WEBVTT

1
00:00:57.387 --> 00:00:58.767
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hey there, can you guys hear me?

2
00:05:05.134 --> 00:05:05.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good afternoon.

3
00:05:06.244 --> 00:05:10.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 2:01 PM on Tuesday, May 26th.

4
00:05:10.502 --> 00:05:15.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am calling to order today's meeting of the City Life Committee.

5
00:05:16.033 --> 00:05:17.300
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wendy, could you please call the roll?

6
00:05:19.060 --> 00:05:19.548
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

7
00:05:20.067 --> 00:05:20.767
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Ryan.

8
00:05:23.509 --> 00:05:23.605
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

9
00:05:23.783 --> 00:05:24.591
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Morillo?

10
00:05:26.043 --> 00:05:26.156
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

11
00:05:26.995 --> 00:05:27.706
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman?

12
00:05:28.771 --> 00:05:29.175
<v Eric Zimmerman>Here.

13
00:05:29.579 --> 00:05:30.692
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Avalos?

14
00:05:30.870 --> 00:05:31.112
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

15
00:05:32.242 --> 00:05:33.035
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney?

16
00:05:33.358 --> 00:05:33.487
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

17
00:05:33.634 --> 00:05:34.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

18
00:05:35.158 --> 00:05:37.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Christopher, could you please read the statement of conduct?

19
00:05:39.550 --> 00:05:41.211
<v Devin Mullins>Welcome to the meeting of the City Life Committee.

20
00:05:41.276 --> 00:05:46.665
<v Devin Mullins>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/citylife.

21
00:05:52.420 --> 00:05:55.839
<v Devin Mullins>Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

22
00:05:56.040 --> 00:05:58.879
<v Devin Mullins>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

23
00:05:58.879 --> 00:06:01.800
<v Devin Mullins>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

24
00:06:02.079 --> 00:06:07.170
<v Devin Mullins>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

25
00:06:07.680 --> 00:06:09.540
<v Devin Mullins>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

26
00:06:09.879 --> 00:06:10.980
<v Devin Mullins>The chair preserves order.

27
00:06:10.980 --> 00:06:18.100
<v Devin Mullins>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude one's testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

28
00:06:18.100 --> 00:06:18.199
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Dan Ryan.

29
00:06:18.216 --> 00:06:19.932
<v Devin Mullins>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

30
00:06:19.980 --> 00:06:22.113
<v Devin Mullins>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

31
00:06:22.483 --> 00:06:25.081
<v Devin Mullins>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

32
00:06:25.610 --> 00:06:28.144
<v Devin Mullins>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

33
00:06:28.497 --> 00:06:30.358
<v Devin Mullins>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

34
00:06:30.487 --> 00:06:32.204
<v Devin Mullins>When testifying, state your name for the record.

35
00:06:32.267 --> 00:06:34.995
<v Devin Mullins>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

36
00:06:35.315 --> 00:06:37.769
<v Devin Mullins>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

37
00:06:37.946 --> 00:06:38.266
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

38
00:06:39.245 --> 00:06:39.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Christopher.

39
00:06:40.593 --> 00:06:42.870
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we have 4 items on the agenda today.

40
00:06:42.999 --> 00:07:02.543
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll start with an update we have an update and overview of a policy that the former Labor and Workforce Committee was considering that got transferred to this committee around fair transparency for our transportation network companies and their contracted drivers.

41
00:07:03.232 --> 00:07:11.632
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Then we will hear from Councilor Novick's team about a change he is proposing in city code around signs in the right-of-way.

42
00:07:12.194 --> 00:07:18.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then we have 2 items from the administration that are the next steps step in the dissolution of the Mt.

43
00:07:18.848 --> 00:07:22.803
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hood Cable Regulatory Commission, which we first heard about a few weeks ago.

44
00:07:23.529 --> 00:07:28.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Before we move into all of that, do we have anybody signed up for public input today?

45
00:07:29.646 --> 00:07:30.920
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, there are 6 individuals.

46
00:07:31.355 --> 00:07:32.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, great.

47
00:07:32.968 --> 00:07:38.293
<v Unidentified speaker>So we have item number 1, public input on City Life Committee topics.

48
00:07:38.517 --> 00:07:53.444
<v Unidentified speaker>And just as a reminder for those signed up to testify, well, you'll be given 3 minutes each, and I'll call up folks in groups of So for those testifying in person, you'll see the timer countdown displayed on the monitor in front of the testimony table.

49
00:07:54.071 --> 00:07:57.185
<v Unidentified speaker>And for those testifying virtually, the timer is displayed in Zoom.

50
00:07:57.362 --> 00:08:01.841
<v Unidentified speaker>You'll hear the timer chime twice, once as a warning when there are 30 seconds left.

51
00:08:02.610 --> 00:08:09.081
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll call the first— oh, and finally, before you begin your testimony, if you could please state your name for the record.

52
00:08:09.995 --> 00:08:17.793
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll call up the first 3, Nathaniel Hudson Hartman, Angela Grigsby and Ahmed Ashamani.

53
00:08:36.761 --> 00:08:37.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

54
00:08:37.606 --> 00:08:38.126
<v Andrew Spear>All right.

55
00:08:39.121 --> 00:08:39.335
<v Dan Ryan>Anyhow.

56
00:09:09.298 --> 00:09:19.773
<v Unidentified speaker>And if I seem desperate, it's because I'm empathically passing on that anxiety and depression to you all that I have been feeling from the community members that I serve.

57
00:09:21.440 --> 00:09:31.019
<v Unidentified speaker>So all that aside, I am so, so grateful to pick up this conversation we started here so long ago in this very room with another quintet of your beautiful faces.

58
00:09:32.577 --> 00:09:41.799
<v Unidentified speaker>I would like to just take a moment and ask every driver who came here today to please raise their hand if they took a trip where Uber and Lyft took at least half of their fare.

59
00:09:47.220 --> 00:09:52.025
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to end it here because I want to leave as much time for the other drivers to speak as much as possible.

60
00:09:52.091 --> 00:09:53.187
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll just end with this.

61
00:09:54.480 --> 00:09:57.937
<v Unidentified speaker>When this is all said and done, I want us to be able to answer these questions.

62
00:10:00.207 --> 00:10:08.759
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

63
00:10:27.514 --> 00:10:29.470
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll call up the next group of 3.

64
00:10:30.245 --> 00:10:35.662
<v Unidentified speaker>Bob Nesbitt, Caleb Price, and Samuel Araya.

65
00:10:49.610 --> 00:10:50.775
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead when you're ready.

66
00:10:51.889 --> 00:10:52.436
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

67
00:10:53.977 --> 00:10:57.528
<v Unidentified speaker>Just want to thank you for letting us address your committee today.

68
00:10:58.076 --> 00:11:00.148
<v Unidentified speaker>I've been doing this for 13 years.

69
00:11:02.990 --> 00:11:11.798
<v Unidentified speaker>About 5 years ago, I was driving somebody from here to Salem, and I got to drop them off, and I got a second call.

70
00:11:12.458 --> 00:11:16.774
<v Unidentified speaker>And when I got there, there was nobody to pick up, and I got a call from Lyft saying it was Lyft.

71
00:11:17.754 --> 00:11:22.515
<v Unidentified speaker>And they said that somebody did not resemble my profile picture, although I have a beard and gray hair.

72
00:11:22.596 --> 00:11:31.375
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not— anyway, they wanted my— a picture of myself, my driver's license, my credit card on file.

73
00:11:31.456 --> 00:11:32.519
<v Unidentified speaker>It was a scam.

74
00:11:33.688 --> 00:11:42.568
<v Unidentified speaker>And the next day when I went to get online for Lyft, they told me that I had fraudulent activity on my account and I couldn't drive anymore.

75
00:11:43.806 --> 00:11:51.471
<v Unidentified speaker>I probably tried 10 times to get back on the Lyft app, and they kept telling me they talked to security.

76
00:11:51.552 --> 00:11:54.293
<v Unidentified speaker>And every time I talked to security, he said it wasn't his job.

77
00:11:54.679 --> 00:11:56.533
<v Unidentified speaker>They sent it upstairs and I never heard back.

78
00:11:56.647 --> 00:12:00.499
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just voided and I went on with my Uber.

79
00:12:02.289 --> 00:12:07.990
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm talking about— I think we're very vulnerable in terms of what we make.

80
00:12:08.234 --> 00:12:08.412
<v Samuel Araya>Yeah.

81
00:12:09.005 --> 00:12:15.499
<v Unidentified speaker>I've been doing this 13 years and my income seems like it's harder for me to make what I used to make.

82
00:12:16.048 --> 00:12:17.323
<v Unidentified speaker>There are no incentives anymore.

83
00:12:19.846 --> 00:12:23.306
<v Unidentified speaker>The hour— excuse me, the mileage rate hasn't improved.

84
00:12:23.971 --> 00:12:26.798
<v Unidentified speaker>And I just wanted to give you some ideas.

85
00:12:27.330 --> 00:12:34.696
<v Unidentified speaker>Seattle pays $1.63 a mile, San Francisco $1.40, New York City $1.28, Portland is $0.70.

86
00:12:35.927 --> 00:12:42.594
<v Unidentified speaker>The federal allowance for driving on income tax is 72.5 cents a mile.

87
00:12:43.225 --> 00:12:46.571
<v Unidentified speaker>So we are basically not making any money.

88
00:12:48.519 --> 00:12:54.173
<v Unidentified speaker>Upon picking up passengers, we never know where they're gonna go, how far they're gonna go, and what we're gonna make on a ride.

89
00:12:54.836 --> 00:13:00.451
<v Unidentified speaker>And as other people have pointed out, the split that we get has been diminished.

90
00:13:00.798 --> 00:13:00.998
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

91
00:13:03.133 --> 00:13:07.020
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're working longer hours to make ends meet.

92
00:13:07.668 --> 00:13:10.374
<v Unidentified speaker>Our expenses have gone up exponentially.

93
00:13:10.730 --> 00:13:15.535
<v Unidentified speaker>Anybody who's driving a gasoline car now, I don't know how you could afford it.

94
00:13:16.197 --> 00:13:23.452
<v Unidentified speaker>I was driving a car that got 42 miles to a gallon and I was still spending $280 to $300 a month in gasoline.

95
00:13:24.053 --> 00:13:25.288
<v Unidentified speaker>Now I've got an electric car.

96
00:13:25.514 --> 00:13:26.083
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

97
00:13:27.428 --> 00:13:27.655
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

98
00:13:28.157 --> 00:13:35.581
<v Unidentified speaker>Uber last year on a national basis made $52 billion globally.

99
00:13:35.678 --> 00:13:39.059
<v Unidentified speaker>It was an 18% increase over the year before.

100
00:13:39.719 --> 00:13:40.063
<v Unidentified speaker>Am I done?

101
00:13:41.710 --> 00:13:46.312
<v Unidentified speaker>The CEO made $39.4 million with his stock options.

102
00:13:46.974 --> 00:13:52.274
<v Unidentified speaker>And I divided his income by 365 days a year.

103
00:13:52.799 --> 00:13:58.629
<v Unidentified speaker>He would make $107,945 a day, and we struggle to make $200 a day.

104
00:13:59.515 --> 00:14:07.796
<v Unidentified speaker>And it's getting harder and harder with all the expenses going up in terms of the price of cars, insurance, gasoline or electric.

105
00:14:08.134 --> 00:14:10.897
<v Unidentified speaker>So we just implore you to support us.

106
00:14:11.379 --> 00:14:11.726
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

107
00:14:12.969 --> 00:14:13.697
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

108
00:14:16.220 --> 00:14:16.542
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

109
00:14:17.043 --> 00:14:19.125
<v Samuel Araya>Hi, good afternoon, committee members.

110
00:14:19.336 --> 00:14:20.433
<v Samuel Araya>My name is Samuel Araya.

111
00:14:20.881 --> 00:14:23.466
<v Samuel Araya>I live in District 3, Portland, Oregon.

112
00:14:23.595 --> 00:14:32.761
<v Samuel Araya>I was a rideshare driver for more than 10 years before Uber and Lyft wrongfully deactivated me for a mistake on my background check.

113
00:14:33.163 --> 00:14:34.928
<v Samuel Araya>They haven't made it easy for me.

114
00:14:35.716 --> 00:14:37.866
<v Samuel Araya>I don't get to speak to the real person.

115
00:14:38.221 --> 00:14:41.801
<v Samuel Araya>They make me text in English, which is not my first language.

116
00:14:42.731 --> 00:14:45.139
<v Samuel Araya>Now I'm struggling to find work and pay my bills.

117
00:14:46.086 --> 00:14:48.421
<v Samuel Araya>But even before I was deactivated.

118
00:14:48.485 --> 00:14:57.075
<v Samuel Araya>I was having to work more times, 6, 7 days a week to make the same money I made when I first started driving.

119
00:14:58.509 --> 00:15:02.635
<v Samuel Araya>Back then, Uber and Lyft paid me 80% of the fare.

120
00:15:02.846 --> 00:15:12.671
<v Samuel Araya>I don't know why they, they cut out my pay so much when they charging my riders so much more money and then keep the rest.

121
00:15:12.720 --> 00:15:12.831
<v Samuel Araya>Thank you.

122
00:15:14.136 --> 00:15:17.452
<v Samuel Araya>I see the receipt and just say, wow, I cannot afford to live.

123
00:15:17.614 --> 00:15:20.913
<v Samuel Araya>I have to pay all the costs— gas, tire maintenance.

124
00:15:21.746 --> 00:15:29.663
<v Samuel Araya>And Uber are a mastermind in avoiding costs and shifting the operational cost to the drivers.

125
00:15:31.057 --> 00:15:32.306
<v Samuel Araya>I just want to be fair again.

126
00:15:33.716 --> 00:15:48.254
<v Samuel Araya>If I get my job back, Uber and Lyft, for all of us drivers to be treated with dignity and respect, because right now I just don't feel I want to be able to work reasonable hours and then my riders to be charged fairly.

127
00:15:49.100 --> 00:15:56.070
<v Samuel Araya>I hope you all support us and help us make the rideshare fair for all of us again, just like used to be.

128
00:15:56.149 --> 00:15:56.601
<v Samuel Araya>Thank you.

129
00:15:58.408 --> 00:15:59.023
<v Samuel Araya>Thank you very much.

130
00:15:59.201 --> 00:15:59.817
<v Samuel Araya>You're welcome.

131
00:16:01.144 --> 00:16:02.908
<v Unidentified speaker>Angela is joining us online.

132
00:16:03.023 --> 00:16:04.544
<v Unidentified speaker>Angela, you can go ahead and unmute.

133
00:16:06.422 --> 00:16:08.605
<v Dan Ryan>Bob, Bob, could I ask you a question really quick?

134
00:16:09.152 --> 00:16:10.388
<v Dan Ryan>When you said, is that your name?

135
00:16:10.932 --> 00:16:11.479
<v Unidentified speaker>Me right here?

136
00:16:11.558 --> 00:16:11.720
<v Andrew Spear>Yeah.

137
00:16:11.960 --> 00:16:12.538
<v Unidentified speaker>Robert, yeah.

138
00:16:12.923 --> 00:16:16.437
<v Dan Ryan>And you said 70 cents in Portland and you compared it to all the other cities.

139
00:16:16.870 --> 00:16:19.070
<v Dan Ryan>What were you— what was the item you were comparing?

140
00:16:19.118 --> 00:16:19.423
<v Dan Ryan>Was it—.

141
00:16:19.455 --> 00:16:19.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm sorry?

142
00:16:20.322 --> 00:16:24.061
<v Dan Ryan>When you said 70 cents in Portland and then you compared it to all the other cities.

143
00:16:24.173 --> 00:16:24.398
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

144
00:16:25.216 --> 00:16:26.596
<v Dan Ryan>What was it that you were comparing?

145
00:16:27.945 --> 00:16:28.796
<v Unidentified speaker>What was I comparing?

146
00:16:28.908 --> 00:16:30.544
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, was it gas reimbursement?

147
00:16:31.057 --> 00:16:33.256
<v Unidentified speaker>No, that's per mile.

148
00:16:33.336 --> 00:16:34.251
<v Dan Ryan>Miles, okay, tax.

149
00:16:34.316 --> 00:16:34.653
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

150
00:16:34.765 --> 00:16:36.225
<v Unidentified speaker>I didn't know that was gas.

151
00:16:36.274 --> 00:16:36.803
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry, those are all per mile.

152
00:16:36.659 --> 00:16:36.918
<v Dan Ryan>That's it.

