WEBVTT

1
00:06:11.422 --> 00:06:15.899
<v Josh Roper>All right, we're starting.

2
00:06:17.702 --> 00:06:18.555
<v Candace Avalos>Good afternoon.

3
00:06:18.668 --> 00:06:29.274
<v Candace Avalos>I am going to call the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee to order at 2:02 PM on Tuesday, June 6th, good afternoon.

4
00:06:29.790 --> 00:06:30.209
<v Diego>Pirtle-Guiney?

5
00:06:32.677 --> 00:06:33.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absent.

6
00:06:33.322 --> 00:06:33.790
<v Diego>Koyama Lane?

7
00:06:34.290 --> 00:06:34.548
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

8
00:06:35.192 --> 00:06:35.677
<v Diego>Novick?

9
00:06:36.387 --> 00:06:36.810
<v Steve Novick>Here.

10
00:06:37.199 --> 00:06:37.507
<v Diego>Green?

11
00:06:38.190 --> 00:06:38.466
<v Mitch Green>Here.

12
00:06:39.067 --> 00:06:39.345
<v Diego>Avalos?

13
00:06:39.490 --> 00:06:39.880
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

14
00:06:40.627 --> 00:06:42.009
<v Candace Avalos>Clerk, please read the statement of conduct.

15
00:06:43.329 --> 00:06:43.827
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Chair.

16
00:06:44.149 --> 00:06:46.627
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good afternoon and welcome to the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

17
00:06:47.062 --> 00:06:52.435
<v Rebecca Dobert>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at portland.gov/councilmeetingrequest.

18
00:06:56.925 --> 00:07:01.389
<v Rebecca Dobert>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

19
00:07:01.903 --> 00:07:04.519
<v Rebecca Dobert>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

20
00:07:05.259 --> 00:07:10.380
<v Rebecca Dobert>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

21
00:07:10.975 --> 00:07:12.822
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

22
00:07:13.463 --> 00:07:14.362
<v Rebecca Dobert>The chair preserves order.

23
00:07:14.524 --> 00:07:21.952
<v Rebecca Dobert>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, Or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

24
00:07:22.774 --> 00:07:24.692
<v Rebecca Dobert>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

25
00:07:25.029 --> 00:07:27.108
<v Rebecca Dobert>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

26
00:07:27.810 --> 00:07:30.627
<v Rebecca Dobert>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

27
00:07:31.286 --> 00:07:34.088
<v Rebecca Dobert>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

28
00:07:34.949 --> 00:07:36.663
<v Rebecca Dobert>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

29
00:07:36.759 --> 00:07:38.699
<v Rebecca Dobert>When testifying, state your name for the record.

30
00:07:39.185 --> 00:07:41.562
<v Rebecca Dobert>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

31
00:07:42.257 --> 00:07:45.459
<v Rebecca Dobert>And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

32
00:07:45.718 --> 00:07:45.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

33
00:07:46.572 --> 00:07:47.134
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Claire.

34
00:07:47.761 --> 00:07:49.833
<v Candace Avalos>We have 4 main items on today's agenda.

35
00:07:49.944 --> 00:07:54.134
<v Candace Avalos>First, we will have time for public comment on housing and permitting issues of concern or interest.

36
00:07:54.600 --> 00:07:58.389
<v Candace Avalos>Then we will hear a resolution on Phase 2 of the Code Alignment Project.

37
00:07:58.776 --> 00:08:01.408
<v Candace Avalos>And then we have 2 ordinances from the Housing Bureau.

38
00:08:02.130 --> 00:08:09.050
<v Candace Avalos>Before we get to those items though, we need to adopt committee minutes for our meetings on April 7th and May 5th.

39
00:08:09.870 --> 00:08:13.098
<v Candace Avalos>So these minutes are approved by an unanimous consent.

40
00:08:13.199 --> 00:08:14.095
<v Candace Avalos>Are there any objections?

41
00:08:16.088 --> 00:08:18.557
<v Candace Avalos>With no objection, the minutes are approved.

42
00:08:19.250 --> 00:08:20.639
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, please read item 2.

43
00:08:21.687 --> 00:08:24.689
<v Diego>Item 2, Housing and Permitting Community Feedback.

44
00:08:25.237 --> 00:08:28.932
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so now we are going to hear from community members on their feedback for our committee.

45
00:08:29.677 --> 00:08:31.639
<v Candace Avalos>Um, each testifier will have 3 minutes.

46
00:08:31.802 --> 00:08:33.211
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, go ahead and call up the first person.

47
00:08:34.049 --> 00:08:38.339
<v Diego>First we have Lacy Sutton, followed by Michael Harrison.

48
00:08:43.436 --> 00:08:44.052
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

49
00:08:44.149 --> 00:08:46.224
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead and introduce yourself and go ahead.

50
00:08:46.272 --> 00:08:46.952
<v Lacey Sutton>Lacey Sutton.

51
00:08:48.023 --> 00:09:05.568
<v Lacey Sutton>Um, so I found what I believe is a loophole in Title 33, and unlike most of the problems I come here to tell you about, this one could be pretty easily fixed with the addition of one sentence: a follow-up pre-application conference will be required if the project changes significantly from what was originally presented.

52
00:09:06.087 --> 00:09:12.025
<v Lacey Sutton>That's in Gresham's code and a lot of other city codes, but so far as I can tell, we don't We don't have anything like that in ours.

53
00:09:12.462 --> 00:09:23.912
<v Lacey Sutton>If we did, then I wouldn't have to be here today because I think this omission laid the groundwork for all our other problems at Cherry Blossom years after Habitat for Humanity purchased the property.

54
00:09:24.623 --> 00:09:27.192
<v Lacey Sutton>Let me explain, try, in 3 minutes.

55
00:09:28.581 --> 00:09:34.692
<v Lacey Sutton>In 2014, the city held a pre-app to discuss the development of 30 2-story houses.

56
00:09:34.885 --> 00:09:49.554
<v Lacey Sutton>Kerry Schimmel, who's now our fire marshal, reviewed those plans, and when the architect submitted the application for Type 3 design review, he included the fire code requirements she discussed at that meeting, but due to missing information, the application was placed on a 180-day hold.

57
00:09:50.035 --> 00:10:04.046
<v Lacey Sutton>After that, they requested 2 consecutive 100— or sorry, 120-day extensions as they proposed several entirely different developments, including a 5-story, 146-unit apartment building, which the Mill Park neighborhood rejected.

58
00:10:04.606 --> 00:10:09.753
<v Lacey Sutton>Finally, the Design Commission held a DAR to consider 31 townhome-style apartments.

59
00:10:10.217 --> 00:10:13.054
<v Lacey Sutton>During this recorded meeting, they discussed fire code requirements.

60
00:10:13.360 --> 00:10:17.047
<v Lacey Sutton>At one point, a commission commissioner asked, how are you getting away with that dead end for fire?

61
00:10:17.447 --> 00:10:24.804
<v Lacey Sutton>And the architect replied, there's pathways with the Portland Fire Department by using sprinklers with the townhomes as well as certain streetlights based on height.

62
00:10:25.285 --> 00:10:36.105
<v Lacey Sutton>In his plans, the buildings were 29 feet 11 inches tall, 1 inch under the maximum height for ground ladder usage, and the street was 26 feet wide— plenty of room for fire trucks.

63
00:10:36.427 --> 00:10:41.027
<v Lacey Sutton>He also said there was a turnaround near the entrance which effectively shortened the distance to the dead end.

64
00:10:41.477 --> 00:10:44.932
<v Lacey Sutton>But he didn't write any of that down, and none of it made it into the staff report.

65
00:10:45.383 --> 00:10:55.179
<v Lacey Sutton>The Design Commission went on to approve 8 apartment buildings with 31 units in 2017 using the original application submitted for 2-story standalone houses.

66
00:10:55.679 --> 00:11:03.490
<v Lacey Sutton>They checked the required pre-app box with a conference that took place 2 and a half years prior when Carrie Schimmel looked at houses.

67
00:11:04.330 --> 00:11:11.037
<v Lacey Sutton>If a second pre-app had been required due to these massive changes in the proposal, the Fire Bureau would have said multifamily apartment buildings need sprinklers.

68
00:11:13.552 --> 00:11:18.794
<v Lacey Sutton>A turnaround and signage, et cetera.

69
00:11:19.263 --> 00:11:20.650
<v Lacey Sutton>But they didn't even see it.

70
00:11:21.119 --> 00:11:22.797
<v Lacey Sutton>I'm not sure any of the bureaus did.

71
00:11:23.071 --> 00:11:26.434
<v Lacey Sutton>The reviews attached to that land use approval are for the houses.

72
00:11:27.114 --> 00:11:32.047
<v Lacey Sutton>So when Habitat bought that property, it had zero fire safety requirements.

73
00:11:32.288 --> 00:11:36.034
<v Lacey Sutton>And they took that like the blank check that it was and cashed it.

74
00:11:36.533 --> 00:11:40.020
<v Lacey Sutton>They built an entire housing development without any fire safety.

75
00:11:40.407 --> 00:11:49.878
<v Lacey Sutton>No sprinklers, no turnaround, no signage, no hydrant, no anything for buildings there were a lot of failure points along the way.

76
00:11:50.442 --> 00:11:53.639
<v Lacey Sutton>This loophole in Title 33 is just the first of them.

77
00:11:54.140 --> 00:11:55.980
<v Lacey Sutton>One sentence would have prevented all of this.

78
00:11:56.561 --> 00:11:59.378
<v Lacey Sutton>Please consider adopting it so this doesn't happen again.

79
00:11:59.700 --> 00:12:00.102
<v Lacey Sutton>Thank you.

80
00:12:01.149 --> 00:12:01.631
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Lacy.

81
00:12:02.292 --> 00:12:02.533
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

82
00:12:04.144 --> 00:12:07.054
<v Michael Harrison>Good afternoon, Chair Avalos and members of the council.

83
00:12:07.216 --> 00:12:08.840
<v Michael Harrison>Thank you for the opportunity to be here today.

84
00:12:10.489 --> 00:12:11.711
<v Michael Harrison>I sort of have 3 things today.

85
00:12:11.856 --> 00:12:12.378
<v Michael Harrison>One is a thank you.

86
00:12:12.443 --> 00:12:13.307
<v Michael Harrison>The other is an apology.

87
00:12:13.355 --> 00:12:13.860
<v Michael Harrison>And the third is a question.

88
00:12:17.149 --> 00:12:28.328
<v Michael Harrison>First, thank you, because the work of this committee, the work of city staff, and the work of council in general, I've noticed, is really an attempt to kind of hone code so that it's effective to meet goals.

89
00:12:29.471 --> 00:12:37.763
<v Michael Harrison>But at the same time, it isn't just sort of regulations for regulation's sake, because they're— and so definitely appreciate that, that move.

90
00:12:37.812 --> 00:12:39.294
<v Michael Harrison>Apology is a very important part of the work that we do.

91
00:12:39.375 --> 00:12:39.505
<v Michael Harrison>Thank you.

92
00:12:39.802 --> 00:12:49.395
<v Michael Harrison>Because there's been a flurry of really good activity, including the Recap 11 item that this committee passed out at your last hearing.

93
00:12:50.390 --> 00:12:56.294
<v Michael Harrison>And I haven't been able to sort of necessarily always absorb the impacts that that would have.

94
00:12:56.486 --> 00:12:57.947
<v Michael Harrison>Sorry, maybe I didn't introduce myself.

95
00:12:58.010 --> 00:13:00.225
<v Michael Harrison>Michael Harrison, Oregon Health and Science University.

96
00:13:00.288 --> 00:13:05.648
<v Michael Harrison>Don't necessarily always fully appreciate and understand the impacts thank you.

97
00:13:05.696 --> 00:13:27.826
<v Michael Harrison>I'm not always aware of the impacts of all the regulations when they're proposed, and I didn't catch until after RECAP 11 passed one particular item, the redefinition of mechanical equipment that was included in RECAP 11, that the impacts that that would have on OHSU as well as sort of other large campus environments and probably as well on smaller properties as well.

98
00:13:29.190 --> 00:13:39.799
<v Michael Harrison>In a nutshell, city code So if it requires a mechanical permit, it's mechanical equipment and therefore requires screening.

99
00:13:40.259 --> 00:13:44.740
<v Michael Harrison>But the definition that is used has been, does it require a mechanical permit?

100
00:13:44.740 --> 00:13:51.659
<v Michael Harrison>So if it requires a mechanical permit, it's mechanical equipment and therefore requires screening.

101
00:13:51.659 --> 00:13:58.279
<v Michael Harrison>But the redefining of mechanical equipment that happened with RECAP 11 that's heading to council on Monday, I believe, is a different full definition.

102
00:13:58.279 --> 00:13:58.299
<v Michael Harrison>Okay.

103
00:13:58.429 --> 00:14:10.370
<v Michael Harrison>Council on the 24th includes a lot of things like gas meters, EV charging equipment, and other equipment that is sort of ubiquitous kind of across our campus.

104
00:14:11.051 --> 00:14:14.408
<v Michael Harrison>And requiring it to be screened would have several effects.

105
00:14:14.472 --> 00:14:16.110
<v Michael Harrison>One, it would just be very expensive to do.

106
00:14:16.660 --> 00:14:20.857
<v Michael Harrison>Two, depending on how it's screened, it can make it more difficult to maintain the equipment.

107
00:14:21.263 --> 00:14:26.653
<v Michael Harrison>And three, sometimes the equipment is located in areas where there's not a natural way to screen it.

108
00:14:26.750 --> 00:14:31.076
<v Michael Harrison>It's like too close to a building, too close to a drive aisle, too close to a sidewalk.

109
00:14:32.357 --> 00:14:36.956
<v Michael Harrison>So the last item is a request for guidance.

110
00:14:37.422 --> 00:14:50.065
<v Michael Harrison>I know that under the new council structure, there's a desire for committee work to be the area where things get resolved, and, and then things would happen faster at the full council.

111
00:14:51.037 --> 00:14:57.618
<v Michael Harrison>Obviously I'm too late because this item isn't on the agenda today, so I'm just not sure kind of what to do.

112
00:14:57.730 --> 00:15:06.917
<v Michael Harrison>And there's a letter here from 3 of our institutions, so if folks could give us some guidance as to what we should do, we'd appreciate it.

113
00:15:07.176 --> 00:15:07.693
<v Michael Harrison>Thank you so much.

114
00:15:10.311 --> 00:15:10.667
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

115
00:15:10.731 --> 00:15:12.692
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor— Vice Chair Green, did you have a comment?

116
00:15:13.323 --> 00:15:13.679
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

117
00:15:14.134 --> 00:15:24.491
<v Mitch Green>I put my hand up to ask a question of Lacey from earlier testimony, but I think I could offer here, I would really encourage you to email this document to the full council.

118
00:15:25.038 --> 00:15:25.198
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

119
00:15:25.535 --> 00:15:29.708
<v Mitch Green>So that way we understand what to consider as we deal with that then.

120
00:15:29.869 --> 00:15:29.932
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

121
00:15:30.014 --> 00:15:31.730
<v Mitch Green>That's probably the best way to move forward at this point.

122
00:15:32.035 --> 00:15:32.581
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

123
00:15:32.966 --> 00:15:33.174
<v Michael Harrison>And then—.

124
00:15:33.865 --> 00:15:34.171
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

125
00:15:34.346 --> 00:15:37.445
<v Mitch Green>If you could please come back for just a moment, Ms. Sutton.

126
00:15:38.841 --> 00:15:43.287
<v Mitch Green>I just wanted to know, have you submitted that sentence that you referred to in writing?

127
00:15:43.655 --> 00:15:44.908
<v Mitch Green>And if you haven't, will you please?

128
00:15:45.583 --> 00:15:46.489
<v Lacey Sutton>I would be happy to.

129
00:15:46.553 --> 00:15:50.855
<v Lacey Sutton>Yeah, I've submitted a lot in writing, but I don't think I have— I've gotten that far.

130
00:15:50.921 --> 00:15:53.768
<v Mitch Green>Wasn't able to, to write that down as you said it verbally.

131
00:15:53.913 --> 00:15:55.501
<v Lacey Sutton>I really appreciate you listening.

132
00:15:56.184 --> 00:15:56.639
<v Lacey Sutton>Thank you.

133
00:15:57.630 --> 00:15:58.182
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you both.

134
00:15:58.702 --> 00:15:59.807
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, please call the next person.

135
00:16:02.042 --> 00:16:11.225
<v Diego>Next we have Cynthia Carmina Gomez, followed by Sid Hariharan Gott.

136
00:16:18.951 --> 00:16:19.274
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>Welcome.

137
00:16:19.323 --> 00:16:22.332
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, and members of the committee.

138
00:16:22.769 --> 00:16:25.163
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>For the record, my name is Cynthia Carmina Gomez.

139
00:16:25.277 --> 00:16:30.264
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>I serve as the Director of Local Government and Community Relations for Portland State University.

140
00:16:31.761 --> 00:16:35.472
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>Thank you for the opportunity to testify, and my apologies for the timing.

141
00:16:35.537 --> 00:16:37.754
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>I echo Michael's, um, apologies.

142
00:16:38.188 --> 00:16:45.216
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>While Recap 11 was— has passed this committee and heads to council next week for a vote, we wanted to flag a technical issue before final adoption.

143
00:16:46.052 --> 00:16:51.706
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>We did email all of your staff yesterday with some details, but we will follow up with that letter.

144
00:16:52.638 --> 00:17:01.071
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>Portland State University, with Oregon Health Sciences University and the University of Oregon's Portland campus, supports clarifying the definition of mechanical equipment.

145
00:17:02.419 --> 00:17:12.922
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>Um, absolutely, but the current draft sweeps in several items that previously didn't require screening, including transformers gas meters, backflow preventers, and EV chargers.

146
00:17:13.579 --> 00:17:19.986
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>For an institution like Portland State, what may seem like a minor technical matter can have significant implications for our community.

147
00:17:20.644 --> 00:17:30.582
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>We are operating under serious financial strain, navigating consequential budget constraints while working hard to protect services to students and the needs of our region.

148
00:17:31.480 --> 00:17:38.332
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>Every capital dollar we spend is one we are weighing against a classroom, A student support program, or a community need.

149
00:17:39.662 --> 00:17:53.974
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>Unanticipated screening requirements for equipment such as transformers and utility meters would add real avoidable design, construction, and ongoing maintenance costs across our campus at exactly the moment we can least afford them.

150
00:17:55.144 --> 00:18:12.979
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>These are the kinds of costs that compound, affecting multiple buildings, projects, and budget cycles, and they come at a direct expense of our ability to invest in our core mission, We'd respectfully ask the committee to consider whether a more nuanced and workable approach could be found.

151
00:18:13.905 --> 00:18:18.473
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>And on behalf of our community, thank you for all you do for our beautiful city.

152
00:18:21.001 --> 00:18:21.724
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

153
00:18:23.092 --> 00:18:24.909
<v Diego>We have Sid joining us online.

154
00:18:25.680 --> 00:18:28.976
<v Diego>Sid, you feel free to unmute and begin your testimony when you're ready.

155
00:18:31.194 --> 00:18:32.045
<v Steve Novick>Great, thank you.

156
00:18:32.348 --> 00:18:34.739
<v Steve Novick>Good afternoon, Chair, Vice Chair, and committee members.

157
00:18:35.155 --> 00:18:36.502
<v Steve Novick>My name is Sid Hariharangat.

158
00:18:37.192 --> 00:18:43.382
<v Steve Novick>I want to echo both Michael and Cynthia that spoke before me and want to provide some input on Recap 11.

159
00:18:43.976 --> 00:18:56.884
<v Steve Novick>Before I do that, I first want to thank city staff for their work on these very important code changes and making a more digestible, predictable, and frankly, a better reading code for the City of Portland.

160
00:18:58.545 --> 00:19:13.026
<v Steve Novick>I'm here with a minor request consistent with testimony that we submitted online, and that testimony online is item number 336781, and that is about moving previously reviewed proposed code from another project into RECAP 11.

161
00:19:14.669 --> 00:19:36.407
<v Steve Novick>We asked that the proposed floodplain land division regulation, which is under Title 33-631-200, be moved out of the Columbia Corridor and Industrial Lands Environmental Overlay Zone project— I'll refer to that as CESL— which has been delayed, and rather incorporate that floodplain land division language into RECAP 11.

162
00:19:37.678 --> 00:19:47.884
<v Steve Novick>The CESL project is designed to update environmental overlay zones in specific industrial areas, focusing on mapping and protecting natural resources like wetlands and habitat.

163
00:19:48.564 --> 00:20:05.832
<v Steve Novick>By contrast, the floodplain land division regulations found in 33-631-200 are citywide development standards that are tied to FEMA requirements, flood hazard mitigation, and how land is legally divided across all zones impacting residential, commercial, and industrial land.

164
00:20:07.442 --> 00:20:12.723
<v Steve Novick>Placing this regulation and this code change within the CSUL project presents 2 challenges.

165
00:20:14.025 --> 00:20:15.808
<v Steve Novick>The first is that it misaligns the scope.

166
00:20:16.692 --> 00:20:28.124
<v Steve Novick>A citywide rule that becomes embedded within a geographically limited project, as the CSUL project is, risks inconsistent application and confusion for property owners and applicants.

167
00:20:28.945 --> 00:20:31.038
<v Steve Novick>Second, it blurs regulatory structure.

168
00:20:31.279 --> 00:20:36.615
<v Steve Novick>So floodplain standards already intersect with broader development codes and federal compliance standards.

169
00:20:37.369 --> 00:20:45.785
<v Steve Novick>These rules should be coordinated in a setting that's designed to address code-wide alignment, not site or area-specific environmental overlays.

170
00:20:47.392 --> 00:20:48.883
<v Steve Novick>And that brings me to Recap 11.

171
00:20:49.144 --> 00:20:58.162
<v Steve Novick>So Recap is specifically intended for targeted Technical zoning updates that improve clarity, remove barriers, and ensure consistency across the code.

172
00:20:59.142 --> 00:21:12.105
<v Steve Novick>RECAP, rather than a CECL project, is the appropriate venue to handle a regulation that applies citywide bridges, floodplain regulations, and land division standards, and requires clean integration across code chapters.

173
00:21:13.053 --> 00:21:20.152
<v Steve Novick>The proposed code amendment of the land division standard has been reviewed by Planning Commission and recommended for council approval.

174
00:21:20.682 --> 00:21:27.614
<v Steve Novick>The issue is that the Cecil project is not anticipated to go in front of council until late 2026 and more likely 2027.

175
00:21:28.096 --> 00:21:32.022
<v Steve Novick>This creates an unnecessary delay in a minor code edit.

176
00:21:33.246 --> 00:21:38.144
<v Steve Novick>I respectfully ask that the committee direct staff to relocate the floodplain land division regulation into RECAP 11.

177
00:21:38.583 --> 00:21:39.233
<v Steve Novick>Thanks for your time.

178
00:21:42.163 --> 00:21:45.077
<v Diego>That concludes— sorry, that concludes testimony.

179
00:21:46.130 --> 00:21:49.417
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Diego, and thank you to all the folks who came and testified.

180
00:21:49.465 --> 00:21:50.308
<v Candace Avalos>It sounds like there are some technical asks.

181
00:21:52.306 --> 00:21:57.983
<v Candace Avalos>And so as Vice Chair Green requested, would love to get those in writing so we can look into those further.

182
00:21:59.202 --> 00:22:00.630
<v Candace Avalos>Oh yes, and Councilor Koyama Lane.

183
00:22:01.769 --> 00:22:09.660
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Well, first I just wanted to thank Chair Avalos and Vice Chair Green for having this opportunity at the beginning of every committee meeting where we hear from people from the community.

184
00:22:10.141 --> 00:22:12.433
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is exactly how it's supposed to work out.

185
00:22:13.395 --> 00:22:15.224
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I don't think any apologies are needed.

186
00:22:15.513 --> 00:22:21.771
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Sometimes when things come forward to committee or they're made more public, that's when more eyes are on them and things get thank you.

187
00:22:21.855 --> 00:22:23.277
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is how this is supposed to work.

188
00:22:25.220 --> 00:22:31.208
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And maybe you know how legislation, how it all flows, but I will say before I started working in this building, I did not.

189
00:22:31.529 --> 00:22:36.616
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so it's— I'll just quickly explain for anyone that needs to know or for people in the community that are watching.

190
00:22:38.618 --> 00:22:42.978
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It passed through committee, it was brought by the mayor's team, but it will go to the full council.

191
00:22:43.092 --> 00:22:46.948
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's an ordinance, so it'll have 2 readings, so there'll be a chance to bring amendments.

192
00:22:47.532 --> 00:22:51.237
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so this is exactly what you're supposed to do, bring us this, Email us.

193
00:22:51.413 --> 00:22:54.909
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And if you want to, even on your way out, stop by the District 3 offices.

194
00:22:55.005 --> 00:23:03.856
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You can even talk to some of my staff about— I mean, I actually— we have to look this through and see where we stand on amendments, but then that would be where we could vote on an amendment as council.

195
00:23:03.921 --> 00:23:05.989
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It would need at least 7 votes.

196
00:23:06.309 --> 00:23:11.634
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And hope that's helpful, and thank you for being here, all the people that came to testify today.

197
00:23:13.125 --> 00:23:13.766
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor.

198
00:23:14.984 --> 00:23:17.054
<v Candace Avalos>All right, let's go ahead and move on to item 3.

199
00:23:17.134 --> 00:23:17.838
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, please read that.

200
00:23:18.817 --> 00:23:26.527
<v Diego>Item 3, direct the city administrator to reestablish a permitting improvement team to lead the second phase of the code alignment project.

201
00:23:27.392 --> 00:23:28.289
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you.

202
00:23:28.450 --> 00:23:35.983
<v Candace Avalos>So before we begin, I just want to acknowledge that this is a resolution that my office was proud to co-sponsor alongside Council President.

203
00:23:36.048 --> 00:23:39.685
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much for being here, and several of our colleagues as well.

204
00:23:40.295 --> 00:23:50.858
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate the collaboration between our offices, the deputy city administrators, and bureau staff in developing a proposal focused on improving accountability, coordination, and efficiency within Portland's permitting system.

205
00:23:52.093 --> 00:23:57.174
<v Candace Avalos>We hear regularly from housing providers and small businesses and community members about the challenges of navigating permitting.

206
00:23:57.222 --> 00:24:04.709
<v Candace Avalos>So this resolution is intended to continue the work of identifying and addressing those barriers so we can make city processes more predictable and easier to navigate.

