WEBVTT

1
00:05:58.452 --> 00:05:59.543
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

2
00:05:59.718 --> 00:06:01.033
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is 9:32.

3
00:06:01.161 --> 00:06:10.107
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am calling to order this meeting, this council work session on— what is it— Wednesday, 9— uh, it's 9:32, I already said that.

4
00:06:10.956 --> 00:06:12.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>May 6th is the word I'm looking for.

5
00:06:12.559 --> 00:06:17.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, today is the first budget work session related to the Community and Economic Development Service Area.

6
00:06:17.689 --> 00:06:18.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>Our second work session will be held on May 17th.

7
00:06:18.939 --> 00:06:21.473
<v Jamie Dunphy>Work session in the series is tomorrow, Thursday, May 7th.

8
00:06:21.619 --> 00:06:25.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today's work session focuses on housing and permitting matters within the service area.

9
00:06:26.031 --> 00:06:32.848
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will be starting with Portland Permitting and Development, move on to the Portland Housing Bureau, and finish with the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

10
00:06:33.331 --> 00:06:38.994
<v Jamie Dunphy>Within the Planning and Sustainability Bureau— Bureau of Planning and Sustainability— we'll be focusing on planning specifically.

11
00:06:39.105 --> 00:06:45.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have over an hour set aside tomorrow to discuss sustainability issues and specifically the Portland Clean Energy Benefits fund.

12
00:06:45.588 --> 00:06:47.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>So hold off on those comments until tomorrow, please.

13
00:06:48.819 --> 00:06:55.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is a service area with a lot of programs, and so today and tomorrow we have many presentations with a relatively tight timeline.

14
00:06:55.961 --> 00:06:57.204
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will be watching the clock.

15
00:06:57.252 --> 00:07:02.463
<v Jamie Dunphy>Specifically, I'm asking colleagues to keep their questions to 5 minutes per time.

16
00:07:02.576 --> 00:07:07.634
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're always welcome to get back in the queue, but we got a lot of folks to get through and a very tight timeline.

17
00:07:08.411 --> 00:07:14.665
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please consider what's best for the body and the city as a whole by being brief and to the point with your questions so that everything and everybody can be heard today.

18
00:07:17.161 --> 00:07:21.423
<v Jamie Dunphy>With that, I'm going to turn it over to DCA Donnie Oliveira.

19
00:07:21.809 --> 00:07:22.192
<v Loretta Smith>Welcome.

20
00:07:23.314 --> 00:07:23.939
<v Donnie Oliveira>You can join us.

21
00:07:25.076 --> 00:07:27.288
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, and we will be holding questions until after the presentation.

22
00:07:27.480 --> 00:07:34.754
<v Jamie Dunphy>And colleagues, for this first section, uh, we have about 40 minutes to ask questions for permitting.

23
00:07:35.507 --> 00:07:36.309
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, take it away.

24
00:07:37.029 --> 00:07:38.728
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you, Council President, Vice President.

25
00:07:38.791 --> 00:07:39.930
<v Donnie Oliveira>Good morning, City Council.

26
00:07:40.795 --> 00:07:45.521
<v Donnie Oliveira>My name is Donnie Oliveira, Deputy City Administrator for the Community and Economic Development Service Area.

27
00:07:46.391 --> 00:07:50.379
<v Donnie Oliveira>I'm joined by Directors Eric Engstrom, Michael Bunnecourt, and Eric Kooch.

28
00:07:51.288 --> 00:07:52.050
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide, please.

29
00:07:54.641 --> 00:08:04.230
<v Donnie Oliveira>I will flag that, as the council president focused on, we're going to target these 3 bureaus today, with coming back with a whole different suite of topics for you tomorrow.

30
00:08:05.379 --> 00:08:06.639
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide.

31
00:08:08.952 --> 00:08:16.971
<v Donnie Oliveira>All right, so the city's Community and Economic Development Service Area focuses on housing, Planning, climate, culture, art, and economic development.

32
00:08:17.548 --> 00:08:20.930
<v Donnie Oliveira>Together, we make Portland's community and built environment more vibrant and sustainable.

33
00:08:21.716 --> 00:08:27.615
<v Donnie Oliveira>We focus on delivering programs and projects that create efficient, transparent, and just solutions to the issues we face.

34
00:08:28.434 --> 00:08:32.472
<v Donnie Oliveira>The service area leans into its stakeholder engagement efforts to work with our communities along the way.

35
00:08:33.403 --> 00:08:36.849
<v Donnie Oliveira>Our best policies and programs are those that center collaboration with the people we serve.

36
00:08:38.227 --> 00:08:46.340
<v Donnie Oliveira>One note for council on this particular slide: the number of FTE is inclusive of Prosper Portland staff, and while they are not formally city Portland employees.

37
00:08:46.403 --> 00:08:51.187
<v Donnie Oliveira>They are every bit a part of the service area team working in collaboration and partnership to meet our city's goals.

38
00:08:52.261 --> 00:08:52.871
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide, please.

39
00:08:54.187 --> 00:08:59.370
<v Donnie Oliveira>And just another way to look at it, uh, the service area is made up of the bureaus and offices you see represented on screen.

40
00:09:00.206 --> 00:09:04.265
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, we've highlighted again Prosper, um, to denote the distinct reporting relationship with the city.

41
00:09:04.457 --> 00:09:16.318
<v Donnie Oliveira>But again, while not a formal city bureau, their efforts supporting our small business community, activating economic and real estate development, and functioning as the stewards of the city's economic development strategy, Advance Portland, are significant.

42
00:09:17.134 --> 00:09:17.754
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide, please.

43
00:09:19.097 --> 00:09:24.110
<v Donnie Oliveira>So as a service area, our mission is to ensure Portland's future is resilient, sustainable, equitable, and prosperous.

44
00:09:24.785 --> 00:09:29.187
<v Donnie Oliveira>We are both designing and planning for the future while providing resources and tools to deliver the results.

45
00:09:30.818 --> 00:09:37.807
<v Donnie Oliveira>Importantly, 70% of our operating budget goes directly to community through grants, loans, or other forms of support from our various funding streams.

46
00:09:38.587 --> 00:09:49.275
<v Donnie Oliveira>Across our bureaus and offices, city leadership worked hard to build a responsive responsible budget proposal, ensuring that our cuts prioritize core and mandated requirements and the priorities of the executive and legislative branch.

47
00:09:49.951 --> 00:10:02.076
<v Donnie Oliveira>At the same time, the past few years have been very difficult when it comes to managing our general fund dollars because over the years we take— we've been taking cuts and that's reduced the percentage of overall higher discretionary dollars.

48
00:10:03.924 --> 00:10:04.552
<v Donnie Oliveira>Next slide, please.

49
00:10:06.429 --> 00:10:14.943
<v Donnie Oliveira>The last slide that I'll walk you through briefly before we get to the, the core details from our our directors, is the breakdown of bureau by bureau and by fund of the service area.

50
00:10:15.923 --> 00:10:23.924
<v Donnie Oliveira>Substantially, PCF makes up a significant portion of our budget, but that includes the, the reserve contingency budgets that are planned for out years.

51
00:10:24.760 --> 00:10:32.585
<v Donnie Oliveira>You may notice a drop from this year's revised budget to, to this, which is just sort of a function of the developing budget as we know it today.

52
00:10:32.953 --> 00:10:47.645
<v Donnie Oliveira>Last, I'll just say for your just situational awareness, is as we look at these dollars, as a reminder, some of them are dollars that are programmed for future years, whether that be in, in TIF or some of the conversations we had around the Housing Bureau dollars.

53
00:10:48.162 --> 00:10:52.969
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, not all the $1.2.4 proposed is, uh, designed to be spent in '26-'27.

54
00:10:55.460 --> 00:11:00.582
<v Donnie Oliveira>All right, and we're going to— the order of the, the presentation is we're starting with permitting development and the housing and BPS.

55
00:11:01.114 --> 00:11:03.418
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so with that, I will turn it to Director Eric Kooch.

56
00:11:03.946 --> 00:11:04.410
<v Eric Kooch>Thank you, Donnie.

57
00:11:05.085 --> 00:11:05.743
<v Eric Kooch>Good morning, Council.

58
00:11:05.966 --> 00:11:06.784
<v Eric Kooch>My name is Eric Kooch.

59
00:11:06.850 --> 00:11:08.581
<v Eric Kooch>I'm the Director of Portland Permitting and Development.

60
00:11:09.014 --> 00:11:14.710
<v Eric Kooch>Today I'm here to walk you through PP&D's proposed budget and how we're working to preserve core services in a challenging environment.

61
00:11:15.817 --> 00:11:20.614
<v Eric Kooch>At a high level, PP&D plays a critical role in supporting development and economic activity across the city.

62
00:11:21.849 --> 00:11:26.469
<v Eric Kooch>And like most service-based organizations, our ability to deliver on that responsibility comes down to our people.

63
00:11:27.705 --> 00:11:33.061
<v Eric Kooch>Without adequate staffing, we cannot provide timely, predictable permitting for customers who are trying to build in Portland.

64
00:11:34.932 --> 00:11:41.768
<v Eric Kooch>At its core, this budget is about maintaining staffing so we can continue delivering the level of service our customers and this council expects.

65
00:11:42.546 --> 00:11:43.080
<v Eric Kooch>Next slide, please.

66
00:11:45.272 --> 00:11:49.232
<v Eric Kooch>At a high level, what this budget reflects is the reality of the resources available to the bureau.

67
00:11:50.591 --> 00:11:53.645
<v Eric Kooch>Most of the impacts you'll see are within the tree permitting program.

68
00:11:54.700 --> 00:11:57.874
<v Eric Kooch>That's where the available funding does not fully support maintaining current service levels.

69
00:11:58.791 --> 00:12:02.368
<v Eric Kooch>As a result, the changes reflected in this budget are driven by those funding constraints.

70
00:12:03.740 --> 00:12:06.440
<v Eric Kooch>I'll walk through what that means in terms of real impacts in just a moment.

71
00:12:07.126 --> 00:12:07.749
<v Eric Kooch>Next slide, please.

72
00:12:11.340 --> 00:12:17.339
<v Eric Kooch>This budget proposes 300.9 positions, down from 337.9 in the current service level.

73
00:12:17.885 --> 00:12:19.549
<v Eric Kooch>That change is driven by 2 factors.

74
00:12:20.706 --> 00:12:24.533
<v Eric Kooch>First, 23 positions are being realigned as part of the core services realignment.

75
00:12:26.070 --> 00:12:30.893
<v Eric Kooch>Second, 14 positions are being reduced within the tree permitting program due to resource constraints.

76
00:12:32.379 --> 00:12:36.296
<v Eric Kooch>Of those 14 positions, 6 are currently filled and 8 are vacant.

77
00:12:37.027 --> 00:12:40.097
<v Eric Kooch>One is a supervisory position and the remaining are non-supervisory.

78
00:12:41.296 --> 00:12:43.889
<v Eric Kooch>It is also important to understand how these positions are funded.

79
00:12:44.615 --> 00:12:46.677
<v Eric Kooch>These positions are not funded by general fund dollars.

80
00:12:47.256 --> 00:12:55.956
<v Eric Kooch>12 Are supported by PSF funding, which while not reduced, does not fully cover the cost of those positions, especially when factoring in inflation.

81
00:12:57.330 --> 00:13:00.936
<v Eric Kooch>The remaining 2 positions were supported through a previous interagency agreement with Parks.

82
00:13:02.192 --> 00:13:08.073
<v Eric Kooch>So when you step back, what you're seeing here is a funding structure that does not fully support maintaining the current level of service.

83
00:13:09.206 --> 00:13:10.307
<v Eric Kooch>Next slide, please.

84
00:13:13.687 --> 00:13:16.128
<v Eric Kooch>That context really drives the approach behind this budget.

85
00:13:17.293 --> 00:13:20.307
<v Eric Kooch>Our primary objective going into this cycle was preserving core services.

86
00:13:21.452 --> 00:13:28.578
<v Eric Kooch>Over the past several years, the bureau has taken on additional responsibilities while also reducing staffing, all within a slower development environment.

87
00:13:29.820 --> 00:13:34.282
<v Eric Kooch>Despite that, we've continued to make progress improving our processes and maintaining performance.

88
00:13:35.991 --> 00:13:40.592
<v Eric Kooch>But after multiple years of reductions, we are now at a point where additional cuts will have noticeable impacts.

89
00:13:42.087 --> 00:13:50.211
<v Eric Kooch>The reductions in this proposal will have an impact on permitting timelines, and any further reductions would make it harder for us to keep projects moving efficiently through the process.

90
00:13:51.753 --> 00:13:54.147
<v Eric Kooch>That is why preserving core services is so important.

91
00:13:54.565 --> 00:13:58.806
<v Eric Kooch>It allows us to maintain stability now and to be ready when development activity increases again.

92
00:14:00.769 --> 00:14:08.495
<v Eric Kooch>We are also continuing to support key customer-facing programs, including process management, which provides a single point of contact for complex projects.

93
00:14:09.847 --> 00:14:18.494
<v Eric Kooch>Simple bathroom permits, which offer expedited permitting, and the Empowered Communities Program, which supports historically underserved customers navigating the permitting process.

94
00:14:19.673 --> 00:14:26.255
<v Eric Kooch>In addition, we continue to provide early assistance and consultation services to help customers before they submit applications.

95
00:14:27.090 --> 00:14:27.701
<v Eric Kooch>Next slide, please.

96
00:14:30.601 --> 00:14:33.404
<v Eric Kooch>The most significant impacts in this budget are within tree permitting.

97
00:14:33.923 --> 00:14:36.969
<v Eric Kooch>This program was transferred from Parks to PP&D over the past 2 years.

98
00:14:37.985 --> 00:14:43.490
<v Eric Kooch>What we've seen is that both the fee structure and the funding that came with the program do not fully support the level of service expected.

99
00:14:44.871 --> 00:14:50.153
<v Eric Kooch>As a result, this budget reduces the program by 12 positions to better align staffing with available resources.

100
00:14:51.052 --> 00:14:54.537
<v Eric Kooch>Of those 12 positions, 6 are currently filled and 6 are vacant.

101
00:14:55.001 --> 00:14:57.586
<v Eric Kooch>One is supervisory and the remaining are non-supervisory.

102
00:14:58.374 --> 00:15:01.182
<v Eric Kooch>This is a significant reduction and will have real impacts.

103
00:15:01.809 --> 00:15:09.275
<v Eric Kooch>We expect longer permitting timelines, Next slide, please.

104
00:15:10.830 --> 00:15:19.059
<v Eric Kooch>Given those constraints, the city may also need to evaluate how the tree code is implemented moving forward, including potential prioritization or future adjustments.

105
00:15:20.720 --> 00:15:21.628
<v Eric Kooch>Next slide, please.

106
00:15:24.392 --> 00:15:28.596
<v Eric Kooch>In addition to that, this budget also reflects the elimination of interagency support from Parks.

107
00:15:29.326 --> 00:15:32.999
<v Eric Kooch>Historically, A portion of this program was subsidized through Parks General Fund.

108
00:15:33.551 --> 00:15:36.230
<v Eric Kooch>That subsidy is being removed as part of the mayor's proposed budget.

109
00:15:37.066 --> 00:15:43.678
<v Eric Kooch>As a result, this budget includes an additional reduction of 2 positions, both of which are currently vacant and non-supervisory.

110
00:15:45.789 --> 00:15:49.726
<v Eric Kooch>This further reduces the program's capacity and adds to the impacts we just discussed.

111
00:15:50.260 --> 00:15:50.812
<v Eric Kooch>Next slide, please.

112
00:15:54.470 --> 00:15:57.567
<v Eric Kooch>Stepping back, all this is happening within a challenging development environment.

113
00:15:58.192 --> 00:16:01.373
<v Eric Kooch>Construction activity declined during the pandemic and has not fully rebounded.

114
00:16:02.592 --> 00:16:09.240
<v Eric Kooch>We are seeing the effects of high interest rates, lower investor confidence, declining property values, and broader uncertainty in the markets.

115
00:16:10.636 --> 00:16:13.414
<v Eric Kooch>There's also an ongoing perception challenge around building in Portland.

116
00:16:14.169 --> 00:16:16.144
<v Eric Kooch>At the same time, our costs continue to rise.

117
00:16:17.445 --> 00:16:23.129
<v Eric Kooch>This budget is designed to maintain service levels where possible by aligning fees more closely with the cost of providing those services.

118
00:16:24.432 --> 00:16:28.759
<v Eric Kooch>As you know, those fees have not yet been approved, which is why they are not reflected in this budget summary.

119
00:16:29.288 --> 00:16:30.736
<v Eric Kooch>I'll walk through that proposal next.

120
00:16:32.330 --> 00:16:33.269
<v Eric Kooch>Next slide.

121
00:16:35.264 --> 00:16:38.784
<v Eric Kooch>At a high level, the fee proposal is structured to be both balanced and targeted.

122
00:16:40.009 --> 00:16:42.538
<v Eric Kooch>Most programs will see a base increase of about 5%.

123
00:16:43.667 --> 00:16:48.145
<v Eric Kooch>Some programs are higher where there are clear gaps between costs and revenue, and others are unchanged.

124
00:16:48.291 --> 00:16:48.548
<v Eric Kooch>Thank you.

125
00:16:49.413 --> 00:16:52.910
<v Eric Kooch>Programs with no increases include facilities permits and cannabis licensing.

126
00:16:54.066 --> 00:17:02.985
<v Eric Kooch>Programs with the base 5% increase include electrical, plumbing, field issuance remodel, site development, zoning enforcement, land use services, neighborhood inspections, and signs.

127
00:17:04.252 --> 00:17:08.938
<v Eric Kooch>Building mechanical is proposed at 9% due to reduced cost recovery tied to fewer larger projects.

128
00:17:09.948 --> 00:17:14.744
<v Eric Kooch>Environmental review, water review, and urban forestry are also at 9% because they are below cost recovery.

129
00:17:15.929 --> 00:17:22.608
<v Eric Kooch>Transportation review reflects a larger increase due to a shift away from interagency funding and toward a fully, a fully self-supported model.

130
00:17:24.130 --> 00:17:31.403
<v Eric Kooch>Accessory short-term rentals are proposed to increase by 26% and noise by 41%, as both are currently below cost recovery.

131
00:17:31.984 --> 00:17:32.615
<v Eric Kooch>Next slide, please.

132
00:17:34.410 --> 00:17:38.153
<v Eric Kooch>Finally, this slide provides a comparison of our fees to other jurisdictions.

133
00:17:39.144 --> 00:17:42.616
<v Eric Kooch>While no comparison is perfect, it does provide a consistent point of reference.

134
00:17:43.517 --> 00:17:51.721
<v Eric Kooch>One important, important distinction is that Portland funds more of its permitting work through fees than many other jurisdictions, which rely more heavily on general fund support.

135
00:17:53.151 --> 00:17:58.594
<v Eric Kooch>So to keep the comparison consistent, this focused specifically on building permit and plan review fees.

136
00:17:59.413 --> 00:18:05.739
<v Eric Kooch>Using a typical single-family project, Portland falls within the range of comparable jurisdictions and in some cases below them.

137
00:18:07.162 --> 00:18:10.897
<v Eric Kooch>We understand the importance of keeping fees reasonable so they do not become a barrier to development.

138
00:18:12.319 --> 00:18:18.705
<v Eric Kooch>At the same time, predictability and permitting timelines are just as important, if not more important, for project feasibility.

139
00:18:19.819 --> 00:18:22.243
<v Eric Kooch>Our goal is to strike the right balance between those 2 priorities.

140
00:18:22.988 --> 00:18:25.185
<v Eric Kooch>We look forward to continuing this conversation with council.

141
00:18:25.589 --> 00:18:25.930
<v Eric Kooch>Thank you.

142
00:18:27.617 --> 00:18:28.998
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

143
00:18:32.488 --> 00:18:37.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>So would we rather get through all the presentations and do it all, questions at once, or do you want to stop and go?

144
00:18:37.635 --> 00:18:43.537
<v Donnie Oliveira>I think if you have questions for specifically for PP&D, it would be appropriate right now, and we just manage time.

145
00:18:43.970 --> 00:18:44.692
<v Donnie Oliveira>Great.

146
00:18:45.173 --> 00:18:51.763
<v Jamie Dunphy>Let's— colleagues, uh, we have a few minutes here to talk about questions, and we can also ask more questions after all the presentations are done.

147
00:18:51.892 --> 00:18:53.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>But for now, Councilor Novick.

148
00:18:54.136 --> 00:18:55.035
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

149
00:18:55.516 --> 00:18:57.648
<v Steve Novick>So I'm going to focus on tree permitting.

150
00:18:59.218 --> 00:19:01.693
<v Steve Novick>And I'm confused in a number of ways.

151
00:19:03.496 --> 00:19:15.848
<v Steve Novick>One is that if we gut the tree permitting program, then it seems to me that we've got all sorts of permit requirements out there that people are supposed to follow in terms of like cutting down what they think are dead or dangerous trees on their property.

152
00:19:16.662 --> 00:19:20.808
<v Steve Novick>But when they submit their permit request, it'll take years for them to actually get it acted on.

153
00:19:21.710 --> 00:19:23.028
<v Steve Novick>Is that right?

154
00:19:23.478 --> 00:19:24.217
<v Eric Kooch>What's your question again?

155
00:19:24.281 --> 00:19:28.519
<v Steve Novick>I'm saying that I mean, the permitting requirements will still exist.

156
00:19:29.066 --> 00:19:29.338
<v Eric Kooch>Correct.

157
00:19:29.386 --> 00:19:39.873
<v Steve Novick>So people will still have to get a permit to remove what they think is a dead or dangerous tree, but they'll submit the permit request and it's going to take forever for you to get it processed.

158
00:19:40.210 --> 00:19:42.136
<v Eric Kooch>It will take longer due to the cuts, correct.

159
00:19:42.218 --> 00:19:42.410
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

160
00:19:42.538 --> 00:19:42.666
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

161
00:19:43.374 --> 00:19:52.494
<v Steve Novick>So I wonder if you've given any thought— it seems to me that if you're going to gut a program like that, then it should probably go along with the suggestion to eliminate the underlying requirement.

162
00:19:52.834 --> 00:19:53.770
<v Steve Novick>Did you consider that?

163
00:19:54.111 --> 00:19:56.050
<v Steve Novick>You're saying people can cut whatever trees they want?

164
00:19:56.551 --> 00:20:09.248
<v Eric Kooch>Yes, Councilor, we are looking at the, uh, the code and the regulations around Title 11 to see if there's anything, you know, any changes we can make, uh, to help, uh, offset the, the additional time that'll come along with the, uh, the cuts in those positions.

165
00:20:10.136 --> 00:20:27.527
<v Steve Novick>Okay, but it kind of seems to me that if— that those two should— I'm not saying it's a good idea, but it kind of seems to me those two should go together if you're saying that you're gutting the permitting program, then the proposal to offset that by reducing some of the permitting requirements should go along with it.

166
00:20:28.957 --> 00:20:43.191
<v Steve Novick>The other thing is, this seems like pretty PSF-y work, and I don't understand why the administration hasn't given more thought to using PSF to fund this work.

167
00:20:44.058 --> 00:20:54.451
<v Steve Novick>And I'll just be blunt and say that if we think we've got $75 million of PSF money to spend on the Moda Center, I don't understand why we don't have $2.9 million to maintain these jobs.

168
00:20:55.999 --> 00:21:06.578
<v Steve Novick>And I have been, I mean, I am looking for a source of PSF money that either I think is inappropriate or underspent to offset this and fund these jobs.

169
00:21:06.643 --> 00:21:21.494
<v Steve Novick>But that's been a bit of a frustrating process because I've asked both PSF and Jonas's office to identify PSF programs that are underspent where it looks like we might have extra money.

170
00:21:21.929 --> 00:21:24.286
<v Steve Novick>And they said they're not really in a position to identify that yet.

171
00:21:24.449 --> 00:21:27.347
<v Steve Novick>So that's just sort of a generic complaint.

172
00:21:28.778 --> 00:21:32.436
<v Steve Novick>But I just— I'd actually like to ask the mayor this question.

173
00:21:34.017 --> 00:21:40.618
<v Steve Novick>If we have $75 million of PSF money to spend in the Moda Center, why don't we have $2.1 million to spend maintaining the pre-permitting program?

174
00:21:45.541 --> 00:21:48.426
<v Keith Wilson>I think that's a false choice if we're looking at that, Councilor.

175
00:21:49.243 --> 00:21:53.057
<v Keith Wilson>We have to look at funding our tree program, which is PCF-driven.

176
00:21:53.314 --> 00:22:03.313
<v Keith Wilson>But if we're looking at the Moda Center, we're looking at the upgrades that are focused on making that platinum LEED to make it a state-of-the-art facility.

177
00:22:03.648 --> 00:22:05.957
<v Keith Wilson>I think we have to look at both, uh, together.

178
00:22:06.212 --> 00:22:12.498
<v Keith Wilson>I, I don't, I don't think that that's a I think that's a matter of let's look at what funding we have, value the Moto.

179
00:22:12.561 --> 00:22:15.320
<v Keith Wilson>We have to renovate the Moto one way or another.

180
00:22:15.528 --> 00:22:18.528
<v Keith Wilson>Let's look at the available funding and capital we have to get that project going.

181
00:22:18.896 --> 00:22:20.339
<v Steve Novick>But Mayor, you have made that choice.

182
00:22:20.820 --> 00:22:33.538
<v Steve Novick>You have said that you want to spend $75 million of PSF money on the Moto Center, but you have not proposed spending $2.9 million of PSF money to continue the tree permitting program, and you're proposing slashing the tree permitting program.

183
00:22:33.586 --> 00:22:35.673
<v Steve Novick>So I Submit, sir, you already have made that choice.

184
00:22:35.962 --> 00:22:36.172
<v Keith Wilson>Right.

185
00:22:36.525 --> 00:22:41.196
<v Keith Wilson>This council last year determined to move the tree program over to Eric's shop.

186
00:22:41.357 --> 00:22:42.561
<v Keith Wilson>So we're following that through.

187
00:22:43.124 --> 00:22:46.559
<v Keith Wilson>There was some funding disparities there that we're trying to fix.

188
00:22:46.896 --> 00:22:48.182
<v Keith Wilson>We don't have all the money to do it.

189
00:22:48.406 --> 00:22:49.852
<v Keith Wilson>Let's go back to the MOTU though.

190
00:22:51.071 --> 00:22:54.395
<v Keith Wilson>I've contemplated ways that we can fund the renovation.

191
00:22:55.151 --> 00:22:59.067
<v Keith Wilson>This council will be the arbiters and the final decision makers.

192
00:22:59.647 --> 00:23:03.141
<v Keith Wilson>What I'll provide to you is a discussion point and an opportunity for you.

193
00:23:03.528 --> 00:23:05.680
<v Keith Wilson>I'm not proposing that you take it or leave it.

194
00:23:05.808 --> 00:23:09.351
<v Keith Wilson>I'm asking for partnership with this council to find a way to renovate the Moda Center.

195
00:23:09.528 --> 00:23:18.644
<v Keith Wilson>That is one of the funding methods, but I'm absolutely open to any method that DCA Oliveira and this council chooses.

196
00:23:18.920 --> 00:23:24.359
<v Keith Wilson>My overall focus with Moda is let's renovate the Moda and get that project moving forward.

197
00:23:26.074 --> 00:23:27.421
<v Donnie Oliveira>Okay, Councilor, may I—.

198
00:23:27.500 --> 00:23:27.965
<v Steve Novick>Yes, thank you.

199
00:23:28.061 --> 00:23:30.980
<v Donnie Oliveira>May I respond to the specific to the tree program related to PCF?

200
00:23:31.059 --> 00:23:31.461
<v Donnie Oliveira>Is that okay?

201
00:23:31.509 --> 00:23:31.846
<v Donnie Oliveira>Is that okay?

202
00:23:31.894 --> 00:23:33.657
<v Donnie Oliveira>Because I think it's a fair question.

203
00:23:34.972 --> 00:23:40.455
<v Donnie Oliveira>Just for context for everybody here, we got the directive, uh, through the last budget to move the program over.

204
00:23:41.049 --> 00:23:49.323
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, the teams at Parks and, and PP&D, I think, did a great job of landing that plane with, with sort of constraints around the funding that only came over was PCF, right?

205
00:23:49.386 --> 00:23:53.027
<v Donnie Oliveira>There was a much more complicated braiding of funding that the Parks was managing for.

206
00:23:53.299 --> 00:23:54.839
<v Donnie Oliveira>Totally understand that.

207
00:23:54.839 --> 00:23:58.480
<v Donnie Oliveira>To answer your question, why didn't we add PSF dollars to make that whole?

208
00:23:59.319 --> 00:24:04.079
<v Donnie Oliveira>Frankly, because Parks also is sort of the manager of the PSF funds related to urban forestry.

209
00:24:04.539 --> 00:24:11.759
<v Donnie Oliveira>And to their credit, they have been looking at ways to move some of those dollars from PSF— or excuse me, from Parks that are PSF funding to PP&D.

210
00:24:11.759 --> 00:24:13.140
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's just going to take a little bit more time.

