions while climate adaptation focuses on making communities more resilient.

297
00:36:38.641 --> 00:36:46.108
<v Unidentified speaker>We found that centralized authority and defined coordination structures would help the city follow through on its climate commitments.

298
00:36:46.284 --> 00:36:53.702
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, a realistic funding plan could help overcome the challenges or the challenge of addressing competing priorities.

299
00:36:54.458 --> 00:37:01.184
<v Unidentified speaker>These internal changes would provide clearer direction to bureaus and help to better prioritize and coordinate climate work.

300
00:37:02.307 --> 00:37:11.400
<v Unidentified speaker>This audit also examined whether the city considered the impacts of climate change on the community and how the city integrated community involvement into its climate work.

301
00:37:12.427 --> 00:37:23.557
<v Unidentified speaker>We found that developing a climate adaptation strategy would help the city to more effectively address community impacts, especially for the Portlanders most vulnerable to the impacts of climate change.

302
00:37:24.054 --> 00:37:31.079
<v Unidentified speaker>We found that increased transparency could help build trust with external partners and help ensure climate actions are implemented.

303
00:37:31.914 --> 00:37:37.666
<v Unidentified speaker>And we found that guidance from a community engagement strategy could help achieve those climate goals.

304
00:37:39.047 --> 00:37:44.606
<v Unidentified speaker>We recommend that city leadership provide clearer direction to ensure the city follows through on its climate commitments.

305
00:37:45.152 --> 00:37:56.751
<v Unidentified speaker>And we also recommend that city leadership work in collaboration with the Sustainability and Climate Commission to more effectively address community climate impacts and build trust with external groups.

306
00:37:57.474 --> 00:38:04.813
<v Unidentified speaker>We presented these results Next slide.

307
00:38:07.556 --> 00:38:10.768
<v Unidentified speaker>Next was the Arts, Education, and Access Fund audit.

308
00:38:11.170 --> 00:38:24.927
<v Unidentified speaker>Before I start, I want to note that recent council actions have changed elements of the arts tax that were in place at the time of the audit and align with a lot of the findings that we made.

309
00:38:26.498 --> 00:38:34.710
<v Unidentified speaker>So Portland voters approved a $35 income tax in 2012 to pay for arts teachers and provide grants to arts organizations.

310
00:38:35.543 --> 00:38:42.615
<v Unidentified speaker>Each year, an average of $11.2 million from the arts tax flows into the Arts Education and Access Fund.

311
00:38:43.402 --> 00:38:51.628
<v Unidentified speaker>This chart shows how the city distributes money from the arts tax to pay for tax collection, elementary arts teachers, city coordination, and grants.

312
00:38:52.447 --> 00:39:04.224
<v Unidentified speaker>Our audit objective was to determine if the city had managed the Arts Education and Access Fund to assure high-quality arts education and arts access to students and underserved communities.

313
00:39:04.994 --> 00:39:12.503
<v Unidentified speaker>Scope of the audit was the city's management of the Arts Access Fund between November 2012 and October 2025.

314
00:39:13.146 --> 00:39:19.612
<v Unidentified speaker>We focused on city actors with fund responsibilities, so the Office of Arts and Culture, Revenue Division, Grants Management Division.

315
00:39:19.659 --> 00:39:19.820
<v Christopher>Thank you.

316
00:39:20.030 --> 00:39:20.543
<v Christopher>Division.

317
00:39:21.731 --> 00:39:30.706
<v Unidentified speaker>And we found that the tax has expanded arts education for elementary school students, but the city did not establish goals or metrics until recently.

318
00:39:31.284 --> 00:39:40.275
<v Unidentified speaker>So as a result, the city has not been able to effectively monitor school district performance or assess differences in students' experiences across and within districts.

319
00:39:41.641 --> 00:39:48.094
<v Unidentified speaker>Grants from the fund have provided valuable support to arts organizations, but the amount available for grants is shrinking.

320
00:39:48.159 --> 00:39:48.496
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

321
00:39:49.443 --> 00:39:56.688
<v Unidentified speaker>Grants are provided only after collection costs and payments to districts are made, as you can see in the graphic here.

322
00:39:57.554 --> 00:40:04.239
<v Unidentified speaker>Because those costs are rising and the tax is not adjusted for inflation, the fund's purchasing power is eroding.

323
00:40:04.655 --> 00:40:12.990
<v Unidentified speaker>We found that the city's method for calculating payments to districts either further limits the amount available for grants or does not fully compensate districts.

324
00:40:14.273 --> 00:40:22.440
<v Unidentified speaker>Despite promises to voters, the city has not ensured that these grants improve access to arts and culture for students and underserved communities.

325
00:40:23.197 --> 00:40:36.786
<v Unidentified speaker>The city code and the way the city distributes funding do not prioritize improving access, and the city cannot determine or demonstrate that most grants improved access because it's not holding grantees to specific outcomes.

326
00:40:38.829 --> 00:40:49.525
<v Unidentified speaker>Then we also found that the city's monitoring responsibilities and the oversight committee's role and authority are not well defined, increasing the that the Arts Access Fund is not used as intended.

327
00:40:50.472 --> 00:41:04.510
<v Unidentified speaker>We make recommendations to strengthen the city's monitoring and coordination of arts education, maximize funding available for grants, ensure grants improve arts access and advance program goals, and improve financial monitoring and oversight.

328
00:41:04.655 --> 00:41:12.291
<v Unidentified speaker>And also in this case, we presented our results to the Arts Access Fund Oversight Committee after the audit was released.

329
00:41:13.083 --> 00:41:13.876
<v Dan Ryan>Next slide.

330
00:41:16.807 --> 00:41:19.835
<v Unidentified speaker>The next item I'd like to speak about is the annual audit schedule.

331
00:41:20.559 --> 00:41:26.585
<v Unidentified speaker>Our next audit schedule will be released tomorrow and provided to each of you directly upon release.

332
00:41:27.101 --> 00:41:40.027
<v Unidentified speaker>As noted by Auditor Reddy in our office's budget work session, the city auditor's requested budget for fiscal year '26-'27 cut one performance auditor position to help respond to the city's financial or fiscal crisis.

333
00:41:40.873 --> 00:41:46.324
<v Unidentified speaker>Therefore, we've selected one fewer topic for this audit schedule schedule to reflect our reduced capacity.

334
00:41:47.478 --> 00:41:58.161
<v Unidentified speaker>Despite this, the schedule maintains coverage of the city's service areas and continues audits already underway, including an audit of Prosper Portland per our agreement with the agency.

335
00:41:59.188 --> 00:42:03.889
<v Unidentified speaker>We developed the audit schedule by collecting ideas for potential audits all year long.

336
00:42:05.139 --> 00:42:08.074
<v Unidentified speaker>We have an online form where the public can suggest topics.

337
00:42:08.813 --> 00:42:11.989
<v Unidentified speaker>Auditors may also identify potential topics while conducting audits.

338
00:42:13.291 --> 00:42:19.284
<v Unidentified speaker>We also engaged with you all and other city leaders to understand what issues are important to you and your constituents.

339
00:42:19.815 --> 00:42:28.411
<v Unidentified speaker>We shared a listing of topics under consideration with the public and community groups through a survey to understand which programs and services they would most like to see audited.

340
00:42:29.295 --> 00:42:35.851
<v Unidentified speaker>We met as an audit team to discuss the potential topics and analyze them based on a variety of risk categories.

341
00:42:36.590 --> 00:42:37.989
<v Unidentified speaker>The list of topics for the next Next slide.

342
00:42:38.054 --> 00:42:46.565
<v Unidentified speaker>The scope of the audit for the next fiscal year was then finalized based on those risk scores, considering coverage across service areas and our capacity.

343
00:42:48.199 --> 00:43:01.768
<v Unidentified speaker>We will also be convening a focus group with community groups to discuss whether there are areas in these topics that we've chosen where community members are able to contribute their lived experiences to an audit.

344
00:43:03.307 --> 00:43:03.518
<v Mitch Green>Next slide.

345
00:43:03.610 --> 00:43:05.340
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

346
00:43:06.431 --> 00:43:09.733
<v Unidentified speaker>And we have 6 performance audits currently underway.

347
00:43:10.456 --> 00:43:16.820
<v Unidentified speaker>We are finishing our audit of 911 and emergency communications focused on the bureau's training efforts.

348
00:43:17.574 --> 00:43:21.150
<v Unidentified speaker>That report will be released next week, and you all will get a copy on Monday.

349
00:43:22.063 --> 00:43:32.644
<v Unidentified speaker>Our audit of the city's gun violence reduction efforts is in fieldwork and focused on the Ceasefire Program and the Office of Violence Prevention's Trauma and Violence Impacted Families Program.

350
00:43:33.543 --> 00:43:42.722
<v Unidentified speaker>And then our audits of cybersecurity, Prosper Portland's grant management, citywide equity, and Portland Solutions are all in their planning phase.

351
00:43:43.219 --> 00:43:50.686
<v Unidentified speaker>This is where auditors gather information on the program, identify criteria, and develop audit objectives to focus on during fieldwork.

352
00:43:51.807 --> 00:43:56.742
<v Unidentified speaker>We update council when audits begin and when we've chosen an objective or objectives.

353
00:43:57.478 --> 00:44:01.740
<v Unidentified speaker>Once complete, we also provide council with an embargo copy of the audit report.

354
00:44:02.306 --> 00:44:05.442
<v Unidentified speaker>And official response before it is released publicly.

355
00:44:08.561 --> 00:44:09.690
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that's it.

356
00:44:09.851 --> 00:44:11.831
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide is for questions.

357
00:44:12.588 --> 00:44:13.443
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Director Jones.

358
00:44:13.490 --> 00:44:17.130
<v Loretta Smith>So before I open it up to questions, I just wanted to share 2 more updates with you.

359
00:44:18.130 --> 00:44:29.326
<v Loretta Smith>One is that the Auditor's Office has undergone an outside assessment of its human resources internal controls, and that's pursuant to a charter requirement that that took effect in 2017.

360
00:44:30.385 --> 00:44:42.155
<v Loretta Smith>That assessment found that we had processes, processes in place and that they were working effectively to ensure compliance with our rules and procedures in 10 different areas of human resource management.

361
00:44:43.568 --> 00:44:52.864
<v Loretta Smith>And it also identified opportunities to clarify documentation, standardize processes, and provide additional supervisor training to improve consistency.

362
00:44:54.320 --> 00:45:02.025
<v Loretta Smith>The assessment and our response will be made public next Monday and accessible online at portland.gov/auditor under the news tab.

363
00:45:03.378 --> 00:45:13.347
<v Loretta Smith>And lastly, the Auditor's Office will be participating in a variety of community events this summer to inform Portlanders about our services, which is a goal of our community engagement strategy.

364
00:45:14.492 --> 00:45:25.907
<v Loretta Smith>You can find us at the Juneteenth Festival this Saturday at Lilla Sunday Parkways in East Portland on June 28th and downtown Portland on September 13th.

365
00:45:26.583 --> 00:45:31.487
<v Loretta Smith>The Portland Pride Parade on Sunday, July 19th, and Welcoming Week in September.

366
00:45:32.467 --> 00:45:36.518
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you for your attention, and now I will open it up to your questions.

367
00:45:38.152 --> 00:45:39.052
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Auditor Reddy.

368
00:45:39.197 --> 00:45:41.157
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Jennifer and Casey, as well.

369
00:45:42.811 --> 00:45:45.239
<v Sameer Kanal>We do not have any testifiers on this item.

370
00:45:45.286 --> 00:45:55.170
<v Sameer Kanal>We did open it up for public testimony, but we do have several council members Councilor Koyama Lane and Councilor Clark will be next.

371
00:45:55.846 --> 00:45:56.666
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

372
00:45:58.090 --> 00:45:59.375
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>First, thank you, Auditor Reddy.

373
00:45:59.711 --> 00:46:08.989
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>As a fellow elected official, I want to appreciate you and the important work that is often underappreciated and unseen that you do for our city.

374
00:46:09.860 --> 00:46:26.414
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And when I see the different audits that are underway, it's really a reminder that your office ensures that the city's work is just and efficient and executing its services under the rule of law and the myriad policies that council also puts in motion.

375
00:46:26.929 --> 00:46:28.277
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I want to acknowledge you and your team.

376
00:46:29.320 --> 00:46:36.045
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And specifically also want to offer my sincerest thank yous to Archives and Records Management.

377
00:46:36.398 --> 00:46:47.503
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My team has made multiple requests this past year, and each time we received really cordial, timely responses, and the archival records around the archives that we requested.

378
00:46:48.659 --> 00:46:56.025
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>One time folks even really quickly pulled together last minute some historical documents when we were honoring Minoru Yasui Day here as council.

379
00:46:56.458 --> 00:47:06.648
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so there were many folks that got to, before the meeting down in the atrium, see some historical documents of the incarceration signs that were put up, you know, on these streets.

380
00:47:06.728 --> 00:47:08.221
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And it was really powerful.

381
00:47:09.440 --> 00:47:17.902
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you to our To Ombudsman Croft and your team for helping make sure that Portland residents and businesses are treated as fairly as possible.

382
00:47:19.297 --> 00:47:27.452
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Have, you know, looked through the report and findings around short-term rentals, and it's pretty grave.

383
00:47:28.927 --> 00:47:34.021
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's a lot of inequity that is clear financially, racially.

384
00:47:35.096 --> 00:47:47.717
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I understand that your office has shared your research and findings with DC Oliveira and relevant bureaus, and that there maybe have been some discussions related to recommendations from you all.

385
00:47:49.460 --> 00:47:56.936
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It appears that there are a number of them that would be really helpful for the city to consider in improving our short-term rental practices.

386
00:47:58.489 --> 00:48:04.403
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm currently very concerned about the inequity implications of our current practices.

387
00:48:04.987 --> 00:48:13.909
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm interested in working with your team, with the DCA, with CA Lee, um, on our programs to address this.

388
00:48:14.327 --> 00:48:21.509
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I also would like to say I'd really like to see the— our new Chief Equity Officer Tillman included in this.

389
00:48:22.280 --> 00:48:25.815
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I would love to see— I was just thinking, oh, maybe Donnie's not here.

390
00:48:25.992 --> 00:48:35.594
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>If, if you're open, I would love to hear, um, if there are any thoughts about next steps about like Like, what commitments can be made?

391
00:48:35.786 --> 00:48:39.409
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are you kind of waiting for councilors to take a lead?

392
00:48:39.456 --> 00:48:42.630
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I would love to hear from you, DCA Oliveira.

393
00:48:43.961 --> 00:48:56.159
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'm— I've already talked to— put some feelers out with some other— some of my colleagues about if there is policy around this that I would love to bring this forward and be as supportive as possible.

394
00:48:56.465 --> 00:48:59.190
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Donny Oliveira, for the record.

395
00:48:59.333 --> 00:48:59.974
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you, Councilor.

396
00:49:00.552 --> 00:49:03.532
<v Donnie Oliveira>Madam Auditor, team, thank you for letting me pop up here.

397
00:49:04.398 --> 00:49:14.940
<v Donnie Oliveira>So going back actually a year and a half, I just want to acknowledge the Ombudsman's Office working with us, providing some recommendations that we were initially able to implement last spring.

398
00:49:15.454 --> 00:49:18.402
<v Donnie Oliveira>They were modest, but they were in response to some feedback they'd given us.

399
00:49:19.074 --> 00:49:21.719
<v Donnie Oliveira>We have the updated recommendations, a little bit more broad in scope.

400
00:49:21.782 --> 00:49:24.554
<v Donnie Oliveira>Some are going to require procedural updates, some are going to require some code changes.

401
00:49:25.387 --> 00:49:34.927
<v Donnie Oliveira>The good news is we also were simultaneously doing some analysis through BPS on those more durable code changes that would frankly enhance our code.

402
00:49:35.009 --> 00:49:42.514
<v Donnie Oliveira>If for the public to appreciate, Portland was one of the first cities to adopt accessory short-term rental code.

403
00:49:43.027 --> 00:49:46.347
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so now many cities have since updated and learned from our experiences.

404
00:49:46.396 --> 00:49:48.931
<v Donnie Oliveira>So now it's time for us to recalibrate our baseline code.

405
00:49:49.539 --> 00:49:53.309
<v Donnie Oliveira>So to answer your question, yes, we are currently working on improving our enforcement.

406
00:49:53.693 --> 00:50:01.840
<v Donnie Oliveira>We're refining how we do work with frankly, Airbnb and VRBO on data sharing.

407
00:50:02.032 --> 00:50:03.251
<v Donnie Oliveira>It still continues to be a barrier.

408
00:50:03.956 --> 00:50:08.318
<v Donnie Oliveira>We can't enforce and we can't do it well without good data, and they are sort of the gatekeepers of that.

409
00:50:08.927 --> 00:50:17.474
<v Donnie Oliveira>But to answer your question, we hope by the end of the year to have some additional procedural improvements that we can own it administratively and hopefully in early '27 come back to you all with some code changes.

410
00:50:18.548 --> 00:50:25.911
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And do you have any thoughts about my idea to see if our Chief Equity I don't know why this is so hard for me to say.

411
00:50:25.990 --> 00:50:31.416
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Chief Equity Officer Tillman can be part of that work and those conversations.

412
00:50:31.465 --> 00:50:31.947
<v Donnie Oliveira>Great idea.

413
00:50:32.170 --> 00:50:34.467
<v Donnie Oliveira>We'd love to have her join and be a part of that.

414
00:50:34.900 --> 00:50:39.492
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And if there is a place where you're waiting for direction from council, please let me know.

415
00:50:39.572 --> 00:50:51.418
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I also would maybe hope, if not, that at the very least, Housing and Permitting Chair Avalos is included in that so we can make sure that we're getting those updates in our Housing and Permitting Committee.

416
00:50:52.079 --> 00:50:54.365
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

417
00:50:54.978 --> 00:51:01.324
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

418
00:51:01.501 --> 00:51:03.661
<v Sameer Kanal>Go to Councilor Clark, followed by Council President Dunphy.

419
00:51:04.822 --> 00:51:05.402
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mr.

420
00:51:05.451 --> 00:51:05.724
<v Angelita Morillo>Chair.

421
00:51:06.679 --> 00:51:08.932
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, thank you, uh, Adoretti and team.

422
00:51:09.271 --> 00:51:10.510
<v Unidentified speaker>I really appreciate your work.

423
00:51:10.639 --> 00:51:15.614
<v Unidentified speaker>I reference it all the time, and in neighborhood meetings and, and about town.

424
00:51:16.514 --> 00:51:18.039
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I think it's super important.

425
00:51:18.155 --> 00:51:19.324
<v Unidentified speaker>I would just echo Thank you, Mayor.

426
00:51:19.405 --> 00:51:21.394
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate also some of Councilor Koyama Lane's comments.

427
00:51:21.492 --> 00:51:30.266
<v Unidentified speaker>And actually, one of my questions was around how we track city responses to your work.

428
00:51:30.331 --> 00:51:35.554
<v Unidentified speaker>And actually, Councilor Koyama Lane brought up the short-term rentals.

429
00:51:36.798 --> 00:51:37.625
<v Unidentified speaker>Progress is being made.

430
00:51:37.851 --> 00:51:38.434
<v Unidentified speaker>We're doing things.

431
00:51:38.483 --> 00:51:44.699
<v Unidentified speaker>How do we know, or do we get feedback from you, or is there a reporting like, oh yes, the city responded?

432
00:51:45.409 --> 00:52:03.101
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, in regards to the parks piece, as well as the arts tax, on the parks piece, I believe the levy actually had a requirement in it that we come back with a fiscal sustainability report, something like that.

433
00:52:03.166 --> 00:52:08.815
<v Unidentified speaker>And I don't think that was in reaction to your audit necessarily because, well, maybe it was, I'm not sure.

434
00:52:09.530 --> 00:52:15.990
<v Unidentified speaker>But how do we track the response and the progress to some of these things, because there is action.

435
00:52:16.086 --> 00:52:22.054
<v Unidentified speaker>I think we are taking action on, on your audits, and it's the same for the arts tax, I believe.

436
00:52:22.101 --> 00:52:23.728
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm just curious about that.

437
00:52:23.842 --> 00:52:28.835
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll just let that hang there for a second, and you can respond if you like.

438
00:52:29.449 --> 00:52:32.668
<v Unidentified speaker>But also on June 18th, the unveiling—.

439
00:52:33.440 --> 00:52:35.003
<v Rebecca Dobert>Is this super top secret?

440
00:52:35.195 --> 00:52:35.920
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't get to know?

441
00:52:37.347 --> 00:52:41.398
<v Loretta Smith>We're trying to strategically build suspense for releasing it tomorrow.

442
00:52:41.525 --> 00:52:42.152
<v Unidentified speaker>It's working.

443
00:52:42.248 --> 00:52:42.940
<v Unidentified speaker>It's working.

444
00:52:42.989 --> 00:52:50.811
<v Loretta Smith>Many, as Director Jones showed on the slide, there's many underway and only a few new topics.

445
00:52:50.875 --> 00:52:52.710
<v Loretta Smith>So hopefully those will stand out to you.

446
00:52:53.114 --> 00:52:55.625
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, well, I'm anxiously awaiting for June 18th then.

447
00:52:58.128 --> 00:53:13.317
<v Unidentified speaker>And one other question, and you can come back and if you want to address the kind of responses have you— I'm sorry, I could look on the web, but have you done an audit or financial audit of PBOT or other audits of PBOT?

448
00:53:14.103 --> 00:53:19.079
<v Unidentified speaker>Our most recent PBOT audit is our Vision Zero audit from a couple years ago.

449
00:53:20.106 --> 00:53:29.847
<v Unidentified speaker>And then I think we had a street improvement audit prior to that that's maybe falling out of our follow-up window, which is yes.

450
00:53:29.913 --> 00:53:31.014
<v Unidentified speaker>So the cycle is 5 years.

451
00:53:31.693 --> 00:53:35.708
<v Unidentified speaker>Each year we go back for every audit issued in the last 5 years.

452
00:53:36.199 --> 00:53:40.695
<v Unidentified speaker>We compile those results into the dashboard.

453
00:53:40.807 --> 00:53:44.818
<v Unidentified speaker>So for individual recommendations, those are all in there.

454
00:53:45.739 --> 00:53:52.164
<v Unidentified speaker>We have introduced a response template in the last 2 years for bureaus.

455
00:53:52.277 --> 00:54:04.273
<v Unidentified speaker>So, you know, we had been getting a lot of of letters back from bureaus as an official response that maybe didn't specify planned actions and those sorts of things.

456
00:54:05.260 --> 00:54:07.199
<v Unidentified speaker>So we turn that into a template.

