WEBVTT

1
00:07:32.735 --> 00:07:33.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

2
00:07:34.175 --> 00:07:38.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>Calling to order this meeting, this work session of the Portland City Council.

3
00:07:38.161 --> 00:07:42.644
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is Friday, May 8th.

4
00:07:42.838 --> 00:07:49.848
<v Jamie Dunphy>This morning we're going to hear from the city— well, we're going to hear about 4 different presentations, largely three.

5
00:07:50.009 --> 00:07:56.711
<v Jamie Dunphy>But around core services realignment, we're going to hear about contracting within the city, and we're going to hear about span of control.

6
00:07:56.809 --> 00:07:59.459
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe I'm welcoming DCA Tracy Warren to the dais.

7
00:08:06.002 --> 00:08:13.934
<v Jamie Dunphy>Tracy, I'm not sure how you all had planned this, whether it was presentation Q&A, presentation Q&A, or if you want to just get through everything and.

8
00:08:14.636 --> 00:08:15.596
<v Jamie Dunphy>Have Q&A at the end?

9
00:08:15.853 --> 00:08:16.413
<v Dan Ryan>What would you prefer?

10
00:08:16.574 --> 00:08:24.922
<v Tracy Warren>Goal was to have, uh, Q&A in between each presentation so that folks could ask questions while the material is fresh.

11
00:08:25.065 --> 00:08:25.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

12
00:08:25.451 --> 00:08:27.598
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will, uh, let you get through the first presentation.

13
00:08:27.646 --> 00:08:28.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will pause.

14
00:08:28.574 --> 00:08:38.092
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I will, uh, hold us to the same 5-minute timeline for each, uh, time we get to ask questions, and then we will get through all 3 presentations today.

15
00:08:38.140 --> 00:08:39.486
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Tracy, take it away.

16
00:08:40.591 --> 00:08:41.666
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you, Council President.

17
00:08:41.714 --> 00:08:42.770
<v Tracy Warren>Good morning, Council.

18
00:08:42.980 --> 00:08:44.602
<v Tracy Warren>Good evening, Council President, Council Members, and City Administrator and Mayor.

19
00:08:45.100 --> 00:08:50.467
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you for the opportunity to present to Council the core services realignment.

20
00:08:50.966 --> 00:08:54.346
<v Tracy Warren>I'm Tracy Warren, the Deputy City Administrator for City Operations.

21
00:08:55.659 --> 00:09:00.057
<v Tracy Warren>We are presenting this budget proposal— oh, I'm sorry.

22
00:09:00.606 --> 00:09:01.399
<v Tracy Warren>Give me just one second.

23
00:09:07.110 --> 00:09:07.789
<v Tracy Warren>Apologies.

24
00:09:07.966 --> 00:09:10.826
<v Tracy Warren>I had a little bit of my talking points from the last time we were here.

25
00:09:10.892 --> 00:09:12.249
<v Olivia Clark>That's okay.

26
00:09:12.328 --> 00:09:14.879
<v Tracy Warren>Last week we ran out of time to present and thank you, Council President Olivia Clark.

27
00:09:14.879 --> 00:09:16.419
<v Tracy Warren>Today we are here to discuss the core services realignment.

28
00:09:17.200 --> 00:09:21.019
<v Tracy Warren>I want to thank you all for making time for an additional work session.

29
00:09:21.019 --> 00:09:24.980
<v Tracy Warren>I know that time is limited, especially during this season, so that's greatly appreciated.

30
00:09:26.100 --> 00:09:29.460
<v Tracy Warren>We have time today to discuss 3 different topics.

31
00:09:29.559 --> 00:09:39.139
<v Tracy Warren>We'll talk about the core service realignment now, we'll do question and answers, and then we'll move on to span of control and then contracting out with the same format.

32
00:09:39.360 --> 00:09:50.155
<v Tracy Warren>Before we begin, I want to acknowledge the moment we are in and thank the many employees and leaders who worked incredibly hard to develop this proposal under difficult circumstances.

33
00:09:51.149 --> 00:10:02.102
<v Tracy Warren>The teams involved approached this work with clear focus on minimizing impacts to both people and services while still addressing the significant financial challenges before us.

34
00:10:03.498 --> 00:10:05.197
<v Tracy Warren>This was no easy task.

35
00:10:05.744 --> 00:10:16.095
<v Tracy Warren>We also know many employees, some of which who are sitting behind us today, would like to have had more time engagement and discussion throughout the process.

36
00:10:16.840 --> 00:10:19.428
<v Tracy Warren>We hear that feedback and we understand it.

37
00:10:20.157 --> 00:10:31.898
<v Tracy Warren>The reality is that teams worked within very compressed timelines and had limited resources while also continuing to deliver critical day-to-day services for the organization.

38
00:10:33.730 --> 00:10:38.808
<v Tracy Warren>These decisions were not made lightly, and we recognize that there are very real impacts.

39
00:10:39.927 --> 00:10:44.847
<v Tracy Warren>That will be had on employees, teams, and the services our bureaus rely on every day.

40
00:10:45.830 --> 00:10:57.581
<v Tracy Warren>This proposal reflects a careful and deliberate effort to balance significant financial constraints while preserving the core internal services necessary to continue serving Portlanders effectively.

41
00:11:00.422 --> 00:11:05.100
<v Tracy Warren>And while this proposal represents an important step, this work is not done yet.

42
00:11:06.244 --> 00:11:17.366
<v Tracy Warren>There's still more work ahead as we continue refining how we deliver services, support employees, and build a more sustainable internal services model for our future.

43
00:11:18.902 --> 00:11:24.361
<v Tracy Warren>I'm going to kick off the realignment presentation with Human Resources, Procurement, Information Technology.

44
00:11:24.960 --> 00:11:35.284
<v Tracy Warren>I'm joined here today by Chief Communications Officer Laura Oppenheimer, who will briefly discuss the communications realignment before handing it over to Chief Engagement Officer Amanda Garcia-Snell.

45
00:11:37.495 --> 00:11:39.964
<v Tracy Warren>To walk through the engagement and equity services.

46
00:11:41.350 --> 00:11:42.043
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide, please.

47
00:11:44.402 --> 00:11:50.395
<v Tracy Warren>We last presented information on the realignment project during the March 11th work session.

48
00:11:51.714 --> 00:12:01.033
<v Tracy Warren>The work is focused on transitioning key administrative functions to a more centralized enterprise model to better support the city's new form of government.

49
00:12:01.741 --> 00:12:11.238
<v Tracy Warren>The goal is to reduce duplication and improve consistency across the organization so that we are better aligned with our new next slide, please.

50
00:12:14.004 --> 00:12:18.418
<v Tracy Warren>The 6 groups listed on this slide submitted packages as part of the mayor's proposed budget.

51
00:12:19.049 --> 00:12:27.783
<v Tracy Warren>While communications is listed on this slide, and we'll touch on it briefly, we did implement realignment of the communications function in January of this year.

52
00:12:29.152 --> 00:12:34.886
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, you'll see the budget and finance group is not represented on this slide.

53
00:12:34.934 --> 00:12:38.865
<v Tracy Warren>I know this came up during our budget conversations last week and the prior work session.

54
00:12:41.144 --> 00:12:46.884
<v Tracy Warren>They paused their work to focus on budget development, but plan to continue this work after the budget process.

55
00:12:48.190 --> 00:12:48.592
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

56
00:12:51.754 --> 00:12:56.062
<v Tracy Warren>This slide shows the general staffing model for the centralized service delivery.

57
00:12:56.756 --> 00:13:06.379
<v Tracy Warren>Each service is led by a director or a chief officer that oversees a core team and embedded teams who are then assigned to support service area.

58
00:13:06.832 --> 00:13:08.087
<v Tracy Warren>Across the enterprise.

59
00:13:09.005 --> 00:13:14.672
<v Tracy Warren>The next couple of slides will provide more context into what it means to be part of a core and embedded team.

60
00:13:16.039 --> 00:13:17.326
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

61
00:13:18.791 --> 00:13:25.216
<v Tracy Warren>The core team within the bureau office are primarily focused on governance, strategy, and standardization.

62
00:13:26.039 --> 00:13:32.188
<v Tracy Warren>They provide services that are enhanced through standardization and require stricter oversight to mitigate risk.

63
00:13:32.253 --> 00:13:32.414
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

64
00:13:33.291 --> 00:13:40.442
<v Tracy Warren>For example, administering employee benefits, cybersecurity, or capital projects contracting.

65
00:13:41.500 --> 00:13:43.600
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

66
00:13:45.169 --> 00:13:52.736
<v Tracy Warren>Embedded teams are the vehicles by which services guided by the core teams are delivered throughout the enterprise to support customer bureaus.

67
00:13:53.416 --> 00:14:03.111
<v Tracy Warren>The embedded teams are able to learn and navigate the intricacies of the customers they serve in alignment with the standards set by the core service bureau.

68
00:14:03.629 --> 00:14:12.061
<v Tracy Warren>For example, entering time codes or processing personnel actions or supporting applications and desktops.

69
00:14:13.620 --> 00:14:16.591
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

70
00:14:18.216 --> 00:14:26.278
<v Tracy Warren>This table shows current and future staffing levels within each core service area along with implementation status.

71
00:14:27.240 --> 00:14:42.357
<v Tracy Warren>Overall, we are reducing from 798 FTE to 729, a net reduction of 69 positions across core services, with the largest reductions being made in technology and human resources.

72
00:14:43.830 --> 00:14:44.153
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

73
00:14:47.725 --> 00:14:53.369
<v Tracy Warren>This slide details total position changes within each of the service areas.

74
00:14:53.450 --> 00:14:59.355
<v Tracy Warren>The City Administrator's Office and the core or existing groups providing services today.

75
00:15:00.301 --> 00:15:12.725
<v Tracy Warren>In this chart, City Operations refers to all of the other bureaus and offices and programs that sit within the City Operations service area, excluding HR, procurement, and IT.

76
00:15:13.542 --> 00:15:21.157
<v Tracy Warren>Similarly, the City Administrator's Office core in this table refers to all other bureaus and programs, excluding equity and engagement.

77
00:15:21.253 --> 00:15:21.365
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

78
00:15:22.849 --> 00:15:35.200
<v Tracy Warren>The row titled core references the total number of staff performing engagement, equity, human resources, procurement, and technology work in those bureaus today and in the future state.

79
00:15:36.970 --> 00:15:42.751
<v Tracy Warren>We laid the table out this way so that you could see all of the dynamics taking place within this realignment.

80
00:15:45.524 --> 00:16:04.284
<v Tracy Warren>Reductions, additions of new positions required to support new service structures, and lastly, realignment to demerge demonstrate the rebalancing of existing staff by moving positions into and out of bureaus or service areas to provide more consistent service delivery across the enterprise.

81
00:16:05.835 --> 00:16:06.221
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

82
00:16:09.303 --> 00:16:17.970
<v Tracy Warren>With that, we're going to focus on 3 services that comprise the city operations realignment efforts, which is HR, procurement, and IT.

83
00:16:18.682 --> 00:16:18.908
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

84
00:16:23.211 --> 00:16:27.350
<v Tracy Warren>I wanted to provide more information and context around the project timeline.

85
00:16:27.703 --> 00:16:33.623
<v Tracy Warren>The next couple of slides will provide a high-level overview of the activities the team has accomplished so far.

86
00:16:34.664 --> 00:16:39.894
<v Tracy Warren>This project was assigned in late 2024 and began in January of 2025.

87
00:16:40.456 --> 00:16:46.438
<v Tracy Warren>The DCA at the time brought on Next Strategies to assist with a Phase 1 and a Phase 2 of the project.

88
00:16:47.721 --> 00:16:52.096
<v Tracy Warren>Phase 1, the primary focus was on understanding our current environment.

89
00:16:53.039 --> 00:17:06.218
<v Tracy Warren>Next Strategies assessed existing reports, available performance data, processes, and administrative documents, and conducted stakeholder interviews to better understand existing service structures and challenges.

90
00:17:08.271 --> 00:17:22.826
<v Tracy Warren>They engaged a total of 46 participants, including the city administrator, the Assistant City Administrator at the time, the majority of the Deputy City Administrators, as well as directors and high-level managers overseeing these functions across the enterprise.

91
00:17:25.342 --> 00:17:35.832
<v Tracy Warren>In their Phase 1 report, they identified key challenges and opportunities for shorter and longer service delivery improvements and proposed a service model to facilitate those improvements.

92
00:17:36.190 --> 00:17:36.336
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

93
00:17:38.913 --> 00:17:49.391
<v Tracy Warren>In phase 2, we convened subgroups to explore how we could better leverage the service or area model to improve responsiveness, consistency, and performance.

94
00:17:50.082 --> 00:18:01.025
<v Tracy Warren>62 Employees were identified by deputy city administrators to serve on the 9 subgroups to further discuss identifying opportunities for improvement and to develop a framework.

95
00:18:01.972 --> 00:18:09.317
<v Tracy Warren>The group was nearly even split 30/32 for managers and non-managers performing and overseeing these functions.

96
00:18:10.471 --> 00:18:31.828
<v Tracy Warren>As part of phase 2, the report phase, NECT strategies recommended phased transition, targeted improvements by function, and 4 foundational needs: clarity in roles and processes, consistent standards, role-specific training, and greater transparency around timelines, criteria, and workflows.

97
00:18:33.386 --> 00:18:38.058
<v Tracy Warren>In late May, the budget and finance track of this project was assigned.

98
00:18:38.588 --> 00:18:47.869
<v Tracy Warren>Those 2 subgroups kicked off in late summer with 25 participants, but that project track paused to allow members to focus on budget development.

99
00:18:48.640 --> 00:18:56.958
<v Tracy Warren>With phase 1 and 2 project complete— of the project completed, we briefed councilors, the mayor, and the city administrator and directors.

100
00:18:57.778 --> 00:18:59.875
<v Tracy Warren>On the project and the next steps.

101
00:19:00.538 --> 00:19:00.924
<v Angelita Morillo>Next slide.

102
00:19:04.959 --> 00:19:11.086
<v Tracy Warren>The next phase of the work was done without consulting support and completed with existing staffing resources.

103
00:19:11.847 --> 00:19:25.019
<v Tracy Warren>In fall of 2025, we worked with the DCAs to identify business operations leads to represent each service area and selected shared service managers to drive the project for each function.

104
00:19:26.925 --> 00:19:32.125
<v Tracy Warren>This team worked together to gather data and ultimately develop our proposals for realignment.

105
00:19:33.327 --> 00:19:47.833
<v Tracy Warren>Through fall into winter, we provided updates to labor partners, directors, and hosted our first webinar for employees across the enterprise who perform HR, IT, and procurement work to update them on the project.

106
00:19:48.971 --> 00:20:02.910
<v Tracy Warren>In January, we returned to labor partners and council with our realignment proposals and met with each service area to discuss proposals and revise concepts based on their feedback and to reduce risk during realignment.

107
00:20:03.824 --> 00:20:09.307
<v Tracy Warren>Those risk mitigation concepts were what I presented to council in March of this year.

108
00:20:10.478 --> 00:20:20.788
<v Tracy Warren>At the end of March, we provided informal notifications to employees who had been potentially impacted if we were to go with a 20% reduction scenario for these services.

109
00:20:20.853 --> 00:20:21.045
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

110
00:20:22.069 --> 00:20:28.086
<v Tracy Warren>At the end of April, we began notifying employees whose positions will be moved as part of realignment.

111
00:20:29.122 --> 00:20:33.829
<v Tracy Warren>And as of now, these teams are working to roll out function-specific onboarding.

112
00:20:34.665 --> 00:20:40.762
<v Tracy Warren>We are coordinating with service areas to identify, draft, and revise any existing service level agreements.

113
00:20:42.229 --> 00:20:42.615
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

114
00:20:45.694 --> 00:20:50.971
<v Tracy Warren>Now I'll walk through the HR, procurement, and technology-specific realignment proposals.

115
00:20:51.326 --> 00:20:52.019
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

116
00:20:55.863 --> 00:21:07.469
<v Tracy Warren>Starting with human resources, this slide highlights a $4.2 million savings, which reduces staffing from 184 FTE to 159 FTE.

117
00:21:08.483 --> 00:21:16.598
<v Tracy Warren>With this realignment, we will be reorganizing services like hiring, payroll, and employee training into a central reporting structure.

118
00:21:17.519 --> 00:21:30.605
<v Tracy Warren>While we are in the process of transitioning, some aspects of service delivery may be slower as we prioritize higher-risk functions like payroll, labor relations, and compliance-oriented work like benefits and leave administration.

119
00:21:32.720 --> 00:21:33.057
<v Angelita Morillo>Next slide.

120
00:21:36.527 --> 00:21:42.094
<v Tracy Warren>This slide format will look familiar to you from the briefings that we've held in the past.

121
00:21:42.445 --> 00:21:47.325
<v Tracy Warren>It reflects the cost savings of the reduction as well as the net FTE reduction.

122
00:21:48.078 --> 00:21:59.442
<v Tracy Warren>In the case of human resources, there are a total of 39 reductions, but they are creating 14 positions, which creates a net FTE reduction of 25 positions.

123
00:22:00.500 --> 00:22:09.606
<v Tracy Warren>This slide also breaks down where reductions are being taken by service area and demonstrates changes to the managerial footprints in the future state.

124
00:22:10.479 --> 00:22:24.488
<v Tracy Warren>The table in the bottom right corner breaks down the reductions by position type, and the furthest right column names the net impact to that position type, accounting for positions that would be created by this realignment.

125
00:22:24.843 --> 00:22:32.989
<v Tracy Warren>For human resources, 14 management positions will be reduced or reclassed, creating a span of control of 1 to 8.

126
00:22:35.075 --> 00:22:35.443
<v Olivia Clark>Next slide.

127
00:22:38.048 --> 00:22:44.528
<v Tracy Warren>This slide details a table that focuses on position changes related to human resources.

128
00:22:44.801 --> 00:22:56.705
<v Tracy Warren>The largest shift you, you can see here is the increase from 100 FTE to 115 FTE within the Bureau of Human Resources, reflecting the move to a more centralized service model.

129
00:22:57.383 --> 00:23:12.012
<v Tracy Warren>For example, we've had fragmented responsibility for administering our employee protected leave programs with a small central team supporting reporting to some bureaus and other bureaus having staff that report to them doing the work as well.

130
00:23:12.479 --> 00:23:24.015
<v Tracy Warren>Almost half of these are a reflection of moving this work all to one team for shared knowledge, workload support, and greater consistency for employees accessing these resources.

131
00:23:24.994 --> 00:23:32.288
<v Tracy Warren>Overall, this table reflects both a reduction in total positions as well as a rebalancing of where positions sit to perform work.

132
00:23:33.530 --> 00:23:40.310
<v Tracy Warren>The increase in capacity within the central team will benefit the entire enterprise as they provide support across the city.

133
00:23:41.132 --> 00:23:41.550
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

134
00:23:45.962 --> 00:23:53.596
<v Tracy Warren>Even in this challenging budget year, our prior— our priority remains delivering consistent, high-quality services to our employees.

135
00:23:55.222 --> 00:23:59.616
<v Tracy Warren>First, we are preserving embedded HR support where proximity matters most.

136
00:24:00.366 --> 00:24:06.398
<v Tracy Warren>Ensuring bureaus still have direct relationship-based support for day-to-day needs.

137
00:24:07.320 --> 00:24:14.457
<v Tracy Warren>We are maintaining strong recruitment and hiring services, which are critical to attracting and onboarding the workforce the city depends on.

138
00:24:16.029 --> 00:24:24.138
<v Tracy Warren>Employee relations support remains a priority, providing guidance to both managers and employees and helping maintain a stable and effective workplace.

139
00:24:25.798 --> 00:24:36.442
<v Tracy Warren>And we are continuing to deliver essential compliance and personnel services, including labor obligations, leave administration, and required personnel processes.

140
00:24:37.585 --> 00:24:45.740
<v Tracy Warren>Overall, while the structure is changing, these services remain in place because they are essential to supporting our workforce and in turn serving the public.

141
00:24:46.321 --> 00:24:46.758
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

142
00:24:50.368 --> 00:24:52.297
<v Tracy Warren>We're now going to move on to procurement.

143
00:24:52.718 --> 00:24:55.278
<v Tracy Warren>There is a savings of $669,900.

144
00:24:57.472 --> 00:25:04.588
<v Tracy Warren>In '88, which represents a total reduction of staffing from 78 FTE to 77 FTE.

145
00:25:06.105 --> 00:25:15.186
<v Tracy Warren>We are applying a similar approach— contracting, purchasing, and grant administration— which will now operate with a more unified, centralized structure.

146
00:25:16.214 --> 00:25:25.353
<v Tracy Warren>As with HR, there may be some initial adjustments, including longer timelines as we prioritize compliance requirements and major projects.

147
00:25:25.402 --> 00:25:25.515
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

148
00:25:26.590 --> 00:25:37.567
<v Tracy Warren>While the staffing impact is relatively a small change, it includes important realignments into centralized enterprise teams and identifying designated capital project support.

149
00:25:38.369 --> 00:25:38.853
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

150
00:25:43.175 --> 00:25:47.902
<v Tracy Warren>In procurement, one position is being reduced within the existing procurement team.

151
00:25:48.433 --> 00:25:54.451
<v Tracy Warren>You'll see a slight reduction in their managerial footprint as well, creating a span of control of 1 to 6.

152
00:25:54.568 --> 00:25:54.786
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

153
00:25:56.586 --> 00:25:57.117
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

154
00:26:01.019 --> 00:26:11.976
<v Tracy Warren>This table details changes within procurement with a small net reduction from 78 to 77 FT. Again, this table does not capture total support for each service area.

155
00:26:12.039 --> 00:26:17.397
<v Tracy Warren>That said, it does show a rebalancing of existing resources across the enterprise.

156
00:26:18.155 --> 00:26:27.349
<v Tracy Warren>We see movement into areas like community and economic development and public safety, while public works see a slight decrease as roles are distributed.

157
00:26:28.161 --> 00:26:36.493
<v Tracy Warren>The core procurement team remains relatively stable, reflecting continuity in central operations while still supporting enterprise-wide coordination.

158
00:26:37.722 --> 00:26:38.126
<v Angelita Morillo>Next slide.

159
00:26:41.199 --> 00:26:48.056
<v Tracy Warren>As with HR, procurement will be focused on preserving the services that are most critical to operations and service delivery.

160
00:26:49.123 --> 00:26:55.836
<v Tracy Warren>First, we are maintaining embedded procurement support where specialized needs require close coordination with bureaus.

161
00:26:56.561 --> 00:27:01.269
<v Tracy Warren>This ensures complex or high-touch work remains well supported.

162
00:27:02.184 --> 00:27:11.715
<v Tracy Warren>We are continuing timely purchasing and contracting services, which are essential to keeping city operations running without disruption.

163
00:27:13.410 --> 00:27:22.861
<v Tracy Warren>Compliance remains a top priority, ensuring procurement meets processes, meet legal requirements, maintain competitiveness, and uphold transparency.

164
00:27:24.603 --> 00:27:31.442
<v Tracy Warren>At the same time, we are strengthening centralized expertise to improve consistency and efficiency across the city.

165
00:27:32.767 --> 00:27:41.576
<v Tracy Warren>Overall, while the structure is evolving, these core procurement services remain in place to support bureaus and service areas and maintain effective operations.

166
00:27:42.968 --> 00:27:43.404
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

167
00:27:46.705 --> 00:27:49.749
<v Tracy Warren>We're now moving on to technology services.

168
00:27:50.748 --> 00:28:02.086
<v Tracy Warren>There's an estimated savings of $13.1 million, which represents a total reduction of staffing from 394 FTE to 363 FTE.

169
00:28:03.577 --> 00:28:14.145
<v Tracy Warren>As part of the technology realignment, the BTS core group will be responsible for cybersecurity, technology infrastructure, and managing enterprise systems.

170
00:28:15.461 --> 00:28:27.134
<v Tracy Warren>Roles supporting business applications, data and spatial analysis, and technology endpoint and license management are being realigned from bureaus to support service areas through embedded teams.

171
00:28:28.599 --> 00:28:28.840
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

172
00:28:32.076 --> 00:28:40.603
<v Tracy Warren>Of the $13.1 million cost savings, Technology Services was able to achieve $7.1 million in savings through non-personnel changes.

173
00:28:41.442 --> 00:28:48.730
<v Tracy Warren>There are a total of 37 reductions as part of this realignment, both in core BTS and Public Works.

174
00:28:48.778 --> 00:28:48.894
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

175
00:28:49.894 --> 00:28:53.288
<v Tracy Warren>Of the 37 reductions, 23 vacancies were cut.

176
00:28:54.679 --> 00:29:01.375
<v Tracy Warren>Technology also has a reduction in their managerial footprint, creating a span of control of 1 to 8.

177
00:29:02.585 --> 00:29:03.036
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

178
00:29:05.960 --> 00:29:11.375
<v Tracy Warren>Once again, this table details position changes related to technology services.

179
00:29:12.281 --> 00:29:16.667
<v Tracy Warren>As you can see, the most significant reduction is in the public works service area.

180
00:29:16.719 --> 00:29:16.838
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

181
00:29:17.326 --> 00:29:24.576
<v Tracy Warren>Where most positions are being reduced and some positions are being shifted to other service areas to even out service delivery.

182
00:29:26.029 --> 00:29:26.384
<v Sylvester>Next slide.

183
00:29:29.685 --> 00:29:41.307
<v Tracy Warren>One of the things that the technology group was able to achieve that is unique within their realignment is they were able to achieve a significant reduction that was not related to personnel.

184
00:29:41.726 --> 00:29:54.810
<v Tracy Warren>This slide breaks down the series of non-personnel reductions which target duplicative tools, Underused or unsupported devices, and increasing the replacement cycles for laptops at the city.

185
00:29:55.472 --> 00:30:05.741
<v Tracy Warren>While these reductions do carry risk as bureaus transition into enterprise tools, it will provide long-term benefits for service support and strategic purchasing moving forward.

186
00:30:07.352 --> 00:30:07.915
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

187
00:30:10.717 --> 00:30:17.136
<v Tracy Warren>Mirroring HR and procurement, IT will provide embedded support to service areas where proximity to the day-to-day business is important.