211
00:24:13.539 --> 00:24:20.400
<v Donnie Oliveira>But as we were building the budget, it wasn't appropriate to go into Parks and pull out resources for programming that was staying behind, right?

212
00:24:20.400 --> 00:24:23.359
<v Donnie Oliveira>So when we moved the program over for permitting and enforcement for Title 11, right.

213
00:24:25.953 --> 00:24:29.759
<v Donnie Oliveira>$3.5 Million, I would say roughly, was what came with it.

214
00:24:30.434 --> 00:24:32.634
<v Donnie Oliveira>And we did our best with that dollar amount.

215
00:24:33.663 --> 00:24:42.751
<v Steve Novick>But you don't need Parks' permission to say that PCF money should go— I mean, I'm addressing this more to the mayor— to say that PCF money should cover something.

216
00:24:42.799 --> 00:24:44.663
<v Steve Novick>I mean, I don't think that it did.

217
00:24:44.983 --> 00:24:47.345
<v Steve Novick>You're talking about moving PCF money to PMO.

218
00:24:47.939 --> 00:24:52.290
<v Steve Novick>I don't think you needed the permission of the bureaus that money would come from in order to do that.

219
00:24:52.948 --> 00:24:55.625
<v Steve Novick>So I don't understand why the same procedure couldn't have applied.

220
00:24:56.201 --> 00:24:58.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>And Councilor, you're at 6 minutes right now.

221
00:24:58.205 --> 00:24:58.750
<v Steve Novick>How many do I have?

222
00:24:59.023 --> 00:24:59.808
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're at 6 minutes already.

223
00:24:59.888 --> 00:25:00.402
<v Steve Novick>Okay, I'm done.

224
00:25:00.722 --> 00:25:03.160
<v Steve Novick>All right, thank you.

225
00:25:04.073 --> 00:25:04.762
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

226
00:25:04.939 --> 00:25:05.627
<v Eric Kooch>Welcome.

227
00:25:06.093 --> 00:25:06.413
<v Steve Novick>Cool.

228
00:25:07.199 --> 00:25:07.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

229
00:25:08.224 --> 00:25:09.171
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor President.

230
00:25:09.748 --> 00:25:13.884
<v Olivia Clark>Just a quick comment on your comparison chart on page 15.

231
00:25:14.028 --> 00:25:15.694
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that you did that.

232
00:25:16.079 --> 00:25:19.924
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm just wondering, this does not include the fee increase does it?

233
00:25:20.069 --> 00:25:20.878
<v Olivia Clark>This is the current?

234
00:25:21.347 --> 00:25:22.027
<v Eric Kooch>Correct.

235
00:25:22.641 --> 00:25:26.958
<v Olivia Clark>It would be helpful to see, you know, if we change the fees, what the comparison would be.

236
00:25:27.571 --> 00:25:29.444
<v Olivia Clark>Do we still rank in the middle like that?

237
00:25:30.073 --> 00:25:40.261
<v Eric Kooch>Councilor, the, the issue— the reason why we weren't able to do that is we don't know if the other jurisdictions are going to change their fees as well, so we wouldn't know where their numbers are at currently.

238
00:25:40.715 --> 00:25:40.991
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

239
00:25:41.528 --> 00:25:45.082
<v Olivia Clark>Well, in any event, I, I really value that comparison.

240
00:25:45.276 --> 00:25:45.567
<v Olivia Clark>Sure.

241
00:25:45.973 --> 00:25:46.476
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

242
00:25:47.335 --> 00:25:48.647
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

243
00:25:49.297 --> 00:25:49.992
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

244
00:25:51.548 --> 00:25:52.506
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

245
00:25:52.942 --> 00:26:01.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I have a couple of questions, maybe going back even before the line of questioning that Councilor Novick was on about the tree permitting program.

246
00:26:02.297 --> 00:26:06.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It sounds like what happened is we didn't move enough funding over last year.

247
00:26:07.036 --> 00:26:07.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

248
00:26:08.016 --> 00:26:09.992
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We thought there was enough funding there and there was not?

249
00:26:10.329 --> 00:26:10.796
<v Eric Kooch>Yes, Councilor.

250
00:26:11.390 --> 00:26:11.567
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

251
00:26:16.240 --> 00:26:18.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Separate question, and then I'll ask about the funding.

252
00:26:18.182 --> 00:26:22.964
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How much of a delay should Portlanders expect with this level of reduction?

253
00:26:23.462 --> 00:26:24.971
<v Eric Kooch>That's a, that's a great question.

254
00:26:25.147 --> 00:26:33.253
<v Eric Kooch>I don't know the exact, the exact additional time it's going to take, but there will be increases in the amount of time for customers to get a permit.

255
00:26:33.351 --> 00:26:36.897
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we talking about an increase of a week or 2, or an increase of a month or 2?

256
00:26:37.041 --> 00:26:43.778
<v Eric Kooch>I, I don't want to lie to you and give you incorrect information, I was trying to have that information in front of me before today's presentation.

257
00:26:43.939 --> 00:26:48.090
<v Eric Kooch>Unfortunately, we're still working on that, but if it's okay, I can provide that information to you at a later date.

258
00:26:48.202 --> 00:26:55.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It would be helpful to have that before we make our final budget decisions, because if this is a matter of a week or 2, I'm frankly less concerned.

259
00:26:55.096 --> 00:27:04.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If this is a matter of 2 or 3 or 4 months delay, then I get a little bit more concerned about the program actually working and Portlanders being able to move forward with their plans.

260
00:27:04.857 --> 00:27:06.891
<v Eric Kooch>Yes, Councilor, we'll, we'll get that over to Thank you.

261
00:27:07.164 --> 00:27:08.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, I appreciate it.

262
00:27:08.678 --> 00:27:24.863
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, on the funding side, I, I know I have other colleagues who are going to be going to dig deeper into what our possibilities are here, but I want to understand a little bit more what went wrong.

263
00:27:25.218 --> 00:27:27.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we thought that there was enough money moving over.

264
00:27:28.932 --> 00:27:29.724
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There wasn't.

265
00:27:29.982 --> 00:27:39.579
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Was that because we did not take enough PCF dollars, or was that because there were more funds of other types supporting these programs?

266
00:27:40.317 --> 00:27:42.467
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, what happened?

267
00:27:42.964 --> 00:27:44.296
<v Eric Kooch>Yeah, that's a great question.

268
00:27:44.344 --> 00:27:55.252
<v Eric Kooch>To my understanding, what happened, Councilor, is that whenever they decided to send those PCF funds along with the positions, they only included the amount that the positions would cost.

269
00:27:55.574 --> 00:28:04.253
<v Eric Kooch>They didn't include our indirect costs so, you know, for example, the overhead that's calculated as well into those positions.

270
00:28:04.611 --> 00:28:06.055
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What are those indirect costs?

271
00:28:08.150 --> 00:28:11.262
<v Eric Kooch>It'd be things— it'd just be, you know, typical things in our overhead.

272
00:28:11.326 --> 00:28:20.271
<v Eric Kooch>So it'd be like, you know, the cost of maintaining our facilities, you know, electricity for the building, things like that.

273
00:28:20.336 --> 00:28:23.654
<v Eric Kooch>I could get you a more detailed list later when we send you that other information.

274
00:28:24.484 --> 00:28:28.272
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So do you split the way that you budget at PP&D?

275
00:28:28.353 --> 00:28:37.596
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you split things like the cost of electricity in the building per person working in that building as opposed to having a separate line item for facilities costs?

276
00:28:40.259 --> 00:28:42.759
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, if I just jump in, uh, thank you for the question.

277
00:28:43.583 --> 00:28:55.400
<v Donnie Oliveira>The fundamental, like, step that happened is when council adopted the amendment that moved the program over isolating PCF, that wasn't the full funding for the whole program.

278
00:28:55.913 --> 00:29:01.403
<v Donnie Oliveira>So Parks had other resources that supported the full suite of, of funding budget needs, right?

279
00:29:01.451 --> 00:29:07.439
<v Donnie Oliveira>So whether it be general fund— and actually, uh, Director Szymanski's in the office, in the room, to maybe help out here.

280
00:29:07.807 --> 00:29:11.917
<v Donnie Oliveira>But the bottom line is what landed in terms of resources was just the PCF amount.

281
00:29:12.528 --> 00:29:20.266
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so because they're— uh, PPD is a fee-based, uh, bureau, they didn't have like the sort of discretionary dollars to make the whole system whole.

282
00:29:20.329 --> 00:29:25.259
<v Donnie Oliveira>Think about office space, vehicles, all the things the staff need to do their jobs, right?

283
00:29:25.307 --> 00:29:29.739
<v Donnie Oliveira>So there's a— there was just a fundamental, like, difference of how the accounting landed at PP&D.

284
00:29:30.348 --> 00:29:40.416
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What I'm trying to understand is we worked pretty hard last year to make sure we had the right number here, and there were a lot of iterations of this amendment and some back and forth to get those dollars right.

285
00:29:41.284 --> 00:29:52.587
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think I'm hearing that we did move over enough funding for the positions, and I'm trying to understand what the other funding is so that we can think about if we want to address this, how we do that.

286
00:29:52.667 --> 00:30:07.006
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because if this is a matter of electrical costs, I'm a little bit confused of how moving a new unit increased those electrical costs, and I'm wondering if we're subsidizing between divisions in a different way than we had before.

287
00:30:07.199 --> 00:30:14.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If the issue is vehicles and vehicles didn't get moved over with the positions, that we might address differently.

288
00:30:14.994 --> 00:30:24.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So understanding if we moved over enough money to fund the positions, why we don't now have enough money, where it is that that gap is, is helpful.

289
00:30:24.231 --> 00:30:28.288
<v Donnie Oliveira>It was about the— the answer is PSF was predominantly funding personnel.

290
00:30:28.865 --> 00:30:29.090
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

291
00:30:29.346 --> 00:30:35.215
<v Donnie Oliveira>So the dollar— the money came over for the personnel, but all the associated costs of running that program did not.

292
00:30:35.279 --> 00:30:39.465
<v Donnie Oliveira>And those for the notes, we're generally general fund and parks levy dollars at parks.

293
00:30:40.106 --> 00:30:52.999
<v Donnie Oliveira>So when— if hypothetically a scenario would have looked like if you were going to move the program, you would have taken all the PCF dollars and general fund and parks levy and moved it all with to make them keep the program whole at PP&D.

294
00:30:53.480 --> 00:30:59.942
<v Donnie Oliveira>But because PCF is the only amount that came over, we were left to manage the program just with PCF dollars.

295
00:31:00.631 --> 00:31:09.022
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we're cutting personnel so that we can cover those other costs that are non-personnel related that are essential to do the work, right?

296
00:31:09.653 --> 00:31:21.622
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if we want to restore this, we need to either think about restoring positions or think about, as we think about buckets that can cover different things, funding for what?

297
00:31:22.256 --> 00:31:24.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Cars, office space, electricity?

298
00:31:26.930 --> 00:31:32.992
<v Donnie Oliveira>If you're talking about funding the program, we would be adding resources to keep the staff, but inclusive of all the tools they need to do their jobs.

299
00:31:33.923 --> 00:31:34.068
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

300
00:31:34.374 --> 00:31:43.461
<v Donnie Oliveira>We'd really want to shy away from isolating staff and space and computers and vehicles, the tools they need.

301
00:31:43.942 --> 00:31:46.432
<v Donnie Oliveira>If you just fund the staff but they don't have the tools, then we don't have a program either.

302
00:31:47.074 --> 00:31:54.412
<v Donnie Oliveira>So basically, what you're asking me is the resources, the gap that we have now is all-inclusive of the thing we need to run the program.

303
00:31:56.400 --> 00:31:56.803
<v Loretta Smith>Holistically.

304
00:31:56.898 --> 00:31:57.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>And, Councilor, you're at 6 minutes.

305
00:31:58.044 --> 00:31:58.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

306
00:31:58.769 --> 00:32:00.124
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks, Councilor President.

307
00:32:00.542 --> 00:32:01.430
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

308
00:32:01.509 --> 00:32:02.058
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

309
00:32:03.832 --> 00:32:04.332
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you.

310
00:32:04.492 --> 00:32:06.329
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to pick up where Steve Novick left off.

311
00:32:06.732 --> 00:32:08.696
<v Mitch Green>Um, Councilor Novick, apologies.

312
00:32:09.631 --> 00:32:10.662
<v Steve Novick>Um, Novick is fine.

313
00:32:10.935 --> 00:32:13.012
<v Donnie Oliveira>Novick.

314
00:32:13.335 --> 00:32:25.825
<v Mitch Green>Um, so when council made that decision to move these people over from one part of the city to the other, The intent was not to erode a program capability.

315
00:32:26.324 --> 00:32:38.563
<v Mitch Green>The intent was to sort of say, and maybe it was a bad idea, but the choice that we made was to say, we think it should be in a different part of the organization for reasons that are about management, oversight, control, and all that.

316
00:32:39.065 --> 00:32:45.125
<v Mitch Green>The intent was never to say, well, we also want to envision fewer people operating at a lower level.

317
00:32:45.173 --> 00:32:45.934
<v Mitch Green>I think that's what we're hearing.

318
00:32:46.705 --> 00:32:55.431
<v Mitch Green>And I'm extremely troubled to hear that our solution to this might actually be amending Title 11 code to take away some of the compliance requirements.

319
00:32:56.105 --> 00:32:59.071
<v Mitch Green>And so that's going to be a non-starter for me.

320
00:33:00.114 --> 00:33:15.430
<v Mitch Green>I will note that this council also approved an amendment to the CIP earlier this year, just maybe a month or 2 ago, that increased the funding allocation to Strategic Program 22, which is the Green Stormwater Infrastructure and Watershed Plan.

321
00:33:15.493 --> 00:33:15.878
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Dan Ryan.

322
00:33:16.056 --> 00:33:20.724
<v Mitch Green>Shed Health Program by $5 million, $5.5 million roughly.

323
00:33:22.534 --> 00:33:39.030
<v Mitch Green>That's the program here that envisions things like Natural Systems O&M program manages over 800 acres of natural areas and stormwater facilities, planting millions of trees, other plants that significantly contribute to carbon sequestration, biodiversity, and on and on and on and on.

324
00:33:39.289 --> 00:33:47.863
<v Mitch Green>So this bucket of money, which is now a total of $75 million, envisions taking care of trees as part of our BES system.

325
00:33:48.969 --> 00:33:55.319
<v Mitch Green>Now, what the mayor has done in the budget is take that $5 million and move it to PIMO.

326
00:33:55.785 --> 00:34:00.242
<v Mitch Green>And I'm not sure that the intent was to raise this by that much so you can then move it to PIMO, but that's what happened.

327
00:34:00.692 --> 00:34:18.429
<v Mitch Green>And so the idea that we're going to cut the tree code, which is a direct nexus to Strategic Program 22, which has PCF money for it, while also making an extremely strained argument of a connection to this program to PMO is frankly egregious.

328
00:34:18.864 --> 00:34:25.817
<v Mitch Green>And so as we approach the budget amendments, colleagues, this is an area that we need to be looking at very closely.

329
00:34:26.458 --> 00:34:31.570
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to tolerate cuts to the tree code people in this budget, and we have money in the PCF fund to do that.

330
00:34:31.634 --> 00:34:33.001
<v Mitch Green>So we'll be looking at an amendment there.

331
00:34:33.708 --> 00:34:34.913
<v Mitch Green>I think that's about all I want to say right now.

332
00:34:34.961 --> 00:34:35.074
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

333
00:34:35.527 --> 00:34:37.358
<v Keith Wilson>Council President, may I?

334
00:34:38.306 --> 00:34:39.302
<v Keith Wilson>Councilor Green, thank you so much.

335
00:34:39.367 --> 00:34:46.144
<v Keith Wilson>I'm gonna just talk about high level and then Donnie, correct me if I'm wrong, but Portland Solutions will have this in there.

336
00:34:47.141 --> 00:34:54.224
<v Keith Wilson>I believe the PMO is being funded through Package 2, Revitalizing Urban Walking Routes.

337
00:34:54.947 --> 00:35:05.181
<v Keith Wilson>And the 3 particular tranches are pathway and sidewalk lighting enhancement, Green space cleaning and urban realm activations and biking and walking.

338
00:35:05.777 --> 00:35:09.344
<v Keith Wilson>Donnie, can you correct me or do we defer?

339
00:35:09.407 --> 00:35:11.317
<v Keith Wilson>I just wanna make sure we correct the record.

340
00:35:11.835 --> 00:35:19.472
<v Keith Wilson>I don't think it was SP22, but I just wanna make sure that we're providing the right information.

341
00:35:20.003 --> 00:35:21.903
<v Keith Wilson>I noticed Sam's not here, so.

342
00:35:22.161 --> 00:35:23.659
<v Donnie Oliveira>I'm looking, I'm pulling it up right now.

343
00:35:26.101 --> 00:35:38.119
<v Donnie Oliveira>It is predominantly coming out of, SP language— excuse me, out of funding from BES and PBOT related to SP5.

344
00:35:38.777 --> 00:35:39.918
<v Donnie Oliveira>There's a portion perhaps.

345
00:35:40.737 --> 00:35:41.750
<v Donnie Oliveira>I'll have to get back to you, Councilor.

346
00:35:41.831 --> 00:35:44.996
<v Keith Wilson>Yeah, let's provide that information so we're really consistent.

347
00:35:45.059 --> 00:35:47.452
<v Keith Wilson>This is obviously going to be a germane topic, so we want to make sure—.

348
00:35:47.452 --> 00:35:48.228
<v Mitch Green>That'd be helpful.

349
00:35:48.293 --> 00:35:55.405
<v Mitch Green>I didn't see that description in the program offer and decision package, and so all I had to go on was the documents that were released on April 3rd.

350
00:35:55.775 --> 00:35:59.387
<v Mitch Green>Which were the original concepts that did reference Strategic Program 22.

351
00:36:00.045 --> 00:36:03.577
<v Mitch Green>So it's going to be really important that you guys update that for the public.

352
00:36:04.300 --> 00:36:11.378
<v Mitch Green>But nevertheless, if it's not coming from '22, that means there's $5 more million there now than there was last year.

353
00:36:11.668 --> 00:36:16.210
<v Mitch Green>And so, colleagues, we have money in this budget to allocate to these positions being cut.

354
00:36:16.500 --> 00:36:16.740
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

355
00:36:17.126 --> 00:36:19.485
<v Donnie Oliveira>No, actually, Councilor Mayor, I do have the answer.

356
00:36:19.567 --> 00:36:25.969
<v Donnie Oliveira>So broadly speaking, and I want to just acknowledge that we're still working with CBO to get this actual information to you.

357
00:36:26.083 --> 00:36:37.278
<v Donnie Oliveira>So the draft understanding is the $5.x million would roughly come from SP32, SP22, and SP31.

358
00:36:39.574 --> 00:36:40.318
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

359
00:36:40.626 --> 00:36:41.353
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

360
00:36:41.677 --> 00:36:42.628
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

361
00:36:43.110 --> 00:36:50.489
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'd like to know how often the permitting bureau accesses or pursues funding through the Portland Clean Energy Fund.

362
00:36:50.670 --> 00:36:56.677
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So like, what capacity or experience does, um, this department have in navigating that process?

363
00:36:57.161 --> 00:36:57.889
<v Eric Kooch>That's a—.

364
00:36:57.889 --> 00:36:58.099
<v Michael Bonaccor>Sorry.

365
00:36:58.373 --> 00:37:00.016
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, uh, thanks for the question, Councilor.

366
00:37:00.610 --> 00:37:07.954
<v Donnie Oliveira>Uh, in the past, there has been a program that BPS worked with PP&D on a solar, like, efficiency, like, to improve solar permitting.

367
00:37:08.018 --> 00:37:12.184
<v Donnie Oliveira>But this is the first time that PP&D has received PSF dollars.

368
00:37:14.425 --> 00:37:16.096
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, thank you for clarifying that.

369
00:37:16.686 --> 00:37:33.498
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, um, thinking about Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's question about the funding and how we're in the place that we're at, how much of us making the cut to those, I think it was 10 FTE before moving them over, how much of that plays a role in where we're at right now?

370
00:37:36.579 --> 00:37:41.161
<v Donnie Oliveira>In a role, can you clarify, Councilor, a role of in terms of our gap in permit timelines?

371
00:37:41.291 --> 00:37:41.452
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

372
00:37:41.614 --> 00:37:43.298
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yes, and not having the right funding.

373
00:37:45.315 --> 00:37:52.931
<v Donnie Oliveira>Oh, that's— I mean, we are— the proposal in front of you is directly correlated to landing the program in the Bureau and the results of that.

374
00:37:54.929 --> 00:38:13.617
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I do share concerns that my colleagues shared about how it just makes so much sense because PCEF has so much alignment with canopy and equity goals that I'd like to see all these positions fully funded through PCEF and hope to see a plan and timeline to help make sure that does happen.

375
00:38:16.360 --> 00:38:16.873
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, thank you.

376
00:38:16.938 --> 00:38:20.536
<v Donnie Oliveira>And I, I just want to reiterate, I want to give Parks leadership a lot of credit.

377
00:38:20.615 --> 00:38:24.648
<v Donnie Oliveira>They have been leaning in to figure out how they help us bridge this gap.

378
00:38:25.048 --> 00:38:25.690
<v Donnie Oliveira>They're aware of it too.

379
00:38:25.771 --> 00:38:26.606
<v Donnie Oliveira>It impacts them as well.

380
00:38:27.940 --> 00:38:33.416
<v Donnie Oliveira>But again, you know, a lot of the resources from PSF 4 or the urban canopy live with Parks because they do most of the planning.

381
00:38:33.481 --> 00:38:37.768
<v Donnie Oliveira>I mean, most of those dollars that went to Parks wasn't for regulatory elements.

382
00:38:37.833 --> 00:38:42.201
<v Donnie Oliveira>It really was to, you know, have people protecting the trees, planting trees, Maintaining.

383
00:38:43.097 --> 00:38:48.869
<v Donnie Oliveira>So the portion that was PSF-funded that was on the regulatory side moved over to PP&D, which was a very small percentage.

384
00:38:48.949 --> 00:38:55.039
<v Donnie Oliveira>But kudos to Parks and their willingness to partner with us to figure out how to get more of those dollars over to help.

385
00:38:55.521 --> 00:38:55.824
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

386
00:38:56.161 --> 00:38:57.588
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm glad they've been great partners.

387
00:38:57.844 --> 00:39:01.692
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And it makes sense to me that it's been challenging just moving that part out of it.

388
00:39:02.172 --> 00:39:14.137
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And Director, I just wanted to make sure that I clarify, I recognize that you are very new here and appreciate you, appreciated you coming to our committee yesterday and hope you know none of this is a referendum on, on your work at all.

389
00:39:14.737 --> 00:39:15.208
<v Eric Kooch>Thank you, Councilor.

390
00:39:17.222 --> 00:39:18.315
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

391
00:39:18.990 --> 00:39:19.521
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

392
00:39:19.778 --> 00:39:24.684
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, President Dunphy, and thank you, Donnie, and permitting Eric for this portion of the presentation.

393
00:39:26.025 --> 00:39:38.329
<v Dan Ryan>Um, looking at the staff reductions and hearing most are from tree permitting and core service alignment, then I look back at the slides that compare us to other markets and Oh, it's up on this screen right now.

394
00:39:38.409 --> 00:39:40.750
<v Dan Ryan>So, you know, it's tolerable.

395
00:39:41.074 --> 00:39:46.626
<v Dan Ryan>And when you look at it this way, but we all know that time is money and you mentioned that.

396
00:39:46.755 --> 00:39:58.456
<v Dan Ryan>I do wish there could be another data point next to it that has something that could measure time, like issuance of permits to whatever, apples and apples with the other markets.

397
00:39:58.940 --> 00:40:00.827
<v Dan Ryan>'Cause I know there's several data points after that.

398
00:40:01.101 --> 00:40:04.231
<v Dan Ryan>Anyway, my question is this, when it comes to staffing, the reason why—.

399
00:40:04.262 --> 00:40:04.523
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

400
00:40:05.438 --> 00:40:12.239
<v Dan Ryan>After going back to the last century, people being very upset with Portland in terms of customer service for permitting.

401
00:40:12.817 --> 00:40:17.405
<v Dan Ryan>And then we started a very difficult reform journey.

402
00:40:18.047 --> 00:40:22.907
<v Dan Ryan>It was the first one that's been successful after several failed attempts from previous councils.

403
00:40:23.485 --> 00:40:25.940
<v Dan Ryan>And one reason that we're— I know the reason it worked.

404
00:40:25.987 --> 00:40:28.186
<v Dan Ryan>It worked 'cause we put staffing into the equation.

405
00:40:28.315 --> 00:40:32.324
<v Dan Ryan>So we had a continuous improvement staffing led by Terri Tyson and her team.

406
00:40:32.806 --> 00:40:34.202
<v Dan Ryan>And that's the reason why we've seen movement.

407
00:40:34.251 --> 00:40:34.411
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

408
00:40:34.893 --> 00:40:35.664
<v Dan Ryan>Over the last 3 years.

409
00:40:35.936 --> 00:40:36.981
<v Dan Ryan>That's exactly why.

410
00:40:37.077 --> 00:40:38.925
<v Dan Ryan>It wasn't because of elected officials.

411
00:40:38.989 --> 00:40:41.802
<v Dan Ryan>We passed policy before, but nothing ever moved.

412
00:40:42.204 --> 00:40:49.117
<v Dan Ryan>So the culture change was because we had those patient and persistent professionals working with those folks in permitting.

413
00:40:49.795 --> 00:40:52.869
<v Dan Ryan>Is that team going to remain intact as we go forward?

414
00:40:54.690 --> 00:40:56.072
<v Eric Kooch>Well, that's an excellent question.

415
00:40:56.983 --> 00:41:03.900
<v Eric Kooch>We're actually working on Cap 2, and Cap 2 kicked off last Would you explain that acronym?

416
00:41:05.333 --> 00:41:05.815
<v Eric Kooch>CAP2.

417
00:41:06.940 --> 00:41:08.244
<v Jamie Dunphy>Code Alignment Project.

418
00:41:08.389 --> 00:41:09.451
<v Eric Kooch>Yeah, Code Alignment Project.

419
00:41:09.579 --> 00:41:09.804
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

420
00:41:09.853 --> 00:41:11.416
<v Dan Ryan>People do ask me all the time, what does that mean?

421
00:41:11.545 --> 00:41:11.753
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

422
00:41:12.817 --> 00:41:13.123
<v Eric Kooch>You're welcome.

423
00:41:13.541 --> 00:41:25.163
<v Eric Kooch>And yeah, like I was saying, so we're looking to build on that momentum with CAP2 to continue to better our processes and looking at areas to right-size our code.

424
00:41:25.226 --> 00:41:26.014
<v Dan Ryan>That's exactly what I'm asking.

425
00:41:26.148 --> 00:41:26.724
<v Dan Ryan>The question.

426
00:41:26.789 --> 00:41:32.760
<v Dan Ryan>So you have staffing so that can continue to build, that momentum can build, and we could continue to get results that go the right direction?

427
00:41:33.032 --> 00:41:41.443
<v Eric Kooch>We, uh, we, we plan on going to council later to ask for funding to, to build a team, uh, that we can, uh, have help support Cap 2.

428
00:41:42.166 --> 00:41:45.856
<v Dan Ryan>Um, have a team, but we're going to eliminate a team, and then you're going to ask us to rebuild that team?

429
00:41:45.952 --> 00:41:46.306
<v Loretta Smith>I'm confused.

430
00:41:46.355 --> 00:41:48.650
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, sorry, to clarify, I have 5 minutes, so that's fine.

431
00:41:48.697 --> 00:41:49.500
<v Donnie Oliveira>Sorry, real quick.

432
00:41:49.565 --> 00:41:54.123
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we have staff at BPS who are leading Cap to staff that came from the PIT team.

433
00:41:54.862 --> 00:41:57.945
<v Donnie Oliveira>They're coordinating, but it's actually going to be a multi-bureau effort.

434
00:41:57.992 --> 00:42:03.740
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we have staff at PBOT and Water, Parks, PP&D, and BPS that are all working on Cap 2.

435
00:42:04.574 --> 00:42:11.945
<v Donnie Oliveira>What the director's referring to is we're working with the council president on a resolution that will look to broaden beyond Cap 2 the scope.

436
00:42:11.992 --> 00:42:13.260
<v Dan Ryan>Oh, I'm getting involved in that resolution.

437
00:42:13.309 --> 00:42:14.496
<v Dan Ryan>That's why I'm kind of asking the question.

438
00:42:14.594 --> 00:42:22.423
<v Dan Ryan>And I realize that's separate, but I just don't want us to get rid of the Muscle memory, if you will, and strength that we've built to do this culture change work.

439
00:42:22.472 --> 00:42:23.081
<v Donnie Oliveira>We definitely have.

440
00:42:23.193 --> 00:42:25.920
<v Donnie Oliveira>We've maintained momentum on the code alignment work.

441
00:42:26.143 --> 00:42:26.528
<v Donnie Oliveira>Absolutely.

