WEBVTT

1
00:07:43.939 --> 00:07:46.254
<v Michael>Good morning, everybody.

2
00:07:49.877 --> 00:07:55.918
<v Steve Novick>Welcome to the first meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee in the reign of the NBA champion New York Knicks.

3
00:07:58.156 --> 00:07:59.648
<v Steve Novick>And I hereby call said meeting to order.

4
00:08:02.230 --> 00:08:03.410
<v Steve Novick>Uh, clerk, can you please call the roll?

5
00:08:04.720 --> 00:08:05.173
<v Brandon Brown>Good morning.

6
00:08:05.610 --> 00:08:06.029
<v Bob Day>Kanal?

7
00:08:06.903 --> 00:08:07.178
<v Sameer Kanal>Present.

8
00:08:08.019 --> 00:08:08.295
<v Angelita Morillo>Morillo?

9
00:08:09.120 --> 00:08:09.232
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

10
00:08:09.571 --> 00:08:10.005
<v Angelita Morillo>Zimmerman.

11
00:08:10.117 --> 00:08:10.375
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

12
00:08:11.182 --> 00:08:11.536
<v Angelita Morillo>Smith.

13
00:08:12.696 --> 00:08:13.035
<v Earl Riley>Novick.

14
00:08:13.887 --> 00:08:14.081
<v Steve Novick>Here.

15
00:08:19.269 --> 00:08:21.117
<v Steve Novick>Christopher, could you please read the statement of conduct?

16
00:08:22.649 --> 00:08:25.093
<v Eric Zimmerman>Welcome to the meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee.

17
00:08:25.175 --> 00:08:37.721
<v James Crooker>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/community-and-public-safety-committee or by calling 311.

18
00:08:38.259 --> 00:08:40.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

19
00:08:40.980 --> 00:08:43.720
<v Sameer Kanal>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

20
00:08:43.720 --> 00:08:46.750
<v Sameer Kanal>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

21
00:08:46.899 --> 00:08:52.029
<v Robert Taylor>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

22
00:08:52.100 --> 00:08:54.090
<v Robert Taylor>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

23
00:08:54.240 --> 00:08:55.360
<v Robert Taylor>The chair preserves order.

24
00:08:55.360 --> 00:09:01.669
<v Robert Taylor>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

25
00:09:01.679 --> 00:09:03.419
<v Robert Taylor>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

26
00:09:03.419 --> 00:09:05.720
<v Robert Taylor>Further disruption results in ejection from the meeting.

27
00:09:05.720 --> 00:09:08.259
<v Robert Taylor>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

28
00:09:08.259 --> 00:09:14.424
<v Bob Day>Additionally, the committee may take a short break thank you, Christopher.

29
00:09:14.537 --> 00:09:23.229
<v Steve Novick>There is an amendment to the statement of conduct for today, which is that spontaneous chants of Go Knicks or Knicks Rule will not be considered disruptive.

30
00:09:24.462 --> 00:09:26.707
<v Steve Novick>Today we might have bitten off more than we can chew.

31
00:09:28.054 --> 00:09:36.730
<v Steve Novick>After last session, we had a great discussion with ceasefire partners, and I thought it would be valuable if we had more discussion with cool people doing cool stuff.

32
00:09:37.500 --> 00:09:48.315
<v Steve Novick>So today we're gonna lead off with a discussion of restorative justice and hear from restorative justice partners and hear something about the relationship of restorative justice partners with law enforcement.

33
00:09:49.369 --> 00:09:52.970
<v Steve Novick>The FITCOG said they wanted to come on down, so I told them come on down.

34
00:09:53.855 --> 00:09:57.390
<v Steve Novick>Then we're gonna resume our discussion of concealed carry in public buildings.

35
00:09:57.892 --> 00:10:02.927
<v Steve Novick>And if we can get to it, we'll turn to psychedelics at the end, but it's quite possible we won't get to it.

36
00:10:03.706 --> 00:10:08.143
<v Steve Novick>And now I will— I'm sorry, We'll ask the clerk to read the first item.

37
00:10:09.663 --> 00:10:15.392
<v Tristan Edwards>Item number 1, April 7th, 2026, Community and Public Safety Committee minutes.

38
00:10:17.090 --> 00:10:17.394
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

39
00:10:17.910 --> 00:10:19.214
<v Steve Novick>And Tristan, take it away.

40
00:10:20.341 --> 00:10:21.274
<v Tristan Edwards>Good morning, Councilors.

41
00:10:21.388 --> 00:10:22.080
<v Edith Thrower>Sorry, apologies.

42
00:10:22.192 --> 00:10:23.336
<v Tristan Edwards>This is the approval of the minutes.

43
00:10:23.384 --> 00:10:23.690
<v Steve Novick>Oh, sorry.

44
00:10:24.429 --> 00:10:25.057
<v Mindy Johnston>Sorry.

45
00:10:25.894 --> 00:10:26.361
<v Steve Novick>I forget.

46
00:10:26.860 --> 00:10:29.384
<v Steve Novick>Do we take a vote immediately or do I just ask for unanimous consent?

47
00:10:30.193 --> 00:10:33.154
<v Tristan Edwards>If there's no objections, then we can do it by unanimous consent.

48
00:10:34.139 --> 00:10:35.798
<v Steve Novick>Do I have unanimous consent to approve the minutes?

49
00:10:37.139 --> 00:10:38.155
<v Steve Novick>All right, approved.

50
00:10:38.865 --> 00:10:39.284
<v Cameron Hayes>Thank you.

51
00:10:39.591 --> 00:10:48.538
<v Tristan Edwards>Item number 2, document number 2026-200, Restorative Justice Programs Within the City and County.

52
00:10:49.070 --> 00:10:50.748
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

53
00:10:50.860 --> 00:10:51.150
<v Loretta Smith>Now, Tristan.

54
00:10:51.424 --> 00:10:54.927
<v Tristan Edwards>Thank you so much, and we really appreciate the opportunity to be here.

55
00:10:55.557 --> 00:10:57.096
<v Tristan Edwards>My name is Tristan Edwards.

56
00:10:57.240 --> 00:11:00.009
<v Tristan Edwards>I am a public defender at Metropolitan Public Defender.

57
00:11:00.543 --> 00:11:14.413
<v Tristan Edwards>I work in the major felony unit, and I also work on policy work today, we're going to be talking about different restorative justice programs that operate in the city.

58
00:11:15.072 --> 00:11:22.393
<v Tristan Edwards>I am going to try and go so fast so that we can get to our amazing presenters here from the different restorative justice programs.

59
00:11:22.668 --> 00:11:28.672
<v Tristan Edwards>And I'm going to have everyone introduce themselves as they take turns talking about their programs.

60
00:11:28.736 --> 00:11:34.418
<v Tristan Edwards>So first, and as briefly as I can possibly go, I just wanted to give a little bit of an orientation around what restorative justice is.

61
00:11:34.466 --> 00:11:44.451
<v Tristan Edwards>So restorative justice is a process sometimes I find it to be helpful to compare and contrast a little bit with the criminal system, which is what most of us are more familiar with.

62
00:11:45.317 --> 00:11:49.181
<v Tristan Edwards>And this kind of gets broken down into 3 questions to explain that framework.

63
00:11:49.565 --> 00:11:54.182
<v Tristan Edwards>So within the criminal system, we ask a set of 3 questions very simplistically.

64
00:11:55.159 --> 00:11:56.265
<v Tristan Edwards>What law was broken?

65
00:11:56.538 --> 00:11:57.500
<v Tristan Edwards>Who broke that law?

66
00:11:58.285 --> 00:11:59.952
<v Tristan Edwards>And how do we punish that person?

67
00:12:00.769 --> 00:12:16.240
<v Tristan Edwards>The criminal system sees harm as a violation of the law, and the outcomes from the criminal system are really oriented around what do we within restorative justice, we ask a different set of questions.

68
00:12:16.509 --> 00:12:17.580
<v Tristan Edwards>Who has been hurt?

69
00:12:17.950 --> 00:12:19.039
<v Tristan Edwards>What are their needs?

70
00:12:19.409 --> 00:12:22.159
<v Tristan Edwards>And whose obligation is it to meet those needs?

71
00:12:22.389 --> 00:12:27.529
<v Tristan Edwards>And so you can see just in kind of these 3 different questions that the framing around restorative justice is different.

72
00:12:27.990 --> 00:12:35.029
<v Tristan Edwards>The discussion is around the harmed party and what can be done to heal, repair harm.

73
00:12:35.029 --> 00:12:35.250
<v Angelita Morillo>So, Councilor Smith, I'm going to turn it over to you.

74
00:12:35.250 --> 00:12:35.330
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

75
00:12:35.942 --> 00:12:40.232
<v Tristan Edwards>Kind of distilling from this some primary goals of restorative justice.

76
00:12:40.491 --> 00:12:43.389
<v Tristan Edwards>Healing for harmed parties is obviously a primary goal.

77
00:12:44.966 --> 00:12:49.489
<v Tristan Edwards>And so oftentimes we say that restorative justice is a survivor-centered process of accountability.

78
00:12:50.169 --> 00:13:00.577
<v Tristan Edwards>That accountability piece for the responsible party is important, but it is centered around the needs of the survivor and with the goal of repairing the harm to the extent that that is possible.

79
00:13:01.341 --> 00:13:10.991
<v Tristan Edwards>I should also mention that while the criminal system sees harm as a violation of the law, restorative justice sees harm as a violation of a relationship that requires repair.

80
00:13:12.066 --> 00:13:15.496
<v Tristan Edwards>Another primary goal within restorative justice is accountability.

81
00:13:16.250 --> 00:13:27.840
<v Tristan Edwards>As a public defender, I hear the word accountability used a lot in the criminal system, and typically what it means is sending someone to prison or jail or placing them on a long period of supervision.

82
00:13:28.738 --> 00:13:48.022
<v Tristan Edwards>That accountability, I think, really gets away from what we really and really what I think we mean when we say we want accountability is a true internal reckoning with a harm that someone has caused and steps to repair that harm.

83
00:13:48.636 --> 00:13:55.458
<v Tristan Edwards>And that accountability piece, that repair, also means that that is an invitation for someone to restore their place in the community.

84
00:13:55.878 --> 00:14:01.568
<v Tristan Edwards>That if they're willing to do that reckoning, that hard internal work, then they can have a pathway back into the community.

85
00:14:01.687 --> 00:14:01.823
<v Tristan Edwards>Thank you.

86
00:14:02.035 --> 00:14:06.186
<v Tristan Edwards>To restoring their place in the community and having a vested interest in the community.

87
00:14:06.538 --> 00:14:11.312
<v Tristan Edwards>And I think both of these things really tie into that— the third goal, which is a goal of public safety.

88
00:14:11.970 --> 00:14:21.119
<v Tristan Edwards>Again, as a public defender, people come to my desk, they become my clients generally because of reactions that come from a place of unhealed trauma.

89
00:14:21.519 --> 00:14:29.547
<v Tristan Edwards>The more that we are promoting healing from harm, the less we are going to have people who are playing out their trauma in unproductive ways in the future.

90
00:14:30.283 --> 00:14:45.852
<v Tristan Edwards>And when it comes to accountability, really the understanding the impacts of a harm and having the opportunity to wrestle with what that means to have caused harm and to reach repair is something that is going to make someone infinitely less likely to repeat that harm in the future.

91
00:14:47.600 --> 00:15:06.239
<v Tristan Edwards>Okay, I'm gonna play this 4-minute video, which is a participant from the Restorative Roots Project, one of the programs that'll be speaking today, I thought that this might be better than trying to explain what a restorative justice process looks like.

92
00:15:06.336 --> 00:15:16.794
<v Tristan Edwards>I'll also just mention that I printed out a flyer that was created by the Restorative Justice Coalition of Oregon that also seeks to dig into a little bit more of the complexities around restorative justice.

93
00:15:20.231 --> 00:15:21.126
<v Michael>My name is Michael.

94
00:15:21.475 --> 00:15:22.866
<v Michael>I'm 20 years old, and I'm a victim of sexual assault.

95
00:15:22.970 --> 00:15:24.730
<v Michael>I'm a fairly recent new barber.

96
00:15:25.090 --> 00:15:26.639
<v Michael>You know, I had never been in a robbery before.

97
00:15:26.809 --> 00:15:28.470
<v Michael>Like, I've never been in this type of situation.

98
00:15:29.009 --> 00:15:32.350
<v Michael>I've heard about them, but I never thought like it would happen to me.

99
00:15:32.350 --> 00:15:39.570
<v Michael>I was working drive-through cashier, so when I saw him in, you know, I just greeted him like any other person.

100
00:15:39.570 --> 00:15:41.320
<v Michael>I was like, hey, hey, how's it going?

101
00:15:41.870 --> 00:15:45.269
<v Michael>I feel like it's crazy because everything turned dark so quickly.

102
00:15:46.200 --> 00:15:51.916
<v Michael>You know, he was laughing, so like when his first sentence was like, oh, I'm going to need all the cash from the register.

103
00:15:52.607 --> 00:15:54.702
<v Michael>You know, I laughed because I thought he was joking around.

104
00:15:55.298 --> 00:15:56.846
<v Michael>And he was like, oh, like, I'm not joking.

105
00:15:57.500 --> 00:16:01.885
<v Michael>And, you know, everything went tense, I guess you could say.

106
00:16:02.225 --> 00:16:05.336
<v Michael>I guess he had no weapons on him, but he made it seem like he did.

107
00:16:05.888 --> 00:16:08.155
<v Michael>So that made it like 10 times more terrifying.

108
00:16:08.779 --> 00:16:10.693
<v Michael>My coworkers, you know, they don't know no English.

109
00:16:11.038 --> 00:16:13.214
<v Michael>So the only language they spoke was Spanish.

110
00:16:14.029 --> 00:16:16.355
<v Michael>So, I mean, they knew a threat was there, right?

111
00:16:16.547 --> 00:16:17.878
<v Michael>But they were scared.

112
00:16:18.326 --> 00:16:23.971
<v Michael>If I'm being honest, like, I— when the whole process came down, I had, like, no idea about this program at all.

113
00:16:25.062 --> 00:16:38.485
<v Michael>It all came down when we went to the attorney, and they were telling us that we had 2 options: to either take the case to trial or to do this new program that we had never heard about before.

114
00:16:38.982 --> 00:16:45.990
<v Michael>I would say the restorative routes this project is a different type of system than what we normally have.

115
00:16:46.346 --> 00:16:50.129
<v Michael>They explained to us that we would get to know some of the answers that we wanted to know.

116
00:16:50.532 --> 00:17:00.065
<v Michael>You know, like instead of trial, like we would have been able to ask him like why he did it or like what was his motives, you know, like what he had been going through.

117
00:17:00.451 --> 00:17:12.837
<v Michael>But being able to like get to know the reason why and get to tell that person how you felt that moment so that they know the impact they had on you and they could take, like, the accountability, you know.

118
00:17:13.304 --> 00:17:17.659
<v Michael>The Restorative Roots facilitator, they helped us in steps.

119
00:17:19.411 --> 00:17:22.642
<v Michael>You know, at first everybody was traumatized, including me.

120
00:17:22.787 --> 00:17:44.478
<v Michael>We didn't really want to talk about the situation, so they did a good job of implementing, like, little steps for when the when the big day came for the conversation, when I got to ask him, like, about his, like, childhood and stuff, like, you know, I got to learn that he didn't really grow up in a nice environment.

121
00:17:45.310 --> 00:17:47.058
<v Michael>You know, it was really rough for him.

122
00:17:47.635 --> 00:17:51.434
<v Michael>And so it definitely helped me because I got to understand a little more.

123
00:17:51.996 --> 00:18:05.988
<v Michael>So by the time, like, we said our thoughts, you know, how we felt, like, towards the end, He spoke again, and that's when we, like, got to see, I guess, the real him, you know, that he was sorry.

124
00:18:06.101 --> 00:18:08.348
<v Michael>And, you know, he was really empathetic.

125
00:18:08.894 --> 00:18:12.201
<v Michael>Like, he had no idea of the impact that he had done to us.

126
00:18:12.522 --> 00:18:16.650
<v Michael>And when he apologized, I feel like that's something that I really needed to hear.

127
00:18:17.243 --> 00:18:18.978
<v Michael>Definitely helped me feel a lot.

128
00:18:19.250 --> 00:18:21.515
<v Michael>You know, it felt like a huge relief, to be honest.

129
00:18:21.660 --> 00:18:23.538
<v Michael>You know, he had never experienced something like that.

130
00:18:23.329 --> 00:18:32.950
<v Michael>And he was really grateful that we had decided to go with the Restored Roots Project because to him it wasn't just like a free get-out-of-jail-free card, you know.

131
00:18:33.209 --> 00:18:38.925
<v Michael>To him it was like, yeah, he was really like impacted and shocked of what all the help he was getting.

132
00:18:41.170 --> 00:18:43.684
<v Michael>And yeah, I mean, towards the end everybody felt good, you know.

133
00:18:43.862 --> 00:18:48.103
<v Michael>It felt like all the questions we had were answered.

134
00:18:48.458 --> 00:18:53.939
<v Michael>He was willing He wanted to work to pay some of the medical bills.

135
00:18:53.987 --> 00:18:55.166
<v Michael>He wanted to write us letters more.

136
00:18:55.296 --> 00:18:59.252
<v Michael>He wanted to know, like, how we're doing, like, anything he could do to make us feel better, you know?

137
00:19:00.362 --> 00:19:06.819
<v Michael>And the crazy thing is, is that when I went to barber school, his brother was actually going to school as well.

138
00:19:07.527 --> 00:19:14.679
<v Michael>So when I got to see him come and visit his brother, you know, he had told me that he was really doing really good, that he was traveling a lot, working a lot.

139
00:19:15.548 --> 00:19:20.768
<v Michael>And, you know, he even offered to bring like post mail from different states he had visited.

140
00:19:20.977 --> 00:19:22.715
<v Michael>I would say we're pretty good friends now.

141
00:19:23.295 --> 00:19:27.729
<v Michael>After the Restorative Roots was over, I was going out more.

142
00:19:28.097 --> 00:19:30.443
<v Michael>You know, I didn't have to watch my back, I guess.

143
00:19:30.669 --> 00:19:32.906
<v Michael>I wasn't, you know, scared at all.

144
00:19:33.814 --> 00:19:39.680
<v Michael>And it helped me learn that I could also watch like some of the stuff I do too, because like of the impact that had happened, you know.

145
00:19:39.744 --> 00:19:40.068
<v Michael>Thank you.

146
00:19:40.519 --> 00:19:47.160
<v Michael>So I mean, not only did it help him, but it helped me to like reflect on some of the stuff I could be doing better as well.

147
00:19:47.450 --> 00:19:51.690
<v Michael>But yeah, I feel like it was— yeah, justice was served.

148
00:19:54.589 --> 00:19:54.950
<v Brandon Brown>Great.

149
00:19:54.950 --> 00:19:57.809
<v Tristan Edwards>Now I'm going to pass it over to Lutheran Community Services.

150
00:19:58.150 --> 00:19:59.470
<v Mindy Johnston>Hi, good morning everybody.

151
00:19:59.470 --> 00:20:00.329
<v Mindy Johnston>Mindy Johnston.

152
00:20:00.329 --> 00:20:05.670
<v Mindy Johnston>I am the program director with our Justice Forward department at Lutheran Community Services Northwest.

153
00:20:05.670 --> 00:20:14.507
<v Mindy Johnston>And this is a lot of information on a slide, but the point that I wanna go over is some of the different branches of services that we provide.

154
00:20:14.570 --> 00:20:23.499
<v Mindy Johnston>So we have community-based victim advocates, and then these are the sort of different branches of restorative justice that we're providing.

155
00:20:24.124 --> 00:20:33.532
<v Mindy Johnston>So we have, we work with juveniles through the Department of Community Justice Juvenile Services Division on both pre- and post-adjudicated cases.

156
00:20:34.445 --> 00:20:36.786
<v Mindy Johnston>We have a partnership with the Portland Police Bureau.

157
00:20:36.946 --> 00:20:37.171
<v Mindy Johnston>Thank you.

158
00:20:38.037 --> 00:20:42.590
<v Mindy Johnston>We have a partnership with the District Attorney's Office and then Portland Public Schools.

159
00:20:43.104 --> 00:20:52.244
<v Mindy Johnston>And out of all of those different partnerships, for the DA's office and PPS, this comes at no cost for them.

160
00:20:52.789 --> 00:21:00.983
<v Mindy Johnston>So our primary funding is through Multnomah County DCJ and then the Criminal Justice Commission's Restorative Justice Grant.

161
00:21:01.690 --> 00:21:12.796
<v Mindy Johnston>And in the exciting, The other thing that I wanna talk about is this pre-arrest partnership we've had with PPB that we've been working on since 2022.

162
00:21:13.198 --> 00:21:25.157
<v Mindy Johnston>So we understand that shifting the criminal justice system takes time, and we're at a point where we wanna start seeing more referrals coming through.

163
00:21:25.768 --> 00:21:31.530
<v Mindy Johnston>So over the last 4 years, we have worked with the police on roll calls.

164
00:21:31.723 --> 00:21:33.650
<v Mindy Johnston>We go to Advanced Academy.

165
00:21:33.761 --> 00:21:34.019
<v Mindy Johnston>Thank you.

166
00:21:36.041 --> 00:21:38.016
<v Mindy Johnston>We meet with the equity team.

167
00:21:38.065 --> 00:21:45.096
<v Mindy Johnston>We've had all kinds of planning and implementation, but we're still really not seeing cases.

168
00:21:45.208 --> 00:21:49.189
<v Mindy Johnston>And one of the things we've reflected on is how these cases come to us.

169
00:21:50.265 --> 00:21:59.511
<v Mindy Johnston>We're having an understanding that criminal justice system partners are uncomfortable talking about restorative justice because that's not their job.

170
00:22:01.326 --> 00:22:07.355
<v Mindy Johnston>So with our partnership with the DA, there's been a shift over the last 6 months.

171
00:22:07.515 --> 00:22:14.057
<v Mindy Johnston>We also spent a lot of time working on the relationship with them, and it was very slow to go.

172
00:22:15.373 --> 00:22:24.721
<v Mindy Johnston>But in the last 6 months, there's been a shift where instead of having attorneys talk to people about restorative justice, they just send the case to us.

173
00:22:25.619 --> 00:22:31.681
<v Mindy Johnston>And then we can explain restorative justice to participants, and they can agree or not.

174
00:22:31.874 --> 00:22:36.830
<v Mindy Johnston>And so that, In the first year of our partnership with the DA, we had one referral.

175
00:22:37.444 --> 00:22:40.176
<v Mindy Johnston>And in the last 6 months, we've had almost 20.

176
00:22:41.082 --> 00:22:45.920
<v Mindy Johnston>And so we're seeing a real shift in the success of that.

177
00:22:46.096 --> 00:22:48.416
<v Mindy Johnston>And we would like to see that also with the police.

178
00:22:48.497 --> 00:22:51.009
<v Mindy Johnston>So we've worked with each of the precincts.

179
00:22:51.090 --> 00:22:54.473
<v Mindy Johnston>We focused for a while on North Precinct.

180
00:22:54.957 --> 00:23:01.424
<v Mindy Johnston>And I think it's— there's just a real challenge in getting officers to buy into restorative justice.

181
00:23:01.523 --> 00:23:01.624
<v Bob Day>Yeah.

182
00:23:02.400 --> 00:23:06.195
<v Mindy Johnston>Even though a lot of times when they hear it, they're excited about it.

183
00:23:06.276 --> 00:23:10.298
<v Mindy Johnston>So I think something happens between Advanced Academy and being on the ground.

184
00:23:13.358 --> 00:23:32.461
<v Mindy Johnston>I would also just like to add that I think out of all of these partners, and including my colleagues down the row, any of these different partners along the line, whether it's pre-arrest or post, you know, pre-arrest, pre-adjudication, post-adjudication, there could be hundreds and hundreds of referrals that came through for all of us.

185
00:23:34.089 --> 00:23:44.195
<v Mindy Johnston>For our juvenile department cases in 2025, for recidivism, the general population was 28% for recidivism on youth cases.

186
00:23:44.957 --> 00:23:48.057
<v Mindy Johnston>For the youth that went through restorative justice, it was 19%.

187
00:23:49.057 --> 00:24:01.864
<v Mindy Johnston>We have data that shows that this is effective in reducing recidivism, and that we know is a cost savings to our community to Public safety, all the things that we all want.

188
00:24:02.904 --> 00:24:15.021
<v Mindy Johnston>So we're here to give a push for this work and for getting your support to help our systems partners meaningfully engage in restorative justice.

189
00:24:16.096 --> 00:24:17.843
<v Mindy Johnston>We can't do it alone.

190
00:24:18.435 --> 00:24:26.898
<v Mindy Johnston>We need to find ways that restorative justice is maintained in the community, but is also institutionalized in some way with our systems partners.

191
00:24:26.946 --> 00:24:27.075
<v Mindy Johnston>Thank you.

192
00:24:27.140 --> 00:24:27.942
<v Mindy Johnston>System partners.

193
00:24:28.840 --> 00:24:31.281
<v Mindy Johnston>Um, and I think that's all.

194
00:24:31.811 --> 00:24:32.838
<v Mindy Johnston>Pass it to Brandon.

195
00:24:33.898 --> 00:24:34.509
<v Brandon Brown>Thank you for that.

196
00:24:35.505 --> 00:24:37.576
<v Brandon Brown>Hello everybody, my name is Brandon Brown.

197
00:24:38.153 --> 00:24:41.782
<v Brandon Brown>I am the Director of Community Outreach for Restorative Roots Project.

198
00:24:42.826 --> 00:24:50.259
<v Brandon Brown>We are a holistic nonprofit organization that aims at the restoration and transformation of individuals and communities.

199
00:24:51.721 --> 00:25:00.112
<v Brandon Brown>Um, Why I am here today, I'm here to speak about our partnership mainly with the District Attorney's Office.

200
00:25:01.730 --> 00:25:07.229
<v Brandon Brown>In 2021, Restorative Roots Project became a program underneath another nonprofit.

201
00:25:08.069 --> 00:25:15.025
<v Brandon Brown>The program did not fit within that org, so we moved on and became our own 501 in 2023.

202
00:25:16.463 --> 00:25:29.820
<v Brandon Brown>As of May 1st, 2025, Restorative Roots Project has been referred and represented an estimated total of 612 months of prison time saved, which would have cost the state $3.2 million.

203
00:25:30.892 --> 00:25:35.503
<v Brandon Brown>This is based on 10 cases in our SAP program and 2 community referrals.

204
00:25:37.634 --> 00:25:43.931
<v Brandon Brown>These charges ranged from Measure 11 person-to-person violent offenses to minor theft and family disputes.

205
00:25:44.596 --> 00:25:51.328
<v Brandon Brown>Our SAP program has had 100% success rate with zero reoffenders and zero cases returned.

206
00:25:52.179 --> 00:26:02.671
<v Brandon Brown>This has resulted in housing assistance, bill assistance, job placement, schooling, 4 years of sobriety, and most importantly, community restoration and healing.

207
00:26:03.521 --> 00:26:12.458
<v Brandon Brown>Our program has not been unsuccessful due to staffing and/or programs, but lack of partnership engagement.

208
00:26:13.132 --> 00:26:32.734
<v Brandon Brown>Our SAP program has not had a case referred to it since October of 2024, our program has seen 2 DA regimes since its implementation, one of those which asked us not to go public with our program, resulting in a lack of communication.

209
00:26:33.038 --> 00:26:50.950
<v Brandon Brown>Our quantitative data is low due to that lack of communication, which led to funding being cut and the loss of 3 staff members and the remaining members to work for free from the months of October 2025 to March of 2026.