153
00:16:37.096 --> 00:16:37.192
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

154
00:16:37.240 --> 00:16:38.452
<v Unidentified speaker>Seattle's $1.63.

155
00:16:38.549 --> 00:16:41.249
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, yeah, that was all the cost per mile.

156
00:16:42.100 --> 00:16:42.375
<v Unidentified speaker>You're welcome.

157
00:16:44.178 --> 00:16:48.076
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, let's move on to our— I think our final testifier.

158
00:16:48.158 --> 00:16:48.677
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

159
00:16:50.580 --> 00:16:53.451
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, and we're trying to get one additional one online.

160
00:16:53.500 --> 00:16:54.936
<v Unidentified speaker>He's having trouble joining Zoom.

161
00:16:55.048 --> 00:16:58.663
<v Unidentified speaker>But Angela, can you hear us?

162
00:17:21.817 --> 00:17:23.441
<v Unidentified speaker>Angela, can you try one more time?

163
00:17:23.538 --> 00:17:24.009
<v Unidentified speaker>There you go.

164
00:17:24.269 --> 00:17:25.339
<v Unidentified speaker>I see you now.

165
00:17:26.622 --> 00:17:27.855
<v Unidentified speaker>There she is.

166
00:17:31.430 --> 00:17:33.026
<v Unidentified speaker>Angela, we're not hearing you.

167
00:17:42.269 --> 00:17:45.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could we make sure she has the phone number if she wants to call in separately?

168
00:17:46.647 --> 00:17:51.929
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, Angela, in your meeting invite there's also a phone number if you want to try calling back on your phone.

169
00:17:55.691 --> 00:17:56.949
<v Unidentified speaker>Texted her the number too.

170
00:18:00.339 --> 00:18:02.585
<v Unidentified speaker>I also texted it to Ahmed Alshammari as well.

171
00:18:04.433 --> 00:18:10.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Angela, as well as the email, it sounds like Nathaniel may have sent you the number if that's more convenient to pull up.

172
00:18:19.555 --> 00:18:21.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wendy, do we have the other individual available in the meantime?

173
00:18:25.210 --> 00:18:27.464
<v Unidentified speaker>They're both having some technical difficulties.

174
00:18:27.818 --> 00:18:34.502
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, why don't we give it just a minute more to see if either of them can get the technology figured out?

175
00:18:34.583 --> 00:18:47.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if not, I suspect that their testimony may relate to the next agenda item, so we could move into that agenda item and then have them testify toward the end there instead.

176
00:18:47.134 --> 00:18:50.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But let's give it just a minute more and see if we can get the sound working.

177
00:19:40.663 --> 00:19:43.144
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Angela, have you been able to figure out the sound on your end?

178
00:19:45.694 --> 00:19:45.792
<v Dan Ryan>No.

179
00:19:46.463 --> 00:19:47.969
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, we still don't hear you.

180
00:19:52.529 --> 00:20:06.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I'd like to keep us moving, and what I'd like to do, Wendy, if it works with your ability to track the meeting, is to invite these 2 individuals to try to testify after the next agenda item.

181
00:20:06.778 --> 00:20:07.279
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that all right?

182
00:20:09.067 --> 00:20:09.792
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, wonderful.

183
00:20:09.856 --> 00:20:11.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Well, thank you both for being here.

184
00:20:11.692 --> 00:20:12.047
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

185
00:20:12.336 --> 00:20:16.442
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Wendy, could we close this item and have you call agenda item 2?

186
00:20:17.832 --> 00:20:26.147
<v Unidentified speaker>Agenda item number 2, discussion on policy proposal regarding the fare transparency and the transportation network company take rate.

187
00:20:26.230 --> 00:20:28.457
<v Unidentified speaker>Item number 2026-173.

188
00:20:30.632 --> 00:20:31.642
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Wendy.

189
00:20:32.474 --> 00:20:45.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, this is a continuation of a conversation that was started in the previous Labor and Workforce Committee on earning standards for drivers of our transportation network companies, or TNCs.

190
00:20:46.256 --> 00:20:48.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those are companies like Uber and Lyft.

191
00:20:49.381 --> 00:20:53.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is an item coming before us today from Councilor Novick and myself.

192
00:20:53.931 --> 00:21:10.201
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think, Councilor Murillo, you are maybe considering Councilor Novick unfortunately is not able to join us, so I will give an overview of what we're looking at and why to provide some background.

193
00:21:11.499 --> 00:21:19.369
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will then hear from a few other parties and then have time for discussion and questions.

194
00:21:20.701 --> 00:21:32.288
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I'm sure many of you have had the opportunity to meet with the drivers union, the folks whose blue shirts and tireless advocacy has been instrumental in advocacy even today make them hard to miss in City Hall.

195
00:21:33.362 --> 00:21:38.986
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'm guessing that some of you have heard from Uber and Lyft and had conversations with them as well.

196
00:21:40.010 --> 00:21:58.050
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The conversations with the drivers union that I have had have revolved mainly, mainly around 2 items: looking at what pay is for TNC drivers in Portland and looking at what support there is and the idea of a driver resource center.

197
00:21:58.613 --> 00:22:02.030
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Today we'll mainly be focused on the first of those items.

198
00:22:03.267 --> 00:22:08.530
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick and I, like I said, have teamed up to lead a conversation on earning standards.

199
00:22:09.429 --> 00:22:34.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And importantly, this conversation is happening all over the country as Uber and Lyft rake in growing profits, but driver pay in many cases goes down, and benefits for these workers, because they have been categorized as independent contractors, in Massachusetts, voters approved a ballot measure which gave rideshare drivers the right to unionize and collectively bargain.

200
00:22:35.122 --> 00:22:37.657
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And in California, drivers are close to forming a union.

201
00:22:38.412 --> 00:22:45.843
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In 2018, New York City passed a minimum per-trip payment formula to ensure an earning standard for drivers.

202
00:22:46.757 --> 00:22:51.186
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Minneapolis, Seattle, and Washington State have similar earning formulas.

203
00:22:51.234 --> 00:22:51.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

204
00:22:52.037 --> 00:22:53.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As do other jurisdictions.

205
00:22:54.378 --> 00:22:57.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This is neither a new conversation nor one that is unique to Portland.

206
00:22:59.270 --> 00:23:06.455
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At the same time, we are seeing this reaction from the driver community here and across the country.

207
00:23:07.371 --> 00:23:10.144
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>TNCs have become an essential infrastructure.

208
00:23:11.380 --> 00:23:15.598
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They help people get to work, to medical appointments, to the airport, and home safely at night.

209
00:23:16.031 --> 00:23:19.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They help folks live in our city without needing a car of their own.

210
00:23:20.747 --> 00:23:25.539
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They support our hospitality and tourism sectors and our arts and cultural institutions.

211
00:23:26.854 --> 00:23:30.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know that Portland needs a functioning, reliable rideshare market.

212
00:23:31.182 --> 00:23:39.933
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's reasonable to say that we want these companies operating here, and I don't fault the worry that some people have that passing meaningful earnings standards for drivers could threaten that.

213
00:23:41.279 --> 00:23:46.857
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While I don't fault it, I will say that I reject the fact that those 2 things are inherently at odds.

214
00:23:46.954 --> 00:23:47.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

215
00:23:48.494 --> 00:23:58.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>While TNCs operate a critical service from out of state and outside of our city, drivers on the ground that do the actual transportation work are our neighbors.

216
00:23:58.769 --> 00:23:59.942
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They are a part of our community.

217
00:24:00.936 --> 00:24:06.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When an elderly neighbor uses rideshare to get to the grocery store, it is a local Portland driver who picks them up.

218
00:24:07.904 --> 00:24:13.861
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When tourists use rideshare to explore our city, it is a Portlander who gets them to each location.

219
00:24:15.875 --> 00:24:16.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Safely.

220
00:24:16.392 --> 00:24:26.541
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And the people who do this work on the ground here, the drivers, are repeatedly reporting earnings that after their business expenses often fall well below minimum wage.

221
00:24:27.123 --> 00:24:36.471
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And as we heard today, well below the required reimbursement for folks who are reimbursed under the federal requirements for driving.

222
00:24:38.119 --> 00:24:53.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because drivers are independent contractors, They cover the cost of doing business— their fuel, insurance, maintenance, depreciation of their vehicles, taxes— and they cover their own benefits, things that are assured to many other types of employees.

223
00:24:55.150 --> 00:25:02.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Increasingly, they are doing so within a pricing system that is not transparent and that is difficult to understand.

224
00:25:03.907 --> 00:25:06.248
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's the crux of the problem that we are trying to solve.

225
00:25:06.521 --> 00:25:10.423
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In collaboration with the drivers union and with Uber and Lyft.

226
00:25:12.230 --> 00:25:19.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick and I are proposing a policy that is admittedly different from those other policies I named, which have been implemented elsewhere.

227
00:25:20.068 --> 00:25:23.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What we're proposing to consider is a simple concept called a take rate.

228
00:25:24.913 --> 00:25:42.044
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to explain what we're trying to achieve with the take rate, but I also want to be clear that the specifics of what this would look like here are part of an ongoing conversation scheduled with Uber and Lyft and with the drivers union over the next three months.

229
00:25:43.440 --> 00:25:59.554
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Essentially, a take rate designates the share of a passenger's fare, a Portlander's fare when they ride in an Uber or a Lyft that goes to the company, and the share that goes to the driver after things like taxes, tips, and set fees that are imposed upon each ride.

230
00:26:00.614 --> 00:26:04.272
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The goal is to ensure that there's a fair split that allows both the TNC.

231
00:26:04.945 --> 00:26:13.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And their independent contractor, the driver, to receive compensation that covers the cost of doing business and allows them to earn a profit too.

232
00:26:14.500 --> 00:26:18.076
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Historically, that split was relatively transparent and relatively stable.

233
00:26:19.470 --> 00:26:25.546
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Lyft has even implemented a formal take rate structure themselves, currently promising a 70/30 split guarantee.

234
00:26:26.909 --> 00:26:35.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Over time though, pricing models have evolved, and in many cases, the connection between the cost of a ride and the pay for drivers has weakened.

235
00:26:35.421 --> 00:26:35.613
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

236
00:26:36.528 --> 00:26:47.768
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What riders pay and what drivers earn are no longer always clearly linked, and in many cases, the company's profit share has grown significantly while drivers' take-home pay has decreased.

237
00:26:48.666 --> 00:26:52.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A take-rate framework is an attempt to realign the incentives.

238
00:26:53.242 --> 00:27:00.902
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should have a predictable, transparent relationship between what Portlanders as riders pay and what our neighbors who are drivers earn.

239
00:27:01.817 --> 00:27:14.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A take rate ensures that drivers receive a fair share of the fare for the work that they perform while still allowing companies to cover their costs of doing business, invest in their platforms, and earn a profit for shareholders.

240
00:27:15.305 --> 00:27:26.448
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And importantly, in fact critically, it does this without directly setting wages or dictating prices, which means TNCs still have flexibility to determine what the price of a ride is.

241
00:27:27.367 --> 00:27:30.489
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what it takes to operate profitably in Portland.

242
00:27:31.733 --> 00:27:36.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Done right, this kind of structure also protects riders by tying company revenue to driver earnings.

243
00:27:37.474 --> 00:27:49.352
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It discourages excessive markups and ensures that surge pricing is actually used to balance supply and demand rather than simply to extract additional revenue.

244
00:27:51.086 --> 00:27:55.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to go back and acknowledge the concern I mentioned earlier that we've heard from a number of stakeholders.

245
00:27:56.239 --> 00:27:59.896
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The importance of maintaining a strong and stable rideshare presence in Portland.

246
00:28:00.690 --> 00:28:16.214
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is not in anyone's interest, not in the interest of businesses in our city, our tourism economy, riders, Portlanders who use Uber and Lyft, or drivers, for services to become less available, less reliable, or leave the market altogether.

247
00:28:18.358 --> 00:28:21.713
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's why we need a system that works for workers and for companies.

248
00:28:22.152 --> 00:28:33.771
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it's why Councilor Novick and I are at the table with each party trying to negotiate language that will be workable, implementable, and fair.

249
00:28:35.837 --> 00:28:41.299
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Under our new form of government, committees are a place to iterate, to discuss, to take feedback, to work a policy.

250
00:28:41.510 --> 00:28:44.103
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we don't have language before us today.

251
00:28:45.042 --> 00:28:47.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are in the process of iterating with stakeholders.

252
00:28:47.424 --> 00:28:47.555
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

253
00:28:47.923 --> 00:29:04.707
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we wanted to bring this forward to update you all on where the conversation is and get your feedback as well, so that when we are able to bring language forward in a few short months, we can do so with some feedback already in place and continue to iterate.

254
00:29:05.750 --> 00:29:09.701
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The goal here is not to design a policy that is nice on paper but fails in practice.

255
00:29:10.568 --> 00:29:13.557
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If that were the case, we might just propose a minimum wage and be done with it.

256
00:29:14.269 --> 00:29:31.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The goal is to truly strike a balance and create a system where companies can continue to operate and grow, where the people doing the work can earn a living that reflects the reality of their costs and their contributions to the system, and where Portlanders still have access to this important service.

257
00:29:35.537 --> 00:29:37.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Today's hearing is an important step.

258
00:29:37.711 --> 00:29:42.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will hear from drivers and their representatives about the on-the-ground realities of their work.

259
00:29:43.682 --> 00:29:49.590
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will hear from an economist who has done research on this industry and the market dynamics within the industry.

260
00:29:50.570 --> 00:29:54.070
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then my staff will go over the timeline and next steps.

261
00:29:54.681 --> 00:29:57.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>After that, we'll have an opportunity for discussion and questions.

262
00:29:58.278 --> 00:30:02.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will note that we invited Uber and Lyft to be a part of the conversation today.

263
00:30:03.352 --> 00:30:05.487
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They declined this particular invitation.

264
00:30:05.550 --> 00:30:05.728
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

265
00:30:06.481 --> 00:30:14.738
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I do think it's important to share that they were invited to have a panel and that they are part of an active ongoing dialogue.

266
00:30:15.363 --> 00:30:20.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we expect that that engagement will continue both from, from their side and from ours.

267
00:30:21.309 --> 00:30:25.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Their perspective matters, and we want to make sure that everybody is at the table as we do this work.

268
00:30:27.065 --> 00:30:39.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, I know we have already heard from a few of our drivers here in Portland, but I believe we have some designated representatives from the drivers union who are going to share some additional information with us.

269
00:30:40.166 --> 00:30:42.028
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd like to invite you all up at this time.

270
00:30:55.252 --> 00:30:57.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome and thank you for being here.

271
00:30:58.798 --> 00:30:59.184
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

272
00:30:59.298 --> 00:30:59.877
<v Unidentified speaker>It's been a while.

273
00:31:02.261 --> 00:31:04.840
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we always welcome young testifiers also.

274
00:31:07.248 --> 00:31:08.199
<v Unidentified speaker>It's good to know.

275
00:31:09.085 --> 00:31:10.294
<v Unidentified speaker>We can't do this without him.

276
00:31:11.487 --> 00:31:13.791
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You just have to adjust the microphone height a little bit.

277
00:31:14.711 --> 00:31:15.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There we go.

278
00:31:23.566 --> 00:31:24.632
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you all for having us.

279
00:31:25.648 --> 00:31:32.413
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we presented a lot of these things in front of the, uh, Labor and Workforce Development Committee.

280
00:31:33.112 --> 00:31:36.307
<v Unidentified speaker>It is great to be back here and in front of some new faces.

281
00:31:37.393 --> 00:31:39.365
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

282
00:31:40.038 --> 00:31:44.048
<v Unidentified speaker>We're here for rideshare drivers, and we're especially here to talk about pay.

283
00:31:44.530 --> 00:32:01.019
<v Unidentified speaker>I have some examples here, if everyone can see these slides, of some of these wildly disparate— wildly— I don't know how to word that— these wildly different fares.

284
00:32:01.355 --> 00:32:07.976
<v Unidentified speaker>And you can see that in some of these cases, the driver is making only 16% of what a passenger pays.

285
00:32:09.488 --> 00:32:19.015
<v Unidentified speaker>So some of these companies may say something like, you know, passenger rates will go up if this legislation passes.

286
00:32:19.608 --> 00:32:20.878
<v Unidentified speaker>Passenger rates are already up.

287
00:32:21.940 --> 00:32:26.786
<v Unidentified speaker>This ride took 33 minutes and cost the passenger over $100, almost $100.

