WEBVTT

1
00:01:34.680 --> 00:01:36.370
<v Loretta Smith>Keelan, this is Loretta Smith.

2
00:01:36.582 --> 00:01:38.600
<v Loretta Smith>I am online.

3
00:01:52.019 --> 00:01:54.176
<v Rebecca Dobert>Good morning, Councilor Smith.

4
00:01:54.275 --> 00:01:54.784
<v Elizabeth Perez>We can hear you.

5
00:01:56.947 --> 00:01:58.103
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

6
00:01:59.195 --> 00:02:00.176
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, and this is Rebecca.

7
00:02:00.320 --> 00:02:04.048
<v Rebecca Dobert>Uh, Wendy is in chambers and she'll hear you when they unmute the room.

8
00:02:04.096 --> 00:02:04.947
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'll let her know you're there.

9
00:02:05.236 --> 00:02:05.959
<v Rebecca Dobert>Perfect.

10
00:04:29.495 --> 00:04:30.185
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

11
00:04:31.180 --> 00:04:35.694
<v Jamie Dunphy>Now calling to order this, uh, work session of the Portland City Council.

12
00:04:35.774 --> 00:04:41.605
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is 9:30 on Tuesday, May 5th, Cinco de Mayo.

13
00:04:42.826 --> 00:04:43.324
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning, everybody.

14
00:04:43.372 --> 00:04:43.677
<v Dan Ryan>Good morning.

15
00:04:45.315 --> 00:04:50.776
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, today we're scheduled for the first of 2 work sessions on bureaus within the Public Safety Service Area.

16
00:04:50.857 --> 00:04:56.944
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll be hearing from the Bureau of Emergency Communications, the Bureau of Emergency Management, and Portland Fire and Rescue.

17
00:04:58.149 --> 00:05:04.526
<v Jamie Dunphy>Contrary to how these work sessions have gone so far, Public Safety staff will be presenting all 3 bureaus together and then taking joint questions.

18
00:05:04.911 --> 00:05:07.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hopefully this means no bureaus will get left behind today.

19
00:05:08.283 --> 00:05:12.749
<v Jamie Dunphy>We will return to hear the remainder of the Public Safety bureaus and programs on May 13th.

20
00:05:17.254 --> 00:05:23.139
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'd also like to acknowledge that we heard word this morning that Deputy City Administrator Bob Casi will be leaving the city on May 18th.

21
00:05:23.202 --> 00:05:31.300
<v Jamie Dunphy>DCA Casi, I don't anticipate asking you any further questions about this matter in a public forum, but I want to thank you for your service and many years of service to this city.

22
00:05:32.004 --> 00:05:36.028
<v Jamie Dunphy>You do incredibly good work, and I'm immensely proud and grateful for your commitment.

23
00:05:36.494 --> 00:05:36.831
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

24
00:05:43.728 --> 00:05:51.762
<v Jamie Dunphy>To begin the session, the Community Safety— Community and Public Safety Committee Chair Councilor Novick would like to make an introduction before we pass things over to the DCA.

25
00:05:52.163 --> 00:05:52.661
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

26
00:05:53.047 --> 00:05:53.947
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

27
00:05:54.331 --> 00:05:54.862
<v Steve Novick>2 things.

28
00:05:55.119 --> 00:06:11.523
<v Steve Novick>One, I'm a bit afraid that when the message goes out that we're not cutting any sworn officers and we're not closing any fire stations, then some of you might get the idea that cuts we're making to public safety Thank you.

29
00:06:12.185 --> 00:06:18.495
<v Steve Novick>I think it's really important for us to be honest with the public about what the impact of cuts are.

30
00:06:20.319 --> 00:06:32.761
<v Steve Novick>And one thing that I want to be careful of in particular is saying, well, somebody else is going to pick it up, because we all know everybody's busy and there'll be some things that just aren't picked up and others that if they are picked up, they won't be done as quickly or as well.

31
00:06:33.550 --> 00:06:41.574
<v Steve Novick>So I really encourage you to be as frank and depressing as is appropriate about what the impact of all these cuts are.

32
00:06:42.360 --> 00:06:44.511
<v Steve Novick>Um, also, I have to say something.

33
00:06:44.624 --> 00:06:53.980
<v Steve Novick>City Administrator Lee, if— by the way, I repeat what the council president has said about how grateful we are for all Bob Cazey has done for years and years.

34
00:06:54.574 --> 00:07:02.245
<v Steve Novick>But City Administrator Lee, your email this morning said that you are going to take over as acting, uh, Deputy City Administrator for Public Safety.

35
00:07:03.000 --> 00:07:05.071
<v Steve Novick>I strongly urge you to reconsider that.

36
00:07:05.488 --> 00:07:10.610
<v Steve Novick>I frankly think that I don't think you have time.

37
00:07:11.206 --> 00:07:17.497
<v Steve Novick>And there's at least one person and probably more who all of us trust who I think would be an obvious interim person.

38
00:07:17.836 --> 00:07:19.334
<v Steve Novick>So I just ask you to please reconsider that.

39
00:07:19.978 --> 00:07:20.398
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

40
00:07:21.911 --> 00:07:22.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

41
00:07:22.894 --> 00:07:24.247
<v Jamie Dunphy>DCA Causie, please take it away.

42
00:07:24.891 --> 00:07:25.165
<v Bob Causie>Thank you.

43
00:07:25.230 --> 00:07:30.773
<v Bob Causie>Good morning, Council President, Vice President, Mayor, City Administrator, and Council.

44
00:07:31.416 --> 00:07:34.694
<v Bob Causie>I'm Bob Causie, Deputy City Administrator for the Public Safety Service Area.

45
00:07:35.786 --> 00:07:36.144
<v Bob Causie>Next slide.

46
00:07:37.348 --> 00:07:42.122
<v Bob Causie>We have 2 work sessions, as was mentioned earlier, today and the next one on May 13th.

47
00:07:42.526 --> 00:07:50.348
<v Bob Causie>Today's presentation and discussion will focus on the Bureau of Emergency Communications, Bureau of Emergency Management, and Portland Fire and Rescue.

48
00:07:51.139 --> 00:07:58.089
<v Bob Causie>The upcoming work session will include the DCA's Office, Community Safety, and Portland Police Bureau.

49
00:07:58.716 --> 00:07:59.086
<v Bob Causie>Next slide.

50
00:08:01.273 --> 00:08:09.634
<v Bob Causie>The proposed $611 million budget includes 2,250 staff across the entirety of the service area.

51
00:08:10.103 --> 00:08:10.605
<v Bob Causie>And next slide.

52
00:08:14.569 --> 00:08:14.923
<v Bob Causie>Next slide.

53
00:08:15.165 --> 00:08:15.632
<v Bob Causie>Oh, thank you.

54
00:08:16.372 --> 00:08:25.838
<v Bob Causie>Here's a high-level org chart of the service area showing emergency communications, emergency management, fire and rescue, police, and community safety.

55
00:08:26.937 --> 00:08:33.149
<v Bob Causie>Portland Street Response, Ceasefire, and the Office of Violence Prevention are all housed within community safety.

56
00:08:34.063 --> 00:08:38.895
<v Bob Causie>The Office of Violence Prevention houses the Safe Blocks and Rose City self-defense programs.

57
00:08:40.004 --> 00:08:45.799
<v Bob Causie>Over the course of this discussion and the one on May 13th, we'll dive deeper into these bureaus and programs.

58
00:08:46.907 --> 00:08:52.623
<v Bob Causie>And to get through the entire presentation, I ask that you please hold questions, if at all possible, until the end.

59
00:08:52.687 --> 00:08:55.464
<v Bob Causie>We will have plenty of time after the presentation.

60
00:08:56.941 --> 00:08:57.342
<v Bob Causie>Next slide.

61
00:08:58.225 --> 00:09:02.609
<v Bob Causie>The vision of Public Safety Service Area is a safe Portland for all.

62
00:09:03.606 --> 00:09:20.249
<v Bob Causie>And our primary focus throughout this budget process is preserving core emergency response capabilities such as 911, fire, police, and emergency management, while preserving continuity of priority programs throughout the service area.

63
00:09:20.908 --> 00:09:25.063
<v Bob Causie>These priority programs include alternative response and prevention.

64
00:09:26.302 --> 00:09:26.706
<v Bob Causie>Next slide.

65
00:09:28.638 --> 00:09:31.378
<v Bob Causie>As we begin this conversation, I wanted to spotlight something.

66
00:09:32.113 --> 00:09:40.750
<v Bob Causie>In my office, I have a collage of these statements, which are snippets of mission statements from the Public Safety Service Area bureaus and programs.

67
00:09:41.761 --> 00:09:49.981
<v Bob Causie>In my opinion, these statements show the intentions of the caring and dedicated professionals who work in their respective bureaus.

68
00:09:51.138 --> 00:09:52.951
<v Bob Causie>Build a more family-friendly city.

69
00:09:54.107 --> 00:09:56.163
<v Bob Causie>Create a safer community.

70
00:09:57.238 --> 00:09:57.847
<v Bob Causie>Proactive.

71
00:09:57.897 --> 00:09:58.057
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

72
00:09:58.443 --> 00:10:00.028
<v Bob Causie>And holistic harm reduction.

73
00:10:01.436 --> 00:10:03.538
<v Bob Causie>Reduce crime and the fear of crime.

74
00:10:05.066 --> 00:10:06.428
<v Bob Causie>All communities protected.

75
00:10:07.581 --> 00:10:10.048
<v Bob Causie>Compassionate and trauma-informed.

76
00:10:11.313 --> 00:10:13.881
<v Bob Causie>Readiness, response, resilience.

77
00:10:15.365 --> 00:10:17.105
<v Bob Causie>And effective and timely.

78
00:10:18.330 --> 00:10:29.846
<v Bob Causie>These statements demonstrate a vision for our city that we see, care, And connect with our neighbors and enjoy a city with clean streets and safe places.

79
00:10:31.259 --> 00:10:38.000
<v Bob Causie>This is all encapsulated in the Public Safety Service Area vision, a safe Portland for all.

80
00:10:38.980 --> 00:10:39.221
<v Bob Causie>Next slide.

81
00:10:41.519 --> 00:10:50.605
<v Bob Causie>And this slide demonstrates the budgets over the past few years in comparison with this proposed budget, showing the service area funded at $620 million.

82
00:10:51.876 --> 00:11:12.101
<v Bob Causie>This includes $319.5 million for PPB, $216.2 million for Portland Fire, $39.6 million for BOEC, $37.3 million for the Office of the DCA, including Community Safety Programs, and $7.6 million for PBEM.

83
00:11:13.288 --> 00:11:22.152
<v Bob Causie>The DCA office is unique in that it houses community safety programs such as Portland Street Response, Office of Violence Prevention, and Ceasefire.

84
00:11:23.022 --> 00:11:35.431
<v Bob Causie>One task that I would like to see happen in the future is that these programs be moved from the DCA's office into a standalone bureau to further tie these programs into the fabric of public safety.

85
00:11:37.330 --> 00:11:38.020
<v Bob Causie>Next slide.

86
00:11:38.631 --> 00:11:43.376
<v Bob Causie>And now I'll hand it off to Interim BOEC Director Steve Maudsley to kick things off with BOEC.

87
00:11:43.796 --> 00:11:44.455
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, DCA.

88
00:11:45.644 --> 00:11:46.384
<v Steve Maudsley>Good morning, Council.

89
00:11:46.950 --> 00:11:50.097
<v Steve Maudsley>I'm Steve Maudsley, Interim Director of the Bureau of Emergency Communications.

90
00:11:51.018 --> 00:11:52.357
<v Steve Maudsley>BOEC's mission is straightforward.

91
00:11:52.552 --> 00:11:59.495
<v Steve Maudsley>It's to work collaboratively with our community and public safety partners to ensure effective and timely 911 call answering and dispatching.

92
00:12:00.926 --> 00:12:07.394
<v Steve Maudsley>In the next year, BOEC has a $39.6 million proposed budget and 163.9 proposed staff.

93
00:12:07.913 --> 00:12:08.581
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

94
00:12:12.178 --> 00:12:17.063
<v Steve Maudsley>This is an overview of all changes to the bureau's budget, including additions, Reductions and realignments.

95
00:12:17.770 --> 00:12:28.706
<v Steve Maudsley>Specifics are described in upcoming slides, but I want to highlight the BART serves all of Multnomah County and receives cost-share revenue from local jurisdictions as well as 911 phone tax in-state shared revenue.

96
00:12:29.495 --> 00:12:34.198
<v Steve Maudsley>The blended cost allocation means that ongoing reductions are seen in both general fund and other funds.

97
00:12:35.067 --> 00:12:40.423
<v Steve Maudsley>The other funds reduction line shows positive because it is a net of revenue increases and reductions.

98
00:12:41.018 --> 00:12:41.419
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide.

99
00:12:44.714 --> 00:12:47.936
<v Steve Maudsley>Over 80% of BOEC staff are call taker dispatcher positions.

100
00:12:48.292 --> 00:12:54.182
<v Steve Maudsley>The current service level FTE includes 8 limited-term positions that are being extended through BOEC's training pipeline.

101
00:12:55.109 --> 00:12:55.671
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

102
00:12:58.240 --> 00:13:03.748
<v Steve Maudsley>While we're facing reductions, we are intentionally preserving key workflows that support our core mission.

103
00:13:04.735 --> 00:13:06.826
<v Steve Maudsley>First, we're maintaining our 911 trainee pipeline.

104
00:13:07.692 --> 00:13:11.803
<v Steve Maudsley>Which allows us to hire ahead of anticipated attrition and sustain staffing over the year.

105
00:13:12.889 --> 00:13:21.217
<v Steve Maudsley>Building on that, and in alignment with our recent International Emergency Medical Dispatch accreditation, we are preserving our quality assurance and improvement program.

106
00:13:21.880 --> 00:13:25.447
<v Steve Maudsley>This serves as the foundation for achieving accreditation across all our disciplines.

107
00:13:26.980 --> 00:13:35.886
<v Steve Maudsley>At the same time, we remain committed to equitable access to 911, particularly for community members who are limited English proficiency or those with varying abilities.

108
00:13:37.375 --> 00:13:45.652
<v Steve Maudsley>Operationally, we're maintaining targeted overtime focused specifically on our highest call volume months and surge events to ensure responsiveness when demand is greatest.

109
00:13:46.999 --> 00:13:55.822
<v Steve Maudsley>In support of timely service across all community— communities and partner jurisdictions in Multnomah County, we're also maintaining staffing in BOEC's Public Records and Research Department.

110
00:13:56.864 --> 00:14:03.360
<v Steve Maudsley>And finally, we're preserving our outreach program, which continues to strengthen relationships through consistent engagement at monthly events.

111
00:14:03.634 --> 00:14:04.541
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

112
00:14:08.049 --> 00:14:10.690
<v Steve Maudsley>We're facing a reduction in contracted security of $325,000.

113
00:14:12.383 --> 00:14:15.952
<v Steve Maudsley>As the hub of countywide emergency communications, we require secure conditions.

114
00:14:16.663 --> 00:14:22.046
<v Steve Maudsley>For the past 2 years, BOEC has funded security for the campus, including BOEC, PBIM, and BTS.

115
00:14:23.043 --> 00:14:37.625
<v Steve Maudsley>In addition to security personnel, we do have additional security measures in place, including camera access to the entire facility, Expanded exterior lighting, 24/7 supervisors on duty with camera access, and mandatory secure badge access.

116
00:14:39.113 --> 00:14:39.711
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

117
00:14:42.539 --> 00:14:47.211
<v Steve Maudsley>We're facing a reduction in training, travel, and continuing education by $381,000.

118
00:14:47.566 --> 00:14:50.772
<v Steve Maudsley>The training required to maintain certifications will continue.

119
00:14:51.840 --> 00:15:01.386
<v Steve Maudsley>Supplemental learning and industry engagement keeps us informed on best practices and provides professional growth and development opportunities and advancement opportunities that support employee retention.

120
00:15:02.405 --> 00:15:10.765
<v Steve Maudsley>Ensuring a focus on call answering during the summer, we'll conduct— we will conduct required training in the fall and winter months as more of our call takers certify later this year.

121
00:15:12.172 --> 00:15:12.721
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

122
00:15:14.740 --> 00:15:17.136
<v Steve Maudsley>We're facing a reduction in operational overtime by $422,000.

123
00:15:19.177 --> 00:15:33.139
<v Steve Maudsley>This is used to do a few things: maintain minimum staffing due to absences, Next slide, please.

124
00:15:33.139 --> 00:15:35.639
<v Steve Maudsley>We're facing a reduction of 2 call taker dispatcher positions throughout the certification process.

125
00:15:35.639 --> 00:15:42.080
<v Steve Maudsley>To preserve operational overtime in the peak summer months, we would reduce overtime primarily in the fall and winter.

126
00:15:42.580 --> 00:15:43.970
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

127
00:15:46.639 --> 00:15:53.840
<v Steve Maudsley>We're facing a reduction of 2 call taker dispatcher positions by $285,000, which reduces our capacity to hire academy trainees into permanent positions.

128
00:15:54.692 --> 00:15:56.326
<v Steve Maudsley>Positions pending attrition.

129
00:15:57.198 --> 00:16:02.586
<v Steve Maudsley>Doing so could impact call answer times, which in concert with the trainee pipeline help us stay ahead of anticipated attrition.

130
00:16:03.796 --> 00:16:11.563
<v Steve Maudsley>If we reduce these 2 permanent positions, which account for 1.5% of our total operational FTE, we will have 126 positions left.

131
00:16:13.059 --> 00:16:13.657
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

132
00:16:16.120 --> 00:16:20.597
<v Steve Maudsley>We're facing a reduction in one of 2 assistant operations manager positions by $234,000.

133
00:16:22.938 --> 00:16:25.947
<v Steve Maudsley>Which is one of 7 non-represented positions at the bureau.

134
00:16:26.740 --> 00:16:35.452
<v Steve Maudsley>This position co-leads and mentors the operations supervisor team, oversees policy and procedure updates, and coordinates operational changes with emergency responder agencies.

135
00:16:36.730 --> 00:16:44.758
<v Steve Maudsley>Reducing this position increases workload on the existing manager, reduces responsiveness to service delivery questions, and limits mentoring and employee relations opportunities.

136
00:16:46.169 --> 00:16:46.779
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

137
00:16:49.837 --> 00:16:54.859
<v Steve Maudsley>We are limiting additional reductions by partially implementing the cost allocation change by $1 million.

138
00:16:56.158 --> 00:17:02.158
<v Steve Maudsley>You may recall that BOEC has an intergovernmental agreement with communities and public safety jurisdictions across Multnomah County.

139
00:17:02.816 --> 00:17:09.056
<v Steve Maudsley>The IGA was established in 1995, followed by 2 cost allocation changes in 2000 and 2005.

140
00:17:10.211 --> 00:17:22.538
<v Steve Maudsley>In October of last year, the BOEC User Board approved a change to the cost allocation model that shifts how jurisdictions receiving BOEC services contribute to BOEC's budget, and this is accounted for in the other funds slide of the budget summary slide.

141
00:17:24.609 --> 00:17:25.124
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

142
00:17:28.082 --> 00:17:36.876
<v Steve Maudsley>A budget note in fiscal year '22 allowed BOEC to keep our underspend in a training pipeline subfund that allowed the bureau to overhire trainees while we work to return to full staffing.

143
00:17:38.201 --> 00:17:51.327
<v Steve Maudsley>The pipeline allows for capacity to hold consistent recruitments throughout the year, as we continue improving 911 call answering times, which are measured against a national standard from the National Emergency Number Association, NENA.

144
00:17:51.457 --> 00:18:08.125
<v Steve Maudsley>While we would like to— this— while we would like this funding to eventually be ongoing, this package continues the one-time use for this year projected underspend from fiscal year '26 in the amount of $1.1 million to extend the training pipeline for one more year, reducing the need for additional general fund resources.

145
00:18:08.191 --> 00:18:08.319
<v Dan Ryan>Second.

146
00:18:09.375 --> 00:18:09.906
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

147
00:18:12.019 --> 00:18:16.277
<v Steve Maudsley>Here's a snapshot of our staffing forecast that shows our progress over the last couple of years.

148
00:18:17.279 --> 00:18:26.269
<v Steve Maudsley>We've increased from 90 911-certified employees in July of 2023 to 113 today, with many more in training.

149
00:18:26.413 --> 00:18:30.845
<v Steve Maudsley>We expect to hire 2 academies in this fiscal year with continued use of our training pipeline.

150
00:18:31.954 --> 00:18:32.617
<v Steve Maudsley>Next slide, please.

151
00:18:36.099 --> 00:18:40.597
<v Steve Maudsley>This slide shows you the impacts of fully certified staffing on lowering operational overtime.

152
00:18:41.617 --> 00:18:46.272
<v Steve Maudsley>Overtime is tied to staffing and leave usage, which can fluctuate over time.

153
00:18:46.353 --> 00:18:50.756
<v Steve Maudsley>We've seen a positive trend with our certifications helping reduce operational overtime.

154
00:18:51.510 --> 00:19:02.160
<v Steve Maudsley>As we adjust to reductions over the next year, we expect to maintain our call answering performance and the reduced need for operational overtime, which is down 56% from fiscal year '23.

155
00:19:03.233 --> 00:19:04.567
<v Steve Maudsley>Now I'll hand off to Director Perez.

156
00:19:05.306 --> 00:19:05.691
<v Elizabeth Perez>Good morning.

157
00:19:06.846 --> 00:19:10.861
<v Elizabeth Perez>Elizabeth Perez, for the record, Interim Director of the Portland Bureau of Emergency Management.

158
00:19:11.583 --> 00:19:15.837
<v Elizabeth Perez>PBEM promotes readiness, coordinates response, and builds resilience for Portland.

159
00:19:16.400 --> 00:19:25.278
<v Elizabeth Perez>We develop and implement strategic planning, programs, and policies to continually advance the city's mitigation, preparedness, response, and recovery capabilities.

160
00:19:26.258 --> 00:19:38.092
<v Elizabeth Perez>The bureau currently has 4 program areas: Community resilience and planning, operations, administration, and regional preparedness via the Regional Disaster Preparedness Organization, or RDPO.

161
00:19:38.527 --> 00:19:39.188
<v Elizabeth Perez>Next slide, please.

162
00:19:41.378 --> 00:19:47.221
<v Elizabeth Perez>This is an overview of all the changes to the bureau's budget, including additions, reductions, and realignments.

163
00:19:47.530 --> 00:19:53.865
<v Elizabeth Perez>The proposed budget for the bureau is $4.9 million, which includes about $500,000 in one-time funding.

164
00:19:54.449 --> 00:19:57.153
<v Elizabeth Perez>This is a total ongoing reduction of about $11.3 million.