457
00:54:08.539 --> 00:54:15.268
<v Unidentified speaker>Typically, bureau leader or city administrator kind of handles the COVID letter sort of portion of it.

458
00:54:15.333 --> 00:54:20.898
<v Unidentified speaker>And then folks we've been working with more directly on the audit typically fill out the template.

459
00:54:21.521 --> 00:54:33.452
<v Unidentified speaker>Responding to each recommendation with a plan for, or expressing whether they agree or disagree, a plan for implementing, and then a timeline for that plan.

460
00:54:33.742 --> 00:54:40.452
<v Unidentified speaker>And I know on asset management, that was one of the things that actually council action like kind of spurred along and moved up.

461
00:54:41.608 --> 00:54:52.630
<v Unidentified speaker>So we use that as kind of our first, First, like, thing that we're checking back in with them in that first year.

462
00:54:52.695 --> 00:54:54.467
<v Unidentified speaker>Hey, are these things underway?

463
00:54:54.565 --> 00:54:55.338
<v Unidentified speaker>How are they going?

464
00:54:56.440 --> 00:55:04.344
<v Unidentified speaker>And then in that follow-up, we are asking them, hey, what's getting in your way of implementing that?

465
00:55:04.440 --> 00:55:11.907
<v Unidentified speaker>So those are the things that we try to use to summarize, like, major challenges and that sort of thing in that audit impact report.

466
00:55:12.019 --> 00:55:12.795
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

467
00:55:13.311 --> 00:55:26.697
<v Unidentified speaker>No surprise that last year prioritization, so like prioritizing implementing our recommendations over things that may be more pressing or that they may not have capacity or budget to do, was the biggest challenge.

468
00:55:28.123 --> 00:55:49.775
<v Unidentified speaker>And we wanna make sure that both like that kind of high-level summary of like, hey, these are the things that are getting in the way, especially as we moved from the old form of government to the new form, Like, hey, are there collaboration challenges or authority issues, those sorts of things that are getting in folks' way?

469
00:55:51.057 --> 00:55:59.679
<v Unidentified speaker>And then also have the dashboard, which lets folks kind of drill down to, hey, I'm interested in this specific bureau and how they're doing and that sort of thing.

470
00:56:00.192 --> 00:56:02.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so I'm glad to know it's really a dynamic process.

471
00:56:02.835 --> 00:56:11.655
<v Unidentified speaker>They're not just put on the shelf and forgotten about and that you have a dashboard that's incumbent on us then to go back and to look at what's going on post.

472
00:56:11.735 --> 00:56:16.110
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, and if you have questions, we're happy to kind of dig through that and guide you through it.

473
00:56:16.918 --> 00:56:20.927
<v Unidentified speaker>We also have all the documentation of what they've sent back to us.

474
00:56:21.219 --> 00:56:25.746
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't just kind of take the form back and say, sounds good, you said it was implemented, we believe you.

475
00:56:26.717 --> 00:56:29.967
<v Unidentified speaker>We ask for kind of supporting documentation along the way.

476
00:56:30.047 --> 00:56:39.858
<v Unidentified speaker>So if there's things through that process, honestly, sometimes it is, we presented this to council, so you may have already heard the thing that they're, they're saying, uh, help them implement it.

477
00:56:39.938 --> 00:56:43.534
<v Unidentified speaker>But, um, yeah, we're, we're happy to help guide through that stuff.

478
00:56:43.969 --> 00:56:44.952
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much, Casey.

479
00:56:45.114 --> 00:56:45.710
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair.

480
00:56:47.487 --> 00:56:48.887
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council Vice President Clark.

481
00:56:48.951 --> 00:56:51.523
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go to Council President Dunphy, followed by Councilor Novick.

482
00:56:51.844 --> 00:56:52.407
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Chair—.

483
00:56:52.730 --> 00:56:53.532
<v Sameer Kanal>Or Chair Kanal.

484
00:56:54.079 --> 00:57:05.385
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I just want to thank you all for the work that you have been doing because I have been, uh, developing a habit in my office of trying to tackle some of the least sexy policy Thank you.

485
00:57:06.733 --> 00:57:21.409
<v Unidentified speaker>And generally, you all have been providing me a guide— a guide path, including yesterday our conversation about single permitting authorities within the permitting bureaus dating all the way back to 1997.

486
00:57:22.164 --> 00:57:34.230
<v Unidentified speaker>So to that end, you know, I really appreciate the help and also the fact— recognizing the fact that we are in a new form of government where some of your Your decades of recommendations can actually be implemented for the first time.

487
00:57:34.918 --> 00:57:38.492
<v Unidentified speaker>So my question is, you know, largely sort of building off what President Clark was saying.

488
00:57:38.588 --> 00:57:46.070
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, I hear that when you say the Parks Department isn't delivering X, Y, and Z, and then you go back to them and say, how are you gonna fix that?

489
00:57:46.135 --> 00:57:48.393
<v Unidentified speaker>But do you do the same thing from a policy perspective?

490
00:57:48.458 --> 00:57:49.771
<v Unidentified speaker>And how far back would you look back?

491
00:57:49.884 --> 00:57:59.641
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, if we successfully get, for example, this permitting authority change, would you go back to your 1997 audit of the Permitting Bureau and say, hey, by the way, in 2026 they fixed it?

492
00:58:04.159 --> 00:58:04.965
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, we could.

493
00:58:05.304 --> 00:58:29.889
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, the— I, I think for us, the, um, the reliance on kind of past, like, oh, this was done in accordance with Yellow Book standards, we, we understand how that recommendation was made, even if, you know, some of us were in high school when it was made, um, kind of gives us that confidence that this is, you is something that may or could still be relevant.

494
00:58:30.355 --> 00:58:39.061
<v Unidentified speaker>Honestly, doing some of the work for the performance audit anniversary project led me to kind of go back through a lot of stuff.

495
00:58:39.608 --> 00:58:50.001
<v Unidentified speaker>I think if we wanted to do that, we would have to look at ways of kind of taking it on as a maybe non-Yellow Book project of its own.

496
00:58:50.596 --> 00:59:02.373
<v Unidentified speaker>I know there are some offices and some Functions of GAO that do these like, hey, this is a specific risk area, or that sort of thing where you can kind of highlight that historical stuff.

497
00:59:04.527 --> 00:59:11.815
<v Unidentified speaker>But sometimes there are members of the public who write to us saying, hey, how are they doing on that thing that you recommended in 1997?

498
00:59:12.764 --> 00:59:22.028
<v Unidentified speaker>But sometimes it's hard for us to piece together, but we usually have more recent coverage in that area that we can kind of point to and say, hey, this is where they were.

499
00:59:22.786 --> 00:59:26.407
<v Unidentified speaker>And these are the biggest things that we saw as relevant at that point.

500
00:59:26.711 --> 00:59:26.793
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

501
00:59:26.889 --> 00:59:32.304
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're trying to follow up with new work to kind of keep tabs on things.

502
00:59:32.481 --> 00:59:38.650
<v Unidentified speaker>Unfortunately, some of the challenges are so deeply rooted that some of the new work may look similar to some of the old work.

503
00:59:39.050 --> 00:59:39.403
<v Unidentified speaker>Absolutely.

504
00:59:39.452 --> 00:59:45.284
<v Unidentified speaker>And I don't wanna create a new body of work for you all to go have to dig through the archives to try and update things from the last 50 years.

505
00:59:46.358 --> 00:59:50.608
<v Unidentified speaker>But I do think it is noteworthy to some degree to demonstrate straight to the public, like, yes, we heard you.

506
00:59:50.688 --> 00:59:52.422
<v Unidentified speaker>The arts tax was not functioning.

507
00:59:52.599 --> 00:59:56.036
<v Unidentified speaker>And in response, the City Council made those changes.

508
00:59:56.389 --> 01:00:03.148
<v Unidentified speaker>And I know that when in the future, in, you know, 10 years, when another arts tax audit comes out, you will be able to go back and say, this is what we said back then.

509
01:00:03.454 --> 01:00:04.786
<v Unidentified speaker>This is the action that was taken.

510
01:00:04.898 --> 01:00:06.873
<v Unidentified speaker>These are the new problems that have developed since then.

511
01:00:07.628 --> 01:00:20.460
<v Unidentified speaker>But I do think it is important that the Auditor's Office isn't viewed as simply a a tattletale that just sort of points out problems, but also recognizes when the solutions have actually been met.

512
01:00:21.204 --> 01:00:26.077
<v Unidentified speaker>And genuinely, some of these improvements are because of the work that your teams have done.

513
01:00:26.141 --> 01:00:29.775
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I wanna thank you for the hard work that you all put in ahead of time to give us a path.

514
01:00:29.824 --> 01:00:31.157
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's the end of my questions.

515
01:00:31.271 --> 01:00:32.010
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair.

516
01:00:33.692 --> 01:00:34.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, President Dunphy.

517
01:00:34.967 --> 01:00:38.177
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll move on to Councilor Novick, followed by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

518
01:00:39.179 --> 01:00:39.679
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr.

519
01:00:39.728 --> 01:00:39.920
<v Steve Novick>Chair.

520
01:00:39.985 --> 01:00:41.389
<v Steve Novick>My questions are all for Jennifer.

521
01:00:42.326 --> 01:00:49.403
<v Steve Novick>The first one is, It was striking that the number of complaints you've heard has more than doubled in just a few years.

522
01:00:49.516 --> 01:00:52.844
<v Steve Novick>And I was just wondering if you have any thoughts about why that might be.

523
01:00:52.974 --> 01:00:55.137
<v Steve Novick>Have you been like advertising on bus benches?

524
01:00:55.233 --> 01:00:56.476
<v Steve Novick>Do you think people are just grumpier?

525
01:00:56.784 --> 01:00:58.204
<v Steve Novick>Has the city been behaving more badly?

526
01:00:58.300 --> 01:00:58.688
<v Steve Novick>What do you think?

527
01:01:01.818 --> 01:01:03.538
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think it's difficult to say.

528
01:01:03.762 --> 01:01:10.719
<v Rebecca Dobert>I would like to think that it is at least partly due to the office becoming better known as a result of outreach efforts.

529
01:01:11.155 --> 01:01:18.782
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think particularly among people living on the street, our number also gets passed around a lot, which is great.

530
01:01:18.927 --> 01:01:24.278
<v Rebecca Dobert>And that's a way that a lot of people hear about us is just through word of mouth.

531
01:01:24.615 --> 01:01:31.313
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I think, yeah, we also have been obviously trying to do outreach.

532
01:01:31.360 --> 01:01:38.139
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think whenever we have a report in the media, that tends to generate more public awareness.

533
01:01:38.945 --> 01:01:40.376
<v Rebecca Dobert>We start hearing from more people.

534
01:01:40.875 --> 01:01:44.108
<v Rebecca Dobert>We hear from people who've contacted us before.

535
01:01:44.333 --> 01:01:49.371
<v Rebecca Dobert>So there's also maybe that element of repeat customers.

536
01:01:49.628 --> 01:01:55.248
<v Rebecca Dobert>And yeah, hard to maybe pin down the exact reason.

537
01:01:55.586 --> 01:02:05.568
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think we wouldn't necessarily conclude that it's because there are more problems, but maybe people are becoming more engaged.

538
01:02:05.728 --> 01:02:07.605
<v Rebecca Dobert>That may be a broader trend.

539
01:02:08.934 --> 01:02:16.086
<v Rebecca Dobert>But yeah, there's probably not one reason, but definitely it's a trend that we've noticed.

540
01:02:16.150 --> 01:02:25.996
<v Rebecca Dobert>On one hand, I think we welcome it because it shows more people are advocating for themselves and looking for assistance with resolving their issues.

541
01:02:27.311 --> 01:02:27.824
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

542
01:02:28.498 --> 01:02:47.179
<v Steve Novick>Of the complaints you get about the police, Do you have any ideas as to what the breakdown is between complaints about too slow response to 911 calls, or police showed up and there was a crime and they didn't investigate it, versus the police beat somebody up, some sort of police misconduct?

543
01:02:51.635 --> 01:03:07.601
<v Rebecca Dobert>Well, I think all of those can be types of complaints that come to us about generally, with complaints of police misconduct, we would direct those to the independent police review since that's really what they're set up to do.

544
01:03:08.708 --> 01:03:16.793
<v Rebecca Dobert>We, yeah, that's not something we have really analyzed within police complaints exactly what they are about.

545
01:03:17.067 --> 01:03:21.157
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I don't really have that kind of breakdown handy.

546
01:03:21.463 --> 01:03:24.543
<v Rebecca Dobert>But yeah, it is indeed, as you said, a range.

547
01:03:24.590 --> 01:03:24.719
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

548
01:03:24.976 --> 01:03:33.791
<v Rebecca Dobert>Of things from response to, you know, an officer was rude or the police are not giving me back my property.

549
01:03:34.561 --> 01:03:35.797
<v Rebecca Dobert>So it's sort of all over the place.

550
01:03:37.275 --> 01:03:47.583
<v Steve Novick>And you probably have the same answer to this, and it's a small sample size, but I was just curious of the 20— you said it was 4% complaints about revenue, which I imagine would be like a couple dozen complaints.

551
01:03:48.114 --> 01:03:50.201
<v Steve Novick>And I was curious how many of those were about the arts tax.

552
01:03:51.630 --> 01:03:58.887
<v Rebecca Dobert>We actually did look at how many complaints there had been about the arts tax in response to a media request.

553
01:03:59.016 --> 01:04:05.085
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I, so we, I have that number and can share that with you if you're interested, but I don't have it off the top of my head.

554
01:04:06.079 --> 01:04:18.320
<v Rebecca Dobert>I would say it has been a fairly, you know, regular area of complaints, both with people who just dislike the tax and what it is.

555
01:04:18.498 --> 01:04:26.552
<v Rebecca Dobert>People who think they're being charged when they don't owe the tax, people who have paid and are still getting billed, those more technical issues.

556
01:04:26.697 --> 01:04:29.233
<v Rebecca Dobert>So a range of concerns about the arts tax.

557
01:04:29.572 --> 01:04:37.916
<v Rebecca Dobert>But yeah, we also get complaints about business tax and other revenue issues.

558
01:04:38.576 --> 01:04:43.143
<v Rebecca Dobert>And yeah, don't necessarily kind of break them down, have our own.

559
01:04:43.673 --> 01:04:44.536
<v Rebecca Dobert>We can do that analysis.

560
01:04:44.586 --> 01:04:44.652
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay.

561
01:04:45.677 --> 01:04:51.001
<v Rebecca Dobert>If we need to, but don't produce that on a regular basis, that kind of breakdown.

562
01:04:52.570 --> 01:04:52.938
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

563
01:04:54.192 --> 01:04:55.766
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

564
01:04:55.815 --> 01:04:57.967
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney will be followed by Councilor Green.

565
01:04:58.771 --> 01:05:03.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair, and thank you all for being here today and for the work that you do.

566
01:05:04.557 --> 01:05:06.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have just a couple of questions.

567
01:05:06.246 --> 01:05:12.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is, you mentioned an increase in complaints specifically from the homeless community.

568
01:05:13.186 --> 01:05:23.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I know that we've heard from the administration that there's been a concerted effort to post information about your number and the services available in some of our shelters.

569
01:05:23.878 --> 01:05:30.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did that increase in complaints correlate to when those numbers were posted, and we should assume that that is maybe the cause?

570
01:05:30.768 --> 01:05:52.650
<v Rebecca Dobert>Or had that increase started previously, and we should think about it as perhaps a So I think we started getting more of those kinds of complaints in 2024, but definitely with a big, much bigger, starting to get a much bigger volume last year.

571
01:05:52.858 --> 01:05:59.041
<v Rebecca Dobert>Well, probably they started more in 2023, but then have continued to grow in 2024 and 2025.

572
01:06:00.061 --> 01:06:01.391
<v Rebecca Dobert>We also did some outreach visits.

573
01:06:01.474 --> 01:06:01.523
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

574
01:06:01.610 --> 01:06:06.030
<v Rebecca Dobert>We did do some visits to the Safe Rest Village type shelters.

575
01:06:06.463 --> 01:06:14.333
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I think that helped to also get the word out both to shelter guests and staff at those sites.

576
01:06:15.300 --> 01:06:21.934
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I think having our posters up, leaving flyers around, probably also contributed.

577
01:06:23.148 --> 01:06:30.599
<v Rebecca Dobert>We haven't tracked necessarily that there was, you know, that there was an exact correlation to, because we don't always know exactly when the posters were posted.

578
01:06:30.731 --> 01:06:30.780
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay.

579
01:06:32.489 --> 01:06:33.204
<v Rebecca Dobert>Were put up.

580
01:06:33.302 --> 01:06:42.505
<v Rebecca Dobert>I, I think again word of mouth has a lot to do with it because that definitely, um, you know, we do hear from people when we ask how they found out about us.

581
01:06:42.586 --> 01:06:50.900
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sometimes people have said specifically from the, the posters, but often it's hearing from, uh, someone they know at the shelter who's been in touch with our office.

582
01:06:51.840 --> 01:06:52.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

583
01:06:55.228 --> 01:06:56.641
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, Madam Auditor, Thank you.

584
01:06:57.028 --> 01:07:36.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mayor, as we think about the important work of your office and kind of the ebb and flow of the budget in the city, on a theory level, do you think that the amount of work that your teams need to be able to perform is related to the size of our government, to the complexity of our government, complexity of our programs, or is there a baseline of audits and capacity for complaints that you need to be able to take that's unrelated to the size or scope of the rest of the work of the city?

585
01:07:37.456 --> 01:07:43.445
<v Loretta Smith>I would say that there is a relationship there, and of course I'd like to see things trending in the same direction.

586
01:07:43.492 --> 01:07:47.806
<v Loretta Smith>So as the city's budget grows, as its responsibilities thank you.

587
01:07:47.972 --> 01:07:52.992
<v Loretta Smith>As the city always expand or becomes more complex, I think my office should, should follow.

588
01:07:54.704 --> 01:08:03.400
<v Loretta Smith>We've historically been categorized as a large audit shop, and that's part of our reputation nationally as being a leader in the audit community.

589
01:08:04.402 --> 01:08:12.010
<v Loretta Smith>With the loss of one auditor, we're now a medium shop, and we'll see what that feels like to be compared to our peers in that category.

590
01:08:13.487 --> 01:08:21.418
<v Loretta Smith>Other auditors look at population size as a way to assess what is sufficient funding for their offices.

591
01:08:21.868 --> 01:08:30.940
<v Loretta Smith>So I think there's, there's not one way to get to what is the appropriate level of funding, but certainly trends that we'd like to see and a relationship that you identify.

592
01:08:31.887 --> 01:08:32.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

593
01:08:32.193 --> 01:08:32.481
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

594
01:08:32.529 --> 01:08:38.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That understanding that the trend line up and down should be related is helpful.

595
01:08:38.777 --> 01:08:48.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I know that as everybody faced budget cuts, that auditor was one of the things that you had said, if we have to make a cut, this is one we can make.

596
01:08:48.438 --> 01:08:53.677
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm glad that that puts us in the middle of the pack and not on the low end of our audit capacity.

597
01:08:53.757 --> 01:08:57.466
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's actually really heartening to hear, so thank you for offering that.

598
01:09:02.377 --> 01:09:23.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I wanna note that I was very pleased I was glad to see earlier this year the climate justice audit come out, and we're going to be looking at some of the city's climate work in the City Life Committee, and we'll certainly be using that, as many of my colleagues have talked about using your work as guides for what they do, using that as one of the things we look to as we think about what work the city has left to do.

599
01:09:24.055 --> 01:09:28.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So thank you for putting that out, and I will look forward to seeing the new topics tomorrow.

600
01:09:29.354 --> 01:09:29.595
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

601
01:09:30.805 --> 01:09:31.881
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

602
01:09:31.979 --> 01:09:35.078
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll move to Councilor Green, who will be followed by Councilor Ryan.

603
01:09:36.912 --> 01:09:37.725
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you, Chair Kanal.

604
01:09:39.296 --> 01:09:46.783
<v Mitch Green>Um, uh, Madam Auditor, I just want to thank you for, um, the focus on the street books archival projects.

605
01:09:46.944 --> 01:10:02.137
<v Mitch Green>I think that really spoke to me, uh, particularly because today, um, there was a— there's a really good article in the OPP today that talks about a person who lost their life in Old Town recently, who was a cherished member of a community served by Street Books.

606
01:10:03.956 --> 01:10:20.783
<v Mitch Green>And I think I'm going to try to do this without getting too emotional, but I think what's important about your project and the project of the Street Books archival work is it captures the lived experience and the life that these people live, which is unique.

607
01:10:21.042 --> 01:10:21.494
<v Mitch Green>It's important.

608
01:10:22.806 --> 01:10:36.636
<v Mitch Green>And they're not just like numbers of, you know, they're— we talk a lot about the homeless people, but having the homeless people talk about their own lives is extremely important, especially since it's such a big programmatic and budgetary focus of the City of Portland.

609
01:10:36.684 --> 01:10:38.141
<v Mitch Green>And so I just, I want to say thank you.

610
01:10:38.766 --> 01:10:44.920
<v Mitch Green>I know it comes at the expense of other things that the broader— you always have to make trade-offs with a scarce budget, right?

611
01:10:45.417 --> 01:10:51.462
<v Mitch Green>But the decision to prioritize that as a moment of important Portland history is noted.

612
01:10:52.362 --> 01:10:58.198
<v Mitch Green>And I think it really dovetails nicely with the project that OPB is trying to pursue on that as well.

613
01:10:59.472 --> 01:11:00.551
<v Mitch Green>So I needed to uplift that.

614
01:11:00.600 --> 01:11:02.595
<v Mitch Green>It's a constituent of mine that's not here anymore.

615
01:11:05.877 --> 01:11:06.666
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

616
01:11:06.746 --> 01:11:22.287
<v Mitch Green>I have some questions about the— so thanks for— Director Jones, thanks for the kind of overview on the audit I guess I do have sort of a general question about— I know that you get a lot of requests for audits.

617
01:11:22.337 --> 01:11:28.532
<v Mitch Green>I know that you get some requests for audits from councilors, and then you make sort of internal determinations on what the priority should be.

618
01:11:29.158 --> 01:11:37.167
<v Mitch Green>Roughly speaking, how many of those can you do as a share of the would you like to do kind of volume of projects?

619
01:11:37.475 --> 01:11:44.014
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, so in the We can add one last thing to this, the schedule.

620
01:11:44.061 --> 01:11:45.194
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it's important.

621
01:11:45.291 --> 01:11:49.608
<v Unidentified speaker>Like we usually have about 10 or 11 topics on the schedule.