207
00:24:05.317 --> 00:24:07.369
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, I'll turn it over to Council President Dunphy.

208
00:24:07.787 --> 00:24:11.730
<v Candace Avalos>And is DCA Donna Paul and DCA Oliveira joining you for the presentation or no?

209
00:24:12.050 --> 00:24:14.535
<v Council President Dunphy>We will have those, not through this part of the presentation though.

210
00:24:14.791 --> 00:24:17.805
<v Council President Dunphy>I'll walk us through what the slides are and then we'll hear from them.

211
00:24:18.382 --> 00:24:18.734
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

212
00:24:18.782 --> 00:24:19.183
<v Candace Avalos>Take it away.

213
00:24:19.568 --> 00:24:20.835
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you very much, Chair Avalos.

214
00:24:21.412 --> 00:24:22.278
<v Council President Dunphy>Good afternoon, colleagues.

215
00:24:22.855 --> 00:24:26.926
<v Council President Dunphy>I'm excited to talk to you today about the Code Alignment Project 2 resolution.

216
00:24:27.278 --> 00:24:31.383
<v Council President Dunphy>This is a critical step in driving this important work forward.

217
00:24:32.409 --> 00:24:38.372
<v Council President Dunphy>When we sat down with staff months ago to scope the next round of code changes, we asked them to think bigger.

218
00:24:39.622 --> 00:24:41.994
<v Council President Dunphy>This resolution is the result of that ambition.

219
00:24:42.683 --> 00:24:51.505
<v Council President Dunphy>It ensures that the CAP team has the authority and cross-bureau cooperation that they need to tackle the most complex barriers to permitting improvement.

220
00:24:51.991 --> 00:24:53.224
<v Council President Dunphy>So here's what we'll be covering today.

221
00:24:54.829 --> 00:24:55.428
<v Council President Dunphy>Oh, do we have a slideshow?

222
00:24:55.509 --> 00:24:56.351
<v Council President Dunphy>Sure, yeah.

223
00:24:56.528 --> 00:24:56.739
<v Council President Dunphy>Yeah.

224
00:24:57.790 --> 00:24:59.086
<v Council President Dunphy>There we go.

225
00:25:00.837 --> 00:25:00.967
<v Queesha Light>Okay.

226
00:25:01.403 --> 00:25:01.790
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

227
00:25:03.826 --> 00:25:06.086
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Sorry, incorrect slide.

228
00:25:06.780 --> 00:25:07.104
<v Council President Dunphy>There we go.

229
00:25:07.266 --> 00:25:07.588
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you.

230
00:25:08.719 --> 00:25:14.676
<v Council President Dunphy>And as Councilor Avalos noted, this is co-sponsored by myself, Councilors Avalos, Murillo, Ryan, and Novick.

231
00:25:15.738 --> 00:25:15.835
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you.

232
00:25:16.183 --> 00:25:18.315
<v Council President Dunphy>So here's what we're going to be covering today.

233
00:25:18.538 --> 00:25:24.067
<v Council President Dunphy>We're going to be talking about applicant permitting experiences and our current performance metrics.

234
00:25:24.627 --> 00:25:34.289
<v Council President Dunphy>We'll get into some history of permitting improvement efforts and the code alignment project work, where we'll discuss how CAP 2 expands on the foundational code improvements from CAP 1.

235
00:25:34.962 --> 00:25:43.807
<v Council President Dunphy>Then we're going to discuss this resolution, what it does, what it doesn't, how it fits within the code alignment work, and why it's needed to achieve the outcomes that we're aiming for.

236
00:25:44.512 --> 00:25:49.403
<v Council President Dunphy>Then after that, we will hear from our invited speakers, DCA Oliveira.

237
00:25:49.804 --> 00:25:52.755
<v Council President Dunphy>PBOT Director Williams is pinch-hitting for DCA Donipal.

238
00:25:53.412 --> 00:26:08.965
<v Council President Dunphy>We'll also hear from Sarah Radcliffe, Director of Government Relations with Habitat for Humanity, Ben Hemson, Government Affairs Director with the Home Building Association of Greater Portland, and Peter Finley Frye, who is a nationally certified planner and founding member of the DRAC, the Development Review Advisory Committee.

239
00:26:09.270 --> 00:26:10.586
<v Council President Dunphy>And then we'll get into public discussion.

240
00:26:12.188 --> 00:26:12.482
<v Council President Dunphy>Testimony.

241
00:26:12.531 --> 00:26:13.548
<v Council President Dunphy>So next slide, please.

242
00:26:15.559 --> 00:26:20.855
<v Council President Dunphy>Colleagues, it's no surprise to anybody here, but Portland is the slowest in the metro region for permitting timelines.

243
00:26:21.404 --> 00:26:35.517
<v Council President Dunphy>A comparative analysis by Johnson Economics found that Portland averages 413 days to issue a multifamily permit, where— while Vancouver averages 225 days, Hillsboro 204, and Gresham is 313 days.

244
00:26:35.954 --> 00:26:43.122
<v Council President Dunphy>Now, I'm not expecting us to be the number one permitting system in the nation, but can we please at least be as good as Gresham?

245
00:26:44.357 --> 00:26:50.056
<v Council President Dunphy>Interestingly, this study found out that the permitting processes across these cities is actually quite similar in steps.

246
00:26:50.682 --> 00:26:56.669
<v Council President Dunphy>The difference is simply how long it takes each of those permits to move through the necessary channels before issuance.

247
00:26:57.423 --> 00:27:01.932
<v Council President Dunphy>As you can see, this is reflected in the current survey metrics.

248
00:27:02.173 --> 00:27:07.615
<v Council President Dunphy>66% Of applicants rated our under review phase as difficult or very difficult.

249
00:27:08.353 --> 00:27:12.894
<v Council President Dunphy>64% Of applications said the application phase is anything less than easy.

250
00:27:13.471 --> 00:27:22.762
<v Council President Dunphy>And our own 2021 audit found that only 7% of new residential construction projects are expected to meet our own timeliness goals in a housing crisis.

251
00:27:23.580 --> 00:27:24.769
<v Council President Dunphy>This is just not sustainable.

252
00:27:25.507 --> 00:27:29.583
<v Council President Dunphy>So I wanna stress that this isn't just a problem for large developers.

253
00:27:30.079 --> 00:27:38.888
<v Council President Dunphy>It hurts small business owners and homeowners just as much, if not more, since the average person does not have the training to navigate our labyrinthian codes and procedures.

254
00:27:39.986 --> 00:27:40.713
<v Council President Dunphy>Next slide, please.

255
00:27:42.817 --> 00:27:46.570
<v Council President Dunphy>When I read through the survey responses, 3 themes came up again and again.

256
00:27:47.250 --> 00:27:53.263
<v Council President Dunphy>Permitting is prohibitively expensive, it's time-consuming, and the service and information is inconsistent at best.

257
00:27:53.829 --> 00:27:58.644
<v Council President Dunphy>One respondent put it simply, permitting projects feels like I'm being punished for doing the right thing.

258
00:27:59.869 --> 00:28:04.306
<v Council President Dunphy>I think my favorite response was from someone who described themselves as a, quote, non-expert.

259
00:28:04.565 --> 00:28:15.693
<v Council President Dunphy>It really sums up the extreme frustration that applicants feel when I say, I quote, I've found the process to build a door to be an expensive, dystopian, Kafkaesque bureaucratic boondoggle.

260
00:28:17.119 --> 00:28:19.171
<v Council President Dunphy>It's funny, but it's also not funny.

261
00:28:20.469 --> 00:28:24.153
<v Council President Dunphy>Permitting a home improvement project shouldn't blur the lines of an existential crisis.

262
00:28:25.420 --> 00:28:26.877
<v Council President Dunphy>I know none of this was intentional.

263
00:28:27.278 --> 00:28:40.347
<v Council President Dunphy>Much of it was the result of our old form of government creating a disjointed system riddled with communication silos and historical policy choices that have compounded into a complex, Conflicting code system, and all adding up to a terrible experience.

264
00:28:42.859 --> 00:28:43.663
<v Council President Dunphy>Next slide, please.

265
00:28:44.192 --> 00:28:53.227
<v Council President Dunphy>From 1997 to 2021, our city auditor has documented— city auditors have documented similar themes in their recommendations.

266
00:28:54.067 --> 00:28:56.295
<v Council President Dunphy>One, we're too slow and we're getting slower.

267
00:28:56.892 --> 00:29:04.653
<v Council President Dunphy>The city hasn't met its own timeliness goals for commercial or residential permits in years, and performance gets worse on complex projects.

268
00:29:05.412 --> 00:29:09.465
<v Council President Dunphy>There's no clear authority or well-implemented coordination process between bureaus.

269
00:29:10.364 --> 00:29:13.680
<v Council President Dunphy>Our codes are conflicting and interpretation is inconsistent.

270
00:29:14.368 --> 00:29:27.909
<v Council President Dunphy>Growing regulatory complexity was consistently named as one of the main reasons for delays, which is not surprising since our zoning code alone has ballooned from 250 pages in 1980 to upwards of 1,800 pages today.

271
00:29:29.351 --> 00:29:35.010
<v Council President Dunphy>What really struck me is how often it cited that customers customer service remains an afterthought.

272
00:29:36.020 --> 00:29:41.669
<v Council President Dunphy>The city has had a complaint system since 2007 or 2004, and yet never followed it.

273
00:29:42.439 --> 00:29:46.609
<v Council President Dunphy>Instead, it's always been that if you knew someone on city council, you got a faster response.

274
00:29:47.028 --> 00:29:48.262
<v Council President Dunphy>If you didn't, you were on your own.

275
00:29:49.000 --> 00:29:55.289
<v Council President Dunphy>The auditor called it, quote, a gray area between customer service and favoritism, and that's just not right or fair.

276
00:29:56.076 --> 00:30:01.227
<v Council President Dunphy>And as a city, we really need to heed the auditor's warnings that delays don't just frustrate customers, they cost us.

277
00:30:01.290 --> 00:30:01.386
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you.

278
00:30:02.076 --> 00:30:06.587
<v Council President Dunphy>Last year alone, we lost an estimated $700 million in development investments.

279
00:30:07.405 --> 00:30:09.203
<v Council President Dunphy>Developers are opting to build elsewhere.

280
00:30:09.877 --> 00:30:17.742
<v Council President Dunphy>Residents aren't permitting their construction work, and Portland is losing the economic activity, jobs, and growth that come with a healthy development environment.

281
00:30:17.824 --> 00:30:20.729
<v Council President Dunphy>But the findings did drive some meaningful actions.

282
00:30:21.097 --> 00:30:32.798
<v Council President Dunphy>As you can see on this slide, in 2021, Commissioners Ryan and Maps convened the Permitting Improvement Task Force, bringing in recommendations from all council offices, permitting bureaus, and the development community.

283
00:30:33.393 --> 00:30:40.701
<v Council President Dunphy>And one of their top recommendations, create a formal ongoing code alignment process, the Code Alignment Project.

284
00:30:41.503 --> 00:30:51.269
<v Council President Dunphy>In 2022, the city auditor found that we've made some progress, but permitting speeds still lagged and we're not consistently following the 2020 or the 2004 customer complaint policy.

285
00:30:52.023 --> 00:30:59.363
<v Council President Dunphy>In 2024, Permitting and Development launched as a consolidated permitting bureau to implement the building codes and lead the permitting work.

286
00:31:00.116 --> 00:31:06.423
<v Council President Dunphy>But this was always considered a starting point, not a full consideration— consolidation, excuse me, not a full consolidation.

287
00:31:06.872 --> 00:31:08.491
<v Council President Dunphy>And staff had real issues with it.

288
00:31:09.439 --> 00:31:17.059
<v Council President Dunphy>And last year in 2025, this council unanimously passed CAP 1 and proved that even a few targeted reforms can make a real impact.

289
00:31:17.942 --> 00:31:18.632
<v Council President Dunphy>Next slide, please.

290
00:31:19.932 --> 00:31:28.179
<v Council President Dunphy>CAP 1 started with a simple but important idea: find the places where the city code conflicts, creates unnecessary barriers, and slows the permitting down.

291
00:31:28.500 --> 00:31:29.252
<v Council President Dunphy>And fix them.

292
00:31:29.973 --> 00:31:40.040
<v Council President Dunphy>With limited staff and an 8-month timeline, the team focused on small-scale residential and small business projects, delivering technical amendments to align Titles 11, 17, and 21.

293
00:31:41.035 --> 00:31:57.625
<v Council President Dunphy>It temporarily suspended 4 key requirements through January of 2029: street tree planting for remodels and additions, project value triggers for frontage improvement requirements, seismic evaluation reports for most pre-1974 buildings, and nonconforming site upgrade requirements.

294
00:31:58.186 --> 00:32:11.672
<v Council President Dunphy>But the team identified far more than we could tackle and that is why Cap 2 is going to take a much bigger swing, resolving conflicts across zoning, right-of-way coordination, change of use, seismic requirements, and more.

295
00:32:12.377 --> 00:32:20.604
<v Council President Dunphy>It focuses on reducing real barriers for housing developers and small businesses and takes on the lingering inter-bureau process inefficiencies that Cap 1 couldn't touch.

296
00:32:21.614 --> 00:32:23.538
<v Council President Dunphy>A big swing like this is needed.

297
00:32:24.002 --> 00:32:27.563
<v Council President Dunphy>It needs a resolution to guide it so it lands exactly where this needs to land.

298
00:32:27.611 --> 00:32:27.755
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you.

299
00:32:28.974 --> 00:32:29.826
<v Council President Dunphy>Next slide, please.

300
00:32:30.661 --> 00:32:35.011
<v Council President Dunphy>Before I get into details of this, I want to be very clear about what this resolution is not.

301
00:32:35.719 --> 00:32:38.913
<v Council President Dunphy>It is not a directive to start rearranging staff.

302
00:32:39.732 --> 00:32:46.315
<v Council President Dunphy>It is not a push to deregulate building activity, bypassing important life and safety codes just to speed things up.

303
00:32:46.395 --> 00:32:47.969
<v Council President Dunphy>That's not reform, that's chaos.

304
00:32:48.723 --> 00:32:51.580
<v Council President Dunphy>What this is, is an enabling policy.

305
00:32:52.095 --> 00:32:56.702
<v Council President Dunphy>It's a way to gather up all the loose ends and start weaving them into something that is cohesive.

306
00:32:57.953 --> 00:32:58.644
<v Council President Dunphy>So here's what it does.

307
00:32:59.396 --> 00:33:01.048
<v Council President Dunphy>It establishes project authority.

308
00:33:01.962 --> 00:33:06.356
<v Council President Dunphy>Right now, there's no real decision maker about who can break a tie on what a code change should be.

309
00:33:06.998 --> 00:33:11.551
<v Council President Dunphy>Many of the conflicts live in administrative rules, which the team currently has no authority over.

310
00:33:12.226 --> 00:33:20.355
<v Council President Dunphy>Without this resolution, some of those fixes could take years of negotiating and might never get resolved or end up as compromises that don't actually move the needle.

311
00:33:20.964 --> 00:33:23.914
<v Council President Dunphy>That's costly in staff time, and it doesn't get us where we need to go.

312
00:33:24.813 --> 00:33:26.896
<v Council President Dunphy>It creates a permanent code team.

313
00:33:27.538 --> 00:33:36.001
<v Council President Dunphy>We're asking for a permanent code writing team like we used to have that works across bureaus, incorporates feedback from customers, and learns what staff sees during implementation.

314
00:33:36.659 --> 00:33:43.296
<v Council President Dunphy>Because if we spend time on the— to fix the codes, we need to make sure those fixes aren't immediately undone by bureaus still writing updates in silos.

315
00:33:44.289 --> 00:33:45.715
<v Council President Dunphy>It strengthens process alignment.

316
00:33:46.292 --> 00:33:53.907
<v Council President Dunphy>We're asking that the city administrator examines our permitting system and brings back a real proposal to finish the work from all our previous efforts.

317
00:33:54.373 --> 00:33:57.676
<v Council President Dunphy>Every person, every project, deserves consistent, reliable service.

318
00:33:58.143 --> 00:34:01.016
<v Council President Dunphy>That means digging in and making some long-term structural changes.

319
00:34:02.075 --> 00:34:03.695
<v Council President Dunphy>And it asks for community involvement.

320
00:34:04.321 --> 00:34:17.338
<v Council President Dunphy>We're requiring that this team actually listen to and implement the feedback from people with real-world experience in building here and in other jurisdictions, people who can offer practical solutions to push us towards best practices and help us simplify.

321
00:34:18.286 --> 00:34:39.291
<v Council President Dunphy>And the outcomes that we are aiming for are, as listed on this slide, faster permits, Last slide, please.

322
00:34:39.726 --> 00:34:48.969
<v Council President Dunphy>Since the auditor has also asked for sustained focus council leadership on permitting efforts since 1997, we're going to do our part to make sure that happens with CAP 2.

323
00:34:49.307 --> 00:35:04.032
<v Council President Dunphy>This can't be another policy that On a quarterly basis, we are requiring a reporting to council with iterative code packages to make sure that council prioritizes this work and that the public knows of our progress and what we're working on next.

324
00:35:05.829 --> 00:35:14.043
<v Council President Dunphy>Within 60 days, we're asking for a scoped work plan for CAP 2 so that the public knows exactly what areas of improvement we're focusing on now and what comes next.

325
00:35:14.869 --> 00:35:17.032
<v Council President Dunphy>The 150 days, we want a picture of where we are.

326
00:35:17.164 --> 00:35:17.262
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you.

327
00:35:17.713 --> 00:35:25.809
<v Council President Dunphy>Agency agreements, current staff resources gaps, and a proposal for how do we simplify authority so the whole system can actually work together.

328
00:35:26.387 --> 00:35:27.721
<v Council President Dunphy>And it's a 2-year target.

329
00:35:28.059 --> 00:35:33.425
<v Council President Dunphy>We're asking for significant work to be done in code alignment, and that's an aggressive timeline for us.

330
00:35:33.536 --> 00:35:42.068
<v Council President Dunphy>But honestly, much of what we'd like to see is in code updates is really just do less, not more, not reinvent the wheel.

331
00:35:42.132 --> 00:35:44.364
<v Council President Dunphy>Let's just find what's working elsewhere and go do that.

332
00:35:45.168 --> 00:35:51.092
<v Council President Dunphy>So in closing, we have spent nearly 30 years as a city identifying the same problems.

333
00:35:51.688 --> 00:35:58.882
<v Council President Dunphy>We've convened task forces, we've conducted audits, we created a new bureau and passed the first round of substantial code changes.

334
00:35:59.074 --> 00:36:01.097
<v Council President Dunphy>But every one of those steps mattered.

335
00:36:01.628 --> 00:36:11.969
<v Council President Dunphy>But without this resolution, CAP 2 moves forward without real authority, without clear timelines, and without any guarantee that the next round of code updates won't just create new conflicts.

336
00:36:12.193 --> 00:36:12.451
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you.

337
00:36:12.724 --> 00:36:18.376
<v Council President Dunphy>This resolution gives the teams the tool to finish the job and gives this council a clear directive to see it through.

338
00:36:19.226 --> 00:36:26.050
<v Council President Dunphy>Portland can be a place where permitting works for everyone, not just those who know how to navigate the system.

339
00:36:26.532 --> 00:36:27.302
<v Council President Dunphy>And that's worth doing.

340
00:36:27.512 --> 00:36:28.266
<v Council President Dunphy>So let's get it done.

341
00:36:29.085 --> 00:36:32.617
<v Council President Dunphy>And that concludes my presentation at this time.

342
00:36:33.099 --> 00:36:43.039
<v Council President Dunphy>We have some invited guests to come up and provide some testimony, and then we have some folks signed up for the public to testify, and then we'll take any of your questions in whatever order you would like us to do, Chair.

343
00:36:43.039 --> 00:36:43.840
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Council President.

344
00:36:44.420 --> 00:36:50.539
<v Candace Avalos>I— but am I understanding that first we're gonna have DCAs and then we're gonna bring invited guests, or do you want me to bring all of them up at once?

345
00:36:51.099 --> 00:36:54.820
<v Council President Dunphy>If we could, I, I would sure love to have the DCAs at the very least up first.

346
00:36:55.380 --> 00:36:56.320
<v Council President Dunphy>Um, if you—.

347
00:36:56.320 --> 00:36:57.019
<v Justin Wood>And then—.

348
00:36:57.019 --> 00:36:57.940
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, yeah.

349
00:36:57.940 --> 00:37:02.219
<v Candace Avalos>So we'll have the DCAs first, and then we'll do invited testimony, and then we'll take regular testimony.

350
00:37:02.239 --> 00:37:03.039
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Council President.

351
00:37:14.302 --> 00:37:16.728
<v Donny Oliveira>All righty, uh, thank you for having us.

352
00:37:16.791 --> 00:37:18.559
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you, Council President, for teeing that up.

353
00:37:19.184 --> 00:37:20.775
<v Donny Oliveira>My name is Donny Oliveira, for the record.

354
00:37:20.822 --> 00:37:30.940
<v Donny Oliveira>I'm the Deputy City Administrator of Community and Economic Development, and joining me today is Millicent Williams, Director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation, sitting in for Councilor DiCiedano-Paol.

355
00:37:31.663 --> 00:37:32.224
<v Donny Oliveira>All right, thank you.

356
00:37:32.273 --> 00:37:33.813
<v Donny Oliveira>I'll start, Director.

357
00:37:34.456 --> 00:37:43.655
<v Donny Oliveira>First and foremost, just want to thank this City Council for its continued commitment to working with the administration on improving our systems specifically related to permitting.

358
00:37:44.634 --> 00:37:56.818
<v Donny Oliveira>As the Council President mentioned, this is not the first time a City Council has contemplated improving our processes, and so we just want to thank— be thankful in advance for working with us to help us contemplate what's the best path forward.

359
00:37:57.557 --> 00:38:09.009
<v Donny Oliveira>I'm going to share a couple of thoughts about where we're at today related to CAP 2, CAP 1, and even just contemplating the PP&D change that happened a couple years ago, and then share why I'm excited and my team's excited about this resolution.

360
00:38:09.844 --> 00:38:15.657
<v Donny Oliveira>Just as a reminder, and this was mentioned by Council President, but permitting development is a relatively young bureau.

361
00:38:15.867 --> 00:38:23.398
<v Donny Oliveira>Yes, it has the roots of the Development Services Bureau with PBOT and Parks, Water, and BES staff joining it.

362
00:38:24.224 --> 00:38:32.637
<v Donny Oliveira>But even that model that we created didn't actually give us an opportunity to think holistically about what the right model could be.

363
00:38:32.847 --> 00:38:39.289
<v Donny Oliveira>We took what we had and made the best of it, and I'm very pleased with what the team's done at PP&D, continue to work with our infrastructure partners.

364
00:38:40.699 --> 00:38:45.378
<v Donny Oliveira>But we think there's a better pathway and another opportunity for us to think about it strategically.

365
00:38:45.813 --> 00:39:01.168
<v Donny Oliveira>So that's why the piece of the resolution that gives us a chance, that 150-day window, to come back with a pathway makes a lot of sense because frankly, we've oftentimes been reacting to a directive versus contemplating for ourselves what might it look like to do it well.

366
00:39:01.762 --> 00:39:03.126
<v Donny Oliveira>So first, I wanna just acknowledge that.

367
00:39:03.528 --> 00:39:10.867
<v Donny Oliveira>And the second piece I wanna share is thank you for adopting CAP 1 and you'll soon adopt RECAP as RECAP 11.

368
00:39:11.380 --> 00:39:16.005
<v Donny Oliveira>But code improvement continues to happen in the city, which we're grateful for the staff resources to do that.

369
00:39:16.518 --> 00:39:18.059
<v Donny Oliveira>And CAP 2 is very much underway.

370
00:39:18.141 --> 00:39:18.268
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you.

371
00:39:18.621 --> 00:39:22.969
<v Donny Oliveira>And why this resolution is important for that though is we don't want CAP 2 to be the last code alignment project.

372
00:39:23.114 --> 00:39:41.485
<v Donny Oliveira>We think this, much like RECAP is at version 11, we'd love to see CAP continue to go forward as we look at our codes and frankly continue to improve work with our communities and our development community about what might success look like and not just improvement in pace, but certainty.

373
00:39:41.724 --> 00:39:43.746
<v Donny Oliveira>And I think that's something that I really want to emphasize.

374
00:39:44.195 --> 00:39:53.858
<v Donny Oliveira>Yes, there's structural and procedural opportunities that we have within the city, but what I hear more than our cost of doing business in the city with related to permitting is people want certainty.

375
00:39:54.067 --> 00:39:59.684
<v Donny Oliveira>They want to know when they enter into our system, they know how long it's going to take, how much it's going to cost, so they can plan for that.

376
00:40:00.021 --> 00:40:11.208
<v Donny Oliveira>And I think that's what CAP is starting to tease out is, can we give our builders and our home improvement DIYers and our small business community consistency on how they engage with us?

377
00:40:11.257 --> 00:40:12.556
<v Donny Oliveira>So that's what's really exciting about the CAP piece.

378
00:40:12.621 --> 00:40:12.748
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you.

379
00:40:13.407 --> 00:40:29.405
<v Donny Oliveira>And last, about the resolution that I want to just further emphasize is if we continue to over-leverage our staff, the doers who are doing permitting, now pulling them away from that work to contemplate a new code or a new structure or a new process, we're doing 2 things.

380
00:40:29.469 --> 00:40:33.737
<v Donny Oliveira>One, we're just over, you know, we're over-leveraging and we're frankly burning out our staff.

381
00:40:34.764 --> 00:40:38.262
<v Donny Oliveira>But also we don't get the full focus of a team.

382
00:40:38.840 --> 00:40:51.460
<v Donny Oliveira>And so the idea of establishing a permit improvement team again, like the last council did, but resourced, will give us the capacity to both maintain our workload, but actually have the resources and focus to think about something different well.

383
00:40:52.072 --> 00:40:56.032
<v Donny Oliveira>So I wanna thank the Council President for giving us that opportunity to bring back an idea around that.

384
00:40:57.052 --> 00:40:59.302
<v Donny Oliveira>And that's my support for this resolution.

385
00:40:59.561 --> 00:41:06.168
<v Donny Oliveira>I wanna thank again the councilors for their continued alignment with code improvement and permitting improvement.

386
00:41:06.217 --> 00:41:06.668
<v Donny Oliveira>So thank you.