442
00:42:26.961 --> 00:42:27.507
<v Donnie Oliveira>That has not stopped.

443
00:42:27.556 --> 00:42:30.137
<v Dan Ryan>The answer to my question though is those positions have been eliminated.

444
00:42:30.393 --> 00:42:30.987
<v Angelita Morillo>Yep.

445
00:42:31.291 --> 00:42:32.335
<v Dan Ryan>That's what I was trying to get at.

446
00:42:32.735 --> 00:42:33.889
<v Donnie Oliveira>No, sorry, Councilor.

447
00:42:34.179 --> 00:42:35.894
<v Donnie Oliveira>They've just been dispersed in different places.

448
00:42:35.943 --> 00:42:37.739
<v Donnie Oliveira>So there's a position in PP&D.

449
00:42:38.445 --> 00:42:40.465
<v Donnie Oliveira>The code leadership is at BPS now.

450
00:42:40.898 --> 00:42:42.148
<v Donnie Oliveira>They're just not at the service level.

451
00:42:43.384 --> 00:42:43.896
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's what changed.

452
00:42:44.907 --> 00:42:47.041
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, can I get more information offline on that?

453
00:42:47.248 --> 00:42:47.409
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

454
00:42:47.585 --> 00:42:49.541
<v Dan Ryan>It's not making total sense.

455
00:42:49.878 --> 00:42:53.086
<v Dan Ryan>And I'll go ahead and stop at 3:33.

456
00:42:53.342 --> 00:42:53.583
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

457
00:42:53.744 --> 00:42:54.882
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

458
00:42:55.972 --> 00:42:56.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

459
00:42:58.315 --> 00:42:59.356
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

460
00:42:59.581 --> 00:43:00.672
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks for this presentation.

461
00:43:01.025 --> 00:43:06.717
<v Angelita Morillo>I wanna follow a little bit on the line of questioning that Councilor Novick had and Councilor Koyama Lane had.

462
00:43:07.376 --> 00:43:08.193
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yay, District 3.

463
00:43:09.782 --> 00:43:18.367
<v Angelita Morillo>Can you describe the impacts to the cuts in urban forestry that we had last year, specifically on customer service, tree canopy preservation, that sort of thing?

464
00:43:28.416 --> 00:43:33.710
<v Eric Kooch>So the question is, how did the cuts to tree permitting last year affect our timelines?

465
00:43:33.807 --> 00:43:35.119
<v Eric Kooch>I'm sorry, can you repeat the question?

466
00:43:35.775 --> 00:43:54.141
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, I think I want to hear about the impacts of the amendments to gut urban forestry, how that has impacted us now that we've had time to take a look at it on customer service, how quickly people are getting their answers, tree canopy preservation, the whole point of the program.

467
00:43:54.204 --> 00:43:54.413
<v Eric Kooch>Gotcha.

468
00:43:54.461 --> 00:43:59.958
<v Eric Kooch>So I will say that since that program has moved over to PP&D, the timelines have increased.

469
00:44:01.112 --> 00:44:02.965
<v Eric Kooch>But what I want everyone—.

470
00:44:02.965 --> 00:44:03.367
<v Angelita Morillo>How much?

471
00:44:04.318 --> 00:44:07.925
<v Eric Kooch>I don't have those numbers in front of me, but they have definitely increased.

472
00:44:08.103 --> 00:44:09.068
<v Eric Kooch>And what I will say, though—.

473
00:44:09.068 --> 00:44:10.481
<v Angelita Morillo>And he said 2 weeks to 8 weeks.

474
00:44:10.713 --> 00:44:11.586
<v Angelita Morillo>Where'd you get those numbers?

475
00:44:11.686 --> 00:44:12.626
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>2 Weeks to 9 weeks.

476
00:44:15.534 --> 00:44:20.387
<v Eric Kooch>I think one important thing to remember is that within tree permitting, there's multiple programs.

477
00:44:20.780 --> 00:44:25.818
<v Eric Kooch>So I wouldn't know, you know, what those 2 weeks to 9 weeks numbers, which program in tree permitting that is.

478
00:44:26.402 --> 00:44:38.141
<v Eric Kooch>What I wanted to say real quick, Councilor, is that, you know, I've been a part of multiple permitting bureaus or permitting centers where we've had realignments where outside disciplines have had to come in.

479
00:44:38.755 --> 00:44:40.697
<v Eric Kooch>And that process is never perfect, right?

480
00:44:40.762 --> 00:44:42.461
<v Eric Kooch>You're bound to have some hiccups along the way.

481
00:44:42.963 --> 00:44:46.954
<v Eric Kooch>So while, you know, those timelines have increased, we are working to improve them.

482
00:44:47.148 --> 00:44:52.929
<v Eric Kooch>And I know that within the next year we can continue to improve those timelines to make it better for our customers.

483
00:44:53.565 --> 00:44:59.159
<v Eric Kooch>However, with that, these cuts, you know, will make it more difficult to improve those timelines.

484
00:44:59.271 --> 00:45:01.481
<v Eric Kooch>But anyways, I hope that answers your question.

485
00:45:02.860 --> 00:45:06.322
<v Angelita Morillo>It doesn't, but I suspect you will find me more details later.

486
00:45:06.465 --> 00:45:11.289
<v Angelita Morillo>And that's not— I want to be clear, that was a council decision that you were forced to live with.

487
00:45:11.432 --> 00:45:14.028
<v Angelita Morillo>I personally did not approve of gutting urban forestry.

488
00:45:14.094 --> 00:45:19.637
<v Angelita Morillo>So this is more of a caution to my colleagues about us bringing amendments and drastically changing thank you.

489
00:45:19.686 --> 00:45:33.317
<v Angelita Morillo>I am also keeping an eye on the cuts to our urban forestry programs because the reality is the reason when people come to Portland, they talk about how verdant and beautiful our city is and how green and lush, and that is in large part because of the work that urban forestry does.

490
00:45:33.847 --> 00:45:42.869
<v Angelita Morillo>So I am having an eye to those cuts as well, and it is not lost on me where we are choosing to use PCF dollars and what we're choosing not to use it for.

491
00:45:42.918 --> 00:45:44.715
<v Angelita Morillo>So thanks for your time.

492
00:45:44.827 --> 00:45:51.300
<v Angelita Morillo>I hope that we can get more specific details on how, what the long-term impacts of that change was.

493
00:45:51.717 --> 00:45:53.934
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, sorry, I do have an answer for you now.

494
00:45:54.143 --> 00:45:58.126
<v Donnie Oliveira>And I just wanna preface it by saying we are general— what I'm generalizing here is all types.

495
00:45:58.175 --> 00:46:00.664
<v Donnie Oliveira>There's various types of tree permits and actions.

496
00:46:01.146 --> 00:46:03.974
<v Donnie Oliveira>So this is just a generalized number, but it is accurate.

497
00:46:04.985 --> 00:46:13.012
<v Donnie Oliveira>Prior to the move to PP&D, a turnaround time for an inquiry was about 2 weeks and we're closer to about 6 to 7 weeks now.

498
00:46:14.563 --> 00:46:16.148
<v Angelita Morillo>That's a terrible change.

499
00:46:16.407 --> 00:46:18.574
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, Councilor Koyama Lane, did you have something to add?

500
00:46:18.768 --> 00:46:25.387
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I just wanted to share that we have a letter from the Urban Forestry Commission about some of the impacts that I am happy to forward to you.

501
00:46:27.724 --> 00:46:29.559
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Maria.

502
00:46:30.655 --> 00:46:31.282
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

503
00:46:32.199 --> 00:46:33.568
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

504
00:46:33.650 --> 00:46:36.097
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for the, um, presentation.

505
00:46:37.014 --> 00:46:50.474
<v Loretta Smith>I'm looking on slide 4 and it says Community and Economic Development, 695.3 proposed staff with a $1.235.5 million proposed budget.

506
00:46:51.184 --> 00:47:03.286
<v Loretta Smith>I imagine that that should be a billion because I cannot imagine that we're paying $1.2 million proposed budget for 695 employees.

507
00:47:04.000 --> 00:47:05.295
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, thanks for the question.

508
00:47:05.652 --> 00:47:21.396
<v Donnie Oliveira>That, that represents $1.2 billion, um, but that's inclusive of all the resources in the service area, including, uh, PSEF, ART tax, children's levy, uh, fund balances that we won't spend next fiscal year, um, that are just, you know, in our balanced budget.

509
00:47:21.476 --> 00:47:23.047
<v Donnie Oliveira>We, you know, we show them.

510
00:47:23.722 --> 00:47:42.086
<v Loretta Smith>So the reason why I, I wanted to see specifically how much were we spending in the community and economic development, um, that $1.235 needs to be changed, and I'm sure the public will look at this and say, how are they paying for 700 employees with $1.2 million?

511
00:47:42.780 --> 00:47:45.039
<v Loretta Smith>Do you see this on, on slide, uh, 4?

512
00:47:45.411 --> 00:47:46.393
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, we're looking at it.

513
00:47:46.780 --> 00:47:48.998
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, that doesn't make sense to me.

514
00:47:49.384 --> 00:47:50.188
<v Loretta Smith>It doesn't add up.

515
00:47:51.135 --> 00:47:51.425
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, that—.

516
00:47:51.842 --> 00:47:55.210
<v Loretta Smith>I can barely pay for my 5 employees with, with $1.2 million.

517
00:47:55.728 --> 00:47:58.679
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, that, that number is representing $1.2 billion.

518
00:47:58.726 --> 00:48:00.121
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's just framed in millions.

519
00:48:00.996 --> 00:48:01.353
<v Steve Novick>But you're right.

520
00:48:01.628 --> 00:48:02.097
<v Loretta Smith>So it's wrong.

521
00:48:02.757 --> 00:48:06.217
<v Loretta Smith>It's not $1.2 million, it is $1.2 billion.

522
00:48:07.527 --> 00:48:09.094
<v Loretta Smith>Can y'all, can y'all go back and change it?

523
00:48:09.143 --> 00:48:10.420
<v Loretta Smith>That's what I'm asking you because—.

524
00:48:10.614 --> 00:48:11.925
<v Donnie Oliveira>I would prefer to see you up there in the room.

525
00:48:11.972 --> 00:48:21.197
<v Loretta Smith>This is the second day, this is the second day that we have wrong information on our, on our documents that are seen by the public.

526
00:48:22.016 --> 00:48:32.648
<v Loretta Smith>And it is the second day I still can't item— see the itemized cost of a bureau in an Excel spreadsheet so I can see what was paid for the year before.

527
00:48:33.418 --> 00:48:36.661
<v Loretta Smith>I know, uh, our budget office and our CFO is in here.

528
00:48:37.192 --> 00:48:44.898
<v Loretta Smith>This is why we asked for this, because it, it makes it clear on what we did and what we took away.

529
00:48:45.362 --> 00:48:51.704
<v Loretta Smith>When you have these narratives that you put up here, it is so hard for us to understand— not to understand.

530
00:48:52.186 --> 00:49:00.907
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I have a lot of questions about what we did with the the Forester stuff, and, and my colleagues have— they have asked the right questions.

531
00:49:01.711 --> 00:49:14.557
<v Loretta Smith>Um, and my issue was, going back to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, was, is it the materials and services budget that didn't come over with those employees?

532
00:49:15.436 --> 00:49:20.675
<v Loretta Smith>That's what it sounds like to me, that the material and service— and why didn't it?

533
00:49:20.929 --> 00:49:23.539
<v Loretta Smith>You know, why did it not come over?

534
00:49:26.320 --> 00:49:32.690
<v Loretta Smith>Um, and the thought that you all are going to present us with something— and Eric, is that, is that your name?

535
00:49:32.690 --> 00:49:33.469
<v Eric Kooch>Yes, Councilor.

536
00:49:33.469 --> 00:49:34.360
<v Loretta Smith>Good to meet you.

537
00:49:34.650 --> 00:49:36.110
<v Eric Kooch>Nice to meet you.

538
00:49:36.170 --> 00:49:45.750
<v Loretta Smith>And to think that Eric is saying that we're going to put one thing forward and then you're going to come back and ask for more money, and I'm trying to figure out where you going to do that from.

539
00:49:45.940 --> 00:49:47.309
<v Loretta Smith>Are you talking about the TOW?

540
00:49:47.797 --> 00:49:50.635
<v Loretta Smith>Is that what you're expecting, to get additional resources from the TAO?

541
00:49:52.063 --> 00:49:53.202
<v Donnie Oliveira>No, no, no, Councilor.

542
00:49:53.282 --> 00:50:04.706
<v Donnie Oliveira>The one of the slides conveys the, the proposed fee schedule that would be an increase to sustain, uh, service level, um, and then in the fee, um, programs.

543
00:50:05.443 --> 00:50:13.385
<v Donnie Oliveira>And then the other conversation around urban forestry is just a proposed cut, so we weren't asking for resources for that at this moment.

544
00:50:13.882 --> 00:50:22.331
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, but I know he said something, we'll come back, we're going to have a group, and then we'll come back and get some more money, as if we're going to have a bump or something somewhere.

545
00:50:22.862 --> 00:50:30.396
<v Eric Kooch>I was, um, whenever— I think what you're referring to is whenever we're speaking about Cap 2, which is a, uh, a separate initiative.

546
00:50:30.733 --> 00:50:34.041
<v Eric Kooch>Um, and I probably kind of, uh, jumped the gun on that one a little bit.

547
00:50:34.266 --> 00:50:38.989
<v Eric Kooch>Um, but essentially, we, we already have a team in place that's driving Cap 2 right now, right?

548
00:50:39.070 --> 00:50:47.713
<v Eric Kooch>So I misspoke a little bit, but, um, in order to implement a resolution, if it does move forward, we would need, um, a larger team to help drive that progress.

549
00:50:47.760 --> 00:50:47.826
<v Eric Engstrom>Right.

550
00:50:47.938 --> 00:50:50.907
<v Loretta Smith>And so you said you were going to come back, um, and get the money.

551
00:50:50.987 --> 00:50:55.175
<v Loretta Smith>Were you thinking that was going to be in the TAO, or were you thinking later in this budget session?

552
00:50:56.730 --> 00:51:01.547
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, we're working with the council president's office on that, and we'll, we'll work with them to contemplate a strategy for resources.

553
00:51:03.726 --> 00:51:05.204
<v Loretta Smith>No, no, no, no, no, no, no.

554
00:51:06.393 --> 00:51:16.106
<v Loretta Smith>TCA Alvarado, no, no, no, you do not get to isolate everybody else and say you're just going to work with the council president's office when we're talking about the budget right now.

555
00:51:17.195 --> 00:51:22.789
<v Donnie Oliveira>Sorry, Councilor, I, I was only— the project that the director was referencing is something that's in the future.

556
00:51:23.302 --> 00:51:25.804
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's not, it's not, it's being drafted.

557
00:51:25.851 --> 00:51:27.838
<v Loretta Smith>Not going to happen in '26-'27?

558
00:51:28.896 --> 00:51:30.612
<v Donnie Oliveira>It may happen in '26-'27.

559
00:51:31.141 --> 00:51:38.197
<v Donnie Oliveira>The details of that resolution are directing the bureaus to come back with a plan, and that plan would likely need resources.

560
00:51:38.552 --> 00:51:40.646
<v Donnie Oliveira>We haven't gone— we haven't gone that far yet, Councilor.

561
00:51:40.726 --> 00:51:41.016
<v Donnie Oliveira>This is—.

562
00:51:41.692 --> 00:51:41.934
<v Steve Novick>We're—.

563
00:51:42.641 --> 00:51:43.237
<v Loretta Smith>I, I don't know.

564
00:51:43.286 --> 00:51:43.818
<v Donnie Oliveira>Very much in draft.

565
00:51:43.865 --> 00:51:55.570
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know how y'all think y'all going to talk about something dealing with money and, and put it in a resolution, and it's not in our budget document, unless you're doing something outside of this that we don't know about.

566
00:51:56.422 --> 00:51:57.097
<v Loretta Smith>And, and it's not—.

567
00:51:58.996 --> 00:51:59.960
<v Olivia Clark>DCA Oliveira.

568
00:52:00.242 --> 00:52:01.030
<v Loretta Smith>You know how I am.

569
00:52:01.592 --> 00:52:01.978
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yes, ma'am.

570
00:52:04.423 --> 00:52:05.630
<v Loretta Smith>And you can't do that.

571
00:52:06.032 --> 00:52:16.771
<v Loretta Smith>It, it is— you, again, this, this particular bureau has a history of spending money before it is authorized.

572
00:52:17.592 --> 00:52:19.005
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm going to go back to it again.

573
00:52:19.119 --> 00:52:19.713
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, yes, yes.

574
00:52:19.777 --> 00:52:28.393
<v Loretta Smith>Don't, don't give me that look like you don't know what I'm talking about, because we just finished a TAO where we spent $56 million that had— that was hidden by the Portland Housing Bureau.

575
00:52:28.523 --> 00:52:30.610
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, for the record, this is the Permitting Development Bureau.

576
00:52:30.724 --> 00:52:33.652
<v Loretta Smith>I know, but it's over the whole thing, and you give me this look like as if—.

577
00:52:33.717 --> 00:52:34.882
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor, we're at 6 minutes now.

578
00:52:35.603 --> 00:52:41.306
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, but, um, please bring us something forward and stop doing stuff offline.

579
00:52:45.476 --> 00:52:46.222
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

580
00:52:46.288 --> 00:52:47.050
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

581
00:52:48.463 --> 00:52:49.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>Hey, good morning.

582
00:52:49.681 --> 00:52:52.231
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, apologies for being a little late through your presentation.

583
00:52:52.311 --> 00:52:55.831
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm had to deal with a personal matter, but great to see you all.

584
00:52:56.045 --> 00:53:00.288
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I just want to, I appreciate the presentation.

585
00:53:00.353 --> 00:53:04.083
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate the direction you're taking the Bureau in terms of permitting development.

586
00:53:06.266 --> 00:53:12.851
<v Eric Zimmerman>It seems that, and I too, I share it with my colleagues, seems some confusion around the tree code changes, right?

587
00:53:12.900 --> 00:53:16.751
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just wanna reiterate what we did last year, which—.

588
00:53:16.784 --> 00:53:17.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

589
00:53:18.456 --> 00:53:34.485
<v Eric Zimmerman>Moved the 27 FTE and the $3.6 million that the Parks Bureau, the Parks Bureau told us was what paid for the tree code compliance staff, right?

590
00:53:34.550 --> 00:53:35.617
<v Eric Zimmerman>We don't make up those numbers.

591
00:53:35.666 --> 00:53:40.784
<v Eric Zimmerman>We took that from the Parks Bureau, the people who are sitting in the back right now who are not sitting in the hot seat right now.

592
00:53:40.849 --> 00:53:41.898
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'll just remind folks.

593
00:53:42.527 --> 00:53:54.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>So we used their numbers that they articulated in their budget last year that 27 full-time employee equivalents and $3.6 million of PCF money moved fully over to PP&D.

594
00:53:55.190 --> 00:54:06.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>All right, so I say that because, uh, that $3.6 million— because the Parks Bureau said that's what it takes to run this aspect of the program.

595
00:54:06.710 --> 00:54:18.641
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that I agree with some of the comments were said, and I know there's, there's disagreement on whether it was a good move or a bad move, but the idea was that code compliance needed to happen in a larger code compliance atmosphere.

596
00:54:19.315 --> 00:54:22.987
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it goes to the idea, if, if you're a hammer, you only see nails.

597
00:54:23.563 --> 00:54:28.132
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so the idea of code compliance is a holistic look at everything, and we have different codes.

598
00:54:28.389 --> 00:54:32.315
<v Eric Zimmerman>And since PP&D takes care of so much of that code compliance, that was really important.

599
00:54:32.893 --> 00:54:39.994
<v Eric Zimmerman>So using Parks Bureau, their words, their dollars, their numbers, their FTE, and moving it over.

600
00:54:40.074 --> 00:54:40.235
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

601
00:54:40.907 --> 00:54:56.516
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just wanna— I'm not sure how many members of the council are aware that in August of last year, the city administrator, not our current one, but the last one, the PP&D staff and the Parks Bureau staff came to me hat in hand, deeply embarrassed that they had wrong numbers.

602
00:54:58.114 --> 00:55:03.657
<v Eric Zimmerman>That when they said 27 people got paid for by a certain fund, they forgot to count.

603
00:55:04.190 --> 00:55:04.498
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

604
00:55:06.007 --> 00:55:08.476
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I want to highlight this.

605
00:55:08.766 --> 00:55:30.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's a great example for a first-year city administrator to understand that when you hear frustration, Mr. Lee, about, uh, what numbers are or are not accurate and whether or not we have spreadsheets or don't to look at this, this is the type of thing that, that bubbles up and becomes frustrating.

606
00:55:31.336 --> 00:55:51.931
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so So this is a great example where, you know, Eric and Donnie, frankly, in my opinion, taking on the move that we passed as a body with the best knowledge that we had and the best information we had, but at the end of the day, we were given bad knowledge, bad information, and a director, I think, pretty much is not here anymore because of it.

607
00:55:54.373 --> 00:55:57.393
<v Eric Zimmerman>So here's the better side of it.

608
00:55:58.307 --> 00:56:01.873
<v Eric Zimmerman>You all are problem solving to figure out what do we do.

609
00:56:02.161 --> 00:56:15.987
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I'd like to know is of the $3.6 million, and this year it's growing to $3.8 million of clean energy fund that was designed to be part of the tree code enforcement, is that still in PP&D?

610
00:56:16.853 --> 00:56:17.143
<v Eric Kooch>Yes.

611
00:56:17.286 --> 00:56:17.559
<v Dan Ryan>It is.

612
00:56:17.753 --> 00:56:19.791
<v Eric Zimmerman>And how many FTE does it pay for now?

613
00:56:25.300 --> 00:56:32.463
<v Eric Kooch>So right now that is funding, um, 14, um, FTE.

614
00:56:33.733 --> 00:56:36.512
<v Eric Zimmerman>Will it continue in the upcoming budget if we pass this?

615
00:56:37.427 --> 00:56:37.668
<v Eric Kooch>No.

616
00:56:37.748 --> 00:56:40.559
<v Donnie Oliveira>Okay, so yes, yeah, yes it will.

617
00:56:41.378 --> 00:56:44.061
<v Donnie Oliveira>If you, if you pass this budget, the $3.8 million is still in place.

618
00:56:44.237 --> 00:56:46.309
<v Eric Kooch>The funding still continues, yes, if the budget passes.

619
00:56:46.503 --> 00:56:53.182
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, so it'll be 14 people who are part of that I'm sorry, I misspoke, Councilor.

620
00:56:53.246 --> 00:56:54.081
<v Donnie Oliveira>So sorry about that.

621
00:56:54.275 --> 00:57:05.851
<v Eric Kooch>I, um, I'm looking at, um, trying to find the total positions in, um, tree permitting, and I apologize if it's okay, I'm going to phone a friend real quick.

622
00:57:05.931 --> 00:57:06.333
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's okay.

623
00:57:06.733 --> 00:57:14.505
<v Eric Zimmerman>Another reason, Mr. Lee, why when we look at program offers, a basic function of budgeting should be how many employees are to each program offer.

624
00:57:15.146 --> 00:57:19.514
<v Eric Zimmerman>And yet I have to go back to page 1 for the entire service area.

625
00:57:20.077 --> 00:57:21.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>Oh, that's what happens when you put the mic too close.

626
00:57:22.532 --> 00:57:26.210
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have to go back to page 1 to see the service area, to see how many employees.

627
00:57:26.547 --> 00:57:44.083
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so from a decision-making perspective, I will continue to highlight that we do not have a centralized budget office that has the tools to show us per bureau, per program, per program offer, how many employees are associated to the funds that we're being asked And in no government that I've ever worked has this gone on this long being unaddressed.

628
00:57:44.148 --> 00:57:46.768
<v Eric Zimmerman>So marching orders if I've ever said marching orders.

629
00:57:48.550 --> 00:57:52.233
<v Donnie Oliveira>So, Councilor, it is 14 staff that are in the budget funded by $3.8 million.

630
00:57:52.891 --> 00:58:02.264
<v Donnie Oliveira>And just to be really clear, I just want to acknowledge part of the challenge of the transfer is that Parks is a general fund bureau, right?

631
00:58:02.360 --> 00:58:06.362
<v Donnie Oliveira>So their structure is different than PP&D's, which is a full cost recovery model.

632
00:58:06.701 --> 00:58:06.846
<v Loretta Smith>Sure.

633
00:58:07.329 --> 00:58:17.503
<v Donnie Oliveira>So what was probably legitimately coming from Parks, accurate about what it cost to run the program once it landed in a different financially structured budget looks different on paper.

634
00:58:17.632 --> 00:58:27.159
<v Donnie Oliveira>So I just want to acknowledge that we got the information that you all adopted and we landed the program in PP&D to the best of our ability, which resulted in 14 FTE.

635
00:58:27.289 --> 00:58:29.952
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not actually— I'm not taking any hits at PP&D on this.

636
00:58:30.146 --> 00:58:41.983
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I am going to highlight is if a program cost Let's just use round numbers here, $1 million in one bureau, but it costs $2 million in another bureau.

637
00:58:42.840 --> 00:58:45.614
<v Eric Zimmerman>The normal guy math starts to get real drunk real fast.

638
00:58:46.146 --> 00:58:46.210
<v Eric Kooch>Right.

639
00:58:46.322 --> 00:58:55.670
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I highlight that as when the Parks Bureau says, I have this many employees, if you'd like to move them to another bureau, this is the money that we allocate for them.

640
00:58:56.190 --> 00:58:59.443
<v Eric Zimmerman>You can move them with funding attached, not being fee-based.

641
00:59:00.695 --> 00:59:04.623
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's some basicness that needs to happen as we move across bureaus.

642
00:59:05.318 --> 00:59:09.038
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think I have beat this horse, others have beat this horse.

643
00:59:09.085 --> 00:59:11.126
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's strong opinions, but I want to end on a high note.

644
00:59:11.353 --> 00:59:23.010
<v Eric Zimmerman>Let me, let me say this: 2 weeks to 6 weeks, 2 weeks to 8 weeks, that is certainly a metric we can talk about, about whether or not we are doing Title 11 at its, at its highest and best use.

645
00:59:23.414 --> 00:59:27.858
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to add another metric that's really important and is actually about the heart of the matter.

646
00:59:27.907 --> 00:59:27.972
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

647
00:59:28.414 --> 00:59:29.643
<v Eric Zimmerman>And why we moved.

648
00:59:31.309 --> 00:59:51.382
<v Eric Zimmerman>For this last 8 to 9 months, my interactions with people who interact with the tree code compliance branch of our government now are reporting deeply improved customer service interactions, a highly improved philosophy and approach to how they do their work.

649
00:59:52.418 --> 00:59:56.831
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that was largely the point insofar as— Thank you.

650
00:59:57.594 --> 01:00:05.114
<v Eric Zimmerman>There is an expectation when we work with our public and the way that our code compliance works with our public that is about problem solving.

651
01:00:05.853 --> 01:00:11.668
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that the tree code compliance has deeply improved from where it was a year or 2 ago.

652
01:00:12.135 --> 01:00:18.449
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I don't think we'll see as many terrible media stories about what I editorialized were abusive practices.

653
01:00:18.947 --> 01:00:22.996
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'll take 8 weeks with a path toward improving that.

654
01:00:23.606 --> 01:00:37.806
<v Eric Zimmerman>If we are doing it in a more respectful way, in a way that meets Portlanders' needs better, in a way that y'all can take a look at how does code compliance in our community happen in a way that can be more working with the public.

655
01:00:37.855 --> 01:00:50.827
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because that was the grand concern that I had last year was that tree code compliance was operating in a way that I think had been hamstrung, frankly, by a certain director's perspective.

656
01:00:50.876 --> 01:00:50.925
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

657
01:00:51.266 --> 01:00:55.873
<v Eric Zimmerman>On the, the other aspect of urban forestry, which is really, really important.

658
01:00:56.001 --> 01:00:59.338
<v Eric Zimmerman>And by the way, we touched not at all all the planting and the science.

659
01:00:59.547 --> 01:00:59.900
<v Jamie Dunphy>I got it.

660
01:00:59.949 --> 01:01:00.976
<v Dan Ryan>We're at 8 and a half minutes.

661
01:01:01.554 --> 01:01:02.291
<v Eric Zimmerman>What was our number?

662
01:01:02.356 --> 01:01:02.644
<v Michael Bonaccor>5.

663
01:01:02.998 --> 01:01:03.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, great.

664
01:01:03.639 --> 01:01:05.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's why I was late, so I didn't have to hear you say that.

665
01:01:05.309 --> 01:01:05.614
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, there you go.

666
01:01:05.710 --> 01:01:07.476
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I'll, I'll wrap up.

667
01:01:08.117 --> 01:01:10.157
<v Eric Zimmerman>No, but I just, I want to end on that high note.

668
01:01:10.300 --> 01:01:12.708
<v Eric Zimmerman>Tree code compliance is going better.

669
01:01:12.949 --> 01:01:15.452
<v Eric Zimmerman>The interactions with the public is better, and I appreciate it.