188
00:30:17.186 --> 00:30:17.287
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

189
00:30:19.609 --> 00:30:27.656
<v Tracy Warren>A primary focus will be providing secure and reliable support for computers, phones, and key business applications.

190
00:30:28.804 --> 00:30:36.489
<v Tracy Warren>And finally, we will strengthen technology governance and standardization by strategically modernizing our technology portfolio.

191
00:30:37.294 --> 00:30:42.657
<v Tracy Warren>Managing fewer, more connected systems increases efficiency and security.

192
00:30:43.655 --> 00:30:48.667
<v Tracy Warren>Council will see future discussions around investment in more modern payroll, HR, and finance systems.

193
00:30:50.942 --> 00:30:55.446
<v Tracy Warren>As well as upgrading our vital public safety communications infrastructure.

194
00:30:56.794 --> 00:31:07.584
<v Tracy Warren>With that, I will hand this off to Chief Communications Officer Laura Oppenheimer to talk to you about the previously implemented communications realignment.

195
00:31:08.721 --> 00:31:09.428
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thanks, Tracy.

196
00:31:09.619 --> 00:31:10.614
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Good morning, everyone.

197
00:31:10.982 --> 00:31:11.848
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I'm Laura Oppenheimer.

198
00:31:11.929 --> 00:31:15.921
<v Laura Oppenheimer>I use she and her pronouns, and I am the city's Chief Communications Officer.

199
00:31:16.577 --> 00:31:24.357
<v Laura Oppenheimer>You heard from DCA Warren about the integrated approach to realigning the technology, human resources, and procurement functions.

200
00:31:24.938 --> 00:31:31.921
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Similarly, we see communications, engagement, and equity as a closely integrated suite of core services.

201
00:31:32.097 --> 00:31:40.796
<v Laura Oppenheimer>By building a shared foundation for those services, we have the opportunity to improve outcomes for community and improve the way we work within the organization.

202
00:31:41.826 --> 00:31:42.515
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next slide, please.

203
00:31:45.071 --> 00:31:59.627
<v Laura Oppenheimer>As a reminder, we initiated the communications realignment last November in the fall technical adjustment and we implemented that new structure in January of this year under the umbrella of the City Communications Office.

204
00:32:00.690 --> 00:32:07.559
<v Laura Oppenheimer>However, the technical adjustment ordinance does not enshrine changes in the city's ongoing budget.

205
00:32:07.689 --> 00:32:13.795
<v Laura Oppenheimer>So you will see some of those actions reflected in the fiscal year budget as well to solidify the new structure.

206
00:32:15.042 --> 00:32:22.529
<v Laura Oppenheimer>The $800,000 savings listed on this slide reflects the reduction from this year's current service level budget.

207
00:32:23.258 --> 00:32:36.306
<v Laura Oppenheimer>However, total savings from the communications realignment are more than $1.5 million per year, taking into account steps that were completed last fall and do not require additional action in this budget.

208
00:32:36.967 --> 00:32:37.676
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Next slide, please.

209
00:32:39.559 --> 00:32:53.343
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This organizational chart gives you a picture of one realigned core service in action, and I'll just briefly walk through how that's the Central Communications team operates citywide communications channels, resources, and strategy.

210
00:32:53.920 --> 00:33:03.944
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This is the group that runs primary City of Portland social media accounts, the Rose City Connection newsletter, the communications equipment library, and leads citywide media response.

211
00:33:04.971 --> 00:33:14.179
<v Laura Oppenheimer>The Communications Leadership team, comprised of the manager overseeing each embedded team, drives strategic initiatives and ensures consistency across the organization.

212
00:33:14.242 --> 00:33:14.419
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

213
00:33:15.237 --> 00:33:27.363
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Projects underway include streamlining the city's social media ecosystem, improving the visibility and reach of news content on our city website, and improving emergency communications preparedness and content.

214
00:33:28.566 --> 00:33:34.710
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Embedded teams focus on the day-to-day needs of bureaus and service areas in alignment with citywide approaches.

215
00:33:35.462 --> 00:33:48.520
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This is where the majority of the content creation, media response, graphic design, public records response, and other ongoing work takes place, leveraging the subject matter expertise and working relationships of the embedded staff.

216
00:33:49.163 --> 00:33:56.943
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Change takes time and we're just 5 months into it, but hope this is able to provide a little bit of a picture of where we're headed with realignments.

217
00:33:57.521 --> 00:34:01.676
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Now I will turn the mic to Amanda Garcia-Snell, our Chief Engagement Officer.

218
00:34:02.496 --> 00:34:03.136
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thanks, Laura.

219
00:34:03.473 --> 00:34:19.710
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So switching gears to engagement, which is one of the core service realignments, as mentioned, is intended to align practice across the organization so that we can provide more effective, equitable engagement opportunities to community and use our resources more effectively.

220
00:34:20.625 --> 00:34:26.657
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>This timeline is a snapshot of the work and various touchpoints with staff and others for the engagement realignment.

221
00:34:27.347 --> 00:34:41.800
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Although the engagement realignment conversation began with previous projects and in some ways was connected to charter reform, The effort to create centralized staffing structure and organizational structure and meet budget realities really began in early 2025.

222
00:34:42.574 --> 00:34:52.356
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>There were many efforts and existing reports prior to that time, and this work built on those, and I'm happy to share those if folks are interested.

223
00:34:54.849 --> 00:35:04.130
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>In beginning in 2025, we conducted an inventory of staff capacity across I was able to meet with staff across the organization and immediately recognize the complexity of this work.

224
00:35:04.420 --> 00:35:12.655
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Given that there is no job family, it took quite a bit of time to really understand who is working in engagement and who should be considered an engagement professional.

225
00:35:13.106 --> 00:35:15.418
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And I'll say that that work continues to this day.

226
00:35:16.637 --> 00:35:22.996
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Between August and November, I conducted several meetings with leadership and staff.

227
00:35:23.525 --> 00:35:30.380
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We did a couple of info sessions, and some of those those were very well attended with 88 staff in attendance at informational sessions.

228
00:35:31.306 --> 00:35:32.085
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

229
00:35:33.679 --> 00:35:55.512
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Most of the time during this calendar year has been spent in conversations and refinement with leadership, the budget office, human resources related to the organizational structure and really wanting to make sure that we are— that we're covering all the bases, that we're able to provide quality service to community and that No piece of work is falling through the cracks.

230
00:35:56.057 --> 00:36:04.632
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The biggest shift in the engagement realignment came after our presentation to you all in March with the determination that engagement realignment really needed to be split into phases.

231
00:36:04.969 --> 00:36:12.949
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>This was to address some of the risks, and that's why you'll see some differences between what was presented in March and what is presented now.

232
00:36:13.576 --> 00:36:14.009
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide.

233
00:36:14.523 --> 00:36:16.996
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

234
00:36:18.152 --> 00:36:28.215
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So under the new model, teams embedded within bureaus and service areas will really serve as spokes, similar to some of the— what you have seen with the previous presentation.

235
00:36:29.288 --> 00:36:33.967
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The Chief Engagement Officer and the core strategic team would be the hub of that larger wheel.

236
00:36:34.559 --> 00:36:41.193
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We're designing a system that improves the consistency and quality of engagement and ultimately improves the experience for community.

237
00:36:42.010 --> 00:36:46.722
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The budget amount looks different than what was presented in March this is due to a couple of factors.

238
00:36:47.155 --> 00:36:56.577
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>As I mentioned, as we talked more about risks and identified those and understood those better, it really illustrated the complexity of this effort and prompted the need to split it into phases.

239
00:36:57.088 --> 00:37:01.672
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And so this first phase has a smaller FTE footprint than initially planned.

240
00:37:02.681 --> 00:37:06.286
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>There are still challenges in parsing out this deeply integrated work.

241
00:37:06.766 --> 00:37:12.119
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>This is really related to the way that the city has historically conducted engagement in some bureaus.

242
00:37:12.280 --> 00:37:30.940
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We also realize that some of the positions initially identified in the engagement structure were also in other realignment lists or identified in other bureau reduction scenarios, and so that also affected the total FTE impact.

243
00:37:33.119 --> 00:37:34.400
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

244
00:37:36.739 --> 00:37:41.019
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So the realignment process for engagement continues to be dynamic and iterative.

245
00:37:41.019 --> 00:37:42.599
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>This table shows position changes with engagement with a small net reduction, and this table shows positions with a net reduction.

246
00:37:44.356 --> 00:37:46.380
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Of one FTE.

247
00:37:47.570 --> 00:37:47.634
<v Laura Oppenheimer>This—.

248
00:37:47.907 --> 00:38:00.585
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We're still working with— on some of these pieces, and there will potentially be some different shifts in the future as we have more conversation about this work.

249
00:38:01.148 --> 00:38:17.681
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>You'll see that the biggest staff impact is in the first phase and in Civic Life as that team transforms to be a more strategic-focused equitable engagement team that can support staff across the entire organization with consistent delivery of equitable engagement practices.

250
00:38:18.836 --> 00:38:25.117
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>You'll also note that there are an additional 25-ish positions that we'll be working on in Phase 2.

251
00:38:25.679 --> 00:38:37.375
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Those positions were identified as more discussion needed to really understand, you know, how much or how little those positions should be considered in the larger structure of engagement professionals.

252
00:38:38.389 --> 00:38:41.871
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And of course, it's important to note that this is budget data.

253
00:38:41.969 --> 00:38:43.789
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>It's not full organizational data.

254
00:38:43.887 --> 00:38:48.842
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And so it may not include every employee contributing to engagement across the organization.

255
00:38:49.215 --> 00:38:56.525
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And we'll continue to have those conversations as we determine what that total universe really looks like.

256
00:38:59.000 --> 00:38:59.869
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

257
00:39:02.657 --> 00:39:06.177
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So this chart shows some of the changes within the service areas and the core team.

258
00:39:06.563 --> 00:39:16.422
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The realignment process for engagement— oops, sorry, I just said that this is dynamic and iterative, and I can't say that enough as we continue to work on this.

259
00:39:18.619 --> 00:39:24.239
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So this demonstrates the, again, the complicated nature of this effort.

260
00:39:27.389 --> 00:39:34.610
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The primary change here in realignment is position shifting across service areas to better balance workload and support a more centralized model.

261
00:39:37.163 --> 00:39:37.882
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

262
00:39:41.085 --> 00:39:44.853
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>As we move to the new model, we are committed to leveraging things that are working well.

263
00:39:45.030 --> 00:39:54.838
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We are also committed to putting the community experience first by reducing burden on the community and our partners that we create by not being internally coordinated.

264
00:39:55.775 --> 00:40:04.349
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Engagement is about making space for community to participate in government decision-making, and the realignment will help provide consistency across the organization to get there.

265
00:40:07.260 --> 00:40:07.822
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

266
00:40:09.402 --> 00:40:32.302
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So shifting into equity, similar to engagement, equity has one core office, the Office of Equity and Human Rights, and while most staffing and decision-making has resided in bureaus, for equity we're just taking the initial steps toward realignment and allowing the new Chief Equity Officer to shape their team, their team, their system, and strategy.

267
00:40:34.501 --> 00:40:42.085
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The proposed budget eliminates 6 positions across the organization while leaving the remaining capacity to be shaped into a cohesive system.

268
00:40:42.748 --> 00:40:54.713
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Outside of the realignment, there are no additional cuts to the Office of Equity and Human Rights to ensure that we can retain the capacity for vital ongoing work related to civil rights, language access, digital access, and other obligations.

269
00:40:55.099 --> 00:40:59.338
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I'll just mention that those 6 positions are primarily vacant positions.

270
00:41:00.110 --> 00:41:01.916
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Similar— oh, next slide, please.

271
00:41:04.550 --> 00:41:08.525
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Similar to engagement, this slide is a snapshot of FTE reductions and shifts.

272
00:41:09.074 --> 00:41:15.829
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Again, this is— it may not capture every employee that's contributing to the work of equity across the organization.

273
00:41:17.150 --> 00:41:17.855
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Councilmember Herbold.

274
00:41:18.809 --> 00:41:26.358
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And as a reminder, those— the reduced positions proposed for reduction are primarily vacant positions.

275
00:41:28.480 --> 00:41:29.248
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

276
00:41:31.360 --> 00:41:38.027
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So this chart illustrates the change in FTE, again, by reducing those primarily vacant positions.

277
00:41:38.219 --> 00:41:45.036
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The realignment process for equity as a whole is still in its infancy, and like other processes, will be dynamic and iterative.

278
00:41:45.085 --> 00:41:45.246
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thank you.

279
00:41:46.536 --> 00:42:00.206
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We do imagine that under the new Chief Equity Officer, who will start on Monday, there will be further conversation and planning to level the remaining capacity across the service areas organization in the organization.

280
00:42:02.559 --> 00:42:11.210
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We I will note that there that there are a couple of corrections that may be needed as as we.

281
00:42:11.648 --> 00:42:15.681
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Some positions may have been erroneously slated for reduction.

282
00:42:16.146 --> 00:42:25.534
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So that's why you'll see one in city operations, there will be a correction that we're working with the budget office to determine how that should go forward.

283
00:42:28.300 --> 00:42:29.090
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Next slide, please.

284
00:42:31.496 --> 00:42:46.309
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>As we move to a new model, we're committed to leveraging things that are working well, continuing to maintain the core citywide functions that provide people with these essential protections and preserving embedded expertise and specialized knowledge that staff working in these areas provide.

285
00:42:47.112 --> 00:42:53.208
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Internal support that helps bureaus navigate requirements, uphold standards, and continue to deliver inclusive services.

286
00:42:54.056 --> 00:43:00.239
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>We're focused on the foundational work that keeps the city compliant, accessible, and aligned with the core values and commitments.

287
00:43:01.954 --> 00:43:13.918
<v Tracy Warren>And with that, I'll hand it As we started out, we talked about, you know, this being a challenging process under tight timelines.

288
00:43:13.983 --> 00:43:31.434
<v Tracy Warren>And I think even if we were in a situation where those things didn't exist, when you're talking about the complexity and citywide nature of this realignment, there's going to be challenges that we're going to need to continue to work through, and we're going to need council support.

289
00:43:32.552 --> 00:43:39.235
<v Tracy Warren>To adjust to ensure that we have the support needed to deliver key services.

290
00:43:41.329 --> 00:43:50.173
<v Tracy Warren>We've been working to review our budget proposal submissions for accuracy and have identified a handful of adjustments that need to be made within the packages.

291
00:43:50.690 --> 00:43:53.561
<v Tracy Warren>I think Amanda just alluded to one of those.

292
00:43:54.547 --> 00:43:59.128
<v Tracy Warren>While some adjustments require longer-term system changes for how we budget, Thank you.

293
00:44:04.782 --> 00:44:07.003
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

294
00:44:13.768 --> 00:44:21.726
<v Tracy Warren>Over the next year, we'll assess whether staffing levels align with services— service demands and make adjustments to address any gaps.

295
00:44:22.242 --> 00:44:29.152
<v Tracy Warren>We'll continue to test and refine the funding approach to ensure transparency and flexibility so staff and resources can shift as priorities evolve.

296
00:44:31.317 --> 00:44:36.315
<v Tracy Warren>And service areas and the needs of the broader organization also evolve.

297
00:44:36.831 --> 00:44:37.317
<v Elise Rosenberg>Next slide.

298
00:44:40.777 --> 00:44:47.539
<v Tracy Warren>We wanted to provide an example of the type of things that we're looking at that will need to be adjusted.

299
00:44:48.217 --> 00:44:59.657
<v Tracy Warren>We have different avenues for making those adjustments, and some of these things you may see as we move past the fiscal year and need to come back for the fall for a technical adjustment.

300
00:44:59.708 --> 00:44:59.896
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

301
00:45:02.193 --> 00:45:11.021
<v Tracy Warren>Of the list, the most important changes would be a handful of position reductions that we would seek a reversal on through this process.

302
00:45:11.538 --> 00:45:16.443
<v Tracy Warren>As you know, you know, we had a tight timeline.

303
00:45:16.556 --> 00:45:26.108
<v Tracy Warren>Things were being entered very quickly across the city for a lot of changes, not just the changes represented in the core service realignment.

304
00:45:26.728 --> 00:45:36.644
<v Tracy Warren>And with any budget process, there are errors that we need to make sure that we review and do our best to correct so that we can continue to deliver services that we've promised.

305
00:45:38.329 --> 00:45:38.778
<v Tracy Warren>Next slide.

306
00:45:43.487 --> 00:45:54.527
<v Tracy Warren>This slide talks about what you can expect to see in future engagement with staff, with leaders within the organization.

307
00:45:56.023 --> 00:46:06.561
<v Tracy Warren>You'll notice that there's one summary area that talks about the different activities over the next several months between now and the new fiscal year.

308
00:46:07.331 --> 00:46:11.773
<v Tracy Warren>And then to the right, you're going to see that there's different folks tagged in.

309
00:46:11.900 --> 00:46:20.286
<v Tracy Warren>And the reason for that is that we've had— we've been on slightly different tracks, and so there's been different level of engagement and activities.

310
00:46:20.800 --> 00:46:37.134
<v Tracy Warren>And so this is to call out where we have some uniqueness and where there will be opportunities for I appreciate your time.

311
00:46:37.213 --> 00:46:49.027
<v Tracy Warren>I think before we jump into questions, I'd like to invite up the directors who have been supporting this project so that they're readily available to support questions from council.

312
00:46:49.576 --> 00:46:50.512
<v Tracy Warren>Elise, Ron, Sylvester.

313
00:46:50.625 --> 00:46:51.237
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

314
00:46:56.818 --> 00:47:01.447
<v Tracy Warren>Oh, we got another chair.

315
00:47:07.755 --> 00:47:12.063
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, everybody, distinguished panel, thank you very much for the presentation.

316
00:47:12.610 --> 00:47:15.088
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're going to jump into questions.

317
00:47:15.170 --> 00:47:17.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to start with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

318
00:47:17.505 --> 00:47:19.882
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

319
00:47:20.010 --> 00:47:29.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to start by just noting, thanking the staff whose work is affected by all of this realignment.

320
00:47:29.789 --> 00:47:43.740
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, we are asking many of our city employees to go through a substantial period of instability, especially as we do this during a cuts budget where we're looking at sheets that show reductions Councilor Loretta Smith.

321
00:47:43.806 --> 00:47:44.110
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you, Mayor.

322
00:47:44.222 --> 00:47:53.952
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are making reductions and additions and realignments, and that means that we have staff who are looking at job reductions, job additions, and job realignments all at the same time.

323
00:47:54.050 --> 00:48:04.630
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that is a lot to ask of people who still have, in many cases, far more than 40 hours of work to do a week, as well as navigate through all of this.

324
00:48:04.871 --> 00:48:24.793
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I just— I want to start there because I think it's important to ground us in the fact that while this is important work and while it is important that we can say in good faith to Portlanders that we are being as efficient and effective as we can with their tax dollars, we're also talking about people who do really important work for the city.

325
00:48:27.632 --> 00:48:33.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I want to ask a couple of questions about what this looks like as we move forward.

326
00:48:35.619 --> 00:49:07.476
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You talked a little bit about examples of true-ups needed, but as we move forward past this budget process and we start to realize that we got it wrong, either a position shouldn't actually have been realigned because it was providing that support that needed to happen at a service area level, or something was cut that shouldn't have been, what is the approach going to be, and are we doing anything to try to catch those before we lose good people out of our city?

327
00:49:10.425 --> 00:49:12.016
<v Tracy Warren>I'll answer that question.

328
00:49:12.128 --> 00:49:13.784
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

329
00:49:16.452 --> 00:49:39.387
<v Tracy Warren>I would say that we are working currently to identify where there are critical risks and folks may be on a list for reduction, and we are trying to work through how do we make changes and are there ways to mitigate that risk, right?

330
00:49:40.717 --> 00:49:53.201
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, we are looking to, you know, a future state where we have a governance model where we are identifying the needs across the city and we have Councilor Smith.

331
00:49:53.264 --> 00:49:54.001
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you, Mayor.

332
00:49:54.065 --> 00:50:11.105
<v Tracy Warren>I think the goal is for us to have broad engagement and input into where we come to council to prioritize those needs, recognizing that we are on a path of stability and that we are likely not to be in a better financial situation the next fiscal year.

333
00:50:11.922 --> 00:50:27.067
<v Tracy Warren>So the goal is for us to start talking about this more broadly, prioritizing our needs across the organization, and investing where we need to invest to deliver the services that council has set that they want Portlanders to receive.

334
00:50:27.918 --> 00:50:32.018
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, I'll come back to that in a minute.

335
00:50:33.228 --> 00:50:53.295
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I noted as we went through these sheets that in all but one of the areas you talked about, there were reductions in supervisory and represented staff, but additions in non-represented that could on the surface look intentional.

336
00:50:54.293 --> 00:51:04.056
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am assuming that it is not, but I am hoping that you can explain to us why that is so consistently seen across these areas of realignment.

337
00:51:06.257 --> 00:51:08.608
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, I'm happy to address that.

338
00:51:08.771 --> 00:51:30.420
<v Tracy Warren>Um, it is not, and it is not, uh, It is intentional in making sure that we are classifying work appropriately to our classification structure and that people who are doing the same work are classified comparable to one another.

339
00:51:31.190 --> 00:51:47.045
<v Tracy Warren>One of the examples that I provided was in the human resources function where I talked about half of those positions being classified as a positions that are being realigned to the central team deliver leave administration.

340
00:51:47.637 --> 00:51:57.304
<v Tracy Warren>We have a team of leave administration— leave administrators within the core human resources team that are classified as human resource analysts.

341
00:51:57.496 --> 00:51:59.228
<v Tracy Warren>Those are non-represented positions.

342
00:52:00.061 --> 00:52:14.840
<v Tracy Warren>When you look into the market and you see who is performing leave administrative type work, you see that they are entry professional level analysts that are in human resources specialty field.

343
00:52:14.920 --> 00:52:21.007
<v Tracy Warren>So this is a goal to classify those people who are doing that work appropriately.

344
00:52:22.195 --> 00:52:28.360
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That makes sense, and it makes sense to me that we want those people all in the same place and not spread out through bureaus.

345
00:52:28.713 --> 00:52:34.137
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We want to make sure that our city employees know what to expect and leave is administered consistently.

346
00:52:36.106 --> 00:52:46.221
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It stands out to me that the places where we are centralizing that work happen to be non-represented places, and the places that we're taking them from happen to be represented.

347
00:52:46.284 --> 00:52:54.271
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, I hope that that just has to do with where unions have been active in the past and not anything else.

348
00:52:56.492 --> 00:52:57.358
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Smith.

349
00:52:57.454 --> 00:53:19.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, I want to share, because this came out of a budget presentation originally, and I am doing this knowing that folks are wary of budget notes, but I am likely going to be bringing a budget note forward for us to consider during our budget process that addresses some of the realignment work that's happening.

350
00:53:20.496 --> 00:53:32.072
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am concerned that as we catch those, um, spaces where we got it wrong, that in the short term we may look to contracted services to provide that work.

351
00:53:32.603 --> 00:53:47.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm going to be bringing something forward asking us to make sure that we are approaching this work deliberately and carefully so that we don't get things wrong, and that if we do, a proposal is brought to council to add positions back.

352
00:53:48.097 --> 00:53:54.344
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rather than a choice made to contract out work that was previously done by city employees.

353
00:53:54.938 --> 00:53:58.197
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're still working on the details of what that will look like.

354
00:53:58.246 --> 00:54:04.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I should have something that I can share within the next week, but I wanted to flag today that I will be bringing something forward there.

355
00:54:04.813 --> 00:54:12.519
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I do believe it's an appropriate budget note because it has to do with how we implement the reductions that are being made in the budget.

356
00:54:13.739 --> 00:54:14.657
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

357
00:54:14.802 --> 00:54:15.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks, Council President.

358
00:54:16.251 --> 00:54:16.943
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

359
00:54:19.295 --> 00:54:20.244
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy.

360
00:54:20.824 --> 00:54:22.355
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you all so much for your presentation today.

361
00:54:22.742 --> 00:54:35.137
<v Angelita Morillo>I know that you have been working extremely hard to get us information under a very difficult circumstance, and I have a lot of comments about this, and I want you to know that it's actually not directed at you.

362
00:54:36.007 --> 00:54:39.278
<v Angelita Morillo>These are comments, frankly, for Mayor Wilson and for the City Administrator.

363
00:54:42.101 --> 00:54:47.965
<v Angelita Morillo>This has been a very difficult process, and I have a lot of concerns about core realignments.

364
00:54:49.074 --> 00:54:58.940
<v Angelita Morillo>In charter reform, Portlanders voted for 2 very specific things: a larger council to expand representation and a city manager to employ a professional to lead operations.

365
00:54:59.936 --> 00:55:21.719
<v Angelita Morillo>The executive branch has used these 2 changes to push the idea that we must wholly reform and realign our operations largely in service to finding funding for work the city has never directed before, like the mayor's shelter plan, but not because anyone in leadership studied our operations and concluded with evidence that this was necessary and achievable without breaking down services.

366
00:55:23.034 --> 00:55:27.458
<v Angelita Morillo>The process that has been undertaken to effect these changes is incomplete at best.

367
00:55:28.324 --> 00:55:43.871
<v Angelita Morillo>First, I am deeply concerned about the lack of transparency broadly and the lack of involvement from any level but people who work at the very top, including in some cases bureau directors themselves, and more importantly, the individuals who are closest to and do the work.

368
00:55:44.608 --> 00:55:48.556
<v Angelita Morillo>Just under $1 million has been spent on a contract with Next Strategies.

369
00:55:49.085 --> 00:56:04.099
<v Angelita Morillo>The contract notes 5 tasks and deliverables, which include strategic analysis, planning, and advising, change management capacity building, organization development consulting, strategic stakeholder engagement, and decision-making framework and support.

370
00:56:05.206 --> 00:56:19.954
<v Angelita Morillo>I've been told directly that there has been zero evidence of strategic stakeholder engagement across all area of core services, and I'm really concerned that members of leadership have told me that they have not had any support in this change management.