210
00:26:52.648 --> 00:27:05.546
<v Brandon Brown>From the months— from the years 2022 to 2025, our partnership did work together to come up with the best ways for referral pathways.

211
00:27:06.546 --> 00:27:12.694
<v Brandon Brown>Due to budgeting cuts, our partners have had less time to focus on our program, but efforts have been made.

212
00:27:13.573 --> 00:27:17.593
<v Brandon Brown>And cases should start flowing back into our program starting in July.

213
00:27:19.170 --> 00:27:30.722
<v Brandon Brown>Most recently, Restorative Roots Project, along with Lutheran Community Services and Brown Hope, have been putting in efforts to get the county to help recognize community-based restorative justice.

214
00:27:31.461 --> 00:27:41.931
<v Brandon Brown>And the results of that is the community putting together a focus group to start finding more ways to help build pathways for community-based restorative justice.

215
00:27:41.996 --> 00:27:42.094
<v Brandon Brown>Thank you.

216
00:27:44.211 --> 00:27:48.151
<v Brandon Brown>Um, these are just minor steps that we have taken.

217
00:27:49.217 --> 00:27:58.471
<v Brandon Brown>We now need a hand and a help, a push to keep us going forward, and more support within our community to help build out community-based restorative justice.

218
00:27:59.569 --> 00:27:59.958
<v Brandon Brown>Thank you.

219
00:28:01.978 --> 00:28:03.061
<v Cameron Hayes>Uh, hello, councilors.

220
00:28:03.125 --> 00:28:04.598
<v Cameron Hayes>My name is Cameron Hayes.

221
00:28:04.663 --> 00:28:06.135
<v Cameron Hayes>I'm the director of Regroup.

222
00:28:06.346 --> 00:28:08.838
<v Cameron Hayes>We are a reentry mutual aid support network.

223
00:28:09.757 --> 00:28:09.853
<v Cameron Hayes>Thank you.

224
00:28:09.997 --> 00:28:21.871
<v Cameron Hayes>And, um, our focus is really building community among returning citizens because most re-entry organizations are really good at that day one support and getting folks on their feet.

225
00:28:22.432 --> 00:28:26.823
<v Cameron Hayes>But as folks with lived experience, we know that that is not always enough.

226
00:28:27.624 --> 00:28:46.682
<v Cameron Hayes>And so in 2025, Regroup secured a pilot grant from the CJC to do a community needs assessment and see what the thoughts were on utilizing, uh, returning citizens and those with lived experience to do conflict mediation and restorative justice processes in the community.

227
00:28:47.419 --> 00:28:50.000
<v Cameron Hayes>And there was almost universal support.

228
00:28:50.961 --> 00:29:10.230
<v Cameron Hayes>We have been operational now for 3 months and have 6 cases, and it's been really cool to see a desire for accountability and healing come from community, because as we know, when folks are released from prison, they have a higher statistic for reoffending but also being victimized.

229
00:29:10.839 --> 00:29:17.406
<v Cameron Hayes>And so this is also a population that is unlikely to trust traditional public safety methods.

230
00:29:17.921 --> 00:29:20.826
<v Cameron Hayes>And so it's been really cool to step in and fill that gap.

231
00:29:21.373 --> 00:29:26.575
<v Cameron Hayes>This is Jerome, our restorative justice director, and I'll let him take over.

232
00:29:26.688 --> 00:29:28.481
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, I'm, uh, hello, councilors.

233
00:29:28.578 --> 00:29:32.200
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm Jerome Sloan, uh, Restorative Justice Director for Regroup.

234
00:29:32.825 --> 00:29:49.442
<v Sameer Kanal>And, um, he basically said a lot about our program, but the thing that I think, um, separates us is that we have lived experience, and the people that we talk to don't necessarily feel comfortable talking with authority figures like police, anything like that.

235
00:29:49.507 --> 00:30:00.164
<v Sameer Kanal>So we fit a little niche where My clients, they're willing to talk to me in a certain group, but this problem probably wouldn't be resolved if they had to deal with a higher authority figure.

236
00:30:01.119 --> 00:30:02.334
<v Manny Guerra>And that's what I've seen for it.

237
00:30:04.731 --> 00:30:06.290
<v Manny Guerra>Yeah, Regroup has did it.

238
00:30:06.338 --> 00:30:13.585
<v Sameer Kanal>We got 6 now and we're moving along strong and I'm happy about it.

239
00:30:13.634 --> 00:30:16.530
<v Manny Guerra>I know that's not about this, but I'm happy about where we've come, but we need help.

240
00:30:16.761 --> 00:30:16.943
<v Michael>So.

241
00:30:18.708 --> 00:30:25.271
<v Tristan Edwards>One thing that I would just add about Regroup, in case it's not clear from the conversation, is that the referral partner is not a system referral.

242
00:30:26.106 --> 00:30:39.557
<v Tristan Edwards>Because of Jerome and Cameron's unique position within the community as trusted figures, as credible messengers, people with lived experience, they are really uniquely positioned to get direct referrals from people who are impacted.

243
00:30:39.910 --> 00:30:41.467
<v Tristan Edwards>We call that a community referral.

244
00:30:42.317 --> 00:30:51.351
<v Tristan Edwards>And I think it really goes to address kind of exactly what Cam and Jerome were talking about, which is kind of this gap in our public safety system, which is cases that go unreported.

245
00:30:52.266 --> 00:30:56.885
<v Tristan Edwards>And so they're catching cases that have never— that were never going to touch the police department in the first place.

246
00:30:57.544 --> 00:31:10.232
<v Tristan Edwards>I would also just say that both Cam and Jerome, not only do they have lived experience in the prison system, but they also have lived experience in restorative justice through their own past experiences, which are incredibly inspiring.

247
00:31:10.297 --> 00:31:15.977
<v Tristan Edwards>We don't have time for here today, but I would encourage you to reach out to learn more about kind of their foundation.

248
00:31:18.413 --> 00:31:28.503
<v Tristan Edwards>Before we open it up for questions, I just wanted to kind of consolidate what really the needs are that Mindy, Brandon, Cameron, and Jerome have really already spoken to.

249
00:31:29.709 --> 00:31:41.246
<v Tristan Edwards>So from the sense of our system partners, it is so challenging to really shift the culture and the mindset towards restorative justice from our punishment system.

250
00:31:41.863 --> 00:31:43.145
<v Tristan Edwards>And that makes a lot of sense.

251
00:31:43.194 --> 00:31:44.445
<v Tristan Edwards>I think that thank you.

252
00:31:44.557 --> 00:31:51.131
<v Tristan Edwards>I think that, you know, as a general understanding in our society, we have learned to equate justice with punishment.

253
00:31:51.660 --> 00:31:54.416
<v Tristan Edwards>And there are a lot of ways to achieve justice.

254
00:31:54.545 --> 00:32:09.003
<v Tristan Edwards>And I know from being in courtrooms and hearing dissatisfaction from victims, from responsible parties, that there really is a need for more restorative justice and for different approaches to harm that are not just our carceral system.

255
00:32:10.270 --> 00:32:15.127
<v Tristan Edwards>That being said, some of these system partner relationships have really taken a lot of time.

256
00:32:16.089 --> 00:32:26.682
<v Tristan Edwards>And we're finding that we need support and help in holding our system partners accountable to utilizing these programs from our elected officials.

257
00:32:26.941 --> 00:32:38.038
<v Tristan Edwards>And so that's part of what we're asking here today is how City Council can help us with really trying to make these partnerships more fluid and to get referrals.

258
00:32:40.430 --> 00:32:40.722
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

259
00:32:40.951 --> 00:32:59.318
<v Tristan Edwards>I mean, Mindy, Brandon both spoke to the difficulties that we've had with getting referrals from and one thing I'll just say that is hopeful is that, you know, from talking to people who've gone through restorative justice processes, from looking at the results from these programs, this works.

260
00:33:00.363 --> 00:33:23.726
<v Tristan Edwards>The individual who was the responsible party in the case that I showed the video for, throughout the process of the restorative justice program, he went from being homeless for several years and having a criminal record and a mental illness diagnosis some pretty significant anger issues, to getting really important and intensive therapy, to getting his commercial driver's license, which led to him getting a full-time job.

261
00:33:24.111 --> 00:33:26.962
<v Tristan Edwards>And today he has his own stable apartment.

262
00:33:27.010 --> 00:33:28.500
<v Tristan Edwards>He's been employed for many years.

263
00:33:28.998 --> 00:33:40.727
<v Tristan Edwards>He's actually still in touch with the restorative justice program because those relationships were so important to him and is at a point of stability that is really something you don't typically see when people are going through the prison system.

264
00:33:40.855 --> 00:33:47.407
<v Tristan Edwards>And for the record, his case, he was looking at close to 6 years in prison, mandatory minimum on that case.

265
00:33:48.161 --> 00:33:59.311
<v Tristan Edwards>Instead, you know, didn't even engage in the criminal system, didn't get a conviction, and is in a place of being just much better positioned in the society and certainly offense-free.

266
00:34:00.577 --> 00:34:04.920
<v Tristan Edwards>The second and always most important thing that we need is funding.

267
00:34:05.769 --> 00:34:10.639
<v Tristan Edwards>There is a state grant that provides funding to restorative justice programs.

268
00:34:10.719 --> 00:34:18.699
<v Tristan Edwards>Specifically programs that avoid a conviction, which is what all of these programs do.

269
00:34:20.291 --> 00:34:23.978
<v Tristan Edwards>That state grant is always in different states of flux.

270
00:34:24.461 --> 00:34:28.309
<v Tristan Edwards>It was granted $4 million for the biennium in 2025.

271
00:34:28.567 --> 00:34:33.036
<v Tristan Edwards>We're now in the process of, you know, getting ready to make another ask in 2027.

272
00:34:33.405 --> 00:34:40.036
<v Tristan Edwards>We have great partnership with the Criminal Justice Commission and the executive branch, but of course the legislature is a whole other animal.

273
00:34:40.105 --> 00:34:40.208
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

274
00:34:40.893 --> 00:34:47.170
<v Tristan Edwards>But I guess the thing that I really want to underscore is that these— the system partner engagement and the funding really go hand in hand.

275
00:34:47.474 --> 00:35:09.934
<v Tristan Edwards>The lack of referrals that were going into the pre-arrest program, the juvenile program, and the adult restorative justice program in 2025 resulted in massive funding cuts for Lutheran Community Services Northwest and the Restorative Roots Project, where in the past they had received upwards of $700,000 from this committee.

276
00:35:10.173 --> 00:35:10.398
<v Tristan Edwards>Thank you.

277
00:35:10.576 --> 00:35:11.057
<v Tristan Edwards>Grant.

278
00:35:11.635 --> 00:35:19.556
<v Tristan Edwards>Last year they experienced massive cuts because there wasn't the ability to demonstrate that there were meaningful system referral pathways.

279
00:35:19.670 --> 00:35:36.748
<v Tristan Edwards>And so the city is missing out on really, really significant investment from the state because of this difficulty that we have with system partners getting referrals, you know, despite the fact that both of these programs have shown an immense amount of success when we can actually get cases in.

280
00:35:37.827 --> 00:35:38.485
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Tristan.

281
00:35:38.565 --> 00:35:46.373
<v Steve Novick>I actually, I was hoping to have the DA's office here today, but I heard this morning that they're not able to make it.

282
00:35:46.503 --> 00:35:47.838
<v Steve Novick>We do have Chief Day here.

283
00:35:48.596 --> 00:36:01.728
<v Steve Novick>And Councilor Rio, I know you've got— Vice Chair Rio, I know you've got your hand up, but I was wondering if you'd indulge me if I would ask Chief Day to come up and just have an exchange with— I'm sorry, is it Mindy from Lutheran Family Services?

284
00:36:01.777 --> 00:36:01.938
<v Earl Riley>Yes.

285
00:36:04.610 --> 00:36:10.916
<v Steve Novick>About, you know, what might be— how it could work better and what might be done to have more buy-in from the police.

286
00:36:13.099 --> 00:36:13.536
<v Steve Novick>That's what I'd like to do.

287
00:36:13.617 --> 00:36:15.969
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Murillo, go ahead with what you were going to ask or say.

288
00:36:20.373 --> 00:36:20.614
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

289
00:36:21.000 --> 00:36:22.655
<v Angelita Morillo>Do you— are you trying to do that now or after?

290
00:36:23.088 --> 00:36:34.485
<v Steve Novick>I just— you were the only person with your hand up, so I was going to like ask you to ask your question, but then I did want to bring Chief Day up to have an okay, well, first of all, I just want to say I'm so delighted that you guys are here.

291
00:36:34.998 --> 00:36:42.742
<v Angelita Morillo>We had Restorative Roots come to our— one of our community events where we were providing different community services, and it was so special to have you guys there.

292
00:36:43.737 --> 00:37:00.474
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think that in a country where we have one of the highest incarceration rates in the entire world, and yet we continue to see crime happen because people are impacted by issues that are not being touched on by the traditional criminal justice system, I think that that means we have to look at things like this.

293
00:37:00.586 --> 00:37:05.715
<v Angelita Morillo>So your work is incredibly valuable, and I'm just very grateful that you're here and we're having this hard conversation today.

294
00:37:06.900 --> 00:37:16.835
<v Angelita Morillo>I was curious, hearing for a few different things, the referral process, because I know it sounds like for Regroup, it's a community referral, correct?

295
00:37:17.715 --> 00:37:23.467
<v Angelita Morillo>But then for Lutheran Community Services, does the referral come from PPB or from somebody else?

296
00:37:23.516 --> 00:37:24.077
<v Angelita Morillo>It comes from PPB.

297
00:37:26.619 --> 00:37:31.284
<v Mindy Johnston>Yeah, so it depends on— based on those partnerships, it can come from a range.

298
00:37:31.396 --> 00:37:37.963
<v Mindy Johnston>So it could be a community-based referral through our victim advocates who work in culturally specific communities.

299
00:37:38.641 --> 00:37:46.760
<v Mindy Johnston>It can come from PPB, it comes from the Juvenile Department, it comes from the DA, and now we also have the PPS, the Portland Public Schools.

300
00:37:47.539 --> 00:37:52.682
<v Mindy Johnston>So we're pretty much anywhere referrals can come through, system or community.

301
00:37:52.780 --> 00:37:56.179
<v Mindy Johnston>And I'm curious, And I think you guys are the same, right?

302
00:37:56.371 --> 00:37:57.653
<v Mindy Johnston>You can— yeah.

303
00:37:58.824 --> 00:37:58.936
<v Tristan Edwards>Yeah.

304
00:37:59.065 --> 00:38:05.297
<v Tristan Edwards>One thing to mention is that with Lutheran Community Services Northwest, the DA relationship is specifically for juveniles.

305
00:38:05.635 --> 00:38:05.795
<v Mindy Johnston>Yes.

306
00:38:06.371 --> 00:38:06.693
<v Angelita Morillo>Gotcha.

307
00:38:06.789 --> 00:38:07.637
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, that's helpful.

308
00:38:08.518 --> 00:38:28.539
<v Angelita Morillo>And for anyone who wants to answer this, what are some of the things that you look for, or what are the— I'm assuming it's less like metrics-based and more general, but what are some of the things that you look for in a person to say, okay, this person should probably go through a restorative justice process and not through the traditional model of accountability?

309
00:38:29.918 --> 00:38:31.744
<v Tristan Edwards>So I can take that one.

310
00:38:32.322 --> 00:38:41.605
<v Tristan Edwards>As the defense representative with the Restorative Roots Project, a lot of my role when we were getting cases was to assess folks to see if they were suitable for the restorative justice program.

311
00:38:42.518 --> 00:38:51.994
<v Tristan Edwards>One thing I'll mention is data has shown that restorative justice is most effective in instances where there is a threat of harm or there has been some sort of serious harm.

312
00:38:52.378 --> 00:38:55.713
<v Tristan Edwards>And that's because we view it through the lens of the impact on the harmed party.

313
00:38:56.628 --> 00:39:00.797
<v Tristan Edwards>If somebody steals your wallet, you just kind of want your wallet back.

314
00:39:01.438 --> 00:39:14.539
<v Tristan Edwards>But if someone has burglarized your home or has threatened you in some way, it means a lot more to go through a process of accountability and hear that that person has really taken it seriously in understanding the impacts and trying to reform.

315
00:39:15.293 --> 00:39:16.768
<v Tristan Edwards>So that's why the restorative roots thank you.

316
00:39:16.815 --> 00:39:20.327
<v Tristan Edwards>So the Restorative Roots Project started with focusing on violent felony offenses.

317
00:39:21.159 --> 00:39:29.175
<v Tristan Edwards>And when I would meet with clients, what I would look for is one, an acknowledgment that they participated in whatever harm occurred.

318
00:39:30.554 --> 00:39:35.554
<v Tristan Edwards>It wasn't necessarily that they needed to be in a full, perfect state of remorse.

319
00:39:36.213 --> 00:39:42.208
<v Tristan Edwards>A lot of the restorative roots or the restorative justice process is about helping people come to that place of accountability.

320
00:39:42.480 --> 00:40:11.485
<v Tristan Edwards>But they at least needed to acknowledge that they had involvement, that there was something to be accountable for, that they could have and then from there, it's really just a willingness, an ability to be able to engage with a program that is rather intensive, and an understanding that they will need to be available, and that they will need to be reachable, and that they need to be showing up for appointments and meetings, and that this is going to take as long as it needs to.

321
00:40:12.496 --> 00:40:16.777
<v Tristan Edwards>A lot of folks come with substance use, mental health issues, housing issues, and so it's a process.

322
00:40:17.215 --> 00:40:38.931
<v Tristan Edwards>And I've actually really been impressed by the way that the Restorative Roots Project has been able to hold those things and really encourage that engagement, which I think is helpful because it comes from this place of mutual respect and relationship, as opposed to kind of a threat of punishment if you don't engage, which is something that we see, you know, when, like, in your classic pretrial release or probation relationships.

323
00:40:39.509 --> 00:40:46.164
<v Tristan Edwards>And then lastly, a willingness to try and pay restitution if there is restitution to be owed in that case.

324
00:40:46.244 --> 00:40:46.356
<v Tristan Edwards>Thank you.

325
00:40:47.447 --> 00:40:54.893
<v Tristan Edwards>On the other end, harmed parties for the Restorative Roots Project need to at least agree that the case can go into restorative justice.

326
00:40:55.648 --> 00:41:04.009
<v Tristan Edwards>They are never required to participate if that is not what feels good to them or what they think is going to be necessary for their healing.

327
00:41:04.072 --> 00:41:10.539
<v Tristan Edwards>Some people say, I want to engage completely, I want to sit in circle with this person and have a true full accountability process.

328
00:41:11.134 --> 00:41:17.987
<v Tristan Edwards>Some people say, I think that this is a great thing for this person who harmed me to go through, but it's not something that I want to participate in.

329
00:41:18.420 --> 00:41:21.309
<v Tristan Edwards>Maybe I want to receive a letter at the end saying how it went.

330
00:41:22.592 --> 00:41:23.251
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Tristan.

331
00:41:23.396 --> 00:41:30.987
<v Steve Novick>Um, I would like to— to me, an important part of this is I do want to see Chief Day engage, and it would be—.

332
00:41:31.036 --> 00:41:33.090
<v Angelita Morillo>Can I get through my question with the panel first though?

333
00:41:33.266 --> 00:41:36.893
<v Steve Novick>Um, well, we're kind of, we're kind of running out of time.

334
00:41:37.119 --> 00:41:38.626
<v Angelita Morillo>But I get to talk to Chief Day all the time.

335
00:41:38.724 --> 00:41:47.469
<v Steve Novick>I don't get to talk to these well, but the issue here is having Chief Day engage with Mindy and give her an opportunity to say how she thinks the relationships could work and see him respond.

336
00:41:48.489 --> 00:41:53.869
<v Steve Novick>So I apologize, but I would really like to see that kind of engagement.

337
00:41:53.869 --> 00:41:54.289
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

338
00:41:54.289 --> 00:41:57.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>Was Chief Day informed that he was going to be a speaker for this topic today?

339
00:41:57.489 --> 00:41:58.170
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

340
00:41:58.170 --> 00:41:58.510
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

341
00:41:58.510 --> 00:41:59.090
<v Steve Novick>He was.

342
00:41:59.090 --> 00:42:00.130
<v Steve Novick>That's why I asked him here.

343
00:42:00.710 --> 00:42:05.059
<v Eric Zimmerman>On the materials that came with this, not a presentation, not a list of presenters.

344
00:42:05.670 --> 00:42:07.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>So just be clear what we're doing here.

345
00:42:08.856 --> 00:42:13.054
<v Steve Novick>And actually, could I ask one of the panel members other than Mindy to step back so Chief Day could come up?

346
00:42:15.233 --> 00:42:17.925
<v Cameron Hayes>I'll step back.

347
00:42:18.217 --> 00:42:19.905
<v Robert Taylor>Good morning.

348
00:42:20.278 --> 00:42:20.797
<v Bob Day>Good, thank you.

349
00:42:20.911 --> 00:42:21.447
<v Michael>Good to see you.

350
00:42:22.311 --> 00:42:29.717
<v Steve Novick>So just, I mean, we need to keep this short, but Mindy, I just want to give you a chance to tell Chief Day how you would hope the relationship would work and give him a chance to respond.

351
00:42:30.440 --> 00:42:34.753
<v Mindy Johnston>Yeah, I just want to acknowledge that Chief Day has been supportive from the get-go.

352
00:42:35.315 --> 00:42:38.621
<v Mindy Johnston>And I think it is a systems implementation issue.

353
00:42:39.407 --> 00:42:51.327
<v Mindy Johnston>So I think for us, our realization over time, which I already mentioned, is how can we get this systematized so that it's not necessarily in individual officers' hands?

354
00:42:52.563 --> 00:42:58.385
<v Mindy Johnston>We do— there's a new app that the PPB has created specifically for restorative justice referrals.

355
00:42:59.043 --> 00:42:59.380
<v Mindy Johnston>Thank you.

356
00:42:59.766 --> 00:43:01.644
<v Mindy Johnston>What we need is how do we push that out?

357
00:43:01.708 --> 00:43:04.487
<v Mindy Johnston>How do we train folks to use it?

358
00:43:04.985 --> 00:43:15.871
<v Mindy Johnston>And also what we've seen, as I mentioned in the DA referral cases, is getting the system partners out of it and letting us talk to people about it.

359
00:43:16.385 --> 00:43:23.739
<v Mindy Johnston>There's a gray zone between even some of those pre-adjudicated youth cases that could have been referred from police.

360
00:43:25.356 --> 00:43:31.489
<v Mindy Johnston>Officers are looking at what they can arrest or charge for and doing their job.

361
00:43:31.909 --> 00:43:37.454
<v Mindy Johnston>And so we need to be creative in how we make it easy for them to send referrals.

362
00:43:38.775 --> 00:43:50.304
<v Mindy Johnston>And I think we need that, you know, the leadership explicitly encouraging, and we've avoided the mandating 'cause we know that's not gonna work.

363
00:43:51.175 --> 00:43:54.835
<v Mindy Johnston>But we need other creative ways to get the engagement.

364
00:43:56.539 --> 00:43:56.829
<v Bob Day>Yeah, thank you.

365
00:43:57.054 --> 00:43:58.344
<v Bob Day>Yeah, good morning, Councilor.

366
00:43:58.987 --> 00:44:00.211
<v Bob Day>Bob Day, Chief of Police.

367
00:44:00.501 --> 00:44:02.144
<v Bob Day>And first of all, just hats off.

368
00:44:02.210 --> 00:44:05.271
<v Bob Day>Thanks for sharing, everybody here at the table, for the good work.

369
00:44:05.699 --> 00:44:07.715
<v Bob Day>A core value of mine is redemption.

370
00:44:07.974 --> 00:44:17.590
<v Bob Day>I believe in the ability to redeem, and relying upon the criminal justice system or incarceration to do that, I don't believe is the only answer.

371
00:44:17.657 --> 00:44:19.251
<v Bob Day>I think that you know, the steps you're taking.

372
00:44:19.300 --> 00:44:20.807
<v Bob Day>So just thank you very much for that.

373
00:44:21.753 --> 00:44:25.264
<v Bob Day>And also thank you for the work Mindy and others have done.

374
00:44:25.601 --> 00:44:32.690
<v Bob Day>And so a couple things I want to highlight, and none of these are meant to be excuses, and I'll have a couple of practical solutions.

375
00:44:32.753 --> 00:44:40.097
<v Bob Day>But the Police Bureau was a leader in this conversation back in '19 and in '18, '19, '20 when we had our school resource officers.

376
00:44:40.916 --> 00:44:46.751
<v Bob Day>We did have a robust effort to try and bring in restorative justice into the police bureau.

377
00:44:47.730 --> 00:44:55.135
<v Bob Day>One of the failures since that— after that program was abolished is we haven't had anybody internally that's really owned it and shepherded it.

378
00:44:55.182 --> 00:45:01.371
<v Bob Day>So that's an awareness piece that I've learned and become more attuned to.

379
00:45:01.916 --> 00:45:04.159
<v Bob Day>I agree 100% that it's a systems issue.

380
00:45:04.431 --> 00:45:10.347
<v Bob Day>I don't believe it's a matter of officers don't care or aren't engaged.

381
00:45:10.411 --> 00:45:20.652
<v Bob Day>It just is lack of the bureau putting in clarity for them to be able to find those lanes to move forward in the demands of the day and the multitude of things that officers are faced with.

382
00:45:20.989 --> 00:45:27.800
<v Bob Day>You know, getting this to rise to the top of the pile for reflection, for time, for commitment, and so forth is a challenge.

383
00:45:28.282 --> 00:45:30.541
<v Bob Day>As mentioned, we did create the app.

384
00:45:31.487 --> 00:45:39.532
<v Bob Day>So a couple things that I just want to highlight going forward, some things that we're looking at is, you know, once again being able to reinforce.

385
00:45:39.597 --> 00:45:46.423
<v Bob Day>And I agree, I don't know that— I don't believe that at this point mandate is the appropriate approach, um, for forcing the issue.

386
00:45:46.969 --> 00:46:02.880
<v Bob Day>But looking at a variety of things, uh, both in our relationship with the DA's office, looking for more pathways between the two of us and seeing, um, them come on board and be more involved, hopefully we can sort of hold each other accountable to making sure that we're identifying the right cases.

387
00:46:03.456 --> 00:46:14.304
<v Bob Day>And I'll be asking when cases are identified by the DA's office why they weren't identified by us and where some of the gaps So that's been a significant improvement in the partnership.

388
00:46:14.865 --> 00:46:23.655
<v Bob Day>We're also looking at, you know, the potential of can we expand this into other areas besides just in the traditional patrol response.

389
00:46:23.766 --> 00:46:33.295
<v Bob Day>We obviously touch community in a variety of different ways, both whether it be in public order events and other types of situations besides just a 911 call.

390
00:46:33.360 --> 00:46:35.063
<v Bob Day>So there might be space there.

391
00:46:35.737 --> 00:46:49.657
<v Bob Day>I will say that, you know, for a longstanding history in the police bureau, juvenile cases are tough to navigate in general, just the understanding of the process they go through and so forth.

392
00:46:49.721 --> 00:46:59.402
<v Bob Day>So I think organizationally we can do a better job of helping them understand and see the role that specific— that Lutheran Family Services plays around juveniles.

393
00:46:59.739 --> 00:47:03.929
<v Bob Day>If I'm not mistaken, that's really the the bread and butter of what we're talking about.