165
00:19:57.298 --> 00:19:57.428
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

166
00:20:00.199 --> 00:20:08.976
<v Elizabeth Perez>In the other funds column, you'll see the $2.7 million that is federally funded grants and partner funding to the RDPO.

167
00:20:09.848 --> 00:20:13.230
<v Elizabeth Perez>This is a separately governed organization housed in the bureau.

168
00:20:13.650 --> 00:20:19.279
<v Elizabeth Perez>PBEM contributes funding to the RDPO on behalf of the city to maintain its member status.

169
00:20:20.105 --> 00:20:20.654
<v Elizabeth Perez>Next slide, please.

170
00:20:22.231 --> 00:20:26.761
<v Elizabeth Perez>This is an overview of all the changes to the bureau's position counts, including additions, reductions, and realignments.

171
00:20:26.809 --> 00:20:26.954
<v Elizabeth Perez>PBEM is—.

172
00:20:26.988 --> 00:20:27.439
<v Elizabeth Perez>Councilor Herbold.

173
00:20:29.440 --> 00:20:31.314
<v Elizabeth Perez>Comprised of 19 FTE.

174
00:20:31.490 --> 00:20:35.895
<v Elizabeth Perez>6.5 Staff the RDPO and 11.5 staff the bureau.

175
00:20:36.681 --> 00:20:41.856
<v Elizabeth Perez>Note that about a third of the 19 staff do not work on Portland-specific programs.

176
00:20:42.834 --> 00:20:43.218
<v Elizabeth Perez>Next slide.

177
00:20:44.708 --> 00:20:45.541
<v Elizabeth Perez>So what are we preserving?

178
00:20:46.295 --> 00:20:54.450
<v Elizabeth Perez>We're preserving our core work, um, community resilience and planning, operations and administration, as well as the RDPO.

179
00:20:55.250 --> 00:20:58.199
<v Elizabeth Perez>When I started in February, the bureau had 6 vacancies.

180
00:20:58.262 --> 00:20:58.535
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

181
00:20:59.113 --> 00:21:06.075
<v Elizabeth Perez>We created a staffing plan to ensure the bureau mission— we could meet the bureau mission and reduce reliance on contract work.

182
00:21:06.749 --> 00:21:09.347
<v Elizabeth Perez>So I feel really privileged to say that we're hiring.

183
00:21:10.422 --> 00:21:15.330
<v Elizabeth Perez>We are currently in the process of hiring 2 planners, which we were given in this year's budget, so thank you.

184
00:21:16.037 --> 00:21:19.790
<v Elizabeth Perez>And we're also hiring an operations manager and of course the director.

185
00:21:20.769 --> 00:21:31.654
<v Elizabeth Perez>In resilience programming, we will strengthen our mitigation work, complete required plans, and reestablish the continuity of operations capabilities and implement a crisis information management system.

186
00:21:32.955 --> 00:21:40.362
<v Elizabeth Perez>The Neighborhood Emergency Teams, or NET, and COAD, Community Organizations Active in Disasters program, continue their great work.

187
00:21:41.550 --> 00:21:45.872
<v Elizabeth Perez>The NET and COAD— we have about 1,700 active NET volunteers.

188
00:21:46.467 --> 00:21:48.876
<v Elizabeth Perez>As far as we know, this is the largest in the country.

189
00:21:50.017 --> 00:22:00.573
<v Elizabeth Perez>Our volunteers staff 136 events last year, and that's about a value of $1.1 million to Portland taxpayers in 2025.

190
00:22:02.291 --> 00:22:10.521
<v Elizabeth Perez>We have about 350 new volunteers that graduate annually, and we have about 3,600 applicants waiting to be trained.

191
00:22:11.554 --> 00:22:16.326
<v Elizabeth Perez>And then we have 100 community-based organizations preparing their communities for disasters.

192
00:22:16.455 --> 00:22:17.755
<v Elizabeth Perez>So we're really proud of that work.

193
00:22:18.432 --> 00:22:30.298
<v Elizabeth Perez>In operations, we're bolstering our Emergency Operations Center program by upgrading the technology, implementing a citywide incident management team and creating a better schedule for our training and exercise plans.

194
00:22:31.198 --> 00:22:37.604
<v Elizabeth Perez>We'll continue our duty officer program, which is 24/7, 365 incident monitoring for the city.

195
00:22:38.439 --> 00:22:51.040
<v Elizabeth Perez>And we recently hired for the alert and warning program, which is staff that ensures the city can provide timely notifications in emergencies using systems that send messages via modes like cell phone, radio, and TV.

196
00:22:52.342 --> 00:23:02.184
<v Elizabeth Perez>And lastly, the RDPO helps the Portland metro area prepare for disasters by getting cities and agencies to work together and funding shared preparedness efforts.

197
00:23:02.878 --> 00:23:09.984
<v Elizabeth Perez>Since 2003, the RDPO has channeled over $100 million in federal grants to the Portland region through the City of Portland.

198
00:23:10.682 --> 00:23:15.866
<v Elizabeth Perez>At least $20 million of that went directly to improving Portland's own emergency preparedness.

199
00:23:17.492 --> 00:23:28.494
<v Elizabeth Perez>However, federal funding for this program is becoming less predictable, so the RDPO is restructuring to run leaner, making sure it can fulfill its mission even if federal money dries up.

200
00:23:29.522 --> 00:23:37.699
<v Elizabeth Perez>Many of you have seen the EMAP certification chart— that's the red, yellow, green— which indicates that Portland has many opportunities for growth.

201
00:23:37.971 --> 00:23:43.063
<v Elizabeth Perez>So we'll continue to strengthen our critical functions with the intention of achieving that certification.

202
00:23:43.847 --> 00:23:44.817
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

203
00:23:46.854 --> 00:23:50.425
<v Elizabeth Perez>So stepping into the role 3 months ago, I did initial review of spending.

204
00:23:50.943 --> 00:23:52.781
<v Elizabeth Perez>At the time, the bureau had 8 vehicles.

205
00:23:53.296 --> 00:23:58.405
<v Elizabeth Perez>I've eliminated half of those vehicles, resulting in $51,000 of ongoing savings.

206
00:23:59.080 --> 00:24:08.136
<v Elizabeth Perez>Ultimately, the impact here will translate into fewer funds for materials and services in the next year, which affects EOC activation and community resilience efforts.

207
00:24:08.883 --> 00:24:09.252
<v Elizabeth Perez>Next slide.

208
00:24:11.700 --> 00:24:16.708
<v Elizabeth Perez>And as I said previously, PBIM had 6 vacancies in January with the authority to create 2 more.

209
00:24:17.883 --> 00:24:25.496
<v Elizabeth Perez>I worked with the team to review the critical positions that we need to hire to make sure we're executing on our critical functions.

210
00:24:25.884 --> 00:24:28.599
<v Elizabeth Perez>We then prioritize the order in which to hire.

211
00:24:29.616 --> 00:24:33.914
<v Elizabeth Perez>Thus far, we've hired 1 position and are in the process of hiring 3 more.

212
00:24:33.962 --> 00:24:34.108
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

213
00:24:34.396 --> 00:24:35.558
<v Elizabeth Perez>Which includes the director.

214
00:24:36.333 --> 00:24:41.625
<v Elizabeth Perez>In this year's budget, again, we were given 2 planners and the reinstatement of a training and exercise position.

215
00:24:42.142 --> 00:24:45.181
<v Elizabeth Perez>These are all positions we are going to maintain in the budget.

216
00:24:45.958 --> 00:24:46.250
<v Elizabeth Perez>Next slide.

217
00:24:48.873 --> 00:24:55.634
<v Elizabeth Perez>PBEM is reinvesting in its emergency management foundation with 2 connected funding items totaling $536,000.

218
00:24:57.193 --> 00:25:04.155
<v Elizabeth Perez>A new crisis incident management system will give the bureaus One shared real-time view during emergencies.

219
00:25:04.817 --> 00:25:10.104
<v Elizabeth Perez>Implementation is going to take a couple years, and we've started on the procurement process with BTS.

220
00:25:10.589 --> 00:25:16.290
<v Elizabeth Perez>We've also started a work group with emergency managers across the city to make sure it's a success.

221
00:25:17.579 --> 00:25:25.115
<v Elizabeth Perez>Another addition is a 1-year limited-term employee solely focused on strengthening the training and exercise program needed to improve preparedness.

222
00:25:25.710 --> 00:25:28.423
<v Elizabeth Perez>This will help jumpstart the program and get it running smoothly.

223
00:25:29.118 --> 00:25:35.204
<v Elizabeth Perez>And for those who recall, that's Green 13 is where we're trying to move the money over.

224
00:25:36.680 --> 00:25:43.143
<v Elizabeth Perez>Together, these investments are going to restart the city's continuity of operations program, which has been on pause since 2023.

225
00:25:44.243 --> 00:25:50.049
<v Elizabeth Perez>Better technology, better trained people, and a more coordinated city response will help us reach our intended mission.

226
00:25:50.726 --> 00:25:55.752
<v Elizabeth Perez>I thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today, and I'm going to turn it over to my colleague, Chief Johnson.

227
00:25:57.910 --> 00:26:00.309
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Director Perez, and good morning, councilors.

228
00:26:00.987 --> 00:26:05.563
<v Rebecca Dobert>For the record, my name is Lauren Johnson and I'm the fire chief at Portland Fire and Rescue.

229
00:26:06.385 --> 00:26:11.113
<v Rebecca Dobert>I appreciate the opportunity that we have here today to go over our budget for the next fiscal year.

230
00:26:12.910 --> 00:26:15.721
<v Rebecca Dobert>Portland Fire's mission is summarized first on this slide.

231
00:26:16.397 --> 00:26:26.496
<v Rebecca Dobert>We exist to provide fire, medical, and all-hazards emergency response and to protect all of Portland with community health and fire prevention programs.

232
00:26:27.480 --> 00:26:35.788
<v Rebecca Dobert>We use this mission every day to focus our actions, whether in my office or out in the field, and it guided us during budget development.

233
00:26:36.519 --> 00:26:37.269
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide, please.

234
00:26:39.759 --> 00:26:45.284
<v Rebecca Dobert>This slide is an overview of all changes to the bureau's budget, including additions, reductions, and realignments.

235
00:26:45.785 --> 00:26:48.078
<v Rebecca Dobert>Specifics are described in upcoming slides.

236
00:26:48.765 --> 00:27:00.881
<v Rebecca Dobert>The other funds that are shown in this slide reflect FPDNR reimbursements of retirement costs for sworn members, fire prevention service charges and fees, and grant funding for our CHAP program.

237
00:27:02.150 --> 00:27:02.989
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide, please.

238
00:27:05.170 --> 00:27:10.807
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is an overview of all changes to the bureau's position counts, including additions, reductions, and realignments.

239
00:27:11.145 --> 00:27:13.788
<v Rebecca Dobert>Again, specifics are described in the upcoming slides.

240
00:27:14.851 --> 00:27:25.420
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's important to note that 90% of fire staff are sworn responders, and the FTE count shown here includes 22 limited-term positions that are part of the CHAT program.

241
00:27:27.001 --> 00:27:29.105
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

242
00:27:29.913 --> 00:27:34.169
<v Rebecca Dobert>As we get into the next slides, it's critical to keep in mind what we're committed to preserving.

243
00:27:34.942 --> 00:27:39.224
<v Rebecca Dobert>We are maintaining a fire engine or fire truck at every station for fire rescue.

244
00:27:39.500 --> 00:27:41.025
<v Rebecca Dobert>Rescue and medical responses.

245
00:27:42.164 --> 00:27:49.150
<v Rebecca Dobert>CHAT teams are staying, and we're continuing to do the work of providing an alternative to 4-person responses by engines and trucks.

246
00:27:49.951 --> 00:28:04.660
<v Rebecca Dobert>And CHAT will also continue the mission associated with Health Share to provide emergency room and hospital diversion services aimed at ensuring that the people in Portland receive the right time of— type of responder and care in the city.

247
00:28:05.767 --> 00:28:10.157
<v Rebecca Dobert>We are continuing to invest in staff that support the health and wellness of our firefighters.

248
00:28:10.990 --> 00:28:21.296
<v Rebecca Dobert>We are committed to continuing to provide occupational, physical, and mental health oversight and guidance so that our members can receive timely care and connection to resources.

249
00:28:22.192 --> 00:28:28.635
<v Rebecca Dobert>These programs also include screenings for job-related cancers and other illnesses that firefighters are at higher risk for.

250
00:28:29.678 --> 00:28:36.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>This kind of preventative work is contributing toward a healthier workforce that is better prepared to serve the city for decades to come.

251
00:28:38.096 --> 00:28:42.429
<v Rebecca Dobert>We are not cutting specialized responders, fire investigators, or fire inspectors.

252
00:28:43.440 --> 00:28:49.088
<v Rebecca Dobert>These personnel are specialists who support wildfire, marine, and hazardous material responses.

253
00:28:49.847 --> 00:28:54.732
<v Rebecca Dobert>They perform technical rescues and guide the development and sustainment of firewise communities.

254
00:28:55.715 --> 00:29:00.401
<v Rebecca Dobert>These are already very small teams that are widely relied on as subject matter experts.

255
00:29:00.707 --> 00:29:07.147
<v Rebecca Dobert>They attend community meetings, perform public education and code enforcement, and make scene responses daily.

256
00:29:08.594 --> 00:29:12.403
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

257
00:29:12.789 --> 00:29:19.438
<v Rebecca Dobert>For a long time now, fire has not had a capital reserve fund entirely adequate for apparatus replacement.

258
00:29:19.808 --> 00:29:26.229
<v Rebecca Dobert>Instead, we've relied on part of our annual operational funding to provide the required amount of funding for new apparatus.

259
00:29:27.444 --> 00:29:30.775
<v Rebecca Dobert>The next several years will bring higher costs for a number of reasons.

260
00:29:31.145 --> 00:29:35.035
<v Rebecca Dobert>One of note is that we have several apparatus that will be reaching end of life.

261
00:29:35.550 --> 00:29:38.116
<v Rebecca Dobert>These were bought using a 2009 GO bond.

262
00:29:38.955 --> 00:29:42.378
<v Rebecca Dobert>As this large batch ages, maintenance and repair costs increase.

263
00:29:42.991 --> 00:29:49.266
<v Rebecca Dobert>We see this both in terms of parts and the additional hours that our mechanics need to put in to keep our equipment running.

264
00:29:50.778 --> 00:29:55.520
<v Rebecca Dobert>The $1.2 million reduction is the equivalent of one engine that will not be purchased.

265
00:29:55.972 --> 00:30:03.719
<v Rebecca Dobert>That means an existing engine will need to stay on the line for longer, which increases the chances of failure, larger costs, and longer downtimes.

266
00:30:05.500 --> 00:30:06.097
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide, please.

267
00:30:08.599 --> 00:30:11.347
<v Rebecca Dobert>This reduction involves our 2-person medical rescues.

268
00:30:12.027 --> 00:30:15.114
<v Rebecca Dobert>We currently have 3 rescues that operate 24 hours a day.

269
00:30:16.051 --> 00:30:21.017
<v Rebecca Dobert>The reduction to halftime, 12 hours, will be felt most in the areas where the rescues are assigned.

270
00:30:21.788 --> 00:30:27.326
<v Rebecca Dobert>Specifically, these are Council Districts 1 and 3 in the Lentz, Mount Tabor, and Rockwood neighborhoods.

271
00:30:28.513 --> 00:30:34.661
<v Rebecca Dobert>Decreasing the operating times for these units will increase response times and add to the burden of surrounding stations.

272
00:30:35.736 --> 00:30:38.497
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's important to note that this is not a plan for layoffs.

273
00:30:39.171 --> 00:30:48.898
<v Rebecca Dobert>All of our concepts involve reducing the number of firefighters who are working every day and using them to fill vacancies at fire stations that currently being covered by overtime.

274
00:30:50.576 --> 00:30:51.845
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

275
00:30:53.644 --> 00:31:04.383
<v Rebecca Dobert>The next reduction involves removing one fire engine from service, which means that the 4 firefighters who were assigned to that engine each day would be reassigned to fill in as staff at other stations.

276
00:31:05.321 --> 00:31:08.691
<v Rebecca Dobert>Again, the cost savings here is happening by way of reducing overtime.

277
00:31:09.940 --> 00:31:21.317
<v Rebecca Dobert>This will be done at a double company house, which has an engine that brings hoses and water to a fire and a truck that carries the big ladders and specialized rescue equipment to fires and other emergencies.

278
00:31:22.569 --> 00:31:28.618
<v Rebecca Dobert>The end result will be a fire station that loses its engine and keeps its truck and goes from 8 firefighters down to 4.

279
00:31:29.880 --> 00:31:35.164
<v Rebecca Dobert>As you know, we've made the decision for this to be Engine 22 in North Portland, Council District 2.

280
00:31:36.202 --> 00:31:36.707
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

281
00:31:39.422 --> 00:31:43.749
<v Rebecca Dobert>This cut reduces administrative— 2 administrative support positions.

282
00:31:44.112 --> 00:31:45.332
<v Rebecca Dobert>One of which is vacant.

283
00:31:46.118 --> 00:31:48.287
<v Rebecca Dobert>One of these positions is largely clerical.

284
00:31:48.528 --> 00:31:58.775
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's focused on task work like ordering supplies, select monthly and annual reports, phone tree management, and other general office work that will be assigned to higher-level positions.

285
00:31:59.835 --> 00:32:01.633
<v Rebecca Dobert>The second position is currently vacant.

286
00:32:01.778 --> 00:32:18.936
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's an analyst position that would have been assigned specific duties associated with the bureau's strategic plan, maintaining and updating our inventory of agreements, with outside agency partners, reviewing dashboards for trends, and providing recommendations to leadership on specific focus areas.

287
00:32:19.991 --> 00:32:20.233
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

288
00:32:23.306 --> 00:32:25.181
<v Rebecca Dobert>CHAT is our community health program.

289
00:32:25.650 --> 00:32:36.443
<v Rebecca Dobert>They provide follow-up medical services to overdose patients and connect them with longer-term resources, and they provide medical aftercare to clients that need extra support and access to social services.

290
00:32:36.491 --> 00:32:36.589
<v Elizabeth Perez>Thank you.

291
00:32:38.190 --> 00:32:41.284
<v Rebecca Dobert>This cut reduces CHAT's funding by $500,000.

292
00:32:42.440 --> 00:32:51.061
<v Rebecca Dobert>$2 Million in one-time funding is expiring and is being replaced by $1.5 million that's coming from a congressional earmark to the city.

293
00:32:52.626 --> 00:33:04.217
<v Rebecca Dobert>These changes will impact our ability to use CHAT as an alternative over sending a 4-person apparatus because the remaining funds come from grants that have specific mission requirements that we will need to continue.

294
00:33:06.000 --> 00:33:12.608
<v Rebecca Dobert>This will increase the burden on fire engines, fire trucks, and our county EMS responder, AMR.

295
00:33:13.190 --> 00:33:20.182
<v Rebecca Dobert>Another impact that is notable is the chance that our state partners will pull back because of a perceived change in commitment on the city's side.

296
00:33:21.183 --> 00:33:26.863
<v Rebecca Dobert>This does result in the elimination of a sworn fire deputy chief and the program strategist.

297
00:33:28.339 --> 00:33:28.778
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

298
00:33:32.765 --> 00:33:35.334
<v Rebecca Dobert>This slide notes a change to our payout budget.

299
00:33:35.575 --> 00:33:46.685
<v Rebecca Dobert>This decision was based on an analysis by our financial partners in the service area who have noted that there's a significant difference between our payout costs when there's a 27th pay period and when there is not.

300
00:33:47.602 --> 00:33:54.136
<v Rebecca Dobert>About 70% of our separation payouts come during a 27th pay period lookback month.

301
00:33:54.766 --> 00:34:01.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>And FY 26-27 does not have a 27th pay period, so we can afford to make this reduction for the upcoming year.

302
00:34:02.449 --> 00:34:05.303
<v Rebecca Dobert>However, the next one will be in October 2027.

303
00:34:07.065 --> 00:34:07.538
<v Eric Zimmerman>Next slide.

304
00:34:10.402 --> 00:34:15.291
<v Rebecca Dobert>This slide shows the added amount that we expect to recover by increasing fire prevention fees.

305
00:34:16.048 --> 00:34:27.318
<v Rebecca Dobert>This is really part of an ongoing effort to make sure that we're routinely looking at our peers and keeping in best practices when it comes to cost recovery and accounting for the dollars associated with doing this work.

306
00:34:28.048 --> 00:34:33.708
<v Rebecca Dobert>The last major updates to our fee schedule were done in 2016, with only a few changes since then.

307
00:34:35.050 --> 00:34:35.809
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide, please.

308
00:34:39.467 --> 00:34:43.054
<v Rebecca Dobert>We're sharing this slide to show you how our staffing can change in big swings.

309
00:34:43.764 --> 00:34:55.871
<v Rebecca Dobert>The reason why this is important is because separations can happen in big chunks and although we are hiring to counter the attrition, recruitment and training takes about 1 year, and it's difficult to get ahead of these retirement cliffs.

310
00:34:56.849 --> 00:35:03.617
<v Rebecca Dobert>This forecast is something that we monitor constantly, and doing this allows us to try to keep pace and smooth out our staffing levels.

311
00:35:04.550 --> 00:35:04.983
<v Rebecca Dobert>Next slide.

312
00:35:07.320 --> 00:35:12.086
<v Rebecca Dobert>On the last slide, we noted that we plan to hire and train about 30 new firefighters next year.

313
00:35:12.619 --> 00:35:21.239
<v Rebecca Dobert>This slide shows the relationship between the number of non-recruit firefighters and backfill overtime that we use to ensure full staffing every day.

314
00:35:22.523 --> 00:35:32.077
<v Rebecca Dobert>As we move through next fiscal year and the firefighters that we've hired recently move from the training academy to the stations, we anticipate a reduction in our overtime costs.

315
00:35:32.463 --> 00:36:01.407
<v Rebecca Dobert>However, we know that the 27th pay period lookback in October of '27 is looming, and this is another retirement cliff that will significantly impact our the notes here highlight that each new firefighter coming out of the academy to the station reduces overtime by about 2,000 hours per year, and that the additional FTE that were allotted to us over the past few years have reduced 33,000 overtime hours from FY24 to now.

316
00:36:02.498 --> 00:36:03.831
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's a reduction of 13%.

317
00:36:04.248 --> 00:36:06.719
<v Rebecca Dobert>And that's the end of my section.

318
00:36:07.250 --> 00:36:08.855
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm going to turn it back over to DCA Causie.

319
00:36:08.902 --> 00:36:09.594
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Deputy City Administrator Morillo.

320
00:36:10.123 --> 00:36:10.572
<v Bob Causie>Thank you, Chief.