622
01:11:49.898 --> 01:11:59.007
<v Unidentified speaker>Like I said, we try to kind of make sure those are spread across service areas so that we're maintaining some coverage.

623
01:12:00.382 --> 01:12:08.188
<v Unidentified speaker>We can kind of err on the larger or the more quantity side if some of those are Yeah.

624
01:12:08.252 --> 01:12:14.224
<v Unidentified speaker>Like maybe a little smaller, but we do try to tackle some of the city's kind of bigger challenges.

625
01:12:14.271 --> 01:12:19.650
<v Unidentified speaker>And sometimes those topics start as something very broad.

626
01:12:19.762 --> 01:12:27.805
<v Unidentified speaker>So Portland Solutions, emergency management, some of these things where we are starting with getting the lay of the land.

627
01:12:28.543 --> 01:12:41.590
<v Unidentified speaker>We may have, or it may have kind of risen to our risk level because we've heard a host of different And we're trying to figure out which of those we can focus on and maybe add the most value.

628
01:12:42.729 --> 01:13:01.146
<v Unidentified speaker>So I know with the topics that we're adding this year, they were as a result of us kind of paying attention to things the public told us they were interested in, things that we have been following for years, topics that are getting discussed in front of City Council.

629
01:13:02.671 --> 01:13:04.130
<v Unidentified speaker>The place where we try to—.

630
01:13:04.130 --> 01:13:04.573
<v Dan Ryan>I'm sorry.

631
01:13:07.948 --> 01:13:34.408
<v Unidentified speaker>Kind of dedicate our time is how can we add the most value, maybe make this an audit and not just a policy kind of like consideration, you know, weighing 3 or 4 different options, or if it is something that the council and the administration are already working out, especially in a public thank you.

632
01:13:34.471 --> 01:13:56.420
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think in terms of the public forum, that may not be the area where we're adding more, but a deeper dive, something that where greater accountability, transparency may be required, those are the sorts of things that may tip it for us, especially if it's something that has historically gone unaddressed or is a persistent problem.

633
01:13:57.559 --> 01:14:11.957
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of the challenges that we highlighted or kind of continue to highlight through transition around collaboration, cooperation, making sure bureaus are working more efficiently and better together.

634
01:14:12.744 --> 01:14:25.154
<v Unidentified speaker>Those are the sorts of things where I think an audit is the best tool for that, 'cause we're going to recommend how, where they should be aligning or focusing on common things.

635
01:14:26.229 --> 01:14:26.694
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

636
01:14:27.417 --> 01:14:40.377
<v Mitch Green>As we've been having this conversation and a couple of my colleagues have raised sort of, I think, almost a question of, you know, we're in this change of government and we had this government for a really long period of time.

637
01:14:40.440 --> 01:14:43.653
<v Mitch Green>And so the auditor's function has been really important through every step of the way.

638
01:14:44.198 --> 01:14:54.011
<v Mitch Green>I think my instinct is that because we are so new in this work, city councilors, the mayor, the city administrator, these are all new functions in a sense.

639
01:14:54.076 --> 01:15:11.570
<v Mitch Green>And so we're probably going to try some things and if we pass policies, they may not be a good idea, or we might try some things that we find out have unintended consequences as we kind of work through this, or we hear from the public that, you know, you're either on the right track or you're on the right track— wrong track.

640
01:15:12.068 --> 01:15:31.943
<v Mitch Green>And so I imagine that the work and the volume and the importance of the auditor function will need to probably be more resourced and probably have to pick up because because it's one thing to have a sort of, okay, we know what our kind of baseline level of pace and work kind of looks like, but that's our normal conditions.

641
01:15:32.618 --> 01:15:41.322
<v Mitch Green>And then boom, you hit a reset, there's a charter reform, and now you're in extraordinary conditions, for lack of a better set of terms here.

642
01:15:41.676 --> 01:16:06.510
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, as this council finds its oversight footing, there will be some of these questions of transparency that are raised that are probably more appropriate and so, I mean, we all— and I think we all received an email sort of in the middle of the budget from the auditor about sort of at the end of the day, it's council's decision on how to resource the auditor's function.

643
01:16:06.510 --> 01:16:16.850
<v Mitch Green>And so I just— I guess that's really for my colleagues, is just for us to think about as we go into the next budget, City Administrator Lee, as we go into the next budget, keeping in mind that we need to be forward-looking about how we're going to fund the auditor's function.

644
01:16:16.850 --> 01:16:16.890
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

645
01:16:17.769 --> 01:16:26.615
<v Mitch Green>On what we need to sort of prioritize for our city budget to have the capability that I think Portlanders are going to expect from the Auditor's Office.

646
01:16:26.824 --> 01:16:28.975
<v Mitch Green>Because you can only do so much with the resources you have.

647
01:16:29.024 --> 01:16:32.380
<v Mitch Green>And we've, you know, we've cut one position here, which comes at a cost.

648
01:16:33.680 --> 01:16:47.126
<v Mitch Green>And so, and I think, you know, when I go out in the community, have town halls, I hear a lot of questions about, you know, how what are you doing to make sure that we have faith in government and good stewardship of taxpayer dollars?

649
01:16:47.399 --> 01:16:51.372
<v Mitch Green>It's at the end of the day, it's making sure that we resource the auditor's function correctly.

650
01:16:52.189 --> 01:16:53.167
<v Mitch Green>I wanted to raise that up.

651
01:16:54.592 --> 01:16:57.396
<v Mitch Green>And then I think there's a connection.

652
01:16:57.636 --> 01:17:05.311
<v Mitch Green>Well, I don't know if there's a connection in your minds, but for me, I see a connection between the work that the ombudsman has done recently around the Urban Alchemy question.

653
01:17:05.744 --> 01:17:10.198
<v Mitch Green>There's some— the report, and then as well as kind of being the recipient of a volume of complaints.

654
01:17:11.661 --> 01:17:17.115
<v Mitch Green>That I do think is a structural uptick, probably has a set of reasons.

655
01:17:17.739 --> 01:17:26.359
<v Mitch Green>And then I wonder if that was a germane reason why Portland Solutions was identified as a priority audit, or was that sort of independent of that?

656
01:17:26.778 --> 01:17:41.529
<v Unidentified speaker>That would've predated, I think, some of the Urban Alchemy work, but we had certainly heard about Concerns about the kind of various programs that fall under that Portland Solutions umbrella.

657
01:17:42.171 --> 01:17:51.434
<v Unidentified speaker>For us, and since we do have 2 projects kind of going on in the same space, our teams are coordinating with each other.

658
01:17:52.747 --> 01:17:57.411
<v Unidentified speaker>For us, we're kind of recognizing that these things come from different places.

659
01:17:57.538 --> 01:18:01.529
<v Unidentified speaker>These are individual people having trouble and they're contacting the ombudsman.

660
01:18:01.609 --> 01:18:04.896
<v Unidentified speaker>To get those situations resolved.

661
01:18:05.329 --> 01:18:16.201
<v Unidentified speaker>We're starting with like, this is basically a new city function that was created out of a mix of things that preexisted and some existed in the mayor's office and that sort of thing.

662
01:18:17.211 --> 01:18:28.948
<v Unidentified speaker>So, you know, we're able to look at it as a strategic management sort of thing with a start and then figure out which area we can focus on deeper with an approach.

663
01:18:29.204 --> 01:18:29.396
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

664
01:18:30.006 --> 01:18:38.134
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're taking a look at the same thing maybe from 2 different directions and making sure we share information along the way.

665
01:18:39.399 --> 01:18:51.293
<v Unidentified speaker>In Audit Services, I think we know from working in the homelessness space on our audit of the Joint Office Shelter Program, the county was doing audit at the same time.

666
01:18:51.342 --> 01:18:52.224
<v Unidentified speaker>We coordinated.

667
01:18:52.319 --> 01:18:58.042
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, you don't want to retraumatize folks by having them kind of have to reshare their experiences.

668
01:18:58.860 --> 01:19:14.304
<v Unidentified speaker>You do not want to burden service providers So we're kind of seeking logical efficiencies there to lessen the burden on people who are just trying to get help.

669
01:19:15.029 --> 01:19:15.932
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

670
01:19:16.061 --> 01:19:26.868
<v Mitch Green>I think that my intuition was that probably because it is such a new function that sort of got cobbled together in an ad hoc fashion over the last few years, it makes sense to do an audit of this function.

671
01:19:26.970 --> 01:19:27.163
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

672
01:19:27.342 --> 01:19:32.250
<v Mitch Green>Especially since we've been funding it at a non-trivial level for a number of years.

673
01:19:34.369 --> 01:19:36.131
<v Mitch Green>You know, just wanted to draw that connection there.

674
01:19:36.827 --> 01:19:37.313
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

675
01:19:37.393 --> 01:19:38.524
<v Unidentified speaker>To the extent it's relevant.

676
01:19:38.686 --> 01:19:47.800
<v Unidentified speaker>Back to your first question, that's an area where, you know, we are thinking like, hey, what are the elements of this that like make it like good for an audit?

677
01:19:47.944 --> 01:19:56.970
<v Unidentified speaker>And like, hey, a new function that is a mix of things that maybe existed that maybe thank you.

678
01:19:56.970 --> 01:20:02.649
<v Mitch Green>I, um, you know, this, this body has to do oversight on, on the Urban Alchemy question just from a budgetary standpoint.

679
01:20:02.649 --> 01:20:03.689
<v Mitch Green>It's a $90 million contract.

680
01:20:04.510 --> 01:20:05.829
<v Mitch Green>It's largely exhausted.

681
01:20:05.829 --> 01:20:08.029
<v Mitch Green>And so that's our responsibility.

682
01:20:08.029 --> 01:20:13.069
<v Mitch Green>But just, just knowing that you're looking at the kind of structural side of the Portland Solutions piece is, is comforting to know.

683
01:20:13.069 --> 01:20:16.989
<v Mitch Green>And I, uh, I think that's all I have, Councilor.

684
01:20:16.989 --> 01:20:18.310
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Green.

685
01:20:18.310 --> 01:20:20.609
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll go to Councilor Ryan, and then I'm the last person on the agenda.

686
01:20:20.796 --> 01:20:22.534
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair.

687
01:20:23.640 --> 01:20:25.867
<v Dan Ryan>Good afternoon, Madam Auditor and team.

688
01:20:25.916 --> 01:20:26.858
<v Dan Ryan>It's great to have you here.

689
01:20:27.880 --> 01:20:31.722
<v Dan Ryan>Kind of following up on Councilor Green, you started going into the same area.

690
01:20:32.225 --> 01:20:38.220
<v Dan Ryan>I think we're all kind of scratching around the prioritization— prioritization— prioritization.

691
01:20:38.528 --> 01:20:39.576
<v Dan Ryan>I'm adding one syllable.

692
01:20:40.649 --> 01:20:41.006
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry.

693
01:20:43.167 --> 01:20:50.462
<v Dan Ryan>It's been clunky in my experience at times to figure out how those are selected, and you're the auditor's office, you're independent, I respect that.

694
01:20:50.800 --> 01:20:53.730
<v Dan Ryan>So you fundamentally get to make those calls.

695
01:20:54.229 --> 01:21:04.051
<v Dan Ryan>But I do think when you look at the data that we're presented with today, and now that we have an ombudsman, there is a more sophisticated complaint system.

696
01:21:04.827 --> 01:21:10.497
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'm trying to connect the dots between that and when we choose to make— when we choose to do an audit.

697
01:21:11.029 --> 01:21:12.725
<v Dan Ryan>So when you mentioned, for example, PBOT, Yeah.

698
01:21:13.305 --> 01:21:14.188
<v Dan Ryan>That was a good example.

699
01:21:14.988 --> 01:21:17.552
<v Dan Ryan>And the most recent one you did was with Vision Zero, correct?

700
01:21:17.712 --> 01:21:18.018
<v Candace Avalos>Mm-hmm.

701
01:21:18.755 --> 01:21:29.923
<v Dan Ryan>So I bet a lot of the calls on complaints that you see under transportation, which is the highest, they're probably— maybe some of them are definitely about pedestrian safety.

702
01:21:30.389 --> 01:21:34.314
<v Dan Ryan>I mean, you hear it every time you go out to the community about the need for more crosswalks and such.

703
01:21:34.939 --> 01:21:38.529
<v Dan Ryan>And then there's the big, you know, doesn't matter what city you live in, potholes.

704
01:21:39.488 --> 01:21:40.925
<v Dan Ryan>Local government equals potholes.

705
01:21:41.377 --> 01:21:54.384
<v Dan Ryan>So when's the last time there was a study on— even though PBOT's increased the number of employees quite a bit over the last decade, why is it that everyone's experiencing less services when it comes to potholes being filled?

706
01:21:56.189 --> 01:21:58.382
<v Dan Ryan>You don't have to answer that like you just did an audit.

707
01:21:58.770 --> 01:22:11.202
<v Dan Ryan>I'm just saying I'm trying to do the dot connection between what you're seeing here, what you're experiencing with the building of the Ombudsman office, yeah, thank you for the question, Vice Chair.

708
01:22:11.331 --> 01:22:20.247
<v Loretta Smith>I wanted to give Ombudsman Crofton an opportunity to speak to why the Transportation Bureau tops the list of complaints, the kind of things that you see.

709
01:22:22.649 --> 01:22:47.939
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah, again, I think it covers the gamut of issues that PBOT works on, including potholes, street conditions, Lighting, I think, and a lot of those types of issues, we will basically just direct people to where, for example, they can report a pothole or file a risk claim if they've experienced damage due to a pothole.

710
01:22:49.033 --> 01:22:57.158
<v Rebecca Dobert>Towing of vehicles has consistently been a high area with a lot of complaints to our office.

711
01:22:57.846 --> 01:23:02.399
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, but also including lived-in vehicles.

712
01:23:02.927 --> 01:23:08.170
<v Rebecca Dobert>So we, we do work on quite a few of those types of cases.

713
01:23:09.340 --> 01:23:16.248
<v Rebecca Dobert>More in terms of a more— we've looked also more systemically at a couple issues with PBOT.

714
01:23:16.939 --> 01:23:38.465
<v Rebecca Dobert>One was a report we published, which I mentioned when I presented here last fall, which was looking at private request tows, which the police can order, but they're covered under the— or not covered, sorry, under PBOT's contract.

715
01:23:38.529 --> 01:23:47.404
<v Rebecca Dobert>So tow companies basically, although most follow the contract prices, we found that one company didn't.

716
01:23:47.533 --> 01:23:49.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so some people who yes.

717
01:23:49.922 --> 01:23:56.222
<v Rebecca Dobert>Had experienced a collision or breakdown, which are usually the circumstances when police order that type of tow.

718
01:23:57.457 --> 01:24:01.993
<v Rebecca Dobert>They had the bad luck to get this company that wasn't following the contract prices.

719
01:24:02.105 --> 01:24:17.511
<v Rebecca Dobert>So in that case, we recommended that some solution be found to that issue so that people were not, yeah, some people would not be charged much more just because of which tow company happened to be called.

720
01:24:17.574 --> 01:24:21.326
<v Rebecca Dobert>So that I guess is an example where we looked at a okay.

721
01:24:21.775 --> 01:24:24.680
<v Rebecca Dobert>So that's a broader PBOT issue, in that case, both PBOT and police.

722
01:24:25.980 --> 01:24:48.229
<v Rebecca Dobert>Also, we're planning to follow up soon a report we had done about how PBOT enforces safety regulations for tour buses, where we found some issues with how those regulations were, or were not necessarily being adequately enforced.

723
01:24:48.856 --> 01:24:55.511
<v Rebecca Dobert>Up in the next couple months about what's happened with our recommendations on that topic.

724
01:24:56.917 --> 01:24:57.206
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

725
01:24:57.270 --> 01:25:03.130
<v Dan Ryan>So do you take the data then from the complaints and then you two talk to each other?

726
01:25:03.739 --> 01:25:03.819
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

727
01:25:03.868 --> 01:25:12.117
<v Unidentified speaker>So we, as we're developing the audit schedule, interface with all of our kind of external-facing.

728
01:25:12.166 --> 01:25:17.844
<v Unidentified speaker>So ombudsman, elections, and lobbying takes complaints, and then we We take tips through the fraud hotline.

729
01:25:18.356 --> 01:25:24.207
<v Unidentified speaker>So those are elements where we would incorporate that feedback into that risk analysis.

730
01:25:25.250 --> 01:25:33.873
<v Unidentified speaker>We are also putting those topics out to the public to say, hey, what's most important to you out of this?

731
01:25:34.530 --> 01:25:35.668
<v Unidentified speaker>In that broad—.

732
01:25:36.054 --> 01:25:36.229
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

733
01:25:36.295 --> 01:25:49.524
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, with that broad question, recognizing that people are coming to the ombudsman maybe with a specific issue and lobbying in elections with a specific issue and not getting asked more broadly, what's important to you?

734
01:25:50.118 --> 01:25:51.180
<v Dan Ryan>And there's also 2 more.

735
01:25:51.323 --> 01:25:54.328
<v Dan Ryan>Since I've been here, the 311's really grown.

736
01:25:54.440 --> 01:25:54.747
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

737
01:25:55.068 --> 01:26:01.972
<v Dan Ryan>And I, I know that people that utilize that service tend to call it when they have more nuanced complaints.

738
01:26:02.615 --> 01:26:05.103
<v Dan Ryan>You also have obviously a different form of government.

739
01:26:05.231 --> 01:26:17.779
<v Dan Ryan>So in this form of government, we should be more of an asset to all of you because we are geographically aligned and we're out more in the community than the other form of government because you have the capacity to do that.

740
01:26:18.103 --> 01:26:19.639
<v Dan Ryan>We're not in here meeting all the time.

741
01:26:20.123 --> 01:26:22.599
<v Dan Ryan>And so you get more readily information.

742
01:26:22.779 --> 01:26:33.440
<v Dan Ryan>So I hope that— I know when in the former government it was like, okay, I have BDS, I need to understand every permit, every permit audit that you've done.

743
01:26:34.104 --> 01:26:39.932
<v Dan Ryan>And Council President was right, there was one done in '19, whatever that was, but there was also one done in 2021.

744
01:26:40.033 --> 01:26:40.201
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

745
01:26:40.645 --> 01:26:40.822
<v Steve Novick>Right.

746
01:26:41.207 --> 01:26:49.136
<v Dan Ryan>And the reason I asked for the ones prior to that, because I was noticing that nothing happened with all of those audits prior to 2021.

747
01:26:49.199 --> 01:26:53.966
<v Dan Ryan>I'm proud to say that this commissioner took the '21 audit and did something with it.

748
01:26:54.046 --> 01:26:55.042
<v Dan Ryan>We built the task force.

749
01:26:55.185 --> 01:27:05.698
<v Dan Ryan>We definitely got to the place where we brought them together, and now we're still dealing with growing pains, but we took action based on the problem that was stated in the 2021 audit.

750
01:27:06.100 --> 01:27:11.052
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that's what Council President's getting at is for our own accountability to look at those audits.

751
01:27:11.166 --> 01:27:13.948
<v Dan Ryan>And when you're a commissioner overseeing a bureau, you asked for those audits.

752
01:27:14.510 --> 01:27:18.247
<v Dan Ryan>Now we're dealing with all of the bureaus as more of an advocate.

753
01:27:18.604 --> 01:27:19.882
<v Dan Ryan>So it's a different stance.

754
01:27:20.190 --> 01:27:23.185
<v Dan Ryan>And I hope that we can figure out how to bring that into fruition.

755
01:27:25.145 --> 01:27:27.426
<v Dan Ryan>I do want to give you one idea.

756
01:27:27.506 --> 01:27:30.764
<v Dan Ryan>I haven't seen anything on here about PHB.

757
01:27:33.239 --> 01:27:38.199
<v Dan Ryan>And the startling information that everyone's talking about is the vacancy rate.

758
01:27:38.894 --> 01:27:45.158
<v Dan Ryan>And our public housing is definitely an issue that's burning right now.

759
01:27:45.755 --> 01:27:55.570
<v Dan Ryan>And so I hope that, that you're all taking that in because we're definitely going to be on the hook on a lot of different levels with that, with these high vacancy rates with our public housing.

760
01:27:55.828 --> 01:27:56.279
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

761
01:27:59.069 --> 01:28:00.338
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

762
01:28:01.640 --> 01:28:03.279
<v Sameer Kanal>I am last in the queue.

763
01:28:04.226 --> 01:28:09.335
<v Sameer Kanal>So I, first I wanted to say thanks for the information about archives.

764
01:28:10.154 --> 01:28:22.171
<v Sameer Kanal>I thought the oral history project and the digital timeline were both really interesting, and I intend to follow up on similar methodologically to what Councilor Koyama Lane was talking about in terms of asking for some support there.

765
01:28:23.520 --> 01:28:25.274
<v Sameer Kanal>It actually a very similar context for Yeah.

766
01:28:25.372 --> 01:28:28.332
<v Sameer Kanal>For a different community than the one you— the example you gave.

767
01:28:31.182 --> 01:28:42.072
<v Sameer Kanal>In doing the sort of back-of-envelope math, the increase in the number of complaints from people that are houseless from last year to this year is the increase in number of complaints total.

768
01:28:42.957 --> 01:28:45.648
<v Sameer Kanal>Like, there's 150-ish more of both.

769
01:28:47.306 --> 01:28:50.456
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I just wanted to contextualize that.

770
01:28:51.168 --> 01:28:59.417
<v Sameer Kanal>If you looked by in terms of the just doing the percentages to the totals here, that's really fascinating.

771
01:28:59.481 --> 01:29:01.279
<v Sameer Kanal>And I guess it opens up a lot of questions.

772
01:29:01.344 --> 01:29:08.796
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to, do you disaggregate where those folks are, whether they're houseless and unsheltered, whether they're in a sheltering system?

773
01:29:09.123 --> 01:29:10.234
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you disaggregate that?

774
01:29:12.729 --> 01:29:22.997
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah, well, one thing I would say is that that percentage of people whose housing status was houseless.

775
01:29:23.659 --> 01:29:27.342
<v Rebecca Dobert>Basically, we have that— we don't have that information for all complainants.

776
01:29:27.471 --> 01:29:35.275
<v Rebecca Dobert>We only were able to collect demographic information on about, I think, a little less than half of complainants last year.

777
01:29:37.048 --> 01:29:43.820
<v Rebecca Dobert>So that wouldn't necessarily— that 36%, I think it was 36% I mentioned, isn't necessarily 36% of the total.

778
01:29:43.868 --> 01:29:48.076
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's out of people who we had some information about their housing status.