387
00:41:07.813 --> 00:41:09.443
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you, DC Oliveira.

388
00:41:09.572 --> 00:41:27.875
<v Millicent Williams>I will be reading DC Donapal's I will share that if I were testifying as the PBOT director, I would be able to provide a different perspective about the work that's been done and how we might be able to continue to be supportive of the work that's planned and that's proposed through this resolution.

389
00:41:28.532 --> 00:41:30.088
<v Millicent Williams>But I am going to be reading her comments.

390
00:41:30.152 --> 00:41:36.454
<v Millicent Williams>I don't want to stray from that, but open to answering questions if folks have those at the conclusion of our conversation.

391
00:41:37.128 --> 00:41:37.914
<v Millicent Williams>So thank you, Chair Avalos.

392
00:41:37.963 --> 00:41:38.320
<v Steve Novick>Councilor thank you, Mr. Mayor.

393
00:41:38.320 --> 00:41:38.440
<v Byron Balog>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

394
00:41:38.440 --> 00:41:38.440
<v Byron Balog>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

395
00:41:38.440 --> 00:41:38.519
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

396
00:41:38.519 --> 00:41:48.400
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you, Councilor Dan Ryan, for the opportunity to speak to Council President Dunphy's resolution to reestablish the permitting improvement team and support the code alignment project phase 2.

397
00:41:48.400 --> 00:41:53.739
<v Millicent Williams>The Public Works service area is fully in support of improving Portland's development permitting process.

398
00:41:53.860 --> 00:42:08.815
<v Millicent Williams>Although the direct functions of Public Works permitting for private development are now housed in PP&D, or Portland Permitting and Development, within the Community and Economic Development service area, we remain strong partners in this work and look forward to collaborating on further improvements.

399
00:42:09.570 --> 00:42:21.740
<v Millicent Williams>As we all know, private, private development is vital to a healthy and growing community, and how that private development interacts with the public right-of-way and commons is critical to creating a safe and beautiful city.

400
00:42:22.737 --> 00:42:26.847
<v Millicent Williams>We all want well-built and safe sidewalks adjacent to new development.

401
00:42:27.472 --> 00:42:39.804
<v Millicent Williams>We all want proper water and sewer lines to connect We all want a healthy tree canopy along our street network to combat the effects of heat islands and to beautify our business districts.

402
00:42:40.621 --> 00:42:45.351
<v Millicent Williams>And none of that happens without effective public works requirements for development.

403
00:42:46.393 --> 00:43:01.534
<v Millicent Williams>The goal of consolidating public works permitting in PP&D 2 years ago was to make sure that we continued that important work while helping our private property owners navigate the permitting process I'm pleased to be here today to support the continuation of that work.

404
00:43:02.336 --> 00:43:07.635
<v Millicent Williams>The reestablishment and resourcing of a permitting improvement team is an exciting step.

405
00:43:07.891 --> 00:43:21.813
<v Millicent Williams>Continuing to make the permitting process more efficient while also ensuring that it helps to advance the thriving, safe, and sustainable city that we all want is hard work, and it is work that the Public Works Service Area looks forward to lending our expertise to.

406
00:43:21.860 --> 00:43:21.956
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

407
00:43:22.327 --> 00:43:24.360
<v Millicent Williams>To and helping to advance.

408
00:43:24.925 --> 00:43:25.248
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

409
00:43:28.153 --> 00:43:28.929
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you all.

410
00:43:29.864 --> 00:43:33.422
<v Candace Avalos>Now let's go ahead and invite our invited panel.

411
00:43:37.833 --> 00:43:41.994
<v Candace Avalos>Um, let's see, we've got Sarah Radcliffe, Peter Finley Frye, and Ben Hempson.

412
00:43:42.815 --> 00:43:43.315
<v Candace Avalos>Come on up.

413
00:43:50.677 --> 00:43:51.894
<v Candace Avalos>All right, Sarah, do you want to kick us off?

414
00:43:52.280 --> 00:43:52.632
<v Diego>Sure.

415
00:43:53.001 --> 00:43:56.255
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Uh, good afternoon, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, members of the committee.

416
00:43:56.302 --> 00:43:59.862
<v Sarah Radcliffe>My name is Sarah Radcliffe, and I'm here with Habitat for Humanity Portland Region.

417
00:44:00.614 --> 00:44:06.128
<v Sarah Radcliffe>We are so pleased to see the continued momentum around streamlining permitting and aligning code.

418
00:44:06.626 --> 00:44:17.094
<v Sarah Radcliffe>We fully support reestablishing a permitting improvement team, and I want to thank the staff and elected leaders who have persevered with a tedious and complicated project over many years.

419
00:44:18.153 --> 00:44:26.563
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Habitat for Humanity has 77 homes currently under construction in the City of Portland and 100 homes in pre-development within the city.

420
00:44:27.092 --> 00:44:30.496
<v Sarah Radcliffe>So we may be one of permitting and development's biggest customers.

421
00:44:31.409 --> 00:44:41.505
<v Sarah Radcliffe>We are primarily building middle housing, often townhomes, which provide permanently affordable homeownership opportunities through the community land trust model in partnership with Proud Ground.

422
00:44:42.469 --> 00:44:56.420
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Often called the missing middle, this type of housing was underproduced in American cities for decades and is in high demand because it's more affordable and family-friendly, often with small yards or shared green space tucked into existing residential neighborhoods.

423
00:44:57.030 --> 00:45:02.311
<v Sarah Radcliffe>It's also more complicated from a permitting perspective than constructing a square building on a square lot.

424
00:45:03.420 --> 00:45:07.978
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Thanks to the city's efforts over the past few years, we have seen improvements regarding building permits.

425
00:45:09.052 --> 00:45:14.376
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Where we still encounter challenges is around site development, public works, and frontage improvements.

426
00:45:14.807 --> 00:45:31.384
<v Sarah Radcliffe>This is an area where a lot of competing interests collide: stormwater, utilities, fire safety, parking, pedestrian and bike access, ADA compliance, tree canopy, street connectivity, and density requirements, creating a process that's prone to delays and code alignment issues.

427
00:45:32.762 --> 00:45:41.090
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Each is a laudable goal, but figuring out how to rank these goals and how to do so efficiently without incurring costs and delays is challenging.

428
00:45:42.088 --> 00:45:51.601
<v Sarah Radcliffe>We look forward to working with the permitting improvement team throughout this process, and because we build in neighboring cities as well, we can bring a valuable cross-jurisdictional perspective.

429
00:45:52.007 --> 00:45:54.469
<v Sarah Radcliffe>We actually have a few developments underway in Gresham.

430
00:45:55.590 --> 00:45:59.054
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Thank you for your consideration and your city— your service to the city.

431
00:46:01.038 --> 00:46:01.362
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

432
00:46:01.847 --> 00:46:02.365
<v Cynthia Carmina Gomez>Go ahead.

433
00:46:02.820 --> 00:46:03.597
<v Peter Finley Fry>Good afternoon.

434
00:46:04.034 --> 00:46:05.525
<v Peter Finley Fry>Um, my name is Peter Finley Fry.

435
00:46:05.978 --> 00:46:08.851
<v Peter Finley Fry>I'm a nationally certified land use planner.

436
00:46:09.563 --> 00:46:16.284
<v Peter Finley Fry>I work primarily with business owners and property owners, but I've done a lot of work with nonprofits.

437
00:46:17.617 --> 00:46:25.860
<v Peter Finley Fry>And for example, I put Self Enhancement Inc. out on Columbia Boulevard in industrial sanctuary, which was quite a feat.

438
00:46:27.670 --> 00:46:42.945
<v Peter Finley Fry>The problem, as the staff has identified, is there's no single authority to negotiate the inconsistencies that occur when you have multiple areas of concern.

439
00:46:44.117 --> 00:46:50.942
<v Peter Finley Fry>Most jurisdictions throughout the United States have site review, which is different than design review.

440
00:46:51.344 --> 00:46:52.500
<v Peter Finley Fry>Portland does not.

441
00:46:53.512 --> 00:47:21.063
<v Peter Finley Fry>Portland's the only place I know of that actually does not have site review, but we have our own solution, and that's a solution that is being advocated by the council president now, the Portland Solution, which, as you already know, directs edits through correct processes, cross-functional code team, unified permitting authority, and quarterly council reports.

442
00:47:21.929 --> 00:47:29.911
<v Peter Finley Fry>So I'm here to strongly support that after almost almost 50 years of work throughout California, Oregon, and Washington.

443
00:47:31.454 --> 00:47:40.355
<v Peter Finley Fry>I want to comment briefly on the fact that permitting is where fantasy meets reality.

444
00:47:40.771 --> 00:47:50.273
<v Peter Finley Fry>We all have in our own heads our bubble, and we want to have beautiful things, and we want to do all this stuff, but in reality, we hit certain realities.

445
00:47:50.322 --> 00:47:50.402
<v Peter Finley Fry>Yes.

446
00:47:53.269 --> 00:48:16.150
<v Peter Finley Fry>These are the realities that developers and business owners and property owners encounter when they enter into the permit process because we are responsible for the permitting process.

447
00:48:16.150 --> 00:48:16.190
<v Peter Finley Fry>Thank you.

448
00:48:16.452 --> 00:48:18.074
<v Peter Finley Fry>For people's life and safety.

449
00:48:18.844 --> 00:48:22.425
<v Peter Finley Fry>We are responsible for creating sidewalks and safe streets.

450
00:48:23.018 --> 00:48:26.840
<v Peter Finley Fry>We are also wanting to make the world a better place.

451
00:48:28.077 --> 00:48:39.541
<v Peter Finley Fry>And there are differences of opinion about eco-roofs and ground floor retail and those kind of things, but those are all manifestations of the public's interest to make the world a better place.

452
00:48:40.615 --> 00:48:44.054
<v Peter Finley Fry>And all these things have to be negotiated negotiated and worked out.

453
00:48:44.923 --> 00:48:58.262
<v Peter Finley Fry>And in the past, they were worked out through these silos, and then you would have the process in having no ability to really coordinate or deal with issues.

454
00:48:58.599 --> 00:49:01.606
<v Peter Finley Fry>I'm not going to be here giving you examples, although I could.

455
00:49:03.182 --> 00:49:19.047
<v Peter Finley Fry>I just wanted to focus on more of the big picture and why this focus of the council president and the— and what is before you is so important because it creates a vessel in which this can be resolved.

456
00:49:20.920 --> 00:49:29.050
<v Peter Finley Fry>Permitting process needs also to be navigated by normal people, and that's the other message I wanted to clearly bring to you.

457
00:49:30.353 --> 00:49:37.983
<v Peter Finley Fry>And I'm only making my observation from what I in here, but a lot of this is driven by development interests, and I don't work for them.

458
00:49:38.047 --> 00:49:45.291
<v Peter Finley Fry>I work for the people, and the people are the ones who need access to the system as much as developers do.

459
00:49:47.074 --> 00:50:16.043
<v Peter Finley Fry>And I do want to say that Portland Planning and Development has done a really good job of opening itself up to people with their 15-minute meetings and other ways they're trying to outreach to just normal people that have to deal with a deck or landscaping or whatever so that a person can navigate your system without having to hire an architect or a planning consultant.

460
00:50:17.280 --> 00:50:39.106
<v Peter Finley Fry>I want to end by basically saying we need to protect the public safety and we need to live in a hello, Chair Avalos, members of the committee.

461
00:50:39.688 --> 00:50:41.563
<v Ben Hemson>For the record, my name is Ben Hemson.

462
00:50:41.644 --> 00:50:45.478
<v Ben Hemson>I'm the Government Affairs Director for the Home Building Association of Greater Portland.

463
00:50:46.414 --> 00:50:58.264
<v Ben Hemson>Our members build homes throughout the region, but in Portland proper are largely engaged in the development of single-family infill, middle housing style homes, and small-scale multifamily.

464
00:50:59.244 --> 00:51:04.027
<v Ben Hemson>We're enthusiastic supporters of the CAP 2 resolution before you today and urge you to support it as well.

465
00:51:05.440 --> 00:51:12.391
<v Ben Hemson>In my role, we hold monthly meetings with the leadership in the PP&D department where we discuss issues and projects across the city.

466
00:51:12.985 --> 00:51:31.728
<v Ben Hemson>And by and large, the issues that we're discussing are not headline-generating policy they're simple code conflicts, interdepartmental communication issues, or concerns that arise around a project being handed off from one workgroup to another.

467
00:51:33.378 --> 00:51:36.030
<v Ben Hemson>So we're excited about the CAP2 project.

468
00:51:36.096 --> 00:51:47.215
<v Ben Hemson>I think it really seeks to address those concerns and those problems and really start turning the tide on the timelines that you heard from Council President Dunphy earlier.

469
00:51:47.280 --> 00:51:47.376
<v Ben Hemson>Thank you.

470
00:51:48.807 --> 00:51:53.697
<v Ben Hemson>I will make just one note on new Director Kooch in PP&D.

471
00:51:53.793 --> 00:52:05.447
<v Ben Hemson>He and his team are working on some other projects that we're really excited about, one of them around looking at the user experience, another around surveying folks that go through the application or the permitting process.

472
00:52:05.494 --> 00:52:06.135
<v Ben Hemson>Excuse me.

473
00:52:06.456 --> 00:52:14.278
<v Ben Hemson>I think this work aligns with, or that work aligns with this work in CAP-2, and we're looking forward to seeing how it all comes together going forward.

474
00:52:15.009 --> 00:52:20.255
<v Ben Hemson>And finally, just thank you to Council President Dunphy, Councilor Avalos, and the other sponsors.

475
00:52:21.559 --> 00:52:29.976
<v Ben Hemson>This is something we're looking forward to being engaged with, and I think we have that relationship with the folks in PPMD to provide our input as it progresses.

476
00:52:31.619 --> 00:52:31.963
<v Ben Hemson>Thank you.

477
00:52:32.699 --> 00:52:33.338
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Ben.

478
00:52:33.518 --> 00:52:35.958
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Sarah and Peter, for your invited testimony.

479
00:52:37.880 --> 00:52:39.927
<v Candace Avalos>Colleagues, we've— I see a lot of hands in the queue.

480
00:52:39.992 --> 00:52:42.762
<v Candace Avalos>We do have a couple of folks, uh, for public testimony.

481
00:52:42.940 --> 00:52:43.980
<v Candace Avalos>Are we cool moving forward?

482
00:52:44.094 --> 00:52:45.847
<v Candace Avalos>And we can— okay, sounds good.

483
00:52:46.123 --> 00:52:47.974
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, go ahead and call public testimony.

484
00:52:49.030 --> 00:52:51.697
<v Diego>First up, Lacey Sutton.

485
00:52:57.068 --> 00:52:59.072
<v Lacey Sutton>Hello again, I'm Lacey Sutton.

486
00:53:00.221 --> 00:53:13.786
<v Lacey Sutton>Um, so I'm aware that this permitting improvement stuff is all about the customer, the developers really especially the affordable housing developers, and not the people who will live in the houses and have to face the consequences of their shoddy work.

487
00:53:14.411 --> 00:53:19.077
<v Lacey Sutton>The city has made it abundantly clear that they don't care about us.

488
00:53:20.440 --> 00:53:21.530
<v Lacey Sutton>It's all about the numbers.

489
00:53:21.820 --> 00:53:22.733
<v Lacey Sutton>It's all about the money.

490
00:53:23.231 --> 00:53:26.630
<v Lacey Sutton>It's about making it easier for developers to build, build, build.

491
00:53:27.400 --> 00:53:34.646
<v Lacey Sutton>Okay, fine, then make it harder for them to do a bad job and make them have to come back and fix it when they do.

492
00:53:35.353 --> 00:53:39.235
<v Lacey Sutton>Create a mechanism for accountability because there is none now.

493
00:53:39.942 --> 00:53:46.182
<v Lacey Sutton>This is particularly necessary for affordable housing developers because we give them our money, lots of it.

494
00:53:46.583 --> 00:53:49.327
<v Lacey Sutton>We give them land tax exemptions.

495
00:53:49.695 --> 00:53:53.001
<v Lacey Sutton>We the people should expect a return on our investment.

496
00:53:53.402 --> 00:53:57.606
<v Lacey Sutton>So when they promise to provide safe and affordable housing, we should expect that.

497
00:53:58.199 --> 00:54:00.541
<v Lacey Sutton>We should expect them to honor their covenants.

498
00:54:00.847 --> 00:54:03.958
<v Lacey Sutton>We should expect compliance with land use codes and laws.

499
00:54:04.632 --> 00:54:19.373
<v Lacey Sutton>And we should expect Portland Fire and Rescue and Portland Permitting and Development to give a low market— sorry, low-income project in East Portland the same care and consideration that they would afford a market-rate project in the Pearl District.

500
00:54:20.077 --> 00:54:30.635
<v Lacey Sutton>When they don't do that, when on our dime they hurt the most vulnerable people in our society, people we were trying to help, we should demand accountability.

501
00:54:31.068 --> 00:54:31.853
<v Lacey Sutton>And we don't.

502
00:54:32.351 --> 00:54:34.387
<v Lacey Sutton>As a city, We just don't.

503
00:54:35.300 --> 00:54:36.983
<v Lacey Sutton>As a citizen, I have.

504
00:54:37.465 --> 00:54:46.701
<v Lacey Sutton>For over 2 years, I've been going around telling anyone who would listen about how the Fire Bureau and PP&D and Habitat for Humanity royally screwed up.

505
00:54:47.422 --> 00:55:13.742
<v Lacey Sutton>And for a long time, I truly believed that if the people in charge would just listen to me, if they would just look at the mountain of evidence, they would see that it was true, and then they would have to do something about but we're at this point where a lot of people, people who work for PF&R, PP&D, and Habitat, people on this council, a lot of people know what I've been saying is true.

506
00:55:14.873 --> 00:55:23.594
<v Lacey Sutton>They know that we're living with, with life-threatening code violations, violations that the city lied about and tried to cover up.

507
00:55:25.268 --> 00:55:33.094
<v Lacey Sutton>I stupidly believed that once the people in charge understood this to be true, they would act, because how could they not?

508
00:55:34.030 --> 00:55:39.503
<v Lacey Sutton>Yet here I— here we are, you know, here I am again because no one is doing anything.

509
00:55:41.175 --> 00:55:46.269
<v Lacey Sutton>The customer isn't just the developer, the architect, the landlord.

510
00:55:46.690 --> 00:55:48.307
<v Lacey Sutton>It's the low-income homeowner.

511
00:55:48.938 --> 00:55:50.344
<v Lacey Sutton>It's the low-income renter.

512
00:55:51.039 --> 00:55:58.507
<v Lacey Sutton>We are paying for a product that is not merely subpar, but dangerous, and we can't do anything to fix it.

513
00:55:58.831 --> 00:56:02.288
<v Lacey Sutton>We can't even move because we don't have the resources.

514
00:56:03.019 --> 00:56:13.076
<v Lacey Sutton>So let them build faster, let them build cheaper, but you must build a system of accountability for us, to us.

515
00:56:13.445 --> 00:56:13.768
<v Lacey Sutton>Thank you.

516
00:56:15.940 --> 00:56:16.471
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Lacy.

517
00:56:17.548 --> 00:56:19.719
<v Diego>Next is Byron Balog.

518
00:56:25.751 --> 00:56:26.463
<v Byron Balog>Good afternoon.

519
00:56:27.610 --> 00:56:27.820
<v Byron Balog>Welcome.

520
00:56:29.710 --> 00:56:32.621
<v Byron Balog>I am Byron Balog from LRS Architects.

521
00:56:36.000 --> 00:56:40.418
<v Byron Balog>Thank you, Chair Avalos and members of the committee, for allowing me to speak to you this afternoon.

522
00:56:40.626 --> 00:56:42.393
<v Byron Balog>It is my pleasure to speak to you.

523
00:56:42.442 --> 00:56:43.824
<v Byron Balog>My name is Byron Balog.

524
00:56:44.065 --> 00:56:48.773
<v Byron Balog>I am a practicing architect and senior associate at LRS Architects here in Portland.

525
00:56:49.679 --> 00:57:03.521
<v Byron Balog>I started my professional career here in 1987, nearly 40 years ago, and I have permitted over 100 projects here in the City of Portland over that time, probably 20 or 30 of those in the past 5 years.

526
00:57:04.228 --> 00:57:07.922
<v Byron Balog>Therefore, I am committed to seeing Portland's revitalization.

527
00:57:09.110 --> 00:57:18.329
<v Byron Balog>As I begin, I want to first acknowledge the talented and hardworking professionals who work in the city's bureaus and permitting departments who have reviewed my projects over the years.

528
00:57:19.054 --> 00:57:25.505
<v Byron Balog>I appreciate their mission, which is to serve and protect the public, and I want to thank them for their time and their efforts.

529
00:57:27.130 --> 00:57:33.735
<v Byron Balog>That being said, I want to testify that over the past 40 years, I've seen the permitting process grow in complexity.

530
00:57:34.449 --> 00:57:44.045
<v Byron Balog>This current decentralized and multilayered system that I have experienced over the years continues to take longer and jeopardize the timeline of viable projects.

531
00:57:44.880 --> 00:57:49.467
<v Byron Balog>In fact, I have— I bring 2 current examples today for you, for you to consider.

532
00:57:51.675 --> 00:58:00.730
<v Byron Balog>LRS Architects is involved in 2 very important, much-needed affordable housing projects that are currently under construction in the City of Portland.

533
00:58:01.583 --> 00:58:10.005
<v Byron Balog>One of those projects took 572 days from initial application to issuance of permits, and the other took 608 days.

534
00:58:10.052 --> 00:58:10.085
<v Byron Balog>Wow.

535
00:58:10.956 --> 00:58:22.161
<v Byron Balog>Now, certainly both projects took some curves and detours along the way, but both are prime examples of what it takes for an owner to get a project built in this city.

536
00:58:23.315 --> 00:58:28.445
<v Byron Balog>My colleagues for both these projects would be happy to share the details with you at another time.

537
00:58:29.568 --> 00:58:39.106
<v Byron Balog>In closing, I reiterate that the current permitting process is too long, too complicated, very costly, and discouraging owners from developing new projects in Portland.

538
00:58:39.650 --> 00:58:47.222
<v Byron Balog>Therefore, I fully support the CAP2 resolution to establish a more centralized and more streamlined approach to permitting in our city.

539
00:58:47.659 --> 00:58:48.356
<v Byron Balog>Thank you very much.

540
00:58:50.000 --> 00:58:50.820
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

541
00:58:52.447 --> 00:58:54.831
<v Diego>Last, I have Ben Hemson listed.

542
00:58:55.605 --> 00:59:02.168
<v Diego>If I may ask, Ben, did you have additional testimony you'd like to provide, or did you conclude your testimony during the presentation?

543
00:59:02.927 --> 00:59:04.672
<v Ben Hemson>I concluded it during the presentation.

544
00:59:04.768 --> 00:59:05.043
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

545
00:59:05.510 --> 00:59:06.286
<v Diego>Thank you so much.

546
00:59:06.382 --> 00:59:07.449
<v Diego>That concludes testimony.

547
00:59:07.820 --> 00:59:08.708
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you.

548
00:59:09.451 --> 00:59:12.018
<v Candace Avalos>Let's go ahead and jump in the queue, starting with Vice Chair Green.

549
00:59:14.722 --> 00:59:15.760
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

550
00:59:17.963 --> 00:59:19.663
<v Mitch Green>Council President Dunphy, come on up.

551
00:59:19.807 --> 00:59:20.067
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

552
00:59:21.929 --> 00:59:26.510
<v Mitch Green>I guess I see that Councilor Novick is a co-sponsor, so maybe this is an appropriate question for Councilor Novick.

553
00:59:26.557 --> 00:59:31.809
<v Mitch Green>So the big orange call-out bubble where you found the really interesting quote, did you write that?

554
00:59:32.018 --> 00:59:34.918
<v Mitch Green>That sounds like it's in your meter and your style of humor.

555
00:59:36.501 --> 00:59:39.023
<v Steve Novick>I'm not that— I'm less original than you think I am.

556
00:59:39.552 --> 00:59:45.739
<v Mitch Green>Okay, and maybe, may, you may or may or not have had a, a problem with building a door, so we'll find out.

557
00:59:45.804 --> 00:59:46.925
<v Mitch Green>Future friend.

558
00:59:47.070 --> 00:59:47.742
<v Mitch Green>Future friend.

559
00:59:48.032 --> 01:00:10.291
<v Mitch Green>Um, I appreciated seeing that because, I mean, I've, I did a bathroom remodel myself, um, and I used the permit process, and I think I had to add some stairs down there to make it conforming, and I think the cost of the permitting side was the cost of the actual other side of the job, and I just remember thinking at that time If I ever find my way in City Hall, I hope we can kind of work on this stuff.

560
01:00:10.438 --> 01:00:12.423
<v Mitch Green>I don't have to, fortunately, because you're taking the lead on this.

561
01:00:12.536 --> 01:00:13.182
<v Mitch Green>So thank you.

562
01:00:13.893 --> 01:00:16.282
<v Mitch Green>I'm broadly supportive of this, but I have a few questions.

563
01:00:18.210 --> 01:00:28.619
<v Mitch Green>One of the things that bubbles up for me is it's also related to the other discussions we've had around kind of core realignment and some of these kind of broader structural changes in the city.

564
01:00:28.942 --> 01:00:48.969
<v Mitch Green>How are we going to ensure that workers with that deep bureau-level experience who may be currently embedded in How are we going to ensure that they're going to be able to bring their knowledge to bear on the problem and sort of not be dismissed or not be sort of like laid off because they ask too many tough questions?

565
01:00:49.170 --> 01:00:52.099
<v Mitch Green>Like, are we going to take the change management part of it seriously here?

566
01:00:52.690 --> 01:00:58.110
<v Mitch Green>I guess you're not the bureau directors, but the resolution is providing the leadership.

567
01:00:58.110 --> 01:00:59.329
<v Mitch Green>So I'm curious if you have any thoughts on that.

568
01:00:59.329 --> 01:01:00.409
<v Mitch Green>I know you've thought about it.

569
01:01:00.409 --> 01:01:04.643
<v Council President Dunphy>Yeah, I think there's going to be an opportunity for this council to weigh in on what comes yes.

570
01:01:04.967 --> 01:01:14.498
<v Council President Dunphy>Before we start talking about rearranging where people sit, let alone who they report to or whether they, you know, their jobs are in what specific bureau.

