WEBVTT

1
00:03:51.837 --> 00:03:52.519
<v Candace Avalos>Good afternoon.

2
00:03:52.712 --> 00:03:56.444
<v Candace Avalos>I am going to call the meeting of— oh, Nope, let's figure out what's going on there.

3
00:04:00.030 --> 00:04:00.497
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, try again.

4
00:04:00.902 --> 00:04:08.694
<v Candace Avalos>Good afternoon, I'm going to call the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee to order on Tuesday, June 2nd at 2:03 PM.

5
00:04:08.905 --> 00:04:09.796
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, please call the roll.

6
00:04:10.680 --> 00:04:11.318
<v Diego>Good afternoon.

7
00:04:11.676 --> 00:04:12.217
<v Diego>Pirtle-Guiney?

8
00:04:14.358 --> 00:04:14.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absent.

9
00:04:15.159 --> 00:04:15.566
<v Diego>Koyama Lane?

10
00:04:16.004 --> 00:04:16.281
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

11
00:04:17.158 --> 00:04:17.694
<v Diego>Novick?

12
00:04:20.050 --> 00:04:20.295
<v Steve Novick>Absent.

13
00:04:21.430 --> 00:04:21.767
<v Jessie Connor>Green?

14
00:04:22.252 --> 00:04:22.363
<v Mitch Green>Here.

15
00:04:22.911 --> 00:04:23.201
<v Diego>Avalos?

16
00:04:23.701 --> 00:04:24.040
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

17
00:04:25.168 --> 00:04:26.845
<v Candace Avalos>Claire, can you please read the statement of conduct?

18
00:04:29.050 --> 00:04:29.403
<v Claire>Thank you, Chair.

19
00:04:29.869 --> 00:04:32.504
<v Claire>Good afternoon and welcome to the meeting of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

20
00:04:32.939 --> 00:04:43.396
<v Claire>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at portland.gov/council/agenda/housingandpermittingcommittee or by calling 311.

21
00:04:44.139 --> 00:04:47.108
<v Claire>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

22
00:04:47.552 --> 00:04:50.411
<v Claire>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

23
00:04:50.990 --> 00:04:55.956
<v Claire>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

24
00:04:56.470 --> 00:04:58.237
<v Claire>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

25
00:04:58.961 --> 00:04:59.925
<v Claire>The chair preserves order.

26
00:05:00.165 --> 00:05:07.766
<v Claire>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

27
00:05:08.601 --> 00:05:10.336
<v Claire>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

28
00:05:10.915 --> 00:05:13.149
<v Claire>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

29
00:05:13.567 --> 00:05:16.523
<v Claire>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

30
00:05:17.136 --> 00:05:19.848
<v Claire>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

31
00:05:20.752 --> 00:05:22.511
<v Claire>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

32
00:05:22.928 --> 00:05:24.761
<v Claire>When testifying, please state your name for the record.

33
00:05:25.259 --> 00:05:27.620
<v Claire>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

34
00:05:28.007 --> 00:05:31.317
<v Claire>And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

35
00:05:31.461 --> 00:05:31.850
<v Claire>Thank you.

36
00:05:33.401 --> 00:05:34.146
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Claire.

37
00:05:34.939 --> 00:05:37.202
<v Candace Avalos>All right, we have 3 items on today's agenda.

38
00:05:37.283 --> 00:05:43.007
<v Candace Avalos>First, we'll have some time for public comment, as we always do at the top of the hour, on housing and permitting issues of concern or interest.

39
00:05:43.057 --> 00:05:49.867
<v Candace Avalos>Then we will We will hear progress reports on the continued work of the Unified Housing Strategy and the Social Housing Study.

40
00:05:50.461 --> 00:05:54.814
<v Candace Avalos>And for the second half of the meeting, we will consider the latest RECAP code improvement package.

41
00:05:55.440 --> 00:05:57.689
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, let's move to— can you call item 1?

42
00:05:58.879 --> 00:06:01.963
<v Diego>Item 1, Housing and Permitting Community Feedback.

43
00:06:02.588 --> 00:06:08.901
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so we're going to hear from community members on their areas of concerns or feedback, and each testifier will have 3 minutes.

44
00:06:09.254 --> 00:06:10.701
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, go ahead and call up the first person.

45
00:06:11.680 --> 00:06:13.622
<v Diego>We have 4 individuals signed up.

46
00:06:14.187 --> 00:06:19.540
<v Diego>First up is Robert Taylor, who— excuse me, Robert Pyle, who will join us online shortly.

47
00:06:20.487 --> 00:06:26.160
<v Diego>David Straub, Benjamin Gilbert, Virginia Hammond.

48
00:06:27.220 --> 00:06:29.995
<v Diego>Robert, feel free to unmute yourself and begin when you're ready.

49
00:06:32.689 --> 00:06:33.336
<v Robert Pyle>Great, thank you.

50
00:06:33.802 --> 00:06:35.579
<v Robert Pyle>Good afternoon, Council.

51
00:06:36.636 --> 00:06:38.466
<v Robert Pyle>I've spoken with most of you present about this.

52
00:06:38.658 --> 00:06:41.903
<v Robert Pyle>Unfortunately, I don't have the others here today, but for the record, my name is Robert Pyle.

53
00:06:42.031 --> 00:06:43.959
<v Robert Pyle>I'm the principal of Oakleaf Redevelopment.

54
00:06:44.586 --> 00:06:59.040
<v Robert Pyle>I wanted to take this opportunity in advance of the City Council meeting on Thursday, where the full council will hear the first reading of the moderate income revolving loan ordinance, to ask you again to remove the minimum unit requirement and the mixed-use preference and to support Councilor Green's amendments.

55
00:06:59.843 --> 00:07:05.721
<v Robert Pyle>A 20-unit minimum excludes missing middle multifamily housing projects of 5 to 19 units for no discernible reason.

56
00:07:06.442 --> 00:07:17.127
<v Robert Pyle>Any project of more than approximately 30 units will trigger BOLI prevailing wage requirements, adding 20 to 35% to the construction costs, creating additional gaps to fill in project feasibility.

57
00:07:18.139 --> 00:07:27.139
<v Robert Pyle>Cottage clusters and townhomes are specifically eligible housing types under the MRL program, which adopts the definition of middle housing in ORS 197A.

58
00:07:28.101 --> 00:07:35.048
<v Robert Pyle>Thompson Springs in Tillamook County is a 10-unit cottage cluster of 4-sale homes featuring universal design.

59
00:07:36.444 --> 00:07:42.521
<v Robert Pyle>Designed for buyers in the 80 to 120% AMI range and is intending to utilize the MRL program.

60
00:07:43.740 --> 00:07:48.439
<v Robert Pyle>Every MRL loan comes with a 5% administration fee paid to the sponsoring jurisdiction.

61
00:07:49.353 --> 00:07:56.665
<v Robert Pyle>For a $750,000 loan funding approximately 30 units, that's a fee value of approximately $50,000 into the general fund.

62
00:07:57.916 --> 00:08:01.637
<v Robert Pyle>District 1 specifically has the fewest tools for these smaller infill projects.

63
00:08:02.007 --> 00:08:08.153
<v Robert Pyle>As most areas are ineligible for the multi-program, which accompanies inclusionary housing requirements for projects of 20 units or more.

64
00:08:09.649 --> 00:08:13.466
<v Robert Pyle>In 2025, 1,600 units were submitted for permit.

65
00:08:13.966 --> 00:08:16.625
<v Robert Pyle>Our official city goal is 6,000 per year.

66
00:08:18.795 --> 00:08:27.249
<v Robert Pyle>I have emailed a memo to all of your offices containing more details, but please do not limit the potential of this tool to help us close that gap even a little bit.

67
00:08:27.872 --> 00:08:28.194
<v Robert Pyle>Thank you.

68
00:08:32.768 --> 00:08:33.668
<v Candace Avalos>Next up.

69
00:08:36.567 --> 00:08:38.100
<v Benjamin Gilbert>Hello, my name is Benjamin Gilbert.

70
00:08:38.278 --> 00:08:43.823
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I am a tenant in District 4, a volunteer lobbyist for the Portland DSA, and I'm speaking on my own behalf today.

71
00:08:44.890 --> 00:08:47.445
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I want to take this opportunity today to speak about social housing.

72
00:08:48.121 --> 00:08:51.993
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I had the privilege of joining a group of Oregonians on a trip to Vienna to study social housing.

73
00:08:52.717 --> 00:08:54.315
<v Benjamin Gilbert>We all went into this trip with expectations.

74
00:08:55.066 --> 00:09:00.264
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I expected to see what I understood to be one of the most successful social housing systems in the world.

75
00:09:01.001 --> 00:09:04.355
<v Benjamin Gilbert>However, I also knew that like any system, there would be a myriad of complexities.

76
00:09:04.788 --> 00:09:14.221
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I knew the stats, that 80% of the city's population were tenants, that the average rents in the city were affordable, and that 60% of the population lived in some form of social housing.

77
00:09:15.296 --> 00:09:21.215
<v Benjamin Gilbert>All of these expectations couldn't have prepared me for the experience of actually seeing the city and speaking with its people.

78
00:09:21.777 --> 00:09:26.014
<v Benjamin Gilbert>To be in a city where housing is not merely a commodity, but a public good, was eye-opening.

79
00:09:26.528 --> 00:09:30.205
<v Benjamin Gilbert>To walk around a city whose residents were housed and not sleeping on the street was comforting.

80
00:09:31.024 --> 00:09:41.186
<v Benjamin Gilbert>A city where a zip code does not correlate with your income and where all residents, not just citizens, after 2 years of residency, including refugees, are eligible for social housing was incredible.

81
00:09:42.245 --> 00:09:47.928
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I have heard explanations for why we are in a housing crisis, like overregulation and prevailing wage.

82
00:09:49.085 --> 00:09:56.393
<v Benjamin Gilbert>But Vienna has over 98% of construction workers covered by collective bargaining agreements and a system of regulations far more thorough than what we have here.

83
00:09:57.131 --> 00:10:07.089
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I have heard how social housing won't work here or how it is too expensive, but Vienna spends less money on housing than our metro area spends on homelessness by a lot, and we're in a country that is far more wealthy.

84
00:10:08.278 --> 00:10:17.340
<v Benjamin Gilbert>It was eye-opening to learn that the shortest lease term in the system was 3 years and that the Chamber for Workers and Employees, a national org that represents all workers in Austria, believed Councilmember Smith.

85
00:10:17.340 --> 00:10:17.340
<v Jessie Connor>I would like to thank the committee for this report.

86
00:10:17.340 --> 00:10:20.690
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I agree with the committee that in order to protect the rights of workers, that that should be extended to 5 years.

87
00:10:21.440 --> 00:10:26.500
<v Benjamin Gilbert>I could keep talking about the amazing work that has been done in Vienna, but I want to communicate what we can apply here in Portland.

88
00:10:26.940 --> 00:10:34.440
<v Benjamin Gilbert>Firstly, it is crucial that we examine cost-based models for setting rent, especially in a system like the limited-profit housing associations of the Austrian model.

89
00:10:34.440 --> 00:10:38.700
<v Benjamin Gilbert>Second, we should build a strong foundation of municipally owned and operated social housing.

90
00:10:38.700 --> 00:10:45.370
<v Benjamin Gilbert>Third, we need a strong foundation of tenants' rights that privilege the right to housing over the ability of landlords to extract wealth from tenants.

91
00:10:45.738 --> 00:10:51.289
<v Benjamin Gilbert>And finally, we need to make sure that this social housing is for the many, not just for those who are most in need.

92
00:10:51.967 --> 00:11:00.417
<v Benjamin Gilbert>In order for the system to have buy-in from the population and to avoid stigma, it must be free from means testing beyond the initial entrance and available to the majority of Portlanders.

93
00:11:01.014 --> 00:11:01.644
<v Benjamin Gilbert>Thank you for your time.

94
00:11:04.756 --> 00:11:06.932
<v Diego>We have Virginia Hammond online.

95
00:11:07.292 --> 00:11:09.417
<v Diego>Virginia, feel free to unmute and begin when you're ready.

96
00:11:11.121 --> 00:11:11.442
<v Virginia Hammond>Thank you.

97
00:11:11.587 --> 00:11:15.056
<v Virginia Hammond>My name is Virginia Hammond, and thank you for this opportunity to speak.

98
00:11:15.682 --> 00:11:19.648
<v Virginia Hammond>I am a homeowner in the Collins View neighborhood in South Portland.

99
00:11:20.177 --> 00:11:32.767
<v Virginia Hammond>I'm here to ask that you reconsider a planning and permitting decision and allow a creative and cost-free to the city solution that keeps developers and neighbors happy.

100
00:11:33.457 --> 00:11:35.865
<v Virginia Hammond>Our family bought our home in 1952.

101
00:11:36.475 --> 00:11:43.692
<v Virginia Hammond>About 50 years ago, our family and our neighbors put in and paid for clearing and graveling part of the road, Orchid Court.

102
00:11:44.493 --> 00:11:48.884
<v Virginia Hammond>At the time, the road was only a line on a map covered with grass and bushes.

103
00:11:49.395 --> 00:11:53.770
<v Virginia Hammond>The road left some 80 feet of the public right-of-way unmodified.

104
00:11:54.267 --> 00:11:57.855
<v Virginia Hammond>Today, this stretch has big laurels, holly trees, and grass.

105
00:11:58.528 --> 00:12:06.668
<v Virginia Hammond>Taking the road all the way through to the cross street, Palatine Hill Road, would require dropping down an embankment and present safety issues.

106
00:12:06.716 --> 00:12:06.924
<v Virginia Hammond>Thank you.

107
00:12:07.182 --> 00:12:13.421
<v Virginia Hammond>There's no need for this, and it is highly unlikely the city will ever consider completing the street.

108
00:12:14.062 --> 00:12:19.659
<v Virginia Hammond>While Orchid Court is on the city's maintain roster, so far the city hasn't done much.

109
00:12:19.772 --> 00:12:23.107
<v Virginia Hammond>There are 4 homes on the road and none of them have street parking.

110
00:12:23.846 --> 00:12:27.197
<v Virginia Hammond>There is a serious drainage issue that we have reported to the city.

111
00:12:27.774 --> 00:12:32.875
<v Virginia Hammond>The drainage issue and the one-lane width of the paving makes parking on the sides impossible.

112
00:12:33.083 --> 00:12:36.019
<v Virginia Hammond>In winter, they are muddy grass leaves and not level.

113
00:12:36.452 --> 00:12:39.408
<v Virginia Hammond>There is no street parking on this street.

114
00:12:40.052 --> 00:12:48.230
<v Virginia Hammond>At the unmodified end of the street, the city has approved a 5-cottage development with no parking, zero parking.

115
00:12:48.889 --> 00:13:00.200
<v Virginia Hammond>The developer presented plans that would have cleared the rest of the public road, about 80 feet of frontage, and graveled it so that the new homeowners would have a place to park their cars.

116
00:13:00.794 --> 00:13:02.160
<v Virginia Hammond>The city said no.

117
00:13:02.787 --> 00:13:13.131
<v Virginia Hammond>To these plans and is asking for a fee of roughly $60,000 from the developer to go into a fund that may or may not contribute to upgrading the street at some time in the future.

118
00:13:14.288 --> 00:13:19.395
<v Virginia Hammond>We accept the infill density, recognizing the need for additional housing in the city.

119
00:13:19.589 --> 00:13:23.250
<v Virginia Hammond>However, these new homeowners will surely need and want cars.

120
00:13:23.909 --> 00:13:30.239
<v Virginia Hammond>Public transportation access is a 10-minute walk, and then it takes another 25 minutes to get downtown.

121
00:13:30.817 --> 00:13:33.770
<v Virginia Hammond>A trip that takes a car about 10 minutes altogether.

122
00:13:34.428 --> 00:13:37.480
<v Virginia Hammond>The closest grocery stores are a 40-minute walk.

123
00:13:37.801 --> 00:13:44.850
<v Virginia Hammond>Realistically, these homes are going to have cars and will need to find someplace to park them, stressing out the whole neighborhood.

124
00:13:45.427 --> 00:13:55.928
<v Virginia Hammond>Please reconsider and permit the low-cost and creative use of this public space so that our neighborhood can remain a nice place to live.

125
00:13:56.811 --> 00:13:57.280
<v Virginia Hammond>Thank you.

126
00:14:00.054 --> 00:14:02.163
<v Diego>Once more for David Straub.

127
00:14:13.471 --> 00:14:14.337
<v David Straub>Good afternoon, councilors.

128
00:14:14.436 --> 00:14:15.238
<v David Straub>My name is David Straub.

129
00:14:16.370 --> 00:14:25.375
<v David Straub>I'm trying to find out, or I would like to have added to this social housing equation, behavioral wellness, and I'm trying to figure out why it It is already an element.

130
00:14:26.498 --> 00:14:39.635
<v David Straub>Back in January when we were nominating another person to the Home Forward board, I had noticed that everyone on there was real estate development oriented and there was no one mental healthcare or behavioral wellness oriented.

131
00:14:40.437 --> 00:14:41.610
<v David Straub>Now I opposed the nomination.

132
00:14:41.721 --> 00:14:44.706
<v David Straub>I knew it was more for just to communicate a message.

133
00:14:45.668 --> 00:14:50.929
<v David Straub>And now we look at the progress report for the social housing program and we seem to be doing the same thing.

134
00:14:51.346 --> 00:14:58.530
<v David Straub>I look at the, there's like, I don't know, a dozen people from Portland Housing Bureau, and they're all real estate development oriented.

135
00:14:59.258 --> 00:15:09.025
<v David Straub>And as I hear, you know, the testimony here and other comments, everyone seems to be focused on the financial and housing issues while no one really seems to be looking at the behavioral health issues.

136
00:15:09.620 --> 00:15:11.837
<v David Straub>I guess I'm just trying to figure out, first of all, why that is.

137
00:15:12.635 --> 00:15:16.235
<v David Straub>And the second part is to really impress upon you that that is really the solution.

138
00:15:17.793 --> 00:15:19.447
<v David Straub>We're never gonna build enough affordable housing.

139
00:15:19.880 --> 00:15:23.769
<v David Straub>We might be able to build some rental housing, probably not in time to deal with Councilor Dan Ryan.

140
00:15:23.769 --> 00:15:33.720
<v David Straub>While we have 16,000 people homeless right now, the solution in my mind is this Portland pilot program that you already have going on for home sharing, renting a room.

141
00:15:34.490 --> 00:15:46.500
<v David Straub>Now I understand that, you know, some people who are experiencing homelessness aren't ready to live in housing, but we need to find out who those people are because my experience is that the vast majority of them can get there.

142
00:15:46.929 --> 00:15:49.309
<v David Straub>I worked at one shelter for a month.

143
00:15:49.309 --> 00:15:51.669
<v David Straub>I worked at another shelter for 6 weeks.

144
00:15:51.850 --> 00:15:53.669
<v David Straub>It was more of a volunteer program and not something that was required.

145
00:15:55.243 --> 00:15:57.553
<v David Straub>But I was able to have an impact with a number of people.

146
00:15:58.051 --> 00:16:04.999
<v David Straub>A lot of them are capable of moving into housing, renting a room, if they're given some guidance.

147
00:16:06.057 --> 00:16:19.216
<v David Straub>And it would need to be a, what I'll call, wraparound service, meaning the landlords and potentially employers of these people would also need to have some type of behavioral wellness training, because in the end, they're going to need some long-term assistance and support.

148
00:16:19.938 --> 00:16:21.993
<v David Straub>But there is a way to educate people to do that.

149
00:16:22.886 --> 00:16:27.602
<v David Straub>And the key is here is that we have more than 300,000 homes in Portland.

150
00:16:28.442 --> 00:16:36.504
<v David Straub>If we start renting rooms, we could potentially end our homeless situation within 2 years if behavioral wellness is the solution.

151
00:16:37.337 --> 00:16:44.182
<v David Straub>If it's a financial problem or we keep looking at it as it is building homes versus building people, we're probably never gonna solve the problem.

152
00:16:44.793 --> 00:16:47.065
<v David Straub>We just don't have the resources to build enough housing.

153
00:16:47.130 --> 00:16:50.120
<v David Straub>We usually only build like 1,000 affordable units each year.

154
00:16:50.169 --> 00:16:50.465
<v Claire>Thank you.

155
00:16:50.735 --> 00:16:51.201
<v Benjamin Gilbert>Councilor Smith.

156
00:16:51.474 --> 00:17:03.148
<v David Straub>We, and we're kind of overtaxed already, so I'm not really sure how we're gonna be able to do this social housing program as it's currently envisioned, given the fact that we already don't have the money to do it.

157
00:17:04.159 --> 00:17:09.008
<v David Straub>Behavioral wellness can be done cheaply if done appropriately, and to me it's the real solution.

158
00:17:09.056 --> 00:17:15.847
<v David Straub>So I'm hoping that you will consider adding a behavioral wellness component to the equation for solving our housing issue here in Portland.

159
00:17:16.348 --> 00:17:16.709
<v David Straub>Thank you.

160
00:17:19.292 --> 00:17:20.422
<v Diego>That concludes testimony.

161
00:17:23.390 --> 00:17:34.019
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you to all of the folks that testified, and please do continue to, uh, come to committee and tell us your thoughts about housing policy during the first 15 minutes of each meeting.

162
00:17:34.761 --> 00:17:36.262
<v Candace Avalos>Diego, please call item 2.

163
00:17:37.747 --> 00:17:43.471
<v Diego>Item 2, Unified Housing Strategy Discussion and Brief Update on Social Housing Study.

164
00:17:44.116 --> 00:17:49.815
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so as staff start making their way up, I'll give some intro remarks to kind of frame what we're doing today.

165
00:17:50.698 --> 00:17:59.621
<v Candace Avalos>And thank you in advance to the PHB staff for the presentations that they put together today and for the tremendous amount of work that has gone into both of these efforts.

166
00:18:00.262 --> 00:18:09.171
<v Candace Avalos>I want to start by acknowledging that both the Unified Housing Strategy and the Social Housing Study originated from resolutions that I was proud to sponsor and that council adopted last year.

167
00:18:09.652 --> 00:18:17.233
<v Candace Avalos>And since then, I have had the opportunity to meet regularly with staff to discuss progress, review emerging ideas, and help move this work forward.

168
00:18:17.811 --> 00:18:22.076
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate the time and thoughtfulness and dedication staff has brought— have brought to these efforts.

169
00:18:22.797 --> 00:18:26.227
<v Candace Avalos>Now, what stands out to me is how connected these 2 bodies of work are.

170
00:18:26.627 --> 00:18:33.905
<v Candace Avalos>The Unified Housing Strategy is asking how we align the city's many housing goals, plans, and investments into a coherent long-term framework.

171
00:18:34.323 --> 00:18:41.118
<v Candace Avalos>And the Social Housing Study is asking what additional tools we may need to create more permanently affordable, stable, and community-centered housing opportunities.

172
00:18:41.648 --> 00:18:44.681
<v Candace Avalos>So taken together, both of those efforts are really about the same challenge.

173
00:18:44.904 --> 00:18:54.114
<v Candace Avalos>How do we build a housing system that not only produces more housing, but also preserves affordability, prevents displacement, and creates greater stability for Portlanders across income levels?

174
00:18:55.252 --> 00:18:59.022
<v Candace Avalos>And I appreciate that neither of these efforts attempts to start from scratch.

175
00:18:59.440 --> 00:19:03.819
<v Candace Avalos>The Unified Housing Strategy builds upon years of planning, community engagement, and adopted policy.

176
00:19:04.334 --> 00:19:12.318
<v Candace Avalos>And similarly, the Social Housing Study draws from existing models local experience, and research to identify potential pathways forward that are grounded in Portland's realities.

177
00:19:12.928 --> 00:19:15.525
<v Candace Avalos>So today's discussion is not about making final decisions.

178
00:19:15.701 --> 00:19:24.422
<v Candace Avalos>Rather, it is an opportunity for committee members to react to the direction of the work, identify any gaps, and provide feedback before staff return with final recommendations.

179
00:19:24.534 --> 00:19:25.896
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

180
00:19:26.217 --> 00:19:30.913
<v Candace Avalos>With that, I will go ahead and hand it over to our staff to get into the presentation.

181
00:19:31.170 --> 00:19:39.088
<v Candace Avalos>And note that there will be one part in the middle of the presentation where we'll take some technical questions, then we'll go through the rest of it, and then we'll dive into more discussion and questions.

182
00:19:41.369 --> 00:19:46.880
<v Queesha Light>Good afternoon, Chair Avalos and members of the Housing and Permitting Committee.

183
00:19:47.555 --> 00:19:51.394
<v Queesha Light>For the record, my name is Queesha Light, and I'm the interim director of the Portland Housing Bureau.

184
00:19:52.454 --> 00:20:04.584
<v Queesha Light>Before we begin, we too want to thank Chair Avalos for her leadership and partnership in advancing this work and for her commitment to creating a more coordinated and strategic approach to housing policy in Portland.

185
00:20:04.647 --> 00:20:05.306
<v Queesha Light>So thank you.

186
00:20:06.960 --> 00:20:16.088
<v Queesha Light>One of the things that we're going to do first is just provide you a very brief update on the social housing.

187
00:20:16.866 --> 00:20:36.458
<v Queesha Light>But before we go there, I just want to note that today that what we'll be doing is providing a progress report on the development of the unified housing strategy and seeking your feedback on the draft strategic direction, the proposed engagement approach, and areas where additional input may strengthen the final strategy.

188
00:20:37.417 --> 00:20:54.811
<v Queesha Light>And then I just want to note that over the last several months, staff across the Community and Economic Development Service area have reviewed more than 20 housing-related plans and over 200 actions, goals, policies, and programs that guide housing work within the city.

189
00:20:56.048 --> 00:21:03.877
<v Queesha Light>And what has become clear through that effort is something that Chair Avalos noted: Portland has no shortage of housing priorities.

190
00:21:03.925 --> 00:21:04.151
<v Queesha Light>Thank you.

191
00:21:04.961 --> 00:21:07.613
<v Queesha Light>The challenge is not identifying what matters.

192
00:21:08.961 --> 00:21:21.248
<v Queesha Light>It is aligning our efforts, aligning our resources, our funding strategies, and political will around a shared set of priorities that can move us closer to the housing outcomes Portlanders need.

193
00:21:22.880 --> 00:21:31.715
<v Queesha Light>And so what I will do is I'm going to actually turn it over to staff because they have all the details.

194
00:21:32.230 --> 00:21:33.365
<v Queesha Light>They'll walk through our project approach.

195
00:21:33.449 --> 00:21:34.176
<v Queesha Light>They'll provide you an update on social housing.

196
00:21:37.256 --> 00:21:42.089
<v Queesha Light>Let you know the work that we've already completed, and then we look forward to a discussion with you.

197
00:21:42.556 --> 00:21:43.856
<v Josh Roper>Thank you.

198
00:21:45.287 --> 00:21:45.817
<v Josh Roper>Good afternoon.

199
00:21:45.929 --> 00:21:48.371
<v Josh Roper>Josh Roper, Policy and Planning Director for the Housing Bureau.

200
00:21:48.804 --> 00:21:49.816
<v Josh Roper>Thank you for having us.

201
00:21:50.490 --> 00:21:54.490
<v Josh Roper>I'm going to try to make this very brief, the update on the social housing study.

202
00:21:55.229 --> 00:22:03.084
<v Josh Roper>We're going to spend the bulk of our time talking about the unified housing strategy, but want to give you a little bit of an update on the work that we've been doing.

203
00:22:04.625 --> 00:22:07.186
<v Josh Roper>We'll start with a quick overview of the project timeline.

204
00:22:07.589 --> 00:22:10.441
<v Josh Roper>We're going to be submitting the final report by the end of August.

205
00:22:11.190 --> 00:22:13.792
<v Josh Roper>We're currently in both phases 3 and 4.