288
00:32:28.954 --> 00:32:29.998
<v Unidentified speaker>I have some more examples.

289
00:32:31.880 --> 00:32:35.403
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of them are pretty bad.

290
00:32:35.868 --> 00:32:40.055
<v Unidentified speaker>You can see this right here: 28 minutes, 17 miles.

291
00:32:40.171 --> 00:32:41.563
<v Unidentified speaker>Why did it cost the passenger $110?

292
00:32:43.913 --> 00:32:45.796
<v Unidentified speaker>And why did the driver only make $14?

293
00:32:48.134 --> 00:32:49.517
<v Unidentified speaker>This isn't just unique to Lyft.

294
00:32:49.886 --> 00:32:57.381
<v Unidentified speaker>These screenshots that you see on the app here, these are screenshots straight from Uber's app, where you can see.

295
00:32:58.190 --> 00:33:11.955
<v Unidentified speaker>Uber is consistently taking a huge amount from passengers and paying the drivers much less, much less than 80%, much less than half in a lot of cases.

296
00:33:14.109 --> 00:33:19.789
<v Unidentified speaker>This is unacceptable in our eyes when we are the ones with the costs.

297
00:33:20.662 --> 00:33:25.412
<v Unidentified speaker>We are the ones with the rising gas prices that I'm sure everyone is well aware of right now.

298
00:33:28.195 --> 00:33:42.766
<v Unidentified speaker>And as far as transparency is concerned, as you can see by this trip, it's kind of hard to deconstruct here, but the passenger actually paid about $52 including their tip.

299
00:33:43.502 --> 00:33:53.744
<v Unidentified speaker>But Lyft likes to frame this in a way where it looks like the numbers are as close together as possible by showing that tip in your earnings down at the bottom.

300
00:33:54.467 --> 00:33:56.653
<v Unidentified speaker>But excluding it from the passenger payment.

301
00:33:57.682 --> 00:34:02.567
<v Unidentified speaker>Just one of many shady practices that these companies use.

302
00:34:04.582 --> 00:34:16.221
<v Unidentified speaker>And why is it that 2 $110 trips— you'll notice the screenshot on the right from earlier— have significant, drastically different pay for the drivers?

303
00:34:18.440 --> 00:34:39.954
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's why over these last few years we have formed I'd like to invite Nathaniel to, uh, make any additions that I might—.

304
00:34:40.050 --> 00:34:41.195
<v Unidentified speaker>You're crushing it right now.

305
00:34:41.840 --> 00:34:42.373
<v Unidentified speaker>Keep going.

306
00:34:43.521 --> 00:34:44.844
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, yeah, thank you.

307
00:34:44.909 --> 00:34:45.458
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Joe.

308
00:34:45.539 --> 00:34:47.090
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, this is a, a really important initiative.

309
00:34:49.592 --> 00:35:07.159
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, something we've really learned, um, and I guess I'm editorializing here, is that through, through our advocacy, um, that you spoke of, um, Chair Pirtle-Guiney, we have discovered that this is not just an issue that matters to our merry band of rideshare drivers.

310
00:35:07.481 --> 00:35:15.751
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, this is an issue that is important to a very, very large you know, group of our community members.

311
00:35:16.007 --> 00:35:27.125
<v Unidentified speaker>And so Fair Rides Oregon represents a coalition of faith-based institutions, folks that are in the housing and food insecurity sectors, folks from labor, transit.

312
00:35:28.056 --> 00:35:38.291
<v Unidentified speaker>And I have provided a copy to the clerk today of a letter of support from one of our community— one of our coalition community members, Dr. J.W.

313
00:35:38.355 --> 00:35:41.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Matt Hennessey from the Vancouver First Baptist Church.

314
00:35:41.804 --> 00:35:44.143
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm just going to read just a small portion of that, if I may.

315
00:35:45.168 --> 00:35:58.324
<v Unidentified speaker>Fair transparency for passengers and drivers and a limit on how much the companies can keep as commission are very reasonable prices— sorry, policies that benefit our entire community, local workers, and consumers alike.

316
00:35:59.014 --> 00:36:02.603
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not just about drivers earning a living wage.

317
00:36:03.021 --> 00:36:05.728
<v Unidentified speaker>This is protecting Portlanders from price gouging.

318
00:36:06.722 --> 00:36:16.496
<v Unidentified speaker>The ride that you took to the Blazer game shouldn't cost you $30 more on the way home, especially when there is a good chance that Uber or Lyft is taking most of that.

319
00:36:17.539 --> 00:36:20.284
<v Unidentified speaker>That surge pricing was supposed to, as you said, balance the market.

320
00:36:20.766 --> 00:36:23.012
<v Unidentified speaker>It is being used to extract profits.

321
00:36:23.735 --> 00:36:33.826
<v Unidentified speaker>And so putting a sensible cap on the commission that they can take not only ensures drivers earn a living wage, but ensures that riders are protected are protected from price gouging.

322
00:36:34.101 --> 00:36:38.028
<v Unidentified speaker>These screenshots that we've been showing you, by the way, that is what you're seeing in the driver app.

323
00:36:39.686 --> 00:36:43.836
<v Unidentified speaker>And it has been increasingly difficult to access that information.

324
00:36:43.983 --> 00:36:55.603
<v Unidentified speaker>It is hidden in external fees and commercial insurance line items and, and Lyft fees and Uber fees, and it is increasingly difficult to suss that out.

325
00:36:55.990 --> 00:37:02.469
<v Unidentified speaker>And the riders have no idea how much of that fare is going into Uber and Lyft's pocket and how oftentimes very little is going into ours.

326
00:37:03.239 --> 00:37:13.485
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I just, I can't say this enough, the fare transparency, that is so important to, you know, help inform and educate kind of both sides, right?

327
00:37:14.110 --> 00:37:16.469
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so, you know, thank you so much for your time.

328
00:37:16.532 --> 00:37:21.295
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, don't want to go too long because we, I know we got a lot of other things to get to.

329
00:37:21.889 --> 00:37:33.150
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so, um, you know, happy to answer any questions or you know, provide any additional context, clarity, um, you know, or feedback for you unless you've got something else.

330
00:37:33.762 --> 00:37:33.876
<v Dan Ryan>Nope.

331
00:37:34.278 --> 00:37:35.166
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, thank you all.

332
00:37:35.552 --> 00:37:35.811
<v Unidentified speaker>We good.

333
00:37:35.956 --> 00:37:37.697
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to know who the co-sponsor is.

334
00:37:39.351 --> 00:37:43.628
<v Unidentified speaker>So, so, buddy, come on, let's go sit down.

335
00:37:43.889 --> 00:37:45.239
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we should turn his mic on.

336
00:37:48.025 --> 00:37:53.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was wondering, I was wondering if he could give us his scariest face because we were getting a lot of faces during that.

337
00:37:53.543 --> 00:37:54.159
<v Eric Zimmerman>That would have been great.

338
00:37:56.130 --> 00:38:06.414
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, Councilors, if there are any questions for folks from the Drivers Union, why don't we ask those now before we move on to hearing from Professor Parrott?

339
00:38:07.697 --> 00:38:09.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, did you have something?

340
00:38:09.927 --> 00:38:10.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, just the scary face.

341
00:38:11.307 --> 00:38:13.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was the best testimony.

342
00:38:13.956 --> 00:38:14.179
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know.

343
00:38:15.079 --> 00:38:26.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other question for— next we are hearing from a professor, an economist who has done significant research on the So I do have a question if we're going to be transitioning.

344
00:38:27.101 --> 00:38:28.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, go ahead, Councilor.

345
00:38:29.389 --> 00:38:38.601
<v Eric Zimmerman>So there's some stuff here that can be a little hard to understand in terms of— I'm balancing roles here.

346
00:38:38.713 --> 00:38:52.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>So when a person elects to be an Uber or Lyft driver, what types of agreements Then are you agreeing to in the payment structure?

347
00:38:52.103 --> 00:39:01.416
<v Eric Zimmerman>What does the company tell you is what— now, you know, I've seen a lot of jobs are like, you can make up to this, and they do that stuff.

348
00:39:01.559 --> 00:39:08.271
<v Eric Zimmerman>I mean, like, what is the actual agreement of this is the percentage, or how is that structured when they bring a new driver in?

349
00:39:09.443 --> 00:39:11.467
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, I would love to share my experience.

350
00:39:12.414 --> 00:39:14.244
<v Unidentified speaker>I started over 10 years ago.

351
00:39:15.045 --> 00:39:16.380
<v Unidentified speaker>In fact, it'll be 11 next month.

352
00:39:17.282 --> 00:39:26.041
<v Unidentified speaker>And when I started, in the agreement, it was made very clear that I would make no less than 80% of what the passenger paid.

353
00:39:27.702 --> 00:39:37.159
<v Unidentified speaker>Through terms of service changes and amendments and all these different things that you are forced to agree to if you want to go to work in the morning, that has changed.

354
00:39:37.273 --> 00:39:40.219
<v Unidentified speaker>It has been whittled down, and so has my pay.

355
00:39:42.110 --> 00:39:48.920
<v Unidentified speaker>Everything moved over to these new models of per mile per minute, and then it got cut down even further.

356
00:39:50.317 --> 00:39:52.880
<v Unidentified speaker>And my pay has not changed since 2018.

357
00:39:57.005 --> 00:40:00.882
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, the, uh, the short answer, uh, Vice Chair Zimmerman, right?

358
00:40:01.510 --> 00:40:02.682
<v Eric Zimmerman>Whatever title they gave me today.

359
00:40:03.052 --> 00:40:03.293
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

360
00:40:04.242 --> 00:40:08.775
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, yeah, the short answer is that it's very unclear.

361
00:40:10.179 --> 00:40:12.744
<v Unidentified speaker>You, like, I think Joe hit the nail right on the head.

362
00:40:13.164 --> 00:40:19.431
<v Unidentified speaker>You have to sign that terms of service, and literally they present that thing to you before you can even take any trips.

363
00:40:20.110 --> 00:40:23.166
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, it gets lost in jumbled legal jargon.

364
00:40:23.442 --> 00:40:32.760
<v Unidentified speaker>And as you are probably well aware, a large portion of our community, English is maybe their 3rd, 4th, 5th, or 6th language, and it's a work in progress.

365
00:40:32.809 --> 00:40:34.532
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's very difficult to understand.

366
00:40:34.726 --> 00:40:38.019
<v Unidentified speaker>But I think— Again, you hit it, you hit the nail right on the head.

367
00:40:38.534 --> 00:40:45.150
<v Unidentified speaker>These companies self-imposed an 80% mandate back in 2015, 2016, 2017.

368
00:40:45.215 --> 00:40:48.387
<v Unidentified speaker>So all we're asking them to do is just go back to something that they started doing already.

369
00:40:49.666 --> 00:41:02.965
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, and then, so some of the screenshots you shared, right, they're quite similar, I think.

370
00:41:03.262 --> 00:41:14.695
<v Eric Zimmerman>From a user perspective, we've all certainly taken a ride that was more than it was the last time, but we chalk it up to the hour is different, and so the demand was different.

371
00:41:15.485 --> 00:41:18.483
<v Eric Zimmerman>But you're highlighting some pretty significant differences there.

372
00:41:18.548 --> 00:41:31.077
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if I were to look at those 2 $110 rides that you highlighted in your presentation, once the driver is taking home $46, I think, and once they were taking home $14.

373
00:41:31.192 --> 00:41:31.679
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

374
00:41:34.018 --> 00:41:35.545
<v Eric Zimmerman>I wanna make sure I didn't miss it.

375
00:41:36.186 --> 00:41:38.081
<v Eric Zimmerman>You're not asserting that we know why that is.

376
00:41:38.130 --> 00:41:40.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>You're just saying look at that disparity.

377
00:41:40.362 --> 00:41:43.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that what we're taking from that?

378
00:41:43.331 --> 00:41:43.556
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

379
00:41:44.360 --> 00:41:49.208
<v Unidentified speaker>Just for some context, and this is not anywhere that we can tell in their terms of service.

380
00:41:50.621 --> 00:42:04.257
<v Unidentified speaker>This, like if you're a driver, you can go on like Uber and Lyft's website and look at what the, pay is per mile and per minute for your region, if one such structure still exists, which it does in Portland.

381
00:42:05.730 --> 00:42:10.476
<v Unidentified speaker>And drivers are being paid $0.70 a mile and $0.24 a minute.

382
00:42:12.170 --> 00:42:16.317
<v Unidentified speaker>So if you take a ride— oh, and was it $0.94 base fare?

383
00:42:16.880 --> 00:42:20.965
<v Unidentified speaker>So the next time you take a ride, you can actually calculate what we're being paid.

384
00:42:21.594 --> 00:42:26.362
<v Unidentified speaker>And so they're paying us a fixed amount out of that based on their rate card, it's called.

385
00:42:27.253 --> 00:42:29.485
<v Unidentified speaker>And so everything above that is pure profit.

386
00:42:29.614 --> 00:42:31.427
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, does that make sense?

387
00:42:31.556 --> 00:42:33.885
<v Eric Zimmerman>So 94 cents a minute, is that—.

388
00:42:33.885 --> 00:42:36.952
<v Unidentified speaker>No, 94 cents, um, it's like a 94-cent base fare.

389
00:42:37.760 --> 00:42:44.038
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, just 94 cents plus 70 cents a mile time, uh, and 24 cents a minute.

390
00:42:44.445 --> 00:42:45.047
<v Unidentified speaker>That's our pay.

391
00:42:46.981 --> 00:43:03.969
<v Unidentified speaker>And the other thing that I wanted to highlight as part of that is These 2 trips that you're referring to, the $110 trips, one of those where the driver made $14, that trip was heavily surged, but that surge did not reflect for the driver's earnings.

392
00:43:04.465 --> 00:43:04.626
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

393
00:43:05.844 --> 00:43:16.820
<v Unidentified speaker>The other trip that is mentioned here is also a trip that took place, began in Washington State, where Washington has regulations on per mile and per minute pay.

394
00:43:17.530 --> 00:43:20.150
<v Unidentified speaker>And that likely shows some of the disparity between the two.

395
00:43:20.280 --> 00:43:23.838
<v Unidentified speaker>However, both trips have extremely high passenger payments.

396
00:43:24.161 --> 00:43:24.824
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

397
00:43:25.068 --> 00:43:27.498
<v Unidentified speaker>Compared to what the driver actually makes.

398
00:43:29.150 --> 00:43:29.824
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks.

399
00:43:29.985 --> 00:43:30.853
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is helpful.

400
00:43:30.949 --> 00:43:31.608
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know there's more.

401
00:43:31.655 --> 00:43:33.599
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just wanted to, while we had you both up there—.

402
00:43:33.599 --> 00:43:36.909
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll have all these slides for the council clerk to share with all of you.

403
00:43:36.974 --> 00:43:40.717
<v Unidentified speaker>And we'll be happy to make like a little cheat sheet and you can take them with you for your next one.

404
00:43:40.766 --> 00:43:42.367
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, that was my other question to the chair.

405
00:43:42.644 --> 00:43:43.543
<v Eric Zimmerman>I did think—.

406
00:43:43.543 --> 00:43:43.623
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

407
00:43:44.012 --> 00:43:45.711
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Novick had said there was a presentation.

408
00:43:45.775 --> 00:43:49.416
<v Eric Zimmerman>Have I missed— was there a presentation we should have with us or is this—.

409
00:43:50.266 --> 00:43:57.755
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, we have the presentation from the driver's union and we can get that posted if you all send it to my team.

410
00:43:57.804 --> 00:43:59.775
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll make sure it gets to the clerk to get posted.

411
00:44:00.594 --> 00:44:06.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we will have a presentation from the economist as well, which I don't have a copy of right now.

412
00:44:07.041 --> 00:44:08.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>None of them are posted yet.

413
00:44:10.088 --> 00:44:17.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll also add, just, we heard from our folks at the table right now about the terms that you're required to sign.

414
00:44:18.744 --> 00:44:23.289
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In most instances, independent contractors negotiate the terms that they work under.

415
00:44:23.788 --> 00:44:28.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's part of what being an independent contractor instead of an employee benefits.

416
00:44:29.730 --> 00:44:32.347
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And in this case, we have an industry where that's really not the case.

417
00:44:32.541 --> 00:44:36.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Everybody's working under those same terms that are laid out daily.

418
00:44:36.170 --> 00:44:36.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

419
00:44:36.483 --> 00:44:37.021
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>By the company.

