WEBVTT

1
00:05:49.079 --> 00:05:50.572
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon, everyone.

2
00:05:50.701 --> 00:05:56.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Before we gavel in today, we will receive and celebrate the annual Portland Sister Cities Coalition presentation.

3
00:05:57.588 --> 00:06:07.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to take a moment to welcome a very special group of guests who are with us here in Council Chambers today, and many of whom joined us just a short while ago downstairs at the 12th Annual Sister Cities Reception.

4
00:06:09.326 --> 00:06:18.684
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, today we have the honor of receiving the Portland Sister Cities Association a celebration of the people-to-people diplomacy that defines Portland on the world stage.

5
00:06:19.509 --> 00:06:30.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>These are relationships built on the voluntary forging of ties across borders to encourage cultural understanding, friendship, and exchange that come back to benefit our communities here at home.

6
00:06:30.689 --> 00:06:37.324
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to extend a warm welcome to the visiting delegation from our sister city in Kaohsiung, Taiwan.

7
00:06:38.160 --> 00:06:47.906
<v Jamie Dunphy>Deputy Director General Chang An-chung and Deputy Director General Wu Wen-jeng from Kaohsiung's City Government, International Affairs, and Education Bureaus.

8
00:06:49.012 --> 00:06:52.415
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd also like to note that today is a particularly historic moment for our program.

9
00:06:53.346 --> 00:07:01.499
<v Jamie Dunphy>On May 27th, this council held the first reading of the ordinance formally elevating Portland's relationship with Lviv, Ukraine from friendship city to sister city.

10
00:07:01.932 --> 00:07:09.442
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today, that relationship becomes official, and in about 15 minutes following our vote, our vote, Portland and Lviv will become sister cities.

11
00:07:09.956 --> 00:07:14.206
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a profound and meaningful milestone, and I'm proud that this council is marking it together.

12
00:07:14.927 --> 00:07:27.271
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like now to turn it over to Chido Dilawayo, our International Relations Manager in the Office of Government Relations, who will share some insights and highlights from our association's work this past year and introduce the leaders who are present with us today.

13
00:07:27.656 --> 00:07:28.377
<v Jamie Dunphy>Chido, take it away.

14
00:07:29.355 --> 00:07:29.692
<v Chido Dilawayo>Thank you.

15
00:07:29.836 --> 00:07:35.463
<v Chido Dilawayo>For the record, my name is Chido Dilawayo, and I manage the International Relations Program in the Office of Government Relations.

16
00:07:36.009 --> 00:07:42.084
<v Chido Dilawayo>It is a privilege to support Portland's Sister Cities Program and the extraordinary volunteer leaders who sustain it.

17
00:07:42.661 --> 00:07:48.975
<v Chido Dilawayo>Thank you, Council President, and thank you to the full council for taking the time today to recognize this important work.

18
00:07:49.697 --> 00:08:02.740
<v Chido Dilawayo>The goal of the International Relations Program is to strengthen Portland's engagements with the world through diplomacy, cultural exchange, economic relationship building, and people-to-people connections that benefit Portland residents.

19
00:08:03.557 --> 00:08:07.949
<v Chido Dilawayo>Portland's Sister Cities Program is one of the oldest and most active in the nation.

20
00:08:08.610 --> 00:08:20.706
<v Chido Dilawayo>At its core, it's, it's citizen diplomacy, the idea that lasting international understanding is built not only between governments but between students, artists, business leaders, families, and neighbors.

21
00:08:22.264 --> 00:08:31.579
<v Chido Dilawayo>Importantly, all Sister City Association programming is funded through volunteers, donors, and grants rather than city resources, making the scope of the work especially remarkable.

22
00:08:32.802 --> 00:08:40.187
<v Chido Dilawayo>I'd like to especially recognize James Autry, Chair of the Portland Sister Cities Coalition and president of the Portland Ashkelon Sister City Association.

23
00:08:41.030 --> 00:08:56.577
<v Chido Dilawayo>Through his leadership, collaboration, and behind-the-scenes coordination, he has helped keep this network connected and ensured the success of shared initiatives, including today's Sister Cities reception and the coalition's participation in the Rose Festival Grand Floral Parade this Saturday.

24
00:08:58.192 --> 00:09:05.567
<v Chido Dilawayo>Today, as Portland officially celebrates 10 sister cities spanning 4 continents, I would like to share a few highlights from the past year.

25
00:09:07.350 --> 00:09:17.730
<v Chido Dilawayo>The Portland-Sapporo Sister City Association continues to steward Portland's oldest sister city relationship through student exchanges and cultural engagement, including an upcoming delegation visit from Sapporo.

26
00:09:19.186 --> 00:09:27.346
<v Chido Dilawayo>The Portland-Suzhou Sister City Association remains committed to fostering people-to-people connections and exploring opportunities in education, culture, and business.

27
00:09:29.312 --> 00:09:40.741
<v Chido Dilawayo>As the Portland-Ulsan Sister City Association approaches its 40th anniversary next year, it continues strengthening ties through educational, cultural, and trade relationships.

28
00:09:42.269 --> 00:09:51.129
<v Chido Dilawayo>The Portland-Bologna Sister City Association hosted another successful Sagra fundraiser supporting youth exchanges and scholarship opportunities for Portland students.

29
00:09:52.842 --> 00:10:02.948
<v Chido Dilawayo>And the Portland-Guadalajara Sister City Association recently hosted Oregon's largest multicultural Cinco de Mayo celebration and continued strengthening ties through delegation exchanges.

30
00:10:05.769 --> 00:10:20.442
<v Chido Dilawayo>The Portland Kaohsiung Sister City Association continues to host the Portland Rose Festival Dragon Boat Races, one of Portland's most beloved cultural traditions, and we are honored to welcome a delegation, as Council President mentioned, from Kaohsiung visiting Portland this week.

31
00:10:22.570 --> 00:10:29.817
<v Chido Dilawayo>And of course, today is especially historic as Portland formalizes the relationship between Lviv as our 10th sister city.

32
00:10:30.173 --> 00:10:47.648
<v Chido Dilawayo>This relationship has been championed by the Portland-Lviv Sister City Association President Tatiana Tredal, whose leadership and dedication helped guide the association through every requirement necessary to achieve official status during an extraordinary difficult period in Ukraine's history.

33
00:10:48.923 --> 00:10:59.258
<v Chido Dilawayo>With the council's action today, Portland and Lviv are now officially sister cities, a partnership rooted in solidarity, shared values, and enduring people-to-people connection.

34
00:10:59.306 --> 00:11:03.947
<v Chido Dilawayo>We're honored to welcome the Portland-Lviv Sister City Association into the Sister Cities family.

35
00:11:05.455 --> 00:11:13.711
<v Chido Dilawayo>At this time, I would like to ask the Sister City Association presidents to stand as I call their names so council and the public may recognize them.

36
00:11:15.192 --> 00:11:18.203
<v Chido Dilawayo>James Autry, the Portland-Ashkelon Sister City Association.

37
00:11:19.057 --> 00:11:22.230
<v Chido Dilawayo>Gabriella Tamay, Portland-Bologna Sister City Association.

38
00:11:23.100 --> 00:11:26.307
<v Chido Dilawayo>Cindy Avila, Portland-Guadalajara Sister City Association.

39
00:11:27.118 --> 00:11:30.474
<v Chido Dilawayo>Chi-Chao Chen, Portland-Gaoshan Sister City Association.

40
00:11:31.293 --> 00:11:34.889
<v Chido Dilawayo>Thomas Banki with the Portland-Habarovsk Sister City Association.

41
00:11:36.046 --> 00:11:39.706
<v Chido Dilawayo>Karen Hansen with the Portland-Mutare Sister City Association.

42
00:11:40.525 --> 00:11:43.962
<v Chido Dilawayo>Mami Kikuchi with the Portland-Sapporo Sister City Association.

43
00:11:44.782 --> 00:11:48.057
<v Chido Dilawayo>Vivian Rin with the Portland-Suzhou Sister City Association.

44
00:11:48.972 --> 00:11:52.393
<v Chido Dilawayo>Catherine Morrow with the Portland-Ulsan Sister City Association.

45
00:11:52.971 --> 00:12:03.220
<v Chido Dilawayo>And Tatiana Turdel I'd like to recognize the incredible volunteer leaders for their service and dedication to the City of Portland.

46
00:12:03.480 --> 00:12:05.289
<v Chido Dilawayo>Thank you, and this completes the report.

47
00:12:06.019 --> 00:12:06.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

48
00:12:06.840 --> 00:12:14.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to thank each of our association leaders for everything that you are doing on behalf of our, our, our city and for the cities and people that you represent.

49
00:12:14.759 --> 00:12:23.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, what you do, you know, organizing exchanges, hosting delegations, raising scholarship funds, welcoming students, building friendship across thousands of miles—.

50
00:12:23.539 --> 00:12:24.299
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's the living embodiment of what the Sister Cities program is all about.

51
00:12:28.273 --> 00:12:31.724
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also would like to just take a moment to give some special recognition to Chito here.

52
00:12:32.820 --> 00:12:40.996
<v Jamie Dunphy>Chito has worked hard to ensure that our city stays meaningfully connected and engaged with our sister city relationships amidst no shortage of other important work.

53
00:12:41.077 --> 00:12:42.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, Chito, thank you for all your work on this.

54
00:12:43.798 --> 00:12:44.120
<v Robert Pyle>You bet.

55
00:12:44.346 --> 00:12:44.556
<v Steve Novick>Today—.

56
00:12:48.292 --> 00:12:51.754
<v Jamie Dunphy>So today is a day to celebrate.

57
00:12:52.488 --> 00:12:57.464
<v Jamie Dunphy>With Lviv shortly becoming officially part of the Portland family, we will be 10 sister cities strong.

58
00:12:58.124 --> 00:12:59.782
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much for everything you're doing here.

59
00:13:00.331 --> 00:13:02.066
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, uh, let's give another round of applause.

60
00:13:02.178 --> 00:13:07.528
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

61
00:13:10.210 --> 00:13:11.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

62
00:13:13.910 --> 00:13:18.034
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, before we gavel in, I wanted to turn it over to, uh, Councilor Koyama Lane.

63
00:13:18.697 --> 00:13:19.241
<v Chido Dilawayo>Thank you.

64
00:13:19.418 --> 00:13:19.835
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

65
00:13:20.235 --> 00:13:27.192
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Colleagues, I wanted to welcome a group of 6th, 7th, and 8th graders who are here from Sunnyside Environmental School.

66
00:13:27.513 --> 00:13:30.414
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I actually taught some of these students when they were in 3rd grade.

67
00:13:30.495 --> 00:13:34.293
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They've been doing their learning, their classroom work today in City Hall.

68
00:13:34.405 --> 00:13:41.027
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They even got to have some time with the mayor earlier to present some of their policy ideas to myself and Mayor Wilson.

69
00:13:41.539 --> 00:13:45.210
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Very proud of them, and it's always great to see young Portlanders in this space.

70
00:13:45.322 --> 00:13:50.692
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I hope they're seeing a possible future where they're maybe working in city government or are maybe sitting on this this dais one day.

71
00:13:50.998 --> 00:13:51.913
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

72
00:13:52.136 --> 00:13:52.988
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Carmelaine.

73
00:13:53.677 --> 00:13:54.287
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, thank you.

74
00:13:54.366 --> 00:13:57.014
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am now calling to order this meeting of the Portland City Council.

75
00:13:58.072 --> 00:13:59.373
<v Jamie Dunphy>Rebecca, can we please call the roll?

76
00:14:00.158 --> 00:14:00.576
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

77
00:14:01.282 --> 00:14:02.373
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

78
00:14:03.287 --> 00:14:03.817
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kurtelgini?

79
00:14:04.234 --> 00:14:04.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

80
00:14:04.892 --> 00:14:05.245
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

81
00:14:05.614 --> 00:14:05.725
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

82
00:14:06.239 --> 00:14:06.865
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

83
00:14:07.201 --> 00:14:07.410
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

84
00:14:08.004 --> 00:14:09.880
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

85
00:14:11.308 --> 00:14:11.422
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

86
00:14:12.351 --> 00:14:12.913
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

87
00:14:13.234 --> 00:14:13.346
<v Steve Novick>Here.

88
00:14:13.940 --> 00:14:14.356
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

89
00:14:14.597 --> 00:14:14.710
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

90
00:14:15.480 --> 00:14:15.769
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

91
00:14:16.855 --> 00:14:17.048
<v Mitch Green>Here.

92
00:14:17.419 --> 00:14:17.806
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

93
00:14:18.080 --> 00:14:18.177
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

94
00:14:19.029 --> 00:14:19.336
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

95
00:14:24.700 --> 00:14:25.053
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

96
00:14:27.245 --> 00:14:27.440
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

97
00:14:28.230 --> 00:14:28.552
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

98
00:14:28.809 --> 00:14:28.971
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

99
00:14:29.615 --> 00:14:31.051
<v Jamie Dunphy>And can we please read the rules of decorum?

100
00:14:32.389 --> 00:14:32.857
<v Robert Taylor>Good afternoon.

101
00:14:33.311 --> 00:14:35.024
<v Robert Taylor>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

102
00:14:35.105 --> 00:14:41.119
<v Robert Taylor>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

103
00:14:44.471 --> 00:14:47.934
<v Robert Taylor>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

104
00:14:48.720 --> 00:14:52.375
<v Robert Taylor>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless presiding officer states otherwise.

105
00:14:52.871 --> 00:14:54.971
<v Robert Taylor>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

106
00:14:55.532 --> 00:14:57.231
<v Robert Taylor>The presiding officer preserves order.

107
00:14:57.519 --> 00:15:05.839
<v Robert Taylor>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

108
00:15:06.495 --> 00:15:08.484
<v Robert Taylor>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

109
00:15:08.996 --> 00:15:11.288
<v Robert Taylor>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

110
00:15:11.352 --> 00:15:11.465
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

111
00:15:11.962 --> 00:15:15.365
<v Robert Taylor>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

112
00:15:15.975 --> 00:15:18.912
<v Robert Taylor>Additionally, Council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

113
00:15:19.570 --> 00:15:22.250
<v Robert Taylor>Your testimony today should address the matter being considered.

114
00:15:22.394 --> 00:15:24.657
<v Robert Taylor>When testifying, state your name for the record.

115
00:15:24.705 --> 00:15:26.020
<v Robert Taylor>Your address is not necessary.

116
00:15:26.567 --> 00:15:29.278
<v Robert Taylor>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

117
00:15:29.519 --> 00:15:33.066
<v Robert Taylor>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

118
00:15:33.307 --> 00:15:33.692
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

119
00:15:34.269 --> 00:15:35.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, colleagues.

120
00:15:35.232 --> 00:15:39.856
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a reminder, this is a recessed meeting of our yesterday full city council meeting.

121
00:15:39.904 --> 00:15:43.552
<v Jamie Dunphy>We've already had communications and approved our agenda, and we are on to item 13.

122
00:15:44.451 --> 00:15:45.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please call item number 13?

123
00:15:45.447 --> 00:15:46.701
<v Candace Avalos>Madam Council President, I am here.

124
00:15:46.894 --> 00:15:48.518
<v Candace Avalos>Apologies for missing the roll call again.

125
00:15:48.969 --> 00:15:49.741
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

126
00:15:50.015 --> 00:15:50.258
<v Dan Ryan>Welcome.

127
00:15:52.029 --> 00:16:00.400
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 13, create a sister city relationship between the City of Portland and the City of Lviv, Ukraine, document number 2026-177.

128
00:16:00.985 --> 00:16:04.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the second reading, uh, Thank you, Councilor Smith.

129
00:16:04.529 --> 00:16:04.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

130
00:16:04.529 --> 00:16:08.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today we are here to discuss an ordinance formalizing the relationship between the City of Portland and the City of Lviv, Ukraine.

131
00:16:08.769 --> 00:16:10.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>We all spoke to this historic moment last week.

132
00:16:10.870 --> 00:16:16.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>However, joining us today is a special guest whom we are honored to welcome despite the significant time difference.

133
00:16:16.149 --> 00:16:17.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'd like to set him up with a little bit of fanfare.

134
00:16:18.850 --> 00:16:28.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lviv has long been one of Ukraine's leading cultural educational centers, known for its historic architecture, vibrant art community, civic engagement, and strong tradition of local democracy.

135
00:16:28.610 --> 00:16:32.509
<v Jamie Dunphy>In recent years, this city has also played a critical humanitarian role.

136
00:16:32.990 --> 00:16:33.166
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

137
00:16:33.230 --> 00:16:39.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcoming internally displaced Ukrainians and helping coordinate relief and recovery efforts during an extraordinarily challenging time for the country.

138
00:16:40.558 --> 00:16:54.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>This ordinance recognizes that even during periods of global uncertainty, cities continue to have both the opportunity and the responsibility to build bridges, strengthen relationships, and advance shared values through local diplomacy.

139
00:16:55.625 --> 00:17:02.486
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just got note that our special guest has not logged on quite yet, but I will note, and when he gets here, we'll acknowledge him.

140
00:17:02.956 --> 00:17:08.321
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our first— our guest is First Deputy Mayor of Lviv, Andriy Moskalenko.

141
00:17:09.034 --> 00:17:16.605
<v Jamie Dunphy>He has helped lead the city through a period of profound challenge and resilience while advancing its vision for recovery, innovation, and international partnership.

142
00:17:17.376 --> 00:17:22.506
<v Jamie Dunphy>His presence reflects the strong commitment of both our cities to build a meaningful and lasting relationship.

143
00:17:25.115 --> 00:17:35.028
<v Jamie Dunphy>Still doesn't seem like he's logged on yet, but but when we are here, we will welcome Deputy Mayor Moskalenko to speak.

144
00:17:35.093 --> 00:17:38.934
<v Jamie Dunphy>But until then, delaying for a few moments, seeing if any—.

145
00:17:39.306 --> 00:17:41.628
<v Olivia Clark>Are they about 8 hours ahead of us?

146
00:17:41.709 --> 00:17:42.886
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think they're more than that.

147
00:17:43.000 --> 00:17:43.516
<v Loretta Smith>More than that?

148
00:17:43.968 --> 00:17:44.338
<v Olivia Clark>10 Hours?

149
00:17:44.386 --> 00:17:45.791
<v Olivia Clark>So it's late night over there.

150
00:17:45.840 --> 00:17:46.522
<v Jamie Dunphy>Quite late, yes.

151
00:17:46.653 --> 00:17:49.203
<v Jamie Dunphy>But this was an important opportunity that he was hoping for us.

152
00:17:49.317 --> 00:17:50.145
<v Olivia Clark>That's terrific.

153
00:17:50.276 --> 00:17:57.029
<v Olivia Clark>Well, we did have a chance to hear from the real mayor during the great.

154
00:17:57.596 --> 00:17:58.646
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

155
00:17:58.971 --> 00:18:02.318
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, why don't we— why don't we move to, uh, councilor comments for now on this?

156
00:18:02.594 --> 00:18:08.311
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, go ahead and jump in the queue, colleagues, and if our Deputy Mayor friend is able to join us, we will get him on screen.

157
00:18:08.827 --> 00:18:13.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>But, uh, whoever wants to talk— Councilor Kanal can kick us off.

158
00:18:14.217 --> 00:18:15.184
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

159
00:18:15.281 --> 00:18:19.080
<v Sameer Kanal>I said most of what I wanted to say last week, so I will keep this relatively brief.

160
00:18:19.144 --> 00:18:27.136
<v Sameer Kanal>But thank you to Mayor Andres Sadovski as Sadavi, as well as, uh, First Deputy Mayor, when he gets here, uh, Moskalenko, as well as his full City Council.

161
00:18:27.201 --> 00:18:32.886
<v Sameer Kanal>The City Council of Lviv has 64 members, so if I really wanted to take up and stall, I would read them all, but I won't.

162
00:18:33.127 --> 00:18:35.761
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but, uh, take that, those who think 12 is a lot.

163
00:18:36.596 --> 00:18:38.154
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, but thank you to the whole government over there.

164
00:18:38.749 --> 00:18:46.297
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, second, thank you to Tatiana, the whole Sister City Association, as well as our performers from earlier today who I see up there, for sharing the culture of Lviv with us.

165
00:18:46.376 --> 00:18:48.980
<v Sameer Kanal>And finally, uh, thank you to Cheeto, Thank you.

166
00:18:49.028 --> 00:18:50.009
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor DiLucaio, for your work.

167
00:18:50.653 --> 00:18:52.844
<v Sameer Kanal>We under-resource the international work at the city.

168
00:18:52.907 --> 00:18:54.373
<v Sameer Kanal>We ask staff to do a lot.

169
00:18:54.421 --> 00:19:01.555
<v Sameer Kanal>We only have one staffer who's solely focused on this type of work, and I wanted to appreciate the work that you've been able to do despite these challenges.

170
00:19:03.258 --> 00:19:04.406
<v Sameer Kanal>Sister cities are important.

171
00:19:04.454 --> 00:19:06.170
<v Sameer Kanal>They're statements of where we stand.

172
00:19:06.219 --> 00:19:12.837
<v Sameer Kanal>They're statements of who we stand with in terms of local government to local government, but also population to population.

173
00:19:13.760 --> 00:19:22.076
<v Sameer Kanal>I really appreciate how much we've gotten to learn not only about Ukraine, which is excellent throughout this process, That ability to learn it, but specifically about Lviv.

174
00:19:22.909 --> 00:19:27.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously learning about America doesn't teach you necessarily a lot about Portland and its uniqueness.

175
00:19:27.798 --> 00:19:31.213
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's been really nice to be able to do that in reverse.

176
00:19:31.871 --> 00:19:40.175
<v Sameer Kanal>And I hope that we have a chance to visit and to see and maybe even take a couple Portland roses over there and bring some of theirs back with us.

177
00:19:41.026 --> 00:19:42.836
<v Sameer Kanal>But I intend to obviously vote yes on this.

178
00:19:43.190 --> 00:19:48.384
<v Sameer Kanal>And thank you for bringing this forward to the mayor and grateful to be able to co-sponsor this with Councilor Ryan as well.

179
00:19:48.497 --> 00:19:48.689
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

180
00:19:52.660 --> 00:19:53.210
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

181
00:19:53.210 --> 00:19:54.309
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

182
00:19:54.430 --> 00:19:55.630
<v Dan Ryan>And we're still waiting, right?

183
00:19:55.769 --> 00:19:57.470
<v Dan Ryan>All right.

184
00:19:57.470 --> 00:20:01.170
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to first of all look out there where she— Tatiana, thank you for your perseverance.

185
00:20:02.490 --> 00:20:09.410
<v Dan Ryan>I recall you coming to this body years ago, especially during the beginning of the conflict and the war.

186
00:20:09.410 --> 00:20:13.170
<v Dan Ryan>And I just really appreciate your perseverance to see this through.

187
00:20:13.170 --> 00:20:14.369
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you so much.

188
00:20:14.369 --> 00:20:15.890
<v Dan Ryan>And your comments downstairs, I think, The were very insightful.

189
00:20:15.890 --> 00:20:15.930
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

190
00:20:15.932 --> 00:20:19.593
<v Dan Ryan>Performances downstairs earlier were very touching, as was the beautiful music.

191
00:20:19.689 --> 00:20:20.556
<v Dan Ryan>There's the musicians.

192
00:20:20.813 --> 00:20:21.310
<v Dan Ryan>There you are.

193
00:20:21.632 --> 00:20:22.819
<v Dan Ryan>Your name, Darka?

194
00:20:23.397 --> 00:20:23.702
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

195
00:20:23.799 --> 00:20:24.410
<v Dan Ryan>And Miri?

196
00:20:25.486 --> 00:20:25.678
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

197
00:20:25.967 --> 00:20:26.560
<v Dan Ryan>Yay.

198
00:20:27.412 --> 00:20:29.901
<v Dan Ryan>They look like they should be musicians, those of you that can't see them.

199
00:20:30.462 --> 00:20:33.498
<v Dan Ryan>And they just really centered us with music.

200
00:20:33.755 --> 00:20:45.090
<v Dan Ryan>There's something about music and food, no irony to what I'm seeing in front of me with some of the signs at the moment, That really do are a big part of international relations work.

201
00:20:45.539 --> 00:20:53.230
<v Dan Ryan>I've had the pleasure of being on this council 5 and a half years, and I dove into one of the sister cities relationships, and that's in Kaohsiung.

202
00:20:53.970 --> 00:20:58.369
<v Dan Ryan>And I've been able to see firsthand the professionalism of Chito that she provides for the city.

203
00:20:59.124 --> 00:21:06.606
<v Dan Ryan>And I also really noticed how important it is that we continue to dive into these, especially when there's conflict.

204
00:21:06.671 --> 00:21:06.815
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

205
00:21:07.873 --> 00:21:16.605
<v Dan Ryan>When I was in Kaohsiung, unfortunately, the conflict in Ireland started and you could feel tension from international guests.

206
00:21:16.828 --> 00:21:26.923
<v Dan Ryan>And but we were able to look at each other in the eye and talk and realize that the government's actions at some very top level are not what the people are like.

207
00:21:27.564 --> 00:21:30.703
<v Dan Ryan>And so we always have to remember to really lean into those friendships.

208
00:21:31.169 --> 00:21:35.510
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm delighted that this weekend we'll be having a lot of fun down at the waterfront.

209
00:21:35.590 --> 00:21:35.719
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

210
00:21:36.795 --> 00:21:43.022
<v Dan Ryan>When we have the Challenge Cup between the City Council, the mayor, and the Kaohsiung City Council.

211
00:21:43.857 --> 00:21:45.239
<v Dan Ryan>And you know how that was created?

212
00:21:45.303 --> 00:21:49.958
<v Dan Ryan>It was created after being up for like 2 days, it felt like, at the end of a dinner.

213
00:21:50.519 --> 00:21:56.619
<v Dan Ryan>And I was trying to convince them to come to Portland as a body to be in the dragon boat race.

214
00:21:57.406 --> 00:21:58.433
<v Dan Ryan>And so they agreed.

215
00:21:58.626 --> 00:21:59.830
<v Dan Ryan>But here's how they agreed.

216
00:22:00.794 --> 00:22:02.865
<v Dan Ryan>They said, well, we won't have time to practice.

217
00:22:03.666 --> 00:22:06.297
<v Dan Ryan>And I said, well, last year we only practiced 3 times.

218
00:22:07.035 --> 00:22:08.461
<v Dan Ryan>And then she said, okay, we're in.

219
00:22:09.311 --> 00:22:13.128
<v Dan Ryan>So I have a feeling we're going to have some major competition on Saturday.

220
00:22:13.690 --> 00:22:16.449
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm really happy that the mayor also is participating.

221
00:22:16.497 --> 00:22:21.180
<v Dan Ryan>He kind of had to because we did a video, all of us in Kaohsiung that night to challenge the mayor.

222
00:22:21.339 --> 00:22:22.527
<v Dan Ryan>So he really didn't have a choice.

223
00:22:23.313 --> 00:22:28.429
<v Dan Ryan>Anyway, I'm giving you that story to say that those are the stories that build friendships, that build relationships.

224
00:22:28.573 --> 00:22:28.684
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

225
00:22:28.925 --> 00:22:34.157
<v Dan Ryan>That go beyond whatever the government is saying at the top.

226
00:22:34.720 --> 00:22:39.261
<v Dan Ryan>And so Portland has to continue to build these relationships, and I'm so happy that we now have 10.

227
00:22:39.872 --> 00:22:45.280
<v Dan Ryan>So I'll stop because I'm really sure that this Deputy Mayor is about ready to get on.

228
00:22:45.713 --> 00:22:50.642
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, unfortunately, it looks like technology, time zones, and transportation have failed us.

229
00:22:50.914 --> 00:22:54.221
<v Jamie Dunphy>And unfortunately, our Deputy Mayor will not be able to join us today.

230
00:22:54.925 --> 00:22:56.738
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, deeply disappointed.

231
00:22:56.786 --> 00:23:01.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will find some new ways to include them in this body.

232
00:23:01.417 --> 00:23:09.769
<v Dan Ryan>As Councilor Clark said, there was a really delightful, um, video that we saw with the mayor of— um, Nieta Rose at the end, and everyone will remember that part the most.

233
00:23:10.153 --> 00:23:13.536
<v Dan Ryan>We saw a rose from, um, um, Lev today.

234
00:23:13.632 --> 00:23:14.769
<v Dan Ryan>So let's do this.

235
00:23:14.978 --> 00:23:16.067
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, uh, Councilor Green.

236
00:23:17.382 --> 00:23:26.253
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, just briefly, I wanted to add my voice to the chorus of folks who are giving Cheeto flowers for, um, Your steadfast work on advancing this relationship.

237
00:23:26.301 --> 00:23:31.231
<v Mitch Green>I'm really proud of the contribution that you deliver for our city and also our sister city.

238
00:23:31.327 --> 00:23:31.826
<v Zachary Lindahl>So thank you.

239
00:23:32.067 --> 00:23:38.394
<v Dan Ryan>Before I forget, can I just say I want to acknowledge Laura Porter, who's a new Rosarian, who's a part of this sister city.

240
00:23:38.490 --> 00:23:44.755
<v Dan Ryan>And if it wasn't for her email to me about 6 weeks ago, I was trying to move this from July to the date today.

241
00:23:44.914 --> 00:23:52.351
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm really grateful that we moved it to today because it's wonderful to do it on the Absolutely.

242
00:23:52.690 --> 00:23:53.317
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

243
00:23:53.738 --> 00:23:54.494
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

244
00:23:55.510 --> 00:24:00.539
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I feel especially moved by a lot of the testimony and emails that I've gotten about this.

245
00:24:00.669 --> 00:24:15.838
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's someone from District 2 who wrote in and said how much this sister city is going to mean to the local Ukrainian community who've been displaced in this horrible war and said even if someone's not from Lviv, they know that Lviv has played a crucial role as a humanitarian hub.

246
00:24:16.373 --> 00:24:17.657
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And has helped many displaced people.

247
00:24:17.897 --> 00:24:18.588
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Now we can help them.

248
00:24:19.440 --> 00:24:29.185
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also want to pile on and thank Chito for all the work she does with our international relations, strengthening relationships and engagement, that people-to-people connections.

249
00:24:29.763 --> 00:24:45.065
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, um, and also as a councilor, she's supported me in getting to meet different electeds from Japan and work with our consul general from Japan who's in the area and taught me how to use both hands when you give business card culturally to people from Japan.

250
00:24:45.128 --> 00:24:46.541
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So thank you for all your work, Chito.

251
00:24:47.922 --> 00:24:48.853
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

252
00:24:49.446 --> 00:24:52.994
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue— oh, Councilor Novick.

