WEBVTT

1
00:04:57.209 --> 00:04:57.769
<v Andrew Fortgang>Good morning.

2
00:04:58.329 --> 00:05:01.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm now calling to order this meeting of the Portland City Council.

3
00:05:03.050 --> 00:05:04.089
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call the roll?

4
00:05:05.689 --> 00:05:07.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh wait, before we do that, I lied.

5
00:05:08.410 --> 00:05:09.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>We actually have a pre-gavel.

6
00:05:09.910 --> 00:05:11.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm, I'm taking back my gavel.

7
00:05:11.910 --> 00:05:12.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>That didn't happen.

8
00:05:12.550 --> 00:05:13.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>No one heard that happen.

9
00:05:13.829 --> 00:05:17.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have a pre-gavel, uh, recognition of the, uh, Vanport Day of Remembrance.

10
00:05:17.990 --> 00:05:19.589
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm turning this over to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

11
00:05:19.910 --> 00:05:20.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

12
00:05:22.149 --> 00:05:29.910
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, today our pre-gavel is, um, about Vanport Day of Remembrance, which is on May 30th.

13
00:05:30.310 --> 00:05:40.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, but as folks who are following the work of Vanport Mosaic know, the Honoring, remembrance, and celebration has been going on all week.

14
00:05:41.990 --> 00:06:07.850
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are doing this pre-gavel as the, as the work continues in community so that we remind our city of this part of our history, so that we don't forget the racist policies that forced Black Portlanders to live only in limited parts of our city where they often faced the the most environmental risk, and as we saw with Vanport floods, the most harm.

15
00:06:08.970 --> 00:06:18.569
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our city was unwilling to invest in risk prevention for entire groups of our community, and that's something that we must do better on today.

16
00:06:19.610 --> 00:06:22.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This pre-gavel, though, is not just a reminder of the harm.

17
00:06:23.370 --> 00:06:33.129
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is also a reminder of the incredible culture that flourishes when people have the space to build community when people are able to come together.

18
00:06:34.089 --> 00:06:47.490
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the lasting cultural impacts from Vanport on our city should continue to be acknowledged, and we must remember that that is tied to the opportunity of community being able to come together.

19
00:06:48.329 --> 00:06:50.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Vanport is not just history.

20
00:06:51.129 --> 00:07:01.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The descendants of Vanport are a part of our community today one of our speakers today, LaVeda Gilmore-Jones, is a descendant of Vanport.

21
00:07:02.629 --> 00:07:12.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to turn over the floor to Laura Loforte with Vanport Mosaic and LaVeda Gilmore-Jones to share with us a little bit more.

22
00:07:13.110 --> 00:07:15.910
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both for being here today and being a part of our work.

23
00:07:27.199 --> 00:07:28.160
<v Laura Loforte>Good morning, everyone.

24
00:07:28.800 --> 00:07:33.120
<v Laura Loforte>Thank you so much for having us, and thank you so much for the beautiful words that you shared.

25
00:07:33.920 --> 00:07:36.079
<v Laura Loforte>That's truly the heart of our work.

26
00:07:37.040 --> 00:07:39.360
<v Laura Loforte>MPOL Mosaic is a memory activism platform.

27
00:07:40.160 --> 00:07:57.689
<v Laura Loforte>We amplify, honor, preserve, and present the many silenced histories of our city and region, and we do it So that we can understand why we got here, we better understand our present, and we can imagine a new story for all of us, one where we all belong and thrive.

28
00:07:58.329 --> 00:08:00.730
<v Laura Loforte>And we do so with oral history first and foremost.

29
00:08:01.290 --> 00:08:09.930
<v Laura Loforte>We build the largest archive of personal memories of life in Vanport, the tragic day of the flood, and its aftermath.

30
00:08:10.170 --> 00:08:13.529
<v Laura Loforte>Like you said, the Vanport story is not a story of the past.

31
00:08:15.209 --> 00:08:22.310
<v Laura Loforte>And personally, I came to Portland in 2014, and I've been receiving the gift of these stories since then.

32
00:08:23.110 --> 00:08:26.790
<v Laura Loforte>And that is why Vanport— that's why Portland is my home.

33
00:08:27.189 --> 00:08:33.590
<v Laura Loforte>It is because of this beautiful community and the lessons of solidarity, resistance, and strength.

34
00:08:34.230 --> 00:08:37.830
<v Laura Loforte>And so since then, we've been telling story with and not the Vanport community.

35
00:08:38.389 --> 00:08:45.029
<v Laura Loforte>So I'm honored to be here with Lavita Gilmore-Jones, who is a descendant and truly a pillar of this work.

36
00:08:46.149 --> 00:08:47.029
<v Laura Loforte>Before I—.

37
00:08:47.659 --> 00:08:47.820
<v Laura Loforte>Thank you.

38
00:08:47.980 --> 00:08:51.259
<v Laura Loforte>I leave the microphone to Lavita.

39
00:08:51.340 --> 00:09:08.620
<v Laura Loforte>I do want to invite you to the next few events of the Vanport Mosaic Festival, which started on Friday with a beautiful concert from Maxfield to Vanport, and then the very special reunion of the Vanport community.

40
00:09:09.659 --> 00:09:19.580
<v Laura Loforte>Particularly, I want to invite you tonight at the screening of oral history, Lost City Living Memories: Vanport Through the Voices of Its Residents.

41
00:09:20.830 --> 00:09:21.870
<v Laura Loforte>And there are more events coming.

42
00:09:22.190 --> 00:09:30.830
<v Laura Loforte>The festival runs until the 31st, and you can go on our website to see what events are coming up, and they're all free or by donation.

43
00:09:33.230 --> 00:09:36.509
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Well, thank you so much for having us here today.

44
00:09:36.669 --> 00:09:38.429
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>My name is Lavita Gilmore-Jones.

45
00:09:39.389 --> 00:09:57.649
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>I was born here in Portland, Oregon, and I was born here because in 1944, my grandfather, my grandmother, my mom, aunt, and uncle came here to— and, uh, my grandparents came to work in the shipyards.

46
00:09:58.169 --> 00:10:16.929
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And, um, ironically, I honestly didn't hear about the story and the community and the people who lived in Vanport until— really, it didn't cement in my mind until my mom's 80th birthday.

47
00:10:17.690 --> 00:10:20.649
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And that was 57 years after the flood.

48
00:10:22.490 --> 00:10:33.450
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Now, for her, the, the memories came forth before that, but she really sat and shared them with us on her 80th birthday.

49
00:10:34.809 --> 00:10:39.370
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And I wondered, why did it take so long for that story to come forth?

50
00:10:40.330 --> 00:10:57.230
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And then I remembered, you know, when traumatic things happen to people, a lot of times we just We, we, we, we power through them, and then we just move on, and we don't stop to process it.

51
00:10:57.990 --> 00:11:27.610
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And so the Vanport Mosaic has given not only people like my mom and my aunt, but so many other people who lived in Vanport, the opportunity to come together and to remember, to remember the stories of joy, And also to remember the day when everything that they knew was washed away, and then when they were washed into Portland.

52
00:11:28.049 --> 00:11:38.090
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And remembering this also helps us remember what we as a city of Portland can do together.

53
00:11:38.370 --> 00:12:00.710
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Even though we had racist laws on the books, in the 1940s and '50s and '60s, we can come together and remember and try to undo and repair that which caused injustice at the time.

54
00:12:00.789 --> 00:12:04.710
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And so we do have a clip from my mom's story.

55
00:12:04.710 --> 00:12:09.669
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And the beauty of it is she was able to be in these chambers a few times.

56
00:12:09.990 --> 00:12:10.149
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Wow.

57
00:12:10.460 --> 00:12:11.659
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>For the proclamation.

58
00:12:11.740 --> 00:12:14.460
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>I know some of you, uh, remember her.

59
00:12:14.700 --> 00:12:17.179
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Uh, Dan, I know you remember her.

60
00:12:17.259 --> 00:12:22.700
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And so, uh, we're going to just share a little bit of her clip and her story of Vanport.

61
00:13:05.129 --> 00:13:05.769
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Technology, huh?

62
00:13:09.450 --> 00:13:11.529
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, let me, let me troubleshoot really quick.

63
00:13:12.649 --> 00:13:12.730
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

64
00:13:13.210 --> 00:13:14.169
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

65
00:13:14.330 --> 00:13:28.809
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And one thing I do want to say is this past, uh, Saturday we had a gathering of 60, about almost 70 people, descendants and, uh, former people who lived in Vanport.

66
00:13:29.450 --> 00:13:30.889
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And I wish you could have been there.

67
00:13:31.129 --> 00:13:41.350
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>It was such a beautiful sight to see our elders coming together, eating together, sharing stories together, laughing together.

68
00:13:41.669 --> 00:13:52.149
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>So, um, next year I can't invite you to the reunion unless you're a descendant, but I can invite you to come to some of the other events that we are having.

69
00:13:52.389 --> 00:13:53.110
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>So please do.

70
00:13:55.830 --> 00:13:56.830
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

71
00:14:29.490 --> 00:14:31.809
<v Bea Gilmore>I was in the theater with a bunch of other kids.

72
00:14:31.889 --> 00:14:33.330
<v Bea Gilmore>We were watching a movie.

73
00:14:33.570 --> 00:14:39.009
<v Bea Gilmore>All of a sudden, one kid came in, ran up to the front, and said the dike broke.

74
00:14:39.730 --> 00:14:42.409
<v Bea Gilmore>And so everybody ran out of the theater.

75
00:14:43.409 --> 00:14:52.929
<v Bea Gilmore>We lived within running distance of the theater, and we ran to— I ran to our house.

76
00:14:53.580 --> 00:14:58.700
<v Bea Gilmore>We tried to put some things together so we could get all in the car to get out.

77
00:14:58.940 --> 00:14:59.899
<v Bea Gilmore>The water was coming.

78
00:15:01.179 --> 00:15:02.940
<v Bea Gilmore>We were driving as fast as we could.

79
00:15:03.340 --> 00:15:07.419
<v Bea Gilmore>People were running and screaming and trying to keep up with their families and, where's my kid?

80
00:15:07.580 --> 00:15:10.019
<v Bea Gilmore>And everybody was taking care of each other.

81
00:15:10.940 --> 00:15:13.340
<v Bea Gilmore>When we got in the car, it was going up the hill.

82
00:15:13.740 --> 00:15:24.159
<v Bea Gilmore>I looked back and I saw a wall of water behind the car, and I realized how close we were to being washed away.

83
00:15:24.320 --> 00:15:27.759
<v Bea Gilmore>But we got up the hill and everybody was helping everybody.

84
00:15:27.919 --> 00:15:42.240
<v Bea Gilmore>I stood with a whole crowd of people looking at the flood just wash the units, the housing units up, and knowing that our possessions were gone.

85
00:15:45.039 --> 00:15:54.889
<v Bea Gilmore>Councilmember I didn't realize that we were homeless until later on in my life.

86
00:15:54.970 --> 00:15:57.929
<v Bea Gilmore>I looked back and I thought we were absolutely homeless.

87
00:15:59.049 --> 00:16:00.730
<v Bea Gilmore>We didn't have much of anything.

88
00:16:03.610 --> 00:16:06.809
<v Bea Gilmore>But the thing about it was people helped each other.

89
00:16:07.929 --> 00:16:08.889
<v Bea Gilmore>We knew each other.

90
00:16:09.210 --> 00:16:10.970
<v Bea Gilmore>They knew each other from being in the shipyards.

91
00:16:11.049 --> 00:16:11.210
<v Bea Gilmore>Thank you.

92
00:16:11.779 --> 00:16:21.539
<v Bea Gilmore>They knew each other from being in Vanport, living close together, because it was no other way you weren't— that you weren't going to know somebody.

93
00:16:33.779 --> 00:16:47.070
<v Bea Gilmore>By that time, I understood the really harsh segregation that was present in Oregon.

94
00:16:47.230 --> 00:16:57.070
<v Bea Gilmore>The contrast was that in Las Vegas, I felt that I could go into the store and buy things, any store.

95
00:16:57.549 --> 00:17:02.750
<v Bea Gilmore>There were stores that had signs in the doors, no Negroes served here.

96
00:17:03.159 --> 00:17:04.759
<v Bea Gilmore>I went in anyway.

97
00:17:05.000 --> 00:17:06.359
<v Bea Gilmore>They served me.

98
00:17:06.599 --> 00:17:13.039
<v Bea Gilmore>So I learned that if I challenged the system, I could probably make a difference.

99
00:17:13.319 --> 00:17:25.119
<v Bea Gilmore>And so I spent a lot of my time figuring out where I was gonna go to either challenge or just let things be.

100
00:17:25.400 --> 00:17:28.680
<v Bea Gilmore>And so that was a big job for me in Portland.

101
00:17:28.920 --> 00:17:29.160
<v Bea Gilmore>Thank you.

102
00:17:29.980 --> 00:17:33.500
<v Bea Gilmore>And whereas in Las Vegas, I didn't have to do that.

103
00:17:40.220 --> 00:17:46.700
<v Bea Gilmore>It really did throw me back to the flood, and I knew how helpless those people felt.

104
00:17:59.670 --> 00:18:11.829
<v Bea Gilmore>I think that was the first time I cried about what had happened to me, and I couldn't be there to help.

105
00:18:16.309 --> 00:18:29.519
<v Bea Gilmore>But I thought, here, this many years, have passed, and we're not taking care of them any better than they took care of the people in Vanport.

106
00:18:40.680 --> 00:18:56.430
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And so in the spirit of Bea Gilmore, today you will hear many things that come before you, and I encourage you to look at them and say, how can we challenge and how can we change?

107
00:18:57.029 --> 00:19:01.150
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>What do we need to challenge and what do we need to change?

108
00:19:02.789 --> 00:19:03.990
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Just a little note.

109
00:19:04.069 --> 00:19:24.839
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>My mom— got to say this, got to brag on her— she passed in December of 2021, but when she did pass she passed the way she wanted to because she was the first African American nurse to graduate from the Oregon Health Science Center in 1955.

110
00:19:25.000 --> 00:19:28.400
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And so she took charge of her medical.

111
00:19:29.160 --> 00:19:39.319
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>And so I challenge you, take charge of what you can take charge of, challenge what needs to be challenged, and change what you can change.

112
00:19:39.640 --> 00:19:39.880
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Thank you.

113
00:19:40.130 --> 00:19:40.450
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Thank you.

114
00:19:41.569 --> 00:19:41.809
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

115
00:19:42.930 --> 00:19:44.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both very much for being here.

116
00:19:50.289 --> 00:19:59.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if you want to leave the handouts about everything else happening this month, all of the other events— Keelan, do you want to hand those out to everybody?

117
00:19:59.890 --> 00:20:01.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that possible if we get them to you?

118
00:20:03.170 --> 00:20:03.730
<v Mikel Johnson>Okay, perfect.

119
00:20:04.609 --> 00:20:05.490
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both so much.

120
00:20:05.930 --> 00:20:07.049
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

121
00:20:07.210 --> 00:20:07.609
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

122
00:20:08.009 --> 00:20:13.049
<v Laura Loforte>And remember that we, we are remembering, uh, throughout the year.

123
00:20:13.130 --> 00:20:16.329
<v Laura Loforte>This is the moment of the festival, but the work is every day.

124
00:20:16.410 --> 00:20:17.049
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

125
00:20:17.210 --> 00:20:19.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much for being here today.

126
00:20:20.569 --> 00:20:26.650
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, with that, I am now calling to order the meeting of the Portland City Council.

127
00:20:26.890 --> 00:20:28.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can you please call the roll?

128
00:20:30.890 --> 00:20:31.369
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

129
00:20:31.880 --> 00:20:31.960
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

130
00:20:32.359 --> 00:20:32.920
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

131
00:20:33.319 --> 00:20:33.400
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

132
00:20:33.799 --> 00:20:33.880
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

133
00:20:34.359 --> 00:20:34.440
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

134
00:20:34.839 --> 00:20:35.160
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama-Lane?

135
00:20:35.480 --> 00:20:35.559
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

136
00:20:35.960 --> 00:20:36.200
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

137
00:20:36.759 --> 00:20:36.839
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

138
00:20:37.240 --> 00:20:37.559
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

139
00:20:38.039 --> 00:20:38.119
<v Steve Novick>Here.

140
00:20:38.519 --> 00:20:38.599
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

141
00:20:39.079 --> 00:20:39.160
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

142
00:20:39.559 --> 00:20:39.640
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

143
00:20:40.359 --> 00:20:40.440
<v Mitch Green>Here.

144
00:20:40.920 --> 00:20:41.319
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

145
00:20:41.559 --> 00:20:41.640
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

146
00:20:41.960 --> 00:20:42.960
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

147
00:20:43.880 --> 00:20:44.359
<v Keelan McClymont>Present virtually.

148
00:20:46.920 --> 00:20:47.000
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

149
00:20:47.720 --> 00:20:47.799
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

150
00:20:47.960 --> 00:20:48.359
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

151
00:20:48.440 --> 00:20:48.920
<v Tanisha Renee>Did you hear me?

152
00:20:49.480 --> 00:20:51.400
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh yes, Councilor Avalos, thank you.

153
00:20:52.680 --> 00:20:53.000
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

154
00:20:53.319 --> 00:20:54.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

155
00:20:55.000 --> 00:20:56.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>And could we please read the rules of decorum?

156
00:20:57.650 --> 00:20:58.210
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, good morning.

157
00:20:58.450 --> 00:20:59.490
<v Keelan McClymont>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

158
00:21:00.049 --> 00:21:05.450
<v Keelan McClymont>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

159
00:21:09.009 --> 00:21:11.650
<v Keelan McClymont>Information on engaging with council can be found at the council clerk's webpage.

160
00:21:12.529 --> 00:21:16.049
<v Keelan McClymont>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

161
00:21:16.609 --> 00:21:18.609
<v Keelan McClymont>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

162
00:21:19.250 --> 00:21:20.769
<v Keelan McClymont>The presiding officer preserves order.

163
00:21:21.410 --> 00:21:28.769
<v Keelan McClymont>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

164
00:21:29.630 --> 00:21:31.470
<v Keelan McClymont>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

165
00:21:31.950 --> 00:21:34.670
<v Keelan McClymont>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

166
00:21:35.470 --> 00:21:39.549
<v Keelan McClymont>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

167
00:21:39.630 --> 00:21:42.349
<v Keelan McClymont>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

168
00:21:43.309 --> 00:21:45.630
<v Keelan McClymont>Your testimony today should address the matter being considered.

169
00:21:46.190 --> 00:21:48.269
<v Keelan McClymont>When testifying, state your name for the record.

170
00:21:48.430 --> 00:21:50.349
<v Keelan McClymont>Your address is not necessary.

171
00:21:50.430 --> 00:21:53.630
<v Keelan McClymont>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

172
00:21:53.789 --> 00:21:56.269
<v Keelan McClymont>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

173
00:21:56.349 --> 00:21:57.230
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Council Clerk Rebecca Dobert.

174
00:21:58.589 --> 00:21:59.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

175
00:21:59.789 --> 00:22:06.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we have a very large agenda today, and we should all expect to be going until 1:30 rather than our normal 12:30 time.

176
00:22:07.549 --> 00:22:18.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I hope everybody's helped to get through a ton of second readings and some things that are relatively ministerial, including 3 items that were not heard at committee but are time sensitive from the administration.

177
00:22:18.190 --> 00:22:19.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so we will be hearing them directly.

178
00:22:20.029 --> 00:22:30.160
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will call those out when we get there, but I just want to note to my colleagues, it is not a precedent to bring things directly to councils, but the budget hearings and work sessions sort of screwed everything up.

179
00:22:30.240 --> 00:22:31.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>So those will be happening here.

180
00:22:32.000 --> 00:22:33.519
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our first item is the agenda approval.

181
00:22:33.680 --> 00:22:38.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any requests to amend the agenda to reorder items or reschedule items to a future reading?

182
00:22:42.880 --> 00:22:44.799
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, Council President.

183
00:22:45.359 --> 00:22:49.680
<v Loretta Smith>I'd like to reorder item number 17 and move that up.

184
00:22:50.160 --> 00:23:01.720
<v Loretta Smith>I do understand about the the administration, but those, um, pieces could have been amended back in January, February.

185
00:23:01.920 --> 00:23:09.440
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, I think this is so important to make sure that we hear these words, particularly after the Vanport, uh, pre-gavel.

186
00:23:09.599 --> 00:23:19.099
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, they've been waiting for months and months to get this, uh, on the agenda, and so it would be great if we could report the agenda and put them at the top.

187
00:23:19.420 --> 00:23:23.660
<v Jamie Dunphy>You'd like to hear them after the time certain or after the consent agenda?

188
00:23:23.980 --> 00:23:24.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>Where on the agenda?

189
00:23:25.019 --> 00:23:25.740
<v Loretta Smith>After the time certain.

190
00:23:26.460 --> 00:23:26.539
<v Bob Day>Okay.

191
00:23:27.339 --> 00:23:33.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith has moved to move item 17 to be heard between items 4 and 5.

192
00:23:33.819 --> 00:23:34.779
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that correct, Councilor?

193
00:23:35.019 --> 00:23:35.099
<v Lucy Olson>Yes.

194
00:23:35.900 --> 00:23:35.980
<v Bea Gilmore>Okay.

195
00:23:36.220 --> 00:23:36.460
<v Keelan McClymont>Second.

196
00:23:36.859 --> 00:23:41.140
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor— Vice President Clark has seconded.

197
00:23:44.220 --> 00:23:45.339
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm just reading my notes real quick.

198
00:23:45.579 --> 00:23:50.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, can we, uh, take a vote on the reordering of the agenda?

199
00:23:52.380 --> 00:23:52.539
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

200
00:23:53.019 --> 00:23:53.099
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

201
00:23:53.980 --> 00:23:54.460
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

202
00:23:54.700 --> 00:23:54.779
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

203
00:23:56.140 --> 00:23:56.220
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

204
00:23:56.619 --> 00:23:56.700
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

205
00:23:57.819 --> 00:23:58.299
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

206
00:23:58.539 --> 00:23:58.619
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

207
00:23:59.339 --> 00:23:59.660
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

208
00:24:00.140 --> 00:24:00.220
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

209
00:24:00.700 --> 00:24:00.940
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

210
00:24:01.420 --> 00:24:01.500
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

211
00:24:01.980 --> 00:24:02.059
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

212
00:24:02.539 --> 00:24:02.619
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

213
00:24:03.180 --> 00:24:03.259
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

214
00:24:03.660 --> 00:24:03.740
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

215
00:24:04.140 --> 00:24:04.460
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

216
00:24:04.700 --> 00:24:04.779
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

217
00:24:05.420 --> 00:24:05.500
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

218
00:24:06.940 --> 00:24:07.019
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

219
00:24:07.900 --> 00:24:07.980
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

220
00:24:08.539 --> 00:24:09.259
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

221
00:24:09.589 --> 00:24:09.829
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

222
00:24:10.309 --> 00:24:10.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

223
00:24:12.230 --> 00:24:16.230
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, the motion to reorder the agenda is approved with a vote of 12 ayes.

224
00:24:16.789 --> 00:24:21.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, do we need to do anything else on that, Keelan?

225
00:24:21.509 --> 00:24:21.589
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're—.

226
00:24:21.910 --> 00:24:22.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>Agenda's approved now, right?

227
00:24:23.190 --> 00:24:23.430
<v Keelan McClymont>We're good.

228
00:24:23.509 --> 00:24:23.750
<v Henry Sheffer>Do we—.

229
00:24:23.829 --> 00:24:24.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>Or do we— okay, there we go.

230
00:24:24.710 --> 00:24:27.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just want to make sure we didn't need a second vote on that, just verify.

231
00:24:27.430 --> 00:24:28.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you everybody.

232
00:24:28.630 --> 00:24:31.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, can we please move to public communications?

233
00:24:35.599 --> 00:24:37.519
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Karen Shirey.

234
00:24:41.680 --> 00:24:44.200
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm upstairs, so I got to come down.

235
00:24:55.039 --> 00:25:00.240
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, thank you, thank you.

236
00:25:44.259 --> 00:25:47.299
<v Karen Shirey>Sorry, I had to go sit upstairs for a few minutes.

237
00:25:47.460 --> 00:25:49.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>No problem, happy to wait for you.

238
00:25:49.299 --> 00:25:49.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

239
00:25:49.700 --> 00:25:51.380
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please introduce yourself for the record.

240
00:25:51.710 --> 00:25:52.029
<v Karen Shirey>Thank you.

241
00:25:52.190 --> 00:25:53.309
<v Angelita Morillo>My name is Karen Chi Ray.

242
00:25:53.710 --> 00:25:56.990
<v Karen Shirey>I am a business owner in District 4 and a resident in District 3.

243
00:25:58.190 --> 00:26:07.230
<v Karen Shirey>And today I was going to talk to you guys about using PSF money for police, but I mostly have, I guess, some questions.

244
00:26:07.630 --> 00:26:30.660
<v Karen Shirey>And I know you guys can't answer because we can't go back and forth, but, um, I'm just, I'm just curious if the Peacock people— do you guys just want lawlessness and/or, um, or— oh my God, I just lost the word— um, street justice instead of police.

245
00:26:30.859 --> 00:26:41.259
<v Karen Shirey>Because I don't think that's the way we should be running our city right now, um, with all the crime that's happening, with all the people getting hurt.

246
00:26:41.420 --> 00:26:42.940
<v Karen Shirey>I mean, you've seen the news.

247
00:26:43.200 --> 00:26:47.599
<v Karen Shirey>The lady that got bludgeoned, the guy that got shot in Southeast Portland.

248
00:26:47.759 --> 00:26:52.160
<v Karen Shirey>I mean, it just seems like it's just continual, you know?

249
00:26:52.400 --> 00:26:54.559
<v Karen Shirey>And like, I'm scared.

250
00:26:54.640 --> 00:26:56.880
<v Karen Shirey>I'm scared of owning a business downtown.

251
00:26:56.880 --> 00:27:00.240
<v Karen Shirey>I'm scared of owning a residence in Southeast Portland.

252
00:27:00.240 --> 00:27:03.079
<v Karen Shirey>You know, like, where can we go to feel safe?

253
00:27:03.279 --> 00:27:08.480
<v Karen Shirey>We can't go to libraries because the homeless are hanging out in front of the libraries doing their drugs.

254
00:27:09.210 --> 00:27:13.130
<v Karen Shirey>Potentially inside too, but I don't go inside, so I don't know.

255
00:27:14.490 --> 00:27:24.289
<v Karen Shirey>And then parks, you know, like homeless hanging out in parks doing their drugs, you know, having their weapons.

256
00:27:25.450 --> 00:27:34.009
<v Karen Shirey>And so I just like, it just amazes me how the police are not important in our city.

257
00:27:34.579 --> 00:27:48.500
<v Karen Shirey>You know, and they are, you know, I understand you guys don't like some of the things that they do, but, you know, there's good people that work for, for the police and they're trying to do a good thing.

258
00:27:49.140 --> 00:28:10.960
<v Karen Shirey>But when you stifle them and make it so that we don't have enough, which we haven't had enough for years, you know, like, what does that tell us as As citizens, you know, that we're not important enough to have law and order in our city, you know.

259
00:28:11.119 --> 00:28:16.240
<v Karen Shirey>And the fact that you guys can't come to an agreement, it's always a 6 and 6, you know.

260
00:28:17.359 --> 00:28:18.559
<v Karen Shirey>I have a magic 8-ball.

261
00:28:18.640 --> 00:28:22.720
<v Karen Shirey>Maybe this will be your, your deciding factor, you know.

262
00:28:23.680 --> 00:28:25.839
<v Karen Shirey>Do the 8-ball, you know.

263
00:28:26.240 --> 00:28:39.240
<v Karen Shirey>I, I think we need to change the charter to have maybe not 12 people, maybe 11 people, you know, or have the mayor or the city administrator help with making decisions, you know.

264
00:28:39.559 --> 00:28:50.200
<v Karen Shirey>But something needs to change because we're not safe and we won't be for a long time because more homeless people are not going to be housed anymore.

265
00:28:51.160 --> 00:28:55.480
<v Karen Shirey>More fees that you guys have are going to kick more people out of their residence.

266
00:28:57.720 --> 00:28:57.799
<v Keelan McClymont>Order.

267
00:28:58.700 --> 00:28:59.019
<v Karen Shirey>Thank you.

268
00:28:59.259 --> 00:28:59.900
<v Andrew Fortgang>Thank you very much.

269
00:29:01.980 --> 00:29:03.819
<v Keelan McClymont>Next, next up we have Fred Stewart.

270
00:29:14.539 --> 00:29:15.019
<v Keelan McClymont>Fred Stewart.

271
00:29:20.460 --> 00:29:23.220
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, next we have Michael Johnson.

272
00:29:35.750 --> 00:29:36.470
<v Mikel Johnson>Tatamewi.

273
00:29:36.549 --> 00:29:37.990
<v Mikel Johnson>Good morning, councilors.

274
00:29:38.230 --> 00:29:39.349
<v Mikel Johnson>My name is Michael Johnson.

275
00:29:39.910 --> 00:29:43.509
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, sorry, that's close.

276
00:29:43.829 --> 00:29:46.589
<v Michael Johnson>Hello, I'm Michael Johnson.

277
00:29:47.109 --> 00:29:49.109
<v Michael Johnson>I live in District 4 or 3.

278
00:29:49.940 --> 00:29:52.380
<v Michael Johnson>But I also lived all over the city.

279
00:29:52.900 --> 00:30:06.299
<v Michael Johnson>And with that said, is I'm a Portland Rip City Blazer fan, and I'm here to, uh, give some words of, uh, from others that's in our community.

280
00:30:07.460 --> 00:30:20.789
<v Michael Johnson>I'm gonna get back to the speech that I wrote, and it was hard to really stick to the piece that I wrote because As I got closer to the chambers, it started to change more and more.

281
00:30:20.869 --> 00:30:34.470
<v Michael Johnson>And so I had to deny my nature and become the big guy that can speak for others.

282
00:30:34.710 --> 00:30:35.990
<v Michael Johnson>And so here we go.

283
00:30:36.150 --> 00:30:46.490
<v Michael Johnson>Council members, my name is Michael Johnson, and I'm writing to express my belief and the transformative potential of our city.

284
00:30:46.730 --> 00:30:58.369
<v Michael Johnson>We stand at a moment where bold ideas, responsible planning, and community-centered leadership can shape the next generation of progress.

285
00:30:59.130 --> 00:31:11.049
<v Michael Johnson>Our residents deserve a city that invests in innovation, protects dignity in every person, and builds a system that works for all, not just for today, but for decades to come.

286
00:31:11.390 --> 00:31:21.750
<v Michael Johnson>I believe in, in a future where sustainability, economics, mobility, and public trust are not just aspirations but everyday realities.

287
00:31:22.430 --> 00:31:30.430
<v Michael Johnson>For example, the Blazers have hosted youth basketball clinics that brings kids together, encourage healthy activities.

288
00:31:30.589 --> 00:31:37.150
<v Michael Johnson>They also support the local charities and small businesses, which really strengthens the bond between the team and the city.

289
00:31:38.410 --> 00:31:41.930
<v Michael Johnson>Overall, their presence adds a lot of pride and unity to the community.

290
00:31:43.369 --> 00:31:48.490
<v Michael Johnson>Blazers are considered a big ticket to support, right along with the police department.

291
00:31:49.849 --> 00:31:52.250
<v Michael Johnson>We stand supporting both, absolutely.

292
00:31:53.609 --> 00:32:06.440
<v Michael Johnson>And that sense of pride in community is exactly why keeping the Blazers here benefits everyone and supporting them with the money that they need to, uh, establish a presence with the new ownership.

293
00:32:07.519 --> 00:32:18.079
<v Michael Johnson>And there's Blazers that have retired and there's current Blazers that are on the team that gets out in the community and reach out to hospitals, our youth, families, and so forth.

294
00:32:18.079 --> 00:32:36.519
<v Michael Johnson>And I've also had a privilege of receiving tickets from the Blazers and sharing those with folks that just got married, that is under the poverty level, got married, And then took those tickets that I gave them and went to a Blazer game and celebrated their honeymoon at the Blazers game.

295
00:32:36.599 --> 00:32:41.720
<v Michael Johnson>So it's really important that we support our Blazers team.

296
00:32:41.799 --> 00:32:45.000
<v Michael Johnson>I was asked to come down in my Blazer gear and so forth.

297
00:32:46.279 --> 00:32:54.200
<v Michael Johnson>So thank you, and I hope that we move forward as a city to be really enjoyable.

298
00:32:54.359 --> 00:32:54.519
<v Michael Johnson>Thank you.

299
00:32:54.599 --> 00:32:54.839
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

300
00:32:55.269 --> 00:32:55.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

301
00:33:01.829 --> 00:33:03.589
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, next up we have Tish Newby.

302
00:33:12.309 --> 00:33:13.430
<v Keelan McClymont>Tish Newby.

303
00:33:17.509 --> 00:33:18.910
<v Keelan McClymont>Edie Rogaway.

304
00:33:27.920 --> 00:33:29.720
<v Keelan McClymont>Edie Rogaway.

305
00:33:34.799 --> 00:33:38.279
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, the alternate, Kristen McLemore.

306
00:33:44.160 --> 00:33:45.920
<v Keelan McClymont>Kristen McLemore.

307
00:33:48.890 --> 00:33:50.809
<v Keelan McClymont>And then one last try, Fred Stewart.

308
00:33:53.769 --> 00:33:55.130
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, that completes communications.

309
00:33:55.690 --> 00:33:57.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you all very much for being here today.

310
00:33:58.490 --> 00:34:06.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, next on our agenda, I'm turning to our city administrator just to see if we have any updates on the, uh, status of the ongoing response to federal interventions in our city.

311
00:34:07.849 --> 00:34:08.650
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Council President.

312
00:34:09.130 --> 00:34:09.929
<v Jabril Willis>No new updates.

313
00:34:10.489 --> 00:34:15.840
<v Bob Day>Uh, we're still looking to hear back from the hearing officer on the 5th So we'll—.

314
00:34:16.079 --> 00:34:20.320
<v Keelan McClymont>Once we have that released, we'll have a new update for council.

315
00:34:20.480 --> 00:34:22.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, sir.

316
00:34:23.280 --> 00:34:28.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call item number 4?

317
00:34:28.719 --> 00:34:43.519
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, item 4, document 2026-177, create a sister city relationship between the City of Portland and the City of Lviv, Ukraine.

318
00:34:44.568 --> 00:34:50.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, today's ordinance is establishing a formal relationship between the City of Portland and the City of Lviv, Ukraine.

319
00:34:50.489 --> 00:34:54.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's also an affirmation of the original purpose behind the city's sister cities movement.

320
00:34:55.929 --> 00:35:10.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>At a time when cities increasingly play an important role in subnational diplomacy, climate cooperation, economic exchange, and humanitarian engagement, sister city relationships continue to serve as one of the most enduring forms of people-to-people diplomacy available to local governments.

321
00:35:11.579 --> 00:35:14.699
<v Jamie Dunphy>That mission remains just as relevant today, perhaps even more so.

322
00:35:15.739 --> 00:35:25.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uniquely, Portland's sister city network has been rooted in grassroots, community-driven structure supported by volunteers, cultural organizations, educational institutions, and residents themselves.

323
00:35:26.219 --> 00:35:29.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>That structure is what has made many of these relationships sustainable over generations.

324
00:35:30.380 --> 00:35:33.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>These relationships have never been simply symbolic.

325
00:35:33.500 --> 00:35:39.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>In fact, several of the Portland sister city relationships were established during periods of geopolitical tension or historical transition.

326
00:35:39.420 --> 00:35:40.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that's a great point.

327
00:35:41.079 --> 00:35:46.440
<v Jamie Dunphy>Historic, yeah, historical transition, when community members believed strongly that bridges needed to be built rather than walls.

328
00:35:47.400 --> 00:35:52.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today, by establishing a sister city relationship with Lviv, Portland continues that tradition.

329
00:35:53.239 --> 00:36:07.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lviv itself has a long— has long served as one of Ukraine's great cultural and educational centers, known for its historical architecture, civic resilience, vibrant arts community, and strong tradition of local democracy and European engagement.

330
00:36:07.829 --> 00:36:17.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>In recent years, the city has also played an important humanitarian role supporting internally displaced Ukrainians and coordinating relief and recovery efforts during an extraordinarily difficult period for the country.

331
00:36:18.309 --> 00:36:27.510
<v Jamie Dunphy>This ordinance recognizes that even during difficult global moments, cities still have the ability and responsibility to foster mutual understanding, human connection, and long-term partnerships.

332
00:36:28.150 --> 00:36:31.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, as a co-sponsor of this, I'd like to turn this over to you.

333
00:36:31.989 --> 00:36:32.789
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

334
00:36:32.949 --> 00:36:33.989
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks everyone for being here.

335
00:36:34.070 --> 00:36:34.789
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll keep it brief.

336
00:36:35.349 --> 00:36:44.050
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's fair to say that this is the next step naturally of a this is a process that began with the declaration of Lviv as a friendship city in 2022.

337
00:36:45.250 --> 00:36:49.809
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a 1-year period that's built into the process, which we are now a few years past.

338
00:36:50.849 --> 00:36:52.610
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think the people of Lviv have been waiting.

339
00:36:52.769 --> 00:36:59.570
<v Sameer Kanal>I think also the people here who've been supportive of this sister city relationship that we're hopefully going to create with this ordinance have been waiting as well.

340
00:37:00.849 --> 00:37:06.769
<v Sameer Kanal>Formalizing relationships as sister cities acknowledges work, goodwill, and personal and community ties that have already grown.

341
00:37:07.480 --> 00:37:09.159
<v Sameer Kanal>Within and between our communities.

342
00:37:09.880 --> 00:37:19.639
<v Sameer Kanal>They create opportunities for cultural exchange, economic collaboration, educational partnerships, tourism, and long-term cooperation between residents as well as civic organizations.

343
00:37:20.360 --> 00:37:33.340
<v Sameer Kanal>I think this is a program that we have underutilized over time, and I think it's a place that I'd like to see us push for more out of this process and out of this structure.

344
00:37:34.139 --> 00:37:49.980
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I also wanted to just thank Chito for, for your work on this and, and, um, the, the work of the, of the position as well, which is really vital to ensuring that we have, um, the ability to grow and develop relationships across and outside of the United States.

345
00:37:50.699 --> 00:37:58.940
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I also just wanted to note that our bonds with Lviv are deeper than the current political status or the current situation in Ukraine, the current war.

346
00:37:59.179 --> 00:38:01.500
<v Sameer Kanal>They're rooted in lasting cultural, civic, and personal connections.

347
00:38:07.010 --> 00:38:08.130
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Council President.

348
00:38:08.449 --> 00:38:17.250
<v Dan Ryan>When I first got the messages from all of you, it was about a month and a half ago, I was delighted to make sure that I raised this up so we could make sure this was on the agenda today.

349
00:38:17.329 --> 00:38:18.610
<v Dan Ryan>So it's really good to see all of you.

350
00:38:18.849 --> 00:38:19.889
<v Dan Ryan>I look forward to your presentation.

351
00:38:20.289 --> 00:38:20.369
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks.

352
00:38:22.130 --> 00:38:24.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, turn it over to our speakers here in a moment.

353
00:38:24.449 --> 00:38:26.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like to especially recognize Tatiana Turdal.

354
00:38:26.130 --> 00:38:27.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>I know she's been working really hard on this.

355
00:38:27.019 --> 00:38:28.219
<v Jamie Dunphy>I may have screwed up your last name.

356
00:38:28.300 --> 00:38:28.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>I apologize.

357
00:38:28.860 --> 00:38:32.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>For your extraordinary leadership, persistence, and community building through this effort.

358
00:38:32.780 --> 00:38:39.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>Tatiana has led the Portland-Lviv Friendship effort, wherein Portland established the Friendship City Association in September of 2022.

359
00:38:40.780 --> 00:38:44.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>Alongside Tatiana is also Chito Dlawayo.

360
00:38:44.860 --> 00:38:45.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Chito, I'm sorry about you.

361
00:38:45.820 --> 00:38:46.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>I screwed it up.

362
00:38:46.940 --> 00:38:55.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>But from our city's Office of Government Relations, Chito worked to help coordinate the formal sister city process and broader intergovernmental engagement associated with this effort.

363
00:38:55.989 --> 00:39:01.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Together, they'll provide an overview of how this partnership developed, the community effort behind it, and the vision for future collaboration.

364
00:39:01.349 --> 00:39:02.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please take it away.

365
00:39:02.309 --> 00:39:03.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for being here.

366
00:39:03.829 --> 00:39:04.230
<v Chido Delawayo>Thank you.

367
00:39:04.309 --> 00:39:06.869
<v Chido Delawayo>Good morning, Council President and members of council.

368
00:39:07.030 --> 00:39:14.230
<v Chido Delawayo>For the record, my name is Chido Delawayo, and I manage the International Relations Program within the city's Office of Government Relations.