420
00:44:38.380 --> 00:44:38.782
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

421
00:44:39.041 --> 00:44:39.298
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

422
00:44:40.009 --> 00:44:41.202
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair Pirtle-Guiney.

423
00:44:41.541 --> 00:44:44.202
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I don't—.

424
00:44:44.284 --> 00:44:47.059
<v Dan Ryan>I think I'll go ahead and ask these questions because the 2 of you are up here right now.

425
00:44:47.300 --> 00:44:55.000
<v Dan Ryan>It could be that it would be better if I listened to the next presentation, and ditto to sending us this presentation and the cheat sheet.

426
00:44:55.465 --> 00:45:08.190
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I think when I was listening, what I was struck with is it made it sound like it's probably the whole system nationally has some questions, but specifically in Portland and perhaps in the state of Oregon.

427
00:45:08.286 --> 00:45:17.052
<v Dan Ryan>Is that what I was supposed to pick up, that you're getting gouged or not being treated even as fairly as some of your peers in other places?

428
00:45:18.188 --> 00:45:23.364
<v Unidentified speaker>We call it algorithmic wage discrimination, and it is happening everywhere, Councilor Ryan.

429
00:45:23.733 --> 00:45:31.621
<v Unidentified speaker>And this is the idea that the TNCs are using their algorithms to extract maximum profit while keeping driver pay as low as possible.

430
00:45:32.791 --> 00:45:37.108
<v Unidentified speaker>And so in most places— this may be getting a little bit of the weeds, but I think it's important to mention.

431
00:45:37.188 --> 00:45:38.632
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, this is all in the weeds at this point.

432
00:45:38.824 --> 00:45:39.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, yes.

433
00:45:40.172 --> 00:45:41.152
<v Unidentified speaker>People don't understand gig work.

434
00:45:41.199 --> 00:45:42.114
<v Unidentified speaker>And there's nothing wrong with that.

435
00:45:42.177 --> 00:45:42.467
<v Unidentified speaker>It just happens.

436
00:45:42.530 --> 00:45:44.360
<v Unidentified speaker>People just don't understand gig work unless they've done it.

437
00:45:44.842 --> 00:45:57.469
<v Unidentified speaker>So in most places outside of Oregon, what happens is, is when you get a ride request, you get any old price for a ride, but that ride is being shopped to multiple drivers.

438
00:45:57.710 --> 00:46:01.900
<v Unidentified speaker>To see which one of them will accept it at the lowest price, right?

439
00:46:02.478 --> 00:46:05.416
<v Unidentified speaker>Meanwhile, algorithms are doing the same thing for the riders.

440
00:46:06.717 --> 00:46:13.333
<v Unidentified speaker>You ever open both of your phones and try to price a ride on both apps and think, wow, this thing jumped up like $15, what the heck happened?

441
00:46:14.280 --> 00:46:20.059
<v Unidentified speaker>That is an algorithm using, you know, your personal data.

442
00:46:20.862 --> 00:46:21.393
<v Dan Ryan>You too, that was—.

443
00:46:21.489 --> 00:46:24.219
<v Unidentified speaker>To determine pricing yeah.

444
00:46:24.860 --> 00:46:31.586
<v Unidentified speaker>You're at the airport, you come back at 1 in the morning, your phone's about to die, you're tired, you're pretty desperate at that point.

445
00:46:31.764 --> 00:46:35.119
<v Unidentified speaker>You'll take— you'll pay any old price for a ride, and the algorithms know this.

446
00:46:36.130 --> 00:46:44.188
<v Unidentified speaker>So in Oregon, in Oregon, at least in Portland, we'll, you know, talk about Portland here, we have what's still called a rate card.

447
00:46:44.543 --> 00:46:53.099
<v Unidentified speaker>Most drivers had a rate card, and it ensured that you were paid a certain fixed amount so you could easily calculate what you were going to earn on every ride.

448
00:46:54.639 --> 00:47:11.606
<v Unidentified speaker>But, um, you know, folks like Len Sherman from the Columbia School of Business, who has— highly recommend checking him, his work out if you haven't already— studied gig work extensively, you know, has done a lot of research into what Uber and Lyft call, you know, dynamic pricing or surveillance pricing.

449
00:47:11.655 --> 00:47:18.630
<v Unidentified speaker>The idea that you're getting charged a different price for the same trip, and it happens with different people.

450
00:47:19.192 --> 00:47:19.561
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

451
00:47:20.556 --> 00:47:22.661
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we have a rate card here.

452
00:47:23.030 --> 00:47:27.268
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a crap rate card, and it's gone down considerably over the years.

453
00:47:28.264 --> 00:47:30.480
<v Unidentified speaker>But what it does is it's very, very low.

454
00:47:30.994 --> 00:47:37.224
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, you know, like I mentioned before, you get to kind of calculate what you're making, but it also sets kind of a wage ceiling.

455
00:47:37.271 --> 00:47:43.726
<v Unidentified speaker>So then the TNCs can, you know, charge more money on that back end, and they still only have to pay us lowly drivers 70 cents a mile.

456
00:47:44.481 --> 00:47:53.409
<v Unidentified speaker>Which for context, as I think Rob mentioned, Bob, sorry, is less than what the IRS will allow you to deduct for your depreciation per mile.

457
00:47:54.885 --> 00:47:56.103
<v Unidentified speaker>Just to put that in context.

458
00:47:57.128 --> 00:47:57.641
<v Dan Ryan>That was helpful.

459
00:47:58.748 --> 00:48:01.760
<v Dan Ryan>I don't know if this is the right place to ask, and it could be for the sponsors.

460
00:48:02.739 --> 00:48:07.916
<v Dan Ryan>Have you also looked at going to the state with some of this legislation?

461
00:48:08.204 --> 00:48:09.711
<v Dan Ryan>Has Salem taken this up?

462
00:48:09.807 --> 00:48:26.045
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, as a matter of fact, We, you know, had a bill that was being considered by the state legislature last year that, you know, took some of the best pieces from other legislations such as Washington and Colorado where they have fare transparency.

463
00:48:27.280 --> 00:48:35.376
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, we were, you know, we've definitely had some conversations with state legislature to, you know, make sure that all Oregon drivers have basic labor standards.

464
00:48:35.615 --> 00:48:36.097
<v Unidentified speaker>Absolutely.

465
00:48:36.737 --> 00:48:39.576
<v Unidentified speaker>But we know that the vast majority of the rides are happening here.

466
00:48:40.025 --> 00:48:41.659
<v Unidentified speaker>The vast majority of the drivers are here.

467
00:48:42.333 --> 00:48:48.481
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, there is a great need okay, and that didn't get out of committee?

468
00:48:48.545 --> 00:48:49.670
<v Dan Ryan>It didn't make it very far?

469
00:48:49.992 --> 00:48:51.148
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It did not get out of committee.

470
00:48:51.244 --> 00:48:55.809
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There are ongoing conversations, but it is slow going.

471
00:48:56.067 --> 00:49:03.202
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And, um, there are times, Councilor, where I'm willing to say it looks like Salem's going to move on this, we should hold.

472
00:49:03.315 --> 00:49:10.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And there are times where, from, from my vantage point, it looks like Salem's having conversations, but they may or may not get there.

473
00:49:10.967 --> 00:49:12.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And so we might have to do something.

474
00:49:12.653 --> 00:49:15.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this felt to me like they may or may not get there.

475
00:49:15.882 --> 00:49:17.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should be having conversations.

476
00:49:17.409 --> 00:49:18.309
<v Dan Ryan>And you've worked in Salem.

477
00:49:18.436 --> 00:49:18.871
<v Dan Ryan>I have not.

478
00:49:18.934 --> 00:49:20.557
<v Dan Ryan>So that means a lot coming from you.

479
00:49:20.702 --> 00:49:22.019
<v Dan Ryan>I always assume it takes longer.

480
00:49:22.614 --> 00:49:23.369
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

481
00:49:23.434 --> 00:49:23.771
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

482
00:49:23.835 --> 00:49:24.927
<v Dan Ryan>Those are a couple of my questions.

483
00:49:26.262 --> 00:49:26.969
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

484
00:49:27.514 --> 00:49:29.909
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, any other questions for the drivers union?

485
00:49:30.181 --> 00:49:32.833
<v Eric Zimmerman>We did have that person get back online.

486
00:49:32.992 --> 00:49:33.331
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

487
00:49:34.197 --> 00:49:34.856
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you both.

488
00:49:34.985 --> 00:49:39.869
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it sounds like at least one of the testifiers from previously is back online.

489
00:49:41.572 --> 00:49:46.536
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wendy, can we invite our guests to say a few words?

490
00:49:48.519 --> 00:49:52.490
<v Unidentified speaker>Angela, will you please try unmuting and see if we can hear you this time?

491
00:49:53.398 --> 00:49:54.047
<v Candace Avalos>Can you hear me?

492
00:49:54.873 --> 00:49:55.911
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can, yes.

493
00:49:56.090 --> 00:49:57.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

494
00:49:57.940 --> 00:49:58.375
<v Unidentified speaker>Yay!

495
00:49:59.146 --> 00:49:59.387
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

496
00:50:00.369 --> 00:50:02.572
<v Candace Avalos>Hello there, councilors.

497
00:50:02.684 --> 00:50:03.842
<v Candace Avalos>My name is Angie Griegs.

498
00:50:04.697 --> 00:50:10.621
<v Candace Avalos>I've been driving rideshare in the Portland area for about 8 years, and thank you for hearing us.

499
00:50:11.538 --> 00:50:12.885
<v Candace Avalos>I love doing this job.

500
00:50:13.047 --> 00:50:19.211
<v Candace Avalos>I love talking with people while I'm making a living and keeping people from driving under the influence.

501
00:50:19.869 --> 00:50:27.335
<v Candace Avalos>It also works for me because I have a bedbound husband who needs a caregiver, and I'm limited on the hours and times I can work.

502
00:50:28.155 --> 00:50:32.617
<v Candace Avalos>If I had a traditional job, they probably would have let me go for calling out too often.

503
00:50:32.715 --> 00:50:32.875
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

504
00:50:33.942 --> 00:50:36.878
<v Candace Avalos>Unfortunately, making a living gets harder every day.

505
00:50:37.798 --> 00:50:44.447
<v Candace Avalos>The cost of food, medicine, gas, everything is skyrocketing, but my pay has gone down over time.

506
00:50:45.081 --> 00:50:47.083
<v Candace Avalos>Uber and Lyft used to pay quite a bit more.

507
00:50:47.376 --> 00:50:51.291
<v Candace Avalos>When I first started, we got a set 80% of the fares.

508
00:50:52.052 --> 00:50:56.032
<v Candace Avalos>Now oftentimes I've seen Uber and Lyft take upwards of 80%.

509
00:50:57.420 --> 00:51:01.583
<v Candace Avalos>And how is this fair when I'm paying for the car, the cost of it, the maintenance?

510
00:51:02.041 --> 00:51:02.715
<v Candace Avalos>Wear and tear.

511
00:51:04.110 --> 00:51:10.509
<v Candace Avalos>And I've also seen they're charging the riders more, and due to this, riders are tipping less.

512
00:51:10.878 --> 00:51:21.559
<v Candace Avalos>I'm not saying everyone has to tip, but when they're paying $100 and assuming we're getting $70 or $75 out of that, we need to know that.

513
00:51:22.168 --> 00:51:27.476
<v Candace Avalos>We need fair transparency because Uber and Lyft make it very hard to see what they paid.

514
00:51:27.539 --> 00:51:27.925
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

515
00:51:29.226 --> 00:51:35.492
<v Candace Avalos>There have been many times taking people home from the airport when riders are charged crazy amounts.

516
00:51:36.521 --> 00:51:42.675
<v Candace Avalos>So I will get riders that are tired, jet-lagged, frustrated, and just want to go home or to their hotel.

517
00:51:43.364 --> 00:51:48.956
<v Candace Avalos>And now they're upset with me because they think I'm the one charging them $100 for a 20-minute ride.

518
00:51:50.032 --> 00:51:54.130
<v Candace Avalos>They don't realize it's not under my control, and I don't get the lion's share of that.

519
00:51:54.195 --> 00:51:54.291
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

520
00:51:55.157 --> 00:51:59.795
<v Candace Avalos>I think the companies know they have a captive audience and increase fares accordingly.

521
00:52:00.853 --> 00:52:07.128
<v Candace Avalos>They also do this at Moda Center and any venue that has large crowds all wanting to go home.

522
00:52:07.931 --> 00:52:15.922
<v Candace Avalos>If there's a peak amount of riders, they will increase prices, sometimes to amounts that are unsustainable, and they don't share that with the drivers.

523
00:52:17.398 --> 00:52:21.539
<v Candace Avalos>We need to see what they've paid without having to jump through hoops continuously.

524
00:52:22.280 --> 00:52:25.849
<v Candace Avalos>And we need a fair wage for our work and for the costs we pay.

525
00:52:26.753 --> 00:52:29.856
<v Candace Avalos>The current system is not fair to the drivers or the riders.

526
00:52:30.679 --> 00:52:32.282
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you all so much for your time.

527
00:52:35.041 --> 00:52:35.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

528
00:52:39.259 --> 00:52:41.855
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wendy, did we get our other testifier back online, or—.

529
00:52:42.244 --> 00:52:43.282
<v Unidentified speaker>No, they weren't able to join.

530
00:52:43.880 --> 00:52:44.268
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

531
00:52:45.398 --> 00:52:49.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, do we have Professor Parrott back online?

532
00:52:51.000 --> 00:52:54.137
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dr. Parrott, I know you were having some technological issues as well.

533
00:52:56.730 --> 00:52:58.623
<v Unidentified speaker>I've just resent that link as well.

534
00:53:00.670 --> 00:53:00.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

535
00:53:05.112 --> 00:53:05.903
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Have you heard back?

536
00:53:05.952 --> 00:53:11.507
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Should we wait for a moment or should we go to the next steps and timeline first?

537
00:53:14.132 --> 00:53:16.487
<v Unidentified speaker>I've just sent it, so it might be good to wait a minute.

538
00:53:18.699 --> 00:53:22.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, it sounds like Councilor Ryan has a question, so we'll go to that question first.

539
00:53:24.170 --> 00:53:24.969
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's not, but it is now.

540
00:53:26.797 --> 00:53:27.027
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

541
00:53:27.664 --> 00:53:43.887
<v Dan Ryan>Um, sorry, I don't know this, but you're all speaking as your drivers, like, um, fare drivers to move people from A to B, but there's also the folks at Uber and Lyft that— I don't know if Lyft does this, um, anyway— that deliver food and such.

542
00:53:44.398 --> 00:53:46.420
<v Dan Ryan>Is that different than this conversation?

543
00:53:47.175 --> 00:53:47.913
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, many of us do.

544
00:53:48.795 --> 00:53:49.036
<v Dan Ryan>Pardon me?

545
00:53:49.614 --> 00:53:51.251
<v Unidentified speaker>Many of us do deliver food as well.

546
00:53:52.150 --> 00:54:00.672
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, the city regulates the movement of people differently from the movement of other goods, including food.

547
00:54:00.721 --> 00:54:01.635
<v Dan Ryan>That's all I needed to hear.

548
00:54:01.717 --> 00:54:02.134
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

549
00:54:02.181 --> 00:54:02.887
<v Dan Ryan>That helped a lot.

550
00:54:03.786 --> 00:54:08.666
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry, I haven't been in the committees that have received any of this context, so I get to ask those kind of questions.

551
00:54:09.164 --> 00:54:24.521
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As context for our colleagues, I believe when you were formerly a commissioner, There was movement on cost share for delivery of food or a limit on how much of an upcharge could be charged there that didn't go to drivers.

552
00:54:24.958 --> 00:54:26.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But that didn't happen for the movement of people.

553
00:54:27.367 --> 00:54:29.340
<v Dan Ryan>No, that was all prior to me.

554
00:54:29.485 --> 00:54:30.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That was prior to you?

555
00:54:30.117 --> 00:54:30.197
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

556
00:54:30.295 --> 00:54:33.144
<v Dan Ryan>And I'll have questions about the contract we signed then.

557
00:54:33.208 --> 00:54:33.777
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

558
00:54:35.398 --> 00:54:37.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wendy, do we have the professor online?

559
00:54:39.293 --> 00:54:39.715
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe so.

560
00:54:40.784 --> 00:54:43.068
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, Dr.

561
00:54:43.117 --> 00:54:43.862
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Parrott, are you—.

562
00:54:44.882 --> 00:54:45.677
<v Dan Ryan>Um, yes.

563
00:54:58.739 --> 00:55:03.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Wendy, can you help him unmute so that we can move to his presentation?