571
01:01:15.163 --> 01:01:16.733
<v Council President Dunphy>We have a lot of decision points between this.

572
01:01:16.780 --> 01:01:33.237
<v Council President Dunphy>This sets us up to go tap into the bureaus that have already been thinking about some of these serious systematic changes that need to happen and relies on their good professional judgment, but also the survey results from customers and the guidance of this body.

573
01:01:33.958 --> 01:01:48.021
<v Council President Dunphy>So I think there's going to be plenty of opportunities for us to make sure we can really dig into some of the details, ensure that we are tapping into the professional expertise, protecting jobs, and also making sure that we get good results on the backside of it.

574
01:01:49.175 --> 01:01:50.235
<v Mitch Green>I'm grateful to hear that.

575
01:01:50.298 --> 01:01:57.884
<v Mitch Green>And I saw the kind of like that interplay with council and the reporting piece as an opportunity to kind of elevate labor as part of this as well.

576
01:01:57.931 --> 01:02:00.336
<v Mitch Green>So thanks for reiterating that intent here.

577
01:02:02.552 --> 01:02:13.240
<v Mitch Green>One thing that I'm really excited about, that's— it's in the kind of impact statements, there's a couple callouts that I think are important, is, you know, change of use and seismic requirements.

578
01:02:14.684 --> 01:02:24.427
<v Mitch Green>I have, you know, I've heard from some constituents or partners of the county that they've had some struggles trying to open a preschool using Preschool for All dollars.

579
01:02:24.474 --> 01:02:35.559
<v Mitch Green>And I'm curious, and I I see that we have staff in the back and I don't know if there's any need or requirement to answer directly to that, but does CAP 2 contemplate some of that?

580
01:02:35.945 --> 01:02:39.447
<v Mitch Green>Or if we're already solving that, let me know, then I can chill out.

581
01:02:39.880 --> 01:02:54.085
<v Council President Dunphy>You know, yeah, we— so there's the resolution before us, which is really about getting the team in place, you know, assembling the Avengers and then deciding how we're going to, save New York City.

582
01:02:56.659 --> 01:02:59.976
<v Council President Dunphy>There's a whole— there, yeah, there's a lot between here and there.

583
01:03:00.219 --> 01:03:09.644
<v Council President Dunphy>But I can tell you that the CAP2 team, the code— the permanent improvement team that is in place right now, they showed us an Excel spreadsheet based off of just the complaints from developers.

584
01:03:10.146 --> 01:03:12.445
<v Council President Dunphy>And, you know, some developers are, I think, are pretty unreasonable.

585
01:03:12.960 --> 01:03:16.534
<v Council President Dunphy>They're like, oh, building in Portland is too expensive because of bird-safe glazing.

586
01:03:16.809 --> 01:03:17.378
<v Council President Dunphy>That ain't it.

587
01:03:17.460 --> 01:03:18.157
<v Council President Dunphy>That's not what it is.

588
01:03:18.329 --> 01:03:32.081
<v Council President Dunphy>But over and over again, the same sort of themes around frontage improvements, dollar-based triggers, noncompliant conformity attempts, things like that, all kept coming up over and over again.

589
01:03:32.130 --> 01:03:42.224
<v Council President Dunphy>And this team really did understand where the value is going to be, and they're going to be able to drive that part of it forward now that they're going to be able to have the authority to say who is on first.

590
01:03:42.547 --> 01:03:54.135
<v Council President Dunphy>The reason Cap One came through and had some relatively minor but meaningful, but still relatively minor code suspensions was because they were the simplest to get across, across multiple bureaus.

591
01:03:54.873 --> 01:04:00.114
<v Council President Dunphy>This challenge of working across multiple bureaus is the challenge right now of solving the problem.

592
01:04:00.177 --> 01:04:06.637
<v Council President Dunphy>It's not that we don't know where the challenges are, it's getting everybody in the same room and saying who is on first base.

593
01:04:07.295 --> 01:04:08.802
<v Council President Dunphy>And that, that is what we're trying to accomplish with this.

594
01:04:09.298 --> 01:04:09.731
<v Mitch Green>That's great.

595
01:04:09.795 --> 01:04:25.295
<v Mitch Green>So it's— we're basically establishing council's intent To say we want to resource this and we want to make sure that we've got this kind of strike team, you know, assemble the Avengers for one last job to kind of accelerate our code change process.

596
01:04:25.358 --> 01:04:26.708
<v Mitch Green>And frankly, I think that's the right approach.

597
01:04:27.250 --> 01:04:30.612
<v Mitch Green>I've thought about, well, can I just go do these one-off amendments?

598
01:04:30.677 --> 01:04:34.170
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's— that maybe contributes to the same problem that we have.

599
01:04:34.219 --> 01:04:38.867
<v Mitch Green>I mean, this does need to be kind of an all hands on deck and kind of bureau-driven process.

600
01:04:39.177 --> 01:04:41.677
<v Mitch Green>Frankly, um, I think it's time.

601
01:04:41.885 --> 01:04:43.905
<v Mitch Green>I applaud you for bringing this forward.

602
01:04:44.112 --> 01:04:50.474
<v Mitch Green>Um, you know, apropos, I, I heard from an architect last week.

603
01:04:50.521 --> 01:04:55.313
<v Mitch Green>I went to A Better Portland Coffee, which I highly recommend anyone doing that if you haven't already.

604
01:04:56.130 --> 01:05:07.059
<v Mitch Green>And, um, he's working on a proposal with his firm to, um, reimagine our vacant storefronts, the, the sort of ground tail actual retail spaces as Yeah.

605
01:05:07.139 --> 01:05:11.447
<v Mitch Green>As places where you can have kind of modularized, lower-cost apartments.

606
01:05:11.721 --> 01:05:18.034
<v Mitch Green>And we usually think about the kind of office to residential, but this would be sort of storefronts to residential, which seems to solve a lot of different problems.

607
01:05:19.547 --> 01:05:27.581
<v Mitch Green>And that would involve surely some kind of change of occupancy considerations in that.

608
01:05:27.646 --> 01:05:30.532
<v Mitch Green>And so that's one of these things where it's like, here's a great idea.

609
01:05:33.228 --> 01:05:35.507
<v Mitch Green>Let it go to waste because it takes years and years and years.

610
01:05:35.554 --> 01:05:43.157
<v Mitch Green>So do you think that this team, if it stood up and properly resourced, would be able to sort of see those opportunities and say, we think this is top priority?

611
01:05:43.461 --> 01:05:52.539
<v Council President Dunphy>I really do, because I think some of the challenges that we have are where you have that intersection of, say, for example, converting a retail space.

612
01:05:53.005 --> 01:05:59.003
<v Council President Dunphy>You're going to have both the permitting and land use folks, but also the water and sewer bureaus, the transportation folks.

613
01:05:59.050 --> 01:06:06.306
<v Council President Dunphy>They're going to have some different considerations for sidewalk improvements in front of a retail space versus a, you know, second-story walk-up apartment.

614
01:06:07.099 --> 01:06:19.293
<v Council President Dunphy>This is an opportunity to be able to really meaningfully deliver on things exactly like that that we never could have done in the previous system because the permitting bureau would send it off and then it would go to the water engineer.

615
01:06:19.342 --> 01:06:21.139
<v Council President Dunphy>I'm not— I'm just picking randomly on a water engineer.

616
01:06:21.186 --> 01:06:21.898
<v Council President Dunphy>I apologize, water.

617
01:06:21.978 --> 01:06:28.231
<v Council President Dunphy>But the water engineer who has to then have dig through all the other 500 applications and suddenly 6 months has gone by.

618
01:06:28.344 --> 01:06:28.393
<v Council President Dunphy>Yeah.

619
01:06:29.197 --> 01:06:37.771
<v Council President Dunphy>We are now gonna be in a spot with, if this resolution passes and the plan that comes back, we'll be able to actually be more directive to staff and say, actually, we need to get that permit done quickly.

620
01:06:37.869 --> 01:06:40.501
<v Council President Dunphy>We need to make sure that these things are moving through with a certain timeline.

621
01:06:41.097 --> 01:06:56.079
<v Council President Dunphy>That is the goal, is allow us to be not able to do just the easy normal things that are the book of business that are still enormously expensive, complicated, and time-consuming, but to also, yeah, meet the challenges right now of vacant storefronts, vacant office spaces.

622
01:06:56.175 --> 01:06:57.445
<v Council President Dunphy>What are we gonna do with these spaces?

623
01:06:57.797 --> 01:07:08.960
<v Council President Dunphy>And if we don't have the team and the systems in place to be able to meet that moment, it doesn't matter how enthusiastic developers or outside parties are going to be to move this city forward.

624
01:07:09.007 --> 01:07:10.931
<v Council President Dunphy>So I have every confidence that this will help.

625
01:07:11.653 --> 01:07:12.391
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

626
01:07:12.472 --> 01:07:24.771
<v Mitch Green>And then lastly, I'll just make an appeal to this committee, to the bureaus, to take it to heart, Lacey Sutton's testimony on sort of the other side of the coin here.

627
01:07:24.978 --> 01:07:28.623
<v Mitch Green>If we're going to have this reporting function on as we go through this.

628
01:07:28.751 --> 01:07:40.007
<v Mitch Green>I want to make sure we're not missing that kind of what is the impact to the accountability side when we do these changes, because I've heard this a couple different times now and I want to make sure we take action.

629
01:07:40.070 --> 01:07:40.472
<v Donny Oliveira>Thanks.

630
01:07:40.954 --> 01:07:41.516
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

631
01:07:42.864 --> 01:07:43.153
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

632
01:07:43.443 --> 01:07:44.293
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Koyama Lane.

633
01:07:45.047 --> 01:07:45.626
<v Byron Balog>Thank you.

634
01:07:45.786 --> 01:07:58.338
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Vice Chair Green, too, for that segue, because I was going to also say something regarding What Lacey has shared with us a few times, and to be honest, it is— a lot of what you share is really horrifying.

635
01:07:58.996 --> 01:08:11.577
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, if you have any examples, or if anyone else who's watching has examples of how other jurisdictions have built-in accountability or oversight, I would really love to have that sent to me directly.

636
01:08:12.317 --> 01:08:13.599
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, and thank you.

637
01:08:14.820 --> 01:08:17.194
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And thank you to my colleagues for working on this.

638
01:08:17.387 --> 01:08:26.168
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you to all those who came here to testify, everyone, but especially Sarah, because Councilor Green, do you want to guess why?

639
01:08:27.579 --> 01:08:28.335
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We always have this joke.

640
01:08:28.479 --> 01:08:30.713
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Oh, did you teach Sarah's kids?

641
01:08:30.890 --> 01:08:32.047
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I taught her kids.

642
01:08:32.400 --> 01:08:32.609
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah.

643
01:08:33.703 --> 01:08:36.065
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I appreciated what Byron said.

644
01:08:36.113 --> 01:08:40.872
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I tried to write it, you were talking fast, but permitting is too long, too complicated, very discouraging.

645
01:08:41.212 --> 01:08:43.724
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I hear that a lot from folks.

646
01:08:44.506 --> 01:08:46.541
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's also a piece of me that's like, I want to work on that.

647
01:08:46.621 --> 01:08:47.662
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm not exactly sure how.

648
01:08:48.528 --> 01:08:54.152
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then I'm like, this is what we need, like a team that actually knows how to do that and has those skills and is ready to do that.

649
01:08:54.216 --> 01:08:55.225
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So thank you for that.

650
01:08:56.298 --> 01:09:04.823
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>One thing I loved hearing in this presentation is that already the DCAs are like, thank you for working with us and for bringing us in.

651
01:09:05.015 --> 01:09:09.229
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And having partners here shows that there's been some back and forth.

652
01:09:09.358 --> 01:09:16.393
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Council President, can you talk a little bit about what that back and forth and engagement has looked like with the DCAs, the bureaus, with the community.

653
01:09:16.953 --> 01:09:21.503
<v Council President Dunphy>Yeah, you know, I have had a particular interest in fixing our permitting system.

654
01:09:21.680 --> 01:09:27.657
<v Council President Dunphy>And when I worked for Commissioner Nick Fish, I lived deep in the permitting system for many years, and I knew where a lot of the flaws were.

655
01:09:28.265 --> 01:09:38.904
<v Council President Dunphy>So when I first got into office, I sat down with DCA Oliveira to talk about what are some of the big swings that we actually need to take that requires— that the bureaus couldn't do on their own and requires leadership.

656
01:09:39.082 --> 01:09:39.561
<v Council President Dunphy>From council.

657
01:09:39.962 --> 01:09:51.068
<v Council President Dunphy>And this is the first big swing that we identified, that the question of who is on first lingers through all of our codes and it taints all of our administrative rules.

658
01:09:51.261 --> 01:10:01.180
<v Council President Dunphy>If until we can identify that question, who is in charge when it comes to these questions of code writing and code implementation, we couldn't really begin to do much more to improve the system.

659
01:10:01.275 --> 01:10:14.534
<v Council President Dunphy>And so this was a part, and candidly, This was not something— this kind of council-driven leadership is not something that was easy to come by in the old form of government because of that cross-bureau requirement.

660
01:10:16.090 --> 01:10:20.324
<v Council President Dunphy>This is our first real opportunity as a city to try and answer this question meaningfully.

661
01:10:20.533 --> 01:10:29.703
<v Council President Dunphy>And so we've worked closely with the DCAs, both the— or the most applicable bureaus, actually also with the public safety areas as they have fire, and fire does a lot of permitting.

662
01:10:30.621 --> 01:10:40.976
<v Council President Dunphy>We've worked with a lot of community groups, nonprofits, and for-profits developers, folks who are housing advocates, and also folks who may not in other circumstances necessarily be friends of mine.

663
01:10:41.796 --> 01:10:56.054
<v Council President Dunphy>And everybody seems to be, you know, that we worked with gave some input into this and seems to agree or see themselves that the challenges we are trying to solve are real challenges, not ones that are so niche that it's not worth the time.

664
01:10:56.422 --> 01:10:58.719
<v Council President Dunphy>These are the big swings that everybody seems to agree on.

665
01:10:59.336 --> 01:11:02.537
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So it sounds like there's been quite a bit of workshopping, which is great.

666
01:11:03.237 --> 01:11:16.322
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And when you say who's on first, is part of that making sure that you're empowering permitting and saying all bureaus, you need to kind of, you need to help out.

667
01:11:16.547 --> 01:11:17.600
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We need you to be part of this.

668
01:11:17.680 --> 01:11:18.554
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is happening.

669
01:11:19.250 --> 01:11:19.800
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is that part of it?

670
01:11:19.881 --> 01:11:20.350
<v Byron Balog>Absolutely.

671
01:11:20.528 --> 01:11:21.386
<v Council President Dunphy>Yeah, absolutely.

672
01:11:21.483 --> 01:11:24.739
<v Council President Dunphy>It's about structurally giving direction to the right.

673
01:11:24.851 --> 01:11:33.231
<v Council President Dunphy>To the various bureaus to say that this is the important, you know, order of operations, that this is how we are going to get this permit done.

674
01:11:33.344 --> 01:11:34.337
<v Council President Dunphy>We're going to get it out the door.

675
01:11:34.546 --> 01:11:35.636
<v Council President Dunphy>We're going to get it done in a time.

676
01:11:36.773 --> 01:11:43.167
<v Council President Dunphy>And this does empower those bureaus to— and gives clear direction on the path we want to move forward.

677
01:11:43.262 --> 01:11:46.931
<v Council President Dunphy>Right now, code writing and code implementation are done by different bureaus, right?

678
01:11:47.748 --> 01:11:51.675
<v Council President Dunphy>Even within the code writing, there's multiple places within the city that also write code.

679
01:11:52.555 --> 01:12:07.250
<v Council President Dunphy>And this at the very least gives us a place, I mean, day to day, I'm sure that some of the specifics won't change, but when we are able to actually see that there's a conflict, this will empower the bureaucracy to say, actually, this is how we're going to move forward.

680
01:12:07.779 --> 01:12:08.452
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks for explaining.

681
01:12:08.515 --> 01:12:20.514
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And when I was hearing about it, it was reminding me, I was making sense of it and thinking about Vision Zero work and how the ask was like it needs to be seen as citywide and we need to have different bureaus being able to be nimble and work together.

682
01:12:20.561 --> 01:12:21.853
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So that makes sense to me.

683
01:12:22.466 --> 01:12:26.146
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You can answer this, or feel free to bring up DCAs.

684
01:12:28.100 --> 01:12:28.229
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How—.

685
01:12:28.761 --> 01:12:35.296
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What do we— what is needed for this team, this work to be done properly, for it to be resourced?

686
01:12:35.377 --> 01:12:37.104
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What's the capacity that's needed?

687
01:12:37.492 --> 01:12:40.631
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is there a financial ask?

688
01:12:41.018 --> 01:12:42.595
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is there work that's not going to happen?

689
01:12:43.030 --> 01:12:43.304
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is this—.

690
01:12:43.997 --> 01:12:44.898
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, can you speak to that a bit?

691
01:12:45.123 --> 01:12:51.041
<v Council President Dunphy>Yeah, invariably there will be a financial We are going to need to resource these folks to be able to do this work.

692
01:12:51.105 --> 01:12:52.164
<v Council President Dunphy>I don't know what that looks like.

693
01:12:52.212 --> 01:12:57.414
<v Council President Dunphy>And I think partially I'm leaving that to council to help us decide based off of what comes back from the administration.

694
01:12:57.912 --> 01:13:05.168
<v Council President Dunphy>We wanna see what the plan is and based on what the plan is and what this council agrees to, that will help determine the resource requirements.

695
01:13:05.555 --> 01:13:06.613
<v Council President Dunphy>But that is an expected—.

696
01:13:06.613 --> 01:13:06.774
<v Council President Dunphy>Okay.

697
01:13:06.935 --> 01:13:16.359
<v Council President Dunphy>Today, this is not us obligating our future selves to anything without future proactive efforts to say, yes, this is what we're doing and this is how we're gonna pay for it.

698
01:13:17.130 --> 01:13:21.109
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So we are asking in this resolution, come back to us and let us know what you need?

699
01:13:21.206 --> 01:13:21.992
<v Council President Dunphy>More or less, yeah.

700
01:13:22.072 --> 01:13:27.479
<v Council President Dunphy>To come back and say within a set timeline, this is the permit team, these are how we're gonna move these things.

701
01:13:27.864 --> 01:13:29.470
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, thank you, Council President.

702
01:13:29.791 --> 01:13:35.904
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think these questions are maybe for Donny and Millicent, my next 2.

703
01:13:36.451 --> 01:13:43.158
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm interested in understanding if there are changes that we need at the state level to improve our local permitting processes.

704
01:13:43.270 --> 01:13:49.019
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know last year, as a city, we supported accessible housing legislation that touched on building code.

705
01:13:49.387 --> 01:13:56.243
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So are any of the service areas planning to work with OGR on any concepts or advocacy for the upcoming session?

706
01:13:56.981 --> 01:14:00.578
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you for the question, Councilor Don Oliveira, for the record.

707
01:14:01.654 --> 01:14:04.095
<v Donny Oliveira>Councilor, we are always responding to state action.

708
01:14:04.304 --> 01:14:25.204
<v Donny Oliveira>In fact, BPS is working on a code project that council will be contemplating later this year that is taking state adopted code and aligning our city code, and simultaneously we're always advocating each session for pieces that we think are relevant to improve to improve our systems both from a code perspective and authority.

709
01:14:25.270 --> 01:14:27.454
<v Donny Oliveira>We always want to retain as much local authority as possible.

710
01:14:27.519 --> 01:14:31.617
<v Donny Oliveira>So kudos to OGR for constantly fighting for that stance.

711
01:14:32.323 --> 01:14:34.958
<v Donny Oliveira>Related to this specifically, you know we touched on size.

712
01:14:35.072 --> 01:14:37.752
<v Donny Oliveira>I think that's a place that we always look at.

713
01:14:37.945 --> 01:14:49.956
<v Donny Oliveira>Land use continues to be a place that we want more flexibility from state related to everything from brownfields cleanup, even to improving our ability to navigate building code and land use code related to housing.

714
01:14:50.003 --> 01:14:59.670
<v Donny Oliveira>So the answer is yes, we'll be putting forward some ledge session issue sheets from the service area that we hope council will support as we continue to improve.

715
01:14:59.719 --> 01:14:59.814
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you.

716
01:15:01.966 --> 01:15:02.930
<v Donny Oliveira>Any thoughts, Director?

717
01:15:03.412 --> 01:15:03.782
<v Millicent Williams>What he said.

718
01:15:04.296 --> 01:15:04.632
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Love it.

719
01:15:05.581 --> 01:15:12.103
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I know we're starting to head into those conversations already with what we want to ask OGR to be talking about.

720
01:15:12.182 --> 01:15:17.917
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So yeah, if anything else comes up, but I wrote down local authorities, seismic, and land use.

721
01:15:18.414 --> 01:15:29.554
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And if you want, if it's helpful for us to be, for myself, I can say, to be talking to OGR about some of those That would be— I would love to hear, because I know permitting is very important.

722
01:15:30.670 --> 01:15:34.228
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, and then my last thing is kind of a joke but kind of not.

723
01:15:34.323 --> 01:15:38.237
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I just feel like we have so many acronyms, and I was like, is— are we going to call this team PIT?

724
01:15:38.752 --> 01:15:39.717
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And can we just not?

725
01:15:39.798 --> 01:15:41.222
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can we just like not?

726
01:15:41.806 --> 01:15:49.014
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It like just makes me think of like the pits and also like Pitocin, um, which is what they say in, in the hospital, and they're like, give them more PIT.

727
01:15:49.435 --> 01:15:51.796
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Or maybe are you already giving— or is this team already called the PIT?

728
01:15:51.930 --> 01:15:57.060
<v Donny Oliveira>We were looking at some other names, maybe PITA, trying to find an A, something more delicious.

729
01:15:57.189 --> 01:15:59.800
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Or just like, just, yeah, do we need another acronym?

730
01:16:00.010 --> 01:16:00.909
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Like, just say the words.

731
01:16:00.909 --> 01:16:01.989
<v Millicent Williams>Permit Improvement Team.

732
01:16:01.989 --> 01:16:04.050
<v Donny Oliveira>Yeah, this committee loves its acronyms, Councilor.

733
01:16:04.050 --> 01:16:06.850
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Ignore me, and I'll, I'll support, I'll support the PIT if needed.

734
01:16:06.850 --> 01:16:08.649
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

735
01:16:08.649 --> 01:16:10.250
<v Candace Avalos>You're silly.

736
01:16:10.250 --> 01:16:11.899
<v Candace Avalos>Um, all right, Councilor Novick.

737
01:16:12.489 --> 01:16:13.390
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

738
01:16:13.390 --> 01:16:22.506
<v Steve Novick>I actually put myself in the queue because, uh, Director Williams piqued my interest when she said she might say other things and Speaking as PBOT director, so I wanna ask you to do that.

739
01:16:22.586 --> 01:16:25.154
<v Steve Novick>But before that, there are 3 other things I wanted to say.

740
01:16:26.550 --> 01:16:35.545
<v Steve Novick>One is that I fully expect that the path forward we hear from staff in another 150 days will be a path forward that will take time and resources to follow.

741
01:16:35.884 --> 01:16:40.028
<v Steve Novick>Nobody's gonna make a— wave a magic wand and make everything better easily.

742
01:16:42.166 --> 01:16:45.256
<v Steve Novick>And Council President, there were 2 things you said I had to respond to.

743
01:16:46.698 --> 01:16:47.837
<v Steve Novick>One is that O.G.

744
01:16:47.917 --> 01:16:51.238
<v Steve Novick>Ananobi and Jalen Brunson have already saved New York City, so that's taken care of.

745
01:16:51.286 --> 01:16:52.152
<v Steve Novick>We don't have to do that.

746
01:16:52.649 --> 01:16:59.916
<v Steve Novick>And the other is that studies show that cities named after former Postmasters General of the United States have always led the nation in permitting.

747
01:17:00.011 --> 01:17:01.921
<v Steve Novick>So beating Gresham might be a stretch.

748
01:17:02.979 --> 01:17:03.605
<v Steve Novick>Director Williams.

749
01:17:04.904 --> 01:17:06.556
<v Millicent Williams>Yes, thank you so much, Councilor Novick.

750
01:17:06.604 --> 01:17:09.363
<v Millicent Williams>Millicent Williams, for the record, Director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

751
01:17:10.439 --> 01:17:15.234
<v Millicent Williams>In my previous statement, I indicated that I'd be happy to share insights from a bureau perspective.

752
01:17:16.212 --> 01:17:22.527
<v Millicent Williams>I will also note that Director Kooch is here from PP&D who might be able to share even a different perspective.

753
01:17:23.505 --> 01:17:27.832
<v Millicent Williams>I will share that PBOT is excited about continuing to be a part of the process.

754
01:17:28.730 --> 01:17:39.519
<v Millicent Williams>We continue to try to find opportunities to help to streamline, but as has been indicated pretty clearly, it's been articulated pretty clearly, the conflict is with the code.

755
01:17:39.600 --> 01:17:39.728
<v Millicent Williams>Code.

756
01:17:40.176 --> 01:17:47.659
<v Millicent Williams>Um, there are, um, pages and pages and reams and reams and notebooks and notebooks and tables full of code that need to be deconflicted.

757
01:17:48.188 --> 01:18:03.956
<v Millicent Williams>And once that happens, and when that happens, uh, we can anticipate that things will move much more quickly, uh, much more, um, equitably, and, uh, in ways that are defensible by all of the bureaus.

758
01:18:04.453 --> 01:18:07.788
<v Millicent Williams>Um, none of the bureaus wanted speak for each other.

759
01:18:08.720 --> 01:18:21.163
<v Millicent Williams>And I think that it is important for there to be the identity that's important for each of the— especially Public Works bureaus— to maintain, because there are components of our work that's really important that we preserve.

760
01:18:22.046 --> 01:18:37.284
<v Millicent Williams>But in each of those instances, if it's the Water Bureau, if it's BES, if it's PBOT, we're also willing to have the conversations about how can we work most closely with the development permitting team, as well as our sister bureaus within Public Works.

761
01:18:37.622 --> 01:18:38.922
<v Millicent Williams>To identify solutions.

762
01:18:39.243 --> 01:18:46.823
<v Millicent Williams>So there have been some individual instances when we've come together to look at how we might make things easier, how we can service a specific need.

763
01:18:47.819 --> 01:18:53.728
<v Millicent Williams>There are tons of opportunities, and one should not have to come to this body to get quick action.

