WEBVTT

1
00:06:32.620 --> 00:06:34.112
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good afternoon.

2
00:06:34.208 --> 00:06:37.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am calling to order this meeting of the Portland City Council.

3
00:06:37.430 --> 00:06:37.975
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is 2 o'clock.

4
00:06:38.562 --> 00:06:41.497
<v Jamie Dunphy>202 On Wednesday, May 6th.

5
00:06:41.987 --> 00:06:43.129
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, can you please call the roll?

6
00:06:45.060 --> 00:06:46.649
<v Sameer Kanal>Kanal here.

7
00:06:47.103 --> 00:06:51.076
<v Keelan McClymont>Portoguiney Ryan here.

8
00:06:52.519 --> 00:06:53.290
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane here.

9
00:06:54.480 --> 00:06:57.713
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo Novick here.

10
00:06:58.983 --> 00:06:59.819
<v Sameer Kanal>Clark here.

11
00:07:00.997 --> 00:07:01.293
<v Gary Darling>Green here.

12
00:07:01.834 --> 00:07:02.670
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman here.

13
00:07:03.622 --> 00:07:06.898
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos present.

14
00:07:07.076 --> 00:07:07.257
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here.

15
00:07:07.975 --> 00:07:10.148
<v Jamie Dunphy>And can we please call the— read the rules of decorum?

16
00:07:13.149 --> 00:07:13.973
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Council President.

17
00:07:14.312 --> 00:07:15.507
<v Keelan McClymont>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

18
00:07:15.670 --> 00:07:21.324
<v Keelan McClymont>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

19
00:07:25.769 --> 00:07:29.216
<v Keelan McClymont>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

20
00:07:30.057 --> 00:07:34.052
<v Keelan McClymont>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

21
00:07:34.646 --> 00:07:36.908
<v Keelan McClymont>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

22
00:07:37.519 --> 00:07:39.235
<v Keelan McClymont>The presiding officer preserves order.

23
00:07:39.701 --> 00:07:46.730
<v Keelan McClymont>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

24
00:07:47.485 --> 00:07:49.778
<v Keelan McClymont>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

25
00:07:50.357 --> 00:07:52.427
<v Keelan McClymont>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

26
00:07:53.165 --> 00:07:56.005
<v Keelan McClymont>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

27
00:07:56.069 --> 00:07:56.358
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mayor.

28
00:07:56.872 --> 00:08:00.848
<v Keelan McClymont>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

29
00:08:01.600 --> 00:08:04.005
<v Keelan McClymont>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

30
00:08:04.149 --> 00:08:06.747
<v Keelan McClymont>When testifying, state your name for the record.

31
00:08:06.810 --> 00:08:08.189
<v Keelan McClymont>Your address is not necessary.

32
00:08:08.750 --> 00:08:11.298
<v Keelan McClymont>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

33
00:08:11.860 --> 00:08:14.810
<v Keelan McClymont>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

34
00:08:15.370 --> 00:08:15.708
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

35
00:08:16.028 --> 00:08:16.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

36
00:08:17.454 --> 00:08:20.452
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, our first item is agenda approval.

37
00:08:20.581 --> 00:08:28.355
<v Jamie Dunphy>Item number 5, document 2026-155, has been requested to be pulled from the consent agenda for discussion by Mark Porras, a member of the public.

38
00:08:29.093 --> 00:08:37.653
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is authorizing borrowings of not more than $95 million in anticipation of the Fire and Police Disability Retirement Fund levy for the fiscal year '26-'27.

39
00:08:38.293 --> 00:08:47.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>I had placed this item on consent because it's a relatively straightforward matter that needs to be law by the end of the fiscal year to keep FPDR whole throughout its collection cycle.

40
00:08:48.168 --> 00:08:53.427
<v Jamie Dunphy>We do this borrowing for FPDR every year, but usually from internal services— sources.

41
00:08:53.602 --> 00:08:56.152
<v Jamie Dunphy>Due to the budget crunch this year, we have to borrow externally.

42
00:08:56.825 --> 00:09:00.158
<v Jamie Dunphy>Normally an item pulled from consent is placed at the end of the agenda, but in this case, I think it's appropriate to move it up to the beginning.

43
00:09:00.222 --> 00:09:00.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>Second.

44
00:09:00.320 --> 00:09:04.746
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think it would be worth getting it out of the way at the top of the regular agenda so that we can be done with it and move forward.

45
00:09:05.100 --> 00:09:06.647
<v Jamie Dunphy>Would councilors agree to this placement?

46
00:09:09.120 --> 00:09:09.313
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

47
00:09:10.042 --> 00:09:15.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>Are there any other requests to amend the agenda, to reorder items, or to reschedule an item for a future meeting date?

48
00:09:17.725 --> 00:09:18.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

49
00:09:18.618 --> 00:09:23.307
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I would like to move to have the pulled item moved to the top of the agenda.

50
00:09:23.371 --> 00:09:24.183
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can I have— is there a second?

51
00:09:24.730 --> 00:09:25.041
<v Dan Ryan>Second.

52
00:09:25.432 --> 00:09:26.267
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

53
00:09:28.744 --> 00:09:34.653
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there any— motions to amend agenda are debatable and may be adopted by unanimous consent or by vote.

54
00:09:35.149 --> 00:09:37.943
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is anyone— discussion to the reordering?

55
00:09:38.442 --> 00:09:38.778
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

56
00:09:39.886 --> 00:09:42.537
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do I have unanimous cons— oh wait, no.

57
00:09:43.081 --> 00:09:43.756
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, can I— yeah.

58
00:09:43.836 --> 00:09:46.245
<v Jamie Dunphy>Do I have unanimous consent to approve the reordering of the agenda?

59
00:09:47.177 --> 00:09:47.643
<v Unidentified speaker>Looks good.

60
00:09:47.980 --> 00:09:49.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>Your agenda is approved.

61
00:09:50.244 --> 00:09:52.009
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, could we please call public communications?

62
00:09:52.073 --> 00:09:52.235
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, Mayor.

63
00:09:54.851 --> 00:09:56.205
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have public communications.

64
00:09:57.480 --> 00:10:01.061
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, David Guither is our first individual.

65
00:10:02.859 --> 00:10:03.148
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

66
00:10:04.403 --> 00:10:04.756
<v David Guither>Thank you.

67
00:10:05.110 --> 00:10:07.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>Feel free to please, uh, introduce yourself for the record.

68
00:10:07.138 --> 00:10:09.471
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're welcome to share your pronouns, and you have 3 minutes.

69
00:10:10.371 --> 00:10:11.453
<v David Guither>My name is David Guither.

70
00:10:12.148 --> 00:10:22.923
<v David Guither>I'm with Rodeo Cab, and I'm here on the issue of, uh, robo-cabs or AV taxis, depending on how you want to phrase it.

71
00:10:25.090 --> 00:10:34.793
<v David Guither>One of the problems with the implementation that's starting now, the PBOT has been working hard, as you probably will find out, a whole series of rules and regs.

72
00:10:35.861 --> 00:10:39.163
<v David Guither>But it's, as they say, mathematics is a house built on sand.

73
00:10:39.844 --> 00:10:44.707
<v David Guither>Well, these rules and regs are built on air, if, if that's true, because there's no law.

74
00:10:45.496 --> 00:10:48.097
<v David Guither>There's no state law, there's no federal law.

75
00:10:48.788 --> 00:10:57.845
<v David Guither>So for example, if the Waymo company wanted to operate out of Gresham or Beaverton, they could pick up in Portland.

76
00:10:57.893 --> 00:10:58.759
<v David Guither>Who's going to stop them?

77
00:10:58.840 --> 00:11:10.400
<v David Guither>There's not— the police are very busy now and don't have time to be chasing anonymous vehicles trying to find out if they're picking up fares without being properly licensed in the state— city of Portland.

78
00:11:11.590 --> 00:11:33.923
<v David Guither>Anyway, um, I— in the last time I was here, I enumerated at least 11 taxes and fees you're going to lose every time one of the 12,000 people who are registered and currently licensed as private-for-hire workers in this city— you're going to lose a lot of tax money that way.

79
00:11:35.210 --> 00:11:42.298
<v David Guither>The new tax that I hear about, the apartment or whatever, some sort of form of property tax for potholes.

80
00:11:45.251 --> 00:11:46.769
<v David Guither>Uh, robots don't have apartments.

81
00:11:47.818 --> 00:11:51.274
<v David Guither>They may have a little building that they store them in, but they don't have apartments.

82
00:11:52.019 --> 00:11:54.447
<v David Guither>So that's something you're going to lose also.

83
00:11:55.024 --> 00:12:02.166
<v David Guither>My suggestion is to have this issue on the ballot for November.

84
00:12:02.217 --> 00:12:02.269
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

85
00:12:02.856 --> 00:12:05.807
<v David Guither>I looked into trying to do this with a petition.

86
00:12:06.947 --> 00:12:11.903
<v David Guither>First of all, you need 40,000+ signatures, which is daunting to begin with.

87
00:12:12.480 --> 00:12:14.711
<v David Guither>And it's just the timing.

88
00:12:14.807 --> 00:12:19.619
<v David Guither>You have to have it ahead of time, and it can't be done this time by an individual.

89
00:12:19.715 --> 00:12:20.565
<v David Guither>But the council can.

90
00:12:21.302 --> 00:12:22.988
<v David Guither>You have magic powers, as you well know.

91
00:12:23.629 --> 00:12:29.274
<v David Guither>You can have whatever you want on the ballot, and you can make it an advisory vote if you wanted to, not necessarily a law.

92
00:12:29.900 --> 00:12:39.182
<v David Guither>But let's get the issue out of PBOT and the Waymo people who obviously have a serious amount of influence.

93
00:12:39.278 --> 00:12:42.634
<v David Guither>Otherwise, they wouldn't be so hasty in moving forward.

94
00:12:43.229 --> 00:12:52.398
<v David Guither>Now, it's true that in the past there have been a number of efforts to create laws, but they have come to nothing.

95
00:12:52.447 --> 00:12:53.523
<v David Guither>There's no state law.

96
00:12:53.988 --> 00:12:57.585
<v David Guither>Here's one stack of paperwork that was created by a task force.

97
00:12:58.003 --> 00:13:00.057
<v David Guither>Here's a very nicely packaged one also.

98
00:13:00.123 --> 00:13:00.315
<v David Guither>Thank you.

99
00:13:01.438 --> 00:13:02.787
<v David Guither>They created a law out of this.

100
00:13:03.043 --> 00:13:08.725
<v David Guither>And my suggestion is to— why doesn't the council with PBOT write a law yourselves?

101
00:13:08.836 --> 00:13:19.205
<v David Guither>Maybe we can get it passed so there's some basis for what is being done, so it's not just flying around out there in regulation heaven.

102
00:13:19.573 --> 00:13:26.298
<v David Guither>Anyway, thank you so much for your time, and I'll be trying to contact your staff and yourselves.

103
00:13:26.409 --> 00:13:26.619
<v David Guither>Thank you.

104
00:13:27.053 --> 00:13:31.136
<v David Guither>Once you get through this budget process, which must be daunting since you have no money.

105
00:13:31.879 --> 00:13:32.669
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

106
00:13:33.105 --> 00:13:34.009
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

107
00:13:35.768 --> 00:13:41.566
<v Keelan McClymont>The next 2 individuals will come up together, Gary Darling and Talitha Mathis.

108
00:13:42.894 --> 00:13:43.298
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

109
00:13:43.703 --> 00:13:44.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>Come on up.

110
00:14:02.956 --> 00:14:07.568
<v Keelan McClymont>So I'm going to set the timer for 6 minutes and they will use the time, um, how they—.

111
00:14:07.568 --> 00:14:08.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sounds good to me.

112
00:14:09.106 --> 00:14:10.740
<v Jamie Dunphy>And make sure to introduce yourselves for the record.

113
00:14:11.028 --> 00:14:13.265
<v Talitha Mathis>Uh, good afternoon, City Council members.

114
00:14:13.604 --> 00:14:17.048
<v Talitha Mathis>My name is Talitha Mathis and I'm the co-founder of OnTrack Developers.

115
00:14:17.798 --> 00:14:40.135
<v Talitha Mathis>I'm here today to ask that you take the following information that I will share with you into consideration during the Planning Commission meeting set for May 12th, 2026 at 2:00 PM when discussing and making decisions in regard to the Columbia Corridor and the Industrial Lands Environmental Overlay Zone project that will have negative impacts on our possibility to develop on the site due to the expansion of the E-Zone.

116
00:14:41.066 --> 00:14:53.581
<v Talitha Mathis>My property is located in District 2 on the corner of North Marine Drive and North Ganton Vine Avenue, which is in the Bridgeton neighborhood on the north side of Marine Drive, and is zoned as a commercial mixed-use not industrial.

117
00:14:54.688 --> 00:15:04.125
<v Talitha Mathis>Our development project is actively working to build homes that will be available for purchase, providing working families with the opportunity to secure stability, a pressing need in our community.

118
00:15:04.543 --> 00:15:16.081
<v Talitha Mathis>This initiative represents a significant step towards providing housing, which is in alignment with the City of Portland's housing initiative to increase the availability of homes for families and address the ongoing housing crisis in our community.

119
00:15:16.659 --> 00:15:17.894
<v Talitha Mathis>We began this project in 2021.

120
00:15:17.943 --> 00:15:18.537
<v Talitha Mathis>Councilmember Herbold.

121
00:15:18.761 --> 00:15:23.335
<v Talitha Mathis>And have invested over $300,000 and 5 years of dedicated effort towards its success.

122
00:15:23.961 --> 00:15:30.009
<v Talitha Mathis>Our pre-construction costs have been funded by Prosper Portland, with our loan agreement expiring in January 2027.

123
00:15:30.554 --> 00:15:36.379
<v Talitha Mathis>Portland is currently facing a housing crisis, and the city has set a goal to build more homes for families.

124
00:15:36.893 --> 00:15:49.345
<v Talitha Mathis>Our project aligns perfectly with this vision, yet the recent discussions regarding the environmental zone expansion, which will be addressed in the planning meeting, On May the 12th poses a significant challenge.

125
00:15:49.970 --> 00:15:56.870
<v Talitha Mathis>The proposed increase in the conservation buffer from 15 feet to 50 feet could render much of our site undevelopable.

126
00:15:57.672 --> 00:16:06.144
<v Talitha Mathis>We have previously submitted written testimony detailing the negative impact this change would have on our project, jeopardizing our goal of providing homes that foster community stability.

127
00:16:06.721 --> 00:16:14.006
<v Talitha Mathis>I urge you to recognize the significance of this project not merely as an investment, but as a crucial step toward meeting the housing needs in our community.

128
00:16:14.264 --> 00:16:14.649
<v Talitha Mathis>Thank you.

129
00:16:15.403 --> 00:16:21.796
<v Talitha Mathis>By proposing owner-occupied housing, we can further enhance the stability of the neighborhood, which in turn supports the health of green space too.

130
00:16:22.533 --> 00:16:23.942
<v Talitha Mathis>Thank you for your time and consideration.

131
00:16:24.440 --> 00:16:26.442
<v Talitha Mathis>And now, Gary, go ahead.

132
00:16:27.163 --> 00:16:29.311
<v Gary Darling>Hello, my name is Gary Darling.

133
00:16:29.519 --> 00:16:34.390
<v Gary Darling>I'm a civil engineer, and this has been my profession since 1997.

134
00:16:35.032 --> 00:16:45.501
<v Gary Darling>In 2021, our company, DL Consulting WA, began working with OnTrack Development Developers LLC on their Marine Drive project as their civil engineers.

135
00:16:46.176 --> 00:16:52.370
<v Gary Darling>The project is located within the Columbia Corridor and Industrial Lands Environmental Overlay.

136
00:16:52.836 --> 00:17:12.790
<v Gary Darling>As you continue to consider potential expansions of this overlay, and during your discussion at the Planning Commission meeting on May 12th, we respectfully urge you to please take our project into consideration when making decisions that will affect the viability of this very needed project in North Portland.

137
00:17:13.464 --> 00:17:27.676
<v Gary Darling>Over the past 5 years, we have worked very closely with the staff from Permitting and Development, PBOT, the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability, and with Multnomah County Urban Flood Safety and Water Quality District.

138
00:17:27.854 --> 00:17:35.867
<v Gary Darling>Our team has invested substantial time, energy into bringing our client's project to fruition.

139
00:17:36.564 --> 00:17:58.799
<v Gary Darling>Due to the nature of the many layers of agency bureaucracy and time delays, we have reached out to multiple departments within the city in an effort to advance our progress at a strong and steady pace, and also to ensure that the environmental overlay adjustments will not negatively impact this project.

140
00:17:59.362 --> 00:18:02.075
<v Gary Darling>In response, we received a highly informative email.

141
00:18:02.557 --> 00:18:14.317
<v Gary Darling>From Stephen Himes of the Public Works Development Division, which provided us with valuable guidelines for proceeding with possibly vesting our site prior to the CCIL expansion.

142
00:18:14.784 --> 00:18:21.885
<v Gary Darling>We sincerely appreciate this assistance in clarifying our options and the necessary next steps.

143
00:18:22.400 --> 00:18:38.530
<v Gary Darling>However, if the site is not vested and the conservation setbacks are adjusted before the site is vested or permitted, my clients will lose most of the developable portion of their property, rendering the project unfeasible for development.

144
00:18:39.509 --> 00:18:56.255
<v Gary Darling>As we just stated, we respectfully request that you factor our project into your decision-making process, as it will significantly impact my clients' ability to pursue a viable development or possibly any development at all.

145
00:18:58.083 --> 00:19:28.114
<v Gary Darling>I would also like to add that in my almost 30 years of being a civil engineer and working on projects in this city with the various bureaus, the most recent changes— when I say recent, I mean over the last few years— of the Public Works permitting concept approval process, the bar is being slowly and consistently raised to a point where just a few years ago, concept or 30% approval was a matter of several months.

146
00:19:28.660 --> 00:19:30.923
<v Gary Darling>Now it may take a year or even longer.

147
00:19:31.325 --> 00:19:47.605
<v Gary Darling>I believe that our PBOT drawings for this project, which are close to but not quite yet have concept approval, are actually much closer to what would have been considered design level or 60% drawings just a few years ago.

148
00:19:48.568 --> 00:19:55.022
<v Gary Darling>We believe that we only need to address a few minor Water Bureau comments to obtain concept approval.

149
00:19:55.568 --> 00:20:03.211
<v Gary Darling>But I bring this up because I believe that the drawings should actually be granted concept approval immediately, as they are now.

150
00:20:04.463 --> 00:20:18.680
<v Gary Darling>And also, I would like to raise the hope that the powers that be will seriously take a hard look at streamlining the public works permitting process thank you very much for your time.

151
00:20:20.059 --> 00:20:21.678
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, and fantastic timing.

152
00:20:21.775 --> 00:20:22.356
<v Jamie Dunphy>That was good.

153
00:20:22.599 --> 00:20:23.652
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

154
00:20:25.189 --> 00:20:27.340
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Addie Smith.

155
00:20:37.595 --> 00:20:38.549
<v Addie Smith>Hello everyone.

156
00:20:38.825 --> 00:20:53.346
<v Addie Smith>Before Keelan starts my timer, I wanted to ask Councilor Smith, no relation, if she would provide me with the voting record for the councilors who voted in support of Hacienda receiving funding.

157
00:20:54.357 --> 00:21:06.015
<v Addie Smith>Last month she said that, uh, Councilor Avalos and Murillo voted in favor of funding for Hacienda, and I wanted to see that voting record, please, if she could.

158
00:21:06.078 --> 00:21:06.576
<v Addie Smith>Councilor Loretta Smith.

159
00:21:07.111 --> 00:21:13.169
<v Addie Smith>Uh, get my email address from Keelan and send me over that voting record for all of the councilors.

160
00:21:14.238 --> 00:21:14.965
<v Addie Smith>Um, thank you.

161
00:21:15.949 --> 00:21:20.104
<v Addie Smith>And so I will, uh, start if you're ready, Keelan.

162
00:21:23.428 --> 00:21:25.026
<v Addie Smith>Hello, my name is Addie Smith.

163
00:21:25.299 --> 00:21:27.317
<v Addie Smith>Today is May 6th, 2026.

164
00:21:27.946 --> 00:21:30.788
<v Addie Smith>I am speaking before the Portland City Council.

165
00:21:31.336 --> 00:21:41.262
<v Addie Smith>I want to call out Willamette Weekly and Sophie Peel for their racist bias and partial reporting on the CEO Ivory Matthews at Home Forward.

166
00:21:41.760 --> 00:21:51.626
<v Addie Smith>What Sophie Peel and Willamette Weekly did not tell the public is that the Chief Operating Officer Ian Davies's salary was also increased by 68%.

167
00:21:52.623 --> 00:21:55.210
<v Addie Smith>He also earns over $300,000.

168
00:21:55.740 --> 00:22:11.174
<v Addie Smith>Ian Davies, who actually is responsible for the operations at Home Forward as the Chief Operating Officer, while he wasn't taking as many trips as Ivory Matthews, he wasn't doing his job while working from home or in the office every day.

169
00:22:11.737 --> 00:22:28.885
<v Addie Smith>Home Forward's debt service coverage ratio, meaning their ability to pay their bills and operate, dropped under his leadership as Chief Operating Officer from 2.36 in 2022, a healthy robust budget coverage, to 1.10 where it currently stands.

170
00:22:28.998 --> 00:22:32.337
<v Addie Smith>Councilor Smith, He didn't visit any of the properties.

171
00:22:32.450 --> 00:22:34.424
<v Addie Smith>He didn't respond to any resident complaints.

172
00:22:34.520 --> 00:22:38.631
<v Addie Smith>He didn't perform any of his duties as Chief Operating Officer.

173
00:22:38.871 --> 00:22:40.733
<v Addie Smith>He must resign.

174
00:22:41.199 --> 00:22:48.406
<v Addie Smith>Not only must he resign, but so must Candy Sage, the Chief Financial Officer, and Kitty Miller, the Chief People and Culture Officer.

175
00:22:48.824 --> 00:22:56.625
<v Addie Smith>They both had salary increases of 59% and 74% respectively, and both earn nearly $300,000 each.

176
00:22:56.657 --> 00:22:57.124
<v Addie Smith>Councilmember Smith, you have 2 minutes.

177
00:22:57.412 --> 00:23:01.680
<v Addie Smith>This does not include thousands of dollars in bonuses and additional compensation.

178
00:23:02.066 --> 00:23:11.050
<v Addie Smith>Meanwhile, they are all furloughing employees and people who've been employed by HomeForward for nearly 30 years and were still entry-level staff.

179
00:23:11.596 --> 00:23:14.098
<v Addie Smith>HomeForward's decline is due to all of them.

180
00:23:14.901 --> 00:23:21.848
<v Addie Smith>Ian Davey, Candy Sage, and Kitty Miller didn't need Ivory Matthews to perform their job duties and responsibilities.

181
00:23:22.442 --> 00:23:25.538
<v Addie Smith>These are adults who intentionally failed to do their jobs.

182
00:23:25.892 --> 00:23:29.595
<v Addie Smith>So while Ivory Matthews was traveling and networking, the board approved it.

183
00:23:29.980 --> 00:23:33.923
<v Addie Smith>The board reviewed her request for travel and networking and approved it.

184
00:23:34.228 --> 00:23:37.048
<v Addie Smith>Should she have been ensuring that her staff were doing their jobs?

185
00:23:37.192 --> 00:23:37.433
<v Addie Smith>Yes.

186
00:23:37.834 --> 00:23:41.457
<v Addie Smith>However, this shouldn't have stopped these adults from performing.

187
00:23:41.761 --> 00:23:45.641
<v Addie Smith>They knew what needed to be done and still chose to allow the organization to fail.

188
00:23:46.314 --> 00:23:49.359
<v Addie Smith>The organization is failing because of them too.

189
00:23:50.241 --> 00:23:52.068
<v Addie Smith>Their resignations— I need a few more minutes, please.

190
00:23:52.230 --> 00:23:53.589
<v Addie Smith>One more minute, please.

191
00:23:53.589 --> 00:23:55.839
<v Addie Smith>Their resignations are a must.

192
00:23:56.109 --> 00:23:59.349
<v Addie Smith>Again, I call on the board to hire me as CEO.

193
00:23:59.349 --> 00:24:06.069
<v Addie Smith>I am a certified financial specialist, a housing credit certified professional, a specialist in housing credit management, and more.

194
00:24:06.069 --> 00:24:08.809
<v Addie Smith>I've been in housing for over 30 years.

195
00:24:08.809 --> 00:24:26.865
<v Addie Smith>There are plenty of nonprofits in Oregon and Washington State that are fraudulent, where the corporate executives are doing the least work, getting all of the salary increases and bonuses, and on-site staff while working in these communities, doing all the work, are being furloughed or laid off and not receiving any pay increases or bonuses at all.

196
00:24:27.861 --> 00:24:31.923
<v Addie Smith>The board must also terminate all contracts with third-party property management companies.

197
00:24:32.180 --> 00:24:33.560
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you so much.

198
00:24:33.978 --> 00:24:36.307
<v Addie Smith>County Commission— one moment.

199
00:24:36.997 --> 00:24:38.666
<v Jamie Dunphy>I, I gotta end you there, unfortunately.

200
00:24:39.181 --> 00:24:39.662
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

201
00:24:39.967 --> 00:24:43.001
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're welcome to send in any of the additional comments to us.

202
00:24:45.682 --> 00:24:47.655
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Joel Meredith.

203
00:24:47.992 --> 00:24:51.377
<v Joel Meredith>Hi, you guys, can you guys hear me?

204
00:24:51.699 --> 00:24:52.229
<v Joel Meredith>Yeah, go ahead.

205
00:24:52.566 --> 00:24:54.346
<v Joel Meredith>All right, uh, thanks for having me.

206
00:24:54.442 --> 00:24:55.421
<v Joel Meredith>I've never done this before.

207
00:24:55.773 --> 00:24:57.041
<v Joel Meredith>Uh, my name is Joel Meredith.

208
00:24:57.218 --> 00:24:57.971
<v Joel Meredith>I live in District 2.

209
00:24:58.982 --> 00:25:10.919
<v Joel Meredith>Uh, I'm here today to ask the city to start making a proactive effort to cleaning up tents and camps that are on major thoroughfares, streets, really anywhere in the city.

210
00:25:11.576 --> 00:25:16.287
<v Joel Meredith>Besides letting them sit and essentially fester and gather garbage.

211
00:25:16.623 --> 00:25:26.093
<v Joel Meredith>And it seems like it's currently on the, uh, responsibility of residents to, uh, make complaints, and then they get eventually cleaned up.

212
00:25:27.295 --> 00:25:38.959
<v Joel Meredith>Just today I was driving to work and I saw there's a tent underneath, uh, the Hawthorne Bridge on MLK Avenue, on 12th and Northeast Sandy, on Lombard and North Mobile or Mobile.

213
00:25:39.615 --> 00:25:51.334
<v Joel Meredith>Uh, and up until a couple of days ago, there was 2 large tents that were kind of combined into one structure right across from the Arbor Lodge, um, Safe Rest Village.

214
00:25:52.279 --> 00:25:54.476
<v Joel Meredith>These are not secluded areas of the cities.

215
00:25:54.539 --> 00:26:03.644
<v Joel Meredith>These are right in the middle of the city, and I have a hard time believing that various, you know, police officers, city officials are not driving past these.

216
00:26:04.542 --> 00:26:12.993
<v Joel Meredith>Um, if this was a building fire, I think that some action would be taken so that damage would be mitigated.

217
00:26:13.522 --> 00:26:18.156
<v Joel Meredith>That does not seem to be happening out here, and it's really kind of appalling.

218
00:26:18.253 --> 00:26:27.298
<v Joel Meredith>I've grown up here, I've lived here my whole life, and it's appalling that we've let this city kind of become a trash heap for people who are setting up tents wherever they want these neighborhoods.

219
00:26:28.036 --> 00:26:41.142
<v Joel Meredith>Uh, I want a safe place for my wife, my kid, my neighbors, and I know that homeless people are not, you know, inherently bad or anything, but they're in the wrong for setting up a tent on public property.

220
00:26:41.205 --> 00:26:44.157
<v Joel Meredith>That is nuts to let that go on, and I'm sick of it.

221
00:26:44.960 --> 00:26:54.169
<v Joel Meredith>Uh, we pay a lot in taxes for the privilege to live here, and I think there's a lot of compassion talk on this.

222
00:26:54.923 --> 00:27:10.776
<v Joel Meredith>There seems to be a lack of compassion for people who are paying the taxes, voting, working, and keeping the city afloat, um, and having to put up with unsafe, dirty, um, situations in their neighborhoods.

223
00:27:10.824 --> 00:27:12.558
<v Joel Meredith>And I think it's just pretty appalling.

224
00:27:13.618 --> 00:27:16.913
<v Joel Meredith>Um, I don't really want to keep a bunch of your time.

225
00:27:17.074 --> 00:27:17.298
<v Joel Meredith>I would—.

226
00:27:17.635 --> 00:27:25.484
<v Joel Meredith>Yeah, I just think there's a responsibility on the authorities in Portland to act more proactively, not let them sit and fester.

227
00:27:25.939 --> 00:27:28.748
<v Joel Meredith>I talked to someone from the, um, impact reduction team.

228
00:27:28.845 --> 00:27:37.598
<v Joel Meredith>They said they, they rate the camps on a number from 1 to 100, and 50 or 51 is when they start taking action.

229
00:27:37.711 --> 00:27:42.262
<v Joel Meredith>I think just one tent on public property should automatically be a 51.

230
00:27:42.537 --> 00:27:46.633
<v Joel Meredith>We should not, as residents, have to sit and just deal with this.

231
00:27:47.146 --> 00:27:48.448
<v Joel Meredith>It's a little much to ask for us.

232
00:27:49.042 --> 00:27:49.684
<v Joel Meredith>Thank you for your time.

233
00:27:51.426 --> 00:27:51.972
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

234
00:27:52.726 --> 00:27:54.136
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes communications.

235
00:27:54.809 --> 00:28:03.883
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, next on our agenda is usually our, uh, where we talk about federal updates, and also we're going to move into the city administrator's update.

236
00:28:03.946 --> 00:28:08.708
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I will just give one very brief federal update that we need to mention.

237
00:28:08.819 --> 00:28:12.394
<v Jamie Dunphy>The Supreme Court last week, uh, gutted Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act.

238
00:28:12.827 --> 00:28:16.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, we have a lot of hard work to do as a community and as a country to move closer to justice.

239
00:28:17.878 --> 00:28:22.874
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, City Administrator Lee, you— turning to you for your monthly City Administrator report.

240
00:28:23.276 --> 00:28:26.247
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, just as a heads up, we have 30 minutes scheduled for this item.

241
00:28:26.744 --> 00:28:29.057
<v Raymond C. Lee>Okay, good afternoon, Council.

242
00:28:29.202 --> 00:28:34.647
<v Raymond C. Lee>This month's, uh, report is, uh, grounded in a single theme of fiscal responsibility.

243
00:28:35.337 --> 00:28:48.848
<v Raymond C. Lee>Across the organization, you will see a consistent focus on aligning our operations, investments, and service delivery with the financial realities in front of us while continuing to deliver results for the community.

244
00:28:49.280 --> 00:28:56.299
<v Raymond C. Lee>What I want to highlight today is how the discipline is showing up in real tangible ways across the organization.

245
00:28:57.053 --> 00:29:02.229
<v Raymond C. Lee>We're continuing to improve how the city operates by aligning services and reducing duplication.

246
00:29:02.885 --> 00:29:08.734
<v Raymond C. Lee>A strong example of this is continued integration within our 311 bureau.

247
00:29:09.071 --> 00:29:19.251
<v Raymond C. Lee>Where we are now unifying dispatch services across parks and transportation into a single 24/7 coordinated system.

248
00:29:19.797 --> 00:29:21.704
<v Raymond C. Lee>This is about more than efficiency.

249
00:29:22.057 --> 00:29:31.483
<v Raymond C. Lee>It's about creating a more responsive, consistent experience for the public while maximizing existing resources.

250
00:29:32.317 --> 00:29:38.237
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are also making disciplined investments that deliver both financial and community value.

251
00:29:38.894 --> 00:29:51.961
<v Raymond C. Lee>The PCF e-bike program is now live, expanding access to affordable, reliable transportation, particularly for low-income residents through a structured rebate program.

252
00:29:52.538 --> 00:30:08.768
<v Raymond C. Lee>At the same time, broader PCF investments, including programs like energy-friendly homes, are deploying sufficient resources in a way that reduces long-term energy costs and improves housing stability.

253
00:30:09.286 --> 00:30:15.538
<v Raymond C. Lee>This is what fiscal responsibility investment looks like— upfront strategy with long-term return.

254
00:30:17.442 --> 00:30:22.839
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are also continuing to identify opportunities to reduce costs and better leverage partnerships.

255
00:30:23.083 --> 00:30:31.055
<v Raymond C. Lee>A strong example of that is the Preschool for All partnership, which is now funding programs within city community centers.

256
00:30:31.631 --> 00:30:38.434
<v Raymond C. Lee>And generating approximately $1 million in general fund savings that can be redirected to other priorities.

257
00:30:40.190 --> 00:30:49.683
<v Raymond C. Lee>Also, you're seeing in Water Bureau's energy management efforts continue to generate ongoing savings and rebates, helping offset rising costs.

258
00:30:49.765 --> 00:30:56.489
<v Raymond C. Lee>These are all types of structural improvements we need to continue in scaling as an organization.

259
00:30:58.119 --> 00:31:01.701
<v Raymond C. Lee>In public safety, we're seeing measurable progress as well.

260
00:31:01.910 --> 00:31:13.521
<v Raymond C. Lee>Portland continues to be recognized nationally for reductions in gun violence, reflecting sustained coordination and focus across our system.

261
00:31:14.180 --> 00:31:23.494
<v Raymond C. Lee>At the same time, the Bureau of Emergency Communications has achieved accreditation, placing it in the top tier of dispatch agencies nationwide.

262
00:31:23.895 --> 00:31:26.237
<v Raymond C. Lee>Which we recently recognized.

263
00:31:26.637 --> 00:31:33.982
<v Raymond C. Lee>These outcomes matter because they reflect both performance and the trust in our core services as a city.

264
00:31:34.961 --> 00:31:40.622
<v Raymond C. Lee>We are also maintaining a strong focus on oversight of our major capital investments.

265
00:31:41.230 --> 00:31:53.336
<v Raymond C. Lee>Projects like Bull Run Filtration Project and our Columbia Boulevard continue to advance with clear attention to schedule, yes.

266
00:31:53.464 --> 00:32:03.471
<v Raymond C. Lee>At the same time, we're strengthening governance structures, including independent oversight, to ensure accountability at the scale these investments require.

267
00:32:05.460 --> 00:32:12.855
<v Raymond C. Lee>From a transparency accountability enhancement, this month's reports also reflects continued progress in this.

268
00:32:13.594 --> 00:32:21.521
<v Raymond C. Lee>At council's request, we enhanced the claims reporting to include court court type and docket information.

269
00:32:22.067 --> 00:32:33.497
<v Raymond C. Lee>We introduced a new active contracts appendix that you will see in the back of the city administrator's report for visibility into the contract capacity across the organization.

270
00:32:34.089 --> 00:32:45.055
<v Raymond C. Lee>There are important steps towards giving council clearer lines of insight into the risks, spending, and long-term obligations that we have as a city.

271
00:32:45.103 --> 00:32:45.278
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

272
00:32:46.097 --> 00:32:54.221
<v Raymond C. Lee>On an organizational leadership standpoint, which I will clap for this 'cause this is my first big executive hire.

273
00:32:54.366 --> 00:33:04.643
<v Raymond C. Lee>Finally, I want to highlight that we're welcoming the city's first Chief Equity Officer, which you've seen in my email, Latricia Tillman, who will start next week.

274
00:33:05.300 --> 00:33:10.807
<v Raymond C. Lee>This role will be critical in aligning our equity efforts across the organization.

275
00:33:11.307 --> 00:33:15.733
<v Raymond C. Lee>And ensuring we are delivering outcomes that reflect our values as a city.

276
00:33:17.630 --> 00:33:20.912
<v Raymond C. Lee>In closing, I would like to say this as well before I close out.

277
00:33:21.364 --> 00:33:27.715
<v Raymond C. Lee>As this council is aware, the hearing officer has heard the merits, uh, as it relates to the appeal.

278
00:33:28.392 --> 00:33:31.096
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, that case has continued until today.

279
00:33:31.853 --> 00:33:37.500
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, we are anticipating not hearing a judgment on this until a couple of weeks out.

280
00:33:38.077 --> 00:33:45.446
<v Raymond C. Lee>The hearing officer has that capability to review and take everything under consideration before we get a report out on that.

281
00:33:46.507 --> 00:34:01.180
<v Raymond C. Lee>One thing I would like to say in closing though, we're still aligning our services, we're still investing, uh, with discipline, we're still improving our transparency, and we're making the hard decisions necessary for long-term stability for our organization.

282
00:34:01.614 --> 00:34:03.523
<v Raymond C. Lee>And I welcome any questions that council may have at this time.

283
00:34:03.604 --> 00:34:03.909
<v Talitha Mathis>Thank you, Mayor.

284
00:34:04.480 --> 00:34:05.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, City Administrator.

285
00:34:05.625 --> 00:34:08.403
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, any questions for our City Administrator on his report?

286
00:34:10.208 --> 00:34:11.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

287
00:34:12.253 --> 00:34:13.152
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

288
00:34:14.762 --> 00:34:16.782
<v Sameer Kanal>First, just a couple quick notes.

289
00:34:16.847 --> 00:34:21.923
<v Sameer Kanal>I really appreciate the shout out to OVP and Ceasefire, the work of the entire public safety system.

290
00:34:22.117 --> 00:34:39.748
<v Sameer Kanal>The report from the Center for American Progress shows that we have nearly doubled the rate of decline in shootings the gun violence rates, gun victimization rates, 56.7% reduction in the last 4 years as compared to 29.4% nationwide.

291
00:34:39.829 --> 00:34:42.523
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that's really worth praising everybody involved in that.

292
00:34:42.619 --> 00:34:50.510
<v Sameer Kanal>Also wanted to take the opportunity to thank, as you mentioned, Judith Mowry, but also Jeff Selby for their work leading the Office of Equity and Human Rights.

293
00:34:51.023 --> 00:34:53.235
<v Sameer Kanal>Excited to welcome Tricia Tillman over as well.

294
00:34:54.166 --> 00:35:00.853
<v Sameer Kanal>Also really appreciated the shout out to Marisol in there about the Community Resilience Team at PBEM and the Office of Small Business, which hit a year.

295
00:35:00.900 --> 00:35:01.028
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

296
00:35:01.606 --> 00:35:21.820
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that your hope expressed in the report that they can do more for small businesses is something that I, I really wanted to highlight, especially given the ideal placement of the Storefront Support Program, in my view, is there and resourcing the office to truly provide support to small businesses around the city, especially those in Lloyd Center.