564
00:55:05.467 --> 00:55:06.016
<v Unidentified speaker>I've tried.

565
00:55:09.172 --> 00:55:12.585
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dr. Parrott, if you can hear us, we are ready to hear from you.

566
00:55:12.715 --> 00:55:20.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think if you're not able to share your presentation, we have staff in the room who can get it up for you.

567
00:55:38.324 --> 00:55:38.518
<v Andrew Spear>Hello?

568
00:55:38.873 --> 00:55:39.391
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hi there.

569
00:55:40.005 --> 00:55:41.476
<v Dan Ryan>Hello, can you hear me?

570
00:55:41.945 --> 00:55:42.561
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes, we can.

571
00:55:44.559 --> 00:55:45.702
<v Dan Ryan>All right, thank you very much.

572
00:55:45.880 --> 00:55:46.846
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks for your patience.

573
00:55:46.990 --> 00:55:50.436
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry about the technical glitches on my end.

574
00:55:50.952 --> 00:55:51.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's all right.

575
00:55:51.596 --> 00:55:56.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Why don't you go ahead and— if you can go ahead and just introduce yourself for the record, that would be great.

576
00:55:56.987 --> 00:55:58.911
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe we have staff working on getting the presentation up.

577
00:55:58.960 --> 00:56:04.398
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that Councilor Novick's All right, thank you.

578
00:56:05.891 --> 00:56:08.507
<v Dan Ryan>James Parrott.

579
00:56:08.860 --> 00:56:18.829
<v Dan Ryan>I am a senior fellow and senior advisor at the Center for New York City Affairs, and I'm formerly the director of economic and fiscal policies at the center.

580
00:56:19.871 --> 00:56:28.972
<v Dan Ryan>Over the past decade, I've worked with several state and local governments across the country in analyzing ridesharing and other gig economy services.

581
00:56:29.929 --> 00:56:46.371
<v Dan Ryan>I've co-authored studies that have formed the basis for the minimum rideshare driver pay standards in New York City, Seattle, and Minnesota that have affected well over 100,000 drivers providing 300 million trips annually.

582
00:56:46.548 --> 00:57:07.411
<v Dan Ryan>I'd like to start off this afternoon by, um, looking at an analysis that, that Uber commissioned recently of what Portland rideshare driver pays, uh, what Portland rideshare drivers make on an hourly basis.

583
00:57:08.197 --> 00:57:14.059
<v Dan Ryan>Uber commissioned the consulting firm, uh, HRA to do an analysis.

584
00:57:14.157 --> 00:57:23.039
<v Dan Ryan>They provided proprietary earnings data for half of all the trips in 2024 by Portland drivers.

585
00:57:24.023 --> 00:57:32.070
<v Dan Ryan>This analysis computed that after allowing for expenses, the drivers took home $21.82 an hour.

586
00:57:34.496 --> 00:57:40.393
<v Dan Ryan>Um, Uber is prone to overstate driver earnings and underpay its drivers.

587
00:57:41.291 --> 00:58:08.818
<v Dan Ryan>In a re-examination of this analysis that Professor Michael Reich from University of California Uh, at Berkeley and myself conducted, we found that after you make necessary adjustments to the way Uber calculates after-expense hourly pay, that Portland Uber drivers are really making something like $12.05 an hour after expenses.

588
00:58:09.876 --> 00:58:26.596
<v Dan Ryan>The difference between these 2 figures is that we provided a much more realistic estimate of what drivers' expenses were, and we included all of the driver's time with an estimate for waiting time that Uber didn't consider.

589
00:58:27.398 --> 00:58:40.922
<v Dan Ryan>Uber had also included in its $21.82 an hour the amount of tips, which are not, of course, not paid by the company, paid by, by the passengers, and shouldn't be counted as part of driver pay.

590
00:58:46.510 --> 00:59:02.567
<v Dan Ryan>When you look at this in relation to the $15.95 minimum hour, uh, minimum pay level in Portland in 2024, you can see that that's, uh, $12.05 is certainly less than $15.95.

591
00:59:03.128 --> 00:59:06.083
<v Dan Ryan>But that's not really an accurate way to make the comparison.

592
00:59:07.608 --> 00:59:18.242
<v Dan Ryan>Minimum wage employers, as all employers do, have to pay the payroll tax, the employer share of the payroll tax for Social Security and Medicare.

593
00:59:18.788 --> 00:59:21.356
<v Dan Ryan>They have to pay unemployment insurance, workers' comp.

594
00:59:22.000 --> 00:59:23.717
<v Dan Ryan>They have to pay paid sick time.

595
00:59:24.650 --> 00:59:36.302
<v Dan Ryan>When you factor in all of those costs, uh, the minimum wage in 2024 in Portland was more like $18.72 an hour.

596
00:59:36.768 --> 00:59:40.920
<v Dan Ryan>That's what it costs an employer to employ a minimum wage worker.

597
00:59:42.297 --> 00:59:47.282
<v Dan Ryan>$12.05 Is quite a bit less than that that Uber pays.

598
00:59:48.773 --> 00:59:53.695
<v Dan Ryan>It's 24% below the $15.95 Portland minimum wage.

599
00:59:54.063 --> 01:00:19.072
<v Dan Ryan>It's 36% less than what an employer of a minimum wage worker must pay per hour, and it's 42% less than what the average fast food worker made in Portland in 2024 once you factor in these mandated costs for payroll taxes and worker safety net costs.

600
01:00:20.590 --> 01:00:36.510
<v Dan Ryan>So it really is more realistic to, to, uh, to consider that Uber is paying in the neighborhood of $12 An hour, not the $21 an hour, $22 an hour that they contended.

601
01:00:37.889 --> 01:00:49.362
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, in looking at trends in Uber pricing over the years, you know, what I'm about to say can shed a little bit of light on, on what the drivers have been testifying about.

602
01:00:50.228 --> 01:01:00.715
<v Dan Ryan>Uber changed their, their pricing policy in, uh, in 2022 to go to an upfront pricing, uh, approach.

603
01:01:01.693 --> 01:01:14.994
<v Dan Ryan>Um, and since then, passenger fares have continued to rise, driver pay has fallen, and Uber's and Lyft's profits have soared.

604
01:01:16.070 --> 01:01:41.670
<v Dan Ryan>A large sample of national data from Gridwise Analytics a third-party app that enables drivers to track their earnings and driving activity, indicates that rideshare fares rose 9.6% from December 2024 to December 2025, while driver pay per trip increased by only 3.6%.

605
01:01:43.498 --> 01:01:51.255
<v Dan Ryan>I think one of the early speakers noted how significant Uber and Lyft profits have been rising recently.

606
01:01:51.351 --> 01:02:10.436
<v Dan Ryan>Let me just underscore that Uber's revenues rose 18% in 2025 and 14%, uh, in the first quarter of 2026, while net operating income climbed 50% in 2025 and was up by 42% through the first quarter.

607
01:02:11.398 --> 01:02:18.672
<v Dan Ryan>For Lyft, revenues rose uh, 9% last year, 14% in the first quarter.

608
01:02:19.965 --> 01:02:32.170
<v Dan Ryan>They— Lyft recorded a 30%— 38% increase in net cash from operations in 2025 and a 7% increase, uh, through the first quarter of this year.

609
01:02:34.994 --> 01:02:58.541
<v Dan Ryan>Based on my analysis of rideshare activity all across the country, over several years, it's very clear that it is possible to effectively regulate through minimum pay standards driver pay so that workers can be compensated for all of their time and have a fair reimbursement rate for their expenses.

610
01:02:59.550 --> 01:03:03.784
<v Dan Ryan>Rideshare driving in America has evolved considerably over the past decade.

611
01:03:04.699 --> 01:03:15.318
<v Dan Ryan>In its early days, Uber and Lyft used ample flows of venture capital to attract drivers to its platform, paying them a relatively fixed 75 to 80% of the passenger fare.

612
01:03:16.335 --> 01:03:22.195
<v Dan Ryan>Company algorithms managed drivers, evaluated their performance, and compiled customer ratings.

613
01:03:23.228 --> 01:03:30.340
<v Dan Ryan>Today, the company algorithms make it extremely difficult for drivers to understand the basis for their compensation.

614
01:03:30.882 --> 01:03:34.748
<v Dan Ryan>The companies use incentives to influence and control driver behavior.

615
01:03:35.487 --> 01:03:42.336
<v Dan Ryan>And algorithmic discipline and deactivation, which are both perplexing and frustrating to resolve.

616
01:03:43.284 --> 01:04:00.706
<v Dan Ryan>Increasingly, in situations where the companies face an excess of drivers relative to consumer demand, the companies often effectively auction trips at the lowest pay a driver will accept while keeping passenger fares high.

617
01:04:01.717 --> 01:04:13.606
<v Dan Ryan>As a result, drivers report that their pay and share of the passenger fare have fallen while rideshare companies', uh, profits climb.

618
01:04:14.503 --> 01:04:43.061
<v Dan Ryan>It's also very clear from my analysis of driver pay trends in several jurisdictions that independent government pay regulation required, such as exists in Seattle, New York City and Minnesota, that this independent governmental pay regulation requires an effective mechanism to maintain a workable balance between the supply of rideshare drivers and the level of consumer demand for rides.

619
01:04:43.911 --> 01:04:52.478
<v Dan Ryan>Without effective supply regulations regulating the supply of drivers, driver pay will continue to be inadequate.

620
01:04:53.539 --> 01:04:56.492
<v Dan Ryan>I'd be happy to answer any questions council members have.

621
01:04:57.168 --> 01:04:57.585
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

622
01:04:58.757 --> 01:04:59.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much.

623
01:04:59.896 --> 01:05:04.264
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, are there questions for Professor Parrott?

624
01:05:04.393 --> 01:05:11.025
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I've seen that at least some people have the written presentation, the written testimony.

625
01:05:12.340 --> 01:05:15.182
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that it is up online now as well.

626
01:05:19.043 --> 01:05:20.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any questions for the professor?

627
01:05:20.822 --> 01:05:20.918
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

628
01:05:21.469 --> 01:05:23.311
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Councilor Zimmerman, go right ahead.

629
01:05:24.510 --> 01:05:24.865
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

630
01:05:25.027 --> 01:05:30.992
<v Eric Zimmerman>You mentioned that in 2022 the program shifted to upfront pricing.

631
01:05:31.789 --> 01:05:46.844
<v Eric Zimmerman>So for a lay user perspective, I remember that's why I originally liked Uber when it all started, because unlike a taxi that it always just kept on running, I knew what my price was as a user.

632
01:05:46.989 --> 01:05:48.722
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I don't think that that's what you mean.

633
01:05:48.835 --> 01:05:53.418
<v Eric Zimmerman>So what does this mean in this context in 2022 that changed?

634
01:05:55.902 --> 01:06:06.036
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, so it is the, the, the term upfront pricing is what the companies use to describe their pay policy.

635
01:06:06.101 --> 01:06:19.773
<v Dan Ryan>But I understand what you mean by, you know, it's always been possible to sort of see To get, to get an estimate of what the fare is before you decide to accept that, that, that ride offer.

636
01:06:19.951 --> 01:06:39.956
<v Dan Ryan>So what the companies did differently, rather than, than use sort of a taxi rate formula where the fare would be determined by so much per minute and so much per mile, you know, the, the time and the distance that it would that it's estimated that that ride would, would require.

637
01:06:41.032 --> 01:06:49.478
<v Dan Ryan>Um, the companies quoted, uh, the passenger a fare and quoted the driver, uh, an amount of money.

638
01:06:50.306 --> 01:06:59.286
<v Dan Ryan>Um, now, uh, this could vary depending upon, um, supply and demand conditions, uh, at the time.

639
01:06:59.994 --> 01:07:06.077
<v Dan Ryan>As the companies, uh, you know, this was in 2022 after the company's been operating for several years.

640
01:07:06.797 --> 01:07:27.052
<v Dan Ryan>They had learned a lot about the market dynamics of the rideshare industry, and they were better able to judge, uh, what sort of fare they could charge for a ride and what sort of pay they would have to provide to the driver to get the driver to accept that.

641
01:07:27.693 --> 01:07:38.998
<v Dan Ryan>So the pricing at that point was decoupled from the, from the taxi sort of rate card approach of so much per mile and so much per minute.

642
01:07:40.735 --> 01:07:55.429
<v Dan Ryan>And it was a function of what the algorithm had, had set the fare and the driver pay at, given everything that it had learned about the local market.

643
01:07:57.130 --> 01:08:07.280
<v Dan Ryan>And, and, and what it could basically charge the passengers and, uh, how little it could pay the drivers to get them to accept the rides.

644
01:08:07.954 --> 01:08:08.836
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you.

645
01:08:08.934 --> 01:08:14.905
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm going to call it in the before era, before era of 2022.

646
01:08:16.206 --> 01:08:20.332
<v Eric Zimmerman>I as a user would know that my ride was $25.

647
01:08:20.396 --> 01:08:35.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>Believe me, I haven't had a $25 ride in years, it feels like, but a $25 ride but the driver, it was a, it was a, it was magic behind the scenes that they wouldn't know until that fare was over to know what their fare was that they were going to make.

648
01:08:36.048 --> 01:08:50.787
<v Eric Zimmerman>And now post-2022 with upfront pricing, I know that the ride is $55 and the driver also before accepting it, they now can see what the fare is.

649
01:08:50.899 --> 01:08:53.403
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that I want to make sure I'm— it is a little hard to hear you.

650
01:08:53.467 --> 01:08:54.895
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's why I'm repeating back to you.

651
01:08:56.259 --> 01:09:03.078
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, yeah, no, that's, that's, uh, that's a succinct way of, uh, of stating it.

652
01:09:04.377 --> 01:09:05.180
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks, Chair.

653
01:09:05.261 --> 01:09:06.543
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's it for my questions right now.

654
01:09:06.625 --> 01:09:07.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Professor.

655
01:09:07.971 --> 01:09:08.871
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

656
01:09:09.095 --> 01:09:10.764
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, Councilor Ryan, did you have questions?

657
01:09:11.197 --> 01:09:13.893
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, this is, uh, Professor Parrott.

658
01:09:14.005 --> 01:09:14.614
<v Dan Ryan>Is that who this is?

659
01:09:14.791 --> 01:09:14.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

660
01:09:15.273 --> 01:09:17.887
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, welcome to Portland, Oregon.

661
01:09:18.320 --> 01:09:20.358
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I see you're at the new school Is that true?

662
01:09:22.326 --> 01:09:22.729
<v Dan Ryan>That's right.

663
01:09:23.068 --> 01:09:23.793
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, great.

664
01:09:23.954 --> 01:09:27.600
<v Dan Ryan>That was my first real job outta college was at the New School in '85 to '89.

665
01:09:27.681 --> 01:09:29.439
<v Dan Ryan>So just wanted to say that.

666
01:09:31.815 --> 01:09:34.744
<v Dan Ryan>You study this across the country.

667
01:09:35.376 --> 01:09:36.703
<v Dan Ryan>It must be something you do, right?

668
01:09:36.751 --> 01:09:40.489
<v Dan Ryan>You study this market across the country?

669
01:09:40.636 --> 01:09:40.797
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

670
01:09:41.219 --> 01:09:41.608
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

671
01:09:42.256 --> 01:09:45.335
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I started— go ahead.

672
01:09:45.935 --> 01:09:48.002
<v Dan Ryan>No, no, tell, tell us more about your credentials.

673
01:09:48.756 --> 01:10:04.716
<v Dan Ryan>So I was just going to say that the, the way I got into it was I was asked in 2017 by the New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission to undertake an analysis of New York City rideshare driver pay.

674
01:10:05.662 --> 01:10:12.055
<v Dan Ryan>The city was getting lots of complaints from the drivers about declining pay at that point.

675
01:10:13.052 --> 01:10:25.096
<v Dan Ryan>And that, that study led to the development of the minimum pay standard that was enacted in 2018 and took effect in 2019.

676
01:10:25.661 --> 01:10:38.622
<v Dan Ryan>And since then, there have been minimum pay standards enacted in Seattle, and later that spread to the entire state of Washington.

677
01:10:39.420 --> 01:10:41.979
<v Dan Ryan>And in Minnesota in, in 2024.

678
01:10:42.091 --> 01:10:43.921
<v Dan Ryan>Well, this is how you became an expert.

679
01:10:46.238 --> 01:11:01.793
<v Dan Ryan>So I started doing that and then have, have been asked by, you know, folks like the City of Portland and cities all over the, the country, um, to help advise them on how to proceed.