321
00:36:11.391 --> 00:36:20.172
<v Bob Causie>As I mentioned earlier, we'll focus on community safety, the DCA's office, and PPB in the upcoming budget work session on Wednesday, May 13th.

322
00:36:20.556 --> 00:36:22.804
<v Bob Causie>And at this point, we're prepared to answer any questions.

323
00:36:23.108 --> 00:36:23.302
<v Bob Causie>Thank you.

324
00:36:24.554 --> 00:36:25.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so very much.

325
00:36:26.335 --> 00:36:32.755
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, I plan on having us take a quick break in about, oh, about half an hour or so.

326
00:36:32.996 --> 00:36:36.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>We've been in here for only about half an hour, so we're going to start with folks in the queue.

327
00:36:36.288 --> 00:36:37.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark, kick us off.

328
00:36:39.175 --> 00:36:40.219
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

329
00:36:41.166 --> 00:36:44.840
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I have a couple of questions, but I want to say a few things.

330
00:36:45.257 --> 00:36:50.518
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, I have to say, this is probably one of the most painful and depressing times I've been on the dais.

331
00:36:51.594 --> 00:36:56.760
<v Olivia Clark>Um, but first, I'll just say I want to thank, uh, DCA Causie for your service.

332
00:36:57.369 --> 00:37:03.224
<v Olivia Clark>It's been a pleasure to work with you, and I, I appreciate everything that you've done, uh, in, in your service.

333
00:37:03.545 --> 00:37:03.980
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

334
00:37:04.125 --> 00:37:04.686
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you.

335
00:37:04.927 --> 00:37:19.139
<v Olivia Clark>I also want to thank the firefighters that are here today for what they do every day, and for those who just responded to the MAC Club disaster, which could have been much worse if it weren't for, I guess, for Providence.

336
00:37:20.407 --> 00:37:26.864
<v Olivia Clark>And thank you for risking your lives, the people who responded to a situation that could have been very horrific.

337
00:37:27.489 --> 00:37:31.766
<v Olivia Clark>And I know these are the kinds of things that you are often called Thank you.

338
00:37:31.847 --> 00:37:34.251
<v Olivia Clark>And I appreciate you very much, all of you.

339
00:37:36.510 --> 00:37:43.983
<v Olivia Clark>And Chief Johnson, I just want to say I appreciate your service and the fact that you mentioned assets, asset management, which is a high priority for me.

340
00:37:44.371 --> 00:37:51.804
<v Olivia Clark>I realize we're far behind in taking care of our equipment, our fire stations, etc., and that's a high priority for me as well.

341
00:37:53.150 --> 00:38:03.422
<v Olivia Clark>But this is really a sad day for me because If our mission is a safe Portland for all, I think we're violating our mission with these proposed cuts.

342
00:38:04.851 --> 00:38:18.317
<v Olivia Clark>I— when I first came into this office, I realized that we were already short, that due to our geography, our rivers, the conditions of our bridges, that we're already underserved.

343
00:38:19.456 --> 00:38:22.764
<v Olivia Clark>And to me, Councilor Smith.

344
00:38:22.844 --> 00:38:27.762
<v Olivia Clark>Fire service, public safety is a core function of government.

345
00:38:28.936 --> 00:38:36.536
<v Olivia Clark>You know, in addition to clean water, to appropriate sewage disposal, to safe streets, public safety is at the top of the list.

346
00:38:36.617 --> 00:38:41.070
<v Olivia Clark>So I'm very— feeling very bad about this.

347
00:38:42.942 --> 00:38:49.608
<v Olivia Clark>I realize there are some bridges that our equipment can't even go over and makes our response time even worse.

348
00:38:51.230 --> 00:38:53.615
<v Olivia Clark>We, uh, response time is of great concern to me.

349
00:38:54.583 --> 00:38:56.228
<v Olivia Clark>So I have a couple questions.

350
00:38:57.219 --> 00:39:10.987
<v Olivia Clark>Um, one is about how the proposed budget cuts will affect the CEI Hub and protecting the CEI Hub, which is in my district and has been an ongoing concern for me since I was elected to this office.

351
00:39:11.893 --> 00:39:13.445
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know who can answer that.

352
00:39:14.320 --> 00:39:18.253
<v Olivia Clark>I also would like to ask a question about the impact on response time.

353
00:39:21.097 --> 00:39:22.780
<v Elizabeth Perez>I can start with the CEI Hub.

354
00:39:23.005 --> 00:39:27.721
<v Elizabeth Perez>Um, like I said, in this year's budget we got 2 planners.

355
00:39:27.817 --> 00:39:29.228
<v Elizabeth Perez>We're still hiring for them.

356
00:39:29.902 --> 00:39:34.536
<v Elizabeth Perez>Our senior planner is actually going to be focused on CEI Hub, among other things.

357
00:39:35.226 --> 00:39:44.655
<v Elizabeth Perez>So we're actually still in building mode for PBEM, so I don't see any current impact to our planning for that.

358
00:39:44.914 --> 00:39:46.711
<v Elizabeth Perez>We're still just getting started.

359
00:39:47.181 --> 00:39:53.452
<v Elizabeth Perez>And our Chief Resilience Officer currently meets with BPS on a regular basis because we're doing that in partnership.

360
00:39:55.677 --> 00:39:58.639
<v Elizabeth Perez>That's all being said, we have a lot of work to do there.

361
00:39:58.817 --> 00:40:05.835
<v Elizabeth Perez>And I think there is opportunity within PBEM, but then also at the state and federal level to get additional funding there.

362
00:40:06.219 --> 00:40:13.675
<v Olivia Clark>Well, you may be in a planning mode, but I'm thinking about the cut that's coming to, I think it's the St. Johns Station.

363
00:40:14.813 --> 00:40:19.360
<v Olivia Clark>That station protects the CEI hub, and I'm concerned about that.

364
00:40:19.873 --> 00:40:26.036
<v Olivia Clark>In addition, I'm glad you're planning, but I'm concerned about right now and what the cut will mean to the CEI hub.

365
00:40:28.057 --> 00:40:28.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Councilor.

366
00:40:28.925 --> 00:40:30.119
<v Rebecca Dobert>I can jump in on that.

367
00:40:31.429 --> 00:40:51.835
<v Rebecca Dobert>So it's important to note that the first-due apparatus that responds to the CEI hub, that station was preserved, and that even the change with taking Engine 22 out of the mix doesn't change the number of resources that we send to any emergency, whether it's at the CEI hub or at somebody's house down the street.

368
00:40:52.833 --> 00:41:04.036
<v Rebecca Dobert>But at the same time, acknowledge— I acknowledge that anytime we take a unit out of our system, which is a closed system, it's going to impact response times.

369
00:41:04.248 --> 00:41:09.375
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I know you had follow-up Questions about response times, so I'd be happy to address that.

370
00:41:10.418 --> 00:41:10.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Right.

371
00:41:11.126 --> 00:41:17.697
<v Olivia Clark>Um, can you talk about what the impact of these cuts will be on response times generally around the city?

372
00:41:17.826 --> 00:41:18.099
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>It's—.

373
00:41:18.211 --> 00:41:19.465
<v Olivia Clark>We're already struggling.

374
00:41:19.577 --> 00:41:22.181
<v Olivia Clark>I know, I know we've made improvements, but we have a ways to go.

375
00:41:22.871 --> 00:41:23.240
<v Rebecca Dobert>I can.

376
00:41:23.498 --> 00:41:24.463
<v Olivia Clark>Yes, thank you.

377
00:41:24.800 --> 00:41:25.523
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sorry about that.

378
00:41:25.909 --> 00:41:30.760
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, yeah, no, I— this is top of mind for me, and I, I've watched your work sessions.

379
00:41:30.809 --> 00:41:36.929
<v Rebecca Dobert>I understand that it's top of mind for all of you and our firefighters and everybody out in the community.

380
00:41:37.025 --> 00:41:38.407
<v Rebecca Dobert>So it's important to talk about it.

381
00:41:39.018 --> 00:41:40.576
<v Rebecca Dobert>Like I said, we're a closed system.

382
00:41:40.704 --> 00:41:42.840
<v Rebecca Dobert>We only have a certain number of resources.

383
00:41:42.952 --> 00:41:50.534
<v Rebecca Dobert>So it stands to reason that anytime we're taking units out of that system, we expect our response times to increase.

384
00:41:51.690 --> 00:41:59.431
<v Rebecca Dobert>There are a couple of things that it's important that you know we are doing to hopefully counteract that or dampen that effect.

385
00:41:59.788 --> 00:42:12.536
<v Rebecca Dobert>One is making sure that we do have a responder from every station that's still available so that your neighborhood responder is still coming, even if it's not that fire engine.

386
00:42:14.119 --> 00:42:21.862
<v Rebecca Dobert>Something that citywide we have noticed a difference in is the number of calls that are related to unsheltered or houseless folks.

387
00:42:23.068 --> 00:42:30.833
<v Rebecca Dobert>We know that just in general, the number of, of people who use our services are largely part of that population.

388
00:42:31.025 --> 00:42:40.273
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so as work continues across the city to improve that situation, we are hoping that the number of calls that we are called out to are reduced.

389
00:42:41.302 --> 00:42:50.726
<v Rebecca Dobert>Something else that was started before I even came and that is really important work is a call allocation project that's happening just in fire.

390
00:42:51.481 --> 00:42:54.836
<v Rebecca Dobert>And what that's looking at primarily is EMS responses.

391
00:42:55.028 --> 00:43:22.373
<v Rebecca Dobert>But so since, like I said, before I got here, so the end of last fiscal year, we've been taking call types and working with the medical director to understand if it's a call that we need to continue to go on or if the community is served just as well to have AMR answer that call and keep our resources available for higher acuity calls and not respond to some of those most low acuity calls.

392
00:43:23.273 --> 00:43:33.726
<v Rebecca Dobert>The last thing that we do every day but will be more of a focus with Engine 22 out of service is just what we think of as dynamic resource deployment.

393
00:43:33.822 --> 00:43:37.530
<v Rebecca Dobert>So we have an officer that's stationed in Boeck.

394
00:43:38.702 --> 00:44:07.617
<v Rebecca Dobert>He's a fire liaison, and his job their job is to make sure that the right responders from fire are assigned to those calls that come into 911, but then also to basically have eyes on our map and watch units across the city so that if we do have a section of the city that's impacted by simultaneous incidents, that fire liaison and any of our on-duty chiefs can coordinate resources.

395
00:44:07.713 --> 00:44:07.938
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

396
00:44:08.371 --> 00:44:11.146
<v Rebecca Dobert>Would make decisions to move our resources around.

397
00:44:11.242 --> 00:44:24.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>So we would move up apparatus to different stations across the city to try to spread our resources out until those initial responding units get freed up from their incident and get to move back to their regular station.

398
00:44:25.612 --> 00:44:42.177
<v Rebecca Dobert>So specific to the, um, reduction of Engine 22, that means that the focus for us and the focus for the fire liaison, for the fire chiefs that are on duty 24/7, is keeping a specific eye on that area to watch.

399
00:44:42.514 --> 00:44:54.925
<v Rebecca Dobert>If Engine 22 and the station adjacent, Engine 26, are both tied up, then we plan to move resources into that area to help adjust our coverage.

400
00:44:55.918 --> 00:45:01.739
<v Olivia Clark>Well, I appreciate that response and the effort to have dynamic response deployment.

401
00:45:03.639 --> 00:45:03.931
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

402
00:45:03.978 --> 00:45:09.782
<v Olivia Clark>To me, it sounds like, you know, doing more with less, kind of like a peanut butter, spreading things around pretty thinly.

403
00:45:12.210 --> 00:45:18.588
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's difficult because I do feel that we're understaffed, underprotected, and very vulnerable throughout the city.

404
00:45:20.195 --> 00:45:25.168
<v Olivia Clark>Well, rest assured that I'll be looking for additional resources to restore some of these cuts as best I can.

405
00:45:26.088 --> 00:45:28.898
<v Olivia Clark>And I appreciate your all being here and explaining this to us.

406
00:45:29.427 --> 00:45:30.829
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, and thank you all for being here.

407
00:45:31.619 --> 00:45:33.054
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

408
00:45:33.393 --> 00:45:34.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

409
00:45:35.876 --> 00:45:36.956
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you, Council President.

410
00:45:37.021 --> 00:45:46.521
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, thank you all so much for being here and presenting today, and thank you very much to the firefighters who showed up today in your shirts to show us, uh, how important this is for the city.

411
00:45:46.715 --> 00:45:58.018
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that, uh, it's really critical that we respect the city employees and unions that come here to represent their interests, because the reality is that, uh, most of you live in the city of Portland and you're our Thank you.

412
00:45:58.065 --> 00:45:59.251
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Koyama Lane, you are our constituent.

413
00:45:59.300 --> 00:46:01.382
<v Angelita Morillo>You are our constituents too, and you provide a vital service for the city.

414
00:46:01.447 --> 00:46:02.905
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you very much for being here.

415
00:46:03.369 --> 00:46:05.340
<v Angelita Morillo>Your presence is noted and honored.

416
00:46:05.998 --> 00:46:13.610
<v Angelita Morillo>And I agree with Councilor Clark, this is very painful as far as— I don't think a single one of these budget sessions has not been painful.

417
00:46:14.427 --> 00:46:14.780
<v Olivia Clark>There are—.

418
00:46:15.548 --> 00:46:18.032
<v Angelita Morillo>I've said it before and I'll say it again, I don't think there is any fat left to trim.

419
00:46:18.193 --> 00:46:20.019
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't think there's anything extra left to cut.

420
00:46:20.115 --> 00:46:23.594
<v Angelita Morillo>Every single employee, every single program is critical.

421
00:46:25.378 --> 00:46:29.072
<v Angelita Morillo>And DCA Causie, thank you so much for everything that you've done.

422
00:46:29.170 --> 00:46:37.608
<v Angelita Morillo>It's been such a pleasure working with you, and you have just always been so level-headed, kind, and generous in how you approach the work, and I just appreciate you very much.

423
00:46:37.800 --> 00:46:38.362
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

424
00:46:38.588 --> 00:46:52.536
<v Angelita Morillo>I have a few questions about FYRE, and one is regarding CHAT, the replacement of the expiring one-time grant funding with $1.5 million in federal grants.

425
00:46:53.409 --> 00:46:59.365
<v Angelita Morillo>What assurance do we have that this grant funding will come in the next fiscal year, or— and has it been awarded yet?

426
00:47:01.329 --> 00:47:04.851
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm gonna phone a friend to get a timeline on that.

427
00:47:07.670 --> 00:47:11.103
<v Rebecca Dobert>Chief Wilson right behind— or do you have an update?

428
00:47:11.510 --> 00:47:13.155
<v Rebecca Dobert>We haven't heard anything.

429
00:47:14.628 --> 00:47:15.213
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Oh, okay.

430
00:47:17.065 --> 00:47:19.536
<v Rebecca Dobert>So we haven't gotten an update on that.

431
00:47:20.067 --> 00:47:22.010
<v Rebecca Dobert>And I would need to follow up.

432
00:47:22.251 --> 00:47:29.369
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's from SAMHSA, which is the federal mental health and substance abuse organization.

433
00:47:31.164 --> 00:47:32.668
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I'm happy to follow up on that one.

434
00:47:33.349 --> 00:47:40.255
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, that's good to know because I think we have to factor in, you know, how sure some of these numbers are so we can calculate the risk or lack of risk there.

435
00:47:40.402 --> 00:47:44.490
<v Angelita Morillo>So that's also helpful to know and look forward to getting that information as well.

436
00:47:44.931 --> 00:47:45.648
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, thanks for that.

437
00:47:47.375 --> 00:47:52.766
<v Angelita Morillo>Another question I had was regarding the 2-person rescue unit reduction.

438
00:47:52.864 --> 00:47:58.235
<v Angelita Morillo>I think we've kind of touched on that a bit, but— and it's okay if you don't know all of this off the top of your head.

439
00:47:58.298 --> 00:48:03.668
<v Angelita Morillo>I think I'm asking very technical questions, but do you know what percentage of your calls are for medical responses?

440
00:48:07.769 --> 00:48:09.315
<v Rebecca Dobert>Let me look at Elizabeth.

441
00:48:09.657 --> 00:48:10.518
<v Rebecca Dobert>We'll pull that up.

442
00:48:12.166 --> 00:48:13.739
<v Rebecca Dobert>I mean, we've got a rough dashboard.

443
00:48:13.851 --> 00:48:16.402
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'd say, you know, 60 to 80%.

444
00:48:16.818 --> 00:48:17.653
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay.

445
00:48:18.023 --> 00:48:19.465
<v Rebecca Dobert>And it's quite a bit.

446
00:48:20.027 --> 00:48:33.086
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah, I was asking because I know, you know, if we're reducing the 2-person rescue unit in Districts 1 and 3, I want to get sort of a mental picture of what that actually looks like for the people who are getting our services.

447
00:48:33.681 --> 00:48:50.880
<v Angelita Morillo>So if someone is calling 911 and they need an advanced medical response, Let me talk about that a little bit, and if we have more info, Elizabeth can come up with specific percentages.

448
00:48:51.500 --> 00:49:04.179
<v Rebecca Dobert>So one thing that's important to note about this reduction and why it was at the top of our cut concepts is because they are only 2-person medical units, and so we cannot provide any fire protection for those units.

449
00:49:04.179 --> 00:49:04.300
<v Angelita Morillo>So that's a 2-person medical unit?

450
00:49:06.626 --> 00:49:15.514
<v Rebecca Dobert>Whereas from our engines and trucks, those were further down on our proposed list because they will answer medical calls and they'll also provide fire protection.

451
00:49:16.255 --> 00:49:23.239
<v Rebecca Dobert>So it was— that was the risk assessment that got us to reducing the hours for the 3-person rescues.

452
00:49:24.070 --> 00:49:29.387
<v Rebecca Dobert>To the point about ALS response in those areas, I mean, it's important to note that those responses are not emergency responses.

453
00:49:29.452 --> 00:49:29.565
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay.

454
00:49:29.675 --> 00:49:34.239
<v Rebecca Dobert>Rescues are there because of the call volume and the demand out in those areas.

455
00:49:34.898 --> 00:49:36.632
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's why those units are stationed there.

456
00:49:37.242 --> 00:49:43.815
<v Rebecca Dobert>They have a paramedic on them and they are ALS responders, but so are our engines and trucks.

457
00:49:43.992 --> 00:50:02.329
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so the removal of those, or when those rescues are out because it's an off-peak hour, then the engine from that station will be making that ALS But it is 3 less units during non-peak hours that would be making that medical response.

458
00:50:03.530 --> 00:50:03.724
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Gotcha.

459
00:50:03.820 --> 00:50:15.753
<v Angelita Morillo>So I'm assuming when you compared what you had to calculate, it's even with a whole fire engine going, it's less expensive to preserve that with the dual system rather than the alternative?

460
00:50:17.567 --> 00:50:27.264
<v Rebecca Dobert>So, I mean, that was definitely one of the factors is how much cost we could recover If we close the rescues versus closing an engine.

461
00:50:27.927 --> 00:50:41.175
<v Rebecca Dobert>The other thing that's a really big factor for us is the amount of calls that happen in those areas, and that taking them out completely would make the workload for the remaining fire stations untenable.

462
00:50:42.373 --> 00:50:47.726
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay, so we would end up, you know, that would end up drawing resources from other areas to that side of town.

463
00:50:48.923 --> 00:50:49.070
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Gotcha.

464
00:50:49.166 --> 00:50:49.505
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay.

465
00:50:49.639 --> 00:50:50.367
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay, thank you so much.

466
00:50:50.418 --> 00:50:51.181
<v Angelita Morillo>That was very helpful.

467
00:50:54.219 --> 00:50:57.934
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay, 65% medical in FY 24-25.

468
00:50:58.063 --> 00:50:59.273
<v Angelita Morillo>Oh, okay, thanks.

469
00:50:59.402 --> 00:51:03.083
<v Angelita Morillo>That's actually a little bit less than I was expecting, so that's good to have a concrete number on that.

470
00:51:04.338 --> 00:51:05.590
<v Angelita Morillo>I have one more question.

471
00:51:06.411 --> 00:51:13.577
<v Angelita Morillo>Chief Johnson, you touched on a couple of response times, but a few years ago we were dealing with having zero ambulances available frequently.

472
00:51:15.789 --> 00:51:23.420
<v Angelita Morillo>How are we reconciling that with the county EMS and AMR with these specific cuts?

473
00:51:23.485 --> 00:51:25.534
<v Angelita Morillo>Or like, how did those— have you been in contact with them?

474
00:51:25.646 --> 00:51:26.755
<v Angelita Morillo>How have those conversations gone?

475
00:51:27.188 --> 00:51:28.282
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes, thank you.

476
00:51:28.797 --> 00:51:38.744
<v Rebecca Dobert>We're in contact with AMR talking about— part of it is talking about the call allocation, so letting them know what we're going to take ourselves off of.

477
00:51:38.938 --> 00:51:42.358
<v Rebecca Dobert>And that's really in an effort to make sure that we're available for the higher Thank you.

478
00:51:42.407 --> 00:51:44.074
<v Rebecca Dobert>So that's the fire acuity or those ALS calls.

479
00:51:45.375 --> 00:51:56.878
<v Rebecca Dobert>The other area that's impacted by this that's not specific to AMR is the partnership we have with Gresham at Station 31, which is in District 1 out east.

480
00:51:58.001 --> 00:52:02.445
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I've been in contact with their fire chief to let them know about the reduction that's coming.

481
00:52:02.958 --> 00:52:13.047
<v Rebecca Dobert>And then I think Councilor Novick is working on getting a presentation together from FHIR and AMR to describe just what moving forward looks like with EMS.

482
00:52:15.637 --> 00:52:15.829
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Awesome.

483
00:52:15.974 --> 00:52:16.456
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you so much.

484
00:52:16.505 --> 00:52:16.987
<v Olivia Clark>Appreciate your time.

485
00:52:17.519 --> 00:52:17.811
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

486
00:52:18.117 --> 00:52:19.072
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Maria.

487
00:52:19.251 --> 00:52:20.108
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Koyama Lane.

488
00:52:21.030 --> 00:52:22.342
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

489
00:52:22.471 --> 00:52:23.733
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you everyone for being here today.

490
00:52:23.862 --> 00:52:24.574
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you for the presentation.

491
00:52:25.952 --> 00:52:32.672
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Before I get into some more specifics, I just want to clarify the, the budgeting process and how the reductions are decided.

492
00:52:32.737 --> 00:52:42.474
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So my understanding is bureau leadership is asked to identify some potential reductions, and then ultimately the mayor makes those decisions on which ones to bring forward.

493
00:52:42.572 --> 00:52:43.025
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is that correct?