371
00:56:20.835 --> 00:56:30.099
<v Angelita Morillo>Those who know most about the work have been left out of the process, and those with the difficult job of finding these efficiencies have, despite a $1 million contract, been set up to fail.

372
00:56:31.269 --> 00:56:40.052
<v Angelita Morillo>This process has and will continue to lead to long-term damage to employee morale and distrust in leadership, unclear roles, and confusing reporting lines.

373
00:56:40.869 --> 00:56:44.699
<v Angelita Morillo>So I am left wondering, has this $1 million achieved any—.

374
00:56:45.534 --> 00:56:45.949
<v Angelita Morillo>Achieved?

375
00:56:46.014 --> 00:56:50.068
<v Angelita Morillo>And what can we get copies of the outcomes and the deliverables in the contract?

376
00:56:50.565 --> 00:56:53.306
<v Angelita Morillo>Why have we insisted on not involving those closest to the work?

377
00:56:53.371 --> 00:56:55.567
<v Angelita Morillo>And what has the criteria been to select positions for layoffs?

378
00:56:55.614 --> 00:57:05.282
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Loretta Smith, Second, I am really concerned about the actions taking place within realignments that seem counter to achieving our goals while also preserving as many jobs as possible.

379
00:57:06.115 --> 00:57:17.882
<v Angelita Morillo>91 Jobs are being lost at the same time that 15 full-time employees are receiving promotions, and there are separate unrelated decision packages in the budget that also request funding for promotions.

380
00:57:18.652 --> 00:57:25.835
<v Angelita Morillo>23 FTE are being added, where sometimes the added position mirrors a job class that was cut and is now being added back.

381
00:57:28.981 --> 00:57:32.273
<v Angelita Morillo>50 Positions need to be trued up.

382
00:57:32.739 --> 00:57:38.952
<v Angelita Morillo>The packages that we have been presented are flawed to begin with, and we found this out last night.

383
00:57:39.434 --> 00:57:47.333
<v Angelita Morillo>So our amendments are due in less than a week, and we have to completely recalculate the amendments that we are bringing forward in my office.

384
00:57:48.393 --> 00:57:51.347
<v Angelita Morillo>Leadership is currently unsure if staffing levels will continue to meet in the coming months.

385
00:57:51.396 --> 00:58:02.509
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Smith, The last thing or area that I want to talk about is the fact that council has been put in a terrible position.

386
00:58:03.449 --> 00:58:16.485
<v Angelita Morillo>While organizational management may fall under the purview of the city manager and administrator, the implications of and costs related to your actions come to this council for approval, especially when they are in service to the mayor's policy goals.

387
00:58:16.550 --> 00:58:17.039
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

388
00:58:17.728 --> 00:58:22.815
<v Angelita Morillo>So it is incumbent upon this body to fully contemplate the potential outcomes of these actions.

389
00:58:23.329 --> 00:58:26.025
<v Angelita Morillo>And our ability to do this has been hamstrung.

390
00:58:26.682 --> 00:58:31.016
<v Angelita Morillo>We only just received detailed information on this budget 2 days ago.

391
00:58:31.512 --> 00:58:39.070
<v Angelita Morillo>All of the decision packages related to this have the exact same copy and pasted information, leaving position changes without any context.

392
00:58:39.440 --> 00:58:44.719
<v Angelita Morillo>We have no idea when a position went from one hierarchy to a different one.

393
00:58:45.135 --> 00:58:47.766
<v Angelita Morillo>We can't see that stream of change over time.

394
00:58:48.521 --> 00:58:51.954
<v Angelita Morillo>That leaves us 2 days to unravel a year's worth of work.

395
00:58:52.516 --> 00:58:58.757
<v Angelita Morillo>That's 2 days to seriously sit with the data and contemplate a change that guts staff and asks many to fight for their own jobs.

396
00:58:59.269 --> 00:59:02.398
<v Angelita Morillo>And thank you to those of you who are here today to give us your feedback.

397
00:59:03.103 --> 00:59:07.356
<v Angelita Morillo>Any briefings received up to this point have been so high level that they were unactionable.

398
00:59:07.932 --> 00:59:17.844
<v Angelita Morillo>This council has repeatedly asked for budget documentation to be clear, Because imprecise or incomplete information inhibits our ability to advance our charter-assigned duties as the budget authority.

399
00:59:19.063 --> 00:59:38.208
<v Angelita Morillo>How much are we advancing that legislative budget authority when we twice have been given a few weeks to process a proposed budget that guts core services in part to advance the executive's policy priorities, all for undefined efficiencies and in service of a policy priority from the executive, not the legislative body, which is us, Council?

400
00:59:39.202 --> 00:59:45.021
<v Angelita Morillo>Is this the serious data-driven policymaking that I am often told we need to be pushing?

401
00:59:45.534 --> 00:59:56.643
<v Angelita Morillo>Because our charter authority in action is that we are rubber stamping someone else's budget because we don't have the information required to make the changes that we need.

402
00:59:58.119 --> 01:00:04.514
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm going to close now by saying that our ability to fully identify and understand all of the nuances from this proposal have been tenuous at best.

403
01:00:06.570 --> 01:00:22.059
<v Angelita Morillo>I am currently awaiting some additional data, but intend to spend the next week, much like the vast majority of the city's frontline staff, processing the extent and implications of this massive reorganization.

404
01:00:22.880 --> 01:00:28.079
<v Angelita Morillo>Portlanders deserve well-run services, and we can't do that without the heart of the city, which is our city employees.

405
01:00:28.659 --> 01:00:31.239
<v Angelita Morillo>And if we're enacting the Doge version of the city of budget, we will not be able to do Portland, that.

406
01:00:31.239 --> 01:00:31.280
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

407
01:00:31.869 --> 01:00:36.838
<v Angelita Morillo>Then we need to seriously reconsider what it is that we have brought forward.

408
01:00:38.101 --> 01:00:50.601
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's unacceptable that we are receiving updated information about positions while we are actively drafting amendments, and our budget amendments are due in 5 business days.

409
01:00:51.630 --> 01:00:57.726
<v Angelita Morillo>Do you think that your colleagues— do you think that you're going to accurately calculate out your budget amendments with this level of information?

410
01:00:57.775 --> 01:00:58.402
<v Angelita Morillo>Because I don't feel like I can.

411
01:00:58.449 --> 01:00:58.788
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Loretta Smith.

412
01:00:59.867 --> 01:01:02.594
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

413
01:01:02.931 --> 01:01:03.557
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

414
01:01:04.440 --> 01:01:05.338
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

415
01:01:05.563 --> 01:01:15.623
<v Steve Novick>Um, DCA Warren, I appreciate your starting in the beginning saying that, um, this work has been done without as much, uh, discussion with frontline staff as you would have liked.

416
01:01:15.831 --> 01:01:20.436
<v Steve Novick>And as Councilor Morillo just indicated, frontline staff are really upset about that.

417
01:01:20.563 --> 01:01:23.099
<v Steve Novick>I mean, and, um, they said they haven't been involved in the process.

418
01:01:23.146 --> 01:01:24.559
<v Steve Novick>There's been little to no communication.

419
01:01:26.298 --> 01:01:33.393
<v Steve Novick>I also appreciate the fact that in briefings before, you've acknowledged that the idea that we're going to save 20% is dangerous.

420
01:01:34.856 --> 01:01:40.094
<v Steve Novick>And the last question I'm going to ask you is, what about these proposals keeps you up at night?

421
01:01:41.000 --> 01:01:48.733
<v Steve Novick>Before that, though, I want to follow up a little bit on what Councilor Pirtle-Guiney was saying and just note that we heard from CPPW.

422
01:01:48.925 --> 01:01:50.900
<v Steve Novick>You talked about human resources systems analysts.

423
01:01:50.949 --> 01:01:51.114
<v Elise Rosenberg>Yes.

424
01:01:51.190 --> 01:01:54.545
<v Steve Novick>And gave some explanation as to why they were being reconfigured.

425
01:01:54.610 --> 01:02:05.347
<v Steve Novick>But CPBW also said that other examples of positions that are currently represented and they're going to be replaced by non-represented positions are multiple family medical leave analysts.

426
01:02:05.492 --> 01:02:09.856
<v Steve Novick>Maybe that's too much in the weeds, but if you just had a response to that quickly, I'd appreciate it.

427
01:02:11.396 --> 01:02:12.561
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, I'll try my best.

428
01:02:12.951 --> 01:02:23.351
<v Tracy Warren>I think your last question was, and please correct me if I But I think your last question was, are those multiple changes the family leave specialists?

429
01:02:23.735 --> 01:02:30.541
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I mean, what's the explanation for those being converted from represented positions to non-represented positions?

430
01:02:31.840 --> 01:02:40.699
<v Tracy Warren>Because when you look to the market, those are done by human resource analyst 1s, and those are currently non-represented classifications within the city.

431
01:02:41.726 --> 01:02:46.684
<v Tracy Warren>So we're aligning it with the classification structure and what you would see for talent in the market.

432
01:02:47.961 --> 01:02:49.755
<v Steve Novick>Does that cost money or save money?

433
01:02:50.143 --> 01:02:50.757
<v Tracy Warren>It's neutral.

434
01:02:52.083 --> 01:02:52.277
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

435
01:02:53.456 --> 01:03:05.547
<v Tracy Warren>There are currently administrative specialist 3s, I believe, that are doing leave administration in bureaus, which is the same pay scale as human resource analyst 1s.

436
01:03:07.481 --> 01:03:12.476
<v Steve Novick>So if it's— there's not any change in the amount of money it costs, is it— seems kind of abstract.

437
01:03:17.092 --> 01:03:31.842
<v Tracy Warren>Well, the goal is for them to all feel a sense of unity, all be classified the same, have the same expectations within their job description, be able to see the work that they're performing identified within the job description.

438
01:03:33.304 --> 01:03:55.726
<v Tracy Warren>I think it would be challenging when you look at the Administrative Specialist 3 class, it is very broad and general and is typically focused on administrative tasks, whereas the HR Analyst 1 is specific to HR-related functions and specifically calls out leave administration.

439
01:03:56.257 --> 01:03:58.373
<v Steve Novick>Okay, thank you.

440
01:03:58.807 --> 01:04:03.027
<v Steve Novick>We've heard various concerns about technology-related positions.

441
01:04:03.539 --> 01:04:08.597
<v Steve Novick>I think that So a number of GIS positions are being eliminated, some are being centralized.

442
01:04:10.608 --> 01:04:18.931
<v Steve Novick>And question is, I mean, do we really think that the work of those folks can be done by fewer people?

443
01:04:19.646 --> 01:04:28.759
<v Steve Novick>And does it make sense to move people from the bureaus to the DCA's office or elsewhere if it's specialized work?

444
01:04:28.838 --> 01:04:35.251
<v Steve Novick>They're going to be doing the same work as they were Thanks for that question.

445
01:04:35.686 --> 01:04:37.139
<v Elise Rosenberg>Good morning, I'm Elise Rosenberg.

446
01:04:37.219 --> 01:04:40.898
<v Elise Rosenberg>I'm the Chief Information Officer and the Director of the Bureau of Technology Services.

447
01:04:42.650 --> 01:04:46.313
<v Elise Rosenberg>So I think there were a couple of questions in there about GIS specialists.

448
01:04:46.362 --> 01:04:48.514
<v Elise Rosenberg>Does it make sense to centralize them?

449
01:04:48.628 --> 01:04:55.485
<v Elise Rosenberg>How do we think that the work will be performed, or do we think it will be performed at the same level or at the same level of specialty?

450
01:04:55.534 --> 01:04:56.057
<v Elise Rosenberg>I think the answer to that is yes.

451
01:04:57.001 --> 01:05:06.213
<v Elise Rosenberg>So I'll just start with the challenge of centralizing while also trying to achieve a double-digit budget cut is real here.

452
01:05:06.293 --> 01:05:12.541
<v Elise Rosenberg>And this is a good example of where that sort of duality comes to play.

453
01:05:13.342 --> 01:05:30.112
<v Elise Rosenberg>What we were trying to do with all of the realignments is establish a scalable model for how service areas could be supported with parity across the organization, but recognizing the level and the complexity might be different across the different service areas.

454
01:05:30.820 --> 01:05:53.891
<v Elise Rosenberg>And so with GIS, the intention is to have a central group within the Corps that owns the infrastructure, that owns the city's relationship with the vendor with whom we— for whom we contract GIS services, and that would own the primary tools or artifacts that folks would use, the map of the city, for example.

455
01:05:53.938 --> 01:05:53.987
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Okay.

456
01:05:55.079 --> 01:06:02.889
<v Elise Rosenberg>And then folks within the service areas to work together to do the more specialized work that's in support of that service area.

457
01:06:03.675 --> 01:06:13.782
<v Elise Rosenberg>So right now we might have folks in bureaus that are making maps or using datasets to solve similar problems differently or duplicatively.

458
01:06:14.699 --> 01:06:19.775
<v Elise Rosenberg>I think there is some risk with the layering of centralization and of a budget cut.

459
01:06:19.824 --> 01:06:19.936
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

460
01:06:20.788 --> 01:06:23.998
<v Elise Rosenberg>That we will have to negotiate a different level of service.

461
01:06:24.173 --> 01:06:40.175
<v Elise Rosenberg>But the intention is to try to have parity across service areas, to have sort of localized work more local to that service area, and to minimize duplicative efforts.

462
01:06:40.786 --> 01:06:41.443
<v Elise Rosenberg>Does that make sense?

463
01:06:41.893 --> 01:06:42.215
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

464
01:06:42.342 --> 01:06:48.858
<v Steve Novick>From what you said though, I mean, you talked about the dual charge of centralization and saving money.

465
01:06:49.132 --> 01:06:57.385
<v Steve Novick>So that kind of suggests that we're doing things that if we weren't under a mandate to save money, you probably wouldn't do.

466
01:06:58.445 --> 01:07:02.059
<v Elise Rosenberg>I'm not sure I would do them at the same level or with the same speed.

467
01:07:02.782 --> 01:07:08.355
<v Elise Rosenberg>I do think that there is efficiency or there's a different operating model to be achieved here.

468
01:07:09.108 --> 01:07:16.143
<v Elise Rosenberg>I would probably be making different recommendations about the timing and the level of reductions after some study.

469
01:07:16.594 --> 01:07:25.297
<v Elise Rosenberg>But given the charge, again, of realigning and of reducing budgets for this fiscal year, we've done the best we can.

470
01:07:26.275 --> 01:07:31.148
<v Elise Rosenberg>And we are— DCA Warren talked about some of those risk mitigation options.

471
01:07:31.679 --> 01:07:39.217
<v Elise Rosenberg>This type of work is exactly some of the risk areas that we've been talking with bureaus and with service areas about.

472
01:07:40.106 --> 01:07:43.452
<v Elise Rosenberg>And so one of the reasons we presented a lower—.

473
01:07:43.469 --> 01:07:43.617
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry.

474
01:07:43.943 --> 01:07:53.603
<v Elise Rosenberg>Reduction scenario option in the March work sessions was to mitigate some of this risk by adding back positions.

475
01:07:55.005 --> 01:07:55.181
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

476
01:07:55.487 --> 01:07:58.385
<v Steve Novick>Does that mean the positions would be cut first and then added back?

477
01:07:58.563 --> 01:07:59.175
<v Elise Rosenberg>Is that the idea?

478
01:07:59.304 --> 01:08:08.213
<v Elise Rosenberg>So in the present— in the proposal that you have in front of you as part of the mayor's proposed, there are fewer positions reduced than in the 20% scenario.

479
01:08:09.360 --> 01:08:32.533
<v Steve Novick>But if there's capacity for future mitigation, as you another concern I've heard is that there's folks in the technology area that they work within the bureaus with arcane specialized software systems that we don't have the capacity to replace.

480
01:08:32.806 --> 01:08:38.358
<v Steve Novick>And they'll be doing this— I mean, and that work will have to continue to be done by the same people that know those systems.

481
01:08:38.422 --> 01:08:38.797
<v Steve Novick>And I think that's a good point.

482
01:08:39.259 --> 01:08:46.694
<v Steve Novick>So again, moving them into— there's no savings from centralizing them because they still have to do the same people doing the same arcane systems.

483
01:08:46.791 --> 01:08:49.569
<v Steve Novick>So just curious your reaction to that.

484
01:08:49.761 --> 01:08:50.581
<v Elise Rosenberg>2 Layers there.

485
01:08:51.431 --> 01:08:59.622
<v Elise Rosenberg>You might recall from the presentation that a little over half of the reductions we've proposed are non-personnel related.

486
01:08:59.703 --> 01:09:06.978
<v Elise Rosenberg>They are trying to get us off some of those arcane systems onto more centralized supported technology.

487
01:09:07.025 --> 01:09:08.262
<v Elise Rosenberg>That absolutely takes time.

488
01:09:09.015 --> 01:09:13.377
<v Elise Rosenberg>And some investment and training to make that change.

489
01:09:14.162 --> 01:09:28.787
<v Elise Rosenberg>But one of the efficiencies we're hoping to achieve with a more centralized service area model is to have fewer of those individual points of failure or individual risks where there's one person who knows that one thing in that one system.

490
01:09:29.462 --> 01:09:45.295
<v Elise Rosenberg>Whereas if we can be more strategic about having more centralized data sources, more standard tools, we get more efficiency, we get more depth of coverage, and we get more ability to leverage skill sets.

491
01:09:46.837 --> 01:09:51.931
<v Steve Novick>This might be unfair because— but I'm asking it in the context that Councilor Morillo raised.

492
01:09:52.029 --> 01:09:53.807
<v Steve Novick>We've got 5 days to do amendments.

493
01:09:53.904 --> 01:10:10.175
<v Steve Novick>I mean, could you— not right now, but could you sort of sketch for us, here's how you would've approached some of these things differently if you weren't under the gun to say I'm happy to follow up with DCA Warren and colleagues to put some thoughts together.

494
01:10:10.578 --> 01:10:11.981
<v Steve Novick>And Mr. President, am I out of time?

495
01:10:12.917 --> 01:10:13.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>Dramatically, yes.

496
01:10:13.658 --> 01:10:14.917
<v Steve Novick>Okay, thank you.

497
01:10:16.456 --> 01:10:19.112
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

498
01:10:19.193 --> 01:10:20.384
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

499
01:10:20.835 --> 01:10:24.698
<v Mitch Green>That was an appropriately dramatic response to that, Council President.

500
01:10:25.326 --> 01:10:33.170
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for the information today, and obviously it's Probably the least pleasant part about this entire conversation.

501
01:10:34.029 --> 01:10:36.150
<v Mitch Green>I just have a few questions on this part of the presentation.

502
01:10:36.199 --> 01:10:37.885
<v Mitch Green>I'll have more as we get into span of control.

503
01:10:39.270 --> 01:10:45.945
<v Mitch Green>But if you can go back to your slides for a minute, I was having trouble following the reduction plan summaries.

504
01:10:46.027 --> 01:10:47.676
<v Mitch Green>I think that began on slide 14.

505
01:10:53.939 --> 01:10:54.198
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thank you.

506
01:10:54.264 --> 01:10:54.814
<v Mitch Green>This is it.

507
01:10:55.314 --> 01:10:55.412
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

508
01:10:55.493 --> 01:10:58.345
<v Mitch Green>So if we look— this— so this is for Bureau of Human Resources.

509
01:10:59.186 --> 01:11:07.640
<v Mitch Green>I'm having trouble with the last table that sort of summarizes the position type supervisor.

510
01:11:07.801 --> 01:11:09.438
<v Mitch Green>It's the bottom right of the slide.

511
01:11:10.512 --> 01:11:10.657
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

512
01:11:10.704 --> 01:11:11.042
<v Tracy Warren>So for—.

513
01:11:11.170 --> 01:11:20.667
<v Mitch Green>If we just go line by line, in supervisor position types, there's a 9 FTE reduction with a net impact of -10.

514
01:11:21.421 --> 01:11:22.543
<v Mitch Green>Help me understand that.

515
01:11:22.688 --> 01:11:25.382
<v Mitch Green>I don't understand the connection between those 2 pieces there.

516
01:11:27.578 --> 01:11:37.417
<v Tracy Warren>I believe what it is, and I believe what it is, is that you have movement out of— you have a net impact.

517
01:11:37.680 --> 01:11:38.648
<v Tracy Warren>Is that a data error?

518
01:11:40.269 --> 01:11:41.398
<v Ron Zito>No, I don't think so.

519
01:11:42.011 --> 01:11:48.369
<v Ron Zito>There are a number of non-rep supervisor positions that will be cut as a part of this realignment.

520
01:11:49.047 --> 01:11:52.158
<v Ron Zito>In terms of the net impact, I think was the question?

521
01:11:52.833 --> 01:11:52.962
<v Mitch Green>Yeah.

522
01:11:53.011 --> 01:12:01.027
<v Mitch Green>So for any— so whether I'm looking at supervisor, non-rep, ASPME, CPPW, There's the FTE reduction, percent of cut, and net impact columns.

523
01:12:01.764 --> 01:12:09.844
<v Mitch Green>And I, I don't know what it means to say that there's a 9 FTE reduction for supervisors but a net impact of -10.

524
01:12:10.356 --> 01:12:10.949
<v Tracy Warren>I can answer that.

525
01:12:11.141 --> 01:12:22.619
<v Tracy Warren>It, it has to do with, um, someone who was supervising being moved out of supervisory, so they will no longer be supervising, but the position itself is not being reduced.

526
01:12:22.859 --> 01:12:35.554
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so So in that sense, for a supervisor, if we're cutting 9 TEs, then that means we're leaving one in a sort of a may-supervise role and not a must-supervise role?

527
01:12:36.163 --> 01:12:37.256
<v Tracy Warren>Or a represented role.

528
01:12:37.560 --> 01:12:42.568
<v Tracy Warren>So we did have shifts from non-represented to represented.

529
01:12:43.819 --> 01:12:48.554
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's a little— well, at least gets me to understand a little bit.

530
01:12:48.618 --> 01:12:56.359
<v Mitch Green>I still don't know largely how to parse this, because like the non-reps, negative 4 FTE reduction, but then the net impact is plus 4.

531
01:12:56.905 --> 01:13:01.548
<v Ron Zito>Yeah, Councilor, maybe it's helpful to hone in on for the HR realignment.

532
01:13:01.613 --> 01:13:04.135
<v Ron Zito>The biggest impact is our embedded services group.

533
01:13:04.199 --> 01:13:12.537
<v Ron Zito>This is this new shared services model, and what we're doing is standing up a number of supervisors to oversee each service area's support team.

534
01:13:13.034 --> 01:13:17.179
<v Ron Zito>And so we have folks that will become Supervisor 2s or slot into those roles.

535
01:13:17.693 --> 01:13:29.055
<v Ron Zito>And then we've got others that, in this case, I think the, the delta of one is going from a supervisor into a represented role as a part of that embedded team, into a different classification altogether.

536
01:13:30.131 --> 01:13:39.856
<v Mitch Green>Okay, um, I'm going to move on, although I don't really— I can't— I'm missing some data here to, to track that, to get a fuller picture.

537
01:13:40.305 --> 01:13:49.591
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, it's pretty challenging to summarize the movements and the changes into one slide.

538
01:13:50.627 --> 01:14:11.354
<v Tracy Warren>You know, when we were doing this work, we had, you know, a large spreadsheet for all of the different areas where we were like, this is a move going here, this is a reclass, this is, you know, a cut because we have particular bargaining language where we can't just reclass and grant status.

539
01:14:11.470 --> 01:14:12.430
<v Tracy Warren>So we have to—.

540
01:14:12.430 --> 01:14:12.497
<v Olivia Clark>Right.

541
01:14:13.277 --> 01:14:17.175
<v Tracy Warren>Cut the position and create the different position and then go through a process.

542
01:14:17.271 --> 01:14:24.676
<v Tracy Warren>So it was a fairly complex process that folks engaged in over several months.

543
01:14:25.243 --> 01:14:28.087
<v Tracy Warren>So it was fairly challenging to describe in one slide.

544
01:14:28.152 --> 01:14:29.637
<v Tracy Warren>So I apologize for that.

545
01:14:31.317 --> 01:14:31.654
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

546
01:14:31.798 --> 01:14:37.835
<v Mitch Green>I acknowledge it can be challenging to display multi-dimensions of data in a single table.

547
01:14:39.434 --> 01:14:53.148
<v Mitch Green>So then the other piece of highlight on this slide is what you're saying is part of this core services realignment, the existing management footprint in human resources goes from 35 sort of, are these managers, are these supervisors?

548
01:14:53.212 --> 01:14:55.962
<v Mitch Green>Like anyone who is supervising, is that?

549
01:14:56.122 --> 01:14:56.365
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

550
01:14:56.672 --> 01:14:58.914
<v Mitch Green>So it goes from 35 and then it goes down to 21.

551
01:15:00.720 --> 01:15:04.007
<v Mitch Green>That's if we adopt this budget as presented, correctly?

552
01:15:04.088 --> 01:15:04.492
<v Tracy Warren>That's correct.

553
01:15:04.604 --> 01:15:04.831
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

554
01:15:05.476 --> 01:15:10.212
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that is helpful for orienting myself.

555
01:15:10.293 --> 01:15:16.524
<v Mitch Green>The other piece I want to ask just broadly about the core services realignment project, I echo a lot of what I've already heard up here.

556
01:15:17.614 --> 01:15:18.595
<v Mitch Green>Those were some of my concerns.

557
01:15:18.658 --> 01:15:33.719
<v Mitch Green>I don't need to sort of reproduce that from my microphone, but I do want to ask, as you know, in the '25-'26 budget, there was a budget note for human resources that yes.

558
01:15:33.895 --> 01:15:48.210
<v Mitch Green>That required the city administrator to instruct the Bureau of Human Resources to review and reevaluate the deputy director positions and classifications, as well as bureau director classifications and pay scales, to reflect duties that have changed in this new form of government.

559
01:15:48.274 --> 01:15:49.814
<v Mitch Green>So that was a budget note that we adopted.

560
01:15:50.520 --> 01:15:55.527
<v Mitch Green>Was that work part of the core services realignment, or is that different work that we're doing?

561
01:15:55.576 --> 01:15:57.484
<v Mitch Green>And did that work happen during that fiscal year?