764
01:18:53.840 --> 01:18:57.340
<v Millicent Williams>They should be able to go through the process, and that is something that we look forward to as well.

765
01:18:58.319 --> 01:19:12.154
<v Millicent Williams>Regarding the appropriate authorities to help to make those ultimate decisions, and this is something that the DCA and the city administrator, mayor, former city administrator, and DCA, Donna Paul, discussed is the role of that ultimate decider.

766
01:19:12.684 --> 01:19:14.078
<v Millicent Williams>Um, is that a bureau head?

767
01:19:14.126 --> 01:19:14.815
<v Millicent Williams>Is that a DCA?

768
01:19:14.944 --> 01:19:15.890
<v Millicent Williams>Is it the city administrator?

769
01:19:15.985 --> 01:19:23.055
<v Millicent Williams>Or is it something like a city engineer, uh, which is not something that we have as a standalone function right now that lives within PBOT?

770
01:19:23.503 --> 01:19:35.109
<v Millicent Williams>Uh, it is a role, it is not a position, but that is something that has been explored as we've considered how to ensure that there is a person who can serve as the referee or the arbiter between, uh, what should be happening and what is happening.

771
01:19:36.796 --> 01:19:37.153
<v Peter Finley Fry>That—.

772
01:19:37.234 --> 01:19:43.547
<v Steve Novick>Is that something that y'all are continuing to explore, the idea of a— yes, an overall city engineer?

773
01:19:43.854 --> 01:19:49.457
<v Millicent Williams>Yes, and that's something that we've discussed even with, uh, Council President Dunphy, uh, in our conversations.

774
01:19:51.882 --> 01:19:52.527
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

775
01:19:54.603 --> 01:19:55.875
<v Candace Avalos>All right, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

776
01:19:57.018 --> 01:19:57.710
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

777
01:19:59.466 --> 01:20:06.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Councilor Koyama Lane, I can't believe you want to give up the opportunity to talk about our city pit crew kicking the tires on our permitting department.

778
01:20:09.643 --> 01:20:10.872
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I can make an event, maybe.

779
01:20:11.018 --> 01:20:23.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I know a few people have mentioned cost already, but there's a cost to even putting together the what of what we might do in the future.

780
01:20:23.588 --> 01:20:38.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I want to ask the question that Councilor Koyama Lane did, but about the first part of this work, which is what will it cost or what will we not do over the next 150 days while you all put together a plan for us to think about planning?

781
01:20:39.850 --> 01:20:41.293
<v Donny Oliveira>Yeah, thanks for the question, Councilor.

782
01:20:41.390 --> 01:20:43.509
<v Donny Oliveira>So take one step back real quick.

783
01:20:44.103 --> 01:20:50.296
<v Donny Oliveira>One of the most significant things the prior council did when they created the first Permit Improvement Task Force was to resource it to be staffed.

784
01:20:50.842 --> 01:20:57.070
<v Donny Oliveira>So that allowed those staff to work with the bureaus to come up with what ultimately became PP&D and the first code element project.

785
01:20:57.136 --> 01:20:59.614
<v Donny Oliveira>So that was, you know, essentially 4 FTE over 2 years.

786
01:21:01.340 --> 01:21:08.944
<v Donny Oliveira>For us to continue CAP 2, we were able to internalize a couple of those positions, one within PP&D, one within BPS, to keep that work going for CAP 2.

787
01:21:09.009 --> 01:21:11.112
<v Donny Oliveira>But we're going to rely on existing staff.

788
01:21:11.597 --> 01:21:12.779
<v Donny Oliveira>And this is what I was alluding to earlier.

789
01:21:13.579 --> 01:21:15.502
<v Donny Oliveira>Our existing staff went within all the bureaus.

790
01:21:15.582 --> 01:21:16.494
<v Donny Oliveira>I can say this comfortably.

791
01:21:16.543 --> 01:21:18.579
<v Donny Oliveira>There's not a bureau that, that this doesn't include.

792
01:21:18.726 --> 01:21:19.069
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you.

793
01:21:19.662 --> 01:21:21.362
<v Donny Oliveira>Everybody is overleveraged.

794
01:21:21.443 --> 01:21:26.365
<v Donny Oliveira>Our best reviewers, engineers, planners, they have full workloads.

795
01:21:27.024 --> 01:21:37.287
<v Donny Oliveira>And so now if we're asking them to not give up anything, keep your workload, and oh, by the way, now you're going to be a part of a team that is going to develop the next phase of code alignment or the next phase of permitting, that's just unfair.

796
01:21:38.122 --> 01:21:44.697
<v Donny Oliveira>So if we're asking— when we come back in 150 days, we do expect to come with a— if we want to do this well, here's what we're going to need to do.

797
01:21:44.761 --> 01:21:44.872
<v Donny Oliveira>Thank you.

798
01:21:44.970 --> 01:21:47.694
<v Donny Oliveira>Need to resource that work to make that big change.

799
01:21:48.271 --> 01:21:51.189
<v Donny Oliveira>Can we get to the first 150-day milestone with existing staff?

800
01:21:51.253 --> 01:21:52.904
<v Donny Oliveira>Yes, I think that's reasonable.

801
01:21:53.161 --> 01:21:57.841
<v Donny Oliveira>Again, I think somebody— a councilor mentioned this already— there are already great ideas in the bureaus.

802
01:21:57.890 --> 01:21:59.012
<v Donny Oliveira>We don't have to fish very hard.

803
01:21:59.092 --> 01:22:02.363
<v Donny Oliveira>We're hearing great feedback from our community partners and stakeholders.

804
01:22:02.475 --> 01:22:04.175
<v Donny Oliveira>We don't have to fish very hard for what's next.

805
01:22:04.639 --> 01:22:08.134
<v Donny Oliveira>It's do we have the time and resources to implement that next plan?

806
01:22:08.631 --> 01:22:14.573
<v Donny Oliveira>So we have the resources to get to 150-day mark We have the resources for that 60-day cap to scoping.

807
01:22:14.832 --> 01:22:15.962
<v Donny Oliveira>That's already in play, by the way.

808
01:22:17.880 --> 01:22:21.979
<v Donny Oliveira>But what comes after 150 days, that will be the question that will come back to council for, for support.

809
01:22:22.592 --> 01:22:27.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that 150 days will fall sometime in between the fall TAO and the next budget, correct?

810
01:22:28.305 --> 01:22:30.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Which means there may be a bit of time we're waiting there.

811
01:22:32.114 --> 01:22:32.243
<v Donny Oliveira>Yes.

812
01:22:32.421 --> 01:22:35.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you give us a sense of scale?

813
01:22:35.583 --> 01:22:39.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're finishing up the this budget work, everyone is already going to start thinking about next budget.

814
01:22:40.676 --> 01:22:42.570
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't expect to have a lot of extra money.

815
01:22:42.764 --> 01:22:48.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What should we be contemplating in terms of scale needing to do here?

816
01:22:48.608 --> 01:22:49.570
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What are we walking into?

817
01:22:50.052 --> 01:22:59.429
<v Donny Oliveira>I, I'm going to speak right now, just something, a brief conversation I had with DCA Donna Paul, but this does not encapsulate the full, you know, brain trust of our city.

818
01:23:00.104 --> 01:23:06.734
<v Donny Oliveira>It's possible that we're going to come with a couple of different options like the, you know, what did a 4-FTE team, would that look like for CAP 1?

819
01:23:07.393 --> 01:23:13.766
<v Donny Oliveira>And then something more robust, something that Council President's been pushing us to do, like what would be the major move, the moonshot maneuver?

820
01:23:14.233 --> 01:23:17.604
<v Donny Oliveira>And we'll put a, you know, put a resource allocation to that and then we'll discuss it.

821
01:23:18.086 --> 01:23:21.280
<v Donny Oliveira>But there's probably going to be something that looks like that, Councilor, because I don't—.

822
01:23:21.842 --> 01:23:24.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're talking between 4 and 10 people-ish?

823
01:23:24.894 --> 01:23:25.970
<v Donny Oliveira>Yes, that seems reasonable.

824
01:23:26.097 --> 01:23:26.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

825
01:23:26.532 --> 01:23:28.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I promise I won't hold you to a specific number.

826
01:23:28.442 --> 01:23:30.466
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But scale is helpful for me.

827
01:23:30.514 --> 01:23:30.835
<v Donny Oliveira>That's right.

828
01:23:31.573 --> 01:23:43.149
<v Donny Oliveira>And again, this is the goal here is, again, we have super talented people within PBOT, BPS, PP&D, water, et cetera, but they all have incredibly overleveraged work plans already.

829
01:23:43.230 --> 01:23:45.960
<v Donny Oliveira>So to continue to tap them is just unfair.

830
01:23:46.569 --> 01:23:48.626
<v Donny Oliveira>And I think they would love a little support anyway.

831
01:23:48.770 --> 01:23:53.538
<v Donny Oliveira>So I think we can resource them to do their ongoing work and this new workload.

832
01:23:54.132 --> 01:23:54.533
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

833
01:23:54.840 --> 01:23:59.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I agree with many of my colleagues that this is important work.

834
01:23:59.270 --> 01:24:17.944
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should be a city where people know that we have policies that match our values, but an easy path to navigate them to get permits, and a path to the point that we heard earlier that we actually require everybody to follow, which is easier to do when our code is simpler.

835
01:24:20.609 --> 01:24:22.006
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think this is important work.

836
01:24:22.311 --> 01:24:35.399
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am not without a bit of nervousness about it though, and I want to state that for the record because I think it is important when we do reform work like this that we don't swing the pendulum too far the other way.

837
01:24:36.104 --> 01:24:50.826
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And everything that I have heard our chief sponsor, co-sponsors, our leads within the administration say is right on track with where I hope this goes, where the proposal goes, and where the work of the group that we presumably put together next year goes.

838
01:24:51.667 --> 01:25:11.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I'm also looking at a 4th be it resolved that doesn't just say the administration will consider, but that the administrator must ensure that the improvements do things like address change of use and occupancy requirements, non-conforming conforming use requirements.

839
01:25:11.876 --> 01:25:14.734
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are things that can start to creep into policy changes.

840
01:25:15.873 --> 01:25:28.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what I'm hearing promised is this isn't policy change, this is streamlining, this is reformation, this is keeping the policies that ensure we build to our values but doing it better.

841
01:25:29.136 --> 01:25:30.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I have a little nervousness.

842
01:25:30.726 --> 01:25:40.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm looking at the next resolved that convenes an advisory body with external stakeholders and experts, which is critically important.

843
01:25:40.307 --> 01:25:43.060
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those are the people who know best what reforms we need to make.

844
01:25:43.833 --> 01:25:46.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They are also the people who may want some of those policy changes.

845
01:25:47.881 --> 01:26:05.552
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I will be asking when we get that preliminary piece of work back in 150 days to get information and to really walk through with us what of these changes are what of these changes are deconflicting?

846
01:26:06.212 --> 01:26:09.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If so, how was the decision made about how we deconflicted?

847
01:26:09.261 --> 01:26:16.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Where do we start to border on policy changes that might require their own discussion and debate?

848
01:26:16.680 --> 01:26:34.422
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Not because the policy change is inherently bad, but because when we wrap up policy changes in what look at the surface like technical administrative changes, we lose trust in the stakeholders who ask for those changes— or from them, rather, right?

849
01:26:34.551 --> 01:26:36.686
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Every piece of code there was put there for a reason.

850
01:26:37.280 --> 01:27:04.788
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They don't all need to be there, but I want to make sure that the work that we are asking to have done today is the work of deconflicting and streamlining and making this a city where our permits reflect our values and allow people to navigate them in the easiest possible way of any city in the region, and that we're not stepping into that policy work in a backdoor sort of way.

851
01:27:06.024 --> 01:27:22.117
<v Council President Dunphy>I will say that as, as the, the chief sponsor of this, it is absolutely my intention that we are not currently changing policies and that this absolutely will result in a point where some policies will need to be changed, and this council will be the body to be able to have those conversations.

852
01:27:22.180 --> 01:27:27.832
<v Council President Dunphy>This really absolutely is, as I think you were leading towards, that this is about process.

853
01:27:27.961 --> 01:27:36.198
<v Council President Dunphy>This is about arranging our own house, but that when we have those policy conversations that will inevitably come out of this, we will be able to move that direction.

854
01:27:36.551 --> 01:27:41.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would ask that when those policy changes do come to us, they come as standalone policy changes.

855
01:27:41.770 --> 01:27:41.881
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

856
01:27:42.011 --> 01:28:02.159
<v Donny Oliveira>Separate from the more administrative Councilor, but I think you are— because I don't want to, um, understate that if, as we evaluate our permitting processes, we're going to see procedures that the administration largely has a lot of control over.

857
01:28:02.229 --> 01:28:09.510
<v Donny Oliveira>We're going to see code that we're going to need you to help us clean up because the intent is not being met how the code's being administered, and we need some true-ups there.

858
01:28:09.510 --> 01:28:11.329
<v Donny Oliveira>And there may be some things that we that need to do that we are not see in the code.

859
01:28:11.329 --> 01:28:11.449
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's a good point.

860
01:28:11.546 --> 01:28:13.100
<v Donny Oliveira>Actually this is a policy change.

861
01:28:13.164 --> 01:28:21.341
<v Donny Oliveira>The, the world has changed, City of Portland values have changed, whatever it may be that we think a code alignment is not just improvement but actually a change.

862
01:28:21.742 --> 01:28:29.243
<v Donny Oliveira>And we will— and, you know, to Council President's point, there will be a moment, you know, or two that will bring something that's distinct that supports the whole thing.

863
01:28:29.436 --> 01:28:44.182
<v Donny Oliveira>And I also just want to flag that because, uh, it got mentioned briefly earlier, there's the CAP2 work, but there continues to be a bunch of work around Councilor Zimmerman and Morillo's design review work, that is essentially improvement of our permitting system, very discrete.

864
01:28:44.520 --> 01:29:00.115
<v Donny Oliveira>So there's a whole suite of things that I know from a CEDSA perspective we're trying to get our hands around, like how are these things all interacting together and what is code, what is policy, what is just procedural that we need to almost Gantt chart and map out for council and the public to see, oh, these are the different moving parts.

865
01:29:00.501 --> 01:29:00.757
<v Donny Oliveira>But there—.

866
01:29:01.064 --> 01:29:07.823
<v Donny Oliveira>I don't want to undersell that there's probably a policy Certainly.

867
01:29:08.015 --> 01:29:28.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just hope that those come separate from the administrative pieces and that they're presented with clarity that this may come out of an administrative process, but it is a big policy decision, as opposed to what I hope is a robust package of more procedural changes that allow us to get moving quickly on the other parts of this.

868
01:29:28.221 --> 01:29:28.552
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Herbold.

869
01:29:28.841 --> 01:29:42.636
<v Council President Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, if this resolution passes today, you have my personal assurance that I will make sure that administrative easy decisions come separately from any of the meaty policy directional changes that we need to take as a city.

870
01:29:43.373 --> 01:29:44.769
<v Council President Dunphy>Those deserve the time and space.

871
01:29:45.764 --> 01:29:55.515
<v Council President Dunphy>We don't need to waste our time on some of the more boring administrata, but these sort of things, absolutely, I will make sure that we're not gonna be sneaky.

872
01:29:55.627 --> 01:30:02.483
<v Council President Dunphy>We're not gonna sneak something in as a big package or say, oh, well, you know, you have to vote on this 100 other things, but this one detail you have to worry about.

873
01:30:02.853 --> 01:30:03.494
<v Council President Dunphy>I won't do that.

874
01:30:04.056 --> 01:30:09.997
<v Council President Dunphy>For the rest of my time in office, I will take— you know, part of my commitment in bringing this is the follow-through.

875
01:30:10.158 --> 01:30:12.052
<v Council President Dunphy>It's not enough to just bring a resolution to committee.

876
01:30:12.261 --> 01:30:15.585
<v Council President Dunphy>So I want to see the same success that you see.

877
01:30:16.581 --> 01:30:16.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

878
01:30:17.127 --> 01:30:23.822
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate your commitment and our administrative commitment on doing So thank you, Chair.

879
01:30:24.465 --> 01:30:26.086
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you.

880
01:30:26.198 --> 01:30:27.065
<v Candace Avalos>And Councilor Koyama Lane?

881
01:30:27.885 --> 01:30:29.024
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for your questioning, Councilor.

882
01:30:29.104 --> 01:30:29.618
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That helped me.

883
01:30:30.292 --> 01:30:35.255
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, I— it also made me look a little bit closer about the advisory body piece of this.

884
01:30:35.528 --> 01:30:41.163
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can someone speak to that, when that would start, um, and about how that would be staffed?

885
01:30:41.533 --> 01:30:42.448
<v Donny Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, thank you.

886
01:30:42.511 --> 01:30:52.539
<v Donny Oliveira>So, um, we have experience with this many times over, uh, and when we had the first Permit Improvement Task we met on a regular basis.

887
01:30:52.539 --> 01:30:59.520
<v Donny Oliveira>We had quarterly updates, and it was really a sounding board where we, you know, we did big surveys and we would do stage gates with them.

888
01:30:59.520 --> 01:31:01.420
<v Donny Oliveira>Like, here's what we're, you know, we're thinking about.

889
01:31:01.420 --> 01:31:02.079
<v Donny Oliveira>Does this look good?

890
01:31:02.079 --> 01:31:03.380
<v Donny Oliveira>Feedback from that.

891
01:31:03.380 --> 01:31:04.229
<v Donny Oliveira>And that was really effective.

892
01:31:04.279 --> 01:31:06.760
<v Donny Oliveira>And I just want to acknowledge the comment that was made.

893
01:31:06.800 --> 01:31:08.100
<v Donny Oliveira>It was a range of stakeholders.

894
01:31:08.220 --> 01:31:13.539
<v Donny Oliveira>It was big builders, home builders, small, you know, ADU builders, tenants, developers, and and the city staff.

895
01:31:13.677 --> 01:31:24.926
<v Donny Oliveira>So we had a range of stakeholders involved, and I would make a statement here to say that we're— I'm confident that we'll have a similar mix of engaged advisory body members.

896
01:31:25.439 --> 01:31:30.695
<v Donny Oliveira>But it's something that will be built in, and we'll daylight that as part of the 150-day plan when we return.

897
01:31:31.449 --> 01:31:36.145
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And this would be one of the official ABCs of the city, the appointed boards, commissions?

898
01:31:36.320 --> 01:31:36.945
<v Donny Oliveira>Great question.

899
01:31:37.057 --> 01:31:37.298
<v Donny Oliveira>I don't—.

900
01:31:37.298 --> 01:31:41.363
<v Donny Oliveira>That's something we'll have to talk to okay.

901
01:31:41.765 --> 01:31:50.189
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I know the 3 of us were on the Governance Committee and just talking about how many ABCs do we have and let's make sure we are intentional about those.

902
01:31:50.237 --> 01:31:57.056
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so I am happy to support this and maybe would love some more information about that at some point before it comes to full council.

903
01:31:57.186 --> 01:31:57.606
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

904
01:32:00.176 --> 01:32:00.435
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

905
01:32:00.500 --> 01:32:01.099
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, colleagues.

906
01:32:01.148 --> 01:32:06.965
<v Candace Avalos>Seeing no one else in the queue, I would entertain a motion to move Resolution Document Number 2027 to the full council.

907
01:32:09.101 --> 01:32:12.542
<v Candace Avalos>So moved.

908
01:32:13.186 --> 01:32:13.493
<v Mitch Green>Second.

909
01:32:14.413 --> 01:32:17.305
<v Candace Avalos>Moved by Councilor Novick, seconded by Vice Chair Green.

910
01:32:17.481 --> 01:32:18.435
<v Candace Avalos>Any further discussion?

911
01:32:20.581 --> 01:32:22.109
<v Candace Avalos>Seeing none, Diego, please call the roll.

912
01:32:23.850 --> 01:32:24.171
<v Diego>Pirtle-Guiney?

913
01:32:24.671 --> 01:32:24.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

914
01:32:25.734 --> 01:32:26.265
<v Diego>Koyama Lane?

915
01:32:26.765 --> 01:32:26.814
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

916
01:32:27.893 --> 01:32:28.311
<v Diego>Novick?

917
01:32:28.698 --> 01:32:28.747
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

918
01:32:30.163 --> 01:32:30.453
<v Diego>Green?

919
01:32:30.953 --> 01:32:31.114
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

920
01:32:32.338 --> 01:32:32.596
<v Diego>Avalos?

921
01:32:33.547 --> 01:32:33.579
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

922
01:32:34.096 --> 01:32:43.475
<v Diego>With 5 ayes, the motion carries, and the resolution document number 2026-203 will move to the full council with a recommendation it be adopted.

923
01:32:44.630 --> 01:32:45.604
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, colleagues.

924
01:32:45.734 --> 01:32:47.603
<v Candace Avalos>So we are gonna take a 12-minute break.

925
01:32:47.650 --> 01:32:48.951
<v Candace Avalos>It is currently 3:28.

926
01:32:49.032 --> 01:32:50.430
<v Candace Avalos>Please be back at 3:40 PM.

927
01:32:50.738 --> 01:32:50.932
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

928
01:45:04.180 --> 01:45:07.197
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, I am going to call this meeting back into order.

929
01:45:08.007 --> 01:45:10.226
<v Candace Avalos>And Diego, please read item 4.

930
01:45:13.039 --> 01:45:20.792
<v Diego>Item 4, establish 2026 sale price cap for the Homebuyer Opportunity Limited Tax Exemption Program.

931
01:45:21.582 --> 01:45:26.863
<v Candace Avalos>All right, colleagues, like I said at the beginning, we've got 2 ordinances coming for— from the Housing Bureau to us.

932
01:45:27.458 --> 01:45:38.863
<v Candace Avalos>This one, um, the Home Homebuyer Opportunity Limited Tax Exemption, or HOLTY, is a city program authorized by state law that helps income-qualified homebuyers purchase newly constructed homes through a property tax exemption.

933
01:45:39.551 --> 01:45:50.311
<v Candace Avalos>State law requires that the city establish an annual maximum sale price for homes eligible to participate in the program, and so today's resolution sets the sale price cap for the 2026 calendar year.

934
01:45:50.921 --> 01:46:01.140
<v Candace Avalos>And I will go ahead and hand it over to Interim Director Light and Josh Roper from the Housing Bureau to walk us through Good afternoon, Chair Avalos and committee members.

935
01:46:01.140 --> 01:46:02.039
<v Queesha Light>Thank you.

936
01:46:02.039 --> 01:46:06.779
<v Queesha Light>Chair Avalos has provided a great summary, so I will not take up any more time.

937
01:46:06.779 --> 01:46:08.619
<v Queesha Light>I know you've had a busy afternoon.

938
01:46:09.819 --> 01:46:20.260
<v Queesha Light>As she stated, though, the HOLTI is a tax exemption incentive for developers and homebuyers intended to make homeownership more accessible to Portlanders.

939
01:46:20.260 --> 01:46:25.439
<v Queesha Light>And I'm going to just also tee up the next one, which I think is also a critical piece here.

940
01:46:25.439 --> 01:46:36.515
<v Queesha Light>The next agenda item is the approval of the The second agenda item is going to be a presentation on our proposed ordinance that's adjusting the Affordable Housing System Development Charge Exemption Program that's administered by the Housing Bureau.

941
01:46:37.094 --> 01:46:40.108
<v Queesha Light>And I would just say that both of these are not major policy changes.

942
01:46:40.284 --> 01:46:50.099
<v Queesha Light>I see them as practical adjustments that help to ensure that our housing system remains usable, you know, it remains aligned and responsive.

943
01:46:50.659 --> 01:46:53.449
<v Queesha Light>So I'll turn it over to Josh Roper, who will walk through both items for us.

944
01:46:53.497 --> 01:46:53.947
<v Queesha Light>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

945
01:46:55.733 --> 01:46:56.570
<v Josh Roper>Thank you, Queesha.

946
01:46:57.344 --> 01:47:00.759
<v Josh Roper>Hi everyone, Josh Roper, Policy and Planning Director for the Portland Housing Bureau.

947
01:47:01.289 --> 01:47:01.935
<v Josh Roper>Thank you for having us.

948
01:47:02.699 --> 01:47:10.259
<v Josh Roper>I'm going to start, as Queesha said, with the HOLTY, Homebuyer Opportunity Limited Tax Exemption, resolution.

949
01:47:13.295 --> 01:47:16.557
<v Josh Roper>So we're going to start with a little background on what HOLTY is.

950
01:47:18.085 --> 01:47:27.987
<v Josh Roper>The HOLTY program aims to increase the production of affordable homes and make those homes affordable to low and moderate income households through tax savings for homebuyers.

951
01:47:29.170 --> 01:47:37.329
<v Josh Roper>Homes must be sold for less than the annually established sale price limit, and homebuyers must meet income eligibility criteria to qualify.

952
01:47:43.689 --> 01:47:52.567
<v Josh Roper>HOLTI provides a 10-year property tax tax exemption on newly constructed homes for buyers with immediate— with an income at 100% or below.

953
01:47:54.537 --> 01:48:05.399
<v Josh Roper>In Portland, by agreement with the county, we're limited to 500 exemption applications per year, except that nonprofits can use the program and are not subject to the annual 500-unit cap.

954
01:48:10.113 --> 01:48:22.984
<v Josh Roper>We're required by law to establish the sales price cap, and the statute, the state statute, allows the cap to be up to 120% of the median sales price.

955
01:48:24.096 --> 01:48:32.490
<v Josh Roper>In 2025, the sales price cap was $455,000, and spoiler alert, we are recommending keeping it right there.

956
01:48:33.523 --> 01:48:38.926
<v Josh Roper>The median home sales price in 2025 was $520,000.

957
01:48:39.394 --> 01:48:44.068
<v Josh Roper>That's the end of November of last year, and that's 14% above the current cap.

958
01:48:46.247 --> 01:48:57.190
<v Josh Roper>So you'll see we could in theory recommend a much higher sales price cap than we do recommend, and we'll explain why we're at a lower number.

959
01:48:59.136 --> 01:49:04.686
<v Josh Roper>But before that, I just want to flag the value of HOLTI to developers and homebuyers.

960
01:49:05.295 --> 01:49:08.956
<v Josh Roper>So on average, $3,500 tax savings per year.

961
01:49:11.729 --> 01:49:19.358
<v Josh Roper>And then a little bit about the purchase price analysis that the development incentives team engaged in and the recommendation from the Housing Bureau.

