WEBVTT

1
00:09:36.863 --> 00:09:37.312
<v Jason Hubert>Good morning.

2
00:09:37.988 --> 00:09:40.381
<v Steve Novick>I call the meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee to order.

3
00:09:40.495 --> 00:09:45.620
<v Steve Novick>It is Tuesday, June 2nd at 9:30 AM, and I'm reliably informed that June is busting out all over.

4
00:09:47.480 --> 00:09:48.525
<v Steve Novick>Uh, could the clerk please call the roll?

5
00:09:49.684 --> 00:09:50.456
<v Rachael Fetters>Good morning, everyone.

6
00:09:50.892 --> 00:09:51.182
<v Rachael Fetters>Kanal?

7
00:09:51.455 --> 00:09:52.323
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

8
00:09:53.225 --> 00:09:53.611
<v Rachael Fetters>Morillo?

9
00:09:54.658 --> 00:09:54.995
<v Angelita Morillo>Absent.

10
00:09:55.173 --> 00:09:55.543
<v Rachael Fetters>Zimmerman?

11
00:09:57.121 --> 00:09:57.219
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

12
00:09:57.427 --> 00:09:57.732
<v Rachael Fetters>Smith?

13
00:09:58.472 --> 00:09:58.746
<v Loretta Smith>Absent.

14
00:09:59.471 --> 00:09:59.775
<v Rachael Fetters>Novick?

15
00:10:00.740 --> 00:10:00.918
<v Steve Novick>Here.

16
00:10:02.269 --> 00:10:04.456
<v Steve Novick>Christopher, can you please read the statement of conduct?

17
00:10:04.990 --> 00:10:07.390
<v Christopher>Welcome to the meeting of the Community and Public Safety Committee.

18
00:10:07.438 --> 00:10:19.754
<v Christopher>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/community-and-public-safety-committee or by calling 311.

19
00:10:20.192 --> 00:10:22.392
<v Christopher>Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

20
00:10:22.780 --> 00:10:25.384
<v Christopher>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

21
00:10:25.450 --> 00:10:26.404
<v Christopher>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

22
00:10:28.389 --> 00:10:33.830
<v Christopher>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the Chair states otherwise.

23
00:10:33.830 --> 00:10:35.629
<v Christopher>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

24
00:10:35.889 --> 00:10:36.889
<v Christopher>The Chair preserves order.

25
00:10:36.889 --> 00:10:43.250
<v Christopher>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

26
00:10:43.309 --> 00:10:45.139
<v Christopher>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

27
00:10:45.149 --> 00:10:47.429
<v Christopher>Further disruption results in ejection from the meeting.

28
00:10:47.429 --> 00:10:50.059
<v Christopher>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

29
00:10:50.409 --> 00:10:53.059
<v Christopher>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

30
00:10:53.309 --> 00:10:55.269
<v Christopher>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

31
00:10:55.269 --> 00:10:56.929
<v Christopher>When testifying, state your name for the record.

32
00:10:56.929 --> 00:10:58.409
<v Christopher>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

33
00:10:58.409 --> 00:11:04.614
<v Christopher>Virtual testifiers Thank you, Christopher.

34
00:11:05.548 --> 00:11:15.725
<v Steve Novick>This morning we're going to have a proclamation for Gun Violence Awareness Month and a discussion of gun violence with our efforts to reduce gun violence with Portland Ceasefire and the Office of Violence Prevention.

35
00:11:16.481 --> 00:11:27.322
<v Steve Novick>Then we'll have a presentation and discussion of the Public Safety Call Allocation Study, and then we'll discuss an ordinance to add psychedelic health and safety code and create the Portland Psychedelics Advisory Commission.

36
00:11:28.015 --> 00:11:33.119
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, that's all right.

37
00:11:33.167 --> 00:11:40.504
<v Steve Novick>So I will begin by reading the mayor's gun violence awareness proclamation.

38
00:11:41.572 --> 00:11:43.221
<v Rachael Fetters>Can I read it into the record first?

39
00:11:43.511 --> 00:11:44.273
<v Steve Novick>Oh, sure.

40
00:11:44.482 --> 00:11:45.000
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

41
00:11:45.452 --> 00:11:53.894
<v Rachael Fetters>Item number 1, document number 2026-184, proclamation for Gun Violence Awareness Month and Portland Ceasefire Day.

42
00:11:53.990 --> 00:11:55.293
<v Rachael Fetters>Fire program discussion.

43
00:11:55.976 --> 00:11:56.384
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

44
00:11:56.547 --> 00:11:57.149
<v Steve Novick>Sorry about that.

45
00:11:59.169 --> 00:12:27.480
<v Steve Novick>Whereas gun violence continues to affect communities across the United States and here in Portland, impacting the safety, health, and well-being of individuals, families, and neighborhoods, and whereas the City of Portland believes every community member deserves to live, learn, work, and gather in safe and supportive environments free from violence, and whereas Wear Orange is a national movement observed annually during the first weekend of June to honor the lives of those impacted by gun violence, uplift survivors, and raise awareness about the importance of community safety and violence prevention.

46
00:12:28.620 --> 00:12:40.383
<v Steve Novick>And whereas the movement began in memory of Hadiya Pendleton, a 15-year-old Chicago student whose friends chose to wear orange to honor her life after she was tragically killed by gun violence in 2013.

47
00:12:41.378 --> 00:13:22.725
<v Steve Novick>And whereas orange has become a nationally recognized symbol of remembrance, visibility, healing, and hope for communities working together to prevent gun violence, and whereas the City of Portland recognizes the efforts of community organizations, educators, advocates, healthcare professionals, outreach workers, violence prevention practitioners, youth leaders, faith communities, and residents who work every day to support safer and healthier communities, and whereas Portland community members and organizations observe Wear Orange Weekend each year through educational events, community gatherings, wellness activities, memorial opportunities, and public awareness efforts centered on healing, connection, and collective action.

48
00:13:23.510 --> 00:13:33.831
<v Steve Novick>And whereas Wear Orange Week serves as an opportunity for Portlanders to come together in solidarity, support those impacted by violence, and reaffirm a shared commitment to community care and public safety.

49
00:13:34.825 --> 00:13:52.482
<v Steve Novick>Now therefore, Keith Wilson, Mayor of the City of Portland, the City of Roses, hereby proclaims the first weekend of June each year to be Wear Orange Weekend in Portland and encourages all Portlanders to wear orange, participate in community events, and support efforts to promote healing awareness and the prevention of gun violence.

50
00:13:55.732 --> 00:13:56.158
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

51
00:13:56.535 --> 00:13:59.451
<v Steve Novick>And now we'll move on to our presentation.

52
00:14:02.176 --> 00:14:02.322
<v Rachael Fetters>Councilor—.

53
00:14:02.337 --> 00:14:03.934
<v April Roa>Hi, Bria Brown for the record.

54
00:14:04.289 --> 00:14:09.099
<v April Roa>Before moving into a presentation from our Ceasefire Program, we would like a couple of comments from our OVP team.

55
00:14:09.922 --> 00:14:10.243
<v April Roa>Thank you.

56
00:14:11.509 --> 00:14:14.504
<v Rachael Fetters>Thank you, Councilors, and thank you, Councilor Novick, for reading the proclamation.

57
00:14:14.568 --> 00:14:20.066
<v Rachael Fetters>My name is Rachael Fetters, and I'm joined by my colleague Rhea Walter on behalf of the city's Office of Violence Prevention.

58
00:14:20.578 --> 00:14:30.529
<v Rachael Fetters>The Office of Violence Prevention addresses the root causes of violence, especially gun violence, through sustained community engagement, violence prevention grants, placemaking initiatives, and personal safety training.

59
00:14:30.995 --> 00:14:35.369
<v April Roa>Today we are here to speak to you about National Gun Violence Awareness Day, which is Friday, June 5th.

60
00:14:35.577 --> 00:14:43.190
<v April Roa>Cities across the nation will wear orange this weekend to honor survivors of gun violence, remember lives lost, and uplift communities working towards peace and safety.

61
00:14:44.298 --> 00:15:01.721
<v Yelena Belikova>This year's Portland event will be a community block party that brings together families, youth, community organizations, and local partners for an afternoon of wellness activities, resources, music, arts and crafts, youth activities, food vendors, and opportunities for community healing and remembrance.

62
00:15:02.299 --> 00:15:09.466
<v Yelena Belikova>This will be held on Sunday, June 7th at Southeast Mill Street in front of Lincoln Park from 12 to 3 PM.

63
00:15:09.676 --> 00:15:15.816
<v Yelena Belikova>We'd love to see you all at the block party and encourage you to wear orange at any other public events throughout the weekend.

64
00:15:16.482 --> 00:15:16.840
<v Jahad Hudson>Thank you.

65
00:15:17.052 --> 00:15:17.458
<v Rachael Fetters>Thank you.

66
00:15:17.880 --> 00:15:18.092
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

67
00:15:29.355 --> 00:15:30.365
<v April Roa>Good morning, councilors.

68
00:15:30.639 --> 00:15:36.063
<v Stephanie Howard>My name is Stephanie Howard, she/her pronouns for the record, and I'm the Director of Community Safety Programs.

69
00:15:36.321 --> 00:15:54.833
<v Stephanie Howard>I'm here today with our team from Portland Ceasefire as well as our partners at the Portland Police Bureau, and I did just want to acknowledge our OVP team members who have to leave and who can't be part of our, our actual presentation today regarding our gun violence strategy, but I'll do my best to fill in the gaps for them.

70
00:15:54.916 --> 00:15:56.889
<v Sierra Ellis>Uh, and with that, I'll hand it over to Sierra Ellis.

71
00:15:58.679 --> 00:16:00.580
<v Sierra Ellis>Good morning, council members.

72
00:16:00.644 --> 00:16:02.562
<v Sierra Ellis>Thank you for having us here today.

73
00:16:03.206 --> 00:16:07.490
<v Sierra Ellis>Um, for the record, my name is Sierra Ellis and I am the Ceasefire Program Manager.

74
00:16:08.278 --> 00:16:14.038
<v Sierra Ellis>Um, I'm here today with my colleague, um, Franz Schaning, and I'll give him a moment to introduce himself.

75
00:16:14.600 --> 00:16:16.365
<v Franz Schaning>Good morning, Chair Novick and the rest of the committee.

76
00:16:16.413 --> 00:16:17.499
<v Franz Schaning>Thank you for the opportunity to be here.

77
00:16:17.692 --> 00:16:19.215
<v Franz Schaning>For the record, my name is Franz Schaning.

78
00:16:19.490 --> 00:16:22.794
<v Franz Schaning>I am the Assistant Chief for the Investigations Branch for the Police Bureau.

79
00:16:23.393 --> 00:16:27.376
<v Franz Schaning>The Investigations Branch covers both the Detective Division and the Specialized Resources Division.

80
00:16:28.035 --> 00:16:33.392
<v Franz Schaning>Between those 2 divisions, we handle all fatal and non-fatal injury shooting incidents and investigations in the City of Portland.

81
00:16:35.133 --> 00:16:41.732
<v Sierra Ellis>First, I want to thank you again for inviting us here today and giving us the opportunity to dive deeper into our work.

82
00:16:42.232 --> 00:16:56.139
<v Sierra Ellis>I think it's incredibly important that you not only hear about the strategy itself, but about the meaningful work happening happening every day across our city to reduce gun violence and support those who are most impacted.

83
00:16:56.556 --> 00:17:06.667
<v Sierra Ellis>Our goal today is to provide you with a better understanding of what Ceasefire is, how the strategy operates, and how our partners work together every day to reduce gun violence.

84
00:17:07.390 --> 00:17:20.497
<v Sierra Ellis>Through this presentation, we will walk through the full scope of Ceasefire, including the role of law enforcement, community violence intervention, and the coordination happening to make sure we have time, we anticipate questions at the end of the presentation.

85
00:17:22.251 --> 00:17:34.365
<v Sierra Ellis>But before we talk about where we are today, it's important to understand how we got here and the conditions that led to implement ceasefire and why and why coordinated focus strategy was needed.

86
00:17:36.026 --> 00:17:36.671
<v Sierra Ellis>Do we have the slide up?

87
00:17:38.019 --> 00:17:38.538
<v Sierra Ellis>Okay, there it is.

88
00:17:40.141 --> 00:17:41.178
<v Sierra Ellis>Okay, so what is?

89
00:17:41.359 --> 00:17:41.825
<v Sierra Ellis>Ceasefire.

90
00:17:42.674 --> 00:17:59.410
<v Sierra Ellis>So ceasefire is a gun violence reduction strategy, and our sole purpose is to reduce shooting injuries and firearm homicides by focusing resources on a small number of individuals and conflicts driving the majority of shootings and gun violence.

91
00:18:00.469 --> 00:18:05.073
<v Sierra Ellis>A core principle of this work is that not everyone is equally at risk.

92
00:18:06.115 --> 00:18:15.217
<v Sierra Ellis>Ceasefire uses data, investigative information, community relationships, to identify those at the highest risk to intervene before additional violence occurs.

93
00:18:15.810 --> 00:18:28.737
<v Sierra Ellis>This approach is guided by a problem analysis, which is a comprehensive assessment that identifies the underlying factors contributing to shootings in the community, including the people, places, conflicts, and circumstances connected to violence.

94
00:18:29.378 --> 00:18:35.608
<v Sierra Ellis>The problem analysis serves as the foundation for Ceasefire by creating a shared understanding of the gun violence problem in Portland.

95
00:18:36.268 --> 00:18:44.648
<v Sierra Ellis>Again, the problem analysis also produces our risk factors and helps us identify and define what high risk means for Portland.

96
00:18:45.115 --> 00:19:26.819
<v Sierra Ellis>The risk factors are identified based on behaviors and connections to violence, and those factors include males 18 to 44 years old, prior involvement in firearm violence or criminal justice system, connections to active group conflicts, I think, Council, it's important to recognize that Ceasefire is both a gun violence reduction strategy that's been used across the country and by different cities.

97
00:19:26.819 --> 00:19:28.359
<v Franz Schaning>It's also a program that's been used within by Portland Police Department to help reduce gun violence.

98
00:19:28.559 --> 00:19:29.259
<v Franz Schaning>The City of Portland.

99
00:19:29.259 --> 00:19:30.960
<v Franz Schaning>I think sometimes in that conversation it gets conflated.

100
00:19:31.559 --> 00:19:38.299
<v Franz Schaning>There's a sense that investing in the program that's housed under Ceasefire is the same as addressing the ceasefire strategy, which it's not.

101
00:19:38.299 --> 00:19:39.599
<v Franz Schaning>It's more complex than that.

102
00:19:39.599 --> 00:19:42.990
<v Franz Schaning>Chief Day talked about the complexity of the systems and the connectedness between systems.

103
00:19:43.640 --> 00:19:47.690
<v Franz Schaning>And so as we talk through this presentation, I would encourage you to reflect back on that.

104
00:19:47.799 --> 00:19:52.589
<v Franz Schaning>You know, like Manager Ellis talked about, we started this with a gun violence problem analysis.

105
00:19:53.140 --> 00:19:56.974
<v Franz Schaning>We brought in an outside body to kind of look at the shootings, within the city of Portland.

106
00:19:57.152 --> 00:20:00.186
<v Franz Schaning>And that started with meetings with the investigators who investigated those shootings.

107
00:20:00.684 --> 00:20:09.423
<v Franz Schaning>So recognizing there's a police component, recognizing there's a services component, and, and really what CERA does is coordinate all those different pieces around this gun violence reduction strategy.

108
00:20:10.403 --> 00:20:10.723
<v April Roa>Thank you.

109
00:20:11.528 --> 00:20:33.598
<v Sierra Ellis>Um, so as you know, or may or may not know, ceasefire was started in July 2023 during a time when Portland was experiencing and one of the most important things to understand is that, as Franz mentioned, it's not just one person, one bureau, one office or organization.

110
00:20:33.646 --> 00:20:39.141
<v Sierra Ellis>It's a coordinated strategy that brings multiple partners together around one shared goal.

111
00:20:39.253 --> 00:20:40.057
<v Sierra Ellis>Can we change the slide?

112
00:20:41.406 --> 00:20:48.683
<v Sierra Ellis>Our goal is, again, to reduce shootings, prevent retaliation, and to reduce the impact of gun violence on our community.

113
00:20:48.652 --> 00:20:50.071
<v Sierra Ellis>And increase public safety.

114
00:20:51.071 --> 00:20:58.236
<v Sierra Ellis>And then, as Frowns mentioned, my role as ceasefire manager is to coordinate the strategy, ensure partners are aligned on the goal.

115
00:21:00.119 --> 00:21:02.705
<v Sierra Ellis>And reducing gun violence cannot happen in silos.

116
00:21:03.143 --> 00:21:11.015
<v Sierra Ellis>And so law enforcement, community organizations, service providers, and system partners all bring different tools, but we have to be working together to make this work.

117
00:21:11.554 --> 00:21:21.565
<v Sierra Ellis>We coordinate closely with partners across the system, including the District Attorney's Office, Department of Community Justice, Oregon Youth Authority, our hospitals, community organizations, and regional partners.

118
00:21:21.676 --> 00:21:24.695
<v Sierra Ellis>And a critical piece of this model is legitimacy.

119
00:21:25.836 --> 00:21:32.467
<v Sierra Ellis>This strategy is intentional and it's designed around collaboration, accountability, transparency, and focused intervention.

120
00:21:33.382 --> 00:21:36.801
<v Sierra Ellis>The goal is to focus on violence and not communities.

121
00:21:36.866 --> 00:21:40.757
<v Sierra Ellis>It's to focus on people who are driving the violence so we can reduce the violence in our city.

122
00:21:41.903 --> 00:21:44.694
<v Sierra Ellis>Next slide.

123
00:21:44.824 --> 00:21:54.508
<v Sierra Ellis>So this strategy relies on 5 core components to make it work and to make it effective.

124
00:21:55.410 --> 00:22:02.788
<v Sierra Ellis>The first is data-driven identification, and that is understanding who is at the highest risk and where intervention is needed.

125
00:22:03.433 --> 00:22:11.913
<v Sierra Ellis>The second is direct communication, delivering a clear message that violence must stop while making sure individuals know support and opportunities are available.

126
00:22:12.526 --> 00:22:19.185
<v Sierra Ellis>The third is community violence intervention, providing intensive services, outreach, mediation, and support.

127
00:22:19.667 --> 00:22:27.013
<v Sierra Ellis>And the fourth is focused enforcement and supervision, ensuring accountability is focused on those driving violence.

128
00:22:28.682 --> 00:22:38.363
<v Sierra Ellis>Um, and then finally, uh, performance management, continuing continuously reviewing outcomes, adjusting our approach, and maintaining accountability and building public trust.

129
00:22:38.523 --> 00:22:40.914
<v Sierra Ellis>And we do that through various measures.

130
00:22:41.027 --> 00:22:49.645
<v Sierra Ellis>I have a data analyst who does an annual report, our monthly report, and quarterly rapid analysis.

131
00:22:49.693 --> 00:22:54.075
<v Sierra Ellis>So we make sure that we're addressing gun violence and staying ahead of the trends that we're seeing.

132
00:22:55.230 --> 00:23:04.109
<v Sierra Ellis>So together, these components create the framework of how next slide.

133
00:23:04.109 --> 00:23:10.359
<v Sierra Ellis>Moving the strategy into action is crucial, and we start with the shooting review.

134
00:23:10.849 --> 00:23:14.309
<v Sierra Ellis>And so I'm going to pass this off to you, Franz, to explain a little bit more about the shooting review.

135
00:23:14.969 --> 00:23:23.309
<v Franz Schaning>So like Sierra said, I mean, at the heart of this is coordination and collaboration, and you can't do that without sharing information across all the different stakeholders around the gun violence problem.

136
00:23:24.369 --> 00:23:26.009
<v Franz Schaning>Obviously, some of that information is sensitive.

137
00:23:26.009 --> 00:23:27.049
<v Franz Schaning>It's law enforcement sensitive.

138
00:23:27.049 --> 00:23:28.730
<v Franz Schaning>It involves investigations that are open and ongoing.

139
00:23:28.730 --> 00:23:28.950
<v Nate Howard>So there's a limited amount of information that we can share.

140
00:23:30.630 --> 00:23:33.321
<v Franz Schaning>Information we can share within that space around these events.

141
00:23:33.946 --> 00:23:47.682
<v Franz Schaning>But what we did was bring in Sierra staff, get them background cleared so that they could sit in those meetings with law enforcement to talk about sensitive open investigations to make sure there's a conduit to pass that information and refer folks for services during that meeting.

142
00:23:47.730 --> 00:23:50.021
<v Franz Schaning>So the shooting review is a biweekly meeting.

143
00:23:50.213 --> 00:24:09.272
<v Franz Schaning>We bring in law enforcement agencies from all around the region, our prosecutors, our community justice partners who are managing parole and probation with community corrections, ceasefire staff, And others, and we literally discuss every single shooting incident that happened in the city of Portland for the prior 2 weeks, whether it involved property damage, injuries, or homicides.

144
00:24:09.851 --> 00:24:11.087
<v Franz Schaning>Every incident is discussed.

145
00:24:11.152 --> 00:24:16.531
<v Franz Schaning>We talk about the people involved in those incidents, both the suspects and the victims, the impacted folks.

146
00:24:16.998 --> 00:24:29.173
<v Franz Schaning>We talk about what drove those shooting incidents, if we can figure out what that is, what factors there are, if there are risk factors that have kind of tied back to the problem analysis, and start identifying when we can start pulling levers and intervene.

147
00:24:29.461 --> 00:24:37.990
<v Franz Schaning>Beyond just the investigation and the accountability piece, when we can start referring people over for services through Ceasefire to the community-based organizations as well.

148
00:24:38.502 --> 00:24:43.296
<v Franz Schaning>We share information between investigators and agencies to see if there's, you know, one shooting is connected to another.

149
00:24:43.712 --> 00:24:50.028
<v Franz Schaning>We talk about every case where somebody was arrested with a firearm in the city of Portland for that prior 2 weeks to see if there's, again, ways we can intervene.

150
00:24:50.300 --> 00:24:51.310
<v Franz Schaning>We know people are carrying guns.

151
00:24:51.647 --> 00:24:53.009
<v Franz Schaning>They may be involved in shootings later on.

152
00:24:53.105 --> 00:24:55.686
<v Franz Schaning>So again, how do we get ahead of that and address those folks?

153
00:24:56.393 --> 00:25:08.544
<v Franz Schaning>We also talk about data around the NIBIN system, or National Integrated Ballistic Information Network system, where, you know, each firearm that's discharged in the city of Portland— for the most part, they discharge spent casings.

154
00:25:08.655 --> 00:25:09.665
<v Franz Schaning>Those have unique markings.

155
00:25:10.098 --> 00:25:16.671
<v Franz Schaning>We can start to enter those into the system and connect different shooting scenes and different guns to different people, or connect certain incidents.

156
00:25:16.815 --> 00:25:26.749
<v Franz Schaning>And so again, taking all that information, figuring out how we can move investigations along, and then again, how we can refer high-risk individuals to Sierra staff for further services.

157
00:25:28.628 --> 00:25:28.950
<v Rachael Fetters>Thanks.

158
00:25:29.769 --> 00:25:36.429
<v Sierra Ellis>So on your presentation, you can see that on respond, there's 2 different ways, as Franz mentioned.

159
00:25:36.477 --> 00:25:42.415
<v Sierra Ellis>So law enforcement is accountability, and then community violence intervention is services, also accountability on that side.

160
00:25:43.579 --> 00:25:52.329
<v Sierra Ellis>And so we are not just looking at individual incidents in these We are looking at relationships.

161
00:25:52.861 --> 00:25:55.855
<v Sierra Ellis>We are looking at retaliation risk.

162
00:25:56.903 --> 00:26:03.736
<v Sierra Ellis>And we're also trying to get ahead of the conflicts that continue to— that continue the cycle of violence.

163
00:26:04.298 --> 00:26:08.093
<v Sierra Ellis>So once those conflicts are identified, we coordinate a response.

164
00:26:08.173 --> 00:26:13.134
<v Sierra Ellis>And these are the 2 ways we do that, through community violence intervention response and then through peer-based response.

165
00:26:14.288 --> 00:26:25.913
<v Sierra Ellis>And both are happening at the same time, most likely, but they obviously have different roles but with the same goals to reduce shootings and prevent retaliation.

166
00:26:27.054 --> 00:26:36.109
<v Sierra Ellis>And so I'm going to start by walking through the community violence intervention side of the strategy, and then Franz will cover the law enforcement side later on.

167
00:26:36.640 --> 00:26:38.646
<v Franz Schaning>Again, talk about the coordination meeting.

168
00:26:39.513 --> 00:26:40.750
<v Sierra Ellis>Oh, yes.

169
00:26:41.183 --> 00:27:04.080
<v Sierra Ellis>So also within this slide, when we analyze the information that comes from the shooting review, the coordination meeting is a more broad meeting with— we have 2 coordination meetings with our service providers and with folks from the county, DCJ, which is Department of Community Justice.

170
00:27:08.041 --> 00:27:11.834
<v Sierra Ellis>Individualized plans for each person who is referred from the shooting review.

171
00:27:12.477 --> 00:27:17.685
<v Sierra Ellis>So that's extremely important because, you know, everyone is different.

172
00:27:17.767 --> 00:27:20.030
<v Sierra Ellis>The circumstances around the shootings are different.

173
00:27:20.935 --> 00:27:27.070
<v Sierra Ellis>So we want to make sure that their— the approach to them is tailored specifically to them.

174
00:27:27.153 --> 00:27:29.795
<v Sierra Ellis>That's why it's important to have multiple community-based organizations that are able to work with them.

175
00:27:30.140 --> 00:27:35.242
<v Sierra Ellis>Organizations who are able to connect with that person.

176
00:27:36.743 --> 00:27:45.818
<v Sierra Ellis>So once we develop that plan, refer them out, community-based organizations have a certain amount of time when they can connect with them.

177
00:27:47.160 --> 00:27:55.077
<v Sierra Ellis>There's a term we use, it's the relentless pursuit model, and that could take anywhere from 3 to 6 months to get someone actually on a caseload.

178
00:27:55.741 --> 00:28:01.892
<v Sierra Ellis>And so that is a lot of where the time and the most important time to like get that person to help change their lives.

179
00:28:02.260 --> 00:28:04.718
<v Sierra Ellis>A lot of people say no, but some people say yes.

180
00:28:05.215 --> 00:28:09.423
<v Sierra Ellis>And those are the ones we want to say yes because those are the people who are driving violence in our city.

181
00:28:09.471 --> 00:28:20.597
<v Sierra Ellis>Those are the people who are meeting all those risk factors that the problem analysis has identified, who are your small portion of people doing most of the gun violence in our city.

182
00:28:22.154 --> 00:28:32.230
<v Sierra Ellis>So community violence focuses on providing intensive services and supports and opportunities to individuals who are at the highest risk, as I mentioned.

183
00:28:32.728 --> 00:28:38.807
<v Sierra Ellis>When appropriate, we, we start with direct and respectful communication through custom notifications and call-ins.

184
00:28:40.203 --> 00:28:44.888
<v Sierra Ellis>Custom notifications are direct communication to the person.

185
00:28:45.162 --> 00:28:52.904
<v Sierra Ellis>I will go to meet someone at a safe spot and have that conversation around their behavior.

186
00:28:53.595 --> 00:29:02.305
<v Sierra Ellis>I will meet with their probation— our probation officer and meet with them to talk them through, like, what we know about their behavior and we would like it to change.

187
00:29:02.368 --> 00:29:04.490
<v Sierra Ellis>Otherwise, there's also accountability to that piece.

188
00:29:05.663 --> 00:29:12.299
<v Sierra Ellis>And then call-ins are a group of folks driving violence, and so we want to have thank you.

189
00:29:12.299 --> 00:29:37.980
<v Sierra Ellis>I think that we need to send out a shared message to them that is respectful but also very clear around their behavior, and that we would— it's not tolerated, and there's also services and supports for you, but we would, you know, continued behavior like that is either, you know, going to have a consequence with law enforcement, and then you also have the consequences of the city.

190
00:29:42.450 --> 00:29:47.861
<v Sierra Ellis>I want to mention that a critical part of this work is relationship-based.

191
00:29:49.146 --> 00:29:51.640
<v Sierra Ellis>It's not simply providing a referral.

192
00:29:51.817 --> 00:30:03.325
<v Sierra Ellis>It requires trusted messengers who consistently engage with people, build trust, and help them remove the barriers that they're facing that might be causing— that might be the root cause of their homelessness.

193
00:30:03.420 --> 00:30:04.462
<v Sierra Ellis>Cause of the violence.

194
00:30:05.603 --> 00:30:15.365
<v Sierra Ellis>From there, individuals are connected to our intensive case management services, which include mentorship, goal planning, connection to resources and services, and long-term support.