369
00:39:14.469 --> 00:39:19.909
<v Chido Delawayo>Thank you, Council President Dunphy, Councilor Kanal, Councilor Ryan, for introducing this item today.

370
00:39:20.070 --> 00:39:33.800
<v Chido Delawayo>The goal of the International Relations Program is to strengthen Portland's engagement with the world through diplomacy, cultural exchange, economic relationship building, and people-to-people connections that ultimately benefit Portland residents.

371
00:39:35.079 --> 00:39:44.760
<v Chido Delawayo>And while this work certainly does not exist in a vacuum, a significant part of my role involves coordinating and responding to a wide range of international engagement requests and efforts.

372
00:39:45.880 --> 00:39:58.699
<v Chido Delawayo>One component of my work involves managing Portland's Sister Cities program and coordinating with the coalition of volunteer-led nonprofit organizations that sustain these relationships through sister cities.

373
00:39:59.219 --> 00:40:12.420
<v Chido Delawayo>As previously shared, Portland has a longstanding history of international engagement, and while sister city relationships are often viewed primarily through a cultural lens, their value extends much further.

374
00:40:12.739 --> 00:40:21.219
<v Chido Delawayo>Across the country, cities increasingly look to Portland's model because our relationships are community-driven and designed to endure beyond political cycles.

375
00:40:22.420 --> 00:40:29.219
<v Chido Delawayo>We also have seen how these relationships can create trust— trusted channels for collaboration during moments of challenge.

376
00:40:30.179 --> 00:40:41.340
<v Chido Delawayo>During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, our sister city of Kaohsiung, Taiwan helped facilitate the delivery of personal protective equipment to Portland during a period of critical shortages.

377
00:40:42.420 --> 00:40:47.380
<v Chido Delawayo>And so part of my role involves reviewing and vetting requests and proposals for new sister city relationships.

378
00:40:47.539 --> 00:40:47.780
<v Chido Delawayo>Thank you.

379
00:40:52.900 --> 00:41:07.340
<v Chido Delawayo>And under those criteria, organizations must demonstrate broad-based community support, nonprofit organizational capacity, financial sustainability, active programming, and an ability to sustain the relationship over time.

380
00:41:07.619 --> 00:41:13.460
<v Chido Delawayo>The process also requires a friendship city trial period to formal city— sister city designation.

381
00:41:14.599 --> 00:41:23.800
<v Chido Delawayo>Lviv is internationally recognized as a UNESCO City of Literature and is widely regarded as one of Eastern Europe's great cultural and intellectual centers.

382
00:41:25.000 --> 00:41:33.400
<v Chido Delawayo>Both of our cities share a strong tradition of creativity, civic engagement, independent culture, education, and public life.

383
00:41:34.519 --> 00:41:44.269
<v Chido Delawayo>Both communities also recognize the importance of the arts, creative economy, and essential components of sustainable urban development and civic identity.

384
00:41:44.789 --> 00:42:02.550
<v Chido Delawayo>Over the past year alone, the Portland-Lviv Friendship City Association has continued to deepen these ties through humanitarian fundraising efforts, medical aid support initiatives, educational exchanges, and public programming designed to raise awareness and maintain direct people-to-people connection between both communities.

385
00:42:03.670 --> 00:42:07.269
<v Chido Delawayo>And those efforts will be discussed in greater detail shortly by Tatiana.

386
00:42:08.420 --> 00:42:21.340
<v Chido Delawayo>And as mentioned, I do also wanna note that while Russia's invasion of Ukraine has understandably shaped the context of this relationship, the effort began years before the invasion and is rooted in genuine civic and community connection.

387
00:42:22.420 --> 00:42:49.690
<v Chido Delawayo>And so since that time of the friendship city status being formalized on September 28th, 2022 through Resolution 37588, The Portland-Lviv Friendship City Association has successfully fulfilled the requirements outlined under Ordinance 176047, which includes sustained programming, nonprofit governance, annual reporting, and demonstrated financial capacity necessary to support long-term relationships.

388
00:42:54.329 --> 00:43:10.750
<v Chido Delawayo>And so, you know, for decades, Tatiana has used her background in international economics her experience as a visiting professor at Ukrainian Catholic University in Lviv, and deep personal and professional ties to both communities to be a voice for Ukrainians here in Portland.

389
00:43:11.110 --> 00:43:20.909
<v Chido Delawayo>More recently, she has spent time in Lviv advocating and ensuring that Portland's solidarity with the Ukrainian people is not simply symbolic, but sustained and active.

390
00:43:21.429 --> 00:43:30.260
<v Chido Delawayo>I first met Tatiana in January of 2019 after she reached out to discuss the possibility of formalizing a sister city relationship between Portland and Lviv.

391
00:43:30.420 --> 00:43:37.059
<v Chido Delawayo>Since then, it has been an honor to witness Tatiana's leadership and steady work that has brought this initiative to where it is today.

392
00:43:37.139 --> 00:43:44.179
<v Chido Delawayo>And so I want to specifically acknowledge and thank Tatiana for her persistence, dedication, and long-term commitment to this effort.

393
00:43:44.420 --> 00:43:53.539
<v Chido Delawayo>Building a sister city relationship through Portland's process requires years of sustained community organizing, volunteer leadership, and institutional coordination.

394
00:43:53.750 --> 00:43:57.670
<v Chido Delawayo>And her commitment has been instrumental in bringing this initiative to this point.

395
00:43:57.670 --> 00:44:07.949
<v Chido Delawayo>It's now my pleasure to introduce Tatiana Jadal, President of the Portland-V Friendship City Association, who will provide additional background on this relationship and the work that has been undertaken.

396
00:44:08.710 --> 00:44:10.110
<v Tatiana Turdal>Thank you, Chida.

397
00:44:11.030 --> 00:44:11.750
<v Tatiana Turdal>Good morning.

398
00:44:13.269 --> 00:44:15.750
<v Tatiana Turdal>Thank you for considering this ordinance.

399
00:44:15.909 --> 00:44:20.869
<v Tatiana Turdal>I would like to— I have prepared a presentation with a number of slides.

400
00:44:20.869 --> 00:44:22.710
<v Tatiana Turdal>I don't know if they will be projected.

401
00:44:23.469 --> 00:44:36.349
<v Tatiana Turdal>Um, there is a presentation, but, um, I can start, uh, speaking to, um, to the presentation.

402
00:44:36.510 --> 00:44:38.030
<v Tatiana Turdal>So my name is Tatiana Turdal.

403
00:44:38.110 --> 00:44:42.190
<v Tatiana Turdal>I'm president of Portland-Lwów Friendship City Association.

404
00:44:42.429 --> 00:44:55.130
<v Tatiana Turdal>The mission of our organization is to promote strong ties between Portland, Oregon and Lwów, Ukraine through cultural exchanges, educational opportunities, business and humanitarian partnerships.

405
00:44:56.010 --> 00:44:59.769
<v Tatiana Turdal>So Lviv is a city in the western part of Ukraine.

406
00:45:01.130 --> 00:45:06.969
<v Tatiana Turdal>It's close to the Polish-Ukrainian border, just about 1 hour by car or train.

407
00:45:07.530 --> 00:45:09.289
<v Tatiana Turdal>So let's go to the next page.

408
00:45:09.289 --> 00:45:10.570
<v Tatiana Turdal>You can see a map of Europe.

409
00:45:12.010 --> 00:45:16.010
<v Tatiana Turdal>Yes, a map of Europe, and you can see where Lviv is located on the map of Europe.

410
00:45:17.019 --> 00:45:28.059
<v Tatiana Turdal>Just like every other old European city, it's gone through a long period of history being part of different kingdoms, republics, empires.

411
00:45:29.340 --> 00:45:40.380
<v Tatiana Turdal>It was founded in 1256 by the King of Galicia, Danylo Halytsky, and named in honor of his son Lev, which means lion in Ukrainian.

412
00:45:40.860 --> 00:45:45.860
<v Tatiana Turdal>So there are lions everywhere in Lviv, and it's known as the City of Lions.

413
00:45:46.019 --> 00:45:59.300
<v Tatiana Turdal>It started the 20th century as part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire and then started the 21st century as one of the major economic, political, educational centers of independent Ukraine.

414
00:45:59.460 --> 00:46:01.019
<v Tatiana Turdal>Next slide, please.

415
00:46:02.420 --> 00:46:03.219
<v Tatiana Turdal>Next slide, please.

416
00:46:03.300 --> 00:46:04.500
<v Tatiana Turdal>It's a very beautiful city.

417
00:46:04.739 --> 00:46:10.739
<v Tatiana Turdal>So these pictures are all the pictures that I took in Lviv in 2002, 2003, and 2004.

418
00:46:10.820 --> 00:46:11.059
<v Tatiana Turdal>Thank you.

419
00:46:11.320 --> 00:46:13.559
<v Tatiana Turdal>So you can see there are lines everywhere.

420
00:46:14.679 --> 00:46:15.719
<v Tatiana Turdal>There is wonderful food.

421
00:46:16.199 --> 00:46:21.719
<v Tatiana Turdal>So Lviv serves rose-infused coffee and rose-infused lemonade.

422
00:46:22.679 --> 00:46:33.840
<v Tatiana Turdal>It's a UNESCO World Heritage Site, and as Chita mentioned, a UNESCO City of Literature, part of UNESCO Creative Cities Network.

423
00:46:34.519 --> 00:46:42.719
<v Tatiana Turdal>It has one of the oldest universities in Eastern Europe, dating back to and in Ukraine, it's one of the IT hubs.

424
00:46:43.360 --> 00:46:51.440
<v Tatiana Turdal>The IT center, IT cluster in Lviv is so big that they have even their own mini football and futsal league.

425
00:46:51.679 --> 00:46:56.079
<v Tatiana Turdal>So IT companies play soccer tournaments among each other.

426
00:46:56.960 --> 00:46:57.599
<v Tatiana Turdal>Next slide, please.

427
00:46:59.039 --> 00:47:04.480
<v Tatiana Turdal>We've had many visitors from Portland going to Lviv and Lviv residents coming to Portland.

428
00:47:05.079 --> 00:47:12.599
<v Tatiana Turdal>And everybody who visits both cities comments on many similarities that exist between the cities.

429
00:47:12.679 --> 00:47:25.559
<v Tatiana Turdal>Even though we are 10 time zones away, we have joint coffee culture, book culture, sustainability, food culture, and definitely very strong arts.

430
00:47:25.880 --> 00:47:28.039
<v Tatiana Turdal>Next slide, please.

431
00:47:28.199 --> 00:47:32.280
<v Tatiana Turdal>Over the years, we've had delegations coming to Portland.

432
00:47:33.769 --> 00:47:38.889
<v Tatiana Turdal>From city government, Lviv city government, Lviv administration, Lviv region.

433
00:47:39.849 --> 00:47:45.530
<v Tatiana Turdal>In 2006, there was a group through State Department program on energy efficiency.

434
00:47:46.570 --> 00:47:49.050
<v Tatiana Turdal>In 2017, there was group on good governance.

435
00:47:50.170 --> 00:47:57.210
<v Tatiana Turdal>And people from those delegations expressed strong interest in creating formal ties between 2 cities.

436
00:47:57.530 --> 00:48:02.780
<v Tatiana Turdal>And our community maintained ties to members of those delegations.

437
00:48:03.019 --> 00:48:12.219
<v Tatiana Turdal>So on the picture is from 2023 at Lviv City Hall with one of the members of the 2017 delegation.

438
00:48:12.460 --> 00:48:13.420
<v Tatiana Turdal>Next slide, please.

439
00:48:13.579 --> 00:48:23.900
<v Tatiana Turdal>We also have a very large Ukrainian-American community here in Portland, Portland Metro, and many of them have ties, family, professional, to Lviv.

440
00:48:25.500 --> 00:48:29.539
<v Tatiana Turdal>For example, every year we have a Ukrainian Day Festival.

441
00:48:30.500 --> 00:48:36.739
<v Tatiana Turdal>This year it will be August 22nd at Westmoreland Park in Southeast Portland, and please everybody come.

442
00:48:37.460 --> 00:48:39.300
<v Tatiana Turdal>It's organized by Ukrainian Foundation.

443
00:48:40.099 --> 00:48:43.780
<v Tatiana Turdal>One of the leaders of the foundation is immigrant from Lviv.

444
00:48:44.739 --> 00:48:59.250
<v Tatiana Turdal>We have a lot of businesses that have roots in Lviv and Ukraine, so some of them you can tell from the name, like Ukrainian Ukrainian Federal Credit Union has Ukrainian in the name.

445
00:48:59.409 --> 00:49:08.289
<v Tatiana Turdal>But then when you think about Powell Books, you can't tell that it was started by first and second immigrants from Ukraine.

446
00:49:08.690 --> 00:49:12.489
<v Tatiana Turdal>Walter Powell's last name in Ukraine was Pavelko.

447
00:49:12.849 --> 00:49:16.570
<v Tatiana Turdal>So Walter Powell, Volodymyr Pavelko.

448
00:49:16.769 --> 00:49:20.530
<v Tatiana Turdal>In our community, we sometimes refer to Powell Books as Pavelko Books.

449
00:49:20.610 --> 00:49:20.849
<v Tatiana Turdal>Thank you.

450
00:49:22.139 --> 00:49:23.579
<v Tatiana Turdal>Next slide, please.

451
00:49:23.739 --> 00:49:28.539
<v Tatiana Turdal>We have also very talented artists as part of our community.

452
00:49:29.019 --> 00:49:39.260
<v Tatiana Turdal>We worked with one of them to create 30 different sketches of logos representing both of our cities, and I wanted to see— for you to see this creative process.

453
00:49:39.820 --> 00:49:59.420
<v Tatiana Turdal>And then we asked Portlanders who came to our events to choose their favorite one and worked with Lviv graphic designer to finalize this lion on a bicycle with roses representing both our city of love, our city of roses, and the city of lions.

454
00:50:00.460 --> 00:50:01.179
<v Tatiana Turdal>Next slide, please.

455
00:50:03.019 --> 00:50:05.739
<v Tatiana Turdal>During the year, we host many events.

456
00:50:06.699 --> 00:50:09.179
<v Tatiana Turdal>We are part of PSU's International Night.

457
00:50:10.059 --> 00:50:12.139
<v Tatiana Turdal>We host International Voshvanka Day.

458
00:50:12.860 --> 00:50:22.340
<v Tatiana Turdal>We've been walking for the last few years in the Grand Floral Parade, so you can see pictures of Randall here holding sunflowers in one of the recent parades.

459
00:50:23.139 --> 00:50:35.980
<v Tatiana Turdal>We've been having Coffee with Lviv, a direct link to Lviv from Just Bob, which is a great coffee house in Northeast Portland that serves Lviv latte.

460
00:50:36.260 --> 00:50:40.900
<v Tatiana Turdal>And we're also part of the internet— of the Ukrainian Day Festival.

461
00:50:40.980 --> 00:50:43.460
<v Tatiana Turdal>So definitely please come see us at the festival.

462
00:50:43.699 --> 00:50:44.019
<v Tatiana Turdal>Thank you.

463
00:50:44.449 --> 00:50:45.650
<v Tatiana Turdal>One, uh, next slide please.

464
00:50:46.050 --> 00:50:59.809
<v Tatiana Turdal>One of our programs that I want to highlight is New Europe Book Club, where we introduce Portlanders to books in English translation by Ukrainian and other authors from Eastern Europe.

465
00:50:59.969 --> 00:51:09.809
<v Tatiana Turdal>So we've read books by Polish, Czech, Ukrainian authors and been very fortunate to have live conversations with modern Ukrainian authors.

466
00:51:10.300 --> 00:51:12.860
<v Tatiana Turdal>Andrei Kulkov and we've also Natalia Matalinets.

467
00:51:13.900 --> 00:51:16.780
<v Tatiana Turdal>Next month we'll be talking, uh, to Akdam Chapai.

468
00:51:17.500 --> 00:51:24.860
<v Tatiana Turdal>Both of his books are at Multnomah County Library, so I encourage people to read them and join our live conversations.

469
00:51:26.059 --> 00:51:27.659
<v Tatiana Turdal>And then, um, next slide.

470
00:51:28.619 --> 00:51:30.699
<v Tatiana Turdal>Part of our mission is humanitarian partnership.

471
00:51:31.980 --> 00:51:44.219
<v Tatiana Turdal>In partnership with Medical Teams International, which is a great nonprofit based in Tigard, and with logistical support from Dawn, we sent a medical supply container to Ukraine.

472
00:51:44.460 --> 00:51:58.539
<v Tatiana Turdal>So 40-foot container filled with 1,200 boxes of medical supplies, and currently they're on a cargo ship going to a Baltic port, and from there will be taken by truck to Lviv.

473
00:51:59.179 --> 00:52:05.130
<v Tatiana Turdal>Artists from Portland who are part of our community have also traveled to Lviv for music festivals.

474
00:52:05.409 --> 00:52:14.210
<v Tatiana Turdal>And last year while they were there, they also gave a concert at Unbroken, just a free concert for people at the rehabilitation center.

475
00:52:14.210 --> 00:52:21.329
<v Tatiana Turdal>So just having, continuing those relationships between people of our cities.

476
00:52:21.570 --> 00:52:22.130
<v Tatiana Turdal>So next slide.

477
00:52:25.250 --> 00:52:30.449
<v Tatiana Turdal>Just saying thank you everybody who has been coming to our events, who have contributed.

478
00:52:30.860 --> 00:52:31.420
<v Tatiana Turdal>To our programs.

479
00:52:32.139 --> 00:52:33.260
<v Tatiana Turdal>And next slide.

480
00:52:33.340 --> 00:52:35.820
<v Tatiana Turdal>I encourage everybody to get involved.

481
00:52:36.059 --> 00:52:49.260
<v Tatiana Turdal>We have a Facebook page, we have a website, and you don't have to be part of the Ukrainian community to participate in our programs or be part of our organization.

482
00:52:49.420 --> 00:52:56.539
<v Tatiana Turdal>The majority of our board members don't have any connections to Ukraine or Lviv, don't speak Ukrainian.

483
00:52:57.320 --> 00:53:03.159
<v Tatiana Turdal>They just are interested in building these ties and learning more about Lviv and Ukraine.

484
00:53:03.239 --> 00:53:12.280
<v Tatiana Turdal>And I would like to thank Randall, who is one of our founding members, for being here and helping build the organization and the ties.

485
00:53:12.679 --> 00:53:16.840
<v Tatiana Turdal>And hopefully he has a few minutes to say something about Lviv.

486
00:53:17.400 --> 00:53:18.519
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, thanks, Tatiana.

487
00:53:18.679 --> 00:53:19.480
<v Randall Blaszczak>Okay, good morning.

488
00:53:19.480 --> 00:53:23.280
<v Randall Blaszczak>My name is Dr. Randall Blaszczak, and thanks for letting us make our Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

489
00:53:23.360 --> 00:53:24.000
<v Randall Blaszczak>Yes, sir.

490
00:53:24.239 --> 00:53:24.719
<v Randall Blaszczak>I have a case.

491
00:53:24.800 --> 00:53:32.639
<v Randall Blaszczak>Shortly after the full-scale invasion in February of 2022, I headed to the Poland-Ukraine border to do relief work.

492
00:53:34.480 --> 00:53:42.480
<v Randall Blaszczak>Lviv had become a city for people escaping the war in eastern Ukraine, so it became a sort of a hub of humanitarian aid.

493
00:53:43.199 --> 00:53:53.329
<v Randall Blaszczak>And I went into Lviv the first time bringing supplies in, bringing things for the internally displaced people.

494
00:53:53.650 --> 00:53:56.530
<v Randall Blaszczak>There may have been a drone or 2 stuck underneath those supplies.

495
00:53:56.769 --> 00:53:57.730
<v Randall Blaszczak>We won't talk about that.

496
00:53:58.929 --> 00:54:07.409
<v Randall Blaszczak>But I spent the night in a— and the first night I spent a night in a bomb shelter, and the word was out that there was this rumor that Lviv was kind of a coffee city.

497
00:54:07.570 --> 00:54:08.849
<v Randall Blaszczak>And I'm like, well, I'm from Portland.

498
00:54:09.090 --> 00:54:09.570
<v Randall Blaszczak>I don't know.

499
00:54:09.650 --> 00:54:10.929
<v Randall Blaszczak>You want to step up?

500
00:54:11.570 --> 00:54:18.780
<v Randall Blaszczak>So that morning I climbed out of the bomb shelter, and Lviv had just been hit for the first time by by Russian rockets, so the smoke was still in the air.

501
00:54:19.739 --> 00:54:27.739
<v Randall Blaszczak>And I was impressed by how the— how normal the city was, but also how much the city felt, looked like Portland.

502
00:54:28.139 --> 00:54:32.059
<v Randall Blaszczak>People on bikes, people in bookstores, people sitting in cafes in the middle of a war.

503
00:54:32.300 --> 00:54:39.179
<v Randall Blaszczak>I went and got a beautiful latte, learning that the person who invented the latte was actually from Lviv.

504
00:54:39.659 --> 00:54:40.460
<v Randall Blaszczak>So thank you.

505
00:54:40.940 --> 00:54:46.230
<v Randall Blaszczak>Starbucks should send him a a check, uh, and had a, had a nice latte.

506
00:54:46.309 --> 00:54:47.829
<v Randall Blaszczak>And I said, you know, I'm from Portland.

507
00:54:48.710 --> 00:54:51.269
<v Randall Blaszczak>And the barista said, what is a Portland?

508
00:54:51.510 --> 00:54:53.909
<v Randall Blaszczak>And I thought, okay, we've got some work to do here.

509
00:54:54.550 --> 00:55:01.349
<v Randall Blaszczak>Uh, but what it— what struck me was how similar Lviv was to Portland in its feel, in its literary feel, in its coffee culture.

510
00:55:01.829 --> 00:55:03.989
<v Randall Blaszczak>The only difference was it was constantly under attack.

511
00:55:04.150 --> 00:55:07.349
<v Randall Blaszczak>And it made me think, what would— what if Portland was experiencing that?

512
00:55:07.510 --> 00:55:12.039
<v Randall Blaszczak>What Portland had rockets coming and people being conscripted into battle?

513
00:55:12.360 --> 00:55:16.199
<v Randall Blaszczak>And, you know, what if Portland had suffered the same fate that Lviv had suffered?

514
00:55:16.519 --> 00:55:18.199
<v Randall Blaszczak>They were very, very similar cities.

515
00:55:18.519 --> 00:55:31.559
<v Randall Blaszczak>So returning from the— returning from that experience of being in a battle zone, I, I really began connecting with the large Ukrainian community here and finding ways to make a difference.

516
00:55:31.880 --> 00:55:58.769
<v Randall Blaszczak>And one of the ways was creating the Lviv Latte, which is at Just Bob's on Northeast Alberta and 24th, as a fundraiser for humanitarian aid, but also doing the work through our organization to get, uh, to get real meaningful aid to people, including, including the organization Unbroken that you heard about that supplies real important, uh, needs to people who have been the victims of war, not just the physical things like prosthetic limbs, but trauma care as well.

517
00:55:59.019 --> 00:56:09.980
<v Randall Blaszczak>And so it's been a great honor to do this and get to know the local Ukrainian community who is both long-lasting in this city, but also many new people who are here since the beginning of this war.

518
00:56:09.980 --> 00:56:16.059
<v Randall Blaszczak>And so that's why I really want to thank you for letting us build this relationship between our 2 great cities.

519
00:56:16.380 --> 00:56:19.099
<v Randall Blaszczak>They are so closely connected and this is a great way to do it.

520
00:56:19.179 --> 00:56:19.420
<v Randall Blaszczak>Thank you.

521
00:56:20.460 --> 00:56:22.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here today.

522
00:56:27.190 --> 00:56:28.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>That concludes the presentation?

523
00:56:28.389 --> 00:56:28.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Perfect.

524
00:56:28.789 --> 00:56:28.949
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

525
00:56:28.949 --> 00:56:30.070
<v Chido Delawayo>Yes, that concludes the presentation.

526
00:56:30.309 --> 00:56:30.550
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

527
00:56:30.789 --> 00:56:31.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

528
00:56:31.190 --> 00:56:33.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, is there anyone signed up for testimony on this item?

529
00:56:33.590 --> 00:56:34.710
<v Keelan McClymont>We have one person signed up.

530
00:56:34.949 --> 00:56:35.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's go ahead and call them up.

531
00:56:36.789 --> 00:56:37.349
<v Keelan McClymont>Sarah Yee.

532
00:56:46.230 --> 00:56:48.030
<v Keelan McClymont>Sarah Yee.

533
00:56:50.579 --> 00:56:51.619
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, that completes testimony.

534
00:56:52.099 --> 00:56:52.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

535
00:56:52.579 --> 00:56:54.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any discussion of this item?

536
00:56:58.260 --> 00:56:58.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

537
00:56:59.300 --> 00:57:01.179
<v Keelan McClymont>Sure, say something.

538
00:57:01.460 --> 00:57:02.579
<v Dan Ryan>Hello everyone, good to see you.

539
00:57:02.980 --> 00:57:07.300
<v Dan Ryan>Um, when, uh, Laurel Porter reached out, I guess it was about 6 weeks ago, is that correct?

540
00:57:07.699 --> 00:57:07.780
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

541
00:57:08.260 --> 00:57:10.739
<v Dan Ryan>Is she going to be a Rosarian soon, correct?

542
00:57:12.420 --> 00:57:13.539
<v Dan Ryan>Is she connected to this?

543
00:57:13.780 --> 00:57:14.900
<v Dan Ryan>Am I thinking of another one?

544
00:57:15.460 --> 00:57:20.420
<v Tatiana Turdal>So she's one of our Rosarian liaison, and I believe she's now a Royal Rosarian.

545
00:57:20.820 --> 00:57:32.860
<v Dan Ryan>So I Gotta give her some— I have to lift her up right now because she texted me and asked if we could make sure that we got this on the agenda before next week's celebration of all the sister cities.

546
00:57:32.860 --> 00:57:37.260
<v Dan Ryan>So your new Rosarian contact was working on all of your behalf.

547
00:57:37.500 --> 00:57:39.739
<v Dan Ryan>Not surprising if anyone knows her history.

548
00:57:39.900 --> 00:57:41.739
<v Dan Ryan>So anyway, congratulations to all of you.

549
00:57:41.739 --> 00:57:43.500
<v Dan Ryan>I'm so glad that this materialized.

550
00:57:43.500 --> 00:57:47.659
<v Dan Ryan>It's been a great joy to watch it evolve, how quickly it's evolved.

551
00:57:47.659 --> 00:57:47.900
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

552
00:57:48.320 --> 00:57:57.199
<v Dan Ryan>And I also want to acknowledge when the conflict started, it was such a fascinating moment in the dais when there was the initial— when the war started years ago now.

553
00:57:57.920 --> 00:58:02.480
<v Dan Ryan>And there was some people that wanted us to not have a sister city relationship with the Russian city.

554
00:58:03.280 --> 00:58:08.960
<v Dan Ryan>And it was actually people from the Kyiv sister city that said, that's not the spirit behind sister city relationships.

555
00:58:10.079 --> 00:58:15.889
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think I'm always remembering that right now as well, because conflict, unfortunately, is inevitable.

556
00:58:16.210 --> 00:58:19.250
<v Dan Ryan>And I don't want to get into that right now because it makes me too sad.

557
00:58:19.329 --> 00:58:25.650
<v Dan Ryan>But what we do know is the relationship building of sister cities is an essence that we must sustain.

558
00:58:25.730 --> 00:58:29.250
<v Dan Ryan>And I look at you, Chito, and I think of the program, International Affairs.

559
00:58:29.250 --> 00:58:30.690
<v Dan Ryan>And the mayor knows this.

560
00:58:30.690 --> 00:58:34.210
<v Dan Ryan>I'm very heartbroken that that was one of our cuts this year.

561
00:58:34.210 --> 00:58:36.369
<v Dan Ryan>And I hope we could still figure out how to restore it.

562
00:58:36.530 --> 00:58:38.769
<v Dan Ryan>I can't think of a more important time for us to lean in.

563
00:58:38.849 --> 00:58:39.090
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

564
00:58:39.420 --> 00:58:45.659
<v Dan Ryan>To sister city relationships than now when we have some isolationism that's quite cringy coming from the White House.

565
00:58:45.820 --> 00:58:47.260
<v Dan Ryan>So it's all about relationships.

566
00:58:48.380 --> 00:58:53.820
<v Dan Ryan>The oceans are not that big, and we really need to keep connecting with each other in a cultural way.

567
00:58:54.300 --> 00:58:56.699
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks so much, and I'm so happy to vote yes on this.

568
00:58:57.820 --> 00:58:58.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

569
00:58:59.340 --> 00:58:59.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

570
00:59:01.099 --> 00:59:01.820
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

571
00:59:02.139 --> 00:59:04.780
<v Olivia Clark>I just want to appreciate all the work that you put into this.

572
00:59:04.940 --> 00:59:11.219
<v Olivia Clark>It was a great presentation, and I feel like hopping on the next plane to get that latte.

573
00:59:11.940 --> 00:59:24.579
<v Olivia Clark>I have a special relationship with Ukraine in that I worked in the city of Salem and we had a sister city with Simferopol, and we know what happened to Simferopol and Crimea, and we don't want that to happen to the rest of Ukraine.

574
00:59:24.659 --> 00:59:29.219
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm very supportive of what you've done, and thank you so much for being here today.

575
00:59:29.380 --> 00:59:29.860
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

576
00:59:30.019 --> 00:59:31.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

577
00:59:31.300 --> 00:59:32.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

578
00:59:33.309 --> 00:59:34.030
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

579
00:59:34.349 --> 00:59:36.190
<v Mitch Green>Just want to thank the sponsors for bringing this forward.

580
00:59:36.510 --> 00:59:38.110
<v Mitch Green>I, I'm highly supportive of this action.

581
00:59:38.590 --> 00:59:40.989
<v Mitch Green>We've had a conversation at a couple different town halls.

582
00:59:41.150 --> 00:59:49.230
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate your doggedness and making sure every councilor understands the importance of this, um, and I hope to someday enjoy a nice cup of coffee in La Vie.

583
00:59:49.949 --> 00:59:50.829
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to support for this.

584
00:59:50.989 --> 00:59:51.070
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks.

585
00:59:51.630 --> 00:59:51.869
<v Tatiana Turdal>Thank you.

586
00:59:52.269 --> 00:59:53.070
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

587
00:59:53.389 --> 00:59:54.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

588
00:59:54.590 --> 01:00:01.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President, and thank you to you all for being here and bringing forward the next step in this process.

589
01:00:01.780 --> 01:00:32.110
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's very clear that the work has been done, the fit, the commonalities between our sisters, between our cities is right, and the time is important both in terms of this, the conditions in Ukraine and the support that Lviv needs from friends, and the conditions in the United States and And the work that we need to do to continue to ally with cities around the world who are fighting against authoritarianism.

590
01:00:34.190 --> 01:00:45.469
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sister cities are by their nature not political, and I appreciate, Chito, that, that you said that as part of the work that we're doing, because this should be about the fit and the relationships and the people.

591
01:00:46.269 --> 01:00:51.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And just like we asked another one of our sister cities to step up.

592
01:00:52.039 --> 01:01:03.639
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, you talked about this, I think, during, during COVID we know that we will need to step up in this relationship and that there will be many times where we ask Lviv to be there for us as well.

593
01:01:06.039 --> 01:01:24.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So to commonalities in commitment to humanitarian work, coffee, books, and bicycles, I appreciate I appreciate all the work you all have done and the process to go through those important steps to make sure that the commitment is truly there and that the relationship is meaningful.

594
01:01:24.050 --> 01:01:26.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I look forward to supporting this.

595
01:01:26.610 --> 01:01:27.730
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

596
01:01:27.809 --> 01:01:29.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

597
01:01:31.090 --> 01:01:31.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

598
01:01:31.329 --> 01:01:32.849
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's great to have you all here.

599
01:01:33.489 --> 01:01:42.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>As a life or a career-long soldier, there aren't many soldiers who don't really value the diplomatic arm.

600
01:01:43.110 --> 01:01:47.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>Of government, because when the diplomatic arm works, it means the military arm doesn't have to.

601
01:01:47.909 --> 01:01:51.070
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so as a soldier, I value that a lot.

602
01:01:51.269 --> 01:02:05.909
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the Sister City program, I've always considered it really— it is a subnational form of diplomacy across the globe that Oregon participates in on behalf of the country, but also on behalf of our everyday residents.

603
01:02:05.989 --> 01:02:07.590
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so it's something we should be proud of.

604
01:02:07.590 --> 01:02:08.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's something we should invest in.

605
01:02:08.710 --> 01:02:08.949
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

606
01:02:09.860 --> 01:02:14.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've had 3 distinct types of services overseas myself.

607
01:02:14.500 --> 01:02:21.539
<v Eric Zimmerman>Of course, war, but more rewarding, frankly, was peacekeeping in Kosovo and diplomatic in Bangladesh.

608
01:02:22.420 --> 01:02:36.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, uh, this is a good move at a time when it's almost impossible to talk about a sister city relationship without acknowledging what is happening, given the aggressions of, of Russia in Ukraine.

609
01:02:36.550 --> 01:02:36.630
<v Eric Zimmerman>Right.

610
01:02:37.269 --> 01:02:45.190
<v Eric Zimmerman>It'd be great to make sister cities in, in wonderful times, but it's also more important, underlined and bolded and italicized, when it's in the hardest of times.

611
01:02:45.590 --> 01:03:01.989
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I remember when that invasion started, and for the first time in my career as an officer, I got a notice from across from the Pentagon side of things: any officer who has connections with Ukraine, make yourself known at this time.

612
01:03:03.000 --> 01:03:03.079
<v Eric Zimmerman>Right.

613
01:03:03.239 --> 01:03:06.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>That was the seriousness of the situation.

614
01:03:07.159 --> 01:03:25.480
<v Eric Zimmerman>California had a lot of people because they have a partnership with Ukraine as a partner nation, and that ability to answer that call, it actually— it, it isn't just in the forms of government in the State Department or in the DOD.

615
01:03:25.639 --> 01:03:30.599
<v Eric Zimmerman>It also takes form in so many ways— cultural, In family relationships.

616
01:03:30.679 --> 01:03:40.360
<v Eric Zimmerman>Most family relationships have connection back across borders, that borders are just made on one day of the year and they hold for a long time, but family relationships cross those borders.

617
01:03:40.440 --> 01:03:48.440
<v Eric Zimmerman>California, because of its official relationships, was able to step up in a lot of ways, and I remember that very specifically.

618
01:03:48.440 --> 01:03:56.880
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so in a time with, with deep aggression happening and assaults against a nation while others are are maybe pulling back from.

619
01:03:58.000 --> 01:04:08.400
<v Eric Zimmerman>I really value the sister city relationship, and I value it through the good times and the bad, because these relationships are what help you get through the bad times so you can thrive in the good times.

620
01:04:09.440 --> 01:04:16.320
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm sure, given geopolitics, there'll be ups and downs to every relationship that we establish, but I really look forward to this.

621
01:04:16.400 --> 01:04:20.320
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm so grateful to your leadership and continued doggedness.

622
01:04:20.400 --> 01:04:20.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

623
01:04:20.840 --> 01:04:22.280
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and making sure we bring this forward.

624
01:04:22.440 --> 01:04:23.320
<v Eric Zimmerman>So happy to support.

625
01:04:23.880 --> 01:04:33.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we continue to invest in the things that set American partnerships up as things to— for us all to aspire to and not walk away from.

626
01:04:34.119 --> 01:04:36.679
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks so much, and I am so happy.

627
01:04:36.840 --> 01:04:44.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for the Ukrainian families and, and residents of Portland, I hope that you see yourself in this today.

628
01:04:45.079 --> 01:04:46.239
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

629
01:04:46.699 --> 01:04:46.940
<v Laura Loforte>Thank you.

630
01:04:47.260 --> 01:04:47.579
<v Randall Blaszczak>Thank you.

631
01:04:47.579 --> 01:04:48.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

632
01:04:51.820 --> 01:04:55.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, this item now moves to second reading.

633
01:04:56.059 --> 01:04:57.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for being here today.

634
01:04:57.500 --> 01:04:59.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

635
01:05:01.179 --> 01:05:07.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call item 17, reordered from our agenda?

636
01:05:08.699 --> 01:05:11.820
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 17, document 2026-182.

637
01:05:12.519 --> 01:05:21.000
<v Keelan McClymont>Appropriate $2,500,000 from the revolving loan and social housing acquisition fund for homeownership development in District 2.

638
01:05:21.960 --> 01:05:23.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, I'm turning this over to Councilor Smith.

639
01:05:25.639 --> 01:05:26.599
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

640
01:05:27.639 --> 01:05:38.599
<v Loretta Smith>Today I am proud to introduce the ordinance to appropriate $2.5 million for 2 community-rooted developers who produce homeownership projects.

641
01:05:39.449 --> 01:05:42.969
<v Loretta Smith>And that would be Self-Enhancement Inc. and Williams and Russell.

642
01:05:43.289 --> 01:05:58.170
<v Loretta Smith>And I'd like to call to the dais, um, Williams and Russell, Self-Enhancement Inc., and Andrew Holm from the Portland Chamber of Commerce.

643
01:06:04.489 --> 01:06:04.809
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

644
01:06:04.760 --> 01:06:04.920
<v Keelan McClymont>Let—.

645
01:06:12.440 --> 01:06:16.119
<v Loretta Smith>Jibreel, uh, can you let, um, Andrew sit there?

646
01:06:17.719 --> 01:06:24.239
<v Loretta Smith>Because we will not be able to do 3, um, at the, at the invited guests.

647
01:06:25.159 --> 01:06:25.480
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

648
01:06:32.280 --> 01:06:36.119
<v Loretta Smith>And I just want to say this, this is about more than housing units.

649
01:06:36.119 --> 01:06:48.239
<v Loretta Smith>This is about repairing harm, creating home ownership opportunities, and making a historic investment in Black home ownership in North and Northeast Portland.

650
01:06:48.679 --> 01:06:57.030
<v Loretta Smith>I also want to note that Councilor Kanal and I are sponsoring an amendment to change the funding source from the revolving, uh, loan fund aye.

651
01:06:57.110 --> 01:07:02.670
<v Loretta Smith>And Social Housing Acquisition Fund to the Construction Excise Tax Fund.

652
01:07:03.030 --> 01:07:13.190
<v Loretta Smith>And so I think we need to note and acknowledge that homeownership— when we talk about that for residents of the City of Portland, there is a gap.

653
01:07:13.349 --> 01:07:22.190
<v Loretta Smith>And we must recognize that Black homeownership in Portland is alarmingly low compared to that of white residents.

654
01:07:22.550 --> 01:07:23.880
<v Loretta Smith>This gap reflects yes.

655
01:07:24.039 --> 01:07:28.440
<v Loretta Smith>Broader systemic issues that require our immediate attention.

656
01:07:30.440 --> 01:07:44.199
<v Loretta Smith>The current statistics— currently statewide Black homeownership rates are approximately 36%, while homeownership stands at about 67% for white homeownership.

657
01:07:45.239 --> 01:07:54.659
<v Loretta Smith>In the Portland area, there are between 25 and 28% Black homeownership, while white homeownership is at 57%.

658
01:07:56.340 --> 01:08:04.019
<v Loretta Smith>These figures are often even more pronounced, underscoring the need for targeted solutions like the ones we're going to hear about today.

659
01:08:05.059 --> 01:08:10.179
<v Loretta Smith>The reality is that the average Black household cannot afford the median home price in Portland.

660
01:08:11.219 --> 01:08:35.899
<v Loretta Smith>This financial barrier not only impacts individual families, but it also hinders the ability to while we cannot overlook the systemic disparities and rapidly rising high costs that contribute to these challenges, addressing these inequities is essential to create a more inclusive housing market.

661
01:08:37.020 --> 01:08:40.739
<v Loretta Smith>We need to promote local supportive programs.

662
01:08:41.260 --> 01:08:42.460
<v Loretta Smith>Fortunately, we have.

663
01:08:42.779 --> 01:08:43.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilmember Smith.

664
01:08:44.060 --> 01:08:48.779
<v Loretta Smith>Williams and Russell, CDC, and Self-Enhancement, Inc.

665
01:08:49.020 --> 01:08:59.779
<v Loretta Smith>There are several culturally specific programs and advocacy organizations, but not enough dedicated to assisting Black Portlanders in achieving homeownership.

666
01:09:00.300 --> 01:09:09.340
<v Loretta Smith>These resources are crucial, and fostering financial stability and empowerment from the city is very important.

667
01:09:09.420 --> 01:09:09.739
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

668
01:09:11.100 --> 01:09:14.779
<v Loretta Smith>And I would like to have Williams and Russell to speak first.

669
01:09:16.140 --> 01:09:17.899
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, can, can our CEO speak?

