WEBVTT

1
00:11:25.956 --> 00:11:27.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, good morning everybody.

2
00:11:28.331 --> 00:11:31.522
<v Jamie Dunphy>Calling to order this welcome to the work session of the Portland City Council.

3
00:11:31.667 --> 00:11:34.985
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is Thursday, May 14th.

4
00:11:35.048 --> 00:11:38.221
<v Jamie Dunphy>Congratulations, friends, this is our final work session of this budget season.

5
00:11:38.269 --> 00:11:39.331
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it's our 13th.

6
00:11:40.182 --> 00:11:48.562
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, this morning we're going to be hearing from the Auditor's Office, we will be hearing from a Public Works service area, and we will also be having a, a presentation on solid waste rates.

7
00:11:48.707 --> 00:11:51.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe I am turning it over to Madam Auditor.

8
00:11:51.214 --> 00:11:52.005
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, welcome.

9
00:11:59.294 --> 00:12:01.650
<v Jamie Dunphy>Apologies to everybody for us starting a little bit late this morning.

10
00:12:02.307 --> 00:12:06.779
<v Simone Reddy>I think Diana is going to advance my slides.

11
00:12:07.196 --> 00:12:09.583
<v Simone Reddy>Um, good aft— good morning.

12
00:12:09.760 --> 00:12:10.625
<v Simone Reddy>It is the morning.

13
00:12:11.202 --> 00:12:15.466
<v Simone Reddy>Um, President Dunphy and councilors, uh, thank you for having me today.

14
00:12:15.850 --> 00:12:23.880
<v Simone Reddy>Um, I'm City Auditor Simone Reddy, and today I'm joined virtually by Chief Deputy City Auditor Reed Brodersen.

15
00:12:25.467 --> 00:12:34.095
<v Simone Reddy>We're here to present my office's budget, which I've requested and the mayor has included in his proposed budget for next fiscal year.

16
00:12:35.120 --> 00:12:46.426
<v Simone Reddy>I'm going to start by providing an overview of the Auditor's Office and our functions, as well as our budget, and I will share with you the approach that I took to developing this request.

17
00:12:47.451 --> 00:12:56.607
<v Simone Reddy>Then I'll hand it over to Chief Deputy Brodersen to get into the details about the cuts and changes that we're making before we answer your questions.

18
00:12:58.225 --> 00:13:08.607
<v Simone Reddy>As a reminder, our city charter requires the auditor to submit a requested budget to the mayor and city council, who are required to consider the auditor's priorities and duties.

19
00:13:09.434 --> 00:13:19.326
<v Simone Reddy>Mayor Wilson, out of respect for my independence and the outcomes that my office ensures, has incorporated my requested budget into his proposed budget without modification.

20
00:13:20.576 --> 00:13:27.980
<v Simone Reddy>And I ask that you adopt my budget without making further cuts beyond those I've consented to, which I'm going to go over with you today.

21
00:13:28.254 --> 00:13:29.658
<v Simone Reddy>So thank you for your consideration.

22
00:13:32.500 --> 00:13:33.273
<v Simone Reddy>2 more slides.

23
00:13:37.870 --> 00:13:39.337
<v Simone Reddy>One more.

24
00:13:40.080 --> 00:13:40.628
<v Simone Reddy>Thank you.

25
00:13:41.370 --> 00:13:47.032
<v Simone Reddy>So the Auditor's Office mission, which I know you're all familiar with, is to ensure open and accountable city government.

26
00:13:47.745 --> 00:13:50.442
<v Simone Reddy>So that all people in Portland experience a sense of belonging.

27
00:13:51.809 --> 00:13:58.018
<v Simone Reddy>Our requested budget for next fiscal year totals 45 FTE and about $14.6 million.

28
00:13:59.669 --> 00:14:00.153
<v Simone Reddy>Next slide.

29
00:14:02.673 --> 00:14:09.522
<v Simone Reddy>The Auditor's Office is organized into 7 divisions that are directly overseen by myself or Chief Deputy Brodersen.

30
00:14:10.748 --> 00:14:26.717
<v Simone Reddy>Our divisions help Portlanders access public records, participate in elections and council business, challenge city decisions, resolve complaints, and understand whether city programs are operating effectively, efficiently, and equitably.

31
00:14:28.115 --> 00:14:37.812
<v Simone Reddy>We also maintain administrative independence, which allows our office to do all of that work without depending on the systems and officials that we are responsible for holding accountable.

32
00:14:38.956 --> 00:14:39.442
<v Simone Reddy>Next slide.

33
00:14:42.937 --> 00:14:52.706
<v Simone Reddy>So my approach for developing this requested budget was really to prioritize legally required work and services and make reductions where possible.

34
00:14:53.892 --> 00:15:02.397
<v Simone Reddy>It uses reserves strategically to avoid deeper disruption and to help the office retain as much of its skilled workforce as it can.

35
00:15:03.850 --> 00:15:11.990
<v Simone Reddy>The result is a budget that that makes cuts and changes responsibly and reflects our shared responsibility to respond to the city's fiscal crisis.

36
00:15:13.011 --> 00:15:13.318
<v Simone Reddy>Next slide.

37
00:15:17.296 --> 00:15:29.018
<v Simone Reddy>The Auditor's Office's greatest asset is our capable staff, and so it's no surprise that personnel is our largest expense at about $9.3 million, or 64% of our budget.

38
00:15:30.677 --> 00:15:36.895
<v Simone Reddy>Therefore, most divisions, which are depicted on this slide, are driven primarily by staffing levels.

39
00:15:38.120 --> 00:15:49.072
<v Simone Reddy>The exceptions are archives and records management and operations management, which carry facility costs for the Portland Archives and Records Center and City Hall office space.

40
00:15:50.517 --> 00:15:54.294
<v Simone Reddy>And those costs total about $2.5 million, or 17% of our budget.

41
00:15:55.461 --> 00:15:55.917
<v Simone Reddy>Next slide.

42
00:15:59.157 --> 00:16:03.874
<v Simone Reddy>As you can see, the office is funded primarily through overhead general funds at about $14.1 million.

43
00:16:06.116 --> 00:16:16.318
<v Simone Reddy>About $250,000 comes from interagency agreements for services provided by our hearings office, and we have about $220,000 in reserves.

44
00:16:18.191 --> 00:16:33.879
<v Simone Reddy>We also receive a small amount of intermittent miscellaneous revenue from sources like reimbursements from Prosper Portland for performance and financial audit work, candidate filing fees, enforcement penalties, and interest earned on the Auditor's Reserve Fund.

45
00:16:34.854 --> 00:16:35.224
<v Simone Reddy>Next slide.

46
00:16:38.710 --> 00:16:47.785
<v Simone Reddy>My requested budget includes roughly $300,000 in additions and $800,000 in reductions from, from the general fund at current service level.

47
00:16:48.774 --> 00:16:51.025
<v Simone Reddy>And Reed is going to walk us through those details shortly.

48
00:16:52.576 --> 00:16:52.994
<v Simone Reddy>Next slide.

49
00:16:56.676 --> 00:17:00.551
<v Simone Reddy>As I mentioned, my requested budget includes 45 FTE.

50
00:17:01.392 --> 00:17:10.499
<v Simone Reddy>And if you adopt the proposed budget as is, 2 divisions, Audit Services and Operations Management, would each lose 1 filled position.

51
00:17:11.546 --> 00:17:12.045
<v Simone Reddy>Next slide.

52
00:17:17.147 --> 00:17:27.503
<v Simone Reddy>While my requested budget includes cuts, it protects services and outcomes that Portlanders expect from my office, those that build access, trust, and participation in our government.

53
00:17:28.915 --> 00:18:03.461
<v Simone Reddy>That includes administering municipal elections, providing voter education, and enforcing the city's campaign finance laws, preserving the city's history and making it available to city employees and the public, administering city council business and maintaining records of council action, building trust in city spending and programs through financial and performance audits as well as ombudsman and fraud hotline investigations, and providing fast, fair, and impartial adjudication of alleged city code violations.

54
00:18:05.609 --> 00:18:07.087
<v Simone Reddy>Next slide.

55
00:18:09.016 --> 00:18:20.298
<v Simone Reddy>Before I hand it over to Deputy Brodersen to highlight the significant cuts and changes, I want to acknowledge that budget reductions for government accountability offices are not a trend that we like to see.

56
00:18:20.346 --> 00:18:20.605
<v Simone Reddy>Thank you.

57
00:18:21.413 --> 00:18:22.996
<v Simone Reddy>But one that we humbly accept.

58
00:18:24.259 --> 00:18:33.061
<v Simone Reddy>We recognize that our independence, which raises the standard for conduct in our office, does not make us immune to changes that are facing our jurisdiction.

59
00:18:34.300 --> 00:18:35.571
<v Simone Reddy>We must be responsive to them.

60
00:18:36.875 --> 00:18:39.545
<v Simone Reddy>And now I would like Reed to go over the details with you.

61
00:18:41.811 --> 00:18:42.457
<v Reed Brodersen>Thank you, everybody.

62
00:18:43.489 --> 00:18:45.730
<v Reed Brodersen>Good morning, Council President Dunphy and councilors.

63
00:18:45.858 --> 00:18:46.761
<v Reed Brodersen>Appreciate the time.

64
00:18:47.584 --> 00:18:48.546
<v Reed Brodersen>My name is Reed Brodersen.

65
00:18:48.807 --> 00:18:51.826
<v Reed Brodersen>I use he and him pronouns, and I'm Chief Deputy City Auditor.

66
00:18:53.220 --> 00:18:59.455
<v Reed Brodersen>Before I get into the weeds, I'd be remiss to not at least acknowledge the human impact of this requested budget.

67
00:19:01.200 --> 00:19:06.057
<v Reed Brodersen>We are, like the auditor already mentioned, we do propose to lay off 2 existing staff.

68
00:19:07.200 --> 00:19:16.237
<v Reed Brodersen>And while we're not suggesting this is avoidable, and I don't envy council's job in decision-making, I at least wanted to start with the people behind the numbers before we get into the details.

69
00:19:17.540 --> 00:19:18.539
<v Reed Brodersen>If we could move to the next slide, please.

70
00:19:21.400 --> 00:19:29.114
<v Reed Brodersen>Okay, our first cut eliminates a filled Performance Auditor 2 position, which would result in fewer performance audits completed.

71
00:19:30.352 --> 00:19:39.516
<v Reed Brodersen>As a reminder, authority for the selection of audit areas resides solely with the auditor, and the loss of a performance auditor means adding less to the annual audit plan.

72
00:19:39.580 --> 00:19:39.726
<v Reed Brodersen>Thank you.

73
00:19:40.044 --> 00:19:41.318
<v Reed Brodersen>Which is published each June.

74
00:19:42.577 --> 00:19:43.248
<v Reed Brodersen>Next slide, please.

75
00:19:45.986 --> 00:19:51.236
<v Reed Brodersen>Our second cut eliminates a filled Administrative Specialist 2 position within operations management.

76
00:19:52.201 --> 00:19:59.105
<v Reed Brodersen>This position provides human resources and finance support, and its loss will slow our processes in both of these areas.

77
00:20:01.006 --> 00:20:01.770
<v Reed Brodersen>Next slide, please.

78
00:20:04.810 --> 00:20:08.669
<v Reed Brodersen>Our third and final set of cuts reduces external materials and services budgets.

79
00:20:09.767 --> 00:20:26.114
<v Reed Brodersen>This includes eliminating budgets for equity training and facilitation and other office-wide strategic initiatives, reducing budgets for advertising as well as nonessential software, and finally bringing operating budgets into alignment with historic spending levels.

80
00:20:27.910 --> 00:20:28.609
<v Reed Brodersen>Next slide, please.

81
00:20:32.509 --> 00:20:35.107
<v Reed Brodersen>Our requested budget also does include 2 addition packages.

82
00:20:36.635 --> 00:20:43.755
<v Reed Brodersen>The first, totaling about $106,000, is required to implement the labor agreement that council ratified on April 29th.

83
00:20:44.851 --> 00:20:51.951
<v Reed Brodersen>This increase to personnel budgets ensures the office can meet its obligations to represent its staff, of which there are 30 in the office.

84
00:20:53.497 --> 00:21:01.438
<v Reed Brodersen>The second adds $190,000 in one-time funding to elections for our contracted voter education services.

85
00:21:01.912 --> 00:21:03.969
<v Reed Brodersen>Provided by community-based organizations.

86
00:21:05.527 --> 00:21:12.974
<v Reed Brodersen>Though election cycles span 2 years, most voter education, of course, occurs in the summer and fall of election years.

87
00:21:13.993 --> 00:21:25.093
<v Reed Brodersen>So with that in mind, the office planned to underspend these funds in fiscal year '25-'26, the current fiscal year, and carry them forward into fiscal year '26-'27.

88
00:21:26.270 --> 00:21:38.935
<v Reed Brodersen>Since it's our understanding that any encumbrance carryforward tool may not be available through the fall bump this year, We were asked to request this previously budgeted but unspent funds as an add package for next year's budget.

89
00:21:40.865 --> 00:21:41.477
<v Reed Brodersen>Next slide, please.

90
00:21:44.702 --> 00:21:50.573
<v Reed Brodersen>Finally, our requested budget draws from the Auditor's Reserve Fund to mitigate deeper service impacts to Portlanders.

91
00:21:51.662 --> 00:21:59.876
<v Reed Brodersen>The Reserve Fund was established through a fiscal year 2019-2020 budget note and is replenished through Auditor's Office underspend.

92
00:22:00.554 --> 00:22:02.364
<v Reed Brodersen>Up to a cap of $500,000.

93
00:22:04.105 --> 00:22:13.369
<v Reed Brodersen>Our use of the fund demonstrates its purpose, which is to allow the auditor to independently manage urgent or emergent budget needs, such as the current fiscal crisis.

94
00:22:14.849 --> 00:22:23.940
<v Reed Brodersen>Our draw next fiscal year would deplete the fund by 44%, leaving enough, we believe, to help us manage what is expected to be a multi-year crisis.

95
00:22:25.695 --> 00:22:26.042
<v Reed Brodersen>Next slide.

96
00:22:26.174 --> 00:22:26.340
<v Reed Brodersen>Thank you.

97
00:22:28.248 --> 00:22:35.663
<v Reed Brodersen>So I'd like to thank you all for your consideration of Auditor's priorities and duties and reiterate her ask to adopt the requested budget without further cuts.

98
00:22:36.991 --> 00:22:40.258
<v Reed Brodersen>And with that, Auditor Reddy and I are available to answer your questions.

99
00:22:40.612 --> 00:22:45.519
<v Reed Brodersen>And we're also joined by our Business Operations Manager, Rosie McGowan, who can help us get into the weeds if we need to.

100
00:22:46.339 --> 00:22:46.696
<v Reed Brodersen>Thank you.

101
00:22:47.671 --> 00:22:48.451
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

102
00:22:50.681 --> 00:22:53.636
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we're now going to move into discussion and conversation.

103
00:22:54.726 --> 00:23:02.222
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have about 20 minutes or so for this section, so I'm going to try and hold councilors to 5 minutes again as normal.

104
00:23:02.366 --> 00:23:03.651
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane, take us away.

105
00:23:03.875 --> 00:23:04.790
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks, Council President.

106
00:23:05.175 --> 00:23:09.462
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to start by saying how proud I am that Portland has an elected independent auditor.

107
00:23:09.751 --> 00:23:10.602
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Not all cities do.

108
00:23:11.436 --> 00:23:18.788
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Kanal and I, we recently met an elected independent auditor in New York State, and he was very excited to hear that we have one in Portland.

109
00:23:19.222 --> 00:23:21.005
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This structure is very important.

110
00:23:21.133 --> 00:23:28.385
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Portlanders voted themselves to reinforce this importance when they approved stronger independence for the Auditor's Office.

111
00:23:29.557 --> 00:23:37.083
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You know, Portlanders have made it clear that accountability, transparency, independence, oversight— those are really core democratic values in our city.

112
00:23:37.901 --> 00:23:51.122
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So, Auditor, first I want to ask candidly, can you explain what— do you see efficiencies or reductions that you believe can be reasonably made in the office, in your office, without materially impacting the mission?

113
00:23:51.474 --> 00:24:04.705
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Like, is there fat to trim, as people often say, or are these proposed reductions really going to meaningfully affect the office's ability to do things like audits, investigations, oversight, accountability work?

114
00:24:04.786 --> 00:24:05.941
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can you outline that a little bit?

115
00:24:07.208 --> 00:24:14.986
<v Simone Reddy>So I think— I'm not sure which slide where we outline some of those cuts, but we are trying to get rid of any nonessential software.

116
00:24:15.932 --> 00:24:26.773
<v Simone Reddy>There are certain materials and internal services charges that we can't avoid, particularly associated with maintaining the Archives and Records Center on PSU's campus.

117
00:24:26.854 --> 00:24:33.201
<v Simone Reddy>There's very specialized costs and needs associated with preserving and documenting our city's history.

118
00:24:35.162 --> 00:24:44.779
<v Simone Reddy>So I think we have done our finest job of looking for efficiencies outside of the personnel costs, which again make up the majority of our expenses.

119
00:24:44.827 --> 00:24:44.974
<v Simone Reddy>Thank you.

120
00:24:46.833 --> 00:24:50.069
<v Simone Reddy>And I would invite my deputy to add any more to that response.

121
00:24:52.440 --> 00:24:54.538
<v Reed Brodersen>Yeah, thank you for the question, Councilor and Auditor.

122
00:24:56.121 --> 00:24:57.105
<v Reed Brodersen>I would tend to agree.

123
00:24:57.219 --> 00:25:02.367
<v Reed Brodersen>Our EMS cuts, I think, pretty minimally impact services to Portlanders.

124
00:25:02.546 --> 00:25:10.886
<v Reed Brodersen>I think we eventually would want to rebuild some funds there to support staff development, particularly around anti-racism equity and facilitation in that space.

125
00:25:12.661 --> 00:25:20.836
<v Reed Brodersen>In terms of personnel, you know, I do think we are looking at a multi-year rebuild plan, particularly for the auditor position.

126
00:25:21.109 --> 00:25:25.028
<v Reed Brodersen>That is a material loss of a service, right?

127
00:25:25.108 --> 00:25:28.433
<v Reed Brodersen>That is an auditor of a few who deliver that work.

128
00:25:29.623 --> 00:25:34.859
<v Reed Brodersen>So that is— that would be a temporary loss as we look to rebuild in the future.

129
00:25:35.566 --> 00:25:35.983
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

130
00:25:36.127 --> 00:25:47.474
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>With those positions, those FTE proposed to be cut, what work could we expect to be delayed or minimized or have to be set aside if those proposed cuts happen?

131
00:25:48.387 --> 00:25:49.237
<v Simone Reddy>Thanks for that question.

132
00:25:49.286 --> 00:25:57.746
<v Simone Reddy>So with the elimination of the performance audit position, that role is responsible for completing performance audits from the annual schedule.

133
00:25:58.563 --> 00:26:00.148
<v Simone Reddy>We publish that schedule every June.

134
00:26:00.244 --> 00:26:09.707
<v Simone Reddy>So it essentially means adding less to that because we probably, I would guess, complete one less audit every 2 years with the loss of that position.

135
00:26:10.692 --> 00:26:21.193
<v Simone Reddy>It would not affect our ability to continue our charter-mandated responsibility of the annual financial audits of results that I've presented to you each year.

136
00:26:23.237 --> 00:26:23.589
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

137
00:26:23.880 --> 00:26:29.374
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And can you or Mr. Mayor explain how the reduction scenarios came about?

138
00:26:29.438 --> 00:26:37.432
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Was this similar to the other bureaus, other service areas that were asked or did this come from the Auditor's Office?

139
00:26:37.721 --> 00:26:39.548
<v Keith Wilson>Yeah, Councilor, I appreciate this conversation.

140
00:26:39.644 --> 00:26:45.638
<v Keith Wilson>I think Auditor Reddy would agree it was very difficult conversations we've had for probably 4 months.

141
00:26:46.376 --> 00:26:51.233
<v Keith Wilson>The good thing is that she came forward with the hard and important work already done.

142
00:26:51.826 --> 00:26:56.202
<v Keith Wilson>And so she came into my office and said, we recognize the difficulties that the city's facing.

143
00:26:56.859 --> 00:27:04.369
<v Keith Wilson>Here's what I think my department could reasonably and that at that point I couldn't accept it because the guidance was 10%.

144
00:27:05.288 --> 00:27:12.002
<v Keith Wilson>And so she went and did hard work and explained that it was gonna have a material effect on her department if she took a cut that deep.

145
00:27:13.201 --> 00:27:19.826
<v Keith Wilson>We held off, we worked on the budget, and in the end we ended up with about a 4%, which certainly wasn't something she wanted.

146
00:27:20.067 --> 00:27:26.464
<v Keith Wilson>But in the end, she recognizes that being a part of the jurisdiction is—.

147
00:27:26.513 --> 00:27:27.141
<v Jonas Biery>It's important.

148
00:27:28.757 --> 00:27:39.777
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, just to be really crystal clear, the auditor came to the executive branch saying, we'd like to show you the 10% cuts, or that's something that you asked of the auditor's office?

149
00:27:39.840 --> 00:27:44.419
<v Keith Wilson>Yeah, the guidance was a 3 and a 7, ostensibly would be a 10.

150
00:27:44.468 --> 00:27:44.950
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>From your office.

151
00:27:45.865 --> 00:27:57.624
<v Keith Wilson>And she proactively came with the 3 and said, I can deliver, with all due respect, auditor, I don't wanna put words in your mouth at all, but she said, you know, I can deliver my charter mandate at this level.

152
00:27:58.154 --> 00:28:04.147
<v Keith Wilson>And then at that point, I had to say I can't accept it because of the challenges we were facing writ large.

153
00:28:04.276 --> 00:28:07.682
<v Keith Wilson>And then we went to work to try and get as close to that as possible.

154
00:28:07.730 --> 00:28:09.272
<v Keith Wilson>And I think we achieved that.

155
00:28:09.883 --> 00:28:31.426
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Mr. Mayor, I would love for you to talk a little bit more because I do have some structural concerns because I believe the independence of all the different bodies are important because I believe you did not ask council to prepare reduction scenarios for our offices, but it was asked of the independently elected Auditor's Office.

156
00:28:31.474 --> 00:28:33.082
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can you explain a little bit the difference there?

157
00:28:33.628 --> 00:28:35.332
<v Keith Wilson>Yeah, you're right.

158
00:28:35.413 --> 00:28:43.156
<v Keith Wilson>As far as council, I trust the 12 councilors as the budget writing committee to be responsible to their own budgets.

159
00:28:43.366 --> 00:28:46.575
<v Keith Wilson>The auditor is under the mayor's purview as far as setting the budget.

160
00:28:47.126 --> 00:28:57.846
<v Keith Wilson>And the auditor and I have a close relationship, and we've worked together over this last year, uh, certainly in the trenches this last 4 months in particular on her budget.

161
00:29:00.531 --> 00:29:10.065
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, well, I just want to note, while public trust in the government is fragile these days, I do think it's very important that we have strong independent oversight.

162
00:29:10.340 --> 00:29:22.931
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm especially concerned about the cut of those FTE, and I'm looking to see about how as a council we can make sure that we can restore those at some point, hopefully in this budget.

163
00:29:23.837 --> 00:29:28.130
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think they're really important to the integrity of our form of government.

164
00:29:28.589 --> 00:29:33.867
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And just to be clear, this is not something that anyone from the Auditor's Office is directly asking of me.

165
00:29:34.174 --> 00:29:41.848
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>From the beginning, when I saw that they were being asked to provide these cut scenarios but council wasn't, I had those concerns coming up for months.

166
00:29:41.993 --> 00:29:42.316
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

167
00:29:43.201 --> 00:29:44.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

168
00:29:44.440 --> 00:29:45.116
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

169
00:29:47.000 --> 00:29:47.258
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

170
00:29:47.306 --> 00:29:53.948
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is a tough one for some of those audit cuts and performance, so I appreciate you coming forward and helping us kind of see how this goes.

171
00:29:55.476 --> 00:30:02.637
<v Eric Zimmerman>I share some concerns with Councilor Koyama Lane in terms of, you know, an independent elected office.

172
00:30:02.767 --> 00:30:14.117
<v Eric Zimmerman>I wanted to talk a little bit about the the elections office with the changes that are going on, and it remains a little fuzzy for me, right?

173
00:30:14.569 --> 00:30:19.621
<v Eric Zimmerman>The Secretary of State conducts elections, then the county elections offices conduct elections.

174
00:30:20.561 --> 00:30:29.161
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think any of the other cities inside Multnomah County, and a lot of cities outside of, of Portland, don't have their own elections office.

175
00:30:29.258 --> 00:30:31.699
<v Eric Zimmerman>So can we talk a little bit?

176
00:30:31.907 --> 00:30:43.790
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is it a, is it a core service when the county also does elections, or what is the reason other cities don't have an elections office?

177
00:30:43.839 --> 00:30:58.400
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm trying to understand what, what happens at our level that is different than if we were to just pay Multnomah County to, to do elections on our behalf, which I think is how other cities and water bureaus and and school districts do it.