195
00:30:16.361 --> 00:30:27.712
<v Sierra Ellis>Our intensive case managers are able to open doors that traditional systems often cannot because they have built relationships with the individuals who are most impacted by violence.

196
00:30:30.282 --> 00:30:39.153
<v Sierra Ellis>They help navigate the barriers, as I mentioned, and build consistent support to create pathways from violence towards stability.

197
00:30:40.133 --> 00:30:48.134
<v Sierra Ellis>Our community partners connect individuals to services while playing a critical role in conflict mediation.

198
00:30:48.890 --> 00:30:54.818
<v Sierra Ellis>And later on, we'll have some of our service providers come up and talk directly about that so you can get a better sense of what that looks like.

199
00:30:58.157 --> 00:31:01.907
<v Sierra Ellis>Again, the community violence intervention is just one side of this strategy.

200
00:31:03.400 --> 00:31:09.403
<v Sierra Ellis>There's another critical component, which is law enforcement, and Franz and Hubert will talk about that right now.

201
00:31:10.613 --> 00:31:11.144
<v Franz Schaning>Next slide, please.

202
00:31:12.619 --> 00:31:17.663
<v Franz Schaning>So we talked a little bit about the Crime Gun Intelligence Center, or the NIBIN system, the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network.

203
00:31:17.728 --> 00:31:25.940
<v Franz Schaning>So we've got folks who, again, take every casing that's collected from a crime scene, entered that system and looked to see if we can start connecting shooting incidents.

204
00:31:26.180 --> 00:31:30.400
<v Franz Schaning>And that's a national network, so we can connect them not only here within the city of Portland but also our regional partners.

205
00:31:30.400 --> 00:31:33.900
<v Franz Schaning>We've had guns that tied to shootings in Gresham, Eugene, around the state.

206
00:31:34.400 --> 00:31:39.319
<v Franz Schaning>So starting to connect those cases and, and develop investigative leads around those.

207
00:31:39.319 --> 00:31:42.220
<v Franz Schaning>Also potentially start looking at if there's patterns that we're seeing.

208
00:31:42.220 --> 00:31:45.390
<v Franz Schaning>We work with our partners at the ATF around gun trafficking investigations.

209
00:31:45.619 --> 00:31:49.945
<v Franz Schaning>So if we start seeing a lot of guns coming back from the same person that are tied to shootings, We can look at that as well.

210
00:31:52.160 --> 00:31:56.260
<v Franz Schaning>So that's one piece of it, again, about kind of building investigative leads and connecting cases.

211
00:31:56.920 --> 00:31:59.526
<v Franz Schaning>The Enhanced Community Safety Team is a team of investigators.

212
00:31:59.574 --> 00:32:07.083
<v Franz Schaning>They follow up every injury, non-fatal injury shooting, and as capacity and bandwidth allows, non-injury shooting incidents as well.

213
00:32:07.923 --> 00:32:16.048
<v Franz Schaning>They respond to scenes to do the investigation, help collect evidence, and then do those investigations, put together those cases, and all the way through the service of search warrants.

214
00:32:16.240 --> 00:32:17.910
<v Franz Schaning>And arrests.

215
00:32:17.910 --> 00:32:18.789
<v Franz Schaning>They're a key piece of this.

216
00:32:18.789 --> 00:32:22.599
<v Franz Schaning>They come to those shooting review meetings and provide information about the investigations they're conducting.

217
00:32:23.230 --> 00:32:39.490
<v Franz Schaning>Officer Hubert's going to talk a little bit more about the Crisis Response Team later on in the presentation, but those are officers that are specially trained and respond to shooting scenes to kind of de-escalate, deal with some of the heightened emotion and trauma around that, and also continuously follow through and follow up with families that are impacted post-shooting.

218
00:32:41.329 --> 00:32:48.791
<v Franz Schaning>And then our Focus Intervention Team, we talked about it a lot, that's our more proactive side of the gun violence reduction strategy at the Portland Police Bureau.

219
00:32:49.306 --> 00:32:51.474
<v Franz Schaning>They're uniformed officers working the afternoon shift.

220
00:32:51.940 --> 00:32:53.611
<v Franz Schaning>They're highly engaged in community.

221
00:32:54.108 --> 00:33:05.416
<v Franz Schaning>They work closely with the Focus Intervention Team Community Oversight Group, the FITCOG, which oversees the procedures and training and deployment of that body of officers.

222
00:33:06.492 --> 00:33:07.633
<v Franz Schaning>They attend community events.

223
00:33:07.681 --> 00:33:13.833
<v Franz Schaning>They build relationships with youth in the community, particularly in some of our marginalized communities that are more directly impacted by gun violence.

224
00:33:14.960 --> 00:33:15.859
<v Franz Schaning>Disproportionately here in the city of Portland.

225
00:33:16.990 --> 00:33:20.359
<v Franz Schaning>And they're also out there proactively doing traffic stops, following up on investigative leads.

226
00:33:20.410 --> 00:33:28.109
<v Franz Schaning>If we have a suspect vehicle description from a shooting incident and they see that vehicle driving around, they'll do a traffic stop to see if we can identify and move that case forward.

227
00:33:28.549 --> 00:33:30.869
<v Franz Schaning>They'll also follow up on information about high-risk individuals.

228
00:33:30.869 --> 00:33:39.329
<v Franz Schaning>If we know someone, a young person, is carrying a firearm, they may look for opportunities to engage them and do a stop and intervene before that person ends up getting caught up in gun violence.

229
00:33:39.797 --> 00:33:41.289
<v Franz Schaning>So again, that more proactive side of that.

230
00:33:41.643 --> 00:33:46.010
<v Franz Schaning>And then outside of these bodies or these groups here, you know, we talked about the shooting review.

231
00:33:46.557 --> 00:33:50.121
<v Franz Schaning>Part of it is, as Sierra said, there's different strategies for different drivers of gun violence.

232
00:33:50.955 --> 00:33:55.115
<v Franz Schaning>Historically, a lot of our gun violence has been driven by social networks, gangs, and groups in the city of Portland.

233
00:33:55.548 --> 00:34:04.924
<v Franz Schaning>But what we're seeing recently is an increase in the frequency of folks who are houseless or being impacted by houselessness showing up in these gun— these shooting incidents.

234
00:34:05.405 --> 00:34:07.522
<v Franz Schaning>So looking at strategies for addressing that as well.

235
00:34:07.604 --> 00:34:26.302
<v Franz Schaning>So we have the precincts, our neighborhood response teams also engage if we've got, you know, camps that are showing up again and again tied to these shooting incidents or other problematic behavior, looking at how we can work with other homeless services providers or organizations in the city to get that stuff cleaned up or provide people with shelter.

236
00:34:26.480 --> 00:34:33.079
<v Franz Schaning>That's another piece that's not really on the slide here, but again, we really look at this holistically across the Police Bureau had different, different levers to pull.

237
00:34:36.054 --> 00:34:36.797
<v Franz Schaning>Great.

238
00:34:37.039 --> 00:34:41.266
<v Franz Schaning>And then this is an infographic that kind of talks about historical trends around gun violence.

239
00:34:41.621 --> 00:34:44.920
<v Franz Schaning>You know, historically, we've— this has been a really safe city.

240
00:34:45.018 --> 00:34:49.753
<v Franz Schaning>I'd say it is still a really safe city, but, um, we certainly experienced a spike in gun violence post-pandemic.

241
00:34:50.527 --> 00:34:54.088
<v Franz Schaning>Uh, the demographic shows 2020, we had the pandemic.

242
00:34:54.492 --> 00:34:57.309
<v Franz Schaning>Uh, we also had some budget reductions in 2020.

243
00:34:58.309 --> 00:35:03.378
<v Franz Schaning>We ended up disbanding the Gun Violence Reduction Team, which was the Police Bureau's gun violence reduction strategy.

244
00:35:04.925 --> 00:35:08.541
<v Franz Schaning>And not saying correlation or causation, but definitely correlation.

245
00:35:09.219 --> 00:35:13.916
<v Franz Schaning>We saw a spike in violence post-pandemic and post-dismantling of GVRT.

246
00:35:15.172 --> 00:35:24.463
<v Franz Schaning>And across 2020 into '21, the peak being 2022, in that period of time, we did bring back the Enhanced Community Safety Team, again, our body of investigators who do that follow-up.

247
00:35:25.119 --> 00:35:40.286
<v Franz Schaning>And then in January of 2022, working closely in conjunction with Mayor Wheeler's office at the time and Stephanie Howard and the Community Oversight Group, brought back that body of uniformed proactive officers to again try to intervene in that gun violence trend.

248
00:35:40.724 --> 00:35:44.494
<v Franz Schaning>And you can see, you know, some successes there into 2022 that starts coming back down.

249
00:35:45.092 --> 00:35:48.090
<v Franz Schaning>And then the formal launch of Ceasefire in July of 2023.

250
00:35:48.576 --> 00:35:49.724
<v Franz Schaning>And that trend has just continued.

251
00:35:49.773 --> 00:35:51.458
<v Franz Schaning>I mean, incredibly proud of the work we're doing.

252
00:35:52.152 --> 00:35:52.719
<v Franz Schaning>It's not done.

253
00:35:52.768 --> 00:36:03.003
<v Franz Schaning>There's still— we're still above where we want to see for gun violence in the City of Portland, but a very successful strategy across the board, bringing all these partners together, and shown there on the infographic.

254
00:36:04.652 --> 00:36:10.858
<v Franz Schaning>And 2026 doesn't have to date, but I'd say the trend is continuing even better or even greater into 2026.

255
00:36:11.134 --> 00:36:12.284
<v Franz Schaning>Really encouraging data.

256
00:36:13.407 --> 00:36:13.753
<v April Roa>Yep.

257
00:36:14.327 --> 00:36:17.503
<v Sierra Ellis>I also want to highlight this slide too because thank you.

258
00:36:17.827 --> 00:36:24.846
<v Sierra Ellis>You know, we're just looking at numbers, but these are lives saved and people— less people being victimized every day.

259
00:36:24.927 --> 00:36:40.797
<v Sierra Ellis>So it's important that this data is here, but that is something that I just— I want to, you know, put out there, that not only are we seeing reductions, we're seeing the reduced trauma in our community that really impacts a small amount of people in our city.

260
00:36:42.440 --> 00:36:52.150
<v Sierra Ellis>And so while we're here, I also want to talk about what the work looks like in real time to get to where we are today.

261
00:36:53.739 --> 00:36:54.226
<v Sierra Ellis>Next slide.

262
00:36:56.188 --> 00:37:05.342
<v Sierra Ellis>I say this coordination happens through 3 phases: planning, responding, and preventing.

263
00:37:06.333 --> 00:37:07.583
<v Sierra Ellis>And I guess 4, intervening.

264
00:37:08.789 --> 00:37:22.054
<v Sierra Ellis>So before a large event like Cinco de Mayo or Good in the Hood happens or other community events, we do not want to wait for something to happen.

265
00:37:22.724 --> 00:37:23.293
<v Sierra Ellis>We want to be proactive.

266
00:37:24.614 --> 00:37:36.188
<v Sierra Ellis>So we bring the partners together, including PPV, event organizers, community violence intervention partners, and other stakeholders so everyone is operating from the same, um, information.

267
00:37:36.766 --> 00:37:44.708
<v Sierra Ellis>We discuss the community dynamics, recent conflicts, potential retaliation concerns, staffing plans, and communications protocols.

268
00:37:45.126 --> 00:37:48.898
<v Sierra Ellis>This is for most of the large events that you see throughout the city of Portland.

269
00:37:50.496 --> 00:37:55.150
<v Sierra Ellis>Um, and the goal is simple: partners should be aligned before anything occurs.

270
00:37:55.728 --> 00:38:09.052
<v Sierra Ellis>Um, if violence does occur, coordination continues through the shooting reviews and partner meetings that We look beyond the individual incident to understand what conflict exists.

271
00:38:09.601 --> 00:38:10.719
<v Sierra Ellis>Is there a risk of retaliation?

272
00:38:11.780 --> 00:38:12.744
<v Sierra Ellis>Who needs support?

273
00:38:13.900 --> 00:38:19.090
<v Sierra Ellis>And what resources need to be activated following that violent incident?

274
00:38:19.670 --> 00:38:22.088
<v Sierra Ellis>From there, each partner responds within their role.

275
00:38:22.251 --> 00:38:30.842
<v Sierra Ellis>And at this point, I'm going to— Councilor you want to talk about your role and the amazing things that you do every day?

276
00:38:31.804 --> 00:38:32.896
<v Jason Hubert>Uh, good morning.

277
00:38:32.945 --> 00:38:33.989
<v Jason Hubert>Uh, Jason Hubert.

278
00:38:34.213 --> 00:38:36.012
<v Jason Hubert>I'm the coordinator for the Crisis Response Team.

279
00:38:37.264 --> 00:38:43.992
<v Jason Hubert>When a shooting occurs, the Crisis Response Team is often one of the first connections between the Portland Police Bureau, impacted individuals, and their families.

280
00:38:45.213 --> 00:38:55.795
<v Jason Hubert>A significant part of my role is serving as that bridge, ensuring information is shared, needs are identified, And coordination occurs between Ceasefire, PPB, and our community partners.

281
00:38:56.791 --> 00:39:08.679
<v Jason Hubert>In the immediate aftermath of a shooting, myself most likely, Sierra and her Ceasefire team, and the CBOs that are behind me, we get together and we ask these several— we ask these 4 questions basically.

282
00:39:09.081 --> 00:39:10.927
<v Jason Hubert>What does the victim family need?

283
00:39:12.277 --> 00:39:14.429
<v Jason Hubert>Are there any immediate safety concerns?

284
00:39:15.168 --> 00:39:15.987
<v Jason Hubert>A lot of times there are.

285
00:39:16.856 --> 00:39:19.201
<v Jason Hubert>Is relocation assistance necessary?

286
00:39:20.166 --> 00:39:22.248
<v Jason Hubert>And is there a risk of retaliation?

287
00:39:22.764 --> 00:39:32.659
<v Jason Hubert>We really concentrate on that last question there, retaliation, because a lot of times people who are on guns, they carry, they carry guns, right?

288
00:39:33.047 --> 00:39:35.188
<v Jason Hubert>So if you carry guns, there's a reason why you carry guns.

289
00:39:35.382 --> 00:39:36.306
<v Jason Hubert>They say for protection.

290
00:39:36.664 --> 00:39:45.333
<v Jason Hubert>Well, if you carry a gun for protection, that means if someone comes at you that you don't like in this current group environment that we have, you will be addressed.

291
00:39:45.431 --> 00:39:46.528
<v Jason Hubert>And this is how we're doing it right now.

292
00:39:47.760 --> 00:39:56.833
<v Jason Hubert>Through the relationships we have built within the community, we are able to have direct and meaningful conversations with families and individuals during some of the most difficult moments of their lives.

293
00:39:57.844 --> 00:40:11.717
<v Jason Hubert>Our support can include connecting families with resources, assisting with funeral-related needs, developing safety plans, assisting them with trauma-impacted counseling, and coordinating services through trusted community partners.

294
00:40:13.034 --> 00:40:16.161
<v Jason Hubert>Another critical component of this work is preventing further violence.

295
00:40:16.884 --> 00:40:30.568
<v Jason Hubert>Through shooting reviews, coordination across PPB units like homicide, ECST, and FIT, and ongoing communication with ceasefire partners, we work together to identify potential retaliation concerns and intervene before another incident occurs.

296
00:40:31.643 --> 00:40:38.509
<v Jason Hubert>Information sharing, collaboration, and trust are essential to the success of this work and to supporting safer outcomes for everyone involved.

297
00:40:40.856 --> 00:40:49.748
<v Jason Hubert>Last thing I would like to say before you guys have questions later is that this man right here, and there's other several people back here in this room, I constantly talk to this guy.

298
00:40:50.376 --> 00:40:51.809
<v Jason Hubert>I talked to him at 4:30 this morning.

299
00:40:52.483 --> 00:40:53.418
<v Jason Hubert>We had a homicide this morning.

300
00:40:53.851 --> 00:40:54.657
<v Jason Hubert>He calls me.

301
00:40:56.949 --> 00:40:57.679
<v Jason Hubert>Can I go there for a minute?

302
00:40:57.858 --> 00:40:58.117
<v Jason Hubert>All right.

303
00:40:58.442 --> 00:41:01.347
<v Jason Hubert>Back in the day, Marvin and I didn't see eye to eye.

304
00:41:01.914 --> 00:41:04.025
<v Jason Hubert>I wore this uniform, Marvin wore another uniform.

305
00:41:05.443 --> 00:41:09.869
<v Jason Hubert>It was all about respect and how we respected each other on the streets when we contacted each other.

306
00:41:10.759 --> 00:41:12.246
<v Jason Hubert>Marvin has my personal number now.

307
00:41:12.778 --> 00:41:13.780
<v Jason Hubert>He calls me all the time.

308
00:41:15.063 --> 00:41:17.811
<v Jason Hubert>The minute I went back, back here behind me, call me all the time.

309
00:41:19.326 --> 00:41:25.668
<v Jason Hubert>You can't— sorry, that doesn't happen anywhere else.

310
00:41:27.932 --> 00:41:37.748
<v Jason Hubert>The compassion that I have and my unit has, my CRT unit has, and the compassion that he has for helping this community, you, you can't, you can't judge that.

311
00:41:37.989 --> 00:41:43.099
<v Jason Hubert>I mean, there's just nothing you can, nothing you can do to see what we're doing in the community.

312
00:41:43.275 --> 00:41:45.172
<v Jason Hubert>It doesn't— it goes unnoticed, I'll tell you that.

313
00:41:46.088 --> 00:41:49.719
<v Jason Hubert>Um, Marvin and I and the people back here in the room, we don't get a pat on the back.

314
00:41:49.784 --> 00:41:50.940
<v Jason Hubert>Hey, thank you for assisting me.

315
00:41:50.989 --> 00:41:51.969
<v Jason Hubert>Hey, thank you for moving me.

316
00:41:52.355 --> 00:41:56.998
<v Jason Hubert>Thank you for, you know, giving me, sending me food or services.

317
00:41:57.159 --> 00:41:57.976
<v Jason Hubert>That doesn't happen.

318
00:41:58.253 --> 00:42:00.998
<v Jason Hubert>We don't get a pat on the back, but we do it because we love our community.

319
00:42:02.632 --> 00:42:03.376
<v Jason Hubert>And I'll be— I'll end there.

320
00:42:04.639 --> 00:42:06.614
<v Jason Hubert>And please ask me questions later.

321
00:42:06.679 --> 00:42:08.103
<v Jason Hubert>I'll, I'll try to calm down.

322
00:42:09.139 --> 00:42:09.943
<v Eric Zimmerman>Sorry.

323
00:42:10.605 --> 00:42:34.731
<v Sierra Ellis>Um, on that note, um, you know, I want to take some time and give Marvin and, uh, Tamo and Jihad some time to really talk about their work and how they how we all work together, because it is— it's something special that, you know, when we travel and go to these conferences around community violence intervention, we're often asked, like, wow, how do you guys, like, work with them?

324
00:42:34.925 --> 00:42:40.721
<v Sierra Ellis>We don't— we do not work with our intervention specialists like that, or we do not work with our law enforcement partners like that.

325
00:42:40.784 --> 00:42:50.514
<v Sierra Ellis>I think there's something, like, really incredibly special up here and behind me and what we've built over the last 3 years, and it's been hard.

326
00:42:50.563 --> 00:42:51.559
<v Sierra Ellis>It's been very hard.

327
00:42:51.623 --> 00:43:05.608
<v Sierra Ellis>We've came off a lot of, um, you know, there was disagreements, but, you know, I think something that is important is that we are all able to adjust and, um, you know, meet the needs of the communities when asked.

328
00:43:05.735 --> 00:43:13.233
<v Sierra Ellis>And I think, you know, again, as Hubert said, there was a homicide today, um, and it's disheartening.

329
00:43:13.378 --> 00:43:18.235
<v Sierra Ellis>You know, we would love to So the work we do is crucial to that.

330
00:43:18.413 --> 00:43:28.065
<v Sierra Ellis>And again, we see our houseless neighbors being victimized at a high rate right now, and that is very concerning for us.

331
00:43:28.179 --> 00:43:38.076
<v Sierra Ellis>And so we are trying to figure out how we can address that problem because it's terrible.

332
00:43:38.400 --> 00:43:39.259
<v Sierra Ellis>Thank you.

333
00:43:40.516 --> 00:43:47.163
<v Sierra Ellis>So, Marvin, I'll pass it off to you to talk about intervention, mediation, and on-scene response.

334
00:43:47.900 --> 00:43:48.961
<v Marvin Young>Hello, my name is Marvin Young.

335
00:43:49.059 --> 00:43:51.543
<v Marvin Young>I'm the executive director of Nurture Outreach Services.

336
00:43:52.840 --> 00:44:12.489
<v Marvin Young>Mediation is one of the most important things in, in this work, but I want to go more into the intervention side of this because mediation happens in both of these, but There is proactive intervention and then there's reactive intervention.

337
00:44:14.000 --> 00:44:17.601
<v Marvin Young>A lot of the reactive intervention is what you guys are tracking with the numbers.

338
00:44:19.817 --> 00:44:20.447
<v Marvin Young>And it's important.

339
00:44:20.561 --> 00:44:21.773
<v Marvin Young>It's very important to do it.

340
00:44:22.786 --> 00:44:30.478
<v Marvin Young>I've been on scenes where we had a reactive intervention and a mediation with entire groups.

341
00:44:31.173 --> 00:44:39.161
<v Marvin Young>On one scene at the same time while the investigation was going on to make sure nothing followed through with that and isolated the incident.

342
00:44:39.630 --> 00:44:46.760
<v Marvin Young>And there's yet to be anything retaliatory of that that cost a life.

343
00:44:47.103 --> 00:44:47.429
<v Marvin Young>Right.

344
00:44:48.717 --> 00:44:51.653
<v Marvin Young>The most unseen part of it is the proactive intervention.

345
00:44:53.780 --> 00:45:02.768
<v Marvin Young>There's avenues like Huber told you, I'm I formerly wore a different suit and I had a feeling towards the police.

346
00:45:04.190 --> 00:45:15.318
<v Marvin Young>And then I got involved in this work and there's things that the data that they give us, it's not always the one that comes through the office that applies to this number.

347
00:45:16.030 --> 00:45:22.255
<v Marvin Young>Like they might know an individual to just— he hasn't made the arrest.

348
00:45:22.318 --> 00:45:22.496
<v Marvin Young>Yeah.

349
00:45:23.065 --> 00:45:27.461
<v Marvin Young>He hasn't made the shooting, but he— I mean, he's right there.

350
00:45:28.221 --> 00:45:34.773
<v Marvin Young>And those type of referrals, I can get a personal call to go check on this individual and get these guys in there.

351
00:45:35.463 --> 00:45:47.813
<v Marvin Young>And that is the unseen data that right now my organization has 70 individuals, 25 through street-level outreach and 45 that's been referred just through the back door.

352
00:45:47.878 --> 00:45:48.088
<v Marvin Young>Thank you.

353
00:45:48.302 --> 00:45:58.344
<v Marvin Young>From community, PPB, and friends and associates that just come through with a community referral off of our own website.

354
00:45:58.505 --> 00:45:59.068
<v Marvin Young>Right.

355
00:45:59.775 --> 00:46:07.121
<v Marvin Young>And the proactive part of this, this that I feel is just, it's just being overlooked because what we do with the program.

356
00:46:07.932 --> 00:46:09.958
<v Marvin Young>So my program is a 4-step program.

357
00:46:10.039 --> 00:46:12.503
<v Marvin Young>It does do off of the ceasefire model.

358
00:46:12.615 --> 00:46:14.302
<v Marvin Young>And you guys heard all of that, right?

359
00:46:14.398 --> 00:46:14.447
<v Marvin Young>Yes.

360
00:46:14.813 --> 00:46:24.596
<v Marvin Young>But the accountability issues and things that these individuals are served with, it's— I don't want you guys to miss out on the influence.

361
00:46:26.331 --> 00:46:27.594
<v Marvin Young>Influence is a big thing in this.

362
00:46:28.759 --> 00:46:33.614
<v Marvin Young>And these individuals, they can be influenced in a negative way or a positive way.

363
00:46:35.353 --> 00:46:41.478
<v Marvin Young>And when we sit here with PBB and Ceasefire and we do an intervention, yes.

364
00:46:42.467 --> 00:46:45.773
<v Marvin Young>On a subject that is going right now.

365
00:46:46.253 --> 00:46:51.195
<v Marvin Young>You guys probably don't know what's going on in the back streets or what's going on in the private things.

366
00:46:52.030 --> 00:46:54.644
<v Marvin Young>And these are the things that is being overlooked on all of this.

367
00:46:54.838 --> 00:47:11.380
<v Marvin Young>And these are the most important things, because if we can mediate the things that's going on that we find out that's going on in the streets— I mean, you have individuals who done came through shooting reviews and done worked with CBOs and they're asking, hey man, we need to mediate this.

368
00:47:11.702 --> 00:47:13.715
<v Marvin Young>Can you get this person and this person?

369
00:47:14.117 --> 00:47:16.581
<v Marvin Young>And I'll tell you, like, individuals will call somebody.

370
00:47:17.097 --> 00:47:21.713
<v Marvin Young>And the way my team is designed, I have a little bit of everybody from every area.

371
00:47:22.630 --> 00:47:32.001
<v Marvin Young>So when you find out that there's a conflict brewing, you will come, they'll call someone, I'll call them, and it'll be the 2 sides of those guys.

372
00:47:32.452 --> 00:47:34.402
<v Marvin Young>It might only take just relocating one guy.

373
00:47:34.530 --> 00:47:34.594
<v Marvin Young>Yeah.

374
00:47:35.202 --> 00:47:40.257
<v Marvin Young>It might take a one-on-one with those guys with us being in the middle, or it might take us and the whole group.

375
00:47:41.541 --> 00:47:49.052
<v Marvin Young>And I think that that's the most important part of the intervention model that needs to be looked at, not just the numbers.

376
00:47:50.047 --> 00:47:52.471
<v Marvin Young>Every time we come into this thing, I hear about the numbers.

377
00:47:53.032 --> 00:48:00.929
<v Marvin Young>The numbers is great, but it's the reason why Portland is different from everywhere else is because the collaboration that's going on.

378
00:48:01.266 --> 00:48:02.403
<v Marvin Young>I never thought I would see it.

379
00:48:02.724 --> 00:48:04.552
<v Marvin Young>I never trusted it in 2023.

380
00:48:04.889 --> 00:48:06.605
<v Marvin Young>I never trusted it in 2024.

381
00:48:07.213 --> 00:48:24.528
<v Marvin Young>But then when you start seeing what's happening and you start getting referrals for individuals that I personally know is high risk from the Portland Police, instead of them booking them on something minor just to get them into the program, I think that's the biggest thing going here.

382
00:48:25.251 --> 00:48:32.152
<v Marvin Young>And I think that I've been looking at this and I felt like everything as it was getting stronger, A Band-Aid was being put over it.

383
00:48:33.103 --> 00:48:40.985
<v Marvin Young>And I think that the Band-Aid being put over it is going to stop everything we're doing within the city with everybody involved in this.

384
00:48:41.422 --> 00:48:50.755
<v Marvin Young>I mean, this is going from the Community Safety Division all the way to the participants, where the participants is now sharing what is going on in the city.

385
00:48:51.498 --> 00:48:57.869
<v Marvin Young>And they're saying to their friends and everything else, this is— you can contact this person or you can contact this person.

386
00:48:58.724 --> 00:49:01.822
<v Marvin Young>And then all we have to do, like, we don't have— I don't have a two-face.

387
00:49:02.257 --> 00:49:03.059
<v Marvin Young>I have one face.

388
00:49:03.525 --> 00:49:23.226
<v Marvin Young>I mean, I can stand in at a funeral and lean into Huber's car and discuss it with him and what's going on and not be questioned by those individuals because the trust is there, because it's spreading from just a person from the streets talking to another person from the streets.

389
00:49:23.291 --> 00:49:23.418
<v Marvin Young>Thank you.

390
00:49:23.936 --> 00:49:25.925
<v Marvin Young>To proven outcomes.

391
00:49:26.603 --> 00:49:27.509
<v Marvin Young>We've served everyone.

392
00:49:27.831 --> 00:49:29.108
<v Marvin Young>And that's all I had to say.

393
00:49:34.208 --> 00:49:35.469
<v Jahad Hudson>Greetings, Council.

394
00:49:35.969 --> 00:49:42.070
<v Jahad Hudson>Uh, Jahad Hudson, Executive Director for HELP Inc., which stands for Healing, Enriching, and Learning Purpose.

395
00:49:42.666 --> 00:49:59.235
<v Jahad Hudson>Um, I generally work with, uh, population, um, of youth thank you.

396
00:49:59.349 --> 00:50:00.782
<v Jahad Hudson>I'm the Deputy City Attorney for Portland Police Department.