206
00:22:14.034 --> 00:22:17.651
<v Josh Roper>So phase 3 is research analysis, education, and engagement.

207
00:22:18.133 --> 00:22:22.109
<v Josh Roper>Phase 4 is synthesizing findings, developing recommendations, drafting the report.

208
00:22:23.634 --> 00:22:31.119
<v Josh Roper>We're in both phases because this work is happening across the Bureau in parallel with multiple teams engaged.

209
00:22:31.299 --> 00:22:35.079
<v Josh Roper>So a particular topic will be handled by some combination of okay.

210
00:22:35.144 --> 00:22:39.545
<v Josh Roper>Teams within the Bureau and another will be another team or another group of teams.

211
00:22:41.726 --> 00:22:54.925
<v Josh Roper>We filed for your review, for the public's review, a progress report in what we're calling a preview draft because we wanted to give people, you all and the public, a sense of the direction and the shape of this work.

212
00:22:54.990 --> 00:22:57.153
<v Josh Roper>It is not close to complete.

213
00:22:57.201 --> 00:22:58.848
<v Josh Roper>We have a lot of work to do in the next few months.

214
00:22:59.701 --> 00:23:08.833
<v Josh Roper>In particular, I wanna highlight that it does not contain the alternative financing strategies work that we are— we really see as a key component of the final product.

215
00:23:09.555 --> 00:23:15.944
<v Josh Roper>But I think does give you a sense of what we've been up to, what we're doing, and where we're trying to land this.

216
00:23:16.555 --> 00:23:19.508
<v Josh Roper>And I think it's a good introduction to the work.

217
00:23:20.777 --> 00:23:22.028
<v Josh Roper>So we can go to the next slide.

218
00:23:23.280 --> 00:23:26.428
<v Josh Roper>And this is just an overview of the contents of that preview draft.

219
00:23:26.476 --> 00:23:41.728
<v Josh Roper>So some introductory information about the resolution that directed the study, the scope of the study, Some background on housing affordability and stability in Portland, which we see as the key things we want to focus on in connection with the social housing work.

220
00:23:42.288 --> 00:23:48.748
<v Josh Roper>Some research findings from a literature review and other research efforts around social housing and other alternative models.

221
00:23:49.580 --> 00:23:54.116
<v Josh Roper>An introduction to development work and this concept of non-market housing.

222
00:23:54.294 --> 00:24:01.443
<v Josh Roper>So this is a term that sort of encompasses alternative models that we're exploring, but also the models that we are already okay.

223
00:24:01.588 --> 00:24:02.671
<v Josh Roper>Using in Portland.

224
00:24:02.750 --> 00:24:08.449
<v Josh Roper>So alternative models like a cost-based model or, you know, an expansion of limited equity co-ops.

225
00:24:09.191 --> 00:24:14.659
<v Josh Roper>But it also encompasses the LIHTC-funded projects that we have done for many years.

226
00:24:16.698 --> 00:24:23.298
<v Josh Roper>And there's a sample of preliminary recommendations, again, excluding alternative financing strategies.

227
00:24:25.265 --> 00:24:33.910
<v Josh Roper>And when I say alternative financing strategies, that's both for multifamily rental and for alternative homeownership opportunities, the financing side of that work.

228
00:24:35.130 --> 00:24:42.907
<v Josh Roper>So again, you'll get a sense of the direction we're going and where we are trying to land this, but it is not comprehensive and it is subject to change.

229
00:24:42.971 --> 00:24:48.478
<v Josh Roper>And then there's a quick update on the alternative financing models work that's happening right now.

230
00:24:50.056 --> 00:24:50.861
<v Josh Roper>Go to the next slide.

231
00:24:52.501 --> 00:24:57.454
<v Josh Roper>And this just sort of reiterates what I just said for the record.

232
00:24:58.567 --> 00:25:00.644
<v Josh Roper>So I think that that covers it.

233
00:25:00.741 --> 00:25:04.636
<v Josh Roper>And like I said, we'll try to spend the rest of the time on the Unified Housing Strategy.

234
00:25:04.701 --> 00:25:06.625
<v Josh Roper>We are more than happy to hear feedback.

235
00:25:07.700 --> 00:25:13.520
<v Josh Roper>As you have time to take a look at the preview draft, feel free to reach out to me or the team.

236
00:25:14.669 --> 00:25:14.991
<v Josh Roper>Thank you.

237
00:25:16.898 --> 00:25:17.691
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Sorry.

238
00:25:18.467 --> 00:25:18.821
<v Staff Routh>You're good.

239
00:25:19.080 --> 00:25:19.961
<v Jessie Connor>Put these together backwards.

240
00:25:20.011 --> 00:25:20.159
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Sorry.

241
00:25:20.700 --> 00:25:20.961
<v Virginia Hammond>Okay.

242
00:25:25.332 --> 00:25:29.416
<v Josh Roper>So we're going to shift to the UHS, the Unified Housing Strategy.

243
00:25:32.932 --> 00:25:35.657
<v Josh Roper>Um, Queesha, I think, gave a good—.

244
00:25:35.657 --> 00:25:37.642
<v Queesha Light>Covered most of those, these slides here.

245
00:25:37.705 --> 00:25:38.691
<v Candace Avalos>We can move forward.

246
00:25:38.755 --> 00:25:39.047
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

247
00:25:42.864 --> 00:25:45.711
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

248
00:25:46.502 --> 00:25:47.840
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, I think we can skip this one too.

249
00:25:48.096 --> 00:25:48.983
<v Josh Roper>It's largely covered.

250
00:25:51.332 --> 00:25:55.554
<v Josh Roper>So a little bit about the timeline and the phases of the Unified Housing Strategy.

251
00:25:55.682 --> 00:26:03.628
<v Josh Roper>So this Unified Housing Strategy development work has occurred in 3 phases starting in the fall of 2025.

252
00:26:04.398 --> 00:26:10.034
<v Josh Roper>So Phase 1 consisted of the assembly of the city's current housing-related commitments.

253
00:26:11.142 --> 00:26:17.867
<v Josh Roper>We took all of those plans and strategies and we categorized them, the action items that made up those plans.

254
00:26:18.461 --> 00:26:24.490
<v Josh Roper>And then we produced an inventory that was going to be used for the phase we're in now, Phase 2.

255
00:26:25.035 --> 00:26:33.338
<v Josh Roper>We came to committee, I don't recall exactly when, but that inventory was made public and is available for review.

256
00:26:34.348 --> 00:26:46.900
<v Josh Roper>So Phase 2, winter 2026 to spring 2026, where we are now, this consisted of reviewing the inventory with the mayor, Councilor Avalos, Staff and council and city staff.

257
00:26:48.357 --> 00:27:13.337
<v Josh Roper>We were looking to identify overarching goals to organize this large body of planning and strategic work that had been conducted over many years, to prioritize the action items that made up those plans, to start to plan for engagement that was meant to begin in Phase 3, and to work excuse me.

258
00:27:13.419 --> 00:27:18.742
<v Josh Roper>Work on the production of a draft unified housing strategy to figure out what the deliverable would look like.

259
00:27:19.673 --> 00:27:25.782
<v Josh Roper>Phase 3 is gonna be this summer through the winter, and that will be when we do the community engagement work.

260
00:27:26.167 --> 00:27:33.833
<v Josh Roper>And that includes what we're calling a broad invitation to support the advancement of the city's housing goals.

261
00:27:33.881 --> 00:27:47.969
<v Josh Roper>So figuring out how stakeholders can plug into this work and support and collaborate, which I think is an important piece of this community engagement work, will be a very important piece of the engagement work.

262
00:27:48.819 --> 00:27:54.378
<v Josh Roper>We're going to be considering and responding to feedback that we receive in connection with that community engagement.

263
00:27:55.020 --> 00:28:04.678
<v Josh Roper>And ultimately, we'll be looking to get the Unified Housing Strategy adopted by Council and then continue the work in an implementation phase that follows.

264
00:28:06.497 --> 00:28:06.884
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

265
00:28:08.196 --> 00:28:13.994
<v Josh Roper>So really briefly, a couple of slides on housing needs analysis targets.

266
00:28:14.690 --> 00:28:24.926
<v Josh Roper>So you'll see here 2022 to 2045 forecasted targets for Central City, a little over 31,000 units.

267
00:28:25.394 --> 00:28:35.130
<v Josh Roper>Citywide, over 120,000, which equates to annual average unit production to meet that target of more than 5,000.

268
00:28:35.210 --> 00:28:39.842
<v Josh Roper>The housing unit targets are in a forecast adopted by City Council.

269
00:28:40.740 --> 00:28:45.243
<v Josh Roper>You also see a 2025 to 2045 revised target.

270
00:28:45.628 --> 00:28:49.700
<v Josh Roper>This is the product of work done by the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

271
00:28:50.277 --> 00:28:55.117
<v Josh Roper>The targets have been revised down based on data that has since become available.

272
00:28:55.824 --> 00:29:07.368
<v Josh Roper>So the central city target under the revised targets is now nearly 23,000, and city— excuse me, citywide is 87,750.

273
00:29:08.092 --> 00:29:14.491
<v Josh Roper>That changes the average annual unit production to meet the target to 4,388.

274
00:29:16.201 --> 00:29:16.782
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

275
00:29:22.402 --> 00:29:29.939
<v Josh Roper>Here are short-term housing needs analysis targets that are particularly relevant to the work that's happening in the Unified Housing Strategy at those tables.

276
00:29:32.294 --> 00:29:38.221
<v Josh Roper>So in Central City, 2025 to 2030, total units 5,700.

277
00:29:39.141 --> 00:29:41.606
<v Josh Roper>For the same period, that annual average is 1,100.

278
00:29:42.607 --> 00:29:47.384
<v Josh Roper>Then you have the mayor's targets for total units by the end of 2030.

279
00:29:47.449 --> 00:29:50.588
<v Josh Roper>So by 2031, that's 2,500.

280
00:29:52.474 --> 00:29:55.278
<v Josh Roper>You have the mayor's target annual average at 500.

281
00:29:55.795 --> 00:29:57.454
<v Josh Roper>Citywide, 22,000.

282
00:29:58.355 --> 00:30:03.157
<v Josh Roper>For 2025 to 2030, annual average 4,400.

283
00:30:05.107 --> 00:30:09.414
<v Josh Roper>Mayor's target, 20,000 by the end of 2032.

284
00:30:10.916 --> 00:30:14.534
<v Josh Roper>So by the time 2033 starts, 2,500 annual average.

285
00:30:14.777 --> 00:30:15.261
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

286
00:30:17.152 --> 00:30:17.232
<v Josh Roper>Okay.

287
00:30:17.442 --> 00:30:20.270
<v Josh Roper>And I'm going to turn it over to Jessie Connor.

288
00:30:21.547 --> 00:30:21.806
<v Josh Roper>Thank you.

289
00:30:25.249 --> 00:30:29.844
<v Jessie Connor>Good afternoon, Chair Avalos and Housing and Permitting Committee members.

290
00:30:30.976 --> 00:30:45.778
<v Jessie Connor>So we're going to roll through a little tiny bit more detail about the 2 initial phases, and then we'll roll through the work we've gotten so far on a draft UHS as well as a proposed engagement plan, all for your thoughts and reflections.

291
00:30:48.048 --> 00:30:54.259
<v Jessie Connor>So at a high level, the Phase 1, like Josh said we really had like kind of 4 big actions.

292
00:30:54.308 --> 00:30:57.936
<v Jessie Connor>We cataloged everything we could search and find.

293
00:30:58.338 --> 00:31:02.368
<v Jessie Connor>We categorized those into buckets based on the resolution direction, right?

294
00:31:02.416 --> 00:31:07.346
<v Jessie Connor>So those were really around funding, production and preservation, homelessness, anti-displacement, etc.

295
00:31:08.053 --> 00:31:42.910
<v Jessie Connor>Then we analyzed those also based on direction that we found in the resolution around tenure, affordability, I think Director Light already covered these, but staff really dug deep, and this just kind of gives you a snapshot of the funding that was available to the the city.

296
00:31:43.451 --> 00:31:59.307
<v Jessie Connor>Strategies and plans that we looked at and included, as well as the sort of non-city adopted plans, you know, the Metro Regional Housing Coordination Strategy, our Anti-Displacement Action Plan Foundation Report, and the Age and Disability Inclusive Neighborhood Action Plan.

297
00:32:02.240 --> 00:32:11.359
<v Jessie Connor>When we moved into Phase 2 in the beginning of January, our first goal was to start to refine down that initial inventory.

298
00:32:11.472 --> 00:32:17.507
<v Jessie Connor>So the inventory was— that intention there was to catalog everything we can find.

299
00:32:17.811 --> 00:32:36.221
<v Jessie Connor>We started to remove items that were either duplicates, some sort of duplicated efforts, some standing city policies with little opportunity for movement or change, items with— and then yes, I already said that part— items with limited opportunity to influence.

300
00:32:36.465 --> 00:32:48.460
<v Jessie Connor>Some of those also were things that were already far along in the legislative process, different proposals from the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability that were either already at committee or were at council.

301
00:32:49.549 --> 00:32:58.151
<v Jessie Connor>Our next step was to take that narrowed-down list and build it into the 5P framework that folks were interested in in Phase 1.

302
00:32:59.097 --> 00:33:06.818
<v Jessie Connor>The 5Ps are produce housing, preserve housing, prevent displacement, promote equity and inclusion, and progress environmental sustainability.

303
00:33:08.200 --> 00:33:23.614
<v Jessie Connor>We took those items and participated in work groups with the mayor and Councilor Avalos and some of the CEDSA staff to really support their discussions around prioritizing those— that remaining list.

304
00:33:23.775 --> 00:33:24.979
<v Jessie Connor>What's really rising to the top?

305
00:33:25.075 --> 00:33:31.972
<v Jessie Connor>What's going to need a little bit of extra something or some alignment from this council and the administrative body.

306
00:33:33.685 --> 00:33:37.836
<v Jessie Connor>And we are at that place of presenting to this committee.

307
00:33:41.020 --> 00:33:48.535
<v Jessie Connor>Part of the way through that Phase 2 process— so that last slide, that's where we had intended and planned on going at the outset in January.

308
00:33:49.117 --> 00:34:01.731
<v Jessie Connor>We got part of the way through that process in our discussions and conversations as a workgroup, we realized that a need to sort of shift and refocus the way that we were working things through.

309
00:34:02.422 --> 00:34:06.869
<v Jessie Connor>So we worked through refining and aligning, placing items into one of the 5P categories.

310
00:34:07.463 --> 00:34:20.516
<v Jessie Connor>We worked through the prioritization exercise with the councilor and the mayor, identifying items as either high priority, a moderate priority, or a lower priority for this particular exercise.

311
00:34:21.030 --> 00:34:31.050
<v Jessie Connor>It doesn't mean that those items don't have value or aren't already being worked on in other spaces, but we were trying to tailor it for this particular body of work.

312
00:34:32.414 --> 00:34:39.639
<v Jessie Connor>The impact of that was that we found the need to restructure the way we were thinking about our framework.

313
00:34:39.751 --> 00:34:53.592
<v Jessie Connor>So we wanted to focus on goals that centered these 3 key elements around production, We included in the work that you will see today for your discussion the highest priorities, the things that were really rising to the top out of those conversations.

314
00:34:54.025 --> 00:35:20.257
<v Jessie Connor>And then a way to tie in sort of the remaining elements of the 5P strategic framework are these, what we're calling right now the Getting It Right, to tie those in around anti-displacement, equity and inclusion, and and those are, are being seen at this moment as additional elements for achieving our outcomes associated with a particular action.

315
00:35:23.239 --> 00:35:27.257
<v Jessie Connor>So that's a bit of a lot around process to date.

316
00:35:27.306 --> 00:35:35.576
<v Jessie Connor>So I just wanted to pause to see if there's any questions, clarifying questions about purpose, Phase 1, or Phase 2.

317
00:35:35.706 --> 00:35:35.788
<v Virginia Hammond>Yes.

318
00:35:38.983 --> 00:35:41.295
<v Candace Avalos>Committee members, any questions at this point?

319
00:35:43.420 --> 00:35:44.579
<v Jessie Connor>Okay, wonderful.

320
00:35:47.079 --> 00:36:06.170
<v Jessie Connor>Okay, so the, the next few slides, um, they're going to be a little, uh, content dense, but that is an attempt to hit the high points of what you're about to talk about and discuss, as well as making sure that we've got members of the public familiar with the way that we're sort of framing this out now.

321
00:36:07.409 --> 00:36:10.864
<v Jessie Connor>So Phase 2 is really centered around 4 primary goals.

322
00:36:12.730 --> 00:36:23.521
<v Jessie Connor>Goal 1 is to produce new housing, adding 20,000 new residential units across all housing types and income levels permitted by 2033 and built by 2035.

323
00:36:24.282 --> 00:36:48.778
<v Jessie Connor>This is our attempt to blend both the mayor's production It should be noted that our intention is for the preservation goal to be additive.

324
00:36:49.300 --> 00:36:52.731
<v Jessie Connor>It is in addition to the production goal, not a subset.

325
00:36:52.782 --> 00:36:53.054
<v Jessie Connor>Thank you.

326
00:36:53.686 --> 00:37:07.295
<v Jessie Connor>Goal 3, innovate production preservation and stabilization, implementing strategies adopted by City Council from the 2026 Social Housing Study to increase the supply of non-market housing options and next-generation housing strategies.

327
00:37:07.728 --> 00:37:15.518
<v Jessie Connor>This one is a little preemptive of your social housing work, a little optimistic on our end.

328
00:37:15.902 --> 00:37:37.532
<v Jessie Connor>Goal 4 is to secure long-term sustainable funding using the city's political will and influence now I'm going to run through each of the goals and identify what was sort of rising to the top out of our workgroup meetings.

329
00:37:38.291 --> 00:37:54.458
<v Jessie Connor>So for Goal 1, the producing new housing, this had by far the most discussion because it has the most this is going to be a little bit much, so hang in there with me.

330
00:37:56.512 --> 00:38:02.153
<v Jessie Connor>Implement accessible housing production strategies and educate on opportunities for aging in place and community.

331
00:38:02.914 --> 00:38:26.264
<v Jessie Connor>Creating an accessible housing inventory, a citywide anti-displacement toolkit that includes some type of impact evaluation tool, conducting a thorough analysis of the landlord-tenant policies, looking at local codes, local city codes, investing in job— excuse me, investing in industry job training, retraining, and career pathways.

332
00:38:26.956 --> 00:38:34.739
<v Jessie Connor>A lot in here also trying to tie housing to workforce training because we need folks to be able to afford the housing that we build and the housing that we have.

333
00:38:36.231 --> 00:39:08.722
<v Jessie Connor>Investing in youth and adult workforce development programs, navigation, and job placement, expanding, um, and improving, really building upon existing mass timber workforce programs, uh, as well as promoting both mass timber, modular, and 3D construction in codes, as well as like building the workforce, uh, for that particular industry and infrastructure, um, and ensuring that the investments are distributed equitably, uh, across all districts with a lens towards historical and under- is invested.

334
00:39:10.235 --> 00:39:19.713
<v Jessie Connor>Using TIF strategic investment funds and a potential middle-income revolving loan fund to invest in mixed-income housing.

335
00:39:20.536 --> 00:39:23.570
<v Jessie Connor>Conducting periodic review of the inclusionary housing program.

336
00:39:24.429 --> 00:39:27.574
<v Jessie Connor>Facilitating community ownership of renewable energy.

337
00:39:28.317 --> 00:39:37.878
<v Jessie Connor>And a host of streamlining permitting processes, coordinating both housing development and infrastructure improvements across the city, how we're sort of really working together.

338
00:39:39.650 --> 00:39:44.117
<v Jessie Connor>Some planning efforts around the Inner East Side, increasing housing capacity and density.

339
00:39:44.744 --> 00:39:56.485
<v Jessie Connor>Again, some code cleanup and permitting process pieces, as well as ensuring that we maintain appropriate land supply for industrial manufacturing.

340
00:39:58.969 --> 00:40:01.786
<v Jessie Connor>Moving on to Goal 2, the sustaining existing housing.

341
00:40:03.115 --> 00:40:19.740
<v Jessie Connor>Our strategies include ensuring preservation strategies prioritize existing residents, that we stabilize the city's affordable housing portfolio as it is today, as well as developing and implementing a regional affordable housing preservation strategy.

342
00:40:21.186 --> 00:40:27.387
<v Jessie Connor>We also acknowledge that we need to enhance asset and property management capacity and proficiency through training and technical assistance.

343
00:40:27.516 --> 00:40:37.405
<v Jessie Connor>I'll make a small asterisk here, and this is one that is actually not located in a plan, but definitely has risen to the top in recent conversations, and so it's included here.

344
00:40:38.900 --> 00:40:50.619
<v Jessie Connor>Focusing on preservation efforts on locations where projects provide affordability in expensive neighborhoods, purchasing middle-income housing and doing a conversion to limited profit.

345
00:40:52.199 --> 00:40:56.780
<v Jessie Connor>Again, launching that affordable housing listing service and leveraging PSEF and other types of resources to really reduce operating costs.

346
00:40:57.056 --> 00:40:57.398
<v Jessie Connor>Thank you.

347
00:40:59.706 --> 00:41:24.094
<v Jessie Connor>Our third goal around innovation includes introducing long-term leases for renters, extending that duration of tenant income recertification period, increasing cooperative opportunities, increasing equity building opportunities for renters, another underscore of advancing innovation around modular construction.

348
00:41:24.141 --> 00:41:24.255
<v Jessie Connor>Thank you.

349
00:41:24.541 --> 00:41:42.701
<v Jessie Connor>Cross-laminated timber and other more earth-friendly technologies, proposing local and state legislative change to support those models so that there— if there needs to be technical language additions into state statute and implementing a land banking strategic plan.

350
00:41:43.918 --> 00:41:53.518
<v Jessie Connor>The last goal is to secure long-term sustainable funding by starting with a communication strategy and a campaign for future housing resources.

351
00:41:54.170 --> 00:42:01.858
<v Jessie Connor>Exploring different types of revenue to identify something long-term and stable as aligned with the housing needs analysis.

352
00:42:02.780 --> 00:42:19.855
<v Jessie Connor>We get increased funding for existing low-income homeowner programs, developing a strategy for building generational wealth, adopting— developing and adopting action plans for the 3 new Central City TIF districts and the 3 new East Portland TIF districts.

353
00:42:21.230 --> 00:42:24.786
<v Jessie Connor>Establishing some requirements for existing housing to increase their resilience.

354
00:42:25.561 --> 00:42:30.637
<v Jessie Connor>Comprehensively studying SDCs and their potential impact on development feasibility.

355
00:42:33.179 --> 00:42:44.494
<v Jessie Connor>Continuing to work through our infrastructure improvements program, you know, supporting offsite improvements, potentially developing a bucket of funds for things that are triggered by individual developments.

356
00:42:45.889 --> 00:42:50.097
<v Jessie Connor>And adopting a sustainable and diverse funding model for Portland permitting and development.

357
00:42:52.449 --> 00:42:55.550
<v Jessie Connor>The next couple of slides I'm just going to hit on quickly here.

358
00:42:55.936 --> 00:42:56.804
<v Jessie Connor>These are the getting it right.

359
00:42:56.885 --> 00:43:00.998
<v Jessie Connor>This is that tie back into that 5P model.

360
00:43:02.284 --> 00:43:05.155
<v Jessie Connor>So these are just extra questions that we will be asking ourselves.

361
00:43:05.815 --> 00:43:14.181
<v Jessie Connor>Are we, with this action item, are we really hitting this mark as well as maybe any unit count that we are also aiming for, right?

362
00:43:14.230 --> 00:43:19.913
<v Jessie Connor>So are we prioritizing, you know, housing and economic stability of the existing residents?

363
00:43:21.039 --> 00:43:23.224
<v Jessie Connor>Are we preserving or enhancing the affordability?

364
00:43:23.355 --> 00:43:25.297
<v Jessie Connor>Are we creating workforce opportunities, right?

365
00:43:26.539 --> 00:43:36.385
<v Jessie Connor>Are we prioritizing modernizing existing housing infrastructure, targeting investments in construction and trade industries that are emerging?

366
00:43:39.297 --> 00:43:45.568
<v Jessie Connor>For equity and inclusion, are we really prioritizing and centering the right communities?

367
00:43:46.690 --> 00:43:52.266
<v Jessie Connor>Are we targeting areas and neighborhoods where there's the greatest difference between extremely low income and market rate rents?

368
00:43:55.990 --> 00:44:03.387
<v Jessie Connor>Are we prioritizing activities within council's direct influence, really centering those items, reducing barriers to housing production and code?

369
00:44:03.927 --> 00:44:08.788
<v Jessie Connor>And deploying funds, of course, across all of these that are aligned with their originating activity.

370
00:44:15.949 --> 00:44:27.585
<v Jessie Connor>So the next piece that I'm going to run through is our proposed engagement plan coming up for this summer that we're really looking forward to getting your thoughts and insights on and some direction.

371
00:44:28.458 --> 00:44:50.644
<v Jessie Connor>So really the purpose the purpose of Phase 3, the engagement there is to identify— to what Director Light was saying— identifying and leveraging stakeholder partnership opportunities, surfacing and addressing barriers to some of the overarching goals, and really sharing a unified strategic direction with the public that shows this council and administration's alignment.

372
00:44:53.746 --> 00:44:57.715
<v Jessie Connor>To do that, this kind of gives you a run-through of how we could approach that work.

373
00:44:58.226 --> 00:45:05.990
<v Jessie Connor>Through sort of building our tables around the 3 big goals and attaching them both with Goal 4 around funding.

374
00:45:06.119 --> 00:45:14.253
<v Jessie Connor>So this would look like producing housing and talking about the funding goal, preserving housing and funding, and then the innovation and funding.

375
00:45:15.409 --> 00:45:27.135
<v Jessie Connor>July and August, we would look to host our facilitated events, really drawing on our— the stakeholder engagement that came with the originating document, right?

376
00:45:27.184 --> 00:45:39.262
<v Jessie Connor>Like if it came from the Housing Production Strategy, if it was something that came from one of the strategic plans that we looked at in Phase 1, really drawing from some of our industry and partners who have participated in some of those spaces so far.

377
00:45:40.739 --> 00:46:07.094
<v Jessie Connor>Of course, a set of period— or, and I will also add, and a more broadly public engagement effort as well, so that we're hitting those stakeholder tables as well as reaching out to every council district, considering those feedback— the feedback, incorporating that, some work sessions with that smaller work group that we had in these last few months, and then bringing those findings for further consideration back to this committee.

378
00:46:10.929 --> 00:46:16.628
<v Jessie Connor>That was a lot, and I think with that it is my turn to turn it over to Chair Avalos.

379
00:46:16.777 --> 00:46:18.494
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much.

380
00:46:18.911 --> 00:46:28.842
<v Candace Avalos>And yes, very dense information, but hopefully we'll just not get too marred down in the details and really bring this conversation up to the strategy.

381
00:46:30.014 --> 00:46:31.731
<v Candace Avalos>So thanks again for the presentations.

382
00:46:32.148 --> 00:46:38.757
<v Candace Avalos>As I mentioned in my opening remarks, the goal is not to make final decisions or debate specific policy recommendations.

383
00:46:39.126 --> 00:46:42.206
<v Candace Avalos>What I'm hoping that we can do today is help shape the direction of the work.

384
00:46:42.592 --> 00:46:44.867
<v Candace Avalos>Before it comes back to us in a more finalized form.

385
00:46:45.556 --> 00:46:48.471
<v Candace Avalos>And there are really 2 things that I'm hoping to get out of this discussion.

386
00:46:48.856 --> 00:46:56.144
<v Candace Avalos>First, I want to understand whether this committee believes we're headed in the right direction with the proposed objectives and strategic framework.