178
00:30:58.480 --> 00:30:59.998
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was hoping to talk a little bit about that.

179
00:31:00.191 --> 00:31:00.949
<v Simone Reddy>Yeah, thanks for that.

180
00:31:03.250 --> 00:31:16.333
<v Simone Reddy>I think what's unique, I guess going back to this point that Councilor Koyama Lane made about accountability and oversight, a big part of our muscle is our ability to enforce the city's campaign finance laws.

181
00:31:16.689 --> 00:31:21.334
<v Simone Reddy>And that is a specific regime that Portlanders voted into law.

182
00:31:22.140 --> 00:31:24.355
<v Simone Reddy>That we are uniquely responsible for overseeing.

183
00:31:26.756 --> 00:31:39.741
<v Simone Reddy>I can't speak to the other jurisdictions, but for the City of Portland, that is a unique function that is citywide and is our responsibility in the Auditor's Office to oversee those.

184
00:31:39.855 --> 00:32:08.878
<v Simone Reddy>So where we have increased our budget and filled vacancies is to make sure that we have enough staff to oversee elections, including implementing ranked-choice voting and educating voters about how that system works, as well as making sure that we have enough staff to enforce the laws with a larger number of elected officials in the new form of government and the number of candidates that are vying for those positions.

185
00:32:09.650 --> 00:32:13.856
<v Eric Zimmerman>So Multnomah County has an election finance limit as well?

186
00:32:16.018 --> 00:32:19.779
<v Eric Zimmerman>Do you know who enforces their campaign finance laws?

187
00:32:19.973 --> 00:32:20.781
<v Eric Zimmerman>I actually don't.

188
00:32:21.023 --> 00:32:21.960
<v Simone Reddy>I don't know.

189
00:32:22.074 --> 00:32:25.012
<v Simone Reddy>I don't know if Chief Deputy Brodersen has the answer to that question.

190
00:32:26.819 --> 00:32:32.498
<v Reed Brodersen>I think it might— I think our elections manager Deborah Scroggin is in the audience and maybe be able to best answer that.

191
00:32:36.336 --> 00:32:37.114
<v Deborah Scroggin>Good morning, councilors.

192
00:32:37.453 --> 00:32:38.005
<v Deborah Scroggin>Good question.

193
00:32:38.750 --> 00:32:40.582
<v Deborah Scroggin>Multnomah County Elections enforces that law.

194
00:32:42.873 --> 00:32:49.589
<v Deborah Scroggin>I will note, and I think that they would agree, that they have not seen a lot of complaints or action compared with the city.

195
00:32:51.876 --> 00:32:58.320
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, I think there's— it's because there's this more straightforward— it's you just can't take more than $603, right?

196
00:32:58.530 --> 00:33:00.361
<v Deborah Scroggin>Maybe that's actually a very similar law.

197
00:33:00.878 --> 00:33:04.020
<v Deborah Scroggin>Okay, passed and proposed by some of the same folks.

198
00:33:04.604 --> 00:33:05.153
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks.

199
00:33:05.202 --> 00:33:09.413
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if we were to adopt this ordinance, If we didn't do it, who would do it?

200
00:33:09.461 --> 00:33:17.059
<v Eric Zimmerman>Does it fall— because elections fall under the Secretary of State's purview, does that then trickle down, or do we like pay for like almost like a contracted service?

201
00:33:17.155 --> 00:33:18.615
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not sure how that would work.

202
00:33:18.694 --> 00:33:26.422
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or is it incumbent upon any jurisdiction that puts a campaign limit on themselves that they then have to create an enforcement division?

203
00:33:26.549 --> 00:33:27.768
<v Deborah Scroggin>I don't actually understand.

204
00:33:28.153 --> 00:33:28.442
<v Eric Zimmerman>That one.

205
00:33:28.617 --> 00:33:28.761
<v Priya Dhanapal>That one.

206
00:33:28.826 --> 00:33:29.019
<v Reed Brodersen>Okay.

207
00:33:29.434 --> 00:33:37.233
<v Deborah Scroggin>We are in charge of enforcing our own laws, and in fact to the city charter states that the city auditor will enforce that campaign finance law that voters passed.

208
00:33:37.538 --> 00:33:37.844
<v Eric Zimmerman>Got it.

209
00:33:37.955 --> 00:33:47.108
<v Eric Zimmerman>So the school district who has unlimited giving, if they were to limit their contributions, for instance, they'd have to create a similar type of structure then.

210
00:33:47.189 --> 00:33:47.991
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, that's really helpful.

211
00:33:48.682 --> 00:33:55.730
<v Eric Zimmerman>My next question was around, it looks like about a $200,000 increase for voter education.

212
00:33:57.127 --> 00:34:00.402
<v Eric Zimmerman>Now, I'm all for it, right?

213
00:34:00.482 --> 00:34:04.083
<v Eric Zimmerman>'24 was challenging for everybody to learn and I think it's really good.

214
00:34:04.212 --> 00:34:19.251
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm trying to just put some comparison tools in place, but unfortunately this open book program doesn't give me squat when it comes to what did that program look like in '24 and how much did we spend in the '24 cycle and how's this look?

215
00:34:19.317 --> 00:34:24.456
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because $200 is right now just a number with no context.

216
00:34:24.505 --> 00:34:24.554
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

217
00:34:25.248 --> 00:34:31.692
<v Eric Zimmerman>And since the elections are about to be half the size, I'm just kind of curious, what's that program look like moving forward and how do we use it?

218
00:34:33.795 --> 00:34:39.882
<v Deborah Scroggin>I think we have a mandate in city charter to conduct voter education campaigns to educate Portlanders on ranked choice voting.

219
00:34:41.043 --> 00:34:45.264
<v Deborah Scroggin>And so this is approximately the same, a little less than we did in 2024.

220
00:34:46.135 --> 00:34:58.264
<v Deborah Scroggin>We know that the second year after the second election after implementing a reform reform like ranked choice voting is an incredibly important year because you don't get as much media attention and it's not as much in the news.

221
00:34:59.163 --> 00:35:02.112
<v Deborah Scroggin>And so you can see a drop-off in voter participation and understanding.

222
00:35:02.626 --> 00:35:13.210
<v Deborah Scroggin>And so our goal is to make sure that all Portlanders feel comfortable voting their ballot, and the money that is requested is actually an underspend of this year's because we did budget it.

223
00:35:14.235 --> 00:35:14.492
<v Eric Zimmerman>Got it.

224
00:35:14.556 --> 00:35:23.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>So is that to say that in '24 cycle we had about $200,000 that went out to community groups to do education, or is this—.

225
00:35:24.021 --> 00:35:24.409
<v Deborah Scroggin>Correct.

226
00:35:25.474 --> 00:35:25.795
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

227
00:35:27.813 --> 00:35:28.086
<v Keith Wilson>So—.

228
00:35:28.378 --> 00:35:37.947
<v Deborah Scroggin>There was actually a larger contracted process overseen by United Way and a coalition of folks that did voter education on behalf of, in partnership with the city.

229
00:35:38.333 --> 00:35:38.510
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

230
00:35:39.460 --> 00:35:46.097
<v Eric Zimmerman>All right, so again, just in context, this is the same amount of money as we used in '24 though?

231
00:35:46.847 --> 00:35:50.853
<v Deborah Scroggin>It is a little less because we brought the project management in-house.

232
00:35:51.126 --> 00:35:57.402
<v Deborah Scroggin>We are managing all of that process and the oversight of it ourselves instead of contracting that out like the city did in 2024.

233
00:35:57.949 --> 00:35:58.498
<v Eric Zimmerman>Got it, thanks.

234
00:35:58.610 --> 00:36:04.996
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then a lot of organizations have like multiple branches, but we'll say they're all part of the same organization.

235
00:36:06.860 --> 00:36:20.605
<v Eric Zimmerman>How will the Auditor's Office ensure that the voters' education funding that goes on remains, I'll say, nonpartisan or not connected to groups who then also do endorsements, right?

236
00:36:20.668 --> 00:36:25.728
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because there's the education piece that should be sacred in terms of how to fill out a ballot.

237
00:36:25.807 --> 00:36:27.268
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then there's the advocacy piece.

238
00:36:27.911 --> 00:36:32.599
<v Eric Zimmerman>Sometimes in our community, our community partners do both of those things.

239
00:36:32.648 --> 00:36:36.454
<v Eric Zimmerman>How do we, is there a firewall there or is it kind of loosey-goosey?

240
00:36:37.112 --> 00:36:37.739
<v Deborah Scroggin>No, absolutely.

241
00:36:37.835 --> 00:36:50.440
<v Deborah Scroggin>Our staff are working really closely with these organizations We have only contracted with, proposed contracting with 501s, and there is strong language in our contracts that C4s cannot be engaged in this work.

242
00:36:50.777 --> 00:37:02.675
<v Deborah Scroggin>We also have meetings and work with them very frequently, so we know what they're doing, and we have oversight monitoring built into our contract operations that we expect to be meeting with them.

243
00:37:02.739 --> 00:37:03.735
<v Deborah Scroggin>They have benchmarks.

244
00:37:04.248 --> 00:37:06.030
<v Deborah Scroggin>We know who they're reaching and how they're reaching folks.

245
00:37:06.512 --> 00:37:06.931
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's awesome.

246
00:37:06.996 --> 00:37:09.945
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think they did a great job, frankly, the education.

247
00:37:09.992 --> 00:37:10.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>I mean, it was a challenge.

248
00:37:10.862 --> 00:37:13.923
<v Eric Zimmerman>You guys really put it out there between you guys and Multnomah County.

249
00:37:13.987 --> 00:37:14.922
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we did a good job.

250
00:37:15.739 --> 00:37:30.206
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's a little bit of confusion though when the C3, C4 issue, but it's, let's say, 75% of the same board members and all the names are exactly the same except they put the PAC at the end of one of 'em and not at the other.

251
00:37:30.367 --> 00:37:33.766
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so everybody knows this doesn't pass the smell test.

252
00:37:33.862 --> 00:37:34.106
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

253
00:37:34.739 --> 00:37:48.027
<v Eric Zimmerman>In that situation, would that be something where the Auditor's Office would feel, hey, we've gotta go in deeper, or do we just accept if you're a C3 or C4, we just don't, we see no evil, we know no evil?

254
00:37:48.157 --> 00:37:56.483
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or is it like, eh, this is getting a little too close for comfort of being an advocacy versus, you know, education-focused?

255
00:37:56.724 --> 00:37:58.032
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor, you're at 8 minutes.

256
00:37:58.353 --> 00:37:58.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

257
00:37:59.708 --> 00:38:01.418
<v Deborah Scroggin>I will say that issue has not come up.

258
00:38:01.500 --> 00:38:11.068
<v Deborah Scroggin>We were very closely working with the, the folks that did the transition in 2024, and there was nonprofit contracting, and that just never became an issue.

259
00:38:11.840 --> 00:38:13.141
<v Deborah Scroggin>We did not hear about the issue.

260
00:38:13.590 --> 00:38:17.347
<v Deborah Scroggin>We were closely involved and we didn't see that become a problem, but we're very aware of it.

261
00:38:17.860 --> 00:38:22.277
<v Deborah Scroggin>We've provided trainings to them and we're in constant communication with them about that very strict firewall.

262
00:38:22.661 --> 00:38:22.918
<v Eric Zimmerman>Got it.

263
00:38:23.304 --> 00:38:24.300
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for these answers.

264
00:38:24.364 --> 00:38:25.246
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those are really great.

265
00:38:25.327 --> 00:38:27.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think the firewall is important, so I appreciate it.

266
00:38:27.880 --> 00:38:28.570
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are you the director now?

267
00:38:31.202 --> 00:38:31.251
<v Priya Dhanapal>No?

268
00:38:31.300 --> 00:38:31.998
<v Simone Reddy>Division manager.

269
00:38:32.097 --> 00:38:33.250
<v Eric Zimmerman>Division manager.

270
00:38:33.396 --> 00:38:33.722
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

271
00:38:34.208 --> 00:38:37.262
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a promotion maybe since last time we talked, but congratulations.

272
00:38:37.376 --> 00:38:38.255
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's nice to see you in the seat.

273
00:38:39.070 --> 00:38:39.891
<v Eric Zimmerman>And thank you, Madam Auditor.

274
00:38:39.956 --> 00:38:41.521
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate your time today.

275
00:38:42.005 --> 00:38:43.021
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

276
00:38:43.135 --> 00:38:43.748
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

277
00:38:44.974 --> 00:38:48.233
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

278
00:38:48.297 --> 00:38:49.505
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks to everybody for being here.

279
00:38:49.586 --> 00:38:51.471
<v Sameer Kanal>It's always a pleasure to have the auditor here.

280
00:38:51.583 --> 00:38:53.871
<v Sameer Kanal>I see a lot of the team back there as well.

281
00:38:53.952 --> 00:38:54.659
<v Sameer Kanal>And thanks, Reed, also.

282
00:38:55.771 --> 00:38:59.514
<v Sameer Kanal>Agreed with everything Councilor Koyama Lane said about how nice it is to have an elected auditor.

283
00:38:59.561 --> 00:39:03.222
<v Sameer Kanal>Shout out to Sam Fain in Albany, New York, who's who we met earlier.

284
00:39:03.623 --> 00:39:07.798
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate the framing of the independence and the comment you made before passing it to Reed earlier.

285
00:39:07.894 --> 00:39:12.471
<v Sameer Kanal>I also really support the decision to propose the budget as you've proposed it.

286
00:39:13.097 --> 00:39:23.052
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, in terms of budget decisions, for the same reason, I think my starting point is to support it as is, although I am actually interested in restoring A position, if not both.

287
00:39:25.114 --> 00:39:34.503
<v Sameer Kanal>Slide 8, there's a point about interagency revenue that got added this current fiscal year that would be continued to next year but wasn't there before that.

288
00:39:35.327 --> 00:39:37.072
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to what that is and what it's for?

289
00:39:38.250 --> 00:39:42.443
<v Simone Reddy>Well, it's nearly invisible on the slide because it's so small.

290
00:39:43.583 --> 00:39:44.724
<v Simone Reddy>That's miscellaneous revenue.

291
00:39:44.789 --> 00:39:51.679
<v Simone Reddy>The interagency revenue, I think you see growing because of our becoming home to the hearings office again.

292
00:39:52.659 --> 00:39:53.318
<v Simone Reddy>Okay.

293
00:39:53.702 --> 00:39:55.485
<v Simone Reddy>I believe that's the primary driver there.

294
00:39:56.527 --> 00:39:57.652
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

295
00:39:58.213 --> 00:40:03.704
<v Sameer Kanal>I think you've given information on one of the 2 positions pretty significantly.

296
00:40:03.751 --> 00:40:06.849
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you just give a little more on the audit services one?

297
00:40:07.909 --> 00:40:11.505
<v Sameer Kanal>You're saying that each position is effectively one audit every 2 years.

298
00:40:11.793 --> 00:40:13.061
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that accurate?

299
00:40:13.382 --> 00:40:15.663
<v Simone Reddy>It's a rough, yeah, if I could respond to that.

300
00:40:15.840 --> 00:40:28.608
<v Simone Reddy>So our audit schedule as is, we can only take on a handful of new topics every year 'cause our work is so in-depth and thorough and follows the government standards for performance audits.

301
00:40:30.233 --> 00:40:34.606
<v Simone Reddy>Our audit service team also responds to reports through the fraud hotline.

302
00:40:34.768 --> 00:40:45.253
<v Simone Reddy>So those are projects that land in our lap depending on what concerns are coming from either city employees or the public that are brave and bold enough to bring their concerns to us.

303
00:40:45.302 --> 00:40:45.449
<v Simone Reddy>Thank you.

304
00:40:46.594 --> 00:40:50.652
<v Simone Reddy>That work is also on the plate of Audit Services.

305
00:40:51.471 --> 00:40:57.389
<v Simone Reddy>We also spend time following up on recommendations that we've issued in the last 5 years.

306
00:40:57.630 --> 00:41:06.855
<v Simone Reddy>So that audit impact report that I present to you annually is a way that we are able to hold the city accountable for recommendations that we've made in our audits.

307
00:41:08.313 --> 00:41:15.673
<v Simone Reddy>So it's a rough estimate to say that the reduction of one staff person would mean one less audit every 2 years.

308
00:41:16.748 --> 00:41:31.858
<v Simone Reddy>And again, that is one area unlike the City Elections Division where we are responsible for enforcing the campaign finance laws on strict timelines, as well as our hearings office, which also delivers on strict timelines.

309
00:41:32.916 --> 00:41:43.784
<v Simone Reddy>Performance audits are at my discretion, so we can choose which topics, how in-depth to go, And which areas of the service we're going, or the city we're going to be looking at any given year.

310
00:41:44.713 --> 00:41:45.195
<v Reed Brodersen>Great.

311
00:41:46.221 --> 00:41:52.539
<v Sameer Kanal>For the slide on the EMS reductions, it's a 2-part question.

312
00:41:52.795 --> 00:41:57.349
<v Sameer Kanal>How much of the $215,000 is equity training specifically?

313
00:41:57.621 --> 00:42:03.762
<v Sameer Kanal>And was the decision on reducing equity training framed by the executive order, or was it an independent decision of your office?

314
00:42:04.500 --> 00:42:06.648
<v Simone Reddy>That was an independent decision of my office.

315
00:42:07.568 --> 00:42:17.755
<v Simone Reddy>We have strong commitments at every division and at the office-wide level for advancing results-based accountability initiatives.

316
00:42:19.905 --> 00:42:22.007
<v Simone Reddy>I don't know if we have an exact figure for that.

317
00:42:22.121 --> 00:42:24.282
<v Simone Reddy>If Reid or Rosie could help me with that.

318
00:42:26.650 --> 00:42:29.342
<v Simone Reddy>But the $215,000 is the sum of all of these cuts.

319
00:42:30.969 --> 00:42:33.746
<v Reed Brodersen>Yeah, thank you, Councilor Reid-Brennersen, again.

320
00:42:34.326 --> 00:42:36.188
<v Reed Brodersen>Rosie may be able to answer a little more specifically.

321
00:42:36.349 --> 00:42:41.246
<v Reed Brodersen>I think it was in the ballpark of $50,000, but I may be a little off there.

322
00:42:42.210 --> 00:42:44.697
<v Simone Reddy>Yeah, Rosie McGowan, Business Operations Manager.

323
00:42:45.164 --> 00:42:58.458
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Um, we had a couple contracts that were ending, so it is about, uh, $25,000, um, in specific ones that we had finished some work we would have liked to been able to continue, um, but decided to not continue that training for this next fiscal year.

324
00:42:58.909 --> 00:42:59.550
<v Sameer Kanal>Great, thank you.

325
00:43:00.434 --> 00:43:06.288
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I, I, my last 2 questions, they're kind of, um, it's the same question, but it's about 2 different things.

326
00:43:07.260 --> 00:43:07.934
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a 2-parter.

327
00:43:08.016 --> 00:43:16.157
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, do you think that this is the role of the auditor's office, and/or can you let us know that it's not so that we might be able to do it somewhere else in the city?

328
00:43:16.956 --> 00:43:25.722
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, because, and I'm, I'm just basing this off of, uh, previous auditors had said our discretion as to whether or not this falls into our office's purview.

329
00:43:25.802 --> 00:43:32.563
<v Sameer Kanal>And when they didn't want to do it, uh, do a function, they said you have to— the rest of the city has to find a place to put it.

330
00:43:33.317 --> 00:43:34.856
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'm thinking of IPR specifically.

331
00:43:34.936 --> 00:43:38.349
<v Sameer Kanal>So given that context, I'm asking for 2 different ideas.

332
00:43:38.844 --> 00:43:43.027
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you think each of them is something that's within the auditor's office or not?

333
00:43:43.572 --> 00:43:46.536
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, and based on that, whether or not we could pursue it somewhere else.

334
00:43:46.873 --> 00:43:50.157
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you do believe it's the auditor's function, this is the second part, can you help me set it up?

335
00:43:50.719 --> 00:43:57.586
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm raising these here because I don't think we haven't really had a space to do it, and I can't really until we get back to Committee of the Whole meetings.

336
00:43:57.699 --> 00:44:17.978
<v Sameer Kanal>But first idea is I'd like a way for city employees, rank and file, to anonymously and directly get, or one layer indirectly, get information or suggestions to the mayor and city council without having, especially in the whistleblower context, without having to go through their manager, manager, manager level to get up through 9 layers.

337
00:44:19.277 --> 00:44:27.914
<v Sameer Kanal>This is something that I've seen done in independent offices, or at least through contractors where the contract is held by an independent office in other jurisdictions.

338
00:44:28.827 --> 00:44:38.056
<v Sameer Kanal>The second idea is I'd like to have rank-and-file city employees be able to suggest a way to reduce spending without reduction of service level and be rewarded for it.

339
00:44:38.521 --> 00:44:39.498
<v Sameer Kanal>We have 2 examples.

340
00:44:39.561 --> 00:44:41.693
<v Sameer Kanal>One is the Chief Savings Officers in New York City.

341
00:44:42.206 --> 00:44:51.067
<v Sameer Kanal>The other is the Washington State Secretary of State, which has a Washington State Productivity Productivity Board that has rewarded state employees with up to $10,000 for coming up with ideas.

342
00:44:51.675 --> 00:44:58.838
<v Sameer Kanal>It has led to a savings of over $11 million and revenue increases of $727,000 from 163 proposals.

343
00:44:59.512 --> 00:45:06.257
<v Sameer Kanal>For that just shy of $12 million of net budget improvement, they've paid, quote, in excess of $120,000, end quote.

344
00:45:06.434 --> 00:45:12.666
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's slightly over 1% is the cost for getting that much of a budget improvement.

345
00:45:13.916 --> 00:45:29.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, in each case, anonymous feedback and suggestions and budget, uh, saving ideas— do you believe that this is something that the Auditor's Office should do, can do, or would you let us say that we can do it somewhere else?

346
00:45:30.054 --> 00:45:30.871
<v Sameer Kanal>Is the first question.

347
00:45:30.920 --> 00:45:38.884
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you do believe it's the Auditor's Office, would you be willing to assist me in developing the legislation budget and all that stuff to be able to implement that?

348
00:45:39.092 --> 00:45:40.101
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor, you're at 7 minutes.

349
00:45:40.213 --> 00:45:40.375
<v Loretta Smith>Just—.

350
00:45:40.375 --> 00:45:41.384
<v Sameer Kanal>That's my last question.

351
00:45:41.496 --> 00:45:41.753
<v Reed Brodersen>Great.

352
00:45:41.880 --> 00:45:42.826
<v Simone Reddy>Thank you for the question.

353
00:45:42.873 --> 00:45:46.896
<v Simone Reddy>So there's a few different ways I would approach this.

354
00:45:47.007 --> 00:45:58.161
<v Simone Reddy>I think the first is just to emphasize that my office is a performance audit shop in terms of the performance improvement services that we provide the city.

355
00:45:58.802 --> 00:46:03.193
<v Simone Reddy>That means we're not necessarily looking for budget savings when we take on a topic.

356
00:46:03.528 --> 00:46:11.092
<v Simone Reddy>We might recommend— recommendations for efficiency, but that's not the primary driver because I report directly to the public.

357
00:46:11.302 --> 00:46:23.016
<v Simone Reddy>I'm looking at issues that Portlanders care about, things they voted on, issues where promises might not be kept, and that is a much broader scope than looking for cost savings.

358
00:46:23.755 --> 00:46:30.519
<v Simone Reddy>I would look to my colleague, the city administrator, whose chartered responsibilities are the financial condition of the city.

359
00:46:31.365 --> 00:46:40.496
<v Simone Reddy>For housing a function like that so that my office is not in a position to be making management decisions around the city's finances.

360
00:46:42.769 --> 00:46:44.103
<v Sameer Kanal>And just that, thank you for that.

361
00:46:44.168 --> 00:46:55.847
<v Sameer Kanal>So that I'm going to interpret that as saying there would be no opposition from the Auditor's Office, and I'm asking this because of previous auditors, not because of anything you've done, I want to be clear, to us doing something in the other branches of the government.

362
00:46:57.172 --> 00:47:03.152
<v Simone Reddy>As long as it wouldn't compete with our gold standard of performance auditing in my office, then I wouldn't have an issue with it.

363
00:47:03.489 --> 00:47:03.713
<v Raymond C. Lee>Great.

364
00:47:03.969 --> 00:47:16.539
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the other question was about, uh, the, um, anonymous feedback portion, which has nothing to do with budget, but just the ability to provide information to council and mayor without having to go through managers.

365
00:47:17.195 --> 00:47:22.038
<v Simone Reddy>Well, our, um, other jurisdictions in our region have yeah.

366
00:47:22.103 --> 00:47:22.882
<v Simone Reddy>Fraud hotlines.

367
00:47:22.978 --> 00:47:26.936
<v Simone Reddy>They're branded differently as good governance or ethics hotlines.

368
00:47:28.925 --> 00:47:32.539
<v Simone Reddy>I think we use that tool as an anonymous intake point.