779
01:29:48.155 --> 01:30:01.695
<v Rebecca Dobert>But yes, I think definitely that's correct that, you know, part of that 32% increase we had last year was due to this high volume of complaints from shelter guests.

780
01:30:02.256 --> 01:30:18.740
<v Rebecca Dobert>That breakdown as to whether people are, you know, completely unsheltered or in a vehicle or at a shelter isn't something we tracked separately, but it would be captured in the complaint record.

781
01:30:19.576 --> 01:30:27.233
<v Rebecca Dobert>You know, I think it would be something we would be able to see in the substance of the complaint.

782
01:30:27.360 --> 01:30:39.256
<v Rebecca Dobert>But we, in terms of what we're tracking and then can, you know, analyze at the end of the year, that's just, you know, whether someone owns or rents or is in temporary housing or is houseless.

783
01:30:39.320 --> 01:30:39.417
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

784
01:30:43.606 --> 01:30:45.220
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that's helpful.

785
01:30:45.301 --> 01:31:09.210
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, at the risk of asking for more, I think it might be really helpful for us to know of that percentage, are we getting more complaints per capita or even just on an aggregate level from folks who are in a shelter operated by a specific provider Or multiple specific providers?

786
01:31:10.529 --> 01:31:14.886
<v Sameer Kanal>We contract with several, and I think if that— that's a data point that I think would be helpful to know.

787
01:31:15.912 --> 01:31:28.974
<v Sameer Kanal>And it opens up a different question that I'm not sure who is the best person to ask, which is, you know, we— and this kind of builds on something Councilor Green was talking about— we hold oversight hearings here.

788
01:31:29.103 --> 01:31:31.757
<v Sameer Kanal>We're going to have one on our shelter program.

789
01:31:31.805 --> 01:31:31.854
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

790
01:31:32.677 --> 01:31:33.319
<v Sameer Kanal>At least one of them.

791
01:31:33.497 --> 01:31:35.792
<v Sameer Kanal>That's inevitable at some point.

792
01:31:36.048 --> 01:31:41.939
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll probably have one on Home Forward or something like that in the future.

793
01:31:42.470 --> 01:31:56.435
<v Sameer Kanal>How would you like it— how would you like us to incorporate into the sort of starting point level-setting information that we provide to the public and to each other the work of the Auditor's Office?

794
01:31:56.515 --> 01:32:08.199
<v Sameer Kanal>How would you like those oversight hearings to inform because I'm hearing, KC, you mentioned if it's something that the council and the administration are already working out, that may not be the area where we're adding more.

795
01:32:08.953 --> 01:32:13.689
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that may be the case, but sometimes it's actually you're a force multiplier for it.

796
01:32:14.105 --> 01:32:21.985
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I would love to figure out how we make that work together as we go forward on these oversight processes.

797
01:32:22.211 --> 01:32:23.751
<v Loretta Smith>I can respond to that, Chair.

798
01:32:24.842 --> 01:32:30.453
<v Loretta Smith>I was going to say that Number one, we want you to use the work that we have published.

799
01:32:30.533 --> 01:32:37.426
<v Loretta Smith>That's rigorous work that has undergone rigorous quality control.

800
01:32:38.627 --> 01:32:47.234
<v Loretta Smith>I think we are interested in our continuous risk assessment to understand what changes are affecting programs that we might look into in the future.

801
01:32:47.699 --> 01:32:58.018
<v Loretta Smith>So understanding, like watching those hearings and understanding what the outcomes are can help us figure out which lane Or where we can be to provide value.

802
01:32:59.800 --> 01:33:01.623
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I was going to agree with your point.

803
01:33:02.091 --> 01:33:22.034
<v Unidentified speaker>It may— knowing that it's something that's maybe already being worked on is not something that necessarily precludes us from doing it, but may shift our focus to some of those more structural elements like I was talking about with Councilor Green, or strategic elements kind of higher-level things.

804
01:33:23.582 --> 01:33:23.841
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

805
01:33:23.921 --> 01:33:32.778
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, my big broader point here is please don't let us discussing it be an inhibiting factor in an even subconscious way.

806
01:33:32.875 --> 01:33:38.359
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's actually sometimes really beneficial, and I think we can probably figure that out case by case.

807
01:33:39.380 --> 01:33:49.774
<v Sameer Kanal>More than that, Councilor Novick's question on— sorry, Councilor Novick's question on slide 12, which has the bars for different parts of it.

808
01:33:49.962 --> 01:34:00.863
<v Sameer Kanal>Just for context here, your question about the police complaints, it doesn't take into account, this number doesn't include complaints that only go to IPR and CRC and Internal Affairs and all that, right?

809
01:34:01.119 --> 01:34:03.720
<v Sameer Kanal>Like this is just the ones that come in the front door here.

810
01:34:04.154 --> 01:34:07.734
<v Sameer Kanal>Does it include the ones that you refer onto them and take no further action on?

811
01:34:08.890 --> 01:34:10.175
<v Rebecca Dobert>It would, yeah, yeah.

812
01:34:10.255 --> 01:34:24.810
<v Rebecca Dobert>This would be anything that sort of comes in our door that is about the police, including complaints that we referred to IPR, or if people have— it could include people have been to IPR, are not satisfied with that outcome, and then come to us.

813
01:34:24.875 --> 01:34:32.640
<v Rebecca Dobert>So this is everything that, that's come into us, but not something that has come into IPR and not come to us.

814
01:34:33.136 --> 01:34:33.842
<v Sameer Kanal>Great.

815
01:34:33.922 --> 01:34:36.810
<v Sameer Kanal>That, that second piece would be, uh, very good to know.

816
01:34:36.971 --> 01:34:42.104
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I might ask for disaggregation on that too, just as we pivot into the new system.

817
01:34:44.827 --> 01:34:45.585
<v Sameer Kanal>Awesome.

818
01:34:47.244 --> 01:34:53.595
<v Sameer Kanal>On the— do you have the information, switching gears to the 2 slides later, on the short-term accessory rentals?

819
01:34:56.006 --> 01:34:56.771
<v Sameer Kanal>2 Questions on that.

820
01:34:56.820 --> 01:35:00.862
<v Sameer Kanal>One is for you, one will be for Chair Avalos, I think, or perhaps others.

821
01:35:02.010 --> 01:35:04.435
<v Sameer Kanal>But when— do you have a comparison?

822
01:35:05.097 --> 01:35:07.588
<v Sameer Kanal>You compare the first-time violator maximum fine.

823
01:35:08.520 --> 01:35:13.265
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you have comparisons that are on the median fine actually levied or any of those types of information?

824
01:35:13.378 --> 01:35:21.329
<v Sameer Kanal>Or is it just that— is it that our range is just giant, or is it that we're actually levying at that high end, the fines?

825
01:35:24.264 --> 01:35:39.170
<v Rebecca Dobert>Well, yeah, this— my colleague who did the investigation really sort of got more into looking at the other cities' types types of fines, so maybe would be a better place to answer the specific question.

826
01:35:39.265 --> 01:35:46.478
<v Rebecca Dobert>But I think part of it is that under the rules in Portland, there are multiple types of violations.

827
01:35:46.605 --> 01:35:48.726
<v Rebecca Dobert>So you can be fined for not having a permit.

828
01:35:49.626 --> 01:35:57.239
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can be fined for advertising more rooms or for more guests than your permit allows.

829
01:35:57.416 --> 01:36:03.087
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can be fined for actually you know, renting out for— to too many people.

830
01:36:03.152 --> 01:36:15.783
<v Rebecca Dobert>So that's how the fines add up, is— and people can be fined, um, I think it's basically 5 separate, uh, times, but as a first— for the first time that they're fined, basically.

831
01:36:16.139 --> 01:36:24.935
<v Rebecca Dobert>So the individual amounts for the individual violation are, you know, several thousand, but then it adds up, and that's why it becomes the $27,000.

832
01:36:25.853 --> 01:36:36.083
<v Sameer Kanal>Right, but is that actually happening, or is this a theoretical exercise of if hypothetically all 5 were found and all 5 were levied at the max amount, it would add up to this?

833
01:36:36.693 --> 01:36:43.140
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, people have been fined that maximum amount and not received prior warning that they were in violation.

834
01:36:43.796 --> 01:36:52.394
<v Sameer Kanal>And there's— and this is the— I would love to know if there's data on what the actual median is, let's say, because it sounds like there's some yeah.

835
01:36:52.475 --> 01:37:00.895
<v Sameer Kanal>Possibility that it could be a lesser amount than this on a first-time violator, and probably the same for these other 4 cities as well, is kind of what I'm getting at there.

836
01:37:01.347 --> 01:37:10.935
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the 2 parts that the administration referred on to council, and this is the question that might be better for my colleagues, is there a timeline for when those are coming to council or to committee?

837
01:37:11.275 --> 01:37:11.923
<v Sameer Kanal>Does anyone know?

838
01:37:14.724 --> 01:37:24.233
<v Sameer Kanal>The specific comment was that the administration referred to council Council the changing of the rules and the reduction of fines, but took on the warning process directly.

839
01:37:24.988 --> 01:37:33.704
<v Sameer Kanal>And so for those 2 pieces that were referred on to council, are those penciled in anywhere for a— I don't know if they're at— okay, uh, Council President, have those been assigned to a committee?

840
01:37:36.649 --> 01:37:38.729
<v Unidentified speaker>Nothing's been filed yet, so I haven't seen anything yet.

841
01:37:39.083 --> 01:37:39.502
<v Sameer Kanal>Got it.

842
01:37:39.712 --> 01:37:41.065
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, good to, good to know.

843
01:37:41.113 --> 01:37:41.501
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

844
01:37:42.048 --> 01:37:44.225
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'll skip ahead.

845
01:37:44.908 --> 01:37:53.087
<v Sameer Kanal>I am super interested in your last slide in learning about the 911 and emergency communications audit, the gun violence reduction audit, the citywide equity audit, the Portland Solutions audit.

846
01:37:53.150 --> 01:37:55.076
<v Sameer Kanal>We talked about these, I know, in the past.

847
01:37:55.541 --> 01:38:06.012
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd love to see some information on, as you do the citywide equity, that's the first of this type of part of the administration.

848
01:38:06.605 --> 01:38:12.925
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd love to know how that informs looking at engagement in particular in the future, our core values broadly.

849
01:38:13.278 --> 01:38:16.497
<v Sameer Kanal>I imagine there will be a lot of recommendations in all of these?

850
01:38:18.150 --> 01:38:26.456
<v Sameer Kanal>You mentioned that there's been no, you've not reduced the number of audits that are underway as a result of budget cuts.

851
01:38:26.537 --> 01:38:35.927
<v Sameer Kanal>Have there been any reductions in the resources devoted to any of these 6 audits as a result of the budget, or will there be when this budget takes effect if approved as is?

852
01:38:36.685 --> 01:38:44.134
<v Unidentified speaker>Not as the result of, The budget.

853
01:38:45.502 --> 01:38:57.141
<v Unidentified speaker>We had a reassignment within this, but it has just been somebody cycling off of one project onto another.

854
01:38:58.681 --> 01:39:04.643
<v Unidentified speaker>And like I said, like it's typically easier for us to just add one fewer thing to the schedule.

855
01:39:04.707 --> 01:39:07.856
<v Unidentified speaker>Folks usually work in teams of one or 2 people.

856
01:39:08.000 --> 01:39:17.045
<v Unidentified speaker>So it just means we would commit to one fewer thing in the next fiscal year.

857
01:39:18.041 --> 01:39:21.752
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that's good to know because I think these are particularly important.

858
01:39:21.896 --> 01:39:22.024
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

859
01:39:22.538 --> 01:39:24.853
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, that concludes my questions.

860
01:39:24.948 --> 01:39:27.956
<v Sameer Kanal>Colleagues, we do have this as a report.

861
01:39:28.502 --> 01:39:33.298
<v Sameer Kanal>And so the action under consideration would be whether or not to refer it.

862
01:39:33.891 --> 01:39:37.838
<v Sameer Kanal>I request a motion to refer to council with a recommendation to accept.

863
01:39:38.130 --> 01:39:38.355
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

864
01:39:38.743 --> 01:39:41.478
<v Sameer Kanal>Moved by Councilor Ryan, seconded by Councilor Clark.

865
01:39:42.448 --> 01:39:45.332
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, is there any discussion further on that motion?

866
01:39:47.962 --> 01:39:49.893
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing none, Rebecca, will you please call the roll?

867
01:39:51.576 --> 01:39:53.474
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Chair, Auditor, do you want to speak to this?

868
01:39:53.586 --> 01:39:54.856
<v Rebecca Dobert>I believe there was no action.

869
01:39:55.130 --> 01:39:59.054
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, well, I'm looking at the, the way this appears on the committee agenda.

870
01:39:59.134 --> 01:40:05.972
<v Loretta Smith>It is It is a report in name, but it is truly just a presentation and a share, so you don't have to take any action on this.

871
01:40:06.887 --> 01:40:10.051
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that will save the full council some time then.

872
01:40:10.645 --> 01:40:12.765
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thank you to Councilors Ryan and Clark anyway.

873
01:40:13.134 --> 01:40:15.189
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so we're—.

874
01:40:15.413 --> 01:40:17.677
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'll just clarify, the item will be placed on file.

875
01:40:18.994 --> 01:40:19.332
<v Christopher>Great.

876
01:40:20.279 --> 01:40:21.692
<v Sameer Kanal>Well, thank you so much for being here.

877
01:40:21.965 --> 01:40:22.703
<v Sameer Kanal>Appreciate it.

878
01:40:22.944 --> 01:40:24.838
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that concludes this item then, right?

879
01:40:26.541 --> 01:40:26.717
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

880
01:40:26.894 --> 01:40:28.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, it does not.

881
01:40:29.109 --> 01:40:30.009
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, well, thank you.

882
01:40:30.090 --> 01:40:30.957
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you all 3.

883
01:40:31.438 --> 01:40:36.592
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we do have one item further on the agenda, but we are going to take a short break first.

884
01:40:36.817 --> 01:40:41.377
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we'll come back in 10 minutes, so, uh, see you back at 3:45.

885
01:40:41.649 --> 01:40:42.148
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

886
01:54:52.020 --> 01:54:52.310
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

887
01:54:52.472 --> 01:54:57.677
<v Sameer Kanal>It is— thank you for the extra few minutes that, that, uh, were taken in this.

888
01:54:57.806 --> 01:54:59.542
<v Sameer Kanal>We're now back in session.

889
01:55:00.380 --> 01:55:03.801
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, as our— Rebecca, would you please call the 3rd item?

890
01:55:07.277 --> 01:55:14.876
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 3, appoint members to the Portland Clean Energy Community Benefits Fund Committee, document number 2026-208.

891
01:55:15.970 --> 01:55:16.212
<v Christopher>Great.

892
01:55:16.389 --> 01:55:25.212
<v Sameer Kanal>And, uh, I believe we have Presenters, uh, Sam Barrasso, PCF Program Manager, and Rafael Tamarchi, who's our PCF External Affairs Manager.

893
01:55:25.796 --> 01:55:27.494
<v Sameer Kanal>As they're coming up, I just want to thank you for your patience.

894
01:55:28.000 --> 01:55:32.090
<v Sameer Kanal>Normally we would put something involving volunteer appointments first on the agenda.

895
01:55:32.315 --> 01:55:38.542
<v Sameer Kanal>We wanted to be respectful of our independently elected colleague, the auditor, as well, so we put her first today.

896
01:55:39.029 --> 01:55:42.935
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate you all being here, and please feel free to take it away whenever you're ready.

897
01:55:49.438 --> 01:55:49.648
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

898
01:55:49.890 --> 01:55:51.323
<v Sameer Kanal>Good afternoon, council members.

899
01:55:52.645 --> 01:55:58.333
<v Sameer Kanal>My name— for the record, my name is Sam Brosso, program manager for the Portland Clean Energy Community Benefits Fund at the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

900
01:55:58.592 --> 01:56:07.398
<v Sameer Kanal>And we're here to talk to you today about the PCEF committee, specifically about some of the newest members recommended here for appointment to the committee as well as reappointment.

901
01:56:08.166 --> 01:56:13.369
<v Sameer Kanal>So today's presenters are presentation here will be brief but plentiful here.

902
01:56:13.820 --> 01:56:26.743
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll give you an overview on the committee's role, then we'll talk about the recruitment process, and then last we'll talk about the recommended appointees as well as reappointees for your confirmation.

903
01:56:27.002 --> 01:56:34.015
<v Sameer Kanal>And we've got Danielle Walker here with us, one of the candidates, and then we've got a few of our folks that will be joining online as they are traveling.

904
01:56:35.402 --> 01:56:39.865
<v Sameer Kanal>And so with that, I'm gonna go ahead and turn over to my colleague Rafael Tamarki to take us from there.

905
01:56:41.560 --> 01:56:41.865
<v Rafael Tamarki>Thank you, Sam.

906
01:56:41.979 --> 01:56:43.463
<v Rafael Tamarki>For the record, my name is Rafael Tamarki.

907
01:56:43.511 --> 01:56:44.592
<v Rafael Tamarki>I use he/him pronouns.

908
01:56:44.658 --> 01:56:46.641
<v Rafael Tamarki>I'm the external affairs manager for PCEF.

909
01:56:47.078 --> 01:56:51.726
<v Rafael Tamarki>I wanna thank you all for the opportunity to present today regarding appointments and reappointments to the PCEF committee.

910
01:56:52.551 --> 01:56:58.036
<v Rafael Tamarki>So before discussing appointments, I just wanna briefly ground the PCEF committee's purpose and role.

911
01:56:58.942 --> 01:56:59.895
<v Rafael Tamarki>Go to the next slide, please.

912
01:57:00.391 --> 01:57:12.141
<v Rafael Tamarki>Forgive me if this is perfunctory or this is information that you already know, but PSET began as a community-led ballot initiative approved by 65% of Portland voters in 2018.

913
01:57:12.639 --> 01:57:26.168
<v Rafael Tamarki>The measure established a dedicated funding source for climate action funded through a surcharge on large retailers, those who make $1 billion nationwide and $500 million locally, while exempting essential goods such as groceries, medicine, and utilities.

914
01:57:26.961 --> 01:57:35.270
<v Rafael Tamarki>Following voter approval, City Council codified PSEF into Chapter 7.07 of City Code, simultaneously establishing both the fund and the PSEF Committee.

915
01:57:36.010 --> 01:57:41.719
<v Rafael Tamarki>So the committee exists because voters and Council established it as a part of PSEF's accountability and governance structure.

916
01:57:42.202 --> 01:57:42.636
<v Rafael Tamarki>Next slide, please.

917
01:57:44.270 --> 01:57:49.176
<v Rafael Tamarki>So under City Code, the PSEF Committee is a 9-member advisory body appointed by the mayor and confirmed by City Council.

918
01:57:49.670 --> 01:57:55.987
<v Rafael Tamarki>Members serve staggered 4-year terms, which— bless you— provides continuity and institutional knowledge over time.

919
01:57:56.051 --> 01:57:56.164
<v Rafael Tamarki>Thank you.

920
01:57:56.670 --> 01:57:57.585
<v Rafael Tamarki>Bless you.

921
01:57:58.789 --> 01:58:05.824
<v Rafael Tamarki>The committee recommends and advises on the climate investment plan, which is the 5-year blueprint for the allocation of resources from the fund.

922
01:58:06.645 --> 01:58:15.382
<v Rafael Tamarki>And the committee also evaluates implementation and program effectiveness through the annual CIP amendment process to help ensure investments align with program goals and community priorities.

923
01:58:16.636 --> 01:58:24.715
<v Rafael Tamarki>Importantly, I think the committee brings a diversity of perspectives, lived experience, and technical expertise related to climate, workforce, energy, and community development.

924
01:58:24.908 --> 01:58:26.591
<v Rafael Tamarki>Next slide, please.

925
01:58:27.311 --> 01:58:46.095
<v Rafael Tamarki>So just drilling down a little bit further, the committee's responsibilities include reviewing and helping establish methodologies to evaluate PCEF's effectiveness, adopting workforce and contractor equity plans for funded projects, and making recommendations to council regarding the climate investment plan amendments and potential code changes.

926
01:58:46.863 --> 01:58:54.636
<v Rafael Tamarki>So while PCEF committee has an important advisory function, any major funding policy or climate investment plan decisions ultimately come before council.

927
01:58:54.750 --> 01:58:54.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

928
01:58:54.770 --> 01:58:54.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

929
01:58:54.770 --> 01:58:54.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

930
01:58:54.789 --> 01:58:59.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for this opportunity to report before this City Council.

931
01:58:59.170 --> 01:59:02.340
<v Rafael Tamarki>Committee members bring a wide range of expertise and experience.

932
01:59:02.489 --> 01:59:20.500
<v Rafael Tamarki>This is a list of the areas of expertise, both residential and commercial renewable energy and energy efficiency, transportation decarbonization, workforce development, minority-owned and women-owned business support, regenerative agriculture and green infrastructure, green financing, and experience with Native American communities and tribal relations.

933
01:59:20.510 --> 01:59:31.506
<v Rafael Tamarki>So the goal is not not uniformity, but a balanced committee capable of bringing multiple perspectives to the complex decisions we often find in front of us.

934
01:59:32.484 --> 01:59:36.560
<v Rafael Tamarki>And this is the current roster for the PCEF committee, including their terms and areas of expertise.

935
01:59:36.752 --> 01:59:41.453
<v Rafael Tamarki>We had 2 members term off last summer and another resigned during that same time.

936
01:59:41.951 --> 01:59:49.002
<v Rafael Tamarki>And those 3 committee members brought subject area expertise in residential energy efficiency, workforce development, And general climate knowledge.

937
01:59:49.068 --> 01:59:51.301
<v Rafael Tamarki>And so this recruitment sought to fill those gaps.

938
01:59:54.770 --> 01:59:59.427
<v Rafael Tamarki>With that, I would like to walk us through the recruitment and the selection process that we used to identify candidates.

939
02:00:01.606 --> 02:00:03.854
<v Rafael Tamarki>And here's the recruitment process timeline.

940
02:00:04.305 --> 02:00:06.423
<v Rafael Tamarki>It was a competitive and structured recruitment process.

941
02:00:06.698 --> 02:00:08.168
<v Rafael Tamarki>It was open for about 6 months.

942
02:00:08.829 --> 02:00:14.159
<v Rafael Tamarki>We received 67 applications for the 3 open positions, and that I think reflects strong community interest in serving Thank you.

943
02:00:14.159 --> 02:00:14.159
<v Rafael Tamarki>Thank you, Mayor.

944
02:00:14.159 --> 02:00:14.159
<v Rafael Tamarki>I'm pleased to report that the committee has completed its review of the applications for the PCEFC Committee.