397
00:50:00.864 --> 00:50:01.985
<v Jahad Hudson>I oversee youth engagement and how we engage youth.

398
00:50:03.402 --> 00:50:10.231
<v Jahad Hudson>We use a number of programs to engage youth that's referred from Ceasefire.

399
00:50:11.688 --> 00:50:17.728
<v Jahad Hudson>I will speak on one of the programs that's coming up this summer, which is our summer program.

400
00:50:17.891 --> 00:50:39.588
<v Jahad Hudson>We're going to have a cohort of 15 youth, some referred through Ceasefire and some that we know that are involved or on the fence of possibly being a perpetrator or victim of gun violence within the next 6 to 9 months.

401
00:50:41.248 --> 00:50:51.733
<v Jahad Hudson>And so how we're engaging these youth is we're providing jobs, we're providing cognitive behavior therapy, we're providing conflict resolution.

402
00:50:53.065 --> 00:50:57.128
<v Jahad Hudson>We're also providing life skills and financial literacy.

403
00:50:58.043 --> 00:51:16.315
<v Jahad Hudson>And so how that program is gonna operate this summer is that starting last week of June, They will have, uh, they will start at 9, and from either 9— from 9 to 10, 10:30, they participate in one of the 4 focuses.

404
00:51:16.829 --> 00:51:21.293
<v Jahad Hudson>All right, so week 1, the cognitive, uh, behavior therapy.

405
00:51:21.871 --> 00:51:24.023
<v Jahad Hudson>Then week 2 will be financial literacy.

406
00:51:24.536 --> 00:51:26.992
<v Jahad Hudson>Then week 3 will be life skills.

407
00:51:27.490 --> 00:51:35.318
<v Jahad Hudson>Week 4, so, so forth, so on, until all skills are please speak into the microphone.

408
00:51:37.664 --> 00:51:38.581
<v Jahad Hudson>Oh, into the microphone?

409
00:51:38.628 --> 00:51:38.853
<v Jahad Hudson>Yes, please.

410
00:51:39.545 --> 00:51:43.286
<v Jahad Hudson>I was trying to see this, stay 6 to 8 inches away from the microphone.

411
00:51:43.384 --> 00:51:44.789
<v Jahad Hudson>I tried to gauge that, you know.

412
00:51:45.949 --> 00:51:52.813
<v Jahad Hudson>But, and so, and then from 10:30 to 3, they'd be out working.

413
00:51:53.507 --> 00:52:03.666
<v Jahad Hudson>So they'd be doing graffiti removal, landscaping, Landscaping and working at a farm, one of our local farms, supporting that.

414
00:52:04.018 --> 00:52:16.478
<v Jahad Hudson>We'll also be doing work at Alberta Simmons Center and other community— or other agencies in the neighborhood with volunteer work.

415
00:52:17.523 --> 00:52:20.172
<v Jahad Hudson>So those are just some of the ways we engage youth.

416
00:52:20.878 --> 00:52:26.244
<v Jahad Hudson>We also use Athletics as a vehicle to get them to engage.

417
00:52:26.855 --> 00:52:46.586
<v Jahad Hudson>So we have also a youth basketball team that we'll be having this summer where they will participate in this, on this team, but there will also be other things they have to follow in order to be on this team and be able to play in games and stuff like that.

418
00:52:46.907 --> 00:52:48.514
<v Jahad Hudson>And these type of things— Thank you.

419
00:52:48.967 --> 00:52:59.795
<v Jahad Hudson>Foster change, to get them around positive men, positive women that can kind of change their trajectory of life.

420
00:53:01.820 --> 00:53:09.965
<v Jahad Hudson>And when I think about the things that I needed when I was growing up to help me change was these type of things.

421
00:53:10.974 --> 00:53:14.012
<v Jahad Hudson>It was the PIC program at my first job.

422
00:53:14.847 --> 00:53:27.601
<v Jahad Hudson>It was my basketball coaches, my football coaches that were involved, that continued to encourage positivity when I had so much negativity around me, in my home, in my community.

423
00:53:28.902 --> 00:53:34.429
<v Jahad Hudson>And so those are just different ways that we engage our youth.

424
00:53:35.248 --> 00:53:37.722
<v Jahad Hudson>And then wraparound services.

425
00:53:39.023 --> 00:53:48.121
<v Jahad Hudson>You know, if you If you ever have broken a bone, especially in your hand, they don't just wrap that individual part up, right?

426
00:53:49.664 --> 00:53:52.893
<v Jahad Hudson>They wrap it and they cast it with another finger.

427
00:53:53.182 --> 00:53:54.650
<v Jahad Hudson>Your wrist is usually involved.

428
00:53:54.795 --> 00:53:59.637
<v Jahad Hudson>And that's what wraparound services looks like.

429
00:54:00.121 --> 00:54:01.686
<v Jahad Hudson>Like it needs to be supported.

430
00:54:01.815 --> 00:54:05.478
<v Jahad Hudson>And so with wraparound services, we're— Thank you.

431
00:54:05.838 --> 00:54:07.235
<v Jahad Hudson>Supporting the family.

432
00:54:07.492 --> 00:54:09.965
<v Jahad Hudson>We're connecting them to mental health services.

433
00:54:10.157 --> 00:54:24.126
<v Jahad Hudson>We're connecting them to energy assistance, providing energy assistance, rental assistance, anything to deter things that may get in the way of them focusing on change.

434
00:54:24.367 --> 00:54:33.061
<v Jahad Hudson>When you have so many social determinants in place, you have so many people trying to operate and try to figure out.

435
00:54:33.623 --> 00:54:41.320
<v Jahad Hudson>And when those things are in place, they can't focus on the positive things and doing things the right way.

436
00:54:43.072 --> 00:54:57.014
<v Jahad Hudson>And when a lot of— when resources are not available and they still want to be a part of, they still want to have, they're going to do things more likely that's going to get them in trouble, that's going to have them in situations where— They're going to get in trouble.

437
00:54:57.853 --> 00:55:00.166
<v Jahad Hudson>They can be impacted by gun and gang violence.

438
00:55:00.905 --> 00:55:11.583
<v Jahad Hudson>And so those are just some of the things that HELP Inc. does in partnership with Ceasefire, being one of the CBOs of Ceasefire.

439
00:55:12.224 --> 00:55:12.641
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

440
00:55:13.012 --> 00:55:17.619
<v Steve Novick>I just wanna say that we wanna, I think we might go a little past 10:35.

441
00:55:17.684 --> 00:55:20.735
<v Steve Novick>We're gonna wanna have some time for councilor questions and discussion.

442
00:55:22.661 --> 00:55:24.585
<v Steve Novick>So I think we have one more organization to hear from.

443
00:55:25.291 --> 00:55:25.869
<v Steve Novick>Yes, sir.

444
00:55:26.110 --> 00:55:26.447
<v Temo Alvarado>Thank you.

445
00:55:26.510 --> 00:55:26.862
<v Temo Alvarado>Good morning.

446
00:55:26.911 --> 00:55:27.360
<v Temo Alvarado>Buenos días.

447
00:55:27.632 --> 00:55:29.125
<v Temo Alvarado>My name is Temo Alvarado.

448
00:55:29.621 --> 00:55:33.054
<v Temo Alvarado>I'm the founder of Guía, and we are a culturally specific outreach.

449
00:55:33.567 --> 00:55:42.067
<v Temo Alvarado>We provide culturally specific outreach, mentorship, violence prevention to some of our Latino communities, especially our youth that are really high risk.

450
00:55:43.349 --> 00:55:46.333
<v Temo Alvarado>We try to help them navigate through situations.

451
00:55:46.398 --> 00:55:52.186
<v Temo Alvarado>We try to de-escalate situations when it comes to gun violence, gang violence in our communities.

452
00:55:53.481 --> 00:56:08.577
<v Temo Alvarado>Through trusted relationships, credible messengers, culturally responsive support, we connect high-risk youth to families and resources, providing positive opportunities, interventions to try to reduce the gun violence in our community.

453
00:56:10.219 --> 00:56:13.344
<v Temo Alvarado>So we have a motto, we say at GEAR, we don't just believe in change, we guide it.

454
00:56:14.820 --> 00:56:24.782
<v Temo Alvarado>And through, you know, our partners here, Ceasefire, We've seen that, you know, we've made national recognition about, you know, reducing our gun violence in the community.

455
00:56:25.423 --> 00:56:43.414
<v Temo Alvarado>So we try to make sure that we keep our youth engaged in positive pro-social activities throughout the week, especially youth that are involved in gang violence or that we know that are associated with, you know, unsafe acts in our community.

456
00:56:45.465 --> 00:56:46.378
<v Temo Alvarado>And I'm going to keep it short.

457
00:56:46.443 --> 00:56:51.105
<v Temo Alvarado>I mean, we're just grateful for this opportunity to be here in front of everybody.

458
00:56:51.782 --> 00:56:58.775
<v Temo Alvarado>We thank Ceasefire and their team, our community partners, Hubert, for the work, great work that we're doing in the community.

459
00:56:59.016 --> 00:56:59.963
<v Temo Alvarado>So thank you for the time.

460
00:57:02.364 --> 00:57:03.463
<v Steve Novick>Thank you so much.

461
00:57:04.610 --> 00:57:05.371
<v Sierra Ellis>Thank you.

462
00:57:06.956 --> 00:57:09.284
<v Sierra Ellis>Any questions?

463
00:57:10.632 --> 00:57:11.579
<v Steve Novick>Any comments for any of our panelists?

464
00:57:19.224 --> 00:57:22.960
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, particularly to those 3 community organizations.

465
00:57:23.025 --> 00:57:24.173
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate you stepping up.

466
00:57:24.989 --> 00:57:29.686
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for that, and thanks for sharing kind of how you're— how you work your piece of the pie.

467
00:57:29.927 --> 00:57:36.105
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that's an important approach in terms of different strategies for different folks.

468
00:57:36.559 --> 00:57:47.934
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, and then just for everybody that's involved, uh, I— every now and then you can hear through the way someone describes their work when their family is taking on a burden.

469
00:57:48.063 --> 00:57:53.809
<v Eric Zimmerman>So a phone call at 4:30 AM means there's a family member who's irritated with you that you had to take a call.

470
00:57:54.548 --> 00:58:02.344
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I just want to say thank you to those family members or any of you who are, um, having to explain to your family why you have to take a phone call at 4:30 AM.

471
00:58:02.835 --> 00:58:05.931
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, that is a, that is a sacrifice as well.

472
00:58:07.007 --> 00:58:24.800
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I was interested in some of the prior event work that you discussed in terms of, um, understanding the dynamics, and you mentioned Cinco de Mayo and, um, other events that happen in the, in the, in the area.

473
00:58:24.847 --> 00:58:41.943
<v Eric Zimmerman>So along with that and other things, if we take an event, how often does a suspect or a victim— how often are they already known to the City of Portland in your work?

474
00:58:43.289 --> 00:58:44.706
<v Sierra Ellis>Depends on who you're asking.

475
00:58:46.106 --> 00:58:50.364
<v Eric Zimmerman>Well, I'm going to say collectively, like, because you talked a lot about your interventions.

476
00:58:50.460 --> 00:58:52.695
<v Eric Zimmerman>You talk about how you get somebody nominated on a list.

477
00:58:52.791 --> 00:58:56.423
<v Eric Zimmerman>You talk about how you decide, like, hey, we got to throw some services around.

478
00:58:56.472 --> 00:59:09.753
<v Eric Zimmerman>So for the lay public, this is an area where we know very little, and I'm curious, just based on your own physical reactions when I asked that question, it seems like it's a— you know a lot, but definitely not everybody.

479
00:59:09.865 --> 00:59:12.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>But how do you react to that question?

480
00:59:15.192 --> 00:59:18.081
<v Franz Schaning>I mean, it's a tough question to answer, Councilor.

481
00:59:18.260 --> 00:59:20.987
<v Franz Schaning>I think generally speaking, our shooters we probably know about.

482
00:59:21.322 --> 00:59:26.378
<v Franz Schaning>They've had some interaction with both police and community intervention folks.

483
00:59:27.324 --> 00:59:30.599
<v Franz Schaning>They're high-risk individuals or higher-risk individuals.

484
00:59:31.032 --> 00:59:36.858
<v Franz Schaning>Victims, it's less certain because sometimes it's uninvolved parties that are unintended bystanders are impacted by gun violence.

485
00:59:36.907 --> 00:59:39.025
<v Franz Schaning>So less clarity on that portion.

486
00:59:39.137 --> 00:59:45.894
<v Franz Schaning>But in all of it, it's not like there's a math equation where you hit a certain number of points and then we know you're going to shoot somebody, right?

487
00:59:46.023 --> 00:59:46.280
<v Franz Schaning>It's—.

488
00:59:46.440 --> 00:59:49.650
<v Franz Schaning>We just know you're engaged in activities or behaviors that are higher risk.

489
00:59:50.132 --> 00:59:57.697
<v Franz Schaning>And we start looking at intervention strategies that are proportionate, that fit your needs, and address those risk factors you're demonstrating.

490
00:59:58.626 --> 01:00:07.121
<v Franz Schaning>But I would say largely my experience has been when— by the time someone fires a gun and hits somebody else, they've been on our radar in some fashion for lower-level offenses prior.

491
01:00:08.083 --> 01:00:09.012
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's so interesting.

492
01:00:09.269 --> 01:00:17.956
<v Eric Zimmerman>And often when we talk about programs like this, right, there's an aspect in this area— you mentioned a small portion of people doing the most violence in our community.

493
01:00:18.005 --> 01:00:18.661
<v Eric Zimmerman>That was your Mm-hmm.

494
01:00:19.463 --> 01:00:26.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so we sometimes get the question of like, why do we put resources at a small number, right, who's choosing to engage in a thing?

495
01:00:26.757 --> 01:00:28.231
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I can't think of another crime.

496
01:00:28.295 --> 01:00:35.268
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I was, as you were all testifying, I was trying to think of any other crime that has a larger ripple effect through the community, right?

497
01:00:35.333 --> 01:00:51.590
<v Eric Zimmerman>You may not know the victim, you may not understand the victim, but understanding that, right, in my own district, that 3 bystanders are hit at a bar because of a drive-by, that has a ripple effect on the whole district.

498
01:00:51.639 --> 01:00:56.675
<v Eric Zimmerman>It has a ripple effect on how we all, in fact, how we choose to then engage.

499
01:00:56.724 --> 01:01:11.864
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think that that's a point well taken and something that I think is worth talking about in that we can reduce the number of instigating ripple moments if we are targeted.

500
01:01:11.927 --> 01:01:12.056
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

501
01:01:12.806 --> 01:01:13.992
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then my last question.

502
01:01:14.103 --> 01:01:32.500
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in the slide that kind of showed the shooting review and kind of the steps that went down, one thing that, that popped into my mind— so the male model of violence is that males are generally quite reactive, and that's a lot of what Ceasefire is about, is like we, we intervene in order to prevent the reaction.

503
01:01:32.692 --> 01:01:37.675
<v Eric Zimmerman>And your primary focus that you mentioned were 18 to 44-year-old males, right?

504
01:01:37.739 --> 01:01:39.744
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's a reason we're talking about men, right?

505
01:01:40.291 --> 01:01:41.753
<v Eric Zimmerman>We are the guilty party here.

506
01:01:42.155 --> 01:01:52.599
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what I found interesting though is the every 2 weeks part, because there's another aspect where you're, you're sending somebody to the hospital, right?

507
01:01:52.664 --> 01:01:57.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>You're intervening in the immediacy with a family member or other, other folks around.

508
01:01:57.824 --> 01:02:06.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>So how do those 2 things— because a 2-week review period, and that's what I think you mentioned, we review every shooting in the last 2 weeks.

509
01:02:06.548 --> 01:02:06.612
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

510
01:02:07.085 --> 01:02:11.592
<v Eric Zimmerman>And sometimes from there we identify names that we want to reach out to and spend some more time with.

511
01:02:12.170 --> 01:02:13.947
<v Eric Zimmerman>But also there's the intervention piece.

512
01:02:14.367 --> 01:02:15.014
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

513
01:02:15.112 --> 01:02:17.376
<v Eric Zimmerman>How do those 2 balance together in the model?

514
01:02:17.536 --> 01:02:18.717
<v Sierra Ellis>Yeah, that's a great question.

515
01:02:19.585 --> 01:02:22.041
<v Steve Novick>I'm sorry, but I have to ask so that we can get through some other questions.

516
01:02:22.427 --> 01:02:24.769
<v Steve Novick>Sarah, could you give a rapid-fire response?

517
01:02:25.947 --> 01:02:27.045
<v Sierra Ellis>Yes, I can.

518
01:02:27.094 --> 01:02:30.893
<v Eric Zimmerman>We only scheduled you for 30 minutes, so I don't know why, but here we are at an hour.

519
01:02:30.974 --> 01:02:32.704
<v Eric Zimmerman>But it's a really good topic, so thank you.

520
01:02:32.753 --> 01:02:33.125
<v Eric Zimmerman>Keep going.

521
01:02:33.318 --> 01:02:34.661
<v Sierra Ellis>Yeah, that's a great question.

522
01:02:34.838 --> 01:02:45.744
<v Sierra Ellis>I think what's I think what's most important to know about the shooting reviews, like, it was every week, but as violence went down, we saw that we didn't need a shooting review every week.

523
01:02:45.871 --> 01:02:48.297
<v Sierra Ellis>But I will tell you, like, we are talking every day.

524
01:02:49.356 --> 01:02:52.422
<v Sierra Ellis>So the shooting today, our teams are talking.

525
01:02:52.552 --> 01:03:03.485
<v Sierra Ellis>So it's just a formalized review, but we're looking at— our data analyst is looking at connections from the victim from the shooting, right?

526
01:03:03.548 --> 01:03:08.782
<v Sierra Ellis>Like, so it's like an everyday thing that we're working on to make sure we get ahead of the retaliation.

527
01:03:08.862 --> 01:03:26.034
<v Sierra Ellis>So even if a shooting happens when we don't have a review, we're still working on that shooting in that individual incident to make sure that, like, we are providing resources, we are reaching out to the family, we are making sure that, um, our trauma violence impact— not trauma— HHP is going to the hospital to meet them.

528
01:03:26.115 --> 01:03:30.081
<v Sierra Ellis>So all those things, um, are— it's real-time work.

529
01:03:30.210 --> 01:03:30.385
<v Sierra Ellis>It's—.

530
01:03:30.579 --> 01:03:32.570
<v Sierra Ellis>It doesn't wait for a meeting, I guess.

531
01:03:33.003 --> 01:03:33.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>Great, thank you.

532
01:03:33.871 --> 01:03:35.331
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate you all spending time today.

533
01:03:35.476 --> 01:03:45.414
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know that in a world of cuts budget, I know that the police chief said I need this program still funded, and there were other things that they gave up in order to secure that, and I appreciate that.

534
01:03:45.463 --> 01:03:49.092
<v Eric Zimmerman>So there's more conversation, and I do appreciate everybody showing up today.

535
01:03:49.141 --> 01:03:49.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

536
01:03:50.907 --> 01:03:51.436
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

537
01:03:52.271 --> 01:03:53.204
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

538
01:03:53.864 --> 01:03:56.230
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you all for coming and giving us this presentation.

539
01:03:56.358 --> 01:03:58.081
<v Loretta Smith>I have a question for Jihad.

540
01:03:58.628 --> 01:04:00.527
<v Loretta Smith>Could you come up to the front, please?

541
01:04:10.300 --> 01:04:10.557
<v Jahad Hudson>Hello.

542
01:04:11.059 --> 01:04:13.583
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for the work that you do with our young people.

543
01:04:13.630 --> 01:04:20.673
<v Loretta Smith>I always tell my youth that I work with, with the summer jobs program, I've never seen a kid doing a drive-by on their way to work.

544
01:04:22.630 --> 01:04:38.485
<v Loretta Smith>That being said, are there any other opportunity gaps that we can address that is not being addressed in, in, in these public safety programs that are sponsored by the city that you would like to see more of?

545
01:04:40.809 --> 01:04:57.090
<v Jahad Hudson>Um, resources in like I've mentioned, families, they're with us roughly 2, 3 hours out the day in the summer.

546
01:04:57.333 --> 01:04:57.880
<v Jahad Hudson>Mm-hmm.

547
01:04:58.557 --> 01:05:00.074
<v Jahad Hudson>But during the school year, it's less.

548
01:05:01.117 --> 01:05:09.759
<v Jahad Hudson>And they're in their environment at home with family, friends, whatever the case is, and those influences.

549
01:05:11.293 --> 01:05:13.054
<v Jahad Hudson>More than they are with us.

550
01:05:13.811 --> 01:05:24.048
<v Jahad Hudson>And so there's a lot of things that they need in the home in order to function and be able to—.

551
01:05:24.081 --> 01:05:25.652
<v Loretta Smith>In terms of wraparound supports?

552
01:05:26.487 --> 01:05:26.664
<v Jahad Hudson>Yep.

553
01:05:27.309 --> 01:05:27.487
<v Jahad Hudson>Okay.

554
01:05:27.858 --> 01:05:36.619
<v Jahad Hudson>And so, and just, there's more resources around that because things are being cut and some things are not being addressed.

555
01:05:37.384 --> 01:05:49.768
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so you're saying that the reduction of wraparound supports is, is also something that is causing you all to not be as successful in certain spaces the way that you would like to be?

556
01:05:50.253 --> 01:05:50.577
<v Jahad Hudson>Correct.

557
01:05:50.835 --> 01:05:52.615
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, that's, that's what I needed to hear.

558
01:05:53.101 --> 01:05:54.039
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

559
01:05:54.476 --> 01:05:55.460
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

560
01:05:56.733 --> 01:05:57.409
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

561
01:05:57.521 --> 01:05:58.552
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal.

562
01:06:00.661 --> 01:06:01.822
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair Novick.

563
01:06:02.288 --> 01:06:03.592
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks everybody for being here.

564
01:06:03.722 --> 01:06:05.130
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate the conversation.

565
01:06:05.179 --> 01:06:11.907
<v Sameer Kanal>I did a ride-along with, with Hubert last year with On the FIT side, I hope to do one with, uh, with ECST, uh, this summer.

566
01:06:12.420 --> 01:06:20.786
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and I, I really wanted to also join everyone in appreciating the, the 3, um, Marvin, Jada, Timo, for everything that you do and, and your organizations as well.

567
01:06:21.492 --> 01:06:29.072
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I wanted to, to go back a little bit to the slide with the graphic on it, the, the chart.

568
01:06:29.554 --> 01:06:30.983
<v Sameer Kanal>It's slide 8.

569
01:06:32.010 --> 01:06:38.882
<v Sameer Kanal>And just kind of kind of run through— this is, this is, uh, both injury and fatal shootings together, and it's a monthly average, right?

570
01:06:39.610 --> 01:06:39.724
<v Temo Alvarado>Right.

571
01:06:39.773 --> 01:06:45.451
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and we've seen the fatal shootings perhaps even have a more stark decline.

572
01:06:45.514 --> 01:06:47.797
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, it was a little steeper, if I recall correctly.

573
01:06:48.411 --> 01:06:52.701
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I just wanted to, to note how each part of this sort of built on itself.

574
01:06:53.367 --> 01:06:59.355
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, here, I appreciate that you noted the ECST's establishment, the FITS establishment, and then the ceasefire's establishment.

575
01:06:59.440 --> 01:07:03.188
<v Sameer Kanal>Establishment, and you see when the corners kind of get turned a little bit.

576
01:07:04.639 --> 01:07:08.114
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and just wanted to, to take the opportunity to highlight that again.

577
01:07:08.777 --> 01:07:19.094
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I think it's impossible to argue the idea that ceasefire has made an impact in that, both in terms of the office and the approach, um, broadly.

578
01:07:19.141 --> 01:07:21.195
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciate the, the distinction being drawn there.

579
01:07:21.875 --> 01:07:27.728
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, when I was at the PSSA, gun violence peaked in 2022 from a homicide perspective.

580
01:07:27.809 --> 01:07:30.795
<v Sameer Kanal>And, and that was, uh, there was emergency declaration.

581
01:07:31.199 --> 01:07:36.320
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Director Howard was at the mayor's office at the time, um, as well, was involved in that.

582
01:07:36.853 --> 01:07:43.105
<v Sameer Kanal>And, um, there were— I remember the conversation being that we would never see pre-pandemic levels of gun violence again.

583
01:07:43.168 --> 01:07:47.320
<v Sameer Kanal>The, the sort of new normal, um, phrase was, was thrown around.

584
01:07:47.369 --> 01:07:52.387
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I appreciate very much being able, many years on now, to, to refute that.

585
01:07:53.510 --> 01:07:59.235
<v Sameer Kanal>And to show it numerically and to appreciate how many folks have been involved in it.

586
01:07:59.300 --> 01:08:00.155
<v Sameer Kanal>It's incredible work.

587
01:08:00.219 --> 01:08:01.123
<v Sameer Kanal>It's got a clear impact.

588
01:08:01.186 --> 01:08:02.204
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a tangible impact.

589
01:08:02.704 --> 01:08:10.273
<v Sameer Kanal>And I know that if— I imagine Nick in the back is probably involved in making the chart and showing how clear and tangible it is.

590
01:08:10.628 --> 01:08:13.554
<v Sameer Kanal>So appreciate everyone who's not up here for doing that as well.

591
01:08:15.617 --> 01:08:30.154
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to also appreciate the conversation around how you connect with regional partners in terms of looking and seeing how there may be a connection if there's a previous shooting that was maybe outside of the jurisdiction.

592
01:08:30.684 --> 01:08:32.462
<v Sameer Kanal>How far does that region go?

593
01:08:32.831 --> 01:08:37.060
<v Sameer Kanal>How are you looking, you know, Seattle down to Grants Pass?

594
01:08:37.140 --> 01:08:37.829
<v Sameer Kanal>How far are we going here?

595
01:08:38.454 --> 01:08:39.832
<v Franz Schaning>So 2 components there.

596
01:08:39.881 --> 01:08:40.778
<v Franz Schaning>One is the shooting review.

597
01:08:40.938 --> 01:08:54.176
<v Franz Schaning>We're bringing in pretty much anybody in the county— Gresham Police Department, Multnomah County Sheriff's Office, federal partners to the extent they do gun violence work for the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network.

598
01:08:54.225 --> 01:09:01.250
<v Franz Schaning>That's a national network, so we can tie shooting incidents anywhere in the country if those casings have been entered in another jurisdiction.

599
01:09:01.782 --> 01:09:03.344
<v Franz Schaning>So we've had cases linked to Eugene.

600
01:09:03.408 --> 01:09:11.894
<v Franz Schaning>Again, I don't know of any, any out of state that come to mind, but it's theoretically possible we could have one, a shooting incident in Florida that we're able to connect to our shooting incident here in Portland.

601
01:09:12.716 --> 01:09:13.021
<v Sameer Kanal>Got it.

602
01:09:13.295 --> 01:09:14.728
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's the, the NIBIN system?

603
01:09:14.809 --> 01:09:14.985
<v Brian Hughes>Right.

604
01:09:15.146 --> 01:09:15.484
<v Jennifer Lucht>Thanks.

605
01:09:17.310 --> 01:09:21.909
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor.

606
01:09:22.310 --> 01:09:32.229
<v Steve Novick>I'm curious about what do you think the actual size is of the group of people who at any given point are at risk of committing or being victimized by gun violence?

607
01:09:32.229 --> 01:09:36.689
<v Steve Novick>Are we talking about a few hundred people in the city, a few thousand, a few dozen?

608
01:09:37.710 --> 01:09:40.180
<v Sierra Ellis>It's a few hundred people.

609
01:09:42.010 --> 01:09:43.369
<v Sierra Ellis>And then you have a subset of those who are at risk of committing or being victimized by gun violence.

610
01:09:46.828 --> 01:09:46.925
<v Rachael Fetters>Okay.

611
01:09:47.279 --> 01:09:50.262
<v Jason Hubert>But also remember that those bullets don't have names on them, right?

612
01:09:50.376 --> 01:09:56.529
<v Jason Hubert>So like what happened at the business downtown, it hit 3 people, and that was not the intended target.

613
01:09:58.368 --> 01:10:06.532
<v Steve Novick>So I think— I just thought it was important to get the number out there because that underscores it really is a small group of people that, you know, a limited number of people can work with.

614
01:10:07.864 --> 01:10:18.395
<v Steve Novick>Um, it seemed to be you were talking about responding, anticipating individual events, responding to individual events, but you're also talking about working with people over a period of months.

615
01:10:18.939 --> 01:10:46.510
<v Steve Novick>And I assume there could be a different answer to this depending which organization you're talking about, but Sierra, on balance, how much time do you think people involved with CSPIRE spend working, responding to, or anticipating a particular event, and how much time working with people who you just I mean, the timeframe is difficult to answer, but we—.