962
01:49:20.189 --> 01:49:33.103
<v Josh Roper>So homes sold through the HOLTI program sold last year for an average of $328,522, which is well below the maximum price program purchase price of $455,000.

963
01:49:34.516 --> 01:49:42.349
<v Josh Roper>For that reason, we are recommending maintaining the maximum sales price, that sales price cap at $455,000.

964
01:49:44.313 --> 01:49:55.960
<v Josh Roper>We had a meeting that included developers and owners in December of last year, and during that meeting, there was general agreement that this was an appropriate path forward.

965
01:49:58.279 --> 01:50:00.194
<v Josh Roper>And that is the presentation on Holti.

966
01:50:00.956 --> 01:50:02.627
<v Josh Roper>Happy to field any questions.

967
01:50:04.612 --> 01:50:05.130
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

968
01:50:05.502 --> 01:50:08.349
<v Candace Avalos>Um, we don't have anyone in the queue yet.

969
01:50:08.430 --> 01:50:10.095
<v Candace Avalos>Do we have any public testimony?

970
01:50:11.306 --> 01:50:12.712
<v Candace Avalos>How many, uh, do we have listed?

971
01:50:13.180 --> 01:50:14.680
<v Diego>We have one individual signed up.

972
01:50:15.537 --> 01:50:17.828
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, are you okay with taking testimony?

973
01:50:18.381 --> 01:50:18.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absolutely.

974
01:50:19.095 --> 01:50:24.256
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I had thought you were moving to questions, so I put myself in so I didn't miss the Okay, no worries.

975
01:50:24.868 --> 01:50:28.042
<v Candace Avalos>Let's go ahead and do testimony, and then we'll bring you all back up for some questions.

976
01:50:28.315 --> 01:50:28.734
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

977
01:50:29.524 --> 01:50:30.087
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead, Diego.

978
01:50:31.449 --> 01:50:32.094
<v Diego>Lacey Sutton.

979
01:50:39.443 --> 01:50:40.393
<v Diego>Once more for Lacey.

980
01:50:43.710 --> 01:50:45.546
<v Diego>Yeah, that concludes testimony.

981
01:50:45.802 --> 01:50:46.591
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, sorry.

982
01:50:46.850 --> 01:50:47.445
<v Candace Avalos>Come on back.

983
01:50:48.073 --> 01:50:48.685
<v Candace Avalos>Musical chairs.

984
01:50:49.265 --> 01:50:49.895
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

985
01:50:50.692 --> 01:50:52.043
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

986
01:50:56.550 --> 01:51:03.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So it looks like the housing being purchased is at a much lower level than the cap pretty consistently.

987
01:51:04.613 --> 01:51:07.206
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have 2 questions about that just to understand this.

988
01:51:07.351 --> 01:51:25.733
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are these generally, um, houses that are being purchased which are subsidized construction new builds, or is this market rate naturally affordable housing that is selling for that price?

989
01:51:25.992 --> 01:51:31.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What is the— what is the subsidy being used to help people purchase?

990
01:51:31.395 --> 01:51:36.842
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, generally these are market rate, more affordable housing opportunities.

991
01:51:36.890 --> 01:51:39.146
<v Josh Roper>So yeah, you're naturally occurring affordable.

992
01:51:39.613 --> 01:51:39.791
<v Lacey Sutton>Okay.

993
01:51:40.515 --> 01:51:44.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as we look at that significant gap between the average price and the cap.

994
01:51:46.484 --> 01:51:55.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is the goal to have the cap at a level that gives buyers flexibility but helps to limit us to the 500 people?

995
01:51:56.078 --> 01:51:59.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess I'm wondering— there's no proposal to lower it.

996
01:52:01.125 --> 01:52:13.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Lowering it would obviously give buyers less flexibility in what they purchase but might help give us a better sense of what the need is and ensure that folks with the most need are in that 500.

997
01:52:14.221 --> 01:52:15.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Can you explain why we haven't lowered it?

998
01:52:15.916 --> 01:52:17.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And also, do we push the limit of the 500?

999
01:52:17.996 --> 01:52:20.686
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we get far more applicants than that?

1000
01:52:20.815 --> 01:52:25.055
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're tapped out by halfway through the year, or is 500 a reasonable level there?

1001
01:52:26.882 --> 01:52:29.761
<v Josh Roper>I believe 500 is a reasonable level.

1002
01:52:29.956 --> 01:52:35.833
<v Josh Roper>500 that are outside of the, the the nonprofit category.

1003
01:52:36.734 --> 01:52:38.163
<v Josh Roper>That's my understanding.

1004
01:52:38.582 --> 01:53:00.787
<v Josh Roper>I will also say that the sale price cap and the conversation we have with developers and owners, there's sort of a back and forth between the increasing cost to build, to develop, the increasing cost of the entire process that folks are going through to get these online that puts pressure on the sale price cap to go up.

1005
01:53:01.171 --> 01:53:07.402
<v Josh Roper>But on the other hand, right, we have this historical data that suggests in reality we're looking at lower sales prices.

1006
01:53:07.498 --> 01:53:17.565
<v Josh Roper>So for a while we've been in this kind of static, you know, pressure from both sides, and we're going to kind of land in the same place we landed last year because it's been working pretty well.

1007
01:53:18.994 --> 01:53:19.717
<v Josh Roper>If that helps.

1008
01:53:20.182 --> 01:53:20.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That does.

1009
01:53:20.680 --> 01:53:26.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And when you talk about the exemption for nonprofits, And that is for nonprofit housing developers.

1010
01:53:26.685 --> 01:53:31.534
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The company developing the housing is a nonprofit, and there are other exemptions for those entities.

1011
01:53:31.615 --> 01:53:32.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1012
01:53:32.466 --> 01:53:32.884
<v Josh Roper>That's right.

1013
01:53:33.045 --> 01:53:41.474
<v Josh Roper>And the, the HOLTI is actually applied for by the developers, so it is sort of transferred to the homeowner when they become the owner.

1014
01:53:41.635 --> 01:53:55.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so when you say exempting nonprofits, those are nonprofit housing developers as opposed to the HOLTI, which is designed for your for- For-profit businesses that are developing housing at various levels of affordability.

1015
01:53:55.761 --> 01:53:56.421
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1016
01:53:56.470 --> 01:54:02.243
<v Josh Roper>They can both take advantage of HULTI, but in both cases it's the developers who actually apply for the HULTI.

1017
01:54:02.823 --> 01:54:09.697
<v Josh Roper>And then when you buy the house, if you're the home buyer, then you become eligible for the remainder of the HULTI.

1018
01:54:10.083 --> 01:54:15.149
<v Queesha Light>There's 500 for one group and 500— the 500 cap for one group and a 500 cap for the other.

1019
01:54:15.539 --> 01:54:20.409
<v Queesha Light>So nonprofits have their own $500,000 cap and individuals, developers have their own.

1020
01:54:21.006 --> 01:54:23.474
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this level would apply to both?

1021
01:54:24.930 --> 01:54:25.755
<v Josh Roper>The sale price cap?

1022
01:54:25.804 --> 01:54:26.225
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sale price cap.

1023
01:54:26.305 --> 01:54:26.823
<v Josh Roper>That's right, yeah.

1024
01:54:26.904 --> 01:54:28.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you very much.

1025
01:54:28.360 --> 01:54:28.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks, Chair.

1026
01:54:30.238 --> 01:54:31.162
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good, thank you.

1027
01:54:33.743 --> 01:54:35.997
<v Candace Avalos>Colleagues, any further discussion or questions?

1028
01:54:40.003 --> 01:54:40.494
<v Candace Avalos>Vice Chair Green?

1029
01:54:41.400 --> 01:54:41.680
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1030
01:54:41.729 --> 01:54:45.328
<v Mitch Green>Do you have any insights— thank you so much, Josh.

1031
01:54:45.394 --> 01:54:54.153
<v Mitch Green>Do you have any insights on why the average sort of seems to— average sales price sort of seems to peak in 2021 and then kind of decline in level?

1032
01:54:54.201 --> 01:54:57.523
<v Mitch Green>Like, what are the underlying factors that are contributing to that?

1033
01:55:00.697 --> 01:55:06.018
<v Josh Roper>I think it might have something to do with the middle housing efforts.

1034
01:55:07.457 --> 01:55:18.435
<v Josh Roper>From the city because we are seeing more of those fourplexes, sixplexes, those sorts of typologies taking advantage of the HULTI.

1035
01:55:18.498 --> 01:55:24.448
<v Josh Roper>So I would think that is probably what you're seeing in play there, that kind of taking off.

1036
01:55:24.771 --> 01:55:26.925
<v Mitch Green>And so the residential infill program for homes?

1037
01:55:27.038 --> 01:55:27.329
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, exactly.

1038
01:55:27.524 --> 01:55:31.167
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's, that's very encouraging actually.

1039
01:55:31.393 --> 01:55:32.364
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, that's great.

1040
01:55:33.755 --> 01:55:36.644
<v Mitch Green>I see no reason why I would not vote for the—.

1041
01:55:36.884 --> 01:55:37.012
<v Mitch Green>Very—.

1042
01:55:37.140 --> 01:55:39.163
<v Mitch Green>Seems very sensible to not raise this at this time.

1043
01:55:39.435 --> 01:55:41.088
<v Mitch Green>Uh, pretty, pretty case closed.

1044
01:55:41.137 --> 01:55:42.550
<v Mitch Green>So thanks for the presentation.

1045
01:55:43.287 --> 01:55:54.345
<v Mitch Green>Um, I, I think that data point though that we've just teased out is a really, really important piece for the broader— the Bureau's broader efforts, and frankly this previous discussion that we were talking about, the code alignment project.

1046
01:55:54.395 --> 01:55:55.759
<v Mitch Green>So I'll be watching that.

1047
01:55:55.823 --> 01:55:59.942
<v Mitch Green>I think that's, um, those are green shoots for the City of Portland and Um, uh, thank you.

1048
01:56:00.006 --> 01:56:02.804
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, colleagues.

1049
01:56:02.981 --> 01:56:05.002
<v Candace Avalos>Um, our testifier, uh, is back.

1050
01:56:05.261 --> 01:56:06.944
<v Candace Avalos>Are we all right with letting them up real quick?

1051
01:56:07.552 --> 01:56:08.771
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, come on up, Lacey.

1052
01:56:10.332 --> 01:56:11.274
<v Candace Avalos>You all can just stay put.

1053
01:56:11.453 --> 01:56:11.746
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We're good.

1054
01:56:13.012 --> 01:56:13.646
<v Lacey Sutton>So sorry.

1055
01:56:14.836 --> 01:56:16.190
<v Lacey Sutton>Um, yeah, it's me again.

1056
01:56:16.287 --> 01:56:16.837
<v Lacey Sutton>This is the last one.

1057
01:56:17.497 --> 01:56:18.530
<v Lacey Sutton>I'm Lacey Sutton.

1058
01:56:19.353 --> 01:56:27.390
<v Lacey Sutton>Uh, I just wanted to make sure that you're all aware that the 10-year tax exemption period begins when the home builder receives it, not the home buyer.

1059
01:56:27.453 --> 01:56:28.993
<v Lacey Sutton>We are on that agenda item, correct?

1060
01:56:30.097 --> 01:56:30.210
<v Lacey Sutton>Okay.

1061
01:56:31.140 --> 01:56:35.016
<v Lacey Sutton>In our case at Cherry Blossom, Habitat for Humanity got it in 2021.

1062
01:56:35.481 --> 01:56:43.525
<v Lacey Sutton>So when we bought our new house in 2023, we paid $900 to apply for what Proud Ground repeatedly referred to as a 10-year tax exemption.

1063
01:56:43.957 --> 01:56:46.329
<v Lacey Sutton>No one explained that that period had already begun.

1064
01:56:46.858 --> 01:56:55.965
<v Lacey Sutton>So for us, it will only be an 8-year tax exemption, and there are people who moved in long after And all the neighbors I've spoken with had no idea.

1065
01:56:56.141 --> 01:56:58.309
<v Lacey Sutton>They thought it would be 10 years as well.

1066
01:56:58.952 --> 01:57:09.034
<v Lacey Sutton>Considering that when this exemption period ends, homeowners will suddenly have to pay hundreds of dollars more per month, I think it's pretty important that they know when to expect that to happen.

1067
01:57:09.708 --> 01:57:28.252
<v Lacey Sutton>I know from speaking with affordable housing people that this looming drop-off is a big concern, and while I don't have any hard data, I think it's quite possible that families have lost their homes or will lose their homes because of this, because their mortgages will instantly increase by like $300, $400.

1068
01:57:30.011 --> 01:57:37.864
<v Lacey Sutton>And this will be on top of regular increases to their HOA dues, because almost all, if not all, new affordable homes have HOAs now.

1069
01:57:38.636 --> 01:57:42.065
<v Lacey Sutton>It's the only way developers can put dozens of homes on a single lot.

1070
01:57:42.903 --> 01:57:45.849
<v Lacey Sutton>HOA dues are hundreds of dollars a month in addition to the mortgage.

1071
01:57:46.372 --> 01:57:50.354
<v Lacey Sutton>We've already had 2 homes go into foreclosure at Cherry Blossom for unpaid dues.

1072
01:57:50.965 --> 01:57:53.470
<v Lacey Sutton>It's a serious problem that is only going to get worse.

1073
01:57:54.064 --> 01:57:57.659
<v Lacey Sutton>A special assessment alone could easily bankrupt families.

1074
01:57:58.399 --> 01:58:01.225
<v Lacey Sutton>Low-income HOAs are a horrible idea.

1075
01:58:02.188 --> 01:58:06.490
<v Lacey Sutton>But back to, to this, um, is it the Holti?

1076
01:58:07.807 --> 01:58:09.157
<v Lacey Sutton>If I was here, I would have heard.

1077
01:58:09.557 --> 01:58:24.204
<v Lacey Sutton>Um, I just, I feel like It might need a new acronym because the 10-year Homebuyer Opportunity Limited Tax Exemption just isn't accurate, or they need to not give years of this exemption period to the homebuilder.

1078
01:58:24.751 --> 01:58:31.046
<v Lacey Sutton>At the very least, PHB needs to be extremely transparent about the fact that it's not going to be 10 years for the homebuyer.

1079
01:58:31.416 --> 01:58:35.576
<v Lacey Sutton>This is especially true for homebuyers who don't speak English as a first language.

1080
01:58:36.057 --> 01:58:40.619
<v Lacey Sutton>From discussions I've had, this information is just not being accurately conveyed to them.

1081
01:58:41.476 --> 01:58:54.261
<v Lacey Sutton>I think most people would still happily take a 7-year discount on their property taxes, but they need to be made aware that it's up in 7 years, not 10, so they can be as financially prepared as possible for that day.

1082
01:58:55.670 --> 01:58:56.880
<v Council President Dunphy>Thank you.

1083
01:58:57.462 --> 01:58:58.042
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Lacey.

1084
01:58:59.172 --> 01:59:00.431
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1085
01:59:01.658 --> 01:59:02.320
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair.

1086
01:59:02.903 --> 01:59:17.756
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm wondering if one of you could Sure.

1087
01:59:19.145 --> 01:59:28.993
<v Josh Roper>So we are setting a price cap for what you can, as a developer, sell a house for to a potential buyer.

1088
01:59:29.787 --> 01:59:29.936
<v Josh Roper>Okay.

1089
01:59:30.292 --> 01:59:39.636
<v Josh Roper>Homebuyer, that's the maximum you can charge for that house and still qualify for this HOLTI tax exemption.

1090
01:59:40.182 --> 01:59:54.296
<v Josh Roper>So if I'm a developer, I want to develop some townhouses, I can only sell those townhouses if I want the HOLTI for up to $455,000 each.

1091
01:59:55.100 --> 02:00:01.470
<v Josh Roper>And there are also income well done.

1092
02:00:02.051 --> 02:00:02.666
<v Josh Roper>Good, thank you.

1093
02:00:05.342 --> 02:00:06.442
<v Candace Avalos>Is that all, Councilor?

1094
02:00:06.618 --> 02:00:06.862
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1095
02:00:08.542 --> 02:00:10.514
<v Candace Avalos>Um, anyone else in the queue?

1096
02:00:11.225 --> 02:00:12.662
<v Candace Avalos>Any other further comments?

1097
02:00:14.109 --> 02:00:18.630
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, well then, with that, let me get the language up here.

1098
02:00:22.725 --> 02:00:28.284
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so I would like to entertain a motion to move— hold on, I don't think this is the right language.

1099
02:00:33.617 --> 02:00:34.546
<v Candace Avalos>Apologies, one second.

1100
02:00:43.734 --> 02:00:53.037
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I think the reason I'm confused is Because it says— am I— it's moving ordinance document number 2026-204.

1101
02:00:53.293 --> 02:00:54.432
<v Candace Avalos>Is that how you have it?

1102
02:00:55.203 --> 02:00:55.893
<v Diego>Resolution.

1103
02:00:56.502 --> 02:00:57.979
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's why I'm confused.

1104
02:00:58.027 --> 02:01:00.385
<v Candace Avalos>I keep seeing resolution and ordinance all over my document.

1105
02:01:00.432 --> 02:01:01.668
<v Candace Avalos>So this is a resolution.

1106
02:01:02.341 --> 02:01:11.439
<v Candace Avalos>So then I will say I'd like to entertain a motion to move the resolution document number 2026-204 to the full council with a recommendation to pass.

1107
02:01:15.932 --> 02:01:16.373
<v Mitch Green>Second.

1108
02:01:16.422 --> 02:01:19.639
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, moved by Vice Chair Green and seconded by Councilor Novick.

1109
02:01:22.131 --> 02:01:23.088
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, let's go ahead and call the roll.

1110
02:01:25.811 --> 02:01:26.984
<v Diego>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney?

1111
02:01:27.113 --> 02:01:27.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1112
02:01:27.257 --> 02:01:28.109
<v Diego>Councilor Koyama Lane?

1113
02:01:29.331 --> 02:01:29.378
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1114
02:01:29.989 --> 02:01:30.712
<v Diego>Councilor Novick?

1115
02:01:31.097 --> 02:01:31.146
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1116
02:01:31.581 --> 02:01:32.287
<v Diego>Councilor Green?

1117
02:01:32.865 --> 02:01:32.881
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1118
02:01:33.042 --> 02:01:34.055
<v Diego>Councilor Avalos?

1119
02:01:34.634 --> 02:01:34.681
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1120
02:01:35.375 --> 02:01:45.282
<v Diego>With 5 ayes, the motion carries, and the resolution document number 2026- We'll move to the full council with a recommendation it be adopted.

1121
02:01:46.131 --> 02:01:46.917
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you.

1122
02:01:47.640 --> 02:01:51.377
<v Candace Avalos>Well, uh, you all are still on the hook because we've got another one coming.

1123
02:01:51.490 --> 02:02:05.416
<v Candace Avalos>So our second ordinance from the Housing Bureau proposes to temporarily remove the income requirement for homebuyers using the Affordable Housing SDC exemption program, expanding the pool of homebuyers able to access programs.

1124
02:02:05.930 --> 02:02:16.515
<v Candace Avalos>It will also allow home builders receiving exemptions under the SDC exemption program which the council passed last July to sell units without needing to find an income-qualified home buyer.

1125
02:02:16.581 --> 02:02:18.818
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll hand it back to you all for more information.

1126
02:02:19.930 --> 02:02:20.105
<v Josh Roper>Thank you.

1127
02:02:20.668 --> 02:02:25.345
<v Josh Roper>Um, let's see, there we go.

1128
02:02:26.405 --> 02:02:30.569
<v Diego>Sorry to interrupt, if I may, Chair, uh, open the item.

1129
02:02:31.275 --> 02:02:31.565
<v Candace Avalos>My bad.

1130
02:02:31.613 --> 02:02:32.498
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, please open the item.

1131
02:02:32.804 --> 02:02:33.238
<v Diego>No problem.

1132
02:02:33.769 --> 02:02:51.265
<v Diego>Um, Item 5, amend partial and full exemptions of system development charges for Affordable Housing Development Code to temporarily remove income requirements for homeownership units, amend Code Section 30.095.

1133
02:02:51.730 --> 02:02:52.519
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1134
02:02:53.515 --> 02:02:54.143
<v Candace Avalos>All right, take it away.

1135
02:02:54.770 --> 02:02:55.189
<v Josh Roper>Thanks.

1136
02:02:55.657 --> 02:03:05.340
<v Josh Roper>So the second item we're presenting is an ordinance that adjusts the Housing Bureau's affordable housing system development charge or SDC program for homeownership.

1137
02:03:06.207 --> 02:03:10.398
<v Josh Roper>I'm going to start by briefly explaining why we're proposing this adjustment.

1138
02:03:11.666 --> 02:03:28.412
<v Josh Roper>When the temporary SDC exemption program passed last year in 2025, we anticipated that there may be interactions between that new temporary program and PHB's existing affordable housing SDC exemption program that would warrant further consideration.

1139
02:03:30.387 --> 02:03:32.652
<v Josh Roper>And we heard about one concern in particular.

1140
02:03:32.716 --> 02:03:34.578
<v Josh Roper>We have heard about one concern in particular.

1141
02:03:35.204 --> 02:03:53.317
<v Josh Roper>Developers who took advantage of the Housing Bureau's Affordable Housing SDC exemption program are required to sell to income-qualifying homeowners, while developers who take advantage of the temporary 2025 SDC waiver are not required to sell to income-qualifying homeowners.

1142
02:03:53.412 --> 02:03:53.798
<v Josh Roper>I have a question.

1143
02:03:54.393 --> 02:04:00.413
<v Josh Roper>Developers and owners have expressed that this creates a competitive disadvantage that they would like to see addressed.

1144
02:04:01.296 --> 02:04:19.457
<v Josh Roper>Given these considerations, along with the time-limited nature of the broad 2025 SDC waiver and the overlap of these 2 programs, we believe it is appropriate to remove temporarily the income requirement from the Housing Bureau's Affordable Housing SDC exemption program.

1145
02:04:21.689 --> 02:04:25.751
<v Josh Roper>This one is even harder to explain to a 5th grader, so I apologize.

1146
02:04:27.068 --> 02:04:42.337
<v Josh Roper>On the next few slides, I'm going to describe the PHB Affordable SDC Program, the temporary SDC waiver— that's the 2025 change— and then the proposed ordinance that's in front of you in more detail.

1147
02:04:42.434 --> 02:04:44.055
<v Josh Roper>Thank you.

1148
02:04:46.671 --> 02:04:50.795
<v Josh Roper>So the Affordable Housing SDC Exemption Program, this is the one run by PHB.

1149
02:04:51.163 --> 02:05:00.261
<v Josh Roper>So we administer this program and it provides an incentive for the development of affordable homeownership and affordable rental housing.

1150
02:05:01.015 --> 02:05:06.903
<v Josh Roper>But we're going to be focusing on the homeownership side of this program, not the rental side of this program.

1151
02:05:07.110 --> 02:05:14.060
<v Josh Roper>This program is separate from the temporary SDC exemption for new housing units that began in August of 2025.

1152
02:05:15.360 --> 02:05:22.362
<v Josh Roper>For the homeownership program, homes must be owner occupied, and this ordinance would not change that requirement.

1153
02:05:22.844 --> 02:05:29.618
<v Josh Roper>It would continue to require owner occupancy for units taking advantage of this PHB-run program.

1154
02:05:30.774 --> 02:05:40.039
<v Josh Roper>And currently, homebuyers must income qualify by earning no more than 100% of area median income, family income for a household of 4.

1155
02:05:41.087 --> 02:05:43.909
<v Josh Roper>And that's the piece that would be removed temporarily.

1156
02:05:46.538 --> 02:05:48.694
<v Josh Roper>The temporary SDC exemption program.

1157
02:05:48.760 --> 02:05:50.293
<v Josh Roper>So this is that 2025 change.

1158
02:05:51.600 --> 02:06:19.110
<v Josh Roper>Council passed Ordinance 192082 that temporarily exempted for new housing, pretty much all new housing in Portland, exempted those units from system development charges if the permit issue date was between August 15th, 2025— or excuse me, sorry.

1159
02:06:23.337 --> 02:06:24.805
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, council passed this ordinance.

1160
02:06:24.871 --> 02:06:34.131
<v Josh Roper>It temporarily exempted system development charges for new housing in Portland with permit issue dates between August 2025 and September 30th, 2028.

1161
02:06:34.326 --> 02:06:41.800
<v Josh Roper>So that period of time, generally speaking, no STC charges for new housing units.

1162
02:06:42.911 --> 02:06:51.105
<v Josh Roper>The temporary STC exemption program applies to nearly all newly built residential housing units and is not limited to regulated affordable housing units.

1163
02:06:52.046 --> 02:06:57.759
<v Josh Roper>Homebuyers purchasing units that received the temporary STC exemption temporary SDC exemption do not need to income qualify.

1164
02:06:58.000 --> 02:07:03.747
<v Josh Roper>So this is where that competitive disadvantage that we're hearing about from developers and owners is coming from.

1165
02:07:06.369 --> 02:07:19.828
<v Josh Roper>So the code amendment proposal that's in front of you, this ordinance would temporarily remove the income requirement for homebuyers purchasing qualifying homes benefiting from the affordable housing SDC exemption program that PHB runs.

1166
02:07:20.202 --> 02:07:20.636
<v Josh Roper>Program.

1167
02:07:21.712 --> 02:07:41.798
<v Josh Roper>Removal of the homebuyer income requirement would only apply to affordable housing SDC homeownership units with building permits issued before January 1st of this year, January 1st, 2026, and the adjustment would extend to September 30th, 2028 to align with the end of the temporary SDC waiver.

1168
02:07:42.216 --> 02:07:49.500
<v Josh Roper>So the idea here is we're trying to address the developers and that got kind of stuck in this limbo with these overlapping programs.

1169
02:07:50.260 --> 02:08:04.550
<v Josh Roper>This wouldn't impact or change the temporary SDC exemption program, and there are some technical fixes and a clarification around penalties for noncompliance with the program in the ordinance as well.

1170
02:08:07.710 --> 02:08:08.841
<v Josh Roper>And that is the presentation.

1171
02:08:09.350 --> 02:08:09.990
<v Josh Roper>Happy to discuss.

1172
02:08:10.090 --> 02:08:10.204
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1173
02:08:11.564 --> 02:08:11.966
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1174
02:08:12.289 --> 02:08:14.484
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, I believe we have one person to testify.