670
01:09:19.100 --> 01:09:19.579
<v Bryson Davis>Sure.

671
01:09:19.819 --> 01:09:20.140
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

672
01:09:20.699 --> 01:09:21.340
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

673
01:09:21.420 --> 01:09:28.659
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, good morning, um, President Dunphy, councilors, Vice President.

674
01:09:29.100 --> 01:09:39.288
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, when we got the phone call about coming here, and we've come here quite a few times, We responded accordingly.

675
01:09:40.769 --> 01:09:46.248
<v Unidentified speaker>We got everybody rallied together because Black homeownership does matter.

676
01:09:47.969 --> 01:10:00.248
<v Unidentified speaker>We thought that we expressed our boundless gratitude about the opportunity in and of itself to be funded, to get our builds done, but it didn't happen.

677
01:10:01.009 --> 01:10:14.130
<v Unidentified speaker>But one thing about Portlanders, specifically Black Portlanders, we persevere and we keep going at it and going at it until we get equity.

678
01:10:14.890 --> 01:10:20.210
<v Unidentified speaker>The very thing we talk about so often— equity, meeting people where they are.

679
01:10:21.449 --> 01:10:28.170
<v Unidentified speaker>Equality doesn't always work, but equity does because of the intentionality behind it.

680
01:10:30.010 --> 01:10:35.090
<v Unidentified speaker>So for the folks who introduced this ordinance, Smith, thank you so much.

681
01:10:35.689 --> 01:10:37.449
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for hearing us.

682
01:10:37.689 --> 01:10:43.890
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for realizing how important this is to us and staying and keeping to the fight.

683
01:10:44.890 --> 01:10:47.409
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman, thank you for getting on this.

684
01:10:48.649 --> 01:10:54.090
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Pirtle-Guiney, Councilor Ryan, and Vice President Clark.

685
01:10:54.090 --> 01:10:54.329
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

686
01:10:54.899 --> 01:10:59.260
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for taking a chance on standing behind this ordinance.

687
01:11:00.579 --> 01:11:10.140
<v Unidentified speaker>And Kanal, thank you for working with Councilor Smith to get this right, to find a funding source that we all can be in agreeance with.

688
01:11:12.020 --> 01:11:15.819
<v Unidentified speaker>Reparative development is what we stand for at Wilmson Russell.

689
01:11:16.420 --> 01:11:18.659
<v Unidentified speaker>Reparative development will be a matter of contemporary policy.

690
01:11:19.779 --> 01:11:31.659
<v Unidentified speaker>And just to reiterate what it is, is that it's a formal acknowledgment and an apology that happened in 2017 from Ted Wheeler, who literally came to Northeast and said, I'm sorry.

691
01:11:33.300 --> 01:11:39.979
<v Unidentified speaker>Not only did he say I'm sorry, he acknowledged the wrong that happened through PCC.

692
01:11:41.619 --> 01:11:46.460
<v Unidentified speaker>And not only did he acknowledge the wrong, he gave us money to build back.

693
01:11:46.739 --> 01:11:47.140
<v Unidentified speaker>Think about that.

694
01:11:47.220 --> 01:11:47.460
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

695
01:11:47.789 --> 01:11:49.630
<v Unidentified speaker>A politician admitting and saying I'm sorry.

696
01:11:50.750 --> 01:11:51.229
<v Unidentified speaker>Imagine that.

697
01:11:52.270 --> 01:11:55.949
<v Unidentified speaker>But he did that, and that's what set us on this course called reparative development.

698
01:11:58.270 --> 01:12:06.510
<v Unidentified speaker>This is no ordinary build, and we stand here with our partners, folks in the gallery, to stand by what it is that we're doing.

699
01:12:06.590 --> 01:12:11.789
<v Unidentified speaker>We're doing nothing more than what you all are doing, and that's getting folks access to housing, home ownership.

700
01:12:12.590 --> 01:12:14.670
<v Unidentified speaker>Affordable housing is good, it's needed, it's thank you.

701
01:12:14.750 --> 01:12:17.310
<v Unidentified speaker>Homeownership is important, but homeownership matters too.

702
01:12:17.630 --> 01:12:19.510
<v Unidentified speaker>It's about wealth creation.

703
01:12:20.350 --> 01:12:30.670
<v Unidentified speaker>Now, I had a script, but I think it's much more important to talk about truth to light and to be honest and to look at you all in your eyes, that we have the opportunity to get this right and right wrongs.

704
01:12:30.829 --> 01:12:35.069
<v Unidentified speaker>The world is watching because Portland does it differently.

705
01:12:35.229 --> 01:12:36.029
<v Unidentified speaker>We dare to dream.

706
01:12:36.670 --> 01:12:38.310
<v Unidentified speaker>We dare to be audacious.

707
01:12:38.670 --> 01:12:41.869
<v Unidentified speaker>We've been thinking about having a sister city in Ukraine.

708
01:12:42.029 --> 01:12:46.189
<v Unidentified speaker>Think about that, because we are here to support each other.

709
01:12:46.189 --> 01:12:47.310
<v Unidentified speaker>We are nothing without each other.

710
01:12:47.390 --> 01:12:48.750
<v Unidentified speaker>We're all in this together.

711
01:12:48.909 --> 01:12:49.949
<v Unidentified speaker>Homeownership matters.

712
01:12:49.949 --> 01:13:01.069
<v Unidentified speaker>And I thank you so much for your time, and I do hope that today we will find a resolution where we all could stand behind this unanimously and really show how Portland stands together.

713
01:13:01.229 --> 01:13:02.470
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

714
01:13:05.310 --> 01:13:06.750
<v Bryson Davis>Good morning, city councilors.

715
01:13:07.000 --> 01:13:07.960
<v Bryson Davis>My name is Bryson Davis.

716
01:13:08.279 --> 01:13:14.680
<v Bryson Davis>I'm the president of the Williams and Russell CDC and the former co-chair of the project working group for Williams and Russell.

717
01:13:16.359 --> 01:13:29.239
<v Bryson Davis>Now, here— we're here talking about the Williams and Russell Knott Street Townhome Project, and this effort represents 55 years of progress on this block.

718
01:13:29.640 --> 01:13:33.960
<v Bryson Davis>It represents over a decade of many people working together to repair a community.

719
01:13:34.920 --> 01:13:43.989
<v Bryson Davis>And like SCI's excellent project, We seek to rebuild the sense of home that was lost due to the actions of the past.

720
01:13:44.670 --> 01:14:00.789
<v Bryson Davis>For generations, Portland's Black communities in North Northeast Portland were harmed by systemic policies, redlining, forced displacement, the construction of I-5, the construction of Veterans Memorial Coliseum, and the expansion of Emmanuel Hospital.

721
01:14:01.869 --> 01:14:04.670
<v Bryson Davis>They devastated a vibrant and thriving neighborhood.

722
01:14:05.489 --> 01:14:06.930
<v Bryson Davis>These weren't isolated events.

723
01:14:06.930 --> 01:14:15.449
<v Bryson Davis>They were part of a pattern of decisions that stripped families of stability, opportunity, and generational wealth.

724
01:14:15.649 --> 01:14:23.289
<v Bryson Davis>The result has been the legalized theft of wealth and the breaking of trust between the city and the communities that it serves.

725
01:14:23.810 --> 01:14:30.449
<v Bryson Davis>The Williams and Russell Knott Street Townhome Project is a meaningful step towards rebuilding that trust.

726
01:14:31.579 --> 01:14:46.020
<v Bryson Davis>As the first project within our broader Williams and Russell development, it is designed with clear purpose to expand affordable homeownership while restoring access to wealth-building opportunities for those who are harmed.

727
01:14:46.220 --> 01:14:52.300
<v Bryson Davis>The project will deliver 20 high-quality townhomes ranging from 1,200 to 1,800 square feet.

728
01:14:52.460 --> 01:15:03.310
<v Bryson Davis>The largest units include fully accessible ground floors making them ideal for multigenerational living, an important priority that we heard that many families have.

729
01:15:03.989 --> 01:15:14.270
<v Bryson Davis>In partnership with the Portland Housing Center, we're using the city's preference policy to connect these townhomes to the people who were displaced by those original actions.

730
01:15:15.670 --> 01:15:24.310
<v Bryson Davis>Importantly, these homes will be built to Earth Advantage Platinum standards, and they're designed to be collectively net zero.

731
01:15:25.060 --> 01:15:34.979
<v Bryson Davis>Thanks to the support of the Portland Clean Energy Fund, that means lower utility costs, healthier living environments, and higher quality buildings for the homeowners.

732
01:15:36.420 --> 01:15:38.659
<v Bryson Davis>The requested one million dollars is essential.

733
01:15:39.460 --> 01:15:46.500
<v Bryson Davis>It will replace funds we've already redirected from other housing projects and our organizational operations to keep this effort moving forward.

734
01:15:47.699 --> 01:15:52.260
<v Bryson Davis>Without it, we risk compromising affordability and delaying future homeownership opportunities.

735
01:15:54.350 --> 01:16:05.590
<v Bryson Davis>When we surveyed community members as part of the project working group, we heard the same refrain over and over: wealth was taken from us.

736
01:16:06.590 --> 01:16:12.310
<v Bryson Davis>We need real ownership opportunities to get that wealth back.

737
01:16:13.229 --> 01:16:24.859
<v Bryson Davis>Many, many people expressed that only building affordable apartments was not sufficient for those families who lost their homes and the wealth that went with it.

738
01:16:27.140 --> 01:16:36.539
<v Bryson Davis>Homeownership is a key pillar to the generational wealth transfer, which we know Black families lag behind the rest of the country.

739
01:16:39.460 --> 01:16:43.619
<v Bryson Davis>I've seen many of you out in our community supporting its people.

740
01:16:44.779 --> 01:16:58.579
<v Bryson Davis>Supporting its businesses, and really just adding to that sense of support and belonging that we all want and that we all want to feel.

741
01:17:01.739 --> 01:17:14.909
<v Bryson Davis>I know that we all share a commitment to affordable housing, a commitment to equity, And a commitment to restoring opportunity and prosperity where it was once taken.

742
01:17:15.909 --> 01:17:33.550
<v Bryson Davis>This investment ensures that the Knott Street Townhomes achieves their fullest impact, that they're delivering not just housing, but stability, dignity, and a path toward rebuilding stolen generational wealth.

743
01:17:33.909 --> 01:17:35.989
<v Bryson Davis>Thank you for your continued leadership and for your support.

744
01:17:35.989 --> 01:17:36.229
<v Bryson Davis>Thank you.

745
01:17:36.680 --> 01:17:42.239
<v Bryson Davis>And we're available— we're here and we're available to you if you have any questions about our project.

746
01:17:42.680 --> 01:17:45.560
<v Loretta Smith>Trent Aldridge from SEI, could you introduce yourself?

747
01:17:48.439 --> 01:17:50.119
<v Trent Aldridge>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

748
01:17:50.279 --> 01:17:54.359
<v Trent Aldridge>Uh, good morning, Council President Dunphy and councilors.

749
01:17:54.359 --> 01:17:59.479
<v Trent Aldridge>My name is Trent Aldridge and I serve as the CEO at Self Enhancement Inc.

750
01:17:59.640 --> 01:18:11.270
<v Trent Aldridge>I want to start by saying thank you to Councilor Smith for your persistence And to Councilors Kanal, Zimmerman, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, and Clark for finding their way to a yes.

751
01:18:11.789 --> 01:18:16.229
<v Trent Aldridge>This journey for me has felt personal.

752
01:18:16.590 --> 01:18:21.350
<v Trent Aldridge>SEI has been in North and Northeast Portland for over 40 years.

753
01:18:21.869 --> 01:18:46.090
<v Trent Aldridge>We have watched families get priced out of neighborhoods we serve, and we have watched the council debate for months on whether an organization with our track record, our relationships, and our documented results deserve $1.5 million to help families own homes on the same streets their grandparents were displaced from.

754
01:18:47.329 --> 01:18:56.210
<v Trent Aldridge>And I will be honest with you, when the Broadway corridor moved forward, we didn't— it didn't just feel like something other than process.

755
01:18:58.039 --> 01:19:03.800
<v Trent Aldridge>Here's what I would like you to know about our project, which we were calling the Ruby Mack Place.

756
01:19:03.960 --> 01:19:16.479
<v Trent Aldridge>We were building 49 homes in East Vanport, 1,500 to 1,800 square foot, uh, net-zero homes that our community can own.

757
01:19:17.079 --> 01:19:23.560
<v Trent Aldridge>Oregon Housing and Community Service awarded LIFT homeownership funds to this project.

758
01:19:23.800 --> 01:19:24.039
<v Trent Aldridge>Thank you.

759
01:19:24.390 --> 01:19:34.750
<v Trent Aldridge>Through a competitive process, because it pencils, because SEI has a proven track record, and because the need is real.

760
01:19:35.109 --> 01:19:39.189
<v Trent Aldridge>The state of Oregon has already voted with its dollars.

761
01:19:39.430 --> 01:19:42.350
<v Trent Aldridge>Now it's Portland's turn to make an investment.

762
01:19:43.270 --> 01:19:49.590
<v Trent Aldridge>What the Ruby Mack Place delivers is not complicated: permanent affordable home ownership.

763
01:19:50.239 --> 01:19:54.560
<v Trent Aldridge>And this $1.5 million is what will make it truly accessible.

764
01:19:56.399 --> 01:19:59.920
<v Trent Aldridge>Without it, units are affordable at 80% AMI.

765
01:20:00.800 --> 01:20:11.920
<v Trent Aldridge>With it, we can push down to 70% or even 65% and cover down payment assistance and purchase costs that stop qualified families.

766
01:20:14.800 --> 01:20:15.119
<v Trent Aldridge>Thank you.

767
01:20:20.489 --> 01:20:29.689
<v Trent Aldridge>Not renting, owning, building generational wealth, creating the kind of stability that means their children don't have to start over.

768
01:20:32.090 --> 01:20:35.210
<v Trent Aldridge>Families who are rooted and stable put money into Portland's economy.

769
01:20:36.409 --> 01:20:47.180
<v Trent Aldridge>According to the Federal Reserve's Survey of Community, uh, Consumer Finances, the median homeowner has 40 times the net worth of the median renter.

770
01:20:47.779 --> 01:20:52.100
<v Trent Aldridge>$400,000 Versus $10,400.

771
01:20:52.420 --> 01:20:54.939
<v Trent Aldridge>That's the door we're trying to open.

772
01:20:55.380 --> 01:20:57.739
<v Trent Aldridge>That is what this vote is about.

773
01:20:58.340 --> 01:21:01.819
<v Trent Aldridge>And SEI doesn't just build units, we stay.

774
01:21:02.420 --> 01:21:08.420
<v Trent Aldridge>Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies found that children of homeowners score up to 9% higher in math.

775
01:21:08.500 --> 01:21:08.899
<v Trent Aldridge>That's right.

776
01:21:10.279 --> 01:21:13.199
<v Trent Aldridge>And 7% higher in, in reading.

777
01:21:15.079 --> 01:21:20.800
<v Trent Aldridge>Even after controlling for income, that is not a housing statistic.

778
01:21:21.000 --> 01:21:32.399
<v Trent Aldridge>That is a child reaching their potential in the classroom, a family investing in their neighborhood, and a generation building wealth instead of inheriting instability.

779
01:21:33.640 --> 01:21:41.210
<v Trent Aldridge>Wraparound services, resident support, Culturally specific programming, that is what we bring.

780
01:21:41.729 --> 01:21:50.770
<v Trent Aldridge>This ordinance is an opportunity to match what Oregon already believes in, and I'm asking this council to take it as well.

781
01:21:51.010 --> 01:21:51.409
<v Trent Aldridge>Thank you.

782
01:21:52.850 --> 01:21:53.170
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

783
01:21:56.930 --> 01:22:00.609
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Good morning, Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of the council.

784
01:22:02.840 --> 01:22:11.159
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I think it's fitting that we're here doing this today on the day that we acknowledged Vanport and the history there.

785
01:22:11.560 --> 01:22:14.520
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And we're looking at a project on the Williams and Russell block.

786
01:22:15.159 --> 01:22:58.159
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>We're looking at a project in East Vanport and have an opportunity to, to make a unified statement that we support Black homeownership, not just support Black homeownership as a whole, as a community, but we support Black homeownership on these sites, I wrote testimony that I was going to share yesterday about four o'clock and was very excited to see that I was going to have to change all the testimony I wrote when I saw the the partnership and the collaboration that went into the amendment that was posted last night.

787
01:22:59.449 --> 01:23:02.329
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I want to thank all of the councilors that worked on the initial ordinance.

788
01:23:02.810 --> 01:23:12.170
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I want to thank all of the councilors that were able to work together to get to a place of collaborative partnership in putting the amendment forward that was put forward.

789
01:23:15.449 --> 01:23:16.970
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>You've all heard me talk about this subject.

790
01:23:18.329 --> 01:23:26.569
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>You all have heard me speak about how I feel about the urgent need for homeownership opportunities for the Black community in Portland.

791
01:23:28.170 --> 01:23:31.210
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>So I didn't plan to talk very much more about that this morning.

792
01:23:31.289 --> 01:23:36.210
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I will echo what Trent said just around the goals of our project.

793
01:23:36.890 --> 01:23:40.729
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>We want to make the highest quality homes that we can.

794
01:23:40.890 --> 01:23:44.649
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>We want to be able to build net-zero home opportunities.

795
01:23:44.810 --> 01:23:48.569
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>We want to be able to create the highest level of affordability that we can also.

796
01:23:49.770 --> 01:23:56.289
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And it is not our goal just to create homeownership units.

797
01:23:56.369 --> 01:24:10.369
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>It is our goal to create homeownership units that are accessible to Black Portlanders who could not afford to buy homes in Portland before these type of projects are able to be developed, funded, and stood up.

798
01:24:10.529 --> 01:24:16.930
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>We don't want to build units that somebody who can already afford to own a home can afford to purchase.

799
01:24:17.090 --> 01:24:21.329
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>We want to build units to somebody who could not otherwise afford to purchase a home.

800
01:24:21.960 --> 01:24:23.720
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Is able to purchase.

801
01:24:24.119 --> 01:24:31.520
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I do want to say a little bit about something that's really important to me.

802
01:24:33.560 --> 01:24:43.079
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I want to be able to appeal to all of you as leaders in this city who have an opportunity to set a foundation for how future decisions can be made.

803
01:24:43.319 --> 01:24:47.159
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>You are the first Portland City Council in this new form of government.

804
01:24:47.649 --> 01:24:56.130
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And the precedents that you set from the seats of power that you sit in will impact every council that occupies these seats after you.

805
01:24:56.289 --> 01:25:08.090
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I want to challenge all of you to think about the example that has been set so far this year and think about how today's events can offer a different example.

806
01:25:08.369 --> 01:25:14.949
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>We've seen a level of hyperpolarization on this council that mirrors our national political landscape.

807
01:25:16.229 --> 01:25:26.069
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>We have seen a reality where any Portlander paying attention can look at a random vote, a random proposal, and predict what the votes are going to be.

808
01:25:26.949 --> 01:25:36.550
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Not based on the merits of that proposal and the values of each of you, the values that each councilor holds, but based on who's proposing it.

809
01:25:37.670 --> 01:25:40.819
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And that's something that I really, really hope were able to see change.

810
01:25:41.539 --> 01:26:07.069
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I hope that the collaboration that led to the amendment that was put forth for these projects is able to set a new foundation and able to initiate a new precedent where the leadership of our city is not paralyzed by voting blocs, but the leadership of our city is able to work together to do what's best for our communities, for all Portlanders.

811
01:26:07.310 --> 01:26:10.670
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I know that Portland is better than that.

812
01:26:10.829 --> 01:26:15.789
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I know that all of you are better than that, and I know that because I know many of you.

813
01:26:16.829 --> 01:26:20.670
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And I have a great relationship with Councilor Smith.

814
01:26:20.829 --> 01:26:24.069
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I also have a great relationship with Councilor Avalos.

815
01:26:24.350 --> 01:26:30.510
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I'm building a very good relationship with President Dunphy and have really enjoyed the interactions we've had.

816
01:26:30.590 --> 01:26:35.550
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I'm also building a very good relationship with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, former President Pirtle-Guiney.

817
01:26:35.630 --> 01:26:35.869
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Thank you.

818
01:26:36.399 --> 01:26:40.159
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And have enjoyed the interactions we've had in building that as well.

819
01:26:40.239 --> 01:26:56.520
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I can go down the line with this council and state emphatically that I've never had a conversation with any of you that I walked away from feeling like this person doesn't align with the values of SEI and the excellence that we want to bring to our communities.

820
01:26:56.720 --> 01:27:05.970
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>So I know there's much more commonality on this council than past voting patterns have suggested.

821
01:27:06.329 --> 01:27:23.130
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And again, I just want to encourage all of you with the hope that what led to the collaborative partnership that brought us to where we are today, the ideals that brought us to where we are today, are able to be represented again over and over and over again.

822
01:27:23.210 --> 01:27:25.850
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And that's what this council will be remembered for.

823
01:27:26.250 --> 01:27:29.369
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>That's the precedent that this council can set going forward.

824
01:27:29.449 --> 01:27:29.689
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Thank you.

825
01:27:30.170 --> 01:27:32.250
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Again, for every council that comes after you.

826
01:27:32.970 --> 01:27:45.449
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>So absolutely here today in support of this amendment and just really, really encouraged by the collaborative process that brought it to where it is.

827
01:27:46.649 --> 01:27:52.810
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>The last thing I'll say, I am the executive— I am the Director of Advocacy and Engagement at SEI.

828
01:27:52.970 --> 01:27:56.010
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I'm also a steering committee member for the Welcome Home Coalition.

829
01:27:56.850 --> 01:28:02.210
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And this morning, Welcome Home submitted written testimony in strong support of this amendment.

830
01:28:02.369 --> 01:28:11.329
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I'm sitting here next to Andrew Holm, the president of the Portland Metro Chamber, and they are in strong support of this amendment and what we are doing here today.

831
01:28:11.569 --> 01:28:11.810
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Thank you.

832
01:28:11.970 --> 01:28:32.750
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>I don't know how much I have to reiterate to all of you the significance of that, that the Portland Metro Chamber and the Welcome Home Coalition are united and the idea is that this is a valuable, a valuable step to take for our city, for our community, specifically for Black Portlanders.

833
01:28:33.550 --> 01:28:36.109
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Black Portlanders deserve this.

834
01:28:36.350 --> 01:28:48.510
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Black Portlanders have had opportunities suppressed for the entire history of this city, and this is an opportunity for the council to say we're going to take an initial step right now to move in a different direction.

835
01:28:49.449 --> 01:28:55.050
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>To disrupt the history that has been the norm in our city and do something different.

836
01:28:55.130 --> 01:29:00.970
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>And again, I hope that this is a precedent that is able to be carried forward with this council and future councils after it.

837
01:29:01.050 --> 01:29:01.529
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>So thank you.

838
01:29:01.930 --> 01:29:02.649
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Sihan.

839
01:29:03.850 --> 01:29:05.930
<v Loretta Smith>Andrew Holm, introduce yourself, please.

840
01:29:06.170 --> 01:29:07.529
<v Andrew Holm>You have to make me go after him, huh?

841
01:29:08.489 --> 01:29:10.489
<v Andrew Holm>It's always a tough act to follow.

842
01:29:10.890 --> 01:29:12.569
<v Andrew Holm>Thank you for those words, and they do strike true.

843
01:29:13.369 --> 01:29:15.210
<v Andrew Holm>Good morning, Council President and councilors.

844
01:29:15.289 --> 01:29:23.949
<v Andrew Holm>My name is Andrew Holm, President and CEO of the Portland Metro Chamber, proud registered lobbyists representing business, employers, nonprofits, community organizations across the region.

845
01:29:25.149 --> 01:29:36.270
<v Andrew Holm>The Chamber is here today in strong support of the Homeownership Investment Ordinance introduced by Councilors Smith, Zimmerman, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, Clark, and Kanal.

846
01:29:37.390 --> 01:29:41.869
<v Andrew Holm>This proposal invests $2.5 million towards homeownership development in District 2.

847
01:29:43.310 --> 01:29:53.479
<v Andrew Holm>And specifically in Self Enhancement Inc. and the Williams and Russell CDC project to help expand affordable homeownership opportunities for Portland families.

848
01:29:54.159 --> 01:30:03.840
<v Andrew Holm>Portland's housing conversation much too often focuses, and appropriately so, on rental housing and shelter capacity and our homelessness response.

849
01:30:04.000 --> 01:30:06.079
<v Andrew Holm>And those investments matter.

850
01:30:06.159 --> 01:30:14.239
<v Andrew Holm>But if we are serious about long-term stability, if we're serious about economic mobility, multigenerational wealth building, thank you.

851
01:30:14.500 --> 01:30:26.739
<v Andrew Holm>And preventing displacement, we must also talk about new housing production and critically home ownership and the opportunity that is before you right now today, Black home ownership.

852
01:30:27.939 --> 01:30:36.100
<v Andrew Holm>Home ownership remains one of the strongest pathways to building household wealth, creating financial stability, and allowing families to remain rooted in their communities.

853
01:30:37.380 --> 01:30:47.000
<v Andrew Holm>Access to ownership opportunities continue to be out of reach for many Portlanders, particularly Black households and historically displaced communities in North and Northeast Portland.

854
01:30:47.159 --> 01:30:53.239
<v Andrew Holm>The ordinance directly acknowledges that history and attempts to create opportunities where few were available before.

855
01:30:53.399 --> 01:30:58.079
<v Andrew Holm>This ordinance is also important because it recognized that housing policy cannot be one-dimensional.

856
01:30:58.600 --> 01:31:03.479
<v Andrew Holm>Portland needs rental housing, supportive housing, middle-income housing, and ownership opportunities.

857
01:31:03.560 --> 01:31:09.319
<v Andrew Holm>We need all of the above approach if we expect to close our housing gap and remain economically competitive.

858
01:31:09.399 --> 01:31:09.720
<v Andrew Holm>Thank you.

859
01:31:10.109 --> 01:31:18.310
<v Andrew Holm>The projects are intended to create new units of housing while promoting long-term community stability and intergenerational wealth building.

860
01:31:18.590 --> 01:31:32.270
<v Andrew Holm>The chamber has consistently advocated for housing production, every type, to be accelerated, and we were proud to stand side by side with William Russell in the state capitol this last legislative session to support the funding for the project and adjacent business hub.

861
01:31:32.430 --> 01:31:36.270
<v Andrew Holm>Housing is critical, but it must also be matched by jobs.

862
01:31:36.430 --> 01:31:36.670
<v Andrew Holm>Thank you.

863
01:31:36.970 --> 01:31:40.329
<v Andrew Holm>This is exactly what is possible at Williams and Russell.

864
01:31:40.489 --> 01:31:44.489
<v Andrew Holm>The state has done its part, and we need the city to lean in as well.

865
01:31:44.649 --> 01:31:50.010
<v Andrew Holm>In addition to the benefits of the project, I want to talk about SEI and about William and Russell.

866
01:31:50.170 --> 01:31:55.329
<v Andrew Holm>They are outstanding partners that will be good stewards of these resources.

867
01:31:55.770 --> 01:32:00.329
<v Andrew Holm>We have the highest regard for their work and for their commitment to excellence.

868
01:32:00.569 --> 01:32:07.630
<v Andrew Holm>They should have our community and this council's full confidence They have earned our trust.

869
01:32:08.069 --> 01:32:19.750
<v Andrew Holm>We encourage the council to support this amendment and send a clear signal that the city council is dedicated to homeownership, Black homeownership, and building intergenerational wealth opportunities by getting shovels in the ground now.

870
01:32:19.989 --> 01:32:21.989
<v Andrew Holm>Thank you for your time and for your consideration.

871
01:32:26.630 --> 01:32:27.109
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Smith.

872
01:32:27.109 --> 01:32:27.350
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

873
01:32:28.710 --> 01:32:29.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that— conclude the presentation?

874
01:32:30.470 --> 01:32:31.590
<v Loretta Smith>This is the invited guest.

875
01:32:31.909 --> 01:32:32.149
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

876
01:32:32.359 --> 01:32:34.680
<v Loretta Smith>I think we have some other guests who have signed up.

877
01:32:35.159 --> 01:32:42.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I understand that Commissioner Singleton is available online also to testify, so I'd like to welcome her to testify.

878
01:32:50.359 --> 01:32:50.680
<v Shannon Singleton>Good morning.

879
01:32:51.079 --> 01:32:54.039
<v Shannon Singleton>Thank you so much for giving me a couple of minutes here.

880
01:32:54.119 --> 01:32:56.600
<v Shannon Singleton>I just hopped out of our board meeting.

881
01:32:57.239 --> 01:32:58.439
<v Shannon Singleton>My name is Shannon Singleton.

882
01:32:58.680 --> 01:33:05.029
<v Shannon Singleton>I am the commissioner for District 2 for Multnomah County, which is north and northeast Portland, as well as the City of Maywood Park.

883
01:33:05.670 --> 01:33:18.069
<v Shannon Singleton>And I'm here today to ask you to support Item 2026-182 to appropriate $2.5 million for homeowner development in District 2 through partnership with SEI and the Williams and Russell Project.

884
01:33:19.270 --> 01:33:25.029
<v Shannon Singleton>With the city's role of infrastructure, zoning, and housing development, many communities have been harmed by previous city decisions.

885
01:33:25.829 --> 01:33:33.729
<v Shannon Singleton>While you all are not the councilors who made those past decisions, you can be the ones to start seeking justice for these communities and their families.

886
01:33:34.090 --> 01:33:40.250
<v Shannon Singleton>District 2 was home to many of our diverse community members in Portland, and the Black community in particular.

887
01:33:40.409 --> 01:33:43.810
<v Shannon Singleton>They invested in these neighborhoods to make for a better future.

888
01:33:44.090 --> 01:33:56.649
<v Shannon Singleton>Both of these developments are in my district and are critical investments in desperately needed affordable housing, in particular the opportunities for affordable homeownership, which are critical to address the widening wealth gap for Black Portlanders.

889
01:33:57.579 --> 01:34:08.619
<v Shannon Singleton>The Portland Housing Bureau data shows that Black households earn an average of an income of just over $44,000 a year, meaning we make less than half of what white households make.

890
01:34:09.420 --> 01:34:15.100
<v Shannon Singleton>It is no wonder that we have no neighborhoods that are affordable to rent, let alone opportunities to buy homes.

891
01:34:16.060 --> 01:34:25.500
<v Shannon Singleton>Please vote yes today and make the opportunity for homeownership a reality for more Black Portlanders so we can live our values and make equitable investments in affordable housing development.

892
01:34:25.579 --> 01:34:25.819
<v Shannon Singleton>Thank you.

893
01:34:26.079 --> 01:34:26.640
<v Shannon Singleton>In this community.

894
01:34:27.359 --> 01:34:28.880
<v Shannon Singleton>Thank you for your work on this amendment.

895
01:34:28.960 --> 01:34:30.399
<v Shannon Singleton>Thank you, Councilor Smith, for your leadership.

896
01:34:31.119 --> 01:34:37.920
<v Shannon Singleton>And thank you to all my friends I see out there in the, uh, in the, uh, audience ready to testify in support of this project.

897
01:34:38.239 --> 01:34:43.359
<v Shannon Singleton>I really appreciate the work and look forward to continued partnership with you all, um, over here at Multnomah County.

898
01:34:44.640 --> 01:34:45.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Commissioner Singleton.

899
01:34:46.319 --> 01:34:47.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Kanal.

900
01:34:48.960 --> 01:34:49.199
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

901
01:34:49.359 --> 01:34:51.449
<v Sameer Kanal>I just, in order to, uh, Thank you.

902
01:34:51.529 --> 01:34:51.850
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mayor.

903
01:34:52.010 --> 01:34:52.810
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mayor.

904
01:34:52.810 --> 01:34:56.250
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm gonna allow for the conversation in the testimony to include a reference to the amendment.

905
01:34:56.409 --> 01:34:59.449
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just gonna do— follow our normal tradition here and float the amendment.

906
01:34:59.930 --> 01:35:00.970
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll formally move it afterwards.

907
01:35:02.489 --> 01:35:05.050
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanna first say it's the only amendment listed.

908
01:35:05.369 --> 01:35:15.529
<v Sameer Kanal>So what it would do is change the funding source from the revolving loan and social housing acquisition fund to the construction excise tax subfund, and it's 225020 for the record.

909
01:35:17.899 --> 01:35:25.500
<v Sameer Kanal>For, um, the use of that particular pot of money instead of the revolving loan and social housing acquisition fund.

910
01:35:25.739 --> 01:35:42.460
<v Sameer Kanal>There is also the addition down at the bottom of the ordinance of a waiver to ensure that, um, this apply— that all the, the, um, applicability of those funds, um, is, is— which we think would have applied anyway, but certainly we'll be sure this way that it applies to both of these 2 projects.

911
01:35:42.859 --> 01:35:46.869
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just want to thank, uh, Councilor Smith for her collaboration on this.

912
01:35:47.109 --> 01:35:53.989
<v Sameer Kanal>I also will want to thank Councilors Murillo and Dunphy who have expressed support for the amendment as well and put their names on it also.

913
01:35:54.550 --> 01:36:01.750
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to make sure that that's something that testifiers can speak to, and then we'll discuss it formally after the testimony.

914
01:36:02.229 --> 01:36:02.390
<v Tanisha Renee>Thank you.

915
01:36:02.710 --> 01:36:03.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

916
01:36:04.550 --> 01:36:08.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I'm going to have us get to public testimony now, and then we'll take a restroom break after that.

917
01:36:08.949 --> 01:36:12.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Keelan, can we please call the first panel of people to testify?

918
01:36:13.439 --> 01:36:14.800
<v Keelan McClymont>We have 13 people signed up.

919
01:36:14.880 --> 01:36:17.039
<v Keelan McClymont>I'll call folks up in groups of 5.

920
01:36:18.960 --> 01:36:29.520
<v Keelan McClymont>Freda Walker, Tanisha Renee, Mark Jackson, Benjamin Gilbert, John Washington.

921
01:36:38.189 --> 01:36:39.470
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're welcome to start us off, please.

922
01:36:39.550 --> 01:36:39.869
<v Randall Blaszczak>All right, perfect.

923
01:36:40.590 --> 01:36:44.510
<v Jabril Willis>Uh, good morning, President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of the council.

924
01:36:44.590 --> 01:36:46.189
<v Jabril Willis>My name is Jabri Willis.

925
01:36:46.189 --> 01:36:49.630
<v Jabril Willis>I'll be speaking in place of Freda Walker, who could not be here today.

926
01:36:49.789 --> 01:36:54.189
<v Jabril Willis>I want to first acknowledge the name of this, uh, project that SEI proposed, the Ruby Mack Project.

927
01:36:54.270 --> 01:37:01.949
<v Jabril Willis>Uh, to many people, this may simply sound like another development name attached to another funding source, uh, but to me, Ruby and Mack were real people.

928
01:37:03.130 --> 01:37:11.210
<v Jabril Willis>Ruby Hobson and Mac Hobson were my wife's grandparents, 2 Black Americans who migrated from the rural South to Portland looking for opportunity.

929
01:37:11.369 --> 01:37:20.210
<v Jabril Willis>They worked in Vanport and raised their family in North Portland during a time that simply having stability, dignity, and ownership in anything for Black people was not something that was guaranteed.

930
01:37:20.569 --> 01:37:35.050
<v Jabril Willis>And I know that never in their wildest dreams could they have imagined that the same area connected to Vanport, a place remembered for one of the most devastating tragedies in Oregon history, would ultimately be a place that was named after them and then also be an opportunity for Black folks to own homes.

931
01:37:37.210 --> 01:37:46.170
<v Jabril Willis>In that time, that would probably have sounded like a fantasy to them because for generations, homeownership in Portland for Black families has sounded like exactly that, a fantasy.

932
01:37:48.489 --> 01:37:56.489
<v Jabril Willis>My wife and I were fortunate enough to purchase a home in 2018, largely because I served 6 years in the United States Army and I was able to use a VA home loan.

933
01:37:56.970 --> 01:38:03.430
<v Jabril Willis>The sacrifices I made for this country, including 2 tours of Afghanistan, allowed me access to doors that many families do not.

934
01:38:03.989 --> 01:38:06.229
<v Jabril Willis>And I realized something after becoming a homeowner.

935
01:38:06.630 --> 01:38:07.750
<v Jabril Willis>The problem wasn't just housing.

936
01:38:08.149 --> 01:38:11.270
<v Jabril Willis>The problem was access, advocacy, information, and representation.

937
01:38:12.310 --> 01:38:27.270
<v Jabril Willis>This realization led me to not only dedicate 10 years of my life to serving youth and families with my work through SEI, but I also became a licensed real estate agent in Oregon and Washington because I understood that if we're not in the room, decisions are often made for us without us.

938
01:38:27.670 --> 01:38:27.909
<v Jabril Willis>Thank you.

939
01:38:28.079 --> 01:38:37.319
<v Jabril Willis>And I can tell you this, that the projects like this have already been talked about throughout our community, and our community has already taken steps today to make sure that they are homeowners tomorrow.

940
01:38:38.239 --> 01:38:41.680
<v Jabril Willis>Please do not let this become another thing that we almost did.

941
01:38:42.000 --> 01:38:44.479
<v Jabril Willis>Our communities have experienced too many broken promises.

942
01:38:44.560 --> 01:38:53.680
<v Jabril Willis>We were promised opportunity before, yet the entire Black neighborhoods were displaced through the expansion of Memorial Coliseum, the freeways, and the hospitals.

943
01:38:54.079 --> 01:38:55.920
<v Jabril Willis>So much that my brother has said before.

944
01:38:56.800 --> 01:39:01.199
<v Jabril Willis>We cannot undo the past, but we can absolutely have the power to impact the future.

945
01:39:02.159 --> 01:39:10.720
<v Jabril Willis>You have the opportunity to help level the playing field, to change the trajectory of generational wealth, and to give working Black families an opportunity that for far too long has felt unreachable.

946
01:39:11.840 --> 01:39:19.520
<v Jabril Willis>And there's something deeply poetic about taking a place connected to the pain and flooding of Vanport and transforming it into a future homeownership.

947
01:39:19.680 --> 01:39:19.920
<v Jabril Willis>Thank you.

948
01:39:20.340 --> 01:39:23.699
<v Jabril Willis>Future stability, and future blessings for generations of Black families.

949
01:39:24.579 --> 01:39:27.460
<v Jabril Willis>I've often heard the phrase, I am the dream of my ancestors.

950
01:39:29.619 --> 01:39:36.579
<v Jabril Willis>Today I stand before you as proof of that dream, and I'm asking that you help to make that— make sure that that dream remains possible for others as well.

951
01:39:37.460 --> 01:39:42.579
<v Jabril Willis>Please support Commissioner Loretta Smith's proposal and approve the full funding amount for both housing projects.

952
01:39:43.060 --> 01:39:43.300
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

953
01:39:43.699 --> 01:39:45.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

954
01:39:52.109 --> 01:39:55.310
<v Mark Jackson>Thank you, uh, Council President Dunphy and all of the council today.

955
01:39:55.470 --> 01:40:02.590
<v Mark Jackson>I want to, uh, just begin by saying I'm Pastor Mark Jackson, uh, the co-founder, uh, co-pastor of Voices of Praise International Ministries.

956
01:40:02.590 --> 01:40:20.539
<v Mark Jackson>Also, I'm also on the board of the Coalition of African and African-American Pastors, EWAMPS, and I want to thank Councilor Smith, uh, for your leadership And for your courage and for modeling what it is to be a city public servant, not just focused on your district but the entire city of Portland.

957
01:40:20.979 --> 01:40:33.020
<v Mark Jackson>I'm here today not to persuade but to encourage, because I truly believe you all have the conviction to do what is right and what is just for Black Portlanders.

958
01:40:33.619 --> 01:40:38.100
<v Mark Jackson>You have all the information you need to make an informed Thank you.

959
01:40:39.899 --> 01:40:42.340
<v Mark Jackson>But this vote is not transactional.

960
01:40:43.340 --> 01:40:52.979
<v Mark Jackson>This vote is a commitment to restorative justice and generational wealth for Black Portlanders.

961
01:40:53.819 --> 01:41:11.739
<v Mark Jackson>What will the future— your grandchildren, your nieces, your nephews— say about you On this day and where you stand, for you've been empowered to be in elected office to reconcile some wrongs.

962
01:41:11.899 --> 01:41:23.939
<v Mark Jackson>And today is your opportunity to be on full display, to let Portland know you have courage, not just individual courage, but collective courage.

963
01:41:24.380 --> 01:41:36.149
<v Mark Jackson>The signs you see in this chamber, we are descendants We are descendants of those who were displaced in the historic Albina District.

964
01:41:37.109 --> 01:41:39.829
<v Mark Jackson>We are here and we're not going anywhere.

965
01:41:41.109 --> 01:41:43.029
<v Mark Jackson>Support these housing projects.