562
01:15:58.686 --> 01:16:01.587
<v Tracy Warren>That is not part of the core services realignment.

563
01:16:01.988 --> 01:16:09.328
<v Tracy Warren>One of the presentations that we'll give after this is a span of control presentation that will give some span of control information.

564
01:16:09.984 --> 01:16:29.916
<v Tracy Warren>And then we are engaged in a classification and compensation study currently that we are looking for input into how we're structured, how that aligns to other areas and what we may need to refine or change based on our change in government.

565
01:16:30.434 --> 01:16:30.595
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

566
01:16:30.659 --> 01:16:32.082
<v Tracy Warren>For those executive positions.

567
01:16:32.277 --> 01:16:35.707
<v Mitch Green>That feeds the span of control update that we'll talk about later in this—.

568
01:16:36.180 --> 01:16:36.554
<v Olivia Clark>That's correct.

569
01:16:36.733 --> 01:16:37.270
<v Mitch Green>Work session.

570
01:16:39.408 --> 01:16:40.813
<v Mitch Green>So I want to make sure I understand.

571
01:16:40.862 --> 01:16:44.814
<v Mitch Green>So the budget note that we adopted was directing work to happen in this fiscal year.

572
01:16:45.041 --> 01:16:48.559
<v Mitch Green>Now that work has started on the deputy directors, but that work is not complete.

573
01:16:49.414 --> 01:16:52.940
<v Mitch Green>I've done the read-ahead on that, so it looks like you're starting this work.

574
01:16:54.832 --> 01:16:57.567
<v Mitch Green>But we did rush this core services realignment piece.

575
01:16:57.922 --> 01:17:05.095
<v Mitch Green>And I'm just flagging that one piece of this feels fast and rushed, and then another piece of this feels deliberate, slow, and patient.

576
01:17:05.738 --> 01:17:09.100
<v Mitch Green>And the deliberate, slow, patient part is at the deputy director and above.

577
01:17:09.841 --> 01:17:10.628
<v Mitch Green>Is that a fair characterization?

578
01:17:13.911 --> 01:17:15.787
<v Tracy Warren>No, I don't believe that it is.

579
01:17:17.203 --> 01:17:23.900
<v Tracy Warren>I think that we worked with the 2 different timelines that were provided.

580
01:17:25.271 --> 01:17:42.207
<v Tracy Warren>So the timeline for the core service realignment was being driven by the budget process and needing to be able to have numbers and concepts and proposals in for the mayor's proposed budget for councilor decision-making.

581
01:17:42.858 --> 01:17:55.748
<v Tracy Warren>Where the budget note is requiring us to do a study and to present information, but isn't necessarily being driven with a need to submit a proposal.

582
01:17:55.796 --> 01:18:03.059
<v Tracy Warren>So what we've talked about with the class compensation study is that they're going to give us recommendations.

583
01:18:03.106 --> 01:18:06.529
<v Tracy Warren>Those are not likely to be ready in this process.

584
01:18:07.059 --> 01:18:12.021
<v Tracy Warren>And so we would need to come back to council if there was changes that they wanted to adopt.

585
01:18:12.072 --> 01:18:12.154
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

586
01:18:12.765 --> 01:18:17.734
<v Tracy Warren>That are compensated relation— or compensation related for those positions.

587
01:18:17.863 --> 01:18:23.413
<v Tracy Warren>So I don't think that there was a choice made to rush one and not the other.

588
01:18:23.817 --> 01:18:34.846
<v Tracy Warren>It was more of we had different forces driving a need for the core service realignment to be ready for this moment in time based on the financial constraints.

589
01:18:35.185 --> 01:18:36.393
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor, you're at 8 minutes.

590
01:18:37.052 --> 01:18:37.649
<v Mitch Green>I'm over?

591
01:18:38.082 --> 01:18:39.126
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, we're at 8 right now.

592
01:18:39.367 --> 01:18:41.551
<v Mitch Green>Okay, I, I'll leave it there.

593
01:18:41.615 --> 01:18:41.823
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

594
01:18:42.563 --> 01:18:43.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>Feel free to jump back in the queue, colleagues.

595
01:18:44.024 --> 01:18:47.750
<v Jamie Dunphy>Remember, we're trying for 5 minutes where possible, and you're always welcome to jump back in the queue afterwards.

596
01:18:47.797 --> 01:18:48.585
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

597
01:18:49.645 --> 01:18:51.091
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

598
01:18:51.395 --> 01:18:53.659
<v Olivia Clark>Um, my apologies for being late.

599
01:18:53.805 --> 01:19:00.838
<v Olivia Clark>I had, um, something already scheduled when this was rearranged, so all my apologies to you, DCA Warren and, and team.

600
01:19:01.112 --> 01:19:05.190
<v Olivia Clark>I missed the presentation, so hopefully, um, my comments and questions won't be Councilor Smith.

601
01:19:05.287 --> 01:19:05.832
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

602
01:19:06.570 --> 01:19:07.485
<v Olivia Clark>I don't want to be too repetitive.

603
01:19:07.533 --> 01:19:15.689
<v Olivia Clark>I just want you to know that I understand we're undergoing a huge culture change and moving from one form of government to another.

604
01:19:16.780 --> 01:19:24.375
<v Olivia Clark>I understand that we're looking for increased standardization across the 26 bureaus that all operated independently.

605
01:19:25.369 --> 01:19:26.091
<v Olivia Clark>I get that.

606
01:19:26.317 --> 01:19:27.698
<v Olivia Clark>I, I support that.

607
01:19:28.323 --> 01:19:32.176
<v Olivia Clark>I know there was tremendous variation and freedom between the 26 thank you.

608
01:19:32.432 --> 01:19:43.145
<v Olivia Clark>So I appreciate the coming together and really, as I like to say, becoming a grown-up city like so many other— the rest of the nation's cities with a different operation.

609
01:19:44.059 --> 01:19:47.024
<v Olivia Clark>And I appreciate the fact that you clued us in early.

610
01:19:47.105 --> 01:19:56.293
<v Olivia Clark>We had some early meetings on this, and I think I expressed my concern at that point about how Public Works was taking the bulk of the core alignment.

611
01:19:56.726 --> 01:20:02.104
<v Olivia Clark>And that's clearly the area that I have the most interest in just because of my committee assignment.

612
01:20:03.331 --> 01:20:05.944
<v Olivia Clark>So I wondered if you could just talk a little bit more.

613
01:20:06.381 --> 01:20:07.462
<v Olivia Clark>I'm sorry I missed this.

614
01:20:07.511 --> 01:20:08.576
<v Olivia Clark>You probably went over it.

615
01:20:09.060 --> 01:20:11.836
<v Olivia Clark>In Public Works, there is no general fund impact here.

616
01:20:13.563 --> 01:20:28.364
<v Olivia Clark>I understand that we're aligning things, but could you address that for me just very briefly, the rationale, and also whether or not— I've looked briefly at the materials, but I don't quite understand the phasing of the implementation.

617
01:20:28.465 --> 01:20:28.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

618
01:20:29.154 --> 01:20:33.260
<v Olivia Clark>In Public Works, and those are primarily coming from HR.

619
01:20:33.662 --> 01:20:42.170
<v Olivia Clark>The, the bulk of the, uh, the realignment and the loss of positions in Public Works are 30 of the 59 are coming from Human Services.

620
01:20:42.217 --> 01:20:44.418
<v Olivia Clark>Could you just talk a little bit about that?

621
01:20:44.548 --> 01:20:51.216
<v Olivia Clark>And thank you for not doing the procurement, because I think in as much in Public Works, that's incredibly important.

622
01:20:51.264 --> 01:20:53.981
<v Olivia Clark>We have very complicated capital projects.

623
01:20:54.604 --> 01:20:55.265
<v Olivia Clark>So I appreciate that.

624
01:20:55.331 --> 01:20:58.898
<v Olivia Clark>But could you just talk about the— this is not a general fund issue.

625
01:20:59.284 --> 01:21:05.784
<v Olivia Clark>We're not benefiting the general fund by these cuts in public works, the HR component, and the phasing.

626
01:21:07.250 --> 01:21:07.653
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

627
01:21:08.377 --> 01:21:09.006
<v Olivia Clark>Absolutely.

628
01:21:10.327 --> 01:21:23.618
<v Tracy Warren>One of the things that we talked about as the added drive to look for cost savings as we realigned, right?

629
01:21:23.667 --> 01:21:35.978
<v Tracy Warren>When we initially started this, When we initially started this project in early 2025, end of 2024, the goal was not to make reductions.

630
01:21:36.091 --> 01:21:53.969
<v Tracy Warren>The goal was to realign services, find some efficiencies across the enterprise, and ensure that we were able to deliver consistent, credible services to all of our customers, both internally and externally to the city.

631
01:21:54.402 --> 01:22:05.640
<v Tracy Warren>Which we, you know, everybody is providing really good services and they provide valuable services, but it doesn't always happen consistently and equitably across the city.

632
01:22:05.735 --> 01:22:08.673
<v Tracy Warren>So that was one of the primary goals when we started out.

633
01:22:09.171 --> 01:22:16.314
<v Tracy Warren>We then layered on top an unknown future fiscal constraint, right?

634
01:22:16.957 --> 01:22:21.533
<v Tracy Warren>And the goal was for us to take reductions across okay.

635
01:22:21.631 --> 01:22:30.435
<v Tracy Warren>Across the enterprise proportionately, not to focus only on the general fund and not to focus only on other funds or rate-driven funds.

636
01:22:31.305 --> 01:22:33.801
<v Tracy Warren>And so that's how we approached the project.

637
01:22:34.364 --> 01:22:47.730
<v Tracy Warren>We were under the understanding that there would be pressures within those other areas for rates, for, Thank you.

638
01:22:47.796 --> 01:22:51.746
<v Tracy Warren>We had added personnel expenses and that we needed to apply this evenly.

639
01:22:52.886 --> 01:23:00.962
<v Tracy Warren>And I believe that as we've moved through the budget process, there has been remedies to some of the financial constraints.

640
01:23:01.653 --> 01:23:04.912
<v Tracy Warren>But I believe that we are still in financial constraints across the city.

641
01:23:05.345 --> 01:23:11.173
<v Tracy Warren>And so we've continued to move forward based on that understanding.

642
01:23:13.774 --> 01:23:18.185
<v Tracy Warren>So that's my response for the, you know, why this and not that.

643
01:23:18.649 --> 01:23:40.689
<v Tracy Warren>And then, you know, for the, you know, the phasings, one of the things that we did, and it was in our project timeline, is, you know, after we developed the proposals, we met with, you know, the DCAs and the directors of those areas and senior managers, and we talked through the plan.

644
01:23:41.908 --> 01:23:52.710
<v Tracy Warren>And we talked through reductions, and they provided us with really good input around where they saw potential risk to services and the ability to deliver.

645
01:23:53.784 --> 01:24:00.717
<v Tracy Warren>And they talked about where there might be key areas where it might actually increase costs for the city if we were to make reductions in those areas.

646
01:24:00.863 --> 01:24:04.634
<v Tracy Warren>And we listened very carefully to them, and we revised our plan based on that.

647
01:24:05.275 --> 01:24:26.220
<v Tracy Warren>And so, you know, when we talked about the human resources function, I think is what what you noted, we didn't make as many reductions there, or we didn't make as many risk mitigation moves there because we were able to mitigate the risk without doing additional things.

648
01:24:27.739 --> 01:24:29.335
<v Olivia Clark>Well, thank you for that explanation.

649
01:24:29.529 --> 01:24:32.817
<v Olivia Clark>Can I just ask further on the phasing?

650
01:24:32.930 --> 01:24:35.719
<v Olivia Clark>Are you looking at phasing this implementation?

651
01:24:36.442 --> 01:24:42.837
<v Olivia Clark>First of all, and secondly, how will we be able to evaluate the impact of the core alignment?

652
01:24:43.335 --> 01:24:45.099
<v Olivia Clark>And forgive me if you've already addressed this.

653
01:24:45.804 --> 01:24:46.862
<v Tracy Warren>No, we have not.

654
01:24:46.942 --> 01:24:48.288
<v Tracy Warren>So your question is great.

655
01:24:48.368 --> 01:24:49.956
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you, Councilor Clark.

656
01:24:50.309 --> 01:24:53.451
<v Tracy Warren>So we will be doing some phasing.

657
01:24:54.541 --> 01:25:13.505
<v Tracy Warren>You know, the reality is, is this is a big lift, and we've been driving to get to this moment so that you all could have enough information to make thank you.

658
01:25:14.711 --> 01:25:24.448
<v Tracy Warren>So we will likely see immediate, some immediate moves where we have folks who will mostly continue doing what they're doing.

659
01:25:25.621 --> 01:25:37.805
<v Tracy Warren>We will also see some areas or pockets where we will take longer because the risk is greater and we need more time and we need to make sure that we are slow and thoughtful with it.

660
01:25:39.010 --> 01:25:47.087
<v Tracy Warren>And then we will have areas that we find out through this process that we didn't all realize we needed to slow down.

661
01:25:47.264 --> 01:25:58.296
<v Tracy Warren>And it will be our responsibility to make sure that we're paying attention and that we're saying, whoa, here's an area that we need to slow down on, take our time, make sure that we have the appropriate things in place.

662
01:25:58.360 --> 01:25:58.457
<v Laura Oppenheimer>Thank you.

663
01:25:59.243 --> 01:25:59.742
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

664
01:26:01.076 --> 01:26:21.108
<v Tracy Warren>And then as far as how we will evaluate effectiveness, you know, one of the things that we recently started doing, and I think we did all of our conversations last week, but we're doing a monthly customer forum with each of the service areas where we come together and we talk about the realignment, we give updates.

665
01:26:21.171 --> 01:26:39.039
<v Tracy Warren>The goal is for it to be a fluid conversation where we are working as a team to talk through the new service delivery model, where there's challenges, where we need to continue to put resources and effort so that we can ensure that we're able to deliver the services.

666
01:26:39.778 --> 01:27:02.396
<v Tracy Warren>Additionally, I think I talked early on around wanting, after we get through the fiscal year, some of the initial onboarding, to start thinking about a governance model for our internal services and how we get cross enterprise-wide participation and input so that we're not making decisions in a vacuum and that we're thinking about the priorities overall for the city.

667
01:27:03.391 --> 01:27:09.798
<v Olivia Clark>Is it— this might be an unfair question, but where do you see the highest risk being right now?

668
01:27:10.457 --> 01:27:11.917
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor, we're at 8 and a half right now.

669
01:27:12.304 --> 01:27:12.463
<v Steve Novick>Oh, I am?

670
01:27:12.609 --> 01:27:13.203
<v Olivia Clark>Oh my gosh.

671
01:27:13.972 --> 01:27:15.643
<v Olivia Clark>How unusual.

672
01:27:18.819 --> 01:27:22.779
<v Tracy Warren>So I think I would look to the directors to answer that question.

673
01:27:24.221 --> 01:27:24.798
<v Ron Zito>Happy to start.

674
01:27:25.376 --> 01:27:26.594
<v Ron Zito>Thank you for the question, Councilor.

675
01:27:26.658 --> 01:27:36.931
<v Ron Zito>I would say from an HR perspective, our biggest risk would be potentially in compliance-related training, safety training, as well as within the processing of payroll.

676
01:27:36.996 --> 01:27:39.898
<v Ron Zito>Those are areas that we just can't fail in either of those.

677
01:27:40.362 --> 01:27:49.185
<v Ron Zito>We do think that we've, we've got a proposal that we can continue those services, but it is still an area I guess I'm next.

678
01:27:49.425 --> 01:27:53.631
<v Sylvester>Thank you, Vice President Clark, in terms of your question.

679
01:27:54.627 --> 01:27:59.909
<v Sylvester>Procurement, I believe that it's the standardization of an understanding of statutes, rules, and policies.

680
01:28:00.423 --> 01:28:08.453
<v Sylvester>Because of the decentralization, we've lost a lot of opportunity, including spend analytics and controls, and being made more aware in terms of commonality of systems.

681
01:28:08.949 --> 01:28:10.667
<v Sylvester>So the risk is not knowing.

682
01:28:10.733 --> 01:28:10.908
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

683
01:28:11.979 --> 01:28:13.685
<v Sylvester>So I think that that's really important.

684
01:28:13.734 --> 01:28:22.159
<v Sylvester>I think that there's an opportunity for a tremendous amount of savings and controls and standardization in procurement for us to be the best in the breed from beginning to end in the systems.

685
01:28:22.516 --> 01:28:27.537
<v Sylvester>So this would be a benefit, wholly a benefit to procurement, the core service realignment.

686
01:28:29.648 --> 01:28:34.204
<v Elise Rosenberg>I think for technology, it's that connection to the services that we provide to Portlanders.

687
01:28:34.253 --> 01:28:48.600
<v Elise Rosenberg>And as we're moving both in terms of changing our operating model and the way that we staff those services, as well as, as we're moving to standardized systems, those are all tied to business processes that result in service.

688
01:28:49.417 --> 01:28:58.570
<v Elise Rosenberg>And so the speed and the sort of lack of detailed visibility with moving pretty quickly could have service impacts.

689
01:28:58.650 --> 01:29:00.350
<v Elise Rosenberg>And that's where I think the risks are.

690
01:29:00.398 --> 01:29:08.909
<v Elise Rosenberg>And I think, again, those exist both in terms of the staffing movement as well as in terms Yeah, I really appreciate that.

691
01:29:09.038 --> 01:29:20.319
<v Olivia Clark>I understand that there's a lot of change management going on here, and it's very difficult for everybody to go through this culture change, but I appreciate your intentionality and the work that you've put into this.

692
01:29:20.898 --> 01:29:26.233
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm really hoping that we do become one city and that we can benefit from this core alignment.

693
01:29:26.280 --> 01:29:27.319
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you very much.

694
01:29:27.756 --> 01:29:28.780
<v Olivia Clark>Sorry I went over time.

695
01:29:28.958 --> 01:29:29.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>All good.

696
01:29:29.364 --> 01:29:30.387
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Council Vice President Clark.

697
01:29:30.907 --> 01:29:31.788
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

698
01:29:32.447 --> 01:29:33.475
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

699
01:29:33.570 --> 01:29:39.203
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to go as quickly as I can, and I'll, I'll just, uh, ask that if I do ask a question, the, the answer be very brief.

700
01:29:39.654 --> 01:29:42.157
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to start with 2 big framing points.

701
01:29:42.639 --> 01:29:58.127
<v Sameer Kanal>One is, uh, that you've now heard those in the chamber, and this is not about this presentation alone, but from Councilors Zimmerman, Green, Murillo, Smith, and myself, that there's less information about the budget in this year's budget than there was in last year's budget.

702
01:29:58.608 --> 01:30:04.998
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's really important to note, especially to any editorial boards that may be watching, that this is not coming from any one group of councilors.

703
01:30:05.192 --> 01:30:06.926
<v Sameer Kanal>We don't all agree on a lot of things.

704
01:30:07.279 --> 01:30:07.984
<v Sameer Kanal>We agree on this.

705
01:30:08.546 --> 01:30:10.409
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's an important thing to bring up.

706
01:30:10.489 --> 01:30:22.099
<v Sameer Kanal>The second thing, for any manager or supervisor class people out there, Canal 08, the budget note that has been used to cite doing a study about manager and supervisor classes, does not say a word about managers.

707
01:30:22.180 --> 01:30:47.760
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

708
01:30:47.760 --> 01:30:47.819
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Mayor.

709
01:30:47.819 --> 01:30:48.020
<v Dan Ryan>I have a question for Deputy City Administrator Donnie Oliveira.

710
01:30:48.219 --> 01:30:55.015
<v Sameer Kanal>To reflect duties that have changed in the new form of government, the review should ensure that director-level positions are commensurate with the size of the unit.

711
01:30:55.336 --> 01:31:01.072
<v Sameer Kanal>The expectation is that this review will result in pay and position reductions that result in cost savings for the city.

712
01:31:02.003 --> 01:31:06.935
<v Sameer Kanal>So this had absolutely nothing to do with commissioning a study, class comp, any of that.

713
01:31:07.064 --> 01:31:14.614
<v Sameer Kanal>It was to look at the specific six positions: Director One, Two, Three, Deputy Director One, Two, Three, and I just really need to set the record straight on that.

714
01:31:14.695 --> 01:31:19.247
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to smash the co-sponsor button on the budget note that you said, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

715
01:31:19.743 --> 01:31:22.114
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with everything Councilor Morillo said.

716
01:31:22.179 --> 01:31:22.707
<v Sameer Kanal>No notes.

717
01:31:23.109 --> 01:31:29.806
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm aware there are major constraints on the staff who led this realignment, and I don't think it's fair to blame you for the imperfections of this process.

718
01:31:30.176 --> 01:31:36.746
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do think it's fair to look at the overall statement of that, that the cord has not done enough engagement with staff nor done this in a fair way.

719
01:31:36.826 --> 01:31:46.814
<v Sameer Kanal>Because when I was in the PSSA and we did realignment to the service area, It was imperfect, but we didn't have this end goal in mind of a 9.5% or 10.5% reduction.

720
01:31:47.167 --> 01:32:05.420
<v Sameer Kanal>In fact, it built in that there would be a little increase because when you bring in Analyst 2s to— and Analyst 3s doing the same type of work to the same place, you often have to reclass to get those 2s up to the 3 level before you get the cross-training benefits, before you get the attrition over time that yields the efficiency and the savings.

721
01:32:06.077 --> 01:32:08.627
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to commend you for moving away from hiring a contractor.

722
01:32:08.676 --> 01:32:09.301
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

723
01:32:09.542 --> 01:32:15.326
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Morillo pointed out a $1 million contract.

724
01:32:15.407 --> 01:32:24.188
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll also note that the comms realignment, which appears to have not used that contractor, was done significantly faster than the one— the 3 that did use the contract.

725
01:32:24.765 --> 01:32:32.119
<v Sameer Kanal>Broadly though, it does seem that the HR procurement technology piece have been going well other than the staff engagement.

726
01:32:32.680 --> 01:32:35.725
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also appreciate all the information distinguishing core and embedded teams.

727
01:32:35.773 --> 01:32:35.885
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

728
01:32:35.981 --> 01:32:43.463
<v Sameer Kanal>It's really important, and I'm broadly supportive of the service area level realignment and less on the— and I've been saying it for a year— on the core side.

729
01:32:44.234 --> 01:32:48.793
<v Sameer Kanal>I also think it's misleading to point out that there are vacancies when there was a hiring freeze.

730
01:32:49.211 --> 01:32:56.596
<v Sameer Kanal>I think if there were vacancies in a normal context, it might mean that we're just getting by without that position filled and we can eliminate it if we need to.

731
01:32:57.014 --> 01:33:00.804
<v Sameer Kanal>But sometimes it just means retirement occurred and management wasn't allowed to fill the role.

732
01:33:00.884 --> 01:33:01.798
<v Sameer Kanal>That doesn't necessarily mean that there's a vacancy.

733
01:33:01.846 --> 01:33:09.895
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor And finally, I want to note that there's a lot of keep us aligned, keep us in compliance, keep us engaged.

734
01:33:10.551 --> 01:33:12.893
<v Sameer Kanal>We're not doing well at some of these functions now.

735
01:33:13.453 --> 01:33:22.768
<v Sameer Kanal>We might be keeping it at a B level or a B-minus level, but I don't think it's fair to say we're going to keep it at an A level if, if before the reductions we haven't been great at it.

736
01:33:22.832 --> 01:33:27.337
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think the engagement is a place, and equity is another place that I think we have not been successful at.

737
01:33:27.385 --> 01:33:27.753
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Dan Ryan.

738
01:33:28.358 --> 01:33:32.342
<v Sameer Kanal>This is not about the people in the roles now or the people starting next week.

739
01:33:33.403 --> 01:33:34.206
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

740
01:33:36.439 --> 01:33:36.551
<v Eric Zimmerman>Wow.

741
01:33:37.082 --> 01:33:44.805
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll note that in slide 27, it talks about— you mentioned feedback from councilors on the realignment of communications.

742
01:33:44.854 --> 01:33:46.971
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll note that some of that feedback wasn't taken.

743
01:33:47.198 --> 01:33:51.002
<v Sameer Kanal>I've noted many times that we are not connecting the service area well enough on public safety.

744
01:33:51.363 --> 01:33:52.801
<v Sameer Kanal>That slide shows public works as well.

745
01:33:52.865 --> 01:33:53.046
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

746
01:33:53.649 --> 01:34:06.152
<v Sameer Kanal>I think in particular in public safety, if we were realizing the communications savings that we've said we're going to find elsewhere, we might save a victims advocate at PPB or a chat staff member in fire or a front desk staffer at PPB.

747
01:34:06.524 --> 01:34:11.113
<v Sameer Kanal>And instead we're keeping a fairly large communications team in the bureau instead of doing the realignment.

748
01:34:12.962 --> 01:34:13.238
<v Sameer Kanal>Slide 30.

749
01:34:13.628 --> 01:34:14.457
<v Sameer Kanal>So here are my questions.

750
01:34:14.506 --> 01:34:15.287
<v Sameer Kanal>Slide 32.

751
01:34:15.872 --> 01:34:21.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you tell me what the 2 new non-rep positions are and what the 3 reduced CPPW positions are.

752
01:34:29.387 --> 01:34:34.604
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll just tell you the other 2 clarification ones just while— so that the other folks might get ready for it.

753
01:34:34.926 --> 01:34:44.591
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to know on slide 33 if the core reductions include elimination of the ABC program staff, and on slide 36-37, what the 2 positions being reduced in equity and public safety are.

754
01:34:44.881 --> 01:34:46.469
<v Sameer Kanal>Those are my 3 clarification questions.

755
01:34:47.186 --> 01:34:51.216
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Okay, so for this slide, I'm sorry, could you restate your question about this particular slide?

756
01:34:51.636 --> 01:34:57.525
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, what the 2 non-rep positions, these are all the bottom right, the 2 new non-rep positions and the 3 reduced CPPW positions.

757
01:34:58.220 --> 01:35:18.569
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So the 3 reduced CPPW positions are vacant positions that are in, 2 of those are in Civic Life and one of those I believe is in the, Uh, city— sorry, the Community Economic and Development Service Area.