369
00:47:33.961 --> 00:47:42.465
<v Simone Reddy>We protect folks' confidentiality that make reports through that channel, and we're able to refer people elsewhere if their concern doesn't have to do with fraud.

370
00:47:42.577 --> 00:47:50.809
<v Simone Reddy>That's often the service that we're providing, often with the Ombudsman as well, is thank you for this, let us tell you where you can get your need addressed.

371
00:47:52.012 --> 00:47:57.692
<v Simone Reddy>I don't know what the demand for the service that you're proposing would be.

372
00:47:58.012 --> 00:48:05.201
<v Simone Reddy>I know that our— the demand for our services are pretty high right now with complaints to the ombudsman in particular.

373
00:48:06.210 --> 00:48:08.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are at 9:30, so thank you very much, Councilor.

374
00:48:09.885 --> 00:48:20.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we are already over time for this section, so Councilor thank you, Councilor President.

375
00:48:20.820 --> 00:48:31.260
<v Olivia Clark>Most of my questions have already been answered, but I just want to express my appreciation to the auditor and her office for your support with the clerk, and especially for the audits.

376
00:48:31.260 --> 00:48:37.409
<v Olivia Clark>I have used your audits repeatedly in my work from day one, and I really appreciate that.

377
00:48:37.460 --> 00:48:39.940
<v Olivia Clark>If my colleagues have ideas on how to restore the audits, I would love to hear them.

378
00:48:39.940 --> 00:48:39.980
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

379
00:48:41.019 --> 00:48:41.583
<v Olivia Clark>An auditor.

380
00:48:41.664 --> 00:48:45.121
<v Olivia Clark>I'm interested in learning about that and potentially supporting that.

381
00:48:45.766 --> 00:48:50.909
<v Olivia Clark>I just want to make clear that you said we're going to lose one audit per every 2 years.

382
00:48:51.023 --> 00:48:55.208
<v Olivia Clark>How many audits are we expected to perform?

383
00:48:59.181 --> 00:49:04.746
<v Simone Reddy>Um, our audit schedule generally adds 3 topics per year.

384
00:49:05.117 --> 00:49:15.266
<v Simone Reddy>I want to say that we we aim to publish about that in addition to our audit impact report and the fraud hotline investigations that pop up.

385
00:49:16.639 --> 00:49:20.365
<v Simone Reddy>So we might add one less topic for the next biennium.

386
00:49:21.567 --> 00:49:23.277
<v Olivia Clark>So from 3 to 2?

387
00:49:25.478 --> 00:49:26.585
<v Simone Reddy>That's new topics.

388
00:49:27.686 --> 00:49:28.253
<v Olivia Clark>New topics.

389
00:49:28.414 --> 00:49:29.983
<v Olivia Clark>All right, I think that's unfortunate.

390
00:49:30.112 --> 00:49:37.003
<v Olivia Clark>And colleagues, I'm interested in any ideas on how to restore thank you so much, Auditor Reed and staff.

391
00:49:38.192 --> 00:49:41.081
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Clark— Vice President Clark.

392
00:49:41.563 --> 00:49:42.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

393
00:49:42.302 --> 00:49:44.293
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

394
00:49:44.630 --> 00:49:45.592
<v Dan Ryan>Good morning, Madam Auditor.

395
00:49:45.672 --> 00:49:47.664
<v Dan Ryan>It's good to see you and your staff.

396
00:49:49.125 --> 00:49:56.333
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Clark just asked the question about how many per year, 3, and it looks like you'll go to 2 for performance audits.

397
00:49:56.815 --> 00:49:59.896
<v Simone Reddy>Yeah, that would just be new topics that we're adding to the schedule.

398
00:50:01.244 --> 00:50:01.485
<v Raymond C. Lee>Okay.

399
00:50:01.952 --> 00:50:03.445
<v Dan Ryan>Do you ever do performance audits?

400
00:50:03.717 --> 00:50:09.175
<v Dan Ryan>And I think the ones that you do on tax measures in particular and tracking the performance is really, really helpful.

401
00:50:10.139 --> 00:50:13.061
<v Dan Ryan>Do you ever do joint audits with the county and neighboring counties?

402
00:50:13.108 --> 00:50:18.326
<v Dan Ryan>I'm thinking of SHS because that could come to the ballot sooner than we think.

403
00:50:18.887 --> 00:50:23.576
<v Dan Ryan>And so I wanted to know, is that one being discussed among auditors in the metro area?

404
00:50:24.586 --> 00:50:25.903
<v Simone Reddy>Yes, thanks for that question.

405
00:50:25.967 --> 00:50:33.324
<v Simone Reddy>So my audit colleagues in other jurisdictions have been very busy auditing housing and homeless services over the last few years.

406
00:50:34.014 --> 00:50:39.764
<v Simone Reddy>It's in our audit standards that we coordinate when taking on topics that have a similar scope.

407
00:50:40.342 --> 00:50:51.233
<v Simone Reddy>And so we meet regularly with the Metro Auditor, Multnomah County Auditor, and sometimes even auditors in other counties on the topic of housing and homelessness.

408
00:50:52.213 --> 00:51:09.030
<v Simone Reddy>It has not I've not seen a joint audit conducted in my audit lifetime, but the purpose of that coordination is really to make sure we're not duplicating effort and we're sharing information so that we're saving the city and our jurisdiction's time as well as our own audit resources.

409
00:51:09.702 --> 00:51:19.369
<v Dan Ryan>So thinking out loud with you then, I think that this is one where, you know, Metro could be the point since it's a Metro audit, it's a Metro performance collection.

410
00:51:19.577 --> 00:51:19.769
<v Dan Ryan>Mm-hmm.

411
00:51:19.882 --> 00:51:25.041
<v Dan Ryan>Even though our revenue division collects the money, which people think it's just coming to the city because of that.

412
00:51:25.409 --> 00:51:29.737
<v Dan Ryan>But my point is, I really do think that's an important one to have as a focus.

413
00:51:30.202 --> 00:51:35.554
<v Dan Ryan>And I will be very supportive of that journey that you'll be on, because it'll be complex.

414
00:51:35.601 --> 00:51:39.480
<v Dan Ryan>It'll be more challenging than some because of that coordination.

415
00:51:40.137 --> 00:51:44.447
<v Dan Ryan>But the voters are all in one space for this.

416
00:51:44.494 --> 00:51:45.873
<v Dan Ryan>So it's important that we do that.

417
00:51:46.547 --> 00:51:51.313
<v Dan Ryan>And I look forward to making sure that that's a priority in terms of performance audits.

418
00:51:51.489 --> 00:51:52.420
<v Dan Ryan>Does that make sense?

419
00:51:52.902 --> 00:51:59.786
<v Simone Reddy>Yeah, and I would like to add that the influx of those dollars did increase audit resources for my colleagues at Metro.

420
00:52:00.525 --> 00:52:07.746
<v Simone Reddy>I think that is a point that I'm trying to make here about being sensitive to the changes in our environment that we audit.

421
00:52:08.612 --> 00:52:15.306
<v Simone Reddy>As the city grows in its complexity and its responsibility, I hope that my office too would reflect those changes.

422
00:52:15.355 --> 00:52:24.244
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I think it's important that a city gets in on that one because that's one of the challenges of the performance of the SHS funds is that the cities don't have access.

423
00:52:24.518 --> 00:52:29.692
<v Dan Ryan>It's all through the county, and it's a model that's frustrating for cities throughout the metro area.

424
00:52:29.853 --> 00:52:32.335
<v Dan Ryan>So I think it's really important that we have a voice at the table.

425
00:52:34.306 --> 00:52:39.585
<v Dan Ryan>The other question Councilor Zimmerman asked, that was good, it was about elections and just making sure we have that firewall.

426
00:52:40.081 --> 00:52:48.588
<v Dan Ryan>Have you considered working with community groups that don't have C4s and that weren't part of the coalition that brought us the charter that we voted on in 2022?

427
00:52:50.663 --> 00:52:54.519
<v Simone Reddy>I'm going to ask my deputy or Deborah to answer that.

428
00:52:57.150 --> 00:52:57.512
<v Dan Ryan>Hi, Deborah.

429
00:52:57.561 --> 00:52:58.172
<v Reed Brodersen>Thank you, Councilor.

430
00:52:58.338 --> 00:52:59.577
<v Reed Brodersen>Yeah, that sounds great.

431
00:53:01.322 --> 00:53:01.907
<v Deborah Scroggin>Thank you, Councilor.

432
00:53:01.972 --> 00:53:13.128
<v Deborah Scroggin>Well, I will note that we didn't— we just noticed awards of contracts contracts recently, and none of— not all of them are C3s or C4s, sorry, have a component C4.

433
00:53:13.418 --> 00:53:14.559
<v Deborah Scroggin>So we do that regularly.

434
00:53:14.623 --> 00:53:27.516
<v Deborah Scroggin>We're looking at service providers, we're looking at folks that work with Oregon Food Bank that are providing service daily to different groups and can reach folks in a way that they are trusted in their communities where we aren't always.

435
00:53:28.512 --> 00:53:37.193
<v Deborah Scroggin>And so sometimes those are C3s with the C4, and sometimes those okay.

436
00:53:37.420 --> 00:53:45.195
<v Dan Ryan>I just am happy to hear that there are some that aren't connected to that network, the political nonprofit network, because then the firewall is a lot easier to manage.

437
00:53:45.621 --> 00:53:45.833
<v Deborah Scroggin>Absolutely.

438
00:53:45.882 --> 00:53:48.389
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, the firewall's taken care of because they don't have that arm.

439
00:53:52.603 --> 00:53:56.882
<v Dan Ryan>The coordination with the Small Donors Office continues to make me think that we need to have a better understanding of how that works.

440
00:53:57.152 --> 00:53:58.103
<v Dan Ryan>How does that work?

441
00:53:58.847 --> 00:54:10.052
<v Dan Ryan>I think that when you're actively campaigning, it was a time where you looked at the elections office as your go-to, but increasingly the real experience day to day is the small donors office.

442
00:54:10.648 --> 00:54:11.632
<v Dan Ryan>How do you coordinate?

443
00:54:11.713 --> 00:54:12.666
<v Dan Ryan>How do you overlap?

444
00:54:12.746 --> 00:54:13.746
<v Dan Ryan>Where does the buck stop?

445
00:54:13.811 --> 00:54:18.086
<v Dan Ryan>And I think the lawsuit that occurred was one of those examples where it got messy.

446
00:54:20.963 --> 00:54:28.719
<v Deborah Scroggin>We enforce the city charter-based campaign finance laws, and Small Donor Elections enforces their city code and rules.

447
00:54:29.554 --> 00:54:40.280
<v Deborah Scroggin>That does require close coordination, and so we do meet with the director there, especially during an election season, more frequently to coordinate and make sure we both— both offices know what's going on.

448
00:54:41.114 --> 00:54:47.585
<v Deborah Scroggin>We recognize this is not an ideal situation for the public, but try to work as closely and as best we can in the system that we have.

449
00:54:47.697 --> 00:54:53.708
<v Dan Ryan>I thought the, the what we passed out of governance was better legislation in terms of those firewalls between the two of you, if you will.

450
00:54:54.333 --> 00:54:59.942
<v Dan Ryan>And I was disappointed that, um, the final version that came to the full council, I thought weakened that.

451
00:55:00.262 --> 00:55:04.043
<v Dan Ryan>And I thought I was basing mine on what we could have learned from the lawsuit.

452
00:55:04.429 --> 00:55:06.623
<v Dan Ryan>So, um, I just wanted to put that on the public record.

453
00:55:07.393 --> 00:55:07.664
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

454
00:55:08.994 --> 00:55:09.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

455
00:55:10.373 --> 00:55:10.902
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

456
00:55:11.735 --> 00:55:12.505
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

457
00:55:12.601 --> 00:55:14.202
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to be brief because we're already over time.

458
00:55:14.362 --> 00:55:15.724
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you for the presentation today.

459
00:55:15.902 --> 00:55:20.394
<v Mitch Green>And explaining sort of the process of how, uh, this proposed cut came to be.

460
00:55:20.556 --> 00:55:26.108
<v Mitch Green>Mr. Mayor, thanks for explaining how that sort of interaction worked with, uh, the Auditor's Office.

461
00:55:26.398 --> 00:55:34.967
<v Mitch Green>Um, I think for my part, if there's any councilor who's working on an amendment that's looking to restore at least one of these positions that's cut, uh, I'm willing to support that amendment.

462
00:55:35.144 --> 00:55:40.650
<v Mitch Green>And it's not because I don't think you had good conversations to sort of find the shared sacrifice.

463
00:55:40.842 --> 00:56:00.596
<v Mitch Green>I just think that just as a matter of principle, I don't think that we should be cutting into the other independent branches of the elected officials' governments beyond what they would prefer, because they're the sort of duly elected officials that steward, that steward those, those charter obligations.

464
00:56:00.643 --> 00:56:04.237
<v Mitch Green>So I understand that you've made this negotiation, but I think your preferred cut level was 3%.

465
00:56:05.070 --> 00:56:08.670
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm willing to work with anyone who's working on that amendment.

466
00:56:08.914 --> 00:56:11.530
<v Mitch Green>There's other places in the City of Portland that we can find these cuts.

467
00:56:11.577 --> 00:56:22.128
<v Mitch Green>And I think it's really, really important that we preserve as much capability of the audit function as possible so Portlanders can find their trust in the City of Portland.

468
00:56:22.369 --> 00:56:24.958
<v Mitch Green>And it's just all I wanted to say.

469
00:56:25.103 --> 00:56:25.666
<v Mitch Green>So thanks.

470
00:56:25.891 --> 00:56:26.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

471
00:56:27.195 --> 00:56:27.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

472
00:56:29.596 --> 00:56:30.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thank you, Council President.

473
00:56:30.675 --> 00:56:35.952
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>I'm sorry, I was hoping I could not say anything to buy us time or save us time.

474
00:56:36.911 --> 00:56:48.583
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>But, uh, Auditor Reddy, because it has come up a few times that some of my colleagues are interested in restoring cuts, can you explain to us what the difference between the 3% and the 4% is?

475
00:56:48.695 --> 00:57:19.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And I'll, I'll just editorialize first and say, I really appreciate you digging deep and thinking about, at a time when we are having to cut core services, frontline services that Portlanders depend on day to day, how do we make sure that we without having to dig more deeply into those core services that Portlanders also rely on, right?

476
00:57:19.302 --> 00:57:20.737
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Both are so critical.

477
00:57:20.833 --> 00:57:32.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And as we're thinking about that balance, if we are looking at any restorations, I want to make sure that they are the restorations of the things that you were most concerned about cutting.

478
00:57:32.931 --> 00:57:33.045
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thank you.

479
00:57:33.876 --> 00:57:37.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And not just based on what, what we think that might be.

480
00:57:39.101 --> 00:57:40.599
<v Simone Reddy>Thank you, Councilor.

481
00:57:42.349 --> 00:57:53.014
<v Simone Reddy>Um, I'm interested in working with Council in the long term on getting the appropriate resources for my office to provide the commensurate level of oversight that our city needs.

482
00:57:54.110 --> 00:58:00.807
<v Simone Reddy>I've been very thorough in the proposal that I've made, which was accepted by the mayor, just to clarify.

483
00:58:00.887 --> 00:58:03.302
<v Simone Reddy>It did not go further than what I asked for.

484
00:58:05.469 --> 00:58:20.262
<v Simone Reddy>Um, I'm interested in, in working on a longer-term solution because I'm, I'm worried that a short-term solution to today's problem could put my office in a worse position a few years from now when we're still working our way out of this fiscal crisis.

485
00:58:23.983 --> 00:58:24.943
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thanks for that clarity.

486
00:58:25.202 --> 00:58:26.422
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>I really appreciate that.

487
00:58:26.585 --> 00:58:45.666
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>I am a firm believer that when we have independent elected leaders running other portions of the government, we need to defer to you on what cuts to take and, and not go in on our own, but also that we need to have that shared sacrifice.

488
00:58:45.778 --> 00:58:53.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And I appreciate you stepping up for that, and I appreciate your clarity today about some of those long-term conversations that we need to have.

489
00:58:53.190 --> 00:58:53.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thank you.

490
00:58:54.545 --> 00:58:55.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

491
00:58:57.717 --> 00:59:01.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>Checking Councilor Zimmerman and Clark, are those, uh, legacy hands?

492
00:59:01.978 --> 00:59:05.775
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you very much for your presentation today.

493
00:59:06.177 --> 00:59:07.273
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we're ready to move to the next one.

494
00:59:08.021 --> 00:59:08.443
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

495
00:59:18.342 --> 00:59:20.797
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, it wasn't talked about.

496
00:59:21.420 --> 00:59:21.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's part of the function.

497
00:59:23.420 --> 00:59:27.025
<v Jamie Dunphy>So next, we're welcoming up our friends from the Public Works Bureau.

498
00:59:27.414 --> 00:59:29.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe I'm turning it over to DCA Dhanapal.

499
00:59:29.606 --> 00:59:30.094
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that correct?

500
00:59:31.199 --> 00:59:31.666
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

501
00:59:32.278 --> 00:59:32.731
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

502
00:59:34.293 --> 00:59:37.146
<v Jamie Dunphy>It feels like we were all just here just moments ago.

503
00:59:37.677 --> 00:59:39.617
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you for spending your entire life in this chamber.

504
00:59:39.938 --> 00:59:40.949
<v Priya Dhanapal>We live here, Councilor.

505
00:59:45.117 --> 00:59:45.983
<v Priya Dhanapal>Good morning, Council.

506
00:59:46.373 --> 00:59:46.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

507
00:59:47.382 --> 00:59:48.860
<v Priya Dhanapal>For the record, my name is Priya Dhanapal.

508
00:59:49.407 --> 00:59:51.206
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'm the Deputy City Administrator for Public Works.

509
00:59:51.384 --> 00:59:58.871
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'm joined by Ting Lu, our Public Utilities Director, who oversees both Bureau of Environmental Services and the Portland Water Bureau.

510
00:59:59.914 --> 01:00:08.639
<v Priya Dhanapal>Today, Ting Lu will go through the proposed budgets for both bureaus, and our finance leads are also in the audience and are available to answer any questions.

511
01:00:09.474 --> 01:00:13.458
<v Priya Dhanapal>We will aim to move through our presentations quickly to allow ample time for your questions.

512
01:00:13.619 --> 01:00:14.217
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

513
01:00:19.159 --> 01:00:24.155
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you for the discussion regarding the proposed parks and PBOT budget during the April 30th work session.

514
01:00:24.427 --> 01:00:30.460
<v Priya Dhanapal>Today we will focus on the proposed budgets for the Office of the Deputy City Administrator and the utility bureaus.

515
01:00:31.045 --> 01:00:40.847
<v Priya Dhanapal>And following those presentations, we'll— the proposed Public Works and Community Economic Development rates, fees, and charges ordinances scheduled for council consideration next week.

516
01:00:41.300 --> 01:00:42.280
<v Priya Dhanapal>Will be presented to you.

517
01:00:43.016 --> 01:00:43.652
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

518
01:00:48.396 --> 01:00:56.416
<v Priya Dhanapal>We provided an overview of the public work service area during the previous budget work session on April 30th, so I will not repeat those details today.

519
01:00:56.737 --> 01:00:59.876
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'll fly through the next few slides as a brief reminder.

520
01:00:59.956 --> 01:01:06.094
<v Priya Dhanapal>The proposed budget includes approximately 3,000 staff and roughly $4.8 billion in total resources.

521
01:01:06.431 --> 01:01:07.059
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

522
01:01:09.483 --> 01:01:15.956
<v Priya Dhanapal>Public Works includes 4 primary bureaus: Parks, Transportation, and the Utility Bureaus, which includes Water and BES.

523
01:01:16.766 --> 01:01:17.119
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

524
01:01:20.952 --> 01:01:33.692
<v Priya Dhanapal>The Public Works service area is facing rising costs that are outpacing available revenues, and this budget prioritizes maintaining essential infrastructure and meeting regulatory requirements while aligning service levels with available resources.

525
01:01:34.231 --> 01:01:37.324
<v Priya Dhanapal>You'll see those trade-offs reflected in the proposals we discussed today.

526
01:01:38.052 --> 01:01:38.750
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

527
01:01:41.880 --> 01:01:47.938
<v Priya Dhanapal>This provides a financial overview by each public works bureau and the funds for all of the public works bureaus as well.

528
01:01:48.146 --> 01:01:52.827
<v Priya Dhanapal>We've seen this at the previous work session, so I'm not going to go into the details of this.

529
01:01:52.907 --> 01:01:54.554
<v Priya Dhanapal>If there are questions, we're happy to answer that.

530
01:01:55.351 --> 01:01:55.971
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

531
01:01:59.516 --> 01:02:04.576
<v Priya Dhanapal>This slide summarizes the position changes within Public Works as a part of the core services realignment effort.

532
01:02:05.235 --> 01:02:14.148
<v Priya Dhanapal>Overall, the positions decreased from 229 to 156 FTEs, which is driven by 62 reductions and limited additions and realignments.

533
01:02:14.791 --> 01:02:21.650
<v Priya Dhanapal>The negative realignments reflect positions shifting out of Public Works to centralized citywide functions rather than being eliminated.

534
01:02:22.806 --> 01:02:24.894
<v Priya Dhanapal>And I will transition to the next slide.

535
01:02:25.163 --> 01:02:26.264
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

536
01:02:35.373 --> 01:02:40.592
<v Priya Dhanapal>So I want to provide a high-level overview of the proposed budget for the Office of the Deputy City Administrator for Public Works.

537
01:02:41.416 --> 01:02:52.492
<v Priya Dhanapal>This office provides executive leadership, strategic oversight, and policy coordination across the public works bureaus to support organizational alignment, infrastructure stewardship, and reliable public service delivery.

538
01:02:53.418 --> 01:03:00.791
<v Priya Dhanapal>The proposed budget includes approximately 131 staff and $26.6 million in total resources.

539
01:03:02.092 --> 01:03:08.405
<v Priya Dhanapal>I want to make sure we understand that there are no additions or reductions to the DCA's office.

540
01:03:09.014 --> 01:03:23.097
<v Priya Dhanapal>A significant portion of the staffing level that you see in this slide, which is about 121 FTEs of the total FTEs, reflects a realignment of the embedded teams into the— from the core services realignment into the Public Works service area.

541
01:03:23.581 --> 01:03:26.554
<v Priya Dhanapal>They're not new positions or direct additions to the DCA's office.

542
01:03:27.335 --> 01:03:34.820
<v Priya Dhanapal>They are embedded core services team in HR, IT, procurement, equity, and engagement that provide coordinated support across the Public Works bureaus.

543
01:03:36.063 --> 01:03:36.675
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

544
01:03:39.072 --> 01:03:43.052
<v Priya Dhanapal>This slide summarizes the proposed budget for the Office of the DCA for Public Works.

545
01:03:43.605 --> 01:03:47.311
<v Priya Dhanapal>The proposed budget the budget totals approximately $26.6 million, as I mentioned earlier.

546
01:03:47.538 --> 01:03:51.105
<v Priya Dhanapal>There are no significant additions proposed within the DCA's office budget itself.

547
01:03:52.211 --> 01:03:58.528
<v Priya Dhanapal>There's a small reduction that is reflected in the table, and it's associated with the citywide interagency reductions applied across bureaus.

548
01:04:00.076 --> 01:04:09.748
<v Priya Dhanapal>The increase from the current service level primarily is the realignment of the embedded core services teams into the Public Works service area as a part of the citywide core services realignment.

549
01:04:10.307 --> 01:04:12.871
<v Priya Dhanapal>And then these are existing positions, not new staffing.

550
01:04:13.775 --> 01:04:14.403
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

551
01:04:19.610 --> 01:04:26.871
<v Priya Dhanapal>This table shows a high-level overview of the changes to the DCA office positions, including additions, reductions, and realignment.

552
01:04:27.257 --> 01:04:30.139
<v Priya Dhanapal>There are no proposed staffing additions or reductions within the DCA's office.

553
01:04:30.983 --> 01:04:37.262
<v Priya Dhanapal>The increase from 10 to 131 reflects the realignment from the core services realignment efforts.

554
01:04:38.050 --> 01:04:43.460
<v Priya Dhanapal>And with that, I will pass it on to Director Lu to provide an overview, overview of the proposed budget for water and BES.

555
01:04:44.617 --> 01:04:46.222
<v Ting Lu>Thank you so much, DC Dhanapal.

556
01:04:46.302 --> 01:04:47.378
<v Ting Lu>Good morning, Council.

557
01:04:47.443 --> 01:04:48.342
<v Ting Lu>My name is Ting Lu.

558
01:04:48.503 --> 01:04:50.880
<v Ting Lu>I'm the Public Utilities Director.

559
01:04:51.762 --> 01:04:59.454
<v Ting Lu>The Bureau of Environmental Services is responsible for protecting public health and the environment for over 650,000 customers.

560
01:05:00.032 --> 01:05:12.896
<v Ting Lu>We achieve this by management of Portland wastewater and stormwater infrastructure infrastructure, including thousands of miles of sewer and stormwater pipes, green infrastructure, close to 100 pump stations, and 7 watersheds.