394
00:47:04.411 --> 00:47:10.043
<v Bob Day>So I do think that there are areas where we have— I do recognize there are areas where we have not been as efficient.

395
00:47:10.108 --> 00:47:10.750
<v Bob Day>We've dropped the ball.

396
00:47:11.311 --> 00:47:14.313
<v Bob Day>And finally, this is something that I believe in.

397
00:47:14.505 --> 00:47:17.362
<v Bob Day>It's just a matter of we've had people come and go and retire.

398
00:47:17.635 --> 00:47:18.550
<v Bob Day>We just haven't had ownership.

399
00:47:18.695 --> 00:47:20.780
<v Bob Day>And so I'm going to try and bring some of that ownership.

400
00:47:20.844 --> 00:47:26.012
<v Bob Day>Councilor Novick, you surfacing this, bringing this to the table today, I'm encouraged in what I've heard.

401
00:47:26.077 --> 00:47:30.458
<v Bob Day>So I'm going to have to go back and do some work to find some ownership to increase those referrals.

402
00:47:30.507 --> 00:47:30.764
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

403
00:47:32.056 --> 00:47:32.802
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Chief.

404
00:47:33.012 --> 00:47:39.235
<v Steve Novick>And Councilor Maria, we'll circle back to you, but I just wanted to give Councilor Zimmerman and Councilor Smith a chance to ask their questions.

405
00:47:40.900 --> 00:47:41.617
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you.

406
00:47:45.536 --> 00:47:54.570
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, this makes a lot of sense for me when I'm, when I'm talking about youth offenses, right?

407
00:47:54.635 --> 00:47:57.646
<v Eric Zimmerman>As somebody who coached high school, like, this is just part of working with youth.

408
00:47:58.041 --> 00:47:58.137
<v Brandon Brown>Right.

409
00:47:58.202 --> 00:48:01.119
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that makes a ton of sense to me.

410
00:48:02.353 --> 00:48:09.163
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, it gets harder for me when we're not clear about what types of crimes for adults.

411
00:48:10.204 --> 00:48:16.838
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and I'm trying to understand how to marry these 2 things up because I don't think it can be an all or nothing.

412
00:48:17.831 --> 00:48:23.264
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so when we're talking about, uh, there are a few quotes that just got me, got me thinking.

413
00:48:23.329 --> 00:48:29.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's like the relationship needs repair, but it left something to be desired.

414
00:48:29.510 --> 00:48:38.389
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's like, but also there was a crime committed against someone, and sometimes there is no relationship there other than a random act of violence or what have you.

415
00:48:39.014 --> 00:48:44.442
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in a victim's perspective, I don't need a relationship repaired with somebody I don't know necessarily.

416
00:48:44.956 --> 00:49:01.697
<v Eric Zimmerman>There are times when I think that that video showed a really interesting experience, but I'm just trying to get a sense for, particularly with adults, what are the types of crimes or offenses or situations where this wouldn't be appropriate?

417
00:49:01.940 --> 00:49:04.222
<v Eric Zimmerman>It might be— maybe that's a shorter list, maybe that's a longer list.

418
00:49:04.269 --> 00:49:05.047
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm actually not sure.

419
00:49:05.434 --> 00:49:07.070
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm curious what your gut—.

420
00:49:07.182 --> 00:49:08.170
<v Brandon Brown>I'm going to be honest.

421
00:49:08.679 --> 00:49:14.217
<v Brandon Brown>Um, yeah, so restorative justice work gets done all over the nation, not just here in Oregon.

422
00:49:15.300 --> 00:49:18.117
<v Brandon Brown>And this has worked in murder cases.

423
00:49:19.023 --> 00:49:24.735
<v Brandon Brown>There's not one type of case that you can't see restorative justice come across where it does not work.

424
00:49:26.697 --> 00:49:32.954
<v Brandon Brown>It works everywhere, and it could work in all of the systems that we have implemented already.

425
00:49:34.376 --> 00:49:43.161
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that, that tells me then it's important not to take statements like avoiding charges is not— that, that is not a prelude to restorative justice.

426
00:49:43.259 --> 00:49:48.561
<v Eric Zimmerman>It means that that can happen later after charges have occurred, after sentences have occurred.

427
00:49:48.737 --> 00:49:50.134
<v Eric Zimmerman>There are other aspects here.

428
00:49:50.405 --> 00:49:51.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know you were raising your hand.

429
00:49:51.432 --> 00:49:51.833
<v Eric Zimmerman>Please go ahead.

430
00:49:51.929 --> 00:49:52.876
<v Cameron Hayes>Uh, yes, please.

431
00:49:53.324 --> 00:50:02.818
<v Cameron Hayes>So one of the number one things almost universally you'll hear victims say as one of their top priorities is to make sure this doesn't happen to anybody else.

432
00:50:03.476 --> 00:50:08.367
<v Cameron Hayes>And the thing is, is that incarceration, um, doesn't provide that, right?

433
00:50:08.447 --> 00:50:20.574
<v Cameron Hayes>It provides, um, a maybe a one definition accountability, but true accountability means internalizing the harm and living amends by, number one, not reoffending, right?

434
00:50:21.137 --> 00:50:26.085
<v Cameron Hayes>And so with everybody, I would say it's not necessarily the crime but the person, right?

435
00:50:26.134 --> 00:50:36.867
<v Cameron Hayes>If we look at people as a bell curve, you're gonna have this one portion over here that's just never gonna change, this portion that's gonna change no matter what, but this great majority of people need some help, right?

436
00:50:36.981 --> 00:50:42.487
<v Cameron Hayes>They need a process to internalize the harm and, and help along those ways.

437
00:50:42.985 --> 00:50:56.730
<v Cameron Hayes>And so I think as practitioners, we believe that the incarceration just causes more harm, and restorative justice at least has this major potential to bring healing to more or less degree.

438
00:50:57.052 --> 00:51:01.322
<v Cameron Hayes>And so that's why we as practitioners believe restorative justice is the best way to go.

439
00:51:01.949 --> 00:51:02.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's really helpful.

440
00:51:03.215 --> 00:51:06.326
<v Mindy Johnston>And I would like to add one more thing.

441
00:51:06.438 --> 00:51:14.643
<v Mindy Johnston>So we've also had cases where the survivor doesn't want it to go through the criminal justice system.

442
00:51:14.771 --> 00:51:16.646
<v Mindy Johnston>They still wanna see something happen.

443
00:51:17.335 --> 00:51:23.235
<v Mindy Johnston>They don't actually wanna engage, but they wanna see the responsible party be accountable.

444
00:51:23.362 --> 00:51:26.760
<v Mindy Johnston>So we've also used what we call surrogate victims.

445
00:51:27.338 --> 00:51:38.146
<v Mindy Johnston>So other survivors who have had a similar type of crime can basically volunteer with us and they come and engage in that restorative process with the responsible party.

446
00:51:38.802 --> 00:51:43.119
<v Mindy Johnston>And we've seen that with car theft, hate crimes.

447
00:51:43.215 --> 00:51:55.711
<v Mindy Johnston>Like, we've had a lot of cases where a surrogate will actually step in and it has the same success and impact as if you engaged the direct survivor of that crime.

448
00:51:56.400 --> 00:52:00.360
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, that kind of goes to my next question.

449
00:52:01.023 --> 00:52:08.425
<v Eric Zimmerman>You had mentioned it's to, to make this more systemic, that it's not in the individual officer's hands to make a call.

450
00:52:08.701 --> 00:52:15.186
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the question that popped up when you say that was, what about the individual or the group of victims and their position?

451
00:52:16.572 --> 00:52:22.355
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because what if I as a victim just don't want to engage here?

452
00:52:22.485 --> 00:52:23.362
<v Mindy Johnston>Then you don't have to.

453
00:52:23.784 --> 00:52:24.418
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think that's the beauty.

454
00:52:24.467 --> 00:52:30.414
<v Mindy Johnston>I I think what we would all say is we know that not every case is going to be appropriate for restorative justice.

455
00:52:32.226 --> 00:52:40.572
<v Mindy Johnston>We also see a sort of paternalistic system that thinks it knows best for survivors, and people don't always want that system.

456
00:52:41.711 --> 00:52:46.806
<v Mindy Johnston>And so we're giving people a choice, and they absolutely have the choice to engage.

457
00:52:46.869 --> 00:52:53.079
<v Mindy Johnston>And if they say no, or if even a case starts with restorative justice and it's unsuccessful, it's gonna go back to the system.

458
00:52:53.128 --> 00:52:54.190
<v Mindy Johnston>It doesn't just disappear.

459
00:52:54.255 --> 00:52:54.483
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

460
00:52:54.619 --> 00:52:55.936
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a great point.

461
00:52:56.097 --> 00:52:58.041
<v Mindy Johnston>Yeah, it's still— there's still accountability.

462
00:52:58.105 --> 00:53:02.458
<v Mindy Johnston>There's still something that happened that is going to be dealt with.

463
00:53:02.907 --> 00:53:08.175
<v Mindy Johnston>But also, like, we see a lot— some of the cases, it's like, is this case actually just going to get dismissed anyway?

464
00:53:08.690 --> 00:53:10.489
<v Mindy Johnston>But we— there was still a harm that happened.

465
00:53:10.538 --> 00:53:17.990
<v Mindy Johnston>And that's why all of us have this continuum of service, whether it's in community or connected to the criminal justice system.

466
00:53:18.039 --> 00:53:22.492
<v Mindy Johnston>At any point, there is a a branch to go to restorative justice.

467
00:53:22.539 --> 00:53:27.143
<v Mindy Johnston>Not everyone's going to want it, but a lot of people will want it, but they don't know it's an option.

468
00:53:28.356 --> 00:53:34.367
<v Eric Zimmerman>And lastly, I think just, um, well, just 2 quick points.

469
00:53:34.416 --> 00:53:43.893
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think one concern that I have on, on this, given that the title of your organization has Lutheran in it, do I have to engage with a religious service to access this?

470
00:53:43.940 --> 00:53:46.226
<v Mindy Johnston>No, we're a nonprofit just like the YMCA, YWCA.

471
00:53:46.452 --> 00:53:48.135
<v Eric Zimmerman>Well, there's a lot of nonprofits who have yeah.

472
00:53:48.215 --> 00:53:49.724
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are related to religious services.

473
00:53:49.788 --> 00:54:02.103
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just, for my engagement in a criminal justice system to be reliant on my engagement with a religious system, that does raise a couple of just like, does that make sense concerns?

474
00:54:02.809 --> 00:54:06.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>I offer it not, there's probably no fix in the room here.

475
00:54:06.432 --> 00:54:09.447
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just say that that's one of those like, let me think about that a little bit.

476
00:54:09.704 --> 00:54:11.052
<v Mindy Johnston>Yeah, we're a nonprofit.

477
00:54:11.164 --> 00:54:21.085
<v Mindy Johnston>It has faith-based roots, but we're a nonprofit that is, You know, serves everybody regardless of all the, you know, special class privileges.

478
00:54:21.262 --> 00:54:24.603
<v Mindy Johnston>And it is, you know, we know people sometimes will say, I'm not Lutheran.

479
00:54:24.715 --> 00:54:25.775
<v Mindy Johnston>It's like, we don't— it's okay.

480
00:54:26.177 --> 00:54:27.398
<v Mindy Johnston>You don't have to be Lutheran.

481
00:54:27.461 --> 00:54:31.429
<v Eric Zimmerman>The balance between, the balance between, I think, is the hard part here, right?

482
00:54:31.478 --> 00:54:36.554
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that often we think about this, we think, what are the types of crimes that make sense?

483
00:54:36.697 --> 00:54:38.481
<v Eric Zimmerman>What are the types of situations that make sense?

484
00:54:38.545 --> 00:54:45.282
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's the great balance that I've certainly not, when I was at the county or over here at the city, quite figured out.

485
00:54:45.347 --> 00:55:00.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that, um, you know, the last DA talked a lot about it and then kind of got walloped by the public in his reelection because it felt like things weren't— the, the most— the lower-level crimes weren't being dealt with in a way.

486
00:55:00.358 --> 00:55:02.891
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it was, is this the— is this the reason?

487
00:55:02.938 --> 00:55:03.436
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is this not?

488
00:55:03.548 --> 00:55:04.222
<v Eric Zimmerman>How do you do both?

489
00:55:04.351 --> 00:55:13.351
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate that you said that if a person chooses not to engage with the restorative justice, that the charge still exists, the, the, the regular system still exists.

490
00:55:13.494 --> 00:55:13.574
<v Loretta Smith>I—.

491
00:55:14.217 --> 00:55:20.362
<v Eric Zimmerman>This balance is going to be the great balance for all chiefs and all sheriffs and all DAs and judges, frankly, going forward.

492
00:55:20.956 --> 00:55:21.918
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, thanks for that.

493
00:55:22.014 --> 00:55:23.121
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate kind of hearing this.

494
00:55:23.282 --> 00:55:28.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it will be a struggle because it, it doesn't seem like one way or the other is the answer at all.

495
00:55:28.335 --> 00:55:34.947
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we probably did decades of one way, but then maybe 4 years of trying it the other way, and that also kind of rebounded in a, in a funny way.

496
00:55:35.027 --> 00:55:36.351
<v Brandon Brown>So thanks.

497
00:55:36.739 --> 00:55:37.351
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

498
00:55:37.400 --> 00:55:38.012
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

499
00:55:40.367 --> 00:55:40.963
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr.

500
00:55:41.012 --> 00:55:41.221
<v Loretta Smith>Chair.

501
00:55:41.818 --> 00:55:42.768
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you all for the presentation.

502
00:55:44.675 --> 00:55:54.233
<v Loretta Smith>Um, just so that I'm, I'm caught up on everything, normally don't we generally have an RFP for this kind of work that we put into bureaus?

503
00:55:55.153 --> 00:56:04.273
<v Loretta Smith>I, I was thinking, um, as I was listening to this, is this a part of Stephanie Howard's no, it's not.

504
00:56:04.322 --> 00:56:10.186
<v Mindy Johnston>So we're all funded through the state grant through the Criminal Justice Commission, the Restorative Justice Grant.

505
00:56:10.474 --> 00:56:10.715
<v Mindy Johnston>Okay.

506
00:56:10.795 --> 00:56:16.755
<v Mindy Johnston>And then we have a tiny— Justice Forward has a little bit of money from Multnomah County Juvenile Services Division.

507
00:56:17.284 --> 00:56:24.445
<v Mindy Johnston>So I think that's part of the point Tristan was making is as a city, there's no money being put into this right now.

508
00:56:25.375 --> 00:56:29.476
<v Mindy Johnston>There's some, a tiny bit under $100,000 of county money.

509
00:56:30.023 --> 00:56:40.539
<v Mindy Johnston>And otherwise, this is all state money, and we've tried to get some engagement with the Office of Violence Prevention, and we have not been successful at that.

510
00:56:40.701 --> 00:56:41.574
<v Mindy Johnston>But it makes sense.

511
00:56:41.898 --> 00:57:05.875
<v Loretta Smith>I think that would be— Chief, that would be an opportunity where we probably want to start this, because I think the impression that, that is given through this presentation is that we're doing— we're not doing something that we're supposed to be doing, but we generally don't do it until we actually have RFPs and have set up stuff.

512
00:57:06.356 --> 00:57:09.481
<v Loretta Smith>And that's why I was wondering where this was coming from.

513
00:57:09.802 --> 00:57:11.117
<v Mindy Johnston>Yeah, we all have MOUs.

514
00:57:11.806 --> 00:57:15.125
<v Mindy Johnston>So I think, you know, there's, there's 2 pieces.

515
00:57:15.172 --> 00:57:16.518
<v Mindy Johnston>There's a funding piece.

516
00:57:16.871 --> 00:57:18.684
<v Mindy Johnston>You need the funding to get the work going.

517
00:57:18.795 --> 00:57:23.940
<v Mindy Johnston>But what you actually need is MOUs and agreements with systems partners, which we have.

518
00:57:24.150 --> 00:57:30.226
<v Mindy Johnston>All the people working with systems partners have those official MOUs and benefit from—.

519
00:57:30.516 --> 00:57:33.014
<v Loretta Smith>And you have one with the chief?

520
00:57:33.096 --> 00:57:33.224
<v Mindy Johnston>Yes.

521
00:57:33.579 --> 00:57:34.416
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, perfect.

522
00:57:36.179 --> 00:57:48.576
<v Loretta Smith>In a— if you had a magic wand to wave around, what would be your first thing that you would want us to engage with you with?

523
00:57:49.206 --> 00:58:07.530
<v Tristan Edwards>I think if I had a magic wand, I would want every survivor and I think another piece of it, more kind of more practically in terms of what can the City Council do, is to continue to follow up on these relationships.

524
00:58:08.150 --> 00:58:18.699
<v Tristan Edwards>I think in particular, the relationship between Lutheran and Portland Police Bureau because of the relationship with the city, to check in and to see how is the development going?

525
00:58:18.889 --> 00:58:20.429
<v Tristan Edwards>Have there been advances made?

526
00:58:20.429 --> 00:58:20.650
<v Edith Thrower>And I think that's something that we can continue to do.

527
00:58:20.974 --> 00:58:30.840
<v Tristan Edwards>The relationship has existed for 4 years, close to 4 years, and there have been continuing struggles to get a consistent stream of referrals into the program.

528
00:58:31.097 --> 00:58:36.012
<v Tristan Edwards>And so I think— and the same goes for partnerships with the District Attorney's Office.

529
00:58:36.077 --> 00:58:46.329
<v Tristan Edwards>And I think what we are seeing is that it needs more support and accountability and oversight from our local government.

530
00:58:48.128 --> 00:58:57.601
<v Tristan Edwards>And when we stand up and say that there are restorative justices available in Portland, that means something real.

531
00:58:58.242 --> 00:59:09.724
<v Loretta Smith>And so I think a better— I think that's great, we can do that as well, but we no longer are responsible for bureaus anymore, and the police bureau is under the mayor's office and the city administrator.

532
00:59:10.349 --> 00:59:12.068
<v Loretta Smith>And so that relationship that you're talking about, I think, is important.

533
00:59:11.940 --> 00:59:19.936
<v Loretta Smith>Talking about, I think it's going to have to come first with those 2 parties first to see what that looks like.

534
00:59:20.063 --> 00:59:25.603
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm not sure what the MOU says or what, what the requirement— I'm behind the 8-ball on this.

535
00:59:26.438 --> 00:59:40.271
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not sure what the, what the MOU says in terms of what our relationship will be, if there's a guaranteed number of how many referrals are done a month, or if there's a guaranteed number of how much money that we're going to put into it, because we're the money side of it.

536
00:59:41.835 --> 00:59:43.655
<v Loretta Smith>They have to be the one that implement it.

537
00:59:43.702 --> 00:59:46.425
<v Loretta Smith>We don't get to tell them what to do anymore.

538
00:59:47.713 --> 00:59:50.365
<v Loretta Smith>So, so that's why I'm trying to figure out the connection.

539
00:59:50.429 --> 01:00:11.130
<v Loretta Smith>But I do understand what you're saying, because I think that restorative justice is necessary and it's needed, and it is really helpful in terms of making sure that folks, when they re-enter the community, that they have opportunities to not just survive, but they can thrive in a community that is welcoming and that has opportunities for them too.

540
01:00:11.628 --> 01:00:13.717
<v Loretta Smith>So that is, that is where I sit.

541
01:00:13.797 --> 01:00:16.208
<v Loretta Smith>That's why I do the summer jobs program.

542
01:00:16.271 --> 01:00:28.034
<v Loretta Smith>That's why I try to do the apprenticeship program so that folks can get placed in these kinds of things where they can get living wage jobs and, and have those relationships.

543
01:00:28.083 --> 01:00:47.905
<v Loretta Smith>So I think we We do play a part in trying to make sure relationships are going, but at the end of the day, I just want you to know that I think the MOU is where you start and getting some of that language in there that makes sense so you can have a definite number.

544
01:00:49.108 --> 01:00:52.480
<v Loretta Smith>And it's not as— it seems like it's a voluntary thing right now.

545
01:00:53.539 --> 01:01:02.219
<v Tristan Edwards>Well, I mean, part of part of the issue that we've had is that we've had memorandums of understanding with DA's office, with Portland Police Bureau for many years.

546
01:01:02.413 --> 01:01:11.288
<v Tristan Edwards>And we've learned that having signatures on a piece of paper simply isn't sufficient to making these referrals come through in a way that is meaningful.

547
01:01:12.429 --> 01:01:12.543
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

548
01:01:12.625 --> 01:01:18.153
<v Tristan Edwards>One thing that I'll offer, similar conversations have been happening on the county side during their budgeting process.

549
01:01:18.807 --> 01:01:38.949
<v Tristan Edwards>And the county did end up passing a budget note with $250,000 of contingency funding, which is associated with a workgroup that they're developing to examine these relationships and try to, you know, have the county play a role in figuring out how do we get referrals into these programs.

550
01:01:38.998 --> 01:01:39.045
<v Bob Day>Right.

551
01:01:39.318 --> 01:01:54.958
<v Tristan Edwards>And I think any support that we can have from the county, from the city, in terms of, you know, asking questions and also being involved in making sure that these system relationships are real relationships where they're functioning is going to be helpful.

552
01:01:55.536 --> 01:01:56.338
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, I think so.

553
01:01:57.126 --> 01:02:05.170
<v Loretta Smith>And going forward, because we just approved all of our amendments and budgets, budget notes last week, which are gonna be ratified this week.

554
01:02:05.876 --> 01:02:12.090
<v Loretta Smith>And I don't know that there's any space for that for this '26-'27 year.

555
01:02:12.170 --> 01:02:28.643
<v Loretta Smith>So I think you have to work backwards and make sure that you have those conversations early on, because we were, you know, in the, in the police budget, their, their training dollars were cut, um, by $5 million.

556
01:02:28.996 --> 01:02:32.949
<v Loretta Smith>Their PS3s were cut by 23, 26 folks.

557
01:02:33.061 --> 01:02:43.577
<v Loretta Smith>So, um, the, the budget is small, and so for us to direct at this point— I'm I can't promise the direction for this point because we're finished and we're past that.

558
01:02:43.625 --> 01:02:50.947
<v Loretta Smith>But in terms of going forward, I think you keep talking to us and putting the pressure on us to see what can we do.

559
01:02:50.994 --> 01:02:52.873
<v Loretta Smith>Because I don't like— this is what I don't like.

560
01:02:53.003 --> 01:02:59.039
<v Loretta Smith>I don't like us having conversations with community groups and giving them the impression that we can do something that we can't.

561
01:02:59.681 --> 01:03:03.615
<v Loretta Smith>And if we can't do it, then we should say that we can't do it.

562
01:03:04.177 --> 01:03:09.590
<v Loretta Smith>But to lead you on and to have this conversation, I, I don't think it's right.

563
01:03:10.090 --> 01:03:18.427
<v Loretta Smith>So for me, um, either we say we can't do it or we're not going to do it, it's not going to be meaningful, or it is, and, and then we move on to something else.

564
01:03:19.360 --> 01:03:34.724
<v Loretta Smith>So, um, being a member of this, of this committee, that's what I would like to see us and how we move around in the community and how we're being helpful in making sure that we're we're being a very transparent partner.

565
01:03:35.735 --> 01:03:36.887
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you for coming.

566
01:03:37.144 --> 01:03:37.481
<v Earl Riley>Thank you.

567
01:03:38.682 --> 01:03:39.612
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

568
01:03:39.724 --> 01:04:03.416
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say that one of the things I had in mind when I asked for this panel is that last year we had a discussion in this committee and also at LPSIC about the fact that there was a tool that the police weren't really thinking of very much, which is extreme risk protection orders to take guns out of the hands of people who are a danger to themselves or others.

569
01:04:04.074 --> 01:04:11.541
<v Steve Novick>And Portland was underutilizing that tool, and it might have happened without this committee looking at it, but we helped shine a light on that tool.

570
01:04:11.797 --> 01:04:16.260
<v Steve Novick>And since then, the Police Bureau has dramatically increased its use of it.

571
01:04:16.840 --> 01:04:27.945
<v Steve Novick>And I think that we've just heard Chief Day say that he is interested in improving this relationship, and I'm hoping, although Very sensitive to Councilor Smith's point about the police not having much money for training.

572
01:04:29.016 --> 01:04:40.215
<v Steve Novick>I'm hopeful that this will lead to further engagement by the police bureau with Mindy's folks, and we might see simply from raising the issue some actual results.

573
01:04:42.289 --> 01:04:47.425
<v Steve Novick>I want to— I think at this point we know we're not gonna get to psychedelics, but I do wanna wrap this up in the next couple minutes.

574
01:04:47.507 --> 01:04:49.336
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Murillo, last word.

575
01:04:50.250 --> 01:04:50.914
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

576
01:04:51.465 --> 01:04:54.385
<v Angelita Morillo>And yeah, I presume we're not going to be getting to that final item today.

577
01:04:56.213 --> 01:05:08.103
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that there— our budget is part of what we prioritize, and a $5 million cut to training within PPB's budget does not mean that we don't have the expansive budget to do this type of work.

578
01:05:08.168 --> 01:05:14.454
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think that's going to be a decision for the Bureau to make if Council is not going to be adjusting all of that individually.

579
01:05:15.210 --> 01:05:37.311
<v Angelita Morillo>I will say I hope that the community referrals are the biggest aspect of this because I was a little bit disturbed to hear that school resource officers were being used as like a key point of referrals for juveniles because it's my understanding from all the statistics that I've read that school resource officers tend to target Black and brown youth, particularly Black youth, more than any other demographic.

580
01:05:38.193 --> 01:05:52.735
<v Angelita Morillo>And so the idea that the same institutions that that are biased against the people who need these restorative justice practices the most, it doesn't really make sense to me about how that would work out as far as those referrals go.

581
01:05:53.490 --> 01:05:57.992
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's not, you know, shame to any individual school resource officers or anything like that.

582
01:05:58.056 --> 01:06:01.067
<v Angelita Morillo>It is a system that is harming individuals.

583
01:06:01.130 --> 01:06:04.896
<v Angelita Morillo>But these things, we're talking about the school-to-prison pipeline.

584
01:06:05.750 --> 01:06:14.682
<v Angelita Morillo>So I would love, and clearly there's an appetite to have more of this conversation, so I hope that you guys get an opportunity I have way more questions to ask than we have time for today.

585
01:06:15.309 --> 01:06:25.132
<v Angelita Morillo>But, you know, I want to hear about how those referrals work when the people that we're depending on referrals from are not necessarily engaged in this system in the ways that they should be.

586
01:06:26.063 --> 01:06:27.284
<v Angelita Morillo>But thank you so much for your time today.

587
01:06:27.349 --> 01:06:28.536
<v Angelita Morillo>Really appreciate your presentations.

588
01:06:28.809 --> 01:06:30.012
<v Tristan Edwards>Thank you.

589
01:06:30.237 --> 01:06:31.539
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal, very quickly.

590
01:06:32.822 --> 01:06:48.429
<v Sameer Kanal>I just had a question about if there is a numerical goal for the number of referrals or for the I was hoping that we could get an answer on that, um, in terms of the next year or so, or even if it's a 2-year goal.

591
01:06:49.583 --> 01:06:53.782
<v Mindy Johnston>We would be so happy to get 15 to 20 cases in a year.

592
01:06:53.990 --> 01:06:58.960
<v Mindy Johnston>Last year we had 1 referral, so anything is going to be an improvement.

593
01:07:00.163 --> 01:07:03.047
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I appreciate that, and I apologize for not being clear on that.

594
01:07:03.112 --> 01:07:06.514
<v Sameer Kanal>I was actually— I really am I'm glad that you gave it from your perspective.