297
00:35:23.023 --> 00:35:24.994
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wanted to ask a couple questions.

298
00:35:25.411 --> 00:35:32.068
<v Sameer Kanal>On April 13th, Microsoft Copilot, launched for all employees on April 13th, and it says here excluding police.

299
00:35:33.112 --> 00:35:35.648
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm not suggesting that it should have been or it shouldn't have been.

300
00:35:35.760 --> 00:35:42.775
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm curious what the rationale was for the, the, the why it was rolled out in the way it was in, in that context.

301
00:35:43.385 --> 00:35:47.606
<v Raymond C. Lee>I don't know if our BTS or DCA over that group is here.

302
00:35:48.297 --> 00:36:03.565
<v Raymond C. Lee>If my recollection is right, it's their systems that they're operating with and the, and the information that they have in their system and its ability from a safety standpoint to be able to be integrated into AI software.

303
00:36:04.014 --> 00:36:18.567
<v Raymond C. Lee>So we're still evaluating that component of it and wanted to make sure we had all those things in order before we opened up a pilot program for the police bureau, especially with the safety-sensitive information that they have.

304
00:36:19.159 --> 00:36:25.186
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that makes sense that they obviously have a different system and that makes sense that it wouldn't necessarily be together.

305
00:36:26.356 --> 00:36:30.159
<v Sameer Kanal>Every to a lesser degree, but of the same type.

306
00:36:30.800 --> 00:36:33.623
<v Sameer Kanal>The concerns around that apply actually elsewhere as well.

307
00:36:34.233 --> 00:36:37.266
<v Sameer Kanal>There's sensitive information that all city employees have access to.

308
00:36:37.362 --> 00:36:39.849
<v Sameer Kanal>Again, not to the same degree as police, but I would like to.

309
00:36:40.876 --> 00:36:47.019
<v Sameer Kanal>I would have loved more engagement on that process with you know the elected representatives instead of it being done through administrative rule.

310
00:36:47.389 --> 00:36:51.864
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to flag that while we're on it because I think that that answer actually illuminates.

311
00:36:51.980 --> 00:36:55.601
<v Sameer Kanal>Why pausing that in the other places would be helpful.

312
00:36:59.717 --> 00:37:00.702
<v Sameer Kanal>This is maybe for later.

313
00:37:00.784 --> 00:37:07.818
<v Sameer Kanal>In the budget note tracker, Canal 13 says it's complete, yet we never got a comprehensive proposal for what a package delivery fee would look like.

314
00:37:08.126 --> 00:37:15.387
<v Sameer Kanal>This got rolled into the PBOT conversation that involved the TUF, the street damage restoration fee, but then that's where all of it went.

315
00:37:15.532 --> 00:37:18.905
<v Sameer Kanal>It was like, we're looking at all 4 of these together, which is separate from the budget note.

316
00:37:19.342 --> 00:37:21.458
<v Sameer Kanal>And then it ended up where we're just getting these 2 proposals.

317
00:37:21.507 --> 00:37:27.007
<v Sameer Kanal>So I just was hoping you could help me follow up with PBOT on that and get the information that I hope was created by then.

318
00:37:28.242 --> 00:37:28.675
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

319
00:37:29.269 --> 00:37:37.240
<v Sameer Kanal>And then you mention in the report engagement with people living in vessels on the Willamette.

320
00:37:38.251 --> 00:37:41.411
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wanted to just ask, what does that look like?

321
00:37:41.474 --> 00:37:48.050
<v Sameer Kanal>'Cause it says Portland Solutions staff and outreach team members joined the Department of State Lands to engage by boat.

322
00:37:48.833 --> 00:37:49.927
<v Sameer Kanal>And offering services.

323
00:37:50.184 --> 00:37:59.246
<v Sameer Kanal>I know that we often use the phrase offering services as a euphemism for sweeps in the Portland Solutions service, their work.

324
00:37:59.293 --> 00:38:01.467
<v Sameer Kanal>So what does that look like in practice?

325
00:38:02.300 --> 00:38:09.320
<v Raymond C. Lee>What I can do for that, Councilor, I know Portland Solutions is coming up and they're— oh, they're literally coming up.

326
00:38:09.641 --> 00:38:10.382
<v Raymond C. Lee>She can address it now.

327
00:38:10.606 --> 00:38:12.027
<v Raymond C. Lee>We can address it during that time as well.

328
00:38:12.800 --> 00:38:13.773
<v Raymond C. Lee>Whatever works best for you.

329
00:38:16.826 --> 00:38:17.565
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, yeah, happy to.

330
00:38:17.644 --> 00:38:19.876
<v Candace Avalos>Just quickly, Councilor, and I can also follow up with you later.

331
00:38:20.358 --> 00:38:25.963
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so this was an initial pilot kind of project that's in partnership with the Department of St. Lands and our outreach team.

332
00:38:26.012 --> 00:38:32.804
<v Candace Avalos>So the folks that are doing that city outreach on the ground just to talk to folks, see if they'd be interested in shelter or maybe some other kind of service on the water.

333
00:38:33.237 --> 00:38:38.987
<v Candace Avalos>So some of these folks, um, had housing or a different apartment and also had a vessel on the water, but some folks didn't.

334
00:38:39.420 --> 00:38:40.978
<v Candace Avalos>So really just offering some services.

335
00:38:41.315 --> 00:38:43.753
<v Candace Avalos>2 Folks expressed interest in shelter, so that was great.

336
00:38:43.817 --> 00:38:44.940
<v Candace Avalos>We can follow up with them.

337
00:38:45.260 --> 00:38:52.155
<v Candace Avalos>But there's also a collaboration with Department of State Lands and the Sheriff's Office because of the river patrol and all the different aspects that are on the water.

338
00:38:52.492 --> 00:38:54.096
<v Candace Avalos>A lot of different jurisdictions involved.

339
00:38:54.143 --> 00:38:55.972
<v Candace Avalos>We wanted to at least offer some services.

340
00:38:56.469 --> 00:39:00.061
<v Candace Avalos>So that was just a first step, but I think there could be more engagement going forward.

341
00:39:00.719 --> 00:39:02.788
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure, thanks for that.

342
00:39:04.182 --> 00:39:17.226
<v Sameer Kanal>Does the suite of services that are being offered, are they comparable to what you would offer someone who might be living in a tent on a street, or is there a difference in any way on that?

343
00:39:17.483 --> 00:39:26.713
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, no, I believe— I wasn't with them when they approached folks, but I believe they offered any pod shelter that was available, but also overnight congregate shelter.

344
00:39:27.114 --> 00:39:27.771
<v Candace Avalos>So it'd be similar.

345
00:39:27.851 --> 00:39:28.012
<v Sameer Kanal>Yep.

346
00:39:28.831 --> 00:39:29.344
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

347
00:39:29.762 --> 00:39:33.068
<v Sameer Kanal>I think I'll pause there because I see other people in the queue.

348
00:39:33.148 --> 00:39:33.951
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

349
00:39:34.257 --> 00:39:34.996
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

350
00:39:35.077 --> 00:39:35.528
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

351
00:39:37.090 --> 00:39:39.425
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you, City Administrator Lee.

352
00:39:39.811 --> 00:39:41.018
<v Mitch Green>I always appreciate the update.

353
00:39:41.663 --> 00:39:46.679
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm just going to follow on to Councilor Kanal's questions about the, the budget note tracker.

354
00:39:46.744 --> 00:39:47.949
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate the tracker.

355
00:39:48.367 --> 00:39:58.597
<v Mitch Green>I will note that Green 10 is highlighted as green and it says it's complete, but we did not get every 6 weeks a briefing that said so.

356
00:39:59.706 --> 00:40:01.201
<v Mitch Green>Don't want to go back in time and revisit that.

357
00:40:01.362 --> 00:40:14.385
<v Mitch Green>I understand there's been a lot of constraints facing the city, but I think as we go into the next budget and we're contemplating new budget notes, if we're not able to execute on that, we probably not— green's probably not the status quo code.

358
00:40:14.643 --> 00:40:16.356
<v Mitch Green>So just wanted to flag that.

359
00:40:17.929 --> 00:40:40.684
<v Mitch Green>The other piece I have a question about, as I was reviewing the contracts, which is very helpful to have that up there, Urban Alchemy's contract began in March of 2023, and that's a total total of $90 million is the contract, and it looks like to date we've spent just over $55 million on that contract because there's roughly $35 million remaining.

360
00:40:41.670 --> 00:40:47.228
<v Mitch Green>I'm asking this question because I understand that they are our contractor for the alternative, the task sites.

361
00:40:48.766 --> 00:40:59.168
<v Mitch Green>The issue I'm having is today there's some reporting that there's been 85 complaints to the ombudsman about serious issues of misconduct at Urban Alchemy— drug dealing, sexual harassment.

362
00:40:59.235 --> 00:40:59.447
<v Mitch Green>That's not true.

363
00:41:05.039 --> 00:41:10.929
<v Mitch Green>And our ombudsman was able to substantiate 6 of those.

364
00:41:11.159 --> 00:41:15.400
<v Mitch Green>42 Of those complaints were referred back to Urban Alchemy's grievance— internal grievance process.

365
00:41:15.400 --> 00:41:17.949
<v Mitch Green>And they, you know, we don't know what the status of that is.

366
00:41:18.239 --> 00:41:25.599
<v Mitch Green>And so we're about to make— we're about to be asked to make budget decisions to renew this pot of money.

367
00:41:26.079 --> 00:41:30.539
<v Mitch Green>I really need to know that we're doing the proper oversight on this contract.

368
00:41:30.539 --> 00:41:31.199
<v Mitch Green>I think—.

369
00:41:31.199 --> 00:41:31.260
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Smith.

370
00:41:31.260 --> 00:41:31.579
<v Keelan McClymont>I think we need to make sure that we're doing the proper oversight on this contract.

371
00:41:31.577 --> 00:41:33.440
<v Mitch Green>I just read this news literally an hour ago.

372
00:41:34.099 --> 00:41:37.248
<v Mitch Green>I'm sure y'all are still trying to grok it as well.

373
00:41:37.858 --> 00:41:40.349
<v Mitch Green>I needed to raise that because that's a serious concern for me.

374
00:41:41.137 --> 00:41:41.652
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you, Councilor.

375
00:41:41.701 --> 00:41:42.440
<v Raymond C. Lee>We'll look into it.

376
00:41:42.666 --> 00:41:42.844
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

377
00:41:44.148 --> 00:41:44.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

378
00:41:45.483 --> 00:41:46.063
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Murillo.

379
00:41:47.833 --> 00:41:51.503
<v Candace Avalos>I have not read that news yet, and maybe you can forward me an article.

380
00:41:52.324 --> 00:41:53.563
<v Candace Avalos>Um, thank you, Council President.

381
00:41:53.626 --> 00:41:55.315
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, City Administrator, for your report.

382
00:41:55.862 --> 00:42:00.378
<v Candace Avalos>Um, just flagging again, and we've already discussed I asked this last time you gave a report.

383
00:42:00.539 --> 00:42:03.760
<v Candace Avalos>I wanted to look into the city's contracts with Celebrite.

384
00:42:04.065 --> 00:42:13.583
<v Candace Avalos>The police bureau has tracking and surveillance software that I wanted to look at how much those contracts cost and what exactly the scope of their work is in using those.

385
00:42:13.695 --> 00:42:18.039
<v Candace Avalos>So looking forward to getting that information, especially as we're approaching a very difficult budget cycle.

386
00:42:19.224 --> 00:42:28.632
<v Candace Avalos>The other thing that you, I think, briefly touched on, and it may have just passed me, but I wanted to get more clarity on where we're at with the detention facility update.

387
00:42:28.681 --> 00:42:28.969
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

388
00:42:29.467 --> 00:42:35.869
<v Candace Avalos>My understanding is, um, there was— so I'm reading through it and it says that there was an appeal scheduled for May 5th.

389
00:42:36.143 --> 00:42:37.795
<v Candace Avalos>The appeals process is still ongoing.

390
00:42:38.405 --> 00:42:43.300
<v Candace Avalos>Do we know what the— how the hearing went yesterday fully?

391
00:42:43.364 --> 00:42:44.873
<v Raymond C. Lee>And not yet.

392
00:42:45.034 --> 00:42:49.400
<v Raymond C. Lee>I've been asking a million questions too to get how the hearing actually went.

393
00:42:49.608 --> 00:43:08.632
<v Raymond C. Lee>Uh, we haven't heard— gotten any new information as it relates to it since there's a continuation today, I'm hoping to get an update after this continuation, if it concludes today, to kind of get an overall update of where we are and kind of the time frame they are anticipating to take on deliberation of that from the hearing officer.

394
00:43:09.278 --> 00:43:12.675
<v Candace Avalos>Um, do we know roughly how long that will take, or—.

395
00:43:12.675 --> 00:43:19.539
<v Raymond C. Lee>What they told me was a couple of weeks minimum, so that's what we have today.

396
00:43:20.086 --> 00:43:21.648
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, appreciate that.

397
00:43:21.713 --> 00:43:22.809
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks for the additional clarity.

398
00:43:26.019 --> 00:43:27.889
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, thank you, Council President.

399
00:43:29.119 --> 00:43:34.130
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I was really happy to see the action being taken to address the derelict boats on the river.

400
00:43:34.360 --> 00:43:38.630
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, also just happy to know we're offering them services, so thank you for that.

401
00:43:38.980 --> 00:43:42.710
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Sky, I, I knew that, but it was good to have you come up and say that.

402
00:43:43.059 --> 00:43:47.719
<v Sameer Kanal>We passed them every dragon boat practice, and there were quite a few until this week.

403
00:43:47.719 --> 00:43:48.960
<v Sameer Kanal>This week we only saw one.

404
00:43:48.960 --> 00:43:49.199
<v Keelan McClymont>I think we're going to have to start doing that more often.

405
00:43:49.422 --> 00:43:54.898
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm really happy to hear that you're providing safe and stable housing off the public right-of-way.

406
00:43:55.668 --> 00:44:01.273
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm also excited to see we have 11 new recruits that became firefighters and got their yellow helmets recently.

407
00:44:01.465 --> 00:44:02.155
<v Sameer Kanal>That's exciting.

408
00:44:02.750 --> 00:44:07.695
<v Sameer Kanal>And finally, I know it's always improving, but thank you for the active contracts dashboard.

409
00:44:07.744 --> 00:44:08.931
<v Sameer Kanal>It's really helpful to see that.

410
00:44:09.653 --> 00:44:10.215
<v Sameer Kanal>Appreciate it.

411
00:44:11.644 --> 00:44:12.512
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

412
00:44:15.257 --> 00:44:15.802
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

413
00:44:16.797 --> 00:44:17.842
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

414
00:44:17.985 --> 00:44:18.755
<v Sameer Kanal>Just a couple more.

415
00:44:19.269 --> 00:44:22.382
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I was hoping to, to get a little— I have 3 things.

416
00:44:22.480 --> 00:44:28.240
<v Sameer Kanal>One, one is, um, about a couple other budget notes that are marked as ongoing, no pro— no timeline specified.

417
00:44:28.914 --> 00:44:34.740
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Kanal 08, but also Mayor's proposed number 4, um, which is about overtime reduction.

418
00:44:35.030 --> 00:44:42.250
<v Sameer Kanal>I understand that the action may be ongoing, but there's, uh, a deliverable in it, and we've also received information about budget notes expiring at the end of the year.

419
00:44:42.731 --> 00:44:48.215
<v Sameer Kanal>So I want to make sure that we can get some idea of when we would receive a deliverable in the next month and a half on those.

420
00:44:48.711 --> 00:45:02.742
<v Sameer Kanal>I know in the case of, uh, Canal 8, it's designed to inform the conversation that we're having right now without the information, which is on how to reduce management bloat through consideration of changes to the director and deputy director classification series.

421
00:45:04.121 --> 00:45:08.739
<v Sameer Kanal>But is there a way to understand the timeline for the deliverables on something where the work is marked as ongoing?

422
00:45:11.525 --> 00:45:19.391
<v Raymond C. Lee>Council, I'm pretty sure we can develop something to follow back up with council as a whole of kind of what that outstanding work is and the time frame of that.

423
00:45:19.762 --> 00:45:24.599
<v Raymond C. Lee>So we can follow up in the next week or so with some kind of, uh, update on that.

424
00:45:25.021 --> 00:45:25.360
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

425
00:45:25.586 --> 00:45:26.655
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Administrator Lee.

426
00:45:27.188 --> 00:45:30.731
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, on page 23, it's line 7.

427
00:45:30.797 --> 00:45:33.018
<v Sameer Kanal>This is the, uh, the closed claims.

428
00:45:33.840 --> 00:45:43.623
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, there's a, uh, a claim that was alleging that a person was injured while sitting in the back of a PPB vehicle that is marked as claim denied.

429
00:45:44.376 --> 00:45:50.971
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'd just like to get— this is the main time we get to see this information— just try to get more information on that and why the claim was denied.

430
00:45:51.034 --> 00:45:55.960
<v Sameer Kanal>There's some things in here that are settled, and, you know, I imagine these are when a tort claim notice is filed.

431
00:45:56.025 --> 00:45:58.222
<v Sameer Kanal>And so just trying to understand what happened there.

432
00:45:58.833 --> 00:46:01.496
<v Sameer Kanal>I know that was relatively recent, just trying to get to that.

433
00:46:01.623 --> 00:46:01.945
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

434
00:46:02.588 --> 00:46:02.780
<v Sameer Kanal>Follow-up.

435
00:46:02.844 --> 00:46:03.085
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

436
00:46:04.369 --> 00:46:14.115
<v Sameer Kanal>Last thing I wanted to just say, thank you for the inclusion of Appendix F. I've been asking about this for a number of months now, and I know as soon as you came in, this was a priority for you as well.

437
00:46:15.367 --> 00:46:25.932
<v Sameer Kanal>Now, the number I'm about to say is inclusive only of contracts that cross the fiscal year, but does include the money that's already been paid out.

438
00:46:25.981 --> 00:46:30.668
<v Sameer Kanal>So if we're in year 5 of a 10-year contract, it includes the 4 years we've already paid.

439
00:46:30.750 --> 00:46:42.079
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't want to say that, but when we talk about contracts, um, there are— and, and whether or not there is a, um, a, a enough of them that there is money to be found there.

440
00:46:42.550 --> 00:46:52.590
<v Sameer Kanal>There are $8.1 billion in contracts that are noted in Appendix F. and if you go to the, the active contracts report that it links to online, you can scroll down and see it all.

441
00:46:52.590 --> 00:46:59.969
<v Sameer Kanal>Of that, $3.775 billion, with a B, dollars are remaining to be paid.

442
00:46:59.969 --> 00:47:00.949
<v Sameer Kanal>And that excludes the ones that are expiring by June 30th of this year.

443
00:47:00.949 --> 00:47:00.969
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

444
00:47:03.467 --> 00:47:05.474
<v Sameer Kanal>So some of these are perfectly legitimate.

445
00:47:05.635 --> 00:47:08.108
<v Sameer Kanal>Most of these are perfectly legitimate at the level they're at.

446
00:47:08.219 --> 00:47:09.617
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not trying to imply anything else.

447
00:47:10.708 --> 00:47:19.891
<v Sameer Kanal>I do appreciate Councilor Green's question about what looks to be the 8th or 9th biggest contract in here, which is the Urban Alchemy one.

448
00:47:20.164 --> 00:47:28.623
<v Sameer Kanal>But when we talk about this in the context of labor, when we talk about this in the context of budget, I just wanted to make sure that that number was there.

449
00:47:28.688 --> 00:47:29.411
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's a number that—.

450
00:47:29.411 --> 00:47:29.507
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

451
00:47:29.891 --> 00:47:34.913
<v Sameer Kanal>Maybe wasn't well known until this appendix was included, and now it's all out there.

452
00:47:34.960 --> 00:47:37.206
<v Sameer Kanal>So I really appreciate that, Administrator Lee.

453
00:47:37.269 --> 00:47:38.233
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

454
00:47:38.376 --> 00:47:39.195
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

455
00:47:39.659 --> 00:47:40.365
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

456
00:47:41.760 --> 00:47:43.045
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, City Administrator.

457
00:47:43.268 --> 00:47:45.963
<v Candace Avalos>I also had a question about the budget note tracker.

458
00:47:46.155 --> 00:47:54.929
<v Candace Avalos>I see that for Avalos 8, which is about protecting workers from future healthcare cuts, that was, you know, last year for this fiscal budget.

459
00:47:54.994 --> 00:47:57.913
<v Candace Avalos>But the way I'm reading it, it says factored into FY26.

460
00:47:58.121 --> 00:47:59.547
<v Candace Avalos>'26-'27 Budget process?

461
00:48:00.028 --> 00:48:02.945
<v Candace Avalos>Does that mean you're automatically planning to do that?

462
00:48:03.010 --> 00:48:09.469
<v Candace Avalos>Because I was planning on introducing another budget note to keep that going, or are you all just adopting that moving forward?

463
00:48:09.644 --> 00:48:10.686
<v Raymond C. Lee>Let's discuss that more.

464
00:48:11.327 --> 00:48:15.960
<v Raymond C. Lee>I would love to hear what you're planning on introducing, and it could be something that's incorporated into it.

465
00:48:16.697 --> 00:48:16.954
<v Talitha Mathis>But what—.

466
00:48:16.954 --> 00:48:19.646
<v Candace Avalos>I guess, what does this mean though if it says that it's factored in?

467
00:48:19.998 --> 00:48:23.958
<v Raymond C. Lee>It's factored in that we're still looking at it and it's worked into our budget currently right now.

468
00:48:24.085 --> 00:48:29.019
<v Raymond C. Lee>But if you're looking at amending anything or doing anything extra No, I wasn't looking to do anything extra.

469
00:48:29.148 --> 00:48:30.650
<v Candace Avalos>I guess maybe I was just surprised.

470
00:48:30.699 --> 00:48:36.556
<v Candace Avalos>I didn't realize that it was— you were just— so did you guys just decide to copy it into this next fiscal year?

471
00:48:36.653 --> 00:48:37.871
<v Candace Avalos>Is that what— how I'm reading this?

472
00:48:37.952 --> 00:48:41.054
<v Raymond C. Lee>I believe so, but let me verify to be 100% sure.

473
00:48:41.233 --> 00:48:41.396
<v Joel Meredith>Okay.

474
00:48:41.721 --> 00:48:45.492
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

475
00:48:47.722 --> 00:48:48.682
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, City Administrator.

476
00:48:48.764 --> 00:48:51.108
<v Jamie Dunphy>That looks like all of our— all of our questions.

477
00:48:52.710 --> 00:48:53.153
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

478
00:48:53.235 --> 00:48:55.094
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please move to the consent agenda?

479
00:48:56.994 --> 00:49:05.407
<v Keelan McClymont>Yep, and as a reminder, one item was pulled, uh, item 5, document 2026-155.

480
00:49:06.306 --> 00:49:09.697
<v Keelan McClymont>I'll call the roll on the remainder of the consent agenda.

481
00:49:10.260 --> 00:49:10.565
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

482
00:49:11.722 --> 00:49:17.302
<v Sameer Kanal>Noting that I did not pull the appointments off the consent agenda for Councilor Ryan, I vote aye.

483
00:49:18.635 --> 00:49:18.650
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

484
00:49:19.853 --> 00:49:19.902
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

485
00:49:23.822 --> 00:49:23.838
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

486
00:49:24.434 --> 00:49:24.483
<v Gary Darling>Aye.

487
00:49:25.271 --> 00:49:25.336
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

488
00:49:26.045 --> 00:49:26.173
<v Raymond C. Lee>Aye.

489
00:49:27.333 --> 00:49:27.349
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

490
00:49:27.896 --> 00:49:27.945
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

491
00:49:28.782 --> 00:49:28.798
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

492
00:49:29.264 --> 00:49:29.313
<v Joel Meredith>Aye.

493
00:49:31.036 --> 00:49:31.085
<v Raymond C. Lee>Aye.

494
00:49:33.697 --> 00:49:33.746
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

495
00:49:35.315 --> 00:49:35.362
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

496
00:49:36.059 --> 00:49:40.956
<v Keelan McClymont>The consent agenda is approved with a vote of 12 ayes.

497
00:49:41.393 --> 00:49:41.862
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

498
00:49:41.943 --> 00:49:43.521
<v Jamie Dunphy>Can we please call item number 5?

499
00:49:45.322 --> 00:50:00.420
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 5, document 2026-01, Thank you.

500
00:50:00.420 --> 00:50:02.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>This is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

501
00:50:03.980 --> 00:50:06.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we have a very, very full agenda today.

502
00:50:06.119 --> 00:50:12.880
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm not going to limit anybody's time, but I would like you to— folks, as we are asking questions just broadly throughout the day, if we could try to stick to around 5 minutes.

503
00:50:12.880 --> 00:50:12.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilmember Herbold.

504
00:50:12.909 --> 00:50:18.255
<v Jamie Dunphy>You can get in the queue as many times as you want, but I want to make sure everybody has an opportunity, and we have a hard out at 5:00 today.

505
00:50:18.351 --> 00:50:20.429
<v Jamie Dunphy>So take it away.

506
00:50:20.574 --> 00:50:20.800
<v Jamie Dunphy>Welcome.

507
00:50:22.329 --> 00:50:22.652
<v Matt Gierach>Good afternoon.

508
00:50:22.829 --> 00:50:26.596
<v Matt Gierach>I'm Matt Gierach, debt manager of the city.

509
00:50:26.724 --> 00:50:30.958
<v Matt Gierach>I'm joined by Stacy Jones, Deputy Director of FPDR.

510
00:50:31.442 --> 00:50:36.833
<v Matt Gierach>I think we had some slides to accompany the presentation.

511
00:50:37.447 --> 00:50:43.288
<v Matt Gierach>I can pull those up unless they're an attachment to the, uh, to the item.

512
00:50:45.090 --> 00:50:46.311
<v Keelan McClymont>We'll pull them up for you.

513
00:50:46.905 --> 00:50:55.278
<v Matt Gierach>Okay, so we are bringing forth this ordinance to provide short-term funding for the FPDNR fund for the beginning of next fiscal year.

514
00:50:56.197 --> 00:51:09.016
<v Matt Gierach>As background, FPDNR Tier 1 and Tier 2 benefit payments are funded on a pay-as-you-go basis, and FPDNR Tier 3 members are pre-funded through the OregonPERS System contributions.

515
00:51:10.157 --> 00:51:15.793
<v Matt Gierach>The funding source for these payments is a dedicated PD&R property tax levy per the city charter.

516
00:51:16.836 --> 00:51:19.375
<v Matt Gierach>This levy is separate from the city's general fund levy.

517
00:51:20.112 --> 00:51:28.190
<v Matt Gierach>Per city charter requirements, the city only levies enough property taxes that are needed to pay requirements of the fund in that respective fiscal year.

518
00:51:29.202 --> 00:51:35.543
<v Matt Gierach>As a result, the fund does not maintain a sizable July 1st beginning cash balance for each fiscal year.

519
00:51:36.585 --> 00:51:53.057
<v Matt Gierach>Since FPD&R property tax collections begin in late November and the fund pays benefits monthly, this results in a projected negative cash balance during the July through November timeframe, as you can see in the chart on the right, top right.

520
00:51:54.371 --> 00:51:59.869
<v Matt Gierach>To address temporary— the temporary funding deficit each fiscal year, the city issues short-term debt obligations.

521
00:51:59.932 --> 00:52:00.108
<v Matt Gierach>Thank you.

522
00:52:00.222 --> 00:52:03.329
<v Matt Gierach>To provide temporary funding during the deficit period.

523
00:52:03.909 --> 00:52:18.014
<v Matt Gierach>These short-term debt obligations are typically referred to as tax anticipation notes and are widely used by local governments around the country for this very same purpose, which is addressing timing differences between tax collections and related expenditures.

524
00:52:19.463 --> 00:52:20.344
<v Matt Gierach>Next slide, please.

525
00:52:23.824 --> 00:52:26.516
<v Matt Gierach>Uh, this next slide provides an overview of the short-term borrowing.

526
00:52:27.168 --> 00:52:31.213
<v Matt Gierach>The amount will not exceed $95 million of funds.

527
00:52:32.710 --> 00:52:42.097
<v Matt Gierach>The note will be secured by both the FPDR property tax levy and the city's full faith and credit, which includes all legally available general fund resources.

528
00:52:42.923 --> 00:52:46.958
<v Matt Gierach>However, it will be paid from the FPDR fund levy resources.

529
00:52:48.503 --> 00:52:52.045
<v Matt Gierach>The note maturity date will be June 2027.

530
00:52:52.110 --> 00:52:52.288
<v Matt Gierach>Thank you.

531
00:52:52.682 --> 00:52:54.567
<v Matt Gierach>Roughly 11 months from the date of issuance.

532
00:52:55.501 --> 00:52:59.333
<v Matt Gierach>The interest rate is estimated to be approximately 3.1%.

533
00:53:00.315 --> 00:53:12.233
<v Matt Gierach>And because the city will be able to earn interest on the borrowed funds in excess of the borrowing rates under the federal tax code, the net borrowing— the net total borrowing cost is projected to be about $300,000.

534
00:53:14.668 --> 00:53:27.516
<v Matt Gierach>With council's approval, the Public Finance Division will negotiate and issue a short-term note with one of the city's banking partners this coming July to ensure that the fund resources are sufficient.

535
00:53:29.532 --> 00:53:31.688
<v Unidentified speaker>And that concludes the presentation.

536
00:53:32.532 --> 00:53:33.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

537
00:53:34.543 --> 00:53:36.764
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, are there any technical or clarifying questions?

538
00:53:37.860 --> 00:53:38.425
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Knoll.

539
00:53:40.318 --> 00:53:43.603
<v Sameer Kanal>I mean, I think this is a technical or clarifying question.

540
00:53:43.862 --> 00:53:46.096
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you— thank you for the presentation.

541
00:53:46.144 --> 00:53:49.523
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you explain why the amount is $95 million?

542
00:53:50.692 --> 00:53:58.114
<v Sameer Kanal>Received some testimony, and it's the written testimony showing that it was $45, $38, $45, and $50 the last 4 years.

543
00:53:58.626 --> 00:54:02.570
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to understand the reason for the amount changing in a pretty significant way.

544
00:54:03.179 --> 00:54:03.916
<v Candace Avalos>Do you want me to take that?

545
00:54:04.061 --> 00:54:04.639
<v Matt Gierach>Yeah, that'd be great.

546
00:54:05.440 --> 00:54:07.539
<v Candace Avalos>So just again, for the record, I'm Stacy Jones.

547
00:54:07.603 --> 00:54:10.121
<v Candace Avalos>I'm the pension and finance manager over at FPDR.

548
00:54:10.809 --> 00:54:20.972
<v Candace Avalos>Yes, the amount is larger than it has been in the past, but I would point out that it is about 1/3 of our tax levy, and we need it to get us through about 1/3 of the fiscal year.

549
00:54:22.192 --> 00:54:24.164
<v Candace Avalos>It makes sense from that point of view.

550
00:54:24.275 --> 00:54:29.039
<v Candace Avalos>But we have a slightly smaller beginning fund balance than usual this year, so that's part of the explanation.

551
00:54:29.728 --> 00:54:36.641
<v Candace Avalos>Another part of the explanation is that we're still in the ramp-up where we are funding 2 generations of pensions simultaneously.

552
00:54:36.864 --> 00:54:40.634
<v Candace Avalos>So every year our expenses are gonna be higher, at least until the early 2030s.

553
00:54:41.596 --> 00:54:48.170
<v Candace Avalos>But the most significant reason for this one-year jump is that we are now reimbursing the general fund for PERS contributions.

554
00:54:48.235 --> 00:54:48.298
<v Candace Avalos>Yes.

555
00:54:48.572 --> 00:54:56.565
<v Candace Avalos>That our fund makes on behalf of sworn employees hired before 2007, we're making those reimbursements on a monthly instead of a quarterly basis.

556
00:54:56.773 --> 00:55:08.409
<v Candace Avalos>So it used to be that we never paid the general fund a dime until we got all of our property taxes, and now we have to make, you know, tens of millions of dollars of payments before we get our property tax receipts.

557
00:55:08.456 --> 00:55:11.362
<v Candace Avalos>But that's a good thing for the general fund, which is now earning that interest.

558
00:55:12.710 --> 00:55:28.202
<v Sameer Kanal>Just to follow up on that last piece, Does that mean that you would normally be paying Q1 or Q3 in September, and then after you get the tax receipts, you'd be paying the second with that in December, and now you're paying 4 or 5 instead of 3 months' worth?

559
00:55:28.778 --> 00:55:41.335
<v Candace Avalos>So we actually, until this past year, really never even made that Q1 payment until November because Community Safety Division didn't usually bill us until November, and they would bill us in November for July, August, and September.

560
00:55:41.929 --> 00:55:44.815
<v Candace Avalos>Sometimes they billed us in October, but almost always it was November.

561
00:55:44.878 --> 00:55:46.530
<v Candace Avalos>And by then we had enough property taxes.

562
00:55:47.188 --> 00:55:55.623
<v Candace Avalos>But now CSD, well, I guess it's not CSD anymore, Public Safety Service Area is billing us really in a really timely way at the end of every month.

563
00:55:55.784 --> 00:55:58.012
<v Candace Avalos>And we're shipping that money over to the general fund every month.

564
00:55:58.686 --> 00:56:01.909
<v Candace Avalos>So that didn't used to be part of our cash flow projection at all.

565
00:56:02.438 --> 00:56:10.907
<v Candace Avalos>And now we have that $30 million-ish in expenses that have to go out the door before we get any property tax receipts.

566
00:56:11.099 --> 00:56:12.028
<v Candace Avalos>So that is a— That's a big chunk.

567
00:56:12.286 --> 00:56:18.713
<v Candace Avalos>A legitimate process change that has just happened in the last year, and that's really beneficial for the general fund.

568
00:56:19.693 --> 00:56:19.934
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

569
00:56:19.998 --> 00:56:22.119
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's all my clarifying questions.

570
00:56:22.248 --> 00:56:23.115
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

571
00:56:23.710 --> 00:56:24.802
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

572
00:56:25.012 --> 00:56:27.342
<v Candace Avalos>I think that covered the questions I had as well.

573
00:56:27.405 --> 00:56:27.824
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

574
00:56:27.887 --> 00:56:28.081
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great.

575
00:56:28.916 --> 00:56:29.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

576
00:56:30.458 --> 00:56:31.599
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Council President.

577
00:56:31.809 --> 00:56:35.697
<v Mitch Green>Um, I wasn't going to ask a question, but then you said something that piqued my interest.

578
00:56:35.905 --> 00:56:37.978
<v Mitch Green>Um, she said we're in the ramp-up period.

579
00:56:39.197 --> 00:56:42.481
<v Mitch Green>And that ramp-up period will continue until the early 2030s.

580
00:56:42.594 --> 00:56:43.186
<v Mitch Green>Is that what I heard?

581
00:56:43.443 --> 00:56:44.949
<v Candace Avalos>That's what we're estimating right now, yes.

582
00:56:45.460 --> 00:56:47.335
<v Mitch Green>So that means there's a ramp-down?

583
00:56:47.864 --> 00:56:48.056
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

584
00:56:48.505 --> 00:56:51.869
<v Mitch Green>And when would the ramp-down be at parity of roughly today?

585
00:56:52.431 --> 00:56:53.552
<v Candace Avalos>Parity of roughly today?

586
00:56:53.632 --> 00:57:02.284
<v Candace Avalos>I'd have to pull up an analysis, which I'm not sure we have time for that now, but it would probably be, off the top of my head, 5 to 10 years after that.

587
00:57:02.699 --> 00:57:07.907
<v Candace Avalos>So right now we've pegged that date as 2033 specifically, but of course it can move around.

588
00:57:08.518 --> 00:57:14.447
<v Candace Avalos>And that'll be the moment when all of our FPDR 2 pension plan beneficiaries are retired.

589
00:57:14.833 --> 00:57:15.155
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

590
00:57:15.284 --> 00:57:18.318
<v Candace Avalos>But there hasn't been significant mortality yet in that population.

591
00:57:18.512 --> 00:57:24.284
<v Candace Avalos>And our entire sworn workforce is FPDR 3, which means they're all prefunded and we're paying their PERS contributions.

592
00:57:24.333 --> 00:57:26.418
<v Candace Avalos>So that's the moment of peak expense.

593
00:57:26.500 --> 00:57:28.184
<v Candace Avalos>We think we're gonna hit that moment in 2033-ish.

594
00:57:30.949 --> 00:57:35.018
<v Candace Avalos>And then after that, there's kind of a couple of years that are fairly level and then mortality.

595
00:57:35.228 --> 00:57:37.585
<v Candace Avalos>Starts to happen in the FPDR 2 population.

596
00:57:37.697 --> 00:57:47.077
<v Candace Avalos>So then those direct pay-as-you-go pension benefits start to fall off, and the FPDR 3 essentially remains stable because the whole workforce is now FPDR 3.

597
00:57:47.719 --> 00:57:53.972
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, there'll be wage increases and probably PERS contribution increases because those never seem to end and things like that.

598
00:57:54.213 --> 00:57:57.373
<v Candace Avalos>But we will no longer be phasing in a population.

599
00:57:57.420 --> 00:58:01.847
<v Candace Avalos>Right now, we have more and more PERS contribution folks every year because every new person we hire.

600
00:58:01.911 --> 00:58:02.054
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

601
00:58:02.552 --> 00:58:04.914
<v Candace Avalos>Is a new FPDR 3 member.

602
00:58:05.284 --> 00:58:11.438
<v Candace Avalos>And we have more and more direct pension benefits 'cause every new retiree is an FPDR 2, FPDR pension plan member.

603
00:58:12.177 --> 00:58:15.164
<v Candace Avalos>And there's not a lot of mortality in that FPDR 2 population yet.

604
00:58:15.326 --> 00:58:17.206
<v Candace Avalos>Does that answer your question?

605
00:58:17.253 --> 00:58:17.864
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, it helps.

606
00:58:17.960 --> 00:58:20.885
<v Mitch Green>And let's hope that we delay the mortality as long as possible.

607
00:58:21.012 --> 00:58:21.206
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

608
00:58:21.351 --> 00:58:23.407
<v Candace Avalos>We would never wish for mortality.

609
00:58:23.599 --> 00:58:23.920
<v Unidentified speaker>No, no.

610
00:58:24.467 --> 00:58:37.010
<v Mitch Green>I just, I wanted to make sure that I understood that because I think it's been described We've raised these questions a couple times in a couple different ways, and that this sort of period of cost is just temporary and it's going to go down.

611
00:58:37.010 --> 00:58:41.650
<v Mitch Green>But I don't— it's going to continue to go up for a few years, and it's going to stay up for a pretty long time.

612
00:58:41.730 --> 00:58:49.389
<v Mitch Green>I've looked at the actuarial charts, and so I just want to make sure the public understands that this is going to be a significant obligation for decades.

