WEBVTT

1
00:02:48.159 --> 00:02:49.360
<v Loretta Smith>So I guess I've got to hand it here.

2
00:02:49.439 --> 00:03:32.949
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm going to ask Right now?

3
00:03:33.590 --> 00:03:34.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Should we just go?

4
00:03:34.629 --> 00:03:35.430
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, okay.

5
00:03:35.509 --> 00:03:36.710
<v Unidentified speaker>They'll kick stuff off officially.

6
00:03:36.789 --> 00:03:37.750
<v Angelita Morillo>Oh, they're gonna start?

7
00:03:37.830 --> 00:03:37.990
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

8
00:03:38.310 --> 00:03:38.389
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

9
00:03:39.750 --> 00:03:40.629
<v Loretta Smith>I'll double-check.

10
00:03:50.629 --> 00:03:50.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

11
00:04:01.860 --> 00:04:03.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon, everybody.

12
00:04:04.099 --> 00:04:13.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Before we begin our meeting of the Portland City Council, we have a pre-gavel recognition from, uh, uh, from our friends at AARP and the Age Friendly Network.

13
00:04:14.099 --> 00:04:15.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>Am I turning it over to you, Councilor?

14
00:04:16.180 --> 00:04:16.259
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

15
00:04:16.189 --> 00:04:16.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>Or am I turning over to Stacy?

16
00:04:16.910 --> 00:04:17.470
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe I'm starting.

17
00:04:17.629 --> 00:04:18.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to start it.

18
00:04:19.470 --> 00:04:22.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>To start us, I'm going to turn it over to Stacy Triplett with the AARP Oregon.

19
00:04:23.230 --> 00:04:23.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

20
00:04:24.110 --> 00:04:24.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

21
00:04:24.509 --> 00:04:27.069
<v Loretta Smith>I'm Stacy Triplett, Engagement Director for AARP Oregon.

22
00:04:27.709 --> 00:04:29.870
<v Angelita Morillo>I live in District 2 and I work in District 4.

23
00:04:30.189 --> 00:04:39.310
<v Loretta Smith>And we are so excited today for the city and partners for this moment of fanfare to move us into the next 5-year cycle of age-friendly actions.

24
00:04:40.189 --> 00:04:43.470
<v Loretta Smith>This age-friendly plaque is truly an expansive effort.

25
00:04:44.209 --> 00:04:49.250
<v Loretta Smith>It represents what everybody has been working on together, and we hope that everyone finds a role in it.

26
00:04:49.410 --> 00:04:54.370
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you very much to the Raging Grannies who sung us in here, who were founded over 15 years ago.

27
00:04:56.689 --> 00:05:03.569
<v Loretta Smith>Oregon has 13 current age-friendly members from Hood River to Ashland, and Portland is in very good company in that network.

28
00:05:03.730 --> 00:05:04.930
<v Loretta Smith>Portland was the first U.S.

29
00:05:05.009 --> 00:05:21.810
<v Angelita Morillo>City involved in the World Health Organization's Global Age-Friendly Research Project that started in 20— In 2006, that research project led to the creation of global and national age-friendly networks, which Portland and Multnomah County remain a part of right now.

30
00:05:22.129 --> 00:05:35.730
<v Unidentified speaker>Today, as I present this plaque to the City of Portland, recognizing that the city and its numerous partners have completed a cycle of assessment, action planning, implementation, and evaluation, I will read the plaque out.

31
00:05:35.970 --> 00:05:44.910
<v Unidentified speaker>AARP says Portland, Oregon is a member in good standing of the AARP Network of Age-Friendly States and Communities has successfully completed a cycle of improvement as an—.

32
00:05:45.069 --> 00:05:52.269
<v Loretta Smith>And is recognized for its age-friendly leadership achievements and continuing commitment toward being a livable community for people of all ages.

33
00:05:52.350 --> 00:05:56.110
<v Unidentified speaker>That is the 2026, uh, plaque that I will leave here.

34
00:05:56.189 --> 00:05:58.230
<v Loretta Smith>I will not take it back with me.

35
00:05:58.589 --> 00:06:05.790
<v Angelita Morillo>As such, Portland is recognized as a member in good standing with the other 1,020 current members and growing.

36
00:06:06.649 --> 00:06:08.569
<v Angelita Morillo>Congrats from AARP Oregon.

37
00:06:08.730 --> 00:06:18.810
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you for all the leadership getting the community active in advancing age-friendly outcomes spanning so many aspects of housing, transportation, public spaces, and beyond.

38
00:06:18.970 --> 00:06:22.009
<v Angelita Morillo>And now back to you, Councilor President Dunphy.

39
00:06:22.089 --> 00:06:23.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much, Stacy.

40
00:06:23.930 --> 00:06:31.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I've had the privilege of being part of Portland's age-friendly journey for more than a decade, dating back to my time as staffer for late Commissioner Nick Fish.

41
00:06:32.350 --> 00:06:44.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>I witnessed the City of Portland and Portland State University support Portland's broader age-friendly efforts on housing, civic engagement, mobility, and health and well-being.

42
00:06:44.670 --> 00:06:52.910
<v Jamie Dunphy>Over time, the community infused age-friendly policies into the Portland Plan, the Comprehensive Plan, and other policies and plans.

43
00:06:53.149 --> 00:07:02.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Portland's age-friendly features include world-class natural features and green spaces and strong opportunities for lifelong education and community engagement.

44
00:07:02.189 --> 00:07:02.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

45
00:07:03.379 --> 00:07:16.660
<v Jamie Dunphy>Real work remains ahead, and I'm excited to work with Councilor Koyama Lane, with Multnomah County, with AARP, and others on revitalizing our age-friendly efforts so that Portlanders of all ages and abilities can live their best lives in our cities.

46
00:07:18.180 --> 00:07:24.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's my honor to turn over to Irma Jimenez, the Multnomah County Aging, Disability, and Veterans Services Division.

47
00:07:25.300 --> 00:07:25.540
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

48
00:07:26.100 --> 00:07:26.420
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

49
00:07:26.819 --> 00:07:28.660
<v Unidentified speaker>As he stated, my name is Irma Jimenez.

50
00:07:28.819 --> 00:07:32.819
<v Unidentified speaker>I am the division director for Multnomah County's Aging, Disability, and Veterans Services Division.

51
00:07:33.860 --> 00:07:36.319
<v Unidentified speaker>Stacy from ARP, who noted that Portland was the first U.S.

52
00:07:36.560 --> 00:07:39.120
<v Loretta Smith>City to work with the World Health Organization.

53
00:07:39.439 --> 00:07:44.000
<v Unidentified speaker>And Council President Dunphy highlighted Portland and Multnomah County's partnership.

54
00:07:45.040 --> 00:07:55.120
<v Unidentified speaker>Multnomah County Aging, Disability, and Veterans Services has been involved in each step of Portland's journey, including our longtime role in the Advisory Council for an Age-Friendly Portland and Multnomah County.

55
00:07:56.079 --> 00:08:09.829
<v Unidentified speaker>In 2014, Multnomah County joined the ARP network of age-friendly states and communities as part of As part of our efforts, we focused on making sure the county is a good place to work no matter your age or your ability.

56
00:08:10.629 --> 00:08:21.829
<v Unidentified speaker>As Portlanders Area Agency on Aging, we continue to innovate, coordinate with national and state partners, and deliver key services and supports to older adults, people with disabilities, and veterans.

57
00:08:22.470 --> 00:08:33.830
<v Unidentified speaker>Recently, we launched an age-friendly business program that aims to attune local business to the needs of older adults and to offer quality services that work for people no matter their age and their— Councilmember Herbold.

58
00:08:34.100 --> 00:08:34.740
<v Candace Avalos>Nor their disability.

59
00:08:35.539 --> 00:08:37.539
<v Unidentified speaker>We are excited to partner on what comes next.

60
00:08:37.940 --> 00:08:41.620
<v Unidentified speaker>Together, the city and the county can create a healthy, supportive, age-friendly community.

61
00:08:42.340 --> 00:08:42.580
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

62
00:08:45.299 --> 00:08:46.620
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know.

63
00:08:47.860 --> 00:09:02.259
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>All right, um, I want to give a huge heartfelt thanks to Council President Dunphy, AARP, Multnomah County, our many community partners for the work that you do every day to make Portland more welcoming, connected, and caring for people of every age.

64
00:09:02.820 --> 00:09:09.679
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also have to give a very special thank you to Thank you to our Raging Grannies for joining us and sharing your music today.

65
00:09:10.480 --> 00:09:18.639
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I see you show up at rallies, protests, community events, in moments when people really need courage and some joy the most.

66
00:09:19.039 --> 00:09:33.440
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I met you first many years back at a Trans Day of Visibility march, and I know that there are Raging Granny groups all over the world, and I'm really proud that we have the largest cohort here in Portland in this chapter.

67
00:09:34.240 --> 00:09:34.960
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And also, they—.

68
00:09:35.279 --> 00:09:35.360
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

69
00:09:35.679 --> 00:09:40.139
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They informed me today that I'm only 10 years away from being able to join the club, so I am counting down.

70
00:09:41.419 --> 00:09:44.139
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>You remind us that older adults are not just sitting on the sidelines.

71
00:09:44.860 --> 00:09:49.259
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Older adults are leading, organizing, singing out, helping move our communities forward.

72
00:09:50.059 --> 00:10:03.100
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>My office also has been really proud to support members of the District 3 community in the Mount Tabor neighborhood whose ideas and advocacy recently secured funding through the AARP Challenge Grant.

73
00:10:03.500 --> 00:10:07.149
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And this These are examples of what people— people-powered change looks like.

74
00:10:07.870 --> 00:10:17.549
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So today, as we recognize Older Americans Month, this year's theme, Champion Your Health, I want us to think bigger than individual choices because health is shaped by the communities we build.

75
00:10:17.950 --> 00:10:20.110
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Health is shaped by the housing we create.

76
00:10:20.669 --> 00:10:23.309
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Health is shaped by the transportation that we provide.

77
00:10:23.950 --> 00:10:28.830
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Health is shaped by whether people feel connected, valued, and safe at every stage of life.

78
00:10:29.789 --> 00:10:33.269
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So that's why my office is focused on some 4 big ideas in this area.

79
00:10:33.590 --> 00:10:36.710
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The first one is being able to grow here at every age.

80
00:10:37.110 --> 00:10:38.629
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The second is everyone ages.

81
00:10:39.909 --> 00:10:42.629
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aging is not something that's someone else's issue.

82
00:10:43.029 --> 00:10:50.230
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>If we're lucky enough to keep living, then we are aging, and we all deserve to age with dignity, connection, and opportunity.

83
00:10:50.950 --> 00:10:52.070
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The third is longevity.

84
00:10:52.549 --> 00:10:59.690
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That means living well with health, purpose, joy, and belonging, and planning for well-being across An entire life course.

85
00:11:00.250 --> 00:11:01.049
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And finally, partnership.

86
00:11:01.610 --> 00:11:10.409
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>An age-friendly Portland only happens when public agencies, nonprofits, educators, businesses, community members are working together across generations.

87
00:11:10.730 --> 00:11:11.690
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So please stay tuned.

88
00:11:11.929 --> 00:11:15.210
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We're going to be continuing this, this work in bigger, bolder ways.

89
00:11:16.330 --> 00:11:17.049
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Be on the lookout.

90
00:11:17.450 --> 00:11:21.610
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And here's to a Portland where aging is joyful and empowering for all.

91
00:11:22.730 --> 00:11:31.269
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And now I am going to read the proclamation on behalf of Mayor Keith Wilson, who cannot join us this afternoon but is very supportive.

92
00:11:32.870 --> 00:12:08.929
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Whereas the City of Portland is home to over 647,805 people, of whom 11.6% are 65 years of age or older, and whereas the number of older adults in Portland is projected to increase significantly in the future, with estimates indicating that by 2050, 27.2% of our population will be comprised of people 65 years of age or older, and whereas Portland's older adults represent Diverse races, ethnicities, cultures, communities, neighborhoods, and generations, contributing to the rich tapestry of our state.

93
00:12:09.570 --> 00:12:19.330
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And whereas older Portlanders continue to be active, engaged, and influential members of our community, participating in volunteer activities, mentoring, and contributing to the workforce.

94
00:12:20.049 --> 00:12:28.129
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And whereas May is designated as Older Americans Month, a time to celebrate and honor the achievements, contributions, and sacrifices of older Portlanders.

95
00:12:28.769 --> 00:12:36.980
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And whereas the theme for Older Americans Month 2026 is Champion Your Health, encouraging us to take an active role in managing and advocating for our health.

96
00:12:37.779 --> 00:12:46.340
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And whereas we strive to build age-friendly communities for people ages 0 to 100+ who are included, engaged, and can thrive.

97
00:12:46.580 --> 00:13:03.700
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And whereas the City of Portland is committed to promoting the health, independence, and well-being of older Americans by addressing issues affecting older adults, including housing, caregiving, workforce, and economic vitality, as well as accessible, inclusive programs to promote the health and well-being of older adults.

98
00:13:03.700 --> 00:13:03.779
<v Angelita Morillo>Second.

99
00:13:04.580 --> 00:13:26.820
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Now, therefore, I, I am not Keith Wilson, but Keith Wilson, the mayor of City of Portland, Oregon, the City of Roses, does hereby proclaim May 2026 to be Older Americans Month in Portland and encourage all businesses and community members to engage with and support older Americans, their families, and their accomplishments to celebrate their contributions.

100
00:13:27.620 --> 00:13:28.419
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so much.

101
00:13:29.299 --> 00:13:29.460
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

102
00:13:35.100 --> 00:13:37.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much for being here today.

103
00:13:38.220 --> 00:13:42.419
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am now going to go ahead and call our meeting to order.

104
00:13:42.779 --> 00:13:44.580
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call the roll?

105
00:13:47.580 --> 00:13:48.580
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

106
00:13:48.940 --> 00:13:49.019
<v Sameer Kanal>Here.

107
00:13:49.580 --> 00:13:50.580
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

108
00:13:51.659 --> 00:13:52.299
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

109
00:13:52.460 --> 00:13:53.100
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

110
00:13:53.419 --> 00:13:54.220
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

111
00:13:54.539 --> 00:13:54.940
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

112
00:13:55.100 --> 00:13:55.659
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

113
00:13:56.110 --> 00:13:57.110
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

114
00:13:57.549 --> 00:13:58.269
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

115
00:13:59.149 --> 00:13:59.230
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

116
00:14:00.350 --> 00:14:00.429
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

117
00:14:04.590 --> 00:14:04.669
<v Unidentified speaker>Here.

118
00:14:05.950 --> 00:14:06.509
<v Unidentified speaker>Here.

119
00:14:06.669 --> 00:14:09.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>And can we please read the rules of decorum?

120
00:14:09.549 --> 00:14:10.110
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

121
00:14:10.269 --> 00:14:11.389
<v Angelita Morillo>Welcome to Portland City Council.

122
00:14:11.710 --> 00:14:17.909
<v Angelita Morillo>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

123
00:14:21.230 --> 00:14:24.350
<v Angelita Morillo>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

124
00:14:25.220 --> 00:14:29.139
<v Angelita Morillo>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

125
00:14:29.220 --> 00:14:31.779
<v Angelita Morillo>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

126
00:14:31.940 --> 00:14:34.019
<v Angelita Morillo>The presiding officer preserves order.

127
00:14:34.179 --> 00:14:42.820
<v Angelita Morillo>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

128
00:14:42.899 --> 00:14:44.980
<v Angelita Morillo>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

129
00:14:45.059 --> 00:14:47.940
<v Angelita Morillo>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

130
00:14:47.940 --> 00:14:52.179
<v Angelita Morillo>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

131
00:14:52.440 --> 00:14:55.399
<v Angelita Morillo>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

132
00:14:56.039 --> 00:14:58.279
<v Angelita Morillo>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

133
00:14:58.759 --> 00:15:00.600
<v Angelita Morillo>When testifying, state your name for the record.

134
00:15:00.919 --> 00:15:02.360
<v Angelita Morillo>Your address is not necessary.

135
00:15:02.919 --> 00:15:05.639
<v Angelita Morillo>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

136
00:15:06.360 --> 00:15:09.960
<v Angelita Morillo>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls their name.

137
00:15:10.279 --> 00:15:10.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

138
00:15:11.240 --> 00:15:11.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

139
00:15:12.360 --> 00:15:15.240
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we have an incredibly busy agenda today.

140
00:15:15.480 --> 00:15:19.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are already scheduled to stay until 6, but we absolutely have to get through this agenda today.

141
00:15:20.919 --> 00:15:26.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Many of these things need to be approved or moved Moving forward before the budget is approved.

142
00:15:26.259 --> 00:15:28.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so I'm hoping that we can all keep that in mind.

143
00:15:29.220 --> 00:15:35.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>To that end, the consent agenda item today has been pulled to the regular agenda at the request of staff.

144
00:15:36.980 --> 00:15:42.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe that this is a— this item is also a must-pass item today for contractual reasons.

145
00:15:42.419 --> 00:15:48.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I would move to place it on the agenda between items 6 and 7 on the regular agenda to get it out of the way.

146
00:15:48.899 --> 00:15:52.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is the first item after we finish up the second reading.

147
00:15:52.259 --> 00:15:52.340
<v Dan Ryan>Second.

148
00:15:54.600 --> 00:16:00.120
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any other requests to amend the agenda, to reorder items, or reschedule an item for a future meeting date?

149
00:16:00.840 --> 00:16:01.639
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

150
00:16:01.799 --> 00:16:03.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor— Vice President Clark.

151
00:16:03.240 --> 00:16:04.039
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor President.

152
00:16:04.279 --> 00:16:12.279
<v Angelita Morillo>I would like to move that we take item 10 and move it up until after item 5, make it item 6.

153
00:16:14.600 --> 00:16:18.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Item 6 is the— before the item pulled through consent.

154
00:16:18.720 --> 00:16:18.799
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

155
00:16:19.200 --> 00:16:19.279
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

156
00:16:20.320 --> 00:16:28.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark has moved to move item 10, the water bonds item, to the top of our regular agenda after the second readings.

157
00:16:28.720 --> 00:16:30.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor Smith has seconded it.

158
00:16:31.039 --> 00:16:33.120
<v Candace Avalos>Point of information, can you tell us why?

159
00:16:33.440 --> 00:16:35.960
<v Angelita Morillo>Just a sense of urgency on this.

160
00:16:37.519 --> 00:16:37.840
<v Angelita Morillo>Pretty straightforward.

161
00:16:38.960 --> 00:16:39.039
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

162
00:16:40.320 --> 00:16:40.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues—.

163
00:16:40.879 --> 00:16:41.360
<v Loretta Smith>Point of order.

164
00:16:42.240 --> 00:16:46.169
<v Angelita Morillo>Are there people signed up for the water bond There are.

165
00:16:46.330 --> 00:16:47.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>There are 20 people signed up for this.

166
00:16:47.529 --> 00:17:00.009
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, so I suspect that many of those people would not be able to attend and testify if we reordered the agenda, and they might have strong feelings about it considering how drastically this could impact water rates over the next few years.

167
00:17:00.809 --> 00:17:07.289
<v Angelita Morillo>So I recommend that we maintain the agenda the same, but I understand this is a vote, so I'm just saying that for my colleagues as they consider their vote.

168
00:17:08.250 --> 00:17:08.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

169
00:17:09.930 --> 00:17:10.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any further discussion?

170
00:17:11.210 --> 00:17:13.730
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, um, and One more point of information.

171
00:17:14.049 --> 00:17:14.369
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor.

172
00:17:14.609 --> 00:17:23.730
<v Candace Avalos>What you mentioned about moving the consent item, I guess, are they— are those separate actions that we need to vote for your change and then Councilor Clark's change?

173
00:17:24.210 --> 00:17:25.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it is one.

174
00:17:27.569 --> 00:17:28.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know.

175
00:17:28.049 --> 00:17:28.769
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm looking at the agenda.

176
00:17:28.769 --> 00:17:31.089
<v Angelita Morillo>I think you can decide how you want to handle it.

177
00:17:31.170 --> 00:17:31.250
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

178
00:17:31.650 --> 00:17:32.690
<v Candace Avalos>I would like to divide the questions.

179
00:17:32.769 --> 00:17:33.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's do 2 separate.

180
00:17:33.490 --> 00:17:35.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>And also, I misspoke.

181
00:17:35.170 --> 00:17:38.130
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd actually like to have the pulled item heard after item 6.

182
00:17:38.329 --> 00:17:40.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>7, Because that is the second reading of an ordinance also.

183
00:17:40.490 --> 00:17:43.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>So it would go between items 7 and 8.

184
00:17:44.089 --> 00:17:46.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm happy to— yeah, let's divide the question.

185
00:17:46.089 --> 00:17:55.289
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's call the roll on the item, on the scheduling of the pulled item from consent, and then we'll have a second vote on reordering item 12 to the top of the agenda.

186
00:17:56.170 --> 00:17:57.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>So can we call the roll on the first part?

187
00:17:59.529 --> 00:18:05.049
<v Unidentified speaker>Calling the vote on reordering consent agenda item 6 to after regular agenda item 7.

188
00:18:05.529 --> 00:18:05.930
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal.

189
00:18:06.460 --> 00:18:06.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

190
00:18:07.259 --> 00:18:07.819
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney.

191
00:18:09.579 --> 00:18:09.660
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan.

192
00:18:10.220 --> 00:18:10.299
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

193
00:18:11.420 --> 00:18:11.980
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane.

194
00:18:12.299 --> 00:18:12.380
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

195
00:18:13.180 --> 00:18:13.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo.

196
00:18:13.980 --> 00:18:14.059
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

197
00:18:14.700 --> 00:18:15.099
<v Loretta Smith>Novick.

198
00:18:15.339 --> 00:18:15.420
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

199
00:18:15.900 --> 00:18:15.980
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark.

200
00:18:16.460 --> 00:18:16.539
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

201
00:18:17.259 --> 00:18:17.339
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

202
00:18:17.819 --> 00:18:17.900
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

203
00:18:18.460 --> 00:18:18.779
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman.

204
00:18:19.180 --> 00:18:19.259
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

205
00:18:19.819 --> 00:18:20.140
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos.

206
00:18:20.460 --> 00:18:20.539
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

207
00:18:21.579 --> 00:18:21.660
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

208
00:18:22.059 --> 00:18:22.140
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

209
00:18:22.859 --> 00:18:23.180
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy.

210
00:18:23.500 --> 00:18:23.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

211
00:18:24.460 --> 00:18:26.619
<v Unidentified speaker>And that agenda reorder is approved.

212
00:18:27.180 --> 00:18:27.339
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

213
00:18:27.500 --> 00:18:31.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>We call the roll on moving item number 10— uh, 12 up.

214
00:18:33.750 --> 00:18:39.269
<v Unidentified speaker>And we're moving item— this is a vote to move item number 12 after, uh, the reordered item 6.

215
00:18:40.470 --> 00:18:41.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>Wait, do I have the wrong numbers?

216
00:18:41.910 --> 00:18:43.670
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, or sorry, item 10.

217
00:18:43.829 --> 00:18:44.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>Item 10.

218
00:18:44.470 --> 00:18:45.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sorry, I have the wrong numbers on my sheet.

219
00:18:46.069 --> 00:18:49.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, moving item number 10 up to— where did you want to put it?

220
00:18:49.910 --> 00:18:53.029
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, maybe before 7, after 6.

221
00:18:53.349 --> 00:18:56.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, between items 5 and 7.

222
00:18:56.710 --> 00:18:57.029
<v Angelita Morillo>Sure.

223
00:18:56.960 --> 00:18:57.359
<v Loretta Smith>That's fine.

224
00:18:57.599 --> 00:18:57.680
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

225
00:18:58.559 --> 00:19:10.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so voting to reorder item 10 to be heard after the newly moved consent item order agenda item 6, but before item 7 on the regular agenda.

226
00:19:10.559 --> 00:19:11.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>That sounds right to me.

227
00:19:11.440 --> 00:19:11.920
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

228
00:19:12.160 --> 00:19:12.400
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

229
00:19:12.880 --> 00:19:12.960
<v Candace Avalos>No.

230
00:19:15.279 --> 00:19:15.759
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

231
00:19:16.880 --> 00:19:16.960
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

232
00:19:18.240 --> 00:19:20.079
<v Dan Ryan>First reading, we have people here to testify.

233
00:19:20.640 --> 00:19:20.720
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

234
00:19:21.920 --> 00:19:22.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

235
00:19:28.210 --> 00:19:28.289
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

236
00:19:31.809 --> 00:19:39.410
<v Angelita Morillo>No, because I'm worried that people who signed up to testify won't know that this order change happened and therefore won't be here in time to testify.

237
00:19:45.329 --> 00:19:46.930
<v Steve Novick>I'm really struggling with this one.

238
00:19:47.250 --> 00:19:51.579
<v Steve Novick>Could we like Find out if the people who are signed up are here.

239
00:19:53.819 --> 00:19:54.220
<v Loretta Smith>There's 20.

240
00:19:55.339 --> 00:19:56.220
<v Candace Avalos>Many are not.

241
00:19:56.619 --> 00:19:57.660
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, many are not.

242
00:19:58.059 --> 00:19:59.019
<v Steve Novick>All right, no.

243
00:20:02.619 --> 00:20:04.140
<v Angelita Morillo>Clark, aye.

244
00:20:07.180 --> 00:20:07.900
<v Unidentified speaker>Green, no.

245
00:20:08.619 --> 00:20:09.420
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman, aye.

246
00:20:10.380 --> 00:20:11.099
<v Candace Avalos>Avalos, no.

247
00:20:13.180 --> 00:20:14.220
<v Loretta Smith>Smith, yes.

248
00:20:16.220 --> 00:20:16.619
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

249
00:20:18.380 --> 00:20:18.460
<v Candace Avalos>No.

250
00:20:20.940 --> 00:20:21.019
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

251
00:20:21.980 --> 00:20:27.019
<v Unidentified speaker>So the reorder, uh, fails with 7 no, 4 aye.

252
00:20:27.660 --> 00:20:31.339
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, the agenda is approved.

253
00:20:32.539 --> 00:20:33.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please move to public communications?

254
00:20:39.660 --> 00:20:47.710
<v Unidentified speaker>First up for public communications, we have Metro G Hello, everyone.

255
00:20:47.950 --> 00:20:48.029
<v Sameer Kanal>Welcome.

256
00:20:48.349 --> 00:20:48.430
<v Candace Avalos>Metro.

257
00:20:49.869 --> 00:21:13.960
<v Loretta Smith>Um, so I noticed that you had a lot of promises for Portland, and there's also a lot of issues that you're working on, such as homelessness, addiction, the $171 million deficit gap, 203 jobs being cut from the city, transferring $27 million from the Portland Clean Energy Fund from Well, clean energy to something else.

258
00:21:14.119 --> 00:21:17.440
<v Loretta Smith>And then the $2.7 billion trade deficit in Oregon.

259
00:21:17.880 --> 00:21:32.359
<v Candace Avalos>But I'm here to talk about a solution that would work on a lot of these issues, um, in addition to promoting pre-pandemic foot traffic, which is changing the pay schedules in Oregon.

260
00:21:32.440 --> 00:21:45.559
<v Candace Avalos>It's instead of having a universal basic income, we're changing the frequency in which people get paid, meaning people would have more financial freedom to do what they need to do in the times that they need to do it.

261
00:21:46.200 --> 00:22:02.279
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I believe that this could be done making a POS system or something like that that takes better accountability of people's hours, um, the discrepancies and the taxes that need to be taken.

262
00:22:03.079 --> 00:22:09.150
<v Candace Avalos>Um, right now there's also $240 million to $400 million loss to wage theft every year.

263
00:22:09.710 --> 00:22:29.950
<v Candace Avalos>So even if this program ran at like 10% capacity, which would be considering failing by most standards, we would be covering potentially up to $40 million, which would help not only run the program, but also mean there'd be less loss of jobs and there'd also be no new tax created to do this.

264
00:22:31.069 --> 00:22:31.950
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

265
00:22:33.990 --> 00:22:51.750
<v Candace Avalos>And this could also mean that there's less action needing to be taken from BOLI since there's about 120,000 cases made each year and less than 5% of them are even taken to BOLI.

266
00:22:52.869 --> 00:22:54.630
<v Unidentified speaker>That's really all I have to say.

267
00:22:55.829 --> 00:22:57.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

268
00:22:57.440 --> 00:22:58.240
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you.

269
00:23:00.559 --> 00:23:04.480
<v Unidentified speaker>Next is Jesse Atkins— apologies, Akins.

270
00:23:11.039 --> 00:23:11.119
<v Candace Avalos>Welcome.

271
00:23:12.079 --> 00:23:12.160
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi.

272
00:23:14.640 --> 00:23:16.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>So make sure to introduce yourself.

273
00:23:16.319 --> 00:23:17.119
<v Mitch Green>I'm Jesse Akins.

274
00:23:18.079 --> 00:23:22.640
<v Mitch Green>Um, I am an unemployed veteran of the United States Army.

275
00:23:22.880 --> 00:23:23.680
<v Mitch Green>I live in District 3.

276
00:23:25.519 --> 00:23:30.589
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm pretty annoyed, honestly, with a lot of the things that have been going on lately.

277
00:23:30.670 --> 00:23:38.430
<v Mitch Green>Um, and basically it comes down to morals and ethics, right?

278
00:23:38.589 --> 00:23:48.670
<v Mitch Green>This budget thing we're dealing with, with the Moda Center and all the backroom dealing and the backtalk and the— all of the duplicity that's been in play.

279
00:23:48.829 --> 00:23:53.880
<v Mitch Green>Um, it's really frustrating to see All of that go down.

280
00:23:54.039 --> 00:24:06.200
<v Mitch Green>Um, there's a lot of us in this city who live on a fixed income who can't, you know, can't afford all of our utility rates to go up, can't afford— that includes the street utility fee, unfortunately.

281
00:24:06.359 --> 00:24:11.880
<v Mitch Green>Um, it includes, you know, all of our gas money going up, which we can't control.

282
00:24:12.039 --> 00:24:22.650
<v Mitch Green>You know, we can't afford all of the things that we have to afford in order to sacrifice In order for MOTA funding to go through.

283
00:24:22.809 --> 00:24:30.329
<v Mitch Green>We have this huge bundle of money that we could use to solve a lot of problems for a lot of people that are environmentally related, right?

284
00:24:30.650 --> 00:24:34.329
<v Mitch Green>Between, again, all those utility fees.

285
00:24:34.490 --> 00:24:38.650
<v Mitch Green>Think about how much a renter pays in utility fees in this city.

286
00:24:38.730 --> 00:24:45.369
<v Mitch Green>Like, it's wild that we are talking about transferring funds from one— from this other fund.

287
00:24:45.450 --> 00:24:45.769
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

288
00:24:45.980 --> 00:24:53.579
<v Mitch Green>To the Moda Center when the Moda Center should be funded already in the lease, in the ordinances that go into it.

289
00:24:53.740 --> 00:24:59.579
<v Mitch Green>Those, those go from one tenant to the next tenant according to those documents.

290
00:25:03.099 --> 00:25:04.619
<v Mitch Green>Why are we worried about the PSIF?

291
00:25:04.700 --> 00:25:06.140
<v Mitch Green>Why are we pulling money out of the PSIF?

292
00:25:06.220 --> 00:25:08.339
<v Mitch Green>That money should already be there.

293
00:25:08.940 --> 00:25:12.619
<v Mitch Green>Why are we sacrificing everybody else's cost of living?

294
00:25:13.869 --> 00:25:15.710
<v Mitch Green>For a basketball team, which we love.

295
00:25:16.109 --> 00:25:17.710
<v Mitch Green>I've loved the Blazers since I was a kid.

296
00:25:20.029 --> 00:25:26.269
<v Mitch Green>But are they really the heart of Portland, or are the people who live here the heart of Portland?

297
00:25:27.549 --> 00:25:48.410
<v Mitch Green>The people who are struggling every day, the people who can't— who make just enough, they can't get enough money from any assistance agencies because they're just over that edge, but they don't make enough to survive all the cost increases that we constantly, constantly, constantly, constantly vote Let's cut everything else.

298
00:25:48.569 --> 00:25:55.329
<v Mitch Green>Let's leave the— let's, let's, let's raid the fund that we do have for renovation that's already paid for.

299
00:25:56.170 --> 00:25:57.170
<v Mitch Green>Why?

300
00:25:58.410 --> 00:26:00.049
<v Mitch Green>Why are we doing that?

301
00:26:02.250 --> 00:26:04.009
<v Mitch Green>Let's think about our morals and our ethics.

302
00:26:04.009 --> 00:26:07.849
<v Mitch Green>Who are we screwing over, and who are we protecting, and who are we helping?

303
00:26:08.089 --> 00:26:10.410
<v Mitch Green>Some of us have already made that decision in previous sessions.

304
00:26:10.970 --> 00:26:15.039
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Regarding the Moda Center, his name signed on it.

305
00:26:15.039 --> 00:26:16.559
<v Mitch Green>He already, he already displayed his.

306
00:26:17.279 --> 00:26:19.000
<v Mitch Green>I'd like to see yours.

307
00:26:19.920 --> 00:26:20.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

308
00:26:21.599 --> 00:26:22.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Marshall McFarland.

309
00:26:28.240 --> 00:26:28.319
<v Mitch Green>Welcome.

310
00:26:31.119 --> 00:26:31.759
<v Mitch Green>Good to see you guys.

311
00:26:33.759 --> 00:26:37.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ladies and gentlemen of the City Council, my name is Marshall McFarland.

312
00:26:37.349 --> 00:26:37.670
<v Mitch Green>Good evening, everyone.

313
00:26:37.750 --> 00:26:40.190
<v Mitch Green>I am Ghalib bin Imhotep El.

314
00:26:40.710 --> 00:26:43.710
<v Mitch Green>And Portland is being besieged by a fiatocracy.

315
00:26:44.630 --> 00:26:46.109
<v Mitch Green>What is a fiatocracy?

316
00:26:46.630 --> 00:26:52.390
<v Mitch Green>Fiat, an authoritative, arbitrary order or decree issued by someone in power.

317
00:26:52.630 --> 00:26:57.710
<v Mitch Green>Fiatocracy, rule by authoritative, arbitrary order or decree.

318
00:26:58.069 --> 00:27:01.990
<v Mitch Green>What is fiatocracy really costing the city of Portland?

319
00:27:02.150 --> 00:27:09.160
<v Mitch Green>We're told that democracy is the price that we pay for a civilized society, but Portland is being taxed By a fiatocracy.

320
00:27:09.599 --> 00:27:27.920
<v Mitch Green>Our government has devolved into an unsustainable, self-sustaining loop where democracy, ruled by the people, is being replaced by fiatocracy, ruled by an arbitrary administrative class under a decree, internal fees, and a willful ignorance to the public's trust that somebody put in power.

321
00:27:28.160 --> 00:27:30.640
<v Mitch Green>Since numbers don't lie, consider these numbers.

322
00:27:30.799 --> 00:27:42.410
<v Mitch Green>There are 98 active communities Whose costs or amounts that I can't— able to— excuse me, that aren't able to be properly sounded with public access tools, but I can verify that they're over $20 million.

323
00:27:43.930 --> 00:27:48.650
<v Loretta Smith>Then you've got the 12-member council that costs $1.6 million per office.

324
00:27:49.130 --> 00:27:50.089
<v Mitch Green>That's another $20 million.

325
00:27:51.369 --> 00:27:56.809
<v Mitch Green>Internal interagency rates, which is the rent the city charges itself, has ballooned to over half a billion dollars.

326
00:27:58.730 --> 00:28:06.539
<v Mitch Green>While the public is left clamoring for meager grants or loans from an overwhelmed Small Business Association that has its own bureaucratic quagmire to deal with.

327
00:28:07.019 --> 00:28:12.059
<v Mitch Green>Our region lost nearly 9,000 jobs, ranking us 4th worst in the nation.

328
00:28:12.220 --> 00:28:18.299
<v Mitch Green>We are spending $23 million a year on legislative overhead and facing a $170 million budget shortfall.

329
00:28:19.099 --> 00:28:25.180
<v Mitch Green>The city's own audits show material weaknesses in financial reporting, according to their auditing law firm Baker Tilly.

330
00:28:25.339 --> 00:28:30.410
<v Mitch Green>There's literally no accounting for the efficiency that their budgeting should accommodate With abundance.

331
00:28:31.369 --> 00:28:38.250
<v Mitch Green>Human Resources Rule— Administrative Rule 11.01 speaks of public trust, yet it's being disregarded in its totality.

332
00:28:39.210 --> 00:28:45.609
<v Sameer Kanal>We prioritize emergency ordinances that hike employee benefits while tabling independent transparency oversight.

333
00:28:46.730 --> 00:28:55.930
<v Mitch Green>When a government treats the public as a revenue source instead of beneficiaries of a public trust, they cease becoming a republic and become a public liability.

334
00:28:56.009 --> 00:28:56.250
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

335
00:28:57.259 --> 00:29:08.460
<v Mitch Green>True du jour governance begins with reference, relation, and regard to the people, the public, the public that put— the same public that put the mayor and you 12 wonderful beings on that dais.

336
00:29:09.500 --> 00:29:17.660
<v Mitch Green>Please, councilors, no more arbitrary decrees, no more intergovernmental gouging agreements, and no more willful ignorance of the public's trust.

337
00:29:18.220 --> 00:29:23.660
<v Mitch Green>Our government must refer to the public, relate to the public, and regard the public or be restructured.

338
00:29:24.359 --> 00:29:25.680
<v Mitch Green>By the public.

339
00:29:26.759 --> 00:29:27.799
<v Mitch Green>I will always offer solutions.

340
00:29:29.079 --> 00:29:35.279
<v Mitch Green>This document I've already submitted to the councilor for public record— or the council clerk for public record.

341
00:29:35.960 --> 00:29:38.359
<v Mitch Green>It's also for your record should you undertake to review it.

342
00:29:39.000 --> 00:29:44.920
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for your time, and it is will that your ethical standards align with reference, regard, and relation to the public.

343
00:29:45.640 --> 00:29:45.960
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

344
00:29:46.200 --> 00:29:46.839
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

345
00:29:47.480 --> 00:29:48.880
<v Unidentified speaker>James Donnelly.

346
00:29:53.730 --> 00:29:53.809
<v Dan Ryan>Welcome.

347
00:30:00.849 --> 00:30:02.650
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon, councilors.

348
00:30:03.009 --> 00:30:08.329
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is James Donnelly and I live in East Portland, um, but I'm really speaking for myself.

349
00:30:09.410 --> 00:30:15.009
<v Sameer Kanal>In Buddhism, as in other philosophies that have endured, one teaching is that there is a limit to compassion.

350
00:30:15.980 --> 00:30:23.220
<v Sameer Kanal>It is indeed good to help others, but that can be done only to the degree that it does not cause yourself also to suffer.

351
00:30:23.740 --> 00:30:27.819
<v Sameer Kanal>For if not, this helping just increases the overall suffering in the world.

352
00:30:27.980 --> 00:30:34.619
<v Sameer Kanal>And if unchecked, causing yourself to suffer will eventually destroy you and leave the person you are trying to help with no one.

353
00:30:34.940 --> 00:30:39.019
<v Sameer Kanal>Portland has been trying to be compassionate and has been suffering for it for 6 years.

354
00:30:39.099 --> 00:30:39.900
<v Sameer Kanal>It needs to stop.

355
00:30:40.220 --> 00:30:40.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

356
00:30:41.109 --> 00:30:46.390
<v Sameer Kanal>Homelessness, high housing costs, high medical costs— these are all worthy problems to solve.

357
00:30:47.829 --> 00:30:49.990
<v Sameer Kanal>But Portland did not create these problems.

358
00:30:50.150 --> 00:30:56.670
<v Sameer Kanal>They were created by governmental policies at the federal level and ultimately can be solved only at the federal level.

359
00:30:56.869 --> 00:31:00.670
<v Sameer Kanal>At best, all Portland and Oregon can do is take care of their own.

360
00:31:01.750 --> 00:31:07.349
<v Sameer Kanal>Yet Portland City seems to have little, if any, residency requirements for receiving extra governmental services for help.

361
00:31:08.289 --> 00:31:11.890
<v Sameer Kanal>And by residency, I mean people who have called Portland their home before they ran into problems.

362
00:31:12.930 --> 00:31:23.410
<v Sameer Kanal>It is not sustainable to simultaneously offer more supportive social services than other cities, allow anyone who has just wandered across the city line to receive them, and keep the city solvent.

363
00:31:23.970 --> 00:31:27.730
<v Sameer Kanal>I stress, it is not sustainable, not in 2026 America.

364
00:31:28.609 --> 00:31:29.250
<v Dan Ryan>Please fix that.

365
00:31:29.730 --> 00:31:30.049
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

366
00:31:31.009 --> 00:31:32.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

367
00:31:34.049 --> 00:31:35.329
<v Unidentified speaker>Brandon Morgove.

368
00:31:47.490 --> 00:31:47.890
<v Dan Ryan>Can you hear me?

369
00:31:48.369 --> 00:31:49.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

370
00:31:49.569 --> 00:31:52.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, first off, I'd like to thank Councilor Dunphy.

371
00:31:52.289 --> 00:31:53.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>I read an article the other day.

372
00:31:53.250 --> 00:32:03.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>It sounds like he's trying to hold the Blazer owner, you know, kind of in check and trying to, um, fight him to keep, you know, the money Going the right way out there.

373
00:32:04.259 --> 00:32:06.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>So what I'm talking about today is 3 things.

374
00:32:07.059 --> 00:32:12.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>These things I think are all important to the city, to its well-being.

375
00:32:13.220 --> 00:32:23.380
<v Jamie Dunphy>First one is, I was going to wear a shirt today that said, blame all your problems on the homeless, close your business, and GTFO.

376
00:32:24.019 --> 00:32:26.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I didn't have the funds to get that shirt ready.

377
00:32:26.339 --> 00:32:32.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Anyways, on closing of the businesses, I kind of feel like It's trendy for Portlanders to close their business.

378
00:32:32.359 --> 00:32:33.000
<v Sameer Kanal>It's like a trend.

379
00:32:33.000 --> 00:32:33.400
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's cool.

380
00:32:33.480 --> 00:32:34.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to close my business.

381
00:32:34.599 --> 00:32:39.240
<v Jamie Dunphy>And what I'd like you all to do, city councilors, when you walk into a business, take a look at the security guards.

382
00:32:40.039 --> 00:32:43.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>The homeless and people that have addictions have always stolen from businesses.

383
00:32:43.960 --> 00:32:45.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Security guards aren't doing their jobs.

384
00:32:45.079 --> 00:32:46.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>You walk in there, they're looking at their phones half the time.

385
00:32:46.839 --> 00:32:52.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>If I was doing that job, I would look at my phone too, here and there, a couple times during the shift, just when I really needed to.

386
00:32:53.160 --> 00:32:57.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>But these businesses are closing because It's cool to close, I think, really.

387
00:32:58.549 --> 00:32:59.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>Second thing, bathrooms.

388
00:33:00.069 --> 00:33:02.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need more bathrooms in the city just to have a clean city.

389
00:33:03.109 --> 00:33:08.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>You have a construction job, you ought to build 4 or 5 more bathrooms just like Pioneer Square with a security guard around town.

390
00:33:10.150 --> 00:33:13.910
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lastly, last thing I was doing, trash cans.

391
00:33:14.309 --> 00:33:16.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, a lot of businesses just don't put trash cans out.

392
00:33:16.309 --> 00:33:16.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>Why?

393
00:33:16.470 --> 00:33:18.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because yeah, a homeless person will break into a trash can.

394
00:33:18.390 --> 00:33:19.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>So no trash cans.

395
00:33:19.670 --> 00:33:21.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, they don't want to clean up one time.

396
00:33:21.349 --> 00:33:22.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, it's too much to ask.

397
00:33:22.950 --> 00:33:33.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, Put the people and the people of Portland, ask them, you know, to kind of do something for the city, like put out trash cans, you know, and say, here, you want trash can, pay the city $500 to have a trash can.

398
00:33:33.680 --> 00:33:35.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Where's the person supposed to throw their trash, you know?

399
00:33:35.759 --> 00:33:37.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>And this kind of goes to the bathrooms too.

400
00:33:37.200 --> 00:33:46.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>If someone doesn't want to clean one bathroom one time, you know, or once every couple months, you know, it's just, you got to ask the people of Portland if you want to keep the city nice.

401
00:33:47.039 --> 00:33:49.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>Trash cans, got to keep them around, the ones that are hard to break into.

402
00:33:49.839 --> 00:33:50.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

403
00:33:50.359 --> 00:33:53.160
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, and bathrooms, 4 or 5.

404
00:33:53.160 --> 00:33:56.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if you guys need workers for them, my temp agency boss can supply them.

405
00:33:56.200 --> 00:34:01.039
<v Jamie Dunphy>Maybe you guys can throw me a little money or something for all the work I do on the side and don't get paid for.

406
00:34:01.720 --> 00:34:02.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's it.

407
00:34:02.839 --> 00:34:03.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

408
00:34:05.400 --> 00:34:06.519
<v Unidentified speaker>That completes public comment.

409
00:34:07.400 --> 00:34:10.519
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, everybody who came to testify.

410
00:34:10.599 --> 00:34:14.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, colleagues, uh, next item is a quick president update.

411
00:34:14.760 --> 00:34:23.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I'd like to take a moment very quickly to tell you all about a new rule Moving forward, I'm going to be asking everyone who is participating virtually to turn their cameras on during votes.

412
00:34:24.539 --> 00:34:29.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the only way we can know if you are absent or present for the vote before the clerk calls your name.

413
00:34:29.340 --> 00:34:39.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>You also may notice we have participating virtually for folks who are participating virtually so that folks in the audience and at home can know that they're not just absent, they're online.

414
00:34:40.460 --> 00:34:43.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll give reminders and a little time to get on camera before we do call the roll.

415
00:34:44.099 --> 00:34:44.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>Call roll when that happens.

416
00:34:46.340 --> 00:34:49.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to turn this over to Councilor Green for a very brief update as well.

417
00:34:50.820 --> 00:34:52.019
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you, Council President.

418
00:34:54.500 --> 00:35:06.260
<v Mitch Green>On April 3rd, the Portland DSA held a town hall where 4 city councilors who are endorsed members of the Portland City Council, myself included, were present.

419
00:35:06.820 --> 00:35:10.739
<v Mitch Green>And 3 of those councilors constitute a quorum of the Public Works Committee.

420
00:35:11.219 --> 00:35:19.849
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm only bringing this up because we did receive a grievance recently that said Hey, I noticed that there were 3 city councilors of the Public Works Committee at this town hall.

421
00:35:20.409 --> 00:35:24.090
<v Mitch Green>We think this might potentially be in violation of public meetings law.

422
00:35:24.650 --> 00:35:35.929
<v Mitch Green>So my instinct, rather than to sort of say, well, I think that you are wrong, or I think that we didn't talk about anything that was relevant in that committee, was to sort of take seriously the grievance and try to use the cure procedure that is in law.

423
00:35:36.170 --> 00:35:53.769
<v Mitch Green>So within Oregon state law, Oregon public meetings law, you can cure You can recover a misstep or a violation of failing to properly notice a meeting if you do it within 45 days in a publicly noticed forum, and then you read into the record and you place into the record a transcript of what happened there.

424
00:35:54.409 --> 00:36:02.409
<v Mitch Green>So I'm just going to take a brief moment to talk about the nature of the questions that we got into with the members of that audience.

425
00:36:03.929 --> 00:36:05.849
<v Mitch Green>We did talk about the transportation utility fee.

426
00:36:06.730 --> 00:36:06.969
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

427
00:36:07.019 --> 00:36:07.099
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

428
00:36:07.420 --> 00:36:10.300
<v Mitch Green>In the Committee of the Whole at that time, but we talked about that.

429
00:36:11.179 --> 00:36:14.219
<v Mitch Green>Earthquake preparedness and the CEI hub was a matter of conversation.

430
00:36:14.460 --> 00:36:19.500
<v Mitch Green>Emergency management and the importance of having NET volunteers was a topic of conversations.

431
00:36:20.380 --> 00:36:27.900
<v Mitch Green>People in that town hall wanted to know what council's doing on implementing a human rights investment screen, so we talked about that as well.

432
00:36:28.460 --> 00:36:34.059
<v Mitch Green>Folks wanted to know about whether or not we're going to move forward with trying to do a more aggressive relocation assistance.

433
00:36:35.170 --> 00:36:35.570
<v Dan Ryan>Type of policy.

434
00:36:35.809 --> 00:36:36.849
<v Mitch Green>And we talked about that as well.

435
00:36:37.809 --> 00:36:40.210
<v Mitch Green>The Moda Center Stadium deal came up in that meeting as well.

436
00:36:40.610 --> 00:36:43.889
<v Mitch Green>And your councilors had a dialogue around where they're at on that.

437
00:36:45.090 --> 00:36:49.650
<v Mitch Green>There was a request to look at our sister city relationship with Ashkelon.

438
00:36:50.050 --> 00:36:51.250
<v Mitch Green>That was in that town hall as well.

439
00:36:52.369 --> 00:36:57.250
<v Mitch Green>And then finally, there was a desire for us to pursue taxes on large corporations.

440
00:36:57.650 --> 00:36:59.329
<v Mitch Green>So councilors talked about that as well.

441
00:36:59.809 --> 00:37:03.699
<v Mitch Green>So while it's not obvious that any of those topics would come before the Public Works Okay.

442
00:37:03.860 --> 00:37:06.739
<v Mitch Green>—In any meaningful timeframe in the near period.

443
00:37:07.619 --> 00:37:15.219
<v Mitch Green>Because of our committee structure and the way we can refer items to basically any committee, I can't rule out that none of those items would ever come before the Public Works Committee.

444
00:37:15.460 --> 00:37:21.380
<v Mitch Green>So we're taking this moment just to read in the record that we had that conversation, that that happened on April 3rd.

445
00:37:22.099 --> 00:37:25.219
<v Mitch Green>We're placing into the public record the transcript that will be available.

446
00:37:26.179 --> 00:37:28.820
<v Mitch Green>And going forward, we'll have to do one of two things.

447
00:37:28.900 --> 00:37:30.159
<v Mitch Green>We'll either notice it I would love to.

448
00:37:30.159 --> 00:37:36.960
<v Mitch Green>You could advertise it as a meeting of the Public Works Committee, which would require the chair over here to say we're going to have a socialist town hall Public Works Committee meeting.

449
00:37:37.119 --> 00:37:38.400
<v Mitch Green>And I would invite you to do it.

450
00:37:38.400 --> 00:37:39.519
<v Mitch Green>I think they'd love to have you.

451
00:37:39.599 --> 00:37:40.559
<v Mitch Green>Same with Councilor Smith.

452
00:37:41.360 --> 00:37:43.840
<v Mitch Green>The more the merrier in the big tent that we call the Portland DSA.

453
00:37:45.039 --> 00:37:51.519
<v Mitch Green>But at the very minimum, we would just read a disclaimer and say, hey, you do have a quorum of your councilors on this committee.

454
00:37:51.519 --> 00:37:53.440
<v Mitch Green>There are things that we have to be very careful about.

455
00:37:53.519 --> 00:37:59.079
<v Mitch Green>We would just decline to comment on that and say Next meeting of the Public Works Committee is on X date.

456
00:37:59.239 --> 00:38:01.000
<v Mitch Green>We encourage you to come and bring your questions there.

457
00:38:01.079 --> 00:38:07.440
<v Mitch Green>So I'll stop talking there, and I think there's 2 other councilors that might want to speak something in the record as well.

458
00:38:10.199 --> 00:38:11.480
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, thank you, Councilor Green.

459
00:38:11.480 --> 00:38:13.000
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think you covered most of that.

460
00:38:13.159 --> 00:38:18.599
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I, uh, sat down with our city attorney Robert Taylor and also spoke about this.

461
00:38:18.679 --> 00:38:32.250
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know that all of us care a lot about transparency and openness, and Do you recall that we also talked about how we could answer questions, but this was a place that we could not have any deliberation or decision-making?

462
00:38:32.969 --> 00:38:41.769
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And Robert Taylor agrees that we can have some sort of statement to make sure that we read that at the beginning of any time that we're all appearing at the same place.

463
00:38:41.769 --> 00:38:52.099
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that can apply for any councilors that might make up a quorum if they're at a Socialist Town Hall or a Metro Chamber event or whatever.

464
00:38:53.059 --> 00:38:55.219
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We can just do that to make sure that we're covering our bases.

465
00:38:55.940 --> 00:39:01.539
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And the only quotes I saw from me was around the CEI Hub.

466
00:39:01.699 --> 00:39:03.059
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I said it is really scary.

467
00:39:03.219 --> 00:39:04.420
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think more people should be scared.

468
00:39:05.059 --> 00:39:08.179
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And around Vision Zero, I said that we have recommitted to Vision Zero.

469
00:39:09.219 --> 00:39:10.099
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's about it.

470
00:39:10.340 --> 00:39:13.940
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Around just infrastructure, I said city government should not be a gatekeeper.

471
00:39:14.099 --> 00:39:16.599
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It should be a megaphone for the People of Portland.

472
00:39:16.920 --> 00:39:17.719
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Those are some quotes.

473
00:39:17.880 --> 00:39:22.840
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They will be put into this meeting as an attachment, the transcript will.

474
00:39:23.159 --> 00:39:23.400
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

475
00:39:24.440 --> 00:39:25.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

476
00:39:27.239 --> 00:39:29.000
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thank you, Council President.

477
00:39:29.239 --> 00:39:31.960
<v Sameer Kanal>I was the 3rd of the councilors who was a member of that committee.

478
00:39:32.199 --> 00:39:35.559
<v Sameer Kanal>Just appreciate the work to get that into the record.

479
00:39:36.920 --> 00:39:40.920
<v Sameer Kanal>Again, nothing that I anticipate coming to that committee, but can't rule it out.

480
00:39:41.320 --> 00:39:48.500
<v Sameer Kanal>I will note the committee started meeting in April, but we created it in, Later in April, but we created it in February.

481
00:39:48.900 --> 00:39:51.860
<v Sameer Kanal>So there's a little bit of a challenge there with the timing as well.

482
00:39:52.820 --> 00:39:55.699
<v Sameer Kanal>But appreciate the transparency on it.

483
00:39:55.699 --> 00:40:02.420
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll note this was a publicly noticed event, and I always have my calendar posted of the places I'm going to be in public.

484
00:40:03.460 --> 00:40:09.860
<v Sameer Kanal>So you can check all of our websites, portland.gov/ourlastname usually has it, even if it's not in the immediate full council website.

485
00:40:10.420 --> 00:40:10.739
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

486
00:40:11.219 --> 00:40:11.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, councilors.

487
00:40:11.909 --> 00:40:12.070
<v Unidentified speaker>City Manager.

488
00:40:13.670 --> 00:40:14.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can I add one thing?

489
00:40:14.949 --> 00:40:15.269
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, please.

490
00:40:15.909 --> 00:40:16.789
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm a socialist.

491
00:40:17.190 --> 00:40:18.150
<v Angelita Morillo>I was at the meeting.

492
00:40:18.230 --> 00:40:28.710
<v Angelita Morillo>I am not part of the Public Works Committee, so I was included in part of the violation of the— or I was listed as one of the people there, but technically I did not commit a quorum violation.

493
00:40:28.869 --> 00:40:30.789
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't think— I think we're doing the cure right now.

494
00:40:31.190 --> 00:40:45.159
<v Angelita Morillo>But I just wanted to flag for members of the public that what is essentially happening with the quorum rules that were There was an attempt to correct the quorum rules and some of the issues with them at the state legislature, and that was vetoed by the governor.

495
00:40:45.239 --> 00:40:53.639
<v Angelita Morillo>And what you are going to see moving forward is that if there is a town hall and, say, you're councilors, there's a tricky topic that comes up for committee.