1175
02:08:14.547 --> 02:08:18.564
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, let's go ahead and call them up, and then we'll get to councilor questions.

1176
02:08:19.970 --> 02:08:21.162
<v Diego>Justin Wood.

1177
02:08:30.926 --> 02:08:31.170
<v Candace Avalos>Welcome.

1178
02:08:31.252 --> 02:08:31.479
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead.

1179
02:08:31.673 --> 02:08:31.917
<v Justin Wood>Welcome.

1180
02:08:32.323 --> 02:08:37.648
<v Justin Wood>Good afternoon, councilors, and thank you for the opportunity to provide some testimony in support of this proposed amendment to the STC waiver program.

1181
02:08:37.797 --> 02:08:39.546
<v Justin Wood>My name is Justin Wood.

1182
02:08:39.610 --> 02:08:41.070
<v Justin Wood>I'm with Fish Construction Northwest.

1183
02:08:41.135 --> 02:08:47.328
<v Justin Wood>I've been building homes in Portland for more than 25 years with a focus on middle housing, infill development, and affordable homeownership.

1184
02:08:47.408 --> 02:08:49.573
<v Justin Wood>That's pretty much all we've ever built.

1185
02:08:50.279 --> 02:08:55.029
<v Justin Wood>I also just briefly want to tell you that I'm fully glad that you guys supported the CAP 2 project.

1186
02:08:55.831 --> 02:09:01.912
<v Justin Wood>Several years ago, I was the chair of the Development Review Advisory Committee, and we had several meetings with Commissioner Nick Fish.

1187
02:09:02.472 --> 02:09:03.500
<v Justin Wood>And when he was the Thank you.

1188
02:09:03.547 --> 02:09:08.934
<v Justin Wood>I was the director of that department, of BDS, and I'm glad to see that we're continuing these efforts.

1189
02:09:10.167 --> 02:09:18.118
<v Justin Wood>Over the majority— over the course of my career, the majority of homes I've built have utilized the city's SDC exemption and the HOLTI program, which you just were just talking about.

1190
02:09:18.662 --> 02:09:26.069
<v Justin Wood>These programs have been critical tools in helping us provide homes to families at or below the median family income and helping them achieve homeownership.

1191
02:09:26.677 --> 02:09:30.845
<v Justin Wood>Without these, many of these homes simply would not have been affordable to the families that have been able to purchase them.

1192
02:09:31.262 --> 02:09:31.904
<v Justin Wood>Thank you.

1193
02:09:32.466 --> 02:09:39.204
<v Justin Wood>The Portland SDC and the HOLTI programs are excellent examples of how local governments can create meaningful pathways to affordable homeownership.

1194
02:09:39.911 --> 02:09:51.238
<v Justin Wood>I recently sat on Governor Kotek's Housing Production Advisory Council, and I frequently pointed to Portland as a way, an example of how cities can do good things to help, and that you guys have model programs for how to do that.

1195
02:09:52.667 --> 02:09:58.989
<v Justin Wood>Last fall, when the council took an important step to encouraging housing production by temporarily suspending the SDC fees on residential new construction, Thank you.

1196
02:09:58.989 --> 02:09:59.090
<v Josh Roper>Councilmember Herbold, you have the floor.

1197
02:09:59.090 --> 02:09:59.090
<v Josh Roper>Thank you, Mayor.

1198
02:09:59.090 --> 02:09:59.989
<v Justin Wood>Councilmember Herbold, I appreciate the question.

1199
02:09:59.989 --> 02:10:06.819
<v Justin Wood>Me and most everybody in the housing— in the homebuilding community supported that decision as a way to increase housing production.

1200
02:10:07.350 --> 02:10:14.970
<v Justin Wood>However, that policy change also created an unintended consequence with us for the small number of us builders who do use the affordable housing SDC program.

1201
02:10:15.550 --> 02:10:24.609
<v Justin Wood>Beginning in late 2025, we started to see ourselves competing against new construction homes that also benefited from the new waiver— waived SDCs that the council passed.

1202
02:10:24.640 --> 02:10:28.057
<v Justin Wood>Passed last fall but didn't require the buyers to meet the income qualifications.

1203
02:10:28.811 --> 02:10:34.911
<v Justin Wood>Meanwhile, our homes were still subject to those restrictions, significantly reducing our pool of eligible buyers.

1204
02:10:35.987 --> 02:10:47.253
<v Justin Wood>We have lost sales to families who preferred our home but couldn't because they might have been slightly over the income cap, and so they chose to purchase a house down the street from somebody else who didn't have the same income cap.

1205
02:10:48.007 --> 02:10:50.416
<v Justin Wood>Um, you can ask yourself if you have a home here yes.

1206
02:10:50.463 --> 02:11:05.271
<v Justin Wood>So if you have Home A and Home B and they're priced at roughly the same price and Home A says, I need you to submit documentation, I need you to give me your income, and I need to give you all this stuff so I can sell you my house at this price, and Home B doesn't have to do any of that stuff, why would anybody submit all the applications to do Home B?

1207
02:11:06.219 --> 02:11:08.207
<v Justin Wood>I want to be clear, this isn't a new subsidy.

1208
02:11:08.881 --> 02:11:12.073
<v Justin Wood>This is just, you know, these are SDCs that have already been waived.

1209
02:11:12.539 --> 02:11:17.082
<v Justin Wood>We're just simply asking the council to fix an unintended consequence of a policy change Thank you.

1210
02:11:19.091 --> 02:11:26.609
<v Justin Wood>This just creates a level playing field and allows us to sell homes, to continue to sell homes and affordable homes to the market.

1211
02:11:28.029 --> 02:11:31.951
<v Justin Wood>You know, we've been a longtime partner of the city, I think, in trying to do the right thing and build affordable housing.

1212
02:11:32.000 --> 02:11:34.807
<v Justin Wood>That's something we've always felt proud of and feel important of.

1213
02:11:35.228 --> 02:11:39.918
<v Justin Wood>And I just ask that the council try to do the right thing and kind of keep being good partners with us.

1214
02:11:40.466 --> 02:11:43.364
<v Justin Wood>And I appreciate PHB for taking the work on this and addressing this issue.

1215
02:11:44.114 --> 02:11:46.871
<v Justin Wood>And happy to answer any questions you might have, but thank you.

1216
02:11:48.386 --> 02:11:49.212
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for your testimony.

1217
02:11:51.962 --> 02:11:52.895
<v Diego>That concludes testimony.

1218
02:11:53.975 --> 02:11:58.288
<v Candace Avalos>All right, let's go ahead and get in the queue, starting with Councilor Koyama Lane.

1219
02:11:59.207 --> 02:11:59.867
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair.

1220
02:12:00.511 --> 02:12:12.720
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I understand that this item would— should make it easier for developers to sell— was it about 700 homes that would be eligible.

1221
02:12:13.752 --> 02:12:21.862
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can I hear an explanation of how this change would benefit or be challenging to potential homebuyers?

1222
02:12:22.364 --> 02:12:33.198
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How do we expect this change to impact families, specifically families that maybe would qualify under the current income limit, and this would be a pathway for them to get a home in Portland?

1223
02:12:34.412 --> 02:12:38.945
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, I think this is where the balancing happens.

1224
02:12:39.125 --> 02:12:40.533
<v Josh Roper>You know, I wouldn't Councilmember Herbold.

1225
02:12:40.614 --> 02:12:57.521
<v Josh Roper>I wouldn't necessarily be comfortable with this as a long-term strategy, but I think given the overlapping programs and this— what we've been describing as this limbo that some folks are finding themselves in and this competitive disadvantage, I am comfortable with this approach.

1226
02:12:57.635 --> 02:13:11.764
<v Josh Roper>But I do think the point that you're raising around folks who are eligible at under 100% AMI, there is something there.

1227
02:13:12.166 --> 02:13:15.025
<v Josh Roper>They lose out on a competitive disadvantage to a degree as well.

1228
02:13:15.073 --> 02:13:17.356
<v Josh Roper>So I think it's a question about throughput.

1229
02:13:17.711 --> 02:13:27.137
<v Josh Roper>It's a question about resolving the conflict between— or not even conflict, but what I'll keep calling overlap between these programs.

1230
02:13:28.948 --> 02:13:33.360
<v Josh Roper>And this is where we landed as as kind of the balance.

1231
02:13:33.922 --> 02:13:35.496
<v Josh Roper>But I hear your concern.

1232
02:13:36.411 --> 02:13:44.970
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can you tell me a little bit if this is a balance, what kind of were the other Goldilocks options or kind of that process for what was chosen?

1233
02:13:45.466 --> 02:13:49.658
<v Josh Roper>It was pretty much status quo, how the program is designed versus this approach.

1234
02:13:49.753 --> 02:13:51.744
<v Josh Roper>I mean, you could have gone farther.

1235
02:13:51.890 --> 02:14:00.073
<v Josh Roper>We could have gone farther and taken away other aspects of the Affordable housing SDC program temporarily as well.

1236
02:14:00.139 --> 02:14:09.784
<v Josh Roper>But what we wanted to do was create parity as much as possible between the temporary SDC program and the PHB-run affordable housing SDC program.

1237
02:14:10.252 --> 02:14:12.395
<v Josh Roper>So we only focused on the income requirement.

1238
02:14:13.250 --> 02:14:15.862
<v Josh Roper>So that's— that was already sort of a middle ground.

1239
02:14:17.917 --> 02:14:19.225
<v Josh Roper>So that was the idea behind it.

1240
02:14:19.274 --> 02:14:30.333
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That was our idea for balancing these And say this were to pass, is there a plan of how to measure the impacts of this change?

1241
02:14:30.671 --> 02:14:32.648
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What data would be planned to collect?

1242
02:14:33.097 --> 02:14:41.627
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Would it be even possible to incorporate the impacts of the changes into larger reporting on the temporary SDC exemption program?

1243
02:14:42.479 --> 02:15:12.134
<v Josh Roper>Would love to better understand just the impact of some of these development incentives and our Yeah, at a minimum, I want to and expect to see informal reporting and analysis around what we will— how the pace of sales changes, because we do have information about home sales when they occur.

1244
02:15:12.230 --> 02:15:12.862
<v Josh Roper>So I think we'll see that.

1245
02:15:12.926 --> 02:15:14.123
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, I think that's a good idea.

1246
02:15:14.305 --> 02:15:24.034
<v Josh Roper>The hope is that it would pick up and that would be the effect that we're looking for to know if this is effective or not.

1247
02:15:24.435 --> 02:15:31.259
<v Josh Roper>Whether or not it could be incorporated into the broader, like the PP&D report that they're doing on the SDC waiver, we could discuss that.

1248
02:15:31.966 --> 02:15:39.158
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But at this point, it sounds like there's not anything formal in terms of if this passes, how are we going to measure the impacts?

1249
02:15:39.286 --> 02:15:51.671
<v Josh Roper>There's not specific data We have some standing data that we already have access to, so we could do kind of a retrospective analysis, which is what I, at a minimum, have been planning.

1250
02:15:53.713 --> 02:15:53.810
<v Josh Roper>But—.

1251
02:15:53.810 --> 02:15:54.716
<v Josh Roper>Or not even retrospective.

1252
02:15:54.765 --> 02:15:55.864
<v Josh Roper>I mean, it could be in real time.

1253
02:15:55.962 --> 02:15:59.536
<v Josh Roper>But no, we don't have a formal evaluation set up.

1254
02:15:59.844 --> 02:16:00.020
<v Sarah Radcliffe>Okay.

1255
02:16:00.086 --> 02:16:00.409
<v Byron Balog>Thank you.

1256
02:16:02.689 --> 02:16:03.438
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, colleagues.

1257
02:16:03.487 --> 02:16:04.560
<v Candace Avalos>I put myself in the queue.

1258
02:16:04.951 --> 02:16:14.948
<v Candace Avalos>I wanted to know first if you all could just talk a little bit about the engagement process that led to this proposal and how feedback from builders and homeowners helped to shape the solution before us today?

1259
02:16:16.609 --> 02:16:29.453
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, it was, um, really outreach without prompting that came from developers and owners who were concerned about what they were facing in the market that prompted this conversation.

1260
02:16:30.211 --> 02:16:45.250
<v Josh Roper>I think it was apparent, like I said, that there would be some There would likely be some issue with the, again, overlap between the Affordable Housing SDC program and the temporary waiver.

1261
02:16:46.022 --> 02:16:57.869
<v Josh Roper>This seemed like a possibility, but we weren't sure what aspects would be creating the competitive disadvantage for, if there were one, for developers and owners.

1262
02:16:58.453 --> 02:17:08.301
<v Josh Roper>So it was really Thank you.

1263
02:17:10.215 --> 02:17:19.168
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate you all bringing this forward and working to address an unintended consequence that emerged after we adopted the temporary SDC exemption.

1264
02:17:20.262 --> 02:17:26.418
<v Candace Avalos>My office spent some time meeting with local homebuilders and developers who raised concerns about the interaction between these 2 programs.

1265
02:17:26.786 --> 02:17:28.665
<v Candace Avalos>And how it was creating an uneven playing field.

1266
02:17:28.712 --> 02:17:37.207
<v Candace Avalos>So we appreciated the opportunity to better understand the challenges that they were experiencing and the practical impacts this was having on projects that were already in the pipeline.

1267
02:17:37.302 --> 02:17:40.899
<v Candace Avalos>Of course, we don't want to hinder projects that already are moving.

1268
02:17:41.575 --> 02:17:48.365
<v Candace Avalos>And I also just want to thank the developers who took time to engage with council and staff and explain the issue and advocate for a solution.

1269
02:17:48.575 --> 02:18:03.250
<v Candace Avalos>I think their feedback really helped identify a problem that might not have been apparent and I think this is a good example of, you know, government listening, identifying an unintended outcome, and then making a targeted adjustment to ensure that our policies are working as intended.

1270
02:18:03.329 --> 02:18:14.922
<v Candace Avalos>Because ultimately, you know, these builders move forward under one set of rules and should not be placed at a competitive disadvantage just because they received the permits before the SEC exemption was created.

1271
02:18:14.970 --> 02:18:25.896
<v Candace Avalos>So I just wanted to name that on the record and say that I'm pleased I'm pleased to see staff bring forward this practical solution that improves the consistency between these programs while also maintaining our broader housing goals.

1272
02:18:26.477 --> 02:18:34.239
<v Candace Avalos>And I think as we continue working to increase housing production and more pathways to homeownership, it's important that our programs are fair and predictable and responsive.

1273
02:18:34.288 --> 02:18:38.157
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm grateful to your work bringing this forward and a targeted solution.

1274
02:18:38.682 --> 02:18:39.207
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for that.

1275
02:18:41.110 --> 02:18:42.420
<v Candace Avalos>Moving on, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1276
02:18:42.698 --> 02:18:43.206
<v Diego>Thank you, Chair.

1277
02:18:44.110 --> 02:18:44.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1278
02:18:47.430 --> 02:18:49.888
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When a—.

1279
02:18:50.257 --> 02:19:11.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I won't say a specific new unit, but as developers are looking at how to build right now, what I think I remember hearing when we passed the SDC waiver, because we did contemplate that there could be impact on this program, I believe what we heard was that the assumption was that developers generally, I think that assumption has been true.

1280
02:19:11.100 --> 02:19:28.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are some more complex projects that have come in since that waiver was passed under this program.

1281
02:19:29.299 --> 02:19:32.840
<v Josh Roper>Generally, I think that assumption has been true.

1282
02:19:32.840 --> 02:19:35.479
<v Josh Roper>There are some more complex projects There that have come are in since some that waiver was passed more under this program.

1283
02:19:35.504 --> 02:19:53.322
<v Josh Roper>Complicated aspects to— there's some tree fee exemptions, some other elements that are— that actually lead to some, I believe, some limited situations where the Affordable Housing SDC program is still preferable.

1284
02:19:53.889 --> 02:19:57.084
<v Josh Roper>But generally, that has been borne out and been accurate.

1285
02:19:57.552 --> 02:20:03.817
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And in those cases where this program would be more beneficial, This waiver wouldn't actually apply.

1286
02:20:04.290 --> 02:20:04.843
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1287
02:20:06.409 --> 02:20:06.868
<v Josh Roper>That's right.

1288
02:20:06.916 --> 02:20:19.992
<v Josh Roper>So in the ordinance, the folks who've taken advantage of HOLTY, of LTIC, and I believe another item that I'm forgetting—.

1289
02:20:20.040 --> 02:20:22.181
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it's the street— the tree waiver.

1290
02:20:22.599 --> 02:20:23.243
<v Josh Roper>Yeah.

1291
02:20:24.353 --> 02:20:26.204
<v Josh Roper>Are not eligible for this waiver.

1292
02:20:28.984 --> 02:20:41.149
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm struggling a little bit right now, and I'm struggling because it sounds like point in time when we pass the SDC waiver moving forward, one of two things happen.

1293
02:20:41.913 --> 02:20:51.391
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Either developers choose not to build under this program, or they choose to build under this program because there are other benefits, in which case they must sell to somebody who is income qualified.

1294
02:20:51.441 --> 02:20:51.815
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a fair point.

1295
02:20:52.492 --> 02:20:59.265
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So from the time the waiver was passed moving forward, there actually isn't much conflict between the programs.

1296
02:21:00.090 --> 02:21:21.478
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's really building that was done under a set of rules where developers knew what the rules were and penciled out their projects, but who haven't sold yet, and so they're on the market potentially with developments that were built under the SDC waiver without an income cap.

1297
02:21:22.361 --> 02:21:23.243
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1298
02:21:24.685 --> 02:21:25.904
<v Josh Roper>I believe so.

1299
02:21:26.128 --> 02:21:26.369
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1300
02:21:26.914 --> 02:21:34.945
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And do we have units that are on the market already that were built under the SDC waiver, or are those generally not yet fully developed?

1301
02:21:36.051 --> 02:21:40.637
<v Josh Roper>I don't believe they're developed yet, but I'm— are there?

1302
02:21:41.021 --> 02:21:42.415
<v Justin Wood>There are homes on the market.

1303
02:21:42.495 --> 02:21:43.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, maybe a few.

1304
02:21:44.811 --> 02:22:15.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess I'm struggling because Councilor Koyama Lane pointed out that the loser here is somebody who is income qualified currently and can't compete with somebody who is not income qualified and really needs this middle-income housing and who won't have access to it even though the person who developed the housing developed it knowing what the rules were at that time.

1305
02:22:15.941 --> 02:22:30.665
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I hear the concern and that competing with houses that can sell to anybody who can pay any price who had this same exemption, but we're not actually talking about a larger cost of development.

1306
02:22:30.728 --> 02:22:32.382
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The SDC waiver is there for both.

1307
02:22:32.479 --> 02:22:38.549
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What we're saying is you have the same cost of development development, you're capped on what you can sell it for, you're not capped on what you can sell it for.

1308
02:22:39.865 --> 02:22:43.013
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And developers knew the rules they were playing by when they got in the queue.

1309
02:22:43.430 --> 02:22:46.272
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's just that the rules changed after they got in line.

1310
02:22:47.283 --> 02:22:58.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm struggling to understand why income quality— why Portlanders who want to own a home and only make 100% of median income are the losers in our solution.

1311
02:23:00.895 --> 02:23:02.441
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just— am I missing something?

1312
02:23:02.569 --> 02:23:05.195
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess my question there is, am I missing something here?

1313
02:23:07.439 --> 02:23:09.477
<v Josh Roper>No, I don't think you are.

1314
02:23:09.621 --> 02:23:23.771
<v Josh Roper>I mean, I think there is a balancing here that is happening, and I think there's feedback that we're getting from developers and owners that these units are sitting on the market and are not selling.

1315
02:23:23.978 --> 02:23:25.859
<v Josh Roper>So that is on the one side.

1316
02:23:26.311 --> 02:23:28.717
<v Josh Roper>And the issue that you're raising is on the other.

1317
02:23:28.797 --> 02:23:30.945
<v Josh Roper>And I think it's totally valid.

1318
02:23:31.186 --> 02:23:31.379
<v Candace Avalos>I guess I—.

1319
02:23:31.411 --> 02:23:42.170
<v Queesha Light>I think it's also the assumption that you have the buyers in the market that are 100% and below that are there and ready to purchase.

1320
02:23:42.265 --> 02:23:54.259
<v Queesha Light>And I think that's the question that we need to have the answer to, because what we were hearing is that there are a lot of buyers that are 100% and above 100% that are on the market to purchase.

1321
02:23:55.091 --> 02:23:57.365
<v Queesha Light>Not necessarily all.

1322
02:23:57.816 --> 02:24:00.075
<v Queesha Light>So we— and I think that's the question, right?

1323
02:24:00.382 --> 02:24:00.528
<v Queesha Light>Who—.

1324
02:24:00.786 --> 02:24:02.851
<v Queesha Light>How many are in the market below that?

1325
02:24:03.302 --> 02:24:05.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's not a problem with the SDC waiver competition, though.

1326
02:24:06.051 --> 02:24:14.626
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That would be a problem with whether we are overbuilding what people at 100% or below can buy.

1327
02:24:15.335 --> 02:24:22.850
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's a question about the viability of this program, not about competition with the SDC waiver that applies more broadly?

1328
02:24:23.269 --> 02:24:26.556
<v Queesha Light>I think it's a little bit of both, but I mean, I do hear you on that.

1329
02:24:26.603 --> 02:24:28.327
<v Queesha Light>I think it's a little bit of both of those things.

1330
02:24:28.889 --> 02:24:41.144
<v Queesha Light>So, I mean, but I think the balance here was we have people who have taken advantage of this program, and, and now it's like we can't— we're not able to sell because people don't have to go through all of these requirements.

1331
02:24:43.156 --> 02:24:45.511
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, but again, the Yes.

1332
02:24:45.656 --> 02:24:53.174
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So you're saying that cost is not more under this program, it's just that the cost is now the same outside of this program to build.

1333
02:24:54.870 --> 02:25:05.438
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did we look at— if the, if the real challenge is not competition between programs because the cost is the same, it sounds like the real challenge is enough buyers.

1334
02:25:06.034 --> 02:25:10.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Have we had more houses to sell than buyers in this program?

1335
02:25:14.717 --> 02:25:17.512
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, we're hearing about it more, certainly.

1336
02:25:18.668 --> 02:25:23.360
<v Josh Roper>This concern about being able to sell the properties has come up more.

1337
02:25:23.808 --> 02:25:29.925
<v Josh Roper>Whether or not that is a product of this particular friction, I can't say.

1338
02:25:31.376 --> 02:25:36.394
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And did we consider a solution like— it looks like we're taking something out of the code that would raise it further.

1339
02:25:36.489 --> 02:25:43.602
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>From 100 to 120, so we're still helping people who struggle to buy our very expensive market-rate housing.

1340
02:25:43.650 --> 02:25:55.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did we consider a solution like that, or did we just jump to strike any support to make sure that folks who are earning around the average income have an opportunity for homeownership?

1341
02:25:56.352 --> 02:26:00.655
<v Josh Roper>There was some discussion about 120.

1342
02:26:02.556 --> 02:26:15.518
<v Josh Roper>There was also discussion about, for example, after a property has been on the market for X days or X months, then it becomes eligible for this, again, reprieve.

1343
02:26:16.353 --> 02:26:22.790
<v Josh Roper>But those are, again, kind of where you land on the balancing of these interests.

1344
02:26:23.112 --> 02:26:23.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

1345
02:26:23.596 --> 02:26:24.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Understood.

1346
02:26:24.146 --> 02:26:34.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think I would have concerns with the latter of those as well, because essentially then that doesn't allow the market to adjust to a rate that people who are earning 100% of median income can afford, right?

1347
02:26:34.138 --> 02:26:35.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's an incentive not to drop the price.

1348
02:26:36.707 --> 02:26:47.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I guess I, Chair, am struggling to see the connection between the problem that we're hearing and the solution at hand.

1349
02:26:47.385 --> 02:26:50.290
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I appreciate this coming forward.

1350
02:26:50.468 --> 02:27:10.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am sympathetic to the concerns that we have heard and I think there might be other ways to look at that, but a solution where we make it harder for folks who otherwise can't afford a home in our community to compete— because that's really what this is about.

1351
02:27:10.121 --> 02:27:11.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Who are you competing with?

1352
02:27:11.893 --> 02:27:22.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And are you getting outbid at every opportunity as 100% of median income homebuyer because somebody comes in who makes 50% more than you and can, can outbid you for that home.

1353
02:27:23.064 --> 02:27:36.435
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we removing the cap so you can get outbid every time because the rules changed and developers want the more, um, profitable rules?

1354
02:27:36.549 --> 02:27:43.049
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, I understand that and I am sympathetic to that, but I'm struggling with this being the solution.

1355
02:27:43.888 --> 02:27:44.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1356
02:27:44.322 --> 02:27:47.344
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For helping me make sure there wasn't anything I was missing.

1357
02:27:47.394 --> 02:27:48.056
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate that.

1358
02:27:48.346 --> 02:27:48.945
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1359
02:27:52.649 --> 02:27:53.266
<v Candace Avalos>Vice Chair Green.

1360
02:27:54.355 --> 02:27:55.217
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

1361
02:27:56.966 --> 02:28:01.960
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I remember that this was a point of interest when we considered the STC waiver.

1362
02:28:02.058 --> 02:28:16.560
<v Mitch Green>I had subsequently had conversations, I think it was actually with Mr. Justin Woods at Senator Confam had a I was on a roundtable for housing production, and this was a topic that came up.

1363
02:28:17.610 --> 02:28:21.379
<v Mitch Green>So I've been expecting this to come back, and I'm glad that you guys have taken it up.

1364
02:28:21.542 --> 02:28:22.603
<v Mitch Green>I guess I have a couple questions.

1365
02:28:24.290 --> 02:28:36.075
<v Mitch Green>The first is, in the presentation, you know, I think the top line summary is that the legislation would temporarily remove the income requirement for this program for eligible families.

1366
02:28:36.691 --> 02:28:36.935
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

1367
02:28:37.397 --> 02:28:44.413
<v Mitch Green>So income requirement for homebuyers purchasing qualifying homes benefiting from the larger program.

1368
02:28:44.460 --> 02:28:48.747
<v Mitch Green>So my understanding is the rest of the qualification requirements stay in place.

1369
02:28:48.813 --> 02:28:51.992
<v Mitch Green>We're just taking away the income cap, income requirement?

1370
02:28:52.810 --> 02:28:53.083
<v Josh Roper>That's right.