387
00:46:56.769 --> 00:46:57.907
<v Candace Avalos>Are these the right outcomes?

388
00:46:58.036 --> 00:46:59.733
<v Candace Avalos>Are we organizing the work in the right way?

389
00:47:00.134 --> 00:47:02.746
<v Candace Avalos>And are there important gaps that staff should continue exploring?

390
00:47:03.739 --> 00:47:06.318
<v Candace Avalos>And second, I want to talk about engagement.

391
00:47:06.382 --> 00:47:09.795
<v Candace Avalos>So we know that a strategy like this is only as strong as the people who help shape it.

392
00:47:10.307 --> 00:47:20.307
<v Candace Avalos>So I want to spend time thinking about who needs to be at the table, who may be missing, and how we ensure we're hearing from both stakeholders and Portlanders more broadly as this work moves forward.

393
00:47:20.724 --> 00:47:39.684
<v Candace Avalos>And I'll just put an extra note on that to say my goal in staggering the kind of engagement is that I really want all of the stakeholders, you know, the people that are in the industries working on all aspects of the housing spectrum, to engage with this information in a way where they can offer expertise but also plug in.

394
00:47:40.599 --> 00:47:51.530
<v Candace Avalos>This is an opportunity for us as we start shopping it around to the public to ask where can private companies, right, or organizations lean in on some of the strategies.

395
00:47:51.579 --> 00:47:54.913
<v Candace Avalos>Maybe they're already doing things that we have on our list that they can plug in.

396
00:47:55.507 --> 00:48:01.726
<v Candace Avalos>And then the second part, when we bring it back out to the general public, that's where we want to hear what does the public want us to prioritize.

397
00:48:02.255 --> 00:48:05.172
<v Candace Avalos>So I see the engagement in those 2 phases for that reason.

398
00:48:06.021 --> 00:48:09.195
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, we are going to open up some discussion.

399
00:48:09.275 --> 00:48:13.588
<v Candace Avalos>I see we've got people in the queue, and these lovely folks will be here to answer questions as well.

400
00:48:13.668 --> 00:48:14.134
<v Candace Avalos>I think Councilor yes.

401
00:48:14.181 --> 00:48:15.592
<v Candace Avalos>—Might have questions, direct questions.

402
00:48:16.824 --> 00:48:22.081
<v Candace Avalos>But the opening question that I have for us is, do these objectives capture the right priorities for the city?

403
00:48:23.074 --> 00:48:31.599
<v Candace Avalos>Colleagues, I sent you guys an email yesterday with just some basic framing of questions for you guys to think about, and I will do my best to guide the discussion.

404
00:48:31.646 --> 00:48:34.835
<v Candace Avalos>Feel free to take your time to speak to whatever.

405
00:48:34.914 --> 00:48:41.949
<v Candace Avalos>You don't need to speak to the questions that I ask, but I will be prompting us throughout just to make sure we're getting what we need to get back to the Housing Bureau.

406
00:48:42.615 --> 00:48:45.496
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, we'll open it up with Councilor Green or Vice Chair Green.

407
00:48:47.170 --> 00:48:48.217
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

408
00:48:49.606 --> 00:48:51.800
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much for the presentation and the updates.

409
00:48:52.027 --> 00:48:54.318
<v Mitch Green>I'll speak just to the UHS for now.

410
00:48:54.527 --> 00:48:57.532
<v Mitch Green>I think I've got— I'll get back in the queue later for some social housing study stuff.

411
00:48:57.614 --> 00:49:03.733
<v Mitch Green>But just at a high level, I like the exposition of these 4 goals.

412
00:49:04.106 --> 00:49:23.380
<v Mitch Green>I think starting off with Goal 1, anchoring it to the housing production strategy, anchoring it to the mayor's priorities, Just reminds us that we— whatever we're doing here needs to be not at cross purposes with like sort of the executive lens and the focus of the City of Portland.

413
00:49:24.458 --> 00:49:31.451
<v Mitch Green>We do need to add 20,000 new residential units, and we have to be reminded of that constantly, that that is an urgent thing.

414
00:49:34.570 --> 00:49:39.784
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, how we get there, We're gonna have to work hard to get there.

415
00:49:39.864 --> 00:49:47.251
<v Mitch Green>But, um, so that kind of brings me into the reason I put— I think initially put my hand in the queue, which was just to make sure I really understand what's happening here.

416
00:49:47.396 --> 00:50:00.099
<v Mitch Green>Um, so all the strategies that have been sort of enumerated on here, is, is that sort of an enumeration of an inventory of the policies and the plans and the strategies we've already adopted in sort of scattershot form?

417
00:50:00.644 --> 00:50:00.773
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

418
00:50:01.481 --> 00:50:02.878
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's, that's really helpful.

419
00:50:03.940 --> 00:50:06.856
<v Mitch Green>I think it's just, it's bewildering how many there are.

420
00:50:07.403 --> 00:50:10.288
<v Mitch Green>And I don't need to tell you, you've done this exercise.

421
00:50:11.052 --> 00:50:15.210
<v Mitch Green>And so I think it's really important for this work to focus all that.

422
00:50:15.275 --> 00:50:17.405
<v Mitch Green>So I appreciate that that was the intent here.

423
00:50:18.371 --> 00:50:26.969
<v Mitch Green>I think just in goal 1, I'm not seeing enough foregrounding of the need to basically take a moonshot.

424
00:50:27.369 --> 00:50:32.744
<v Mitch Green>And I know this is an inventory of existing stuff, so we're thinking about how we move forward.

425
00:50:32.793 --> 00:50:32.875
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

426
00:50:33.385 --> 00:50:59.829
<v Mitch Green>And to do something new, I think we really should foreground a lot more of the need for us to sort of press the gas, so to speak, on updating our codes, our zoning approaches, and doing that in a multi-jurisdictional, cross-jurisdictional partnership way with state legislature and other areas of the region because we're not going to be able to do 20,000 units of new production.

427
00:51:00.494 --> 00:51:22.838
<v Mitch Green>If we cannot change our existing planning processes, I know we're ascribed by law to a certain degree, but like pushing that boundary and having sort of a— and this is a budget question for us to contemplate over the next few years— is like making sure that we are dedicating resources for BPS to have whatever team it needs to move as quickly as possible.

428
00:51:23.304 --> 00:51:27.889
<v Mitch Green>So that way when we do things like entity site for all resolution to speed things up, it doesn't take away from other work.

429
00:51:27.949 --> 00:51:28.130
<v Virginia Hammond>Yeah.

430
00:51:28.630 --> 00:51:28.969
<v David Straub>Mm-hmm.

431
00:51:29.130 --> 00:51:37.175
<v Mitch Green>And it takes a lot of work and staff time to focus all this and ask the question of, is this new idea, is this new concept pulling away from the thing that we actually think we want to preserve?

432
00:51:39.083 --> 00:51:52.847
<v Mitch Green>So, you know, things like expanding our portfolio of pre-approved designs, all sorts of ways to sort of make it as easy as possible to do development in the City of Portland, I think needs to be a thing that comes out of this document.

433
00:51:54.545 --> 00:51:58.561
<v Mitch Green>I do wanna say that I appreciate the anticipation of the social housing study results.

434
00:51:58.947 --> 00:52:12.958
<v Mitch Green>I think it would've been a misstep to notice that there's these 2 resolutions in play and think about this in its own set of silos and then think, well, we'll deal with the social housing results as it comes out because I know that there's already conversations that are cross-pollinating there.

435
00:52:13.199 --> 00:52:14.677
<v Mitch Green>So kudos to that effort.

436
00:52:14.724 --> 00:52:15.431
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that.

437
00:52:16.059 --> 00:52:18.677
<v Mitch Green>On goal 4, and I think I'll just leave it there for now.

438
00:52:20.885 --> 00:52:43.130
<v Mitch Green>And let my colleagues speak is I do think that we need to secure stable funding for this work, but I maybe wanna soften the new revenue streams in bold and just say, just make sure that we have sustainable and dedicated revenue because it's entirely possible we can contemplate pushing forward a policy agenda that repurposes existing revenue.

439
00:52:43.663 --> 00:52:44.599
<v Mitch Green>Mm-hmm.

440
00:52:45.215 --> 00:52:48.840
<v Mitch Green>Or if when metro regional government's ready to kind of think about something new, Yes.

441
00:52:49.112 --> 00:52:56.677
<v Mitch Green>We work with them to expand the language around the thing that they want to renew or float to support our work here.

442
00:52:57.190 --> 00:53:01.646
<v Mitch Green>Just want to be really mindful that there is a certain amount of tax fatigue out there.

443
00:53:02.239 --> 00:53:06.503
<v Mitch Green>And we do spend a lot of money on housing-related stuff in this region.

444
00:53:06.728 --> 00:53:14.567
<v Mitch Green>And if we're focused, then we're just spending that same pot of money more wisely is kind of how I would offer a framing.

445
00:53:16.204 --> 00:53:18.097
<v Mitch Green>But really appreciate the update.

446
00:53:18.146 --> 00:53:22.757
<v Mitch Green>I know a lot of work's going into this, and the good news is we've already done a lot of work.

447
00:53:22.838 --> 00:53:24.311
<v Mitch Green>So let's kind of bring it all together.

448
00:53:24.376 --> 00:53:25.590
<v Mitch Green>So I'll leave it there for now.

449
00:53:27.643 --> 00:53:28.094
<v Candace Avalos>Wonderful.

450
00:53:28.289 --> 00:53:28.628
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

451
00:53:29.579 --> 00:53:34.355
<v Candace Avalos>Quick process note to say that we have this conversation until about 3:35.

452
00:53:34.403 --> 00:53:40.807
<v Candace Avalos>So just FYI, we might have a little bit more time as well 'cause we could eat in a little bit into the other item.

453
00:53:41.963 --> 00:53:44.413
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, next up, Councilor Novick.

454
00:53:45.407 --> 00:53:46.128
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

455
00:53:47.217 --> 00:53:55.954
<v Steve Novick>I have a question about, I think it's Goal 2, sustain existing housing, preserve 1,400 units of existing affordable housing by 2035.

456
00:53:56.675 --> 00:53:57.733
<v Steve Novick>What does that mean?

457
00:53:57.878 --> 00:54:10.125
<v Steve Novick>Does that mean that at least 1,400 currently affordable units will still be affordable then, or does it mean that 1,400 affordable units that we think right now are in danger of disappearing are preserved?

458
00:54:11.106 --> 00:54:11.702
<v Steve Novick>What does it mean?

459
00:54:13.539 --> 00:54:26.088
<v Josh Roper>So it means that over that time period, that many units should be involved in our preservation strategy of some— it's like some kind of preservation strategy from the Housing Bureau.

460
00:54:26.152 --> 00:54:30.637
<v Josh Roper>And that could be focused on physical issues with a building.

461
00:54:30.733 --> 00:54:39.815
<v Josh Roper>It could be focused on expiring regulatory covenants that need Some kind of solution to extend the affordability.

462
00:54:40.329 --> 00:54:44.505
<v Josh Roper>There are different strategies that apply that fit under that preservation umbrella.

463
00:54:45.485 --> 00:54:46.835
<v Josh Roper>Excuse me.

464
00:54:48.121 --> 00:54:56.233
<v Josh Roper>But fundamentally, yes, it's about are we avoiding the loss of affordable units from the market?

465
00:54:57.454 --> 00:55:02.965
<v Steve Novick>So that means you're identifying affordable units that you think are at risk of loss and doing something to avert the loss.

466
00:55:03.367 --> 00:55:17.311
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, so when you hear us talk about a preservation NOFA, for example, that's an example of how we invite providers to apply to us to seek funding to avoid the loss of affordable units in the market.

467
00:55:18.356 --> 00:55:29.625
<v Steve Novick>Another question I have is, are we looking at other cities that have a good track record of producing housing and having housing affordable and seeing what they do?

468
00:55:29.802 --> 00:55:39.463
<v Steve Novick>Like, I remember Some years ago, Willamette Week had an article saying that Chicago and Tokyo are among the cities that do a good job of creating new housing.

469
00:55:40.519 --> 00:55:43.420
<v Steve Novick>Are we doing that kind of scan of cities around the country and the world?

470
00:55:44.206 --> 00:55:57.744
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, a lot of the work that's happening under the social housing study umbrella involves comparative analysis of, you know, Portland compared to— you'll hear about Vienna a lot, but that's not the only place we're looking at.

471
00:55:58.563 --> 00:56:06.402
<v Josh Roper>There are other examples of social housing and other examples of housing work being done well that we're comparing Portland to.

472
00:56:06.610 --> 00:56:11.445
<v Josh Roper>You know, you'll hear about the revolving loan fund in Montgomery County in Maryland, for example.

473
00:56:11.653 --> 00:56:14.159
<v Josh Roper>You'll hear about Chicago and their work.

474
00:56:14.208 --> 00:56:15.443
<v Josh Roper>You'll hear about Seattle.

475
00:56:15.813 --> 00:56:20.599
<v Steve Novick>And you're looking at zoning and permitting rules and strategies in other cities as well?

476
00:56:20.889 --> 00:56:25.143
<v Josh Roper>I know planning is— the housing bureau to a To a lesser degree.

477
00:56:26.585 --> 00:56:29.871
<v Josh Roper>That's a little bit outside of our primary scope.

478
00:56:30.208 --> 00:56:32.420
<v Josh Roper>It's definitely outside of our primary scope.

479
00:56:32.597 --> 00:56:34.135
<v Steve Novick>Okay, so you should be asking them that.

480
00:56:34.264 --> 00:56:35.884
<v Steve Novick>All right.

481
00:56:37.230 --> 00:56:39.666
<v Steve Novick>What does introduce long-term leases mean?

482
00:56:39.731 --> 00:56:44.893
<v Steve Novick>Does that mean in city-owned affordable housing or sort of promoting the concept in general?

483
00:56:45.422 --> 00:56:47.313
<v Josh Roper>It could be a variety of ways.

484
00:56:47.521 --> 00:57:03.304
<v Josh Roper>So for example, it could be that if we're funding This is down the road, but funding something that we've identified as a social housing project, that the funding solicitation includes requirements around how leasing works.

485
00:57:05.074 --> 00:57:12.731
<v Josh Roper>So that could lay out how long, you know, at a minimum leases need to last and the circumstances under which the leases can end.

486
00:57:13.342 --> 00:57:21.545
<v Josh Roper>It's sort of a regulatory layer that exists outside of The broad legal layer that applies to all housing.

487
00:57:22.224 --> 00:57:24.144
<v Josh Roper>But there are other ways to accomplish that.

488
00:57:24.548 --> 00:57:26.672
<v Josh Roper>You could use just law, right?

489
00:57:27.322 --> 00:57:27.746
<v Josh Roper>Local law.

490
00:57:28.688 --> 00:57:31.677
<v Josh Roper>And there are other mechanisms that we're looking into as well.

491
00:57:31.726 --> 00:57:32.327
<v Josh Roper>So it's pretty broad.

492
00:57:34.577 --> 00:57:40.257
<v Steve Novick>I was pleased to see the idea of promoting mass timber, modular, 3D.

493
00:57:42.101 --> 00:57:53.501
<v Steve Novick>Are there currently laws that restrict the ability to build, that the city controls, that restrict people's ability to build cross-laminated timber housing or modular housing, et cetera?

494
00:57:54.802 --> 00:57:55.878
<v Josh Roper>Not that I'm aware of.

495
00:57:55.989 --> 00:58:07.726
<v Josh Roper>We've been doing some accelerator, this mass timber accelerator work where we've had some firms assessing the feasibility of using mass timber for projects.

496
00:58:08.623 --> 00:58:12.139
<v Josh Roper>I haven't heard at least that the obstacles they're running into are legal.

497
00:58:12.253 --> 00:58:16.675
<v Josh Roper>It's more of a feasibility, like a funding feasibility angle.

498
00:58:16.724 --> 00:58:19.025
<v Josh Roper>But we can get you more on that if there's anything there.

499
00:58:20.119 --> 00:58:20.376
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

500
00:58:20.876 --> 00:58:44.358
<v Steve Novick>And finally, Madam Chair, reflecting on the large number of strategies listed here, my reaction is that if we're going to go out to the public and ask for them to prioritize, We can't ask people to pick among such a long list that we need to narrow it down and ask for people to help choose between a small— a smaller number of things.

501
00:58:45.434 --> 00:58:45.755
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

502
00:58:47.282 --> 00:58:47.556
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

503
00:58:47.603 --> 00:58:48.181
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate that.

504
00:58:48.231 --> 00:58:48.840
<v Candace Avalos>And I agree.

505
00:58:48.889 --> 00:58:52.525
<v Candace Avalos>And I hope that what this conversation can do is we're starting to winnow that down.

506
00:58:54.202 --> 00:58:54.737
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

507
00:58:54.835 --> 00:58:56.688
<v Candace Avalos>Next up, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

508
00:58:59.143 --> 00:58:59.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There we go.

509
00:58:59.565 --> 00:59:00.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

510
00:59:03.019 --> 00:59:04.922
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are definitely a lot of strategies here.

511
00:59:05.150 --> 00:59:20.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm a little concerned that as we open up this conversation, um, we're seeing what's here and what's missing, and we need to be figuring out priorities and risk adding to it, especially as we talk to stakeholders.

512
00:59:21.072 --> 00:59:35.675
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, but in risking doing that, I want to flag a couple of things that I didn't see that I think are important for us to look at, and then a couple of other thoughts about how this looks and what the engagement piece might be.

513
00:59:36.550 --> 00:59:39.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is under Goal 2, when we talk about preservation.

514
00:59:40.356 --> 01:00:40.262
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's a lot about how much money we spend preserving and what preservation means, but I wonder if we are having conversations as we think about our housing strategy about a better approach to preservation in the long run and expanding the period of time under which we have covenants for affordability and building into the work that we do, especially as we develop housing, as opposed to just funding the development of housing, funding for regular maintenance so that But those preservation NOFAs are less critical crisis moment, and there is a regular cadence built into the funding models, which as I understand it right now, the funding models allow our nonprofit providers to operate but not always to keep up with that regular cadence of maintenance, which is why we end up with the crises we do.

515
01:00:41.097 --> 01:00:53.994
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And should we be thinking more proactively about our preservation model as we look at the development of new properties or the purchase of properties that we bring into our portfolio for the first time.

516
01:00:55.652 --> 01:01:06.780
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also did not see anywhere on any of these lists the words family-size unit, and that is incredibly concerning to me.

517
01:01:07.650 --> 01:01:09.369
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As long as we continue Councilor Smith.

518
01:01:09.432 --> 01:01:10.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Mayor.

519
01:01:10.219 --> 01:01:17.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we continue to just talk about the number of units we need and not what type of housing we need, we are going to continue to have a housing crisis.

520
01:01:19.067 --> 01:01:20.641
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do not have space for families.

521
01:01:21.797 --> 01:01:24.862
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do not have space for families with more than 1 or 2 kids.

522
01:01:25.713 --> 01:01:40.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do not develop affordable housing in a way that allows for multigenerational living because our affordable units generally require people to apply for just their insular family based on number of children and number of working parents.

523
01:01:41.081 --> 01:01:44.965
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Multigenerational living literally breaks those covenants in many cases.

524
01:01:46.443 --> 01:02:01.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And until we start to think more flexibly about how people live and who they live with and build that into our goals, not just into our conversations, we are missing the thank you.

525
01:02:05.000 --> 01:02:18.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm risking adding more to what is already a long list because I think that it is just not feasible for us to move forward with a set of goals and priorities that doesn't look at what we're building.

526
01:02:20.291 --> 01:02:26.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I really appreciated the note to— I think it was in Goal 1— Industrial land.

527
01:02:27.150 --> 01:02:39.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There was a lot in Goal One about the construction industry and construction jobs, and we have a number of large projects in our region where we know that we will need to increase the pipeline of people into construction jobs.

528
01:02:40.012 --> 01:02:51.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We also know that when the economy is struggling, the construction workforce is one of the easiest places for the public sector to infuse support to get people back into.

529
01:02:52.735 --> 01:02:53.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Living wage jobs.

530
01:02:55.067 --> 01:03:05.782
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if we just rely on growth for the creation of living wage jobs, we are going to enter a cycle or continue a cycle that is just not long-term sustainable, and we know that.

531
01:03:07.976 --> 01:03:23.927
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'd like to just highlight the inclusion of ensuring that our increased construction maintains space for industrial jobs, because I think we need to say that regularly and make sure it continues to be part of the work that we do.

532
01:03:24.568 --> 01:04:05.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also think as we look at our zoning and our land use and what housing looks like in our community, we need to not only think about the importance of industrial land but also the importance of green space as a means for public health, and the fact that as we build denser and we have fewer garden apartments, fewer single-family homes, fewer unit types that have green space naturally around them, and denser living, we need to be more intentional about making sure that that's paired with green space to maintain the public health benefits, including cooling benefits.

533
01:04:06.492 --> 01:04:07.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I just wanted to note that.

534
01:04:08.081 --> 01:04:18.061
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As we think about the inclusion of industrial land and potentially other land types as needing to balance with our with our zoning that also allows for the increased housing that we need.

535
01:04:24.840 --> 01:04:33.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I, in seeing the community engagement plan, didn't see a lot about engagement of the.

536
01:04:33.420 --> 01:04:34.306
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Community as a whole.

537
01:04:36.081 --> 01:04:37.543
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see a lot around stakeholders.

538
01:04:39.360 --> 01:04:47.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I see a lot around making sure that people who are engaged in conversations about housing are engaged in this conversation about housing.

539
01:04:48.748 --> 01:04:57.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I don't actually see in this plan a place where we say to Portland, is this what we want housing to look like in our community?

540
01:04:57.882 --> 01:05:02.438
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so, Chair, I hear you saying that that is part 2 of the plan, but I don't see it here.

541
01:05:04.275 --> 01:05:18.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think we need to be very honest with ourselves, because if what we are doing is having a conversation of the usual suspects about whether we're going in the direction that the usual suspects all want to go, let's not call this community engagement.

542
01:05:19.083 --> 01:05:20.326
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's call it stakeholder engagement.

543
01:05:21.414 --> 01:05:34.813
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if what we actually mean is that we want to hear from Portlanders, will this plan create the type of place that you want to live in a way that allows you to live with the people you want to live with in a way that is affordable?

544
01:05:36.065 --> 01:06:04.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Then we need that to be in the plan, and we need to not just say it's in the plan, and we need to think very intentionally about what types of questions we're asking, because I fear that we will ask questions that point people to an answer or that limit their ability to think creatively about what they want their future to be in our community because we just ask technical A or B questions.

545
01:06:04.942 --> 01:06:11.385
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I hope that— I hope that we are talking about true community engagement.

546
01:06:12.048 --> 01:06:13.643
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we are, I need to see it here.

547
01:06:15.527 --> 01:06:40.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we are, I hope that that is something where you use us as folks who are in community regularly to help think about how we might ask some of those questions to really allow our community, not just our engaged stakeholders, to think about our community's future.

548
01:06:42.373 --> 01:06:50.894
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What that looks like and to really buy into what is at the end of the day a big change for Portland.

549
01:06:51.201 --> 01:06:56.289
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because if we're talking about building this many units, that changes the face of our city.

550
01:06:57.237 --> 01:06:58.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that's what we need, right?

551
01:06:58.688 --> 01:07:06.706
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know that this is Portland's moment where we're kind of saying we're not the big boys.

552
01:07:07.282 --> 01:07:08.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Little town anymore.

553
01:07:08.313 --> 01:07:09.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're not the big little city.

554
01:07:09.440 --> 01:07:12.726
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're actually becoming a more urbanized city.

555
01:07:14.570 --> 01:07:19.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's a change in what our city looks like, and that's hard.

556
01:07:20.666 --> 01:07:22.898
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have to be bringing Portlanders along with us.

557
01:07:23.092 --> 01:07:23.916
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have to do it.

558
01:07:23.981 --> 01:07:32.039
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can't create this in a way where Portlanders are telling us we can't go there, because we know it is what our community needs, and leadership means helping get there.

559
01:07:32.818 --> 01:07:45.525
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But if we're not bringing people along with us, it's going to be really hard to get there in a way that is comprehensive and that includes all of our neighbors, all of our neighborhoods, all of our communities.

560
01:07:46.775 --> 01:07:54.635
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I hope that's what we mean by community engagement, and I hope that you will work with us to help make sure that we can do it successfully and bring people along with us.

561
01:07:56.242 --> 01:07:56.856
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll end there for now.

562
01:07:56.923 --> 01:07:57.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

563
01:08:00.847 --> 01:08:01.297
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

564
01:08:01.650 --> 01:08:02.740
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Koyama Lane.

565
01:08:03.398 --> 01:08:03.976
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Chair.

566
01:08:04.378 --> 01:08:05.548
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for the presentation.

567
01:08:05.661 --> 01:08:19.347
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's so much in here that I'm very excited about, specifically looking at Phase 1, calling attention to housing that meets the need of youth, families, older adults, people with disabilities, caregivers.

568
01:08:20.502 --> 01:08:26.856
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We know that Portland needs to be a place that people can age in and be able to thrive.

569
01:08:27.405 --> 01:08:37.761
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know about a year ago, Councilor Avalos made the decision to make sure to include the Age and Disability Inclusive Neighborhoods AIDEN Action Plan into the Unified Housing Strategy.

570
01:08:37.876 --> 01:08:38.966
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for doing that, Chair.

571
01:08:40.561 --> 01:08:44.395
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I see it mentioned on slide 11, I believe.

572
01:08:44.895 --> 01:09:02.320
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm wondering if someone can explain a little bit more about the city strategies and plans versus not city adopted but included and the differences and Yeah, any possibilities of making that plan be one that is officially under city strategies and plans?

573
01:09:04.408 --> 01:09:16.505
<v Jessie Connor>So the difference between those 2 categories, Councilor, is that the top, the city-adopted ones, they've gone through the full legislative process and either been adopted by resolution or ordinance.

574
01:09:17.198 --> 01:09:23.282
<v Jessie Connor>The other 3, I mean, Metro's Plan, um, is a different jurisdiction's plan.

575
01:09:24.376 --> 01:09:34.997
<v Jessie Connor>But, uh, we do— I mean, we could put them on the spot a little bit, but we do have, uh, members of Planning and Sustainability that could speak more specifically about Aiden.

576
01:09:37.198 --> 01:09:40.073
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's just helpful, and I, I will be following up.

577
01:09:40.139 --> 01:09:41.065
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm excited about that.

578
01:09:41.618 --> 01:09:54.378
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am curious, um, how are we as a committee able to track which elements from the ADEN plan are being implemented so we can know and the public can know.

579
01:09:55.011 --> 01:09:57.694
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are there any thoughts that anyone wants to share about that?

580
01:09:59.435 --> 01:10:15.255
<v Jessie Connor>There are a couple of ideas that we've been thinking about, perhaps around a dashboard with the— around the inventory, the Phase 1 inventory, because that really is the sort of laundry list of all of the pieces in connecting those.

581
01:10:15.768 --> 01:10:42.550
<v Jessie Connor>And while AIDEN may not be a council-adopted plan, I do know that Planning and Sustainability made a concerted and intentional effort to incorporate elements of that body of work into parts of the housing production strategy, which Thank you.

582
01:10:43.483 --> 01:10:59.485
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And within Goal 1, was glad to see that the strategies listed right away were around accessible housing production, aging in place and community, specifically creating an accessible housing inventory.

583
01:10:59.844 --> 01:11:16.643
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I know my staff and I have been meeting with advocates and experts and understand that there isn't a city in Oregon yet, including Portland, that actually has knowledge of their accessible housing stock and that there isn't a known clear method or approach yet.

584
01:11:17.462 --> 01:11:20.109
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We don't seem to collect the information during the permitting process.

585
01:11:20.158 --> 01:11:26.225
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I'm wondering if anyone can speak to what's our plan to do that inventory.