595
01:07:06.577 --> 01:07:11.137
<v Sameer Kanal>I was hoping to hear from Chief Day what their numerical goal is as well.

596
01:07:11.313 --> 01:07:17.094
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, Chief Day, my guess is you don't have a numeric goal, but you want to take a shot at that?

597
01:07:17.735 --> 01:07:19.887
<v Bob Day>No, I'm going to say I don't have a goal.

598
01:07:20.610 --> 01:07:23.563
<v Bob Day>Yeah, thank you, but we'll keep in the conversation.

599
01:07:23.677 --> 01:07:24.286
<v Bob Day>Thank you very much.

600
01:07:24.623 --> 01:07:25.074
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

601
01:07:26.405 --> 01:07:26.726
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

602
01:07:27.675 --> 01:07:29.536
<v Steve Novick>Thank you all very, very much.

603
01:07:29.842 --> 01:07:30.757
<v Steve Novick>I really appreciated this.

604
01:07:31.144 --> 01:07:31.956
<v Steve Novick>Really appreciate it.

605
01:07:32.038 --> 01:07:33.318
<v Steve Novick>You're making the time to be here.

606
01:07:33.400 --> 01:07:35.719
<v Steve Novick>Appreciate it, Chief Day, taking the time to be here.

607
01:07:36.985 --> 01:07:38.056
<v Steve Novick>Could the clerk read the next item?

608
01:07:39.427 --> 01:07:49.135
<v Tristan Edwards>Item number 3, document number 2026-201, Focused Intervention Team Community Oversight Group.

609
01:07:52.775 --> 01:07:53.713
<v Steve Novick>Thank you very much.

610
01:07:54.052 --> 01:08:05.284
<v Steve Novick>And actually, I don't have a list of who wants to speak first, so Uh, whatever you've pre— whatever you— whatever you've predetermined about who wants to go first, uh, take it away.

611
01:08:05.445 --> 01:08:08.065
<v Edith Thrower>Okay, thank you.

612
01:08:09.635 --> 01:08:10.628
<v Edith Thrower>And get our PowerPoint loaded.

613
01:08:14.280 --> 01:08:16.944
<v Edith Thrower>Greetings and good morning.

614
01:08:17.703 --> 01:08:33.012
<v Edith Thrower>Thank you for, uh, allowing the Focus Intervention Team Community Oversight Group to present during Gun Violence Awareness Month, and thank you especially, Councilor Novak, for squeezing us into your agenda so quickly.

615
01:08:33.365 --> 01:08:34.856
<v Edith Thrower>We greatly appreciate that.

616
01:08:35.273 --> 01:08:36.844
<v Edith Thrower>My name is Edith Thrower.

617
01:08:37.229 --> 01:08:44.394
<v Edith Thrower>I am the program manager for the Focus Intervention Team Community Oversight Group, um, FITCOG for short.

618
01:08:45.292 --> 01:08:48.962
<v Edith Thrower>And to my immediate left is Earl Riley.

619
01:08:49.475 --> 01:08:52.233
<v Edith Thrower>He is the vice chair of the FITCOG.

620
01:08:52.908 --> 01:09:06.202
<v Edith Thrower>And he will also, uh, be presenting, um, as well as Commander Crooker from, uh, PPB, also command, among many other things, the focus intervention team.

621
01:09:08.270 --> 01:09:19.795
<v Edith Thrower>Uh, Ladaquan Watley— I just want to mention this— is the chair of the FITCOG, and he had a family emergency, um, and pretty tragic, actually.

622
01:09:19.859 --> 01:09:25.978
<v Edith Thrower>So we're keeping him in our thoughts, or else he would be doing what I'm doing this morning.

623
01:09:27.270 --> 01:09:37.426
<v Edith Thrower>I want to acknowledge another member of our team who will not be speaking today, but who is present to support us, and that's Liz Taylor back there.

624
01:09:37.878 --> 01:09:42.389
<v Edith Thrower>And you've— many of you have seen her in City Council.

625
01:09:45.466 --> 01:09:48.137
<v Angelita Morillo>Next slide.

626
01:09:49.368 --> 01:10:00.765
<v Edith Thrower>So I'm going to pass the baton to Earl Riley, the vice chair, and he will lead us in our discussion and, uh, and defer to me when he needs to.

627
01:10:01.423 --> 01:10:02.596
<v Edith Thrower>Um, again, thank you.

628
01:10:03.030 --> 01:10:12.194
<v Edith Thrower>Um, I would like to say, uh, this, uh, the impetus for us being here is that we don't think okay, I'm sorry, the commander is going to go first.

629
01:10:12.997 --> 01:10:13.640
<v Edith Thrower>Oh, thank you.

630
01:10:14.104 --> 01:10:14.443
<v Steve Novick>Is that—.

631
01:10:15.166 --> 01:10:18.733
<v Edith Thrower>We, we were, we were not certain that you knew, um, about us.

632
01:10:18.925 --> 01:10:31.038
<v Edith Thrower>We wanted you to see our beautiful smiling faces, and we wanted to get to know you and for you to get to know us, and in my opinion, the important work that this team does.

633
01:10:31.472 --> 01:10:31.939
<v Edith Thrower>Commander?

634
01:10:32.983 --> 01:10:33.609
<v James Crooker>All right, thank you, Edith.

635
01:10:34.349 --> 01:10:35.104
<v James Crooker>Uh, good morning, everybody.

636
01:10:35.233 --> 01:10:40.210
<v James Crooker>This is, uh, A good opportunity to highlight this collaboration that's been going on for a few years now, so I appreciate it.

637
01:10:40.612 --> 01:10:41.399
<v James Crooker>My name is James Crooker.

638
01:10:41.527 --> 01:10:52.429
<v James Crooker>I'm the commander of the Specialized Resources Division, which includes a number of units including the Focused Intervention Team, the Enhanced Community Safety Team, CERT, and our NIBIN program.

639
01:10:53.296 --> 01:10:59.734
<v James Crooker>In 2021, the City of Portland experienced a gun violence crisis that was unlike anything that we had ever seen before.

640
01:11:00.360 --> 01:11:01.628
<v James Crooker>Shootings reached record levels.

641
01:11:01.902 --> 01:11:05.462
<v James Crooker>With 1,315 shootings in that year.

642
01:11:06.070 --> 01:11:12.934
<v James Crooker>And I was approached and asked to create a team focused on gun violence, which later became known as the Focused Intervention Team.

643
01:11:14.088 --> 01:11:21.015
<v James Crooker>It was clear that we needed to start this team differently than we had used in any other approach previous.

644
01:11:22.411 --> 01:11:38.693
<v James Crooker>It had to be tailored around the community's needs and our legal environment while following the best practices in gun violence this required collaboration with a number of partners and a real investment in education in the discipline of gun violence reduction.

645
01:11:39.431 --> 01:11:48.586
<v James Crooker>The FIT team was built to have a data-driven and investigation-driven approach with accountability and legitimacy at the heart of all of their interactions with the community from the very beginning.

646
01:11:49.738 --> 01:12:00.078
<v James Crooker>The Focused Intervention Team Community Oversight Group, or FITCOG, was created alongside FIT as a partner to ensure that the community's voice and legitimacy were built into every strategy.

647
01:12:00.818 --> 01:12:02.680
<v James Crooker>The FITCOG was not an afterthought.

648
01:12:03.322 --> 01:12:05.923
<v James Crooker>FITCOG was designed as a core part of our model.

649
01:12:07.417 --> 01:12:12.635
<v James Crooker>In January of 2022, the newly developed FIT team began its work.

650
01:12:13.341 --> 01:12:19.779
<v James Crooker>To this day, it remains the only uniformed team in the Portland Police Bureau whose full-time mission it is to address gun violence.

651
01:12:20.421 --> 01:12:28.042
<v James Crooker>FIT officers develop deep, real-time knowledge of gun violence trends, groups in conflict, and active investigations including homicides.

652
01:12:28.942 --> 01:12:39.240
<v James Crooker>In addition to ongoing community feedback, they receive ongoing enhanced training in a variety of topics including touch DNA collection and a number of other areas which I can go into during the Q&A session if needed.

653
01:12:40.140 --> 01:12:47.792
<v James Crooker>The FIT team works closely with our NIBIN coordinator and our Strategic Services Division to identify and prioritize repeat, repeat crime guns.

654
01:12:48.034 --> 01:12:50.234
<v James Crooker>So those are guns that are involved in more than one shooting.

655
01:12:51.270 --> 01:13:00.744
<v James Crooker>This focus is why FIT regularly attends high-risk events such as funerals, parades, and large gatherings with a history of violence or the likelihood of retaliation.

656
01:13:01.551 --> 01:13:05.439
<v James Crooker>They are very effective at interrupting the cycle of violence wherever they go.

657
01:13:06.354 --> 01:13:17.168
<v James Crooker>The FIT officers also participate in biweekly shooting reviews with a number of partners, including the U.S. Attorney's Office, The FBI, neighboring agencies, the DA's office, the ceasefire partners, and a number of other partners.

658
01:13:18.789 --> 01:13:27.215
<v James Crooker>An important internal Portland Police Bureau partnership to highlight is the relationship between the FIT team and the Enhanced Community Safety Team.

659
01:13:29.684 --> 01:13:30.006
<v James Crooker>Can you hear me?

660
01:13:30.474 --> 01:13:30.636
<v Mindy Johnston>Yes.

661
01:13:30.877 --> 01:13:31.667
<v James Crooker>All right.

662
01:13:33.345 --> 01:13:41.990
<v James Crooker>The important relationship between PPB's FIT team and ECST Their collaboration has strengthened the investigative capacity in both units.

663
01:13:42.554 --> 01:13:53.509
<v James Crooker>ECST now generates the highest volume of missions for our CERT team, which increased from 114 missions in 2021 to 222 in 2025, and I believe that'll exceed 300 this year.

664
01:13:55.225 --> 01:14:16.171
<v James Crooker>These are almost all search warrants and arrest warrants related to gun violence cases, and every single time we execute one of these, it has an immediate impact in stopping ongoing gun violence with At this point in 2024, we had already begun seeing significant reductions of gun violence from its peak.

665
01:14:16.653 --> 01:14:20.646
<v James Crooker>And at this point in 2024, we were at 30 homicides year to date.

666
01:14:21.304 --> 01:14:24.046
<v James Crooker>As of now in 2026, we continue to improve.

667
01:14:24.689 --> 01:14:27.832
<v James Crooker>We are currently at 11 as, as I'm sitting here right now.

668
01:14:28.762 --> 01:14:33.462
<v James Crooker>And all of the partners that I've mentioned in this introduction are extremely busy with those cases.

669
01:14:33.511 --> 01:14:33.622
<v James Crooker>Thank you.

670
01:14:34.377 --> 01:14:36.748
<v James Crooker>And focused on trying to prevent any more cases from occurring.

671
01:14:38.144 --> 01:14:43.320
<v James Crooker>FITCOG members have participated in every FIT officer selection process since the team was created.

672
01:14:43.368 --> 01:14:44.859
<v James Crooker>That includes the sergeant positions.

673
01:14:45.757 --> 01:15:11.711
<v James Crooker>The chair and the vice chair joined me in Florida for a week-long executive law enforcement training through the FBI's Project Safe Neighborhoods program, and the Portland Police Bureau and the City of Portland have also invested in sending leaders in in the Bureau as well as other parts of the city to the University of Chicago's Policing Leadership Academy for a 6-month-long master's level program focused on the latest practices in gun violence reduction.

674
01:15:12.384 --> 01:15:15.077
<v James Crooker>FIT is critical to implementing these strategies with our partners.

675
01:15:15.814 --> 01:15:23.092
<v James Crooker>FIT and the FITCOG meets regularly so that these strategies and community-police interactions are continuously discussed and reviewed through a lens of legitimacy.

676
01:15:24.087 --> 01:15:33.644
<v James Crooker>FIT is the only uniformed PPB member that has such direct relationship with the community group, constantly shaping and improving community interactions while engaging in this extremely dangerous work.

677
01:15:34.814 --> 01:15:38.904
<v James Crooker>Treating the community with respect, dignity, and fairness remains central to the FIT team's work.

678
01:15:39.465 --> 01:15:42.046
<v James Crooker>The FIT COG helps to keep us accountable to that standard.

679
01:15:42.769 --> 01:15:52.487
<v James Crooker>These integrated public safety partnerships have resulted in shooting incidents dropping from 1,315 documented shootings in 2021 to 574 in 2025.

680
01:15:53.128 --> 01:15:59.981
<v James Crooker>And I didn't write this down, but in April we just experienced the lowest number of shootings that brought us back to pre-2019 levels.

681
01:16:00.574 --> 01:16:09.289
<v James Crooker>And just today I received a report showing that our shootings for the month of May were below 40, and that's, I think, the 4th consecutive month below 40 that we've seen.

682
01:16:10.028 --> 01:16:12.386
<v James Crooker>And in the previous 5 years, I think we only saw that one time.

683
01:16:13.639 --> 01:16:19.015
<v James Crooker>While we've made real progress, gun violence does continue to have a lasting impact on individuals and on our community.

684
01:16:20.078 --> 01:16:27.569
<v James Crooker>There is still more work to do, and I'd like to thank the FITCOG's current and past members for their selflessness in volunteering for this civic partnership.

685
01:16:28.560 --> 01:16:30.838
<v James Crooker>I'll be available after the presentation for questions.

686
01:16:31.018 --> 01:16:33.688
<v James Crooker>With that, I'll turn it back over to Edith or Earl.

687
01:16:36.168 --> 01:16:36.926
<v Earl Riley>Thank you very much.

688
01:16:37.184 --> 01:16:40.485
<v Earl Riley>My name is Earl Riley, Vice Chair of FITCOG.

689
01:16:42.498 --> 01:16:44.899
<v Earl Riley>FITCOG launched on June 23rd, 2019.

690
01:16:45.095 --> 01:16:54.149
<v Earl Riley>21 Members recruited by City Council and, you know, neogov, but officially appointed by the mayor.

691
01:16:55.702 --> 01:17:07.908
<v Earl Riley>Members have varying backgrounds, like the— I believe our vice chair and chair before was Edward— Pastor Edwards and Kim.

692
01:17:08.600 --> 01:17:12.617
<v Earl Riley>And then we had Terrence Hayes, who also ran for City Council.

693
01:17:13.394 --> 01:17:15.373
<v Earl Riley>And Dr. Gina Rowland.

694
01:17:15.909 --> 01:17:20.033
<v Earl Riley>And then we preceded me, Juma and myself.

695
01:17:21.909 --> 01:17:23.877
<v Earl Riley>Let's see, people with lived experience.

696
01:17:23.942 --> 01:17:25.957
<v Earl Riley>I came in with lived experience.

697
01:17:26.037 --> 01:17:28.586
<v Earl Riley>Juma also is a community member as well.

698
01:17:30.289 --> 01:17:36.943
<v Earl Riley>We assist with recommendations to reduce gun violence through prevention and intervention and response.

699
01:17:37.572 --> 01:17:38.832
<v Earl Riley>Actively recruiting right now.

700
01:17:39.538 --> 01:17:41.042
<v Earl Riley>I'll just speak off of that.

701
01:17:42.207 --> 01:17:51.578
<v Earl Riley>I would say I personally have helped and called and emailed lieutenant.

702
01:17:52.015 --> 01:18:11.233
<v Earl Riley>Just being a community member, I've emailed and called Lieutenant and talked with him because I've gotten information from community members who have seen gun violence and have been involved and I was able to call and let them know about activity that goes on in the community.

703
01:18:12.859 --> 01:18:20.382
<v Earl Riley>A little bit about myself, I was also involved in gang violence at a young age.

704
01:18:20.560 --> 01:18:21.534
<v Earl Riley>I've been through the system.

705
01:18:22.529 --> 01:18:38.909
<v Earl Riley>So it was a little bit hard for me at first being on this, on this committee and doing ride-alongs because Of course, there was a mistrust when it came to dealing with the PBB or Portland, the police.

706
01:18:38.909 --> 01:18:47.369
<v Earl Riley>So working with FITCOC has helped me, I believe, gain more trust with PBB.

707
01:18:47.369 --> 01:18:58.510
<v Earl Riley>I'm able to go on ride-alongs, go to roll calls, and be able to comfortably sit and talk with them and talk about issues in the community.

708
01:18:59.533 --> 01:19:15.868
<v Earl Riley>And I will say FIT has made it very, very easy working with some of the officers, understanding because they understand and want to understand, and they have the compassion to want to understand and deal with the community and work with the community.

709
01:19:16.850 --> 01:19:17.506
<v Earl Riley>We go to the next slide.

710
01:19:23.130 --> 01:19:23.470
<v Earl Riley>What's that?

711
01:19:24.886 --> 01:19:28.612
<v Edith Thrower>It's down there, but we can go straight to current projects.

712
01:19:28.676 --> 01:19:30.024
<v Edith Thrower>You wanna talk about the FITCOG?

713
01:19:30.682 --> 01:19:31.935
<v Earl Riley>No, we can go to current projects.

714
01:19:31.983 --> 01:19:49.195
<v Earl Riley>All right, so current projects right now, we have a survey that we have developed that basically has a scan you can scan in, and we put it out in the community, and the community basically have given us feedback on what they see in certain areas.

715
01:19:51.061 --> 01:20:02.435
<v Earl Riley>We put the actual survey in different demographics, like people who live in higher earning communities and lower earning communities.

716
01:20:03.100 --> 01:20:05.975
<v Earl Riley>And we've got pretty much the same feedback.

717
01:20:08.279 --> 01:20:10.065
<v Earl Riley>They want to see a change and—.

718
01:20:10.065 --> 01:20:14.466
<v Eric Zimmerman>For what?

719
01:20:15.689 --> 01:20:16.363
<v Angelita Morillo>General feedback.

720
01:20:16.604 --> 01:20:40.229
<v Earl Riley>Yeah, uh, the respondents from a wide range of Portland neighborhoods describe regular exposure to shootings, stabbings, overdose, uh, break-ins and thefts, street racing, frequent police and emergency responses, uh, and, uh, excuse me, strong support for combined approach and accountability and provision, uh, prevention.

721
01:20:40.823 --> 01:21:03.555
<v Earl Riley>There's no single preferred solution, and residents consistently expressed support for outreach events, block parties, foot patrols, regular non-crisis engagement, and being able to recognize and know officers, which leads to a recommendation that PB— the COG came up with and discussed with PBB about the patches.

722
01:21:04.149 --> 01:21:13.917
<v Earl Riley>So now FIT-COG does have patches that are— they can be identified in the community when they're out and serving the community, which I think helps a lot.

723
01:21:13.965 --> 01:21:20.458
<v Earl Riley>It kind of helps them stick out like a sore thumb when it comes to them doing work in the community and going to events.

724
01:21:20.930 --> 01:21:23.021
<v Earl Riley>People know who the FIT officers are.

725
01:21:24.721 --> 01:21:25.289
<v Mindy Johnston>All right.

726
01:21:26.685 --> 01:21:27.851
<v Tristan Edwards>Service activities.

727
01:21:28.112 --> 01:21:31.176
<v Earl Riley>Our service activities, we do things like ride-alongs.

728
01:21:32.590 --> 01:21:39.680
<v Earl Riley>We go to, we go to let's see, the roll calls, uh, we do it.

729
01:21:40.019 --> 01:21:44.141
<v Earl Riley>Community engagements, we invite the FIT officers out to community engagements.

730
01:21:44.545 --> 01:21:46.224
<v Earl Riley>They're very active in the community.

731
01:21:48.889 --> 01:21:50.817
<v Edith Thrower>Um, get back, see this.

732
01:21:52.695 --> 01:21:55.757
<v Earl Riley>Okay, in the beginning of— sorry guys, I'm, I'm trying to read this.

733
01:21:57.176 --> 01:22:08.322
<v Earl Riley>Uh, in the beginning of August 1st, 2025, a FIT, uh, FIT COG workgroup recommended in lieu of 2 FITCOG meetings per month.

734
01:22:09.310 --> 01:22:16.780
<v Earl Riley>That member engaged in a service activity to enhance learning and build relationships and inform recommendations.

735
01:22:18.100 --> 01:22:22.771
<v Earl Riley>For example, if we— if you choose, you could discuss some of the activities below.

736
01:22:24.060 --> 01:22:40.655
<v Earl Riley>We go on ride-alongs, attend a FIT roll call, we participate in FIT interviews, we the COG, the vice chair and the chair himself, we actually are very active in interviewing new FIT officers.

737
01:22:40.913 --> 01:22:46.064
<v Earl Riley>And also we interview some members that come onto the COG as well.

738
01:22:47.819 --> 01:22:56.168
<v Earl Riley>We do one-to-one with FIT officers, one-on-ones with FIT officers, relevant neighborhood associations and community meetings or events.

739
01:22:57.087 --> 01:23:22.948
<v Earl Riley>We attend other city public safety advisory body meetings or events, Community Police Academy, citizen review committee meetings, police review board meetings, Portland Committee and Community Engaged Policing meetings, training advisory council meetings, police equity advisory council meetings, and community board for police academy meetings.

740
01:23:23.257 --> 01:23:24.060
<v Edith Thrower>All right.

741
01:23:24.141 --> 01:23:26.310
<v Edith Thrower>Okay, uh, thank you, Earl.

742
01:23:26.921 --> 01:23:43.182
<v Edith Thrower>Um, and so, and those are just some of the things that they, that they can do, and, um, and, and all to, uh, gather information, build relationships, and build up, build their learnings to inform their recommendations.

743
01:23:43.712 --> 01:23:53.166
<v Edith Thrower>So, um, the, the group thought it was more practical, uh, a better use of time to engage in these service activities.

744
01:23:54.143 --> 01:24:04.462
<v Edith Thrower>Um, I would like to share another current project of the FITCOG, and that is that a direct, um, observation assessment tool for ride-alongs.

745
01:24:05.198 --> 01:24:08.837
<v Edith Thrower>And I, I won't go over the tool unless you ask me specific questions.

746
01:24:08.900 --> 01:24:10.006
<v Edith Thrower>I did bring it with me.

747
01:24:10.327 --> 01:24:21.449
<v Edith Thrower>However, what that encompasses, it's, it's intended to support FITCOG's oversight and learning by capturing capturing high-level observations about how the FIT engages with the community and partners.

748
01:24:22.219 --> 01:24:27.493
<v Edith Thrower>It is not intended, however, to evaluate individual officers or document specific incidents.

749
01:24:28.760 --> 01:24:36.840
<v Edith Thrower>And they're careful to avoid overreach into operational and personnel-level evaluation.

750
01:24:37.993 --> 01:24:57.600
<v Edith Thrower>Many of our members have been on ride-alongs, and it is pretty much required that they do it on a regular basis, again, to gain learning, to enhance their learning, to inform their recommendations, to be able to better engage with the officers and, uh, make suggestions about how they police.

751
01:25:01.394 --> 01:25:01.641
<v Loretta Smith>Another—.

752
01:25:01.641 --> 01:25:04.252
<v Edith Thrower>I'm sorry, could you go back to the previous slide?

753
01:25:07.692 --> 01:25:15.110
<v Edith Thrower>The performance dashboard, um, assesses whether FITCAG is an effective oversight and advisory body.

754
01:25:15.720 --> 01:25:17.836
<v Edith Thrower>So the dashboard is in the works.

755
01:25:17.884 --> 01:25:29.966
<v Edith Thrower>It will likely be an interactive Excel dashboard but will include the repeatable survey that Earl, uh, spoke of earlier, uh, the repeatable community impact survey.

756
01:25:30.671 --> 01:25:37.457
<v Edith Thrower>And it will also include information gathered from the ride-alongs that Earl also noted.

757
01:25:37.826 --> 01:26:05.976
<v Edith Thrower>Together with this dashboard to include information that is gathered from the community, to include information that is gathered during ride-alongs, this group believes that it will be able to track its own effectiveness as an advisory body, assess community-level impact of the focus intervention team, The fit and systemically or systematically capture learning from direct observation activities.

758
01:26:06.090 --> 01:26:24.677
<v Edith Thrower>This approach is consistent with the intent to support data-informed recommendations, community temperature checks, and continuous improvement, and builds directly on the findings from the themes identified in the community engagement survey that Earl referenced earlier.

759
01:26:25.341 --> 01:26:34.515
<v Edith Thrower>Um, The data collected, however, and I wanna note, is unofficial and for the express purpose of informing recommendations.

760
01:26:34.710 --> 01:26:48.350
<v Edith Thrower>PPB collects data, as you know, and that is obviously official public safety data, whereas this is designed to inform FITCOG recommendations.

761
01:26:48.832 --> 01:26:49.927
<v Edith Thrower>Sorry, I didn't bring my glasses.

762
01:26:54.905 --> 01:27:05.315
<v Edith Thrower>Another, another, uh, another current project is, uh, forming community partnerships with community-based organizations that share FITCAG's mission.

763
01:27:06.070 --> 01:27:24.832
<v Edith Thrower>So a memorandum of agreement is underway in a subcommittee and being crafted for, uh, city attorney's review, after which community partnerships will be formed with a view toward expanding community outreach and learning more about community public safety concerns.

764
01:27:25.345 --> 01:27:36.698
<v Edith Thrower>And there have been several community groups who have expressed an interest in partnering with the FITCOG, like Dads Helping Dads, Elate for Youth, Black Men in Training, just for example, and there are many more.

765
01:27:37.131 --> 01:27:39.154
<v Edith Thrower>So we're, we're really excited about that.

766
01:27:39.701 --> 01:27:49.550
<v Edith Thrower>As you may know, the FITCOG has met all around the city and all around the county trying to get in areas, trying to get in the troubled areas, uh, trying to engage those communities.

767
01:27:50.127 --> 01:27:55.640
<v Edith Thrower>And sometimes we have a— we, we gather a big crowd, sometimes they gather a very small crowd.

768
01:27:55.689 --> 01:28:12.552
<v Edith Thrower>So they came up with the idea of partnering with organizations to help, um, inform the community better about, um, what the FITCOG is doing, what the FIT is doing, and also to get, uh, to better assess their concerns around public safety.

769
01:28:13.530 --> 01:28:19.930
<v Edith Thrower>Earl also talked about, um, participating in FIT interviews.

770
01:28:20.378 --> 01:28:32.439
<v Edith Thrower>So the FITCOG has been allowed the privilege and honor of participating in interviews where 2 members typically sit on an interview panel to interview officers and sergeants.

771
01:28:32.935 --> 01:28:37.539
<v Edith Thrower>They've been doing this, I think, since the very beginning of the group.

772
01:28:38.069 --> 01:28:40.881
<v Edith Thrower>And Earl, I don't know, you've been in an interview.

773
01:28:40.961 --> 01:28:42.743
<v Edith Thrower>Can you share your interview experience?

774
01:28:43.610 --> 01:28:47.884
<v Earl Riley>I've only interviewed, I believe, just COG members.

775
01:28:47.948 --> 01:28:50.550
<v Earl Riley>I've never had the opportunity to really interview officers.

776
01:28:50.679 --> 01:28:51.979
<v Earl Riley>I believe that was just Juma.

777
01:28:52.381 --> 01:29:00.701
<v Edith Thrower>Some of the questions that they ask in these interviews of fit officers and sergeants are, what are your strategies for building trust with the community?

778
01:29:01.055 --> 01:29:04.792
<v Edith Thrower>Describe a time you had a difficult dispute and what was the outcome.

779
01:29:05.128 --> 01:29:09.311
<v Edith Thrower>Questions are already prepared for the officers by the FIT.

780
01:29:09.615 --> 01:29:14.055
<v Edith Thrower>However, FITCOG members are allowed to ask questions.