966
01:41:44.470 --> 01:41:45.670
<v Mark Jackson>Support William and Russell.

967
01:41:46.710 --> 01:41:47.430
<v Mark Jackson>Support SCI.

968
01:41:48.069 --> 01:41:49.909
<v Mark Jackson>It's proven and it's documented.

969
01:41:50.229 --> 01:41:50.550
<v Tanisha Renee>Thank you.

970
01:41:51.510 --> 01:41:53.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

971
01:41:56.319 --> 01:41:56.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ben, go ahead.

972
01:41:57.359 --> 01:41:58.319
<v Mitch Green>My name is Benjamin Gilbert.

973
01:41:58.720 --> 01:42:04.399
<v Mitch Green>I am a tenant in District 4 and a volunteer lobbyist for the Portland Democratic Socialists of America.

974
01:42:05.439 --> 01:42:13.439
<v Mitch Green>I want to speak in favor of this appropriation for SEI Williamson— uh, slash Williams and Russell, as amended by Kanal-Smith, Murillo, Dunphy 1.

975
01:42:14.640 --> 01:42:20.000
<v Mitch Green>I strongly support removing social housing as the funding source and using the construction excise tax revenue instead.

976
01:42:20.739 --> 01:42:24.539
<v Mitch Green>This is a viable source for funding SEI and Williams and Russell projects.

977
01:42:24.979 --> 01:42:31.420
<v Mitch Green>We hope for the success of these projects and the community members who will benefit and urge councilors to support the use of the CET.

978
01:42:31.619 --> 01:42:35.699
<v Mitch Green>I want to thank Councilor Smith for co-sponsoring a change to this funding source.

979
01:42:35.859 --> 01:42:42.859
<v Mitch Green>By using CET, we don't take away from a funding source that was created to fund permanently affordable housing, social housing.

980
01:42:43.539 --> 01:42:49.859
<v Mitch Green>It is paramount that we expand municipal capacity for the development of social housing, not further hollow it out.

981
01:42:50.739 --> 01:42:53.140
<v Mitch Green>Shelter doesn't need to be another speculative asset for capital.

982
01:42:54.100 --> 01:42:57.060
<v Mitch Green>Renting can and should be a stable arrangement for tenants.

983
01:42:57.539 --> 01:43:03.939
<v Mitch Green>If we are serious about the economic future of our city and the wealth building of all Portlanders, we cannot rely on speculation.

984
01:43:04.500 --> 01:43:05.460
<v Mitch Green>A better world is possible.

985
01:43:06.340 --> 01:43:16.689
<v Mitch Green>A world where leases can be passed on to your children, where rent is controlled and rent burden is a distant memory, and where our neighbors are housed Thank you very much.

986
01:43:18.529 --> 01:43:18.930
<v Keelan McClymont>Tanisha.

987
01:43:20.369 --> 01:43:21.090
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, good morning.

988
01:43:21.569 --> 01:43:26.689
<v Tanisha Renee>My name is Tanisha Renee, and I am the Deputy Executive Director at Williams and Russell CDC.

989
01:43:27.250 --> 01:43:30.930
<v Tanisha Renee>And I just want to echo the sentiments of my colleagues that have already shared.

990
01:43:31.329 --> 01:43:33.649
<v Tanisha Renee>This is not just about housing, this is about repair.

991
01:43:34.449 --> 01:43:38.890
<v Tanisha Renee>And for generations, Albina and Vanport were central to Black life in Portland.

992
01:43:39.210 --> 01:43:44.890
<v Tanisha Renee>These are places where Black families built community, raised children, opened business, worshiped, and thrived.

993
01:43:45.289 --> 01:43:56.130
<v Tanisha Renee>And those roots were disrupted by deliberate public decisions that displaced Black Portlanders, excluding families from homeownership and weakened pathways to generational wealth.

994
01:43:56.649 --> 01:43:59.210
<v Tanisha Renee>We are still living with the impact of those decisions.

995
01:43:59.289 --> 01:44:01.449
<v Tanisha Renee>We see it in the racial homeownership gap.

996
01:44:01.850 --> 01:44:09.989
<v Tanisha Renee>We see it in housing instability, and we see it in limited opportunities for Black families to buy homes, keep their homes and pass those homes down.

997
01:44:11.350 --> 01:44:15.189
<v Tanisha Renee>This is why investment in SEI and Williams and Russell's development matters so much.

998
01:44:15.510 --> 01:44:23.430
<v Tanisha Renee>These projects are rooted in historically significant communities that were deeply impacted by displacement and past public policy decisions.

999
01:44:24.229 --> 01:44:31.989
<v Tanisha Renee>And for many first-time homebuyers, especially those who've been denied access, pushed out, or left behind, the purchase price is still the barrier.

1000
01:44:32.789 --> 01:44:34.760
<v Tanisha Renee>This investment will help us close that gap.

1001
01:44:35.319 --> 01:44:44.359
<v Tanisha Renee>And I really just want to urge council to support the funding to help families come home, stay rooted, and build true generational wealth and be able to pass that down.

1002
01:44:44.920 --> 01:44:56.439
<v Tanisha Renee>I also want to thank Councilor Smith for your unwavering support of the Black community and our work, and really thank the rest of the council too for coming together and being able to collaborate and work together.

1003
01:44:57.000 --> 01:44:59.000
<v Tanisha Renee>Thank you for your time, and I appreciate it.

1004
01:44:59.319 --> 01:44:59.479
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1005
01:45:00.930 --> 01:45:02.489
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you very much.

1006
01:45:04.689 --> 01:45:17.609
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, uh, John Washington, Phil Berlin, Michael Johnson, Tyler King, Veronica Oro.

1007
01:45:17.890 --> 01:45:19.250
<v Keelan McClymont>I see we have John online.

1008
01:45:19.970 --> 01:45:21.289
<v Keelan McClymont>Go ahead, John.

1009
01:45:22.210 --> 01:45:23.250
<v John Washington>Good morning, Council.

1010
01:45:24.529 --> 01:45:29.729
<v John Washington>My name is John Washington, and I'm toggling between 2 Uh, board meetings right, right now.

1011
01:45:29.890 --> 01:45:34.850
<v John Washington>But, but it's ironic that I'm sitting, uh, in the board meeting with PCRI.

1012
01:45:36.130 --> 01:45:54.850
<v John Washington>Um, and you know, what draws to mind, um, first of all, I'd like to also appreciate my district reps. And, um, you know, I appreciate you guys coming to the forefront on these issues and staying you know, in the game with them.

1013
01:45:55.090 --> 01:46:00.210
<v John Washington>And of course, Loretta Smith, in the work, the tireless work that I see that you've been doing.

1014
01:46:00.449 --> 01:46:13.890
<v John Washington>And as I continue to think about Maxine Fitzpatrick, um, and she used to always say to me that affordable housing is, is not— the intention of affordable housing is not to have it in perpetuity.

1015
01:46:14.689 --> 01:46:26.560
<v John Washington>But what she was also trying to say, that there needed to be a structure around affordable housing that ensured inspired people and gave people hope to continue to aspire toward the American dream.

1016
01:46:26.760 --> 01:46:40.479
<v John Washington>And the one thing that I've witnessed and we've been a part of— I also am the executive director of the Soul District, or the North Northeast Business Association, one of the largest business districts in, in the city.

1017
01:46:40.680 --> 01:47:00.520
<v John Washington>But what we've come to understand is that the Williams and Russell project is one of the most comprehensive projects that we've seen today, because not only does it afford people housing, it also affords people the opportunity to dream and the opportunity to advance their lives.

1018
01:47:00.600 --> 01:47:06.920
<v John Washington>You can come into affordable housing structures, you can— you're surrounded by the opportunity to grow into homeownership.

1019
01:47:07.000 --> 01:47:14.270
<v John Washington>And if you have a vision for whatever it is that you want to accomplish in this, in this, in this world, You also have a business hub.

1020
01:47:14.590 --> 01:47:16.869
<v John Washington>You can achieve your dreams.

1021
01:47:17.550 --> 01:47:26.430
<v John Washington>What I support is the fact that this project is probably one of the most comprehensive projects that I've been able to be a part of, and I'm proud to be a part of it.

1022
01:47:26.590 --> 01:47:41.630
<v John Washington>But I'm also proud to see how long over a span of time— and I've been watching these processes for the last 40 years— and where we've come to today is probably one of the most important, significant times that we've arrived to.

1023
01:47:41.630 --> 01:47:41.789
<v John Washington>Thank you.

1024
01:47:42.329 --> 01:47:52.090
<v John Washington>I'd like to encourage the council to make sure that they make the right decision today in supporting these 2 projects and making sure that we're on the road to recovery.

1025
01:47:52.890 --> 01:47:55.289
<v John Washington>I appreciate it, and thank you all for allowing me to share with you.

1026
01:47:56.010 --> 01:47:57.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here today.

1027
01:48:04.810 --> 01:48:07.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Somebody jump in, whoever wants to go first.

1028
01:48:07.380 --> 01:48:07.859
<v Keelan McClymont>Good morning.

1029
01:48:10.020 --> 01:48:11.460
<v Phil Berlin>All right, good morning.

1030
01:48:12.659 --> 01:48:17.539
<v Phil Berlin>President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of the council, my name is Phil Berlin.

1031
01:48:17.619 --> 01:48:20.579
<v Phil Berlin>I serve as a housing coordinator with Self Enhancement.

1032
01:48:20.739 --> 01:48:24.020
<v Phil Berlin>In 1978, my mother moved to this country.

1033
01:48:24.180 --> 01:48:29.300
<v Phil Berlin>She rented the same home for more than 10 years before having the opportunity to purchase it.

1034
01:48:29.380 --> 01:48:34.020
<v Phil Berlin>And now today, this home is still in our family and her grandchildren are beginning their lives there.

1035
01:48:34.550 --> 01:48:36.510
<v Phil Berlin>That is the power of homeownership.

1036
01:48:36.710 --> 01:48:40.949
<v Phil Berlin>It creates stability, roots, and the opportunity for generational wealth.

1037
01:48:41.109 --> 01:48:45.350
<v Phil Berlin>Now, at the same time, that opportunity has not been accessible, equally accessible.

1038
01:48:45.590 --> 01:48:57.069
<v Phil Berlin>The city of Portland has a history of policies and practices that have suppressed African American homeownership, denying families access to the very pathways that build wealth in this country.

1039
01:48:57.350 --> 01:49:00.630
<v Phil Berlin>Homeownership is a primary vehicle for generational wealth.

1040
01:49:00.630 --> 01:49:00.869
<v Phil Berlin>Thank you.

1041
01:49:01.319 --> 01:49:07.000
<v Phil Berlin>And when African Americans are excluded from that system, the impact is felt for generations.

1042
01:49:07.159 --> 01:49:10.920
<v Phil Berlin>That's why projects like the Ruby Mack development matter.

1043
01:49:11.159 --> 01:49:12.680
<v Phil Berlin>This is more than just housing.

1044
01:49:12.680 --> 01:49:20.520
<v Phil Berlin>It's an opportunity to restore part of Portland's Black community and to create real pathways towards generational wealth.

1045
01:49:20.600 --> 01:49:22.680
<v Phil Berlin>Let's be honest about the affordability.

1046
01:49:22.920 --> 01:49:26.760
<v Phil Berlin>Right now, these homes are targeted for those who are about 80% AMI.

1047
01:49:27.069 --> 01:49:28.590
<v Phil Berlin>That's around $100,000 a year.

1048
01:49:29.630 --> 01:49:31.789
<v Phil Berlin>That does not reflect the reality of our workforce.

1049
01:49:32.510 --> 01:49:40.029
<v Phil Berlin>Many of the very people providing housing and social services in this city, including myself, earn closer to $50,000 to $60,000 a year.

1050
01:49:40.909 --> 01:49:45.069
<v Phil Berlin>If we want equity, we have to build it for the people who are doing the work.

1051
01:49:45.710 --> 01:49:58.699
<v Phil Berlin>This investment would lower home prices by $30,000 to $50,000, bringing them closer to what is actually financially affordable and moves towards a bigger goal of making them accessible for those who are at 50 to 60% of AMI.

1052
01:49:59.579 --> 01:50:15.739
<v Phil Berlin>So I urge you to support this investment in the Ruby Mack project and in African American homeownership, because it's not just about housing, it's about access, equality, and— excuse me, access, equity, and the ability for families like mine to build something that lasts.

1053
01:50:16.140 --> 01:50:16.699
<v Phil Berlin>Thank you very much.

1054
01:50:17.979 --> 01:50:18.140
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1055
01:50:18.149 --> 01:50:19.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here.

1056
01:50:21.750 --> 01:50:22.229
<v Mikel Johnson>Tatamewi.

1057
01:50:22.630 --> 01:50:23.590
<v Mikel Johnson>Good morning, councilors.

1058
01:50:23.909 --> 01:50:29.109
<v Mikel Johnson>My name is Mikel Johnson, and I am an enrolled member of the Nez Perce Tribe and a direct descendant of Old Chief Joseph.

1059
01:50:29.829 --> 01:50:40.630
<v Mikel Johnson>I'm here today on behalf of the Northwest Native Chamber and the Community Economic Coalition to ask for your support of Councilor Smith's proposal of $2.5 million in one-time funding for housing.

1060
01:50:41.430 --> 01:50:47.800
<v Mikel Johnson>The Community Economic Coalition is a partnership between the Black, Hispanic, Native, and Philippine Chambers of Commerce.

1061
01:50:48.680 --> 01:50:53.000
<v Mikel Johnson>Our mission is to transform the economic landscape and build intergenerational wealth.

1062
01:50:53.720 --> 01:50:58.119
<v Mikel Johnson>We are deeply grateful for the council's continued support of our economic development agenda.

1063
01:50:59.079 --> 01:51:02.920
<v Mikel Johnson>However, business support is only one piece of the larger picture.

1064
01:51:03.720 --> 01:51:07.479
<v Mikel Johnson>Every day we hear from clients who are devastated by the rising cost of living.

1065
01:51:08.199 --> 01:51:20.800
<v Mikel Johnson>Housing instability creates a ripple effect for low- and middle-income Portlanders And without a stable place to call home, pursuing education, maintaining employment, and building financial resilience becomes nearly impossible.

1066
01:51:21.119 --> 01:51:26.560
<v Mikel Johnson>Simply put, homeownership is a critical economic development and growth issue.

1067
01:51:26.720 --> 01:51:39.439
<v Mikel Johnson>Without housing stability, our clients remain trapped in a daily struggle to meet ends meet, and it leaves them without the capacity to pursue business opportunities that uplift families and drive Portland's grassroots economic recovery.

1068
01:51:40.670 --> 01:51:46.670
<v Mikel Johnson>As Indigenous and Black people, we are not merely secondary characters to the story of this nation.

1069
01:51:46.829 --> 01:52:03.869
<v Mikel Johnson>Rather, we are the foundation of all that is and ever was, and we therefore urge you to support the supplemental budget ordinance directly supporting the $2.5 million in unallocated funds toward affordable housing and community development projects that promote homeownership.

1070
01:52:03.949 --> 01:52:05.390
<v Mikel Johnson>Thank you for your time and consideration.

1071
01:52:05.470 --> 01:52:05.710
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1072
01:52:06.600 --> 01:52:07.159
<v Andrew Fortgang>Thank you very much.

1073
01:52:08.680 --> 01:52:12.119
<v Veronica Oro>Greetings, President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of the council.

1074
01:52:13.159 --> 01:52:29.720
<v Veronica Oro>I am Dr. Veronica Oro, a senior data research and analysis specialist at Self Enhancement, Inc. My expertise is in developmental psychology, and I adopt a bioecological lens to examine the myriad dynamic and multi-structural factors that influence human growth and development.

1075
01:52:30.760 --> 01:52:49.250
<v Veronica Oro>Bioecological psychological theory states that human development is guided by characteristics intrinsic to the individual, such as personality, factors in the immediate environment, such as the family and home, and macrostructural influences, such as the very city ordinance I am here today to discuss.

1076
01:52:49.409 --> 01:52:57.010
<v Veronica Oro>The decisions you make here have resounding impacts on community members and can alter developmental trajectories for better or for worse.

1077
01:52:57.579 --> 01:53:00.460
<v Veronica Oro>Particularly for the most vulnerable among us.

1078
01:53:00.539 --> 01:53:08.859
<v Veronica Oro>An individual may have all the grit in the world, but can they truly thrive when systemic barriers hold strong, the proverbial foot on their neck?

1079
01:53:08.939 --> 01:53:22.859
<v Veronica Oro>You may not have the power to fully lift this, but you are equipped to relieve it by supporting Black homeownership in Portland, a mechanism through which— a mechanism through which— excuse me.

1080
01:53:24.289 --> 01:53:30.930
<v Veronica Oro>Um, generational wealth, economic mobility can be built and sustained in an equitable way.

1081
01:53:31.810 --> 01:53:38.050
<v Veronica Oro>I'm a fairly new resident of Portland, having moved to Oregon in 2021 and Portland specifically in 2024.

1082
01:53:38.609 --> 01:53:46.930
<v Veronica Oro>I am originally from New Orleans, a city that owes all that it is beloved for, for food, music, hospitality, to the rich Black culture there.

1083
01:53:47.010 --> 01:53:56.300
<v Veronica Oro>I was hesitant to move here for a job assignment as a Latina, fearful of the culture shock and of experiencing exclusion in a city known for the hashtag Portland So White.

1084
01:53:56.939 --> 01:54:04.779
<v Veronica Oro>However, in the short time that I have lived here, I have found strong community and have come to know what a falsehood the national perception of Portland is.

1085
01:54:05.659 --> 01:54:09.500
<v Veronica Oro>SEI played a large part in altering, altering my own perception.

1086
01:54:10.380 --> 01:54:26.949
<v Veronica Oro>I have the great pleasure of working for an organization that is a steward of racial racial justice in Portland, leveraging culturally informed practices rooted in 45 years of on-the-ground work in our community to connect with Black youth and families and bolster them in actualizing their full potential.

1087
01:54:27.909 --> 01:54:31.350
<v Veronica Oro>Our hub is in the Northeast, home to Portland's historic Black neighborhoods.

1088
01:54:31.829 --> 01:54:38.390
<v Veronica Oro>However, I can't help but notice the very people we are meant to serve in close proximity being pushed out in real time.

1089
01:54:39.430 --> 01:54:47.550
<v Veronica Oro>Clients are being forced to relocate due to the housing affordability crisis further away from critical resources and community that uplifts them.

1090
01:54:48.430 --> 01:54:56.670
<v Veronica Oro>I shudder at the thought that the cultural fabric of this city could be rendered homogeneous and one-note if this gentrification continues to go unchecked.

1091
01:54:57.470 --> 01:55:00.270
<v Veronica Oro>I implore you to support Councilor Loretta Smith's amendment.

1092
01:55:01.069 --> 01:55:11.550
<v Veronica Oro>Do your part to advance Black home ownership and economic mobility in Portland and entrust nonprofit nonprofit partners with proven track records in the community to serve as the stewards of this mission.

1093
01:55:11.710 --> 01:55:13.310
<v Veronica Oro>Thank you for your time and consideration.

1094
01:55:14.590 --> 01:55:16.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

1095
01:55:17.069 --> 01:55:21.470
<v Tyler King>Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, members of council, my name is Tyler King.

1096
01:55:21.470 --> 01:55:27.310
<v Tyler King>I'm a principal broker and a realtor here in Portland and a proud member of the Portland Metropolitan Association of Realtors.

1097
01:55:27.470 --> 01:55:29.229
<v Tyler King>I'm here in support of this ordinance.

1098
01:55:29.390 --> 01:55:36.409
<v Tyler King>Homeownership is a proven path to reduce poverty, Stabilize neighborhoods and set families up for success for generations to come.

1099
01:55:36.569 --> 01:55:40.890
<v Tyler King>And this puts real money behind that idea in exactly the right places.

1100
01:55:41.050 --> 01:55:45.850
<v Tyler King>But I do want to touch on the broader picture because I do think it matters.

1101
01:55:46.170 --> 01:55:48.489
<v Tyler King>Rental assistance is an operating expense.

1102
01:55:48.729 --> 01:55:51.609
<v Tyler King>Down payment assistance is a capital investment.

1103
01:55:51.689 --> 01:55:54.250
<v Tyler King>One stabilizes a household for a lease cycle.

1104
01:55:54.409 --> 01:55:56.810
<v Tyler King>The other transforms it for generations.

1105
01:55:56.970 --> 01:56:01.210
<v Tyler King>The United States is the only country where a family can lock in a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage.

1106
01:56:01.210 --> 01:56:02.250
<v Tyler King>It's as American as apple pie.

1107
01:56:02.329 --> 01:56:02.569
<v Tyler King>Thank you.

1108
01:56:03.270 --> 01:56:08.470
<v Tyler King>A buyer closing today knows exactly what their principal and interest payment will be in 2055.

1109
01:56:08.710 --> 01:56:15.270
<v Tyler King>No lease renewal surprises, no pet rent, no wondering if assistance will be renewed in the next budget cycle.

1110
01:56:15.430 --> 01:56:18.470
<v Tyler King>And while making that predictable payment, they are building wealth.

1111
01:56:18.550 --> 01:56:22.789
<v Tyler King>The typical net worth of homeowners nationally is $430,000.

1112
01:56:23.029 --> 01:56:24.869
<v Tyler King>For renters, it's $10,000.

1113
01:56:24.869 --> 01:56:26.710
<v Tyler King>That's a 43-to-1 gap.

1114
01:56:26.949 --> 01:56:30.750
<v Tyler King>That is how generational wealth is built, or conversely, Not built.

1115
01:56:30.989 --> 01:56:34.750
<v Tyler King>Many on the City Council have been working to expand its government housing footprint.

1116
01:56:34.829 --> 01:56:38.350
<v Tyler King>I understand the appeal, but government housing manages poverty.

1117
01:56:38.350 --> 01:56:39.550
<v Tyler King>It does not end it.

1118
01:56:39.710 --> 01:56:41.829
<v Tyler King>Creating a floor is well-intentioned.

1119
01:56:42.109 --> 01:56:44.430
<v Tyler King>We also need to provide a ladder.

1120
01:56:44.750 --> 01:56:49.470
<v Tyler King>Down payment assistance in projects like we're talking about today is that ladder.

1121
01:56:49.630 --> 01:56:54.430
<v Tyler King>The Williams and Russell project and Self-Enhancement Inc. project both include homeownership units.

1122
01:56:54.510 --> 01:57:00.670
<v Tyler King>When a family in North or Northeast Portland closes on a home, they are not receiving a subsidy that will need to be renewed next year.

1123
01:57:00.920 --> 01:57:02.119
<v Tyler King>They are building equity.

1124
01:57:02.199 --> 01:57:04.119
<v Tyler King>They are building something to pass down.

1125
01:57:04.279 --> 01:57:08.920
<v Tyler King>They are doing what families displaced from those same neighborhoods never got a chance to do.

1126
01:57:09.079 --> 01:57:11.560
<v Tyler King>I do want to name one thing plainly.

1127
01:57:11.720 --> 01:57:18.199
<v Tyler King>The city is proposing to spend $10 million becoming a landlord while spending $800,000 helping people build generational wealth.

1128
01:57:18.359 --> 01:57:21.319
<v Tyler King>That is a policy choice, and I think it's the wrong one.

1129
01:57:21.479 --> 01:57:29.880
<v Tyler King>Every dollar in down payment assistance creates a private asset, permanently removes the household— removes a household from the subsidy treadmill, and frees up a rental unit in the process.

1130
01:57:30.039 --> 01:57:30.279
<v Tyler King>Thank you.

1131
01:57:30.930 --> 01:57:33.329
<v Tyler King>Approve this ordinance and then please do more of this.

1132
01:57:33.329 --> 01:57:37.729
<v Tyler King>And a special thank you to Councilor Smith for her continued leadership in bringing this forward.

1133
01:57:37.810 --> 01:57:42.130
<v Tyler King>And I want to point you to PMAR's letter of support of this as well.

1134
01:57:42.210 --> 01:57:42.609
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1135
01:57:42.689 --> 01:57:44.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1136
01:57:46.210 --> 01:57:46.689
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up—.

1137
01:57:47.810 --> 01:57:48.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, sorry.

1138
01:57:48.770 --> 01:57:49.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>They can go sit down.

1139
01:57:51.250 --> 01:57:52.409
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1140
01:57:53.090 --> 01:57:55.810
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Henry Sheffer.

1141
01:57:56.060 --> 01:58:00.140
<v Keelan McClymont>Hope Baraka, Lorena Guyette, Justice Reggie.

1142
01:58:02.699 --> 01:58:03.100
<v Keelan McClymont>Go ahead, Henry.

1143
01:58:04.300 --> 01:58:05.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi, hi, thank you.

1144
01:58:05.500 --> 01:58:07.100
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, recognize Henry Shepherd.

1145
01:58:07.180 --> 01:58:07.899
<v Jabril Willis>I'm a—.

1146
01:58:08.060 --> 01:58:10.539
<v Keelan McClymont>Hey, Henry, sorry, we're having trouble hearing you.

1147
01:58:14.779 --> 01:58:16.140
<v Henry Sheffer>Um, is that better?

1148
01:58:16.939 --> 01:58:18.739
<v Keelan McClymont>It's still really quiet.

1149
01:58:22.149 --> 01:58:25.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, that's sounding better already.

1150
01:58:26.470 --> 01:58:26.949
<v Dan Ryan>Just a little closer.

1151
01:58:27.590 --> 01:58:27.829
<v Keelan McClymont>That's better.

1152
01:58:28.149 --> 01:58:28.470
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1153
01:58:28.869 --> 01:58:30.390
<v Henry Sheffer>Well, thank you for— thank you for letting me know.

1154
01:58:30.789 --> 01:58:32.949
<v Henry Sheffer>Hi, I'm, uh, for the record, my name is Henry Sheffer.

1155
01:58:33.109 --> 01:58:34.710
<v Henry Sheffer>I'm a renter in District 2 up here.

1156
01:58:35.109 --> 01:58:41.109
<v Henry Sheffer>Um, so first I'd like to say, uh, Self Enhancement Incorporated does really wonderful work for our community.

1157
01:58:41.989 --> 01:58:47.189
<v Henry Sheffer>Um, and I think we can all agree that we want to increase rates of Black and Indigenous homeownership in this neighborhood.

1158
01:58:48.029 --> 01:58:53.310
<v Henry Sheffer>If you've looked at any of our data, you know that we have really high rates of rentership in North Portland.

1159
01:58:54.750 --> 01:59:08.029
<v Henry Sheffer>However, I'm here to support the amendment, I believe, introduced by Councilors Dunphy, Murillo, Kanal, and Smith, to instead of taking that money from the revolving loan fund, to instead take it from the construction excise tax review instead.

1160
01:59:09.869 --> 01:59:21.289
<v Henry Sheffer>I think it's a mistake to pit social housing against Homeownership assistance because those communities, really all communities in Portland, are going to benefit from both of those things.

1161
01:59:24.250 --> 01:59:27.130
<v Henry Sheffer>Yeah, sorry, that's most of what I have to say.

1162
01:59:27.529 --> 01:59:39.689
<v Henry Sheffer>Yeah, I think the the revolving loan fund is going to create a long-term sustainable way of sort of helping renters who do not have.

1163
01:59:40.569 --> 01:59:55.289
<v Henry Sheffer>A lot of recourse in other ways by introducing forces onto the rental market that will stop this ever-increasing exponential growth of rate— rent rates that we see at the moment, which homeownership will hopefully also do.

1164
01:59:56.729 --> 02:00:01.130
<v Henry Sheffer>So I don't think we should really be putting— pitting these 2 things against each other.

1165
02:00:02.649 --> 02:00:05.770
<v Henry Sheffer>I think they're both really reasonable solutions that should both be invested in.

1166
02:00:07.149 --> 02:00:12.590
<v Henry Sheffer>So, um, I'm here to support the amendment that takes it from the construction excise tax instead.

1167
02:00:13.310 --> 02:00:14.270
<v Henry Sheffer>Um, thank you.

1168
02:00:14.430 --> 02:00:14.989
<v Henry Sheffer>I cede my time.

1169
02:00:15.390 --> 02:00:16.109
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1170
02:00:17.710 --> 02:00:17.789
<v Bea Gilmore>Hope.

1171
02:00:21.710 --> 02:00:24.670
<v Hope Baraka>Good morning, Council President and members of City Council.

1172
02:00:25.550 --> 02:00:35.229
<v Hope Baraka>My name is Hope Baraka, and I'm here today in strong support of the ordinance appropriating $2.5 million for homeownership development in District thank you.

1173
02:00:40.710 --> 02:00:45.670
<v Hope Baraka>I have worked in residential and commercial real estate in Portland's urban core for 20 years.

1174
02:00:46.310 --> 02:00:56.949
<v Hope Baraka>I currently own and manage Think Real Estate, and our brokerage is affiliated with Williams Russell CDC as the brokerage of record, working alongside Portland Housing Center.

1175
02:00:58.390 --> 02:01:08.210
<v Hope Baraka>I am speaking both as a real estate professional and as someone directly involved in the practical work of helping families move from aspiration to ownership.

1176
02:01:08.649 --> 02:01:18.409
<v Hope Baraka>As you've heard, homeownership remains one of the primary ways families build generational wealth, but access to that wealth-building tool has never been equal.

1177
02:01:18.729 --> 02:01:27.250
<v Hope Baraka>Black Portlanders own homes at nearly half the rate as white Portlanders, and those statistics have barely changed over 60 years.

1178
02:01:27.529 --> 02:01:29.529
<v Hope Baraka>That is not an accident of the market.

1179
02:01:29.729 --> 02:01:31.329
<v Hope Baraka>And it's not in the past.

1180
02:01:31.489 --> 02:01:39.289
<v Hope Baraka>It's a result of policy, lending discrimination, redlining, displacement, appraisal bias, predatory lending.

1181
02:01:39.810 --> 02:01:43.409
<v Hope Baraka>And the loss is staggering when you look at the broader wealth gap.

1182
02:01:43.569 --> 02:01:50.569
<v Hope Baraka>The median white household holds roughly $240,000 more wealth than the median Black household.

1183
02:01:51.250 --> 02:01:56.050
<v Hope Baraka>The Williams and Russell project promises to utilize Portland Housing Bureau's preference policy.

1184
02:01:56.210 --> 02:01:56.449
<v Hope Baraka>Thank you.

1185
02:01:57.119 --> 02:02:00.960
<v Hope Baraka>It is one of the City of Portland's clearest tools for, for repair.

1186
02:02:02.319 --> 02:02:06.520
<v Hope Baraka>But a policy without funding is only a promise on paper.

1187
02:02:07.439 --> 02:02:20.800
<v Hope Baraka>At Williams and Russell, Black Portlanders were not just displaced from a neighborhood, they were stripped of ownership, of equity, of place, and the ability to build generational wealth where ownership should have remained in community hands.

1188
02:02:21.760 --> 02:02:22.000
<v Hope Baraka>Thank you.

1189
02:02:22.890 --> 02:02:26.250
<v Hope Baraka>The right to return has to mean more than the right to apply.

1190
02:02:27.210 --> 02:02:36.329
<v Hope Baraka>It has to include the real financial support needed for Black Portlanders to come back as homeowners, to rebuild equity, and to regain some measure of what was taken.

1191
02:02:37.609 --> 02:02:48.890
<v Hope Baraka>If Portland is serious about repair, then funding homeownership at Williams and Russell and Self-Enhancement Inc. is part of fulfilling a commitment the City of Portland has already made.

1192
02:02:48.890 --> 02:02:49.130
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1193
02:02:52.359 --> 02:02:54.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for being here.

1194
02:02:54.520 --> 02:02:55.520
<v Keelan McClymont>Lorena.

1195
02:02:59.640 --> 02:03:00.680
<v Angelita Morillo>Hi, can you hear me?

1196
02:03:00.920 --> 02:03:02.399
<v Keelan McClymont>We can hear you.

1197
02:03:02.680 --> 02:03:03.079
<v Angelita Morillo>Perfect.

1198
02:03:03.079 --> 02:03:03.720
<v Lorena Gayette>Thank you.

1199
02:03:03.880 --> 02:03:05.399
<v Lorena Gayette>My name is Lorena Gayette.

1200
02:03:05.479 --> 02:03:07.960
<v Lorena Gayette>Uh, just wanted to speak in regards to this.

1201
02:03:07.960 --> 02:03:14.680
<v Lorena Gayette>I wanted to make sure I show my initial support for the funding for housing development, especially for Black homeownership.

1202
02:03:14.609 --> 02:03:28.130
<v Lorena Gayette>Um, express some concerns at the original writing, specifically for the choice of appropriating from social housing, and really appreciating and vocalizing my support for the most recent Kanal-Smith amendment that's been introduced.

1203
02:03:29.890 --> 02:03:43.199
<v Lorena Gayette>Housing to me is deeply, deeply important, not just as someone who is a Latina, but also someone who has seen how housing has been helpful for my Afro-Latino cousins who are— who is who he is currently expecting a daughter.

1204
02:03:43.520 --> 02:03:45.279
<v Lorena Gayette>So I'm very excited for him.

1205
02:03:45.680 --> 02:03:55.359
<v Lorena Gayette>And I was really, really devastated when Kanal's amendment last week to make sure that this had funding failed to pass.

1206
02:03:55.520 --> 02:03:56.800
<v Lorena Gayette>That was really devastating.

1207
02:03:57.119 --> 02:04:02.319
<v Lorena Gayette>So I'm really grateful that this is still getting a second shot at life.

1208
02:04:02.800 --> 02:04:13.649
<v Lorena Gayette>To me, it's really, really vital to— in order to provide this type of funding for District 2, but definitely not at the expense of additional investments in other long-term solutions.

1209
02:04:14.289 --> 02:04:17.970
<v Lorena Gayette>Social housing and programs like this are both gaining traction.

1210
02:04:18.770 --> 02:04:28.609
<v Lorena Gayette>There is a wealth of data showing the benefits to social housing as well as housing for specific marginalized communities, and then there has been recent news that has shown its popularity.

1211
02:04:29.970 --> 02:04:31.569
<v Lorena Gayette>I really do appreciate the amendments.

1212
02:04:32.489 --> 02:04:42.170
<v Lorena Gayette>And I definitely can't help but feel a pause if the most recent amendments were to be rejected as well for, you know, the Smith-Kanal amendment in order to change the funding.

1213
02:04:43.210 --> 02:05:01.369
<v Lorena Gayette>And I do understand that the budgeting session this year was very stressful, so I do feel that changing the funding source from social housing to CET revenue seems to be the ideal solution for an ultimately stressful thing, and hopefully that both of these things will cause the necessary long-term solutions.

1214
02:05:01.529 --> 02:05:07.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilmember Smith, Thank you very much.

1215
02:05:12.170 --> 02:05:12.970
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, peace.

1216
02:05:13.289 --> 02:05:15.850
<v Justice Rajeev>Uh, my name is— for the record, my name is Justice Rajeev.

1217
02:05:16.170 --> 02:05:21.850
<v Justice Rajeev>Um, I am a registered lobbyist for this with the City of Portland, but I am not here in any professional capacity.

1218
02:05:21.930 --> 02:05:37.930
<v Justice Rajeev>I am here today as the current board chair of the Williams Russell CDC, but also a community member who who has served and volunteered on this project since its beginning, which is almost at 8 years if I'm correct at this point, which I would remind some of us is longer than some of us have been in elected office.

1219
02:05:38.890 --> 02:06:00.739
<v Justice Rajeev>And that's important to understand because I was one of the people who took the initial surveys on the site with the community who experienced almost 50 years of a blank slate of land that was cleared and supposed to be something, and it was the primary message, the largest message we received from the community was get something done on this site.

1220
02:06:01.699 --> 02:06:05.380
<v Justice Rajeev>And I've personally dedicated myself to make sure that happens.

1221
02:06:05.539 --> 02:06:19.060
<v Justice Rajeev>So when I'm here in front of you, I'm hoping not to repeat, you know, facts you've already heard, but to give some context to institutions such as the city government have a memory and a history that they are responsible for, regardless if they chose to do it in the past or not.

1222
02:06:19.140 --> 02:06:25.060
<v Justice Rajeev>Or they thought it was right or wrong in the past or not, or they thought they followed the right process in the past or not, you are still responsible.

1223
02:06:25.380 --> 02:06:49.979
<v Justice Rajeev>As the person in the seat, the people are looking to you, and I've said this in other spaces, to move heaven and earth to get something done the way we have seen other things that had far more resources, support, access to capital, institutional power, social power, social capital, structure around them, people with powerful names and powerful influence to make things Get done, receive all sorts of support.

1224
02:06:50.739 --> 02:06:56.659
<v Justice Rajeev>I'm also proud to say I'm a former employee of SEI and a friend to the service they provide to this community.

1225
02:06:57.939 --> 02:07:11.470
<v Justice Rajeev>And in the larger scope, in understanding the impact that not only SEI and Women for the City, but other community-based organizations have been doing in leading the way to building housing in this city, building housing in this region, because housing is not just about the city of Portland, it's about the thank you.

1226
02:07:11.550 --> 02:07:12.270
<v Justice Rajeev>It's about the entire state of Oregon.

1227
02:07:12.829 --> 02:07:14.189
<v Justice Rajeev>It's about our country as a whole.

1228
02:07:16.270 --> 02:07:28.109
<v Justice Rajeev>So with that, I— whatever the source, whatever the correct tool or mechanism to get it done, I implore you to get this done, to meet the moment, to meet the people and build the trust.

1229
02:07:28.270 --> 02:07:56.039
<v Justice Rajeev>So whatever future programs that this city wishes to hold and say, we're going to deliver on this next idea, we're going to deliver on social housing, we're going to deliver on market rate, whatever that completes testimony.

1230
02:07:56.920 --> 02:08:01.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, it is currently 1— or I'm sorry, 11:33.

1231
02:08:01.560 --> 02:08:07.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would like to give everybody a 15-minute bathroom break, so if we could please be back here at What is that, 11:50?

1232
02:08:09.380 --> 02:08:11.380
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have a long agenda to go.

1233
02:08:12.899 --> 02:08:14.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for everybody who testified.

1234
02:08:31.220 --> 02:08:31.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1235
02:26:04.510 --> 02:26:06.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are coming back from break.

1236
02:26:06.590 --> 02:26:11.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you everybody for your patience and Thank you for your understanding that we are humans also.

1237
02:26:12.040 --> 02:26:13.440
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1238
02:26:13.959 --> 02:26:22.120
<v Sameer Kanal>Hi, I just wanted to formally move the amendment and I ask— I described it already, so I won't do it again, but I ask for a second.

1239
02:26:24.040 --> 02:26:24.440
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

1240
02:26:24.600 --> 02:26:29.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal moves the Kanal-Smith-Morillo-Dunphy amendment.

1241
02:26:29.559 --> 02:26:30.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith seconds.

1242
02:26:31.159 --> 02:26:34.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, debate to— or discussion around the amendment.

1243
02:26:36.930 --> 02:26:38.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1244
02:26:39.010 --> 02:26:40.129
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

1245
02:26:40.129 --> 02:26:46.209
<v Mitch Green>I just really want to, um, say thank you, uh, for working through it and slogging through this.

1246
02:26:46.450 --> 02:26:48.850
<v Mitch Green>Thank you to everyone who showed up once again to provide the testimony.

1247
02:26:49.809 --> 02:26:56.450
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, um, I think this is a really good example of compromise, and it gets me to a place where I can very easily say yes to this.

1248
02:26:56.530 --> 02:27:01.010
<v Mitch Green>And I see this— someone put it earlier— is we don't have to pit these 2 things against each other.

1249
02:27:01.629 --> 02:27:04.750
<v Mitch Green>We can do them both, and we're going to do them both if we vote yes on this amendment.

1250
02:27:05.309 --> 02:27:05.549
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1251
02:27:06.350 --> 02:27:07.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1252
02:27:07.629 --> 02:27:08.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1253
02:27:09.389 --> 02:27:12.110
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I'd like to ask a question of Donny Oliveira if he's here.

1254
02:27:21.629 --> 02:27:22.750
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, DC Oliveira.

1255
02:27:22.909 --> 02:27:29.489
<v Steve Novick>My question is, um, will the different funding source affect Would this have any impact on the substance or the timing of the projects at all?

1256
02:27:30.610 --> 02:27:40.049
<v Steve Novick>Depending on— I mean, if we were funding this with the revolving loan fund, would that mean any— make any difference to what the projects would have to look like or what the timing would be compared to this proposal?

1257
02:27:41.329 --> 02:27:43.170
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for the question, Councilor Don Oliveira.

1258
02:27:43.329 --> 02:27:45.569
<v Mitch Green>Deputy City Administrator for Community Economic Development.

1259
02:27:46.450 --> 02:27:47.569
<v Mitch Green>The answer to your question is no.