494
00:52:44.697 --> 00:52:53.045
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'm just curious about if our union leaders included in any of that brainstorming or conversations, specifically with, with fire?

495
00:52:54.789 --> 00:52:54.981
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes.

496
00:52:55.047 --> 00:53:05.315
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I feel very fortunate to be working well with the firefighters union and appreciate so much their work and for their presence today.

497
00:53:06.086 --> 00:53:13.606
<v Rebecca Dobert>We have had lots of difficult conversations about where we were with our cut concepts and why we were in this position that we were in.

498
00:53:14.280 --> 00:53:23.231
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so although it's not the outcome that they desired, and I understand that, it's something that we've been in communication about and have had—.

499
00:53:23.985 --> 00:53:37.865
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I've been really open to hearing all And Chief Johnson, I want to highlight how you've hit the ground running.

500
00:53:38.076 --> 00:53:44.137
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I was at your swearing-in ceremony and saw how powerful it was to have folks handing you off here.

501
00:53:44.202 --> 00:53:56.518
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And as a rank-and-file union member, I really value what I hear from workers, and I'm hearing from a lot of firefighters that they're genuinely impressed by the trust that you're building and momentum there.

502
00:53:56.807 --> 00:54:00.978
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that's something that means a lot and that I'm hearing.

503
00:54:01.396 --> 00:54:01.751
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

504
00:54:02.282 --> 00:54:06.085
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Overall, I'm really concerned about the proposed cuts to the Fire Bureau.

505
00:54:07.117 --> 00:54:09.969
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Like my colleague said, these cuts aren't to excess.

506
00:54:10.034 --> 00:54:16.063
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>They're cuts to core services, including literal fire companies that our community relies on.

507
00:54:16.726 --> 00:54:31.684
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And from conversations I've had, I've heard that The Fire Bureau has made really hard choices, you know, over the last 5, 10 years, cutting a lot of administrative capacity and protecting community-facing services and work.

508
00:54:32.394 --> 00:54:43.197
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And that is maybe different from some of the other public service, public safety bureaus in Portland, and that you're really running bare bones.

509
00:54:43.538 --> 00:55:00.097
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I will say, We, we've also— I've also heard from different firefighters, and we've heard it from our constituents, that the chat program supports this, their work, a lot, that it helps firefighters respond more effectively.

510
00:55:00.534 --> 00:55:06.315
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We had community members show up to our D3 listening session specifically sharing how the chat team has supported them.

511
00:55:07.889 --> 00:55:10.525
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So I am, I'm really thinking about that.

512
00:55:10.606 --> 00:55:25.215
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And one of my questions too is, if this is a bureau that's continued to cut Like all of the administrative pieces, and they've, uh, which I feel like has been the right thing, and has— have left their funding towards, uh, community-facing services.

513
00:55:26.114 --> 00:55:35.943
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Mr. Mayor, have you thought about the cuts over the last 10 years and how they've looked, um, with the Fire Bureau compared to, um, other bureaus like the Police Bureau?

514
00:55:36.023 --> 00:55:42.436
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What I've heard is that it's been kind of flip-flopped in a, in a way, that there are no people really doing the administrative work.

515
00:55:42.565 --> 00:55:42.663
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah.

516
00:55:43.547 --> 00:55:44.456
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>In fire anymore.

517
00:55:44.827 --> 00:55:50.565
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so those cuts are going to feel a lot different than other bureaus that have made those cuts differently.

518
00:55:55.269 --> 00:55:59.777
<v Keith Wilson>Chief Johnson and I were just talking about that yesterday, and I can just give you some high-level numbers.

519
00:56:00.132 --> 00:56:04.510
<v Keith Wilson>They're off the top of my mind, so take it with a grain of salt.

520
00:56:05.869 --> 00:56:17.702
<v Keith Wilson>Fire since 2005, Had 670 sworn firefighters, and today they have 710.

521
00:56:19.277 --> 00:56:23.650
<v Keith Wilson>They had 29 fire stations, now they have 31.

522
00:56:24.646 --> 00:56:28.514
<v Keith Wilson>They did take on additional geography, 3 stations in the east.

523
00:56:29.789 --> 00:56:34.096
<v Keith Wilson>And so what we've seen, and you're right, administratively about the same, right?

524
00:56:34.242 --> 00:56:35.501
<v Keith Wilson>Back office staff about the same.

525
00:56:35.599 --> 00:56:37.835
<v Keith Wilson>So thinking about technology, productivity, and so on, that's about right.

526
00:56:38.065 --> 00:56:43.976
<v Keith Wilson>So they've seen Status quo, if not a little bit gain.

527
00:56:44.329 --> 00:56:51.376
<v Keith Wilson>When we look at PPB or police, in 2005 they had 1,057 sworn officers.

528
00:56:51.954 --> 00:56:53.672
<v Keith Wilson>Today they have 822.

529
00:56:55.021 --> 00:56:57.108
<v Keith Wilson>In 2005 they had 5 precincts.

530
00:56:57.572 --> 00:56:59.065
<v Keith Wilson>Today they have 3.

531
00:57:00.014 --> 00:57:17.010
<v Keith Wilson>So when we think about those 2 public safety response systems, it is clear PPB has had a reduction of overall headcount of about 20 to 23%, yet our city has grown significantly in that time.

532
00:57:17.092 --> 00:57:23.340
<v Keith Wilson>So just to answer your question, those are the numbers and they're pretty close to that.

533
00:57:25.827 --> 00:57:26.586
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

534
00:57:26.797 --> 00:57:32.768
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I will say that it feels like we're asking the same bureau, the Fire Bureau, to absorb cuts.

535
00:57:33.630 --> 00:57:38.559
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I hear us saying a lot there's no fat to trim, which I actually believe with this bureau.

536
00:57:39.465 --> 00:57:46.275
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I, I do see some areas where it seems like there is some fat or there are some extras.

537
00:57:46.389 --> 00:57:50.550
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>There's literally a line item for downtown marketing, an ad for that.

538
00:57:51.063 --> 00:57:52.545
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So that's— it's hard to see those.

539
00:57:53.206 --> 00:57:59.335
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, and I also wanted to clarify to make sure I understand what's happening with CHAT.

540
00:57:59.429 --> 00:58:09.449
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So we— is it correct that we have funded it with $2 million of general fund dollars and now we're switching over to grants?

541
00:58:09.932 --> 00:58:12.429
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so that $500,000 is just— is really that gap there?

542
00:58:12.653 --> 00:58:13.909
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

543
00:58:15.811 --> 00:58:20.373
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I just— I've said this already, I've said this before, but want to be clear.

544
00:58:20.422 --> 00:58:27.498
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm going to have a hard time supporting a budget that includes cuts to any companies fire companies in any of the districts.

545
00:58:27.643 --> 00:58:32.365
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I love District 3, but I think all of the districts are connected and we should care about all of them.

546
00:58:32.704 --> 00:58:36.621
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'm going to have a very hard time seeing us reduce our capacity in CHAT also.

547
00:58:38.800 --> 00:58:39.768
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

548
00:58:40.043 --> 00:58:40.688
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

549
00:58:41.722 --> 00:58:42.708
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

550
00:58:42.934 --> 00:58:47.844
<v Steve Novick>I wanted to just follow up a bit, Chief Johnson, on Councilor Murillo's line of questioning.

551
00:58:48.996 --> 00:58:59.797
<v Steve Novick>And as you said, next month I'm hoping to do a Public Safety Committee, uh, the Community and Public Safety Committee discussion of the relationship, um, between the city and the county on emergency medical services.

552
00:58:59.974 --> 00:59:10.394
<v Steve Novick>But just briefly, um, I hear from people out in the world that, wait a minute, why is fire responding to these medical calls and they and, they and AMR both show up?

553
00:59:10.474 --> 00:59:11.264
<v Steve Novick>Isn't that wasteful?

554
00:59:11.829 --> 00:59:21.195
<v Steve Novick>And so some people, if they hear that there's rescues that specifically respond only to medical calls, they might say, well, why isn't Why aren't the ambulances doing that?

555
00:59:21.597 --> 00:59:30.954
<v Steve Novick>So I just wanted to ask you to spend a couple of minutes today talking about the relationship and why we can't just count on the ambulances to respond speedily to every call.

556
00:59:32.413 --> 00:59:33.471
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Councilor.

557
00:59:34.016 --> 00:59:46.692
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's something that recently when I've been doing ride-outs, I noticed too, is that in many parts of the city when I respond with our fire engines or fire trucks to a medical call, call, AMR follows closely behind.

558
00:59:47.157 --> 00:59:51.693
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so it does raise a flag to me of this is not an efficient system.

559
00:59:51.965 --> 00:59:56.661
<v Rebecca Dobert>Why is that happening, especially on basic calls, the lower acuity calls?

560
00:59:57.175 --> 01:00:01.614
<v Rebecca Dobert>Certainly on a higher acuity call, we want to be the first responder there.

561
01:00:01.806 --> 01:00:12.144
<v Rebecca Dobert>We are happy to be the first paramedics there because that's a higher, more critical call that potentially needs more than just the 2 responders that are going to come on the ambulance.

562
01:00:12.210 --> 01:00:12.657
<v Dan Ryan>Mm-hmm.

563
01:00:13.284 --> 01:00:29.076
<v Rebecca Dobert>But it's important for you all to know that we're talking with AMR about just that, that we have— I've talked to some of our responders in different parts of town that do wait for a longer amount of time, and then in many other places we've got just a short wait before AMR rolls up.

564
01:00:29.476 --> 01:00:33.934
<v Rebecca Dobert>We'd like to spread that out and use those resources more efficiently.

565
01:00:34.110 --> 01:00:36.067
<v Rebecca Dobert>Of course, they're controlled by AMR.

566
01:00:36.675 --> 01:00:41.550
<v Rebecca Dobert>AMR does posting based on call volume, usually across Yes.

567
01:00:41.983 --> 01:00:53.581
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so it sounds like they plan to look at our response times to parts of the city and then make adjustments to their posting sites so that we are doing that better, better.

568
01:00:53.693 --> 01:01:03.556
<v Rebecca Dobert>And if there's parts of the city where we are arriving very near time to them on a BLS call, then we would take ourselves off those calls.

569
01:01:04.070 --> 01:01:09.170
<v Rebecca Dobert>And we currently can do that anyways, which is Thank you.

570
01:01:09.170 --> 01:01:16.710
<v Rebecca Dobert>I just want to ask you to make probably the obvious point that if it is a basic life support call that really just needs AMR to arrive, once we make that assessment, our companies can clear up.

571
01:01:18.329 --> 01:01:19.809
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

572
01:01:19.809 --> 01:01:37.250
<v Steve Novick>I just want to ask you to make probably the obvious point that if it is a high-priority medical call like a heart attack, then it kind of— to me, it kind of makes sense that both fire and AMR goes out to see, because whoever gets there first, if they get there a minute earlier, they might save a life.

573
01:01:37.250 --> 01:01:37.309
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's pretty simple.

574
01:01:37.309 --> 01:01:37.429
<v Steve Novick>I think that's a fair point.

575
01:01:41.552 --> 01:01:42.003
<v Candace Avalos>Absolutely.

576
01:01:42.617 --> 01:01:45.186
<v Steve Novick>I wanted to ask about the apparatus budget.

577
01:01:47.119 --> 01:01:58.300
<v Steve Novick>It obviously worries me to think that we're using old, old vehicles, and I'm curious how often— I mean, I assume that— do we have any extra vehicles around?

578
01:01:58.349 --> 01:02:00.518
<v Steve Novick>If one goes down, is the one ready to step in?

579
01:02:01.101 --> 01:02:04.985
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes, we do have a few that are reserve engines and reserve trucks.

580
01:02:05.257 --> 01:02:12.969
<v Rebecca Dobert>That we use during regular prolonged maintenance that our engines and trucks go in, we'll swap them onto a reserve.

581
01:02:13.967 --> 01:02:15.766
<v Rebecca Dobert>That inventory is running low.

582
01:02:17.659 --> 01:02:18.657
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

583
01:02:19.367 --> 01:02:24.987
<v Steve Novick>And I mean, I assume that they're like regularly inspected to make sure that there's nothing going wrong.

584
01:02:25.117 --> 01:02:25.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's right.

585
01:02:26.228 --> 01:02:30.634
<v Steve Novick>But at a certain point, when they're ancient vehicles, it just— you can't count on them.

586
01:02:35.565 --> 01:02:45.007
<v Steve Novick>One thing you said was that you're going to lose some administrative staff and their work will be filled in by higher-level people.

587
01:02:45.599 --> 01:02:47.362
<v Steve Novick>And that always raises red flags for me.

588
01:02:47.443 --> 01:02:50.072
<v Steve Novick>Like, what kind of work will be done by what higher-level people?

589
01:02:51.114 --> 01:02:51.418
<v Rebecca Dobert>Right.

590
01:02:52.157 --> 01:02:56.389
<v Rebecca Dobert>I was speaking specifically about an office assistant position.

591
01:02:57.096 --> 01:03:00.378
<v Rebecca Dobert>That a lot of that work will still need to be done.

592
01:03:00.474 --> 01:03:11.251
<v Rebecca Dobert>So it's phone tree management, listening to voicemails that we get from the community, and then assigning them to the appropriate recipient to make a response.

593
01:03:11.931 --> 01:03:13.873
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's things like customer service.

594
01:03:14.213 --> 01:03:21.764
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's a customer-facing position that would greet interview candidates that we would have coming for interviews.

595
01:03:22.070 --> 01:03:22.425
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

596
01:03:23.085 --> 01:03:32.510
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's doing some reporting about fire fatalities and then annual reports that are required.

597
01:03:33.103 --> 01:03:38.119
<v Steve Novick>And I'm sure actually my District 2 colleagues will get into this in great detail.

598
01:03:38.329 --> 01:03:45.862
<v Steve Novick>But if you eliminate, I mean, an engine from a station, then the engines are the vehicles that have water.

599
01:03:46.181 --> 01:03:58.023
<v Steve Novick>So the idea that we'd have the truck that deals with, like, Sort of extricating people from tall buildings, etc., but we don't— wouldn't have any water seems probably counterintuitive to people.

600
01:03:58.072 --> 01:04:02.842
<v Steve Novick>So can you explain how the absence of a vehicle with water affects that jurisdiction?

601
01:04:03.340 --> 01:04:03.677
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sure.

602
01:04:04.480 --> 01:04:05.476
<v Rebecca Dobert>I mean, you said it.

603
01:04:05.588 --> 01:04:13.971
<v Rebecca Dobert>So we have 2 primary work assignments when we arrive at a structure fire, and they are done by engines and trucks.

604
01:04:14.034 --> 01:04:15.898
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so the engines carry water.

605
01:04:16.106 --> 01:04:20.137
<v Rebecca Dobert>Those firefighters are assigned primarily for fire extinguishment.

606
01:04:20.297 --> 01:04:23.429
<v Rebecca Dobert>We know that everything gets better when we put the fire out.

607
01:04:24.391 --> 01:04:31.280
<v Rebecca Dobert>The firefighters that work on trucks, their primary duty is search and rescue, and so it's meant to be in concert.

608
01:04:31.376 --> 01:04:44.574
<v Rebecca Dobert>When the engine is doing fire extinguishment, the firefighters from the truck are assigned to do search and rescue for victims in that structure and then to ventilate to improve the environment for anybody thank you.

609
01:04:44.655 --> 01:04:44.862
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you, Mayor.

610
01:04:44.927 --> 01:04:46.806
<v Rebecca Dobert>I'm going to turn it over to Deputy City Attorney Nancy Thorington.

611
01:04:47.094 --> 01:04:56.744
<v Rebecca Dobert>You know, I think it's important to say before I even, you know, get a question from District 2, the choice about Engine 22 is not a value statement.

612
01:04:57.210 --> 01:05:01.594
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's not about the neighborhood, the community, the firefighters that work there.

613
01:05:02.364 --> 01:05:22.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>It was simply data analysis and assessing our risk and trying to do the most good and the smallest amount of harm that we know would, that would come with this budget package that's designed to improve the city's ability to recover in the next several years.

614
01:05:23.483 --> 01:05:38.784
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so when we looked at the last 5 years of data to make this decision, one of the things we were looking at certainly was that engine's call volume and making sure that as best as we could, we were picking something that wasn't already very busy.

615
01:05:39.442 --> 01:05:45.248
<v Rebecca Dobert>But equally important was looking at the next closest station because we knew that that's where the burden would shift.

616
01:05:45.713 --> 01:06:00.275
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so when we were looking at the city, we had to make sure we were picking only from a fire station that was a double company house, and then from a lower volume engine, and then that the area adjacent could tolerate the increase in call volume.

617
01:06:01.172 --> 01:06:02.327
<v Rebecca Dobert>The data that we have Thank you.

618
01:06:02.376 --> 01:06:09.748
<v Rebecca Dobert>So our analysis of the staffing graph show that Engine 26, which is the next due engine, arrives about a minute to locations after Engine 22 does.

619
01:06:10.824 --> 01:06:19.144
<v Rebecca Dobert>That minute's not insignificant, but that is— that minimizes the change to our response times across the city.

620
01:06:20.302 --> 01:06:25.842
<v Rebecca Dobert>And those were some of the decisions that I needed to make as we prepared to move forward in this budget.

621
01:06:26.164 --> 01:06:44.601
<v Rebecca Dobert>And it's important to me that you hear I've asked both the CA, DCA, and the mayor for the operational flexibility for us to watch for trends and watch for changes and make a change if we need to throughout the year.

622
01:06:48.800 --> 01:06:49.253
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Chief.

623
01:06:49.382 --> 01:06:52.139
<v Steve Novick>Actually, just, I wanted to follow up on that for a second.

624
01:06:52.186 --> 01:06:57.958
<v Steve Novick>I mean, it's my understanding that most of the stations with the lowest absolute call volume are on the west side.

625
01:06:59.565 --> 01:07:12.420
<v Steve Novick>But my guess is that the geography there is such that if you cut one of those stations or reduce based on that fact, it would take— the response times increase would be far higher.

626
01:07:13.751 --> 01:07:17.909
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's true about changing the response times just because of the geography.

627
01:07:18.567 --> 01:07:24.409
<v Rebecca Dobert>It also doesn't meet the mission of ensuring that every fire station got to stay open.

628
01:07:25.083 --> 01:07:27.784
<v Rebecca Dobert>We only have 8 double company houses.

629
01:07:28.619 --> 01:07:38.309
<v Rebecca Dobert>The ones that are on the west side are really close into downtown and one, have a call volume that makes it too hard for the surrounding stations to absorb it.

630
01:07:38.806 --> 01:07:50.119
<v Rebecca Dobert>But then 2 are also first due to high-rise fire responses that we really need to assemble a bunch of firefighters in a short amount of time to be effective at those locations.

631
01:07:51.628 --> 01:07:52.097
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

632
01:07:53.166 --> 01:08:01.335
<v Steve Novick>Director Baudsley, you talked about reducing operational overtime set aside for non-peak months.

633
01:08:01.740 --> 01:08:14.742
<v Steve Novick>I think you were saying that we are still having it for summer when we tend to have the most surges, but does that mean that if there is a really bad day that is not in the summer, then we might have less coverage?

634
01:08:15.244 --> 01:08:19.167
<v Steve Novick>It is Thank you for the question.

635
01:08:19.585 --> 01:08:20.612
<v Steve Maudsley>Yes, that is what that means.

636
01:08:20.868 --> 01:08:29.244
<v Steve Maudsley>You know, we would keep an eye on that, and if we continue to have bad days— I mean, the difficult thing about all of our business in public safety is emergencies aren't planned.

637
01:08:29.791 --> 01:08:36.064
<v Steve Maudsley>So we ensure that we have that framework in place to be able to respond in the moment.

638
01:08:36.675 --> 01:08:38.904
<v Steve Maudsley>It is tough when we're cutting operational overtime.

639
01:08:39.242 --> 01:08:48.511
<v Steve Maudsley>I do support it because I have seen our improvements over time with bringing folks in the door using our trainee pipeline, bringing them to full certification.

640
01:08:48.655 --> 01:08:58.435
<v Steve Maudsley>It is kind of a challenge though to balance out, you know, folks can leave employment with 2 weeks' notice, let's say, and it takes us around 2 years to bring them in the door, train them to full certification to call, take, and dispatch.

641
01:08:59.701 --> 01:09:04.783
<v Steve Novick>I also just quickly wanted to ask, you're talking about cutting an assistant operations manager.

642
01:09:05.712 --> 01:09:06.721
<v Steve Novick>What does that person do?

643
01:09:07.219 --> 01:09:08.725
<v Steve Novick>What won't be done if we lose that person?

644
01:09:08.822 --> 01:09:09.671
<v Steve Maudsley>That's a great question.

645
01:09:09.720 --> 01:09:11.979
<v Steve Maudsley>They, boy, they're the wearer of all hats.

646
01:09:12.189 --> 01:09:15.378
<v Steve Maudsley>It was a position I had several years ago for a number of years.

647
01:09:15.859 --> 01:09:16.551
<v Steve Maudsley>Right now we have 2.

648
01:09:16.680 --> 01:09:19.609
<v Steve Maudsley>They primarily oversee the operations supervisors.

649
01:09:20.382 --> 01:09:26.132
<v Steve Maudsley>They're the ones that supervise day-to-day operations of call-taking and dispatch work.

650
01:09:27.006 --> 01:09:30.016
<v Steve Maudsley>So we have a team of 14 operations supervisors.

651
01:09:30.082 --> 01:09:31.926
<v Steve Maudsley>12 Of those work on the operations floor.

652
01:09:32.006 --> 01:09:33.463
<v Steve Maudsley>2 are assigned to our training department.

653
01:09:35.313 --> 01:09:40.136
<v Steve Maudsley>And the assistant operations manager primarily leads and mentors that group.

654
01:09:40.377 --> 01:09:47.557
<v Steve Maudsley>They're also the single point of contact, or the first point of contact, I'd say, for service complaints.

655
01:09:48.088 --> 01:09:58.135
<v Steve Maudsley>When we look at how we're providing service, we receive community feedback on those things and work on policy and procedure and also work in the labor relations on negotiations.

656
01:10:00.099 --> 01:10:01.194
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

657
01:10:01.774 --> 01:10:09.146
<v Steve Novick>Director Perez, one thing I was pleased to see that you're maintaining the positions the council either deliberately saved or deliberately added last year.

658
01:10:09.984 --> 01:10:16.717
<v Steve Novick>One question I had was you said that with the decline in materials and services budget, that will affect EOC activation.

659
01:10:16.926 --> 01:10:18.086
<v Steve Novick>Could you just elaborate on that?

660
01:10:18.552 --> 01:10:20.387
<v Elizabeth Perez>It's more just our EMS in general.

661
01:10:20.501 --> 01:10:27.850
<v Elizabeth Perez>So depending on how many times we have to activate next year, it does impact.