781
01:29:14.439 --> 01:29:42.841
<v Edith Thrower>So the ongoing compact survey, the service activities in lieu of a monthly meeting, the direct observation assessment tool for ride-alongs, the FITCOG performance dashboards to assess FITCAG's effectiveness and forming community partnerships with community-based organizations are just a few of the current projects on the table with the FITCAG.

782
01:29:43.180 --> 01:29:47.840
<v Edith Thrower>Currently, there are 2 recommendations being considered by the mayor's office.

783
01:29:48.279 --> 01:29:48.393
<v Loretta Smith>Earl?

784
01:29:50.536 --> 01:29:53.167
<v Earl Riley>One is for— excuse me.

785
01:29:54.168 --> 01:29:59.823
<v Earl Riley>A formal FIT training needs assessment and historical respiratory.

786
01:30:01.302 --> 01:30:06.524
<v Earl Riley>Enhance FIT's legitimacy through varied experience and community trust.

787
01:30:07.087 --> 01:30:11.024
<v Earl Riley>And informal is uniform patches, which we already went over.

788
01:30:11.666 --> 01:30:19.395
<v Earl Riley>One of those, enhance FIT's legitimacy through varied experiences and community trust, is one that I wrote myself.

789
01:30:19.555 --> 01:30:19.988
<v Bob Day>Councilor Smith.

790
01:30:20.600 --> 01:30:35.043
<v Earl Riley>It's basically wanting to keep what we have as far as the dynamic of FITS legitimacy and what they're doing right now, because they are doing a great job.

791
01:30:35.831 --> 01:30:46.338
<v Earl Riley>And lived experience, having that mirror the communities that they are policing, specifically the Black and brown communities.

792
01:30:47.131 --> 01:30:49.229
<v Earl Riley>So that's the gist of it.

793
01:30:49.534 --> 01:30:57.367
<v Earl Riley>I know we're working with Law and Equity right now to kind of change some of the verbiage because I kind of want a little ham in that.

794
01:30:57.837 --> 01:30:59.932
<v Earl Riley>But we're working on it.

795
01:31:01.507 --> 01:31:09.275
<v Earl Riley>Currently, it looks like the FIT training needs assessment historical proposal, it's already been on the table and approved.

796
01:31:09.662 --> 01:31:11.514
<v Earl Riley>The second one that we're working on right now.

797
01:31:11.738 --> 01:31:11.899
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

798
01:31:12.060 --> 01:31:14.298
<v Edith Thrower>And I can speak to the training needs assessment.

799
01:31:14.695 --> 01:31:26.470
<v Edith Thrower>Strategic Training Plan, COG Collaboration Model, Community-Based Training Standards, and Historical Learning Repository recommendation that was submitted to the mayor late last year.

800
01:31:27.145 --> 01:31:34.920
<v Edith Thrower>I'd like to quote PPB first, and then I can let you know the, the impetus behind this recommendation.

801
01:31:35.497 --> 01:31:53.636
<v Edith Thrower>Law enforcement on patrol face a particular challenge pertaining to skill perishability especially with events that are high stress and low frequency in nature, as they are forced to make split-second decisions in circumstances that are tense, uncertain, and rapidly evolving.

802
01:31:54.311 --> 01:32:01.591
<v Edith Thrower>These decision points are analyzed through the totality of circumstances and reasonableness of the officer's actions.

803
01:32:02.024 --> 01:32:10.277
<v Edith Thrower>Continual training is critical to ensure that officers can perform at their best under these unpredictable and complicated circumstances.

804
01:32:10.390 --> 01:32:13.393
<v Edith Thrower>PPP Training Bureau Division 2024.

805
01:32:15.217 --> 01:32:23.372
<v Edith Thrower>In 2024 also, the Portland Police Bureau's Training Division completed a comprehensive bureau-wide training needs assessment.

806
01:32:23.954 --> 01:32:37.042
<v Edith Thrower>This assessment affirmed that PP— that the PPP Training Division does not create or oversee FIT-specific training, although FIT officers enter their role with varying degrees of training.

807
01:32:37.109 --> 01:32:43.532
<v Edith Thrower>In fact, they complete 65 additional hours to participate, um, as officers in the FIT.

808
01:32:43.949 --> 01:32:56.462
<v Edith Thrower>There is no standardized training framework for FIT officers, nor a pathway for ongoing professional development or reduction— or, um, or the reduction of perishable skills.

809
01:32:57.041 --> 01:33:02.967
<v Edith Thrower>So that's how they came up with the recommendation for a training needs assessment and a strategic plan going forward.

810
01:33:03.546 --> 01:33:18.170
<v Edith Thrower>Uh, currently we have a subcommittee meeting with FIT officers and 2 consultants, uh, retained by the FIT to determine, uh, the needs assessment and, and the strategic plan going forward.

811
01:33:18.250 --> 01:33:24.747
<v Edith Thrower>So we're very happy about that recommendation and that, that, that was approved by the mayor's office to move forward.

812
01:33:28.859 --> 01:33:32.795
<v Edith Thrower>That is a photograph of an officer, um, I believe Officer Trummer.

813
01:33:32.842 --> 01:33:33.525
<v Earl Riley>Mr. Trummer, yeah.

814
01:33:33.591 --> 01:33:33.753
<v Edith Thrower>Uh-huh.

815
01:33:33.916 --> 01:33:42.161
<v Edith Thrower>And on the back of his his uniform or vest is the patch that we talked— that Earl mentioned earlier, that was approved by PPB.

816
01:33:42.466 --> 01:33:46.755
<v Edith Thrower>So they are readily identifiable in communities.

817
01:33:47.108 --> 01:33:55.541
<v Edith Thrower>And that was what we like to refer to as an informal recommendation by the FIT COG, but that was formalized by PPB.

818
01:33:56.664 --> 01:33:57.194
<v Angelita Morillo>Next slide.

819
01:34:01.787 --> 01:34:03.485
<v Edith Thrower>I apologize, Earl, I cannot see that.

820
01:34:03.565 --> 01:34:04.784
<v Earl Riley>I can read it for you.

821
01:34:05.394 --> 01:34:06.579
<v Earl Riley>2 Bodies, one mission.

822
01:34:07.012 --> 01:34:16.135
<v Earl Riley>The FIT, Focused Intervention Team, PBV's specialized unit deployed to neighborhoods hit hardest by gun violence.

823
01:34:16.775 --> 01:34:26.939
<v Earl Riley>FIT builds relationships, responds to gun-related violence, intervenes before violence erupts, and responds with both enforcement and outreach.

824
01:34:27.775 --> 01:34:38.489
<v Earl Riley>The FITCOG Community Oversight Group, the independent community body that oversees FIT, ensuring that strategies are equitable and just and accountable.

825
01:34:38.635 --> 01:34:45.797
<v Earl Riley>FITCOG is the reason Portland's gun violence response has community trust behind it.

826
01:34:52.125 --> 01:34:54.555
<v Earl Riley>Relationship between FIT and the FITCOG.

827
01:34:54.604 --> 01:34:59.676
<v Earl Riley>FITCOG provides guidance and mentorship to the FIT to reduce gun violence.

828
01:35:00.242 --> 01:35:06.461
<v Earl Riley>This unique approach to community policing could easily become a national model.

829
01:35:07.253 --> 01:35:28.533
<v Earl Riley>Oversight bodies like FITCA independently lend their support to enhance police accountability, transparency, and rebuild public trust with a view toward continuous improvement, collaboration amongst our teams, and crucial next slide.

830
01:35:31.162 --> 01:35:32.390
<v Earl Riley>Meetings and cadence.

831
01:35:33.247 --> 01:35:38.020
<v Earl Riley>We have hybrid meetings on the 3rd Thursday of each month from 6 to 8.

832
01:35:39.152 --> 01:35:43.061
<v Earl Riley>Quarterly listening sessions are held 4 times per year.

833
01:35:43.658 --> 01:36:00.268
<v Earl Riley>Annual retreat planning sessions, January or February annual meetings our next meeting will be with FIT COP meeting will be community listening session at East Portland Community Center multipurpose room from 6 to 8.

834
01:36:05.291 --> 01:36:05.677
<v Earl Riley>Questions?

835
01:36:08.050 --> 01:36:11.716
<v Edith Thrower>I'd like to make one more comment about the rec— there are 2 recommendations on the table.

836
01:36:11.796 --> 01:36:15.268
<v Edith Thrower>Wanted to be clear, one's regarding training, one's regarding the structure of the FIT.

837
01:36:15.867 --> 01:36:18.065
<v Edith Thrower>Earl talked a little bit about it.

838
01:36:18.130 --> 01:36:30.054
<v Edith Thrower>He was the crafter of the proposal for the recommendation to enhance the focus intervention team's legitimacy through varied experiences and accessibility.

839
01:36:30.407 --> 01:36:47.948
<v Edith Thrower>I know that's a mouthful, but basically what it boils down to is putting the right team together to address communities, to be able to to approach communities, be received by communities, so that these officers can do their work effectively.

840
01:36:48.729 --> 01:37:03.484
<v Edith Thrower>So they recommended that they prioritize varied experiences within the structure and operations, as it's essential to build legitimacy, trust, and collaboration with impacted communities.

841
01:37:06.134 --> 01:37:21.164
<v Edith Thrower>And this is currently before the mayor's office, as Earl Earl said that we're meeting with both representatives from the Law Department as well as Equity to kind of frame the recommendation a little differently.

842
01:37:22.550 --> 01:37:33.823
<v Edith Thrower>Earl was very passionate about the recommendation, and so we probably included some things that we can use in another way for another purpose.

843
01:37:33.935 --> 01:37:38.078
<v Edith Thrower>And so that is something that we're We're very proud of.

844
01:37:38.529 --> 01:37:45.095
<v Edith Thrower>And he doesn't— he didn't read this, but I'm going to read it because he wrote it.

845
01:37:45.627 --> 01:37:49.963
<v Edith Thrower>And I, and I think we can conclude on this and then answer your questions thereafter.

846
01:37:52.100 --> 01:38:00.787
<v Edith Thrower>As a young man who grew up on the South Side of Chicago and lived on the streets of Gary, Indiana, I didn't just witness gun violence, I was a part of it.

847
01:38:01.653 --> 01:38:05.877
<v Edith Thrower>I was a gang member, and I have dealt with the police more times than I can count.

848
01:38:06.751 --> 01:38:09.557
<v Edith Thrower>Most of those times I wasn't on the right side of the law.

849
01:38:10.203 --> 01:38:17.029
<v Edith Thrower>However, even, even when I was, I still faced the discrimination and stereotypes that come with the color of my skin.

850
01:38:17.627 --> 01:38:23.408
<v Edith Thrower>I know exactly what it feels like to look at the— look at a uniform and see an enemy.

851
01:38:23.908 --> 01:38:30.520
<v Edith Thrower>But for the last 2 years, serving as a leader within the FITCOG, my perspective has been forced to change.

852
01:38:31.020 --> 01:38:44.966
<v Edith Thrower>I have gone on ride-alongs I have watched these officers do the street work, not just making arrests, but knowing the families, talking to mothers on their porches, and building real relationships with the children in our communities.

853
01:38:45.625 --> 01:38:58.389
<v Edith Thrower>I am living proof that when the police look like the community they serve, and by look like, that means have— Without trying to—.

854
01:38:58.470 --> 01:38:58.869
<v Earl Riley>Oh, sorry.

855
01:38:59.448 --> 01:39:07.622
<v Edith Thrower>I'm sorry, that means have attributes that are appropriate for the work and the body of work that they do.

856
01:39:09.677 --> 01:39:14.899
<v Edith Thrower>Trust isn't just a word, it's a result, end quote.

857
01:39:15.158 --> 01:39:15.768
<v Edith Thrower>Earl Riley.

858
01:39:16.458 --> 01:39:21.297
<v Edith Thrower>So the short of it is that this is working.

859
01:39:22.252 --> 01:39:23.902
<v Edith Thrower>It's a great platform.

860
01:39:23.949 --> 01:39:29.789
<v Edith Thrower>And I love the quote that Earl, or the statement Earl made about this potentially being a national model.

861
01:39:30.238 --> 01:39:33.716
<v Edith Thrower>Actually, we, we borrowed that from a FIT officer, Lieutenant Dullio.

862
01:39:34.180 --> 01:39:37.930
<v Edith Thrower>He used to always say it in meetings because no one's doing this.

863
01:39:38.811 --> 01:39:43.411
<v Edith Thrower>I would also like to note this is the only oversight body within PPB.

864
01:39:44.260 --> 01:39:49.212
<v Edith Thrower>Um, they, they decided early on to approach this work, um, collaboratively.

865
01:39:49.868 --> 01:39:59.500
<v Edith Thrower>And so we, we want— we thank you for your continued support of the FIT and the FITCOG and are happy to answer any questions that you might have.

866
01:40:01.159 --> 01:40:02.130
<v Steve Novick>Thank you so much.

867
01:40:02.140 --> 01:40:04.510
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith, is that a legacy hand or is that for this?

868
01:40:05.579 --> 01:40:11.739
<v Loretta Smith>It, it was a legacy hand, but I do have a question in terms of being able to continue this training.

869
01:40:11.739 --> 01:40:24.134
<v Loretta Smith>Do you see any issues with the reduced training dollars that were I defer to the commander.

870
01:40:26.310 --> 01:40:37.198
<v James Crooker>I expected there to be a question about training, so I brought the annual training schedule for the FIT team, uh, that it goes from January to December, uh, that annual training.

871
01:40:37.247 --> 01:40:39.962
<v James Crooker>So, you know, the Police Bureau puts a pretty high premium on training.

872
01:40:40.076 --> 01:40:46.390
<v James Crooker>I think you'd be hard-pressed to find any other agency that's similar to ours that has as much of an emphasis on training as we do.

873
01:40:47.826 --> 01:41:00.722
<v James Crooker>Right now we have, for the FIT team, in addition to the training that every officer receives, the FIT team receives an additional training day every month, which is fairly significant for a police organization.

874
01:41:01.332 --> 01:41:11.082
<v James Crooker>So for the month, or for the year that we're in right now, calendar year, the curricula— I'm just going to read it directly off the special order for the current year.

875
01:41:11.274 --> 01:41:15.815
<v James Crooker>And, you know, year after year, it's going to be something similar, building on what we have.

876
01:41:16.810 --> 01:41:38.748
<v James Crooker>So for this year, we have officers receiving additional training on the FIT team in active threats, elevated-risk traffic stops, emergency entries, critical incident response, weapon range weapon drills, rescues, surveillance and follows, anti-bias and ABLE principles in shootings and gang investigations.

877
01:41:40.210 --> 01:41:58.690
<v James Crooker>Introduction to tactical emergency casualty care provided by our Fire Bureau, investigative use of social media, crime scene management and evidence processing, the ceasefire model, which our FIT team works really closely with, control tactics, and training around wellness.

878
01:41:58.755 --> 01:42:04.519
<v James Crooker>Particularly, they are exposed to a lot of sort of the highest profile calls that are experienced on the streets.

879
01:42:05.210 --> 01:42:07.002
<v James Crooker>I don't know if that answers your question.

880
01:42:08.083 --> 01:42:14.024
<v James Crooker>Getting into the budget is going to be outside of the scope of what I can answer for the next calendar year or the next fiscal year.

881
01:42:14.640 --> 01:42:18.682
<v James Crooker>I can say that training has been a priority and will continue to be a priority.

882
01:42:18.747 --> 01:42:23.890
<v James Crooker>And if we can squeeze training into the next year's calendar for the FIT team, we will.

883
01:42:24.164 --> 01:42:28.270
<v James Crooker>And I don't think anything is going to— I don't see anything right now anyway that would stop us from doing that.

884
01:42:28.804 --> 01:42:29.095
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

885
01:42:31.260 --> 01:42:36.342
<v Loretta Smith>You believe that you'll still be able to have a very aggressive training schedule?

886
01:42:37.484 --> 01:42:40.783
<v James Crooker>Yeah, I can't imagine anything stopping us from doing that next year.

887
01:42:41.009 --> 01:42:50.779
<v James Crooker>Now, I reserve the right to be wrong about that, of course, because I have bosses, but I think that right now we're gonna be able to squeeze this training calendar into the following calendar year and fiscal year as well.

888
01:42:51.185 --> 01:42:52.189
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, I understand.

889
01:42:52.238 --> 01:42:53.779
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much for all that you do.

890
01:42:54.006 --> 01:42:54.329
<v Earl Riley>You're welcome.

891
01:42:56.899 --> 01:42:57.689
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

892
01:42:57.948 --> 01:43:00.305
<v Steve Novick>I put myself in the queue to ask a couple of questions.

893
01:43:00.449 --> 01:43:07.274
<v Steve Novick>One is, and Commander, you just mentioned this, could you describe the relationship between FIT and the FITCOG and our ceasefire partners?

894
01:43:09.051 --> 01:43:16.868
<v James Crooker>So there's a huge ecosystem of partners that are involved in gun violence reduction, and it's not just ceasefire, it's not just FIT, it's not just FITCOG.

895
01:43:16.934 --> 01:43:30.497
<v James Crooker>There are other partners as well, and internally in the police bureau, we obviously have have strong partnerships between ECST and FIT and Homicide and Major Crimes and all the other investigative units and patrol officers who respond to the calls the moment the call happens.

896
01:43:31.149 --> 01:43:39.653
<v James Crooker>But externally, outside of the Police Bureau, we have partners ranging from probation and parole, other law enforcement agencies in the area, and neighboring agencies.

897
01:43:39.717 --> 01:43:46.068
<v James Crooker>We have a number of federal partners who routinely sit in on our weekly— or biweekly now— shooting reviews.

898
01:43:46.246 --> 01:43:50.573
<v James Crooker>They include, you know, the U.S. Attorney's Office, And the FBI and a number of other partners.

899
01:43:51.039 --> 01:44:04.011
<v James Crooker>So there are, as we see a shooting occur, there is an analysis on the likelihood for retaliation in that shooting, and our FIT team is present for all of those discussions.

900
01:44:04.670 --> 01:44:18.476
<v James Crooker>And then those discussions turn into a conversation about which individuals are appropriate for referral for ceasefire services, which there's a wide range of services, and I know that you already had a meeting about that.

901
01:44:18.957 --> 01:44:28.860
<v James Crooker>And so we partner really closely with Ceasefire to make sure that those call-ins— that we— they do regular call-ins and something called custom notifications.

902
01:44:28.908 --> 01:44:47.500
<v James Crooker>If there's— if it would be inappropriate to bring a large group of people who are in conflict with each other into a meeting together, the Portland Police Bureau and the FIT team in particular partner with Ceasefire to ensure that we've identified the people for those events and probably the best way to be successful in those events with ceasefire.

903
01:44:49.935 --> 01:44:51.262
<v Steve Novick>A really basic question.

904
01:44:51.845 --> 01:44:55.036
<v Steve Novick>How many officers are in FIT and how many members are there of the FITCOG?

905
01:44:56.159 --> 01:44:57.286
<v James Crooker>Yeah, the FIT team has 12.

906
01:44:57.560 --> 01:45:00.474
<v James Crooker>We're authorized to have 12 officers and 2 sergeants.

907
01:45:00.859 --> 01:45:02.341
<v James Crooker>The police bureau is in a staffing crisis.

908
01:45:02.390 --> 01:45:03.211
<v James Crooker>I think we all know that.

909
01:45:03.581 --> 01:45:07.007
<v James Crooker>So we're not up to full staff right now, but that is what our authorized strength is.

910
01:45:10.761 --> 01:45:17.028
<v Earl Riley>Uh, we can have up to 15, but we currently have 9, and we're actively doing interviews right now.

911
01:45:18.393 --> 01:45:29.095
<v Edith Thrower>Regarding interviewing, I'd like to add that when they started— when they began this work, City Council members were permitted to submit names to the mayor.

912
01:45:29.882 --> 01:45:32.854
<v Edith Thrower>I don't know why you haven't, but you are permitted to.

913
01:45:33.354 --> 01:45:38.167
<v Edith Thrower>The mayor solely makes appointments, and, you know, we welcome your recommendations.

914
01:45:38.920 --> 01:45:45.750
<v Edith Thrower>Currently, they've been taking recruitment applications off the NeoGov— from the NeoGov system.

915
01:45:45.797 --> 01:45:52.807
<v Edith Thrower>However, you are welcome to make recommendations to the mayor for members to the FIDCAG, and we are actively recruiting.

916
01:45:54.862 --> 01:45:55.252
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

917
01:45:55.511 --> 01:46:00.793
<v Steve Novick>And Mr. Riley, I think that you talked about engagement with the Community Police Academy.

918
01:46:01.386 --> 01:46:04.505
<v Steve Novick>And I've gone through that a couple of times and I was just curious what that engagement is.

919
01:46:04.617 --> 01:46:09.967
<v Steve Novick>I mean, are you involved in like reviewing that and trying to figure out ways to make it more realistic or more valuable?

920
01:46:10.658 --> 01:46:12.136
<v Steve Novick>Just hold forth on that, please.

921
01:46:13.037 --> 01:46:26.614
<v Earl Riley>I know we have been through several trainings there and it's just kind of like to get the COG kind of familiar with the trainings that FIT goes through and that the PBB goes through.

922
01:46:27.819 --> 01:46:31.756
<v Edith Thrower>I'd like to add that we require this of every member of the COG.

923
01:46:32.511 --> 01:46:39.372
<v Edith Thrower>It is, it is, it's part of their orientation to enter into the CPA, the, the commu— the Community Police Academy.

924
01:46:40.032 --> 01:46:43.550
<v Edith Thrower>Um, everyone has reported a very— well, we've had mixed reviews.

925
01:46:44.128 --> 01:46:56.746
<v Edith Thrower>Um, in fact, uh, we've— one of the recommendations came, um, out of a member's observation there, but pretty much, um, people Members have expressed, you know, gratitude for going.

926
01:46:57.247 --> 01:46:59.498
<v Edith Thrower>Um, it's, it's, uh, very well done.

927
01:47:00.082 --> 01:47:05.082
<v Edith Thrower>Um, and, um, and they, they've learned a lot about police practices.

928
01:47:05.534 --> 01:47:07.912
<v Edith Thrower>So the, the group does support the academy.

929
01:47:09.238 --> 01:47:09.659
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

930
01:47:09.951 --> 01:47:10.662
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal.

931
01:47:13.523 --> 01:47:14.961
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair Novick.

932
01:47:16.180 --> 01:47:17.618
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thanks everybody for being here.

933
01:47:17.975 --> 01:47:22.697
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate the members that are all— I like the list of names you mentioned earlier Terrence and Gina and all the work that, that they've done.

934
01:47:22.809 --> 01:47:23.337
<v Sameer Kanal>Juma as well.

935
01:47:23.609 --> 01:47:24.988
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate the staff as well.

936
01:47:25.132 --> 01:47:26.046
<v Sameer Kanal>Edith, uh, good to see you.

937
01:47:26.110 --> 01:47:27.056
<v Sameer Kanal>Liz, good to see you.

938
01:47:27.296 --> 01:47:28.707
<v Sameer Kanal>Mila, Commander Crooker, and more.

939
01:47:29.301 --> 01:47:36.161
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, full disclosure before I start, I worked with FIT Cog and supported their work in my old job from July 2022 to October 2024.

940
01:47:37.074 --> 01:47:39.302
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, couple comments and I have a couple questions at the end.

941
01:47:39.399 --> 01:47:43.759
<v Sameer Kanal>I've done some ride-alongs, um, and one was with FIT with Officer Hubert specifically.

942
01:47:43.823 --> 01:47:45.618
<v Sameer Kanal>I look forward to doing one with ECST as well.

943
01:47:46.148 --> 01:47:49.818
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it was really helpful for me personally to see And understand a bit of the work.

944
01:47:50.378 --> 01:47:53.327
<v Sameer Kanal>I also appreciate, Commander Crooker, your point about the level of training.

945
01:47:53.439 --> 01:47:55.827
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a really important part of this conversation as well.

946
01:47:56.787 --> 01:47:59.497
<v Sameer Kanal>I understand that FITCOC was not an afterthought.

947
01:47:59.689 --> 01:48:02.364
<v Sameer Kanal>I kind of saw the beginning of that development.

948
01:48:02.412 --> 01:48:14.350
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope that next time we talk about it, we can talk about from PPB getting some context as to why the FIT's predecessors, which did not have an attached oversight group, were not as successful.

949
01:48:14.399 --> 01:48:14.494
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

950
01:48:15.314 --> 01:48:17.038
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that comparison point would be helpful.

951
01:48:17.474 --> 01:48:27.322
<v Sameer Kanal>Also why they didn't continue, meaning I'd like the history as to why there wasn't a dedicated gun violence reduction-oriented team at PPB at the time that the choice was made to create the FIT.

952
01:48:28.895 --> 01:48:37.966
<v Sameer Kanal>FIT and ECST are examples of PPB focusing on a primary priority that I think is a consensus in this community, responding to gun violence and reducing the recurrence of it.

953
01:48:38.802 --> 01:48:43.744
<v Sameer Kanal>The last topic raised issues of changing away from a culture of response or punishment to a culture of repair.

954
01:48:44.354 --> 01:48:53.631
<v Sameer Kanal>It raised a concern for me that we can't even get majority support on this council to ask PPB to prioritize within the responses on things like prioritizing human trafficking over protest response.

955
01:48:53.984 --> 01:48:55.926
<v Sameer Kanal>But FIT is a good example of that priority.

956
01:48:56.537 --> 01:48:59.489
<v Sameer Kanal>It is also the question of how that priority would be pursued.

957
01:48:59.747 --> 01:49:05.364
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's where I think that historical context would be helpful, as well as more information on the claim of no complaints.

958
01:49:05.797 --> 01:49:07.145
<v Sameer Kanal>That was a bit of a surprise to me.

959
01:49:07.226 --> 01:49:08.671
<v Sameer Kanal>I know there was an internal review.

960
01:49:09.136 --> 01:49:11.414
<v Sameer Kanal>On cases like that of Tyrone Johnson, for example.

961
01:49:11.463 --> 01:49:17.337
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I might follow up for more information offline on that, um, and, and understand what you mean exactly by that.

962
01:49:17.882 --> 01:49:23.917
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, very interested in the FIT training needs assessment historical repository recommendation and the patches recommendation.

963
01:49:23.980 --> 01:49:25.666
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll probably follow up for more on that too.

964
01:49:26.387 --> 01:49:33.432
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I just wanted to get on the record something that I wish I had understood when I started working with FITCOG, um, in my earlier years.

965
01:49:33.706 --> 01:49:35.631
<v Sameer Kanal>If anyone's looking at the word oversight Right.

966
01:49:35.792 --> 01:49:45.645
<v Sameer Kanal>In the name and thinking of it in a reactive way or a responsive way, an after-the-fact, let's hold you accountable for the thing that you did or didn't do kind of way.

967
01:49:45.740 --> 01:49:50.185
<v Sameer Kanal>That's, that's holding FITCOG to a standard that's not the standard of FITCOG.

968
01:49:50.668 --> 01:49:51.603
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not the point.

969
01:49:52.423 --> 01:50:04.605
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that what I learned during it is that FITCOG is more actively involved during the conversation and, and frankly prior to many of the occurrences that occur on a FIT officer shift.

970
01:50:05.345 --> 01:50:12.893
<v Sameer Kanal>They've at times called themselves a proactive oversight model, and I think that's really valuable to differentiate and very helpful to do.

971
01:50:13.198 --> 01:50:22.657
<v Sameer Kanal>I think you referred to it here as guidance and mentorship in the slides, and that's valid and it's valuable, and that's okay, and it's different from what like a CBPA offers.