680
01:11:03.226 --> 01:11:06.256
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, um, so anyway, that's how you became an expert.

681
01:11:06.432 --> 01:11:13.198
<v Dan Ryan>And so my point that I want to ask the question is, what sticks out about Portland when you compare it to other markets you've studied?

682
01:11:14.261 --> 01:11:18.184
<v Dan Ryan>If you would say there's one thing that's special, unique, different, what would it be?

683
01:11:21.746 --> 01:11:31.747
<v Dan Ryan>Well, I don't know that there's anything that, that I've learned about how rideshare operates in Portland that is unique.

684
01:11:31.909 --> 01:11:40.404
<v Dan Ryan>I think it's fairly I think the, the way the industry operates is, uh, you know, to, to a large extent it's fairly uniform.

685
01:11:41.271 --> 01:12:00.110
<v Dan Ryan>That's, that's the kind of, um, uh, operation that the companies have, have sought in order to present consumers wherever they may be getting off a plane, uh, with a predictable, uh, rideshare experience.

686
01:12:00.190 --> 01:12:13.051
<v Dan Ryan>So the companies have tried to, to make the industry fairly uniform across cities in the United States, and they've also spread to other countries as well.

687
01:12:13.838 --> 01:12:15.653
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, thank you, Professor Parrott.

688
01:12:15.702 --> 01:12:30.671
<v Dan Ryan>I think from listening to the, the good people in the room, it sounded like there were some issues that were a little bit unique, but your, your you're making it clear there's a pattern about the entire country in terms of this practice.

689
01:12:31.328 --> 01:12:36.682
<v Dan Ryan>And I appreciate that Councilor Zimmerman made it really clear there's been a difference since 2022.

690
01:12:37.100 --> 01:12:41.509
<v Dan Ryan>And I knew there was a reason I stopped using it as much, 'cause the prices did go up dramatically.

691
01:12:41.748 --> 01:12:42.679
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thanks.

692
01:12:44.073 --> 01:12:44.489
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

693
01:12:44.569 --> 01:12:46.060
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Any other questions for the professor?

694
01:12:47.536 --> 01:12:53.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you so much for being here with us and bearing with us through the technological challenges we're having today.

695
01:12:54.028 --> 01:12:55.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We really appreciate hearing from you.

696
01:12:57.332 --> 01:12:57.738
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

697
01:12:57.965 --> 01:13:03.125
<v Dan Ryan>I think that, I think the technical problems were all on my end, so I'm really apologetic for that.

698
01:13:04.212 --> 01:13:04.762
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's okay.

699
01:13:04.860 --> 01:13:05.557
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These things happen.

700
01:13:07.591 --> 01:13:19.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we are next going to hear from my policy staffer, Devin, about the timeline and next steps for the work that we have been convening.

701
01:13:19.760 --> 01:13:35.277
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while Devin's sitting down, I will say I was remiss before in not noting when I said that Councilor Murillo was looking at working on this as well, that Councilor Dunphy has also signed on and is partnering on the work.

702
01:13:36.375 --> 01:13:39.796
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize to him and his team that I didn't mention that previously.

703
01:13:39.877 --> 01:13:43.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's a newer partner, and we're excited to have him.

704
01:13:45.060 --> 01:13:50.395
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Devin, why don't you tell us about what the next couple of months look like and what we have calendared out?

705
01:13:50.756 --> 01:13:56.061
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To make sure that this conversation doesn't lose momentum and we keep working and moving forward.

706
01:13:56.863 --> 01:13:57.279
<v Samuel Araya>Absolutely.

707
01:13:57.328 --> 01:13:58.305
<v Devin Mullins>Thank you, Councilor.

708
01:13:58.850 --> 01:14:00.037
<v Devin Mullins>For the record, Devin Mullins.

709
01:14:00.213 --> 01:14:02.521
<v Devin Mullins>I am a policy manager for Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

710
01:14:03.179 --> 01:14:06.337
<v Devin Mullins>A couple of important dates to kind of flag for you.

711
01:14:06.641 --> 01:14:20.876
<v Devin Mullins>Firstly is we have Councilor Pirtle-Guiney and Councilor Novick, and as well as other co-sponsors, are convening kind of a roundtable series to discuss and negotiate with Uber and Lyft over what a policy might look like that works in Portland.

712
01:14:21.613 --> 01:14:22.399
<v Devin Mullins>This process has started.

713
01:14:23.652 --> 01:14:36.465
<v Devin Mullins>So we're looking at, I think the first meeting is June 18th, and we're looking at 3 or 4 meetings, however many it takes to get the policy right, but probably 3 or 4 meetings over the course of June and July and possible follow-up.

714
01:14:37.283 --> 01:14:47.784
<v Devin Mullins>Another important date to flag is kind of separate legislation that we see as complementary to this legislation, but isn't exactly what was discussed today, is on a driver's resource center.

715
01:14:48.282 --> 01:14:52.342
<v Devin Mullins>Looking to have this in this committee and City Life on June 9th.

716
01:14:52.695 --> 01:14:59.806
<v Devin Mullins>Again, this is complementary legislation that deals with other challenges in the market, from deactivation support to translation interpretation services.

717
01:15:00.417 --> 01:15:06.146
<v Devin Mullins>Our office will send out an informational memo similar to the ones we've done on other policy ahead of the City Life Committee meeting.

718
01:15:06.484 --> 01:15:07.737
<v Devin Mullins>That way you have some background on it.

719
01:15:08.747 --> 01:15:15.890
<v Devin Mullins>And then finally, a kind of mid-July, August timeframe, we're aiming to have the draft ordinance on the earnings standard that was discussed today.

720
01:15:16.532 --> 01:15:23.768
<v Devin Mullins>However that might look, kind of at the conclusion of those negotiations with Uber and Lyft and after robust conversations with the drivers union.

721
01:15:24.394 --> 01:15:31.292
<v Devin Mullins>Importantly, this will still be a work in progress, but we'll aim to have a hearing on it in the committee so that it can be sufficiently worked by you all.

722
01:15:32.399 --> 01:15:41.752
<v Devin Mullins>And then just one thing I wanted to add as well is the— I'm gonna send out an email to all of you all and your policy staff with the presentations today.

723
01:15:42.189 --> 01:15:45.557
<v Devin Mullins>Apologies, it was my fault that those were not posted in time, so I apologize about that.

724
01:15:45.993 --> 01:15:53.685
<v Devin Mullins>And then also share a presentation from the take rate proposal that Councilor Novick's office presented at the last Labor and Workforce Committee.

725
01:15:53.733 --> 01:15:54.997
<v Devin Mullins>I already found that presentation.

726
01:15:55.046 --> 01:15:56.425
<v Devin Mullins>I'm going to send it to you all so you have that context.

727
01:15:58.907 --> 01:15:59.533
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Devin.

728
01:16:01.172 --> 01:16:04.337
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, any questions about those next steps?

729
01:16:04.771 --> 01:16:10.795
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And at this time, if anybody has general comments or discussion, It's a great time to get in the queue.

730
01:16:10.859 --> 01:16:13.720
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll take just a few more minutes before we move to the next agenda item.

731
01:16:18.520 --> 01:16:19.537
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

732
01:16:20.135 --> 01:16:25.432
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, before we close this, Wendy, did we get any of our other testifiers back?

733
01:16:27.609 --> 01:16:29.615
<v Unidentified speaker>We have Ahmed calling in.

734
01:16:31.251 --> 01:16:35.769
<v Unidentified speaker>Ahmed, can you please unmute and speak?

735
01:16:35.859 --> 01:16:36.889
<v Unidentified speaker>Speak if you're ready.

736
01:16:43.760 --> 01:16:46.313
<v Unidentified speaker>Believe it's star 6 if you're on your phone.

737
01:16:57.362 --> 01:16:58.472
<v Unidentified speaker>We have tried.

738
01:16:59.213 --> 01:17:02.801
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I think at this point we will need to move to the next agenda item.

739
01:17:02.934 --> 01:17:16.059
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you to everybody who was and if there were folks who wanted to testify and the technology wasn't working, please feel free to submit testimony or send information to our offices.

740
01:17:17.539 --> 01:17:21.033
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, Diana, could you please call the next item on the agenda?

741
01:17:22.020 --> 01:17:34.177
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, item number 3, document number 2026-174, amend city code to transfer oversight of portable sign placement in the right-of-way and remove registration requirements for portable signs.

742
01:17:44.359 --> 01:17:44.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

743
01:17:45.005 --> 01:17:53.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, this comes to us from Councilor Novick's office and he is unfortunately not able to be here today, but had asked us to move forward anyway.

744
01:17:53.162 --> 01:17:57.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe we have somebody from his team here to present.

745
01:17:57.637 --> 01:17:58.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

746
01:17:58.310 --> 01:17:59.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Spencer, good to see you.

747
01:17:59.505 --> 01:17:59.537
<v Candace Avalos>Hi.

748
01:18:04.435 --> 01:18:06.021
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, City Life Committee.

749
01:18:06.118 --> 01:18:07.225
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Spencer Knowles.

750
01:18:07.480 --> 01:18:26.432
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the chief of staff for Councilor Steve Novick in District 3, and it's a pleasure to be here today for what I hope is a somewhat practical and straightforward change to city code and how we regulate, uh, portable signs, also known as sandwich boards.

751
01:18:26.497 --> 01:18:30.766
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll share a presentation On my screen.

752
01:18:50.088 --> 01:19:06.110
<v Unidentified speaker>So while that gets loaded up, um, this concept came to us when we were meeting, um, with various business districts and one of the leaders said, you know, I'd like to buy sandwich boards for all the business members in my district.

753
01:19:06.256 --> 01:19:12.426
<v Unidentified speaker>But not only is there the price of buying the sandwich board, but then there's this permit that you have to get through the city.

754
01:19:13.328 --> 01:19:19.841
<v Unidentified speaker>And that piqued our interest 'cause we didn't realize that you had to get these things permitted.

755
01:19:20.019 --> 01:19:30.432
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll note that if you walk down many business districts in the City of Portland and you look at all the different A-Boards, I won't— they're not all permitted.

756
01:19:31.025 --> 01:19:33.396
<v Unidentified speaker>The compliance rate is fairly low.

757
01:19:34.213 --> 01:19:40.190
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we decided to take a look at it and see what could be done.

758
01:19:41.279 --> 01:19:43.171
<v Unidentified speaker>For starters, what is a portable sign?

759
01:19:43.266 --> 01:19:46.375
<v Unidentified speaker>They're also known as A-boards or sandwich boards.

760
01:19:46.567 --> 01:19:49.338
<v Unidentified speaker>They're not attached to the structure or the ground.

761
01:19:50.796 --> 01:19:56.628
<v Unidentified speaker>The placement and standards for portable signs are currently regulated under Portland's sign code, which is lengthy.

762
01:19:58.210 --> 01:20:01.898
<v Unidentified speaker>And was established— this permit requirement was established in 2001.

763
01:20:03.122 --> 01:20:11.471
<v Unidentified speaker>To place a portable sign in the right-of-way, you must apply for and display a permit as a little sticker on the bottom of the A-board.

764
01:20:14.328 --> 01:20:17.074
<v Unidentified speaker>Why were they initially regulated?

765
01:20:17.220 --> 01:20:23.164
<v Unidentified speaker>It was part of the right-of-way management, a citywide effort in 2001 to regulate the right-of-way.

766
01:20:23.850 --> 01:20:28.988
<v Unidentified speaker>And was a piece of the sit/lie ordinances that were big at that time.

767
01:20:29.844 --> 01:20:32.557
<v Unidentified speaker>There were also factors of ADA accessibility.

768
01:20:34.250 --> 01:20:40.802
<v Unidentified speaker>If they're not placed properly, they can impede the right-of-way, people walking and navigating the sidewalks.

769
01:20:41.608 --> 01:20:51.372
<v Unidentified speaker>And also, there was at one point some revenue positives that the city was receiving from this program.

770
01:20:52.407 --> 01:21:01.166
<v Unidentified speaker>However, permitting is no longer necessary for the city and is a burden upon many of the small businesses in Portland, even if it's just a small one.

771
01:21:02.939 --> 01:21:05.422
<v Unidentified speaker>So just a brief overview of the regulatory program.

772
01:21:05.715 --> 01:21:09.676
<v Unidentified speaker>Permits you can get in 1, 2, or 4-year spans.

773
01:21:11.060 --> 01:21:15.956
<v Unidentified speaker>The number of permits has been issued— that have been issued has been decreasing over the years.

774
01:21:17.208 --> 01:21:24.466
<v Unidentified speaker>You'll see here the— in the calendar year '23, '24, '25, all decreasing.

775
01:21:24.579 --> 01:21:32.581
<v Unidentified speaker>And there used to be much higher, as is reflected on the right in the registration fees the city used to receive from them.

776
01:21:33.079 --> 01:21:39.426
<v Unidentified speaker>So for example, in 2016, we got $214,000 from Rayboard registrations.

777
01:21:40.582 --> 01:21:43.318
<v Unidentified speaker>And last year we got $40,000.

778
01:21:43.417 --> 01:21:43.451
<v Dan Ryan>Wow.

779
01:21:44.694 --> 01:21:56.435
<v Unidentified speaker>And one of the problems is we received $40,000 in registration revenue, but the program to operate the Aboard regulatory program, the cost was $46,000.

780
01:21:56.533 --> 01:22:04.440
<v Unidentified speaker>So we were losing $7,000 a year adding this burden of a permit for small businesses.

781
01:22:09.658 --> 01:22:15.243
<v Eric Zimmerman>Sorry, Chair, before we move on, that last slide, total sign program revenue.

782
01:22:15.324 --> 01:22:17.273
<v Eric Zimmerman>What am I supposed to read about that column though?

783
01:22:17.981 --> 01:22:21.685
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because the program you said brought in $38,000, but what is the $168,000?

784
01:22:23.488 --> 01:22:31.250
<v Unidentified speaker>So, um, the sign program doesn't only address A-board signs, it's all the signs across program— across the city.

785
01:22:31.587 --> 01:22:36.895
<v Unidentified speaker>And you still have to get permits for other types of signs like awnings or lighted signs, stuff like that.

786
01:22:37.137 --> 01:22:38.997
<v Eric Zimmerman>You're just separating out the two.

787
01:22:39.141 --> 01:22:39.820
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, appreciate it.

788
01:22:39.886 --> 01:22:40.500
<v Unidentified speaker>That's correct, yeah.

789
01:22:44.699 --> 01:22:53.521
<v Unidentified speaker>We've also seen that complaints about A-Boards have dropped over the years.

790
01:22:54.122 --> 01:22:59.757
<v Unidentified speaker>So A-Board compliance is complaint-driven and is currently investigated by the PP&D enforcement team.

791
01:23:02.012 --> 01:23:04.615
<v Unidentified speaker>People from that team are here if you have questions for them.

792
01:23:05.050 --> 01:23:08.600
<v Unidentified speaker>If a violation is found, a notice is sent.

793
01:23:09.484 --> 01:23:12.055
<v Unidentified speaker>If not corrected, then a citation is issued.

794
01:23:12.442 --> 01:23:17.176
<v Unidentified speaker>Usually they try and get people into compliance before issuing any sort of citations.

795
01:23:19.119 --> 01:23:27.408
<v Unidentified speaker>Compliance with permitting is low, yet complaints have also been falling, suggesting that business owners are somewhat self-regulating.

796
01:23:28.350 --> 01:23:40.872
<v Unidentified speaker>And I, you know, when we started looking into this, we were really concerned that if we removed the permit, there might be some ADA compliance issues and that, you know, that would affect that population greatly.

797
01:23:41.015 --> 01:23:52.706
<v Unidentified speaker>But we're not seeing currently that the level of complaints for ADA compliance is not something that couldn't be handled by the PBOT right-of-way regulatory team.

798
01:23:55.212 --> 01:23:59.367
<v Unidentified speaker>So what this ordinance does, it removes the permit requirement from Title 32.

799
01:23:59.543 --> 01:24:04.617
<v Unidentified speaker>Businesses will no longer need to apply for and display a permit for the sandwich board.

800
01:24:05.890 --> 01:24:20.934
<v Unidentified speaker>All the other standards for portable signs, such as size and design, will all— will still remain in Title 32, as well as some placement restrictions in certain zones and districts.

801
01:24:22.664 --> 01:24:30.137
<v Unidentified speaker>And then it will also add to Title 17 to certify PBOT's authority to regulate portable signs in the right-of-way.