496
00:40:53.719 --> 00:41:06.610
<v Angelita Morillo>If I wanted to avoid answering your questions as a member of the committee about those topics, what I would do is I would invite 3 members of the committee to come with me so that when you ask your question, I could say, Whoops, I'm so sorry about that.

497
00:41:06.690 --> 00:41:11.329
<v Angelita Morillo>We actually can't answer any questions about that because there's a quorum here.

498
00:41:11.489 --> 00:41:19.489
<v Angelita Morillo>That is going to be the material impact on you as voters and residents of Portlanders trying to get answers from your elected officials at public meetings.

499
00:41:19.969 --> 00:41:27.090
<v Angelita Morillo>And I certainly don't believe that there should be any deliberations behind the scenes without the public present and available to understand that.

500
00:41:27.090 --> 00:41:32.610
<v Angelita Morillo>But I want to point out the access issues that you are going to face moving forward.

501
00:41:32.869 --> 00:41:33.909
<v Angelita Morillo>If, uh, if that happens.

502
00:41:34.869 --> 00:41:42.710
<v Angelita Morillo>So I, I just want to be clear about why, if we're holding a meeting moving forward, if we can't answer your questions, why that might happen.

503
00:41:42.869 --> 00:41:42.949
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks.

504
00:41:43.989 --> 00:41:44.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

505
00:41:46.630 --> 00:41:51.510
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator Lee, do we have any updates on the city's response to the federal interventions?

506
00:41:52.710 --> 00:41:53.349
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, we do.

507
00:41:53.909 --> 00:42:10.500
<v Sameer Kanal>The hearing actually did conclude, and there is something posted online on our website As it relates to the hearing officer, uh, releasing her, uh, decision on this on June the 5th at 3:00 PM.

508
00:42:10.900 --> 00:42:14.500
<v Steve Novick>So that ruling will be released at that time.

509
00:42:15.619 --> 00:42:16.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, sir.

510
00:42:18.659 --> 00:42:20.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 4?

511
00:42:22.099 --> 00:42:47.940
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 4, consider appeal by Pleasant Valley Neighborhood Association against the hearings officer's decision to approve with conditions a planned development land division and environmental review for the creation of 12 single dwelling lots and 1 multi-dwelling lot in the Pleasant Valley neighborhood, LU23-003731, LDS ENPD document number 2026-144.

512
00:42:48.980 --> 00:42:49.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

513
00:42:50.260 --> 00:43:00.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, on April 23rd, Council voted 8 to 1 to tentatively deny the appeal and uphold the hearings officer's decision with conditions, with revised findings.

514
00:43:01.070 --> 00:43:05.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>The revised findings were prepared and posted on the council agenda website on Friday.

515
00:43:05.630 --> 00:43:08.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are now ready to take a final vote.

516
00:43:08.349 --> 00:43:14.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>May I have a motion to deny the appeal, uphold the decision of the hearings officer, and adopt the findings?

517
00:43:14.750 --> 00:43:15.909
<v Candace Avalos>So moved.

518
00:43:16.110 --> 00:43:17.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there a second?

519
00:43:17.400 --> 00:43:17.480
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

520
00:43:20.119 --> 00:43:22.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan moves, Councilor Kanal seconds.

521
00:43:22.840 --> 00:43:23.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call the roll?

522
00:43:27.079 --> 00:43:27.320
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

523
00:43:28.039 --> 00:43:28.119
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

524
00:43:29.960 --> 00:43:30.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

525
00:43:34.440 --> 00:43:34.519
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

526
00:43:36.039 --> 00:43:36.119
<v Steve Novick>Ryan?

527
00:43:36.599 --> 00:43:36.679
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

528
00:43:37.480 --> 00:43:37.960
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

529
00:43:38.280 --> 00:43:38.360
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

530
00:43:40.039 --> 00:43:40.280
<v Angelita Morillo>Murillo?

531
00:43:40.679 --> 00:43:40.760
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

532
00:43:42.280 --> 00:43:42.679
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

533
00:43:42.840 --> 00:43:42.920
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

534
00:43:46.090 --> 00:43:46.969
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark, absent.

535
00:43:48.969 --> 00:43:49.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

536
00:43:49.929 --> 00:43:50.010
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

537
00:43:50.809 --> 00:43:51.210
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

538
00:43:51.530 --> 00:43:51.610
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

539
00:43:52.730 --> 00:43:53.690
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos, absent.

540
00:43:55.130 --> 00:43:55.929
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith, absent.

541
00:43:56.329 --> 00:43:56.730
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

542
00:43:57.130 --> 00:43:57.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

543
00:44:00.250 --> 00:44:06.809
<v Unidentified speaker>And the motion is approved with 7 aye votes, 1 nay, and 3 absent.

544
00:44:07.369 --> 00:44:08.969
<v Unidentified speaker>The appeal is— oh, pardon me, 8.

545
00:44:09.599 --> 00:44:10.400
<v Unidentified speaker>8 Aye votes.

546
00:44:10.880 --> 00:44:11.119
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

547
00:44:11.519 --> 00:44:12.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

548
00:44:12.239 --> 00:44:13.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>The appeal is denied.

549
00:44:13.840 --> 00:44:17.519
<v Jamie Dunphy>The decision of the hearings officer is upheld and the findings are adopted.

550
00:44:18.719 --> 00:44:22.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item 5?

551
00:44:23.920 --> 00:44:35.599
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 5, approve funding recommendations of the Portland Children's Levy Allocation Committee for July 1st, 2026 through June 30th, 2029, document number 2026-132.

552
00:44:36.269 --> 00:44:40.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, last week we heard public testimony on this item and moved it to a second reading without debate.

553
00:44:41.150 --> 00:44:42.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today we will discuss and vote.

554
00:44:43.550 --> 00:44:49.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have staff available in the room to answer any questions about this, so we are gonna move now into council discussion.

555
00:44:50.030 --> 00:44:50.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

556
00:44:51.869 --> 00:44:52.190
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

557
00:44:52.269 --> 00:44:55.630
<v Sameer Kanal>I do have a question for staff, so I can wait as they come up, but—.

558
00:44:55.710 --> 00:44:55.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

559
00:44:56.190 --> 00:44:57.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on up, folks.

560
00:45:03.639 --> 00:45:07.400
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll let you all introduce yourself for the record first, and thank you for your work on this.

561
00:45:07.880 --> 00:45:08.440
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks, Councilor.

562
00:45:08.599 --> 00:45:09.719
<v Angelita Morillo>My name is Meg McElroy.

563
00:45:09.880 --> 00:45:11.639
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm the interim director at the Children's Levy.

564
00:45:11.639 --> 00:45:12.599
<v Angelita Morillo>I use she/her pronouns.

565
00:45:13.639 --> 00:45:18.199
<v Loretta Smith>I use she/her pronouns, and I am a grant manager at the Portland Children's Levy.

566
00:45:19.159 --> 00:45:20.519
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm Katrina Peterson.

567
00:45:20.679 --> 00:45:24.199
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the policy and engagement coordinator at the Portland Children's Levy.

568
00:45:25.239 --> 00:45:25.320
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

569
00:45:25.719 --> 00:45:30.900
<v Sameer Kanal>My, my question, um, It's phrased simply, but I imagine the answer may be complex.

570
00:45:32.340 --> 00:45:53.139
<v Sameer Kanal>When we talked about this item last year, there was a great deal of testimony that related to the question of, is it relevant when a grantee aims to serve a particular target population, whether or not the organization itself is led by members of the community that it aims to serve uniquely?

571
00:45:54.230 --> 00:46:03.989
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, in other words, if the, if the, uh, board or the, um, leadership is, is members of the community or, or can include some members of that community.

572
00:46:04.630 --> 00:46:17.989
<v Sameer Kanal>This was a, a conversation that didn't really get resolved in the context of the philosophical, but one of the questions that I recognize that I don't believe this question was directed at anybody up here, uh, last year, but was if that's something that we even collect information on.

573
00:46:18.469 --> 00:46:35.940
<v Sameer Kanal>Do we know, not necessarily for every grant category, but for the categories that are aiming to serve a targeted population, whether or not— do we even have the data on whether the board or executives are of that community or identify as such?

574
00:46:36.500 --> 00:46:39.300
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that information that has started to be collected?

575
00:46:40.659 --> 00:46:43.940
<v Sameer Kanal>And if— and can you just walk us through any progress on that front?

576
00:46:44.579 --> 00:46:45.139
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure.

577
00:46:45.460 --> 00:46:50.809
<v Unidentified speaker>I think I can begin answering that question, and then I can kick it over to Meg to flesh it out a little bit.

578
00:46:51.929 --> 00:46:52.409
<v Unidentified speaker>We know that—.

579
00:46:53.449 --> 00:47:01.210
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So currently, and not including those that we're looking at today as being approved, but our current portfolio, we have 94 grants.

580
00:47:01.849 --> 00:47:08.809
<v Loretta Smith>And of those 94 grants, 71% are from organizations with a majority of BIPOC staff.

581
00:47:09.929 --> 00:47:17.650
<v Loretta Smith>PCL does collect demographic data on the boards of directors, the employees.

582
00:47:19.539 --> 00:47:22.340
<v Angelita Morillo>Of the staff, and those are reported to us.

583
00:47:22.500 --> 00:47:30.340
<v Angelita Morillo>We also collect demographic information on the clients of the organization, whether those are parents or children and youth.

584
00:47:32.500 --> 00:47:42.260
<v Loretta Smith>We do not use demographic data such as that in the decision-making of the funding process and cannot do so under the guise of the current executive order.

585
00:47:44.099 --> 00:47:46.000
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so Thank you for that.

586
00:47:46.320 --> 00:47:47.199
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, that's super helpful.

587
00:47:47.440 --> 00:47:57.519
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I guess sometimes an organization may be applying to serve, um, one— they're not all applying to serve the same populations, right?

588
00:47:58.159 --> 00:48:10.960
<v Sameer Kanal>So, and, and I'll also note that I think, um, and I'm speaking here as a person who identifies as BIPOC myself but not Black, and there are grant programs that Yes.

589
00:48:11.199 --> 00:48:16.159
<v Sameer Kanal>Or I should say there were applications which were seeking to serve the Black community specifically.

590
00:48:16.159 --> 00:48:24.000
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't think that my inclusion on a board necessarily creates representation for the Black community in this context.

591
00:48:25.840 --> 00:48:27.360
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to just be clear about that.

592
00:48:27.360 --> 00:48:30.480
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there are uniquenesses to different experiences.

593
00:48:31.360 --> 00:48:41.070
<v Sameer Kanal>So in terms of disaggregating that data, do you collect it in the context of what they are applying, the organization is applying for a specific program to serve?

594
00:48:41.550 --> 00:48:46.030
<v Sameer Kanal>In other words, if they're applying to serve BIPOC communities, it might be different than if they're applying to serve women and girls.

595
00:48:46.909 --> 00:48:46.989
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

596
00:48:48.670 --> 00:48:52.429
<v Loretta Smith>Also because of the executive order, I'm going to kick that over to Meg.

597
00:48:52.750 --> 00:48:52.829
<v Angelita Morillo>Sure.

598
00:48:53.789 --> 00:48:55.630
<v Angelita Morillo>Absolutely, we do collect that information.

599
00:48:55.869 --> 00:49:01.150
<v Angelita Morillo>And I want to sort of take a step back and try to explain how we ask questions of all applicants.

600
00:49:01.710 --> 00:49:07.760
<v Angelita Morillo>So when an organization is applying for a grant from the Children's Levy, they're applying to operate specific program services.

601
00:49:08.559 --> 00:49:15.039
<v Angelita Morillo>So we're trying to understand what is the service you're trying to provide, who are you trying to provide it to, and what's your experience and success doing so?

602
00:49:15.679 --> 00:49:19.280
<v Angelita Morillo>And so part of understanding that is understanding that information.

603
00:49:19.840 --> 00:49:28.880
<v Angelita Morillo>And organizations that can answer those questions well and make that case tend to score better from the perspective of reviewers in how they talk about their work.

604
00:49:29.360 --> 00:49:35.119
<v Angelita Morillo>So there's sort of— we're asking those questions across the board regardless of who the applicant is as an organization.

605
00:49:35.119 --> 00:49:40.400
<v Angelita Morillo>We want to understand the program's ability to have success with whoever they're trying to serve.

606
00:49:40.559 --> 00:49:43.199
<v Angelita Morillo>In addition to that, we are collecting demographics.

607
00:49:43.199 --> 00:49:44.239
<v Angelita Morillo>They are disaggregated.

608
00:49:44.239 --> 00:49:45.679
<v Angelita Morillo>We've been doing that since 2020.

609
00:49:45.920 --> 00:49:47.360
<v Angelita Morillo>We've reported it out annually.

610
00:49:47.440 --> 00:49:56.079
<v Angelita Morillo>All those reports are available on our website, and I would be happy to follow up with you with those disaggregated data for your information at any time.

611
00:49:56.239 --> 00:50:04.360
<v Unidentified speaker>If I may jump in from the recent small grants application that we Just concluded the funding round for.

612
00:50:05.400 --> 00:50:17.559
<v Unidentified speaker>As a part of that application and some of the questions that we asked, there are questions about describing the organization's mission, history, and populations, and how they involve the population they serve in their work.

613
00:50:18.039 --> 00:50:23.719
<v Unidentified speaker>And then in the scoring criteria that are used to evaluate the application, we—.

614
00:50:25.079 --> 00:50:27.809
<v Loretta Smith>Points are awarded based on How they—.

615
00:50:28.929 --> 00:50:30.289
<v Unidentified speaker>How the organization's founding and history.

616
00:50:32.690 --> 00:50:33.010
<v Dan Ryan>Let's see.

617
00:50:35.730 --> 00:50:42.449
<v Loretta Smith>Like, the applicant demonstrates at least 3 years of experience delivering programming with children, youth, and families in alignment with its mission.

618
00:50:44.449 --> 00:50:50.449
<v Unidentified speaker>They describe how the population to be served is involved in determining the mission and activities of the organization.

619
00:50:51.250 --> 00:50:53.969
<v Unidentified speaker>They explain how they gather client and community feedback.

620
00:50:53.969 --> 00:50:54.130
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

621
00:50:54.550 --> 00:50:57.429
<v Unidentified speaker>And how they use that feedback to inform or change their programming and policies.

622
00:50:58.869 --> 00:51:10.389
<v Unidentified speaker>They are also awarded points based on whether or not they're trauma-informed and have experience serving that population, if that's helpful information.

623
00:51:11.269 --> 00:51:12.550
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I, I think that's very helpful.

624
00:51:12.630 --> 00:51:17.989
<v Sameer Kanal>In particular, they describe how the population to be served is involved in determining the mission and activities of the organization.

625
00:51:18.789 --> 00:51:28.349
<v Sameer Kanal>I felt compelled to This is just based on the conversation from last year and to give the opportunity, 'cause I know something had been done, but I appreciate the detail on what that was, and I'm prepared to support this today.

626
00:51:28.429 --> 00:51:28.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

627
00:51:29.789 --> 00:51:29.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

628
00:51:31.309 --> 00:51:32.269
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

629
00:51:32.670 --> 00:51:35.949
<v Dan Ryan>Colleagues, I won't do the long thing that was prepared last week 'cause we were in a hurry.

630
00:51:36.510 --> 00:51:40.590
<v Dan Ryan>And really, I want to start off by saying it's an honor to be the chair of the Allocation Committee.

631
00:51:40.590 --> 00:51:45.400
<v Dan Ryan>It's the oversight of the Children's Levy, and it was really wonderful last week that we Thank you.

632
00:51:45.480 --> 00:51:46.840
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Dan Ryan, for allowing ourselves to stay late.

633
00:51:47.000 --> 00:51:56.039
<v Dan Ryan>I want to thank staff for that, and thank you, Councilor Smith, for advocacy for such civil— such civics and good manners.

634
00:51:57.000 --> 00:52:05.719
<v Dan Ryan>Just real quick, all the levy grants are a result of a well-constructed funding process developed over 3 years with extensive community involvement.

635
00:52:06.440 --> 00:52:08.760
<v Dan Ryan>This year's small grants process centered community voice.

636
00:52:09.159 --> 00:52:17.210
<v Dan Ryan>For example, the levels— the levies, community council advisory boards scored applicant videos and made funding recommendations to the allocation committee.

637
00:52:18.010 --> 00:52:27.929
<v Dan Ryan>Finally, the small grants and the 8% increase to the 94 grants will put resources into the community quickly and efficiently starting July 1st, hence the reason we have to vote on this today.

638
00:52:28.409 --> 00:52:33.449
<v Dan Ryan>All grants directly serve children across the city, and we all know the need is great and we wish there was more.

639
00:52:34.170 --> 00:52:34.650
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks again.

640
00:52:34.889 --> 00:52:36.090
<v Dan Ryan>I want to add just one more thing.

641
00:52:36.570 --> 00:52:46.969
<v Dan Ryan>We are going to have a conversation at the next meeting about always having an alternate with the small grants because sometimes one might go away and then we have someone in the queue that we were— that we thoroughly discussed.

642
00:52:47.369 --> 00:52:48.650
<v Dan Ryan>So we'll be doing that the next meeting.

643
00:52:48.969 --> 00:52:49.769
<v Dan Ryan>When is our next meeting?

644
00:52:50.250 --> 00:52:52.730
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, June 16th.

645
00:52:53.530 --> 00:52:53.610
<v Dan Ryan>Wonderful.

646
00:52:54.489 --> 00:52:55.369
<v Dan Ryan>All right, thanks so much.

647
00:52:55.690 --> 00:52:56.889
<v Dan Ryan>I hope you all can support this.

648
00:52:57.050 --> 00:52:57.929
<v Dan Ryan>We can move on with the meeting.

649
00:52:58.329 --> 00:52:58.409
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

650
00:52:58.730 --> 00:52:59.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

651
00:52:59.849 --> 00:53:00.570
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

652
00:53:01.210 --> 00:53:01.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, thanks.

653
00:53:01.769 --> 00:53:06.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's been a challenging couple of years in, in your realm, and I just want Give compliments.

654
00:53:07.710 --> 00:53:11.070
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have watched how you've brought this to us last year, this year.

655
00:53:12.030 --> 00:53:12.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>It makes sense to me.

656
00:53:12.909 --> 00:53:18.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>It also seems quite responsive to what you're hearing on the ground and the changing dynamic for kids and families.

657
00:53:18.510 --> 00:53:20.349
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I just have a lot of appreciation there.

658
00:53:20.510 --> 00:53:38.139
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to also, as our representative to that funding board, Councilor Ryan, I think that you are doing us a service in Commissioner Dan Saltzman's shadow in terms of of keeping this, keeping this council directly connected to this.

659
00:53:38.139 --> 00:53:43.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I have a lot of appreciation, right, from his building up and working with the staff to build the program into what it is.

660
00:53:43.500 --> 00:53:52.780
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, uh, not an easy year to do what Portland has decided we want to do, and you have threaded that needle, and I think he would be proud as well.

661
00:53:53.099 --> 00:53:53.579
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you.

662
00:53:54.300 --> 00:53:55.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

663
00:53:57.579 --> 00:54:00.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue, can we please call the roll?

664
00:54:00.510 --> 00:54:04.829
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Kanel?

665
00:54:06.510 --> 00:54:06.590
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

666
00:54:06.750 --> 00:54:07.469
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

667
00:54:07.789 --> 00:54:08.349
<v Unidentified speaker>No vote on this item.

668
00:54:09.389 --> 00:54:09.469
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

669
00:54:10.510 --> 00:54:10.590
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

670
00:54:10.989 --> 00:54:11.070
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

671
00:54:11.949 --> 00:54:12.429
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Mitchell Green?

672
00:54:12.829 --> 00:54:12.909
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

673
00:54:13.710 --> 00:54:14.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Dan Ryan?

674
00:54:14.429 --> 00:54:14.510
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

675
00:54:16.510 --> 00:54:18.510
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Samir Kanal?

676
00:54:18.829 --> 00:54:18.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

677
00:54:21.389 --> 00:54:25.309
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Eric Zimmerman?

678
00:54:25.630 --> 00:54:26.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

679
00:54:26.599 --> 00:54:26.920
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

680
00:54:27.239 --> 00:54:27.320
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

681
00:54:28.840 --> 00:54:28.920
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

682
00:54:30.599 --> 00:54:30.679
<v Loretta Smith>Absent.

683
00:54:32.760 --> 00:54:33.079
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

684
00:54:33.480 --> 00:54:33.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

685
00:54:34.760 --> 00:54:38.199
<v Unidentified speaker>And the ordinance passes with 11 aye, 1 absent.

686
00:54:38.679 --> 00:54:39.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much for being here.

687
00:54:39.960 --> 00:54:41.320
<v Dan Ryan>Now you can show your enthusiasm.

688
00:54:41.480 --> 00:54:41.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yay!

689
00:54:41.960 --> 00:54:42.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yay!

690
00:54:43.719 --> 00:54:44.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please call item 7?

691
00:54:49.800 --> 00:54:51.159
<v Unidentified speaker>It's the new item 6.

692
00:54:51.400 --> 00:54:52.679
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 6.

693
00:54:52.920 --> 00:54:53.159
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

694
00:54:53.159 --> 00:54:53.960
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 6.

695
00:54:54.469 --> 00:55:08.710
<v Unidentified speaker>Authorize borrowings of not more than $95 million in anticipation of the Fire and Police Disability and Retirement Fund levy for FY 2026-27, document number 2026-155.

696
00:55:09.429 --> 00:55:11.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

697
00:55:11.829 --> 00:55:13.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there any further discussion of this item?

698
00:55:18.150 --> 00:55:19.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else in the queue, can we please call the roll?

699
00:55:24.920 --> 00:55:25.800
<v Loretta Smith>Kanal?

700
00:55:26.039 --> 00:55:26.119
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

701
00:55:27.159 --> 00:55:28.159
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

702
00:55:28.679 --> 00:55:28.760
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

703
00:55:30.039 --> 00:55:30.599
<v Angelita Morillo>Ryan?

704
00:55:30.760 --> 00:55:30.840
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

705
00:55:31.719 --> 00:55:32.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

706
00:55:32.679 --> 00:55:32.760
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

707
00:55:33.559 --> 00:55:34.199
<v Unidentified speaker>Murillo?

708
00:55:34.360 --> 00:55:34.440
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

709
00:55:35.400 --> 00:55:35.800
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

710
00:55:36.039 --> 00:55:36.119
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

711
00:55:36.760 --> 00:55:37.639
<v Loretta Smith>Clark?

712
00:55:37.800 --> 00:55:37.880
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

713
00:55:38.840 --> 00:55:38.920
<v Dan Ryan>Green?

714
00:55:44.280 --> 00:55:44.360
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

715
00:55:44.920 --> 00:55:45.400
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

716
00:55:45.559 --> 00:55:45.960
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

717
00:55:46.019 --> 00:55:46.099
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

718
00:55:47.380 --> 00:55:47.699
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

719
00:55:48.179 --> 00:55:48.260
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

720
00:55:49.059 --> 00:55:49.139
<v Loretta Smith>Smith?

721
00:55:49.619 --> 00:55:49.699
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

722
00:55:50.500 --> 00:55:50.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

723
00:55:51.219 --> 00:55:51.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

724
00:55:52.340 --> 00:55:54.820
<v Unidentified speaker>The ordinance passes with 12 aye votes.

725
00:55:55.460 --> 00:55:56.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

726
00:55:56.340 --> 00:56:00.179
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we now please call new item number 6 or 7?

727
00:56:00.420 --> 00:56:00.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't—.

728
00:56:00.820 --> 00:56:01.780
<v Dan Ryan>I'm confused on my own.

729
00:56:01.780 --> 00:56:02.179
<v Unidentified speaker>You got it.

730
00:56:02.579 --> 00:56:18.489
<v Unidentified speaker>New item number 7, authorize conveyance of city-owned real property to Habitat for Humanity Portland Metro East for the construction of Thank you.

731
00:56:18.489 --> 00:56:20.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the first reading of an emergency ordinance.

732
00:56:20.809 --> 00:56:25.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>With us from Council Ops is Claire Adamsick with a committee staff summary.

733
00:56:25.769 --> 00:56:26.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Take it away, Claire.

734
00:56:27.130 --> 00:56:28.730
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President and councilors.

735
00:56:28.809 --> 00:56:33.690
<v Angelita Morillo>For the record, Claire Adamsick, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Housing and Permitting Committee.

736
00:56:33.849 --> 00:56:44.079
<v Angelita Morillo>The emergency ordinance before you, document number 2026-151, was heard in the Housing and Permitting Committee on May 5th, where it was referred to full council with the recommendation to pass.

737
00:56:44.159 --> 00:56:54.400
<v Angelita Morillo>It authorizes the transfer of city-owned property near 6631 North Syracuse Street to Habitat for Humanity Portland Region for the construction of the True North project.

738
00:56:54.480 --> 00:57:08.440
<v Angelita Morillo>The project will include 50 family-sized units of 2 bedrooms or more, with 25 units available to households earning up to 60% median family income and 25 per 25 units available to households earning up to 80% MFI at initial sale.

739
00:57:09.880 --> 00:57:19.800
<v Angelita Morillo>The Portland Housing Bureau will require the project to record an affordable housing covenant on each home, ensuring affordability in perpetuity to households earning up to 80% MFI.

740
00:57:20.760 --> 00:57:37.380
<v Angelita Morillo>The emergency ordinance also authorizes the city administrator, in accordance with Portland City Code, to execute a disposition and development agreement and any other documents The ordinance includes an emergency clause in order to meet required project financing timelines.

741
00:57:38.099 --> 00:57:44.739
<v Angelita Morillo>The full impact statement on this item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts and analysis and community impacts and community involvement.

742
00:57:45.619 --> 00:57:49.940
<v Angelita Morillo>No written or verbal testimony was provided on this item prior to committee action on May 5th.

743
00:57:50.260 --> 00:57:51.539
<v Angelita Morillo>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

744
00:57:51.860 --> 00:57:52.099
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

745
00:57:52.340 --> 00:57:53.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Claire.

746
00:57:54.500 --> 00:57:56.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, this came out of your committee.

747
00:57:56.500 --> 00:57:57.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Did you have any comments?

748
00:57:57.440 --> 00:57:57.760
<v Candace Avalos>My committee.

749
00:57:57.920 --> 00:57:59.519
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, well, kind of your— I'm driving the wrong thing.

750
00:57:59.519 --> 00:57:59.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>I apologize.

751
00:58:00.159 --> 00:58:01.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos, please.

752
00:58:01.679 --> 00:58:01.920
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

753
00:58:03.039 --> 00:58:13.039
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I appreciated the opportunity to discuss this project at the Housing and Permitting Committee and hear more about the long-term vision for creating permanently affordable homeownership opportunities in our city.

754
00:58:14.000 --> 00:58:16.880
<v Candace Avalos>This is a partnership with Habitat for Humanity Portland Region.

755
00:58:17.840 --> 00:58:26.079
<v Candace Avalos>And right now with Portland being in a housing crisis, we need more pathways, not just into housing, but into stable, affordable homeownership for working families.

756
00:58:26.489 --> 00:58:33.690
<v Candace Avalos>What stands out about the project is that all 50 units will be family-sized homes, which is something that we desperately need more of in Portland.

757
00:58:33.769 --> 00:58:44.570
<v Candace Avalos>I also appreciate that these homes will be permanently affordable and prioritized through the North and Northeast Preference Policy to help address the historic displacement that Black families and communities experience in North and Northeast Portland.

758
00:58:44.730 --> 00:58:53.289
<v Candace Avalos>This project reflects intentional community engagement with outreach directly to households impacted by displacement and prospective homeowners helping to shape the project design and priorities.

759
00:58:53.489 --> 00:58:56.449
<v Candace Avalos>And lastly, I want to acknowledge the sustainability component of this project.

760
00:58:57.170 --> 00:59:04.690
<v Candace Avalos>Building net-zero-ready homes that align with the city's renewable energy goals shows that we can advance both housing justice and climate justice together.

761
00:59:04.849 --> 00:59:12.610
<v Candace Avalos>This is exactly the type of housing investment we should continue making— affordable family size, community informed, and focused on long-term stability for Portland families.

762
00:59:13.010 --> 00:59:14.769
<v Candace Avalos>And it passed out of committee.

763
00:59:14.849 --> 00:59:15.409
<v Candace Avalos>That's all.

764
00:59:15.570 --> 00:59:16.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

765
00:59:17.010 --> 00:59:19.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, are there any technical or clarifying questions on this item?

766
00:59:20.179 --> 00:59:21.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

767
00:59:21.300 --> 00:59:21.619
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

768
00:59:21.619 --> 00:59:28.860
<v Sameer Kanal>I just was hoping, uh, someone could maybe— I'm not sure if it's Claire, if the co-sponsors could speak to the reason for it being an emergency ordinance.

769
00:59:29.699 --> 00:59:34.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have staff in the room from the Housing Bureau as well who are coming up.

770
00:59:34.820 --> 00:59:36.179
<v Eric Zimmerman>And why it was pulled.

771
00:59:36.500 --> 00:59:37.940
<v Sameer Kanal>And yeah, why it was pulled.

772
00:59:37.940 --> 00:59:39.539
<v Sameer Kanal>That's a good— thank you for that.

773
00:59:39.619 --> 00:59:41.619
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, a little confused there.

774
00:59:45.940 --> 00:59:46.900
<v Loretta Smith>Welcome.

775
00:59:49.150 --> 00:59:49.630
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

776
00:59:49.869 --> 00:59:50.590
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, Council.

777
00:59:50.590 --> 00:59:51.869
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for having us here today.

778
00:59:51.869 --> 00:59:53.070
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Kara Hamilton.

779
00:59:53.070 --> 00:59:57.869
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm staff at the Portland Housing Bureau, and I work with Habitat Humanity on this project.

780
00:59:58.030 --> 01:00:12.429
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, part of the reason that this item was asked to be on the emergency ordinance is that we are planning to close financially on May 28th with our funding partners, OHCS, OnPoint Community Credit Union, and of course Habitat themselves.

781
01:00:13.800 --> 01:00:27.159
<v Unidentified speaker>And Habitat is positioned to start site development immediately after financial closing and is hoping to take advantage of the warm weather to avoid incurring significant costs if they start later in the season.

782
01:00:29.480 --> 01:00:35.639
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, PHB is currently managing a security contract with Northwest Enforcement that ends on June 30th.

783
01:00:36.440 --> 01:00:42.489
<v Unidentified speaker>If closing is pushed past the current target, PHB will likely need to solicit bids for a new contract.

784
01:00:43.210 --> 01:00:51.769
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, PHB has not budgeted for a security contract past June 30th, the end of the fiscal year, as closing has been planned for this date for some time.

785
01:00:52.650 --> 01:00:54.170
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm happy to answer any other questions.

786
01:00:59.369 --> 01:01:01.769
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, just why was it pulled off the consent agenda?

787
01:01:03.369 --> 01:01:05.210
<v Sameer Kanal>We were heard— we heard it was staff who pulled it.

788
01:01:05.610 --> 01:01:06.969
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, it was not PHB staff.

789
01:01:07.690 --> 01:01:08.690
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

790
01:01:10.409 --> 01:01:11.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

791
01:01:11.769 --> 01:01:13.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>Was it pulled by staff or by public?

792
01:01:14.409 --> 01:01:14.650
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do you know?

793
01:01:17.130 --> 01:01:19.730
<v Unidentified speaker>It was pulled by— thanks.

794
01:01:20.889 --> 01:01:21.530
<v Sameer Kanal>Hello there.

795
01:01:21.929 --> 01:01:24.250
<v Sameer Kanal>For the record, Eben Hoffer, staff to Councilor Dunphy.

796
01:01:26.489 --> 01:01:33.449
<v Sameer Kanal>DCA administrative staff had placed this on their run spreadsheet as a regular agenda item.

797
01:01:33.980 --> 01:01:35.420
<v Sameer Kanal>Somehow we got our wires crossed.

798
01:01:36.619 --> 01:01:39.820
<v Mitch Green>They asked me if we could pull it back to the regular agenda.

799
01:01:41.739 --> 01:01:45.980
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, and this is DCA for Community and Economic Development?

800
01:01:47.260 --> 01:01:47.739
<v Sameer Kanal>That office?

801
01:01:47.980 --> 01:01:48.699
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that's okay.

802
01:01:50.460 --> 01:01:53.179
<v Sameer Kanal>Great, appreciate the— I think this one's on me mostly.

803
01:01:53.900 --> 01:01:54.780
<v Sameer Kanal>Appreciate the clarity there.

804
01:01:56.860 --> 01:02:00.929
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think, Yeah, I'll let others ask their questions.

805
01:02:01.250 --> 01:02:01.329
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

806
01:02:01.570 --> 01:02:02.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

807
01:02:02.610 --> 01:02:03.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith?

808
01:02:03.650 --> 01:02:05.010
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, are we going to get a presentation?

809
01:02:06.530 --> 01:02:07.650
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just the staff summary report.

810
01:02:08.289 --> 01:02:10.769
<v Loretta Smith>So there's a presentation on the, on the exhibit.

811
01:02:11.250 --> 01:02:13.730
<v Loretta Smith>I, I don't sit on the committee, so I don't know anything about this.

812
01:02:15.090 --> 01:02:21.809
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, yes, there was a full presentation on May 5th, but we are happy to share the presentation if that would be helpful.

813
01:02:22.210 --> 01:02:24.449
<v Loretta Smith>Where is the land located?

814
01:02:24.690 --> 01:02:27.489
<v Unidentified speaker>It's in the University Park neighborhood of North Portland.

815
01:02:27.420 --> 01:02:29.099
<v Loretta Smith>University Park?

816
01:02:31.340 --> 01:02:31.420
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

817
01:02:32.860 --> 01:02:34.139
<v Loretta Smith>And so we're—.

818
01:02:34.699 --> 01:02:35.900
<v Dan Ryan>Peninsula Crossing Trail.

819
01:02:37.659 --> 01:02:39.019
<v Sameer Kanal>It was the Safe Restrooms there.

820
01:02:39.739 --> 01:02:40.219
<v Loretta Smith>It was the what?

821
01:02:40.380 --> 01:02:41.739
<v Sameer Kanal>It was Peninsula Crossing Safe Restrooms.

822
01:02:41.900 --> 01:02:44.380
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, where the cut is, the bike trail there.

823
01:02:44.539 --> 01:02:46.940
<v Loretta Smith>So are we putting out, um, bonds on this?

824
01:02:47.099 --> 01:02:50.860
<v Loretta Smith>How, how is— are we actually giving money to this or just land?

825
01:02:52.460 --> 01:02:56.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the item before you today is just to approve the disposition of the land.

826
01:02:56.909 --> 01:03:10.909
<v Unidentified speaker>The financing, uh, is approved by the city administrator, which we did, um, allocate Metro Housing Bond funds and Ecuria Interstate Urban Corridor— uh, Interstate Corridor Urban Renewal Area TIF funds as well.

827
01:03:12.429 --> 01:03:14.750
<v Loretta Smith>So it was in— to the tune of $2 million?

828
01:03:15.869 --> 01:03:18.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the Ecuria TIF funds were $2 million.

829
01:03:18.670 --> 01:03:25.019
<v Loretta Smith>The Metro Bond funds were roughly So how much in all are we as the City of Portland putting forward on this?

830
01:03:25.420 --> 01:03:26.460
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, roughly $8 million.

831
01:03:27.019 --> 01:03:28.460
<v Loretta Smith>$8 Million plus the land?

832
01:03:29.260 --> 01:03:30.059
<v Unidentified speaker>Correct.

833
01:03:30.219 --> 01:03:32.860
<v Loretta Smith>And when was the hearing through the Housing Committee?

834
01:03:33.659 --> 01:03:34.219
<v Angelita Morillo>Uh, May 5th.

835
01:03:34.780 --> 01:03:36.539
<v Loretta Smith>May 5th?

836
01:03:37.019 --> 01:03:40.739
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so that was about a week ago or so.

837
01:03:41.340 --> 01:03:41.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

838
01:03:42.139 --> 01:03:45.340
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, um, thank you for this.

839
01:03:45.420 --> 01:03:47.179
<v Loretta Smith>And how many people is it going to serve?

840
01:03:49.050 --> 01:03:50.489
<v Unidentified speaker>So there are 50 units.

841
01:03:51.130 --> 01:03:54.650
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, they range from 2 to 4 bedrooms.

842
01:03:55.690 --> 01:04:00.650
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, Sarah, do you know how many, uh, households it's planned to serve?

843
01:04:08.250 --> 01:04:09.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, Council.

844
01:04:09.289 --> 01:04:10.409
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Sarah Radcliffe.

845
01:04:10.730 --> 01:04:12.010
<v Unidentified speaker>I work with Habitat for Humanity.

846
01:04:12.969 --> 01:04:24.920
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we anticipate that with 50 family-sized homes of 2, 3, and 4 bedrooms that approximately 191 people will call this development home.

847
01:04:25.880 --> 01:04:25.960
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

848
01:04:26.840 --> 01:04:29.079
<v Loretta Smith>And did, did we do a SuperNOFA or something?

849
01:04:29.320 --> 01:04:30.440
<v Loretta Smith>How did this come about?

850
01:04:30.679 --> 01:04:34.280
<v Loretta Smith>How did they— did they contact us and ask us if we could help?

851
01:04:35.000 --> 01:04:38.679
<v Loretta Smith>How did this whole relationship come up, come together?

852
01:04:39.400 --> 01:04:39.480
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

853
01:04:39.800 --> 01:04:43.639
<v Unidentified speaker>So PHB held a solicitation in 2022.

854
01:04:45.000 --> 01:04:54.690
<v Unidentified speaker>There were multiple sites and development financing available through the solicitation, and Habitat's proposal was selected as part of this NOFA.

855
01:04:55.210 --> 01:04:57.289
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, and so we're just now getting to this?

856
01:04:57.369 --> 01:04:59.210
<v Loretta Smith>It took us 4 years to do this?

857
01:04:59.449 --> 01:05:12.010
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, part of that is because there was a Safe Rest Village and the Belmont Goats located on the site, and their lease— not a lease, use agreement ended in June 2025.

858
01:05:12.980 --> 01:05:15.059
<v Unidentified speaker>We expected to close shortly after that.

859
01:05:15.059 --> 01:05:22.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, closing has been delayed due to negotiations of contracts, um, and permitting.

860
01:05:23.059 --> 01:05:26.460
<v Loretta Smith>And so the previous council approved this?

861
01:05:26.659 --> 01:05:29.500
<v Loretta Smith>It didn't go through us, is that what you're saying?

862
01:05:29.699 --> 01:05:32.420
<v Unidentified speaker>It hasn't gone through council before.

863
01:05:32.659 --> 01:05:36.099
<v Unidentified speaker>Financing is approved through the city administrator.

864
01:05:36.179 --> 01:05:38.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the land is approved by city council.

865
01:05:39.420 --> 01:05:40.059
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay.

866
01:05:40.059 --> 01:05:44.059
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just trying to figure out how this process went and if there was a process.

867
01:05:44.300 --> 01:05:44.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

868
01:05:45.099 --> 01:05:46.619
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you so much.

869
01:05:47.900 --> 01:05:49.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

870
01:05:49.260 --> 01:05:49.820
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

871
01:05:49.900 --> 01:05:51.099
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

872
01:05:51.099 --> 01:05:58.699
<v Dan Ryan>I just wanted to provide a little bit more context than you provided, but I appreciate what you said and I enjoyed the questions from Councilor Smith.

873
01:05:58.860 --> 01:06:09.550
<v Dan Ryan>This was an example where bureaus worked together and we had Parks, PBOT, PHB, and then the office that was trying to build Safe Rest Villages.

874
01:06:09.710 --> 01:06:17.630
<v Dan Ryan>And so we actually saved some time and efficiency because when we built the villages, we did a lot of infrastructure work to set this up.

875
01:06:17.869 --> 01:06:21.630
<v Dan Ryan>So when they left, you could quickly get in there and do your thing.

876
01:06:21.710 --> 01:06:31.630
<v Dan Ryan>We also— for those that are from that part of town, it used to be there were unsanctioned camps that went all the way from Willamette down to Columbia Boulevard along the Peninsula Crossing Trail.

877
01:06:31.989 --> 01:06:42.309
<v Dan Ryan>And for over a decade, I hear 12 to 13 years, the residents of University Park had no access for the most part to that family-friendly amenity that we built.

878
01:06:42.469 --> 01:06:50.469
<v Dan Ryan>So when we put in the SafeRest Village, we made the whole neighborhood safer by clearing out the pathway, and then that started being used again by the neighbors.

879
01:06:51.030 --> 01:06:56.550
<v Dan Ryan>And then the infrastructure work was done with PBOT, so after that was closed down, we could immediately start the building.

880
01:06:56.630 --> 01:06:57.909
<v Dan Ryan>And I think we're all excited about the opportunity.

881
01:06:57.909 --> 01:06:58.150
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

882
01:06:58.519 --> 01:07:07.719
<v Dan Ryan>Opportunities for homeownership, the pathway to financial stability, and to the North and Northeast preference policy that was always a part of this journey as well.

883
01:07:07.800 --> 01:07:10.440
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you, Housing Bureau, for seeing this through.

884
01:07:11.880 --> 01:07:12.679
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

885
01:07:13.880 --> 01:07:15.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please move to public testimony?

886
01:07:17.800 --> 01:07:20.679
<v Unidentified speaker>We have one person signed up, Lacey Sutton.

887
01:07:22.679 --> 01:07:23.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you guys for the presentation.

888
01:07:24.039 --> 01:07:35.369
<v Unidentified speaker>You can Hi, Lacey Sutton.

889
01:07:37.769 --> 01:07:46.570
<v Unidentified speaker>In 2020, in the middle of a pandemic, our 7-year-old daughter was diagnosed with a rare kidney disease that made her severely immune compromised.

890
01:07:47.130 --> 01:07:56.500
<v Unidentified speaker>It was the beginning of the hardest time of our lives, but Through it all, we held fast to our dream of owning a home, of giving our children safety and stability.

891
01:07:56.739 --> 01:08:02.179
<v Unidentified speaker>We were overjoyed to purchase a Habitat home, and that joy was robbed from us.

892
01:08:02.340 --> 01:08:13.059
<v Unidentified speaker>I've spent the past 2 and a half years fighting for basic code-required safety, for answers, time I should have been spending with my family enjoying the house we worked so hard for.

893
01:08:13.539 --> 01:08:15.460
<v Unidentified speaker>But I had kids sleeping on the third story.

894
01:08:16.029 --> 01:08:16.109
<v Angelita Morillo>Of—.

895
01:08:16.430 --> 01:08:23.949
<v Unidentified speaker>On a dark, unmarked, dead-end road filled with cars, a road Habitat and the city used to insist was not a fire lane.

896
01:08:24.430 --> 01:08:37.949
<v Unidentified speaker>It took 2 and a half years of my life, hundreds of emails, complaints, testimony, investigations by the fire department, the ombudsman, the media, just to get a tacit admission that yes, we do in fact need fire access.

897
01:08:38.670 --> 01:08:41.069
<v Unidentified speaker>They painted some curbs and put in some signs.

898
01:08:41.069 --> 01:08:41.310
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

899
01:08:41.599 --> 01:08:44.158
<v Unidentified speaker>But it's still not up to code and they still won't explain it.

900
01:08:45.838 --> 01:08:51.679
<v Unidentified speaker>Over these years, I have been surprised to learn that while things are particularly bad at Cherry Blossom, we are not alone.

901
01:08:53.279 --> 01:08:58.958
<v Unidentified speaker>Everywhere I go talking about this, people come up to me— homeowners, tradespeople, church leaders—.

902
01:08:59.359 --> 01:09:01.439
<v Angelita Morillo>And tell me they're familiar with Habitat's work.

903
01:09:02.078 --> 01:09:09.988
<v Unidentified speaker>Leaking roofs, black mold, bad wiring, wall heaters that are at best incredibly Expensive to run and at worst burst into flame.

904
01:09:10.788 --> 01:09:14.628
<v Unidentified speaker>One water meter, so struggling families can't get a discount from the water bureau.

905
01:09:14.788 --> 01:09:15.748
<v Unidentified speaker>That's going to get a lot harder.

906
01:09:16.948 --> 01:09:19.828
<v Unidentified speaker>Homeowners in foreclosure for unpaid HOA dues.

907
01:09:20.708 --> 01:09:24.469
<v Unidentified speaker>This low-income housing model is an experiment and it is failing.

908
01:09:25.509 --> 01:09:34.328
<v Unidentified speaker>And we don't— we can't move because permanent affordability with capped equity and silent second mortgages and DPAL, you have to pay back is not how you build wealth.

909
01:09:34.569 --> 01:09:35.048
<v Angelita Morillo>We're stuck.

910
01:09:36.088 --> 01:09:37.769
<v Angelita Morillo>So why don't you hear about this?

911
01:09:38.488 --> 01:09:44.649
<v Unidentified speaker>Maybe for the same reason the ombudsman rewrote their findings after a chat with Steve Massanetti.

912
01:09:45.208 --> 01:09:57.368
<v Unidentified speaker>Or how about that time back in 2019 when the fire plant examiner identified significant violations in the plans and was ordered to just approve it the day before Habitat's deadline?

913
01:09:57.929 --> 01:09:58.889
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a term for that.

914
01:09:59.539 --> 01:10:00.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Dereliction of duty.

915
01:10:01.779 --> 01:10:03.539
<v Unidentified speaker>But without enforcement, those are just words.

916
01:10:04.500 --> 01:10:23.140
<v Angelita Morillo>Habitat for Humanity is a powerful organization with money and lawyers and friends in high places, and we have sick kids and several jobs and bills and homes that are falling apart and fears of retaliation and indifference that are totally founded.

917
01:10:24.420 --> 01:10:27.710
<v Unidentified speaker>Several of you have asked me what you could do for us.

918
01:10:28.430 --> 01:10:29.229
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, here you go.

919
01:10:30.109 --> 01:10:31.710
<v Unidentified speaker>Habitat wants something from you.

920
01:10:32.350 --> 01:10:42.909
<v Unidentified speaker>Seems to me like this would be the perfect time to ask them some hard questions, make some demands, condition your approval on answers, repairs, accountability.

921
01:10:43.949 --> 01:10:46.189
<v Unidentified speaker>It's the only way we're going to get any.

922
01:10:47.229 --> 01:10:47.470
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

923
01:10:48.350 --> 01:10:49.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

924
01:10:50.739 --> 01:10:51.460
<v Unidentified speaker>That completes testimony.

925
01:10:52.420 --> 01:10:54.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, is there further discussion of this item?

926
01:10:57.539 --> 01:10:59.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

927
01:10:59.619 --> 01:11:00.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

928
01:11:00.340 --> 01:11:16.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so first off, I want to acknowledge what, what we're talking about here, um, in the testimony and say that we have a necessity to ensure that things that are built are up to code.

929
01:11:17.100 --> 01:11:18.939
<v Sameer Kanal>I've been looking into this off and on.

930
01:11:18.939 --> 01:11:25.500
<v Sameer Kanal>I know it's not in our district, but I do think that there's— it's a worthwhile conversation for us to have about that location.

931
01:11:25.819 --> 01:11:31.020
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's up to this council whether or not that affects the question about this particular ordinance.

932
01:11:31.340 --> 01:11:32.699
<v Sameer Kanal>I just want to acknowledge that first.

933
01:11:34.460 --> 01:11:40.699
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate Councilor Avalos, Chair Avalos, bringing up the context of the size of the units.

934
01:11:42.060 --> 01:11:42.220
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

935
01:11:42.220 --> 01:11:45.100
<v Sameer Kanal>This ordinance relates to a property that is in our district.

936
01:11:46.220 --> 01:12:01.979
<v Sameer Kanal>One of the challenges that we're facing, and my colleague Councilor Ryan talks a lot about declining enrollment in PPS schools, and part of the reason for that is we don't have affordable units in which people can have a family, have children in.

937
01:12:02.300 --> 01:12:08.380
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I am grateful that that is a part of the plan and that is the focus of this particular plan.

938
01:12:08.380 --> 01:12:13.279
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm also grateful that there is Inclusion in the North Northeast Preference Policy.

939
01:12:13.520 --> 01:12:18.159
<v Sameer Kanal>I could repeat pretty much everything that you said, Chair Avalos, and I won't, but I did wanna just shout that out.

940
01:12:18.800 --> 01:12:28.239
<v Sameer Kanal>I also wanted to note that I believe all 3 of us from D2 toured that facility together back when it was a Safe Rest Village.

941
01:12:28.720 --> 01:12:31.600
<v Sameer Kanal>And this has been on the radar for a while.

942
01:12:32.000 --> 01:12:44.029
<v Sameer Kanal>This particular plan has been effectively in the works with relation to transferring the property because it was originally purchased, if I recall correctly, for affordable housing development when it was transferred.

943
01:12:44.670 --> 01:12:51.949
<v Sameer Kanal>So that to me is a core part of what we're doing here is we're effectively finishing something that was already put into effect.

944
01:12:53.789 --> 01:12:55.390
<v Sameer Kanal>But I just wanted to get that all on the record.

945
01:12:57.149 --> 01:13:02.270
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not sure how others would like to approach this in light of other things, but I wanted to at least get that on the record.

946
01:13:02.510 --> 01:13:02.590
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

947
01:13:02.909 --> 01:13:03.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

948
01:13:04.189 --> 01:13:04.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

949
01:13:06.029 --> 01:13:19.170
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just wanted to say briefly, one of the, One of the issues that we discussed in the committee was that this is an example, a prototype example of the impact of land banking.

950
01:13:19.890 --> 01:13:31.489
<v Mitch Green>You know, this was a sort of not part of a systematic strategy per se, but it was a one-off opportunity that the Portland Housing Bureau saw to secure land at a price that it knew would become more dear over time.

951
01:13:32.289 --> 01:13:36.399
<v Mitch Green>And the result of that was that we were able to build a number of units that are family-sized Yes.

952
01:13:36.399 --> 01:13:41.439
<v Mitch Green>— At a cost that pencils out for these families.

953
01:13:41.840 --> 01:14:02.640
<v Mitch Green>And so I made the point that I said, you know, to the extent that the social housing study is looking at land banking as part of a broader framework, to the extent that Unified Housing Strategy is looking at land banking as part of a broader framework, we don't need to wait to start looking at those opportunities to pilot something in the future when we already have a pilot here.

954
01:14:02.800 --> 01:14:12.670
<v Mitch Green>And so I just wanted to make sure we use the lessons of this as evidence when we, when we write that report, um, and just recognize that, um, that it can have good impacts.

955
01:14:13.229 --> 01:14:20.430
<v Mitch Green>Um, obviously, you know, there's, there's accountability and, you know, code enforcement issues notwithstanding.

956
01:14:23.470 --> 01:14:24.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

957
01:14:24.670 --> 01:14:25.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

958
01:14:26.029 --> 01:14:26.909
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

959
01:14:27.949 --> 01:14:33.550
<v Loretta Smith>Is this the $8 million that's being used to, um, fund this project?

960
01:14:33.789 --> 01:14:42.970
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is this coming out of the '25-'26 Anybody from Housing Bureau available to answer that?

961
01:14:44.250 --> 01:14:52.649
<v Loretta Smith>And also, I wanted to know, was this project budgeted in this last budget, if it was put in the budget?

962
01:14:56.090 --> 01:14:57.289
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, thank you, Councilor Smith.

963
01:14:57.529 --> 01:15:02.250
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, it's expected in the FY 2026-2027 budget.

964
01:15:02.649 --> 01:15:07.449
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we expect the first allocation of funds to be in June or, uh, in July of 2026.

965
01:15:07.510 --> 01:15:14.869
<v Unidentified speaker>'26 This year, and it was included in the 5-year forecast, so it should have been in all of the budgets you've seen.

966
01:15:15.670 --> 01:15:15.750
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

967
01:15:16.390 --> 01:15:18.710
<v Loretta Smith>No, I was just trying to figure out if it was in the budget.

968
01:15:19.189 --> 01:15:25.189
<v Loretta Smith>What I'm concerned about is that we're approving monies to do monies before our actual budget is done.

969
01:15:25.829 --> 01:15:34.550
<v Loretta Smith>If it was for '25-'26, I could understand this, but we have not— we're not in the '26-'27 budget year, so why are we approving this now?

970
01:15:37.829 --> 01:15:39.189
<v Loretta Smith>What if that budget doesn't go?

971
01:15:39.510 --> 01:15:40.630
<v Loretta Smith>I see the DCA here.

972
01:15:44.949 --> 01:15:45.350
<v Mitch Green>Thanks, Tim.

973
01:15:45.350 --> 01:15:45.670
<v Mitch Green>Great job.

974
01:15:46.949 --> 01:15:50.149
<v Mitch Green>Donny Oliveira, for the record, Deputy City Administrator of Community and Economic Development.

975
01:15:50.949 --> 01:15:51.909
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, thank you for the question.

976
01:15:52.310 --> 01:15:59.430
<v Mitch Green>So anytime we're talking about something as complex as a housing development deal, it takes place over several years.

977
01:16:00.229 --> 01:16:08.369
<v Mitch Green>So when the team goes to do their underwriting with a project, any given project, we have to look at it over time.

978
01:16:09.250 --> 01:16:20.369
<v Mitch Green>At the same time, our development partners, in this case Habitat for Humanity, needs to have some level of certainty that the resources, in this case bond dollars, are going to be available to complete the project.

979
01:16:21.090 --> 01:16:28.930
<v Mitch Green>So the reality is for any housing production is there is going to happen over several— 10 years.

980
01:16:29.890 --> 01:16:30.529
<v Loretta Smith>Budget cycles.

981
01:16:31.569 --> 01:16:39.649
<v Loretta Smith>So, well, it depends on what we do with the '26-'27 budget, and I have a problem with approving stuff before its time.

982
01:16:39.970 --> 01:16:49.329
<v Loretta Smith>If it was about '25-'26— and again, here we go, we're going out of order again because this is not an emergency that has to be approved today.

983
01:16:49.810 --> 01:16:51.250
<v Loretta Smith>They know we're good for the money.

984
01:16:51.329 --> 01:17:05.420
<v Loretta Smith>They understand that we do have a budget, but to have this approved now It does not, it does not math for me because what if we decide to, to choose some other routes to fill that $171 million gap?

985
01:17:06.779 --> 01:17:07.659
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, that's a fair question.

986
01:17:08.140 --> 01:17:10.380
<v Mitch Green>You— 2 things are why this is pressing.

987
01:17:11.100 --> 01:17:22.529
<v Mitch Green>Uh, staff did relay the, the sequence of events that have to happen before the end of the fiscal year, including a burden that we put on the Housing Bureau for, in this case, security costs in the next fiscal year if we didn't land this deal.

988
01:17:22.930 --> 01:17:29.890
<v Mitch Green>The second thing, there are other funders, um, that we're partnering with that are, are ready for our final piece to complete the capital stack.

989
01:17:30.369 --> 01:17:32.529
<v Mitch Green>So we're putting several partners, you know, at risk here.

990
01:17:35.170 --> 01:17:37.010
<v Loretta Smith>What, what partners are you putting at risk?

991
01:17:37.090 --> 01:17:39.489
<v Loretta Smith>I, I, I don't see what partners you're going to put at risk.

992
01:17:39.489 --> 01:17:46.289
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, it's Oregon Housing and Community Services, so the state funding organization, and OnPoint Community Credit Union.

993
01:17:46.449 --> 01:17:53.770
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, also just adding that the funds are Metro Housing bond dollars and, um, TIF dollars, so they have to be used for specific purposes.

994
01:17:55.050 --> 01:17:56.010
<v Loretta Smith>So that's what I'm saying.

995
01:17:56.729 --> 01:17:59.050
<v Loretta Smith>We must be using '25-'26.