662
01:10:28.028 --> 01:10:35.632
<v Elizabeth Perez>And just to note, all the bureaus participate in EOC activation, so all the bureaus have to participate in the funding of it.

663
01:10:36.762 --> 01:10:40.576
<v Elizabeth Perez>It really is just dependent on what kind of disasters we see next year.

664
01:10:40.865 --> 01:10:47.438
<v Elizabeth Perez>So as of right now, I think we'll be Okay.

665
01:10:47.534 --> 01:11:03.180
<v Steve Novick>And finally, I just want to join my colleagues in saluting the firefighters that are here and let you know that people who— there's going to be some of us looking for additional funding to restore some of those cuts, whether we happen to represent District 2 or not.

666
01:11:03.519 --> 01:11:04.485
<v Steve Novick>So thanks for being here.

667
01:11:05.195 --> 01:11:15.984
<v Steve Novick>And I also wanted to say that when I saw you all in the hall, not to make light of anything, but my initial reaction was to yell, Thank you, Councilor Novick.

668
01:11:16.065 --> 01:11:19.680
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

669
01:11:20.438 --> 01:11:21.323
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

670
01:11:21.467 --> 01:11:23.605
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, thank you everyone for being here for the presentation.

671
01:11:23.654 --> 01:11:33.603
<v Sameer Kanal>I just want to note I see people from all the, the parts of, uh, the service area back there, and that's been a testament to the service area's work at building a collective culture and system, and I appreciate that.

672
01:11:33.893 --> 01:11:36.524
<v Sameer Kanal>Appreciate the CA, uh, Lee being here as well as the mayor.

673
01:11:37.545 --> 01:11:38.711
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks to everyone in the gallery as well.

674
01:11:38.774 --> 01:11:39.828
<v Sameer Kanal>City Hall is the people's house.

675
01:11:39.891 --> 01:11:43.228
<v Sameer Kanal>Chamber is a place you come to be heard, whether you're doing it individually or through a group.

676
01:11:43.275 --> 01:11:47.180
<v Sameer Kanal>For those who are gonna watch on video later or now, there's a significant audience today.

677
01:11:47.327 --> 01:11:50.770
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate when people organize to be here, whether you're wearing matching t-shirts or not.

678
01:11:52.600 --> 01:11:57.694
<v Sameer Kanal>First, on the DCA transition, DCA Kazi, I'm grateful for your stepping up for the last 11 months.

679
01:11:58.176 --> 01:12:01.438
<v Sameer Kanal>We will be worse off not having you here as a city.

680
01:12:02.967 --> 01:12:07.319
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think we've seen the progress not only in the DCA role, but also in BOEC.

681
01:12:07.720 --> 01:12:13.822
<v Sameer Kanal>A lot of what we're talking about here is things that occurred, the positive from what you created when you were director there.

682
01:12:15.042 --> 01:12:19.537
<v Sameer Kanal>I also have confidence in the entire public safety workforce to adjust to changing circumstances and thrive.

683
01:12:19.601 --> 01:12:20.404
<v Sameer Kanal>That's what you do.

684
01:12:21.032 --> 01:12:27.373
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that that goes from the rank and file all the way up to Chief Johnson, to Director Perez, and Director Madsley as well.

685
01:12:27.533 --> 01:12:27.774
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

686
01:12:28.770 --> 01:12:30.176
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll start with, I'll just go in the order.

687
01:12:30.439 --> 01:12:32.287
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks to BOEC for the presentation.

688
01:12:34.060 --> 01:12:47.568
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you contextualize losing 2 call takers in the context of also reducing 311 hours of operation and how you think that those 2 things, are those going to be essentially multiplying the effect of the other?

689
01:12:48.020 --> 01:12:49.037
<v Sameer Kanal>How do you see that interacting?

690
01:12:50.359 --> 01:12:50.694
<v Steve Maudsley>Is that relevant?

691
01:12:51.979 --> 01:12:55.806
<v Steve Maudsley>Yeah, it's really the reduction of 2 call taker dispatcher positions yes.

692
01:12:55.953 --> 01:13:01.497
<v Steve Maudsley>One of the consequences is going to be a reduction in the number of folks we can bring in throughout the fiscal year into academies.

693
01:13:02.145 --> 01:13:09.851
<v Steve Maudsley>As I mentioned during the presentation, we intend on hiring 2 academies this year because, you know, we are pushing our full allotted FTE.

694
01:13:10.630 --> 01:13:22.545
<v Steve Maudsley>This reduction will— I think this reduction will reduce our ability to bring in 2 folks into one of those 2 academies later in the year.

695
01:13:23.653 --> 01:13:27.547
<v Steve Maudsley>But I do know that mandatory training will continue.

696
01:13:27.900 --> 01:13:29.680
<v Steve Maudsley>We will continue bringing in those academies.

697
01:13:29.728 --> 01:13:30.947
<v Steve Maudsley>They'll just have 2 less overall.

698
01:13:31.891 --> 01:13:32.149
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

699
01:13:32.613 --> 01:13:36.396
<v Steve Maudsley>And you'd asked about 311 and kind of the coordination there on the balance.

700
01:13:37.760 --> 01:13:45.662
<v Steve Maudsley>I really— I think we will be able to— we would be able to adjust to that increased call volume with reduced 311 hours.

701
01:13:46.737 --> 01:13:53.550
<v Steve Maudsley>Again, the 2 positions tied specifically to really, 2 out of 126 remaining call taker dispatcher positions.

702
01:13:54.176 --> 01:13:58.921
<v Steve Maudsley>Any reductions aren't great, but we understand the need and we think we can adjust to it over the year.

703
01:14:00.363 --> 01:14:00.748
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

704
01:14:00.989 --> 01:14:04.934
<v Sameer Kanal>Are the 2 Business System Analyst 3 positions being reallocated elsewhere?

705
01:14:05.014 --> 01:14:06.377
<v Sameer Kanal>Are those positions just going away?

706
01:14:06.761 --> 01:14:10.145
<v Steve Maudsley>The 2 are being reallocated in the core services realignment to technology.

707
01:14:10.945 --> 01:14:11.572
<v Sameer Kanal>So to BTS?

708
01:14:11.923 --> 01:14:12.774
<v Steve Maudsley>To BTS, yes.

709
01:14:13.752 --> 01:14:14.153
<v Steve Maudsley>Thanks.

710
01:14:14.474 --> 01:14:31.335
<v Sameer Kanal>And then my pivot, and I'm not sure to PBAM which will answer it, In the context of the security contract, because PBEM also has space, do you get IMS payments, internal payments from other bureaus who are in that facility to help cover the cost of the security contract?

711
01:14:32.122 --> 01:14:32.636
<v Steve Maudsley>BOEC does not.

712
01:14:32.701 --> 01:14:37.729
<v Steve Maudsley>So a couple years ago, I think we've had 2 years now of this contracted security.

713
01:14:38.869 --> 01:14:45.038
<v Steve Maudsley>You know, it's a tough thing to put up for a reduction because of the optics and overall security of the facility.

714
01:14:45.552 --> 01:14:51.432
<v Steve Maudsley>We have security measures in place, and I'm confident that what we have will continue to maintain security of the facility.

715
01:14:51.835 --> 01:15:06.324
<v Steve Maudsley>A couple years ago, though, when we brought that contract on, we had, we had a break-in at the facility, a vehicle stolen from inside the warehouse bay there, and some other security concerns, just folks coming on the property that should not have been there after hours.

716
01:15:07.722 --> 01:15:08.140
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

717
01:15:08.510 --> 01:15:10.229
<v Sameer Kanal>I have some concern about that.

718
01:15:10.373 --> 01:15:13.800
<v Sameer Kanal>If the contract continues, I think it might be worth having the conversation there.

719
01:15:14.337 --> 01:15:16.030
<v Sameer Kanal>Not that PBEM is flush with money either.

720
01:15:16.127 --> 01:15:16.730
<v Sameer Kanal>I know that.

721
01:15:16.926 --> 01:15:17.854
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's my pivot.

722
01:15:19.347 --> 01:15:21.001
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate the changes you've laid out.

723
01:15:21.065 --> 01:15:23.545
<v Sameer Kanal>Everything that you said made sense, Director Perez.

724
01:15:23.658 --> 01:15:29.613
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to get the opportunity to ask about some things that maybe aren't on the— in the slides.

725
01:15:31.162 --> 01:15:35.136
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you speak to the overall vision right now?

726
01:15:35.458 --> 01:15:42.055
<v Sameer Kanal>Because I think before getting into the details, there's definite interest in my office in supporting a more robust emergency management bureau.

727
01:15:42.103 --> 01:15:42.185
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

728
01:15:44.355 --> 01:15:53.444
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not 100% clear what you need for that, and I want to make sure that PBEM— you know, Councilor Novick and I talked about this last year— want to make sure that you have what you need.

729
01:15:53.974 --> 01:15:58.734
<v Sameer Kanal>We rely on PBEM here, and I also know there's a lot of important work on the council side.

730
01:15:58.783 --> 01:16:00.899
<v Sameer Kanal>I mean, there's also a lot of important work that you mentioned.

731
01:16:00.947 --> 01:16:08.273
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm super excited after talking about it for a year and a half that the continuity of operations program is being restarted in a new form of government.

732
01:16:08.578 --> 01:16:13.921
<v Sameer Kanal>But can you speak to maybe the big picture, what you What do you need and how does that serve the vision?

733
01:16:14.434 --> 01:16:21.194
<v Elizabeth Perez>Yeah, so as interim, I'll talk about where I'm trying to get to then hand the reins over to a new director.

734
01:16:22.381 --> 01:16:26.845
<v Elizabeth Perez>But I've been really privileged to work with a really strong team.

735
01:16:27.921 --> 01:16:38.244
<v Elizabeth Perez>We had a strategic planning session last week to start talking through our mission, vision, values, and just reestablish what is PBEM and what should we be doing.

736
01:16:39.320 --> 01:16:42.179
<v Elizabeth Perez>I think overall, like I said, we have 4 program areas.

737
01:16:42.932 --> 01:16:43.783
<v Elizabeth Perez>We've lacked planners.

738
01:16:44.777 --> 01:16:51.319
<v Elizabeth Perez>And the first part of, you know, working towards being prepared as a city is having those plans in place.

739
01:16:51.912 --> 01:16:58.615
<v Elizabeth Perez>So we have certain plans that we're required to do through the federal government, but then plans that we need as a city.

740
01:16:58.807 --> 01:17:09.262
<v Elizabeth Perez>And so there are some plans that need more significant change and some that just need changes in terms of reflecting the new form of government.

741
01:17:10.371 --> 01:17:15.541
<v Elizabeth Perez>So when we're talking vision, I'm, I'm really talking about foundation.

742
01:17:16.216 --> 01:17:27.631
<v Elizabeth Perez>It's really getting us to our planning, our operations, making sure that we have a functional operations center, making sure that we are— we have our plans and then we're training and exercising them.

743
01:17:27.712 --> 01:17:34.744
<v Elizabeth Perez>I know Councilor Zimmerman has talked about this before, you know, just really making sure that we are prepared to do the work.

744
01:17:35.679 --> 01:17:39.360
<v Elizabeth Perez>In a time where we don't know what is going to happen.

745
01:17:39.636 --> 01:17:48.542
<v Elizabeth Perez>And really focusing on all hazards, because if we're prepared for the big one, we're likely going to be prepared for pretty much anything with some changes.

746
01:17:50.055 --> 01:17:54.309
<v Elizabeth Perez>And then making sure that our community resilience programs are intact.

747
01:17:54.550 --> 01:17:56.997
<v Elizabeth Perez>Our NET program is phenomenal.

748
01:17:58.252 --> 01:18:10.351
<v Elizabeth Perez>And I think that the staff that have worked on that, you know, even through the past couple years of changes, have really persevered and made sure that even with less staff, they are still training up volunteers.

749
01:18:10.688 --> 01:18:12.997
<v Elizabeth Perez>And I think that is a real boon to the city.

750
01:18:13.510 --> 01:18:16.684
<v Elizabeth Perez>So in terms of vision, we're looking at foundation.

751
01:18:16.811 --> 01:18:21.957
<v Elizabeth Perez>So what is it that the city, this city, capital C, is ready for?

752
01:18:22.310 --> 01:18:27.712
<v Elizabeth Perez>And then making sure that as we're preparing that, our community members are also prepared.

753
01:18:27.792 --> 01:18:35.167
<v Elizabeth Perez>So that is through the NETS and then our, our COAD, making sure that we have culturally specific work happening in the community.

754
01:18:35.230 --> 01:18:35.439
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

755
01:18:35.807 --> 01:18:45.005
<v Elizabeth Perez>So those are the 2 elements that we're working through, and I'm really excited to hire a full-time bureau director to lead the bureau and the really excellent staff.

756
01:18:46.144 --> 01:18:46.400
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

757
01:18:46.545 --> 01:18:53.960
<v Sameer Kanal>And it should be noted that you'll be here presenting a completely different area later on because you still have your old job as well.

758
01:18:54.314 --> 01:18:54.506
<v Olivia Clark>I do.

759
01:18:54.601 --> 01:18:57.283
<v Sameer Kanal>So appreciate the work flexing into that.

760
01:18:58.567 --> 01:19:00.909
<v Steve Maudsley>One question that I want to return to the net thing for a moment.

761
01:19:02.048 --> 01:19:07.309
<v Sameer Kanal>And this relates to realignment, or, and maybe it, maybe these are 2 questions and maybe they think they may be one.

762
01:19:08.046 --> 01:19:16.497
<v Sameer Kanal>Which position's being realigned into where and why is community programs, that might relate to what you just said, but why is the personnel cost increasing there?

763
01:19:17.411 --> 01:19:17.876
<v Sameer Kanal>How's that?

764
01:19:18.389 --> 01:19:28.331
<v Elizabeth Perez>I believe the one position, and we're still having conversations about this, is the community resilience program.

765
01:19:29.554 --> 01:19:35.667
<v Elizabeth Perez>I think she's an analyst, so that's— she works with the COAD, so the Community Organizations in Disasters.

766
01:19:37.353 --> 01:19:49.430
<v Elizabeth Perez>The understanding is that she would be moved more to the service area to help not only work on the emergency management piece, but also in community resilience across public safety.

767
01:19:50.173 --> 01:19:51.756
<v Elizabeth Perez>We're still having conversations on that.

768
01:19:52.466 --> 01:19:53.177
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

769
01:19:54.823 --> 01:20:06.087
<v Sameer Kanal>In terms of the NET programs, and this is my segue, I'm pretty sure, but you could tell me, that St. John's is one of the largest NET teams in the city.

770
01:20:07.257 --> 01:20:08.074
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that accurate?

771
01:20:08.283 --> 01:20:08.877
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it number one?

772
01:20:08.925 --> 01:20:09.485
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not sure.

773
01:20:09.582 --> 01:20:16.809
<v Elizabeth Perez>I'm seeing from my Deputy Director Jordan Wiley a head nod, so we can come back to you and confirm that, but I think it's true.

774
01:20:16.856 --> 01:20:17.979
<v Sameer Kanal>It may be second biggest.

775
01:20:18.139 --> 01:20:18.859
<v Sameer Kanal>They're doing great.

776
01:20:18.923 --> 01:20:19.564
<v Sameer Kanal>That's my pivot in.

777
01:20:19.630 --> 01:20:20.542
<v Sameer Kanal>That's my area.

778
01:20:20.654 --> 01:20:24.532
<v Elizabeth Perez>So I just wanted to shout out, it's my pivot into fire.

779
01:20:24.693 --> 01:20:32.479
<v Sameer Kanal>And, and also to just say, um, I was really hoping that after last year we wouldn't be having the conversation that starts with the question, why are we beating up on St. John's again?

780
01:20:32.559 --> 01:20:51.225
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, I, I really want to express that I, I understand why, given what you had to do in terms of the exercise, why a process started and led to an answer that frankly, if it was in a different district those councilors would have hated just as much as I hate it.

781
01:20:51.579 --> 01:20:55.427
<v Sameer Kanal>I totally get that, and I am not faulting that process for it.

782
01:20:56.087 --> 01:21:04.557
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think that the potential closure of Station 22 in St. Johns is unacceptable, and largely that's because I live right on the border.

783
01:21:04.768 --> 01:21:09.421
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm kind of close to where Station 8 serves and where 26 serves.

784
01:21:09.695 --> 01:21:11.740
<v Sameer Kanal>I was as a candidate in the 26.

785
01:21:12.015 --> 01:21:13.545
<v Sameer Kanal>I live in 26's area.

786
01:21:15.539 --> 01:21:31.621
<v Sameer Kanal>And the context of Station 8 a few years ago losing its double company status, and to contextualize the figures we are talking about, both in terms of Councilor Koyama Lane's question to the mayor, but also in terms of how we look at this, call volume has to be compared.

787
01:21:31.748 --> 01:21:37.430
<v Sameer Kanal>We can't just look at raw numbers over time, but did those raw numbers change in light of call volume?

788
01:21:37.478 --> 01:21:40.399
<v Sameer Kanal>And I know that staffing hasn't increased anywhere in public safety.

789
01:21:40.817 --> 01:21:43.771
<v Sameer Kanal>To keep up with call volume, but I'm talking about proportionally.

790
01:21:44.511 --> 01:21:46.421
<v Sameer Kanal>And Station 8 has had among the large—.

791
01:21:46.454 --> 01:21:46.614
<v Mitch Green>That's—.

792
01:21:46.631 --> 01:21:52.878
<v Sameer Kanal>This is Lombard and Interstate right by the Fred Meyer, uh, for those who don't know, uh, has had one of the biggest increases in call volume.

793
01:21:53.506 --> 01:21:56.060
<v Sameer Kanal>At the same time, it's lost one of its 2 apparatus.

794
01:21:56.878 --> 01:22:05.905
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and that's context, which means that Station 26, just to the west of it, um, in Portsmouth, is assisting there quite a bit.

795
01:22:05.970 --> 01:22:06.131
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

796
01:22:07.253 --> 01:22:13.283
<v Sameer Kanal>And now would also be asked to assist to its west, which is the St. Johns Station, Station 22.

797
01:22:14.726 --> 01:22:18.560
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that an accurate read of what would happen if this was cut?

798
01:22:19.601 --> 01:22:19.810
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is.

799
01:22:20.243 --> 01:22:28.631
<v Sameer Kanal>And engines, for those who don't know, have the significantly larger water capacity than either of the other 2 trucks or quints.

800
01:22:29.560 --> 01:22:35.287
<v Sameer Kanal>So when we're talking about actually putting I love the phrase, put the wet thing on the hot thing.

801
01:22:36.105 --> 01:22:41.127
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the particular apparatus that's most useful for that, right?

802
01:22:41.479 --> 01:22:42.056
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's right.

803
01:22:43.324 --> 01:22:54.555
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so we've also established that Station 22 neighbors and serves the south side of the St. Johns Bridge in part, and therefore is a neighboring station to Linton and the CEI hub area.

804
01:22:55.148 --> 01:23:13.445
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll also mention that Station 17 on Hayden Island has a large portion of the North Portland industrial waterfront and is reliant— because the station itself is in Hayden Island— is reliant on a bridge and traffic on that bridge on I-5 to get to that portion of their area.

805
01:23:13.849 --> 01:23:21.280
<v Sameer Kanal>And if they can't because of traffic or bridge issues, Station 22's engine would normally be supporting that too.

806
01:23:21.426 --> 01:23:21.957
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that correct?

807
01:23:22.394 --> 01:23:22.555
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes.

808
01:23:23.442 --> 01:23:23.684
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

809
01:23:24.572 --> 01:23:36.157
<v Sameer Kanal>So with all that said, we're talking about a very large fire management area to begin with, but also being a primary support to half of North Portland, pretty much, if not more.

810
01:23:36.686 --> 01:23:38.595
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's very concerning to me.

811
01:23:38.692 --> 01:23:52.219
<v Sameer Kanal>I also think it's a little bit— there's a way to tell this story financially that I have a little question about, which is we're calling it a saving of $2.5 million because it's also saving overtime.

812
01:23:52.894 --> 01:24:00.105
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's because we're reducing the workload of the bureau as a whole and therefore having less of a draw on overtime.

813
01:24:00.523 --> 01:24:06.707
<v Sameer Kanal>So the actual reduction in the apparatus and the people who work on it is less than that.

814
01:24:07.847 --> 01:24:09.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that— I'm seeing a nod from CA Lee.

815
01:24:09.533 --> 01:24:27.309
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think there's an argument to be made here that we're not actually saving as much as we should be looking to save to achieve a 4% target, which I'm also not Uh, in love with, but, um, that is actually the, the reduction itself is not creating that savings so much as that plus the overtime reduction.

816
01:24:27.983 --> 01:24:30.422
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, just wanted to, to get that on the record here.

817
01:24:31.016 --> 01:24:34.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, and we could talk about this for an entire work session, but I won't.

818
01:24:35.029 --> 01:24:39.011
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but, uh, I'm against it, just to be clear on that.

819
01:24:39.701 --> 01:24:42.269
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so, uh, switching gears to CHAT.

820
01:24:42.573 --> 01:24:49.712
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, first off, I am really grateful to everybody involved in getting the $1.5 million that's a hard thing to do right now, and I'm grateful for it.

821
01:24:50.033 --> 01:24:52.822
<v Sameer Kanal>It is being used to replace $2 million in city one-time dollars.

822
01:24:52.917 --> 01:24:56.541
<v Sameer Kanal>We have no ongoing dollars in CHAT, which is why the staff are limited term, as you mentioned.

823
01:24:57.166 --> 01:25:04.042
<v Sameer Kanal>I think you've gone through what the impacts of the funding decrease are, and the good news for us is we're not looking to replace $2 million.

824
01:25:04.395 --> 01:25:06.270
<v Sameer Kanal>We'd be looking to replace half a million dollars there.

825
01:25:07.681 --> 01:25:10.055
<v Sameer Kanal>And I would love to— last year I put up an amendment.

826
01:25:10.103 --> 01:25:14.382
<v Sameer Kanal>You can anticipate one again to get some number of ongoing dollars into this program.

827
01:25:14.479 --> 01:25:17.716
<v Sameer Kanal>Everybody up here at some point has said we think that CHAT should be a part of our future.

828
01:25:17.780 --> 01:25:17.925
<v Steve Maudsley>Thank you.

829
01:25:18.747 --> 01:25:26.396
<v Sameer Kanal>And it is time to get one or more dollars into this program on an ongoing basis so that it is a locked-in part of our future.

830
01:25:26.476 --> 01:25:28.055
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously, I'd love a lot more than a dollar.

831
01:25:31.212 --> 01:25:39.855
<v Sameer Kanal>Are the 2 positions being eliminated additional to or the same as the Deputy Chief and Program Strategist in CHAT?