253
00:24:54.247 --> 00:25:04.297
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say that I've had the experience of visiting a sister city 10 years ago, visited Bologna, and I was going to Italy anyway, and I thought, well, it's a sister city, I guess I gotta go.

254
00:25:04.761 --> 00:25:08.598
<v Steve Novick>And it's one of my favorite cities, and you really did get red carpet treatment.

255
00:25:09.184 --> 00:25:14.204
<v Steve Novick>So I was actually just looking for flights to Lviv, but I should have realized that there's not commercial flights operating now.

256
00:25:14.753 --> 00:25:18.008
<v Steve Novick>But you can fly to Poland and take a land route over.

257
00:25:18.545 --> 00:25:22.273
<v Steve Novick>And I hope that some of us are able to do that in the next couple of years.

258
00:25:24.019 --> 00:25:24.815
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

259
00:25:28.319 --> 00:25:28.595
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

260
00:25:29.324 --> 00:25:36.289
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, to our colleagues participating virtually, please put cameras on and we will move to a roll call vote.

261
00:25:40.047 --> 00:25:40.256
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

262
00:25:41.092 --> 00:25:41.333
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

263
00:25:42.218 --> 00:25:42.684
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

264
00:25:43.103 --> 00:25:43.231
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

265
00:25:43.826 --> 00:25:44.132
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

266
00:25:44.470 --> 00:25:44.549
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

267
00:25:45.500 --> 00:25:45.820
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

268
00:25:46.077 --> 00:25:46.125
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

269
00:25:46.607 --> 00:25:47.123
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

270
00:25:49.131 --> 00:25:49.179
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

271
00:25:50.175 --> 00:25:50.673
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

272
00:25:50.818 --> 00:25:50.851
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

273
00:25:51.798 --> 00:25:52.183
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

274
00:25:52.586 --> 00:25:52.617
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

275
00:25:53.244 --> 00:25:53.534
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

276
00:25:53.872 --> 00:25:54.031
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

277
00:25:54.740 --> 00:25:54.965
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

278
00:25:55.320 --> 00:25:55.402
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

279
00:25:56.048 --> 00:25:56.435
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

280
00:25:57.421 --> 00:25:57.470
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

281
00:25:58.423 --> 00:25:58.971
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

282
00:25:59.762 --> 00:25:59.811
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

283
00:26:00.586 --> 00:26:00.925
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

284
00:26:01.496 --> 00:26:01.528
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

285
00:26:02.325 --> 00:26:04.926
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the ordinance passes with 12 aye votes.

286
00:26:05.317 --> 00:26:06.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

287
00:26:06.211 --> 00:26:07.008
<v Jamie Dunphy>Congratulations.

288
00:26:07.740 --> 00:26:07.932
<v Keelan McClymont>Welcome all.

289
00:26:08.255 --> 00:26:13.211
<v Mitch Green>Welcome, welcome to the family.

290
00:26:18.740 --> 00:26:19.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 14?

291
00:26:20.711 --> 00:26:26.047
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 14, add code to prohibit the sale or provision of certain force-fed poultry products.

292
00:26:26.516 --> 00:26:28.358
<v Rebecca Dobert>Add Code Chapter 17.110.

293
00:26:31.530 --> 00:26:33.605
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

294
00:26:33.653 --> 00:26:35.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

295
00:26:35.969 --> 00:26:37.161
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, to discussion?

296
00:26:37.258 --> 00:26:37.965
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

297
00:26:40.721 --> 00:26:42.846
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, thank you, colleagues.

298
00:26:42.894 --> 00:26:48.377
<v Eric Zimmerman>You may see in the posted documents with this, I've posted an amendment, Zimmerman 1.

299
00:26:49.382 --> 00:27:03.183
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciated the delay that you adopted last time, and, um, Um, you know, from a perspective of, uh, well, I'm going to read it in and then I can discuss it.

300
00:27:03.537 --> 00:27:26.042
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, uh, applicability: this chapter does not apply to retail establishments or food service establishment that regularly, in the course of its normal operations as of June 1st, 2026, provided, sold, or offered for sale, or provided free of charge, or served in any other manner by any force-fed product or food product in which a force-fed product is an ingredient.

301
00:27:26.123 --> 00:27:34.290
<v Eric Zimmerman>This section may be asserted as an affirmative defense to any enforcement under— and then it lists the Portland City Code.

302
00:27:35.269 --> 00:27:44.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>In other words, this is a grandfather clause or a legacy exemption clause, uh, which I would move, and I would ask for a second so that we can then discuss.

303
00:27:44.337 --> 00:27:44.659
<v Dan Ryan>Second.

304
00:27:44.818 --> 00:27:45.237
<v Eric Engstrom>Second.

305
00:27:45.622 --> 00:27:48.734
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman moves Zimmerman 1, and Ryan seconds.

306
00:27:49.008 --> 00:27:49.634
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

307
00:27:49.713 --> 00:27:49.875
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

308
00:27:50.067 --> 00:27:51.013
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, I appreciate that.

309
00:27:51.720 --> 00:28:10.858
<v Eric Zimmerman>I, I think that I think that in the world of compromise, that this offers us an option here that— you know, I was trying to think about what does it mean to be not of a political party but of a liberal mindset, right?

310
00:28:10.939 --> 00:28:19.536
<v Eric Zimmerman>I consider myself a liberal mindset, and the liberal mindset is that there are many ways of life underneath the tent in which you consider your society.

311
00:28:19.584 --> 00:28:19.808
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

312
00:28:20.567 --> 00:28:24.213
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then there's the illiberal, which says only our way.

313
00:28:25.343 --> 00:28:28.054
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that I don't give a damn about foie gras.

314
00:28:29.737 --> 00:28:29.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't.

315
00:28:30.481 --> 00:28:31.077
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really don't.

316
00:28:32.038 --> 00:28:40.646
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I do, without cursing, give a darn about the role in which government plays.

317
00:28:41.710 --> 00:29:00.967
<v Eric Zimmerman>And while there may be— and I don't know the true number— there may be only 7, as reported by some media establishments, of restaurants in our community who sell this product, I think that this will pass easily because not enough people care— or not, not enough, that gives it a value statement.

318
00:29:01.288 --> 00:29:08.763
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's just such a small thing in our community for such a small group, and that's okay, but it doesn't rise up to be a fervor.

319
00:29:08.844 --> 00:29:29.624
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what we should care about is that to be a liberal society, to be a liberal community, we have to accept that some folks do a thing that we may not personally enjoy, that we may not personally abide by, that we may not personally find to be something that we want to participate in.

320
00:29:29.961 --> 00:29:33.269
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that is the great goal of, I think, a liberal society.

321
00:29:34.700 --> 00:29:40.499
<v Eric Zimmerman>A couple of years ago, Multnomah County banned hookah locations, right?

322
00:29:40.964 --> 00:29:51.299
<v Eric Zimmerman>And they did that from a public health perspective because Multnomah County has a long, drawn-out history, which was good in terms of reducing tobacco use by young people.

323
00:29:51.912 --> 00:29:53.349
<v Eric Zimmerman>Great, great mission.

324
00:29:54.757 --> 00:30:04.826
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what they inadvertently did is they removed a significant cultural gathering place for a very small portion of our community.

325
00:30:05.907 --> 00:30:07.248
<v Eric Zimmerman>They eliminated it like that.

326
00:30:07.683 --> 00:30:15.315
<v Eric Zimmerman>And as a person who has been stationed in multiple countries where that was a cultural gathering space.

327
00:30:15.426 --> 00:30:25.172
<v Eric Zimmerman>In fact, my going away by the locals in Bangladesh was to bring in— actually, like you bring in hookah providers, if you will.

328
00:30:25.220 --> 00:30:26.152
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's part of a party.

329
00:30:26.986 --> 00:30:28.865
<v Eric Zimmerman>I say that not because it's related to foie gras.

330
00:30:29.074 --> 00:30:43.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>I say that because in Portland, in a community that I think strives to have many people under our sun and for them to do well, and that we won't always understand everybody.

331
00:30:44.549 --> 00:30:56.737
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that Multnomah County failed because they put their desire to protect children from tobacco, and somehow they used that lens to say people over 21 couldn't go into a place and make a choice for themselves.

332
00:30:57.643 --> 00:30:59.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think they got that backwards.

333
00:30:59.194 --> 00:31:00.990
<v Eric Zimmerman>This feels very similar to me.

334
00:31:01.701 --> 00:31:04.836
<v Eric Zimmerman>If we don't grandfather in the current providers of foie gras—.

335
00:31:04.836 --> 00:31:05.686
<v Zachary Lindahl>I, I only know, I think, the one who came to testify.

336
00:31:05.752 --> 00:31:07.208
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really don't know where— I think there's 2.

337
00:31:09.231 --> 00:31:10.162
<v Eric Zimmerman>This product is sold.

338
00:31:10.835 --> 00:31:20.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I find it more responsible if the goal is to reduce the product in the future, that this would allow that to happen.

339
00:31:20.452 --> 00:31:24.925
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if any of these establishments cease to exist, then the grandfather clause goes away.

340
00:31:26.208 --> 00:31:29.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I would ask for reasonable consideration of this amendment.

341
00:31:29.575 --> 00:31:36.961
<v Eric Zimmerman>I recognize it may not be palatable to everybody, but again, it may not be palatable to everybody, but that is the liberal mindset in a liberal society.

342
00:31:37.413 --> 00:31:42.259
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I would really appreciate at least some basic consideration of this, uh, as we offer it up.

343
00:31:42.339 --> 00:31:42.808
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, colleagues.

344
00:31:43.309 --> 00:31:44.117
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

345
00:31:44.781 --> 00:31:46.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues to the amendment?

346
00:31:46.318 --> 00:31:47.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

347
00:31:48.826 --> 00:31:51.641
<v Candace Avalos>I want to talk to under— to the underlying, so I'll stand in queue for that.

348
00:31:51.690 --> 00:31:52.417
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

349
00:31:52.482 --> 00:31:54.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green, to the amendment?

350
00:31:54.182 --> 00:31:54.876
<v Mitch Green>Yes, to the amendment.

351
00:31:55.055 --> 00:31:59.050
<v Mitch Green>Um, thank you for articulating your position, Councilor Zimmerman.

352
00:31:59.099 --> 00:32:00.086
<v Mitch Green>I always enjoy when you do.

353
00:32:00.718 --> 00:32:06.612
<v Mitch Green>Um, I I want to challenge a couple things there in the sake of, you know, the discourse here.

354
00:32:08.550 --> 00:32:16.349
<v Mitch Green>I think what you're describing is more of a classic liberal society or a libertarian society, which is sort of a laissez-faire approach to things.

355
00:32:16.559 --> 00:32:23.978
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, I would embrace much more of a modern liberal society that says it's okay to regulate certain things in the public good.

356
00:32:24.740 --> 00:32:26.259
<v Mitch Green>Mm-hmm.

357
00:32:26.307 --> 00:32:31.953
<v Mitch Green>For instance, we used to allow the sale of shark fin as a delicacy in the United States, and we banned that practice.

358
00:32:32.452 --> 00:32:35.818
<v Mitch Green>And I don't think that that is a generally controversial thing.

359
00:32:37.170 --> 00:32:52.144
<v Mitch Green>I also earlier in the year, maybe it was last year now, sought to bring forward an ordinance to make it much easier to run sidewalk vending carts by removing some of the proximity requirements near adjacent businesses.

360
00:32:52.192 --> 00:33:01.336
<v Mitch Green>While you haven't had a chance to weigh in on that, I had some colleagues say that, you know, we actually want to regulate that and prevent that sort of competition.

361
00:33:01.384 --> 00:33:06.549
<v Mitch Green>So I think there's appetite on this body to pick and choose what it is we regulate and how to do it.

362
00:33:06.821 --> 00:33:07.544
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's okay.

363
00:33:08.569 --> 00:33:19.058
<v Mitch Green>I wouldn't want someone in my neighborhood to fire up a coal-fired power plant because they have the ultimate freedom to do so under that sort of frame.

364
00:33:19.476 --> 00:33:23.195
<v Mitch Green>And because of that, we've got land use, we've got zoning considerations to restrict that.

365
00:33:23.244 --> 00:33:23.580
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a good point.

366
00:33:26.703 --> 00:33:28.857
<v Mitch Green>So I think of this in the same vein.

367
00:33:29.355 --> 00:33:43.357
<v Mitch Green>I'll note that my opposition is not on the sort of rhetorical basis of what a liberal or libertarian or authoritarian society is, but rather what it does functionally to the ordinance that underlies it.

368
00:33:43.439 --> 00:33:45.135
<v Mitch Green>I think that this largely guts it.

369
00:33:46.057 --> 00:33:49.165
<v Mitch Green>It allows the under— it allows the ongoing sale of marijuana to happen.

370
00:33:49.230 --> 00:33:57.897
<v Mitch Green>Councilor and consumption of foie gras in the City of Portland and largely changes nothing about the current conditions.

371
00:33:58.123 --> 00:34:02.471
<v Mitch Green>And what the ordinance is trying to do is say we want to cease this practice in the City of Portland.

372
00:34:02.777 --> 00:34:11.268
<v Mitch Green>And I've already compromised by voting in favor of an amendment that delays the implementation day quite far into the future.

373
00:34:12.038 --> 00:34:15.425
<v Mitch Green>So while I appreciate the intent, I thank you for laying out your argumentation.

374
00:34:15.536 --> 00:34:17.815
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to support the amendment today for that reason.

375
00:34:17.913 --> 00:34:18.041
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

376
00:34:19.951 --> 00:34:20.706
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

377
00:34:21.010 --> 00:34:23.257
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark, Vice President Clark.

378
00:34:24.045 --> 00:34:25.023
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

379
00:34:25.731 --> 00:34:30.610
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman, for offering this up, this compromise.

380
00:34:30.804 --> 00:34:37.626
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's very interesting, and I really appreciate the story about the hookah lounges and the mistake that Multnomah County made.

381
00:34:38.188 --> 00:34:54.737
<v Olivia Clark>But I, I really believe in choice, and in choice to control my body, control what I eat, and I'd like to know from maybe Councilor Green, what shade of liberalism is it that dictates how I can control my body?

382
00:34:57.842 --> 00:35:03.844
<v Mitch Green>I would say that you're trying to draw a false equivalency to bodily autonomy in a very inappropriate way, Councilor.

383
00:35:04.474 --> 00:35:19.039
<v Mitch Green>I think that we have got a tradition in the United States of saying we think that certain activities have an unacceptable harm to the broader society or the broader economy or the broader environmental that go beyond individual choice.

384
00:35:19.858 --> 00:35:24.653
<v Mitch Green>And so I am comfortable with a certain level of regulation in society.

385
00:35:25.007 --> 00:35:27.253
<v Mitch Green>That's something that I'm saying is okay.

386
00:35:27.413 --> 00:35:35.096
<v Mitch Green>And I just, I don't accept this comparison to sort of abortion rights, for instance, is kind of, I think, what you're doing here.

387
00:35:35.416 --> 00:35:35.737
<v Steve Novick>Thanks.

388
00:35:36.396 --> 00:35:37.567
<v Olivia Clark>Can I ask another question?

389
00:35:37.838 --> 00:35:50.780
<v Olivia Clark>Not necessarily about choice or liberalism, but I understand that the underlying ordinance here was also on the books in Chicago and that it was repealed.

390
00:35:50.846 --> 00:35:53.105
<v Olivia Clark>Do you have any idea why it was repealed in Chicago?

391
00:35:54.250 --> 00:35:56.161
<v Mitch Green>I do not have any idea why it was repealed in Chicago.

392
00:35:58.838 --> 00:35:59.791
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you, Vice President Clark.

393
00:36:00.034 --> 00:36:00.681
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

394
00:36:03.025 --> 00:36:07.947
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, first of all, I wanted to say I I appreciate the impulse behind Councilor Zimmerman's amendment.

395
00:36:09.038 --> 00:36:14.501
<v Steve Novick>I don't want to see a dramatic negative impact in a couple of restaurants in Portland.

396
00:36:14.710 --> 00:36:23.476
<v Steve Novick>I actually made a reservation to go to Le Pigeon to eat the vegetarian menu a couple of weeks from now, but I've been warned that, well, if I do that, they might spit at my food.

397
00:36:23.539 --> 00:36:25.030
<v Steve Novick>So I might have to think about that.

398
00:36:25.527 --> 00:36:28.764
<v Steve Novick>Imagine if you go to Le Pigeon.

399
00:36:29.228 --> 00:36:39.925
<v Steve Novick>But I mean, I think that If there was seen to be some prospect of a dramatic new expansion of foie gras restaurants, then actually this amendment would appeal to me more.

400
00:36:40.213 --> 00:36:50.782
<v Steve Novick>But since I don't think there is such an expand— such a proposed expansion, it seemed, it seemed a little disingenuous to say it could keep on going in the places that it currently is, which is always going to happen anyway.

401
00:36:51.583 --> 00:36:59.471
<v Steve Novick>Um, this— I also wanted to respond to Councilor Clark's comment about being able to control what you put in your body.

402
00:37:00.311 --> 00:37:15.925
<v Steve Novick>And to say that I've heard people say government shouldn't control what people eat, and I just have a hard time believing that people— most people, or that a large number of people would actually want to take that to its logical conclusion.

403
00:37:17.990 --> 00:37:22.420
<v Steve Novick>It's only been illegal on a federal level to kill and eat dogs since 2018.

404
00:37:22.699 --> 00:37:29.686
<v Steve Novick>It was part of the 2018 Farm Bill passed by Republican Congress and signed by Donald Trump.

405
00:37:30.807 --> 00:37:47.297
<v Steve Novick>And I somehow don't think that if Maxine Dexter came forward with a proposal to repeal that and allow the killing and eating of dogs, people would applaud her and say that, you know, thank God that Maxine Dexter is standing up for our right to eat dogs.

406
00:37:47.969 --> 00:37:53.463
<v Steve Novick>So I think that I think that each of these decisions has to stand on its own merits.

407
00:37:53.625 --> 00:37:56.827
<v Steve Novick>I don't think that there are sweeping generalizations.

408
00:37:58.795 --> 00:38:13.101
<v Steve Novick>And this is a tough one for me, but ultimately I find myself in the same position as the city councilors in New York City in 2019 who voted 42 to 6 for this ban.

409
00:38:13.766 --> 00:38:24.130
<v Steve Novick>And I think that It probably wasn't like the thing that they started the year thinking they were going to vote on, but presented with the question, do you think it's okay to force-feed an animal to produce an expensive delicacy for a few people?

410
00:38:24.626 --> 00:38:26.967
<v Steve Novick>They voted 42 to 6 that no, they don't think it's okay.

411
00:38:27.672 --> 00:38:34.867
<v Steve Novick>In Pittsburgh in 1923— and Pittsburgh, by the way, I don't think is known as like a wacky liberal community— the city council vote was 7 to 2.

412
00:38:35.541 --> 00:38:39.114
<v Steve Novick>So I do think that this is a tough vote.

413
00:38:39.289 --> 00:38:39.786
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

414
00:38:40.237 --> 00:38:48.775
<v Steve Novick>But I reject the idea that there's sort of a general rule that anybody can eat anything they want, because I just— I don't think that most of us would ultimately agree with that.

415
00:38:50.175 --> 00:38:51.012
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

416
00:38:51.557 --> 00:38:53.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

417
00:38:55.880 --> 00:38:56.539
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, thank you.

418
00:38:56.701 --> 00:39:12.721
<v Angelita Morillo>I hope for the media that's watching this, they see how seriously this is being debated to the point where we are engaging in long philosophical diatribes about liberalism and what that actually means and bodily autonomy over a foie gras ban to just stop monkeys from getting tortured.

419
00:39:13.315 --> 00:39:34.221
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm sorry, but as someone with a uterus that is actually living through a time where our bodily autonomy is being stripped away from us, the idea that our feminism or our discussion about bodily autonomy means that we have a right to cause unnecessary pain to living creatures for our own gratification is an absurd comparison.

420
00:39:34.318 --> 00:39:35.858
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Smith, I'm sorry, but I think you're making an absurd comparison.

421
00:39:36.516 --> 00:39:42.215
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, foie gras is actually just a gross practice that does not need to exist.

422
00:39:42.695 --> 00:39:45.360
<v Angelita Morillo>We will all be okay without this additional delicacy.

423
00:39:45.440 --> 00:39:50.849
<v Angelita Morillo>There are many delicious and wonderful things to eat in the world that do not include having to force-feed an animal.

424
00:39:51.362 --> 00:40:14.923
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, and I, I'm sorry, but I just cannot believe that we are— while women are actually dying across the country because their abortion rights are being stripped away, and Black women are dying in hospitals at disproportionate rates because they are not getting the care that they need, that we are seriously entertaining that argument yet again at this dais over a foie gras ban.

425
00:40:15.534 --> 00:40:20.750
<v Angelita Morillo>So, um, personally, to the media, I would have liked to spend a lot less time on this.

426
00:40:20.813 --> 00:40:22.530
<v Angelita Morillo>This is a very simple vote to me.

427
00:40:23.221 --> 00:40:26.543
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, this should have moved through simply or died if people wanted to vote no.

428
00:40:26.592 --> 00:40:27.650
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Smith, I'm sorry, I have to interrupt you.

429
00:40:28.784 --> 00:40:31.329
<v Angelita Morillo>But hopefully we can get this done today and move on.

430
00:40:31.425 --> 00:40:33.052
<v Angelita Morillo>And I am going to be proudly voting yes.

431
00:40:33.213 --> 00:40:33.536
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks.

432
00:40:34.487 --> 00:40:35.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

433
00:40:36.259 --> 00:40:36.822
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

434
00:40:38.760 --> 00:40:39.742
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

435
00:40:39.902 --> 00:40:43.188
<v Olivia Clark>I, I too regret that we've spent so much time on this.

436
00:40:43.284 --> 00:40:48.103
<v Olivia Clark>In fact, I think I brought that up when this issue first surfaced in the Arts and Culture Committee.

437
00:40:48.152 --> 00:40:53.036
<v Olivia Clark>It's why are we spending so much time when we have other more important issues to be dealing with?

438
00:40:53.101 --> 00:40:53.637
<v Olivia Clark>But here we are.

439
00:40:54.246 --> 00:40:54.887
<v Olivia Clark>We're still at it.

440
00:40:55.449 --> 00:41:13.393
<v Olivia Clark>And I would just say, bottom line, colleagues, I think this is a real slap in the face at the handful of restaurants, the very small handful of restaurants in Portland that serve foie gras and that have helped us through very difficult times, that have helped put us on the map as a culinary destination.

441
00:41:14.052 --> 00:41:18.318
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's very unfortunate, and that's why I'm supporting Councilor Zimmerman's amendment.

442
00:41:18.557 --> 00:41:19.905
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

443
00:41:20.867 --> 00:41:21.414
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

444
00:41:23.615 --> 00:41:24.596
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. President.

445
00:41:24.804 --> 00:41:29.726
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I just wanted to say for the record I support, uh, Councilor Zimmerman's amendment.

446
00:41:30.032 --> 00:41:36.842
<v Loretta Smith>And I, I sat on the Arts, um, Committee, and this, this actual amendment failed.

447
00:41:36.923 --> 00:41:41.518
<v Loretta Smith>It did not pass our committee, so it had to go through a roundabout to get here today.

448
00:41:41.746 --> 00:41:50.289
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm from a district in District 1 And we don't even have no foie gras restaurants.

449
00:41:50.387 --> 00:41:52.266
<v Loretta Smith>I don't even know what it is really.

450
00:41:52.940 --> 00:42:14.242
<v Loretta Smith>But the idea that, um, that we are now getting into, to things that I don't think that we regulate here at the city, and there is expected to be, uh, a ballot measure where people will be able to, um, say what they want, if they want these kinds of things, um, regulated or banned.

451
00:42:14.722 --> 00:42:16.344
<v Loretta Smith>So that's coming up in November.

452
00:42:16.617 --> 00:42:23.501
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I'd like to see what the public has to say, and I think we should actually table this until after that vote is taken.

453
00:42:24.400 --> 00:42:24.690
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

454
00:42:25.780 --> 00:42:26.503
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

455
00:42:27.130 --> 00:42:27.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

456
00:42:28.590 --> 00:42:40.063
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to start by saying that I do see this amendment being brought by my colleague as genuinely looking to try to support some of these small businesses who are worried about the impact on their business.

457
00:42:40.800 --> 00:42:41.746
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I acknowledge that.

458
00:42:42.291 --> 00:42:51.327
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was glad and happy to support the amendment last week that extended a longer runway and lengthened the timeline for this.

459
00:42:52.224 --> 00:43:09.822
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And also, I'm worried that grandfathering creates some messy implementation, some questions regarding, you know, which businesses qualify, what happens if ownership changes, can exempted restaurants expand sales or if exemptions can transfer to new entities.

460
00:43:10.340 --> 00:43:19.302
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So for that reason, I— for all of those, I think that a universal, more universal standard is cleaner and simpler and is going to be easier for us to enforce.

461
00:43:21.070 --> 00:43:21.878
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

462
00:43:22.219 --> 00:43:22.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

463
00:43:23.190 --> 00:43:24.340
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

464
00:43:24.777 --> 00:43:29.101
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to acknowledge, thank you so much, Councilor Zimmerman, for putting this on the docket.

465
00:43:29.213 --> 00:43:31.663
<v Dan Ryan>This amendment is really thoughtful.

466
00:43:32.193 --> 00:43:50.791
<v Dan Ryan>It doesn't look like it has the support, but I think what you did is you listened to the testimony and you came up with the solution for those who were brave enough to come into the council room and speak on the importance of this for their business.

467
00:43:51.612 --> 00:44:02.827
<v Dan Ryan>At a time where our economy is suffering like I've never seen it before, and when we have a few restaurants that really pleaded with us to please prevent this ban.

468
00:44:03.420 --> 00:44:09.317
<v Dan Ryan>And I've heard from numerous restaurants that don't serve foie gras that also wanted us to not pass this ban.

469
00:44:10.471 --> 00:44:26.626
<v Dan Ryan>I just really think it's very thoughtful that we have an amendment today that would have allowed those loyal businesses that are some of, as Councilor Clark said, some of the most, the strongest part of our local economy is our is our gourmet restaurants and cuisine.

470
00:44:26.882 --> 00:44:29.865
<v Dan Ryan>Anytime anyone visits, that's one of the first things they go to.

471
00:44:30.443 --> 00:44:33.041
<v Dan Ryan>So I just really, again, thank you for this thoughtful amendment.

472
00:44:33.088 --> 00:44:35.318
<v Dan Ryan>I'm really proud to vote aye on it.

473
00:44:36.280 --> 00:44:37.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

474
00:44:37.402 --> 00:44:38.012
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

475
00:44:38.990 --> 00:44:40.449
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

476
00:44:40.514 --> 00:44:43.865
<v Sameer Kanal>First, let me say I think I take the amendment in good faith.

477
00:44:43.961 --> 00:44:45.228
<v Sameer Kanal>I wish I'd known there was one coming.

478
00:44:45.565 --> 00:44:48.724
<v Sameer Kanal>I would've loved to be aware of that.

479
00:44:48.789 --> 00:44:55.297
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think I really appreciated the comments about the hookah ban.

480
00:44:57.353 --> 00:45:00.978
<v Sameer Kanal>Personally, I had not known a lot of the history about that.

481
00:45:01.623 --> 00:45:05.563
<v Sameer Kanal>I left town for a few years, came back, and it occurred in between.

482
00:45:05.757 --> 00:45:14.262
<v Sameer Kanal>And some of my memories as a young person coming into town before I was— before I left was going to some of the hookah lounges.

483
00:45:14.327 --> 00:45:15.521
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I appreciate that.

484
00:45:15.601 --> 00:45:18.923
<v Sameer Kanal>And obviously the cultural context the context is not lost on me, given my background.

485
00:45:19.085 --> 00:45:31.842
<v Sameer Kanal>I think what I'm struggling with is the applicability to something that's not— we're not hearing a cultural protections argument on foie gras at this moment.

486
00:45:32.134 --> 00:45:35.485
<v Sameer Kanal>And if there is one that we're going to entertain, then let's have that conversation.

487
00:45:36.822 --> 00:45:38.583
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do appreciate that comment.

488
00:45:38.681 --> 00:45:42.768
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there are conversations there that may be worth having in a different context with the county.

489
00:45:45.726 --> 00:46:03.731
<v Sameer Kanal>I guess had we been having a conversation around a two-tiered system, because that's essentially what this would be creating, is saying any new restaurant that wishes to serve foie gras or any existing restaurant that doesn't currently serve it that wishes to start serving it would exist in one plane of one legal category.

490
00:46:04.036 --> 00:46:05.096
<v Sameer Kanal>It would be unable to do so.

491
00:46:05.657 --> 00:46:11.534
<v Sameer Kanal>And then anyone who has already been serving it as of June 1st would be able to continue using it.

492
00:46:11.599 --> 00:46:17.152
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that there are always gonna be 2-tier questions like what Councilor Koyama Lane said.

493
00:46:17.442 --> 00:46:21.648
<v Sameer Kanal>But if the idea was there's 2 tiers and it takes effect at a different time, that'd be one thing.

494
00:46:21.711 --> 00:46:31.021
<v Sameer Kanal>But if it just never takes effect, that's something that I've got concerns about because it essentially would mean that there is no practical change from adopting this ordinance.

495
00:46:31.487 --> 00:46:32.755
<v Sameer Kanal>That's where I'm at at the moment.

496
00:46:33.333 --> 00:46:39.929
<v Sameer Kanal>But I am trying to engage with this because I appreciate the attempt to get to a place where it might get someone to a yes.

497
00:46:40.025 --> 00:46:40.315
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

498
00:46:41.048 --> 00:46:42.099
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that.

499
00:46:42.422 --> 00:46:43.860
<v Sameer Kanal>I just, I'm not seeing those 2 things.

500
00:46:43.989 --> 00:46:46.184
<v Sameer Kanal>And so at this moment, I'm a no as a result of that.

501
00:46:46.393 --> 00:46:46.748
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks.

502
00:46:47.440 --> 00:46:48.293
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knell.

503
00:46:49.050 --> 00:46:49.744
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

504
00:46:51.804 --> 00:46:52.335
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

505
00:46:52.528 --> 00:47:03.771
<v Eric Zimmerman>So to the not knowing it was coming, the point being is that quite literally today, racking my brain last night and trying to find a way in language.

506
00:47:04.721 --> 00:47:14.199
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in our engagement with the City Attorney's Office, we used some language that and we considered some of the points as it— as we think about our smoking bans, right?