613
00:58:49.389 --> 00:58:49.909
<v Candace Avalos>Precisely.

614
00:58:49.909 --> 00:58:57.329
<v Candace Avalos>And, you know, I'm happy to come, and Peter, the city economist, would be happy to come and talk with you all in more detail about it.

615
00:58:57.329 --> 00:58:59.362
<v Candace Avalos>I know it's a topic that's That's come up several times.

616
00:59:00.101 --> 00:59:14.932
<v Candace Avalos>And, but you know, the bottom line is that this generation of taxpayers is being double burdened because they are simultaneously funding pay-as-you-go pension benefits to current retirees, and they're also pre-funding pension benefits for FPDR 3 members.

617
00:59:15.302 --> 00:59:17.981
<v Candace Avalos>So this generation of taxpayers is double burdened.

618
00:59:18.079 --> 00:59:24.226
<v Candace Avalos>They're taking, it's a rare occurrence, I think, of one generation taking a hit for a future generation.

619
00:59:25.061 --> 00:59:35.369
<v Candace Avalos>And then in future generations, Future generations of property taxpayers will have much lower bills as a consequence since council shifted to a prefunded plan in 2006 when the plan was reformed.

620
00:59:36.541 --> 00:59:37.376
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you for that.

621
00:59:37.423 --> 00:59:38.161
<v Mitch Green>That's all I have right now.

622
00:59:38.789 --> 00:59:39.574
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

623
00:59:40.313 --> 00:59:42.498
<v Jamie Dunphy>Keelan, do we have anyone signed up to testify on this item?

624
00:59:43.621 --> 00:59:48.518
<v Keelan McClymont>We had 2 people sign up, uh, George Washington and Bernie Bro.

625
00:59:58.494 --> 01:00:01.126
<v Keelan McClymont>Looks like George is joining us online.

626
01:00:10.659 --> 01:00:11.429
<v Keelan McClymont>George, can you hear us?

627
01:00:14.739 --> 01:00:15.137
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes.

628
01:00:18.925 --> 01:00:21.505
<v Keelan McClymont>George, we can't hear you if you are speaking.

629
01:00:21.865 --> 01:00:22.650
<v Keelan McClymont>We can see you.

630
01:00:22.911 --> 01:00:23.449
<v Keelan McClymont>Can you hear us?

631
01:00:25.349 --> 01:00:29.239
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, we can't hear you yet.

632
01:00:33.460 --> 01:00:39.380
<v Keelan McClymont>No, you might, you might try to call in.

633
01:00:39.721 --> 01:00:42.681
<v Keelan McClymont>There's a phone number that was provided in your invitation.

634
01:00:48.045 --> 01:00:49.483
<v Keelan McClymont>No, we still can't hear you.

635
01:01:00.688 --> 01:01:02.300
<v Keelan McClymont>No, why don't you troubleshoot?

636
01:01:02.431 --> 01:01:07.690
<v Keelan McClymont>If you want to try to call in, we'll, we'll go and see if the next testifier is available, and then we'll circle back to you.

637
01:01:07.949 --> 01:01:10.079
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, uh, Bernie Bro.

638
01:01:20.632 --> 01:01:21.827
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, we still can't hear you.

639
01:01:49.130 --> 01:01:49.927
<v Keelan McClymont>Still not working.

640
01:01:50.139 --> 01:01:50.659
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sorry.

641
01:01:51.668 --> 01:01:53.327
<v Keelan McClymont>Do you have the phone number to try to call in?

642
01:01:55.010 --> 01:01:55.221
<v Talitha Mathis>No.

643
01:01:55.838 --> 01:01:56.358
<v Talitha Mathis>Let's see.

644
01:01:59.105 --> 01:02:08.347
<v Keelan McClymont>You're welcome to submit written testimony and we can make sure that gets Yeah, apologies for technology failing us.

645
01:02:11.889 --> 01:02:12.951
<v Jamie Dunphy>He's gonna call in, he says.

646
01:02:13.244 --> 01:02:16.380
<v Jamie Dunphy>All right, wait just a second.

647
01:02:19.349 --> 01:02:20.016
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

648
01:02:20.326 --> 01:02:22.248
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, we just resent the number.

649
01:02:29.552 --> 01:02:35.193
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, as we are waiting to see if this person can call in, is there any further council discussion of this item?

650
01:02:40.271 --> 01:02:45.018
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, seeing no one, unfortunately there are technical difficulties.

651
01:02:45.065 --> 01:02:47.253
<v Jamie Dunphy>We're not going to be able to have our folks come testify.

652
01:02:47.349 --> 01:02:49.215
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are going to move this item to a second reading.

653
01:02:50.440 --> 01:02:51.902
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, sorry, Kunal, if you wanted to—.

654
01:02:51.918 --> 01:02:53.543
<v Sameer Kanal>There's further debate, right?

655
01:02:53.641 --> 01:02:54.177
<v Jamie Dunphy>I just called it.

656
01:02:54.289 --> 01:02:55.125
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm sorry.

657
01:02:55.365 --> 01:02:56.201
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor Knoll.

658
01:02:56.731 --> 01:02:56.987
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

659
01:02:57.115 --> 01:02:58.143
<v Sameer Kanal>Sound is not working.

660
01:02:58.240 --> 01:02:59.172
<v Dan Ryan>Is the sound working now?

661
01:03:00.103 --> 01:03:00.681
<v Jamie Dunphy>We just heard you.

662
01:03:00.746 --> 01:03:01.211
<v Jamie Dunphy>There you go.

663
01:03:01.387 --> 01:03:01.677
<v Jamie Dunphy>Go ahead.

664
01:03:01.789 --> 01:03:02.672
<v Sameer Kanal>There we go.

665
01:03:02.849 --> 01:03:05.356
<v Dan Ryan>Appreciate you guys spending all the time to troubleshoot with me.

666
01:03:05.403 --> 01:03:06.077
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry about that.

667
01:03:06.512 --> 01:03:07.813
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, simple human error.

668
01:03:08.038 --> 01:03:10.478
<v Dan Ryan>Um, needed to click on my bottom left corner.

669
01:03:10.543 --> 01:03:15.409
<v Dan Ryan>If this happens again, bottom left corner, uh, unmute on the actual app rather than on my picture.

670
01:03:15.458 --> 01:03:16.293
<v Dan Ryan>So appreciate your time.

671
01:03:16.806 --> 01:03:17.947
<v Dan Ryan>Okay, good afternoon everybody.

672
01:03:18.012 --> 01:03:20.532
<v Dan Ryan>Councilmen, councilwomen, my name is George Washington.

673
01:03:20.902 --> 01:03:26.405
<v Dan Ryan>Named after a real American patriot rather than the paid patriots that we see down at the Portland Ice facility.

674
01:03:26.838 --> 01:03:36.177
<v Dan Ryan>I'm here to oppose the borrowing and calling out the destructive failure of your fairy tale ideology and leadership, if you could call it leadership.

675
01:03:36.610 --> 01:03:44.168
<v Dan Ryan>You're asking to borrow up to $95 million, and we just heard testimony that, you know, it was a word salad of the excuse of why that number is so high.

676
01:03:44.713 --> 01:03:50.637
<v Dan Ryan>And also in quarter one, if you're barely paying those you know, obligations in November.

677
01:03:51.086 --> 01:03:55.166
<v Dan Ryan>If I did that as a business owner, you guys would come after us, right?

678
01:03:55.632 --> 01:03:58.797
<v Dan Ryan>Whether it's tax property, you'd put a lien on our property, stuff like that.

679
01:03:58.844 --> 01:03:59.969
<v Dan Ryan>So it's just unacceptable.

680
01:04:00.773 --> 01:04:04.643
<v Dan Ryan>You're asking to borrow $95 million for the fire and police disability retirement fund.

681
01:04:04.965 --> 01:04:13.318
<v Dan Ryan>This is taxpayer money, our money, not your money to spend like a spoiled snot-nosed brat and treat it like an ATM with your failed socialist experiments.

682
01:04:13.382 --> 01:04:14.023
<v Dan Ryan>And it's got to stop.

683
01:04:14.121 --> 01:04:16.416
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Portland doesn't have a revenue problem.

684
01:04:16.608 --> 01:04:30.748
<v Dan Ryan>We have a spending problem driven by fairy tale ideology that fund— that seeks to defund the police and our firefighters, if you will, coddles criminals and prioritizes illegal immigrants.

685
01:04:30.893 --> 01:04:49.751
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, illegal immigrants and radical leftist protesters like we see at the ICE Portland facilities, uh, in organizations like and like was mentioned earlier by someone here in this panel a minute ago, businesses are leaving the area.

686
01:04:50.521 --> 01:04:52.972
<v Dan Ryan>It's not a safe environment for businesses in general.

687
01:04:53.726 --> 01:04:55.360
<v Dan Ryan>Uh, try and keep track on time.

688
01:04:55.648 --> 01:04:57.827
<v Dan Ryan>Look at the ICE facility in Portland, for instance.

689
01:04:58.773 --> 01:05:03.773
<v Dan Ryan>It's not, it's not even mass deportations or anything crazy going on over there.

690
01:05:03.916 --> 01:05:06.432
<v Dan Ryan>It's a handful of DHS personnel doing basic work.

691
01:05:06.481 --> 01:05:06.704
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Smith.

692
01:05:06.882 --> 01:05:13.291
<v Dan Ryan>Yet the city allows violent, crime-ridden, enforcement-free zone to just manifest.

693
01:05:13.851 --> 01:05:18.594
<v Dan Ryan>And not only is it hurting the residents that might be on your side, right, they're probably super liberal.

694
01:05:18.739 --> 01:05:21.639
<v Dan Ryan>It's, it's affecting small local businesses that are closing.

695
01:05:22.086 --> 01:05:23.065
<v Dan Ryan>Violence is rapid.

696
01:05:23.690 --> 01:05:31.556
<v Dan Ryan>Residents suffer basically nonstop chaos, whether it's noise, uh, people thinking because they wear a vest they could stop traffic.

697
01:05:31.701 --> 01:05:33.014
<v Dan Ryan>It's getting insane down there.

698
01:05:33.063 --> 01:05:35.371
<v Dan Ryan>This is becoming a national It's a joke.

699
01:05:35.804 --> 01:05:37.152
<v Dan Ryan>Portland's becoming a joke.

700
01:05:37.875 --> 01:05:39.978
<v Dan Ryan>Um, and not to mention the filth.

701
01:05:40.684 --> 01:05:44.422
<v Dan Ryan>What exactly are these paid triads even protesting down there?

702
01:05:44.777 --> 01:05:46.653
<v Dan Ryan>It's an empty building that's boarded up.

703
01:05:46.702 --> 01:05:51.630
<v Dan Ryan>Someone mentioned the boarding up earlier, um, in a different thing that I was watching.

704
01:05:51.951 --> 01:05:54.277
<v Dan Ryan>It's boarded up because people are attacking the building.

705
01:05:54.342 --> 01:05:55.161
<v Dan Ryan>It looks like crap.

706
01:05:55.851 --> 01:05:59.494
<v Dan Ryan>Um, and lastly, if you don't mind, um, I'll skip through all of it.

707
01:05:59.574 --> 01:06:00.393
<v Dan Ryan>I'm gonna just go to the end.

708
01:06:00.681 --> 01:06:04.835
<v Dan Ryan>Stop stealing from the essential services to prop up the failed socialist ideology.

709
01:06:04.947 --> 01:06:08.297
<v Dan Ryan>Enforce the laws on the book to solve the improb— I'll skip this.

710
01:06:08.731 --> 01:06:09.134
<v Dan Ryan>Go to the end.

711
01:06:09.456 --> 01:06:14.856
<v Dan Ryan>I, I think that you guys need to figure out the money situation and stop trying to ask for more money and creating problems.

712
01:06:14.985 --> 01:06:19.514
<v Dan Ryan>Portland deserves a hell of a lot better than this pathetic council of radical ideologues.

713
01:06:19.900 --> 01:06:22.315
<v Dan Ryan>And stop fucking around with our money and do your damn job.

714
01:06:22.798 --> 01:06:23.523
<v Dan Ryan>Unfiltered and raw.

715
01:06:25.760 --> 01:06:26.356
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

716
01:06:28.045 --> 01:06:29.063
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

717
01:06:29.500 --> 01:06:29.838
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

718
01:06:30.210 --> 01:06:30.663
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

719
01:06:32.552 --> 01:06:33.989
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, a hard act to follow.

720
01:06:34.103 --> 01:06:43.108
<v Sameer Kanal>I can't say I had FPDR as socialist on my bingo card for today, um, but I appreciate, uh, everyone who wrote or testified in.

721
01:06:43.641 --> 01:06:48.641
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I, I did want to highlight, um, just a couple things that there are.

722
01:06:49.092 --> 01:06:52.800
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Councilor Green's question I thought was really important.

723
01:06:53.284 --> 01:06:57.402
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, about 1/3 of the city's portion of property taxes goes to FPDR right now.

724
01:06:57.498 --> 01:07:00.498
<v Sameer Kanal>That, that number will increase, but also the percentage will increase.

725
01:07:01.347 --> 01:07:04.027
<v Sameer Kanal>Somewhere in the 2030s, it'll, it'll top out.

726
01:07:04.715 --> 01:07:06.721
<v Sameer Kanal>The estimate that I've seen is close to about 40%.

727
01:07:07.827 --> 01:07:16.730
<v Sameer Kanal>And then if that's the same number of years from now until it gets back down to present levels, we're talking about 6, 7 years after that.

728
01:07:17.083 --> 01:07:22.617
<v Sameer Kanal>So it will be 2039 before the, that portion of the property tax bill declines.

729
01:07:22.681 --> 01:07:22.905
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

730
01:07:23.614 --> 01:07:26.992
<v Sameer Kanal>Right, because that's the amount of years from now till '22 or '23.

731
01:07:27.090 --> 01:07:32.880
<v Sameer Kanal>I think they also mentioned— staff mentioned that it might level for a couple years before it goes down, so we might be looking at 2040.

732
01:07:33.722 --> 01:07:43.686
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to push back on one idea here, which is the idea that we are doing something generationally towards the next generation.

733
01:07:43.815 --> 01:07:45.304
<v Sameer Kanal>It's exactly the opposite of that.

734
01:07:45.418 --> 01:07:54.900
<v Sameer Kanal>We are currently seeing this generation of taxpayers burdened because of a earlier taxpayers not pre-investing in their retirees then.

735
01:07:56.278 --> 01:07:58.297
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's the way the plan was structured.

736
01:07:58.619 --> 01:08:06.121
<v Sameer Kanal>We're actually restoring some of the generational equity here if we can find a way to alleviate some of the costs.

737
01:08:06.217 --> 01:08:16.926
<v Sameer Kanal>And I encourage everyone to read the rest of the written testimony and also the other written testimony we've had on FPDR over the years to see— and I know that the staff has also expressed some interest in pursuing this.

738
01:08:17.439 --> 01:08:20.987
<v Sameer Kanal>Related to this item, $95 million is a lot.

739
01:08:21.307 --> 01:08:24.645
<v Sameer Kanal>It is disappointing that that is not able to be borrowed from within.

740
01:08:25.319 --> 01:08:28.962
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the only thing that I would mention here that relates to this particular item.

741
01:08:29.636 --> 01:08:34.354
<v Sameer Kanal>In '22-'23 and '23-'24, we did do that.

742
01:08:34.627 --> 01:08:37.595
<v Sameer Kanal>It's only that the last 2 years we've been able to borrow from parks.

743
01:08:38.220 --> 01:08:41.686
<v Sameer Kanal>And I hope that we are able to think about that in the future.

744
01:08:41.768 --> 01:08:42.729
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the only thing that I think—.

745
01:08:42.729 --> 01:08:42.907
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Smith.

746
01:08:43.882 --> 01:08:45.090
<v Sameer Kanal>Can occur.

747
01:08:45.154 --> 01:08:46.555
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'll wrap it up there.

748
01:08:46.618 --> 01:08:47.488
<v Sameer Kanal>I know we're okay.

749
01:08:48.534 --> 01:08:49.564
<v Sameer Kanal>I guess that became a question.

750
01:08:49.886 --> 01:08:51.061
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I just wanna clarify.

751
01:08:51.126 --> 01:08:56.238
<v Unidentified speaker>So we did look at the interfund borrowing and it's actually worse.

752
01:08:56.351 --> 01:09:01.338
<v Unidentified speaker>The internal borrowing rate is higher than what we can achieve externally 'cause of the tax exemption.

753
01:09:03.399 --> 01:09:03.480
<v Unidentified speaker>So—.

754
01:09:03.512 --> 01:09:14.314
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's because interfund borrowing, we have to have, you would have to pay as the borrower the interest equivalent to what the investment income of that money would be.

755
01:09:14.682 --> 01:09:24.979
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so the investment income anticipated from Parks by not lending it to FPDR is higher than the rate you can get on the open market in private.

756
01:09:25.042 --> 01:09:25.636
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that correct?

757
01:09:25.943 --> 01:09:26.457
<v Matt Gierach>That's right.

758
01:09:27.307 --> 01:09:29.203
<v Sameer Kanal>Why was that different the last 2 years?

759
01:09:30.503 --> 01:09:34.246
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, it has to do with the way that the investment portfolio works.

760
01:09:34.680 --> 01:09:49.429
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so as investments mature in the investment portfolio, they're reinvested at current market rates, and it's just the— it's the interest rate path of which the internal treasury portfolio performs.

761
01:09:49.957 --> 01:10:02.444
<v Sameer Kanal>So some combination of investment yields for parks going up relative to the last 2 years and interest rates in the private market going down has made those lines cross.

762
01:10:02.542 --> 01:10:04.929
<v Sameer Kanal>So now it's a better deal to go to the private market, is that correct?

763
01:10:05.168 --> 01:10:05.681
<v Unidentified speaker>That's right, yeah.

764
01:10:05.778 --> 01:10:14.494
<v Unidentified speaker>So there's kind of a lag that happens between our treasury portfolio versus what happens in the market because we're buy and hold, uh, we're a buy and hold investor.

765
01:10:15.439 --> 01:10:20.583
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that answers the question that I didn't know I was asking, but appreciate you coming up to do it.

766
01:10:20.728 --> 01:10:28.868
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I do think we should have the broader conversation related to FPDR at some point soon, and maybe I'm giving myself a task as the Committee of the Whole chair to get that time scheduled.

767
01:10:29.364 --> 01:10:32.176
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, but thank Thank you much, Councilor Kanal.

768
01:10:33.583 --> 01:10:35.541
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this item now moves to second reading.

769
01:10:35.993 --> 01:10:36.916
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much for being here today.

770
01:10:38.369 --> 01:10:40.216
<v Jamie Dunphy>Please call item number 9.

771
01:10:42.176 --> 01:10:54.510
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 9, document 2026-039, amend Chronic Nuisance Property Code to address human trafficking, gun violence, and administrative challenges, amend Code Chapter 14B.

772
01:10:55.311 --> 01:10:56.016
<v Keelan McClymont>6-0.

773
01:10:57.076 --> 01:11:00.219
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, this is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

774
01:11:01.484 --> 01:11:02.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there council discussion?

775
01:11:02.768 --> 01:11:03.537
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have some.

776
01:11:03.586 --> 01:11:05.895
<v Jamie Dunphy>I put myself in the queue already, but go ahead and get in the queue.

777
01:11:05.960 --> 01:11:07.403
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I'd like to just start us off.

778
01:11:07.899 --> 01:11:11.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>First of all, colleagues, I want to thank you all.

779
01:11:12.229 --> 01:11:20.456
<v Jamie Dunphy>This book— this bill has seen a lot of work, and it is substantially better than it was every time we've seen it.

780
01:11:21.033 --> 01:11:24.176
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to get a few pieces on the legislative intent on the record.

781
01:11:25.619 --> 01:11:33.333
<v Jamie Dunphy>People in my neighborhood constantly say, and they say, I call and I complain about these properties with drug use, crime, fires, and nothing happens for years.

782
01:11:33.398 --> 01:11:39.748
<v Jamie Dunphy>And that lack of a function of— that lack is a function of capacity as well as tools.

783
01:11:39.877 --> 01:11:43.261
<v Jamie Dunphy>But from what we've heard, it does seem like a better tool would help.

784
01:11:44.127 --> 01:11:51.360
<v Jamie Dunphy>That said, this exact law was at the center of a pattern of racist enforcement against Black-owned businesses in the 2010s.

785
01:11:52.628 --> 01:11:54.636
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm hesitant to give power back to it.

786
01:11:54.813 --> 01:12:01.203
<v Jamie Dunphy>But a complaint-based nuisance code, by its very nature, has to be broader than the actual expected bad activity.

787
01:12:01.251 --> 01:12:16.182
<v Jamie Dunphy>So you— because you know you won't catch every bad thing that happens at this site, so you write the law for a large physical radius, a long timeline, and a small number of violations that— so that if you know a site has problems, you have a good chance of catching them.

788
01:12:16.230 --> 01:12:16.617
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's how it works.

789
01:12:16.744 --> 01:12:17.338
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that's a good point.

790
01:12:17.853 --> 01:12:26.154
<v Jamie Dunphy>A lot of places will be in violation of the letter of the law, but not everywhere that gets a bunch of nuisance complaints is going to be— get follow-up from PPB.

791
01:12:26.524 --> 01:12:30.136
<v Jamie Dunphy>Not every business on a 200-foot block where there are nuisance problems will get a letter.

792
01:12:31.100 --> 01:12:36.045
<v Jamie Dunphy>PPB gets to decide what they think is an adequate abatement plan and if the problems have been abated.

793
01:12:37.104 --> 01:12:42.452
<v Jamie Dunphy>And there is inherently discretion built in, and the community allows discretion to those who it trusts.

794
01:12:42.564 --> 01:12:42.676
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

795
01:12:43.623 --> 01:12:46.145
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to dig in on that abatement plan piece.

796
01:12:46.819 --> 01:12:48.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>Here's how this used to work.

797
01:12:48.199 --> 01:12:53.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>A property owner would get a letter from the Police Bureau saying you're a chronic nuisance property, write back to us telling us how you're going to fix it.

798
01:12:54.301 --> 01:13:01.399
<v Jamie Dunphy>The owner then had to write back with a plan that, quote, the chief of police or the precinct commander agrees will abate the nuisance.

799
01:13:01.622 --> 01:13:06.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>If the person fails to respond to that language, PPB could move to have the city attorney enforce.

800
01:13:06.423 --> 01:13:21.555
<v Jamie Dunphy>And in some situations, that practically meant that PPB would simply not respond to the property owner's abatement plan on the grounds that it was inadequate in the commander's eyes, then say that the owner had never responded as required by code, and then enforce a closure item after a 10-day reply clock ran out.

801
01:13:22.212 --> 01:13:24.055
<v Jamie Dunphy>That got to count as due process.

802
01:13:24.920 --> 01:13:30.032
<v Jamie Dunphy>This maneuver closed a Black-owned bar on 82nd called Seasonings back in 2011.

803
01:13:30.144 --> 01:13:35.046
<v Jamie Dunphy>Some of us remember that that became— because it turned into a federal lawsuit.

804
01:13:35.110 --> 01:13:35.158
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

805
01:13:36.216 --> 01:13:38.765
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick, you've fixed a lot of these problems.

806
01:13:39.020 --> 01:13:45.528
<v Jamie Dunphy>You gave PPB this menu of reasonable abatement options and required that they offer them to the applicant up front.

807
01:13:45.671 --> 01:13:49.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>You made it so that the owner's reply doesn't have to be deemed adequate to count as a reply.

808
01:13:50.559 --> 01:13:54.470
<v Jamie Dunphy>You gave PPB guidance to consider financial capacity when proposing abatement measures.

809
01:13:55.127 --> 01:13:55.622
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great work.

810
01:13:56.505 --> 01:14:12.456
<v Jamie Dunphy>But PPB and the owner still have to agree on a course of action within 60 days, and that means there is so Councilor Novick, can you state for me on the record that you sincerely believe Portland Police Bureau will engage in those negotiations in good faith and not solely to achieve a preordained outcome?

811
01:14:14.291 --> 01:14:21.506
<v Steve Novick>I do, and it would be helpful— I think that Assistant Chief Hughes is here to talk about, and he'd be willing to talk about how they plan to use it.

812
01:14:21.618 --> 01:14:34.097
<v Steve Novick>I also want to say that there was an amendment that Councilor Koyama Lane and I proposed To have regular annual reporting on the implementation of this, of this, of these amendments.

813
01:14:34.225 --> 01:14:37.127
<v Steve Novick>This law is amended and any equity impacts.

814
01:14:37.528 --> 01:14:38.586
<v Steve Novick>That amendment failed.

815
01:14:39.034 --> 01:14:52.162
<v Steve Novick>What I plan to do at the end of this year as CAPS chair is ask for a report from the bureau on how this law is being used, which will include any equity impacts, but also what is the— what has the back and forth been with the property owners?

816
01:14:53.301 --> 01:14:57.404
<v Steve Novick>Were they given a full and fair opportunity to develop a plan jointly.

817
01:14:58.511 --> 01:15:10.636
<v Steve Novick>And obviously last year I might not— next year I might not be CAPS chair, I might not even be here, but I would recommend that the next CAPS chair and whoever, whatever council president appoints the next CAPS chair continue that practice.

818
01:15:10.716 --> 01:15:13.380
<v Steve Novick>Every 6 months we get that kind of report.

819
01:15:13.988 --> 01:15:17.405
<v Steve Novick>And now we do have Chief Hughes here.

820
01:15:18.256 --> 01:15:19.170
<v Steve Novick>Do you have any thought?

821
01:15:19.538 --> 01:15:24.719
<v Steve Novick>Could you share with us how the department would plan or how the bureau would plan to use this tool?

822
01:15:26.597 --> 01:15:27.336
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilors.

823
01:15:27.400 --> 01:15:28.942
<v Sameer Kanal>For the record, my name is Brian Hughes.

824
01:15:29.006 --> 01:15:39.217
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm the Acting Deputy Chief of the Portland Police Bureau, and I grew up in the organization as a Neighborhood Response Team officer, so I'm very familiar with the chronic nuisance law.

825
01:15:40.100 --> 01:15:51.693
<v Sameer Kanal>I also know that it was sparingly applied during my time as a Neighborhood Response Team officer, and since it has been looked at and revised, we have not used it a whole lot.

826
01:15:51.740 --> 01:15:56.478
<v Sameer Kanal>So I really appreciate you coming back with an more an intentional approach in how the tool is used.

827
01:15:57.039 --> 01:16:00.748
<v Sameer Kanal>It was my experience that it wasn't used much back when I was a Neighborhood Response Team officer.

828
01:16:00.796 --> 01:16:18.555
<v Sameer Kanal>But going forward, based on the amendments put forth by Councilor Novick, it appears to me that there are checks and balances in place through the City Attorney's Office, and the Police Bureau is merely documenting where probable cause exists to believe a select group of offenses has occurred.

829
01:16:18.699 --> 01:16:18.957
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

830
01:16:19.328 --> 01:16:37.596
<v Sameer Kanal>And when it comes to precinct commanders working with the city on developing abatement processes, it appears to me that there are also checks and balances in place through the city attorney's office to make the ordinance more applicable.

831
01:16:38.909 --> 01:16:55.284
<v Steve Novick>Chief Hughes, actually, the revised ordinance says that it'll be the city administrator's designee who will be involved in the the discussions with the property owner, but it may be that the city administrator will designate somebody in the police bureau because that's been the past practice.

832
01:16:55.796 --> 01:17:07.582
<v Steve Novick>If it is somebody in the police bureau, do you think you can assure us that that person will engage in good faith discussions with the property owner and have a back and forth to try to achieve an abatement plan that's agreeable?

833
01:17:08.365 --> 01:17:09.704
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, I can assure you that will happen.

834
01:17:11.560 --> 01:17:11.743
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

835
01:17:11.827 --> 01:17:12.511
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

836
01:17:13.362 --> 01:17:13.971
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, AC Hughes.

837
01:17:14.631 --> 01:17:19.867
<v Jamie Dunphy>I actually— you queued me up perfectly because that is what I was trying to establish, you know.

838
01:17:20.108 --> 01:17:24.381
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I want to return very briefly to the issue of discretion and trust.

839
01:17:24.685 --> 01:17:41.064
<v Jamie Dunphy>You're right that we've fixed this in a lot of ways, but we do have to talk about trust because back in 2011, the PPB member whose discretion led to the closure of Seasonings was the commander of what was then called Drug and Vice Division, a man named Mark Krueger.

840
01:17:41.145 --> 01:17:49.615
<v Jamie Dunphy>When we make the wrong decisions about where to place trust and grant discretion, the results can define a generation of public attitudes towards police and public safety.

841
01:17:49.938 --> 01:17:51.082
<v Jamie Dunphy>The stakes are truly that high.

842
01:17:51.162 --> 01:18:07.305
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, Councilor Novick, I plan on supporting this legislation today, but I want— and I want to tell you that my support is rooted in the belief that an agency can change, that it can grow, and that it does not have to repeat its history, and that it cannot do that unless we give it the grace to try.

843
01:18:07.466 --> 01:18:18.514
<v Jamie Dunphy>So my expectation is that PPB will be very scrupulous in keeping records on how this code is utilized, will be very prompt and forthcoming in those records when this council returns to check on how this is going.

844
01:18:19.429 --> 01:18:27.634
<v Jamie Dunphy>If we have— if we have to fight PPB to get clarity on how it's using, I will be the first vote to constrain and repeal this at the earliest possible instance.

845
01:18:27.761 --> 01:18:29.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>But for today, I will be a yes.

846
01:18:29.945 --> 01:18:30.636
<v Jamie Dunphy>So thank you.

847
01:18:30.733 --> 01:18:33.543
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Councilor Avalos.

848
01:18:34.286 --> 01:18:36.641
<v Joel Meredith>Thank you.

849
01:18:36.963 --> 01:18:42.546
<v Talitha Mathis>Hmm, I don't have that same confidence you do.

850
01:18:44.460 --> 01:18:47.931
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I want to start by— and thank you, you, you don't have to stay up there.

851
01:18:48.176 --> 01:18:48.569
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

852
01:18:50.167 --> 01:18:56.877
<v Candace Avalos>I want to start by thanking the survivors, the advocates, and the community members who have continued to engage on this issue.

853
01:18:57.150 --> 01:19:05.387
<v Candace Avalos>These are really difficult and deeply personal conversations, and I really appreciate everyone who's come forward to share their perspectives and their lived experiences.

854
01:19:06.126 --> 01:19:14.395
<v Candace Avalos>And I also want to be clear that I share the urgency around addressing human trafficking, exploitation, and violence in our communities, especially in East Portland.

855
01:19:16.163 --> 01:19:24.594
<v Candace Avalos>But after several committee hearings, multiple rounds of amendments, and continued discussion, I remain concerned that the heart of this ordinance is still fundamentally the same.

856
01:19:25.212 --> 01:19:33.925
<v Candace Avalos>I don't have the same confidence in the police to not disproportionately impact the communities that I represent.

857
01:19:34.478 --> 01:19:38.555
<v Candace Avalos>And at its core, this is still an enforcement-driven, place-based approach.

858
01:19:38.912 --> 01:19:40.792
<v Candace Avalos>And for me, the central question has always been, who is the police?

859
01:19:40.858 --> 01:19:41.750
<v Candace Avalos>Councilmember Smith, I think you're on mute.

860
01:19:42.006 --> 01:19:45.073
<v Candace Avalos>Ultimately experiences the consequences of that enforcement.

861
01:19:45.699 --> 01:20:00.588
<v Candace Avalos>Because what I continue to hear from community members, including those with the lived experience that we've been hearing from at the dais, is that policies like this can push people further into the margins, into less visible and more dangerous situations, and further away from services and support.

862
01:20:01.456 --> 01:20:14.832
<v Candace Avalos>So I appreciate the amendments that were made in response to concerns raised by council and the public, and I appreciate the efforts to clarify things like the timelines and the notice procedure stands as a standards of proof and language around victims versus buyers.

863
01:20:15.265 --> 01:20:17.962
<v Candace Avalos>But respectfully, those amendments do not resolve my core concern.

864
01:20:18.380 --> 01:20:21.172
<v Candace Avalos>For me, this is not primarily a drafting problem.

865
01:20:21.284 --> 01:20:22.617
<v Candace Avalos>It is a framework problem.

866
01:20:23.274 --> 01:20:28.555
<v Candace Avalos>The question is not whether the ordinance has become slightly narrower or more procedurally refined.

867
01:20:28.828 --> 01:20:38.877
<v Candace Avalos>The question is whether this model actually reduces exploitation and trafficking, or whether it risks displacing harm while increasing vulnerability for the very people that we are saying we want to protect.

868
01:20:38.925 --> 01:20:43.702
<v Candace Avalos>Councilmember And I still have not heard convincing evidence that this approach meaningfully addresses that concern.

869
01:20:44.390 --> 01:20:56.525
<v Candace Avalos>In East Portland especially, we have to acknowledge that interactions with law enforcement can carry very real consequences for immigrant communities, communities of color, undocumented workers, tenants, and vulnerable women navigating survival.

870
01:20:57.198 --> 01:21:00.069
<v Candace Avalos>That reality has to matter in how we design policy.

871
01:21:00.662 --> 01:21:19.835
<v Candace Avalos>And I also remain concerned that we continue to default toward enforcement mechanisms in response to deeply complex social and economic conditions rather than investing more heavily in housing housing stability, victim services outreach, economic support, pathways to safety that don't depend on increased contact with enforcement systems.

872
01:21:20.363 --> 01:21:26.600
<v Candace Avalos>So at the end of the day, I believe that this ordinance risks creating unintended harm while giving the appearance of action.

873
01:21:26.953 --> 01:21:28.780
<v Candace Avalos>And for those reasons, I will not be supporting it.

874
01:21:29.101 --> 01:21:29.341
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

875
01:21:29.662 --> 01:21:30.769
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

876
01:21:31.362 --> 01:21:31.890
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Ryan.

877
01:21:32.148 --> 01:21:33.286
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

878
01:21:34.247 --> 01:21:41.832
<v Sameer Kanal>Parents, schools, neighbors are waiting and waiting for us to improve our tools ASAP to help victims of self— sex trafficking.

879
01:21:42.746 --> 01:21:51.935
<v Sameer Kanal>Mostly this action is about doing something for the voiceless, the children and youth, all gender identities who don't have the agency to advocate for themselves.

880
01:21:53.314 --> 01:21:58.750
<v Sameer Kanal>The testimony from adults who were violently abused as children and youth was the story.

881
01:21:59.823 --> 01:22:08.533
<v Sameer Kanal>The pain they have gone through, the trauma they currently manage— they were so brave to come here on Wednesday night, March 13th, To tell their truth.

882
01:22:09.707 --> 01:22:10.413
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe them.

883
01:22:11.119 --> 01:22:15.634
<v Sameer Kanal>That was some of the most courageous testimony I've experienced in my 5 and a half years on this council.

884
01:22:16.421 --> 01:22:19.617
<v Sameer Kanal>We must take action and reward their willingness to share their stories.

885
01:22:20.516 --> 01:22:21.512
<v Sameer Kanal>This action is for you.

886
01:22:22.702 --> 01:22:23.938
<v Sameer Kanal>We can and should be helping.

887
01:22:24.372 --> 01:22:27.006
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a step towards better outcomes for humanity.

888
01:22:27.905 --> 01:22:32.595
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you so much, Councilor Novick, for your patience and your persistence to get this across the finish line.

889
01:22:32.659 --> 01:22:32.868
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

890
01:22:34.118 --> 01:22:34.987
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

891
01:22:35.739 --> 01:22:36.623
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Koyama Lane.

892
01:22:40.050 --> 01:22:49.063
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciate the work that's gone into improving this ordinance and want to acknowledge Councilor Novick's responsiveness and openness to feedback.

893
01:22:49.720 --> 01:22:57.796
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I want to thank him for hearing my perspective in our private conversations and for recognizing the complexity of this issue for me.

894
01:22:58.671 --> 01:23:12.658
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>As the first and only Asian American woman on this council, I have complex feelings about policies that intersect with how Asian American women are perceived, particularly in discussions related to human trafficking.

895
01:23:13.171 --> 01:23:23.587
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And these issues carry a broader historical context, including the violence experienced by Asian American communities in the Atlanta spa shootings, for example.

896
01:23:24.146 --> 01:23:26.261
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So for these reasons, I will be voting no today.

897
01:23:26.534 --> 01:23:34.087
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand that's Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

898
01:23:34.523 --> 01:23:35.297
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

899
01:23:36.219 --> 01:23:37.414
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

900
01:23:39.640 --> 01:23:50.476
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we have before us a difficult piece of our law, and as my colleague, our Council President, shared, this is a piece of our law that has been used in terribly racist ways.

901
01:23:51.301 --> 01:23:52.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It has been abused by discriminatory police officers.

902
01:23:52.750 --> 01:23:54.914
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Disgruntled and often racist neighbors.

903
01:23:55.668 --> 01:23:58.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And because of that, it's rarely been used in recent years.

904
01:23:59.279 --> 01:24:00.162
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that's a problem.

905
01:24:01.349 --> 01:24:18.274
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>As a councilperson, a legislator, a lawmaker, I don't believe we should riddle our books with unused laws, especially when we've heard some significant concerns— significant concerns brought forward in part by youth in our community.

906
01:24:18.372 --> 01:24:29.752
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>High school students asking us to make a change, where this law could, if used appropriately, be an important tool.

907
01:24:31.523 --> 01:24:42.349
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, I appreciate the time you took listening to community members who testified, your colleagues who shared concerns, and bringing forward changes.

908
01:24:43.570 --> 01:24:44.390
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Rarely do I see.

909
01:24:44.529 --> 01:24:51.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>See our iterations outside of committee and at full council as this responsive and successful.

910
01:24:53.057 --> 01:25:07.305
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate the support from those of you who voted for the amendments that I brought forward to try to address even additional changes that I hope will help to mitigate some of the risk associated with this policy.

911
01:25:08.478 --> 01:25:15.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to specifically call out changes to the types of nuisances this code will cover following the updates.

912
01:25:16.185 --> 01:25:30.380
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to specifically call out the work to ensure that we don't criminalize victims and to support property owners in working with service providers and advocate groups as an allowable mitigation measure.

913
01:25:31.135 --> 01:25:48.672
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because in doing so, when we pass this and update the law, We can actually help to increase safety by incentivizing property owners to work with those advocate groups, which I think is exactly what we want to be doing more of.

914
01:25:50.935 --> 01:26:01.787
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When I first read this, I wasn't sure if I would be able to support it or not, and seeing the work that has gone into trying to mitigate the risks, I am willing to take the risk today in supporting it.

915
01:26:02.992 --> 01:26:29.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Part of my willingness to do that is based on hearing that I am not alone in wanting us to keep a close eye on how this is used, to make sure that we are moving forward in supporting our community members who need us to have this tool on the books and not using it in ways that thank you.