972
01:50:22.770 --> 01:50:26.190
<v Sameer Kanal>So there's often a question of why is there a redundancy or something like that.

973
01:50:26.238 --> 01:50:26.817
<v Sameer Kanal>There isn't one.

974
01:50:27.490 --> 01:50:28.534
<v Sameer Kanal>They just happen to use the name oversight.

975
01:50:28.922 --> 01:50:30.021
<v Sameer Kanal>Oversight, the word oversight.

976
01:50:30.070 --> 01:50:32.479
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think it's really helpful to know it was good for me.

977
01:50:34.239 --> 01:50:34.724
<v Sameer Kanal>My questions.

978
01:50:37.078 --> 01:50:42.628
<v Sameer Kanal>Commander Crooker, you mentioned that there are an authorized staffing level of 2 sergeants and 12 officers.

979
01:50:43.547 --> 01:50:48.661
<v Sameer Kanal>A lot of the officers that have been with FIT have been there for a long time, but the sergeants I know have rotated.

980
01:50:49.113 --> 01:50:53.854
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to how that works and what the— if there have been any impacts of that?

981
01:50:56.077 --> 01:51:02.418
<v James Crooker>Yeah, I mean, maintaining continuity in a team when you have a change in supervision is always, you know, a challenge.

982
01:51:02.484 --> 01:51:03.667
<v James Crooker>That's something that we pay attention to.

983
01:51:04.170 --> 01:51:17.350
<v James Crooker>The FIT team also has, as a result of that, that we're currently working on a contract or a partnership with to make sure that we have enhanced training supervision for the lieutenant and the sergeants of the FITCOG.

984
01:51:19.371 --> 01:51:38.798
<v James Crooker>I think for me, For me, because I was there from the beginning, the important thing is to understand what the mission and the goal of the team is and making sure that the sergeants, sergeants are probably the most important leadership rank in any organization, that line-level supervision is critical in making sure that we are going in the right direction.

985
01:51:40.546 --> 01:52:04.314
<v James Crooker>And when we have sergeants come on, I make sure that we have really intentional conversations with those sergeants about the goal, the vision, the direction of what the team is, and ensuring that we adhere to that and that there is not a deviation from that into something that might seem easy to have happen in the absence of that close oversight.

986
01:52:04.923 --> 01:52:23.972
<v James Crooker>And we've been very lucky in the fact that we've selected very capable and bright and engaging sergeants and so, you know, everybody's encouraged to look to the future and, you know, to build their career the way that they would like to build their careers and have a future in the Bureau the way that they'd like to have it.

987
01:52:24.020 --> 01:52:30.213
<v James Crooker>And I think the FIT team is a really good launching board for a lot of supervisors to go on to bigger and better things in the organization.

988
01:52:30.279 --> 01:52:31.626
<v James Crooker>And I don't want to stand in the way of that.

989
01:52:32.108 --> 01:52:46.405
<v James Crooker>And so we just are very intentional about making sure that every time we have a new sergeant come in, that they they are following all of those sort of, you know, genesis documents to make sure that we stick to the principles that we started with, that you were part of a little bit of that.

990
01:52:47.131 --> 01:52:48.210
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I appreciate that.

991
01:52:48.274 --> 01:52:53.201
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that relates to the historical repository side from the COG recommendation side too.

992
01:52:53.282 --> 01:52:54.908
<v Sameer Kanal>So that aligns.

993
01:52:54.957 --> 01:52:55.568
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for that.

994
01:52:56.930 --> 01:52:57.384
<v Edith Thrower>Yeah.

995
01:52:57.448 --> 01:53:02.916
<v Sameer Kanal>With relation to the COG, 9 out of 15 are filled right now, as you mentioned.

996
01:53:02.963 --> 01:53:05.890
<v Sameer Kanal>Has anyone new been appointed since Mayor Wilson took office?

997
01:53:07.557 --> 01:53:10.909
<v Edith Thrower>Yes, excuse me, yes, 4 members were appointed.

998
01:53:11.378 --> 01:53:23.529
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, this is one of the ones where, um, obviously Mayor Wilson has the right to appoint, um, and I think one of the things we haven't yet addressed, uh, and this is more for the administrator, is how we have the transparency around that.

999
01:53:23.721 --> 01:53:32.967
<v Sameer Kanal>Normally, um, a lot of advisory groups around the, the city, and this is, this is more than just an advisory group, so I, I think that's a a, a bar that we should exceed.

1000
01:53:33.436 --> 01:53:34.488
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we would do a report.

1001
01:53:35.037 --> 01:53:43.832
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and so I would love to, to talk about how we do that, because one of the great things, um, that happened in the last year or so is I— well, actually, let me confirm that.

1002
01:53:43.993 --> 01:53:45.023
<v Sameer Kanal>Is funding now ongoing?

1003
01:53:46.502 --> 01:53:47.837
<v Edith Thrower>It is, and thank you.

1004
01:53:48.192 --> 01:53:52.707
<v Edith Thrower>Okay, well, that's premature, but pending the vote that occurs this week.

1005
01:53:53.158 --> 01:53:58.618
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so FITCOC's been one-time funded after one- Yeah.

1006
01:53:58.860 --> 01:54:02.590
<v Sameer Kanal>And so if that goes through, I think that's really important and I'm supportive of it.

1007
01:54:04.409 --> 01:54:11.283
<v Sameer Kanal>One thing though, I think FITCOG, other than the budget authorization, is primarily created through a set of press releases.

1008
01:54:13.021 --> 01:54:23.752
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think getting things written down, including how we have that transparency into appointments, would be really helpful because I actually didn't know and I probably could have just asked a while ago.

1009
01:54:24.353 --> 01:54:25.444
<v Sameer Kanal>It'd be helpful to know that.

1010
01:54:25.797 --> 01:54:33.746
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think to ensure that the folks on this side of the dais are aware on a regularized basis as people are being appointed of the work.

1011
01:54:34.774 --> 01:54:42.625
<v Sameer Kanal>In other words, I think there are levels of low to high profile within the ranks of volunteer groups in the city.

1012
01:54:43.203 --> 01:54:46.094
<v Sameer Kanal>And we should probably take this one up at least a rung on the ladder.

1013
01:54:47.234 --> 01:54:49.320
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think one of the ways to do that is the appointments.

1014
01:54:49.945 --> 01:54:52.046
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's all I have right now.

1015
01:54:52.189 --> 01:54:52.430
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1016
01:54:53.167 --> 01:54:53.969
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

1017
01:54:54.130 --> 01:54:59.851
<v Steve Novick>Seeing no one else in the queue, I really appreciate your reaching out to ask to come here.

1018
01:55:00.524 --> 01:55:05.685
<v Steve Novick>And I'm one of the people that was woefully uninformed about the work of the FITCOG.

1019
01:55:05.734 --> 01:55:11.456
<v Steve Novick>So I really, I in particular personally really appreciate it and look forward to continuing conversations.

1020
01:55:11.824 --> 01:55:13.444
<v Steve Novick>Edith, was there something you wanted to add at the—.

1021
01:55:13.444 --> 01:55:14.469
<v Edith Thrower>One final comment.

1022
01:55:14.805 --> 01:55:17.707
<v Edith Thrower>We made a presentation before Mr. Lee.

1023
01:55:18.318 --> 01:55:26.244
<v Edith Thrower>It was a little more comprehensive than, than this presentation, um, but, uh, uh, we didn't have the time constraint.

1024
01:55:27.020 --> 01:55:27.166
<v Robert Taylor>His—.

1025
01:55:27.587 --> 01:55:36.520
<v Edith Thrower>After observing, um, our presentation and another advisory body's presentation, he asked, where do you see yourselves going from here?

1026
01:55:38.046 --> 01:55:43.650
<v Edith Thrower>And we were all like, well, you know, where?

1027
01:55:43.747 --> 01:55:43.877
<v Steve Novick>Where?

1028
01:55:44.342 --> 01:55:54.073
<v Edith Thrower>We're so involved in doing the work, we're not thinking about where we're going from here necessarily, but we're not thinking about an endgame.

1029
01:55:54.618 --> 01:56:09.327
<v Edith Thrower>To his point and to Councilor Kanal's point, we see ourselves, and I've discussed this both with the Vice Chair and the Chair, as being more proactive as opposed to reactive in this body of work.

1030
01:56:09.872 --> 01:56:35.251
<v Edith Thrower>One of the overall community sentiment in the ongoing survey that they're doing and what we've gathered so far is that residents describe gun violence as a related disorder as— I mean, I'm sorry, describe gun violence and related disorder as a real and persistent issue and expressed a strong desire for practical, balanced solutions rather than ideological positions.

1031
01:56:35.993 --> 01:56:40.115
<v Edith Thrower>So it behooves us to be proactive in our work.

1032
01:56:41.134 --> 01:56:41.942
<v Edith Thrower>And that's the goal.

1033
01:56:42.346 --> 01:56:43.025
<v Edith Thrower>That's the aim.

1034
01:56:43.920 --> 01:56:44.212
<v Edith Thrower>Thank you.

1035
01:56:46.141 --> 01:56:47.002
<v Steve Novick>Thank you so much.

1036
01:56:47.439 --> 01:56:54.786
<v Steve Novick>We're now going to— the council president has waited patiently to talk about concealed carry.

1037
01:56:55.386 --> 01:56:59.505
<v Steve Novick>By pursuant to the council president's directions, I need to give everybody a 12-minute break.

1038
01:57:00.378 --> 01:57:02.693
<v Steve Novick>We will come back at 11:34.

1039
02:10:05.807 --> 02:10:07.257
<v Steve Novick>I actually— excuse me.

1040
02:10:07.456 --> 02:10:09.444
<v Steve Novick>Could you read the first item?

1041
02:10:09.492 --> 02:10:15.362
<v Steve Novick>And then I am gonna wait a minute because I kind of think that we need most— we need more of us here, even though I said 11:34.

1042
02:10:16.068 --> 02:10:16.548
<v Tristan Edwards>Certainly.

1043
02:10:17.014 --> 02:10:36.761
<v Tristan Edwards>Item number 4, document number 2026-123, amend code related to prohibitions on possession of firearms within certain city buildings to disallow affirmative defense for persons with concealed handgun licenses.

1044
02:10:37.363 --> 02:10:51.222
<v Tristan Edwards>Amend City Code Sections 3.18.020, 14A60.010, and 20.12.050.

1045
02:10:54.230 --> 02:10:54.603
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1046
02:10:54.975 --> 02:10:57.773
<v Steve Novick>Mr. President, Mr. Harford, could you come up slowly?

1047
02:10:57.886 --> 02:10:59.807
<v Steve Novick>I'm hoping at least one more councilor will join us.

1048
02:10:59.942 --> 02:11:00.176
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1049
02:11:00.279 --> 02:11:03.439
<v Steve Novick>Now we got 4.

1050
02:11:03.439 --> 02:11:18.970
<v Steve Novick>And it has been a while, so if you could give a recap of what the legislation is about and then describe the amendment that grows out of the last conversation we have.

1051
02:11:20.180 --> 02:11:20.680
<v Eben Harford>Absolutely.

1052
02:11:20.680 --> 02:11:21.949
<v Eben Harford>I will do my very best.

1053
02:11:22.140 --> 02:11:23.600
<v Eben Harford>Thanks all.

1054
02:11:23.600 --> 02:11:30.340
<v Eben Harford>So in brief, there are pretty wide-ranging limitations on the kinds of weapons that you can have in a public building.

1055
02:11:33.787 --> 02:11:34.078
<v Michael>Under—.

1056
02:11:34.222 --> 02:11:41.037
<v Eben Harford>Until last year, concealed handguns were presumptively allowed in any public building in a public meeting.

1057
02:11:42.373 --> 02:11:46.953
<v Eben Harford>It was an affirmative defense to any law that attempted to limit that.

1058
02:11:48.472 --> 02:12:07.064
<v Eben Harford>In last year's long session, the legislature allowed localities to say, you know what, that affirmative defense of I have a concealed handgun, license on a city-by-city basis or a locality-by-locality basis, you can say, no, we don't want to have that anymore.

1059
02:12:08.444 --> 02:12:13.412
<v Eben Harford>So late last year, Multnomah County instantiated that.

1060
02:12:13.475 --> 02:12:22.099
<v Eben Harford>They said we're going to not have concealed handguns be allowed in public buildings where there is a public hearing.

1061
02:12:22.194 --> 02:12:28.229
<v Eben Harford>So things like council chambers, the meeting space over where the planning commission meets yeah.

1062
02:12:28.313 --> 02:12:28.645
<v Jamie Dunphy>Et cetera.

1063
02:12:29.246 --> 02:12:30.680
<v Eben Harford>So the county did that last fall.

1064
02:12:32.268 --> 02:12:35.684
<v Eben Harford>This ordinance does essentially the exact same thing for the city.

1065
02:12:36.313 --> 02:12:51.180
<v Eben Harford>So it's specific to places where we have public meetings, which is this room, it's the 1900 building, and where there are official oversight bodies that meet in those spaces as well when those are stood up.

1066
02:12:51.261 --> 02:12:55.068
<v Eben Harford>If it's in a public building, you wouldn't be able to have a concealed handgun there either.

1067
02:12:56.770 --> 02:13:00.126
<v Eben Harford>And the actual code, there's 3 exhibits.

1068
02:13:00.175 --> 02:13:02.097
<v Eben Harford>So it touches the law in 3 places.

1069
02:13:04.710 --> 02:13:08.453
<v Eben Harford>You have rules of conduct at city property, which is Exhibit A.

1070
02:13:09.599 --> 02:13:12.826
<v Eben Harford>So there's a number of weapons here that you can't have on city property.

1071
02:13:13.587 --> 02:13:22.704
<v Eben Harford>And we add a bit of text that says the affirmative defense that says I have a concealed handgun license, that's not going to work anymore on city property.

1072
02:13:24.400 --> 02:13:36.524
<v Eben Harford>Over in Exhibit B, I'll just say Exhibit A is the main event, and then there's a couple other places where there's lists of weapons you can't have places, and then we kind of true up the language in those spots.

1073
02:13:37.086 --> 02:13:46.688
<v Eben Harford>So Exhibit B controls having a loaded firearm in a public place, which is something you can't do in Portland, and it basically ports in that same language.

1074
02:13:46.752 --> 02:13:56.387
<v Eben Harford>So in case you read 14A-60-010 and thought that it maybe superseded the prohibition on having a gun in a public meeting.

1075
02:13:56.613 --> 02:13:56.886
<v Eben Harford>It doesn't.

1076
02:13:58.060 --> 02:14:03.845
<v Eben Harford>And then over in Exhibit C, we have the situation, public parks.

1077
02:14:04.729 --> 02:14:07.027
<v Eben Harford>So parks also have a prohibition on carrying weapons.

1078
02:14:07.074 --> 02:14:19.694
<v Eben Harford>It does the same thing, flies in that same language, says in the weird situation in which there was a you flew council chambers in the future into a public park once again.

1079
02:14:21.216 --> 02:14:24.130
<v Eben Harford>This exemption, this affirmative defense does not apply here.

1080
02:14:24.712 --> 02:14:31.100
<v Eben Harford>So everywhere where we have those lists of prohibited weapons, this mention of the affirmative defense is added.

1081
02:14:31.761 --> 02:14:32.761
<v Eben Harford>So that's what this does.

1082
02:14:33.841 --> 02:14:34.728
<v Eben Harford>Relatively narrow.

1083
02:14:35.275 --> 02:14:39.930
<v Eben Harford>There's 2 things that came up in conversation at the last hearing.

1084
02:14:40.078 --> 02:14:40.323
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1085
02:14:41.479 --> 02:14:48.664
<v Eben Harford>The first was around the exact way that Exhibit C was fixed up by the legal folks.

1086
02:14:50.475 --> 02:15:05.503
<v Eben Harford>In that wording, we also added a reference to 14A-60-030, which is this sort of relatively new description of tear gas and pepper spray and tear gas canisters.

1087
02:15:06.926 --> 02:15:21.537
<v Eben Harford>The way that this was worded would seem to make carrying pepper spray for personal protection, for personal defense, a mace canister or something like that, presumptively illegal in a park.

1088
02:15:22.661 --> 02:15:25.166
<v Eben Harford>And if you're just passing through a park, that doesn't make a lot of sense.

1089
02:15:26.128 --> 02:15:44.224
<v Eben Harford>So what the amendment does is it takes out the word tear gas, mace, and pepper mace, which are together in the first first prong, there's like 2 buckets of kinds of deleterious aerosol agent in the relevant code, and says, all right, that's not something we're going to list as presumptively illegal.

1090
02:15:45.199 --> 02:15:55.099
<v Eben Harford>Instead, if you go up above, it would just categorize— be categorized as any object carried with the intent to threaten or cause bodily harm to another.

1091
02:15:55.711 --> 02:15:58.797
<v Eben Harford>So if you're carrying that mace for your own protection, it should be okay.

1092
02:15:59.520 --> 02:16:04.738
<v Eben Harford>If you're walking around with a, with a big can of bear mace threatening people, that would not be okay.

1093
02:16:05.688 --> 02:16:10.805
<v Eben Harford>So that's what the amendment does, just, just trying to be responsive to the questions from the dais last time.

1094
02:16:11.619 --> 02:16:31.483
<v Eben Harford>Finally, there was some concern from the dais in the last reading of this about whether employees of the city who had a concealed handgun license whether this would change their status of whether or not they could have their weapon with them while they were at work.

1095
02:16:32.427 --> 02:16:34.288
<v Eben Harford>And we had a lot of back and forth about that.

1096
02:16:34.368 --> 02:16:55.119
<v Eben Harford>We clarified in an email after the hearing that currently under HRAR 4.12, it's a condition of employment with the city that you can't have a dangerous or deadly weapon, which does include a handgun and specifically includes It doesn't matter whether you have a CHL or not.

1097
02:16:56.227 --> 02:16:57.842
<v Eben Harford>And that's been law in the city.

1098
02:16:58.808 --> 02:17:01.050
<v Eben Harford>We went back into the arc— sorry, you're right.

1099
02:17:01.181 --> 02:17:07.502
<v Eben Harford>That has been administrative rule in the city or binding city policy, not law, since 2002.

1100
02:17:08.308 --> 02:17:11.472
<v Eben Harford>That was when that was first passed in by council via ordinance.

1101
02:17:13.447 --> 02:17:19.588
<v Eben Harford>And it's pursuant to the option of an employer to contract freely with an employee.

1102
02:17:19.684 --> 02:17:20.864
<v Eben Harford>So that can be the conditions of contract.

1103
02:17:20.930 --> 02:17:21.123
<v Eben Harford>Thank you.

1104
02:17:21.397 --> 02:17:24.477
<v Eben Harford>Which is constitutionally protected as well.

1105
02:17:25.814 --> 02:17:27.004
<v Eben Harford>Anyway, so that's what this is.

1106
02:17:27.718 --> 02:17:31.277
<v Eben Harford>Thank you for listening to that somewhat long explanation, but hopefully we're all up to speed.

1107
02:17:33.439 --> 02:17:33.979
<v Loretta Smith>Bless you.

1108
02:17:34.209 --> 02:17:36.689
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith, is that a legacy hand or a new hand?

1109
02:17:38.421 --> 02:17:39.429
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

1110
02:17:40.957 --> 02:17:51.201
<v Loretta Smith>But currently, just so that we're clear, folks from the outside can come in here with their concealed weapon permit and they're allowed to come into City Hall?

1111
02:17:51.459 --> 02:17:55.720
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, members of the— sorry, for the record, uh, Jamie Dunphy, Portland City Councilor.

1112
02:17:56.250 --> 02:18:06.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, yes, currently under, under the existing rules, any member of the public who has a concealed handgun license can walk through City Hall and be able to come into a meeting in a public space.

1113
02:18:06.763 --> 02:18:07.019
<v Loretta Smith>But—.

1114
02:18:07.227 --> 02:18:07.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>But employees cannot.

1115
02:18:07.965 --> 02:18:09.390
<v Loretta Smith>But employees cannot.

1116
02:18:09.470 --> 02:18:15.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Correct, unless otherwise explicitly described in their okay, and counselors cannot?

1117
02:18:16.075 --> 02:18:16.397
<v Jamie Dunphy>Correct.

1118
02:18:16.800 --> 02:18:21.619
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, just wanted to make sure because I saw some folks coming in with their concealed weapon permit.

1119
02:18:21.716 --> 02:18:23.213
<v Loretta Smith>I was like, okay, thanks.

1120
02:18:28.740 --> 02:18:37.561
<v Steve Novick>I have a question about— I think, Mr. Harper, you're talking about buildings where there are public meetings like the 1900 Building and City Hall.

1121
02:18:38.275 --> 02:18:44.072
<v Steve Novick>When I look at the language, it refers to buildings owned or controlled by the city for use for official meetings.

1122
02:18:44.832 --> 02:18:50.576
<v Steve Novick>And that would seem to me to include any official meeting, whether the public is invited or not.

1123
02:18:53.715 --> 02:18:56.824
<v Eben Harford>I would have to defer to the lawyers on that one.

1124
02:18:57.033 --> 02:19:01.639
<v Eben Harford>If we have legal counsel here, we may not.

1125
02:19:04.287 --> 02:19:07.783
<v Eben Harford>But if you'll give me a second to look into the code, I can try to answer that question a little better.

1126
02:19:10.104 --> 02:19:22.743
<v Steve Novick>I confess that one of the reasons I was interested in that is I was looking for some reason at the concealed carry rules in Oklahoma, and they ban concealed carry in buildings which I think involve meetings that the public is involved in.

1127
02:19:22.936 --> 02:19:26.585
<v Steve Novick>So I was curious as to whether this is the same as that or different.

1128
02:19:28.694 --> 02:19:29.246
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman.

1129
02:19:31.450 --> 02:19:32.034
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1130
02:19:32.911 --> 02:19:47.718
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am really, really hoping that I just want to make sure that everybody who's going to take a vote on this can think about some of the terms that we're using and that we have our kind of our facts and ducks in a row in terms of what it is that you're, you're considering taking here.

1131
02:19:47.782 --> 02:20:01.367
<v Eric Zimmerman>Last time it was almost confusing listening to this panel and the presenters talk about what it meant to have a concealed weapon, and it was so bad that it almost seemed like people thought folks were walking in here with visible weapons.

1132
02:20:01.415 --> 02:20:01.849
<v Brandon Brown>I think that's a good point.

1133
02:20:03.549 --> 02:20:07.548
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that isn't the case, right?

1134
02:20:07.840 --> 02:20:15.546
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that I last time cited that in 5 years there were 3 incidents, or it was in 3 years there were 5 incidents, something along those lines.

1135
02:20:15.708 --> 02:20:28.120
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in those cases, a person was stopped at our metal detectors, proved that they had a legal right to carry, and that's the end of the story because they were carrying a firearm legally.

1136
02:20:28.168 --> 02:20:28.315
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1137
02:20:28.809 --> 02:20:43.661
<v Eric Zimmerman>Part of the idea of a concealed carry permit is that you've gone through the required local sheriff, you know, steps to get that, which is another way of saying you've followed the law.

1138
02:20:46.274 --> 02:20:52.076
<v Eric Zimmerman>The state's previous ability to have the affirmative defense, I guess I don't understand the rush.

1139
02:20:52.531 --> 02:20:57.855
<v Eric Zimmerman>Well, Councilor Dunphy, to change something.

1140
02:20:58.450 --> 02:21:00.024
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not sure what's not working.

1141
02:21:00.395 --> 02:21:22.836
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not sure what you're trying to solve here with respect to now that cities can get rid of that affirmative defense for those people who have chosen to say, I'm going to put my name on a public registry that says I have a, a concealed weapons permit and I've followed the law, why it is that they're your target versus illegal gun owners or people who seek to do violence?

1142
02:21:22.902 --> 02:21:25.388
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I'm not seeing the connective tissue right now.

1143
02:21:26.462 --> 02:21:35.847
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I wasn't understanding what was broken prior to this state action that you're trying to fix now that the state has said, if you want to, cities, you can do it.

1144
02:21:36.009 --> 02:21:37.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>What are you trying to solve here?

1145
02:21:37.549 --> 02:21:40.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I mean, philosophically, I'm trying to have no guns in City Hall.

1146
02:21:42.024 --> 02:21:44.864
<v Eric Zimmerman>Does that work for— I mean, I get that.

1147
02:21:44.929 --> 02:21:45.859
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have that same desire.

1148
02:21:46.131 --> 02:21:59.933
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, but there's— so there's, there's 2 people on either side of you right now who are carrying guns, and there's a few people outside who are carrying guns solely for the fact that sometimes people don't give a damn about what law you just said, right, or just passed.

1149
02:21:59.981 --> 02:22:08.943
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what about this keeps a person intent on doing violence from doing violence?

1150
02:22:09.056 --> 02:22:21.574
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, well, as I, I think I said last time I was here, And a philosophical argument that I learned was that 75% of people won't— don't need a law to do what's right, and 10% of people won't ever do what's right no matter what the law.

1151
02:22:22.183 --> 02:22:23.737
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so we're governing for the 15%.

1152
02:22:24.346 --> 02:22:28.002
<v Jamie Dunphy>And you're right, absolutely, we do need to have police.

1153
02:22:28.129 --> 02:22:34.108
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need our security to be able to keep us safe, and we need additional tools at every level in order to be able to make sure that that is the case.

1154
02:22:34.220 --> 02:22:54.476
<v Jamie Dunphy>This seems to me, you know, first of all, not a rushed situation as the state we passed it last year, and in the time since then, the Oregon Health Authority, the Oregon Youth Authority, the Oregon Department of Administrative Services, Port of Portland, Multnomah County have all passed this as a rule for their public bodies.

1155
02:22:54.667 --> 02:22:56.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we're actually a little bit behind.

1156
02:22:56.449 --> 02:22:57.186
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, so let's be clear.

1157
02:22:57.459 --> 02:22:57.572
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

1158
02:22:57.796 --> 02:22:59.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>Rules and laws are very different.

1159
02:22:59.304 --> 02:22:59.480
<v Bob Day>Sure.

1160
02:22:59.640 --> 02:23:00.555
<v Eric Zimmerman>Am I incorrect?

1161
02:23:00.683 --> 02:23:06.314
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are you trying to pass a rule, which is just enforceable by, you know, an HR thing, or are you trying to pass a law, Councilor?

1162
02:23:06.361 --> 02:23:07.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, this is an ordinance.

1163
02:23:07.325 --> 02:23:09.879
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am trying to the Oregon Health Authority doesn't pass laws.

1164
02:23:09.976 --> 02:23:10.313
<v James Crooker>Correct.

1165
02:23:10.634 --> 02:23:12.852
<v Eric Zimmerman>The Oregon Youth Authority doesn't pass laws.

1166
02:23:13.286 --> 02:23:15.905
<v Eric Zimmerman>They pass policy in their place.

1167
02:23:16.082 --> 02:23:27.184
<v Eric Zimmerman>The reason— this is what I'm hoping folks will really gear into— is I appreciate that there are policies, and those are, those are applicable to the extent that that policy hits.

1168
02:23:27.248 --> 02:23:29.611
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what you're asking to do is change a law.

1169
02:23:29.980 --> 02:23:30.093
<v Bob Day>Yes.

1170
02:23:30.398 --> 02:23:37.375
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so if a person violates this law in the future, What type of crime will they be guilty of or accused of?

1171
02:23:40.058 --> 02:23:46.665
<v Eben Harford>All the way through this, at the very end of the process, there is a felony charge.

1172
02:23:46.729 --> 02:23:47.881
<v Eric Zimmerman>A felony, folks.