996
01:17:59.210 --> 01:18:04.890
<v Loretta Smith>How can we commit in this ordinance '26-'27 if we don't have it?

997
01:18:05.050 --> 01:18:06.649
<v Loretta Smith>Because we don't even know what we're going to get.

998
01:18:07.210 --> 01:18:10.250
<v Loretta Smith>This must be old money because we don't have any more of that money anymore.

999
01:18:10.729 --> 01:18:11.930
<v Loretta Smith>It goes through the county.

1000
01:18:13.130 --> 01:18:21.369
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, um, when bond dollars are released, in this case Metro bond dollars, those are revenues that are are predictable in the sense that we know what they are.

1001
01:18:21.770 --> 01:18:23.289
<v Mitch Green>And so they're programmed out over time.

1002
01:18:23.770 --> 01:18:23.850
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1003
01:18:23.850 --> 01:18:26.170
<v Mitch Green>So it's not like they're a new revenue that we collect every year.

1004
01:18:26.569 --> 01:18:28.810
<v Mitch Green>They're essentially sitting in our coffers to be spent.

1005
01:18:29.130 --> 01:18:37.850
<v Mitch Green>In the case of both of the bonds, both housing dollars and, or Portland Housing Dollars and Metro Dollars, these are the ends of the resources that have been committed over many years ago.

1006
01:18:38.170 --> 01:18:39.770
<v Mitch Green>These are the final products of those investments.

1007
01:18:40.329 --> 01:18:44.529
<v Mitch Green>So these are basically the final dispersals of those resources.

1008
01:18:44.819 --> 01:18:48.739
<v Loretta Smith>So again, are we dispersing 26-27 or 25-26?

1009
01:18:49.220 --> 01:18:52.579
<v Loretta Smith>Because I don't, I don't see the emergency right now, um, City Administrator.

1010
01:18:55.779 --> 01:18:56.899
<v Loretta Smith>I, I, I, I just don't.

1011
01:18:56.899 --> 01:18:57.460
<v Loretta Smith>I don't understand.

1012
01:18:58.100 --> 01:18:59.220
<v Loretta Smith>It doesn't math for me.

1013
01:19:00.340 --> 01:19:03.659
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, I thought staff did an adequate job of explaining the emergency.

1014
01:19:12.510 --> 01:19:12.989
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know.

1015
01:19:12.989 --> 01:19:14.029
<v Loretta Smith>I don't, I don't get it.

1016
01:19:14.029 --> 01:19:14.829
<v Loretta Smith>I don't understand it.

1017
01:19:14.829 --> 01:19:16.350
<v Loretta Smith>I don't understand the capital stack on it.

1018
01:19:16.350 --> 01:19:25.550
<v Loretta Smith>I don't understand why we're doing it now and not a month from now, because you already said they know that you're going to do the bonds.

1019
01:19:25.550 --> 01:19:27.710
<v Loretta Smith>They come at a certain time, so they know you're good for the money.

1020
01:19:28.430 --> 01:19:33.789
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, the action today is to, to disburse the land to Habitat so they can take action, right?

1021
01:19:33.949 --> 01:19:34.909
<v Mitch Green>That's what's happening today.

1022
01:19:34.989 --> 01:19:39.949
<v Mitch Green>So we're asking for council's approval of the transition of the property from the city to Habitat.

1023
01:19:40.350 --> 01:19:43.369
<v Mitch Green>That is the functional action that's happening No, but I asked about the money.

1024
01:19:43.609 --> 01:19:45.130
<v Loretta Smith>I had asked about the $8 million.

1025
01:19:45.289 --> 01:19:46.569
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I was concerned about.

1026
01:19:46.970 --> 01:19:47.449
<v Mitch Green>I understand.

1027
01:19:47.449 --> 01:19:59.449
<v Loretta Smith>But this, but this is, this is already giving us a direction to take $8 million before our budget is approved, to take that $8 million before the budget is approved.

1028
01:20:00.890 --> 01:20:02.250
<v Loretta Smith>It's, it's requiring us to do that.

1029
01:20:02.329 --> 01:20:02.970
<v Loretta Smith>Can we do that?

1030
01:20:03.210 --> 01:20:04.250
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, where's the legal counsel?

1031
01:20:04.250 --> 01:20:08.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Counselor, I don't, I don't see anything in here that says we are transferring cash.

1032
01:20:08.250 --> 01:20:09.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>This looks like it's No, no, no.

1033
01:20:09.739 --> 01:20:15.819
<v Loretta Smith>But, but what it's saying in the document is that we're going to spend $8 million in '26-'27.

1034
01:20:16.939 --> 01:20:24.460
<v Loretta Smith>And so we're doing an ordinance in '25-'26 that it's, it's mixing 2.

1035
01:20:24.779 --> 01:20:27.739
<v Loretta Smith>And so we have to do one before we do the other.

1036
01:20:27.819 --> 01:20:34.100
<v Loretta Smith>We have to approve a budget before you can agree to take '26-'27.

1037
01:20:37.109 --> 01:20:40.949
<v Loretta Smith>You cannot take money from another budget year without approving it first.

1038
01:20:40.949 --> 01:20:42.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I don't— we're not approving money here in this.

1039
01:20:43.270 --> 01:20:48.710
<v Loretta Smith>No, but in the ordinance, he said that it was going to be $8 million that we spend towards it.

1040
01:20:48.869 --> 01:20:50.229
<v Loretta Smith>And so maybe I'm getting this confused.

1041
01:20:50.310 --> 01:20:51.989
<v Loretta Smith>I didn't go to the— I don't sit on the committee.

1042
01:20:52.310 --> 01:20:54.390
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, I was just trying to respond to your question.

1043
01:20:54.710 --> 01:20:56.229
<v Mitch Green>Today's action is just about the land.

1044
01:20:56.789 --> 01:20:57.270
<v Loretta Smith>Just right.

1045
01:20:57.510 --> 01:21:00.149
<v Loretta Smith>But I asked you the question, are we putting any cash towards this?

1046
01:21:01.449 --> 01:21:02.329
<v Loretta Smith>And you said $8 million.

1047
01:21:02.569 --> 01:21:04.170
<v Loretta Smith>And I said, what year is it coming out of?

1048
01:21:04.250 --> 01:21:05.930
<v Loretta Smith>You said '26-'27.

1049
01:21:07.050 --> 01:21:14.409
<v Loretta Smith>And so if this is referring that we're, we're doing an action right now, what if we don't approve the budget for '26-'27?

1050
01:21:14.569 --> 01:21:16.250
<v Loretta Smith>Where are you going to get that $8 million from?

1051
01:21:17.609 --> 01:21:18.329
<v Loretta Smith>That's all I'm saying.

1052
01:21:18.409 --> 01:21:19.770
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just trying to say order.

1053
01:21:20.090 --> 01:21:21.289
<v Loretta Smith>We're not doing things in order.

1054
01:21:22.970 --> 01:21:25.369
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I think we will— yes, I heard.

1055
01:21:25.529 --> 01:21:32.529
<v Loretta Smith>And that's why I'm asking legal counsel I think—.

1056
01:21:33.170 --> 01:21:33.970
<v Angelita Morillo>Oh, go ahead, Adrienne.

1057
01:21:36.449 --> 01:21:50.689
<v Angelita Morillo>The answer is the action doesn't implicate the budget technically because it doesn't attempt to allocate or appropriate funds from the '26-'27 budget.

1058
01:21:51.090 --> 01:21:53.250
<v Angelita Morillo>It technically just transfers land.

1059
01:21:53.329 --> 01:21:58.109
<v Angelita Morillo>It's a fair question of whether or not the city should be What if we do this and council decides not to appropriate?

1060
01:21:58.829 --> 01:22:00.270
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just responding to what he said.

1061
01:22:00.350 --> 01:22:05.310
<v Loretta Smith>He said his partners need to know that we're good for the money.

1062
01:22:06.670 --> 01:22:08.350
<v Loretta Smith>But today is not about the money.

1063
01:22:08.670 --> 01:22:10.109
<v Loretta Smith>You said it's about the land.

1064
01:22:10.430 --> 01:22:22.029
<v Loretta Smith>So what about this particular ordinance is going to give them some security that we're going to actually be able to bond that for '26-'27 if we haven't passed it?

1065
01:22:22.380 --> 01:22:24.140
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I'm— that's what I'm trying to say.

1066
01:22:24.140 --> 01:22:24.859
<v Loretta Smith>We're out of order.

1067
01:22:29.739 --> 01:22:31.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any further response, team?

1068
01:22:33.659 --> 01:22:34.619
<v Loretta Smith>I don't have a problem with it.

1069
01:22:34.619 --> 01:22:35.100
<v Loretta Smith>I like the project.

1070
01:22:35.340 --> 01:22:36.060
<v Loretta Smith>I think we need to do it.

1071
01:22:36.060 --> 01:22:39.180
<v Loretta Smith>But I'm just saying that when we're doing the money, we did the same thing last year.

1072
01:22:39.819 --> 01:22:49.180
<v Loretta Smith>We approved a budget with the hopes that we were going to get $15 million from the governor, and we didn't, and it messed our budget up, and we had to go and and do a TAL to correct it.

1073
01:22:49.579 --> 01:22:55.979
<v Loretta Smith>I don't want to have to go and do something different to correct something that we did wrong in the wrong fiscal year.

1074
01:22:56.460 --> 01:22:56.539
<v Angelita Morillo>Right.

1075
01:22:56.699 --> 01:23:05.100
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think to be really clear, a transfer of land does not have a budget implication in the way of like what your budget looks like.

1076
01:23:05.899 --> 01:23:09.819
<v Loretta Smith>So we're not saying to the partners that, oh, we just buying the land.

1077
01:23:10.539 --> 01:23:12.380
<v Loretta Smith>It doesn't mean that we're not going to give you the $8 million.

1078
01:23:12.779 --> 01:23:17.489
<v Loretta Smith>So are we— Are we signaling we're going to give you the $8 million in some kind of way?

1079
01:23:18.289 --> 01:23:21.409
<v Loretta Smith>Does this give them more confidence if we pass this today?

1080
01:23:22.210 --> 01:23:25.250
<v Loretta Smith>Does this give them more confidence that we're going to actually give them the $8 million?

1081
01:23:28.689 --> 01:23:32.850
<v Mitch Green>Councilor, I believe that confidence is built on years of working together to get things done.

1082
01:23:32.850 --> 01:23:33.970
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I'm talking about.

1083
01:23:34.050 --> 01:23:34.930
<v Loretta Smith>That's all I'm saying.

1084
01:23:36.210 --> 01:23:38.050
<v Loretta Smith>I think we have a relationship.

1085
01:23:39.090 --> 01:23:45.220
<v Loretta Smith>So the emergency, the urgency is not the urgency that you're saying that it is today.

1086
01:23:45.380 --> 01:23:46.180
<v Loretta Smith>That's all I'm saying.

1087
01:23:48.180 --> 01:23:49.380
<v Loretta Smith>We're not passing any money.

1088
01:23:52.020 --> 01:23:55.220
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you, Councilor.

1089
01:23:55.539 --> 01:23:58.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, we are well over time right now, folks.

1090
01:23:58.819 --> 01:24:01.380
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are half an hour over on our calendar already.

1091
01:24:02.340 --> 01:24:08.020
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I like the project, um, DCA Oliveira.

1092
01:24:08.180 --> 01:24:15.100
<v Loretta Smith>I think it's a great project and it is going to The end user are the people who I'm concerned about, and I think that it's gonna serve us well.

1093
01:24:15.260 --> 01:24:27.739
<v Loretta Smith>But in terms of process, every time we make a mistake, and I'm really concerned as it relates to the Portland Housing Bureau because we get— we play fast and loose with certain things.

1094
01:24:27.899 --> 01:24:30.859
<v Loretta Smith>We found $106 million that we didn't have.

1095
01:24:31.100 --> 01:24:31.739
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, sir.

1096
01:24:31.899 --> 01:24:33.579
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, I'm gonna always bring that up.

1097
01:24:34.859 --> 01:24:35.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is for the city.

1098
01:24:36.069 --> 01:24:42.630
<v Loretta Smith>So when you do things out of order in my, in my world, I'm going to ask you about it.

1099
01:24:48.390 --> 01:24:49.590
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you, Councilor.

1100
01:24:50.869 --> 01:24:51.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1101
01:24:54.310 --> 01:24:54.390
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1102
01:24:54.710 --> 01:24:59.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>To just to get the heart of this point, let's say that the budget aspect does not get approved.

1103
01:25:00.149 --> 01:25:05.909
<v Eric Zimmerman>When we give land away to an organization for an intent that they develop it.

1104
01:25:06.789 --> 01:25:16.069
<v Eric Zimmerman>Do we have a deed restriction or some sort of covenant that says if they fail, fall on their face, cease to be an organization in the next X number of months or years, that we get the land back?

1105
01:25:17.350 --> 01:25:22.789
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, we'll be executing a disposition and development agreement that has a reversionary interest clause on it.

1106
01:25:23.270 --> 01:25:23.510
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1107
01:25:24.949 --> 01:25:25.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1108
01:25:26.310 --> 01:25:27.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo— oh, never mind.

1109
01:25:28.149 --> 01:25:28.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1110
01:25:29.859 --> 01:25:36.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we— let's see, seeing no one else in the queue, can we please— this is an emergency ordinance.

1111
01:25:36.979 --> 01:25:39.220
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, I'm sorry, is there— we already get testimony?

1112
01:25:39.619 --> 01:25:41.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, can we please move to a roll call vote?

1113
01:25:41.939 --> 01:25:45.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>And colleagues, reminder, this is emergency ordinance, it requires 9 votes to pass.

1114
01:25:52.899 --> 01:26:05.529
<v Sameer Kanal>Indicating an intent here to do significant oversight on This, uh, project and, and a request from everybody, Fire Bureau as well actually, uh, to, to keep council looped in on any approval of any permits related to this project.

1115
01:26:06.170 --> 01:26:06.569
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, aye.

1116
01:26:09.529 --> 01:26:09.930
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney.

1117
01:26:12.250 --> 01:26:18.890
<v Angelita Morillo>True family-sized units, a real choice for homeownership for more families, and a land banking success.

1118
01:26:19.050 --> 01:26:21.130
<v Angelita Morillo>I am proud to co-sponsor and happy to vote aye.

1119
01:26:23.810 --> 01:26:25.010
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, happy to see this back.

1120
01:26:25.170 --> 01:26:25.250
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1121
01:26:26.130 --> 01:26:27.130
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1122
01:26:29.170 --> 01:26:31.409
<v Angelita Morillo>I appreciate your line of questioning, Councilor Smith.

1123
01:26:31.489 --> 01:26:40.130
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I think that there are things we need to look at and make sure we're doing it in the right order, and I think I feel satisfied by Councilor Zimmerman's answer to those questions, but I just wanted to affirm that.

1124
01:26:40.210 --> 01:26:43.729
<v Angelita Morillo>So I vote aye knowing that we can do oversight later.

1125
01:26:44.050 --> 01:26:44.529
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1126
01:26:44.609 --> 01:26:44.689
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1127
01:26:45.970 --> 01:26:46.970
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1128
01:26:50.090 --> 01:26:50.890
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1129
01:26:52.329 --> 01:26:52.409
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1130
01:26:53.930 --> 01:26:54.010
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1131
01:26:54.970 --> 01:26:57.609
<v Unidentified speaker>The ordinance passes with 12 aye votes.

1132
01:26:58.090 --> 01:26:58.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1133
01:26:58.890 --> 01:27:04.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please move to item— the next item.

1134
01:27:04.090 --> 01:27:06.210
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know what number it is anymore.

1135
01:27:07.130 --> 01:27:07.689
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 8.

1136
01:27:08.090 --> 01:27:08.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1137
01:27:08.489 --> 01:27:08.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>There we go.

1138
01:27:10.010 --> 01:27:21.619
<v Unidentified speaker>Add identification of law enforcement officers Code to prohibit facial covering, require badge visibility, and require identity verification for individuals conducting law enforcement activities.

1139
01:27:22.500 --> 01:27:28.020
<v Unidentified speaker>Add Code Chapter 23.30, document number 2026-111.

1140
01:27:28.899 --> 01:27:32.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the continued first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1141
01:27:33.460 --> 01:27:40.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>When we left off, Councilor Murillo had moved all of Councilor Novick's first generation of amendments as a package, and Councilor Avalos had seconded it.

1142
01:27:41.850 --> 01:27:50.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>All of these amendments are out of date, but while it is still active, we have one amendment from Kanal and one from Novick.

1143
01:27:50.810 --> 01:27:53.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo, would you be willing to withdraw your motion so we can get—.

1144
01:27:54.569 --> 01:27:55.609
<v Angelita Morillo>So happy to withdraw.

1145
01:27:56.010 --> 01:27:56.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1146
01:27:56.409 --> 01:27:56.810
<v Jamie Dunphy>There we go.

1147
01:27:57.770 --> 01:28:01.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>So now I'm turning it over to Councilor Kanal.

1148
01:28:01.609 --> 01:28:01.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that right?

1149
01:28:02.489 --> 01:28:16.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, can I just ask a clarifying question on what you just said as my policy advisor Jack Jaden's gonna be sharing the screen here, but can I just ask a clarifying— which amendments are still in the universe right now?

1150
01:28:16.149 --> 01:28:18.390
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it Novick 7 and Pirtle-Guiney Canal 1?

1151
01:28:18.550 --> 01:28:19.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is my understanding.

1152
01:28:19.750 --> 01:28:20.149
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, is that—.

1153
01:28:21.270 --> 01:28:22.789
<v Steve Novick>Actually, I'm withdrawing Novick 7.

1154
01:28:23.029 --> 01:28:28.149
<v Steve Novick>I'm proposing amendments 1 and 2 to Canal Pirtle-Guiney 1.

1155
01:28:28.949 --> 01:28:30.630
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, okay, thank you for clarifying that.

1156
01:28:30.869 --> 01:28:40.750
<v Sameer Kanal>So I will, I guess, first just for the record, move Pirtle-Guiney Canal 1 as an amendment, and then I'll, I'll, I have— I'll explain it.

1157
01:28:40.909 --> 01:28:46.510
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but just wanted to, to move that, and, uh, hopefully she's still connected and can second it.

1158
01:28:52.029 --> 01:28:52.109
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1159
01:28:52.670 --> 01:28:53.470
<v Steve Novick>Yes, thank you.

1160
01:28:54.270 --> 01:28:54.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you very much.

1161
01:28:55.470 --> 01:28:59.949
<v Sameer Kanal>So, uh, just a real quick— we got a request, uh, in the last session.

1162
01:29:00.189 --> 01:29:01.720
<v Sameer Kanal>There were several, uh, Thank you.

1163
01:29:02.840 --> 01:29:13.399
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not going to go through, explain the whole thing again, and I don't want to take up time on things we've already talked about, but I did want to just do a quick side-by-side comparison here of what is being done.

1164
01:29:14.359 --> 01:29:19.239
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is referring to in the amendment what would be done.

1165
01:29:19.640 --> 01:29:27.560
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think the screen share is up, but the same underlying legislative intent exists.

1166
01:29:27.909 --> 01:29:34.869
<v Sameer Kanal>We have masked people which are taking and detaining folks with no license plates, unmarked cars, things like that.

1167
01:29:35.270 --> 01:29:40.310
<v Sameer Kanal>And it is unclear and unable to be immediately determined if people are imposters or not.

1168
01:29:41.270 --> 01:29:44.390
<v Sameer Kanal>And there is still an underlying need to build the public trust.

1169
01:29:46.229 --> 01:30:14.649
<v Sameer Kanal>The ordinance seeks still to create, and this is the legislative intent once again for the record, the right to know for the public as well as the city government that a person claiming to be law enforcement actually is and is not an imposter, that there is transparency and accountability for all law enforcement, not just Portland Police operating in Portland, and that there's enough information being collected that there's a record of what's going on so someone can file a complaint or, you know, follow up in the event of a feeling that wrongdoing has occurred.

1170
01:30:15.369 --> 01:30:17.930
<v Sameer Kanal>So I won't go back over this next slide.

1171
01:30:17.930 --> 01:30:19.689
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll just show it for a second here of what it does.

1172
01:30:20.420 --> 01:30:24.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Visible identification, preliminary investigations, and documentation here.

1173
01:30:25.380 --> 01:30:35.859
<v Sameer Kanal>But I did want to go to these last just 3 quick things: the overlap, the differences, and the differences relative to the state and California law.

1174
01:30:36.500 --> 01:30:45.539
<v Sameer Kanal>So for those who again may have forgotten, we are required by state law to create a policy that relates to masking and identification.

1175
01:30:45.560 --> 01:30:45.720
<v Sameer Kanal>Mm-hmm.

1176
01:30:46.279 --> 01:30:48.680
<v Sameer Kanal>This goes further than that, and that's the right column here.

1177
01:30:48.760 --> 01:30:50.760
<v Sameer Kanal>But the left column is what we are required to do.

1178
01:30:50.840 --> 01:30:52.119
<v Sameer Kanal>We are fulfilling that obligation.

1179
01:30:53.640 --> 01:30:58.760
<v Sameer Kanal>We are complying with the masking piece exactly as the state requires it.

1180
01:30:59.319 --> 01:31:05.479
<v Sameer Kanal>With the identification piece, we are— you can see Section 1 there on the left that you're allowed to adopt more stringent requirements.

1181
01:31:05.960 --> 01:31:07.560
<v Sameer Kanal>And so we're showing that on the next slide.

1182
01:31:08.439 --> 01:31:13.079
<v Sameer Kanal>And then we copied and pasted from the state law the definitions of these sorts of terms.

1183
01:31:13.770 --> 01:31:20.729
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the right side of this slide shows that there's a— oh, that's the mass identification.

1184
01:31:20.810 --> 01:31:21.689
<v Sameer Kanal>I already talked about that.

1185
01:31:22.090 --> 01:31:22.569
<v Sameer Kanal>Next slide, please.

1186
01:31:22.729 --> 01:31:39.060
<v Sameer Kanal>The differences is that we add in this piece of potential imposter investigations and then documentation of how it was known that that authority was present for someone claiming law enforcement authority without any immediate way to know that for Sure.

1187
01:31:39.859 --> 01:31:41.859
<v Sameer Kanal>So basically what happens when it's looked into.

1188
01:31:42.180 --> 01:31:54.340
<v Sameer Kanal>And then just getting to the, the last slide here, because the California law has been asked several times, there are differences in how our ordinance compares to the California law.

1189
01:31:55.300 --> 01:32:09.939
<v Sameer Kanal>Our ordinance focuses pretty significantly on imposters, as the second point says, but it is also that we are looking more at the Chicago model than the California model as it relates to mass And identification in terms of being able to seek injunctive relief from a court.

1190
01:32:10.020 --> 01:32:13.859
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to thank Councilor Novick for bringing that issue up more clearly.

1191
01:32:14.579 --> 01:32:17.939
<v Sameer Kanal>So, and that's a topic that's not in Oregon state law or in California.

1192
01:32:18.500 --> 01:32:22.260
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to get this on the record for legislative intent because there's been a lot of questions.

1193
01:32:22.819 --> 01:32:28.100
<v Sameer Kanal>So now that we've moved the amendment and it has been seconded, I'd love to get into the conversation and I'll stop here.

1194
01:32:29.939 --> 01:32:30.020
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1195
01:32:30.579 --> 01:32:31.220
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

1196
01:32:32.850 --> 01:32:35.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, we are in an amendment.

1197
01:32:37.090 --> 01:32:39.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have an amendment before us that's been moved and seconded.

1198
01:32:40.449 --> 01:32:41.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1199
01:32:42.930 --> 01:32:43.649
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1200
01:32:44.289 --> 01:32:48.930
<v Steve Novick>First of all, I want to thank Councilor Kanal and his staff and Councilor Pirtle-Guiney over the past few days.

1201
01:32:50.130 --> 01:33:00.529
<v Steve Novick>We've been— I've been bombarding them with questions, suggested additions, suggested deletions, and we've made a lot of progress over the last few weeks, and I really appreciate that.

1202
01:33:02.239 --> 01:33:04.880
<v Steve Novick>There's 2 amendments that I want to offer.

1203
01:33:06.479 --> 01:33:18.960
<v Steve Novick>One is, I originally thought, and I still think, that we should not be in the position of— I mean, I don't think that we need to tell PPB how internally to comply with this law or the state law.

1204
01:33:19.279 --> 01:33:28.960
<v Steve Novick>I don't think PPB has a history of over-masking or under-identifying, but I'm willing to go along with having some element of that.

1205
01:33:29.039 --> 01:33:30.399
<v Steve Novick>But one thing that concerns me is that Councilmember Herbold.

1206
01:33:30.560 --> 01:33:43.760
<v Steve Novick>The one that concerns me is that the requirement for documentation and approval of certain exemptions, in particular the one for working in extreme or severely inclement weather, including freezing temperatures, high wind, highly dusty conditions.

1207
01:33:44.720 --> 01:33:57.600
<v Steve Novick>And there's a requirement if that exemption is invoked that the operational necessity must be documented, a listing of the assigned duties or deployment at the time of the exception.

1208
01:33:57.850 --> 01:34:02.970
<v Steve Novick>The specific rationale for the exception, the name and rank of the supervising PPV officer who authorized the exception.

1209
01:34:03.930 --> 01:34:17.850
<v Steve Novick>And what that raises for me is a prospect of it's a really cold day and 200 patrol officers call their sergeant and say, hey, Sarge, I'm— it's really cold, I'm wrapping my scarf around the bottom of my face.

1210
01:34:19.210 --> 01:34:20.970
<v Steve Novick>And that just strikes me as overkill.

1211
01:34:21.289 --> 01:34:31.699
<v Steve Novick>So one of my amendments would Just delete the reference to the severe weather exemption from those— from that requirement.

1212
01:34:33.619 --> 01:34:51.939
<v Steve Novick>The second amendment that I'm proposing is that in the section which talks about incident reports of encounters with alleged law enforcement officers, I'd like to add something to the incident report requirement, which is that—.

1213
01:34:52.100 --> 01:34:52.180
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1214
01:34:53.329 --> 01:35:06.770
<v Steve Novick>Even if the PPB officer determines finally that the person purporting to be law enforcement is law enforcement, I want to document instances of possible violations of the identification and masking requirements.

1215
01:35:07.890 --> 01:35:21.189
<v Steve Novick>So my amendment would say that if, if the PPB officer observed that the person in question was wearing a mask or was not wearing a badge, Or was not wearing either a permanent identifying number or a name tag.

1216
01:35:21.350 --> 01:35:22.470
<v Steve Novick>Oh, sorry, typo here.

1217
01:35:22.710 --> 01:35:24.149
<v Steve Novick>It says of a name tag, meant or.

1218
01:35:24.630 --> 01:35:26.069
<v Steve Novick>The report shall include that information.

1219
01:35:27.909 --> 01:35:40.670
<v Steve Novick>And the purpose of that is that we should be gathering information about potential violations of the law that then we could invoke if we attempt to enforce the law through a lawsuit.

1220
01:35:40.949 --> 01:35:43.109
<v Steve Novick>So I move to approve.

1221
01:35:43.510 --> 01:35:43.590
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1222
01:35:44.079 --> 01:35:49.520
<v Steve Novick>Novick 1 to Kanal-Pirtle-Guiney 1, and I move Novick 2 to Kanal-Pirtle-Guiney 1.

1223
01:35:50.560 --> 01:35:54.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick has moved Novick 1 and Novick 2.

1224
01:35:54.399 --> 01:35:54.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there a second?

1225
01:35:55.600 --> 01:35:57.039
<v Sameer Kanal>Can I second one of them?

1226
01:35:57.439 --> 01:35:57.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

1227
01:35:58.239 --> 01:35:58.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

1228
01:35:59.039 --> 01:36:01.039
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm happy to second Novick 2.

1229
01:36:01.600 --> 01:36:01.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1230
01:36:02.560 --> 01:36:05.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal seconds Novick number 2.

1231
01:36:05.359 --> 01:36:09.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there a second on Novick 1?

1232
01:36:11.680 --> 01:36:12.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>Not hearing one.

1233
01:36:13.920 --> 01:36:16.880
<v Sameer Kanal>And I can speak to both in the same if that's helpful when we get to—.

1234
01:36:17.039 --> 01:36:17.119
<v Loretta Smith>Sure.

1235
01:36:18.159 --> 01:36:23.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, we are now to— yeah, Councilor, it seems as though we do not have a second for your other amendment.

1236
01:36:24.800 --> 01:36:29.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we are now in discussion on Novick 2.

1237
01:36:31.760 --> 01:36:33.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman to the amendment.

1238
01:36:36.220 --> 01:36:40.300
<v Eric Zimmerman>Why are we in discussion of Novick 2 if we— if it is only to Pirtle-Guiney Canal 1?

1239
01:36:40.460 --> 01:36:42.220
<v Eric Zimmerman>Shouldn't we take up Pirtle-Guiney Canal 1?

1240
01:36:42.300 --> 01:36:46.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>I thought that's what we were discussing before he makes his amendment to a thing that doesn't exist yet.

1241
01:36:46.539 --> 01:36:47.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that how it works?

1242
01:36:47.739 --> 01:36:48.859
<v Eric Zimmerman>I guess I'm just trying to understand.

1243
01:36:48.939 --> 01:36:49.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, that's fair.

1244
01:36:51.420 --> 01:36:52.779
<v Jamie Dunphy>I thought we debate the amendment.

1245
01:36:53.100 --> 01:36:54.619
<v Eric Zimmerman>You're amending just their amendment, not—.

1246
01:36:54.779 --> 01:36:54.859
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1247
01:36:55.100 --> 01:36:59.579
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, I'll hold because I just— my question to you, Councilor, you were talking a little bit about the California thing.

1248
01:36:59.659 --> 01:37:00.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to get back into that.

1249
01:37:00.789 --> 01:37:02.310
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm going to hold no comments on this.

1250
01:37:02.310 --> 01:37:02.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will come back to that.

1251
01:37:03.189 --> 01:37:06.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, Councilor Murillo, to the— to Novick 1 or Novick 2?

1252
01:37:11.109 --> 01:37:12.390
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm going to put my hand back down.

1253
01:37:12.949 --> 01:37:13.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Gotcha.

1254
01:37:13.909 --> 01:37:14.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal?

1255
01:37:15.670 --> 01:37:21.270
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I'm happy to, to speak to this because this is both about, um, documentation in 2 different parts.

1256
01:37:21.590 --> 01:37:24.630
<v Sameer Kanal>One is in the context of incident reporting, and that's the one that I seconded.

1257
01:37:25.109 --> 01:37:33.989
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I think it's helpful to have more information, um, Wherever we can all agree that that is not an administrative burden and we all agree it's a good idea.

1258
01:37:34.949 --> 01:37:39.510
<v Sameer Kanal>So I see no concern with that and I'm happy to support it.

1259
01:37:39.590 --> 01:37:41.430
<v Sameer Kanal>I haven't heard any negativity towards it.

1260
01:37:41.430 --> 01:37:47.270
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously we're all just hearing it, but if there was, I'd be open to that, but I don't immediately see any sort of issue with it.

1261
01:37:47.270 --> 01:37:54.630
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to second it and thank Councilor Novick for the continued, you know, looking into it and seeing where it can be improved.

1262
01:37:55.310 --> 01:37:56.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

1263
01:37:58.189 --> 01:38:00.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue— Councilor Morillo.

1264
01:38:02.670 --> 01:38:06.029
<v Angelita Morillo>Am I allowed to ask Councilor Novick, 'cause I like this amendment, I think it's good.

1265
01:38:07.390 --> 01:38:10.350
<v Angelita Morillo>Are you— does this satisfy your concerns about the policy?

1266
01:38:10.750 --> 01:38:13.710
<v Angelita Morillo>Will you be able to vote in favor of it if this is approved?

1267
01:38:16.270 --> 01:38:21.750
<v Steve Novick>Councilor, you're asking me to like spoil the fun.

1268
01:38:23.000 --> 01:38:25.079
<v Steve Novick>I have a couple of clarifying questions to ask.

1269
01:38:25.399 --> 01:38:32.600
<v Steve Novick>I am disappointed that nobody, nobody seconded Novick 1, so I'm gulping over that a little bit.

1270
01:38:33.640 --> 01:38:40.359
<v Steve Novick>But you'll notice that I did not move my separate comprehensive amendment, so you can maybe infer that I'm kind of getting there.

1271
01:38:42.119 --> 01:38:43.880
<v Angelita Morillo>That's so unhelpful.

1272
01:38:45.560 --> 01:38:47.079
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, that's as far as we go, I guess.

1273
01:38:47.479 --> 01:38:48.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1274
01:38:48.359 --> 01:38:49.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1275
01:38:51.189 --> 01:38:51.989
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Councilor Novick.

1276
01:38:52.069 --> 01:38:53.029
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm reading it.

1277
01:38:53.270 --> 01:39:01.590
<v Eric Zimmerman>Your amendment says in line 232 after agency, so—.

1278
01:39:02.149 --> 01:39:02.229
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1279
01:39:02.949 --> 01:39:10.789
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, and to the Pirtle-Guiney-Kanal amendment that I'm holding, line 232 is about body-worn cameras.

1280
01:39:12.229 --> 01:39:17.930
<v Steve Novick>Maybe I'm looking at it either a too later or a Maybe I'm looking at the wrong—.

1281
01:39:18.090 --> 01:39:19.130
<v Eric Zimmerman>Oh, what am I getting wrong here?

1282
01:39:19.130 --> 01:39:19.689
<v Steve Novick>That I had this morning.

1283
01:39:23.770 --> 01:39:24.170
<v Eric Zimmerman>Where is this?

1284
01:39:25.369 --> 01:39:33.609
<v Steve Novick>Taking it out of the context of lines, this is under 23.30.060 incident reports, A1.

1285
01:39:34.170 --> 01:39:38.449
<v Steve Novick>So it would add to the end of A1 after and agency.

1286
01:39:38.729 --> 01:39:41.130
<v Steve Novick>The report will also include blah, blah, blah.

1287
01:39:41.569 --> 01:39:43.489
<v Steve Novick>So it'd be the end of A1.

1288
01:39:43.810 --> 01:39:44.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you.

1289
01:39:44.850 --> 01:39:46.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>So got it.

1290
01:39:51.970 --> 01:39:52.609
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

1291
01:39:54.770 --> 01:40:01.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue for debate, can we please call the roll on Novick 2?

1292
01:40:05.810 --> 01:40:06.369
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick 2.

1293
01:40:07.880 --> 01:40:09.560
<v Unidentified speaker>To Canal EPG 1?

1294
01:40:09.880 --> 01:40:09.960
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

1295
01:40:10.119 --> 01:40:10.199
<v Unidentified speaker>Correct.

1296
01:40:10.760 --> 01:40:11.239
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, Canal?

1297
01:40:12.119 --> 01:40:12.199
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1298
01:40:13.960 --> 01:40:14.520
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

1299
01:40:14.760 --> 01:40:15.000
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1300
01:40:15.239 --> 01:40:15.479
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

1301
01:40:15.560 --> 01:40:15.960
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1302
01:40:16.680 --> 01:40:17.079
<v Candace Avalos>Koyama Lane?

1303
01:40:17.319 --> 01:40:17.399
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1304
01:40:18.840 --> 01:40:18.920
<v Unidentified speaker>Murillo?

1305
01:40:19.399 --> 01:40:19.640
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1306
01:40:19.640 --> 01:40:19.720
<v Loretta Smith>Novick?

1307
01:40:20.039 --> 01:40:20.439
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1308
01:40:20.520 --> 01:40:20.680
<v Loretta Smith>Clark?

1309
01:40:20.680 --> 01:40:20.840
<v Olivia Clark>No.

1310
01:40:20.840 --> 01:40:21.000
<v Loretta Smith>Green?

1311
01:40:21.000 --> 01:40:21.239
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1312
01:40:21.239 --> 01:40:21.399
<v Loretta Smith>Ryan?

1313
01:40:21.399 --> 01:40:21.560
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1314
01:40:21.560 --> 01:40:22.119
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

1315
01:40:22.520 --> 01:40:22.600
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1316
01:40:23.560 --> 01:40:23.880
<v Steve Novick>Murillo?

1317
01:40:24.680 --> 01:40:24.760
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1318
01:40:25.479 --> 01:40:25.800
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

1319
01:40:26.119 --> 01:40:26.199
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1320
01:40:27.960 --> 01:40:28.039
<v Loretta Smith>Clark?

1321
01:40:28.520 --> 01:40:28.600
<v Olivia Clark>No.

1322
01:40:29.880 --> 01:40:29.960
<v Steve Novick>Green?

1323
01:40:31.079 --> 01:40:31.159
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1324
01:40:32.199 --> 01:40:32.520
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

1325
01:40:33.350 --> 01:40:33.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1326
01:40:35.350 --> 01:40:35.750
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

1327
01:40:36.229 --> 01:40:36.310
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1328
01:40:37.590 --> 01:40:37.670
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

1329
01:40:39.109 --> 01:40:39.189
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1330
01:40:41.750 --> 01:40:42.069
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

1331
01:40:42.470 --> 01:40:42.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1332
01:40:44.229 --> 01:40:47.350
<v Unidentified speaker>And the amendment is approved with 8 aye, 4 nay.

1333
01:40:48.149 --> 01:40:55.510
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, the amendment has been approved— has been amended to the underlying amendment to Kanal Pirtle-Guiney.

1334
01:40:56.229 --> 01:40:57.869
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilors, discussion?

1335
01:40:59.119 --> 01:40:59.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1336
01:41:02.159 --> 01:41:17.920
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Kanal, I do want to hear your answer to the question about why isn't there a— doesn't it seem kind of goofy to require 200 patrol officers to call up and say, hey, Sarge, it's cold, I'm wrapping the scarf around the bottom of my face?

1337
01:41:21.119 --> 01:41:31.710
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so I want to look at, and this is 233030, Section E-2.

1338
01:41:32.590 --> 01:41:38.029
<v Sameer Kanal>In— it's in my, um, version, it's in the lines 145 to 151 area.

1339
01:41:38.109 --> 01:41:39.229
<v Sameer Kanal>That's what we're talking about here.

1340
01:41:39.789 --> 01:41:39.949
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1341
01:41:39.949 --> 01:41:47.710
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so there's a change in the, um— this is something similar to something that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney brought up, uh, about this.

1342
01:41:47.949 --> 01:42:17.220
<v Sameer Kanal>And so you'll, you'll notice the words on a per-PPB officer basis So I think my— I think that we addressed the underlying concern that you're trying to solve already in the underlying amendment by removing that so that there does not need to be 200 calls, but any supervisor who's able to, you know, do so can just say it was 20 degrees outside, we exempted for that particular purpose.

1343
01:42:17.220 --> 01:42:17.460
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1344
01:42:17.390 --> 01:42:17.470
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1345
01:42:18.029 --> 01:42:23.550
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I believe that that covers it and addresses it sufficiently.

1346
01:42:24.510 --> 01:42:40.989
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll also note that having no documentation would be challenging because at the request of PSSA, the— at least indirect request— the part that defines extreme weather has been removed.

1347
01:42:41.229 --> 01:42:52.279
<v Sameer Kanal>So in order to know that it was 20 degrees, You do need something there, but I think that removing the per-officer basis allows it to be one report instead of 200 if there are 200 officers on duty.

1348
01:42:52.600 --> 01:42:53.800
<v Steve Novick>Thank you for clarifying that.

1349
01:42:54.039 --> 01:43:06.680
<v Steve Novick>So when it says the name and rank of the supervising PPE officer who authorized the exception, you could have a captain or somebody say, hey, you guys, I know it's cold out there, I authorize you to protect your faces from the cold.

1350
01:43:07.079 --> 01:43:08.439
<v Sameer Kanal>That is a legislative intent, yes.

1351
01:43:08.920 --> 01:43:09.560
<v Steve Novick>Okay, thank you.

1352
01:43:09.529 --> 01:43:10.250
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1353
01:43:10.569 --> 01:43:33.050
<v Steve Novick>The only other question I have is where it talks about the 23-30-050A says the section applies when a person of ambiguous authority is engaged in conduct that would be unlawful for a civilian, and ambiguous authority is not defined.

1354
01:43:33.850 --> 01:43:35.529
<v Steve Novick>I just want to be clear.

1355
01:43:36.840 --> 01:44:00.960
<v Steve Novick>If a PPB officer shows up on a scene and a reported law enforcement officer is wearing a badge, is not wearing— is wearing a badge and is wearing either a unique identifying number or a name tag, are you assuming that the PPB officer can decide right then and there, okay, this is not ambiguous authority, this is real authority?

1356
01:44:01.409 --> 01:44:04.850
<v Sameer Kanal>So let's just step back for a second.

1357
01:44:05.489 --> 01:44:06.369
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm gonna answer your question.

1358
01:44:06.689 --> 01:44:11.409
<v Sameer Kanal>I do wanna note, I think you might have an old version that got updated to lacking immediate proof of authority.

1359
01:44:12.050 --> 01:44:14.850
<v Sameer Kanal>Proof of authority is defined up above.

1360
01:44:15.170 --> 01:44:18.289
<v Sameer Kanal>So just clarifying that, I'll make sure you have the right copy just in case.

1361
01:44:20.210 --> 01:44:36.020
<v Sameer Kanal>But to answer your direct question, if a PPB officer shows up in a scene, on a scene, and a reported law enforcement officer or potential imposter is wearing is not— is wearing a badge and wearing either a unique identifier or a name tag.

1362
01:44:36.340 --> 01:44:44.500
<v Sameer Kanal>So that to me constitutes proof of authority under this context, given what is written above.

1363
01:44:44.579 --> 01:44:50.979
<v Sameer Kanal>It meets— oh boy, it meets the— sorry, it meets the definition above as I understand it.

1364
01:44:51.460 --> 01:44:54.340
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just gonna let Jack speak more to that if there's anything you wanted to add.

1365
01:44:54.659 --> 01:44:55.060
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry if I—.

1366
01:44:56.859 --> 01:45:00.699
<v Unidentified speaker>Jack Jaden, she/they pronouns for the record, Senior Policy Advisor for Councilor Kanal.

1367
01:45:01.899 --> 01:45:07.739
<v Angelita Morillo>I was passing out printed copies of the most recent version, and it sounds like you'd like me to explain the—.

1368
01:45:08.859 --> 01:45:11.739
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, can you explain your hypothetical one more time?

1369
01:45:12.140 --> 01:45:15.180
<v Unidentified speaker>What page are we on?

1370
01:45:16.060 --> 01:45:21.659
<v Sameer Kanal>Page 6, 23A.

1371
01:45:22.979 --> 01:45:27.939
<v Sameer Kanal>3050, Part A, scope, the first sentence.

1372
01:45:29.699 --> 01:45:33.380
<v Sameer Kanal>This section applies when a person lacking immediate proof of authority.

1373
01:45:34.260 --> 01:45:36.979
<v Sameer Kanal>And Councilor Nowak, can you repeat it for—.

1374
01:45:37.779 --> 01:45:39.619
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, thanks, Councilor.

1375
01:45:39.699 --> 01:45:40.260
<v Steve Novick>Thanks, Jack.

1376
01:45:40.899 --> 01:45:57.439
<v Steve Novick>My question is, would the state-required identification, which we're also requiring it, would, if the person is wearing a badge and either a unique identifier or a name tag, does that qualify as immediate proof of authority?

1377
01:45:58.079 --> 01:46:01.600
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would point to line 33, proof of authority.

1378
01:46:02.079 --> 01:46:08.239
<v Angelita Morillo>And so if it was lacking what is in there, that's where they would defer to.

1379
01:46:09.119 --> 01:46:16.409
<v Angelita Morillo>The previous version was a bit more vague Ambiguous, as the word suggests.

1380
01:46:16.489 --> 01:46:25.050
<v Angelita Morillo>And so we, through some helpful partners, better defined it in a way that is already spelled out.

1381
01:46:27.050 --> 01:46:33.689
<v Steve Novick>Okay, but proof of— the definition of proof authority says the indicia set forth below are illustrative and not exhaustive.

1382
01:46:35.369 --> 01:46:38.890
<v Steve Novick>And I don't think you could possibly be requiring that all of these be present.

1383
01:46:39.670 --> 01:46:49.989
<v Steve Novick>I'm just asking as a statement of legislative intent, is having the unique identifier or name tag and the badge enough to constitute immediate proof of authority?

1384
01:46:50.710 --> 01:46:54.710
<v Angelita Morillo>If they're lacking anything, then that is enough to constitute this scope.

1385
01:46:57.189 --> 01:47:02.869
<v Steve Novick>Okay, so if they are— if they don't have a judicial warrant, then they don't meet the—.

1386
01:47:02.949 --> 01:47:05.590
<v Sameer Kanal>No, no, no, sorry, you are correct.

1387
01:47:05.859 --> 01:47:08.819
<v Sameer Kanal>That it is not at all a comprehensive list.

1388
01:47:09.060 --> 01:47:09.859
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not a checklist.

1389
01:47:10.260 --> 01:47:11.699
<v Sameer Kanal>You do not have to do it as it says.

1390
01:47:11.859 --> 01:47:12.579
<v Sameer Kanal>It's illustrative.

1391
01:47:13.460 --> 01:47:13.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay?

1392
01:47:15.779 --> 01:47:27.300
<v Sameer Kanal>My legislative intent, to answer your direct question about that, is that in that scenario, that is, you know, if someone's got a uniform with a badge, a name tag, and I believe you also said a number.

1393
01:47:27.939 --> 01:47:28.659
<v Steve Novick>A name tag, yeah.

1394
01:47:29.060 --> 01:47:31.380
<v Steve Novick>Well, either a name tag or a number.

1395
01:47:31.619 --> 01:47:35.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for clarifying that because we did change the and to an or for clarity there in the other section.

1396
01:47:36.180 --> 01:47:47.359
<v Sameer Kanal>But yes, that would be sufficient to, to, um, constitute, uh, the, the, sorry, the preliminary investigation would not need to occur.

1397
01:47:47.760 --> 01:47:47.840
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1398
01:47:48.079 --> 01:47:53.760
<v Steve Novick>Now, I'm sorry, you said a uniform, and actually there are law enforcement agencies that don't traditionally wear uniforms.

1399
01:47:54.159 --> 01:48:02.399
<v Steve Novick>Um, so even if they don't wear a uniform, if they're wearing the, uh, the badge and identifying number or name tag, is that okay?

1400
01:48:02.720 --> 01:48:09.619
<v Sameer Kanal>You're not requiring agencies that don't have uniforms to have Generally speaking, we're not seeing people wearing a badge on a not uniform.

1401
01:48:10.420 --> 01:48:14.659
<v Steve Novick>Well, my understanding, my understanding is that ICE normally doesn't wear uniforms.

1402
01:48:15.220 --> 01:48:15.300
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure.

1403
01:48:15.859 --> 01:48:18.819
<v Sameer Kanal>So, but the same point I just made still applies.

1404
01:48:19.380 --> 01:48:19.460
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1405
01:48:20.180 --> 01:48:20.899
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of—.

1406
01:48:20.979 --> 01:48:21.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor?

1407
01:48:21.460 --> 01:48:21.699
<v Steve Novick>Directing.

1408
01:48:21.939 --> 01:48:22.020
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1409
01:48:22.260 --> 01:48:24.100
<v Angelita Morillo>Can I jump in on part of the answer here?

1410
01:48:24.979 --> 01:48:25.060
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1411
01:48:26.340 --> 01:48:36.560
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to point out that one of the changes in Pirtle-Guiney Canal 1 In, um, on the line notation, it's line 115.

1412
01:48:37.039 --> 01:48:39.760
<v Angelita Morillo>It's 2330.030.

1413
01:48:40.640 --> 01:48:42.640
<v Angelita Morillo>The words in uniform are removed.

1414
01:48:44.000 --> 01:48:54.720
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, so we are not setting a precedent anywhere in the language here about a uniform being part of the requirement for complying with the rest of the code.

1415
01:48:55.840 --> 01:49:07.840
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I'll also just note, I think Councilor Kanal gave a good technical answer, but that list you were referring to is an or list, not an and list.

1416
01:49:08.640 --> 01:49:19.600
<v Angelita Morillo>So as you're looking at that, what it's saying is this thing could show you, this other thing could show you, or this other thing could show you, or it could be something else not listed here altogether.

1417
01:49:20.880 --> 01:49:29.750
<v Angelita Morillo>There's no intent from my end, at least, for that to be a list where more than one thing needs to be met to comply.

1418
01:49:30.630 --> 01:49:31.029
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1419
01:49:31.510 --> 01:49:31.590
<v Steve Novick>And—.

1420
01:49:31.590 --> 01:49:33.670
<v Eric Zimmerman>Mr. President, can we just have a— I'm sorry, Councilor.

1421
01:49:33.909 --> 01:49:34.229
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, sure.

1422
01:49:34.229 --> 01:49:35.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>Point of information.

1423
01:49:35.989 --> 01:49:45.270
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Kanal, your staff members handed out something to us, and you guys are going back and forth on the word and and or, but that's in a different place.

1424
01:49:46.229 --> 01:49:53.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>But we were talking about proof of authority, a uniform and a visibly displaying badge, and Agency identification.

1425
01:49:55.210 --> 01:49:56.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>Do we have the wrong document?

1426
01:49:56.409 --> 01:50:00.010
<v Eric Zimmerman>As you said, maybe Councilor Novick did, or are we all working from the same sheet of music?

1427
01:50:00.250 --> 01:50:02.729
<v Eric Zimmerman>And quite literally, are we working from the same sheet of music here?

1428
01:50:03.130 --> 01:50:03.289
<v Candace Avalos>Can I—.

1429
01:50:03.529 --> 01:50:05.449
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I apologize for interrupting.

1430
01:50:05.609 --> 01:50:12.010
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just don't know what you referenced when Councilor Elana Pirtle-Guiney is saying or, but the document you just handed us says and.

1431
01:50:12.729 --> 01:50:19.050
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so let me, those are 2 different questions and it's not immediately obvious.

1432
01:50:19.529 --> 01:50:23.369
<v Sameer Kanal>The and and or is in line 117 on page 4.

1433
01:50:24.500 --> 01:50:29.060
<v Sameer Kanal>And it, um, it's also 116 and 117 were both just referenced.

1434
01:50:29.380 --> 01:50:33.220
<v Sameer Kanal>116 Is where the in uniform was removed, and that's also where the and/or was changed.

1435
01:50:33.460 --> 01:50:48.819
<v Sameer Kanal>To answer your first question, proof of authority is in line 33 on page 2, and it has that it is— shall be established by at least one, uh, indicia of authority.

1436
01:50:49.060 --> 01:50:58.250
<v Sameer Kanal>So that means that There is some sort of thing that shows that a person has authority and they have an illustrative list in the definition down below.

1437
01:50:59.369 --> 01:51:03.369
<v Sameer Kanal>And I can speak more detail if there's a specific question.

1438
01:51:03.369 --> 01:51:04.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think I see it now.

1439
01:51:04.250 --> 01:51:05.529
<v Eric Zimmerman>My point of information was corrected.

1440
01:51:05.529 --> 01:51:07.609
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll ask you a substantive question about that later.

1441
01:51:07.850 --> 01:51:07.930
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

1442
01:51:08.010 --> 01:51:08.810
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1443
01:51:08.970 --> 01:51:09.050
<v Eric Zimmerman>Sorry.

1444
01:51:11.210 --> 01:51:15.579
<v Mitch Green>Can I, may I just for the record, and this might help Thank you.

1445
01:51:15.659 --> 01:51:24.220
<v Mitch Green>Just to help folks following along and, um, and council, there, there is a Pirtle-Guiney Canal Amendment 1 that's posted online with this item.

1446
01:51:26.699 --> 01:51:28.140
<v Mitch Green>There have been changes to that.

1447
01:51:29.579 --> 01:51:32.380
<v Mitch Green>Those changes were passed out to members of the council.

1448
01:51:33.979 --> 01:51:40.460
<v Mitch Green>So, so the document you are looking at at council is not at the moment the one that's posted online.

1449
01:51:40.619 --> 01:51:45.979
<v Eric Zimmerman>The clerk, I believe, has it, is working to post the current version online as soon as possible.

1450
01:51:50.220 --> 01:51:50.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1451
01:51:50.859 --> 01:51:52.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, okay.

1452
01:51:52.699 --> 01:51:54.220
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick, are you done?

1453
01:51:55.899 --> 01:51:58.539
<v Steve Novick>I've signed back in to talk about something else, so I'm done with this round.

1454
01:51:58.699 --> 01:51:58.859
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

1455
01:51:58.859 --> 01:51:59.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

1456
01:51:59.819 --> 01:52:00.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1457
01:52:01.739 --> 01:52:05.420
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, just briefly, I wanted to put my hand up, uh, to the earlier question.

1458
01:52:05.899 --> 01:52:16.920
<v Mitch Green>Um, you know, I had always interpreted I think I was thinking of the sort of inclement weather exemption as being a thing that once it's codified in law that you would need to do that.

1459
01:52:19.239 --> 01:52:23.800
<v Mitch Green>You know, you have your orders of the day, here's your uniform of the day, and by the way, there's some exemptions today.

1460
01:52:23.800 --> 01:52:30.760
<v Mitch Green>It's going to be cold out, you're authorized to, you know, use a mask for that purpose, as we would do in like the Army back in my day.

1461
01:52:30.920 --> 01:52:34.119
<v Mitch Green>So I don't know if it's still like that, but it was when I was in.

1462
01:52:34.199 --> 01:52:40.529
<v Mitch Green>So that's kind of how I thought about it, and that's why I Thank you, Councilor Green.

1463
01:52:40.770 --> 01:52:41.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1464
01:52:45.250 --> 01:52:46.210
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1465
01:52:47.409 --> 01:52:58.529
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, colleagues, I know there are a lot of changes here in what you're looking at and some Scribner errors that were corrected in what you have before you on paper.

1466
01:52:59.329 --> 01:53:12.510
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to speak a little bit as to why I I signed on to an amendment, and Council President, I will have some questions that I want to ask, so I'll get back into the queue for that after others have a little bit of time.

1467
01:53:12.750 --> 01:53:16.670
<v Angelita Morillo>My questions are more related to the underlying and the general concept here.

1468
01:53:18.670 --> 01:53:56.449
<v Angelita Morillo>You know, I think it is not a surprise that Councilor Kanal and I, while both very detail-focused, And I think I was pretty clear with a lot of folks on council that while I absolutely agree with the goals and values of the original version, I couldn't get there on it because I didn't think it was going to do the things we needed to, to keep Portlanders safe and work in a way that was implementable.

1469
01:53:56.529 --> 01:53:57.010
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Herbold.

1470
01:53:57.590 --> 01:54:02.630
<v Angelita Morillo>That we could stand behind and say, yes, this will happen in the way that we're saying it will.

1471
01:54:03.590 --> 01:54:08.829
<v Angelita Morillo>I had concerns on the labor side and the operational side.

1472
01:54:09.590 --> 01:54:24.149
<v Angelita Morillo>I also, though, kept coming back to that need to do something to support our community here, and the very poignant call I was hearing from Portlanders who expect us to do everything we can.

1473
01:54:25.250 --> 01:54:39.329
<v Angelita Morillo>To not just hold the line, but push the line on our response to the federal government and to set the standard for what we can do, knowing that there is a lot that we can't do.

1474
01:54:39.729 --> 01:54:44.770
<v Angelita Morillo>And I will ask some questions to get some of those pieces on the record later in our conversation.

1475
01:54:47.569 --> 01:54:51.970
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to thank Councilor Kanal for taking seriously the concerns that I raised.

1476
01:54:53.029 --> 01:55:16.949
<v Angelita Morillo>And I want to thank PPB and the Public Safety Service Area for sitting down with me and walking through the implementation side and what we could do to make sure that this both responds to the clarion call from community that we're hearing, but does so in a way that is implementable.