758
01:35:19.559 --> 01:35:30.904
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the non-rep positions, this is another zero and two, I think, Councilor Green's question, kind of.

759
01:35:31.001 --> 01:35:36.845
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Yeah, I, I would, I would refer— defer to the budget office around that analysis there.

760
01:35:37.149 --> 01:35:45.275
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I under— I Because I don't want to misspeak about what was— how that was determined.

761
01:35:46.136 --> 01:35:49.671
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I know for the supervisor position, I can speak to that.

762
01:35:50.234 --> 01:35:50.490
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>The—.

763
01:35:51.761 --> 01:35:51.953
<v Elise Rosenberg>We—.

764
01:35:52.420 --> 01:36:01.140
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>One supervisor classification is reduced in Civic Life, and one manager position is being proposed to be created in the Public Works.

765
01:36:03.340 --> 01:36:03.560
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

766
01:36:04.458 --> 01:36:05.485
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Service area.

767
01:36:05.951 --> 01:36:13.478
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>That's the only manager classification in the whole organizational— in all of those 38 positions.

768
01:36:14.377 --> 01:36:20.572
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>And most of the management positions are in the analyst and coordinator buckets.

769
01:36:20.796 --> 01:36:21.037
<v Sylvester>Okay.

770
01:36:21.454 --> 01:36:22.225
<v Tracy Warren>One other thing.

771
01:36:22.514 --> 01:36:22.787
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry.

772
01:36:23.301 --> 01:36:25.997
<v Tracy Warren>I can add a little context there just to—.

773
01:36:26.045 --> 01:36:27.328
<v Sameer Kanal>If it's not on the manager, that's good.

774
01:36:27.377 --> 01:36:28.645
<v Sameer Kanal>I only am curious about the CPV.

775
01:36:28.693 --> 01:36:28.742
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

776
01:36:28.822 --> 01:36:28.934
<v Jamie Dunphy>I was—.

777
01:36:28.981 --> 01:36:30.689
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, I was going to address the non- But that's okay.

778
01:36:31.322 --> 01:36:34.561
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so the— is the ABC program staff being eliminated?

779
01:36:36.329 --> 01:36:54.654
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>That position, yes, but the proposal is to create a different classification of position that serves that program better and the implementation of the enhancement efforts across the organization.

780
01:36:55.204 --> 01:37:13.003
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>So currently the The position that serves the ABC program is a classification that I don't believe meets the need of implementing those enhanced— the enhancements that you all agreed on in code to add that chapter into code of the advisory body enhancement project.

781
01:37:13.372 --> 01:37:17.351
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I don't believe that current classification meets the need of that.

782
01:37:18.265 --> 01:37:20.015
<v Sameer Kanal>What classification is the new position?

783
01:37:21.699 --> 01:37:27.837
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>That is something that's being determined by HR in terms of the class and comp analysis.

784
01:37:28.319 --> 01:37:41.975
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>I believe it's a Coordinator 2 or an Analyst 2 placeholder, but I can— we don't know yet what that will be determined based on the position description and the skills needed to implement those enhancements.

785
01:37:42.618 --> 01:37:42.795
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

786
01:37:43.003 --> 01:37:50.372
<v Sameer Kanal>On the very next slide, it says that we're centralizing engagement efforts to improve coordination across bureaus and effectiveness in community.

787
01:37:50.628 --> 01:38:01.270
<v Sameer Kanal>Broadly speaking, that feels like wishcasting, um, because, of course, one of the, the parts of our engagement system that are working well are the parts that are tailored specifically to what they're engaging about.

788
01:38:02.006 --> 01:38:15.693
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and the ABC program is basically the only place so far that has done the coordination across bureaus to get some level of continuity and, um, and similarity to how we do things.

789
01:38:15.805 --> 01:38:23.836
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm concerned about not only the broad idea that that would be how it would work, but also how that particular position fits into that.

790
01:38:24.274 --> 01:38:32.837
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not going to ask the question about equity because I know I'm over time, but I did want to say I am very, very concerned that equity is being reframed as compliance.

791
01:38:33.671 --> 01:38:38.604
<v Sameer Kanal>And there are people who— that is a part of it, right?

792
01:38:38.670 --> 01:38:41.256
<v Sameer Kanal>ADA compliance, Title VI compliance, and all of that.

793
01:38:41.320 --> 01:38:41.368
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

794
01:38:41.582 --> 01:38:44.228
<v Sameer Kanal>That's not what the core values of the city say.

795
01:38:44.932 --> 01:38:50.208
<v Sameer Kanal>And so we can't both call it compliance and say we are fulfilling the core values of the city.

796
01:38:51.507 --> 01:39:02.958
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you look at the equity core value, which is the second one, or the anti-racism one, which is the first one, we just skip over that right now pretty much every time when we talk about these core values.

797
01:39:03.777 --> 01:39:13.940
<v Sameer Kanal>There is a very clear connection between proactive work that the staff not only should be doing, and that may be going away, but already are doing.

798
01:39:15.336 --> 01:39:20.594
<v Sameer Kanal>And there are equity staff across the entire city, 2 of which are being reduced in public safety in this budget.

799
01:39:20.641 --> 01:39:26.444
<v Sameer Kanal>That's a 33% reduction to the staff that are focused on equity and public safety, which is unconscionable.

800
01:39:27.037 --> 01:39:33.755
<v Sameer Kanal>But there is work that is already being done that will not be being done, and we're simultaneously being told there's no service impact.

801
01:39:33.835 --> 01:39:33.962
<v Sylvester>Thank you.

802
01:39:34.573 --> 01:39:37.025
<v Sameer Kanal>Because the only service we're measuring is the compliance piece.

803
01:39:37.538 --> 01:39:39.094
<v Sameer Kanal>And that is really concerning to me.

804
01:39:39.462 --> 01:39:43.568
<v Sameer Kanal>And we have a new equity officer coming in, and I'm willing to be— it's a very big hire.

805
01:39:43.648 --> 01:39:45.699
<v Sameer Kanal>It's your first big hire, as you pointed out, CA Lee.

806
01:39:45.796 --> 01:39:49.228
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm very excited about that, and I'm optimistic about that.

807
01:39:49.484 --> 01:39:51.729
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think you cannot succeed at what you don't measure.

808
01:39:52.289 --> 01:40:01.429
<v Sameer Kanal>And right now, if all we're measuring is compliance with the ADA and Title VI and other specific laws, we are not going to even know in a public-facing way what it is that we are losing.

809
01:40:01.573 --> 01:40:02.568
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's a very important point.

810
01:40:04.309 --> 01:40:05.916
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

811
01:40:07.426 --> 01:40:08.310
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

812
01:40:08.551 --> 01:40:10.304
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, it is currently 11 o'clock.

813
01:40:10.399 --> 01:40:13.922
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are halfway through our work session for the day and we have 2 more presentations still.

814
01:40:15.619 --> 01:40:24.662
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm gonna have— we have Councilors Novick, Ryan, and Zimmerman in the queue, and then we're gonna take a break and then come back and do our last 2.

815
01:40:25.021 --> 01:40:26.166
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

816
01:40:27.047 --> 01:40:27.847
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

817
01:40:28.462 --> 01:40:39.101
<v Steve Novick>Quick question to which you've probably already given us the answer and I don't need it right now, but I am curious, of the savings contemplated from core realignment, how much of that would be in the general fund?

818
01:40:40.481 --> 01:40:46.804
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, I'd— we'll follow up with the budget office, but I believe it's somewhere between $3 to $4 million.

819
01:40:47.637 --> 01:40:47.958
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

820
01:40:48.746 --> 01:40:51.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

821
01:40:51.153 --> 01:40:52.146
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

822
01:40:52.452 --> 01:40:53.623
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, President Dunphy.

823
01:40:53.976 --> 01:40:55.564
<v Dan Ryan>Hello, Tracy, and the esteemed panel.

824
01:40:55.907 --> 01:40:59.306
<v Dan Ryan>And the hardworking public servants in the council chambers this morning.

825
01:40:59.747 --> 01:41:00.680
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for being here.

826
01:41:01.170 --> 01:41:02.703
<v Dan Ryan>I'm well aware we are talking about you.

827
01:41:02.997 --> 01:41:05.427
<v Dan Ryan>It must feel personal, and I'm deeply aware of that.

828
01:41:07.063 --> 01:41:14.229
<v Dan Ryan>Big picture is we moved from 5 commissioners with limited capacity to oversee 26 to 27 bureaus and offices.

829
01:41:14.679 --> 01:41:23.493
<v Dan Ryan>Now we have removed the elected officials from that daily oversight, with the exception of the mayor, and now we have 3 layers the top is the central administration.

830
01:41:25.279 --> 01:41:28.711
<v Dan Ryan>The middle is the work areas that we're speaking of, that DCAs oversee.

831
01:41:29.805 --> 01:41:36.868
<v Dan Ryan>And then we have the bureaus and offices, those closest to the ground, engaging with Portlanders to provide service.

832
01:41:37.966 --> 01:41:46.387
<v Dan Ryan>And so we have moved the city away from those 5 silos, which were wildly fluid based on commissioners' assignments, to this, to this new day.

833
01:41:47.163 --> 01:41:49.914
<v Dan Ryan>Voters wanted to have our operations under a city administrator.

834
01:41:50.984 --> 01:41:54.567
<v Dan Ryan>And the world is your oyster, City Administrator, to restructure our city.

835
01:41:55.403 --> 01:41:59.386
<v Dan Ryan>And so this is exactly the type of tough, necessary work we're supposed to be doing.

836
01:42:00.783 --> 01:42:04.043
<v Dan Ryan>I hope we make decisions based on the service to Portlanders.

837
01:42:04.557 --> 01:42:15.351
<v Dan Ryan>It mentions with that consolidation, some of the work is going to be prioritized over others, and with a smaller staff capacity, some services and functions therefore will be slower.

838
01:42:15.417 --> 01:42:15.545
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

839
01:42:16.426 --> 01:42:24.942
<v Dan Ryan>Can you briefly explain the functions and bodies of the work and how they were prioritized in this realignment?

840
01:42:26.368 --> 01:42:30.489
<v Dan Ryan>I don't know if that's for Tracy, City Administrator.

841
01:42:30.554 --> 01:42:35.894
<v Dan Ryan>You've been here just 4 or 5 months, but this has been going on much before you arrived.

842
01:42:36.631 --> 01:42:44.423
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, I think that our next presentation on span of control, we have some information related to our Okay.

843
01:42:44.568 --> 01:42:46.234
<v Tracy Warren>That has to do with executives.

844
01:42:46.411 --> 01:42:52.534
<v Tracy Warren>And so I think that that will help inform more information related to how we compare to other cities.

845
01:42:52.582 --> 01:42:54.010
<v Dan Ryan>Can we repeat this question?

846
01:42:54.202 --> 01:42:55.051
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, absolutely.

847
01:42:55.243 --> 01:42:55.612
<v Dan Ryan>Absolutely.

848
01:42:55.868 --> 01:42:59.811
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, I have, and I, then I'm gonna zip, zip, zip, zip, zip.

849
01:42:59.891 --> 01:43:03.610
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, finally, we've had conversations about non-represented employees.

850
01:43:04.284 --> 01:43:09.926
<v Dan Ryan>And I recall it was on January 1st, 2025, I asked that question.

851
01:43:10.554 --> 01:43:16.085
<v Dan Ryan>And at that time we had 700 of our 7,000, so 10% of our city was non-represented.

852
01:43:16.488 --> 01:43:17.789
<v Dan Ryan>Has that number changed?

853
01:43:20.569 --> 01:43:27.470
<v Ron Zito>And forgive me, Councilor, I think even last year in 2025 we were around the same number, which is roughly—.

854
01:43:27.470 --> 01:43:28.520
<v Dan Ryan>That was in January.

855
01:43:28.585 --> 01:43:29.442
<v Dan Ryan>That was the number I had.

856
01:43:29.797 --> 01:43:31.417
<v Ron Zito>Okay, was around 700 you say?

857
01:43:31.789 --> 01:43:32.243
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

858
01:43:33.344 --> 01:43:35.949
<v Ron Zito>And we can follow up with the exact numbers as of January 1st, 2023.

859
01:43:40.399 --> 01:43:44.189
<v Dan Ryan>It's important, I think, for us to know that denominator when we make— when we ask questions.

860
01:43:45.880 --> 01:43:54.706
<v Dan Ryan>Um, not knowing the details of my fellow D2 colleagues' budget note, I am also supportive of the idea of having agile responses as we do change.

861
01:43:54.770 --> 01:43:55.516
<v Dan Ryan>That's so important.

862
01:43:56.069 --> 01:43:57.253
<v Dan Ryan>So you've been doing the planning.

863
01:43:57.368 --> 01:44:00.729
<v Dan Ryan>It's plan, do, and the doing is what we're talking about right now.

864
01:44:01.184 --> 01:44:08.038
<v Dan Ryan>And then there's the and then the study part, that's when council should have the opportunity to have oversight and engagement.

865
01:44:08.600 --> 01:44:10.814
<v Dan Ryan>But I also really want to stress this.

866
01:44:10.909 --> 01:44:14.344
<v Dan Ryan>When you're doing continuous improvement work, it must include the employees on the ground.

867
01:44:14.777 --> 01:44:16.702
<v Dan Ryan>They have to give— they have the wisdom.

868
01:44:16.782 --> 01:44:17.198
<v Dan Ryan>They're there.

869
01:44:17.824 --> 01:44:18.916
<v Dan Ryan>They're the ones facing Portlanders.

870
01:44:18.963 --> 01:44:24.210
<v Dan Ryan>So we have to figure out how to have that communication loop from them as we study this implementation.

871
01:44:24.884 --> 01:44:27.065
<v Dan Ryan>And then we recast, redo is the last part.

872
01:44:27.130 --> 01:44:27.418
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

873
01:44:28.077 --> 01:44:33.192
<v Dan Ryan>And I think we need to have that culture throughout the city, and the council oversight should always be in that study.

874
01:44:33.465 --> 01:44:37.713
<v Dan Ryan>So I hope that we're moving into a continuous improvement, all one city environment.

875
01:44:38.579 --> 01:44:39.926
<v Dan Ryan>I'm really comfortable with change.

876
01:44:40.038 --> 01:44:43.935
<v Dan Ryan>It's been often a main title in my job description.

877
01:44:44.512 --> 01:44:47.784
<v Dan Ryan>And so I know our goal is to help improve services for Portlanders.

878
01:44:47.961 --> 01:44:51.119
<v Dan Ryan>Again, that's why people voted for the charter change in 2022.

879
01:44:51.664 --> 01:44:54.247
<v Dan Ryan>So please include those work teams on the ground so they're engaged.

880
01:44:54.310 --> 01:44:54.454
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Thank you.

881
01:44:54.939 --> 01:44:57.359
<v Dan Ryan>Which also can include engagement from the public.

882
01:44:58.503 --> 01:45:05.243
<v Dan Ryan>I have to say that slide, the total position change across 5 core areas, it was like one of the first ones.

883
01:45:05.453 --> 01:45:06.738
<v Dan Ryan>So the first one's really easy.

884
01:45:06.786 --> 01:45:09.083
<v Dan Ryan>The second one, City Administrator, there are 3.

885
01:45:09.277 --> 01:45:10.225
<v Dan Ryan>After, there's 1.

886
01:45:10.802 --> 01:45:11.671
<v Dan Ryan>Reductions, 1.

887
01:45:11.783 --> 01:45:17.037
<v Dan Ryan>So I could get to why the final number was what it was after FTE.

888
01:45:17.586 --> 01:45:20.185
<v Dan Ryan>But I got to tell you, I'm usually really good with numbers and charts.

889
01:45:20.234 --> 01:45:20.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

890
01:45:21.307 --> 01:45:22.657
<v Dan Ryan>It was really hard to figure out.

891
01:45:22.704 --> 01:45:27.890
<v Dan Ryan>Maybe it's the slashes and the realignments part, but I have to spend a little more time to understand.

892
01:45:28.002 --> 01:45:31.855
<v Dan Ryan>And this is kind of like the big picture data points.

893
01:45:32.385 --> 01:45:36.141
<v Dan Ryan>And so I don't wanna go further into this without understanding this slide.

894
01:45:36.961 --> 01:45:38.261
<v Dan Ryan>Does that make sense?

895
01:45:38.582 --> 01:45:38.791
<v Elise Rosenberg>Yes.

896
01:45:39.127 --> 01:45:39.465
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

897
01:45:39.626 --> 01:45:43.574
<v Dan Ryan>And if I'm the only one that is struggling with this, I'd be shocked.

898
01:45:44.185 --> 01:45:47.266
<v Dan Ryan>So anyway, I think my time is up.

899
01:45:47.893 --> 01:45:49.337
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

900
01:45:49.658 --> 01:45:50.301
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

901
01:45:51.265 --> 01:45:51.762
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

902
01:45:53.207 --> 01:45:55.936
<v Eric Zimmerman>No specific questions with regard to the brief.

903
01:45:56.065 --> 01:45:58.426
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just want to talk a little bit about kind of a culture.

904
01:45:58.795 --> 01:46:08.733
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think one of the— if we're going to go through significant change, an area that I hope that I can flag both in terms of my own expectations, but also where I think we need some attention.

905
01:46:09.568 --> 01:46:09.697
<v Steve Novick>Right.

906
01:46:09.744 --> 01:46:13.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think one of the great indicators of a good or a bad boss yes.

907
01:46:13.823 --> 01:46:20.243
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is whether or not they have tough conversations with their employees themselves or if they have HR have that conversation.

908
01:46:21.867 --> 01:46:23.863
<v Eric Zimmerman>HR is a crutch for really bad leaders.

909
01:46:24.765 --> 01:46:31.695
<v Eric Zimmerman>And when we're talking about realignment, and in this last several months, I'll just tell you, Mr.

910
01:46:31.743 --> 01:46:56.881
<v Eric Zimmerman>Administrator and Mayor, I think that you've got a challenge in front of you because I think that there are aspects of, I'll say, the broader leadership team who've let it come into our organization that somehow realignment was just about general fund or just about money and it wasn't about the overall direction of this government and that we all work for one city administrator now.

911
01:46:57.349 --> 01:47:05.796
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I think that's allowed some unfortunate cultural rifts to occur that I think need some attention.

912
01:47:09.833 --> 01:47:18.577
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, in no world does anybody in the City of Portland believe that we need 27 versions of HR, procurement, or IT, right, from our old version of government.

913
01:47:19.314 --> 01:47:40.354
<v Eric Zimmerman>But also what I'm not getting is a significant amount of leadership at the— again, I'll just say the broader leadership level of the city administration at many levels of of supervisory manager, director levels of buy-in and of articulating the vision.

914
01:47:42.350 --> 01:47:57.636
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I offer that because if you're a bureau director or a deputy director or a manager who's going to come in front of the City Council and talk about a realignment, what we really need is that you have command of the information, that you have—.

915
01:47:57.668 --> 01:47:57.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

916
01:47:59.042 --> 01:48:11.956
<v Eric Zimmerman>A vision for the direction that you're taking your bureau, that you have an idea for how to accomplish the mission, so to speak, and that you are projecting leadership in that space.

917
01:48:13.502 --> 01:48:24.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>If you're unable to articulate how your bureau is going to accomplish a job, don't be afraid to say that is not something the bureau will be taking on in the future year.

918
01:48:24.137 --> 01:48:24.268
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

919
01:48:24.867 --> 01:48:29.251
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or articulate how you plan to adjust how we've done that mission.

920
01:48:30.101 --> 01:48:48.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the soft language, the wishy-washiness, the I'm not sure-isms does nothing to project leadership, both to me as a, as a councilor, but really having been through a situation like this as an AFSCME member, as a new employee a long time ago in the Great Recession.

921
01:48:48.887 --> 01:48:49.658
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor Smith.

922
01:48:50.412 --> 01:49:00.002
<v Eric Zimmerman>We as employees can get through hard things if we have a leader who can articulate the vision and the direction and the path that we're about to walk on together.

923
01:49:01.318 --> 01:49:08.020
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is so much harder if we don't have faith in the people who are speaking for us at just our next level above us.

924
01:49:09.095 --> 01:49:35.801
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I would encourage all levels of, of our non-represented workforce who are coming to convey a budget message, a realignment, et cetera, that you really think about what do you want to articulate for your office or your bureau, your service area, how it's gonna work through these changes and how you're working with your employees to project a vision, right?

925
01:49:36.587 --> 01:49:41.127
<v Eric Zimmerman>Realignment shouldn't be a flat-footedness and a ho-hum, we just have to do it.

926
01:49:41.640 --> 01:49:50.341
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because when you start with ho-hum, we just have to do it, People need meaning around our hardest conversations, and the meaning is going to matter here.

927
01:49:50.487 --> 01:50:06.355
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't know that we have done a great job down through the organization to do that, and it has allowed a bit of a crutch to start to form underneath the arms of some, of some topics, some areas that I, I think should be avoided, avoidable and avoided.

928
01:50:07.046 --> 01:50:08.957
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I appreciate the work.

929
01:50:09.037 --> 01:50:09.503
<v Eric Zimmerman>It is difficult work.

930
01:50:09.583 --> 01:50:09.856
<v Ron Zito>Thank you.

931
01:50:10.145 --> 01:50:11.253
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

932
01:50:11.993 --> 01:50:44.072
<v Eric Zimmerman>And, and I know there will be more to this, but for those who are going to face some very difficult conversations, I hope that the most senior leaders, the 2 that are sitting across from me, can project down your expectations of your subordinate senior leaders and, and how they should be having these conversations with their, with their teams, those who may be leaving us and also those who will remain here and what we're going to do to build a single one city, like one water, like one road, like one city of Portland.

933
01:50:44.136 --> 01:50:45.519
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think you both have that vision.

934
01:50:45.567 --> 01:50:46.692
<v Eric Zimmerman>You've both talked to me about it.

935
01:50:47.591 --> 01:50:52.813
<v Eric Zimmerman>And you need some help at the levels below you, the people who are closest to our employees and to our neighborhoods.

936
01:50:52.926 --> 01:50:54.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I appreciate that.

937
01:50:54.179 --> 01:50:54.837
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Mr. President.

938
01:50:55.224 --> 01:50:56.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

939
01:50:57.457 --> 01:50:58.582
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, it is 11:15.

940
01:50:58.743 --> 01:51:01.377
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to give us a 10-minute restroom break and we're going to come back.

941
01:51:01.426 --> 01:51:06.984
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to ask I'm going to ask Tracy if we can do both the presentations at once so we can have, uh, the rest of the meeting.

942
01:51:07.551 --> 01:51:09.216
<v Jamie Dunphy>Everybody please be back here at 11:25.

943
01:51:09.719 --> 01:51:09.976
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

944
01:51:14.380 --> 01:51:15.134
<v Tracy Warren>Thank you.

945
02:05:55.820 --> 02:05:58.176
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are back.

946
02:05:59.404 --> 02:06:00.485
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you, friends.

947
02:06:01.648 --> 02:06:09.787
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have 1 hour left and 2 full presentations still to get through, so I'm asking our staff to please go ahead and just do back-to-back presentations on this.

948
02:06:10.220 --> 02:06:14.436
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll handle all the rest of our questions and we will get out of here at a reasonable time.

949
02:06:15.046 --> 02:06:15.929
<v Tracy Warren>Tracy, please take it away.

950
02:06:15.993 --> 02:06:16.329
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

951
02:06:16.810 --> 02:06:17.114
<v Angelita Morillo>Absolutely.

952
02:06:17.194 --> 02:06:23.288
<v Tracy Warren>Actually, I'm, I'm going to be here in a supporting role, so I'm going to turn it over to Director Zito.

953
02:06:23.689 --> 02:06:24.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>Take it away, Ron.

954
02:06:25.453 --> 02:06:29.318
<v Ron Zito>Good morning, Mayor, councilors, Council President, Vice President.

955
02:06:29.927 --> 02:06:30.938
<v Ron Zito>For the record, I'm Ron Zito.

956
02:06:30.985 --> 02:06:33.359
<v Ron Zito>I'm the interim director of the Bureau of Human Resources.

957
02:06:34.194 --> 02:06:42.844
<v Ron Zito>I'm joining you today to provide an overview of a topic that I know is of interest to many as we navigate this year's budget process, and that concept is span of control.

958
02:06:43.501 --> 02:06:49.407
<v Ron Zito>For some, this is maybe a term that's unfamiliar or even feel like organizational management jargon.

959
02:06:49.936 --> 02:06:52.649
<v Ron Zito>So let's start by defining what span of control refers to.

960
02:06:52.970 --> 02:06:53.659
<v Ron Zito>Next slide, please.

961
02:06:54.333 --> 02:06:54.639
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

962
02:06:55.713 --> 02:07:06.377
<v Ron Zito>In its simplest form, span of control refers to how supervisory responsibilities distributed throughout our organization, and in general, it speaks to the number of staff a supervisor is responsible for.

963
02:07:07.180 --> 02:07:17.385
<v Ron Zito>Now, in our city, we have classifications who may supervise staff depending on the nature of the assignment, and there are classifications who must supervise to adequately meet the criteria of that classification.

964
02:07:18.108 --> 02:07:26.029
<v Ron Zito>By way of a quick example, an Analyst 3 may supervise staff, whereas a Manager 1 must directly supervise a minimum of 4 employees.

965
02:07:26.863 --> 02:07:30.757
<v Ron Zito>And may indirectly supervise staff assigned to other subordinate supervisors.

966
02:07:31.591 --> 02:07:39.332
<v Ron Zito>Now, available literature on the topic consistently indicates that there is no single target span of control appropriate for all situations and every team.

967
02:07:40.087 --> 02:07:45.984
<v Ron Zito>An optimal span depends on multiple factors that can be difficult to quantify, may even change over time.

968
02:07:46.722 --> 02:07:53.470
<v Ron Zito>However, this is not to say that span of control doesn't matter or have a real impact on our organization, our staff, or service delivery.

969
02:07:53.534 --> 02:07:53.774
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

970
02:07:55.128 --> 02:07:57.180
<v Ron Zito>Next slide, please.