586
01:11:26.563 --> 01:11:27.573
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's very exciting.

587
01:11:28.216 --> 01:11:29.435
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, excuse me.

588
01:11:29.595 --> 01:11:34.298
<v Josh Roper>We've been working on an RFP for an affordable housing listing service.

589
01:11:34.796 --> 01:11:47.855
<v Josh Roper>And the goal would be to have that provider able to, well, to set up the system so that people can filter by certain features, including, you know, accessible units and other characteristics.

590
01:11:48.416 --> 01:11:53.256
<v Josh Roper>The idea is for that platform to be focused on affordable though, right?

591
01:11:53.319 --> 01:11:55.610
<v Josh Roper>Not the entire housing market.

592
01:11:57.085 --> 01:12:07.493
<v Josh Roper>I'm not sure what the options for non-affordable market look like currently, but that at least is what we're trying to fill a gap with.

593
01:12:09.380 --> 01:12:09.493
<v Shannon Buno>Yeah.

594
01:12:09.573 --> 01:12:10.511
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Really exciting.

595
01:12:10.932 --> 01:12:18.649
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I don't have to convince any of you that we need to know what the current stock is to know how we get to where we need to be in the future.

596
01:12:18.729 --> 01:12:19.438
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So thank you.

597
01:12:19.743 --> 01:12:20.097
<v Josh Roper>Thank you.

598
01:12:23.527 --> 01:12:23.832
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

599
01:12:24.122 --> 01:12:27.310
<v Candace Avalos>So we are going to go back around into the stack.

600
01:12:27.390 --> 01:12:29.949
<v Candace Avalos>We'll go right to you in a second, Vice Chair Green.

601
01:12:30.476 --> 01:12:36.436
<v Candace Avalos>Let me just offer a couple more guided questions that I'd love for you all to weigh in on.

602
01:12:38.699 --> 01:12:43.488
<v Candace Avalos>You know, we want to make sure that we— thank you for all the comments people are making about the objectives.

603
01:12:43.747 --> 01:12:51.094
<v Candace Avalos>And I'll just note, definitely agree with your points, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, and it is the intention to do that.

604
01:12:51.158 --> 01:12:56.233
<v Candace Avalos>But I agree with the framing, especially your framing around the city will change.

605
01:12:56.527 --> 01:12:56.918
<v Candace Avalos>I agree.

606
01:12:57.148 --> 01:12:58.226
<v Candace Avalos>And I do think that we need to—.

607
01:12:58.226 --> 01:12:58.373
<v Candace Avalos>I agree.

608
01:12:58.582 --> 01:13:02.287
<v Candace Avalos>Talk about that when we're asking Portlanders what they want their housing future to be.

609
01:13:02.367 --> 01:13:07.340
<v Candace Avalos>So I would welcome you and everybody on this committee as we get into that phase.

610
01:13:07.387 --> 01:13:10.868
<v Candace Avalos>Let's talk about how we talk about that with Portlanders and ask those questions.

611
01:13:11.318 --> 01:13:18.021
<v Candace Avalos>Also, Councilor Novick, definitely don't want to overwhelm the public, so we'll want to make sure that we're dwindling that down.

612
01:13:18.070 --> 01:13:40.661
<v Candace Avalos>And I'll just say, I believe that my goal in having this first phase of engagement be the stakeholders, one, like I said earlier, is because I want I want the stakeholders to buy in, literally in some cases, but also figuratively to just say, like, this is, you know, if these are the plans that the city has, these are areas of our work that already overlap with the city, how can we make those align?

613
01:13:42.351 --> 01:13:48.291
<v Candace Avalos>But then also, I want Portlanders, I don't want to overwhelm them by giving them all of those details.

614
01:13:48.340 --> 01:13:53.291
<v Candace Avalos>I think we want to give them the overarching goals and ask the questions that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney is asking, right?

615
01:13:53.340 --> 01:13:54.930
<v Candace Avalos>Like, what does your housing future look like?

616
01:13:54.996 --> 01:13:55.422
<v Candace Avalos>What do you need?

617
01:13:55.471 --> 01:14:08.800
<v Candace Avalos>And then they will be able to react to something because I I want them to react to a list that they can say, of these, the shortlist, these are the things that are rising to my priority, so we can get a temperature check from the public.

618
01:14:08.847 --> 01:14:12.606
<v Candace Avalos>So that's what I'm hoping that phase with the community looks like.

619
01:14:13.971 --> 01:14:15.948
<v Candace Avalos>And so we'll go back around.

620
01:14:15.996 --> 01:14:23.319
<v Candace Avalos>I think I would love to learn more about if there's anything that people feel is missing from these lists.

621
01:14:23.465 --> 01:14:32.956
<v Candace Avalos>I think the only thing that's missing is the and also what we like about the approach, because I'll note that the way that we started, we had the 5 Ps and we kind of were going to just go through each P and make objectives.

622
01:14:33.052 --> 01:14:39.095
<v Candace Avalos>And we realized that 3 of those Ps should just be incorporated with preserve and produce, right?

623
01:14:39.159 --> 01:14:47.929
<v Candace Avalos>So preserving, anti-displacement, sustainability, all of those things should be parts of the bigger goals of production and preservation.

624
01:14:47.976 --> 01:14:50.045
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm curious to hear your reaction to that.

625
01:14:50.743 --> 01:14:53.884
<v Candace Avalos>Because that was a shift that we made and I want to see if that feels right.

626
01:14:54.835 --> 01:15:00.994
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll leave that question there and then we'll get the queue going up with Vice Chair.

627
01:15:01.689 --> 01:15:02.546
<v Mitch Green>Go ahead.

628
01:15:02.595 --> 01:15:03.452
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

629
01:15:03.565 --> 01:15:09.791
<v Mitch Green>And I'll speak to your prompt question first and then I sort of raised my hand for a couple different other reasons.

630
01:15:09.872 --> 01:15:26.712
<v Mitch Green>But yeah, I think the thing that's missing for me so far and what I hope maybe we can roll into as we move forward is Is some sort of systematic way to analyze, I guess, to work backwards from the goal 1.

631
01:15:27.532 --> 01:15:30.840
<v Mitch Green>Like, what would we— what would some planning timelines need to look like?

632
01:15:31.161 --> 01:15:40.618
<v Mitch Green>Like, for example, like, if we identify that we are going to pursue a plumbing code change, say, you know, agenda, like, how long would that take?

633
01:15:41.036 --> 01:15:42.112
<v Mitch Green>And what would the impacts be?

634
01:15:42.578 --> 01:15:48.239
<v Mitch Green>Similarly so, like, if we were to adopt Inter-Eastside for All, Next, what was the timeline?

635
01:15:48.837 --> 01:15:49.649
<v Mitch Green>Well, it'll be next year.

636
01:15:51.292 --> 01:15:59.622
<v Mitch Green>Then how long, of course, from the time that we would adopt that, would we expect to see sort of the necessary kind of state planning goal timelines be?

637
01:15:59.685 --> 01:16:15.255
<v Mitch Green>Like having a matrix of almost like a Gantt chart of what those timelines look like could be really helpful for not only the community, but this council, because every day that we lose is just a delayed— it just gets costlier down the road for that marginal unit of housing that's gonna be produced.

638
01:16:16.127 --> 01:16:28.069
<v Mitch Green>And so I think it might help us raise up both just the interdependencies at play here between BPS, Housing Bureau, and the rest of the city, but also just the urgency for us.

639
01:16:29.313 --> 01:16:41.405
<v Mitch Green>So that's maybe new work here, but I do think it's crucial for unpacking this kind of like spaghetti of sort of policy strategies that's built into here.

640
01:16:44.363 --> 01:16:48.426
<v Mitch Green>To the comments, I wanted to respond to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

641
01:16:48.474 --> 01:16:57.912
<v Mitch Green>You raised, I think, a really important set of concerns and questions regarding the intergenerational housing and kind of the family-scale stuff.

642
01:16:58.025 --> 01:17:00.430
<v Mitch Green>You also, Councilor Koyama Lane, you spoke to that as well.

643
01:17:01.869 --> 01:17:06.668
<v Mitch Green>When I think about social housing, I think about that as the big opportunity to take that issue head on.

644
01:17:07.365 --> 01:17:07.836
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

645
01:17:08.875 --> 01:17:15.265
<v Mitch Green>I think the comment about, you know, covenants and are we violating those is well taken.

646
01:17:16.020 --> 01:17:29.636
<v Mitch Green>And so when we do social housing, or as we're sort of analyzing and contemplating it, I really don't want us to try to reimagine in like, how do we do the same thing we've been doing but just slightly different with a different brand?

647
01:17:29.908 --> 01:17:34.693
<v Mitch Green>I don't really want to reproduce the same regulatory burden that has led us to a place that we've gotten.

648
01:17:35.302 --> 01:17:39.298
<v Mitch Green>If we— if that's what we get out of social housing, we will have failed, frankly, as far as I'm concerned.

649
01:17:40.519 --> 01:17:46.103
<v Mitch Green>So to that end, like, it's less about AMI levels for me and more about what is our planning problem.

650
01:17:46.520 --> 01:17:50.533
<v Mitch Green>We need X amount of housing for family-sized units by this date.

651
01:17:51.399 --> 01:18:01.298
<v Mitch Green>How do we set up— how do we have the public sector step in as the guiding force there with the financing and the sort of regulatory framework to unlock that.

652
01:18:01.828 --> 01:18:07.180
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, I think about why people leave Multnomah County.

653
01:18:08.333 --> 01:18:12.628
<v Mitch Green>There's a lot of different reasons why people leave Multnomah County, but the largest is affordability.

654
01:18:13.462 --> 01:18:16.988
<v Mitch Green>And most people by definition who leave are not rich.

655
01:18:17.389 --> 01:18:23.318
<v Mitch Green>They are working-class families who can't make it work in the city of Portland.

656
01:18:23.557 --> 01:18:25.609
<v Mitch Green>They've had to move further and further to the margins.

657
01:18:25.867 --> 01:18:28.115
<v Mitch Green>To find 2, 3-bedroom housing.

658
01:18:29.668 --> 01:18:33.519
<v Mitch Green>And then they finally give up and they move to Clackamas County or Clark County or Washington County.

659
01:18:34.819 --> 01:18:44.355
<v Mitch Green>And we can actually have, if we do it right, and we've intentionally built intergenerational living spaces or even just traditional family spaces.

660
01:18:45.443 --> 01:18:46.952
<v Mitch Green>And we've said, this is social housing.

661
01:18:47.228 --> 01:18:48.167
<v Mitch Green>You've got a lifetime lease.

662
01:18:48.850 --> 01:18:51.806
<v Mitch Green>You've hereditary rights to this lease that you can pass down through the generations.

663
01:18:52.632 --> 01:19:01.225
<v Mitch Green>Then you've created— you've like frozen in time a cost basis for a family that can stay and they can grow into their income a little bit.

664
01:19:01.354 --> 01:19:06.036
<v Mitch Green>I think that's like the thing I think about most when that thing comes up.

665
01:19:06.100 --> 01:19:18.926
<v Mitch Green>We've built a lot of— by having the market lead, even in affordable housing, which is sometimes thought of as non-market, we've had the result being a lot of studios built and one bedrooms built because that's how things pencil out on the pro forma.

666
01:19:19.006 --> 01:19:21.378
<v Mitch Green>And it has led to a mismatch in demand and supply.

667
01:19:22.029 --> 01:19:24.185
<v Mitch Green>So that's my comment on that.

668
01:19:24.251 --> 01:19:28.774
<v Mitch Green>So I'm really supportive for us thinking about family and intergenerational living as a thing to be solved for.

669
01:19:30.699 --> 01:19:37.007
<v Mitch Green>In the document on social housing, I really appreciate the kind of— I know it was a quick breeze-by on the presentation, but I did do the pre-read.

670
01:19:37.671 --> 01:19:39.854
<v Mitch Green>And a few things I want to note that I appreciate.

671
01:19:41.420 --> 01:20:05.412
<v Mitch Green>Calling out the limited profit housing area as being one of the big opportunities is It's pretty crucial because it's sort of, even though we haven't done the alternative financing yet, it sort of suggests that there's the space for sort of nonprofit or NGO or sort of community orgs that could also be development partners with the City of Portland.

672
01:20:05.829 --> 01:20:08.211
<v Mitch Green>And our job is to help them do it and do it well.

673
01:20:08.983 --> 01:20:12.038
<v Mitch Green>One part that I would offer as a suggestion is— I think that's a great point.

674
01:20:12.775 --> 01:20:17.143
<v Mitch Green>There's a line that says it serves low and moderate income households from 0 to 120% AMI.

675
01:20:18.170 --> 01:20:21.155
<v Mitch Green>I think serves those AMIs is too restrictive.

676
01:20:21.604 --> 01:20:27.672
<v Mitch Green>Like, I think we should prioritize those AMI groups to get into limited profit housing, but I don't think we should means test them beyond that.

677
01:20:27.737 --> 01:20:38.814
<v Mitch Green>So I don't want the social housing stock that's part of the limited profit housing association approach to forever always think about how are we always calibrating these units for those AMI levels.

678
01:20:38.877 --> 01:20:47.760
<v Mitch Green>I want folks to be able to have You know, if you're a single mother or you're a recent college grad, you should have first in line kind of access.

679
01:20:47.989 --> 01:20:49.069
<v Mitch Green>But once you're there, you're there.

680
01:20:49.449 --> 01:20:52.239
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's the magic of this type of housing.

681
01:20:53.350 --> 01:21:01.149
<v Mitch Green>And I just think throughout the document, we should strive to decouple from HUD AMI levels as much as possible because for one, well, 2 reasons.

682
01:21:01.149 --> 01:21:02.729
<v Mitch Green>One, it's really confusing to the public.

683
01:21:02.729 --> 01:21:08.649
<v Mitch Green>I mean, I think everyone in this room knows and can live and breathe AMIs and like you can right off the top of your head know what an AMI at 60% is.

684
01:21:08.649 --> 01:21:08.670
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

685
01:21:08.761 --> 01:21:10.835
<v Mitch Green>60% Rent, it looks like, but most people don't.

686
01:21:11.413 --> 01:21:13.872
<v Mitch Green>And I have to do my homework before I think about it too.

687
01:21:14.466 --> 01:21:20.301
<v Mitch Green>I think just thinking about it in terms of serving most Portlanders is a really good way to think about it.

688
01:21:21.199 --> 01:21:32.896
<v Mitch Green>And these are cost-based rental models where, again, as I said, prioritize folks at the lower end of the income distribution or of higher need, and then never check again.

689
01:21:34.997 --> 01:21:38.724
<v Mitch Green>Really, really happy to see TOPA and right of first refusal language in there.

690
01:21:38.948 --> 01:21:42.448
<v Mitch Green>For those following along, that's tenant opportunity to purchase.

691
01:21:43.507 --> 01:21:58.345
<v Mitch Green>Having some legislation that we adopt that comes out of this recommendation to facilitate renters becoming owners of their apartment buildings through a limited equity model is, I think, a really very Portland thing that we can do.

692
01:21:58.859 --> 01:22:04.845
<v Mitch Green>And that's a way that we can Plug in some of our local institutions to kind of turnkey social housing a little bit.

693
01:22:06.840 --> 01:22:08.342
<v Mitch Green>Lots of great language on tenant governance.

694
01:22:08.391 --> 01:22:11.980
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm trying to be mindful of how much I'm speaking here, so I'll just leave it there.

695
01:22:12.850 --> 01:22:16.993
<v Mitch Green>Looking forward to the broader study being complete.

696
01:22:17.090 --> 01:22:20.911
<v Mitch Green>And just last note, the literature review of social housing models.

697
01:22:20.958 --> 01:22:50.489
<v Mitch Green>I just want to note that most of these cities, Montgomery County, sorry, taking notes.

698
01:22:51.000 --> 01:22:51.550
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

699
01:22:52.136 --> 01:23:01.475
<v Candace Avalos>I put myself in the queue to say a couple of things in response to some of that because completely agree as it relates to the means testing.

700
01:23:02.220 --> 01:23:06.782
<v Candace Avalos>And we talk a lot about aging in place, and I want to talk about waging in place.

701
01:23:06.863 --> 01:23:07.462
<v Candace Avalos>I'm going to make that a thing.

702
01:23:07.720 --> 01:23:07.916
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

703
01:23:08.466 --> 01:23:22.644
<v Candace Avalos>Because that's the issue, and that's what we learned a lot about in Vienna, is that you should be able to get in, and then it— you should not have to fear that if you are moving yourself up, And gaining economic prosperity, that now you're risking your housing.

704
01:23:22.756 --> 01:23:31.764
<v Candace Avalos>Because if you just are $1 above whatever arbitrary line that has been set, it doesn't mean that you can suddenly afford, you know, some luxury apartment, right?

705
01:23:31.828 --> 01:23:37.416
<v Candace Avalos>But what it— then, you know, people are often restricting themselves just so that they can keep their housing.

706
01:23:37.528 --> 01:23:38.539
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, I hear it all the time.

707
01:23:38.587 --> 01:23:45.011
<v Candace Avalos>I'm sure we all hear that from folks who are— and it's not even— it's not just housing we hear it on, like food stamps or other services.

708
01:23:45.060 --> 01:23:49.091
<v Candace Avalos>So I just, I really want to encourage us to get away from AMI.

709
01:23:49.878 --> 01:24:03.422
<v Candace Avalos>And one way that I talk about it in my district, because in East Portland they talk a lot about, like, I hear people say, we don't want to have all the affordable housing in our part of the town, like, why doesn't it share it across the city and all of that.

710
01:24:03.551 --> 01:24:12.082
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that mentality comes from, you know, a certain place that I can understand, but my response is always, it's not about building affordable housing.

711
01:24:12.131 --> 01:24:13.898
<v Candace Avalos>It's about building housing that's affordable.

712
01:24:14.073 --> 01:24:25.605
<v Candace Avalos>Like, we have to reframe that so that we're not thinking about affordable housing as, you know, just some kind of— like, I think there's a mentality that it's like trashy housing that nobody wants to live in.

713
01:24:26.185 --> 01:24:33.685
<v Candace Avalos>And, and so what I try to stress to my constituents is, I want— do you want your neighbors to be able to afford to live here, right?

714
01:24:33.750 --> 01:24:39.457
<v Candace Avalos>If we keep getting priced out, we have the least economic thank you.

715
01:24:40.152 --> 01:24:52.796
<v Candace Avalos>And so I just want to encourage us as we continue to talk about that, that we use that framing, because when we bring this conversation to the public, to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's earlier points around there might be fear, right?

716
01:24:52.845 --> 01:25:00.673
<v Candace Avalos>Or there might be discomfort in the change that will come with increasing housing stock and neighborhoods change and all of that.

717
01:25:00.755 --> 01:25:11.591
<v Candace Avalos>And we want to get away from this mentality that that's a bad thing, but we have to prove that it's a good thing by making sure that we're putting all the supports around it, that we're building neighborhoods that have amenities, right?

718
01:25:11.831 --> 01:25:14.030
<v Candace Avalos>Because that's the other thing that I hear in East Portland.

719
01:25:14.078 --> 01:25:19.872
<v Candace Avalos>People are concerned also that we're just going to build up a bunch of housing and we're not going to have anything around it, right?

720
01:25:19.938 --> 01:25:36.599
<v Candace Avalos>It's like, sure, there's a lot of land in East Portland that we could build things on, but if you're not building infrastructure around it, and especially in a place that already lacks so many basic infrastructure needs like sidewalks, then that makes the idea of having more housing in their neighborhood feel less appealing.

721
01:25:36.957 --> 01:25:39.550
<v Candace Avalos>So we have to continue to work on that mind shift.

722
01:25:41.060 --> 01:25:42.717
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I'll leave it at that for now.

723
01:25:43.168 --> 01:25:45.212
<v Candace Avalos>I don't see anyone else in the queue right now.

724
01:25:45.358 --> 01:25:50.155
<v Candace Avalos>Let me prompt you with a couple other questions and see if folks will get back in the queue.

725
01:25:52.487 --> 01:25:52.890
<v Candace Avalos>Hold on.

726
01:25:54.720 --> 01:25:57.494
<v Candace Avalos>So can we talk a little bit more about engagement?

727
01:25:58.889 --> 01:26:05.628
<v Candace Avalos>I, you know, we're starting to discuss what are our expectations for like how we talk to the public.

728
01:26:05.742 --> 01:26:06.354
<v Candace Avalos>Hold on.

729
01:26:06.904 --> 01:26:08.051
<v Candace Avalos>No, I'm just in the queue.

730
01:26:08.471 --> 01:26:09.054
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, great.

731
01:26:09.862 --> 01:26:10.055
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

732
01:26:10.121 --> 01:26:11.478
<v Candace Avalos>I see you're in the queue, Councilor Novick.

733
01:26:11.559 --> 01:26:13.012
<v Candace Avalos>I'll finish this question and then answer.

734
01:26:13.158 --> 01:26:14.628
<v Candace Avalos>You can answer that or say whatever you need to say.

735
01:26:16.268 --> 01:26:20.574
<v Candace Avalos>Help me think through what does that phasing look like?

736
01:26:20.639 --> 01:26:28.716
<v Candace Avalos>Because like I said, I think that there's a couple of different— there's a different way to approach the different stakeholder groups, right?

737
01:26:28.845 --> 01:26:31.744
<v Candace Avalos>And I want to hear from you all how you're thinking about that.

738
01:26:32.645 --> 01:26:41.443
<v Candace Avalos>And just in general, also, I would love to know what is this committee's interest in now moving forward being more a part of this?

739
01:26:41.506 --> 01:26:45.114
<v Candace Avalos>Because as you know, this committee is all brand new to the housing work.

740
01:26:45.163 --> 01:26:48.613
<v Candace Avalos>So a lot of this for you all, you know, we've been working on this over the last year.

741
01:26:49.003 --> 01:26:59.122
<v Candace Avalos>And so I also just would love to hear from the councilors, what is your intent in helping to shape these next few steps that are going to be very public-facing?

742
01:26:59.301 --> 01:27:00.386
<v Candace Avalos>And I would love your support.

743
01:27:00.658 --> 01:27:02.377
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, Councilor Novick, go ahead.

744
01:27:03.212 --> 01:27:14.952
<v Steve Novick>Madam Chair, looking at the list, I was thinking that one way we might divide up the strategies for public discussion is there's a number of the strategies that involve spending money on something or other.

745
01:27:15.354 --> 01:27:21.681
<v Steve Novick>So we might want to sort of slim that down and say, okay, here's ways we could spend money, which ways make sense to you?

746
01:27:22.387 --> 01:27:23.979
<v Steve Novick>And then there's policy choices.

747
01:27:24.042 --> 01:27:25.664
<v Steve Novick>I mean, some of them are like nobody disagrees.

748
01:27:25.777 --> 01:27:26.788
<v Steve Novick>Yes, we should streamline permitting.

749
01:27:27.371 --> 01:27:30.945
<v Steve Novick>But then there's a question of should we change zoning to make it easier to build more things somewhere?

750
01:27:31.027 --> 01:27:34.715
<v Steve Novick>I mean, that's something that is a policy choice people might have different views on.

751
01:27:35.555 --> 01:27:42.384
<v Steve Novick>As far as community engagement, I was thinking about what Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said about, you know, are we just engaging stakeholders?

752
01:27:42.658 --> 01:27:50.030
<v Steve Novick>And I was thinking personally, I always like doing scientific polls on issues where it makes sense.

753
01:27:50.304 --> 01:27:54.868
<v Steve Novick>So we make sure that we're not just— we're listening to a large cross-section of the community.

754
01:27:55.443 --> 01:28:12.189
<v Steve Novick>But another thing you can do, which is something actually I've had people lobbying me on in different contexts in the past few months, is to have citizen juries to like randomly select a group of people drawn from all over the place to sit and think about a problem.

755
01:28:12.847 --> 01:28:14.582
<v Steve Novick>And maybe it's 24 people.

756
01:28:14.791 --> 01:28:29.104
<v Steve Novick>I mean, and by definition, that's not a statistically significant group, but I think other jurisdictions have had some success pulling together a group of people and you'd have to like, you know, pay them for their time to come in and study a public policy problem and come up with recommendations.

757
01:28:30.115 --> 01:28:34.020
<v Steve Novick>And so that's, you know, something different from a poll of 400 people.

758
01:28:34.390 --> 01:28:42.875
<v Steve Novick>It's something different from inviting, talking to people who happen to show up at a, you know, at a neighborhood association or one of the groups we talk about.

759
01:28:43.453 --> 01:28:46.168
<v Steve Novick>So that's something that I would be really interested in exploring.

760
01:28:47.739 --> 01:28:49.789
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

761
01:28:49.789 --> 01:28:52.069
<v Candace Avalos>I will Google that and look into it more.

762
01:28:52.069 --> 01:28:53.489
<v Candace Avalos>And it sounds like you've had some info.

763
01:28:53.489 --> 01:28:54.699
<v Candace Avalos>I would love if you would share it with me.

764
01:28:54.829 --> 01:28:58.220
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I can, I can sic the people who've been sicced on me on you too.

765
01:28:58.649 --> 01:28:59.590
<v Candace Avalos>Send them my way.

766
01:28:59.989 --> 01:29:01.550
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

767
01:29:01.550 --> 01:29:03.579
<v Candace Avalos>All right, uh, Councilor Koyama Lane.

768
01:29:04.029 --> 01:29:04.590
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Chair.

769
01:29:04.590 --> 01:29:07.630
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are we moving to the engagement conversation, those questions?

770
01:29:08.210 --> 01:29:08.510
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

771
01:29:08.510 --> 01:29:10.529
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, I think we're— it's open-ended, so if you'd like to—.

772
01:29:10.529 --> 01:29:15.496
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, yeah, that's kind of what I wanted to add on to, and I appreciated Councilor Pirtle-Guiney bringing Thank you.

773
01:29:15.543 --> 01:29:17.648
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Smith, thank you for bringing up the question about engagement.

774
01:29:17.792 --> 01:29:23.301
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think advisory bodies are important, and we can look at the inventory to see which ones align.

775
01:29:23.557 --> 01:29:27.122
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And we also know that a lot of the people that join those are already engaged.

776
01:29:27.186 --> 01:29:28.826
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's what we were kind of talking about.

777
01:29:29.420 --> 01:29:37.417
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also view our job as city councilors as representing our districts, for us to be doing a lot of that engagement.

778
01:29:37.930 --> 01:29:45.783
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And we have every district represented up here, so I would love to think about what that What our role is as committee members.

779
01:29:46.041 --> 01:30:05.550
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And engagement doesn't always have to be fancy or expensive, but thinking about what that can look like in terms of town halls or trying to do some of our own paid polls, or maybe just some of our own serving and making ourselves available in our districts to bring back here what is the pulse in our district on some of these topics.

780
01:30:05.710 --> 01:30:06.336
<v Claire>Thank you.

781
01:30:10.479 --> 01:30:10.819
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

782
01:30:11.060 --> 01:30:14.551
<v Candace Avalos>I definitely agree and would love to take Housing Committee to the streets.

783
01:30:14.793 --> 01:30:18.380
<v Candace Avalos>So we'll talk about, um, some ways that I, I have some ideas on that.

784
01:30:20.323 --> 01:30:22.171
<v Candace Avalos>All right, we're winding down a bit.

785
01:30:22.349 --> 01:30:23.842
<v Candace Avalos>I don't see anyone else in the queue.

786
01:30:24.341 --> 01:30:31.287
<v Candace Avalos>Um, let me just look at my notes on if there are any final things I wanted to make sure you all react to.

787
01:30:32.908 --> 01:30:44.503
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I will note that, uh, I owe Jesse a list and that I'm going to get to you eventually.

788
01:30:44.552 --> 01:30:45.579
<v Candace Avalos>I'm sorry.