507
00:47:14.454 --> 00:47:21.056
<v Eric Zimmerman>We all know that smoking is not legal in restaurants anymore or clubs the way it was maybe when some folks on this dais were younger.

508
00:47:21.585 --> 00:47:29.021
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, but there are still places in which you can apparently light up a cigar in our community inside, indoors.

509
00:47:29.117 --> 00:47:30.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>They were grandfathered in.

510
00:47:30.320 --> 00:47:32.626
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that was kind of where the model kind of came from.

511
00:47:33.364 --> 00:47:42.557
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and but that that, that just— it was, uh, some trying to think through like what would implementation look like and applicability.

512
00:47:42.606 --> 00:47:43.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I appreciate that.

513
00:47:44.130 --> 00:47:45.864
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to offer just one last piece.

514
00:47:46.297 --> 00:47:47.597
<v Eric Zimmerman>I do think there's a cultural aspect.

515
00:47:47.644 --> 00:47:51.833
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just don't think it's a cultural aspect that's highly represented in Portland and is speaking out.

516
00:47:52.057 --> 00:47:55.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't know that that's even my main concern.

517
00:47:55.427 --> 00:47:59.103
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've just used it as an example of sometimes we have unintended consequences.

518
00:47:59.840 --> 00:48:07.804
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I would say this, if this were to pass, I would support us moving this to an emergency, and I would be one of the 9.

519
00:48:09.760 --> 00:48:19.277
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, and I think that there is a path there that should be— I hope is considered, um, not friendly in the way we say friendly amendments, but I, I think that is a very workable piece.

520
00:48:19.568 --> 00:48:24.715
<v Eric Zimmerman>And to the questions that Councilor Koyama Lane raises, I think those are also quite pertinent.

521
00:48:24.844 --> 00:48:31.353
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't know that they need to be in an ordinance to answer those applicability about sale or ownership changes, etc.

522
00:48:31.416 --> 00:48:43.628
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I think that we take a look at what is the practice in other places where grandfathering has occurred, and does that go with the license of the business, or does it go with the ownership on the, on the, you know, at the Secretary of State's?

523
00:48:43.771 --> 00:48:44.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't know that answer yet.

524
00:48:44.831 --> 00:48:49.902
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think it has to be in ordinance to decide that, but I think those are really valid, valid points.

525
00:48:49.949 --> 00:48:56.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if this were to pass, I would support an emergency, and I'd be the 9th vote to, to help it get through as your current timeline is.

526
00:48:56.527 --> 00:48:57.362
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for the consideration.

527
00:48:57.411 --> 00:48:57.507
<v Zachary Lindahl>Thank you.

528
00:48:57.824 --> 00:48:59.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

529
00:48:59.208 --> 00:48:59.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

530
00:49:01.164 --> 00:49:02.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

531
00:49:04.260 --> 00:49:12.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I've been interested in the debate between my colleagues today, and, you know, I've actually spent a lot of time meeting with people about this issue broadly.

532
00:49:12.974 --> 00:49:49.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I came in very much undecided, and I think that may be not unique but somewhat rare on this issue across this and I've been really impressed by the commitment to making progress on animal welfare concerns, the commitment to talking about what a clear enforceable policy would look like, the commitment to balancing free choice and different choices, and an openness to having a community with different choices with our collective moral conscious.

533
00:49:49.619 --> 00:50:00.967
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I actually find this amendment very interesting because we know that there are a number of restaurants in our community that periodically serve foie gras on their menu.

534
00:50:01.014 --> 00:50:03.489
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We've heard about seasonal choices and things like that.

535
00:50:04.132 --> 00:50:14.985
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We also have heard that we have at least one restaurant in our community where foie gras has become kind of the, the center of what a lot of people go there for.

536
00:50:15.257 --> 00:50:23.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think this allows us to differentiate between those 2 things.

537
00:50:24.192 --> 00:50:33.014
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it will eventually phase out foie gras in our city over time because most restaurants don't exist forever.

538
00:50:35.961 --> 00:50:52.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it ensures that we don't continue down the path of an action that a number of folks in our community have raised animal welfare concerns about while also having that conversation about that balance there.

539
00:50:52.264 --> 00:51:04.465
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I, I'm very interested in this, and if the concern that my colleagues have is the policy direction in general, then perhaps there is not a path.

540
00:51:04.528 --> 00:51:13.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I wanted to I put myself in the queue just to clarify for folks at home.

541
00:51:13.552 --> 00:51:20.532
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I certainly would be interested in being one of 9 to make sure that we don't delay in decision-making if this were adopted.

542
00:51:21.880 --> 00:51:22.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

543
00:51:22.735 --> 00:51:23.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

544
00:51:26.059 --> 00:51:30.306
<v Jamie Dunphy>I put myself in the queue just to clarify for folks at home, tobacco is bad.

545
00:51:30.630 --> 00:51:36.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>As the former lobbyist for the American Cancer Society, 1 hour of hookah is the equivalent of over 100 cigarettes.

546
00:51:38.422 --> 00:51:43.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>And tobacco is a North American plant that was brought to the Middle East as a part of colonialism.

547
00:51:45.269 --> 00:51:50.402
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue for the comment— it's absolutely true.

548
00:51:50.547 --> 00:51:52.717
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please move to a vote on Zimmerman 1?

549
00:51:54.070 --> 00:51:58.628
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is Zimmerman 1, moved by Councilor Zimmerman, seconded by Councilor Ryan.

550
00:51:58.789 --> 00:51:58.806
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

551
00:51:59.047 --> 00:52:00.172
<v Rebecca Dobert>No.

552
00:52:00.670 --> 00:52:01.411
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Loretta Smith?

553
00:52:01.909 --> 00:52:02.327
<v Loretta Smith>No.

554
00:52:02.697 --> 00:52:02.954
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, Kanelle?

555
00:52:03.083 --> 00:52:03.405
<v Eric Engstrom>No.

556
00:52:05.094 --> 00:52:05.623
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

557
00:52:06.041 --> 00:52:06.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

558
00:52:06.847 --> 00:52:07.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

559
00:52:07.739 --> 00:52:07.786
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

560
00:52:08.014 --> 00:52:09.099
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

561
00:52:09.617 --> 00:52:09.860
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

562
00:52:11.027 --> 00:52:13.619
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

563
00:52:14.478 --> 00:52:14.608
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

564
00:52:14.690 --> 00:52:14.882
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

565
00:52:15.206 --> 00:52:15.431
<v Steve Novick>Nay.

566
00:52:16.981 --> 00:52:17.447
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

567
00:52:17.771 --> 00:52:17.820
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

568
00:52:18.351 --> 00:52:18.965
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

569
00:52:19.643 --> 00:52:19.788
<v Mitch Green>No.

570
00:52:20.755 --> 00:52:21.224
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

571
00:52:21.418 --> 00:52:21.449
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

572
00:52:22.289 --> 00:52:22.675
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

573
00:52:23.675 --> 00:52:23.902
<v Candace Avalos>No.

574
00:52:25.340 --> 00:52:25.548
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

575
00:52:25.757 --> 00:52:25.806
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

576
00:52:26.577 --> 00:52:27.028
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

577
00:52:27.367 --> 00:52:27.447
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

578
00:52:28.653 --> 00:52:32.306
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the amendment fails with 5 aye, 7 nay votes.

579
00:52:33.420 --> 00:52:34.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, to the underlying.

580
00:52:35.396 --> 00:52:36.034
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Avalos.

581
00:52:37.782 --> 00:52:38.371
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you.

582
00:52:39.775 --> 00:52:41.505
<v Candace Avalos>Um, yeah, colleagues, I won't bury the lead.

583
00:52:41.813 --> 00:52:42.606
<v Candace Avalos>I support this ordinance.

584
00:52:42.847 --> 00:52:52.876
<v Candace Avalos>And to be honest, I think that one of the reasons this conversation has become so strange to me is that we've spent weeks debating something that, yeah, in the grand scheme of Portland challenges is actually pretty small.

585
00:52:53.260 --> 00:52:58.536
<v Candace Avalos>We do have major conversations ahead of us about housing and homelessness and public safety and transportation and affordability.

586
00:52:59.050 --> 00:53:02.016
<v Candace Avalos>This isn't one of those conversations, and that's also okay.

587
00:53:02.577 --> 00:53:07.356
<v Candace Avalos>Not every policy that comes before council needs to be a grand referendum on the future of the city.

588
00:53:07.773 --> 00:53:14.286
<v Candace Avalos>Sometimes community members come to us and they say, we've identified a problem, we think there's a reasonable solution, and we'd like you to act.

589
00:53:14.751 --> 00:53:16.739
<v Candace Avalos>And sometimes the answer is simply, that seems reasonable.

590
00:53:17.235 --> 00:53:18.438
<v Candace Avalos>And that is part of governing too.

591
00:53:19.255 --> 00:53:30.679
<v Candace Avalos>We pass major policies, we pass technical policies, we pass niche policies, we pass policies that matter deeply to communities that may be small in number but care enough to organize, testify, and participate in democracy.

592
00:53:30.936 --> 00:53:31.833
<v Candace Avalos>That is what happened here.

593
00:53:32.378 --> 00:53:34.686
<v Candace Avalos>Do I think foie gras is the most important issue facing District 1?

594
00:53:34.782 --> 00:53:35.487
<v Candace Avalos>Absolutely not.

595
00:53:35.920 --> 00:53:40.806
<v Candace Avalos>My constituents are talking to me about rent and groceries and child care and transportation and basic affordability.

596
00:53:41.206 --> 00:53:51.800
<v Candace Avalos>But I also don't think that every item that comes before council to be measured against the single biggest crisis facing the city, because if that were the standard, then we would never do anything except talk about one issue all day, every day.

597
00:53:52.364 --> 00:54:02.242
<v Candace Avalos>The reality is that local government does a lot of things at once, and I think we sometimes contribute to public frustration when we turn relatively straightforward decisions into political theater.

598
00:54:02.708 --> 00:54:16.320
<v Candace Avalos>Portlanders want us to focus on the big issues, I agree, but they also want us to be capable of making routine decisions, responding to community concerns, So for me, this falls into that category.

599
00:54:16.320 --> 00:54:21.960
<v Candace Avalos>So while animal welfare is not necessarily my primary policy passion, I respect the advocates who brought this forward.

600
00:54:22.320 --> 00:54:27.929
<v Candace Avalos>I understand the values argument that they're making, and I think that this is a reasonable policy, and so I plan on supporting it.

601
00:54:28.400 --> 00:54:29.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

602
00:54:29.179 --> 00:54:30.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

603
00:54:30.619 --> 00:54:32.699
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

604
00:54:32.699 --> 00:54:34.500
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you, Council President.

605
00:54:34.500 --> 00:54:37.079
<v Mitch Green>Before we get too much further into the discussion, I just want to clarify that I'm not opposed to the ordinance.

606
00:54:37.126 --> 00:54:45.210
<v Mitch Green>I just want to clarify up front because I think the county has handled some phone calls around this and a bit of a panic of like, oh my God, are we on the hook for enforcement?

607
00:54:45.275 --> 00:54:52.641
<v Mitch Green>I just want to make it crystal clear that at no— at this point, there has not been a conversation with the county about county handling the implementation.

608
00:54:53.077 --> 00:55:01.751
<v Mitch Green>So if this were to pass, the City of Portland may entertain an IGA or a conversation with the county on how to actually handle the enforcement side of this.

609
00:55:01.880 --> 00:55:04.117
<v Mitch Green>But that hasn't happened yet.

610
00:55:04.353 --> 00:55:04.536
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

611
00:55:05.072 --> 00:55:12.565
<v Mitch Green>This is very much a sort of, um, um, kind of a sort of complaint-driven system and a presumption system.

612
00:55:12.614 --> 00:55:19.000
<v Mitch Green>So there's not, there's not an enforcement arm that's like center, like forefronted in here, and it's certainly not the county.

613
00:55:19.047 --> 00:55:25.001
<v Mitch Green>So if there's folks from the county watching this, rest assured that we're not committing you to anything at this point.

614
00:55:25.931 --> 00:55:26.172
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

615
00:55:27.038 --> 00:55:27.711
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

616
00:55:28.001 --> 00:55:28.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

617
00:55:29.621 --> 00:55:30.985
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

618
00:55:31.146 --> 00:55:38.376
<v Steve Novick>Following up a bit on what Councilor Avalos was saying, We have all heard from a number of people saying, I can't believe that this is the City Council's priority.

619
00:55:39.166 --> 00:55:41.409
<v Steve Novick>And this was not one of my high priorities.

620
00:55:42.297 --> 00:55:43.898
<v Steve Novick>I didn't propose bringing this to this body.

621
00:55:44.400 --> 00:55:58.889
<v Steve Novick>My priorities are reducing gun violence and making sure that the students at McDaniel High School don't have to walk through a gauntlet of sex trafficking and making sure that we're doing our part to address climate change and using the resources that we have in the Portland Clean Energy Fund to do that in the most effective and cost-effective way.

622
00:55:59.141 --> 00:56:00.007
<v Steve Novick>Effective way possible.

623
00:56:00.664 --> 00:56:05.920
<v Steve Novick>But when we have a vote in this body, we don't get to vote high priority or low priority.

624
00:56:06.431 --> 00:56:07.554
<v Steve Novick>We vote yes or no.

625
00:56:08.338 --> 00:56:28.298
<v Steve Novick>And again, I'm following the lead of the overwhelming majority of city councilors in New York City, the epicenter of fine dining in America, and Pittsburgh, not known as a wacky liberal city, in saying that I just cannot say that I feel like it's okay to force-feed an animal to produce an expensive delicacy.

626
00:56:28.882 --> 00:56:30.519
<v Steve Novick>And I know that reasonable people can disagree.

627
00:56:30.762 --> 00:56:31.606
<v Steve Novick>It's an emotional issue.

628
00:56:31.817 --> 00:56:34.005
<v Steve Novick>So by definition, reasonable people can disagree.

629
00:56:35.471 --> 00:56:36.235
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

630
00:56:36.706 --> 00:56:37.454
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

631
00:56:38.251 --> 00:56:39.244
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor President.

632
00:56:40.489 --> 00:56:43.952
<v Olivia Clark>Back to the unintended consequences.

633
00:56:44.371 --> 00:56:59.188
<v Olivia Clark>I just maybe have a question for the carrier of this proposed ordinance about what you think the estimated cost in time and money will be for the city administration to prosecute a violation, or whether it's the city or the county.

634
00:56:59.347 --> 00:57:00.679
<v Olivia Clark>Do you have any sense for that?

635
00:57:01.177 --> 00:57:04.481
<v Olivia Clark>Can you clue us into what it might cost as an unintended consequence?

636
00:57:04.722 --> 00:57:13.224
<v Mitch Green>We do have Director Engstrom in the office or in the chambers who might be able to answer that, because our office has worked with them on the cost side of this and the implementation piece.

637
00:57:13.304 --> 00:57:16.561
<v Mitch Green>So I'd be curious to see if that's something he wants to entertain.

638
00:57:17.715 --> 00:57:19.496
<v Mitch Green>Not to put you on the spot, Director, but you're on the spot.

639
00:57:19.545 --> 00:57:19.721
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

640
00:57:19.961 --> 00:57:22.106
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

641
00:57:22.219 --> 00:57:23.155
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Director Engstrom.

642
00:57:25.106 --> 00:57:25.380
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

643
00:57:25.443 --> 00:57:26.686
<v Eric Engstrom>For the record, Eric Engstrom.

644
00:57:26.733 --> 00:57:28.878
<v Eric Engstrom>I'm the director of the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

645
00:57:30.418 --> 00:57:37.192
<v Eric Engstrom>Um, the councilor has spoken with our office about what this might look like if the city were administering it.

646
00:57:37.929 --> 00:57:42.155
<v Eric Engstrom>We've talked about what the logical places would be for administration to occur.

647
00:57:42.333 --> 00:57:48.280
<v Eric Engstrom>There's been some discussion that the county may play a role, but no commitments, and that would be a discussion that we would have in the future if it passes.

648
00:57:50.420 --> 00:58:05.862
<v Eric Engstrom>Um, BPS has been considered for that role in part because we have folks through our sustainability program as well as our waste program who are regularly engaging with restaurants, and in our case through composting technical assistance.

649
00:58:05.943 --> 00:58:06.942
<v Eric Engstrom>But, but we're there.

650
00:58:07.538 --> 00:58:10.041
<v Eric Engstrom>The county is obviously there from a health department perspective.

651
00:58:10.849 --> 00:58:16.969
<v Eric Engstrom>Um, and we've also taken on enforcement of a number of other things recently, such as the leaf blower ban.

652
00:58:17.067 --> 00:58:17.228
<v Eric Engstrom>Yes.

653
00:58:18.969 --> 00:58:19.648
<v Eric Engstrom>Things like that.

654
00:58:21.862 --> 00:58:27.054
<v Eric Engstrom>As you've pointed out, this is not a situation where there's a large number of players out there in the world.

655
00:58:27.199 --> 00:58:30.833
<v Eric Engstrom>There's a relatively small number of entities that serve this.

656
00:58:31.695 --> 00:58:34.585
<v Eric Engstrom>So we're not seeing it as a major endeavor.

657
00:58:35.405 --> 00:58:46.518
<v Eric Engstrom>There would likely be some ramp-up cost in year 1 to potentially develop some administrative rules, do an education campaign for people to understand that the rules exist.

658
00:58:48.108 --> 00:58:56.152
<v Eric Engstrom>That could involve a person in our office having to work on this part-time for the first 6 months of its implementation.

659
00:58:57.619 --> 00:59:04.733
<v Eric Engstrom>Ongoing, again, because there's not too many restaurants, we don't anticipate there'd be, you know, very many complaints on this.

660
00:59:07.079 --> 00:59:11.152
<v Eric Engstrom>That would not likely be consequential to a budgeting perspective.

661
00:59:11.217 --> 00:59:12.155
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

662
00:59:13.481 --> 00:59:19.663
<v Eric Engstrom>That said, you know, having this role, minor role, in a number of different things does add up.

663
00:59:19.744 --> 00:59:24.648
<v Eric Engstrom>So ideally you would consider the, the financial consequences when you add a program like that to a bureau.

664
00:59:25.456 --> 00:59:44.123
<v Eric Engstrom>Um, it's, it's definitely not, um, hundreds of thousands of dollars a year, and it's, it's probably not $100 a year either, but, um, there is a small cost and it would thank you.

665
00:59:44.865 --> 00:59:47.338
<v Olivia Clark>Just one other question along the same lines.

666
00:59:47.916 --> 01:00:01.987
<v Olivia Clark>I understand that farmers have actually challenged these ordinances in other states, in New York, in California, where they actually overturned it for a period of time, and in Chicago.

667
01:00:02.471 --> 01:00:06.543
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm wondering what the unintended consequence might be or the estimated cost of a legal defense.

668
01:00:06.594 --> 01:00:07.398
<v Olivia Clark>Well, I think that's a very good question.

669
01:00:12.460 --> 01:00:15.760
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, I don't know that I can give you that number.

670
01:00:15.880 --> 01:00:26.010
<v Mitch Green>I mean, I suppose that's a risk that we always take before this body when we make policy that might invite someone who doesn't like our policy to try to sue us and challenge us.

671
01:00:26.099 --> 01:00:27.820
<v Mitch Green>We take those risks all the time.

672
01:00:27.820 --> 01:00:34.079
<v Mitch Green>And we do have a legal risk fund to hedge against that sort of a thing.

673
01:00:34.079 --> 01:00:37.539
<v Mitch Green>And so I don't think that there's a direct cost estimate that one can make.

674
01:00:37.539 --> 01:00:37.739
<v Eric Engstrom>I'll just note that we have a legal risk fund.

675
01:00:37.739 --> 01:00:37.780
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

676
01:00:40.278 --> 01:00:48.056
<v Mitch Green>I personally am comfortable taking that risk, and I don't know if there's much more I can offer you than that.

677
01:00:48.295 --> 01:00:49.130
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that.

678
01:00:49.257 --> 01:00:51.246
<v Olivia Clark>And maybe that's a fund we should have looked at raiding.

679
01:00:51.438 --> 01:00:53.170
<v Olivia Clark>I didn't think about that fund.

680
01:00:54.550 --> 01:00:57.724
<v Mitch Green>I think some other councilors have in prior discussions.

681
01:00:57.773 --> 01:00:57.900
<v Adrienne Delgado>Yes.

682
01:00:59.280 --> 01:01:03.224
<v Olivia Clark>It does concern me, and I'm really curious to know what happened in Chicago.

683
01:01:03.400 --> 01:01:21.179
<v Mitch Green>Maybe that's irrelevant to the vote today, but Chicago did and, you know, if you want to take the legal conversation further, we do have Rob from the City Attorney's Office who's advised on this issue online available to answer that question.

684
01:01:21.579 --> 01:01:24.050
<v Mitch Green>So you can ask the question to Rob about the legal risk.

685
01:01:25.159 --> 01:01:29.000
<v Mitch Green>He'd be happy to answer your questions, I think.

686
01:01:31.530 --> 01:01:34.579
<v Robert Taylor>I'm looking at what happened in Chicago, and you're correct, it was passed.

687
01:01:34.722 --> 01:01:37.309
<v Robert Taylor>And then another city council repealed it.

688
01:01:37.389 --> 01:01:39.958
<v Robert Taylor>So it wasn't due to a legal challenge.

689
01:01:40.746 --> 01:01:45.855
<v Robert Taylor>As far as what happened in New York City, initially the ban was struck down.

690
01:01:46.063 --> 01:01:56.443
<v Robert Taylor>New York has an Agricultural and Markets Act law that regulates agricultural practices throughout the state.

691
01:01:56.827 --> 01:01:59.751
<v Robert Taylor>So initially that ban was struck down.

692
01:01:59.929 --> 01:02:06.858
<v Robert Taylor>It was on appeal and actually In, uh, I believe it was at the end of March of this year that was reversed.

693
01:02:07.036 --> 01:02:09.221
<v Robert Taylor>So it is now banned in New York.

694
01:02:09.335 --> 01:02:14.485
<v Robert Taylor>It hasn't been implemented, but that, that, um, lower court decision was reversed.

695
01:02:15.358 --> 01:02:18.085
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, when I started working on this in the fall, that wasn't the case.

696
01:02:18.134 --> 01:02:20.297
<v Robert Taylor>I mean, this, this just changed a couple months ago.

697
01:02:20.603 --> 01:02:24.009
<v Robert Taylor>Uh, so that's what happened with New York and Chicago.

698
01:02:24.331 --> 01:02:26.478
<v Robert Taylor>I forget if you asked another jurisdiction.

699
01:02:27.467 --> 01:02:32.795
<v Robert Taylor>Um, but I will say I've spent time looking at California, the definitions.

700
01:02:32.922 --> 01:02:39.646
<v Robert Taylor>The, the act is modeled after California's ban, which had 12 years of litigation that went up to the 9th Circuit.

701
01:02:40.385 --> 01:02:45.376
<v Robert Taylor>Initially, this ordinance had some what I viewed to be some legal defects.

702
01:02:46.179 --> 01:02:50.335
<v Robert Taylor>So I recommended we go with what was in the 9th Circuit since we are in the 9th Circuit.

703
01:02:50.431 --> 01:02:53.465
<v Robert Taylor>So I think it should be legally defensible.

704
01:02:53.512 --> 01:02:53.625
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

705
01:02:54.266 --> 01:03:08.800
<v Robert Taylor>As far as the amendment that failed today, that was a, I thought, a reasonable limitation because we had, uh, I had some concerns on it's a 180-day implementation or effective date period.

706
01:03:08.849 --> 01:03:13.657
<v Robert Taylor>So there was a concern that folks might try to race to get foie gras on the menu.

707
01:03:14.217 --> 01:03:18.657
<v Robert Taylor>I think what was drafted addressed that by having it dated June 1st.

708
01:03:18.721 --> 01:03:18.864
<v Robert Taylor>Thank you.

709
01:03:19.425 --> 01:03:22.251
<v Robert Taylor>So that could have remedied that, but that did not pass.

710
01:03:22.652 --> 01:03:25.014
<v Robert Taylor>If you've got more questions, I'm happy to answer them.

711
01:03:25.849 --> 01:03:26.427
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Rob.

712
01:03:26.666 --> 01:03:32.045
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that information that in Chicago it was actually another council that overturned it.

713
01:03:32.447 --> 01:03:35.980
<v Olivia Clark>I didn't realize it had been in the courts for 11 years in California.

714
01:03:36.204 --> 01:03:39.206
<v Olivia Clark>I wouldn't be shocked if that happened here, another attempt.

715
01:03:39.271 --> 01:03:40.202
<v Olivia Clark>But thank you so much.

716
01:03:41.664 --> 01:03:43.445
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

717
01:03:43.525 --> 01:03:44.056
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

718
01:03:46.168 --> 01:03:46.833
<v Loretta Smith>It was a legacy.

719
01:03:47.157 --> 01:03:47.318
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

720
01:03:48.681 --> 01:03:49.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

721
01:03:50.237 --> 01:03:51.518
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

722
01:03:53.139 --> 01:03:59.266
<v Dan Ryan>From a personal values perspective, some of my colleagues may feel very strongly about this issue, and I understand that.

723
01:04:00.376 --> 01:04:10.568
<v Dan Ryan>Yet my filter is to focus on making decisions about our infrastructure, our public spaces, services we deliver, and I know the majority of Portlanders want us to improve on our primary purpose.

724
01:04:11.983 --> 01:04:17.052
<v Dan Ryan>It's really hard for me to understand why we're legislating on a handful of local restaurants' menu choices.

725
01:04:18.382 --> 01:04:20.275
<v Dan Ryan>It's no surprise to anyone who's been tracking this.

726
01:04:20.708 --> 01:04:25.791
<v Dan Ryan>I see all of the lobbyists who are here, the community's here, the grassroots support.

727
01:04:26.561 --> 01:04:34.034
<v Dan Ryan>We saw you last year in the Arts and Economy Committee, and we did vote this legislation down, as you know, by a 3-2 vote.

728
01:04:34.820 --> 01:04:37.048
<v Dan Ryan>And so I will remain consistent with my vote against this legislation.

729
01:04:37.242 --> 01:04:44.242
<v Dan Ryan>This ban will further tarnish our economic development reputation at a time we can least afford it.

730
01:04:47.396 --> 01:04:48.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

731
01:04:48.847 --> 01:04:49.413
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

732
01:04:50.284 --> 01:04:51.170
<v Steve Novick>Uh, thank you, Mr. President.

733
01:04:51.251 --> 01:04:58.349
<v Steve Novick>Just following up on what Rob just said, um, there is Ninth Circuit precedent upholding the California ban, and we are in the Ninth Circuit.

734
01:04:58.414 --> 01:05:02.684
<v Steve Novick>So I think that for somebody to challenge this would be a fool's errand.

735
01:05:03.358 --> 01:05:10.005
<v Steve Novick>And as an aside, I'd also mention that Kamala Harris was quite proud of her defense of California's foie gras ban as Attorney General.

736
01:05:10.518 --> 01:05:14.052
<v Steve Novick>And Kamala Harris is about as mainstream— no offense— about as mainstream a figure as you can get.

737
01:05:14.998 --> 01:05:16.684
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

738
01:05:17.021 --> 01:05:17.713
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

739
01:05:19.126 --> 01:05:29.594
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also wanted to highlight that at least 27 countries have limited the production, sale, or import of foie gras, and King Charles has banned it from all royal residences.

740
01:05:31.353 --> 01:05:36.072
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Portland has a really vibrant food scene and is one of the coolest places to eat.

741
01:05:36.411 --> 01:05:41.146
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I really do believe in our ability to continue having incredible food scene without foie gras.

742
01:05:42.289 --> 01:05:42.626
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

743
01:05:42.949 --> 01:05:43.963
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

744
01:05:44.318 --> 01:05:44.961
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

745
01:05:46.572 --> 01:05:46.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

746
01:05:47.119 --> 01:05:54.882
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I find a couple of the arguments here really good faith and a couple that are really challenging to associate with.

747
01:05:55.268 --> 01:05:59.313
<v Sameer Kanal>We, we cannot legislate from a position of fear that one person might file a lawsuit.

748
01:05:59.795 --> 01:06:13.346
<v Sameer Kanal>We've had this debate on at least 10 things over the last year and a half where there's the idea of empowering a singular person who might have enough money to hire a lawyer to stop any legislation before we even adopt it.

749
01:06:13.989 --> 01:06:22.240
<v Sameer Kanal>It becomes a valid concept that can be used to not pass in the first place, and I find that to be absurd, whether it's on this or on any other ordinance.

750
01:06:22.898 --> 01:06:42.536
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so that, that argument does not have weight because we cannot— not only is it one person should not be able to prevent us from having a legitimate policy conversation, but also that is not actually a fairly distributed set of power because not everybody has the money to hire a lawyer to sue the city.

751
01:06:43.650 --> 01:06:49.949
<v Sameer Kanal>And I imagine that most of the people— the other argument I want to point out is that most of the people out here I imagine are not paid to advocate for this.

752
01:06:50.956 --> 01:06:58.387
<v Sameer Kanal>And you may have to register as a lobbyist because the city requires, if you do a certain amount of time advocating, that you have to register as a lobbyist.

753
01:06:58.483 --> 01:07:01.663
<v Sameer Kanal>But the idea that people are paid to be here is not always the case.

754
01:07:03.068 --> 01:07:12.516
<v Sameer Kanal>I haven't committed to this either way in public, so it's been— I've seen 2 articles now saying so-and-so hasn't said where they're at on it, but I've been supportive of it for a long time.

755
01:07:13.172 --> 01:07:18.474
<v Sameer Kanal>I support it because I think it's not about what we're talking— only about what we're putting inside of us.

756
01:07:18.539 --> 01:07:19.043
<v Dan Ryan>It's about how it got in there.

757
01:07:19.092 --> 01:07:19.237
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

758
01:07:20.099 --> 01:07:26.260
<v Sameer Kanal>And that production issue is the problem.

759
01:07:26.260 --> 01:07:40.780
<v Sameer Kanal>We often limit— we use, when we talk about gas taxes, we use the argument not only about its consumption here being a problem, but also its production and how harmful that is to justify why we do gas taxes.

760
01:07:40.780 --> 01:07:48.199
<v Sameer Kanal>We do this with many other policy choices we make, that it's not only about what happens in front of us, but how the thing got to be in the first place.

761
01:07:48.199 --> 01:07:48.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's a good point.

762
01:07:48.492 --> 01:07:49.681
<v Sameer Kanal>To us in the first place.