802
01:24:30.458 --> 01:24:32.985
<v Unidentified speaker>It'll maintain standards for ADA compliance.

803
01:24:34.630 --> 01:24:44.430
<v Unidentified speaker>Right-of-way management will be further consolidated within PBOT, and it maintains penalties for any violations under the transportation fee schedule.

804
01:24:46.878 --> 01:24:49.400
<v Unidentified speaker>And then lastly, Why does this matter?

805
01:24:49.777 --> 01:24:52.707
<v Unidentified speaker>We all know how important small businesses are to Portland.

806
01:24:54.489 --> 01:24:59.145
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I know Councilor Ryan has discussed that at length, and this committee has discussed that at length.

807
01:25:02.478 --> 01:25:03.043
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's see.

808
01:25:03.755 --> 01:25:21.170
<v Unidentified speaker>And we feel this is a more efficient and sensible approach to A boards, and it just is one extra permit that the city is requiring, a level of red tape that we can take away and help small businesses operate in the city.

809
01:25:21.703 --> 01:25:23.543
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's our pitch to you.

810
01:25:23.850 --> 01:25:27.757
<v Unidentified speaker>Happy to answer any questions or call up any staff.

811
01:25:27.822 --> 01:25:34.520
<v Unidentified speaker>We have folks from both PBOT, Right-of-Way Compliance, and PP&D here if there are questions.

812
01:25:36.149 --> 01:25:36.920
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Spencer.

813
01:25:37.002 --> 01:25:38.872
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, would you like to kick us off?

814
01:25:40.189 --> 01:25:41.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>So much I want to kick us off.

815
01:25:42.636 --> 01:25:51.621
<v Eric Zimmerman>I love that this is coming forward, and, and hats off to, uh, Councilor Novick and his team for— I don't know, whatever the analogy of getting this over the line.

816
01:25:51.748 --> 01:26:01.007
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, the fact that we even brought in $39,000 last year in revenue because people followed the permitting laws is amazing to me.

817
01:26:01.850 --> 01:26:11.541
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I just find— so just, I say this in the same week that in one of my districts, one of my neighborhoods in the district, I've got people complaining about signage boards right now.

818
01:26:12.873 --> 01:26:20.002
<v Eric Zimmerman>But in large part, I was aware of the permitting and that it seems like they have certainly gone down in the usage.

819
01:26:20.100 --> 01:26:34.438
<v Eric Zimmerman>It used to be you'd see that City of Portland little sticker on a lot of them, and you barely see them anymore, which is why I'll be supportive of this, because even in a time when people are not following it, it— Portland has a particular— A lot of signs.

820
01:26:35.775 --> 01:26:42.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>Passive aggressiveness that will make sure that business owners comply with keeping the sidewalks clear, right?

821
01:26:42.942 --> 01:26:48.733
<v Eric Zimmerman>We are, we are big fans of shaming you into doing the right thing, and I think that that's what's going to apply here.

822
01:26:49.216 --> 01:27:00.220
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we talk about compliance— Spencer, thanks for laying that out— when a code compliance officer shows up and says you're out of compliance, please just move it 6 inches to the left and all of a sudden you're in compliance.

823
01:27:00.284 --> 01:27:04.087
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's that's the— like, we don't have to over-engineer the damn thing, right?

824
01:27:04.231 --> 01:27:09.279
<v Eric Zimmerman>So this is definitely one of those dumb laws accounts, and dumb laws should always be attacked.

825
01:27:10.340 --> 01:27:15.635
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, what I really like about it though is that having standards is what people ask for.

826
01:27:17.380 --> 01:27:23.765
<v Eric Zimmerman>Having to take out a permit to verify that you followed those standards is the silliness of this, not that there are standards.

827
01:27:23.814 --> 01:27:25.301
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that was a good distinction.

828
01:27:25.479 --> 01:27:33.319
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for putting that in here, is that there will still be standards, and when somebody gets out of them, our code compliance and nosy neighbors will still be able to do their thing.

829
01:27:34.090 --> 01:27:40.684
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we don't have to do a mother may I permission slip, and being a city of permission slips is something that I'm quite tired of.

830
01:27:40.747 --> 01:27:44.229
<v Eric Zimmerman>So all in, all the time, run it all the way across.

831
01:27:44.358 --> 01:27:44.935
<v Eric Zimmerman>Let's pass it.

832
01:27:45.000 --> 01:27:46.091
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for bringing it forward.

833
01:27:47.086 --> 01:27:58.680
<v Eric Zimmerman>And as one of the neighborhoods with plenty of, of concern about sandwich boards, I have thank you, Councilor.

834
01:27:58.744 --> 01:28:02.917
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Morillo, were you in the queue, or— No, it got answered by Whitney, so—.

835
01:28:03.515 --> 01:28:03.823
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

836
01:28:04.569 --> 01:28:07.532
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You don't want to also suggest that people shouldn't follow our codes?

837
01:28:09.543 --> 01:28:10.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, certainly not.

838
01:28:11.322 --> 01:28:18.729
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I guess the only clarifying question I kind of had that I think was touched on already was, is there— because I think this is very silly, and I agree, and I hope that the city staff agrees.

839
01:28:18.819 --> 01:28:19.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it should go away.

840
01:28:20.400 --> 01:28:30.519
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The only question I have is, are we going to have any issues with like ADA compliance or lawsuits on the city if we change this because of the ADA compliance aspect of it?

841
01:28:32.229 --> 01:28:34.069
<v Unidentified speaker>I would think not, but I would—.

842
01:28:34.166 --> 01:28:34.828
<v Unidentified speaker>At any time.

843
01:28:35.069 --> 01:28:40.712
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome Lisa to come up here and talk about her work on that issue.

844
01:28:47.192 --> 01:28:47.704
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

845
01:28:47.753 --> 01:28:49.503
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name's Lisa Strader.

846
01:28:49.583 --> 01:28:50.771
<v Unidentified speaker>I use she/her pronouns.

847
01:28:50.965 --> 01:28:53.983
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the Portland Bureau of Transportation's ADA coordinator.

848
01:28:55.363 --> 01:29:08.738
<v Unidentified speaker>I was just looking at my tracking of concerns and complaints that I've received over the last couple of years for sidewalks, and I get about 2 to 3 dozen a year.

849
01:29:10.224 --> 01:29:12.028
<v Unidentified speaker>But that's all kinds of things on sidewalks.

850
01:29:13.439 --> 01:29:21.800
<v Unidentified speaker>So vegetation, somebody's basketball hoop, heaved sidewalks, so literally the infrastructure.

851
01:29:22.893 --> 01:29:29.764
<v Unidentified speaker>I've had like 3 or 4 in the last 2 years about something like a sidewalk sign.

852
01:29:29.909 --> 01:29:32.978
<v Unidentified speaker>And as somebody just mentioned, those are pretty easily rectified.

853
01:29:35.587 --> 01:29:39.171
<v Unidentified speaker>The standards don't change, as I think Spencer mentioned.

854
01:29:39.268 --> 01:29:47.345
<v Unidentified speaker>So even though somebody doesn't have to get a permit, the sizes are regulated, where they're placed is regulated.

855
01:29:48.118 --> 01:30:00.387
<v Unidentified speaker>And because it seems like they're so reasonably priced that they're pretty— they're more widely used, I think people can easily adjust them when there's a problem.

856
01:30:01.766 --> 01:30:09.612
<v Unidentified speaker>I, I think we can continue to point to all the standards that we have and that the corrective measures don't change.

857
01:30:09.676 --> 01:30:23.672
<v Unidentified speaker>We still have a complaint-driven system with changing the code from requiring a permit to have one versus just having it be available to small businesses.

858
01:30:23.881 --> 01:30:25.007
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, great.

859
01:30:25.072 --> 01:30:26.408
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for answering my question.

860
01:30:26.503 --> 01:30:27.376
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That great.

861
01:30:27.712 --> 01:30:30.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

862
01:30:30.902 --> 01:30:32.889
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan, did you have something or did it get answered?

863
01:30:33.161 --> 01:30:33.288
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go ahead.

864
01:30:33.368 --> 01:30:35.740
<v Dan Ryan>Well, no, I want to thank Councilor Morillo for asking that question.

865
01:30:35.788 --> 01:30:37.023
<v Dan Ryan>That was my main question.

866
01:30:37.230 --> 01:30:41.350
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I think I just want to profess I'm just excited about this.

867
01:30:41.413 --> 01:30:45.532
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you, Councilor Novick and Spencer, for bringing this forward.

868
01:30:45.885 --> 01:30:48.833
<v Dan Ryan>I really appreciate all of the information that you provided.

869
01:30:49.443 --> 01:30:54.926
<v Dan Ryan>It's such a simple solution, um, for local businesses to actually the city provides one less headache for them.

870
01:30:55.182 --> 01:30:56.113
<v Dan Ryan>They're not used to that.

871
01:30:56.243 --> 01:30:59.275
<v Dan Ryan>So this would be a lovely message we'd be sending out.

872
01:31:00.158 --> 01:31:12.355
<v Dan Ryan>And your answer about the fact that you can manage the complaints, um, with anyone coming from an ADA complaint, whether there's a permit or not, that's what I thought I heard.

873
01:31:12.453 --> 01:31:13.576
<v Dan Ryan>Was that correct?

874
01:31:14.363 --> 01:31:15.791
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, yes, Councilor Ryan.

875
01:31:15.984 --> 01:31:16.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

876
01:31:16.400 --> 01:31:21.248
<v Dan Ryan>So that, that really was my only like concern that there might be on this one.

877
01:31:21.827 --> 01:31:25.456
<v Dan Ryan>And then when you heard this year alone, we're in the red for even managing this.

878
01:31:25.631 --> 01:31:28.891
<v Dan Ryan>So it's, um, it's not doing anyone any good, it seems like.

879
01:31:29.774 --> 01:31:36.743
<v Dan Ryan>Um, so anyway, I look forward to moving this along, and thank you so much, Councilor Novick, for bringing this forward.

880
01:31:36.935 --> 01:31:37.658
<v Dan Ryan>It's spot on.

881
01:31:38.220 --> 01:31:40.292
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

882
01:31:41.014 --> 01:31:43.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I put myself in the queue with 2 small questions.

883
01:31:43.614 --> 01:32:00.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Spencer, You, on the slide about revenues and us being in the red here, there was a note that said the sign program has a reserve deficit of over $250,000.

884
01:32:01.287 --> 01:32:06.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If the permit program goes away, what fund is absorbing that deficit?

885
01:32:07.942 --> 01:32:10.293
<v Unidentified speaker>So that is the— that's the whole sign program.

886
01:32:10.537 --> 01:32:10.765
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

887
01:32:11.760 --> 01:32:24.818
<v Unidentified speaker>So actually, if we got rid of this permitting program for A-Boards, it would've prevented last year adding $7,397 to the reserve account.

888
01:32:24.881 --> 01:32:35.713
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should know that we have a broader problem than just A-Boards in terms of the sign program and its ability to self-maintain.

889
01:32:35.842 --> 01:32:37.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we're subsidizing that elsewhere.

890
01:32:37.242 --> 01:32:40.588
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Where without this, we take away part of that problem?

891
01:32:41.890 --> 01:32:42.099
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

892
01:32:42.324 --> 01:32:42.453
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

893
01:32:42.502 --> 01:32:46.891
<v Unidentified speaker>Without being an expert on the deficit, reserve deficit, I would say yes.

894
01:32:47.472 --> 01:32:47.649
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

895
01:32:48.440 --> 01:32:57.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then you said on slide 6 that this maintains penalties for violations under the transportation fee schedule.

896
01:32:59.756 --> 01:33:03.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I assume the penalties for violations were elsewhere in code before.

897
01:33:04.770 --> 01:33:10.948
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are the penalty levels themselves changing or are we just moving where those penalties are located?

898
01:33:11.819 --> 01:33:20.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Should businesses expect that costs, if they are out of compliance and don't correct the issue and it goes to a penalty, are going up, going down, or staying the same?

899
01:33:22.180 --> 01:33:34.877
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would expect that similar to how currently A-Boards are regulated, The work would be to resolve the issue without a citation first.

900
01:33:35.444 --> 01:33:40.965
<v Unidentified speaker>And then I forgot to print out the transportation fee schedule and bring it with me.

901
01:33:42.462 --> 01:33:46.747
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it's comparable, but I can get back to you with that information.

902
01:33:48.542 --> 01:33:52.265
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it would be helpful to know if there's a major change.

903
01:33:52.345 --> 01:33:54.762
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm happy to wait until we get to full council.

904
01:33:54.827 --> 01:33:59.345
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I also see our PBOT director coming up good afternoon.

905
01:33:59.409 --> 01:34:01.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>Millicent Williams, Director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

906
01:34:01.658 --> 01:34:04.820
<v Eric Zimmerman>Dan Barton is also here in chambers today.

907
01:34:05.109 --> 01:34:07.198
<v Eric Zimmerman>He is our code compliance officer.

908
01:34:07.920 --> 01:34:16.766
<v Eric Zimmerman>He has, I believe, at the request of several councilors even seated here today, gone to community to help to support problem solving before a fee is assessed.

909
01:34:17.216 --> 01:34:26.274
<v Eric Zimmerman>However, the fees, if there were any, would not be an increase to what is already published regarding correcting the issues.

910
01:34:26.707 --> 01:34:30.612
<v Eric Zimmerman>The violation fee would not be any higher than it currently is.

911
01:34:31.046 --> 01:34:41.006
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we do work pretty tirelessly to ensure that we're not passing on onerous or unreasonable or even reasonable fees when we can solve the problem.

912
01:34:41.970 --> 01:34:42.372
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

913
01:34:42.630 --> 01:34:49.201
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd just like to make sure we don't have an unexpected shock a few years from now when we find out that fees have gone up.

914
01:34:49.667 --> 01:34:56.988
<v Eric Zimmerman>Many times we're working with business owners for many months prior to even those fees being assessed.

915
01:34:57.390 --> 01:35:04.582
<v Eric Zimmerman>So from time to time, there may be people who are surprised by a fee given perhaps the relationship with the property.

916
01:35:04.775 --> 01:35:14.779
<v Eric Zimmerman>If they're a renter of the property or a leaser, lessee of a property versus property owner, and we've been in contact with one or the other, there may be a surprise.

917
01:35:15.052 --> 01:35:25.594
<v Eric Zimmerman>But typically it's been months, uh, that we've worked with, uh, properties and businesses to ensure that they are aware of what's happening and what the potential consequence could be to failure to comply.

918
01:35:26.462 --> 01:35:26.807
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

919
01:35:27.202 --> 01:35:28.104
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

920
01:35:30.000 --> 01:35:36.106
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, any other questions, um, for anybody from the PBOT team or for Spencer?

921
01:35:38.113 --> 01:35:42.355
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, seeing none.

922
01:35:42.567 --> 01:35:46.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would— oh, do we have public testimony on this item?

923
01:35:46.243 --> 01:35:48.877
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I didn't see any signed up, but has there been any last minute?

924
01:35:49.657 --> 01:35:50.319
<v Unidentified speaker>No one signed up.

925
01:35:50.966 --> 01:35:51.354
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

926
01:35:52.340 --> 01:35:57.368
<v Unidentified speaker>Because there's no public testimony, I will say we took this to all the business districts and asked for their feedback.

927
01:35:57.417 --> 01:36:03.108
<v Unidentified speaker>So we did do some community engagement on it, and their reaction was pretty much, sure, yeah.

928
01:36:03.578 --> 01:36:05.851
<v Eric Zimmerman>Their reaction was, we don't follow it anyway, so thanks.

929
01:36:05.949 --> 01:36:05.997
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

930
01:36:06.382 --> 01:36:06.851
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, pretty much.

931
01:36:07.255 --> 01:36:09.630
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's why your collections are difficult.

932
01:36:09.694 --> 01:36:18.764
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, I look forward to Councilor Novick mitigating or mediating the upcoming A-board sign wars of some neighborhood at one time, whenever it happens.

933
01:36:18.828 --> 01:36:20.253
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we should still pass it.

934
01:36:20.367 --> 01:36:21.500
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'd motion to move this forward.

935
01:36:22.090 --> 01:36:22.349
<v Dan Ryan>Second.

936
01:36:22.836 --> 01:36:23.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Fantastic.

937
01:36:24.541 --> 01:36:29.864
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, could Wendy— could you— oh wait, Diana, could you please call the roll?

938
01:36:31.492 --> 01:36:32.189
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Little swap out here.

939
01:36:32.871 --> 01:36:36.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, so just to confirm, Moved by Zimmerman and seconded by Ryan?