561
01:05:13.333 --> 01:05:17.885
<v Ting Lu>We also operate 2 treatment plants, including one of the largest in Oregon.

562
01:05:18.398 --> 01:05:25.963
<v Ting Lu>This vital work is carried out by over 600 dedicated employees and is supported by a $1.55 billion budget.

563
01:05:26.632 --> 01:05:27.416
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

564
01:05:29.976 --> 01:05:34.994
<v Ting Lu>This slide provides a summary of our proposed budget compared to the current service level.

565
01:05:35.427 --> 01:05:42.896
<v Ting Lu>The proposed budget is approximately $1.55 billion, which is about $6 million below the current service level.

566
01:05:43.282 --> 01:05:54.054
<v Ting Lu>This reflects a $1.1 million addition supported by congressional earmark funding, offset by $3.3 million in reductions and $4 million in realignment.

567
01:05:54.503 --> 01:05:59.688
<v Ting Lu>The change is specific to the 3.3 million reductions will be discussed in the upcoming slides.

568
01:06:00.382 --> 01:06:01.090
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

569
01:06:03.309 --> 01:06:09.862
<v Ting Lu>This is the overview of all the changes to the bureau's position counts, including additions, reductions, and realignment.

570
01:06:10.039 --> 01:06:26.318
<v Ting Lu>I want to note there was a slight data error in the FTE count, so the amount in this table and elsewhere in the proposed budget shows a reduction of 3.3 FTE, and it should reflect 6.3 positions, or above about 1% change.

571
01:06:26.833 --> 01:06:31.505
<v Ting Lu>This brings our total proposed budget to 605.7 FTE.

572
01:06:31.827 --> 01:06:34.710
<v Ting Lu>This will be corrected in the next iteration of the budget.

573
01:06:35.838 --> 01:06:41.411
<v Ting Lu>I also want to note that this 6.3 positions being proposed for reductions are vacant positions.

574
01:06:41.876 --> 01:06:45.561
<v Ting Lu>We'll dive into the specifics of these positions in the upcoming slides.

575
01:06:45.833 --> 01:06:46.606
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

576
01:06:49.597 --> 01:06:56.784
<v Ting Lu>Our sewer and stormwater system operates 24/7 and is essential to our public health, livability, and environmental protection.

577
01:06:57.282 --> 01:07:01.565
<v Ting Lu>Our goal is— in this budget cycle was to prioritize 4 core areas.

578
01:07:02.014 --> 01:07:07.806
<v Ting Lu>First, we maintain the service necessary for federal and state regulation— regulatory compliance.

579
01:07:08.224 --> 01:07:12.507
<v Ting Lu>Second, we preserve the financial assistance programs that support affordability.

580
01:07:13.230 --> 01:07:25.143
<v Ting Lu>Third, we continue to preserve capital investment in critical sewer and stormwater infrastructure using a risk-based asset management approach focused on high-risk treatment and pumping systems currently.

581
01:07:25.672 --> 01:07:37.329
<v Ting Lu>Finally, we continue to maintain the core operational resources necessary to provide reliable wastewater and stormwater services and minimize service disruptions.

582
01:07:37.875 --> 01:07:48.947
<v Ting Lu>The reductions you will hear about today were developed a system-wide review focused on identifying efficiencies, prioritizing core functions, and minimizing impacts where possible.

583
01:07:49.190 --> 01:07:49.965
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

584
01:07:53.246 --> 01:07:55.876
<v Ting Lu>We bundled our reductions into 5 categories.

585
01:07:56.215 --> 01:07:58.572
<v Ting Lu>The first one is a business support program.

586
01:07:58.990 --> 01:08:08.067
<v Ting Lu>This category eliminates 2 vacant internal support services positions and $20,000, or 5% of a janitorial service contract.

587
01:08:08.115 --> 01:08:08.228
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

588
01:08:08.692 --> 01:08:12.027
<v Ting Lu>These changes total 430,000 in reductions.

589
01:08:12.541 --> 01:08:18.811
<v Ting Lu>The staff reductions may lead to reduced capacity for engineering support and internal administrative support.

590
01:08:19.516 --> 01:08:26.028
<v Ting Lu>Work will be reprioritized with existing resources to maintain core engineering and administrative support functions.

591
01:08:26.573 --> 01:08:37.248
<v Ting Lu>Janitorial services will continue to prioritize sanitation and high-touch areas with reduced focus on lower priority cosmetic cleaning.

592
01:08:37.606 --> 01:08:38.470
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

593
01:08:41.158 --> 01:08:45.903
<v Ting Lu>This category reflects reductions within the Project Management Office program.

594
01:08:46.274 --> 01:08:59.617
<v Ting Lu>The proposal eliminates one vacant project delivery support position and reduces the bureau's transitory budget for urgent and unforeseen work by $1 million, from $6.9 million to $5.9 million.

595
01:09:00.021 --> 01:09:05.463
<v Ting Lu>These changes total $1,198,000 in reductions.

596
01:09:05.979 --> 01:09:12.960
<v Ting Lu>The transitory budget provides contingency funding for urgent and unforeseen non-capital operations and repairs needs.

597
01:09:13.395 --> 01:09:18.125
<v Ting Lu>These reductions decrease the contingency resource available for unexpected needs.

598
01:09:18.609 --> 01:09:29.365
<v Ting Lu>The bureau will continue prioritizing emergency response, operational resilience, and minimizing impact to the community through through reprioritization of existing resources as needed.

599
01:09:30.122 --> 01:09:31.137
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

600
01:09:33.880 --> 01:09:36.971
<v Ting Lu>The 3rd category is a strategy and integrated planning program.

601
01:09:37.538 --> 01:09:46.865
<v Ting Lu>This category includes reductions of $230,000, or roughly 50% of professional service contract funding for integrated planning support.

602
01:09:47.252 --> 01:09:55.595
<v Ting Lu>It also includes a partial reduction of 1 FTE that supports project communication coordinations non-urgent planning support work.

603
01:09:56.061 --> 01:10:01.125
<v Ting Lu>These changes total $296,600 in reductions.

604
01:10:01.606 --> 01:10:12.177
<v Ting Lu>The bureau will continue prioritizing planning work related to essential infrastructure, regulatory compliance, and high-priority risk analysis within existing resources.

605
01:10:12.675 --> 01:10:13.485
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

606
01:10:16.372 --> 01:10:19.822
<v Ting Lu>Our 4th category is the leadership program and security services.

607
01:10:20.319 --> 01:10:30.274
<v Ting Lu>This category eliminates 2 vacant positions and reduces contracted security services by $491,000, which is 16% of the contract.

608
01:10:30.756 --> 01:10:38.484
<v Ting Lu>These changes totals $1,120,436 in reductions.

609
01:10:39.000 --> 01:10:47.542
<v Ting Lu>The reductions of the management position will increase the span of control for the remaining manager from 5 direct reports to 7 direct reports.

610
01:10:48.021 --> 01:10:54.451
<v Ting Lu>The reduction of an analyst position will reduce internal capacity for strategy analysis and operational support.

611
01:10:55.076 --> 01:11:07.948
<v Ting Lu>I would like to note that we are continuing to strengthen coordination across the top leadership teams between Water and BES to continue to improve coordination, efficiency, and long-term system planning.

612
01:11:08.365 --> 01:11:14.248
<v Ting Lu>Roles and responsibilities associated with these functions will continue to be evaluated as part of that effort.

613
01:11:14.954 --> 01:11:28.712
<v Ting Lu>In addition, security services will be scaled to focus on priority locations and higher-risk facilities with increased reliance, reliance, reliance on alarms, cameras, and as-needed responses.

614
01:11:29.368 --> 01:11:30.555
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

615
01:11:31.789 --> 01:11:37.288
<v Ting Lu>And finally, our 5th category is the Technical Services Environmental Compliance Program.

616
01:11:37.658 --> 01:11:41.698
<v Ting Lu>This category reflects a reduction of over $223,000.

617
01:11:41.795 --> 01:11:42.034
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

618
01:11:42.453 --> 01:11:50.323
<v Ting Lu>Which includes elimination of one vacant analyst position and one seasonal support position for illicit discharge investigations.

619
01:11:50.885 --> 01:11:58.963
<v Ting Lu>These changes may reduce capacity to select planned code updates and development-related update activities.

620
01:11:59.478 --> 01:12:12.091
<v Ting Lu>We're refining our workflows to ensure that we prioritize our specialized expertise for critical environmental needs and code development support, as well as outfall screening and urgent responses.

621
01:12:12.430 --> 01:12:27.078
<v Ting Lu>Overall, Bureau's reduction packages reflect our thoughtful approach to ensure we prioritize on high-impact, risk-based— high-impact, risk-based approach to align with our financial and resource capabilities.

622
01:12:27.890 --> 01:12:31.426
<v Ting Lu>This concludes the presentation for the Bureau of Environmental Services.

623
01:12:31.939 --> 01:12:35.106
<v Ting Lu>With that, I'll now move to the Water Bureau budget presentation.

624
01:12:35.541 --> 01:12:36.247
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

625
01:12:38.965 --> 01:12:40.671
<v Ting Lu>Now we'll dive into the Water Bureau.

626
01:12:41.203 --> 01:12:51.648
<v Ting Lu>Water Bureau provides safe, reliable drinking water for nearly 1 million customers and not only support public health but also economic vitality of our region.

627
01:12:52.503 --> 01:12:58.957
<v Ting Lu>This essential work is supported by over 550 dedicated staff and totals $2.1 billion budget.

628
01:13:00.029 --> 01:13:00.807
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

629
01:13:03.194 --> 01:13:08.487
<v Ting Lu>This slide provides a summary of our proposed budget compared to the current service level.

630
01:13:08.886 --> 01:13:14.934
<v Ting Lu>The proposed budget includes a total adjustment of $19.2 million since the initial requested budget.

631
01:13:15.382 --> 01:13:35.908
<v Ting Lu>This is driven by 3 main factors: the removal of $0.8 million facilities integrate— facilities interagency agreement, a $15 million adjustment to lower our ending fund balance and a $3.3 million reduction in decision packages, which I will discuss in more detail in the upcoming slides.

632
01:13:37.220 --> 01:13:37.807
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

633
01:13:40.140 --> 01:13:45.912
<v Ting Lu>This is the overview of all changes to the bureau's position counts, including additions, reductions, and realignment.

634
01:13:46.398 --> 01:13:59.563
<v Ting Lu>I want to note there was a slight data entry error in the FTE count, so the amounts in the table and elsewhere in the proposed budget show shows a reduction of 15 FTE, and it should reflect 14 positions instead.

635
01:14:00.014 --> 01:14:02.814
<v Ting Lu>This will be corrected in the next iteration of the budget.

636
01:14:03.341 --> 01:14:08.341
<v Ting Lu>I also want to note that these 14 positions being proposed for reductions are vacant positions.

637
01:14:09.149 --> 01:14:12.746
<v Ting Lu>We will dive into the specifics of these positions in the upcoming slides.

638
01:14:13.149 --> 01:14:13.712
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

639
01:14:15.738 --> 01:14:24.262
<v Ting Lu>Similar to BES, we're priority— prioritizing core services to protect public health and maintain regulatory compliance.

640
01:14:24.680 --> 01:14:27.534
<v Ting Lu>Our approach focuses on 4 core priorities.

641
01:14:27.807 --> 01:14:32.859
<v Ting Lu>First, we are preserving services necessary to meet regulatory and permit compliance.

642
01:14:33.355 --> 01:14:39.082
<v Ting Lu>Second, we remain committed to support financial assistance programs to support affordability.

643
01:14:40.060 --> 01:14:51.668
<v Ting Lu>Third, we are preserving capital investment in drinking water infrastructure, including treatment, water mains, pumps and distribution system to support the long-term system reliability.

644
01:14:52.166 --> 01:14:59.203
<v Ting Lu>We have prioritized the key CIP project and strategically delayed other investment to avoid high peak rates to our customers.

645
01:15:00.020 --> 01:15:07.057
<v Ting Lu>Finally, we are preserving resources to maintain reliable services for safe and reliable drinking water 24/7.

646
01:15:07.650 --> 01:15:21.753
<v Ting Lu>The reductions you will hear from us today were developed with a deliberate system-wide approach through reviewing services and identifying efficiencies with a focus on prioritizing core functions and minimizing impact where possible.

647
01:15:22.710 --> 01:15:23.386
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

648
01:15:25.689 --> 01:15:38.622
<v Ting Lu>We have 20 budget reduction packages totaling $3.3 million that includes 14 vacant position reductions, and we are— we have bundled them into 4 categories, and I'll start with the drinking water operations.

649
01:15:38.737 --> 01:15:38.868
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

650
01:15:39.868 --> 01:15:50.774
<v Ting Lu>The package reduces operational capacity through the elimination of 4 vacant positions across lab services, backflow inspection, system flushing, and water quality functions.

651
01:15:51.368 --> 01:15:55.671
<v Ting Lu>These changes total $632,000 in reductions.

652
01:15:56.185 --> 01:16:03.060
<v Ting Lu>These reductions reduce capacity for selected non-regulatory sampling, inspection, and system flushing.

653
01:16:03.654 --> 01:16:08.198
<v Ting Lu>Regulatory compliance and core drinking water operations will continue to be prioritized.

654
01:16:08.488 --> 01:16:20.738
<v Ting Lu>Through strategic reprioritization, we're confident in our ability to continue performing all regulatory and essential work, ensuring our system remains safe, reliable, and in full compliance.

655
01:16:21.144 --> 01:16:21.858
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

656
01:16:25.072 --> 01:16:28.274
<v Ting Lu>This package reflects reductions within system maintenance.

657
01:16:28.712 --> 01:16:35.527
<v Ting Lu>It reduces staff capacity for system maintenance, facility management, and water loss prevention activities.

658
01:16:35.577 --> 01:16:35.712
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

659
01:16:36.063 --> 01:16:40.578
<v Ting Lu>It also includes a streamlined street opening permit process to achieve cost savings.

660
01:16:41.286 --> 01:16:45.274
<v Ting Lu>These changes total $781,000 in reductions.

661
01:16:45.872 --> 01:16:55.199
<v Ting Lu>This category eliminates 4 vacant positions across equipment maintenance, construction field support, facilities management, and water loss prevention.

662
01:16:56.904 --> 01:17:07.340
<v Ting Lu>Work will be reprioritized within existing resources, with a priority maintained for urgent repairs, Regulatory maintenance and continuity of critical services.

663
01:17:08.014 --> 01:17:15.041
<v Ting Lu>Non-urgent facility support requests and some water loss reduction activities may experience longer timelines.

664
01:17:15.377 --> 01:17:20.448
<v Ting Lu>However, the state-mandated annual water loss audit will remain prioritized.

665
01:17:20.929 --> 01:17:30.212
<v Ting Lu>We'll continue exploring shared opportunities between water and BES to improve coordination, optimize staff resources, and support operational efficiencies.

666
01:17:30.729 --> 01:17:31.475
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

667
01:17:35.920 --> 01:17:40.682
<v Ting Lu>This package reflects reductions in engineering, planning, and coordination category.

668
01:17:41.426 --> 01:17:48.496
<v Ting Lu>In this bundle, we are eliminating 4 vacant positions that support engineering, planning, intergovernmental coordination.

669
01:17:49.011 --> 01:17:52.963
<v Ting Lu>This change totals $910,000 in reductions.

670
01:17:53.591 --> 01:18:07.161
<v Ting Lu>This change reduces capacity for early project planning, project implementation support for permitting and land use review, development and maintenance of engineering standard, and coordination with the regulatory and partner agencies.

671
01:18:07.755 --> 01:18:17.886
<v Ting Lu>However, consistent with our approach to other impacted work, we have prioritized key resources to ensure continuity of critical services and regulatory requirements.

672
01:18:18.448 --> 01:18:26.509
<v Ting Lu>Additionally, we'll continue to explore and implement shared opportunities between Water and BES to maximize our efficiencies and impact.

673
01:18:28.038 --> 01:18:28.554
<v Ting Lu>Next slide.

674
01:18:30.613 --> 01:18:39.386
<v Ting Lu>The final category is the customer services, with adjustment to customer engagement, billing approaches, and security operations and logistics.

675
01:18:39.868 --> 01:18:43.378
<v Ting Lu>This change totals $990,000 in reductions.

676
01:18:44.070 --> 01:18:53.896
<v Ting Lu>To achieve this, we are eliminating 2 vacant positions with our customer contact center and customer billing teams, along with reducing printing and mailing costs by $200,000.

677
01:18:54.878 --> 01:19:11.474
<v Ting Lu>By expanding paperless billing, shifting to an opt-out model, customer service levels will remain consistent, supported by expanded use of online self-service option and strengthened by increased adoption of paperless billing and electronic correspondence.

678
01:19:12.430 --> 01:19:23.398
<v Ting Lu>We also anticipate cost avoidance with a reduction to permitting payment processing fees when Portland Permitting and Development shifts credit card processing fees to developers.

679
01:19:23.873 --> 01:19:27.054
<v Ting Lu>The Water Bureau expects to save $200,000 annually.

680
01:19:28.942 --> 01:19:40.376
<v Ting Lu>Additional reductions in consulting, sponsorship, and contracted security services will be focused on aligning resources with immediate operational priorities and citywide coordination efforts.

681
01:19:40.989 --> 01:19:44.962
<v Ting Lu>This concludes the presentation for the operating budget of Water Bureau.

682
01:19:45.430 --> 01:19:49.546
<v Ting Lu>With that, I'll now transition to the proposed rate projections for both bureaus.

683
01:19:55.480 --> 01:20:04.347
<v Ting Lu>Both water and BES rely on utility rate revenues to support day-to-day operations and to finance major capital investments through long-term bonds.

684
01:20:04.850 --> 01:20:15.389
<v Ting Lu>The proposed budget includes an 8.1% increase in water rates and a 5.15% increase in BES rates, resulting in combined rate increase of 6.36%.

685
01:20:15.520 --> 01:20:15.634
<v Ting Lu>Second.

686
01:20:15.729 --> 01:20:17.640
<v Ting Lu>For the upcoming fiscal year.

687
01:20:18.234 --> 01:20:28.974
<v Ting Lu>Over the next 4 years, water rates are projected to increase by 9.8% annually through 2031 to fund essential health and safety projection— protections.

688
01:20:29.471 --> 01:20:36.149
<v Ting Lu>For BES, rates will increase to 5.5% before decreasing by 0.5% each year.

689
01:20:36.792 --> 01:20:41.898
<v Ting Lu>We project that these annual percent increases will stabilize for both bureaus around or under 5%.

690
01:20:41.945 --> 01:20:42.266
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

691
01:20:42.591 --> 01:20:45.565
<v Ting Lu>In 5 years as of current forecast.

692
01:20:49.899 --> 01:21:01.631
<v Ting Lu>The forecasted assumptions include 30-year term bonds and is really a base projection and is updated each year as part of a budget process and adjusted with updated assumptions and budget decisions.

693
01:21:02.288 --> 01:21:03.078
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

694
01:21:05.596 --> 01:21:12.140
<v Ting Lu>This slide illustrates the impact of this investment on our single-family residential customers.

695
01:21:12.654 --> 01:21:24.828
<v Ting Lu>Currently, the average single-family customer using 500 cubic feet, 5 CCF, for water pays $160.29 per month for combined water, sewer, and stormwater rates services.

696
01:21:25.327 --> 01:21:35.188
<v Ting Lu>With a proposed combined rate increase of 6.36%, these customers will experience an increase of $10.20 per month to their total bill.

697
01:21:35.235 --> 01:21:35.444
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

698
01:21:35.849 --> 01:21:45.117
<v Ting Lu>I also want to note that many households consume less than 5 CCFs due to the Conservation and Water Efficiency Alliance, which further lowers individual bills.

699
01:21:45.711 --> 01:21:58.569
<v Ting Lu>We are continuing to invest in financial assistance programs, including bill discounts, crisis vouchers, flexible payment plans, and stormwater discounts to help every customer regardless of their financial situation.

700
01:21:59.247 --> 01:21:59.943
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

701
01:22:03.061 --> 01:22:07.220
<v Ting Lu>Also want to share about the Portland bill, how we compare with other utilities.

702
01:22:07.734 --> 01:22:14.286
<v Ting Lu>A common misconception is that Portland has some of the highest utility rates in the region or even the country.

703
01:22:14.800 --> 01:22:26.408
<v Ting Lu>Despite the cost pressures, Portland utilities continue to keep costs to customers within range of comparable national peer utilities that have similar scale of water, sewer, and stormwater systems.

704
01:22:26.905 --> 01:22:47.314
<v Ting Lu>The chart on this slide includes 2 types of utilities: neighboring utilities, which are geographical— geographically close to Portland, and here for reference, and peer utilities, which share similar system characteristics such as combined sewer overflow infrastructures and drinking water filtration requirements.

705
01:22:47.538 --> 01:22:51.778
<v Ting Lu>The most apples-to-apples comparison is made between peer utilities.

706
01:22:52.520 --> 01:23:01.475
<v Ting Lu>Utility costs vary based on geographic infrastructure age and regulatory requirement, but this chart provides important context.

707
01:23:01.621 --> 01:23:08.309
<v Ting Lu>Portland's rates are not an outlier; they reflect the real cost of maintaining a safe, reliable, and modern system.

708
01:23:10.899 --> 01:23:18.055
<v Ting Lu>Many of our peers have completed filtration but haven't addressed combined sewer overflows, which BES did with the big pipe.

709
01:23:18.130 --> 01:23:20.006
<v Ting Lu>Types many years ago.

710
01:23:20.199 --> 01:23:34.032
<v Ting Lu>So we expect to remain in the middle of the pack of comparable peer utilities as filtrations completed in Portland and other cities address CSOs, as this capital investment represents similar magnitude of the cost.

711
01:23:37.605 --> 01:23:44.800
<v Ting Lu>This slide shows a holistic overview of our financial assistance programs with dedicated $40 million funding support.

712
01:23:45.069 --> 01:23:50.525
<v Ting Lu>For, for example, we provide bill discounts of up to 80% based on income.

713
01:23:50.943 --> 01:24:01.951
<v Ting Lu>For the Low Income Bill Assistance Program, households earning up to 60% of the state median family income are eligible for Tier 1 assistance, 50% of a typical bill.

714
01:24:02.497 --> 01:24:12.045
<v Ting Lu>Households earning up to 30% of the MFI are eligible for Tier 2 assistance, which is 80% of the typical— 80% of the typical bill.

715
01:24:12.850 --> 01:24:22.454
<v Ting Lu>Programs like RAMP and Clean River Rewards also support renters, affordable housing properties, and customers who manage stormwater on site.

716
01:24:23.003 --> 01:24:34.109
<v Ting Lu>Our RAMP program specifically supports regulated affordable multifamily properties, ensuring these benefits reach renters and the nonprofit housing providers.

717
01:24:36.850 --> 01:24:47.287
<v Ting Lu>The Water Bureau's water efficiency teams works closely with the business and the resident— residents to help reduce water use and save money on their utility bills.

718
01:24:47.882 --> 01:24:59.057
<v Ting Lu>We have also simplified the application process and partnered with the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability to reduce administrative burden on residents seeking help with the garbage and recycling bills.

719
01:25:00.974 --> 01:25:02.734
<v Ting Lu>So there is a comprehensive program.

720
01:25:02.814 --> 01:25:04.865
<v Ting Lu>Details are available on the website.

721
01:25:05.185 --> 01:25:14.935
<v Ting Lu>Customers can also contact us by calling 503-823-7770 to learn more about our programs and confirm their eligibility.

722
01:25:17.149 --> 01:25:17.877
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

723
01:25:18.475 --> 01:25:22.082
<v Ting Lu>This concludes our presentation on water and BES proposed budget.

724
01:25:22.421 --> 01:25:27.365
<v Ting Lu>We'll now discuss utility fees and charges that will be coming to council next week for consideration.

725
01:25:32.793 --> 01:25:33.668
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

726
01:25:35.563 --> 01:25:46.873
<v Ting Lu>This chart shows the primary revenue categories for BES and the Water Bureau associated with the annual rates, fees, and charges ordinances that will be before council next week.

727
01:25:47.375 --> 01:25:59.597
<v Ting Lu>Utility rates revenues account for approximately 90% of total revenues for both bureaus, while permitting, development, and other fees and charges account for the remaining approximately next slide, please.

728
01:26:01.783 --> 01:26:11.099
<v Ting Lu>This slide summarized proposed utility rates, fees, and charges associated with the customer account development and permitting activities.

729
01:26:11.679 --> 01:26:22.378
<v Ting Lu>First, customer account-related fees including late notice fees, disconnection fees for non-payment, and water service restoration fees are proposed to remain unchanged.

730
01:26:23.121 --> 01:26:35.150
<v Ting Lu>Second, The bureau is proposing adjustment to development and permitting fees, including system development charges and other permitting-related fees, generally at the cost of service and not to exceed 9%.

731
01:26:35.823 --> 01:26:42.524
<v Ting Lu>Some development and permitting fees currently do not fully recover the cost of providing those services.