616
01:10:46.510 --> 01:10:53.189
<v Sierra Ellis>The community-based organizations that we work with, they employ their staff 40 hours a week, full-time.

617
01:10:53.189 --> 01:10:54.520
<v Sierra Ellis>And so that is their job.

618
01:10:54.689 --> 01:10:58.039
<v Sierra Ellis>They have caseloads that they are connecting with individuals.

619
01:10:58.890 --> 01:11:10.750
<v Sierra Ellis>You know, a person who might have been referred to a community-based organization, they might be referred to a you know, they're starting the program versus someone who might have been in the program for 9 months, the intensity is different for that person.

620
01:11:10.881 --> 01:11:22.007
<v Sierra Ellis>So we, you know, we expect for the organizations to make sure that their employees are, you know, connecting to the people who we refer.

621
01:11:22.730 --> 01:11:26.282
<v Sierra Ellis>In terms of, like, events and gun violence, I think that's something that we're going to continue to work on.

622
01:11:26.362 --> 01:11:26.538
<v Sierra Ellis>Thank you.

623
01:11:31.099 --> 01:11:42.018
<v Sierra Ellis>And so that planning, depending on the event— Cinco de Mayo was one— just based on the information we had from the event organizers from last year, how many guns they turned away.

624
01:11:43.229 --> 01:11:44.884
<v Sierra Ellis>And then, you know, Good in the Hood's coming up.

625
01:11:44.948 --> 01:11:48.033
<v Sierra Ellis>They had significant issues there last year.

626
01:11:48.498 --> 01:11:52.387
<v Sierra Ellis>So we really want to support them this year in getting a comprehensive plan in place.

627
01:11:52.500 --> 01:12:07.793
<v Sierra Ellis>Councilmember Herbold, I think Marvin could answer this a little bit better around, like, how much actual time is spent.

628
01:12:09.385 --> 01:12:18.997
<v Marvin Young>Well, I think a big piece missing here when it comes to the individuals being served and the victims and everything is the word retaliatory.

629
01:12:21.154 --> 01:12:32.529
<v Marvin Young>The reason why is because that sets a strict population, and that is what we're dealing with when it comes to the actual shooters.

630
01:12:33.514 --> 01:12:39.001
<v Marvin Young>When it comes to the victims, I can't give you a flat-out number for that.

631
01:12:39.581 --> 01:12:51.064
<v Marvin Young>But when an individual comes into our program or comes through the Ceasefire model and then is referred to us, the individual is in our program for approximately 18 months.

632
01:12:52.789 --> 01:12:59.488
<v Marvin Young>When they— some individuals, they will take the service right upon being called.

633
01:13:00.381 --> 01:13:04.033
<v Marvin Young>Some of them, you have to do a relentless pursuit.

634
01:13:05.467 --> 01:13:09.555
<v Marvin Young>Once you get them into the program, we have a CVI team.

635
01:13:09.797 --> 01:13:13.804
<v Marvin Young>So our CVI team people will call them an outreach worker.

636
01:13:14.125 --> 01:13:17.881
<v Marvin Young>My program is set up with CVIs and case managers.

637
01:13:18.814 --> 01:13:23.020
<v Marvin Young>So the CVI is the individual who works daily with this individual.

638
01:13:23.759 --> 01:13:36.298
<v Marvin Young>We have 3 to 5 contacts a week when it's— when they're in phase 1, 2 to 3 contacts a week when they're in phase 2, 2 weeks a month— 2 times a month when they're in phase 3.

639
01:13:36.380 --> 01:13:36.475
<v Marvin Young>Thank you.

640
01:13:37.895 --> 01:13:39.945
<v Marvin Young>These individuals come into our program.

641
01:13:39.994 --> 01:13:53.657
<v Marvin Young>Once they graduate from our program, then we have a group that's just— because what we learned down the line was we would complete somebody from our program and they would pop right back in.

642
01:13:53.930 --> 01:14:09.413
<v Marvin Young>Like, they will come back up because they will now be— if they came in as a victim, their name will pop up because their friend It's probably a victim, or they was— they finished the program and got caught up in another situation.

643
01:14:09.783 --> 01:14:11.534
<v Marvin Young>So the time frame can go anywhere.

644
01:14:12.752 --> 01:14:20.034
<v Marvin Young>With our program, it's a minimum of 12 to 16 months, but our program length is 18 months and then aftercare.

645
01:14:21.577 --> 01:14:22.046
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

646
01:14:22.547 --> 01:14:27.792
<v Steve Novick>My last question is, how do you convince somebody not to retaliate?

647
01:14:28.274 --> 01:14:33.621
<v Steve Novick>'Cause I have to say, if somebody I cared about was shot, I'd want to shoot somebody.

648
01:14:34.407 --> 01:14:37.168
<v Steve Novick>And I'm actually not sure what would convince me not to do that.

649
01:14:37.715 --> 01:14:46.722
<v Steve Novick>So how do you, when you've got somebody who somebody they care about has been shot, how do you convince them not to retaliate?

650
01:14:46.850 --> 01:14:47.734
<v Steve Novick>What arguments work?

651
01:14:48.810 --> 01:14:51.010
<v Marvin Young>So this is where the influence piece come in, right?

652
01:14:55.704 --> 01:15:01.847
<v Marvin Young>I got to— This is where the influence piece comes in, because there's a structure to everything.

653
01:15:02.944 --> 01:15:05.377
<v Marvin Young>And so in this line of work, like, this has never happened.

654
01:15:06.792 --> 01:15:07.208
<v Marvin Young>It wouldn't happen.

655
01:15:07.442 --> 01:15:09.355
<v Marvin Young>This opportunity wasn't out here when I was out here.

656
01:15:11.974 --> 01:15:16.027
<v Marvin Young>So my organization deals with 18 to 44.

657
01:15:16.381 --> 01:15:17.747
<v Marvin Young>Some of them be older than 44.

658
01:15:18.953 --> 01:15:21.365
<v Marvin Young>Sometimes you have to do the whole family.

659
01:15:21.430 --> 01:15:22.637
<v Marvin Young>You have to take care of the whole family.

660
01:15:23.137 --> 01:15:31.625
<v Marvin Young>So that's where pieces like Jihad and, and others in the community, you, you have to start putting everybody that's being served into this ecosystem.

661
01:15:32.435 --> 01:15:33.581
<v Marvin Young>And that wasn't being done at first.

662
01:15:33.925 --> 01:15:36.725
<v Marvin Young>It was just focused on this one person, right?

663
01:15:41.411 --> 01:15:56.823
<v Marvin Young>When you use the influence and you come from a structure and these people was involved in a structure that was created by some individuals that were 30 years older than them, and they're now following the structure that the first generation destroyed and never prepared them for.

664
01:15:57.453 --> 01:16:01.649
<v Marvin Young>Sometimes, like, you know, you guys get voted in, it's politics.

665
01:16:02.762 --> 01:16:04.103
<v Marvin Young>It's politics to everything.

666
01:16:05.184 --> 01:16:09.342
<v Marvin Young>And sometimes you just have to tell them the truth about what's going on.

667
01:16:09.456 --> 01:16:12.485
<v Marvin Young>See, like, it can be food to say we can stop everything.

668
01:16:12.582 --> 01:16:14.354
<v Marvin Young>We can't stop everything, and we know that.

669
01:16:15.154 --> 01:16:27.685
<v Marvin Young>But when you're setting the example of, like, for my organization, we have prior adversaries working together.

670
01:16:29.216 --> 01:16:37.551
<v Marvin Young>And so these individuals who you're talking to, they have a very high respect for some of these individuals that's working here.

671
01:16:37.943 --> 01:16:41.087
<v Marvin Young>And so their question is, how are you guys working together?

672
01:16:41.557 --> 01:16:42.043
<v Marvin Young>Councilor Smith.

673
01:16:42.287 --> 01:16:49.640
<v Marvin Young>When they know that in '90 a situation occurred between you guys' family and that carried into 2000.

674
01:16:50.077 --> 01:16:52.497
<v Marvin Young>Now you guys are pushing us not to do it.

675
01:16:53.060 --> 01:17:00.507
<v Marvin Young>A lot of these young men, they don't want to do it, but they think it's a norm.

676
01:17:00.929 --> 01:17:09.118
<v Marvin Young>So like all these abnormal behaviors that's being promoted through social media, through Oh, television, everything.

677
01:17:09.230 --> 01:17:17.310
<v Marvin Young>And then individuals who— and I'm just going to bluntly put it out there— there wasn't nobody back in the '80s and '90s and 2000s.

678
01:17:17.795 --> 01:17:19.542
<v Marvin Young>That's who's gassing these babies.

679
01:17:20.399 --> 01:17:23.131
<v Marvin Young>So now they have outlets where they can call.

680
01:17:23.537 --> 01:17:24.814
<v Marvin Young>These little dudes will call you.

681
01:17:25.234 --> 01:17:27.716
<v Marvin Young>We know a lot that happened before it even get to the police.

682
01:17:29.199 --> 01:17:32.760
<v Marvin Young>So these little babies will call you and tell you what's going on.

683
01:17:33.051 --> 01:17:35.268
<v Marvin Young>So it's not really as hard as you think it is.

684
01:17:35.997 --> 01:17:41.378
<v Marvin Young>Everything seems to be spontaneous, like you will run into that individual.

685
01:17:41.426 --> 01:17:50.448
<v Marvin Young>And when you have 2 scared individuals with a gun and they're behind a keyboard telling what they're going to do to each other, that's when you get into shootings.

686
01:17:52.213 --> 01:17:52.712
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

687
01:17:53.420 --> 01:17:55.509
<v Steve Novick>We could continue this conversation for another hour.

688
01:17:55.588 --> 01:17:58.417
<v Steve Novick>I'm really hugely grateful to everyone who's been here.

689
01:17:59.430 --> 01:18:02.197
<v Steve Novick>We need to move on to the call allocation study discussion.

690
01:18:02.756 --> 01:18:04.451
<v Steve Novick>But thank you so, so much.

691
01:18:09.680 --> 01:18:11.520
<v Steve Novick>And could the clerk read the next item?

692
01:18:13.159 --> 01:18:21.666
<v Rachael Fetters>Item number 2, document number 2026-14— sorry, 185, Public Safety Call Allocation Study Discussion.

693
01:18:25.082 --> 01:18:25.648
<v Steve Novick>Come on down.

694
01:18:53.547 --> 01:18:54.623
<v Nick McDonald>My name is Nick McDonald.

695
01:18:54.703 --> 01:18:59.832
<v Nick McDonald>I'm a performance analyst I'm going to let my colleagues introduce themselves.

696
01:19:00.820 --> 01:19:04.112
<v Stephanie Howard>Alicia Russell, Lieutenant with Portland Police Bureau, and I currently work in the Chief's Office.

697
01:19:05.180 --> 01:19:07.990
<v April Roa>April Roa, Interim Program Manager with Portland Street Response.

698
01:19:08.827 --> 01:19:11.332
<v Todd Deweese>Todd Deweese, Interim Operations Manager with BOEC.

699
01:19:13.100 --> 01:19:14.402
<v Nick McDonald>So thanks for your time this morning.

700
01:19:14.449 --> 01:19:21.149
<v Nick McDonald>We're here to talk about the recommendations from Novicko 2 from last year about reassignment of welfare checks.

701
01:19:21.908 --> 01:19:32.604
<v Nick McDonald>This is the Call Allocation Working Group, has been working on looking at the calls that are allocated to Police Bureau as welfare checks.

702
01:19:34.310 --> 01:19:40.385
<v Nick McDonald>This working group includes BOEC, Portland Street Response, the Public Safety Service Area, and the Police Bureau.

703
01:19:42.210 --> 01:19:42.997
<v Nick McDonald>So yes, next slide please.

704
01:19:44.998 --> 01:19:45.277
<v Nick McDonald>Sorry, yeah.

705
01:19:45.900 --> 01:19:59.521
<v Nick McDonald>So in November last year, BOEC and PPB the Police Bureau undertook a study of the welfare checks during a 2-month period, and this was a total of about 3,000 calls that went to the Police Bureau.

706
01:20:00.600 --> 01:20:09.018
<v Nick McDonald>BOEC and the Police Bureau did a very thorough review of the reasons these were dispatched, the nature of the calls, and I'm going to pass over to Captain Russell to talk about the findings.

707
01:20:10.239 --> 01:20:10.338
<v Sierra Ellis>Okay.

708
01:20:10.833 --> 01:20:11.064
<v Loretta Smith>All right.

709
01:20:11.922 --> 01:20:12.880
<v Stephanie Howard>Next slide, please.

710
01:20:15.310 --> 01:20:18.713
<v Stephanie Howard>Okay, sorry, I wasn't planning on addressing these ones.

711
01:20:18.762 --> 01:20:19.341
<v Stephanie Howard>Oh, I beg your pardon.

712
01:20:19.404 --> 01:20:21.315
<v Stephanie Howard>I can go with this if you keep going.

713
01:20:21.427 --> 01:20:22.407
<v Stephanie Howard>Yeah, sure, absolutely.

714
01:20:22.471 --> 01:20:23.418
<v Stephanie Howard>I'm a few slides ahead.

715
01:20:23.515 --> 01:20:23.885
<v Nick McDonald>Beg your pardon.

716
01:20:24.863 --> 01:20:33.599
<v Nick McDonald>So when we look at the total welfare check calls in the study, we grouped them into 5 areas.

717
01:20:33.872 --> 01:20:48.644
<v Nick McDonald>So we've got calls that the nexus was aggression or violence, things that took place in a private building, things that involve traffic or a vehicle, calls where Portland Street Response was unavailable, and calls where weapons were called out.

718
01:20:48.724 --> 01:20:53.717
<v Nick McDonald>So these are the reasons that these calls went to the Police Bureau in the first place, right?

719
01:20:53.782 --> 01:21:02.837
<v Nick McDonald>So currently Portland Street Response does not deal with calls that have weapons or aggressive or violent people as a subject.

720
01:21:03.238 --> 01:21:08.692
<v Nick McDonald>They don't respond in private buildings they don't involve— they don't respond involving traffic.

721
01:21:10.770 --> 01:21:11.538
<v Nick McDonald>If we get the next slide.

722
01:21:14.554 --> 01:21:26.597
<v Nick McDonald>So of these, the ones that we thought had the highest likelihood of being able to be rerouted are these calls involving traffic hazards and calls involving non-publicly accessible spaces.

723
01:21:27.440 --> 01:21:30.600
<v Nick McDonald>So we broke out these traffic calls into calls involving yes.

724
01:21:30.713 --> 01:21:37.520
<v Nick McDonald>Calls involving bicycles, wheelchairs, or people in traffic, vehicles in the roadway, and vehicles not in the roadway.

725
01:21:39.220 --> 01:21:44.926
<v Nick McDonald>And we determined that Portland Street Response could potentially respond to about 85% of these calls.

726
01:21:45.988 --> 01:21:50.494
<v Nick McDonald>And then the other big bucket that we looked at was calls involving non-publicly accessible spaces.

727
01:21:51.271 --> 01:21:58.462
<v Nick McDonald>So these are calls involving a potential crime, civil custodial issues, calls involving children.

728
01:22:00.189 --> 01:22:01.590
<v Nick McDonald>These we recommend stay with PPB.

729
01:22:02.974 --> 01:22:13.393
<v Nick McDonald>The ones that we recommend moving are medical checks, possible medical issues, unable to reach, possible or suspected mental health or drug crisis, and person needs to be checked on.

730
01:22:13.618 --> 01:22:24.573
<v Nick McDonald>So we think PSR could field about 69% of these, and of the total 3,000 calls, we We think PSR could have responded on about 60% of them.

731
01:22:26.439 --> 01:22:27.293
<v Nick McDonald>So if we could get the next slide.

732
01:22:29.618 --> 01:22:43.610
<v Nick McDonald>So the core recommendations of the study, where there's no evidence to suggest a concern about the safety of the public, the responders, or a criminal nexus, alternative responders can and should be the primary response.

733
01:22:45.037 --> 01:22:58.572
<v Nick McDonald>We think PPB should remain the primary responder for welfare check calls involving running vehicles, vehicles in a traffic lane or otherwise creating a hazard, as well as anything where there's a criminal or safety nexus.

734
01:23:01.210 --> 01:23:07.935
<v Nick McDonald>We think alternative responders can be the primary response for calls involving pedestrians, wheelchairs, and bicycles, even if they're interacting with traffic.

735
01:23:09.782 --> 01:23:21.760
<v Nick McDonald>And then regarding private buildings, calls So if we get the next slide.

736
01:23:22.880 --> 01:23:23.880
<v Nick McDonald>Okay, great.

737
01:23:23.880 --> 01:23:24.659
<v Nick McDonald>Catherine Russell.

738
01:23:24.659 --> 01:23:33.960
<v Stephanie Howard>Okay, so you can see here the average of welfare checks over the last 3 years have been very consistent, averaging just over 23,000 calls per year.

739
01:23:34.239 --> 01:23:35.319
<v Stephanie Howard>Next slide, please.

740
01:23:36.239 --> 01:23:56.773
<v Stephanie Howard>So what we did is we took that 45-day pilot project data, we looked at it at a 3-year average, and that's what the numbers that you're looking So those 42A calls, like Nick said, it's like those calls that have some component of aggressive or violent nature that we're looking at possibly 4,500 calls, and those would stay with police.

741
01:23:57.560 --> 01:24:05.731
<v Stephanie Howard>Those 42T calls, that person that might be, you know, an example is that person that maybe has stepped off the sidewalk at one moment, is back on the sidewalk, maybe back and forth.

742
01:24:05.779 --> 01:24:09.585
<v Stephanie Howard>That is a call we realize that could probably go to an alternate responder.

743
01:24:09.634 --> 01:24:10.628
<v Stephanie Howard>I'm sorry, Deputy City Attorney.

744
01:24:11.207 --> 01:24:12.373
<v Stephanie Howard>Or, you know, in a vehicle.

745
01:24:12.439 --> 01:24:15.289
<v Stephanie Howard>So those are about 6,800 calls, as you see there.

746
01:24:16.002 --> 01:24:21.261
<v Stephanie Howard>Those private buildings, that was the biggest number, 9,400.

747
01:24:21.375 --> 01:24:24.063
<v Stephanie Howard>And those 42U calls, those are the ones when PSR wasn't available.

748
01:24:24.354 --> 01:24:27.819
<v Stephanie Howard>Maybe it was after hours or it was they were busy on other calls.

749
01:24:28.622 --> 01:24:31.899
<v Stephanie Howard>And then obviously those 42W calls, those are ones that would stay with police.

750
01:24:32.703 --> 01:24:36.833
<v Stephanie Howard>And then those ones that say no data, those are, that came out of the study.

751
01:24:36.898 --> 01:24:38.289
<v Stephanie Howard>They were coded incorrectly.

752
01:24:38.420 --> 01:24:40.654
<v Stephanie Howard>That's since been changed, but we hadn't updated the slide here.

753
01:24:44.435 --> 01:24:44.807
<v Stephanie Howard>Next slide.

754
01:24:46.945 --> 01:24:54.088
<v Stephanie Howard>So again, those calls that involve vehicles or traffic, those vehicles in a roadway, obviously there could be some impairment.

755
01:24:54.479 --> 01:24:57.368
<v Stephanie Howard>Maybe somebody is stopped at the green light, not moving.

756
01:24:57.483 --> 01:25:00.015
<v Stephanie Howard>Those would clearly be calls that would still stay with police.

757
01:25:01.029 --> 01:25:09.297
<v Stephanie Howard>And again, you know, those person, bicycle, or wheelchair possibly in traffic, maybe on the sidewalk or on the side of the road, those are calls that could possibly go to an alternate responder.

758
01:25:10.136 --> 01:25:19.765
<v Stephanie Howard>And then those vehicles not on roadway, that parked car, maybe somebody's living out of it possibly, or it couldn't run, those calls would go to PSR or an alternate responder.

759
01:25:20.507 --> 01:25:20.814
<v Stephanie Howard>Next slide.

760
01:25:22.734 --> 01:25:26.109
<v Stephanie Howard>And again, this was the biggest bucket, as you saw earlier, those 42B calls.

761
01:25:27.032 --> 01:25:34.034
<v Stephanie Howard>We probably could have 20 categories here that just covers a ton of different calls as well for checks in a private residence or a building.

762
01:25:34.326 --> 01:25:38.061
<v Stephanie Howard>And those all other calls at 2900, Calls.

763
01:25:38.576 --> 01:25:40.949
<v Stephanie Howard>That could be, you know, obviously something involving a weapon.

764
01:25:40.997 --> 01:25:45.506
<v Stephanie Howard>It could be, um, uh, you know, a custody issue or somebody under 18 years old.

765
01:25:45.555 --> 01:25:48.394
<v Stephanie Howard>Those are calls that would not go to an alternate responder.

766
01:25:48.762 --> 01:25:52.903
<v Stephanie Howard>And then I know Nick already touched on a lot of these— medical check, unable to reach.

767
01:25:53.175 --> 01:26:00.988
<v Stephanie Howard>That could be that person that didn't show up to work, appointment, did not answering their phone, and somebody would like them to be checked on.

768
01:26:01.100 --> 01:26:14.368
<v April Roa>And obviously somebody also in a mental health this is a little more of a breakdown on what those calls look like.

769
01:26:14.432 --> 01:26:26.720
<v April Roa>And I just— what we were looking at for PSR on taking on approximately 14,000 calls is making sure that the calls that we're talking about are currently within mobile crisis and using that as the lens.

770
01:26:26.898 --> 01:26:28.386
<v April Roa>So if you notice, we have a breakdown of mobile crisis.

771
01:26:28.762 --> 01:26:34.386
<v April Roa>Notice it's— we're not changing what we're responding to, it's more the where we would be responding to.

772
01:26:35.103 --> 01:26:39.261
<v April Roa>And then breaking it up in a way that is very clear.

773
01:26:40.703 --> 01:26:43.576
<v April Roa>Like we talked about the welfare check bucket, it's a huge bucket.

774
01:26:43.706 --> 01:27:12.583
<v April Roa>We could have had so many more categories and trying to break these down in a way that makes sense and leads us or gains the opportunity that we can do a staged addition, if that's the route that we go, in order to handle staffing up, training, and making sure that PSR is prepared to handle these calls in a safe way for our responders.

775
01:27:16.136 --> 01:27:19.814
<v April Roa>Here is, again, specific recommendations.

776
01:27:19.863 --> 01:27:27.944
<v April Roa>And again, this allows us to staff up, to train, and to provide additional safety training for our folks.

777
01:27:28.313 --> 01:27:31.155
<v April Roa>Vehicles not in a roadway, that seems like a very simple one.

778
01:27:31.220 --> 01:27:41.659
<v April Roa>That's why we kind of put that on the year 1 as if we were looking at these consecutively, how would we staff up to be able to gain that total 14,000 estimate?

779
01:27:42.608 --> 01:27:45.738
<v April Roa>And so that is exactly what this is set out to do.

780
01:27:46.478 --> 01:27:58.012
<v April Roa>This recommendation year by year does not account for increases in PSR's call volume outside of this call reallocation, as well as 24/7.

781
01:27:58.141 --> 01:28:01.684
<v April Roa>So that would— this is just for call reallocation.

782
01:28:01.780 --> 01:28:06.438
<v April Roa>So if we are looking at some of those other things, it would need to be a blended staged model for those.

783
01:28:10.476 --> 01:28:15.983
<v Stephanie Howard>Yeah, so our recommendations, as you all know, our call response times need to improve.

784
01:28:16.032 --> 01:28:25.953
<v Stephanie Howard>So if we could lower those, shift some of those calls to alternate responders, Ultimately, that would lower our call response time to those more urgent incidents.

785
01:28:26.594 --> 01:28:37.063
<v Stephanie Howard>And we put on here, obviously, we could devote more resources to investigating those property crimes, which we're well above the national average, unfortunately.

786
01:28:37.800 --> 01:28:39.435
<v Stephanie Howard>We could devote more resources to that.

787
01:28:39.498 --> 01:28:50.841
<v Stephanie Howard>So through this reallocation, potentially saving hundreds of thousands of officer hours over time, You know, to improve those persistent property crime and lower those numbers.

788
01:28:52.060 --> 01:29:00.797
<v Stephanie Howard>So strategically redeploying our resources and pursuing both together will strengthen the overall impact of this effort.

789
01:29:01.921 --> 01:29:10.555
<v Stephanie Howard>And as PSR expands, you know, it doesn't reduce the demand on PPB, it just redirects it where sworn officers are needed the most.

790
01:29:13.356 --> 01:29:13.614
<v Steve Novick>Right.

791
01:29:13.679 --> 01:29:13.887
<v Nick McDonald>Thanks.

792
01:29:14.081 --> 01:29:16.929
<v Nick McDonald>I just want to say thank you to everyone who was involved in putting this together.

793
01:29:17.217 --> 01:29:24.993
<v Nick McDonald>Like, the sense of real commitment to looking at the 911 system as an integrated resource just is really impressive to me.

794
01:29:25.056 --> 01:29:25.672
<v Eric Zimmerman>And thank you.

795
01:29:26.855 --> 01:29:27.050
<v Sierra Ellis>Sorry.

796
01:29:27.811 --> 01:29:28.297
<v Nick McDonald>Thanks very much.

797
01:29:32.529 --> 01:29:33.063
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

798
01:29:33.759 --> 01:29:34.195
<v Steve Novick>Let's see.

799
01:29:34.939 --> 01:29:35.926
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal.

800
01:29:38.161 --> 01:29:39.478
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thank you so much for all this.

801
01:29:39.686 --> 01:29:46.224
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate— I was going to ask this question that you just put up the slide on, so that saves us all a lot of time on who was on the work group.

802
01:29:46.288 --> 01:29:47.188
<v Nick McDonald>Oh, sorry, you wanted to see that?

803
01:29:47.317 --> 01:29:48.457
<v Sameer Kanal>No, no, no, it's good that it's in there.

804
01:29:48.520 --> 01:29:54.480
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I appreciate the— in there, you can, you can put it on the other, um, slide that you were going to.

805
01:29:55.186 --> 01:30:00.809
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, I wanted to add first, thank you, Councilor Novick, once again for the note that sort of started part of this process up.

806
01:30:00.905 --> 01:30:07.559
<v Sameer Kanal>And, and I know that there was a long there remains an ongoing call allocation workgroup and study for many, many years now.

807
01:30:09.054 --> 01:30:10.951
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to ask a couple questions.

808
01:30:12.349 --> 01:30:20.188
<v Sameer Kanal>One related to the— if you go back one slide, there's the years layout, or actually it's one more than this.

809
01:30:21.108 --> 01:30:22.091
<v Sameer Kanal>Love that slide, by the way.

810
01:30:22.399 --> 01:30:27.564
<v Sameer Kanal>The PPB one felt like we've had this conversation for a long time, and I really appreciate it.

811
01:30:27.984 --> 01:30:33.427
<v Sameer Kanal>This one, where is the private building component?

812
01:30:35.462 --> 01:30:51.412
<v April Roa>So those are the 42B calls, so year 4, and that's going to take the most amount of training for our folks to really make sure that they understand what safety concerns and how to respond inside a confined space.

813
01:30:52.413 --> 01:31:00.386
<v April Roa>And I think labor is also going to be a big component in being prepared to take those calls on, or the labor negotiations.

814
01:31:03.337 --> 01:31:03.676
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

815
01:31:04.145 --> 01:31:07.823
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, let me just big picture, loved everything in this except the number 4.

816
01:31:09.889 --> 01:31:12.729
<v Sameer Kanal>That we've— we're how many years into this pilot now?

817
01:31:12.954 --> 01:31:14.828
<v Sameer Kanal>And I would love to get this done a lot faster than that.

818
01:31:14.877 --> 01:31:19.448
<v Sameer Kanal>So I will be probably following up asking, you know, how do we do this in a shorter period of time?

819
01:31:19.497 --> 01:31:22.023
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't want to take up the time here with that.

820
01:31:22.819 --> 01:31:24.952
<v Sameer Kanal>But that's the only real concern I had with this.

821
01:31:25.016 --> 01:31:26.872
<v Sameer Kanal>And then my questions are largely clarification.

822
01:31:26.921 --> 01:31:27.018
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

823
01:31:27.216 --> 01:31:39.158
<v Sameer Kanal>Other than that, since you mentioned labor, is this going to be— are you expecting both the components of bargaining?

824
01:31:39.851 --> 01:31:45.426
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, are we expecting concerns on the side of where the calls are coming from or where they're going to or both?

825
01:31:46.024 --> 01:31:46.136
<v Sameer Kanal>Both.

826
01:31:46.380 --> 01:31:48.853
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that's good to know.

827
01:31:49.498 --> 01:32:01.900
<v Sameer Kanal>Have you been in communication or has anyone on this workgroup been in communication with BHR as it relates to the currently ongoing bargaining processes because some of the relevant unions are in conversation here?