945
02:00:14.159 --> 02:00:14.159
<v Rafael Tamarki>We received 26 applications for the position.

946
02:00:14.159 --> 02:00:16.140
<v Rafael Tamarki>18 Of those were selected for further review by the PCEFC Committee on this particular committee.

947
02:00:16.140 --> 02:00:32.920
<v Rafael Tamarki>Applications were then reviewed by staff and PCEFC Committee's Recruitment Subcommittee, which then assessed candidates based on a series of categories, including interest and motivation, commitment to collaboration, civic commitments and community involvement, relevant subject area expertise, and their goals for service.

948
02:00:33.420 --> 02:00:38.909
<v Rafael Tamarki>The pool was then narrowed to 18 candidates, followed by interviews with 6 finalists.

949
02:00:39.119 --> 02:00:44.199
<v Rafael Tamarki>The subcommittee brought the recommendations to the whole PCEFC Committee for vote, which passed, and now we're bringing these appointments to Council for confirmation.

950
02:00:49.234 --> 02:00:54.002
<v Rafael Tamarki>And with that, I'd like to introduce the recommended appointees and reappointment.

951
02:00:58.565 --> 02:01:00.479
<v Rafael Tamarki>I am very happy with this group.

952
02:01:00.528 --> 02:01:14.350
<v Rafael Tamarki>We've gotten to know each other through this relatively long process, and the recommended candidates, I think, bring a combination of energy efficiency expertise, workforce and labor experience, program implementation and evaluation, Thank you.

953
02:01:14.350 --> 02:01:14.350
<v Rafael Tamarki>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

954
02:01:14.350 --> 02:01:22.109
<v Rafael Tamarki>So I'll move one by one and begin with Tamara Kennedy, who's currently the executive director at Northwest Energy Coalition.

955
02:01:22.710 --> 02:01:27.270
<v Rafael Tamarki>She brings significant experience in regional clean energy policy and equitable economic growth.

956
02:01:27.310 --> 02:01:35.319
<v Rafael Tamarki>She leads a regional alliance of around 100 organizations advancing clean, affordable, and equitable energy policies across the Pacific Northwest.

957
02:01:35.350 --> 02:01:49.051
<v Rafael Tamarki>And she's formerly the director of economic development at the Port of Portland, where she led investment attraction, workforce development, and equitable To my side, we also have Danielle Walker, Principal Consultant at the Brightline Group.

958
02:01:49.858 --> 02:02:00.810
<v Rafael Tamarki>Nearly 20 years of energy efficiency evaluation experience across residential, commercial, and industrial sectors, including roles at the Energy Trust of Oregon, Bonneville Power Administration, and the Department of Energy.

959
02:02:01.197 --> 02:02:10.247
<v Rafael Tamarki>I want to say Danielle is the rare, really the rare candidate with local, regional, federal, and utility experience in energy efficiency evaluation and programming.

960
02:02:10.300 --> 02:02:10.472
<v Rafael Tamarki>Thank you, Mayor.

961
02:02:15.069 --> 02:02:17.829
<v Rafael Tamarki>Thank you.

962
02:02:17.829 --> 02:02:25.939
<v Rafael Tamarki>We also have Randall Friesen, the Executive Secretary-Treasurer of the Columbia Pacific Building Trades and Construction Council.

963
02:02:26.649 --> 02:02:35.279
<v Rafael Tamarki>Randall provides deep expertise in construction trades, apprenticeship pathways, and workforce development, all critical to the climate implementation at scale that we're looking for.

964
02:02:35.890 --> 02:02:40.609
<v Rafael Tamarki>He's a graduate of a state-registered 5-year, 8,000-hour apprenticeship through Plumbers and Pipefitters Local 290.

965
02:02:41.340 --> 02:02:51.997
<v Rafael Tamarki>He represents a coalition of 22 local unions comprised of more than 16,000 construction workers in the Portland region, coordinating project labor agreements and partnerships with labor and community organizations.

966
02:02:53.939 --> 02:02:59.427
<v Rafael Tamarki>And finally, our reappointment, D'Angelo Moaning, is currently the Workforce Outreach Manager at Espousal Strategies.

967
02:02:59.524 --> 02:03:01.235
<v Rafael Tamarki>He's also currently the co-chair.

968
02:03:01.317 --> 02:03:10.914
<v Rafael Tamarki>He brings continuity to that group and deep historic Albina community ties and expertise connecting public investments to workforce, small business opportunities, and minority contractors.

969
02:03:10.962 --> 02:03:17.029
<v Rafael Tamarki>He leads workforce outreach and and community engagement for major regional infrastructure projects at Espousal.

970
02:03:17.710 --> 02:03:22.796
<v Rafael Tamarki>And he's experienced in creating pathways to employment for youth, formerly incarcerated individuals, and other underserved populations.

971
02:03:23.087 --> 02:03:29.680
<v Rafael Tamarki>So together, these appointments strengthen the committee's ability to, I think, support implementation during this period of significant growth.

972
02:03:31.760 --> 02:03:37.581
<v Rafael Tamarki>So councilors, today the requested action is confirmation of these 3 new appointments and 1 reappointment to the PCEF committee.

973
02:03:37.921 --> 02:03:50.822
<v Rafael Tamarki>We believe that they're well positioned to support the committee's advisory role as PCEF continues implementation We have the appointees and reappointee today, so you can— they can offer comment or are open for questions.

974
02:03:50.869 --> 02:03:51.994
<v Rafael Tamarki>I just want to thank you for your consideration.

975
02:03:54.881 --> 02:03:55.944
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

976
02:03:56.314 --> 02:04:03.094
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, is it your intention that we just have the in-response, or would you like them to all speak for a moment first?

977
02:04:03.658 --> 02:04:11.761
<v Rafael Tamarki>I think it'd be— I mean, we serve at your pleasure, of course, but I think it would be a nice opportunity to give them each an opportunity to just talk I would love that.

978
02:04:11.824 --> 02:04:12.327
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thank you.

979
02:04:12.715 --> 02:04:13.070
<v Rafael Tamarki>Okay, great.

980
02:04:14.398 --> 02:04:17.779
<v Rafael Tamarki>I'm going to begin with Tamara and we'll go in the order that we had them on the slides.

981
02:04:18.118 --> 02:04:18.555
<v Rafael Tamarki>Tamara, are you there?

982
02:04:19.470 --> 02:04:19.774
<v Unidentified speaker>I am.

983
02:04:19.887 --> 02:04:20.145
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here.

984
02:04:20.306 --> 02:04:21.434
<v Unidentified speaker>Can everyone hear me okay?

985
02:04:21.980 --> 02:04:22.078
<v Candace Avalos>Yep.

986
02:04:23.028 --> 02:04:23.365
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

987
02:04:23.688 --> 02:04:23.944
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

988
02:04:24.010 --> 02:04:42.695
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a true honor to be presented to be part of this committee that I have been following the great work of the PCF committee for a number of years and I'm excited that it's at this position that can continue to create strong opportunities for green workforce development in the Portland area and continue to support the city charter.

989
02:04:42.792 --> 02:04:52.908
<v Unidentified speaker>So again, very excited to be able to, now that I'm in a regional role, to be able to ensure that I'm providing some context, but also to support the strategic direction of PSUF.

990
02:04:53.453 --> 02:04:58.881
<v Unidentified speaker>Open, happy to answer any questions after the rest of the members introduce themselves.

991
02:04:59.073 --> 02:04:59.395
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

992
02:05:01.963 --> 02:05:02.685
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, good afternoon.

993
02:05:03.247 --> 02:05:04.064
<v Rafael Tamarki>Danielle Walker.

994
02:05:05.011 --> 02:05:14.509
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think my interest really stems from just dedication and into this field for the past 20 years, my entire professional career.

995
02:05:15.984 --> 02:05:27.198
<v Unidentified speaker>When a program like this gets passed, it's, it's as big as it gets for our industry, the clean energy industry, especially in the utility space and state and federal space that I've been in.

996
02:05:27.296 --> 02:05:33.721
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just wanted to be able to contribute my lived experience as best I could.

997
02:05:34.703 --> 02:05:53.715
<v Unidentified speaker>I would like to focus my area in ensuring that these programs are reliable, measurable, a prudent use of taxpayer dollars, and that we're able to really share the stories and successes of what these programs are able to accomplish.

998
02:05:56.992 --> 02:05:59.618
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, everybody.

999
02:05:59.667 --> 02:06:02.261
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Randal Friesen with the Columbia Pacific Building Trades Council.

1000
02:06:02.390 --> 02:06:12.136
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd like to echo kind of what Danielle had to say as far as making sure that our dollars are used responsibly and that they're also— that they're a benefit to the community.

1001
02:06:12.248 --> 02:06:23.947
<v Unidentified speaker>So I strongly believe that all public dollars should benefit the communities that they're in, and especially Especially to make sure that we are prudent with those dollars and that they benefit everyone.

1002
02:06:24.493 --> 02:06:25.411
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you very much.

1003
02:06:25.492 --> 02:06:26.488
<v Unidentified speaker>Happy to answer any questions.

1004
02:06:29.390 --> 02:06:30.279
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll round us out.

1005
02:06:30.537 --> 02:06:33.109
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, City Council, those of you in the council chambers.

1006
02:06:33.222 --> 02:06:34.809
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name is DeAngelo Moaning.

1007
02:06:35.149 --> 02:06:38.465
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to jump in real quick and apologize for not being there in person today.

1008
02:06:39.126 --> 02:06:42.976
<v Unidentified speaker>As some of you may know, I work on the Interstate Bridge Replacement Program and I needed to be in office.

1009
02:06:43.122 --> 02:06:44.748
<v Unidentified speaker>So we've been having some network issues.

1010
02:06:44.859 --> 02:06:47.122
<v Unidentified speaker>Issues, but hope it doesn't drop off.

1011
02:06:47.523 --> 02:06:49.079
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, just quick background about myself.

1012
02:06:49.304 --> 02:06:56.974
<v Unidentified speaker>I've been a member of PCEF since my appointment in July 2023 and have been reappointed as a co-chair since August of 2025.

1013
02:06:57.310 --> 02:07:13.117
<v Unidentified speaker>I've had the privilege of engaging in PCEF's work, multiple rounds of community grants allocations, collaborative discussions with City Council, the CIP amendment process, engagement with frontline and priority populations, and most recently the selection process for new Thank you.

1014
02:07:14.033 --> 02:07:22.469
<v Unidentified speaker>So while I understand that I'm also up for reappointment, I actually wanted to take my time to really focus on the nominees since I'm familiar with most, if not all, of council.

1015
02:07:23.256 --> 02:07:45.796
<v Unidentified speaker>But as a representative of the subcommittee as well as co-chair of the P Subcommittee as a whole, we all fully agree that, you know, Danielle's extensive background with Bonneville Power, the current work with Brightline Group, Tamber Strategic Management and Vision with the Port of Portland and the Northwest Energy Coalition, And the incredible work Randall has done with the Columbia Pacific Building Trades, supporting 2 dozen trades unions and over 20,000 trades workers.

1016
02:07:46.533 --> 02:07:51.078
<v Unidentified speaker>These things are all a testament to show that these nominees have the ability to lead at the highest level.

1017
02:07:52.073 --> 02:08:18.627
<v Unidentified speaker>I firmly believe that they bring an incredible wealth of experience, expertise, and critical PCF categories, and the commitment required to advance the mission, vision, and values of PCF and the climate and equity framework that guides They're very well positioned to help guide the investments that reduce climate impacts, expand opportunity, and ensure accountability in how these funds are used to support communities that have historically been underserved, especially as we transition into this environmental infrastructure.

1018
02:08:19.301 --> 02:08:23.621
<v Unidentified speaker>So myself, my committee, our representatives, we fully support these appointments.

1019
02:08:24.181 --> 02:08:30.828
<v Unidentified speaker>I look forward to working alongside them, the city administration, City Council, as we continue advancing this work to meet these challenges.

1020
02:08:30.893 --> 02:08:31.020
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1021
02:08:31.181 --> 02:08:36.939
<v Unidentified speaker>Is seize opportunities and celebrate our collective wins and build on the progress that comes ahead of where we stand today.

1022
02:08:37.086 --> 02:08:41.292
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you a lot for allowing me the time to share these words with you.

1023
02:08:44.528 --> 02:08:44.868
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1024
02:08:45.903 --> 02:08:48.637
<v Sameer Kanal>So we do have, uh, one testifier signed up.

1025
02:08:48.734 --> 02:08:54.989
<v Sameer Kanal>Are there any technical questions related to this process, uh, before we get into the discussion?

1026
02:08:55.037 --> 02:08:57.203
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll just run through the queue to, to ask that question.

1027
02:08:57.369 --> 02:08:58.430
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to ask for a question from each of you.

1028
02:08:58.525 --> 02:08:59.377
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Councilor Green?

1029
02:09:00.356 --> 02:09:01.095
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1030
02:09:01.176 --> 02:09:01.867
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Dunphy?

1031
02:09:02.622 --> 02:09:03.311
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Smith?

1032
02:09:04.645 --> 02:09:06.942
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it technical or is it for discussion?

1033
02:09:07.198 --> 02:09:07.471
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1034
02:09:07.921 --> 02:09:08.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick?

1035
02:09:09.769 --> 02:09:10.378
<v Steve Novick>Not technical.

1036
02:09:10.813 --> 02:09:11.631
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Murillo?

1037
02:09:12.515 --> 02:09:14.056
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, mine is technical.

1038
02:09:15.470 --> 02:09:17.703
<v Sameer Kanal>It's June 2026.

1039
02:09:18.185 --> 02:09:21.703
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I noticed that, uh, D'Angelo's appointment is backdated.

1040
02:09:22.296 --> 02:09:26.809
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to what happened there and just how he wasn't already reappointed?

1041
02:09:28.141 --> 02:09:37.969
<v Sameer Kanal>This is, this is always the challenge of managing our timelines and our recruitments, and just to be blunt about the time it takes to get through the processes.

1042
02:09:38.033 --> 02:09:42.063
<v Sameer Kanal>And so we had always originally planned to batch our recruitments together.

1043
02:09:42.110 --> 02:09:44.439
<v Sameer Kanal>We didn't expect it would take this long to get here.

1044
02:09:44.520 --> 02:09:49.047
<v Sameer Kanal>We expected we'd be here in a perfect universe closer to February so that the lag yeah.

1045
02:09:49.112 --> 02:09:50.042
<v Sameer Kanal>Wouldn't have taken as long.

1046
02:09:50.332 --> 02:09:56.895
<v Sameer Kanal>It's something we're now taking account and accounting for as we sort of walk back and understand the timelines we now have to work with.

1047
02:09:57.521 --> 02:10:01.565
<v Sameer Kanal>We, for instance, have, uh, 2 more folks that will be rolling off in September.

1048
02:10:01.711 --> 02:10:04.054
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll be beginning those recruitments shortly.

1049
02:10:04.118 --> 02:10:11.613
<v Sameer Kanal>So this is just a function of the timeline and our desire to batch them together, and, and yet they spread apart when this recruitment took longer.

1050
02:10:11.661 --> 02:10:19.073
<v Sameer Kanal>And so had we looked back, we would have just gone and separately brought the appointment and come back and done the others, but at that time we thought we could batch them together.

1051
02:10:19.622 --> 02:10:20.443
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thank you.

1052
02:10:20.490 --> 02:10:25.600
<v Sameer Kanal>And then if, if these appointments are approved by council, will the committee be full up until that September?

1053
02:10:25.811 --> 02:10:28.252
<v Sameer Kanal>Correct, you will have a full 9-person committee at that point.

1054
02:10:28.657 --> 02:10:28.819
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

1055
02:10:29.854 --> 02:10:32.828
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, all right, I guess Rebecca, if you could please call the testifier.

1056
02:10:35.801 --> 02:10:39.425
<v Rebecca Dobert>We do have one person signed up, uh, Babs Fanelli.

1057
02:10:40.676 --> 02:10:41.618
<v Rebecca Dobert>Babs is online.

1058
02:10:42.362 --> 02:10:44.932
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can unmute and go ahead.

1059
02:10:46.646 --> 02:10:48.360
<v Loretta Smith>Hi everyone, can you hear me okay?

1060
02:10:48.684 --> 02:10:49.055
<v Loretta Smith>We can.

1061
02:10:50.203 --> 02:10:50.462
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1062
02:10:50.931 --> 02:10:57.875
<v Loretta Smith>So hello, I've had the great honor and privilege of meeting all of you, uh, at various points over the last few years.

1063
02:10:58.630 --> 02:11:03.046
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, I'm soon to be 78, lifelong Portlander, currently in District 2.

1064
02:11:04.226 --> 02:11:06.587
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, I am extremely grateful that I tuned in today.

1065
02:11:07.948 --> 02:11:16.543
<v Loretta Smith>I normally would watch the marathon session scheduled for tonight, but I have tickets for the Portland Fire game.

1066
02:11:18.029 --> 02:11:18.920
<v Loretta Smith>Got your back, Dan.

1067
02:11:21.155 --> 02:11:33.220
<v Loretta Smith>So I followed PCF since early 2020 and am continually impressed with the work Thank you.

1068
02:11:33.349 --> 02:11:34.136
<v Loretta Smith>I applaud the work that they do.

1069
02:11:34.681 --> 02:11:40.751
<v Loretta Smith>My main concern— and also applaud the 4 candidates that have already spoken.

1070
02:11:42.068 --> 02:12:12.543
<v Loretta Smith>The other part of what I want to say is that I am one of thousands of Portlanders who have been pretty vocal about making certain that PCF funds, including all that interest Thank you.

1071
02:12:19.546 --> 02:12:26.560
<v Loretta Smith>A one-slide caveat is normally I would watch the marathon session tonight.

1072
02:12:27.025 --> 02:12:37.399
<v Loretta Smith>I will view it after the fact, and I implore and beg all of you to pass a budget.

1073
02:12:37.944 --> 02:12:46.390
<v Loretta Smith>I know you all love our City of Roses, and please demonstrate that to us by giving us a budget.

1074
02:12:46.855 --> 02:12:47.322
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you all.

1075
02:12:47.996 --> 02:12:48.108
<v Candace Avalos>Bye.

1076
02:12:51.829 --> 02:12:53.059
<v Rebecca Dobert>That concludes testimony.

1077
02:12:56.010 --> 02:12:56.791
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, uh, colleagues.

1078
02:12:56.840 --> 02:12:59.069
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go through the, um, the queue now.

1079
02:12:59.135 --> 02:13:01.217
<v Sameer Kanal>Feel free to ask questions of the candidates or discuss.

1080
02:13:02.063 --> 02:13:09.945
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, when screen share ends, the order gets redone, so I'll go in the order I called everyone's name earlier, which means Councilor Green first, followed by Council President Dunphy.

1081
02:13:11.506 --> 02:13:15.000
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Kanal, and, uh, thanks for bringing forward these appointments today.

1082
02:13:16.520 --> 02:13:21.658
<v Mitch Green>I think I've got questions for all the new appointees and my appreciation to D'Angelo for stepping up again.

1083
02:13:23.056 --> 02:13:25.368
<v Mitch Green>Is it Tamara or Tamara?

1084
02:13:25.850 --> 02:13:26.172
<v Mitch Green>Tamara?

1085
02:13:26.590 --> 02:13:27.233
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thank you.

1086
02:13:27.730 --> 02:13:28.020
<v Mitch Green>Tamara.

1087
02:13:28.100 --> 02:13:29.786
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for applying for this.

1088
02:13:29.867 --> 02:13:34.315
<v Mitch Green>And I'm, you know, I'm a veteran of the industry as well.

1089
02:13:34.668 --> 02:13:54.712
<v Mitch Green>And so I clocked that you're the executive director of the Northwest Energy Coalition, which, has been sort of on the forefront of really trying to make sure we're putting renewables on the grid and we're greening our grid in every opportunity, right?

1090
02:13:54.792 --> 02:14:08.395
<v Mitch Green>And so I've sometimes thought about, can PSEF be a way to help finance independent power production, maybe help like the City of Portland maybe get into the generation supply business itself, things of that nature.

1091
02:14:09.381 --> 02:14:24.229
<v Mitch Green>And I just, I wonder if you have any ideas from your current position how you might enter into the committee work, understanding that a lot of the focus that you spoke to is workforce development, but I see potentially two sides of the same coin on that.

1092
02:14:25.909 --> 02:14:27.359
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for the question.

1093
02:14:28.037 --> 02:14:32.373
<v Unidentified speaker>I will just put one little caveat is, so the Northwest Energy Coalition, we are a nonprofit.

1094
02:14:32.856 --> 02:14:42.717
<v Unidentified speaker>We focus on, we operate we operate in Oregon, Washington, Montana, and Idaho, and really we're an advocate for ratepayers and just focus on equity and transparency and for moving from policy to implementation.

1095
02:14:42.765 --> 02:14:57.521
<v Unidentified speaker>So we don't actually get involved in direct physical projects, but many organizations like Renewable Northwest have spun out of us, and we really just try to make sure we create aligned spaces for collaborative engagement to support a really strong regional clean energy economy.

1096
02:14:58.453 --> 02:15:24.828
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't know if I have specific thanks for your question that you have, but my goal here being part of the committee is, A, to support the overall governance structure and follow, of course, what the city charter has outlined, ensure that we have a really strong, you know, climate investment plan that supports that, and that any individual perspective is really balanced with the overall diverse perspectives that are on the overall governance committee.

1097
02:15:25.957 --> 02:15:27.112
<v Mitch Green>Well, that's a great answer.

1098
02:15:27.176 --> 02:15:34.007
<v Mitch Green>And I think I would just— thanks for clarifying the kind of positions and ratepayer advocacy that Northwest Energy Coalition does.

1099
02:15:34.072 --> 02:15:38.177
<v Mitch Green>That's been my experience with them as being kind of on the other side of the rate case, so to speak.

1100
02:15:38.947 --> 02:15:49.885
<v Mitch Green>I think that that's going to be top of mind and for taxpayers or voters in general when they think about the Portland Clean Energy Fund and future climate investment plan amendments.

1101
02:15:49.932 --> 02:15:50.958
<v Mitch Green>So I'm looking forward to that perspective.

1102
02:15:52.069 --> 02:15:53.067
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1103
02:15:55.318 --> 02:16:03.091
<v Mitch Green>Danielle, so colleagues, full disclosure, I used to work with Danielle at Bonneville Power Administration for probably about 5 years very closely.

1104
02:16:04.175 --> 02:16:10.525
<v Mitch Green>Danielle was our energy efficiency lead that was our liaison with the Northwest Power and Planning Council.