1371
02:28:53.452 --> 02:28:53.565
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1372
02:28:53.790 --> 02:28:59.023
<v Mitch Green>Can you speak a little bit about what the rest of those programs do to sort of protect this?

1373
02:28:59.328 --> 02:29:00.757
<v Mitch Green>So let me just get to the point.

1374
02:29:00.854 --> 02:29:20.429
<v Mitch Green>What do I say to someone who is worried that this just becomes sort of a giveaway to like a speculator who would then just go out and buy this at any price, turn it into some sort of a rental, and end up moving us further away from the stated goals of the affordable housing program in general?

1375
02:29:20.493 --> 02:29:24.515
<v Mitch Green>Because I understand that there's some first-time homebuyer requirements, there's some other aspects of it.

1376
02:29:24.579 --> 02:29:29.004
<v Mitch Green>So can you speak more broadly about how, like, what this preserves in that program?

1377
02:29:29.067 --> 02:29:34.713
<v Mitch Green>Because I don't think this just waives the program writ large and just creates a market program out of it.

1378
02:29:36.451 --> 02:29:36.888
<v Josh Roper>That's right.

1379
02:29:36.936 --> 02:29:37.808
<v Josh Roper>It doesn't.

1380
02:29:44.183 --> 02:29:45.958
<v Mitch Green>And you can get back to me with that.

1381
02:29:46.200 --> 02:29:47.793
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, I'm debating.

1382
02:29:48.131 --> 02:29:52.786
<v Josh Roper>I might do that because I want to be comprehensive and I might just give you a slice.

1383
02:29:53.495 --> 02:29:54.349
<v Josh Roper>So I'll do that.

1384
02:29:54.997 --> 02:29:55.494
<v Mitch Green>And that's okay.

1385
02:29:55.974 --> 02:30:02.347
<v Mitch Green>I wanted to make sure that I think it'll be important as we move from this committee to the council as a whole.

1386
02:30:03.930 --> 02:30:15.049
<v Mitch Green>I guess the other piece, and I appreciate the discussion, it is a concern, but I think that needs to be weighed against the— there's a fabric of policy here.

1387
02:30:15.436 --> 02:30:20.878
<v Mitch Green>There is a sort of landscape of policy at play.

1388
02:30:20.927 --> 02:30:23.735
<v Mitch Green>And when we created a waiver, we did so in light of the Yes.

1389
02:30:23.816 --> 02:30:40.530
<v Mitch Green>We created a bit of a rift in that fabric, and it's hard for me not to see the parallels between the sort of homeownership side of the affordable housing provider industry, so to speak, and also the kind of rental delivery side.

1390
02:30:41.219 --> 02:30:46.021
<v Mitch Green>And if we've got— I think I saw the impact statement said something like 700 units that are unsold.

1391
02:30:46.132 --> 02:30:48.842
<v Mitch Green>It's probably a subset of that because we're looking at a Yes.

1392
02:30:49.197 --> 02:31:10.986
<v Mitch Green>That, you know, if we've got units that can't be sold because of this rip in the fabric, so to speak, then I worry that we are putting some balance sheet pressure on some developers who could then get busy doing the next project under other emerging conditions that, you know, we've got the residential infill program.

1393
02:31:11.099 --> 02:31:23.063
<v Mitch Green>We've just adopted a MIRL, Middle Income Revolving Loan Program, that, you know, might provide a pathway for financing some of this, although I think that's largely for rental housing.

1394
02:31:23.159 --> 02:31:27.902
<v Mitch Green>But I think the idea is we're moving towards a direction to lower the cost of production, basically.

1395
02:31:28.581 --> 02:31:41.113
<v Mitch Green>And so I worry about tying up the balance sheets a little bit of some of these developers who cannot convert the investment into a receipt of cash and then move to the next one.

1396
02:31:41.243 --> 02:32:04.352
<v Mitch Green>And I worry that if we don't don't solve this problem here under a temporary waiver as well, then we're adding that same— or we're sort of like continuing that imbalance that we're seeing, frankly, with the affordable housing rental stock, which is also close to market and also means that, you know, that's one reason why you have problems with lease-ups.

1397
02:32:04.563 --> 02:32:19.000
<v Mitch Green>Obviously, there are other reasons, but these are sort of holistic dynamics that I'm And so I share some of the concern about maybe are we taking away a protection that a first-time homebuyer has to get access to this market.

1398
02:32:19.065 --> 02:32:23.594
<v Mitch Green>But I also know that we've seen this segment of the market soften in price.

1399
02:32:24.511 --> 02:32:34.778
<v Mitch Green>And as long as I know that there are some aspects of the program itself that do provide those guardrails, like you must be a first-time homebuyer, I think that's part of this program, if I'm not mistaken.

1400
02:32:34.842 --> 02:32:35.099
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1401
02:32:35.967 --> 02:32:39.320
<v Mitch Green>Then I think I can get very comfortable with just truing this piece up.

1402
02:32:39.369 --> 02:32:42.530
<v Mitch Green>So I think that's an important piece of the conversation that's not in play.

1403
02:32:42.577 --> 02:32:55.083
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, if it's appropriate, Chair, you know, we could ask the question of the practitioner in the audience, maybe to give your perspective on this from your experience, if you feel comfortable coming back up.

1404
02:32:59.637 --> 02:33:00.022
<v Justin Wood>Thank you.

1405
02:33:00.425 --> 02:33:02.519
<v Justin Wood>A couple things I wanted to just point out.

1406
02:33:02.695 --> 02:33:04.483
<v Justin Wood>I think your concerns are valid.

1407
02:33:04.611 --> 02:33:09.799
<v Justin Wood>I think if we were in a an otherwise hot housing market, I think that's a totally fair assessment.

1408
02:33:10.040 --> 02:33:10.875
<v Justin Wood>Unfortunately, we're not.

1409
02:33:11.147 --> 02:33:12.558
<v Justin Wood>We're in a slow housing market right now.

1410
02:33:13.072 --> 02:33:20.111
<v Justin Wood>And many of us who build houses using the SDC waiver program, we don't have big margins on our houses.

1411
02:33:20.625 --> 02:33:23.913
<v Justin Wood>And I count on having the SDC waivers to be able to sell my homes.

1412
02:33:25.099 --> 02:33:31.802
<v Justin Wood>If simply saying, well, just repay the $35,000 if you can't find a qualified buyer, that in a lot of cases means I lose money on the homes.

1413
02:33:31.851 --> 02:33:36.138
<v Justin Wood>And so So if it's a choice of losing money or not selling the home, so a lot of times we sit on it.

1414
02:33:36.653 --> 02:33:44.988
<v Justin Wood>And Councilor Green, you mentioned, unfortunately that means we have other homes in the project pipeline that we'd like to get built and add to the housing inventory stock that we can't.

1415
02:33:45.038 --> 02:33:54.787
<v Justin Wood>So we're really just trying for, I mean, in my company, we're down to 7 homes right now that we have that are competing against other homes that we just can't move off our balance sheet because we're struggling.

1416
02:33:56.103 --> 02:34:00.698
<v Justin Wood>And we, and I don't see in this market right now a situation where you're having Yes.

1417
02:34:01.244 --> 02:34:11.295
<v Justin Wood>Buyers at or below 100% of MFI competing against those higher income buyers right now, just 'cause we're in a market where there is an oversaturation of product on the market and prices have declined.

1418
02:34:11.519 --> 02:34:17.379
<v Justin Wood>And so I think that buyers who want to find homes and looking for home products have lots of options out there.

1419
02:34:17.459 --> 02:34:26.899
<v Justin Wood>And because of the fact that they have lots of options right there, they're choosing— the buyer who makes less than 100% of MFI can go down the street and buy a home from somebody who doesn't have Thank you.

1420
02:34:26.948 --> 02:34:28.459
<v Justin Wood>They have the same qualifications that I do.

1421
02:34:29.263 --> 02:34:34.102
<v Justin Wood>They're not over— they're not paying more for their home than they are for my home, but they have more options there.

1422
02:34:34.246 --> 02:34:42.421
<v Justin Wood>And in some respects, they're choosing to not buy my home because they have to pay $1,000 in fees to be able to apply for the program to buy it.

1423
02:34:42.549 --> 02:34:46.636
<v Justin Wood>So why would they choose to do mine versus the guy next door who doesn't require it?

1424
02:34:47.899 --> 02:35:00.244
<v Justin Wood>So if anything, this is kind of holding back the housing inventory, I think, somewhat for the few of us And I think I've heard the number 700, at least the handful of people that I know that utilize the program.

1425
02:35:00.600 --> 02:35:06.055
<v Justin Wood>I feel like the number right now is we're probably only talking 200 to 300 on the market right now today that this will be impacted by.

1426
02:35:07.677 --> 02:35:15.388
<v Justin Wood>But I know this has been a program that we've been big believers in, and I just want to see it be successful and continue for all of us to be able to use for years.

1427
02:35:16.385 --> 02:35:18.024
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for allowing that, Chair.

1428
02:35:18.108 --> 02:35:18.986
<v Mitch Green>Just one quick follow-up.

1429
02:35:20.323 --> 02:35:27.613
<v Mitch Green>You're obviously in the business of selling houses to people with an income restriction because that's your target, that's your market.

1430
02:35:27.934 --> 02:35:29.712
<v Mitch Green>Do you provide any sort of services?

1431
02:35:29.761 --> 02:35:31.347
<v Mitch Green>Do you help them through that process?

1432
02:35:31.396 --> 02:35:35.754
<v Mitch Green>Do you have like a counterpart that helps them through financing, helps them through kind of that capability?

1433
02:35:36.027 --> 02:35:46.009
<v Justin Wood>Yeah, we have a couple different lenders that we work with that are really familiar, not just the STC waiver program, but more probably the HOLTI program, because a lot of lenders don't understand how that works.

1434
02:35:49.075 --> 02:35:57.519
<v Justin Wood>So we have lenders and realtors that we're familiar with the programs that help us to do that, and we market those accordingly so that they know how to take advantage of those programs.

1435
02:35:57.855 --> 02:36:01.756
<v Justin Wood>So, yeah, sorry, and I'll say the HOLTI program is not affected by this.

1436
02:36:01.853 --> 02:36:04.373
<v Justin Wood>So the HOLTI program still has the income price cap.

1437
02:36:04.647 --> 02:36:16.270
<v Justin Wood>And so a lot of the— there are a lot of homes out there that have— that are— that do offer HOLTI, and this will not be— those homes will not be affected by this because the HOLTI to qualify for that still has an income cap on it.

1438
02:36:16.783 --> 02:36:18.710
<v Mitch Green>So yeah, so that's important.

1439
02:36:19.095 --> 02:36:30.528
<v Mitch Green>I worry that we lose that capability, which is an ancillary service provided to these homebuyers, if, you know, if we sort of get engulfed by the market segment, the sort of unrestricted market segment, because they don't bring that.

1440
02:36:30.609 --> 02:36:32.566
<v Mitch Green>So that's my assumption.

1441
02:36:32.680 --> 02:36:34.976
<v Mitch Green>And just, it was helpful to have that conversation.

1442
02:36:35.072 --> 02:36:40.388
<v Mitch Green>And I think I've used up a lot of time, so I'm gonna go ahead and— To, to me, or—.

1443
02:36:40.613 --> 02:36:40.951
<v Candace Avalos>Oh yeah.

1444
02:36:41.433 --> 02:36:59.131
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm wondering, thank you, if it's okay, Chair, I'm wondering, Councilor Green, if your question was answered, because what I heard in your line of questioning and your thoughts is that if we, um, if we remove the income cap, we might— there might still be some other provisions around first-time homebuyer.

1445
02:36:59.567 --> 02:37:01.295
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I didn't hear an answer if that's the case.

1446
02:37:01.360 --> 02:37:13.833
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And is that that we're not sure, or like these 7 homes, would you— are there Would it be now it's exactly the same as the other SDC waiver, or would you— does it make sense what I'm asking?

1447
02:37:14.331 --> 02:37:15.085
<v Mitch Green>It makes sense.

1448
02:37:15.375 --> 02:37:20.227
<v Mitch Green>I don't— so I have some preliminary familiarity with this program, but I am not the expert.

1449
02:37:20.275 --> 02:37:20.421
<v Mitch Green>And so—.

1450
02:37:20.421 --> 02:37:25.467
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I'm wondering if your question was answered and I missed it, or if someone can answer it or get back to me.

1451
02:37:25.675 --> 02:37:28.134
<v Josh Roper>I think I deferred, but I got a confirmation.

1452
02:37:28.229 --> 02:37:31.668
<v Josh Roper>So there is no first-time homebuyer requirement.

1453
02:37:31.750 --> 02:37:34.185
<v Josh Roper>But it isn't an owner occupancy requirement.

1454
02:37:34.847 --> 02:37:38.606
<v Josh Roper>So you wouldn't have a developer who then can just turn it into a rental.

1455
02:37:38.672 --> 02:37:41.156
<v Mitch Green>Same as like a VA underwriting, like you have to be the owner occupier.

1456
02:37:41.610 --> 02:37:43.834
<v Mitch Green>You can't use it as a speculative rental property.

1457
02:37:43.898 --> 02:37:47.896
<v Mitch Green>So I mean, that's one piece of my— that was one piece of my concerns that's now been settled here.

1458
02:37:51.076 --> 02:37:51.340
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

1459
02:37:51.981 --> 02:37:53.362
<v Candace Avalos>You're up next, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1460
02:37:58.306 --> 02:38:11.269
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do want to say I understand some of the frustration and confusion, and I— the illustration of like you get in line and then other people get in line and the rules have changed, or I'm thinking like you buy a sweater and then you see it's on sale later.

1461
02:38:11.510 --> 02:38:13.647
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That does seem very frustrating.

1462
02:38:14.805 --> 02:38:26.816
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am looking for some more specific data around— well, now I'm confused because there's 700 here, and then I'm hearing the number 200 to 300.

1463
02:38:26.881 --> 02:38:27.193
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>300.

1464
02:38:32.468 --> 02:38:38.743
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also have not heard the housing market described as slow.

1465
02:38:39.782 --> 02:38:42.531
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I have heard it as maybe not hot, but still competitive.

1466
02:38:43.117 --> 02:38:45.378
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is not my complete area of expertise.

1467
02:38:45.956 --> 02:39:00.326
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am interested also in what can we do to also let people know about these homes that are people are trying to sell and, you know, like, let's let teachers know about these.

1468
02:39:01.701 --> 02:39:14.962
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What data do we have specifically about how many units are on the market from the temporary SDC exemption program right now that are competing with this 200 to 700 homes from the AH SDC exemption program?

1469
02:39:15.288 --> 02:39:15.987
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Do we have those numbers?

1470
02:39:17.905 --> 02:39:21.828
<v Josh Roper>So maybe I can address the 700 versus 200 to 300.

1471
02:39:22.000 --> 02:39:24.190
<v Josh Roper>I'll just add one piece and then back into that question.

1472
02:39:25.120 --> 02:39:28.940
<v Josh Roper>So the 700 was an estimate based on permitting.

1473
02:39:28.940 --> 02:39:32.620
<v Josh Roper>So it's based on access to our permitting database.

1474
02:39:32.920 --> 02:39:44.700
<v Josh Roper>So do you sort of fit into this, again, limbo that we've been calling it, which is different from the question of whether or not those units are active in the, you know, on the market, available for purchase right now.

1475
02:39:44.700 --> 02:39:46.760
<v Josh Roper>Some of them may not be.

1476
02:39:46.870 --> 02:39:47.700
<v Josh Roper>And some of those 700 units 700 are not going to be available for purchase.

1477
02:39:48.046 --> 02:39:52.631
<v Josh Roper>May have gone on the market and sold and would be deducted from the 700.

1478
02:39:52.712 --> 02:39:52.825
<v Josh Roper>Okay.

1479
02:39:53.681 --> 02:39:58.672
<v Josh Roper>So it's totally plausible that you would have a smaller number on the market currently.

1480
02:40:00.545 --> 02:40:11.737
<v Josh Roper>In terms of data that we have access to, though, we don't have a great— we don't have a way to— or I'm not aware of a way to do a close analysis of what is on the market.

1481
02:40:12.096 --> 02:40:24.968
<v Josh Roper>Or Maybe we could, but we haven't, I should say, done a close analysis of what is on the market currently compared to basically the analysis that you're requesting.

1482
02:40:25.016 --> 02:40:25.579
<v Josh Roper>We haven't done that.

1483
02:40:26.530 --> 02:40:34.224
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I know I really love seeing data and would just— I would be interested in, and it would be really helpful for me to see that.

1484
02:40:34.902 --> 02:40:42.601
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I mean, it is compelling to hear you're doing open houses, trying to sell a home, and then And, you know, next door there's another one that's easier to sell.

1485
02:40:44.061 --> 02:40:52.317
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I would like to see data in addition to the, like, I'm hearing from developers, or this is kind of just being said.

1486
02:40:53.997 --> 02:40:58.218
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm not saying it's not true, but would like to know that we have some real data to back that up.

1487
02:41:00.042 --> 02:41:05.748
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'm feeling this, like, I kind of would like some more information in general about a couple of these things.

1488
02:41:06.010 --> 02:41:13.213
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And something I keep coming back to is when we do these incentives, like, what was the initial real intention or goal?

1489
02:41:14.064 --> 02:41:24.220
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And when it was the AHSDC, it's a big part of that is to provide affordable housing, which we don't have a glut of in our city, right?

1490
02:41:24.333 --> 02:41:25.665
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Like, we need more of that.

1491
02:41:26.163 --> 02:41:35.853
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then for the temporary SDC exemption, it was our mayor, our council really wants like a big boom and we want to show that Portland's ready to invest in.

1492
02:41:35.966 --> 02:41:37.185
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So come develop.

1493
02:41:37.250 --> 02:41:37.522
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1494
02:41:38.115 --> 02:41:38.485
<v Byron Balog>Right now.

1495
02:41:38.693 --> 02:41:51.576
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so it seems like there were kind of some different points to or goals attached to those exemptions, even though there are maybe similar people doing both of those, both of the buildings.

1496
02:41:51.769 --> 02:42:03.545
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then the folks who, if there are developers who got the AH SDC exemption program, could those, any of those developers apply to do more housing under the temporary SDC exemption?

1497
02:42:04.105 --> 02:42:04.397
<v Josh Roper>They could.

1498
02:42:04.592 --> 02:42:06.878
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It would just have to be a different project.

1499
02:42:06.942 --> 02:42:07.104
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

1500
02:42:07.656 --> 02:42:08.531
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for clarifying.

1501
02:42:13.590 --> 02:42:16.851
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to move to Councilor Novick if that's okay since he hasn't spoken yet.

1502
02:42:17.334 --> 02:42:18.191
<v Candace Avalos>And then I'll come back to you.

1503
02:42:18.707 --> 02:42:19.450
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1504
02:42:19.497 --> 02:42:26.993
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to clarify the sales cap will still apply to these previously, to these properties, right?

1505
02:42:27.041 --> 02:42:29.708
<v Steve Novick>So the properties will still be in the affordable range.

1506
02:42:29.772 --> 02:42:30.645
<v Steve Novick>It's only the income requirement.

1507
02:42:31.174 --> 02:42:32.408
<v Josh Roper>That will change.

1508
02:42:35.333 --> 02:42:35.850
<v Steve Novick>Whereas the—.

1509
02:42:36.060 --> 02:42:39.084
<v Josh Roper>The sale price cap does continue to apply.

1510
02:42:40.309 --> 02:42:40.470
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes.

1511
02:42:40.631 --> 02:43:09.634
<v Steve Novick>And I just want to go back to a point that Justin made is that, you know, right now if somebody below the income cap is looking for a house, they probably would— and some of— and any of the housing being built, you know, outside of this program but with the SDC waiver, is affordable to them, then they're likely to buy the house that where they don't have to— I mean, it's a pain in the neck to have to go through income verification.

1512
02:43:09.825 --> 02:43:13.656
<v Steve Novick>So their preference would be to buy something where they don't have to go through that.

1513
02:43:14.168 --> 02:43:16.059
<v Steve Novick>At least we can imagine that.

1514
02:43:16.700 --> 02:43:22.837
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, I mean, the administrative burden attached to any of these programs does add a little bit of extra friction.

1515
02:43:23.608 --> 02:43:25.306
<v Josh Roper>We try to minimize it, but it does.

1516
02:43:25.386 --> 02:43:35.603
<v Steve Novick>It's kind of like if you had an option between 2 free health insurance programs, one is Medicaid where you have to prove your income, and one is another one that you don't have to prove your income, you would avoid Medicaid and go with the other one.

1517
02:43:35.877 --> 02:43:38.157
<v Queesha Light>Yeah, it's the same thing that we see in the rental market, right?

1518
02:43:38.528 --> 02:43:51.206
<v Queesha Light>Is the challenges make it harder for, you know, when I've got to supply all of these documents and do all of this work, I'm going to— I, and I can pay the same price, why would I wait over here for 6 months before I can even do it?

1519
02:43:51.254 --> 02:43:51.783
<v Queesha Light>So, okay.

1520
02:43:52.506 --> 02:43:52.907
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1521
02:43:54.370 --> 02:43:55.220
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1522
02:43:56.377 --> 02:43:56.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1523
02:43:57.501 --> 02:43:59.620
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It sounds like you have the support here.

1524
02:43:59.893 --> 02:44:07.808
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I just want to be clear, I'm very sympathetic to the challenges that the program is facing as the market changes, right?

1525
02:44:07.856 --> 02:44:22.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as the market softens, especially in this segment of the market, those spaces where there isn't always a huge difference in cost And there is a very tight margin for developers doesn't leave a lot of room for movement.

1526
02:44:22.709 --> 02:44:29.372
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think that there is absolutely a space for the city to have a conversation about waiving that $1,000 fee.

1527
02:44:29.934 --> 02:44:39.102
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think there is absolutely a space for the city to have a conversation about raising the income cap to 120% where it sat previously.

1528
02:44:39.231 --> 02:44:42.941
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think there are a lot of things we could be doing to address the challenges.

1529
02:44:43.149 --> 02:44:49.412
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Challenges that this program is facing based on where the market is at in those very tight margins for developers.

1530
02:44:50.310 --> 02:45:06.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I just don't think that making it even harder for folks who are making average income or less to enter homeownership is the right way for us to be addressing those challenges.

1531
02:45:07.811 --> 02:45:08.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks, Chair.

1532
02:45:09.498 --> 02:45:10.397
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1533
02:45:10.718 --> 02:45:14.284
<v Candace Avalos>Put myself in the queue just to say, uh, I appreciate the discussion.

1534
02:45:14.959 --> 02:45:27.263
<v Candace Avalos>Like I said, my office had been working on this, and ultimately, um, I, I personally feel that this is the right solution to, um, a pipelining problem and a competitive problem.

1535
02:45:27.343 --> 02:45:38.465
<v Candace Avalos>I get the concerns, um, but I think that if we are creating this program that is adding this other barrier for how housing to get into the hands of folks and for us to keep that moving.

1536
02:45:38.897 --> 02:45:43.704
<v Candace Avalos>That is my concern and is why I think this is a solution to address that.

1537
02:45:43.864 --> 02:45:44.842
<v Candace Avalos>Is it a perfect solution?

1538
02:45:45.049 --> 02:45:45.227
<v Candace Avalos>No.

1539
02:45:45.852 --> 02:45:49.231
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but I don't think the SCC waiver was a perfect solution either.

1540
02:45:49.408 --> 02:45:52.836
<v Candace Avalos>So I've kind of— I kind of feel like my hands are tied because we already agreed to that.

1541
02:45:53.301 --> 02:45:58.300
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and now this is a hangup that, um, we have to resolve in order to keep projects moving.

1542
02:45:58.364 --> 02:46:03.509
<v Candace Avalos>And that's ultimately the whole point of the SCC exemption program, was to keep projects moving.

1543
02:46:03.588 --> 02:46:06.715
<v Candace Avalos>So I understand the concerns that my colleagues have raised.

1544
02:46:06.763 --> 02:46:09.665
<v Candace Avalos>I share them, but I do plan to support this today.

1545
02:46:10.146 --> 02:46:10.674
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much.

1546
02:46:12.054 --> 02:46:17.120
<v Candace Avalos>I don't see anyone else in the queue, so do I— let's see.

1547
02:46:17.263 --> 02:46:18.242
<v Candace Avalos>Now I got to get the language up.

1548
02:46:19.363 --> 02:46:25.551
<v Candace Avalos>I would like to entertain a motion to move ordinance document number 2026-205 to full council with a recommendation to pass.

1549
02:46:26.320 --> 02:46:27.459
<v Council President Dunphy>So moved.

1550
02:46:29.833 --> 02:46:30.156
<v Mitch Green>Second.

1551
02:46:30.627 --> 02:46:34.951
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, so moved by Councilor Novick and seconded by Vice Chair Green.

1552
02:46:36.444 --> 02:46:39.752
<v Candace Avalos>I see no further discussion, therefore please call the roll, Diego.

1553
02:46:41.203 --> 02:46:41.672
<v Diego>Pirtle-Guiney?

1554
02:46:42.106 --> 02:46:42.236
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1555
02:46:43.690 --> 02:46:44.029
<v Diego>Koyama Lane?

1556
02:46:44.369 --> 02:46:44.450
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

1557
02:46:45.986 --> 02:46:46.326
<v Diego>Novick?

1558
02:46:46.861 --> 02:46:46.908
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1559
02:46:48.090 --> 02:46:48.381
<v Diego>Green?

1560
02:46:49.126 --> 02:46:49.174
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1561
02:46:50.420 --> 02:46:50.727
<v Diego>Avalos?

1562
02:46:51.510 --> 02:46:51.527
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1563
02:46:52.220 --> 02:47:03.234
<v Diego>With 3 ayes and 2 nay votes, the motion carries and the ordinance document number 2026-1 Will move to the full council with the recommendation it be passed.

1564
02:47:03.781 --> 02:47:04.039
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1565
02:47:04.200 --> 02:47:05.601
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Housing Bureau, for being here.

1566
02:47:06.379 --> 02:47:08.148
<v Candace Avalos>Colleagues, our next meeting is July 7th.

1567
02:47:08.245 --> 02:47:15.227
<v Candace Avalos>At that meeting, we will have a presentation on the North and Northeast Housing Strategy, and I will give you some more updates on other agenda items that we're still cooking.

1568
02:47:15.932 --> 02:47:19.637
<v Candace Avalos>And with that, I will adjourn the meeting of Housing and Permitting Committee at 4:43 PM.