828
01:32:03.000 --> 01:32:12.225
<v April Roa>I'm into bargaining with Pro-Tech and with PFFA for the community health medical responder currently.

829
01:32:12.980 --> 01:32:18.594
<v April Roa>This is not on the table right now as far as what we're working on.

830
01:32:20.337 --> 01:32:22.707
<v April Roa>So these recommendations were coming here first.

831
01:32:23.800 --> 01:32:23.994
<v Todd Deweese>Great.

832
01:32:24.238 --> 01:32:29.274
<v Sameer Kanal>We have 9 days to put something new on the agenda of one of these particular contracts.

833
01:32:30.250 --> 01:32:34.057
<v Sameer Kanal>So let's please make sure that it gets on that list with BHR.

834
01:32:34.685 --> 01:32:35.841
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, I did ask about it.

835
01:32:36.051 --> 01:32:37.753
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it may already be on the list.

836
01:32:37.899 --> 01:32:39.731
<v Sameer Kanal>It's just a question of which articles are open.

837
01:32:40.572 --> 01:32:44.686
<v Sameer Kanal>But I'll leave it there to not go beyond what I'm allowed to talk about.

838
01:32:45.332 --> 01:32:47.157
<v Sameer Kanal>But the deadline is in 9 days on that one.

839
01:32:47.835 --> 01:32:49.226
<v Sameer Kanal>The other question, if you, um—.

840
01:32:49.226 --> 01:32:49.551
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm sorry.

841
01:32:51.036 --> 01:32:52.295
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's 2 slides forward.

842
01:32:55.153 --> 01:33:09.416
<v Sameer Kanal>With relation to the weapon reported, I understand it's a very small number relative to the 30,000 calls that we're talking about here, but they often lead to the highest profile outcomes.

843
01:33:10.166 --> 01:33:19.770
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I wanted to ask, have those— with the vehicle calls, you disaggregated them further into the type the subtype.

844
01:33:20.171 --> 01:33:30.167
<v Sameer Kanal>Has there been work done on the disaggregation of the weapon calls so that we can start talking about the difference between a knife, a stick, a gun, and the different types of reports there?

845
01:33:32.841 --> 01:33:34.979
<v April Roa>I don't think we broke it out in this study.

846
01:33:35.091 --> 01:33:35.895
<v April Roa>Not in this study, no.

847
01:33:36.296 --> 01:33:47.207
<v April Roa>But, you know, I will say that we know that folks in the community that we serve tend to have ways to defend themselves.

848
01:33:48.300 --> 01:33:50.546
<v April Roa>So that's not unusual.

849
01:33:51.237 --> 01:33:56.757
<v April Roa>If there is something out in active play and brandished, that's definitely where we're going.

850
01:33:57.015 --> 01:33:58.122
<v April Roa>These are PPB calls.

851
01:33:58.957 --> 01:34:09.533
<v April Roa>If somebody just mentions, I know they have a stick and it's laying outside their tent or nearby, that doesn't necessarily preclude them from PSR from going currently.

852
01:34:09.710 --> 01:34:09.886
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

853
01:34:10.966 --> 01:34:18.703
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I think there's a little bit of reliance on then who the dispatcher kind of making the determination.

854
01:34:18.801 --> 01:34:20.481
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it might be helpful for clarity.

855
01:34:21.094 --> 01:34:27.023
<v Sameer Kanal>There was a call last June in my neighborhood involving someone who was allegedly hanging a knife out a window.

856
01:34:29.704 --> 01:34:31.996
<v Sameer Kanal>The access point was not through a window, right?

857
01:34:32.305 --> 01:34:36.689
<v Sameer Kanal>Access point was through the door of the apartment, and it ended up with somebody dead.

858
01:34:37.266 --> 01:34:43.662
<v Sameer Kanal>At the end of that, that's a situation where obviously it would be— it's a moot point if we're not talking about getting into private buildings.

859
01:34:44.175 --> 01:34:52.686
<v Sameer Kanal>But now that we are starting to have that conversation, and thank you for doing it, I do also want to have the conversation about trying to get a little bit more information there.

860
01:34:52.751 --> 01:34:56.404
<v Sameer Kanal>And I understand 187 calls is a very small number relative to the size.

861
01:34:56.757 --> 01:35:01.293
<v Sameer Kanal>But again, I do think when there's something that goes wrong in these situations, it tends to be higher profile.

862
01:35:01.806 --> 01:35:08.219
<v Sameer Kanal>And so just wanted to ask if we can get that number broken down a little bit further for the future.

863
01:35:08.300 --> 01:35:13.479
<v Sameer Kanal>It doesn't have to be right now, in terms of understanding how many of those are knives, sticks, guns, whatever.

864
01:35:14.061 --> 01:35:23.042
<v Sameer Kanal>As well as I appreciate the distinction between possession existing and brandishing in the moment of the 911 call being made.

865
01:35:23.802 --> 01:35:24.144
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

866
01:35:24.841 --> 01:35:27.823
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

867
01:35:28.422 --> 01:35:28.844
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

868
01:35:30.021 --> 01:35:46.546
<v Loretta Smith>Based on the sample staff estimate that of roughly 23,000 welfare checks per year, about 14,000 could transition to PSR while about 8,600 should remain with PPB.

869
01:35:47.500 --> 01:35:51.774
<v Loretta Smith>With a full transition, it is estimated that it might take about 4 years.

870
01:35:53.623 --> 01:36:06.984
<v Loretta Smith>Um, can you give me the Is there a clear criterion in which BOEC will use to decide whether a welfare check goes to PSR, PPB, or to another first responder?

871
01:36:09.409 --> 01:36:15.894
<v Todd Deweese>Well, right now, PSR— we have our set criteria for PSR, which we get from PSR.

872
01:36:16.506 --> 01:36:21.475
<v Todd Deweese>And right now, it is— a lot of it is person down, not checked.

873
01:36:22.746 --> 01:36:27.398
<v Todd Deweese>People who are experiencing some mental health crisis, people that need resources.

874
01:36:29.753 --> 01:36:31.757
<v Todd Deweese>If PSR is available, we try and send them.

875
01:36:32.588 --> 01:36:34.398
<v Todd Deweese>If they're not available, we send the police out.

876
01:36:37.345 --> 01:36:51.408
<v Loretta Smith>So in terms of the staffing, training, labor bargaining, and infrastructure changes that are needed before PSR can absorb the 14,000 additional calls per year.

877
01:36:52.895 --> 01:37:00.186
<v Loretta Smith>What is your sense about that, about them being able to meet the moment on these additional calls?

878
01:37:02.859 --> 01:37:05.764
<v April Roa>I'm not sure I totally understand the question.

879
01:37:06.457 --> 01:37:13.351
<v April Roa>So when looking at the 14,000 number, our total call volume in 2025 was 15,000.

880
01:37:13.822 --> 01:37:13.997
<v April Roa>Okay.

881
01:37:14.335 --> 01:37:16.658
<v April Roa>So that's doubling what we have now.

882
01:37:17.332 --> 01:37:21.016
<v April Roa>So that is a lot of staff to train.

883
01:37:21.337 --> 01:37:29.078
<v April Roa>And I think this year was highly aggressive in our training and our hiring, and we promoted and hired 22 individuals this fiscal year.

884
01:37:29.591 --> 01:37:33.020
<v April Roa>And it, it really was a challenge for our folks.

885
01:37:33.436 --> 01:37:46.931
<v April Roa>So hiring that many and getting them ready for solo status, then trying to hire our or train our existing staff on new safety techniques and new areas that they're responding to.

886
01:37:47.252 --> 01:37:49.978
<v April Roa>It's a large endeavor.

887
01:37:50.538 --> 01:37:51.902
<v April Roa>So it is just gonna take us some time.

888
01:37:51.949 --> 01:37:56.838
<v Loretta Smith>What's new techniques that you'll need to train staff for those additional 14,000?

889
01:37:57.256 --> 01:38:09.213
<v April Roa>So such as vehicles and roadway, how to safely approach a vehicle, what things to look for for safety, and how to begin that engagement is very important.

890
01:38:09.342 --> 01:38:17.597
<v April Roa>Is this something that we would need what can we legally do and how would we do that safely?

891
01:38:18.273 --> 01:38:21.921
<v April Roa>Same with like responding to a building, you know, training our folks.

892
01:38:22.435 --> 01:38:23.849
<v April Roa>What are the safety concerns?

893
01:38:23.896 --> 01:38:25.037
<v April Roa>How should they approach a door?

894
01:38:25.101 --> 01:38:25.985
<v April Roa>How should they knock?

895
01:38:26.613 --> 01:38:29.055
<v April Roa>How far into a building should they go?

896
01:38:29.907 --> 01:38:31.721
<v April Roa>And what should they be scanning a room for?

897
01:38:32.171 --> 01:38:33.072
<v April Roa>Those types of things.

898
01:38:33.233 --> 01:38:36.574
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I was looking for in my question, to see what exactly that would look like.

899
01:38:36.735 --> 01:38:42.997
<v Loretta Smith>This is exactly what I wanted to find out, what new changes or things that we needed to do to be able to meet that moment.

900
01:38:43.560 --> 01:38:47.060
<v Loretta Smith>And I want to talk with the police.

901
01:38:47.975 --> 01:38:57.432
<v Loretta Smith>How will what she just said about the training and different techniques, how will this affect PPB response time for higher priority calls?

902
01:38:58.653 --> 01:39:10.222
<v Stephanie Howard>Will that have some impact in terms of how quickly you get to yeah, I mean, like April said, this isn't, you know, this is a graded response.

903
01:39:10.271 --> 01:39:11.484
<v Stephanie Howard>This isn't gonna happen overnight.

904
01:39:11.962 --> 01:39:12.106
<v Stephanie Howard>Right.

905
01:39:12.380 --> 01:39:14.119
<v Stephanie Howard>As far as allowing us that time.

906
01:39:14.442 --> 01:39:28.748
<v Stephanie Howard>But yes, I mean, if you can see if they take for, you know, are able, you know, to take an extra 14,000 calls a year, I mean, that's a significant number that would allow us time for, you know, like I said, those other investigations or respond to those other, those more urgent calls.

907
01:39:31.502 --> 01:39:45.222
<v Loretta Smith>And right now, are we tracking any of those outcomes about how quickly we get to a call and how PSR, how they're offsetting?

908
01:39:46.323 --> 01:39:48.408
<v Stephanie Howard>Not in this workgroup, no.

909
01:39:48.472 --> 01:39:50.487
<v Stephanie Howard>We didn't get down to those details, no.

910
01:39:50.841 --> 01:39:52.145
<v Stephanie Howard>I mean, I know those numbers are being tracked.

911
01:39:52.194 --> 01:40:03.494
<v Stephanie Howard>Unfortunately, Christian, who is our data guru, isn't here today to answer some of those, but I know that is because I think that's what it's going to come down to.

912
01:40:03.641 --> 01:40:05.583
<v Loretta Smith>It's going to come down to we're going to look at the data.

913
01:40:06.239 --> 01:40:09.251
<v Loretta Smith>What does, what does the data show that we can actually do?

914
01:40:09.395 --> 01:40:17.215
<v Loretta Smith>Because that is what will make sense in any of these new policy changes that, that we may go forward with.

915
01:40:17.408 --> 01:40:25.412
<v Stephanie Howard>And I'll just add, I mean, when— if they, they increase their call load by this much, there will be a dedicated dispatcher, PSR dispatcher.

916
01:40:25.493 --> 01:40:26.516
<v Stephanie Howard>So that will change the workload of the PSR dispatchers.

917
01:40:27.057 --> 01:40:33.804
<v Stephanie Howard>I don't know how far out we are on that, but I know that is part of this training that we're talking about.

918
01:40:34.189 --> 01:40:58.114
<v Loretta Smith>And I am looking forward— yesterday was the deadline for a report that I asked DCA Causie for in terms of how much would it take in resources, time, training to put another 400 officers in Portland Police Bureau and what that would look like realistically, because I heard you loud and clear.

919
01:40:58.795 --> 01:41:01.487
<v Loretta Smith>I want to have some realistic timelines too.

920
01:41:01.568 --> 01:41:08.204
<v Loretta Smith>And so they're not finished with the report yet, but that's going to come out in a couple weeks.

921
01:41:08.981 --> 01:41:16.021
<v Loretta Smith>But I would strongly encourage you to look at that because this may help to inform what you all have, have done as well.

922
01:41:17.423 --> 01:41:17.520
<v Stephen Maris>Thank you.

923
01:41:20.260 --> 01:41:21.224
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman.

924
01:41:22.140 --> 01:41:22.510
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

925
01:41:22.703 --> 01:41:32.434
<v Eric Zimmerman>As we discuss the private building, I have a question about private building public access or private building private access, meaning an apartment is a private building, so to speak.

926
01:41:33.081 --> 01:41:36.573
<v Eric Zimmerman>Starbucks is a private building, so to speak, but it's public access.

927
01:41:36.654 --> 01:41:40.493
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are we, are we squaring that out, or is it all private building?

928
01:41:41.009 --> 01:41:41.636
<v Nick McDonald>April, do you want to take this?

929
01:41:41.829 --> 01:41:48.569
<v April Roa>Yeah, the, the— we currently respond to publicly so Starbucks during business hours, we respond to.

930
01:41:49.069 --> 01:41:52.019
<v April Roa>For this study, we're talking about private residences.

931
01:41:52.569 --> 01:41:53.516
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you.

932
01:41:53.646 --> 01:41:54.595
<v Eric Zimmerman>That really helps.

933
01:41:54.644 --> 01:41:55.738
<v Eric Zimmerman>I wasn't quite sure.

934
01:41:56.375 --> 01:41:57.600
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know that's been an evolution.

935
01:41:57.649 --> 01:42:04.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>So we are, PSR will now go into a publicly accessible private building currently?

936
01:42:06.167 --> 01:42:08.203
<v April Roa>If the recommendation is implemented, yes.

937
01:42:09.784 --> 01:42:10.703
<v April Roa>A private residence.

938
01:42:10.769 --> 01:42:11.171
<v April Roa>Oh, I'm sorry.

939
01:42:11.332 --> 01:42:11.784
<v Eric Zimmerman>No, no, sorry.

940
01:42:11.930 --> 01:42:13.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>Fred Meyer, a store, a convenience store will go into a building.

941
01:42:13.639 --> 01:42:14.768
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes, we do currently do private buildings.

942
01:42:15.445 --> 01:42:16.844
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not just an outside thing anymore.

943
01:42:16.908 --> 01:42:17.100
<v April Roa>Correct.

944
01:42:17.293 --> 01:42:17.485
<v Steve Novick>Got it.

945
01:42:17.614 --> 01:42:17.743
<v Angelita Morillo>Great.

946
01:42:18.578 --> 01:42:20.298
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, okay, thank you.

947
01:42:22.355 --> 01:42:33.314
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I think I would encourage folks to just— there's so much nuance when it comes to the proper approach and safety when we're talking about a vehicle, right?

948
01:42:34.280 --> 01:42:40.610
<v Eric Zimmerman>A Honda Civic with not blacked-out windows, something you can see into, versus an RV, right?

949
01:42:40.676 --> 01:42:42.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those approaches are so different.

950
01:42:42.069 --> 01:42:48.061
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I do want to you know, verbalize, I think, permission to take time in the training approach.

951
01:42:48.865 --> 01:42:55.378
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that what you've laid out here makes sense, and not all vehicles are a safe approach for anybody.

952
01:42:55.770 --> 01:43:01.331
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in that case, we have a dedicated group of sworn officers for the most critical nature situations.

953
01:43:01.444 --> 01:43:05.962
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I do think that there's a spectrum here that's important to acknowledge.

954
01:43:07.063 --> 01:43:19.476
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I am— I both see the value in the private home access, and it gives me a great deal of anxiety.

955
01:43:21.270 --> 01:43:27.541
<v Eric Zimmerman>A friend of mine is a person who responded to a call at a domestic home, and he never went home that night, right?

956
01:43:27.590 --> 01:43:28.819
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think about that.

957
01:43:30.345 --> 01:43:37.596
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, you know, oftentimes we talk about like co-response isn't a thing we want to promote.

958
01:43:37.854 --> 01:43:43.123
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I see where co-response could make a lot of sense of assess if it's a safe situation.

959
01:43:43.670 --> 01:43:46.779
<v Eric Zimmerman>If it is, then maybe one service backs off.

960
01:43:47.118 --> 01:43:49.381
<v Eric Zimmerman>If it's not, then a different service backs off.

961
01:43:50.739 --> 01:43:52.502
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I see that being a positive approach.

962
01:43:52.680 --> 01:43:58.563
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the idea of a lot of these calls— and here's my other pieces.

963
01:43:58.837 --> 01:43:59.257
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

964
01:44:02.185 --> 01:44:04.030
<v Eric Zimmerman>A call for a welfare check.

965
01:44:05.100 --> 01:44:28.873
<v Eric Zimmerman>I guess maybe I need to understand better what the procedures for a person who goes to a welfare check might be, because when it comes to can you enter a premises, what is cause, who can do that, who can't, if your neighbors or your family have called because you haven't shown up to work for a few days, What does that look like?

966
01:44:29.082 --> 01:44:35.231
<v Eric Zimmerman>And are we just kicking the can a little bit if we send a group who can't respond, who can't do anything if nobody comes to the door?

967
01:44:36.082 --> 01:44:37.479
<v Eric Zimmerman>Which I think is the PSR version.

968
01:44:37.768 --> 01:44:39.085
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can't do anything if nobody comes to the door.

969
01:44:39.613 --> 01:44:39.918
<v Sarah Honeycutt>Right.

970
01:44:40.015 --> 01:44:45.329
<v April Roa>And, and I'm glad you brought that up because that's something we spent a lot of time discussing in this group.

971
01:44:45.939 --> 01:44:51.622
<v April Roa>And I mean, it, it was really, what is the outcome that we're looking to, to have on these calls?

972
01:44:52.201 --> 01:45:02.029
<v April Roa>And so we kind of went down that rabbit hole of if it's somebody who didn't show up for work today, I'm worried because they were sick yesterday, can we, you know, knock on the door?

973
01:45:02.238 --> 01:45:05.780
<v April Roa>Sure, we can knock on the door, but is that the outcome that we want?

974
01:45:05.988 --> 01:45:15.270
<v April Roa>And, you know, if it's more like I really am worried and I want somebody walking around the house to check and make sure they're not down somewhere, then that becomes a PPB call.

975
01:45:15.319 --> 01:45:24.253
<v April Roa>So there is a lot of nuances, um, in call in how these calls are handled, and we have to keep that in mind with any of these.

976
01:45:24.992 --> 01:45:32.568
<v April Roa>There's always going to be some of these nuances where we are going to have to bring in our partners when it isn't— when our responders don't feel like it's safe.

977
01:45:32.695 --> 01:45:37.221
<v April Roa>Because again, it's a vehicle, like, I can't see into it, I can't do my safety checks.

978
01:45:37.608 --> 01:45:39.725
<v April Roa>Now I need to bring in that higher level of care.

979
01:45:39.838 --> 01:45:43.962
<v April Roa>And same again with going inside a private building, even when we're invited.

980
01:45:44.028 --> 01:45:45.963
<v April Roa>Like, I don't want my folks certainly.

981
01:45:46.011 --> 01:45:58.014
<v April Roa>Going down into the back bedroom with somebody, I want them where they have an exit at their back and somebody they're able to get out because that's the only recourse they have is to leave.

982
01:45:58.868 --> 01:46:05.239
<v April Roa>So just, I appreciate you bringing that thoughtfulness up because that's where my heart lies as well.

983
01:46:05.320 --> 01:46:06.207
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

984
01:46:08.027 --> 01:46:16.913
<v Nick McDonald>If I may, just on that one, one of the things that isn't in this presentation, which is in the broader report, is the role of Project Respond, which I believe does a lot more aggressive co-response with police.

985
01:46:16.962 --> 01:46:19.962
<v Nick McDonald>I don't know whether you want to talk about that, Captain.

986
01:46:20.476 --> 01:46:29.207
<v Stephanie Howard>Well, yeah, I mean, we're talking about, yeah, on those, you know, mental health crisis calls, of course that would be a resource we would use.

987
01:46:29.545 --> 01:46:37.746
<v Stephanie Howard>But we did, I mean, to your point, Councilor Zimmerman, we talked a lot about the, you know, should we even send PSR to these calls at houses when they can only go to the front door?

988
01:46:37.810 --> 01:46:40.779
<v Stephanie Howard>They're not going to walk around and look in the other windows or look around the back.

989
01:46:41.100 --> 01:46:45.945
<v Stephanie Howard>Is that a good use of their time, or should that just be sent to the police because we might eventually have to come?

990
01:46:46.538 --> 01:46:59.807
<v Stephanie Howard>Um, so we did spend, like April said, a lot of time talking about that, but we also spent a lot of time talking about the collaboration between us and PSR and not saying like, okay, PSR, you're going to go, but you don't want to be seen with us, you're going to leave before we come, or vice versa.

991
01:46:59.872 --> 01:47:09.305
<v Stephanie Howard>Like, just really talking about the collaboration and how helpful that will be for the community and for us to get to know PSR better and them for get to know, um, PPB a lot better.

992
01:47:09.354 --> 01:47:12.885
<v Stephanie Howard>So we did talk about that just, you know, yeah, maybe we're going to co-respond.

993
01:47:13.350 --> 01:47:20.703
<v Stephanie Howard>Maybe PSR sticks around while we do look around the house and maybe they have resources to give that person if that person is inside.

994
01:47:21.923 --> 01:47:26.113
<v Stephanie Howard>So we spent a lot of time talking about the collaboration piece between us too.

995
01:47:26.515 --> 01:47:31.940
<v April Roa>And I also want to highlight Project Respond is currently responding to residences.

996
01:47:32.037 --> 01:47:36.676
<v April Roa>That is their— I mean, we're not looking to do anything differently.

997
01:47:37.430 --> 01:47:40.385
<v April Roa>That is the model that they have been doing for a long time.

998
01:47:40.962 --> 01:47:42.809
<v April Roa>And they've been able to do it safely.

999
01:47:42.905 --> 01:47:51.092
<v April Roa>So that we are looking to them and taking the information that they have in their experience into consideration on how we develop PSR.

1000
01:47:51.478 --> 01:47:52.201
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you.

1001
01:47:52.345 --> 01:47:59.425
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then I just want to compliment the person, bicycle, wheelchair in traffic.

1002
01:47:59.890 --> 01:48:10.447
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that sometimes in government we get quite funny about the line of demarcation If it's a sidewalk, it's this group.

1003
01:48:10.496 --> 01:48:12.283
<v Eric Zimmerman>If it's a street, it's that group, right?

1004
01:48:12.380 --> 01:48:18.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>And even outside the public safety realm, like to clean graffiti on a road sign, that's PBOT.

1005
01:48:18.186 --> 01:48:21.832
<v Eric Zimmerman>To clean graffiti on the side of a building, that's BES, right?

1006
01:48:21.898 --> 01:48:23.646
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's some silliness that always happens.

1007
01:48:24.377 --> 01:48:32.939
<v Eric Zimmerman>But there are everyday people who are constantly dealing with somebody who is in the roadway and they're untrained.

1008
01:48:33.466 --> 01:48:40.506
<v Eric Zimmerman>And they're doing what mom and dad taught them to do, is look both ways and make yourself seen, because they're trying to intervene all the time.

1009
01:48:40.554 --> 01:48:59.664
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just appreciate— this seems like a common sense approach, and it requires you as a supervisor to provide enough ownership and cover for your employees to say, yes, I know I could have responded, but it wasn't a safe situation, so I didn't.

1010
01:49:00.229 --> 01:49:00.439
<v Eric Zimmerman>Respond.

1011
01:49:00.889 --> 01:49:09.818
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was staged off the side because they weren't just in the roadway, they were in the roadway of 99W, and it was like not safe for us, right?

1012
01:49:10.076 --> 01:49:16.519
<v Eric Zimmerman>Which is different than on the corner at 3rd and Burnside, which right now I guarantee there are 3 people laying in the street, right?

1013
01:49:16.744 --> 01:49:19.814
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is what happens at 3rd and Burnside in Northwest every single day.

1014
01:49:20.721 --> 01:49:26.055
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't know that the police are the only group that can respond to the, you know, in front of street routes.

1015
01:49:26.155 --> 01:49:26.751
<v Eric Zimmerman>So to speak.

1016
01:49:26.800 --> 01:49:32.708
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just, I think that that's a good, and there's a lot of calls, so I just think that that's a good dispersion.

1017
01:49:32.756 --> 01:49:33.707
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for the study.

1018
01:49:33.819 --> 01:49:34.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>I do appreciate it.

1019
01:49:34.770 --> 01:49:38.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I hope as you move forward, remember that the nuance will matter.

1020
01:49:38.409 --> 01:50:04.929
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is a spectrum and none of these choices were binary and that the decision on the ground by the responder, and sorry, I just looked at BOEC and I want to remind folks, I always try to, that giving a lot of grace to the person who is dispatching to make the best assessment based on the information you as a caller give is also a really important part of this equation.

1021
01:50:05.122 --> 01:50:12.153
<v Eric Zimmerman>I meet way too many people who don't realize that the way to get PSR to the place is to still call 911, right?

1022
01:50:12.216 --> 01:50:18.533
<v Eric Zimmerman>That you are— your team is trained to say that's a PSR type of response or that's not a PSR type of response.

1023
01:50:18.597 --> 01:50:21.880
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I always try to encourage people, you don't have to remember a bunch of numbers.

1024
01:50:22.248 --> 01:50:24.368
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's the same number your mom and dad taught you when you're a kid.

1025
01:50:24.514 --> 01:50:28.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>911 will get you whatever you need to if you're in crisis or somebody you see is in crisis.

1026
01:50:28.818 --> 01:50:34.215
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that decision-making at your level, at your team's level, is something I find very important as well.

1027
01:50:34.359 --> 01:50:35.097
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for everybody.

1028
01:50:35.579 --> 01:50:36.367
<v Todd Deweese>Appreciate that.

1029
01:50:37.331 --> 01:50:37.731
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1030
01:50:38.439 --> 01:50:44.350
<v Steve Novick>I wanted to say that I am grateful and fascinated and encouraged by this report.

1031
01:50:44.574 --> 01:50:47.867
<v Steve Novick>I'm grateful because this is exactly what, you know, we were talking about doing last year.

1032
01:50:48.480 --> 01:50:51.948
<v Steve Novick>I'm fascinated because the results are different from what I expected.

1033
01:50:53.539 --> 01:51:06.176
<v Steve Novick>Last year, talking and having anecdotal conversations with some people in BOEC and in the Police Bureau, I was under the impression that most welfare checks was like somebody lying on the sidewalk somewhere, and that a very few of them were private residence calls.

1034
01:51:07.233 --> 01:51:09.427
<v Steve Novick>It turns out that that was simply not true.

1035
01:51:11.097 --> 01:51:22.989
<v Steve Novick>And I'm encouraged by the fact that even though the numbers aren't what we expected, You still think that there is substantial capacity for these calls to be shifted to unarmed responders.

1036
01:51:23.726 --> 01:51:36.641
<v Steve Novick>I had 2 questions, one of which was PSR generally deals with mental health response, and a lot of these calls, there's no particular reason to think that mental health is involved.

1037
01:51:36.706 --> 01:51:42.987
<v Steve Novick>Like, I haven't gotten a response from somebody, from somebody I work with or a family member, doesn't necessarily mean there's a mental health issue.

1038
01:51:43.453 --> 01:51:53.738
<v Steve Novick>So was there thought given to the possibility of maybe having PS3s respond to those instead, or was that thought canceled by the mayor's proposing to cut PS3s by 80%?

1039
01:51:56.320 --> 01:52:00.733
<v Stephanie Howard>Well, we started the workgroup long before the proposal to cut PS3s.

1040
01:52:01.266 --> 01:52:03.480
<v Stephanie Howard>But no, that, I mean, that just is not in their contract.

1041
01:52:03.529 --> 01:52:10.139
<v Stephanie Howard>And we were— we inquired with the police union, and that was not going to be bargained into their contract as well to respond to these calls.

1042
01:52:13.793 --> 01:52:27.359
<v April Roa>Well, and I think also having our medical responders and crisis responders on, you know, on the same team kind of gives us a couple of lenses on showing up to assess, you know, somebody's well-being in the moment.

1043
01:52:27.456 --> 01:52:32.752
<v April Roa>So it kind of gives us a more robust lens on these calls.

1044
01:52:34.680 --> 01:52:44.939
<v Steve Novick>So you don't think that the reaction of a lot of PSR people will be, I think our down and unchecked are the same thing.

1045
01:52:45.079 --> 01:52:52.739
<v April Roa>You know, I think they— down and unchecked is really we don't have enough information to know whether or not somebody's okay.

1046
01:52:52.899 --> 01:52:58.529
<v April Roa>And I think that's the same as what we're asking at this point, is we don't have enough information to know if somebody's okay.