1105
02:16:11.515 --> 02:16:14.787
<v Mitch Green>And I was junior to you at that time.

1106
02:16:15.887 --> 02:16:18.025
<v Mitch Green>And we worked on the resource program together.

1107
02:16:18.550 --> 02:16:20.188
<v Mitch Green>So I just want you guys to know that.

1108
02:16:20.909 --> 02:16:22.645
<v Mitch Green>But I also know what your expertise is.

1109
02:16:22.997 --> 02:16:24.314
<v Mitch Green>And so I want to ask you a question.

1110
02:16:25.470 --> 02:16:44.020
<v Mitch Green>A lot of discussion that we've had lately and what's been top of mind for me is when we think about candidate projects for the Portland Clean Energy Fund, for me, it's not necessarily that that specific thing has a climate nexus or has an opportunity to have an efficiency saving, but it's also part of a portfolio.

1111
02:16:44.358 --> 02:16:44.663
<v Mitch Green>Mm-hmm.

1112
02:16:44.774 --> 02:16:49.190
<v Mitch Green>That there may be some competing proposals and some sort of alternatives analysis, so to speak.

1113
02:16:49.254 --> 02:17:09.004
<v Mitch Green>So I wonder if, one, you're going to bring your experience into that work a little bit, but then also if you can just maybe share a little bit with the City Council, a little bit of how you think about kind of evaluating proposals and the costs kind of works from your experience and how you might apply that to this.

1114
02:17:10.477 --> 02:17:11.391
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, thank you.

1115
02:17:11.841 --> 02:17:13.122
<v Unidentified speaker>It's great to see you.

1116
02:17:14.262 --> 02:17:17.757
<v Unidentified speaker>And I know Councilor Dunphy as well, so it was great to see you too.

1117
02:17:19.137 --> 02:17:33.057
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, yes, to— okay, so the word that comes to mind for me as you talk through all of that, managing a portfolio, evaluating decision-making, to me is a decision-making framework and criteria.

1118
02:17:33.665 --> 02:17:43.174
<v Unidentified speaker>So you have to have outlined and agreed upon all of the criteria of which you are going to weigh and compare all of those options.

1119
02:17:43.766 --> 02:17:51.477
<v Unidentified speaker>And then you have to have a framework for which, for how those criteria are going to get them, you know, considered and how a decision will get made.

1120
02:17:51.541 --> 02:18:03.806
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think it will be me understanding the framework that already exists, the criteria that already exists, what the priorities are for the various stakeholders all involved.

1121
02:18:03.886 --> 02:18:11.710
<v Unidentified speaker>Everyone is coming to the table with equally important but different priorities of those criteria.

1122
02:18:11.790 --> 02:18:13.698
<v Unidentified speaker>And so how do you weigh those and consider those?

1123
02:18:15.524 --> 02:18:28.819
<v Unidentified speaker>So I, yeah, I think it would be understanding the existing framework, understanding what else is needed, and then putting that through these, you know, these decisions and what's on the table.

1124
02:18:29.450 --> 02:18:29.985
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1125
02:18:30.032 --> 02:18:31.279
<v Mitch Green>And just a little follow-up question.

1126
02:18:32.666 --> 02:18:40.507
<v Mitch Green>From your experience working with the kind of BPA to council nexus, would you say that that— was that work ever political at times?

1127
02:18:41.406 --> 02:18:42.609
<v Mitch Green>Was it ever not political?

1128
02:18:42.689 --> 02:18:42.929
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

1129
02:18:43.105 --> 02:18:46.007
<v Mitch Green>Well, yeah, just can you speak about sort of the intersection of that?

1130
02:18:46.072 --> 02:18:48.253
<v Mitch Green>Because that matters for this question too.

1131
02:18:48.541 --> 02:18:48.781
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1132
02:18:48.861 --> 02:18:52.148
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, I think my background, I have a technical background.

1133
02:18:52.229 --> 02:18:55.452
<v Unidentified speaker>I have a master's from Portland State in economics.

1134
02:18:56.575 --> 02:19:04.889
<v Unidentified speaker>Yet I think I quickly realized that when I entered into federal that you can't untie the technical from the policy and from the political.

1135
02:19:05.370 --> 02:19:27.135
<v Unidentified speaker>And so really, it's— I think as my career has progressed, it's been, you know, finding the nuance of how you use the technical and how you ground yourself in analytics to support and facilitate and move forward in sensitive political policy-related conversations.

1136
02:19:28.494 --> 02:19:42.637
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's essentially what we did at Bonneville often, either with the council or with utilities or with advocates, was taking our technical background and supporting a policy conversation.

1137
02:19:43.022 --> 02:19:43.984
<v Unidentified speaker>So yeah.

1138
02:19:44.289 --> 02:19:44.930
<v Mitch Green>Well, thank you.

1139
02:19:44.994 --> 02:19:47.816
<v Mitch Green>I'm really glad to see your interest in this board.

1140
02:19:48.201 --> 02:19:49.003
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1141
02:19:49.100 --> 02:19:50.992
<v Mitch Green>And then I'll ask Randall.

1142
02:19:51.167 --> 02:19:54.326
<v Mitch Green>It was great to see you up there, Randall.

1143
02:19:55.417 --> 02:20:12.665
<v Mitch Green>You know, what is your vision for like decarbonization, like PSEF as a decarbonization tool with respect to labor and sort of opportunities for building generations of good-paying jobs when we think about moving beyond fossil fuels?

1144
02:20:12.921 --> 02:20:14.685
<v Mitch Green>Do you have any thoughts on that?

1145
02:20:15.424 --> 02:20:18.938
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, first off, thank you for allowing me to attend remote.

1146
02:20:19.018 --> 02:20:20.236
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm out of town for work too.

1147
02:20:20.445 --> 02:20:20.831
<v Unidentified speaker>Obviously.

1148
02:20:20.879 --> 02:20:29.254
<v Unidentified speaker>So, um, I guess my mind goes to— there's all kinds of new technologies that are coming, and there's a lot of trades that we already have.

1149
02:20:29.527 --> 02:20:35.719
<v Unidentified speaker>The affiliates that I represent, we already do a lot of different work.

1150
02:20:35.768 --> 02:20:45.218
<v Unidentified speaker>Like, like when solar panels came along, construction trades already installed those, and our workforce is already trained in those kinds of things.

1151
02:20:45.265 --> 02:20:57.325
<v Unidentified speaker>So I want to make sure that we don't use funding to stand up duplicate programs or other programs that aren't state registered or try to solve for a problem that doesn't exist, especially when it comes to workforce.

1152
02:20:57.917 --> 02:21:09.736
<v Unidentified speaker>So my expertise of coming from the trades and going through our state registered apprenticeship program helps us link up with, with crafts that already do that work and make sure that we don't again duplicate efforts, right?

1153
02:21:10.602 --> 02:21:11.548
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm excited about that.

1154
02:21:12.270 --> 02:21:13.055
<v Unidentified speaker>Does that answer your question?

1155
02:21:14.661 --> 02:21:34.763
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, and I just think that, you know, sometimes there's a— there might be a perception that, you know, the environmental movement and decarbonization might be at odds with the trades, but do you see it as an opportunity to work together to build a solid blue-green alliance and kind of move us into the 21st century with good, high-quality union jobs?

1156
02:21:35.453 --> 02:21:35.935
<v Unidentified speaker>Absolutely.

1157
02:21:36.015 --> 02:21:48.367
<v Unidentified speaker>There's one project that is privately funded That is, is coming to the region, and it's Next Clean Energy, and it's solely going to be a renewable energy plant that isn't— is not fossil fuels.

1158
02:21:48.944 --> 02:21:51.772
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that's a good example of that, is carbon reduction.

1159
02:21:51.915 --> 02:22:01.762
<v Unidentified speaker>And, and, uh, yeah, so we're absolutely excited to take that on, and I do see it as a, a really good, good, uh, opportunity and to support, uh, decarbonization.

1160
02:22:01.809 --> 02:22:04.668
<v Unidentified speaker>There's, there's other, there's other, uh, things that we do too.

1161
02:22:04.750 --> 02:22:08.601
<v Unidentified speaker>That, that we represent, uh, when it comes to wind farms.

1162
02:22:09.179 --> 02:22:10.606
<v Unidentified speaker>Our crafts also work on those.

1163
02:22:10.879 --> 02:22:15.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, you know, there's just a multitude of, of different technologies that we already perform.

1164
02:22:16.495 --> 02:22:17.185
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

1165
02:22:17.442 --> 02:22:22.240
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I don't want to monopolize the rest of the mic, so I, I love this topic area, so thanks so much.

1166
02:22:22.577 --> 02:22:24.119
<v Mitch Green>I, I plan to support all of you today.

1167
02:22:24.199 --> 02:22:24.680
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1168
02:22:25.627 --> 02:22:25.995
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1169
02:22:26.444 --> 02:22:27.521
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1170
02:22:27.568 --> 02:22:29.782
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go to Council President Dunphy, followed by Councilor Smith.

1171
02:22:29.959 --> 02:22:30.233
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1172
02:22:30.313 --> 02:22:41.038
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll be real brief, but, um, You know, panels like this of just incredible community volunteers who are willing to spend their time, it's always humbling to me to see this happen.

1173
02:22:41.118 --> 02:22:52.261
<v Unidentified speaker>But also, I am struggling right now about whether or not Portland is just a really small city or I am old and have been doing this work for a long time because I have a personal relationship with all 4 of these folks in different capacities.

1174
02:22:52.935 --> 02:22:58.762
<v Eric Zimmerman>Tamara and I met almost a decade ago when she was with Travel Portland and we got to work together while I was working Working for Commissioner Nick Fish's office.

1175
02:22:59.259 --> 02:23:06.408
<v Eric Zimmerman>Danielle and I met 4 years ago when we served a 3-year term on the Parkrose School Board Budget Committee together.

1176
02:23:06.568 --> 02:23:10.335
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I know that she is a glutton for punishment and staring at Excel spreadsheets.

1177
02:23:10.977 --> 02:23:14.985
<v Unidentified speaker>Randall and I have gotten to work together for the last 2 years over campaign time mostly.

1178
02:23:15.146 --> 02:23:24.885
<v Eric Zimmerman>And D'Angelo, I— we met once prior to me being in this role when he was working for Espousal, but I've also just been so deeply impressed with his leadership as co-chair.

1179
02:23:25.239 --> 02:23:28.575
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, and every time we've gotten to connect, I have so much confidence in his leadership.

1180
02:23:28.639 --> 02:23:32.042
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm enthusiastic to support all 4 of these nominees.

1181
02:23:32.253 --> 02:23:33.921
<v Unidentified speaker>And, uh, kudos, gentlemen.

1182
02:23:33.969 --> 02:23:35.459
<v Unidentified speaker>Good work on the recruitment process.

1183
02:23:35.588 --> 02:23:35.944
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1184
02:23:38.082 --> 02:23:39.166
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1185
02:23:39.216 --> 02:23:40.786
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go to Councilor Smith, followed by Novick.

1186
02:23:41.309 --> 02:23:42.332
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr.

1187
02:23:42.379 --> 02:23:42.704
<v Loretta Smith>Chair.

1188
02:23:43.549 --> 02:23:51.037
<v Loretta Smith>I want to thank all of you for, um, for presenting, uh, Rafael and, um, making sure that you got Good quality people.

1189
02:23:51.148 --> 02:23:53.411
<v Loretta Smith>I too know many of these folks.

1190
02:23:54.277 --> 02:24:08.957
<v Loretta Smith>I have been in passing with Danielle, but I think that you have picked a superstar group of folks who will have the level of consciousness that's needed at this time to do this kind of work.

1191
02:24:10.240 --> 02:24:12.550
<v Loretta Smith>And yes, Danielle, it will get political at times.

1192
02:24:12.647 --> 02:24:14.266
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know when it's not political.

1193
02:24:14.427 --> 02:24:17.700
<v Loretta Smith>Just say the word PSF and everything goes crazy.

1194
02:24:18.379 --> 02:24:23.716
<v Loretta Smith>But, um, but I, I think it's— I think you've, you've picked a good group.

1195
02:24:23.942 --> 02:24:29.088
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I, I too plan to support all of you and, um, wish you well.

1196
02:24:32.157 --> 02:24:32.994
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1197
02:24:33.058 --> 02:24:34.487
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, followed by Morillo.

1198
02:24:35.853 --> 02:24:36.304
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr.

1199
02:24:36.352 --> 02:24:36.545
<v Steve Novick>Chair.

1200
02:24:36.978 --> 02:24:44.725
<v Steve Novick>Um, first of all, I'm so impressed by the background and experience each of you have, and we're really grateful that all of you were willing to do thank you, Mayor.

1201
02:24:44.917 --> 02:24:53.095
<v Steve Novick>I want to describe some concerns I've had and questions I have about the relationship between the PCEF and the PCEF Committee and the Council.

1202
02:24:53.658 --> 02:24:58.832
<v Steve Novick>And I'm not necessarily asking you to give your thoughts on this because I might be asking you about things you never thought about before.

1203
02:24:58.897 --> 02:25:01.033
<v Steve Novick>If you have some spontaneous thoughts, please share them.

1204
02:25:01.692 --> 02:25:19.207
<v Steve Novick>But we had an experience last year where in the annual amendments, the PCEF recommended and taking money out of a pot that had gone to a transportation program which wasn't really being spent and putting it into a housing pot.

1205
02:25:20.074 --> 02:25:31.736
<v Steve Novick>And I was particularly concerned about— I mean, about— I tend to think that we spend too little on transportation, and I was concerned about taking money out of transportation and putting it into housing where we spend a lot.

1206
02:25:32.345 --> 02:25:46.799
<v Steve Novick>And I suggested that we consider some various other transportation And the response that we got from some of the housing organizations who were planning to get the money is, we've already been promised this money, that's unfair.

1207
02:25:46.799 --> 02:25:54.079
<v Steve Novick>And we wound up having a discussion in council and my proposals to keep the money in transportation lost 11 to 1.

1208
02:25:54.079 --> 02:26:04.340
<v Steve Novick>But I think that there were other councilors who shared my concern that, I mean, there's some councilors here I should tell you that think that the council has no business interfering with the decisions of the Portland of Bureau of Transportation.

1209
02:26:04.340 --> 02:26:04.479
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a very fair point.

1210
02:26:04.845 --> 02:26:06.240
<v Steve Novick>The committee or the PCF staff.

1211
02:26:06.305 --> 02:26:07.730
<v Steve Novick>The council should just be a rubber stamp.

1212
02:26:08.227 --> 02:26:15.647
<v Steve Novick>There's some of us who think the council should not be a rubber stamp and would like to have some opportunities to weigh in and have a discussion.

1213
02:26:16.466 --> 02:26:26.226
<v Steve Novick>One thing that I would like the council to know is in advance, what are programs that are underspending and therefore might be the subject of proposals to change?

1214
02:26:26.802 --> 02:26:41.761
<v Steve Novick>I've had some exchanges in the past few months with both the financial professionals, like the CFO's office and the budget office and the city and with PSAP staff who told me we don't really have a handle on what areas there are underspending in.

1215
02:26:42.227 --> 02:26:55.784
<v Steve Novick>So I'm really hoping that before the next time PSAP recommends moving money around because there's areas of underspending, there's something, an area of underspending, the council is aware of that in advance.

1216
02:26:57.680 --> 02:27:12.436
<v Steve Novick>So I mean, again, this is, I mean, I'm worried about council being put in a position where they're asked to confirm a decision and told that by people who were relying on the previous decision that they think they've been promised the money.

1217
02:27:12.950 --> 02:27:18.036
<v Steve Novick>I'm worried about our not knowing in advance that there's areas of underspending which might prompt a revision.

1218
02:27:19.334 --> 02:27:26.939
<v Steve Novick>And I'm hoping there can be a more collaborative relationship and exchange of information between PCF and the committee.

1219
02:27:27.675 --> 02:27:28.460
<v Steve Novick>And the councilors.

1220
02:27:28.989 --> 02:27:30.753
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to get that out there.

1221
02:27:30.897 --> 02:27:36.792
<v Steve Novick>If anybody has an initial reaction, I'd be happy to hear it, but I would quite understand if nobody has an initial reaction.

1222
02:27:36.842 --> 02:27:39.277
<v Loretta Smith>Mr. Chairman, before they answer, point of information.

1223
02:27:39.388 --> 02:27:40.318
<v Loretta Smith>So let's clear up something.

1224
02:27:41.456 --> 02:27:47.609
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, the folks that he said that he— they were promised something to, they were not promised anything.

1225
02:27:47.864 --> 02:27:50.093
<v Loretta Smith>They went through a PCF process.

1226
02:27:50.701 --> 02:27:52.175
<v Loretta Smith>So let's clear that up first.

1227
02:27:52.833 --> 02:28:00.841
<v Loretta Smith>They went through a process that PCF set they were not just told they were going to get something.

1228
02:28:01.659 --> 02:28:04.582
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Smith, just to be clear, everything you just said is perfectly valid.

1229
02:28:04.646 --> 02:28:05.898
<v Sameer Kanal>It's just not a point of information.

1230
02:28:06.477 --> 02:28:13.798
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, I thought it was a point of information, but I wanted to clear up my colleague before he has them answer something that they are getting political about.

1231
02:28:14.022 --> 02:28:17.540
<v Steve Novick>Well, and Councilor, I recognize that he did go through a process.

1232
02:28:17.636 --> 02:28:20.638
<v Steve Novick>The question is, is the— is the committee process the proper process?

1233
02:28:20.489 --> 02:28:22.569
<v Loretta Smith>You said that PCF promised them.

1234
02:28:22.569 --> 02:28:23.450
<v Loretta Smith>They didn't promise them.

1235
02:28:23.450 --> 02:28:24.579
<v Loretta Smith>They went through a process.

1236
02:28:24.709 --> 02:28:26.739
<v Loretta Smith>So don't change it around, Councilor.

1237
02:28:26.809 --> 02:28:33.090
<v Steve Novick>And Councilor, you know my concern is that I think that the process that PCF goes through is just not— should not be the end of the story.

1238
02:28:33.090 --> 02:28:33.090
<v Steve Novick>We know.

1239
02:28:33.090 --> 02:28:33.860
<v Loretta Smith>You didn't recognize people who got the money.

1240
02:28:34.049 --> 02:28:35.090
<v Loretta Smith>So let's continue.

1241
02:28:35.090 --> 02:28:37.399
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Smith, you're welcome to get back in the queue.

1242
02:28:37.450 --> 02:28:39.899
<v Sameer Kanal>I just, I want to make sure the person in the queue is recognized.

1243
02:28:41.229 --> 02:28:45.329
<v Steve Novick>So again, if anybody has a reaction to that, I'd be happy to hear it.

1244
02:28:45.329 --> 02:28:51.153
<v Unidentified speaker>I perfectly understand if nobody I'd like just a real quick chance to respond, if that's all right.

1245
02:28:51.769 --> 02:28:52.075
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1246
02:28:52.902 --> 02:29:00.228
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, no, I— one, I want to specifically appreciate Councilor Novick because, um, he has been an advocate for PSF in a lot of different ways.

1247
02:29:00.504 --> 02:29:05.724
<v Unidentified speaker>He has made sure to inform myself and my fellow co-chair of any amendments that he may be proposing.

1248
02:29:05.836 --> 02:29:10.725
<v Unidentified speaker>There's been ongoing conversation about what his thoughts are, so I understand Councilor Novick's position.

1249
02:29:11.484 --> 02:29:24.425
<v Unidentified speaker>I also appreciate Just, I appreciate Councilor Smith's response, just kind of clarifying the process, but also want to draw attention to how that allocation was made very briefly.

1250
02:29:24.475 --> 02:29:33.909
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, we were looking at a program that was underperforming for the time that it was at the CIP amendment process, comparing that to a program that was overperforming.

1251
02:29:34.056 --> 02:29:42.486
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, you know, I think there's a nuance that should be appreciated and understood that it wasn't just we are deprioritizing transportation for housing.

1252
02:29:43.015 --> 02:29:49.316
<v Unidentified speaker>Even background on myself, my career is primarily in transportation, you know, Rosewater Project, Interstate Bridge.

1253
02:29:49.414 --> 02:29:54.399
<v Unidentified speaker>I work with TriMet, so I understand very much the woes that we have in the transportation industry.

1254
02:29:54.448 --> 02:29:55.795
<v Unidentified speaker>It's where I— it's kind of where I live.

1255
02:29:56.629 --> 02:30:08.063
<v Unidentified speaker>But this was a particular situation in which we're looking at an underperforming program that happened to be transportation and matured allocation to a program that was overperforming in which case was housing.

1256
02:30:08.111 --> 02:30:13.156
<v Unidentified speaker>So just to clarify that we are not prioritizing or deprioritizing one or the other.

1257
02:30:13.718 --> 02:30:27.968
<v Unidentified speaker>This was an allocation made based on the data that we had in serving programs that were already showing their value and could use more assistance with funds that were then made available due to that allocation.

1258
02:30:28.016 --> 02:30:37.766
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just want to clarify that for the sake of the conversation, but I also want to acknowledge That I do believe a more collaborative process is necessary with council.

1259
02:30:37.896 --> 02:30:41.653
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, I've had conversations with most, if not all, of the folks on city council.

1260
02:30:41.733 --> 02:30:47.319
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, everybody has a wealth of ideas about how these allocations are made and where they can participate.

1261
02:30:47.368 --> 02:30:59.779
<v Unidentified speaker>But I believe that, and I've said this openly and I'm happy to say it again, that, you know, this is a program that was pulled together by members of the community to prioritize investments in frontline communities.

1262
02:31:00.067 --> 02:31:14.368
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would prefer to see a collaborative process with frontline communities, those that are the most impacted, City Council, the administration, and the committee, uh, to ensure that we are making these allocations in a way where they serve the people that they were designed to serve.

1263
02:31:14.463 --> 02:31:18.407
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you for allowing me to make comments.

1264
02:31:18.664 --> 02:31:19.049
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1265
02:31:19.209 --> 02:31:35.265
<v Steve Novick>And I do have a question that I actually would like to ask people to answer, which is that There's— when PSEP was put on the ballot, it said that it was for energy efficiency projects, but which I think includes transportation alternatives to gasoline cars.

1266
02:31:35.780 --> 02:31:37.584
<v Steve Novick>But that wasn't a focus of PSEP for a while.

1267
02:31:37.808 --> 02:31:42.125
<v Steve Novick>Since then, a small fraction of PSEP money has gone to transportation.

1268
02:31:42.706 --> 02:31:45.363
<v Steve Novick>I think that in some circles that's still controversial.