1477
01:55:18.869 --> 01:55:22.470
<v Angelita Morillo>I also appreciate conversations to that end with the City Attorney's Office.

1478
01:55:24.789 --> 01:55:50.840
<v Angelita Morillo>In the amendment before us, we added a number of tools for identifying law enforcement from all levels of government on Portland streets, not just targeting a single agency, along with codifying state law and pushing PPB to continue to be on the front end, which I know Councilor Kanal was working to do at every step of the way.

1479
01:55:52.119 --> 01:56:00.520
<v Angelita Morillo>We made sure that we could do that in a way that moves forward as quickly as possible.

1480
01:56:01.880 --> 01:56:19.020
<v Angelita Morillo>And we added key protections to the bargaining process, both in some of the changes that are made in the text and in changes that were made before I was signed on in language that ensures that pieces of this that must be bargained will be before they go into effect.

1481
01:56:19.420 --> 01:56:40.310
<v Angelita Morillo>And Robert Taylor, if you're in the room, I'll want to ask a question a little bit later about implementation because it's my understanding that pieces of this will, will be implemented on different timelines, some at the normal 30-day mark and some after they are bargained because there's clear direction that there are pieces of this the implementation of which we will need to bargain.

1482
01:56:41.109 --> 01:56:42.789
<v Angelita Morillo>We need to let that process play out.

1483
01:56:43.670 --> 01:56:49.149
<v Angelita Morillo>We also can't stop council from acting when there's a clear reason to act.

1484
01:56:49.750 --> 01:56:57.750
<v Angelita Morillo>For those reasons and many more, I got to a place where I felt like I could strongly support an amendment to this policy.

1485
01:56:59.909 --> 01:57:08.609
<v Angelita Morillo>I, like I said, will ask some questions later to make sure our intent is I think it is important that we worked hard to get this right.

1486
01:57:10.289 --> 01:57:27.970
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think it's important that we are hearing from Portlanders who are the most affected, both about what they need to feel safe and about how we can meet those needs in a meaningful way, in a way that is implementable, in a way that actually moves us forward.

1487
01:57:29.010 --> 01:57:31.329
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that what we have before us today does that.

1488
01:57:31.329 --> 01:57:31.729
<v Dan Ryan>Councilmember Herbold.

1489
01:57:32.390 --> 01:57:48.789
<v Angelita Morillo>And I would ask for folks who have been on board from the start to be willing to take this step with Councilor Kanal and I, and folks who have not been on board to look seriously at the changes and consider joining us in moving this forward.

1490
01:57:49.430 --> 01:57:49.750
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1491
01:57:50.710 --> 01:57:51.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1492
01:57:52.310 --> 01:57:53.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan, to the amendment.

1493
01:57:54.390 --> 01:57:55.670
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Council President.

1494
01:57:56.789 --> 01:57:58.329
<v Dan Ryan>First, thank you to the heartfelt Thank you.

1495
01:57:58.409 --> 01:58:00.170
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Smith, for the testimony we heard last week.

1496
01:58:01.449 --> 01:58:04.489
<v Dan Ryan>I realize that was just a week ago, but it was compelling.

1497
01:58:05.369 --> 01:58:08.090
<v Dan Ryan>As this amendment was shared this morning, I'm trying to get current.

1498
01:58:08.569 --> 01:58:20.250
<v Dan Ryan>Can you explain in your own words, sponsors— I'm looking at your empty chair because I know you're remote, Pirtle-Guiney— what this amendment does to meet community needs at this time?

1499
01:58:24.010 --> 01:58:33.619
<v Sameer Kanal>Just clarifying the question before I respond to it, Councilor Ryan, when you say the amendment, do you mean The ordinance itself or the new change that is being proposed right now?

1500
01:58:33.779 --> 01:58:40.659
<v Dan Ryan>I think speaking to the amendment, 'cause the amendment that you approved as a friendly amendment, or you're doing it with her, is additive.

1501
01:58:40.819 --> 01:58:42.579
<v Dan Ryan>So tell me why that's so.

1502
01:58:44.340 --> 01:58:47.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I can go first if— okay, I see a nod there.

1503
01:58:47.859 --> 01:58:53.140
<v Sameer Kanal>So the first thing is we got feedback.

1504
01:58:53.699 --> 01:59:08.560
<v Sameer Kanal>I think one of the great things, it's also a challenging thing for those who've been following along with our new council relative to the council before, Is that the new form of government took effect with an expanded council at the same time that there's new public meetings law.

1505
01:59:08.880 --> 01:59:13.439
<v Sameer Kanal>So one of the frustrating things is that we do a lot more in public and that makes it slower.

1506
01:59:13.760 --> 01:59:19.039
<v Sameer Kanal>And one of the great things is we do a lot of things in public and now you get to see the sausage getting made more often.

1507
01:59:19.439 --> 01:59:25.199
<v Sameer Kanal>So there are trade-offs and finding the right balance is a state conversation that I'm sure we're all going to weigh in on more obliquely.

1508
01:59:25.359 --> 01:59:27.600
<v Sameer Kanal>But as it relates to where we are now and how this works, Thank you.

1509
01:59:28.279 --> 01:59:39.880
<v Sameer Kanal>We heard the feedback from last time that we brought this up, both from the testifiers and from colleagues who have discussed this at different levels.

1510
01:59:40.039 --> 01:59:44.199
<v Sameer Kanal>It's also come to committee, the CAPS committee originally, a couple times as well.

1511
01:59:44.840 --> 01:59:47.479
<v Sameer Kanal>So as we go through it, there was some duplicative language.

1512
01:59:47.960 --> 01:59:52.119
<v Sameer Kanal>That duplicative language had the risk of being interpreted as separate requirements.

1513
01:59:52.840 --> 01:59:53.720
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's really important.

1514
01:59:53.880 --> 01:59:58.859
<v Sameer Kanal>You can see a lot of specific sections that have been Just crossed out because of that.

1515
01:59:59.340 --> 02:00:04.140
<v Sameer Kanal>Part of that is previous amendments had erased references to sections.

1516
02:00:04.380 --> 02:00:06.859
<v Sameer Kanal>So there's a definition that has no— it never got used.

1517
02:00:07.020 --> 02:00:07.899
<v Sameer Kanal>So why do you need the definition?

1518
02:00:08.460 --> 02:00:11.420
<v Sameer Kanal>So, but part of it is just ensuring that there's no misinterpretation.

1519
02:00:12.619 --> 02:00:21.979
<v Sameer Kanal>Moving an item that was effectively a definition in a paragraph that there was no operation to it into the definition section better clarifies legislative intent.

1520
02:00:21.979 --> 02:00:22.220
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1521
02:00:23.409 --> 02:00:35.890
<v Sameer Kanal>More clarity around interpretation of what constitutes an investigation when there is reasonable suspicion, or the step that has to come before that, which is a preliminary investigation, which is officers looking into the context.

1522
02:00:36.369 --> 02:00:39.810
<v Sameer Kanal>So you can see preliminary— those words are being referenced several times here.

1523
02:00:40.529 --> 02:01:09.899
<v Sameer Kanal>And then, as you— we've talked a little bit about so far today, the documentation requirements, aligning it with how we wanted it to ensure that there is information so that the public has a right to know, which I think is the fundamental answer to your question, what does this do to benefit the community, is it ensures you have a right to know who is operating and who's claiming law enforcement authority, but also ensuring that it's operationally feasible and not creating an undue burden.

1524
02:01:10.380 --> 02:01:12.939
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's the big broad strokes of the amendment.

1525
02:01:13.899 --> 02:01:16.689
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't know if Councilor Pirtle-Guiney would like to add it.

1526
02:01:17.010 --> 02:01:17.729
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, one other thing.

1527
02:01:18.529 --> 02:01:30.770
<v Sameer Kanal>We borrowed with extreme gratitude the section adding from Councilor Novick, the section adding the right to a lawsuit to seek injunctive relief to make that explicit.

1528
02:01:31.010 --> 02:01:32.210
<v Sameer Kanal>And that is the very end of the document.

1529
02:01:33.489 --> 02:01:36.210
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to make sure that that was clear.

1530
02:01:39.649 --> 02:01:44.369
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Ryan, for the question and Councilor Kanal for taking it further.

1531
02:01:44.409 --> 02:01:48.649
<v Angelita Morillo>First, I'll pick up on that last piece that Councilor Kanal just named.

1532
02:01:48.810 --> 02:01:52.649
<v Angelita Morillo>I think the new thing here is that injunctive relief.

1533
02:01:54.569 --> 02:02:03.930
<v Angelita Morillo>But more broadly, what I have heard from community that folks want that we can do, because there's a lot that we can't do, right?

1534
02:02:04.569 --> 02:02:10.329
<v Angelita Morillo>At the end of the day, the Supremacy Clause exists and there are limitations to what we can do.

1535
02:02:11.479 --> 02:02:36.439
<v Angelita Morillo>But I have heard a real community interest in knowing what law enforcement agencies are operating in our city and in having the assurance when a law enforcement entity is operating in our city in a way in which the average person walking by can't tell if it's a law enforcement agent or not.

1536
02:02:39.449 --> 02:02:49.810
<v Angelita Morillo>Understanding who that is and having some assurance that there's a way of, of making sure that they are in fact a law enforcement officer.

1537
02:02:50.170 --> 02:02:53.369
<v Angelita Morillo>Often PPB already knows these things, but not always.

1538
02:02:53.529 --> 02:03:02.569
<v Angelita Morillo>We started this work in the Protect Portland initiative where we talked about check and verify, calling dispatch and other agencies to find out who was here.

1539
02:03:03.220 --> 02:03:15.939
<v Angelita Morillo>This takes the next step in ensuring that people know who is operating in our city, and that when somebody is operating in such a way that the average person walking by can't tell if they're a law enforcement agent or not, we look into that.

1540
02:03:16.979 --> 02:03:26.420
<v Angelita Morillo>I also have heard loud and clear that there's an interest in understanding when there are other agencies operating in Portland, which happens all the time, right?

1541
02:03:26.659 --> 02:03:36.909
<v Angelita Morillo>We share jurisdiction in our city with a number of other entities, that if they are not operating in a way that meets our state or local standards, we know that.

1542
02:03:39.550 --> 02:03:46.109
<v Angelita Morillo>And we start to build an understanding of where we have folks operating in our city under different standards.

1543
02:03:46.430 --> 02:03:51.390
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's some of the reporting requirements are to help build that understanding.

1544
02:03:52.909 --> 02:03:58.109
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to be really clear that there is a lot that community has asked for that I don't think we can legally do.

1545
02:03:59.000 --> 02:04:22.840
<v Angelita Morillo>But I do think that on those 3 things, knowing who's here, knowing who it is if the average person can't tell, building that understanding of who might be operating regularly in our city to different standards, and then having that injunctive relief, those are things I think we can do that this measure clearly lays out a path for— for this amendment, I should say.

1546
02:04:22.920 --> 02:04:23.880
<v Loretta Smith>Councilmember Herbold?

1547
02:04:24.289 --> 02:04:27.569
<v Dan Ryan>A follow-up then would be to get to the practical effects of your amendment.

1548
02:04:28.050 --> 02:04:34.689
<v Dan Ryan>Can you give us a real-world scenario of a Portland Police Bureau officer encountering a masked ICE agent?

1549
02:04:35.649 --> 02:04:39.409
<v Dan Ryan>What would the PPB officer do under this policy?

1550
02:04:43.250 --> 02:04:50.449
<v Sameer Kanal>So let me start by saying, uh, and, and I'm gonna— this is gonna sound like it's, uh, not relevant at first, but it is.

1551
02:04:50.770 --> 02:04:58.180
<v Sameer Kanal>Earlier in this meeting, uh, Council President mentioned that when we are virtual, we have to have our camera on, right?

1552
02:04:58.979 --> 02:05:09.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and the reason for that is on Zoom you can see a name, but I could change my name right now in Zoom on here, and without the ability to know our face, we don't actually know who this person is.

1553
02:05:11.060 --> 02:05:11.939
<v Sameer Kanal>We have to look into it.

1554
02:05:12.020 --> 02:05:20.899
<v Sameer Kanal>If you're familiar with the, uh, Schrödinger's cat, um, thought experiment, um, the idea that you don't know the condition of an entity until you look at it is the That's correct.

1555
02:05:20.899 --> 02:05:22.420
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the sort of colloquial oversimplification.

1556
02:05:24.100 --> 02:05:30.979
<v Sameer Kanal>So at the time that a Portland police officer encounters the individual in question, they don't know whether or not that person is an ICE agent or not.

1557
02:05:31.140 --> 02:05:32.579
<v Sameer Kanal>They don't know if that person's MCSO.

1558
02:05:32.579 --> 02:05:36.180
<v Sameer Kanal>They don't know if it's another Portland police officer in this hypothetical context, right?

1559
02:05:36.659 --> 02:05:40.020
<v Sameer Kanal>They are seeing a person who is wearing a mask.

1560
02:05:40.659 --> 02:05:48.189
<v Sameer Kanal>Now, if that person is not claiming law enforcement authority, then there's no reason— it doesn't involve the scope at all.

1561
02:05:48.750 --> 02:06:01.789
<v Sameer Kanal>If they are claiming law enforcement authority and doing something that they would need that authority to do, for example, putting a different person zip-tied into the back of a vehicle, that is where the scope would potentially come into play.

1562
02:06:02.670 --> 02:06:06.909
<v Sameer Kanal>The first thing would be to look and see, is there, you know, visible authority?

1563
02:06:07.310 --> 02:06:16.569
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's the language that we were talking about earlier with Councilor Novick's question About, um, uh, lacking immediate proof of authority.

1564
02:06:17.130 --> 02:06:22.250
<v Sameer Kanal>So only if all of that is, is applicable does the Portland police officer actually have to do anything.

1565
02:06:23.529 --> 02:06:24.329
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, let's start with that.

1566
02:06:25.130 --> 02:06:29.449
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the second thing is they have to do a preliminary investigation.

1567
02:06:29.770 --> 02:06:45.210
<v Sameer Kanal>And now I'm, I'm moving from Section A— this is 23-3050A, bottom of page 6— moving into Part B at the beginning of page At that point, the obligatory actions are to notify— the PPB officer would notify their supervisor.

1568
02:06:46.329 --> 02:06:49.930
<v Sameer Kanal>They would also contact possible agencies or dispatch centers.

1569
02:06:50.250 --> 02:06:58.090
<v Sameer Kanal>This would be calling somebody in potential agencies that this person might work for if in fact they are law enforcement, right?

1570
02:06:58.810 --> 02:07:01.289
<v Sameer Kanal>Potential imposter may be law enforcement, may not be.

1571
02:07:02.569 --> 02:07:05.130
<v Sameer Kanal>And then they have other things that they can look for.

1572
02:07:06.390 --> 02:07:07.189
<v Sameer Kanal>But all that is optional.

1573
02:07:07.430 --> 02:07:13.750
<v Sameer Kanal>The only required activity is what I just said, the notifying the supervisor, um, and calling the dispatch centers.

1574
02:07:14.630 --> 02:07:23.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, the other things then, uh, only in the event of— after assessing the totality of the circumstances, and I believe this is called Terry, right?

1575
02:07:24.229 --> 02:07:29.590
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm seeing, uh, the, the rules about reasonable suspicion is the— it's case law, um, at the— on the federal level.

1576
02:07:29.989 --> 02:07:30.890
<v Sameer Kanal>If there's reasonable Yes.

1577
02:07:30.890 --> 02:07:44.569
<v Sameer Kanal>If there is reasonable suspicion that a crime is being committed, is about to be being committed, or was just committed, then the officer can continue on into the next stage, which is now getting into Part C. And that's the federal standard.

1578
02:07:44.729 --> 02:07:47.449
<v Sameer Kanal>We didn't touch that, of what constitutes reasonable suspicion.

1579
02:07:48.250 --> 02:07:52.250
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's where the reasonable suspicion is that the person may be an imposter.

1580
02:07:52.890 --> 02:08:13.590
<v Sameer Kanal>But if at any point we're seeing that a Portland police officer is finding some information to dispel the notion of reasonable suspicion, including but not limited to this person has a badge in their pocket that they show them, including that they called the FBI and the FBI said, yeah, we got people at this, at this, uh, in this neighborhood.

1581
02:08:14.550 --> 02:08:24.390
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, all of those types of things are among the ways that, that the notion that they may be an imposter can be dispelled, but they're not the only ones.

1582
02:08:26.109 --> 02:08:29.229
<v Sameer Kanal>That, and that effectively concludes the interaction.

1583
02:08:30.670 --> 02:08:35.869
<v Sameer Kanal>And then there is one follow-up requirement, which is the incident report.

1584
02:08:36.270 --> 02:08:39.069
<v Sameer Kanal>And now we're switching to page 8, 233060.

1585
02:08:40.909 --> 02:08:50.670
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's all the parts that we were talking about in terms of the— that Councilor Zimmerman was asking about earlier with written reports, body cams, if applicable.

1586
02:08:50.779 --> 02:08:53.340
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's a lot of put the information you have in.

1587
02:08:53.420 --> 02:08:59.420
<v Sameer Kanal>And I believe we just added a section to that particular requirement with Novick 2 as well.

1588
02:08:59.500 --> 02:09:08.939
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's— I think that's— without getting into even more detail, I think that's the response to your question.

1589
02:09:09.020 --> 02:09:24.470
<v Sameer Kanal>Now, in the event, of course, that we know that this person, that the police officer is aware that this person is a law enforcement official at any level, Council President, can I jump in here as well?

1590
02:09:24.630 --> 02:09:24.710
<v Mitch Green>Absolutely.

1591
02:09:26.390 --> 02:09:28.710
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that last piece is really important.

1592
02:09:28.869 --> 02:09:40.149
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Ryan, you asked the question, if a Portland police officer is called out because an ICE agent is taking action in Portland, what are they required to do?

1593
02:09:40.310 --> 02:09:59.399
<v Angelita Morillo>And the reality is, if a Portland Police Bureau officer is called out to assist ICE agents, The Portland police officer knows that the individual taking an action is an ICE agent and that, that level of proof has been met, they disengage.

1594
02:10:00.359 --> 02:10:10.119
<v Angelita Morillo>They don't continue through the process that Councilor Kanal has just described because the preliminary investigation to find out who they are is not required.

1595
02:10:10.119 --> 02:10:10.359
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1596
02:10:12.010 --> 02:10:21.529
<v Angelita Morillo>The proof or the reasonable suspicion would not be there because we know who they are and why they're operating in our city.

1597
02:10:23.210 --> 02:10:27.609
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's a really important point when we talk about what the limitations are in what we can do.

1598
02:10:28.329 --> 02:10:35.890
<v Angelita Morillo>And it's also a really important point in thinking about the legality of the measure.

1599
02:10:38.920 --> 02:10:49.399
<v Angelita Morillo>Those pieces of this amendment, and if it's adopted, the underlying are about what we do when we don't know who somebody is who's operating in our city.

1600
02:10:59.000 --> 02:10:59.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan?

1601
02:10:59.960 --> 02:11:00.199
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1602
02:11:00.600 --> 02:11:02.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you very much.

1603
02:11:02.810 --> 02:11:04.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1604
02:11:04.970 --> 02:11:05.689
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1605
02:11:06.970 --> 02:11:11.770
<v Steve Novick>I'd like to take a shot at answering, giving answers to a couple of Councilor Ryan's questions too.

1606
02:11:12.090 --> 02:11:18.489
<v Steve Novick>One is I just wanted to say, Councilor Ryan, that a few days ago I was looking at a draft of this document and I was very confused.

1607
02:11:18.569 --> 02:11:25.689
<v Steve Novick>And I told Councilor Kanal, I'm in various ways, I'm not sure if I were a Portland police officer whether I'd know what to do under this thing.

1608
02:11:26.329 --> 02:11:30.649
<v Steve Novick>So actually a lot of the modifications we've made over the last few days were addressed towards precisely that point.

1609
02:11:31.479 --> 02:11:34.439
<v Steve Novick>And personally, I had a version of this.

1610
02:11:34.600 --> 02:11:42.680
<v Steve Novick>My Novick 7 basically just said PPV officers shall make reasonable efforts to determine whether the person is in fact a law enforcement officer acting under lawful authority.

1611
02:11:42.760 --> 02:11:49.319
<v Steve Novick>I thought that would have been good enough, but I felt that we were able to move close enough to that that I'm comfortable with this.

1612
02:11:49.479 --> 02:12:01.220
<v Steve Novick>And my interpretation of your question of you— the police show up and somebody's wearing a mask, I think even if they're wearing a mask, if they're wearing a unique identifier, name tag, and a badge, That I think that is still proof of authority.

1613
02:12:01.539 --> 02:12:02.819
<v Steve Novick>That's the way I'm reading it.

1614
02:12:04.899 --> 02:12:12.979
<v Steve Novick>Another thing I wanted to say, though, is in response to the question, you know, what are we— what community demands is this responding to?

1615
02:12:13.699 --> 02:12:23.539
<v Steve Novick>I would say, and I think I have an obligation as the only lawyer on this council to say this, we are trying to respond to the community demand that people know who's policing them.

1616
02:12:24.579 --> 02:12:49.340
<v Steve Novick>I have to say that I think it is It's likely that we will fail because the Ninth Circuit panel that ruled on the California masking— not masking, identification requirement a few weeks ago said basically that the state cannot override the federal government's power to determine whether, how, and when to publicly identify its officers.

1617
02:12:49.579 --> 02:12:53.659
<v Steve Novick>Now, that was a preliminary ruling in the context of a preliminary investigation.

1618
02:12:53.859 --> 02:12:59.060
<v Steve Novick>I mean, a preliminary injunction, so technically it's preliminary, but the language is decisive.

1619
02:13:00.420 --> 02:13:07.460
<v Steve Novick>And that panel is never going to say that the law we're proposing here is legal.

1620
02:13:08.180 --> 02:13:24.460
<v Steve Novick>Now, it is conceivable that the full Ninth Circuit, if that ruling or another ruling was appealed to the full Ninth Circuit, would reverse that decision, or that the Supreme Court might reverse It is conceivable.

1621
02:13:25.020 --> 02:13:35.020
<v Steve Novick>The fact, however, that it was a unanimous bipartisan panel, including an Obama appointee, makes it, in my view, very unlikely that the decision will be overturned.

1622
02:13:36.300 --> 02:13:44.460
<v Steve Novick>I actually asked the ACLU the other day, do we have any examples of a unanimous bipartisan decision on a hot potato issue like this being overturned?

1623
02:13:44.539 --> 02:13:46.220
<v Steve Novick>And they— and I don't have an answer yet.

1624
02:13:46.300 --> 02:13:47.180
<v Steve Novick>I think this is a long shot.

1625
02:13:47.420 --> 02:13:48.619
<v Steve Novick>I think it's a long shot.

1626
02:13:48.960 --> 02:13:52.079
<v Steve Novick>I think it's an important enough issue to the community that's worth taking the long shot.

1627
02:13:52.880 --> 02:14:05.359
<v Steve Novick>As I said last time, I'm a sports fan, and the Mets did come back in the bottom of the 10th in 1986, and the Lakers came back with 30 seconds left being down 6 with Houston having the ball just a couple of weeks ago.

1628
02:14:06.000 --> 02:14:09.920
<v Steve Novick>So miracles do happen, but I do think we need to be straight with the community.

1629
02:14:10.079 --> 02:14:10.479
<v Steve Novick>It's unlikely.

1630
02:14:12.000 --> 02:14:12.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1631
02:14:13.920 --> 02:14:14.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1632
02:14:16.420 --> 02:14:26.420
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I just wanted to start by adding that the version that for the public is the one online, that that is now the public version as well.

1633
02:14:28.180 --> 02:14:35.699
<v Sameer Kanal>The second thing I wanted to do is just ask Councilor Novick, we could probably use the Portland Fire example from last night if we're looking for comebacks.

1634
02:14:36.340 --> 02:14:39.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Buzzer beater there for those who weren't taking note.

1635
02:14:40.979 --> 02:15:03.939
<v Sameer Kanal>And the third thing I just wanted to say is, well, I guess I can hold off on the points unless there's specific questions, but I think Councilor Novick's point about trying to respond and Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's point about trying to meet the need within the context of the law is really the starting point of this whole thing.

1636
02:15:04.739 --> 02:15:08.260
<v Sameer Kanal>And the right to know is, I mean, that's why it's the name of it.

1637
02:15:08.260 --> 02:15:09.460
<v Sameer Kanal>It's the core concept here.

1638
02:15:11.460 --> 02:15:12.500
<v Sameer Kanal>So I appreciate that.

1639
02:15:12.979 --> 02:15:23.699
<v Sameer Kanal>I will ask if anyone wants to get in the queue to do so, 'cause I'll move to just on the amendment to limit debate to the current queue and anyone who wants to get in, get in.

1640
02:15:23.699 --> 02:15:23.939
<v Sameer Kanal>But yeah.

1641
02:15:25.140 --> 02:15:26.020
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1642
02:15:27.060 --> 02:15:28.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith, to the amendment.

1643
02:15:30.420 --> 02:15:35.899
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, I wanted to comment on Councilor Novick's Comments.

1644
02:15:36.939 --> 02:15:41.260
<v Loretta Smith>If you think it's going to be not going to be overturned, then why do it?

1645
02:15:43.500 --> 02:15:44.939
<v Steve Novick>Because it's a one in a million chance.

1646
02:15:45.819 --> 02:15:46.539
<v Steve Novick>That's really the reason.

1647
02:15:47.500 --> 02:15:51.020
<v Steve Novick>And I don't see any reason not to take, to take the one in a million chance.

1648
02:15:52.300 --> 02:15:57.739
<v Loretta Smith>Well, I'm going to be looking to our legal counsel to see if it is constitutional for us to do this.

1649
02:15:58.779 --> 02:16:18.079
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, I, I don't think we do one in a million chances We took an oath and we have to follow the Constitution, the U.S. Constitution and the Oregon Constitution, and I don't think it's fair or right to mislead people to thinking that this is going to do more than what it actually does.

1650
02:16:22.159 --> 02:16:22.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1651
02:16:23.520 --> 02:16:25.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark, to the amendment.

1652
02:16:26.000 --> 02:16:31.789
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm not sure— Councilor Smith, are you asking for our legal department to come up and address that?

1653
02:16:32.590 --> 02:16:34.670
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, I, I don't see— is Robert here?

1654
02:16:39.629 --> 02:16:42.389
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, you're hiding from me.

1655
02:16:42.670 --> 02:16:44.190
<v Loretta Smith>They've been doing that all day today.

1656
02:16:50.510 --> 02:16:51.950
<v Mitch Green>Uh, Robert Taylor, City Attorney.

1657
02:16:52.110 --> 02:16:54.110
<v Mitch Green>For the record, I was not hiding.

1658
02:16:54.430 --> 02:17:00.809
<v Loretta Smith>I was picking up my papers We're hiding nothing in the City of Portland.

1659
02:17:00.889 --> 02:17:01.370
<v Loretta Smith>We never do.

1660
02:17:01.610 --> 02:17:02.250
<v Mitch Green>We never do that.

1661
02:17:02.409 --> 02:17:03.049
<v Mitch Green>We never do that.

1662
02:17:03.450 --> 02:17:05.610
<v Mitch Green>Um, thank you for the question.

1663
02:17:06.489 --> 02:17:10.569
<v Mitch Green>I think by and large I agree with Councilor Novick.

1664
02:17:11.610 --> 02:17:23.069
<v Mitch Green>Uh, the decision— and this council as a local government, we are in a very difficult situation right now because we have a state law that That's correct.

1665
02:17:23.069 --> 02:17:32.430
<v Mitch Green>That, on the face of the state law, has requirements for masking and identification requirements for federal, state, and local law enforcement.

1666
02:17:33.149 --> 02:17:34.989
<v Mitch Green>We are trying to comply with that state law.

1667
02:17:36.590 --> 02:17:39.629
<v Mitch Green>I believe this ordinance complies with that state law.

1668
02:17:40.510 --> 02:17:43.309
<v Mitch Green>There has also recently been this Ninth Circuit decision.

1669
02:17:45.389 --> 02:17:53.420
<v Mitch Green>That Ninth Circuit decision, it is a Published panel decision of the 9th Circuit.

1670
02:17:54.700 --> 02:17:56.659
<v Mitch Green>It's on a preliminary injunction.

1671
02:17:57.180 --> 02:18:05.979
<v Mitch Green>The rule of law in the 9th Circuit is that a published panel decision on an injunction is binding on other panels of the 9th Circuit and lower courts in the 9th Circuit.

1672
02:18:06.620 --> 02:18:15.489
<v Mitch Green>So that decision is binding on us, and that decision said states and cities cannot directly regulate There it is.

1673
02:18:16.690 --> 02:18:21.649
<v Mitch Green>Masking for federal law enforcement or identification requirements for federal law enforcement.

1674
02:18:22.850 --> 02:18:28.930
<v Mitch Green>So the law today is it is unconstitutional for state or local governments to try to directly regulate.

1675
02:18:30.770 --> 02:18:31.170
<v Angelita Morillo>There it is.

1676
02:18:31.649 --> 02:18:33.969
<v Mitch Green>Our state law tells us to do that.

1677
02:18:34.530 --> 02:18:56.889
<v Mitch Green>And so I think that is the position we are in today, is trying to thread that needle, comply with the state law, Do the regulations, the ordinance or the code would allow us to file a suit to try to enforce this against the federal government, and we can make our legal arguments in that litigation.

1678
02:18:59.930 --> 02:19:06.329
<v Mitch Green>And there's, as Councilor Novick gave you the odds on the success of that, and I think he's probably right about that.

1679
02:19:06.329 --> 02:19:07.610
<v Mitch Green>I think it's 50/50.

1680
02:19:08.649 --> 02:19:23.209
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate his honesty on that and telling folks, but you just said something that is a— I don't cross that line.

1681
02:19:23.209 --> 02:19:32.969
<v Loretta Smith>If you're saying that this is unconstitutional, that that decision is binding, and that what we're doing here is not legal, really what you're saying.

1682
02:19:32.969 --> 02:19:33.530
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not saying that.

1683
02:19:34.000 --> 02:19:34.239
<v Loretta Smith>To us.

1684
02:19:34.479 --> 02:19:35.920
<v Loretta Smith>We're in— we would be in violation.

1685
02:19:37.520 --> 02:19:39.040
<v Loretta Smith>And so why are we doing this?

1686
02:19:39.120 --> 02:19:47.280
<v Loretta Smith>And, and, and how were the makers of, of, of these amendments able to bring them forward if they are unconstitutional?

1687
02:19:47.360 --> 02:19:48.959
<v Loretta Smith>Because they have to go through legal counsel.

1688
02:19:49.280 --> 02:19:50.719
<v Loretta Smith>I don't get what's going on here.

1689
02:19:52.799 --> 02:19:53.840
<v Mitch Green>I, I appreciate that.

1690
02:19:54.319 --> 02:20:10.040
<v Mitch Green>And, uh, and we have advised on the risks of this, and, and we have advised on the The difficult situation the city is in with trying to comply both with state law and now this recent 9th Circuit decision.

1691
02:20:11.000 --> 02:20:15.719
<v Mitch Green>That is, we are in complex legal times that are changing rapidly.

1692
02:20:16.760 --> 02:20:16.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

1693
02:20:17.079 --> 02:20:21.799
<v Mitch Green>And we are now kind of in the difficult situation posed by that.

1694
02:20:22.520 --> 02:20:23.959
<v Loretta Smith>And I, yeah, I hear you.

1695
02:20:24.200 --> 02:20:37.020
<v Loretta Smith>And I could see a scenario where if it changes and that $1 million of a time, then we come back and do these amendments in, in our version of what the mass law should be.

1696
02:20:37.659 --> 02:20:40.860
<v Loretta Smith>But at this point, I am totally satisfied with the state law.

1697
02:20:41.500 --> 02:20:42.379
<v Loretta Smith>I am not happy.

1698
02:20:42.700 --> 02:20:52.379
<v Loretta Smith>I am not— I'm troubled by, by colleagues who are trying to force me to do something that's unconstitutional, and, and they know it.

1699
02:20:52.940 --> 02:21:00.209
<v Loretta Smith>And, and the makers are saying that this is a A, a, a, a one in a million chance of, of it holding up.

1700
02:21:00.930 --> 02:21:15.250
<v Loretta Smith>So for me, I think as, as legal counsel for all of us, for me, y'all tell me I can't have a, a software program in our firm or than, than what you're being with us right now with this mask ordinance.

1701
02:21:16.209 --> 02:21:17.809
<v Loretta Smith>Say no, you can't do that, Councilor.

1702
02:21:17.889 --> 02:21:20.370
<v Loretta Smith>That's— Okay.

1703
02:21:21.459 --> 02:21:22.180
<v Loretta Smith>I can't do it.

1704
02:21:23.540 --> 02:21:26.420
<v Loretta Smith>But I think we are tiptoeing around here.

1705
02:21:27.299 --> 02:21:30.500
<v Loretta Smith>We have something here in Oregon that a lot of folks don't have.

1706
02:21:31.780 --> 02:21:32.260
<v Loretta Smith>That's good.

1707
02:21:32.579 --> 02:21:33.860
<v Loretta Smith>Let's see what it looks like.

1708
02:21:34.020 --> 02:21:41.459
<v Loretta Smith>Let's see how we can help, because I don't want people to get a false sense that Portland Police can go around taking off masks of folks.

1709
02:21:43.219 --> 02:21:44.020
<v Loretta Smith>Let's put it like this.

1710
02:21:44.340 --> 02:21:44.979
<v Loretta Smith>I worked for a U.S.

1711
02:21:45.139 --> 02:21:46.739
<v Loretta Smith>Senator, Ron Wyden, for 21 years.

1712
02:21:47.500 --> 02:21:49.579
<v Loretta Smith>He sits on the Finance Committee as the chairman.

1713
02:21:51.260 --> 02:21:54.940
<v Loretta Smith>Immigration and ICE never listen to him, and he has authority over them.

1714
02:21:55.659 --> 02:22:01.100
<v Loretta Smith>What the heck are they going to do with this, this ordinance that, that we're putting through?

1715
02:22:01.579 --> 02:22:05.819
<v Loretta Smith>They're not going to listen to us, and they know they don't have to listen to us.

1716
02:22:05.979 --> 02:22:07.979
<v Loretta Smith>This is performative at this point.

1717
02:22:10.139 --> 02:22:11.100
<v Sameer Kanal>Just a quick point of order.

1718
02:22:11.899 --> 02:22:17.049
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, the, uh, The quote was that the makers are saying that this is unconstitutional.

1719
02:22:17.209 --> 02:22:18.409
<v Sameer Kanal>That is not accurate at all.

1720
02:22:18.649 --> 02:22:19.290
<v Loretta Smith>Not the makers.

1721
02:22:19.690 --> 02:22:20.889
<v Loretta Smith>Well, the makers are saying that—.

1722
02:22:20.969 --> 02:22:21.530
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the exact quote.

1723
02:22:21.690 --> 02:22:23.049
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to note that.

1724
02:22:23.209 --> 02:22:23.290
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1725
02:22:23.850 --> 02:22:27.690
<v Loretta Smith>The makers are saying that it is a one in a million chance that this is going to stick.

1726
02:22:27.850 --> 02:22:28.409
<v Sameer Kanal>No, they're not.

1727
02:22:29.209 --> 02:22:29.290
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1728
02:22:29.530 --> 02:22:30.649
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Novick says that.

1729
02:22:30.729 --> 02:22:33.290
<v Loretta Smith>I meant— that's who I was talking about, Councilor Novick.

1730
02:22:34.329 --> 02:22:39.620
<v Loretta Smith>So you have to decide on the underlying what to do, but I think you need to set a a line in the sand.

1731
02:22:39.940 --> 02:22:50.579
<v Loretta Smith>Um, City Attorney Taylor, you need to tell us what to do and what not to do, because for us to sit here and waste this kind of time—.

1732
02:22:51.059 --> 02:22:52.940
<v Angelita Morillo>This is a first for Loretta.

1733
02:22:55.540 --> 02:22:56.420
<v Loretta Smith>I'm with him when he right.

1734
02:23:03.139 --> 02:23:04.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, thank you, Councilor Mr.

1735
02:23:04.280 --> 02:23:07.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>Chair, colleagues, we are half an hour past where we're supposed to be at this point.

1736
02:23:07.959 --> 02:23:11.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have 2 more items after this and we are to the amendment.

1737
02:23:11.479 --> 02:23:17.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>And also, Councilor Kanal had moved to limit debate to those who were in the queue.

1738
02:23:19.399 --> 02:23:22.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe Councilor Pirtle-Guiney was the last in the queue at that moment.

1739
02:23:22.360 --> 02:23:22.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>I had taken that.

1740
02:23:23.000 --> 02:23:28.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then when we were done with this, we were gonna take a break 'cause I was hoping to give us a bio break at 4 o'clock and it's now 4:20.

1741
02:23:28.520 --> 02:23:29.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Vice President Clark.

1742
02:23:30.190 --> 02:23:31.069
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1743
02:23:31.309 --> 02:23:33.309
<v Angelita Morillo>I'll be very brief as usual.

1744
02:23:34.350 --> 02:23:47.229
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I feel like I'm at a very distinct disadvantage because I just got this amendment today, um, and I'm rushing and struggling to, uh, integrate it all.

1745
02:23:47.709 --> 02:24:07.239
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, and I just want to say that I really appreciate that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney is trying to respond to a call, but I don't think it's I guess I agree with Councilor Smith that I think we're creating false hopes among the community, that we're raising expectations that we won't be able to meet.

1746
02:24:08.600 --> 02:24:11.559
<v Angelita Morillo>And, um, that concerns me.

1747
02:24:11.799 --> 02:24:18.440
<v Angelita Morillo>And I appreciate your opinion, Robert Taylor, about this and the unconstitutionality of it.

1748
02:24:19.159 --> 02:24:28.690
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think that we are, uh, I don't think that it keeps Portlanders any safer, and there's not much we can do, and I think we are raising false hopes.

1749
02:24:30.209 --> 02:24:38.370
<v Angelita Morillo>But I appreciate the sincere attempt on the part of the drafters to meet those hopes, but I don't think we can.

1750
02:24:39.889 --> 02:24:41.409
<v Angelita Morillo>Just leave it at that.

1751
02:24:41.649 --> 02:24:42.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1752
02:24:42.850 --> 02:24:43.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1753
02:24:45.649 --> 02:24:46.370
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

1754
02:24:46.770 --> 02:24:48.290
<v Angelita Morillo>Is Robert Taylor still up there by chance?

1755
02:24:48.219 --> 02:24:48.780
<v Angelita Morillo>He is.

1756
02:24:50.379 --> 02:24:56.940
<v Angelita Morillo>Mr. Taylor, is there anything unconstitutional about the verification portions of this measure?

1757
02:25:00.299 --> 02:25:20.629
<v Mitch Green>Oh, that's a great question, and I should also note that if a court holds that the regulations in this code directed at Federal law enforcement are unconstitutional, then there's a severability provision.

1758
02:25:20.950 --> 02:25:21.590
<v Mitch Green>They would be severed.

1759
02:25:22.870 --> 02:25:26.950
<v Mitch Green>Those would not go into effect, but the remainder of it would go into effect.

1760
02:25:27.510 --> 02:25:28.950
<v Mitch Green>So I think that's an important point.

1761
02:25:29.909 --> 02:25:50.190
<v Mitch Green>To get to your question, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, I view the code as currently written as It's hewing very close to what the existing law is and what the existing process would be.

1762
02:25:51.309 --> 02:26:03.950
<v Mitch Green>And I do think it's important to note, and for the record, and if we ever end up getting in litigation, what that verification is getting at now is a very important government interest.

1763
02:26:05.389 --> 02:26:06.670
<v Steve Novick>And it's twofold.

1764
02:26:07.469 --> 02:26:14.190
<v Mitch Green>The first government interest is it is illegal to impersonate a police officer, a local police officer or a federal police officer.

1765
02:26:16.590 --> 02:26:19.790
<v Mitch Green>So we have a government interest in trying to enforce those criminal laws.

1766
02:26:20.989 --> 02:26:36.829
<v Mitch Green>Secondly, and this word has been talked about before, but this concept of deconfliction, where we have our local officers, we do not want them to come in conflict with other law enforcement who are engaged in legitimate law enforcement activities.

1767
02:26:38.579 --> 02:27:01.780
<v Mitch Green>And so both to enforce the laws against impersonation and to ensure deconfliction, this code now provides for if an office— if a PPB officer shows up and there is indicia of authority, then no action is required.

1768
02:27:02.260 --> 02:27:02.500
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1769
02:27:02.870 --> 02:27:06.389
<v Mitch Green>You can do, can do a preliminary investigation if that's not clear.

1770
02:27:06.549 --> 02:27:11.229
<v Mitch Green>Preliminary investigation is calling dispatch, for example.

1771
02:27:11.989 --> 02:27:21.590
<v Mitch Green>And you can only move to actually detain a federal law enforcement or do anything like that if you have reasonable suspicion that a crime is being committed.

1772
02:27:21.590 --> 02:27:23.989
<v Mitch Green>And that's the constitutional standard anyway.

1773
02:27:24.149 --> 02:27:27.750
<v Mitch Green>And I think all of those steps that I have outlined are things we would do now.

1774
02:27:27.829 --> 02:27:28.069
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1775
02:27:28.879 --> 02:27:37.440
<v Mitch Green>If we thought that person looks like they're impersonating a police officer and doing something illegal, we would try to verify their authority.

1776
02:27:37.760 --> 02:27:38.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>We would call dispatch.

1777
02:27:39.360 --> 02:27:41.920
<v Mitch Green>We would investigate until we thought there was a crime.

1778
02:27:42.319 --> 02:27:50.959
<v Mitch Green>So, so on the verification part of this, how it is crafted now today, I would be comfortable defending that portion of it.

1779
02:27:53.600 --> 02:28:04.860
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think the point that I want to make, and I hear you that some of this is what we would do now, and I think I think in many cases it is what happens now, and we want to make sure we capture the exceptions to that.

1780
02:28:05.899 --> 02:28:13.979
<v Angelita Morillo>The point that I want to make sure that we can make is that this will be challenged.

1781
02:28:14.059 --> 02:28:16.860
<v Angelita Morillo>There are pieces of this that may be deemed unconstitutional.

1782
02:28:18.059 --> 02:28:23.180
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Novick thinks it's a one in a million chance that it won't be, I think was what you said.

1783
02:28:23.979 --> 02:28:24.459
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1784
02:28:24.829 --> 02:28:49.149
<v Angelita Morillo>But even if the way that 2330.030 and are applied to federal agents or other law enforcement agents of agencies that, um, are of a higher authority than our fine city, with that severability clause, other things that we're doing would be able to move forward.

1785
02:28:49.469 --> 02:28:55.379
<v Angelita Morillo>And I, I just think that's a really Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1786
02:28:58.260 --> 02:29:03.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please move to a roll call vote on Kanal-Pirtle-Guiney 1?

1787
02:29:09.540 --> 02:29:09.780
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

1788
02:29:10.659 --> 02:29:10.739
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1789
02:29:11.940 --> 02:29:12.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

1790
02:29:13.620 --> 02:29:13.700
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1791
02:29:14.500 --> 02:29:14.579
<v Eric Zimmerman>Ryan?

1792
02:29:15.139 --> 02:29:15.219
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1793
02:29:16.260 --> 02:29:16.500
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Smith?

1794
02:29:16.989 --> 02:29:17.069
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1795
02:29:19.469 --> 02:29:19.549
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1796
02:29:20.829 --> 02:29:20.909
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1797
02:29:23.309 --> 02:29:28.670
<v Angelita Morillo>I believe we should adopt the state law, watch its implementation, and come back and change it at a later date.

1798
02:29:28.909 --> 02:29:29.309
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm a no.

1799
02:29:31.389 --> 02:29:31.469
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1800
02:29:33.069 --> 02:29:33.149
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1801
02:29:34.110 --> 02:29:35.110
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1802
02:29:43.719 --> 02:29:44.840
<v Loretta Smith>Ask the question again.

1803
02:29:46.760 --> 02:29:48.319
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's on this.

1804
02:29:51.959 --> 02:29:52.760
<v Loretta Smith>No, no, no, no.

1805
02:29:54.680 --> 02:29:58.360
<v Unidentified speaker>That's a nay to Canal Pirtle Guinea 1 from Smith.

1806
02:29:59.959 --> 02:30:00.840
<v Loretta Smith>I believe that's a no.

1807
02:30:01.000 --> 02:30:01.079
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1808
02:30:01.319 --> 02:30:01.559
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1809
02:30:01.559 --> 02:30:01.639
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1810
02:30:02.040 --> 02:30:02.280
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1811
02:30:04.520 --> 02:30:04.840
<v Angelita Morillo>Dunphy.

1812
02:30:05.159 --> 02:30:05.239
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1813
02:30:07.719 --> 02:30:10.040
<v Unidentified speaker>And the amendment is approved as amended.

1814
02:30:11.000 --> 02:30:13.079
<v Unidentified speaker>With 8 aye and 4 nay votes.

1815
02:30:13.719 --> 02:30:18.040
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, I'm going to give us a restroom break.

1816
02:30:18.920 --> 02:30:22.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please come back in— let's call it 10 minutes— 4:35.

1817
02:44:06.049 --> 02:44:08.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, welcome back, folks.

1818
02:44:09.090 --> 02:44:11.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are now in councilor discussion of this item.

1819
02:44:12.290 --> 02:44:16.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Zimmerman, you are first in the queue for questions.

1820
02:44:18.299 --> 02:44:18.940
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thanks.

1821
02:44:20.940 --> 02:44:29.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have several, and I'll just say, Mr. President, I think that this may be one of the more consequential, so I frankly don't care about the arts tax compared to this topic.

1822
02:44:29.260 --> 02:44:30.299
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if we have to go late, we should.

1823
02:44:31.020 --> 02:44:37.500
<v Eric Zimmerman>So with respect to— that was a great discussion, frankly, on just the way that the different aspects of this are.

1824
02:44:39.579 --> 02:44:43.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm slowing down, frankly, 'cause we have barely anybody on this dais right now.

1825
02:44:48.639 --> 02:44:49.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think I'm actually going to hold.

1826
02:44:50.000 --> 02:44:56.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'd like to have this conversation with people who are present, so I'm going to pause for a second.

1827
02:44:56.559 --> 02:44:56.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1828
02:44:57.600 --> 02:44:58.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1829
02:45:01.200 --> 02:45:04.799
<v Angelita Morillo>Gosh, I can't see who's there and who's not there, and now I'm a little bit concerned.

1830
02:45:06.799 --> 02:45:18.180
<v Angelita Morillo>I have a couple of questions, and I am guessing I'm guessing, given the time they spent with us this morning, that we don't have anybody from PPB or the Public Safety Service Area in the room.

1831
02:45:18.260 --> 02:45:18.819
<v Angelita Morillo>Is that correct?

1832
02:45:22.180 --> 02:45:24.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>It— oh, we do have— we have at least one person here.

1833
02:45:25.219 --> 02:45:26.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, Director Elizabeth.

1834
02:45:26.739 --> 02:45:29.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, Director of, uh, BOEC.

1835
02:45:30.500 --> 02:45:31.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>Enterprise Services.

1836
02:45:31.860 --> 02:45:33.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>There we go, 2 for one.

1837
02:45:34.979 --> 02:45:57.229
<v Angelita Morillo>Evolving test, uh, I have a couple of questions that maybe Director Perez can answer and maybe Robert Taylor can answer, and maybe I'll just assert what I have heard if neither of them can answer, because I do think it's really important that we're clear about what this does and doesn't do so that Portlanders know what to expect.

1838
02:45:59.229 --> 02:46:19.129
<v Angelita Morillo>So my first question is, if this ordinance passes, are there any circumstances where a PPV officer would be directed to or even allowed to compel a non-cooperative federal agent to remove a face mask or a covering of some sort?

1839
02:46:19.850 --> 02:46:27.690
<v Angelita Morillo>And what authority within this code change would compel them to do that in a way that is different from today?

1840
02:46:27.700 --> 02:46:30.899
<v Unidentified speaker>Sounds a bit like a legal question.

1841
02:46:31.379 --> 02:46:32.020
<v Mitch Green>Uh, good question.

1842
02:46:32.420 --> 02:46:33.700
<v Mitch Green>Robert Taylor, City Attorney.

1843
02:46:33.780 --> 02:46:37.620
<v Mitch Green>If I'm understanding the question, I think the answer is, is no.

1844
02:46:38.340 --> 02:46:49.379
<v Mitch Green>Our officers would not be compelled to do that if it was clear that that person was a, a federal law enforcement agent operating with— oh, thank you.

1845
02:46:49.459 --> 02:47:08.969
<v Mitch Green>Sorry, uh, I believe the answer is no if I understand the question, and that a A Portland police officer would not be compelled to forcibly remove the mask of a federal agent if it's clear that the federal agent is operating within its course and scope of its lawful duties.

1846
02:47:10.409 --> 02:47:25.399
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, and does this code change change at all our reasonable suspicion standard or an officer's ability to use their judgment in meeting that reasonable suspicion standard in the field?

1847
02:47:27.000 --> 02:47:27.079
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

1848
02:47:28.600 --> 02:47:28.680
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1849
02:47:30.600 --> 02:47:48.819
<v Angelita Morillo>Once an individual is verified to be a federal agent, will PPB be compelled, required, or allowed to delay or interfere with or otherwise Interact with that agent's activities?

1850
02:47:50.180 --> 02:47:50.260
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1851
02:47:51.860 --> 02:47:51.940
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1852
02:47:54.260 --> 02:47:57.700
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, we talked about this previously, but I'm going to reiterate it.

1853
02:47:58.739 --> 02:48:31.389
<v Angelita Morillo>Is it correct that in the current draft, subsection 2330.030 and directly address the conduct and characteristics of all law enforcement officers, including federal agents, but that the remainder of the ordinance mainly governs how our own officers interact with other agents working within our jurisdiction, but doesn't specifically compel the work of those other officers.

1854
02:48:34.190 --> 02:48:36.350
<v Mitch Green>I believe that is correct.

1855
02:48:37.469 --> 02:48:42.350
<v Mitch Green>And in the definition section in 2330.020, Yes.

1856
02:48:42.989 --> 02:48:51.309
<v Mitch Green>You'll see there's a definition for officer, and there's also a separate definition for PPB officer.

1857
02:48:52.670 --> 02:48:59.790
<v Mitch Green>So in the code change where it refers to PPB officer, we are talking about our law enforcement employees.

1858
02:49:00.750 --> 02:49:12.909
<v Mitch Green>When we talk about— when we say officer without qualification, we are talking about any sworn law enforcement Okay.

1859
02:49:14.030 --> 02:49:39.659
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, Elizabeth, I don't know if you can answer this or if we would need somebody from PPB, but can you speak to, with the changes in the amendment that's been adopted, um, the extent of any administrative burden on the reporting requirements and whether The bureau and the service area would consider those at this point.

1860
02:49:40.540 --> 02:49:41.579
<v Angelita Morillo>Certainly it's new reporting.

1861
02:49:41.899 --> 02:49:50.459
<v Angelita Morillo>Any reporting creates some administrative burden, but a high, medium, or low level of additional requirement at this point.

1862
02:49:51.579 --> 02:49:52.700
<v Unidentified speaker>Elizabeth Perez, for the record.

1863
02:49:54.379 --> 02:49:59.219
<v Unidentified speaker>At this point, hearing from PPB, it still increases the reporting.

1864
02:50:00.719 --> 02:50:05.760
<v Unidentified speaker>But it would have to be PPB that lets us know what that burden is.

1865
02:50:07.440 --> 02:50:08.079
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1866
02:50:08.319 --> 02:50:25.680
<v Angelita Morillo>From my conversations with them, my understanding is that with the ability to have bureau-wide or, um, um, group-wide reporting on exemptions, that that helps lower the burden.

1867
02:50:26.350 --> 02:50:30.750
<v Angelita Morillo>As did some clarity around when the final reports would have to be written.

1868
02:50:30.989 --> 02:50:32.909
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't want to speak for them on the level.

1869
02:50:34.270 --> 02:50:37.709
<v Angelita Morillo>It sounds like we may need to just not have that answered today, and that's all right.

1870
02:50:39.629 --> 02:50:51.389
<v Angelita Morillo>Mr. Taylor, given Sections C and D of the resolved clauses, not what is before us in the attachment that would be going into code, but that language that leads to our discussion of the code.

1871
02:50:51.469 --> 02:50:52.270
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's a good question.

1872
02:50:54.799 --> 02:51:00.399
<v Angelita Morillo>Does the city plan to bargain implementation of pieces of the code if adopted?

1873
02:51:02.159 --> 02:51:02.399
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1874
02:51:02.559 --> 02:51:03.920
<v Mitch Green>Robert Taylor, City Attorney.

1875
02:51:05.200 --> 02:51:06.079
<v Mitch Green>That— it's a great question.

1876
02:51:06.479 --> 02:51:07.920
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for identifying that.

1877
02:51:10.639 --> 02:51:33.729
<v Mitch Green>In the ordinance, which is the document that would enact the code provision, it has 2 directives in there, C and D. C says that the code provision only applies to members of affected bargaining units, which would in this instance be our Portland Police Association.

1878
02:51:34.930 --> 02:51:44.930
<v Mitch Green>It only applies to members of affected bargaining units upon compliance with any legal obligation the city may have under the Public Employee Collective Bargaining Act.

1879
02:51:45.409 --> 02:51:57.340
<v Mitch Green>So The code we've been talking about today would not apply to those bargaining units until we have complied with our obligation under that act to bargain.

1880
02:51:58.299 --> 02:52:16.899
<v Mitch Green>And then also D says that we will give notice to any potentially affected bargaining unit, allow them an opportunity to demand to bargain, Which they have, on any mandatory subjects of bargaining.

1881
02:52:17.860 --> 02:52:29.620
<v Mitch Green>And then the city would engage in good faith bargaining as required by law, as may be required, including the obligation to be open to proposals that change this code.

1882
02:52:30.819 --> 02:52:36.500
<v Mitch Green>And then we would return to council with any proposed amendments to the code that result from the bargaining.

1883
02:52:37.059 --> 02:52:38.819
<v Mitch Green>So that's the process in C&D.

1884
02:52:38.899 --> 02:52:38.979
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1885
02:52:39.920 --> 02:52:46.319
<v Mitch Green>That's outlined in the city's effort to meet our obligation under the law to bargain with the affected bargaining units.

1886
02:52:47.840 --> 02:52:49.520
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think that's really important for 2 reasons.

1887
02:52:49.840 --> 02:53:04.559
<v Angelita Morillo>The first is when we talk about implementation as a non-emergency ordinance, this measure is implemented in 30 days, but there are pieces of it that might not be fully implemented until a little further than that as we move through these processes.

1888
02:53:05.909 --> 02:53:25.549
<v Angelita Morillo>The other thing that I think is important is that while council sets policy, we know that the implementation of the policy that we set has to move through rulemaking and sometimes bargaining processes to determine how our policies are implemented.

1889
02:53:25.750 --> 02:53:30.790
<v Angelita Morillo>And we've heard a lot about the potential labor implications here.

1890
02:53:30.790 --> 02:53:31.030
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1891
02:53:31.690 --> 02:53:57.290
<v Angelita Morillo>In the work on the amendment, we tried to make sure that we were coming in in a place that is respectful of our union's rights—the right to bargain—and we do have language in to ensure that that bargaining over implementation happens, which is a really important piece of this.

1892
02:54:10.270 --> 02:54:13.549
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you, Robert, for helping to point that out.

1893
02:54:15.069 --> 02:54:20.909
<v Angelita Morillo>Colleagues, I said earlier that I had heard a clear call from community that there was a need, and I wanted to make sure we did it right.

1894
02:54:20.989 --> 02:54:22.590
<v Angelita Morillo>And I asked the questions I did because I wanted to make sure that we were doing it right.