916
01:26:30.489 --> 01:26:39.766
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Allow people to abuse it, that allow people to abuse it against their neighbors, or that allow the city to use it in inappropriate ways.

917
01:26:40.921 --> 01:26:55.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Novick, I think this is work that we will be able to be proud of, and I would look to our law enforcement agents but also to the city administrator, because ultimately, Mr. City Administrator, you will decide who is in charge.

918
01:26:55.811 --> 01:27:02.926
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Of how this is implemented and enforced, to say that I hope I can stand by that statement.

919
01:27:04.470 --> 01:27:15.788
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that you work with this tool in a way that protects members of our community and provides support, and not in a way that does harm.

920
01:27:16.710 --> 01:27:17.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I look forward to voting yes.

921
01:27:18.204 --> 01:27:18.578
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

922
01:27:19.001 --> 01:27:20.479
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

923
01:27:21.131 --> 01:27:21.716
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick.

924
01:27:23.247 --> 01:27:24.355
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, fellow councilors.

925
01:27:25.592 --> 01:27:43.904
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to take this opportunity to recite some things that Esther Garrett of Safety Compass, which does crisis intervention and stabilization services for victims of trafficking, some points that she had that I got from her that I don't know if she had an opportunity to say in front of committee or the full council.

926
01:27:45.362 --> 01:27:51.635
<v Steve Novick>One is, I asked her what her response is to the question, if you drive sex trafficking out of hotels, will it happen in more dangerous places?

927
01:27:51.682 --> 01:27:51.747
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

928
01:27:52.713 --> 01:28:00.051
<v Steve Novick>And she says, I would respond that the question is built on a false pretense that there are significantly less safe places than hotels on 82nd Avenue.

929
01:28:00.806 --> 01:28:10.795
<v Steve Novick>And she said that hotels have been the scenes of homicides and stabbings, forced drug use, rape, and other types of serious crimes occurring every hour of every day.

930
01:28:11.645 --> 01:28:21.939
<v Steve Novick>I also asked her to talk about what happens when the police go out on missions, the human trafficking unit, and—.

931
01:28:21.939 --> 01:28:22.164
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

932
01:28:22.805 --> 01:28:28.381
<v Steve Novick>And some missions might be in response to reports that we get, but partly driven as a result of this law.

933
01:28:29.134 --> 01:28:34.516
<v Steve Novick>And she said, when Portland Police works missions on 82nd, they involve a Safety Compass advocate.

934
01:28:34.997 --> 01:28:37.689
<v Steve Novick>We do follow-up support with survivors they've identified in the city.

935
01:28:38.122 --> 01:28:41.326
<v Steve Novick>We work alongside PPV in person in this approximately once a week.

936
01:28:41.886 --> 01:28:44.273
<v Steve Novick>When we meet with providers, they're not cited for prostitution.

937
01:28:44.369 --> 01:28:46.900
<v Steve Novick>They're offered hotties, hand warmers, ChapSticks, toiletries.

938
01:28:47.269 --> 01:28:53.309
<v Steve Novick>And if they want a safety plan, they're offered rides to the ER or the Safe Center, detox, and emergency shelter if interested.

939
01:28:53.404 --> 01:28:53.501
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

940
01:28:54.061 --> 01:28:55.954
<v Steve Novick>Everything's survivor-centered, meaning it's at will.

941
01:28:56.292 --> 01:28:57.783
<v Steve Novick>All services are free and confidential.

942
01:28:58.233 --> 01:29:04.890
<v Steve Novick>The model was created by people with lived experience, and many organization reps are able to use that life experience to work from a peer-based perspective.

943
01:29:05.452 --> 01:29:20.417
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to raise that to address concerns that we've done our level best to address, that this ordinance will result in targeting sex workers as opposed to traffickers and sex buyers.

944
01:29:20.529 --> 01:29:20.819
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

945
01:29:26.050 --> 01:29:26.965
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

946
01:29:27.574 --> 01:29:28.039
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Green.

947
01:29:28.698 --> 01:29:31.154
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. President.

948
01:29:31.988 --> 01:29:40.076
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Novick, I think we had a conversation and I said I'm going to support your amendments to this because I think they improve the underlying, but I may not support the underlying.

949
01:29:40.829 --> 01:29:44.921
<v Mitch Green>And it will depend upon sort of the balance of what we have discussed today.

950
01:29:46.286 --> 01:29:47.586
<v Mitch Green>I can't support the underlying today.

951
01:29:47.634 --> 01:29:48.148
<v Mitch Green>I think it's a good amendment.

952
01:29:48.998 --> 01:29:58.826
<v Mitch Green>Largely because I am worried that if we address it through these sites of location, it doesn't do anything about the underlying risk to those being human trafficked.

953
01:29:59.034 --> 01:30:12.458
<v Mitch Green>Appreciate the comments that you got just now, but I put that in the context of, you know, this budget that we're about to adopt and consider cuts $320,000 from the Victim Services Unit.

954
01:30:13.487 --> 01:30:23.472
<v Mitch Green>And it's really hard for me to adopt Um, an enforcement piece that relies upon that practice to be resourced properly.

955
01:30:23.698 --> 01:30:34.752
<v Mitch Green>We're also closing precincts that offer walk-in service, all except for Central Precinct, and that's oftentimes a place for folks who feel like they need help and support to escape an abusive situation go.

956
01:30:35.287 --> 01:30:37.734
<v Mitch Green>And so I think this is going to pass.

957
01:30:38.204 --> 01:30:48.708
<v Mitch Green>So if we're going to move in this direction as a body, Then we need to resource the parts of our budget that go to address these safety concerns for those most impacted in Centennial.

958
01:30:48.756 --> 01:30:50.457
<v Mitch Green>So I just, I needed to raise that there.

959
01:30:50.987 --> 01:30:57.693
<v Mitch Green>I do appreciate your willingness to, to kind of get in the mix with all of us and adapt and be nimble on your original designs.

960
01:30:57.805 --> 01:31:01.688
<v Mitch Green>I do think it has improved the, the product from your initial conception.

961
01:31:01.880 --> 01:31:04.238
<v Mitch Green>And, um, yeah, that's, that's my piece.

962
01:31:04.367 --> 01:31:04.640
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

963
01:31:05.265 --> 01:31:06.036
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Green.

964
01:31:06.708 --> 01:31:07.222
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick.

965
01:31:08.393 --> 01:31:14.036
<v Steve Novick>I just wanted to say what I meant to say earlier, that of course this legislation is not just about sex trafficking.

966
01:31:14.100 --> 01:31:22.787
<v Steve Novick>It provides a tool that can be used in cases where there's, you know, drug trafficking or violence or other unsavory behavior in properties.

967
01:31:22.900 --> 01:31:31.235
<v Steve Novick>And the fundamental question is, do we think that property owners have some obligation to take steps to keep their properties free of crime?

968
01:31:31.780 --> 01:31:32.998
<v Steve Novick>And I think that they do.

969
01:31:33.239 --> 01:31:38.979
<v Steve Novick>I know that there's some people on this council who think that property owners have an obligation to keep their properties occupied.

970
01:31:39.027 --> 01:31:39.427
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that's a very good point.

971
01:31:40.567 --> 01:31:48.414
<v Steve Novick>And I suspect that most Portlanders would think that property owners have at least as much of an obligation to keep their properties free of crime as they do to keep them occupied.

972
01:31:50.728 --> 01:31:51.547
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

973
01:31:51.837 --> 01:31:52.385
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Knoll.

974
01:31:53.206 --> 01:31:53.608
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

975
01:31:53.689 --> 01:31:55.248
<v Sameer Kanal>I have, uh, 2 questions.

976
01:31:55.377 --> 01:31:59.117
<v Sameer Kanal>One is for the legislative intent piece, uh, to Councilor Novick.

977
01:31:59.734 --> 01:32:02.377
<v Sameer Kanal>How do you intend to measure if this has an effect?

978
01:32:02.426 --> 01:32:06.239
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm talking about metrics that aren't surveillance-based or any of the other abatements.

979
01:32:06.993 --> 01:32:11.326
<v Sameer Kanal>Beyond the surveillance ones, but if we're seeing reductions in human trafficking.

980
01:32:11.859 --> 01:32:14.203
<v Sameer Kanal>So outcomes, not outputs.

981
01:32:18.087 --> 01:32:25.220
<v Steve Novick>I think that most legislation that we pass, it's hard to say precisely what difference it made.

982
01:32:25.527 --> 01:32:32.939
<v Steve Novick>I mean, you were talking earlier about the success that we've had and Ceasefire has had in reducing gun violence.

983
01:32:33.578 --> 01:32:38.005
<v Steve Novick>And we have had a dramatic reduction in gun violence in Portland in the past few years.

984
01:32:38.440 --> 01:32:45.422
<v Steve Novick>Before that, we had a huge increase in gun violence that wildly outpaced what most of the rest of the country was seeing.

985
01:32:45.810 --> 01:32:57.106
<v Steve Novick>So there's actually no way to know whether the efforts of ceasefire and other parts of our system, which I strongly support, made the difference or if it was just a regression to the mean.

986
01:32:57.524 --> 01:33:17.431
<v Steve Novick>I don't know that we're going to see metrics that show whether Councilor Murillo's I think that in most of our cases, we're not in a position to say we will have a report that definitively proves how big a difference this made in a couple of years.

987
01:33:18.248 --> 01:33:21.152
<v Steve Novick>We can only make educated guesses as to whether something makes any difference.

988
01:33:22.257 --> 01:33:26.203
<v Sameer Kanal>Well, I appreciate that candor and that answer.

989
01:33:26.684 --> 01:33:36.805
<v Sameer Kanal>I would point out that the 3 neighborhoods that have seen the most arrests in the last 2 years, The biggest reduction in gun violence are the priority neighborhoods funded by the Byrne Justice Grant at OVP and Safe Blocks.

990
01:33:36.853 --> 01:33:43.126
<v Sameer Kanal>So in addition to the normal reduction that you see citywide, you actually do see it more where it's a focus area.

991
01:33:43.462 --> 01:33:48.693
<v Sameer Kanal>So I want to strongly push back on that narrative, but that's outside the scope of this, so we can debate it another place.

992
01:33:49.448 --> 01:33:57.902
<v Sameer Kanal>Council President, you mentioned there was an individual police officer who exercised discretion, and that resulted in the closure of the bar seasonings.

993
01:33:57.951 --> 01:33:59.057
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe you said 2011?

994
01:33:59.329 --> 01:33:59.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>I believe that's right.

995
01:34:00.997 --> 01:34:02.617
<v Sameer Kanal>The name you mentioned was Mark Krueger.

996
01:34:02.761 --> 01:34:12.716
<v Sameer Kanal>If someone was maybe, if that name rang a bell, but maybe we don't know why outside of the context of seasonings, why would that be?

997
01:34:13.020 --> 01:34:22.895
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, that was a police officer who got in trouble for having a penchant towards some Nazi paraphernalia and some other troubling racist behavior.

998
01:34:24.161 --> 01:34:31.086
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I encourage everyone to, it has only one E in it at the end there, to search the OPB article on that.

999
01:34:32.898 --> 01:34:35.801
<v Sameer Kanal>And the public display aspect of it.

1000
01:34:37.163 --> 01:34:52.529
<v Sameer Kanal>But to the underlying, and then just to actually speak to this because that's also a little bit outside the scope, I wanna say thank you to everyone who made a meaningful contribution to this policy and who has tried to make a meaningful contribution to human trafficking and other nuisance issues.

1001
01:34:53.042 --> 01:35:06.274
<v Sameer Kanal>I really do support the work of the people, the advocates on this issue, and appreciate their contributions as well as those who are speaking to related but different issues like the broader conversation around sex work, regardless of whether you and I have the same beliefs on this ordinance.

1002
01:35:06.819 --> 01:35:09.369
<v Sameer Kanal>I too recognize the problem that human trafficking exists.

1003
01:35:09.466 --> 01:35:10.797
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's very important to discuss.

1004
01:35:11.230 --> 01:35:15.000
<v Sameer Kanal>I really do want to thank Councilor Novick and his team and all the councilors who've taken part in it.

1005
01:35:15.658 --> 01:35:25.122
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick's team came into this with good faith, and I think they've been very responsive to the concerns around this that have not altered the main thrust of the document but have made improvements to it.

1006
01:35:25.538 --> 01:35:34.087
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to distinguish here between the code as it exists today before the ordinance Before this proposed action, on the one hand, and the code as this proposal seeks to change it.

1007
01:35:34.569 --> 01:35:38.402
<v Sameer Kanal>Most of my concerns with this code are actually about the current pre-ordinance code.

1008
01:35:39.155 --> 01:35:50.590
<v Sameer Kanal>But I also know that there is clearly stated legislative intent to improve the code through this ordinance with the stated intent, including as recently as today, that it be used more frequently.

1009
01:35:50.783 --> 01:35:55.914
<v Sameer Kanal>In other words, my concerns with the current pre-ordinance code are largely academic.

1010
01:35:56.796 --> 01:36:02.328
<v Sameer Kanal>But if this ordinance passes and the code is improved more often, those concerns that it does not address are not academic at all.

1011
01:36:03.435 --> 01:36:10.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick's proposal, both as it was originally put up and as it's now been amended, makes significant improvements to the pre-ordinance code.

1012
01:36:11.453 --> 01:36:17.853
<v Sameer Kanal>But for me, it's not enough, and largely because I believe this is the wrong tool to serve as the primary tool to address human trafficking.

1013
01:36:17.965 --> 01:36:32.265
<v Sameer Kanal>I proposed last June, and this council passed, A budget note that instructed the Portland Police Bureau to move overtime dollars towards a list of community needs, which we copied and pasted from PPB's budget request last year, a list that included human trafficking.

1014
01:36:32.713 --> 01:36:43.293
<v Sameer Kanal>And yet we also heard throughout the discussion on this ordinance that the human traffic team— human trafficking team testified that a couple of years ago they had overtime dollars and they do not this year.

1015
01:36:44.336 --> 01:36:52.095
<v Sameer Kanal>The impact statement for this notes that opposition was expected from motels, and we heard a lot of skepticism or opposition about the ideas that motels can be held accountable.

1016
01:36:52.175 --> 01:37:01.475
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilmember accountable for the broader human— sorry, broader social problems and crime problems like human trafficking, or the limitations of the current enforcement responses.

1017
01:37:02.293 --> 01:37:11.514
<v Sameer Kanal>At our first full council meeting on this, a woman who co-owns a motel also spoke about the risk associated with being perceived as collaborating or even simply calling law enforcement.

1018
01:37:11.561 --> 01:37:18.019
<v Sameer Kanal>She called police and was threatened for it with a gun, and requiring such an action will put more people at risk.

1019
01:37:18.551 --> 01:37:29.560
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll also note that these are the workforce and ownership, a workforce that is disproportionately people of color, a workforce that is disproportionately immigrants, noncitizens, a workforce that is disproportionately South Asian American.

1020
01:37:32.069 --> 01:37:34.734
<v Sameer Kanal>The last thing I want to mention is the guilt by association concern.

1021
01:37:35.493 --> 01:37:43.264
<v Sameer Kanal>The idea that holding people responsible for what happens 199 feet from their door, if someone has patronized your business, is a very big risk to take.

1022
01:37:43.591 --> 01:37:46.018
<v Sameer Kanal>And certainly it constitutes guilt by association.

1023
01:37:46.737 --> 01:37:52.295
<v Sameer Kanal>The idea that this code's discretion will be used to protect those people has not been borne out by recent years' evidence.

1024
01:37:52.615 --> 01:37:57.771
<v Sameer Kanal>And I recognize that some of my colleagues with different lived experiences than I have are willing to take that risk.

1025
01:37:58.301 --> 01:37:58.719
<v Sameer Kanal>I am not.

1026
01:37:59.923 --> 01:38:03.954
<v Sameer Kanal>For those reasons, I will be voting no on this, but I appreciate the work that's gone into it.

1027
01:38:04.003 --> 01:38:04.886
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1028
01:38:05.047 --> 01:38:05.914
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1029
01:38:06.349 --> 01:38:06.958
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman.

1030
01:38:08.292 --> 01:38:08.613
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1031
01:38:08.757 --> 01:38:15.791
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate the dialogue and the discussion from From all members, I think these are important points and notable.

1032
01:38:17.560 --> 01:38:29.489
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, having spent a lot of time at Multnomah County, who really led, frankly, in our human trafficking discussion and brought the city of Portland to that discussion, I feel like I've got some pretty clear eyes on this.

1033
01:38:29.601 --> 01:38:41.483
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'll just be very clear, my vote in support today makes no bounds about the idea that this will in any way reduce Anybody in terms of human trafficking.

1034
01:38:41.823 --> 01:38:54.556
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm taking a vote in support of this today because I do think that for, for unfortunate reasons, that has been the topic that has generally driven most of this discussion.

1035
01:38:54.670 --> 01:39:07.561
<v Eric Zimmerman>But the support that I've got today is all about, I think, the rights of neighbors, the rights of people who live nearby problematic areas, be them Name the item that is the nuisance.

1036
01:39:07.835 --> 01:39:19.382
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I, and I recognize that this has gone into really one lane of discussion, but when I think about the high school principal coming— I mean, how many high school principals have come?

1037
01:39:19.976 --> 01:39:20.506
<v Eric Zimmerman>Not very many.

1038
01:39:20.699 --> 01:39:22.048
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think one since we've been here.

1039
01:39:22.386 --> 01:39:31.186
<v Eric Zimmerman>High school principal comes to, to participate and, and testify in the original committee meeting about the challenges that, that his students face at McDaniel.

1040
01:39:31.283 --> 01:39:31.636
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1041
01:39:32.092 --> 01:39:33.298
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's not lost on me.

1042
01:39:34.184 --> 01:39:45.364
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not lost on me that I've had similar discussions with the principal at Lincoln about things that are completely unrelated to human trafficking, but they are definitely related to nuisance properties.

1043
01:39:47.109 --> 01:39:48.533
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'll throw one out there.

1044
01:39:48.597 --> 01:39:49.536
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not a hotel.

1045
01:39:49.713 --> 01:39:51.671
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's the McDonald's on Burnside, right?

1046
01:39:52.221 --> 01:39:54.260
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think this will help us in that fight.

1047
01:39:55.270 --> 01:39:59.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>So yes, this has gotten some attention within that, but I—.

1048
01:39:59.420 --> 01:39:59.515
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1049
01:39:59.746 --> 01:40:11.612
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have spent way too many years, been at way too many victim panels, gone to too many of the DA's John School hot washes for like, how did it go, to think that somehow this is the magic pill.

1050
01:40:11.804 --> 01:40:12.158
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's not.

1051
01:40:13.009 --> 01:40:21.551
<v Eric Zimmerman>But for those who want to be bad neighbors, this will make it harder for you to continue to be a bad neighbor, and that is worth our support today.

1052
01:40:21.840 --> 01:40:22.081
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1053
01:40:22.899 --> 01:40:23.814
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1054
01:40:24.247 --> 01:40:24.873
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Murillo.

1055
01:40:25.854 --> 01:40:27.701
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

1056
01:40:28.344 --> 01:40:47.746
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Just to help advance the record here, Mark Krueger was a police officer that instituted a Nazi shrine on Powell Butte, and then he got 2 weeks without pay as his punishment because the police union contract made it impossible to fire him.

1057
01:40:48.501 --> 01:40:53.545
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so he ended up working after being reinstated into a different unit.

1058
01:40:53.592 --> 01:40:53.704
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1059
01:40:54.042 --> 01:40:56.143
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>For a very long time until he retired.

1060
01:40:56.367 --> 01:41:03.648
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that is the reality of the systems that we are dealing with and how difficult it is to hold our police accountable when some of them overstep.

1061
01:41:04.386 --> 01:41:09.998
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Those are systems that I hope we will change together, but those are systems that are very much still intact.

1062
01:41:11.345 --> 01:41:13.301
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I really appreciate the discussion we've had.

1063
01:41:13.430 --> 01:41:15.338
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciate the amendments that came forward.

1064
01:41:15.435 --> 01:41:18.850
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I voted for some of those amendments because I do think they make things better.

1065
01:41:19.363 --> 01:41:19.908
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Smith.

1066
01:41:20.488 --> 01:42:10.101
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And it is also not lost on me that the vast majority of councilors here who are people of color, who are Black, who have different lived experiences with police, are having a different reaction to being told that we need to trust that this is just going to not harm our communities when we are not being and I think that when I hear, don't worry guys, we'll test this out, and then at the end of the year we'll get a report back and get more information on whether or not it harmed your communities, I feel like maybe that means that it needs to go back to committee and be worked on a little bit longer because there's no need to rush it through if we're not sure that it's not going to have those intended impacts.

1067
01:42:10.149 --> 01:42:10.680
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1068
01:42:11.386 --> 01:42:19.304
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I do appreciate, Councilor Zimmerman, you repeatedly saying that this is not actually going to address human trafficking, because that's the reality.

1069
01:42:19.881 --> 01:42:40.193
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Every major national organization that talks about human trafficking and who deals with these issues, the number one things that they talk about to address these problems are economic stability for victims so that they are actually able to live lives free of the power dynamics that come when you are economically disadvantaged.

1070
01:42:40.819 --> 01:42:45.460
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So because of that, I appreciate the work that's gone into this.

1071
01:42:45.636 --> 01:42:46.375
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciate that.

1072
01:42:46.519 --> 01:42:50.180
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I trust my colleagues when they say that there will be watchdogging on this later on.

1073
01:42:51.078 --> 01:42:57.085
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will also be engaging in that watchdogging, but at this time I cannot advance this forward.

1074
01:42:57.838 --> 01:43:01.452
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I am appreciative of the responsiveness of this for the most part.

1075
01:43:02.014 --> 01:43:02.350
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1076
01:43:02.414 --> 01:43:04.934
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Try that.

1077
01:43:05.083 --> 01:43:05.985
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1078
01:43:09.552 --> 01:43:14.717
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

1079
01:43:18.112 --> 01:43:18.417
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal.

1080
01:43:19.256 --> 01:43:19.481
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

1081
01:43:19.578 --> 01:43:20.673
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

1082
01:43:21.335 --> 01:43:21.382
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1083
01:43:22.140 --> 01:43:22.447
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

1084
01:43:22.784 --> 01:43:22.913
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1085
01:43:23.527 --> 01:43:24.059
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

1086
01:43:24.719 --> 01:43:24.880
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No.

1087
01:43:25.590 --> 01:43:25.849
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo.

1088
01:43:26.610 --> 01:43:26.903
<v Angelita Morillo>No.

1089
01:43:27.405 --> 01:43:27.891
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

1090
01:43:28.280 --> 01:43:28.329
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1091
01:43:29.011 --> 01:43:29.350
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

1092
01:43:29.820 --> 01:43:29.837
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1093
01:43:31.149 --> 01:43:31.327
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1094
01:43:32.765 --> 01:43:32.780
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1095
01:43:35.203 --> 01:43:35.220
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1096
01:43:35.914 --> 01:43:35.962
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1097
01:43:36.722 --> 01:43:42.877
<v Unidentified speaker>The ordinance passes with a vote of 7 ayes and 5 nos.

1098
01:43:44.680 --> 01:43:47.024
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, the time is currently 3:40.

1099
01:43:47.217 --> 01:43:53.717
<v Unidentified speaker>We have, uh, about 40 minutes left today, and we have 3 items left.

1100
01:43:53.766 --> 01:44:01.652
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just want to note that we are almost certainly not going to be able to make it to item No, we got an hour and 40 minutes.

1101
01:44:01.716 --> 01:44:03.600
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, I'm sorry, an hour and 20.

1102
01:44:04.195 --> 01:44:05.097
<v Unidentified speaker>I still don't think we're gonna have time.

1103
01:44:05.259 --> 01:44:09.170
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, regardless, yeah, my math is bad, my facts are correct.

1104
01:44:11.649 --> 01:44:17.015
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we almost certainly will not make it to the masking and, uh, law enforcement identification item.

1105
01:44:17.483 --> 01:44:20.006
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, it is my intention to put that at the top of our next meeting.

1106
01:44:21.127 --> 01:44:29.868
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I am going to give us a 10-minute restroom break, and we will be back here at 3:50, and we will move on to item 10, the arts tax.

1107
01:56:12.027 --> 01:56:14.113
<v Unidentified speaker>And we are back.

1108
01:56:14.194 --> 01:56:38.206
<v Unidentified speaker>Keelan, can we please call item number Item 10, document 2026-147, amend arts tax code to provide tax relief, promote sustainability of arts access fund, define critical terms, and respond to community and audit recommendations, amend code chapter 6.10.

1109
01:56:40.503 --> 01:56:43.175
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, this is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

1110
01:56:44.246 --> 01:56:52.515
<v Unidentified speaker>We have Christopher Hare here from Council Operations to give us a committee staff summary report, and then I'm going to turn it over to our sponsors, including myself, for some opening remarks.

1111
01:56:52.756 --> 01:56:53.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Christopher, take us away.

1112
01:56:54.377 --> 01:56:56.353
<v Christopher Hare>Good afternoon, Council President and Councilors.

1113
01:56:56.448 --> 01:57:00.448
<v Christopher Hare>For the record, Christopher Hare, Council Operations Policy Analyst, and I serve as staff to the City Life Committee.

1114
01:57:01.185 --> 01:57:09.407
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance before you, document number 2026-147, was considered in the City Life Committee on April 28th, where it was referred to Council with a recommendation it be passed.

1115
01:57:09.952 --> 01:57:16.444
<v Christopher Hare>This ordinance amends City Code Chapter 6.10 that governs the Arts Education and Access Income Tax as detailed in Exhibit A.

1116
01:57:17.246 --> 01:57:23.914
<v Christopher Hare>The amendments revise definitions to improve clarity and scope, including adding new definitions to support newly introduced code provisions.

1117
01:57:24.234 --> 01:57:43.203
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance updates allocation language by directing that 95% of Arts Education and Access tax revenues be dedicated to Portland's K through 12 students and/or underserved communities, and that 5% be distributed through grants and sponsorship to nonprofit organizations and schools providing arts programs and experiences specific yes.

1118
01:57:43.527 --> 01:57:56.637
<v Christopher Hare>It also adds a requirement that schools document any year-over-year underspending of funds received, including the school's reasons for underspending and its plans to use— plans for use of any ending fund balances.

1119
01:57:57.073 --> 01:58:23.208
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance modifies the Arts Access Fund Oversight Committee structure by reducing membership from a range of 10 to 20 members to 5 to 11 members and establishes specific representation requirements, including 2 members who are parents or guardians of Portland K-5 students not enrolled in the same school district, one member representing arts organizations with annual budgets under $1 million, one member representing arts organizations with annual budgets over $1 million, and at least one at-large member.

1120
01:58:23.818 --> 01:58:31.060
<v Christopher Hare>It further directs the mayor and city council to ensure geographic diversity and representation of underserved communities, uh, as newly defined in the chapter.

1121
01:58:31.462 --> 01:58:54.039
<v Christopher Hare>It requires the Office of Arts and Culture to provide administrative support to the ordinance adds a requirement for compliance with state income tax laws and guidance and increases the tax from $35 to $50 imposed on each city resident subject to tax under ORS Chapter 316 who is at least 18 years old.

1122
01:58:54.039 --> 01:59:01.560
<v Christopher Hare>It establishes a new exemption for taxpayers whose adjusted income does not exceed $40,000 for joint filers and $20,000 for single filers.

1123
01:59:01.560 --> 01:59:01.579
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1124
01:59:01.579 --> 01:59:01.600
<v Eric Zimmerman>Second.

1125
01:59:01.600 --> 01:59:01.619
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Second.

1126
01:59:01.932 --> 01:59:12.594
<v Christopher Hare>With these thresholds indexed to inflation using the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers, or CPI-U, or a comparable index if discontinued, along with rounding guidance for indexed amounts.

1127
01:59:12.850 --> 01:59:18.550
<v Christopher Hare>The Revenue Division is required to publish any indexing adjustments by November 15th prior to the applicable tax year.

1128
01:59:18.871 --> 01:59:37.854
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance also authorizes deductions for dependents based on federal poverty guidelines, income steps published by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, clarifies filing requirements and due dates for annual tax returns, including provisions for extensions granted by the Revenue Division, and makes additional technical amendments to ensure compliance with tax law and improve clarity.

1129
01:59:38.448 --> 01:59:43.148
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance also establishes several reporting requirements, administrative actions, and future planning efforts.

1130
01:59:43.484 --> 02:00:02.319
<v Christopher Hare>The Office of Arts and Culture must report within 30 days of the effective date on plans to reintroduce a grant funding factor prioritizing arts organizations serving K through 12 students in underserved communities, including a cap limiting any single grant to no more than 30% of the grantee's annual budget in the fiscal year 2026-27 general operating support cycle.

1131
02:00:02.993 --> 02:00:11.546
<v Christopher Hare>A report is required by September 30th, 2026 on implementation of the arts education framework and review of school district agreements to ensure appropriate use of funds.

1132
02:00:12.204 --> 02:00:26.904
<v Christopher Hare>A further report is required by September 30th, 2027 evaluating potential use of sponsorship to support arts activities not covered by general operating support, options for strengthening teaching artist programs in public schools, and associated fiscal impacts.

1133
02:00:27.640 --> 02:00:38.167
<v Christopher Hare>The Revenue Division is directed to report by December 30th, 2026 on plans to replace mailed paper tax returns with reminder postcards and to evaluate the feasibility of prepayment options for taxpayers.

1134
02:00:38.520 --> 02:00:49.479
<v Christopher Hare>By February 15th, 2028, it must report on the first year of tax collection under the updated structure and recommend any necessary code changes to support the financial stability of the Arts Access Fund.

1135
02:00:50.072 --> 02:00:53.885
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance allocates $1.15 million from the Arts Education and Access Fund.

1136
02:00:53.965 --> 02:00:54.189
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

1137
02:00:54.381 --> 02:01:06.094
<v Christopher Hare>Fund 223, in coordination with the City Budget Office, to increase the fiscal year 2026-27 Revenue Division budget and add 2, uh, 0.0 full-time equivalent positions to implement the changes.

1138
02:01:06.462 --> 02:01:23.833
<v Christopher Hare>Finally, it directs City Council, in coordination with the Office of Government Relations, to engage over a 3 to 5 year period with Oregon local governments to share information on Portland's art— Portland's art education and access tax model and explore potential pathways for broader adoption, including possible integration with state tax systems.

1139
02:01:24.347 --> 02:01:29.966
<v Christopher Hare>The full impact statements on this item includes financial and budgetary impacts, community impacts, and community involvement.

1140
02:01:30.609 --> 02:01:37.641
<v Christopher Hare>12 Individuals provided verbal testimony in committee on April 28th, and 5 people submitted written testimony prior to committee action.

1141
02:01:37.994 --> 02:01:52.253
<v Christopher Hare>General themes of testimony included concerns that the art tax is regressive, burdensome, and misaligned with its original intent, suggestions to reform including automatic low-income exemptions, Reduced penalties and consideration of a more income-linked structure.

1142
02:01:52.606 --> 02:01:57.314
<v Christopher Hare>Concerns regarding insufficient revenue, reduced grant funding, and financial strain on arts organizations.

1143
02:01:57.650 --> 02:02:04.060
<v Christopher Hare>Discussion of competitive grant processes and interest in funding allocations based on effectiveness and fiscal responsibility.

1144
02:02:04.814 --> 02:02:09.922
<v Christopher Hare>Reference to prior advocacy efforts and interest in changes to oversight and implementation processes.

1145
02:02:10.341 --> 02:02:16.765
<v Christopher Hare>Emphasis on arts access as a core component of education and community life, including the importance of representation in arts yes.

1146
02:02:17.023 --> 02:02:19.639
<v Christopher Hare>Instruction and equitable access for diverse communities.

1147
02:02:20.314 --> 02:02:28.742
<v Christopher Hare>Comparison to more robust pre-1990s arts education systems to highlight perceived declines and interest in reinvestment and long-term improvements.

1148
02:02:29.143 --> 02:02:33.269
<v Christopher Hare>Interest in having changes to the tax determined through a public vote rather than council action.

1149
02:02:33.637 --> 02:02:40.381
<v Christopher Hare>Perspectives supporting elimination of the tax and shifting responsibility to state funding for schools and voluntary donations for nonprofit support.

1150
02:02:40.685 --> 02:02:49.448
<v Christopher Hare>Positive impacts of art education, citing benefits such as improved student outcomes, engagement, confidence, and opportunities for self-expression, particularly for underserved students.

1151
02:02:49.850 --> 02:02:51.341
<v Christopher Hare>And that concludes the committee staff summary.

1152
02:02:51.454 --> 02:02:51.711
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

1153
02:02:52.096 --> 02:02:52.930
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Christopher.

1154
02:02:53.765 --> 02:03:00.615
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, just as an FYI, I've invited Revenue Bureau Director Thomas Lanham and my policy director, Evan Hoffer, here.

1155
02:03:00.680 --> 02:03:07.033
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a few things that have come up since the committee hearing that we wanna clarify, just to tell everybody that didn't— wasn't specifically asked.

1156
02:03:07.097 --> 02:03:12.118
<v Unidentified speaker>But first, I'd like to turn it over to Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, who is the chair of City Life and heard this item.

1157
02:03:13.420 --> 02:03:13.676
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1158
02:03:13.740 --> 02:03:18.011
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Would you like me to speak as a co-sponsor also at this time, or keep those 2 things separate?

1159
02:03:18.573 --> 02:03:18.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sure.

1160
02:03:19.601 --> 02:03:27.613
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, so colleagues, I think that committee staff summary, which was very thorough, covered most of the conversation that we had in committee.

1161
02:03:28.368 --> 02:03:31.659
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to speak to the policy before us just a bit though.

1162
02:03:32.462 --> 02:03:42.096
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When I spoke about this in committee, I actually brought some of my kids' artwork to talk about the real-life impacts of art education, my staff told me I could not bring the walrus back today.

1163
02:03:43.060 --> 02:03:51.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I hope that it helped to humanize the policy and expand our thinking on this a little bit more for those who were able to watch the committee deliberations.

1164
02:03:52.998 --> 02:04:05.877
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are at a time when nationally school districts are cutting critical arts programs and educators, and in Portland, though our school districts are facing significant cuts We have a built-in commitment to the arts.

1165
02:04:06.487 --> 02:04:14.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That commitment funds not just arts education, but also allows some amount of money to go to arts organizations doing important work in our community.

1166
02:04:15.318 --> 02:04:40.474
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But as we all have heard and probably experienced personally, the arts tax as it exists today is annoying to pay, annoying for low-income filers to apply for exemptions, structurally about as regressive as can be, eminently insolvent, not to mention seriously burdensome for folks who are barely making an income.

1167
02:04:41.608 --> 02:04:56.807
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This legislation makes meaningful improvements to each of these concerns, and most importantly, it raises the threshold from the absurd $1,000 a year to $20,000 or $40,000 of Oregon taxable income.

1168
02:04:57.643 --> 02:05:03.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I want to be clear that when we say Oregon taxable income, that's income after potential deductions.

1169
02:05:04.002 --> 02:05:08.240
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the number of folks who this affects is actually much more than that.

1170
02:05:09.364 --> 02:05:19.689
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The legislation makes the tax simpler by moving to a standard single and joint filing status system and getting rid of paper returns with complex income definitions and poverty worksheets.

1171
02:05:20.448 --> 02:05:27.012
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Which are frankly dehumanizing, frustrating, and confusing for people to fill out.

1172
02:05:28.010 --> 02:05:36.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you make less than the amount of Oregon taxable income, you don't have to file rather than filing only to ask for an exemption.

1173
02:05:38.743 --> 02:05:45.284
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is compelling to me that between these two changes, 41% of Portlanders will be totally exempt.

1174
02:05:45.797 --> 02:05:46.440
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>From the tax.

1175
02:05:47.743 --> 02:05:55.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And while I've heard from many people concerns that this is still a regressive tax, it is much less so after these changes.

1176
02:05:56.493 --> 02:05:58.296
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It also addresses the solvency issue.

1177
02:05:58.988 --> 02:06:08.229
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And when our council president came to me and said the arts tax will not be able to fund arts teachers in schools in just a few years, I took note.

1178
02:06:09.359 --> 02:06:20.006
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But by making a one-time back-looking inflationary adjustment and then pegging this to inflation going forward, we ensure that we can continue to support students in our communities.

1179
02:06:21.699 --> 02:06:26.551
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, the Arts Fund is far from perfect, and this ordinance does not solve all of the problems.

1180
02:06:27.229 --> 02:06:31.323
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But as with everything we do, we can't let the best be the enemy of the better.

1181
02:06:32.269 --> 02:07:01.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I hope today, as you hear from community members and learn a little little more details from our experts, that you find it compelling to support arts education for our students, to ensure that this is something that we continue to prioritize in our community, and to do so in a way that is a little less dehumanizing for our lowest income earners, a little less regressive for all payers, and that keeps pace for years to come.

1182
02:07:01.922 --> 02:07:02.099
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1183
02:07:03.198 --> 02:07:04.180
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1184
02:07:05.774 --> 02:07:12.121
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, uh, colleagues, I've been saying this for a while, but I, I have found something to be true, and I'm going to say it again.

1185
02:07:12.234 --> 02:07:16.505
<v Unidentified speaker>Portlanders love the arts, they love kids, and they hate the arts tax.

1186
02:07:19.618 --> 02:07:21.382
<v Unidentified speaker>Voters approved this tax back in 2012.

1187
02:07:21.577 --> 02:07:30.761
<v Unidentified speaker>It was the first local option non-property tax that we ever did as a city, and I got to tell you, it shows.

1188
02:07:30.939 --> 02:07:32.166
<v Unidentified speaker>This tax is a pain to pay.

1189
02:07:32.569 --> 02:07:33.908
<v Unidentified speaker>It's extraordinarily regressive.

1190
02:07:33.957 --> 02:07:42.381
<v Unidentified speaker>It's running out of money due to inflation, and it has had long-running governance issues because the city has not stepped up until recently to the plate of that governance.

1191
02:07:43.060 --> 02:07:52.846
<v Unidentified speaker>My co-sponsors and I are bringing this bill to address those 4 issues, and we're doing it within what I believe are the 4 corners of the tax that voters approved nearly 15 years ago.

1192
02:07:53.841 --> 02:07:57.340
<v Unidentified speaker>But we are massively underinvested in the arts in Portland.

1193
02:07:57.837 --> 02:08:03.948
<v Unidentified speaker>A lot of that is that we're downstream from a massively dysfunctional and underfunded state-level art funding system.

1194
02:08:05.216 --> 02:08:14.185
<v Unidentified speaker>This arts tax would have given $4 million additionally— $4 million more per year to arts organizations if it had been indexed to inflation from the beginning.

1195
02:08:15.082 --> 02:08:20.136
<v Unidentified speaker>Currently, the City of Portland is investing a total of $100,000 annually into the music industry.