1173
02:23:48.932 --> 02:23:59.968
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in their presentation, they tried to equate an HR policy, which, you know, any employee is going to take that into their— and, you know, I drove a county car once over the speed limit.

1174
02:24:00.083 --> 02:24:00.810
<v Eric Zimmerman>I violated policy.

1175
02:24:01.787 --> 02:24:03.132
<v Eric Zimmerman>By God, slap me with a felony.

1176
02:24:04.447 --> 02:24:06.337
<v Eric Zimmerman>My point is, let's not conflate the two.

1177
02:24:07.091 --> 02:24:16.834
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think you are conflating the two in a manner that is kind of disrespectful, frankly, to people who have chosen to follow the law and get a permit.

1178
02:24:17.011 --> 02:24:30.873
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so an HR policy is fine to have, but a felony, a felony for otherwise doing what the state has said Here's how you will have— here's how you follow the law.

1179
02:24:31.101 --> 02:24:36.004
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I am just asking us to please take a look at what this means.

1180
02:24:36.263 --> 02:24:39.210
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to give you one example from the staff one which they just presented.

1181
02:24:39.984 --> 02:24:41.127
<v Eric Zimmerman>They're, they're making some changes.

1182
02:24:41.191 --> 02:24:43.833
<v Eric Zimmerman>And last time we talked a lot about mace, pepper spray.

1183
02:24:43.913 --> 02:24:49.181
<v Eric Zimmerman>Hell, I think even Novick over here was talking about nunchucks or something.

1184
02:24:49.229 --> 02:24:54.630
<v Eric Zimmerman>There was something that— there was some weapon that we were all unfamiliar— it was a different kind A mace.

1185
02:24:54.743 --> 02:24:55.353
<v Sameer Kanal>That's what it was.

1186
02:24:55.932 --> 02:24:56.752
<v Eric Zimmerman>Anyway, my point—.

1187
02:24:56.752 --> 02:24:58.840
<v Steve Novick>I thought I was asking about the difference between dirks and daggers.

1188
02:24:58.936 --> 02:25:01.827
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, so my point here, I do appreciate those changes.

1189
02:25:01.957 --> 02:25:03.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to, I want to give credit where credit's due.

1190
02:25:03.498 --> 02:25:13.570
<v Eric Zimmerman>I disagree that this needs to come forward, but thank you for addressing the fact that I bet we have employees today who have mace in their pocket, in their locker, or in their purse.

1191
02:25:14.816 --> 02:25:21.141
<v Eric Zimmerman>That might be a violation of city policy, and no one will ever know until the day it has to get used.

1192
02:25:21.207 --> 02:25:24.291
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then I'd say I dare the city to enforce that policy.

1193
02:25:25.033 --> 02:25:29.450
<v Eric Zimmerman>So this is one of those— there's a silliness that sometimes it comes along with certain types of things.

1194
02:25:30.048 --> 02:25:33.173
<v Eric Zimmerman>But at the same time, this change for parks was a really good one.

1195
02:25:33.352 --> 02:25:37.036
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that'll be an important— if you guys end up passing this, pass that amendment.

1196
02:25:37.743 --> 02:25:48.801
<v Eric Zimmerman>But here's what the staff said: mace for your own protection is okay, but carrying a big can of bear spray or intimidating others is not okay.

1197
02:25:48.882 --> 02:25:59.878
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I would, I would give to you, everybody, that is the exact example of the difference between an open carry of a rifle or even a gun on the hip versus a concealed carry.

1198
02:26:00.536 --> 02:26:04.292
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because a concealed carry, one should never know that someone is concealed carrying.

1199
02:26:04.549 --> 02:26:05.546
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's the whole point.

1200
02:26:06.333 --> 02:26:32.263
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so in the sponsor's own language about why mace in a park is okay, I think they've given you why a concealed weapons permit holder should not be the concern if your concern is violence, if your concern is gun violence, in the list of people to be worried about, those who put their name on a, on a public registry, ask for a background check, ask for a course, and carry a permit to do so, they're not the concern here.

1201
02:26:32.730 --> 02:26:44.198
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if you have a concealed permit for your own protection, it's not okay, but if you have mace for your own protection, it's okay.

1202
02:26:44.290 --> 02:26:44.867
<v Edith Thrower>Yes.

1203
02:26:45.123 --> 02:26:47.532
<v Eric Zimmerman>But carrying a big can of pepper spray is not okay.

1204
02:26:47.692 --> 02:26:50.021
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what are we trying to do here?

1205
02:26:50.182 --> 02:26:53.152
<v Eric Zimmerman>So the, the— it doesn't hold up.

1206
02:26:54.019 --> 02:26:57.052
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the consequences are why this matters, colleagues.

1207
02:26:58.049 --> 02:26:59.831
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is not an HR policy.

1208
02:26:59.895 --> 02:27:02.753
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is not an employment policy.

1209
02:27:03.010 --> 02:27:10.459
<v Eric Zimmerman>You are asking to place a felony on those who right now under state law can do a thing.

1210
02:27:11.375 --> 02:27:13.879
<v Eric Zimmerman>And you're saying we don't think that's the truth.

1211
02:27:14.024 --> 02:27:24.465
<v Eric Zimmerman>If you think that we have this grand problem inside this building or any other Portland building with concealed weapon permit holders doing violence or threatening violence, I am all ears and I will help.

1212
02:27:24.867 --> 02:27:33.235
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I have had zero complaints in my time in office, and I've had zero complaints in my time as a chief of staff or as a senior staffer at this government or any other.

1213
02:27:33.878 --> 02:27:37.108
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I don't know what we're trying to solve.

1214
02:27:37.719 --> 02:27:54.341
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if you are dead set on this, I hope you will at least consider that you are adding a significant legal risk to people who are otherwise following the law.

1215
02:27:54.906 --> 02:27:56.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, I think that deserves our pause.

1216
02:27:57.566 --> 02:28:05.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't think that right now that this is going to make any one person or any group of people thank you, Chair.

1217
02:28:06.825 --> 02:28:07.483
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

1218
02:28:07.548 --> 02:28:08.059
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal.

1219
02:28:08.509 --> 02:28:11.009
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair Novick.

1220
02:28:11.313 --> 02:28:13.557
<v Sameer Kanal>Can I just start by asking a process question?

1221
02:28:13.653 --> 02:28:17.049
<v Sameer Kanal>Are we currently still on the underlying, or has the amendment been moved?

1222
02:28:17.387 --> 02:28:23.412
<v Steve Novick>Um, still on the underlining, but if you like to move the, move the amendment to put it to get it out there, I'd be fine with that.

1223
02:28:23.636 --> 02:28:27.082
<v Steve Novick>Although I expect that we might want to discuss the underlying a bit further before we get to vote on the amendment.

1224
02:28:27.322 --> 02:28:35.640
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, then I will wait to do that so that we can have I think one of the things that we have an opportunity to do in committee is have the broader conversation.

1225
02:28:35.753 --> 02:28:39.551
<v Sameer Kanal>And I know this is something a few of us have talked about, so I, I do intend to move it.

1226
02:28:39.600 --> 02:28:42.709
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's worth discussing, and I, I will get to that when I get to it.

1227
02:28:43.190 --> 02:28:51.269
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, I struggle with a couple of the conversations here because there are many things that I agree with in what Councilor Zimmerman just said.

1228
02:28:51.444 --> 02:29:07.843
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, I also know that there are some— we do not have the authority under the, uh, the new form of government to write administrative rules, to write HRARs, even ones that apply to us evidently, which I think is something we have to get some additional guidance on because that, that doesn't make any sense.

1229
02:29:08.085 --> 02:29:15.201
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I think as an independent branch of government, we should not be subject to mayor's, uh, HRARs.

1230
02:29:15.911 --> 02:29:34.406
<v Sameer Kanal>Having said that, um, I also know that, that there are, um, some questions that I think are not yet resolved and I do think it's fair to say that there has been a recognition by the state that anyone can currently get a concealed carry permit going through a process in their relevant counties.

1231
02:29:34.940 --> 02:29:53.436
<v Sameer Kanal>And this idea that we all have to sort of honor each other's, and also that there was a gap that they felt was sufficient enough to allow local jurisdictions to address, not to address themselves, But to allow us to, and so to enable that conversation.

1232
02:29:54.416 --> 02:30:00.088
<v Sameer Kanal>I have a feeling that no matter what we do here, we're gonna end up having this debate again at the full council.

1233
02:30:00.442 --> 02:30:06.998
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm inclined to support having that debate at the full council because I know our other 7 colleagues will have thoughts on it.

1234
02:30:07.449 --> 02:30:12.300
<v Sameer Kanal>But I also know that we should have conversations around how to make this the best product possible when it gets there.

1235
02:30:13.699 --> 02:30:25.440
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that thank you, Councilor.

1236
02:30:25.891 --> 02:30:33.941
<v Steve Novick>Um, I have— what about Councilor Zimmerman's point that this is a felony, which is a pretty darn serious thing?

1237
02:30:34.135 --> 02:30:36.521
<v Steve Novick>Would there have been an option to go with a misdemeanor instead of a felony?

1238
02:30:37.537 --> 02:30:50.557
<v Steve Novick>Do they have the other— um, has— well, the Port of Portland— I mean, does Multnomah County make it a felony to my understanding is that the proposal before us would bring us on parity with Multnomah County and the Port of Portland.

1239
02:30:52.414 --> 02:30:52.736
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1240
02:30:53.382 --> 02:30:57.838
<v Steve Novick>Would you be willing to contemplate downgrading it to a misdemeanor?

1241
02:30:58.790 --> 02:31:10.843
<v Jamie Dunphy>My understanding is that it's more of a— that the felony is at the end of the process, but that there are— it's not that if you showed up downstairs and presented your concealed carry card and said that immediately you'd be prosecuted.

1242
02:31:11.350 --> 02:31:12.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thrown into it with a charge.

1243
02:31:13.695 --> 02:31:22.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>That there's some level of processing and steps between and some discretion to be able to get to that level.

1244
02:31:22.824 --> 02:31:33.465
<v Jamie Dunphy>If it were something egregious, then a felony charge is an option for the charging officer, but that it's not necessarily guaranteed that that would be the first reaction from— for enforcement.

1245
02:31:34.012 --> 02:31:34.994
<v Steve Novick>Hmm.

1246
02:31:37.530 --> 02:31:46.047
<v Steve Novick>But I mean, is that— but is there any like lesser included charge that could be brought?

1247
02:31:47.396 --> 02:31:47.990
<v Eben Harford>Yes, Councilor.

1248
02:31:48.055 --> 02:31:54.550
<v Eben Harford>So again, let me introduce myself as not a lawyer.

1249
02:31:55.113 --> 02:31:56.370
<v Eben Harford>However, I am speaking to one.

1250
02:31:56.885 --> 02:32:01.699
<v Eben Harford>So, you know, the first thing here is that this is in the police code.

1251
02:32:02.290 --> 02:32:02.484
<v Earl Riley>Right.

1252
02:32:02.565 --> 02:32:03.666
<v Eben Harford>And public order and police.

1253
02:32:03.781 --> 02:32:10.394
<v Eben Harford>And so violations of the local code carry a potential fine and potential brief jail time.

1254
02:32:12.381 --> 02:32:14.777
<v Eben Harford>So those citations can be issued if necessary.

1255
02:32:15.213 --> 02:32:16.701
<v Eben Harford>I can even go back another step.

1256
02:32:17.058 --> 02:32:28.115
<v Eben Harford>So what you would need to do is to arrive at a public meeting with a concealed handgun, not disclose that handgun, gain access yes.

1257
02:32:28.475 --> 02:32:33.664
<v Eben Harford>To the meeting, have it be discovered, refuse to leave.

1258
02:32:36.769 --> 02:32:50.674
<v Eben Harford>And then the situation would need to be such that the city decided that whatever sanctions that it could issue via Portland City Code were insufficient and that pressing charges were necessary.

1259
02:32:51.751 --> 02:32:53.888
<v Eben Harford>So there's discretion at a number of steps of the process.

1260
02:32:57.523 --> 02:33:15.097
<v Steve Novick>So when you say that it has to be discovered and you have to be asked to leave, does that mean that if it was not discovered, but then somebody found out later on that somebody carried a concealed weapon into a public meeting, then there's— they could not be prosecuted?

1261
02:33:15.521 --> 02:33:17.149
<v Eben Harford>Oh, I wouldn't say that.

1262
02:33:18.643 --> 02:33:18.822
<v Eben Harford>Okay.

1263
02:33:20.024 --> 02:33:25.805
<v Eben Harford>There would need to be— you would have to the first thing that happens is you go through a metal detector, right?

1264
02:33:27.299 --> 02:33:31.040
<v Eben Harford>If somebody then discovers that you have a concealed handgun, there's your first moment.

1265
02:33:31.954 --> 02:33:33.560
<v Eben Harford>You say, hey, I have a CHL.

1266
02:33:34.202 --> 02:33:39.549
<v Eben Harford>And the person says, hey, look at the sign that, you know, you can't bring that in here regardless.

1267
02:33:40.706 --> 02:33:42.487
<v Eben Harford>Okay, what choice do you make in that moment?

1268
02:33:42.551 --> 02:33:43.885
<v Eben Harford>Do you say, no, I'm coming in?

1269
02:33:44.398 --> 02:33:47.657
<v Eben Harford>Or do you say, all right, I'm gonna— I'm not coming in.

1270
02:33:48.574 --> 02:33:50.261
<v Eben Harford>There's a choice that somebody gets to make.

1271
02:33:50.823 --> 02:33:52.606
<v Eben Harford>Say there's a room without a metal detector.

1272
02:33:52.655 --> 02:33:54.775
<v Eben Harford>Somebody comes in, is carrying a CHL.

1273
02:33:54.840 --> 02:33:58.680
<v Eben Harford>They see the clearly posted sign that says, can't do that here.

1274
02:33:58.761 --> 02:34:00.222
<v Eben Harford>And they say, eh, I'm going to do it anyway.

1275
02:34:00.318 --> 02:34:04.609
<v Eben Harford>And then something happens in that meeting where it becomes clear that they're carrying a loaded weapon.

1276
02:34:05.588 --> 02:34:06.843
<v Eben Harford>Then there's another decision point.

1277
02:34:07.709 --> 02:34:09.269
<v Eben Harford>Somebody has a conversation with them.

1278
02:34:09.943 --> 02:34:11.630
<v Eben Harford>What is their conduct in that moment?

1279
02:34:11.774 --> 02:34:13.927
<v Eben Harford>All those things could be considered in the context of what?

1280
02:34:13.977 --> 02:34:14.104
<v Bob Day>The risk.

1281
02:34:19.180 --> 02:34:28.149
<v Eben Harford>Ultimately, it is possible if you're carrying a loaded firearm in a place where you're not under state statute to be charged with, I think, a Class C felony.

1282
02:34:28.149 --> 02:34:30.579
<v Steve Novick>But okay, I'm still a little confused.

1283
02:34:31.010 --> 02:34:48.435
<v Steve Novick>I mean, sure, I can understand a scenario where you can be charged with a felony if you refuse to leave after it's been discovered that you carried in a weapon, but if you're carrying If a firearm in a place where you're not allowed to carry a weapon, it simply turned out that you carried in a weapon and nobody ever found out about it until afterwards and you never refused anything, then that might be a misdemeanor.

1284
02:34:48.516 --> 02:34:50.943
<v Steve Novick>I mean, that strikes me as one possible way to address this.

1285
02:34:51.593 --> 02:34:58.378
<v Eben Harford>In the context of whether it's a felony or a misdemeanor, Councilor, really is a matter of the state statute.

1286
02:34:59.659 --> 02:35:07.194
<v Eben Harford>And so we don't— all we are doing here is saying for the purpose of this situation that affirmative defense is not qualified.

1287
02:35:08.361 --> 02:35:13.644
<v Steve Novick>So the state statute gives us no choice as to whether it's a felony or a misdemeanor?

1288
02:35:14.993 --> 02:35:15.987
<v Steve Novick>What I refer to—.

1289
02:35:16.051 --> 02:35:18.750
<v Sameer Kanal>We just asked legal to come up to answer some of these questions.

1290
02:35:18.926 --> 02:35:21.639
<v Sameer Kanal>I would lean on legal to address some of these questions.

1291
02:35:22.379 --> 02:35:24.594
<v Steve Novick>Um, actually, so we have one of our lawyers here?

1292
02:35:25.590 --> 02:35:26.408
<v Sameer Kanal>They should be on their way.

1293
02:35:26.552 --> 02:35:27.099
<v Eben Harford>We've reached out.

1294
02:35:27.195 --> 02:35:28.094
<v Eben Harford>Okay.

1295
02:35:29.202 --> 02:35:37.896
<v Eben Harford>I think the, the general point, Councilor, that we're trying to make is that As I think all of us know, there's discretion in how law enforcement works.

1296
02:35:38.058 --> 02:35:46.502
<v Eben Harford>So the idea that you put a finger over the line, somebody finds out about it a month later, and boom, you have a felony record, that's not true to reality.

1297
02:35:47.016 --> 02:35:51.296
<v Eben Harford>The exact mechanics of how that works, we should absolutely defer to legal counsel.

1298
02:35:54.046 --> 02:35:54.753
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman.

1299
02:35:56.496 --> 02:35:56.744
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1300
02:35:59.843 --> 02:36:10.163
<v Eric Zimmerman>That conversation in context to a felony as the consequence is— should give everybody great pause.

1301
02:36:10.355 --> 02:36:29.926
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I will also offer that that conversation, I think, provides us with a much better option that gets the same intent without the harsh legal aspect, which is We can certainly say upon discovery you are excluded.

1302
02:36:32.280 --> 02:36:51.076
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so if you come to— we could say that, yes, Joe Schmo coming through the metal detector, you do have a CHL, but we have noticed this weapon that in the City of Portland's building is still not permitted, and you are excluded if you decide you want to come in with it.

1303
02:36:51.126 --> 02:36:51.174
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1304
02:36:53.625 --> 02:36:58.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>Same outcome, different stick.

1305
02:36:59.130 --> 02:37:15.617
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if they choose then to say, no, I have my God-given and sheriff-given and state constitution-given right, I believe it's fully within our scope to be able to say, okay, that's fine, but you are then excluded from this building.

1306
02:37:15.745 --> 02:37:21.105
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we have a host of, which we're all more familiar with, Councilor Smith.

1307
02:37:22.421 --> 02:37:39.105
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that if your goal is that no person enter in with a weapon, even those who are legally doing so, that this idea of exclusion and using those, those rules are far more appropriate than what's being proposed.

1308
02:37:39.186 --> 02:37:49.978
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I would say that allows the concealed weapon holder to make a choice I think we should make a choice instead of— because frankly, this after-the-fact conversation is alarming.

1309
02:37:51.197 --> 02:37:56.052
<v Eric Zimmerman>After the fact, we're going to then maybe charge you with something, whether it be a felony or not.

1310
02:37:56.566 --> 02:38:09.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>How about we just say no longer does a CHL grant you the permission to come into a public building with a weapon on its surface if that building has a policy that says no.

1311
02:38:10.030 --> 02:38:21.378
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if you guys are dead set on passing something, I'd say pass something close which is about upon discovery— and let's say they're sitting in the audience— upon discovery, ma'am, you cannot have that.

1312
02:38:21.650 --> 02:38:23.397
<v Eric Zimmerman>I need you to leave City Hall for that purpose.

1313
02:38:23.670 --> 02:38:26.763
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if they don't, then we have a law that says exclusion.

1314
02:38:27.516 --> 02:38:29.792
<v Eric Zimmerman>We have a rule that says exclusion, trespassing.

1315
02:38:29.841 --> 02:38:30.563
<v Eric Zimmerman>We can do that.

1316
02:38:30.947 --> 02:38:38.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>We don't have to put the threat of a felony against people who own and, and have a license as the thing.

1317
02:38:38.480 --> 02:38:39.619
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think there's an option here.

1318
02:38:39.699 --> 02:38:40.852
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we can work through it if we use our regular ordinances.

1319
02:38:40.900 --> 02:38:40.996
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1320
02:38:41.545 --> 02:38:44.981
<v Eric Zimmerman>Big boy and big girl brains and, and, and really want to get into this.

1321
02:38:45.563 --> 02:38:46.352
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we can do this.

1322
02:38:46.628 --> 02:38:55.716
<v Eric Zimmerman>But that conversation, the back and forth about how it will be applied, should scare the hell out of us in terms of that's not how laws are supposed to be written.

1323
02:38:56.806 --> 02:38:58.176
<v Eric Zimmerman>I worry about that a lot.

1324
02:38:58.257 --> 02:39:07.126
<v Eric Zimmerman>But it is why local trespass policies, local what you can and can't have policies— you know what else you can't have in here?

1325
02:39:08.349 --> 02:39:09.139
<v Eric Zimmerman>Big noisemakers.

1326
02:39:10.125 --> 02:39:15.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>You can have a choice to leave that noisemaker at the, at the door, but if you come in, we're going to trespass you with that thing.

1327
02:39:17.647 --> 02:39:22.504
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we didn't threaten them with a felony on the back end if they bring in the noisemaker, right?

1328
02:39:22.568 --> 02:39:29.287
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think there's an expectation here for what the expectation is inside a public building and a public deliberating body space.

1329
02:39:29.433 --> 02:39:30.654
<v Eric Zimmerman>I respect that a lot.

1330
02:39:31.777 --> 02:39:46.281
<v Eric Zimmerman>Let's work in that let's amend this to not have a backdrop which is a felony, because I think we can do everything that the council president and the sponsor is asking us to do in a more reasonable manner.

1331
02:39:48.457 --> 02:39:49.686
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal.

1332
02:39:50.092 --> 02:39:50.448
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1333
02:39:50.722 --> 02:40:03.090
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, first, I, I'd like to just indicate that in the future, I think if there is going to be legislation that will eventually have a vote I think in committee we should have an attorney here as a default item.

1334
02:40:03.494 --> 02:40:12.774
<v Sameer Kanal>I understand that we might need to have some conversations around capacity and staffing and all that, but I, I, I, and I appreciate that, but I, I'm saying up here, and I appreciate, uh, Robert Taylor being here.

1335
02:40:13.388 --> 02:40:16.941
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I also note that our security manager's here, and I, I appreciate that as well.

1336
02:40:17.586 --> 02:40:21.855
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the discretion conversation did scare the hell out of me.

1337
02:40:22.984 --> 02:40:33.159
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, just, just fundamentally that I, I am concerned about the idea of there being a felony for some of us and not for all of us.

1338
02:40:35.058 --> 02:40:40.543
<v Sameer Kanal>In that scenario, I am comfortable with the idea that there should be a consequence.

1339
02:40:41.998 --> 02:40:47.286
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't have discomfort around that because this is— I appreciate the comparison to a noisemaker.

1340
02:40:47.351 --> 02:40:55.979
<v Sameer Kanal>A noisemaker generally, under very, very— the odds are probably a million to one that they'll cause they're a lot higher with a firearm.

1341
02:40:56.043 --> 02:41:01.379
<v Sameer Kanal>So I do think it's, it's, it's, it's, and I don't think it's just a matter of same kind, different degree.

1342
02:41:01.443 --> 02:41:03.221
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think it's a different kind.

1343
02:41:03.480 --> 02:41:10.433
<v Sameer Kanal>At the same time, I am concerned about the idea of there being that much discretion in the context of it.

1344
02:41:10.496 --> 02:41:20.484
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a thing I've been pretty consistent about as we've had the conversation around all of the debates that we've had that relate to the criminal justice system.

1345
02:41:22.043 --> 02:41:25.222
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm interested in that conversation a little bit more.

1346
02:41:25.433 --> 02:41:32.013
<v Sameer Kanal>I couldn't find in any of the 3 pieces of code that were referenced a place where it said it was a felony.

1347
02:41:32.061 --> 02:41:34.718
<v Sameer Kanal>So I appreciate the conversation around it's state law.

1348
02:41:35.426 --> 02:41:49.693
<v Sameer Kanal>Council President, could you speak a little bit more to, I guess, just build on what we've been talking about here with how this particular methodology— it sounds like we sort of were given an option by the state.

1349
02:41:49.742 --> 02:41:50.435
<v Sameer Kanal>We're looking at the state's recommendation.

1350
02:41:50.484 --> 02:41:50.565
<v Robert Taylor>Yeah.

1351
02:41:51.162 --> 02:41:51.627
<v Sameer Kanal>The state.

1352
02:41:52.269 --> 02:41:56.492
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm open to the conversation around is there a better way to get to the same end goal.

1353
02:41:56.763 --> 02:42:00.584
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a good idea, and I think it's a good use of committee time.

1354
02:42:00.649 --> 02:42:02.913
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm just trying to understand what am I missing, if anything?

1355
02:42:03.988 --> 02:42:06.219
<v Sameer Kanal>But yeah, because I appreciate the intent very much.

1356
02:42:06.557 --> 02:42:09.864
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I will just first start by saying I didn't actually author this.

1357
02:42:10.170 --> 02:42:12.385
<v Jamie Dunphy>This came out of Bree Brown out of the City Attorney's Office.

1358
02:42:13.075 --> 02:42:17.763
<v Jamie Dunphy>This was me working directly with the administration on what they see as a security gap.

1359
02:42:18.115 --> 02:42:24.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm happy to be the sponsor of this because anything that I think we can do to get guns out of public spaces is great.

1360
02:42:26.140 --> 02:42:29.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>If there's a better way to do foot forward, this committee, that is the point of these committees.

1361
02:42:29.847 --> 02:42:37.711
<v Jamie Dunphy>If this committee believes there is a better way to get the same outcome, I'm absolutely open to, you know, whatever you all decide is the best way forward.

1362
02:42:37.777 --> 02:42:42.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>This, however, this specific language was not drafted by me or by Eben.

1363
02:42:43.329 --> 02:42:46.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>We've helped, obviously, but this was coming from City Attorney's Office.

1364
02:42:46.972 --> 02:42:47.148
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1365
02:42:47.935 --> 02:42:53.681
<v Eben Harford>And we do have the city attorney here to clarify the legal risk to individuals at this point.

1366
02:42:54.956 --> 02:42:56.038
<v Eben Harford>I personally misspoke.

1367
02:42:56.166 --> 02:42:56.569
<v Eben Harford>I was incorrect.

1368
02:42:57.250 --> 02:42:58.843
<v Eben Harford>So we should defer to Robert on that.

1369
02:43:02.870 --> 02:43:09.197
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, actually, I would like to— Councilor Kanal, would it be okay to bring the city attorney up to answer some of these questions?

1370
02:43:10.477 --> 02:43:16.307
<v Steve Novick>And as Councilor Zimmerman just muttered, it actually would be nice to have people in the administration who wanted to bring this forward here too.

1371
02:43:16.500 --> 02:43:23.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>But yeah, but because it inherently makes it more political when it comes from a councilor, right?

1372
02:43:24.066 --> 02:43:26.092
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I appreciate you sharing that, Council President.

1373
02:43:26.156 --> 02:43:31.033
<v Eric Zimmerman>You've seemed kind of— your answers in the previous session and this one kind of seemed like this was your pet project.

1374
02:43:31.515 --> 02:43:38.458
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, yeah, I think— I feel like there is an opening to a conversation here to have.

1375
02:43:38.667 --> 02:43:40.011
<v Eric Zimmerman>So let's do that.

1376
02:43:40.270 --> 02:43:45.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>But We've got to— if the security needs to bring things to the committee, we need to be hearing that.

1377
02:43:46.450 --> 02:43:48.435
<v Steve Novick>Uh, Mr. Taylor, can you come up?

1378
02:43:50.647 --> 02:44:04.427
<v Steve Novick>And other councilors might have other questions to ask, but I, I just kind of want to know, do we have options other than this is a felony or this isn't if we want to discourage people from bringing firearms into public buildings?