971
02:07:59.798 --> 02:08:16.136
<v Ron Zito>Again, while there's not a single ideal span of control for all work in an organization, generally a smaller span of control can support closer oversight, coordination, and consistency within a team, whereas larger spans require clear delegation of authority and effective decision-making processes to avoid bottlenecks.

972
02:08:16.701 --> 02:08:22.100
<v Ron Zito>While larger spans are often associated with greater efficiency and less hierarchical structure, Thank you, Councilor Smith.

973
02:08:22.100 --> 02:08:22.100
<v Ron Zito>Thank you, Mayor.

974
02:08:22.100 --> 02:08:22.100
<v Ron Zito>As Deputy City Administrator, I'm pleased to present the recommendation for the City of Portland's new policy on span of control.

975
02:08:22.100 --> 02:08:22.100
<v Ron Zito>As Mayor Wilson mentioned, span of control is a critical component of effective management.

976
02:08:22.100 --> 02:08:22.100
<v Ron Zito>Without a clear understanding of span of control, managers may not be able to effectively manage their departments or employees.

977
02:08:22.100 --> 02:08:27.359
<v Ron Zito>Without a clear understanding of span of control, managers may also present problems or challenges related to consistency, clear communication, and accountability.

978
02:08:27.359 --> 02:08:35.020
<v Ron Zito>Perhaps said more simply, no one wants a manager they can never reach to support them or is too busy to provide for an adequate employee experience.

979
02:08:35.479 --> 02:08:41.380
<v Ron Zito>And alternatively, no one wants to be micromanaged or see budgets drained by unnecessary or burdensome oversight.

980
02:08:41.380 --> 02:08:48.090
<v Ron Zito>Ideally, span of control should be determined by the nature of the work, operational complexity, and tailored to the organization's needs.

981
02:08:48.858 --> 02:08:57.610
<v Ron Zito>And before we look at the data, I'd be remiss not to acknowledge that employees with supervisory responsibilities also perform non-supervisory work as a part of their classification.

982
02:08:58.207 --> 02:09:03.760
<v Ron Zito>In fact, in most instances, non-supervisory duties make up the majority of a supervisor's overall workload.

983
02:09:04.509 --> 02:09:05.283
<v Ron Zito>Next slide, please.

984
02:09:07.337 --> 02:09:13.018
<v Ron Zito>And here's just a quick visual example to set the tone for the next few slides and to hammer home the terminology we're going to be using.

985
02:09:13.694 --> 02:09:18.039
<v Ron Zito>In this example, this supervisor has 4 direct reports who directly report into them.

986
02:09:19.076 --> 02:09:22.520
<v Ron Zito>And 3 indirect reports who report to subordinate supervisors.

987
02:09:23.020 --> 02:09:29.859
<v Ron Zito>Therefore, the span of control for this supervisor is 4 direct reports to 1 supervisor, or we may refer to it as 1 to 4.

988
02:09:32.189 --> 02:09:32.948
<v Ron Zito>Next slide, please.

989
02:09:35.310 --> 02:09:38.367
<v Ron Zito>So what is our average span of control within the City of Portland?

990
02:09:38.706 --> 02:09:49.354
<v Ron Zito>Using a recent report from April of this year that I believe was sent to councilors last night, we find that excluding police, It is 1 manager for every 7.7 direct reports.

991
02:09:49.868 --> 02:09:56.420
<v Ron Zito>Now, that's up from 1994 where we had 1 manager for every 6.5 direct reports, and that also excluded police.

992
02:09:57.479 --> 02:10:05.893
<v Ron Zito>And I should say police is considered separately due to their unique rank-based and organizational culture and structure, which would likely overstate spans.

993
02:10:06.872 --> 02:10:13.006
<v Ron Zito>But as you can see here, averages vary widely across service areas, with public safety being the highest span of 1 to 11.

994
02:10:13.069 --> 02:10:13.182
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

995
02:10:14.579 --> 02:10:19.974
<v Ron Zito>And to be clear, this is addressing those directly reporting to that manager, not the total number of indirect reports.

996
02:10:20.391 --> 02:10:24.126
<v Ron Zito>This also does not include casual staff who might report to that manager as well.

997
02:10:27.199 --> 02:10:28.064
<v Ron Zito>Next slide, please.

998
02:10:29.775 --> 02:10:41.394
<v Ron Zito>Now, since 2020, we have seen some growth in all positions, the largest being those positions which may supervise, and that was 73%, where again supervision is optional rather than required within those classifications.

999
02:10:41.582 --> 02:10:54.925
<v Ron Zito>It's also important to consider that supervisory classified positions represent a smaller share of the overall workforce, so percentage increases reflect more modest changes in the total number of positions than the rates alone here might suggest.

1000
02:10:55.534 --> 02:11:01.604
<v Ron Zito>However, overall supervisory classifications did grow faster than non-supervisory over the review period.

1001
02:11:02.390 --> 02:11:10.994
<v Ron Zito>And as of March 2026, we have about 905 managers who must supervise out of a total non-casual population of 6,695.

1002
02:11:12.720 --> 02:11:13.445
<v Ron Zito>Next slide, please.

1003
02:11:17.658 --> 02:11:18.045
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1004
02:11:18.546 --> 02:11:28.309
<v Ron Zito>Now, as mentioned earlier, classifications who must supervise staff, with limited exceptions, are expected to supervise at least 4 direct reports, and that's defined in our classification specifications.

1005
02:11:29.136 --> 02:11:36.708
<v Ron Zito>As of March 4th, 2026, 57 supervisors in those must-supervise classifications had fewer than 4 direct reports.

1006
02:11:37.335 --> 02:11:42.007
<v Ron Zito>This represents approximately 8% of supervisors in classifications subject to that minimum.

1007
02:11:42.890 --> 02:11:50.886
<v Ron Zito>In March of last year, 2025, bureaus were surveyed and provided context regarding these types of positions not meeting that 4-person standard.

1008
02:11:51.320 --> 02:12:15.042
<v Ron Zito>And as you can see here on the slide, the majority of responses reflect that the bureau did not believe the positions should be required to meet the minimum standard due to the nature of the work As we discussed earlier, and we will again here, the city is currently conducting a classification and compensation study for its non-represented classifications, which is primarily including manager and supervisory roles.

1009
02:12:15.545 --> 02:12:26.055
<v Ron Zito>As a part of that effort, options will be developed to crosswalk some of these scenarios with existing manager and supervisor positions that do not meet the span of control standards into more appropriate classifications where warranted.

1010
02:12:26.121 --> 02:12:26.265
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1011
02:12:27.247 --> 02:12:31.248
<v Ron Zito>In fact, we met with Evergreen just yesterday to review some of their preliminary recommendations.

1012
02:12:31.443 --> 02:12:33.458
<v Ron Zito>We look forward to bringing those to you in the future.

1013
02:12:36.685 --> 02:12:37.152
<v Jamie Dunphy>Next slide, please.

1014
02:12:39.047 --> 02:12:51.770
<v Ron Zito>And so shifting slightly, another influence on span of control includes the number of organizational layers we maintain and where most staff fall within that hierarchy, meaning how many layers of management are between maybe elected officials and staff.

1015
02:12:52.212 --> 02:12:57.078
<v Ron Zito>In other words, our city administrator and DCAs would account for layer 1 of an organization.

1016
02:12:57.529 --> 02:13:03.984
<v Ron Zito>If, for example, I'm a director reporting to a deputy city administrator, I would reside in layer 2 of that organization.

1017
02:13:04.644 --> 02:13:09.927
<v Ron Zito>And if I report directly to a bureau director, it's likely I reside in layer 3, and so on and so forth.

1018
02:13:11.083 --> 02:13:21.983
<v Ron Zito>As, as of March 2026, the city's organizational hierarchy reached up to 9 layers, and the majority of staff reside within layers 4 through 6, which is typical for an organization of our size.

1019
02:13:23.061 --> 02:13:29.792
<v Ron Zito>The drivers of these layers include charter reform as well as other reorganization efforts that we expect will also impact these layers as we move forward.

1020
02:13:31.520 --> 02:13:32.005
<v Ron Zito>Next slide, please.

1021
02:13:33.493 --> 02:13:33.800
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1022
02:13:34.932 --> 02:13:38.797
<v Ron Zito>Now, another area of particular interest may be span of control in our senior leadership roles.

1023
02:13:38.993 --> 02:13:40.578
<v Ron Zito>So let's double-click here for a moment.

1024
02:13:41.336 --> 02:13:44.917
<v Ron Zito>As you are aware, our city's service areas are led by deputy city administrators.

1025
02:13:44.981 --> 02:13:45.096
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

1026
02:13:45.878 --> 02:13:53.554
<v Ron Zito>City bureaus are generally led by a director, and some bureaus establish a deputy director position to break large spans and better support bureau leadership.

1027
02:13:54.595 --> 02:14:31.350
<v Ron Zito>As we look across these senior levels of leadership, the city administrator, deputy city administrators, and director positions all meet that minimum span of control of 4, with a few exceptions in the deputy director classification, and those generally fall in relatively small bureaus with complex missions, for example, PBEM, government relations, All right.

1028
02:14:31.350 --> 02:14:33.789
<v Ron Zito>So again, slightly changing gears.

1029
02:14:33.789 --> 02:14:42.625
<v Ron Zito>Recently, using data from our 2023 market study for DCA positions, we were able to determine that the average salary for a DCA position the city operations team began assessing leadership structure across comparable cities.

1030
02:14:43.220 --> 02:14:48.856
<v Ron Zito>And this research is ongoing, but we did want to share some of the high-level findings with you today as it relates to span of control.

1031
02:14:50.979 --> 02:14:55.448
<v Ron Zito>So I'm going to jump through these next few slides fairly quickly, but I just want to call out the main points.

1032
02:14:56.078 --> 02:14:59.612
<v Ron Zito>So this first chart shows total population across a number of cities.

1033
02:15:00.127 --> 02:15:13.385
<v Ron Zito>As we look at comparable-sized cities across the U.S., that includes Portland, Seattle, for instance, Phoenix, Arizona, on the far left of this chart, with approximately 1.6 million residents, and Orlando, Florida, on the far right, which is close to 400,000.

1034
02:15:13.822 --> 02:15:22.511
<v Ron Zito>The average population here is approximately 740,000, and you can see Portland sits close to the middle of this pack at around 650,000.

1035
02:15:22.865 --> 02:15:23.608
<v Ron Zito>Next slide, please.

1036
02:15:25.447 --> 02:15:31.257
<v Ron Zito>This next slide speaks to total number of employees within those cities, with an average of of 8,150 staff.

1037
02:15:31.914 --> 02:15:41.543
<v Ron Zito>And while this has some very small font, so forgive me, you can probably see Portland is just upper middle of the pack with a seasonal high of approximately 8,786.

1038
02:15:42.168 --> 02:15:43.707
<v Ron Zito>And that does include casual staff.

1039
02:15:44.573 --> 02:15:49.266
<v Ron Zito>That puts us right in line with cities such as San Jose, Charlotte, Columbus, and Atlanta for comparison.

1040
02:15:50.100 --> 02:15:51.990
<v Ron Zito>And then next slide, please.

1041
02:15:53.465 --> 02:16:05.192
<v Ron Zito>And this slide compares total city budget and reveals Portland is most similar to cities such Phoenix and Seattle, but across the group we see an average of about $3.58 billion as a budget.

1042
02:16:05.547 --> 02:16:10.695
<v Ron Zito>And it's probably fair here to say that not every city has the same structure and the same breadth of services.

1043
02:16:11.069 --> 02:16:15.588
<v Ron Zito>Some have separate utilities that they break out or specialty districts, so I just want to call that out as well.

1044
02:16:19.640 --> 02:16:23.818
<v Ron Zito>Finally, this slide reflects the number of deputy city administrators across those cities.

1045
02:16:24.519 --> 02:16:26.417
<v Ron Zito>With the average being 4.7.

1046
02:16:26.627 --> 02:16:31.135
<v Ron Zito>And Portland is again just about middle of the pack with 5 DCA roles.

1047
02:16:32.299 --> 02:16:38.308
<v Ron Zito>Again, as we went out to market on this, other titles might include city manager, assistant city manager, et cetera.

1048
02:16:40.813 --> 02:16:44.718
<v Ron Zito>And then lastly, this— I'm sorry, if we could jump.

1049
02:16:44.847 --> 02:16:45.105
<v Dan Ryan>Yep.

1050
02:16:45.752 --> 02:16:50.204
<v Ron Zito>Lastly, this slide, this chart reflects how many departments report to each DCA position.

1051
02:16:50.254 --> 02:16:50.350
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1052
02:16:50.935 --> 02:16:54.253
<v Ron Zito>And what we see here is an average of 5 departments to 1 DCA.

1053
02:16:55.077 --> 02:17:00.127
<v Ron Zito>This is also the average we see in our city, as well as others such as Charlotte, Oakland, Austin, and Raleigh.

1054
02:17:02.569 --> 02:17:03.816
<v Ron Zito>Jump to the next slide.

1055
02:17:05.172 --> 02:17:15.515
<v Ron Zito>And finally, as it relates to the city's budget, I just want to summarize what we've covered in some of the previous slides, and that is span of control is only one of many factors to consider when assessing organizational efficiency.

1056
02:17:16.527 --> 02:17:29.355
<v Ron Zito>Like I said earlier, there is no one-size-fits-all approach, and as we move through the various realignment efforts taking place in our city, such as core services, engagement, and equity that you heard about earlier, we'll continue to monitor and make adjustments to spans of control.

1057
02:17:30.174 --> 02:17:40.515
<v Ron Zito>And as previously mentioned, our intention is to use data from our non-rep class comp study currently underway to appropriately classify and consolidate positions that do not meet the minimum standard of 4 direct reports.

1058
02:17:40.564 --> 02:17:40.789
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1059
02:17:43.453 --> 02:17:44.449
<v Ron Zito>And next slide, please.

1060
02:17:45.444 --> 02:17:53.764
<v Ron Zito>And in conclusion, as we look at next steps, we have actions already underway such as completing the non-rep class comp study, including director and deputy director positions.

1061
02:17:54.600 --> 02:18:00.189
<v Ron Zito>We also have future actions to consider, such as perhaps developing a citywide administrative guideline for span of control.

1062
02:18:00.863 --> 02:18:07.817
<v Ron Zito>And finally, we have ongoing monitoring that could be beneficial, including publishing span of control metrics periodically as a part of the budget planning process.

1063
02:18:09.588 --> 02:18:13.689
<v Ron Zito>I'm going to take a deep breath there and say I know I moved very quickly through those slides.

1064
02:18:13.753 --> 02:18:18.740
<v Ron Zito>There's a ton of information, but I thank you for your time and allowing me to walk you through this.

1065
02:18:18.853 --> 02:18:22.882
<v Ron Zito>And I think we're going to jump to contracting out before we address questions.

1066
02:18:29.408 --> 02:18:29.859
<v Sylvester>Good morning.

1067
02:18:30.373 --> 02:18:34.227
<v Sylvester>Good morning, Councilor— Council President Dunphy, Council Vice President thank you, Council Vice President Clark.

1068
02:18:34.967 --> 02:18:41.549
<v Sylvester>Mr. Mayor, Mr. City Administrator, community partner, community labor partners, as well as city staff.

1069
02:18:42.657 --> 02:18:55.245
<v Sylvester>Contracting is one of the city's most effective tools in maintaining operational flexibility and agility and meeting our regulatory obligations, our values, and ensuring that we can deliver services to the community without interruption.

1070
02:18:56.081 --> 02:18:56.611
<v Sylvester>Next slide, please.

1071
02:18:59.692 --> 02:19:08.990
<v Sylvester>When used appropriately, contracting strengthens, not substitutes, our workforce by providing targeted support for defined projects and time-limited needs across our bureau spaces.

1072
02:19:09.647 --> 02:19:13.656
<v Sylvester>Across the organization, the city holds multiple different types of contracts.

1073
02:19:13.976 --> 02:19:19.058
<v Sylvester>Today we're focused on just 2 of those services.

1074
02:19:19.411 --> 02:19:21.462
<v Sylvester>There's professional services and design services.

1075
02:19:22.441 --> 02:19:26.846
<v Sylvester>This is a category— these categories are often used to supplement our internal capabilities and needs.

1076
02:19:28.251 --> 02:19:36.296
<v Sylvester>These contracts provide access to expertise and capacity that allows our bureaus to continue delivering services efficiently and effectively.

1077
02:19:37.120 --> 02:19:41.584
<v Sylvester>Examples of professional services includes auditing and technology project support.

1078
02:19:42.231 --> 02:19:45.622
<v Sylvester>Examples of design services includes architectural and engineering work.

1079
02:19:47.246 --> 02:20:06.713
<v Sylvester>Right now, contracting information is dispersed across the decentralized system, detailed are embedded within individual bureaus, limiting our visibility into work that is performed externally and preventing a holistic strategic view of our contracting landscape and also aligning with our values as well as transparency.

1080
02:20:07.790 --> 02:20:19.639
<v Sylvester>As we move forward to a more centralized procurement model, we have significant opportunity to improve oversight, strengthen governance, gain clearer insight into services that the city is relying on external partners to provide.

1081
02:20:20.475 --> 02:20:32.646
<v Sylvester>As we transition into this new model, we will conduct a comprehensive assessment of our existing contracts, develop recommendations to support stronger alignment, strategic decision-making, as well as aligning our values.

1082
02:20:33.560 --> 02:20:42.215
<v Sylvester>Over the last 3 years, our contracting needs have included project management for major technology initiatives, system testing support, and specialized expertise for surge capacity.

1083
02:20:42.280 --> 02:20:55.916
<v Sylvester>Capacity for critical infrastructure projects, illustrating a breadth of work and contracting enabling us to accomplish in service to our community, as well as supporting our grants operations as well and regulations.

1084
02:20:59.459 --> 02:21:00.799
<v Sylvester>These 2— next slide.

1085
02:21:01.123 --> 02:21:01.316
<v Ron Zito>Sorry.

1086
02:21:03.111 --> 02:21:07.715
<v Sylvester>These 2 line graphs show 3 years of trend data for professional services and design services.

1087
02:21:08.488 --> 02:21:15.765
<v Sylvester>On the left, you see year-over-year decline in total contracted amounts for professional service and design— professional and design services.

1088
02:21:15.927 --> 02:21:20.933
<v Sylvester>On the right, you see the corresponding decline in payments made for work performed under those contracts.

1089
02:21:21.965 --> 02:21:27.593
<v Sylvester>Together, these trends show a significant reduction in the city's use of professional and design services over the past 3 years.

1090
02:21:28.915 --> 02:21:29.349
<v Sylvester>Next slide.

1091
02:21:32.471 --> 02:21:32.890
<v Sylvester>Slide 4.

1092
02:21:33.917 --> 02:21:40.195
<v Sylvester>This slide shows aggregated contracting data for professional services and design services over the same 3-year period.

1093
02:21:40.596 --> 02:21:42.218
<v Sylvester>On the left, you see the total contracted amounts.

1094
02:21:42.282 --> 02:21:44.386
<v Sylvester>On the right, total payments for work performed.

1095
02:21:45.013 --> 02:21:53.009
<v Sylvester>For professional services, the city contracted $230.1 million and paid $86.6 million over 3 years.

1096
02:21:53.907 --> 02:22:00.843
<v Sylvester>For design services, the city contracted for $123.1 million and paid $20.8 million.

1097
02:22:01.453 --> 02:22:12.575
<v Sylvester>Contracted amounts represents the maximum authorized value of a multi-year not-to-exceed agreement, while payments reflect only the work actually completed and is invoiced as well.

1098
02:22:13.121 --> 02:22:17.952
<v Sylvester>It is normal and appropriate for these payments to be significantly lower than the total contracted amount.

1099
02:22:18.868 --> 02:22:21.371
<v Sylvester>Next slide.

1100
02:22:22.558 --> 02:22:33.611
<v Sylvester>Allowable contracting for professional services before you, you'll see a list of the allowed categories of examples that consist— constitutes the allowable use of contracting.

1101
02:22:34.268 --> 02:22:40.699
<v Sylvester>This contracting for outside services is limited both by the state rules, example given Oregon Forward, and the city's labor agreements.

1102
02:22:40.876 --> 02:22:45.638
<v Sylvester>It is governed by clear requirements, and we use it only when it's allowable and appropriate.

1103
02:22:46.858 --> 02:23:06.459
<v Sylvester>These categories outlined in the slide represent the most common allowable reasons for engaging in external support for the city's labor agreements includes cost savings, emergencies, statutory requirements, extreme risk, capital projects, warranty work, proprietary systems, urgent need, limited scope work, peak load staffing, as well as grant alignment.

1104
02:23:07.084 --> 02:23:10.625
<v Sylvester>It is important to note that not all labor agreements allow for services listed here.

1105
02:23:11.538 --> 02:23:14.743
<v Sylvester>Reference would be AFSCME labor agreement Section 6.3.

1106
02:23:15.720 --> 02:23:15.944
<v Sylvester>Next slide.

1107
02:23:20.925 --> 02:23:29.265
<v Sylvester>Contracting supports multiple core operational needs for the city, particularly in areas where capacity— internal capacity cannot reasonably flex to meet that demand.

1108
02:23:29.843 --> 02:23:34.295
<v Sylvester>For capital projects, staffing needs significantly shift throughout the construction cycles.

1109
02:23:34.601 --> 02:23:40.031
<v Sylvester>There are moments when we simply need more inspectors, engineers, technical support than we can maintain as permanent staff.

1110
02:23:40.932 --> 02:24:03.708
<v Sylvester>We also rely on contracting to access specialized technology skills, technical skills, and expertise the city needs only intermittently, that are only intermittently, such as cybersecurity, SAP development, financial advising, geotechnical support, and/or targeted legal support, highly specialized and not required for full-time levels.

1111
02:24:05.266 --> 02:24:13.832
<v Sylvester>Finally, Certain work is regulatory and compliance-driven and must be performed by certified external providers or independent evaluators.

1112
02:24:14.265 --> 02:24:19.902
<v Sylvester>Examples include assessments, background checks, right-of-way acquisition, professional appraisals.

1113
02:24:20.207 --> 02:24:25.875
<v Sylvester>In these cases, contracting is not just practical, it is required to meet legal and regulatory obligations.

1114
02:24:26.565 --> 02:24:48.568
<v Sylvester>Examples: capital— not just about capital project works— specialized technology, experience specialized technology systems development and evaluation, specifically the SLAMTECH assessment for PCEF, regulatory compliance-driven auditing outside, for example Moss Adams, and our requirements, requirements as it relates to our annual audit.

1115
02:24:49.495 --> 02:24:52.159
<v Sylvester>Next slide.

1116
02:24:52.661 --> 02:24:56.438
<v Sylvester>Community partnerships, community partnerships and temporary staffing.

1117
02:24:56.793 --> 02:25:04.612
<v Sylvester>Some of our contracted services reflect longstanding community partnership delivery models that are central on how the city engages with the public.

1118
02:25:04.773 --> 02:25:13.900
<v Sylvester>These include— related to these, these works include public space management, arts and culture, community outreach, and the stewardship of natural areas.

1119
02:25:14.257 --> 02:25:18.924
<v Sylvester>These are mission-aligned collaborations designed to extend the city's reach in the community.

1120
02:25:20.590 --> 02:25:24.379
<v Sylvester>Finally, as we use contracting in a limited way to meet temporary or thank you.

1121
02:25:24.379 --> 02:25:24.379
<v Sylvester>Next, we have the temporary staffing ordinance.

1122
02:25:24.379 --> 02:25:25.700
<v Sylvester>This ordinance provides for transitional staffing needs.

1123
02:25:25.700 --> 02:25:35.420
<v Sylvester>These include short-term support during major system rollouts, emergency backup staffing to ensure continuity of operations, project-specific administrative support.

1124
02:25:35.420 --> 02:25:46.510
<v Sylvester>In these instances, they are intentionally time-bound and to provide targeted capacity when internal staffing is not immediately available or when need is too short-term to justify a permanent position.

1125
02:25:47.139 --> 02:26:03.640
<v Sylvester>Example, community partnerships, BES watershed agreements, temporary transitional staffing, DPI staffing contracts, as well as Oregon Forward agreements that work primarily— it goes individuals with disabilities as well.

1126
02:26:04.610 --> 02:26:05.075
<v Sylvester>Next slide.

1127
02:26:08.320 --> 02:26:10.472
<v Sylvester>Contracting and good— with good governance.

1128
02:26:11.292 --> 02:26:20.599
<v Sylvester>As I outlined how contracting is strategic tool enabling the city to remain flexible, meet the regulatory obligations, as well as delivering services effectively.

1129
02:26:21.337 --> 02:26:30.956
<v Sylvester>When governed well, it strengthens, not replaces, our workforce by ensuring continuity across bureaus while operating within established rules, agreements, statutory requirements, and our values.

1130
02:26:31.934 --> 02:26:43.936
<v Sylvester>Effective governance begins with clarity of authority, roles, decision rights, and clearly defined responsibilities consistently applied and accountability sits at the appropriate leadership level.

1131
02:26:44.584 --> 02:26:51.011
<v Sylvester>Strong contracting governance also ensures alignment with labor agreements, procurement policies, legal requirements, and again, our values.

1132
02:26:51.864 --> 02:26:57.537
<v Sylvester>It supports cross-bureau collaboration, promotes transparency, reduces the risk of delays, disputes, or rework.

1133
02:26:58.135 --> 02:27:18.579
<v Sylvester>Standardized processing, common templates, workflows, approval pathways make contracting predictable scalable, while performance and oversight ensures contractors are delivering against— delivering against expectations through metrics, reviews, data-driven decisions against time, terms, and conditions.

1134
02:27:19.646 --> 02:27:28.590
<v Sylvester>In our next slide, contracting upward processing process improvements.

1135
02:27:29.622 --> 02:27:32.703
<v Sylvester>In our future state, post-COVID-19, service realignment.

1136
02:27:32.784 --> 02:27:46.513
<v Sylvester>Contracting will be realigned to support, to support fully the city's core services model, creating a more centralized, transparent, strategically managed system in alignment with our values and community requirements.

1137
02:27:46.995 --> 02:27:57.158
<v Sylvester>By consolidating authorities, standardizing processes, strengthening across-bureau coordination, we will gain a clearer oversight of contracted work and ensure it directly reinforces our operational priorities.