1260
02:27:48.129 --> 02:27:52.450
<v Mitch Green>This will not have a material impact on timing or our ability to get the resources with any restrictions.

1261
02:27:52.379 --> 02:27:53.180
<v Mitch Green>Restrictions to the projects.

1262
02:27:54.059 --> 02:27:54.379
<v John Washington>Thank you.

1263
02:27:55.819 --> 02:27:56.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1264
02:27:57.260 --> 02:27:58.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1265
02:27:59.899 --> 02:28:00.540
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1266
02:28:00.780 --> 02:28:02.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not actually sure who needs to answer this question.

1267
02:28:03.659 --> 02:28:19.040
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know that there is language in the amendment that says that some of the normal requirements of the fund are not in effect for this appropriation, but I just would like the confirmation that no changes to be made to the projects.

1268
02:28:19.600 --> 02:28:23.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are no complications about whether the project will meet any requirements or not.

1269
02:28:24.319 --> 02:28:34.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These funds can be used for the projects as they are currently conceived of, and we don't have to ask people to fit in a box that doesn't quite fit to make this work.

1270
02:28:35.440 --> 02:28:39.120
<v Jamie Dunphy>I see DCA Oliveira nodding profusely in the back of the room.

1271
02:28:40.159 --> 02:28:40.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're all good?

1272
02:28:41.360 --> 02:28:42.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1273
02:28:42.159 --> 02:28:45.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it's important to have that on the thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1274
02:28:46.149 --> 02:28:46.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1275
02:28:47.750 --> 02:28:48.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1276
02:28:48.709 --> 02:29:02.309
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to first thank Councilor Smith for having the conversation, seeing how can we take this from something that will probably happen to something that will be an overwhelming majority support, which is I think what happens when the amendment passes.

1277
02:29:02.549 --> 02:29:15.379
<v Sameer Kanal>And if, while we can't count votes up here, and so I'm not going to speculate as to how that's going to work, I will say that it wasn't just as as Sahand pointed out, it wasn't just that the Portland Metro Chamber and Welcome Home would be allying on it.

1278
02:29:15.459 --> 02:29:19.540
<v Sameer Kanal>I also heard from someone from DSA as well and the realtors and that.

1279
02:29:20.020 --> 02:29:23.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>These things, this gets more and more rare as it keeps going.

1280
02:29:24.100 --> 02:29:26.979
<v Sameer Kanal>But we should take those opportunities when they last.

1281
02:29:27.219 --> 02:29:45.680
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think the other thing, and I really appreciated the written testimony, I wanted to point out that the overwhelming majority of people who testified, it was there were people who supported, people who supported with changes, people opposed that were all— most of the opposition was about the funding source, not about the projects.

1282
02:29:45.680 --> 02:29:54.959
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think we are resolving that with this amendment and helping to unify not only the people up here, but hopefully everyone around the importance of these investments.

1283
02:29:56.079 --> 02:30:01.760
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll talk more about those after we have the— when we debate the underlying, but just wanted to say that about the amendment.

1284
02:30:01.920 --> 02:30:02.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1285
02:30:03.670 --> 02:30:08.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, is there further debate of the Canal-Smith-Murillo-Dunphy amendment?

1286
02:30:11.510 --> 02:30:13.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing none, Keelan, can we call the roll on the amendment?

1287
02:30:15.190 --> 02:30:15.430
<v Keelan McClymont>Canal.

1288
02:30:17.350 --> 02:30:17.430
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1289
02:30:18.069 --> 02:30:19.069
<v Keelan McClymont>Bertolghini.

1290
02:30:19.350 --> 02:30:19.430
<v Bea Gilmore>Aye.

1291
02:30:20.229 --> 02:30:20.389
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

1292
02:30:20.790 --> 02:30:20.870
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1293
02:30:21.510 --> 02:30:22.229
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

1294
02:30:22.389 --> 02:30:22.469
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1295
02:30:23.510 --> 02:30:23.989
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo.

1296
02:30:24.149 --> 02:30:24.229
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1297
02:30:24.950 --> 02:30:25.190
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

1298
02:30:25.510 --> 02:30:25.590
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1299
02:30:26.309 --> 02:30:26.389
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

1300
02:30:26.870 --> 02:30:26.950
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1301
02:30:27.430 --> 02:30:27.510
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

1302
02:30:27.909 --> 02:30:27.989
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1303
02:30:28.549 --> 02:30:29.030
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

1304
02:30:32.020 --> 02:30:32.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1305
02:30:35.059 --> 02:30:35.139
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1306
02:30:35.940 --> 02:30:36.020
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1307
02:30:36.739 --> 02:30:37.059
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1308
02:30:37.379 --> 02:30:37.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1309
02:30:38.420 --> 02:30:41.700
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with a vote of 11 ayes and 1 absent.

1310
02:30:47.620 --> 02:30:50.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any further discussion of the underlying amendment— underlying ordinance now?

1311
02:30:53.379 --> 02:30:53.780
<v Loretta Smith>Council President?

1312
02:30:54.500 --> 02:30:54.739
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Smith?

1313
02:30:54.899 --> 02:30:54.979
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1314
02:30:56.030 --> 02:30:58.670
<v Loretta Smith>I would just like to say something on this.

1315
02:30:59.069 --> 02:31:08.190
<v Loretta Smith>The underlying, uh, from the beginning was always, um, a document that, uh, reflect our values.

1316
02:31:09.389 --> 02:31:18.469
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that us coming together in an amendment, it shows that we value the work.

1317
02:31:18.750 --> 02:31:25.719
<v Loretta Smith>We, we value Your time, and we value what you're going to do for us in the future.

1318
02:31:26.760 --> 02:31:38.280
<v Loretta Smith>Because as we are coming together on this, and the underlying is, is actually identifying resources to, to organizations that historically have not had those investments.

1319
02:31:39.479 --> 02:31:44.440
<v Loretta Smith>And so for me today, this is very, very personal because I listened to a young woman.

1320
02:31:45.079 --> 02:31:47.639
<v Loretta Smith>My grandparents came here from, from Brooklyn, New York.

1321
02:31:47.639 --> 02:31:47.799
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1322
02:31:49.120 --> 02:31:53.600
<v Loretta Smith>To work in the Kaiser— my grandfather to work in the Kaiser shipyards.

1323
02:31:54.319 --> 02:31:55.760
<v Loretta Smith>And he was a part of Vanport.

1324
02:31:55.920 --> 02:31:57.280
<v Loretta Smith>He experienced the flood.

1325
02:31:58.719 --> 02:32:00.079
<v Loretta Smith>We were displaced.

1326
02:32:00.639 --> 02:32:04.239
<v Loretta Smith>I wasn't living then, but we were displaced from the Coliseum area.

1327
02:32:05.120 --> 02:32:09.360
<v Loretta Smith>We still have a home that we've owned for 66 years.

1328
02:32:10.719 --> 02:32:11.760
<v Loretta Smith>My aunt just passed away.

1329
02:32:11.840 --> 02:32:12.639
<v Loretta Smith>She lived in that home.

1330
02:32:12.799 --> 02:32:13.360
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, I'm sorry.

1331
02:32:13.670 --> 02:32:16.149
<v Loretta Smith>Last week, and it will stay in our family.

1332
02:32:17.190 --> 02:32:32.629
<v Loretta Smith>But, but the idea that, um, you can build generational wealth like the generational wealth that was built in my family over many, many years, that we're going to offer that opportunity to others.

1333
02:32:33.350 --> 02:32:41.729
<v Loretta Smith>49 homeownership opportunities for SEI, 20 homeownership opportunities from Williams and Russell CDC.

1334
02:32:41.889 --> 02:32:49.729
<v Loretta Smith>That's just like unheard of stuff, and produced by Black community-based developers for the Black community.

1335
02:32:50.610 --> 02:32:51.889
<v Loretta Smith>That is very rich.

1336
02:32:52.129 --> 02:32:57.329
<v Loretta Smith>And so I thank you and urge all of you to vote for the underlying amendment.

1337
02:32:57.649 --> 02:32:59.090
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you so very much.

1338
02:32:59.409 --> 02:33:00.930
<v Loretta Smith>I'm, I'm very proud today.

1339
02:33:01.170 --> 02:33:03.010
<v Loretta Smith>I'm very proud of, of my colleagues.

1340
02:33:03.969 --> 02:33:04.290
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Thank you.

1341
02:33:04.530 --> 02:33:05.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1342
02:33:05.729 --> 02:33:06.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1343
02:33:07.139 --> 02:33:07.940
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1344
02:33:08.340 --> 02:33:12.819
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, I'm sorry, I know you want to move us along, but I think we need to say a few things here.

1345
02:33:12.979 --> 02:33:13.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the time to say stuff.

1346
02:33:14.579 --> 02:33:18.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am so proud to have supported this work for a bit of time now.

1347
02:33:19.379 --> 02:33:28.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, homeownership should be an option for every single person in my district, in our city.

1348
02:33:29.860 --> 02:33:33.389
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Homeownership should be an option for every single Black Portlander.

1349
02:33:35.069 --> 02:33:46.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, repair means making up for past harm, and that means ensuring that we support the work of rebuilding lost equity through homes owned, through businesses owned.

1350
02:33:47.469 --> 02:34:03.799
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's what we're doing here today, and it is important that we acknowledge that that is what we are doing here today, because homeownership homeownership remains one of the most important pathways to building generational wealth and long-term stability in our country.

1351
02:34:05.239 --> 02:34:05.719
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It just is.

1352
02:34:07.559 --> 02:34:12.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While the earlier work on this didn't move forward, I am really glad to have the policy back in front of us today.

1353
02:34:13.159 --> 02:34:22.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while we have it before us, I want to note that this is a piece of the work, but our work on homeownership is not done after today.

1354
02:34:23.079 --> 02:34:23.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1355
02:34:23.889 --> 02:34:41.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because we know that support for wealth building, partnerships to match down payments, so many other policies are needed before we can truly say that homeownership is an option for every single person in our city.

1356
02:34:42.290 --> 02:34:45.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This does not mean that we stop supporting affordable rental units.

1357
02:34:46.129 --> 02:35:04.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It does not mean that that part of the work is not also It does not mean that we don't move forward with new innovative opportunities, but it means we stop accepting a world where some people have a choice about whether they want to rent or own a home and some people don't.

1358
02:35:06.299 --> 02:35:14.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because in the future of Portland I want to see, that's a choice every single person gets to make when they think about what is best for their family.

1359
02:35:17.030 --> 02:35:28.549
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith, thank you for keeping this on our agenda, for working with many councilors on finding a path forward that could get majority support.

1360
02:35:29.590 --> 02:35:33.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Kanal, thank you for helping to find the path that's before us today.

1361
02:35:35.110 --> 02:35:38.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I hope that this can get unanimous support today.

1362
02:35:39.670 --> 02:36:00.239
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This this feels like a real opportunity to follow through and get meaningful homeownership investments over the finish line and take one more step toward that world where every single Portlander can choose whether homeownership is the right path for them and can achieve it if it is.

1363
02:36:00.879 --> 02:36:01.200
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1364
02:36:01.840 --> 02:36:02.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1365
02:36:03.600 --> 02:36:04.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

1366
02:36:05.610 --> 02:36:06.489
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy.

1367
02:36:07.530 --> 02:36:16.649
<v Angelita Morillo>First, I want to say thank you, Councilor Smith, for bringing this forward and how heartening it was for me to see this morning that we got to co-sponsor the amendment together.

1368
02:36:17.209 --> 02:36:33.270
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's really special because we've had our tussle over this, and I think it's really special and important that at this critical moment where there are so many housing needs in the city that we are not pitting social housing against these developments because they are both So important for the community.

1369
02:36:33.989 --> 02:36:39.510
<v Angelita Morillo>So it meant a lot to me to see that partnership with you and Councilor Kanal and Councilor Dunphy.

1370
02:36:40.069 --> 02:36:43.270
<v Angelita Morillo>And I know that we had tried to bring that forward during the budget process.

1371
02:36:43.510 --> 02:36:47.110
<v Angelita Morillo>It was a very tense time with a lot of different things that we were trying to absorb.

1372
02:36:47.350 --> 02:36:51.350
<v Angelita Morillo>So I appreciate my colleagues being flexible as we get that information on that.

1373
02:36:52.790 --> 02:36:54.870
<v Angelita Morillo>And as people know, it's not a mystery.

1374
02:36:55.110 --> 02:37:09.520
<v Angelita Morillo>I've been very consistent that I think that council needs to have a specific process for how we hand out dollars, even if it is going to be a restorative program, because we need proof that the work that we're doing is going to be restorative for the community.

1375
02:37:09.760 --> 02:37:11.200
<v Angelita Morillo>And I take that very seriously.

1376
02:37:11.200 --> 02:37:12.319
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't take that lightly at all.

1377
02:37:13.440 --> 02:37:18.239
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think that I can be a little analytical in my thinking sometimes in approaching that work.

1378
02:37:19.040 --> 02:37:23.520
<v Angelita Morillo>But there's also a deep personal and emotional tie in this and how we discuss it.

1379
02:37:23.600 --> 02:37:27.760
<v Angelita Morillo>So I want to thank the folks that have flagged that, that have come and testified.

1380
02:37:27.760 --> 02:37:28.000
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1381
02:37:27.959 --> 02:37:28.120
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1382
02:37:28.200 --> 02:37:29.719
<v Angelita Morillo>And Councilor Smith for bringing that as well.

1383
02:37:32.040 --> 02:37:42.680
<v Angelita Morillo>There were, in previous votes, there were times where organizations got the funding without having to show proof, and these organizations did not.

1384
02:37:43.479 --> 02:37:46.920
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's not fair, and Councilor Smith was able to point that out consistently.

1385
02:37:47.959 --> 02:38:00.399
<v Angelita Morillo>While I consistently voted to get proof for any organization, regardless of who they are, where they came from, even if they were for my community, Because I think that is the standard by which we should be doing this work.

1386
02:38:01.520 --> 02:38:06.319
<v Angelita Morillo>I also see when it's unfair that we are doing that to certain groups and not to others.

1387
02:38:07.120 --> 02:38:16.239
<v Angelita Morillo>And so I'm very grateful that we are bringing this forward today, that the amendment has passed, and I'm grateful to the community members who have come in and testified.

1388
02:38:16.479 --> 02:38:20.719
<v Angelita Morillo>And I'm sorry that it's been an arduous process, but things are made better by you being here.

1389
02:38:21.360 --> 02:38:28.420
<v Angelita Morillo>I also want to acknowledge that It's, uh, I look forward to just getting to know all of you more and getting to work with you in the future.

1390
02:38:28.739 --> 02:38:29.139
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you.

1391
02:38:30.260 --> 02:38:30.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1392
02:38:31.459 --> 02:38:32.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1393
02:38:33.379 --> 02:38:33.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1394
02:38:33.700 --> 02:38:52.430
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I wanted to take the opportunity to, to thank, uh, the DCA for, um, Community Economic Development, DCA Olvera, as well as the attorneys who worked in support of, of ensuring everything was above board on, on the funding source change and, and our city Budget Officer Ruth Levine as well.

1395
02:38:52.989 --> 02:38:55.790
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to make sure that, that their work wasn't forgotten here.

1396
02:38:56.030 --> 02:39:09.069
<v Sameer Kanal>We often are— we, we're willing to point out when there needs to be something critical and feedback given, but I really want to make sure we're also saying thanks when, when they really help make this happen and all their teams as well.

1397
02:39:11.709 --> 02:39:23.090
<v Sameer Kanal>I think when looking back over this, to kind of build off of something Councilor Murillo said, I think there have been 4 votes that somehow related to these projects, and I think every person on the City Council has voted yes 2 times on it.

1398
02:39:23.569 --> 02:39:28.450
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think we have the opportunity in the 5th vote on this to make it we all voted yes a 3rd time.

1399
02:39:29.090 --> 02:39:30.370
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope we get a chance to do that.

1400
02:39:30.770 --> 02:39:30.850
<v Bea Gilmore>Thanks.

1401
02:39:31.649 --> 02:39:32.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1402
02:39:32.770 --> 02:39:33.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1403
02:39:35.329 --> 02:39:35.409
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1404
02:39:38.049 --> 02:39:43.299
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, Councilor Smith, you're a champion in ways that I hope others aspire to Thank you.

1405
02:39:45.459 --> 02:39:50.979
<v Eric Zimmerman>You're a champion sometimes even for a district you no longer represent, but you did for a long time.

1406
02:39:51.940 --> 02:39:56.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I've always very much valued your leadership in this— in that space.

1407
02:39:57.379 --> 02:40:11.780
<v Eric Zimmerman>And while I think that there was some shenanigans that held this process hostage, unfortunately, for strange reasons, if I'm ever held hostage, I hope the negotiator is Loretta Smith.

1408
02:40:16.190 --> 02:40:17.069
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I'll be free.

1409
02:40:20.270 --> 02:40:22.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>It might take some time, but I'll be free.

1410
02:40:24.909 --> 02:40:28.270
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I remember who brought this to me.

1411
02:40:28.510 --> 02:40:36.270
<v Eric Zimmerman>I remember from the very beginning when I decided that I was a supporter of it, and I remember every time taking a vote to be supportive of it for Councilor Loretta Smith.

1412
02:40:36.909 --> 02:40:42.709
<v Eric Zimmerman>For you community members who I've gotten to know more and more over these last several months, Many of which, you're not new faces.

1413
02:40:42.709 --> 02:40:44.709
<v Eric Zimmerman>This was just a new fight we were in together.

1414
02:40:44.790 --> 02:40:47.190
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I appreciate it.

1415
02:40:47.829 --> 02:40:48.389
<v Eric Zimmerman>A hell yes.

1416
02:40:48.709 --> 02:40:49.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>And thank you, Councilor Smith.

1417
02:40:50.790 --> 02:40:51.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1418
02:40:51.989 --> 02:40:52.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1419
02:40:52.709 --> 02:40:54.229
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Council President.

1420
02:40:54.229 --> 02:40:59.030
<v Dan Ryan>You know, I'm always thrilled to fund legislation for homeownership, especially this one.

1421
02:40:59.190 --> 02:41:02.909
<v Dan Ryan>This legislation has deep roots and the work will continue.

1422
02:41:03.190 --> 02:41:07.829
<v Dan Ryan>Good news is this legislation has survived multiple mayors now and multiple city councils.

1423
02:41:08.489 --> 02:41:10.850
<v Dan Ryan>Which I'm learning is never easy.

1424
02:41:11.209 --> 02:41:16.729
<v Dan Ryan>As such, I voted yes on legislation for William and Russell multiple times, and I'll continue to do so.

1425
02:41:16.889 --> 02:41:25.610
<v Dan Ryan>That said, this latest challenge has been a long journey since it was part of the original proposal at the Homelessness and Housing on December 9th.

1426
02:41:25.850 --> 02:41:30.569
<v Dan Ryan>So here we are, 5+ months later, finally getting it across the finish line.

1427
02:41:30.729 --> 02:41:34.409
<v Dan Ryan>So first, I want to look out there and say thank you to the community advocates.

1428
02:41:34.409 --> 02:41:34.649
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1429
02:41:34.829 --> 02:41:42.989
<v Dan Ryan>You've been here quite a few times now in all different hours of the day and night, and your perseverance is seen and it's really respected and appreciated.

1430
02:41:45.309 --> 02:41:49.549
<v Dan Ryan>And thank you, Councilor Smith, for your steady persistence to win this race.

1431
02:41:50.590 --> 02:41:52.510
<v Dan Ryan>Your leadership is inspirational, my friend.

1432
02:41:52.909 --> 02:41:53.709
<v Dan Ryan>You have so much fight.

1433
02:41:54.989 --> 02:42:01.870
<v Dan Ryan>I recall the many point of orders, point of order— I can't do your voice— flying between you and the council president.

1434
02:42:03.280 --> 02:42:04.799
<v Dan Ryan>It's kind of entertaining, let's face it.

1435
02:42:05.440 --> 02:42:06.879
<v Dan Ryan>And thank you.

1436
02:42:07.520 --> 02:42:12.639
<v Dan Ryan>And it also allowed us to stay focused on what the end game is.

1437
02:42:13.600 --> 02:42:17.360
<v Dan Ryan>Stop the shenanigans and let's focus on what we need to deliver.

1438
02:42:18.000 --> 02:42:19.760
<v Dan Ryan>And that's what we have today.

1439
02:42:20.000 --> 02:42:20.479
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you.

1440
02:42:21.200 --> 02:42:21.280
<v Dan Ryan>Congratulations.

1441
02:42:22.479 --> 02:42:23.600
<v Dan Ryan>Congratulations, my friend.

1442
02:42:24.799 --> 02:42:26.399
<v Dan Ryan>Again, I am a big fan of homeownership.

1443
02:42:26.559 --> 02:42:28.799
<v Dan Ryan>I've made that clear for the past 6 years on the dais.

1444
02:42:29.040 --> 02:42:34.319
<v Dan Ryan>It's truly the one way a person, a family, can build financial security.

1445
02:42:34.399 --> 02:42:36.639
<v Dan Ryan>I know this from my own personal experience.

1446
02:42:36.799 --> 02:42:39.040
<v Dan Ryan>This is how we build generational wealth.

1447
02:42:39.200 --> 02:42:42.799
<v Dan Ryan>This is how a family is healthier when you look at all the data.

1448
02:42:42.879 --> 02:42:50.079
<v Dan Ryan>I really appreciate someone bringing up the education crosswalk scores and how it impacts families in that regard.

1449
02:42:50.239 --> 02:42:56.719
<v Dan Ryan>As such, this is equity in action since we are focusing on the community who has suffered from injustice.

1450
02:42:57.149 --> 02:42:58.389
<v Dan Ryan>And how.

1451
02:42:58.670 --> 02:43:03.229
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, we heard about those red lines from the Vanport flood just earlier today.

1452
02:43:03.229 --> 02:43:04.909
<v Dan Ryan>So it's a great day for Portland.

1453
02:43:04.909 --> 02:43:07.069
<v Dan Ryan>It's a great day for the City Council.

1454
02:43:07.229 --> 02:43:13.469
<v Dan Ryan>This is targeted economic justice investment that will always build more stability for a person, a family, and a community.

1455
02:43:13.469 --> 02:43:14.510
<v Dan Ryan>That's why we're here.

1456
02:43:14.590 --> 02:43:17.950
<v Dan Ryan>It's exactly the type of investment we can all feel good about.

1457
02:43:18.190 --> 02:43:22.030
<v Dan Ryan>Again, congratulations, Councilor Smith, and thank you, community, who has been relentless.

1458
02:43:22.030 --> 02:43:22.270
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1459
02:43:23.639 --> 02:43:25.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1460
02:43:26.200 --> 02:43:29.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, this item now moves to second reading.

1461
02:43:29.639 --> 02:43:31.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you everybody for being here today.

1462
02:43:32.760 --> 02:43:35.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call the consent agenda item 5?

1463
02:43:36.440 --> 02:43:39.559
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, uh, no items have been pulled from the consent agenda.

1464
02:43:40.200 --> 02:43:41.319
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, I'll call the roll.

1465
02:43:41.719 --> 02:43:42.719
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1466
02:43:43.479 --> 02:43:43.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1467
02:43:44.840 --> 02:43:45.479
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1468
02:43:45.479 --> 02:43:45.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1469
02:43:47.079 --> 02:43:47.159
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1470
02:43:47.479 --> 02:43:47.799
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1471
02:43:47.729 --> 02:43:49.569
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Koyama Lane?

1472
02:43:49.809 --> 02:43:49.889
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1473
02:43:51.329 --> 02:43:51.649
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

1474
02:43:51.969 --> 02:43:52.049
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1475
02:43:53.649 --> 02:43:54.049
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1476
02:43:54.290 --> 02:43:54.370
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1477
02:43:55.409 --> 02:43:55.489
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1478
02:43:55.969 --> 02:43:56.049
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1479
02:43:56.930 --> 02:43:57.010
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1480
02:43:57.729 --> 02:43:57.809
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1481
02:43:58.610 --> 02:43:59.170
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1482
02:43:59.250 --> 02:43:59.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1483
02:44:00.209 --> 02:44:00.530
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1484
02:44:02.049 --> 02:44:03.049
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1485
02:44:03.729 --> 02:44:03.809
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1486
02:44:05.010 --> 02:44:05.090
<v Loretta Smith>Absent.

1487
02:44:05.889 --> 02:44:06.209
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1488
02:44:06.610 --> 02:44:06.690
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1489
02:44:07.329 --> 02:44:11.250
<v Keelan McClymont>The consent agenda is approved with a vote of 11 ayes and 1 absent.

1490
02:44:12.370 --> 02:44:13.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, colleagues.

1491
02:44:13.329 --> 02:44:18.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have 11 items on our agenda and a little Over an hour and 20 minutes to get through them.

1492
02:44:18.680 --> 02:44:22.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't imagine that's going to happen, but most of these are second readings that are going to be relatively quick.

1493
02:44:22.840 --> 02:44:28.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, we're going to push through and we are out of here at 1:30, and we will continue items that we are unable to get to.

1494
02:44:29.079 --> 02:44:30.040
<v Jamie Dunphy>I apologize in advance.

1495
02:44:30.200 --> 02:44:31.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 6?

1496
02:44:33.239 --> 02:44:54.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>Document 2026-179, pay settlement of Gabriella Raffe bodily injury lawsuit in the sum of colleagues, this is an item that did not go to committee, as I mentioned earlier, but needs to be moved forward today.

1497
02:44:55.120 --> 02:45:00.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm going to just turn it over to Dave Farrow from Risk and Lucy Olson from the Attorney's Office.

1498
02:45:01.120 --> 02:45:01.200
<v Dan Ryan>Welcome.

1499
02:45:02.479 --> 02:45:03.440
<v Lucy Olson>Good afternoon, Council.

1500
02:45:03.760 --> 02:45:05.360
<v Lucy Olson>Lucy Olson, Deputy City Attorney.

1501
02:45:06.479 --> 02:45:09.920
<v Lucy Olson>This case involves a rear-end vehicle accident that occurred near the intersection of 2nd and 2nd Avenue in downtown Portland.

1502
02:45:10.250 --> 02:45:15.930
<v Lucy Olson>Of Southwest Tualatin Sherwood Road and Southwest Olds Place in September of 2020.

1503
02:45:16.170 --> 02:45:26.729
<v Lucy Olson>Now retired Portland Police Bureau Sergeant Brett Barnum was driving a city Chevy Tahoe and collided with a minivan that plaintiff Gabriella Raffee was driving.

1504
02:45:26.889 --> 02:45:37.930
<v Lucy Olson>Ms. Raffee was a minor at the time, and both Ms. Raffee and her mother, Sarah Imel, who was a passenger in the van, were injured, and the city settled Ms. Imel's claim for injuries in 2023.

1505
02:45:37.930 --> 02:45:38.250
<v Lucy Olson>Thank you.

1506
02:45:38.909 --> 02:45:46.549
<v Lucy Olson>Ms. Rafi's lawsuit sought a total of $900,000, alleging that Sergeant Barnum negligently caused the crash.

1507
02:45:46.989 --> 02:45:57.229
<v Lucy Olson>Sergeant Barnum wrote in his police report after the accident that he was going approximately 35 to 45— 40 miles per hour at the time of the crash, and the speed limit was 45.

1508
02:45:57.389 --> 02:46:06.700
<v Lucy Olson>He was driving a take-home vehicle pursuant to city policy at the time, and he was headed to his home in Sherwood after he completed his shift.

1509
02:46:06.940 --> 02:46:10.379
<v Lucy Olson>He saw Ms. Rafi's van in front of him, but he didn't see brake lights.

1510
02:46:10.540 --> 02:46:18.139
<v Lucy Olson>He looked down at his cup holder to put his drink back, and when he looked up, he realized the van was actually stopped or just slightly moved, rolling forward.

1511
02:46:18.299 --> 02:46:21.940
<v Lucy Olson>He attempted to brake but wasn't successful in avoiding the crash.

1512
02:46:22.540 --> 02:46:32.780
<v Lucy Olson>Ms. Rafi and her counsel presented evidence of chronic hip and back pain with sacroiliac joint dysfunction, as well as headaches, fogginess, dizziness, and nausea.

1513
02:46:33.690 --> 02:46:48.729
<v Lucy Olson>After an investigation, the City Attorney's Office and Risk Management determined that the negligent operation of the city vehicle in failing to keep a proper lookout for other vehicles and failing to maintain a safe distance caused the collision and Ms. Rafi's injuries.

1514
02:46:48.969 --> 02:46:59.049
<v Lucy Olson>We negotiated informally with plaintiff's counsel and mutually agreed on a settlement of $315,000, which includes reimbursing plaintiff's insurer for personal injury protection.

1515
02:47:00.420 --> 02:47:09.700
<v Lucy Olson>The City Attorney's Office recommends approval of the settlement as it will allow the city to avoid the expense of further litigation and a likely risk of a higher adverse verdict.

1516
02:47:10.979 --> 02:47:12.899
<v Lucy Olson>I'm happy to answer any questions that you have.

1517
02:47:13.700 --> 02:47:14.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1518
02:47:15.059 --> 02:47:16.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, has anyone signed up to testify on this item?

1519
02:47:17.299 --> 02:47:17.860
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1520
02:47:18.180 --> 02:47:23.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, are there any, uh, technical or clarifying questions or any discussion?

1521
02:47:27.469 --> 02:47:36.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one in the queue, colleagues, this is an emergency item, um, so we will move to a roll call vote.

1522
02:47:36.350 --> 02:47:41.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>As a remember— as a reminder, uh, emergency items require 9 votes to pass.

1523
02:47:43.549 --> 02:47:47.469
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks to Risk Attorneys and to PPB for sending me the info I needed on this one.

1524
02:47:47.549 --> 02:47:48.790
<v Keelan McClymont>I vote aye.

1525
02:47:50.440 --> 02:47:50.520
<v Masae Hoshide>Absent.

1526
02:47:51.319 --> 02:47:51.399
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1527
02:47:52.360 --> 02:47:52.440
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1528
02:47:53.479 --> 02:47:53.959
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

1529
02:47:54.440 --> 02:47:54.520
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1530
02:47:55.239 --> 02:47:55.479
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

1531
02:47:55.959 --> 02:47:56.040
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1532
02:47:56.920 --> 02:47:57.239
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1533
02:47:57.559 --> 02:47:57.639
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1534
02:47:58.280 --> 02:47:58.360
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1535
02:47:58.760 --> 02:47:58.840
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1536
02:47:59.799 --> 02:47:59.879
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1537
02:48:00.360 --> 02:48:00.600
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1538
02:48:01.000 --> 02:48:01.319
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1539
02:48:01.559 --> 02:48:01.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1540
02:48:02.120 --> 02:48:02.440
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1541
02:48:04.040 --> 02:48:04.120
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1542
02:48:06.040 --> 02:48:06.120
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1543
02:48:06.920 --> 02:48:07.000
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1544
02:48:07.559 --> 02:48:07.879
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1545
02:48:08.280 --> 02:48:08.440
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1546
02:48:09.000 --> 02:48:12.040
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with a vote of 11 ayes and 1 absent.

1547
02:48:12.600 --> 02:48:13.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, colleagues.

1548
02:48:13.559 --> 02:48:15.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 7?

1549
02:48:17.690 --> 02:48:31.969
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-180, appropriate grant award for Homeownership Assistance Program Veterans Restore Health and Safety and down payment assistance for up to $667,230.

1550
02:48:34.569 --> 02:48:34.649
<v Hope Baraka>Sorry.

1551
02:48:35.850 --> 02:48:36.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Keelan.

1552
02:48:36.729 --> 02:48:39.209
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is a first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1553
02:48:39.370 --> 02:48:50.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is similarly another item that did not move yes.

1554
02:48:50.909 --> 02:48:57.870
<v John Trinh>Good afternoon, President Councilor Dunphy, Vice President Clark, council members, CA Lee, and staff.

1555
02:48:58.510 --> 02:48:59.309
<v John Trinh>My name is John Trinh.

1556
02:48:59.469 --> 02:49:02.350
<v John Trinh>I am with the Housing Preservation Manager with the Portland Housing Bureau.

1557
02:49:02.989 --> 02:49:07.389
<v John Trinh>I'm here to speak to you briefly on an agenda item that put forth together by the grant management team.

1558
02:49:07.379 --> 02:49:15.700
<v John Trinh>Management Office to appropriate the grant of $667,230 for Veterans Restore Health and Safety and Down Payment Assistance Program.

1559
02:49:18.899 --> 02:49:21.059
<v John Trinh>I want to share a screen to do a quick presentation.

1560
02:49:28.260 --> 02:49:29.420
<v John Trinh>All right.

1561
02:49:43.549 --> 02:49:54.430
<v John Trinh>Okay, so back in February 2027— of 20— I'm sorry, back in February 27th, 2025, I applied for a grant with the Oregon Housing Community Services.

1562
02:49:55.549 --> 02:50:04.280
<v John Trinh>On June 9th, 2025, we received a notice that the the city of Portland was awarded the Veterans Restore Health and Safety and Down Payment Assistance grant for $540,000.

1563
02:50:05.639 --> 02:50:17.680
<v John Trinh>The budget splits are as follows: for the restoring health and safety, it was $358,650, and for the down payment assistance, it was $181,350.

1564
02:50:19.399 --> 02:50:32.479
<v John Trinh>In addition to the Restore Health and Safety, the grantee allowed to bill up to additional $107,559, giving us a total of $466,245 for the Restore Health.

1565
02:50:33.040 --> 02:50:42.719
<v John Trinh>And for down payment system, they gave us an additional funding of $19,000 that we could bill for— $19,635— giving us a total of $200,985.

1566
02:50:43.040 --> 02:50:46.000
<v John Trinh>So those 2 together adds up to $667,230.

1567
02:50:47.680 --> 02:50:56.899
<v John Trinh>It took us a while to sign off on the grant agreement due contract language to comply with the mayor's executive orders, which were signed on December 23rd, 2025.

1568
02:50:58.659 --> 02:51:14.020
<v John Trinh>The purpose of the grant is to provide health and safety repair for eligible veterans in owner-occupied residence with household income at or below 100% AMI, which is area median income, in maintaining a safe and healthy home.

1569
02:51:15.219 --> 02:51:24.069
<v John Trinh>The other part of money is to provide down payment assistance to eligible veteran households with income below, at or below 100% area median income.

1570
02:51:25.110 --> 02:51:30.309
<v John Trinh>This down payment assistance loan is zero interest, zero payment, and is forgiven after 5 years.

1571
02:51:31.590 --> 02:51:40.549
<v John Trinh>For context, income at or below 100% AMI for one household size is $88,000— sorry, $89,810.

1572
02:51:40.950 --> 02:51:41.750
<v Bob Day>$89,810.

1573
02:51:42.829 --> 02:51:46.350
<v John Trinh>Or a family of 4 is $128,300.

1574
02:51:51.950 --> 02:52:03.870
<v John Trinh>The key program deliveries, we're hoping to provide 4 down payment assistance loans through this grant and also provide 25 households with home repair grants.

1575
02:52:04.270 --> 02:52:11.889
<v John Trinh>This grant period is July 1st, 2024 And it ends June 30th, 2028.

1576
02:52:13.010 --> 02:52:14.290
<v John Trinh>With that, I open up for question.

1577
02:52:14.610 --> 02:52:14.850
<v Laura Loforte>Thank you.

1578
02:52:15.569 --> 02:52:16.209
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1579
02:52:16.690 --> 02:52:18.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, has anyone signed up to testify on this item?

1580
02:52:18.850 --> 02:52:19.489
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1581
02:52:19.889 --> 02:52:26.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, any technical or clarifying questions or any discussion about this grant appropriation?

1582
02:52:30.450 --> 02:52:33.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one in the queue, John, thank you very much.

1583
02:52:34.129 --> 02:52:36.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>This item Moving to second reading.

1584
02:52:36.620 --> 02:52:39.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1585
02:52:39.579 --> 02:52:43.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call item number 8?

1586
02:52:43.819 --> 02:52:52.459
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-181, appropriate grant for pilot mass timber feasibility study for $100,000.

1587
02:52:52.700 --> 02:52:55.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1588
02:52:55.020 --> 02:52:57.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Similarly, this is another item that did not go to committee.

1589
02:52:57.500 --> 02:52:58.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>I again apologize.

1590
02:52:58.620 --> 02:53:08.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>With us this morning, we have Sheila Craig from the Grants Office, Chris Gustafson, our financial analyst, and Masae— I can't pronounce, I'm sorry.

1591
02:53:08.860 --> 02:53:09.860
<v Keelan McClymont>Masae—.

1592
02:53:12.139 --> 02:53:13.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry, how do you pronounce your name?

1593
02:53:13.579 --> 02:53:14.700
<v Masae Hoshide>Masae Hochide.

1594
02:53:15.340 --> 02:53:18.379
<v Jamie Dunphy>Masae Hochide, with the Housing Portfolio Finance Coordinator.

1595
02:53:18.540 --> 02:53:18.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1596
02:53:19.100 --> 02:53:19.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>I apologize.

1597
02:53:20.059 --> 02:53:20.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>Take it away.

1598
02:53:21.899 --> 02:53:22.940
<v Keelan McClymont>Hello, City Council members.

1599
02:53:23.260 --> 02:53:24.299
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you for your time today.

1600
02:53:24.540 --> 02:53:29.950
<v Keelan McClymont>For the record, my name is Sheila Craig from the Grants Management I am here presenting with the Portland Housing Bureau.

1601
02:53:30.350 --> 02:53:36.590
<v Keelan McClymont>This agenda item requests your approval to appropriate $100,000 in grant funding for the '25-'26 budget.

1602
02:53:37.229 --> 02:53:48.270
<v Keelan McClymont>The purpose of this ordinance is to formally establish the grant budget authority required to expend grant funds, ensure grant revenue and related project expenses are accurately reflected in the city's budget.

1603
02:53:48.909 --> 02:53:54.379
<v Keelan McClymont>This appropriation increase in the grants fund specifically to carry out the works Supported by this grant.

1604
02:53:54.540 --> 02:53:59.579
<v Keelan McClymont>At this point, I want to turn it over to the Housing Bureau staff to provide a brief program overview.

1605
02:53:59.819 --> 02:54:00.940
<v Keelan McClymont>Today is grant day.

1606
02:54:00.940 --> 02:54:04.500
<v Keelan McClymont>We're just here to bring the city more money.

1607
02:54:04.780 --> 02:54:06.020
<v Keelan McClymont>Love that.

1608
02:54:06.299 --> 02:54:07.819
<v Masae Hoshide>Good morning, City Council members.

1609
02:54:07.979 --> 02:54:09.739
<v Masae Hoshide>My name is Masae Hoshide.

1610
02:54:09.819 --> 02:54:14.059
<v Masae Hoshide>I'm a Housing Portfolio Finance Coordinator with the Portland Housing Bureau.

1611
02:54:14.139 --> 02:54:18.219
<v Masae Hoshide>I'm joined today by colleagues who will introduce themselves if they address council.

1612
02:54:18.870 --> 02:54:20.870
<v Masae Hoshide>I'll provide a very brief overview of this grant.

1613
02:54:21.989 --> 02:54:30.389
<v Masae Hoshide>The Portland Housing Bureau is partnering with the USDA Forestry and the Softwood Lumber Board to create a pilot mass timber feasibility study program.

1614
02:54:32.149 --> 02:54:38.389
<v Masae Hoshide>We are joining other cities across the nation to identify as an accelerator city for mass timber initiatives.

1615
02:54:39.590 --> 02:54:42.469
<v Masae Hoshide>The total grant program is $450,000.

1616
02:54:44.129 --> 02:54:49.250
<v Masae Hoshide>$100,000 Is being provided by the USDA Forestry and the Softwood Lumber Board.

1617
02:54:49.969 --> 02:54:53.250
<v Masae Hoshide>$350,000 Is being provided by CET funds.

1618
02:54:54.770 --> 02:55:06.530
<v Masae Hoshide>This grant program is intended to provide 6 small microgrants to 6 new construction projects within the City of Portland to explore the use of mass timber as a structural system.

1619
02:55:07.409 --> 02:55:14.620
<v Masae Hoshide>The entire grant program is expected to be The feasibility study report will be made public.

1620
02:55:15.739 --> 02:55:22.780
<v Masae Hoshide>The new construction projects will be making public presentations on their findings, and we look forward at this time to answering any questions.

1621
02:55:24.299 --> 02:55:24.700
<v Bea Gilmore>Thank you.

1622
02:55:25.659 --> 02:55:27.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, has anyone signed up to testify on this item?

1623
02:55:27.899 --> 02:55:28.540
<v Keelan McClymont>No one signed up.

1624
02:55:28.940 --> 02:55:29.340
<v Andrew Fortgang>Thank you.

1625
02:55:30.860 --> 02:55:33.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, technical or clarifying questions or council discussion?

1626
02:55:33.579 --> 02:55:34.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1627
02:55:37.010 --> 02:55:38.450
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

1628
02:55:38.450 --> 02:55:41.409
<v Olivia Clark>Do we know who is going to do the feasibility study?