832
01:25:40.454 --> 01:25:41.765
<v Rebecca Dobert>Those are the 2 positions.

833
01:25:41.829 --> 01:25:49.627
<v Rebecca Dobert>So the initial budget book, I think, that you all got that said, 3 positions, which was the equivalent of 3 frontline chat responders.

834
01:25:50.542 --> 01:25:58.006
<v Rebecca Dobert>And we decided to leave those 3 employees in place and make the reduction to the deputy chief and the program strategist.

835
01:25:58.471 --> 01:26:03.914
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm going to ask on the strategy side, and this is maybe not just the position but the overall situation.

836
01:26:04.091 --> 01:26:14.189
<v Sameer Kanal>My understanding is that role is part of what's working on a project to get reimbursement lined up, Medicaid reimbursement, which would be a part of getting us out of this conversation.

837
01:26:14.365 --> 01:26:16.243
<v Sameer Kanal>That's correct.

838
01:26:16.613 --> 01:26:18.748
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes, he is part of that position.

839
01:26:18.942 --> 01:26:28.801
<v Rebecca Dobert>That worker, you know, our member is part of working on those kind of agreements and maintaining relationships and looking for additional funding options.

840
01:26:29.250 --> 01:26:39.253
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so cutting that work would potentially limit our ability to get that reimbursement figured out as rapidly as possible.

841
01:26:39.350 --> 01:26:39.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that correct?

842
01:26:40.506 --> 01:26:45.199
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's going to be shifted to the remaining folks that work in that group.

843
01:26:45.828 --> 01:26:46.087
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

844
01:26:46.167 --> 01:26:49.798
<v Sameer Kanal>And then last question on CHAT.

845
01:26:50.364 --> 01:26:55.686
<v Sameer Kanal>What is the impact in— how does it work in terms of the org chart if the Deputy Chief gets eliminated?

846
01:26:55.783 --> 01:26:58.081
<v Sameer Kanal>What does that do to where CHAT sits in your org chart?

847
01:26:59.091 --> 01:27:04.926
<v Rebecca Dobert>So CHAT, right now we're planning for that to stay under the Emergency Operations Division.

848
01:27:05.420 --> 01:27:12.805
<v Rebecca Dobert>But that deputy chief was critical just in terms of getting chat responders worked into the fabric of fire stations.

849
01:27:13.704 --> 01:27:25.233
<v Rebecca Dobert>And he's been critical in just understanding both sides of the program that chat— the work that chat does, and then helping our firefighters understand the value that chat brings to the station.

850
01:27:25.908 --> 01:27:30.868
<v Rebecca Dobert>Our plan is to use another existing deputy chief position to fill that.

851
01:27:34.362 --> 01:27:35.997
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks for that.

852
01:27:37.454 --> 01:27:40.162
<v Sameer Kanal>I think everybody said it already in terms of the rescues.

853
01:27:40.498 --> 01:27:43.895
<v Sameer Kanal>I would love to— not only should we be saving those, I'd love to get some in D2.

854
01:27:44.039 --> 01:27:49.743
<v Sameer Kanal>I think a significant portion— I think you said 65% of calls now are on the medical side.

855
01:27:50.353 --> 01:27:50.801
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's right.

856
01:27:51.170 --> 01:27:59.069
<v Sameer Kanal>And so, you know, rescues— I'll also mention, and this relates to St. Johns, when I did a ride-along, we responded from Station 8 to St. Johns.

857
01:27:59.341 --> 01:28:01.153
<v Sameer Kanal>To a fire in St. Johns.

858
01:28:01.328 --> 01:28:09.582
<v Sameer Kanal>And getting— when the grid changes as you go west, it's actually difficult to maneuver, especially if someone's parking up to the corner.

859
01:28:09.742 --> 01:28:12.417
<v Sameer Kanal>And shout out to people who want to daylight our intersections.

860
01:28:13.203 --> 01:28:20.527
<v Sameer Kanal>But to actually get around— and a rescue is a much smaller vehicle, so there's quicker responses, more roads available as well.

861
01:28:20.654 --> 01:28:25.961
<v Sameer Kanal>But I share the concern about that largely because, like the Other conversation we've had.

862
01:28:26.009 --> 01:28:29.203
<v Sameer Kanal>It's a short-term budgetary gain with a long-term downside.

863
01:28:29.780 --> 01:28:37.868
<v Sameer Kanal>I did want to say thank you for the prevention fee updates and the budgets for payouts, whoever caught that in Business Services.

864
01:28:38.863 --> 01:28:50.837
<v Sameer Kanal>Mr. Mayor, I hope we can restore the payout schedule for 2027-2028 when there are 27 pay period months anticipated so that we're not caught flat-footed on that, but it's good to reduce it when we don't have that.

865
01:28:50.900 --> 01:28:50.997
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

866
01:28:51.783 --> 01:29:10.994
<v Sameer Kanal>Because we're in May and this is a 27-pay-period month, um, how— last year we had this conversation in the spring TAL and in the budget about what it would mean to start an academy not in July, which would line up with this month for when people would be, um, out, but, uh, starting it later.

867
01:29:11.588 --> 01:29:21.962
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, how are we doing on retirements this month, and should we anticipate an overtime which one do you want?

868
01:29:22.042 --> 01:29:23.494
<v Sameer Kanal>This is relevant to next year's budget.

869
01:29:23.640 --> 01:29:30.106
<v Rebecca Dobert>I mean, uh, do you— can you come up and fill that in so that—.

870
01:29:31.930 --> 01:29:32.319
<v Elizabeth Perez>Thank you.

871
01:29:35.130 --> 01:29:35.983
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Hello, Elizabeth Gallagher.

872
01:29:36.030 --> 01:29:38.284
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>For the record, I'm Deputy Director at Portland Fire and Rescue.

873
01:29:38.929 --> 01:29:50.221
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Um, in terms of retirements for this month, uh, we have over 20 that we've received at this point in time that are going to be participating, or at least have put their interest in to be part of the Retire Rehire program.

874
01:29:51.167 --> 01:29:57.224
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>And what that does is it allows those folks to work potentially for another year serving as frontline firefighters.

875
01:29:57.336 --> 01:30:01.181
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>And that is something that we anticipate helping with some of the staffing over the course of the summer months.

876
01:30:01.886 --> 01:30:06.117
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>That being said, we also have a number of folks who have just indicated that they will be retiring.

877
01:30:06.789 --> 01:30:12.253
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>It's an advantageous time to do that, and we've got wonderful folks who've put in lots of great years of service.

878
01:30:13.439 --> 01:30:17.369
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>And so that number you know, we kind of get some new information every day.

879
01:30:18.252 --> 01:30:21.319
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Not everybody is super vocal about that, keep it kind of close to the vest.

880
01:30:21.448 --> 01:30:26.844
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>And so we're watching that very closely because we know that that payout amount for this year is going to be very tight.

881
01:30:27.003 --> 01:30:33.667
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>And with it being the end of the year, we have minimal opportunity to adjust for that if it is more than what we had anticipated.

882
01:30:34.534 --> 01:30:35.819
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I guess so.

883
01:30:35.899 --> 01:30:38.099
<v Sameer Kanal>From the payout perspective, I really appreciate that.

884
01:30:38.243 --> 01:30:44.757
<v Sameer Kanal>From the retirement perspective, I'm thinking also the overtime side because we're pulling in people from traveler pool.

885
01:30:44.903 --> 01:30:51.176
<v Sameer Kanal>You got a lot of different ways that you account for it, all of which I imagine have a budgetary impact, certainly the ones we talked about.

886
01:30:53.225 --> 01:30:55.518
<v Sameer Kanal>What is the size of the spike?

887
01:30:55.809 --> 01:31:02.476
<v Sameer Kanal>Is it on average, are we looking at like a 10-15% increase in retirements when there's a 27-pay period?

888
01:31:02.524 --> 01:31:03.945
<v Sameer Kanal>Are we looking at doubling, tripling?

889
01:31:04.059 --> 01:31:05.916
<v Sameer Kanal>What's the scale of the spike?

890
01:31:06.546 --> 01:31:12.225
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>I'm actually also going to turn my head back to I believe that she looked at that too, but it's typically, I mean—.

891
01:31:12.225 --> 01:31:12.403
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>70%.

892
01:31:12.466 --> 01:31:13.613
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>70% Retire during—.

893
01:31:15.079 --> 01:31:15.466
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

894
01:31:17.354 --> 01:31:22.327
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Yeah, of folks who retire, 70% opt to retire during a 27-pay period lookback month.

895
01:31:22.844 --> 01:31:26.573
<v Sameer Kanal>And there's about one of those a year on average?

896
01:31:26.864 --> 01:31:27.853
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>It rolls, honestly.

897
01:31:28.095 --> 01:31:39.314
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Like, I've tried to look for a pattern in it, but it, yeah, you can kind of bank on one a year, but just the way that that spread works, again, like this coming fiscal year, The spread is such that we miss it in FY27.

898
01:31:39.828 --> 01:31:47.600
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so if retirements were evenly spaced over 12 months, we'd be looking at 8 or 9% of retirements occurring in a given month.

899
01:31:48.484 --> 01:31:54.603
<v Sameer Kanal>And in a 27-pay-period month, we're getting 70% of the retirements, just to scale that here.

900
01:31:54.684 --> 01:32:18.743
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's why it's so important that we prepare for this financially, not only— and I really appreciate the payout look, but also on the overtime side and how we scale our trainings, which is what gets me back to this year's— or sorry, the coming year's budget, because everything I've been asking kind of relates to this year's, which is I would love to look at how we can get what BOEC has for fire with the overhiring authority.

901
01:32:19.819 --> 01:32:23.770
<v Sameer Kanal>Because within a fiscal year, 10 months, we can get— I think it's a little shorter now, right?

902
01:32:24.557 --> 01:32:24.846
<v Sameer Kanal>9.

903
01:32:25.666 --> 01:32:27.689
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, we can get somebody hired up.

904
01:32:28.396 --> 01:32:35.859
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think if we have that overhiring capacity, built in, we can build to where we're going to need to be before those months happen.

905
01:32:35.954 --> 01:32:36.740
<v Angelita Morillo>For sure.

906
01:32:36.902 --> 01:32:44.905
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>I would add as well that just the way that hiring happened over the course of the '90s and the early aughts, we saw larger, huge classes of folks coming in.

907
01:32:46.381 --> 01:32:47.537
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>That's true for both police and fire.

908
01:32:48.532 --> 01:32:55.510
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>And just as we kind of move to a smoother hiring that happened 20 years ago, we'll see some of that phase out.

909
01:32:56.006 --> 01:33:01.556
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>The difference between FPD and our being the retirement plan as compared to folks now being on the PERS system.

910
01:33:02.344 --> 01:33:04.783
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>As of 2007, that also makes a difference.

911
01:33:05.296 --> 01:33:12.295
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>So we anticipate seeing changes, but yes, it is a huge financial calculus that we have to bring in, um, over the next few years for sure.

912
01:33:12.792 --> 01:33:13.899
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thanks.

913
01:33:14.043 --> 01:33:20.030
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll also just close by saying I, I agree with my colleagues on the point of the, the 2 admin positions piece as well.

914
01:33:20.158 --> 01:33:21.154
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to flag that.

915
01:33:21.217 --> 01:33:22.326
<v Steve Novick>Thanks, Council President.

916
01:33:22.631 --> 01:33:23.448
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

917
01:33:23.529 --> 01:33:24.829
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, it is 11 o'clock.

918
01:33:24.894 --> 01:33:30.796
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have 7 more people in the queue and a little over We have about an hour and a half until we are scheduled to get out of here.

919
01:33:31.247 --> 01:33:33.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to give us a 15-minute bathroom break.

920
01:33:33.175 --> 01:33:36.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Everybody please be back here at 11:15, and Councilor Avalos will be kicking us off.

921
01:33:42.935 --> 01:33:44.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

922
01:49:25.778 --> 01:49:27.556
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we are back.

923
01:49:27.798 --> 01:49:28.478
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, folks.

924
01:49:29.335 --> 01:49:32.634
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have about an hour and 15 minutes left.

925
01:49:32.715 --> 01:49:34.720
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have 7 councilors left in the queue.

926
01:49:34.832 --> 01:49:37.786
<v Jamie Dunphy>That means, colleagues, I'm trying to hold us to 10 minutes apiece.

927
01:49:38.220 --> 01:49:39.511
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos, take us away.

928
01:49:39.850 --> 01:49:40.496
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds great.

929
01:49:40.560 --> 01:49:40.931
<v Elizabeth Perez>Thank you.

930
01:49:43.302 --> 01:49:49.902
<v Candace Avalos>Well, you know, I feel like a lot of my colleagues have asked many of the questions that I had, so I'll keep it a little bit high level.

931
01:49:50.015 --> 01:49:57.734
<v Candace Avalos>But I think that, you know, what I'm hearing a lot of is that we're you know, preserving core services and a safe Portland for all.

932
01:49:58.393 --> 01:50:03.002
<v Candace Avalos>And I very much appreciate the work that goes into maintaining emergency response systems.

933
01:50:03.051 --> 01:50:03.837
<v Candace Avalos>Those are crucial.

934
01:50:04.752 --> 01:50:17.890
<v Candace Avalos>But as I'm looking closely at the budget and in the presentation, I feel like I'm seeing something different emerging, which is a pattern of maintaining the appearance of core services while reducing the underlying capacity that actually makes those services reliable.

935
01:50:17.939 --> 01:50:22.194
<v Candace Avalos>So that's fewer 911 call takers or reduced training or fewer response units.

936
01:50:22.259 --> 01:50:22.708
<v Candace Avalos>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

937
01:50:24.488 --> 01:50:25.755
<v Candace Avalos>Reductions in things like CHAT.

938
01:50:25.867 --> 01:50:35.902
<v Candace Avalos>So I just kind of wanted to better understand how these decisions are being made and what they actually mean for service reliability, especially for East Portland.

939
01:50:35.966 --> 01:50:46.529
<v Candace Avalos>So high level, can you just walk me through what is the framework that you're using to determine what reductions are acceptable in this service area?

940
01:50:46.689 --> 01:51:01.701
<v Candace Avalos>But specifically, what are the performance metrics or response time thresholds or service standards that you're using to conclude that these changes are not going to there we go.

941
01:51:03.136 --> 01:51:04.328
<v Bob Causie>Thank you for the question, Councilor.

942
01:51:05.289 --> 01:51:19.546
<v Bob Causie>The process involved— early on involved guidance from the budget office that the bureaus submit reduction packages, and they were aligned with a 3% reduction and an additional 7% reduction.

943
01:51:19.676 --> 01:51:31.966
<v Bob Causie>So those reduction packages were brought forward, and the service area basically compiled all of those into a generalized report.

944
01:51:32.756 --> 01:51:40.411
<v Bob Causie>And that report kind of showed me as the DCA all of the potential cuts that the bureaus brought forward.

945
01:51:41.073 --> 01:51:51.836
<v Bob Causie>And I brought those along with the other DCAs, all of our collective efforts from the bureaus, and had a workshop with the city administrator.

946
01:51:52.536 --> 01:51:56.462
<v Bob Causie>And looked at all of those potential cuts.

947
01:51:56.863 --> 01:52:12.935
<v Bob Causie>We reviewed each one individually, and then in that collective workshop made decisions on the overall impact and whether or not we could afford the cuts, and went through many iterations.

948
01:52:12.984 --> 01:52:31.693
<v Bob Causie>There was that initial iteration kind of looking for and then we had to go through a second round and even massaging some of those reductions.

949
01:52:32.127 --> 01:52:40.755
<v Bob Causie>For example, one concept, the original concept for police, was to cut the PS3 program altogether.

950
01:52:41.547 --> 01:52:45.382
<v Bob Causie>And in that conversation, realized that we didn't want to remove the program completely.

951
01:52:45.430 --> 01:52:45.755
<v Bob Causie>I think that's a good point.

952
01:52:45.850 --> 01:52:51.168
<v Bob Causie>Completely because we wanted to maintain at least the framework so that it can be built back over time.

953
01:52:51.847 --> 01:53:02.627
<v Bob Causie>And then decided collectively through that process to reduce that one by 80% so that at least the framework's still in place, there's some employees, and then it can be built back.

954
01:53:04.167 --> 01:53:08.992
<v Bob Causie>At that point then, the city administrator had recommendations.

955
01:53:09.670 --> 01:53:38.359
<v Bob Causie>That almost final list that was handed and then in meeting with the mayor a couple times, as, you know, the, the DCAs and the mayor's office met to kind of further massage the list and, and kind of have a back-and-forth conversation with the Bureau of Directors as well as all of the DCAs and the mayor's office in determining the final list.

956
01:53:38.470 --> 01:53:38.904
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

957
01:53:40.898 --> 01:53:43.034
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for that explanation.

958
01:53:43.243 --> 01:54:00.439
<v Candace Avalos>I think part of why I'm asking it is I'm just trying to, as we're looking at the whole budget, not just this area, understand what we mean when we say we're preserving core services if we are also chipping away at the things that make those core services.

959
01:54:00.715 --> 01:54:06.313
<v Candace Avalos>That's what I'm trying to understand, your decision-making and what it means to maintain quality of service.

960
01:54:06.377 --> 01:54:06.668
<v Steve Maudsley>Thank you.

961
01:54:07.592 --> 01:54:11.889
<v Candace Avalos>As opposed to just a skeleton of a service just existing for the sake of existing.

962
01:54:11.936 --> 01:54:21.475
<v Candace Avalos>So this is the kind of mindset I'm trying to understand, because at the end of the day, when we have such a big deficit, we have to make hard decisions about what are things that we scale back or we cut.

963
01:54:21.539 --> 01:54:31.221
<v Candace Avalos>But when I'm hearing, you know, you all say, but we're keeping core services, we're keeping core services, I guess I don't maybe agree with what the definition of core services is, right?

964
01:54:31.301 --> 01:54:31.559
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mm-hmm.

965
01:54:31.639 --> 01:54:37.483
<v Candace Avalos>If you're reducing things like chat, 911 responders, I would not agree that that means you're keeping a core service.

966
01:54:37.532 --> 01:54:39.293
<v Candace Avalos>So I think that's what I'm trying to get at.

967
01:54:40.082 --> 01:54:50.574
<v Candace Avalos>And I wonder, as it relates to 911 in particular, you know, given that the data you all provided shows that increased staffing has reduced overtime, it has improved performance.

968
01:54:50.993 --> 01:54:54.568
<v Candace Avalos>So what is the rationale then for reducing 911 call takers?

969
01:54:54.631 --> 01:54:58.947
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, I heard you answer some of those questions, but I want to ask more pointedly because of what your data showed.

970
01:54:59.043 --> 01:54:59.237
<v Steve Novick>Yeah.

971
01:54:59.896 --> 01:55:02.082
<v Candace Avalos>What is the rationale for reducing that?

972
01:55:02.729 --> 01:55:13.199
<v Candace Avalos>Should— and also, were there alternative reductions that were considered, particularly in other admin or non-frontline functions before reducing call-taking capacity?

973
01:55:13.329 --> 01:55:14.726
<v Candace Avalos>How were those trade-offs assessed?

974
01:55:15.619 --> 01:55:16.333
<v Steve Maudsley>Yeah, great question.

975
01:55:18.854 --> 01:55:25.412
<v Steve Maudsley>What we were looking to do is really align any reductions that I brought forward with our core mission.

976
01:55:26.207 --> 01:55:30.511
<v Steve Maudsley>Which in BOEC, most of our FTE are operations-focused.

977
01:55:30.559 --> 01:55:34.622
<v Steve Maudsley>They're frontline-focused on effective and timely 911 call answering and dispatching.

978
01:55:35.231 --> 01:55:39.470
<v Steve Maudsley>So any reductions may impact call answering down the road.

979
01:55:39.872 --> 01:55:50.487
<v Steve Maudsley>What I was trying to do is really minimize what those reductions are across the bureau and maintain our departments as they are today, or minimum maintain the departments.

980
01:55:50.551 --> 01:55:55.301
<v Steve Maudsley>We sometimes have departments of really 1 to 3 people outside call-taking and dispatch operations.

981
01:55:56.023 --> 01:55:58.381
<v Steve Maudsley>So places to reduce are very minimal.

982
01:55:58.814 --> 01:56:01.587
<v Steve Maudsley>So then we looked at things like training, security.

983
01:56:02.726 --> 01:56:06.720
<v Steve Maudsley>You know, reductions that weren't taken involve a couple administrative personnel.

984
01:56:07.313 --> 01:56:27.724
<v Steve Maudsley>And so it was really trying to look at maintaining frontline services of call-taking, dispatching, and quality assurance, and also balancing out and maintaining internal support systems for our training department, our public records and research, and the folks that in quality assurance that support our frontline folks and that make up most of our FTE.

985
01:56:31.930 --> 01:56:32.273
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

986
01:56:33.750 --> 01:56:49.746
<v Candace Avalos>Um, you know, I think it speaks to, um, something that I heard Councilor Koyama Lane say just around how are we deciding where, as we're balancing our budget, not every cut is felt equally across each bureau, right?

987
01:56:49.890 --> 01:56:51.046
<v Candace Avalos>We all know and understand that.

988
01:56:51.253 --> 01:56:55.537
<v Candace Avalos>But that seems to be the broader approach to this budget.

989
01:56:55.649 --> 01:56:58.569
<v Candace Avalos>And that's where I think you're hearing a lot of councilors' concerns, right?

990
01:56:58.649 --> 01:57:04.775
<v Candace Avalos>If we're saying that we're keeping core services, but we're hollowing out essential functions of those core services.

991
01:57:05.274 --> 01:57:13.086
<v Candace Avalos>And there, I think there's a lot of line items across the city that I'm like, well, why are we keeping that if we're going to be cutting 911 call takers, right?

992
01:57:13.149 --> 01:57:19.582
<v Candace Avalos>So if we look the budget as simply take 10% from each bureau, that's the kind of budgeting we're getting.

993
01:57:19.645 --> 01:57:25.404
<v Candace Avalos>And I don't agree that that's the way to best deliver quality services to Portlanders, right?

994
01:57:25.966 --> 01:57:35.800
<v Candace Avalos>Can you tell me a little bit— I heard a little exchange around like, you know, you all as the bureaus and the experts in your field are putting forward what you recommend as cuts.

995
01:57:35.912 --> 01:57:43.323
<v Candace Avalos>Obviously, again, we all have to do some kind of cut, uh, at the end of the day, um, but then those decisions ultimately get made by the mayor.

996
01:57:43.371 --> 01:57:43.466
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

997
01:57:43.547 --> 01:57:47.253
<v Candace Avalos>Can you talk about where what, what goes on in that in-between part?

998
01:57:47.335 --> 01:57:51.990
<v Candace Avalos>Like, how are you assessing what the bureau staff are telling you are the best places?