789
01:30:45.853 --> 01:30:56.497
<v Candace Avalos>Um, but, um, uh, the bureaus put together— because also a reminder, the Unified Housing Strategy work is not just PHB, it's all of the essentially CSDA bureaus.

790
01:30:56.609 --> 01:31:00.998
<v Candace Avalos>So we've got BPS, we've got permitting, we've got Prosper in the room, we've got Portland Solutions.

791
01:31:01.418 --> 01:31:14.322
<v Candace Avalos>So we've got all of these cross-sections across the bureau, and we— they put together these lists of essentially the frequent flyers, right, of City Hall, people that have been engaged, are on all these committees.

792
01:31:14.742 --> 01:31:25.436
<v Candace Avalos>And they gave me this long document with all those lists, and what I've been doing is just going through them and just kind of seeing, you know, if I recognize names, if there are people that I know in community that I don't see on those lists.

793
01:31:25.838 --> 01:31:33.855
<v Candace Avalos>So I would love some support in you all, you know, reaching into your networks and adding to the list.

794
01:31:33.904 --> 01:31:37.131
<v Candace Avalos>So I would ask that folks be thinking about that.

795
01:31:37.180 --> 01:31:46.203
<v Candace Avalos>And if you want to send me ideas and names, soon we're going to start putting out feelers for times in summer to get— and this is like the stakeholder group.

796
01:31:46.268 --> 01:31:51.405
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm talking like the industry experts or developers or people in affordable housing, all of that.

797
01:31:51.502 --> 01:31:52.706
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

798
01:31:53.556 --> 01:31:56.846
<v Candace Avalos>And then, so I just wanted to mention that.

799
01:31:56.926 --> 01:31:57.826
<v Candace Avalos>I think I've asked—.

800
01:31:58.226 --> 01:31:59.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we have that current list?

801
01:32:00.216 --> 01:32:01.469
<v Candace Avalos>I have that list and I can send that.

802
01:32:01.757 --> 01:32:02.496
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you.

803
01:32:02.769 --> 01:32:02.864
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

804
01:32:03.587 --> 01:32:06.845
<v Candace Avalos>Um, well, I think we covered quite a bit.

805
01:32:06.893 --> 01:32:08.417
<v Candace Avalos>I want to check with you all.

806
01:32:08.561 --> 01:32:13.039
<v Candace Avalos>Is there anything that you didn't hear from us that you want to make sure you ask us that you need?

807
01:32:13.569 --> 01:32:14.949
<v Josh Roper>This has been really helpful.

808
01:32:14.997 --> 01:32:16.730
<v Josh Roper>I don't have anything in particular.

809
01:32:16.908 --> 01:32:17.180
<v Josh Roper>I don't know.

810
01:32:17.469 --> 01:32:19.378
<v Sandra Wood>No, just think we're, we're all aligned and happy.

811
01:32:19.671 --> 01:32:21.082
<v Sandra Wood>Know where we're going after this.

812
01:32:21.278 --> 01:32:22.447
<v Sandra Wood>I mean, yeah, it's good.

813
01:32:24.817 --> 01:32:25.684
<v Candace Avalos>Great, thank you so much.

814
01:32:25.877 --> 01:32:26.295
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

815
01:32:26.423 --> 01:32:28.302
<v Candace Avalos>Well, um, thank you, colleagues.

816
01:32:28.431 --> 01:32:29.539
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, the work continues.

817
01:32:29.636 --> 01:32:33.926
<v Candace Avalos>I think the next steps from here, as you saw on the timeline, we're going to be starting to do that engagement.

818
01:32:33.975 --> 01:32:35.069
<v Candace Avalos>I'll keep you posted on that.

819
01:32:35.520 --> 01:32:41.301
<v Candace Avalos>And then we're working towards, um, what will be a final product that honestly we're still trying to shape.

820
01:32:41.396 --> 01:33:01.257
<v Candace Avalos>And so that's another area I'd love your thoughts in the coming weeks, um, because the whole point of this exercise is for us to, as a city, as councilors, as representatives of our districts, of our constituents, to bring together our visions and make sure that we are communicating clearly to the staff what we expect out of housing policy, our housing future.

821
01:33:01.322 --> 01:33:03.791
<v Candace Avalos>So that's what they're looking to from us.

822
01:33:03.886 --> 01:33:14.646
<v Candace Avalos>And I'm hoping the final product, if you will, of this will be some culmination of a direction that council is directly giving to the city about what we want them to prioritize, what we want them to work on.

823
01:33:15.114 --> 01:33:22.944
<v Candace Avalos>And then that will inform us as we enter future budget discussions when we start seeing what we want to prioritize in funding.

824
01:33:25.315 --> 01:33:25.882
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you again.

825
01:33:25.932 --> 01:33:27.216
<v Candace Avalos>This has been a very helpful conversation.

826
01:33:28.555 --> 01:33:30.612
<v Candace Avalos>And yeah, we will continue soon.

827
01:33:31.179 --> 01:33:33.349
<v Candace Avalos>So we are going to take a quick break.

828
01:33:34.180 --> 01:33:35.574
<v Candace Avalos>We're going to take a 10-minute break.

829
01:33:35.671 --> 01:33:38.073
<v Candace Avalos>Actually, let's just come back at 3:45.

830
01:33:39.159 --> 01:33:41.189
<v Candace Avalos>And then from there, we'll go on to item 3, which is recap.

831
01:33:41.237 --> 01:33:41.335
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

832
01:33:42.046 --> 01:33:42.823
<v Candace Avalos>See you at 3:45.

833
01:46:43.524 --> 01:46:52.283
<v Candace Avalos>All right, colleagues and audience, we are going to get back started.

834
01:46:54.119 --> 01:46:55.831
<v Candace Avalos>Um, let's call Item 3, please.

835
01:46:57.979 --> 01:47:06.954
<v Diego>Item 3, amend City Code and improve land use regulations through the Regulatory Improvement Code Amendment Package 11.

836
01:47:07.652 --> 01:47:11.771
<v Diego>Amend Code Titles 20— excuse me, 32 and 33.

837
01:47:13.101 --> 01:47:13.567
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

838
01:47:14.368 --> 01:47:17.206
<v Candace Avalos>All right, if you all want to come up while I give some intro remarks.

839
01:47:17.253 --> 01:47:23.024
<v Candace Avalos>So colleagues, before us today is Regulatory Improvement Code Amendment Package 11, or recap.

840
01:47:23.826 --> 01:47:28.649
<v Candace Avalos>This is part of the city's ongoing effort to maintain and improve our zoning and land use code.

841
01:47:29.275 --> 01:47:40.528
<v Candace Avalos>While these amendments may not be headline-grabbing, they are important because they address the day-to-day challenges that residents businesses, nonprofit organizations, and city staff encounter when navigating our permitting and development processes.

842
01:47:41.217 --> 01:47:50.578
<v Candace Avalos>Recap projects are intended to identify technical corrections, clarify existing regulations, remove unnecessary barriers, and improve the overall functionality of our code.

843
01:47:50.916 --> 01:47:57.984
<v Candace Avalos>And this package includes dozens of relatively small amendments, but together they help create a more predictable, efficient, and user-friendly system.

844
01:47:58.529 --> 01:48:07.618
<v Candace Avalos>I appreciate the work of the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability and the Portland Permitting and Development staff, as well as the Planning Commission and community members who participated in reviewing this package.

845
01:48:08.404 --> 01:48:19.353
<v Candace Avalos>These types of code maintenance efforts are an important part of ensuring that our regulations continue to support housing production, economic activity, and effective service delivery while reducing confusion and administrative burden.

846
01:48:19.626 --> 01:48:21.069
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, I'll turn it over to staff.

847
01:48:21.869 --> 01:48:23.600
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you, Chair Avalos and councilors.

848
01:48:23.873 --> 01:48:25.748
<v Eric Engstrom>Appreciate the introduction.

849
01:48:25.877 --> 01:48:29.292
<v Eric Engstrom>For the record, my name is Eric Engstrom, Director of the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

850
01:48:30.301 --> 01:48:34.710
<v Eric Engstrom>Staff will carry the bulk of the presentation, but I just want to say a few things before we get started.

851
01:48:35.158 --> 01:48:38.670
<v Eric Engstrom>We're very happy to be bringing you regulatory improvement code package thank you.

852
01:48:38.670 --> 01:48:38.670
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

853
01:48:38.670 --> 01:48:42.770
<v Eric Engstrom>We now move to Agenda Item 2, Public Communications Package, aka Recap Number 11.

854
01:48:42.770 --> 01:48:46.250
<v Eric Engstrom>You said it well in terms of the purpose of it, so I won't reiterate that.

855
01:48:47.310 --> 01:48:56.239
<v Eric Engstrom>Continue to improving our regulations for development is one of my top priorities as director in partnership with other bureaus, including PBOT, PP&D, and Housing and others.

856
01:48:57.270 --> 01:49:00.250
<v Eric Engstrom>Councilor Green, I appreciate your moonshot comments earlier.

857
01:49:00.310 --> 01:49:02.350
<v Eric Engstrom>That's on point to this.

858
01:49:06.033 --> 01:49:06.759
<v Eric Engstrom>Agree.

859
01:49:06.855 --> 01:49:09.890
<v Eric Engstrom>I'd like to ramp up that effort to include more meaningful reforms.

860
01:49:10.729 --> 01:49:34.104
<v Eric Engstrom>And to that end, we will be bringing you a number of other projects to improve development regulations in the coming year-ish, including a plan to further look at design review reforms, a central city-focused package, of course, the Code Alignment Project, CAP 2, which is a collaboration focused on issues that cut across multiple city titles.

861
01:49:36.409 --> 01:49:51.011
<v Eric Engstrom>Collectively, all this means we're going to be looking at things like parking and frontage issues, repurposing existing buildings, elements of the tree code, continued work on middle housing codes, and a lot more.

862
01:49:52.270 --> 01:49:59.171
<v Eric Engstrom>Today is just a teaser at the— that again, as Chair Avalos mentioned, is fairly minor things, but collectively they matter.

863
01:49:59.350 --> 01:50:00.902
<v Eric Engstrom>And with that, I'll turn it over.

864
01:50:03.416 --> 01:50:03.609
<v Sandra Wood>Great.

865
01:50:03.675 --> 01:50:06.355
<v Sandra Wood>Good afternoon, Chair Avalos and councilors.

866
01:50:06.404 --> 01:50:07.405
<v Sandra Wood>My name is Sandra Wood.

867
01:50:07.551 --> 01:50:12.627
<v Sandra Wood>I'm with the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability, and I'm the code development manager.

868
01:50:12.725 --> 01:50:22.784
<v Sandra Wood>And with me today is JP McNeil, the project manager for this project, and Shannon Buno, who is our code editor, but in this case she's also a senior planner working on the project.

869
01:50:23.975 --> 01:50:37.573
<v Sandra Wood>As you all know, we're here for the Recap 11 hearing and to hear the Planning Commission's this is our agenda for our time together today.

870
01:50:37.717 --> 01:50:41.604
<v Sandra Wood>I'll provide some background on the program, its origins, and the current context.

871
01:50:41.912 --> 01:50:44.389
<v Sandra Wood>JP and Shannon will then share the proposals.

872
01:50:44.840 --> 01:50:52.865
<v Sandra Wood>Our presentation will conclude with the Planning Commission Vice Chair Lucas Pollack saying a few words about the Planning Commission's recommendations and an amendment they made.

873
01:50:52.913 --> 01:50:53.545
<v Sandra Wood>Thank you, Deputy City Attorney.

874
01:50:54.006 --> 01:50:58.180
<v Sandra Wood>Then we'll have time for oral testimony, though I believe no one has signed up.

875
01:50:58.261 --> 01:50:59.112
<v Sandra Wood>We can confirm that.

876
01:50:59.722 --> 01:51:04.170
<v Sandra Wood>And afterwards, the committee can have time to discuss and to take action on this item.

877
01:51:05.502 --> 01:51:31.057
<v Sandra Wood>The Planning Commission recommends that the City Council take the following actions: adopt the project report, amend Title 33 of the city code, which is the planning and zoning title, per the project Portland's current zoning code was rewritten entirely and adopted in 1990.

878
01:51:31.637 --> 01:51:37.381
<v Sandra Wood>And of course, as you might imagine, the world changes between the time of a new adoption of a zoning code.

879
01:51:37.786 --> 01:51:50.088
<v Sandra Wood>And so over time, there's changing needs, new laws and court rulings, new technology, and obviously some changing perspectives and priorities that necessitate updates and improvements to our regulations.

880
01:51:50.923 --> 01:51:56.480
<v Sandra Wood>So code maintenance is considered best practice in the regulatory and in the urban planning fields.

881
01:51:56.930 --> 01:52:18.626
<v Sandra Wood>Having the recap program helps us carry out one of our comprehensive plan policies, 10.4, which calls for promoting good planning by addressing existing problems, ensuring good administration of regulations by keeping regulations as simple as possible and improving the code document by using clear language and identifying and acting on regulatory improvement suggestions.

882
01:52:20.430 --> 01:52:21.270
<v Sandra Wood>So what is RCAP?

883
01:52:21.820 --> 01:52:25.847
<v Sandra Wood>As you've heard, the acronym stands for Regulatory Improvement Code Amendment Package.

884
01:52:26.350 --> 01:52:36.377
<v Sandra Wood>These are a bit different than other legislative packages in that their purpose is to provide an ongoing vehicle to ease regulatory burdens and make the zoning code easier to understand.

885
01:52:37.052 --> 01:52:42.144
<v Sandra Wood>Amendments address a variety of topics and geographies which are packaged together for efficiency.

886
01:52:42.891 --> 01:52:45.759
<v Sandra Wood>They're focused on technical and minor policy changes.

887
01:52:46.903 --> 01:52:51.479
<v Sandra Wood>Major policy requests are assigned to other projects like the ones that Eric was describing.

888
01:52:53.195 --> 01:53:05.306
<v Sandra Wood>The work plan is based on an online database of amendment suggestions that we receive from the public and implementers, and we have a fair and transparent selection process— selection criteria that are established.

889
01:53:06.829 --> 01:53:12.645
<v Sandra Wood>Just to note that RECAP is not the same as the Code Alignment Project, CAP, which you may have heard of.

890
01:53:13.112 --> 01:53:23.578
<v Sandra Wood>The main purpose of the new CAP program is to create alignment between different city codes, and RECAP has generally been mainly about the zoning code.

891
01:53:26.220 --> 01:53:29.930
<v Sandra Wood>So we use selection criteria to rank the suggestions that are received.

892
01:53:30.074 --> 01:53:41.131
<v Sandra Wood>This is to ensure that we are objective, as objective and transparent as possible, while keeping an eye on the comprehensive plan guiding principles of equity, health, prosperity, and resilience.

893
01:53:41.853 --> 01:53:44.641
<v Sandra Wood>The higher the score, the more likely an item will be addressed.

894
01:53:45.059 --> 01:53:53.198
<v Sandra Wood>We look at the variety of stakeholders affected by that issue, the geographic applicability, how— as in, how widespread is the issue?

895
01:53:53.247 --> 01:54:01.837
<v Sandra Wood>Does the degree of impact— how problematic is the issue when it's being implemented?

896
01:54:01.966 --> 01:54:07.393
<v Sandra Wood>Is there an avenue for an applicant to seek regulatory relief in the form of a land use review?

897
01:54:08.307 --> 01:54:17.813
<v Sandra Wood>And the regulatory improvement— what is the potential for improving the regulation without adding a lot of complexity and options for the development community and public to wade through?

898
01:54:18.198 --> 01:54:19.064
<v Jessie Connor>We put a lot of thought into this.

899
01:54:19.130 --> 01:54:26.923
<v Sandra Wood>We published the work plan with items we're addressing, but we also publish an appendix with the scores of the suggestions of items we did not select.

900
01:54:27.149 --> 01:54:29.037
<v Sandra Wood>And those are the 2 documents shown on the screen.

901
01:54:30.810 --> 01:54:33.868
<v Sandra Wood>This next slide summarizes the public involvement for RECAP 11.

902
01:54:34.143 --> 01:54:44.353
<v Sandra Wood>We published our work plan, and, um, in March of 2025, the discussion draft period was open for 6 weeks, and that is our proposal to the public.

903
01:54:44.400 --> 01:54:44.532
<v Sandra Wood>Thank you.

904
01:54:44.659 --> 01:54:44.916
<v Sandra Wood>Public.

905
01:54:45.559 --> 01:54:50.327
<v Sandra Wood>We do our public engagement, and it was open in the summer— last summer.

906
01:54:50.632 --> 01:54:54.726
<v Sandra Wood>We presented the proposal to several groups, including those listed on the slide.

907
01:54:55.514 --> 01:55:05.404
<v Sandra Wood>The MAP app, which is BPS's testimony repository that you're using for this process here too, was open during that time, and we received 36 comments.

908
01:55:06.769 --> 01:55:10.109
<v Sandra Wood>Many of those comments were about the Multnomah Safe Rest Village.

909
01:55:11.345 --> 01:55:18.104
<v Sandra Wood>We sent notice to over 700 people for the Planning Commission hearing that occurred in September.

910
01:55:18.570 --> 01:55:23.355
<v Sandra Wood>The commission received 12 pieces of written testimony and one person testified in person.

911
01:55:24.350 --> 01:55:26.407
<v Sandra Wood>And today this committee is holding another hearing.

912
01:55:27.225 --> 01:55:45.569
<v Sandra Wood>As of noon today, you received 8 pieces of written testimony on this matter, and as of that time, no one had signed up to finally, we've provided updates on the project to the 700 subscribers at each of our project milestones.

913
01:55:46.659 --> 01:55:50.354
<v Sandra Wood>With that background, I'll pass it on to JP and Shannon to discuss the proposals.

914
01:55:50.627 --> 01:55:50.949
<v Sandra Wood>Thank you.

915
01:55:51.591 --> 01:55:52.251
<v JP McNeil>Thanks, Sandra.

916
01:55:52.315 --> 01:55:53.890
<v JP McNeil>So my name is JP McNeill.

917
01:55:54.002 --> 01:55:56.707
<v JP McNeil>I'm a city planner with the Bureau of Planning Sustainability.

918
01:55:57.403 --> 01:56:01.206
<v JP McNeil>So Shannon and I will now go through the amendments that are in the RECAP 11 packet.

919
01:56:01.340 --> 01:56:02.863
<v JP McNeil>Thank you, Councilor Mitch.

920
01:56:03.072 --> 01:56:07.099
<v JP McNeil>So there are a total of 56 code amendments in Recap 11.

921
01:56:08.126 --> 01:56:12.810
<v JP McNeil>Sometimes for some recaps, the scope of the project is built around specific topics.

922
01:56:13.340 --> 01:56:21.234
<v JP McNeil>So for example, the last recap, Recap 10, there was a directive to focus on amendments that supported post-pandemic recovery and housing production.

923
01:56:22.229 --> 01:56:27.301
<v JP McNeil>For this recap, the amendments are bundled by topics that rose thank you.

924
01:56:27.350 --> 01:56:36.954
<v JP McNeil>There are 2 categories that rose to the top in the ranking process that Sandra was just talking about, and those themes were parking and exterior areas and activities.

925
01:56:37.711 --> 01:56:42.591
<v JP McNeil>There's also a 3rd, more general catch-all regulatory improvement category.

926
01:56:44.072 --> 01:56:54.505
<v JP McNeil>There are also 7 sign code amendments that were added to RECAP 11 to support some work that Parks is doing, and those amendments relate to wayfinding and moving image signs at Washington Park.

927
01:56:55.439 --> 01:57:01.837
<v JP McNeil>We won't be covering all of these amendments today, but we've pulled out some topics and examples to give you a sense of what's in the package.

928
01:57:03.130 --> 01:57:10.487
<v JP McNeil>There's a table at the beginning of the recommended draft that lists all of the amendments, including the technical ones, for your reference if you are interested.

929
01:57:11.970 --> 01:57:15.456
<v JP McNeil>All right, our first theme is a group of minor parking updates.

930
01:57:16.198 --> 01:57:18.023
<v JP McNeil>These fall into 2 subcategories.

931
01:57:18.136 --> 01:57:21.009
<v JP McNeil>One is related to vehicle parking and one is to bike parking.

932
01:57:22.167 --> 01:57:26.435
<v JP McNeil>Our bike parking amendments, we have 3 that are related to this topic.

933
01:57:27.381 --> 01:57:38.512
<v JP McNeil>The first 2 are to ensure that all bike parking users have access to the bike parking area, and this is resolving the issue of users being locked out of bike parking areas.

934
01:57:39.331 --> 01:57:48.939
<v JP McNeil>The second, there's also an amendment that would allow for a change of use in a building without triggering the requirement to install more bike parking.

935
01:57:49.453 --> 01:57:59.613
<v JP McNeil>So the rationale is that someone could come in for a permit for alterations and be exempt from the bike parking requirements under the nonconforming upgrade rules.

936
01:58:00.270 --> 01:58:08.922
<v JP McNeil>But a change of use, which isn't subject to those nonconforming upgrade rules, might not even include any alterations, and therefore it should also be exempt.

937
01:58:09.661 --> 01:58:17.189
<v JP McNeil>And the amendment, it creates more— it creates parity and makes it easier for businesses to open or to fill vacant commercial spaces.

938
01:58:20.095 --> 01:58:22.054
<v JP McNeil>Our vehicle parking amendments.

939
01:58:22.262 --> 01:58:26.726
<v JP McNeil>Of these, the one that we found the most significant is item MP3.

940
01:58:27.240 --> 01:58:33.760
<v JP McNeil>So this proposal is to allow parking in residential front setbacks when a garage is being converted to living area.

941
01:58:34.256 --> 01:58:40.775
<v JP McNeil>So under current code, as illustrated by the diagram on the left there, there's often a driveway.

942
01:58:41.048 --> 01:58:49.967
<v JP McNeil>It has to be removed and the curb cut cut closed when a garage is converted to, say, an ADU or other living area because parking isn't allowed in that front setback.

943
01:58:50.689 --> 01:58:56.847
<v JP McNeil>So this change would allow the driveway to remain provided it's at least 18 feet long and can accommodate a parking space.

944
01:58:57.649 --> 01:59:04.882
<v JP McNeil>And it only applies when there's an existing garage that is being converted and there's an existing driveway and an existing curb cut.

945
01:59:04.979 --> 01:59:08.426
<v JP McNeil>It would not allow for a new 18-foot deep driveway to be poured.

946
01:59:08.975 --> 01:59:12.814
<v JP McNeil>This makes residential conversions easier and more practical for homeowners.

947
01:59:15.832 --> 01:59:21.448
<v JP McNeil>The next category of amendments relate to exterior areas and activities, and there's 3 subcategories here.

948
01:59:22.534 --> 01:59:26.005
<v JP McNeil>One is screening, exterior activities, and common areas.

949
01:59:29.962 --> 01:59:42.588
<v JP McNeil>The first— there are proposed amendments to clarify setback and screening rules for mechanical equipment To ensure that it's screened when necessary without impeding the operation of common smaller equipment like heat pumps.

950
01:59:43.376 --> 02:00:11.064
<v JP McNeil>The Planning Commission amended this item to lessen the requirements for installation of mechanical equipment in single dwelling zones, but in multi-dwelling zones where larger equipment may create more impacts, screening requirements will remain with added requirement for screening from the street when it's located within a set there's also an amendment to exempt screening from design review for some minor accessory structures such as trash enclosures or loading areas.

951
02:00:11.579 --> 02:00:14.921
<v JP McNeil>And this makes it easier to improve a property without an additional review.

952
02:00:19.206 --> 02:00:34.398
<v JP McNeil>And for exterior activities, currently the code is very inconsistent on how exterior activities— so there are things that happen outside of a building but are related to the use, how those are categorized and when they're allowed.

953
02:00:34.655 --> 02:00:54.847
<v JP McNeil>So this amendment clarifies a distinction between activities associated with uses that are associated— that are— that there's a distinction, I'm sorry, with uses of an industrial nature from other generally commercial or recreationally oriented uses and when those are allowed.

954
02:00:55.014 --> 02:00:55.273
<v JP McNeil>Thank you.

955
02:00:55.627 --> 02:00:57.002
<v JP McNeil>In various sections of the code.

956
02:00:57.162 --> 02:01:11.314
<v JP McNeil>There aren't any real changes to what's allowed where, but it makes it clear for businesses that the fun stuff like outdoor dining or a bocce ball court or something like that, those are allowed in commercial areas, but not things like metalworking.

957
02:01:14.829 --> 02:01:18.143
<v JP McNeil>And then finally, the common areas for residential uses.

958
02:01:19.289 --> 02:01:25.983
<v JP McNeil>Multi-dwelling developments, they're required to have outdoor areas, either individual areas per unit or common areas.

959
02:01:26.697 --> 02:01:30.833
<v JP McNeil>It ensures that apartment dwellers have outdoor areas to relax and recreate.

960
02:01:31.699 --> 02:01:41.048
<v JP McNeil>And the common area amendments, they make it clear what types of structures can be in a required outdoor area and that the outdoor area can be covered, but it can't be fully enclosed.

961
02:01:43.975 --> 02:01:48.512
<v JP McNeil>And with that, I'm going to turn it over to Shannon to take on the next batch of amendments.

962
02:01:49.238 --> 02:01:49.771
<v Shannon Buno>Good afternoon.

963
02:01:50.046 --> 02:01:54.685
<v Shannon Buno>My name is Shannon Buno, and I am also a city planner with the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

964
02:01:55.585 --> 02:02:00.145
<v Shannon Buno>The next Recap 11 category is a catch-all theme called Regulatory Improvement.

965
02:02:00.882 --> 02:02:09.233
<v Shannon Buno>This category contains 30 disparate amendments, including amendments related to outdoor shelters, temporary activities, and a host of other topics.

966
02:02:10.051 --> 02:02:18.400
<v Shannon Buno>The bulk of the amendments in this category are technical in nature, but there are 5 minor policy amendments, and I'm going to talk about 3 of them.

967
02:02:20.229 --> 02:02:30.756
<v Shannon Buno>MP-14 increases the total number of individual shelters allowed for an outdoor shelter located in the EX, commercial, or multi-dwelling zones.

968
02:02:31.434 --> 02:02:38.576
<v Shannon Buno>The amendments align the zoning code with the capacity of the outdoor shelters that have been built during the declared housing emergency.

969
02:02:39.332 --> 02:02:45.376
<v Shannon Buno>This will allow those outdoor shelters to continue operating after the housing emergency expires in 2027.

970
02:02:45.456 --> 02:02:45.744
<v Shannon Buno>Second.

971
02:02:46.823 --> 02:02:52.407
<v Shannon Buno>Without this change, some of the shelters would need to go through a conditional use review to continue operating.

972
02:02:53.481 --> 02:02:57.573
<v Shannon Buno>This amendment garnered the most attention in earlier phases of this project.

973
02:02:58.680 --> 02:03:13.154
<v Shannon Buno>The increase in the commercial zones was scaled back by the Planning Commission from 200 units to 100 in response to testimony from neighbors who were concerned that the larger increase would allow the Multnomah Safe Rest Village to continue to expand.

974
02:03:14.085 --> 02:03:21.792
<v Shannon Buno>The Planning Commission's recommendation sets the maximum number in a commercial zone at exactly the current size of the Multnomah Village shelter.

975
02:03:23.092 --> 02:03:36.820
<v Shannon Buno>MP-14 also includes amendments that allow existing outdoor shelters located on publicly owned parcels in the general employment and industrial zones to continue operating without going through the conditional use process.

976
02:03:40.514 --> 02:03:44.543
<v Shannon Buno>The next 2 amendments are to the temporary activities chapter of the zoning code.

977
02:03:45.090 --> 02:03:54.980
<v Shannon Buno>The temporary activities chapter allows short-term deviations from the code for activities that are temporary in nature and will not adversely impact the surrounding area.