1895
02:54:22.590 --> 02:54:29.309
<v Angelita Morillo>And I asked the questions I did Because I think it is very important to be clear about what we can do and what we can't.

1896
02:54:30.629 --> 02:54:32.110
<v Angelita Morillo>This is meaningful.

1897
02:54:32.790 --> 02:54:45.229
<v Angelita Morillo>This is moving the needle on making sure that Portlanders understand who is operating in our community, um, and that we understand where there are folks who aren't living up to our standards and not.

1898
02:54:46.069 --> 02:54:48.870
<v Angelita Morillo>There are things this doesn't do that people want it to do.

1899
02:54:48.950 --> 02:54:49.030
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

1900
02:54:50.200 --> 02:54:51.639
<v Angelita Morillo>But I do think it is worth doing.

1901
02:54:52.520 --> 02:55:09.719
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that it will be positive for our community, and I think that we can do it in a way that still respects our union's rights and that doesn't create too heavy a burden for our police bureau or for individual law enforcement officers.

1902
02:55:11.879 --> 02:55:14.840
<v Angelita Morillo>I hope that we'll have strong support today.

1903
02:55:14.799 --> 02:55:20.639
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, thank you, Council President, and thank you to Director Perez and Mr. Taylor for those answers.

1904
02:55:21.920 --> 02:55:22.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1905
02:55:23.760 --> 02:55:26.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we are a full hour over our current time.

1906
02:55:27.600 --> 02:55:29.280
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have 2 more full items to go.

1907
02:55:29.440 --> 02:55:41.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have instructed council staff that we are here until we are done, and so it is up to this body to get us through this, but we are going to be continuing to work until we get done with all 3 of the items on our agenda.

1908
02:55:43.180 --> 02:55:50.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>Also, for everyone's edification, the item— our last item, the water bond item, has 24 people signed up to testify.

1909
02:55:50.219 --> 02:55:53.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>As such, I have reduced each testimony to 90 seconds.

1910
02:55:55.260 --> 02:55:57.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith, is that a legacy hand, or—.

1911
02:55:57.340 --> 02:55:57.500
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1912
02:55:57.739 --> 02:55:58.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor Zimmerman.

1913
02:56:00.620 --> 02:56:00.700
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1914
02:56:01.260 --> 02:56:04.459
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I appreciate this.

1915
02:56:04.620 --> 02:56:09.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>I was really excited when I saw the state legislature Take action with 4138.

1916
02:56:09.190 --> 02:56:23.670
<v Eric Zimmerman>And Representative Chotson, who was here, I think it was March, in your committee, I thought he just did a wonderful job representing kind of, I think, our state and largely Portland's concerns with what we saw last summer and last fall.

1917
02:56:25.270 --> 02:56:26.389
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I share those concerns.

1918
02:56:27.510 --> 02:56:35.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the idea of the non-uniformed masked-up person Is a huge concern.

1919
02:56:36.159 --> 02:56:38.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I have a lot of support for 4138.

1920
02:56:39.680 --> 02:56:50.239
<v Eric Zimmerman>Today's answers, frankly, from the city attorney about constitutionality is giving me some pause on going further than the state law.

1921
02:56:50.639 --> 02:57:06.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>So Councilor Kanal, I mentioned to you in break, I want to— if you talked a little bit in your opening remarks about California law, and you referenced California law multiple times because we fall in the same Ninth Circuit as them.

1922
02:57:07.000 --> 02:57:07.799
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's relevant, obviously.

1923
02:57:09.479 --> 02:57:18.520
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can I ask you a little bit more specific what it is you were referencing in your opening dialogue and your disagreement with Ninth Circuit?

1924
02:57:18.760 --> 02:57:25.319
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because it sounds like both Councilors Novick and our city attorney are citing that as a big concern.

1925
02:57:25.639 --> 02:57:26.280
<v Eric Zimmerman>What was it you were?

1926
02:57:28.639 --> 02:57:29.360
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for the question.

1927
02:57:29.840 --> 02:57:32.319
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to clarify what I said.

1928
02:57:33.120 --> 02:57:37.920
<v Sameer Kanal>We do something different than the California law does, is— was the point I was making.

1929
02:57:38.319 --> 02:57:43.680
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, there's a term used in that ruling about direct regulation.

1930
02:57:44.799 --> 02:57:49.120
<v Sameer Kanal>As I've mentioned, this does not include direct regulation in the same way.

1931
02:57:50.079 --> 02:57:53.040
<v Sameer Kanal>What it does do is allow for seeking injunctive relief from a court.

1932
02:57:53.659 --> 02:57:57.100
<v Sameer Kanal>We all have a right to sue when we feel that there's a reason to do that.

1933
02:57:57.340 --> 02:58:06.940
<v Sameer Kanal>Our— the ordinance focuses primarily on imposters, and as our attorney mentioned, the verification piece as well as the documentation piece are outside of the scope of that ruling.

1934
02:58:07.819 --> 02:58:10.059
<v Sameer Kanal>With relation to masks and identification—.

1935
02:58:10.379 --> 02:58:10.940
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can I ask clarifying?

1936
02:58:11.260 --> 02:58:11.659
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, of course.

1937
02:58:11.819 --> 02:58:21.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>The verification piece and the identification piece are outside the scope of that ruling, meaning our part in this, the verification identification, that's outside the scope of the Ninth Circuit that you're referencing?

1938
02:58:21.540 --> 02:58:23.139
<v Sameer Kanal>Verification and documentation.

1939
02:58:23.379 --> 02:58:24.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>And documentation.

1940
02:58:25.059 --> 02:58:25.299
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1941
02:58:25.620 --> 02:58:28.899
<v Sameer Kanal>Because those are regulating what city employees do.

1942
02:58:31.059 --> 02:58:43.700
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the other piece is, you know, as I mentioned, there's still an obligation at this present moment to abide by 4138 on the masking and identification side.

1943
02:58:44.819 --> 02:58:44.899
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1944
02:58:45.219 --> 02:58:50.870
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's because California was saying something More aggressive in terms of what they were— what got struck down or whatever?

1945
02:58:51.350 --> 02:58:55.190
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I don't know if I could classify it in terms of more or less aggressive, but it's different.

1946
02:58:55.590 --> 02:58:57.510
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, the text is different, and I— that— yeah.

1947
02:58:58.229 --> 02:59:03.270
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, I want to pick up kind of where Councilor Pirtle-Guiney left off.

1948
02:59:03.750 --> 02:59:18.629
<v Eric Zimmerman>She said that this is doing something that meets people's needs, and so this is a part that's kind of giving me a little bit of heartburn based on— I was I was both very much aware of the testimony that we got from the public.

1949
02:59:19.909 --> 02:59:20.629
<v Eric Zimmerman>Was it last week?

1950
02:59:21.430 --> 02:59:21.909
<v Eric Zimmerman>The week before?

1951
02:59:22.309 --> 02:59:33.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then hearing all of those who crafted this and what our police chief and our mayor and our city attorneys and what they say is actually going to happen.

1952
02:59:34.309 --> 02:59:48.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>For whatever reason, and I am not going to cast blame anywhere, for whatever reason over the last couple weeks, It was seen as if— I think this got proposed like Portland Police were gonna assign a squad or something to follow ICE and then demask, right?

1953
02:59:48.879 --> 02:59:57.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that unfortunately really set up a dialogue that, well, that would be great, is clearly just not what this does.

1954
02:59:58.000 --> 02:59:59.280
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think you're nodding in agreement.

1955
02:59:59.520 --> 03:00:00.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>I see that you're agreeing to that.

1956
03:00:01.040 --> 03:00:27.149
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm still having trouble based on what Councilor Pirtle-Guiney just said for When she talks about what this does, other than it very clearly defines, which so does 4138, that Portland Police cannot wear masks and must wear identifying uniforms or badges or numbers and names in accordance with the state law, which I think is great.

1957
03:00:27.549 --> 03:00:32.989
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I do not know what it is that she or you are referencing in terms of— The mask mandate.

1958
03:00:34.100 --> 03:00:36.100
<v Eric Zimmerman>What it does on that.

1959
03:00:36.659 --> 03:00:56.579
<v Eric Zimmerman>The point in life where Portland Police would cross paths with federal police or agents, different than what our city attorney talked about, we currently have laws on the books for the impersonation of an officer, and we can go down those investigations.

1960
03:00:56.739 --> 03:00:59.700
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm having trouble with a little bit of like, what's the real meat here on that?

1961
03:00:59.700 --> 03:01:01.409
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think the point is that Part of it, not the masking part.

1962
03:01:01.489 --> 03:01:01.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's very clear.

1963
03:01:02.129 --> 03:01:02.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>I got that.

1964
03:01:03.329 --> 03:01:13.409
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, given this new amendment, you know, we received a letter from the mayor 2 weeks ago urging us not to support your initial thing.

1965
03:01:13.569 --> 03:01:28.549
<v Eric Zimmerman>Now things have been amended, but I haven't seen the city administrator, the mayor, the chief of police— I haven't seen them in this room endorsing this change, saying this is actually This is operational.

1966
03:01:29.670 --> 03:01:41.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm wondering if it comes down to a part in the way you describe in here, I think it's the area of the identifying what the preliminary investigation is.

1967
03:01:41.590 --> 03:01:52.309
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say it from this perspective, we set laws, but I don't know any other laws yet where we have said this is how you'll investigate that law.

1968
03:01:52.309 --> 03:01:52.389
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1969
03:01:52.850 --> 03:02:06.690
<v Eric Zimmerman>Whether it's been broken or not, I find that to be fully into the administration's role insofar as there are policies at the bureau that would say, you know, we investigate, name the crime, this way, and that's the chief's prerogative.

1970
03:02:07.649 --> 03:02:09.809
<v Eric Zimmerman>This one seems differently, or different.

1971
03:02:11.409 --> 03:02:11.889
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is it different?

1972
03:02:12.290 --> 03:02:12.530
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1973
03:02:12.770 --> 03:02:24.479
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are you sensing a desire to outline how we encode Are going to say how this law will be preliminarily investigated?

1974
03:02:25.040 --> 03:02:35.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because that seems like an interesting rub here that I'm wondering, is the concern— maybe that's the concern from the administration, is that that's something that's in that branch of government and not in our branch of government.

1975
03:02:37.280 --> 03:02:40.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm curious to you, Councilor Kanal, like, how does that question land on you?

1976
03:02:40.879 --> 03:02:41.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>What's your interpretation?

1977
03:02:41.840 --> 03:02:42.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or maybe what was your intent?

1978
03:02:44.159 --> 03:02:44.879
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for the question.

1979
03:02:47.200 --> 03:03:02.000
<v Sameer Kanal>I guess let me start by saying, um, there's— it's, it's interesting because sometimes there's a third party who'll say this ordinance claims to do ABC, and then I'm asked, or the, you know, our co-sponsors are asked to, to justify that when we never said it would do that.

1980
03:03:02.479 --> 03:03:16.010
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so I just want to clarify, um, as I said in January when somebody asked what would this do, uh, in the committee, uh, CAPS committee, what would this do about If an ICE agent is masked and doing, I can't remember what the end of the question was.

1981
03:03:16.409 --> 03:03:19.049
<v Sameer Kanal>And I said, I'm pretty sure this is a quote, absolutely nothing.

1982
03:03:20.489 --> 03:03:30.010
<v Sameer Kanal>And there were people who were in the crowd that were there to support the ordinance, and at least two of them booed at that because it's not in anyone's interest for us to oversell what this does.

1983
03:03:30.569 --> 03:03:31.450
<v Sameer Kanal>It's in nobody's interest.

1984
03:03:32.090 --> 03:03:38.729
<v Sameer Kanal>You could, you know, in some period of time, we would immediately be losing trust if we said it does more than it does.

1985
03:03:42.389 --> 03:03:49.190
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's a similar thing for the idea, as has been expressed, that this would cause Portland Police to go around taking off masks.

1986
03:03:49.510 --> 03:03:50.309
<v Sameer Kanal>It does not do that.

1987
03:03:52.229 --> 03:04:00.229
<v Sameer Kanal>To directly answer the question— excuse me— it's about checking every time and documenting those checks.

1988
03:04:00.709 --> 03:04:03.110
<v Sameer Kanal>It's about ensuring that we have options.

1989
03:04:03.590 --> 03:04:04.870
<v Sameer Kanal>I mentioned that the preliminary investigation is ongoing.

1990
03:04:04.870 --> 03:04:05.829
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's not about taking off masks?

1991
03:04:05.860 --> 03:04:07.940
<v Sameer Kanal>Is very limited in what it requires.

1992
03:04:08.340 --> 03:04:20.420
<v Sameer Kanal>It requires a phone call, notification of a supervisor, and a phone call to the potential dispatching agents of if the potential imposter is not an imposter and in fact a law enforcement agent.

1993
03:04:21.620 --> 03:04:23.139
<v Sameer Kanal>And then after-the-fact documentation.

1994
03:04:23.620 --> 03:04:23.700
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1995
03:04:24.020 --> 03:04:28.899
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that— when you explain that, or that's where I— one of the things I wrote down is like, we've all seen it.

1996
03:04:28.979 --> 03:04:31.549
<v Eric Zimmerman>We've all been outside and we've— I mean, these are horrific Thank you.

1997
03:04:31.950 --> 03:04:33.469
<v Eric Zimmerman>—Interactions that are very scary for the public.

1998
03:04:34.670 --> 03:04:50.989
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm trying to put my— like, if I were to be stopped by a police officer for any number of crimes, there's that point, and maybe if you're a nerd and you've watched some of these police videos, people ask, am I being detained?

1999
03:04:51.069 --> 03:04:51.790
<v Eric Zimmerman>Am I under arrest?

2000
03:04:51.950 --> 03:04:52.909
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those are like important questions.

2001
03:04:54.110 --> 03:04:59.959
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in that instance, are you— does this law then dictate that a Portland police officer, Yes.

2002
03:04:59.959 --> 03:05:06.200
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because what we saw is ICE came in fast, rapid, with minivans, put people in, and then they left.

2003
03:05:08.760 --> 03:05:14.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>If a Portland police officer was standing there, or if they got called to that situation— if they're standing there, great, at least they have the sense.

2004
03:05:14.920 --> 03:05:19.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have a feeling if they got a 911 call, the ability to get there before the scene is cleared is unlikely.

2005
03:05:20.520 --> 03:05:23.479
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, I'm trying to put some reality around, like, what does this interaction look like?

2006
03:05:24.440 --> 03:05:26.469
<v Eric Zimmerman>But me, as a civilian, What's the question?

2007
03:05:26.629 --> 03:05:45.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>If during the preliminary part of an investigation, I decide to walk off, are we putting a place where a federal officer kind of flips the bird at a Portland police officer and says, that's great that you're trying to verify my identity, shove off, and they continue their mission and they do their thing?

2008
03:05:46.549 --> 03:05:52.370
<v Eric Zimmerman>Are we— are you asking that we pursue that, that we just say, okay, we just stop and say, Okay.

2009
03:05:52.770 --> 03:06:12.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>Somebody grabbed somebody and there was not enough— I'm going to use the word incorrectly here, but indicia— there's not enough indicia that, that they were a law enforcement, a federal law enforcement officer, and then I call my own supervisor and I say, I think this is a concern, or do they pursue that?

2010
03:06:12.770 --> 03:06:19.659
<v Eric Zimmerman>I guess I'm trying to get a sense for, for what the preliminary part, when you describe it that way, given how fast these interactions Were happening in the community.

2011
03:06:20.620 --> 03:06:24.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>We got a lot of calls, I feel like, as it was happening, but by the time that they're gone—.

2012
03:06:27.020 --> 03:06:27.340
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you have any—.

2013
03:06:27.659 --> 03:06:31.659
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just, I'm trying to think through this because like I said, like, there's a few pieces here.

2014
03:06:31.739 --> 03:06:33.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm trying to understand the rub.

2015
03:06:34.620 --> 03:06:34.860
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2016
03:06:35.100 --> 03:06:49.540
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so I think you've identified the— and this is colloquial, I'm not a lawyer— uh, distinction between preliminary and, and, uh, The Part C section here of investigations, it is the idea of a stop or seizure.

2017
03:06:49.620 --> 03:06:50.579
<v Sameer Kanal>It's, am I free to go?

2018
03:06:51.139 --> 03:06:51.219
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

2019
03:06:52.579 --> 03:07:03.940
<v Sameer Kanal>I think you're correct that many of the interactions are very rapid, and it is possible, and in fact likely in those scenarios, that a responding officer, PPB officer, would arrive after the incident is over.

2020
03:07:04.579 --> 03:07:11.299
<v Sameer Kanal>There's also examples of a person is trying to get into a building to detain somebody, and the door is locked.

2021
03:07:11.540 --> 03:07:12.979
<v Sameer Kanal>And so that interaction might last longer.

2022
03:07:14.149 --> 03:07:17.670
<v Sameer Kanal>Enough for a Portland police officer who has been dispatched to arrive.

2023
03:07:18.229 --> 03:07:22.149
<v Sameer Kanal>So there, it's not 100% of the time, it is some of the time that there would be a rapid interaction.

2024
03:07:22.469 --> 03:07:31.829
<v Sameer Kanal>In that scenario, excuse me, the person could, the potential imposter could say pound sand and go.

2025
03:07:32.069 --> 03:07:43.079
<v Sameer Kanal>And the determination of what continues on is what is already in federal law with no change, which is the presence of reasonable suspicion that a crime is, is about to be, or just was committed.

2026
03:07:44.040 --> 03:07:48.040
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's all retained exactly as is with no changes.

2027
03:07:49.959 --> 03:07:50.040
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

2028
03:07:50.360 --> 03:08:14.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is helpful because, so I'm gonna put Councilor Green and I kind of in a bucket that's different than the rest of you, which is we can probably, the two of us having spent time in uniform and in the military, we can, We can identify somebody who's cosplaying probably quicker than the rest of you because we kind of know what a proper uniform looks like.

2029
03:08:14.290 --> 03:08:17.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>We kind of know what— how somebody might use the certain words, etc.

2030
03:08:18.530 --> 03:08:29.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I can see that a police officer could also make that determination, maybe from further away than satisfies the public or satisfies the person who's made the call.

2031
03:08:30.610 --> 03:08:40.040
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I think you're acknowledging that That every interaction with a federal officer with a mask on is not gonna result in a Portland police officer intervening and stopping them?

2032
03:08:41.559 --> 03:08:41.639
<v Dan Ryan>Correct.

2033
03:08:41.879 --> 03:08:45.799
<v Eric Zimmerman>Pulling the mask down, getting ID, and doing the whole, like, let me take my notes.

2034
03:08:46.120 --> 03:08:58.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>You're saying, I think what I'm hearing you say is they could use any one of the criteria that you've identified as, like, from afar, and I think that Mitch and I could do it with soldiers, but from afar we could say, like, That's a real operation.

2035
03:09:03.329 --> 03:09:10.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>What do we say then to the public who kind of expects that this is going to have us interact with every one of those calls that comes up?

2036
03:09:10.850 --> 03:09:24.690
<v Eric Zimmerman>If we have another surge like we experienced in the fall, which was a terrible couple of months there, do we say that we're following the letter or we're surged out, we can't do it?

2037
03:09:24.860 --> 03:09:35.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like, how do you see that interaction going, or do you give some credence to those who can identify that identifying information because of their experience and their role and from afar?

2038
03:09:35.659 --> 03:09:39.500
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, first, thank you for clarifying the nature of the commonality there.

2039
03:09:39.500 --> 03:09:44.620
<v Sameer Kanal>I thought you were leaving out Council President Dunphy for a second, uh, in your— the bald club there.

2040
03:09:44.780 --> 03:10:04.459
<v Sameer Kanal>But, uh, secondly, um, yeah, to, uh, this is very similar to a conversation I had with, uh, one of the, the leadership at PPB about this, and it's exactly why the people doing the checking are police, because they would have that context and that experience and that potential ability to identify quickly.

2041
03:10:05.020 --> 03:10:17.100
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's fair to say that there are ways in which— that there's never going to be 0% trust or 100% trust, but there are things that we can do within the spectrum of 1 to 99% to increase trust.

2042
03:10:17.659 --> 03:10:26.040
<v Sameer Kanal>One of the things is simply stating Here's why it wasn't worth continuing on with.

2043
03:10:26.600 --> 03:10:29.319
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's not a box-checking exercise.

2044
03:10:29.399 --> 03:10:31.719
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a qualitative description kind of thing.

2045
03:10:33.559 --> 03:10:37.079
<v Sameer Kanal>And there are many things that can be— and that's why many things that can be looked at.

2046
03:10:37.079 --> 03:10:46.700
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's why it says these criteria are illustrative and not designed to be a series of of steps or a checklist.

2047
03:10:47.340 --> 03:10:48.299
<v Sameer Kanal>So yes to your question.

2048
03:10:49.260 --> 03:10:50.299
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I really appreciate this.

2049
03:10:50.459 --> 03:10:51.579
<v Eric Zimmerman>This has been a helpful dialogue.

2050
03:10:52.059 --> 03:10:55.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>And for those who are watching, I just, thanks for holding on with us.

2051
03:10:57.340 --> 03:11:06.620
<v Eric Zimmerman>So getting to kind of wrapping up here, and I'm gonna ask Robert Taylor, you're up next by the way.

2052
03:11:06.780 --> 03:11:08.459
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if you're in the room, please come up.

2053
03:11:12.069 --> 03:11:56.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Kanal, given what I think I'm gonna hear again, which is similar to what he said earlier about supremacy and constitutionality and legally defensible, here's my question to you is, would it be potentially safer for the city and our public to do a 4138 compliant ordinance with a, with a more aspirational resolution to direct the, the administration, meaning like the chief and the CA, and to come up with some of the more prescribed parts, the parts of your ordinance that go a little above 4138.

2054
03:11:58.180 --> 03:12:05.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say this because I think what he's going to say is 4138 has some parts that are going to— he's deemed Constitutional from his chair.

2055
03:12:07.129 --> 03:12:20.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>If the city comes into compliance with a state law and the state law is determined to be unconstitutional, I guess part of me says that's the state's problem.

2056
03:12:21.209 --> 03:12:23.690
<v Eric Zimmerman>Meaning we followed the state law, now the state's got to defend it.

2057
03:12:23.930 --> 03:12:32.309
<v Eric Zimmerman>Whereas if we go above and beyond, are we now putting ourselves in the first chair where we have to defend and And the state is playing second fiddle.

2058
03:12:32.469 --> 03:12:35.030
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I pose— maybe I don't want an answer.

2059
03:12:35.190 --> 03:12:38.709
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm going to give you that rhetorically, and I'd like— maybe you can think about it.

2060
03:12:38.709 --> 03:12:55.030
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I'm wondering if there's the 4138 aspect that is the ordinance, and you could pare part of it down with an aspirational resolution, which I think is our role is to direct the development of internal policies, which most of the cities I think are doing internal policies.

2061
03:12:55.590 --> 03:12:55.670
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

2062
03:12:56.639 --> 03:12:57.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just want to consider that.

2063
03:12:58.079 --> 03:13:07.520
<v Eric Zimmerman>Now, Robert Taylor, I really need to hear very clear because you kind of put my hair on— well, the non-hair on back of my neck or whatever— on edge when you were answering Councilor Smith, right?

2064
03:13:07.760 --> 03:13:33.239
<v Eric Zimmerman>I took an oath about state constitution, United States Constitution, the city code laws to knowingly pass an ordinance that our city attorney is raising concern about I want to make sure I'm hearing you out from not a— we have a little bit of lawsuit risk here, but we have a recent federal appeals court, Ninth Circuit issue.

2065
03:13:33.559 --> 03:13:35.239
<v Eric Zimmerman>We have a constitutionality issue.

2066
03:13:35.479 --> 03:13:40.120
<v Eric Zimmerman>And your words 20 minutes ago were, as it currently stands, is unconstitutional.

2067
03:13:43.399 --> 03:13:45.719
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to make sure I understood that and heard that correct.

2068
03:13:46.360 --> 03:13:55.190
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is, that is what you are conveying to us if we were to pass this today as it is Councilor Zimmerman, you're 20 minutes into this line of questioning.

2069
03:13:55.270 --> 03:13:56.389
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, it's great, isn't it?

2070
03:13:56.469 --> 03:13:57.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm hitting all the good points.

2071
03:13:57.829 --> 03:14:01.510
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, uh, so Robert's Rules limits it to 10 minutes per speaker per motion.

2072
03:14:01.750 --> 03:14:02.709
<v Eric Zimmerman>Well, Robert's sitting over there.

2073
03:14:03.030 --> 03:14:05.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great, so please go ahead and wrap up.

2074
03:14:08.469 --> 03:14:10.629
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you, Robert Taylor, City Attorney.

2075
03:14:10.790 --> 03:14:13.909
<v Mitch Green>Council President, you are correct on the Robert's Rules time limit.

2076
03:14:14.309 --> 03:14:18.270
<v Mitch Green>Um, on And on your point, yes, let me be clear.

2077
03:14:19.229 --> 03:14:30.430
<v Mitch Green>Under the current Ninth Circuit ruling, it is unconstitutional under the Supremacy Clause to directly regulate federal law enforcement identification and masking.

2078
03:14:30.829 --> 03:14:31.629
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, okay.

2079
03:14:31.790 --> 03:14:41.069
<v Mitch Green>And if this is passed and it was challenged, or we brought a lawsuit to challenge it, that would likely be held unconstitutional.

2080
03:14:41.629 --> 03:14:43.629
<v Mitch Green>It would be severed from the code.

2081
03:14:44.430 --> 03:14:47.389
<v Mitch Green>The remaining part of the code would be in effect.

2082
03:14:48.909 --> 03:15:02.590
<v Mitch Green>And then from my perspective, what is important is that the decision makers who, who are in this room understand what might happen and that the public understands what might happen.

2083
03:15:04.670 --> 03:15:09.709
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, Councilor Knoll, I very much value the dialogue we just had.

2084
03:15:09.870 --> 03:15:10.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

2085
03:15:10.059 --> 03:15:10.780
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

2086
03:15:10.780 --> 03:15:12.139
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate it.

2087
03:15:12.459 --> 03:15:16.540
<v Eric Zimmerman>Very concerning, but also thank you for that, um, Mr. Taylor.

2088
03:15:18.860 --> 03:15:19.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2089
03:15:19.659 --> 03:15:20.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2090
03:15:20.940 --> 03:15:21.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2091
03:15:22.860 --> 03:15:24.540
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, First Sergeant Dunphy.

2092
03:15:26.219 --> 03:15:32.860
<v Mitch Green>Um, I hesitated to get in the queue because we're already what must be an hour and 20 minutes over time now at this point.

2093
03:15:33.260 --> 03:15:35.420
<v Mitch Green>Um, and so I'm in the queue for 2 reasons.

2094
03:15:35.579 --> 03:15:37.530
<v Mitch Green>One, to I just wanted to provide a brief statement of support.

2095
03:15:38.170 --> 03:15:41.290
<v Mitch Green>I cannot wait to vote yes on the underlying of this amendment.

2096
03:15:41.530 --> 03:15:44.809
<v Mitch Green>I think it's an important step for this city to take.

2097
03:15:45.129 --> 03:16:00.569
<v Mitch Green>We've had extensive debate on the limitations of it, the risks of it, but we've also heard loudly that we need to use every tool that we have in our kit to show our community we're protecting them, keeping them safe.

2098
03:16:01.129 --> 03:16:01.370
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2099
03:16:02.260 --> 03:16:03.700
<v Mitch Green>There's a severability clause in this.

2100
03:16:04.420 --> 03:16:08.579
<v Mitch Green>This does— adopting this does not mean we're doing something unconstitutional, by the way.

2101
03:16:08.579 --> 03:16:10.340
<v Mitch Green>So there's an important nuance that you laid out there.

2102
03:16:11.059 --> 03:16:11.620
<v Mitch Green>We know the risks.

2103
03:16:13.540 --> 03:16:13.940
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not—.

2104
03:16:14.420 --> 03:16:21.139
<v Mitch Green>I was not put in this office to not fight for the community that wants me to fight for them.

2105
03:16:21.860 --> 03:16:41.250
<v Mitch Green>And so I was— I remember being at the bottom of, uh, at Toriliger Boulevard and And whatever the road that goes up to the VA hospital is, at a vigil after Alex Purdy was murdered by Department of Homeland Security agents, there were almost 1,000 Portlanders there, many of them from our district.

2106
03:16:42.129 --> 03:16:44.370
<v Mitch Green>And they said, what are you doing to keep us safe?

2107
03:16:44.770 --> 03:16:47.649
<v Mitch Green>And it wasn't just me, it was Congresswoman Maxine Dexter.

2108
03:16:47.969 --> 03:16:52.690
<v Mitch Green>And we had a dialogue and we said, look, you can't regulate the federal government at the local level.

2109
03:16:52.770 --> 03:16:53.329
<v Loretta Smith>You can't do that.

2110
03:16:53.329 --> 03:16:53.889
<v Mitch Green>I'm not saying that.

2111
03:16:54.819 --> 03:16:57.540
<v Mitch Green>That's my job as a congresswoman to try to do that.

2112
03:16:58.579 --> 03:17:09.540
<v Mitch Green>But the local level does have tools where we can sort of clarify the role of police in this and create expectations that people feel gives them clarity on who's operating in their city.

2113
03:17:09.540 --> 03:17:13.139
<v Mitch Green>That's why I support this, and I just want to thank the sponsors of this ordinance.

2114
03:17:13.379 --> 03:17:20.100
<v Mitch Green>I want to thank Councilor Pearl Guinea for working very closely with the carriers to try to find a path that gets you to yes.

2115
03:17:20.100 --> 03:17:20.340
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2116
03:17:20.850 --> 03:17:27.010
<v Mitch Green>I want to thank you, Councilor Novick, for— I know that you've spent a lot of time with these folks to try to improve this process.

2117
03:17:27.010 --> 03:17:36.049
<v Mitch Green>So, and we've had a spirited debate, we've had a long conversation, and I just think at this point I would love to move on in our agenda.

2118
03:17:36.049 --> 03:17:42.770
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm going to stop talking, and I hope the rest of us can be brief in the remainder of the night so we can actually get to the rest of the voting items tonight.

2119
03:17:43.010 --> 03:17:43.889
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

2120
03:17:43.969 --> 03:17:44.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

2121
03:17:45.010 --> 03:17:45.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

2122
03:17:46.540 --> 03:17:47.180
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

2123
03:17:47.579 --> 03:17:48.299
<v Steve Novick>I will be brief.

2124
03:17:49.180 --> 03:17:59.020
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Zimmerman, since Robert Taylor didn't say it expressly, if the 9th Circuit opinion holds up, 4138 is toast too.

2125
03:17:59.500 --> 03:18:09.579
<v Steve Novick>Because what the 9th Circuit opinion said is that you cannot regulate the federal government's decisions as to when and whether or how to identify themselves, do not pass go, do not collect $200.

2126
03:18:10.780 --> 03:18:17.469
<v Steve Novick>I think that we have good legal arguments that that panel was wrong, just like California did, just like the state lawyers did.

2127
03:18:18.590 --> 03:18:24.909
<v Steve Novick>But there's no real distinction in the possible constitutionality of California versus the state versus us.

2128
03:18:26.430 --> 03:18:27.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

2129
03:18:27.549 --> 03:18:28.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

2130
03:18:29.069 --> 03:18:29.389
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2131
03:18:29.549 --> 03:18:30.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Just 4 quick points.

2132
03:18:31.469 --> 03:18:37.229
<v Sameer Kanal>One is the state constitution also requires for us to follow state law that's in effect at the time that applies to us.

2133
03:18:37.719 --> 03:18:39.239
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's part of my oath too.

2134
03:18:39.879 --> 03:18:50.280
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with the broader comment on oaths, and I think that's a really important conversation where it's a little bit of a time where things are shifting and how we interpret those, and I recognize that.

2135
03:18:51.559 --> 03:18:53.079
<v Sameer Kanal>I didn't get a chance to mention this earlier.

2136
03:18:53.319 --> 03:19:04.780
<v Sameer Kanal>I forgot to, with relation to the administrative versus legislative aspect of it, I do think that most of what we're doing here is saying what to do and providing illustrations of how, but not Not requiring a certain how.

2137
03:19:04.940 --> 03:19:15.260
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I know that there's an ongoing conversation in our new form of government about where the sort of vertical line is between the really high-level things and the really low-level things in terms of legislative to administrative.

2138
03:19:15.739 --> 03:19:24.299
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think we attempted to, to, you know, uh, stay on the correct side of that, um, noting that we don't all agree on where the line is 100% of the time.

2139
03:19:25.020 --> 03:19:32.079
<v Sameer Kanal>As it relates to the, the resolution question, but more broadly the question about Could this be ruled unconstitutional in part?

2140
03:19:33.200 --> 03:19:37.920
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think this applies to could there be opposition in other contexts after the fact as well.

2141
03:19:38.159 --> 03:19:39.200
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's fair to say that.

2142
03:19:39.840 --> 03:19:43.600
<v Sameer Kanal>I also think it's fair to point out that the fight hasn't been held yet.

2143
03:19:44.479 --> 03:19:49.920
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't like the idea of comparing every legislative action we take to a fight.

2144
03:19:50.079 --> 03:19:51.920
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's an overused trope.

2145
03:19:52.239 --> 03:19:54.559
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also think that there are a few things that are fights.

2146
03:19:55.450 --> 03:20:15.209
<v Sameer Kanal>I think ensuring that we are safe from the type of impersonation that has occurred where people have claimed authority they did not have and used it to rob, used it to detain, used it to kidnap, used it to sexually assault people is an important thing to do and important enough that I think the term fight does apply.

2147
03:20:15.850 --> 03:20:18.809
<v Sameer Kanal>And when we're in a fight, we shouldn't give up on it before it's fought.

2148
03:20:19.129 --> 03:20:19.690
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll leave it there.

2149
03:20:19.850 --> 03:20:20.090
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

2150
03:20:20.739 --> 03:20:21.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

2151
03:20:22.100 --> 03:20:22.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

2152
03:20:24.819 --> 03:20:25.299
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, colleagues.

2153
03:20:25.540 --> 03:20:30.180
<v Candace Avalos>I know we're running late, but I didn't want to miss the opportunity to add my voice in support of this ordinance.

2154
03:20:30.899 --> 03:20:35.940
<v Candace Avalos>As the daughter of immigrants representing one of the most diverse districts in Portland, I take this issue very seriously.

2155
03:20:36.819 --> 03:20:46.899
<v Candace Avalos>For many immigrant families, when someone is taken by law enforcement, families are often left with no information, no clarity, and no understanding of where their loved one was taken or even who took them in the first place.

2156
03:20:47.920 --> 03:20:51.200
<v Candace Avalos>That fear is very real in our communities, especially in East Portland.

2157
03:20:51.760 --> 03:20:54.000
<v Candace Avalos>At its core, this ordinance is about something very basic.

2158
03:20:54.479 --> 03:21:00.079
<v Candace Avalos>If someone is exercising the power to stop, detain, or arrest you, people have a right to know who you are.

2159
03:21:00.719 --> 03:21:00.799
<v Candace Avalos>Simple.

2160
03:21:01.360 --> 03:21:14.399
<v Candace Avalos>And importantly, the documentation provisions here are new, and they matter because they create a record and a level of accountability that communities, organizations like the American Civil Liberties Union, PERC, and immigrant advocates have been asking for.

2161
03:21:14.399 --> 03:21:14.559
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2162
03:21:14.989 --> 03:21:21.629
<v Candace Avalos>So this ordinance stays within the authority that we have as a city, and what we can do to protect Portlanders, we should absolutely do.

2163
03:21:21.950 --> 03:21:22.989
<v Candace Avalos>I plan on supporting it.

2164
03:21:23.069 --> 03:21:23.389
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2165
03:21:23.870 --> 03:21:25.149
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Councilor Avalos.

2166
03:21:25.309 --> 03:21:25.870
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

2167
03:21:27.309 --> 03:21:32.430
<v Angelita Morillo>I want to say something, uh, similar to what Councilor Avalos just said, and I think this is an important discussion to have.

2168
03:21:33.469 --> 03:22:03.790
<v Angelita Morillo>But to me, the most important part of this ordinance is that there— we can use the surveillance State, and we can use our police who are going to be tracking and monitoring where ICE is operating, their patterns of going into neighborhoods, what times they do it, how they are investigating, who they are taking into account, because all of that is tracked and then becomes a report that goes back to City Council, which is presented on, which is a public record.

2169
03:22:04.030 --> 03:22:07.229
<v Angelita Morillo>There are community members that are organizing in the community.

2170
03:22:07.309 --> 03:22:07.629
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2171
03:22:08.450 --> 03:22:13.010
<v Angelita Morillo>Frankly, beyond the bounds of legality, that because they are not bound by that, but we are.

2172
03:22:13.889 --> 03:22:16.770
<v Angelita Morillo>And that is the historic moment that we are in right now.

2173
03:22:18.530 --> 03:22:19.649
<v Angelita Morillo>I understand that.

2174
03:22:20.129 --> 03:22:22.370
<v Angelita Morillo>Look, I'm a Constitution Team scholar, national winner.

2175
03:22:22.850 --> 03:22:22.930
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay?

2176
03:22:23.090 --> 03:22:24.209
<v Angelita Morillo>I understand the Constitution.

2177
03:22:24.450 --> 03:22:25.889
<v Angelita Morillo>I care about it, and I uphold it.

2178
03:22:26.530 --> 03:22:35.329
<v Angelita Morillo>And if we always followed only if our courage only was held within the bounds of the law.

2179
03:22:39.100 --> 03:22:47.180
<v Angelita Morillo>We are supposed to push on this, and this is a matter that is going to be litigated in federal court at some point or another.

2180
03:22:47.819 --> 03:23:01.500
<v Angelita Morillo>Because if there is a situation where an immigrant who is, who is white is, for example, getting kidnapped by an ICE agent, would a police officer intervene because they would assume that that person isn't an immigrant?

2181
03:23:01.500 --> 03:23:01.659
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

2182
03:23:01.659 --> 03:23:12.940
<v Angelita Morillo>Would a police officer intervene And vice versa, if a person of color who is an American citizen is being kidnapped by random people, would the police not intervene or investigate because they would assume that person is an immigrant and that those people are ICE?

2183
03:23:15.020 --> 03:23:19.819
<v Angelita Morillo>This is going to end up being a court case at some point, at one point or another.

2184
03:23:20.940 --> 03:23:30.379
<v Angelita Morillo>And the data tracking that we are doing is absolutely critical to make sure that the community has as much information as possible to deal with what's happening.

2185
03:23:31.020 --> 03:23:38.940
<v Angelita Morillo>There are limits to the bureaucracy, but within the limits of that bureaucracy, we can use our state power to give people information to act.

2186
03:23:41.020 --> 03:23:58.329
<v Angelita Morillo>Again, colleagues, I am literally beseeching you right now that if we were only to ever do what was in the bounds of the law or what was already legal based on prior precedent, then we would never move forward as a society.

2187
03:23:58.489 --> 03:24:01.049
<v Angelita Morillo>We have a duty to push on this.

2188
03:24:01.290 --> 03:24:04.329
<v Angelita Morillo>So I really appreciate the amendments that were made.

2189
03:24:04.489 --> 03:24:11.569
<v Angelita Morillo>I will be the first to clarify in whatever video I make after this to the community what this accomplishes and doesn't accomplish.

2190
03:24:12.649 --> 03:24:17.129
<v Angelita Morillo>But this does do something, and we have to use the tools that we have.

2191
03:24:17.290 --> 03:24:20.889
<v Angelita Morillo>So I will strongly be supporting the underlying ordinance.

2192
03:24:21.149 --> 03:24:26.510
<v Angelita Morillo>I think this should go all the way up to the Supreme Court, and, and we need to fight it out.

2193
03:24:26.670 --> 03:24:28.909
<v Angelita Morillo>This is something that we have to try.

2194
03:24:29.149 --> 03:24:34.190
<v Angelita Morillo>We don't have a lot of tools as a local government, but the tools that we do have, we have to try.

2195
03:24:34.350 --> 03:24:34.989
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2196
03:24:35.229 --> 03:24:36.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

2197
03:24:36.350 --> 03:24:37.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

2198
03:24:37.549 --> 03:24:38.270
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

2199
03:24:38.670 --> 03:24:41.389
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Morillo, that's a very compelling argument.

2200
03:24:41.469 --> 03:24:46.829
<v Angelita Morillo>I appreciate that, and I am going to reserve the right to change my mind in the future.

2201
03:24:48.329 --> 03:24:58.170
<v Angelita Morillo>Perhaps not today, but I'm curious to know where the mayor stands on this, if we can get some kind of intelligence, and where the chief of police stands on this.

2202
03:25:01.209 --> 03:25:03.770
<v Angelita Morillo>Can we get an answer to that by any— from anyone?

2203
03:25:07.129 --> 03:25:09.370
<v Angelita Morillo>Well, we have, we have, we have a second reading too.

2204
03:25:09.370 --> 03:25:11.129
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, thank you.

2205
03:25:11.209 --> 03:25:27.239
<v Angelita Morillo>The mayor's job is not— I'm sorry, under the charter authority Thank you, Councilor Smith.

2206
03:25:30.680 --> 03:25:31.559
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

2207
03:25:34.360 --> 03:25:37.479
<v Loretta Smith>The struggle is real and it's deadly when dealing with ICE.

2208
03:25:37.959 --> 03:25:40.280
<v Loretta Smith>I believe that ICE officers are not trained to deal with people in crisis.

2209
03:25:40.270 --> 03:25:40.829
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Herbold.

2210
03:25:40.829 --> 03:25:43.469
<v Loretta Smith>I think the officers are ruthless enforcers of the law.

2211
03:25:45.389 --> 03:25:58.909
<v Loretta Smith>They prioritize deportation quotas over compassion, and they also foster no compassion and a climate of fear within communities.

2212
03:26:00.590 --> 03:26:06.110
<v Loretta Smith>And for me, their actions are seen as lacking empathy, but it's more than that.

2213
03:26:07.549 --> 03:26:15.950
<v Loretta Smith>They are targeting vulnerable individuals and families, leaving behind a trail of emotional distress and destruction and disruption.

2214
03:26:17.229 --> 03:26:26.030
<v Loretta Smith>Many ICE agents uphold an inhumane system, contributing to the separation of families and the perpetuation of injustice.

2215
03:26:27.069 --> 03:26:29.389
<v Loretta Smith>And so as a result, we're here today.

2216
03:26:31.229 --> 03:26:40.870
<v Loretta Smith>ICE has fueled widespread Widespread protests nationwide and in Oregon and calls for reforms reflecting a significant mistrust.

2217
03:26:41.430 --> 03:26:42.709
<v Loretta Smith>And that's what we're seeing here.

2218
03:26:43.190 --> 03:26:48.469
<v Loretta Smith>We have a significant mistrust between ICE officers and the communities that they serve.

2219
03:26:49.590 --> 03:26:51.030
<v Loretta Smith>But we also have a bigger problem.

2220
03:26:51.750 --> 03:27:02.610
<v Loretta Smith>We have an administration and a Supreme Court that is — is allowing ICE to do the things that they do.

2221
03:27:04.770 --> 03:27:12.209
<v Loretta Smith>And until we change what's happening at the top, what we're doing on the local level, I don't think it's going to change anything.

2222
03:27:13.649 --> 03:27:15.649
<v Loretta Smith>But it is not lost on me who ICE is.

2223
03:27:17.170 --> 03:27:17.969
<v Loretta Smith>They're kidnappers.

2224
03:27:19.170 --> 03:27:19.729
<v Loretta Smith>They're killers.

2225
03:27:21.250 --> 03:27:21.729
<v Loretta Smith>We know that.

2226
03:27:22.930 --> 03:27:23.489
<v Loretta Smith>And they're dangerous.

2227
03:27:23.569 --> 03:27:23.809
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2228
03:27:24.219 --> 03:27:25.180
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm afraid of them.

2229
03:27:26.139 --> 03:27:28.540
<v Loretta Smith>I'm afraid for my grandchildren.

2230
03:27:31.020 --> 03:27:33.340
<v Loretta Smith>I'm afraid for my son and his wife.

2231
03:27:35.180 --> 03:27:42.780
<v Loretta Smith>So for me, this is very, you know, it's something that I'm struggling with right now.

2232
03:27:45.180 --> 03:27:47.180
<v Loretta Smith>Because we've been talking about this for a long time.

2233
03:27:49.100 --> 03:27:49.500
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2234
03:27:51.530 --> 03:27:59.129
<v Loretta Smith>Sanctuary cities, sanctuary counties, those kinds of things, they give people a certain feeling about government.

2235
03:28:00.170 --> 03:28:09.770
<v Loretta Smith>But I would like to talk to the chief of police and say to him, are you going to follow this ordinance?

2236
03:28:10.569 --> 03:28:17.540
<v Loretta Smith>If they don't feel like this ordinance is something they should follow, What are we doing?

2237
03:28:18.340 --> 03:28:19.540
<v Loretta Smith>What are we changing?

2238
03:28:19.780 --> 03:28:20.579
<v Loretta Smith>How do we change it?

2239
03:28:21.860 --> 03:28:23.459
<v Loretta Smith>Because you can't legislate good sense.

2240
03:28:23.780 --> 03:28:24.579
<v Loretta Smith>I'm going to tell you that.

2241
03:28:25.860 --> 03:28:30.260
<v Loretta Smith>And my mom was here for the last 2 weeks, and she said common sense is just not common anymore.

2242
03:28:30.260 --> 03:28:31.059
<v Loretta Smith>And I agree with her.

2243
03:28:31.379 --> 03:28:33.620
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2244
03:28:33.860 --> 03:28:49.659
<v Loretta Smith>But this is something that I don't want our community councilors to feel that they have Any greater protections with these amendments in this actual ordinance than they do with the state law.

2245
03:28:50.379 --> 03:28:55.819
<v Loretta Smith>And I do agree that if, if it comes back, they're going to look at the state law and they're going to take away everything.

2246
03:28:57.500 --> 03:28:59.979
<v Loretta Smith>But right now, folks, we have a state law.

2247
03:29:00.139 --> 03:29:03.020
<v Loretta Smith>We have something that very few states have.

2248
03:29:03.899 --> 03:29:07.180
<v Loretta Smith>We have a great legislature, and I support them in what they did.

2249
03:29:07.180 --> 03:29:07.340
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2250
03:29:08.379 --> 03:29:13.899
<v Loretta Smith>But I'm really struggling right now to decide whether or not this is just something that's performative.

2251
03:29:14.299 --> 03:29:15.500
<v Loretta Smith>It's going to actually make a difference.

2252
03:29:16.219 --> 03:29:17.579
<v Loretta Smith>The police are going to follow it.

2253
03:29:18.139 --> 03:29:18.459
<v Loretta Smith>Will they?

2254
03:29:18.700 --> 03:29:19.020
<v Loretta Smith>Won't they?

2255
03:29:19.579 --> 03:29:20.299
<v Loretta Smith>Will it make a change?

2256
03:29:20.700 --> 03:29:26.379
<v Loretta Smith>Will they, will they do, do all those things that we think they're going to do and they're going to direct and write things down?

2257
03:29:27.020 --> 03:29:27.500
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know.

2258
03:29:27.579 --> 03:29:38.520
<v Loretta Smith>I want to ask the chief of police, are you going to, in this budget cycle, set aside some officers that are going to be Dedicated specifically to do this reporting?

2259
03:29:42.760 --> 03:29:44.760
<v Loretta Smith>All the officers will do it.

2260
03:29:46.280 --> 03:29:47.079
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, will they?

2261
03:29:48.600 --> 03:29:50.360
<v Loretta Smith>Well, if they're obeying the law.

2262
03:29:51.079 --> 03:29:51.479
<v Loretta Smith>We're not.

2263
03:29:53.079 --> 03:29:55.559
<v Loretta Smith>We're not even letting the mayor break a tie.

2264
03:29:56.120 --> 03:30:00.680
<v Loretta Smith>So we have different— I'm not going to let y'all off on that.

2265
03:30:01.500 --> 03:30:05.260
<v Loretta Smith>So anyway, I'm struggling with this and I'm not sure right now.

2266
03:30:06.780 --> 03:30:07.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

2267
03:30:08.139 --> 03:30:08.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

2268
03:30:10.620 --> 03:30:10.700
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

2269
03:30:11.100 --> 03:30:27.479
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I, I am hoping maybe after this first reading to have a conversation with you, Councilor Murillo, and Councilor, uh, Kanal, with respect to— I think you're talking about the compliance and reporting aspect when you mentioned in your I appreciate that.

2270
03:30:27.479 --> 03:30:27.959
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate that.

2271
03:30:27.959 --> 03:30:30.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate your speech about data tracking and like where they're going and what they're doing.

2272
03:30:30.840 --> 03:30:36.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll tell you what's not coming off the page to me is like where that is and what that, what that means.

2273
03:30:37.479 --> 03:30:47.079
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and I do want to understand if before we get to a second reading and a vote, if this will direct a, a data tracking system.

2274
03:30:47.399 --> 03:30:48.600
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I want to talk more about that.

2275
03:30:48.680 --> 03:31:15.879
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say that because I think this conversation, and I think frankly your, your ordinance I think this ordinance would be easier to pass and implement if, to your point, Councilor Kanal, you said sometimes people speak for us, third parties sometimes speak for us, but something got into the ether over the last couple of months to kind of say what this was versus what it wasn't.

2276
03:31:16.120 --> 03:31:17.399
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's unfortunate.

2277
03:31:17.799 --> 03:31:27.629
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it was hard for me to listen to Portlanders who thought we had the magic pen here when we won't.

2278
03:31:27.629 --> 03:31:47.120
<v Eric Zimmerman>And at the same time, I don't want this to be negative because I still am very happy about 4138 and knowing that all law enforcement officers in the state of Oregon who go through DPSST and are certified by our standards in the state of Oregon will be identifiable by their agency, by their public, without masks, Mm-hmm.

2279
03:31:48.319 --> 03:31:54.239
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's an important thing that the state legislature took on, and I don't ever want that to be lost.

2280
03:31:54.639 --> 03:32:07.120
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I definitely want to be supportive of, and I agree, I think with Councilor Clark's point, before the second reading, I too want to hear what the administration's take is on this new amendment.

2281
03:32:07.440 --> 03:32:09.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is a substantial change to it.

2282
03:32:10.719 --> 03:32:14.399
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate the severability aspect that was brought up.

2283
03:32:15.110 --> 03:32:19.909
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, because 4138 is a win that cannot be lost.

2284
03:32:20.149 --> 03:32:23.270
<v Eric Zimmerman>Like, that is a win for all Oregonians and all Portlanders.

2285
03:32:23.510 --> 03:32:27.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>And Portland Police were held up in writing that as the gold standard for how we do it.

2286
03:32:28.069 --> 03:32:37.670
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we're just— I think we're letting the desire maybe to go further shade the, the real big win on 4138.

2287
03:32:37.829 --> 03:32:42.780
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we should have— and Councilor Clark brought up, we might change our opinions later But we should have the talk about going further, et cetera.

2288
03:32:43.020 --> 03:32:48.459
<v Eric Zimmerman>But 4138 is a big win, and Willie Chotson and the representative in Southeast Portland was the leader there.

2289
03:32:48.540 --> 03:32:53.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm just, I hope for a couple more conversations, but thanks for the dialogue today.

2290
03:32:53.260 --> 03:32:54.059
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think I have what I need.

2291
03:32:54.940 --> 03:32:55.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2292
03:32:55.979 --> 03:32:57.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, last word.

2293
03:32:58.860 --> 03:32:58.940
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

2294
03:33:00.139 --> 03:33:02.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>With that, I'm gonna move this item to second reading.

2295
03:33:02.780 --> 03:33:06.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could we please call item number 9?

2296
03:33:07.909 --> 03:33:17.270
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 9, amend arts tax code to provide tax relief, promote sustainability of Arts Access Fund, define critical terms, and respond to community and audit recommendations.

2297
03:33:17.829 --> 03:33:22.229
<v Unidentified speaker>Amend Code Chapter 6.10, document number 2026-147.

2298
03:33:23.030 --> 03:33:27.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is a continued first reading of our, uh, last hearing.

2299
03:33:27.270 --> 03:33:30.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>We heard testimony last time and, and continued the hearing.

2300
03:33:31.110 --> 03:33:34.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am going to be Actually, I'll look.

2301
03:33:34.750 --> 03:33:36.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, there is an amendment on the table.

2302
03:33:36.510 --> 03:33:38.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal last week introduced an amendment.

2303
03:33:39.389 --> 03:33:49.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, working with Councilor Kanal and Pirtle-Guiney and Koyama Lane, we now have introduced Kanal, Dunphy, Pirtle-Guiney, Koyama Lane 1, which should be in your inboxes.

2304
03:33:50.270 --> 03:33:57.870
<v Jamie Dunphy>This amendment combines the suggestions of Kanal 1 with additional feedback from the current membership of the Arts Access Fund Oversight Committee.

2305
03:33:57.950 --> 03:33:58.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2306
03:33:59.000 --> 03:34:03.239
<v Jamie Dunphy>The underlying ordinance proposes a range of possible committee membership sizes from 5 to 11.

2307
03:34:03.799 --> 03:34:14.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>Per Kanal 1, emerging citywide best practice is to have a fixed number of seats on advisory boards, in part to maintain a clear and predictable standard for quorum regardless of whether there are unfilled seats.

2308
03:34:15.079 --> 03:34:18.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>As such, this amendment moves to a fixed size for the oversight committee.

2309
03:34:19.319 --> 03:34:24.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>The executive committee of the Arts Access Fund Oversight Committee offered a few suggestions for improvement of this section.

2310
03:34:24.909 --> 03:34:45.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>Including reducing the size of the committee from 11 to 9 to ease quorum requirements and expanding the membership definitions of— from parents of K-5 students to parents of K-12 students in light of concerns that parents with very young children have greater difficulty participating in volunteer evening activities and may wish to engage with their committee as they grow older.

2311
03:34:45.950 --> 03:34:50.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the language is redlined and it should be in your inbox.

2312
03:34:50.829 --> 03:34:58.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I am moving Kanal, Dunphy, Pirtle-Guiney, Koyama Lane 1, and would entertain a second.

2313
03:34:58.510 --> 03:34:59.229
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

2314
03:34:59.549 --> 03:35:00.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane seconds.

2315
03:35:02.030 --> 03:35:04.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, is there discussion of the amendment?

2316
03:35:05.069 --> 03:35:05.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

2317
03:35:06.030 --> 03:35:10.430
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not sure if I need to say this live because we moved it last time, but I do want to formally withdraw the previous amendment.

2318
03:35:10.590 --> 03:35:11.309
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, that's fine.

2319
03:35:11.309 --> 03:35:11.629
<v Sameer Kanal>Apologies.

2320
03:35:12.270 --> 03:35:13.229
<v Sameer Kanal>Just to get that on the record.

2321
03:35:13.469 --> 03:35:19.040
<v Sameer Kanal>And I appreciate all the work that you have done, Council President, as well as the, the members of the committee for weighing in.

2322
03:35:19.120 --> 03:35:19.600
<v Sameer Kanal>I support this.

2323
03:35:19.680 --> 03:35:19.760
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

2324
03:35:20.319 --> 03:35:20.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2325
03:35:22.079 --> 03:35:24.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any further discussion of the amendment?

2326
03:35:26.639 --> 03:35:31.040
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we call a roll on Kanal, Dunphy, Pirtle-Guiney, Koyama Lane 1?

2327
03:35:32.959 --> 03:35:33.120
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

2328
03:35:33.760 --> 03:35:33.840
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2329
03:35:34.639 --> 03:35:35.200
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

2330
03:35:36.079 --> 03:35:36.159
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

2331
03:35:37.120 --> 03:35:37.200
<v Angelita Morillo>Ryan?

2332
03:35:37.760 --> 03:35:37.840
<v Dan Ryan>No.