999
01:57:52.329 --> 01:57:54.689
<v Candace Avalos>How are you making those final calls for where to cut?

1000
01:57:57.623 --> 01:57:59.144
<v Keith Wilson>I think that's a great question.

1001
01:57:59.256 --> 01:58:00.356
<v Keith Wilson>I think that's a framing.

1002
01:58:01.181 --> 01:58:06.489
<v Keith Wilson>We start at the umbrella level and clean streets and safe places, and every meeting began with that.

1003
01:58:07.515 --> 01:58:11.275
<v Keith Wilson>We looked at the fatality rate in '23 and '24.

1004
01:58:11.341 --> 01:58:14.479
<v Keith Wilson>We lost 800 Portlanders on the street homeless.

1005
01:58:14.979 --> 01:58:16.914
<v Keith Wilson>So that's that overall framing part of it.

1006
01:58:17.963 --> 01:58:24.820
<v Keith Wilson>Our goal this year is to reduce that by over 70%, less people dying in Portland.

1007
01:58:25.648 --> 01:58:28.956
<v Keith Wilson>Our public safety system is at the cornerstone of making that happen.

1008
01:58:30.840 --> 01:58:38.993
<v Keith Wilson>DC Icazzi said at the very beginning, it's a holistic system we have to focus on, and it's a very complex system of which it's only one part.

1009
01:58:39.833 --> 01:58:45.216
<v Keith Wilson>When we go down the line and we look at Steve and what Steve's doing at BOAC, we see a 5% reduction in overall call volume.

1010
01:58:45.923 --> 01:58:48.800
<v Keith Wilson>Pressure on his system is being addressed.

1011
01:58:49.136 --> 01:59:03.420
<v Keith Wilson>When I set up this budget, focus is to reduce unsheltered homelessness, end it, which will reduce the burden on our public safety system, which is the folks we have right here, which will help us revitalize our economy and improve livability.

1012
01:59:04.176 --> 01:59:09.023
<v Keith Wilson>Steve's workload and his department is doing well.

1013
01:59:09.695 --> 01:59:11.203
<v Keith Wilson>Overtime is mitigated.

1014
01:59:11.957 --> 01:59:12.809
<v Keith Wilson>It is always green.

1015
01:59:13.546 --> 01:59:20.108
<v Keith Wilson>He is leading the best bureau we have right now as far as overtime and management, and call volume is falling.

1016
01:59:21.023 --> 01:59:22.354
<v Keith Wilson>And yet we have a fiscal crisis.

1017
01:59:22.402 --> 01:59:24.279
<v Keith Wilson>So we have to take the wins we have.

1018
01:59:24.953 --> 01:59:29.171
<v Keith Wilson>That department is outperforming like we haven't seen in 5 years.

1019
01:59:29.829 --> 01:59:35.926
<v Keith Wilson>When we go to Chief Johnson, we look at at her call volume, 9% of all of her calls are homelessness.

1020
01:59:36.425 --> 01:59:41.395
<v Keith Wilson>When we reduce unsheltered homelessness, we ostensibly reduce the burden on her.

1021
01:59:42.434 --> 01:59:56.560
<v Keith Wilson>Now, when we look at the budget writ large, Chief Johnson and I were in some very difficult meetings up until the budget was proposed to you because I had noted we are not going to close a fire station.

1022
01:59:57.181 --> 01:59:57.282
<v Olivia Clark>Yes.

1023
01:59:57.863 --> 02:00:06.592
<v Keith Wilson>And she had put forward drastic cuts to fire because that was the goal, not just doing a 10% cut across the whole.

1024
02:00:07.420 --> 02:00:14.213
<v Keith Wilson>The goal was making sure that her team was as intact as we could to respond when a Portlander calls.

1025
02:00:15.783 --> 02:00:29.260
<v Keith Wilson>And so we carved from other areas and funded her at the last moment to make sure she didn't close any fire stations because to meet that 10%, She was going to have to do drastic cuts, and it wasn't going to meet the core value of what our budget writing was.

1026
02:00:29.792 --> 02:00:30.711
<v Keith Wilson>She ended up with a 4%.

1027
02:00:32.533 --> 02:00:48.363
<v Keith Wilson>Police, because our goal was we didn't want to see a single sworn officer, which takes years to become fully operational, we wanted to keep every patrol officer and every investigator on staff.

1028
02:00:48.507 --> 02:01:04.173
<v Keith Wilson>And to do that, We only took a 6% cut, and then we saw higher cuts in parks and in sheltering, even though we want to make sure we have at least one empty shelter bed every night for somebody who's ready to come in off of the street.

1029
02:01:04.881 --> 02:01:07.417
<v Keith Wilson>So it was not a cut across the system.

1030
02:01:07.466 --> 02:01:10.613
<v Keith Wilson>It was not a standard cut that everybody took.

1031
02:01:11.238 --> 02:01:12.877
<v Keith Wilson>It was very judicious.

1032
02:01:13.582 --> 02:01:14.466
<v Keith Wilson>It was very difficult.

1033
02:01:14.530 --> 02:01:14.627
<v Ginger Damron>Thank you.

1034
02:01:15.194 --> 02:01:20.168
<v Keith Wilson>It was having these individuals at my table over the course of many, many months.

1035
02:01:20.363 --> 02:01:27.180
<v Keith Wilson>And in the end, Friday night, Chief Johnson heading out to do a camping trip, we needed her and she answered the call.

1036
02:01:27.844 --> 02:01:32.677
<v Keith Wilson>And fire is the least cut bureau that we have.

1037
02:01:34.244 --> 02:01:37.072
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, I will leave it at that.

1038
02:01:37.136 --> 02:01:37.863
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for your time.

1039
02:01:38.927 --> 02:01:39.832
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1040
02:01:40.018 --> 02:01:40.771
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1041
02:01:42.506 --> 02:01:43.631
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

1042
02:01:43.855 --> 02:01:49.748
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I have a couple of smaller questions to start and then some deeper things I want to go into.

1043
02:01:50.439 --> 02:02:04.649
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, on— there were 2 areas where funding sources were identified as replacement dollar amounts, and I want to understand whether they are already secured, maybe not in the bank, but we know they are coming or not.

1044
02:02:05.467 --> 02:02:10.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first, my colleague Councilor Morillo asked about is the CHAT grant funding.

1045
02:02:10.797 --> 02:02:19.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know we're not sure on the timing for that funding, but has it been allocated on the federal level, or is it something that we are hoping will be allocated?

1046
02:02:20.331 --> 02:02:21.864
<v Rebecca Dobert>We've been awarded the grant.

1047
02:02:22.413 --> 02:02:24.367
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes, we've been awarded the grant.

1048
02:02:24.511 --> 02:02:30.872
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we are 100% sure, as much as we can be with this federal administration, that that money is coming.

1049
02:02:31.100 --> 02:02:31.295
<v Bob Causie>Yes.

1050
02:02:31.652 --> 02:02:31.797
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1051
02:02:32.667 --> 02:02:42.125
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then on the, um, cost allocation with the county that I believe is within BOEC.

1052
02:02:42.622 --> 02:02:42.783
<v Steve Maudsley>Yes.

1053
02:02:43.345 --> 02:03:05.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Have we notified the county of that change, and are they including their increased costs in their budget, or is there a possibility that this will end up being a budget hole through the year because they are not currently planning to include the increased Yeah, the county is a member of BOEC's user board and has been involved in conversations for a number of years.

1054
02:03:05.518 --> 02:03:12.578
<v Steve Maudsley>I think since DCA Kazi became director at BOEC, those conversations started about updating the IGA.

1055
02:03:13.663 --> 02:03:23.519
<v Steve Maudsley>And again, with the cost allocation last updated in 2005, the county has been at the table for those discussions.

1056
02:03:23.568 --> 02:03:28.167
<v Steve Maudsley>So in October of last year, the county was invited to participate in a the user board did take the vote to approve the new model.

1057
02:03:28.505 --> 02:03:29.338
<v Steve Maudsley>County was present.

1058
02:03:29.805 --> 02:03:38.243
<v Steve Maudsley>Multnomah County has 2 seats on the board for Multnomah County Emergency Medical System or Emergency Medical Services and Multnomah County Sheriff.

1059
02:03:38.387 --> 02:03:41.547
<v Steve Maudsley>Both voted no on that vote, but the vote did pass by quorum.

1060
02:03:42.253 --> 02:03:50.868
<v Steve Maudsley>So we are working right now with CA's office and administration to move official notice to the county.

1061
02:03:51.462 --> 02:03:57.260
<v Steve Maudsley>So they can include whatever allocation changes they need to make for the upcoming year.

1062
02:03:57.420 --> 02:04:00.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So again, they will budget how they budget.

1063
02:04:00.118 --> 02:04:02.413
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We can't control that, but they know this is coming.

1064
02:04:02.783 --> 02:04:08.692
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It was part of the vote, and we have every reason to believe that we will get that full amount of money from them.

1065
02:04:09.688 --> 02:04:19.529
<v Bob Causie>Yeah, I am, you know, I put it in percentages, 80% confident, only because We built a glide path for them.

1066
02:04:19.881 --> 02:04:25.564
<v Bob Causie>Their bill is actually much higher based on the funding model for, uh, for BOEC.

1067
02:04:25.965 --> 02:04:44.456
<v Bob Causie>And in order to help them through this transition, the decision to charge them $1 million over what they're currently paying to help offset the EMS costs that, that BOEC basically absorbs for AMR.

1068
02:04:44.921 --> 02:04:48.068
<v Bob Causie>That's really what this is all pertaining to.

1069
02:04:48.117 --> 02:04:58.216
<v Bob Causie>So we're building them a glide path so that they only pay $1 million above their current bill and then begin to build that out in, in following years.

1070
02:04:58.987 --> 02:05:12.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, and if the 20% chance happens, are we going to see you at fall TAO, or is there some sort plan B that is built into other funding within the bureau or the service area?

1071
02:05:14.238 --> 02:05:18.368
<v Bob Causie>I'll jump in and Steve can jump in if he has additional information.

1072
02:05:20.087 --> 02:05:20.778
<v Bob Causie>A couple things.

1073
02:05:21.131 --> 02:05:26.604
<v Bob Causie>The bureau will have to absorb that amount, which certainly will impact the bureau.

1074
02:05:26.929 --> 02:05:31.854
<v Bob Causie>On the bright side of that, overtime is going down.

1075
02:05:32.358 --> 02:05:35.796
<v Bob Causie>The costs do seem to be stable at BOEC right now.

1076
02:05:37.140 --> 02:05:40.109
<v Bob Causie>So the bureau is going to be taking a close look at that.

1077
02:05:40.688 --> 02:05:52.377
<v Bob Causie>They bill every month to all of the partner agencies— Troutdale, Fairview, Wood Village, Gresham, as well as Multnomah County— and we'll have a really clear picture early on.

1078
02:05:53.036 --> 02:05:53.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1079
02:05:54.417 --> 02:06:12.978
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And DCA Cossi, I should have started by saying thank you for your service to the city, not only over this past year in your DCA position, but starting many of the changes that have helped us to decrease the costs at BOEC that you're talking about now in your many years of service there before.

1080
02:06:13.524 --> 02:06:31.747
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate everything you've done for the city, and I will say, at least from, from the seat I sit in, the service area feels much more stable and like there's some clear integrated direction than it did a year ago today, and I appreciate your leadership in helping to make that happen.

1081
02:06:32.439 --> 02:06:33.489
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1082
02:06:33.684 --> 02:06:37.484
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>One more question while I'm on BOEC.

1083
02:06:39.164 --> 02:06:50.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In terms of implementation and what we should expect as impact from the cut of 2 full-time positions, does that mean that there will be more overtime?

1084
02:06:50.527 --> 02:06:58.128
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does that mean that there will be 2 fewer positions on the rotation of people answering calls.

1085
02:06:58.868 --> 02:07:03.909
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Should we expect that that means that wait times could increase slightly?

1086
02:07:04.680 --> 02:07:15.341
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is this covered by those trainees, or is this in line with maintaining current call answer times given the decrease in call volume?

1087
02:07:16.064 --> 02:07:17.364
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What is the impact on the ground?

1088
02:07:17.670 --> 02:07:17.958
<v Jamie Dunphy>Great question.

1089
02:07:18.072 --> 02:07:28.135
<v Steve Maudsley>Councilor, you've hit a number of things that keep me up at night, uh, increased call volume and wait times, uh, workload on staff and burnout, uh, those sorts of things.

1090
02:07:28.648 --> 02:07:43.998
<v Steve Maudsley>So, um, with the reduction of our 2 call taker dispatcher positions from our, uh, permanent staffing, we have an offset of the 8 limited-term positions in the, uh, $1.1 million, uh, training pipeline.

1091
02:07:44.658 --> 02:07:46.938
<v Steve Maudsley>So the change will be minimal.

1092
02:07:47.002 --> 02:07:59.448
<v Steve Maudsley>It is an impact to our permanent positions, which we would need to wait for attrition throughout the year to bring in 2— I guess we'd be bringing in 2 less folks into one of our academies, one of the 2, in the next 12 months.

1093
02:08:00.091 --> 02:08:02.788
<v Steve Maudsley>So generally it would be like a fall and a spring academy.

1094
02:08:03.448 --> 02:08:10.626
<v Steve Maudsley>And if we intend to bring in 8 at that time, because that's the number of positions we have available, or 10, then we would bring in 2 less at that time.

1095
02:08:10.675 --> 02:08:10.802
<v Steve Maudsley>Thank you.

1096
02:08:12.153 --> 02:08:19.908
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So what I'm hearing is we should not expect to hear from Portlanders that there's been a significant change in wait time for calls to be answered.

1097
02:08:22.310 --> 02:08:33.744
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We should expect to see 2 fewer people coming out of training, which could be an overtime issue in the coming years if we don't make up for that in future years.

1098
02:08:34.342 --> 02:08:40.398
<v Steve Maudsley>Yeah, I don't expect calls I don't expect our performance to change drastically.

1099
02:08:40.478 --> 02:08:43.064
<v Steve Maudsley>You know, one of the things we don't control is call volume.

1100
02:08:43.193 --> 02:08:53.411
<v Steve Maudsley>And, you know, we want to ensure that we have folks in the seats ready to answer those calls and also at the times of the year that makes sense for that based on historical performance and call volume.

1101
02:08:53.747 --> 02:09:00.335
<v Steve Maudsley>2022, 2023 were kind of odd years in the way that I think in 2022 was our highest call volume ever.

1102
02:09:00.479 --> 02:09:04.190
<v Steve Maudsley>And it happened to be the same year where we were at lowest certified staffing ever.

1103
02:09:04.287 --> 02:09:05.591
<v Steve Maudsley>Since then, we've been building back.

1104
02:09:05.751 --> 02:09:20.029
<v Steve Maudsley>I intend to do that over the next year, couple years, at least those 2 positions back, in addition to, you know, as far as we can get down the road, regaining those 8 limited-term positions and converting what we can to permanent positions, because that is our way forward.

1105
02:09:20.077 --> 02:09:20.689
<v Steve Maudsley>That is our way out.

1106
02:09:21.936 --> 02:09:22.387
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1107
02:09:24.099 --> 02:09:28.261
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>On the fire side, and I'll start not at Station 22, we'll get to that.

1108
02:09:31.052 --> 02:09:40.800
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Chief Johnson, with the reduction to 12 hours for the rescue units, I'd like to understand what we might be able to expect there.

1109
02:09:41.747 --> 02:09:48.041
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we have other rescue units that are already operating at just 12 hours a day, or are these our only 3 rescue units?

1110
02:09:48.153 --> 02:09:49.920
<v Rebecca Dobert>They're the only 3 rescue units.

1111
02:09:50.273 --> 02:09:58.783
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we don't have something to compare it to, to say here's what happens right.

1112
02:09:59.201 --> 02:10:05.225
<v Rebecca Dobert>We would be able to take roughly the amount of call volume that they respond to annually and cut that in half.

1113
02:10:05.885 --> 02:10:14.337
<v Rebecca Dobert>Although the plan is to have them doing the work when the majority of the calls come in so that they cover most of the peak hours.

1114
02:10:15.319 --> 02:10:19.735
<v Rebecca Dobert>The only condition that's really affecting that is our ability to staff the calls.

1115
02:10:19.784 --> 02:10:19.833
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1116
02:10:19.930 --> 02:10:23.413
<v Rebecca Dobert>The staff largely depends on when we start that work shift.

1117
02:10:23.478 --> 02:10:32.180
<v Rebecca Dobert>So it's going to be closer to when the firefighters get off from regular shifts at the station and start a shift on the rescue.

1118
02:10:33.207 --> 02:10:40.081
<v Rebecca Dobert>Right now we're thinking 8 AM to 8 PM, which will encompass most of the busiest hours of the rescues.

1119
02:10:41.076 --> 02:10:45.378
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, and you said something about having some flexibility in some of these changes.

1120
02:10:45.460 --> 02:11:00.985
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Changes, will you have the flexibility if we retain this cut, um, to shift around timing and staffing to find where the, where the most effective hours are to have these rigs available?

1121
02:11:01.226 --> 02:11:02.896
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's absolutely the plan.

1122
02:11:03.217 --> 02:11:11.390
<v Rebecca Dobert>That, like I said, the hinge I think is making sure that we can still have staff to work those shifts, but that's absolutely absolutely.

1123
02:11:12.064 --> 02:11:16.365
<v Rebecca Dobert>What our intention is, is to cover the busiest hours with those units.

1124
02:11:16.462 --> 02:11:17.185
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's why they're there.

1125
02:11:17.554 --> 02:11:18.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great, thank you.

1126
02:11:19.752 --> 02:11:21.052
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A question on CHAT.

1127
02:11:21.212 --> 02:11:35.867
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At one point I read something in the mayor's documents about the CHAT cut removing the follow-up care units, but I'm also seeing that the CHAT cut is these 2 positions, one of which is a management position.

1128
02:11:36.381 --> 02:11:40.527
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Will we Do we still have follow-up care teams at CHAT, or are those eliminated?

1129
02:11:42.489 --> 02:11:43.845
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yep, not eliminated.

1130
02:11:44.216 --> 02:11:45.234
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's not changing.

1131
02:11:45.605 --> 02:11:57.091
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So in terms of vehicles on the ground in community providing direct service, are there reductions with these CHAT cuts right now?

1132
02:11:57.284 --> 02:11:59.014
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, no, no, ma'am.

1133
02:11:59.466 --> 02:11:59.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1134
02:12:02.319 --> 02:12:11.707
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You mentioned that you had some concern that the state might see this as the city not being committed anymore because we don't have general fund in the program any longer.

1135
02:12:13.759 --> 02:12:17.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that would be a potential reduction in health share dollars available.

1136
02:12:17.872 --> 02:12:20.010
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that what you are concerned about?

1137
02:12:20.462 --> 02:12:23.216
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's the risk that I've been told.

1138
02:12:23.539 --> 02:12:34.528
<v Rebecca Dobert>I haven't been involved in those conversations up till now, just coming on in this fiscal we do have the mayor's offices involved with an upcoming meeting to talk about the changes with Health Share.

1139
02:12:34.997 --> 02:12:37.435
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, and when is the Health Share contract up?

1140
02:12:37.500 --> 02:12:44.257
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we need to worry about a renewal this budget cycle, or is that something that we could signal differently next year?

1141
02:12:47.970 --> 02:12:51.832
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay, current contract is up June 30th of this year.

1142
02:12:52.225 --> 02:12:55.998
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So when this budget goes into We're negotiating that contract right now.

1143
02:12:57.350 --> 02:12:57.610
<v Elizabeth Perez>Okay.

1144
02:13:01.015 --> 02:13:05.791
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think I remember that we're also negotiating our contract with our employees there.

1145
02:13:06.162 --> 02:13:06.742
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's right.

1146
02:13:07.387 --> 02:13:08.484
<v Rebecca Dobert>They're currently in bargaining.

1147
02:13:08.840 --> 02:13:18.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we need to worry that if we don't have city dollars in, in the pot here, that that could affect our contract negotiations?

1148
02:13:19.422 --> 02:13:28.648
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yes, let me turn around and look to see with those that are involved in the negotiations if that's—.

1149
02:13:28.648 --> 02:13:38.595
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I don't want to get too deep into that here at the dais, but I just, I want to understand if there's an implication that we should ask more about in executive session at some point there.

1150
02:13:38.851 --> 02:13:41.483
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think that's a fair assessment, fair statement.

1151
02:13:42.204 --> 02:13:44.418
<v Rebecca Dobert>Okay, yes, I would agree with that.

1152
02:13:44.500 --> 02:13:52.488
<v Rebecca Dobert>Agree that what you said is correct and that it's something we need to be concerned about moving forward in that contract.

1153
02:13:53.199 --> 02:13:53.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1154
02:13:54.104 --> 02:14:00.235
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate that you found a way to take reductions in that program that doesn't affect frontline service for Portlanders.

1155
02:14:00.753 --> 02:14:07.435
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's something that many of us have talked about hoping to see as we deal with some very difficult budget cuts.

1156
02:14:07.676 --> 02:14:16.365
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am a little bit concerned about what this means as we're We're in the middle of negotiating 2 contracts, one for funding coming in and one for supporting our staff on the ground.

1157
02:14:17.126 --> 02:14:20.349
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll ask more questions about that in the appropriate venues.

1158
02:14:20.689 --> 02:14:21.353
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1159
02:14:21.661 --> 02:14:30.118
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, last question before I turn to Station 22: do any of the cuts in fire slow down training or hiring?

1160
02:14:31.520 --> 02:14:34.159
<v Rebecca Dobert>No, that is what we've preserved.

1161
02:14:34.417 --> 02:14:34.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1162
02:14:36.914 --> 02:14:37.899
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So Station 22.

1163
02:14:39.659 --> 02:14:48.798
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, I will note, Chief, that we've had a lot of bureau directors up here over the last few weeks, and nobody likes the cuts that they put forward.

1164
02:14:51.265 --> 02:14:58.648
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But there was a sense of, I don't know, maybe defeat that I felt in your tone when you were talking about this.

1165
02:14:58.841 --> 02:15:00.402
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I, I don't know how real that is.

1166
02:15:00.454 --> 02:15:00.935
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think it's real.

1167
02:15:02.305 --> 02:15:05.845
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I can tell that you don't take these proposals lightly.

1168
02:15:10.706 --> 02:15:21.364
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Should residents of St. Johns, if we cut an engine from Station 22, expect that they will have the same level of service that the rest of the city has for fire safety?

1169
02:15:25.518 --> 02:15:29.140
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think the answer okay.

1170
02:15:29.364 --> 02:15:32.881
<v Rebecca Dobert>Um, we have data, right, and trends.