1629
02:55:41.649 --> 02:55:45.649
<v Masae Hoshide>Yes, at this time we have a total funding for 6 grantees.

1630
02:55:45.729 --> 02:55:52.610
<v Masae Hoshide>We've awarded 5, and so we have provided award letters to 5 grantees to provide those feasibility studies.

1631
02:55:53.010 --> 02:55:59.610
<v Masae Hoshide>3 Of those grantees have actually submitted their final feasibility studies for review and acceptance.

1632
02:56:00.049 --> 02:56:02.530
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so you know what I'm gonna say.

1633
02:56:03.659 --> 02:56:10.700
<v Loretta Smith>Hmm, you awarded the funds without appropriating some of these funds first.

1634
02:56:12.139 --> 02:56:14.780
<v Loretta Smith>So, uh, do we know exactly who those folks are?

1635
02:56:14.940 --> 02:56:18.139
<v Loretta Smith>You can, you can email me who the, who the, um, grantees are.

1636
02:56:19.180 --> 02:56:23.020
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, we are trying, we are trying.

1637
02:56:23.340 --> 02:56:24.139
<v Loretta Smith>I know, I know.

1638
02:56:24.540 --> 02:56:34.870
<v Masae Hoshide>I, I saw you over there looking to see if I was going to say something, but I'm going to be consistent I'd be happy to read off the names of the grantees at this time, or I can email you just in the interest of time.

1639
02:56:35.110 --> 02:56:35.909
<v Masae Hoshide>Would you like me to read them off?

1640
02:56:35.989 --> 02:56:36.549
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, that would be great.

1641
02:56:37.030 --> 02:56:37.270
<v Masae Hoshide>All right.

1642
02:56:37.750 --> 02:56:39.909
<v Masae Hoshide>We have the Broadway Corridor Parcel 4A.

1643
02:56:40.709 --> 02:56:43.430
<v Masae Hoshide>We have the OMSI Master Plan District Parcel A.

1644
02:56:44.309 --> 02:56:46.469
<v Masae Hoshide>We have the Lentz AIP Parcel.

1645
02:56:47.270 --> 02:56:48.069
<v Masae Hoshide>We have Shortstack.

1646
02:56:49.030 --> 02:56:51.270
<v Masae Hoshide>We have the Lan Su Chinese Garden Expansion.

1647
02:56:53.190 --> 02:56:53.590
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

1648
02:56:54.479 --> 02:56:55.520
<v Loretta Smith>I see why this is an emergency.

1649
02:56:56.799 --> 02:56:57.040
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1650
02:56:57.760 --> 02:56:58.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1651
02:56:59.120 --> 02:56:59.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1652
02:57:01.040 --> 02:57:02.000
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, thank you, Council President.

1653
02:57:02.159 --> 02:57:03.360
<v Olivia Clark>I just have a couple, couple questions.

1654
02:57:03.600 --> 02:57:05.120
<v Olivia Clark>So let me make sure I understand this.

1655
02:57:05.200 --> 02:57:10.159
<v Olivia Clark>The feasibility is for the use of this new form of building materials?

1656
02:57:10.639 --> 02:57:12.239
<v Olivia Clark>Is that what the feasibility studies are for?

1657
02:57:12.399 --> 02:57:22.409
<v Masae Hoshide>Yeah, the feasibility study is to explore the potential to use mass timber as a structural system in these proposed new developments located okay, so each of those individual developments.

1658
02:57:22.809 --> 02:57:23.530
<v Olivia Clark>Gotcha.

1659
02:57:23.610 --> 02:57:35.530
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm just curious, are you, um, do you have a partnership or are you working with OSU, Oregon State University, which has a large mass timber study unit?

1660
02:57:35.610 --> 02:57:36.569
<v Masae Hoshide>That's a terrific question.

1661
02:57:37.209 --> 02:57:50.819
<v Masae Hoshide>We are so fortunate within this region to have many different public agencies deeply involved in addressing the mass timber industry and how to move it forward, both for economic development opportunities, design, construction within our region.

1662
02:57:51.540 --> 02:57:56.979
<v Masae Hoshide>While we don't have a formal partnership with OSU, we are in contact with them and we think that what they're doing is fabulous.

1663
02:57:57.780 --> 02:58:08.659
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, they're doing a lot of experimentation with the actual lumber, what it can take, not take, how it operates under certain weather, seismic situations.

1664
02:58:08.979 --> 02:58:18.450
<v Olivia Clark>It just seems like that's a natural partnership Are there other— are there some private sector partners here in the region that you're partnering with, aside from the grantees?

1665
02:58:19.090 --> 02:58:22.690
<v Masae Hoshide>Aside from the grant— yeah, at this moment, no, we don't have formal partnerships.

1666
02:58:22.930 --> 02:58:27.649
<v Masae Hoshide>But just to let you know, I've been down to the— I've been down to visit in Salem, the fabulous prototypes that are going on.

1667
02:58:28.290 --> 02:58:34.610
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, I thought there were other prototypes going on in our region up here in Portland as well, and on the private sector side.

1668
02:58:35.569 --> 02:58:39.200
<v Masae Hoshide>One of the grantees is exploring prototypes in mass timber for homeownership.

1669
02:58:39.840 --> 02:58:42.479
<v Masae Hoshide>And so we're happy that this grant is able to support them with their research.

1670
02:58:42.879 --> 02:58:42.959
<v Hope Baraka>Great.

1671
02:58:43.440 --> 02:58:43.760
<v Shannon Singleton>Okay, thanks.

1672
02:58:44.959 --> 02:58:45.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1673
02:58:46.319 --> 02:58:46.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1674
02:58:47.920 --> 02:58:48.559
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1675
02:58:49.280 --> 02:58:52.319
<v Steve Novick>Um, could you just take a second explaining what mass timber is?

1676
02:58:52.559 --> 02:58:54.799
<v Steve Novick>It is the same as mass laminated timber?

1677
02:58:57.520 --> 02:59:13.649
<v Masae Hoshide>So mass timber— I didn't expect actually to have that question come up, but mass mass timber is actually a different form of a structural system, and so it is utilizing— instead of it being a solid wood product, it actually is a laminated panelized product.

1678
02:59:13.809 --> 02:59:16.129
<v Masae Hoshide>There are many different approaches to mass timber.

1679
02:59:16.290 --> 02:59:27.729
<v Masae Hoshide>There are many different construction types, and we are so fortunate within the city of Portland, within our region, that we are considered to be kind of forward thinkers and leaders within the mass timber industry.

1680
02:59:28.540 --> 02:59:28.860
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1681
02:59:30.780 --> 02:59:31.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1682
02:59:32.299 --> 02:59:32.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1683
02:59:33.659 --> 02:59:34.540
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1684
02:59:34.700 --> 02:59:35.739
<v Dan Ryan>It's good to see all of you.

1685
02:59:35.739 --> 02:59:39.500
<v Dan Ryan>It's always fun to talk about grant investments and the leveraging that we can take place.

1686
02:59:39.979 --> 02:59:41.180
<v Dan Ryan>This is exciting.

1687
02:59:41.659 --> 02:59:45.659
<v Dan Ryan>I do have a couple of questions about how we're visioning this going forward.

1688
02:59:45.659 --> 02:59:56.700
<v Dan Ryan>I want to know if maybe you can answer this, any of you, or maybe DCA Oliveira has to come up or one of his deputies, Director Engstrom.

1689
02:59:56.700 --> 03:00:02.100
<v Dan Ryan>But how are we How are we looking into this investment turn of the effort currently?

1690
03:00:03.059 --> 03:00:04.899
<v Dan Ryan>Prosper Portland's been talking about this.

1691
03:00:04.979 --> 03:00:10.620
<v Dan Ryan>So are we in conversations with them, first of all, about leveraging these dollars?

1692
03:00:11.459 --> 03:00:12.100
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Yes.

1693
03:00:12.260 --> 03:00:17.379
<v Masae Hoshide>So this pilot mass timber feasibility study program is in essence a pilot.

1694
03:00:17.860 --> 03:00:31.389
<v Masae Hoshide>So we have identified new construction projects that already have a preexisting public-private partnership with the City of Portland who expressed an interest in exploring mass timber.

1695
03:00:32.030 --> 03:00:32.110
<v Masae Hoshide>Okay.

1696
03:00:32.270 --> 03:00:43.069
<v Masae Hoshide>We're providing them with $75,000 in grant money, up to $75,000, to explore and formalize a feasibility study report as to whether or not they can utilize mass timber.

1697
03:00:43.309 --> 03:00:48.909
<v Masae Hoshide>That report will be made public, which we hope will create a ripple effect for other people to learn about mass timber.

1698
03:00:49.159 --> 03:00:50.360
<v Dan Ryan>When can we expect that report?

1699
03:00:51.479 --> 03:00:55.000
<v Masae Hoshide>We expect all reports to be available publicly by the end of this calendar year.

1700
03:00:55.719 --> 03:00:55.799
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

1701
03:00:56.520 --> 03:00:56.760
<v Dan Ryan>All right.

1702
03:00:57.799 --> 03:01:01.479
<v Dan Ryan>And so the Planning and Sustainability is involved in the plan there at the table?

1703
03:01:02.120 --> 03:01:02.200
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1704
03:01:02.680 --> 03:01:02.760
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

1705
03:01:03.239 --> 03:01:08.120
<v Dan Ryan>So hopefully this will come to City Life because that's where we're doing economic development conversations.

1706
03:01:09.559 --> 03:01:20.149
<v Masae Hoshide>We can discuss ways in which we plan to create a public website and make the feasibility reports public, as well as providing a public presentation of the feasibility study reports.

1707
03:01:20.309 --> 03:01:23.989
<v Masae Hoshide>And we'll continue to partner in ways that will make the best use of that communication.

1708
03:01:24.629 --> 03:01:24.950
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1709
03:01:25.270 --> 03:01:25.829
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you so much.

1710
03:01:26.309 --> 03:01:31.430
<v Dan Ryan>It's exciting, DC Oliveira, that we can talk about an investment and how we're leveraging it.

1711
03:01:31.750 --> 03:01:33.510
<v Dan Ryan>We haven't had a lot of these presentations lately.

1712
03:01:33.989 --> 03:01:34.950
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, Councilor, thank you.

1713
03:01:35.190 --> 03:01:43.829
<v Mitch Green>And just echoing the report, when those reports are published, it's not just a standalone, live on a shelf thing.

1714
03:01:44.350 --> 03:01:53.790
<v Mitch Green>The teams have been working together across the service area, looking at what sort of zoning permitting changes we'll have to make to accommodate mass timber when necessary.

1715
03:01:53.870 --> 03:02:02.430
<v Mitch Green>But to that question about where Prosper's participation is, this is us looking for the angle for our market, like what is the right place for investments.

1716
03:02:02.510 --> 03:02:07.149
<v Mitch Green>And so the idea is the feasibility studies present a pathway for future Prosper investments.

1717
03:02:07.950 --> 03:02:08.590
<v Dan Ryan>That makes sense.

1718
03:02:08.590 --> 03:02:11.469
<v Mitch Green>Pathway for code to be adopted by you all.

1719
03:02:11.750 --> 03:02:21.670
<v Mitch Green>To improve the feasibility for mass timber construction and in theory makes it a better place to build, Portland being that place, because our codes are streamlined for it.

1720
03:02:21.829 --> 03:02:22.229
<v Keelan McClymont>Perfect.

1721
03:02:22.309 --> 03:02:22.870
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you so much.

1722
03:02:23.030 --> 03:02:24.510
<v Dan Ryan>That helped a lot.

1723
03:02:25.030 --> 03:02:25.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1724
03:02:25.909 --> 03:02:27.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1725
03:02:27.590 --> 03:02:29.030
<v Olivia Clark>Sorry, just a couple more questions.

1726
03:02:29.510 --> 03:02:37.590
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's great that we're working cross-service area and that we're focused on Portland, but it seems like there's a— this is a much larger issue.

1727
03:02:38.010 --> 03:02:39.850
<v Olivia Clark>Um, with so much more potential.

1728
03:02:40.090 --> 03:02:48.649
<v Olivia Clark>I just wondered if we're in contact with OFIC, the Oregon Forest Industries Council, or other state organizations, because this is all transferable.

1729
03:02:48.969 --> 03:02:54.729
<v Olivia Clark>I think there's a lot going on, and it seems like we're often kind of factionalized, or we're doing a little over here, a little over there.

1730
03:02:54.889 --> 03:03:04.409
<v Olivia Clark>And I just wonder if there's a larger body in Oregon that's coordinating these— this kind of— the kind of research, the application, because we are a forest industry state.

1731
03:03:04.889 --> 03:03:06.569
<v Olivia Clark>So this has so much potential statewide.

1732
03:03:06.649 --> 03:03:08.409
<v Olivia Clark>I just was curious if you're connected.

1733
03:03:09.850 --> 03:03:19.930
<v Masae Hoshide>It's actually one of the exciting things about this Mass Timber Feasibility Study program is just the ability to develop partnerships and relationships with so many organizations right now that are exploring mass timber.

1734
03:03:20.809 --> 03:03:27.690
<v Masae Hoshide>The Oregon Mass Timber Coalition comes to mind, as well as Oregon State University, University of Oregon.

1735
03:03:28.489 --> 03:03:33.860
<v Masae Hoshide>These are large public institutions, you know, as well as coalitions who are actively exploring mass timber.

1736
03:03:34.420 --> 03:03:40.899
<v Masae Hoshide>We currently host one of the largest and most respected mass timber conferences on an annual basis.

1737
03:03:41.299 --> 03:03:52.180
<v Masae Hoshide>It happens every year within the city of Portland, and we are so fortunate that what it does is highlight that we do have world-class design and construction expertise towards mass timber.

1738
03:03:53.299 --> 03:03:58.510
<v Olivia Clark>I really, I really appreciate Hearing that, I just want to know that we're really integrated in everything that's going on in the state.

1739
03:03:58.909 --> 03:04:00.110
<v Olivia Clark>So it sounds great.

1740
03:04:00.510 --> 03:04:12.350
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, Councilor, I think the— our response initially was specific to the potential in Portland, but to your broader question about that, that networking and the coordination, our partners at the port, you know, they have the accelerator there at T2.

1741
03:04:12.989 --> 03:04:20.350
<v Mitch Green>There's so much rich investment and prototyping and piloting going on in the region that it'll just make whatever we do in Portland that much stronger.

1742
03:04:21.579 --> 03:04:30.219
<v Olivia Clark>And I think that we're demonstrating the transferability among other local governments with, as I just said, code changes or code updates, that sort of thing.

1743
03:04:30.379 --> 03:04:31.180
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you so much.

1744
03:04:32.139 --> 03:04:33.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1745
03:04:34.139 --> 03:04:37.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, this item now moves to second reading.

1746
03:04:37.420 --> 03:04:38.379
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for the presentation.

1747
03:04:39.819 --> 03:04:40.379
<v Masae Hoshide>Thank you so much.

1748
03:04:41.659 --> 03:04:45.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>We now have 7 second readings in a row.

1749
03:04:46.170 --> 03:04:53.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>And about an hour to get through them, plus an additional extended first reading of an item.

1750
03:04:53.850 --> 03:04:55.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we're going to try and get through as many of these things as possible.

1751
03:04:57.209 --> 03:04:58.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please move to item number 9?

1752
03:05:00.569 --> 03:05:19.250
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-158, amend Portland Clean Energy Community Benefits Fund Code to allow transfer of interest earned in FY 2024-25 for the FY thank you.

1753
03:05:19.329 --> 03:05:21.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1754
03:05:21.649 --> 03:05:23.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, is there any discussion?

1755
03:05:27.250 --> 03:05:29.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one in the queue, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

1756
03:05:31.010 --> 03:05:31.250
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1757
03:05:31.809 --> 03:05:31.889
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1758
03:05:33.409 --> 03:05:33.809
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1759
03:05:34.370 --> 03:05:34.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absent.

1760
03:05:34.930 --> 03:05:35.090
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1761
03:05:35.250 --> 03:05:35.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>He's online.

1762
03:05:36.209 --> 03:05:38.129
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, aye.

1763
03:05:39.670 --> 03:05:39.989
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1764
03:05:42.309 --> 03:05:42.389
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1765
03:05:42.870 --> 03:05:42.950
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1766
03:05:45.110 --> 03:05:45.270
<v Keelan McClymont>Lane?

1767
03:05:45.670 --> 03:05:45.750
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1768
03:05:46.389 --> 03:05:46.709
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

1769
03:05:47.190 --> 03:05:47.270
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

1770
03:05:48.549 --> 03:05:50.709
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sorry, was that no?

1771
03:05:50.950 --> 03:05:51.270
<v Lorena Gayette>Thank you.

1772
03:05:52.309 --> 03:05:52.629
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1773
03:05:53.030 --> 03:05:53.110
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1774
03:05:53.909 --> 03:05:53.989
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1775
03:05:54.389 --> 03:05:54.469
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1776
03:05:55.270 --> 03:05:55.350
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1777
03:05:55.829 --> 03:05:55.909
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1778
03:05:56.629 --> 03:05:57.030
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1779
03:05:57.270 --> 03:05:57.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1780
03:05:57.989 --> 03:05:58.389
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1781
03:06:03.590 --> 03:06:04.469
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Avalos?

1782
03:06:13.110 --> 03:06:14.069
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor, can you hear us?

1783
03:06:14.870 --> 03:06:15.829
<v Keelan McClymont>I see you're unmuted.

1784
03:06:21.270 --> 03:06:21.350
<v Unidentified speaker>Absent.

1785
03:06:22.149 --> 03:06:22.229
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

1786
03:06:22.229 --> 03:06:22.790
<v Tanisha Renee>Can you hear me now?

1787
03:06:23.190 --> 03:06:23.270
<v Tanisha Renee>Sorry.

1788
03:06:24.389 --> 03:06:25.030
<v Keelan McClymont>We can hear you.

1789
03:06:26.469 --> 03:06:27.590
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, I vote no.

1790
03:06:29.110 --> 03:06:30.110
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

1791
03:06:31.200 --> 03:06:31.280
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1792
03:06:32.959 --> 03:06:33.040
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1793
03:06:34.159 --> 03:06:38.000
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with a vote of 10 ayes and 2 no votes.

1794
03:06:38.799 --> 03:06:39.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1795
03:06:39.280 --> 03:06:40.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 10?

1796
03:06:44.799 --> 03:07:00.840
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-159, adopt solid waste and recycling rates and fees for franchised residential collection in the commercial tonnage this is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1797
03:07:01.079 --> 03:07:02.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, is there any further discussion?

1798
03:07:03.399 --> 03:07:03.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1799
03:07:05.319 --> 03:07:10.200
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to vote yes on this, but I want the haulers to take note that you skipped my trash again.

1800
03:07:10.760 --> 03:07:13.639
<v Mitch Green>Um, please don't do that ever again, or I'll vote no next time.

1801
03:07:14.520 --> 03:07:15.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1802
03:07:15.719 --> 03:07:16.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1803
03:07:16.520 --> 03:07:23.000
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I just wanted to make a statement that I've made it clear I'll only support rate increases that remain at or below current inflation, which is 3%.

1804
03:07:25.010 --> 03:07:27.489
<v Dan Ryan>As such, my no vote should not be a surprise.

1805
03:07:27.569 --> 03:07:36.129
<v Dan Ryan>Um, we're experiencing such severe affordability challenges for working-class taxpaying Portlanders, and I just know they want us to live within our means.

1806
03:07:36.290 --> 03:07:38.850
<v Dan Ryan>But the first one I will be supporting because it's below that.

1807
03:07:39.090 --> 03:07:39.409
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks.

1808
03:07:39.489 --> 03:07:41.209
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1809
03:07:41.889 --> 03:07:45.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, can we please move to a roll call vote?

1810
03:07:46.049 --> 03:07:46.690
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1811
03:07:46.850 --> 03:07:46.930
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1812
03:07:48.049 --> 03:07:48.129
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1813
03:07:48.370 --> 03:07:48.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1814
03:07:51.430 --> 03:07:51.510
<v Mikel Johnson>Aye.

1815
03:07:53.270 --> 03:07:53.350
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1816
03:07:54.469 --> 03:07:54.549
<v Karen Shirey>Aye.

1817
03:07:56.629 --> 03:07:56.709
<v Tatiana Turdal>Aye.

1818
03:07:58.069 --> 03:07:58.149
<v Bea Gilmore>Aye.

1819
03:07:59.430 --> 03:07:59.510
<v Bea Gilmore>Aye.

1820
03:08:00.709 --> 03:08:00.790
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1821
03:08:02.629 --> 03:08:02.709
<v Trent Aldridge>Aye.

1822
03:08:05.510 --> 03:08:05.590
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

1823
03:08:06.389 --> 03:08:06.469
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1824
03:08:07.110 --> 03:08:07.430
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

1825
03:08:07.829 --> 03:08:07.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1826
03:08:08.870 --> 03:08:11.270
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with a vote of 12 ayes.

1827
03:08:11.909 --> 03:08:12.229
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1828
03:08:12.309 --> 03:08:14.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please call item number 11?

1829
03:08:15.760 --> 03:08:26.879
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-160, revised transportation fees, rates, and charges for the FY 2026-27 and amend transportation fee schedule.

1830
03:08:27.840 --> 03:08:29.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1831
03:08:29.920 --> 03:08:30.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, is there any discussion?

1832
03:08:33.840 --> 03:08:35.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing none, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

1833
03:08:36.159 --> 03:08:36.239
<v Olivia Clark>Null.

1834
03:08:37.520 --> 03:08:37.680
<v Trent Aldridge>Aye.

1835
03:08:38.239 --> 03:08:39.239
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

1836
03:08:39.690 --> 03:08:40.690
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1837
03:08:42.010 --> 03:08:42.090
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1838
03:08:42.569 --> 03:08:42.649
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1839
03:08:43.770 --> 03:08:44.329
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

1840
03:08:44.649 --> 03:08:44.729
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1841
03:08:45.370 --> 03:08:45.610
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

1842
03:08:46.170 --> 03:08:46.250
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1843
03:08:47.049 --> 03:08:47.290
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1844
03:08:47.690 --> 03:08:47.770
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1845
03:08:48.329 --> 03:08:48.409
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1846
03:08:48.969 --> 03:08:49.049
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1847
03:08:49.610 --> 03:08:49.690
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1848
03:08:50.250 --> 03:08:50.409
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1849
03:08:50.969 --> 03:08:51.370
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1850
03:08:51.610 --> 03:08:51.690
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1851
03:08:52.889 --> 03:08:53.209
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1852
03:08:57.530 --> 03:08:59.290
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm, I'm sorry, Councilor, was that aye?

1853
03:08:59.450 --> 03:08:59.930
<v Loretta Smith>Did you hear me?

1854
03:09:00.409 --> 03:09:00.889
<v Olivia Clark>I didn't.

1855
03:09:02.729 --> 03:09:02.809
<v Hope Baraka>Sorry.

1856
03:09:03.209 --> 03:09:03.770
<v Bea Gilmore>I'm not—.

1857
03:09:03.770 --> 03:09:04.170
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, thank you.

1858
03:09:05.690 --> 03:09:05.770
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1859
03:09:06.389 --> 03:09:06.469
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1860
03:09:07.430 --> 03:09:07.909
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1861
03:09:07.989 --> 03:09:08.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1862
03:09:08.950 --> 03:09:11.670
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with a vote of 10 ayes and 2 nos.

1863
03:09:12.149 --> 03:09:12.389
<v Bea Gilmore>Thank you.

1864
03:09:12.469 --> 03:09:14.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please call item number 12?

1865
03:09:14.629 --> 03:09:18.350
<v Keelan McClymont>Read item number 12.

1866
03:09:18.790 --> 03:09:27.110
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-161, revise sewer and stormwater rates, charges, and fees for FY 2026-27.

1867
03:09:28.229 --> 03:09:29.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>The second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1868
03:09:30.069 --> 03:09:31.510
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there any discussion?

1869
03:09:34.559 --> 03:09:36.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing none, Keelan, can you please call the roll?

1870
03:09:36.639 --> 03:09:36.879
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1871
03:09:37.840 --> 03:09:37.920
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1872
03:09:38.719 --> 03:09:39.719
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1873
03:09:41.760 --> 03:09:42.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1874
03:09:48.559 --> 03:09:48.799
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1875
03:09:49.200 --> 03:09:49.280
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1876
03:09:50.079 --> 03:09:50.159
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1877
03:09:50.639 --> 03:09:50.719
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1878
03:09:51.440 --> 03:09:51.520
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1879
03:09:52.239 --> 03:09:52.399
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1880
03:09:53.040 --> 03:09:53.440
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1881
03:09:53.760 --> 03:09:53.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1882
03:09:54.799 --> 03:09:55.200
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1883
03:09:56.719 --> 03:09:56.799
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1884
03:09:58.559 --> 03:09:58.639
<v John Trinh>Aye.

1885
03:10:00.159 --> 03:10:00.239
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

1886
03:10:01.040 --> 03:10:04.639
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with a vote of 9 ayes and 3 nos.

1887
03:10:05.280 --> 03:10:05.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1888
03:10:05.760 --> 03:10:07.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we move to item 13, please?

1889
03:10:09.760 --> 03:10:23.040
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-162, adopt rates, charges, and fees for water and water-related services for the fiscal year beginning July 1st, 2026, and ending June 30th, 2027.

1890
03:10:24.120 --> 03:10:26.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1891
03:10:26.360 --> 03:10:28.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there any discussion?

1892
03:10:31.079 --> 03:10:32.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing none, can we please call the roll?

1893
03:10:32.760 --> 03:10:33.239
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1894
03:10:33.479 --> 03:10:33.559
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1895
03:10:34.200 --> 03:10:35.200
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1896
03:10:36.440 --> 03:10:36.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1897
03:10:37.319 --> 03:10:37.879
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1898
03:10:38.120 --> 03:10:39.120
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1899
03:10:39.639 --> 03:10:40.360
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

1900
03:10:40.440 --> 03:10:41.399
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

1901
03:10:41.719 --> 03:10:42.600
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo?

1902
03:10:42.840 --> 03:10:43.719
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

1903
03:10:44.040 --> 03:10:44.760
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1904
03:10:45.000 --> 03:10:45.079
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1905
03:10:45.719 --> 03:10:45.799
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1906
03:10:46.360 --> 03:10:46.760
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1907
03:10:47.079 --> 03:10:47.159
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1908
03:10:47.879 --> 03:10:47.959
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1909
03:10:48.840 --> 03:10:49.399
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1910
03:10:49.670 --> 03:10:49.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1911
03:10:51.030 --> 03:10:56.709
<v Tatiana Turdal>Um, aye.

1912
03:10:59.350 --> 03:10:59.430
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1913
03:11:00.469 --> 03:11:00.709
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1914
03:11:01.030 --> 03:11:01.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1915
03:11:01.750 --> 03:11:04.950
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with a vote of 8 ayes and 4 nos.

1916
03:11:05.909 --> 03:11:07.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>And can we please go to item number 14?

1917
03:11:08.790 --> 03:11:34.350
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-111, add identification of law enforcement officers thank you, Council President.

1918
03:11:34.510 --> 03:11:39.069
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll keep my opening brief and pass it along to fellow co-sponsors and colleagues for their final comments.

1919
03:11:39.309 --> 03:11:52.409
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll place myself back in the queue to close at the end, but I wanted to I wanted to just note for the record the addition of Councilor— sorry, Councilor Morillo was a scrivener's error not being on as a co-sponsor on the online version before.

1920
03:11:53.129 --> 03:11:54.649
<v Sameer Kanal>She's been a co-sponsor for a while.

1921
03:11:55.610 --> 03:12:05.850
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I also wanted to note Councilor Pirtle-Guiney being added as a co-sponsor, and in, I think, recognition of the work in the amendment we passed last time we brought this up.

1922
03:12:07.209 --> 03:12:12.489
<v Sameer Kanal>Today we will be taking a final vote on important legislation legislation that has been corrected, has been amended, has been revised.

1923
03:12:12.569 --> 03:12:16.889
<v Sameer Kanal>It's been coming through several steps and as a result has come a long way.

1924
03:12:17.049 --> 03:12:26.809
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think it reflects the spirit of collaboration that we have said we want to embody and that we've embodied earlier today as well, while also responding to calls from the community for action.

1925
03:12:26.889 --> 03:12:34.170
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to start by saying thanks to all my colleagues for staying engaged through this public process and for thoughtful and certainly robust discussion along the way.

1926
03:12:34.250 --> 03:12:34.329
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks.

1927
03:12:34.489 --> 03:12:34.809
<v Laura Loforte>Thank you.

1928
03:12:34.979 --> 03:12:35.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

1929
03:12:36.100 --> 03:12:36.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1930
03:12:37.219 --> 03:12:38.500
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1931
03:12:38.739 --> 03:12:49.379
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to thank Councilor Knoll for working with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney and me and probably others to answer questions and take suggestions, work through confusion.

1932
03:12:49.780 --> 03:12:52.819
<v Steve Novick>It's been a really good process and I really appreciate it.

1933
03:12:52.819 --> 03:12:59.860
<v Steve Novick>It's gotten to us a place where we have something that isn't what any of us would've written ourselves alone, but something we can all support.

1934
03:13:00.340 --> 03:13:02.180
<v Steve Novick>Just a couple of public expectation things.

1935
03:13:02.889 --> 03:13:22.569
<v Steve Novick>I do want to make sure that people know that this is not going to result in Portland Police physically tearing masks from ICE agents' faces, but it hopefully will result in them documenting instances where there's violations of the law, and there's a provision in the law that allows for us to compel compliance through a lawsuit.

1936
03:13:22.889 --> 03:13:31.129
<v Steve Novick>Speaking of lawsuits, I need to say again that I think there's a high likelihood that this will be struck down in court because of the 9th Circuit decision.

1937
03:13:31.209 --> 03:13:31.530
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1938
03:13:32.030 --> 03:13:40.989
<v Steve Novick>On the same topic in California, but we do have strong legal arguments and it's an important cause, so I think it's worth taking a chance that we might prevail.

1939
03:13:42.270 --> 03:13:43.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1940
03:13:43.309 --> 03:13:44.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1941
03:13:45.549 --> 03:13:46.270
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor President.

1942
03:13:48.430 --> 03:13:53.950
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Novick said something that really resonates with me, and that is public expectations.

1943
03:13:55.069 --> 03:14:02.000
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm really concerned that We have raised public expectations about what we can do and not do.

1944
03:14:04.639 --> 03:14:09.280
<v Olivia Clark>I think we may be doing a disservice to the public by creating those expectations.

1945
03:14:10.639 --> 03:14:29.430
<v Olivia Clark>I would really appreciate the opportunity to have Chief Bob Day come up and, if he's available, and talk to us a little bit more about what this really can and can't do, or what— and I would also like to ask Point of order.

1946
03:14:29.829 --> 03:14:30.709
<v Angelita Morillo>This is the second reading.

1947
03:14:30.950 --> 03:14:32.709
<v Angelita Morillo>We've gone over this during the first reading.

1948
03:14:32.950 --> 03:14:34.950
<v Angelita Morillo>We've already heard from Chief Day numerous times.

1949
03:14:35.190 --> 03:14:36.950
<v Angelita Morillo>We have outlined what the ordinance does.

1950
03:14:37.190 --> 03:14:43.989
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Kanal has repeatedly stated that this does not mean our police are going to magically arrest ICE agents and rip the masks off their faces.

1951
03:14:44.709 --> 03:14:44.790
<v Mikel Johnson>So—.

1952
03:14:45.510 --> 03:14:45.829
<v John Washington>Point of order.

1953
03:14:46.389 --> 03:14:48.709
<v Angelita Morillo>The point of order is, can we move on to our business?

1954
03:14:48.950 --> 03:14:49.190
<v Keelan McClymont>All right.

1955
03:14:49.190 --> 03:14:49.989
<v Keelan McClymont>I think we should move on to our business.

1956
03:14:50.559 --> 03:14:52.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't find that to be a point of order.

1957
03:14:53.440 --> 03:15:04.079
<v Olivia Clark>I think I'm, um, I'm asking for more clarification again about what this really can do and can't do and what the expectations are for the sponsors.

1958
03:15:04.319 --> 03:15:06.079
<v Olivia Clark>What is this really going to do?

1959
03:15:06.239 --> 03:15:13.040
<v Olivia Clark>I think we've raised the expectations on the public so high, and, um, I don't think it's legitimate.

1960
03:15:13.440 --> 03:15:18.909
<v Olivia Clark>It really concerns me that we're not going to be able to do the kinds of things that people think we can do with this.

1961
03:15:19.149 --> 03:15:20.750
<v Olivia Clark>It seems very symbolic to me.

1962
03:15:21.469 --> 03:15:25.549
<v Olivia Clark>And I know that we all received a letter from Chief Day.

1963
03:15:25.549 --> 03:15:36.829
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know if, Council President, if you mind actually asking Chief Day to come up and maybe talk a little bit about— help me understand what's really going on here.

1964
03:15:37.629 --> 03:15:38.270
<v Olivia Clark>Is that possible?

1965
03:15:38.670 --> 03:15:39.870
<v Olivia Clark>Do you mind coming up?

1966
03:15:39.870 --> 03:15:41.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm happy to have Chief Day come up.

1967
03:15:43.159 --> 03:15:49.559
<v Olivia Clark>I just, um, I really think we've raised expectations among the public that are, um, unreal— unrealizable.

1968
03:15:51.879 --> 03:15:52.200
<v Bob Day>Well, good afternoon.

1969
03:15:52.520 --> 03:15:56.200
<v Bob Day>Thank you, Council President, Vice President, councilors, City Administrator Lee.

1970
03:15:56.760 --> 03:15:58.440
<v Bob Day>For the record, I'm Bob Day, Chief of Police.

1971
03:15:58.680 --> 03:16:00.680
<v Bob Day>With me is Deputy Chief Brian Hughes.

1972
03:16:01.559 --> 03:16:03.399
<v Bob Day>Appreciate the moment just to be able to respond.

1973
03:16:03.559 --> 03:16:05.239
<v Bob Day>Y'all did, uh, receive my document.

1974
03:16:05.879 --> 03:16:07.319
<v Bob Day>I want to be clear on a couple things.

1975
03:16:07.559 --> 03:16:11.319
<v Bob Day>One is that We are in agreement on intent.

1976
03:16:11.719 --> 03:16:20.360
<v Bob Day>It should not be taken away from anyone on the dais or listening that the Portland Police Bureau is opposed to identification of police officers.

1977
03:16:20.920 --> 03:16:31.719
<v Bob Day>And as has been testified to many times, the Police Bureau policy regarding our own identification has been the gold standard that's been looked upon statewide, and it's really what the House bill was built upon.

1978
03:16:31.799 --> 03:16:53.809
<v Bob Day>And we've made several efforts in the last 18 months to distinguish ourselves from the federal law enforcement, including multilingual videos and ongoing outreach and frequently asked question pages, and doing many things that I believe has really allowed for our constituents and our community members to understand who we are and what we represent and how we do business.

1979
03:16:53.809 --> 03:16:59.409
<v Bob Day>We're also guided by state law, which requires the identification of a local law enforcement officer within 14 days.

1980
03:16:59.489 --> 03:17:05.420
<v Bob Day>So even if I were to operate today with A mask and no badge and et cetera, but somebody were to ask, who is that?

1981
03:17:05.659 --> 03:17:09.819
<v Bob Day>We would be mandated by state law to provide that information within 14 days, and we do that.

1982
03:17:11.260 --> 03:17:14.459
<v Bob Day>I have asked in my letter for the clear understanding.

1983
03:17:14.620 --> 03:17:19.020
<v Bob Day>I appreciate already Councilor Novick has addressed one of the primary concerns I have.

1984
03:17:19.979 --> 03:17:41.030
<v Bob Day>But in our position in reviewing this is I do not anticipate there to be significant change, both in the behavior of Portland officers and what we've been doing for the last 18 months and what we will be and it certainly is not going to change anything on the behalf of the federal law enforcement because it's been made abundantly clear that we cannot correct that or change that behavior.

1985
03:17:41.030 --> 03:17:48.149
<v Bob Day>So the ordinance has been asked to me several times, if it doesn't change anything, then does it matter if it's codified or not?

1986
03:17:48.149 --> 03:17:55.510
<v Bob Day>And for me, it doesn't because we're going to continue doing business the same way whether this language stays or whether this passes or whether it doesn't.

1987
03:17:55.670 --> 03:17:59.829
<v Bob Day>We do all these investigations based upon reasonable suspicion, based upon probable cause, and we do them the same way.

1988
03:17:59.829 --> 03:18:00.069
<v Bob Day>Thank you.

1989
03:18:00.780 --> 03:18:16.780
<v Bob Day>The context of preliminary investigation is essentially an early-on investigation that we do and we have been doing for the last 18 months through the course of maybe over a dozen times where we've been called to look at incidents or review incidents that may or may not involve federal law enforcement.

1990
03:18:17.180 --> 03:18:24.139
<v Bob Day>So we already have a policy in place that requires our officers to respond, requires them to do investigation, requires them to document them.

1991
03:18:24.379 --> 03:18:31.180
<v Bob Day>So I am just concerned that people would walk outta here and think that there's going to be some sort of dramatic change in police response as it relates to the federal law enforcement.

1992
03:18:31.180 --> 03:18:31.979
<v Bob Day>I think that's what the question is.

1993
03:18:32.760 --> 03:18:35.159
<v Bob Day>And I want to be clear on the record that that's not the case.

1994
03:18:36.440 --> 03:18:44.360
<v Bob Day>The other piece, the other 2 pieces around the bargaining, I've heard Councilor Pirtle-Guiney address this, but we are in bargaining now currently with the PPA contract.

1995
03:18:44.920 --> 03:18:47.319
<v Bob Day>Been several issues identified that are part of bargaining.

1996
03:18:47.399 --> 03:18:53.879
<v Bob Day>I don't believe that every single time that council or the state wants to act, that that's a subject of bargaining.

1997
03:18:53.879 --> 03:19:05.280
<v Bob Day>But there are aspects of this that I do believe have a safety component that are And I would just ask that we initiate the bargaining process as soon as possible with labor to demonstrate a commitment to the CBA.

1998
03:19:05.680 --> 03:19:12.719
<v Bob Day>And then finally, the changes that will occur, I would like you to be sensitive to the fact that this is going to add an administrative burden to the Police Bureau.

1999
03:19:12.959 --> 03:19:15.200
<v Bob Day>This is going to require us to develop a policy.

2000
03:19:15.520 --> 03:19:17.200
<v Bob Day>It's going to require us to train to that policy.

2001
03:19:18.000 --> 03:19:21.840
<v Bob Day>It's going to require the documentation for the granting of the exceptions.

2002
03:19:22.639 --> 03:19:32.399
<v Bob Day>These are all additional tasks and they may seem Small or insignificant, but they do add to an already workload that's already substantial.

2003
03:19:32.799 --> 03:19:43.920
<v Bob Day>So there, I'm sure there will be a great deal of clarification needed after the ordinance if it is adopted, because we will want to make sure that we're meeting the expectations of council and so forth.

2004
03:19:44.159 --> 03:19:46.079
<v Bob Day>But I think there's a path forward.

2005
03:19:46.319 --> 03:19:57.459
<v Bob Day>I think continuing to work on House Bill 4138 together, working on the existing policy that we're putting together for that, and working with many of our immigrant groups that we have been doing for the last several months is the path forward.

2006
03:19:57.459 --> 03:20:12.340
<v Bob Day>But primarily, I see this as language that does not have a direct impact on the actual behavior of federal officers or Portland officers, primarily the new administrative burden placed upon us around identification and reporting.

2007
03:20:13.940 --> 03:20:15.540
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you for that, Chief.

2008
03:20:15.700 --> 03:20:17.700
<v Olivia Clark>I think you answered my question, but I'm not sure.

2009
03:20:18.020 --> 03:20:19.459
<v Olivia Clark>Just let me ask one more time.

2010
03:20:19.819 --> 03:20:26.860
<v Olivia Clark>If we just adopted the state law 4138 as opposed to this, what is the difference?

2011
03:20:26.940 --> 03:20:28.780
<v Olivia Clark>What are we doing differently under this?

2012
03:20:29.739 --> 03:20:36.379
<v Bob Day>Primarily what we're doing differently under this is the imposition or the additional requirements you're placing on the Portland Police Bureau.

2013
03:20:37.020 --> 03:20:37.100
<v Bob Day>Okay.

2014
03:20:37.180 --> 03:20:47.579
<v Bob Day>That's the primary change that's happening is the additional requirements that you're placing upon the Portland Police Bureau and potentially placing upon our partners who may want to come from other state agencies.

2015
03:20:47.860 --> 03:20:50.739
<v Bob Day>Again, remembering we can't do anything to affect the federal behavior.

2016
03:20:51.459 --> 03:20:54.100
<v Bob Day>So all of this is a local context.