2333
03:35:39.120 --> 03:35:39.600
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

2334
03:35:39.920 --> 03:35:40.159
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2335
03:35:40.879 --> 03:35:41.120
<v Steve Novick>Morillo?

2336
03:35:41.520 --> 03:35:42.319
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2337
03:35:42.969 --> 03:35:43.209
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick.

2338
03:35:43.530 --> 03:35:43.610
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

2339
03:35:44.409 --> 03:35:44.489
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark.

2340
03:35:44.969 --> 03:35:45.049
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2341
03:35:45.770 --> 03:35:45.850
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

2342
03:35:46.729 --> 03:35:47.049
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2343
03:35:47.530 --> 03:35:47.930
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman.

2344
03:35:48.250 --> 03:35:48.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

2345
03:35:48.969 --> 03:35:49.290
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos.

2346
03:35:49.690 --> 03:35:49.770
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2347
03:35:50.569 --> 03:35:50.649
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

2348
03:35:51.370 --> 03:35:51.450
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2349
03:35:52.329 --> 03:35:52.649
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy.

2350
03:35:52.969 --> 03:35:53.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2351
03:35:53.690 --> 03:35:56.010
<v Unidentified speaker>Amendment is approved with 11 aye, 1 nay vote.

2352
03:35:56.649 --> 03:35:57.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, colleagues.

2353
03:35:58.090 --> 03:36:02.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, to the underlying— to the discussion of the underlying bill now.

2354
03:36:06.889 --> 03:36:07.209
<v Jamie Dunphy>Everyone's ready.

2355
03:36:08.090 --> 03:36:08.409
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

2356
03:36:17.590 --> 03:36:30.549
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I appreciate that there were some changes at the same time that there was an exemption for others, right?

2357
03:36:30.549 --> 03:36:34.069
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that that moving off the $1,000 is an important topic.

2358
03:36:35.040 --> 03:36:40.639
<v Eric Zimmerman>In committee, I really was hoping that we could actually do what I thought committees were designed to do, which is work through some stuff.

2359
03:36:40.799 --> 03:36:44.239
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the committee chair just kind of took the vote, and I thought that was pretty unfortunate.

2360
03:36:44.959 --> 03:36:54.959
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'll tell you, I just— I, I am not going to vote to raise taxes on a minimum wage Portlander by 42%.

2361
03:36:54.959 --> 03:36:55.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just not going to do it.

2362
03:36:56.239 --> 03:37:01.600
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that was worthy of conversation.

2363
03:37:01.600 --> 03:37:02.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Dan Ryan.

2364
03:37:02.729 --> 03:37:13.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we bundled it with the fixes I think that the revenue division has outlined in terms of just some of the silliness of how people file and things like that.

2365
03:37:14.090 --> 03:37:37.360
<v Eric Zimmerman>And while I want to be supportive of those changes, raising up that threshold at a time when affordability is becoming not the weekly topic but now the, the daily topic when I'm in the community And frankly, I don't know what the substantive difference is when you're talking about below minimum wage and a new tax.

2366
03:37:37.680 --> 03:37:50.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that if you wanted to talk about where does it come in, you talk about a real number where it comes in, and you say, we admit as an organization, as a society, as a city, that we want this thing to kick in at— and then you name a number.

2367
03:37:50.799 --> 03:37:52.959
<v Eric Zimmerman>But if you go to minimum wage, I'm not doing that.

2368
03:37:53.200 --> 03:37:53.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I—.

2369
03:37:53.840 --> 03:37:54.159
<v Steve Novick>Councilor Dan Ryan.

2370
03:37:55.489 --> 03:38:01.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that if there is a stomach for changing some of the other stuff, that you separate out the two.

2371
03:38:01.489 --> 03:38:11.649
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I find a tax raise right now on top of the TUF, on top of the utility fees, to be a thing that is just a bridge too far.

2372
03:38:11.889 --> 03:38:19.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>And frankly, not a city who has, I think, come far enough in terms of identifying what its core is before we just raise taxes, raise taxes, raise taxes.

2373
03:38:19.569 --> 03:38:20.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Dan Ryan.

2374
03:38:20.530 --> 03:38:20.850
<v Dan Ryan>Raise taxes.

2375
03:38:21.250 --> 03:38:27.969
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think I am in not just the minority, but a very deep minority, and I will be happy in my little deep minority there.

2376
03:38:28.209 --> 03:38:30.049
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I did have to just say that.

2377
03:38:30.290 --> 03:38:46.209
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know that there's a lot of passion around this, and I know that it provides great stuff in our community, which is why it was worthy of more conversation and more correct fixes than the time that we were given it at committee when it was rushed through to a vote after we expired in time.

2378
03:38:47.670 --> 03:38:48.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2379
03:38:48.790 --> 03:38:49.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

2380
03:38:50.229 --> 03:38:50.870
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

2381
03:38:52.790 --> 03:39:06.069
<v Steve Novick>I think I might have seniority here in hating the arts tax because I was one of the few politicians who opposed it when it was on the ballot in 2012 because it's both administratively ridiculous and ridiculously regressive.

2382
03:39:06.870 --> 03:39:19.170
<v Steve Novick>I appreciate the council president's effort to improve it, but I'm not going to be able to support something that still leaves us with with a goofy little standalone tax where people making $40,000 a year make— pay the same as people paying a million.

2383
03:39:21.010 --> 03:39:27.729
<v Steve Novick>And I think that we should try to reform the arts tax in a way that gets rid of it as a standalone tax.

2384
03:39:28.049 --> 03:39:35.649
<v Steve Novick>My preferred method would be to send out an early renewal of the children's levy and have it be a children and arts levy.

2385
03:39:36.290 --> 03:39:46.190
<v Steve Novick>It largely serves children anyway and sort of add the arts tax into And that would eliminate the administrative cost of administering a standalone tax.

2386
03:39:46.430 --> 03:39:50.590
<v Steve Novick>It would eliminate people's personal annoyance with having to pay an extra tax.

2387
03:39:51.790 --> 03:39:53.950
<v Steve Novick>So that's something I'm going to come back and propose.

2388
03:39:54.989 --> 03:40:04.989
<v Steve Novick>But again, I really appreciate the effort, but I think this is an example where the phrase putting lipstick on a pig is really unfair to pigs because pigs are smart and the arts tax is stupid.

2389
03:40:05.069 --> 03:40:05.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2390
03:40:06.840 --> 03:40:07.799
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

2391
03:40:08.920 --> 03:40:09.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2392
03:40:11.799 --> 03:40:12.680
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you.

2393
03:40:14.200 --> 03:40:19.479
<v Mitch Green>I always have to follow Councilor Novick right after he's made some joke, and I'm the sucker for, for bad jokes.

2394
03:40:20.200 --> 03:40:21.799
<v Steve Novick>Um, that was not a joke, Councilor.

2395
03:40:22.280 --> 03:40:23.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, just funny.

2396
03:40:24.520 --> 03:40:25.159
<v Mitch Green>Anyway, it made me laugh.

2397
03:40:25.479 --> 03:40:27.639
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I, I have a question for you, Council President.

2398
03:40:27.879 --> 03:40:31.079
<v Mitch Green>So I just want to make sure I understand that this is a— this is net of deductions.

2399
03:40:32.000 --> 03:40:34.079
<v Mitch Green>Right, this is your adjusted gross income, basically?

2400
03:40:34.159 --> 03:40:34.479
<v Dan Ryan>Correct.

2401
03:40:34.559 --> 03:40:36.719
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's a very important thing to establish.

2402
03:40:36.719 --> 03:40:49.200
<v Mitch Green>So if we don't— if we don't adopt this amendment, then, uh, we will keep in place a tax that has the highest burden rate for people who make the least amount of money in the city of Portland.

2403
03:40:49.280 --> 03:40:50.559
<v Mitch Green>That's currently what happens.

2404
03:40:50.719 --> 03:41:00.459
<v Mitch Green>Currently, if you make $1,000— and that's not, to my knowledge, net of deductions, that's $1,000 of gross income— Um, you're going to pay $35 a year.

2405
03:41:01.340 --> 03:41:04.860
<v Mitch Green>And if we were to— and then, you know, I would pay $35 a year.

2406
03:41:04.860 --> 03:41:05.739
<v Mitch Green>I make a lot more than that.

2407
03:41:06.379 --> 03:41:10.540
<v Mitch Green>Um, and if we did adopt this, no, it's not perfect.

2408
03:41:10.860 --> 03:41:22.459
<v Mitch Green>No, it's— it, you know, if I had my druthers, we would go out and we would tax the largest corporations for every last cent that we could get, and we would fund all of our great things with those revenues, and we would cut fees and utility rates for the city of Portland.

2409
03:41:22.540 --> 03:41:38.819
<v Mitch Green>But I don't have my druthers What we do have is an opportunity to make this less regressive than it is, to provide relief to families or households that, you know, I bet a minimum wage filer after they filed their deductions would not have to pay this tax, but I'm not a tax expert.

2410
03:41:40.260 --> 03:41:49.139
<v Mitch Green>The point I'm trying to make here is this makes it better for those of us who have the least in our community while also delivering arts programming for those that deserve that too.

2411
03:41:49.139 --> 03:41:49.620
<v Mitch Green>Councilmember Dan Ryan.

2412
03:41:50.510 --> 03:41:52.190
<v Mitch Green>And particularly our children in our schools.

2413
03:41:52.190 --> 03:41:54.110
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm going to support it for that reason.

2414
03:41:54.829 --> 03:41:59.870
<v Mitch Green>I think that we must have a broader conversation about revenue reform in this city.

2415
03:42:00.110 --> 03:42:02.989
<v Mitch Green>It needs to be a partnership with Metro County.

2416
03:42:02.989 --> 03:42:05.229
<v Mitch Green>It needs to be a partnership with the state of Oregon.

2417
03:42:05.549 --> 03:42:12.190
<v Mitch Green>We have to come together and figure out who we want to tax in this state, because right now we're not taxing the wealthiest people in this state like we should.

2418
03:42:12.270 --> 03:42:14.030
<v Mitch Green>And so we're, we're suffering for it.

2419
03:42:14.030 --> 03:42:14.829
<v Mitch Green>So I'm going to support it.

2420
03:42:14.829 --> 03:42:15.229
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Dan Ryan.

2421
03:42:15.559 --> 03:42:16.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

2422
03:42:16.680 --> 03:42:18.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

2423
03:42:21.319 --> 03:42:23.200
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

2424
03:42:25.000 --> 03:42:36.280
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do first want to acknowledge the concerns that I hear from constituents who wish that there were more tiers in this reform, opportunities for public feedback throughout the process.

2425
03:42:36.280 --> 03:42:39.399
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's really real and makes a lot of sense.

2426
03:42:39.399 --> 03:42:41.959
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think, believe those concerns are valid.

2427
03:42:43.069 --> 03:42:49.870
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think it's important that we continue to be working with community and listening and talking about affordability, equity, and implementation.

2428
03:42:50.750 --> 03:42:53.309
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I also know that there's a bit of a deadline.

2429
03:42:53.549 --> 03:42:58.989
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We have to get this done by early June in order for this to apply to next tax season.

2430
03:43:01.309 --> 03:43:06.430
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And because at this— knowing all of those things, I do think the reform moves us in a better direction.

2431
03:43:06.750 --> 03:43:14.600
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's going to relieve about 44% of current filers from paying for this, for this being an obligation.

2432
03:43:15.000 --> 03:43:20.680
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that means that significantly fewer people will be required to pay the arts tax.

2433
03:43:21.959 --> 03:43:24.360
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to reiterate that it's not a new tax.

2434
03:43:24.360 --> 03:43:26.040
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's a reform of an existing tax.

2435
03:43:26.840 --> 03:43:30.920
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And we know that it's been increasingly unsustainable over time.

2436
03:43:32.760 --> 03:43:38.319
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will say, as a mom and educator, I see every day How art is important to kids.

2437
03:43:38.879 --> 03:43:42.959
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Helps kids think, express themselves, feel a sense of belonging.

2438
03:43:43.840 --> 03:43:47.680
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I really do believe that our tax policy should be supporting that.

2439
03:43:49.040 --> 03:43:50.639
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And inflation is real.

2440
03:43:51.280 --> 03:44:09.850
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The adjustment from $35,000 to $50,000 in order to account for inflation since 2012 is really important and isn't— I think it will stabilize funding and prevent major future cuts to our local arts organizations and to many art teachers who really do depend on this funding stream.

2441
03:44:12.649 --> 03:44:16.090
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So this is kind of that multiple things can be true at the same time.

2442
03:44:16.569 --> 03:44:25.770
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I do think that this reform is important and it's about reducing who has to pay at that lower end and recognizing people's real financial constraints.

2443
03:44:25.930 --> 03:44:27.129
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>This conversation's not over.

2444
03:44:28.010 --> 03:44:28.409
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

2445
03:44:28.870 --> 03:44:37.909
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And to me, this ordinance is about sustainability, fairness, and preserving access to the arts for current generations and future ones.

2446
03:44:38.790 --> 03:44:45.270
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Council President and Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, I'm really proud to co-sponsor this with both of you, and thank you very much.

2447
03:44:45.750 --> 03:44:46.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

2448
03:44:47.270 --> 03:44:47.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

2449
03:44:50.069 --> 03:44:50.309
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2450
03:44:51.030 --> 03:44:54.309
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I'll reiterate what everyone has been saying.

2451
03:44:55.450 --> 03:45:10.010
<v Candace Avalos>I definitely think this is difficult at a time where affordability is really challenging, and I— but I appreciate the work that's been done to make this reform, especially to exempt many Portlanders.

2452
03:45:10.170 --> 03:45:19.850
<v Candace Avalos>I think it's important that we pause though on the fact that 44%, I think it was, is Portlanders that are making $20,000 or less or $40,000 or less joint files.

2453
03:45:20.659 --> 03:45:23.219
<v Candace Avalos>That, that is staggering to me.

2454
03:45:23.620 --> 03:45:29.780
<v Candace Avalos>And that to me, like, really explains the broader economic crisis that we're struggling with.

2455
03:45:29.860 --> 03:45:33.940
<v Candace Avalos>It's way beyond this arts tax, the broader affordability crisis.

2456
03:45:34.500 --> 03:45:39.780
<v Candace Avalos>And, you know, people are struggling with housing costs and groceries and utilities, and this explains it.

2457
03:45:39.940 --> 03:45:50.500
<v Candace Avalos>So I just want to zoom in on that because to Councilor Green's point, there are a lot of people who are struggling and we keep asking them for more and we're not asking for the people that have it.

2458
03:45:50.500 --> 03:45:50.659
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2459
03:45:51.159 --> 03:45:51.479
<v Candace Avalos>For more.

2460
03:45:52.440 --> 03:46:00.600
<v Candace Avalos>So I think that this is an important step that we need to take to exempt those Portlanders, to sustain the fund, because arts education is important.

2461
03:46:01.399 --> 03:46:12.520
<v Candace Avalos>I was asked recently on an interview whether, like, what should people who don't have children, how they should feel about the arts tax and if they find that it has value.

2462
03:46:12.760 --> 03:46:14.440
<v Candace Avalos>And I said, absolutely it has value.

2463
03:46:15.079 --> 03:46:28.790
<v Candace Avalos>I don't have children, but I still deeply see the value and the impact of arts education because it really is something that creates opportunities for young people to dream and to imagine and to explore their creativity, build their confidence in themselves and in their voices.

2464
03:46:29.110 --> 03:46:31.190
<v Candace Avalos>And that matters for all of us as a society.

2465
03:46:32.309 --> 03:46:37.909
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that whether we have children or not, we have a responsibility to contribute to that for our next generation.

2466
03:46:38.950 --> 03:46:45.190
<v Candace Avalos>To quote James Baldwin, the children are always ours, every single one of them, all over the globe.

2467
03:46:45.829 --> 03:46:59.250
<v Candace Avalos>And so for those reasons, while I think there are still larger conversations we need to continue having about equity and affordability, I do plan to support this, and I thank the sponsors for putting us in the right direction towards that conversation.

2468
03:46:59.649 --> 03:46:59.729
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

2469
03:47:00.049 --> 03:47:00.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

2470
03:47:01.250 --> 03:47:01.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

2471
03:47:01.969 --> 03:47:03.090
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

2472
03:47:03.409 --> 03:47:07.649
<v Dan Ryan>I'm an enthusiastic arts supporter, and I'm a consistent supporter of children and youth.

2473
03:47:08.209 --> 03:47:12.690
<v Dan Ryan>I fought hard to get money into the PPS budget for arts as a school board member in the aughts.

2474
03:47:12.850 --> 03:47:13.569
<v Dan Ryan>It was really difficult.

2475
03:47:14.930 --> 03:47:15.569
<v Dan Ryan>We got some in.

2476
03:47:16.049 --> 03:47:19.250
<v Dan Ryan>My biggest takeaway, though, from this conversation is that this is exactly what we need to do.

2477
03:47:19.219 --> 03:47:30.340
<v Dan Ryan>This is the exact type of item that needs to go back to the voters to decide how they want to fund the arts moving forward since they adopted the original version at the ballot box in 2012.

2478
03:47:31.700 --> 03:47:36.659
<v Dan Ryan>Thus, on principle, to no one's surprise, I cannot support this process to increase taxes from the dais.

2479
03:47:37.219 --> 03:47:38.739
<v Dan Ryan>This should be decided by the voters.

2480
03:47:39.700 --> 03:47:39.780
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

2481
03:47:40.420 --> 03:47:41.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

2482
03:47:41.700 --> 03:47:42.420
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

2483
03:47:43.700 --> 03:47:44.579
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

2484
03:47:45.870 --> 03:47:47.709
<v Angelita Morillo>The arts tax, totally annoying.

2485
03:47:49.629 --> 03:47:51.309
<v Angelita Morillo>Very annoying to have to deal with it every year.

2486
03:47:53.149 --> 03:47:54.510
<v Angelita Morillo>And it's a ridiculous threshold.

2487
03:47:54.989 --> 03:47:55.229
<v Angelita Morillo>$1,000?

2488
03:47:56.030 --> 03:47:56.670
<v Angelita Morillo>You've got to be kidding.

2489
03:47:58.030 --> 03:48:02.110
<v Angelita Morillo>So we've simplified it, as Councilor Green mentioned.

2490
03:48:03.790 --> 03:48:09.870
<v Angelita Morillo>We've recognized income disparity, which is, I think, a point that Councilor Avalos was trying to make, which is a much bigger issue than just Portland and Oregon.

2491
03:48:09.950 --> 03:48:10.670
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's a fair point.

2492
03:48:10.670 --> 03:48:10.829
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2493
03:48:12.590 --> 03:48:18.110
<v Angelita Morillo>But colleagues, I'm here today on this dais because of the arts.

2494
03:48:19.629 --> 03:48:30.510
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I've told you a little bit about my background, not all of it, but as a young person, it was the arts that got me to college and the arts that got me a scholarship to college.

2495
03:48:31.629 --> 03:48:43.079
<v Angelita Morillo>So when I think about the arts tax, I think about all those young people who will succeed through the arts who will rise up out of their beginnings and be successful.

2496
03:48:43.600 --> 03:48:48.639
<v Angelita Morillo>So I appreciate the leadership of President Dunphy, who's been working on this for multiple years.

2497
03:48:50.000 --> 03:48:54.079
<v Angelita Morillo>The effort to reform it, I think, is a good one, and I will be a yes vote.

2498
03:48:54.319 --> 03:48:55.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

2499
03:48:55.920 --> 03:48:57.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

2500
03:48:58.079 --> 03:48:58.479
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2501
03:48:58.559 --> 03:49:02.639
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I believe we're technically in the discussion of the amendment still.

2502
03:49:03.129 --> 03:49:03.930
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that accurate?

2503
03:49:04.569 --> 03:49:05.129
<v Dan Ryan>No, we passed that.

2504
03:49:05.610 --> 03:49:06.569
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, yeah, I'm mistaken.

2505
03:49:06.729 --> 03:49:08.250
<v Sameer Kanal>I just— yeah, it's been going.

2506
03:49:08.569 --> 03:49:10.969
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I think this is— yeah, my mistake.

2507
03:49:11.129 --> 03:49:28.409
<v Sameer Kanal>I first wanted to say I really appreciated the, uh, reminder of the Baldwin quote, um, because the remainder of that is, um, something to the effect of, and I'm beginning to suspect, that anyone who is incapable of recognizing that is incapable of morality, or something to that effect.

2508
03:49:28.739 --> 03:49:33.299
<v Candace Avalos>And I am beginning to suspect that whoever is incapable of recognizing this may be incapable of morality.

2509
03:49:33.540 --> 03:49:34.420
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks for sharing the rest of it.

2510
03:49:34.500 --> 03:49:36.020
<v Steve Novick>Oh, I cut it off because of time.

2511
03:49:36.260 --> 03:49:45.219
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, no, I, I, but I think it is a question of we, we, um, taxes are the price we pay for civilization, and this is a part of that, I think.

2512
03:49:45.540 --> 03:49:48.579
<v Sameer Kanal>Having said that, I agree completely that $1,000 is ridiculous.

2513
03:49:49.139 --> 03:49:51.940
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm really open to longer-term conversations around this.

2514
03:49:51.940 --> 03:49:56.270
<v Sameer Kanal>I think this, this ordinance as a whole Makes it significantly better.

2515
03:49:56.350 --> 03:50:01.309
<v Sameer Kanal>And I guess the question is, you know, how— it's not incrementalism in the sense of very small.

2516
03:50:01.549 --> 03:50:02.750
<v Sameer Kanal>It is a significant step.

2517
03:50:03.309 --> 03:50:05.709
<v Sameer Kanal>It also does not address all the underlying issues.

2518
03:50:05.950 --> 03:50:09.229
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that the sponsors have been very, very upfront about that.

2519
03:50:09.389 --> 03:50:18.430
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to highlight 610120 as a really important thing where we actually put into our code Consumer Price Index adjustments.

2520
03:50:18.670 --> 03:50:18.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Mm-hmm.

2521
03:50:19.469 --> 03:50:22.079
<v Sameer Kanal>And we are building that up both on the rate Yes.

2522
03:50:22.399 --> 03:50:28.079
<v Sameer Kanal>And on the amount of income that, that is necessary to make in order to have to pay this.

2523
03:50:29.600 --> 03:50:47.360
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that we will likely end up moving this piece of code to another area and having several other pieces of code reference it at some point because we need to be doing this for a lot of our taxes, whatever particular purpose they serve.

2524
03:50:47.520 --> 03:50:54.299
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to highlight that because it hadn't been mentioned yet, but I'm I'm broadly supportive of this and also recognize that it is not the end of the conversation.

2525
03:50:55.659 --> 03:50:56.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

2526
03:50:56.700 --> 03:50:57.340
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

2527
03:50:58.700 --> 03:50:59.579
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

2528
03:51:01.340 --> 03:51:02.219
<v Loretta Smith>I like the art tax.

2529
03:51:03.420 --> 03:51:04.700
<v Loretta Smith>I think this— it's important.

2530
03:51:05.180 --> 03:51:05.420
<v Loretta Smith>I do.

2531
03:51:07.180 --> 03:51:12.379
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, I think it's important for our young people to have art in their life.

2532
03:51:13.500 --> 03:51:20.520
<v Loretta Smith>And if any of you follow me on social media, you'll probably see the majority of stuff that that I do is around my grandchildren.

2533
03:51:21.959 --> 03:51:23.879
<v Loretta Smith>And I think it's, it's so important.

2534
03:51:25.000 --> 03:51:34.200
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, people who have art in their world and music, they have a higher rate of going to, um, to college.

2535
03:51:34.360 --> 03:51:35.440
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2536
03:51:36.360 --> 03:51:48.770
<v Loretta Smith>But the other piece that I'm also struggling with right now is that this was a voter-approved Uh, tax, and I think it needs to go back to the voters.

2537
03:51:50.049 --> 03:51:53.329
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, I asked the question last week of Robert Taylor.

2538
03:51:54.610 --> 03:52:19.979
<v Loretta Smith>Um, there are increases that happen automatically without coming back to either council or to the public, and I don't know how this measure— how it lines up with the, um, the children's levy If the same thing is true of the children's levy, could we just put in a different policy in code and increase the children's levy?

2539
03:52:21.579 --> 03:52:27.819
<v Loretta Smith>I think the real big issue here is Oregon does not have a sales tax, and that's what we're dealing with right here.

2540
03:52:28.059 --> 03:52:29.659
<v Loretta Smith>And no one wants to really have that question.

2541
03:52:30.700 --> 03:52:40.540
<v Loretta Smith>And I'd like these great minds that sit up here to figure out a way that that is a conversation In the bigger conversation of how do we pay for things.

2542
03:52:41.500 --> 03:52:46.860
<v Loretta Smith>I think our property taxes are higher because we don't have those things, but we're taxing people.

2543
03:52:47.100 --> 03:52:51.500
<v Loretta Smith>And this has to probably be the most tax-happy city council that I've seen in a long time.

2544
03:52:52.459 --> 03:52:56.219
<v Loretta Smith>The water tax, the TUF tax, the this tax, that tax.

2545
03:52:58.139 --> 03:53:03.180
<v Loretta Smith>My district, the average household makes about $60,000 a year.

2546
03:53:05.219 --> 03:53:08.579
<v Loretta Smith>They cannot afford all these little bitty taxes.

2547
03:53:09.059 --> 03:53:12.260
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, we're just nickel and diming them to death.

2548
03:53:13.940 --> 03:53:17.299
<v Loretta Smith>And I think that we need to be very clear.

2549
03:53:18.020 --> 03:53:25.459
<v Loretta Smith>And I really have a lot of respect for the sponsors of this, of this measure, because they do think about people.

2550
03:53:25.700 --> 03:53:26.420
<v Loretta Smith>They care about people.

2551
03:53:26.579 --> 03:53:27.299
<v Loretta Smith>They care about diversity.

2552
03:53:27.620 --> 03:53:29.700
<v Loretta Smith>They care about housing equity and all those things.

2553
03:53:29.940 --> 03:53:32.319
<v Loretta Smith>And, and And we all have that in common.

2554
03:53:33.280 --> 03:53:45.200
<v Loretta Smith>But I think that at one point we have to get very creative and not be lazy about looking at our current budget and how we can pay for things.

2555
03:53:46.159 --> 03:53:50.159
<v Loretta Smith>It's easy to get low-hanging fruit and say, oh, I'll increase that because that's easy.

2556
03:53:51.280 --> 03:53:53.200
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, I'll take that away because that's easy.

2557
03:53:54.239 --> 03:54:05.129
<v Loretta Smith>I really want us to really be very, um, curious and have a, a rigorous understanding of our budget.

2558
03:54:06.010 --> 03:54:18.409
<v Loretta Smith>Because I believe there are things in our budget and there are ways to pay for stuff that you want to pay for, whether it be arts or other things that we already have in our budget, but we just have not got the total command of it yet.

2559
03:54:19.610 --> 03:54:28.510
<v Loretta Smith>And the easy thing to do is, oh, let's talk to operations, let's figure out a tax And that's not the way to go, especially when this was put on the ballot.

2560
03:54:29.309 --> 03:54:31.389
<v Loretta Smith>And I know you know about this, Councilor Novick.

2561
03:54:31.790 --> 03:54:33.069
<v Loretta Smith>This is very personal.

2562
03:54:34.430 --> 03:54:48.989
<v Loretta Smith>So, um, I'm just— I, I appreciate what, what you did because, Councilor Dunphy, I remember we were at a campaign event in 2024 and we sat on that stage in downtown at that place.

2563
03:54:49.229 --> 03:54:53.809
<v Loretta Smith>I can't Call the name of the, um, it's over in, uh, Northwest.

2564
03:54:54.290 --> 03:55:00.530
<v Loretta Smith>And he said, he was asked the question, he said, I am going to change the art tax.

2565
03:55:01.569 --> 03:55:03.809
<v Loretta Smith>And he is making good on his promise.

2566
03:55:05.250 --> 03:55:08.850
<v Loretta Smith>And so I appreciate you following up and really doing that.

2567
03:55:08.930 --> 03:55:13.729
<v Loretta Smith>I remember that you said that, and, um, I was like, oh wow, that's very ambitious.

2568
03:55:13.969 --> 03:55:18.090
<v Loretta Smith>I, I probably wouldn't say that out the first thing out of the gate that I was going to do a tax.

2569
03:55:19.770 --> 03:55:21.049
<v Loretta Smith>But I appreciate it.

2570
03:55:21.129 --> 03:55:21.770
<v Loretta Smith>I understand it.

2571
03:55:22.170 --> 03:55:24.569
<v Loretta Smith>And I know the history of this.

2572
03:55:24.969 --> 03:55:27.049
<v Loretta Smith>And I think it's good.

2573
03:55:27.450 --> 03:55:28.170
<v Loretta Smith>I like the art tax.

2574
03:55:28.250 --> 03:55:29.370
<v Loretta Smith>And I can pay some more art tax.

2575
03:55:29.610 --> 03:55:30.489
<v Loretta Smith>I can pay $100.

2576
03:55:31.290 --> 03:55:34.889
<v Loretta Smith>But I just don't think this is the right way to do what we're doing right now.

2577
03:55:35.850 --> 03:55:36.090
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2578
03:55:36.329 --> 03:55:37.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

2579
03:55:37.770 --> 03:55:38.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

2580
03:55:40.090 --> 03:55:41.129
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy.

2581
03:55:42.389 --> 03:55:44.309
<v Angelita Morillo>I think this is very simple.

2582
03:55:44.950 --> 03:55:48.229
<v Angelita Morillo>Arts are good, arts tax bad and inequitable.

2583
03:55:48.629 --> 03:55:58.389
<v Angelita Morillo>This amendment makes it slightly more equitable, but we should also be taxing the rich, and unfortunately we can't do that at the local level, so we are stuck trying to do TUFs and things like that to create sidewalks.

2584
03:55:58.549 --> 03:56:03.750
<v Angelita Morillo>We are stuck trying to fund the arts in ways that we should frankly be able to do in other ways.

2585
03:56:04.870 --> 03:56:16.209
<v Angelita Morillo>I am very glad to hear that my colleagues care about the will of the voters, I hope we keep that in mind for the Portland Clean Energy Fund, and I'm also glad that people care about sending things to the ballot because maybe we can do that for MOTA as well.

2586
03:56:16.850 --> 03:56:18.129
<v Angelita Morillo>So I will be supporting this.

2587
03:56:18.530 --> 03:56:18.770
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2588
03:56:19.809 --> 03:56:20.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

2589
03:56:21.569 --> 03:56:23.170
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, thank you for your comments.

2590
03:56:23.569 --> 03:56:27.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to just say I, on the one hand, absolutely agree.

2591
03:56:28.129 --> 03:56:46.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>Everybody— affordability is an enormous challenge right now, and everybody is suffering for reasons that are within government control and reasons that are outside of I— if I were inventing a way to pay for arts teachers and the arts in the city, I would not do it the way the arts tax is set up.

2592
03:56:46.540 --> 03:56:51.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I fully agree, Councilor Novick, that we are in many ways putting lipstick on a pig.

2593
03:56:52.139 --> 03:56:56.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a voter-approved tax that we are trying to meet the moment with.

2594
03:56:57.819 --> 03:57:15.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>There were some real challenges with how it was originally implemented, to the point where The former city councils have on 5 separate occasions taken legislative action to help change the language that was approved by voters and make it sustainable, including the $1,000 exemption.

2595
03:57:15.909 --> 03:57:24.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>So as has been said, Portlanders love art, Portlanders love kids, everyone hates the arts tax.

2596
03:57:24.469 --> 03:57:36.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are doing as best as we can to try and make this less annoying and sustainable for the future, long-term, and, uh, will continue to demonstrate the will of what the voters originally passed.

2597
03:57:36.239 --> 03:57:44.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if we can come up with something else that is more robust and easier to pay and, uh, accomplishes the same things, I am very open to those conversations.

2598
03:57:44.479 --> 03:57:54.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>So seeing no one else in the queue for discussion, we're— this item now moves to second reading.

2599
03:57:54.350 --> 03:57:55.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Herbold.

2600
03:57:55.069 --> 03:57:55.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>That concludes our public comment meeting.

2601
03:57:55.790 --> 03:57:57.629
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item 10?

2602
03:57:58.909 --> 03:58:11.549
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 10, authorize water revenue bonds to finance water system capital improvements for an amount sufficient to produce net proceeds of up to $525 million to refund outstanding water revenue bonds.

2603
03:58:11.870 --> 03:58:14.350
<v Unidentified speaker>Document number 2026-134.

2604
03:58:15.950 --> 03:58:20.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have Claire Adamsick from Council Ops here to give us a committee staff summary.

2605
03:58:20.559 --> 03:58:22.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

2606
03:58:23.280 --> 03:58:23.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>Claire, take it away.

2607
03:58:24.319 --> 03:58:25.760
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President and councilors.

2608
03:58:25.920 --> 03:58:29.840
<v Angelita Morillo>Again, for the record, Claire Adamsick, Council Policy Analyst and staff to the Public Works Committee.

2609
03:58:30.479 --> 03:58:39.840
<v Angelita Morillo>The ordinance before you, document number 2026-134, was heard in the Public Works Committee on April 14th, where it was referred to full council with a recommendation to pass.

2610
03:58:40.719 --> 03:58:47.579
<v Angelita Morillo>The ordinance authorizes the issuance of revenue bonds pursuant to ORS 287A.150 Thank you.

2611
03:58:47.979 --> 03:59:00.139
<v Angelita Morillo>The ordinance authorizes the city to issue revenue bonds in the amount of $525 million to pay for system improvements to the city's water system, plus additional amounts required to fund bond reserves to pay capitalized interest and costs related to the financings.

2612
03:59:00.940 --> 03:59:06.780
<v Angelita Morillo>The total principal amount of revenue bonds required for these services is not estimated to exceed $530.5 million.

2613
03:59:07.659 --> 03:59:12.780
<v Angelita Morillo>Bonds authorized by the ordinance are special obligations of the city payable solely from the city's water system revenues.

2614
03:59:13.909 --> 03:59:35.989
<v Angelita Morillo>The ordinance also authorizes the issuance of refunding bonds pursuant to applicable Oregon statutes and to refinance any revenue bonds issued in accordance with the ordinance provisions to provide interim financing and, if conditions warrant, to refinance any of the city's outstanding water revenue bonds to obtain debt service savings or achieve a favorable reorganization of outstanding bonds.

2615
03:59:36.950 --> 03:59:51.709
<v Angelita Morillo>Finally, the ordinance describes the actions that may be taken upon passage and the effective date of the ordinance by the authorized officer or another individual designated by the city administrator, uh, on behalf of the city, on behalf of the city, and without further council action.

2616
03:59:52.510 --> 03:59:58.989
<v Angelita Morillo>The full impact statement on this item includes information on financial and budgetary impacts and analysis and community impacts and community involvement.

2617
04:00:00.030 --> 04:00:22.750
<v Angelita Morillo>One person testified during the committee meeting on April 14th, and no one submitted written testimony prior to committee action on the The general themes of the testimony the committee heard included concern regarding the amount of debt issuance proposed and adverse impacts to ratepayers, and consideration of comprehensive plan anti-displacement policies and other equity-focused city policies in investment decisions.

2618
04:00:23.229 --> 04:00:24.590
<v Angelita Morillo>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

2619
04:00:24.909 --> 04:00:25.149
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2620
04:00:25.469 --> 04:00:26.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Claire.

2621
04:00:27.709 --> 04:00:29.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark, this came out of your committee.

2622
04:00:30.110 --> 04:00:30.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>Any remarks?

2623
04:00:31.149 --> 04:00:51.870
<v Angelita Morillo>Just very briefly, We did have a very thorough discussion of the project, the project evolution, the budget's evolution, the cost controls that have been put in place by this administration, and the creation of an oversight committee to monitor the project.

2624
04:00:53.309 --> 04:00:59.549
<v Angelita Morillo>But these bonds are critical to continuing to build out the water filtration plant.

2625
04:00:59.790 --> 04:01:06.409
<v Angelita Morillo>But it was a very thorough discussion in our Thank you, Councilor Clark.

2626
04:01:07.850 --> 04:01:11.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, there are 24 people signed up to testify on this item.

2627
04:01:11.610 --> 04:01:20.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is my priority to get through testimony before we get to technical or clarifying comments and council discussion, but we do have to get through the first reading today and move this on to second reading.

2628
04:01:21.209 --> 04:01:26.010
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, I'd like to call up our, our first panel of testimony, please.

2629
04:01:27.049 --> 04:01:37.940
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember John Fall, Samuel Diaz, Charles Siko, Kelly Landsbaugh, and Liz Levinson.

2630
04:01:42.500 --> 04:01:43.219
<v Unidentified speaker>Charles is online.

2631
04:01:47.780 --> 04:01:48.020
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2632
04:01:49.139 --> 04:01:55.870
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Oh, sorry, John Fall is on line too.

2633
04:01:56.030 --> 04:01:56.829
<v Unidentified speaker>John, you can unmute.

2634
04:01:57.389 --> 04:02:04.350
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I've unmuted, and I haven't been on Zoom in 5 years because I loathe it, so, uh, I don't know how to operate the video.

2635
04:02:06.190 --> 04:02:06.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're doing great.

2636
04:02:07.950 --> 04:02:08.030
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

2637
04:02:08.590 --> 04:02:11.469
<v Mitch Green>Um, first, I want to— uh, here we go.

2638
04:02:12.989 --> 04:02:25.829
<v Mitch Green>Uh, second, what Jesse Atkins said during public comment, um, about Basically, the fees and taxes are just becoming unsustainable.

2639
04:02:26.190 --> 04:02:29.709
<v Mitch Green>And as Councilor Smith just said, you are nickel and diming us.

2640
04:02:29.870 --> 04:02:35.510
<v Mitch Green>I've recently testified twice against the street repair tax being added to water bills.

2641
04:02:36.270 --> 04:02:40.829
<v Mitch Green>Yes, the streets need to repair, but that tax is unimaginative and inequitable.

2642
04:02:40.829 --> 04:02:44.190
<v Mitch Green>But the other reason I testified against that tax is because I knew.

2643
04:02:44.360 --> 04:02:49.719
<v Mitch Green>The flood mitigation increase was coming to water bills along with increases due to the Bull Run fiasco.

2644
04:02:51.959 --> 04:02:58.600
<v Mitch Green>I have never been against needed taxes, but the Bull Run and the Water Bureau are fiascos.

2645
04:02:59.399 --> 04:03:05.719
<v Mitch Green>You may have read the article in today's Oregonian regarding the percentage of people considering leaving Portland due to high taxes and fees.

2646
04:03:06.040 --> 04:03:16.120
<v Mitch Green>As it happens, after you added the road repair fee to our water bills, my partner and I began to contemplate 2-year and a 5-year plan to move away from here.

2647
04:03:18.600 --> 04:03:31.639
<v Mitch Green>Once you have finished hollowing out the economic center, who do you think neighborhood associations serve on neighborhood coalitions, chair land use committees, and volunteer untold hours to help business districts recover from the next recession?

2648
04:03:32.680 --> 04:03:35.479
<v Mitch Green>Not your billionaire basketball buddies, I assure you.

2649
04:03:37.959 --> 04:03:49.350
<v Mitch Green>Finally, So the Water Bureau itself is a fiasco, and I'll just come back for the second reading since the time was cut Kafkaesque-like from 2— 3 minutes to 2 minutes.

2650
04:03:49.989 --> 04:03:58.389
<v Mitch Green>But I'm completely opposed to the fiasco that the Water Bureau is putting on all of us.

2651
04:03:58.870 --> 04:04:00.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here today.

2652
04:04:02.229 --> 04:04:02.309
<v Sameer Kanal>Samuel.

2653
04:04:04.229 --> 04:04:05.110
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, good evening, Council.

2654
04:04:05.350 --> 04:04:12.670
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm Sam Diaz, Executive Director I'm here to deliver testimony on behalf of TAP, Together for an Affordable Portland.

2655
04:04:13.149 --> 04:04:18.430
<v Sameer Kanal>In response to Bull Run, TAP advocates for water affordability, accountability, and alternatives that work.

2656
04:04:18.829 --> 04:04:26.750
<v Sameer Kanal>We can satisfy the EPA mandate with a renewed waiver thanks to a near-pristine primary source and a strong secondary water source, which we're on right now.

2657
04:04:27.389 --> 04:04:34.110
<v Sameer Kanal>Council should have a full and fair opportunity to also discuss backup options to treat Cryptosporidium, and let's recognize we have multiple ways to achieve that.

2658
04:04:34.190 --> 04:04:34.350
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

2659
04:04:34.399 --> 04:04:34.559
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2660
04:04:35.360 --> 04:04:39.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today represents an opportunity for our city to fix what was broken in the old form of government.

2661
04:04:40.239 --> 04:04:54.639
<v Sameer Kanal>Bureau of fiefdoms, black box project management, cost overruns from missing project elements, in this case, 7 miles of pipeline, and based on reporting, a revolving door between former city staff and the firms that they go to who, quote unquote, score City Water Bureau contracts.

2662
04:04:55.360 --> 04:04:59.520
<v Sameer Kanal>We have heard very real concerns if we don't challenge the old way of doing things.

2663
04:05:00.399 --> 04:05:04.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Continued uncertainty about whether the project is $2.56 billion or over $4 billion.

2664
04:05:04.979 --> 04:05:14.340
<v Sameer Kanal>A nursery farmer who hasn't had water for over two months from Conduit Four, local residents who are concerned about dynamite blasting, and the dominoes that fall when water rates are more than doubled.

2665
04:05:15.059 --> 04:05:24.260
<v Sameer Kanal>We are here because it is not too late into the project to adapt with new information in this new form of government, with new leadership and staff, and new leadership in elected office.

2666
04:05:24.899 --> 04:05:32.739
<v Sameer Kanal>We respectfully urge you to amend the water revenue bond amount down to only include the amount required, and hold an emergency work session for City Council that details.

2667
04:05:39.360 --> 04:05:41.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Charles, you can go ahead online.

2668
04:05:43.440 --> 04:05:50.719
<v Mitch Green>Hello, uh, Charles Siko on behalf of Multnomah County Rural Fire Protection District 10.

2669
04:05:51.200 --> 04:05:58.319
<v Mitch Green>We recognize that today you are struggling with the massive impact this filtration project will have on your ratepayers.

2670
04:05:58.649 --> 04:06:02.729
<v Mitch Green>However, the financial ramifications extend beyond your city boundaries.

2671
04:06:03.770 --> 04:06:18.329
<v Mitch Green>In our case, your project has or will in the future impact district funding by the removal of multiple properties from the tax rolls and the inevitable reductions in the value of properties located proximate to this project.

2672
04:06:19.209 --> 04:06:29.610
<v Mitch Green>At the same time, 7 years of construction and ongoing operation of this industrial plant represents a substantial addition to our coverage responsibility.

2673
04:06:30.809 --> 04:06:51.129
<v Mitch Green>A few examples: 1 million-plus construction-related trips on rural roads combined with lengthy road closures and detours, 8 different health and safety hazards for Water Bureau staff once the plant is operational, approximately 1,000 deliveries of hazardous chemicals every year.

2674
04:06:51.799 --> 04:06:56.040
<v Unidentified speaker>These hazards will require emergency response when accidents occur.

2675
04:06:56.600 --> 04:07:04.280
<v Mitch Green>As it stands now, the Water Bureau will pay absolutely nothing for vital emergency services that this plant requires.

2676
04:07:05.159 --> 04:07:11.159
<v Mitch Green>The impacts of this filtration plant is an exceptional and unfair burden for Fire District 10.

2677
04:07:11.879 --> 04:07:18.040
<v Mitch Green>If construction continues, we are asking that you join us in a good faith negotiation to determine.

2678
04:07:18.430 --> 04:07:29.430
<v Mitch Green>An equitable annual fee for the emergency services FD10 will be providing to your facility for generations to come.

2679
04:07:30.350 --> 04:07:30.989
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2680
04:07:32.670 --> 04:07:47.090
<v Unidentified speaker>Kelly Landsbaugh, Liz Levinson, Jeremy, Jeremy Bosseley-Smith, Rosalyn Poton, David Sweet, Gilbert Devine, Jeremy's online.

2681
04:07:47.170 --> 04:07:47.809
<v Unidentified speaker>You can go ahead.

2682
04:07:55.569 --> 04:07:57.729
<v Unidentified speaker>Jeremy, you can unmute and, and begin testimony.

2683
04:08:03.729 --> 04:08:04.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon, councilors.

2684
04:08:05.969 --> 04:08:10.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>This issue takes me back to my first Portland City Council meeting 5 years ago.

2685
04:08:11.229 --> 04:08:20.350
<v Mitch Green>I heard someone go up and they testified about this project, and it's the project I've heard testified about most consistently in my 5 years out here in Portland.

2686
04:08:21.149 --> 04:08:23.790
<v Mitch Green>For me, I've worked on many capital projects.

2687
04:08:24.270 --> 04:08:31.709
<v Mitch Green>I've worked actually for Kiewit, which is one of the contractors in this joint venture, and something I know about them is they have high turnover rate.

2688
04:08:32.190 --> 04:08:41.840
<v Mitch Green>They also will bid jobs low so they can get them, and then they change order Over and over again until you know we end up in the situation that we're in.

2689
04:08:42.079 --> 04:08:49.840
<v Mitch Green>I worked on a huge public works project like this back in D.C., where it started out at two billion, and by the time it was finally done, it was six billion.

2690
04:08:50.639 --> 04:08:53.840
<v Mitch Green>So we know Portlanders are already super squeezed at the moment.

2691
04:08:54.479 --> 04:08:57.520
<v Mitch Green>Doubling the prices over the next decade—it's only going to make it worse.

2692
04:08:58.479 --> 04:09:01.600
<v Mitch Green>Municipalities are pulling out of the Portland Water Bureau service area.

2693
04:09:01.920 --> 04:09:02.399
<v Mitch Green>It's going to burden.

2694
04:09:03.209 --> 04:09:05.450
<v Mitch Green>Us even more, those of us that still are in it.

2695
04:09:06.010 --> 04:09:08.729
<v Mitch Green>And this money, at the end of the day, it needs stipulations.

2696
04:09:09.209 --> 04:09:17.610
<v Mitch Green>Really, we should pause funding until the joint venture can provide a schedule on how they're going to get this done and how there aren't going to be additional costs.

2697
04:09:18.329 --> 04:09:23.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>$525 Million is a lot to put on Portland Water Bureau ratepayers.

2698
04:09:24.090 --> 04:09:26.170
<v Mitch Green>So this is a tough situation.

2699
04:09:26.409 --> 04:09:32.620
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's not something that any of you asked for, and you were not set set up for success by previous councils.

2700
04:09:33.100 --> 04:09:41.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>When projects, they get out of control like this, it really hurts efforts to municipalize some of our other utilities and it erodes public trust.

2701
04:09:41.180 --> 04:09:43.500
<v Mitch Green>So we need to see the schedule and budget.

2702
04:09:43.899 --> 04:09:47.659
<v Mitch Green>Definitely pause the funding for this at this moment.

2703
04:09:48.299 --> 04:09:53.420
<v Mitch Green>And yeah, make sure that if it does go beyond schedule, that there are liquidated damages.

2704
04:09:53.500 --> 04:09:53.899
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2705
04:09:54.540 --> 04:09:55.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2706
04:09:57.430 --> 04:09:58.389
<v Unidentified speaker>You can go ahead at the table.

2707
04:10:00.870 --> 04:10:04.229
<v Loretta Smith>My name is Liz Levinson and I live in District 2.

2708
04:10:04.870 --> 04:10:13.350
<v Loretta Smith>I am here today to urge you not to approve additional water revenue bonds to finance the Bull Run Filtration Project, which now exceeds $2.5 billion.

2709
04:10:14.629 --> 04:10:28.049
<v Loretta Smith>Portland families are stretched to the limit between recently approved electric, gas, and water rate hikes, ever-increasing property taxes and an already high income tax burden, Portland is becoming less and less affordable for middle-income families.

2710
04:10:29.010 --> 04:10:30.370
<v Loretta Smith>I am a lifelong Portlander.

2711
04:10:30.930 --> 04:10:35.010
<v Loretta Smith>I was born in Northeast Portland and raised in both Northeast and Northwest Portland.

2712
04:10:35.489 --> 04:10:37.489
<v Loretta Smith>My husband was born and raised in Inner Southeast.

2713
04:10:38.530 --> 04:10:43.649
<v Loretta Smith>We are now raising our own family in Northeast in a 2-income household, and our children attend PPS.

2714
04:10:44.530 --> 04:10:48.899
<v Loretta Smith>We want to stay in the city and continue to raise our children here as long as we can afford it.

2715
04:10:49.540 --> 04:11:01.700
<v Loretta Smith>However, increasingly it feels like this city views families like ours primarily as a revenue source for every new project the city wants to pursue, and as a result, this city is becoming less and less affordable.

2716
04:11:02.500 --> 04:11:06.420
<v Loretta Smith>When this project was first discussed in 2017, the estimate was around $500 million.

2717
04:11:07.139 --> 04:11:14.430
<v Loretta Smith>It has now ballooned into a $2.5 billion megaproject with no clear ceiling in sight, and How does the city plan to pay for it?

2718
04:11:14.750 --> 04:11:18.190
<v Loretta Smith>The city itself has admitted that the repayment plan rests on ratepayers.

2719
04:11:18.350 --> 04:11:19.549
<v Loretta Smith>In other words, Portland residents.

2720
04:11:20.350 --> 04:11:21.709
<v Loretta Smith>This is not just a homeowner issue.

2721
04:11:22.110 --> 04:11:31.870
<v Loretta Smith>Water rate increases of 6 to 8% per year will raise rents as well in a city already viewed by many residents as costing too much while delivering too little in return.

2722
04:11:32.510 --> 04:11:34.989
<v Loretta Smith>At what cost does this project become unacceptable?

2723
04:11:35.469 --> 04:11:42.540
<v Loretta Smith>Where is the transparent analysis comparing alternatives like UV treatment, phased implementation, or redesigning the scope of the project.

2724
04:11:43.420 --> 04:11:46.139
<v Loretta Smith>Please stop treating Portland residents like an open wallet.

2725
04:11:46.700 --> 04:11:52.700
<v Loretta Smith>Portlanders deserve transparent cost ceilings, independent oversight, and protection from endless utility increases.

2726
04:11:53.180 --> 04:11:58.459
<v Loretta Smith>I beg you, please do not approve additional bonds to support this boondoggle of a project.

2727
04:11:59.100 --> 04:11:59.340
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2728
04:11:59.659 --> 04:12:01.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2729
04:12:05.909 --> 04:12:06.790
<v Unidentified speaker>Greetings, councilors.

2730
04:12:06.950 --> 04:12:08.389
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name is Rose Podent.

2731
04:12:08.469 --> 04:12:12.629
<v Loretta Smith>I'm the water justice coordinator at Verde and a community member here in Portland.

2732
04:12:13.909 --> 04:12:21.670
<v Loretta Smith>Verde builds environmental wealth through social enterprise advocacy and a deep commitment to water affordability and equitable infrastructure.

2733
04:12:22.950 --> 04:12:33.360
<v Loretta Smith>Today you are considering issuing over half— or $525 million in water revenue bonds for the Bull Run Filtration Plant, a project that is now about $2.5 billion.

2734
04:12:34.879 --> 04:12:41.440
<v Loretta Smith>We're here to express concerns regarding the escalating costs and the lack of comprehensive equitable financing strategy.

2735
04:12:42.559 --> 04:12:45.520
<v Loretta Smith>First, there is an unsustainable burden on ratepayers.

2736
04:12:46.239 --> 04:12:52.719
<v Loretta Smith>Verde works closely with community members who tell us one thing consistently: utility rates are already too high.

2737
04:12:53.440 --> 04:12:57.120
<v Loretta Smith>Families are making impossible trade-offs between water, housing, and food.

2738
04:12:58.559 --> 04:13:01.360
<v Loretta Smith>Our engagements show a deep pattern of anxiety.

2739
04:13:01.840 --> 04:13:05.270
<v Loretta Smith>People are Already rationing water use or missing payments entirely.

2740
04:13:06.629 --> 04:13:16.389
<v Loretta Smith>Under this current plan, rates are projected to increase about 9.8% annually for the next decade, which effectively doubles the water bills in less than 10 years.

2741
04:13:16.629 --> 04:13:18.549
<v Loretta Smith>This isn't just a line item.

2742
04:13:19.350 --> 04:13:24.389
<v Loretta Smith>It is a direct threat to financial security and well-being of Portland's most vulnerable households.

2743
04:13:25.350 --> 04:13:31.079
<v Loretta Smith>Second of all, well, we need a different solution that won't Increase water rates.

2744
04:13:31.639 --> 04:13:33.239
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, thank you for your time and consideration.

2745
04:13:34.840 --> 04:13:35.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2746
04:13:37.079 --> 04:13:45.399
<v Unidentified speaker>Curtis French, Tamara Winsank, Rod Park, Andres Mendoza, Devin Ruiz.

2747
04:13:51.000 --> 04:13:51.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Rod's online.

2748
04:13:51.879 --> 04:13:53.079
<v Unidentified speaker>Rod, you can unmute and go ahead.

2749
04:13:55.569 --> 04:13:55.889
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2750
04:13:56.129 --> 04:13:57.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, my name is Rod Park.

2751
04:13:57.489 --> 04:14:02.129
<v Mitch Green>I, uh, operate a nursery out in the Boring area that's near the water treatment plant to be constructed.

2752
04:14:03.010 --> 04:14:12.209
<v Mitch Green>I'm also a former Metro councilor representing the eastern portion of Portland and the areas east of Multnomah County, cities of Gresham and Wood Village, Fairview, etc.

2753
04:14:13.090 --> 04:14:19.729
<v Mitch Green>I think I bring a background and perspective of these large regional decisions as the ones, uh, that just don't affect Portland residents.

2754
04:14:20.290 --> 04:14:24.420
<v Mitch Green>It also affects surrounding Urban areas and rural ones as well.

2755
04:14:25.940 --> 04:14:28.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>Many, like I, had to decide regarding where the region should grow.

2756
04:14:29.860 --> 04:14:31.940
<v Mitch Green>You're being asked to consider the future cost of water.

2757
04:14:32.260 --> 04:14:40.659
<v Mitch Green>I've heard it now estimated if the current course continues, the estimated rate will increase and almost double in the next 8 to 10 years.

2758
04:14:41.700 --> 04:14:45.620
<v Mitch Green>I've been told that Portland has to take action or be out of compliance with water quality standards.

2759
04:14:46.260 --> 04:14:49.409
<v Mitch Green>But is this the only action, or can others be like ultraviolet light Thank you.

2760
04:14:49.649 --> 04:14:50.129
<v Mitch Green>I think that might suffice.

2761
04:14:51.170 --> 04:14:52.209
<v Mitch Green>There's time to change course.

2762
04:14:52.690 --> 04:14:56.610
<v Mitch Green>Money spent on the current plan is not a reason to continue the same course.

2763
04:14:57.329 --> 04:14:58.450
<v Mitch Green>I'm also a private pilot.

2764
04:14:58.930 --> 04:15:00.290
<v Loretta Smith>I set course for a destination.

2765
04:15:00.770 --> 04:15:03.250
<v Mitch Green>I use the best information possible before taking off.

2766
04:15:03.889 --> 04:15:08.770
<v Mitch Green>However, things can change— weather, etc., a whole host of variety of things.

2767
04:15:09.090 --> 04:15:13.969
<v Mitch Green>That does not mean I continue on just because, uh, I set the course.

2768
04:15:15.850 --> 04:15:19.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>I continue because I flew the previous, uh, previous miles.

2769
04:15:20.729 --> 04:15:24.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>I make adjustments, plot a new course as new information or circumstances change.

2770
04:15:25.209 --> 04:15:32.649
<v Mitch Green>I'm asking you to consider what new information you have received, such as the cost of the project, the federal requirements, and whether options are available.