978
02:03:55.993 --> 02:04:05.128
<v Shannon Buno>The temporary rules allow short-term activities ranging from farmers markets and garage sales in residential zones to construction staging and commercial filming.

979
02:04:06.444 --> 02:04:16.801
<v Shannon Buno>Activities like fairs, carnivals, and other major event entertainment uses are allowed temporarily in many zones, but they are currently limited to 2 weeks at a time.

980
02:04:17.588 --> 02:04:27.944
<v Shannon Buno>However, circuses and seasonal outdoor events like the downtown holiday ice skating rink occur for more than 2 weeks and have structures that take time to install and remove.

981
02:04:29.092 --> 02:04:39.055
<v Shannon Buno>Amendment MP-15 extends the time limit for these types of temporary activities to the duration approved as part of a required Portland Fire and Rescue permit.

982
02:04:39.826 --> 02:04:42.024
<v Shannon Buno>This will make it easier for these events to operate.

983
02:04:43.289 --> 02:04:52.515
<v Shannon Buno>The Temporary Activities Chapter also currently allows many kinds of temporary activities and structures during a natural disaster or other health and safety emergency.

984
02:04:53.402 --> 02:05:04.033
<v Shannon Buno>MP-16 clarifies that a sobering center is an allowed temporary activity during the duration of a declared shelter shortage or other health and safety emergency.

985
02:05:04.872 --> 02:05:12.176
<v Shannon Buno>Without this amendment, a conditional use review is often required, adding cost and process to establishing these important facilities.

986
02:05:15.622 --> 02:05:17.775
<v Shannon Buno>And finally, we have a few sign code amendments.

987
02:05:18.844 --> 02:05:30.863
<v Shannon Buno>The overarching goal of this group of sign code amendments is to provide Portland Parks and Recreation more flexibility to install modern and informative sign in large— signs in large parks such as Washington Park.

988
02:05:31.938 --> 02:05:45.614
<v Shannon Buno>The amendments will allow signs in public parks located in residential and open space zones in the same manner as is currently allowed for signs for other institutional uses such as schools and religious institutions in those zones.

989
02:05:47.073 --> 02:06:02.832
<v Shannon Buno>In addition, the amendments will allow small changing image signs in parks that are more than 5 acres And the amendments will allow Portland Parks and Recreation to go through a sign code adjustment to allow a larger changing image sign in any park that's over 50 acres in size.

990
02:06:05.329 --> 02:06:06.614
<v Shannon Buno>That concludes our presentation.

991
02:06:07.210 --> 02:06:15.462
<v Shannon Buno>This slide shows where we are along our project timeline, and at this time we've requested another hearing before the full council on June 25th.

992
02:06:17.104 --> 02:06:35.274
<v Shannon Buno>Thank you for listening, and to reiterate our proposal, The Planning Commission recommends that City Council take the following actions: adopt the project report, amend Title 33, Planning and Zoning, per the recommended draft, and amend Title 32, Signs and Related Regulations.

993
02:06:36.159 --> 02:06:44.128
<v Shannon Buno>And please let me introduce Lucas Pollock, Vice Chair of the Portland Planning Commission, who will provide some insights on the Planning Commission's recommendation.

994
02:06:45.442 --> 02:06:46.212
<v Lucas Pollock>Hello, councilors.

995
02:06:46.565 --> 02:06:49.103
<v Lucas Pollock>Thank you for hearing the Planning Commission's recommendation on Recap 11.

996
02:06:49.777 --> 02:06:53.533
<v Lucas Pollock>Again, my name is Lucas Pollock, and I'm the vice chair of the Planning Commission and the current youth commissioner.

997
02:06:54.431 --> 02:06:58.654
<v Lucas Pollock>On October 28th, we voted unanimously to recommend that the City Council adopt this project.

998
02:06:59.006 --> 02:07:02.667
<v Lucas Pollock>But before that, in September, the commission held a public hearing on this project.

999
02:07:03.261 --> 02:07:08.719
<v Lucas Pollock>We heard testimony from residents living near a 100-unit outdoor shelter who raised concerns regarding the impacts of the use.

1000
02:07:09.265 --> 02:07:15.957
<v Lucas Pollock>They also expressed frustration that the outdoor shelter regulation Thank you.

1001
02:07:17.369 --> 02:07:24.640
<v Lucas Pollock>In our deliberation, the commission recognizes the dire need for outdoor shelters to provide a stable place for Portlanders experiencing homelessness.

1002
02:07:25.234 --> 02:07:38.954
<v Lucas Pollock>We also recognized that the impact of outdoor shelters are not being shared equally across the city, that there are few sites available, and we heard from Portland Solutions that providers can more efficiently serve a greater number of people at larger sites.

1003
02:07:40.015 --> 02:07:50.981
<v Lucas Pollock>Nevertheless, the Planning Commission was sympathetic to neighborhood concerns and passed an amendment to lower the number of outdoor shelters allowed in commercial zones from the staff-proposed 200 outdoor shelter units to 100 units.

1004
02:07:51.881 --> 02:07:56.199
<v Lucas Pollock>The result is still a net increase from the currently allowed 60 units to 100 units.

1005
02:07:57.034 --> 02:08:04.277
<v Lucas Pollock>The amendment reflected the commission's interest in creating some level of predictability, as shelters have become a longer-term solution than was originally anticipated.

1006
02:08:04.947 --> 02:08:09.854
<v Lucas Pollock>The Recap 11 packet before you today incorporates this important amendment, and we urge you to adopt it as written.

1007
02:08:10.488 --> 02:08:11.594
<v Lucas Pollock>Thank you for your time and consideration.

1008
02:08:16.082 --> 02:08:16.439
<v Candace Avalos>Wonderful.

1009
02:08:16.568 --> 02:08:19.690
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much, and thanks for your service on the commission.

1010
02:08:20.729 --> 02:08:24.421
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, so we've got councilors in the queue, and we're going to kick it off with Vice Chair Green.

1011
02:08:26.649 --> 02:08:27.185
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

1012
02:08:27.251 --> 02:08:29.916
<v Mitch Green>Didn't know I was going to go first on this, but that's okay.

1013
02:08:30.662 --> 02:08:33.291
<v Mitch Green>I really appreciate the Thank you for the presentation.

1014
02:08:33.711 --> 02:08:36.327
<v Mitch Green>The summary table is extremely useful.

1015
02:08:36.376 --> 02:08:41.000
<v Mitch Green>I'm sure you guys know that already, but I was like, how am I gonna possibly follow all this?

1016
02:08:41.148 --> 02:08:42.878
<v Mitch Green>But that's just a really good way to do it.

1017
02:08:44.119 --> 02:08:46.248
<v Mitch Green>I support largely most of this.

1018
02:08:46.329 --> 02:08:47.185
<v Mitch Green>I do have a question though.

1019
02:08:47.539 --> 02:08:52.912
<v Mitch Green>I'm a little uncomfortable about the, what was it, MP14?

1020
02:08:53.284 --> 02:08:55.117
<v Mitch Green>Is that the one with the shelters?

1021
02:08:55.543 --> 02:08:56.201
<v Lucas Pollock>Yes, yes.

1022
02:08:56.283 --> 02:08:56.627
<v Josh Roper>Yeah.

1023
02:08:58.020 --> 02:09:00.609
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate the Planning Commission's intervention on that.

1024
02:09:00.738 --> 02:09:04.877
<v Mitch Green>I still think 100 is too high for a single site.

1025
02:09:05.761 --> 02:09:15.310
<v Mitch Green>Doesn't really, it doesn't concord with the evidence on like how people interact together at a place like this.

1026
02:09:15.649 --> 02:09:32.121
<v Mitch Green>And I mean, I worry that our approach to zoning standards is driving the thing and cost efficiency is driving the thing rather than sort What do evidence-based practitioners want out of a congregate— sort of not congregate, but, um, you know, these temporary alternative sites?

1027
02:09:32.360 --> 02:09:33.882
<v Mitch Green>So I'm uncomfortable with that level.

1028
02:09:33.930 --> 02:09:37.199
<v Mitch Green>I don't know what the best way to amend that is.

1029
02:09:37.377 --> 02:09:40.164
<v Mitch Green>This is a very different style of ordinance than I am used to.

1030
02:09:40.212 --> 02:09:43.899
<v Mitch Green>And so if we can have a dialogue on that, I'd appreciate that.

1031
02:09:43.947 --> 02:09:53.569
<v Mitch Green>But if I wanted to just reject that amendment, I'm curious what the committee thinks of that one, but also what's, what's the least disruptive way to do that?

1032
02:09:54.710 --> 02:09:56.733
<v Candace Avalos>Well, let me just note a process thing too.

1033
02:09:57.744 --> 02:10:02.497
<v Candace Avalos>If we make changes because it's a land use thing, there's like additional noticing that we'll need to do.

1034
02:10:02.578 --> 02:10:07.395
<v Candace Avalos>I'm not saying that is a barrier to you, but just that will be one thing we'll need to consider.

1035
02:10:08.020 --> 02:10:14.908
<v Mitch Green>Um, that's why I'm— that's why I'm treading lightly here, because I understand that there is that other layer, and I just, I'm just hoping we can have that conversation.

1036
02:10:15.278 --> 02:10:19.252
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I think definitely let's entertain the discussion and colleagues can react to that.

1037
02:10:19.301 --> 02:10:19.612
<v David Straub>Okay.

1038
02:10:21.474 --> 02:10:25.927
<v Mitch Green>So I guess it's an open question for anyone in the building if you want to respond to that.

1039
02:10:28.134 --> 02:10:29.247
<v Sandra Wood>Let me take a stab at that.

1040
02:10:29.295 --> 02:10:32.988
<v Sandra Wood>I'm trying to digest a little bit maybe what your thinking is.

1041
02:10:34.565 --> 02:10:41.574
<v Sandra Wood>The 100-foot limit applies both in the multi-dwelling zones and the higher density multi-dwelling zones.

1042
02:10:42.810 --> 02:10:46.692
<v Sandra Wood>And the Planning Commission's proposal was also for the commercial zones.

1043
02:10:47.688 --> 02:10:54.467
<v Sandra Wood>So in the multi-dwelling zones, there was already a 60-foot limit and— right, unit, sorry.

1044
02:10:54.805 --> 02:10:54.886
<v Sandra Wood>Yeah.

1045
02:10:55.143 --> 02:10:55.833
<v Sandra Wood>Unit limit.

1046
02:10:55.881 --> 02:10:58.171
<v Sandra Wood>So the 60 increased to 100.

1047
02:10:58.833 --> 02:11:02.621
<v Sandra Wood>And in the commercial zones, it also went from 60 to 100.

1048
02:11:03.560 --> 02:11:12.606
<v Sandra Wood>So maybe we could understand a little better if you're concern about the 100 in the multi-dwelling zones and the commercial zones, or one or the other?

1049
02:11:12.947 --> 02:11:15.020
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I'm happy to sort of articulate a little bit more.

1050
02:11:17.103 --> 02:11:29.277
<v Mitch Green>When you talk about outcomes and you talk about the population being served by these shelter sites, you reach a point at which— and it's just some research I can dig up and share with the committee on this.

1051
02:11:29.358 --> 02:11:31.876
<v Mitch Green>I don't have the citation at hand, but beyond about yeah.

1052
02:11:32.036 --> 02:11:38.271
<v Mitch Green>About 30, really, but definitely by 60, you get really poor diminishing returns of scale on outcomes.

1053
02:11:38.784 --> 02:11:46.560
<v Mitch Green>Because when you concentrate that many people with that high of a need on one spot, you start to get a bunch of interactions that are undesirable.

1054
02:11:47.104 --> 02:12:00.283
<v Mitch Green>And you move away from the goal of trying to steward transitional housing situation and then ultimately move these people into a permanent Mm-hmm.

1055
02:12:00.542 --> 02:12:02.634
<v Mitch Green>100 People is outside of that.

1056
02:12:03.292 --> 02:12:06.640
<v Mitch Green>The proposed site in North Portland is 200-some-odd people.

1057
02:12:06.689 --> 02:12:17.300
<v Mitch Green>That's, that's way outside of any reasonable basis of, of warehousing people, frankly, on a piece of land.

1058
02:12:17.364 --> 02:12:35.390
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm really uncomfortable with codifying an increase in that just based upon I recognize that there was an initial desire to go higher, and then the Planning Commission said, let's, let's ease off on this.

1059
02:12:35.819 --> 02:12:45.840
<v Mitch Green>But for me, it's about— I know that this is a temporary emergency, but if we're codifying it, sort of sends a signal that that's— this is just now the new normal.

1060
02:12:45.859 --> 02:12:48.779
<v Mitch Green>We're just going to have for decades, perhaps, people living in temporary housing.

1061
02:12:48.779 --> 02:12:48.899
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's a fair point.

1062
02:12:49.442 --> 02:12:56.042
<v Mitch Green>Um, little huts in a parking lot, and we have not addressed the underlying, um, problem.

1063
02:12:56.510 --> 02:13:06.993
<v Mitch Green>And also, we have not really chosen the right model to, to allow these people to move on into a much, um, more humane and frankly better outcome situation.

1064
02:13:07.137 --> 02:13:25.109
<v Mitch Green>So I don't personally want to vote for an amendment that says we've ignored the science and we're just going to go ahead and codify but I also understand that there are important interactions in our land use process that this sort of discussion I'm having right now throws a wrench into.

1065
02:13:25.173 --> 02:13:31.385
<v Mitch Green>And I, I, I, I definitely don't want to be the person, the reason why our, our ability to change our codes and zoning is ground down to a halt.

1066
02:13:31.432 --> 02:13:32.427
<v Mitch Green>But this is an important one.

1067
02:13:32.877 --> 02:13:38.815
<v Eric Engstrom>Councilor, just speaking broadly, um, it's completely fair game to talk about individual items in this package.

1068
02:13:39.056 --> 02:13:46.287
<v Eric Engstrom>With past recaps, that's been in a typical scenario where the council dives in and says, you know, I'm uncomfortable with number 22 or whatever.

1069
02:13:46.626 --> 02:13:51.358
<v Eric Engstrom>So I want to— we'll speak up if there's a notification issue involved with that.

1070
02:13:53.395 --> 02:14:08.331
<v Eric Engstrom>For this particular item, the context there is, as you all know, the best practices and the council policy on what our shelter strategy is has evolved over the years, and we've been trying to keep the zoning as best we can current with the latest thinking on that.

1071
02:14:08.884 --> 02:14:10.733
<v Eric Engstrom>There was a larger package yes.

1072
02:14:10.829 --> 02:14:17.466
<v Eric Engstrom>Some years ago, the Shelter to Housing Continuum Project, which really reformed that structure and created the opportunity for outdoor shelters.

1073
02:14:18.590 --> 02:14:27.407
<v Eric Engstrom>This amendment started at a moment where it looked like our direction was to move towards bigger shelters.

1074
02:14:28.390 --> 02:14:32.993
<v Eric Engstrom>I think it's really the Planning Commission— or sorry, the council's prerogative to decide what your policy is on this.

1075
02:14:33.137 --> 02:14:41.636
<v Eric Engstrom>So, and it might be worthy of discussion with with the shelter provider folks if that's an interest of yours.

1076
02:14:42.134 --> 02:14:56.150
<v Eric Engstrom>We're just responding, frankly, to what the city's overall administrative direction has been with those things and trying to make sure that the zoning code is not a barrier to the direction that the city is trying to go.

1077
02:14:56.585 --> 02:14:58.399
<v Mitch Green>I really appreciate that, Director Engstrom.

1078
02:14:58.447 --> 02:15:00.405
<v Mitch Green>That's very helpful from the process side.

1079
02:15:01.641 --> 02:15:08.438
<v Mitch Green>This is a council I'm curious what my colleagues on the committee think about my reservations with that specific item.

1080
02:15:10.369 --> 02:15:10.546
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1081
02:15:10.627 --> 02:15:15.488
<v Candace Avalos>And sorry, I have to pause to say I forgot to mention there is no official testimony.

1082
02:15:15.536 --> 02:15:16.743
<v Candace Avalos>Let's just confirm that, Diego.

1083
02:15:18.952 --> 02:15:19.516
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

1084
02:15:19.662 --> 02:15:19.823
<v Candace Avalos>Say it.

1085
02:15:19.920 --> 02:15:20.469
<v Diego>No one signed up.

1086
02:15:20.969 --> 02:15:22.905
<v Candace Avalos>Perfect.

1087
02:15:23.067 --> 02:15:23.761
<v Candace Avalos>We jumped right in.

1088
02:15:24.115 --> 02:15:26.132
<v Candace Avalos>I knew that there were no testimony, but get it on the record.

1089
02:15:26.617 --> 02:15:26.778
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1090
02:15:29.192 --> 02:15:31.454
<v Candace Avalos>I'll respond to your thoughts when I'm up.

1091
02:15:31.713 --> 02:15:33.233
<v Candace Avalos>But next up we have Councilor Novick.

1092
02:15:35.020 --> 02:15:35.649
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1093
02:15:35.844 --> 02:15:50.587
<v Steve Novick>Coincidentally, I was coming at the issue from the opposite direction, and I haven't read the research that the council, all the research Councilor Green's talking about, but I've heard the Community First Village in Austin, which has several hundred tiny home residents, held up as a model.

1094
02:15:51.184 --> 02:15:59.283
<v Steve Novick>And I wanted to hear What did the staff have to say about why 200 would be better?

1095
02:16:00.130 --> 02:16:06.260
<v Steve Novick>What concerns were there about the limited number of sites for putting any of these places?

1096
02:16:06.356 --> 02:16:19.630
<v Steve Novick>Were there thoughts about maybe not wanting to foreclose the possibility of using really large sites, like to refer to Councilor Murillo and my— Councilor Murillo's and my dream— golf courses that you'd preclude possibilities if you limited to 100?

1097
02:16:19.680 --> 02:16:20.373
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I think that's a good question.

1098
02:16:21.644 --> 02:16:23.006
<v Steve Novick>What was the argument for 200?

1099
02:16:24.351 --> 02:16:26.033
<v JP McNeil>I can speak a little bit to that.

1100
02:16:26.194 --> 02:16:38.003
<v JP McNeil>I also haven't seen the research that Councilor Green was referring to, but we, at the Planning Commission stage, we were heavily involved with— or Portland Solutions staff was involved with the project.

1101
02:16:38.083 --> 02:16:39.765
<v JP McNeil>And so we brought them on board.

1102
02:16:40.230 --> 02:16:47.728
<v JP McNeil>They were at the Planning Commission, and they shared with us their experience working with operators about the shelters here in Portland.

1103
02:16:48.226 --> 02:16:52.468
<v JP McNeil>And their experience has been there is a limit.

1104
02:16:52.661 --> 02:17:02.189
<v JP McNeil>The limit is higher than what the research might show where things, where the conditions might deteriorate or there's pressures on the services.

1105
02:17:02.300 --> 02:17:06.960
<v JP McNeil>But they've been, the 200 was sort of their absolute cap.

1106
02:17:07.105 --> 02:17:11.202
<v JP McNeil>And I think their ideal would be more in the hundreds.

1107
02:17:11.540 --> 02:17:13.549
<v JP McNeil>But they did, they've definitely experienced that.

1108
02:17:13.629 --> 02:17:13.837
<v JP McNeil>Thank you.

1109
02:17:15.673 --> 02:17:21.993
<v JP McNeil>Thank you.

1110
02:17:23.514 --> 02:17:23.978
<v Steve Novick>Anything to add?

1111
02:17:25.948 --> 02:17:31.694
<v Sandra Wood>Might I offer also, I think there's 2 different issues here.

1112
02:17:31.922 --> 02:17:39.674
<v Sandra Wood>One is the land use issue, and the caps that we're putting for the land use perspective are 20 individual shelters in a single dwelling unit.

1113
02:17:39.817 --> 02:17:49.876
<v Sandra Wood>Zones, 60 in the lower multi-dwelling zones, 100 in the highest multi-dwelling zones, 100 in commercial zones, 200 in the EX zones.

1114
02:17:50.325 --> 02:17:58.137
<v Sandra Wood>So the reasoning behind that is because of the impacts, infrastructure, planning reasons, right?

1115
02:17:58.250 --> 02:18:10.941
<v Sandra Wood>Like, we have— those lots could be used for multi-dwelling housing and could have similar impacts with similar So that's like the land use, and that's of course our expertise.

1116
02:18:11.296 --> 02:18:18.838
<v Sandra Wood>And like JP was saying, during the Planning Commission deliberations, Portland Solutions was there to speak to the operational side.

1117
02:18:19.307 --> 02:18:25.048
<v Sandra Wood>So the operational side is a different question, and that's where their expertise comes in.

1118
02:18:25.940 --> 02:18:35.495
<v Sandra Wood>And the operational side, I think they could probably run a 100-unit shelter regardless of zone.

1119
02:18:36.105 --> 02:18:52.127
<v Sandra Wood>So I think what we have here is what the land use perspective is, taking into account what the Portland Solutions and the operators were saying is the economies of scale that they're trying to achieve from an administrative standpoint.

1120
02:18:52.912 --> 02:18:57.707
<v Eric Engstrom>I guess another way to say that is we're trying not to use the land use code to dictate their operational choices.

1121
02:18:57.884 --> 02:19:07.583
<v Eric Engstrom>We were and so setting the number high enough was sort of the logic of doing that so that we weren't in the way of those decisions.

1122
02:19:08.962 --> 02:19:12.077
<v Sandra Wood>And we took a look at all the shelters that were operating.

1123
02:19:12.736 --> 02:19:19.513
<v Sandra Wood>And the fact is that we have— they're allowed to operate until the housing emergency ends next year.

1124
02:19:20.282 --> 02:19:29.908
<v Sandra Wood>And what we were trying to ensure was that we had enough space to thank you.

1125
02:19:32.334 --> 02:19:33.289
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1126
02:19:34.274 --> 02:19:35.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

1127
02:19:36.895 --> 02:19:47.237
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At the beginning of the presentation, you all talked about the selection process for what is included in the reports, and there were a lot of technical steps that you went through.

1128
02:19:47.302 --> 02:19:49.072
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a similar process for the public comments?

1129
02:19:49.265 --> 02:19:54.754
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a step where somebody says, do we actually want this policy change?

1130
02:19:55.469 --> 02:19:59.523
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does this fit with the policy direction that we have been moving?

1131
02:19:59.701 --> 02:20:01.583
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if so, who makes that call?

1132
02:20:01.987 --> 02:20:04.226
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because that wasn't on the list that you went through for us.

1133
02:20:06.305 --> 02:20:09.179
<v Sandra Wood>I think we're making that call right here and at the Planning Commission.

1134
02:20:09.355 --> 02:20:11.842
<v Sandra Wood>I think the legislative process is that process.

1135
02:20:13.245 --> 02:20:20.865
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So there are not things that you're staff looks at and says, we've gotten 10 complaints about this, but this was actually an intentional decision.

1136
02:20:21.701 --> 02:20:34.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you got 10 complaints and that's more than anything else— that's, I'm sure, a much smaller number than what you get, but we're using small numbers for the sake of efficiency here— that would come to us regardless of what the policy is.

1137
02:20:35.836 --> 02:20:38.068
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>Well, for the record, Patricia Deifeneder—.

1138
02:20:38.068 --> 02:20:38.550
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>Yes and a no.

1139
02:20:38.888 --> 02:20:51.265
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>Well, I think we would say I would say that, overarching, the RECAP program is about addressing what we call technical changes or minor policy amendments.

1140
02:20:51.345 --> 02:20:54.011
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>So it's a bit of a judgment call.

1141
02:20:54.075 --> 02:20:56.739
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>It's not a, you know, it's more of an art than a science.

1142
02:20:56.804 --> 02:21:08.168
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>But the idea is that, again, we had been making past code changes to facilitate outdoor shelters, and this was consistent with that.

1143
02:21:08.746 --> 02:21:20.860
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>And I think as Director Engstrom said, the direction at the time that we initiated this project was we were looking at more— fewer but larger kind of shelters.

1144
02:21:21.453 --> 02:21:30.273
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>And so this was consistent with past actions and with the direction that— where things were going at the time.

1145
02:21:30.370 --> 02:21:36.579
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>And I think that this is a moment to have this conversation and to evaluate, is that I think that's still the case.

1146
02:21:36.579 --> 02:21:39.579
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>I think, overarching— I think that's still the case.

1147
02:21:39.579 --> 02:21:51.180
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>I think, overarching— I think, overarching— The goal here was to contemplate that if the shelter emergency— sorry, the emergency ordinance was removed, would these shelters be able to remain?

1148
02:21:51.219 --> 02:22:03.180
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>We were trying to create a regulatory environment where they could remain and operate, given that we know that, you know, these needs are going to go beyond next year.

1149
02:22:03.568 --> 02:22:05.913
<v Eric Engstrom>Stepping away, just then for the record, Eric Kingstrom again.

1150
02:22:06.201 --> 02:22:20.829
<v Eric Engstrom>Stepping away from this specific issue, broadly speaking, yes, the BPS management, when we're reviewing what's moving forward in the work plan, we are considering policy and existing policy and considering whether it's a minor policy or major policy change.

1151
02:22:21.938 --> 02:22:25.582
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so that's happening at the 2 of your level.

1152
02:22:26.176 --> 02:22:30.218
<v Eric Engstrom>And, and to some extent, the professional planners take that into account.

1153
02:22:30.540 --> 02:22:35.361
<v Sandra Wood>I mean, for example, we receive— and these are suggestions for improvements to the code.

1154
02:22:35.653 --> 02:22:42.702
<v Sandra Wood>Sometimes people will say, hey, I'm working on a development and I'm seeing a conflict between this code and that code.

1155
02:22:42.751 --> 02:22:45.055
<v Sandra Wood>And we look at it and we're like, yeah, that's not what we intended.

1156
02:22:45.941 --> 02:22:47.412
<v Sandra Wood>We should definitely fix that.

1157
02:22:47.459 --> 02:22:48.947
<v Sandra Wood>And that's a minor policy amendment.

1158
02:22:49.043 --> 02:22:50.561
<v Sandra Wood>So let's put that in the next package.

1159
02:22:51.128 --> 02:22:54.148
<v Sandra Wood>Sometimes we get requests for things that are not anti-theory.

1160
02:22:57.005 --> 02:23:02.611
<v Sandra Wood>And one of the most common ones is that we should be requiring parking.

1161
02:23:03.537 --> 02:23:11.100
<v Sandra Wood>You know, a lot of community members are concerned about parking and new apartments in their neighborhoods, and so they want us to have minimum parking requirements.

1162
02:23:11.572 --> 02:23:15.879
<v Sandra Wood>At this point, we're not even allowed to have minimum parking requirements per the state.

1163
02:23:16.250 --> 02:23:18.340
<v Sandra Wood>So no, we don't advance that.

1164
02:23:18.484 --> 02:23:19.465
<v Sandra Wood>And but you probably would.

1165
02:23:19.529 --> 02:23:19.898
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's a good point.

1166
02:23:20.000 --> 02:23:28.510
<v Sandra Wood>You'll see in the appendix of things we did not choose and why it scored low, um, because it doesn't comport to, to the goals.

1167
02:23:29.103 --> 02:23:30.806
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, that's really helpful.

1168
02:23:31.415 --> 02:23:42.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is a long list, and so for me, understanding some of that background and the, the policy and political calls that are made is helpful.

1169
02:23:42.270 --> 02:23:51.806
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The way our process currently works, we have what, 4 days with this before we're sitting here discussing it to read through 190-something pages of changes.

1170
02:23:54.985 --> 02:23:59.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, so understanding what some of those decision-making processes are, are really helpful.

1171
02:24:00.484 --> 02:24:11.726
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Green, to your point, to the point that you raised, I don't know that I give you a yes or no on where I'm at on that today.