763
01:07:49.777 --> 01:07:53.726
<v Sameer Kanal>And, and what we're talking about is an abusive treatment.

764
01:07:54.112 --> 01:08:04.405
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I'm proud to support legislation to address animal welfare at the production level, even though it's not here, through responsible commerce practices and our community's commitment to compassion and ethical treatment of animals.

765
01:08:04.934 --> 01:08:09.173
<v Sameer Kanal>As someone who's not vegan myself, I'm also especially proud that Portland has this scene.

766
01:08:09.911 --> 01:08:13.556
<v Sameer Kanal>And in District 2, we have a vibrant community-centered vegan food culture.

767
01:08:13.813 --> 01:08:28.185
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'll take the opportunity to shout out Vegan Flipside Market on June 27th at the Arbor Beer Lodge, and shout out to Peter Schufter at the Arbor Beer Lodge for working with my office to ensure that the alley was graveled by PBOT to ensure a good experience for market event attendees.

768
01:08:28.842 --> 01:08:29.708
<v Sameer Kanal>We have the Veganizer Market.

769
01:08:29.756 --> 01:08:36.557
<v Sameer Kanal>We have a lot of different things going on, and I think when we talk about what we might lose, we should also have a conversation on what we're helping grow.

770
01:08:37.439 --> 01:08:48.354
<v Sameer Kanal>Because we have— I have cousins who are vegans who live in Southern California, and they talk about how easy it is when they come up here to find the options that they want.

771
01:08:49.381 --> 01:08:55.068
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's really important to me as someone who obviously wants my cousins, who I am very close to, to come visit.

772
01:08:55.564 --> 01:09:07.641
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's the case for just about everybody who's sitting around the country who may have any sort of dietary restriction, whether it's voluntary or it's health-based, to be able to say, I can come here and get what I want to eat and have that.

773
01:09:07.690 --> 01:09:12.324
<v Sameer Kanal>And part of that is about ensuring that we have a compassionate system in the first place.

774
01:09:12.757 --> 01:09:21.171
<v Sameer Kanal>And the other thing I want to just shout out is, you know, Councilor Green has been responsive to a real community that exists, not just the people in this room.

775
01:09:21.876 --> 01:09:37.072
<v Sameer Kanal>I've heard about it from a lot of folks, and I'm proud to stay on the same side as Councilor Green in supporting those local organizers, the small businesses, and the, of course, the animal rights activists who brought this issue forward for Councilor Green to champion and care Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

776
01:09:37.734 --> 01:09:38.445
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

777
01:09:40.805 --> 01:09:41.484
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, thanks.

778
01:09:43.699 --> 01:09:50.060
<v Eric Zimmerman>While I agree with the— I would have liked to have spent time on other things.

779
01:09:50.157 --> 01:09:52.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think this should have died at committee the way it did die at committee.

780
01:09:53.152 --> 01:09:55.612
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I, I do think it's been irresponsible to bring it forward.

781
01:09:55.676 --> 01:09:58.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>It has come forward, and I agree with Councilor Novick, we do have to take a yes or no.

782
01:10:01.204 --> 01:10:07.162
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I'm also, I'm not really sure what triggered a few members, but I'm apologizing to Councilor Clark.

783
01:10:07.210 --> 01:10:12.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't know why my amendment brought such, I think, very terrible words that were just said to you a few minutes ago.

784
01:10:12.524 --> 01:10:18.032
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that was irresponsible of a few members, and really there was an undertone there.

785
01:10:18.079 --> 01:10:24.599
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not totally sure if I understood it, but like I said, I don't really care about foie gras, but when it comes to—.

786
01:10:24.599 --> 01:10:24.855
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark.

787
01:10:26.171 --> 01:10:27.757
<v Eric Zimmerman>Personal choices and things like that.

788
01:10:27.837 --> 01:10:29.761
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's been— yes, there are limits, right?

789
01:10:29.856 --> 01:10:33.206
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think about safety to others and safety to yourself.

790
01:10:33.382 --> 01:10:37.788
<v Eric Zimmerman>If those 2 things are met, then I think that we have to really question what is the role in government here.

791
01:10:38.445 --> 01:10:48.573
<v Eric Zimmerman>So for me, I won't be supporting this because I don't see this being a thing that is hurting the person who eats it, and I don't see it hurting a person who chooses not to eat it if someone near them chooses to.

792
01:10:49.390 --> 01:10:55.145
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, uh, this feels like a punch down at the minority That I just don't want to be a part of.

793
01:10:55.337 --> 01:11:01.368
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just find it like government will always have this— there will be a voice always that comes up.

794
01:11:01.431 --> 01:11:07.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>How we protect that voice, whether it be 1, 5, or 500, is something that I'm trying to think through on this a lot.

795
01:11:07.606 --> 01:11:19.378
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so for me, this doesn't pass that test, and I don't see a safety concern for the people that we are given a duty to protect.

796
01:11:19.490 --> 01:11:21.657
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I don't know why we would inject ourselves here.

797
01:11:21.720 --> 01:11:25.358
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so So I do believe that this should not pass today.

798
01:11:25.439 --> 01:11:25.925
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

799
01:11:26.475 --> 01:11:27.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

800
01:11:27.688 --> 01:11:28.270
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Green.

801
01:11:29.711 --> 01:11:30.099
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

802
01:11:30.617 --> 01:11:40.140
<v Mitch Green>I thought I'd just place on the record that I believe very deeply that one of our most urgent priorities is economic development in the City of Portland.

803
01:11:40.351 --> 01:11:54.198
<v Mitch Green>And I think this body's focus, my particular focus on liberalizing our housing production methods housing is one of the center points of that economic development strategy.

804
01:11:54.984 --> 01:12:00.725
<v Mitch Green>If we can make it easier to build more housing in this city, then you get more people staying here, and that's the engine of growth.

805
01:12:01.880 --> 01:12:03.515
<v Mitch Green>That has largely been my focus.

806
01:12:04.350 --> 01:12:21.533
<v Mitch Green>I'll just note that I have a lot of faith and confidence in the innovative capacity of our local restaurant scene, which has demonstrated over the decades to respond to conditions, innovate, offer new menus, and really attract that.

807
01:12:21.676 --> 01:12:29.753
<v Mitch Green>And so perhaps I have more confidence in these restaurants than some other folks, but I continue to have that confidence because I've seen it.

808
01:12:30.042 --> 01:12:30.974
<v Mitch Green>I've seen it in action.

809
01:12:31.872 --> 01:12:36.176
<v Mitch Green>And so I don't think that this tarnishes our economic development capabilities at all.

810
01:12:36.930 --> 01:12:38.296
<v Mitch Green>And I look forward to moving to a vote.

811
01:12:38.537 --> 01:12:38.729
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

812
01:12:39.354 --> 01:12:40.014
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

813
01:12:40.623 --> 01:12:41.024
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

814
01:12:41.587 --> 01:12:42.761
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

815
01:12:43.595 --> 01:12:54.345
<v Loretta Smith>Um, while I respect the concerns that have been raised around animal welfare, I do not believe this is the right time for council to move forward with this policy.

816
01:12:55.407 --> 01:13:08.806
<v Loretta Smith>And as I said before, there's already a broader statewide ballot measure being pursued that would ask Oregon voters to weigh in on major restrictions related to animal products, hunting, fishing, and Uh, agricultural practices.

817
01:13:09.546 --> 01:13:18.125
<v Loretta Smith>And before I signal support for local policy in this space, I believe we should let the statewide conversation play out and hear directly from Oregon voters.

818
01:13:18.398 --> 01:13:30.573
<v Loretta Smith>This ordinance may be well-intentioned, and which I believe it is, but I do not believe it is— it is the responsibility for this council or any other council to take steps in this juncture.

819
01:13:31.233 --> 01:13:36.942
<v Loretta Smith>I, I believe that if there's any government, local government, that should be working on this, it should be Multnomah County.

820
01:13:37.850 --> 01:13:39.957
<v Loretta Smith>And for those reasons, I will be voting no.

821
01:13:40.930 --> 01:13:41.286
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

822
01:13:41.350 --> 01:13:42.533
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

823
01:13:48.729 --> 01:13:52.787
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue, Rebecca, can we please move to a roll call vote?

824
01:13:54.846 --> 01:13:56.238
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues online, please turn your cameras on.

825
01:13:58.560 --> 01:14:02.471
<v Rebecca Dobert>Calling the vote on 2026- Councilor Mitchell, 149.

826
01:14:03.212 --> 01:14:03.519
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

827
01:14:04.097 --> 01:14:04.146
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

828
01:14:05.064 --> 01:14:05.530
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

829
01:14:07.983 --> 01:14:08.210
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

830
01:14:09.585 --> 01:14:10.054
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

831
01:14:10.474 --> 01:14:10.636
<v Dan Ryan>No.

832
01:14:11.849 --> 01:14:12.479
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

833
01:14:12.981 --> 01:14:13.029
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

834
01:14:14.260 --> 01:14:14.805
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

835
01:14:17.168 --> 01:14:17.185
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

836
01:14:19.337 --> 01:14:19.771
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

837
01:14:19.980 --> 01:14:20.012
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

838
01:14:20.784 --> 01:14:21.203
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

839
01:14:21.828 --> 01:14:22.006
<v Olivia Clark>No.

840
01:14:23.180 --> 01:14:23.342
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

841
01:14:24.177 --> 01:14:24.260
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

842
01:14:24.783 --> 01:14:25.306
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

843
01:14:25.731 --> 01:14:25.814
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

844
01:14:28.041 --> 01:14:28.185
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

845
01:14:28.298 --> 01:14:28.314
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

846
01:14:28.878 --> 01:14:29.314
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

847
01:14:30.860 --> 01:14:31.101
<v Loretta Smith>No.

848
01:14:31.844 --> 01:14:32.181
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

849
01:14:32.632 --> 01:14:32.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

850
01:14:33.519 --> 01:14:36.845
<v Rebecca Dobert>The ordinance passes with 7 ayes and 5 nays.

851
01:14:41.720 --> 01:14:42.768
<v Jamie Dunphy>I appreciate that.

852
01:14:48.989 --> 01:14:53.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>We do not allow applause in this room right now, but thank you very much for everybody for being here and for all your support.

853
01:14:54.434 --> 01:14:56.293
<v Jamie Dunphy>Rebecca, can we please move to item number 15?

854
01:14:58.796 --> 01:15:05.445
<v Rebecca Dobert>Item 15, adopt and implement the Moderate Income Revolving Loan Program, document number 2026-124.

855
01:15:07.600 --> 01:15:11.155
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

856
01:15:12.891 --> 01:15:23.726
<v Jamie Dunphy>Since our friends in green shirts are exiting and it's a little loud, I'm going to wait just a second before we turn over to Claire Adamsick with Council Operations for a committee staff summary report?

857
01:15:26.220 --> 01:15:26.527
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, we're good.

858
01:15:26.576 --> 01:15:27.353
<v Jamie Dunphy>Claire, go right ahead.

859
01:15:28.664 --> 01:15:30.188
<v Claire Adamsick>Thank you, Council President and councilors.

860
01:15:30.284 --> 01:15:34.318
<v Claire Adamsick>For the record, Claire Adamsick, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Housing and Permitting Committee.

861
01:15:35.420 --> 01:15:45.130
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance before you, document number 2026-124, was heard in the Housing and Permitting Committee on April 7th, where it was referred to full council as amended with a recommendation to pass.

862
01:15:46.206 --> 01:16:17.020
<v Claire Adamsick>The ordinance adopts and implements the City of Portland Moderate Income Revolving Loan Program in accordance with the terms described in Exhibit A, which describe the establishment of a grant program to fund developers for eligible housing projects, defines affordability requirements and other applicable terms, designates Prosper Portland as the administrator of the program and clarifies requirements for program administration and compliance in accordance with state law, directs the city to work with the Multnomah County Tax Assessor to establish a process to exempt from property tax thank you.

863
01:16:17.135 --> 01:16:21.435
<v Claire Adamsick>Eligible housing projects that use a fee-in-lieu option to repay program loans.

864
01:16:23.199 --> 01:16:39.465
<v Claire Adamsick>And the committee approved an amendment to the ordinance that changed the income qualifications for eligible housing projects from 60% to 50% of area median income, or AMI, and also clarified the program will support the development of low-income in addition to middle-income housing projects.

865
01:16:40.060 --> 01:16:45.765
<v Claire Adamsick>The amendment also reduced the minimum number of required housing units for eligible projects thank you.

866
01:16:47.242 --> 01:16:55.126
<v Claire Adamsick>The full impact statement on this item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts, economic and real estate development impacts, and community impacts and community involvement.

867
01:16:55.912 --> 01:17:01.420
<v Claire Adamsick>One person provided testimony at the committee meeting on April 7th, and no one submitted written testimony prior to committee action.

868
01:17:02.175 --> 01:17:14.337
<v Claire Adamsick>General themes of the testimony the committee heard included supporting the city's ability to utilize available state dollars for eligible development projects, Allowing grant access for smaller development projects by reducing the 75-unit minimum.

869
01:17:15.155 --> 01:17:21.904
<v Claire Adamsick>And finally, a suggestion to remove the prioritization of mixed-use development projects and maintain focus on residential unit development.

870
01:17:22.128 --> 01:17:23.443
<v Claire Adamsick>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

871
01:17:23.506 --> 01:17:23.844
<v Claire Adamsick>Thank you.

872
01:17:24.100 --> 01:17:24.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Claire.

873
01:17:25.189 --> 01:17:27.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos, this came out of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

874
01:17:27.595 --> 01:17:28.685
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can I turn it to you?

875
01:17:29.838 --> 01:17:29.966
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right.

876
01:17:30.784 --> 01:17:32.771
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, so this item came to committee in April.

877
01:17:33.029 --> 01:17:40.472
<v Candace Avalos>The ordinance establishes Portland's Moderate Income Revolving Loan Program and enables the city to access state funding created through Senate Bill 1537.

878
01:17:41.131 --> 01:17:48.356
<v Candace Avalos>The program allows the city to receive no-interest loans from the state and provide grants to eligible housing developments that meet affordability requirements.

879
01:17:48.694 --> 01:17:55.132
<v Candace Avalos>The ordinance designates Prosper Portland as the program administrator and establishes the framework necessary for the city to participate in the program.

880
01:17:55.823 --> 01:18:13.210
<v Candace Avalos>At committee, members discussed program oversight and accountability, how the city will evaluate whether the program is achieving its housing and financial goals, We also discussed state requirements related to tax increment financing districts and project eligibility criteria.

881
01:18:13.430 --> 01:18:29.189
<v Candace Avalos>The committee approved an amendment that lowered the affordability threshold from 60% AMI to 50% AMI, as Claire mentioned, also clarified that the program can support low-income as well as middle-income housing, and reduced the minimum project size from 75 units to 20 units to expand access to smaller developments.

882
01:18:29.189 --> 01:18:29.270
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

883
01:18:30.551 --> 01:18:40.448
<v Candace Avalos>Public testimony generally supported the city's ability to leverage available state funding or state housing dollars and expressed support for making the program accessible to a broader range of housing projects.

884
01:18:40.850 --> 01:18:44.804
<v Candace Avalos>After discussion and adoption of the amendment, the committee voted to recommend the ordinance to the full council.

885
01:18:45.061 --> 01:18:45.627
<v Candace Avalos>That is my report.

886
01:18:47.069 --> 01:18:48.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Councilor Avalos.

887
01:18:50.127 --> 01:18:52.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, there are 4 people signed up to testify on this.

888
01:18:53.770 --> 01:19:05.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's a couple folks in the queue, and I also understand there are some amendments, so I'd like to I'm going to turn first to Councilor Green to float his amendments so that we can have that and our folks who are going to testify can respond to that.

889
01:19:05.542 --> 01:19:09.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then Councilors Smith and Murillo, for technical questions, I'll come to you and then we'll go to testimony.

890
01:19:09.813 --> 01:19:10.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Councilor Green.

891
01:19:11.323 --> 01:19:12.318
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

892
01:19:12.847 --> 01:19:16.011
<v Mitch Green>Colleagues, I'm bringing 3— proposing 3 amendments today.

893
01:19:16.621 --> 01:19:19.623
<v Mitch Green>They're titled Green 2, Green 3, and Green 4.

894
01:19:19.976 --> 01:19:27.100
<v Mitch Green>I decided to split these because they all do kind of different things and don't wanna complicate the matter.

895
01:19:29.105 --> 01:19:35.278
<v Mitch Green>The first amendment basically just strikes the minimum unit count eligibility requirement entirely.

896
01:19:36.257 --> 01:19:43.175
<v Mitch Green>It also strikes the requirement to sort of prioritize these— this program eligibility for mixed use.

897
01:19:44.176 --> 01:19:47.801
<v Mitch Green>And I can speak, I can motivate kind of broadly when we get into discussion.

898
01:19:47.872 --> 01:19:47.923
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

899
01:19:49.016 --> 01:19:49.434
<v Mitch Green>Excuse me.

900
01:19:50.237 --> 01:19:52.676
<v Mitch Green>Green 3, which is the second of my amendments.

901
01:19:52.724 --> 01:19:57.747
<v Mitch Green>The nomenclature is funny because Green 1 failed in committee, so I'm bringing Green 2 back as Green 1.

902
01:19:57.939 --> 01:20:14.998
<v Mitch Green>But Green 3 is the second of my amendments that just adds an explicit kind of disclosure requirement to council for the due diligence documents, like kind of pro forma underwriting requirements that are already in state law, so that council has some oversight capability.

903
01:20:16.507 --> 01:20:19.104
<v Mitch Green>For funds that it ultimately is on the hook for.

904
01:20:19.909 --> 01:20:33.192
<v Mitch Green>And then finally, Green 4 strikes the delegation clauses that put this implementation underwriting function in Prosper Portland and moves it actually into the Portland Housing Bureau.

905
01:20:33.690 --> 01:20:34.881
<v Mitch Green>So those are what the 3 amendments do.

906
01:20:36.431 --> 01:20:37.462
<v Mitch Green>I take them independently.

907
01:20:37.920 --> 01:20:40.779
<v Mitch Green>I could live with any of them passing, but hopefully all of them.

908
01:20:40.828 --> 01:20:40.862
<v Mitch Green>So.

909
01:20:40.911 --> 01:20:41.024
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

910
01:20:41.328 --> 01:20:41.588
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

911
01:20:41.994 --> 01:20:42.775
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

912
01:20:43.458 --> 01:20:44.322
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Smith.

913
01:20:46.546 --> 01:20:49.351
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, uh, thank you, Council President.

914
01:20:49.689 --> 01:20:55.159
<v Loretta Smith>Um, in terms of those amendments, did you drop any of those in the, uh, committee?

915
01:20:57.137 --> 01:21:04.434
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, we had a total of 30 minutes in that for that item on that day, and so I introduced Green 1, which is the same as Green 2 today.

916
01:21:05.327 --> 01:21:06.805
<v Mitch Green>Didn't have much time to make the case.

917
01:21:06.869 --> 01:21:07.292
<v Mitch Green>It failed.

918
01:21:07.372 --> 01:21:08.807
<v Mitch Green>So I'm, I'm trying to—.

919
01:21:08.807 --> 01:21:11.886
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I was trying to figure out, if it had failed in, in committee.

920
01:21:12.192 --> 01:21:12.704
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, thanks.

921
01:21:13.377 --> 01:21:14.051
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

922
01:21:14.275 --> 01:21:14.805
<v Robert Taylor>Councilor Ryan.

923
01:21:16.184 --> 01:21:17.099
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, thank you, Council President.

924
01:21:17.644 --> 01:21:24.426
<v Dan Ryan>On that same thought, so the overriding failed in the committee and then you split it up into amendments?

925
01:21:25.581 --> 01:21:34.529
<v Mitch Green>I did a very narrow amendment, Councilor, in committee, um, based upon some testimony and email exchanges I had with the developer that just struck the minimum limit.

926
01:21:36.408 --> 01:21:37.130
<v Mitch Green>That failed.

927
01:21:37.371 --> 01:21:40.293
<v Mitch Green>And so since then I've had conversations and so I'm adding more.

928
01:21:40.984 --> 01:21:48.449
<v Mitch Green>But that first one that did fail, I'm trying to bring that back and also strike the mixed-use part, which was not in the first amendment.

929
01:21:48.530 --> 01:21:54.390
<v Mitch Green>And I did that because I think this is just gonna foreclose a lot of opportunities the developers are ready to go on.

930
01:21:54.648 --> 01:21:56.783
<v Mitch Green>So that's why I'm bringing it back a little bit differently this time.

931
01:21:57.667 --> 01:21:59.368
<v Dan Ryan>But you didn't bring it back to the committee.

932
01:22:00.717 --> 01:22:01.744
<v Mitch Green>It advanced out of committee.

933
01:22:02.484 --> 01:22:04.684
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, so you did bring all these amendments?

934
01:22:04.731 --> 01:22:06.641
<v Mitch Green>I brought one of them to committee.

935
01:22:06.835 --> 01:22:07.525
<v Dan Ryan>And it failed.

936
01:22:08.038 --> 01:22:12.422
<v Mitch Green>And then since then, I've had the opportunity to think more about what I want to do with this piece of legislation.

937
01:22:13.016 --> 01:22:13.466
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm bringing—.

938
01:22:13.498 --> 01:22:17.945
<v Dan Ryan>Well, since then, I'm just confused why since then you didn't choose to go back to the committee for all of you to—.

939
01:22:18.492 --> 01:22:19.969
<v Mitch Green>It didn't go back to the committee, Councilor.

940
01:22:20.018 --> 01:22:20.771
<v Mitch Green>It came straight to council.

941
01:22:21.993 --> 01:22:23.903
<v Mitch Green>I didn't have an opportunity to take it back to committee.

942
01:22:26.425 --> 01:22:28.320
<v Dan Ryan>Because that committee's disbanded?

943
01:22:28.673 --> 01:22:31.534
<v Mitch Green>No, this is the Housing and Permitting— came out of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

944
01:22:32.515 --> 01:22:34.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, the committee voted to refer it.

945
01:22:35.021 --> 01:22:35.503
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, they did?

946
01:22:35.583 --> 01:22:35.824
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

947
01:22:36.130 --> 01:22:38.460
<v Dan Ryan>I think we had a miscommunication in front of everybody right now.

948
01:22:38.797 --> 01:22:38.957
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

949
01:22:39.198 --> 01:22:39.439
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

950
01:22:39.939 --> 01:22:40.099
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

951
01:22:40.163 --> 01:22:43.586
<v Dan Ryan>Because what I heard you answer first was that it died in committee.

952
01:22:43.875 --> 01:22:47.587
<v Mitch Green>The amendment— one of the amendments did die in committee.

953
01:22:47.635 --> 01:22:47.972
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

954
01:22:48.213 --> 01:22:54.028
<v Mitch Green>And what I'm trying to do now is have an opportunity to discuss with my colleagues and then that was resurrected and then it passed.

955
01:22:55.024 --> 01:22:57.993
<v Jamie Dunphy>The ordinance passed out of committee.

956
01:22:58.137 --> 01:22:59.407
<v Jamie Dunphy>The amendment failed in committee.

957
01:22:59.760 --> 01:23:00.001
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

958
01:23:00.386 --> 01:23:01.301
<v Dan Ryan>I was really listening.

959
01:23:01.364 --> 01:23:03.067
<v Dan Ryan>That's why I had to ask technical questions.

960
01:23:03.355 --> 01:23:05.828
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, it's confusing when you're not on the committee sometimes.

961
01:23:06.020 --> 01:23:06.390
<v Mitch Green>Absolutely.

962
01:23:06.726 --> 01:23:07.047
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

963
01:23:08.332 --> 01:23:10.805
<v Dan Ryan>I just wanted to ask those technical questions before there's testimony.

964
01:23:11.061 --> 01:23:11.238
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

965
01:23:11.703 --> 01:23:12.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

966
01:23:12.682 --> 01:23:13.373
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

967
01:23:13.791 --> 01:23:14.207
<v Zachary Lindahl>Thanks.

968
01:23:15.155 --> 01:23:17.033
<v Eric Zimmerman>These are pretty significant changes.

969
01:23:17.097 --> 01:23:32.697
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I guess my I think as we go through the conversation, I'm going to be looking to the staff to understand why they brought an original, because you've, you've made a lot of changes here, and I— you're not exactly a person I consider the developer whisperer.

970
01:23:32.905 --> 01:23:38.548
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I am wondering why it is they were brought from the staff in one perspective and now they're changing.

971
01:23:38.596 --> 01:23:41.561
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think that'll be where I'm listening to see.

972
01:23:41.787 --> 01:23:49.509
<v Eric Zimmerman>And staff, I hope you're prepared to start talking about what the staff thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

973
01:23:49.590 --> 01:23:50.140
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

974
01:23:50.948 --> 01:23:52.097
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

975
01:23:52.177 --> 01:23:53.569
<v Steve Novick>I was actually going to say the same thing.

976
01:23:53.618 --> 01:23:59.092
<v Steve Novick>I'm just wondering whether it'd be appropriate to ask Donnie Oliveira and his team up to answer some questions.

977
01:23:59.189 --> 01:24:00.481
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, would that be appropriate now?

978
01:24:00.644 --> 01:24:01.725
<v Jamie Dunphy>This would be an appropriate time for that.

979
01:24:01.774 --> 01:24:03.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, we are in technical questions.

980
01:24:03.329 --> 01:24:05.068
<v Steve Novick>Okay, Mr. Oliveira.

981
01:24:11.324 --> 01:24:28.865
<v Steve Novick>Just asking you to hold forth on all of these amendments, the numeric limitation, the mixed-use requirement, the disclosure idea, and the idea of switching from Prosper to PHB.

982
01:24:29.667 --> 01:24:30.261
<v Donnie Oliveira>Great.

983
01:24:30.645 --> 01:24:31.416
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you, Councilors.

984
01:24:32.168 --> 01:24:34.413
<v Donnie Oliveira>Donnie Oliveira, for the record, Deputy City Administrator.

985
01:24:35.536 --> 01:24:37.332
<v Donnie Oliveira>Let's start with— I'll just go down the line.

986
01:24:37.380 --> 01:24:37.845
<v Donnie Oliveira>Is that appropriate?

987
01:24:37.974 --> 01:24:38.390
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you, Mayor.

988
01:24:38.663 --> 01:24:42.244
<v Donnie Oliveira>Regarding the threshold, this was a conversation that happened at committee.

989
01:24:43.465 --> 01:24:57.563
<v Donnie Oliveira>The original intent was 75, and the rationale behind that was essentially looking at what's in our pipeline for development around the city, and especially actually seeing what's happening with the SDC exemption.

990
01:24:58.140 --> 01:25:03.182
<v Donnie Oliveira>We're seeing a lot of projects coming in in that smaller window, 2 to 10 units is really the sweet spot right there.

991
01:25:03.631 --> 01:25:08.297
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that's also consistent with what we're just seeing with the financing models that are happening right now.

992
01:25:08.345 --> 01:25:13.668
<v Donnie Oliveira>We're seeing a lot of interest and capacity for those smaller, important projects still, by the way.

993
01:25:13.716 --> 01:25:15.385
<v Donnie Oliveira>I don't want to sound like I'm disparaging.

994
01:25:15.737 --> 01:25:17.372
<v Donnie Oliveira>Any housing production is good production right now.

995
01:25:17.934 --> 01:25:26.159
<v Donnie Oliveira>But we're still seeing a lack of those bigger projects, over 40, over 75, that really moves our housing production needle.

996
01:25:26.961 --> 01:25:31.097
<v Donnie Oliveira>So when we're looking at a product like— financing project like Merle, the idea is—.

997
01:25:31.210 --> 01:25:31.738
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

998
01:25:32.237 --> 01:25:36.087
<v Donnie Oliveira>Let's try to incentivize those bigger projects.

999
01:25:36.586 --> 01:25:44.497
<v Donnie Oliveira>And just for the public's knowledge, the MERL project out of the state has a fund of $50 million statewide.

1000
01:25:45.314 --> 01:25:53.162
<v Donnie Oliveira>And while we think it'll be competitive and first come, first serve, so to speak, we don't believe the whole $50 million will come to the City of Portland.

1001
01:25:53.211 --> 01:25:55.681
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we're likely to see a few projects come our way.

1002
01:25:55.841 --> 01:25:58.603
<v Donnie Oliveira>And I think our preference would be those projects would be larger in capacity.

1003
01:25:58.682 --> 01:25:58.859
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

1004
01:25:59.051 --> 01:26:00.255
<v Donnie Oliveira>We'll take what we can get, of course.

1005
01:26:00.978 --> 01:26:07.444
<v Donnie Oliveira>But there was no specifically strategic— I think I said this on the DIA SAC committee— the number could have been 60, could have been 90.

1006
01:26:07.637 --> 01:26:13.270
<v Donnie Oliveira>75 was just to signal that we were looking for something in that higher production level.

1007
01:26:13.976 --> 01:26:21.006
<v Donnie Oliveira>Regarding the framing of mixed-use as something to contemplate and consider prioritize, that can be struck, especially if that number goes down.

1008
01:26:21.921 --> 01:26:33.355
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's just to encourage these vital developments that we look like, Look for, especially in our higher density commercial corridors where a larger project would likely exist.

1009
01:26:33.823 --> 01:26:44.273
<v Donnie Oliveira>And then last thing, just to acknowledge why 20 seemed practical at the time of the committee, 'cause we were negotiating with the committee on the fly, is that keeps inclusionary housing threshold in place.

1010
01:26:44.550 --> 01:26:50.213
<v Donnie Oliveira>So those units below 20, or those projects below 20 don't hit IH.

1011
01:26:50.505 --> 01:26:51.667
<v Donnie Oliveira>So 20 was the threshold.

1012
01:26:51.716 --> 01:26:52.976
<v Donnie Oliveira>But again, that was— I'm sorry.

1013
01:26:53.576 --> 01:26:56.529
<v Donnie Oliveira>Largely on the fly working with the committee to contemplate that number.

1014
01:26:57.604 --> 01:27:07.810
<v Donnie Oliveira>I said this to a couple of councilors before, while we want to encourage the higher unit production, it is a policy choice for council to set that limit or not.

1015
01:27:09.078 --> 01:27:15.850
<v Donnie Oliveira>When it comes to the disclosure, it's legally doable.

1016
01:27:16.380 --> 01:27:30.000
<v Donnie Oliveira>The one thing we would just caution, and this is speculative, but we just want to acknowledge this, On behalf of the teams, it may dissuade some people from participating if they're not comfortable having their financials disclosed.

1017
01:27:30.252 --> 01:27:31.654
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that's just something for us to contemplate.