670
01:01:15.581 --> 01:01:19.338
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to make sure that PCF dollars stay with these employees and stay with this program.

671
01:01:19.594 --> 01:01:23.592
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if there's anything I can do to make sure that the PCF always does, I absolutely will.

672
01:01:23.849 --> 01:01:24.123
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

673
01:01:24.684 --> 01:01:25.407
<v Eric Zimmerman>Sorry, Mr. President.

674
01:01:25.536 --> 01:01:26.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

675
01:01:26.114 --> 01:01:27.639
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Point of information, Council President.

676
01:01:27.784 --> 01:01:38.878
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>The decision package from the mayor on page 138 says there are 26 FTE positions, and then the mayor's proposed is reducing it by 12 FTE.

677
01:01:39.135 --> 01:01:40.260
<v Donnie Oliveira>Okay, so 14 will remain.

678
01:01:40.420 --> 01:01:42.057
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So 14, but right now we have 20.

679
01:01:48.117 --> 01:01:48.342
<v Loretta Smith>26.

680
01:01:48.423 --> 01:01:50.081
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, some of those are vacant positions.

681
01:01:50.179 --> 01:01:53.623
<v Donnie Oliveira>We can get you the exact number that's actually in the, the, the program right now.

682
01:01:53.737 --> 01:01:55.797
<v Eric Zimmerman>People were mad that they had to move, so they just quit.

683
01:01:56.672 --> 01:01:58.360
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay, clarity on those numbers would be great.

684
01:01:58.423 --> 01:01:58.681
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

685
01:01:58.842 --> 01:02:00.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

686
01:02:00.514 --> 01:02:01.302
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Kanal.

687
01:02:02.139 --> 01:02:03.119
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

688
01:02:03.199 --> 01:02:07.253
<v Sameer Kanal>I have a couple questions, uh, and I, I also apologize, I was a little late.

689
01:02:07.302 --> 01:02:09.393
<v Sameer Kanal>I think I— this wasn't in there, but I'm, I'm just Just check in.

690
01:02:09.844 --> 01:02:13.885
<v Sameer Kanal>23 Positions being realigned from PP&D is 6.8% of the workforce.

691
01:02:14.318 --> 01:02:16.226
<v Sameer Kanal>30 Positions from BPS is 18%.

692
01:02:17.365 --> 01:02:18.746
<v Sameer Kanal>That both seems like a lot.

693
01:02:18.905 --> 01:02:19.835
<v Sameer Kanal>Where are they going?

694
01:02:20.028 --> 01:02:23.204
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak a little bit more to the particular places they're being realigned?

695
01:02:24.262 --> 01:02:25.112
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you, Councilor.

696
01:02:25.226 --> 01:02:30.213
<v Donnie Oliveira>I, you know, for realignment questions, definitely wanna defer to my colleagues at Business Ops.

697
01:02:31.416 --> 01:02:31.833
<v Donnie Oliveira>But there are—.

698
01:02:32.139 --> 01:02:33.438
<v Sameer Kanal>Wait till that work session on Friday.

699
01:02:33.518 --> 01:02:33.695
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yes.

700
01:02:33.902 --> 01:02:34.288
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, thank you.

701
01:02:34.367 --> 01:02:37.126
<v Donnie Oliveira>But a couple, there are things that are outside of the realignment project.

702
01:02:37.945 --> 01:02:38.530
<v Donnie Oliveira>That are happening.

703
01:02:38.577 --> 01:02:47.070
<v Donnie Oliveira>So for example, so a couple positions as a part of the creation of the data office are leaving BPS, as an example of some smaller things.

704
01:02:47.166 --> 01:02:51.244
<v Donnie Oliveira>But yeah, the other, the larger realignment stuff will be covered by Business Ops.

705
01:02:51.697 --> 01:02:52.054
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

706
01:02:53.715 --> 01:02:57.206
<v Sameer Kanal>This may be hard to answer on the fly, so let me know if you need to get back to me.

707
01:02:57.592 --> 01:03:09.817
<v Sameer Kanal>The turnaround time for an inquiry going from 2 to 7 or 8 weeks, can you speak to what portion of that has to do with the workforce reduction And what portion of that has to do with the physical bureau it's in question.

708
01:03:10.025 --> 01:03:11.963
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's an important distinction here.

709
01:03:13.277 --> 01:03:14.992
<v Sameer Kanal>And I don't know if we've teased that out.

710
01:03:16.001 --> 01:03:20.713
<v Sameer Kanal>And I imagine it's a little bit of both at least, but if you can speak anything to that or get back to me, it's fine.

711
01:03:20.826 --> 01:03:34.445
<v Eric Kooch>Yeah, if it's okay, I'd like to get back with you with more data behind that, just because I'd like to better understand the numbers fully with how many staff that they had prior to the move to now so that we can quantify it.

712
01:03:34.494 --> 01:03:38.599
<v Eric Kooch>So if it's okay, I'll get you those, the data behind that at a later date.

713
01:03:38.760 --> 01:03:39.101
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

714
01:03:39.568 --> 01:03:42.121
<v Sameer Kanal>One other question is just to what you just said here, and then I have a comment.

715
01:03:42.266 --> 01:03:47.483
<v Sameer Kanal>There's 27 positions got reallocated in the amendment, and you just said that there were 26.

716
01:03:48.032 --> 01:03:49.387
<v Sameer Kanal>What happened to the 27th position?

717
01:03:51.070 --> 01:03:51.847
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's a good question, Councilor.

718
01:03:51.896 --> 01:03:53.731
<v Donnie Oliveira>We'll have to figure out where the math landed on that.

719
01:03:54.411 --> 01:03:54.574
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

720
01:03:57.639 --> 01:03:58.250
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that.

721
01:03:58.619 --> 01:04:10.949
<v Sameer Kanal>I just think that that highlights sort of the— and I'll note last year we had tables in the budget that had the FTs at the beginning, what was added, what was removed, what was being realigned, and what the proposed budget would do by classification.

722
01:04:11.047 --> 01:04:12.155
<v Sameer Kanal>The rows were classifications.

723
01:04:12.251 --> 01:04:17.902
<v Sameer Kanal>And this year, most of the tables I'm seeing is classifications and number if you accept the budget.

724
01:04:18.449 --> 01:04:20.262
<v Sameer Kanal>But there's not all those other columns.

725
01:04:20.440 --> 01:04:21.949
<v Sameer Kanal>So we're getting less information.

726
01:04:22.206 --> 01:04:24.996
<v Sameer Kanal>Even as the budget has nearly tripled in length.

727
01:04:25.831 --> 01:04:31.173
<v Sameer Kanal>And we talked about the narratives there too, but I agree on all the issues about tables, math, numbers, spreadsheets.

728
01:04:32.007 --> 01:04:36.836
<v Sameer Kanal>I do want to take a moment to defend the Zimmerman 15 amendment from last year, which is the amendment we're talking about here.

729
01:04:37.382 --> 01:04:40.911
<v Sameer Kanal>That amendment had some consequences we anticipated and some we didn't.

730
01:04:41.472 --> 01:04:47.987
<v Sameer Kanal>We are talking about some of the negative consequences here, reducing from 37 to 27 number of treat code enforcement personnel.

731
01:04:48.050 --> 01:04:48.163
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

732
01:04:48.452 --> 01:04:51.864
<v Sameer Kanal>The negative outcome regarding the move to PP&D from Parks.

733
01:04:51.913 --> 01:05:02.168
<v Sameer Kanal>But I don't think it's been mentioned yet that there was a cut of 10 FTE to Parks maintenance in the mayor's proposed last year, that the Zimmerman 15 Amendment saved those jobs.

734
01:05:03.114 --> 01:05:08.722
<v Sameer Kanal>And these are the people that plant and help trees— I'm, I'm oversimplifying here— planting and helping trees grow.

735
01:05:09.668 --> 01:05:18.744
<v Sameer Kanal>And that also involved reducing the tree code enforcement by At least as far as we knew at the time, 10, maybe 11 positions.

736
01:05:18.791 --> 01:05:19.969
<v Sameer Kanal>We picked winners and losers.

737
01:05:20.016 --> 01:05:26.092
<v Sameer Kanal>That was, I think, last year I used the quote that our job is in large part to pick winners and losers.

738
01:05:26.606 --> 01:05:35.961
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a compelling argument to me about our not just ability, but frankly responsibility to make a decision like this and not solely defer to the administration and the mayor's proposed about it.

739
01:05:37.809 --> 01:05:41.454
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that was a decision we had to make as council.

740
01:05:41.806 --> 01:05:43.521
<v Sameer Kanal>We could say it wasn't our responsibility.

741
01:05:43.648 --> 01:05:45.460
<v Sameer Kanal>The mayor put forward the proposal.

742
01:05:45.572 --> 01:05:46.726
<v Sameer Kanal>Mayor had to make tough cuts.

743
01:05:46.791 --> 01:05:46.887
<v Steve Novick>It's—.

744
01:05:46.951 --> 01:05:52.465
<v Sameer Kanal>He has the, the sort of misfortune of being the first to take the crack at it, and we had to then react to it.

745
01:05:53.025 --> 01:05:57.257
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'm really glad that based on the information we had, there wasn't a net reduction.

746
01:05:57.353 --> 01:06:05.208
<v Sameer Kanal>But I, I do want to just point out there are 10 people who are unemployed now because of that decision, and there are 10 other people who are employed now because of it.

747
01:06:05.929 --> 01:06:09.135
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and that's a really important piece of this conversation.

748
01:06:09.952 --> 01:06:11.331
<v Sameer Kanal>Don't get me wrong, I don't wanna cut further.

749
01:06:11.958 --> 01:06:18.599
<v Sameer Kanal>I do support the lines of questioning around PSF money being here or instead of areas that I agree are stretching like PIMO.

750
01:06:19.818 --> 01:06:24.822
<v Sameer Kanal>But I just wanted to make sure that that other consequence, the positive consequence, was also discussed there.

751
01:06:25.336 --> 01:06:27.599
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm looking in parks, in urban forestry.

752
01:06:28.239 --> 01:06:28.416
<v Steve Novick>Thanks.

753
01:06:28.802 --> 01:06:29.844
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Knoll.

754
01:06:30.164 --> 01:06:30.775
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

755
01:06:31.369 --> 01:06:32.427
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

756
01:06:32.556 --> 01:06:36.244
<v Dan Ryan>I have 1 minute and 30 seconds remaining in my 5 minutes, so I thought I'd get back in.

757
01:06:36.583 --> 01:06:41.355
<v Dan Ryan>And go back to the conversation about how we can continue to improve customer satisfaction.

758
01:06:42.527 --> 01:06:48.922
<v Dan Ryan>One reason why Councilor Zimmerman was able to make that comment is because of the hard work that was done starting in 2021.

759
01:06:49.436 --> 01:06:50.353
<v Dan Ryan>That was the focus.

760
01:06:50.545 --> 01:06:53.358
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, that was the number one issue that came up.

761
01:06:54.257 --> 01:07:10.634
<v Dan Ryan>In addition to thinking it's wise to have some internal cat herders, continuous improvement people, it also was so important that The DRAC board and external partners that are high users of our system were at the table.

762
01:07:11.260 --> 01:07:23.387
<v Dan Ryan>That table of active advisors was the main reason why we had some tension to get started and allowed our culture to be shook up a bit to focus in a different way, to listen in a different way.

763
01:07:24.094 --> 01:07:32.344
<v Dan Ryan>And so I urge you, as you're working with the council president, I'm trying to get on board to be A co-sponsor of this, to make sure that you lean into that.

764
01:07:32.697 --> 01:07:43.974
<v Dan Ryan>If you dismantle your internal cat herders and if you dismantle the external feedback loop that was very active in this process, you will not see these reforms implemented.

765
01:07:44.327 --> 01:07:45.644
<v Dan Ryan>We all know this will take some time.

766
01:07:45.708 --> 01:07:47.411
<v Dan Ryan>It took us decades to get to this place.

767
01:07:47.492 --> 01:07:49.322
<v Dan Ryan>It's going to take us a little while to get out.

768
01:07:49.643 --> 01:07:52.375
<v Dan Ryan>We're on year 5, so I'm attached to it, obviously.

769
01:07:52.760 --> 01:07:56.405
<v Dan Ryan>It was really important that the last council was able to bring in each office.

770
01:07:56.454 --> 01:07:56.614
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

771
01:07:56.856 --> 01:07:58.059
<v Dan Ryan>And made this an all-in effort.

772
01:07:58.492 --> 01:07:59.117
<v Dan Ryan>All right, thanks.

773
01:07:59.822 --> 01:08:06.108
<v Eric Kooch>I just want to say I agree 100%, Councilor, and we'll definitely continue to engage with our external stakeholders as we move forward.

774
01:08:06.414 --> 01:08:06.717
<v Eric Kooch>Thank you.

775
01:08:07.681 --> 01:08:08.643
<v Dan Ryan>That was me to shut up.

776
01:08:08.818 --> 01:08:15.811
<v Donnie Oliveira>All right, Council President, I have the answer for both Councilor Koyama Lane and Councilor Kanal.

777
01:08:16.501 --> 01:08:25.109
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor Kanal, the 26 versus 27, you are correct, uh, the original number was 27, but upon further analysis It was only 26 that moved over.

778
01:08:25.238 --> 01:08:26.712
<v Donnie Oliveira>One position stayed at Parks.

779
01:08:27.417 --> 01:08:28.265
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that was the decision.

780
01:08:28.314 --> 01:08:32.463
<v Donnie Oliveira>It was basically an understanding of people's roles, like what was appropriate to move over.

781
01:08:32.784 --> 01:08:34.466
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that was the difference between 27 and 26.

782
01:08:34.948 --> 01:08:42.798
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor Koyama Lane, today, as we sit here today, of the 26 that moved over, there are 20 positions that are filled, 6 are vacant.

783
01:08:43.423 --> 01:08:50.778
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so in the proposed budget for next year, there would be 14 filled positions, 12 would be cut, 6 of which are filled positions.

784
01:08:50.841 --> 01:08:50.985
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

785
01:08:51.435 --> 01:08:55.060
<v Donnie Oliveira>So those are the numbers to, to close that gap.

786
01:08:55.462 --> 01:08:55.990
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Donnie.

787
01:08:56.568 --> 01:08:59.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Smith, and then we're going to move to the Housing Bureau.

788
01:08:59.454 --> 01:09:00.673
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, thank you.

789
01:09:01.234 --> 01:09:05.774
<v Loretta Smith>So I don't know if you all heard about, uh, Chris Bolton.

790
01:09:06.270 --> 01:09:16.743
<v Loretta Smith>He was in the paper a few days ago, and he lives in my district on 89th Street and Southeast, and he was complaining about a lot of tents and trailers outside of his house.

791
01:09:17.050 --> 01:09:18.855
<v Loretta Smith>And he was trying to get some support.

792
01:09:19.484 --> 01:09:33.957
<v Loretta Smith>And then he reported this, and I don't know if it was someone from PP&D who came out or from the— somebody cited him from the City of Portland and said that he needed to cut down his hedges.

793
01:09:35.100 --> 01:09:36.690
<v Loretta Smith>Can someone explain this to me?

794
01:09:37.795 --> 01:09:40.912
<v Eric Kooch>Uh, Councilor, I'm not familiar with that, that particular issue.

795
01:09:41.042 --> 01:09:42.131
<v Eric Kooch>I would need, um—.

796
01:09:42.537 --> 01:09:46.636
<v Loretta Smith>It was a mastic article, and, uh, he was on the front page.

797
01:09:47.662 --> 01:09:51.283
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor, my understanding is that that was, uh, a citation from the Bureau of Transportation.

798
01:09:51.587 --> 01:09:52.020
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, okay.

799
01:09:52.100 --> 01:09:58.653
<v Loretta Smith>So that's what I wanted to find out, if, if there was a permit who came from your office, but it wasn't.

800
01:09:59.373 --> 01:10:01.824
<v Dan Ryan>I thought it was all integrated.

801
01:10:02.481 --> 01:10:04.100
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, it could be PYI.

802
01:10:04.180 --> 01:10:04.581
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know.

803
01:10:04.805 --> 01:10:05.622
<v Dan Ryan>It was integrated.

804
01:10:05.863 --> 01:10:06.728
<v Loretta Smith>It was all integrated.

805
01:10:06.807 --> 01:10:06.984
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

806
01:10:07.207 --> 01:10:07.577
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

807
01:10:07.689 --> 01:10:11.918
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm just— I want to follow up offline because I know we don't have enough time.

808
01:10:12.576 --> 01:10:37.264
<v Loretta Smith>And I'll shoot you the newspaper article, but it was disturbing to me that someone tries to get help and get those unsanctioned homeless shelters that they have outside of people's houses and camps, and then they get cited and have to spend a lot of money for some— basically, we just ignored what their concern was and then gave them a bill.

809
01:10:37.873 --> 01:10:39.077
<v Loretta Smith>So that was a problem.

810
01:10:40.652 --> 01:10:43.729
<v Eric Kooch>Councilor, I look forward to working with you to help resolve this.

811
01:10:44.519 --> 01:10:44.904
<v Loretta Smith>Excellent.

812
01:10:45.226 --> 01:10:45.501
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

813
01:10:45.791 --> 01:10:46.338
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

814
01:10:48.529 --> 01:10:49.194
<v Jamie Dunphy>On to the Housing Bureau.

815
01:10:49.260 --> 01:10:53.948
<v Jamie Dunphy>Director Bongcar, I want to start by thanking you for your service here in the city in the interim role.

816
01:10:54.063 --> 01:10:59.537
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we understand that, you know, you'll be leaving us soon to go fix another problem somewhere else.

817
01:10:59.587 --> 01:11:04.824
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you for the time you've given to us and take it away for the presentation on the Housing Bureau.

818
01:11:05.252 --> 01:11:08.351
<v Michael Bonaccor>Thank you, Council President, Vice President Clark, councilors.

819
01:11:08.528 --> 01:11:08.832
<v Michael Bonaccor>Good morning.

820
01:11:08.881 --> 01:11:09.925
<v Michael Bonaccor>My name is Michael Bonaccor.

821
01:11:09.988 --> 01:11:14.243
<v Michael Bonaccor>I am— I remain the interim director of the Portland Housing Bureau for another week and a half.

822
01:11:14.582 --> 01:11:16.541
<v Michael Bonaccor>It's a pleasure to be here this morning.

823
01:11:17.118 --> 01:11:26.094
<v Michael Bonaccor>The mission of the Housing Bureau is to foster an inclusive and sustainable city by creating stable and long-term housing opportunities for Portland.

824
01:11:27.073 --> 01:11:34.115
<v Michael Bonaccor>We fund affordable housing, ensure protection for renters, preserve existing homes, and create homeownership opportunities.

825
01:11:35.173 --> 01:11:44.296
<v Michael Bonaccor>The Housing Bureau regulates a growing portfolio of 19,000 apartments of affordable housing throughout the city with a dedicated team of 86 professionals.

826
01:11:45.753 --> 01:11:49.121
<v Michael Bonaccor>Our proposed budget is $276.3 million.

827
01:11:49.778 --> 01:12:03.462
<v Michael Bonaccor>This is an all-in number that includes $86 million planned both for committed and planned future investments beyond the upcoming fiscal year, which will be categorized in the budget as contingency.

828
01:12:04.855 --> 01:12:05.471
<v Michael Bonaccor>Next slide.

829
01:12:06.588 --> 01:12:10.752
<v Michael Bonaccor>So forgive me, I'm going to jump past this slide and then we'll come back in just a minute.

830
01:12:10.899 --> 01:12:12.060
<v Michael Bonaccor>So next slide, please.

831
01:12:14.801 --> 01:12:24.938
<v Michael Bonaccor>So the big takeaway as you look at this slide is that the general fund continues to comprise a relatively small proportion of PHB's overall budget.

832
01:12:25.358 --> 01:12:34.061
<v Michael Bonaccor>That's the $1.2 million shown as a reduction which means that we'll be able to absorb that loss without layoffs or reductions in services.

833
01:12:34.560 --> 01:12:37.021
<v Michael Bonaccor>And I'll provide more information about that in the slides ahead.

834
01:12:38.677 --> 01:12:51.661
<v Michael Bonaccor>The number you see for the reduction related to realignment largely reflects the pass-through of funds that has typically gone to Multnomah County Homeless Services Division, and this year will go to Portland Solutions.

835
01:12:52.096 --> 01:12:53.484
<v Michael Bonaccor>So this has no impact on PHP.

836
01:12:53.550 --> 01:12:53.694
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

837
01:12:54.757 --> 01:12:56.670
<v Michael Bonaccor>Next slide.

838
01:12:58.854 --> 01:13:13.818
<v Michael Bonaccor>With respect to staffing, we have the movement of 3 FTE from the bureau to the service area under core services realignment, 2 in comms, 1 in community engagement, and the cut of 2 vacant positions, which I will describe in a moment.

839
01:13:14.171 --> 01:13:15.699
<v Michael Bonaccor>Next slide.

840
01:13:16.970 --> 01:13:39.376
<v Michael Bonaccor>As I mentioned earlier, all of Portland Housing Bureau's existing services will be maintained in the upcoming budget year, and the work we do falls broadly into the 4 buckets that you see in front of you: affordable housing development, renter protections and stabilization, homeownership access, and home repair and safety programs that help Portlanders stay in their homes.

841
01:13:41.050 --> 01:13:45.016
<v Michael Bonaccor>So now if we could jump back to slide 17, with apologies again.

842
01:13:46.344 --> 01:13:49.693
<v Michael Bonaccor>So here you see some of the impact thank you.

843
01:13:49.854 --> 01:13:52.929
<v Michael Bonaccor>So this is a summary of our impacts through our proposed budget.

844
01:13:53.155 --> 01:13:57.670
<v Michael Bonaccor>About 85% of our budget directly supports housing investments and services.

845
01:13:58.365 --> 01:14:08.871
<v Michael Bonaccor>In the upcoming year, we are looking at investing in 18 projects representing more than 1,800 apartments and homeownership opportunities.

846
01:14:09.707 --> 01:14:26.048
<v Michael Bonaccor>We will provide education and counseling to about 1,000 households, landlord and tenant education referrals to more than 6,000 folks, legal services for more than 1,500 households, and again, $86 million that is categorized in contingency.

847
01:14:26.631 --> 01:14:33.492
<v Michael Bonaccor>And again, those are for committed and planned future investments, not technically contingency.

848
01:14:34.458 --> 01:14:36.537
<v Michael Bonaccor>That's just the accounting label that we use.

849
01:14:36.713 --> 01:14:40.153
<v Michael Bonaccor>So if we could now jump a couple more to—.

850
01:14:40.153 --> 01:14:40.546
<v Steve Novick>2.

851
01:14:42.239 --> 01:14:42.416
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

852
01:14:43.157 --> 01:14:49.560
<v Michael Bonaccor>So now we will talk about the various reductions.

853
01:14:49.672 --> 01:14:57.065
<v Michael Bonaccor>So again, there's a reallocation of the pass-through that has traditionally gone to Homeless Services Division at the county.

854
01:14:58.630 --> 01:15:13.359
<v Michael Bonaccor>So that will now, in addition to elimination of $263,000 from the recreational cannabis cannabis funds support Portland Solutions.

855
01:15:14.100 --> 01:15:26.929
<v Michael Bonaccor>And again, there's no— this historic pass-through has happened for many years and there's no impact to the Portland Housing Bureau's service delivery and no expected staffing impact.

856
01:15:27.493 --> 01:15:28.027
<v Michael Bonaccor>Next slide.

857
01:15:32.497 --> 01:15:34.965
<v Michael Bonaccor>Reduction of external materials and legal services.

858
01:15:35.014 --> 01:15:42.158
<v Michael Bonaccor>So this is— This removes general fund that previously supported legal services.

859
01:15:42.430 --> 01:15:45.555
<v Michael Bonaccor>There will be no reduction in the legal services that support the Bureau.

860
01:15:45.635 --> 01:15:53.599
<v Michael Bonaccor>We'll just use other funding sources to make up for that reduction and reduction in things like supplies, meeting costs, advertising.

861
01:15:54.849 --> 01:16:03.389
<v Michael Bonaccor>We will also decrease the discretionary external materials and services budget, again, all without affecting core services or service delivery.

862
01:16:04.212 --> 01:16:06.327
<v Michael Bonaccor>And with no expected staffing impact.

863
01:16:06.730 --> 01:16:07.296
<v Michael Bonaccor>Next slide.

864
01:16:09.458 --> 01:16:20.261
<v Michael Bonaccor>We are proposing to reduce funding in our agreement with BTS that will remove one embedded BTS applications analyst at the Bureau.

865
01:16:20.617 --> 01:16:29.748
<v Michael Bonaccor>That person supports some of our specialized software solutions related to our loan subsidiary portfolio.

866
01:16:30.462 --> 01:16:33.949
<v Michael Bonaccor>And so we will lose that embedded employee through this cut.

867
01:16:34.881 --> 01:16:35.573
<v Michael Bonaccor>Next slide.

868
01:16:37.935 --> 01:16:41.761
<v Michael Bonaccor>And then the elimination of 2 vacant data analyst positions.

869
01:16:41.872 --> 01:16:49.328
<v Michael Bonaccor>So the Bureau currently relies on a small team to provide data analysis that supports multiple high-priority policy initiatives.

870
01:16:50.136 --> 01:16:53.387
<v Michael Bonaccor>We'll be able to maintain our current service levels with the existing team.

871
01:16:53.889 --> 01:16:59.765
<v Michael Bonaccor>This is more of an opportunity cost in terms of how much bandwidth we have for research or analysis on new policy initiatives.

872
01:17:00.604 --> 01:17:03.317
<v Michael Bonaccor>But again, no loss in the current capacity.

873
01:17:05.631 --> 01:17:08.622
<v Michael Bonaccor>And I believe that is all.

874
01:17:08.686 --> 01:17:09.284
<v Michael Bonaccor>Next slide.

875
01:17:09.899 --> 01:17:11.063
<v Michael Bonaccor>Yes, those are all.

876
01:17:11.918 --> 01:17:12.453
<v Michael Bonaccor>That's our presentation.

877
01:17:15.439 --> 01:17:16.212
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

878
01:17:16.774 --> 01:17:18.368
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, colleagues, feel free to jump back in the queue.

879
01:17:18.431 --> 01:17:19.993
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green, kick us off.

880
01:17:20.283 --> 01:17:21.231
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm ready.

881
01:17:21.506 --> 01:17:21.747
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

882
01:17:21.828 --> 01:17:22.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

883
01:17:25.974 --> 01:17:27.284
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

884
01:17:28.644 --> 01:17:29.502
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

885
01:17:31.395 --> 01:17:40.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, if this is not an appropriate time, I don't have to ask this now, but I want to use the opportunity because of something in one of these slides to ask the city administrator a broader question.

886
01:17:41.804 --> 01:17:41.932
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sure.

887
01:17:42.046 --> 01:17:46.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So, Mr. City Administrator, one of the things that Director Bonaccort said he's cutting is advertising.

888
01:17:48.079 --> 01:17:55.095
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And there are a lot of bureaus that do a lot of advertising and sponsorships and things like that.

889
01:17:55.159 --> 01:18:04.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And some of those things are recruitment opportunities for new staff and making sure that members of our community know the city is a great place to work.

890
01:18:05.051 --> 01:18:06.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that, that's a good thing.

891
01:18:06.818 --> 01:18:20.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Some of those opportunities sponsor community events that many of us up here and many community members members absolutely love and events that depend on city sponsorship in part to be able to move forward.

892
01:18:21.569 --> 01:18:42.561
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I don't know that we've asked any questions about this before, and I'm wondering if at some point we could get some information about across bureaus how much is actually spent on advertising and event sponsorship where we have 4 or 5 bureaus all sponsoring the same community and that looks like about half the sponsorships for that event.

893
01:18:43.395 --> 01:18:59.327
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, if we're really looking under every couch cushion and turning over every rock and trying to not cut a fire engine and frontline services, could we get some broader citywide information about this?

894
01:19:00.417 --> 01:19:00.850
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yes, we can.

895
01:19:01.845 --> 01:19:02.247
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

896
01:19:02.600 --> 01:19:11.430
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that something we should expect in time for this budget, or is Or is that something that will take a little more time and we need to ask you to do a deeper dive over the next few months?

897
01:19:12.041 --> 01:19:21.003
<v Sameer Kanal>I would want to do a deep dive on that, but let me get back to you and see if it's something we can talk through this budget cycle.

898
01:19:21.518 --> 01:19:25.309
<v Sameer Kanal>But I have a feeling this is a much bigger topic.

899
01:19:25.630 --> 01:19:33.451
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I recognize there may be some impacts to asking this question that we don't want to see and that could concern a lot of folks in the community.

900
01:19:33.547 --> 01:19:38.323
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm not asking for any big changes, but it seems like a space that we need to understand.

901
01:19:38.800 --> 01:19:39.123
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Most definitely.

902
01:19:39.480 --> 01:19:39.822
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

903
01:19:40.211 --> 01:19:43.747
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President, for letting me take that tangential opportunity.

904
01:19:44.340 --> 01:19:44.501
<v Eric Engstrom>Absolutely.