1172
02:24:14.756 --> 02:24:26.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I read through most of this and marked a few pieces where I felt like I needed to ask some follow-up questions, not necessarily in this room, but of stakeholders and other groups that are interested.

1173
02:24:26.376 --> 02:24:35.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm still working through some of that, but I do think that there's a lot that, that needs some consideration, certainly.

1174
02:24:36.590 --> 02:24:37.137
<v Sandra Wood>Thank you, Chair.

1175
02:24:38.217 --> 02:24:39.813
<v Sandra Wood>And can I clarify one more thing?

1176
02:24:39.925 --> 02:24:44.808
<v Sandra Wood>I mean, everything in this package we think are good ideas, and so did the Planning Commission.

1177
02:24:45.262 --> 02:24:53.292
<v Sandra Wood>It's not that— and there are many other requests that are still on the list of exploring for future projects.

1178
02:24:53.828 --> 02:24:54.837
<v Sandra Wood>Does that help?

1179
02:24:57.603 --> 02:25:01.977
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That does make sense, knowing who is making the judgment calls and when and how.

1180
02:25:03.500 --> 02:25:09.441
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is the type of work where I think council sometimes feels like we are put in a position of rubber stamping administrative work.

1181
02:25:09.554 --> 02:25:09.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mm-hmm.

1182
02:25:10.180 --> 02:25:16.378
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And having both that background information and the time to really sit with it and dig in on it is important.

1183
02:25:16.505 --> 02:25:25.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that the Planning Commission has done a lot of that work, and I have a lot of faith in our Planning Commission, but we are the ones who hear from constituents if we make the wrong call.

1184
02:25:27.698 --> 02:25:39.771
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I think I just would make a plug here broadly to the ethers that we still need to figure out how to back up the postings so that councilors have more time sitting with documents like this.

1185
02:25:40.111 --> 02:25:43.079
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that's something that I know we're working on internally.

1186
02:25:46.157 --> 02:25:46.432
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1187
02:25:47.220 --> 02:25:48.349
<v Candace Avalos>All right, I'm up in the queue.

1188
02:25:49.266 --> 02:25:52.038
<v Candace Avalos>Let me just start by appreciating this work.

1189
02:25:52.119 --> 02:25:57.209
<v Candace Avalos>You know, these amendments are technical in nature, but the work is important because it reflects thank you, Councilor Smith.

1190
02:25:57.209 --> 02:25:57.209
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mayor.

1191
02:25:57.209 --> 02:26:02.170
<v Candace Avalos>I think this is a great package that reflects the city's commitment to continuously improving how our regulations function in practice.

1192
02:26:02.170 --> 02:26:08.229
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm grateful that we kind of have this ongoing practice of checking these codes.

1193
02:26:08.229 --> 02:26:19.040
<v Candace Avalos>We need to make it easier to build housing and support businesses, and sometimes that's major policy, but sometimes we're just getting into the nitty-gritty here of where our code can be clearer and more predictable and less burdensome.

1194
02:26:19.149 --> 02:26:22.629
<v Candace Avalos>So I appreciate what this package brings forward on that front.

1195
02:26:22.639 --> 02:26:23.237
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Councilor Herant.

1196
02:26:24.536 --> 02:26:47.179
<v Candace Avalos>Um, as it relates to your prompt, um, Vice Chair, I, um, I think I definitely agree in spirit, and I want to learn more about what— like, I, I also know that the data in general show— is showing that it's better to have more condensed, you know, groups of people.

1197
02:26:47.779 --> 02:26:58.420
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I, I I, for example, I spoke out very vigorously a couple years ago when they were trying to make 3,000-person camps, um, or 1,000-person camps, but 3 of them or whatever.

1198
02:26:58.965 --> 02:27:27.277
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and so, uh, definitely something that we've been talking about a lot in community over the years as we've been standing up all of these shelters, uh, or all of these, uh, the pods and things that we want to obviously increase our capacity as much as possible because we have so many people that need access and if we're looking holistically at what it takes to facilitate, you know, these kinds of spaces, it gets really challenging for the providers.

1199
02:27:27.325 --> 02:27:42.234
<v Candace Avalos>And I had this conversation with Cultivate Initiatives because the city was pushing for the Menlo Park site to increase by 50 more people, and they had expressed their concerns and shared why that would be difficult.

1200
02:27:42.282 --> 02:27:42.672
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm carrying that forward.

1201
02:27:42.719 --> 02:27:42.897
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1202
02:27:43.010 --> 02:27:51.992
<v Candace Avalos>I'm just keeping that in my mind as I'm reflecting on your question and agreeing that I've heard from community that we need to be careful about how we scale these sites.

1203
02:27:52.200 --> 02:27:57.969
<v Candace Avalos>So I am definitely interested in looking into that.

1204
02:27:58.049 --> 02:28:00.733
<v Candace Avalos>I would love to— I mean, I heard the logic.

1205
02:28:00.798 --> 02:28:05.665
<v Candace Avalos>I would love— maybe I'll reach out to the Planning Commission to just understand a little more about how they're feeling.

1206
02:28:05.715 --> 02:28:08.093
<v Candace Avalos>I know there's some planning commissioners here if you want to react to that.

1207
02:28:08.140 --> 02:28:08.606
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's a great idea.

1208
02:28:09.246 --> 02:28:15.103
<v Candace Avalos>I'd welcome you to— did you want to respond to kind of y'all's thoughts on this change?

1209
02:28:18.925 --> 02:28:19.461
<v Lucas Pollock>Yeah, yeah.

1210
02:28:19.510 --> 02:28:25.581
<v Lucas Pollock>You'll have to forgive me and I'll let staff correct me if I say anything incorrect or anything, because it has been since October.

1211
02:28:26.479 --> 02:28:57.337
<v Lucas Pollock>But overall, the— what I kind of remember being okay with the 100-unit aspect was when we talked to people from Portland Solutions, they They said that actually it kind of helps their economy of scale when they're able to access and provide services on larger sites, but that currently most sites are pretty much under the 100-unit mark and didn't really have plans to expand to certainly not 200 units, but also not to 100 units.

1212
02:28:57.402 --> 02:29:00.645
<v Lucas Pollock>But I think it was kind of more establishing a precedent.

1213
02:29:00.917 --> 02:29:05.479
<v Lucas Pollock>You know, we're gonna be dealing with outdoor shelters for a long time coming still most likely.

1214
02:29:06.218 --> 02:29:20.503
<v Lucas Pollock>And I think a lot of our thinking was having something set in the code helps us kind of navigate in the future in a way that'll be, that will both help serve our houseless neighbors and also the neighborhoods that are hosting these sites.

1215
02:29:21.162 --> 02:29:22.673
<v Lucas Pollock>If that answers any questions for you guys.

1216
02:29:23.251 --> 02:29:23.540
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1217
02:29:23.653 --> 02:29:27.106
<v Candace Avalos>That is helpful just to hear your logic behind that.

1218
02:29:27.188 --> 02:29:31.284
<v Candace Avalos>And I think just hearing that it's very future-focused, right?

1219
02:29:31.459 --> 02:29:34.626
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, we are going to continue to need these sites.

1220
02:29:34.707 --> 02:29:40.314
<v Candace Avalos>We're going to probably need to scale them up, not just on their sites, but creating more of them.

1221
02:29:41.200 --> 02:29:42.584
<v Candace Avalos>So I hear that.

1222
02:29:43.180 --> 02:29:50.960
<v Candace Avalos>But yeah, I definitely have some reservations that Councilor Green does and would be curious if we should talk more about what that looks like.

1223
02:29:51.041 --> 02:29:56.811
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor, were you thinking that— I know there's like a bunch of process-type things that we need to consider in making amendments.

1224
02:29:56.861 --> 02:29:56.958
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1225
02:29:57.564 --> 02:30:07.888
<v Candace Avalos>Is this something that you're thinking would bring to full council to propose an amendment to change, or you're going to change it here, or which one is it?

1226
02:30:08.197 --> 02:30:11.516
<v Mitch Green>I think it'd be best to try to change it here first.

1227
02:30:11.679 --> 02:30:11.922
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1228
02:30:12.245 --> 02:30:14.766
<v Mitch Green>And if, you know, if we have to have more conversation, we have to have more conversation.

1229
02:30:14.831 --> 02:30:17.183
<v Mitch Green>But I feel like, I feel like this is probably the opportunity to do that.

1230
02:30:17.568 --> 02:30:18.889
<v Candace Avalos>And what would changing it look like?

1231
02:30:18.954 --> 02:30:21.870
<v Candace Avalos>Is it that we reject it entirely?

1232
02:30:22.014 --> 02:30:26.720
<v Candace Avalos>Is it that we're changing the amount, or what would the change for me, I—.

1233
02:30:27.010 --> 02:30:34.027
<v Mitch Green>It would just be moving to, um, reject the proposed amendments on— where is it— page 111 of the Exhibit B.

1234
02:30:34.476 --> 02:30:34.700
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1235
02:30:35.038 --> 02:30:37.655
<v Mitch Green>Which I think is— it just has the— it has the red lines.

1236
02:30:38.345 --> 02:30:39.950
<v Mitch Green>So basically just undo those red lines.

1237
02:30:40.031 --> 02:30:40.208
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1238
02:30:40.256 --> 02:30:41.493
<v Mitch Green>That's kind of how I'm thinking about it.

1239
02:30:41.718 --> 02:30:42.360
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's good.

1240
02:30:42.424 --> 02:30:46.406
<v Mitch Green>I don't want to, like, insert my own planning frame into this.

1241
02:30:46.599 --> 02:30:46.775
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

1242
02:30:46.824 --> 02:30:48.253
<v Mitch Green>Like, I don't want to change these numbers.

1243
02:30:48.300 --> 02:30:49.682
<v Mitch Green>I think that's haphazard and chaotic.

1244
02:30:49.745 --> 02:30:51.501
<v Eric Engstrom>I I'm fine with where they're at.

1245
02:30:51.904 --> 02:30:52.840
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, sounds good.

1246
02:30:53.662 --> 02:30:58.047
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I, I think I would lean towards supporting that effort, so I'll just put that on the record.

1247
02:30:59.179 --> 02:31:24.958
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and then the only other question I had was, um, I guess I just wanted to hear high level, what are, in your opinions, the most meaningful improvements that applicants, homeowners, and businesses or community orgs will experience as a result of this like, as you all have been discussing this on the Planning Commission, been hearing from stakeholders, can you talk to me about what you all expect the impact to be?

1248
02:31:26.572 --> 02:31:38.855
<v Lucas Pollock>I think, I think a lot of the impact we're seeing is going to kind of be more establishing a ceiling and a precedent for how we're dealing with large outdoor shelters going forward.

1249
02:31:39.454 --> 02:31:50.248
<v Lucas Pollock>And on top of that, from what we heard from service providers, You know, some might be under the current 68-unit limit, but with hopes to expand under 100 units.

1250
02:31:50.569 --> 02:31:51.083
<v Candace Avalos>Let me pause you.

1251
02:31:51.629 --> 02:31:52.351
<v Candace Avalos>I mean in general.

1252
02:31:52.656 --> 02:31:52.993
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, okay.

1253
02:31:53.154 --> 02:31:54.051
<v Candace Avalos>Not just about this one.

1254
02:31:54.100 --> 02:31:55.319
<v Candace Avalos>I mean like for the whole package.

1255
02:31:55.480 --> 02:31:56.523
<v Lucas Pollock>Oh, for the whole package.

1256
02:31:57.406 --> 02:32:00.968
<v Lucas Pollock>I think this was easy as this was what we got the most testimony on.

1257
02:32:01.016 --> 02:32:04.435
<v Lucas Pollock>This is what we definitely focused most of our deliberation on.

1258
02:32:05.013 --> 02:32:14.227
<v Lucas Pollock>I think kind of what we would benefit from during the full package is just kind of continuity, removing redundancies and making It clearer on these smaller things.

1259
02:32:14.805 --> 02:32:33.740
<v Lucas Pollock>You know, we didn't hear any testimony really about, you know, the minor parking updates or signage necessarily, but I think going forward, just having these in— having these approved in place alongside the shelter amendment will kind of just give everyone, you know, a little clearance.

1260
02:32:33.916 --> 02:32:43.031
<v Lucas Pollock>A lot of complaints we get about Portland zoning code is that it's confusing and that there there's some broad, you know, kind of overlaps and redundancies.

1261
02:32:43.078 --> 02:32:46.509
<v Lucas Pollock>And I think this kind of helps to clean it up, make it more accessible to people.

1262
02:32:47.663 --> 02:32:51.381
<v Candace Avalos>And also just curious, could you gimme a flavor of like what you were hearing?

1263
02:32:51.477 --> 02:32:56.334
<v Candace Avalos>Like what was it that people were saying when they were testifying as it relates to the shelter amendment?

1264
02:32:57.343 --> 02:33:09.183
<v Lucas Pollock>They were mostly concerned that the increase to 200 units was not what they had been kind of promised or heard about when they were talking with both the shelter provider and the city, I believe.

1265
02:33:09.602 --> 02:33:27.543
<v Lucas Pollock>I think they were also under the impression that the site in, I believe, Multnomah Village was at some point slated to become permanent affordable housing, and they weren't super either aware or happy if they thought the outdoor shelter was to be both expanded and kept for longer than intended.

1266
02:33:28.987 --> 02:33:29.183
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1267
02:33:29.247 --> 02:33:30.400
<v Candace Avalos>That's helpful to understand.

1268
02:33:30.709 --> 02:33:33.665
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, those are all my questions.

1269
02:33:33.715 --> 02:33:35.405
<v Candace Avalos>We'll pass it back to Councilor Vice Chair Green.

1270
02:33:36.020 --> 02:33:38.343
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1271
02:33:38.471 --> 02:33:39.295
<v Candace Avalos>Oh wait, can I pause you?

1272
02:33:39.584 --> 02:33:39.795
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1273
02:33:41.134 --> 02:33:42.827
<v Candace Avalos>Did Councilor Koyama Lane speak yet?

1274
02:33:44.075 --> 02:33:44.334
<v Candace Avalos>Not yet.

1275
02:33:44.656 --> 02:33:46.448
<v Candace Avalos>Let me get to Councilor Koyama Lane and then I'll come back to you.

1276
02:33:46.593 --> 02:33:46.835
<v Josh Roper>Thanks.

1277
02:33:48.111 --> 02:33:48.481
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks, Chair.

1278
02:33:48.611 --> 02:34:08.145
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was, uh, going down a similar line of thinking, uh, reading in the exhibit that most of the testimony was really about livability concerns, neighborhood— the neighborhood association and residents having expressed opposition to the shelters.

1279
02:34:09.522 --> 02:34:17.838
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Were there any folks there that specifically were coming in talking about concerns around outcomes for those who are accessing the shelters?

1280
02:34:17.951 --> 02:34:22.486
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And did that come up at all, this conversation that we're kind of having about what's the right number?

1281
02:34:23.559 --> 02:34:25.771
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Happy to hear from you all, or Chair Routh.

1282
02:34:27.084 --> 02:34:30.818
<v Lucas Pollock>I believe we only had one person come in and testify verbally.

1283
02:34:31.459 --> 02:34:31.556
<v Lucas Pollock>Yeah.

1284
02:34:31.667 --> 02:34:38.402
<v Lucas Pollock>I spoke to a number of FAE orally, and their concern was generally about the outcomes for people.

1285
02:34:38.450 --> 02:34:44.207
<v Lucas Pollock>But I think mostly overall it was the uncertainty around what's going on.

1286
02:34:44.302 --> 02:34:54.565
<v Lucas Pollock>It's, you know, it's a very fluid situation with what they're dealing with, and it's kind of— I think they were hearing a lot of one thing and then another, and they really wanted someone to just come in and give like a concrete answer.

1287
02:34:55.622 --> 02:34:55.863
<v Candace Avalos>And I—.

1288
02:34:56.488 --> 02:34:56.793
<v JP McNeil>Yeah, go ahead.

1289
02:34:56.873 --> 02:35:02.489
<v JP McNeil>Sorry, just one thing to add is that there's the written testimony that was also provided to the Planning Commission.

1290
02:35:02.859 --> 02:35:21.435
<v JP McNeil>I don't have it right here in front of me, but I know that there were a few pieces that came in, and I don't know if this was what you were asking, that was in support of the idea that we need these shelters, we need to be able to be standing them up, that there's a need for them in the city, and that these are challenges that we're facing.

1291
02:35:21.549 --> 02:35:27.376
<v JP McNeil>And so it wasn't— everybody wasn't coming up coming up against it, I guess, is what I'm saying.

1292
02:35:28.754 --> 02:35:34.483
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And can someone kind of explain to me how MP14 would look in action?

1293
02:35:34.547 --> 02:35:38.718
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Because I'm looking at, like, the Multnomah Safe Rest Village.

1294
02:35:38.799 --> 02:35:40.531
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's one that we're discussing.

1295
02:35:41.029 --> 02:35:44.461
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And on our website, it says that there are 100 shelter units.

1296
02:35:44.575 --> 02:35:45.762
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's our capacity right now.

1297
02:35:46.259 --> 02:35:47.237
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We're looking at Menlo.

1298
02:35:47.317 --> 02:35:49.099
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It says 75 sleeping units.

1299
02:35:49.147 --> 02:35:54.363
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So is this, Can someone explain to me how they're zoned and maybe—.

1300
02:35:55.310 --> 02:36:09.774
<v JP McNeil>The whole point of this that we started off with was so that what exists on the ground today would be allowed to or able to continue operating under the zoning code if the housing emergency were to go away tomorrow.

1301
02:36:09.854 --> 02:36:11.828
<v JP McNeil>And it's slated to go away in 2027.

1302
02:36:12.199 --> 02:36:21.906
<v JP McNeil>So what it would look like at Multnomah Safe Rest Village is nothing would change because They would be in compliance with the code if the housing emergency went away tomorrow.

1303
02:36:22.534 --> 02:36:26.962
<v JP McNeil>At Menlo Park, they'd be able to go up a little bit if they wanted to.

1304
02:36:27.300 --> 02:36:28.365
<v JP McNeil>There's the flexibility there.

1305
02:36:28.445 --> 02:36:34.578
<v JP McNeil>It doesn't mean, from what Portland Solutions told us, they don't have plans necessarily to expand all these.

1306
02:36:34.628 --> 02:36:40.269
<v JP McNeil>It was just to have the wiggle room in case things, they can, as things change and needing to move around.

1307
02:36:41.447 --> 02:36:47.699
<v JP McNeil>And there, I know that since Planning Commission, it's been a while, we haven't been, that was back in October, but since then, I talked to them recently, several of the shelters have closed.

1308
02:36:47.780 --> 02:36:47.844
<v JP McNeil>Right.

1309
02:36:49.829 --> 02:36:49.989
<v JP McNeil>Yes.

1310
02:36:50.038 --> 02:36:51.433
<v JP McNeil>Or slated to close.

1311
02:36:51.930 --> 02:36:58.168
<v JP McNeil>And so that's one of the other challenges that they face with this is that the reality is that it's difficult to site these.

1312
02:36:58.585 --> 02:37:02.932
<v JP McNeil>I think that this, the testimony that you heard, it sort of illustrates that.

1313
02:37:03.397 --> 02:37:07.213
<v JP McNeil>And so one of their challenges is that they have some sites that are in place.

1314
02:37:07.342 --> 02:37:10.790
<v JP McNeil>And so siting new ones is difficult.

1315
02:37:11.094 --> 02:37:14.671
<v JP McNeil>Siting new ones within neighborhoods is challenging.

1316
02:37:14.718 --> 02:37:17.653
<v JP McNeil>And so then I heard some Some concerns about warehousing.

1317
02:37:18.085 --> 02:37:26.325
<v JP McNeil>And so then that's the tension here is that there can be in neighborhoods and Multnomah Village doesn't seem to really like having that shelter.

1318
02:37:26.743 --> 02:37:33.844
<v JP McNeil>Or the alternative, which is kind of what's happening now, is North Portland Road, which is in an industrial area, is getting larger because other shelters are closing.

1319
02:37:33.894 --> 02:37:36.619
<v JP McNeil>And so there's a balance there.

1320
02:37:36.860 --> 02:37:48.721
<v JP McNeil>It can be big shelters out in industrial areas, which has its own problems, and then the challenges of trying to— so part of that, what I'm getting at is the ones that are in place now, we're trying to keep there.

1321
02:37:48.930 --> 02:37:51.430
<v JP McNeil>That was the goal that was given to us.

1322
02:37:51.990 --> 02:37:54.346
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Do you know if Clinton Triangle would fall under the same?

1323
02:37:55.195 --> 02:38:04.058
<v JP McNeil>Clinton Triangle, we— that one is zoned EX, and so that is the only zone that would now allow up to 200.

1324
02:38:04.475 --> 02:38:05.579
<v JP McNeil>And they're already at 160.

1325
02:38:05.852 --> 02:38:13.032
<v JP McNeil>Yeah, so that one, um, and EX zoning is central employment, so it's generally Central city located.

1326
02:38:13.450 --> 02:38:18.871
<v JP McNeil>So that was the one where the largest impact, largest footprint seemed appropriate.

1327
02:38:20.202 --> 02:38:24.036
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Chair, is it possible for me to hear Steph Routt's perspective?

1328
02:38:24.854 --> 02:38:28.944
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are you open to kind of sharing some of the process and where you're at?

1329
02:38:29.024 --> 02:38:31.270
<v Staff Routh>Also happy birthday last week.

1330
02:38:31.768 --> 02:38:32.313
<v Staff Routh>Okay.

1331
02:38:33.194 --> 02:38:36.691
<v Staff Routh>Hello, Chair Avalos, Vice Chair Green, and members of the committee.

1332
02:38:37.590 --> 02:38:39.450
<v Staff Routh>Happy Pride, and thank you for having me.

1333
02:38:40.561 --> 02:38:43.775
<v Staff Routh>I want to, like, take us back first.

1334
02:38:43.953 --> 02:38:47.750
<v Staff Routh>RECAP, as you've probably heard, RECAP is kind of our regular—.

1335
02:38:48.541 --> 02:38:49.898
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can you say your name for the record?

1336
02:38:50.059 --> 02:38:50.350
<v Staff Routh>I'm sorry.

1337
02:38:50.495 --> 02:38:50.947
<v Staff Routh>Oh, I'm sorry.

1338
02:38:51.059 --> 02:38:54.014
<v Staff Routh>I'm Staff Routh, Chair of the Planning Commission, for the record.

1339
02:38:54.063 --> 02:38:54.256
<v Staff Routh>Sorry.

1340
02:38:57.744 --> 02:39:06.173
<v Staff Routh>RECAP generally is kind of our annual housekeeping, like spring cleaning of a lot of codes.

1341
02:39:06.365 --> 02:39:10.441
<v Staff Routh>And as Sandra said, Like, it's what filters to the top.

1342
02:39:11.253 --> 02:39:15.855
<v Staff Routh>Land use in my experience is, it's a really blunt tool.

1343
02:39:16.701 --> 02:39:20.736
<v Staff Routh>And especially the shelter amendment, I'm so glad that you are talking about it.

1344
02:39:20.816 --> 02:39:27.826
<v Staff Routh>We foresaw and hoped that you would also struggle with this, for we did as well, and we like to be in good company.

1345
02:39:28.202 --> 02:39:30.489
<v Staff Routh>So we are all in good company with each other.

1346
02:39:32.058 --> 02:39:37.327
<v Staff Routh>And that shelters particularly are a context-sensitive, like the success and failure is really context-sensitive.

1347
02:39:41.590 --> 02:39:43.513
<v Staff Routh>And as I said, land use is blunt.

1348
02:39:44.010 --> 02:40:04.257
<v Staff Routh>And so one question I think that we had just generally as a body is how much for this zoning process should be what we can do versus what we should do, and is what elements should be confined to a zoning or a land use conversation?

1349
02:40:04.353 --> 02:40:04.978
<v Staff Routh>And I think that's a great question.

1350
02:40:05.414 --> 02:40:07.319
<v Staff Routh>Versus a program conversation.

1351
02:40:07.513 --> 02:40:31.418
<v Staff Routh>And so I think that one thing that we felt coming to you, and please, I'm also looking if I am speaking out of turn, but we felt that some of that was, we went into the closest to a middle ground that allowed for the conditions that currently exist on the ground, such as Multnomah.

1352
02:40:33.831 --> 02:40:42.109
<v Staff Routh>While still pulling us into what the limits of a shelter that would be too far.

1353
02:40:42.334 --> 02:40:47.114
<v Staff Routh>And we did feel that 200 was too much too far.

1354
02:40:48.045 --> 02:40:50.194
<v Staff Routh>Was 100 the correct answer?

1355
02:40:50.933 --> 02:40:53.468
<v Staff Routh>I'm not entirely sure, honestly.

1356
02:40:53.820 --> 02:41:03.459
<v Staff Routh>Like, I struggle, I continue to struggle with that decision, and I think most that was probably a non-answer.

1357
02:41:03.523 --> 02:41:04.754
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No, this is all really helpful.

1358
02:41:04.818 --> 02:41:05.304
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1359
02:41:05.402 --> 02:41:06.728
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And thank you everyone for your patience.

1360
02:41:08.156 --> 02:41:12.063
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I am grateful that you all did the work.

1361
02:41:12.709 --> 02:41:15.808
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It sounds like there was maybe a move for there to be an expansion.

1362
02:41:16.280 --> 02:41:22.145
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is more being able to make sure things could stay where they're at if needed.

1363
02:41:23.144 --> 02:41:23.225
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks.

1364
02:41:23.843 --> 02:41:25.770
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1365
02:41:26.156 --> 02:41:30.924
<v Candace Avalos>All right, Vice Chair Green, you are going to, uh, you're up next, but do you mind if I ask the question?

1366
02:41:30.972 --> 02:41:32.949
<v Candace Avalos>Because I know what you were going to do so that we can get that clarified.

1367
02:41:33.542 --> 02:41:46.052
<v Candace Avalos>So staff, um, we just want to understand, can the committee vote on Councilor Green's amendment that he's going to propose in a moment without further notice or Measure 56 notice and the opportunity for public testimony?

1368
02:41:47.273 --> 02:41:47.402
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1369
02:41:47.674 --> 02:41:57.558
<v Candace Avalos>So we will be able to discuss an amendment here, pass yes, I don't think—.

1370
02:41:57.574 --> 02:41:58.725
<v Sandra Wood>I, I'm trying to think.

1371
02:41:58.870 --> 02:42:01.268
<v Sandra Wood>Definitely not a Measure 56 notice.

1372
02:42:02.561 --> 02:42:11.144
<v Sandra Wood>And when you're moving on to full council, then the public will have an opportunity to testify at the full council.

1373
02:42:11.674 --> 02:42:13.096
<v Sandra Wood>So that would be good.

1374
02:42:13.293 --> 02:42:15.443
<v Sandra Wood>We'll want to publish it in some way so that they know what the notice is.

1375
02:42:15.493 --> 02:42:15.887
<v Sandra Wood>I think we should publish it.

1376
02:42:16.850 --> 02:42:18.117
<v Queesha Light>Right?

1377
02:42:18.261 --> 02:42:52.460
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>Yeah, I'll just add, I mean, typically, if a provision, an amendment is not expanding or making less restrictive, in this case it'd be making it more restrictive by reducing the number that was proposed, that kind of falls within the umbrella of what we studied and how, you know, what we engaged So that's typically something that can be done without triggering kind of all other requirements for noticing and further outreach.

1378
02:42:53.612 --> 02:43:06.149
<v Sandra Wood>And as we understand it, the amendment would be basically to strike the whole Minor Policy 14, which means everything would go back to the current code.

1379
02:43:06.760 --> 02:43:07.966
<v Sandra Wood>And so it wouldn't be more restrictive.

1380
02:43:08.095 --> 02:43:11.221
<v Sandra Wood>If you were to go beyond that and make it more restrictive, then we would—.