1269
02:31:45.927 --> 02:32:05.712
<v Steve Novick>So I just want to ask each of the nominees, do you think Do you think that investments in transportation to reduce emissions and to reduce the cost of transportation for PSF priority communities by providing cheaper, greener alternatives, do you think that that's a legitimate use of PSF resources or not?

1270
02:32:10.871 --> 02:32:14.736
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, I'll go first.

1271
02:32:16.433 --> 02:32:20.628
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, I think I would first need to immerse myself in all of the specific language.

1272
02:32:20.739 --> 02:32:29.789
<v Unidentified speaker>Language within the act and within any plans to make sure that this decision would be consistent with that.

1273
02:32:30.013 --> 02:32:39.233
<v Unidentified speaker>I would say in my professional experience outside of this specific program, the answer would generally be yes.

1274
02:32:40.592 --> 02:32:49.823
<v Unidentified speaker>But I think that that is always caveated with the specifics of the program and the rules and requirements And legal underpinnings of it.

1275
02:32:49.951 --> 02:32:53.228
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's my response.

1276
02:32:55.799 --> 02:33:02.157
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I would just add that any decision that needs to be made would have to be in alignment with what the, uh, what the goals of PSAP are.

1277
02:33:03.302 --> 02:33:04.684
<v Unidentified speaker>And it's also a group discussion, right?

1278
02:33:04.733 --> 02:33:10.134
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would definitely have to review more information, and I wouldn't be able to say yes or no to that.

1279
02:33:10.213 --> 02:33:20.930
<v Unidentified speaker>But on, on the face value It sounds like it would meet, it would meet those requirements, but without more information, it'd be difficult to make an affirmative answer on it, right?

1280
02:33:21.286 --> 02:33:21.351
<v Unidentified speaker>So.

1281
02:33:23.923 --> 02:33:24.505
<v Unidentified speaker>And thank you.

1282
02:33:24.569 --> 02:33:27.450
<v Unidentified speaker>I agree with both comments stated before.

1283
02:33:28.227 --> 02:33:41.013
<v Unidentified speaker>I do see a role in transportation decarbonization as really important in general, but I would like to understand how that has fit into the priorities of the overall climate investment plan and what— how that has been structured.

1284
02:33:41.094 --> 02:33:42.422
<v Unidentified speaker>So I feel like I don't have enough.

1285
02:33:43.909 --> 02:33:50.593
<v Unidentified speaker>I would want to do a little bit more deep dive into that and also make sure that I'm in line with the overall goals of the committee.

1286
02:33:51.905 --> 02:33:52.618
<v Unidentified speaker>But thank you for that question.

1287
02:33:54.558 --> 02:33:55.656
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll round us out here.

1288
02:33:56.416 --> 02:34:02.313
<v Unidentified speaker>I think— and I, one, I want to say that yes, I think that there is a priority in transportation decarbonization through PSIF.

1289
02:34:02.717 --> 02:34:16.429
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that we have to determine a way that we can have transportation decarbonization priorities that also focuses on ensuring that priority populations have an equitable way to access the transportation decarbonization.

1290
02:34:16.863 --> 02:34:18.489
<v Unidentified speaker>I won't go into great length.

1291
02:34:18.619 --> 02:34:45.298
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't want to take too much time, but, you know, we often tote the idea of electric vehicles and providing those to priority populations, but we don't talk enough about the infrastructure required to implement electric We don't talk about how priority populations generally live in mixed-income housing, which may only have 2 to 3 charging stations, nor do we talk about the impact that that would have on the grid for black and brownouts specifically in lower-income priority population communities.

1292
02:34:45.345 --> 02:35:10.502
<v Unidentified speaker>So I agree that there should be a focus on transportation decarbonization that is a part of PCEF, but I think that we have to reimagine what that looks like in terms of equitable access in a way that doesn't again, I don't want to go into detail, but I'm happy to have this conversation when we have the space to do so.

1293
02:35:11.224 --> 02:35:15.829
<v Steve Novick>Angela, I really appreciate that answer, and this obviously is something that you've given a lot of, a lot of thought to.

1294
02:35:16.504 --> 02:35:32.014
<v Steve Novick>I have to say, I'm a little worried that people, that the rest of you who have been nominated for these positions and supposedly have presumably have looked into PSF before, aren't at all sure whether any transportation investments are appropriate subjects for PSF.

1295
02:35:32.207 --> 02:35:37.539
<v Steve Novick>PSF has made some such investments, although I think it's too small a percentage.

1296
02:35:37.636 --> 02:35:59.093
<v Steve Novick>But to me, the fact that none of you were sure that transportation was even in the abstract a possible use reflects to me the fact that other than D'Angelo, we haven't had many people come to the committee who have a transportation background and have thought about the interaction of transportation and PSAP.

1297
02:35:59.140 --> 02:36:06.786
<v Steve Novick>So I just encourage you to give the matter further thought and talk to D'Angelo about his thoughts, et cetera.

1298
02:36:07.011 --> 02:36:07.347
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1299
02:36:08.471 --> 02:36:16.084
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, if I could briefly respond, I do want to also just again reiterate that I have an experience and a background in transportation.

1300
02:36:16.149 --> 02:36:21.610
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't necessarily believe that it's a failure of our committee members to engage in PCF.

1301
02:36:21.610 --> 02:36:25.350
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that PCF is a broad program that has various different things.

1302
02:36:25.350 --> 02:36:35.770
<v Unidentified speaker>Even for me, when I first started in 2023, like I came from a minority contractor, my background was primarily in supporting small businesses and minority contractors into getting into this space.

1303
02:36:35.770 --> 02:36:42.489
<v Unidentified speaker>And through my tenure, I've been able to then apply what I've learned in engaging with the program to other areas.

1304
02:36:42.489 --> 02:36:44.502
<v Unidentified speaker>So I can speak about regenerative agriculture.

1305
02:36:44.597 --> 02:36:46.167
<v Unidentified speaker>I may not be an expert, but I could speak about it.

1306
02:36:46.216 --> 02:37:06.183
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think really this is a conversation or a question that was focused on someone that has had the time to go through the CIP that works in that space that can answer that question appropriately, whereas my colleagues— I think it was a— it's a fair question, a fair response to say we don't know how this intersects with how PCEP operates and what PCEP investments have been, because there have been substantial investments.

1307
02:37:06.231 --> 02:37:31.059
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would focus more on Thank you.

1308
02:37:31.059 --> 02:37:33.239
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you all so much for being here today.

1309
02:37:33.459 --> 02:37:43.763
<v Angelita Morillo>It's— you are choosing to be in a position to help guide the city on an issue that I think is really difficult and scrutinized more than many of our other recommending bodies.

1310
02:37:43.860 --> 02:37:47.449
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I appreciate you putting yourself forward and bringing that expertise.

1311
02:37:48.522 --> 02:38:02.701
<v Angelita Morillo>I have one question that's for all of you, just to kind of in line with what Councilor Novick was talking about actually, because when the Climate Committee existed, RIP, it was a big focus for us yes.

1312
02:38:02.959 --> 02:38:10.088
<v Angelita Morillo>And we heard, or at least in District 3, we definitely heard a big community outcry about the fact that transportation is being cut.

1313
02:38:10.137 --> 02:38:15.665
<v Angelita Morillo>That obviously happened at the state legislature, but there was sort of a push from the community for us to respond to that.

1314
02:38:16.052 --> 02:38:26.548
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I'm curious how, if you don't have a fully formed thought about transportation as part of PSEF, what would engagement look like through the climate investment plan with community?

1315
02:38:28.351 --> 02:38:36.084
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm not saying you need to have a determination, but sort of like, how would you engage with the community to figure that out?

1316
02:38:39.403 --> 02:38:41.007
<v Angelita Morillo>And anyone can answer, online folks too.

1317
02:38:47.924 --> 02:38:49.212
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I can jump in real briefly.

1318
02:38:49.600 --> 02:38:53.145
<v Unidentified speaker>I will relate my answer to the regenerative agriculture study.

1319
02:38:54.444 --> 02:38:57.818
<v Unidentified speaker>It was a space that when I initially came on, I was not at all familiar with.

1320
02:38:58.622 --> 02:39:07.244
<v Unidentified speaker>I had visited, you know, Black Futures Farms and other places or other spaces in the city that had regenerative agriculture as their primary north star, I would say.

1321
02:39:07.665 --> 02:39:18.769
<v Unidentified speaker>But for me, engaging with the community meant connecting with Meg Horst, who is an extraordinary advocate for regenerative agriculture, like really being able to lean on the committee members that have expertise in that space.

1322
02:39:18.879 --> 02:39:28.407
<v Unidentified speaker>Space, and then leveraging those relationships to then explore more into what it looks like when PCF engages with, like I said, for me, Regenerative Ag.

1323
02:39:28.858 --> 02:39:36.666
<v Unidentified speaker>I've learned so much more than I would have ever thought I could have learned in a short amount of time just because of that proximity to somebody that is an expert.

1324
02:39:37.212 --> 02:39:51.766
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that for committee members that may have spots that have, I wouldn't say deficiencies, but spots where they have opportunities for more growth or Thank you.

1325
02:39:53.463 --> 02:40:06.719
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think it starts with taking advantage of the group and then expanding beyond that to the folks that care about that and the PCF members and the community members that have those things as their North Stars.

1326
02:40:10.850 --> 02:40:11.415
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, D'Angelo.

1327
02:40:11.500 --> 02:40:12.331
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, D'Angelo.

1328
02:40:12.412 --> 02:40:13.439
<v Angelita Morillo>Anyone else want to jump in?

1329
02:40:15.479 --> 02:40:19.912
<v Angelita Morillo>If not, just know that that might be a thing you will have to consider later on.

1330
02:40:21.233 --> 02:40:36.090
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't have a solid good answer for that other than I'm a group-oriented, group-working person that I would absolutely reach out for advice from other folks that may be their expertise, you know, like D'Angelo is talking about.

1331
02:40:36.560 --> 02:40:40.352
<v Unidentified speaker>And I am an open and that's how I approach it overall.

1332
02:40:40.593 --> 02:40:58.271
<v Unidentified speaker>I know that's a really generic answer and I don't have any specifics, but I would reach out to community members and listen, listen to folks that, that reach out to the PSAP committee and, and just take their, their input and really think about it.

1333
02:40:59.121 --> 02:40:59.572
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1334
02:41:00.021 --> 02:41:00.519
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1335
02:41:01.240 --> 02:41:02.605
<v Sameer Kanal>I would like to thank the presenters.

1336
02:41:03.040 --> 02:41:12.721
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll just add, I think stakeholder engagement happens at both a very formal level and process, and I have a lot of experience with that.

1337
02:41:12.771 --> 02:41:17.138
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think you can— it can be subject agnostic to the process.

1338
02:41:17.201 --> 02:41:48.209
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't need to be a specialist in transportation, which I'm not, just, you know, to be able to develop a process to make sure that the right people are at the table, that the right people are heard, that they have opportunities to provide, you know, written I also, you know, and that there's a process that they understand for how their input is incorporated and plays out, because it doesn't feel good to participate and then not know, you know, what happens in the end.

1339
02:41:49.559 --> 02:41:51.469
<v Unidentified speaker>And then it also happens informally.

1340
02:41:51.520 --> 02:41:55.139
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that you've got to be functioning at both levels.

1341
02:41:55.139 --> 02:41:57.399
<v Unidentified speaker>You have to have those formal processes, and you also have to be able to be flexible and flexible in your approach.

1342
02:41:57.399 --> 02:41:57.440
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1343
02:41:58.610 --> 02:42:05.770
<v Unidentified speaker>We all, we live here, we're immersed in this, and it can be— it doesn't, doesn't have to be a big formal process.

1344
02:42:06.260 --> 02:42:08.780
<v Unidentified speaker>So at both levels, I think you can engage.

1345
02:42:09.620 --> 02:42:11.530
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you so much, all of you, for your answers.

1346
02:42:11.559 --> 02:42:16.920
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think it's— I appreciate the humility in saying that maybe you're not an expert in transportation, but you'll find the right people.

1347
02:42:17.340 --> 02:42:21.489
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's an underrated quality in most leaders, so I appreciate that.

1348
02:42:21.620 --> 02:42:24.479
<v Angelita Morillo>I have one question for Randall, and then I will turn it over to Councilor Smith.

1349
02:42:27.680 --> 02:42:41.320
<v Angelita Morillo>Randall, not to put you on the spot, but I think one of the big issues of our time is going to be the intersection between construction of things like data centers and the clean energy movement and what we're trying to do here.

1350
02:42:42.542 --> 02:42:50.238
<v Angelita Morillo>Obviously, we know that data centers are extremely harmful to communities, create noise pollution, poison a lot of communities' waterways, all of those things.

1351
02:42:50.816 --> 02:43:05.322
<v Angelita Morillo>And they are often pushed forward by local governments because people want revenue, they want construction jobs, they want, you know, different sort of economic benefits that they believe this will provide in the short term at the expense of our environment in the long term.

1352
02:43:06.414 --> 02:43:12.228
<v Angelita Morillo>What is your position, or how would you sort of address that if there's a greenwashing movement for data centers at the local level?

1353
02:43:13.722 --> 02:43:15.826
<v Unidentified speaker>That is an excellent question, and it's a difficult question.

1354
02:43:15.940 --> 02:43:16.820
<v Unidentified speaker>That's a great question.

1355
02:43:17.558 --> 02:43:23.310
<v Unidentified speaker>We do obviously represent workers that perform that work on those data centers.

1356
02:43:24.128 --> 02:43:33.646
<v Unidentified speaker>I guess the best way for me to answer that is if there's some kind of conflict of interest or something like that that I'd have to bring up, I'd still be open-minded.

1357
02:43:33.759 --> 02:43:36.338
<v Unidentified speaker>I would talk through it and see what that looks like, right?

1358
02:43:36.403 --> 02:43:38.886
<v Unidentified speaker>It still comes down to a group decision.

1359
02:43:39.511 --> 02:43:41.962
<v Unidentified speaker>I really don't know how to answer that question.

1360
02:43:42.011 --> 02:43:42.155
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1361
02:43:42.716 --> 02:43:51.817
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, I have thought about those things, and, you know, it's still forefront is, is making sure that everybody in our community is, is served well.

1362
02:43:52.331 --> 02:44:04.333
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, and whatever happens with that, I, you know, I would absolutely reach out for all of our groups on the— with the, the, the board and discuss that and see what it is.

1363
02:44:04.380 --> 02:44:04.605
<v Angelita Morillo>It's—.

1364
02:44:05.165 --> 02:44:09.668
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not the only one that has a vote on that board or makes recommendations right?

1365
02:44:09.781 --> 02:44:11.091
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's still a group decision.

1366
02:44:11.430 --> 02:44:17.763
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, similar to you all, you all have difficult things that you have to— um, that's politics.

1367
02:44:18.370 --> 02:44:20.356
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't know how else to answer that.

1368
02:44:20.406 --> 02:44:22.344
<v Unidentified speaker>I hope that's sufficient.

1369
02:44:22.425 --> 02:44:24.947
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know, does that clear what I'm trying to say?

1370
02:44:27.742 --> 02:44:27.838
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

1371
02:44:29.033 --> 02:44:37.403
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, are, are you asking me directly, would I come out against, uh, Data centers or for data centers?

1372
02:44:38.819 --> 02:44:43.604
<v Angelita Morillo>I mean, I just think you're, you're in a very unique position, and I'm just acknowledging that.

1373
02:44:46.272 --> 02:44:53.603
<v Angelita Morillo>It's because— so yeah, if there's a situation where— I definitely see a future where they greenwash data centers.

1374
02:44:53.652 --> 02:44:58.131
<v Angelita Morillo>They say like, actually, this is magical for the environment, and this is great for electrification or something.

1375
02:44:58.230 --> 02:44:59.584
<v Angelita Morillo>Let's use PSF dollars for this.

1376
02:45:00.787 --> 02:45:07.841
<v Angelita Morillo>I put no limit in what sort of greenwashing campaigns can do to our movements in these spaces.

1377
02:45:08.018 --> 02:45:16.582
<v Angelita Morillo>So would you exempt yourself from a vote in that case if your workers were going to get construction contracts for that type of thing?

1378
02:45:16.693 --> 02:45:20.067
<v Angelita Morillo>Like, how does that— what is the line of efficacy for you?

1379
02:45:20.727 --> 02:45:21.819
<v Unidentified speaker>It would be case by case.

1380
02:45:21.868 --> 02:45:37.146
<v Unidentified speaker>The way I would kind of compare that, there's also other projects there's other, there's other work that we do that, that, um, would, would fall— would also be controversial.

1381
02:45:38.180 --> 02:45:40.884
<v Unidentified speaker>Every— that's where we're at, and that's where we're in a democracy, right?

1382
02:45:40.965 --> 02:45:45.875
<v Unidentified speaker>So we still have to work through those things and try to find fair and equitable solutions for that.

1383
02:45:45.940 --> 02:45:50.307
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't have anything specific in front of me to say yes or no.

1384
02:45:50.777 --> 02:45:51.816
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, I'm not being—.

1385
02:45:51.847 --> 02:45:51.945
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1386
02:45:52.138 --> 02:46:03.449
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, in the moment, I'm not working on anything with data centers, uh, in my role where I am and with our council, uh, so I really can't answer that because there's nothing specific to answer, right?

1387
02:46:03.529 --> 02:46:05.679
<v Unidentified speaker>So every situation is different.

1388
02:46:06.145 --> 02:46:08.149
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I, I don't know.

1389
02:46:08.310 --> 02:46:09.225
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know how to answer that.

1390
02:46:09.289 --> 02:46:25.274
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the only way that I can answer that is that it is politics, and there's times if, if I was stuck in a, in, in a conflict, then I'd have to recognize that and I would do whatever was ethical and legal and make sure that nothing shady happened, right?

1391
02:46:25.354 --> 02:46:30.720
<v Unidentified speaker>So just to be as, as direct as I can, I don't— is that clear?

1392
02:46:34.083 --> 02:46:35.078
<v Angelita Morillo>You're doing your best, man.

1393
02:46:35.352 --> 02:46:36.460
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a hard question.

1394
02:46:37.039 --> 02:46:41.570
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I think I, I understand what you're saying though, and, uh, I will just leave it at that.

1395
02:46:41.635 --> 02:46:41.971
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1396
02:46:43.209 --> 02:46:43.567
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1397
02:46:44.790 --> 02:46:45.868
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1398
02:46:45.933 --> 02:46:47.368
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll go to Councilor Ryan, then Avalos.

1399
02:46:47.981 --> 02:46:49.057
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair.

1400
02:46:49.585 --> 02:46:50.434
<v Dan Ryan>Good to see everyone.

1401
02:46:50.628 --> 02:46:51.460
<v Dan Ryan>Great process.

1402
02:46:51.654 --> 02:46:53.850
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I've sat through a few of these.

1403
02:46:53.897 --> 02:46:56.912
<v Dan Ryan>This is an outstanding slate of candidates.

1404
02:46:57.040 --> 02:47:02.810
<v Dan Ryan>Like it's been said before, I have a lot of respect for anyone that's on the Parkrose Budget Committee.

1405
02:47:02.954 --> 02:47:05.745
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for your service to the students and families in Parkrose.

1406
02:47:06.481 --> 02:47:13.631
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, kind of following up on some other things that have been said, I, I keep hoping that, you know, we need jobs right now.

1407
02:47:13.777 --> 02:47:14.611
<v Dan Ryan>Jobs, jobs, jobs.

1408
02:47:14.995 --> 02:47:21.302
<v Dan Ryan>I really don't think— I just have to put on the record that PSEF is going to take over any investments in data centers.

1409
02:47:21.512 --> 02:47:22.700
<v Dan Ryan>So just want to say that.

1410
02:47:23.325 --> 02:47:28.252
<v Dan Ryan>Um, but you will perhaps have some opportunities to look at some other crossover green industry.

1411
02:47:28.781 --> 02:47:36.853
<v Dan Ryan>And I think Portland fancies itself as a center of green industry, but I think a lot of people want to actually see the results of that.

1412
02:47:37.368 --> 02:47:40.299
<v Dan Ryan>I think we might be leading the nation in regulation Councilor Smith.

1413
02:47:40.299 --> 02:47:40.299
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

1414
02:47:40.299 --> 02:47:40.299
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

1415
02:47:40.299 --> 02:47:40.299
<v Dan Ryan>I think that's a great point.

1416
02:47:40.299 --> 02:47:44.200
<v Dan Ryan>We're leading the nation in green energy, but we probably aren't leading the nation in green industry jobs.

1417
02:47:44.559 --> 02:47:50.969
<v Dan Ryan>And so I do think that that is the bigger picture conversation that I hope that PCEP does take up.

1418
02:47:52.040 --> 02:47:56.270
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Kanal, Chair Kanal leaned over to me and said, are you gonna ask that question that you always ask?

1419
02:47:56.959 --> 02:47:59.270
<v Dan Ryan>And then I had to say, what's that question that I always ask?

1420
02:47:59.780 --> 02:48:05.979
<v Dan Ryan>And the question I often ask is, it gets to where Councilor Morella went with the conflict of interest.

1421
02:48:06.603 --> 02:48:08.802
<v Dan Ryan>So there will be times where you're in that.

1422
02:48:08.868 --> 02:48:11.452
<v Dan Ryan>So maybe I'd look to the two of you, Raphael and Sam.

1423
02:48:11.967 --> 02:48:15.996
<v Dan Ryan>What are some of the guidelines that you discuss when there is a conflict of interest?

1424
02:48:16.461 --> 02:48:17.200
<v Dan Ryan>I'm just curious.

1425
02:48:17.441 --> 02:48:20.493
<v Dan Ryan>I don't think I've ever heard the policy before the storm.

1426
02:48:21.681 --> 02:48:22.403
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilmembers.

1427
02:48:22.885 --> 02:48:24.811
<v Sameer Kanal>And thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1428
02:48:25.630 --> 02:48:36.131
<v Sameer Kanal>What we do is, one, when we onboard our committee members, what we'll do is go through a pretty rigorous training in terms of all the different ways they need to think about conflicts of interest.

1429
02:48:36.211 --> 02:48:42.779
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously there's the actual, there's the potential, and then there's the perceived, which is something we actively manage just because of the nature of the body.

1430
02:48:42.875 --> 02:48:45.252
<v Sameer Kanal>It's really important we manage even those perceptions of conflict.

1431
02:48:45.299 --> 02:48:47.564
<v Sameer Kanal>So one, we just baseline start with the training.

1432
02:48:48.110 --> 02:48:55.432
<v Sameer Kanal>Every single year we do a survey of our committee members to check in and say, have any of your conflicts, at least where you stand today, changed?