905
01:19:44.550 --> 01:19:45.471
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

906
01:19:45.746 --> 01:19:46.393
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

907
01:19:47.768 --> 01:19:48.672
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Michael.

908
01:19:48.721 --> 01:20:01.659
<v Eric Zimmerman>My questions really just kind of go to, you know, given a budget moment that we're in and where everybody else is taking significant cuts.

909
01:20:02.833 --> 01:20:08.606
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, I think the last time we spoke from the dais, I said I would be comfortable with you if you cleaned house in that bureau.

910
01:20:09.331 --> 01:20:23.502
<v Eric Zimmerman>And what I really want to understand is, given the challenges that we've seen come out of that bureau and the way that they have or not administered programs, is this not an opportunity to dig deeper and maybe reset?

911
01:20:23.551 --> 01:20:24.085
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a great question.

912
01:20:24.524 --> 01:20:29.065
<v Eric Zimmerman>In ways that can be foundational in terms of where the Housing Bureau goes in the years to come?

913
01:20:30.161 --> 01:20:37.078
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because if this is that moment, I don't see that reflected in the budget.

914
01:20:37.238 --> 01:20:45.265
<v Eric Zimmerman>I kind of see a status quo, and there may be no bureau that I'm more uncomfortable with status quo than the Housing Bureau after these last 6 months.

915
01:20:46.162 --> 01:20:47.595
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I just want to give you an opportunity.

916
01:20:49.609 --> 01:20:50.972
<v Eric Zimmerman>One, you could say, You know what?

917
01:20:51.231 --> 01:20:52.619
<v Eric Zimmerman>No, Councilor, we're on the right track.

918
01:20:52.701 --> 01:20:53.605
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're going in the right direction.

919
01:20:53.670 --> 01:20:55.608
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's why I'm doing minimal amounts of cuts.

920
01:20:55.753 --> 01:21:04.127
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or perhaps you'd like to, you just don't know that since you were in the interim role, it would be good to propose it.

921
01:21:04.175 --> 01:21:15.994
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just trying to understand because frankly, I would've expected to probably see a more aggressive realignment, reapproach, redesign for a bureau who frankly has only existed since 2009.

922
01:21:17.167 --> 01:21:19.479
<v Eric Zimmerman>Which by the way is when Portland kind of stopped building housing.

923
01:21:20.248 --> 01:21:33.279
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that correlation causation, I'm not gonna try and make a connection that's not there, but there's, I have deep concerns that whether or not the Bureau has been built on a correct foundation to be successful by 2030, 2035, and 2040.

924
01:21:34.756 --> 01:21:35.012
<v Dan Ryan>Thoughts?

925
01:21:35.479 --> 01:21:37.180
<v Michael Bonaccor>Yes, thank you, Councilor, for the question.

926
01:21:37.228 --> 01:21:37.966
<v Michael Bonaccor>I appreciate it.

927
01:21:38.769 --> 01:21:47.789
<v Michael Bonaccor>Maybe I'll start with the idea that the Bureau the Bureau has been in existence since 2009.

928
01:21:48.319 --> 01:22:02.867
<v Michael Bonaccor>The Bureau has in fact gone through a number of evolutions and its current existence is a breaking off of being part of sort of a larger entity that was the Bureau of Housing and Community Development.

929
01:22:04.216 --> 01:22:08.054
<v Michael Bonaccor>So, you know, I think that's reflective of— the Bureau of Housing and Community Development.

930
01:22:08.858 --> 01:22:25.113
<v Michael Bonaccor>A number of transitions that the Bureau has gone through over the years, including a very intensive period of years recently in which there has been a high degree of turnover at the executive level.

931
01:22:25.243 --> 01:22:57.171
<v Michael Bonaccor>And this, as we chatted informally about, any organization can't sort of go through that degree of upheaval at that level and not expect to see implications on how it's functioning and its ability to sort of be fully accountable when folks are understandably asking questions from the dais that I have a 6-month perspective on.

932
01:22:57.283 --> 01:23:00.015
<v Michael Bonaccor>That's really challenging and that's not just, Me.

933
01:23:00.095 --> 01:23:00.145
<v Michael Bonaccor>Me.

934
01:23:00.193 --> 01:23:04.994
<v Michael Bonaccor>That's the shallowness that has been there from the beginning.

935
01:23:05.900 --> 01:23:25.615
<v Michael Bonaccor>As all of that turmoil has happened, what I have seen my first time around and since I've been back is that the folks who keep the Bureau running and the reason that there aren't more challenges is that the staff of the Bureau do exceptional work.

936
01:23:25.712 --> 01:23:42.203
<v Michael Bonaccor>And they have, again, thank you for this opportunity because they have heard in the press and in these conversations, you know, questions about their competence and whether the Bureau is, you know, sort of doing its work appropriately.

937
01:23:42.636 --> 01:23:54.282
<v Michael Bonaccor>And anything that has gone well, I think, deserves a lot of credit to the represented staff who show up every day and keep their heads down and are listening to all of these conversations in their earbuds as they do their work.

938
01:23:55.207 --> 01:24:11.100
<v Michael Bonaccor>I do believe there's a good deal of internal stabilization and some structural realignment in the Bureau that has to happen periodically no matter what, and especially because it needs leadership that has the ability to settle in and really focus on that.

939
01:24:11.501 --> 01:24:31.600
<v Michael Bonaccor>And I think the, you know, this construct and the accountability that is driven by needing to demonstrate all of the funds to Council and not just sort of what we're asking for in a given year, Like, these are all steps that are going to shore up the Bureau's ability to like really do the work that's needed.

940
01:24:31.697 --> 01:24:35.676
<v Michael Bonaccor>But I'll say it a third time.

941
01:24:36.768 --> 01:24:44.966
<v Michael Bonaccor>The Portland Housing Bureau staff have been waiting for someone to kind of stand up for them and say they are an exceptional group of professionals.

942
01:24:45.015 --> 01:24:48.208
<v Michael Bonaccor>They have my support, and I will pass that on to whoever the next leader is.

943
01:24:48.962 --> 01:24:49.363
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

944
01:24:49.685 --> 01:24:54.195
<v Eric Zimmerman>I had a feeling you might say that, and I'm glad that I'm glad that you had the opportunity to say it.

945
01:24:54.260 --> 01:25:15.344
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it is, and I agree with you, and I think that it is just foundational, bolded, underlined, italicized that the need for deep visionary, but also Type A leadership to come into the Housing Bureau as you step away to go resuscitate another failing organization is so needed.

946
01:25:15.537 --> 01:25:19.295
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so for the city administration leadership that's in the room, I agree.

947
01:25:20.198 --> 01:25:30.006
<v Eric Zimmerman>I hope that we really grab the words of the director that he just shared with us because, you know, there is taking care of stuff behind the scenes.

948
01:25:30.119 --> 01:25:33.095
<v Eric Zimmerman>There is bailing water out to make sure the ship doesn't sink.

949
01:25:34.604 --> 01:25:39.698
<v Eric Zimmerman>But all of that is fruitless if nobody is giving orders from the deck, right?

950
01:25:39.779 --> 01:25:41.166
<v Eric Zimmerman>In terms of what— where are we overall?

951
01:25:41.279 --> 01:25:41.827
<v Eric Zimmerman>What are we doing?

952
01:25:42.100 --> 01:25:42.795
<v Eric Zimmerman>Where are we going?

953
01:25:43.132 --> 01:25:44.667
<v Eric Zimmerman>What is the overall plan?

954
01:25:44.765 --> 01:25:51.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that we have largely been bailing the water out for a while without an idea of are we gonna hit land soon?

955
01:25:51.885 --> 01:26:20.003
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I really look forward to bolstering what can be possible in the Housing Bureau with clear-eyed leadership who knows that the most important thing that we do is we create an environment for more housing to exist, that we create an environment that enables all types of housing to exist, and that creation of housing is first and foremost, and everything after that is a byline.

956
01:26:20.341 --> 01:26:22.202
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for your work.

957
01:26:22.363 --> 01:26:26.807
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know you're in the last few days, weeks of your interim position here.

958
01:26:27.658 --> 01:26:33.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>And to the Housing Bureau employees, I hope that you have heard what your director just said because I think he nailed it on the head.

959
01:26:33.595 --> 01:26:34.557
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you for that.

960
01:26:34.958 --> 01:26:36.452
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I appreciate the budget presentation.

961
01:26:36.500 --> 01:26:40.270
<v Eric Zimmerman>It was less important to me than having an opportunity to hear from you directly.

962
01:26:40.335 --> 01:26:40.881
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thank you.

963
01:26:41.056 --> 01:26:41.682
<v Michael Bonaccor>Thank you, Councilor.

964
01:26:41.923 --> 01:26:42.757
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

965
01:26:42.903 --> 01:26:43.463
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

966
01:26:43.609 --> 01:26:44.811
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

967
01:26:44.908 --> 01:26:45.421
<v Dan Ryan>Hi, Michael.

968
01:26:47.140 --> 01:26:59.743
<v Dan Ryan>I want to— I'm looking at slide 17, explains what Portland Housing Bureau does, and it's really missing something that's become painfully aware thanks to some investigative reporting by the Willamette Week.

969
01:27:00.403 --> 01:27:07.515
<v Dan Ryan>Where's the oversight part of this bureau and where is the longitudinal data that we must look at?

970
01:27:07.932 --> 01:27:16.369
<v Dan Ryan>So when we build something, we help build something, when we're the leaders of that, Where's our responsibility to have metrics that follow for 3 years?

971
01:27:16.548 --> 01:27:17.653
<v Dan Ryan>How many people are living there?

972
01:27:18.189 --> 01:27:18.967
<v Dan Ryan>What's their satisfaction?

973
01:27:19.930 --> 01:27:21.873
<v Dan Ryan>What are the challenges, which we're hearing many about?

974
01:27:21.953 --> 01:27:23.594
<v Dan Ryan>Like, where is that oversight?

975
01:27:23.641 --> 01:27:27.931
<v Dan Ryan>And where— I know I couldn't attend the meeting that I'm not a member of anymore yesterday.

976
01:27:27.997 --> 01:27:34.206
<v Dan Ryan>Maybe we got at some of this, but I think it's strange that's missing from what the Housing Bureau does.

977
01:27:36.090 --> 01:27:36.277
<v Michael Bonaccor>Sure.

978
01:27:36.378 --> 01:27:54.467
<v Michael Bonaccor>And these are absolutely you know, just sort of high-level outputs as opposed to outcomes, I would say, is a great question in the context of, you know, the reality that we will eliminate some data analysis capacity.

979
01:27:54.726 --> 01:28:05.728
<v Michael Bonaccor>You know, what we are able to do in the Bureau is particularly make sure that the funds that we are investing in capital projects, as it, you know, as it relates to folks' housing, Councilor—.

980
01:28:05.728 --> 01:28:06.064
<v Michael Bonaccor>Councilmember Herbold.

981
01:28:07.046 --> 01:28:22.048
<v Michael Bonaccor>That money is being sort of diligently tracked and expended as it's meant to, and that there is compliance with the regulatory agreement on the other side of completion of the property.

982
01:28:22.483 --> 01:28:30.193
<v Michael Bonaccor>We don't have any capacity to do more evaluation-based work.

983
01:28:31.158 --> 01:28:34.225
<v Michael Bonaccor>We do have a renter hotline in which people can call in and—.

984
01:28:34.225 --> 01:28:34.327
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

985
01:28:35.912 --> 01:28:36.090
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

986
01:28:36.396 --> 01:28:39.643
<v Michael Bonaccor>Express concerns that we can sort of help route and follow up on.

987
01:28:39.707 --> 01:28:53.137
<v Michael Bonaccor>But in terms of, you know, sort of what is the quality of life of folks' experience in the housing that we help fund, that's not a line of, you know, sort of outcome measurement that we currently provide.

988
01:28:53.250 --> 01:29:04.203
<v Michael Bonaccor>But in terms of our ability to provide a deeper level of what sorts of things do we track, you know, There's opportunity to present more on that.

989
01:29:04.412 --> 01:29:05.248
<v Dan Ryan>There is opportunity.

990
01:29:05.296 --> 01:29:07.095
<v Dan Ryan>I think Councilor Zimmerman spoke to that.

991
01:29:07.161 --> 01:29:14.856
<v Dan Ryan>There's an opportunity to rethink the structure of this bureau, and we have enough information to realize that this is a need.

992
01:29:15.756 --> 01:29:17.765
<v Dan Ryan>There's so many reasons for that.

993
01:29:18.890 --> 01:29:19.934
<v Dan Ryan>What is the vacancy?

994
01:29:20.014 --> 01:29:21.507
<v Dan Ryan>What are the major maintenance issues?

995
01:29:21.604 --> 01:29:23.146
<v Dan Ryan>What's the quality of life for residents?

996
01:29:23.710 --> 01:29:30.876
<v Dan Ryan>We should be tracking that for at least 3 years, and it's not just it's the Home Forward issues that keep coming up in District 2.

997
01:29:31.020 --> 01:29:32.033
<v Dan Ryan>It's with others.

998
01:29:32.305 --> 01:29:46.012
<v Dan Ryan>So we were at a budget hearing on Monday night, and I had the 3rd person from a unit explain to me very similar stories of what we're reading about some of the units and some of the buildings at Home Forward.

999
01:29:46.606 --> 01:29:59.412
<v Dan Ryan>This is yet another elder who says they don't feel safe in their building, and they pay their fixed income is given to this organization so they can live there, and they assume there could be a high quality of life.

1000
01:29:59.878 --> 01:30:07.948
<v Dan Ryan>So I think that we really need to get to the bottom of this, and we need to be proactive and not continue to look like it's not our issue when it is.

1001
01:30:09.297 --> 01:30:11.912
<v Dan Ryan>I'm curious about a couple other things.

1002
01:30:12.041 --> 01:30:18.872
<v Dan Ryan>One is I appreciated when Chair Avalos in early this year had— we had a great discussion about the roles between the city and the county.

1003
01:30:18.929 --> 01:30:19.024
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

1004
01:30:19.989 --> 01:30:21.984
<v Dan Ryan>And we kind of landed in some places.

1005
01:30:22.095 --> 01:30:23.318
<v Dan Ryan>The city's about building.

1006
01:30:23.382 --> 01:30:24.460
<v Dan Ryan>The city's about building.

1007
01:30:24.507 --> 01:30:25.649
<v Dan Ryan>That came up over and over again.

1008
01:30:25.713 --> 01:30:26.920
<v Dan Ryan>The county's more about rent.

1009
01:30:27.909 --> 01:30:35.539
<v Dan Ryan>The irony of that is then we listen to advocates say they want rent vouchers, and then after 2 minutes of discussion, that passed 3 to 2 that we should do what we said.

1010
01:30:35.636 --> 01:30:36.953
<v Dan Ryan>We really isn't our role clarity.

1011
01:30:37.018 --> 01:30:38.565
<v Dan Ryan>But anyway, I'll try to get over that.

1012
01:30:40.166 --> 01:30:43.655
<v Dan Ryan>My point is, what is our role?

1013
01:30:44.528 --> 01:30:45.949
<v Dan Ryan>And this is a time maybe to rethink that.

1014
01:30:45.998 --> 01:30:46.176
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1015
01:30:46.341 --> 01:31:00.363
<v Dan Ryan>That because the county exists and so does the city, and we're duplicating some of our efforts, and we don't have time for that now with the, with the reality of the local budget crisis because of the lack of revenue that's coming into both the city and the county.

1016
01:31:00.877 --> 01:31:04.938
<v Dan Ryan>I was curious about the $234K from the cannabis fund going away.

1017
01:31:05.795 --> 01:31:09.902
<v Dan Ryan>Where's that going, or is there just not enough money in the cannabis fund coming to us anymore?

1018
01:31:09.983 --> 01:31:11.114
<v Dan Ryan>Do you know the answer to that question?

1019
01:31:12.524 --> 01:31:15.671
<v Michael Bonaccor>I do believe it's a reduction in revenue that's available, but yes.

1020
01:31:15.719 --> 01:31:16.457
<v Donnie Oliveira>That is correct, Councilor.

1021
01:31:17.805 --> 01:31:23.073
<v Dan Ryan>And so I wish it was there 'cause actually I think it's going to some strange places now.

1022
01:31:23.521 --> 01:31:35.114
<v Dan Ryan>I think that if the Housing Bureau was using it for behavioral health specialists in these same units where everyone's complaining those services were promised but they're not receiving them, that would be a start.

1023
01:31:36.127 --> 01:31:36.448
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1024
01:31:36.849 --> 01:31:37.234
<v Michael Bonaccor>Thank you.

1025
01:31:37.765 --> 01:31:38.747
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1026
01:31:39.086 --> 01:31:39.632
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1027
01:31:41.984 --> 01:31:43.690
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you so much, Director Bonaccor.

1028
01:31:43.851 --> 01:31:44.770
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for your service as well.

1029
01:31:45.123 --> 01:31:50.054
<v Mitch Green>Um, wish you, uh, all the best into your, into your next very difficult, um, job.

1030
01:31:50.555 --> 01:32:02.295
<v Mitch Green>Uh, just very briefly, I just was hoping to get some sense of whether or not these 2, um, cut vacancy positions, um, are going to impact the, um, Unified Housing Strategy work and the social housing work.

1031
01:32:05.912 --> 01:32:06.894
<v Michael Bonaccor>Thanks for the question, Councilor.

1032
01:32:06.958 --> 01:32:09.072
<v Michael Bonaccor>Again, I think it's more of an opportunity cost.

1033
01:32:09.185 --> 01:32:15.826
<v Michael Bonaccor>I think if there was more, if those positions were there, our ability to do more would exist.

1034
01:32:16.822 --> 01:32:24.225
<v Michael Bonaccor>But we're not in a position where we're saying the Unified Housing Strategy can't be supported by the Bureau or the Social Housing Study can't be.

1035
01:32:24.369 --> 01:32:31.333
<v Michael Bonaccor>And I think hopefully you're seeing good progress on both and we feel like we can You know, continue to stay on that track.

1036
01:32:31.445 --> 01:32:40.770
<v Michael Bonaccor>There could come moments depending on what the next iteration of work looks like or what implementation looks like that in future budget cycles we might say if we're going to pull this off, we would need X.

1037
01:32:40.931 --> 01:32:47.548
<v Michael Bonaccor>But as it stands now, that work, you know, we're staffed to continue moving that work forward.

1038
01:32:47.920 --> 01:32:48.016
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1039
01:32:48.355 --> 01:32:49.100
<v Mitch Green>I needed to hear that.

1040
01:32:49.229 --> 01:32:49.439
<v Michael Bonaccor>Thank you.

1041
01:32:49.488 --> 01:32:49.634
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1042
01:32:51.573 --> 01:32:52.286
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1043
01:32:52.545 --> 01:32:53.095
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1044
01:32:53.854 --> 01:32:54.987
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

1045
01:32:55.471 --> 01:32:57.520
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Michael, for all the work that you've done for us.

1046
01:32:57.605 --> 01:33:02.643
<v Loretta Smith>I worked with you when I was a Multnomah County Commissioner, and I appreciated your work.

1047
01:33:03.444 --> 01:33:08.728
<v Loretta Smith>Um, but as for this budget, I want to know more about the Home Share program.

1048
01:33:09.868 --> 01:33:16.547
<v Loretta Smith>Um, there was $500,000 put in the budget for 20— what was it, '25-'26?

1049
01:33:17.253 --> 01:33:23.340
<v Loretta Smith>And I believe we, we're also putting another $500,000 in.

1050
01:33:23.886 --> 01:33:24.655
<v Eric Engstrom>No.

1051
01:33:24.881 --> 01:33:32.983
<v Michael Bonaccor>Uh, so the, the the initial $500,000 rolls— is requested to roll into this budget year.

1052
01:33:33.774 --> 01:33:35.145
<v Loretta Smith>It will be the leftover money?

1053
01:33:35.210 --> 01:33:35.338
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1054
01:33:35.693 --> 01:33:40.701
<v Loretta Smith>And so with the mayor's budget, he's asking to have that rolled over to be able to pay for it.

1055
01:33:41.006 --> 01:33:42.181
<v Loretta Smith>So tell me what happened.

1056
01:33:42.230 --> 01:33:44.810
<v Loretta Smith>Why didn't that program get off the ground in a year?

1057
01:33:46.444 --> 01:33:48.483
<v Michael Bonaccor>It did get off the ground in a year.

1058
01:33:49.760 --> 01:34:05.329
<v Michael Bonaccor>So there was a process of designing the program, finding platforms that could sort of make the connections between renters and homeowners, sort of developing the policy of how that works, legal review.

1059
01:34:05.957 --> 01:34:23.176
<v Michael Bonaccor>So some of the, you know, what we wanted to be sure of here in Portland was this program work, you know, is in other markets, but are the sort of protections that folks will have adequate as they are in other places, or did, you know, are there other pieces that need to be put in place?

1060
01:34:23.689 --> 01:34:29.313
<v Michael Bonaccor>So the program's up and running now, and homeowners and renters can now be matched.

1061
01:34:29.408 --> 01:34:33.827
<v Loretta Smith>How many renters will we help with that $500,000?

1062
01:34:34.774 --> 01:34:40.220
<v Michael Bonaccor>I believe there is funding for up to 350 renters.

1063
01:34:41.521 --> 01:34:42.613
<v Loretta Smith>Who actually does that program?

1064
01:34:42.662 --> 01:34:44.895
<v Loretta Smith>Who's the coordinator or director of that program?

1065
01:34:45.082 --> 01:34:47.502
<v Loretta Smith>Where does that program— who does that?

1066
01:34:47.681 --> 01:34:47.957
<v Michael Bonaccor>Sure.

1067
01:34:48.104 --> 01:34:52.975
<v Michael Bonaccor>That is under the direction of Josh Roper, our Policy and Planning Director.

1068
01:34:54.076 --> 01:34:54.658
<v Loretta Smith>Policy and Planning Director.

1069
01:34:55.126 --> 01:35:04.528
<v Loretta Smith>That was one of the new programs that I was really excited about in terms of making sure that people got into homes.

1070
01:35:04.673 --> 01:35:07.643
<v Loretta Smith>And that was something different from what we were doing.

1071
01:35:08.713 --> 01:35:15.037
<v Loretta Smith>Will you all, because I know it started, the process in February and it was approved in June.

1072
01:35:16.018 --> 01:35:18.363
<v Loretta Smith>But I'm just trying to— I, I'd like to have a report.

1073
01:35:18.444 --> 01:35:28.439
<v Loretta Smith>I know you're not going to be here, but it would be great to have a report out on— in the Housing and Permit or in the Committee of the Whole, just, you know, what's going on with it.

1074
01:35:28.487 --> 01:35:30.389
<v Loretta Smith>What kind of folks are we putting in?

1075
01:35:30.436 --> 01:35:32.020
<v Loretta Smith>Are these people from shelters?

1076
01:35:32.440 --> 01:35:35.914
<v Loretta Smith>Who, who are the folks that are using this particular program?

1077
01:35:36.399 --> 01:35:37.291
<v Michael Bonaccor>Yes, absolutely.

1078
01:35:37.729 --> 01:35:38.199
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1079
01:35:39.594 --> 01:35:40.453
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1080
01:35:42.949 --> 01:35:44.158
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, no one else in the queue?

1081
01:35:44.417 --> 01:35:45.530
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to give us a bathroom break.

1082
01:35:45.578 --> 01:35:45.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>I thought I was.

1083
01:35:45.966 --> 01:35:46.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, Councilor Ryan.

1084
01:35:46.949 --> 01:35:48.564
<v Jamie Dunphy>Then we're going to go bathroom break.

1085
01:35:48.627 --> 01:35:49.402
<v Dan Ryan>40 Seconds.

1086
01:35:50.466 --> 01:35:57.130
<v Dan Ryan>Question, what was the FTE of the Housing Bureau before the 2016 bond?

1087
01:35:58.270 --> 01:35:59.990
<v Dan Ryan>What was it at peak of the bond?

1088
01:36:00.457 --> 01:36:01.341
<v Dan Ryan>And what is it today?

1089
01:36:03.277 --> 01:36:06.711
<v Michael Bonaccor>We will get you factual answers to that question, Councilor.

1090
01:36:06.792 --> 01:36:20.979
<v Michael Bonaccor>I can tell you what I understand anecdotally is that as resources swelled into the bureau, there was not a significant increase, if any, staff to manage those resources.

1091
01:36:21.155 --> 01:36:22.423
<v Michael Bonaccor>So we haven't seen—.

1092
01:36:23.018 --> 01:36:30.542
<v Dan Ryan>You're telling me I'll see numbers for FTE prior to the bonds similar to the number of FTE FTEs during the bond, the peak of the bond.

1093
01:36:30.862 --> 01:36:36.746
<v Michael Bonaccor>You know, honestly, actually, Councilor, forgive me, I was thinking of the ARPA resources and not the bond.

1094
01:36:36.810 --> 01:36:39.247
<v Michael Bonaccor>So we'll just get you that, we'll get you that information.

1095
01:36:39.295 --> 01:36:41.217
<v Dan Ryan>And you can include ARPA.

1096
01:36:41.378 --> 01:36:49.185
<v Dan Ryan>My point is we had those FTE rate prior to, during the peak, and then you could tell me the sources and then where we are today.

1097
01:36:49.875 --> 01:36:54.494
<v Dan Ryan>I think I'm looking at what is the Housing Bureau today Post-bond.

1098
01:36:55.635 --> 01:37:04.663
<v Dan Ryan>And of course, I'm advocating for more oversight with metrics so we can be more accountable to the good people in Portland that are living in the units that we help build.

1099
01:37:04.889 --> 01:37:05.546
<v Michael Bonaccor>Understood, Councilor.

1100
01:37:05.595 --> 01:37:06.012
<v Michael Bonaccor>Thank you.

1101
01:37:07.217 --> 01:37:07.988
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1102
01:37:08.101 --> 01:37:10.912
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, we're going to take a quick 15-minute bathroom break.

1103
01:37:11.234 --> 01:37:16.054
<v Jamie Dunphy>Back here at 11:15, we'll come back and finish the planning section of Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

1104
01:37:16.872 --> 01:37:18.061
<v Jamie Dunphy>See you at 11:15.

1105
01:37:18.222 --> 01:37:20.295
<v Jamie Dunphy>Well, that's 12 minutes.

1106
01:37:20.917 --> 01:52:25.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's 12 minutes, but I know everyone's gonna roll in at 11:20, so it's and we are thank you very much, friends.

1107
01:52:25.805 --> 01:52:31.373
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to, uh, we're now turning over to the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability, where— correction, we're not just talking about planning.

1108
01:52:31.871 --> 01:52:35.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are also talking about everything in the Planning and Sustainability Bureau except for PSEF.

1109
01:52:36.076 --> 01:52:38.065
<v Jamie Dunphy>So hold your PSEF questions till later.

1110
01:52:38.371 --> 01:52:44.083
<v Jamie Dunphy>But otherwise, I'm going to turn it over, back over to DCA Oliveira and Director Engstrom.

1111
01:52:44.324 --> 01:52:45.207
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you, Council President.

1112
01:52:45.271 --> 01:52:49.476
<v Donnie Oliveira>Actually, you said the thing that I was just going to say, so I'm just going to kick right over to Director Engstrom.

1113
01:52:49.782 --> 01:52:50.069
<v Dan Ryan>Perfect.

1114
01:52:50.262 --> 01:52:50.712
<v Eric Engstrom>Good morning.

1115
01:52:50.807 --> 01:52:52.234
<v Eric Engstrom>For the record, my name is Eric Engstrom.

1116
01:52:52.283 --> 01:52:54.560
<v Eric Engstrom>I'm the director of the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

1117
01:52:55.954 --> 01:53:03.779
<v Eric Engstrom>BPS collaborates with partners, organizations, and community to help design and implement the next generation of urban strategies to achieve our citywide goals.

1118
01:53:04.453 --> 01:53:09.247
<v Eric Engstrom>BPS's work is externally facing and fundamentally about setting direction for the future.

1119
01:53:10.225 --> 01:53:21.801
<v Eric Engstrom>The bureau includes urban planning, climate and energy programs, solid waste and recycling, franchise utilities, and the Portland Clean Energy PSEF is being discussed tomorrow, so today we're going to focus on the rest of BPS.

1120
01:53:22.979 --> 01:53:26.327
<v Eric Engstrom>PSEF is more than 90% of BPS's budget.

1121
01:53:26.521 --> 01:53:27.235
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide, please.

1122
01:53:30.101 --> 01:53:33.525
<v Eric Engstrom>So I'm going to help you understand what you see with it.

1123
01:53:33.573 --> 01:53:38.863
<v Eric Engstrom>This is the whole bureau when you see this slide, but I'm going to walk you through what the elements of the non-PSEF parts are.

1124
01:53:39.497 --> 01:53:41.396
<v Eric Engstrom>Again, 90% of the bureau's budget is PSEF.

1125
01:53:41.462 --> 01:53:41.997
<v Eric Engstrom>That's a lot of money.

1126
01:53:42.942 --> 01:53:45.538
<v Eric Engstrom>This total includes roughly $425 million.