1196
02:08:20.699 --> 02:08:23.029
<v Unidentified speaker>We have no citywide approach to events management.

1197
02:08:23.109 --> 02:08:26.386
<v Unidentified speaker>We have no plan for how to invest in our city-owned art spaces and menus.

1198
02:08:27.123 --> 02:08:29.421
<v Unidentified speaker>And this bill won't fix those things.

1199
02:08:30.273 --> 02:08:41.211
<v Unidentified speaker>This is here to just make sure that the hole that is— we are trying to keep the hole from getting bigger and to take the pressure off from carrying— the pressure of carrying that off of the poorest Portlanders.

1200
02:08:41.291 --> 02:08:43.411
<v Unidentified speaker>So this is the beginning, not the end.

1201
02:08:43.619 --> 02:08:44.230
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a fix.

1202
02:08:44.729 --> 02:08:45.386
<v Unidentified speaker>It is sensible.

1203
02:08:45.515 --> 02:08:47.716
<v Unidentified speaker>Straightforward, technical, and long overdue.

1204
02:08:48.293 --> 02:08:50.478
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's move it today and pass it.

1205
02:08:51.136 --> 02:08:58.234
<v Unidentified speaker>With that, I'm gonna turn it over— well, and Councilor Koyama Lane is also a co-sponsor on this, but doesn't have any opening comments.

1206
02:08:58.444 --> 02:08:59.649
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you.

1207
02:09:00.130 --> 02:09:08.385
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm gonna turn it over to my policy director, Eben Hofer, and to Revenue Division Director Thomas Lanham for a brief presentation.

1208
02:09:08.641 --> 02:09:16.869
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi folks, we'll keep this real quick on my side, just letting Revenue Director Lanham clarify some matters.

1209
02:09:18.828 --> 02:09:20.137
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll run through here.

1210
02:09:23.010 --> 02:09:23.268
<v Unidentified speaker>All right.

1211
02:09:23.364 --> 02:09:24.639
<v Unidentified speaker>So this is the arts tax.

1212
02:09:24.720 --> 02:09:26.189
<v Unidentified speaker>That is what we are already aware of.

1213
02:09:27.704 --> 02:09:31.158
<v Unidentified speaker>It has funded a lot of teachers and schools, as you see here on this slide.

1214
02:09:33.329 --> 02:09:41.000
<v Unidentified speaker>The approach to the reform here is to honor the structure and the intent of the tax as approved by voters, respond to issues, act by council ordinance, and maintain okay.

1215
02:09:41.097 --> 02:09:44.676
<v Unidentified speaker>Continuity of funding year over year from the past to the future.

1216
02:09:45.568 --> 02:09:48.694
<v Unidentified speaker>And we'll attempt to address those problems in a number of ways.

1217
02:09:52.895 --> 02:09:58.762
<v Unidentified speaker>As we understand here, the Arts Tax 101, just the basic structure, there are 3 tranches that this pays from.

1218
02:09:58.811 --> 02:10:04.594
<v Unidentified speaker>It starts with administrative costs of collection and then pays into schools and then pays into arts programs.

1219
02:10:04.706 --> 02:10:12.103
<v Unidentified speaker>Just to be clear from the committee staff that 95/5 breakdown is within the arts programs themselves.

1220
02:10:13.243 --> 02:10:15.798
<v Unidentified speaker>And we can check the text on that exactly.

1221
02:10:15.992 --> 02:10:19.494
<v Unidentified speaker>But that 95% is not oriented towards educators.

1222
02:10:20.329 --> 02:10:27.529
<v Unidentified speaker>That is sort of larger-scale arts programs that benefit the city with a focus on underserved communities.

1223
02:10:27.706 --> 02:10:31.996
<v Unidentified speaker>And then the 5 or above is programs that must target the underserved communities.

1224
02:10:32.045 --> 02:10:32.157
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1225
02:10:32.318 --> 02:10:34.206
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1226
02:10:34.463 --> 02:10:39.207
<v Unidentified speaker>Essentially what we're looking at from a solvency perspective is that receipts have been flat since 2017.

1227
02:10:40.756 --> 02:10:43.364
<v Unidentified speaker>Educator salaries have gone up and collection costs have gone up.

1228
02:10:43.528 --> 02:10:46.505
<v Unidentified speaker>That is resulting in a fundamental hole.

1229
02:10:48.282 --> 02:10:51.786
<v Unidentified speaker>The arts tax started running out of money for artists last year.

1230
02:10:52.042 --> 02:10:57.854
<v Unidentified speaker>There was a 44% cut in the last fiscal year that we backfilled in the last TAO.

1231
02:10:57.920 --> 02:11:12.934
<v Unidentified speaker>We're about 5 years out from seeing significant there have been a number of reports asking for programmatic improvements from the oversight committee as well as from the auditor's report.

1232
02:11:13.109 --> 02:11:19.442
<v Unidentified speaker>They essentially align, consider indexing, define high-quality arts education, et cetera.

1233
02:11:20.579 --> 02:11:24.027
<v Unidentified speaker>And those things are addressed here as follows in front of you.

1234
02:11:24.811 --> 02:11:25.902
<v Unidentified speaker>And now let me turn it over to Thomas.

1235
02:11:25.951 --> 02:11:26.382
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1236
02:11:27.239 --> 02:11:28.739
<v Thomas Lanham>Good afternoon, Council.

1237
02:11:28.739 --> 02:11:29.560
<v Thomas Lanham>I'm Thomas Lanham.

1238
02:11:29.560 --> 02:11:30.829
<v Thomas Lanham>I'm the Revenue Division Director.

1239
02:11:31.840 --> 02:11:35.560
<v Thomas Lanham>Uh, I'm going to speak to about 4 or 5 different topics very briefly.

1240
02:11:35.560 --> 02:11:38.539
<v Thomas Lanham>I just want to touch upon the definition of income.

1241
02:11:38.539 --> 02:11:41.239
<v Thomas Lanham>That's a fundamental shift that's occurring with this change.

1242
02:11:41.539 --> 02:11:52.659
<v Thomas Lanham>I think everyone can understand that the fixed rate going from 35% to 50% is pretty straightforward, that the threshold of $1,000 to $20,000 or $40,000 for joint filers is straightforward.

1243
02:11:52.659 --> 02:12:09.934
<v Thomas Lanham>But I want to walk through a couple of slides on talk briefly about the directives that are in the ordinance, discuss briefly the criticism about the difficulty paying the tax, and then finally touch on the revenue forecast and the ending fund balance.

1244
02:12:10.913 --> 02:12:18.554
<v Thomas Lanham>So this slide, just the basic takeaway from this slide is that we are currently using 2 definitions of income.

1245
02:12:19.020 --> 02:12:25.136
<v Thomas Lanham>One is essentially a gross income feature, all income that is taxable legally in the state of Oregon.

1246
02:12:25.184 --> 02:12:25.664
<v Thomas Lanham>And the other is taxable income.

1247
02:12:26.323 --> 02:12:27.412
<v Thomas Lanham>Without deductions.

1248
02:12:27.622 --> 02:12:35.381
<v Thomas Lanham>So when we say $1,000 of income in the current structure, that means every— essentially every form of taxable income.

1249
02:12:35.943 --> 02:12:39.261
<v Thomas Lanham>It doesn't include Social Security, but virtually everything else.

1250
02:12:40.112 --> 02:12:59.877
<v Thomas Lanham>In the new world, when we— if this is passed under using Oregon taxable income, there will be numerous deductions and exemptions so that, as you see in a future table, $20,000 of taxable Oregon taxable income is more than 20 times the $1,000 threshold now, if you will.

1251
02:13:01.287 --> 02:13:20.914
<v Thomas Lanham>So these multiple income definitions also include the family poverty exemption that exists and has been stated earlier, requiring people to actually affirmatively complete a form declaring that they're exempt and including information about those that are in their household.

1252
02:13:20.979 --> 02:13:22.788
<v Thomas Lanham>We're moving away from that with these changes.

1253
02:13:22.837 --> 02:13:22.965
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1254
02:13:23.609 --> 02:13:30.725
<v Thomas Lanham>And only people that actually have Oregon taxable income above those thresholds would be required to file and pay.

1255
02:13:31.371 --> 02:13:42.738
<v Thomas Lanham>So what's broken about the current tax is you might not have a federal or state filing requirement, but under the current arts tax, you actually do if you earn $1,000 of income.

1256
02:13:42.899 --> 02:13:44.470
<v Thomas Lanham>Let's go to the next slide.

1257
02:13:46.481 --> 02:13:52.238
<v Thomas Lanham>So as I just said, $1,000 of income, you must pay unless you're in a household with a poverty exemption.

1258
02:13:52.927 --> 02:13:57.500
<v Thomas Lanham>So some examples on this slide, seniors on limited or fixed income generally must pay.

1259
02:13:58.365 --> 02:14:04.125
<v Thomas Lanham>These are these 1 to 4 person household figures are— that's the actual poverty guideline.

1260
02:14:04.783 --> 02:14:09.371
<v Thomas Lanham>And just would note that Oregon minimum wage is $33,904.

1261
02:14:09.451 --> 02:14:10.797
<v Thomas Lanham>It's $16.30 an hour.

1262
02:14:11.198 --> 02:14:12.722
<v Thomas Lanham>That's the annualized rate.

1263
02:14:13.060 --> 02:14:19.349
<v Thomas Lanham>So someone below minimum wage is actually currently required to file and pay even with the poverty exemption.

1264
02:14:19.412 --> 02:14:19.604
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1265
02:14:20.567 --> 02:14:29.961
<v Thomas Lanham>Uh, and so moving to this Oregon taxable income concept will provide broad-based relief to over 200,000 taxpayers from having to pay this tax.

1266
02:14:30.907 --> 02:14:31.612
<v Thomas Lanham>Next slide, please.

1267
02:14:33.070 --> 02:14:38.649
<v Thomas Lanham>So the first table here on this slide just shows the number of people that are currently expected to file.

1268
02:14:39.194 --> 02:14:41.310
<v Thomas Lanham>It's over 532,000.

1269
02:14:41.358 --> 02:14:51.793
<v Thomas Lanham>It's every adult 18 and over, period, in, or in Portland, uh, whether they're exempt or whether they owe, they're expected to file under the current structure.

1270
02:14:52.788 --> 02:14:58.456
<v Thomas Lanham>Into the new structure, that number of expected filers drops to 318,000.

1271
02:14:58.503 --> 02:15:07.750
<v Thomas Lanham>And so that's your difference of 214,000 people that no longer have any obligation to the City of Portland under this tax.

1272
02:15:07.814 --> 02:15:13.224
<v Thomas Lanham>And I'll say that again, they don't need to do anything, don't need to file, don't need to pay, no exemption.

1273
02:15:13.351 --> 02:15:19.146
<v Thomas Lanham>We handle all that administratively on the back end using Oregon taxpayer data provided by the Oregon Department of Revenue.

1274
02:15:20.318 --> 02:15:23.588
<v Thomas Lanham>The second table shows the reduction in the number of payers.

1275
02:15:24.118 --> 02:15:33.145
<v Thomas Lanham>So you can see in the, the third from the right column, the reduction in payers is about 147,000 people would no longer have to pay.

1276
02:15:33.643 --> 02:15:37.460
<v Thomas Lanham>That number is a subset of the 214,000 mentioned above.

1277
02:15:37.555 --> 02:15:39.944
<v Thomas Lanham>Let's go to the next slide, please.

1278
02:15:41.323 --> 02:15:42.270
<v Thomas Lanham>Very busy slide.

1279
02:15:42.462 --> 02:16:05.140
<v Thomas Lanham>All I wanted to do on this slide is highlight for you 3 examples of taxpayers and I go through again the, the concept that $20,000 of Oregon taxable income is— doesn't sound like a lot until you realize that to get to that OTI number, you've already subtracted a lot of income, a lot of deductions or exclusions to income.

1280
02:16:05.685 --> 02:16:12.078
<v Thomas Lanham>So in the 3rd example on the far right, you've actually got $60,000, almost $64,000 of income.

1281
02:16:12.742 --> 02:16:22.055
<v Thomas Lanham>From a pair of joint filers, after some very reasonable deductions and exclusions, they're actually at $38,500 in that example.

1282
02:16:22.103 --> 02:16:24.208
<v Thomas Lanham>They would not pay this tax.

1283
02:16:25.278 --> 02:16:26.234
<v Thomas Lanham>Let's go to the next slide.

1284
02:16:28.140 --> 02:16:37.237
<v Thomas Lanham>There are 3 directives in the— in this ordinance, one of which is that the Revenue Division will report back regarding the transitioning from mailing tax returns.

1285
02:16:37.945 --> 02:16:42.104
<v Thomas Lanham>To postcards and the feasibility of prepayment options for taxpayers.

1286
02:16:42.298 --> 02:16:45.027
<v Thomas Lanham>We'll talk a little bit about prepayment options in a minute.

1287
02:16:45.909 --> 02:16:48.528
<v Thomas Lanham>As to postcards, we did try that in 2014.

1288
02:16:49.281 --> 02:16:52.284
<v Thomas Lanham>I can't call it a success then, but the world has moved on.

1289
02:16:53.136 --> 02:17:05.675
<v Thomas Lanham>We may be able to put a QR code on postcards and, and try to make it easier for people and reduce that actual mailing out of tax returns to individual households, which encourages people, by the way, to reply back in paper.

1290
02:17:05.724 --> 02:17:05.900
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1291
02:17:07.327 --> 02:17:17.495
<v Thomas Lanham>Also to work with the Office of Arts and Culture to create a reserve policy, and finally to report back to council by February of 2028 about the first year of collections.

1292
02:17:17.929 --> 02:17:27.134
<v Thomas Lanham>The reason that's so far out is the changes before you now would actually impact tax year 2026 that we're in now, which is due in April of '27.

1293
02:17:27.630 --> 02:17:31.623
<v Thomas Lanham>We then receive data from the Oregon Department of Revenue for the balance of '27.

1294
02:17:31.672 --> 02:17:31.897
<v Thomas Lanham>Thank you.

1295
02:17:32.442 --> 02:17:33.510
<v Thomas Lanham>And do some enforcement work.

1296
02:17:33.590 --> 02:17:39.325
<v Thomas Lanham>So we won't really know until the first quarter of '28 how we did for tax year 2026.

1297
02:17:40.569 --> 02:17:41.296
<v Thomas Lanham>Next slide, please.

1298
02:17:43.655 --> 02:17:46.981
<v Thomas Lanham>Uh, just a few things about paying the arts tax.

1299
02:17:47.370 --> 02:17:53.127
<v Thomas Lanham>I think there's been a lot of statements made, uh, there's a lot of different ways to look at whether it's easy or hard to pay.

1300
02:17:53.693 --> 02:17:54.778
<v Thomas Lanham>This is just some data.

1301
02:17:55.377 --> 02:17:57.869
<v Thomas Lanham>78% Of arts taxpayers pay electronically.

1302
02:17:57.959 --> 02:18:07.030
<v Thomas Lanham>Electronically using either products like TurboTax or online on the Portland Revenue Online platform that we have implemented.

1303
02:18:07.766 --> 02:18:13.537
<v Thomas Lanham>It takes the average logged-in taxpayer 54 seconds to pay their arts tax.

1304
02:18:14.337 --> 02:18:18.808
<v Thomas Lanham>By logged in, I mean they're— they have an account on our platform.

1305
02:18:19.306 --> 02:18:28.537
<v Thomas Lanham>They've already populated their name, their address, their Social Security number, and other basic information, including ACH payment information, which is captured and maintained.

1306
02:18:29.082 --> 02:18:29.724
<v Thomas Lanham>In the system.

1307
02:18:30.059 --> 02:18:40.849
<v Thomas Lanham>So the point being, for the, for the 65,000 Portlanders that actually set up a pro account, an Arts Tax account, the payment experience is very straightforward, very simple.

1308
02:18:41.425 --> 02:18:45.641
<v Thomas Lanham>Those that don't have an account need to spend a few minutes entering information.

1309
02:18:46.138 --> 02:18:49.569
<v Thomas Lanham>That's a 5-minute— takes about 5 minutes to do that on average.

1310
02:18:50.403 --> 02:18:56.064
<v Thomas Lanham>In 2022, we had a consultant review top to bottom our payment experience for For taxpayers.

1311
02:18:56.255 --> 02:18:59.514
<v Thomas Lanham>They made some recommendations, and those recommendations were all implemented.

1312
02:19:00.414 --> 02:19:06.948
<v Thomas Lanham>Finally, like, unlike other income taxes, there is no credit card, quote, convenience fee for paying the arts tax.

1313
02:19:07.397 --> 02:19:16.242
<v Thomas Lanham>This is the entity or the agency's effort to recover merchant fees, bank card fees that are charged for using bank cards.

1314
02:19:16.885 --> 02:19:25.790
<v Thomas Lanham>We don't charge that on the arts tax, so that's the only income tax you'll ever see that I'm aware of in the country that doesn't charge a convenience fee.

1315
02:19:26.255 --> 02:19:30.441
<v Thomas Lanham>So it's not perfect, but I just wanted to lay out some data about the payment experience.

1316
02:19:31.885 --> 02:19:41.188
<v Thomas Lanham>Again, here you can just see that all of the ways that you can pay the city arts tax are replicated across the Oregon Department of Revenue and the IRS.

1317
02:19:41.894 --> 02:19:46.640
<v Thomas Lanham>So there are no differences there except prepayments, which you are directing us to go take a look at.

1318
02:19:47.602 --> 02:19:49.608
<v Thomas Lanham>There are a lot of pros and cons to prepayments.

1319
02:19:49.688 --> 02:19:50.699
<v Thomas Lanham>I won't get into that.

1320
02:19:51.131 --> 02:19:54.819
<v Thomas Lanham>Into that today, but we'll bring a report forward about, about that later.

1321
02:19:55.301 --> 02:19:56.665
<v Thomas Lanham>Let's go to the next slide.

1322
02:19:56.745 --> 02:20:03.448
<v Thomas Lanham>Okay, uh, and so again, all income taxes have a separate freestanding tax return.

1323
02:20:03.545 --> 02:20:06.046
<v Thomas Lanham>The reason for that is they're often structured differently.

1324
02:20:06.608 --> 02:20:15.283
<v Thomas Lanham>Combining them all onto a single unified statement or, or return, while that sounds intriguing, sounds like a good idea, it can be problematic.

1325
02:20:16.054 --> 02:20:27.414
<v Thomas Lanham>There are experiences that people can have using, again, third-party products like TurboTax, which have a wizard kind of environment that help to make it feel like you're not really doing 3 tax returns.

1326
02:20:27.933 --> 02:20:30.337
<v Thomas Lanham>But in the end, you'd still have to do 3 tax returns.

1327
02:20:30.386 --> 02:20:31.734
<v Thomas Lanham>That's what's happening in the background.

1328
02:20:33.649 --> 02:20:37.897
<v Thomas Lanham>So it's been suggested that it should be combined with other income tax forms.

1329
02:20:38.123 --> 02:20:41.855
<v Thomas Lanham>I get it, we would love to be able to do that, but there are some complexities there.

1330
02:20:42.559 --> 02:20:48.533
<v Thomas Lanham>The Oregon Department of Revenue has turned down our request to have this it's placed on the Oregon Form 40 on multiple occasions.

1331
02:20:49.351 --> 02:21:00.918
<v Thomas Lanham>The supportive housing services and preschool for all taxes that we also collect in the revenue division, only 14% of our taxpayers have to file those taxes because they have a much higher income threshold.

1332
02:21:01.879 --> 02:21:08.256
<v Thomas Lanham>So there's a trade-off in asking people to wade through portions of a tax return that don't apply to them.

1333
02:21:09.090 --> 02:21:14.617
<v Thomas Lanham>So again, I'll just stop there, but there, there are trade-offs in terms of confusing potentially taxpayers.

1334
02:21:14.986 --> 02:21:21.743
<v Thomas Lanham>Who currently only have to file one return might now have to go through essentially 3 returns combined into one.

1335
02:21:23.486 --> 02:21:28.947
<v Thomas Lanham>I think the filing reminders are probably another thing that stands out about this tax compared to others.

1336
02:21:29.059 --> 02:21:31.879
<v Thomas Lanham>We do do an annual all-household mailer.

1337
02:21:32.861 --> 02:21:36.620
<v Thomas Lanham>The reason that we do this is because this tax is unique.

1338
02:21:37.136 --> 02:21:38.180
<v Thomas Lanham>It's easy to forget.

1339
02:21:38.870 --> 02:21:40.541
<v Thomas Lanham>It's not like other taxes.

1340
02:21:40.670 --> 02:21:42.228
<v Thomas Lanham>It doesn't feel like other taxes.

1341
02:21:42.531 --> 02:21:52.163
<v Thomas Lanham>But in fact, mechanically it is like other taxes, but that fixed $35 or maybe, maybe in the future $50 assessment can feel very different.

1342
02:21:53.046 --> 02:22:00.430
<v Thomas Lanham>And so we found that if we don't do some kind of physical reminder every year, we have lower compliance, substantially lower compliance.

1343
02:22:00.541 --> 02:22:02.244
<v Thomas Lanham>Let's go to the next slide.

1344
02:22:02.997 --> 02:22:04.475
<v Thomas Lanham>Only a few more slides and we'll be done.

1345
02:22:05.469 --> 02:22:10.045
<v Thomas Lanham>So I just want to talk briefly about the revenue forecast.

1346
02:22:10.221 --> 02:22:13.475
<v Thomas Lanham>We have put together a forecast for the revenues.

1347
02:22:13.586 --> 02:22:23.009
<v Thomas Lanham>We do anticipate that tax year '26 will essentially be revenue neutral to the current tax year, or the previous tax year, tax year '25.

1348
02:22:23.120 --> 02:22:30.106
<v Thomas Lanham>That is to say, there are hundreds of thousands, over 100,000 people no longer paying, but those that remain pay more.

1349
02:22:30.811 --> 02:22:47.827
<v Thomas Lanham>And so we've designed this to try to track inflation from 2012 to land in a spot which is essentially Revenue neutral today, and then indexes going forward, indexes the threshold, indexes the rate as well.

1350
02:22:48.278 --> 02:22:58.295
<v Thomas Lanham>So there won't be bracket creep where slowly over time people that— I guess what I would like to say is that in the future it won't be $20,000, it might be $22,500 or $25,000.

1351
02:22:58.376 --> 02:22:59.575
<v Thomas Lanham>It will slowly go up.

1352
02:23:00.629 --> 02:23:02.154
<v Thomas Lanham>Let's go to the next slide.

1353
02:23:04.259 --> 02:23:09.165
<v Thomas Lanham>So there's been a lot of discussion, I think, in the community and the media about the arts tax fund balance.

1354
02:23:09.870 --> 02:23:15.708
<v Thomas Lanham>Just briefly, this is a model of what the fund balance looks like over a 5-year timeline.

1355
02:23:16.300 --> 02:23:22.120
<v Thomas Lanham>The red dashed line at the bottom would be the fund having a zero balance in that moment of time.

1356
02:23:23.179 --> 02:23:32.257
<v Thomas Lanham>The black stars on the graph indicate the moment in time when the city's annual comprehensive financial report snapshot is taken.

1357
02:23:32.739 --> 02:23:40.726
<v Thomas Lanham>So at that moment in time, it just so happens that that is just a month and a half or so after our tax filing deadline.

1358
02:23:41.416 --> 02:23:50.060
<v Thomas Lanham>And so obviously we've collected the bulk of the taxes and we're sitting on what looks like a pile of stagnant cash over 5 years.

1359
02:23:50.656 --> 02:23:56.601
<v Thomas Lanham>If you look back in the annual comprehensive financial report, it always looks like we have between 8 and 9.5 or so.

1360
02:23:57.083 --> 02:24:01.514
<v Thomas Lanham>Million, but as you can see here, that balance is actually quite dynamic.

1361
02:24:01.578 --> 02:24:06.590
<v Thomas Lanham>We spend it down in the fall and winter, and then we collect it in the spring, and so on.

1362
02:24:06.638 --> 02:24:08.050
<v Thomas Lanham>That's how the cycle has gone.

1363
02:24:08.725 --> 02:24:14.458
<v Thomas Lanham>So we're spending the previous fiscal year's arts tax dollars in the current fiscal year.

1364
02:24:15.148 --> 02:24:18.006
<v Thomas Lanham>This has been a very conservative approach.

1365
02:24:18.504 --> 02:24:19.853
<v Thomas Lanham>It's an appropriate approach.

1366
02:24:20.448 --> 02:24:23.852
<v Thomas Lanham>It's a best practice approach, but we may have another option that we can—.

1367
02:24:23.852 --> 02:24:23.965
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1368
02:24:24.210 --> 02:24:25.363
<v Thomas Lanham>We can exercise.

1369
02:24:26.430 --> 02:24:27.292
<v Thomas Lanham>Let's go to the next slide.

1370
02:24:28.930 --> 02:24:38.733
<v Thomas Lanham>This is what that same chart looks like if we allow ourselves to spend down one time about $3.5 million of that projected ending fund balance.

1371
02:24:39.379 --> 02:24:46.358
<v Thomas Lanham>The fund is in a deficit position temporarily during right around the middle of the fiscal year before it should recover.

1372
02:24:47.373 --> 02:24:50.648
<v Thomas Lanham>We've seen some pretty stable revenues over the years.

1373
02:24:50.762 --> 02:25:00.456
<v Thomas Lanham>I don't anticipate that we're going to have a year where We're unable to snap back to get to a positive cash position by year-end, which is required by state budget law.

1374
02:25:01.343 --> 02:25:16.441
<v Thomas Lanham>So this is a framework that we can use essentially to bridge to the— until we get to inflation-adjusted dollars, trying to hold— make sure that we're able to continue to distribute some money to arts organizations.

1375
02:25:16.572 --> 02:25:26.688
<v Unidentified speaker>And and we'll be available to answer questions, but I think we can call it good at that.

1376
02:25:26.800 --> 02:25:27.879
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much for your time.

1377
02:25:28.408 --> 02:25:29.439
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you both for your presentation.

1378
02:25:30.260 --> 02:25:33.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, are there technical or clarifying questions before we move to public testimony?

1379
02:25:33.986 --> 02:25:34.615
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Avalos?

1380
02:25:37.551 --> 02:25:38.084
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Green?

1381
02:25:39.326 --> 02:25:41.002
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you, Director Lanham.

1382
02:25:42.352 --> 02:25:47.340
<v Mitch Green>Um, so what would be the case for allowing it to go Why would we do that relative to the current practices?

1383
02:25:47.436 --> 02:25:50.199
<v Mitch Green>Is it just so the public sees us spending more money earlier?

1384
02:25:51.146 --> 02:25:54.453
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, so we did have a dramatic cliff that we experienced last year.

1385
02:25:54.599 --> 02:26:03.478
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the disbursements to the Arts and Culture Office dropped from about $3.5 on average in the preceding years to around $2.1 or $2.2 million.

1386
02:26:04.780 --> 02:26:18.041
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we can use this as a tool to kind of bridge that, to try to hold a $3.5 million line Until such time as the inflation-adjusted dollars begin showing up.

1387
02:26:18.683 --> 02:26:22.391
<v Unidentified speaker>So we may be able to use it as a shock absorber as a matter of policy.

1388
02:26:22.841 --> 02:26:23.835
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's helpful.

1389
02:26:23.932 --> 02:26:24.220
<v Mitch Green>Thanks.

1390
02:26:25.424 --> 02:26:26.114
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1391
02:26:26.227 --> 02:26:26.870
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick.

1392
02:26:28.138 --> 02:26:28.956
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1393
02:26:30.400 --> 02:26:47.463
<v Steve Novick>I think that a lot of people might be confused thinking, wait a minute, I think the median family income, median household income in Portland is something like $90,000 how can 41% of families be making less than $40,000 even without— even after deductions?

1394
02:26:47.960 --> 02:26:49.951
<v Steve Novick>Can you just address that for a bit?

1395
02:26:50.306 --> 02:26:51.284
<v Steve Novick>And how can that be possible?

1396
02:26:51.430 --> 02:26:55.764
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I mean, medians and means and modes, there's different ways of chopping and slicing data.

1397
02:26:56.584 --> 02:27:01.304
<v Unidentified speaker>So there are some very high earners that are dragging, you know, that median up.

1398
02:27:02.347 --> 02:27:08.989
<v Unidentified speaker>There are just a tremendous number of people that are below $20,000 and $40,000 of Oregon taxable income.

1399
02:27:08.989 --> 02:27:15.329
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think, you know, that's, uh, these are the tables that we pulled from the Oregon Department of Revenue when we looked at these figures.

1400
02:27:16.049 --> 02:27:17.510
<v Steve Novick>But median is in the middle.

1401
02:27:17.510 --> 02:27:19.500
<v Steve Novick>It's not— mean is average.

1402
02:27:20.010 --> 02:27:30.370
<v Steve Novick>It just, uh, it just— the numbers, I guess, are the numbers, but it just strikes me as bizarre that if median family income is like $90,000, then 41% of people would be below $40,000.

1403
02:27:30.370 --> 02:27:31.590
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, that would be all income.

1404
02:27:31.590 --> 02:27:32.290
<v Unidentified speaker>That's the other piece.

1405
02:27:33.079 --> 02:27:36.481
<v Unidentified speaker>So when we talk about median family income, that's all income, all in.

1406
02:27:37.621 --> 02:27:45.309
<v Unidentified speaker>And Councilor, there's also the factor of currently individual requirements to pay and individual income versus family income.

1407
02:27:45.903 --> 02:27:48.600
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that may also be skewing the numbers from what you're expecting.

1408
02:27:49.273 --> 02:27:50.605
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thank you.

1409
02:27:51.745 --> 02:27:52.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1410
02:27:52.725 --> 02:27:53.157
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Kanal.

1411
02:27:54.474 --> 02:27:54.730
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1412
02:27:54.875 --> 02:27:57.506
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, I want to follow up on both of those questions, actually.

1413
02:28:00.329 --> 02:28:00.909
<v Unidentified speaker>So is the—.

1414
02:28:00.989 --> 02:28:03.566
<v Sameer Kanal>Does the proposal actually do the last slide?

1415
02:28:04.452 --> 02:28:06.175
<v Sameer Kanal>I got a little confused there on that.

1416
02:28:07.350 --> 02:28:08.566
<v Unidentified speaker>Previous council budget action.

1417
02:28:08.664 --> 02:28:12.493
<v Unidentified speaker>When you say the last slide, you're referring to the chart that talked about the fund balance?

1418
02:28:12.897 --> 02:28:14.975
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, the change from the second to last to the last.

1419
02:28:15.087 --> 02:28:16.628
<v Unidentified speaker>That change has already occurred.

1420
02:28:17.516 --> 02:28:19.811
<v Unidentified speaker>The council adopted the change in the TAO.

1421
02:28:20.603 --> 02:28:26.099
<v Unidentified speaker>So there was an increase of about $1.6 million in the technical adjustment that just occurred a month ago or so.

1422
02:28:26.926 --> 02:28:36.385
<v Unidentified speaker>Ago, and then in the current budget going forward, I believe the city administrator has placed $3.5 million to the arts office in that budget.

1423
02:28:36.433 --> 02:28:39.227
<v Unidentified speaker>So yes, it's been implemented, but not in this ordinance.

1424
02:28:39.628 --> 02:28:43.000
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, and there's no further change to the target fund balance?

1425
02:28:44.283 --> 02:28:44.621
<v Jonas Biery>No.

1426
02:28:44.685 --> 02:28:44.990
<v Sameer Kanal>In this?

1427
02:28:45.167 --> 02:28:46.629
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that's— thanks.

1428
02:28:47.656 --> 02:29:10.293
<v Sameer Kanal>And then to Councilor Novick's point, so my understanding is if we're reducing by 41%, the number of, of filers, and we are increasing the amount they file by 42.7%, that we're at a 15.8% reduction in the amount of money we raise.

1429
02:29:11.472 --> 02:29:14.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Are you anticipating higher levels of compliance?

1430
02:29:14.150 --> 02:29:15.481
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that why it's revenue neutral?

1431
02:29:15.935 --> 02:29:16.975
<v Sameer Kanal>How do we get to that point?

1432
02:29:18.003 --> 02:29:22.958
<v Unidentified speaker>No, uh, so I don't— we could look back to the table if that's helpful.

1433
02:29:23.054 --> 02:29:25.506
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know if we could go back to the table, but—.

1434
02:29:25.843 --> 02:29:26.341
<v Unidentified speaker>But a moment.

1435
02:29:27.222 --> 02:29:32.963
<v Unidentified speaker>Those percentages, I don't think that works the way that you may be suggesting.

1436
02:29:33.059 --> 02:29:44.029
<v Unidentified speaker>So there's been a lot of analysis, uh, of the data and the number of remaining taxpayers that are paying the higher rates of $50 or $100.

1437
02:29:48.860 --> 02:29:54.054
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I'm gonna follow up on that, uh, before we take the final vote, I guess, next week.

1438
02:29:54.135 --> 02:29:57.259
<v Sameer Kanal>But, um, I'll move on here.

1439
02:29:57.889 --> 02:30:02.434
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, I wanted to ask another— I guess it's maybe not technical, so I'll wait.

1440
02:30:02.548 --> 02:30:02.742
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1441
02:30:03.014 --> 02:30:03.916
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, thank you.

1442
02:30:04.319 --> 02:30:05.609
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Clark.

1443
02:30:05.931 --> 02:30:08.037
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Council President.

1444
02:30:08.268 --> 02:30:14.165
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, so I want to make sure I understand that if there the joint filers, they only pay one $50?

1445
02:30:15.888 --> 02:30:18.183
<v Unidentified speaker>A joint filer would pay $100.

1446
02:30:18.378 --> 02:30:19.315
<v Candace Avalos>$100.

1447
02:30:19.654 --> 02:30:20.623
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, they each pay.

1448
02:30:20.962 --> 02:30:21.206
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1449
02:30:21.997 --> 02:30:32.880
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and I don't know if this is technical, but can you briefly, um, mention what were the issues that the city auditor outlined around the arts tax?

1450
02:30:33.764 --> 02:30:35.024
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I'm happy to do that.

1451
02:30:35.711 --> 02:30:38.138
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, looking back to the audit thank you.

1452
02:30:38.379 --> 02:30:38.974
<v Olivia Clark>I'll try to be brief.

1453
02:30:39.102 --> 02:30:41.833
<v Unidentified speaker>I think there are a couple of things that I want to highlight here.

1454
02:30:41.881 --> 02:30:47.246
<v Unidentified speaker>First, the city has only recently begun adopting standards for high-quality arts education.

1455
02:30:48.259 --> 02:31:02.264
<v Unidentified speaker>So these are— high-quality arts access and high-quality arts education are essentially the deliverables of the fund, of the Arts Access Fund, and that we did not have any sort of centralized understanding of what constituted high-quality arts ed.

1456
02:31:02.860 --> 02:31:25.156
<v Unidentified speaker>Now, the city has started developing that over the course of the last Last year, there was just a pilot year that was completed with Portland Public Schools, and its first year of full implementation is starting very soon in September for something called the Portland Arts Education Framework, which are sort of some basic standards around what we expect is necessary for quality arts education to occur.

1457
02:31:26.295 --> 02:31:31.956
<v Unidentified speaker>So that is introduced into code as an administrative rule that can be referenced as yes.

1458
02:31:32.132 --> 02:31:34.549
<v Unidentified speaker>What constitutes high-quality art set.

1459
02:31:37.110 --> 02:31:43.670
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, RACC and the city had not taken sufficient care in managing agreements with school districts and had potentially been overbilled.

1460
02:31:44.138 --> 02:31:58.831
<v Unidentified speaker>The process of revising those IGAs, one round of that has completed, I believe, last year, and another round in the response of the city administrator to the auditor is scheduled for the following year to ensure that some of those yes.

1461
02:31:58.879 --> 02:32:02.094
<v Unidentified speaker>Some of those tightenings happen and some of that insight occurs.

1462
02:32:03.680 --> 02:32:09.689
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe those IGAs had not been reviewed since essentially their inception prior to last year.

1463
02:32:10.415 --> 02:32:12.888
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're making good progress in that sense.

1464
02:32:14.497 --> 02:32:33.879
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, neither Councilor Rak nor the city had ever adopted a definition of underserved communities, which is essentially those to whom these dollars were intended by the voters there is a little bit of a definition in the existing code which refers to people who are underserved by existing arts infrastructure.

1465
02:32:36.110 --> 02:32:48.884
<v Unidentified speaker>We worked with the city attorney to create a definition of folks who face barriers in access to arts experiences that can be used in sort of a number of different metrics to prove that you're underserved.

1466
02:32:49.972 --> 02:32:54.983
<v Unidentified speaker>Finding folks who have trouble getting into spaces where there's art and making it easier for them to do so.

1467
02:32:55.306 --> 02:32:59.735
<v Unidentified speaker>That's for the funder as well as the providers to be able to come to that together.

1468
02:33:01.396 --> 02:33:07.468
<v Unidentified speaker>And then finally, that the fund oversight committee was not particularly well-defined.

1469
02:33:07.532 --> 02:33:08.709
<v Unidentified speaker>Membership was not defined.

1470
02:33:09.459 --> 02:33:10.546
<v Unidentified speaker>Membership very large.

1471
02:33:10.594 --> 02:33:13.515
<v Unidentified speaker>There were quorum issues, mostly when it was under RACC.

1472
02:33:14.326 --> 02:33:22.322
<v Unidentified speaker>And similarly— and also the responsibilities of the Office of Arts and Culture to that body had not been defined.

1473
02:33:22.920 --> 02:33:31.200
<v Unidentified speaker>So the code again sort of touches on all those things, shrinks the size, gives us some sense of who should be on it, what kind of service they need from the city, et cetera.

1474
02:33:32.313 --> 02:33:32.941
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you.

1475
02:33:33.198 --> 02:33:34.004
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate that.

1476
02:33:34.470 --> 02:33:36.112
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

1477
02:33:36.725 --> 02:33:37.191
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Smith.

1478
02:33:38.110 --> 02:33:40.268
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1479
02:33:40.429 --> 02:33:42.186
<v Candace Avalos>I have a technical question.

1480
02:33:43.707 --> 02:33:46.777
<v Candace Avalos>Mr. President, and it's for the attorney.

1481
02:33:46.841 --> 02:33:48.085
<v Candace Avalos>Do we have a city attorney here?

1482
02:33:50.260 --> 02:33:51.534
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe Ken McGarry is with us.

1483
02:33:53.753 --> 02:34:00.308
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, voters approved this ART tax in 2012 at $35 per person.

1484
02:34:01.063 --> 02:34:07.398
<v Candace Avalos>This ordinance raises the tax to $50 and indexes it annually.

1485
02:34:08.626 --> 02:34:18.358
<v Candace Avalos>Can the city can the city attorney explain to me on the record the legal basis for council increasing a voter-approved tax without sending it back to the voters?

1486
02:34:20.296 --> 02:34:21.099
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor.

1487
02:34:21.180 --> 02:34:22.690
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Robert Taylor, city attorney.