1381
02:43:11.801 --> 02:43:13.960
<v Eric Engstrom>I think the current code does not require notice.

1382
02:43:14.154 --> 02:43:15.023
<v Jessie Connor>Than what was proposed.

1383
02:43:15.600 --> 02:43:16.759
<v Jessie Connor>Than what is current.

1384
02:43:17.387 --> 02:43:17.498
<v Jessie Connor>Right.

1385
02:43:17.548 --> 02:43:17.902
<v Candace Avalos>What did you say?

1386
02:43:18.674 --> 02:43:19.881
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>That's true, yeah.

1387
02:43:20.284 --> 02:43:23.166
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>And it's not more restrictive than what is currently on the books.

1388
02:43:23.280 --> 02:43:32.610
<v Sandra Wood>If you wanted to put something on, if you wanted to make an amendment that makes it more strict than what's currently in the zoning code, then we would need to notify the property owners.

1389
02:43:33.289 --> 02:43:33.450
<v Jessie Connor>Okay.

1390
02:43:33.870 --> 02:43:34.212
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

1391
02:43:34.293 --> 02:43:35.272
<v Candace Avalos>Well then, Vice Chair, go ahead.

1392
02:43:37.469 --> 02:43:38.195
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Avalos.

1393
02:43:38.325 --> 02:43:44.814
<v Mitch Green>And just for everyone's edification, I emailed every member of this committee the report that I had in my brain.

1394
02:43:45.073 --> 02:43:48.489
<v Mitch Green>I've made it available to the clerk as well so we can have that for posterity.

1395
02:43:48.555 --> 02:44:01.502
<v Mitch Green>But it is a PSU study, um, commissioned by the, uh, Portland State University Homelessness Research and Action Collaborative, uh, was it was funded by a Meyer Memorial Trust grant.

1396
02:44:02.209 --> 02:44:16.756
<v Mitch Green>Anyway, they did an analysis based upon, I think, a total of about 3,000 survey respondents for folks either with— who live in these villages, live near the villages, and then randomized sample of Portlanders.

1397
02:44:16.870 --> 02:44:19.722
<v Mitch Green>And they found— and this is on page 181 of this—.

1398
02:44:20.560 --> 02:44:22.043
<v Candace Avalos>There's only 138.

1399
02:44:22.108 --> 02:44:22.736
<v Candace Avalos>That's what I was about to ask.

1400
02:44:22.816 --> 02:44:23.477
<v Mitch Green>Okay, well, there's—.

1401
02:44:23.477 --> 02:44:24.236
<v Candace Avalos>Which page is it on?

1402
02:44:24.364 --> 02:44:32.590
<v Mitch Green>It's page 92 of the PDF, but it's 181 of the actual— sorry, um, it's, it's page 91 of the PDF.

1403
02:44:32.814 --> 02:44:33.006
<v Mitch Green>Sorry.

1404
02:44:33.296 --> 02:44:33.424
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1405
02:44:33.905 --> 02:44:45.259
<v Mitch Green>It poses the question based upon their analysis on how many villagers, and they say that overwhelmingly when they speak to this broad cross-section of people, the ideal village size is somewhere between 25 and 30.

1406
02:44:45.307 --> 02:44:52.269
<v Mitch Green>And I know that's decidedly smaller than what the kind of current model is, but this is a very different model, and this is the model that's a good point.

1407
02:44:52.525 --> 02:44:56.063
<v Mitch Green>That's the model that I think is where the city should strive to go towards in the future.

1408
02:44:56.770 --> 02:45:02.354
<v Mitch Green>And the key piece here is this is a level, maybe 60 is the upper bound.

1409
02:45:02.403 --> 02:45:04.790
<v Mitch Green>That's Dignity Village, by the way, has about 60 residents.

1410
02:45:06.649 --> 02:45:22.333
<v Mitch Green>That's the upper bound at which, like, there's a seemingly stable balance of community relationships there where villagers are not disruptive to their neighbors, that are also not disruptive with each other, and so on and so forth.

1411
02:45:22.444 --> 02:45:33.492
<v Mitch Green>And so it's for that reason that I, I would move to strike the changes on page 111 of Exhibit B, essentially just rejecting MP-14.

1412
02:45:34.085 --> 02:45:35.032
<v Mitch Green>And I would look for a second.

1413
02:45:36.156 --> 02:45:36.832
<v Candace Avalos>I will second that.

1414
02:45:36.959 --> 02:46:06.699
<v Diego>And is that, you know, clerk folks, is that the right language, or do we need to if I may state it for the record, the proposed amendment would be to remove amendments to Chapter 33.285, short-term mass and outdoor shelters, specifically Code Section 33.285.040, use regulations, which is page 11, Exhibit B.

1415
02:46:07.397 --> 02:46:08.061
<v Claire>111.

1416
02:46:08.370 --> 02:46:09.147
<v Diego>111, Sorry.

1417
02:46:10.708 --> 02:46:19.954
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, and it's just, there are track changes on this site, on this, in this document, and the intent is to revert to the original pre-amended language.

1418
02:46:20.667 --> 02:46:20.926
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1419
02:46:22.302 --> 02:46:29.123
<v Sandra Wood>May I clarify just so we're talking about page 111 and 113, correct?

1420
02:46:29.351 --> 02:46:29.967
<v Sandra Wood>It goes on.

1421
02:46:31.629 --> 02:46:31.990
<v Sandra Wood>Correct.

1422
02:46:32.467 --> 02:46:34.584
<v Sandra Wood>And we're talking about all of Section 35.1.

1423
02:46:40.438 --> 02:46:42.995
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, my intent is to just reject MP-14.

1424
02:46:47.299 --> 02:46:54.395
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>So it's, it's not any specific zone, it's, it's all of the, the changes per any of the, the zones.

1425
02:46:54.573 --> 02:46:56.818
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I do not want to raise the capacity.

1426
02:46:57.231 --> 02:46:57.377
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>Okay.

1427
02:46:57.780 --> 02:47:04.218
<v JP McNeil>One other consequence of that is that, um, it's the how the employment zones and industrial zones are treated a little differently.

1428
02:47:04.816 --> 02:47:10.153
<v JP McNeil>Because a conditional use review is required in those zones.

1429
02:47:10.347 --> 02:47:28.281
<v JP McNeil>And so this, and this on page 113, the amendment would allow any existing outdoor shelters that are in those zones, namely North Portland Road, I forget what else is left that's in the, oh, Clinton Triangle.

1430
02:47:28.557 --> 02:47:29.445
<v Shannon Buno>Dignity Village.

1431
02:47:29.657 --> 02:47:32.949
<v JP McNeil>And Dignity Village to continue operating without a conditional use.

1432
02:47:33.825 --> 02:47:41.043
<v JP McNeil>When the emergency goes away, they'll have to come in for a conditional use review, which opens it up to discretion and public comment.

1433
02:47:43.474 --> 02:47:47.206
<v JP McNeil>So that is just to be aware that that's also a consequence of striking the whole thing.

1434
02:47:47.722 --> 02:47:48.386
<v Mitch Green>Good, thanks.

1435
02:47:48.756 --> 02:47:49.081
<v Patricia Diefenderfer>And does—.

1436
02:47:49.435 --> 02:47:55.284
<v Candace Avalos>So you're saying if and when the emergency clause ends, when does it end?

1437
02:47:55.381 --> 02:47:55.863
<v Candace Avalos>I don't even know.

1438
02:47:55.944 --> 02:47:58.212
<v JP McNeil>It's scheduled now to end in October of 2027.

1439
02:47:58.422 --> 02:47:58.888
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, okay, good.

1440
02:47:59.834 --> 02:48:02.772
<v Mitch Green>They just— you have to go through the conditional land use permit process again.

1441
02:48:02.948 --> 02:48:05.451
<v JP McNeil>Yeah, if they can't get approval, they'd have to close.

1442
02:48:06.318 --> 02:48:06.559
<v Candace Avalos>Got it.

1443
02:48:06.736 --> 02:48:09.111
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, well, this has been moved and seconded.

1444
02:48:09.208 --> 02:48:14.040
<v Candace Avalos>I chatted the language to, uh, the committee members so you can see that in front of you.

1445
02:48:14.585 --> 02:48:17.908
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and we will now move into discussion on this amendment.

1446
02:48:18.630 --> 02:48:21.792
<v Candace Avalos>So, uh, Councilor Novick, did you want to speak to the amendment?

1447
02:48:22.450 --> 02:48:33.730
<v Steve Novick>Um, yeah, one thing I wanted to mention— you mentioned cultivate initiatives, Madam Chair, and And they were actually the organization that told me that they looked to the village in Austin with several hundred residents as a model.

1448
02:48:33.940 --> 02:48:36.329
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to mention that.

1449
02:48:36.970 --> 02:48:40.131
<v Steve Novick>And so I just wanted to go back to what we were talking about a minute ago.

1450
02:48:41.141 --> 02:48:49.227
<v Steve Novick>If this passes, then Dignity Village will have to seek to renew a conditional use permit when the emergency expires?

1451
02:48:49.418 --> 02:48:49.996
<v JP McNeil>That's correct.

1452
02:48:50.846 --> 02:48:54.199
<v Steve Novick>Are there other, are there other places that'll have to go through the same thing?

1453
02:48:54.619 --> 02:48:58.629
<v JP McNeil>The North Portland Road, any— yeah, North Portland Road and Clinton Triangle.

1454
02:48:58.757 --> 02:48:59.906
<v JP McNeil>And as far as I—.

1455
02:49:00.295 --> 02:49:01.328
<v Jessie Connor>And Multnomah Village.

1456
02:49:01.653 --> 02:49:04.981
<v JP McNeil>And well, no, Multnomah Village has been rezoned to CM-2.

1457
02:49:05.143 --> 02:49:06.031
<v Shannon Buno>But they're above 60.

1458
02:49:07.387 --> 02:49:13.215
<v JP McNeil>Well, that would be— well, yes, that's a different— I'm just talking about the employment and industrial zone ones at the moment.

1459
02:49:14.671 --> 02:49:16.450
<v Steve Novick>And the limit we'd be reverting to is 60?

1460
02:49:17.860 --> 02:49:19.052
<v JP McNeil>I'm sorry?

1461
02:49:19.183 --> 02:49:21.424
<v Steve Novick>And what the limit we'd be reverting to is 60, is that right?

1462
02:49:22.068 --> 02:49:22.880
<v Steve Novick>Is that across the board?

1463
02:49:23.287 --> 02:49:23.546
<v Sandra Wood>No.

1464
02:49:24.082 --> 02:49:24.097
<v Steve Novick>Oh.

1465
02:49:24.584 --> 02:49:26.956
<v JP McNeil>It would vary by zone.

1466
02:49:27.829 --> 02:49:37.594
<v JP McNeil>One thing, so for, it would go back to in single-family zones, this wasn't proposed to change, so the maximum is 20 individual shelters.

1467
02:49:38.420 --> 02:49:44.799
<v JP McNeil>In some of the lower impact multi-dwelling zones, it's 30 shelters.

1468
02:49:45.629 --> 02:49:51.145
<v JP McNeil>In the commercial zones and some of the higher density multi-dwelling zones, That's 60.

1469
02:49:51.823 --> 02:49:52.854
<v JP McNeil>Same with the EX.

1470
02:49:52.985 --> 02:49:55.179
<v JP McNeil>So that's Clinton Triangle would be limited to 60.

1471
02:49:55.695 --> 02:50:01.841
<v JP McNeil>And then when you get to the other employment, general employment zones and the industrial zones, they're not allowed by right.

1472
02:50:01.906 --> 02:50:03.325
<v JP McNeil>They have to go through a conditional use.

1473
02:50:03.534 --> 02:50:12.531
<v JP McNeil>So Clinton Triangle, Dignity Village, North Portland, and I think that might be it that's left now.

1474
02:50:13.013 --> 02:50:13.334
<v Benjamin Gilbert>Kenton.

1475
02:50:13.575 --> 02:50:14.427
<v JP McNeil>I think I said Clinton Triangle.

1476
02:50:14.523 --> 02:50:15.632
<v JP McNeil>If I didn't, oh, Kenton.

1477
02:50:15.808 --> 02:50:30.799
<v Sandra Wood>And Kenton would all have to go through a conditional use review because there is no and to be clear, the cap in the other zones that you were just summarizing, that's the cap that's allowed by right.

1478
02:50:30.959 --> 02:50:33.370
<v Sandra Wood>Above that is also a conditional use review.

1479
02:50:34.479 --> 02:50:44.352
<v Steve Novick>And I apologize for not knowing this, but would the proposed amendment have raised the limit to 100 everywhere or just in some places and left others alone?

1480
02:50:44.787 --> 02:50:45.495
<v JP McNeil>It would be a conditional use review for all.

1481
02:50:46.340 --> 02:50:53.620
<v JP McNeil>The proposed amendment increases it in the commercial zones to 100.

1482
02:50:54.251 --> 02:50:59.281
<v JP McNeil>In the higher density multifamily zones, it increases it to 100.

1483
02:50:59.894 --> 02:51:07.863
<v JP McNeil>And then in the lower density multi-dwelling zones and some campus institutional zones, it increases it from 30 to 60.

1484
02:51:09.352 --> 02:51:16.343
<v JP McNeil>And then the biggest jump is for in the EX zone, which is central employment, Where there's— that's Clinton Triangle.

1485
02:51:16.391 --> 02:51:18.218
<v JP McNeil>That goes from 60 to 200.

1486
02:51:20.511 --> 02:51:20.915
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1487
02:51:22.445 --> 02:51:31.367
<v Steve Novick>I am going to be opposing this partly because I'm concerned about using the land use system to make operational decisions of what happens at these sites.

1488
02:51:31.448 --> 02:51:53.260
<v Steve Novick>But also, I think that given the limited number of— given the difficulty in finding sites, I think that this will significantly restrict our ability to rely on the tiny house village model okay, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, to the amendment.

1489
02:51:53.986 --> 02:51:54.504
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Chair.

1490
02:51:55.344 --> 02:52:02.105
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I want to thank Councilor Koyama Lane for the line of questioning that she went down.

1491
02:52:02.218 --> 02:52:05.509
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That was really helpful for me in understanding the impact here.

1492
02:52:07.890 --> 02:52:11.388
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Councilor Mr. Green, I think I need to oppose this today.

1493
02:52:13.138 --> 02:52:19.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I agree that we need to look carefully at the size of a lot of these villages, and you and I have talked about that.

1494
02:52:19.808 --> 02:52:33.293
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are some that I think are getting too big, and I think specifically as you're talking about self-governed villages, which is what the bulk of the report that you sent focuses on, there definitely is a smaller size that's necessary.

1495
02:52:35.659 --> 02:52:49.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Some of the villages that we have that are not the self-governed villages but more of the, the top-down structure that are pretty large have been able to be successful, some less so, right?

1496
02:52:49.308 --> 02:52:52.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I have concerns about what we're doing out at Portland Road.

1497
02:52:53.563 --> 02:53:00.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But what I don't want to do is create a scenario where we have villages Thank you.

1498
02:53:00.837 --> 02:53:02.333
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I think that's a really good point.

1499
02:53:03.040 --> 02:53:09.245
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that there are some shelters that can't operate once the— once our state of emergency goes away.

1500
02:53:11.242 --> 02:53:24.459
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would be interested if we had more time, which I don't think we do unfortunately, in thinking about how we treat new shelters and what is sunsetted in and what's not.

1501
02:53:25.934 --> 02:53:27.834
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I don't want us to lose shelters.

1502
02:53:28.012 --> 02:53:44.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the, the warning specifically that one of our self-governed villages would have to apply for a land use variance if we don't make this change when that state of emergency goes through— or goes away, rather— is a big red flag for me.

1503
02:53:45.513 --> 02:53:50.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't want to put them in a situation of needing to kick people out or lose their land.

1504
02:53:51.290 --> 02:54:00.072
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so I think that given that piece especially, I can't support the wholesale change today.

1505
02:54:01.188 --> 02:54:01.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1506
02:54:08.065 --> 02:54:08.372
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1507
02:54:08.550 --> 02:54:09.344
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1508
02:54:10.252 --> 02:54:11.110
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, everyone.

1509
02:54:13.468 --> 02:54:23.202
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, can someone explain to me yeah, I think it could be amended back in by any of the other councilors who are on the committee.

1510
02:54:23.283 --> 02:54:23.429
<v Virginia Hammond>Okay.

1511
02:54:42.069 --> 02:54:44.445
<v Sandra Wood>Aren't here today or by any of you.

1512
02:54:45.538 --> 02:54:57.836
<v Sandra Wood>Um, if it gets amended out completely and the council passes, you know, no amendment on this, most of these shelters are operating under the housing emergency, right?

1513
02:54:58.462 --> 02:54:58.575
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah.

1514
02:54:58.944 --> 02:55:13.254
<v Sandra Wood>And so they would continue to operate, and then we would be getting closer to the October 2027 date with maybe there's a a conversation amongst council and the city administrator about what to do with the Safe Rest Villages in particular.

1515
02:55:14.958 --> 02:55:19.674
<v Sandra Wood>And maybe there's a solution, or maybe we're told, uh-oh, we're going to have a problem.

1516
02:55:21.319 --> 02:55:24.918
<v Sandra Wood>There isn't a, you know, a magic thing that happens on that day.

1517
02:55:25.548 --> 02:55:28.549
<v Sandra Wood>What would probably happen is on a complaint basis.

1518
02:55:28.599 --> 02:55:33.840
<v Sandra Wood>So community members will say, hey, the housing emergency is over, this was supposed to last until only now.

1519
02:55:34.146 --> 02:55:43.174
<v Sandra Wood>So they would issue a complaint to our bureau partner of Portland Permitting and Development, and they would start acting on that.

1520
02:55:44.165 --> 02:55:47.528
<v Sandra Wood>Not a great situation, I think, for the providers to have that uncertainty.

1521
02:55:49.342 --> 02:55:51.287
<v Sandra Wood>A legislative process takes a while.

1522
02:55:52.170 --> 02:56:01.004
<v Sandra Wood>So if we were to want to amend the code back or have some kind of compromise, I think this is probably the project to do it in.

1523
02:56:01.585 --> 02:56:23.597
<v Sandra Wood>You know, Director Engstrom or Patricia can correct me if I'm wrong, but I would be concerned that we think the problem's gone away and then we get to next summer and all of a sudden we have to like scramble to come up with a different land use solution when possibly what you're looking for is an operational solution.

1524
02:56:25.157 --> 02:56:43.415
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will say I would— I'm concerned about the idea of many of these sites at some point having to close some of their beds and wondering, you know, that assuming that means people are pushed to the streets or to the congregate overnight-only shelters, which I think are not as preferable.

1525
02:56:45.790 --> 02:56:49.770
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Even though October 2027 does seem close, it does seem like there's some time.

1526
02:56:50.929 --> 02:56:52.829
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith.

1527
02:56:53.007 --> 02:57:00.030
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I am interested in, in actually talking to some of my colleagues at the county, some of the commissioners, and seeing what their perspectives are.

1528
02:57:00.632 --> 02:57:07.685
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so where this lands, however I vote here, might not be the same that I vote at the full council.

1529
02:57:08.250 --> 02:57:14.066
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I, I'm interested in supporting it but having some conversations to see if it's something that can come back in.

1530
02:57:14.751 --> 02:57:17.457
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciate this study that you shared.

1531
02:57:17.522 --> 02:57:20.172
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'd like to look some other studies too.

1532
02:57:20.269 --> 02:57:29.454
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I also want to acknowledge that a lot of work has been done and that this conversation isn't, isn't over.

1533
02:57:30.996 --> 02:57:43.722
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Also, Chair Avalos, if for some reason MP-14 isn't addressed here or at the full council, would you say that it would be something that you would prioritize for us to make sure we're not waiting until the last minute?

1534
02:57:43.771 --> 02:57:44.145
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Smith.

1535
02:57:46.585 --> 02:57:49.736
<v Candace Avalos>Do you mean like operationally, to talk about the operation?

1536
02:57:49.834 --> 02:57:50.077
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1537
02:57:50.402 --> 02:57:51.458
<v Claire>Yes, absolutely.

1538
02:57:51.765 --> 02:58:00.700
<v Candace Avalos>I agree that there is a— we need to talk about the policy behind it and not maybe not muck up the land use issues.

1539
02:58:00.814 --> 02:58:02.427
<v Candace Avalos>So that's— yeah.

1540
02:58:02.868 --> 02:58:05.264
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm down to prioritize that conversation.

1541
02:58:06.524 --> 02:58:07.676
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1542
02:58:09.266 --> 02:58:11.815
<v Candace Avalos>I'm next in the queue, but I said what essentially I was going to say.

1543
02:58:12.602 --> 02:58:13.210
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Green.

1544
02:58:13.724 --> 02:58:14.750
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Alvo.

1545
02:58:14.831 --> 02:58:17.058
<v Mitch Green>Colleagues, I'm going to withdraw my amendment actually.

1546
02:58:17.315 --> 02:58:18.902
<v Mitch Green>I've been moved by the discussion.

1547
02:58:19.672 --> 02:58:31.710
<v Mitch Green>I think every single person up here has made a remark that acknowledges the thing that I am worried about, but raises some risks that I personally find unacceptable.

1548
02:58:32.000 --> 02:58:43.440
<v Mitch Green>Particularly, I'm very worried that some of these villages that I care deeply about, who I know people who live in them, Being kicked out because then they lost a by-right place to be.

1549
02:58:43.440 --> 02:58:46.909
<v Mitch Green>And I can't control who's going to be on the next council or who's going to be the next mayor.

1550
02:58:47.239 --> 02:58:49.319
<v Mitch Green>So I appreciate, I really value the discussion.

1551
02:58:49.319 --> 02:58:55.629
<v Mitch Green>I think what we can do when we go to the full body is we can daylight that we had this conversation and that it was a robust conversation.

1552
02:58:56.100 --> 02:58:58.579
<v Mitch Green>And then if we want to make adjustments there, we can.

1553
02:58:58.579 --> 02:58:59.459
<v Mitch Green>We'll have a little bit more time.

1554
02:58:59.459 --> 02:59:02.819
<v Mitch Green>But at this time, I'm going to support the entire recap.

1555
02:59:02.819 --> 02:59:03.959
<v Mitch Green>I really appreciate all the work that's the been done.

1556
02:59:03.959 --> 02:59:04.000
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1557
02:59:03.992 --> 02:59:08.031
<v Mitch Green>Hard work that's been done in there, and thanks for being in this dialogue with me.

1558
02:59:08.176 --> 02:59:10.269
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to formally withdraw my amendment at this time.

1559
02:59:11.340 --> 02:59:11.549
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

1560
02:59:11.614 --> 02:59:13.543
<v Candace Avalos>And since I was your seconder, I agree to withdraw.

1561
02:59:13.802 --> 02:59:14.030
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

1562
02:59:14.759 --> 02:59:17.465
<v Candace Avalos>Um, okay, well, I don't see anyone else in the queue.

1563
02:59:18.096 --> 02:59:19.652
<v Candace Avalos>Colleagues, are we ready to move to a vote?

1564
02:59:20.929 --> 02:59:24.226
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, then I will entertain— let me get the language up.

1565
02:59:24.647 --> 02:59:33.065
<v Candace Avalos>I would like to entertain a motion to move the ordinance document number 2026-189 to the full council with a Aye.

1566
02:59:34.281 --> 02:59:36.775
<v Candace Avalos>Seconded by Councilor Novick.

1567
02:59:37.343 --> 02:59:37.975
<v Candace Avalos>Please call the roll.

1568
02:59:40.959 --> 02:59:41.333
<v Diego>Pirtle-Guiney?

1569
02:59:41.626 --> 02:59:41.804
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1570
02:59:42.600 --> 02:59:43.137
<v Diego>Koyama Lane?

1571
02:59:43.494 --> 02:59:44.630
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for all your hard work.

1572
02:59:44.875 --> 02:59:44.924
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1573
02:59:46.012 --> 02:59:46.370
<v Diego>Novick?

1574
02:59:47.003 --> 02:59:48.040
<v Steve Novick>Yes, thank you very much.

1575
02:59:48.443 --> 02:59:48.492
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1576
02:59:51.106 --> 02:59:51.172
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1577
02:59:52.236 --> 02:59:52.543
<v Diego>Avalos?

1578
02:59:52.882 --> 02:59:52.931
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1579
02:59:54.029 --> 02:59:58.434
<v Diego>With 5 ayes, the motion carries, and the ordinance, document number 2026-10, passes unanimously.

1580
03:00:04.281 --> 03:00:06.568
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you so much to all of you for your hard work.

1581
03:00:06.875 --> 03:00:11.917
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you to the Planning Commission for their work and for helping us grapple with these issues.

1582
03:00:12.079 --> 03:00:17.963
<v Candace Avalos>I think you can hear our intent, and we will continue to have a discussion about the policy aspect of what we discussed today.

1583
03:00:19.319 --> 03:00:21.104
<v Candace Avalos>Colleagues, our next meeting is Tuesday, June 16th.

1584
03:00:21.364 --> 03:00:24.109
<v Candace Avalos>At that meeting, we— oh, sorry, there's one more piece in terms of the agenda.

1585
03:00:24.157 --> 03:00:24.238
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1586
03:00:24.287 --> 03:00:24.742
<v Diego>Councilor Smith.

1587
03:00:26.700 --> 03:00:27.981
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, I am very sorry.

1588
03:00:28.111 --> 03:00:30.270
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, I have that in the notes and I didn't say it.

1589
03:00:30.351 --> 03:00:32.995
<v Candace Avalos>All right, um, hold on.

1590
03:00:35.649 --> 03:00:44.093
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, so the Regulatory Improvement Code amendment package will be continued to a full council meeting on June 25th, 2026 at 2 PM, time certain.

1591
03:00:45.426 --> 03:00:45.670
<v Candace Avalos>Got it.

1592
03:00:45.914 --> 03:00:47.977
<v Sandra Wood>And can we clarify one other thing too?

1593
03:00:48.513 --> 03:00:50.284
<v Sandra Wood>I believe— is the oral testimony closed?

1594
03:00:50.493 --> 03:00:54.016
<v Sandra Wood>At this point, and the written testimony will remain open.

1595
03:00:55.299 --> 03:00:57.653
<v Queesha Light>Okay, that's—.

1596
03:00:57.782 --> 03:00:59.915
<v Candace Avalos>Is that a question, or is that a— that's what's happening?

1597
03:01:00.109 --> 03:01:21.759
<v Sandra Wood>Well, um, I spoke to the city attorney about, about that because usually— well, well, we're new to the committee structure too, so usually the oral testimony needs to be closed before deliberation and passing a recommendation, and the written testimony in this case, we would suggest leaving it open, um, so that the public can continue testifying.

1598
03:01:22.335 --> 03:01:27.158
<v Sandra Wood>Um, and when you get to full council, then we'll close the written testimony, the written record.

1599
03:01:27.495 --> 03:01:34.370
<v Candace Avalos>So to confirm, oral testimony is now closed, written will continue until the council meeting, correct?

1600
03:01:34.771 --> 03:01:35.587
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, perfect.

1601
03:01:36.212 --> 03:01:36.597
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1602
03:01:37.495 --> 03:01:47.860
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, um, at our next meeting, we are anticipating a resolution from Councilor Dunphy and I on the second phase of the Code Alignment Project, or CAP 2, and we'll have a couple of affordable housing finance items from the Housing Bureau.

1603
03:01:48.481 --> 03:01:52.488
<v Candace Avalos>And with that, I will adjourn the meeting of Housing and Permitting at 5 on the dot.

1604
03:01:52.554 --> 03:01:53.361
<v Mitch Green>Look at that.

1605
03:01:53.555 --> 03:01:53.748
<v Jessie Connor>Wow.

1606
03:01:53.895 --> 03:01:54.427
<v Candace Avalos>Hell yeah.