732
01:26:43.198 --> 01:27:05.757
<v Priya Dhanapal>The proposed adjustments are intended to better align fees with service delivery costs and reduce reliance on utility rates revenues that concludes our presentation for the utility bureaus, and I would like to call Jeremy Patton from PBOT to talk about PBOT's rates, fees, and charges.

733
01:27:10.462 --> 01:27:11.060
<v Jeremy Patton>Morning, Council.

734
01:27:11.109 --> 01:27:12.974
<v Jeremy Patton>Jeremy Patton, Public Works Enterprise Services.

735
01:27:13.252 --> 01:27:15.029
<v Jeremy Patton>Can we jump to the next slide, please?

736
01:27:16.813 --> 01:27:22.914
<v Jeremy Patton>So the PBOT fee ordinance that will be discussed next week is going to include 8 separate schedules and over 500 fees.

737
01:27:23.529 --> 01:27:31.006
<v Jeremy Patton>These fees account for about $152.2 million of the total PBOT resources, or 26% of our overall budget.

738
01:27:31.587 --> 01:27:36.881
<v Jeremy Patton>Most of the fees within the various schedules are either set to inflationary increases or cost recovery targets.

739
01:27:37.604 --> 01:27:38.212
<v Jeremy Patton>Next slide, please.

740
01:27:40.310 --> 01:27:50.645
<v Jeremy Patton>So stated in the previous slide, most fees are increasing by the bureau's weighted inflation factor, which covers cost increases for things like personnel, central services, office and building supplies, and vendor contracts.

741
01:27:51.579 --> 01:27:59.770
<v Jeremy Patton>Other factors that drive rate changes include construction cost increases, market conditions, cost recovery targets, and regulatory or contractual constraints.

742
01:28:01.024 --> 01:28:01.926
<v Jeremy Patton>Next slide.

743
01:28:03.391 --> 01:28:29.443
<v Jeremy Patton>Bit of an eye chart, but this is the $152 million in fee resources that cover costs within 14 of our 20 programs these fees support services like permitted uses of the right-of-way, such as block parties and street parking reservations, regulation of private-for-hire vehicles and towing companies, street openings to access utilities, and the use of parking garages, and parking permits and meter charges which support all transportation needs.

744
01:28:31.855 --> 01:28:32.414
<v Jeremy Patton>Next slide, please.

745
01:28:32.775 --> 01:28:35.176
<v Jeremy Patton>I know I'm flying through these a little, but come back for questions.

746
01:28:35.225 --> 01:28:35.405
<v Jeremy Patton>Thank you.

747
01:28:37.606 --> 01:28:40.382
<v Jeremy Patton>This is a list of all the general transportation revenue fees.

748
01:28:40.430 --> 01:28:51.375
<v Jeremy Patton>These are fees that can support any transportation-related need, and they include things like parking meter fees, parking permits, parking citations, temporary street use permits, and transportation network company fees.

749
01:28:52.194 --> 01:28:58.917
<v Jeremy Patton>Table includes some examples of the expected increases for these fees over the 5-year forecast period based on current projected inflationary factors.

750
01:28:59.688 --> 01:29:05.266
<v Jeremy Patton>These fees are— increases are necessary to maintain the current revenue forecast is presented to council during the budget development process.

751
01:29:05.395 --> 01:29:08.087
<v Jeremy Patton>And these are the fees that are tying into what we mostly call GTR.

752
01:29:08.201 --> 01:29:12.734
<v Jeremy Patton>And when we're talking about our forecast, it's heavily reliant on these fees and then state highway funds.

753
01:29:14.090 --> 01:29:14.701
<v Jeremy Patton>Next slide, please.

754
01:29:17.057 --> 01:29:22.552
<v Jeremy Patton>So just as a point of comparison, this is the parking meter rate for downtown and how it compares to other cities.

755
01:29:23.067 --> 01:29:27.043
<v Jeremy Patton>And you can see that we kind of land right in the middle of the pack compared to those cities.

756
01:29:29.797 --> 01:29:30.300
<v Jeremy Patton>Next slide.

757
01:29:32.680 --> 01:29:43.409
<v Jeremy Patton>And then finally, the proposed budget includes $3.1 million of fee revenue related to the creation of new fees for development-related work and eliminates the interagency with Portland Permitting and Development that funded this work in previous years.

758
01:29:44.412 --> 01:29:53.838
<v Jeremy Patton>There are 44 new fees ranging from $151 for an additional sidewalk or driveway inspection to $7,631 for a street lighting public works permit, just as a few examples.

759
01:29:55.417 --> 01:30:01.127
<v Jeremy Patton>And this concludes our presentation of the PBOT fees, and I'll now pass it over to DC Oliveira.

760
01:30:01.225 --> 01:30:01.773
<v Jeremy Patton>Yep, he is here.

761
01:30:14.353 --> 01:30:14.882
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you, Jeremy.

762
01:30:15.719 --> 01:30:17.020
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, good morning, Council.

763
01:30:17.485 --> 01:30:21.229
<v Donnie Oliveira>Donnie Oliveira, for the record, Deputy City Administrator for Community and Economic Development.

764
01:30:21.612 --> 01:30:34.938
<v Donnie Oliveira>I want to just take a moment to thank the council president, vice president, and Deputy City Administrator Dhanapal for letting BPS sneak into this presentation to cover the BPS waste rates and have a quick note on the, um, on the piece of interest, I believe.

765
01:30:35.085 --> 01:30:35.704
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide, please.

766
01:30:37.319 --> 01:30:41.099
<v Donnie Oliveira>Um, so real quick, councilors, um, I'm joined by Director Engstrom from BPS.

767
01:30:41.792 --> 01:30:53.091
<v Donnie Oliveira>We covered some of this information, um, at the, the CEDSA work session related to BPS, but just to package this with the rate content that you're contemplating today, we just thought we'd bring back the waste and recycling rates.

768
01:30:53.940 --> 01:31:03.065
<v Donnie Oliveira>Just as a reminder, and as we shared last week, the waste and recycling utility is divided into 2 primary systems, residential and commercial.

769
01:31:03.563 --> 01:31:09.095
<v Donnie Oliveira>The residential waste system generates about one-third of the waste in the city, and the commercial system generates about two-thirds of the waste.

770
01:31:09.737 --> 01:31:13.121
<v Donnie Oliveira>The city has a rate-setting authority over the residential system, but not the commercial system.

771
01:31:13.168 --> 01:31:13.265
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

772
01:31:13.329 --> 01:31:13.537
<v Donnie Oliveira>System.

773
01:31:14.405 --> 01:31:24.688
<v Donnie Oliveira>The residential system is franchise system where private companies provide service on behalf of the city to assigned geographies, and the city sets the rules governing the types of service that must be provided through franchise agreements.

774
01:31:25.492 --> 01:31:31.082
<v Donnie Oliveira>And as a reminder, the rate formulas are set by franchise agreements that are negotiated every 5 to 7 years.

775
01:31:31.757 --> 01:31:35.421
<v Donnie Oliveira>Council reviews the rates annually, but there is not much discretion in annual rate setting.

776
01:31:35.935 --> 01:31:40.720
<v Donnie Oliveira>The expectation, of course, is that we honor the agreed-to formulas so that we maintain services across the city.

777
01:31:41.555 --> 01:31:49.168
<v Donnie Oliveira>Per the franchise agreements, residential rates are set based on a cost of service plus an allowance for target operating margin and incorporation of the city's franchise fee.

778
01:31:49.890 --> 01:31:57.185
<v Donnie Oliveira>In contrast, the commercial system is a free market system where the city sets rules and establishes a per-ton tipping fee, but customers may choose their hauler.

779
01:31:57.506 --> 01:31:59.045
<v Donnie Oliveira>And again, we don't set those rates.

780
01:31:59.829 --> 01:32:00.247
<v Donnie Oliveira>Excuse me.

781
01:32:01.432 --> 01:32:02.042
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide, please.

782
01:32:03.516 --> 01:32:11.177
<v Donnie Oliveira>Real quick, This slide just encapsulates some of the things that we're solving for as a part of the rate setting.

783
01:32:11.755 --> 01:32:23.083
<v Donnie Oliveira>Of course, you have the typical things like fuel, wage benefits, maintenance and repairs that contribute to increasing costs, not just in the waste system but across the board in our economy.

784
01:32:24.029 --> 01:32:36.376
<v Donnie Oliveira>But this year we're also calibrating against investments from the Recycling Modernization Act related to glass incentives and recycling process costs that are continuing to evolve with the state's legislation.

785
01:32:37.231 --> 01:32:38.993
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that's, that's some good news for our future as well.

786
01:32:39.478 --> 01:32:40.091
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide, please.

787
01:32:42.207 --> 01:32:50.002
<v Donnie Oliveira>And this is intended to give a snapshot of what this looks like for our customers for the residential rate setting.

788
01:32:50.534 --> 01:32:57.228
<v Donnie Oliveira>So just for backdrop, the review process begins in January when we have a detailed cost report from each hauler.

789
01:32:57.746 --> 01:32:58.291
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, sent to us.

790
01:32:58.724 --> 01:33:01.609
<v Donnie Oliveira>We send those to a certified public accountant to vet those costs.

791
01:33:02.489 --> 01:33:07.202
<v Donnie Oliveira>We then adjust costs with the CPA and work with economists to prepare the rate model.

792
01:33:07.779 --> 01:33:11.113
<v Donnie Oliveira>In early April, we meet with the haulers and host public information sessions.

793
01:33:11.770 --> 01:33:16.449
<v Donnie Oliveira>And included in that cost, of course, is the Metro disposal fees, which they set annually.

794
01:33:17.171 --> 01:33:21.738
<v Donnie Oliveira>In prior years, we would have used the actual proposed Metro fees, which don't become available until May.

795
01:33:22.347 --> 01:33:30.307
<v Donnie Oliveira>But in order to create more time for council to absorb those proposed rates and act on them, this year we are to use an assumed Metro rate based on the prior year's cost escalator.

796
01:33:32.239 --> 01:33:38.779
<v Donnie Oliveira>If Metro's actual rates increase more than a forecasted inflator, then we'll, we'll have to catch up with our system.

797
01:33:39.492 --> 01:33:46.817
<v Donnie Oliveira>That appears to be the case this year as Metro is considering 10% increases for waste and organics disposal, which would continue the trend of disposal increases well above inflation.

798
01:33:48.000 --> 01:33:55.435
<v Donnie Oliveira>Because proposed rates include a modest increase this year, driving higher costs include wages, benefits, as I alluded to, We'll have to calibrate that.

799
01:33:56.510 --> 01:33:59.336
<v Donnie Oliveira>We are not proposing any increase to the commercial tonnage fee this year.

800
01:34:00.105 --> 01:34:07.475
<v Donnie Oliveira>And if you adjust our rates for inflation, waste rates overall have been flat over the past 2 decades, rising slightly less than the overall rate of inflation.

801
01:34:07.988 --> 01:34:12.130
<v Donnie Oliveira>That means your garbage bill today is similar to what it was in 2012, adjusted for inflation.

802
01:34:13.430 --> 01:34:23.556
<v Donnie Oliveira>Last thing, a reminder that in 2025, we implemented a financial assistance program for qualified homeowners that comes with a discount of about $22 per month as at the $35 a gallon service level.

803
01:34:24.637 --> 01:34:27.622
<v Donnie Oliveira>Since launch in November, we have 900 customers enrolled.

804
01:34:28.091 --> 01:34:34.798
<v Donnie Oliveira>We're now working on ways to expand eligibility to low-income renters, and we also launched standardized rates for bulk items this year.

805
01:34:34.880 --> 01:34:43.604
<v Donnie Oliveira>I also want to thank the director of BES and Water for their support in getting that launched, and thanks, team, for your collaboration there.

806
01:34:44.725 --> 01:34:45.682
<v Donnie Oliveira>And next slide, please.

807
01:34:47.389 --> 01:34:48.015
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide, please.

808
01:34:49.493 --> 01:35:06.599
<v Donnie Oliveira>And the last thing we'll touch on, as has been adopted the last 2 years and the proposed fiscal year '26-'27 budget, there's a proposal to transfer interest accrued, in this case fiscal year '24-'25, from the PSIF interest into the general fund.

809
01:35:07.161 --> 01:35:11.032
<v Donnie Oliveira>That amount is, as you see on the screen, is just a little over $26 million.

810
01:35:11.884 --> 01:35:16.317
<v Donnie Oliveira>This is a one-time effort, so it each year council contemplates it.

811
01:35:16.398 --> 01:35:25.563
<v Donnie Oliveira>We will have to come back to amend the code to make that adjustment, and that will be, um, a part of this year's— it's built into this year's budget, proposed budget.

812
01:35:27.244 --> 01:35:29.783
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that's— that wraps for our content.

813
01:35:31.418 --> 01:35:33.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you all very much.

814
01:35:34.430 --> 01:35:35.645
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, it's 11 o'clock.

815
01:35:35.953 --> 01:35:37.264
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is time for a quick restroom break.

816
01:35:37.345 --> 01:35:38.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd like everybody back here at 11:15.

817
01:35:40.542 --> 01:35:41.282
<v Jamie Dunphy>See you in a few minutes.

818
01:54:10.157 --> 01:54:12.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi everybody, welcome back to this, and we're going to jump into questions.

819
01:54:14.032 --> 01:54:18.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>And since most of my colleagues are not here, I'm going to lead us off.

820
01:54:21.838 --> 01:54:32.461
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I wanted to briefly sort of connect our conversation yesterday about the water bonds and talk about the rate increases that we are projecting and how that what that really sort of means for people.

821
01:54:32.957 --> 01:54:38.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, in my district in East Portland, like most communities, people are feeling really stretched.

822
01:54:40.104 --> 01:54:47.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>At the same time, the combined One Water Bureau has a $3.6 billion-ish budget.

823
01:54:48.292 --> 01:54:56.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>And from what I can tell from these slides, we're cutting about $6.6 million between BES and water, largely by eliminating vacancies.

824
01:54:56.787 --> 01:55:00.701
<v Jamie Dunphy>And some sort of smaller cuts like custodial services and security.

825
01:55:00.829 --> 01:55:15.876
<v Jamie Dunphy>But if my math adds up correctly, while $6.6 million is a big number empirically, in comparison to the total budget, it's like 0.02% of the total budget that is being cut while we are also raising rates by 6% this year.

826
01:55:16.921 --> 01:55:26.284
<v Jamie Dunphy>So my first question is, if expenses are outpacing incomes, why are these 2 bureaus not taking deeper cuts proportionate to what the other city bureaus are taking rather than raising rates?

827
01:55:29.775 --> 01:55:31.171
<v Ting Lu>Thank you so much for the question.

828
01:55:31.378 --> 01:55:37.595
<v Ting Lu>We also recognize balancing affordability and the long-term investment for the utility bureaus.

829
01:55:38.109 --> 01:55:53.203
<v Ting Lu>I want to say, even though you see there is over $1.5 billion and $2.0 billion for both BES and the Water Bureau, but that's actually the operating budget of those billion dollars are much smaller than the billion dollars there.

830
01:55:53.619 --> 01:56:00.748
<v Ting Lu>So for BES, about $700 million, less than $700 million are operating.

831
01:56:00.926 --> 01:56:07.189
<v Ting Lu>A lot of them are already obligated for different PURS and other payments.

832
01:56:07.591 --> 01:56:11.404
<v Ting Lu>And then we also have about 1/3 of that is a capital program.

833
01:56:11.836 --> 01:56:19.542
<v Ting Lu>We are very committed for the CIP project and making sure we don't defer any of the risk to the future generations too.

834
01:56:20.152 --> 01:56:24.766
<v Ting Lu>And then another 1/3 of that is to the debt payment and all the fund management.

835
01:56:24.814 --> 01:56:30.426
<v Ting Lu>And it's really fund moving within the— between the city construction and CIP.

836
01:56:30.762 --> 01:56:37.127
<v Ting Lu>So the true operating budget that BES can adjust is a little bit over $200 million.

837
01:56:37.496 --> 01:56:39.805
<v Ting Lu>So it's not the Water Bureau.

838
01:56:40.125 --> 01:56:45.431
<v Ting Lu>The operating budget is around $100 million on the operating side that we can adjust.

839
01:56:45.655 --> 01:56:47.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, that makes some sense.

840
01:56:49.250 --> 01:57:01.243
<v Jamie Dunphy>So on slide 28, I think it was, our model combined the water and sewer bill on— sorry, I'm reading my notes funny.

841
01:57:02.021 --> 01:57:10.877
<v Jamie Dunphy>Looks like the model shows that the combined water sewer bill will double to about $300 a month by 2035.

842
01:57:11.023 --> 01:57:25.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if we held a conservative, like steady 4% increase after that to 2060, to pay our covenanted water bonds, today's young people, when they're looking at retirement, will be looking at a bill of almost $800 a month.

843
01:57:27.207 --> 01:57:34.555
<v Jamie Dunphy>If we adjusted for— if we accounted for inflation based on today's median retirement income, that bill would still be roughly 50% of monthly income.

844
01:57:36.201 --> 01:57:38.247
<v Jamie Dunphy>I feel like we should be doing a lot about this right now.

845
01:57:38.393 --> 01:57:51.768
<v Jamie Dunphy>So my question is, what are we doing to prevent future, uh, rising costs that we know a lot of these costs are out of our control, but what are we doing now to correct this course for those folks in 2060?

846
01:57:54.412 --> 01:58:07.533
<v Ting Lu>Uh, yeah, I look at it as both as how we are adjusting right now for operation efficiencies as well as looking to the long-term financial planning to making sure we have sustained financial health for both bureaus.

847
01:58:07.791 --> 01:58:19.578
<v Ting Lu>There are multiple ways we are looking to this holistically first, we are looking to, like I mentioned, based on the risk-based asset management approach to prioritizing our CIP project.

848
01:58:19.913 --> 01:58:24.753
<v Ting Lu>We know we won't be able to address all the capital asset.

849
01:58:25.137 --> 01:58:32.109
<v Ting Lu>So combined for both water and BES, we have over $50 billion for the asset underground or above ground.

850
01:58:32.556 --> 01:58:37.716
<v Ting Lu>So there is a lot of the investment and aging infrastructure we still have to maintain.

851
01:58:37.780 --> 01:58:37.908
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

852
01:58:38.118 --> 01:58:41.875
<v Ting Lu>So we are really prioritizing and using risk-based approach for that.

853
01:58:42.180 --> 01:58:47.703
<v Ting Lu>The second is making sure we are continuing to explore business opportunities and diversify our revenues.

854
01:58:48.216 --> 01:58:55.730
<v Ting Lu>So how we can attract more business and the commercial partners just with other bureaus together within the city.

855
01:58:56.164 --> 01:59:02.362
<v Ting Lu>I truly believe we have the great water source and we are here and we want to support folks coming to Portland.

856
01:59:03.149 --> 01:59:10.706
<v Ting Lu>The last piece is, I will say, is we are continuing to seek extra external funding opportunities, including low-interest loans and grants.

857
01:59:10.770 --> 01:59:15.407
<v Ting Lu>And for BES, we are already looking to 5 additional grants.

858
01:59:15.858 --> 01:59:17.854
<v Ting Lu>And this is going to be also for Water Bureau.

859
01:59:17.935 --> 01:59:22.219
<v Ting Lu>We are actively looking to different ways, incentives to lower the cost.

860
01:59:23.024 --> 01:59:26.132
<v Ting Lu>The last piece, the operational efficiency between the 2 bureaus.

861
01:59:26.631 --> 01:59:36.561
<v Ting Lu>I'm very confident with the One Water effort, we can look into additional shared services and cost savings moving forward, and happy to provide more update on that effort in the future.

862
01:59:37.858 --> 01:59:38.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

863
01:59:38.422 --> 01:59:40.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would love to make sure that we do have that.

864
01:59:40.295 --> 01:59:43.894
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that this is a narrative that the community wants to have.

865
01:59:44.087 --> 01:59:50.037
<v Jamie Dunphy>We want to hear if we are investing this much money into our infrastructure, that also it's not going to bankrupt us in the future.

866
01:59:50.135 --> 02:00:01.948
<v Jamie Dunphy>And there are a number of terrifying cautionary tales that we've seen around the country where municipalities get into infrastructure and then end up declaring bankruptcy and we privatize systems.

867
02:00:02.012 --> 02:00:04.121
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm honestly really worried about this.

868
02:00:04.217 --> 02:00:13.207
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I hope that is the, you know, this great chapter of these bureaus is about the filtration plant and getting the 2 to combine.

869
02:00:13.465 --> 02:00:21.788
<v Jamie Dunphy>I hope that the next chapter is about affordability and that we look at every area that we can start cutting pennies and trying to make this system more efficient.

870
02:00:22.158 --> 02:00:30.916
<v Priya Dhanapal>So if, Councilor, if I may add one additional thing that the bureau is focusing on is rate design, and we look forward to working in the next couple of years on how we can streamline that as well.

871
02:00:31.284 --> 02:00:36.529
<v Priya Dhanapal>And that will play a huge role in affordability as well as how we can make it better for different customer classes.

872
02:00:36.577 --> 02:00:38.197
<v Priya Dhanapal>So that's something that's upcoming as well.

873
02:00:38.582 --> 02:00:39.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

874
02:00:40.426 --> 02:00:41.051
<v Jamie Dunphy>My time is up.

875
02:00:41.099 --> 02:00:41.805
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm at 5 minutes.

876
02:00:41.868 --> 02:00:43.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

877
02:00:44.194 --> 02:00:46.005
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

878
02:00:46.421 --> 02:00:51.858
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to build off of where Council President just left off and where you were kind of starting to head.

879
02:00:52.595 --> 02:01:04.042
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know my office has been in discussions starting to talk with your team about rate design and what it would look like to engage in a significant rate structure review process.

880
02:01:04.154 --> 02:01:10.868
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This is something that Councilor Green and I, I know is at the top of our list and when we're talking about public works.

881
02:01:11.427 --> 02:01:17.372
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I do believe there's a strong need to undertake a comprehensive redesign of our rate system.

882
02:01:18.012 --> 02:01:25.992
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'd like to invite you, Director or DCA Dhanapal, or a combination of you both to speak a little bit more about that effort and what you're thinking.

883
02:01:27.305 --> 02:01:32.480
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'm gonna have Director Lew talk about the different strategies.

884
02:01:32.577 --> 02:01:35.975
<v Priya Dhanapal>We are looking at rate design, and we're looking forward to partnering with you all on this too.

885
02:01:36.103 --> 02:01:40.734
<v Priya Dhanapal>And thanks to Councilor Green and you, Councilor Carmelina, as well on the interest in rate design.

886
02:01:41.470 --> 02:01:50.509
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, I think this is really building to the holistic rate strategy and how we want to make sure we have affordable, equitable rate for everyone.

887
02:01:50.957 --> 02:01:56.951
<v Ting Lu>So right now, the Water Bureau, we have the rate is the— everyone have the same, the base rate.

888
02:01:57.528 --> 02:02:00.427
<v Ting Lu>So I think there's different ways we can look into.

889
02:02:00.636 --> 02:02:03.231
<v Ting Lu>It's really looking to what the outcomes we are looking for.

890
02:02:03.663 --> 02:02:10.778
<v Ting Lu>So for some of the cities, they are looking for conservation, and then you'll want to incentivize people conserving the water.

891
02:02:11.131 --> 02:02:20.296
<v Ting Lu>And others are looking for economic development, and then you want to look into how do you build the policy and rate design to support the outcomes you are looking for.

892
02:02:21.081 --> 02:02:24.444
<v Ting Lu>So we would love to get the council's feedback.

893
02:02:24.509 --> 02:02:25.918
<v Ting Lu>And before we get into this, Councilor Loretta Smith.

894
02:02:26.448 --> 02:02:35.613
<v Ting Lu>Next stage and making sure we are continue having that engagement with council members and communities and moving forward on this very important initiative.

895
02:02:36.286 --> 02:02:36.654
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

896
02:02:36.926 --> 02:02:43.127
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are there resources or funds ID'd to get this plan moving as soon as possible?

897
02:02:43.238 --> 02:02:46.699
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And how soon could we be starting these conversations and this work?

898
02:02:47.404 --> 02:02:50.033
<v Ting Lu>We have already started the conversation within the bureaus.

899
02:02:50.145 --> 02:03:05.340
<v Ting Lu>So it's really getting these outcomes and the policy guidance first, and then we, we can already kind of starting to put some of the information and data on where we are, um, so we can follow up on that after the budget here.

900
02:03:05.869 --> 02:03:06.143
<v Mitch Green>Great.

901
02:03:06.416 --> 02:03:12.068
<v Priya Dhanapal>To specifically, we do have, um, a budgeted amount in this fiscal year to account for rate study.

902
02:03:12.453 --> 02:03:13.287
<v Ting Lu>So great.

903
02:03:13.399 --> 02:03:16.274
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I look forward to exploring this more in the Public Works Committee.

904
02:03:16.692 --> 02:03:17.270
<v Ting Lu>Thanks.

905
02:03:18.297 --> 02:03:19.518
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

906
02:03:19.759 --> 02:03:20.288
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

907
02:03:22.672 --> 02:03:24.315
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

908
02:03:25.780 --> 02:03:32.042
<v Mitch Green>Director Lew, you have a very difficult job, but I have the full confidence in you that you can do this job.