1488
02:34:23.027 --> 02:34:30.485
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, be happy to talk about this in executive session if you'd like, but we have reviewed this issue.

1489
02:34:31.808 --> 02:34:34.518
<v Eric Zimmerman>This council, if it wanted to, could refer this to the voters.

1490
02:34:35.402 --> 02:34:36.958
<v Unidentified speaker>It is not required to do that here.

1491
02:34:38.129 --> 02:34:39.286
<v Unidentified speaker>That's, uh, the—.

1492
02:34:39.655 --> 02:34:39.912
<v Steve Novick>We—.

1493
02:34:40.602 --> 02:34:41.388
<v Sameer Kanal>The city has—.

1494
02:34:41.725 --> 02:34:44.934
<v Steve Novick>We believe the city has authority to impose this tax.

1495
02:34:46.218 --> 02:34:52.622
<v Unidentified speaker>When the voters approve it, they are exercising their legislative authority as voters.

1496
02:34:53.457 --> 02:35:05.897
<v Eric Zimmerman>This council has concurrent legislative authority, and so this council can make changes And these changes, we believe, are consistent with the original.

1497
02:35:06.362 --> 02:35:16.847
<v Candace Avalos>Is that— and I'm just trying to figure out if that's in code, that we can unilaterally change this tax from $35 to $50 and it can change and adjust for inflation.

1498
02:35:17.539 --> 02:35:18.549
<v Candace Avalos>That is in our code?

1499
02:35:18.743 --> 02:35:19.433
<v Candace Avalos>Is that what you're saying?

1500
02:35:20.188 --> 02:35:23.512
<v Unidentified speaker>We, we believe council has the authority to pass this, yes.

1501
02:35:24.346 --> 02:35:26.273
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, thank you.

1502
02:35:27.109 --> 02:35:28.826
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1503
02:35:29.838 --> 02:35:30.898
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Green.

1504
02:35:31.990 --> 02:35:33.661
<v Mitch Green>Yes, uh, thank you, Mr. President.

1505
02:35:33.757 --> 02:35:52.662
<v Mitch Green>Just because Councilor Novick raised the statistics question, um, if you have a distribution of 10 observations, 10 people with income, and 4 of those make $20,000 a year and the rest of, rest of them make $90,000 a year, um, 40% of that discount, that distribution is, is $20,000 a year.

1506
02:35:52.693 --> 02:35:53.304
<v Mitch Green>It's just the middle of the income distribution.

1507
02:35:53.352 --> 02:35:59.095
<v Mitch Green>And so that's how you get to a situation where you have— and I chose 90 because 90 is the median income.

1508
02:35:59.914 --> 02:36:09.908
<v Mitch Green>Um, it's— that's how you get to a situation where, where you have, um, a very high share of people who make significantly lower than the median income because it's not a symmetric distribution.

1509
02:36:09.957 --> 02:36:13.534
<v Mitch Green>It's, it's concentrated and lumped in the lower part of the distribution.

1510
02:36:14.225 --> 02:36:17.370
<v Mitch Green>So I don't think that was very helpful, but I had to say it.

1511
02:36:18.139 --> 02:36:29.988
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, I You know, so if we go back to the slide that had the 3 examples, I mean, I think it's really important to understand that we're not talking about, you know, apples and oranges.

1512
02:36:30.744 --> 02:36:34.067
<v Unidentified speaker>Median family income is all income, all in, from all sources.

1513
02:36:35.319 --> 02:36:44.039
<v Unidentified speaker>The numbers that you see on this slide are only all in, all sources at the, at the top of each of these sections, income before deductions.

1514
02:36:44.166 --> 02:36:44.215
<v Jonas Biery>Okay.

1515
02:36:44.873 --> 02:36:46.287
<v Unidentified speaker>And then you get into deductions.

1516
02:36:46.495 --> 02:36:55.021
<v Unidentified speaker>So with the median family income statistics that you see published, there aren't deductions, there aren't exclusions, it's just all in.

1517
02:36:56.049 --> 02:36:58.569
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm assuming that's going to be the difference.

1518
02:36:59.003 --> 02:37:03.370
<v Unidentified speaker>And then, Councilor Kanal, I think to your question, I thought about it a little more.

1519
02:37:04.863 --> 02:37:20.082
<v Unidentified speaker>We will be in a place now where with a joint filer you may have had Uh, a primary filer and a secondary filer or spouse that are now paying together $100 on a joint return.

1520
02:37:21.013 --> 02:37:29.199
<v Unidentified speaker>If one of those, uh, 2 filers had been below $1,000 previously, then you wouldn't have received 2 payments from that household.

1521
02:37:29.247 --> 02:37:30.595
<v Unidentified speaker>You would have only received one.

1522
02:37:31.350 --> 02:37:34.704
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so I think that might be part of the answer, and we can dig into the rest.

1523
02:37:35.058 --> 02:37:37.513
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, thank you.

1524
02:37:38.557 --> 02:37:40.002
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, do I still.

1525
02:37:41.149 --> 02:37:42.001
<v Olivia Clark>Are you still— is that Legacy?

1526
02:37:42.337 --> 02:37:42.915
<v Olivia Clark>That's okay.

1527
02:37:42.995 --> 02:37:43.573
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Kanal.

1528
02:37:44.118 --> 02:37:44.295
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1529
02:37:44.359 --> 02:37:55.049
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, and I figured out the rest as well, which is that the, the statement about 41% of folks being exempt is not 41% of the current tax base being exempt.

1530
02:37:55.049 --> 02:37:56.170
<v Sameer Kanal>It's 41% of the total.

1531
02:37:56.569 --> 02:37:56.889
<v Sameer Kanal>Total, right.

1532
02:37:56.889 --> 02:37:59.450
<v Sameer Kanal>There's already some people that are being exempt, that are exempted.

1533
02:37:59.530 --> 02:38:05.790
<v Sameer Kanal>So there's a 31-point-something percent reduction that nets out to just shy of equal revenue.

1534
02:38:05.790 --> 02:38:07.110
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think what you just explained makes sense.

1535
02:38:07.110 --> 02:38:08.290
<v Sameer Kanal>That's right.

1536
02:38:08.290 --> 02:38:11.709
<v Sameer Kanal>I did want to ask a clarifying question to something Evan said.

1537
02:38:13.389 --> 02:38:23.229
<v Sameer Kanal>And this relates to something I was going to— this is the thing I was going to wait for after, but because I may float an amendment to this, I wanted to mention it before, which is the oversight committee.

1538
02:38:25.573 --> 02:38:34.871
<v Sameer Kanal>The ranges, we've agreed, old council, new council, as a best practice that membership of volunteer bodies should have a fixed number.

1539
02:38:36.270 --> 02:38:44.332
<v Sameer Kanal>That's in the ABC project, and there's a reduction from 10 to 20 as the range to 5 to 11 as the range.

1540
02:38:44.397 --> 02:38:51.125
<v Sameer Kanal>And I just wanted to ask why, what the thought process was, the sort of reasoning behind that.

1541
02:38:52.870 --> 02:38:53.066
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

1542
02:38:53.296 --> 02:38:54.297
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then I'll have a comment.

1543
02:38:54.936 --> 02:39:06.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>As for the size, basically it's in response to what the kind of quorum numbers were historically and when there were problems with keeping seats filled.

1544
02:39:07.013 --> 02:39:11.255
<v Jamie Dunphy>Obviously the body is now fully within the city rather than somewhere between the city and RACC.

1545
02:39:11.914 --> 02:39:18.180
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so our capacity to be responsive and keep seats filled may simply be better moving forward.

1546
02:39:18.325 --> 02:39:20.646
<v Jamie Dunphy>And indeed, it's a stronger board than it's been.

1547
02:39:21.708 --> 02:39:28.627
<v Jamie Dunphy>Already, the— I would say that when it comes to moving to a fixed number, we'd most likely be open to that.

1548
02:39:29.364 --> 02:39:44.647
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I, I, uh, because you had already settled on, uh, the 2 ranges, 10 to— and I'm just mentioning I may make this proposal after testimony, um, you've already— the, the existing range is 10 to 20, the proposed range is 5 to 11.

1549
02:39:44.921 --> 02:39:47.779
<v Sameer Kanal>The only odd number that meets both of those is 11.

1550
02:39:48.291 --> 02:39:54.824
<v Sameer Kanal>And there are currently 9 members, so you wouldn't be reducing it below the current membership if you went to 11 or 9.

1551
02:39:54.871 --> 02:40:00.408
<v Sameer Kanal>So I did file with the clerk's office an amendment that would simply make it 11.

1552
02:40:01.836 --> 02:40:04.227
<v Sameer Kanal>And I may propose that afterwards.

1553
02:40:04.822 --> 02:40:16.923
<v Sameer Kanal>Fixed memberships are, as I said, a best practice, but also I think having the diversity that you laid out, which I really, really support, by the way, and I appreciate you writing that in, I think that is also a best practice.

1554
02:40:17.163 --> 02:40:17.789
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1555
02:40:17.917 --> 02:40:26.825
<v Sameer Kanal>It's really hard to do that with 5 people checking all those boxes, whereas I think having a larger group allows you to actually achieve the thing that code is requiring you to achieve.

1556
02:40:27.469 --> 02:40:27.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thanks.

1557
02:40:27.972 --> 02:40:28.851
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1558
02:40:29.532 --> 02:40:31.305
<v Olivia Clark>Keelan, can we please move to public testimony?

1559
02:40:34.516 --> 02:40:36.725
<v Keelan McClymont>We have 15 people signed up.

1560
02:40:36.934 --> 02:40:39.416
<v Keelan McClymont>I will call people up in groups of 5.

1561
02:40:40.415 --> 02:40:57.545
<v Olivia Clark>Blake Shell, John Goodwin, Beth Lewis, And for folks who are waiting for the children's levy, I need to note that we are unfortunately going to be leaving here at 5 o'clock today.

1562
02:40:57.789 --> 02:41:01.754
<v Olivia Clark>And so we will almost certainly not have enough time to get to the children's levy item today.

1563
02:41:02.211 --> 02:41:09.092
<v Olivia Clark>It will be— that and the following items will be moved to the top of our next meeting agenda, which is next Wednesday.

1564
02:41:09.480 --> 02:41:10.694
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Point of order.

1565
02:41:11.315 --> 02:41:19.049
<v Jamie Dunphy>Is there a way that we could stay at least 30 more minutes until 5:30 to get this finished, because it doesn't make sense for them to come all the way here and then come back again.

1566
02:41:19.594 --> 02:41:20.093
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's too much.

1567
02:41:21.024 --> 02:41:21.522
<v Molly Armentrout>I mean, they're here.

1568
02:41:21.652 --> 02:41:21.747
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean—.

1569
02:41:21.747 --> 02:41:23.836
<v Olivia Clark>Let me see if we can get our staff to stay until 5:30.

1570
02:41:23.916 --> 02:41:24.157
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1571
02:41:24.559 --> 02:41:26.343
<v Olivia Clark>And in the meantime, welcome up, folks.

1572
02:41:26.390 --> 02:41:27.709
<v Olivia Clark>Please introduce yourselves for the records.

1573
02:41:27.756 --> 02:41:33.548
<v Evan Lewis>And Blake Schell had a family emergency, so I'm going to read the testimony on her behalf.

1574
02:41:34.194 --> 02:41:38.088
<v Evan Lewis>My name is Evan Lewis, and I work with her for Portland Arts and Culture for Equity.

1575
02:41:38.331 --> 02:41:39.188
<v Evan Lewis>So here's her statement.

1576
02:41:39.852 --> 02:41:40.951
<v Evan Lewis>Good afternoon, City Council.

1577
02:41:41.165 --> 02:41:49.324
<v Evan Lewis>I'm Blake Schell from Oregon Contemporary representing Portland Arts and Culture for Equity and Portland Arts Leaders, groups that together represent the breadth of Portland's cultural landscape.

1578
02:41:49.404 --> 02:41:59.425
<v Evan Lewis>I'm speaking on behalf of 45 specific organizations that sent a letter to council to express our collective enthusiastic support of the proposed amendments to the Arts, Education, and Access Fund Tax.

1579
02:42:00.084 --> 02:42:11.263
<v Evan Lewis>It is unprecedented for a group of this scale, including groups with budgets under $75,000 and our city's 5 largest institutions, to join together with such a singular unified response to the impacts of Portland's arts ecosystem.

1580
02:42:11.310 --> 02:42:11.406
<v Evan Lewis>Thank you.

1581
02:42:12.113 --> 02:42:16.981
<v Evan Lewis>While the arts tax was visionary at its inception, it was fundamentally flawed because it was never indexed for inflation.

1582
02:42:17.415 --> 02:42:21.881
<v Evan Lewis>This led to a steady loss of revenue that created a state of scarcity that will only grow in the next 5 years.

1583
02:42:22.379 --> 02:42:31.489
<v Evan Lewis>The previous city government and the transition to the Office of Arts and Culture exacerbated these issues, pitting large against small groups and leading to a loss of the very access goals the tax was meant to serve.

1584
02:42:32.197 --> 02:42:38.109
<v Evan Lewis>We saw the impact of this broken system clearly last year with a shift in funding tiers prioritizing budget size over equity and access.

1585
02:42:38.605 --> 02:42:44.474
<v Evan Lewis>45 Organizations lost funding despite their deep commitment to arts access to underserved Portlanders across the city's district.

1586
02:42:44.875 --> 02:42:50.021
<v Evan Lewis>Dozens of organizations and hundreds of individuals spoke out and formed Portland Arts and Culture for Equity as a result.

1587
02:42:50.486 --> 02:42:58.677
<v Evan Lewis>These amendments are a critical course correction that will restore the tax's original intent, adjust for inflation, and finally allow for inclusion of new organizations in our funding pool.

1588
02:42:59.863 --> 02:43:02.829
<v Evan Lewis>The arts are a quantifiable engine for our city's prosperity.

1589
02:43:03.230 --> 02:43:10.717
<v Evan Lewis>In Oregon, the arts generate $829 million in annual economic activity, including tickets, Dinner, parking, childcare, and more.

1590
02:43:11.470 --> 02:43:20.191
<v Evan Lewis>Beyond the dollars, the arts are the only economic driver that are also emotionally and mentally healing, create empathy and increase voting and participants, and bring people together in person.

1591
02:43:20.559 --> 02:43:23.878
<v Evan Lewis>In short, the arts are the answer for the times we find ourselves living in.

1592
02:43:24.695 --> 02:43:27.966
<v Evan Lewis>Finally, we want to express our deep gratitude to Council President Jamie Dunphy.

1593
02:43:28.237 --> 02:43:32.342
<v Evan Lewis>For years, our community has spoken up about these longstanding problems only to feel unheard.

1594
02:43:32.790 --> 02:43:37.439
<v Evan Lewis>Your willingness to take action where previous council and current administration has stalled is a breath of fresh air.

1595
02:43:37.920 --> 02:43:45.028
<v Evan Lewis>Thank you for your leadership and for investing in Portland's arts and culture Thank you very much.

1596
02:43:46.497 --> 02:43:47.662
<v Beth Lewis>Good afternoon, councilors.

1597
02:43:47.726 --> 02:43:51.184
<v Beth Lewis>My name is Beth Lewis, and I'm the Director of Development at Portland Opera.

1598
02:43:51.721 --> 02:43:58.066
<v Beth Lewis>I'm testifying today in support of Council President Jamie Dunphy's proposed amendments to the Arts Tax Code, Chapter 6.10.

1599
02:43:59.147 --> 02:44:05.950
<v Beth Lewis>For many residents, the tax is confusing, difficult to comply with, and disproportionately frustrating given its relatively small amount.

1600
02:44:06.545 --> 02:44:10.545
<v Beth Lewis>The administrative burden and penalties have created resentment that undermines the very programs the tax is meant to support.

1601
02:44:12.962 --> 02:44:20.853
<v Beth Lewis>When people feel alienated by the system, they are less likely to engage, less likely to comply, and less likely to support arts funding in the long run.

1602
02:44:21.543 --> 02:44:31.215
<v Beth Lewis>Council President Dunphy's proposal offers a path forward by addressing these structural issues and making the system more fair, more transparent, and more workable for everyday Portlanders.

1603
02:44:31.728 --> 02:44:38.513
<v Beth Lewis>Reform can improve compliance, restore public confidence, and ultimately create a more stable and sustainable funding stream.

1604
02:44:39.106 --> 02:44:40.870
<v Beth Lewis>The arts are in a funding crisis.

1605
02:44:41.191 --> 02:44:43.663
<v Beth Lewis>And no one understands that more than Portland Opera.

1606
02:44:44.224 --> 02:44:52.583
<v Beth Lewis>As you know, we're in a $5 million, 16-month SOS fundraising campaign— Keep Portland Operatic, Save Our Songs, Secure Our Future.

1607
02:44:53.209 --> 02:45:01.198
<v Beth Lewis>We've been part of the cultural fabric of Portland for 61 years, and we're doing everything we can to ensure we're here for the next 61.

1608
02:45:01.888 --> 02:45:16.451
<v Beth Lewis>Without this much-needed arts tax reform, including indexing it to inflation, we risk losing the very institutions that make Portland vibrant, and we also risk losing the next generation of arts lovers by failing to sustain arts education in our schools.

1609
02:45:17.270 --> 02:45:21.215
<v Beth Lewis>We don't have to choose between supporting the arts and fixing a flawed tax.

1610
02:45:21.615 --> 02:45:23.507
<v Beth Lewis>We can and should do both.

1611
02:45:24.182 --> 02:45:27.356
<v Beth Lewis>I urge the council to adopt these amendments to the arts tax code.

1612
02:45:27.693 --> 02:45:28.448
<v Beth Lewis>Thank you for your time.

1613
02:45:28.753 --> 02:45:29.378
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

1614
02:45:32.986 --> 02:45:33.739
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, we're going in order.

1615
02:45:33.804 --> 02:45:34.075
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>Okay.

1616
02:45:34.588 --> 02:45:34.685
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>Hi.

1617
02:45:34.829 --> 02:45:38.629
<v Edwina Kane>First, thank you so much to the council for the opportunity to testify today.

1618
02:45:39.254 --> 02:45:39.879
<v Edwina Kane>I'm Edwina Kane.

1619
02:45:40.361 --> 02:45:44.095
<v Edwina Kane>I'm the Director of Advancement and Special Projects at Portland Center Stage.

1620
02:45:44.609 --> 02:45:47.126
<v Edwina Kane>I not only work in District 4, I live there as well.

1621
02:45:47.751 --> 02:45:51.647
<v Edwina Kane>I'm testifying in support of the proposed amendments to the arts tax code.

1622
02:45:52.384 --> 02:46:02.364
<v Edwina Kane>The arts play an integral role in the community, not only through the artistic programs that we publicly present But also through the work that we do in lifting the public education system.

1623
02:46:03.168 --> 02:46:14.690
<v Edwina Kane>The most recent DataArts survey just released earlier this week noted that more than $150 million are invested in the Portland economy from arts organizations across the community.

1624
02:46:15.284 --> 02:46:23.608
<v Edwina Kane>This includes both visual and performing arts organizations with budget sizes ranging from less than $250,000 to over $10 million.

1625
02:46:23.672 --> 02:46:23.849
<v Edwina Kane>Thank you.

1626
02:46:24.666 --> 02:46:29.222
<v Edwina Kane>Each of these organizations plays an essential role in the arts ecosystem in our community.

1627
02:46:30.201 --> 02:46:37.997
<v Edwina Kane>PCS alone offers employment opportunities for 350 individuals, including 200 of which are artisans and artists.

1628
02:46:38.718 --> 02:46:51.055
<v Edwina Kane>In addition to the public performances we offer on our stages, we serve over 7,000 students, of which 6,000 are attending student matinees, which are either highly subsidized or wholly free.

1629
02:46:51.858 --> 02:46:57.780
<v Edwina Kane>We also offer nearly 100 free community programs which serve over 9,000 individuals.

1630
02:46:58.677 --> 02:47:07.040
<v Edwina Kane>All of our colleagues offer similar opportunities throughout the community, and all of these programs provide invaluable services for Portland residents.

1631
02:47:07.842 --> 02:47:20.418
<v Edwina Kane>As the cost of delivering these programs has grown exponentially over the years, smaller arts organizations in particular have faced increasing challenges with an arts tax that has remained flat since its inception.

1632
02:47:21.319 --> 02:47:30.914
<v Edwina Kane>The amended arts tax code will ensure that all arts organizations in our community are equitably supported by the city, in turn lifting each organization's ability to thrive.

1633
02:47:36.465 --> 02:47:37.200
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

1634
02:47:38.179 --> 02:47:39.126
<v John Goodwin>My name is John Goodwin.

1635
02:47:40.379 --> 02:47:41.271
<v John Goodwin>Good afternoon, everyone.

1636
02:47:41.773 --> 02:47:43.250
<v John Goodwin>I am honored to speak with you today.

1637
02:47:43.902 --> 02:47:48.452
<v John Goodwin>My name is John Goodwin, and I'm the Director of Community Philanthropy at the Portland Art Museum.

1638
02:47:49.254 --> 02:47:53.485
<v John Goodwin>My friend and colleague Stephanie Parrish, the museum's Director of Learning, is also in the room.

1639
02:47:54.415 --> 02:48:00.247
<v John Goodwin>She and her team are at the forefront of welcoming thousands of young visitors to the museum every year.

1640
02:48:01.289 --> 02:48:08.869
<v John Goodwin>Council President Dunphy and the entire council, thank you very much for the opportunity to talk with you about the proposed ordinance amending City Code 610.

1641
02:48:10.649 --> 02:48:16.138
<v John Goodwin>As you know, the Art Access Fund provides critical funding for our city's arts and culture ecosystem.

1642
02:48:16.748 --> 02:48:20.038
<v John Goodwin>For arts organizations, funding has declined at an alarming rate.

1643
02:48:20.841 --> 02:48:32.459
<v John Goodwin>At the museum, these dramatic reductions are impacting us harshly, just as our visitation is increasing, just as we are attracting more people downtown, and just as we demand the programming is growing.

1644
02:48:33.134 --> 02:48:38.799
<v John Goodwin>In November, when we celebrated our newly expanded campus, 40,000 people enjoyed the museum.

1645
02:48:38.976 --> 02:48:39.474
<v John Goodwin>For free.

1646
02:48:40.356 --> 02:48:48.680
<v John Goodwin>We're doing everything we can do to remove barriers to access through programs such as the free First Thursday and quarterly community free days.

1647
02:48:49.739 --> 02:48:52.792
<v John Goodwin>We expect to serve more than 300,000 visitors this year.

1648
02:48:53.113 --> 02:48:58.480
<v John Goodwin>Of those, more than 100,000 will visit for free and at a significantly reduced price.

1649
02:48:59.075 --> 02:49:05.115
<v John Goodwin>10% Of our adult visitors earn less than $30,000, and children 17 and under are always free.

1650
02:49:05.165 --> 02:49:05.261
<v John Goodwin>Thank you.

1651
02:49:06.079 --> 02:49:07.925
<v John Goodwin>School tours are also free.

1652
02:49:08.215 --> 02:49:11.729
<v John Goodwin>Nearly half of the school visits to the museum are from Title I-A schools.

1653
02:49:12.308 --> 02:49:28.150
<v John Goodwin>That's to say that schools with high percentage of students from low-income households— as the amount that we receive from the Arts Access Fund declines, it makes it even more difficult for us to provide these vital services to our most vulnerable children.

1654
02:49:29.002 --> 02:49:36.317
<v John Goodwin>Every year we present the Heart of Portland, the celebration of student creativity that Perfectly highlights the impact of the Arts Access Fund.

1655
02:49:36.798 --> 02:49:47.859
<v John Goodwin>Last month, we welcomed over 3,500 students and families to that free event profiling student dance, music, and viewing more than 100 works of art created by the Portland Public Schools students.

1656
02:49:48.501 --> 02:49:55.361
<v John Goodwin>This student art exhibition on the museum's highly valued walls is on view through September, and I hope that you will stop by to see us.

1657
02:49:55.954 --> 02:49:58.855
<v John Goodwin>I know several of you have memberships, so we hope that you'll do that.

1658
02:49:59.801 --> 02:50:07.013
<v John Goodwin>Decades ago, long before I joined the museum, I'd watch from my office window as children climbed out of school buses parked outside the museum.

1659
02:50:07.415 --> 02:50:12.381
<v John Goodwin>As they approached the building, many seemed apprehensive, unsure of where they were or what to expect.

1660
02:50:12.782 --> 02:50:13.536
<v John Goodwin>Not anymore.

1661
02:50:13.888 --> 02:50:22.684
<v John Goodwin>Today, they skip through our beautiful new transparent spaces, see art that looks like them, and sprawl across the furniture, happily exhausted from discovering great art.

1662
02:50:23.102 --> 02:50:24.880
<v John Goodwin>This is the real impact of the arts tax.

1663
02:50:25.057 --> 02:50:31.915
<v John Goodwin>Stable, consistent, and sufficient operating support for arts organizations is critical to sustaining the impact envisioned by the arts tax.

1664
02:50:31.962 --> 02:50:32.138
<v John Goodwin>Thank you.

1665
02:50:32.316 --> 02:50:32.860
<v John Goodwin>Access Fund.

1666
02:50:33.277 --> 02:50:34.093
<v John Goodwin>Thank you very much.

1667
02:50:34.495 --> 02:50:36.865
<v John Goodwin>Please come see us where everyone is an art person.

1668
02:50:37.924 --> 02:50:38.629
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

1669
02:50:39.605 --> 02:50:48.483
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Good afternoon, Council President Dunphy, Council Vice President Clark, and members of— sorry, members of Portland City Council.

1670
02:50:49.219 --> 02:50:54.492
<v Kimberly Armstrong>My name is Kimberly Armstrong, and I have the pleasure of serving as superintendent of Portland Public Schools.

1671
02:50:54.987 --> 02:51:01.222
<v Kimberly Armstrong>So I also acknowledge those who work and serve in our schools, and of course those who send Their children to us.

1672
02:51:02.602 --> 02:51:07.896
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Portland Public Schools strongly supports the proposed ordinance amending the arts tax.

1673
02:51:08.554 --> 02:51:17.183
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Portland has always valued creativity, opportunity, and community, and the Arts Access Fund reflects those values in our schools.

1674
02:51:17.778 --> 02:51:33.545
<v Kimberly Armstrong>These funds directly support certified elementary teachers and, and middle, and ensures— and high school— and ensures students across our city have access to music and visual arts as part of a well-rounded education.

1675
02:51:34.282 --> 02:51:36.304
<v Kimberly Armstrong>We see the impact every day.

1676
02:51:36.944 --> 02:51:41.483
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Arts education helps students build confidence, connection, and belonging.

1677
02:51:42.156 --> 02:51:49.886
<v Kimberly Armstrong>We see students who struggle to engage in other settings come alive in music, drawing, theater, and performance.

1678
02:51:50.495 --> 02:51:50.896
<v Kimberly Armstrong>We do.

1679
02:51:51.056 --> 02:52:01.292
<v Kimberly Armstrong>We see students gaining confidence by performing in front of their peers, expressing themselves through visual art, And finding joy and connection through creativity.

1680
02:52:01.807 --> 02:52:05.951
<v Kimberly Armstrong>For many students, the arts are where they feel successful and seen.

1681
02:52:07.108 --> 02:52:11.735
<v Kimberly Armstrong>We also know that districts across Portland are facing serious budget challenges.

1682
02:52:12.248 --> 02:52:13.613
<v Kimberly Armstrong>We are one of those districts.

1683
02:52:14.000 --> 02:52:18.898
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Without stable funding, arts programs and positions are increasingly at risk.

1684
02:52:19.316 --> 02:52:25.228
<v Kimberly Armstrong>The proposed changes in the arts tax are critical because they help protect these opportunities for students.

1685
02:52:25.277 --> 02:52:25.405
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Thank you.

1686
02:52:25.806 --> 02:52:29.121
<v Kimberly Armstrong>And ensure the fund remains sustainable for the future.

1687
02:52:29.906 --> 02:52:42.611
<v Kimberly Armstrong>This ordinance also strengthens equity and accountability by helping ensure students across all neighborhoods continue to receive consistent, high-quality arts instruction.

1688
02:52:43.587 --> 02:52:47.320
<v Kimberly Armstrong>For Portland school districts, this funding is essential.

1689
02:52:47.930 --> 02:52:56.565
<v Kimberly Armstrong>It helps ensure every child, regardless of background or zip code, has access to meaningful arts education and the opportunities that come with it.

1690
02:52:56.612 --> 02:52:57.189
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Thank you, Councilor Loretta Smith.

1691
02:52:57.766 --> 02:53:07.665
<v Kimberly Armstrong>We urge the council to support this ordinance in continuing investing in Portland students' future, and we could also use funds in the present.

1692
02:53:07.729 --> 02:53:13.746
<v Kimberly Armstrong>And so I would love to follow the conversation on the fund balance because we do have significant needs now.

1693
02:53:14.371 --> 02:53:17.676
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Thank you for your leadership and commitment to our young people.

1694
02:53:18.077 --> 02:53:18.462
<v Kimberly Armstrong>Thank you.

1695
02:53:18.960 --> 02:53:19.923
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you all very much.

1696
02:53:22.997 --> 02:53:33.029
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, next up we have Vicki Payne, Angela Bonilla, Alicia Chavez, Jennifer Falco, Michael Lopez-Serrao.

1697
02:53:33.783 --> 02:53:34.298
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, folks.

1698
02:53:34.362 --> 02:53:42.601
<v Olivia Clark>As you're coming up, I want to let my colleagues know we've gotten permission to stay until 5:30 so we can get into the— as much testimony from the children's levy item as possible.

1699
02:53:46.676 --> 02:53:50.176
<v Olivia Clark>And some of our colleagues are going to have to leave, and that will be okay as long as there's 7 of us here to hear testimony.

1700
02:53:50.487 --> 02:53:54.250
<v Olivia Clark>So go ahead and jump on in and please introduce yourself for the record and take it away.

1701
02:53:54.877 --> 02:53:55.504
<v Angela Bonilla>All right.

1702
02:53:57.143 --> 02:53:59.782
<v Angela Bonilla>Hello, my name is Angela Bonilla.

1703
02:53:59.879 --> 02:54:04.799
<v Angela Bonilla>Good afternoon, city councilors, Council President Dunphy, Council Vice President Clark.

1704
02:54:05.509 --> 02:54:14.236
<v Angela Bonilla>I'm the current president of the Portland Association of Teachers, and I'm speaking in support of the changes to the arts tax as a PPS educator for the last 10 years.

1705
02:54:15.057 --> 02:54:18.759
<v Angela Bonilla>Every year around this time of approving the PPS budget, I hear the same questions.

1706
02:54:18.808 --> 02:54:20.193
<v Angela Bonilla>Why are there so many cuts to visual and performing arts education?

1707
02:54:22.611 --> 02:54:23.862
<v Angela Bonilla>Where's the arts tax money?

1708
02:54:24.296 --> 02:54:26.347
<v Angela Bonilla>Isn't that supposed to fund our arts programs?

1709
02:54:26.861 --> 02:54:28.048
<v Angela Bonilla>And this year is no different.

1710
02:54:28.144 --> 02:54:37.171
<v Angela Bonilla>We have cuts all across the board, including to arts education for some of our youngest learners in pre-K. We also have cuts across the city.

1711
02:54:37.683 --> 02:54:43.424
<v Angela Bonilla>For example, Buckman Elementary is an arts-focused school that is losing arts staffing.

1712
02:54:43.921 --> 02:54:46.566
<v Angela Bonilla>And because of these realities, the questions persist.

1713
02:54:47.224 --> 02:55:02.718
<v Angela Bonilla>And as a Portland resident, I've also been frustrated with the annoying separate tax I have to pay after my state and federal taxes, but I swallow that annoyance because I know in theory that this will support arts education across our city and in the 6 school districts that call Portland home.

1714
02:55:03.969 --> 02:55:13.498
<v Angela Bonilla>And it will help put core into core enrichment, as arts are not just an extra or a dessert to the meal of education, but an integral part of a student's education.

1715
02:55:14.156 --> 02:55:17.076
<v Angela Bonilla>For many students, arts are what keep them coming back to school.

1716
02:55:17.125 --> 02:55:20.048
<v Angela Bonilla>Councilmember school when they hit the difficult years of middle and high school.

1717
02:55:20.995 --> 02:55:24.948
<v Angela Bonilla>And what I share with these families and educators is the reality that we've seen over time.

1718
02:55:25.076 --> 02:55:31.373
<v Angela Bonilla>The arts tax has not risen to match the rate of inflation, so it does not fund as much as it originally intended to.

1719
02:55:31.824 --> 02:55:40.643
<v Angela Bonilla>The arts tax funding does not require that it be spent solely on staffing, so the district could reduce arts educators but still increase art fundings and arts events.

1720
02:55:41.301 --> 02:55:53.260
<v Angela Bonilla>That arts tax funding doesn't just go to PPS but to other school districts And most folks nod solemnly or share, well, that sucks.

1721
02:55:53.260 --> 02:55:56.010
<v Angela Bonilla>Why, why do we pay the tax if it doesn't keep our arts educators?

1722
02:55:57.079 --> 02:56:11.540
<v Angela Bonilla>The lack of clarity, the diminishing funding, and the inadequate requirements have harmed the public's faith in this tax and our ability to advocate for arts in public schools all across Portland districts and to ensure that funds that come into our districts go directly to supporting arts Supporting programs.

1723
02:56:11.540 --> 02:56:11.579
<v Angela Bonilla>Councilmember Herbold.

1724
02:56:11.932 --> 02:56:12.140
<v Angela Bonilla>Arts.

1725
02:56:12.734 --> 02:56:16.950
<v Angela Bonilla>And I believe the proposed amendments will address these very real concerns.

1726
02:56:17.462 --> 02:56:23.618
<v Angela Bonilla>First, it commits to reducing the tax burden on our lowest-income residents while raising and indexing the rate of the tax.

1727
02:56:24.034 --> 02:56:30.415
<v Angela Bonilla>This will help stabilize our funding year after year, especially for if it is used for staffing.

1728
02:56:31.072 --> 02:56:32.979
<v Angela Bonilla>It also clarifies key terms.

1729
02:56:33.108 --> 02:56:38.815
<v Angela Bonilla>It helps the arts tax funding specifically target the populations and programming it intends to invest in.

1730
02:56:39.327 --> 02:56:56.440
<v Angela Bonilla>It clearly defines arts educators, and it also confirms that under It'll also clearly define standards for spending in the 6 districts who receive the funds.

1731
02:56:57.079 --> 02:57:04.120
<v Angela Bonilla>I know educators at PPS want more transparency and accountability, and this amendment will help to do that.

1732
02:57:04.120 --> 02:57:11.979
<v Angela Bonilla>So please vote in favor of this amendment and help the arts tax fulfill its original purpose of supporting the arts in our city for all people.

1733
02:57:11.979 --> 02:57:12.079
<v Vicki Payne>Thank you, Councilor Loretta Smith.

1734
02:57:12.263 --> 02:57:13.799
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

1735
02:57:15.641 --> 02:57:20.958
<v Alicia Chavez>Hello, good afternoon, Council President Dunphy, Council Vice President Clark, and fellow councilors.

1736
02:57:21.850 --> 02:57:33.942
<v Alicia Chavez>First of all, I want to say Happy Teacher Appreciation Week to all the educators here today, those working here in City Hall, across the city, and those who may be watching this testimony from home.

1737
02:57:34.881 --> 02:57:36.145
<v Alicia Chavez>My name is Alicia Chavez.

1738
02:57:36.404 --> 02:57:38.168
<v Alicia Chavez>I am the current vice president of Portland Association of Teachers.

1739
02:57:38.270 --> 02:57:40.308
<v Alicia Chavez>Association of Teachers and president-elect.

1740
02:57:41.175 --> 02:57:54.710
<v Alicia Chavez>Prior to my role as vice president, I was a kindergarten through 2nd grade special education teacher for nearly a decade, and long before that, I was a kid who dreamed of becoming a Broadway star, whose favorite subject was choir and drama.

1741
02:57:55.787 --> 02:57:56.815
<v Alicia Chavez>Art was my first love.

1742
02:57:57.488 --> 02:58:03.350
<v Alicia Chavez>It was how I made sense of the world, how I built confidence, and how I found joy in my day-to-day.

1743
02:58:04.377 --> 02:58:09.319
<v Alicia Chavez>While my dreams of being a Broadway star never happened, I got to relive that in my classroom.

1744
02:58:10.331 --> 02:58:13.764
<v Alicia Chavez>My paraeducators affectionately call me a walking musical.

1745
02:58:14.825 --> 02:58:19.927
<v Alicia Chavez>But more importantly, I saw the same transformation through art happen for my students.

1746
02:58:20.826 --> 02:58:24.181
<v Alicia Chavez>For many of my students, traditional instruction can be really limiting.

1747
02:58:25.175 --> 02:58:34.533
<v Alicia Chavez>But through art, whether it is music, drawing, movement, or storytelling, I saw my students find access points to relate to their peers.

1748
02:58:35.449 --> 02:58:39.190
<v Alicia Chavez>Art created pathways where there were often barriers.

1749
02:58:40.088 --> 02:58:44.359
<v Alicia Chavez>Art gave my students a way to communicate when sometimes communicating was hard.

1750
02:58:45.644 --> 02:58:50.989
<v Alicia Chavez>Art builds fine motor skills, social-emotional skills, and truly gave them a sense of belonging.

1751
02:58:52.209 --> 02:58:56.529
<v Alicia Chavez>I remember one student in particular who during the school day would completely shut down.

1752
02:58:57.443 --> 02:58:59.159
<v Alicia Chavez>But during art class, he came alive.

1753
02:59:00.075 --> 02:59:05.867
<v Alicia Chavez>He would paint or draw these wonderful things, often sharing stories and his interests through his work.

1754
02:59:06.507 --> 02:59:14.818
<v Alicia Chavez>And because of this, we used art for math, drawing little blocks for learning addition, or using drawing to understand his learning in reading.

1755
02:59:15.734 --> 02:59:19.695
<v Alicia Chavez>Art didn't just engage him; it gave him the power he knew he had.

1756
02:59:20.868 --> 02:59:22.215
<v Alicia Chavez>That's what this ordinance is about.

1757
02:59:23.049 --> 02:59:30.309
<v Alicia Chavez>It's about ensuring every single student in every single school in Portland has access to these life-changing opportunities.

1758
02:59:31.081 --> 02:59:37.665
<v Alicia Chavez>It's about equity, because without stable funding, it will be our most vulnerable students who lose access first.

1759
02:59:38.613 --> 02:59:41.119
<v Alicia Chavez>We talk a lot about preparing students for the future.

1760
02:59:41.889 --> 02:59:48.138
<v Alicia Chavez>The arts teach creativity, problem-solving, and resilience, and these are the skills every student needs to be successful.

1761
02:59:48.185 --> 02:59:48.555
<v Alicia Chavez>Councilmember Herbold.