1047
01:52:59.159 --> 01:53:00.380
<v Loretta Smith>So—.

1048
01:53:00.380 --> 01:53:01.000
<v Peggy Parks>Okay.

1049
01:53:01.000 --> 01:53:02.079
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1050
01:53:02.079 --> 01:53:22.734
<v Steve Novick>And Nick, following up on Councilor Zimmerman's question about basically about the safety of going to— unarmed people going to a private residence, I think we all agree that I think you've told me before that there's a lot of data about the safety of unarmed responders going to lots of different kinds of calls around the country and the world, and generally the results are pretty good.

1051
01:53:23.262 --> 01:53:24.932
<v Steve Novick>So am I remembering that correctly?

1052
01:53:25.832 --> 01:53:26.345
<v Nick McDonald>Yeah.

1053
01:53:26.409 --> 01:53:35.145
<v Nick McDonald>So first off, I want to say we have the utmost concern for the safety of all our responders, and we don't want to be sending people into situations that they don't feel safe in.

1054
01:53:35.210 --> 01:53:35.595
<v Nick McDonald>Safe in.

1055
01:53:36.188 --> 01:53:42.750
<v Nick McDonald>Any responder, when they get on scene, always has the option to call for backup or other services to support them before they enter a building.

1056
01:53:42.797 --> 01:53:46.359
<v Nick McDonald>So we'd never want to be putting someone in an unsafe situation.

1057
01:53:47.177 --> 01:53:59.804
<v Nick McDonald>That said, we believe the data from Project Respond and the data nationally is that these kinds of services, when they're responding to any kinds of calls, be that in a vehicle or a private residence or on the street, have an excellent safety record.

1058
01:54:00.333 --> 01:54:09.729
<v Nick McDonald>I'm not I'm not aware of anyone in this line of work in the last 30 years being killed in the line of duty except through a traffic accident.

1059
01:54:10.296 --> 01:54:20.707
<v Nick McDonald>And I'm not aware of any situations within Portland with any of the alternative response systems that have resulted in serious injury or death.

1060
01:54:22.252 --> 01:54:25.426
<v Nick McDonald>That said, we definitely want to monitor this very carefully as we roll it out.

1061
01:54:25.492 --> 01:54:26.828
<v Nick McDonald>We want to learn from other organizations.

1062
01:54:27.140 --> 01:54:33.038
<v Nick McDonald>We want to put people in the position where they have the best training to be able to make the best decision about what they go into and what they don't, for sure.

1063
01:54:33.423 --> 01:54:34.320
<v Nick McDonald>Do you want to add anything, sir?

1064
01:54:35.171 --> 01:54:41.295
<v Stephanie Howard>Well, we brought in, and I don't remember the acronym, but the same, the PSR in LA.

1065
01:54:41.743 --> 01:54:44.436
<v Stephanie Howard>I can't remember their exact name right now.

1066
01:54:45.287 --> 01:54:50.752
<v Stephanie Howard>And they actually respond to a lot more calls that PSR isn't even considering going to.

1067
01:54:51.377 --> 01:54:53.579
<v Stephanie Howard>They have a very, very robust program.

1068
01:54:53.645 --> 01:55:09.483
<v Stephanie Howard>And so we learned a lot from our meetings with them and then also have asked for their, um, some of their policies and, you know, just to get, you know, just to understand more because they seem to be very successful down south and, and, um, want to bring that information up here as well.

1069
01:55:11.798 --> 01:55:13.791
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1070
01:55:14.212 --> 01:55:28.359
<v Steve Novick>And do you want to— we have another item to get to and we were— I would think yeah, yesterday the council president sort of scolded those of us who are chairs for not giving sufficient breaks during 3-hour meetings.

1071
01:55:28.440 --> 01:55:31.087
<v Steve Novick>So we need to take a 15-minute break before the next item.

1072
01:55:31.490 --> 01:55:34.119
<v Steve Novick>So I'm hoping we can wrap this discussion up quickly.

1073
01:55:34.943 --> 01:55:35.201
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1074
01:55:35.345 --> 01:55:38.899
<v Sameer Kanal>I think you're talking about Circle, the LA program in Canopy Roots.

1075
01:55:38.962 --> 01:55:48.269
<v Sameer Kanal>And yeah, I had a chance to meet with their— they do it in Canopy Roots, does a similar program in Minneapolis, and they have part of LA as well.

1076
01:55:48.398 --> 01:55:50.327
<v Sameer Kanal>So, uh, spoke about that also.

1077
01:55:50.648 --> 01:55:52.095
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there's, there's a lot to be learned there.

1078
01:55:52.158 --> 01:55:52.479
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree.

1079
01:55:53.042 --> 01:55:53.912
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, 3 quick things.

1080
01:55:54.007 --> 01:55:57.195
<v Sameer Kanal>One is the— I, I am comfortable.

1081
01:55:58.033 --> 01:56:04.358
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to understand the next steps for how we can— you said if the recommendations are accepted a couple times, uh, April.

1082
01:56:04.407 --> 01:56:14.137
<v Sameer Kanal>So I wanted to just understand how that occurs and how we can lock that in so that if it's going to take longer than 2 years, I want to make sure that we have it locked in.

1083
01:56:14.206 --> 01:56:14.344
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1084
01:56:14.820 --> 01:56:25.390
<v Sameer Kanal>So that the electoral timeline affiliated with the mayor's office does not interfere in this, because that has been a risk in other contexts.

1085
01:56:25.615 --> 01:56:29.225
<v Sameer Kanal>So I want to just understand the next step on that, and then I have 2 quick other—.

1086
01:56:29.483 --> 01:56:32.061
<v April Roa>Well, I think a big part of that is budget, right?

1087
01:56:32.222 --> 01:56:35.337
<v April Roa>All of these include staffing up.

1088
01:56:35.823 --> 01:56:41.648
<v April Roa>If we don't have the funding to staff up to handle the calls, then where it's kind of a moot point.

1089
01:56:42.337 --> 01:56:54.197
<v April Roa>We also then have to bargain with all of, I think, the Police Officers Association and the other 2 representative, you know, unions representing PSR folks.

1090
01:56:55.497 --> 01:57:18.882
<v April Roa>And then there's a lot of work that we have to do with BOEC, and we already have begun that work for dedicated dispatch because as it is right now, our call volume is getting to the point where It's really a huge burden for our PSR staff to try and triage calls on their own with a single call type without having a dedicated dispatcher.

1091
01:57:19.011 --> 01:57:20.027
<v April Roa>So there's some work there.

1092
01:57:21.042 --> 01:57:24.509
<v April Roa>But budget is going to drive a big portion of that.

1093
01:57:25.752 --> 01:57:25.912
<v Jahad Hudson>Okay.

1094
01:57:26.298 --> 01:57:30.916
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm more thinking about code as a way of locking things in.

1095
01:57:31.206 --> 01:57:32.685
<v Sameer Kanal>That's my primary concern here.

1096
01:57:33.207 --> 01:57:36.979
<v Sameer Kanal>Start on a timeline last June to get to a place where PSR will get into code.

1097
01:57:37.027 --> 01:57:38.631
<v Sameer Kanal>So wanted to talk about that.

1098
01:57:38.728 --> 01:57:41.134
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I think bargaining is also super important.

1099
01:57:41.198 --> 01:57:46.125
<v Sameer Kanal>The budget side, that can, you know, that, that has volatility built in, of course.

1100
01:57:46.654 --> 01:58:07.886
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, the second thing I had, uh, was CHAT considered as a potential responder to the, the welfare check, uh, categories that are exclusively physical health focused, or that we believe at the time of dispatch are and I, I think yes, but the ones that we are—.

1101
01:58:08.078 --> 01:58:13.841
<v April Roa>PSR is responding to don't have enough information for it to be triaged as a medical call.

1102
01:58:14.853 --> 01:58:19.315
<v April Roa>So ours are third party, and it's like, I don't know, they don't look very well.

1103
01:58:20.135 --> 01:58:26.363
<v April Roa>So I don't know, in the absence of information, that's why PSR is going to obtain more information.

1104
01:58:26.716 --> 01:58:31.175
<v April Roa>If it is, um, A higher acuity, of course we're calling them in.

1105
01:58:31.528 --> 01:58:41.386
<v April Roa>We often are still calling in CHAT on those calls when we have determined that there is a longer-term need there, if it's something that our folks can't address in the moment.

1106
01:58:41.801 --> 01:58:55.411
<v April Roa>So we are using, again, it's that lack of information, and we're going, because there's only so much we can get from a third-party caller or through the phone, and it's always different when we show up, and then we assess and evaluate and then try and get that other response.

1107
01:58:55.490 --> 01:58:55.635
<v April Roa>Thank you.

1108
01:58:57.970 --> 01:59:05.411
<v Sameer Kanal>And the third piece is just to follow up on the Project Respond piece.

1109
01:59:08.274 --> 01:59:14.764
<v Sameer Kanal>Project Respond cannot be dispatched through 911 as per, like, directly from the caller, right?

1110
01:59:14.811 --> 01:59:17.568
<v Sameer Kanal>It has to— it involves the Portland police officer requesting.

1111
01:59:17.615 --> 01:59:18.150
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that correct?

1112
01:59:18.360 --> 01:59:18.604
<v Todd Deweese>Correct.

1113
01:59:18.667 --> 01:59:18.911
<v Todd Deweese>Yeah.

1114
01:59:19.154 --> 01:59:20.173
<v Todd Deweese>Police will respond.

1115
01:59:20.610 --> 01:59:22.359
<v Todd Deweese>They'll request Project Respond.

1116
01:59:22.957 --> 01:59:26.313
<v Todd Deweese>We'll send out a page and then they'll contact the officer directly.

1117
01:59:26.762 --> 01:59:27.757
<v Todd Deweese>So as long as—.

1118
01:59:27.757 --> 01:59:37.215
<v Todd Deweese>We also transfer callers through to the BHCC, the Behavioral Health Crisis Center, and then they dispatch Project Respond as well.

1119
01:59:37.359 --> 01:59:46.141
<v Todd Deweese>So if we have a caller that we transfer over to them and they deem, oh, we should have some follow-up, they'll contact Project Respond.

1120
01:59:46.479 --> 01:59:55.652
<v Todd Deweese>They also have access to their their records, their caseworkers, and they can handle all those notifications and contact directly as well.

1121
01:59:56.250 --> 02:00:00.520
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's usually for something like a person calling for themselves?

1122
02:00:02.073 --> 02:00:04.404
<v Todd Deweese>It could be first party or second party.

1123
02:00:05.082 --> 02:00:05.326
<v Todd Deweese>Okay.

1124
02:00:05.795 --> 02:00:10.315
<v Todd Deweese>Typically first party is best because they can actually speak with the person, but sometimes it could be second party.

1125
02:00:10.814 --> 02:00:11.038
<v Jahad Hudson>Okay.

1126
02:00:11.216 --> 02:00:29.646
<v Sameer Kanal>Because the reason I'm bringing this up is to say, as long as it is dispatched differently, from either PSR or Portland Police, which kind of have a similar process of direct, then it doesn't make sense to me to consider that a part of the response continuum in the same way.

1127
02:00:30.497 --> 02:00:37.770
<v Sameer Kanal>Because again, to use the same example, Project Respond probably should have been dispatched to Damon Lamar Johnson.

1128
02:00:38.829 --> 02:00:44.640
<v Sameer Kanal>And the fact that it wasn't is a failure of a system that has been brought up.

1129
02:00:44.929 --> 02:00:55.095
<v Sameer Kanal>Reporting from the Mercury shows about 3% of the time that it is responded, that Project Respond is dispatched, is because of calls from the city side.

1130
02:00:55.706 --> 02:01:07.188
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's a thing that we have to look at here and try and ensure that we're either not building a future that relies on something that's dispatched differently, or we're fixing it.

1131
02:01:07.621 --> 02:01:08.342
<v Sameer Kanal>Either way is fine with me.

1132
02:01:08.439 --> 02:01:09.465
<v Sameer Kanal>I just want to make sure that's on the table.

1133
02:01:10.752 --> 02:01:11.475
<v Steve Novick>Thanks, Councilor.

1134
02:01:11.737 --> 02:01:14.346
<v Steve Novick>Um, thank you very much, really appreciated.

1135
02:01:15.877 --> 02:01:24.378
<v Steve Novick>Um, and we're going to have a 13-minute break before getting to the psychedelics item, so please be back at 11:40.

1136
02:01:27.172 --> 02:01:27.483
<v Marvin Young>Thank you.

1137
02:15:15.342 --> 02:15:15.551
<v Angelita Morillo>Do we—.

1138
02:15:15.551 --> 02:15:17.943
<v Sierra Ellis>Oh, I'm sorry, you could do your job.

1139
02:15:18.408 --> 02:15:21.954
<v Steve Novick>All right, I told people 11:40, it's 11:41.

1140
02:15:22.002 --> 02:15:22.645
<v Steve Novick>We do have a quorum.

1141
02:15:22.921 --> 02:15:24.738
<v Steve Novick>So could I have the clerk read the next item?

1142
02:15:26.738 --> 02:15:42.201
<v Rachael Fetters>Item number 3, document number 2026-186, add psychedelic health and safety code and create the Portland Psychedelic Advisory Commission, add code chapter 14B.140.

1143
02:15:43.349 --> 02:15:45.789
<v Steve Novick>And Councilors Murillo and Green, this is your show.

1144
02:15:45.871 --> 02:15:46.809
<v Steve Novick>How do you want— what do you want to do first?

1145
02:15:49.782 --> 02:15:51.086
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Green, why don't you come up?

1146
02:15:51.617 --> 02:15:55.914
<v Angelita Morillo>And I wasn't sure if Councilor Pirtle-Guiney would be here as well since she's another co-sponsor.

1147
02:15:55.979 --> 02:15:57.427
<v Steve Novick>Apparently she can't make it.

1148
02:15:57.605 --> 02:15:57.992
<v Angelita Morillo>Oh, okay.

1149
02:15:58.233 --> 02:15:59.264
<v Angelita Morillo>I see her chief is here though.

1150
02:16:02.850 --> 02:16:04.054
<v Franz Schaning>Councilor Mitch Green for the record.

1151
02:16:09.920 --> 02:16:10.996
<v Angelita Morillo>Do you want to introduce yourself as well?

1152
02:16:11.158 --> 02:16:11.631
<v Devin Mullins>Oh yeah, sorry.

1153
02:16:11.974 --> 02:16:12.447
<v Devin Mullins>Devin Mullins.

1154
02:16:12.545 --> 02:16:14.094
<v Devin Mullins>I'm policy manager for Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1155
02:16:14.997 --> 02:16:15.672
<v Angelita Morillo>Awesome, thank you.

1156
02:16:15.801 --> 02:16:16.619
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, feel free to take it away.

1157
02:16:17.407 --> 02:16:17.984
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

1158
02:16:18.210 --> 02:16:19.798
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you, Chair Novick.

1159
02:16:19.846 --> 02:16:48.626
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Vice Chair Murillo, for making time to talk about this ordinance, um, that I've co-sponsored with, uh, Councilors Pirtle-Guiney and Councilors Murillo, um, which, you know, seeks to sort of formalize a low law enforcement priority in the City of Portland for the use, uh, cultivation, uh, and practice of psychedelic substances like, you know, psilocybin and the like.

1160
02:16:50.075 --> 02:16:56.305
<v Mitch Green>There's going to be a lot of folks behind me, I think, that can answer a lot of technical questions, and there's been a lot of work that our 3 offices have put into it.

1161
02:16:56.369 --> 02:17:00.682
<v Mitch Green>But I think for you, for our purposes of motivating this, I'd like to just speak from the heart for a moment.

1162
02:17:01.847 --> 02:17:07.329
<v Mitch Green>A big motivation for me in supporting this legislation is it does Councilmember Smith.

1163
02:17:07.378 --> 02:17:14.224
<v Mitch Green>I think it is important for people with post-traumatic stress disorder to, um, to find a pathway to wellness and healing.

1164
02:17:14.993 --> 02:17:18.327
<v Mitch Green>It has had this effect on a lot of people, particularly in my life.

1165
02:17:18.728 --> 02:17:22.752
<v Mitch Green>I'm a veteran of the United States Army, saw combat.

1166
02:17:23.009 --> 02:17:24.210
<v Mitch Green>A lot of my friends did too.

1167
02:17:24.900 --> 02:17:32.290
<v Mitch Green>And I know for me, psychedelics was a big part of finding some sort of peace and reckoning with that experience.

1168
02:17:32.996 --> 02:17:42.173
<v Mitch Green>I don't think it's a replacement necessarily for talking to a therapist and a trained practitioner, you know, doing it sort of on your own because you know a guy who knows a guy.

1169
02:17:42.237 --> 02:17:44.676
<v Mitch Green>I mean, that's, that's not what I'm advocating here.

1170
02:17:44.984 --> 02:17:53.852
<v Mitch Green>But what I am saying is there were a lot of my friends who had the same experience I did overseas, my brother in fact, who took a different path.

1171
02:17:54.694 --> 02:17:58.298
<v Mitch Green>They ended up developing a pretty significant opiate addiction.

1172
02:17:58.716 --> 02:18:02.111
<v Mitch Green>My brother was a heroin addict on the streets of Portland for 3 years and Seattle.

1173
02:18:02.979 --> 02:18:04.670
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, he's clean today.

1174
02:18:04.766 --> 02:18:05.314
<v Mitch Green>That's great.

1175
02:18:05.755 --> 02:18:27.269
<v Mitch Green>From a lot of help, but I know that there were folks in my life who walked that edge, um, and then were able to experiment with psychedelics under the sort of care of people who were pretty practiced in their communities and had an outcome that actually allowed them to sort of come out of that experience, um, in a, in a very sort of healthy kind of way.

1176
02:18:27.494 --> 02:18:55.121
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm hoping that what this ordinance can do for us is allow us to articulate that it is a low— it's, you know, lowest law enforcement priority that we have, um, and then allow us to stand up a, um, an advisory body to help us learn from this and, and to help us sort of create a nexus with, uh, folks in our communities who, um, who have some expertise with this, these materials, um, to, to do— to actually engage in evidence-based, uh, community practice of wellness.

1177
02:18:55.170 --> 02:19:08.049
<v Devin Mullins>So I think for there, I'll just leave it there and Uh, Chair Novick, members of the committee, for the record, I'm Devin Mullins, policy manager for Councilor Elana Pirtle-Guiney.

1178
02:19:08.049 --> 02:19:10.540
<v Devin Mullins>I'm delivering these remarks on behalf of the councilor.

1179
02:19:10.549 --> 02:19:12.079
<v Devin Mullins>She apologizes for not being here.

1180
02:19:12.510 --> 02:19:16.329
<v Devin Mullins>The councilor is excited to be introducing this ordinance alongside Councilors Green and Murillo.

1181
02:19:16.329 --> 02:19:23.540
<v Devin Mullins>This ordinance simply says that non-commercial personal use of naturally occurring psychedelics is a low priority for law enforcement and creates an advisory body to develop thank you, Mayor.

1182
02:19:23.540 --> 02:19:23.540
<v Devin Mullins>Thank you, Mayor.

1183
02:19:23.540 --> 02:19:25.079
<v Devin Mullins>This ordinance is an important step for our city to a policy create a clear policy body to guide future work on these issues.

1184
02:19:25.739 --> 02:19:34.170
<v Devin Mullins>Our office hears over and over again from constituents that they want us focused on activities, including substance use, that are doing real harm, that are killing people and wrecking lives.

1185
02:19:34.440 --> 02:19:47.129
<v Devin Mullins>This ordinance allows our limited public safety resources to go towards what is actually causing the most harm in our community, the most harmful substances, the ones that most lead to overdose death in our communities, the activities that pose the greatest risk to community safety.

1186
02:19:47.659 --> 02:19:52.916
<v Devin Mullins>And at a time when we have very real challenges challenges in the city and a challenging budget environment, we need to prioritize.

1187
02:19:53.350 --> 02:19:55.962
<v Devin Mullins>We have finite law enforcement and behavioral health resources.

1188
02:19:56.235 --> 02:19:57.052
<v Devin Mullins>That's just a fact.

1189
02:19:57.597 --> 02:20:01.654
<v Devin Mullins>So every decision we make about priorities is also a decision about what we are not focusing on.

1190
02:20:02.326 --> 02:20:06.301
<v Devin Mullins>This ordinance allows us to focus our resources on the highest-risk issues in front of us.

1191
02:20:07.280 --> 02:20:13.115
<v Devin Mullins>Importantly, we are not deprioritizing the activities where any substances, including natural psychedelics, do cause harm.

1192
02:20:13.628 --> 02:20:17.977
<v Devin Mullins>We are maintaining regular enforcement against illegal sales, impaired driving, and unsafe behavior.

1193
02:20:18.747 --> 02:20:20.963
<v Devin Mullins>All of these will remain normal priorities for PPB.

1194
02:20:21.735 --> 02:20:27.081
<v Devin Mullins>The ordinance also creates an advisory body to provide evidence-based guidance on harm reduction education and implementation.

1195
02:20:27.932 --> 02:20:37.679
<v Devin Mullins>This is something that community members who have experience with natural psychedelics, including spiritual or medicinal, or who have experience with law enforcement of natural psychedelics, have been asking for for years.

1196
02:20:38.352 --> 02:20:46.523
<v Devin Mullins>Advisory bodies help us engage folks who might be left out of the conversation and help us learn from diverse community perspectives, bringing in expertise we don't have on our city staff.

1197
02:20:47.290 --> 02:20:53.717
<v Devin Mullins>I'll note, because I'll suspect we'll hear this is a rather niche cause for an advisory body, that we have some very niche advisory bodies.

1198
02:20:54.649 --> 02:20:59.990
<v Devin Mullins>These are important groups, though none of them, including the one we're proposing here, need to last forever— just long enough to get the work done.

1199
02:21:00.750 --> 02:21:04.730
<v Devin Mullins>Last year, Council passed new rules on advisory bodies, which includes mandatory sunsets.

1200
02:21:05.198 --> 02:21:06.933
<v Devin Mullins>That's a good change, and it's appropriate here.

1201
02:21:07.638 --> 02:21:21.628
<v Devin Mullins>The advisory body gives us a structured way to monitor how the deprioritization concept is working and make adjustments over time, and it gives us an opportunity to learn from the, the advocacy community in this space and understand how we can shape meaningful, meaningful policy going forward.

1202
02:21:22.380 --> 02:21:29.495
<v Devin Mullins>The North Star of this ordinance is focusing on what matters most for public health and public safety, knowing that we live in a world of increasingly scarce resources.

1203
02:21:29.944 --> 02:21:38.420
<v Devin Mullins>It's a small but meaningful change, and the council thank you.

1204
02:21:38.420 --> 02:21:43.489
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Morillo, do you want to move on to public testimony, or are there other experts that you want to bring up first?

1205
02:21:43.620 --> 02:21:45.739
<v Steve Novick>There are 6 people signed up for testimony, is my understanding.

1206
02:21:46.219 --> 02:21:49.920
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, I think, um, I, I just wanted to thank you so much for saying all of that.

1207
02:21:49.920 --> 02:21:51.120
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that outlined it really well.

1208
02:21:51.120 --> 02:21:54.440
<v Angelita Morillo>I appreciate both of you coming up here and you coming in Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's place.

1209
02:21:54.440 --> 02:22:09.647
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, uh, the only last thing I want to add as one of the co-sponsors as well is that, you know, I think we're all in agreement that we need to I think that when we talk about psilocybin and its uses, we— part of that is destigmatization, and that can only be done when we actually change our laws to deprioritize it.

1210
02:22:10.016 --> 02:22:14.266
<v Angelita Morillo>An internal PPB memo doesn't necessarily change how it is viewed by the public.

1211
02:22:14.650 --> 02:22:16.799
<v Angelita Morillo>Only actually taking that legal step does.

1212
02:22:16.912 --> 02:22:20.648
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think that's why it's important to do this today and why it's not just a niche thing to do.

1213
02:22:21.643 --> 02:22:27.539
<v Angelita Morillo>We do have some community experts here who have studied and worked on this for a very long time, and I would love to bring them up.

1214
02:22:28.006 --> 02:22:38.393
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I believe we have Nate Howard, Courtney Moran, and Max Kellerman, uh, coming up to present briefly, and then we will move on to community testimony.

1215
02:22:40.024 --> 02:22:40.415
<v Steve Novick>Coming up.

1216
02:22:51.402 --> 02:22:51.851
<v Rachael Fetters>May I begin?

1217
02:22:52.843 --> 02:22:54.655
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes, and please introduce yourselves for the record.

1218
02:22:54.942 --> 02:22:55.567
<v April Roa>Okay, great.

1219
02:22:55.952 --> 02:22:59.621
<v Courtney Moran>Good morning, Chair Novick, Vice Chair Murillo, members of the committee.

1220
02:22:59.798 --> 02:23:00.566
<v Courtney Moran>I am Courtney Moran.

1221
02:23:00.775 --> 02:23:07.313
<v Courtney Moran>I'm founding principal of the Portland-based law firm Earth Law LLC, and I'm also the chief legislative strategist for Agricultural Solutions.

1222
02:23:07.889 --> 02:23:18.593
<v Courtney Moran>I'm here today testifying on behalf of the Portland Psychedelic Society Action Fund to testify in support of the ordinance to add the Psychedelic Health and Safety Code and create the Portland Psychedelics Advisory Commission.

1223
02:23:19.443 --> 02:23:26.231
<v Courtney Moran>This ordinance affirms non-commercial personal use of natural psychedelics as a low priority for law enforcement.

1224
02:23:26.970 --> 02:23:28.382
<v Courtney Moran>This is not decriminalization.

1225
02:23:29.057 --> 02:23:30.245
<v Courtney Moran>This is not legalization.

1226
02:23:30.998 --> 02:23:32.893
<v Courtney Moran>This does not authorize sales.

1227
02:23:33.807 --> 02:23:47.770
<v Courtney Moran>It is simply a statement from the city that the personal use of naturally occurring psychedelic plants and fungi is a low priority while maintaining enforcement of impaired driving, Illegal sales, and other unsafe conduct.

1228
02:23:48.492 --> 02:24:04.908
<v Courtney Moran>This allows limited law enforcement resources to more effectively focus on urgent community needs, including high-risk substances associated with addiction and overdose, drug trafficking, and activities that pose the greatest public safety concerns for our city.

1229
02:24:06.064 --> 02:24:17.345
<v Courtney Moran>The ordinance also establishes the Portland Psychedelics Advisory Commission, a publicly accountable advisory body that provides expert guidance and recommendations and reports directly to City Council.

1230
02:24:18.325 --> 02:24:45.842
<v Courtney Moran>Duties of the commission include studying the use of natural psychedelics and alleviating addiction and treatment substance use disorders, recommending evidence-based harm reduction approaches, cataloging medical, psychological, and scientific research, disseminating educational materials, offering recommendations to law enforcement around best practices, and monitoring at the state, federal, and international levels policy evolution.

1231
02:24:46.682 --> 02:24:58.030
<v Courtney Moran>PPAC provides a community-driven approach to advance public health, provide evidence-based education, best practices, and safety related to natural psychedelics.

1232
02:24:58.609 --> 02:25:00.949
<v Courtney Moran>We respectfully ask for your yes vote.

1233
02:25:01.433 --> 02:25:01.806
<v Courtney Moran>Thank you.

1234
02:25:07.073 --> 02:25:07.698
<v Nate Howard>Is it my turn?

1235
02:25:09.542 --> 02:25:10.787
<v Nate Howard>There's no applause in here, right?

1236
02:25:12.902 --> 02:25:13.677
<v Nate Howard>Oh, oh, there is applause.

1237
02:25:13.774 --> 02:25:14.486
<v Nate Howard>You can applaud.

1238
02:25:14.680 --> 02:25:15.019
<v Nate Howard>Thanks, Courtney.

1239
02:25:15.309 --> 02:25:15.843
<v Nate Howard>Oh, to applaud.

1240
02:25:16.555 --> 02:25:17.265
<v Nate Howard>Oh, there actually is.

1241
02:25:17.329 --> 02:25:17.411
<v Nate Howard>No.

1242
02:25:18.639 --> 02:25:19.576
<v Nate Howard>Oh, there's sparkle fingers.

1243
02:25:20.190 --> 02:25:22.063
<v Nate Howard>Oh, I remember that from back in the day.

1244
02:25:22.725 --> 02:25:24.049
<v Nate Howard>A real treat to be here.

1245
02:25:24.808 --> 02:25:25.180
<v Nate Howard>I mean it.

1246
02:25:25.536 --> 02:25:28.297
<v Nate Howard>I feel like City Hall for me kind of feels like a fun summer camp.

1247
02:25:28.653 --> 02:25:37.843
<v Nate Howard>My name is Nate Howard, and thank you, Chair Novick, Vice Chair Morillo, members of the committee, thank you all for your service, for running, for serving.