1138
02:27:57.674 --> 02:28:08.984
<v Sylvester>This realignment will enable us to deploy contracting more intentionally, focusing on essential expertise, compliance-driven needs, flexible capacity, while maintaining strong governance and workforce alignment.

1139
02:28:09.547 --> 02:28:16.204
<v Sylvester>Together, these changes position the city to operate with greater consistency, accountability, and long-term effectiveness.

1140
02:28:18.640 --> 02:28:19.911
<v Sylvester>That concludes my presentation.

1141
02:28:22.484 --> 02:28:22.792
<v Sylvester>Thank you.

1142
02:28:22.959 --> 02:28:23.618
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all.

1143
02:28:26.780 --> 02:28:28.557
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now we're going to jump into questions, colleagues.

1144
02:28:28.654 --> 02:28:31.334
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have about 37 minutes left.

1145
02:28:31.900 --> 02:28:32.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, take us on.

1146
02:28:33.399 --> 02:28:35.022
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1147
02:28:35.102 --> 02:28:36.291
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for the presentation.

1148
02:28:36.950 --> 02:28:44.671
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I wanted to say I really like the idea of using organizational layers as a thing we look at, but not necessarily something to use as a goal.

1149
02:28:45.353 --> 02:28:55.069
<v Sameer Kanal>And what I mean by that is I think degrees of separation is a maybe better way of of thinking about it where CA Lee is 1 and everybody that reports to him is 2.

1150
02:28:55.213 --> 02:28:58.772
<v Sameer Kanal>And that can mean his EA or a DCA, right?

1151
02:28:58.902 --> 02:29:00.648
<v Sameer Kanal>And we're looking at how many layers we've got.

1152
02:29:00.728 --> 02:29:06.886
<v Sameer Kanal>I think 1 through 9 seems like a lot, but it's actually more if the DCAs and CA are both in layer 1.

1153
02:29:07.783 --> 02:29:09.852
<v Sameer Kanal>And there's— I understand why police is different.

1154
02:29:10.028 --> 02:29:14.790
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not sure why fire isn't also different, but I do get that.

1155
02:29:14.997 --> 02:29:18.076
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd love to see the direct report number because I think that illustrates it.

1156
02:29:18.125 --> 02:29:38.240
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor there are people— I've been in a role, and I've related to roles where much of our time we're paying a city employee to manage contracts to do work that might actually just— I'm thinking in the engagement space where you're managing a couple contracts to do engagement work that one could do themselves.

1157
02:29:39.620 --> 02:29:41.081
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's not a full-time FD.

1158
02:29:41.145 --> 02:29:42.155
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not a 1-to-1 ratio.

1159
02:29:42.203 --> 02:29:44.995
<v Sameer Kanal>It might be 1 to 0.5, but I just wanted to flag that.

1160
02:29:45.042 --> 02:29:45.138
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

1161
02:29:45.236 --> 02:29:47.274
<v Sameer Kanal>And we'll get to that.

1162
02:29:47.338 --> 02:29:52.959
<v Sameer Kanal>But in the— in the— some of those roles have a supervisory component too, and that's why it's related to this.

1163
02:29:53.360 --> 02:29:58.370
<v Sameer Kanal>Just trying to understand how we can— I'm using degrees of separation as sort of a colloquial term.

1164
02:29:58.417 --> 02:30:00.585
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm sure there's a corporate speak word for it somewhere.

1165
02:30:00.665 --> 02:30:03.202
<v Sameer Kanal>But, uh, yeah, something that, that does that.

1166
02:30:03.251 --> 02:30:05.611
<v Sameer Kanal>Does that make sense in terms of like framing?

1167
02:30:06.542 --> 02:30:07.569
<v Ron Zito>It does, Councilor, yes.

1168
02:30:08.212 --> 02:30:10.684
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, because you can actually see that in the address.

1169
02:30:11.343 --> 02:30:11.922
<v Sameer Kanal>Book.

1170
02:30:11.986 --> 02:30:16.879
<v Sameer Kanal>Like, you can actually go to somebody in the address book on our systems and see who they report to, who they report through.

1171
02:30:16.977 --> 02:30:20.164
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's also easier for us to just quickly find that information.

1172
02:30:20.599 --> 02:30:23.898
<v Sameer Kanal>And that, I think we could get to a goal of saying this should be X number.

1173
02:30:24.204 --> 02:30:25.252
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not sure what it should be.

1174
02:30:26.395 --> 02:30:28.262
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to speak candidly about this.

1175
02:30:28.326 --> 02:30:29.292
<v Sameer Kanal>I was an Analyst 3.

1176
02:30:29.694 --> 02:30:31.911
<v Sameer Kanal>In 2022, I was promoted to a Manager 1.

1177
02:30:34.137 --> 02:30:37.498
<v Sameer Kanal>I should probably have not been a manager.

1178
02:30:37.564 --> 02:30:38.555
<v Sameer Kanal>I should have probably been a supervisor.

1179
02:30:38.602 --> 02:30:38.667
<v Sylvester>Yeah.

1180
02:30:40.959 --> 02:30:44.889
<v Sameer Kanal>Supervisor 2 is the same pay scale as a Manager 1, so I'm not sure that it would have made a financial difference.

1181
02:30:46.469 --> 02:30:52.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Kind of like analyst and coordinator, there's one rung apart on the ladder, and, you know, 2 is a 1 here, or 3 is a 2.

1182
02:30:52.069 --> 02:31:01.930
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do think that evaluating that is important, and we've often erred on the side of when there's a disparity, just taking it up to the higher point.

1183
02:31:02.829 --> 02:31:07.489
<v Sameer Kanal>So if there's a— as we consolidate, if there's an Analyst 3 doing the same thing as an Analyst 2, then we're going to go with 2 the higher point.

1184
02:31:07.638 --> 02:31:10.951
<v Sameer Kanal>Over here, we would never consider taking the Analyst 3 down to a 2.

1185
02:31:11.031 --> 02:31:12.615
<v Sameer Kanal>We would take the 2 and put it up to a 3.

1186
02:31:12.665 --> 02:31:17.703
<v Sameer Kanal>And I get why, but I think it's worth, uh, considering as we, as we talk about this from a—.

1187
02:31:18.906 --> 02:31:19.134
<v Sylvester>The—.

1188
02:31:19.557 --> 02:31:22.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Especially on the management level, but I think it applies everywhere.

1189
02:31:22.841 --> 02:31:32.378
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, is the statement that there are 5 DCAs an acknowledgement that Portland Solutions is a service area and that Skyler Brocker Knapp is effectively a DCA?

1190
02:31:33.326 --> 02:31:38.165
<v Sameer Kanal>Or on the other hand, is it a forward-looking anticipation that the ACA will be a DCA if we approve that position?

1191
02:31:38.647 --> 02:31:41.476
<v Sameer Kanal>We have 4 DCAs, uh, currently listed.

1192
02:31:41.523 --> 02:31:47.315
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's including our CFO, uh, because of the classification level is at the DCA level.

1193
02:31:47.813 --> 02:31:48.521
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, CFO.

1194
02:31:49.180 --> 02:32:02.245
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, if we were to bring back the ACA position, I believe before it was not classed at the same level as the DCAs, and it was classed a little lower than that.

1195
02:32:02.967 --> 02:32:06.947
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe, and I'll have you correct, I believe it was classed at the same level as the DCAs.

1196
02:32:07.380 --> 02:32:08.166
<v Tracy Warren>That's correct, it was.

1197
02:32:08.279 --> 02:32:09.899
<v Sameer Kanal>And it would be again if it's brought back now?

1198
02:32:10.045 --> 02:32:10.541
<v Tracy Warren>That's correct.

1199
02:32:10.671 --> 02:32:10.846
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1200
02:32:11.954 --> 02:32:31.393
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, just again wanted to note before I move on to contracts, we again never asked for a study in Canal 8 just to reduce the expense on deputy directors and directors, while noting of course that every bureau needs a director and the only role on that side is 1 versus 2 versus 3, but that some bureaus don't need deputy directors at all in addition to the 1 versus 2 versus 3.

1201
02:32:32.436 --> 02:32:34.363
<v Sameer Kanal>Moving to contracts, thank you so much for that.

1202
02:32:35.166 --> 02:32:50.420
<v Sameer Kanal>And I really wanted to commend you as someone who's been talking for over 2 years about— actually longer than that— about the need to reduce professional services contracts specifically, which is not a perfect analog, but very similar to the way I've framed it of contracts where we pay people to think for us.

1203
02:32:50.902 --> 02:32:52.873
<v Sameer Kanal>Versus contracts where we pay people to do for us.

1204
02:32:52.986 --> 02:32:58.612
<v Sameer Kanal>We don't own a construction company yet, but until then, we're going to need to pay people to build things.

1205
02:32:58.676 --> 02:33:01.771
<v Sameer Kanal>But the thinking side has always been kind of frustrating.

1206
02:33:01.818 --> 02:33:06.115
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to commend you for that reduction.

1207
02:33:06.195 --> 02:33:08.712
<v Sameer Kanal>That was more stark than I had anticipated.

1208
02:33:08.761 --> 02:33:10.781
<v Sameer Kanal>So wanted to start with that.

1209
02:33:11.278 --> 02:33:11.967
<v Elise Rosenberg>Thank you.

1210
02:33:12.143 --> 02:33:15.220
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to ask about the project management side as well.

1211
02:33:16.623 --> 02:33:22.549
<v Sameer Kanal>And just see, you know, we have this, we have project managers at the city.

1212
02:33:22.727 --> 02:33:25.496
<v Sameer Kanal>And so is that a focus area for you?

1213
02:33:25.560 --> 02:33:36.691
<v Sameer Kanal>Do you have focus areas in terms of the subcategories of the, I think it's 538,000 or whatever that code is, that professional services, like there's subcategories under it though.

1214
02:33:36.963 --> 02:33:37.558
<v Sylvester>There are.

1215
02:33:38.074 --> 02:33:45.021
<v Sylvester>And I would, with the project management, management series, in terms of speaking to that, it's more of a personnel space.

1216
02:33:45.518 --> 02:34:06.022
<v Sylvester>I would rather not speak for the entire organization, but we'll say that I will monitor that more with the centralization and also have those kinds of conversations with my counterparts at the director level, but also having those conversations probably with the DCAs as well in terms of how does that work in terms of future leaning.

1217
02:34:06.327 --> 02:34:24.379
<v Sylvester>I've actually engaged my So we're working to kind of give more transparency as we're centralizing.

1218
02:34:24.379 --> 02:34:29.840
<v Sylvester>We'll be able to give you those types of numbers at that level, the project management level, or even others as well.

1219
02:34:29.840 --> 02:34:32.600
<v Sylvester>So we're working on that in terms of giving you business intelligence.

1220
02:34:32.659 --> 02:34:33.200
<v Sylvester>I recognize that's I'd not necessarily rather what you're asking for, but not that's what we're just working on.

1221
02:34:33.200 --> 02:34:33.239
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1222
02:34:33.301 --> 02:34:36.398
<v Sylvester>Say data because it's business intelligence for you to make business decisions.

1223
02:34:37.457 --> 02:34:38.628
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, I appreciate that.

1224
02:34:39.077 --> 02:34:40.056
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor, you're at 6 minutes.

1225
02:34:40.361 --> 02:34:44.515
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I'll just make the wrap-up comment here and then I have a question for later.

1226
02:34:44.675 --> 02:35:03.043
<v Sameer Kanal>The, um, I had a position, I had a function that I needed to do when I was at the Portland building where we had a court that told us we needed to increase our capacity and we had the money to do it, but we were not given the position authority to do it, uh, for 3 years, and we contracted it out.

1227
02:35:03.604 --> 02:35:10.806
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and we got— it was the same amount of money because that's the budget we had, but we would— we got less service as a result for contracting it out than we would have otherwise.

1228
02:35:11.462 --> 02:35:15.152
<v Sameer Kanal>And, uh, it was the old mayor's office that was preventing us from doing that.

1229
02:35:15.487 --> 02:35:20.042
<v Sameer Kanal>And on day one, uh, Mayor Wilson let that position get created.

1230
02:35:20.122 --> 02:35:22.576
<v Sameer Kanal>It took a while to get filled, but day one he fixed that problem.

1231
02:35:22.640 --> 02:35:24.516
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I really want to commend you for that again.

1232
02:35:25.174 --> 02:35:33.424
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, But I wanted to indicate how the hiring freeze and the position authority conversations often force contracting.

1233
02:35:34.082 --> 02:35:45.316
<v Sameer Kanal>And because you can put the money in EMS more easily and then use it for contracting out some of the work when you can't get the position authority or you have the position authority, but you're not allowed to hire it.

1234
02:35:45.733 --> 02:35:48.380
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just wanted to flag that as a thing to consider.

1235
02:35:48.701 --> 02:35:49.407
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks, Council President.

1236
02:35:49.665 --> 02:35:50.772
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Councilor Kanal.

1237
02:35:51.093 --> 02:35:51.575
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1238
02:35:52.393 --> 02:35:53.773
<v Mitch Green>Thanks, Council President.

1239
02:35:53.903 --> 02:35:56.102
<v Mitch Green>Um, just want to be mindful of my time.

1240
02:35:56.166 --> 02:35:57.836
<v Mitch Green>I'm setting my stopwatch here.

1241
02:35:58.076 --> 02:36:02.557
<v Mitch Green>Um, so appreciate the span of control discussion.

1242
02:36:03.632 --> 02:36:03.648
<v Elise Rosenberg>I—.

1243
02:36:03.777 --> 02:36:06.539
<v Mitch Green>The, the report that was sent out ahead was— is very useful.

1244
02:36:06.907 --> 02:36:08.081
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that thinking.

1245
02:36:08.129 --> 02:36:22.772
<v Mitch Green>So the first question I have is, the proposed budget that we're considering, um, the data that's in this— in, in the span of control document, does that analyze the city as it was in April, or does it also have these proposed changes in it?

1246
02:36:23.768 --> 02:36:33.674
<v Tracy Warren>No, it's, it's the time and place in April, so it does not include the considerations that you all are making.

1247
02:36:34.364 --> 02:36:35.488
<v Mitch Green>Got it, that's helpful.

1248
02:36:35.649 --> 02:36:41.317
<v Mitch Green>Um, my second question, I want to go back to the sort of different levels of hierarchy conversation.

1249
02:36:41.671 --> 02:36:49.467
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm kind of struck by this idea that the DCAs are in the same level as the city administrator.

1250
02:36:50.092 --> 02:37:01.495
<v Mitch Green>Typically, the way I think about an org chart is your C-suite has your chief executive, then you've got, you know, your CFO, your chief operating officer, you've got, you know, some of those folks.

1251
02:37:02.617 --> 02:37:09.079
<v Mitch Green>But the way that we've constructed it with these DCAs and these service areas seems to be that those are executive vice presidents of a particular function of the city.

1252
02:37:11.040 --> 02:37:18.471
<v Mitch Green>When you pulled Jonas out and made him a CFO and put him up at that level, that to me was moving him to level 1 of the organization and out of level 2.

1253
02:37:19.102 --> 02:37:24.347
<v Mitch Green>And so I kind of pushed back, and I don't, I don't think the DCAs are in level 1.

1254
02:37:24.413 --> 02:37:29.877
<v Mitch Green>I think they're in level 2 of the organization, and I think most people would probably agree with that.

1255
02:37:31.356 --> 02:37:35.674
<v Mitch Green>Then from there, you've got bureau directors, And then deputy directors.

1256
02:37:36.031 --> 02:37:38.603
<v Mitch Green>So that's 2 more layers.

1257
02:37:40.541 --> 02:37:47.261
<v Mitch Green>And then I think manager 3 is where you get your first executive management classification.

1258
02:37:49.128 --> 02:37:55.680
<v Mitch Green>So to me, that's like, that's 4 layers of executive leadership below the CEO.

1259
02:37:56.067 --> 02:37:58.584
<v Mitch Green>Is that— am I missing something?

1260
02:37:59.084 --> 02:38:00.774
<v Ron Zito>No, Councilor, I think you're correct.

1261
02:38:01.403 --> 02:38:18.628
<v Ron Zito>I do think going back to Councilor Kanal's degrees of separation is kind of a nice that's a nice way to look at it, and it could be degrees of separation from the community, from a council, from the CA, or from how we did in this report, a bucket of executive leadership which includes CA plus the DCA.

1262
02:38:18.708 --> 02:38:24.129
<v Ron Zito>So I think there's probably room to make arguments either way of what layer is 1 versus layer 2.

1263
02:38:24.770 --> 02:38:29.131
<v Mitch Green>But that's, that's good to hear because I think it's a little more fluid than, than that.

1264
02:38:29.260 --> 02:38:30.254
<v Mitch Green>Um, thank you.

1265
02:38:30.703 --> 02:38:36.176
<v Mitch Green>So if I were to look at I've got just in the Bureau of Human Resources is just a sort of entry point here.

1266
02:38:37.194 --> 02:38:49.284
<v Mitch Green>Just as there's a total of 115 positions in the proposed, and there's one Director II, that's probably your position because DCA Warren's in an interim DCA role.

1267
02:38:51.709 --> 02:39:03.549
<v Mitch Green>And so they've got— I've got a Director II, there's a manager— there's one Manager III, one manager— no, you know, 7 Manager 2s, 3 Manager 1s, and an Analyst 4.

1268
02:39:05.436 --> 02:39:14.944
<v Mitch Green>Is the span of control the director, and then under that, that is a Manager 3 who then manages the, the 2s, or are they all pointing to the director independently?

1269
02:39:16.299 --> 02:39:18.684
<v Ron Zito>Currently, the Manager 3 position is vacant.

1270
02:39:20.260 --> 02:39:23.953
<v Ron Zito>Director 2 that I sit in as an interim today has 12 direct reports.

1271
02:39:24.792 --> 02:39:31.495
<v Ron Zito>Those direct reports are a mix of administrative support staff as well as managerial staff that oversee functional areas.

1272
02:39:31.768 --> 02:39:33.370
<v Mitch Green>That's helpful.

1273
02:39:34.156 --> 02:39:37.988
<v Mitch Green>And if you were to click into some of the functional areas, I'm looking at employee and labor relations.

1274
02:39:38.726 --> 02:39:41.819
<v Mitch Green>There are 3 manager 2s, 2 manager 1s.

1275
02:39:42.445 --> 02:39:46.358
<v Mitch Green>So do all of those managers report directly to you?

1276
02:39:47.463 --> 02:39:50.093
<v Ron Zito>No, there's a senior manager for employee relations.

1277
02:39:50.445 --> 02:39:52.674
<v Ron Zito>There's also a labor relations manager.

1278
02:39:53.013 --> 02:39:54.870
<v Ron Zito>2 Roles do point into myself.

1279
02:39:55.359 --> 02:40:01.570
<v Ron Zito>I would say that labor relations and employee relations, probably some of the more complex work within our bureau.

1280
02:40:02.119 --> 02:40:05.248
<v Ron Zito>And so therefore, the span of controls there are pretty narrow.

1281
02:40:07.397 --> 02:40:08.235
<v Mitch Green>I understand that.

1282
02:40:08.282 --> 02:40:10.569
<v Mitch Green>I just— I think I'm running out of time here.

1283
02:40:11.826 --> 02:40:15.967
<v Mitch Green>And I raised some of these concerns in the earlier part of the presentation.

1284
02:40:16.014 --> 02:40:25.579
<v Mitch Green>But, you know, when I was at the Bonneville Power Administration, which is a federal institution, not a you had 3 tiers of management.

1285
02:40:25.579 --> 02:40:33.479
<v Mitch Green>You had the administrator, and then you had the executive vice presidents, and then you had the managers.

1286
02:40:34.579 --> 02:40:41.639
<v Mitch Green>I was a non-supervisory GS-14 because I did very complex region-wide work for rate setting.

1287
02:40:41.639 --> 02:40:42.930
<v Mitch Green>I was paid the same as my manager.

1288
02:40:43.760 --> 02:40:47.260
<v Mitch Green>And so I think what we've got in our city is we've got a structure where it's like we've created these roles that are not really real.

1289
02:40:47.260 --> 02:40:47.379
<v Olivia Clark>I think that's a good point.

1290
02:40:47.506 --> 02:40:51.750
<v Mitch Green>Because you need to pay that person more than the people they supervise.

1291
02:40:52.505 --> 02:41:00.045
<v Mitch Green>And with 9 layers of levels in the organization, we've ended up with 33 Manager 3s across the entire city.

1292
02:41:01.350 --> 02:41:01.591
<v Sameer Kanal>Manager 3s.

1293
02:41:01.638 --> 02:41:02.281
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, Manager 3s.

1294
02:41:02.522 --> 02:41:08.595
<v Mitch Green>So that's 33 executives before you even get into directors and deputy directors and deputy city administrators and the like.

1295
02:41:08.708 --> 02:41:18.817
<v Mitch Green>And so as we're looking at the budget choices we've made, you know, we're We're closing down a fire engine to keep 33 executives before you get into bureau directors.

1296
02:41:19.091 --> 02:41:23.504
<v Mitch Green>And I just kind of think that that's a challenge for me in this budget.

1297
02:41:23.648 --> 02:41:25.527
<v Mitch Green>I'm out of time, so I'll leave it there.

1298
02:41:26.458 --> 02:41:27.244
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1299
02:41:27.596 --> 02:41:28.207
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1300
02:41:29.362 --> 02:41:33.279
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

1301
02:41:33.520 --> 02:41:35.735
<v Dan Ryan>My questions are going to be focused on span and control.

1302
02:41:36.344 --> 02:41:37.820
<v Dan Ryan>And so, yeah.

1303
02:41:38.832 --> 02:41:41.639
<v Dan Ryan>When you say bureaus, you mean bureaus and offices, right?

1304
02:41:42.024 --> 02:41:42.746
<v Ron Zito>That's correct, Councilor.

1305
02:41:42.795 --> 02:41:43.066
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1306
02:41:43.164 --> 02:41:46.180
<v Dan Ryan>And what is the total of bureaus plus offices?

1307
02:41:47.639 --> 02:41:50.061
<v Dan Ryan>Some people say 25, some people say 28.

1308
02:41:50.222 --> 02:41:53.478
<v Dan Ryan>I say 27 because I say something in between.

1309
02:41:54.217 --> 02:41:55.260
<v Dan Ryan>I've literally tried to count.

1310
02:41:56.157 --> 02:42:00.297
<v Ron Zito>I don't want to misspeak, but typically in the past we've referred to 26 bureaus.

1311
02:42:00.729 --> 02:42:01.308
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I'd want to—.

1312
02:42:01.308 --> 02:42:02.927
<v Dan Ryan>Let's use that as a working definition.

1313
02:42:03.200 --> 02:42:03.378
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1314
02:42:04.645 --> 02:42:04.805
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1315
02:42:05.311 --> 02:42:12.663
<v Dan Ryan>And I think it's important that we say bureaus/offices, because when we're in this conversation of span and control, there's differences when you look at the two.

1316
02:42:13.325 --> 02:42:19.197
<v Dan Ryan>A big bureau like Parks has more supervisors, probably more coaches on the ground.

1317
02:42:19.879 --> 02:42:25.031
<v Dan Ryan>And so I just think that it gets— it's minor, but I think it's important that we get consistency on that.

1318
02:42:26.406 --> 02:42:31.629
<v Dan Ryan>And when you speak of reporting relationships, which I think of span and control as how many people you're responsible for.

1319
02:42:31.677 --> 02:42:32.593
<v Dan Ryan>How many people do you coach?

1320
02:42:32.641 --> 02:42:33.701
<v Dan Ryan>How many people do you care for?

1321
02:42:33.765 --> 02:42:36.272
<v Dan Ryan>How many people are you supervising, advocating for?

1322
02:42:36.898 --> 02:42:42.263
<v Dan Ryan>Um, do you take into consideration those who staff volunteers from commissions and advisory boards?

1323
02:42:43.484 --> 02:42:45.235
<v Ron Zito>We do not, not in this report, Councilor.

1324
02:42:45.684 --> 02:42:47.595
<v Dan Ryan>Ooh, let's let that settle for a second.

1325
02:42:48.141 --> 02:42:58.950
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, in my career I've done a lot of, um, staffing of boards, um, people who are really busy that expect a lot of professional service.

1326
02:43:00.186 --> 02:43:03.718
<v Dan Ryan>And it takes a lot of time, and you got to do it right.

1327
02:43:04.377 --> 02:43:14.106
<v Dan Ryan>And I think sometimes culturally we have a challenge at the city because we, we have so many of these, which we know we're trying to figure out the efficiency there as well.

1328
02:43:14.958 --> 02:43:25.550
<v Dan Ryan>But that's a high-level service that you're providing when you're stewarding volunteers, whether it's at the commission and supervisory or at the advisory level.

1329
02:43:26.289 --> 02:43:33.231
<v Dan Ryan>But then I also think we have to have conversations about those, like say in parks, that have volunteers that want to help maintain nature trails.

1330
02:43:33.969 --> 02:43:35.397
<v Dan Ryan>That's also a responsibility.

1331
02:43:35.909 --> 02:43:43.093
<v Dan Ryan>When I say I want us to engage more volunteers, I don't say that to say that we're going to replace them with workers.

1332
02:43:43.702 --> 02:43:53.218
<v Dan Ryan>I'm saying that we're expanding our impact because we have employees who have the skill sets to to help manage and supervise and coach those volunteers.

1333
02:43:54.041 --> 02:43:59.292
<v Dan Ryan>So I hope that that becomes part of the equation as you continue to do this work.

1334
02:44:00.870 --> 02:44:05.111
<v Dan Ryan>The comparable city charts, I think, get us in trouble, and you've tried to explain that.

1335
02:44:05.498 --> 02:44:07.506
<v Dan Ryan>The apples and oranges are tough to define.

1336
02:44:08.425 --> 02:44:12.075
<v Dan Ryan>And are all the ones listed, the 12, are they separate from county?

1337
02:44:12.138 --> 02:44:14.518
<v Dan Ryan>Is it city only, not city and county?

1338
02:44:14.854 --> 02:44:19.914
<v Dan Ryan>I noticed San Francisco wasn't included unless I could I didn't see it, but they are merged, the city and the county?