1762
02:59:48.620 --> 02:59:49.825
<v Alicia Chavez>Successful human beings.

1763
02:59:50.886 --> 02:59:58.905
<v Alicia Chavez>As someone who once dreamed of the stage, and as someone who has seen the power of art in the classroom, I know that this is not extra.

1764
02:59:59.388 --> 03:00:01.551
<v Alicia Chavez>This is essential for all of our students.

1765
03:00:02.213 --> 03:00:06.878
<v Alicia Chavez>Please support the art tax amendment because our students and educators deserve nothing less.

1766
03:00:07.540 --> 03:00:07.879
<v Alicia Chavez>Thank you.

1767
03:00:08.329 --> 03:00:09.040
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

1768
03:00:11.557 --> 03:00:15.736
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>Good afternoon, Council President Dunphy, Vice President Clark, and members of the council.

1769
03:00:15.994 --> 03:00:21.932
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>My name is Michael Lopes-Sahal, and I have the pleasure of serving as the superintendent of the Parkrose District in Northeast Portland.

1770
03:00:22.558 --> 03:00:24.421
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>Thank you for the opportunity to testify today.

1771
03:00:24.468 --> 03:00:36.013
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>I'm here to express my strong support for the proposed ordinance amending the arts tax to and to share what these changes are going to mean for students across Portland, especially in East Portland communities like Park Rose.

1772
03:00:36.913 --> 03:00:41.216
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>Arts education is fundamental to student success, like many of my colleagues here have said today.

1773
03:00:41.585 --> 03:00:45.808
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>In our schools, the arts give students a place to belong, to express themselves.

1774
03:00:46.885 --> 03:00:48.120
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>And stay engaged in learning.

1775
03:00:48.475 --> 03:00:55.700
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>And for many students, especially those who all often don't see themselves reflected in traditional academic settings, the arts are where they thrive.

1776
03:00:56.584 --> 03:01:03.827
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>At a time where districts across Portland are facing significant budget challenges, these opportunities are increasingly at risk.

1777
03:01:04.389 --> 03:01:12.629
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>We're making difficult decisions about staffing and programming, and without stable dedicated funding, arts education is often one of the first areas to be reduced.

1778
03:01:12.676 --> 03:01:16.590
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>Councilmember That's why the proposed updates to the arts tax are so important.

1779
03:01:16.831 --> 03:01:24.496
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>By adjusting the rate to reflect inflation and indexing it moving forward, this ordinance protects the long-term stability of the Arts Access Fund.

1780
03:01:24.930 --> 03:01:37.310
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>Without these changes, we are already seeing cuts to arts organizations, and we know that reductions to school-based arts educators could soon follow, directly impacting students' access to consistent, high-quality instruction.

1781
03:01:38.465 --> 03:01:42.619
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>In 2012, there was one music teacher for 4 elementary schools.

1782
03:01:43.438 --> 03:01:45.685
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>The kids got music for 25 minutes a week.

1783
03:01:46.649 --> 03:01:53.730
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>And today there's a music teacher in every one of our elementary schools, and they receive over an hour of instruction in music a week.

1784
03:01:54.453 --> 03:01:56.203
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>That's because of this tax.

1785
03:01:57.424 --> 03:02:05.277
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>This ordinance will also strengthen governance and accountability by clarifying what we mean by high-quality arts education and prioritizing underserved students.

1786
03:02:05.453 --> 03:02:10.158
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>That matters deeply in East Portland, where districts like Parkrose serve diverse communities.

1787
03:02:10.495 --> 03:02:14.363
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>And where access to the arts education must be protected, not left to chance.

1788
03:02:14.989 --> 03:02:17.959
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>For districts like Parkrose, this funding is not supplemental.

1789
03:02:18.200 --> 03:02:18.906
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>It is essential.

1790
03:02:19.114 --> 03:02:24.764
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>It is especially critical as Parkrose and other districts in the region experience major budget reductions.

1791
03:02:25.359 --> 03:02:33.031
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>It allows us to retain qualified arts teachers and ensure that all students, regardless of background, have access to meaningful arts experiences.

1792
03:02:33.625 --> 03:02:38.488
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>These changes will make the Art Access Fund more equitable, more sustainable, and more impactful for students.

1793
03:02:38.552 --> 03:02:38.665
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>Thank you.

1794
03:02:39.165 --> 03:02:46.118
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>And I urge your support so we can continue providing art education for our students and what— and give them what they need and deserve.

1795
03:02:46.666 --> 03:02:47.022
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>Thank you.

1796
03:02:47.799 --> 03:02:48.719
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much for being here.

1797
03:02:49.027 --> 03:02:49.575
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, all 3.

1798
03:02:50.463 --> 03:02:52.385
<v Keelan McClymont>Vicki Payne is joining us online.

1799
03:02:58.873 --> 03:02:59.903
<v Keelan McClymont>Vicki, can you hear us?

1800
03:03:02.558 --> 03:03:03.551
<v Vicki Payne>Hi, can you hear me?

1801
03:03:04.379 --> 03:03:05.042
<v Keelan McClymont>We can hear you.

1802
03:03:06.272 --> 03:03:11.949
<v Vicki Payne>Okay, um, sorry, I'm not at my house anymore, uh, since I'm not on video.

1803
03:03:12.590 --> 03:03:13.664
<v Vicki Payne>My name is Vicki Payne.

1804
03:03:13.727 --> 03:03:17.912
<v Vicki Payne>I'm here today as one of the few people who's been paying this tax annually since its inception.

1805
03:03:18.441 --> 03:03:24.870
<v Vicki Payne>Thankfully, when I stupidly voted to pass this, I had finally broken into the world of office work and out of less than $20 an hour jobs.

1806
03:03:25.495 --> 03:03:27.226
<v Vicki Payne>I was just barely able to afford this every year.

1807
03:03:27.899 --> 03:03:30.656
<v Vicki Payne>I have always scoffed at the low exemption salary amount, however.

1808
03:03:30.720 --> 03:03:30.849
<v Vicki Payne>Thank you.

1809
03:03:31.442 --> 03:03:37.746
<v Vicki Payne>The changes you are proposing prove that nobody has any idea what it's like to make under $60,000 a year in the city.

1810
03:03:38.501 --> 03:03:45.286
<v Vicki Payne>Patting yourselves on the back to raising the bar to $20K when your report just showed that $33K is the minimum wage annual salary in Portland.

1811
03:03:45.799 --> 03:03:47.772
<v Vicki Payne>Why are we not at least using that number?

1812
03:03:48.365 --> 03:03:57.574
<v Vicki Payne>Um, but you know, in what corner of Portland do you have to live in to be able to afford an extra $50 every year on top of that, the normal cost of living at that?

1813
03:03:57.815 --> 03:04:00.415
<v Vicki Payne>It's It's not reasonable.

1814
03:04:00.540 --> 03:04:03.790
<v Vicki Payne>And weirdly, one salary doesn't give you the full lived experience of an individual.

1815
03:04:04.020 --> 03:04:05.879
<v Vicki Payne>Are they taking care of family members?

1816
03:04:05.879 --> 03:04:09.309
<v Vicki Payne>Are they supplementing income for a friend or a relative who can't afford their bills?

1817
03:04:09.440 --> 03:04:12.200
<v Vicki Payne>Were they previously in debt before they started making a new salary?

1818
03:04:12.719 --> 03:04:17.379
<v Vicki Payne>Uh, I can say that I've successfully struggled to survive in the city for almost 20 years at this point.

1819
03:04:17.379 --> 03:04:22.239
<v Vicki Payne>I'm obviously wondering why the hell I've endured surviving over actually living for so long.

1820
03:04:22.239 --> 03:04:27.920
<v Vicki Payne>And of course, we all know Portland and Oregon are hard to quit, but every year our electeds seem to be making that decision easier and easier.

1821
03:04:27.920 --> 03:04:38.448
<v Vicki Payne>Councilmember I'm looking at the upcoming summer concert schedule and bemoaning the fact that I can't afford to buy a concert ticket right now, thinking about you increasing this tax and thinking about how next summer I will likely be in the same boat.

1822
03:04:38.913 --> 03:04:52.311
<v Vicki Payne>So I will forego putting money into the local economy and a few hours of my own enjoyment of life and instead give the city that doesn't work more money and continue being angry that a large percent of the city still isn't paying this tax, many of whom can afford it much more than I can.

1823
03:04:52.873 --> 03:04:53.595
<v Vicki Payne>Food for thought.

1824
03:04:53.675 --> 03:04:58.555
<v Vicki Payne>Why not fix the system and prove to voters it's effective before adding more layers on top of it?

1825
03:04:58.602 --> 03:04:59.084
<v Vicki Payne>Councilor Smith.

1826
03:04:59.292 --> 03:05:04.929
<v Vicki Payne>Why not ensure everyone is paying first before upping the bill for those of us who've been diligently paying since 2013?

1827
03:05:05.635 --> 03:05:11.800
<v Vicki Payne>You were just able to push a transportation tax, and yes, it's a tax when you can't opt out of it, not a fee, into our water bill.

1828
03:05:11.961 --> 03:05:16.602
<v Vicki Payne>Where is the urgency to put this into the water bill to ensure those who can afford to pay are actually paying?

1829
03:05:16.779 --> 03:05:24.020
<v Vicki Payne>Because I can assure you there's a ton of tech bros on Reddit bragging that they've still never paid this tax, even with threats of it going to collections.

1830
03:05:24.727 --> 03:05:30.941
<v Vicki Payne>So maybe look at creating jobs that pay $60K or higher so we have more taxpayers that aren't hurting to contribute to this tax.

1831
03:05:31.038 --> 03:05:36.849
<v Vicki Payne>And P.S., most of us aren't happy to supplement our largest failing school system for their financial mismanagement anymore.

1832
03:05:37.010 --> 03:05:37.284
<v Vicki Payne>Thank you.

1833
03:05:39.754 --> 03:05:41.175
<v Keelan McClymont>Jennifer is joining us online.

1834
03:05:45.250 --> 03:05:46.377
<v Jennifer Falco>Good afternoon, everyone.

1835
03:05:46.731 --> 03:05:48.343
<v Jennifer Falco>My name is Jennifer Falco.

1836
03:05:48.970 --> 03:06:00.947
<v Jennifer Falco>I am the mother of a Portland Public I'm a Portland School senior, the chair of the Arts Access Fund Oversight Committee, and a business leader with 25 years of experience including fiscal oversight.

1837
03:06:01.507 --> 03:06:07.211
<v Jennifer Falco>I'm here to testify as a member of the public in support of updating the Arts Access Fund.

1838
03:06:07.501 --> 03:06:25.063
<v Jennifer Falco>The changes proposed to the fund build on the Arts Oversight Committee's 2025 annual reports, which notes that inflation between 2012 and 2026 dampen the fund's ability to provide the level of service Portlanders voted for when they passed the ballot measure.

1839
03:06:25.542 --> 03:06:27.801
<v Jennifer Falco>They also make the tax more progressive.

1840
03:06:28.827 --> 03:06:33.810
<v Jennifer Falco>I personally support the changes to the fund because it does 2 important things for Portland.

1841
03:06:34.274 --> 03:06:40.813
<v Jennifer Falco>As Dr. Armstrong and our other superintendent spoke about, the fund helps keep arts education in our elementary schools.

1842
03:06:41.468 --> 03:06:55.109
<v Jennifer Falco>Between the virtual room and the room in Portland, what do we have, maybe 100 people, 100 and Every day, almost 27,000 K-5 kids across the city are creating and learning in visual arts, dance, theater, music.

1843
03:06:55.606 --> 03:07:09.706
<v Jennifer Falco>And not only do the results of these give us things like the walrus we saw in committee or Cornfish, which I have on my fridge over there, early arts education translates to positive life outcomes for our children.

1844
03:07:10.300 --> 03:07:14.941
<v Jennifer Falco>More community engagement, fewer disciplinary problems, Higher graduation rates.

1845
03:07:15.198 --> 03:07:17.590
<v Jennifer Falco>These are positive, real-world impacts.

1846
03:07:18.167 --> 03:07:21.155
<v Jennifer Falco>The fund also helps to keep our arts ecosystem vibrant.

1847
03:07:21.861 --> 03:07:32.715
<v Jennifer Falco>Each year, it provides millions of dollars to local arts organizations who deliver programs in and for our community, including our K-12 kids and our underserved communities.

1848
03:07:33.341 --> 03:07:36.761
<v Jennifer Falco>These artists and arts organizations help make Portland Portland.

1849
03:07:37.338 --> 03:07:40.612
<v Jennifer Falco>You know, we have a great city, and arts is a pillar of this community.

1850
03:07:40.981 --> 03:07:43.629
<v Jennifer Falco>It's also an important part of our economic landscape.

1851
03:07:44.575 --> 03:07:55.289
<v Jennifer Falco>The Arts Access Fund Citizen Oversight Committee— and we are a diverse group from all over Portland— meets regularly with our city partners to ensure the effective administration of this fund.

1852
03:07:55.801 --> 03:07:58.416
<v Jennifer Falco>We report expenditures and impacts annually.

1853
03:07:58.930 --> 03:08:03.501
<v Jennifer Falco>If you haven't read our reports, they're available to you on the Office of Arts and Culture's website.

1854
03:08:04.046 --> 03:08:06.003
<v Jennifer Falco>I joined this committee in 2021.

1855
03:08:06.066 --> 03:08:07.511
<v Jennifer Falco>It's my second term as chair.

1856
03:08:07.575 --> 03:08:07.718
<v Jennifer Falco>Thank you.

1857
03:08:07.992 --> 03:08:11.094
<v Jennifer Falco>And each year we've found that this fund does what it said it would do.

1858
03:08:11.674 --> 03:08:17.617
<v Jennifer Falco>It provides dollars for K-5 educators and it supports arts organizations.

1859
03:08:18.217 --> 03:08:23.208
<v Jennifer Falco>We've been working hard with the city to ensure that the fund is ever more effectively managed.

1860
03:08:23.700 --> 03:08:29.852
<v Jennifer Falco>With the changes under consideration today, we will see that it continues to do so the first— for the foreseeable future.

1861
03:08:30.462 --> 03:08:30.897
<v Vicki Payne>Thank you.

1862
03:08:32.792 --> 03:08:33.418
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

1863
03:08:34.049 --> 03:08:45.273
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Brianna Linden, Astrid Linden, Danielle Milan Gonzalez, Viola LaForti de Vigo, Daisy Liangel.

1864
03:08:45.979 --> 03:08:56.338
<v Olivia Clark>As those folks are coming up, I just want people who are still in the room to know we are going to— when we are done with testimony on this item, we're going to continue this item to an additional first reading at our next meeting.

1865
03:08:56.483 --> 03:09:02.418
<v Olivia Clark>And I'm going to move to get as many people who are here to sign up to testify for the children's levy to get through.

1866
03:09:03.141 --> 03:09:04.522
<v Olivia Clark>We will jump directly into testimony.

1867
03:09:04.602 --> 03:09:07.572
<v Olivia Clark>So welcome to the dais and introduce yourselves.

1868
03:09:07.717 --> 03:09:08.038
<v Olivia Clark>Go ahead.

1869
03:09:08.905 --> 03:09:10.316
<v Brianna Linden>Hi, I'm Brianna Linden.

1870
03:09:10.430 --> 03:09:13.398
<v Brianna Linden>I'm the executive director for Arts for Learning Northwest.

1871
03:09:13.993 --> 03:09:22.903
<v Brianna Linden>I testified last week in committee and I'm back with this full council with one of my children, the one that made the t-shirt I wore last week, who's a PPS student and will speak next.

1872
03:09:23.834 --> 03:09:31.957
<v Brianna Linden>Last week at the end of Prosper Portland's presentation, Councilor Zimmerman, you remarked that Portland's looking for those mechanisms that make the city awesome.

1873
03:09:32.599 --> 03:09:38.282
<v Brianna Linden>Comprehensive arts education is just one of those mechanisms, and I want to talk today about what it takes to deliver that.

1874
03:09:39.165 --> 03:09:57.558
<v Brianna Linden>I told you in committee what happens when a child encounters a teaching artist or a cultural artist, how it can be the first time they see their own culture as something worthy of learning from, worthy of celebration, and equally how important it is for children to engage with new perspectives in the languages of the arts.

1875
03:09:58.703 --> 03:10:04.174
<v Brianna Linden>What I want to tell you to— what I want you to understand today is those moments don't happen by accident.

1876
03:10:05.788 --> 03:10:13.965
<v Brianna Linden>They happen because organizations like ours make them possible, residency by residency, school by school, child by child.

1877
03:10:15.558 --> 03:10:18.664
<v Brianna Linden>And they only keep happening if you fund the infrastructure that delivers them.

1878
03:10:20.165 --> 03:10:22.627
<v Brianna Linden>At Arts for Learning Northwest, we serve 40,000 students.

1879
03:10:23.220 --> 03:10:27.212
<v Brianna Linden>Last year through 125 rostered teaching and cultural artists.

1880
03:10:27.870 --> 03:10:32.503
<v Brianna Linden>We handle the vetting, the training, the district compliance, the relationships.

1881
03:10:33.225 --> 03:10:34.907
<v Brianna Linden>The infrastructure already exists.

1882
03:10:35.565 --> 03:10:44.735
<v Brianna Linden>What we need to ensure that students have access to the rich diversity of artistic and cultural experiences that they deserve is sustained dedicated funding.

1883
03:10:45.665 --> 03:10:48.325
<v Brianna Linden>This ordinance opens 2 doors to support that work.

1884
03:10:49.513 --> 03:11:06.002
<v Brianna Linden>The report on granting priorities is an opportunity to ensure that arts education organizations, the ones already putting teaching art and cultural artists directly in front of children, are named as a distinct priority, not as an afterthought to general arts funding, but as a named commitment.

1885
03:11:06.835 --> 03:11:10.620
<v Brianna Linden>The report on teaching artist programming is a promise to Portland's kids.

1886
03:11:11.245 --> 03:11:13.443
<v Brianna Linden>We intend to hold you to it, and we want to help shape it.

1887
03:11:14.052 --> 03:11:22.355
<v Brianna Linden>We are ready to convene art teachers, teaching artists, cultural artists, and district administrators to make sure that the report reflects what Portland's children actually need.

1888
03:11:23.190 --> 03:11:29.967
<v Brianna Linden>The children I'm speaking for today will grow up to be Portland's artists, teachers, engineers, parents, and leaders.

1889
03:11:30.783 --> 03:11:38.346
<v Brianna Linden>What we give them now— the experience of being seen, of having their culture matter, of discovering they have something to say— we give them forever.

1890
03:11:38.891 --> 03:11:42.289
<v Brianna Linden>Councilor Zimmerman, you asked for mechanisms that make Portland awesome.

1891
03:11:42.593 --> 03:11:45.173
<v Brianna Linden>Our children are a long-term investment in awesomeness.

1892
03:11:45.220 --> 03:11:45.349
<v Brianna Linden>Thank you.

1893
03:11:46.143 --> 03:11:50.251
<v Brianna Linden>Invest in them now by voting yes on the updates to the Arts Education and Access Fund.

1894
03:11:50.477 --> 03:11:50.815
<v Brianna Linden>Thank you.

1895
03:11:55.715 --> 03:11:57.131
<v Brianna Linden>Yep, just go.

1896
03:11:57.180 --> 03:11:57.566
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, okay.

1897
03:11:58.934 --> 03:12:00.736
<v Astrid Linden>Hi, my name is Astrid Linden.

1898
03:12:01.188 --> 03:12:03.328
<v Astrid Linden>I'm in 7th grade and go to Da Vinci Arts Middle School.

1899
03:12:04.287 --> 03:12:09.605
<v Astrid Linden>I was lucky to have lotteried into an arts-focused school, but not all kids get the same privilege.

1900
03:12:10.349 --> 03:12:13.808
<v Astrid Linden>I believe it shouldn't matter what neighborhood a kid is in or if they can lottery into a school.

1901
03:12:14.201 --> 03:12:15.531
<v Astrid Linden>That offers the arts.

1902
03:12:16.350 --> 03:12:21.783
<v Astrid Linden>All kids deserve to learn through art because it's a way to process emotions, imagine new ways of thinking, and express themselves.

1903
03:12:22.361 --> 03:12:24.172
<v Astrid Linden>It's a way to get what's on the inside out.

1904
03:12:25.245 --> 03:12:30.711
<v Astrid Linden>One of my primary art forms is writing, and often when I write outside of school, I get stuck or there's something else to do.

1905
03:12:31.529 --> 03:12:33.966
<v Astrid Linden>School is a place I get to focus completely on what I'm doing.

1906
03:12:34.622 --> 03:12:41.338
<v Astrid Linden>Having my creative writing teacher, Miss Connor, to help me and guide— allows me to do my best work and come up with new ideas.

1907
03:12:41.403 --> 03:12:41.514
<v Astrid Linden>Thank you.

1908
03:12:42.992 --> 03:12:49.123
<v Astrid Linden>Artists inspire kids by showing them what's possible, showing that they can be creative and accomplish amazing things.

1909
03:12:49.637 --> 03:12:50.567
<v Astrid Linden>Kids need to feel seen.

1910
03:12:50.986 --> 03:12:55.944
<v Astrid Linden>Artists show them that they are seen and that they are heard, even when they can't express themselves with words.

1911
03:12:56.843 --> 03:13:00.119
<v Astrid Linden>That's— there are so many other ways to communicate through the arts.

1912
03:13:01.129 --> 03:13:09.444
<v Astrid Linden>The past, the present, we learn about this in school, and though it is very important, supplying kids with the arts is how we invest in our future.

1913
03:13:09.524 --> 03:13:09.637
<v Astrid Linden>Thank you.

1914
03:13:10.183 --> 03:13:10.440
<v Astrid Linden>Thank you.

1915
03:13:11.370 --> 03:13:12.077
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

1916
03:13:13.459 --> 03:13:14.647
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>Hello, esteemed councilors.

1917
03:13:14.823 --> 03:13:30.896
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>I'm Danielle Milan Gonzalez, executive director at El Centro Milagro, the only professional Latino arts, cultural, and heritage center in the state of Oregon and the oldest continually operating theater in the city of Portland.

1918
03:13:31.602 --> 03:13:40.341
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>In our 40-year history, we have, um, implemented bilingual arts education programs across the state and the region.

1919
03:13:40.838 --> 03:13:55.798
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>We have also contracted and partnered with several state and county agencies, starting with Washington County Sheriff's Department, where we created one of the first after-school theater programs for Latino teens.

1920
03:13:56.281 --> 03:14:05.183
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>We partnered with the Oregon State Health Department, creating educational plays and Spanish about breast cancer and HIV that toured across the state.

1921
03:14:05.746 --> 03:14:14.532
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>We also partnered with the, um, Multnomah County Health Department.

1922
03:14:14.774 --> 03:14:27.457
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>We created a play about teen sex trafficking, in fact, because as you know, uh, the state of Oregon has the highest rate of sex trafficking of minors under the age of Yes.

1923
03:14:27.875 --> 03:14:31.212
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>We presented that educational play in several schools.

1924
03:14:32.593 --> 03:14:49.590
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>And so it's important to note that while people are concerned about a $15 increase, it's also important to look at all the studies about arts education and the power of the upstream effect of keeping kids in school, of student retention.

1925
03:14:50.183 --> 03:15:00.266
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>We even conducted a unique case study that demonstrated a 40% increase in comprehensive learning through bilingual arts education.

1926
03:15:00.861 --> 03:15:11.153
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>So imagine what $15 can do to keep teens in school, to keep kids out of trouble, versus all the money that is going to go for other state agencies.

1927
03:15:11.217 --> 03:15:13.064
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>So it's a small investment to make.

1928
03:15:13.400 --> 03:15:17.398
<v Danielle Milan Gonzalez>So thank you for your yes vote today on this amendment.

1929
03:15:17.783 --> 03:15:18.024
<v Astrid Linden>Thank you.

1930
03:15:18.577 --> 03:15:19.509
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you all very much.

1931
03:15:22.069 --> 03:15:23.853
<v Mitch Green>Just for the record, I'm Councilor Green.

1932
03:15:24.193 --> 03:15:27.179
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Zimmerman's a different person.

1933
03:15:28.585 --> 03:15:29.957
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1934
03:15:31.956 --> 03:15:34.036
<v Viola Devagal>Um, good afternoon, City Council members.

1935
03:15:36.290 --> 03:15:37.166
<v Olivia Clark>Go ahead, Viola.

1936
03:15:37.394 --> 03:15:38.838
<v Viola Devagal>Good afternoon, City Council members.

1937
03:15:38.968 --> 03:15:46.623
<v Viola Devagal>For the record, my name is Viola Devagal and I'm a sophomore at McDaniel High School, and I'm here today in support of Document 2026, um, 147.

1938
03:15:47.361 --> 03:15:52.391
<v Viola Devagal>Arts education is not just an extra program, it is an essential part of our schools and our communities.

1939
03:15:52.888 --> 03:15:57.840
<v Viola Devagal>For many students in Portland Public Schools, school is the only place where they can access these opportunities.

1940
03:15:58.272 --> 03:16:04.378
<v Viola Devagal>Without these programs, entire creative pathways are closed off to young people before they even get the chance to discover them.

1941
03:16:04.986 --> 03:16:12.505
<v Viola Devagal>Right now, high school and college students living at home and working part-time with $1,000 of income generally have to pay the tax.

1942
03:16:12.939 --> 03:16:21.015
<v Viola Devagal>Raising the income threshold means low-income Portlanders, including many working families and these young workers, will no longer have to file to pay for the tax.

1943
03:16:21.530 --> 03:16:24.628
<v Viola Devagal>Second, these reforms improve accountability and organization.

1944
03:16:25.207 --> 03:16:35.627
<v Viola Devagal>This proposal directly responds to past audit findings by clarifying definitions, strengthening accountability measures, and making sure that funds are actually used in a way that voters intend.

1945
03:16:36.766 --> 03:16:39.737
<v Viola Devagal>And third, these changes help protect the future of arts funding itself.

1946
03:16:40.299 --> 03:16:49.468
<v Viola Devagal>Through my own experience in band, musical theater, and dance, I know firsthand how much the arts help students grow, not just creatively but socially, emotionally, and academically.

1947
03:16:50.030 --> 03:16:55.087
<v Viola Devagal>The arts help shape who I am today, and every student deserves the opportunity to discover that part of themselves too.

1948
03:16:55.809 --> 03:17:11.166
<v Viola Devagal>Choosing not to act is also a choice, and it's a choice to let funding fall behind, a choice to risk cutting programs The arts don't just create artists, they create confidence, connection, leadership, and community.

1949
03:17:11.601 --> 03:17:14.463
<v Viola Devagal>And those are the things that the city of Portland should continue supporting.

1950
03:17:14.833 --> 03:17:19.416
<v Viola Devagal>So thank you for your time, and I urge you to vote in support of Document 2026-147.

1951
03:17:20.537 --> 03:17:21.333
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

1952
03:17:26.597 --> 03:17:28.858
<v Daisy Liang>Uh, good afternoon, City Council members.

1953
03:17:28.950 --> 03:17:28.950
<v Daisy Liang>Thank you, Mayor.

1954
03:17:28.950 --> 03:17:29.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mayor.

1955
03:17:29.030 --> 03:17:29.370
<v Nhu Hoang>Thank you, Councilors.

1956
03:17:29.370 --> 03:17:30.959
<v Daisy Liang>For the record, my name is Daisy Liang.

1957
03:17:31.129 --> 03:17:38.790
<v Daisy Liang>I'm also a sophomore at McDaniel, and I'm here in support of the reform on document 2026-147.

1958
03:17:38.790 --> 03:17:44.719
<v Daisy Liang>I believe that it is imperative now more than ever that we fund the arts through the taxation of higher-income families.

1959
03:17:45.090 --> 03:17:53.770
<v Daisy Liang>In an age in which schools are overcome with an increase in AI usage and constant social media consumption, arts provide a rare opportunity for students— creativity.

1960
03:17:54.701 --> 03:18:03.908
<v Daisy Liang>When we give students outlets for a range of artistic mediums, we allow them to express themselves and find a unique form of innovation that is increasingly less and less present in a school setting.

1961
03:18:04.906 --> 03:18:07.700
<v Daisy Liang>Not only that, the arts allow students to voice their perspective.

1962
03:18:08.360 --> 03:18:15.558
<v Daisy Liang>Schools can often be a hard place for minority students or students who don't align with the status quo, and yet through art, these students can find themselves.

1963
03:18:16.153 --> 03:18:20.379
<v Daisy Liang>It can unite them with like-minded individuals and allow them to display their authenticity and individuality.

1964
03:18:20.652 --> 03:18:23.222
<v Daisy Liang>Individuality, often for the first time.

1965
03:18:24.105 --> 03:18:27.849
<v Daisy Liang>When we take away funding for the arts, we are not just taking away supplies or classrooms.

1966
03:18:28.202 --> 03:18:33.471
<v Daisy Liang>We are taking away opportunities for students to find joy, creativity, and most importantly, themselves.

1967
03:18:34.629 --> 03:18:44.861
<v Daisy Liang>And given all this, we must pass this reform not only to fund the arts, but also to take the burden off the Portlanders that are struggling and instead distribute the responsibility fairly and equitably to all.

1968
03:18:46.114 --> 03:18:51.706
<v Daisy Liang>I've lived in Portland for most of my life, And I've seen the economic disparities between neighborhoods, streets, and even houses.

1969
03:18:52.379 --> 03:18:57.086
<v Daisy Liang>It is time that we stop forcing the single parent and family barely getting by to carry the weight of our community.

1970
03:18:57.906 --> 03:19:07.318
<v Daisy Liang>I urge each and every one of you to fight for my future, the future of my peers, and the future of our community, and vote yes on the reform for Document 147 to amend the arts tax code.

1971
03:19:07.783 --> 03:19:08.522
<v Daisy Liang>Thank you for your time.

1972
03:19:09.004 --> 03:19:09.775
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

1973
03:19:10.691 --> 03:19:11.752
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

1974
03:19:11.913 --> 03:19:15.638
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, colleagues, I'm going to continue this item to our next scheduled meeting.

1975
03:19:16.227 --> 03:19:18.969
<v Olivia Clark>Can we please call item 11?

1976
03:19:21.500 --> 03:19:22.927
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you all so much for everybody who's here today.

1977
03:19:24.299 --> 03:19:36.742
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 11, document 2026-132, approve funding recommendations of the Portland Children's Levy Allocation Committee for July 1st, 2026 through June 30th, 2029.

1978
03:19:37.179 --> 03:19:48.340
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, I'm going to ask, uh, Council Ops staff Christopher Hare to do a very Brief committee staff summary report, and then I'd like to dive directly into testimony, and we will continue this item as well.

1979
03:19:48.899 --> 03:19:49.969
<v Olivia Clark>So Christopher, please take it away.

1980
03:19:51.360 --> 03:19:53.780
<v Christopher Hare>Uh, yes, for the record, Christopher Hare, Council Operations Policy Analyst.

1981
03:19:53.780 --> 03:19:55.430
<v Christopher Hare>I serve as staff to the City Life Committee.

1982
03:19:55.520 --> 03:20:02.739
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance before you, document number 2026-132, was considered in the City Life Committee on April 14th, where it was referred to council with a recommendation it be passed.

1983
03:20:03.079 --> 03:20:13.904
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance approves, uh, the funding recommendations of the Children's Levy Allocation Committee for small grants totaling $2,555,000 over 3 years to 12 organizations as detailed in Exhibit A.

1984
03:20:14.385 --> 03:20:22.574
<v Christopher Hare>It authorizes the director of the Office of the Portland Children's Levy to enter into grant agreements with the approved organizations effective July 1st, 2026.

1985
03:20:22.879 --> 03:20:28.932
<v Christopher Hare>The ordinance also authorizes the director to terminate a grant agreement if a grantee is unable or unwilling to use city funds in accordance with the agreements.

1986
03:20:28.995 --> 03:20:43.369
<v Christopher Hare>In such cases, the director may reallocate the remaining funds by entering into a new agreement with a different grantee or by amending existing agreements, provided the total reallocation amount does not exceed the unspent balance of the terminated grant and the scope of the work remains substantially similar.

1987
03:20:43.674 --> 03:20:52.877
<v Christopher Hare>In addition, the ordinance approves 8% increases to 94 existing 3-year grants totaling $5,198,080 over the next 2 years, as outlined in Exhibit B.

1988
03:20:53.182 --> 03:20:56.666
<v Christopher Hare>The director is authorized to amend current agreements to implement these funding increases.

1989
03:20:57.084 --> 03:21:05.283
<v Christopher Hare>The full impact statements on this item includes financial and budgetary impact, economic and real estate development impacts, community impacts, and community involvement.

1990
03:21:05.588 --> 03:21:11.665
<v Christopher Hare>2 Individuals provided verbal testimony on the April 14th committee meeting, and 12 individuals submitted written testimony prior to committee action.

1991
03:21:12.003 --> 03:21:39.977
<v Christopher Hare>General themes of testimony included positive impact of the Portland Children's Levy grants on service providers and the communities they serve, the importance of continued funding for after-school programming, the significance of the proposed 8% increase in large grant funding in the current economic Current— excuse me— concerns regarding accountability for both provider organizations and the city, including reimbursement timing and the need for providers to cover service costs, and suggestions to consider certain organizations as alternate grantees.

1992
03:21:40.250 --> 03:21:41.629
<v Christopher Hare>That concludes the committee staff summary.

1993
03:21:41.773 --> 03:21:42.031
<v Christopher Hare>Thank you.

1994
03:21:42.319 --> 03:21:43.041
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Christopher.

1995
03:21:43.442 --> 03:21:46.876
<v Olivia Clark>Can we call up our first panel of testifiers?

1996
03:21:47.004 --> 03:21:50.727
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, I'll call folks up in groups of 5.

1997
03:21:51.545 --> 03:21:53.795
<v Keelan McClymont>Each Each testifier will receive 2 minutes.

1998
03:21:54.533 --> 03:22:04.013
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Jonas, Cassie, Rana, Usaman, Eric Knox, Tiffany, Thomas Geiss, Ayesha Carter.

1999
03:22:05.218 --> 03:22:09.558
<v Olivia Clark>If you're coming up, thank you so much for your patience as you've been waiting for your time to get up here all day.

2000
03:22:10.361 --> 03:22:16.691
<v Olivia Clark>We've got a couple of— we've got a city council that turns into pumpkins pretty quick here, so we want to hear from you.

2001
03:22:16.950 --> 03:22:17.318
<v Olivia Clark>Take it away.

2002
03:22:17.448 --> 03:22:17.960
<v Olivia Clark>Jump on in.

2003
03:22:18.411 --> 03:22:18.940
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you.

2004
03:22:19.117 --> 03:22:20.289
<v Jonas Biery>Good afternoon, councilors.

2005
03:22:21.509 --> 03:22:22.745
<v Jonas Biery>My name is Jonas Biery.

2006
03:22:22.792 --> 03:22:24.992
<v Jonas Biery>I'm the executive director of ECRC.

2007
03:22:25.233 --> 03:22:33.611
<v Jonas Biery>ECRC is a nonprofit organization established in 2017 to serve immigrant refugee community in East Portland.

2008
03:22:33.949 --> 03:22:39.342
<v Jonas Biery>I'm here with my staff, mentors, project managers, also some parents.

2009
03:22:40.610 --> 03:22:47.255
<v Jonas Biery>I'm here today to express my— our strong support for the proposed 8% increase to the Portland Children's Levy.

2010
03:22:47.834 --> 03:22:55.685
<v Jonas Biery>First, I want to thank you for your continued leadership and commitment to, in, in, to investing in children and families.

2011
03:22:56.200 --> 03:23:05.640
<v Jonas Biery>Programs like PCL have been essential in helping organizations like us deliver culturally responsive services that truly reach underserved communities.

2012
03:23:06.396 --> 03:23:09.686
<v Jonas Biery>This increase is not just a number, it has a real impact.

2013
03:23:10.394 --> 03:23:11.308
<v Jonas Biery>Quality Councilor Dan Ryan.

2014
03:23:11.371 --> 03:23:16.260
<v Jonas Biery>Qualitatively, it allows us to improve the depth and quality of our mentoring and youth program.

2015
03:23:16.644 --> 03:23:25.522
<v Jonas Biery>We can provide more consistent support, stronger relationship, and better outcomes for youth who need guidance, stability, and opportunity.

2016
03:23:26.595 --> 03:23:29.047
<v Jonas Biery>Quantitatively, it allows us to expand.

2017
03:23:29.543 --> 03:23:38.110
<v Jonas Biery>We can increase mentors' hours, serve more youth, and reduce barriers that many families face, especially transportation and access to other challenges.

2018
03:23:38.546 --> 03:23:44.682
<v Jonas Biery>For many of the families we serve, even small barriers can prevent children from participating consistently.

2019
03:23:45.149 --> 03:23:50.323
<v Jonas Biery>This investment helps us address those gaps so youth can fully engage and succeed.

2020
03:23:50.903 --> 03:23:58.809
<v Jonas Biery>Such impact does not only benefit individuals, youth, and families, it strengthens the overall well-being, safety, and the future of our city.

2021
03:24:00.639 --> 03:24:04.405
<v Jonas Biery>We see every day how mentorship tutorial and family engagement change lives.

2022
03:24:04.599 --> 03:24:11.311
<v Jonas Biery>With this increase, we can do more, reach more youth, support more families, and build stronger, more equitable futures for our community.

2023
03:24:11.699 --> 03:24:17.061
<v Jonas Biery>On behalf of ECRC and the families we serve, we are grateful for your leadership and we strongly support this proposal.

2024
03:24:17.334 --> 03:24:20.620
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you for your time and your commitment to Portland's children.

2025
03:24:21.280 --> 03:24:21.917
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

2026
03:24:24.301 --> 03:24:25.867
<v Rana>Hi, my name is Rana.

2027
03:24:26.221 --> 03:24:33.447
<v Rana>I am the executive director of Portland Youth Builders, a pre-apprenticeship program down in Southeast Portland.

2028
03:24:33.593 --> 03:24:40.477
<v Rana>We are first-year recipients of PCL funding, and I want to talk to you a little bit about the folks we serve and how we use PCL funding.

2029
03:24:41.100 --> 03:24:41.293
<v Rana>What I—.

2030
03:24:41.293 --> 03:24:53.476
<v Rana>A common thread that I hear from the folks that we serve is desperation and access, is desperation to be able to live and lack of access and where to find access to help figure out how to not be poor.

2031
03:24:55.013 --> 03:24:59.298
<v Rana>The things that we connect with PCL on— I'm going to read you a couple of goals.

2032
03:25:01.406 --> 03:25:05.147
<v Rana>Connecting children and youth with caring adult role models to support their well-being.

2033
03:25:06.609 --> 03:25:19.163
<v Rana>Creating after-school and summer mentoring programs promoting academic achievement, reducing the number of youth victimized by crime, increasing graduation rates, mentoring programs supporting transition to college and a career path for young people.