1248
02:25:39.147 --> 02:25:40.320
<v Nate Howard>Yeah, I really mean that.

1249
02:25:41.059 --> 02:25:45.577
<v Nate Howard>And thanks for hearing this today and for being, yeah, being willing to hear this policy.

1250
02:25:45.949 --> 02:25:49.822
<v Nate Howard>So I'm a District 3 resident, a former City Hall staffer.

1251
02:25:49.968 --> 02:25:52.020
<v Nate Howard>It really does feel lovely to be back here.

1252
02:25:52.779 --> 02:26:15.385
<v Nate Howard>And in 2018, coming out of City Hall and about a decade of different campaigns and political work, a— and this is not the case for everyone, sometimes it takes multiple, but a single evening with a psychedelic session where my now wife sat with me changed my life in many ways.

1253
02:26:16.605 --> 02:26:34.299
<v Nate Howard>My relationship with my parents, I became open to dogs, realizing that I was just wrong about dogs, and a lot of other stuff happened, including Working with 2 therapists who ended up creating Ballot Measure 109, the first legal psychedelic healthcare program in the world governed by the government or regulated.

1254
02:26:34.750 --> 02:26:48.862
<v Nate Howard>And the big thing is that it also helped me recover from what I realized later was severe political burnout that had led to alcoholism, which I never thought would happen for me, having seen it happen with my parents and family members.

1255
02:26:49.602 --> 02:26:56.248
<v Nate Howard>And so since then Feels like a long time, but I guess it's 8 years.

1256
02:26:56.746 --> 02:27:10.058
<v Nate Howard>I have spent all of my professional and volunteer time working to advance broadly science-based psychedelic health policy here, statewide, nationally, and increasingly internationally.

1257
02:27:10.411 --> 02:27:15.084
<v Nate Howard>And so it's with that context that I offer that this policy is not new.

1258
02:27:15.532 --> 02:27:16.753
<v Nate Howard>It's not an tested.

1259
02:27:17.299 --> 02:27:25.290
<v Nate Howard>It is a best practices approach already adopted in dozens of cities or counties around the country, which Max will speak to a bit more.

1260
02:27:25.885 --> 02:27:36.814
<v Nate Howard>And here in Portland, this effort has been shaped over several years, and by several, I kind of feel disappointed to say 6 years that we've been working on this, just because, you know, it's a lot of time.

1261
02:27:36.974 --> 02:27:50.949
<v Nate Howard>And it's really worth it because over the process that has included hundreds of people that have been part of of stakeholder involvement, community leaders here nationally and internationally, legal and policy experts, healthcare professionals.

1262
02:27:51.627 --> 02:27:59.414
<v Nate Howard>Importantly, the National Council of the Native American Church was part of the origin of this policy and helped shape it.

1263
02:28:00.716 --> 02:28:15.390
<v Nate Howard>And yeah, so we're here now and we're hearing from City Hall and beyond that now is feeling like the time to codify cultural norms that already exist in Portland's culture and in law enforcement community.

1264
02:28:17.114 --> 02:28:34.087
<v Nate Howard>And we have, to the best of our ability through surveys and polls, we have as good evidence as we're going to find that there is somewhere in the tens of thousands of Portlanders, somewhere in the realm of tens of thousands of Portlanders who already have some relationship with these naturally occurring plants.

1265
02:28:34.190 --> 02:28:35.763
<v Nate Howard>Plants in non-commercial contexts.

1266
02:28:35.826 --> 02:28:40.611
<v Nate Howard>And when we say relationship, we're talking about like eating a cactus or eating a mushroom.

1267
02:28:40.708 --> 02:28:45.574
<v Nate Howard>Those are the kind of natural medicines we're talking about with no commercial components.

1268
02:28:45.621 --> 02:28:47.917
<v Nate Howard>So this is— no money is changing hands.

1269
02:28:48.656 --> 02:28:57.727
<v Nate Howard>And lastly, the policy here clarifies again that commercial sales are not allowed, which Courtney alluded to, underscoring that there has been confusion in the past.

1270
02:28:57.905 --> 02:28:59.606
<v Nate Howard>And so this once— we want to clarify that.

1271
02:28:59.976 --> 02:29:08.904
<v Nate Howard>While helping to ensure that addictive and harmful substances remain a priority for law enforcement, really underscoring what Devin said earlier.

1272
02:29:09.402 --> 02:29:12.404
<v Nate Howard>So personal, non-commercial use, law enforcement priority.

1273
02:29:12.997 --> 02:29:18.344
<v Nate Howard>The idea is that there's more education, there's more clarity, there's more psychological safety for everyone.

1274
02:29:19.084 --> 02:29:36.707
<v Nate Howard>And those— that is often the substrate in other areas of policy we have seen where the normalization makes it easier for people to have conversations, ask honest questions, seek education, and consider whether this medicine has a role in their healthcare routine and in their healing.

1275
02:29:36.835 --> 02:29:44.238
<v Nate Howard>So one idea is, you know, how do we make it easier for people to have the kind of life-changing experiences that I had in 2018?

1276
02:29:44.912 --> 02:29:47.203
<v Nate Howard>Passing this would support that.

1277
02:29:47.540 --> 02:29:50.728
<v Nate Howard>So we generously ask you all for your support.

1278
02:29:54.150 --> 02:29:57.806
<v Nate Howard>Did I go overtime?

1279
02:30:00.447 --> 02:30:01.138
<v Nate Howard>Sparkle fingers.

1280
02:30:02.218 --> 02:30:02.587
<v Max Kellerman>Thank you.

1281
02:30:02.861 --> 02:30:06.532
<v Max Kellerman>Good morning, Chair Novick, Vice Chair Morillo, and members of the committee.

1282
02:30:06.807 --> 02:30:07.805
<v Max Kellerman>My name is Max Kellerman.

1283
02:30:08.239 --> 02:30:16.363
<v Max Kellerman>I'm a District 2 resident and the executive director of the Portland Psychedelic Society, Oregon's largest and longest-running psychedelic education and advocacy organization.

1284
02:30:16.459 --> 02:30:18.143
<v Max Kellerman>Education and community organization.

1285
02:30:18.880 --> 02:30:31.261
<v Max Kellerman>And over the past decade, our community has grown to more than 11,000 Portland area members seeking education, support, and responsible approaches to psychedelic use, as both my colleagues have described here.

1286
02:30:32.207 --> 02:30:39.551
<v Max Kellerman>And I'd say one of my greatest privileges of this work is witnessing people who might not otherwise meet find each other through our community.

1287
02:30:40.065 --> 02:30:48.980
<v Max Kellerman>They come from different backgrounds, professions, generations, conditions and life experience, yet they share this common desire to learn, grow, and support one another.

1288
02:30:50.152 --> 02:31:13.806
<v Max Kellerman>I want to emphasize today as we sit here, uh, that Portland already has a substantial psychedelic economic ecosystem including licensed facilitators and service centers, physicians, therapists, researchers, recovery advocates, educators, coaches, spiritual leaders, authors, conference organizers, and countless Portlanders exploring new pathways for healing and well-being.

1289
02:31:14.710 --> 02:31:24.465
<v Max Kellerman>And together they are helping address some of the very challenges our city continues to face, including depression, anxiety, PTSD, addiction, grief, and social isolation.

1290
02:31:25.479 --> 02:31:28.485
<v Max Kellerman>This ecosystem is already here and it continues to grow.

1291
02:31:29.995 --> 02:31:32.469
<v Max Kellerman>And Portland, as Nate mentioned, is not acting alone.

1292
02:31:32.582 --> 02:31:55.172
<v Max Kellerman>More than 2 dozen jurisdictions across the country, including Seattle, San Francisco, Francisco, Denver, Minneapolis, Washington, D.C. have adopted similar approaches, while states, universities, healthcare systems, federal agencies, and policymakers are increasingly establishing advisory bodies, task forces, and commissions to help navigate this rapidly evolving psychedelic landscape.

1293
02:31:56.247 --> 02:32:13.611
<v Max Kellerman>The proposed Portland Psychedelics Advisory Commission would be a municipal adaptation of this emerging governance and Portland is uniquely positioned to benefit from it because we already have practitioners, researchers, educators, service providers, and community organizations with decades of experience supporting these conversations.

1294
02:32:14.846 --> 02:32:27.472
<v Max Kellerman>And one of the greatest benefits of this proposal is its potential, as Councilor Murillo described, is to help destigmatize and demystify these conversations while creating a constructive framework for education.

1295
02:32:27.682 --> 02:32:38.317
<v Max Kellerman>Public interest in psychedelics continues to grow, whether through scientific research, healthcare discussions, media coverage, and personal experience.

1296
02:32:38.990 --> 02:32:47.975
<v Max Kellerman>When people of all backgrounds feel safe asking questions and learning from qualified professionals and trusted community resources, better outcomes become possible.

1297
02:32:49.033 --> 02:32:54.119
<v Max Kellerman>Stigma and silence rarely improve public health or public safety, but education does.

1298
02:32:56.120 --> 02:33:02.528
<v Max Kellerman>Portland has been a long leader in innovation and community-based solutions.

1299
02:33:03.027 --> 02:33:13.045
<v Max Kellerman>This proposal creates greater clarity around an issue that is already present in our community and supports a future where education, safety, and informed decision-making can thrive.

1300
02:33:13.141 --> 02:33:16.304
<v Max Kellerman>So I just want to say thank you for your consideration and encourage your support.

1301
02:33:19.074 --> 02:33:19.534
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1302
02:33:20.643 --> 02:33:22.582
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Morillo, do you have any more invited testimony?

1303
02:33:22.629 --> 02:33:23.816
<v Steve Novick>Should we move on to public testimony?

1304
02:33:24.072 --> 02:33:25.049
<v Steve Novick>Public testimony.

1305
02:33:25.754 --> 02:33:26.091
<v Steve Novick>All right.

1306
02:33:26.476 --> 02:33:28.431
<v Steve Novick>Oh, and Kanal has a technical question.

1307
02:33:28.511 --> 02:33:28.783
<v Steve Novick>Sorry.

1308
02:33:29.200 --> 02:33:34.936
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so for the sponsor, for— this is really something that Devin mentioned, but anyone can answer it.

1309
02:33:36.027 --> 02:33:46.802
<v Sameer Kanal>There's reference to the sunset provisions of the ABC project that we adopted last year as it relates to the commission, but at multiple times, and this says ongoing.

1310
02:33:47.656 --> 02:33:55.665
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, I just wanted to understand the intention here, um, as to whether or not the— you know, and I'll, I'll be very specific here.

1311
02:33:55.859 --> 02:34:07.963
<v Sameer Kanal>In Exhibit A, 14B-14010, Part C, it says establishing an ongoing advisory body, and in, uh, Exhibit B, it refers to ongoing several times.

1312
02:34:08.013 --> 02:34:19.299
<v Sameer Kanal>So my understanding from the ABC project is that If it says nothing, there's a mandatory sunset, but that it can be explicitly created as ongoing through this process.

1313
02:34:20.636 --> 02:34:25.069
<v Sameer Kanal>And so my understanding is that the text would create it in an ongoing way.

1314
02:34:25.166 --> 02:34:28.197
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that in line with the legislative intent here?

1315
02:34:30.969 --> 02:34:31.854
<v Devin Mullins>Councilor, thank you for the question.

1316
02:34:31.984 --> 02:34:33.465
<v Devin Mullins>I don't know if this is working.

1317
02:34:33.560 --> 02:34:33.787
<v Devin Mullins>Yeah, it is.

1318
02:34:34.688 --> 02:34:37.408
<v Devin Mullins>For the record, Devin Mullins, policy manager for Councilor Elana Pirtle-Guiney.

1319
02:34:38.786 --> 02:34:44.694
<v Devin Mullins>That was not my read of what was adopted by council last year on ABCs.

1320
02:34:44.807 --> 02:34:55.308
<v Devin Mullins>My read, and I'm trying to find the specific provision now, was that all ongoing advisory bodies had to come up for renewal after 4 years and council could take an explicit action that renewed them.

1321
02:34:56.609 --> 02:35:10.665
<v Devin Mullins>That was the intent at which we drafted it with council, you know, leaving that discretion to council to decide whether or not that If that is an incorrect interpretation of it, which I can certainly check, we can add clarity to the text.

1322
02:35:11.515 --> 02:35:13.617
<v Sameer Kanal>I might be wrong on that as well, but I'll check.

1323
02:35:13.842 --> 02:35:24.811
<v Courtney Moran>If I can add something, Chair Novick, Councilor Kanal, under the commission membership section, sub F, it does say that the PPAC will continue as an ongoing advisory body unless terminated by the City Council.

1324
02:35:24.861 --> 02:35:28.228
<v Courtney Moran>So the council has the right to terminate the body when they feel that the work is completed.

1325
02:35:28.597 --> 02:35:28.726
<v Angelita Morillo>Right.

1326
02:35:28.773 --> 02:35:30.505
<v Sameer Kanal>So that would involve a different council action.

1327
02:35:30.554 --> 02:35:31.933
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm asking about whether or not the work is complete.

1328
02:35:31.968 --> 02:35:36.022
<v Sameer Kanal>It would be automatic sunset provisions would apply, which we adopted last year.

1329
02:35:36.136 --> 02:35:36.379
<v Brian Hughes>Thank you.

1330
02:35:37.954 --> 02:35:38.726
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman.

1331
02:35:42.164 --> 02:35:44.236
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it— I can hold questions.

1332
02:35:44.510 --> 02:35:48.578
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that let's let the public stuff come out, and then I think we'll have a larger discussion.

1333
02:35:48.627 --> 02:35:52.497
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've got a lot of questions, but I think I'd rather hear from the public first.

1334
02:35:52.561 --> 02:35:52.885
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1335
02:35:53.594 --> 02:35:55.997
<v Steve Novick>All right, move on to public testimony.

1336
02:35:56.997 --> 02:35:57.385
<v Rachael Fetters>Thank you.

1337
02:35:57.706 --> 02:35:59.200
<v Rachael Fetters>I will call folks up in groups of 3.

1338
02:35:59.409 --> 02:36:04.841
<v Rachael Fetters>For those testifying in person, you'll see a timer countdown displayed on the monitor in front of the testimony table.

1339
02:36:05.338 --> 02:36:08.537
<v Rachael Fetters>For those testifying virtually, the timer is displayed in Zoom.

1340
02:36:08.953 --> 02:36:10.706
<v Rachael Fetters>You will hear the timer chime twice.

1341
02:36:11.203 --> 02:36:15.414
<v Rachael Fetters>Once is a warning when 30 seconds are left, and the second time when your time is up.

1342
02:36:15.863 --> 02:36:19.029
<v Rachael Fetters>Finally, before you begin, please state your name for the record.

1343
02:36:19.237 --> 02:36:19.592
<v Rachael Fetters>Thank you.

1344
02:36:20.620 --> 02:36:28.897
<v Rachael Fetters>First up, we have, uh, Jennifer Lucht, followed by Henry Fields and Yelena Belikova.

1345
02:36:32.808 --> 02:36:34.601
<v Rachael Fetters>And you can start whenever you get to the table.

1346
02:36:34.907 --> 02:36:35.280
<v April Roa>Thank you.

1347
02:36:40.965 --> 02:36:44.876
<v Jennifer Lucht>Hello, very grateful for all of you and, um, grateful for the time today.

1348
02:36:45.733 --> 02:36:47.350
<v Jennifer Lucht>Um, hi, my name is Jennifer Lucht.

1349
02:36:47.915 --> 02:36:55.550
<v Jennifer Lucht>I'm a District 3 resident, a decolonial community psychologist Communications strategist, and a PhD candidate.

1350
02:36:56.225 --> 02:37:07.255
<v Jennifer Lucht>My research focuses on the benefits of psychedelic plants and fungi for healing and how communities can leverage public health initiatives to reduce harm and create safety for individuals and collective healing.

1351
02:37:08.265 --> 02:37:16.122
<v Jennifer Lucht>In my personal journey with natural psychedelics, these medicines have helped me heal from depression and anxiety when pharmaceutical interventions wouldn't work.

1352
02:37:16.924 --> 02:37:21.605
<v Jennifer Lucht>In my family and my community, I've seen psychedelics save lives and end cycles of addiction.

1353
02:37:22.536 --> 02:37:28.434
<v Jennifer Lucht>I can confidently say that there are people in my life that would not be here today if it weren't for these natural medicines.

1354
02:37:29.493 --> 02:37:37.570
<v Jennifer Lucht>They have impacted me so much so that 6 years ago I decided to shift careers to work in this space and went back to school to get my master's in psychology.

1355
02:37:38.790 --> 02:37:56.897
<v Jennifer Lucht>As a state-trained psychedelic facilitator, I've experienced firsthand how community-led education on safety, preparation, and integration can protect community members and how we can provide them with the information and support they need to safely navigate these experiences with natural psychedelic medicines.

1356
02:37:57.730 --> 02:38:04.920
<v Jennifer Lucht>For many Portlanders, it can be difficult to find the information and support they need out of fear of retaliation or prosecution.

1357
02:38:06.397 --> 02:38:17.165
<v Jennifer Lucht>We must all accept that both regulated and non-regulated substance use exists, exists in our society, and we should choose to minimize the harmful effects rather than simply ignore or condemn them.

1358
02:38:18.256 --> 02:38:31.533
<v Jennifer Lucht>When we accept that non-commercial personal use of these substances exists in our city and work to promote education and safety, we create more protections for folks and position communities as the experts of their own healing.

1359
02:38:32.706 --> 02:38:53.316
<v Jennifer Lucht>The public education components of this policy allow us to tap into both traditional knowledge and modern research around these natural medicines, relying on the cross-cultural communities that have been intentionally working with these substances practices, some for hundreds of thousands of years, positioning Portland as a leader in safe psychedelic policy that meets community members where they're at.

1360
02:38:54.551 --> 02:38:58.692
<v Jennifer Lucht>This policy allows us to codify a cultural, cultural norm that already exists in this city.

1361
02:38:59.351 --> 02:39:09.043
<v Jennifer Lucht>By creating more education and safety around these medicines, we are listening to some of our Portland community's real needs and prioritizing quality of individual and community well-being.

1362
02:39:09.942 --> 02:39:12.029
<v Jennifer Lucht>This is why The council should vote yes.

1363
02:39:12.694 --> 02:39:13.149
<v Jennifer Lucht>Thank you again.

1364
02:39:18.461 --> 02:39:19.242
<v Rachael Fetters>Uh, Henry's online.

1365
02:39:19.338 --> 02:39:21.028
<v Rachael Fetters>Henry, you can unmute and begin your testimony.

1366
02:39:27.513 --> 02:39:29.000
<v Henry Fields>Hi, councilors and chair.

1367
02:39:29.518 --> 02:39:31.441
<v Henry Fields>My name is Henry Fields.

1368
02:39:31.700 --> 02:39:32.735
<v Henry Fields>Uh, thank you for your time.

1369
02:39:33.640 --> 02:39:36.788
<v Henry Fields>I am a licensed psilocybin facilitator in Oregon.

1370
02:39:37.628 --> 02:39:48.271
<v Henry Fields>Um, I found that that substance was extremely useful for helping me with my personal addiction as well as depression.

1371
02:39:49.105 --> 02:40:01.484
<v Henry Fields>And I'm a spiritual seeker, so whatever that is that you want to name when people truly ask to be connected in that way, I found that psilocybin was extremely useful in that.

1372
02:40:02.672 --> 02:40:18.439
<v Henry Fields>I'm also a steward of an access fund called the Inward Dive Fund, which is directed to work with the formerly incarcerated and the population that's affected by the stress and trauma from dealing with your criminal justice system.

1373
02:40:18.503 --> 02:40:23.415
<v Henry Fields>So namely formerly incarcerated, but also family members and advocates in the space.

1374
02:40:23.704 --> 02:40:29.148
<v Henry Fields>So I help educate about the efficacy of psilocybin as well as remove the financial barrier.

1375
02:40:29.727 --> 02:40:36.379
<v Henry Fields>Um, what I will say is that in speaking to that population, there are 2 energies.

1376
02:40:36.652 --> 02:40:54.215
<v Henry Fields>One is of really rapt attention and curiosity about using it in a healing way, and the other is just fear, uh, just fear of anything to do with drug, drug laws, sentencing.

1377
02:40:55.468 --> 02:41:15.164
<v Henry Fields>So I found that speaking about a legal framework, it's starting to soften some of that apprehension in a population that really could be serviced by using the substance is starting to change their relationship to how they think about it.

1378
02:41:15.760 --> 02:41:41.128
<v Henry Fields>So a measure that's being considered today Hi.

1379
02:41:41.370 --> 02:41:41.824
<v Yelena Belikova>Good morning.

1380
02:41:42.423 --> 02:41:43.668
<v Yelena Belikova>My name is Yelena Belikova.

1381
02:41:43.718 --> 02:41:48.005
<v Yelena Belikova>I'm a District 1 resident here today in support of the ordinance you have before you.

1382
02:41:48.792 --> 02:41:52.871
<v Yelena Belikova>For more than a decade, I carried a depression so heavy I did not believe I would survive it.

1383
02:41:53.707 --> 02:42:02.795
<v Yelena Belikova>I came to this country 10 years old with my family, but with no one to help me navigate the language or the country or the inside of my own head after a series of traumatic events.

1384
02:42:03.565 --> 02:42:06.165
<v Yelena Belikova>Asking another human being for help did not feel safe.

1385
02:42:06.872 --> 02:42:08.847
<v Yelena Belikova>Naturally occurring psychedelics saved my life.

1386
02:42:09.699 --> 02:42:12.075
<v Yelena Belikova>Psychedelics were a resource when no other resource was available.

1387
02:42:13.896 --> 02:42:14.769
<v Yelena Belikova>Thank you.

1388
02:42:15.512 --> 02:42:22.798
<v Yelena Belikova>Psychedelics are how I learned to trust a person enough to ask for help, to find a therapist, a doctor, and community.

1389
02:42:23.522 --> 02:42:26.081
<v Yelena Belikova>I'm standing here today because of natural psychedelics.

1390
02:42:26.885 --> 02:42:30.152
<v Yelena Belikova>For a long time, I was afraid to say that out loud, and I'm not the only one.

1391
02:42:30.971 --> 02:42:36.185
<v Yelena Belikova>There are people in this room, people in your districts who have a story like mine who will never tell it.

1392
02:42:36.879 --> 02:42:41.213
<v Yelena Belikova>Some are afraid of their doctor, their employer, their family, and law enforcement.

1393
02:42:41.855 --> 02:42:49.290
<v Yelena Belikova>And some are afraid of the medicine itself because they have been told their whole lives that the thing that could save them is dangerous, criminal, and shameful.

1394
02:42:49.819 --> 02:42:53.031
<v Yelena Belikova>So they go through it alone, and the people who could help them never hear them.

1395
02:42:54.283 --> 02:43:00.851
<v Yelena Belikova>You have already heard what the ordinance does and does not do, and I'm here to tell you what real healing work looks like when people are not afraid.

1396
02:43:01.524 --> 02:43:03.772
<v Yelena Belikova>It looks like being able to say out loud what helped you.

1397
02:43:04.254 --> 02:43:07.257
<v Yelena Belikova>It looks like a community that can support someone through a hard process.

1398
02:43:08.109 --> 02:43:11.479
<v Yelena Belikova>It looks like doing the deepest work of your life without having to hide it.

1399
02:43:12.282 --> 02:43:18.400
<v Yelena Belikova>Portlanders are already doing this work, and right now, without clear education, they do it with less support and more risk.

1400
02:43:19.011 --> 02:43:21.869
<v Yelena Belikova>This ordinance lets them do it safely and without fear.

1401
02:43:22.880 --> 02:43:24.132
<v Yelena Belikova>That is psychological safety.

1402
02:43:24.630 --> 02:43:25.497
<v Yelena Belikova>That is public health.

1403
02:43:25.691 --> 02:43:26.862
<v Yelena Belikova>And that is public safety.

1404
02:43:27.601 --> 02:43:30.212
<v Yelena Belikova>That is how people like me stay Stop healing in silence.

1405
02:43:30.537 --> 02:43:36.076
<v Yelena Belikova>I'm asking this committee to vote yes so more Portland residents get to heal out loud safely.

1406
02:43:36.742 --> 02:43:37.147
<v Yelena Belikova>Thank you.

1407
02:43:39.665 --> 02:43:43.907
<v Rachael Fetters>Next we have Peggy Parks, Sarah Honeycutt, and Stephen Maris.

1408
02:43:59.369 --> 02:44:00.807
<v Peggy Parks>Good afternoon, Council.

1409
02:44:02.277 --> 02:44:03.424
<v Peggy Parks>My name is Peggy Parks.

1410
02:44:04.377 --> 02:44:10.460
<v Peggy Parks>I am a Portland resident, a senior citizen, and a volunteer with the Portland Psychedelic Society.

1411
02:44:11.304 --> 02:44:14.889
<v Peggy Parks>Thank you for the opportunity to share my perspective today with you.

1412
02:44:16.505 --> 02:44:19.737
<v Peggy Parks>My first experience with psychedelics was when I was 19 years old.

1413
02:44:20.683 --> 02:44:24.888
<v Peggy Parks>That experience was not recreational in the way many people imagine.

1414
02:44:25.818 --> 02:44:30.522
<v Peggy Parks>It was profound, deeply meaningful, and spiritual.

1415
02:44:31.756 --> 02:44:38.882
<v Peggy Parks>It gave me a sense of connection to other people, to nature, and to something larger than myself.

1416
02:44:40.183 --> 02:44:46.136
<v Peggy Parks>More than 50 years later, I still remember it as one of the most significant experiences of my life.

1417
02:44:46.200 --> 02:44:46.408
<v Peggy Parks>Thank you.

1418
02:44:47.605 --> 02:45:03.558
<v Peggy Parks>At 77 years old, I've watched our understanding of these substances evolve over nearly 6 decades, and I believe it is time for our policies to reflect both the evidence and the lived experience of responsible adults.

1419
02:45:04.922 --> 02:45:15.263
<v Peggy Parks>Like many people of my generation, I grew up through the decades of the war on drugs, when discussion of psychedelics was largely replaced by fear and stigma.

1420
02:45:16.531 --> 02:45:22.707
<v Peggy Parks>Yet in recent years, research and personal experience have encouraged many of us to take a second look.

1421
02:45:23.989 --> 02:45:28.112
<v Peggy Parks>As a senior, I have seen growing interest among older adults.

1422
02:45:29.122 --> 02:45:36.597
<v Peggy Parks>Many people my age are facing grief, loss, serious illness, and questions about aging and mortality.

1423
02:45:37.865 --> 02:45:49.443
<v Peggy Parks>Author and journalist Michael Pollan has written that psychedelic experiences can help people see death, quote, not as a wall but as a horizon, unquote.

1424
02:45:50.310 --> 02:45:52.834
<v Peggy Parks>That simple idea resonates deeply with me.

1425
02:45:54.263 --> 02:46:07.551
<v Peggy Parks>Many seniors are seeking greater peace, connection, and acceptance as they navigate the later chapters of life, and for some, psychedelic experiences may offer a meaningful path toward those goals.

1426
02:46:07.600 --> 02:46:07.777
<v Peggy Parks>Thank you.

1427
02:46:09.108 --> 02:46:12.201
<v Peggy Parks>This measure is not about encouraging use.

1428
02:46:13.050 --> 02:46:18.342
<v Peggy Parks>It's about prioritizing education, safety, and sensible law enforcement.

1429
02:46:19.302 --> 02:46:26.806
<v Peggy Parks>It allows our community to focus resources where they are most needed while reducing the harms that can come from criminalization.

1430
02:46:27.863 --> 02:46:30.203
<v Peggy Parks>I respectfully ask you to support this measure.

1431
02:46:31.069 --> 02:46:49.604
<v Sarah Honeycutt>Thank you for your time, your service to Portland, Chair Novak, Vice Chair Morello, and members of the committee.

1432
02:46:51.719 --> 02:46:53.005
<v Sarah Honeycutt>My name is Sarah Honeycutt.

1433
02:46:53.263 --> 02:47:09.560
<v Sarah Honeycutt>I'm a District 3 resident, a licensed psilocybin facilitator, and the lead of something called Soul Liberation Fund, which is a scholarship program for folks who have experienced houselessness and addiction to receive psilocybin services.

1434
02:47:12.402 --> 02:47:19.090
<v Sarah Honeycutt>At 13, I was shunned, uh, excuse me, from my fundamentalist community.

1435
02:47:19.349 --> 02:47:24.555
<v Sarah Honeycutt>By 10th grade, I was out of school at my parents' home with very little direction or support.

1436
02:47:25.804 --> 02:47:33.922
<v Sarah Honeycutt>The stories from the pulpit were clear about what happened to people like me: abandonment by family, addiction, and jail.

1437
02:47:34.375 --> 02:47:36.936
<v Sarah Honeycutt>My lived experience includes all of that.