1433
02:48:55.977 --> 02:48:59.512
<v Sameer Kanal>Because there's just a recognition So that's the information at the front end that folks may have, things that may change.

1434
02:48:59.592 --> 02:49:07.240
<v Sameer Kanal>And then there's the active, every single meeting, anytime there's a decision coming up, committee members know decisions may be coming up.

1435
02:49:07.305 --> 02:49:17.236
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's something that we work with them through the training, that as decisions are coming up, it's not just what you tell us at the beginning of the year or annually, it's also actively managing it as you're about to make a decision.

1436
02:49:17.332 --> 02:49:22.666
<v Sameer Kanal>So we've had this happen where committee members ring me up and they'll say, hey, that decision is coming up in the next meeting.

1437
02:49:22.876 --> 02:49:25.638
<v Sameer Kanal>Want to tell you I've got a potential conflict, let's talk it through.

1438
02:49:25.781 --> 02:49:32.173
<v Sameer Kanal>And then we workshop it and we say, is this one that you actually need to sit out of and recuse yourself from that decision-making?

1439
02:49:32.525 --> 02:49:33.682
<v Sameer Kanal>And so that's exactly what we do.

1440
02:49:33.729 --> 02:49:46.317
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's a very active process where we train folks up front, annual surveys, and then play it on a meeting-by-meeting where committee members are expected to reach out based on the topics that are in front of them and let us know.

1441
02:49:46.398 --> 02:49:51.795
<v Sameer Kanal>And then we work through how they so Sam, you definitely have a process.

1442
02:49:51.908 --> 02:49:52.202
<v Steve Novick>Is it—.

1443
02:49:52.218 --> 02:49:52.546
<v Unidentified speaker>Did it—.

1444
02:49:52.546 --> 02:49:54.324
<v Dan Ryan>Was it created because of lived experience?

1445
02:49:55.947 --> 02:49:58.556
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, each time we learned, we're like, oh, we need to tighten that up.

1446
02:49:58.620 --> 02:49:59.989
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's, that's exactly right.

1447
02:50:00.069 --> 02:50:01.325
<v Dan Ryan>That's the best kind of practice.

1448
02:50:01.761 --> 02:50:08.566
<v Rafael Tamarki>If I may, Councilor, just to sort of add on, just to broaden it a bit, um, everyone on the committee, just like this council, we have communities of accountability.

1449
02:50:08.840 --> 02:50:21.727
<v Rafael Tamarki>I think we try to place a premium on transparency so people can both advocate and represent their position, the communities that they're among and the issues that they wanna uplift without feeling compromised or having to really hide the ball.

1450
02:50:21.921 --> 02:50:31.242
<v Rafael Tamarki>And so it is a tension that we hold, but by making everybody be upfront, we have more productive conversations and we're able to make more complex decisions.

1451
02:50:32.413 --> 02:50:34.772
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, and I'll just end with, of course, your job is political.

1452
02:50:34.819 --> 02:50:40.547
<v Dan Ryan>It's become more political because everyone's becoming more aware that PCF exists.

1453
02:50:41.494 --> 02:50:47.162
<v Dan Ryan>They understand that it's a largest— it seems to be a largest amount of money to invest.

1454
02:50:47.900 --> 02:50:52.236
<v Dan Ryan>And it's not just opinion pieces in the one daily newspaper, kind of daily newspaper.

1455
02:50:52.557 --> 02:50:55.720
<v Dan Ryan>It's just on the top of people's minds right now.

1456
02:50:55.784 --> 02:50:57.004
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you for leaning in.

1457
02:50:57.470 --> 02:51:00.152
<v Dan Ryan>You're building something with the community right now.

1458
02:51:00.682 --> 02:51:06.125
<v Dan Ryan>And I think a lot of people that weren't as engaged when it was brought to the ballot are now more and more engaged.

1459
02:51:06.700 --> 02:51:12.939
<v Dan Ryan>So you definitely are entering into probably one of our committees that will have the most interest.

1460
02:51:13.829 --> 02:51:13.958
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1461
02:51:14.906 --> 02:51:23.180
<v Dan Ryan>And I won't ask you what your opinion was of the recent editorial in a local media source because we have to start a meeting at 6 o'clock.

1462
02:51:23.662 --> 02:51:25.806
<v Dan Ryan>I think that's why this could go on for too long.

1463
02:51:25.998 --> 02:51:27.047
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for your interest.

1464
02:51:27.208 --> 02:51:28.513
<v Dan Ryan>I'm supportive of all 3 of you.

1465
02:51:30.109 --> 02:51:31.350
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1466
02:51:32.170 --> 02:51:34.144
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll go to Councilor Avalos and then myself.

1467
02:51:34.208 --> 02:51:34.930
<v Sameer Kanal>We're the last 2 in the queue.

1468
02:51:35.155 --> 02:51:35.941
<v Sameer Kanal>Take it away, Councilor Avalos.

1469
02:51:36.359 --> 02:51:36.711
<v Sameer Kanal>Sounds good.

1470
02:51:36.775 --> 02:51:37.192
<v Rafael Tamarki>Thank you.

1471
02:51:38.059 --> 02:51:42.618
<v Candace Avalos>First, I'll just say PSEF is political because energy and climate resilience is political.

1472
02:51:42.715 --> 02:51:44.238
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, look at the federal government.

1473
02:51:44.304 --> 02:51:50.868
<v Candace Avalos>They are literally doing everything they can to stop us from protecting against a very uncertain climate future.

1474
02:51:51.317 --> 02:51:54.688
<v Candace Avalos>So it's not about PSEF, it's about climate is political.

1475
02:51:54.833 --> 02:51:55.876
<v Candace Avalos>So I just needed to say that.

1476
02:51:56.502 --> 02:52:02.441
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much to everyone who applied to serve on the PSEF committee, and congratulations Congratulations to the individuals before us today.

1477
02:52:02.537 --> 02:52:04.126
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks to the staff for the recruitment.

1478
02:52:04.462 --> 02:52:09.245
<v Candace Avalos>Seems like you all really did a good job in getting a wide range of perspectives and expertise.

1479
02:52:09.343 --> 02:52:15.234
<v Candace Avalos>And so I'm really looking forward to seeing how that benefits the PCEF and definitely plan to support all of your appointments today.

1480
02:52:16.245 --> 02:52:24.415
<v Candace Avalos>As we know, the committee plays a very critical role in helping Portland deliver on one of the most ambitious climate and environmental justice programs in the country.

1481
02:52:24.847 --> 02:52:31.975
<v Candace Avalos>And so your work is going to help shape these investments in clean energy and workforce development And green infrastructure, transportation, housing, all of that.

1482
02:52:32.457 --> 02:52:35.394
<v Candace Avalos>And ultimately community wellbeing for years to come.

1483
02:52:36.405 --> 02:52:49.134
<v Candace Avalos>So I just wanted to take a moment to share how I think about the relationship between this committee and the council, because as you're hearing, this continues to evolve and we need as a council to provide direction to you all about our expectations.

1484
02:52:50.593 --> 02:52:55.313
<v Candace Avalos>I do not believe that this committee exists for council to simply rubber stamp every recommendation.

1485
02:52:55.730 --> 02:53:00.289
<v Candace Avalos>Council has an independent responsibility to exercise judgment and make difficult policy decisions.

1486
02:53:00.370 --> 02:53:00.610
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1487
02:53:00.610 --> 02:53:09.170
<v Candace Avalos>I believe that we should be able to make informed decisions, but I also do not believe that the council should just casually substitute our own preferences for a thoughtful community process without a compelling reason.

1488
02:53:09.270 --> 02:53:17.629
<v Candace Avalos>And the members of this committee devote an enormous amount of time and lived experience and deliberation to these decisions, and that work matters and it deserves respect.

1489
02:53:18.049 --> 02:53:30.842
<v Candace Avalos>And when council chooses to depart from a recommendation, especially because we're in the middle of a CIP, I believe that we owe the public and the committee a clear explanation that's grounded in evidence and policy and the public interest, not just in our thank you.

1490
02:53:32.028 --> 02:53:39.543
<v Candace Avalos>As we continue adapting to the new form of government, I want to make a commitment to strengthening the governance relationship between the council and the committee.

1491
02:53:40.361 --> 02:53:49.560
<v Candace Avalos>That commitment feels especially important as we're heading into another climate investment plan process where difficult trade-offs and strategic decisions are going to inevitably arise.

1492
02:53:50.138 --> 02:53:53.456
<v Candace Avalos>And I also want the committee to know that my office is a partner to you.

1493
02:53:53.904 --> 02:54:00.619
<v Candace Avalos>I want to hear directly from members about what information, communication, or tools that you need to help make these complex decisions well.

1494
02:54:01.211 --> 02:54:07.833
<v Candace Avalos>So if there are any ways that we can strengthen accountability and transparency or better support your work, I want to be part of that conversation.

1495
02:54:09.050 --> 02:54:19.743
<v Candace Avalos>And finally, I just want to address a narrative that has surfaced in some of our recent debates, the idea that if one individual investment shifts from one category to another, somehow the entire mission of PSEF has been abandoned.

1496
02:54:20.048 --> 02:54:21.170
<v Candace Avalos>I simply do not see it that way.

1497
02:54:21.971 --> 02:54:24.280
<v Candace Avalos>The climate investment plan is a portfolio.

1498
02:54:24.681 --> 02:54:27.790
<v Candace Avalos>It should be evaluated as a whole, not litigated line by line.

1499
02:54:28.543 --> 02:54:32.279
<v Candace Avalos>PSEF is already making substantial investments in transportation and transportation-related climate change.

1500
02:54:32.343 --> 02:54:32.486
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1501
02:54:32.791 --> 02:54:33.433
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1502
02:54:33.834 --> 02:54:41.262
<v Candace Avalos>And at the same time, it invests in building decarbonization and renewable energy, workforce development, and resilience for frontline communities.

1503
02:54:41.453 --> 02:54:55.859
<v Candace Avalos>And so I think that sometimes the most responsible thing that we can do is recognize when a particular project category is not yet ready to deploy funding at scale and temporarily prioritize investments that are shovel-ready and can deliver emissions reductions and community benefits immediately.

1504
02:54:56.692 --> 02:54:58.409
<v Candace Avalos>That is not abandoning transportation.

1505
02:54:58.522 --> 02:54:59.805
<v Candace Avalos>It is exercising good stewardship.

1506
02:55:00.943 --> 02:55:14.032
<v Candace Avalos>I worry that when we create false binaries that suggest climate investments must compete against one another, or that supporting housing decarbonization somehow means that we're neglecting transportation, this is a false choice.

1507
02:55:14.177 --> 02:55:15.349
<v Candace Avalos>We can and should do both.

1508
02:55:15.925 --> 02:55:22.004
<v Candace Avalos>The question is how we sequence investments to maximize their impact while remaining faithful to the vision of Portland voters.

1509
02:55:22.534 --> 02:55:25.502
<v Candace Avalos>So to me, that vision has always been bigger than any single line item.

1510
02:55:25.663 --> 02:55:27.299
<v Candace Avalos>It's about building a healthier, more resilient city.

1511
02:55:27.362 --> 02:55:27.490
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1512
02:55:28.148 --> 02:55:38.658
<v Candace Avalos>It's about reducing climate pollution, and it's about investing in the communities that have historically borne the greatest environmental burdens and ensuring that the benefits of the clean energy transition are shared broadly.

1513
02:55:39.204 --> 02:55:50.084
<v Candace Avalos>And so I'm really grateful to the incoming community members for stepping up to lead that work, and I'm eagerly looking forward to partnering with you as we continue to strengthen PSEF and deliver on that promise for Portlanders.

1514
02:55:50.131 --> 02:55:51.367
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you again for your service.

1515
02:55:52.120 --> 02:55:54.014
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1516
02:55:54.352 --> 02:55:57.945
<v Sameer Kanal>I thought that Councilor Smith's hand was a legacy hand, so I apologize for that.

1517
02:55:57.994 --> 02:55:58.747
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm happy to go to you.

1518
02:55:59.664 --> 02:56:02.716
<v Sameer Kanal>We do have a hard stop, so I'd ask if you could keep it brief, but thank you.

1519
02:56:02.957 --> 02:56:10.332
<v Loretta Smith>No, I just want to say I thank you all for even stepping up to this, and I just want you all to know that you are enough.

1520
02:56:11.297 --> 02:56:15.569
<v Loretta Smith>You are enough in yourself, in your history, and what you know.

1521
02:56:16.197 --> 02:56:17.948
<v Loretta Smith>Because as you see, we have 12 people.

1522
02:56:18.140 --> 02:56:28.123
<v Loretta Smith>We all didn't have political experience here, and some of this stuff we have to learn along the way, but we wanted to do it, and we were up for the challenge.

1523
02:56:28.494 --> 02:56:30.296
<v Loretta Smith>And I think you all are up for the challenge.

1524
02:56:30.924 --> 02:56:32.163
<v Loretta Smith>So just know that you're enough.

1525
02:56:32.977 --> 02:56:33.397
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1526
02:56:36.212 --> 02:56:37.166
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1527
02:56:38.316 --> 02:56:43.932
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, I'm next and last in the queue, uh, and I, I just— a couple quick process notes.

1528
02:56:44.045 --> 02:57:01.313
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I, uh, would love it if in future we can see the full list of who all is being appointed in these reports, uh, as well as who's continuing on with start and end I'm interested in seeing if it's possible to align the term end dates so we don't have to do this again where there's a lag.

1529
02:57:01.361 --> 02:57:07.799
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it'd be great if D'Angelo could serve until, what is it, July 23rd of 2030 as well, for example.

1530
02:57:07.863 --> 02:57:09.260
<v Sameer Kanal>And just wanted to get that out there.

1531
02:57:09.565 --> 02:57:12.183
<v Sameer Kanal>I also wanted to praise you for the high number of applicants.

1532
02:57:12.841 --> 02:57:18.363
<v Sameer Kanal>That ratio is really great of the number of applicants to number of vacancies, and I think a testament to the work that you do.

1533
02:57:18.459 --> 02:57:18.700
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1534
02:57:18.941 --> 02:57:23.375
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think this is more in Rafael's shop within your staff, Director Barrasso.

1535
02:57:23.456 --> 02:57:25.711
<v Sameer Kanal>But so praise specifically there, Rafael.

1536
02:57:25.792 --> 02:57:28.274
<v Sameer Kanal>But yeah, I just wanted to get that on the record.

1537
02:57:28.649 --> 02:57:30.915
<v Sameer Kanal>I also wanted to specifically praise the applicants.

1538
02:57:31.494 --> 02:57:43.579
<v Sameer Kanal>The backgrounds that are very relevant to this I think have been said, but I wanted to highlight a couple things that maybe weren't— aren't directly related in an obvious sense, but I think will be very beneficial.

1539
02:57:43.969 --> 02:57:49.041
<v Sameer Kanal>Tamara, as a co-founder of My People's Market, Something that I thought was really great to bring up.

1540
02:57:49.814 --> 02:58:04.433
<v Sameer Kanal>Council President already mentioned the Parkrose Budget Committee for you, Danielle, and I, in addition to being gluttonous for punishment, I think that's also really valuable from the perspective that that is functionally a lot of what this is, this particular work.

1541
02:58:05.800 --> 02:58:14.752
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to thank Randall for the specific responses that related to your background, but also the Metropolitan Alliance for Workforce Equity, which we've talked about.

1542
02:58:14.800 --> 02:58:14.898
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1543
02:58:15.049 --> 02:58:20.879
<v Sameer Kanal>About in other contexts on this dais is something that I think is, is a very relevant experience as well.

1544
02:58:20.944 --> 02:58:25.666
<v Sameer Kanal>As for D'Angelo, I, I think I can just rattle off all the whole background, so I won't.

1545
02:58:25.924 --> 02:58:38.260
<v Sameer Kanal>But I will say, um, that the, the way in which we determine that public investments yield, um, back benefits for not only the community but specific communities, I think, is a really relevant thing.

1546
02:58:38.596 --> 02:58:44.602
<v Sameer Kanal>And, and, um, I'm appreciative of I also should disclose I have met D'Angelo a couple times.

1547
02:58:44.665 --> 02:58:49.584
<v Sameer Kanal>We— I feel like everybody here has met Randall several times in this other capacity as well.

1548
02:58:52.342 --> 02:58:56.213
<v Sameer Kanal>I intend to be supportive as well when we get to this at the full council as well as here.

1549
02:58:56.760 --> 02:59:07.022
<v Sameer Kanal>But at this moment, I did want to just opine on one thing about PSEF, which is I think there's a really interesting conversation here that you're going to be at the forefront of.

1550
02:59:07.086 --> 02:59:17.927
<v Sameer Kanal>And from the process perspective, Setting aside the content, I am really interested in the conversation around better and more frequent communication with council that Councilor Novick brought up.

1551
02:59:19.130 --> 02:59:33.885
<v Sameer Kanal>Not specifically to achieve any particular goal, but because I do think there are— when council is not directly engaged on a regularized basis, then we get to those high-stakes moments where there's a desire to make a more blunt change.

1552
02:59:34.659 --> 02:59:47.439
<v Sameer Kanal>That is usually more adversarial than it needs to be, or where other branches of government— I think there was an example, the mayor putting something into the amendments this year that did not come out of the same process.

1553
02:59:48.278 --> 02:59:52.990
<v Sameer Kanal>So I definitely think that these are things that we need to communicate on because the final vote is ours.

1554
02:59:53.586 --> 03:00:03.433
<v Sameer Kanal>And so if we're able to talk ahead of time, we can say, hey, look, if this— if these amendments have this in it or don't have this in it, that affects my vote so you know in advance.

1555
03:00:03.531 --> 03:00:07.540
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not a surprise, it's not a feeling of betrayal or anything like that.

1556
03:00:07.799 --> 03:00:11.935
<v Sameer Kanal>It's, hey, maybe we don't need Councilor Kanal on this one, you know, but we can at least talk it out.

1557
03:00:12.307 --> 03:00:21.394
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that regular communication structure is really vital in that particular process of the CIP amendments.

1558
03:00:22.760 --> 03:00:24.606
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that, the queue is exhausted.

1559
03:00:24.655 --> 03:00:28.818
<v Sameer Kanal>We do need a motion to refer this report on to council with the recommendation.

1560
03:00:28.868 --> 03:00:28.996
<v Unidentified speaker>So moved.

1561
03:00:29.180 --> 03:00:29.421
<v Unidentified speaker>So moved.

1562
03:00:29.871 --> 03:00:30.388
<v Steve Novick>Second.

1563
03:00:31.307 --> 03:00:34.400
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to give that one to Councilor Novick.

1564
03:00:35.860 --> 03:00:41.066
<v Sameer Kanal>So Councilor Clark made the motion, and I assume Councilor Clark with a recommendation that it be accepted?

1565
03:00:41.372 --> 03:00:41.761
<v Loretta Smith>Absolutely.

1566
03:00:41.954 --> 03:00:42.924
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1567
03:00:43.328 --> 03:00:45.301
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there any further discussion on the motion?

1568
03:00:48.430 --> 03:00:54.699
<v Angelita Morillo>So for clarity, this will go to full council and then it will be discussed and voted on there to officially give the position.

1569
03:00:55.792 --> 03:00:56.593
<v Sameer Kanal>That is correct.

1570
03:00:56.737 --> 03:01:04.365
<v Sameer Kanal>And if it is referred out from the Committee of the Whole with a recommendation that it be accepted, uh, Council President generally puts it on the consent agenda.

1571
03:01:04.445 --> 03:01:06.864
<v Sameer Kanal>It obviously could be removed from that, but yeah.

1572
03:01:07.154 --> 03:01:07.729
<v Angelita Morillo>Great, thank you.

1573
03:01:09.173 --> 03:01:09.493
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1574
03:01:09.798 --> 03:01:12.825
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, any further discussion?

1575
03:01:13.884 --> 03:01:15.084
<v Sameer Kanal>Rebecca, will you please call the roll?

1576
03:01:16.527 --> 03:01:20.117
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, on the motion moved by Clark, seconded by Novick, Pirtle-Guiney.

1577
03:01:20.773 --> 03:01:23.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all for stepping Up to serve, aye.

1578
03:01:24.709 --> 03:01:24.935
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan.

1579
03:01:25.290 --> 03:01:25.337
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1580
03:01:26.318 --> 03:01:27.735
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you all.

1581
03:01:28.104 --> 03:01:28.218
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1582
03:01:29.779 --> 03:01:29.906
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1583
03:01:31.886 --> 03:01:33.189
<v Steve Novick>Really impressed by your backgrounds.

1584
03:01:33.478 --> 03:01:33.495
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1585
03:01:34.041 --> 03:01:34.459
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark.

1586
03:01:35.006 --> 03:01:35.056
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1587
03:01:35.650 --> 03:01:35.876
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green.

1588
03:01:36.697 --> 03:01:36.859
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1589
03:01:37.990 --> 03:01:38.298
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos.

1590
03:01:39.445 --> 03:01:39.494
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1591
03:01:40.334 --> 03:01:40.722
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy.

1592
03:01:40.981 --> 03:01:41.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1593
03:01:42.308 --> 03:01:42.663
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith.

1594
03:01:43.325 --> 03:01:43.359
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1595
03:01:44.393 --> 03:01:44.764
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal.

1596
03:01:45.768 --> 03:01:46.336
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks for stepping up.

1597
03:01:46.420 --> 03:01:46.452
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1598
03:01:47.227 --> 03:01:50.381
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the motion is approved with 11 ayes, Anyone absent?

1599
03:01:51.015 --> 03:01:54.770
<v Rebecca Dobert>The item will be referred to full council with a recommend— do pass recommendation.

1600
03:01:56.120 --> 03:01:56.393
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1601
03:01:56.474 --> 03:01:57.165
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, everybody.

1602
03:01:57.665 --> 03:02:02.497
<v Sameer Kanal>Just before wrapping up, you can see the full agenda as planned in the Committee of the Whole chair update.

1603
03:02:02.577 --> 03:02:06.462
<v Sameer Kanal>But next week's meeting, which will be back on Thursday, is a budget process recap.

1604
03:02:06.867 --> 03:02:15.131
<v Sameer Kanal>Please come not grievance-oriented, but with specific ideas and feedback, as well as a follow-up on the budget note, Muriel 11.5.

1605
03:02:15.229 --> 03:02:18.102
<v Sameer Kanal>From last year, which related to communication between the branches of government.

1606
03:02:18.654 --> 03:02:19.174
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thanks so much.

1607
03:02:19.222 --> 03:02:19.968
<v Sameer Kanal>See you all at 6.

1608
03:02:20.195 --> 03:02:20.764
<v Sameer Kanal>This meeting is adjourned.