1018
01:27:32.939 --> 01:27:38.640
<v Donnie Oliveira>I can't guarantee that won't happen or will happen, but that's something we would be just— we'd flag for council's contemplation.

1019
01:27:38.689 --> 01:27:44.975
<v Donnie Oliveira>But it's technically allowable to share that information with council at the appropriate time.

1020
01:27:45.643 --> 01:27:47.337
<v Donnie Oliveira>And regarding Green 4, Yes.

1021
01:27:48.524 --> 01:27:54.666
<v Donnie Oliveira>When it comes to the management of the program's administration of the program, here's what our current thinking is.

1022
01:27:55.980 --> 01:28:07.542
<v Donnie Oliveira>Prosper's in the best position to do that right now, largely because it was true back then, it's even more so now with the newly adopted housing package, the $56 million that council just directed.

1023
01:28:08.009 --> 01:28:13.588
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's the same team that would run the MRL that is now on the hook for the revolving loan fund for the rent buydown program.

1024
01:28:13.670 --> 01:28:15.539
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that's all new work for them.

1025
01:28:15.810 --> 01:28:19.460
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so there's actually another program they're going to be launching next fiscal year as well.

1026
01:28:19.710 --> 01:28:23.460
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we're truly at a capacity where there's going to be some trade-offs or things are just going to slow down.

1027
01:28:23.909 --> 01:28:35.550
<v Donnie Oliveira>So it'd be my recommendation, and why I'm speaking here and not the bureaus, is to say if we're looking for all these projects to move forward congruently and with some urgency, we can't over-leverage the Housing Bureau.

1028
01:28:35.729 --> 01:28:39.109
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that would be— that's just our recommendation, would be it still sticks with Prosper.

1029
01:28:39.329 --> 01:28:39.529
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

1030
01:28:39.896 --> 01:28:44.641
<v Donnie Oliveira>And the other piece about the— there was a striking of some language related to TIF.

1031
01:28:44.962 --> 01:28:49.582
<v Donnie Oliveira>We can solve for that on the back end with an IG between the bureaus, but it is more administrative work.

1032
01:28:49.972 --> 01:28:55.542
<v Donnie Oliveira>And I would just encourage councilors to give us as much flexibility as possible to administer the program.

1033
01:28:58.756 --> 01:28:59.015
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1034
01:28:59.807 --> 01:29:00.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick, anything?

1035
01:29:01.021 --> 01:29:01.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1036
01:29:01.345 --> 01:29:01.685
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1037
01:29:01.912 --> 01:29:02.835
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, councilor.

1038
01:29:03.368 --> 01:29:07.452
<v Jamie Dunphy>And colleagues, reminder, we are in technical and clarifying questions, and we have 4 okay, Donnie.

1039
01:29:07.500 --> 01:29:14.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>Like I said, I had some questions.

1040
01:29:14.479 --> 01:29:19.547
<v Eric Zimmerman>So sorry, it was a little unclear what you were saying there in terms of what the position was.

1041
01:29:19.661 --> 01:29:20.800
<v Eric Zimmerman>You, you went all over the map.

1042
01:29:21.024 --> 01:29:23.993
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we went back to Carmen Sandiego.

1043
01:29:24.313 --> 01:29:27.875
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, so 20, 0, or 75, right?

1044
01:29:27.922 --> 01:29:32.399
<v Eric Zimmerman>You started at 75, the committee changed it to 20, and now he's making a proposal at 0.

1045
01:29:32.655 --> 01:29:32.832
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1046
01:29:33.891 --> 01:29:42.063
<v Eric Zimmerman>So you mentioned something with IH as it relates to 20, but these are all restricted 50% AMI.

1047
01:29:42.143 --> 01:29:44.134
<v Eric Zimmerman>Isn't that what you guys adjusted it to?

1048
01:29:44.712 --> 01:29:45.610
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what are we talking about here?

1049
01:29:45.836 --> 01:29:48.934
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we're looking for maximum flexibility.

1050
01:29:48.981 --> 01:29:55.805
<v Donnie Oliveira>So from that logic, reducing the minimum would allow units that are, or projects that are 4 to 6 units to be in play.

1051
01:29:56.333 --> 01:29:59.625
<v Donnie Oliveira>And yes, the different financing mechanisms change based on the size of the project.

1052
01:30:00.029 --> 01:30:00.854
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's absolutely true.

1053
01:30:01.260 --> 01:30:08.319
<v Donnie Oliveira>I was saying if we were keeping the project levels relatively high, the difference between 19 and 20 is IH or not IH.

1054
01:30:08.545 --> 01:30:09.881
<v Donnie Oliveira>Again, options.

1055
01:30:09.978 --> 01:30:16.002
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's just an option that a potential housing producer could take advantage of.

1056
01:30:17.050 --> 01:30:24.899
<v Donnie Oliveira>So there's really no— at this point, if the question is should it be zero or something else, we would say at a minimum 20.

1057
01:30:25.094 --> 01:30:50.109
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if it's I feel like there should be some understanding for what— so when I, when I am complaining often to people about they didn't build high enough in my district, often they'll say to me, because this type of construction above, let's say, the 8th floor or the 7th floor or whatever, it significantly changes the cost.

1058
01:30:50.172 --> 01:30:55.448
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that gives us an idea for where in the cost structure assistance is needed.

1059
01:30:56.220 --> 01:31:12.492
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what I'd be looking for is where, where in the middle-income revolving loan world is the most help needed in terms of 75% as a base, 20% as a base, or 0% as a base.

1060
01:31:12.652 --> 01:31:16.631
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say that with $50 million across the state, yes, is nothing.

1061
01:31:17.050 --> 01:31:17.451
<v Eric Zimmerman>Correct.

1062
01:31:17.690 --> 01:31:20.387
<v Eric Zimmerman>So great, we can finance A couple of projects.

1063
01:31:20.436 --> 01:31:21.207
<v Donnie Oliveira>A couple of floors?

1064
01:31:21.319 --> 01:31:21.993
<v Donnie Oliveira>We could finance a couple—.

1065
01:31:21.993 --> 01:31:24.980
<v Eric Zimmerman>A couple of floors in a couple of projects, 'cause we're not gonna get the whole $50 million.

1066
01:31:25.078 --> 01:31:25.430
<v Donnie Oliveira>Correct.

1067
01:31:25.655 --> 01:31:30.569
<v Donnie Oliveira>And this is not designed, this fund is not designed to be the full capital stack of a project.

1068
01:31:30.634 --> 01:31:33.363
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's designed to support and assist in that.

1069
01:31:33.460 --> 01:31:37.716
<v Donnie Oliveira>But you are speaking to this question of what project types need the most help.

1070
01:31:37.859 --> 01:31:42.918
<v Donnie Oliveira>And I think it's fair to say across the board, across the city, all project types need help right now.

1071
01:31:43.480 --> 01:31:47.978
<v Donnie Oliveira>I mean, I'm bringing up the SDC exemption because this is action this council took last year.

1072
01:31:48.363 --> 01:31:53.769
<v Donnie Oliveira>We are seeing, We're seeing the usage of that product, which is great, but not to the scale that we hope.

1073
01:31:53.833 --> 01:31:55.791
<v Donnie Oliveira>And it's still— we're still in the middle of the program.

1074
01:31:56.319 --> 01:31:59.207
<v Donnie Oliveira>We're seeing at this nice threshold of middle housing, which is great.

1075
01:32:00.250 --> 01:32:07.019
<v Donnie Oliveira>What we are not seeing though is the larger projects that are going from those wood frame buildings to your concrete buildings.

1076
01:32:07.067 --> 01:32:09.233
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that's where the gap's just not being met right now.

1077
01:32:09.328 --> 01:32:13.467
<v Donnie Oliveira>So those larger projects, those 8-story projects, the financing's just not working out.

1078
01:32:13.965 --> 01:32:16.515
<v Donnie Oliveira>So in theory, as we're introducing a new product into the market, Thank you.

1079
01:32:20.886 --> 01:32:23.956
<v Donnie Oliveira>Now, does reducing the minimum prevent a project like that from coming online?

1080
01:32:24.314 --> 01:32:24.756
<v Donnie Oliveira>It does not.

1081
01:32:25.474 --> 01:32:26.078
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that's what I'm saying.

1082
01:32:26.979 --> 01:32:27.060
<v Donnie Oliveira>It—.

1083
01:32:27.092 --> 01:32:29.810
<v Donnie Oliveira>By reducing the minimum, you don't hinder a project like that from coming in.

1084
01:32:30.409 --> 01:32:34.407
<v Donnie Oliveira>But what is true is you just increase the range of projects that might come in.

1085
01:32:34.779 --> 01:32:42.015
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, so your amendment, Councilor Green, gives me a lot of pause at the minimum issue, but I do appreciate the mixed-use.

1086
01:32:42.369 --> 01:32:48.935
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I expect, based on testimony here, I expect I'll probably go ahead and ask to split that question.

1087
01:32:50.329 --> 01:33:02.761
<v Eric Zimmerman>With respect to the other technical aspects, so the— I want to make sure I understand.

1088
01:33:03.327 --> 01:33:11.069
<v Eric Zimmerman>So was the requirement for disclosure documents to the council okay, to the city seems something somewhat reasonable.

1089
01:33:11.149 --> 01:33:18.664
<v Eric Zimmerman>To the council seems very strange to me, and I'm trying to think in the course of our other work, is this a unique thing?

1090
01:33:18.761 --> 01:33:21.895
<v Eric Zimmerman>You mentioned something about whether or not organizations may or may not want to.

1091
01:33:22.314 --> 01:33:23.310
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is this a unique thing?

1092
01:33:23.422 --> 01:33:26.527
<v Eric Zimmerman>How does that play out currently in the Housing Bureau or in PROSPER?

1093
01:33:27.689 --> 01:33:32.405
<v Eric Zimmerman>What kind of change does this actually implement if Green 3 were to pass?

1094
01:33:33.618 --> 01:33:45.264
<v Donnie Oliveira>If I read the amendment correctly, the, the direction would be for the Bureau to disseminate, um, the financing, uh, term sheets related to a particular project to council.

1095
01:33:46.051 --> 01:33:56.137
<v Eric Zimmerman>And does that take an ordinance to accomplish that, or is that saying all financial sheets that ever come to the city that want this program have to also come to us?

1096
01:33:56.346 --> 01:33:58.145
<v Eric Zimmerman>Am I going to get inundated with every application?

1097
01:33:58.483 --> 01:34:00.682
<v Donnie Oliveira>It was not our understanding that was all projects.

1098
01:34:00.747 --> 01:34:01.694
<v Donnie Oliveira>It was just related to the MURL.

1099
01:34:05.587 --> 01:34:09.822
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, but I'm— I mean, correct me if I'm wrong on this assumption.

1100
01:34:10.015 --> 01:34:25.345
<v Eric Zimmerman>As the MRL is written without this, the assessment if a project is applicable and awardable, you would have some sense of their financial documents before you made that— and I say you mean the city— before you made that determination.

1101
01:34:25.538 --> 01:34:26.184
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that accurate?

1102
01:34:26.345 --> 01:34:26.667
<v Mitch Green>Correct.

1103
01:34:26.989 --> 01:34:27.118
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1104
01:34:28.092 --> 01:34:34.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>In this case now, not only will you all have that, but now all those documents will come to the council.

1105
01:34:36.029 --> 01:34:37.064
<v Eric Zimmerman>Am I getting a courier pigeon?

1106
01:34:37.113 --> 01:34:39.345
<v Eric Zimmerman>What am I getting to go through their documents?

1107
01:34:39.604 --> 01:34:48.576
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, I, I think that based on the amendment, we're working from the assumption that the documents related to that specific deal for the financing of that project would be made available to council.

1108
01:34:49.565 --> 01:34:51.302
<v Eric Zimmerman>If I were to ask for those now, are they not?

1109
01:34:51.693 --> 01:34:51.871
<v Chido Dilawayo>Yeah.

1110
01:34:54.278 --> 01:34:57.596
<v Adrienne Delgado>Hi, Adrienne Delgado with City Attorney's Office.

1111
01:34:58.943 --> 01:35:09.412
<v Adrienne Delgado>So I think the way that this would work and the intention would be that council, when they want the documents, would pass a resolution so that the entire council is requesting the documents.

1112
01:35:09.845 --> 01:35:17.844
<v Adrienne Delgado>Now generally, if you want to get documents from a bureau, I think our office has issued advice that you can ask the city administrator for reports.

1113
01:35:18.324 --> 01:35:24.027
<v Adrienne Delgado>You also also have some investigatory power, um, if you were doing a full investigation on a bureau.

1114
01:35:24.845 --> 01:35:32.523
<v Adrienne Delgado>But this, I think, is a more direct path to requesting specific records instead of asking for a report from the city administrator.

1115
01:35:32.957 --> 01:35:38.707
<v Adrienne Delgado>But we would still expect a resolution to be brought forth every time that you want to receive the records.

1116
01:35:39.381 --> 01:35:40.185
<v Eric Zimmerman>That would be strange.

1117
01:35:40.345 --> 01:35:42.962
<v Eric Zimmerman>I asked for records all the time and I've never passed a resolution for them.

1118
01:35:43.542 --> 01:35:48.069
<v Adrienne Delgado>Well, trying to understand, and I think right, that's getting into probably the nuances of the relationship.

1119
01:35:48.118 --> 01:35:54.685
<v Adrienne Delgado>Like, if a councilor calls a bureau, there's no legal restriction that the bureau would not give you the records.

1120
01:35:54.797 --> 01:36:00.546
<v Adrienne Delgado>But I think this is a request to formally turn over records to the entire council, is the way that I was interpreting it.

1121
01:36:00.721 --> 01:36:00.899
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1122
01:36:01.317 --> 01:36:03.146
<v Mitch Green>All right.

1123
01:36:03.532 --> 01:36:20.844
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then, uh, in the third piece, I want to make sure, given Councilor Ryan's conversation about what did or didn't happen in committee, did the Housing Bureau versus Prosper conversation happen at committee?

1124
01:36:21.197 --> 01:36:22.623
<v Eric Zimmerman>And is this a bring back or not?

1125
01:36:23.265 --> 01:36:25.800
<v Mitch Green>I do think that one was part of my first effort.

1126
01:36:26.072 --> 01:36:29.296
<v Mitch Green>And like, I think I got a total of 12 minutes to talk about it.

1127
01:36:29.391 --> 01:36:30.787
<v Mitch Green>It died immediately.

1128
01:36:30.963 --> 01:36:32.855
<v Mitch Green>We didn't have time for a reasonable debate on that.

1129
01:36:32.984 --> 01:36:38.557
<v Mitch Green>So I've split it into a different theme because I recognize some of these may be all right, last technical question.

1130
01:36:38.639 --> 01:36:40.331
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are we under some sort of time crunch?

1131
01:36:40.411 --> 01:36:43.037
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that why it moved out of committee so fast instead of getting work done?

1132
01:36:44.420 --> 01:36:56.911
<v Mitch Green>That day we had 30 minutes allocated to this item, and then we had the Keep Portland in the House TAO ordinance, and that was the bigger, lengthier piece of business to fill.

1133
01:36:57.041 --> 01:36:59.118
<v Mitch Green>And so we didn't really have time to run long.

1134
01:36:59.840 --> 01:37:03.554
<v Eric Zimmerman>But like, this doesn't have a— we don't have to adopt by a day or we lose out on applications?

1135
01:37:04.019 --> 01:37:05.304
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1136
01:37:06.155 --> 01:37:06.412
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1137
01:37:07.457 --> 01:37:15.265
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just, I asked that in the spirit of some committees have taken the spirit of committees, which is working it out, and others are just conveyor belting through.

1138
01:37:15.409 --> 01:37:20.277
<v Eric Zimmerman>So it feels like you guys had some more to have, but you keep, guys keep talking about we only had so much time.

1139
01:37:20.390 --> 01:37:23.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>But, uh, okay, that's it for my technical questions.

1140
01:37:24.164 --> 01:37:25.016
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1141
01:37:25.369 --> 01:37:25.851
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1142
01:37:26.333 --> 01:37:30.189
<v Mitch Green>Oh, I was just putting my hand in the queue for the underlying after the post-testimony.

1143
01:37:30.511 --> 01:37:32.438
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Councilor Kanal.

1144
01:37:33.305 --> 01:37:33.787
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1145
01:37:34.188 --> 01:37:43.533
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so I'm going to keep the, the comments here specific to the, the, um, the questions, the technical questions.

1146
01:37:43.596 --> 01:37:47.771
<v Sameer Kanal>But I, I wanted to ask, um, I've gotten a couple more as we've been going through this.

1147
01:37:49.041 --> 01:37:52.573
<v Sameer Kanal>DC Oliveira, you mentioned, um, that we will get a couple projects.

1148
01:37:53.070 --> 01:37:55.094
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you anticipate that we're going to be allocated this?

1149
01:37:55.158 --> 01:37:58.335
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you, can you speak to why we're looking at projects instead of dollars?

1150
01:37:58.832 --> 01:38:06.757
<v Sameer Kanal>Like, wouldn't the idea of smaller projects, if we were getting— if we were anticipating a finite set of dollars, mean more projects could get some portion of financing?

1151
01:38:07.528 --> 01:38:08.795
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm seeing nods behind you, so.

1152
01:38:09.115 --> 01:38:11.747
<v Donnie Oliveira>When I mentioned the— yeah, thank you for giving me a chance to clarify.

1153
01:38:11.827 --> 01:38:16.175
<v Donnie Oliveira>When I mentioned the couple projects, that's what we were contemplating, a couple larger projects.

1154
01:38:16.496 --> 01:38:22.238
<v Donnie Oliveira>You're right, in theory, if they're smaller projects, but again, I'm speculating on what the state's going to allocate to the city.

1155
01:38:22.849 --> 01:38:25.769
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's a $50 million pot of resources once we have our program up and running.

1156
01:38:26.282 --> 01:38:28.881
<v Donnie Oliveira>Again, these programs have to come in to, you know, apply.

1157
01:38:29.009 --> 01:38:31.319
<v Donnie Oliveira>We have to work with them and to make sure they're, you know, ready to go.

1158
01:38:31.657 --> 01:38:35.796
<v Donnie Oliveira>And of course, we're putting our resources as a safety net to back these loans.

1159
01:38:35.891 --> 01:38:37.832
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we also want to do the due diligence.

1160
01:38:38.555 --> 01:38:40.640
<v Donnie Oliveira>One thing I didn't mention related to this—.

1161
01:38:40.640 --> 01:38:48.149
<v Sameer Kanal>Just before you— I'll let you go on, but just to clarify, the thing that they will be allocating to us is a dollar amount.

1162
01:38:49.225 --> 01:38:50.204
<v Donnie Oliveira>Loans, yeah, through the—.

1163
01:38:50.252 --> 01:38:50.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>Through loans.

1164
01:38:50.815 --> 01:38:53.658
<v Sameer Kanal>It will not be a number of loans, it will be a number of dollars.

1165
01:38:53.722 --> 01:38:53.996
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that correct?

1166
01:38:54.043 --> 01:38:54.349
<v Sameer Kanal>Correct.

1167
01:38:54.462 --> 01:38:54.751
<v Eric Engstrom>Okay, thanks.

1168
01:38:54.831 --> 01:38:55.956
<v Donnie Oliveira>And we don't know what that number is too.

1169
01:38:56.036 --> 01:38:56.613
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, fair enough.

1170
01:38:56.774 --> 01:38:57.626
<v Sameer Kanal>But sorry, carry on.

1171
01:38:57.899 --> 01:38:58.525
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah.

1172
01:38:58.766 --> 01:39:11.890
<v Donnie Oliveira>Oh, just, um, related to the administration of the program, which is still— is also material to your question, um, PHB manages programs up to a certain AMI amount, and then Prosper manages like the middle income level.

1173
01:39:11.953 --> 01:39:24.204
<v Donnie Oliveira>So if we're looking at PHB But using TIF dollars, for example, to back some of these loans, we're basically having 2 different administrative processes that make it a little convoluted for our community to navigate.

1174
01:39:24.252 --> 01:39:27.287
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's manageable, but I just want to add that just adds a little bit more confusion.

1175
01:39:27.368 --> 01:39:38.654
<v Donnie Oliveira>But it speaks to the reason why your question reminded me of that, Councilor, is when we are looking at some of these pro formas on the projects, these larger projects, that's sort of the sweet spot, what Prosper does.

1176
01:39:39.167 --> 01:39:40.019
<v Donnie Oliveira>Like, that's what they're good at.

1177
01:39:40.372 --> 01:39:42.604
<v Donnie Oliveira>Trying to get these middle-income housing projects built.

1178
01:39:43.166 --> 01:39:52.349
<v Donnie Oliveira>And PHP can do it as well, but we'd really be kind of ping-ponging between the 2 bureaus on trying to land which projects we're prioritizing as we move them through the state.

1179
01:39:52.654 --> 01:39:55.189
<v Donnie Oliveira>So it just adds a little bit more dynamic to the administration.

1180
01:39:56.506 --> 01:39:57.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

1181
01:39:57.309 --> 01:40:06.653
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I'm a little— I'm going to switch to Adrian, if that's okay, for Amendment 3 here.

1182
01:40:09.061 --> 01:40:09.384
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm—.

1183
01:40:09.384 --> 01:40:14.413
<v Sameer Kanal>This seemed a lot more straightforward until that response that you gave to Councilor Zimmerman.

1184
01:40:15.073 --> 01:40:18.270
<v Sameer Kanal>Would removing the words upon request make it easier?

1185
01:40:19.509 --> 01:40:27.583
<v Sameer Kanal>Because I think the idea of having to go through a resolution to get basic information necessary to do our jobs is really unappealing to me.

1186
01:40:27.958 --> 01:40:35.867
<v Adrienne Delgado>I think it's— I mean, it's just that a resolution is how the council Council speaks as a body, so I think it depends on your intent.

1187
01:40:35.994 --> 01:40:44.819
<v Adrienne Delgado>If the intent is that each council member could access the records individually, that's different than the council accessing records, right?

1188
01:40:46.295 --> 01:40:49.936
<v Adrienne Delgado>So I would kind of put it back to the council on what the intent is.

1189
01:40:50.369 --> 01:40:56.210
<v Adrienne Delgado>If the intent is that you meet as a body and you review the records, then they would be coming to the council.

1190
01:40:56.770 --> 01:41:04.997
<v Sameer Kanal>I think I would then I appreciate the opportunity.

1191
01:41:07.349 --> 01:41:14.594
<v Mitch Green>My intent is actually to really honor the executive side's ability to execute things, and I think the MURL is a really important program.

1192
01:41:15.391 --> 01:41:32.225
<v Mitch Green>It does give me some risk profile concerns, and I think that the state law does require certain underwriting and disclosure requirements I think there's a clause that says you must show a but-for need, that if not for this loan, you would not be able to do an affordable project.

1193
01:41:32.289 --> 01:41:38.028
<v Mitch Green>So there's a pretty high standard there for making the case in a due diligence sense.

1194
01:41:38.734 --> 01:41:41.667
<v Mitch Green>I don't actually want to go in and ask for these records all the time.

1195
01:41:42.195 --> 01:41:42.596
<v Mitch Green>I don't.

1196
01:41:42.822 --> 01:41:45.627
<v Mitch Green>And I don't think— I think that's actually inappropriate for councilors to do.

1197
01:41:46.108 --> 01:42:00.099
<v Mitch Green>But I think that there's a time where council should say, hey, we might have some concerns that perhaps the implementation or the choice to award a grant that we now have to pay back to the state may— is straying from the intent of the state law.

1198
01:42:00.547 --> 01:42:02.069
<v Mitch Green>So how do we do oversight on this?

1199
01:42:02.149 --> 01:42:15.610
<v Mitch Green>And I want to make sure that we are not in a situation where some councilors— and not to sort of suggest any ill intent— but some councilors are not able to get access to that information without a pathway.

1200
01:42:15.996 --> 01:42:24.466
<v Mitch Green>And so just by writing it into the codifying it right here to say, look, it's going to be council as a body that would need to sort of say we have an interest in this.

1201
01:42:25.318 --> 01:42:27.082
<v Mitch Green>That was my intent.

1202
01:42:27.243 --> 01:42:35.201
<v Mitch Green>I think earlier, I think my staff, when we were contemplating what to do, we sort of thought about maybe, well, any councilor at any time could request this.

1203
01:42:35.265 --> 01:42:40.414
<v Mitch Green>I was like, no, I think that's overly— you're putting your hand too far into the administration side.

1204
01:42:40.479 --> 01:42:56.287
<v Mitch Green>And so that's— so I'm happy I'm actually very much interested in us using this as a method to say there's a formal way to get this, and with all the appropriate redactions that would be appropriate, to sort of make sure that this program is being implemented in accordance with the law and we're not exposing ourselves to undue risk.

1205
01:42:56.350 --> 01:42:56.992
<v Mitch Green>So that's my intent.

1206
01:42:57.472 --> 01:43:10.210
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so then from the purpose of where we're at right now, it sounds to me like that interpretation that we just received aligns with your intent, and we can debate if that's the right thing to do thank you, Councilor Smith.

1207
01:43:13.372 --> 01:43:15.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1208
01:43:18.197 --> 01:43:33.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So hearing that last response, is the administration's interpretation that if we pass that amendment, an individual councilor who is looking to better understand a single project would not be able to do that?

1209
01:43:33.746 --> 01:43:43.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To more casually request that and receive the information the way that we can with any other record that we're trying to, to be able to review?

1210
01:43:46.899 --> 01:43:49.016
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, uh, thanks for the question.

1211
01:43:49.097 --> 01:43:52.765
<v Donnie Oliveira>I think it's more of a relation— relationship issue.

1212
01:43:52.975 --> 01:44:06.748
<v Donnie Oliveira>I don't, I don't know if, um, yeah, that's okay, I'm not sure there's my question.

1213
01:44:06.829 --> 01:44:16.347
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm trying to understand if we pass that amendment, if that actually limits our ability to get information more casually in the way that we normally would.

1214
01:44:18.020 --> 01:44:22.079
<v Adrienne Delgado>It wouldn't legally change the way that you interact with the executive branch.

1215
01:44:23.503 --> 01:44:24.394
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I understand the legal.

1216
01:44:32.868 --> 01:44:40.537
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, I don't think we've ever been in a situation where we've provided, you know, loan details to council.

1217
01:44:41.101 --> 01:44:47.975
<v Donnie Oliveira>You know, there's some, you know, concern about just, you know, public record type things in general.

1218
01:44:49.135 --> 01:44:56.362
<v Donnie Oliveira>But I think if you're asking us for information on a regular basis for projects, Where appropriate, we share that information.

1219
01:44:57.989 --> 01:45:08.015
<v Donnie Oliveira>In this particular case, I was— we were interpreting it that Councilor Green was asking for projects explicit to this program.

1220
01:45:08.322 --> 01:45:16.627
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we would go in consciously knowing that we'd be preparing this information in a way that would likely be conveyed to the City Council.

1221
01:45:18.885 --> 01:45:19.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1222
01:45:23.422 --> 01:45:24.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1223
01:45:24.659 --> 01:45:25.386
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1224
01:45:28.369 --> 01:45:29.858
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

1225
01:45:30.117 --> 01:45:32.770
<v Olivia Clark>Excuse me just a second.

1226
01:45:33.822 --> 01:45:37.606
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Green, well, let me— I, I'm going to beat this a little bit.

1227
01:45:38.253 --> 01:45:40.502
<v Olivia Clark>Um, we'll be lucky if we get any of this money.

1228
01:45:41.100 --> 01:45:51.528
<v Olivia Clark>I mean, it's not very much money, but I am concerned that I don't want to do anything based on your comment, that would dissuade anyone from investing here.

1229
01:45:52.555 --> 01:46:03.960
<v Olivia Clark>I don't want to add anything that's suspect or that would, that would be an impediment to somebody wanting to come here and, and work on a project.

1230
01:46:04.681 --> 01:46:06.641
<v Olivia Clark>I guess that, that's kind of my concern on the other end.

1231
01:46:07.011 --> 01:46:13.163
<v Olivia Clark>And if there's a way for us to get this information, great, but it seems a little, um, Over the top.

1232
01:46:13.534 --> 01:46:15.484
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know, you can help clarify that for me.

1233
01:46:15.630 --> 01:46:18.417
<v Olivia Clark>I, I don't feel like I need it, and I don't want to dissuade anyone.

1234
01:46:18.563 --> 01:46:20.255
<v Olivia Clark>And if I really needed it, I know how to get it.

1235
01:46:20.658 --> 01:46:22.783
<v Olivia Clark>So I don't know if it's really—.

1236
01:46:24.582 --> 01:46:30.944
<v Mitch Green>I think those are reasonable questions, and I, I'm prepared to sort of lay all that out when we get into discussion debate.

1237
01:46:31.073 --> 01:46:31.122
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1238
01:46:31.170 --> 01:46:39.626
<v Mitch Green>And I did structure these specifically as independent things, understanding that some of these things may not pass because folks have a different risk assessment than I do.

1239
01:46:39.689 --> 01:46:41.716
<v Mitch Green>So, um, I am prepared to speak to your concern.

1240
01:46:41.796 --> 01:46:42.264
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, thanks.

1241
01:46:42.922 --> 01:46:46.664
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Rebecca, can we move to public testimony, please?

1242
01:46:50.099 --> 01:46:51.774
<v Rebecca Dobert>First up, we have Robert Pyle.

1243
01:46:56.409 --> 01:46:57.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome, Robert.

1244
01:46:57.904 --> 01:46:59.384
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on up, introduce yourself for the record.

1245
01:47:00.895 --> 01:47:02.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome to share your pronouns, and you have 3 minutes.

1246
01:47:04.157 --> 01:47:05.055
<v Robert Pyle>Good afternoon, Council.

1247
01:47:05.439 --> 01:47:06.755
<v Robert Pyle>For the record, my name is Robert Pyle.

1248
01:47:06.835 --> 01:47:08.327
<v Robert Pyle>I'm the principal of Oakley Free Development.

1249
01:47:09.320 --> 01:47:16.362
<v Robert Pyle>I'm here today to ask you to please support the Green 2 amendment to the MRL ordinance and remove the minimum unit requirement and mixed-use preference.

1250
01:47:17.323 --> 01:47:23.337
<v Robert Pyle>There is no minimum unit requirement in the state statute, and there should not be any minimum unit requirement in our local ordinance.

1251
01:47:24.140 --> 01:47:33.041
<v Robert Pyle>Cottage clusters and townhomes are specifically eligible housing types for the MRL program under the statutory definition of middle housing in ORS 197A.