1438
02:47:37.838 --> 02:47:47.921
<v Sarah Honeycutt>I'm here today without shame largely because of the healing and self-acceptance that I've found through plant-based psychedelics.

1439
02:47:48.986 --> 02:47:58.393
<v Sarah Honeycutt>I went on to earn a master's degree in economics and have supported the development of some of the world's largest utility-scale renewable energy.

1440
02:48:01.039 --> 02:48:12.265
<v Sarah Honeycutt>Someone who witnessed my journey donated funds to create that scholarship program for others who struggled with addiction and homelessness because they saw what was possible.

1441
02:48:13.724 --> 02:48:30.790
<v Sarah Honeycutt>These medicines are a miracle for the plant medicine was part of my path back.

1442
02:48:31.829 --> 02:48:42.068
<v Sarah Honeycutt>My clients in the Oregon's regulated psilocybin model aren't just seeking a substance, they're seeking what I needed too, which is connection and community.

1443
02:48:42.138 --> 02:48:42.260
<v Sarah Honeycutt>Thank you.

1444
02:48:42.461 --> 02:48:43.152
<v Sarah Honeycutt>And community.

1445
02:48:44.067 --> 02:48:55.354
<v Sarah Honeycutt>These medicines carry a low likelihood of harm to self, others, and addiction, and that is based on peer-reviewed scientific studies.

1446
02:48:56.271 --> 02:48:57.586
<v Sarah Honeycutt>I came up in the rave scene.

1447
02:48:58.117 --> 02:49:01.055
<v Sarah Honeycutt>I witnessed its beauty and its underbelly.

1448
02:49:01.793 --> 02:49:03.914
<v Sarah Honeycutt>I also lost friends along the way.

1449
02:49:04.941 --> 02:49:10.935
<v Sarah Honeycutt>Much of that harm was compounded by secrecy because telling the truth had legal consequences.

1450
02:49:11.675 --> 02:49:16.406
<v Sarah Honeycutt>It stayed hidden and people suffered for it, and I suffered for it.

1451
02:49:17.459 --> 02:49:27.090
<v Sarah Honeycutt>Real equity is looking around and seeing who is at the table, who isn't at the table and doesn't have the resources, and then doing the work to change that.

1452
02:49:28.592 --> 02:49:31.433
<v Sarah Honeycutt>You have the chance to be a part of history today.

1453
02:49:31.980 --> 02:49:45.051
<v Sarah Honeycutt>Help make it safer for our lights to shine so that those of us who have found our way back can become beacons for those who are still lost.

1454
02:49:45.870 --> 02:49:46.656
<v Sarah Honeycutt>Please vote yes.

1455
02:49:55.550 --> 02:49:56.147
<v Stephen Maris>Good afternoon.

1456
02:49:57.067 --> 02:49:58.165
<v Stephen Maris>My name is Stephen Maris.

1457
02:49:58.456 --> 02:50:03.253
<v Stephen Maris>I've lived in the Portland area for roughly half my life, work as a CPA.

1458
02:50:04.708 --> 02:50:15.040
<v Stephen Maris>I care about this ordinance because I've had the personal benefit from working with natural psychedelic medicines within cultures where it's intertwined and ingrained in both personal and community healing.

1459
02:50:17.148 --> 02:50:18.664
<v Stephen Maris>My story is a fairly common one.

1460
02:50:19.018 --> 02:50:23.145
<v Stephen Maris>I quit drinking and was looking for a better way, a better path forward.

1461
02:50:23.611 --> 02:50:26.158
<v Stephen Maris>I wanted to be a better parent, better son.

1462
02:50:29.415 --> 02:50:32.371
<v Stephen Maris>I started with ketamine-assisted psychotherapy in Portland.

1463
02:50:33.480 --> 02:50:42.617
<v Stephen Maris>In addition to— in addition to this, I was seeking to experience other psychedelics and within cultures that have long traditions of knowledge passed down through the generations.

1464
02:50:43.932 --> 02:50:45.815
<v Stephen Maris>This path led me to Mexico and Peru.

1465
02:50:46.432 --> 02:50:49.790
<v Stephen Maris>My life has been impacted profoundly and changed for the better.

1466
02:50:51.452 --> 02:50:53.340
<v Stephen Maris>It's been around 6 years since my last drink.

1467
02:50:53.388 --> 02:50:53.698
<v Stephen Maris>I'm sorry.

1468
02:50:53.923 --> 02:50:57.237
<v Stephen Maris>And I credit in part my work with the natural psychedelics for this.

1469
02:50:59.382 --> 02:51:16.997
<v Stephen Maris>While I've also participated in the Measure 109 regulated framework for psilocybin, I've been able to firsthand see how community and culture can pass on these traditions, practices, and knowledge to access, access the healing potential of psychedelics, to access it in a safe way.

1470
02:51:18.665 --> 02:51:30.799
<v Stephen Maris>I also know there would be some in Portland that may not have the time or the money I thank you for your time and hope you'll vote yes for a couple reasons.

1471
02:51:32.190 --> 02:51:33.889
<v Stephen Maris>First, psychedelics may not be for everyone.

1472
02:51:34.930 --> 02:51:38.409
<v Stephen Maris>They also may not be a cure-all, but they are a beautiful medicine.

1473
02:51:39.430 --> 02:51:45.360
<v Stephen Maris>Second, the people of Portland deserve the potential for healing and the autonomy to explore their consciousness.

1474
02:51:46.030 --> 02:51:47.969
<v Stephen Maris>They deserve this without the fear of being labeled crazy or dangerous.

1475
02:51:47.969 --> 02:51:48.010
<v Stephen Maris>Thank you.

1476
02:51:53.121 --> 02:51:53.507
<v Stephen Maris>Thank you.

1477
02:51:56.500 --> 02:51:58.735
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1478
02:51:59.233 --> 02:52:00.406
<v Rachael Fetters>And that concludes testimony.

1479
02:52:03.340 --> 02:52:06.175
<v Steve Novick>All right, Councilor Zimmerman, you had a whole raft of questions.

1480
02:52:06.242 --> 02:52:06.917
<v Steve Novick>Want to start asking them?

1481
02:52:10.188 --> 02:52:15.390
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, I won't make any assumptions that we're going to get through this since it's only 13 minutes to the end.

1482
02:52:15.521 --> 02:52:29.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, so, um, let's— if we wouldn't mind, I'll start with a couple, and I know there are others, but, um, with the invited testimony, Nathan and others, and Mac, you can just come on up.

1483
02:52:29.552 --> 02:52:52.055
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I want to, with respect to psychedelics, are there Is there any evidence about a physical addiction as it relates to psychedelics?

1484
02:52:55.479 --> 02:52:59.058
<v Max Kellerman>Well, yeah, there's evidence that it's low risk of addiction.

1485
02:52:59.270 --> 02:52:59.807
<v Max Kellerman>Low risk?

1486
02:52:59.905 --> 02:53:00.653
<v Max Kellerman>Very low risk.

1487
02:53:01.471 --> 02:53:09.882
<v Max Kellerman>There is a chart that does a risk profile of addiction for common substances, alcohol being number one.

1488
02:53:10.299 --> 02:53:10.442
<v Max Kellerman>Okay.

1489
02:53:11.149 --> 02:53:13.397
<v Max Kellerman>Psilocybin pretty much at the very bottom.

1490
02:53:13.815 --> 02:53:13.992
<v Max Kellerman>Okay.

1491
02:53:14.281 --> 02:53:14.634
<v Max Kellerman>And so—.

1492
02:53:14.859 --> 02:53:16.817
<v Eric Zimmerman>What other kind of things are up near alcohol?

1493
02:53:17.652 --> 02:53:23.496
<v Max Kellerman>Uh, fentanyl, heroin, opioids, um, even cannabis is above psilocybin.

1494
02:53:24.493 --> 02:53:26.243
<v Nate Howard>Caffeine's kind of high up there, unfortunately.

1495
02:53:26.484 --> 02:53:27.237
<v Nate Howard>You know, risk profile—.

1496
02:53:27.237 --> 02:53:27.656
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll admit.

1497
02:53:28.009 --> 02:53:28.522
<v Max Kellerman>Risk profile.

1498
02:53:28.666 --> 02:53:29.068
<v Henry Fields>Yeah, me too.

1499
02:53:29.148 --> 02:53:30.095
<v Nate Howard>Yeah, it's my main drug.

1500
02:53:30.272 --> 02:53:33.756
<v Nate Howard>Risk profile is different than addiction, but, but in terms of addiction, they're up there.

1501
02:53:34.753 --> 02:53:49.195
<v Nate Howard>What we're talking about As close as it is responsible to— you can't say non-addictive because like caffeine, food, but it's almost— it's as far away as you can almost get, uh, natural psychedelics.

1502
02:53:49.277 --> 02:53:49.373
<v Nick McDonald>Yeah.

1503
02:53:49.519 --> 02:53:49.615
<v Henry Fields>Yeah.

1504
02:53:49.777 --> 02:53:51.180
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm going to ask a lot of questions.

1505
02:53:51.228 --> 02:53:55.763
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if you're a member of the media, I would encourage you to really lock in now, right?

1506
02:53:55.891 --> 02:53:59.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>In terms of it— there's a responsibility to cover this the right way.

1507
02:53:59.700 --> 02:54:05.613
<v Eric Zimmerman>So not just my questions but others, because headline media on this type of topic won't do us any good.

1508
02:54:05.806 --> 02:54:15.261
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, for bringing a little levity, I thought that the first time that I'd only heard the word fentanyl was in the current era.

1509
02:54:15.917 --> 02:54:16.976
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm a fan of The Office.

1510
02:54:17.745 --> 02:54:26.990
<v Eric Zimmerman>It turns out that there's an episode where Creed talks about fentanyl in the hospital as a thing that was, that was given to a person for pain.

1511
02:54:27.584 --> 02:54:27.921
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1512
02:54:28.867 --> 02:54:29.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>You live and learn.

1513
02:54:29.685 --> 02:54:35.306
<v Eric Zimmerman>I didn't realize, right, that fentanyl— until the last few years, I didn't realize it was actually a drug that wasn't just a street drug.

1514
02:54:36.284 --> 02:54:38.997
<v Eric Zimmerman>So you mentioned natural psychedelics.

1515
02:54:40.058 --> 02:54:47.748
<v Eric Zimmerman>Our country is going through a hell right now because of a synthetic adaptation to fentanyl that has hit our streets.

1516
02:54:47.813 --> 02:54:50.527
<v Eric Zimmerman>We still use the word fentanyl, but it's obviously something else.

1517
02:54:51.538 --> 02:55:03.469
<v Eric Zimmerman>So can you talk a little bit about your emphasis that I see time and time again with the word natural psychedelics and what your aim is with that word in front of the word psychedelics.

1518
02:55:04.014 --> 02:55:07.235
<v Max Kellerman>Yeah, these simply grow from nature, right?

1519
02:55:07.619 --> 02:55:12.250
<v Max Kellerman>It's a fungi or a plant, so there's no processing or minimal processing.

1520
02:55:12.345 --> 02:55:14.059
<v Max Kellerman>There's no chemistry involved.

1521
02:55:14.108 --> 02:55:21.060
<v Max Kellerman>It's literally taking what nature grows naturally and letting it dry so it can be easy to store and consume.

1522
02:55:21.734 --> 02:55:23.144
<v Max Kellerman>That's as simple as that.

1523
02:55:23.239 --> 02:55:30.120
<v Max Kellerman>And that's why we want to emphasize natural, because of It's accessible for folks to do this on their own.

1524
02:55:30.231 --> 02:55:37.474
<v Max Kellerman>There's no degrees in chemistry or any processes they need to learn beyond just learning how to store plants, essentially.

1525
02:55:38.020 --> 02:55:38.436
<v Todd Deweese>Okay.

1526
02:55:39.304 --> 02:55:44.281
<v Nate Howard>Can I underscore the natural— to Max's point, means grows out of the ground.

1527
02:55:44.361 --> 02:55:45.679
<v Nate Howard>So what do we picture here?

1528
02:55:45.887 --> 02:55:53.433
<v Nate Howard>Picture a cactus, like literally one of the cactuses that people used to call wachuma, which we also call San Pedro.

1529
02:55:53.656 --> 02:55:55.852
<v Nate Howard>You can find them at some hardware stores like Home Depot.

1530
02:55:55.997 --> 02:56:06.353
<v Nate Howard>And if you have a lot, it produces mescaline, the same active ingredient that's found in peyote, which different native folks on this continent had used for likely millennia, best we can tell.

1531
02:56:07.122 --> 02:56:15.490
<v Nate Howard>And so mushrooms, cactuses— I would love a bunch of visual aids, you know, because it's like pretty, you know, it's like beautiful plants.

1532
02:56:15.539 --> 02:56:18.328
<v Eric Zimmerman>We continue this conversation, I might actually ask you to bring those.

1533
02:56:18.842 --> 02:56:19.259
<v Nate Howard>Yeah.

1534
02:56:20.592 --> 02:56:27.156
<v Nate Howard>And so the reason we say natural too is because there are synthetic psychedelics, which are incredible.

1535
02:56:27.509 --> 02:56:33.736
<v Nate Howard>And, and some of these things are the reason that we just had that excellent executive order from the Oval Office.

1536
02:56:35.037 --> 02:56:38.534
<v Nate Howard>And those things have higher risk profiles than what we're talking about.

1537
02:56:38.744 --> 02:56:41.039
<v Nate Howard>Still non-addictive, but have higher risk profiles.

1538
02:56:41.457 --> 02:56:44.264
<v Nate Howard>What we're talking about have as close to little risk profile as possible.

1539
02:56:48.079 --> 02:56:53.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm going to— since there are only 7 minutes, I'm going to go ahead and reserve.

1540
02:56:53.690 --> 02:57:00.370
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know there are a few other people in the queue, but I do take your commitment to continuing this with another meeting because I think this will be a robust conversation.

1541
02:57:00.870 --> 02:57:02.040
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you, guys.

1542
02:57:02.729 --> 02:57:04.930
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Smith.

1543
02:57:04.930 --> 02:57:06.709
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

1544
02:57:06.709 --> 02:57:10.500
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you all for coming and giving us a presentation.

1545
02:57:10.500 --> 02:57:10.700
<v Loretta Smith>I think it's very important that we have this conversation.

1546
02:57:11.389 --> 02:57:21.968
<v Loretta Smith>Is this by accident that we don't have any additional mainstream healthcare providers and/or anyone from the public safety service area?

1547
02:57:23.920 --> 02:57:24.597
<v Max Kellerman>By accident?

1548
02:57:25.759 --> 02:57:26.404
<v Nate Howard>Like speaking today?

1549
02:57:28.219 --> 02:57:28.949
<v Nate Howard>No, no accident.

1550
02:57:30.034 --> 02:57:31.865
<v Loretta Smith>It was, it was on purpose.

1551
02:57:33.179 --> 02:57:34.977
<v Nate Howard>Well, no intention applied.

1552
02:57:35.058 --> 02:57:40.462
<v Nate Howard>There are members of our group We have a group in our committee who are members of public safety and are healthcare professionals.

1553
02:57:40.736 --> 02:57:42.913
<v Nate Howard>Some folks are here and most people are not.

1554
02:57:43.171 --> 02:57:45.218
<v Loretta Smith>So I guess I should be more specific.

1555
02:57:45.930 --> 02:57:47.075
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1556
02:57:47.254 --> 02:57:50.290
<v Loretta Smith>Is there anyone from Multnomah County who does mental health?

1557
02:57:50.404 --> 02:58:01.606
<v Loretta Smith>Is there anyone from our public safety service area who could also offer some remarks on this?

1558
02:58:01.927 --> 02:58:21.338
<v Loretta Smith>Because I'll tell you what I'm trying to figure out, and I know nothing about So if I understand this correctly, the psychedelics, right, they're banned by federal, state, and local law at this point?

1559
02:58:21.498 --> 02:58:24.860
<v Max Kellerman>With the exclusion of psilocybin at the state level here in Oregon.

1560
02:58:25.340 --> 02:58:30.760
<v Max Kellerman>There is a department of OHA, the Oregon Health Authority, called the Oregon Psilocybin Services Program, which is a federally licensed program.

1561
02:58:30.842 --> 02:58:34.903
<v Max Kellerman>Which was created through that Measure 109 in 2020 and began.

1562
02:58:35.576 --> 02:58:43.056
<v Max Kellerman>And in fact, the Oregon Health Authority just released their— it's a 4-year plan.

1563
02:58:43.103 --> 02:58:45.799
<v Max Kellerman>It's called their State Health Improvement Plan.

1564
02:58:46.153 --> 02:58:56.472
<v Max Kellerman>And included in that, it's a whole list of health improvement plans, but they've included the destigmatization of psilocybin as part of that 4-year priority plan.

1565
02:58:57.083 --> 02:59:01.915
<v Max Kellerman>And so they're very much engaged with this topic as well, but it's at the state level.

1566
02:59:02.045 --> 02:59:03.120
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1567
02:59:03.264 --> 02:59:07.808
<v Loretta Smith>And Mr. Howard, you had said earlier that you've been working on this for 6 years.

1568
02:59:08.387 --> 02:59:13.059
<v Loretta Smith>Were you talking about working within City Hall to try to get this passed?

1569
02:59:13.605 --> 02:59:17.218
<v Loretta Smith>With— you were getting pushback, that's why it hadn't passed in the past?

1570
02:59:18.423 --> 02:59:23.038
<v Nate Howard>I would say less pushback and more just a lot of conversation about why this why is it important?

1571
02:59:23.102 --> 02:59:25.981
<v Nate Howard>We have so many other issues, you know, build more housing.

1572
02:59:26.322 --> 02:59:43.735
<v Nate Howard>And really the reason why it's moved this slowly, and we've worked on versions of this that have passed in other cities, Seattle included, is largely because the 2 sponsors at the time weren't reelected when we changed forms of government.

1573
02:59:43.879 --> 02:59:45.638
<v Nate Howard>And so we restarted and we essentially pushed pause.

1574
02:59:46.799 --> 02:59:47.331
<v Nate Howard>So pushback.

1575
02:59:48.319 --> 02:59:51.965
<v Loretta Smith>So they obviously couldn't get 3 votes at the previous council for this.

1576
02:59:53.345 --> 02:59:53.859
<v Nick McDonald>There was a—.

1577
02:59:54.100 --> 02:59:59.559
<v Nate Howard>There was a— as close to as a 3-vote, maybe more, but not a consensus that it was the right time to bring it forth.

1578
02:59:59.639 --> 03:00:04.682
<v Loretta Smith>So you couldn't get 3 votes at that time to do it?

1579
03:00:05.501 --> 03:00:08.583
<v Loretta Smith>Because that's like most anything, um, it's, it's timing.

1580
03:00:09.016 --> 03:00:12.757
<v Loretta Smith>Things are timing, and you have 12 new fresh ears.

1581
03:00:13.418 --> 03:00:16.983
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, to listen to this, but I want to— I'm trying to get, get someplace.

1582
03:00:17.226 --> 03:00:19.316
<v Loretta Smith>Um, thank you, officer.

1583
03:00:21.000 --> 03:00:21.435
<v Brian Hughes>Hi, Councilor.

1584
03:00:21.501 --> 03:00:23.102
<v Brian Hughes>For the record, Deputy Chief Brian Hughes.

1585
03:00:23.781 --> 03:00:24.202
<v Loretta Smith>How are you?

1586
03:00:24.251 --> 03:00:24.915
<v Loretta Smith>Good, thank you.

1587
03:00:25.140 --> 03:00:25.707
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1588
03:00:26.225 --> 03:00:31.333
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm trying to figure out what this ordinance is actually solving for.

1589
03:00:32.493 --> 03:00:49.141
<v Brian Hughes>Is there a, um, a rise of police activity So, Councilor, no, there is not a rise in enforcement on psychedelics at this time.

1590
03:00:49.737 --> 03:00:59.870
<v Brian Hughes>And I just want to echo that we have been briefed in by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's staff on the ordinance and consulted on it.

1591
03:01:00.791 --> 03:01:08.282
<v Brian Hughes>And I think where you were going earlier about the issues around state law, there are still some right.

1592
03:01:08.427 --> 03:01:10.153
<v Brian Hughes>And being scheduled.

1593
03:01:10.797 --> 03:01:18.355
<v Brian Hughes>So for that reason, I believe at this point the police bureau's stance on this would have to be neutral.

1594
03:01:19.147 --> 03:01:19.358
<v Brian Hughes>Okay.

1595
03:01:19.809 --> 03:01:20.504
<v Brian Hughes>But, you know—.

1596
03:01:20.537 --> 03:01:21.620
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I'm trying to find out.

1597
03:01:21.814 --> 03:01:21.990
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1598
03:01:22.557 --> 03:01:42.389
<v Loretta Smith>If any of you have watched me before, whether it be the mask ban or other things, I'm really concerned about if we We are breaking the law, uh, state, federal, if we are being constitutional and unconstitutional by putting things forward.

1599
03:01:43.212 --> 03:02:15.891
<v Loretta Smith>And if this is something— and I, and I did see your stuff, Mr. Howard, of other places in Colorado that have done this, and I'm trying to figure out, and I'm trying to figure out if, if we're on the right side of this if this is the right place for this to start now, and considering this is a huge healthcare issue, because I've— I listened to a lot of the comments, and the young lady said that she had tried everything, and then she got assessed and she started taking the psychedelics.

1600
03:02:15.940 --> 03:02:21.703
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'm— if this is illegal, how can you refer people to this if this is an illegal substance?

1601
03:02:21.753 --> 03:02:21.944
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1602
03:02:23.068 --> 03:02:26.843
<v Loretta Smith>And I, I, because I couldn't ask her any further questions, I, I didn't.

1603
03:02:26.923 --> 03:02:34.452
<v Loretta Smith>But I'm trying to figure out how are people learning about this or even its use if it is an illegal substance.

1604
03:02:34.870 --> 03:02:43.605
<v Loretta Smith>I, I don't do any of this stuff, so I don't know how folks get it or how folks are, are told to use it because it's good for medical reasons.

1605
03:02:44.119 --> 03:02:46.704
<v Loretta Smith>But I'm just trying to figure out how are they evaluating that.

1606
03:02:46.833 --> 03:02:52.347
<v Loretta Smith>Is there some medical data that's out there that we can look to?

1607
03:02:52.736 --> 03:03:00.752
<v Loretta Smith>Is there something in Multnomah County that we can look to to say this is why they're being referred to this for a reason?

1608
03:03:02.488 --> 03:03:04.094
<v Loretta Smith>So, Mr.

1609
03:03:04.144 --> 03:03:07.486
<v Nate Howard>Howard, uh, the answer is yes, we can supply that.

1610
03:03:07.838 --> 03:03:10.361
<v Nate Howard>And there's really outstanding questions.

1611
03:03:10.409 --> 03:03:11.084
<v Nate Howard>There's a few in there.

1612
03:03:11.614 --> 03:03:26.309
<v Nate Howard>I would say that, uh, like headline answer Or to the degree there's a through line there, is individuals are finding— this is the personal use component— this cacti or mushrooms essentially through friends and family.

1613
03:03:27.438 --> 03:03:32.691
<v Nate Howard>And there is, what is it, 56 years since the Scheduling Act began, the drug war.

1614
03:03:32.853 --> 03:03:32.950
<v Nate Howard>Right.

1615
03:03:33.015 --> 03:03:39.266
<v Nate Howard>The government had its own evidence, its own studies saying some of these things were nontoxic and as close to nonaddictive as possible.

1616
03:03:45.724 --> 03:03:45.836
<v Nate Howard>Right.

1617
03:03:46.094 --> 03:03:53.337
<v Nate Howard>And then the guy who crafted that in the Oval Office was caught on tape saying, we did that to, quote, control hippies and Black folks.

1618
03:03:53.515 --> 03:03:59.316
<v Nate Howard>And so there's a through line of not having— like, the science is on our side, but the government is not caught up.

1619
03:03:59.495 --> 03:04:05.362
<v Nate Howard>And so it is increasingly seen to be the most compelling treatment for people with PTSD.

1620
03:04:09.547 --> 03:04:10.193
<v Nate Howard>Right.

1621
03:04:11.100 --> 03:04:14.123
<v Nate Howard>And they're getting it through friends and family.

1622
03:04:14.236 --> 03:04:25.140
<v Nate Howard>And so Henry, who talked earlier, who I work with closely, the 20-person retreat that we're putting on next month is all with folks, folks who were previously incarcerated or justice-impacted, meaning they had friends or family who served time.

1623
03:04:25.674 --> 03:04:29.993
<v Nate Howard>And those are all people who've found it through word of mouth and are coming here to Oregon for that.

1624
03:04:30.283 --> 03:04:30.915
<v Max Kellerman>Can, can I add to that?

1625
03:04:31.010 --> 03:04:32.968
<v Loretta Smith>I just have one last question.

1626
03:04:33.032 --> 03:04:36.405
<v Loretta Smith>So here's what I'm concerned about, um, Chief.

1627
03:04:37.368 --> 03:04:58.104
<v Loretta Smith>I'm concerned if we pass something like this and say, okay, police are no longer going to— um, this is going to be a low priority, that it's going to cause— it's going to be opening up the floodgates where it's going to give people the, um, the encouragement to do more.

1628
03:04:58.588 --> 03:05:18.036
<v Loretta Smith>And that's what I'm concerned about, particularly since I don't have the medical data that backs up the use that, that people are— and, and I don't doubt that people are being treated for mental health issues and other things, and that they're— and that it has helped them because they're testifying to that.

1629
03:05:18.149 --> 03:05:20.440
<v Loretta Smith>I have no other reason to believe than what they say.

1630
03:05:20.992 --> 03:05:30.802
<v Loretta Smith>But I'm are you concerned that there's going to be a— if they know the police are going to turn their head about something, are you concerned about that?

1631
03:05:31.718 --> 03:05:34.238
<v Steve Novick>And I just need to add, we're at time.

1632
03:05:34.479 --> 03:05:39.569
<v Steve Novick>So Chief Hughes, if you'd answer that quickly, and then Councilor Kanal had something you wanted to put on the record, and then we'll draw to a close.

1633
03:05:39.906 --> 03:05:46.328
<v Brian Hughes>Yes, Councilor, I can assure you that as it stands right now, this is already a low priority for the Police Bureau.

1634
03:05:46.665 --> 03:05:48.158
<v Brian Hughes>I don't have the statistics on the seizures.

1635
03:05:48.798 --> 03:05:59.292
<v Brian Hughes>But it's a pretty low priority at this time, and I can assure you that going forward, the direction will be in alignment with the ordinance that it remain a low priority for enforcement.

1636
03:05:59.615 --> 03:06:02.801
<v Loretta Smith>And if it is such a low priority now, why do we need an ordinance?

1637
03:06:05.760 --> 03:06:07.257
<v Nate Howard>Do you want— I'd love to answer that.

1638
03:06:07.307 --> 03:06:10.966
<v Nate Howard>So when we're talking about psychological safety and codifying cultural norms—.

1639
03:06:11.013 --> 03:06:13.045
<v Steve Novick>I'm sorry, we need to cut this off.

1640
03:06:13.270 --> 03:06:14.369
<v Stephen Maris>Councilor Thank you.

1641
03:06:14.496 --> 03:06:18.770
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll just put this on the record very briefly because I think we don't have time to talk about it.

1642
03:06:18.915 --> 03:06:25.740
<v Sameer Kanal>I worked in advisory bodies, I staffed them for a couple years, uh, and this is where— why the level of importance I'm going to give to this comment.

1643
03:06:26.222 --> 03:06:44.058
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, I am very interested in the, the reasoning for this, very supportive broadly at this moment, though I want to get more information about the ordinance and about Exhibit A. I have lots and lots of concerns about Exhibit B, and my vote will probably be contingent on whether or not we can resolve those, uh, in the next, uh, round of this.

1644
03:06:44.218 --> 03:06:53.000
<v Sameer Kanal>I do not want to set, uh, volunteers up to fail, and I am— the way it's written right now, I think that's the best-case scenario in the creation of the, of the advisory body.

1645
03:06:53.112 --> 03:06:53.369
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1646
03:06:54.298 --> 03:06:55.004
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, everybody.

1647
03:06:55.435 --> 03:06:57.246
<v Steve Novick>And we'll continue this conversation at a later meeting.

1648
03:06:57.343 --> 03:07:00.531
<v Steve Novick>And now the— this meeting of the Committee and Public Safety Committee is adjourned.

1649
03:07:01.829 --> 03:07:02.359
<v Nate Howard>Thank you, everybody.

1650
03:07:02.406 --> 03:07:02.904
<v Todd Deweese>That was fun.

1651
03:07:03.128 --> 03:07:03.416
<v Jahad Hudson>Thank you.

1652
03:07:03.465 --> 03:07:04.586
<v Nate Howard>Appreciate it.

1653
03:07:04.635 --> 03:07:04.890
<v Christopher>Thank you.