2017
03:20:54.500 --> 03:21:26.100
<v Bob Day>And a concern that I have would be that as, you know, local agencies that we've worked really hard to establish our memorandums of agreement with and so forth, as they come into the city, you know, they're going to be expected to abide by these same expectations that are being placed on the police bureau, which the ultimate irony of this whole conversation is 5 years ago we were disciplining officers for not wearing a mask, and now, uh, for, you know, now we're going to tell them, um, we disciplined them if they didn't wear a mask, and now we're going to tell them we're going to discipline them if they do wear a mask.

2018
03:21:26.340 --> 03:21:35.620
<v Bob Day>So there are a lot of exceptions built in, and we will be working through those exceptions, and I appreciate the efforts that have been made to try and find a way to, uh, to meet those.

2019
03:21:36.420 --> 03:21:40.979
<v Bob Day>But at the end of the day, it's the impact of this has to do with the impact on the Portland Police Bureau.

2020
03:21:41.139 --> 03:21:46.200
<v Bob Day>It does not have context in the larger thank you for that, Chief Day.

2021
03:21:46.680 --> 03:21:52.680
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate trying to delineate what the real differences are between the state law and these ordinances.

2022
03:21:54.040 --> 03:22:10.170
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, I think it's really— speaking of irony, it's difficult for me to think about this in terms of the added burden because we're in the process of cutting the public safety budget, cutting the training budget, Cutting the P3s.

2023
03:22:10.729 --> 03:22:17.930
<v Olivia Clark>So I don't know how this work is going to be done when we can't even guarantee a reasonable response to 911.

2024
03:22:19.129 --> 03:22:23.370
<v Olivia Clark>So I think we've got a little bit of a disconnect here that really concerns me.

2025
03:22:23.530 --> 03:22:39.770
<v Olivia Clark>But thank you, Chief, for helping to clarify the difference between just adopting the state law as it is, maybe tweaking it later, and adopting this ordinance which creates a whole other burden on the thank you, Vice President Clark.

2026
03:22:40.010 --> 03:22:40.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2027
03:22:43.049 --> 03:22:43.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

2028
03:22:45.290 --> 03:22:56.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I know we've heard some of this already from Councilor Novick and Councilor Clark, but I want to say a few things about what this ordinance does and doesn't do and why I still find it to be important to pass.

2029
03:22:57.370 --> 03:23:03.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This ordinance does not give the City of Portland the authority to control or direct federal law enforcement.

2030
03:23:03.440 --> 03:23:05.360
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It will not get ICE out of Portland.

2031
03:23:05.760 --> 03:23:08.799
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It will not stop the terror that they are inflicting on our communities.

2032
03:23:09.200 --> 03:23:15.799
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And barring a miracle in the courts, it will not— in the courts, excuse me— it will not allow us to unmask federal agents.

2033
03:23:16.000 --> 03:23:32.020
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It will also take time to implement because there will have to be a rulemaking process, and because parts of this ordinance do impact working conditions and safety, which means that implementation will be bargained.

2034
03:23:33.459 --> 03:23:34.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't say any of this lightly.

2035
03:23:36.260 --> 03:23:40.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't say I am looking for a miracle in the courts because that's where I want to be standing.

2036
03:23:41.379 --> 03:23:45.379
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I think that we need to be honest with Portlanders about what this does and doesn't do.

2037
03:23:46.100 --> 03:23:51.139
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think we need to be honest about what our intent is if we do think this will go before the courts.

2038
03:23:54.659 --> 03:23:59.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, I say this to all of you, not to our constituents.

2039
03:24:00.909 --> 03:24:12.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it is incredibly irresponsible when we either personally or through not correcting our surrogates allow misinformation to be spread about the work that we're doing.

2040
03:24:13.149 --> 03:24:28.680
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's irresponsible because it sets expectations that we know our city cannot meet, and it's irresponsible because it sets an expectation that will be turned to in the courts that might make it harder for us to prevail and get that miracle.

2041
03:24:31.719 --> 03:24:37.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Despite my concerns there, um, I am excited to be supportive today.

2042
03:24:38.680 --> 03:24:46.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When this first came forward, I had some serious concerns about not only what was being said about it but also some of the structure.

2043
03:24:48.870 --> 03:24:58.790
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I also ran for office saying I would be a pragmatic progressive, and that means sitting down and doing the hard work of figuring out how to make policies like this workable.

2044
03:24:58.870 --> 03:25:13.909
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Councilor Kanal, I know we sometimes have our disagreements, but I appreciate that you took the time to sit down with me and talk through those structural concerns and figure out how we could make this an ordinance that we both felt would achieve the goals Portlanders were asking for.

2045
03:25:13.909 --> 03:25:14.149
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2046
03:25:15.500 --> 03:25:21.940
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Respond to the call from community for action, and also be implementable on the ground.

2047
03:25:22.379 --> 03:25:32.340
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we've gotten there, and I want to say a huge thank you to both of our staff who took even more time than we did to make sure that we got the language right.

2048
03:25:33.180 --> 03:25:39.739
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While this ordinance does not do the things I mentioned before, it does a few really important things that I think are worth our support.

2049
03:25:41.909 --> 03:26:00.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Even if we are hearing from the chief that much of what is in this ordinance is how our police operate, even if we hear from other cities that Portland has the standard in the state for how we should be operating, if community does not know that, we're not building trust.

2050
03:26:01.190 --> 03:26:05.510
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this ordinance ensures that we are all on the same page about what to expect.

2051
03:26:07.670 --> 03:26:27.309
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It adds important clarity on how we deal with people who cannot be identified, at least on initial glance, to make sure that Portlanders know what our police officers will do and that police officers have a laid-out order of what the work looks like.

2052
03:26:28.950 --> 03:26:31.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it pushes our police to do a little further investigation.

2053
03:26:31.829 --> 03:26:32.149
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

2054
03:26:32.319 --> 03:26:39.120
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To make sure that those calls are made every time, not just most of the time, that we're logging and reporting the details.

2055
03:26:39.440 --> 03:26:52.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And critically, what this does is it creates that reporting requirement which our community partners have said repeatedly will give them records through public records requests that can be used in court cases.

2056
03:26:54.479 --> 03:27:04.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are fighting in the courts— repeat, we are fighting in the courts over and over again against the federal administration, and we need the data to do so.

2057
03:27:04.770 --> 03:27:07.729
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are tools that we're passing today.

2058
03:27:07.889 --> 03:27:14.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They don't end the terror that the Trump administration has brought forward, but they give us tools in the fight.

2059
03:27:14.690 --> 03:27:18.209
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Portland has never been a city that sits back and waits for others to act.

2060
03:27:18.290 --> 03:27:20.049
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are a city that pushes.

2061
03:27:20.209 --> 03:27:24.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are a city that says, what tools do we have and how do we get ourselves more tools?

2062
03:27:25.090 --> 03:27:25.489
<v Mark Jackson>Thank you.

2063
03:27:25.739 --> 03:27:26.940
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think this does that.

2064
03:27:27.899 --> 03:27:57.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think this allows us to be clear about our high standards, to continue to try to do repair work and build trust between Portlanders and our police officers who serve us, and to make sure that we have the tools in place that our city and our partners can fight against the encroaching authoritarianism and overreach of federal law enforcement that we know we all want to push back against.

2065
03:27:58.889 --> 03:28:15.129
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am supporting this ordinance with some reservations about the expectations being too high, but also with hope that those increased tools allow us to continue to do the hard work that we have been doing together as a council.

2066
03:28:16.329 --> 03:28:19.450
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I hope that others are able to join me in supporting today.

2067
03:28:20.250 --> 03:28:21.129
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

2068
03:28:21.850 --> 03:28:22.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

2069
03:28:23.209 --> 03:28:23.690
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2070
03:28:24.649 --> 03:28:25.370
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

2071
03:28:25.770 --> 03:28:37.049
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I got in the queue because I was hoping to motion to limit debate to those in the queue because it is 12:54 and we— I would love to have an opportunity to have a first reading on my item.

2072
03:28:37.850 --> 03:28:40.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, I will limit debate to those who are in the queue right now.

2073
03:28:40.889 --> 03:28:43.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Councilor Clark will be our last on this item.

2074
03:28:43.850 --> 03:28:44.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

2075
03:28:44.889 --> 03:28:45.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

2076
03:28:47.930 --> 03:28:48.809
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

2077
03:28:49.850 --> 03:28:52.010
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to go back to our first reading.

2078
03:28:53.850 --> 03:28:55.370
<v Loretta Smith>Is, uh, Robert Taylor here?

2079
03:28:58.889 --> 03:28:59.209
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2080
03:28:59.290 --> 03:29:00.569
<v Loretta Smith>Could you come to the dais, please?

2081
03:29:10.090 --> 03:29:17.030
<v Loretta Smith>Um, my colleagues I almost have failed to, to bring up something important that you said, and I want to make sure that I have it right.

2082
03:29:18.229 --> 03:29:26.149
<v Loretta Smith>The last time that we talked about this, the first time that we heard it, you said that this ordinance is unconstitutional.

2083
03:29:26.870 --> 03:29:27.909
<v Loretta Smith>Is that still the case?

2084
03:29:28.149 --> 03:29:29.670
<v Loretta Smith>Is that still your opinion?

2085
03:29:31.190 --> 03:29:31.750
<v Jabril Willis>Uh, thank you.

2086
03:29:31.909 --> 03:29:33.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>For the record, Robert Taylor, City Attorney.

2087
03:29:34.709 --> 03:29:46.530
<v Mitch Green>According to current Ninth Circuit precedent, uh, the The city cannot regulate the federal government's identification or masking requirements.

2088
03:29:46.690 --> 03:29:49.649
<v Keelan McClymont>So that portion of this likely would be unconstitutional.

2089
03:29:50.049 --> 03:29:51.250
<v Loretta Smith>And that's binding?

2090
03:29:51.409 --> 03:29:51.969
<v Steve Novick>It would be bind—.

2091
03:29:52.209 --> 03:29:54.930
<v Keelan McClymont>That decision by the 9th Circuit would be binding on us.

2092
03:29:55.090 --> 03:29:57.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that portion of the ordinance would be unconstitutional.

2093
03:29:58.129 --> 03:30:05.250
<v Eric Zimmerman>Ordinance also has a severability clause, so that portion would be struck and the rest of it would remain in place.

2094
03:30:06.079 --> 03:30:06.559
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, great.

2095
03:30:07.200 --> 03:30:09.520
<v Loretta Smith>I, um, I will not be supporting this.

2096
03:30:10.799 --> 03:30:19.040
<v Loretta Smith>If, if our opinion from our attorneys are saying that this is a binding opinion from California, we should take heed to that.

2097
03:30:19.280 --> 03:30:26.000
<v Loretta Smith>And I know that many of you— Councilor, um, Pirtle-Guiney, I have a lot of respect for you and I support your opinion.

2098
03:30:26.319 --> 03:30:32.239
<v Loretta Smith>I know we move forward and we, and we push a little, but we also have to understand where boundaries are.

2099
03:30:33.120 --> 03:30:36.959
<v Loretta Smith>And I am still— I have not been moved by the testimony.

2100
03:30:37.440 --> 03:30:48.639
<v Loretta Smith>I have not been moved by the co-sponsors to do anything different other than if this is unconstitutional, we should not be supportive of this amendment.

2101
03:30:48.879 --> 03:30:50.000
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2102
03:30:50.239 --> 03:30:51.040
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

2103
03:30:51.440 --> 03:30:52.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

2104
03:30:53.280 --> 03:30:54.799
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

2105
03:30:56.399 --> 03:31:04.430
<v Steve Novick>On the issue of constitutionality, The state, when it passed its law, thought we had strong— they had strong legal arguments that it was constitutional.

2106
03:31:04.909 --> 03:31:08.909
<v Steve Novick>State of California, when it passed its similar law, thought they had strong legal arguments it was constitutional.

2107
03:31:09.709 --> 03:31:10.670
<v Steve Novick>And so do we.

2108
03:31:11.229 --> 03:31:19.790
<v Steve Novick>Because there was this unanimous bipartisan decision by a 3-judge panel of the Court of Appeals, it seems highly unlikely that that decision will be reversed.

2109
03:31:20.270 --> 03:31:25.790
<v Steve Novick>But it is barely conceivable that if the issue goes to a larger panel of the Court of Appeals, it could be reversed.

2110
03:31:25.950 --> 03:31:26.190
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

2111
03:31:27.370 --> 03:31:29.450
<v Steve Novick>So we are kind of hoping for a miracle.

2112
03:31:31.370 --> 03:31:37.209
<v Steve Novick>I do want to note in response to Councilor Clark's question that our ordinance is different from the state ordinance.

2113
03:31:37.530 --> 03:31:49.049
<v Steve Novick>The state's ordinance, through what I believe was an oversight, effectively exempted ICE from the identification requirement because it said that it only applied to people involved in criminal law enforcement, and ICE is primarily civil law enforcement.

2114
03:31:49.209 --> 03:31:57.620
<v Steve Novick>So our ordinance, if it does survive legal challenge, actually does apply the identification requirements to ICE, whereas the state's did not.

2115
03:31:58.180 --> 03:32:08.659
<v Steve Novick>The state also— its enforcement mechanism was simply citizen suits, and our ordinance specifically authorizes the mayor on the part of the city to bring suit against an agency that's violating the law.

2116
03:32:09.219 --> 03:32:16.979
<v Steve Novick>So there is a substantive difference if the ordinance, or the state's ordinance for that matter, happened to survive judicial scrutiny.

2117
03:32:17.059 --> 03:32:17.299
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2118
03:32:18.510 --> 03:32:19.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

2119
03:32:19.950 --> 03:32:20.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

2120
03:32:21.149 --> 03:32:22.030
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

2121
03:32:25.149 --> 03:32:28.190
<v Dan Ryan>First, thanks for everybody that's been showing up to testify.

2122
03:32:28.350 --> 03:32:28.829
<v Dan Ryan>It's been helpful.

2123
03:32:29.549 --> 03:32:34.190
<v Dan Ryan>And I really appreciated, Councilor Clark, that you did bring up the chief to have some more dialogue.

2124
03:32:35.069 --> 03:32:40.590
<v Dan Ryan>We listened to the testimony, but we didn't really have a lot of chance to do this type of dialogue that we're doing right now.

2125
03:32:41.389 --> 03:32:43.389
<v Dan Ryan>Ditto to you, Councilor Smith.

2126
03:32:43.450 --> 03:32:43.850
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Mayor.

2127
03:32:44.170 --> 03:32:45.530
<v Dan Ryan>I'm disappointed on your stand on this.

2128
03:32:45.690 --> 03:32:50.610
<v Dan Ryan>This legislation will put us in a place where we are overpromising and we're underdelivering.

2129
03:32:50.889 --> 03:33:02.450
<v Dan Ryan>It places our police in a no-win situation, just as half this council are comfortable defunding the police with cuts to training and the PS3s who are focused on primary property crime.

2130
03:33:03.129 --> 03:33:08.809
<v Dan Ryan>Yet we want to pass something and gamble with taxpayers' money at horrific odds, one in a million shot.

2131
03:33:09.049 --> 03:33:10.250
<v Dan Ryan>This is big hat, no cattle.

2132
03:33:13.120 --> 03:33:14.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

2133
03:33:14.559 --> 03:33:15.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

2134
03:33:19.440 --> 03:33:22.159
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, first, thanks to the city administrator and the chief.

2135
03:33:22.319 --> 03:33:26.079
<v Eric Zimmerman>I asked last time, given the amendments, that you weigh in, and you both have done that.

2136
03:33:26.239 --> 03:33:27.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I do want to say thank you for that.

2137
03:33:28.799 --> 03:33:29.680
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, it does help.

2138
03:33:30.159 --> 03:33:36.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>I wasn't sure what the outcome of the amendments, um, that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney had worked on was going to be.

2139
03:33:36.799 --> 03:33:39.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so, uh, That was helpful.

2140
03:33:42.299 --> 03:33:51.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, the impersonation laws that exist on the books have allowed, I think, Portland Police to do a good job at those who break that law.

2141
03:33:52.700 --> 03:34:19.870
<v Eric Zimmerman>The gold standard, as was discussed to us by Representative Willie Chotson when he appeared here months ago and talked about this when they passed House Bill 4138, was the reason why I wrote An ordinance that I offered up behind the scenes that if this was going to go too far or not be seen as constitutional, that we let the state take the lead on that part and we just enact what is state law, which is we have to do 4138.

2142
03:34:19.870 --> 03:34:21.709
<v Eric Zimmerman>I still think that was the right thing to do.

2143
03:34:21.790 --> 03:34:24.190
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it remains the right thing to do.

2144
03:34:27.469 --> 03:34:32.670
<v Eric Zimmerman>Constitutional questions, labor law questions, those were pretty important in my decision here.

2145
03:34:34.059 --> 03:34:45.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what I'm most disappointed about is what some folks have alluded to, is this lie that's been told to the public that somehow Portland Police are going to be snatching masks off of federal officers.

2146
03:34:45.739 --> 03:34:54.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's very clear with the Chief of Police and others that one, that remains a thing that would be illegal for the City of Portland to do to them and isn't something that will happen.

2147
03:34:55.420 --> 03:34:59.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm sorry that that misperception has grown so much.

2148
03:34:59.309 --> 03:35:10.590
<v Eric Zimmerman>So much as this went forward, because 4138 was designed to be a good, good step forward, uh, a good promise to Oregonians across, and Portland could have been a teammate in all of that.

2149
03:35:11.309 --> 03:35:23.389
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm, I'm upset by that, but I, at this point, am, you know, I think that there was a reason why that has remained in this, in this, in the ether, if you will.

2150
03:35:24.430 --> 03:35:28.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, With the way that the sponsors have put things forward.

2151
03:35:29.950 --> 03:35:33.309
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, that's— that remains deeply concerning.

2152
03:35:35.149 --> 03:35:45.870
<v Eric Zimmerman>But for all the reasons that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney laid out, I think those are all the reasons why a no vote on going further than 4138 is the right thing today.

2153
03:35:46.750 --> 03:35:53.930
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that what she laid out, when you have questions of constitutionality, questions of labor law, question of perception for your public.

2154
03:35:54.729 --> 03:36:01.370
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not in the business of lying to my public, and I think that this will further that in an unfortunate manner.

2155
03:36:02.409 --> 03:36:06.809
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I also will be a no vote today, uh, moving forward.

2156
03:36:07.450 --> 03:36:07.690
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

2157
03:36:08.010 --> 03:36:16.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>I hope that others will consider that so that we can work on a House Bill 4138 compliant ordinance as, uh, is available as soon as this body is ready for it.

2158
03:36:17.690 --> 03:36:18.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2159
03:36:18.989 --> 03:36:19.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

2160
03:36:20.989 --> 03:36:24.670
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, um, colleagues, community.

2161
03:36:24.989 --> 03:36:38.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, today is the culmination of 9 months of outreach, listening, collaboration, and workshopping with community public safety leaders, state legislators, including the prime sponsor of House Bill 4138 who came in support of this, and attorneys, and many of you here in the room.

2162
03:36:38.909 --> 03:36:47.559
<v Sameer Kanal>It's also the tireless— a result of tireless advocacy from Portlanders who believe that we should be a city that holds true to its values And stands up for immigrant, refugee, and Latino communities.

2163
03:36:48.440 --> 03:36:51.639
<v Sameer Kanal>Portlanders have been asking us to do something, and today we will see if we do.

2164
03:36:53.799 --> 03:36:58.200
<v Sameer Kanal>Fundamentally, this has always been about a single, simple premise: you have a right to know who's policing you.

2165
03:36:58.760 --> 03:37:04.360
<v Sameer Kanal>I said throughout this process that when it comes to the federal government, there's a lot we can't do, but everything we can do, we must do.

2166
03:37:04.840 --> 03:37:09.879
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe we've arrived at a piece of legislation that does the most it can to protect Portlanders within the limits of federal law.

2167
03:37:10.280 --> 03:37:15.280
<v Sameer Kanal>We cannot forcibly unmask at ICE, but we do get to decide what we want our laws to be.

2168
03:37:15.440 --> 03:37:28.799
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to thank my co-sponsors, Councilor Morillo and Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, for their willingness to roll up their sleeves and spend countless hours working through code, laws, Constitution, and public safety practices to thread the needle on legislation that is both meaningful and implementable.

2169
03:37:28.879 --> 03:37:31.920
<v Sameer Kanal>I know other colleagues have also been involved in that, such as Councilor Novick.

2170
03:37:32.559 --> 03:37:35.840
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to thank everyone who shared testimony and reached out to our office in support.

2171
03:37:36.079 --> 03:37:50.010
<v Sameer Kanal>Hundreds of people shared stories of why this means so much to you, from parishioners too afraid to attend church services to individuals who filed restraining orders worried about how easy it would be for their abuser to put on a mask and harm them, to the need to protect the integrity of law enforcement's role.

2172
03:37:50.969 --> 03:37:59.370
<v Sameer Kanal>The common sense masking policy and minimum identification standards we're voting on today are a step towards greater transparency and accountability, without which there is no true public safety.

2173
03:38:00.090 --> 03:38:07.399
<v Sameer Kanal>Verification and documentation policies will help combat the increasing threat posed by imposters and help us understand who's operating in our city and where.

2174
03:38:07.799 --> 03:38:13.799
<v Sameer Kanal>And the injunctive relief provision offers a pathway for pursuing enforcement when our masking and identification policies aren't followed.

2175
03:38:14.600 --> 03:38:26.760
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to take the opportunity to speak directly to the conversation with relation to the letter from Chief Day, and I want to thank Chief Day for taking the time to write that, as well as to ADC Hughes for his time, which he's put in a lot of, to provide several rounds of feedback.

2176
03:38:26.920 --> 03:38:33.030
<v Sameer Kanal>What I appreciate the most about that letter is that it was clear about what the needs were, and there were 3 specific asks in it.

2177
03:38:33.430 --> 03:38:39.190
<v Sameer Kanal>First, establish a clear understanding between your offices and the public that this ordinance cannot and will not unmask ICE agents.

2178
03:38:39.829 --> 03:38:46.950
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick already spoke to this, so, so have some others, but since I'm the primary sponsor, let me say this clearly: this ordinance cannot and will not unmask ICE agents.

2179
03:38:48.309 --> 03:38:50.229
<v Sameer Kanal>Second, acknowledge and initiate the bargaining process.

2180
03:38:50.549 --> 03:38:52.950
<v Sameer Kanal>I absolutely have acknowledged the bargaining process.

2181
03:38:53.190 --> 03:38:59.840
<v Sameer Kanal>It's been written into both the ordinance and the code that any portion which has a bargaining component needs to be bargained before it can be implemented.

2182
03:39:00.399 --> 03:39:08.239
<v Sameer Kanal>As a councilor, I personally can't initiate the bargaining process, but I, I join the chief and other councilors in asking the administration, uh, CA Lee and his team, to do so.

2183
03:39:08.879 --> 03:39:14.479
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, third, work to— with, uh, the PPB to reduce operational inefficiency and the administrative burden of this legislation.

2184
03:39:15.200 --> 03:39:21.680
<v Sameer Kanal>Mayor certainly has a role in this, the administration as well, but on the council side, I remain as committed as always to our role in reducing operational inefficiency.

2185
03:39:22.079 --> 03:39:26.549
<v Sameer Kanal>And as we think of specific administrative burdens we can help to alleviate, I'd love to be supportive and helping.

2186
03:39:26.950 --> 03:39:33.590
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I might disagree with other components of the letter and other opinions that people have on this, but I think these specific asks are very fair.

2187
03:39:34.229 --> 03:39:58.309
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, one other thing on this, and this isn't from the letter but from the conversation that came from it, this ordinance cannot both be something that does not significantly change police activity and procedure on the one hand, and on the other hand pose a significant change to response times, which is a valid concern that has been brought up by councilors who unfortunately voted no on amendments to assist with getting those police staffing cuts from the mayor filled.

2188
03:39:58.549 --> 03:40:00.469
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm disappointed by those votes.

2189
03:40:00.549 --> 03:40:02.950
<v Sameer Kanal>But either of those can be true, they both can't be true.

2190
03:40:03.430 --> 03:40:20.649
<v Sameer Kanal>And just this week, a Noticias Telemundo investigation, which you can look up, it's on NBC News as Fake ICE Agents Terrorize Immigrants Amid Trump's Crackdown, told the harrowing stories of a few of the people who who've been harmed by law enforcement impersonators since the current federal administration took over.

2191
03:40:20.729 --> 03:40:26.850
<v Sameer Kanal>A man whose forehead was split open by the butt of a gun, a woman beaten and raped after leaving a medical appointment.

2192
03:40:27.209 --> 03:40:30.170
<v Sameer Kanal>Imposters pointing a gun at an infant as they robbed the baby's parents.

2193
03:40:30.250 --> 03:40:40.809
<v Sameer Kanal>Many of our community members are terrified that something like this could happen to them, and with this vote, we can show them that they are not alone, that their city has their backs, and that secret police have no place in a democracy.

2194
03:40:41.690 --> 03:40:45.370
<v Sameer Kanal>I encourage you to stand with those Portlanders, colleagues, and help build trust in local law enforcement.

2195
03:40:47.030 --> 03:40:47.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

2196
03:40:48.069 --> 03:40:49.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark, last word.

2197
03:40:49.590 --> 03:40:50.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

2198
03:40:50.709 --> 03:40:51.670
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

2199
03:40:53.510 --> 03:40:55.270
<v Olivia Clark>I'm going to speak from my heart here.

2200
03:40:56.870 --> 03:41:02.709
<v Olivia Clark>To all the people that are in the audience, I believe you have the highest motivation, and I share that with you.

2201
03:41:04.229 --> 03:41:07.430
<v Olivia Clark>We desperately need change at the federal level, no question.

2202
03:41:08.709 --> 03:41:18.000
<v Olivia Clark>There's no question that we all oppose federal overreach and We're all on the same team, um, and I'm very concerned about encroaching fascism.

2203
03:41:18.319 --> 03:41:21.840
<v Olivia Clark>I think, as you are too, most of the people in this audience, I'm sure.

2204
03:41:22.799 --> 03:41:30.399
<v Olivia Clark>But I cannot in good conscience vote for something that does really not make a difference but maybe make people feel good.

2205
03:41:31.360 --> 03:41:49.799
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I think that we need to— if we're really going to do this, the folks that are voting for it need to be willing to restore the cuts that have been made in the public safety budget that are going to make it more difficult for our, our friends in public safety to protect us.

2206
03:41:50.200 --> 03:41:51.559
<v Olivia Clark>There's a real disconnect here.

2207
03:41:52.360 --> 03:41:55.159
<v Olivia Clark>But I want to— I want you to know that I appreciate you.

2208
03:41:55.399 --> 03:41:57.639
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate what you've tried to do.

2209
03:41:57.959 --> 03:42:01.719
<v Olivia Clark>I don't think it will make a difference, and I think we're doing you a disservice.

2210
03:42:02.520 --> 03:42:03.799
<v Olivia Clark>So with that, I am going to vote no.

2211
03:42:03.799 --> 03:42:04.040
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2212
03:42:05.090 --> 03:42:06.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

2213
03:42:07.250 --> 03:42:10.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can we please call the roll on this item?

2214
03:42:13.170 --> 03:42:13.329
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

2215
03:42:14.209 --> 03:42:14.290
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2216
03:42:17.250 --> 03:42:17.329
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2217
03:42:19.090 --> 03:42:19.170
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

2218
03:42:22.049 --> 03:42:22.690
<v Karen Shirey>Good work, colleagues.

2219
03:42:23.010 --> 03:42:23.809
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm proud to vote aye.

2220
03:42:24.930 --> 03:42:25.250
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

2221
03:42:27.010 --> 03:42:28.010
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2222
03:42:29.819 --> 03:42:30.299
<v Keelan McClymont>Did you say aye?

2223
03:42:30.299 --> 03:42:30.940
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, I'm sorry.

2224
03:42:31.340 --> 03:42:31.420
<v Keelan McClymont>Sorry.

2225
03:42:32.459 --> 03:42:33.659
<v Keelan McClymont>Sorry, I was like, wait a minute.

2226
03:42:33.819 --> 03:42:34.379
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

2227
03:42:34.540 --> 03:42:35.100
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye, thank you.

2228
03:42:35.260 --> 03:42:35.819
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2229
03:42:36.059 --> 03:42:36.379
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

2230
03:42:36.540 --> 03:42:36.620
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2231
03:42:36.940 --> 03:42:37.659
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2232
03:42:37.899 --> 03:42:38.459
<v Olivia Clark>No.

2233
03:42:38.700 --> 03:42:39.100
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2234
03:42:39.260 --> 03:42:39.899
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2235
03:42:40.219 --> 03:42:40.700
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2236
03:42:40.780 --> 03:42:41.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

2237
03:42:41.500 --> 03:42:42.500
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2238
03:42:43.500 --> 03:42:44.379
<v Keelan McClymont>Great work, aye.

2239
03:42:45.340 --> 03:42:45.979
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2240
03:42:46.219 --> 03:42:46.780
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2241
03:42:47.100 --> 03:42:47.659
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2242
03:42:47.739 --> 03:42:48.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2243
03:42:48.700 --> 03:42:53.219
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with a vote of 8 ayes and 4 nos.

2244
03:42:55.030 --> 03:42:57.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Congratulations, all involved.

2245
03:42:57.750 --> 03:42:59.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please move to item 15?

2246
03:43:02.549 --> 03:43:14.469
<v Keelan McClymont>2026-147, amend arts tax code to provide tax relief, promote sustainability of Arts Access Fund, define critical terms, and respond to community and audit recommendations.

2247
03:43:14.790 --> 03:43:16.469
<v Keelan McClymont>Amend Code Chapter 6.10.

2248
03:43:17.670 --> 03:43:18.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

2249
03:43:18.309 --> 03:43:20.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

2250
03:43:21.750 --> 03:43:24.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there further council discussion?

2251
03:43:24.469 --> 03:43:26.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith, is that a legacy hand?

2252
03:43:26.149 --> 03:43:27.190
<v Loretta Smith>A legacy, I'm sorry.

2253
03:43:27.270 --> 03:43:28.069
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2254
03:43:28.229 --> 03:43:30.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any further discussion of this item?

2255
03:43:34.069 --> 03:43:36.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one in the queue, can we please call the roll?

2256
03:43:37.110 --> 03:43:38.110
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

2257
03:43:40.629 --> 03:43:40.709
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2258
03:43:41.510 --> 03:43:42.510
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

2259
03:43:42.950 --> 03:43:43.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2260
03:43:43.750 --> 03:43:43.829
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

2261
03:43:44.389 --> 03:43:45.389
<v Dan Ryan>No.

2262
03:43:46.069 --> 03:43:46.790
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

2263
03:43:47.680 --> 03:43:49.600
<v Keelan McClymont>Really grateful for your leadership, Council President.

2264
03:43:50.000 --> 03:43:50.639
<v Lorena Gayette>Proud to vote aye.

2265
03:43:51.760 --> 03:43:52.000
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo.

2266
03:43:52.559 --> 03:43:53.600
<v Angelita Morillo>Appreciate this improvement.

2267
03:43:53.680 --> 03:43:53.760
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2268
03:43:54.479 --> 03:43:54.719
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

2269
03:43:55.120 --> 03:43:55.200
<v Steve Novick>No.

2270
03:43:56.319 --> 03:43:56.399
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

2271
03:43:57.520 --> 03:43:57.600
<v Olivia Clark>No.

2272
03:43:58.319 --> 03:43:58.399
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

2273
03:43:59.440 --> 03:43:59.520
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2274
03:44:00.479 --> 03:44:00.879
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

2275
03:44:01.280 --> 03:44:01.360
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

2276
03:44:02.639 --> 03:44:03.040
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

2277
03:44:04.479 --> 03:44:04.559
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2278
03:44:06.079 --> 03:44:06.159
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

2279
03:44:07.120 --> 03:44:07.200
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2280
03:44:08.000 --> 03:44:08.319
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

2281
03:44:08.719 --> 03:44:08.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2282
03:44:09.680 --> 03:44:13.120
<v Keelan McClymont>The ordinance passes with a vote of 7 ayes and 5 nos.

2283
03:44:14.420 --> 03:44:14.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

2284
03:44:15.139 --> 03:44:16.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 16?

2285
03:44:20.420 --> 03:44:30.340
<v Keelan McClymont>Document 2026-149, add code to prohibit the sale or provision of certain force-fed poultry products, add code Chapter 17.110.

2286
03:44:31.860 --> 03:44:40.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is amazingly still the first reading of this ordinance, which was first heard in the former Arts and Economy committee on January 27th of this year.

2287
03:44:40.590 --> 03:44:53.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to thank Councilor Green for his grace and patience as this item has been postponed repeatedly to make time, uh, to make space for time-sensitive legislation, most recently waiting a full month between public testimony and the completion of this first reading of this item.

2288
03:44:54.270 --> 03:45:02.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>That delay was triggered by Councilor Green's choice to pause this item specifically to ensure that the Portland Children's Levy testimony could be heard.

2289
03:45:02.190 --> 03:45:04.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I hope that that does not go unnoticed.

2290
03:45:04.440 --> 03:45:09.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green, would you like to reorient us to this ordinance, and then we can enter debate in the queue?

2291
03:45:10.440 --> 03:45:17.479
<v Mitch Green>Yes, thank you so much, Council President, and thanks for acknowledging the willingness of my office to prioritize other things ahead of this.

2292
03:45:19.000 --> 03:45:21.159
<v Mitch Green>And I just hope folks are paying attention to that.

2293
03:45:22.280 --> 03:45:31.159
<v Mitch Green>So colleagues, what this does— we first talked about this in the Arts and Economy Committee— this ordinance would prohibit the sale or provision of force-fed poultry products.

2294
03:45:31.760 --> 03:45:35.200
<v Mitch Green>AKA things like foie gras, in the City of Portland.

2295
03:45:35.360 --> 03:45:39.040
<v Mitch Green>It also covers foods where a force-fed product is an ingredient.

2296
03:45:39.600 --> 03:46:00.319
<v Mitch Green>The key piece here is that it doesn't sort of require the Bureau to go out and actively inspect and make sure that there's compliance, but rather this is sort of a complaint-driven system where the ordinance creates a rebuttable presumption that any item advertised or represented as foie gras Is a force-fed product.

2297
03:46:00.319 --> 03:46:10.000
<v Mitch Green>So if you have foie gras on your menu, there's a presumption that you're feeding— you have an ingredient that doesn't comply with the ordinance.

2298
03:46:11.920 --> 03:46:17.440
<v Mitch Green>And it can only be rebutted by documentary evidence showing the product is not force-fed.

2299
03:46:17.760 --> 03:46:24.319
<v Mitch Green>It also does not ban foie gras products that might be non-force-fed.

2300
03:46:24.479 --> 03:46:30.049
<v Mitch Green>There are some Specific cases where you can produce foie gras without force-feeding poultry.

2301
03:46:30.129 --> 03:46:33.889
<v Mitch Green>So that's the basic contours of what the ordinance does.

2302
03:46:35.569 --> 03:46:45.969
<v Mitch Green>I just want to know that the community, you've seen in these chambers many times, this has been something that they've been looking for this body to take up for a long period of time.

2303
03:46:46.610 --> 03:46:49.729
<v Mitch Green>And it's not just when we started in City Hall.

2304
03:46:49.969 --> 03:46:52.049
<v Mitch Green>It is something that goes back many, many years.

2305
03:46:52.049 --> 03:46:52.290
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2306
03:46:53.040 --> 03:47:00.159
<v Mitch Green>And I want to thank the advocates for being dogged in this, and I'm happy to be your champion on this.

2307
03:47:00.239 --> 03:47:06.479
<v Mitch Green>So colleagues, I hope that we can have a good conversation around this, and I hope to have your support for the ordinance.

2308
03:47:06.719 --> 03:47:09.280
<v Mitch Green>And I also noticed that there's been an amendment that's been filed.

2309
03:47:09.440 --> 03:47:11.840
<v Mitch Green>So Councilor Clark, do you want to speak to your amendment?

2310
03:47:12.799 --> 03:47:13.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark?

2311
03:47:13.440 --> 03:47:14.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark?

2312
03:47:15.040 --> 03:47:15.280
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

2313
03:47:17.200 --> 03:47:20.750
<v Olivia Clark>It's Councilor Green and Council President, um, I do have an amendment.

2314
03:47:20.989 --> 03:47:21.709
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's filed.

2315
03:47:22.190 --> 03:47:22.989
<v Olivia Clark>Everybody should have seen it.

2316
03:47:23.790 --> 03:47:31.870
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, basically, um, it would change the effective date of the ordinance to July 1st, 2027.

2317
03:47:33.709 --> 03:47:37.790
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm asking for your support for this for a variety of reasons.

2318
03:47:38.829 --> 03:47:49.030
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I think, you know, we do have a, a minority of restaurants, just a handful in Portland, that Do serve foie gras and that actually have a reputation for that service.

2319
03:47:50.709 --> 03:47:52.870
<v Olivia Clark>They're known probably internationally.

2320
03:47:54.149 --> 03:48:04.629
<v Olivia Clark>But if this thing passes today without this amendment, it's going to be very difficult for them to rapidly change their way of doing business, their marketing strategy.

2321
03:48:06.149 --> 03:48:08.790
<v Olivia Clark>They need to develop a whole new different kind of menu.

2322
03:48:09.430 --> 03:48:12.030
<v Olivia Clark>There are some restaurants that, that focus on foie gras.

2323
03:48:13.069 --> 03:48:17.309
<v Olivia Clark>Um, so this really definitely impacts their ability to do business.

2324
03:48:18.989 --> 03:48:30.110
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm asking you to consider giving them additional time to change their menu, to draw down on their inventory, to come up with a different marketing strategy.

2325
03:48:31.069 --> 03:48:44.649
<v Olivia Clark>You know, we're already penalizing restaurants that have put us on the map, that has helped, helped us through, um, uh, difficult times, uh, have brought people here from all over the world to eat at our restaurants.

2326
03:48:45.129 --> 03:48:46.729
<v Olivia Clark>So we're already penalizing them.

2327
03:48:47.129 --> 03:48:56.090
<v Olivia Clark>I, I'm just asking you to give them more time to adapt to this new world order should, should the underlying ordinance pass.

2328
03:48:56.649 --> 03:48:56.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2329
03:48:57.049 --> 03:48:58.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so are you formally moving your—.

2330
03:48:58.729 --> 03:49:00.409
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, please, I would like to move my amendment.

2331
03:49:01.290 --> 03:49:04.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Clerk needs— Clerk 1 and Councilor Smith Second.

2332
03:49:05.409 --> 03:49:06.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, discussion to the amendment?

2333
03:49:08.370 --> 03:49:08.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

2334
03:49:09.409 --> 03:49:10.610
<v Loretta Smith>I think this is so important.

2335
03:49:11.170 --> 03:49:14.370
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, thank you, Council President and Councilor Clark.

2336
03:49:14.850 --> 03:49:41.719
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I appreciate you because as a small business owner too, previous to this, having an unfunded mandate, um, put upon you as a business owner, this, this gives them the, the kind of time that they need to, to recoup And I support you in this effort, and I think it's so important to remember that, um, these are small businesses.

2337
03:49:42.280 --> 03:49:52.040
<v Loretta Smith>They're the ones who, who pay the BLT, which also helped to pay some of those things that, that we, that we like and support in our city budget.

2338
03:49:52.360 --> 03:49:53.559
<v Loretta Smith>So I will be supporting you.

2339
03:49:53.959 --> 03:49:54.280
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2340
03:49:54.840 --> 03:49:55.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

2341
03:49:55.959 --> 03:49:57.440
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2342
03:49:57.809 --> 03:49:58.610
<v Mitch Green>Yes, this is to the amendment.

2343
03:50:01.010 --> 03:50:07.729
<v Mitch Green>I appreciated our brief phone call this morning, and thank you for motivating your reasons for this.

2344
03:50:09.729 --> 03:50:16.209
<v Mitch Green>You know, I'll say at the outset that I'm not comfortable waiting a year, but I am interested in this spirit of compromise.

2345
03:50:16.450 --> 03:50:20.530
<v Mitch Green>I am interested in having a conversation about whether we can meet in the middle on this.

2346
03:50:21.329 --> 03:50:36.340
<v Mitch Green>I am compelled, By the idea that perhaps 60 days effective upon the— past the effective date of the ordinance might be a bit of a tight timeline to change menus and to sort of pursue different marketing strategy.

2347
03:50:37.299 --> 03:50:50.430
<v Mitch Green>And so I would move to amend your amendment by just replacing— let's see here— just replacing it to 6 months so that the effect— I think that's January 1st, 2027.

2348
03:50:51.229 --> 03:50:51.309
<v Trent Aldridge>We—.

2349
03:50:51.549 --> 03:50:55.709
<v Mitch Green>I think it's better to say 120 days since the effective date of the, of the amendment.