1379
02:44:07.579 --> 02:44:09.851
<v Robert Taylor>Hello, Robert Taylor, City Attorney.

1380
02:44:10.629 --> 02:44:13.843
<v Robert Taylor>If I can just start with a process point that might be helpful.

1381
02:44:15.814 --> 02:44:19.163
<v Robert Taylor>We have a lawyer in our office who has been handling this.

1382
02:44:20.747 --> 02:44:21.977
<v Robert Taylor>They have a conflict.

1383
02:44:22.058 --> 02:44:24.161
<v Robert Taylor>They're handling other city business right now.

1384
02:44:26.356 --> 02:44:32.659
<v Robert Taylor>If members of the committee or proponents of legislation want a lawyer who's handling this to be available.

1385
02:44:33.829 --> 02:44:39.415
<v Robert Taylor>It's very helpful to have that communication so that they can be sure to be available to answer those questions.

1386
02:44:40.229 --> 02:44:45.959
<v Robert Taylor>I'm happy to be here to pinch-hit today on this, and I'll give you my best answers.

1387
02:44:47.281 --> 02:44:53.284
<v Robert Taylor>And as this continues to move through the process, we're happy to update any information that we share today.

1388
02:44:55.131 --> 02:45:09.319
<v Robert Taylor>So for— First, let me just say that this is all a creature of state statute, of state criminal law, and anything we do needs to be consistent with the state criminal law.

1389
02:45:11.471 --> 02:45:19.415
<v Robert Taylor>This law regarding possession of weapons in a public building is complicated, and it has been subject to amendments over the years.

1390
02:45:23.309 --> 02:45:35.845
<v Robert Taylor>2025, When the legislature took action, it was illegal— it was a felony to carry a weapon into a public building.

1391
02:45:37.406 --> 02:45:48.183
<v Robert Taylor>There was an affirmative defense, however, to that felony, which was if you had a concealed handgun license, you can assert that affirmative defense and you would not be prosecuted.

1392
02:45:51.362 --> 02:46:05.304
<v Robert Taylor>In 2025, the law was changed and it gave governing bodies the ability to have a policy that says that affirmative defense no longer applies.

1393
02:46:07.100 --> 02:46:13.231
<v Robert Taylor>So if you have— and if you have a policy that says the concealed handgun license no longer applies, then you can't prosecute for that.

1394
02:46:13.344 --> 02:46:13.393
<v Robert Taylor>Okay.

1395
02:46:15.025 --> 02:46:27.805
<v Robert Taylor>Then, if you have a weapon in a public building where the governing body holds official meetings, then if you have the CHL, it's not an affirmative defense.

1396
02:46:28.519 --> 02:46:30.028
<v Robert Taylor>Instead, it is a misdemeanor.

1397
02:46:31.585 --> 02:46:38.007
<v Robert Taylor>So what this legislation does is it says the affirmative defense under state law no longer applies.

1398
02:46:39.340 --> 02:46:58.531
<v Robert Taylor>So that if you have a CHL at a meeting where the governing body is present, then in a building where the governing body holds official meetings, then that is a misdemeanor, not a felony, but it is still subject to a criminal penalty in a way that it wasn't before.

1399
02:47:00.292 --> 02:47:07.022
<v Robert Taylor>And Councilor Novick asked a question earlier about what types of buildings does it apply to?

1400
02:47:07.166 --> 02:47:16.355
<v Robert Taylor>Under the state statute, you can make a policy governing buildings where a governing body has official meetings.

1401
02:47:17.292 --> 02:47:20.636
<v Robert Taylor>So it's not just any meeting of staff in a building.

1402
02:47:20.829 --> 02:47:25.328
<v Robert Taylor>It's got to be a governing body where they hold official meetings.

1403
02:47:26.415 --> 02:47:31.727
<v Steve Novick>Could we narrow it to a subset of that, to like meetings where the public— where the public are in attendance?

1404
02:47:33.048 --> 02:47:35.599
<v Eric Zimmerman>Have any official meetings that they aren't in attendance?

1405
02:47:36.417 --> 02:47:43.653
<v Steve Novick>Um, I don't know, but it just seems like there might be— I mean, there might be meetings that are somewhat official in some part of the city.

1406
02:47:43.701 --> 02:47:47.199
<v Steve Novick>You might be having a meeting that somebody would consider official that the public isn't involved in.

1407
02:47:47.407 --> 02:47:51.483
<v Robert Taylor>It's— it— under the state statute, I believe it's got to be a governing body.

1408
02:47:52.092 --> 02:47:54.868
<v Robert Taylor>So Planning Commission would be a governing body.

1409
02:47:54.948 --> 02:47:57.418
<v Robert Taylor>We have advisory bodies that might be considered governing bodies.

1410
02:47:57.579 --> 02:48:05.880
<v Robert Taylor>Governing bodies, but it's not just any building where staff meet, for example.

1411
02:48:06.602 --> 02:48:18.773
<v Robert Taylor>So that's why the City Hall governing body meets, we have official meetings here, 1900 building, that happens there, might happen in the Portland building.

1412
02:48:19.465 --> 02:48:39.264
<v Robert Taylor>So that's the intent of the legislature, So they've sort of predefined official meeting in a narrow way.

1413
02:48:39.654 --> 02:48:46.509
<v Robert Taylor>Well, they didn't really define what official meetings is, but it's in the statute.

1414
02:48:46.605 --> 02:48:51.636
<v Robert Taylor>It's buildings where okay.

1415
02:48:52.898 --> 02:48:58.876
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

1416
02:48:59.555 --> 02:49:00.201
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, thank you.

1417
02:49:00.444 --> 02:49:01.139
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal.

1418
02:49:02.547 --> 02:49:04.617
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, uh, for the responses.

1419
02:49:05.960 --> 02:49:09.167
<v Sameer Kanal>It's with relation to governing body definitions.

1420
02:49:09.280 --> 02:49:17.097
<v Sameer Kanal>So ultimately what we're talking about is a decision that is, is directly made at the gov— at the, at the body.

1421
02:49:17.394 --> 02:49:22.465
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that a good way of— because I understand the planning commission's piece.

1422
02:49:24.716 --> 02:49:30.770
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm a little concerned around, like, for example, the CBPA, the Committee Board for Police Accountability, is a governing body.

1423
02:49:31.932 --> 02:49:38.025
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just want to verify that and be kind of— what's the simplest way for us to articulate the difference on that?

1424
02:49:40.203 --> 02:49:57.679
<v Robert Taylor>I mean, the simplest way to articulate the difference is a governing body is one that's subject to the public meetings law, and their meetings need to be open to the public because they are making decisions on behalf of the entity or making recommendations to the council.

1425
02:49:57.808 --> 02:49:59.125
<v Robert Taylor>That's what a governing body is.

1426
02:49:59.204 --> 02:50:08.197
<v Robert Taylor>And if you are one of those types of bodies, then you are also subject to the public meetings law, which I think is why the legislature used that term.

1427
02:50:08.469 --> 02:50:11.632
<v Robert Taylor>So governing bodies are subject to the public meetings law.

1428
02:50:11.792 --> 02:50:15.533
<v Robert Taylor>They need to let the public have access to the meeting.

1429
02:50:16.593 --> 02:50:20.880
<v Robert Taylor>And so I think that's why the legislature constructed the statute that way.

1430
02:50:21.411 --> 02:50:32.586
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so anybody that makes recommendations to council, because council is subject to public meetings law the same way a city council committee is subject to it, anybody that makes a recommendation to us is also subject to it.

1431
02:50:35.454 --> 02:50:37.251
<v Robert Taylor>Formally, right?

1432
02:50:37.379 --> 02:50:38.448
<v Robert Taylor>Roughly speaking, yeah.

1433
02:50:39.078 --> 02:50:42.006
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, um, thanks.

1434
02:50:42.234 --> 02:50:50.528
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, on a somewhat related piece, um, if a city leases a building and we hold a meeting there, does that still count?

1435
02:50:51.716 --> 02:50:55.141
<v Robert Taylor>I think the statute is owned, like, owned or controlled by.

1436
02:50:55.575 --> 02:51:05.342
<v Robert Taylor>So yeah, so if we lease a building, if we lease a building and you want to have city council If we're holding council meetings there, that would be the same as holding it in City Hall.

1437
02:51:05.727 --> 02:51:12.423
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, and then we have no committee or council meetings on Monday or Friday, so is— or Saturday or Sunday for that matter.

1438
02:51:12.647 --> 02:51:14.863
<v Sameer Kanal>How does that apply in terms of City Hall?

1439
02:51:15.056 --> 02:51:17.031
<v Sameer Kanal>Would it be only at times where it's meeting?

1440
02:51:18.268 --> 02:51:20.370
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it any building where we're holding it?

1441
02:51:20.418 --> 02:51:22.104
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just trying to get these things on the record, by the way.

1442
02:51:33.361 --> 02:51:43.202
<v Robert Taylor>So the statute says does not apply to the possession of firearms within a building owned or controlled by the governing body that is used by the governing body for official meetings.

1443
02:51:43.974 --> 02:51:49.385
<v Robert Taylor>So I think you could— I mean, you can interpret that either way to say it applies to the whole building.

1444
02:51:49.561 --> 02:51:50.413
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's the whole building.

1445
02:51:50.621 --> 02:51:55.280
<v Robert Taylor>If you have official meetings in the building, then you can't have guns in that building.

1446
02:51:55.733 --> 02:51:55.959
<v Bob Day>Okay.

1447
02:51:56.363 --> 02:51:56.574
<v Sameer Kanal>And then—.

1448
02:51:57.091 --> 02:52:09.858
<v Robert Taylor>Or if you wanted to narrow that so that you're only abolishing the affirmative defense at specific times when meetings are held, you could do that.

1449
02:52:09.954 --> 02:52:15.860
<v Robert Taylor>I think that there are logistical concerns you would want to think through with that.

1450
02:52:16.152 --> 02:52:22.523
<v Robert Taylor>In terms of making sure signage is posted and people really know what the rules are when they're entering a building or not.

1451
02:52:23.679 --> 02:52:25.477
<v Sameer Kanal>So 2 final questions.

1452
02:52:25.604 --> 02:52:28.751
<v Sameer Kanal>One is just to kind of follow up on that.

1453
02:52:29.056 --> 02:52:40.435
<v Sameer Kanal>One of the conversations we've had sort of behind the scenes, or it's in front of the scenes, but periodically, sporadically at this point actually, is what if we held a City Council meeting in D1?

1454
02:52:41.656 --> 02:52:46.524
<v Sameer Kanal>And in order to do that, we'd probably be renting a space As a one-off.

1455
02:52:46.862 --> 02:52:52.942
<v Sameer Kanal>I mean, maybe the McPhish can handle it, but, but, uh, there's— if it was a one-off rental for something like that, that still counts, right?

1456
02:52:54.442 --> 02:52:54.765
<v Robert Taylor>Yes.

1457
02:52:54.862 --> 02:52:55.235
<v Michael>Okay.

1458
02:52:55.799 --> 02:53:08.662
<v Sameer Kanal>And then last question, in terms of who is exempted from it, um, we have a conversation around, uh, it says police officers that are active, which makes sense, but also says honorably retired.

1459
02:53:09.177 --> 02:53:18.566
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that something within, um, Within city council's authorization, like, are we able to exempt— to not exempt people who are no longer in that field?

1460
02:53:19.787 --> 02:53:24.733
<v Robert Taylor>I believe that is an exception in state law.

1461
02:53:25.519 --> 02:53:27.445
<v Sameer Kanal>Meaning we could not supersede that?

1462
02:53:27.494 --> 02:53:28.634
<v Robert Taylor>We could not supersede that.

1463
02:53:29.742 --> 02:53:34.575
<v Robert Taylor>Any criminal statute the council passes must be consistent with state criminal law.

1464
02:53:35.137 --> 02:53:36.245
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure, just making sure I understand.

1465
02:53:38.822 --> 02:53:44.740
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Morillo, you're good with Brian.

1466
02:53:49.129 --> 02:54:15.610
<v Steve Novick>So this is a, this is a situation where, um, I'm particularly frustrated by the public meetings law because I think based on this conversation, what I ideally would like to do is to I would like to sit down with Councilor Zimmerman and Councilor Kanal, who has expressed an interest, and with Councilor Dunphy and with the administration and with the lawyers and try to figure out if we can work out something that we can all more or less agree on.

1467
02:54:15.959 --> 02:54:20.590
<v Steve Novick>I can't do that because then that would be 3 members of this committee involved.

1468
02:54:21.540 --> 02:54:30.780
<v Steve Novick>But I'm sort of hoping— I don't think that we're prepared to vote on this today, and I think that there's no real point to moving the amendment if we don't know what we're doing with the underlying ordinance.

1469
02:54:30.780 --> 02:54:30.899
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a good point.

1470
02:54:30.966 --> 02:54:35.355
<v Steve Novick>Well, actually, okay, do you want to move the amendment anyway, Councilor Kanal?

1471
02:54:35.629 --> 02:54:35.965
<v Sameer Kanal>I do.

1472
02:54:36.494 --> 02:54:41.894
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the question of the prohibit— what the consequences are is a lot of what we're talking about here.

1473
02:54:42.343 --> 02:54:53.014
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do think the idea of ensuring our definitions are not inadvertently self-contradictory is good, which I think is the concern that the amendment seeks to address.

1474
02:54:54.297 --> 02:54:57.101
<v Sameer Kanal>So I do think it's worth moving, and I will move it at this moment.

1475
02:54:57.997 --> 02:55:06.566
<v Sameer Kanal>Because I think it's, even if we're not getting everything done today, and I agree with your broader approach, I think it's worth getting one piece done today.

1476
02:55:06.796 --> 02:55:08.103
<v Steve Novick>All right, second.

1477
02:55:11.957 --> 02:55:20.127
<v Steve Novick>Should we just go ahead and vote on the amendment since that seems to be a matter of— any debate on the amendment previously described?

1478
02:55:21.739 --> 02:55:22.593
<v Steve Novick>Clerk, could you call the roll?

1479
02:55:24.718 --> 02:55:30.835
<v Tristan Edwards>This is the motion to amend Exhibit C to the ordinance, moved by Kanal and seconded by Novick.

1480
02:55:31.300 --> 02:55:31.510
<v Steve Novick>Kanal?

1481
02:55:32.007 --> 02:55:32.056
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1482
02:55:33.034 --> 02:55:33.452
<v James Crooker>Murillo?

1483
02:55:34.094 --> 02:55:34.143
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1484
02:55:34.850 --> 02:55:35.282
<v James Crooker>Zimmerman?

1485
02:55:35.781 --> 02:55:35.797
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1486
02:55:36.456 --> 02:55:36.727
<v Tristan Edwards>Smith?

1487
02:55:37.467 --> 02:55:37.514
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1488
02:55:38.206 --> 02:55:38.606
<v Angelita Morillo>Novick?

1489
02:55:39.073 --> 02:55:39.120
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1490
02:55:40.518 --> 02:55:48.305
<v Tristan Edwards>With a vote of 5 ayes, the motion to amend Exhibit C to the ordinance as shown in Councilor Dunphy 1 has been approved.

1491
02:55:50.212 --> 02:55:50.680
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1492
02:55:52.147 --> 02:55:57.869
<v Steve Novick>Mr. President, do you have some thoughts as to how we should proceed and who should be involved in discussions before we bring this up again?

1493
02:55:58.093 --> 02:56:00.156
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would love to be involved in the conversations.

1494
02:56:00.204 --> 02:56:08.001
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to make sure also that the administration's involved and absolutely support the continued conversation about this and not rushing this to a vote.

1495
02:56:08.096 --> 02:56:12.997
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that there will be obviously more conversation at the full council, but this is a good conversation to have.

1496
02:56:13.693 --> 02:56:15.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I would be happy to be involved in whatever way you need me.

1497
02:56:16.666 --> 02:56:19.727
<v Steve Novick>I think I'd hope Councilor Zimmerman would be involved.

1498
02:56:20.128 --> 02:56:24.359
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal, should you and I flip a coin as to which of us is also involved in the discussion?

1499
02:56:25.000 --> 02:56:28.477
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll make sure that there's not a— we can make sure there's not a quorum.

1500
02:56:28.685 --> 02:56:30.079
<v Steve Novick>We'll flip a coin afterwards.

1501
02:56:30.368 --> 02:56:31.153
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sounds good.

1502
02:56:31.345 --> 02:56:31.665
<v Steve Novick>All right.

1503
02:56:31.970 --> 02:56:33.717
<v Steve Novick>Really appreciate this discussion.

1504
02:56:34.390 --> 02:56:43.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>I did make a request that— I mean, we've got— when the council president said that there was some aspect that the administration wanted this to come forward Is there— I see Manny.

1505
02:56:43.129 --> 02:56:43.917
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is it possible?

1506
02:56:44.159 --> 02:56:45.075
<v Steve Novick>Oh, sure, sure.

1507
02:56:45.284 --> 02:56:45.558
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1508
02:56:47.054 --> 02:57:01.165
<v Eric Zimmerman>Manny, if you're able, if there is a role in which— because this question is hanging for me, which is, are we looking for an exclusion, or are we looking to enforce a felony law, or, or sometimes a misdemeanor law?

1509
02:57:01.856 --> 02:57:09.993
<v Eric Zimmerman>What is it that you're trying to solve if this is truly coming from the administration through the president's office what is at issue here?

1510
02:57:10.218 --> 02:57:12.795
<v Manny Guerra>Well, for the record, my name is Manny Guerra.

1511
02:57:12.876 --> 02:57:13.728
<v Manny Guerra>I'm the security manager.

1512
02:57:16.029 --> 02:57:21.318
<v Manny Guerra>Just to step back just a little bit, this wasn't brought forth by security itself.

1513
02:57:21.529 --> 02:57:25.234
<v Manny Guerra>This wasn't like integrated security saying, hey, we need to have it, this needs to happen.

1514
02:57:26.141 --> 02:57:32.263
<v Manny Guerra>This is prior to, I think, everybody here on the dais and especially the CA.

1515
02:57:32.753 --> 02:57:40.030
<v Manny Guerra>There was state law that went into effect that prohibited having firearms, even if you had a concealed carry, to go in.

1516
02:57:40.416 --> 02:57:46.673
<v Manny Guerra>A lot of cities got upset because they, at the time, they were not included in that statute.

1517
02:57:47.335 --> 02:57:57.587
<v Manny Guerra>So then the following year, I guess there were some folks that went to the state and said, hey, we feel like the cities should also be included in this.

1518
02:57:57.653 --> 02:58:01.728
<v Manny Guerra>We should have the right to also exclude folks that have a concealed carry.

1519
02:58:02.978 --> 02:58:06.800
<v Manny Guerra>The City of Portland also went in on that.

1520
02:58:07.570 --> 02:58:10.460
<v Manny Guerra>On my end, I would just say that's a little bit of the background.

1521
02:58:10.540 --> 02:58:28.009
<v Manny Guerra>But on my end, I would just say that when it comes to this, somebody that comes in with a CHL and tells us upfront that they have a CHL and shows it to us and then goes through the processes of what we have, which is give us a few minutes, we're going to contact PBB, they're going to send an officer and then verify your CHL.

1522
02:58:28.606 --> 02:58:32.310
<v Manny Guerra>Once it's verified, I do not have an issue with that at all.

1523
02:58:32.958 --> 02:58:48.700
<v Manny Guerra>That is actually somebody that is abiding by current law, is letting us know exactly what they have on their persons, and is able to verify that they actually have—it's valid for them to carry that firearm.

1524
02:58:49.040 --> 02:58:50.908
<v Manny Guerra>So not an issue in that aspect.

1525
02:58:51.135 --> 02:58:55.228
<v Manny Guerra>In my concern is always for the person that has a nefarious.

1526
02:58:55.731 --> 02:59:06.329
<v Manny Guerra>Reason why they're concealed carrying, they somehow are able to make it into so-called facility without us knowing about that.

1527
02:59:06.635 --> 02:59:08.255
<v Manny Guerra>That is the concern.

1528
02:59:08.962 --> 02:59:18.822
<v Manny Guerra>In the big picture, more guns do not make areas more safe, but I also understand the reality of the world that we live in currently.

1529
02:59:19.639 --> 02:59:33.231
<v Manny Guerra>So, I would just, I would be very comfortable with the idea of just saying, hey, if you refuse to leave, you have, we understand you have a valid CHL, we ask you to leave.

1530
02:59:33.280 --> 02:59:36.929
<v Manny Guerra>You cannot come in because of this rule that we have, this code.

1531
02:59:38.022 --> 02:59:42.797
<v Manny Guerra>You are ejected from, you know, or you're not welcome to come in for this.

1532
02:59:43.992 --> 02:59:47.592
<v Manny Guerra>Usually, I'll just tell you that most folks will abide by that the next time they come back.

1533
02:59:47.639 --> 02:59:47.689
<v Manny Guerra>Okay.

1534
02:59:48.010 --> 02:59:55.596
<v Manny Guerra>So there's no reason to say like, hey, we need to have a trespass for more than, you know, for long term if they understand what the rules are.

1535
02:59:56.112 --> 02:59:59.835
<v Manny Guerra>So that's how I feel about it.

1536
03:00:00.110 --> 03:00:11.361
<v Manny Guerra>I don't think it should go automatically to a criminal matter since, I mean, they are abiding by state and, you know, state law and state rules.

1537
03:00:11.912 --> 03:00:12.105
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1538
03:00:13.582 --> 03:00:14.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>Follow-up.

1539
03:00:14.144 --> 03:00:32.449
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, you know, Councilor Smith and I come from the experience in the early 2010s at Multnomah County where there were at various times, you know, they would pack the chambers, so to speak, and they'd pack the chambers with their weapons out.

1540
03:00:33.492 --> 03:00:38.469
<v Eric Zimmerman>And this was this point of time when it was also happening at the state capitol.

1541
03:00:39.333 --> 03:00:44.533
<v Eric Zimmerman>Where our, our Western roots were showing, I'll just say.

1542
03:00:44.761 --> 03:00:59.425
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, uh, and it is, it is not inherently unsafe, and it is inherently, um, I'm missing the word here, but it is, it is, it is a— it's intimidating.

1543
03:00:59.490 --> 03:01:00.102
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Councilor.

1544
03:01:00.216 --> 03:01:02.231
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's inherently an intimidating moment.

1545
03:01:02.313 --> 03:01:06.925
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say that because as I look at this crowd Yeah.

1546
03:01:08.608 --> 03:01:17.574
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, there are key indicators of someone's behavior or things that I will visualize and know that's off, something's off.

1547
03:01:18.546 --> 03:01:24.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>When the whole room is packed that way, to pick up on small movements is hard to do.

1548
03:01:24.940 --> 03:01:27.896
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll just— that's just me being incredibly transparent.

1549
03:01:28.057 --> 03:01:32.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>So having a whole room of folks with weapons on their shoulders, on their hips, Yes.

1550
03:01:32.561 --> 03:01:33.063
<v Eric Zimmerman>Not great.

1551
03:01:33.144 --> 03:01:33.807
<v Eric Zimmerman>Not a great look.

1552
03:01:33.951 --> 03:01:40.998
<v Eric Zimmerman>As a weapon carrier myself, as a CHL holder myself, I find it stupid.

1553
03:01:42.917 --> 03:01:54.950
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that that has, in some communities, the presence of a CHL has been a way in which people were getting around the exclusion of weapons inside official chambers.

1554
03:01:56.272 --> 03:02:06.067
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think it's perfectly reasonable to say that is not acceptable, and I think that's part partially where the state law is coming from, that that can't be an excuse for an intimidation tactic.

1555
03:02:06.165 --> 03:02:09.138
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that's reasonable to talk about.

1556
03:02:11.120 --> 03:02:14.389
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I appreciate the direction that you're going, Chair.

1557
03:02:14.536 --> 03:02:15.879
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that we can work this out.

1558
03:02:16.876 --> 03:02:24.411
<v Eric Zimmerman>There is more here to work out if our whole goal is to exclude weapons from a deliberative body's decision-making place.

1559
03:02:24.653 --> 03:02:25.879
<v Tristan Edwards>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1560
03:02:28.029 --> 03:02:31.248
<v Eric Zimmerman>But it's also a small part in which we're carving out, right?

1561
03:02:31.329 --> 03:02:35.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Smith has an office in East Portland.

1562
03:02:35.756 --> 03:02:40.861
<v Eric Zimmerman>Since the body doesn't meet there, this does not apply to that office, even though she's a member of this body.

1563
03:02:40.925 --> 03:02:43.566
<v Eric Zimmerman>But until we go as a group, that's not a body, right?

1564
03:02:44.146 --> 03:03:04.664
<v Eric Zimmerman>To Councilor Kanal's points, I think that those things that we're really talking about, a few buildings only, which is why I think it's, I think it's appropriate to talk about what is our exclusion policy, and we can say something like the City of Portland now has state law that say we don't actually have to recognize that a CHL must be allowed to be permitted in.

1565
03:03:05.096 --> 03:03:13.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a reasonable discussion to have, but it worries me when we go down the path of criminal enforcement.

1566
03:03:13.751 --> 03:03:15.645
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'd like to continue that conversation.

1567
03:03:15.692 --> 03:03:16.864
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate the nodded heads.

1568
03:03:17.121 --> 03:03:24.679
<v Eric Zimmerman>Manny, I thank you for because I actually approach it very much the way your conversation was, is like, we're going to identify, we're going to know.

1569
03:03:25.194 --> 03:03:29.391
<v Eric Zimmerman>If we say they're excluded, most people are going to say, okay, I'm out, or I'm going to go put it away somewhere.

1570
03:03:30.119 --> 03:03:36.390
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I also add the one thing that is concerning here is I don't want to do anything that adds to the prevalence of guns being left in cars.

1571
03:03:37.290 --> 03:03:51.629
<v Eric Zimmerman>The DA would slap me sideways if, if he knew we were doing anything that gets people to go leave their guns in cars, because I don't want to say the majority, but a tremendous amount of Stolen weapons are coming from cars because people leave them in there because they couldn't take them to a place, etc., etc., etc.

1572
03:03:51.726 --> 03:03:52.610
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's wild, actually.

1573
03:03:52.657 --> 03:03:55.373
<v Eric Zimmerman>It would shock the pants off you when you start figuring that stuff out.

1574
03:03:56.081 --> 03:03:58.201
<v Eric Zimmerman>So let's keep working this.

1575
03:03:59.744 --> 03:04:05.855
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's a route here that doesn't have to be a hard yes or a hard no on what came to committee.

1576
03:04:07.165 --> 03:04:17.933
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that it is fair to say we're trying to solve against what I would say was an intimidation tactic from 10-some-odd years ago, and I'm sure it's happened more recently in, in other communities in Portland.

1577
03:04:17.980 --> 03:04:21.754
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just talking about my experience at Multnomah County, and it probably happened here too.

1578
03:04:22.958 --> 03:04:23.280
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Chair.

1579
03:04:24.082 --> 03:04:24.933
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

1580
03:04:26.234 --> 03:04:33.587
<v Steve Novick>I hope that by the next meeting we can work things out so that we either have an agreement or we know what are the insoluble disagreements, but we can't guarantee that.

1581
03:04:33.700 --> 03:04:37.939
<v Steve Novick>But let's work towards that to see if we can take some action on July 7th.

1582
03:04:39.421 --> 03:04:40.693
<v Steve Novick>Thank you all very much.

1583
03:04:40.808 --> 03:04:44.379
<v Steve Novick>This meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee is right on time adjourned.

1584
03:05:00.631 --> 03:05:00.998
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