1127
01:53:45.587 --> 01:53:50.988
<v Eric Engstrom>That's PCF's ending fund balance, or future year CIP spending, if you want to call it that.

1128
01:53:52.399 --> 01:53:56.295
<v Eric Engstrom>Without that fund balance, the bureau's budget is closer to $300 million.

1129
01:53:56.407 --> 01:54:02.065
<v Eric Engstrom>And without PCF, the budget for planning, community technology, and waste programs together is about $41 million.

1130
01:54:02.802 --> 01:54:05.832
<v Eric Engstrom>A chunk of that is in the general fund and a chunk is in the other funds.

1131
01:54:06.666 --> 01:54:13.527
<v Eric Engstrom>The general fund is about a third of BPS's non-PCF funding, which supports planning, community technology, and graffiti abatement.

1132
01:54:14.104 --> 01:54:19.412
<v Eric Engstrom>Other revenue comes from the Solid Waste Fund, intergovernmental agreements, the state, and some grants.

1133
01:54:20.855 --> 01:54:25.073
<v Eric Engstrom>Urban Planning is primarily funded by the General Fund with some secondary grant funding.

1134
01:54:25.987 --> 01:54:29.931
<v Eric Engstrom>The Climate and Energy programs are supported by PSEF and the Solid Waste Funds.

1135
01:54:30.478 --> 01:54:38.671
<v Eric Engstrom>Community Technology, the largest component of which is the franchise utility team, is funded by the General Fund and historically with some interagency revenue from the Mt.

1136
01:54:38.801 --> 01:54:49.490
<v Eric Engstrom>Hood Cable Regulatory Commission, and we'll discuss The franchise utility program, just a reminder that that brings in about $90 million annually into the general fund.

1137
01:54:50.442 --> 01:54:57.302
<v Eric Engstrom>It's one of your primary revenue sources through franchise that we grant to private utilities to operate in the public right-of-way.

1138
01:54:57.368 --> 01:55:01.688
<v Eric Engstrom>This includes things like power companies, the gas company, pipelines, and telecommunications.

1139
01:55:03.317 --> 01:55:10.564
<v Eric Engstrom>The solid waste and recycling utility is funded by the Solid Waste Management Fund, which is generated when you pay your garbage bill, and we'll discuss the waste rates in a moment.

1140
01:55:10.631 --> 01:55:10.796
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

1141
01:55:11.810 --> 01:55:13.623
<v Eric Engstrom>A little bit later in this presentation.

1142
01:55:14.970 --> 01:55:23.534
<v Eric Engstrom>BPS also supports its internal service functions with an overhead pool that includes contributions from all these sources that I just mentioned, including PSF and waste.

1143
01:55:24.404 --> 01:55:32.777
<v Eric Engstrom>That pool pays for things like communications, HR, procurement, tech services, engagement, finance, and the director's office.

1144
01:55:35.364 --> 01:55:39.654
<v Eric Engstrom>That pool is shown on this chart as part of the general fund budget because that's where we budget it.

1145
01:55:39.779 --> 01:55:42.862
<v Eric Engstrom>But some of that revenue, I just want to note, is coming from PSF and waste.

1146
01:55:43.006 --> 01:55:46.670
<v Eric Engstrom>So the actual general fund total is a little bit less than what you're seeing there.

1147
01:55:48.380 --> 01:55:51.606
<v Eric Engstrom>The general fund column also includes some one-time money going to graffiti.

1148
01:55:52.671 --> 01:55:53.381
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide, please.

1149
01:55:55.699 --> 01:56:03.637
<v Eric Engstrom>Most of, as you can see here, one of the biggest changes in our FTE count is through the broader citywide internal services realignment.

1150
01:56:06.725 --> 01:56:14.224
<v Eric Engstrom>Most of that team is being realigned to join the CEDSA internal services team now serving PP&D housing as well as BPS.

1151
01:56:14.658 --> 01:56:18.817
<v Eric Engstrom>And you'll learn more about that with the realignment discussion in a few days, I believe.

1152
01:56:19.893 --> 01:56:23.201
<v Eric Engstrom>But that includes our HR procurement tech services and engagement teams.

1153
01:56:24.613 --> 01:56:30.587
<v Eric Engstrom>2 Other positions, as was noted earlier, are being realigned to support the new city data and privacy office as well.

1154
01:56:30.716 --> 01:56:32.963
<v Eric Engstrom>That's within that realignment number.

1155
01:56:33.045 --> 01:56:33.204
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1156
01:56:35.195 --> 01:56:35.775
<v Sameer Kanal>Next slide.

1157
01:56:38.497 --> 01:56:48.653
<v Eric Engstrom>So despite this being a difficult budget year, BPS will continue to prioritize working with other bureaus, especially PP&D and Public Works, to streamline and improve regulations that apply to development.

1158
01:56:49.270 --> 01:56:54.751
<v Eric Engstrom>In coordination with Portland Permitting and Development, we will be launching several regulatory improvement initiatives in the coming year.

1159
01:56:55.364 --> 01:56:58.729
<v Eric Engstrom>You already hear a little bit about the CAP 2 project being one of those.

1160
01:56:59.873 --> 01:57:07.119
<v Eric Engstrom>Portland also has a solid, world-class solid waste and recycling service, and we're well positioned to continue making that better.

1161
01:57:07.667 --> 01:57:15.537
<v Eric Engstrom>Our biggest push this year will be aimed at apartment buildings as we evaluate options to improve recycling and composting services for those customers.

1162
01:57:17.920 --> 01:57:36.761
<v Eric Engstrom>Finally, although the Chief Sustainability Officer is now housed with the City Administrator, we continue to be one of the key pillars in the city's climate work, including supporting energy efficiency in buildings, Supporting the development of a city energy strategy, managing the renewable fuels transition, and engagement with energy utilities working towards a cleaner grid.

1163
01:57:38.119 --> 01:57:44.307
<v Eric Engstrom>And of course, promoting sustainable development is inherently connected to our land use and comprehensive planning functions as well.

1164
01:57:45.899 --> 01:57:46.386
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide.

1165
01:57:48.677 --> 01:57:52.252
<v Eric Engstrom>These next few slides describe the places where we're going to be doing a bit less.

1166
01:57:53.579 --> 01:57:57.639
<v Eric Engstrom>One of the mayor's guidance encouraged us to look at specific functions rather than just thinning the soup across the board, and we took that to heart.

1167
01:57:57.704 --> 01:57:57.868
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

1168
01:58:01.155 --> 01:58:05.618
<v Eric Engstrom>Area planning is one of the functions where the proposed budget will leave us with fewer resources.

1169
01:58:06.358 --> 01:58:09.136
<v Eric Engstrom>This is the team that does area-specific neighborhood planning.

1170
01:58:09.408 --> 01:58:11.801
<v Eric Engstrom>This team has been an important part of the Bureau for many years.

1171
01:58:12.378 --> 01:58:25.144
<v Eric Engstrom>Recent examples of their work include the, the Lower Southeast Rising Area Plan, the Southwest Town Center Plans, our work to support the Albina Vision Trust, and the Montgomery Park Area Plan.

1172
01:58:25.192 --> 01:58:25.368
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

1173
01:58:26.125 --> 01:58:34.506
<v Eric Engstrom>In this coming budget year, we're gonna prioritize delivery of the Inner East rezoning project, which you all have talked about.

1174
01:58:34.734 --> 01:58:40.654
<v Eric Engstrom>I know it's a council priority, but we're gonna not have as much capacity to do other things within that team.

1175
01:58:42.506 --> 01:58:42.730
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide.

1176
01:58:45.430 --> 01:58:50.764
<v Eric Engstrom>A second area of cuts is pausing our outgoing Digital Inclusion Grant Program in community technology.

1177
01:58:51.198 --> 01:58:54.764
<v Eric Engstrom>This is one of the larger buckets of general fund money within the Bureau's budget.

1178
01:58:55.125 --> 01:58:57.895
<v Eric Engstrom>That does not— is not all staff.

1179
01:58:57.960 --> 01:59:00.309
<v Eric Engstrom>So that's one of the reasons that cut was taken.

1180
01:59:01.510 --> 01:59:01.913
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide.

1181
01:59:04.064 --> 01:59:08.578
<v Eric Engstrom>Third, we'll be cutting the remaining general fund support from our climate team.

1182
01:59:08.805 --> 01:59:14.588
<v Eric Engstrom>This was money we used for contractors to provide technical expertise that we don't have as much of in-house.

1183
01:59:14.798 --> 01:59:22.873
<v Eric Engstrom>This is going to reduce our ability to support— provide technical support to customers and realtors who are fulfilling the home energy score requirements.

1184
01:59:23.600 --> 01:59:31.672
<v Eric Engstrom>It's going to reduce our ability to do some climate-related technical analysis, and it's going to affect our participation in some peer city networks.

1185
01:59:33.564 --> 01:59:48.091
<v Eric Engstrom>While we're reducing our reliance on contractors with this cut, and we will need to rethink some of these programs or do less with those programs as a result, in addition to the general fund reduction, this team is losing an ongoing grant-funded position.

1186
01:59:49.055 --> 01:59:54.131
<v Eric Engstrom>Because we came to the end of a long multi-year grant that we had over the last decade.

1187
01:59:54.372 --> 02:00:01.389
<v Eric Engstrom>And so that ongoing position was cut as a— not as a result of the general fund cuts, but as a result of the grant running out.

1188
02:00:02.519 --> 02:00:03.036
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide.

1189
02:00:05.731 --> 02:00:06.878
<v Eric Engstrom>I'm gonna talk now about the Mt.

1190
02:00:06.960 --> 02:00:08.685
<v Eric Engstrom>Hood Cable Regulatory Commission.

1191
02:00:10.502 --> 02:00:17.532
<v Eric Engstrom>As you all have heard before, the number of people who have cable television subscriptions is declining and is expected to continue declining.

1192
02:00:17.579 --> 02:00:17.693
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

1193
02:00:18.697 --> 02:00:22.431
<v Eric Engstrom>This means that cable franchise revenue is declining, making the existing Mt.

1194
02:00:22.479 --> 02:00:25.045
<v Eric Engstrom>Hood Cable Commission structure unsustainable.

1195
02:00:25.670 --> 02:00:31.985
<v Eric Engstrom>And accordingly, as I've talked to you all before, the city has signed a dissolution agreement with other member jurisdictions.

1196
02:00:32.563 --> 02:00:33.988
<v Eric Engstrom>That happened in 2025.

1197
02:00:34.518 --> 02:00:44.697
<v Eric Engstrom>The mayor's budget includes several technical decisions related to that dissolution, including recognizing cable revenue coming to the city rather than flowing through the Mt.

1198
02:00:44.824 --> 02:00:59.449
<v Eric Engstrom>Hood Cable Commission, redirecting some staff funds that had previously gone to the Mount Hood Cable Commission that would now go to BPS, and then reassigning some council-specific open signal funding from BPS to council operations.

1199
02:00:59.868 --> 02:01:02.033
<v Eric Engstrom>That's related to your broadcasting funding.

1200
02:01:02.858 --> 02:01:14.787
<v Eric Engstrom>Essentially, the city will continue to have a cable franchise, but the dissolution of the commission and the budget decisions we're making here mean that we'll be directly managing that work rather than relying on the Mount Hood Cable Commission.

1201
02:01:15.877 --> 02:01:16.362
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide.

1202
02:01:17.510 --> 02:01:21.113
<v Eric Engstrom>I'm now going to pivot to our waste and recycling rates.

1203
02:01:23.155 --> 02:01:28.243
<v Eric Engstrom>The waste and recycling utility is divided into 2 primary systems, residential and commercial.

1204
02:01:28.887 --> 02:01:33.123
<v Eric Engstrom>The residential waste system generates about 1/3 of all the waste we handle.

1205
02:01:33.640 --> 02:01:40.475
<v Eric Engstrom>The commercial system, which includes businesses, apartments, and deconstruction waste, generates about 2/3 of the waste.

1206
02:01:41.307 --> 02:01:46.057
<v Eric Engstrom>The city has waste-setting authority over the residential system but not the commercial system.

1207
02:01:46.859 --> 02:01:54.289
<v Eric Engstrom>The residential system is a franchise utility where private companies provide the service on our behalf, assigned to specific geographies.

1208
02:01:54.563 --> 02:02:00.404
<v Eric Engstrom>The city sets the overall rules and the types of services that must be provided through franchise agreements.

1209
02:02:01.222 --> 02:02:07.128
<v Eric Engstrom>And as a reminder, the rate formulas are driven by those franchise agreements, which are negotiated every 5 to 7 years.

1210
02:02:07.193 --> 02:02:07.385
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

1211
02:02:07.882 --> 02:02:10.966
<v Eric Engstrom>Council reviews the rates annually as we're doing starting now.

1212
02:02:12.217 --> 02:02:15.157
<v Eric Engstrom>But this is— there's not a lot of discretion in this process.

1213
02:02:15.814 --> 02:02:23.024
<v Eric Engstrom>There's an agreed-to formula in the franchise agreements and deviating from that would put the franchise agreements and services in jeopardy.

1214
02:02:24.404 --> 02:02:56.021
<v Eric Engstrom>Per the franchise agreements, the residential rates are based on the cost of service plus an allowance for a target operating margin and incorporation of the city's franchise To break that down a little bit more, about 39% goes to the cost of collection, 25% is related to the cost of disposal, 19% is company administrative costs, 9.5% is the operating margin, and 8% is the city's franchise fee, which goes into the solid waste fund and supports the BPS solid waste programs.

1215
02:02:57.179 --> 02:03:02.619
<v Eric Engstrom>The 9.5% operating margin, by the way, is used to establish the rates at It's not a guaranteed rate of return.

1216
02:03:04.880 --> 02:03:07.832
<v Eric Engstrom>Again, in contrast, the commercial system is a free market system.

1217
02:03:07.895 --> 02:03:09.219
<v Eric Engstrom>There's not assigned geographies.

1218
02:03:09.347 --> 02:03:16.697
<v Eric Engstrom>The city sets the overall rules and establishes a per-ton tipping fee, but customers may choose their haulers and we don't set those rates.

1219
02:03:17.966 --> 02:03:18.496
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide.

1220
02:03:19.894 --> 02:03:27.542
<v Eric Engstrom>Here you can see how our rates compare to other cities on the West Coast as well as some neighboring cities.

1221
02:03:27.657 --> 02:03:29.578
<v Eric Engstrom>We kind of fall in the middle of that range.

1222
02:03:30.747 --> 02:03:37.257
<v Eric Engstrom>Where it says equal, it means that they provide an equivalent level of service as us in that category.

1223
02:03:37.354 --> 02:03:41.295
<v Eric Engstrom>Where it says less means either less often or fewer services.

1224
02:03:41.488 --> 02:03:45.654
<v Eric Engstrom>And where it says more means that they handle more or do it more often.

1225
02:03:47.279 --> 02:03:55.202
<v Eric Engstrom>And generally, the cities that provide higher service have higher rates than the cities that provide equal or lower service have lower rates.

1226
02:03:57.189 --> 02:03:57.770
<v Eric Engstrom>Next slide.

1227
02:03:59.850 --> 02:04:03.766
<v Eric Engstrom>This slide shows our proposed rate changes this year.

1228
02:04:04.930 --> 02:04:10.287
<v Eric Engstrom>The rate review process begins in January when we receive detailed cost reports from each hauler.

1229
02:04:10.529 --> 02:04:13.532
<v Eric Engstrom>We then send those to a CPA to vet them.

1230
02:04:14.350 --> 02:04:23.712
<v Eric Engstrom>We receive adjusted costs from those— from that CPA, and then we work with an economist to implement our rate model and come up with the numbers that you see in front of you.

1231
02:04:24.587 --> 02:04:30.189
<v Eric Engstrom>In early April, we met with haulers and we also hosted a public information session for general public interest.

1232
02:04:32.224 --> 02:04:38.356
<v Eric Engstrom>I want to highlight here that one component of the cost in disposal is Metro's disposal fees.

1233
02:04:38.632 --> 02:04:46.387
<v Eric Engstrom>And in prior years, we would use actual Metro fees as the calculator there, which don't become available until May.

1234
02:04:47.113 --> 02:04:59.568
<v Eric Engstrom>In order to create more time for you all to consider the rates, we are pivoting this year to a system where we use an assumed Metro rate based on the prior year plus a cost escalator.

1235
02:05:00.288 --> 02:05:05.212
<v Eric Engstrom>If Metro's rates then come in differently than what we predicted, that will catch up in the following year.

1236
02:05:05.292 --> 02:05:18.364
<v Eric Engstrom>So other cities in the region do this backward-looking rate calculation instead of forward, and we're going to pivot to that this year because it allows us more time and we're not going to force you into an emergency ordinance at the end of the year.

1237
02:05:19.150 --> 02:05:19.279
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

1238
02:05:21.768 --> 02:05:24.743
<v Eric Engstrom>The proposed rates, as you can see, are a modest increase this year.

1239
02:05:24.823 --> 02:05:31.095
<v Eric Engstrom>Drivers of the higher costs include wages, benefits, and fuel, and increased disposal costs, as I just described.

1240
02:05:32.300 --> 02:05:41.404
<v Eric Engstrom>Those are partially offset by declining recycling costs, which are in part due to the Statewide Recycling Modernization Act and some of the subsidies that show up there.

1241
02:05:43.395 --> 02:05:48.136
<v Eric Engstrom>The rate increases are very modest, and this is actually the smallest increase we've proposed in recent years.

1242
02:05:48.202 --> 02:05:48.331
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

1243
02:05:49.954 --> 02:05:55.145
<v Eric Engstrom>We're not proposing any increase to the commercial tonnage fee, so I'm not even showing that on the chart.

1244
02:05:55.194 --> 02:06:00.956
<v Eric Engstrom>And that is within our discretion to— and is a slight deviation from our 5-year financial plan.

1245
02:06:01.085 --> 02:06:06.844
<v Eric Engstrom>But given the city's budget situation, we chose to not move a rate increase on that forward this year.

1246
02:06:08.386 --> 02:06:15.005
<v Eric Engstrom>If you look at the rates adjusted for inflation, the waste rates overall have been flat for the past 2 decades.

1247
02:06:17.239 --> 02:06:24.270
<v Eric Engstrom>This means your garbage bill today is similar to what it was in 2012, adjusted for inflation.

1248
02:06:24.939 --> 02:06:38.399
<v Eric Engstrom>And finally, a reminder that last year we implemented a financial assistance program for qualified homeowners that comes to a discount of about $22 per month at the 35-gallon service level.

1249
02:06:38.399 --> 02:06:44.420
<v Eric Engstrom>And since the launch in November, we have 900 customers now enrolled in that program, which is linked to the Water Bureau discount program.

1250
02:06:44.409 --> 02:06:44.560
<v Eric Engstrom>Discount thank you, Deputy City Administrator Donnie Oliveira.

1251
02:06:44.765 --> 02:06:45.248
<v Eric Engstrom>Program.

1252
02:06:47.104 --> 02:06:51.106
<v Eric Engstrom>We are working now on ways to expand that eligibility to low-income renters.

1253
02:06:52.011 --> 02:06:58.703
<v Eric Engstrom>That's a little bit more technically difficult just because a lot of times they don't hold the garbage bill, but we're working on that.

1254
02:06:59.381 --> 02:07:03.293
<v Eric Engstrom>We also launched a standardized rate for bulky item disposal this year.

1255
02:07:03.488 --> 02:07:08.838
<v Eric Engstrom>Previous, each hauler had different rates, or sometimes they didn't even advertise their rates.

1256
02:07:09.229 --> 02:07:18.726
<v Eric Engstrom>We now require a consistent rate for that, which which we hope will help folks understand how they can properly dispose of bulky items instead of just dumping them in a ravine or something.

1257
02:07:20.976 --> 02:07:23.310
<v Eric Engstrom>And that concludes my presentation.

1258
02:07:24.131 --> 02:07:24.953
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, thank you.

1259
02:07:25.823 --> 02:07:27.353
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, let's get into the queue.

1260
02:07:27.434 --> 02:07:29.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

1261
02:07:30.345 --> 02:07:31.898
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Vice President Clark.

1262
02:07:32.770 --> 02:07:33.837
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

1263
02:07:33.903 --> 02:07:35.585
<v Olivia Clark>There's a lot here, Eric.

1264
02:07:36.006 --> 02:07:37.439
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate Thank you.

1265
02:07:37.503 --> 02:07:37.873
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Mayor.

1266
02:07:38.726 --> 02:07:49.186
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate the information, but I just want to briefly ask you a little bit about under what you're preserving on slide 28, just about the waste and recycling services that you have.

1267
02:07:50.600 --> 02:08:01.807
<v Olivia Clark>You have a project underway to improve multi-dwelling recycling and composting services and develop a low-income rate for renters.

1268
02:08:01.921 --> 02:08:20.500
<v Eric Engstrom>Can you talk a little bit more about the yeah, this is a significant project, and we're actually looking at the whole commercial system, the part that's not part of the residential franchise, which again includes apartments, commercial services, and construction waste.

1269
02:08:20.645 --> 02:08:26.894
<v Eric Engstrom>And this is an opportunity to look holistically at the structure of that service and figure out whether we want to do it differently.

1270
02:08:27.570 --> 02:08:34.733
<v Eric Engstrom>Hypothetically, you know, should should multifamily properties be folded into the residential system, for example?

1271
02:08:34.877 --> 02:08:36.515
<v Eric Engstrom>That's a potential question to ask.

1272
02:08:36.724 --> 02:08:37.655
<v Olivia Clark>Are they commercial now?

1273
02:08:37.784 --> 02:08:39.246
<v Eric Engstrom>They're part of the commercial system now.

1274
02:08:39.310 --> 02:08:46.474
<v Eric Engstrom>So property managers of larger multifamily buildings, more than 5 units, can choose their hauler.

1275
02:08:46.698 --> 02:08:53.043
<v Eric Engstrom>And that leads— that has led to a little bit spottier service from the end user's perspective.

1276
02:08:53.671 --> 02:09:06.695
<v Eric Engstrom>If you're an apartment dweller, You know, you're moving from place to place, you're going to experience slightly different levels of service as you go from building to building and hauler to hauler because it's less regulated and it's not as consistent.

1277
02:09:07.418 --> 02:09:17.506
<v Eric Engstrom>Sometimes the composting might be missing from your service, or they might not have as much space in an older building for disposal of recycling goods.

1278
02:09:17.859 --> 02:09:19.641
<v Eric Engstrom>So it's a big project.

1279
02:09:19.770 --> 02:09:23.319
<v Eric Engstrom>There's going to be public involvement with both property managers and renters.

1280
02:09:23.384 --> 02:09:23.609
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

1281
02:09:24.587 --> 02:09:33.112
<v Eric Engstrom>It's going to take us much of the next year or 2 to work through, but we will be bringing proposals back for changes to that system.

1282
02:09:33.801 --> 02:09:47.326
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, may I just want to offer, because this project started when I was back at BPS as well, but the question we're contemplating is what would it look like in Portland if everybody, no matter where you lived and what type of building, had access to the same level of service?

1283
02:09:48.224 --> 02:09:49.201
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that is not true today.

1284
02:09:51.239 --> 02:09:55.060
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, no, I really appreciate that because I am a condo dweller also.

1285
02:09:56.369 --> 02:09:58.470
<v Olivia Clark>Um, you didn't mention the haulers.

1286
02:09:58.470 --> 02:10:01.170
<v Olivia Clark>I imagine you have the haulers involved in this project.

1287
02:10:01.369 --> 02:10:02.050
<v Olivia Clark>Absolutely.

1288
02:10:02.050 --> 02:10:08.880
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, and I'm just thinking that at some point, Eric, you'll maybe bring this for a preview to the Public Works Committee.

1289
02:10:09.670 --> 02:10:13.489
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, we've, we've talked about a potential check-in.

1290
02:10:13.489 --> 02:10:15.289
<v Eric Engstrom>We're developing the, the objectives for the we project right now, don't and we're going to bring it back to the Public Works Committee.

1291
02:10:15.349 --> 02:10:23.055
<v Eric Engstrom>Have objectives for the project right now, and we were thinking that we would bring the objectives to vet through a committee sometime this fall.

1292
02:10:23.601 --> 02:10:23.907
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1293
02:10:23.987 --> 02:10:39.835
<v Olivia Clark>And I would just imagine that you might want to talk to PBOT since we're also looking at a different way of dealing with multifamily on the TUF, that there's some synergy between Water, Public Works, and your bureau as well.

1294
02:10:41.090 --> 02:10:42.011
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, thank you.

1295
02:10:42.692 --> 02:10:43.743
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1296
02:10:43.970 --> 02:10:44.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1297
02:10:46.560 --> 02:10:48.939
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you, Director Engstrom, for the presentation.

1298
02:10:49.069 --> 02:10:52.412
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I want to kind of narrow in on the franchise utility program for a second.

1299
02:10:52.622 --> 02:10:56.076
<v Mitch Green>Um, it is a pretty important revenue stream for the City of Portland.

1300
02:10:56.123 --> 02:10:59.301
<v Mitch Green>It's not the biggest, of course, but it's a pretty foundational one.

1301
02:10:59.350 --> 02:11:10.957
<v Mitch Green>And I'm looking at the proposed budget, um, and it looks like it's just 3 FTEs in the franchise utility Um, I might need to get—.

1302
02:11:11.310 --> 02:11:16.329
<v Eric Engstrom>I think there's some partial people who are split, but approximately 3 or 4.

1303
02:11:16.796 --> 02:11:25.345
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that would explain maybe, because what I'm seeing in the position report is 1 analyst 4 and then 2 analyst 2s and then some vacancies.

1304
02:11:26.479 --> 02:11:34.569
<v Mitch Green>Um, and the Analyst 4 is like under range for that job class, and so I, I, I'm trying to understand.

1305
02:11:35.454 --> 02:11:35.824
<v Mitch Green>Maybe they're—.

1306
02:11:35.824 --> 02:11:36.677
<v Eric Engstrom>It's a small team.

1307
02:11:36.743 --> 02:11:36.984
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah.

1308
02:11:37.064 --> 02:11:37.788
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1309
02:11:37.949 --> 02:11:38.110
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1310
02:11:38.899 --> 02:11:57.775
<v Mitch Green>Um, you know, we're not in an ad year, of course, but I'm thinking when we think about where the resources go in the budget, um, I'm a little bit apprehensive, and maybe you can tell me why I shouldn't be apprehensive, but that we have such a small team managing such a large, uh, revenue center for the, for the city.

1311
02:11:58.180 --> 02:11:59.797
<v Mitch Green>And is that a thing to be worried about?

1312
02:11:59.878 --> 02:12:07.917
<v Mitch Green>Do, do we need to think about Is there a strategic vision on the horizon that I shouldn't be aware of?

1313
02:12:08.608 --> 02:12:18.807
<v Eric Engstrom>I agree with the sentiment that you want to be careful about cutting programs that are generating revenue, and we did not cut core staff in the franchise utility program.

1314
02:12:18.970 --> 02:12:19.018
<v Eric Engstrom>We—.

1315
02:12:19.228 --> 02:12:30.997
<v Eric Engstrom>The larger Community Technology Division did take a cut, in part related to the Mount Hood Cable transition and in part due to the transition of the city's by unwinding the Digital Inclusion Grant Program.

1316
02:12:31.494 --> 02:12:37.220
<v Eric Engstrom>Those are in the same general program, but we didn't cut the core team that's working on the franchise utility revenue.

1317
02:12:37.268 --> 02:12:39.545
<v Eric Engstrom>And I will say that the team has been doing a great job.

1318
02:12:39.625 --> 02:12:48.877
<v Eric Engstrom>They've increased the general fund revenue in the last couple years by more aggressively going after people who haven't paid their franchise bills.

1319
02:12:49.310 --> 02:12:51.106
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, and I want to recognize that.

1320
02:12:51.155 --> 02:12:52.487
<v Mitch Green>I've heard that in other settings.

1321
02:12:52.838 --> 02:12:53.704
<v Mitch Green>That's kudos to that team.

1322
02:12:54.685 --> 02:12:56.771
<v Mitch Green>Let me ask it a slightly different way.

1323
02:12:58.039 --> 02:13:04.670
<v Mitch Green>I have been talking about rate setting as a more sort of deliberate practice across the city, a little bit closer to a hearings process.

1324
02:13:05.585 --> 02:13:17.689
<v Mitch Green>With this staff, could you accommodate requests for different rate design proposals and different ways of thinking about the franchise utility approach, or would that be too burdensome for that staff to accommodate?

1325
02:13:18.123 --> 02:13:20.065
<v Eric Engstrom>No, we have done that.

1326
02:13:20.961 --> 02:13:35.273
<v Eric Engstrom>Just a couple years ago, we rewrote the right-of-way code, which governs the franchise utility system, and that moved us away from individually negotiating franchises to more of a standardized license approach.

1327
02:13:36.659 --> 02:13:46.154
<v Eric Engstrom>And then we are currently doing a project right now to modernize their technology, the portal that the customers use to pay their franchise system.

1328
02:13:46.270 --> 02:13:51.328
<v Eric Engstrom>So the 2 things part of the team's work is sort of system improvement and contemplating improvement.