2350
03:50:56.670 --> 03:50:59.309
<v Olivia Clark>Would you consider a compromise of 8 months?

2351
03:51:01.229 --> 03:51:01.309
<v Keelan McClymont>No?

2352
03:51:01.790 --> 03:51:01.870
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>Okay.

2353
03:51:02.190 --> 03:51:02.270
<v Henry Sheffer>No?

2354
03:51:02.350 --> 03:51:03.870
<v Mitch Green>I mean, no, I think 6 months—.

2355
03:51:04.430 --> 03:51:04.510
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

2356
03:51:04.750 --> 03:51:07.229
<v Mitch Green>Is, is, is about far as I can go on that.

2357
03:51:07.229 --> 03:51:08.750
<v Olivia Clark>I don't consider that a friendly amendment.

2358
03:51:08.829 --> 03:51:10.750
<v Mitch Green>Okay, well, there's, there's no friendly amendments in Robert's Rules.

2359
03:51:10.750 --> 03:51:11.069
<v Tanisha Renee>Yeah, sorry.

2360
03:51:11.069 --> 03:51:12.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Not, not a thing.

2361
03:51:12.270 --> 03:51:12.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

2362
03:51:12.670 --> 03:51:20.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, so Councilor Green has moved To amend the amendment to read 6 months, and Councilor Kanal has seconded.

2363
03:51:22.479 --> 03:51:23.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

2364
03:51:25.200 --> 03:51:28.479
<v Steve Novick>First of all, I should just say that I was hoping you'd say yes to 8 months.

2365
03:51:28.479 --> 03:51:30.079
<v Steve Novick>I'm not sure where I am in 6 months.

2366
03:51:30.079 --> 03:51:36.399
<v Steve Novick>But I actually, when I first saw Councilor Clark's amendment, my reaction was, don't restaurants change their menus every week?

2367
03:51:36.799 --> 03:51:44.700
<v Steve Novick>But I looked at the menu for Le Pigeon, and actually 2 of the 7 items on their non-vegetarian menu are foie gras.

2368
03:51:44.780 --> 03:51:46.059
<v Steve Novick>It is a significant part of their business.

2369
03:51:46.780 --> 03:51:50.299
<v Steve Novick>And I was just wondering, is Andrew Fortgang from Le Pigeon here today?

2370
03:51:50.700 --> 03:51:50.780
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

2371
03:51:51.420 --> 03:51:59.659
<v Steve Novick>Would it be okay if he came up and just sort of described the significance of foie gras to his venue and whether he thinks the additional time would make any difference?

2372
03:51:59.819 --> 03:52:03.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd be happy to, but I will just note we have 13 minutes left today.

2373
03:52:05.020 --> 03:52:06.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>So come on up, Andy.

2374
03:52:08.469 --> 03:52:18.309
<v Steve Novick>Is that the question?

2375
03:52:20.389 --> 03:52:29.030
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, the question is, you know, why and how would having additional time make a difference to adjust if this does pass?

2376
03:52:31.590 --> 03:52:36.069
<v Andrew Fortgang>Well, kind of as you put forward where, you know, we have the vegetarian menu and then we have our omnivore menu.

2377
03:52:36.750 --> 03:52:38.430
<v Andrew Fortgang>There are 2 foie gras items.

2378
03:52:38.510 --> 03:52:40.590
<v Andrew Fortgang>We've had those for a long time.

2379
03:52:40.989 --> 03:52:48.989
<v Andrew Fortgang>We're celebrating our 20th anniversary in District 3, I guess since there's been a District 3, but we've been there for 20 years and this has been a part of what we've done.

2380
03:52:49.229 --> 03:52:52.829
<v Andrew Fortgang>So 60 days is incredibly short.

2381
03:52:52.829 --> 03:52:57.870
<v Andrew Fortgang>And I feel strongly that this whole conversation is silly that we're even talking about this ban.

2382
03:52:57.870 --> 03:53:01.309
<v Andrew Fortgang>And I'd like the opportunity to talk a little bit more about that.

2383
03:53:01.950 --> 03:53:02.270
<v Andrew Fortgang>Okay.

2384
03:53:02.389 --> 03:53:10.629
<v Andrew Fortgang>And a year would really give us the time to make changes that, you know, it's not realistic for us to change how we're known.

2385
03:53:10.709 --> 03:53:12.950
<v Andrew Fortgang>We're known nationally, we're known internationally.

2386
03:53:13.030 --> 03:53:15.510
<v Andrew Fortgang>People come to the city to eat at our restaurant.

2387
03:53:19.590 --> 03:53:20.989
<v Andrew Fortgang>And we're here.

2388
03:53:21.750 --> 03:53:22.389
<v Michael Johnson>Come on.

2389
03:53:22.629 --> 03:53:23.750
<v Andrew Fortgang>60 Days is absurd.

2390
03:53:23.829 --> 03:53:25.590
<v Andrew Fortgang>That it's even a thing is absurd.

2391
03:53:25.590 --> 03:53:27.590
<v Andrew Fortgang>I'm sorry that I'm getting upset.

2392
03:53:27.590 --> 03:53:27.989
<v Andrew Fortgang>It's okay.

2393
03:53:28.290 --> 03:53:35.170
<v Andrew Fortgang>And if I can, once you've discussed the amendments, I'd like to speak for 60 to 90 seconds.

2394
03:53:36.450 --> 03:53:39.329
<v Steve Novick>Does it mean, you say 60 days is absurd.

2395
03:53:39.409 --> 03:53:43.889
<v Steve Novick>Would it really make a difference for you whether it was 6 months or 8 months or a year?

2396
03:53:44.129 --> 03:53:44.610
<v Steve Novick>I mean—.

2397
03:53:44.850 --> 03:53:46.770
<v Andrew Fortgang>I mean, a year, yeah, a year would be great.

2398
03:53:47.010 --> 03:53:49.370
<v Andrew Fortgang>Time goes fast, seasons go fast.

2399
03:53:49.969 --> 03:53:50.209
<v Andrew Fortgang>Okay.

2400
03:53:50.370 --> 03:53:54.969
<v Andrew Fortgang>We have employees, we have staff, we have, You know, we have plans.

2401
03:53:54.969 --> 03:53:57.770
<v Andrew Fortgang>We have people who have made plans to come here to eat at our restaurant.

2402
03:53:59.690 --> 03:54:01.129
<v Keelan McClymont>How far in advance do people book?

2403
03:54:02.569 --> 03:54:05.290
<v Andrew Fortgang>We take bookings up to 90 days ahead.

2404
03:54:05.850 --> 03:54:05.930
<v Bea Gilmore>Okay.

2405
03:54:07.290 --> 03:54:07.610
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

2406
03:54:08.569 --> 03:54:09.290
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

2407
03:54:09.930 --> 03:54:10.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

2408
03:54:13.850 --> 03:54:15.610
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I'm glad you're up here, Andy.

2409
03:54:15.690 --> 03:54:15.770
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

2410
03:54:16.170 --> 03:54:29.719
<v Dan Ryan>So you mentioned the amendment to me on the way in this morning, and I was confused, of course, because I was I was hoping we could vote this down in general, but you've been in touch with restaurateurs, hence Andy.

2411
03:54:29.879 --> 03:54:37.079
<v Dan Ryan>He made it really clear that a year was something that if forced to live with this new policy, that would be helpful, correct?

2412
03:54:37.159 --> 03:54:39.559
<v Dan Ryan>And so we just established that right now.

2413
03:54:40.600 --> 03:54:40.680
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

2414
03:54:41.000 --> 03:54:49.559
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to thank you, Councilor Clark, for being the person on the former committee who reached out to all the restaurants that this is impacting.

2415
03:54:49.989 --> 03:54:54.549
<v Dan Ryan>When we make decisions up here, the first people we should talk to are those being most impacted by legislation.

2416
03:54:55.430 --> 03:54:57.989
<v Dan Ryan>And they all made it really clear this would be harmful to them.

2417
03:54:58.870 --> 03:55:00.229
<v Dan Ryan>Congratulations on 20 years, by the way.

2418
03:55:00.389 --> 03:55:01.270
<v Dan Ryan>That's amazing.

2419
03:55:01.829 --> 03:55:03.590
<v Dan Ryan>Not too many restaurants can ever say that.

2420
03:55:04.389 --> 03:55:11.430
<v Dan Ryan>And anyway, I will support the 1 year and remain a big no on the overarching.

2421
03:55:11.829 --> 03:55:11.909
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks.

2422
03:55:12.389 --> 03:55:13.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

2423
03:55:13.510 --> 03:55:14.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

2424
03:55:16.639 --> 03:55:18.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>I thought that this year amendment would be easy.

2425
03:55:18.959 --> 03:55:30.879
<v Eric Zimmerman>I mean, it just seems like such a simple, meaningful change to this that I'm actually amazed that this has now become something that doesn't— a quick pass-through.

2426
03:55:31.280 --> 03:55:32.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm pretty disheartened by that.

2427
03:55:32.959 --> 03:55:42.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>I thought that that would make this workable, and I'm sorry that it seems like it may be more controversial than makes any reasonable sense to me.

2428
03:55:42.000 --> 03:55:53.540
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor So I, I think this feels like the, the city almost punching down or, or bullying in a way.

2429
03:55:54.020 --> 03:55:56.579
<v Eric Zimmerman>So Councilor Clark, I 100% support your amendment.

2430
03:55:58.020 --> 03:55:58.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2431
03:55:59.299 --> 03:55:59.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

2432
03:56:00.899 --> 03:56:02.260
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, uh, Council President.

2433
03:56:02.579 --> 03:56:12.809
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I guess I— my, my question for— I guess I was originally going to direct it to just Councilor Clark, but I, I guess it's I'd add in, uh, Councilor Zimmerman as well based on that comment.

2434
03:56:13.770 --> 03:56:15.850
<v Sameer Kanal>I just want to understand workable in this context.

2435
03:56:16.329 --> 03:56:20.090
<v Sameer Kanal>Are you saying that if this were to go a year out, you'd be voting in favor of the underlying ordinance?

2436
03:56:23.290 --> 03:56:23.370
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

2437
03:56:23.850 --> 03:56:24.010
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

2438
03:56:24.170 --> 03:56:24.969
<v Keelan McClymont>So what's the point?

2439
03:56:25.129 --> 03:56:25.209
<v Randall Blaszczak>Yep.

2440
03:56:25.530 --> 03:56:25.610
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks.

2441
03:56:26.489 --> 03:56:27.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

2442
03:56:27.610 --> 03:56:27.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor—.

2443
03:56:28.090 --> 03:56:29.290
<v Eric Zimmerman>Point is not punishing businesses.

2444
03:56:29.850 --> 03:56:30.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is the point.

2445
03:56:31.610 --> 03:56:32.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

2446
03:56:33.290 --> 03:56:36.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, I'm sorry, Councilor Green, is that a legacy hand?

2447
03:56:36.159 --> 03:56:37.200
<v Sameer Kanal>No, it's not.

2448
03:56:37.520 --> 03:56:37.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, I apologize.

2449
03:56:38.079 --> 03:56:38.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2450
03:56:39.920 --> 03:56:49.360
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say in response to Councilor Kanal's question that although Councilor Clark would not be voting against the underlying ordinance, voting for the underlying ordinance regardless of the extension, I would.

2451
03:56:52.239 --> 03:56:52.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2452
03:56:56.799 --> 03:57:03.459
<v Mitch Green>I think that when you talk about compromise, oftentimes It's a negotiation.

2453
03:57:03.620 --> 03:57:07.100
<v Mitch Green>So my initial position was 60 days on this ordinance.

2454
03:57:07.379 --> 03:57:10.659
<v Mitch Green>Then I saw an amendment that says, what about a year out?

2455
03:57:10.659 --> 03:57:30.879
<v Mitch Green>Now, I already know that Councilor Clark's going to be a no on the underlying, but if the intention here is to change this for the sake of making this more palatable for a broader set of councilors, then going halfway seems like the definition of compromise.

2456
03:57:31.120 --> 03:57:32.719
<v Mitch Green>6 Months is halfway between the two.

2457
03:57:33.600 --> 03:57:38.479
<v Mitch Green>I don't think you can hold inventories on fog law for longer than a couple weeks at a time.

2458
03:57:38.879 --> 03:57:39.440
<v Sihan Goetgheluck>It's frozen.

2459
03:57:40.319 --> 03:57:41.120
<v Mitch Green>Okay, well, that's all right.

2460
03:57:41.440 --> 03:57:42.479
<v Mitch Green>6 Months is plenty of time.

2461
03:57:43.840 --> 03:57:44.879
<v Mitch Green>6 Months is plenty of time.

2462
03:57:45.600 --> 03:57:48.239
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, two things can't be true at once.

2463
03:57:49.760 --> 03:57:54.399
<v Mitch Green>I've heard that this is a waste of time because it's such an insignificant change.

2464
03:57:54.579 --> 03:58:02.340
<v Mitch Green>Share of the restaurant scene in Portland, but that also banning foie gras will fundamentally destroy the restaurant scene in Portland.

2465
03:58:02.819 --> 03:58:04.659
<v Mitch Green>Those 2 things cannot be true at the same time.

2466
03:58:05.139 --> 03:58:07.620
<v Andrew Fortgang>It's the argument that the others— that you're making on the other side.

2467
03:58:07.940 --> 03:58:09.459
<v Mitch Green>Sir, you're not recognized right now.

2468
03:58:13.299 --> 03:58:19.780
<v Mitch Green>And so I hope to have your support on the amendment to the amendment, and then I hope we can move forward on this discussion.

2469
03:58:21.069 --> 03:58:21.870
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

2470
03:58:22.750 --> 03:58:24.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

2471
03:58:25.469 --> 03:58:26.829
<v Angelita Morillo>That's really generous, Councilor Green.

2472
03:58:27.229 --> 03:58:33.629
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not going to be supporting the amendment to the amendment now because of the behavior that I've seen up here when we're being told to compromise constantly.

2473
03:58:34.989 --> 03:58:36.670
<v Angelita Morillo>This council has supported small businesses.

2474
03:58:37.309 --> 03:58:39.709
<v Angelita Morillo>We supported it a lot through the amendment process.

2475
03:58:40.510 --> 03:58:45.389
<v Angelita Morillo>And yes, even the socialists voted in favor of amendments to support small businesses, crazy as it may seem.

2476
03:58:46.850 --> 03:58:51.729
<v Angelita Morillo>So I will not be supporting an amendment to whittle this away any further.

2477
03:58:52.290 --> 03:58:53.489
<v Angelita Morillo>This is a very simple policy.

2478
03:58:55.729 --> 03:58:58.450
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that you have a fantastic restaurant.

2479
03:58:58.770 --> 03:59:00.129
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's going to continue to succeed.

2480
03:59:00.610 --> 03:59:01.889
<v Angelita Morillo>I think 6 months is generous.

2481
03:59:02.610 --> 03:59:06.129
<v Angelita Morillo>So that was plenty of time to make those changes.

2482
03:59:07.170 --> 03:59:09.250
<v Angelita Morillo>And this is very simple.

2483
03:59:11.170 --> 03:59:13.729
<v Angelita Morillo>And very simple things get dragged out by this body quite a lot.

2484
03:59:13.729 --> 03:59:14.129
<v Shannon Singleton>Councilor Dan Ryan.

2485
03:59:14.559 --> 03:59:24.399
<v Angelita Morillo>So, um, I— it's also just funny, like, the decorum things, who gets to have outbursts about what and when and how.

2486
03:59:24.799 --> 03:59:26.159
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Zimmerman, looking at you.

2487
03:59:26.879 --> 03:59:32.319
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, so I will be for sure voting in favor of this and just making sure that it passes.

2488
03:59:32.479 --> 03:59:32.559
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks.

2489
03:59:39.040 --> 03:59:40.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, seeing— I see Councilor Novick.

2490
03:59:41.620 --> 03:59:42.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that a—.

2491
03:59:42.659 --> 03:59:42.739
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah.

2492
03:59:43.620 --> 03:59:49.620
<v Steve Novick>Oh yeah, actually, this is just an appeal to Councilor Green, recognizing that there's not really a lot of science to this.

2493
03:59:49.940 --> 03:59:53.540
<v Steve Novick>I just really would feel more comfortable with 8 months than with 6.

2494
03:59:54.340 --> 03:59:58.100
<v Steve Novick>Um, so is there any chance that you will be willing to reconsider that?

2495
04:00:01.780 --> 04:00:02.659
<v Steve Novick>Just based on vibes?

2496
04:00:04.340 --> 04:00:04.979
<v Steve Novick>Sorry, no.

2497
04:00:06.100 --> 04:00:06.260
<v Bea Gilmore>All right.

2498
04:00:08.270 --> 04:00:09.870
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you, Councilor Novick.

2499
04:00:10.909 --> 04:00:15.870
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue, can we please call the roll on the Green Amendment to the Clark Amendment?

2500
04:00:17.870 --> 04:00:19.309
<v Keelan McClymont>Can you please restate what that is?

2501
04:00:19.469 --> 04:00:20.989
<v Keelan McClymont>That is just changing it to 6 months?

2502
04:00:21.389 --> 04:00:22.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Correct, yes.

2503
04:00:22.270 --> 04:00:29.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>This, uh, the Green Amendment to the Clark Amendment would reduce it to a 6-month, uh, timeline rather than a 12-month timeline.

2504
04:00:29.870 --> 04:00:34.750
<v Keelan McClymont>And then, sorry, just to clarify, are we saying 6 months or are we saying January 1st, 2024?

2505
04:00:36.430 --> 04:00:37.709
<v Mitch Green>I'll clarify my intent.

2506
04:00:37.709 --> 04:00:44.510
<v Mitch Green>The original language had a relative date marker, so 60 days after passage of the effective date of the ordinance.

2507
04:00:44.750 --> 04:00:48.670
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Clark put a date that was a year out.

2508
04:00:48.909 --> 04:00:51.950
<v Mitch Green>My intent would be to just change it from 60 days to 120 days.

2509
04:00:52.590 --> 04:00:52.829
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

2510
04:00:55.549 --> 04:00:55.629
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

2511
04:00:56.909 --> 04:00:57.629
<v John Washington>180 Days.

2512
04:00:57.709 --> 04:00:58.989
<v Mitch Green>I'm sorry, 180 days.

2513
04:00:59.069 --> 04:00:59.389
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2514
04:00:59.629 --> 04:01:00.350
<v Keelan McClymont>180 Days.

2515
04:01:03.559 --> 04:01:07.319
<v Keelan McClymont>So to be clear, the amendment is for January 2027?

2516
04:01:07.719 --> 04:01:11.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>No, it's 180 days after approval by this body.

2517
04:01:13.559 --> 04:01:13.639
<v Randall Blaszczak>Okay.

2518
04:01:15.719 --> 04:01:18.040
<v Steve Novick>After approval or effective date, or is there a difference between them?

2519
04:01:18.040 --> 04:01:18.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, effective date.

2520
04:01:19.239 --> 04:01:19.319
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

2521
04:01:21.719 --> 04:01:25.239
<v Sameer Kanal>So just to clarify, this is not currently an emergency ordinance.

2522
04:01:25.719 --> 04:01:38.010
<v Sameer Kanal>So if it's 180 days after the effective date, This is a point of information, I apologize, uh, that it'd actually be 7 months, just to clarify, um, from the date of the final vote.

2523
04:01:38.010 --> 04:01:42.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Right, because there's a 30-day activation after the end of approval of non-emergency ordinances.

2524
04:01:42.649 --> 04:01:44.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Cass, could we please call the roll?

2525
04:01:45.209 --> 04:01:45.450
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

2526
04:01:46.489 --> 04:01:46.569
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2527
04:01:47.450 --> 04:01:47.850
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

2528
04:01:52.889 --> 04:01:53.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2529
04:01:55.940 --> 04:01:56.020
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2530
04:01:56.500 --> 04:01:56.579
<v Dan Ryan>No.

2531
04:01:57.459 --> 04:01:58.340
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

2532
04:01:58.579 --> 04:01:58.659
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2533
04:01:59.379 --> 04:02:00.379
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

2534
04:02:01.379 --> 04:02:05.340
<v Angelita Morillo>Because I expect we'll have 7 votes with the compromise, then yes.

2535
04:02:06.579 --> 04:02:07.059
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

2536
04:02:07.219 --> 04:02:07.299
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2537
04:02:08.420 --> 04:02:09.420
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2538
04:02:10.739 --> 04:02:11.739
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2539
04:02:12.819 --> 04:02:13.780
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2540
04:02:13.940 --> 04:02:14.020
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2541
04:02:14.899 --> 04:02:15.899
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2542
04:02:17.139 --> 04:02:18.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

2543
04:02:18.340 --> 04:02:19.340
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2544
04:02:19.700 --> 04:02:20.260
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2545
04:02:21.829 --> 04:02:21.909
<v Bea Gilmore>Aye.

2546
04:02:24.069 --> 04:02:24.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2547
04:02:26.549 --> 04:02:32.389
<v Keelan McClymont>The motion to amend Clark 1 is approved with a vote of 9 ayes and 3 nos.

2548
04:02:33.510 --> 04:02:37.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we now take a vote on the underlying amendment, the now amended Clark 1?

2549
04:02:37.590 --> 04:02:40.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, could we please call the roll on the now amended Clark 1?

2550
04:02:41.909 --> 04:02:42.149
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

2551
04:02:42.790 --> 04:02:46.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this would— this is now to have, uh, uh, 6 months.

2552
04:02:46.309 --> 04:02:49.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is codifying what we just fixed or what we just changed.

2553
04:02:51.659 --> 04:02:52.219
<v Andrew Fortgang>And—.

2554
04:02:52.299 --> 04:02:52.780
<v Dan Ryan>This is the overarching?

2555
04:02:53.420 --> 04:02:55.500
<v Dan Ryan>No, no, the 2nd amendment.

2556
04:02:55.659 --> 04:03:01.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the— we amended Councilor Clark's amendment, and now we have to vote on the amended amendment.

2557
04:03:02.139 --> 04:03:03.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>I know, I know.

2558
04:03:04.780 --> 04:03:06.540
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, sorry, sorry.

2559
04:03:06.860 --> 04:03:07.420
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

2560
04:03:07.659 --> 04:03:07.739
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2561
04:03:09.180 --> 04:03:10.180
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

2562
04:03:10.620 --> 04:03:10.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2563
04:03:11.500 --> 04:03:12.139
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2564
04:03:15.430 --> 04:03:17.270
<v Dan Ryan>This is for a year, uh, 6 months.

2565
04:03:17.510 --> 04:03:17.909
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>6 Months.

2566
04:03:18.069 --> 04:03:19.469
<v Loretta Smith>It's changing—.

2567
04:03:19.510 --> 04:03:19.829
<v John Washington>Point of order.

2568
04:03:19.829 --> 04:03:27.110
<v Sameer Kanal>It's changing it from the current 60 days to 180 days from the effective date.

2569
04:03:27.190 --> 04:03:28.629
<v Sameer Kanal>It is changing it from 60 to 180.

2570
04:03:28.709 --> 04:03:30.229
<v Dan Ryan>So it's a little bit of aspirin.

2571
04:03:30.629 --> 04:03:30.709
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

2572
04:03:30.950 --> 04:03:31.030
<v Michael Johnson>Aye.

2573
04:03:32.870 --> 04:03:34.190
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

2574
04:03:34.469 --> 04:03:34.549
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2575
04:03:35.190 --> 04:03:35.430
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo.

2576
04:03:35.989 --> 04:03:36.069
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2577
04:03:36.629 --> 04:03:37.030
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

2578
04:03:37.350 --> 04:03:37.670
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2579
04:03:38.239 --> 04:03:38.319
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2580
04:03:38.799 --> 04:03:38.879
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2581
04:03:39.680 --> 04:03:39.760
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2582
04:03:40.239 --> 04:03:40.319
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2583
04:03:41.040 --> 04:03:41.440
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2584
04:03:41.760 --> 04:03:41.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2585
04:03:42.399 --> 04:03:42.719
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2586
04:03:43.840 --> 04:03:43.920
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2587
04:03:44.799 --> 04:03:44.879
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2588
04:03:45.520 --> 04:03:45.600
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2589
04:03:46.399 --> 04:03:46.719
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2590
04:03:47.120 --> 04:03:47.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2591
04:03:47.920 --> 04:03:49.920
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with a vote of 12 ayes.

2592
04:03:50.639 --> 04:03:56.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, this is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

2593
04:03:56.559 --> 04:04:01.040
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is 1:30, and I am moving us to a second reading.

2594
04:04:03.530 --> 04:04:04.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Right, that's a good point.

2595
04:04:04.250 --> 04:04:05.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're right, we didn't actually.

2596
04:04:05.290 --> 04:04:12.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I, I actually have to continue this to a continued first reading because it is 1:30 and we are at a hard deadline.

2597
04:04:12.090 --> 04:04:15.290
<v Dan Ryan>Since Andy's here and he just wanted a little bit of time, can we please give him that?

2598
04:04:15.370 --> 04:04:17.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd be happy to give Andy, uh, 60 seconds.

2599
04:04:20.489 --> 04:04:24.690
<v Andrew Fortgang>I wrote something out to just— okay, hold, hold the start time.

2600
04:04:30.010 --> 04:04:31.530
<v Andrew Fortgang>Thank you for the chance to speak here.

2601
04:04:31.530 --> 04:04:38.530
<v Andrew Fortgang>I don't wanna reiterate too much of what has been covered already in prior council meetings or things that I've said before this body already.

2602
04:04:39.049 --> 04:04:49.770
<v Andrew Fortgang>Briefly, it has been laid out already that the text of the ordinance itself and the supporting documentation is misleading, contains clear inaccuracies and fearmongering half-truths.

2603
04:04:50.090 --> 04:04:53.930
<v Andrew Fortgang>Sadly, to me, that does not seem to be disqualifying for the ordinance.

2604
04:04:54.090 --> 04:05:00.430
<v Andrew Fortgang>I can't understand how inaccuracies cannot be disqualifying for an ordinance, but apparently it is.

2605
04:05:00.829 --> 04:05:02.270
<v Andrew Fortgang>That's the way it is.

2606
04:05:02.430 --> 04:05:20.989
<v Andrew Fortgang>As a restaurant, I am deeply concerned that the ordinance plans to implement this proposed ban by tattletaling, by partnering with a group that used guerrilla tactics to disrupt and disturb small independent restaurants, businesses that were operating lawfully.

2607
04:05:21.399 --> 04:05:28.360
<v Andrew Fortgang>That bullied restaurants, and then that the city looks to reward and empower that bad behavior and not support the restaurant industry.

2608
04:05:28.520 --> 04:05:31.719
<v Andrew Fortgang>That hurts, and it really seems wrong to me.

2609
04:05:31.959 --> 04:05:41.879
<v Andrew Fortgang>Separate, not as a business, but as a citizen of the city, I watched last week the tough choices and discussions over the budget, the hard cuts that had to be made.

2610
04:05:42.040 --> 04:05:47.000
<v Andrew Fortgang>It makes me slightly incensed, frankly, that this proposed ban will cost the city money.

2611
04:05:47.489 --> 04:05:50.129
<v Andrew Fortgang>In time and money with its implementation.

2612
04:05:50.450 --> 04:05:54.969
<v Andrew Fortgang>This is a fact that Councilor Smith demonstrated in the committee meeting back in January.

2613
04:05:55.489 --> 04:05:57.729
<v Andrew Fortgang>Further, the city will have to defend this bill in court.

2614
04:05:58.770 --> 04:06:09.409
<v Andrew Fortgang>That is completely squandering the city's resources to defend this bill with time and money of the city attorney or outsourcing to other attorneys.

2615
04:06:10.209 --> 04:06:14.290
<v Andrew Fortgang>All of that when all sides acknowledge that only 6 or 7 businesses even sell foie gras.

2616
04:06:14.370 --> 04:06:14.530
<v Andrew Fortgang>Thank you.

2617
04:06:15.389 --> 04:06:17.870
<v Andrew Fortgang>Portlanders, the city deserves better than that.

2618
04:06:18.030 --> 04:06:19.549
<v Andrew Fortgang>The city budget deserves better than that.

2619
04:06:19.870 --> 04:06:21.790
<v Andrew Fortgang>The city's resources deserve better than that.

2620
04:06:22.350 --> 04:06:24.270
<v Andrew Fortgang>It just does not feel like responsible governance.

2621
04:06:24.590 --> 04:06:25.229
<v Andrew Fortgang>It feels like politics.

2622
04:06:26.350 --> 04:06:29.389
<v Andrew Fortgang>And I urge all of you to think about this.

2623
04:06:30.350 --> 04:06:32.350
<v Andrew Fortgang>Vote what is really best for this city.

2624
04:06:33.870 --> 04:06:34.190
<v Andrew Fortgang>Thank you.

2625
04:06:35.950 --> 04:06:46.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, we will have the ability to discuss this at our next meeting, but I am moving this to second reading.

2626
04:06:47.040 --> 04:06:50.799
<v Angelita Morillo>And are the animal rights folks in the audience going to get a special time slot as well?

2627
04:06:51.760 --> 04:06:53.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will see when we get to second reading.

2628
04:06:53.280 --> 04:06:53.360
<v Bob Day>Great.

2629
04:06:54.319 --> 04:06:59.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>Council President, how do we move to a second reading if we haven't gone through the discussion, or are you just eliminating that?

2630
04:07:00.639 --> 04:07:02.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will have time for discussion at the second reading.

2631
04:07:02.639 --> 04:07:04.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>We always have time at second readings.

2632
04:07:05.200 --> 04:07:07.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>But you're eliminating one half of the time we have for discussion.

2633
04:07:08.219 --> 04:07:14.139
<v Eric Zimmerman>Which is first reading, and then we always have the option during a second reading for council discussion.

2634
04:07:14.379 --> 04:07:14.459
<v Lorena Gayette>True.

2635
04:07:15.260 --> 04:07:16.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am moving this one forward.

2636
04:07:18.459 --> 04:07:19.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, and with that, we are at 1:32.

2637
04:07:20.540 --> 04:07:22.299
<v Eric Zimmerman>I object to the motion by the chair.

2638
04:07:22.860 --> 04:07:23.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's noted.

2639
04:07:25.180 --> 04:07:26.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>With that, yes.

2640
04:07:29.899 --> 04:07:31.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, great.

2641
04:07:31.420 --> 04:07:32.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've asked for votes in the past on that.

2642
04:07:33.100 --> 04:07:33.180
<v Keelan McClymont>Great.

2643
04:07:34.450 --> 04:07:37.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilors, we will discuss this now.

2644
04:07:37.489 --> 04:07:38.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal?

2645
04:07:38.850 --> 04:07:39.569
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not in the queue.

2646
04:07:39.569 --> 04:07:39.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, okay.

2647
04:07:40.049 --> 04:07:40.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman?

2648
04:07:41.889 --> 04:07:46.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, there is a discussion about whether or not to move this to second reading or continue a first reading.

2649
04:07:47.889 --> 04:07:49.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we discuss— do we vote on this?

2650
04:07:50.209 --> 04:07:50.850
<v Keelan McClymont>Was there a second?

2651
04:07:51.569 --> 04:07:51.649
<v Tatiana Turdal>Yes.

2652
04:07:52.209 --> 04:07:53.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor Ryan seconds.

2653
04:07:53.729 --> 04:07:54.290
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, thank you.

2654
04:07:56.049 --> 04:07:56.930
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sorry, point of order.

2655
04:07:57.170 --> 04:08:04.469
<v Keelan McClymont>Is this just a challenge to the chair's decision to move to second reading and that's what the vote Yes, this is a non-debatable motion.

2656
04:08:04.709 --> 04:08:09.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>There has been a second, uh, about whether to move this to a continued first reading or move it to a second reading.

2657
04:08:10.149 --> 04:08:10.709
<v John Trinh>Can we call a vote?

2658
04:08:10.950 --> 04:08:11.030
<v Justice Rajeev>Yes.

2659
04:08:11.670 --> 04:08:11.750
<v Bea Gilmore>What?

2660
04:08:11.989 --> 04:08:13.110
<v Keelan McClymont>And a vote no means what?

2661
04:08:14.709 --> 04:08:15.030
<v John Washington>A vote—.

2662
04:08:15.590 --> 04:08:16.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, that's a good question.

2663
04:08:19.829 --> 04:08:21.510
<v Keelan McClymont>I just want to make sure I understand what I'm voting for.

2664
04:08:21.670 --> 04:08:26.389
<v Keelan McClymont>So yes means that I agree with Council President's decision, and no means I do not?

2665
04:08:26.549 --> 04:08:27.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>The opposite.

2666
04:08:27.809 --> 04:08:34.209
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you vote yes, that means that you agree that this should be moving to a continued first reading and overrule the ruling of the chair.

2667
04:08:35.649 --> 04:08:38.610
<v Keelan McClymont>And a vote of no means I don't want to overrule the chair's decision.

2668
04:08:39.010 --> 04:08:39.090
<v Lucy Olson>Correct.

2669
04:08:39.250 --> 04:08:39.329
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah.

2670
04:08:40.129 --> 04:08:40.370
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2671
04:08:40.850 --> 04:08:41.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2672
04:08:45.729 --> 04:08:45.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

2673
04:08:46.209 --> 04:08:47.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's move to a vote.

2674
04:08:47.729 --> 04:08:48.370
<v Steve Novick>Point of information.

2675
04:08:49.649 --> 04:08:53.489
<v Steve Novick>What happens with— did we already have public testimony on this and I didn't notice it?

2676
04:08:53.569 --> 04:08:54.209
<v Steve Novick>Did nobody sign up?

2677
04:08:54.290 --> 04:08:55.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>Public testimony happened a month ago.

2678
04:08:56.049 --> 04:08:56.129
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

2679
04:08:56.209 --> 04:08:56.530
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

2680
04:08:57.969 --> 04:08:58.930
<v Steve Novick>It's been a while ago.

2681
04:08:59.969 --> 04:09:02.129
<v Keelan McClymont>Only 70 or so, 80-something.

2682
04:09:02.450 --> 04:09:02.530
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

2683
04:09:02.930 --> 04:09:03.809
<v Keelan McClymont>Robert's saying the opposite.

2684
04:09:05.409 --> 04:09:06.129
<v Keelan McClymont>You testified.

2685
04:09:06.209 --> 04:09:06.370
<v Angelita Morillo>Everybody—.

2686
04:09:06.530 --> 04:09:07.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>And hold on a second, I'd like to verify.

2687
04:09:08.129 --> 04:09:13.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>We've got conflicting information in my chat here about whether a yes upholds the vote of the chair or upholds the motion.

2688
04:09:15.889 --> 04:09:18.049
<v Keelan McClymont>Robert's saying the opposite, so why don't we go with Robert?

2689
04:09:18.370 --> 04:09:22.129
<v Keelan McClymont>So the opposite yes will uphold the ruling of the chair.

2690
04:09:22.489 --> 04:09:27.370
<v Keelan McClymont>And a no would support Zimmerman's, um, moving— keeping it as a first reading.

2691
04:09:27.610 --> 04:09:28.969
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, just switched it.

2692
04:09:29.049 --> 04:09:29.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just gonna switch it.

2693
04:09:29.850 --> 04:09:32.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>A yes is to vote for me and a no is to vote for Zimmerman.

2694
04:09:33.209 --> 04:09:34.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's take the roll, please.

2695
04:09:35.770 --> 04:09:40.409
<v Keelan McClymont>I don't know that that's the official city attorney's ruling because that doesn't make sense to me.

2696
04:09:40.569 --> 04:09:40.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is what—.

2697
04:09:41.129 --> 04:09:47.770
<v Keelan McClymont>If Councilor Zimmerman is saying that he does not agree with your decision, then he's trying to overrule your decision.

2698
04:09:47.930 --> 04:09:53.149
<v Keelan McClymont>So me voting no would mean that I wanted Right?

2699
04:09:54.030 --> 04:09:54.190
<v John Trinh>You're—.

2700
04:09:55.790 --> 04:10:02.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>At this point, I'm just going to just say, because as long as we all know what we are voting on, I have, uh, made a ruling.

2701
04:10:02.909 --> 04:10:03.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>It has been challenged.

2702
04:10:03.950 --> 04:10:05.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you agree with that ruling, vote yes.

2703
04:10:05.629 --> 04:10:07.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>If you disagree with that ruling, vote no.

2704
04:10:08.190 --> 04:10:09.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

2705
04:10:10.030 --> 04:10:10.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Call the roll, please.

2706
04:10:12.110 --> 04:10:12.190
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

2707
04:10:13.389 --> 04:10:15.190
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh, sorry, no.

2708
04:10:15.959 --> 04:10:16.040
<v Randall Blaszczak>Yes.

2709
04:10:20.440 --> 04:10:28.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have questions about this still, and because this is not a debatable motion, I wasn't even able to ask if I could ask those questions if we moved to second reading.

2710
04:10:28.280 --> 04:10:31.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I'm sorry, Council President, but I have to be a no right now.

2711
04:10:38.200 --> 04:10:39.200
<v Keelan McClymont>No.

2712
04:10:41.170 --> 04:10:48.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think she has dropped off.

2713
04:10:49.969 --> 04:10:50.049
<v LaVeda Gilmore-Jones>Absent.

2714
04:10:51.489 --> 04:10:51.729
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo.

2715
04:10:52.690 --> 04:10:54.690
<v Angelita Morillo>We had over 70 people testify.

2716
04:10:54.770 --> 04:10:56.530
<v Angelita Morillo>That is extensive public process.

2717
04:10:57.409 --> 04:10:58.129
<v Angelita Morillo>Let's get it done.

2718
04:10:58.850 --> 04:10:58.930
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2719
04:10:59.889 --> 04:11:00.209
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

2720
04:11:00.610 --> 04:11:00.690
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

2721
04:11:01.489 --> 04:11:01.569
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

2722
04:11:03.409 --> 04:11:03.489
<v Olivia Clark>No.

2723
04:11:04.290 --> 04:11:04.370
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

2724
04:11:05.409 --> 04:11:05.489
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

2725
04:11:07.420 --> 04:11:07.819
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

2726
04:11:08.139 --> 04:11:08.219
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

2727
04:11:09.020 --> 04:11:09.340
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2728
04:11:10.299 --> 04:11:10.379
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

2729
04:11:12.059 --> 04:11:12.139
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2730
04:11:12.860 --> 04:11:12.940
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2731
04:11:13.979 --> 04:11:14.299
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2732
04:11:14.620 --> 04:11:14.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

2733
04:11:17.020 --> 04:11:25.260
<v Keelan McClymont>The motion carries with a vote— no, no, sorry, the motion fails with a vote of 6 ayes and 6 nos.

2734
04:11:25.899 --> 04:11:28.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, this item will be moved at— continued as—.

2735
04:11:28.540 --> 04:11:30.299
<v Loretta Smith>Is it 5 nos and 1 absent?

2736
04:11:32.690 --> 04:11:34.370
<v Keelan McClymont>It's 6— oh, sorry, sorry.

2737
04:11:34.770 --> 04:11:35.569
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah, my, my fault.

2738
04:11:35.969 --> 04:11:38.290
<v Keelan McClymont>6 Ayes, 5 nos, 1 absent.

2739
04:11:38.770 --> 04:11:48.690
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, we're moving to first reading, and we are— nope, we're moving to first— we're moving this to a continued first reading of this item because the appeal of the chair was not upheld.

2740
04:11:49.489 --> 04:11:51.250
<v Keelan McClymont>Is there anyone in the queue right now?

2741
04:11:51.969 --> 04:11:58.209
<v Sameer Kanal>Nope, we are, uh, if the appeal of the chair was not upheld.

2742
04:11:59.040 --> 04:12:01.840
<v Sameer Kanal>Then the appeal of the chair failed, which means the chair's ruling stands.

2743
04:12:02.719 --> 04:12:04.239
<v Sameer Kanal>If that's not the case—.

2744
04:12:05.280 --> 04:12:05.600
<v Tyler King>Hold on.

2745
04:12:06.719 --> 04:12:08.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, appreciate everybody sticking with us at home.

2746
04:12:09.280 --> 04:12:14.319
<v Keelan McClymont>So yeah, so the appeal of the chair stands— or no, no, the chair's ruling stands.

2747
04:12:14.719 --> 04:12:16.159
<v Keelan McClymont>The appeal was— the appeal failed.

2748
04:12:16.639 --> 04:12:24.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>The appeal failed, which means the chair ruling of the chair has stood, which means this item is moving to second reading and we are adjourned.

2749
04:12:24.399 --> 04:12:24.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2750
04:12:24.670 --> 04:12:26.430
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

2751
04:12:26.510 --> 04:12:28.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>Which means it should have been a no anyway.

2752
04:12:28.190 --> 04:12:28.270
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

2753
04:12:29.950 --> 04:12:30.270
<v Keelan McClymont>Right.

2754
04:12:30.350 --> 04:12:31.389
<v Sameer Kanal>He's like, that's right.