909
02:03:32.475 --> 02:03:34.082
<v Mitch Green>I've been impressed by your leadership.

910
02:03:34.469 --> 02:03:50.427
<v Mitch Green>You bring a level of industry-standard leading-edge expertise to the table, and I just wanted to say that first because we've had a lot of discussion coming out of my office in particular about calling the question on certain projects and rate proposals.

911
02:03:50.475 --> 02:03:56.043
<v Mitch Green>So I don't want my skepticism to be construed as a lack of faith in the current leadership.

912
02:03:56.204 --> 02:03:58.046
<v Mitch Green>I think you've made a great choice, DCA Dhanapal.

913
02:03:58.774 --> 02:04:12.469
<v Mitch Green>So my question though is to sort of speak to— I don't understand though on the rate slide how we get from 9.8% in a 2038-2031 rate proposal and then down to 6%.

914
02:04:12.725 --> 02:04:14.719
<v Mitch Green>So I think that's a great question.

915
02:04:16.284 --> 02:04:23.605
<v Mitch Green>Because my understanding is that we have constant debt service that's going to happen through 2060 at like $168 million.

916
02:04:24.104 --> 02:04:27.359
<v Mitch Green>And then also, I think the WIFIA loans start to be in repayment.

917
02:04:27.472 --> 02:04:29.703
<v Mitch Green>So help me understand a little bit.

918
02:04:29.945 --> 02:04:33.389
<v Mitch Green>And maybe, you know, if I see— well, I see, I see Mr. Biery approaching.

919
02:04:34.908 --> 02:04:38.698
<v Mitch Green>Um, I, I don't really get how we get that drop.

920
02:04:38.747 --> 02:04:39.837
<v Mitch Green>And so help me understand.

921
02:04:40.358 --> 02:04:40.503
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

922
02:04:42.792 --> 02:04:47.426
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, thank you, Councilor, and apologies 'cause I don't have a detailed set of numbers in front of me.

923
02:04:47.490 --> 02:04:50.154
<v Jonas Biery>But for the record, Jonas Biery, City Chief Financial Officer.

924
02:04:52.680 --> 02:04:58.811
<v Jonas Biery>As we kind of mentioned during the council session last night, there's a lot of dynamic things changing up and changing down, right?

925
02:04:58.860 --> 02:05:01.912
<v Jonas Biery>And so the bureau's forecast considers all of those, right?

926
02:05:01.962 --> 02:05:05.854
<v Jonas Biery>The operational costs, and a big piece of that is the debt service cost.

927
02:05:06.162 --> 02:05:16.898
<v Jonas Biery>Because we have, in the context of this slide that I think is still up on the screen, because of the capital investment happening right now on the project, we're sort of adding debt, right?

928
02:05:16.962 --> 02:05:23.421
<v Jonas Biery>As we're doing additional issues over the next few years to meet the obligation, that debt service is increasing over time.

929
02:05:24.015 --> 02:05:30.539
<v Jonas Biery>And then you get to, I think in this slide, around '29, '30, we stop those increases in debt service and it levels out.

930
02:05:30.989 --> 02:05:32.467
<v Jonas Biery>I'm oversimplifying a little bit.

931
02:05:32.534 --> 02:05:32.585
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah.

932
02:05:32.792 --> 02:05:39.448
<v Jonas Biery>But that's where you start to see that ability to drop because we're gaining other things in the forecast, customers, et cetera.

933
02:05:39.833 --> 02:05:44.005
<v Jonas Biery>But you don't need that incremental increase to meet new additional incremental debt service.

934
02:05:44.101 --> 02:05:51.015
<v Mitch Green>I want to go back to a thing you just said, which I don't think has been obvious to everyone else in the public, which is there's other stuff in the forecast.

935
02:05:51.079 --> 02:05:54.305
<v Mitch Green>We're gaining projected increases in revenues.

936
02:05:55.091 --> 02:05:59.117
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's really important to emphasize here because there's 2 pieces of the ledger.

937
02:05:59.717 --> 02:06:02.152
<v Mitch Green>And so thanks for saying that.

938
02:06:02.216 --> 02:06:12.201
<v Mitch Green>So what I'm reading here is the incremental difference between $6.2 and $9.8 is driven largely by just adding these new debt obligations in the short run.

939
02:06:13.865 --> 02:06:27.305
<v Mitch Green>But because we'll stop adding the new debt obligations, and then at the same time, we're projected a growth in revenue through population growth, economic, whatever our forecasts are, That helps bring it down.

940
02:06:27.386 --> 02:06:28.439
<v Mitch Green>That's right?

941
02:06:28.845 --> 02:06:29.445
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, that's correct.

942
02:06:29.510 --> 02:06:38.117
<v Jonas Biery>I mean, essentially it's stopping that, you know, no longer needing those incremental, significant incremental increases in debt service as that project gets completed.

943
02:06:38.940 --> 02:06:39.344
<v Mitch Green>That's helpful.

944
02:06:39.393 --> 02:06:44.726
<v Mitch Green>So what happens, and I don't, if we don't plan this far out, but what happens after 2025, 2036, Director?

945
02:06:48.309 --> 02:06:53.841
<v Mitch Green>Do we have a long-run rates forecast that goes like 30 years out or do we, is it just, Is it just through '35?

946
02:06:55.657 --> 02:06:57.426
<v Ting Lu>We do have the historical as well.

947
02:06:58.011 --> 02:06:58.172
<v Ting Lu>Okay.

948
02:06:58.676 --> 02:06:59.065
<v Ting Lu>Yeah.

949
02:06:59.390 --> 02:07:05.323
<v Ting Lu>And I will also add, Councilor Green, this is also typical for large infrastructure investment.

950
02:07:05.387 --> 02:07:12.507
<v Ting Lu>So, you know, for BES, when we are building the big pipes, so the rate for certain years getting to the double digit.

951
02:07:13.010 --> 02:07:28.949
<v Ting Lu>And because we also have get the 25-year loans and we are just getting paid off on that, so that's, Typical when you have this large infrastructures getting to the double digit and getting down and now it's really stabilized and focus on other day-to-day maintenance part.

952
02:07:28.949 --> 02:07:35.189
<v Jonas Biery>And sorry, Councilor, if I may jump in, I think your question was also what happens beyond '35, '36?

953
02:07:35.189 --> 02:07:36.439
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, does it stay at 5.7%?

954
02:07:36.729 --> 02:07:40.770
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, and I'll add, I think there's probably Bureau staff in the room who know the answer to that.

955
02:07:40.770 --> 02:07:42.470
<v Jonas Biery>The Bureau does forecast beyond that.

956
02:07:42.470 --> 02:07:47.810
<v Jonas Biery>The one thing I'll note is, you know, as you go farther out in the chain, those forecasts become a lot more unpredictable.

957
02:07:47.810 --> 02:07:48.729
<v Mitch Green>But your jaws of uncertainty.

958
02:07:48.850 --> 02:07:49.390
<v Jonas Biery>That's exactly exactly right.

959
02:07:49.615 --> 02:07:49.760
<v Jonas Biery>Right.

960
02:07:49.936 --> 02:07:53.176
<v Jonas Biery>And I just would use that example you just made, the JAWS example.

961
02:07:53.320 --> 02:08:09.326
<v Jonas Biery>What I would love to be able to do, not just for the utilities, but for all citywide forecasts, is develop the bandwidth and rigor so that when we prepare forecasts, we're not just preparing that straight-line forecast, but being able to prepare those more gradient levels of outcomes.

962
02:08:09.662 --> 02:08:15.082
<v Jonas Biery>We're not there yet, but I just will plant that seed today that that's something that I'd really like to be able to achieve in the coming years.

963
02:08:15.131 --> 02:08:15.404
<v Jonas Biery>Councilor Herbold.

964
02:08:15.681 --> 02:08:16.533
<v Mitch Green>I'd like to support that.

965
02:08:16.582 --> 02:08:19.944
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to move on because I only have a minute and a half left, but thanks for that clarification.

966
02:08:22.260 --> 02:08:30.631
<v Mitch Green>As I've worked through the budget amendments, as we've all worked through the budget amendments, we've had to deal with the general fund discretionary versus general fund overhead type of costing problem.

967
02:08:31.372 --> 02:08:41.055
<v Mitch Green>And my understanding is the general fund overhead is an overhead cost that needs to go back to— and it's billed by things like rate-funded bureaus as well as other parts of the agency.

968
02:08:41.764 --> 02:08:56.173
<v Mitch Green>And so this might be too complicated of a question for the time I have, but how much of the management or the staff outside of the bureaus are being funded by rates through this overhead model?

969
02:08:57.381 --> 02:09:03.228
<v Mitch Green>And I can take an answer in writing later, but I'm starting to kind of see that a little bit as I'm looking through this.

970
02:09:03.358 --> 02:09:07.993
<v Mitch Green>And it's— I see Director Levine getting Nancy back there as well.

971
02:09:08.059 --> 02:09:13.146
<v Mitch Green>So that's a question that I think we do need to get a handle on at this council.

972
02:09:17.356 --> 02:09:17.551
<v Deborah Scroggin>Thanks.

973
02:09:18.170 --> 02:09:19.747
<v Simone Reddy>Yeah, for the record, Ruth Levine, Budget Director.

974
02:09:19.796 --> 02:09:21.975
<v Simone Reddy>Just real quick, and then we can get you the exact numbers.

975
02:09:23.289 --> 02:09:34.360
<v Simone Reddy>It fluctuates based on the fiscal year and how big each of the respective bureaus is, but water, sewer, and transportation are each roughly 10 to 13% of our revenue.

976
02:09:34.868 --> 02:09:43.755
<v Simone Reddy>Of the sort of, if you think about the revenue paying for those overhead costs in the city, depends on the year and the specific bureau.

977
02:09:43.819 --> 02:09:44.430
<v Simone Reddy>We can get you those.

978
02:09:44.479 --> 02:09:51.340
<v Simone Reddy>So that's the percentage of the overhead cost pool that is paid by each of those bureaus.

979
02:09:51.917 --> 02:09:52.351
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

980
02:09:53.042 --> 02:09:59.389
<v Mitch Green>I think I just wanna flag one of the things I'm concerned about, and it's not just about the bureau, the rate-funded bureau model.

981
02:10:00.556 --> 02:10:01.502
<v Mitch Green>Contributing to the overhead.

982
02:10:01.614 --> 02:10:16.716
<v Mitch Green>But when we grow our city and the billable parts that are overhead of our city, we start to put a cost on our rate-funded bureaus as well as, you know, when we grow our costs in the internal services fund model.

983
02:10:17.645 --> 02:10:23.753
<v Mitch Green>It's this indirect way of also putting costs on the general fund, and I just— that gives me a lot of anxiety.

984
02:10:23.818 --> 02:10:38.377
<v Mitch Green>And I hope that as we develop these budgets going forward, we start to really make that very clear earlier on, and we think about what we can do to, to ring-fence a little bit the impact, particularly to ratepayers.

985
02:10:38.796 --> 02:10:45.930
<v Mitch Green>Because I, I think at some point you get outside of what's an allowable, um, uh, rate cost, cost of service thing.

986
02:10:46.042 --> 02:10:55.550
<v Mitch Green>And so, um, I don't have a— I'm not asking for an answer right now, but it's thanks.

987
02:10:55.550 --> 02:10:56.680
<v Mitch Green>I think I'm out of time.

988
02:10:56.970 --> 02:10:57.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>You are.

989
02:10:57.930 --> 02:10:59.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, thank you, Councilor Green.

990
02:11:00.810 --> 02:11:05.310
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

991
02:11:05.310 --> 02:11:06.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thanks, Council President.

992
02:11:06.510 --> 02:11:13.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>I'm gonna stick with the water and BES questions here.

993
02:11:14.529 --> 02:11:27.636
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>You know, some of my colleagues have asked questions about those increases, and I want to note that on that graph that was just shown, the increases in the CFO Biery, you used language about things coming down.

994
02:11:27.701 --> 02:11:38.635
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>What we're talking about is the rate of increase coming down, but we still have increases through those out years when we're finished paying off the bonds.

995
02:11:39.573 --> 02:11:43.712
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Rates don't come down, they just go up less every year under these projections.

996
02:11:45.886 --> 02:12:02.286
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And so I'm wondering Director Liu, if you can help us understand what service would look like if we asked you, not for this year, not for this budget, but it's budget season, so we get to talk about this.

997
02:12:03.676 --> 02:12:27.592
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>What would it take to not have rates increasing at the doubling rate that they are, to not not to see 9.5 or 9.8 on top of 9.8 on top of 9.8, and then that dropping to between 4 and 6% a year, but to, I don't know, maybe cut by 25% that rate of increase.

998
02:12:27.784 --> 02:12:41.854
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>What would that mean in terms of changes in service level, changes in customer service, changes in— where would you go if we said that it was a priority of council to not have rates increase?

999
02:12:41.918 --> 02:12:42.512
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Well, I think that's a great question.

1000
02:12:42.819 --> 02:12:43.429
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>At that rate?

1001
02:12:45.046 --> 02:12:46.463
<v Ting Lu>Thank you so much for the question.

1002
02:12:46.657 --> 02:12:52.744
<v Ting Lu>I want to recognize this is where we are looking for the long-term financial strategy here.

1003
02:12:52.939 --> 02:13:01.472
<v Ting Lu>Like I mentioned earlier, so one is really growing our customer base, rate base for both the utility bureaus and for the Portland city as a whole.

1004
02:13:01.891 --> 02:13:04.721
<v Ting Lu>I think we have a great infrastructure, we have a great city.

1005
02:13:04.787 --> 02:13:11.237
<v Ting Lu>I'm very confident for the future, people coming here and the business and commercial partners that will really help.

1006
02:13:11.380 --> 02:13:13.354
<v Ting Lu>Spread the rates in the future.

1007
02:13:13.739 --> 02:13:17.159
<v Ting Lu>At the same time, I also want to say it's a trade-off.

1008
02:13:17.256 --> 02:13:18.845
<v Ting Lu>It's a risk-based approach.

1009
02:13:19.344 --> 02:13:33.296
<v Ting Lu>And this is something we would love to also provide more information from an asset management perspective to getting council's, the policy decisions too, because some of our infrastructure is 50 to 100 years old.

1010
02:13:33.649 --> 02:13:36.555
<v Ting Lu>So we are looking to a risk-based approach.

1011
02:13:36.619 --> 02:13:36.716
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

1012
02:13:37.023 --> 02:13:42.612
<v Ting Lu>And understanding the condition and what is the most likely to fail for this infrastructure.

1013
02:13:42.918 --> 02:13:45.164
<v Ting Lu>And then we are going to do that investment first.

1014
02:13:46.229 --> 02:13:53.391
<v Ting Lu>So that's really helped us to be more prioritizing based on risk model and minimizing the customer impact.

1015
02:13:54.641 --> 02:13:57.198
<v Ting Lu>And then there is a trade-off and risk on that.

1016
02:13:57.359 --> 02:14:02.087
<v Ting Lu>Anything that if we don't address, there is emergency repair, that's always—.

1017
02:14:02.119 --> 02:14:02.280
<v Ting Lu>Right.

1018
02:14:02.488 --> 02:14:11.453
<v Ting Lu>Expensive just because, you know, you have to pay that right away and it really doesn't support your infrastructure overall.

1019
02:14:11.710 --> 02:14:17.323
<v Ting Lu>So it is a trade-off discussion on how we are growing our customer base together.

1020
02:14:17.547 --> 02:14:23.658
<v Ting Lu>But I'm very hopeful how we are getting more consistent and projecting our rates and getting better in the future.

1021
02:14:24.845 --> 02:14:27.122
<v Raymond C. Lee>And Councilor, I would like to add to that as well.

1022
02:14:27.811 --> 02:14:43.618
<v Raymond C. Lee>What you see in most cities when they go through this type of conversation or have this type of conversation, this is when you start getting to the situation of deferred maintenance and just putting off things that you had routinely scheduled for now to a later date.

1023
02:14:43.859 --> 02:14:47.271
<v Raymond C. Lee>And that number just starts to grow over time.

1024
02:14:47.337 --> 02:14:48.743
<v Raymond C. Lee>That number does not go away.

1025
02:14:49.277 --> 02:14:50.528
<v Raymond C. Lee>It just starts to increase.

1026
02:14:53.113 --> 02:14:54.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>I appreciate that.

1027
02:14:54.177 --> 02:15:07.426
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And I think there's maybe a broader conversation that I'm not on the committee, but Vice President Clark, maybe your committee could have on, on council's behalf before next budget season.

1028
02:15:08.260 --> 02:15:23.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Because if the answer truly is the only things we can cut are maintenance costs or service costs, then I think we need to have that honest conversation with Portlanders and be really clear about the fact that rates are going up.

1029
02:15:23.560 --> 02:15:29.176
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>We are in line with comparable cities, and if we don't do this, we'll pay later.

1030
02:15:29.930 --> 02:15:39.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And if there are places where we could provide service differently, really do the hard work to make sure we're identifying those.

1031
02:15:40.346 --> 02:15:50.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>We only talk about rates in the middle of budget season for the most part, when it's kind of a yes/no, as opposed to these longer conversations.

1032
02:15:50.073 --> 02:15:52.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And I'm very uncomfortable hearing that our—.

1033
02:15:52.351 --> 02:15:52.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1034
02:15:53.506 --> 02:16:15.470
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Our only solution right now is to shift who pays how much, which I don't think always actually works out well for consumers, or to assume that growth will take care of this for us by spreading the ratepayer base, which I assume Portland will grow, but the extent we would need to grow to do that makes me a bit nervous.

1035
02:16:15.519 --> 02:16:21.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>So I hope that we can have some broader conversations with the Bureau and the service area.

1036
02:16:21.811 --> 02:16:22.005
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thank you.

1037
02:16:25.569 --> 02:16:38.049
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Council President, can I just respond to that?

1038
02:16:38.069 --> 02:16:39.110
<v Simone Reddy>Absolutely.

1039
02:16:39.110 --> 02:16:42.350
<v Olivia Clark>I just— I appreciate that, um, Councilwoman Pirtle-Guiney.

1040
02:16:42.350 --> 02:16:48.010
<v Olivia Clark>We have already talked about restructuring, that that's on our agenda, but in September we're going to In be having September, a discussion about the budget.

1041
02:16:48.727 --> 02:16:54.447
<v Olivia Clark>We're scheduled to receive the asset management report, which will give us an idea of where we're behind as well.

1042
02:16:54.992 --> 02:16:58.212
<v Olivia Clark>And that might also be an opportunity to kick off this conversation.

1043
02:16:58.277 --> 02:16:59.718
<v Olivia Clark>But I really appreciate your input.

1044
02:17:01.081 --> 02:17:02.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thank you, Vice President.

1045
02:17:02.121 --> 02:17:07.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And as you know, I'm a big supporter of that asset management work.

1046
02:17:07.154 --> 02:17:18.623
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>And maybe that's a place where we can not necessarily lower costs, but pay for things in a different way so that that right on.

1047
02:17:20.110 --> 02:17:20.513
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thank you.

1048
02:17:20.659 --> 02:17:21.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thanks, Council President.

1049
02:17:21.968 --> 02:17:22.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1050
02:17:22.597 --> 02:17:23.147
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1051
02:17:25.037 --> 02:17:25.731
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

1052
02:17:25.909 --> 02:17:28.981
<v Loretta Smith>I just want to piggyback on what Councilor Pirtle-Guiney was talking about.

1053
02:17:29.078 --> 02:17:46.459
<v Loretta Smith>I think a more appropriate place would be at the Committee of the Whole in the finance section because we're talking about money, and those are the things that we need to talk about, not just in our specific Public Utility— I mean, Public Works Committee.

1054
02:17:47.120 --> 02:17:50.119
<v Loretta Smith>And I'll talk to Councilor Kanal about that.

1055
02:17:50.683 --> 02:17:55.335
<v Loretta Smith>The only question— thank you all for the— thank you for the presentation.

1056
02:17:55.385 --> 02:17:56.131
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate it.

1057
02:17:56.197 --> 02:18:02.108
<v Loretta Smith>It's tough when you have to talk about ratepayers and that they have to pay increased costs.

1058
02:18:02.301 --> 02:18:05.529
<v Loretta Smith>It's just, you know, one of those things that you hate to really talk about.

1059
02:18:05.933 --> 02:18:07.004
<v Loretta Smith>But I want to go back to the budget.

1060
02:18:07.068 --> 02:18:07.198
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1061
02:18:07.880 --> 02:18:27.911
<v Loretta Smith>Um, in your, in your service area, um, DCA, um, Priya, what is the projected ending balance for the Water Bureau, Parks, and Transportation?

1062
02:18:28.512 --> 02:18:33.860
<v Priya Dhanapal>Jeremy, um, Are you able to answer that?

1063
02:18:33.924 --> 02:18:45.286
<v Loretta Smith>And if that projected— and if in the second piece to it, and if that projected ending balance is going forward to pay for '26-'27?

1064
02:18:47.552 --> 02:18:50.060
<v Priya Dhanapal>That's a great question, Councilor Smith.

1065
02:18:50.207 --> 02:18:52.326
<v Priya Dhanapal>We will work on it and get back to you on that question.

1066
02:18:52.391 --> 02:18:58.454
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so you don't know that it's— if it's rolling over to the new year to be— to fill the gap?

1067
02:19:00.841 --> 02:19:02.924
<v Jeremy Patton>I can, I can answer from a PBOT perspective.

1068
02:19:02.972 --> 02:19:07.316
<v Jeremy Patton>Yes, some of those balances are rolling into '26-'27 to pay for projects in '26-'27.

1069
02:19:07.668 --> 02:19:09.609
<v Jeremy Patton>So those balances, if that's your question—.

1070
02:19:10.121 --> 02:19:11.003
<v Loretta Smith>Not some of the balances.

1071
02:19:11.083 --> 02:19:12.365
<v Loretta Smith>What is the ending balance?

1072
02:19:12.430 --> 02:19:15.075
<v Loretta Smith>What is the projected ending balance of PBOT?

1073
02:19:15.476 --> 02:19:21.807
<v Loretta Smith>And if that ending balance is being rolled over into the '26-'27 to be used to balance the budget?

1074
02:19:22.849 --> 02:19:28.334
<v Raymond C. Lee>She's basically asking, are we encumbering funds for projects that we're going to be doing next year.

1075
02:19:28.818 --> 02:19:29.013
<v Jeremy Patton>Yes.

1076
02:19:30.191 --> 02:19:37.361
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, I'll try that next time, those nice $2,000 words.

1077
02:19:37.718 --> 02:19:38.400
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

1078
02:19:38.840 --> 02:19:39.197
<v Reed Brodersen>Thank you.

1079
02:19:39.895 --> 02:19:40.724
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1080
02:19:41.949 --> 02:19:42.807
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal is not here.

1081
02:19:42.870 --> 02:19:43.486
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1082
02:19:44.636 --> 02:19:46.029
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

1083
02:19:46.918 --> 02:19:51.145
<v Dan Ryan>It's good to see you all, um, especially the 2 that were here late last night.

1084
02:19:52.309 --> 02:19:54.058
<v Dan Ryan>DCA Dhanapal and Director Liu.

1085
02:19:54.511 --> 02:19:56.275
<v Dan Ryan>I thought that was a really good conversation.

1086
02:19:56.550 --> 02:19:57.328
<v Dan Ryan>It was necessary.

1087
02:19:58.852 --> 02:20:06.397
<v Dan Ryan>We had dialogue as opposed to just us giving speeches and hoping that you will justify what we just said.

1088
02:20:07.956 --> 02:20:13.558
<v Dan Ryan>I thought there was a lot of listening to understand what the heck's going on, 'cause it is a really big project.

1089
02:20:13.622 --> 02:20:16.059
<v Dan Ryan>I really enjoyed Councilor Zimmerman's—.

1090
02:20:16.075 --> 02:20:16.609
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1091
02:20:17.668 --> 02:20:25.643
<v Dan Ryan>Use of language about the fact that basically I was asking questions that, you know, can we really pivot to do something different?

1092
02:20:26.889 --> 02:20:31.222
<v Dan Ryan>Because there has been new people at the table now joining opposition that were never around before.

1093
02:20:31.302 --> 02:20:33.647
<v Dan Ryan>So it's become more political.

1094
02:20:34.020 --> 02:20:36.981
<v Dan Ryan>And I thought you handled all of the questions really well.

1095
02:20:38.661 --> 02:20:42.378
<v Dan Ryan>We don't want a big hole to nowhere and we don't want Trump Water, if I could summarize.

1096
02:20:42.789 --> 02:20:46.144
<v Dan Ryan>I thought that was really great language last night, so thank you.

1097
02:20:47.649 --> 02:20:54.445
<v Dan Ryan>That said, it reminds me as a taxpayer, as a ratepayer, the Big Pipe was, it was hard.

1098
02:20:54.525 --> 02:20:57.112
<v Dan Ryan>I remember getting those bills from BES.

1099
02:20:57.240 --> 02:20:59.355
<v Dan Ryan>I didn't realize there were 2 bureaus at the time.