1329
02:13:52.082 --> 02:13:52.966
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate it.

1330
02:13:53.046 --> 02:13:55.680
<v Donnie Oliveira>Hey, Councilor, may I offer this to the question about the strategy?

1331
02:13:55.952 --> 02:13:56.193
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah.

1332
02:13:56.417 --> 02:14:05.779
<v Donnie Oliveira>I think the point is salient in that, and it's maybe a cautionary tale for all the other conversations we've had earlier about moving programs from one bureau to another.

1333
02:14:07.192 --> 02:14:11.559
<v Donnie Oliveira>The franchise utility team came from another entity that moved into BPS a few years ago.

1334
02:14:12.154 --> 02:14:15.127
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so It's largely still landing in the bureau.

1335
02:14:15.192 --> 02:14:15.434
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's—.

1336
02:14:15.434 --> 02:14:22.630
<v Donnie Oliveira>The team's doing great, to your point and to Eric's point, but we haven't had that time to do that strategic planning yet because we're still stabilizing them as an entity in the bureau.

1337
02:14:22.711 --> 02:14:25.105
<v Donnie Oliveira>So that work is certainly due.

1338
02:14:25.833 --> 02:14:26.918
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that.

1339
02:14:26.966 --> 02:14:33.488
<v Mitch Green>And, you know, as I look at this, the position report here, it looks like the most senior person in that group is an Analyst 4.

1340
02:14:33.634 --> 02:14:35.457
<v Mitch Green>Are they the sort of supervisor?

1341
02:14:35.811 --> 02:14:36.279
<v Mitch Green>Correct.

1342
02:14:36.472 --> 02:14:37.908
<v Mitch Green>Okay, thank you.

1343
02:14:39.222 --> 02:14:39.944
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1344
02:14:40.265 --> 02:14:40.890
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1345
02:14:41.369 --> 02:14:42.220
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1346
02:14:42.925 --> 02:14:49.960
<v Steve Novick>So it's my understanding, based on 60 years of consumption of popular culture, that the mafia is traditionally heavily involved in waste management.

1347
02:14:50.425 --> 02:15:00.423
<v Steve Novick>And this is really a question for the city attorney, I guess, but are we under any legal obligation to consult with the mafia before changing policies and practices relating, relating to waste management?

1348
02:15:00.471 --> 02:15:02.106
<v Steve Novick>And if so, have we discharged that obligation?

1349
02:15:06.060 --> 02:15:09.136
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, we'll defer that to the city attorney when they, when they're available.

1350
02:15:10.930 --> 02:15:11.172
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1351
02:15:11.225 --> 02:15:11.832
<v Steve Novick>I'll follow up.

1352
02:15:13.250 --> 02:15:14.077
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1353
02:15:14.417 --> 02:15:15.229
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1354
02:15:17.502 --> 02:15:19.287
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, I don't think I can follow that.

1355
02:15:19.432 --> 02:15:20.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No, I don't think so.

1356
02:15:20.909 --> 02:15:26.436
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, 2 questions.

1357
02:15:26.502 --> 02:15:37.427
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first one is very small, but because you brought up the work around improvements for multi-dwelling recycling and composting services.

1358
02:15:38.182 --> 02:15:53.789
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Would that change the, the way that we regulate multi-dwelling units and align pickup days with residential units, or would the multi-dwelling, the commercial side, retain separate pickups?

1359
02:15:54.384 --> 02:15:57.076
<v Eric Engstrom>That's all on the table as options to discuss.

1360
02:15:57.588 --> 02:16:02.106
<v Eric Engstrom>But yeah, one of the options would be to align with the residential system.

1361
02:16:02.555 --> 02:16:02.811
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1362
02:16:03.115 --> 02:16:15.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As we have more multi-dwelling units in residential neighborhoods with small streets, I occasionally hear from constituents about the impacts there.

1363
02:16:16.189 --> 02:16:24.953
<v Eric Engstrom>And that's one of the logics of doing this project is over the years we're becoming a more multi-dwelling city as our land use processes play out.

1364
02:16:25.001 --> 02:16:29.569
<v Eric Engstrom>And so So that's— we're shifting more of our waste stream and more customers into that commercial system.

1365
02:16:30.595 --> 02:16:32.263
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So let's talk about land use and planning.

1366
02:16:32.775 --> 02:16:33.930
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for that transition.

1367
02:16:35.004 --> 02:16:42.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You're cutting 2 staff from the area district planning team and moving 2 others to specific projects.

1368
02:16:43.100 --> 02:16:46.691
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That planning work is part of what has made our city the way that it is.

1369
02:16:46.898 --> 02:16:49.208
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How many staff are retained on that team?

1370
02:16:51.612 --> 02:16:55.354
<v Eric Engstrom>I may have to get back to you with the precise number, but it's few.

1371
02:16:55.547 --> 02:16:58.100
<v Eric Engstrom>It's around 7 or 8 total.

1372
02:16:58.533 --> 02:17:00.379
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we're cutting about a third of the team?

1373
02:17:01.183 --> 02:17:01.969
<v Eric Engstrom>A quarter maybe.

1374
02:17:02.274 --> 02:17:03.237
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, something like that.

1375
02:17:04.057 --> 02:17:04.298
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1376
02:17:05.084 --> 02:17:15.970
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And you said that other than the Inner Eastside for All work, there is not a lot else that that team will be able to take on over the next 6 months to year with that type of reduction.

1377
02:17:18.488 --> 02:17:20.477
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What, what are we losing?

1378
02:17:21.310 --> 02:17:23.396
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What are we losing in this decision package?

1379
02:17:23.861 --> 02:17:28.335
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, we're losing flexibility to take on new projects.

1380
02:17:28.432 --> 02:17:35.070
<v Eric Engstrom>I think— I feel pretty confident that we can manage the InterEast project and finish the projects we have underway.

1381
02:17:35.905 --> 02:17:47.460
<v Eric Engstrom>As you mentioned, some of our— as we've lost general fund in previous years, we've had to cover staff with grants, and so that that tends to lock them into a project because the grant is what it is and we have to pay them with it.

1382
02:17:47.541 --> 02:17:54.891
<v Eric Engstrom>And so it takes them off the board in terms of staff I might assign to a project that council might come up with next year.

1383
02:17:58.565 --> 02:18:08.022
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As we think about loss of production, and I— this is a cuts budget, but I want to make sure that we know what we're getting.

1384
02:18:10.522 --> 02:18:10.861
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1385
02:18:10.992 --> 02:18:25.843
<v Eric Engstrom>To give you a concrete example of that, as the designs of the latest iteration of the Interstate Bridge come towards a conclusion, it's been in our mind that we're gonna have to do an update to the Jensen Beach plan.

1386
02:18:27.531 --> 02:18:29.771
<v Eric Engstrom>That would be the kind of work that this team would do.

1387
02:18:29.966 --> 02:18:33.001
<v Eric Engstrom>And right now, I don't have a way to start in on a project like that.

1388
02:18:34.825 --> 02:18:35.756
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's a great example.

1389
02:18:35.805 --> 02:18:42.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So as we think about that project, um, when would that be able to come online?

1390
02:18:42.516 --> 02:18:43.753
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How long will that take?

1391
02:18:43.800 --> 02:18:51.251
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are we getting ourselves— I guess what I'm trying to understand is, is 7 or 8 staff the place where we can really only do one thing at a time?

1392
02:18:51.363 --> 02:19:09.568
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if we have to do the Jantzen Beach project, something that my colleagues in D1 would love to do, but that we're not being forced to do by outside pressures has to wait, or will we still be able to do 2 or 3 things at a time, but maybe not 5 or 6 things at a time?

1393
02:19:10.113 --> 02:19:11.716
<v Eric Engstrom>It's correct.

1394
02:19:11.780 --> 02:19:22.549
<v Eric Engstrom>It's— you're gonna— the wait time for us to start a new project that council might want us to do, it will be longer and we'll be able to manage fewer of them at once.

1395
02:19:22.629 --> 02:19:29.344
<v Eric Engstrom>And the Inner East example is a pretty significant amount of work, and I know council wants us to move fast, so we're gonna put a lot of resources into it.

1396
02:19:30.486 --> 02:19:32.912
<v Eric Engstrom>That means we probably can't do other things at the same time.

1397
02:19:33.040 --> 02:19:34.084
<v Eric Engstrom>Okay.

1398
02:19:34.197 --> 02:19:40.222
<v Eric Engstrom>With a previous team, with a larger team of 8 or 9 people, we can manage multiple streams of work.

1399
02:19:40.351 --> 02:19:52.771
<v Eric Engstrom>But with the team we're in now where we have— again, I have to get back to you on the exact number, but let's say we have 6 and 2 of those are funded by grants that have to work only on those grants.

1400
02:19:53.621 --> 02:19:55.759
<v Eric Engstrom>That leaves me with not very many people to do that work.

1401
02:19:56.898 --> 02:20:09.375
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I've had conversations about other parts of the budget where I've asked folks, you know, what are the things that we can cut and we probably— it'll change what we do, we don't like it, but we can move forward?

1402
02:20:09.504 --> 02:20:13.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What are the things that we absolutely cannot cut without major impacts?

1403
02:20:13.533 --> 02:20:19.667
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what are the things that we can cut and be okay muddling through for a year or two, but in the long run we might need to add them back?

1404
02:20:19.796 --> 02:20:25.215
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This sounds from what you're saying like in that latter category, which is actually the middle category.

1405
02:20:25.984 --> 02:20:28.036
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that an accurate assessment?

1406
02:20:28.531 --> 02:20:42.552
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, that's one of the reasons we made the decision to make cuts here is in other teams we have regulatory requirements coming at us from above, like the code team with regulatory improvement.

1407
02:20:42.953 --> 02:20:44.717
<v Eric Engstrom>That's clearly also a council priority.

1408
02:20:44.797 --> 02:20:45.629
<v Eric Engstrom>We did not cut there.

1409
02:20:46.542 --> 02:20:53.552
<v Eric Engstrom>Our environmental team is already tiny and has mandates related to floodplain and endangered species and things.

1410
02:20:55.989 --> 02:21:01.912
<v Eric Engstrom>So yeah, we're looking at trying to maintain core capacity to do regulatorily required work.

1411
02:21:03.126 --> 02:21:09.736
<v Eric Engstrom>And the area planning is important, good work, but there aren't necessarily external drivers forcing us to do it.

1412
02:21:10.540 --> 02:21:17.255
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, there have been times in the past though where we've had external directives like the director mentioned IBR.

1413
02:21:17.819 --> 02:21:23.429
<v Donnie Oliveira>If several of those come at once, we will ultimately have to come back to council when that time is appropriate to ask for resources.

1414
02:21:23.912 --> 02:21:24.829
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that has happened in the past.

1415
02:21:24.878 --> 02:21:27.777
<v Donnie Oliveira>That's not unique to a budget cut scenario.

1416
02:21:27.922 --> 02:21:35.287
<v Donnie Oliveira>It's just if the program load becomes overwhelming and we have must-haves to do, we'll look to, look to the council for resources to deliver.

1417
02:21:35.432 --> 02:21:48.753
<v Eric Engstrom>That's a good, a good example is large transportation infrastructure projects tend to need a land use partner in the work, and that tends to come from our area planning team because those projects are geographically based.

1418
02:21:49.138 --> 02:21:53.438
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I consider myself now on notice that we'll need to add something here at some point in the next couple of years.

1419
02:21:54.513 --> 02:21:55.362
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1420
02:21:55.411 --> 02:21:56.550
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that's probably my time.

1421
02:21:56.614 --> 02:21:57.031
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that right?

1422
02:21:57.144 --> 02:21:57.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is.

1423
02:21:57.641 --> 02:21:57.881
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1424
02:21:57.945 --> 02:21:58.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you much, Councilor.

1425
02:21:59.647 --> 02:22:00.289
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1426
02:22:00.674 --> 02:22:03.657
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1427
02:22:04.620 --> 02:22:08.246
<v Sameer Kanal>First, just 2 questions related to that last line of questioning on Jantzen Beach Plan.

1428
02:22:08.536 --> 02:22:11.777
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously want to make sure all 3 of us are consulted on that.

1429
02:22:12.066 --> 02:22:18.307
<v Sameer Kanal>People in Hayden Island are very interested in the future of their neighborhood, and I want to make sure that we're able to represent that.

1430
02:22:18.980 --> 02:22:20.537
<v Sameer Kanal>Where is the full list of every plan?

1431
02:22:21.243 --> 02:22:23.040
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there a single place that's extant?

1432
02:22:23.632 --> 02:22:27.290
<v Sameer Kanal>Because every now and then we'll find a— be referencing a plan I've never heard of.

1433
02:22:27.404 --> 02:22:28.013
<v Eric Engstrom>There is.

1434
02:22:28.190 --> 02:22:36.260
<v Eric Engstrom>There's a planning library on our website that gives you all the different area plans, and there's a map you can click to see where they are.

1435
02:22:37.093 --> 02:22:41.328
<v Eric Engstrom>And then all of our current planning projects are also in the planning portion of our website.

1436
02:22:43.260 --> 02:22:44.323
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, great.

1437
02:22:44.484 --> 02:22:47.997
<v Sameer Kanal>I will follow up and make sure that that is known to constituents as well.

1438
02:22:49.238 --> 02:22:51.478
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak a little bit more to Smart City cuts specifically?

1439
02:22:53.868 --> 02:22:59.257
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to make sure that there's no impact to the surveillance and privacy work that's being done there.

1440
02:23:00.278 --> 02:23:03.065
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that something that will be affected by this reduction?

1441
02:23:03.534 --> 02:23:03.843
<v Eric Engstrom>No.

1442
02:23:04.493 --> 02:23:11.566
<v Eric Engstrom>What you see is the Smart City program offer is actually a combination of the Smart City team and our digital inclusion program.

1443
02:23:11.614 --> 02:23:22.531
<v Eric Engstrom>When, when we absorbed the Office of Community Technology a number of years ago, we merged those 2 teams together, and the cut we're taking is more on the digital inclusion side with that grant program.

1444
02:23:22.886 --> 02:23:34.054
<v Eric Engstrom>The, the Smart Cities program, um, a lot of that funding is being transferred with the realignment to the Data and Privacy Office with that decision package.

1445
02:23:34.974 --> 02:23:35.538
<v Sameer Kanal>Great, thanks.

1446
02:23:36.897 --> 02:23:47.841
<v Sameer Kanal>On waste and recycling, I know there's been some interest in the idea of doing commercial franchising, which among other things is more climate-friendly when you make areas served by a single company more compact.

1447
02:23:48.951 --> 02:23:54.888
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to understand if there's anything, any new updates, anything that you can share on that conversation.

1448
02:23:57.059 --> 02:24:08.551
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, we are jumping into that project and there is work going on right now with stakeholders to identify and solidify the objectives of that system review.

1449
02:24:08.681 --> 02:24:16.745
<v Eric Engstrom>And so our intent is to come back to a council committee in the fall and give you an opportunity to look at what we're mapping out as the project objectives.

1450
02:24:18.429 --> 02:24:18.615
<v Loretta Smith>Great.

1451
02:24:21.248 --> 02:24:31.844
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to reiterate my interest and commitment to continuing our work to allow renters to directly ask for a different size garbage bin that that fits their needs and a different cadence as needed as well.

1452
02:24:32.840 --> 02:24:37.448
<v Sameer Kanal>This is something that is a really, really small thing that doesn't affect a ton of people.

1453
02:24:37.576 --> 02:24:47.980
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, single-family renters are still a significant population, but has a significant impact on their lives and seems that it should have been done before.

1454
02:24:48.029 --> 02:24:49.007
<v Sameer Kanal>But I'm glad we're working on it.

1455
02:24:49.072 --> 02:24:50.372
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to get that on the record.

1456
02:24:50.903 --> 02:24:57.711
<v Sameer Kanal>I also want to continue to express concern about launching a financial assistance program for qualified homeowners without simultaneously supporting renters.

1457
02:24:58.306 --> 02:25:04.618
<v Sameer Kanal>I know better late than never, but I, I think we should always be starting with the people who need the help most, and that is renters.

1458
02:25:04.730 --> 02:25:07.846
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, I'm not really sure why that, that went that way.

1459
02:25:08.103 --> 02:25:09.100
<v Sameer Kanal>What is the timeline on that?

1460
02:25:10.031 --> 02:25:20.343
<v Eric Engstrom>We're working on that right now, and, um, we, based on some discussions we've had with a number of you, we know that there's, there's a few of you interested in that topic, and so we're trying to accelerate that right now.

1461
02:25:20.791 --> 02:25:26.529
<v Sameer Kanal>And will that apply to multifamily renters or single-family renters or both?

1462
02:25:27.025 --> 02:25:29.477
<v Eric Engstrom>Don't know yet, but that's part of what we're looking at right now.

1463
02:25:29.750 --> 02:25:35.470
<v Eric Engstrom>And, um, I— my hope is we can bring you back something within this next fiscal year.

1464
02:25:36.272 --> 02:25:36.576
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1465
02:25:37.378 --> 02:25:57.981
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, and I just want to close by saying I, I agree with everything Councilor Clark talked about with relation to collaborating with PBOT, BES, uh, water, obviously thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1466
02:25:58.047 --> 02:25:58.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1467
02:25:59.341 --> 02:26:00.487
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

1468
02:26:00.750 --> 02:26:01.634
<v Dan Ryan>Good to see you, Eric.

1469
02:26:03.255 --> 02:26:12.066
<v Dan Ryan>At a time when less money is coming into government from our bread and butter revenue streams due to our low-performing economy, people are asking for reforms from government right now.

1470
02:26:12.545 --> 02:26:18.817
<v Dan Ryan>They're really asking for us to really lean in and look where there could be a new way of thinking in terms of delivering customer service.

1471
02:26:20.127 --> 02:26:24.925
<v Dan Ryan>On that note, would you say that your bureau specifically works closely with Metro?

1472
02:26:26.606 --> 02:26:33.227
<v Eric Engstrom>Yes, we work with Metro closely on both the land use side and the waste side.

1473
02:26:33.290 --> 02:26:39.314
<v Eric Engstrom>They also have a role in the disposal of waste, and then we work with them a little bit increasingly.

1474
02:26:39.379 --> 02:26:42.936
<v Dan Ryan>They're getting into the climate what'd you say at the end?

1475
02:26:43.257 --> 02:26:46.384
<v Eric Engstrom>On climate, they have some climate planning happening as well.

1476
02:26:46.849 --> 02:26:53.727
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that's what people are telling me, that they see that coordination, and they also see sometimes duplication.

1477
02:26:54.225 --> 02:27:05.513
<v Dan Ryan>Have you— are you having conversations with people at Metro where in fact there's some overlap and there could be some new ways of thinking about the service delivery, just like the city has to constantly do with the county?

1478
02:27:06.025 --> 02:27:08.495
<v Dan Ryan>And of course, we can improve upon it for public safety and for housing.

1479
02:27:09.338 --> 02:27:22.368
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, I think in both the land use sphere and the waste side, Metro's role is at that policy larger scale, and we are more the direct implementers.

1480
02:27:25.319 --> 02:27:26.694
<v Dan Ryan>The bureaus are the direct implementers?

1481
02:27:26.953 --> 02:27:30.997
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, we— the bureaus in the city are the direct implementers, both in waste and land use.

1482
02:27:31.823 --> 02:27:51.230
<v Eric Engstrom>The spaces where there is often an interaction where we have to work out whose lane we're in There is always an active conversation on the waste side about Metro's role with disposal and whether they own and operate facilities or whether they have private companies doing that.

1483
02:27:51.295 --> 02:27:56.386
<v Eric Engstrom>That's an active conversation that the city has opinions about from a waste perspective.

1484
02:27:57.641 --> 02:28:06.920
<v Eric Engstrom>On the land use side, sometimes both Metro and the city are involved in pushing forward strategic projects like Metro Park.

1485
02:28:06.968 --> 02:28:07.033
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah.

1486
02:28:07.311 --> 02:28:11.352
<v Eric Engstrom>Metro, for example, gave grants to Albina Vision Trust, and we're also in that space.

1487
02:28:11.561 --> 02:28:23.108
<v Eric Engstrom>And so working out who's doing what between Prosper and us and Metro can sometimes— when Metro dives into a very highly local project, that can be a little bit—.

1488
02:28:23.590 --> 02:28:24.727
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate your honesty.

1489
02:28:24.775 --> 02:28:32.986
<v Dan Ryan>I think that a lot of people are seeing that, and I think now is a really good time to keep having those meetings with your partners at Metro to find who's on first where.

1490
02:28:33.436 --> 02:28:38.287
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, overall I would— I want to say Metro is a good partner, but there are points there that we're—.

1491
02:28:38.287 --> 02:28:39.523
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, everyone's a good person.

1492
02:28:39.781 --> 02:28:50.397
<v Dan Ryan>Everyone just needs to see that there's efficiency that we're trying to get out of it, because people tell me they feel like they get one answer there and one answer here, and it gets confusing, I think, when it comes to land use.

1493
02:28:50.573 --> 02:28:52.870
<v Dan Ryan>So, um, that's all on land use.

1494
02:28:53.030 --> 02:28:59.808
<v Dan Ryan>I think that maybe the theme I'm getting when it comes to East Columbia and Hayden Island, uh, our north thank you.

1495
02:28:59.985 --> 02:29:00.096
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1496
02:29:00.177 --> 02:29:12.582
<v Dan Ryan>One of the things that I think is really important with waterfront that we neglect quite a bit at this city is that there's a frustration that decisions seem to be made by sitting at home looking at graphs and charts and such and not enough walking the land.

1497
02:29:12.790 --> 02:29:17.708
<v Dan Ryan>Like, they tell me, I've never met anyone from BPS, but here's the new code that they want to deliver.

1498
02:29:18.672 --> 02:29:30.266
<v Dan Ryan>And then when I hear about cuts, are you cutting those type of positions, or do the job descriptions those positions positions, not ask them to actually go out and walk the land and connect with those that are impacted?

1499
02:29:31.997 --> 02:29:38.927
<v Eric Engstrom>No, I mean, unfortunately, the area planning team is the team that's most likely to be out walking.

1500
02:29:39.441 --> 02:29:51.287
<v Eric Engstrom>The environmental team, which I think is the one involved in the East Columbia planning, does of course spend a lot of time in the field too, because you can't do— you can't understand environmental resources without walking the land, literally.

1501
02:29:51.774 --> 02:29:55.673
<v Eric Engstrom>They're out in the field quite a bit, but the area planning team is also out in the field a lot.

1502
02:29:56.968 --> 02:29:57.049
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1503
02:29:57.179 --> 02:30:04.190
<v Dan Ryan>And I think some people perhaps don't realize that they have been walking because they perhaps haven't been having dialogue with those folks.

1504
02:30:05.760 --> 02:30:11.238
<v Dan Ryan>Code clutter, as you know, has been a big topic of mine for some time because you can't do permitting reforms without it.

1505
02:30:11.334 --> 02:30:21.635
<v Dan Ryan>And after the lack of someone picking up the phone and doing customer service with frustrated folks trying to work with us on permitting, that that's a good point.

1506
02:30:21.796 --> 02:30:23.639
<v Dan Ryan>The second one was about code clutter.

1507
02:30:23.784 --> 02:30:34.388
<v Dan Ryan>They would say they would get advice about a code from 1992, and then they find out another person that it's handed off to wants them to deal with a code that was passed in 2012.

1508
02:30:34.756 --> 02:30:38.415
<v Dan Ryan>And then the third person talks to them about a code passed in 2022.

1509
02:30:39.826 --> 02:30:40.549
<v Dan Ryan>That's not right.

1510
02:30:40.709 --> 02:30:45.424
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm starting to get impatient with this project that I know started quite a bit ago.

1511
02:30:46.003 --> 02:30:56.880
<v Dan Ryan>Quite a while ago about how BPS is helping out the permitting bureau to actually get into there and really scrub some of those codes that are no longer relevant, but they're still on record.

1512
02:30:57.234 --> 02:31:00.891
<v Dan Ryan>And so it confuses and slows down time for those trying to do permitting.

1513
02:31:01.887 --> 02:31:02.977
<v Dan Ryan>Any response to this?

1514
02:31:03.731 --> 02:31:12.091
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, and as you know, Councilor, I've been involved in the space of code improvement for many years and have a lot of ideas about that.

1515
02:31:12.299 --> 02:31:18.459
<v Eric Engstrom>I'm very excited to be working with Eric Kooch to to ramp up our efforts around regulatory improvement.

1516
02:31:18.670 --> 02:31:24.230
<v Eric Engstrom>And that means staffing CAP adequately and moving those things forward.

1517
02:31:24.360 --> 02:31:31.139
<v Eric Engstrom>It means continuing to work at the— with the DCA to understand what the overall city priorities are for regulatory improvement and streamlining.

1518
02:31:31.959 --> 02:31:36.843
<v Eric Engstrom>As I said in my remarks earlier, we're going to be taking on a number of projects.

1519
02:31:36.907 --> 02:31:45.233
<v Eric Engstrom>We are bringing the latest iteration of RECAP to Council next month, and we will continue to do that kind of work as well.

1520
02:31:45.297 --> 02:31:55.622
<v Eric Engstrom>So I'm looking forward to bringing you a more holistic view with Eric and Donnie on what our next few years of regulatory improvement, what our roadmap is.

1521
02:31:56.057 --> 02:31:59.059
<v Dan Ryan>As we're working on that legislation, I'll have definitely a lens there.

1522
02:31:59.108 --> 02:32:07.940
<v Dan Ryan>I want to end with saying that it makes me sad what's happened to Hayden Island and the North Shore of our city in general, the North Waterfront.

1523
02:32:08.502 --> 02:32:13.862
<v Dan Ryan>I lived in the mobile home court in high school out on Hayden Island, so I know it well with my mom.

1524
02:32:14.022 --> 02:32:20.073
<v Dan Ryan>And the neglect that has taken place over time is really sad.

1525
02:32:20.121 --> 02:32:21.356
<v Dan Ryan>It looked much better in the late '70s.

1526
02:32:22.368 --> 02:32:25.417
<v Dan Ryan>And then you contrast that just for our economic development.

1527
02:32:25.513 --> 02:32:45.789
<v Dan Ryan>When you come across the current interstate bridge, you see such a contrast from Vancouver and the way the state of Washington and their WDOT or whatever they call it, the Washington Bureau of Transportation takes care of their roads in the way— welcome to Oregon, the land of like abandoned hotels and weeds.

1528
02:32:46.688 --> 02:32:47.780
<v Dan Ryan>It's just not okay.

1529
02:32:48.212 --> 02:32:54.747
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'm hoping that we as a city, maybe the 3 of us will do a garden party with residents out at Hayden Island to help with that.

1530
02:32:54.844 --> 02:33:11.280
<v Dan Ryan>But my point is, I hope that this city in its planning stops neglecting thank you.

1531
02:33:11.280 --> 02:33:12.879
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1532
02:33:12.879 --> 02:33:13.770
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

1533
02:33:13.959 --> 02:33:14.879
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks.

1534
02:33:14.879 --> 02:33:19.219
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to first start by wishing everyone a happy Older Americans Month.

1535
02:33:19.219 --> 02:33:21.620
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We'll be honoring this more next week.

1536
02:33:21.620 --> 02:33:39.844
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But with that in mind, Director Angstrom, can you speak to how this— the proposed budget cuts to BPS could impact our capacity to prioritize and support age-friendly initiatives to advance work aligned with our ADEN project, Age and Disability Inclusive Neighborhood project.

1537
02:33:40.470 --> 02:33:44.903
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, I'm familiar with that effort.

1538
02:33:46.252 --> 02:33:55.227
<v Eric Engstrom>That document was produced, as you I'm sure know, with help from a one-time position we had in BPS for a number of years.

1539
02:33:57.040 --> 02:34:11.557
<v Eric Engstrom>The late Commissioner Fish had put in the budget some funding for us to pilot an age-friendly cities staff position, which we had from, I think, around 2019 or '18 and through 2021-ish or so.

1540
02:34:12.566 --> 02:34:16.027
<v Eric Engstrom>That position was the victim of a prior year budget cut.

1541
02:34:16.155 --> 02:34:23.029
<v Eric Engstrom>It was essentially a cut year, and we never had the opportunity to ask for a continuation of the one-time position, and so it ended.

1542
02:34:24.024 --> 02:34:28.343
<v Eric Engstrom>I was involved with helping to oversee that work when it was in the Bureau.

1543
02:34:29.564 --> 02:34:30.382
<v Eric Engstrom>It's important work.

1544
02:34:30.447 --> 02:34:33.015
<v Eric Engstrom>It's not currently funded within the Bureau.

1545
02:34:33.353 --> 02:34:41.782
<v Eric Engstrom>So that's— it does relate to a lot of the work we do in terms of land use and the built environment.

1546
02:34:41.847 --> 02:34:46.520
<v Eric Engstrom>So I appreciate the work, but I want to be clear, it's probably not within our current FTE.

1547
02:34:47.243 --> 02:34:49.200
<v Keith Wilson>And Councilor, I think I think one of the things—.