940
01:36:36.975 --> 01:36:37.564
<v Devin Mullins>Correct.

941
01:36:37.972 --> 01:36:38.838
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All right, thank you very much.

942
01:36:40.476 --> 01:36:40.622
<v Dan Ryan>Ryan?

943
01:36:41.108 --> 01:36:41.155
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

944
01:36:42.095 --> 01:36:42.484
<v Candace Avalos>Murillo?

945
01:36:43.373 --> 01:36:43.422
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

946
01:36:44.101 --> 01:36:44.442
<v Eric Zimmerman>Zimmerman?

947
01:36:44.750 --> 01:36:44.797
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

948
01:36:45.574 --> 01:36:45.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos?

949
01:36:46.207 --> 01:36:46.368
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

950
01:36:46.708 --> 01:36:47.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney?

951
01:36:47.502 --> 01:36:47.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

952
01:36:48.635 --> 01:36:59.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With 5 ayes, the motion to refer Ordinance Document Number 2026-174 to Council with a recommendation to be passed has passed.

953
01:37:00.078 --> 01:37:01.055
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

954
01:37:04.087 --> 01:37:06.960
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Diana, could you please read items 4 and 5?

955
01:37:07.024 --> 01:37:08.648
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe we're opening these together.

956
01:37:10.630 --> 01:37:29.556
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 4, authorize a cable franchise fund for the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability to support the collection of public education and government revenues and management cable franchise Work related to intergovernmental agreements with jurisdictions.

957
01:37:30.557 --> 01:37:38.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item 4, amend City Code to reflect the dissolution of the Mount Hood Cable Regulatory Commission.

958
01:37:39.024 --> 01:37:44.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Amend City Code Chapters 3.33 and 3.115.

959
01:37:46.355 --> 01:37:47.110
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

960
01:37:47.239 --> 01:37:59.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, we have 2 folks from the administration here to help us understand what we're doing today, and I believe Andrew Spear is going to kick us off, is that right?

961
01:38:00.081 --> 01:38:01.317
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, okay, kick us off.

962
01:38:01.365 --> 01:38:02.039
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Hi, perfect.

963
01:38:02.087 --> 01:38:02.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I apologize.

964
01:38:03.613 --> 01:38:04.850
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, thank you for having us today.

965
01:38:05.220 --> 01:38:09.779
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Seema Gadkumar, Chief of Community Technology for the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

966
01:38:10.679 --> 01:38:23.109
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, in light of the fact that the MHCRC is going to dissolve at the end of our fiscal year, June 30th, 2026, we are here to present 2 ordinances for your consideration.

967
01:38:23.685 --> 01:38:31.565
<v Unidentified speaker>The first ordinance seeks to amend Portland City Code Chapters 3.33 and 3.115.

968
01:38:32.046 --> 01:38:45.060
<v Unidentified speaker>The intention of these amendments is to effectively transfer existing MHCRC responsibilities concerning cable franchise oversight and management back to the City of Portland.

969
01:38:45.447 --> 01:38:58.402
<v Unidentified speaker>This is essentially a housekeeping/administrative update that's necessary to implement so that the city can effectively assume those cable franchise functionalities as the commission is going to dissolve at the end of our fiscal year.

970
01:38:59.077 --> 01:39:05.310
<v Unidentified speaker>The second ordinance seeks to establish a new cable franchise fund, Fund 234.

971
01:39:05.744 --> 01:39:20.269
<v Unidentified speaker>The intention of this, uh, new cable franchise fund is to allow the City of Portland to receive directly its cable franchise revenues and to effectively manage the compliance obligations derived from those cable franchise revenues.

972
01:39:20.703 --> 01:39:31.189
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, the new cable franchise fund will succeed and eventually replace the existing MHCRC Fund 855, considering that the commission is going to dissolve.

973
01:39:32.087 --> 01:39:33.918
<v Unidentified speaker>With that overview, I'll pass it to Andrew Spear.

974
01:39:34.110 --> 01:39:34.560
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

975
01:39:35.524 --> 01:39:36.697
<v Andrew Spear>Hi, good afternoon, councilors.

976
01:39:36.761 --> 01:39:41.546
<v Andrew Spear>My name is Andrew Spear, and I'm the franchise utility program manager within the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

977
01:39:41.819 --> 01:39:47.649
<v Andrew Spear>Just have a short presentation that will go over a little bit more detail than what Seema shared just now in summary.

978
01:39:48.259 --> 01:39:55.805
<v Andrew Spear>You'll recall I was here last month for the cable franchise amendments for Comcast.

979
01:39:55.869 --> 01:39:57.988
<v Andrew Spear>And so these next 2 slides should look familiar.

980
01:39:58.118 --> 01:40:09.871
<v Andrew Spear>But as Seema mentioned, we're going through the process of just closing up all aspects of requirements to dissolve the commission as of the end of this fiscal year.

981
01:40:10.385 --> 01:40:17.667
<v Andrew Spear>And so as part of that, these 2 items are practically required for the City of Portland to administer the cable program, as Seema outlined.

982
01:40:20.112 --> 01:40:22.097
<v Andrew Spear>And then again, this slide you've seen as well.

983
01:40:22.780 --> 01:40:26.426
<v Andrew Spear>We're at the point of the far right item, which is just implementation.

984
01:40:27.000 --> 01:40:32.077
<v Andrew Spear>And so we're practically just carrying out these last remaining items for approval.

985
01:40:32.773 --> 01:40:36.265
<v Andrew Spear>And I think these are the last 2 items that will need council approval.

986
01:40:36.756 --> 01:40:51.856
<v Andrew Spear>And so we're just working through the steps to functionalize here's just an overview of the chapters that we are bringing forward in the first item with the chapter titles.

987
01:40:52.909 --> 01:40:59.576
<v Andrew Spear>So chapter— both chapters just have minor edits, and I'll cover those in small detail next 2 slides.

988
01:40:59.689 --> 01:41:06.850
<v Andrew Spear>But in short, most of the changes are just removing references to the MHCRC and ensuring that Portland is the city that is the owner of the property.

989
01:41:06.917 --> 01:41:07.030
<v Andrew Spear>Thank you.

990
01:41:07.181 --> 01:41:12.453
<v Andrew Spear>The operator in, um, in effectuating the, um, code itself.

991
01:41:15.144 --> 01:41:21.203
<v Andrew Spear>For Chapter, uh, 3.33, you'll see here on the right-hand column, um, those are the changes.

992
01:41:21.398 --> 01:41:25.279
<v Andrew Spear>And again, just removing the references to MHCRC.

993
01:41:25.908 --> 01:41:35.025
<v Andrew Spear>Um, and then there's some other functions or other language edits that just bring in that the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability is the operator of the code.

994
01:41:35.569 --> 01:41:39.581
<v Andrew Spear>Um, and you know, very practical edits here.

995
01:41:41.488 --> 01:41:44.573
<v Andrew Spear>Nothing technical in nature other than just the name change.

996
01:41:45.059 --> 01:41:52.057
<v Andrew Spear>And these edits were included as exhibits into the packet as well for reference if you have the redline open.

997
01:41:55.539 --> 01:42:08.186
<v Andrew Spear>Chapter 3.115, again on the right-hand column, removes references to MHCRC, ensures that cable operators Yes.

998
01:42:08.831 --> 01:42:14.931
<v Andrew Spear>And then that the BPS is the operator of the code to enforce those.

999
01:42:15.511 --> 01:42:29.588
<v Andrew Spear>And then we also— just a technical aspect— as part of Open Signal's work, City of Portland has an opportunity to have board members on Open Signal's board, and those are appointed via the mayor.

1000
01:42:29.814 --> 01:42:34.497
<v Andrew Spear>And so this just retains that right and clarifies it and removes references to the mayor.

1001
01:42:39.676 --> 01:42:48.627
<v Andrew Spear>That concludes the first item, uh, and then we're moving on to the second item, which is the creation of the new fund, uh, post-MHCRC.

1002
01:42:48.771 --> 01:42:57.786
<v Andrew Spear>And again, as Seema mentioned, the 855 fund is the current fund we operate under where cable revenues go into, uh, as part of the MHCRC.

1003
01:42:58.252 --> 01:43:06.845
<v Andrew Spear>With the dissolution, the that fund will no longer be able to be used for Portland proper, and so the creation of a new fund is required.

1004
01:43:07.407 --> 01:43:27.769
<v Andrew Spear>So this is just simply authorizing approval of the new fund, which will then be for Portland-only revenues, and for the city to finish out all the dissolution actions as part of the next 2.5, 3 years with paying out the community technology grants, which have been issued out by the commission.

1005
01:43:28.185 --> 01:43:33.029
<v Andrew Spear>Um, would still have, uh, process and payments to go out over those periods.

1006
01:43:33.318 --> 01:43:46.501
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, just a point of, um, fact, uh, the Fund 855 will likely close towards the end of our calendar year just because there might be residual lingering responsibilities emanating from the closing out of the, the commission.

1007
01:43:46.885 --> 01:43:50.012
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the fund will actually probably close a little bit later than June 30th.

1008
01:43:50.172 --> 01:43:51.070
<v Unidentified speaker>Just a point of clarification.

1009
01:43:51.936 --> 01:43:52.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, go ahead.

1010
01:43:53.220 --> 01:43:56.393
<v Andrew Spear>And then this is a little bit of summary.

1011
01:43:56.649 --> 01:44:00.847
<v Andrew Spear>Again, just wanting to clarify what we're approving and for what.

1012
01:44:01.457 --> 01:44:18.426
<v Andrew Spear>I've mentioned the first 2 bullets, but I think the last bullet here is an aspect of strategy and direction for both the Bureau and the city to consider more generally about what is the use of PEG dollars over time and how do we forecast those PEG dollars.

1013
01:44:18.778 --> 01:44:29.336
<v Andrew Spear>And as the dissolution occurs, The monies that we take in from the MHCRC that are Portland's PEG revenues, what's the use of those funds?

1014
01:44:29.384 --> 01:44:43.458
<v Andrew Spear>So there's a strategic aspect to this, and the creation of the fund will allow those dollars to be held separately from other revenues and comply with all federal and FCC guidance on PEG use and administering of PEG revenues.

1015
01:44:44.519 --> 01:44:49.430
<v Andrew Spear>And with that, that concludes the presentation on my end, and I'm happy to take questions.

1016
01:44:49.510 --> 01:44:49.831
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1017
01:44:52.863 --> 01:44:56.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Diana, do we have anybody signed up for public testimony on either of these items?

1018
01:44:57.524 --> 01:44:58.252
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No one signed up.

1019
01:44:59.109 --> 01:45:04.556
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so colleagues, if there are any comments, questions, or discussion, let's take that at this time.

1020
01:45:10.356 --> 01:45:35.293
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Seeing none, I will say I really appreciate the, um, The staged presentation we've gotten over a couple of committee meetings to ensure that we understand what is happening as this moves through, because these are technical pieces that are necessary and while small in terms of the changes in the text, do have a significant impact for some members of our community.

1021
01:45:35.373 --> 01:45:39.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I appreciate the time you've taken to describe the details in previous meetings.

1022
01:45:40.561 --> 01:45:41.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Did you have a question?

1023
01:45:41.463 --> 01:45:42.132
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, similar.

1024
01:45:42.542 --> 01:45:43.636
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council.

1025
01:45:44.631 --> 01:45:46.658
<v Dan Ryan>You're not Council President, but you are the chair of this committee.

1026
01:45:47.529 --> 01:45:51.887
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you so much, Andrew, for coming back, and it's good to see you.

1027
01:45:52.792 --> 01:45:54.260
<v Dan Ryan>You said this is the last one, right?

1028
01:45:54.814 --> 01:45:56.961
<v Dan Ryan>Like, this is like the 4th update?

1029
01:45:57.751 --> 01:46:01.091
<v Andrew Spear>The last item that requires Council action as part of the dissolution.

1030
01:46:01.220 --> 01:46:05.716
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, I appreciate that you made that clear, and thanks for methodically walking us through it.

1031
01:46:05.899 --> 01:46:06.693
<v Dan Ryan>It's really appreciated.

1032
01:46:07.555 --> 01:46:17.479
<v Dan Ryan>And, uh, it'll be interesting to see how we, uh, use the funds that are going into this new account going forward, and we'll look forward to your leadership to make some suggestions on that.

1033
01:46:18.171 --> 01:46:18.542
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1034
01:46:21.296 --> 01:46:35.371
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, seeing no other discussion, if we feel satisfied with the information and ready to move these forward, I would entertain separate motions to move items 4 and 5 to full I'm so moved.

1035
01:46:35.984 --> 01:46:36.421
<v Dan Ryan>Second.

1036
01:46:36.939 --> 01:46:42.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, and that was moved and seconded by Councilor Ryan and Councilor Morillo on both items, is that correct?

1037
01:46:42.261 --> 01:46:42.423
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1038
01:46:43.152 --> 01:46:46.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, Diana, could you please call the roll?

1039
01:46:47.217 --> 01:46:47.476
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure.

1040
01:46:48.172 --> 01:46:48.643
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Ryan?

1041
01:46:49.387 --> 01:46:49.565
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1042
01:46:50.212 --> 01:46:50.471
<v Eric Zimmerman>Morillo?

1043
01:46:51.731 --> 01:46:51.780
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1044
01:46:52.395 --> 01:46:52.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Zimmerman?

1045
01:46:53.929 --> 01:46:55.140
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, absent?

1046
01:46:55.384 --> 01:46:56.158
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos?

1047
01:46:56.578 --> 01:46:56.676
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1048
01:46:57.725 --> 01:46:58.130
<v Candace Avalos>Pirtle-Guiney?

1049
01:46:58.179 --> 01:46:58.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1050
01:46:58.445 --> 01:46:58.493
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1051
01:46:59.583 --> 01:47:14.514
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With a vote of 4 ayes and 1 absent, the motion to refer both Ordinance Number 2026-175 and 2026-176 to City Council with a recommendation that be passed have passed.

1052
01:47:15.940 --> 01:47:17.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman, would you like to add your vote?

1053
01:47:17.609 --> 01:47:18.827
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was 4 to 0.

1054
01:47:19.533 --> 01:47:19.997
<v Eric Zimmerman>5 To 0.

1055
01:47:21.136 --> 01:47:23.911
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I believe because the vote was called, we need to suspend the rules.

1056
01:47:23.975 --> 01:47:26.819
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there any objection to allowing Councilor Zimmerman to add his vote?

1057
01:47:27.045 --> 01:47:27.301
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1058
01:47:27.608 --> 01:47:27.945
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1059
01:47:28.412 --> 01:47:28.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1060
01:47:29.216 --> 01:47:29.747
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1061
01:47:31.710 --> 01:47:35.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, colleagues, that completes our final item on the agenda today.

1062
01:47:35.509 --> 01:47:36.542
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, you read those 2 together?

1063
01:47:36.719 --> 01:47:37.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We did, yes.

1064
01:47:37.686 --> 01:47:40.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We had a presentation of the 2 together and you moved them together.

1065
01:47:42.050 --> 01:47:43.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We moved them in one item.

1066
01:47:46.546 --> 01:47:47.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We all good on that?

1067
01:47:47.590 --> 01:47:47.769
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1068
01:47:48.078 --> 01:47:48.730
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, absolutely.

1069
01:47:49.073 --> 01:47:49.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

1070
01:47:50.458 --> 01:48:02.057
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, so colleagues, our next At that meeting, we will, as Devin mentioned earlier, hear more about the Driver Resource Center idea.

1071
01:48:02.619 --> 01:48:11.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will be asked to approve a transfer of the franchise agreement for Zenith, which has been bought by a new parent company.

1072
01:48:12.880 --> 01:48:23.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we will hear an ask to extend the lease for the for city kids in one of our city buildings, as well as, of course, have time for public input.

1073
01:48:23.804 --> 01:48:41.564
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I will just mention for members of the community who are listening that that time at the beginning of each of our meetings is for us to hear from you about any item, not just those on the agenda, but anything related to the committee's work more broadly or issues that you'd like us to take up and consider that you haven't seen on our agendas.

1074
01:48:42.221 --> 01:48:49.087
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are happy to hear from people at that time, and, um, I hope that the community will take advantage of that opportunity.

1075
01:48:50.485 --> 01:48:55.010
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If there is nothing else, colleagues, I will adjourn today's meeting.

1076
01:48:55.123 --> 01:48:55.529
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1077
01:48:56.259 --> 01:48:56.404
<v Dan Ryan>Yay!