2771
04:15:33.129 --> 04:15:33.370
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2772
04:15:34.250 --> 04:15:34.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2773
04:15:36.889 --> 04:15:37.450
<v Unidentified speaker>You can go ahead.

2774
04:15:38.809 --> 04:15:39.930
<v Angelita Morillo>My name is Tammy Wensink.

2775
04:15:40.489 --> 04:15:42.409
<v Angelita Morillo>Resiliency is how this project is being sold.

2776
04:15:43.079 --> 04:15:52.120
<v Angelita Morillo>Last week, when the South Shore wells were activated, Director Lu publicly stated that our water system is designed for resilience because we have 2 high-quality drinking water sources.

2777
04:15:52.920 --> 04:15:56.360
<v Angelita Morillo>The well fields handle storms, floods, fires, and infrastructure problems.

2778
04:15:57.079 --> 04:15:58.200
<v Angelita Morillo>That is resiliency.

2779
04:15:58.760 --> 04:16:02.600
<v Angelita Morillo>The plant will filter microscopic organisms, not sizable particulate.

2780
04:16:03.000 --> 04:16:08.440
<v Angelita Morillo>If a forest fire loads our watershed with debris, the new plant can't handle it, and we'd switch to the well field anyway.

2781
04:16:08.440 --> 04:16:08.680
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2782
04:16:09.170 --> 04:16:11.170
<v Angelita Morillo>This project is not adding resiliency.

2783
04:16:11.329 --> 04:16:12.370
<v Angelita Morillo>We already have it.

2784
04:16:13.010 --> 04:16:16.370
<v Angelita Morillo>Dynamite blasting, a new cost that is not fully represented in the current budget.

2785
04:16:16.930 --> 04:16:21.090
<v Angelita Morillo>They keep hitting more boulders and rock, which means more blasting, more risk, more cost.

2786
04:16:21.649 --> 04:16:31.969
<v Angelita Morillo>A local hydrologist says this blasting could collapse the dewatered layers and compromise the structural integrity of the entire area and could even drain the aquifer that feeds hundreds of homes and farms in the area.

2787
04:16:32.770 --> 04:16:37.899
<v Angelita Morillo>Seismic damage to homes, wells, and roads is a known risk and a huge legal liability.

2788
04:16:38.059 --> 04:16:42.459
<v Angelita Morillo>These are catastrophic costs that would cost the city millions to billions.

2789
04:16:42.620 --> 04:16:48.299
<v Angelita Morillo>As we've seen with many adjustments to the project already, there are no assurances it won't happen.

2790
04:16:48.459 --> 04:16:57.340
<v Angelita Morillo>None of this information is in the budget you're seeing, and these exceptionally and exponentially rising costs are not going to magically disappear and end here.

2791
04:16:57.739 --> 04:17:00.059
<v Angelita Morillo>We're only 30% complete at best.

2792
04:17:00.549 --> 04:17:05.590
<v Angelita Morillo>Prior council approved this project, and you're being handed selective curated information by the Water Bureau.

2793
04:17:05.989 --> 04:17:07.829
<v Angelita Morillo>We're here to fill in the missing pieces for you.

2794
04:17:08.309 --> 04:17:11.909
<v Angelita Morillo>Don't let this continue unchecked and become the straw that breaks Portland's back.

2795
04:17:12.629 --> 04:17:15.829
<v Angelita Morillo>Deny the bonds, pause the project, demand an independent audit.

2796
04:17:16.389 --> 04:17:16.629
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

2797
04:17:17.510 --> 04:17:18.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2798
04:17:19.590 --> 04:17:21.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Devin, you can go ahead online.

2799
04:17:23.750 --> 04:17:24.309
<v Candace Avalos>Good evening, council.

2800
04:17:24.709 --> 04:17:25.590
<v Candace Avalos>My name is Devin Ruiz.

2801
04:17:25.829 --> 04:17:28.549
<v Candace Avalos>I live in District 2, and I'm a registered lobbyist for NextStep.

2802
04:17:29.420 --> 04:17:35.819
<v Candace Avalos>We are a nonprofit organization that works to amplify the voice and leadership of diverse young people to achieve a more just and equitable Oregon.

2803
04:17:36.620 --> 04:17:40.700
<v Candace Avalos>We know firsthand the struggle our young people are facing with securing sustained and affordable housing.

2804
04:17:41.500 --> 04:17:48.780
<v Candace Avalos>The rising cost of utilities each year plays a huge role in the feasibility of young people continuing to live in or move to Portland in the future.

2805
04:17:49.579 --> 04:18:05.670
<v Candace Avalos>If the Bull Run Filtration Plant moves forward as is and these water revenue bonds are approved without Without direction for an alternative course, Portland water ratepayers will need to be ready to absorb at least 10% increases each year for the next 10 years.

2806
04:18:06.309 --> 04:18:15.430
<v Candace Avalos>We do not support the last-minute proposed water rate increases for fiscal year 26-27 because it locks in these increases for the next 10 fiscal years at minimum.

2807
04:18:16.549 --> 04:18:21.409
<v Candace Avalos>Next up is leading Metro's Future Vision Youth Committee, who will shape the future of this region.

2808
04:18:22.049 --> 04:18:26.129
<v Candace Avalos>Their top issue priorities are affordability and climate resiliency and preparedness.

2809
04:18:26.930 --> 04:18:31.969
<v Candace Avalos>This decision, if it goes forward, will stunt the growth of the region and create numerous barriers for young people.

2810
04:18:32.610 --> 04:18:36.930
<v Candace Avalos>We believe ratepayer increases should be a fraction or a match of building preparedness.

2811
04:18:37.409 --> 04:18:46.370
<v Candace Avalos>Putting the entire fiscal burden of these large multi-billion dollar efforts defeats the major goal of resiliency planning, building stronger communities in the face of changing conditions.

2812
04:18:47.569 --> 04:18:57.729
<v Candace Avalos>We urge City Council to amend the water revenue bond amount to only include the amount required for maintenance of existing city infrastructure and explore options proposed by TAP.

2813
04:18:57.809 --> 04:19:00.129
<v Candace Avalos>I will submit my full remarks as written testimony.

2814
04:19:00.610 --> 04:19:01.170
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2815
04:19:01.250 --> 04:19:02.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2816
04:19:04.450 --> 04:19:11.690
<v Unidentified speaker>Randall Friesen, Elizabeth Linder, Joe Bond, Katie Farrell, Anjanette Banuelos-Bolanos.

2817
04:19:13.260 --> 04:19:14.299
<v Unidentified speaker>You can go ahead at the table.

2818
04:19:16.459 --> 04:19:16.540
<v Mitch Green>Great.

2819
04:19:16.860 --> 04:19:17.819
<v Mitch Green>Good evening, everybody.

2820
04:19:17.819 --> 04:19:19.979
<v Mitch Green>I'm Randall Friesen with the Columbia Pacific Building Trades Council.

2821
04:19:20.780 --> 04:19:22.299
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for all your time and your consideration.

2822
04:19:23.420 --> 04:19:33.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm here today on behalf of over 16,000 union construction professionals to express our strong support for the issuance of bonds to fund the necessary cost adjustments for the Bull Run Filtration Project.

2823
04:19:34.299 --> 04:19:37.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>Last year's project delays and construction pause directly disrupted Thank you.

2824
04:19:37.729 --> 04:19:42.850
<v Mitch Green>This project has disrupted over 400 local families and numerous small businesses reliant on this work.

2825
04:19:43.649 --> 04:19:59.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>Deferring or rejecting this bond issuance will inevitably escalate the final projection costs, creating a less-for-more scenario for Portland ratepayers, and could add further damage to small contractors still recovering from the previous past due pause due to no fault of their own.

2826
04:20:00.129 --> 04:20:07.739
<v Mitch Green>With the city already in the middle of construction and contracts released, this This would cause additional litigation for breach of contract, adding further costs and further delays.

2827
04:20:08.299 --> 04:20:16.620
<v Mitch Green>The past couple of years, we have seen several settlements paid by the city in construction project litigation, which in most, if not all, cases were completely avoidable.

2828
04:20:17.100 --> 04:20:27.579
<v Jamie Dunphy>At a time when Portland must act as an economic driver for the state, institutional delays undermine economic recovery and send a discouraging signal to outside businesses looking to invest in our region.

2829
04:20:28.540 --> 04:20:37.510
<v Mitch Green>Councilmember To remain competitive and demonstrate that Portland is a stable, forward-moving city for development, the council must finalize this business and prevent further costly project extensions.

2830
04:20:38.629 --> 04:20:48.469
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here at the council, we are committed to working with some of the groups that you've heard today to help advocate and find different funding mechanisms to help backfill some of these losses, right?

2831
04:20:48.549 --> 04:20:54.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think there's an opportunity to have federal and state funding, and we're here to help support that.

2832
04:20:57.250 --> 04:20:57.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2833
04:20:58.290 --> 04:21:01.329
<v Unidentified speaker>You can go ahead at the table.

2834
04:21:01.649 --> 04:21:01.969
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2835
04:21:02.370 --> 04:21:04.370
<v Loretta Smith>My name is Elizabeth, resident in District 1.

2836
04:21:05.409 --> 04:21:15.729
<v Loretta Smith>The current Bull Run Filtration Plant proposal, now a multi-billion dollar project, does not reflect the full range of viable water treatment options available to us.

2837
04:21:17.329 --> 04:21:27.149
<v Loretta Smith>There are proven, less expensive, and less invasive alternatives That the Portland Water Bureau has not meaningfully evaluated despite repeated community requests.

2838
04:21:27.870 --> 04:21:43.549
<v Loretta Smith>According to TAP Coalition and water treatment experts, the city could pursue options such as ultraviolet treatment, a widely used and EPA-recognized method that disinfects water without chemicals at a fraction of the cost of full filtration.

2839
04:21:44.430 --> 04:21:53.799
<v Loretta Smith>2, Smaller, more appropriately scaled treatment facilities Located closer to the communities that receive the water, reducing costs and impact.

2840
04:21:54.280 --> 04:21:58.680
<v Loretta Smith>There is a site that exists that is already owned by the city of Portland near Palbut.

2841
04:21:59.239 --> 04:22:07.399
<v Candace Avalos>By moving the project to the site, we will immediately reduce costs to the project and cease the destructive impact to the communities Cottrell and Pleasant Home.

2842
04:22:08.040 --> 04:22:13.959
<v Candace Avalos>Option three: resuming robust water testing and transparent reporting, which would allow the city to tailor treatment to.

2843
04:22:14.069 --> 04:22:19.590
<v Loretta Smith>Actual conditions rather than building the most expensive system possible just in case.

2844
04:22:20.950 --> 04:22:41.909
<v Loretta Smith>Before moving forward, the city must fully evaluate lower-cost alternatives including UV treatment and smaller-scale facilities, provide transparent, accessible public information about the true costs, risks, trade-offs, and trade-offs of each option, and center impacted communities both rural near the construction site and the Portlanders who are already struggling to pay our bills.

2845
04:22:42.700 --> 04:22:45.340
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

2846
04:22:46.860 --> 04:22:48.139
<v Unidentified speaker>Joe, you can go ahead online.

2847
04:22:52.299 --> 04:22:54.379
<v Mitch Green>Good evening, uh, members of the City Council.

2848
04:22:54.940 --> 04:22:55.899
<v Mitch Green>My name is Joe Bond.

2849
04:22:56.059 --> 04:23:01.819
<v Mitch Green>I'm an electrician of 14 years along with being a member and business representative of IBEW Local 48.

2850
04:23:02.379 --> 04:23:06.940
<v Mitch Green>I'm speaking in support of the approval of the bond issuance for the Bull Run Water Filtration Project.

2851
04:23:07.739 --> 04:23:16.569
<v Mitch Green>This facility is needed for multiple One being a much-needed infrastructure project for the region in order for the community to have access to adequate amounts of clean drinking water.

2852
04:23:17.209 --> 04:23:20.409
<v Mitch Green>Another being the needed jobs for our region in this economic downturn.

2853
04:23:21.129 --> 04:23:28.969
<v Mitch Green>Not only does this project give the ability to increase the capacity of clean drinking water, but also increase capacity for safety reasons when needed.

2854
04:23:29.850 --> 04:23:33.530
<v Mitch Green>This bond is needed due to the six-month delay in the project last year.

2855
04:23:34.170 --> 04:23:35.770
<v Mitch Green>The most affordable time to build.

2856
04:23:36.200 --> 04:23:37.799
<v Mitch Green>Build this facility is right now.

2857
04:23:38.280 --> 04:23:40.680
<v Mitch Green>Delaying only makes things more expensive.

2858
04:23:40.840 --> 04:23:46.840
<v Mitch Green>This project is also helping provide family wage jobs and training opportunities for craft people from the Portland metro area.

2859
04:23:47.879 --> 04:23:53.959
<v Mitch Green>Delaying this project further will only increase costs, hurt the workers who are currently there, and any that will be there in the near future.

2860
04:23:54.840 --> 04:24:01.319
<v Mitch Green>Also, if this project doesn't get done or is delayed, it may create problems with the EPA, which may lead to possible fines.

2861
04:24:06.209 --> 04:24:13.569
<v Mitch Green>I strongly urge the passing of this bond to keep the project moving and keep people working to help bolster the region in a multitude of ways.

2862
04:24:13.729 --> 04:24:16.129
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for allowing time to comment on this.

2863
04:24:16.370 --> 04:24:17.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2864
04:24:30.219 --> 04:24:33.180
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, and sorry, Katie Farrell actually joined us online.

2865
04:24:33.340 --> 04:24:33.979
<v Unidentified speaker>Katie, you can go ahead.

2866
04:24:42.620 --> 04:24:43.340
<v Candace Avalos>Go ahead, Katie.

2867
04:24:45.899 --> 04:24:46.940
<v Angelita Morillo>All right, can you hear me?

2868
04:24:47.899 --> 04:24:48.139
<v Sameer Kanal>We can.

2869
04:24:49.100 --> 04:24:53.100
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm sorry, I just got home, but, um, my name's Katie Farrell.

2870
04:24:53.340 --> 04:25:03.290
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I'm a resident of District District 4, and I just wanted to make a few comments about the Bull Run water infiltration project.

2871
04:25:05.049 --> 04:25:29.860
<v Angelita Morillo>First of all, it's come to my attention that the budget is way over capacity, and I took a few moments and looked at a few other cities who have done infiltration projects recently, one of them being the city of Denver, and their project was completed in 2024 for $600 million.

2872
04:25:32.340 --> 04:25:36.100
<v Angelita Morillo>Our cost is estimated now to be $2.56 billion.

2873
04:25:38.260 --> 04:25:42.739
<v Angelita Morillo>This is just absolutely unaffordable for the city and the people of Portland.

2874
04:25:44.500 --> 04:25:51.149
<v Angelita Morillo>I also looked at the Water rates, which are we pay about $160 a month.

2875
04:25:52.110 --> 04:25:59.549
<v Angelita Morillo>The average cost in the United States for rates is about $45 to $79 a month.

2876
04:26:00.829 --> 04:26:03.469
<v Angelita Morillo>These rates we're already paying are extraordinary.

2877
04:26:04.270 --> 04:26:11.790
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm just asking the council if you can please evaluate this in great detail and.

2878
04:26:12.360 --> 04:26:15.719
<v Angelita Morillo>Not allow future funding to be passed.

2879
04:26:16.360 --> 04:26:16.440
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks.

2880
04:26:17.559 --> 04:26:18.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

2881
04:26:19.159 --> 04:26:19.959
<v Unidentified speaker>Floy, you can go ahead.

2882
04:26:20.840 --> 04:26:21.719
<v Loretta Smith>Floy Jones.

2883
04:26:22.120 --> 04:26:27.799
<v Loretta Smith>I've spent about, oh, I don't know, 7,000 or 8,000 hours on this project over the last 20 years.

2884
04:26:29.000 --> 04:26:32.280
<v Loretta Smith>I was on the Water Bureau Budget Committee for several years.

2885
04:26:32.440 --> 04:26:33.639
<v Loretta Smith>We were a part of a water lawsuit.

2886
04:26:34.360 --> 04:26:37.319
<v Loretta Smith>We filed 26156.

2887
04:26:37.489 --> 04:26:40.209
<v Angelita Morillo>I went to Washington, D.C. and testified on this rule.

2888
04:26:40.850 --> 04:26:56.209
<v Angelita Morillo>We joined New York, San Francisco, Seattle, Tacoma in submitting substantive comments against this poorly crafted rule, which you have to know at least the basic that the Portland Water Bureau was the one and only utility that helped craft this poorly crafted rule.

2889
04:26:58.049 --> 04:27:05.260
<v Angelita Morillo>In Portland, for Portland water ratepayers, wholesale customers have historically made up 40% of our rate base, right?

2890
04:27:05.739 --> 04:27:10.620
<v Angelita Morillo>And now the 3 largest wholesale customers are leaving because of this filtration plant.

2891
04:27:11.020 --> 04:27:15.739
<v Angelita Morillo>I understand that you received comments from Tualatin Valley, which is ironic since they are leaving.

2892
04:27:17.020 --> 04:27:21.739
<v Loretta Smith>And that means we're now at that point where the base is shrinking, shrinking, shrinking.

2893
04:27:21.819 --> 04:27:37.670
<v Angelita Morillo>And if we continue down this road where we're dumping tons of cancer-causing chemicals into our water for no measurable public health benefit, and then we're creating this massive debt service which we're not going to be able to pay, and then we're going to end up bankrupt and privatization.

2894
04:27:37.989 --> 04:27:39.909
<v Angelita Morillo>That's not what anybody wants for this system.

2895
04:27:40.309 --> 04:27:45.190
<v Candace Avalos>We have the best water in the country right now, the only federally protected watershed in the country.

2896
04:27:45.670 --> 04:27:55.520
<v Loretta Smith>The Portland Water Bureau voluntarily abandoned a 10-year variance because they said spending $1 million a year on testing is way too much.

2897
04:27:55.760 --> 04:27:57.360
<v Angelita Morillo>$1 Million a year on testing.

2898
04:27:57.760 --> 04:27:59.200
<v Loretta Smith>We could have still been in that place.

2899
04:27:59.600 --> 04:28:03.120
<v Loretta Smith>We could have gone back and renegotiated this poorly crafted rule.

2900
04:28:03.600 --> 04:28:06.959
<v Loretta Smith>We could have worked with OHA and made some changes.

2901
04:28:07.280 --> 04:28:10.319
<v Loretta Smith>We've already spent $16 million on a UV design.

2902
04:28:10.799 --> 04:28:11.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much for being here today.

2903
04:28:12.000 --> 04:28:12.559
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes, you're welcome.

2904
04:28:13.760 --> 04:28:17.040
<v Angelita Morillo>Anybody's interested in actually learning more, you could come to my basement.

2905
04:28:17.120 --> 04:28:21.440
<v Angelita Morillo>There are volumes and volumes of documents there, and I'd be happy to bring them in.

2906
04:28:21.920 --> 04:28:23.120
<v Unidentified speaker>Patricia is online.

2907
04:28:23.360 --> 04:28:25.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Patricia, you can go Go ahead.

2908
04:28:30.500 --> 04:28:30.579
<v Angelita Morillo>Hello.

2909
04:28:31.540 --> 04:28:33.139
<v Angelita Morillo>Hi, my name is Patricia Fiedler.

2910
04:28:33.700 --> 04:28:38.579
<v Eric Zimmerman>I find it unfortunate and amazing that the councilors are considering more money for the filtration plant.

2911
04:28:39.059 --> 04:28:40.659
<v Angelita Morillo>Let me go back in history to the beginning.

2912
04:28:41.219 --> 04:28:47.700
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to share with you a few words from Nick Fish, a past city commissioner, at a council meeting before he passed away.

2913
04:28:48.420 --> 04:28:57.959
<v Loretta Smith>He noted a yes vote on the filtration plant was difficult for him He was very troubled when the cost estimate rose from $350 to $850 million.

2914
04:28:58.680 --> 04:29:14.520
<v Loretta Smith>I want to be very clear, he said, we are not writing a blank check to the Water Bureau, noting he would jump on an amendment to cap construction costs if necessary, nor are commissioners approving the potentially $1 billion plant in its entirety.

2915
04:29:14.760 --> 04:29:34.450
<v Loretta Smith>What would Nick Fish say now with the costs At 2.6 billion plus, and a 30% reduction of ratepayers due to wholesale customers not renewing their contracts, and approximately one billion dollars in WIFIA loans with 614 million dollars interest for those loans.

2916
04:29:35.329 --> 04:29:38.690
<v Loretta Smith>And water bureaus are already some of the highest in the nation.

2917
04:29:39.329 --> 04:29:43.409
<v Loretta Smith>Does the council realize that an inexpensive option which is used by Boston, Seattle?

2918
04:29:44.000 --> 04:29:45.200
<v Loretta Smith>New York, and San Francisco.

2919
04:29:45.840 --> 04:29:58.879
<v Loretta Smith>UV— in 2009, Amanda Fritz, also a commissioner, stated after reading a report by the Portland Water Bureau that it was clear that UV has many additional water treatment actions better than filtration.

2920
04:30:00.479 --> 04:30:04.559
<v Loretta Smith>PWB worries about fires and turbidity causing a temporary UV shutdown.

2921
04:30:04.799 --> 04:30:09.440
<v Loretta Smith>Filtration plants can also be overwhelmed by storm conditions and temporary shutdowns.

2922
04:30:10.059 --> 04:30:10.459
<v Loretta Smith>Are you listening?

2923
04:30:11.020 --> 04:30:12.059
<v Loretta Smith>Stop the filtration plant.

2924
04:30:12.540 --> 04:30:14.860
<v Loretta Smith>Stop spending money the ratepayers cannot afford.

2925
04:30:15.260 --> 04:30:16.860
<v Loretta Smith>Don't throw good money after bad.

2926
04:30:17.819 --> 04:30:18.139
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

2927
04:30:18.620 --> 04:30:19.260
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

2928
04:30:20.540 --> 04:30:21.340
<v Unidentified speaker>That concludes testimony.

2929
04:30:22.780 --> 04:30:28.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, we are now moving into, uh, council discussion and technical and clarifying questions.

2930
04:30:28.860 --> 04:30:47.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have, uh, DCA Priya Dhanapal, uh, Director of Public Utilities Ting Lu, and Matt I'd asked them initially to do a presentation, but noting that it is 6:30, I'm going to leave it to us to just ask them technical questions and they can help us.

2931
04:30:48.250 --> 04:30:50.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, anybody who has any questions, get in the queue.

2932
04:30:52.010 --> 04:30:53.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, Vice President Clark.

2933
04:30:54.170 --> 04:30:55.129
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

2934
04:30:55.370 --> 04:30:57.770
<v Angelita Morillo>For some reason I lost the little hand thing.

2935
04:30:59.530 --> 04:31:01.290
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you all for being here today.

2936
04:31:01.219 --> 04:31:01.700
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Mayor.

2937
04:31:01.780 --> 04:31:02.819
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Wilson, for tonight.

2938
04:31:02.819 --> 04:31:25.459
<v Angelita Morillo>I just had a— based on some of the testimony we just heard, I was under the impression that the water filtration plant would actually be able to deal with storms that create lots of turbidity and landslides and forest fires that create particulate.

2939
04:31:28.000 --> 04:31:29.680
<v Angelita Morillo>Verify that for me again?

2940
04:31:30.639 --> 04:31:39.120
<v Angelita Morillo>And secondly, you know, we hear a lot about UV, UV, and for some reason that whole idea was rejected years ago.

2941
04:31:40.559 --> 04:31:47.280
<v Angelita Morillo>And maybe you could address— I know some of us are all new, but why was that option rejected?

2942
04:31:51.600 --> 04:31:52.959
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much for the question.

2943
04:31:53.600 --> 04:31:57.120
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name is Ting Lu, Portland Public Utilities Director.

2944
04:31:57.319 --> 04:31:58.280
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mayor.

2945
04:31:58.600 --> 04:32:01.959
<v Unidentified speaker>So there are multiple questions about the filtration and the UV.

2946
04:32:02.440 --> 04:32:09.719
<v Unidentified speaker>First, I will address why filtration can be more resilient for the long term for earthquakes, wildfires, and everything.

2947
04:32:10.520 --> 04:32:20.680
<v Unidentified speaker>Because whenever there is an earthquake, whenever there is like wildfires and extreme weather event, it really creates a high turbidity event.

2948
04:32:21.239 --> 04:32:29.290
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's based on the current, current process, we won't be able to meet the permit compliance.

2949
04:32:29.450 --> 04:32:31.290
<v Unidentified speaker>That's why we switched to the groundwater.

2950
04:32:31.690 --> 04:32:33.450
<v Unidentified speaker>But that's not a sustainable solution.

2951
04:32:34.170 --> 04:32:46.170
<v Unidentified speaker>By having the filtration as a series of the process, we'll be having the filtration, we'll having the coagulation, flocculation, sedimentation, and all the way to the disinfection.

2952
04:32:46.569 --> 04:32:50.889
<v Unidentified speaker>It's really provide a multi-barrier treatment for the entire—.

2953
04:32:50.969 --> 04:32:51.209
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2954
04:32:51.620 --> 04:32:52.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Water quality process.

2955
04:32:54.020 --> 04:33:02.579
<v Unidentified speaker>When we talk about why UV is not comparable to the filtration, I would say if we are looking at the Cryptosporidium, that's correct.

2956
04:33:02.899 --> 04:33:10.580
<v Unidentified speaker>From US EPA, the only 2 treatment technology that can treat Cryptosporidium is either UV or filtration.

2957
04:33:11.380 --> 04:33:24.778
<v Unidentified speaker>However, UV is highly dependent on the incoming water quality, which means that when the water is very turbid, like whenever you have a high rain event or wet weather event, the water becomes turbid.

2958
04:33:25.498 --> 04:33:31.739
<v Unidentified speaker>UV is not going to be able to treat the crypto because it inactivates the pathogen here.

2959
04:33:32.298 --> 04:33:38.138
<v Unidentified speaker>When you have a turbid water quality, it won't be able to treat the crypto at all.

2960
04:33:38.219 --> 04:33:41.658
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's why we are not really comparing apples to apples.

2961
04:33:41.818 --> 04:33:46.539
<v Unidentified speaker>We're comparing one technology to a whole resilient solution for the future.

2962
04:33:47.019 --> 04:33:48.059
<v Angelita Morillo>Well, thank you, Director Liu.

2963
04:33:48.138 --> 04:33:57.639
<v Angelita Morillo>I just want to make sure I understand the first part of what you were saying is that the new filtration plant that's under construction will be able to handle particulate and turbidity?

2964
04:33:58.279 --> 04:33:58.360
<v Unidentified speaker>Correct.

2965
04:33:58.840 --> 04:33:59.080
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

2966
04:34:02.040 --> 04:34:03.720
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

2967
04:34:04.279 --> 04:34:04.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

2968
04:34:06.279 --> 04:34:07.000
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

2969
04:34:07.479 --> 04:34:16.680
<v Mitch Green>Um, as the chair of the Public Works Committee in her report indicated, there was one no vote, uh, and that was me.

2970
04:34:16.680 --> 04:34:28.479
<v Mitch Green>So I feel, I feel duty-bound I'd like to respond to talk about that a little bit, about why I was the no vote, and then talk— ask you to sort of daylight a little bit of what we have— your response to my questions in that.

2971
04:34:28.799 --> 04:34:34.799
<v Mitch Green>So first of all, colleagues, um, I think it was a surprise that I voted no on that.

2972
04:34:34.959 --> 04:34:40.639
<v Mitch Green>I've been a champion for, um, investing in infrastructure and issuing debt to do so and all these things.

2973
04:34:41.520 --> 04:34:54.490
<v Mitch Green>Um, but it didn't occur to me, uh, maybe it should have occurred to me earlier, but it didn't occur to me until, you know, I'm reading the financial impact statement of the ordinance for the bond issuance of precisely what that cumulative rate impact would be.

2974
04:34:54.650 --> 04:34:57.450
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, it's Rule of 72.

2975
04:34:57.450 --> 04:35:01.610
<v Mitch Green>You take 72 and you divide the interest rate of growth over time, and that's how long it takes.

2976
04:35:01.689 --> 04:35:03.689
<v Mitch Green>That's how many years it takes to double.

2977
04:35:03.770 --> 04:35:06.330
<v Mitch Green>And I calculated that to be about 7 or 8 years.

2978
04:35:06.330 --> 04:35:09.689
<v Mitch Green>And so I— that alarmed me and it gave me pause.

2979
04:35:10.330 --> 04:35:11.540
<v Mitch Green>In that committee meeting, Yes.

2980
04:35:13.299 --> 04:35:19.139
<v Mitch Green>I sort of suggested there could be an alternative that we have not explored, which is a point-of-entry system of filtration.

2981
04:35:20.740 --> 04:35:21.939
<v Mitch Green>It came out of nowhere.

2982
04:35:21.939 --> 04:35:23.220
<v Mitch Green>It's really sort of off the hip.

2983
04:35:23.459 --> 04:35:25.939
<v Mitch Green>It's something that I have some knowledge of, but I am not an engineer.

2984
04:35:26.500 --> 04:35:36.659
<v Mitch Green>And so I asked the bureaus, I said, I understand that I surprised you with this vote and this sort of decision to introduce this new level of uncertainty.

2985
04:35:37.709 --> 04:35:42.349
<v Mitch Green>Do you have the capacity to use your mettle and your skills to evaluate that?

2986
04:35:43.150 --> 04:35:43.630
<v Mitch Green>And they did.

2987
04:35:43.869 --> 04:35:45.310
<v Mitch Green>They turned that around inside of 2 weeks.

2988
04:35:46.509 --> 04:35:58.509
<v Mitch Green>They produced a report that it's not friendly to my initial findings, but I think it's important to have that conversation and to maybe share with this council what you did find when I asked that question.

2989
04:35:58.909 --> 04:36:06.129
<v Mitch Green>And I got to recognize that it's really hard to do an alternatives analysis This is not a replacement for a full-blown alternatives analysis.

2990
04:36:06.449 --> 04:36:10.449
<v Mitch Green>This is just sort of a what you can do in 10 days type of analysis.

2991
04:36:10.769 --> 04:36:17.489
<v Mitch Green>But would you mind sharing a little bit about what you did for my request and what you learned, please?

2992
04:36:18.769 --> 04:36:19.728
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Green.

2993
04:36:19.969 --> 04:36:22.048
<v Unidentified speaker>This is Priya Dhanapal, DCA for Public Works.

2994
04:36:22.688 --> 04:36:25.809
<v Unidentified speaker>And we appreciate the questions and perspective you brought to the discussion.

2995
04:36:26.129 --> 04:36:29.568
<v Unidentified speaker>And we took those questions seriously because it is concerning.

2996
04:36:29.888 --> 04:36:43.990
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we had— we contracted with Black and design consulting engineering firm that is internationally known, and we have them complete analysis of the point-of-use filtration that you requested us to look into.

2997
04:36:45.029 --> 04:36:55.830
<v Unidentified speaker>In addition to that, we also looked at other potential alternatives like point-of-use UV as well, and we also had them look at decentralized systems too.

2998
04:36:56.150 --> 04:37:00.479
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm going to ask Director Lu to provide the cost ranges As a sort of analysis.

2999
04:37:00.959 --> 04:37:06.479
<v Unidentified speaker>And we also have the consultant present in the audience if you have additional questions on assumptions or any further questions.

3000
04:37:07.680 --> 04:37:08.000
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3001
04:37:08.720 --> 04:37:09.759
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you so much.

3002
04:37:10.080 --> 04:37:13.200
<v Unidentified speaker>We are always looking for cost-effective ways to reduce the cost.

3003
04:37:13.919 --> 04:37:20.319
<v Unidentified speaker>So follow up on this study, so there has been multiple analysis and alternatives for the point of entry.

3004
04:37:21.040 --> 04:37:25.360
<v Unidentified speaker>How can we become more decentralized when looking to addressing this question?

3005
04:37:26.229 --> 04:37:42.150
<v Unidentified speaker>So the 2 primary alternatives that the consultant has evaluated is including a membrane ultrafiltration microfiltration filter that's going to be installed at the meter side or at the right-of-way, because it's not impossible to do it at the household.

3006
04:37:42.549 --> 04:37:47.750
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not a regulatory— like, the regulatory won't allow you to install in the household.

3007
04:37:48.470 --> 04:38:00.500
<v Unidentified speaker>It's important also to see that this is a type of a membrane Cannot be just from Home Depot or Lowe's because the, the size of the crypto, we have to have specialized microfiltration and ultrafiltration too.

3008
04:38:01.139 --> 04:38:08.740
<v Unidentified speaker>The other analysis the consultant does is also what about we're looking to the decentralized, every single household have a UV system as well.

3009
04:38:09.540 --> 04:38:13.299
<v Unidentified speaker>So those are the 2 primary analysis they did.

3010
04:38:13.619 --> 04:38:18.580
<v Unidentified speaker>So coming back from the capital cost, the capital costs are going to be from a range.

3011
04:38:18.900 --> 04:38:20.779
<v Unidentified speaker>They We also did a sensitivity analysis.

3012
04:38:21.180 --> 04:38:28.459
<v Unidentified speaker>It's from $3.7 billion to $5.6 billion for the point of entry for membrane filtration.

3013
04:38:29.419 --> 04:38:37.099
<v Unidentified speaker>For the UV, it's a little bit lower, but it's still— the capital cost is $2.5 billion to $4 billion for the capital cost alone.

3014
04:38:37.979 --> 04:38:56.188
<v Unidentified speaker>And then when you are looking to the operating costs and on the annual basis, there's a monitoring, maintenance, and the filter replacement And everything, the total annual cost will be $400 million to over $200 million for the membrane filtration for point of entry.

3015
04:38:57.228 --> 04:39:04.588
<v Unidentified speaker>For the UV, that will be $50 million to $82 million each year for the point of entry maintenance.

3016
04:39:05.309 --> 04:39:12.188
<v Unidentified speaker>Compared with the ball round filtration, it's $17 million for the annual maintenance, operation maintenance cost.

3017
04:39:12.188 --> 04:39:12.508
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3018
04:39:13.200 --> 04:39:23.759
<v Unidentified speaker>And also from an implementation perspective, the point of entry, because of all the installation and everything, is going to take over 10 to 13 years for both point of entry.

3019
04:39:24.639 --> 04:39:34.880
<v Unidentified speaker>The consultant has also done additional alternatives for smaller, like a 4 or 5 filtration plant versus one centralized filtration plant.

3020
04:39:35.520 --> 04:39:41.130
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, because of a cost escalation and everything, It's— these costs are going to be a bookend.

3021
04:39:41.369 --> 04:39:50.009
<v Unidentified speaker>And even though we are looking to 4 or 5 filtration plants, it's going to still going to be higher than the current cost.

3022
04:39:51.450 --> 04:39:52.009
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for that.

3023
04:39:52.009 --> 04:40:02.250
<v Mitch Green>And I'm sure we could spend a lot more time on this than we have tonight, but I just, I wanted to be honest about what I learned from you, which I think is important for the public.

3024
04:40:02.569 --> 04:40:17.430
<v Mitch Green>I think there's a rightful A well-placed lack of trust in the City of Portland with respect to not only this project, but the broader transparency frame that we've chosen in the city.

3025
04:40:17.669 --> 04:40:30.310
<v Mitch Green>And so if I'm not disclosing that I asked a question, I got results that are not in accordance with— I thought they would, or, you know, that sort of challenged my initial assumptions, then I'm not doing my part to help that transparency either.

3026
04:40:30.470 --> 04:40:33.139
<v Mitch Green>And so So thanks for engaging with us.

3027
04:40:33.540 --> 04:40:36.580
<v Mitch Green>And I hope you make that report available to the public.

3028
04:40:36.740 --> 04:40:37.139
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, we will.

3029
04:40:37.139 --> 04:40:38.020
<v Mitch Green>I think that'll be important.

3030
04:40:38.979 --> 04:41:08.349
<v Mitch Green>I think the last thing I'll say is whatever happens with these bonds, whatever happens with this project, we absolutely have to figure out how to find a way to buy down the cost of this project because it is, I mean, I think the Water Bureau probably would take issue with my calculations of the rate increase, but a constant growth rate on an annual basis has a compounding effect.

3031
04:41:08.909 --> 04:41:10.189
<v Mitch Green>And I think ratepayers know that.

3032
04:41:11.069 --> 04:41:12.990
<v Mitch Green>And I think they're becoming aware of that.

3033
04:41:13.150 --> 04:41:15.229
<v Mitch Green>And it is unsustainable.

3034
04:41:15.869 --> 04:41:20.509
<v Mitch Green>And so to the earlier comment, our rate base also depends on our wholesale customers.

3035
04:41:20.909 --> 04:41:30.000
<v Mitch Green>And if they start to leave, Then that sort of sets into motion a sort of kind of almost a doom loop of a cost pressure of rate increases.

3036
04:41:30.959 --> 04:41:58.490
<v Mitch Green>And so my appeal is that we use this moment that we've opened up a little bit here to throw our full weight behind our legislative agenda to get some real meaningful grant monies to support not only this type of an infrastructure project, But frankly, the broad infrastructure costs that we face as a community, so it doesn't just fall on ratepayers and just taxpayers in the City of Portland because we're the engine of growth for the State of Oregon.

3037
04:41:58.490 --> 04:42:00.569
<v Mitch Green>And so I'll just leave my comments there at that.

3038
04:42:00.650 --> 04:42:11.689
<v Mitch Green>I'm still really struggling with this bond issuance, but I just wanted to make sure, colleagues, you understood that I had a conversation with these leaders of the Water Bureau and I needed to make that public.

3039
04:42:12.090 --> 04:42:12.169
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

3040
04:42:12.810 --> 04:42:13.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

3041
04:42:14.330 --> 04:42:23.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>I put myself in the queue now Next, I gotta tell you, I am struggling with this item, with the entire— with the filtration plant in general.

3042
04:42:24.709 --> 04:42:26.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was in Commissioner Fish's office in 2017.

3043
04:42:28.790 --> 04:42:42.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>We were there when we were debating between a $250 million UV plant and a $500 million filtration plant, and it was hours and hours of hand-wringing about it, and now we are 5 4 times bigger than that.

3044
04:42:42.779 --> 04:42:43.500
<v Jamie Dunphy>4 Times bigger than that.

3045
04:42:43.659 --> 04:42:45.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm struggling with this.

3046
04:42:45.419 --> 04:43:05.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>I also— and maybe the information has changed and I don't know this, but my understanding was that in 2017, we never even had a— we've never had a single boil water notice due to crypto, that we've had positive O-site tests, but that we've never actually detected crypto as a vector in our water proper.

3047
04:43:05.979 --> 04:43:07.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm struggling pretty hard I'm glad we're talking about this.

3048
04:43:07.990 --> 04:43:20.150
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have— I want to ask, though, putting aside the question of whether we should— are we— this is the right thing to do, I want to understand a little bit more about the repayment of these bonds.

3049
04:43:22.150 --> 04:43:28.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the ordinance explicitly states that council must approve rate increases in perpetuity to cover this cost.

3050
04:43:29.430 --> 04:43:40.959
<v Jamie Dunphy>Debt service on $2.85 billion Grows to about $168 million per year by 2035 and then holds there through 2060.

3051
04:43:41.520 --> 04:43:49.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>So 25 years at $168 million, 34 years of debt payments total, all covered by ratepayers.

3052
04:43:50.080 --> 04:44:03.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>Could you tell me, I mean, all in, I'm not the math guy, but what are we in total going to be spending on this, almost $3 billion project over the 30 years or 25 years?

3053
04:44:06.189 --> 04:44:09.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't have that information up right now.

3054
04:44:09.069 --> 04:44:10.349
<v Jamie Dunphy>I can pull it up though in a few minutes.

3055
04:44:10.830 --> 04:44:10.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

3056
04:44:11.630 --> 04:44:15.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if I may, Council President, for the record, Jonas Beery, the city's chief financial officer.

3057
04:44:16.830 --> 04:44:21.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>Just, there's, I think, 2 things that are sort of happening here with that in the question that you just asked.

3058
04:44:22.590 --> 04:44:24.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>One is the total cost of debt service for the project.

3059
04:44:25.229 --> 04:44:28.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so debt manager Matt Gerach will work on gathering that.

3060
04:44:28.549 --> 04:44:29.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>And providing it.

3061
04:44:29.349 --> 04:44:36.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>The other question related to the council's obligation to raise rates is broader than just this project, right?

3062
04:44:37.270 --> 04:44:43.029
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's a covenant that we make with bondholders that we will produce revenues to pay the debt.

3063
04:44:43.590 --> 04:44:50.869
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if rate increases are required in order to meet that legal obligation, then that is the future council's obligation.

3064
04:44:52.069 --> 04:44:56.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>The amount of that increase, the number of that increase is dependent on many factors.

3065
04:44:56.069 --> 04:44:56.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Right.

3066
04:44:56.189 --> 04:44:59.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>Factors, of which the debt service on this bond issue is one.

3067
04:44:59.869 --> 04:45:04.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>We pay off debt that we currently have outstanding, so that reduces that number.

3068
04:45:05.150 --> 04:45:08.669
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's operational decisions that are made at the bureaus that impact the rate matrix.

3069
04:45:09.069 --> 04:45:21.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I just wanna be clear that there is an explicit obligation in the bond covenants to increase rates at the amount necessary, but that is not necessarily specifically only tied to the debt service that's incurred by these bonds.

3070
04:45:21.549 --> 04:45:21.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

3071
04:45:22.520 --> 04:45:22.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

3072
04:45:23.159 --> 04:45:23.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>Does that make sense?

3073
04:45:23.880 --> 04:45:25.560
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think so, kind of.

3074
04:45:26.200 --> 04:45:44.040
<v Sameer Kanal>Based on the numbers that I have in front of me, the total debt service on the debt, not excluding the debt that already exists, but the city previously issued, it's $4.98 billion total principal and interest.

3075
04:45:44.200 --> 04:45:44.279
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

3076
04:45:44.439 --> 04:45:46.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm not sure why, I think your microphone is turned off for some reason.

3077
04:45:46.759 --> 04:45:47.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm not clear what's going on there.

3078
04:45:48.009 --> 04:45:51.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I just want to— is that— oh, there we go.

3079
04:45:51.689 --> 04:45:51.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

3080
04:45:51.770 --> 04:45:51.849
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

3081
04:45:51.930 --> 04:45:54.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, $4.98 billion in total.

3082
04:45:55.770 --> 04:46:01.209
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, and that, that debt also includes other capital work, not just, um, for the project.

3083
04:46:01.849 --> 04:46:01.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

3084
04:46:02.490 --> 04:46:10.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>And, and Jonas, thank you for sort of touching on my second question, was about the fact that we are going to have to rate increase rates, and it's not clear what those will look like.

3085
04:46:10.729 --> 04:46:17.069
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, and I, I'll, I'll say that between the filtration plant The smart meter installation that's going to be happening.

3086
04:46:18.669 --> 04:46:39.150
<v Jamie Dunphy>Some of the other just sort of general ways these things are creeping as we are combining BES and water into one bureau, talking about the— there was a maintenance overage over at the lagoon that we have that required additional— like, I'm just very, very worried that we aren't keeping as tight a lid on rate increases.

3087
04:46:39.389 --> 04:46:50.290
<v Jamie Dunphy>In fact, In fact, when I was in Commissioner Fish's office, his one overarching requirement for the 2 combined utility bureaus was we're going to do 5% increase over the years.

3088
04:46:51.090 --> 04:46:56.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I sat in meetings with Jonas in there for a long time trying to figure out how we're going to get the combined rate down below 5%.

3089
04:46:57.250 --> 04:47:00.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm not clear that we have that level of cheerleader right now.

3090
04:47:01.569 --> 04:47:18.220
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so I'm asking you to be those cheerleaders, to really take the fact that if we are seriously looking at doubling our water bills in the next decade because of how these increases happen, that is just unsustainable, and we really need to be very, very intentional about it.

3091
04:47:18.380 --> 04:47:22.060
<v Dan Ryan>So, Councilor Novick.

3092
04:47:23.740 --> 04:47:24.459
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

3093
04:47:25.580 --> 04:47:36.020
<v Steve Novick>I'd just like you to respond to the argument that we have a— in case of an emergency, we have a backup source of water, we have the groundwater, And just why isn't that sufficient?

3094
04:47:36.259 --> 04:47:39.299
<v Sameer Kanal>We have a wildfire, we have an earthquake, can't we just rely on the groundwater?

3095
04:47:41.380 --> 04:47:42.900
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I can answer that question.

3096
04:47:44.020 --> 04:47:49.220
<v Unidentified speaker>So the groundwater is really for short-term, like a temporary backup for our systems.

3097
04:47:50.340 --> 04:47:50.900
<v Unidentified speaker>And also it's—.

3098
04:47:51.060 --> 04:47:51.380
<v Steve Novick>How temporary?

3099
04:47:51.860 --> 04:47:53.619
<v Steve Novick>Like a day, 10 days, a month?

3100
04:47:54.900 --> 04:47:59.459
<v Unidentified speaker>It's more than a day, but I don't have that kind of the timeframe there.

3101
04:47:59.939 --> 04:48:06.049
<v Unidentified speaker>But the key part is it won't meet the summer demand when there's more demand for the water.

3102
04:48:06.369 --> 04:48:13.650
<v Unidentified speaker>And keeping in mind there's a lot of other water, city system is also drawing from that groundwater reservoir as well.

3103
04:48:14.209 --> 04:48:19.330
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's really, it's for a short-term solution versus a filtration.

3104
04:48:19.650 --> 04:48:27.250
<v Unidentified speaker>And also the other things, whenever we turn on the groundwater, there is a cost for electricity and everything else, pumping and everything else going on as well.

3105
04:48:28.369 --> 04:48:41.470
<v Steve Novick>So leaving that aside, can you just sort of paint a picture for people of We have this huge event, we have a wildfire, we have an earthquake and landslides, we don't have the filtration plant.

3106
04:48:42.430 --> 04:48:45.630
<v Steve Novick>What is people's experience of water going to be?

3107
04:48:45.790 --> 04:48:47.790
<v Steve Novick>Will they not get any water at all coming out of the tap?

3108
04:48:47.869 --> 04:48:49.389
<v Steve Novick>Will they get water coming out that's poisonous?

3109
04:48:49.630 --> 04:48:50.029
<v Steve Novick>What would happen?

3110
04:48:52.669 --> 04:48:56.990
<v Unidentified speaker>I think we're really talking about emergency supply and disaster planning.

3111
04:48:57.549 --> 04:49:09.909
<v Unidentified speaker>That's really going to be a very tough situation, we have— we will need to be really prioritizing and looking to— not everyone will have the water.

3112
04:49:10.229 --> 04:49:15.830
<v Unidentified speaker>So we'll need to really look into how we can supply that at the city level.

3113
04:49:16.310 --> 04:49:18.869
<v Steve Novick>But would that be true with or without the filtration plant?

3114
04:49:19.029 --> 04:49:26.229
<v Steve Novick>I'm just trying to get a sense of what people's experience, personal experience will be after a disastrous event.

3115
04:49:26.810 --> 04:49:28.810
<v Steve Novick>With a filtration plant or without a filtration plant?

3116
04:49:31.209 --> 04:49:35.930
<v Unidentified speaker>With the filtration plant, because we do have the pipelines that are seismic resilient.

3117
04:49:36.250 --> 04:49:49.290
<v Unidentified speaker>So we'll be able to deliver the water into a central place and then be able to deliver the water to more city communities versus right now those pipelines are not seismic resilient and many of them are very old actually.

3118
04:49:49.770 --> 04:49:55.689
<v Unidentified speaker>So we haven't been— we have been deferring that to the replacement because of the filtration pipeline replacement.

3119
04:49:55.650 --> 04:49:57.009
<v Steve Novick>Wait a minute.

3120
04:49:57.490 --> 04:50:00.130
<v Steve Novick>How does— I don't actually understand the relationship between that.

3121
04:50:00.290 --> 04:50:00.369
<v Steve Novick>Why?

3122
04:50:01.970 --> 04:50:05.250
<v Steve Novick>I would've thought that the filtration plant is one thing and the pipes are another.

3123
04:50:06.529 --> 04:50:27.080
<v Unidentified speaker>The filtration included both the filtration facility as well as the 7 miles of the pipeline that's connecting from the raw water to the filtration facility, as well as coming out from the filtration facility to our conduit and coming to the Does that mean the filtration plant isn't just a filtration plant?

3124
04:50:27.240 --> 04:50:27.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Correct.

3125
04:50:28.360 --> 04:50:28.439
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

3126
04:50:32.279 --> 04:50:37.880
<v Steve Novick>What would it cost to just replace the pipes with things that are seismic resilient and not build a filtration plant?

3127
04:50:41.240 --> 04:50:43.599
<v Unidentified speaker>Let me check on that info.

3128
04:50:44.520 --> 04:50:46.360
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll see our chief engineer.

3129
04:50:46.599 --> 04:50:47.799
<v Unidentified speaker>Miro, do you have that number here?

3130
04:50:50.299 --> 04:50:52.619
<v Unidentified speaker>The pipeline versus the facility itself?

3131
04:50:52.700 --> 04:50:55.259
<v Eric Zimmerman>Oh, the dollars for the program?

3132
04:50:56.700 --> 04:51:07.020
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I just like assuming that all you were going to do is replace the pipes so that they're seismic resilient and you weren't worrying about building a filtration plant, how much would that cost?

3133
04:51:08.700 --> 04:51:09.900
<v Unidentified speaker>It would be a different routing.

3134
04:51:10.060 --> 04:51:11.259
<v Unidentified speaker>It wouldn't be the same pipes.

3135
04:51:11.659 --> 04:51:15.259
<v Unidentified speaker>So we would have to have different routing and replacing existing pipes.

3136
04:51:15.419 --> 04:51:20.279
<v Unidentified speaker>Those pipes are added to connect to the filtration plant Okay.

3137
04:51:20.520 --> 04:51:27.799
<v Unidentified speaker>So I could— we could probably run numbers for replacing the existing pipes to the existing plant.

3138
04:51:28.680 --> 04:51:31.720
<v Steve Novick>That would probably mean— would that be like hundreds of millions or billions?

3139
04:51:32.040 --> 04:51:33.240
<v Steve Novick>What would it be, do we think?

3140
04:51:34.599 --> 04:51:36.200
<v Unidentified speaker>It would be significant.

3141
04:51:36.759 --> 04:51:38.360
<v Unidentified speaker>The current pipelines project—.

3142
04:51:39.560 --> 04:51:40.119
<v Loretta Smith>Give me a second.

3143
04:51:43.159 --> 04:51:44.360
<v Unidentified speaker>So we did split it in 2.

3144
04:51:44.939 --> 04:52:04.299
<v Unidentified speaker>So the current pipelines for 7 miles is about $445 million, $400, close to $500 million, just the pipelines and 7 miles of it.

3145
04:52:04.860 --> 04:52:08.220
<v Steve Novick>Okay, but that's still just a fraction of $2.5 billion.

3146
04:52:09.099 --> 04:52:25.869
<v Steve Novick>So again, my question My question is, leaving that aside, assuming that we have seismically strengthened pipes, what will the water drinking experience be of people after the disaster without the filtration plant or with the filtration plant?

3147
04:52:29.229 --> 04:52:30.509
<v Steve Novick>Will people be getting water at all?

3148
04:52:30.590 --> 04:52:31.389
<v Steve Novick>Will they be drinking poison?

3149
04:52:31.790 --> 04:52:33.549
<v Steve Novick>What will happen if we don't have the filtration plant?

3150
04:52:34.110 --> 04:52:39.009
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, the facility itself having the seismic resilient piece of it.

3151
04:52:39.169 --> 04:52:46.930
<v Unidentified speaker>So we'll definitely have the water and then getting to the certain areas for communities for distributing and everything.

3152
04:52:47.409 --> 04:52:51.729
<v Unidentified speaker>But without the facility, there is a lot of the landslide and everything.

3153
04:52:52.130 --> 04:52:56.529
<v Unidentified speaker>The water is not meeting permit compliance for drinking water quality.

3154
04:52:57.729 --> 04:53:01.650
<v Steve Novick>Okay, but leaving aside legal compliance, you're actually a person drinking it.

3155
04:53:01.970 --> 04:53:02.610
<v Steve Novick>Will you get sick?

3156
04:53:03.090 --> 04:53:03.169
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

3157
04:53:03.880 --> 04:53:03.959
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

3158
04:53:05.000 --> 04:53:08.360
<v Steve Novick>Um, how would you get sick?

3159
04:53:08.520 --> 04:53:09.639
<v Steve Novick>What would be the ways you might get sick?

3160
04:53:10.040 --> 04:53:16.200
<v Unidentified speaker>All the particles and all the landslide and all the kind of particles got into the drinking water pipes.

3161
04:53:17.080 --> 04:53:20.200
<v Steve Novick>But like, what sort of illness would you get if you're drinking contaminated water?

3162
04:53:21.080 --> 04:53:25.240
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, that's all the microorganisms, there's the chemicals.

3163
04:53:25.560 --> 04:53:26.840
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, that's very serious.

3164
04:53:27.560 --> 04:53:29.159
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's really about public health.

3165
04:53:30.049 --> 04:53:31.569
<v Steve Novick>Okay, thank you.

3166
04:53:34.689 --> 04:53:36.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

3167
04:53:37.090 --> 04:53:37.490
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

3168
04:53:39.490 --> 04:53:54.770
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I just neglected to mention during the, uh, my initial round at this is that this is precisely why we need to have a formal rate hearing process, um, on a sort of periodic basis that's written into our code.

3169
04:53:55.319 --> 04:54:00.680
<v Mitch Green>We currently have a very informal process, and we have to adopt rates during an annual budget review process.

3170
04:54:01.080 --> 04:54:16.119
<v Mitch Green>But if we can adopt a policy in the City of Portland to say we're going to set rates in the Water Bureau, the BES Bureau, once every 2 years or once every 5 years, whatever we think makes the most sense, then we can put our long-run planning data into the mix.

3171
04:54:16.279 --> 04:54:20.439
<v Mitch Green>We can use our best estimates into the mix, and we can evaluate.

3172
04:54:21.169 --> 04:54:25.250
<v Mitch Green>What our rates are going to cost in advance of the projects that it funds.

3173
04:54:25.250 --> 04:54:34.130
<v Mitch Green>Because part of the issue that we're facing here and the pushback that we're getting is we're approving the financing before we've approved the rates to validate that.

3174
04:54:34.130 --> 04:54:38.729
<v Mitch Green>And we're going to have to approve the rates to validate that to stay in compliance with our covenants.

3175
04:54:39.810 --> 04:54:45.970
<v Mitch Green>But the risk that I have flagged in the committee was I'm worried about the political appetite for our future council to raise those rates.

3176
04:54:46.380 --> 04:54:47.740
<v Mitch Green>And so that's a very serious concern.

3177
04:54:47.740 --> 04:55:02.380
<v Mitch Green>So some of us are gonna be pushing very hard irrespective of this specific matter to put into practice that rate-setting process so that we can mature as an infrastructure and rate-making institution as a city.

3178
04:55:02.380 --> 04:55:03.900
<v Mitch Green>So I just wanted to raise that up.

3179
04:55:04.139 --> 04:55:04.700
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

3180
04:55:04.860 --> 04:55:05.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

3181
04:55:05.819 --> 04:55:06.299
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

3182
04:55:07.819 --> 04:55:08.619
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

3183
04:55:10.139 --> 04:55:17.630
<v Dan Ryan>You know, I did a site visit with former leaders in water I think it was in 2023, and so I spent the entire day up at Bull Run.

3184
04:55:18.750 --> 04:55:25.549
<v Dan Ryan>And one reason they wanted me to do that, because I asked a lot of concerning questions at that time as it started to escalate.