1252
01:47:33.842 --> 01:47:40.146
<v Robert Pyle>These project types are effectively precluded from the program if the 20-unit minimum unit is retained.

1253
01:47:41.301 --> 01:47:49.177
<v Robert Pyle>In 2025, only 1,652 units of housing were submitted for permit against the updated annual goal of 4,500.

1254
01:47:50.123 --> 01:47:57.326
<v Robert Pyle>The $50 million MRL fund is first-come, first-served, and the— and we should seek as much of that as possible.

1255
01:47:57.904 --> 01:48:00.438
<v Robert Pyle>The only statutory allocation is 20% to rural areas.

1256
01:48:00.502 --> 01:48:00.726
<v Robert Pyle>Thank you.

1257
01:48:02.314 --> 01:48:07.826
<v Robert Pyle>We cannot both be serious about our housing production goals and support a 20-unit minimum requirement for the MRL program.

1258
01:48:08.162 --> 01:48:12.890
<v Robert Pyle>We need all the tools we can get, and arbitrarily limiting access to this program serves no purpose that I can tell.

1259
01:48:14.252 --> 01:48:21.542
<v Robert Pyle>During the Housing and Permitting Committee meeting April 7th, uh, DCA Oliveira confirmed the staff workload is the same for a 5-unit or a 75-unit project.

1260
01:48:22.648 --> 01:48:27.279
<v Robert Pyle>Um, funding to administer the program comes from a 5% fee built into every loan.

1261
01:48:28.018 --> 01:48:29.083
<v Robert Pyle>As part of the state statute.

1262
01:48:30.359 --> 01:48:34.074
<v Robert Pyle>Loan funds come from the state budget allocation with no impact to the city budget.

1263
01:48:34.930 --> 01:48:38.759
<v Robert Pyle>I'll repeat, these funds are provided by the state with no impact to the city budget.

1264
01:48:39.555 --> 01:48:43.658
<v Robert Pyle>As Councilor Green recently put it, a revolving loan program is the cheat code for housing production.

1265
01:48:45.231 --> 01:48:51.578
<v Robert Pyle>A 20-unit minimum requirement also conflicts with inclusionary housing and the multiple-unit limited tax exemption, the multi-program.

1266
01:48:52.525 --> 01:49:01.336
<v Robert Pyle>20 To 75-unit projects, which are eligible for both, Thank you.

1267
01:49:02.942 --> 01:49:12.735
<v Robert Pyle>There are zero areas of District 1 that are eligible for the multi program, meaning the MURL is the only potential tool to support the production of moderate-income housing in District 1.

1268
01:49:13.699 --> 01:49:23.051
<v Robert Pyle>Many projects of 20 units or more in D1 still won't be feasible due to construction type and the use of concrete and steel, but many 5 to 19-unit projects Wood-framed could be.

1269
01:49:24.176 --> 01:49:30.550
<v Robert Pyle>Additionally, projects over approximately 30 units will trigger the BOLI prevailing wage requirements, creating additional feasibility challenges.

1270
01:49:32.043 --> 01:49:37.775
<v Robert Pyle>Senator Pham is holding a housing production roundtable in the GA District on June 22nd, which I know some of you are attending.

1271
01:49:38.369 --> 01:49:44.407
<v Robert Pyle>As the chief sponsor of the MORAL program, it would be great to share with her that we adopted an ordinance that allowed for the broadest possible use of this tool.

1272
01:49:45.033 --> 01:49:45.354
<v Robert Pyle>Thank you.

1273
01:49:46.221 --> 01:49:46.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here.

1274
01:49:49.204 --> 01:49:50.614
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zachary Lindahl's online.

1275
01:49:50.952 --> 01:49:52.570
<v Rebecca Dobert>You can unmute and begin testimony.

1276
01:49:53.596 --> 01:49:54.270
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1277
01:49:54.478 --> 01:49:56.194
<v Zachary Lindahl>I just want to make sure everybody can hear me.

1278
01:49:56.257 --> 01:49:57.699
<v Zachary Lindahl>My side seems to be pretty quiet.

1279
01:49:58.164 --> 01:49:58.822
<v Zachary Lindahl>We can hear you.

1280
01:49:59.927 --> 01:50:01.146
<v Zachary Lindahl>Excellent.

1281
01:50:01.386 --> 01:50:10.539
<v Zachary Lindahl>Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and Portland City Council, for the record, my name is Zach Lindahl and I'm the Director of Government Affairs for Multifamily Northwest.

1282
01:50:10.764 --> 01:50:14.738
<v Zachary Lindahl>We represent nearly 300,000 rental homes across Oregon.

1283
01:50:15.396 --> 01:50:18.543
<v Zachary Lindahl>And the professionals who own, operate, and maintain them.

1284
01:50:18.944 --> 01:50:29.590
<v Zachary Lindahl>Multifamily Northwest is pleased to support Document 2026-124, which would implement— adopt and implement the Moderate Income Revolving Loan Program known as MIRRL.

1285
01:50:30.087 --> 01:50:50.710
<v Zachary Lindahl>This ordinance is practical, forward-looking step that enables the City of Portland to finance more housing by authorizing the Housing and Community Services Department to fund mixed-income housing developments and establish a dedicated Portland's housing shortage requires policies that increase housing supply across income levels.

1286
01:50:51.127 --> 01:50:58.947
<v Zachary Lindahl>Mixed-income housing plays an important role in that effort by supporting financially viable projects that include both market-rate and affordable units.

1287
01:50:59.444 --> 01:51:09.698
<v Zachary Lindahl>Our organization has a long history of supporting policies such as this, as it provides an additional financing tool that can help, help projects move forward that might otherwise stall due to funding gaps.

1288
01:51:09.800 --> 01:51:23.619
<v Zachary Lindahl>In fact, Multifamily Northwest enthusiastically supported both Senate Bill 1537 during the 2024 session as well as House Bill 4037 during the 2026 session, allowing the creation of the local MRL.

1289
01:51:23.619 --> 01:51:32.250
<v Zachary Lindahl>By establishing the new local MRL and the rules established by OHCS, the City of Portland has created a program that provides flexibility while maintaining accountability.

1290
01:51:32.619 --> 01:51:42.233
<v Zachary Lindahl>The ability to offer below-market below-market short-term loans can help unlock private capital, support project feasibility, and accelerate housing production.

1291
01:51:42.988 --> 01:51:52.155
<v Zachary Lindahl>Additionally, our team would like to recognize the intention of this policy to help provide housing to those earning between 50% and 120% area median income.

1292
01:51:52.605 --> 01:51:55.238
<v Zachary Lindahl>This diversity of affordable housing is critical.

1293
01:51:55.576 --> 01:52:01.034
<v Zachary Lindahl>Dedicated workforce housing priced at 80% to 120% is often the least represented in our housing continuum.

1294
01:52:01.453 --> 01:52:03.557
<v Zachary Lindahl>And the most precarious to finance and build.

1295
01:52:04.409 --> 01:52:11.746
<v Zachary Lindahl>Lastly, I would like to say, say that we support Councilor Green's amendment that eliminates the cap on the number of units for these projects.

1296
01:52:12.215 --> 01:52:18.020
<v Zachary Lindahl>This change in the cap will allow for developers to consider a variety of projects that might work best for them.

1297
01:52:18.684 --> 01:52:29.490
<v Zachary Lindahl>Multifamily Northwest supports policies that move Portland closer to achieving 120,000 new units by 2045 and the governor's goal of producing 36,000 new units every year.

1298
01:52:30.055 --> 01:52:39.626
<v Zachary Lindahl>We believe this ordinance aligns squarely with the objective by extending the city's capacity to support housing development at scale without overprescribing outcomes or adding unnecessary barriers.

1299
01:52:40.143 --> 01:52:40.967
<v Zachary Lindahl>Thank you for your time.

1300
01:52:41.679 --> 01:52:42.713
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here today.

1301
01:52:43.582 --> 01:52:43.806
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1302
01:52:45.030 --> 01:52:45.997
<v Rebecca Dobert>Benjamin Gilbert.

1303
01:52:51.134 --> 01:52:52.775
<v Jamie Dunphy>Robert, if you want to sit, you don't have to sit there.

1304
01:52:57.219 --> 01:52:59.404
<v Donnie Oliveira>Hello, my name is Benjamin Gilbert.

1305
01:52:59.628 --> 01:53:03.676
<v Donnie Oliveira>I'm a tenant in District 4 and a volunteer lobbyist for the Portland Democratic Socialists of America.

1306
01:53:04.689 --> 01:53:10.425
<v Donnie Oliveira>I support the adoption and implementation of the, of the Moderate Income Revolving Loan Program as amended.

1307
01:53:11.034 --> 01:53:13.573
<v Mitch Green>I want to specifically voice my support for Green 3 and 4.

1308
01:53:14.264 --> 01:53:17.203
<v Mitch Green>It's essential that we build state capacity in housing development.

1309
01:53:18.039 --> 01:53:20.802
<v Mitch Green>The Housing Bureau, not Prosper Portland, is the logical place for this.

1310
01:53:24.439 --> 01:53:27.222
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1311
01:53:30.439 --> 01:53:30.878
<v Rebecca Dobert>Jordan Lewis.

1312
01:53:31.368 --> 01:53:33.175
<v Rebecca Dobert>Jordan, you can unmute and go ahead online.

1313
01:53:36.079 --> 01:53:36.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hello, City Council.

1314
01:53:36.837 --> 01:53:37.693
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My name is Jordan Lewis.

1315
01:53:37.952 --> 01:53:41.841
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>My pronouns are he/him, and I'm a volunteer lobbyist with Portland DSA.

1316
01:53:42.261 --> 01:53:44.939
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm testifying in support of Green Amendments 2, 3, and 4.

1317
01:53:45.626 --> 01:53:51.034
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I support Green 2 because I think Uh, Portland needs residential infill yesterday.

1318
01:53:51.501 --> 01:54:00.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>More people in city limits means more tax revenue for services, more transit riders, and the cost to provide sewer and water services is split between more ratepayers.

1319
01:54:01.088 --> 01:54:08.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are all consensus goals for the city, and if we can get them done sooner with a more diverse portfolio of smaller units, then we should do that.

1320
01:54:09.006 --> 01:54:13.471
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also support Green 2 as someone who lives above 7 vacant ground floor retail units.

1321
01:54:13.520 --> 01:54:13.872
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1322
01:54:14.483 --> 01:54:23.538
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We clearly have too much mixed-use development for a city of our density, and until we get that density up, mixed-use requirements function functionally as taxes on new developments.

1323
01:54:24.421 --> 01:54:33.318
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If someday we enter another Portlandia-era building boom, that'll be a great problem to have, and we can recalibrate our retail standards then.

1324
01:54:33.751 --> 01:54:37.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But right now, I think something needs to change to better outcomes.

1325
01:54:37.363 --> 01:54:39.243
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm also supportive of Green 3 and 4.

1326
01:54:39.291 --> 01:54:39.403
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1327
01:54:40.076 --> 01:54:51.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because we are living in the shadow of just decades of failures by markets, by governments to provide housing where people want to live.

1328
01:54:52.654 --> 01:54:54.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have to treat that like an emergency.

1329
01:54:54.578 --> 01:54:56.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd almost treat it like an earthquake.

1330
01:54:56.980 --> 01:55:01.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And after an earthquake, we don't delegate it outside of government.

1331
01:55:01.948 --> 01:55:06.418
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, we should have state capacity to fix these like super pressing problems.

1332
01:55:07.404 --> 01:55:10.703
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Housing is the number one problem for the Portland area.

1333
01:55:10.832 --> 01:55:22.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I would really like to see government stand up and remediate this problem just like it stood up and remediated like earthquakes in Alaska or California.

1334
01:55:23.177 --> 01:55:24.956
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, that's all I gotta say.

1335
01:55:25.216 --> 01:55:25.606
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1336
01:55:26.421 --> 01:55:27.121
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1337
01:55:28.520 --> 01:55:29.561
<v Rebecca Dobert>That concludes testimony.

1338
01:55:31.899 --> 01:55:36.398
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, we are now into discussion of the underlying.

1339
01:55:37.368 --> 01:55:37.921
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1340
01:55:38.929 --> 01:55:40.604
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

1341
01:55:40.717 --> 01:55:42.604
<v Mitch Green>At this time, I'd like to move Green 1.

1342
01:55:42.653 --> 01:55:43.384
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to do these separately.

1343
01:55:44.573 --> 01:55:44.912
<v Mitch Green>Green 2.

1344
01:55:44.976 --> 01:55:45.590
<v Mitch Green>I'm sorry.

1345
01:55:45.927 --> 01:55:46.251
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1346
01:55:46.331 --> 01:55:46.814
<v Mitch Green>Green 2.

1347
01:55:47.153 --> 01:55:47.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1348
01:55:47.878 --> 01:55:49.748
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green moves Green 2.

1349
01:55:49.975 --> 01:55:50.538
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there a second?

1350
01:55:51.539 --> 01:55:52.310
<v Dan Ryan>I'll second that.

1351
01:55:52.600 --> 01:55:53.467
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan seconds.

1352
01:55:54.304 --> 01:55:56.023
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, to the discussion.

1353
01:55:56.070 --> 01:55:56.408
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1354
01:55:57.036 --> 01:56:00.538
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I appreciate the opportunity for the discussion.

1355
01:56:01.217 --> 01:56:03.493
<v Mitch Green>We did have a brief discussion in committee about this.

1356
01:56:05.211 --> 01:56:24.533
<v Mitch Green>I think for me, the economics of scale when you build something right now with the external forces that we're facing, the cost of capital, the cost of labor inputs, the cost of material inputs, make it really hard to complete a capital stack even with this little bit of MRL for larger units.

1357
01:56:24.966 --> 01:56:36.275
<v Mitch Green>And while I do want to see those go up, especially in areas that are zoned for density, Right now we have a lot of capacity to build, and that's been created by the residential infill program.

1358
01:56:36.939 --> 01:56:45.604
<v Mitch Green>And the buildings that have been built under this program are affordable at the middle-income level just by the native characteristics of those projects.

1359
01:56:45.652 --> 01:56:52.082
<v Mitch Green>And so for me, it's about how quickly can we disperse these dollars out the door to get shovels in the ground.

1360
01:56:52.664 --> 01:56:59.369
<v Mitch Green>And I think I was moved by Robert Pyle's sort of testimony, and also he reached out to my office.

1361
01:56:59.380 --> 01:57:06.170
<v Mitch Green>We had a couple conversations, and, you know, he showed me the permits in flight, walked me through kind of the economics of these projects.

1362
01:57:06.399 --> 01:57:12.229
<v Mitch Green>And I have actually seen the success stories of folks who've been able to go out there and buy one of these units for $200,000 to $300,000.

1363
01:57:12.859 --> 01:57:17.020
<v Mitch Green>And that is squarely in the affordability range.

1364
01:57:17.020 --> 01:57:21.699
<v Mitch Green>Or, you know, in the case of an apartment, it's just a— it's a function of the cost.

1365
01:57:21.699 --> 01:57:21.739
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1366
01:57:21.822 --> 01:57:23.860
<v Mitch Green>Of production so that you can have lower rents there too.

1367
01:57:24.470 --> 01:57:27.890
<v Mitch Green>And so I really do think this is going to allow us to spend the dollars.

1368
01:57:27.988 --> 01:57:46.757
<v Mitch Green>And when you're in a crisis of faith in government where you're constantly wondering if our taxes are then translating into benefits that people can feel, I think it's better for the long-term health of the MRL program, which I would like to see expanded at the state level, if we can show a lot of case studies of success.

1369
01:57:46.822 --> 01:57:47.095
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1370
01:57:47.578 --> 01:57:49.770
<v Mitch Green>In Portland, Oregon, of putting some buildings up.

1371
01:57:50.494 --> 01:58:02.145
<v Mitch Green>In my district, there's a program that's currently not eligible as written on Southwest Nebraska Street that could be something financed with MRL and their gap could be closed.

1372
01:58:02.194 --> 01:58:04.400
<v Mitch Green>So that's my primary reason for Green 2.

1373
01:58:05.863 --> 01:58:23.046
<v Mitch Green>Also, we have a glut of commercial retail space right now, and adding more to that, I think, hurts our current storefront owners because then they have to deal with the fact that there's new competition for the storefronts that are vacant next to them.

1374
01:58:23.579 --> 01:58:26.765
<v Mitch Green>And it also just works against the economics of the situation we're in right now.

1375
01:58:26.831 --> 01:58:31.376
<v Mitch Green>And so you heard that also from Multifamily Northwest as well.

1376
01:58:32.006 --> 01:58:33.858
<v Mitch Green>And so I ask for your support for Green 2.

1377
01:58:34.163 --> 01:58:34.404
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1378
01:58:34.872 --> 01:58:35.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1379
01:58:36.015 --> 01:58:38.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, to Green 2, Councilor Avalos.

1380
01:58:39.849 --> 01:58:40.363
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1381
01:58:41.054 --> 01:58:42.612
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, thanks for the discussion, folks.

1382
01:58:42.739 --> 01:58:51.878
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so as we have shared, yes, we did discuss it in committee, um, and we made the decision at that time to move it from 75 to 20.

1383
01:58:52.779 --> 01:59:03.251
<v Candace Avalos>I supported that change because the 20 units, um, like we've been saying and like you heard from Donnie, and I do agree with that argument that we're trying to stretch these dollars, right?

1384
01:59:03.636 --> 01:59:04.872
<v Candace Avalos>It is a limited pot of money.

1385
01:59:05.547 --> 01:59:13.608
<v Candace Avalos>And given this, the— given that, um, it makes sense to me to prioritize projects that deliver more units per dollar.

1386
01:59:14.378 --> 01:59:16.128
<v Candace Avalos>So that's why I supported moving it to 20.

1387
01:59:16.322 --> 01:59:20.368
<v Candace Avalos>And then I don't— now I'm like, can't remember, did we try to move it to 0 in committee and we failed that?

1388
01:59:20.431 --> 01:59:20.832
<v Candace Avalos>I can't remember.

1389
01:59:20.898 --> 01:59:26.453
<v Candace Avalos>But we ended up— we landed on 20, um, and I stood by that for those reasons.

1390
01:59:26.597 --> 01:59:28.862
<v Candace Avalos>I think that the— and, you know, thank you, Robert.

1391
01:59:28.909 --> 01:59:45.725
<v Candace Avalos>We've been, uh, in communication with I've spoken with him as well, my office, and I think the arguments around wanting to infuse dollars right away, wanting to give— make sure that these dollars are eligible in District 1, of course, is going to hit home for me.

1392
01:59:46.877 --> 01:59:52.552
<v Candace Avalos>And, you know, when I talked with Donnie about this, I think ultimately it's a policy choice.

1393
01:59:53.103 --> 01:59:54.605
<v Candace Avalos>And I think the policy choice—.

1394
01:59:55.787 --> 01:59:56.158
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1395
01:59:59.027 --> 02:00:00.373
<v Candace Avalos>Discernible reason, I guess.

1396
02:00:00.551 --> 02:00:03.710
<v Candace Avalos>I don't remember how he phrased it, that we would be making this policy choice.

1397
02:00:03.837 --> 02:00:04.319
<v Candace Avalos>I disagree.

1398
02:00:04.430 --> 02:00:11.198
<v Candace Avalos>I think there is a reason to make a policy choice of 20 units for everything that we've said, and it's not a hill I need to die on.

1399
02:00:11.295 --> 02:00:15.110
<v Candace Avalos>I think it's fine to just bring it to the state's level.

1400
02:00:16.121 --> 02:00:24.877
<v Candace Avalos>And so while I didn't support it in committee and I still have my feelings like I would prefer 20, it's not a hill I'm interested in dying on.

1401
02:00:24.940 --> 02:00:29.797
<v Candace Avalos>I want to get cranes in the sky, and I want to get some of that middle housing built in East Portland.

1402
02:00:29.845 --> 02:00:32.411
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll, I'll go ahead and plan to support it today.

1403
02:00:32.779 --> 02:00:33.115
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

1404
02:00:33.837 --> 02:00:34.766
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1405
02:00:35.425 --> 02:00:37.573
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1406
02:00:39.032 --> 02:00:43.118
<v Eric Zimmerman>I wanted to give one last opportunity to the staff.

1407
02:00:43.439 --> 02:00:46.917
<v Eric Zimmerman>You included mixed-use for a reason, I have to presume.

1408
02:00:47.783 --> 02:00:48.634
<v Eric Zimmerman>What was that reason?

1409
02:00:48.826 --> 02:01:01.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I am generally in agreement that that is an unnecessary code requirement that we have just blanketed across the city and we are seeing failing in a lot of places.

1410
02:01:01.658 --> 02:01:02.993
<v Eric Zimmerman>So like, what was the reason?

1411
02:01:03.364 --> 02:01:05.184
<v Eric Zimmerman>I can't— I hope it wasn't just happenstance.

1412
02:01:05.360 --> 02:01:06.086
<v Donnie Oliveira>No, Councilor.

1413
02:01:06.262 --> 02:01:15.435
<v Donnie Oliveira>And just for clarity, in the original ordinance, it references it as one of the things we would look at as a priority, was like not a must-have, because we were looking at the different structures of a project.

1414
02:01:15.873 --> 02:01:17.185
<v Donnie Oliveira>Mixed-use would be a thing that we'd contemplate.

1415
02:01:17.659 --> 02:01:31.600
<v Donnie Oliveira>Because in many cases when we're talking about the larger projects, based on where those would go by our zoning, it makes sense to have a mixed-use development in places like a 75-unit project would go.

1416
02:01:31.600 --> 02:01:38.840
<v Donnie Oliveira>Now with the rest of Green 2, by reducing the minimum, the mixed-use component becomes irrelevant.

1417
02:01:38.840 --> 02:01:43.859
<v Donnie Oliveira>'Cause it's absolutely right, you wouldn't build a mixed-use building with 4 units in every zone.

1418
02:01:43.859 --> 02:01:45.859
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's just, that's not a relevant consideration.

1419
02:01:47.060 --> 02:01:47.159
<v Loretta Smith>So.

1420
02:01:47.159 --> 02:01:47.220
<v Eric Engstrom>Councilor Smith.

1421
02:01:47.676 --> 02:01:51.369
<v Donnie Oliveira>If Green 2 is adopted holistically, then that makes you— piece becomes moot.

1422
02:01:52.859 --> 02:01:54.600
<v Mitch Green>Okay, thanks.

1423
02:01:57.962 --> 02:02:02.507
<v Eric Zimmerman>And who from the city brought this original work to the committee?

1424
02:02:03.007 --> 02:02:04.524
<v Eric Zimmerman>What department or what section?

1425
02:02:04.958 --> 02:02:06.362
<v Eric Zimmerman>Where'd this come from?

1426
02:02:06.733 --> 02:02:08.363
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's actually Prosper Housing.

1427
02:02:08.429 --> 02:02:11.061
<v Donnie Oliveira>It was Prosper Housing and Revenue.

1428
02:02:11.902 --> 02:02:12.322
<v Eric Zimmerman>And Revenue.

1429
02:02:12.628 --> 02:02:12.774
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1430
02:02:14.427 --> 02:02:15.765
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's why Tim's here.

1431
02:02:16.698 --> 02:02:16.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1432
02:02:17.681 --> 02:02:18.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>All right.

1433
02:02:18.375 --> 02:02:18.583
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1434
02:02:20.145 --> 02:02:21.015
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1435
02:02:21.500 --> 02:02:21.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1436
02:02:24.351 --> 02:02:26.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks, Council President.

1437
02:02:27.412 --> 02:02:38.780
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I, you know, I, I was listening to everything Councilor Avalos was saying about our discussion in committee and wanted to jump in to say that for those reasons, I'm actually not going to support this amendment.

1438
02:02:38.829 --> 02:02:41.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We did have a discussion about the right level.

1439
02:02:42.001 --> 02:02:45.405
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We heard from advocates who were worried 75 would be too high.

1440
02:02:46.176 --> 02:03:01.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We heard from folks in the administration that they wanted to make sure that we captured— if it's first come, first serve, and if we're only going to get so many projects, let's make sure we're capturing some of those larger projects.

1441
02:03:01.739 --> 02:03:08.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we settled on 20, that number where inclusionary zoning in to say we already have a line here.

1442
02:03:09.462 --> 02:03:18.627
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's make sure that we're focused not on the cottage clusters and duplexes, which I think are actually an incredibly important part of the system, but a different part of the system.

1443
02:03:19.157 --> 02:03:22.141
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's make sure we're focused on those larger-scale projects.

1444
02:03:23.007 --> 02:03:32.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, let's make sure we're focused because we specifically said transit-oriented, um, as one of the other criteria here for preference.

1445
02:03:32.734 --> 02:03:37.837
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When you talk about transit-oriented, we are often More likely to be talking about mixed use.

1446
02:03:38.528 --> 02:03:53.935
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There was a really intentional decision here, and I, I feel the need to stick with that decision that we made as we evaluated all of these pieces through a true quick discussion but relatively comprehensive conversation in committee.

1447
02:03:54.480 --> 02:03:55.363
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks, Council President.

1448
02:03:56.167 --> 02:03:57.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1449
02:03:57.595 --> 02:03:58.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I put myself in the queue.

1450
02:03:58.958 --> 02:04:00.837
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to be supportive of Green 2.

1451
02:04:01.447 --> 02:04:11.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will tell you that first, when we have— first, I think Robert Pyle is a fantastic developer and the infill model that he has been working on and a lot of cottage cluster things.

1452
02:04:11.823 --> 02:04:23.162
<v Jamie Dunphy>When we hear from Multifamily Northwest coming and telling us please do this, and then we also have DSA here telling us to do this, I feel like either this is a great idea or somehow a terrible idea that I just can't understand.

1453
02:04:23.226 --> 02:04:25.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>But it seems like a really good idea to me.

1454
02:04:26.359 --> 02:04:29.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also think that I mean, I will be honest and I will be transparent to this body.

1455
02:04:30.146 --> 02:04:33.266
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am not certain that inclusionary housing is serving our city well.

1456
02:04:34.350 --> 02:04:42.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>The number of 19-unit buildings, the concerns I hear from developers, the sort of automatic triggers, I'm just not sure that right now it is helping.

1457
02:04:43.386 --> 02:04:45.083
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I also am really concerned about this.

1458
02:04:45.632 --> 02:04:51.921
<v Jamie Dunphy>So for that purpose, I am concerned about this MRL being tagged at the 20-unit building.

1459
02:04:53.342 --> 02:04:53.904
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1460
02:04:55.028 --> 02:05:16.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also am worried about trying to make— trying to use this as a tool to entice bigger projects, because I have been hearing from developers that those projects are simply not coming right now, that those investors who would be bringing that level of capital are looking around and saying, we could spend X on building a new building, or we could spend a tenth of X and buy a building that's currently in foreclosure.

1461
02:05:16.189 --> 02:05:29.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if this could help make some of the smaller projects A 10-unit, a 15-unit, something on my side of town, as Mr. Pyle was saying, actually start and we can get any units going, I think that that's a really big deal right now.

1462
02:05:30.342 --> 02:05:35.747
<v Jamie Dunphy>In a perfect world, if we were in the Portlandia era, absolutely, let's tie it to a bigger thing and see if we can get more skyscrapers.

1463
02:05:36.260 --> 02:05:37.724
<v Jamie Dunphy>But that ain't where we are right now.

1464
02:05:37.788 --> 02:05:39.203
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm gonna be supportive of this.

1465
02:05:41.176 --> 02:05:42.484
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1466
02:05:44.412 --> 02:05:47.024
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just— one last pitch on this.

1467
02:05:47.234 --> 02:06:03.315
<v Mitch Green>Green 2 is really designed to maximize the flexibility and lower the burden as much as possible for developers, just because I do think that we need to really use every tool in the toolkit right now to just get production going.

1468
02:06:03.588 --> 02:06:08.256
<v Mitch Green>That will help our economic picture in ways that have a multiplier effect.

1469
02:06:08.594 --> 02:06:09.784
<v Mitch Green>The other amendments are different.

1470
02:06:10.051 --> 02:06:15.750
<v Mitch Green>And so I just want you to focus on the nature of Green 2 and the intent behind it.

1471
02:06:16.311 --> 02:06:20.725
<v Mitch Green>And again, hope that you see that I'm trying to speed up the rate of housing production here.

1472
02:06:20.805 --> 02:06:21.127
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1473
02:06:21.287 --> 02:06:22.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1474
02:06:22.811 --> 02:06:23.341
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1475
02:06:23.597 --> 02:06:25.219
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Council President.

1476
02:06:25.363 --> 02:06:29.841
<v Dan Ryan>You actually said much of the things that I would've said, so I really appreciate your comments.

1477
02:06:30.435 --> 02:06:33.372
<v Dan Ryan>The adaptable shift from this body is a really encouraging sign.

1478
02:06:34.046 --> 02:06:35.090
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Robert Pyle.

1479
02:06:35.234 --> 02:06:35.395
<v Dan Ryan>There you are.

1480
02:06:35.993 --> 02:06:38.155
<v Dan Ryan>For sharing your lived experience.

1481
02:06:38.332 --> 02:06:38.832
<v Dan Ryan>I believe you.

1482
02:06:39.689 --> 02:06:40.494
<v Dan Ryan>Superb testimony.

1483
02:06:40.576 --> 02:06:40.914
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1484
02:06:42.109 --> 02:06:44.965
<v Dan Ryan>We can't have housing production numbers like 2025.

1485
02:06:45.189 --> 02:06:46.096
<v Dan Ryan>It's just unacceptable.

1486
02:06:46.243 --> 02:06:47.101
<v Dan Ryan>We have to do something.

1487
02:06:47.555 --> 02:06:48.738
<v Dan Ryan>So let's align with the state.

1488
02:06:48.837 --> 02:06:49.533
<v Dan Ryan>Let's move some dirt.

1489
02:06:49.662 --> 02:06:51.105
<v Dan Ryan>I'm all in for green too.

1490
02:06:52.872 --> 02:06:53.581
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1491
02:06:54.159 --> 02:06:57.813
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan, 'cause you said the word green, it came outta my mouth.

1492
02:06:58.729 --> 02:06:59.485
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1493
02:07:01.378 --> 02:07:02.350
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1494
02:07:02.511 --> 02:07:06.752
<v Steve Novick>I had the same reaction you did to the varied testimony on this topic.

1495
02:07:07.238 --> 02:07:15.061
<v Steve Novick>I also just need to take this opportunity to say that I said earlier that I wasn't going to go to Le Pigeon because I've been warned that somebody might spit in my food.

1496
02:07:15.159 --> 02:07:17.257
<v Steve Novick>That was a joke in bad taste that I should not have repeated.