1548
02:34:49.200 --> 02:34:49.248
<v Michael Bonaccor>Yes.

1549
02:34:49.297 --> 02:35:01.272
<v Donnie Oliveira>Because I was at BPS when that report was completed as well, one of the things, the key lesson was some of the key priorities out of the research that was done led us to think that it was broader than just a planning land use lens to approach the work.

1550
02:35:01.352 --> 02:35:08.597
<v Donnie Oliveira>So where else in the city could we activate resources and partnership to further advance sort of age-friendly policies?

1551
02:35:09.174 --> 02:35:17.354
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so I think if we were going to evaluate next steps for that, it would probably work with the city administrator and my colleagues to See what kind of team can we put together to really advance that work?

1552
02:35:17.435 --> 02:35:23.762
<v Donnie Oliveira>'Cause land use is an important tool, but it's probably not the only one that we want to do to address— use to address age-friendly policies.

1553
02:35:24.050 --> 02:35:29.381
<v Eric Engstrom>I also wanted to just say we are working on some of the action items in that plan that continue to happen.

1554
02:35:29.879 --> 02:35:32.078
<v Eric Engstrom>So we didn't put it on a shelf.

1555
02:35:32.144 --> 02:35:39.978
<v Eric Engstrom>There are a few things that have moved forward since that report was written, but it's kind of slow incremental work rather than a dedicated position.

1556
02:35:42.719 --> 02:35:48.152
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And when you're saying there's not capacity to really dig into this, that's at where we're at currently?

1557
02:35:48.487 --> 02:35:50.122
<v Eric Engstrom>That's before the cuts, yeah.

1558
02:35:50.346 --> 02:35:55.058
<v Eric Engstrom>The cuts don't really directly affect our capacity to do this work, but doesn't help.

1559
02:35:56.516 --> 02:36:01.164
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then what would the capacity need to be to be able to focus on this more?

1560
02:36:01.869 --> 02:36:14.465
<v Eric Engstrom>At the time, we had one FTE devoted to age-friendly cities work, and that That was at the time, it was thought of as a pilot project and we just never got to move beyond the pilot stage because of funding.

1561
02:36:15.060 --> 02:36:15.478
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1562
02:36:15.784 --> 02:36:18.103
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1563
02:36:18.281 --> 02:36:18.844
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1564
02:36:19.729 --> 02:36:21.275
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1565
02:36:21.356 --> 02:36:29.027
<v Steve Novick>I forgot that I actually had a serious question, which is about the cutting the funding for the climate team and particularly the home energy score program.

1566
02:36:29.782 --> 02:36:36.558
<v Steve Novick>And I would actually just ask you to like Remind people what the Home Energy Score program is and what would be the effects of that cut?

1567
02:36:37.760 --> 02:36:48.809
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, the Home Energy Score is a code requirement that when you sell a home, you have to get an energy score, essentially kind of like what you'd see on a washer and dryer if you bought a new washer and dryer.

1568
02:36:49.280 --> 02:36:54.825
<v Eric Engstrom>I went through that actually myself last year when I sold a home and sadly got a poor rating.

1569
02:36:55.280 --> 02:36:56.128
<v Eric Engstrom>It was an older house.

1570
02:36:56.209 --> 02:37:08.808
<v Eric Engstrom>But essentially, the realtor has to hire someone who writes a A report that's a few pages about the— they go out and do a test of the home and look for energy leaks, and they look at your windows and things.

1571
02:37:08.888 --> 02:37:11.359
<v Eric Engstrom>And it's a— so it's a code requirement.

1572
02:37:11.406 --> 02:37:12.879
<v Eric Engstrom>It's implemented by the private sector.

1573
02:37:12.929 --> 02:37:19.532
<v Eric Engstrom>But the funds that were cut are to a consultant contract that was providing technical assistance to the realtors.

1574
02:37:19.647 --> 02:37:24.779
<v Eric Engstrom>So it was like a helpline that you could call to get help with the technical work to comply.

1575
02:37:25.647 --> 02:37:27.635
<v Eric Engstrom>So the code continues to apply.

1576
02:37:27.764 --> 02:37:29.381
<v Eric Engstrom>We didn't— we're not proposing to—.

1577
02:37:29.381 --> 02:37:29.527
<v Eric Engstrom>Okay.

1578
02:37:30.903 --> 02:37:36.442
<v Eric Engstrom>Delete the code from the city code, but there would be fewer resources for technical assistance with this cut.

1579
02:37:36.988 --> 02:37:39.671
<v Steve Novick>And how well utilized was this technical assistance?

1580
02:37:39.718 --> 02:37:42.433
<v Steve Novick>Did a lot of realtors call up to ask questions?

1581
02:37:43.172 --> 02:37:44.969
<v Eric Engstrom>I will have to get back to you on the volumes.

1582
02:37:45.019 --> 02:37:45.548
<v Eric Engstrom>I'm not sure.

1583
02:37:46.559 --> 02:37:53.433
<v Steve Novick>Because, I mean, this is of concern to me if we have reason to think that it would undermine the program not to have this technical assistance available.

1584
02:37:54.092 --> 02:38:01.299
<v Steve Novick>And I think that actually, I think Vivian Satterfield just sang to me recently that she thinks the Home Energy Score program has been really effective.

1585
02:38:02.817 --> 02:38:06.629
<v Steve Novick>I'd like to see if it really is going to have impact.

1586
02:38:06.677 --> 02:38:07.986
<v Steve Novick>I'd like to see this cut avoided.

1587
02:38:08.602 --> 02:38:19.176
<v Steve Novick>And actually, this is another example of where I think PSEF funding would be appropriate and it'd be reasonable to look for PSEF to make up a rather small amount of money.

1588
02:38:20.909 --> 02:38:21.173
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1589
02:38:21.421 --> 02:38:22.179
<v Eric Engstrom>I can look into it.

1590
02:38:22.837 --> 02:38:23.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1591
02:38:24.066 --> 02:38:25.254
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1592
02:38:26.235 --> 02:38:26.972
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you.

1593
02:38:27.198 --> 02:38:34.085
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, I didn't ask this one question, and it's something that since we've moved to this form of government, we have more time to listen to neighbors.

1594
02:38:34.343 --> 02:38:46.016
<v Dan Ryan>And one consistent theme is they start off by saying, I'm all in for density and housing, and my street's only this big, like it's narrow.

1595
02:38:46.963 --> 02:38:57.658
<v Dan Ryan>And when you put these complexes in with no parking and you have parking on both sides in the road, a little car can barely get through, let alone kids on bikes and roller skating.

1596
02:38:58.257 --> 02:39:02.426
<v Dan Ryan>And then if there is a fire, how are they— how's the emergency trucks going to get in?

1597
02:39:03.120 --> 02:39:06.503
<v Dan Ryan>So I just keep hearing about this over and over again.

1598
02:39:06.567 --> 02:39:13.396
<v Dan Ryan>And these again are people that are not your typical, I don't want— like they'll say, can there just be 4 units instead of 8?

1599
02:39:13.509 --> 02:39:17.727
<v Dan Ryan>Like, can we maybe consider one lane, one side of the street for parking?

1600
02:39:17.825 --> 02:39:17.905
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

1601
02:39:18.679 --> 02:39:22.700
<v Dan Ryan>So it makes me think, are you working with PBOT when you're doing the planning?

1602
02:39:22.764 --> 02:39:32.406
<v Dan Ryan>When we're doing code work, are we getting outside of the building but actually looking at the right-of-way and knowing that in Portland you can go one block over and it's a completely different street size?

1603
02:39:32.907 --> 02:39:35.640
<v Dan Ryan>And everyone knows that in both and throughout the city.

1604
02:39:36.254 --> 02:39:57.379
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm just starting to wonder if we're looking at it big picture, which is why I put an amendment in recently for the Inner East Side to make sure that we're yeah, PBOT is an important partner in most of our area plans, and the Inner East is an example of that where they're going to be a critical partner.

1605
02:39:59.063 --> 02:40:19.433
<v Eric Engstrom>At the stage we're at right now, we're still talking about conceptual zoning bubbles and general direction, but when we actually produce a zoning map, we do start thinking of it on a street-by-street basis, and it's not uncommon That we will get testimony about things like dead ends without turnarounds or narrow, particularly narrow streets in some cases.

1606
02:40:19.546 --> 02:40:29.272
<v Eric Engstrom>And that's the kind of situation where we do fine-tune the zoning map and consult with fire and PBOT and others around some of those potential constraints.

1607
02:40:29.579 --> 02:40:45.538
<v Eric Engstrom>I recall during years ago when we rewrote the comp plan and remapped another part of town, there being examples where we exempted certain— call this— or certain streets from the increased density because of the lack of a turnaround or things like that.

1608
02:40:45.602 --> 02:40:49.034
<v Eric Engstrom>So we, we do work in that way and, and try to fine-tune the proposal.

1609
02:40:49.114 --> 02:40:50.334
<v Dan Ryan>Always respect authority.

1610
02:40:50.511 --> 02:40:56.766
<v Dan Ryan>So who on your team— and if it's you, that's fine— can we guide constituents that have those concerns when a project's going in?

1611
02:40:57.376 --> 02:41:02.781
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, I mean, with any given project, we'll have a contact point, and that's the appropriate person to talk to about it.

1612
02:41:02.989 --> 02:41:04.096
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, thank you.

1613
02:41:04.337 --> 02:41:05.139
<v Dan Ryan>It just keeps popping up.

1614
02:41:05.396 --> 02:41:07.352
<v Eric Engstrom>In the case of Inner East, it's Bill Cunningham.

1615
02:41:07.450 --> 02:41:10.742
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, all right, thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1616
02:41:11.094 --> 02:41:11.657
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1617
02:41:12.122 --> 02:41:16.171
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to use my last minute here to build off of 2 things Councilor Ryan said.

1618
02:41:16.235 --> 02:41:26.322
<v Sameer Kanal>One, uh, with relation to Hayden Island and East Columbia, I do think that the capacity being, uh, retained for actually walking around makes sense.

1619
02:41:26.370 --> 02:41:34.302
<v Sameer Kanal>I was doing some tours out there with relation to the proposed E-Zone, um, changes out there, and it— there's nothing like seeing thank you.

1620
02:41:34.384 --> 02:41:37.158
<v Sameer Kanal>And so getting out there in person is, I think, really helpful.

1621
02:41:38.378 --> 02:41:48.948
<v Sameer Kanal>As for the other piece around density, I think I would love to hear when we get into that conversation, not now, how we're not only connecting with PBOT but also the conversation around transit broadly.

1622
02:41:49.541 --> 02:41:58.861
<v Sameer Kanal>Because the density to parking issue does not get solved until we have the real conversation we have to have around transit as a city.

1623
02:41:58.925 --> 02:42:07.471
<v Sameer Kanal>And one of the challenges we're facing is, of course, that we don't direct Oh, the ones like a block from a bus.

1624
02:42:08.049 --> 02:42:20.700
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so that's another conversation as well, is to what degree can it not just be street by street, block by block, though obviously it is, but sort of the middle layer of what's the distance from the nearest MAX stop, right?

1625
02:42:20.878 --> 02:42:27.372
<v Sameer Kanal>And you see how that has played out in other cities based on major arterial roads from a driving perspective.

1626
02:42:27.422 --> 02:42:39.927
<v Sameer Kanal>But I think if we're able to do that and scale it to distance from a MAX stop, for example, that's going to have better impacts for us and allow for that density increases without seeing as much of a strain on parking.

1627
02:42:40.120 --> 02:42:40.858
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1628
02:42:40.922 --> 02:42:43.296
<v Donnie Oliveira>Councilor, we actually have 2 bites at the apple as a city, right?

1629
02:42:43.343 --> 02:42:59.358
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we have the area planning that BPS leads, but also we have the transportation system plan that comes out of PBOT, and they're actually in the process of looking holistically at our 2045 vision where they'll contemplate those very things like what is the appropriate distance for Density to transit access, like a bus stop.

1630
02:42:59.920 --> 02:43:02.024
<v Donnie Oliveira>All those sorts of ideas are contemplated in the TSP.

1631
02:43:02.104 --> 02:43:09.063
<v Donnie Oliveira>So they kind of set the citywide parameters for that, and then BPS will implement locally in an area plan.

1632
02:43:09.560 --> 02:43:22.158
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, and I would— it's hard because there's a lot of things that could go in the TSP, but I think the big one there, and thank you for bringing this up, DC Oliveira, because it relates to BPS too, we don't have the density for the number of road miles.

1633
02:43:22.352 --> 02:43:24.114
<v Sameer Kanal>We just don't.

1634
02:43:24.434 --> 02:43:24.755
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1635
02:43:24.852 --> 02:43:28.441
<v Sameer Kanal>Especially as material costs go up and weight goes up and the wear and tear goes up.

1636
02:43:28.763 --> 02:43:36.824
<v Sameer Kanal>We do not have density for the number of road miles we need to maintain, even after all the, the TUF and all that other good work that's been done to help stabilize PBOT's funding.

1637
02:43:36.936 --> 02:43:38.586
<v Sameer Kanal>It just is— it, it's out of sequence.

1638
02:43:38.924 --> 02:43:41.504
<v Sameer Kanal>So out of proportion, I should say.

1639
02:43:41.665 --> 02:44:02.058
<v Sameer Kanal>And so as we get the density increased over the course of the next, I guess we're looking at what, 19 years, that, that's going to be something where we are also assessing that relationship, um, and, uh, also looking at where we can depave, um, or do something maybe a little less drastic than that, like car-free streets.

1640
02:44:02.220 --> 02:44:02.465
<v Steve Novick>Thanks.

1641
02:44:02.951 --> 02:44:05.406
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

1642
02:44:06.692 --> 02:44:08.246
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kamelane, is that a legacy hand?

1643
02:44:08.393 --> 02:44:08.717
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

1644
02:44:09.591 --> 02:44:16.004
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have a question that is not strictly budget related, but, uh, Eric, maybe you can help me out with this.

1645
02:44:16.085 --> 02:44:26.988
<v Jamie Dunphy>When, when your teams are going through, like, thinking about the, the area planning team As they are creating their plans, is there a cost as a consideration for the final regulations?

1646
02:44:27.556 --> 02:44:33.977
<v Jamie Dunphy>Meaning, like, I was sort of riffing off what Councilor Ryan was saying, like thinking about site-specific problems or unique challenges.

1647
02:44:34.024 --> 02:44:40.602
<v Jamie Dunphy>But do we also have like, here's the bells and whistles version of it, here is a bare bones like kind of area plan?

1648
02:44:41.524 --> 02:44:43.969
<v Jamie Dunphy>How do we think about that?

1649
02:44:44.277 --> 02:44:44.373
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1650
02:44:45.286 --> 02:44:45.863
<v Michael Bonaccor>Yes.

1651
02:44:46.104 --> 02:44:57.154
<v Eric Engstrom>To give you an example, when we did the Southwest Town Center, as you probably all know, that's a challenging geography with a lot of unpaved streets and lack of stormwater systems.

1652
02:44:57.442 --> 02:44:58.486
<v Eric Engstrom>Sidewalks don't exist.

1653
02:44:59.434 --> 02:45:04.043
<v Eric Engstrom>It's a challenging place to put a town center, but it is a town center on the Metro plan.

1654
02:45:04.734 --> 02:45:13.672
<v Eric Engstrom>When we developed the plan for that town center, we had to think about several different options because the gold-plated town center was was gonna be very expensive.

1655
02:45:13.720 --> 02:45:21.897
<v Eric Engstrom>And we have to think about that in terms of the timescale and what kind of capital improvements might be possible within a 20-year period.

1656
02:45:23.869 --> 02:45:36.034
<v Eric Engstrom>And that's where the TSP and the land use plan are critically linked together because we need to make assumptions in the land use plan that are backable by a financially realistic TSP.

1657
02:45:36.115 --> 02:45:44.037
<v Eric Engstrom>And so in that case, we rezoned some land and then we left some land that we might want for higher density in the future, but we didn't immediately rezone it.

1658
02:45:44.085 --> 02:45:51.823
<v Eric Engstrom>We gave it a comprehensive planning designation, and that was a signal that we want to go there in the future, but we don't have the resources yet to build those streets.

1659
02:45:51.871 --> 02:45:53.734
<v Eric Engstrom>So, um, yes, that is important.

1660
02:45:54.825 --> 02:45:55.147
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1661
02:45:55.644 --> 02:46:00.459
<v Donnie Oliveira>And Council President, we'll also add on a project like something like significant like the residential infill project, right?

1662
02:46:01.085 --> 02:46:05.260
<v Donnie Oliveira>We're working with our partners to see like what we're designing, is it even buildable?

1663
02:46:05.677 --> 02:46:09.754
<v Donnie Oliveira>Can we actually, you know, like, so if you look at some of the— this is really wonky, but humor me for a second.

1664
02:46:09.819 --> 02:46:20.037
<v Donnie Oliveira>When we started looking at some of the FAR bonuses for affordable housing, we worked with our nonprofit developers to ensure that we were creating a product that they could actually get the pencil out, right?

1665
02:46:20.085 --> 02:46:26.058
<v Donnie Oliveira>So those are different kind of economics, but they are meaningful because what's the point of going through the process if we build a tool that won't get used?

1666
02:46:26.459 --> 02:46:28.620
<v Donnie Oliveira>So we'll also look at that level of granularity as well.

1667
02:46:29.154 --> 02:46:29.863
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1668
02:46:30.766 --> 02:46:31.218
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1669
02:46:33.090 --> 02:46:33.413
<v Donnie Oliveira>Thank you.

1670
02:46:33.574 --> 02:46:54.680
<v Mitch Green>I'm back in the queue to ask a— I guess it's not necessarily related to this specific budget, but it is about A lot of times, you know, you'll see a city say, hey, we're rolling out this new initiative to— we're going to waive this, we're going to do a temporary waiver on a certain set of permit and code requirements to try to accelerate housing production.

1671
02:46:55.610 --> 02:46:57.670
<v Mitch Green>You've heard some councilors talk about that.

1672
02:46:57.670 --> 02:46:59.180
<v Mitch Green>I've talked about that at times.

1673
02:47:00.030 --> 02:47:00.569
<v Mitch Green>Is it—.

1674
02:47:00.569 --> 02:47:01.489
<v Mitch Green>Is the—.

1675
02:47:01.489 --> 02:47:05.350
<v Mitch Green>What position does that type of code update work, that sort of strike team work?

1676
02:47:05.350 --> 02:47:05.489
<v Loretta Smith>Is it a permit and code department?

1677
02:47:05.489 --> 02:47:05.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's a permit and yeah, code department.

1678
02:47:07.398 --> 02:47:21.451
<v Eric Engstrom>That's been typically the BPS code development team, but we work closely with PP&D staff as well because they have the direct front counter experience that will understand how it will get implemented.

1679
02:47:21.900 --> 02:47:24.015
<v Mitch Green>That's exactly where I was going to go next.

1680
02:47:24.400 --> 02:47:31.500
<v Mitch Green>So really at your level, DCA Oliveira, it's like if we were to— it's probably not this budget, but if we were to contemplate right.

1681
02:47:31.995 --> 02:47:34.864
<v Mitch Green>Like a, um, I'll just give you an example.

1682
02:47:35.618 --> 02:47:58.308
<v Mitch Green>If we wanted to expand our book of pre-approved plans that are just off the shelf, self-certified, let's go, and we want to take it from just 4 ADU designs to like a whole menu of stuff, like I would imagine you'd need to get a term, like a 5-year LTE kind of position, set of position descriptions, and it would be sort of matrixed between BPS Yes, and PP&D.

1683
02:47:58.372 --> 02:48:00.022
<v Mitch Green>Is that the right way to think about that type of thing?

1684
02:48:00.376 --> 02:48:02.875
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, Councilor, and I just want to echo something Councilor Ryan had said.

1685
02:48:02.923 --> 02:48:13.915
<v Donnie Oliveira>When the permit improvement team that was started in the old form of government was successful in the new because we kept it at the service level area, mainly because so many different bureaus have to contribute, right?

1686
02:48:13.978 --> 02:48:25.114
<v Donnie Oliveira>And so even in your example that you framed, yes, it'd largely be led out of BPS and PP&D, but we might want— need to bring in Fire, we might want to bring in PBOT to ensure that from their line of sight we're hitting all the notes that they want to hit.

1687
02:48:26.077 --> 02:48:32.363
<v Donnie Oliveira>And then again, just to share this, if we're looking at broader, larger reform, absolutely we'd want to be at a higher level for 2 reasons.

1688
02:48:32.492 --> 02:48:39.291
<v Donnie Oliveira>One is when we tap staff that have ongoing work plans, we're taking them away from their core functions to do something new, which is important.

1689
02:48:39.805 --> 02:48:47.550
<v Donnie Oliveira>But by creating a new team that's distinct, we can really isolate them from a perspective of work creep to work across the city.

1690
02:48:47.599 --> 02:48:49.763
<v Donnie Oliveira>So I think you're touching on something.

1691
02:48:49.811 --> 02:48:54.319
<v Donnie Oliveira>Yeah, if we were going to do something significant like that, We would create it at a service area level.

1692
02:48:54.319 --> 02:48:55.579
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that.

1693
02:48:55.579 --> 02:48:58.899
<v Mitch Green>And that's something that I'm kind of signaling to maybe the next budget.

1694
02:48:58.899 --> 02:49:02.479
<v Mitch Green>That might be a budget note that we try to craft or something going forward.

1695
02:49:02.479 --> 02:49:03.940
<v Mitch Green>But I wanted to make sure I talked to you guys.

1696
02:49:04.200 --> 02:49:05.719
<v Mitch Green>You're in the trenches, so.

1697
02:49:05.719 --> 02:49:18.299
<v Donnie Oliveira>And Councilor, the model that's been working really well, and I've said it in many spaces, so broken record for those who've heard it, is the Vision Zero structure that's been led by a staffer out of the Public Works Service Area, but they coordinate across all the bureaus that are engaged.

1698
02:49:18.887 --> 02:49:25.486
<v Donnie Oliveira>And that seems to be a model that has engagement from the DCA level, directors, and of course the staff that are doing the work.

1699
02:49:26.369 --> 02:49:26.787
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1700
02:49:27.814 --> 02:49:28.504
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1701
02:49:29.002 --> 02:49:29.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1702
02:49:29.661 --> 02:49:31.395
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I just want to get this question in.

1703
02:49:31.747 --> 02:49:38.090
<v Dan Ryan>I, first of all, colleagues, I think it's fine when we don't just talk about line items, but that we look at the function of the bureau.

1704
02:49:38.492 --> 02:49:40.708
<v Dan Ryan>What are our priorities in '26-'27?

1705
02:49:40.980 --> 02:49:44.014
<v Dan Ryan>If you know what that is, then we adjust FTEs accordingly.

1706
02:49:44.639 --> 02:49:48.316
<v Dan Ryan>And so with that question, I'm always curious going 10 years back.

1707
02:49:48.707 --> 02:49:56.439
<v Dan Ryan>So in '26-'27, we're projecting 139.5 FTs according to one of your charts, right?

1708
02:49:58.593 --> 02:49:59.347
<v Dan Ryan>I got this from you.

1709
02:49:59.734 --> 02:50:00.457
<v Eric Engstrom>That's correct.

1710
02:50:00.682 --> 02:50:01.212
<v Dan Ryan>All right, so yes.

1711
02:50:01.904 --> 02:50:06.935
<v Dan Ryan>And then I would like to have information on where you were 10 years ago in 2016, 2017.

1712
02:50:07.692 --> 02:50:09.545
<v Eric Engstrom>Sure, we can get that.

1713
02:50:09.968 --> 02:50:10.989
<v Eric Engstrom>Follow-up information.

1714
02:50:11.671 --> 02:50:21.158
<v Eric Engstrom>The 2 trends I would say in that response is that we have— we are bigger than we were then, but most of that is PCF growth.

1715
02:50:21.755 --> 02:50:25.406
<v Eric Engstrom>PCF didn't exist in 2017 and now it's close to 50 people.

1716
02:50:27.005 --> 02:50:29.822
<v Dan Ryan>And that would be helpful to have that really clear in the comments.

1717
02:50:29.984 --> 02:50:37.363
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, the general fund programs have faced some percentage cuts almost every year since 2017.

1718
02:50:37.462 --> 02:50:42.458
<v Eric Engstrom>So most of those are going to be a third smaller than they were at that point.

1719
02:50:44.275 --> 02:50:51.649
<v Eric Engstrom>And the waste functions, I think, have been fairly stable, although we had a lot of turnover during the pandemic, but that wasn't necessarily budget related.

1720
02:50:52.552 --> 02:51:04.594
<v Dan Ryan>Give us some vision on what are the big projects that BPS is working on that Portland's known to— it used to be known for doing bold things that others would want to study years later.

1721
02:51:05.126 --> 02:51:06.281
<v Dan Ryan>What is that today?

1722
02:51:06.842 --> 02:51:10.289
<v Eric Engstrom>I think the Inner East project is exciting and bold.

1723
02:51:10.577 --> 02:51:15.933
<v Eric Engstrom>We continue to work in partner— the Inner East zoning work is one of our priorities.

1724
02:51:16.365 --> 02:51:28.327
<v Eric Engstrom>We continue to work in partner with Prosper and Housing Bureau on various central city strategic projects, whether it's OMSI or Albina Vision Trust, the Broadway corridor projects.

1725
02:51:28.424 --> 02:51:32.416
<v Eric Engstrom>Those are important in terms of Portland's image and economy.

1726
02:51:33.694 --> 02:51:41.566
<v Eric Engstrom>On the waste side, the, the, this commercial system overhaul is an opportunity to significantly improve recycling and composting across the city.

1727
02:51:41.630 --> 02:51:42.643
<v Eric Engstrom>And so that's a big deal.

1728
02:51:44.364 --> 02:51:51.031
<v Eric Engstrom>We're supporting the Chief Sustainability Officer in the next generation of the Climate Action Plan.

1729
02:51:51.829 --> 02:51:52.558
<v Eric Engstrom>That's huge.

1730
02:51:52.671 --> 02:51:58.480
<v Eric Engstrom>And of course, PSEF is doing at least 5 or 6 big visionary things right now, and we'll talk more about that tomorrow.

1731
02:51:58.577 --> 02:51:58.805
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1732
02:51:58.899 --> 02:52:02.813
<v Dan Ryan>Victor, I'm glad you brought up Olmsted, Broadway Corridor, and the— you didn't say Montgomery.

1733
02:52:03.022 --> 02:52:04.407
<v Dan Ryan>Maybe I missed it, the Montgomery.

1734
02:52:04.471 --> 02:52:06.275
<v Eric Engstrom>I didn't, but that's in that category too.

1735
02:52:06.984 --> 02:52:07.096
<v Angelita Morillo>And—.

1736
02:52:07.129 --> 02:52:12.760
<v Dan Ryan>Those are on the tip of my tongue 'cause that's been what we've been focused on for over 5 years.

1737
02:52:13.421 --> 02:52:18.119
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'd hope that we're persistent in focusing on such big projects like those 3.

1738
02:52:18.603 --> 02:52:27.980
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, and in fact, I think PP&D is now working in the early stages of permitting assistance for the first building that's coming into the Montgomery Park project area.

1739
02:52:28.031 --> 02:52:28.736
<v Eric Engstrom>So that's exciting.

1740
02:52:29.272 --> 02:52:36.388
<v Dan Ryan>When people hear about these big projects, they get excited, and it's— then they start to say, well, you vision and you plan a lot, but what's happening?

1741
02:52:36.742 --> 02:52:38.507
<v Dan Ryan>Like, what's going on at Broadway Corridor?

1742
02:52:38.894 --> 02:52:40.162
<v Dan Ryan>What's going on with OMSI?

1743
02:52:40.611 --> 02:52:47.148
<v Dan Ryan>So anyway, it's important for us to continue to help constituents see that we're not just planners, but we also do things.

1744
02:52:47.325 --> 02:53:07.222
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, and we are trying to— as a group of directors that are involved in development review, we meet monthly, and one of the things we talk about in that meeting is accountability for those major projects, so we're just not forgetting about them, that we're asking about what the status is and what the— what's, what's hung up, what, what's the bottleneck right now on any of those.

1745
02:53:07.271 --> 02:53:07.772
<v Dan Ryan>That's fair.

1746
02:53:08.323 --> 02:53:08.647
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1747
02:53:08.727 --> 02:53:10.668
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

1748
02:53:14.495 --> 02:53:18.148
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue— is that Councilor Green?

1749
02:53:18.198 --> 02:53:18.712
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is that a legacy?

1750
02:53:19.244 --> 02:53:21.174
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, okay.

1751
02:53:21.388 --> 02:53:21.501
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right.

1752
02:53:21.679 --> 02:53:24.252
<v Jamie Dunphy>That concludes all our questions from our councilors.

1753
02:53:24.851 --> 02:53:29.333
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, staff, for all the great questions and answers.

1754
02:53:30.239 --> 02:53:32.513
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we are adjourned.

1755
02:53:32.691 --> 02:53:36.773
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll see you back here at 2:00 for our regular meeting of the City Council.

1756
02:53:37.434 --> 02:53:39.596
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you.