3185
04:55:27.150 --> 04:55:28.590
<v Dan Ryan>I really appreciate this conversation.

3186
04:55:28.909 --> 04:55:29.549
<v Dan Ryan>It's really needed.

3187
04:55:32.189 --> 04:55:42.240
<v Dan Ryan>I became sold by the end of the day, and I now just have some more questions to I wanted to ask first about the legal delay.

3188
04:55:42.319 --> 04:55:44.000
<v Dan Ryan>How long was that, the recent legal delay?

3189
04:55:45.360 --> 04:55:47.200
<v Unidentified speaker>The recent legal delay was about 7 months.

3190
04:55:47.919 --> 04:55:50.560
<v Unidentified speaker>We also had a 9-month permitting delay at the beginning of the project.

3191
04:55:50.880 --> 04:55:52.159
<v Unidentified speaker>Total 16-month delay.

3192
04:55:52.479 --> 04:55:53.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Was that last year?

3193
04:55:53.759 --> 04:55:55.439
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, the 7-month delay was last year.

3194
04:55:55.840 --> 04:55:57.200
<v Dan Ryan>How much did that cost us per day?

3195
04:55:58.479 --> 04:56:00.319
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe it's about $30 million per day.

3196
04:56:01.759 --> 04:56:25.060
<v Unidentified speaker>We're finalizing that negotiation for that cost, and we're not going to reveal the number right here, but I can tell you we've estimated the cost of delays moving forward to be $12 to $17 million a month, which reflected some of the comments that we heard related to delaying the project once you have equipment and people and workers already committed to that work.

3197
04:56:25.939 --> 04:56:28.580
<v Unidentified speaker>It has a cost of suspension.

3198
04:56:30.340 --> 04:56:32.979
<v Dan Ryan>I must have missed, what was the estimate of cost per day?

3199
04:56:34.180 --> 04:56:37.860
<v Unidentified speaker>$12 To $17 million per day moving forward for further delays.

3200
04:56:41.990 --> 04:56:42.790
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, per month.

3201
04:56:42.790 --> 04:56:43.110
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry.

3202
04:56:43.430 --> 04:56:43.509
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

3203
04:56:44.950 --> 04:56:45.590
<v Angelita Morillo>It's getting late.

3204
04:56:45.669 --> 04:56:46.310
<v Unidentified speaker>Per month, yes.

3205
04:56:47.509 --> 04:56:48.630
<v Dan Ryan>So I was doubting myself.

3206
04:56:49.110 --> 04:56:49.909
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks for catching that.

3207
04:56:50.150 --> 04:56:50.470
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

3208
04:56:50.709 --> 04:56:52.950
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciated your questions, Councilor Novick.

3209
04:56:53.029 --> 04:56:55.270
<v Dan Ryan>I wanted to hang out there for a while as well.

3210
04:56:56.389 --> 04:57:02.470
<v Dan Ryan>I would like you to comment on— Director Liu, were you here and I just didn't know you when we had the big wildfire?

3211
04:57:02.709 --> 04:57:03.830
<v Dan Ryan>Was that in 2023?

3212
04:57:04.939 --> 04:57:05.580
<v Dan Ryan>I'll run.

3213
04:57:06.060 --> 04:57:11.259
<v Unidentified speaker>I joined while Water Bureau was responding to that wildfire, so I remember part of that.

3214
04:57:11.659 --> 04:57:13.340
<v Dan Ryan>DCA Dipole, you weren't here then, right?

3215
04:57:13.659 --> 04:57:14.540
<v Dan Ryan>No, I was not here.

3216
04:57:14.540 --> 04:57:14.939
<v Dan Ryan>I'm unfamiliar.

3217
04:57:15.180 --> 04:57:20.220
<v Dan Ryan>The reason I bring that up is because it was a big concern and we did temporarily have to go to groundwater, correct?

3218
04:57:21.580 --> 04:57:21.659
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

3219
04:57:22.860 --> 04:57:25.580
<v Dan Ryan>I'm hoping there's some institutional memory around here besides me.

3220
04:57:30.069 --> 04:57:30.790
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, in 20.

3221
04:57:32.150 --> 04:57:38.630
<v Unidentified speaker>So you're hearing back from the Water Bureau that we did augment with groundwater supply during that time.

3222
04:57:38.630 --> 04:57:38.950
<v Dan Ryan>Well, thank you.

3223
04:57:39.029 --> 04:57:40.549
<v Dan Ryan>That was really kind of you.

3224
04:57:43.750 --> 04:57:45.590
<v Dan Ryan>Because I probably need a hearing aid, I lost something.

3225
04:57:46.229 --> 04:57:46.950
<v Dan Ryan>What would you say?

3226
04:57:48.709 --> 04:57:54.950
<v Unidentified speaker>We did have confirmation that the Water Bureau augmented with the groundwater supply during that time when there was a wildfire.

3227
04:57:58.720 --> 04:58:01.759
<v Dan Ryan>So I think we have this real-time example not too long ago.

3228
04:58:01.919 --> 04:58:03.840
<v Dan Ryan>It really wasn't, it was within the last 2 years.

3229
04:58:04.799 --> 04:58:07.200
<v Dan Ryan>And what did we learn from that?

3230
04:58:07.439 --> 04:58:16.400
<v Dan Ryan>Like, I was trying to, when I was listening to Councilor Novick's question, I was trying to really be persuaded by that experience just a couple years ago.

3231
04:58:17.040 --> 04:58:24.770
<v Dan Ryan>And then hidden in his questioning that this is so necessary because we learned during that time the constraints of groundwater.

3232
04:58:24.849 --> 04:58:36.610
<v Dan Ryan>I don't want to put words in your mouth, so tell me more forcefully, what did we learn from that experience, and did it help make the case for what we're trying to do here, choosing this more expensive option?

3233
04:58:37.729 --> 04:58:43.650
<v Unidentified speaker>The, the Camp Creek wildfire was not— it was a wildfire, but it was not a significant one.

3234
04:58:43.810 --> 04:58:44.450
<v Unidentified speaker>But even that—.

3235
04:58:44.689 --> 04:58:45.729
<v Dan Ryan>It sure felt significant.

3236
04:58:46.130 --> 04:58:46.529
<v Dan Ryan>I'm sorry.

3237
04:58:46.930 --> 04:58:56.770
<v Unidentified speaker>No, I want to But the point I'm trying to make is even, even at that, with that level of, um, uh, extent of, um, the fire that we had, we had to switch to the groundwater wells.

3238
04:58:57.090 --> 04:59:07.169
<v Unidentified speaker>And I, what I'm learning from the Water Bureau is it takes about, um, we, we can supplement for 180 days, um, if you're for a sustained period of only 180 days or so.

3239
04:59:07.650 --> 04:59:16.130
<v Unidentified speaker>And so if it is longer than that, if there's extensive wildfire or if it's, um, much more, uh, um, damage than that, then It's gonna be difficult.

3240
04:59:16.610 --> 04:59:29.090
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's why the filtration is gonna be really important to make sure we are able to filter the, you know, if there's turbidity or other particulates, it's important to have the filtration to be able to do that.

3241
04:59:31.090 --> 04:59:31.169
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

3242
04:59:31.169 --> 04:59:33.650
<v Dan Ryan>So when you're up here, thank you, that was helpful.

3243
04:59:34.930 --> 04:59:39.650
<v Dan Ryan>When you're up here, you just have this, when's another shoe gonna drop feeling?

3244
04:59:40.290 --> 04:59:44.900
<v Dan Ryan>And how, this reminds me a little bit back when we were trying to, build the tram.

3245
04:59:45.459 --> 04:59:45.860
<v Dan Ryan>Remember that?

3246
04:59:46.180 --> 04:59:48.659
<v Dan Ryan>Everyone was getting really impatient with how expensive that was getting.

3247
04:59:50.740 --> 04:59:50.819
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

3248
04:59:51.060 --> 04:59:56.740
<v Dan Ryan>What can you say that gives us confidence about what's different today than maybe what we've experienced in the last 2 years?

3249
04:59:58.819 --> 05:00:00.819
<v Dan Ryan>Last 2 years hasn't gone very well for this project.

3250
05:00:03.380 --> 05:00:06.020
<v Unidentified speaker>So, you know, we have new leadership here.

3251
05:00:06.180 --> 05:00:09.220
<v Unidentified speaker>We have Director Lew, we have Chief Engineer Muriel.

3252
05:00:09.849 --> 05:00:12.970
<v Unidentified speaker>And we have strengthened the accountability measures in place.

3253
05:00:14.009 --> 05:00:23.049
<v Unidentified speaker>We've had a PDAD team, and I'm going to request Dr. Lu to talk about the accountability measures in place and also the oversight mechanisms that we have in place.

3254
05:00:23.529 --> 05:00:38.479
<v Unidentified speaker>We're identifying the risks and also actively managing the risks to make sure we deliver the project on within the extended timeline that is given to us by OHA as well as We have cost control mechanisms in place as well.

3255
05:00:38.959 --> 05:00:44.159
<v Unidentified speaker>So we have all hands on deck on the Water Bureau right now trying to manage costs and the schedule.

3256
05:00:44.880 --> 05:00:51.520
<v Unidentified speaker>And we are happy to talk about the measures that we have in place as well, if Director Lu or Chief Engineer Muriel wants to talk about that.

3257
05:00:51.919 --> 05:01:00.080
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I'll just— back to the 2 years I was not with the Water Bureau, but I still hear people on staff from Water Bureau talk a lot.

3258
05:01:00.080 --> 05:01:03.119
<v Unidentified speaker>It's only a few miles from actually our water source.

3259
05:01:03.650 --> 05:01:05.729
<v Unidentified speaker>So people were very scared during that time.

3260
05:01:05.970 --> 05:01:13.409
<v Unidentified speaker>What if it's really touching our water supply and we don't have a really resilient supply to supply for the Portlanders?

3261
05:01:13.569 --> 05:01:17.729
<v Unidentified speaker>And people think if we have the filtration, that will be much a different story.

3262
05:01:18.369 --> 05:01:24.930
<v Unidentified speaker>So it is still impacting everyone, and the way I'll talk about it and think about it for the 2 years was really a scary time.

3263
05:01:25.970 --> 05:01:33.180
<v Unidentified speaker>So the lesson learned from a project management perspective, I'll just say The biggest part is how we are handling a mega project.

3264
05:01:33.979 --> 05:01:43.099
<v Unidentified speaker>This is over billions of a project, and this is the first time that for the bureau and even for the city, we are like a largest infrastructure project we have.

3265
05:01:43.419 --> 05:01:51.340
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's really strengthening that accountability, transparency, and also making sure there's multiple layers of oversight and accountability.

3266
05:01:52.220 --> 05:01:56.700
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're focusing, focusing on a lot of oversight panel and the owner's trust.

3267
05:01:56.700 --> 05:01:56.860
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3268
05:01:57.279 --> 05:01:58.560
<v Unidentified speaker>For moving forward.

3269
05:01:58.720 --> 05:02:06.639
<v Unidentified speaker>The other thing that I look at is how can we transform from the monthly update to foresight and insights?

3270
05:02:06.720 --> 05:02:15.840
<v Unidentified speaker>How can we translating that to the actionable items and milestones and making sure we are mitigating those risks proactively, making sure we stay on schedule?

3271
05:02:15.919 --> 05:02:18.880
<v Unidentified speaker>And every time, every day costs money.

3272
05:02:18.880 --> 05:02:22.479
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's really what we are being more proactive moving forward.

3273
05:02:22.409 --> 05:02:23.049
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Herbold.

3274
05:02:23.290 --> 05:02:25.209
<v Unidentified speaker>So maybe I can jump in a little bit.

3275
05:02:25.209 --> 05:02:27.529
<v Unidentified speaker>So I am, for the record, I'm Muriel Geisel-Teufel.

3276
05:02:27.610 --> 05:02:30.330
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the new interim chief for the Water Bureau.

3277
05:02:30.330 --> 05:02:32.169
<v Unidentified speaker>I came from the BES side.

3278
05:02:32.810 --> 05:02:35.130
<v Unidentified speaker>My expertise is in program management.

3279
05:02:35.130 --> 05:02:38.810
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm an engineer, but managing capital delivery, big ones.

3280
05:02:39.689 --> 05:02:50.740
<v Unidentified speaker>So I've joined a couple of weeks ago, and over those weeks I've made some changes in direction to the team for the management to really Strengthen the program controls aspect.

3281
05:02:51.540 --> 05:03:10.500
<v Unidentified speaker>So a little less engineering, but more program controls, which relates to forecasting, reporting, schedule control, schedule analysis, so that we can match the pace and the intensity of construction, and that we can manage those risks and work through our contracts and keep accountabilities where they lie, including our own.

3282
05:03:12.020 --> 05:03:18.580
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're making a lot of changes in Risk reporting, risk forecasting, and mitigation.

3283
05:03:18.979 --> 05:03:29.459
<v Unidentified speaker>And right now with land use being, as of changes, things that have changed in the last 2 years is really the land use risk has gone away.

3284
05:03:29.540 --> 05:03:35.139
<v Unidentified speaker>And that was a massive risk of delay that has actually incurred and that we are paying for now.

3285
05:03:35.939 --> 05:03:41.459
<v Unidentified speaker>So moving forward at the 30% phase of construction, it's really about managing the construction work.

3286
05:03:41.540 --> 05:03:41.860
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3287
05:03:42.349 --> 05:03:48.909
<v Unidentified speaker>Minimizing changes and having our eyes wide open for those changes and understanding who owns them.

3288
05:03:50.189 --> 05:03:50.990
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's what we bring.

3289
05:03:50.990 --> 05:03:51.950
<v Dan Ryan>That gives us some confidence.

3290
05:03:52.270 --> 05:03:56.110
<v Dan Ryan>The staff retention challenges have been a concern when you're up here.

3291
05:03:56.590 --> 05:03:59.229
<v Dan Ryan>So it helped to have all of you just pipe in right now.

3292
05:03:59.229 --> 05:03:59.869
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate it.

3293
05:04:00.349 --> 05:04:02.270
<v Dan Ryan>I'll just end with a couple quick questions.

3294
05:04:03.229 --> 05:04:13.369
<v Dan Ryan>I think what's hard for some of us is, are we too far down the road to put the genie back in the bottle, to go for Plan B?

3295
05:04:14.729 --> 05:04:19.529
<v Dan Ryan>And would that be more expensive than pursuing this through?

3296
05:04:20.330 --> 05:04:24.970
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that's the big question that I'm asking now at 7 o'clock.

3297
05:04:26.009 --> 05:04:29.930
<v Dan Ryan>And I hope that I could get some clear answers on that before I have to vote.

3298
05:04:30.169 --> 05:04:31.209
<v Dan Ryan>Is it next week we vote?

3299
05:04:31.450 --> 05:04:31.610
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

3300
05:04:31.610 --> 05:04:31.689
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

3301
05:04:32.409 --> 05:04:32.729
<v Dan Ryan>2 Weeks.

3302
05:04:32.729 --> 05:04:34.729
<v Dan Ryan>And was this discussed in the committee?

3303
05:04:35.549 --> 05:04:38.669
<v Dan Ryan>This is where I'm not on the committee, so again, I'm asking questions.

3304
05:04:38.750 --> 05:04:40.909
<v Dan Ryan>I'm sorry if this is boring for those of you in the committee.

3305
05:04:42.669 --> 05:04:45.069
<v Unidentified speaker>The clear answer, Councilor Ryan, is yes.

3306
05:04:47.150 --> 05:04:49.150
<v Unidentified speaker>Anything other than the pathway that you're taking—.

3307
05:04:49.229 --> 05:04:49.630
<v Dan Ryan>You're saying yes.

3308
05:04:49.950 --> 05:04:50.669
<v Unidentified speaker>It's going to be more expensive.

3309
05:04:50.750 --> 05:04:52.349
<v Dan Ryan>You can't put the genie back in the bottle.

3310
05:04:52.830 --> 05:04:52.909
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

3311
05:04:53.869 --> 05:04:56.990
<v Unidentified speaker>We have looked at other alternatives.

3312
05:04:57.150 --> 05:05:12.700
<v Unidentified speaker>We looked at point-of-use filtration, point-of-use UV, We've looked at decentralized treatment systems, and we are also obligated under the federal regulations to meet the regulations by requirement by 2 years.

3313
05:05:13.259 --> 05:05:26.060
<v Unidentified speaker>So we, in addition, after Councilor Green checked in with us about alternative options, we've had conversations with OHA as well, and we've had clear direction from them that we are— the city is required to meet the regulations.

3314
05:05:26.139 --> 05:05:26.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3315
05:05:26.849 --> 05:05:28.290
<v Unidentified speaker>And complete the project in 2 years.

3316
05:05:29.409 --> 05:05:37.729
<v Unidentified speaker>So at this point, if you have to go back and do something else, we've already sunk in $750 million in this project.

3317
05:05:38.290 --> 05:05:56.779
<v Unidentified speaker>So if you're choosing some other alternate treatment, it's going to cost more to decommission this plant and then go back and find another alternate to, you know, for treatment or other Other, you know, it's gonna take a long time and money.

3318
05:05:58.299 --> 05:06:00.380
<v Unidentified speaker>It's gonna cost more in the long run.

3319
05:06:01.900 --> 05:06:04.939
<v Dan Ryan>The dissent is so different today than it was 2 years ago.

3320
05:06:05.419 --> 05:06:09.099
<v Dan Ryan>It was neighbors out in East County mostly.

3321
05:06:09.580 --> 05:06:14.619
<v Dan Ryan>I saw the big signs when I went to the site visit, you know, go away filtration system.

3322
05:06:16.779 --> 05:06:17.900
<v Dan Ryan>They were big signs too.

3323
05:06:17.979 --> 05:06:18.540
<v Dan Ryan>You couldn't miss 'em.

3324
05:06:19.110 --> 05:06:21.189
<v Dan Ryan>And that's when you knew you were on the way to the Bull Run.

3325
05:06:21.509 --> 05:06:22.950
<v Dan Ryan>You could just follow those signs.

3326
05:06:24.069 --> 05:06:26.470
<v Dan Ryan>I've been hanging in there mostly 'cause of labor.

3327
05:06:28.310 --> 05:06:31.349
<v Dan Ryan>It's a really amazing project.

3328
05:06:31.349 --> 05:06:39.110
<v Dan Ryan>You can have a youth from East County hopefully be a pre-apprentice and get all the way to journey person throughout the duration of the project.

3329
05:06:39.110 --> 05:06:44.229
<v Dan Ryan>We don't have a lot of projects like that, but I don't want them to retire while they're working on this project.

3330
05:06:44.799 --> 05:06:46.080
<v Dan Ryan>And that's the big concern.

3331
05:06:46.240 --> 05:06:48.240
<v Dan Ryan>It's just like, when is this?

3332
05:06:48.560 --> 05:06:49.680
<v Dan Ryan>Like, what's the timeline?

3333
05:06:50.479 --> 05:06:52.000
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that needs to be answered.

3334
05:06:52.799 --> 05:06:56.959
<v Dan Ryan>I will also say that this is our most precious resource in the city of Portland, is Bull Run.

3335
05:06:57.680 --> 05:07:07.200
<v Dan Ryan>It's one of our biggest assets, like understatement of the year, about why we are a futuristic city when it comes to the climate crisis.

3336
05:07:07.439 --> 05:07:08.560
<v Dan Ryan>So we want to get this right.

3337
05:07:09.360 --> 05:07:13.060
<v Dan Ryan>And so we're going to keep asking necessary questions for the public.

3338
05:07:13.860 --> 05:07:16.020
<v Dan Ryan>And I do think that we need more updates.

3339
05:07:16.020 --> 05:07:20.180
<v Dan Ryan>I'm really grateful, Chair Clark, that you're focused on this issue.

3340
05:07:21.459 --> 05:07:25.700
<v Dan Ryan>And I know that the legal challenge and the delay was really unfortunate last year.

3341
05:07:25.860 --> 05:07:28.900
<v Dan Ryan>I remember when I heard that news, it was— it hit hard.

3342
05:07:29.700 --> 05:07:34.340
<v Dan Ryan>So, but I didn't hear much because of this new form of government, and I'm not in the committee.

3343
05:07:34.500 --> 05:07:36.020
<v Dan Ryan>I didn't really get an update.

3344
05:07:36.259 --> 05:07:37.619
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you for catching me up a bit.

3345
05:07:37.619 --> 05:07:37.779
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

3346
05:07:41.319 --> 05:07:42.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

3347
05:07:42.439 --> 05:07:43.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

3348
05:07:45.720 --> 05:07:46.200
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

3349
05:07:46.360 --> 05:07:49.319
<v Eric Zimmerman>The genie in the bottle question is kind of where I want to go to.

3350
05:07:50.200 --> 05:07:52.360
<v Eric Zimmerman>$750 Million that's already been spent.

3351
05:07:52.439 --> 05:08:07.490
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm trying to get a sense of— because I have no way of understanding $750 million, but is this that we bought the lot, we built the walls, the foundation, And we haven't put the roof on yet, or we put the roof on but there's nothing on the inside yet.

3352
05:08:07.810 --> 05:08:15.689
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, you know, it just— in terms of the way we think about it, it gets to the what happens if we don't issue bonds?

3353
05:08:16.049 --> 05:08:19.970
<v Eric Zimmerman>What would be the course of action if that was the case?

3354
05:08:20.689 --> 05:08:22.369
<v Eric Zimmerman>What happens if we don't?

3355
05:08:23.330 --> 05:08:28.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't know even who the right person to pose that to, so between the 5 of you, roll the dice.

3356
05:08:28.849 --> 05:08:28.930
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

3357
05:08:28.950 --> 05:08:31.669
<v Unidentified speaker>Could I defer it to CFO Peery or—.

3358
05:08:31.830 --> 05:08:32.389
<v Eric Zimmerman>Of course they will.

3359
05:08:33.270 --> 05:08:33.349
<v Loretta Smith>Sure.

3360
05:08:34.389 --> 05:08:35.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, DCA Donahue.

3361
05:08:35.990 --> 05:08:37.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I can't answer from a project perspective.

3362
05:08:38.069 --> 05:08:42.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mean, certainly there would be project risks and folks at the Bureau might be able to talk about those project risks.

3363
05:08:43.909 --> 05:08:55.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>There is a pretty significant risk to massively— to not issuing these bonds and to massively pivoting or pausing the funding plan.

3364
05:08:56.520 --> 05:09:08.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>The city has received the benefit of WIFIA loans, the Water Infrastructure Financing and Innovation Act, federal dollars to fund major water and public health projects.

3365
05:09:09.400 --> 05:09:15.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>The terms of that agreement, which are very beneficial to the city, require that we have a funding plan.

3366
05:09:15.639 --> 05:09:21.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Those dollars are only available to fund up to 49, I think it's 49% of the project.

3367
05:09:21.479 --> 05:09:22.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have to fund the other 51%.

3368
05:09:22.680 --> 05:09:22.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

3369
05:09:24.110 --> 05:09:28.669
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have received some of those loans and are bound to those agreements.

3370
05:09:28.830 --> 05:09:37.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I can say from a financing perspective, one extremely challenging outcome is we would be at risk of potentially defaulting those agreements.

3371
05:09:38.110 --> 05:09:43.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>And the consequences of that would be very, very unpleasant.

3372
05:09:43.869 --> 05:09:44.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>I mean, unknown at this moment.

3373
05:09:45.150 --> 05:09:48.189
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'm certainly hopeful that that's not something that we have to address with attorneys.

3374
05:09:48.430 --> 05:09:48.590
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

3375
05:09:49.209 --> 05:09:52.729
<v Unidentified speaker>I can speak a little bit if you'd like to the status.

3376
05:09:53.610 --> 05:10:00.970
<v Unidentified speaker>So the site was ours and we're building on it, but we're about 30% complete on the filtration site.

3377
05:10:01.130 --> 05:10:09.529
<v Unidentified speaker>So that means the excavations have been completed, the concrete pours have largely been completed, and the site is going— starting to go vertical.

3378
05:10:09.930 --> 05:10:12.169
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're building walls and starting to build up.

3379
05:10:12.409 --> 05:10:15.209
<v Unidentified speaker>So lots of cranes and equipment is mobilized on the site.

3380
05:10:15.209 --> 05:10:15.369
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3381
05:10:16.540 --> 05:10:27.979
<v Unidentified speaker>No buildings are complete yet, or no tanks are complete yet, but a lot of pipes, underground work is pretty advanced as we're going further up.

3382
05:10:28.380 --> 05:10:31.659
<v Unidentified speaker>And on the $750 million was as of March.

3383
05:10:31.979 --> 05:10:35.099
<v Unidentified speaker>As of April, we're $785 million spent.

3384
05:10:35.580 --> 05:10:48.310
<v Unidentified speaker>And if we were to cancel tomorrow or terminate tomorrow, We have about, we estimate a 10 to 30% termination fee on the remaining contract values.

3385
05:10:48.709 --> 05:10:51.430
<v Unidentified speaker>We have about 1.9 contracts committed.

3386
05:10:52.709 --> 05:11:06.470
<v Unidentified speaker>And then we also would have to incur costs to deconstruct what we've put in, the concrete, the rebar, dispose of it, refill the big excavations, and essentially restore the site.

3387
05:11:06.549 --> 05:11:06.709
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

3388
05:11:07.180 --> 05:11:15.659
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's— we estimate this $100 to $300 million in addition to the termination fees that are $100 to $350 million.

3389
05:11:16.860 --> 05:11:28.220
<v Unidentified speaker>And to add to what, um, Muriel was saying, you know, in addition to facing contractor claims, like, we are— even if the bonds don't pass, we'll still be legally required by OHA to complete the filtration plant.

3390
05:11:28.939 --> 05:11:33.340
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so not issuing the bonds does not, you know, eliminate that obligation.

3391
05:11:34.340 --> 05:11:39.139
<v Unidentified speaker>It will create financing schedule issues, cause problems for a project that is already significantly underway.

3392
05:11:39.939 --> 05:11:40.180
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

3393
05:11:40.500 --> 05:11:41.459
<v Eric Zimmerman>Council President, I'm going to pause.

3394
05:11:41.540 --> 05:11:43.939
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have to step out for a sec, but I would like to keep myself in the queue.

3395
05:11:44.099 --> 05:11:44.979
<v Eric Zimmerman>Just please go to the next person.

3396
05:11:45.459 --> 05:11:45.540
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

3397
05:11:46.659 --> 05:11:47.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

3398
05:11:48.979 --> 05:12:01.549
<v Angelita Morillo>Well, I was kind of hoping that we could wind down a little bit here and take a break, but I, just as the chair of the Public Works Committee now, And a couple of my members are here.

3399
05:12:02.509 --> 05:12:06.430
<v Angelita Morillo>I just want to express that we have a new team in town.

3400
05:12:07.389 --> 05:12:09.110
<v Angelita Morillo>We have new leadership.

3401
05:12:09.310 --> 05:12:16.750
<v Angelita Morillo>I have a lot of confidence in the new leadership that's sort of making up for lost time, maybe making up for past mistakes.

3402
05:12:17.229 --> 05:12:31.049
<v Angelita Morillo>And I have just grown— I don't know if the other committee members feel that— I have a lot of confidence in the new team and your Your oversight, what you've been putting in place, the money that you've already saved in the process.

3403
05:12:32.490 --> 05:12:45.209
<v Angelita Morillo>And I look to the future, to other discussions aside from the plant, to the rate restructuring that Councilor Green alluded to, that we have a lot of work to do, but we're not going to go backwards.

3404
05:12:45.689 --> 05:12:46.889
<v Angelita Morillo>We have to go forwards.

3405
05:12:47.049 --> 05:12:59.540
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think you're doing a great job in getting control of this project and getting, um, what's it called, the, uh, project, uh, not the oversight person, but what is it called?

3406
05:13:00.180 --> 05:13:00.740
<v Loretta Smith>Owner's rep.

3407
05:13:00.819 --> 05:13:01.540
<v Angelita Morillo>The owner's rep.

3408
05:13:01.700 --> 05:13:01.939
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

3409
05:13:02.099 --> 05:13:06.900
<v Angelita Morillo>That we finally have an owner's rep, that we're, we're really— we're kind of growing up now.

3410
05:13:06.979 --> 05:13:17.380
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, and to your comment, uh, Councilor Ryan, I was here when the tram was built, and I remember all the hoo-ha about the increased price.

3411
05:13:17.709 --> 05:13:20.029
<v Angelita Morillo>And now you look back and it was a good investment.

3412
05:13:20.110 --> 05:13:21.310
<v Angelita Morillo>It was a really good investment.

3413
05:13:21.630 --> 05:13:32.669
<v Angelita Morillo>And we thought it was very, very expensive and the price went up, but we did the right thing in building that and in building the light rail lines that people thought were very expensive, but they, they've served us well.

3414
05:13:33.069 --> 05:13:39.470
<v Angelita Morillo>And we are getting WIFIA loans in, in addition to other kinds of financing assistance.

3415
05:13:39.549 --> 05:13:44.419
<v Angelita Morillo>So I just wanted to put a little more positive note on this that we are.

3416
05:13:44.659 --> 05:13:47.939
<v Angelita Morillo>We do have really good leadership now, and we're making up for lost time.

3417
05:13:50.099 --> 05:13:51.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

3418
05:13:51.860 --> 05:13:52.419
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

3419
05:13:54.419 --> 05:13:55.220
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

3420
05:13:56.099 --> 05:13:57.299
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you all for your presentation.

3421
05:13:57.700 --> 05:13:59.060
<v Loretta Smith>I, I appreciate it.

3422
05:13:59.139 --> 05:14:04.659
<v Loretta Smith>And we had a nice conversation in our Public Works Committee and offline.

3423
05:14:05.459 --> 05:14:17.720
<v Loretta Smith>I was, um, I was a little surprised at the amount of bonding that we were going to do in I understand, you know, what has taken place, and I, and I appreciate the, the breakdown that you gave me.

3424
05:14:18.599 --> 05:14:35.240
<v Loretta Smith>It would be helpful because we will be privy to information in the Public Works Committee if we can also do additional work sessions or something in the Committee of the Whole, because people need to be updated on this.

3425
05:14:35.479 --> 05:14:39.080
<v Loretta Smith>It's, it's like I don't sit on certain committees and then I hear something, it's like I didn't know about that.

3426
05:14:39.080 --> 05:14:39.159
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

3427
05:14:40.119 --> 05:14:43.240
<v Loretta Smith>But I think it's going to be helpful, and I think that might be the better place.

3428
05:14:43.400 --> 05:15:01.479
<v Loretta Smith>I know the Committee of the Whole is booked up with a lot of things, but even if we can't do Committee of the Whole, for us to do a work session, um, if it's too much to, to get us on the regular BIC schedule, because this is a big deal and people are wanting to see what we're going to do.

3429
05:15:03.240 --> 05:15:09.220
<v Loretta Smith>And I remember last year I was bombarded with this, with this issue when we were going through LUBA.

3430
05:15:10.259 --> 05:15:15.139
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, the minority contractors were, were calling me and they weren't getting paid.

3431
05:15:15.299 --> 05:15:16.979
<v Loretta Smith>All of their equipment was on site.

3432
05:15:17.299 --> 05:15:18.419
<v Loretta Smith>They couldn't do anything else.

3433
05:15:18.659 --> 05:15:23.860
<v Loretta Smith>So it, it really put a, um, a strain on their budgets.

3434
05:15:24.900 --> 05:15:29.220
<v Loretta Smith>And so, uh, I want to make sure that we're, we're doing everything that we need to do.

3435
05:15:29.299 --> 05:15:31.060
<v Loretta Smith>We don't need any more distractions.

3436
05:15:31.779 --> 05:15:37.950
<v Loretta Smith>I know you can't help if there's an emergency that's uncontrollable.

3437
05:15:38.270 --> 05:15:44.590
<v Loretta Smith>That is an active God of sorts.

3438
05:15:46.830 --> 05:15:51.630
<v Loretta Smith>But I think that we'll be on the right track with using these funds.

3439
05:15:52.750 --> 05:15:55.470
<v Loretta Smith>And I think if you keep us really—.

3440
05:15:57.069 --> 05:15:58.029
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm sure.

3441
05:15:59.720 --> 05:16:05.479
<v Loretta Smith>When there are problems, little or small, let us know what it is because I think it can just get out of control.

3442
05:16:06.759 --> 05:16:07.240
<v Loretta Smith>But thank you.

3443
05:16:08.599 --> 05:16:09.319
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

3444
05:16:09.319 --> 05:16:17.799
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to use the opportunity to very briefly say we will be including an update on a filtration— on the filtration project and every month in the CAIS report.

3445
05:16:18.040 --> 05:16:21.560
<v Unidentified speaker>We also have a pub— transparency is very important to us.

3446
05:16:21.799 --> 05:16:25.240
<v Unidentified speaker>We want to— we want the public to know the status of the project.

3447
05:16:25.830 --> 05:16:31.750
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we have a website where we are updating the project status every month on the 20th of every month as well.

3448
05:16:32.150 --> 05:16:37.669
<v Unidentified speaker>And we are happy to come to the full council or committee of the whole to provide updates as well.

3449
05:16:37.990 --> 05:16:44.869
<v Loretta Smith>And when the weather gets warmer, I want to see how we can all go out on a bus and go on a field trip.

3450
05:16:45.349 --> 05:16:46.310
<v Unidentified speaker>We've scheduled it.

3451
05:16:47.509 --> 05:16:49.430
<v Loretta Smith>Are we going together or do we have to go separately?

3452
05:16:50.229 --> 05:16:51.590
<v Angelita Morillo>We're going— well, I think we're going—.

3453
05:16:51.669 --> 05:16:53.750
<v Unidentified speaker>The Public Works Committee is going together in August.

3454
05:16:53.830 --> 05:16:54.229
<v Loretta Smith>Public Works.

3455
05:16:54.389 --> 05:16:58.250
<v Loretta Smith>But I mean, We would be happy to take it to committee.

3456
05:16:59.849 --> 05:17:00.650
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

3457
05:17:00.810 --> 05:17:01.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

3458
05:17:01.930 --> 05:17:02.650
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

3459
05:17:05.209 --> 05:17:05.610
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

3460
05:17:05.689 --> 05:17:09.369
<v Candace Avalos>I know it's late and there are— this is a big item.

3461
05:17:09.369 --> 05:17:19.209
<v Candace Avalos>I think I just wanted to get in the queue to just put my, uh, put my voice in to say that I am just unsure.

3462
05:17:19.290 --> 05:17:20.729
<v Candace Avalos>I'm unsure about this.

3463
05:17:20.810 --> 05:17:22.650
<v Candace Avalos>I'm, I'm hearing the testimony.

3464
05:17:23.020 --> 05:17:25.979
<v Candace Avalos>We're talking broadly about affordability issues.

3465
05:17:25.979 --> 05:17:32.779
<v Candace Avalos>I'm concerned about the potential for people's water to double, triple.

3466
05:17:34.299 --> 05:17:38.619
<v Candace Avalos>You know, my HOA, the water bill is like bankrupting us.

3467
05:17:38.700 --> 05:17:41.180
<v Candace Avalos>Like, so it is a real problem.

3468
05:17:41.259 --> 05:17:45.819
<v Candace Avalos>And obviously I understand the need for infrastructure, the need for clean water.

3469
05:17:45.900 --> 05:17:48.900
<v Candace Avalos>We want to preserve our, you know, world-class clean water.

3470
05:17:49.700 --> 05:17:57.619
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and these trade-offs are just really hard, especially as we're making all of these other decisions, right, with the TUF and the arts tax and all of that.

3471
05:17:57.700 --> 05:17:59.939
<v Candace Avalos>We can't, um, look at this in a vacuum.

3472
05:18:01.060 --> 05:18:09.299
<v Candace Avalos>And so, um, you probably already said, but give— because this is a non-emergency ordinance, first reading, is that right, Council President?

3473
05:18:09.779 --> 05:18:09.860
<v Unidentified speaker>Correct.

3474
05:18:10.259 --> 05:18:10.340
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

3475
05:18:10.900 --> 05:18:20.360
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and then we've got the discussion next week about the rates, like Like, how does this conversation, I guess, overlap with that discussion?

3476
05:18:20.599 --> 05:18:28.759
<v Candace Avalos>I'm not sure how this fits into the current budget cycle, AKA I'm trying to, uh, understand what is the timeline.

3477
05:18:29.080 --> 05:18:33.080
<v Candace Avalos>Because as you're hearing, people are like, we should do work sessions, we should do more, you know, community engagement.

3478
05:18:33.479 --> 05:18:39.080
<v Candace Avalos>So can you just give me an understanding of the relationship of this ordinance to the rate conversation we have next week?

3479
05:18:41.240 --> 05:18:42.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, yeah, yeah.

3480
05:18:42.680 --> 05:18:43.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

3481
05:18:43.720 --> 05:18:54.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, So they are related just as sort of, this is all a thread of related actions over multiple years and budgets, actions play a role.

3482
05:18:54.700 --> 05:19:00.939
<v Jamie Dunphy>The ordinance today or for adoption, I guess next week, is specific to authorize the bonds.

3483
05:19:01.419 --> 05:19:05.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>Ultimately, those bonds have to be paid for with revenues.

3484
05:19:06.139 --> 05:19:12.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>So the bond, what the action does is allows the debt manager and team to start working on Setting that up.

3485
05:19:12.529 --> 05:19:17.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's a multi-month process to get to the point where we issue the bonds, get the money, contribute to the project.

3486
05:19:20.209 --> 05:19:26.529
<v Jamie Dunphy>On a parallel path, we have action to take around increasing rates or adjusting rates.

3487
05:19:27.009 --> 05:19:30.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that action will happen at whatever level Council chooses.

3488
05:19:31.650 --> 05:19:38.610
<v Jamie Dunphy>The rates that are proposed or will be proposed in the rate ordinance are built based upon an assumption of the costs related to this bond issue.

3489
05:19:39.220 --> 05:19:43.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>If council chooses something otherwise, the authorization for these bonds still stand.

3490
05:19:44.259 --> 05:19:49.700
<v Jamie Dunphy>The capacity won't be there to issue the full amount because we only issue the bonds that we actually have money to pay for.

3491
05:19:50.340 --> 05:19:54.979
<v Jamie Dunphy>So let's imagine if the rate increase request is 8% and council says, oh, we only want 2%.

3492
05:19:56.020 --> 05:20:00.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, then we don't issue $500 million of bonds because we don't have revenues to pay for it.

3493
05:20:01.380 --> 05:20:04.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>That then institutes all of the sort of cost increases Yeah.

3494
05:20:04.950 --> 05:20:06.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>Risks that we've just talked about in other contexts.

3495
05:20:07.430 --> 05:20:19.830
<v Jamie Dunphy>The other thing I'll note is from at least the sort of side of the folks sitting over here at the table, we don't intend and didn't intend this year for these 2 conversations to be so closely aligned in time.

3496
05:20:20.310 --> 05:20:26.630
<v Jamie Dunphy>But it was really challenging to find space on committees and agendas to not have them overlap.

3497
05:20:26.630 --> 05:20:29.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I just wanna acknowledge that that's not our objective.

3498
05:20:30.069 --> 05:20:32.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our objective is to actually have separation in these conversations.

3499
05:20:33.119 --> 05:20:35.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that it doesn't feel like it's all compressed at one time.

3500
05:20:35.200 --> 05:20:38.720
<v Jamie Dunphy>We just were sort of stuck in this moment in this particular month.

3501
05:20:41.119 --> 05:20:42.479
<v Candace Avalos>That's helpful to understand.

3502
05:20:42.880 --> 05:20:51.520
<v Candace Avalos>So am I interpreting this to say these calls that councilors have for more time and process, do we have time to do that?

3503
05:20:54.639 --> 05:21:00.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, I don't— I mean, ultimately council has the authority to do what you choose.

3504
05:21:00.639 --> 05:21:11.319
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think the risk is You know, we're bringing this item now because we do need to start the process to issue the bonds, to receive the money, and be able to fund the project without delay and cost increase.

3505
05:21:11.799 --> 05:21:16.599
<v Jamie Dunphy>So there is some time sensitivity around getting the authorization for the bonds.

3506
05:21:18.040 --> 05:21:25.479
<v Jamie Dunphy>Again, parallel track, there's obviously a time requirement to increase the rates relative to the budget actions that are coming over the next few weeks.

3507
05:21:26.520 --> 05:21:27.159
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

3508
05:21:27.970 --> 05:21:35.970
<v Candace Avalos>And then, um, this kind of question around— so what we're all talking about is that this is falling on the ratepayers, on the ratepayers.

3509
05:21:36.610 --> 05:21:38.290
<v Candace Avalos>Where does the general fund come into this?

3510
05:21:38.369 --> 05:21:41.650
<v Candace Avalos>Like, I guess I want to understand at what, what is our flexibility?

3511
05:21:42.290 --> 05:21:59.180
<v Candace Avalos>Like, if in the future we, you know, let's say we prove this as is, okay, in the future are we able to come back and say, okay, we're not going to— instead of, you know, this year we're slated to increase by X percentage to ratepayers, but instead we found General fund money to, to bypass that?

3512
05:21:59.340 --> 05:22:14.139
<v Candace Avalos>Like, help me understand our— what our options are in the future, um, so that I would understand what— by taking this action, whether it's in this form or not, are we going to be able to talk in the future about other revenue, whether we increase revenue in some other place?

3513
05:22:14.299 --> 05:22:19.020
<v Candace Avalos>And I know that water is mostly ratepayer, maybe even 100% now with the current budget.

3514
05:22:19.740 --> 05:22:25.150
<v Candace Avalos>So, um, I, I also want to understand the philosophy of that because I know that in this budget you guys moved a lot of general fund.

3515
05:22:25.709 --> 05:22:28.430
<v Candace Avalos>Not— it wasn't that much, but you moved it out officially.

3516
05:22:29.229 --> 05:22:32.990
<v Candace Avalos>So what would it look like to move general fund back in in the future for this kind of reason?

3517
05:22:33.310 --> 05:22:35.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, Councilor, that would always be something at council's discretion.

3518
05:22:37.229 --> 05:22:37.310
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

3519
05:22:39.790 --> 05:22:47.549
<v Candace Avalos>And so lastly, for next week, so this is on the agenda, Council President, to come back next week— oh, in 2 weeks.

3520
05:22:47.869 --> 05:22:47.950
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

3521
05:22:48.509 --> 05:22:51.610
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, and then that is It is next week.

3522
05:22:51.689 --> 05:22:52.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm wrong.

3523
05:22:52.330 --> 05:22:53.130
<v Mitch Green>Evan told me I'm wrong.

3524
05:22:54.729 --> 05:22:55.290
<v Candace Avalos>Oh, really?

3525
05:22:56.490 --> 05:22:58.569
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, we have a meeting next week.

3526
05:22:58.889 --> 05:23:04.889
<v Jamie Dunphy>I know, I, I believe— I mean, I can't see Evan, so he can throw something at me if I say wrong.

3527
05:23:04.889 --> 05:23:12.729
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe this is in the queue of a variety of items that'll be, um, in the suite of things for Wednesday next week, um, for adoption next week.

3528
05:23:12.970 --> 05:23:15.450
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, I can— I, I may be wrong.

3529
05:23:15.689 --> 05:23:16.569
<v Jamie Dunphy>I guess the following week.

3530
05:23:16.709 --> 05:23:16.869
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

3531
05:23:17.110 --> 05:23:18.549
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we're just doing the budget next week.

3532
05:23:18.630 --> 05:23:18.709
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

3533
05:23:19.830 --> 05:23:20.389
<v Jamie Dunphy>That may be true.

3534
05:23:20.549 --> 05:23:20.950
<v Jamie Dunphy>I can't recall.

3535
05:23:21.029 --> 05:23:23.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll get back to everybody as soon as I know.

3536
05:23:24.069 --> 05:23:24.150
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

3537
05:23:26.790 --> 05:23:28.630
<v Candace Avalos>Sorry, I got jumbled there with what my question was.

3538
05:23:29.029 --> 05:23:35.110
<v Candace Avalos>I think I was just asking then— no, I'll just leave it at that.

3539
05:23:35.830 --> 05:23:35.909
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

3540
05:23:36.790 --> 05:23:37.509
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

3541
05:23:39.110 --> 05:23:40.869
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to limit debate to those in the queue.

3542
05:23:41.990 --> 05:23:43.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, then Councilor Zimmerman.

3543
05:23:45.340 --> 05:23:45.580
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

3544
05:23:46.060 --> 05:23:56.619
<v Sameer Kanal>I have one question, um, and it's just to respond to what we've been seeing in the written and even in the, the verbal testimony around an independent audit.

3545
05:23:57.419 --> 05:24:05.659
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to stress that I know pretty much everybody up here inherited a lot of this and not try to put anything on you.

3546
05:24:05.900 --> 05:24:12.700
<v Sameer Kanal>I think, um, a lot of the work that you've been doing to create more public transparency and to to just get a handle on things is helpful.

3547
05:24:13.500 --> 05:24:27.340
<v Sameer Kanal>I also know that sometimes, and we know this on this side of the, the dais too, you inherit something that you didn't create, doesn't have a lot of public trust in it, and now you inherit the lack of public trust and have a responsibility to dig out of it too, even though it was not your fault.

3548
05:24:28.380 --> 05:24:37.500
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, one of the things that could help with that that's been suggested, I'm not sure until I ask this question, is an independent audit.

3549
05:24:39.200 --> 05:24:44.479
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to that in terms of what it would cost, what the timeline would be, why it— what the conversation's been?

3550
05:24:45.680 --> 05:24:46.400
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor.

3551
05:24:47.439 --> 05:24:52.159
<v Unidentified speaker>We are in the works of trying to create an independent financial oversight panel.

3552
05:24:52.959 --> 05:25:04.319
<v Unidentified speaker>And we are— Director Liu is bringing together the scope of work for that, what the panel structure would be, and what are the expertise that we are looking for in the panel.

3553
05:25:04.990 --> 05:25:07.150
<v Unidentified speaker>And we will be sending it to you all for feedback.

3554
05:25:07.229 --> 05:25:09.549
<v Unidentified speaker>And Director Lew, if you want to talk to that briefly.

3555
05:25:10.669 --> 05:25:18.669
<v Sameer Kanal>Is the use of the— is the choice of not using the word audit just because of the auditor, or is it some different scope of work?

3556
05:25:19.310 --> 05:25:21.069
<v Angelita Morillo>Do you mind if I step in here just for a moment?

3557
05:25:21.229 --> 05:25:24.189
<v Angelita Morillo>Because this is something that we discussed in the Public Works Committee.

3558
05:25:24.830 --> 05:25:41.939
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't know if you were then there yet, but we discussed this concept of having an An external independent audit, but we decided it in the short run now to go with this oversight committee to let them do their work and then decide, do we really— do we go to the next step?

3559
05:25:42.580 --> 05:25:45.299
<v Angelita Morillo>So that, that's, I think, the way we approached it in Public Works.

3560
05:25:46.020 --> 05:25:54.180
<v Angelita Morillo>They've put, they've put together this oversight committee, which I'm sure they can explain who's on it, what their function will be, but we did talk about an external independent audit.

3561
05:25:55.860 --> 05:25:56.099
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

3562
05:25:56.099 --> 05:25:57.259
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

3563
05:25:58.259 --> 05:26:01.459
<v Sameer Kanal>And then just a quick note on the conversation around the Committee of the Whole.

3564
05:26:01.540 --> 05:26:14.500
<v Sameer Kanal>When we were talking about this item and where to put it, I think my expectation— I can't speak for anybody else, but mine was that this would be about the bonds as a tool, not about the project itself.

3565
05:26:15.380 --> 05:26:16.500
<v Sameer Kanal>That is clearly not what happened.

3566
05:26:18.020 --> 05:26:21.779
<v Sameer Kanal>And based on that assumption, we went with send it to the Public Works Committee.

3567
05:26:22.840 --> 05:26:28.520
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think that there's a need to have a full council conversation about it.

3568
05:26:28.520 --> 05:26:30.040
<v Sameer Kanal>It sounds like a work session would work.

3569
05:26:30.599 --> 05:26:34.599
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm happy to facilitate that or not, as your discretion.

3570
05:26:34.759 --> 05:26:40.200
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm more concerned about the time slot than I am about who has the responsibility for the work of it.

3571
05:26:40.520 --> 05:26:46.520
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm happy to work on that with, I guess, both in the context of vice president and committee chair and the council president.

3572
05:26:47.479 --> 05:26:47.880
<v Sameer Kanal>But thank you.

3573
05:26:48.200 --> 05:26:48.279
<v Dan Ryan>Absolutely.

3574
05:26:48.360 --> 05:26:48.759
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

3575
05:26:48.759 --> 05:26:49.400
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

3576
05:26:49.560 --> 05:26:50.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

3577
05:26:51.880 --> 05:26:54.040
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, and thanks for letting me do this in a 2-part.

3578
05:26:54.119 --> 05:26:56.200
<v Eric Zimmerman>I had to run out quick, but thanks for the answer on the last one.

3579
05:26:56.279 --> 05:26:56.919
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate that.

3580
05:26:57.240 --> 05:26:59.560
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'll just re— I'm going to reframe what you said.

3581
05:26:59.639 --> 05:27:07.479
<v Eric Zimmerman>Basically, um, if we were to not issue these bonds, we'd have maybe worse than Sarah Palin's Bridge to Nowhere.

3582
05:27:07.720 --> 05:27:16.029
<v Eric Zimmerman>We would have a hole to nowhere that we then have to decommission, refill to nowhere for the tune of about a billion If I kind of got your estimates right.

3583
05:27:16.189 --> 05:27:18.830
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that, that was helpful for me to hear, and I appreciate that.

3584
05:27:20.029 --> 05:27:34.909
<v Eric Zimmerman>The other part I wanted to just really double-check, because as a, as a layperson for the last 20 years in Portland, just knowing that the feds were talking about something that we had to come in compliance with and trying to come up to speed with that.

3585
05:27:35.150 --> 05:27:47.060
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, Priya, you ended, I think, when— before we stepped out, that we still have to do the filtration, or I know there are some folks that want us to zap the water with lights or whatever it is, right?

3586
05:27:49.540 --> 05:27:57.939
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if we just say, damn it, we're not doing it, does that mean that the EPA then says, cool, we're gonna take over your system and do it for you?

3587
05:27:58.259 --> 05:27:59.139
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that the situation?

3588
05:28:00.419 --> 05:28:00.580
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

3589
05:28:00.979 --> 05:28:06.180
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, everybody's nodding their heads, and I'll just tell you, like, I'm not looking forward to Trump water.

3590
05:28:06.939 --> 05:28:07.020
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

3591
05:28:07.659 --> 05:28:07.740
<v Angelita Morillo>Right?

3592
05:28:07.900 --> 05:28:10.939
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is something that is deeply concerning to me, and I'll tell you why.

3593
05:28:11.259 --> 05:28:18.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I don't think that they would give a darn about anybody along Oxbow, Lusted Road, Dodge Park.

3594
05:28:19.259 --> 05:28:25.979
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think they'd bulldoze everything and say the hell with it, and there wouldn't be a whole lot of environmental protecting going on.

3595
05:28:27.020 --> 05:28:48.860
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I do have that concern, meaning I, like most everybody up here and everybody sitting at the dais, Much of this decision was off to the races before we all got into the seats that we're in, and I'm feeling a commitment, frankly, that you have a responsibility to finish a job once you've started it, even if maybe it wasn't the one you would have picked.

3596
05:28:48.939 --> 05:28:55.659
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm not even making that value judgment because I'm not really sure that UV lighting water is the thing here.

3597
05:28:55.900 --> 05:28:57.819
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not sure why that's getting so much attention right now.

3598
05:28:57.900 --> 05:29:01.189
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we all Decided, or previous people decided that wasn't going to work.

3599
05:29:01.750 --> 05:29:12.790
<v Eric Zimmerman>But there are some aspects of avoiding the Trump Water idea that are very attractive to me, meaning the thousands of people who will work on this project.

3600
05:29:13.430 --> 05:29:16.709
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can we do it from a community benefits standpoint, a PLA?

3601
05:29:16.869 --> 05:29:22.790
<v Eric Zimmerman>That means we put Portland wages into— I'll say Portland region workers.

3602
05:29:24.229 --> 05:29:26.549
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is attractive to I'll say that.

3603
05:29:26.790 --> 05:29:33.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then I wanted to double-check how many municipalities are actually on this system.

3604
05:29:34.310 --> 05:29:37.189
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not just Portland Water, is that right?

3605
05:29:38.470 --> 05:29:38.549
<v Unidentified speaker>Correct.

3606
05:29:40.229 --> 05:29:48.630
<v Unidentified speaker>Aside from Portland, we have at least, we have 15 partner agencies who have renewed their contract with us for the next 30 years.

3607
05:29:49.349 --> 05:29:58.560
<v Eric Zimmerman>15 Agencies who've renewed their contract with us for the next 30 years, which means when we talk about ratepayers, we're not So we're not just talking about Portland, we're talking about everybody across that system?

3608
05:29:59.360 --> 05:29:59.439
<v Loretta Smith>Correct.

3609
05:30:00.000 --> 05:30:04.319
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, that is somewhat helpful.

3610
05:30:04.560 --> 05:30:08.400
<v Eric Zimmerman>It seems like a somewhat of a vote of confidence, if you will, from our customers.

3611
05:30:08.799 --> 05:30:11.360
<v Eric Zimmerman>In that sense, we are providing customer service to them.

3612
05:30:12.479 --> 05:30:22.080
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I mean, I'm very sensitive to the points that were made about how do we, how do we monitor costs, how do we, how do we ensure that we aren't ballooning or doing unnecessary stuff.

3613
05:30:22.209 --> 05:30:25.889
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I'm not getting the sense that that's where this conversation is.

3614
05:30:25.970 --> 05:30:35.169
<v Eric Zimmerman>I feel like some of the advocacy that's happening today are the same advocates who were there 5 years ago who just lost and are trying to rehash the issue right now.

3615
05:30:35.729 --> 05:30:39.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't know that that is the crux of today's decision.

3616
05:30:39.970 --> 05:30:51.740
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm leaning quite supportively, mostly because I would like Portland and Oregonians to do this and not federal failing EPA standards to do this.

3617
05:30:51.900 --> 05:30:53.659
<v Eric Zimmerman>If we have to do it, I'd like to do it our way.

3618
05:30:55.580 --> 05:31:04.139
<v Eric Zimmerman>I believe that the point that Priya made as our Deputy City Administrator, that we have all new leadership up here, is an important point and something that I'm taking very seriously.

3619
05:31:05.099 --> 05:31:19.040
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that I think we are working with our, our local labor to make sure that we deliver this project with local labor, with PLA and CBA et cetera, et cetera, that is something I see a future in, even if these 3 years suck.

3620
05:31:20.000 --> 05:31:21.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that's okay to acknowledge.

3621
05:31:22.720 --> 05:31:27.520
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I don't want to be Sarah Palin with my bridge to nowhere that we actually have to take down and put trees back on.

3622
05:31:28.000 --> 05:31:32.799
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I definitely don't want Trump Water to be the thing we have to put on our side of our trucks instead of Portland Water.

3623
05:31:33.200 --> 05:31:35.040
<v Eric Zimmerman>So you'll have my support when it's time.

3624
05:31:36.959 --> 05:31:38.000
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

3625
05:31:38.639 --> 05:31:39.159
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, Aye.

3626
05:31:39.639 --> 05:31:42.840
<v Jamie Dunphy>With no one else in the queue, this item now moves to second reading.

3627
05:31:44.439 --> 05:31:45.560
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that is the end of our agenda.

3628
05:31:45.959 --> 05:31:49.240
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are a full 90 minutes over where I thought we'd be, but we made it.

3629
05:31:49.639 --> 05:31:50.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>We got everything accomplished.

3630
05:31:51.159 --> 05:31:52.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>With that, we are adjourned.

3631
05:31:52.599 --> 05:31:54.200
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you everybody for being here so late.