1100
02:21:00.244 --> 02:21:03.972
<v Dan Ryan>Before I go any further, this feels more like One Water than any other presentation.

1101
02:21:04.504 --> 02:21:06.248
<v Dan Ryan>So was that by design?

1102
02:21:08.236 --> 02:21:14.058
<v Priya Dhanapal>Yes, we have a joint utility director now overseeing both bureaus, and we are looking at both bureaus together.

1103
02:21:14.363 --> 02:21:16.530
<v Dan Ryan>Director Lu is overseeing the One Water?

1104
02:21:16.737 --> 02:21:16.931
<v Priya Dhanapal>Yes.

1105
02:21:17.011 --> 02:21:17.924
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, congratulations.

1106
02:21:19.400 --> 02:21:25.256
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, so I got a little distracted because of that, but I just wanted to acknowledge that's a milestone moment.

1107
02:21:26.058 --> 02:21:30.021
<v Dan Ryan>I think when you— the rates did go down, I recall that.

1108
02:21:31.031 --> 02:21:39.462
<v Dan Ryan>But I also think that when you're visually showing that, it might be good to use that as Exhibit A on what happened with our bills during Big Pipe.

1109
02:21:39.945 --> 02:21:43.305
<v Dan Ryan>Was that in the late aughts that that went up?

1110
02:21:43.986 --> 02:21:46.825
<v Dan Ryan>And anyway, that visual could help.

1111
02:21:47.309 --> 02:22:01.201
<v Dan Ryan>I think one of the challenges with a group of employees that are engineers— God love you engineers, you're smarter than I'll ever be— but you're not the best, let's see, not the best communicators on making information digestible.

1112
02:22:01.282 --> 02:22:01.444
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1113
02:22:01.747 --> 02:22:07.078
<v Dan Ryan>So work with some really smart comms people to help you make it digestible.

1114
02:22:07.576 --> 02:22:08.700
<v Dan Ryan>And visuals help.

1115
02:22:09.102 --> 02:22:13.228
<v Dan Ryan>And we need to see— I think we don't tell the story very well.

1116
02:22:13.308 --> 02:22:18.929
<v Dan Ryan>So that's why I'm trying to help you with— you have an example of Exhibit A with what happened with the Big Pipe.

1117
02:22:19.218 --> 02:22:21.209
<v Dan Ryan>So that was just offering some suggestions.

1118
02:22:21.305 --> 02:22:26.731
<v Dan Ryan>Because sometimes when I read your information, I'm becoming more familiar.

1119
02:22:26.780 --> 02:22:26.924
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1120
02:22:27.246 --> 02:22:32.826
<v Dan Ryan>But I keep thinking how important it is to make it so it is digestible to your average taxpayer and Portlander.

1121
02:22:32.876 --> 02:22:33.539
<v Dan Ryan>Does that make sense?

1122
02:22:34.930 --> 02:22:35.852
<v Priya Dhanapal>Yes, Councilor, thank you.

1123
02:22:36.264 --> 02:22:37.188
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, no, you're welcome.

1124
02:22:39.329 --> 02:22:41.772
<v Dan Ryan>Big picture, 'cause most of my questions have been asked.

1125
02:22:41.852 --> 02:22:42.753
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, colleagues.

1126
02:22:42.881 --> 02:22:44.793
<v Dan Ryan>I know you're listening.

1127
02:22:45.003 --> 02:22:48.334
<v Dan Ryan>So I hope that you also can explain this.

1128
02:22:49.016 --> 02:22:52.711
<v Dan Ryan>Of all of the work areas, I think with public service, we experienced some of this as well.

1129
02:22:53.433 --> 02:23:00.046
<v Dan Ryan>The transition to how we're organizing the city with DCAs is taking some dramatic pivots right now.

1130
02:23:00.656 --> 02:23:08.297
<v Dan Ryan>And so a lot of your movement seems to be, from what I can see, from bureaus into the DCA world.

1131
02:23:08.378 --> 02:23:11.171
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'm going to bring in City Administrator Lee as well.

1132
02:23:11.908 --> 02:23:16.484
<v Dan Ryan>I think that also I saw some of that with Economic Development, Donnie Oliveira's group.

1133
02:23:16.870 --> 02:23:26.405
<v Dan Ryan>So I think as a council member, I'd like to understand the this transition of how we're structurally organizing the city at this moment.

1134
02:23:26.743 --> 02:23:33.744
<v Dan Ryan>And I don't need a lot of time 'cause I'll be told I'm over 5 minutes, but just your vision on where this is.

1135
02:23:33.873 --> 02:23:39.806
<v Dan Ryan>Is this a better practice that you experienced in other positions that you're seeing nationwide with cities?

1136
02:23:40.129 --> 02:23:44.939
<v Dan Ryan>Are we moving towards a more efficient model of how we do our organization chart in general?

1137
02:23:45.165 --> 02:23:46.784
<v Dan Ryan>'Cause this is a big shift from last year's budget.

1138
02:23:47.020 --> 02:23:48.048
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yeah, I think it's unique.

1139
02:23:48.095 --> 02:24:06.007
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think public safety was the first service area to kind of move to this model of a kind of an enterprise method of pulling the HR, performance management, finance all under one consolidated area to provide those services for that whole service area.

1140
02:24:06.409 --> 02:24:08.176
<v Raymond C. Lee>Public safety, a large service area.

1141
02:24:08.498 --> 02:24:13.606
<v Raymond C. Lee>Public works is the largest service area that we have that is looking to do the same.

1142
02:24:13.719 --> 02:24:21.493
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think historically through the city, they've seen some success through that model and really trying to establish that in another service area.

1143
02:24:21.958 --> 02:24:28.271
<v Raymond C. Lee>Is it something that I've seen throughout my career as it relates to large cities and how they have functioned?

1144
02:24:28.543 --> 02:24:29.393
<v Raymond C. Lee>Not necessarily.

1145
02:24:30.226 --> 02:24:37.277
<v Raymond C. Lee>But that doesn't mean that it's not a model that can work for Portland if we're seeing success in one service area altogether.

1146
02:24:37.597 --> 02:24:39.825
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think it's something that I will continue to evaluate.

1147
02:24:40.162 --> 02:24:52.906
<v Raymond C. Lee>To see if we're seeing the efficiencies that we would want to see in having this type of organizational structure for the organization and see if it's reaping the benefits that are best for Portlanders as it relates to service delivery.

1148
02:24:54.125 --> 02:24:54.429
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1149
02:24:54.750 --> 02:24:57.620
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that that helped me understand that this is fluid.

1150
02:24:58.277 --> 02:24:58.565
<v Raymond C. Lee>It is.

1151
02:24:58.693 --> 02:25:00.617
<v Raymond C. Lee>It's always fluid as we look at this.

1152
02:25:00.682 --> 02:25:05.730
<v Raymond C. Lee>And we're always looking at how do we do business better as an organization, how we can be more efficient.

1153
02:25:05.860 --> 02:25:09.020
<v Raymond C. Lee>And effective and economical in the services we provide.

1154
02:25:09.662 --> 02:25:23.620
<v Dan Ryan>And it's, it's never black and white and easy to understand, but in some worlds you think it's a pyramid with— and so what I'm seeing with this is that it goes down into positions that could be very close to the ground within the DCA office.

1155
02:25:24.342 --> 02:25:31.576
<v Dan Ryan>And I think for councilors, it's important for us to try to understand the evolution of this change to the org chart.

1156
02:25:32.106 --> 02:25:32.653
<v Raymond C. Lee>Most definitely.

1157
02:25:32.990 --> 02:25:48.200
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that it needs to be a current conversation that we have throughout this year, because I imagine now that you'll be here more than a half hour, but you'll have more of a year under your belt, you'll have a chance to work with the DCAs to keep refining this as we go into the next budget year.

1158
02:25:48.489 --> 02:25:49.037
<v Raymond C. Lee>Most definitely.

1159
02:25:49.614 --> 02:25:57.452
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that's where we'll also see opportunities in our restructuring to look at some of that pruning and efficiency that we've been trying to get at.

1160
02:25:58.207 --> 02:25:58.528
<v Raymond C. Lee>Correct.

1161
02:25:58.864 --> 02:26:05.010
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, so thank you for, um, your, your visuals made it more clear to me that that shift was taking place.

1162
02:26:05.666 --> 02:26:13.158
<v Dan Ryan>But I'm going to be curious as time goes on to understand if we're delivering better services, because that's what people complain about.

1163
02:26:13.224 --> 02:26:15.405
<v Dan Ryan>They complain about 2 things all the time.

1164
02:26:15.533 --> 02:26:25.064
<v Dan Ryan>Everyone up here knows that they're spending more money to live here, and they can't understand why the services aren't as good as they used to be when they paid less that's it.

1165
02:26:26.074 --> 02:26:30.793
<v Dan Ryan>And so we're trying to get an organization chart that will allow us to provide better service.

1166
02:26:32.712 --> 02:26:33.444
<v Simone Reddy>Thanks.

1167
02:26:33.592 --> 02:26:34.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1168
02:26:34.584 --> 02:26:35.234
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1169
02:26:36.031 --> 02:26:37.656
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1170
02:26:37.852 --> 02:26:38.291
<v Steve Novick>Oh, sorry.

1171
02:26:39.283 --> 02:26:39.933
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1172
02:26:41.152 --> 02:26:57.004
<v Steve Novick>On the filtration plant, one thing I wanted to say is that to me, and I suspect to a lot of other people, the the argument that, well, this is legally required isn't very compelling because frankly my response is, okay, let them go ahead and sue us.

1173
02:26:57.212 --> 02:27:00.746
<v Steve Novick>The penalties we pay won't be anywhere near as costly as building this filtration plant.

1174
02:27:01.469 --> 02:27:09.034
<v Steve Novick>The argument that I do find compelling is if there's a wildfire or an earthquake, the water will be contaminated and people will get sick.

1175
02:27:09.806 --> 02:27:15.924
<v Steve Novick>And I'm wondering, do you have access to a public health expert who can explain that to To us and to other people?

1176
02:27:17.113 --> 02:27:19.826
<v Steve Novick>What would happen health-wise if the water is contaminated?

1177
02:27:20.886 --> 02:27:24.643
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, we can definitely follow up on the public health.

1178
02:27:24.996 --> 02:27:31.209
<v Ting Lu>We have worked with the Multnomah County, the public health, and then they have been seeing the benefit of filtration.

1179
02:27:31.819 --> 02:27:33.474
<v Ting Lu>So we can follow up on that.

1180
02:27:33.890 --> 02:27:58.791
<v Steve Novick>I really think that, I wish I'd thought about this a few weeks ago, but I think it would've really benefited if in these discussions we'd had the public health person here to say, the other question is, I think I want to find out how long can we use— I think you might have said, Director Lew, yesterday that we can rely on the groundwater backup supply for up to 180 days, or I might have heard the number wrong.

1181
02:27:59.227 --> 02:28:01.292
<v Ting Lu>That's what I heard.

1182
02:28:03.648 --> 02:28:07.975
<v Priya Dhanapal>Okay, I can take the question, Councilor Nowak, if that's okay.

1183
02:28:08.272 --> 02:28:08.448
<v Priya Dhanapal>What?

1184
02:28:09.298 --> 02:28:10.869
<v Ting Lu>I can take the question if it's okay with you.

1185
02:28:11.815 --> 02:28:23.566
<v Priya Dhanapal>So, you know, our Columbia Shore well field is designed as an emergency and supplemental supply, not a full-term replacement for our Bull Run system.

1186
02:28:24.639 --> 02:28:36.059
<v Priya Dhanapal>So based on our current modeling and assuming there's no well failures, the groundwater system could provide approximately, you know, 78 MGD, million gallons per day, for about 30 days.

1187
02:28:36.799 --> 02:28:37.345
<v Priya Dhanapal>30 Days.

1188
02:28:37.683 --> 02:28:38.118
<v Priya Dhanapal>For 30 days.

1189
02:28:38.423 --> 02:28:41.685
<v Priya Dhanapal>So it's 78 million gallons for 30 days.

1190
02:28:42.264 --> 02:28:46.395
<v Priya Dhanapal>For context, Portland's average annual demand is about 90 million gallons.

1191
02:28:46.834 --> 02:28:48.396
<v Priya Dhanapal>So it doesn't meet the demand.

1192
02:28:49.409 --> 02:28:51.765
<v Priya Dhanapal>And so, and summer demands can be 120 days.

1193
02:28:52.139 --> 02:28:55.780
<v Priya Dhanapal>So in plain speak, it will not meet the demand that we need.

1194
02:28:57.155 --> 02:28:59.516
<v Priya Dhanapal>And the 30 days is where we are at right now.

1195
02:28:59.614 --> 02:28:59.875
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1196
02:29:00.072 --> 02:29:01.032
<v Steve Novick>That's very helpful.

1197
02:29:01.097 --> 02:29:07.284
<v Steve Novick>'Cause if it was 180 days, then I think people would think, well, by then all of the stuff will have settled anyway and you could just restart the old system.

1198
02:29:07.365 --> 02:29:09.898
<v Steve Novick>But 30 days does not sound like very much.

1199
02:29:10.171 --> 02:29:23.332
<v Priya Dhanapal>And then if Bull Run was unavailable during the summer season, during peak hot weather season, the city will likely have to implement like curtailment measures in less than 1 month to reduce the demand and preserve ground— and so we can preserve groundwater supply.

1200
02:29:23.413 --> 02:29:25.736
<v Priya Dhanapal>So that's the estimate that we can provide.

1201
02:29:26.041 --> 02:29:33.094
<v Steve Novick>I think that in the aftermath of an earthquake, people would be okay with some water rationing, but if it's going to run out in 30 days, then that's a problem.

1202
02:29:33.719 --> 02:29:43.530
<v Steve Novick>I also wanted to note, I mean, we're all concerned about the financial impact on people, and it's huge.

1203
02:29:44.700 --> 02:29:58.500
<v Steve Novick>This is not really going to be very helpful, but I mean, I should note that the city of Ashland in 1993 adopted a 5% tax on restaurant meals that they use largely to offset the utilities costs.

1204
02:29:59.605 --> 02:30:07.120
<v Steve Novick>And I actually polled on a 5% restaurant tax in like 2015 and for something else, and it was disastrous.

1205
02:30:08.434 --> 02:30:15.052
<v Steve Novick>But I mean, that's like, I think that's the kind of option that we might at some point want to consider.

1206
02:30:15.870 --> 02:30:19.680
<v Steve Novick>I also had a couple of more specific questions about the thank you, Mayor.

1207
02:30:19.680 --> 02:30:20.340
<v Jeremy Patton>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator, for the presentation.

1208
02:30:20.340 --> 02:30:29.579
<v Steve Novick>I was curious about the cut to the staff person that— the cut to non-regulatorily required water sampling.

1209
02:30:29.579 --> 02:30:38.510
<v Steve Novick>And I just want to know what kind of sampling is that and is cutting that going to make the water less safe even if we are still meeting regulatory requirements?

1210
02:30:41.040 --> 02:30:47.319
<v Ting Lu>For the non-regulatory sampling, we do definitely— this is going to be in full compliance.

1211
02:30:47.879 --> 02:30:54.941
<v Ting Lu>We will be prioritizing everything, but it's really some of the things that we could kind of hold the sampling a little bit longer.

1212
02:30:55.263 --> 02:31:05.394
<v Ting Lu>So instead of analyzing like for a few days, we're going to take it a little bit longer, but it's still within the hold time.

1213
02:31:05.843 --> 02:31:10.468
<v Ting Lu>So there's no compromise for the water quality for our communities.

1214
02:31:11.608 --> 02:31:14.771
<v Steve Novick>Okay, if it doesn't matter, why do we have that position to begin with?

1215
02:31:17.564 --> 02:31:25.469
<v Ting Lu>We do having that position and we want to expedite a lot of the sampling and the results and things.

1216
02:31:25.902 --> 02:31:30.792
<v Ting Lu>But this is the things we can reprioritize and making sure existing staff have done that.

1217
02:31:31.338 --> 02:31:31.674
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1218
02:31:32.557 --> 02:31:36.293
<v Priya Dhanapal>And the regulatory requirements is the, like, the minimum guidance.

1219
02:31:36.887 --> 02:31:41.698
<v Priya Dhanapal>We tend to do more so that we can be better with operational, the way we operate a system.

1220
02:31:41.858 --> 02:31:46.161
<v Priya Dhanapal>So it is something that you know, we want to do more than minimum.

1221
02:31:46.273 --> 02:31:50.451
<v Priya Dhanapal>So that's what the non-regulatory is about, non-mandatory is about.

1222
02:31:51.479 --> 02:31:57.418
<v Ting Lu>The other thing I want to add is that, you know, for water quality sampling, there is regulatory compliance and things.

1223
02:31:57.756 --> 02:32:00.123
<v Ting Lu>There is also internal process optimization.

1224
02:32:00.188 --> 02:32:04.968
<v Ting Lu>We use sampling and the data analysis to inform our operation optimization.

1225
02:32:05.353 --> 02:32:07.976
<v Ting Lu>So some of this we can adjust and optimize.

1226
02:32:08.395 --> 02:32:11.463
<v Ting Lu>Those are the things we're reprioritizing.

1227
02:32:11.626 --> 02:32:18.014
<v Ting Lu>So it's not about the end quality, but it's about operational optimization and sampling and how we optimize that.

1228
02:32:19.327 --> 02:32:20.147
<v Simone Reddy>Okay.

1229
02:32:21.064 --> 02:32:27.200
<v Steve Novick>Another position that you talked about cutting was for engineering standards review.

1230
02:32:27.489 --> 02:32:29.459
<v Steve Novick>And since I'm not an engineer, that sort of scared me.

1231
02:32:29.509 --> 02:32:33.605
<v Steve Novick>It's like, wait a minute, does that mean that we'll be doing things that don't meet engineering standards and things will all fall apart?

1232
02:32:34.243 --> 02:32:34.291
<v Ting Lu>No.

1233
02:32:35.611 --> 02:32:51.041
<v Ting Lu>We'll continue having the engineering standard, the design standard and things, but it's really looking to more consistent engineering standard and also looking to more, when you're looking to the project planning and things, a more standard approach.

1234
02:32:52.036 --> 02:33:00.072
<v Ting Lu>So we have been getting that information prior, getting that workload prioritized with the existing engineering staff.

1235
02:33:00.457 --> 02:33:10.318
<v Ting Lu>But this is a part of where the One Water effort, we are looking both bureaus from Water and BES, how we can have that consistent engineering standard across the utility bureaus.

1236
02:33:10.753 --> 02:33:16.129
<v Ting Lu>So this is a type of a position we're evaluating, making sure we have that consistent standard.

1237
02:33:16.179 --> 02:33:18.040
<v Ting Lu>So it's a strategic priority for us.

1238
02:33:19.590 --> 02:33:22.772
<v Steve Novick>Okay, but how does cutting this position affect that work?

1239
02:33:23.726 --> 02:33:29.602
<v Ting Lu>Uh, it, it's not going to, uh, affect that work.

1240
02:33:29.667 --> 02:33:38.638
<v Ting Lu>So we are looking to both from a project level rely on existing engineering staff to focus, comply with the standard.

1241
02:33:38.701 --> 02:33:46.979
<v Ting Lu>But across the bureaus, we'll look for shared services and resource to support the developing somewhat consistent standard.

1242
02:33:47.846 --> 02:33:48.873
<v Steve Novick>Okay, thank you.

1243
02:33:50.317 --> 02:33:51.120
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1244
02:33:51.842 --> 02:33:53.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have myself back in the queue.

1245
02:33:54.087 --> 02:33:56.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>I got a couple questions I wanted to follow up on from Councilor Ryan.

1246
02:33:56.992 --> 02:33:58.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>About realignment.

1247
02:33:59.193 --> 02:34:10.932
<v Jamie Dunphy>First, of the positions that are being cut, do we— do you have a sense of which ones are managerial versus administrative versus service level?

1248
02:34:11.093 --> 02:34:26.643
<v Jamie Dunphy>It seemed like a lot of them were vacancies, but— and I saw the, you know, you are cutting a vacant supervisor position that's going to lead to a broader span of control, but just sort of generally, do you have a number To say like frontline versus admin versus managerial?

1249
02:34:27.606 --> 02:34:31.139
<v Priya Dhanapal>I know that for the utilities, all positions that are being cut are vacant.

1250
02:34:31.540 --> 02:34:33.034
<v Priya Dhanapal>Do you have the breakdown of—.

1251
02:34:34.351 --> 02:34:41.352
<v Ting Lu>We don't have the exact breakdown for the managerial or frontline, so we can definitely follow up on that.

1252
02:34:41.416 --> 02:34:44.902
<v Ting Lu>There is a few managers and there is the different positions there.

1253
02:34:45.415 --> 02:34:50.570
<v Ting Lu>I will also say the vacancies, those are for the last 6 or a year.

1254
02:34:51.486 --> 02:34:55.970
<v Ting Lu>So there's a timeframe for the vacancy reduction here.

1255
02:34:56.585 --> 02:34:58.415
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'm just getting an update from the Water Bureau.

1256
02:34:58.771 --> 02:35:03.793
<v Priya Dhanapal>For the Water Bureau, 2 of the cuts is non-represented, whereas the rest are non-represented.

1257
02:35:03.843 --> 02:35:06.665
<v Priya Dhanapal>I think we have total of how many cuts at the Water Bureau?

1258
02:35:07.487 --> 02:35:07.987
<v Ting Lu>16.

1259
02:35:08.213 --> 02:35:08.875
<v Priya Dhanapal>16, Yep.

1260
02:35:09.117 --> 02:35:10.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

1261
02:35:12.067 --> 02:35:13.084
<v Jamie Dunphy>Similar question.

1262
02:35:13.423 --> 02:35:19.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>With realignment, I'm seeing, you know, we're noticing a lot of the positions moving the rate bureaus into the DCA's office.

1263
02:35:20.558 --> 02:35:27.691
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that means that we are now— your office is now both general funded and ratepayer funded.

1264
02:35:28.189 --> 02:35:31.192
<v Jamie Dunphy>How are we differentiating between the staff in those positions?

1265
02:35:31.240 --> 02:35:33.441
<v Jamie Dunphy>How are we— are we braiding those fundings?

1266
02:35:33.729 --> 02:35:35.690
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are we keeping them very separate?

1267
02:35:35.737 --> 02:35:38.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>How are you approaching that budgeting challenge?

1268
02:35:38.887 --> 02:35:39.786
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy.

1269
02:35:39.834 --> 02:35:47.667
<v Priya Dhanapal>I'm going to call Director Levine to talk about the rate model for okay.

1270
02:35:47.813 --> 02:35:57.800
<v Ting Lu>Or, Chief Biery, if—.

1271
02:36:00.213 --> 02:36:01.049
<v Jonas Biery>My apologies, Councilor.

1272
02:36:01.097 --> 02:36:02.867
<v Jonas Biery>Would you kindly repeat the question?

1273
02:36:02.947 --> 02:36:10.379
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, well, in the DCA's office, she's now going to have, uh, ratepayer-funded positions and general fund-funded positions.

1274
02:36:11.228 --> 02:36:15.202
<v Jamie Dunphy>How are we— are we braiding those funds into one FTE?

1275
02:36:15.332 --> 02:36:17.431
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are we keeping them totally separate?

1276
02:36:17.478 --> 02:36:20.843
<v Jamie Dunphy>How are we maintaining faith with the—.

1277
02:36:20.843 --> 02:36:23.280
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, yeah, no, it's a great, great question.

1278
02:36:23.327 --> 02:36:27.926
<v Jonas Biery>And I do know there was a question earlier about sort of management of the concern about the ratepayer funds.

1279
02:36:27.990 --> 02:36:32.157
<v Jonas Biery>And so we are very, very mindful of monitoring and managing that.

1280
02:36:33.343 --> 02:36:44.757
<v Jonas Biery>Ruth can probably follow up separately for the sort of the technically accurate answer, but I'll sort of say generally, there'll be multiple years of sort of transitioning to this different model, right?

1281
02:36:44.806 --> 02:36:49.861
<v Jonas Biery>And so we have both the flow-through of general fund overhead, right?

1282
02:36:49.974 --> 02:36:51.665
<v Jonas Biery>We kind of generally know how that works.

1283
02:36:52.149 --> 02:37:00.715
<v Jonas Biery>And then within the DCA's office, you know, be carefully monitoring to make sure that we're allocating those appropriately within the service area.

1284
02:37:00.763 --> 02:37:00.843
<v Jonas Biery>Okay.

1285
02:37:01.138 --> 02:37:08.643
<v Jonas Biery>And making sure that that's tying back to a supportable nexus to the work that's being done.

1286
02:37:08.903 --> 02:37:19.596
<v Jonas Biery>As we realign the work citywide, we know that there are lots of things that we do that we typically did and thought of very vertically, right?

1287
02:37:19.645 --> 02:37:25.157
<v Jonas Biery>That this service only serves this bureau when in fact much of those services reach across the organization.

1288
02:37:25.737 --> 02:37:29.566
<v Jonas Biery>And we weren't able to sort of track and see that in the prior iteration.

1289
02:37:29.614 --> 02:37:29.664
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

1290
02:37:30.311 --> 02:37:32.804
<v Jonas Biery>So we'll do that work.