1339
02:44:21.756 --> 02:44:23.227
<v Ron Zito>Yes, I'd have to look close.

1340
02:44:23.549 --> 02:44:24.083
<v Ron Zito>Are they all cities?

1341
02:44:24.761 --> 02:44:27.038
<v Dan Ryan>They're all city purely, not city-county?

1342
02:44:27.731 --> 02:44:28.492
<v Tracy Warren>That's correct.

1343
02:44:28.700 --> 02:44:30.947
<v Tracy Warren>Well, they're, they're all cities.

1344
02:44:32.014 --> 02:44:34.229
<v Tracy Warren>I don't know if some of them have a county structure.

1345
02:44:34.844 --> 02:44:46.236
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, it would be interesting to do that as well, then look at the ones that are merged, and then take City of Portland and Multnomah County and look at our combined budget and those that are similar scope that are merged.

1346
02:44:46.444 --> 02:44:47.542
<v Dan Ryan>I'm a big fan of merger.

1347
02:44:47.704 --> 02:44:49.463
<v Dan Ryan>Just thought I'd say that for the 100th time.

1348
02:44:53.010 --> 02:44:55.914
<v Dan Ryan>I also think that the way we talk about our budget gets us in trouble.

1349
02:44:56.317 --> 02:45:03.271
<v Dan Ryan>When you go out in the community and they have every right to say it's an $8.6 billion budget, because all they have to do is Google and AI tells them that.

1350
02:45:05.382 --> 02:45:08.090
<v Dan Ryan>But I ask them to know that we're talking about our general fund.

1351
02:45:08.685 --> 02:45:10.908
<v Dan Ryan>Like, our engagement with them right now is about our general fund.

1352
02:45:11.375 --> 02:45:13.316
<v Dan Ryan>And that's so much less, right?

1353
02:45:13.736 --> 02:45:20.076
<v Dan Ryan>It's roughly, what is it, $806 million was the last time I saw a number that kept being repeated.

1354
02:45:21.899 --> 02:45:35.873
<v Dan Ryan>I wonder in the comparison here where we really stick out, if those, like in other cities that are of comparable size, let's say Oklahoma City, I wonder if they take out those utilities that are separate.

1355
02:45:35.922 --> 02:45:35.986
<v Amanda Garcia-Snell>Yeah.

1356
02:45:37.898 --> 02:45:44.763
<v Dan Ryan>And I know there's like an accountant will give me a really long like interpretation of why the legality of that.

1357
02:45:45.957 --> 02:45:55.638
<v Dan Ryan>It doesn't translate to your average human being that's trying to understand what we do and have, I think, some pretty extreme complaints about us because of the way we report this.

1358
02:45:58.010 --> 02:45:58.851
<v Ron Zito>I would agree, Councilor.

1359
02:45:58.915 --> 02:46:01.877
<v Ron Zito>I think this was a preliminary look at some comparable cities.

1360
02:46:02.298 --> 02:46:04.097
<v Ron Zito>Now that we're living into this new structure.

1361
02:46:04.434 --> 02:46:14.537
<v Ron Zito>I do think there's more work and analysis to be done, particularly on the granularity that you called out in terms of county versus county and city and some of how they break out their work.

1362
02:46:14.617 --> 02:46:18.352
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, we just get beat up when we go out in the community and they look at a chart like this.

1363
02:46:18.850 --> 02:46:22.715
<v Dan Ryan>And then I don't have enough to counter all their arguments.

1364
02:46:22.795 --> 02:46:32.313
<v Dan Ryan>I do have enough to say, well, our general fund is this, and it does calm people down a bit and they're ready to listen and not just show up to attack the fact that we have a bloated budget compared to others.

1365
02:46:33.069 --> 02:46:41.297
<v Dan Ryan>But I don't know if we're translating this very well from a communication standpoint to people who are trying to lean in and understand how we do our work.

1366
02:46:41.963 --> 02:46:42.680
<v Ron Zito>Appreciate it.

1367
02:46:43.004 --> 02:46:45.575
<v Dan Ryan>I just think that we have to continue to think about that.

1368
02:46:46.420 --> 02:46:47.855
<v Dan Ryan>All right, I've made that point.

1369
02:46:48.405 --> 02:46:49.873
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, I'll stop because I'm supposed to.

1370
02:46:49.923 --> 02:46:50.536
<v Dan Ryan>It's 5:20.

1371
02:46:50.648 --> 02:46:50.906
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1372
02:46:50.971 --> 02:46:52.472
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1373
02:46:53.231 --> 02:46:53.958
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1374
02:46:55.420 --> 02:46:56.323
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

1375
02:46:56.372 --> 02:46:57.192
<v Olivia Clark>Just a couple quick questions.

1376
02:46:57.771 --> 02:47:05.708
<v Olivia Clark>If I wanted to find out what contracts were in, for example, Public Works service area, is there a place online I can go look at those?

1377
02:47:07.420 --> 02:47:11.789
<v Sylvester>If you— if you get— the parameters are set, we can actually pull that for you and report that for you.

1378
02:47:12.127 --> 02:47:14.922
<v Sylvester>It's a link on our— actually our annual report.

1379
02:47:15.003 --> 02:47:16.674
<v Sylvester>I mean, our usual CPO report.

1380
02:47:16.995 --> 02:47:19.170
<v Sylvester>You can click and you can actually set some parameters yourself.

1381
02:47:19.427 --> 02:47:21.297
<v Sylvester>However, my staff can actually send it over to you as well.

1382
02:47:21.361 --> 02:47:21.877
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, thanks.

1383
02:47:21.924 --> 02:47:22.699
<v Olivia Clark>I'll follow up with you.

1384
02:47:22.809 --> 02:47:25.907
<v Olivia Clark>You know, we have a lot, a lot of large capital projects.

1385
02:47:25.971 --> 02:47:29.135
<v Olivia Clark>I assume, you know, we have to contract out certain areas.

1386
02:47:29.246 --> 02:47:35.122
<v Olivia Clark>I just wondered if when we have an owner's rep for a big project, is that a contracted out function?

1387
02:47:35.540 --> 02:47:39.458
<v Sylvester>It's very likely that that is included in the construction costs in the contract.

1388
02:47:40.245 --> 02:47:56.404
<v Olivia Clark>And I was interested to see you had the category community partnerships because I imagine that we have a lot of little teeny contracts I wouldn't say the dollar, but there are very much—.

1389
02:47:56.596 --> 02:48:03.048
<v Sylvester>There's task order contracting as well, which we don't have a lot of visibility except at the bureau level.

1390
02:48:03.129 --> 02:48:04.327
<v Sylvester>We would like to pull those in.

1391
02:48:04.959 --> 02:48:11.282
<v Sylvester>Then the centralization of that and core service realignment will allow us more visibility in that area as well.

1392
02:48:11.605 --> 02:48:12.977
<v Sylvester>But those are very different.

1393
02:48:13.299 --> 02:48:14.363
<v Sylvester>Those are real estate contracts.

1394
02:48:14.427 --> 02:48:16.996
<v Sylvester>So you're saying that the and those would not be considered services.

1395
02:48:17.174 --> 02:48:19.165
<v Sylvester>Because you mentioned leasing.

1396
02:48:19.356 --> 02:48:21.540
<v Sylvester>Leasing is actually a real estate contract.

1397
02:48:21.750 --> 02:48:22.889
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, okay.

1398
02:48:22.986 --> 02:48:24.592
<v Olivia Clark>So that's not considered a contract.

1399
02:48:24.672 --> 02:48:28.204
<v Olivia Clark>If we're leasing the Fulton Community Center for $1 a year, that's a real estate issue.

1400
02:48:28.316 --> 02:48:29.552
<v Olivia Clark>That would be real estate.

1401
02:48:29.939 --> 02:48:30.950
<v Sylvester>That falls within real estate.

1402
02:48:31.304 --> 02:48:33.503
<v Olivia Clark>And can I get a list of those by bureau?

1403
02:48:33.727 --> 02:48:34.819
<v Olivia Clark>Is that possible?

1404
02:48:35.236 --> 02:48:38.721
<v Sylvester>I would work with the appropriate bureau for that and can get that to you as well.

1405
02:48:38.801 --> 02:48:43.073
<v Olivia Clark>I see the— Bureau Director back there.

1406
02:48:43.345 --> 02:48:50.555
<v Olivia Clark>I'm kind of interested in the list of those real estate relationships, particularly the dollar-a-year leases.

1407
02:48:50.907 --> 02:48:51.599
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

1408
02:48:51.694 --> 02:48:52.481
<v Olivia Clark>A great presentation.

1409
02:48:53.781 --> 02:48:54.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1410
02:48:55.227 --> 02:48:58.486
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have a very quick question, Tracy, to follow up on something you said to Councilor Kanal.

1411
02:48:59.722 --> 02:49:09.802
<v Jamie Dunphy>I understand that the proposal for an assistant city administrator in this budget is for a classified position as Deputy City Administrator under our job classifications.

1412
02:49:10.995 --> 02:49:20.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>But we do have a separate class title for Assistant City Administrator with a significantly lower pay salary range.

1413
02:49:21.880 --> 02:49:28.016
<v Jamie Dunphy>Why are we— if we have that classification, why are we using a different classification to create this position?

1414
02:49:30.029 --> 02:49:31.739
<v Tracy Warren>Happy to answer that, Councilor.

1415
02:49:31.822 --> 02:49:49.908
<v Tracy Warren>When we initially when we initially began the new form of government transition, we went out and we did a market study and we created classifications based on what we thought we would need, based on how we were thinking the organization would be designed.

1416
02:49:50.808 --> 02:50:01.578
<v Tracy Warren>As we started to live into the new structure, it became apparent that we needed to have comparable for those roles to be comparable to one another.

1417
02:50:01.659 --> 02:50:24.328
<v Tracy Warren>It didn't make sense for the assistant city administrator to be paid much lower than the deputy city administrators when the assistant city administrator is frequently stepping in for the city administrator directly, is also overseeing several offices, and has a large responsibility comparatively to the deputy city administrators.

1418
02:50:24.849 --> 02:50:26.604
<v Tracy Warren>So that's why we just leveled it out.

1419
02:50:26.701 --> 02:50:31.727
<v Jamie Dunphy>At some point, will we be doing a code cleanup to get rid of that classification if it's not going to be ever used again?

1420
02:50:33.069 --> 02:50:41.406
<v Tracy Warren>Yeah, we would likely, if we decided we were never going to use that classification, we would abolish it from our classification and compensation plan.

1421
02:50:41.808 --> 02:50:41.969
<v Elise Rosenberg>Yes.

1422
02:50:42.870 --> 02:50:43.174
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1423
02:50:43.673 --> 02:50:44.283
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knell.

1424
02:50:46.485 --> 02:50:46.822
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1425
02:50:47.208 --> 02:50:50.718
<v Sameer Kanal>First, I wanted to thank Councilor Ryan for recognizing thank you.

1426
02:50:50.765 --> 02:50:54.838
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mayor, for recognizing the work of those who support volunteer boards and commissions.

1427
02:50:55.095 --> 02:51:08.295
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that that's something that being on that side of the dais for a few years was not always clear, and I hope that everybody who does that work in the city heard it from him, and I certainly stand by it as well.

1428
02:51:09.209 --> 02:51:14.837
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to get into the governance questions that were in the last couple slides on procurement.

1429
02:51:16.746 --> 02:51:21.387
<v Sameer Kanal>What rules govern what you evaluate in procurement processes?

1430
02:51:21.579 --> 02:51:30.700
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it entirely administrative rules, or are there resolutions, ordinances, code that— in terms of what constitutes the factors and the scoring?

1431
02:51:31.229 --> 02:51:41.779
<v Sylvester>It could be a multitude of things, everything from Commerce Code to the actual codes in terms of our equity goals as well, our former equity goals.

1432
02:51:42.228 --> 02:51:45.440
<v Sylvester>So there is a multitude of statutes that come into play.

1433
02:51:45.906 --> 02:51:48.957
<v Sylvester>For me to name them all would probably take some time.

1434
02:51:49.679 --> 02:51:50.851
<v Sylvester>I don't want to eat away at the time.

1435
02:51:51.269 --> 02:51:52.441
<v Sylvester>I'm not trying to be flippant.

1436
02:51:52.488 --> 02:51:52.617
<v Tracy Warren>No, no.

1437
02:51:52.665 --> 02:51:54.608
<v Sylvester>I just want to be very respectful of time.

1438
02:51:55.362 --> 02:52:03.825
<v Sylvester>Everything from ORS to federal grant requirements as well.

1439
02:52:03.888 --> 02:52:05.190
<v Sylvester>I just want to name them all as well.

1440
02:52:05.558 --> 02:52:12.361
<v Sylvester>But there are, depending upon the function and what the work is going to be, what the work is going to be, it can be a magnitude, a magnitude of rules.

1441
02:52:13.179 --> 02:52:18.423
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so I just want to— this is outside, maybe outside the scope of the budget conversation for this year's budget.

1442
02:52:18.470 --> 02:52:30.147
<v Sameer Kanal>It might affect it a little bit, but I just wanted to sort of signify an intent, uh, to look at that because there are a few factors that, um, I'm not sure are weighted at all or weighted heavily enough.

1443
02:52:30.259 --> 02:52:35.070
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think you administer the rules in your bureau the rules as they are very well.

1444
02:52:35.184 --> 02:52:40.870
<v Sameer Kanal>So I don't— I think this is more about what are the rules we're asking you as a council to look at.

1445
02:52:42.262 --> 02:53:14.863
<v Sameer Kanal>I think when we look at nonprofits, and especially this came up in last year's conversation, I know I'm not gonna— I'm gonna scare anybody by saying last year's conversation about the children's levy, but the conversation around when we ask for an organization that we're contracting with or granting money to, to serve a particular community, do we even ask about whether or not any of the members of the board or the senior leadership are members of that same community or not?

1446
02:53:15.311 --> 02:53:18.998
<v Sameer Kanal>Whether or not that's weighted or not, I'm not getting into, but whether that's a factor.

1447
02:53:19.078 --> 02:53:34.540
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the same thing applies here, that when we're looking at who we contract with, asking certain questions might be helpful for I'm interested in whether or not we should be contracting— we should look at the CEO salary or the executive director's salary.

1448
02:53:34.540 --> 02:53:43.180
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there's been a lot about nonprofits that are getting money in the affordable housing space with $500,000, you know, executive directors or CEO pay.

1449
02:53:43.180 --> 02:53:49.500
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm interested in having that be a detrimental factor for the contracting process.

1450
02:53:49.500 --> 02:53:51.299
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm very interested in local procurement.

1451
02:53:51.299 --> 02:53:51.360
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1452
02:53:51.502 --> 02:53:51.981
<v Sameer Kanal>Procurement.

1453
02:53:52.367 --> 02:54:10.458
<v Sameer Kanal>We know about the multiplier effect of, uh, dollars that are spent on local, um, organizations and feeding that money back into our community and not into— I don't want to name another part of the country and single them out, but somewhere far away, uh, that where the money doesn't circulate in our economy multiple times.

1454
02:54:10.809 --> 02:54:14.719
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's for when we have to contract out work.

1455
02:54:15.281 --> 02:54:17.828
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so I, I would love to work with, with you on that.

1456
02:54:18.004 --> 02:54:20.865
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, And try to, try to figure that out.

1457
02:54:21.447 --> 02:54:31.627
<v Sameer Kanal>The other question I had related to contracts is where, where, um, are we at in terms of reducing or eliminating sole source contracts?

1458
02:54:34.162 --> 02:54:34.420
<v Sylvester>I am—.

1459
02:54:34.549 --> 02:54:37.727
<v Sylvester>That's probably one of the biggest crusades I've had over my career.

1460
02:54:38.516 --> 02:54:41.388
<v Sameer Kanal>I remember you bringing this up at the dais in the old—.

1461
02:54:41.663 --> 02:54:51.716
<v Sylvester>So yeah, um, we are doing much better than we have done, I would say, considering the structure of procurement as it is today.

1462
02:54:52.502 --> 02:54:57.510
<v Sylvester>However, I would like for it to be, quite frankly, zero in a perfect world.

1463
02:54:57.654 --> 02:55:07.252
<v Sylvester>We have full competition and we have a supported supplier diversity environment, and we are actually procuring that allows for us to get out of the proprietary space.

1464
02:55:07.861 --> 02:55:09.739
<v Sylvester>So I'm working very hard with my thank you.

1465
02:55:09.739 --> 02:55:09.739
<v Sylvester>I think we need to have a better scope of work.

1466
02:55:09.739 --> 02:55:10.649
<v Sylvester>We need to have a better scope of work and a better procurement team in order to do that.

1467
02:55:10.649 --> 02:55:13.000
<v Sylvester>So it's one of my professional crusades.

1468
02:55:13.700 --> 02:55:25.799
<v Sylvester>But also, I'm more going back to what your previous statement— the scope of work decides and defines some of the triggering and some of the governing rules as it relates to procurement.

1469
02:55:26.500 --> 02:55:36.777
<v Sylvester>The better we are with our scope of work and responsible and aligning with our values, that's legally permissible, we can definitely align and with their organizational goals.

1470
02:55:36.825 --> 02:55:37.852
<v Sylvester>I think it's very important.

1471
02:55:38.253 --> 02:55:39.840
<v Sylvester>It shows identity in our procuring.

1472
02:55:40.577 --> 02:55:47.698
<v Sameer Kanal>So yeah, and I think you're highlighting this last bullet point on the good governance slide around partnership with bureaus.

1473
02:55:47.809 --> 02:55:54.272
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not realistic to expect procurement to know the details of the work that a different bureau is contracting out.

1474
02:55:54.320 --> 02:55:56.165
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's the— there's sort of 3 parties.

1475
02:55:56.212 --> 02:56:00.110
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a contractor there, or bidders, I guess.

1476
02:56:00.558 --> 02:56:05.818
<v Sameer Kanal>There's the the bureau that's asking for work to be done, and then there's sort of the procurement check on it.

1477
02:56:06.061 --> 02:56:06.483
<v Sylvester>Correct.

1478
02:56:06.629 --> 02:56:25.275
<v Sameer Kanal>As part of the realignment, how are you approaching the issue of when a contract is being developed, or, or I should say an RFA is being developed, RFP, which procurement is being the check on it?

1479
02:56:25.773 --> 02:56:32.962
<v Sameer Kanal>So to be specific, We had bureau or service area procurement and central procurement that were both weighing in.

1480
02:56:33.027 --> 02:56:36.013
<v Sameer Kanal>And as part of the realignment, is that part of what's changing?

1481
02:56:36.447 --> 02:56:38.084
<v Sylvester>That will be the biggest change, actually.

1482
02:56:38.165 --> 02:56:47.862
<v Sylvester>It will be a standardization of that activity, providing good governance as it relates to RFP development, RFX development, and scope of work, responsible scope of work.

1483
02:56:49.066 --> 02:56:57.175
<v Sylvester>The bureaus as well as core procurement are now going through a series of training that aligns us with the national standards, and that includes how procurement works.

1484
02:56:58.203 --> 02:57:16.218
<v Sylvester>It was something that was initiated as part of my ability to try and be able to give the standardization and evaluate how effective we are in terms of how we're meeting the requirements to the community, to council's values and objectives, as well as the executives.

1485
02:57:16.459 --> 02:57:23.942
<v Sylvester>So it's trying to create a value value-add and strategic partnership in developing everything from the scope of work to vendor performance.

1486
02:57:24.698 --> 02:57:25.050
<v Sameer Kanal>Great.

1487
02:57:25.115 --> 02:57:45.575
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, so I think that the performance piece, I'd love to hear more maybe in the Committee of the Whole or something about how we, what the nature of the division of responsibility is there between the procurement core, I guess, at this point, or core embedded will be aligned if not necessarily the same, and the bureau that's actually doing the contract.

1488
02:57:46.217 --> 02:57:46.522
<v Sylvester>Absolutely.

1489
02:57:46.618 --> 02:57:52.514
<v Sylvester>I consider it a partnership, a very cohesive partnership in a perfect, perfect sense.

1490
02:57:52.996 --> 02:58:01.144
<v Sylvester>But also, I realize that I have a lot of training to do because procurement can be nebulous and it can be quite frustrating at times because we have compliance as well as performance.

1491
02:58:02.396 --> 02:58:03.088
<v Sameer Kanal>One last question.

1492
02:58:03.443 --> 02:58:21.234
<v Sameer Kanal>When we get to the stage of establishing panels to review the bids, and, and this may come up earlier in the process on the decision point on whether or not to contract in the first place, but I don't think there's a formalized structure for that.

1493
02:58:21.877 --> 02:58:30.467
<v Sameer Kanal>Do we have a standard practice, or could we start one of inviting representation from the relevant labor partner to be part of that?

1494
02:58:31.109 --> 02:58:33.549
<v Sylvester>That would be something we can, uh, talk about later.

1495
02:58:33.597 --> 02:58:36.039
<v Sylvester>Maybe I should try and investigate the legalities of that.

1496
02:58:36.150 --> 02:58:39.648
<v Sylvester>I would rather not say yeah, I appreciate that.

1497
02:58:40.179 --> 02:58:42.441
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry to put you on the spot with that.

1498
02:58:42.504 --> 02:58:44.076
<v Sameer Kanal>That was not one of the prep questions.

1499
02:58:44.815 --> 02:58:46.193
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much, Council President.

1500
02:58:46.354 --> 02:58:47.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, Councilor Kanal.

1501
02:58:48.119 --> 02:58:48.745
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1502
02:58:49.804 --> 02:59:04.129
<v Steve Novick>Yeah, I just— and I don't expect anybody to have this detail in front of them, but I just did want to note that we have been told by city employees that there are some contracts where contractors are doing the same work as city employees side by side.

1503
02:59:04.387 --> 02:59:04.934
<v Steve Novick>For years.

1504
02:59:05.209 --> 02:59:09.046
<v Steve Novick>One specific example we've been given is construction inspectors.

1505
02:59:09.722 --> 02:59:10.802
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to flag that.

1506
02:59:12.343 --> 02:59:12.715
<v Sylvester>Thank you.

1507
02:59:14.105 --> 02:59:14.947
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1508
02:59:15.254 --> 02:59:15.788
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1509
02:59:16.709 --> 02:59:17.939
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thanks.

1510
02:59:18.148 --> 02:59:23.270
<v Mitch Green>Um, I didn't really have a chance to ask questions about the procurement slide, so I appreciate the updates, uh, Sylvester.

1511
02:59:23.478 --> 02:59:34.243
<v Mitch Green>Um, can you— on the slide that had the roll-ups on, um, there was that first chart, and I think I think it was slide 3 that talked about the sort of decline over time.

1512
02:59:35.238 --> 02:59:36.637
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, this is helpful.

1513
02:59:36.685 --> 02:59:38.195
<v Mitch Green>I think this is at the aggregate level.

1514
02:59:38.388 --> 02:59:42.724
<v Mitch Green>I would love to see sort of some detailed data on that.

1515
02:59:45.004 --> 02:59:46.245
<v Mitch Green>That would be helpful for my office.

1516
02:59:46.601 --> 02:59:51.569
<v Mitch Green>I suspect that some contractors are different than others and some program areas are different than others.

1517
02:59:51.618 --> 03:00:17.498
<v Mitch Green>I think in particular, if you go to the next slide, This piece is something I've thought a lot about, which is if we're going to use contracting for cost efficiency purposes— I mean, there's a lot of different reasons we use it, but if we're going to do that for cost efficiency purposes, like, what is the ratio between what the bid for the contractor was and what was their total cost through change orders and the like?

1518
03:00:17.563 --> 03:00:26.170
<v Mitch Green>And I think that I'm thinking more in terms of capital project contracting than I am other procurement stuff, but I I see you're sort of smiling on that, so I think you know what I'm talking about, right?

1519
03:00:26.235 --> 03:00:30.103
<v Sylvester>That's another crusade, a professional crusade of mine, so thank you for bringing that up.

1520
03:00:30.634 --> 03:00:31.613
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1521
03:00:32.319 --> 03:00:47.959
<v Sylvester>Being a public administrator student, I think that's one of the biggest, one of the bigger things that we probably can quite win, probably be quite a big of a win if we are able to do that, and having some sort of financial engagement with some financial analysts.

1522
03:00:48.040 --> 03:00:54.059
<v Sylvester>Probably, um, on procurement, on our procurement team, to be able to really kind of, for lack of a better term, count the beans.

1523
03:00:54.814 --> 03:00:55.858
<v Sylvester>And I think that's really important.

1524
03:00:56.113 --> 03:00:57.478
<v Sylvester>So thank you for bringing that up.

1525
03:00:57.542 --> 03:01:00.239
<v Sylvester>It's one of the bigger things that I'm actually interested in.

1526
03:01:00.834 --> 03:01:01.573
<v Mitch Green>I'm glad to hear that.

1527
03:01:01.620 --> 03:01:12.087
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I think when we think about, similar to Councilor Kanal's question, when we think about our, um, our sort of unbiased, our ranking system for how we would award a contract, we come up with like clearly identified metrics.

1528
03:01:12.618 --> 03:01:24.825
<v Mitch Green>A metric that sort of looked at how often your change order came in above your initial bid and being dinged for that could, could level the playing field, I think, for some contractors who, um, who are trying to do it right.

1529
03:01:25.397 --> 03:01:25.755
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1530
03:01:26.702 --> 03:01:27.813
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1531
03:01:30.256 --> 03:01:33.442
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, anybody else, uh, wanting to get into the queue?

1532
03:01:36.861 --> 03:01:39.927
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, looks like that concludes all councilor questions.

1533
03:01:40.878 --> 03:01:43.251
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much for these presentations.

1534
03:01:43.315 --> 03:01:44.622
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's a lot of information.

1535
03:01:44.752 --> 03:01:49.060
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, thank you for all your thoughtful questions on this and for sticking us on it.

1536
03:01:49.126 --> 03:01:50.128
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're getting out on time.

1537
03:01:50.810 --> 03:01:53.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>That concludes this work session of the Portland City Council.

1538
03:01:53.509 --> 03:01:53.801
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1539
03:01:53.851 --> 03:01:54.224
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are adjourned.

1540
03:01:59.639 --> 03:01:59.923
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