2034
03:25:19.227 --> 03:25:20.608
<v Rana>That is what we do.

2035
03:25:21.394 --> 03:25:26.467
<v Rana>We have been doing that for 31 years, and with PCL funding, we've been allowed to expand our services.

2036
03:25:27.237 --> 03:25:35.269
<v Rana>So far, we've already served over 100 youth, and we are about three-quarters of the way through our grant.

2037
03:25:35.847 --> 03:25:51.878
<v Rana>We will greatly exceed that number, and we will happily exceed that number because that there is need out there, and this eight percent increase for us would be huge, and moreover, for the communities that we serve that are poor communities.

2038
03:25:52.456 --> 03:25:54.125
<v Rana>Looking to find access.

2039
03:25:55.521 --> 03:26:00.220
<v Rana>Our hope, our hope is with these funds we'll be able to hire an alumni support person.

2040
03:26:00.317 --> 03:26:05.595
<v Rana>This person is specifically focused to work with folks that have graduated in our program.

2041
03:26:06.414 --> 03:26:11.050
<v Rana>What we see a lot in Portland is funding for initiatives, funding for new things.

2042
03:26:11.965 --> 03:26:18.837
<v Rana>This is an amazing way to continue to fund something that is a staple for people to become successful and work their way out of poverty.

2043
03:26:19.597 --> 03:26:24.595
<v Rana>And someone said it here before, investing in our young people is awesome.

2044
03:26:25.355 --> 03:26:27.764
<v Rana>So I hope you all feel the same.

2045
03:26:28.072 --> 03:26:28.314
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

2046
03:26:28.815 --> 03:26:29.622
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

2047
03:26:30.575 --> 03:26:31.529
<v Eric Knox>Hello, councilors.

2048
03:26:31.965 --> 03:26:32.659
<v Eric Knox>Good afternoon.

2049
03:26:32.852 --> 03:26:36.698
<v Eric Knox>My name is Eric Knox, and I'm the executive director of Hala Mentors.

2050
03:26:38.690 --> 03:26:42.324
<v Eric Knox>May 20th, we're celebrating 13 years.

2051
03:26:43.245 --> 03:27:07.075
<v Eric Knox>And if you do the math, that's like 156 months That's 4,700 days, and that's roughly 6.8 million minutes we've been putting work on the east side, especially when we know the history of Black and brown families have been displaced and pushed out on the edges of the city.

2052
03:27:08.293 --> 03:27:19.397
<v Eric Knox>And typically where I work, lots of organizations like ours are always Under-resourced when money starts to shrink.

2053
03:27:20.327 --> 03:27:21.468
<v Eric Knox>And we know this, right?

2054
03:27:21.612 --> 03:27:30.221
<v Eric Knox>When the city catches a cold or when the city sneezes, the places like East County and Black and brown spaces catch a cold.

2055
03:27:31.184 --> 03:27:48.880
<v Eric Knox>And we are fortunate to be first-time recipients of PCL funding, and through it, We're able to serve over 100 Black and brown youth in East County and in East Portland.

2056
03:27:49.731 --> 03:27:53.872
<v Eric Knox>And so for organizations like us, longevity and capacity means everything.

2057
03:27:54.933 --> 03:27:58.416
<v Eric Knox>Our work grows, our budget must grow alongside it.

2058
03:27:58.480 --> 03:28:04.003
<v Eric Knox>And this is why 8% of PCL increase is so important to us.

2059
03:28:04.966 --> 03:28:17.954
<v Eric Knox>It's not simply about maintaining programs, It's about sustaining impact and expanding reach and ensuring that organizations deeply rooted in community continue to serve young people who need it the most.

2060
03:28:19.191 --> 03:28:31.683
<v Eric Knox>Black-led organizations— more than symbolic support or baseline investment, we need equitable, sustained funding that recognizes both the scale and need and the value of our work.

2061
03:28:31.939 --> 03:28:37.211
<v Eric Knox>So we hope that you consider Thank you very much.

2062
03:28:40.059 --> 03:28:42.635
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>Thank you, councilors, for the opportunity to testify today.

2063
03:28:43.359 --> 03:28:44.790
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>My name is Tiffany Thomas Geiss.

2064
03:28:45.230 --> 03:28:46.474
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>I use she and her pronouns.

2065
03:28:46.522 --> 03:28:48.974
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>I'm the program and services director at Bradley Angle.

2066
03:28:50.101 --> 03:29:03.604
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>Bradley Angle is in our 51st year of providing services to survivors of domestic and sexual violence in Multnomah County, and we are the only culturally specific standalone organization supporting survivors of domestic and sexual violence and their children in the city of Portland.

2067
03:29:04.343 --> 03:29:07.102
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>As well as queer and trans survivors in the state of Oregon.

2068
03:29:08.434 --> 03:29:13.650
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>We are also one of the large grant recipient organizations that receive funding through the Portland Children's Levy.

2069
03:29:14.918 --> 03:29:23.568
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>These dollars are for our Healing Roots and Kinship programs, a tandem approach to addressing the impact of intergenerational violence on Black families.

2070
03:29:24.548 --> 03:29:33.792
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>We work with Black survivors of domestic violence as well as their children to restore safety, Thank you.

2071
03:29:37.261 --> 03:29:55.890
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>We provide financial support for basic needs and housing stability, host support groups for survivors to connect, engage in art therapy and cooking classes that focus on culture and community, and host monthly family outings to remind our participants that they also deserve joy.

2072
03:29:56.298 --> 03:29:56.314
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>Aye.

2073
03:29:57.468 --> 03:30:10.282
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>Youth participants receive one-on-one mentorship and support, lessons on safe adults and how to identify them, and culturally relevant space to process through the trauma they've experienced in their homes.

2074
03:30:11.277 --> 03:30:25.759
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>Healing Roots and Kinship are responsive, impactful, and the only programs of their kind that combine both dedicated space for survivors as well as their children to process, grieve, and reconnect after being impacted by domestic violence in their homes.

2075
03:30:26.674 --> 03:30:42.148
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>With cuts on every level of government to services across the board, the 8% increase being voted on today would ensure that we're able to continue providing a space of refuge, healing, and stability for Black families impacted by domestic and sexual violence in our community.

2076
03:30:42.904 --> 03:30:48.334
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>We're grateful for your support and look forward to doing more incredible and impactful work with these funds.

2077
03:30:48.593 --> 03:30:49.427
<v Tiffany Thomas Geiss>Thank you for your time.

2078
03:30:50.070 --> 03:30:50.858
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

2079
03:30:52.207 --> 03:30:53.234
<v Ayesha Carter>Hi everyone.

2080
03:30:53.570 --> 03:30:59.204
<v Ayesha Carter>Um, first and foremost, thank you so much for extending the time to allow us the opportunity to testify today.

2081
03:30:59.590 --> 03:31:00.648
<v Ayesha Carter>I do appreciate that.

2082
03:31:01.370 --> 03:31:02.591
<v Ayesha Carter>My name is Aisha Carter.

2083
03:31:02.718 --> 03:31:06.057
<v Ayesha Carter>I use she/her pronouns, and I am Bradley Engel's development director.

2084
03:31:06.586 --> 03:31:16.103
<v Ayesha Carter>I'm going to do my best not to reiterate too much of what Tiffany just said, but for the last over 50 years, we have been serving survivors in Multnomah County.

2085
03:31:16.552 --> 03:31:24.717
<v Ayesha Carter>Since 1975, our commitment to serving all survivors has been and continues to be unwavering.

2086
03:31:25.622 --> 03:31:33.704
<v Ayesha Carter>And we are especially proud to provide culturally specific services to Black and African American survivors as well as LGBTQIA+ folks.

2087
03:31:35.480 --> 03:31:39.825
<v Ayesha Carter>These critical dollars, as mentioned, support our Healing Roots and Kinship programs.

2088
03:31:40.503 --> 03:31:50.373
<v Ayesha Carter>These programs work hand in hand to support both the parent survivor and the child or children affected in establishing safety and reestablishing family stability and trust.

2089
03:31:51.372 --> 03:32:09.199
<v Ayesha Carter>They are unique in their approach of navigating the entire family dynamic impacted by the presence of violence in the home through mentorship, one-on-one advocacy, workshops that honor both healing and the importance of family bonding, providing financial assistance for essential needs such as housing and food support, and so much more.

2090
03:32:09.871 --> 03:32:14.841
<v Ayesha Carter>These programs get to the root of the cultural elements in play within the Black healing experience.

2091
03:32:15.802 --> 03:32:22.279
<v Ayesha Carter>As Bradley Ingalls Development Director, I see the funding cuts from every level of the government and their direct impacts on essential services overall.

2092
03:32:23.273 --> 03:32:34.093
<v Ayesha Carter>We are witness to the continued reality that supports— that support for marginalized identities is less accessible than it should be and is oftentimes more at risk when funding cuts hit.

2093
03:32:34.655 --> 03:32:44.318
<v Ayesha Carter>This is why this 8% increase being voted on today makes a tremendous difference in ensuring that we are able to continue meeting the increasing needs of our community and providing culturally specific care.

2094
03:32:45.009 --> 03:32:56.673
<v Ayesha Carter>We thank you for your support of our impactful work and urge you to vote in favor of this increase to ensure that our services continue providing a safe haven for Black families in our community to work holistically to break the intergenerational cycles of trauma.

2095
03:32:56.914 --> 03:32:57.252
<v Ayesha Carter>Thank you.

2096
03:32:57.879 --> 03:32:58.652
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you all so much.

2097
03:32:58.994 --> 03:32:59.628
<v Alicia Chavez>Thank you.

2098
03:33:00.391 --> 03:33:13.527
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Momar Al-Saidi, Kim Filla, Beth Kapsch, Fidel Ferrer, Faith Rose.

2099
03:33:20.934 --> 03:33:28.234
<v Olivia Clark>Feel free to— whoever wants to jump on and introduce yourself to the record, please.

2100
03:33:28.621 --> 03:33:29.268
<v Momar Al-Saidi>Hi, Council.

2101
03:33:29.429 --> 03:33:30.763
<v Momar Al-Saidi>My name is Momar Al-Saidi.

2102
03:33:31.454 --> 03:33:40.735
<v Momar Al-Saidi>I work at Outside In as a grants and contracts manager, and I'm here in support of the 8% increased funding to the PCL large grants portfolio.

2103
03:33:42.326 --> 03:33:55.739
<v Momar Al-Saidi>At Outside In, the PCL grant supports 3 program areas: workforce development, GED services, and mentorship for youth experiencing homelessness ages 16 to 24.

2104
03:33:56.364 --> 03:34:02.630
<v Momar Al-Saidi>These are young people actively working to stabilize their housing, education, and employment pathways all at the same time.

2105
03:34:03.720 --> 03:34:06.604
<v Momar Al-Saidi>Of these 3 areas, I'd like to take a moment and focus on GED services.

2106
03:34:06.718 --> 03:34:30.117
<v Momar Al-Saidi>According to the Census Bureau, individuals without a high school credential face significantly significantly worse outcomes, with GED holders earning about $3,100 per month compared to $4,700 for high school graduates, and only 43% of GED holders pursuing any post-secondary education compared to 73% of diploma holders.

2107
03:34:31.272 --> 03:34:33.377
<v Momar Al-Saidi>This translates into long-term instability.

2108
03:34:33.746 --> 03:34:44.076
<v Momar Al-Saidi>As youth without a high school credential are far more likely to experience persistent unemployment and lower lifetime earnings, reinforcing cycles of housing insecurity and, uh, well-being.

2109
03:34:44.927 --> 03:35:12.585
<v Momar Al-Saidi>The need is further reflected in who Outside In has served this fiscal year utilizing the PCL grant, of which about 50% of participants self-identified as LGBTQ+, over 50% as youth of color, and about 21% as identifying with diverse gender identities, all of which are far higher— are all of which are far higher concentrations than the general Portland population.

2110
03:35:13.356 --> 03:35:15.091
<v Momar Al-Saidi>At the same time, funding is shrinking.

2111
03:35:15.444 --> 03:35:34.323
<v Momar Al-Saidi>In the recent biennium, the Oregon Department of Education's Job and Work Readiness Grant was reduced from an anticipated 30 awards to about 15 awards statewide due to federal funding on Other similar funding impacts have been experienced outside in and with our peer organizations under the PCL large grants portfolio.

2112
03:35:34.662 --> 03:35:37.483
<v Momar Al-Saidi>So we appreciate your consideration of this funding increase.

2113
03:35:38.052 --> 03:35:38.835
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

2114
03:35:41.829 --> 03:35:43.584
<v Mitch Green>I'll just go for it then.

2115
03:35:45.486 --> 03:35:50.288
<v Mitch Green>Members of the council, City Council, thank you so much for extending the time first and foremost.

2116
03:35:50.676 --> 03:36:03.155
<v Mitch Green>My name is Fidel Ferrer and I am the executive director of Project Lido organization that focuses on opening pathways Pathways for programs that are culturally responsive for youth who face systemic barriers to achieve their full potential.

2117
03:36:03.556 --> 03:36:06.331
<v Mitch Green>We do that through STEM-focused programs.

2118
03:36:07.148 --> 03:36:14.304
<v Mitch Green>So I'm here to definitely be in support of the Portland Children's Levy increase of 8%.

2119
03:36:15.170 --> 03:36:20.929
<v Mitch Green>And as an Afro-Latino immigrant, this work really, really deeply is personal.

2120
03:36:21.361 --> 03:36:33.932
<v Mitch Green>And I know what it's like when you walk into a room as a Right now where you don't see a lot of folks that look like you, but more importantly, that you're perhaps the feeling of belonging is not there.

2121
03:36:34.012 --> 03:36:54.566
<v Mitch Green>That's why we are so deeply with this Portland Children's Levy increase that pretty much creates access for capacity and for mentorship programs and opportunities in the afterschool where kids, they feel themselves in the field that they wanna see in the brighter future.

2122
03:36:55.119 --> 03:37:00.713
<v Mitch Green>At Project Lido, we create a big impact when it comes to the community.

2123
03:37:01.525 --> 03:37:12.182
<v Mitch Green>We are about like 500 to 600 year-over-year students that they go through our programs and they build robots, that they are acquainted with technology, acquainted with AI, cybersecurity, and so much more.

2124
03:37:12.631 --> 03:37:16.296
<v Mitch Green>And that happens throughout the Portland metro area, specifically in District 1.

2125
03:37:17.838 --> 03:37:33.795
<v Mitch Green>In our organization, it's deeply a reflection not only for our Project Lido organization, for so many other, uh, organizations that they're part of it— educators, nonprofit mentors, school and community leaders.

2126
03:37:33.890 --> 03:37:42.635
<v Mitch Green>They're working tirelessly every single day to make sure that every child has academic identity, motivational resilience, and growth mindset.

2127
03:37:43.051 --> 03:37:49.438
<v Mitch Green>So I urge you to vote yes on the increase of 8% in our Portland Children's Levy.

2128
03:37:49.502 --> 03:37:49.757
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2129
03:37:49.854 --> 03:37:50.094
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

2130
03:37:50.577 --> 03:37:51.191
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

2131
03:37:52.995 --> 03:37:55.315
<v Beth Lewis>Good early evening, councilors.

2132
03:37:56.057 --> 03:37:58.022
<v Beth Lewis>Thank you so much for the time to speak with you today.

2133
03:37:58.166 --> 03:37:59.297
<v Beth Lewis>My name is Kim Villa.

2134
03:37:59.781 --> 03:38:02.661
<v Beth Lewis>I'm the Chief Family and Wellness Officer at POIC.

2135
03:38:03.485 --> 03:38:09.400
<v Beth Lewis>I am a licensed clinical social worker, and I've served the community at POIC for over 23 years.

2136
03:38:10.953 --> 03:38:14.709
<v Beth Lewis>I support the proposed 8% increase to PCL large grants.

2137
03:38:15.308 --> 03:38:28.441
<v Beth Lewis>Each year, POIC serves over 3,000 youth and families in our focus wraparound services, including education, employment and training, community safety, and family and health.

2138
03:38:28.873 --> 03:38:31.459
<v Beth Lewis>We are honored to partner with PCL.

2139
03:38:31.908 --> 03:38:40.595
<v Beth Lewis>I've personally worked alongside with PCL staff and am deeply grateful for their consistent partnership and support.

2140
03:38:40.900 --> 03:38:45.579
<v Beth Lewis>Today, PCL supports our after-school program, hunger, Aye.

2141
03:38:45.579 --> 03:38:45.579
<v Christopher Hare>Motion passes.

2142
03:38:45.579 --> 03:38:52.139
<v Christopher Hare>Next item on the agenda is the 2023-24 budget for Portland Youth Services, foster care, and child abuse prevention and intervention.

2143
03:38:52.139 --> 03:39:01.680
<v Beth Lewis>Youth and families are coming to us with increasing financial, emotional, and basic needs while state and federal resources are in decline.

2144
03:39:01.680 --> 03:39:17.804
<v Beth Lewis>This 8% increase helps PYC stabilize essential services, allowing us to meet rising cuts, costs, Such as rent, COLA, healthcare, transportation, and other business operations.

2145
03:39:18.236 --> 03:39:26.252
<v Beth Lewis>I deeply appreciate the increased investment capacity of PCL and wish all funders could offer this level of support.

2146
03:39:26.893 --> 03:39:32.152
<v Beth Lewis>This increase for the 94 existing 3-year grants is both timely and necessary.

2147
03:39:32.648 --> 03:39:34.492
<v Beth Lewis>This investment is critical.

2148
03:39:35.132 --> 03:39:36.078
<v Beth Lewis>Thank you for your leadership.

2149
03:39:37.061 --> 03:39:37.674
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

2150
03:39:39.402 --> 03:39:50.299
<v Beth Kapsch>Hi, um, hi, I'm Beth Kapsch and I am a licensed clinical social worker and I work as the Director of Health and Wellness at POIC.

2151
03:39:50.766 --> 03:40:07.311
<v Beth Kapsch>I've been serving youth and families in Oregon for almost 30 years and I've been at POIC for the last 7 years and I oversee the PCL programs at POAC and have seen directly the impact that this has had.

2152
03:40:07.809 --> 03:40:26.804
<v Beth Kapsch>Earlier, some of the council members mentioned that really the way that we ensure our most vulnerable community members' safety and stability is direct investment in these families, and that is exactly what these PCL funds do.

2153
03:40:27.093 --> 03:40:27.397
<v Beth Kapsch>Thank you.

2154
03:40:28.233 --> 03:40:36.460
<v Beth Kapsch>At POIC, we have a food pantry, and we have already this year given out more than 12,000 pounds of food.

2155
03:40:36.878 --> 03:40:39.748
<v Beth Kapsch>This has impacted nearly 700 individuals.

2156
03:40:39.861 --> 03:40:46.164
<v Beth Kapsch>We have a lot of families who come to our food pantries every week, especially as food costs are increasing.

2157
03:40:46.997 --> 03:40:56.509
<v Beth Kapsch>We've been able to partner with local farmers so we can get fresh local produce to families, which also keeps these dollars in our community.

2158
03:40:56.670 --> 03:40:58.818
<v Beth Kapsch>So it's like even expanding its impact.

2159
03:40:59.588 --> 03:41:12.838
<v Beth Kapsch>We're able to support young parents and youth with foster care experience to reduce barriers to school attendance and also help them in that transition between high school and then what's next.

2160
03:41:12.904 --> 03:41:19.529
<v Beth Kapsch>We can continue to support them even after they've graduated from our schools due to this— these funds.

2161
03:41:19.640 --> 03:41:22.625
<v Beth Kapsch>And I really appreciate your support of the 8% increase.

2162
03:41:22.704 --> 03:41:23.105
<v Astrid Linden>Thank you so much.

2163
03:41:23.170 --> 03:41:23.411
<v Brianna Linden>Thank you.

2164
03:41:24.132 --> 03:41:24.694
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you all.

2165
03:41:25.481 --> 03:41:25.707
<v Michael Lopes-Sahal>Thank you.

2166
03:41:26.059 --> 03:41:27.311
<v Keelan McClymont>Faith.

2167
03:41:28.549 --> 03:41:31.583
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Thank you all for being here and for staying to hear our testimony.

2168
03:41:31.840 --> 03:41:33.300
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>You know, it means a lot to us.

2169
03:41:33.430 --> 03:41:42.245
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Um, my name is Faith Briggs-Rose, and it's my great honor to speak to you all today representing Wonderfolk as our interim executive director while our executive director is out welcoming his new baby.

2170
03:41:42.983 --> 03:41:54.625
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Um, what the Portland Children's Levy is doing in the community is truly life-changing because the support it gives to all the organizations I've been involved with Wonderfolk since 2019, and I'm a very proud board member.

2171
03:41:54.720 --> 03:41:56.583
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>This is our 10th year serving our community.

2172
03:41:57.209 --> 03:42:06.168
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Wonderfolk is a youth-focused organization that serves Portland youth from underserved communities by creating in-depth program comprised of mentoring and hands-on service in our community.

2173
03:42:06.586 --> 03:42:11.661
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>We focus on youth leadership, developing youth voices, and bridging the opportunity gap that exists for these students.

2174
03:42:12.238 --> 03:42:16.716
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Our program pillars are unity through arts, Our naturehood and global leadership.

2175
03:42:17.197 --> 03:42:26.242
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>That means that our youth learn leadership development while being exposed to nature in our city through hiking, beekeeping, painting murals, farming, documentary filmmaking, and more.

2176
03:42:27.043 --> 03:42:35.527
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>I wanted to explain to you all how deeply we work with each youth and how dedicated our staff are, so I attempted to add up the number of hours that we spend with each youth in our program.

2177
03:42:36.024 --> 03:42:40.418
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>It's up to 75 hours per student here in Portland, depending on the student's availability.

2178
03:42:40.483 --> 03:42:40.674
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Thank you.

2179
03:42:41.093 --> 03:42:44.658
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>And even more during our global leadership trips, and that's just in their first year.

2180
03:42:45.525 --> 03:42:48.128
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>So our staff saw the first year and said, what else can we do?

2181
03:42:49.108 --> 03:42:53.058
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Our work with the Portland Children's Levy is actually related to our second-year program, which is new.

2182
03:42:53.524 --> 03:42:56.850
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Our staff is so dedicated that they said, what else can we do to support them?

2183
03:42:57.091 --> 03:43:05.105
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>So working with our alumni board, we've come up with a second-year program that also provides workforce development for youth that have been part of the program.

2184
03:43:05.426 --> 03:43:07.627
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>That development is is led by our youth.

2185
03:43:07.675 --> 03:43:19.850
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>As I said, they help tell us what they need, and that includes panels coming from different people in different careers, interviewing tactics, resume building, financial literacy.

2186
03:43:20.106 --> 03:43:25.841
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>And then we place them in internships and working with our different partners.

2187
03:43:25.888 --> 03:43:29.134
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>They're learning to track timesheets, they're going through their first internship process.

2188
03:43:29.198 --> 03:43:38.148
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>So please vote yes to the 8% increase and help continue— all of us continue to encourage and serve this next generation of city leaders here in Portland.

2189
03:43:38.406 --> 03:43:39.021
<v Faith Briggs-Rose>Thank you so much.

2190
03:43:39.538 --> 03:43:40.280
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

2191
03:43:43.219 --> 03:43:43.750
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we—.

2192
03:43:44.601 --> 03:43:48.103
<v Keelan McClymont>Oops, sorry.

2193
03:43:48.474 --> 03:43:48.843
<v Keelan McClymont>Molly?

2194
03:43:49.984 --> 03:43:50.161
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah.

2195
03:43:50.240 --> 03:43:50.353
<v Molly Armentrout>Yes.

2196
03:43:51.350 --> 03:43:53.362
<v Molly Armentrout>Hello, thank you all for staying late.

2197
03:43:53.476 --> 03:43:54.850
<v Molly Armentrout>My name is Molly Armentrout.

2198
03:43:54.995 --> 03:44:00.337
<v Molly Armentrout>I'm a resident of District 2, and I work with immigrant and refugee communities at ERCCO.

2199
03:44:01.060 --> 03:44:06.810
<v Molly Armentrout>I want to voice my strong support for the resolution to approve the 8% increase for Portland Children's Levy.

2200
03:44:07.486 --> 03:44:18.618
<v Molly Armentrout>Amidst the current turbulent political environment and a worsening affordability crisis, I see the effective and critical work that is being done by my colleagues funded by PCL.

2201
03:44:19.291 --> 03:44:26.486
<v Molly Armentrout>In the small and dynamic program I am a part of, the team speaks over 8 languages and we come from a variety of cultural backgrounds and countries.

2202
03:44:27.158 --> 03:44:40.443
<v Molly Armentrout>The PCL program is best positioned to provide outreach and critical services to some of Portland's most vulnerable communities, including immigrant and refugee communities that I work with every day, primarily in East Portland.

2203
03:44:40.877 --> 03:44:53.474
<v Molly Armentrout>These communities face systemic barriers when accessing and navigating services and resources, and the PCL-funded organizations help bridge that gap through culturally specific and targeted services and outreach.

2204
03:44:53.940 --> 03:45:17.252
<v Molly Armentrout>Every day I see hundreds of children living in multi-generational working-class families being positively impacted by PCL services, which include after-school academic and enrichment programs, youth mentorship and job preparation services, and services that support struggling families connect with food services, child care, Accessing healthcare, and so much more.

2205
03:45:17.797 --> 03:45:33.456
<v Molly Armentrout>Amid the, amid the worsening affordability crisis, it is really important that the city not pull back from investing in social services that directly benefit our working-class residents, but instead step up to the moment.

2206
03:45:33.841 --> 03:45:43.084
<v Molly Armentrout>By approving the 8% increase for PCL, the city would be confirming their obligation and commitment to the welfare of Portland's most vulnerable residents.

2207
03:45:43.552 --> 03:45:52.275
<v Molly Armentrout>The city would also be ensuring that the money would go towards organizations that have proven year after year to deliver crucial services to Portland families.

2208
03:45:52.860 --> 03:45:55.925
<v Molly Armentrout>Therefore, I strongly support the passage of this resolution.

2209
03:45:57.083 --> 03:45:59.717
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

2210
03:46:01.122 --> 03:46:16.045
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up, we have Nhu Hoang, Lakiana Yato, Yatoma Drury, Muna Youssef, Hisham Sheikh Hussein, Ayat Hassan.

2211
03:46:18.981 --> 03:46:23.273
<v Unidentified speaker>Great evening, uh, President Dunphy and councilors of Portland City Council.

2212
03:46:23.323 --> 03:46:26.698
<v Unidentified speaker>We really appreciate you all staying late to hear our testimony.

2213
03:46:26.890 --> 03:46:37.050
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the founder and executive director of Word Is Bond, as well as a proud resident of District 2, um, and we We strongly advocate for the 8% increase in the Portland Children's Levy.

2214
03:46:37.634 --> 03:46:43.147
<v Unidentified speaker>Word Is Bond serves 4 quadrants of young Black men ages 14 to— excuse me, 15 to 20 years old.

2215
03:46:43.617 --> 03:46:52.168
<v Unidentified speaker>African Americans born in this country, African immigrants, those with high barriers including economic and legal barriers, and then those with more supports.

2216
03:46:54.088 --> 03:46:56.566
<v Unidentified speaker>Currently we have 26 young men in high school.

2217
03:46:56.760 --> 03:47:00.434
<v Unidentified speaker>We have a 91% graduation rate.

2218
03:47:00.498 --> 03:47:02.344
<v Unidentified speaker>We have 24 young men in the workforce.

2219
03:47:02.621 --> 03:47:06.280
<v Unidentified speaker>Another 22 in college, and 4 who are incarcerated.

2220
03:47:06.936 --> 03:47:12.695
<v Unidentified speaker>And it goes without saying how important it is to support young Black men, especially in a city like Portland.

2221
03:47:13.594 --> 03:47:23.459
<v Unidentified speaker>Considering the $160 million or so budget deficit that we're facing right now, I think it's extremely important that we invest in people, right?

2222
03:47:23.557 --> 03:47:40.780
<v Unidentified speaker>We know that data shows when we invest in youth in our communities that those Those youth go on to be productive members of our workforce, go on to be homeowners, and be less reliant on social services from the city, including overpolicing of Black communities.

2223
03:47:41.134 --> 03:47:48.490
<v Unidentified speaker>So keeping this sweet and short, we strongly advocate for this increase to support youth in our city.

2224
03:47:48.540 --> 03:47:52.203
<v Unidentified speaker>That will be a long-term investment to the vibrancy of this city.

2225
03:47:52.494 --> 03:47:52.833
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2226
03:47:54.673 --> 03:47:56.771
<v Edwina Kane>Hello everyone, my name is Munee Youssef.

2227
03:47:57.093 --> 03:47:59.118
<v Jamie Dunphy>I had a few kiddos that were supposed to come up, but they couldn't wait.

2228
03:48:01.120 --> 03:48:01.280
<v Edwina Kane>Thank you.

2229
03:48:01.407 --> 03:48:03.606
<v Edwina Kane>I'm sorry, I know we're running late and they had to leave.

2230
03:48:03.671 --> 03:48:12.078
<v Edwina Kane>But my name is Muna Youssef, like I stated, and I serve as a program manager for Center for African Immigrants and Refugee Organization, also known as CAIRO.

2231
03:48:12.608 --> 03:48:17.293
<v Edwina Kane>I really do want to thank you guys for sticking behind and giving us this opportunity to speak with you.

2232
03:48:18.560 --> 03:48:21.481
<v Edwina Kane>We've dealt with a lot throughout this past year.

2233
03:48:21.674 --> 03:48:31.528
<v Edwina Kane>Our organization in August has experienced an arson attack at a preschool program that we've offered in On our preschool playground.

2234
03:48:31.880 --> 03:48:32.170
<v Edwina Kane>Sorry.

2235
03:48:33.550 --> 03:48:47.182
<v Edwina Kane>And following that fire, we've experienced a lot of safety concerns, break-ins, threats, which has really did force us to stop a lot of in-person activities to kind of focus on the safety of our community and the children.

2236
03:48:48.322 --> 03:48:51.742
<v Edwina Kane>At the same time, we've dealt with a lot of rising operational costs.

2237
03:48:52.191 --> 03:49:04.299
<v Edwina Kane>Limited funding kind of forced our organization to figure out other avenues while also doing more with the fewer staff that we have while the community demands continue to grow.

2238
03:49:05.359 --> 03:49:16.888
<v Edwina Kane>And I believe, you know, despite these challenges, we've really shown out for our students that we're kind of supposed to be here to talk about what this program has provided for them and the impact that it's brought into their lives.

2239
03:49:17.001 --> 03:49:28.773
<v Edwina Kane>But I really do believe that this 8% increase is really important in stabilizing a lot of the work that we're doing and sustainability for a lot of the nonprofit organizations that are providing these services.

2240
03:49:29.352 --> 03:49:51.844
<v Edwina Kane>Um, and I also want to highlight that the workforce development grant used to go up to the age of 18, and this is the first year it's tackling into going up to the age of 24, which is really important because there is a lot of challenges when it comes to navigating adulthood and that age and the proper support that we can provide for those students.

2241
03:49:52.983 --> 03:49:55.498
<v Edwina Kane>Thank you again for all of you guys, and thank you.

2242
03:49:56.209 --> 03:50:00.935
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, and I'm sorry that your littles couldn't stay with us.

2243
03:50:02.909 --> 03:50:04.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

2244
03:50:05.175 --> 03:50:06.987
<v Nhu Hoang>Hello, members of the City Council.

2245
03:50:07.296 --> 03:50:11.322
<v Nhu Hoang>For the record, my name is Nhu Hoang, and I live in District 1 of Portland City.

2246
03:50:12.097 --> 03:50:18.922
<v Nhu Hoang>I'm here today to support, to support the proposed 8% increase slash grant funding for after-school programs.

2247
03:50:19.968 --> 03:50:33.540
<v Nhu Hoang>As an immigrant parent navigating a new country, language, and school system can be overwhelming, and I'm most worried about whether my children feel safe, have a sense of belonging, have enough support to succeed in school.

2248
03:50:35.190 --> 03:50:44.203
<v Nhu Hoang>My son was born a couple years before the COVID hit, during the time everyone practicing social distancing, and he didn't have many friends back then.

2249
03:50:44.299 --> 03:50:44.557
<v Nhu Hoang>Thank you.

2250
03:50:45.102 --> 03:50:47.014
<v Nhu Hoang>He was shy and afraid to speak up.

2251
03:50:48.138 --> 03:50:54.934
<v Nhu Hoang>His teacher said he didn't raise hand to participate much in class and his student skills were below average.

2252
03:50:55.289 --> 03:50:57.987
<v Nhu Hoang>I would know— were not sure how to help him.

2253
03:50:59.064 --> 03:51:03.547
<v Nhu Hoang>However, joining the OCO after-school program have been life-changing for my child.

2254
03:51:04.768 --> 03:51:07.965
<v Nhu Hoang>After joining for a few months, I began seeing the meaningful changes.

2255
03:51:08.076 --> 03:51:18.163
<v Nhu Hoang>He come home with smile talking about what he done with his friends in the program, such as reading books, doing art projects, building Legos, and other cultural activities.

2256
03:51:18.259 --> 03:51:18.612
<v Nhu Hoang>Mm-hmm.

2257
03:51:18.997 --> 03:51:24.504
<v Nhu Hoang>The program provided a safe space for my child to feel safe, respected, and connected.

2258
03:51:25.645 --> 03:51:36.869
<v Nhu Hoang>Now my child is improving reading skills, feels confident expressing who he is, building friendships across cultures, participating in activities that reflect both cultural heritage and future goals.

2259
03:51:37.077 --> 03:51:37.093
<v Nhu Hoang>Aye.

2260
03:51:37.528 --> 03:51:39.390
<v Nhu Hoang>That make a powerful difference.

2261
03:51:40.338 --> 03:51:52.904
<v Nhu Hoang>Despite increase of ICE activity make the fear many immigrant and refugee families are experiencing, the program continue provide inclusive community where you feel safe, valued, and empowered.

2262
03:51:53.513 --> 03:52:05.495
<v Nhu Hoang>With 8% increase, the after-school program can serve more hundreds of children of color, provide more resources, more healthy snacks that my son excited to have after a long day Thank you for listening.

2263
03:52:07.155 --> 03:52:07.888
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much.

2264
03:52:09.500 --> 03:52:18.286
<v Keelan McClymont>Next up we have Crystal Ross, Lisa Jackson Spotted Elk, and Joye Manns.

2265
03:52:25.424 --> 03:52:26.200
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, we have 2 online.

2266
03:52:39.217 --> 03:52:40.877
<v Keelan McClymont>Checking one last time.

2267
03:52:41.166 --> 03:52:47.345
<v Keelan McClymont>Crystal Ross, Lisa Jackson-Spotted Elk, Joye Manns.

2268
03:52:50.155 --> 03:52:51.486
<v Olivia Clark>I see, I see someone online.

2269
03:52:54.770 --> 03:52:55.050
<v Joye Manns>There's—.

2270
03:52:55.117 --> 03:52:55.630
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, great.

2271
03:52:55.879 --> 03:52:57.270
<v Keelan McClymont>Joya, can you hear us?

2272
03:53:01.397 --> 03:53:02.703
<v Joye Manns>Yes, can you guys hear me all?

2273
03:53:03.431 --> 03:53:04.301
<v Joye Manns>We can hear you.

2274
03:53:04.963 --> 03:53:07.030
<v Joye Manns>Okay, hi everyone, my name is Joya Manns.

2275
03:53:07.400 --> 03:53:16.109
<v Joye Manns>I'm with the program of Love Is Stronger, and I'm here to talk on, um, behalf of not cutting them out of the 13, I believe.

2276
03:53:16.397 --> 03:53:22.363
<v Joye Manns>I think they placed 13 and there's only 12 people that will benefit from the act of receiving funding.

2277
03:53:23.447 --> 03:53:32.640
<v Joye Manns>I've been working with Love Is Stronger since I've been, I want to say, 16 going to 17 in my high school years, and I'm still part of the program as a college student.

2278
03:53:33.235 --> 03:53:44.627
<v Joye Manns>And for the future, Love Is Stronger is a very great program, especially for the minorities within the Southeast District and some people that live in the North Portland area.

2279
03:53:45.364 --> 03:54:02.352
<v Joye Manns>With that being said, I'm hoping that you guys are able to reinstate them into hopefully giving them Not only does Love Is Stronger not, not just help me through— have not just helped me through my high school years, but it's still helping me with my college years.

2280
03:54:02.721 --> 03:54:27.327
<v Joye Manns>It's such a benefit for the younger generation to be active in the community, which Love Is Stronger— and if you guys don't know, the owner of Love Is Stronger, Lionel, he— Lionel Irving, excuse me— is a very big activist when it comes to the community as far as gun violence and helping the less fortunate and making sure that we pour prioritized and important to the children that may not get the full attention that they seek at home or seek in the school system.

2281
03:54:28.056 --> 03:54:31.091
<v Joye Manns>Um, with that being said, I hope you guys are able to reconsider them.

2282
03:54:31.629 --> 03:54:32.755
<v Joye Manns>Um, thank you guys again.

2283
03:54:33.032 --> 03:54:34.256
<v Joye Manns>That's all I have to say.

2284
03:54:36.619 --> 03:54:37.735
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

2285
03:54:38.495 --> 03:54:40.597
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much, colleagues.

2286
03:54:40.986 --> 03:54:48.584
<v Olivia Clark>I will be building out enough time for us to just add some, uh, laudits and some Love for this program when we move this to second reading.

2287
03:54:48.713 --> 03:54:50.513
<v Olivia Clark>Is there any discussion at this time?

2288
03:54:53.180 --> 03:54:56.183
<v Sameer Kanal>Quick question, will we have staff available at that one too?

2289
03:54:56.424 --> 03:54:56.861
<v Sameer Kanal>Absolutely.

2290
03:54:57.005 --> 03:54:57.167
<v Olivia Clark>Great.

2291
03:54:57.652 --> 03:54:59.605
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, and it'll be time certain.

2292
03:55:00.131 --> 03:55:01.461
<v Olivia Clark>And I'll, I'll move it to time certain.

2293
03:55:01.510 --> 03:55:02.320
<v Olivia Clark>Sure, absolutely.

2294
03:55:02.888 --> 03:55:10.335
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, seeing no further discussion, I'd like to move this item to second reading.

2295
03:55:12.775 --> 03:55:17.257
<v Olivia Clark>And colleagues, I am going to continue item 12 to our next meeting.

2296
03:55:18.582 --> 03:55:21.700
<v Olivia Clark>With that, we're not— we're adjourning, right?

2297
03:55:21.747 --> 03:55:22.781
<v Olivia Clark>We don't have an afternoon tomorrow.

2298
03:55:23.251 --> 03:55:26.110
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, with that, I'm adjourning the meeting of the Portland City Council.

2299
03:55:26.174 --> 03:55:27.854
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you all so much for your patience sticking late.

2300
03:55:30.850 --> 03:55:31.903
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, everybody.