1291
02:37:33.208 --> 02:37:42.888
<v Jonas Biery>The last thing I'll say is as we implement that this year, we'll also be continuing to look and say, where is it not quite right and where do we refine that in future year budget adjustments?

1292
02:37:43.209 --> 02:37:44.273
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, great.

1293
02:37:45.079 --> 02:37:46.416
<v Jamie Dunphy>Glad that— I'm glad I asked.

1294
02:37:47.726 --> 02:37:53.118
<v Jamie Dunphy>Moving to, I have a specific question about the transportation development review fees.

1295
02:37:54.667 --> 02:37:55.426
<v Jamie Dunphy>Slide 42.

1296
02:37:56.990 --> 02:38:08.138
<v Jamie Dunphy>One of my main priorities in my time in office has been supporting the streamlining efforts that we are doing to drive more development activity and to right-size cost recovery without simply relying on fee increases.

1297
02:38:08.733 --> 02:38:10.548
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is the focus of Cap 2.

1298
02:38:11.462 --> 02:38:20.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'd like to better understand how we're estimating the revenue impacts here and what the net effect of the changes to the Transportation Development Review fees will actually be.

1299
02:38:21.037 --> 02:38:24.578
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor look like for permitters, people who are applying for permits?

1300
02:38:25.667 --> 02:38:28.537
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we have, you know, what is— how are things going to be different?

1301
02:38:29.691 --> 02:38:37.542
<v Jeremy Patton>So at a highest level, there will be new fees coming from transportation within the fee schedule that those developers will have to pay.

1302
02:38:38.888 --> 02:38:45.218
<v Jeremy Patton>Those revenues were coming from existing fees in PP&D, but those existing fees in PP&D are not cost recovery.

1303
02:38:45.459 --> 02:38:46.820
<v Jeremy Patton>They are not enough to provide the program.

1304
02:38:47.157 --> 02:38:48.764
<v Jeremy Patton>So there was basically 2 choices to be made.

1305
02:38:48.828 --> 02:38:58.487
<v Jeremy Patton>You either increase those fees in PP&D and continue to transfer funds to PBOT, or you just make up that difference by creating those kind of similar fees in PBOT to collect those revenues.

1306
02:38:58.954 --> 02:38:59.775
<v Jeremy Patton>And so we chose the latter.

1307
02:39:00.146 --> 02:39:00.355
<v Sameer Kanal>Gotcha.

1308
02:39:01.611 --> 02:39:13.247
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we talk— I want to talk about that actually specifically, the interagency agreement with PP&D and the historic relationship, and then I guess how this is sort of moving forward.

1309
02:39:13.516 --> 02:39:19.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>I understand that the IGA between PBOT and PP&D is no longer in place or no longer going to be in place.

1310
02:39:19.889 --> 02:39:23.504
<v Jamie Dunphy>What is that actually gonna mean in practice beyond the fee recovery component of it?

1311
02:39:23.634 --> 02:39:27.185
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do we know what, how that will be operationalized?

1312
02:39:27.396 --> 02:39:37.761
<v Jeremy Patton>Yeah, the only thing that it means in practice is rather than charging PP&D for those services from a PBOT perspective, we will collect our own revenues to provide those services.

1313
02:39:38.131 --> 02:39:38.262
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1314
02:39:39.686 --> 02:39:43.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>And just so— just one last thing, you know, we're adding some fees on the PBOT side.

1315
02:39:44.190 --> 02:39:45.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are any fees being retired?

1316
02:39:46.977 --> 02:39:48.067
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are we getting rid of any fees?

1317
02:39:48.131 --> 02:39:49.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are we reducing anything?

1318
02:39:50.039 --> 02:39:54.204
<v Jeremy Patton>There are, um, not related specifically to development review fees, no.

1319
02:39:54.365 --> 02:39:55.935
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, okay, thank you very much.

1320
02:39:56.770 --> 02:39:57.378
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1321
02:39:58.789 --> 02:40:04.735
<v Mitch Green>I, I just got back in the queue if we had time because I wanted to make one point on the sort of thank you.

1322
02:40:04.879 --> 02:40:07.804
<v Mitch Green>I just want to echo the broad conversation on the sustainability of our water rates.

1323
02:40:08.414 --> 02:40:18.389
<v Mitch Green>I've said this before, but I think it's really important that we're doing everything we can to unlock housing development in the City of Portland.

1324
02:40:18.454 --> 02:40:30.763
<v Mitch Green>And I know that this effort's underway because the more meters that we can add to our system, the more that we can spread the fixed costs of that project over a larger rate base.

1325
02:40:30.893 --> 02:40:32.248
<v Mitch Green>So that's part of the rate design question.

1326
02:40:32.961 --> 02:40:40.252
<v Mitch Green>But it's also part of this idea that there's a positive interaction effect by promoting densification.

1327
02:40:40.413 --> 02:40:58.011
<v Mitch Green>I know that that's going to require some upgrades and some system assets that are downstream of the plant, but if that provides more ratepayers at a pace that's faster than the cost of the upgrade to those pipes, then we're going to be able to get ourselves on a trajectory where you actually can lower those rates.

1328
02:40:58.478 --> 02:41:05.518
<v Mitch Green>As Councilor Pirtle-Guiney had sort of suggested, rather than saying we're going to reduce the rate of increase, we might get to a place where we could actually just lower rates.

1329
02:41:06.200 --> 02:41:08.040
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's what we should be striving towards.

1330
02:41:08.088 --> 02:41:11.479
<v Mitch Green>So it's part of your vision, Mr. Mayor, of economic development.

1331
02:41:12.111 --> 02:41:18.038
<v Mitch Green>Just want to reaffirm that I think this council should be supporting that with every tool that we have.

1332
02:41:18.537 --> 02:41:18.795
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thanks.

1333
02:41:19.519 --> 02:41:19.695
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Thank you.

1334
02:41:19.745 --> 02:41:20.227
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1335
02:41:21.865 --> 02:41:23.652
<v Raymond C. Lee>And I'll add something to that, Councilor Green.

1336
02:41:23.752 --> 02:41:33.157
<v Raymond C. Lee>I think in any rate-based utility like this, you need those large users from an industrial and from a commercial standpoint.

1337
02:41:33.415 --> 02:41:37.715
<v Raymond C. Lee>That's the only way to truly have a financially sustainable system.

1338
02:41:38.308 --> 02:41:50.068
<v Raymond C. Lee>So I think that's something as administration, I know the mayor is keen on as well, is how do we recruit and retain those large industrial commercial users to help balance the system.

1339
02:41:50.117 --> 02:41:50.277
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

1340
02:41:52.750 --> 02:41:53.086
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you.

1341
02:41:53.617 --> 02:41:54.725
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1342
02:41:55.880 --> 02:41:57.213
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President Jeremy.

1343
02:41:58.513 --> 02:41:59.975
<v Dan Ryan>I don't have any planned questions.

1344
02:42:00.040 --> 02:42:03.556
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to have a conversation with you about the lovely topic of parking meters.

1345
02:42:04.711 --> 02:42:09.978
<v Dan Ryan>I think after like gas prices, parking meters like really hit home for Portlanders.

1346
02:42:10.588 --> 02:42:12.129
<v Dan Ryan>And so there's a lot of nuances on this one.

1347
02:42:12.177 --> 02:42:14.602
<v Dan Ryan>I was surprised that we were in the middle of the pack, to be honest with you.

1348
02:42:14.730 --> 02:42:23.658
<v Dan Ryan>And I think it's because I maybe have the unfortunate circumstances of meeting somebody for a meal while there's a Blazer game going on, and so it's higher.

1349
02:42:24.156 --> 02:42:28.957
<v Dan Ryan>So we have prices that are situational, correct?

1350
02:42:29.198 --> 02:42:29.486
<v Jeremy Patton>Correct.

1351
02:42:30.387 --> 02:42:32.200
<v Dan Ryan>And how do we—.

1352
02:42:32.248 --> 02:42:32.971
<v Jeremy Patton>In certain districts.

1353
02:42:33.277 --> 02:42:33.613
<v Jeremy Patton>Pardon me?

1354
02:42:33.709 --> 02:42:34.433
<v Jeremy Patton>In certain districts.

1355
02:42:34.897 --> 02:42:35.989
<v Dan Ryan>In certain districts, of course.

1356
02:42:36.745 --> 02:42:44.042
<v Dan Ryan>And so I assume the data that you compiled is quite a, Collection of all those different, okay.

1357
02:42:44.847 --> 02:42:51.145
<v Dan Ryan>And so that's why someone could feel like they're paying a lot more than that if they show up at those places at peak times, right?

1358
02:42:51.306 --> 02:42:51.564
<v Jeremy Patton>Correct.

1359
02:42:52.031 --> 02:42:53.398
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, stay with me.

1360
02:42:53.704 --> 02:43:00.703
<v Dan Ryan>And so I know a lot of people have never gotten over the Sunday, the Sunday, free Sundays were quite popular.

1361
02:43:01.849 --> 02:43:03.091
<v Dan Ryan>Just, that's not a question.

1362
02:43:05.189 --> 02:43:18.859
<v Dan Ryan>And then I also would say that, How can I— I hear this often from storefronts and restaurants that their employees, they want some relief.

1363
02:43:19.132 --> 02:43:26.924
<v Dan Ryan>And so when we think about the program, the storefront program support, I hope that we think creatively about something like this.

1364
02:43:28.079 --> 02:43:36.286
<v Dan Ryan>So restaurants where the people who work there are doing working-class wages, and when they get off their thank you.

1365
02:43:36.365 --> 02:43:42.345
<v Dan Ryan>So if you have a bad shift and they didn't have a great night and then they have a parking ticket, they're really upset and they want to quit.

1366
02:43:43.340 --> 02:43:49.014
<v Dan Ryan>And so I've heard from people explain these stories that it's an angst for many of their employees.

1367
02:43:49.608 --> 02:43:58.584
<v Dan Ryan>Is there a program where that we could come up with, maybe a councilor could do a resolution or an ordinance on this that— but I don't want to get that micro.

1368
02:43:59.049 --> 02:44:10.019
<v Dan Ryan>I'd rather work with you to have some sort of adaptable program that works with the restaurants, works so they could have some access to some free parking for their working-class employees.

1369
02:44:10.916 --> 02:44:14.670
<v Jeremy Patton>And there are existing programs for reduced levels of parking in the garages.

1370
02:44:14.958 --> 02:44:21.388
<v Jeremy Patton>So if those employees work in the garages and say on night shifts, there are reduced rates for those particular employees, but we can explore more.

1371
02:44:21.822 --> 02:44:22.063
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>Absolutely.

1372
02:44:22.222 --> 02:44:24.484
<v Dan Ryan>When you say parking lot, you're talking about SmartPark?

1373
02:44:24.629 --> 02:44:25.126
<v Dan Ryan>Correct.

1374
02:44:26.007 --> 02:44:27.370
<v Dan Ryan>'Cause we have jurisdiction over that.

1375
02:44:27.675 --> 02:44:27.933
<v Jeremy Patton>Correct.

1376
02:44:28.237 --> 02:44:28.495
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney, Rosie McGowan>Okay.

1377
02:44:29.522 --> 02:44:32.237
<v Dan Ryan>I knew that, but that was one of those rhetorical questions.

1378
02:44:33.716 --> 02:44:52.556
<v Dan Ryan>So how do I get back to some folks that would like to tap into that program where there aren't big parking lots, where they're in, like, say, the Pearl that doesn't have as many parking lots, or they're in the Lloyd area that don't have those, and no one could park in those empty parking lots at Lloyd Center for some reason?

1379
02:44:54.787 --> 02:45:04.230
<v Dan Ryan>How do I work with PBOT to try to provide some relief to the storefronts who are suffering and their employees who are angry about parking fees?

1380
02:45:05.218 --> 02:45:06.011
<v Jeremy Patton>Yeah, happy to work with you.

1381
02:45:06.059 --> 02:45:09.134
<v Jeremy Patton>We actually have Erica in the room, and that's who you'd be working with.

1382
02:45:09.199 --> 02:45:11.998
<v Jeremy Patton>She's in the back over here, but she'd be happy to reach out to your office.

1383
02:45:13.310 --> 02:45:14.525
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, thank you, Erica.

1384
02:45:14.609 --> 02:45:15.101
<v Dan Ryan>Hi, Erica.

1385
02:45:15.331 --> 02:45:16.168
<v Dan Ryan>Erica just stood up.

1386
02:45:16.333 --> 02:45:16.924
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Erica.

1387
02:45:18.540 --> 02:45:18.706
<v Dan Ryan>Staff.

1388
02:45:19.129 --> 02:45:22.895
<v Dan Ryan>Just remind me that we're gonna have a meeting with— do you wanna be in that meeting?

1389
02:45:24.129 --> 02:45:24.865
<v Jeremy Patton>Absolutely, yeah.

1390
02:45:25.250 --> 02:45:25.490
<v Dan Ryan>All right.

1391
02:45:26.675 --> 02:45:34.222
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, it's really just, I think we have to have some parking meter solutions as we, and adaptability across the city on that.

1392
02:45:34.623 --> 02:45:36.322
<v Dan Ryan>How do we study though if it's working?

1393
02:45:36.467 --> 02:45:48.738
<v Dan Ryan>So what's the impact of the rate increases and if it's in fact hurt the businesses that might, therefore we might have another business go out of business Go out and we have another 4 lease signups.

1394
02:45:48.852 --> 02:45:52.247
<v Dan Ryan>So how can we look at the trade-off of that data?

1395
02:45:53.069 --> 02:45:55.885
<v Dan Ryan>Like, are we bringing in more money because of the parking fee?

1396
02:45:55.997 --> 02:46:02.486
<v Dan Ryan>Are we bringing in less money because the parking fee might be hurting businesses and then we have less business taxes from them?

1397
02:46:04.368 --> 02:46:10.557
<v Jeremy Patton>I would say that the revenue from the fee increases is bringing in more money because of the fee increases themselves.

1398
02:46:10.734 --> 02:46:21.801
<v Jeremy Patton>There are usually with any fee increase, slight downticks in the number of transactions of people utilizing parking, but usually the fee increases are more than covering those particular downward trends in transactions.

1399
02:46:22.332 --> 02:46:27.790
<v Jeremy Patton>As far as hurting businesses in turnover, that's a question I actually don't know the answer to.

1400
02:46:27.870 --> 02:46:37.584
<v Jeremy Patton>I would say businesses typically like turnover, so they want to make sure that those parking rates are at a rate high enough to make sure that people aren't parking there all day in front of their business because they do—.

1401
02:46:37.727 --> 02:46:38.563
<v Dan Ryan>No, they like the 15.

1402
02:46:38.659 --> 02:46:38.933
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1403
02:46:39.254 --> 02:46:43.558
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, especially in the neighborhood business, the Main Street areas.

1404
02:46:44.152 --> 02:46:57.081
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, I think we haven't figured out what that economic analysis is on when it hurts businesses and that hurts us because then we have less revenue coming from them, or if we just get more from the fee.

1405
02:46:57.563 --> 02:46:59.234
<v Dan Ryan>And so I keep trying to figure that out.

1406
02:46:59.314 --> 02:47:02.109
<v Dan Ryan>That's what I'm doing with you in real time without any prepared questions.

1407
02:47:02.461 --> 02:47:03.859
<v Dan Ryan>So that's the kind of conversation.

1408
02:47:03.906 --> 02:47:15.644
<v Dan Ryan>I do think one, That would allow us to provide some— a win, and that some of these— we've had a lot of restaurants close, and some of the issues is that they can't keep staff, and it's really become rough for them.

1409
02:47:15.805 --> 02:47:22.644
<v Dan Ryan>So I think anything we could do to provide some help for them, that would be, that would be something I look forward to working with you on.

1410
02:47:23.174 --> 02:47:28.360
<v Dan Ryan>And Mayor, maybe in the storefront support program, we can look, as this is one of the ideas.

1411
02:47:28.697 --> 02:47:32.185
<v Dan Ryan>So the point is that Anne Hill or who, who's the point?

1412
02:47:33.122 --> 02:47:34.851
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, all right, Victor.

1413
02:47:35.545 --> 02:47:36.288
<v Dan Ryan>Victor's the point.

1414
02:47:36.627 --> 02:47:37.014
<v Dan Ryan>And Anne.

1415
02:47:37.256 --> 02:47:38.840
<v Dan Ryan>Those people, that's who I talked to about this.

1416
02:47:39.129 --> 02:47:39.614
<v Dan Ryan>All right, thank you.

1417
02:47:40.735 --> 02:47:41.558
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1418
02:47:42.075 --> 02:47:42.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1419
02:47:44.805 --> 02:47:45.403
<v Reed Brodersen>Thank you.

1420
02:48:00.271 --> 02:48:01.716
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, I just forgot my question.

1421
02:48:03.595 --> 02:48:06.069
<v Deborah Scroggin>Just too much meat to start talking.

1422
02:48:06.263 --> 02:48:07.548
<v Loretta Smith>Right, right.

1423
02:48:07.933 --> 02:48:11.611
<v Loretta Smith>And I think I actually asked the question.

1424
02:48:11.789 --> 02:48:12.222
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1425
02:48:13.379 --> 02:48:14.942
<v Dan Ryan>Don't take yourself too seriously.

1426
02:48:19.600 --> 02:48:21.727
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor, uh, Councilor Novick.

1427
02:48:22.627 --> 02:48:24.897
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1428
02:48:25.443 --> 02:48:30.257
<v Steve Novick>I think that there's a lot of reasons to make sure that we're charging appropriate prices for parking.

1429
02:48:31.450 --> 02:48:36.713
<v Steve Novick>There's a value to turnover, there's a value to reducing traffic.

1430
02:48:38.290 --> 02:49:01.141
<v Steve Novick>But I am struck by Councilor Ryan's question about employees, and I was just wondering, have we ever, come up with a concept like where in a metered district there's people who work there that have like, you know, monthly permits where they pay less than they would if they were parking, paying a meter?

1431
02:49:02.855 --> 02:49:05.040
<v Jeremy Patton>That's a question.

1432
02:49:05.543 --> 02:49:08.452
<v Jeremy Patton>Yeah, I'm gonna bring Eric out to maybe answer that.

1433
02:49:13.719 --> 02:49:14.527
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>Hello, Councilors.

1434
02:49:14.575 --> 02:49:17.110
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>I'm sorry, Commissioner Novick, or Councilor Novick, I apologize.

1435
02:49:17.384 --> 02:49:18.724
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>Can you repeat that question for me, please?

1436
02:49:18.983 --> 02:49:43.327
<v Steve Novick>I was just, this is an incredibly vague question, but have in the parking context, have we ever like come up with a special employee permit where they would pay less than people than they otherwise would on the street or in another context, or like in one of our garages where if an employee works in a particular place, There's some sort of discount for them?

1437
02:49:44.930 --> 02:49:47.463
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>Yes, and I'm sorry, for the record, my name is Erica Namioka-Niebel.

1438
02:49:47.528 --> 02:49:51.725
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>I'm the division manager that oversees parking operations and regulatory operations at PBOT.

1439
02:49:53.661 --> 02:49:57.220
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>We do have business permits in some of the districts.

1440
02:49:57.560 --> 02:50:02.221
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>Downtown is not one of them for central city reasons.

1441
02:50:03.442 --> 02:50:03.540
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>Yeah.

1442
02:50:04.190 --> 02:50:10.846
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>SmartPark would be a great space for that, especially since the garages have capacity right now and they have been for the last few years.

1443
02:50:11.284 --> 02:50:21.599
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>However, zoning does not allow us to sell monthlies at, I believe, 3 of our core garages, which would be 10th and Yamhill, 3rd and Alder, and 4th and Yamhill.

1444
02:50:22.809 --> 02:50:23.765
<v Steve Novick>Zoning doesn't allow us?

1445
02:50:24.364 --> 02:50:25.596
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>I believe so, yes.

1446
02:50:25.986 --> 02:50:26.164
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1447
02:50:26.487 --> 02:50:26.699
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>That's—.

1448
02:50:27.298 --> 02:50:28.918
<v Steve Novick>How would— I wonder why that would be.

1449
02:50:31.088 --> 02:50:34.997
<v Steve Novick>We can follow up on that afterwards, but that's interesting.

1450
02:50:35.755 --> 02:50:41.697
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>Yeah, and there are other garages that also cannot sell monthlies because of that reason, but I'm happy to follow up.

1451
02:50:42.354 --> 02:50:43.174
<v Simone Reddy>Okay.

1452
02:50:43.478 --> 02:50:59.856
<v Steve Novick>And also, I think that I read recently that by rolling back the extension of meters to 10:00 PM, we lost about $5 million a year.

1453
02:50:59.952 --> 02:51:00.483
<v Steve Novick>Is that right?

1454
02:51:02.073 --> 02:51:03.319
<v Erica Namioka-Niebel>I'm going to switch over to Jeremy.

1455
02:51:03.452 --> 02:51:03.685
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1456
02:51:09.435 --> 02:51:21.936
<v Jeremy Patton>We've never actually fully collected a full year's worth of revenue, but based on some of the revenues that we saw coming in when we first initiated that until we stopped it in the fall, if you projected that out, it would probably be close to about $5 million.

1457
02:51:22.292 --> 02:51:26.388
<v Jeremy Patton>What we had actually only built into the budget was about $1 million for the current year that we then paused.

1458
02:51:27.413 --> 02:51:30.629
<v Steve Novick>But it would have been— but we think it would have been close to $5 million a year.

1459
02:51:31.034 --> 02:51:36.644
<v Jeremy Patton>If you extrapolate out what we saw earlier, that just depends on, yeah, if that was a spike in parking during those particular months.

1460
02:51:36.709 --> 02:51:39.907
<v Jeremy Patton>There's just a very, very small data set that we'd have to use for that.

1461
02:51:40.166 --> 02:51:40.343
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

1462
02:51:40.586 --> 02:51:41.070
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1463
02:51:42.510 --> 02:51:43.414
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1464
02:51:45.700 --> 02:51:46.934
<v Jamie Dunphy>Pausing for dramatic effect.

1465
02:51:48.936 --> 02:51:52.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue to discuss, thank you all so much for being here for your presentation.

1466
02:51:53.365 --> 02:51:57.091
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is going to conclude our final work session of this budget season.

1467
02:51:57.781 --> 02:52:01.827
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, just— and for the folks watching at home, just so we know what next steps are with the budget.

1468
02:52:01.956 --> 02:52:09.422
<v Jamie Dunphy>On Monday, this coming Monday, we will be hearing all public testimony for the budget, both for the city's budget and for the Prosper Portland budget.

1469
02:52:09.503 --> 02:52:13.822
<v Jamie Dunphy>That will be happening right, you know, starting up the day in this chamber.

1470
02:52:13.870 --> 02:52:15.202
<v Jamie Dunphy>So everyone plan to get comfy.

1471
02:52:15.781 --> 02:52:21.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Tuesday, we will be hearing the Portland City of Portland budget and the Prosper Portland budget.

1472
02:52:21.702 --> 02:52:29.371
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then on Wednesday, we will be hearing our rate bureau— our rates and our utility ordinances, followed by final work on our amendments.

1473
02:52:30.141 --> 02:52:31.168
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan, last word for you.

1474
02:52:31.505 --> 02:52:31.843
<v Jonas Biery>Oh, sure.

1475
02:52:32.050 --> 02:52:38.981
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to thank CA Lee and all of the DCAs and bureau directors that have shown up for these budget sessions, work sessions.

1476
02:52:39.110 --> 02:52:46.876
<v Dan Ryan>I think these are the most important sessions we have because this is our chance to understand, ask questions understand how to run a city.

1477
02:52:47.934 --> 02:52:59.522
<v Dan Ryan>And when we jump too quickly into policy without having the context of what's really going on and how we operate a city, I don't think we're behaving in a way that will move our city forward.

1478
02:52:59.586 --> 02:53:07.034
<v Dan Ryan>So I just know this has taken up a lot of time, but please know it's so helpful to the public and to those of us that represent the public.

1479
02:53:07.595 --> 02:53:10.131
<v Dan Ryan>And I, I think that we should always lean in.

1480
02:53:10.211 --> 02:53:10.405
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1481
02:53:10.726 --> 02:53:12.218
<v Dan Ryan>To such sessions each year.

1482
02:53:12.506 --> 02:53:18.281
<v Dan Ryan>I actually think we could have them earlier and, and we could be in a more relaxed environment where we're doing dialogue.

1483
02:53:18.682 --> 02:53:19.772
<v Dan Ryan>This isn't about gotchas.

1484
02:53:19.966 --> 02:53:22.980
<v Dan Ryan>It's to understand how to run the city.

1485
02:53:23.495 --> 02:53:26.912
<v Dan Ryan>And I really appreciate the openness that's occurred as these have taken place.

1486
02:53:27.167 --> 02:53:27.488
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1487
02:53:28.130 --> 02:53:29.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1488
02:53:29.414 --> 02:53:30.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for your patience.

1489
02:53:30.792 --> 02:53:32.173
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for your participation.

1490
02:53:32.253 --> 02:53:33.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>And with that, we are adjourned.