1497
02:07:18.894 --> 02:07:22.163
<v Steve Novick>Le Pigeon did not warn me of that, and I'm planning to go there on July 10th.

1498
02:07:22.746 --> 02:07:25.045
<v Steve Novick>And if somebody wants to join me, because I don't have a date, I will pay.

1499
02:07:26.365 --> 02:07:27.158
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1500
02:07:31.100 --> 02:07:32.817
<v Jamie Dunphy>You got 8— you got 7 months.

1501
02:07:34.248 --> 02:07:36.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, uh, Councilor Zimmerman, is that a legacy hand?

1502
02:07:37.685 --> 02:07:37.878
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

1503
02:07:38.007 --> 02:07:38.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

1504
02:07:40.140 --> 02:07:48.002
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue to discuss Green 2, Rebecca, can we please call the roll on Green 2?

1505
02:07:48.260 --> 02:07:50.579
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green 2, moved by Green, seconded by Ryan.

1506
02:07:50.774 --> 02:07:52.042
<v Jamie Dunphy>And cameras on, please, colleagues.

1507
02:07:52.725 --> 02:07:52.953
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal.

1508
02:07:55.833 --> 02:07:55.865
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1509
02:07:56.835 --> 02:07:57.060
<v Rebecca Dobert>No.

1510
02:07:58.515 --> 02:07:58.805
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

1511
02:07:59.225 --> 02:07:59.274
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1512
02:08:01.167 --> 02:08:01.216
<v Adrienne Delgado>Aye.

1513
02:08:02.139 --> 02:08:02.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

1514
02:08:07.972 --> 02:08:08.811
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, absent.

1515
02:08:08.876 --> 02:08:09.262
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1516
02:08:10.391 --> 02:08:10.439
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1517
02:08:12.567 --> 02:08:13.067
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

1518
02:08:13.695 --> 02:08:15.887
<v Olivia Clark>Thanks to Robert and to Zach for their testimony.

1519
02:08:15.935 --> 02:08:16.242
<v Olivia Clark>I'm an aye.

1520
02:08:17.139 --> 02:08:17.453
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1521
02:08:18.381 --> 02:08:18.398
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1522
02:08:19.398 --> 02:08:19.832
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1523
02:08:20.090 --> 02:08:20.266
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1524
02:08:21.457 --> 02:08:21.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

1525
02:08:23.548 --> 02:08:26.702
<v Angelita Morillo>Sorry, go ahead, go ahead, Murillo.

1526
02:08:27.280 --> 02:08:27.650
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

1527
02:08:28.439 --> 02:08:29.239
<v Angelita Morillo>Sorry, I'm here.

1528
02:08:30.996 --> 02:08:31.012
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1529
02:08:31.095 --> 02:08:31.159
<v Rebecca Dobert>Aye.

1530
02:08:31.257 --> 02:08:31.634
<v Candace Avalos>And I vote aye.

1531
02:08:32.140 --> 02:08:32.811
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo is an aye.

1532
02:08:34.021 --> 02:08:35.591
<v Candace Avalos>Avalos is an aye.

1533
02:08:35.753 --> 02:08:35.997
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1534
02:08:37.229 --> 02:08:37.667
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1535
02:08:38.332 --> 02:08:38.381
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1536
02:08:40.538 --> 02:08:40.993
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1537
02:08:42.502 --> 02:08:42.536
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1538
02:08:43.301 --> 02:08:45.894
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the amendment's approved with 11 ayes, 1 nay vote.

1539
02:08:47.140 --> 02:08:47.819
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you very much.

1540
02:08:49.645 --> 02:08:50.292
<v Rebecca Dobert>Councilor Novick?

1541
02:08:51.279 --> 02:08:51.650
<v Steve Novick>Legacy?

1542
02:08:51.747 --> 02:08:52.055
<v Steve Novick>Legacy.

1543
02:08:52.248 --> 02:08:53.720
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1544
02:08:54.350 --> 02:08:54.885
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1545
02:08:56.113 --> 02:08:56.617
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, colleagues.

1546
02:08:56.681 --> 02:08:59.475
<v Mitch Green>I'd like to move Green— what is it— 3.

1547
02:09:00.676 --> 02:09:01.326
<v Mitch Green>I look for a second.

1548
02:09:03.573 --> 02:09:07.467
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green moves Green 3.

1549
02:09:07.597 --> 02:09:08.551
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal seconds.

1550
02:09:09.877 --> 02:09:10.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1551
02:09:11.234 --> 02:09:12.220
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you, colleagues.

1552
02:09:12.447 --> 02:09:33.155
<v Mitch Green>Um, we got into this a little bit during the technical discussion, but the the intent behind Green 3 is just to add an explicit recognition that City Council can engage more formally on making sure that this program is being implemented to state law.

1553
02:09:34.077 --> 02:09:41.048
<v Mitch Green>And I know that there's an implicit duty and right of Council to invoke its charter investigatory powers.

1554
02:09:41.148 --> 02:09:44.260
<v Mitch Green>I think that that's That's way up the scale of oversight.

1555
02:09:44.404 --> 02:09:46.442
<v Mitch Green>That's, that's a blunt tool for something like this.

1556
02:09:46.923 --> 02:10:00.068
<v Mitch Green>It's much more direct, um, as you heard from our city attorney, to just sort of say explicitly that, um, the city's program manager, their designee, shall make available to council these, these financial statements.

1557
02:10:00.132 --> 02:10:09.518
<v Mitch Green>And, uh, this, this one will be especially important for me if we don't pass Green 4, because now we've got this separation of the the designee is Prosper Portland.

1558
02:10:10.180 --> 02:10:15.106
<v Mitch Green>We don't have that ability to sort of do that investigation on Prosper Portland because they're a distinct entity.

1559
02:10:15.171 --> 02:10:28.957
<v Mitch Green>And so this just writes in, writes into the code that there is an expectation that council can exercise its oversight powers responsibly when appropriate through this codification.

1560
02:10:29.878 --> 02:10:32.934
<v Mitch Green>And it would obviously apply whoever the designee is, but— I think that's a good point.

1561
02:10:33.622 --> 02:10:34.810
<v Mitch Green>That's the spirit behind it.

1562
02:10:34.921 --> 02:10:36.077
<v Mitch Green>It doesn't do anything more than that.

1563
02:10:36.253 --> 02:10:36.511
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1564
02:10:36.751 --> 02:10:37.488
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1565
02:10:38.179 --> 02:10:48.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I had intended to give us a restroom break before moving to the next amendment, so I'm going to pause this right here and I'm going to give us a 10-minute restroom break and have everybody back here at 4:15.

1566
02:10:48.927 --> 02:10:54.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>We still have an entire— we have 2 other items after this still, so in addition to the one we're on.

1567
02:10:54.333 --> 02:10:55.632
<v Jamie Dunphy>So see you in 10 minutes.

1568
02:25:23.860 --> 02:25:25.847
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are back, friends.

1569
02:25:27.083 --> 02:25:29.728
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are in discussion of Green 3.

1570
02:25:30.209 --> 02:25:32.213
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark, turning to you.

1571
02:25:32.760 --> 02:25:34.282
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, thank you, Council President.

1572
02:25:34.362 --> 02:25:35.983
<v Olivia Clark>I think— oh, Green 3, right.

1573
02:25:36.448 --> 02:25:54.414
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I just would, um, was going to reiterate my concern about adding anything that dissuades private participation in the stack, and, um, It just seems like there are ways for us to get this information if we really need to have it.

1574
02:25:55.219 --> 02:26:02.129
<v Olivia Clark>Um, so I'm— I appreciate your efforts on this, I really do, um, as a housing advocate.

1575
02:26:02.176 --> 02:26:09.427
<v Olivia Clark>So, uh, I just don't want to do anything that might prevent, uh, the private sector from getting involved in a, in a project.

1576
02:26:09.477 --> 02:26:10.439
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm probably going to vote no.

1577
02:26:12.396 --> 02:26:13.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

1578
02:26:13.479 --> 02:26:14.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1579
02:26:15.063 --> 02:26:18.377
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any further discussion of Green 3?

1580
02:26:18.620 --> 02:26:19.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1581
02:26:20.058 --> 02:26:21.384
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Council President.

1582
02:26:21.449 --> 02:26:23.422
<v Dan Ryan>I think it gets to both 3 and 4.

1583
02:26:24.569 --> 02:26:26.170
<v Dan Ryan>Um, DCL Alvaro, could you please come up?

1584
02:26:31.986 --> 02:26:41.425
<v Dan Ryan>Well, 3 I, I have opinions on because when I was Housing Commissioner, I, I, I fully trusted the staff's due diligence in the process that we had, so I don't— I'm I'm clear, I'm a no on that.

1585
02:26:42.052 --> 02:26:50.870
<v Dan Ryan>But I thought I heard on 4, but I think you're being very diplomatic and perhaps I wasn't hearing it, but I heard capacity strain and challenges.

1586
02:26:51.384 --> 02:26:51.881
<v Dan Ryan>Is that true?

1587
02:26:52.027 --> 02:26:53.086
<v Dan Ryan>Is that on both or on 4?

1588
02:26:53.858 --> 02:26:58.820
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, are we, just to be clear, are we discussing just 3 or are we open to 4?

1589
02:26:58.869 --> 02:26:59.190
<v Candace Avalos>Sorry.

1590
02:26:59.575 --> 02:27:01.406
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're on 3, but you're welcome to comment on 4.

1591
02:27:01.503 --> 02:27:01.985
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, great.

1592
02:27:02.129 --> 02:27:02.417
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you for—.

1593
02:27:02.417 --> 02:27:03.076
<v Dan Ryan>Trying to be efficient.

1594
02:27:03.173 --> 02:27:03.558
<v Dan Ryan>Absolutely.

1595
02:27:03.655 --> 02:27:03.879
<v Dan Ryan>Time.

1596
02:27:04.474 --> 02:27:05.533
<v Donnie Oliveira>Donnie Oliveira for the record.

1597
02:27:06.240 --> 02:27:10.829
<v Donnie Oliveira>Regarding 4, the question is, about capacity.

1598
02:27:11.199 --> 02:27:22.605
<v Donnie Oliveira>And right now at PHB, we are aggressively standing up new programs that council directed the bureau to do related to the $56 million ordinance, the Keeping Portlanders Housed initiative.

1599
02:27:23.135 --> 02:27:25.746
<v Donnie Oliveira>And those are some really big lifts and really excited to get those forward.

1600
02:27:25.795 --> 02:27:30.153
<v Donnie Oliveira>We've shared some of the timelines with the project sponsors on that.

1601
02:27:30.825 --> 02:27:39.529
<v Donnie Oliveira>It'd be the same team, a very small but mighty team that is working on those that would pivot to work on MRL because we are This is also an urgent program as well.

1602
02:27:40.138 --> 02:27:43.041
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so we do have limitations just staffing capacity-wise at the Housing Bureau.

1603
02:27:43.170 --> 02:27:57.834
<v Donnie Oliveira>There's talented team partners that can support Prosper in this, but at the same time, the projects we're looking at too, Prosper just has the capacity and the expertise to move these forward quickly, working with the state to get these dollars allocated.

1604
02:27:58.427 --> 02:28:05.190
<v Donnie Oliveira>So it would be our preference that the administration remains with Prosper, acknowledging just the capacity at Thank you so much.

1605
02:28:05.370 --> 02:28:06.167
<v Dan Ryan>I needed to hear that directly.

1606
02:28:07.670 --> 02:28:08.235
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1607
02:28:08.332 --> 02:28:08.800
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1608
02:28:10.046 --> 02:28:17.417
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, just speaking into it, like, colleagues, I recognize that not everyone's comfortable with this.

1609
02:28:17.547 --> 02:28:20.123
<v Mitch Green>And Councilor Clark, I hear your concerns and I take them well.

1610
02:28:21.025 --> 02:28:33.093
<v Mitch Green>I think for me, if we don't pass this, I think it's still incumbent on this body to at times ask the questions it needs to ask and do the, do this oversight it needs to do.

1611
02:28:33.141 --> 02:28:40.005
<v Mitch Green>It just— it will become a little bit more ad hoc, and this just provides a kind of formal declaration.

1612
02:28:40.070 --> 02:28:40.975
<v Mitch Green>But I'll leave it there.

1613
02:28:41.087 --> 02:28:47.628
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to try to, uh, you know, um, uh, what's the euphemism?

1614
02:28:47.804 --> 02:28:49.009
<v Mitch Green>I'm not— I'll just leave it there.

1615
02:28:49.459 --> 02:28:54.713
<v Mitch Green>I, I accept the position that folks are in, um, and this is why I separated the amendments in the first place.

1616
02:28:55.281 --> 02:28:56.317
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1617
02:28:56.593 --> 02:28:57.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1618
02:29:00.135 --> 02:29:00.986
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1619
02:29:01.033 --> 02:29:03.746
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we have, um, the acting city administrator with us right now?

1620
02:29:04.227 --> 02:29:06.587
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have an acting city administrator.

1621
02:29:06.652 --> 02:29:09.028
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is, uh, uh, DCA Dhanapal.

1622
02:29:10.408 --> 02:29:11.805
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, that'll work.

1623
02:29:12.495 --> 02:29:19.206
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we don't usually put language like this in ordinances that we pass.

1624
02:29:20.040 --> 02:29:24.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there— I'm gonna think about how I want to ask this.

1625
02:29:27.179 --> 02:29:29.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm trying to understand the necessity.

1626
02:29:30.954 --> 02:29:46.534
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there an assumption right now in the direction that you all both give and get that when councilors or the council requests information, it is gotten to us as quickly as feasible?

1627
02:29:47.372 --> 02:29:50.114
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or is that not an assumption on all work that we do?

1628
02:29:58.447 --> 02:30:27.254
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Again, sorry, is there an assumption within the administration right now that when councilors, or when the council— it sounds like this language the lawyers would say we would need to pass a resolution for anyway— That when we ask for something, it should be gotten to us for information or financial statements, it should be gotten to us as soon as possible, or is that not an assumption for any similar ask that council might make?

1629
02:30:30.557 --> 02:30:39.968
<v Chido Dilawayo>I will have to check with City Administrator Lee for the response, but we are— our goal is to get it back to you as soon as possible.

1630
02:30:41.522 --> 02:30:44.316
<v Loretta Smith>That's, that's the—.

1631
02:30:44.396 --> 02:30:46.996
<v Keelan McClymont>On the administrative side, we try to get back to you as soon as possible.

1632
02:30:48.104 --> 02:30:48.409
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1633
02:30:48.570 --> 02:30:50.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I put you in an awkward position.

1634
02:30:50.497 --> 02:30:55.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You are not the, the always city administrator, and I apologize for that, DCA Dhanapal.

1635
02:30:57.001 --> 02:31:12.237
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You know, when we break with precedent, when we say something somewhere and not everywhere, that starts to create or can start to create the precedent that we mean it in some places and not other places.

1636
02:31:13.290 --> 02:31:22.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Green, I agree with you very much that there are going to be places where we need to do some oversight and we should ask for the information to be able to do that.

1637
02:31:22.552 --> 02:31:35.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it concerns me that we were told that if we pass this, we'll need to pass a resolution when we want the information anyway, because anytime we pass a resolution, we should get that information.

1638
02:31:35.626 --> 02:31:36.939
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In fact, we shouldn't have to.

1639
02:31:37.003 --> 02:31:39.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Anytime we ask for something, we should get that information.

1640
02:31:39.635 --> 02:32:02.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So as long as that is the administration's intent always, I am hesitant to pass this language here and start to say, hey, sometimes we call it out and sometimes we don't, and then leave to legal interpretation the difference between our intent and what we, what we might want in those different scenarios.

1641
02:32:02.343 --> 02:32:02.648
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

1642
02:32:04.990 --> 02:32:06.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1643
02:32:06.450 --> 02:32:08.023
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

1644
02:32:08.858 --> 02:32:09.227
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1645
02:32:09.724 --> 02:32:13.896
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, is one of the housing city attorneys who was here earlier, if they could come up?

1646
02:32:14.297 --> 02:32:19.863
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, are we allowed to compel Prosper to give us a pro forma?

1647
02:32:20.233 --> 02:32:36.208
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I think, you know, I think sometimes when I'm thinking of these amendments, there are varying degrees to which any number of us can get And pieces of information, and it really varies person by person that they're speaking with in each bureau or agency.

1648
02:32:38.472 --> 02:32:42.452
<v Adrienne Delgado>I think there's a number of ways that you can request information from Prosper.

1649
02:32:42.583 --> 02:32:51.056
<v Adrienne Delgado>It's not going to be the same path that we've been talking about with asking the city administrator or calling a bureau and asking for advice, um, for the records.

1650
02:32:51.413 --> 02:32:54.666
<v Adrienne Delgado>There you could ask for, you know, an issue of public records request.

1651
02:32:55.807 --> 02:33:08.844
<v Adrienne Delgado>When we send money from the general fund, we would execute an IGA, and I would assume there would be a term in that IGA that Prosper has to disclose records when we, when we ask for them.

1652
02:33:10.338 --> 02:33:11.591
<v Adrienne Delgado>But it's not the same path.

1653
02:33:11.686 --> 02:33:36.168
<v Adrienne Delgado>So I think part of the discussion is like, if this is— if Prosper is going to be executing this program, then We would either— this clause would help the city get records from Prosper, or when Prosper executes an IGA with the city administrator or revenue, then that's another pathway, um, to— for the city to get records from Prosper, is to include that clause in the IGA.

1654
02:33:39.109 --> 02:34:05.433
<v Adrienne Delgado>And would a records request get us a really redacted pro forma from Prosper, or would we get to Generally, um, I can answer it from the, like, from the Housing Bureau attorney perspective, is that when we get a public records request that involves financial information of a developer, that we would redact that information because it's— there is a specific public records law exemption.

1655
02:34:06.059 --> 02:34:10.091
<v Adrienne Delgado>So certain financial information, including the pro forma, would generally be redacted.

1656
02:34:10.171 --> 02:34:10.299
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1657
02:34:11.902 --> 02:34:17.158
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, and if we asked the Housing Bureau for a pro forma, can they provide that?

1658
02:34:18.663 --> 02:34:22.215
<v Adrienne Delgado>There's certainly nothing that prevents them from providing it.

1659
02:34:22.635 --> 02:34:30.724
<v Adrienne Delgado>So the public records exemption is conditional, meaning that you have— the city has the choice whether or not to exercise it.

1660
02:34:32.024 --> 02:34:39.345
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, I think in, in my experience, when my office has asked for pro formas, that's not how it's worked out in practice.

1661
02:34:40.067 --> 02:34:50.888
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, they have said— the Housing Bureau said that they're not able to send them over, um, and it really depends on Prosper's responsiveness as well if we get them or not.

1662
02:34:51.865 --> 02:35:05.475
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I also think that there is something to be said here about the fact that we are elected officials who are technically, uh, having some oversight over these dollars but then not having direct oversight over them.

1663
02:35:05.958 --> 02:35:15.121
<v Angelita Morillo>And that means that, that we as elected officials have to do records requests on a city agency to get information, I think is kind of concerning.

1664
02:35:15.252 --> 02:35:21.808
<v Angelita Morillo>So that's part of why I think that this amendment matters, because we need to have a different avenue for getting this information.

1665
02:35:22.325 --> 02:35:24.132
<v Angelita Morillo>And, and that's why I'll be supportive of it.

1666
02:35:24.778 --> 02:35:25.945
<v Angelita Morillo>So thanks for answering my questions.

1667
02:35:26.010 --> 02:35:27.324
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate you.

1668
02:35:28.102 --> 02:35:28.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1669
02:35:29.092 --> 02:35:29.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1670
02:35:31.281 --> 02:35:38.452
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just wanted to Respond briefly to, I think, the line of concern that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney raised.

1671
02:35:38.969 --> 02:35:43.343
<v Mitch Green>And I tend to agree, but I think I want to just make it clear why I included this here.

1672
02:35:45.626 --> 02:35:48.740
<v Mitch Green>I am sympathetic to that sort of like precedent thing.

1673
02:35:49.159 --> 02:36:00.867
<v Mitch Green>It's just that in the state law that created the MURL, there's a whole section that explicitly says there is an obligation to disclose the full financials And make the case that you have a but-for need.

1674
02:36:01.620 --> 02:36:23.200
<v Mitch Green>And so I think especially when we're in a case where there is a potential principal-agent separation and council as the budget authority is ultimately on the hook for paying back whatever choice the designee has made for the developer, we should be able to have a pathway to sort of look in and inspect those books, so to speak.

1675
02:36:23.391 --> 02:36:23.728
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1676
02:36:24.164 --> 02:36:25.309
<v Mitch Green>So that was the motivation there.

1677
02:36:25.454 --> 02:36:27.019
<v Mitch Green>I, I, I think it's very peculiar.

1678
02:36:27.454 --> 02:36:29.954
<v Mitch Green>It's, it's, it's particular to this thing that we're trying to do here.

1679
02:36:30.641 --> 02:36:34.938
<v Mitch Green>Um, I don't contemplate that generally for all of our legislation because we do just have that native authority.

1680
02:36:36.325 --> 02:36:37.750
<v Mitch Green>Um, and I'll just leave it there.

1681
02:36:38.568 --> 02:36:40.320
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you, Councilor Green.

1682
02:36:46.278 --> 02:36:51.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue, Rebecca, Okay, could we please call the roll on Green 3?

1683
02:36:52.835 --> 02:36:55.204
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green 3, moved by Green, seconded by Kanal.

1684
02:36:56.043 --> 02:36:56.397
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

1685
02:36:56.688 --> 02:36:56.850
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1686
02:36:57.638 --> 02:36:58.040
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

1687
02:36:59.102 --> 02:36:59.246
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

1688
02:37:00.710 --> 02:37:01.016
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

1689
02:37:01.290 --> 02:37:01.370
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1690
02:37:02.882 --> 02:37:03.430
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

1691
02:37:03.847 --> 02:37:03.897
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1692
02:37:05.056 --> 02:37:05.538
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

1693
02:37:06.503 --> 02:37:06.550
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1694
02:37:07.628 --> 02:37:07.981
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1695
02:37:08.271 --> 02:37:08.432
<v Steve Novick>No.

1696
02:37:09.477 --> 02:37:09.814
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

1697
02:37:10.200 --> 02:37:10.313
<v Olivia Clark>No.

1698
02:37:11.020 --> 02:37:11.389
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1699
02:37:12.049 --> 02:37:12.209
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1700
02:37:12.804 --> 02:37:13.237
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1701
02:37:13.513 --> 02:37:13.662
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1702
02:37:14.819 --> 02:37:15.183
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

1703
02:37:17.157 --> 02:37:17.207
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1704
02:37:17.791 --> 02:37:18.246
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1705
02:37:19.156 --> 02:37:19.399
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1706
02:37:20.471 --> 02:37:20.814
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1707
02:37:23.093 --> 02:37:23.256
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1708
02:37:23.438 --> 02:37:25.724
<v Rebecca Dobert>And the amendment fails with 6 aye, 6 no votes.

1709
02:37:32.409 --> 02:37:33.765
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor Green.

1710
02:37:36.779 --> 02:37:45.067
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I don't think this is going to pass, but I do just want to move it and just I just have— I want to put on the record why I introduced it.

1711
02:37:45.966 --> 02:37:47.988
<v Mitch Green>So I would like to move Green 4.

1712
02:37:48.325 --> 02:37:49.336
<v Mitch Green>Can I ask for a second?

1713
02:37:49.417 --> 02:37:49.674
<v Robert Pyle>Thanks.

1714
02:37:50.123 --> 02:37:50.429
<v Angelita Morillo>Second.

1715
02:37:51.728 --> 02:37:51.953
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1716
02:37:52.066 --> 02:37:53.367
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green has moved Green 4.

1717
02:37:53.431 --> 02:37:54.763
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal has seconded.

1718
02:37:55.100 --> 02:37:55.518
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1719
02:37:56.786 --> 02:38:08.968
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, colleagues, briefly, I think there's just— there's a couple reasons why I think Green 4 improves this and puts the city in a position to be better stewards of those state funds and also, frankly, our own money because we have to pay it back.

1720
02:38:10.278 --> 02:38:16.772
<v Mitch Green>And it comes from— I'll firstly speak to my experience as a counterparty risk analyst in my prior career.

1721
02:38:18.190 --> 02:38:42.602
<v Mitch Green>Whenever a decision is made to advance a loan to one party, there's an immediate— and there's an obliga— particularly in a situation where like the grantee, who's the developer, receives the grant through the underwriting process, and then simultaneously the City of Portland now has a loan obligation to the state of Oregon, we now enter into what's called counterparty risk.

1722
02:38:43.180 --> 02:38:49.298
<v Mitch Green>Because if the person— if there's a default situation or the— there's 2 sources of payback in this method.

1723
02:38:49.345 --> 02:38:53.457
<v Mitch Green>It's fee and lieu, and then there's the sort of proceeds from a TIF district.

1724
02:38:53.953 --> 02:38:57.342
<v Mitch Green>If either of those fail to materialize, we still have to pay back the state of Oregon.

1725
02:38:57.389 --> 02:39:01.066
<v Mitch Green>And so we still— we now— we bear the exposure for counterparty risk.

1726
02:39:02.191 --> 02:39:11.543
<v Mitch Green>And so having that I think that having the agent, the underwriting agent be the city itself mitigates that counterparty risk.

1727
02:39:12.431 --> 02:39:15.158
<v Mitch Green>You can mitigate the counterparty risk by having more controls.

1728
02:39:15.755 --> 02:39:23.115
<v Mitch Green>We just passed— we just failed to pass an amendment that I think would have probably helped mitigate that a little bit by giving council some oversight.

1729
02:39:23.181 --> 02:39:26.022
<v Mitch Green>But it does introduce some risk.

1730
02:39:26.070 --> 02:39:27.620
<v Mitch Green>I'm not saying the risk is insurmountable.

1731
02:39:27.668 --> 02:39:28.040
<v Mitch Green>We take on risks all the time.

1732
02:39:28.104 --> 02:39:28.734
<v Mitch Green>I think the risk is insurmountable.

1733
02:39:29.343 --> 02:39:31.832
<v Mitch Green>But it is something that I thought about because of my prior experience.

1734
02:39:32.635 --> 02:39:42.558
<v Mitch Green>The other piece is that I actually think that revolving loan funds are going to become a very important and central part of housing production in general, whether we're talking about market housing, social housing, anything in between.

1735
02:39:43.296 --> 02:39:50.361
<v Mitch Green>And I want them to be successful, and I want us to do a lot more of them, and I want the state to re-up this program and expand it.

1736
02:39:51.501 --> 02:40:03.665
<v Mitch Green>And so I think that Developing the administrative capacity for the City of Portland to facilitate that as we do it, we just capitalize a small revolving loan for our own selves.

1737
02:40:04.674 --> 02:40:06.816
<v Mitch Green>Building that capability, I think, is really important.

1738
02:40:07.252 --> 02:40:16.768
<v Mitch Green>And so having this work be done in the Portland Housing Bureau and be funded by that 5% fee that Robert Pyle spoke to earlier gives us an opportunity to build that capacity in-house.

1739
02:40:18.183 --> 02:40:22.445
<v Mitch Green>This is not a— I think it's important to note that the vote of no confidence in Prosper Portland.

1740
02:40:22.621 --> 02:40:31.513
<v Mitch Green>They do great work over there, but Prosper Portland needs to focus, in my view, on economic development, and Portland Housing Bureau should focus on housing production.

1741
02:40:31.690 --> 02:40:38.559
<v Mitch Green>That's the— those are the lanes that Nick Fish actually— Commissioner Nick Fish identified and articulated when we split these things off in the first place.

1742
02:40:39.795 --> 02:40:41.850
<v Mitch Green>So I go back to that kind of initial intent.

1743
02:40:41.897 --> 02:40:51.230
<v Mitch Green>And so I worry if we go down this road, we'll continue to sort of I guess in some sense lose an opportunity to build that administrative capacity.

1744
02:40:51.279 --> 02:40:52.689
<v Mitch Green>So that's my primary motivation.

1745
02:40:52.784 --> 02:40:53.281
<v Mitch Green>It's risk.

1746
02:40:53.361 --> 02:40:59.099
<v Mitch Green>It's a risk thing as well as it is a let's build our administrative capacity frame.

1747
02:40:59.210 --> 02:41:01.647
<v Mitch Green>And so hope, hope, hope for support.

1748
02:41:01.854 --> 02:41:02.174
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1749
02:41:02.575 --> 02:41:03.281
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1750
02:41:03.858 --> 02:41:05.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1751
02:41:05.540 --> 02:41:06.438
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1752
02:41:06.486 --> 02:41:10.172
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, Councilor Green, for doing the work on this and all the other amendments as well.

1753
02:41:10.363 --> 02:41:12.238
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to smash the yes button on this one.

1754
02:41:12.334 --> 02:41:22.235
<v Sameer Kanal>I I think it's really vital that for the taxpayers that are looking at us as a steward of this particular program, obviously they paid into it from the state perspective.

1755
02:41:24.513 --> 02:41:32.858
<v Sameer Kanal>It's vital that we are able to keep this in-house to be able to exercise that democratic control and have the actual oversight of the program.

1756
02:41:34.635 --> 02:41:37.533
<v Sameer Kanal>And we've had this conversation around democratic accountability several times.

1757
02:41:37.583 --> 02:41:38.347
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's really vital.

1758
02:41:38.971 --> 02:41:48.013
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's also fair to point out that I really appreciate DCA Oliveira's point about having enough— whether or not PHB has enough staff.

1759
02:41:48.447 --> 02:41:51.668
<v Sameer Kanal>I also want to note that Prosper Portland is facing the same concerns.

1760
02:41:51.717 --> 02:41:55.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Prosper Portland is zeroing out its equity department, for example, right now.

1761
02:41:55.244 --> 02:42:08.719
<v Sameer Kanal>They are also facing some of the same issues, and I think the question is how do we solve for the problem as opposed to just take the face value Which I think is accurate of where we're at staffing-wise, and assume it can't be changed.

1762
02:42:08.783 --> 02:42:11.579
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we can do what we need to do to provide enough capacity.

1763
02:42:11.933 --> 02:42:27.293
<v Sameer Kanal>That 5% would go a long way, I imagine, towards that, but also ensure that we're not simply looking at one potential option in a vacuum and not taking into account that Prosper is also facing some of the same staff capacity concerns there as well.

1764
02:42:27.518 --> 02:42:27.840
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1765
02:42:28.788 --> 02:42:29.752
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

1766
02:42:30.073 --> 02:42:30.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1767
02:42:34.327 --> 02:42:34.986
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, thank you.

1768
02:42:35.612 --> 02:42:41.217
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I hear and understand that argument, Councilor Kanal, and I appreciate you, Councilor Green.

1769
02:42:41.393 --> 02:42:44.572
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I, I do understand where you're coming from.

1770
02:42:44.764 --> 02:42:54.896
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and, um, you know, like I said in committee, I believe that there are some policy ways to go— excuse me— policy ways to go about it.

1771
02:42:55.361 --> 02:43:00.180
<v Candace Avalos>Um, also Just like oversight and reporting requirements.

1772
02:43:00.597 --> 02:43:07.953
<v Candace Avalos>I'm not convinced at this moment that changing this improves the program, and I am actually pretty concerned about the Housing Bureau's capacity.

1773
02:43:08.611 --> 02:43:15.663
<v Candace Avalos>And I say that as somebody who's working very closely with them and is constantly pushing them, and there— it's, it's too much.

1774
02:43:15.920 --> 02:43:22.264
<v Candace Avalos>And please know I will be coming back at some point this year to ask council to help me figure out how to increase capacity.

1775
02:43:22.313 --> 02:43:22.424
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1776
02:43:22.826 --> 02:43:34.500
<v Candace Avalos>In the Housing Bureau too, because they are doing excellent work, but they are at the breaking point, and I want to acknowledge that because I'm really grateful for what they've been doing.

1777
02:43:34.581 --> 02:43:43.363
<v Candace Avalos>So I think because this is a program that is going to draw down those dollars very quickly, it's kind of a one-time thing.

1778
02:43:43.412 --> 02:43:50.236
<v Candace Avalos>I'm not too concerned about the long-term governance questions, even though I agree with your governance questions, Councilor Green.

1779
02:43:50.284 --> 02:43:50.429
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1780
02:43:50.926 --> 02:43:59.613
<v Candace Avalos>I just don't think this particular thing will address those necessarily, and I want your help and I want everyone's help in increasing Housing Bureau's capacity.

1781
02:44:00.078 --> 02:44:02.584
<v Candace Avalos>And let's absolutely talk about those governance questions overall.

1782
02:44:02.985 --> 02:44:03.290
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1783
02:44:04.511 --> 02:44:05.361
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1784
02:44:05.635 --> 02:44:06.341
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1785
02:44:06.903 --> 02:44:07.978
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

1786
02:44:08.108 --> 02:44:14.754
<v Olivia Clark>Um, thank you, Councilor Green, for your continued advocacy on all things housing.

1787
02:44:15.012 --> 02:44:15.926
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that.

1788
02:44:16.632 --> 02:44:42.893
<v Olivia Clark>But I, at this point, I really agree with Councilor Avalos and the notes that I had written when I first read this, that there's just so much fluidity right now in the housing industrial complex, you know, with not just our bureau but with Home Forward and other things, that I would prefer that this issue be come back to the Housing Committee for further review.

1789
02:44:43.038 --> 02:44:43.871
<v Olivia Clark>And I also feel like we need to be careful about the language.

1790
02:44:43.921 --> 02:44:44.129
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Avalos.

1791
02:44:44.242 --> 02:44:53.245
<v Olivia Clark>To give our new Cornel Wesley, who's still relatively new, an opportunity to really right the ship at Prosper.

1792
02:44:53.574 --> 02:44:59.829
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm gonna vote against this, but I definitely appreciate your effort and really agree with Councilor Avalos.

1793
02:45:01.263 --> 02:45:02.228
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1794
02:45:02.711 --> 02:45:04.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1795
02:45:04.886 --> 02:45:05.980
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. President.

1796
02:45:07.445 --> 02:45:25.620
<v Loretta Smith>I was looking at this and I'm at the point, Councilor Green, that we need to get a handle on what the Portland Housing Bureau is doing, period, before giving them any additional, um, things to do, because I'm not clear that they're doing what they need to do right now, especially with the challenges they've had.

1797
02:45:25.814 --> 02:45:30.738
<v Loretta Smith>And so putting some more responsibility over there, that's not what we need to be doing.

1798
02:45:31.493 --> 02:45:37.379
<v Loretta Smith>Um, Prosper Portland is capable and able To do this.

1799
02:45:38.630 --> 02:45:47.033
<v Loretta Smith>And the governance and boosting up, we can't boost a whole lot up right now because people are losing their jobs.

1800
02:45:47.242 --> 02:46:00.504
<v Loretta Smith>So I don't know how we boost up a bureau or any bureau in this city until we get a handle on how we fill our gaps in our budget and until we can bring some more revenue in.

1801
02:46:01.082 --> 02:46:02.108
<v Loretta Smith>We need different revenue sources.

1802
02:46:02.172 --> 02:46:02.620
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1803
02:46:03.328 --> 02:46:13.495
<v Loretta Smith>To be able to boost up any office existing or new or plans to expand any other bureaus in the City of Portland.

1804
02:46:13.545 --> 02:46:15.511
<v Loretta Smith>So I will be voting no for this.

1805
02:46:16.950 --> 02:46:17.501
<v Loretta Smith>I hear you.

1806
02:46:18.846 --> 02:46:19.254
<v Loretta Smith>I'm—.

1807
02:46:19.254 --> 02:46:22.728
<v Loretta Smith>I hear you, but now is not the time.

1808
02:46:24.888 --> 02:46:25.593
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1809
02:46:26.283 --> 02:46:27.005
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

1810
02:46:28.551 --> 02:46:29.659
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1811
02:46:29.900 --> 02:46:47.861
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, colleagues, I kind of want us to think back to just a few months ago when the news came out about the Made in Old Town controversy with Prosper Portland and how Prosper Portland had mismanaged funds by spending, uh, giving a $7 million loan for a sneaker company.

1812
02:46:48.055 --> 02:46:52.596
<v Angelita Morillo>And then it turns out that the building was only appraised for, I think it was close to $4 million.

1813
02:46:52.773 --> 02:47:01.185
<v Angelita Morillo>So they got millions more than was needed due to Prior relationships that were established there in ways that are not fully vetted.

1814
02:47:02.583 --> 02:47:16.102
<v Angelita Morillo>When we have— we as a city council have no direct oversight on Prosper or how they use their funding, and that puts us in a really precarious position when we are not able to do any oversight whatsoever.

1815
02:47:16.697 --> 02:47:16.906
<v Angelita Morillo>We—.

1816
02:47:17.515 --> 02:47:21.450
<v Angelita Morillo>They can make mistakes, and the city is going to be in the position of footing the bill.

1817
02:47:21.530 --> 02:47:21.898
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Koyama Lane.

1818
02:47:22.333 --> 02:47:29.016
<v Angelita Morillo>And then not only that, but we don't even have the power to retroactively look at those mistakes and do oversight and correct them in the future.

1819
02:47:29.899 --> 02:47:44.296
<v Angelita Morillo>So if we don't have a mechanism for doing any oversight on Prosper, that's going to put us in a really bad position, and we are going to be handling the payments for their mistakes with our taxpayer dollars because that's how we're funded.

1820
02:47:44.842 --> 02:47:47.653
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think it's really important that we do vote this amendment through.

1821
02:47:47.701 --> 02:47:48.568
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Smith, I think we have a motion to table.

1822
02:47:49.208 --> 02:47:55.681
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think as other folks have stated, you know, the Housing Bureau and Prosper are both going through staffing changes.

1823
02:47:55.745 --> 02:47:58.014
<v Angelita Morillo>So there's going to be struggles on either end.

1824
02:47:58.305 --> 02:48:04.029
<v Angelita Morillo>But at least we as council can exercise our oversight authority to make sure that those dollars are spent appropriately.

1825
02:48:05.869 --> 02:48:16.322
<v Angelita Morillo>And I don't bring up the Made in Old Town thing to like throw anyone under the bus publicly, but that is a big thing that happened that we can't just brush aside when we're talking about millions of dollars.

1826
02:48:16.388 --> 02:48:17.111
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Smith, I think you're Yes.

1827
02:48:17.754 --> 02:48:24.752
<v Angelita Morillo>They got like $4 million extra that was not needed, and that, that can't be responsible governance on our end.

1828
02:48:24.816 --> 02:48:31.588
<v Angelita Morillo>So because of that, and because we have such limited oversight over how Prosper does things, I think that we do need to rein that in a bit.

1829
02:48:32.183 --> 02:48:46.925
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, and I will be supportive of the amendment overall, and I, I hope that this council is just more interested in doing oversight moving forward because I feel like we are relinquishing some of our core powers when we do this.

1830
02:48:47.118 --> 02:48:48.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that's it.

1831
02:48:49.281 --> 02:48:51.043
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1832
02:48:51.269 --> 02:48:52.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I put myself in the queue.

1833
02:48:52.967 --> 02:48:57.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will say I am supportive of the principle of what this amendment is trying to do.

1834
02:48:57.694 --> 02:49:08.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I will tell you that DCA Oliveira's concerns about capacity are very real, and he wouldn't come up and say it publicly if it weren't probably already past the point where it is too Thank you.

1835
02:49:08.752 --> 02:49:10.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for the few folks at the PHB.

1836
02:49:11.546 --> 02:49:22.846
<v Jamie Dunphy>But to that end, I do have some concerns about the fact that— well, first I'd like to just sort of say the state of Oregon does the underwriting of this, but the city of Portland backs the loan.

1837
02:49:24.083 --> 02:49:38.547
<v Jamie Dunphy>Prosper won't be making any of the decisions on the specific loan terms, and the state is the one that gets to make the final call on which of these projects is actually— I think it's worth— I don't know a lot about finance, and so I'm just trying to state these things very clearly for myself.

1838
02:49:38.659 --> 02:49:39.109
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1839
02:49:39.173 --> 02:49:45.965
<v Jamie Dunphy>But the concern I have is, and I have a lot of faith in our— the new Prosper director, Cornell Wesley.

1840
02:49:46.141 --> 02:49:48.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think he's moving this bureau in the right direction.

1841
02:49:48.148 --> 02:49:53.656
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I do have worries about separating our low-income housing from our moderate-income housing programs.

1842
02:49:53.768 --> 02:50:15.292
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have worries about the fact that if the city is backing the loan, but we can't— we don't necessarily have direct insight into what Prosper's decision-making process is or the other documents that they are considering, That leaves us in a precarious position and also leaves us in a financially precarious position because Prosper is not capital C City of Portland government.

1843
02:50:18.051 --> 02:50:23.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I think that the right place for housing loans and housing programs should be the Housing Bureau.

1844
02:50:23.418 --> 02:50:26.134
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I also definitely hear that there is capacity issues.

1845
02:50:26.245 --> 02:50:30.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>I suspect based on the conversations that this doesn't have the votes to pass.

1846
02:50:31.683 --> 02:50:32.511
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we should move forward.

1847
02:50:32.559 --> 02:50:33.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is 4:45.

1848
02:50:33.209 --> 02:50:33.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1849
02:50:35.275 --> 02:50:39.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I do think that fundamentally we should not be duplicating kinds of projects.

1850
02:50:39.792 --> 02:50:43.795
<v Jamie Dunphy>We should really find out like what is somebody— what is a bureau's lane and put them in there.

1851
02:50:44.134 --> 02:50:47.927
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then it is up to us to right-size the staffing and resources.

1852
02:50:49.920 --> 02:50:50.497
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's all I have to say.

1853
02:50:50.593 --> 02:50:51.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

1854
02:50:52.441 --> 02:50:52.666
<v Steve Novick>Thanks.

1855
02:50:52.763 --> 02:50:57.342
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I mean, I think this is a— I appreciate the comments.

1856
02:50:57.406 --> 02:50:59.558
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate everything that you just said as well.

1857
02:50:59.659 --> 02:51:15.202
<v Sameer Kanal>Well, I mean, I, I don't know about prognostication as it relates to the, the, um, amendment or the underlying, but I, I know that this passing would give me the confidence in the underlying ordinance, um, which may be relevant to those who are counting.

1858
02:51:15.941 --> 02:51:21.051
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I, I'm very, very— this is the most important amendment I think that we've talked about.

1859
02:51:21.100 --> 02:51:29.165
<v Sameer Kanal>It's also the last one that I see right now, so I have no idea if, uh, there's another mechanism And to create that confidence in those who may not have it, like myself.

1860
02:51:29.582 --> 02:51:41.933
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do think that there's a conversation we have to have here because right now we have influence over, I think, one thing at Prosper, which is going to come to the Committee of the Whole at some point, which is appointing one member or reappointing a member to the board.

1861
02:51:43.298 --> 02:51:53.111
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's, I think, a really concerning lack of influence over an agency that we seem to be giving more and more and more Thank you.

1862
02:51:53.323 --> 02:51:57.486
<v Sameer Kanal>And I've had— there are times where I think that's important to do.

1863
02:51:58.445 --> 02:52:01.969
<v Sameer Kanal>I supported the Storefront Support Program being at Prosper, for example.

1864
02:52:02.422 --> 02:52:04.086
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a good use of Prosper.

1865
02:52:04.136 --> 02:52:08.578
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's not exclusively everything should go there or nothing should go there.

1866
02:52:08.627 --> 02:52:10.379
<v Sameer Kanal>It's that we should be thoughtful about this.

1867
02:52:10.893 --> 02:52:16.354
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think it's pretty obvious to me that it's a better fit at the Portland Housing Bureau.

1868
02:52:16.997 --> 02:52:32.176
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that the second Part of that chronologically is how do we ensure the capacity is, is there necessarily to support the work and sort of address the concern that has been raised by the Deputy City Administrator?

1869
02:52:32.226 --> 02:52:38.218
<v Sameer Kanal>Because I do think that's worth, worth addressing, even if we don't put more work there, but certainly if we do.

1870
02:52:38.510 --> 02:52:38.688
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1871
02:52:39.076 --> 02:52:40.356
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1872
02:52:40.859 --> 02:52:41.328
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1873
02:52:43.144 --> 02:52:56.504
<v Loretta Smith>And I also just want to add the fact that, um, when you give the money to the Portland Housing Bureau, they're not going to have access to other resources that, that, um, Prosper Portland has, because it's not going to be just like one and done.

1874
02:52:56.568 --> 02:53:02.882
<v Loretta Smith>They're going to have to probably put a capital stack with it, and we don't have that extra capital stack that they have over at Prosper.

1875
02:53:03.620 --> 02:53:11.070
<v Loretta Smith>So, I mean, they're not prepared for this, and, um, I'll be asking all of you to, to pass on this and vote no.

1876
02:53:11.135 --> 02:53:11.246
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1877
02:53:12.898 --> 02:53:13.686
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1878
02:53:14.120 --> 02:53:14.891
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1879
02:53:21.995 --> 02:53:30.984
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I heard the amendment sponsor talk about being concerned about creating a revolving loan at Prosper and not at the city.

1880
02:53:31.566 --> 02:53:58.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, is there anybody there who is able to speak to what power we have as council through our budget role with Prosper to move programs between Prosper and the city and carry the dollars that go with those programs from Prosper back to the city, should we develop a loan program at Prosper and decide that we want it in the Housing Bureau a few years from now when the capacity exists?

1881
02:53:59.965 --> 02:54:02.934
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's see, is there anybody here who could speak to the legality of that?

1882
02:54:05.393 --> 02:54:07.208
<v Chido Dilawayo>DC Oliveira, would you like to come up?

1883
02:54:12.180 --> 02:54:13.737
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, Donnie Oliveira for the record.

1884
02:54:13.962 --> 02:54:32.263
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, Councilor, the question that you asked, I'm, I'm not going to speak to the housing program for a second, but the, the conditions by which the city, uh, could work with Prosper to bring a program with resources from Prosper to the city, or in that same manner from the city to Prosper, uh, is being discussed.

1885
02:54:32.832 --> 02:54:34.629
<v Donnie Oliveira>Like, what's the process to do that?

1886
02:54:34.997 --> 02:54:38.030
<v Donnie Oliveira>So the answer is yes, we are contemplating what that structure would look like.

1887
02:54:38.447 --> 02:54:40.917
<v Donnie Oliveira>It doesn't necessarily even have to be a budget action.

1888
02:54:41.013 --> 02:54:42.474
<v Donnie Oliveira>It could be an IGA.

1889
02:54:42.618 --> 02:54:46.275
<v Donnie Oliveira>But we're working with the City Attorney's Office on that, talking about a different program.

1890
02:54:47.431 --> 02:54:50.591
<v Donnie Oliveira>I just want to flag 2 things for this conversation.

1891
02:54:50.799 --> 02:54:58.628
<v Donnie Oliveira>There's a lot of merit to the questions that councilors may have brought about oversight of PROSPER, organizationally where resources belong to do these programs.

1892
02:54:58.692 --> 02:54:58.965
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

1893
02:54:59.542 --> 02:55:03.684
<v Donnie Oliveira>What's the role of Prosper versus housing when it comes to housing production?

1894
02:55:04.102 --> 02:55:09.207
<v Donnie Oliveira>Those are all valid things that we're contemplating in the administration and things that this council should discuss as well.

1895
02:55:10.122 --> 02:55:24.361
<v Donnie Oliveira>What I want to flag, and I believe Councilor Avalos said this most eloquently, is the program that we're talking about right now is very short-term and largely, and I think Councilor President, you said this as well, the administration of it is a pass-through function where the state really is the loaner.

1896
02:55:24.441 --> 02:55:25.918
<v Donnie Oliveira>Like, they're the ones providing the resources.

1897
02:55:26.433 --> 02:55:29.822
<v Donnie Oliveira>The administrator, whether it's Prosper or Housing Bureau, is doing the pass-through.

1898
02:55:29.886 --> 02:55:31.299
<v Donnie Oliveira>Still administration work, still a lot of work.

1899
02:55:31.427 --> 02:55:36.728
<v Donnie Oliveira>I don't want to minimize it, but it's less financial burden from a decision-making perspective.

1900
02:55:36.792 --> 02:55:38.157
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor Murillo, you are right.

1901
02:55:38.478 --> 02:55:46.862
<v Donnie Oliveira>The city will ultimately back these loans, whether it be through TIF or other mechanisms, but the program itself is largely short time.

1902
02:55:47.377 --> 02:55:51.986
<v Donnie Oliveira>What we're hoping to do is focus the PHB staff on those longer-term programs that councilors are seeking.

1903
02:55:52.436 --> 02:56:02.280
<v Donnie Oliveira>Rent buydown, the revolving loan, et cetera, and allow Prosper to do this work because, A, it's in their portfolio today and it is a more timely lift.

1904
02:56:02.666 --> 02:56:07.917
<v Donnie Oliveira>So hopefully that answers your question, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, and the underlying question about oversight.

1905
02:56:09.375 --> 02:56:09.825
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It does.

1906
02:56:09.938 --> 02:56:10.227
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1907
02:56:10.325 --> 02:56:16.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think it gives me the assurance that I need to move forward as things are drafted, especially given the short-term nature of this program.

1908
02:56:17.184 --> 02:56:30.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do think it is important Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1909
02:56:30.250 --> 02:56:30.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Knoll.

1910
02:56:30.250 --> 02:56:33.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, DC Oliveira, I'm just— I think it's important that we have a clear path to do that.

1911
02:56:33.450 --> 02:56:37.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If not, I think council may need to help weigh in there as well at some point.

1912
02:56:37.590 --> 02:56:38.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1913
02:56:38.829 --> 02:56:40.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1914
02:56:40.370 --> 02:56:41.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

1915
02:56:41.709 --> 02:56:44.610
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, DC Oliveira, I'm just— I think it's important that I'm we have a clear path to do gonna that.

1916
02:56:44.967 --> 02:56:45.495
<v Sameer Kanal>Ask one more.

1917
02:56:45.703 --> 02:56:48.028
<v Jamie Dunphy>I moonwalk back up.

1918
02:56:48.364 --> 02:56:48.718
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry.

1919
02:56:48.974 --> 02:56:49.808
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, thank you.

1920
02:56:50.336 --> 02:56:52.421
<v Sameer Kanal>We had the same conversation like a year ago.

1921
02:56:52.820 --> 02:56:52.933
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1922
02:56:53.381 --> 02:56:57.629
<v Sameer Kanal>And there's been nothing from the administration yet to resolve the underlying issue about oversight.

1923
02:56:58.111 --> 02:57:03.096
<v Sameer Kanal>So can we expect that there's going to be some— or I shouldn't say oversight, democratic accountability?

1924
02:57:03.817 --> 02:57:16.530
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there, is there anything in the works that we can, that we can look forward to from the administration, or is this something where we're gonna Because again, if we've, we've had this conversation, if we don't get something, it becomes a blunt instrument conversation.

1925
02:57:16.706 --> 02:57:16.818
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure.

1926
02:57:17.186 --> 02:57:20.281
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's what we have available to us.

1927
02:57:20.969 --> 02:57:27.270
<v Sameer Kanal>Can we look forward to literally anything coming out of the administration related to democratic accountability?

1928
02:57:28.167 --> 02:57:30.941
<v Donnie Oliveira>Regarding democratic accountability, Councilor, thank you for the question.

1929
02:57:31.085 --> 02:57:31.149
<v Donnie Oliveira>I—.

1930
02:57:31.614 --> 02:57:48.079
<v Donnie Oliveira>It is absolutely a conversation that needs to happen on this dais related to what, what our existing structure is like the functional, like how Prosper exists, you know, a redevelopment agency in the city of Portland, what it does, this, this body's oversight of it through the budget process and not.

1931
02:57:48.611 --> 02:57:57.208
<v Donnie Oliveira>I was referring to questions that we've been contemplating on the, the second part that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney asked about moving programs over and what the mechanisms are for that.

1932
02:57:57.546 --> 02:58:04.976
<v Donnie Oliveira>Your question though is clearly about what is this body's role in oversight of basically programmatic functions of the agency, correct?

1933
02:58:05.040 --> 02:58:05.168
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yes.

1934
02:58:05.782 --> 02:58:10.628
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that needs to be discussed foundationally, what it is today and what it could be.

1935
02:58:10.852 --> 02:58:13.819
<v Sameer Kanal>I mean, that and Main and Old Town type of situation.

1936
02:58:14.125 --> 02:58:14.766
<v Sameer Kanal>I mean, I think—.

1937
02:58:14.766 --> 02:58:15.327
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm sorry.

1938
02:58:15.584 --> 02:58:16.899
<v Sameer Kanal>The Main and Old Town situation.

1939
02:58:17.236 --> 02:58:17.317
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah.

1940
02:58:17.718 --> 02:58:21.584
<v Donnie Oliveira>And this is also where you've alluded to it, the appointment of a board.

1941
02:58:21.648 --> 02:58:25.307
<v Donnie Oliveira>Prosper has a public body that makes these decisions as well.

1942
02:58:25.370 --> 02:58:33.975
<v Donnie Oliveira>So in a lot of ways, that body functions publicly as a government agency that is— or entity, excuse me, That is making decisions on behalf of the public dollar.

1943
02:58:34.234 --> 02:58:38.941
<v Donnie Oliveira>Not this council, of course, but that, that's another place where public oversight happens.

1944
02:58:41.781 --> 02:58:41.976
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1945
02:58:42.670 --> 02:58:43.412
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1946
02:58:43.557 --> 02:58:44.024
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1947
02:58:45.090 --> 02:58:45.477
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1948
02:58:45.655 --> 02:58:52.926
<v Loretta Smith>Um, thank you, DCA Alavarado, because I was going to bring up again Prosper Portland has their own board that they have to adhere to.

1949
02:58:53.056 --> 02:59:05.351
<v Loretta Smith>Anything that changes or anything, any scope of work that has to go through their board The only thing that we do is appoint a, um, an executive director, and that's done out of the mayor's office.

1950
02:59:05.399 --> 02:59:07.940
<v Loretta Smith>So I think we, we need to stay in our lane, y'all.

1951
02:59:08.134 --> 02:59:12.784
<v Loretta Smith>We got enough stuff to do over here that we don't have under control yet before we start trying to mess with Prosper.

1952
02:59:13.012 --> 02:59:13.887
<v Loretta Smith>Just let it go.

1953
02:59:15.105 --> 02:59:15.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1954
02:59:17.605 --> 02:59:26.935
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, seeing no one else in the queue, Rebecca, can we please move to a roll call vote on Green Green 4, moved by Green, seconded by Kanal.

1955
02:59:27.796 --> 02:59:28.217
<v Rebecca Dobert>Kanal?

1956
02:59:28.979 --> 02:59:29.012
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1957
02:59:29.334 --> 02:59:29.947
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

1958
02:59:35.525 --> 02:59:35.960
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absent.

1959
02:59:36.009 --> 02:59:36.316
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

1960
02:59:36.429 --> 02:59:37.200
<v Rebecca Dobert>She's coming online.

1961
02:59:37.475 --> 02:59:37.843
<v Rebecca Dobert>Oh, sorry.

1962
02:59:39.162 --> 02:59:39.644
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney?

1963
02:59:42.200 --> 02:59:44.835
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, no.

1964
02:59:46.246 --> 02:59:47.200
<v Rebecca Dobert>Pirtle-Guiney is a no.

1965
02:59:49.356 --> 02:59:49.733
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ryan?

1966
02:59:50.092 --> 02:59:50.174
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1967
02:59:52.216 --> 02:59:52.836
<v Rebecca Dobert>Koyama Lane?

1968
02:59:53.180 --> 02:59:53.197
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1969
02:59:54.453 --> 02:59:54.972
<v Rebecca Dobert>Murillo?

1970
02:59:55.863 --> 02:59:55.912
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1971
02:59:57.921 --> 02:59:58.390
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick?

1972
02:59:59.524 --> 03:00:06.637
<v Steve Novick>In light of Mr. Oliveira's comment that this is a limited-time program, and I think that the mural should live short and prosper.

1973
03:00:10.085 --> 03:00:10.586
<v Rebecca Dobert>Wow.

1974
03:00:11.218 --> 03:00:12.447
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's terrible.

1975
03:00:16.995 --> 03:00:17.888
<v Rebecca Dobert>Novick is nay.

1976
03:00:18.619 --> 03:00:18.959
<v Rebecca Dobert>Clark?

1977
03:00:19.772 --> 03:00:20.065
<v Olivia Clark>No.

1978
03:00:21.218 --> 03:00:21.510
<v Rebecca Dobert>Green?

1979
03:00:22.013 --> 03:00:22.143
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1980
03:00:23.425 --> 03:00:23.864
<v Rebecca Dobert>Zimmerman?

1981
03:00:24.382 --> 03:00:24.674
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1982
03:00:25.983 --> 03:00:26.370
<v Rebecca Dobert>Avalos?

1983
03:00:27.453 --> 03:00:27.697
<v Candace Avalos>No.

1984
03:00:29.459 --> 03:00:29.846
<v Rebecca Dobert>Smith?

1985
03:00:31.075 --> 03:00:31.254
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1986
03:00:33.015 --> 03:00:33.324
<v Rebecca Dobert>Dunphy?

1987
03:00:35.398 --> 03:00:35.431
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1988
03:00:35.930 --> 03:00:39.086
<v Rebecca Dobert>The amendment fails with 5 aye, 7 no votes.

1989
03:00:40.617 --> 03:00:43.996
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing No other amendments proposed.

1990
03:00:44.077 --> 03:00:45.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there further discussion of this item?

1991
03:00:50.559 --> 03:00:54.013
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

1992
03:00:54.528 --> 03:00:55.235
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, thank you all.

1993
03:00:55.331 --> 03:00:59.588
<v Candace Avalos>I just want to appreciate the conversation that we have had over this.

1994
03:00:59.734 --> 03:01:07.119
<v Candace Avalos>I think that the things that we're wrestling with right now are exactly what I'm hoping we can start to get some clarity about.

1995
03:01:07.637 --> 03:01:24.977
<v Candace Avalos>As a council, I'm really grateful to housing committee members who engaged in a great discussion on Tuesday about the progress of the unified housing strategy and where— what we're going to be bringing to council is a discussion about what we need to prioritize, what's most important.

1996
03:01:25.379 --> 03:01:32.844
<v Candace Avalos>And it is nitty-gritty, it's wonky like the conversation that we had, but I just want to emphasize the importance of that.

1997
03:01:33.165 --> 03:01:40.938
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that the city will appreciate us wrestling with this.

1998
03:01:41.033 --> 03:01:43.613
<v Candace Avalos>And so I just want to encourage us to keep doing that.

1999
03:01:43.677 --> 03:01:58.676
<v Candace Avalos>And I also say that because I think honestly I'm pretty shook by the polling data, and I think we need to really work hard to show Portlanders that we are serious about making responsible policy decisions that are going to move housing production forward.

2000
03:01:58.725 --> 03:01:58.949
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2001
03:01:59.365 --> 03:02:08.287
<v Candace Avalos>Forward, that we're going to address these governance issues that absolutely need to be addressed as we're creating, you know, continuing to stand up our form of government.

2002
03:02:08.912 --> 03:02:16.291
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm really looking to my colleagues to bring those ideas to the table, and let's create more space for that.

2003
03:02:17.013 --> 03:02:28.022
<v Candace Avalos>Obviously, Housing Committee is one place for that, but something I want to talk to Council President and Councilor Kanal about really elevating more in maybe Committee of the Whole because it is— it affects all of us.

2004
03:02:28.505 --> 03:02:34.200
<v Candace Avalos>It's all of our, you know, top priorities in lots of ways, and I'm just really grateful for that discussion.

2005
03:02:34.329 --> 03:02:37.462
<v Candace Avalos>Even where there's disagreements, I think we're moving something forward that's positive.

2006
03:02:37.512 --> 03:02:38.388
<v Candace Avalos>So I wanted to say that.

2007
03:02:38.469 --> 03:02:38.972
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

2008
03:02:39.038 --> 03:02:40.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

2009
03:02:42.951 --> 03:02:47.877
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, this item is a non-emergency ordinance, moves now to second reading.

2010
03:02:49.542 --> 03:02:54.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>And colleagues, it is currently We have 2 additional items regarding the Mt.

2011
03:02:54.628 --> 03:02:58.956
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hood Cable Regulatory Commission and Cable Franchise Fund.

2012
03:02:59.277 --> 03:03:00.527
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are not going to be able to get to this.

2013
03:03:00.622 --> 03:03:11.266
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am going to continue these 2 items to the next available agenda, which is likely 2 weeks out because next week we are doing our final votes on the budget.

2014
03:03:12.197 --> 03:03:17.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I will be continuing document number 2026-175 and document 2026-176.

2015
03:03:17.790 --> 03:03:17.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2016
03:03:25.275 --> 03:03:33.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're just so late that—.

2017
03:03:34.790 --> 03:03:35.299
<v Loretta Smith>I know.