1171
02:15:33.073 --> 02:15:43.671
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think what's so hard about this is that there are models for understanding where we should make cuts based on population changes but not on budget requirements.

1172
02:15:44.394 --> 02:16:04.583
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so what's important to note is the major cause of fires, along with the major cause of medical emergencies and rescue emergencies are people, and it's very hard for us to predict changes in the population or in certain pockets of the city with enough speed to adjust the location of our resources.

1173
02:16:05.641 --> 02:16:14.210
<v Rebecca Dobert>We're also limited just by the structures that we have in terms of what additional units we can fit in closer fire stations.

1174
02:16:15.140 --> 02:16:19.024
<v Rebecca Dobert>So we're dealing with some fixed asset problems.

1175
02:16:19.842 --> 02:16:32.174
<v Rebecca Dobert>And to answer your question even more directly about what could change for those neighborhoods is that it's our estimation that a fire engine coming to that neighborhood is going to take 1 minute longer.

1176
02:16:33.570 --> 02:16:42.915
<v Rebecca Dobert>And then I really want to follow that up with the reassurance that that's the area that we are watching, that we prioritize moving resources up to.

1177
02:16:43.606 --> 02:16:49.979
<v Rebecca Dobert>Just like we do today if companies are on or tied up during simultaneous incidents.

1178
02:16:51.934 --> 02:16:57.851
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So a couple of other questions here just to understand the impact of this proposal, right?

1179
02:16:58.029 --> 02:17:12.215
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think this is one of the stations that has some of our wildfire, wildland fire resources, and they provide backup both in the natural areas along the Columbia Slough to the north and also to the station that covers Forest Park.

1180
02:17:12.699 --> 02:17:13.376
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that accurate?

1181
02:17:13.729 --> 02:17:13.956
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is.

1182
02:17:14.809 --> 02:17:34.184
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So if we are reduced to one vehicle, one rig at this station, and there is a wildland fire that requires backup in the Slough area or in Forest Park, what will happen to response times in the Station 22 area?

1183
02:17:35.890 --> 02:17:41.056
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think those will still, when it's requiring an engine, will be about that minute out.

1184
02:17:43.481 --> 02:18:03.325
<v Rebecca Dobert>The other operational changes that we would be able to make is we send firefighters from other stations to Station 22 to pick up those resources and still use them so that those assets that exist there for wildland or for the terminal okay.

1185
02:18:04.101 --> 02:18:11.386
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe this is one of about 5 or 6 stations that has their jurisdiction split by a bridge.

1186
02:18:12.727 --> 02:18:16.443
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There aren't very many in our city, and this is one of them.

1187
02:18:19.649 --> 02:18:27.486
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Does the idea that we could get stuck with a single rig on one side of the bridge and need support on the other side give you pause?

1188
02:18:28.240 --> 02:18:28.611
<v Rebecca Dobert>It does.

1189
02:18:29.284 --> 02:18:29.654
<v Rebecca Dobert>It does.

1190
02:18:29.990 --> 02:18:33.459
<v Rebecca Dobert>And unfortunately, it's not unique to that area.

1191
02:18:34.262 --> 02:18:47.477
<v Rebecca Dobert>I think what's so hard about this conversation is that we know, like you've said, regardless of which district this cut was impacting, we have high-value target hazards spread out across the city.

1192
02:18:48.070 --> 02:18:50.672
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's why fire stations are in the locations that they are.

1193
02:18:51.442 --> 02:19:01.832
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so it's so unfortunate, but we would be having this conversation regardless of which of those 8 stations we decided to remove an engine from.

1194
02:19:02.441 --> 02:19:08.913
<v Rebecca Dobert>And it was those 8 stations so that we could maintain an open fire station in every neighborhood.

1195
02:19:10.132 --> 02:19:12.188
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hear that, and I appreciate that.

1196
02:19:12.300 --> 02:19:19.911
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think what gives me concern here, and I want to be clear, I'm not proposing that we cut anybody else's fire engine instead.

1197
02:19:20.408 --> 02:19:32.772
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But what gives me pause about this fire station specifically is that I, I understand that from a call volume perspective, this may have been the best station to look at.

1198
02:19:33.270 --> 02:20:04.520
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>From an emergency preparedness perspective, I'm very worried because we know that St. John's has some particular impacts when it comes to emergency emergency preparedness as a peninsula, a peninsula with bridges that are not all quite sound, an area with many bridges that are not up to the structural integrity to hold a quint, and an area that serves Linton and backs up CEI Hub and Forest Park across the river.

1199
02:20:05.532 --> 02:20:07.460
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It seems to me that this station.

1200
02:20:07.600 --> 02:20:08.198
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1201
02:20:08.456 --> 02:20:20.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Again, from a call volume perspective might have made sense, but from an emergency situation perspective, it's one of the hardest areas to see reduced resource in the city.

1202
02:20:21.054 --> 02:20:29.949
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Also, as a peninsula, we can't easily get vehicles in on the other side quite as quickly as, as somewhere else.

1203
02:20:30.046 --> 02:20:33.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So I will be looking to figure out what we can do here.

1204
02:20:34.427 --> 02:20:39.060
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, this isn't something that I can easily stomach for that community.

1205
02:20:39.397 --> 02:20:45.424
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I appreciate your honesty in answering the direct question about what folks in the region should expect.

1206
02:20:46.691 --> 02:20:51.531
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, Council President, I think that's more than my 10 minutes, so I'll pause there.

1207
02:20:51.916 --> 02:20:52.638
<v Steve Maudsley>Thank you, Councilor.

1208
02:20:52.879 --> 02:20:54.081
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1209
02:20:54.721 --> 02:20:55.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman.

1210
02:20:55.828 --> 02:20:56.052
<v Steve Maudsley>Great.

1211
02:20:56.308 --> 02:21:03.311
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, my conversation is going to be entirely with the Fire Bureau and the leadership So if you've got your budget folks around, why don't you bring them on up?

1212
02:21:03.649 --> 02:21:11.177
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I want to talk a little bit about just some mechanisms.

1213
02:21:11.436 --> 02:21:20.564
<v Eric Zimmerman>So can we first talk about, Chief, how many current vacancies does the bureau have with respect to firefighters?

1214
02:21:20.905 --> 02:21:21.813
<v Rebecca Dobert>Firefighters?

1215
02:21:22.121 --> 02:21:25.686
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or any level of, I'll say, captain and below.

1216
02:21:26.162 --> 02:21:26.315
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sure.

1217
02:21:28.099 --> 02:21:29.195
<v Rebecca Dobert>Ginger was right there.

1218
02:21:30.680 --> 02:21:34.227
<v Rebecca Dobert>Do you have that?

1219
02:21:34.308 --> 02:21:34.614
<v Eric Zimmerman>Good morning.

1220
02:21:36.486 --> 02:21:36.956
<v Ginger Damron>Good morning.

1221
02:21:37.052 --> 02:21:38.979
<v Ginger Damron>Ginger Damron, Public Safety Budget Manager.

1222
02:21:39.659 --> 02:21:50.212
<v Ginger Damron>There's 11 vacant firefighters, um, as of today, with an academy anticipated to start this month, but also all of the retirements that were mentioned.

1223
02:21:50.309 --> 02:21:53.921
<v Ginger Damron>Um, we may have already had a couple of those, so Okay.

1224
02:21:54.018 --> 02:21:54.113
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah.

1225
02:21:54.179 --> 02:21:54.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for that.

1226
02:21:54.840 --> 02:22:09.552
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in terms of, you know, looking through these budget documents, one thing that is hard to suss out here is, does the Fire Bureau have a separate line item budget for overtime purely?

1227
02:22:12.440 --> 02:22:12.927
<v Ginger Damron>Yes.

1228
02:22:13.188 --> 02:22:31.700
<v Ginger Damron>There's definitely a separate line item for overtime, and they're a little bit unique where it's not necessarily offset with vacancy savings, particularly because this year we added 10 FTE in the FY26 budget that did not have funding, with the assumption that as they staffed up, they would offset overtime.

1229
02:22:32.326 --> 02:22:34.174
<v Ginger Damron>So those positions weren't funded.

1230
02:22:34.301 --> 02:22:42.683
<v Ginger Damron>They're already sort of baked in, if that makes sense, of they, they are going to be funded by once they're deployed to, to offset overtime.

1231
02:22:43.710 --> 02:22:46.247
<v Ginger Damron>But the total overtime budget's around $22 million.

1232
02:22:46.328 --> 02:22:46.488
<v Elizabeth Perez>Thank you.

1233
02:22:48.314 --> 02:22:53.333
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that a separate line item budget or is that partially vacancy savings?

1234
02:22:53.445 --> 02:22:54.282
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's what I'm trying to get to.

1235
02:22:54.426 --> 02:22:56.583
<v Ginger Damron>Yeah, not for the Fire Bureau.

1236
02:22:56.744 --> 02:22:57.700
<v Ginger Damron>It's not vacancy savings.

1237
02:22:58.385 --> 02:22:59.475
<v Eric Zimmerman>It is not vacancy savings.

1238
02:22:59.523 --> 02:22:59.702
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

1239
02:22:59.915 --> 02:23:00.093
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1240
02:23:00.762 --> 02:23:02.014
<v Eric Zimmerman>So $22 million.

1241
02:23:04.229 --> 02:23:04.443
<v Angelita Morillo>Got it.

1242
02:23:04.988 --> 02:23:05.286
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1243
02:23:09.058 --> 02:23:09.172
<v Candace Avalos>And—.

1244
02:23:09.284 --> 02:23:16.631
<v Ginger Damron>But let me just, let me clarify one thing though, because I think that something that got mentioned is there is a dynamic between staffing and overtime.

1245
02:23:16.712 --> 02:23:28.895
<v Ginger Damron>And so if we have more separations in May, sort of what we're assuming to be staffed next year, we may have more overtime and then would have some vacancy savings because there's— it takes time to hire people.

1246
02:23:28.990 --> 02:23:30.595
<v Eric Zimmerman>I get that, right.

1247
02:23:30.996 --> 02:23:40.311
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I'm trying to understand right now is if the bureau's financial practice is take a look at a given month and say, Golly, look at that.

1248
02:23:40.524 --> 02:24:01.587
<v Eric Zimmerman>I had 11 vacancies that otherwise would have been straight time, but since those employees were not filled, if the bureau is using those funds, that bucket, so to speak, the unexpended funds, as its first tranche of money then to fill shifts in an overtime status, that's what I'm trying to figure out here.

1249
02:24:01.747 --> 02:24:16.704
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or if that's not the case and in fact actually to fill shifts that we are tapping into the overtime fund, which is now, has been established as a line item, while the vacancy one does not get filled.

1250
02:24:16.754 --> 02:24:19.513
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's what I'm trying to understand from a financials practice purpose.

1251
02:24:20.352 --> 02:24:32.844
<v Ginger Damron>Yeah, and so the way it works is there's an overtime line item, and really what we are doing is staffing 171 on-duty responders.

1252
02:24:33.729 --> 02:24:33.875
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1253
02:24:33.954 --> 02:24:38.195
<v Ginger Damron>So whether we're doing that with straight time or overtime, that is how many we're staffing.

1254
02:24:38.244 --> 02:24:52.965
<v Ginger Damron>So we have a staffing plan that says we're going to have X number of responders next year, and they're going to do— 80% of their hours will be working, and then we need a certain number of overtime hours to offset the rest of it.

1255
02:24:53.158 --> 02:25:00.888
<v Ginger Damron>And so there's this— there's this difference than how the police bureau, for example, operates, where there are vacancy savings that are accounting for it.

1256
02:25:01.977 --> 02:25:10.913
<v Ginger Damron>Having said all that, I anticipate next year we may have some vacancy savings that will fund what could be additional overtime if we have higher turnover in May.

1257
02:25:11.490 --> 02:25:12.052
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1258
02:25:14.270 --> 02:25:20.876
<v Eric Zimmerman>It matters here in terms of the number we're talking about, and I don't know what your per-funded FTE round number would be.

1259
02:25:20.956 --> 02:25:25.640
<v Eric Zimmerman>Let's just round number it at 118, which is similar to the police bureau.

1260
02:25:26.207 --> 02:25:29.566
<v Eric Zimmerman>But 11 people times 118 each month, that's kind of where I'm going.

1261
02:25:31.270 --> 02:25:43.787
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say that, that seems like complicated acrobatic math, but when we're trying to understand a $2.5 million cut, acrobatic math gets you to budget dust and budget dust gets you to an engine.

1262
02:25:45.165 --> 02:25:56.095
<v Eric Zimmerman>So when I look at $2.5 million for an engine consideration, and that's essentially $300 an hour in a 24-hour period.

1263
02:25:56.192 --> 02:25:56.274
<v Bob Causie>Yeah.

1264
02:25:56.381 --> 02:25:57.561
<v Eric Zimmerman>To keep that thing alive, right?

1265
02:25:57.610 --> 02:26:08.325
<v Eric Zimmerman>If it's a 4-person engine, $72 an hour, $300 an hour overall to keep that thing functioning is kind of the math if I deduce it out of what the cut to an engine truly means.

1266
02:26:14.046 --> 02:26:18.501
<v Eric Zimmerman>So we have established the concern around Station 22.

1267
02:26:20.318 --> 02:26:27.665
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to just make sure that I understand one piece that that came up that, you know, we're all learning about different types of apparatus here.

1268
02:26:27.957 --> 02:26:30.236
<v Eric Zimmerman>Engines versus trucks versus— somebody said a quint.

1269
02:26:30.495 --> 02:26:32.451
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't know what that is, but that sounds like a bigger thing.

1270
02:26:33.569 --> 02:26:36.405
<v Eric Zimmerman>But it's not.

1271
02:26:39.546 --> 02:26:40.271
<v Eric Zimmerman>Chief, what's a quint?

1272
02:26:40.529 --> 02:26:48.286
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah, so it's something that does a little bit of what an engine does because it carries water in a small amount of hose.

1273
02:26:48.796 --> 02:26:48.908
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

1274
02:26:48.972 --> 02:26:54.656
<v Rebecca Dobert>But then it is a big heavy unit that has the same big ladder on top so that it's—.

1275
02:26:54.656 --> 02:26:54.769
<v Olivia Clark>Got it.

1276
02:26:55.236 --> 02:27:03.094
<v Rebecca Dobert>For us and our system, when we've had to use them, they act like trucks, but they do have an available tank of water to use based on the incident.

1277
02:27:03.175 --> 02:27:07.158
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just want to ask some layperson questions, right?

1278
02:27:07.450 --> 02:27:12.740
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think about Portland neighborhoods and we talk about the presence of water.

1279
02:27:12.870 --> 02:27:14.095
<v Eric Zimmerman>There are fire hydrants.

1280
02:27:14.144 --> 02:27:25.936
<v Eric Zimmerman>So in terms of the initial attack, does initial attack on a fire happen with water that you bring with you, and then we're looking for where can we hook up that may be half a block away to supplement that supply.

1281
02:27:26.001 --> 02:27:27.630
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that kind of what we're talking about?

1282
02:27:28.059 --> 02:27:28.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1283
02:27:28.253 --> 02:27:37.051
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so we have more engines that respond to a structure fire because they do use hoses to connect to the fire hydrant and bring that water to the scene.

1284
02:27:37.308 --> 02:27:37.614
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1285
02:27:38.161 --> 02:27:46.387
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then in Forest Park, for instance, or in that area, we're talking we bring the water that we have to fight with and that's kind of about it.

1286
02:27:46.622 --> 02:27:53.262
<v Eric Zimmerman>Unless we have a specialty, unless we happen to be close to an infrastructure that actually has a hydrant system.

1287
02:27:53.325 --> 02:27:53.649
<v Rebecca Dobert>Right.

1288
02:27:53.729 --> 02:28:01.369
<v Rebecca Dobert>We do have some wildland units that are more adept and able to get into certain parts of Forest Park.

1289
02:28:01.850 --> 02:28:08.595
<v Rebecca Dobert>There's also a sort of a sprinkler system that is set up in that area that neighborhood teams can activate.

1290
02:28:08.871 --> 02:28:09.164
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

1291
02:28:10.153 --> 02:28:10.688
<v Eric Zimmerman>All right, that's helpful.

1292
02:28:15.495 --> 02:28:23.085
<v Eric Zimmerman>So traditionally, how has the— how have vacancy savings then been used by the Fire Bureau?

1293
02:28:23.134 --> 02:28:25.873
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to make sure I'm understanding just kind of the, the mechanisms here.

1294
02:28:26.791 --> 02:28:38.155
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, in years past, if the fire business ops— if you came to the end of like the first quarter and you had a certain number of vacancies, what then were those funds expended for?

1295
02:28:39.368 --> 02:28:40.522
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>I can speak to that a little bit.

1296
02:28:40.826 --> 02:28:47.771
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>I think that fire is unique relative to some of the other bureaus in that we don't typically carry many vacancies, or certainly not operational vacancies.

1297
02:28:48.347 --> 02:28:54.713
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Oftentimes, if you were to pull a report out of SAP or have that provided to you, it will potentially show a vacancy on paper.

1298
02:28:55.259 --> 02:29:05.088
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>What it doesn't necessarily note is that perhaps in a different position, we've double, double filled to operationally get the capacity that we need working to staff the 171.

1299
02:29:05.764 --> 02:29:26.750
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>And so it is not historically not often where there have been a material amount of vacancies that the bureau is carrying that would have been something, again, different from police, for example, where you can look at a larger group and kind of apply that, what otherwise would have been budgeted for those positions towards something else.

1300
02:29:27.431 --> 02:29:27.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1301
02:29:27.609 --> 02:29:35.219
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>So fire's just, yeah, historically not had that same volume of money to So where does the—.

1302
02:29:35.509 --> 02:29:41.176
<v Eric Zimmerman>If I look back at the multiple years, where did the ending fund balances come from, right?

1303
02:29:41.386 --> 02:29:49.541
<v Eric Zimmerman>Over the last several years, ending fund balance in the Fire Bureau looks to be around hovering around a quarter million dollars either direction of $7 million.

1304
02:29:49.896 --> 02:29:51.275
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>That's the capital reserve fund.

1305
02:29:51.341 --> 02:29:52.640
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's just capital reserves?

1306
02:29:52.704 --> 02:29:52.977
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Correct.

1307
02:29:53.042 --> 02:29:54.520
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>That is only the capital reserve fund.

1308
02:29:54.647 --> 02:30:00.798
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>And those are the residual funds from the Got it.

1309
02:30:01.041 --> 02:30:01.204
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

1310
02:30:03.145 --> 02:30:03.943
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you for that.

1311
02:30:05.289 --> 02:30:10.990
<v Eric Zimmerman>In terms of operational funds, does the Fire Bureau generally turn anything back in at the end of the year?

1312
02:30:12.041 --> 02:30:12.431
<v Candace Avalos>We have.

1313
02:30:12.528 --> 02:30:16.754
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>I mean, in the— was it just last year that there was some?

1314
02:30:16.884 --> 02:30:20.800
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>I know that previously there was about $900,000 that we had turned back in.

1315
02:30:21.042 --> 02:30:23.369
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>It was part of the public safety policy set-aside monies.

1316
02:30:24.063 --> 02:30:25.859
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>That I believe— was that just last year?

1317
02:30:26.066 --> 02:30:26.579
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>What is time?

1318
02:30:26.852 --> 02:30:28.777
<v Ginger Damron>That was, um, I had one 2 years ago.

1319
02:30:29.032 --> 02:30:29.257
<v Ginger Damron>Okay.

1320
02:30:29.337 --> 02:30:30.042
<v Ginger Damron>We didn't turn anything.

1321
02:30:30.299 --> 02:30:30.459
<v Ginger Damron>Yeah.

1322
02:30:30.781 --> 02:30:30.893
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Okay.

1323
02:30:30.972 --> 02:30:31.502
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>No, last year.

1324
02:30:31.599 --> 02:30:32.095
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Yeah, last year.

1325
02:30:32.159 --> 02:30:32.448
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>That's right.

1326
02:30:32.560 --> 02:30:35.013
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>Last year we, we squeaked through by the skin of our teeth.

1327
02:30:35.190 --> 02:30:37.578
<v Elizabeth Gallagher>But, um, prior to that, yes, we have given back funds.

1328
02:30:38.092 --> 02:30:38.333
<v Ginger Damron>Okay.

1329
02:30:38.974 --> 02:30:43.672
<v Ginger Damron>I mean, and I, I do want to kind of clarify because I'm— I think I'm tracking with where you're going.

1330
02:30:43.863 --> 02:30:50.052
<v Ginger Damron>The vacancies— I mean, if there are vacant positions, fire's very set on the minimum staffing level.

1331
02:30:50.278 --> 02:30:58.662
<v Ginger Damron>And so if we're vacant positions and so then effectively it is getting used for overtime.

1332
02:30:59.415 --> 02:31:06.966
<v Ginger Damron>I think there's a little bit of a different dynamic where the work week was shortened, and so the hours worked increased also that was needed.

1333
02:31:08.297 --> 02:31:12.288
<v Ginger Damron>And the original— we added 33 positions in the last 3 years.

1334
02:31:12.463 --> 02:31:17.626
<v Ginger Damron>The first 13 didn't have funding, so they're supposed to offset overtime, and then the last 10 this year didn't have funding.

1335
02:31:17.722 --> 02:31:18.138
<v Ginger Damron>Councilor Smith.

1336
02:31:23.100 --> 02:31:28.340
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, I think actually not having the dynamic be quite as clean is actually problematic, right?

1337
02:31:28.340 --> 02:31:32.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>So an unfunded position, we think— I think we need to wrap our heads around what the hell that actually means.

1338
02:31:33.079 --> 02:31:35.399
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so that's the challenge here.

1339
02:31:36.399 --> 02:31:45.333
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so what I'm trying to get at is, and we've had this conversation with other bureaus too, is that we yeah.

1340
02:31:45.239 --> 02:31:45.420
<v Dan Ryan>Need to be very careful about what we're saying.

1341
02:31:45.559 --> 02:31:54.897
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is the way a person who fills a shift on an overtime status is paid, right?

1342
02:31:54.961 --> 02:31:59.411
<v Eric Zimmerman>That person's paycheck should not know what the backend accounting was.

1343
02:31:59.490 --> 02:32:02.104
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's just that X number of hours were in an overtime status.

1344
02:32:02.445 --> 02:32:04.262
<v Eric Zimmerman>Great, that's what should occur.

1345
02:32:04.959 --> 02:32:36.335
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I'm trying to understand is if we are, We are placing funds into an overtime bucket at the expense of placing them in an operational bucket because our practice is to tap an overtime bucket anytime somebody moves into an overtime status versus if we had the operational bucket filled.

1346
02:32:36.433 --> 02:32:36.514
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay.

1347
02:32:38.128 --> 02:32:42.293
<v Eric Zimmerman>And therefore the overtime budget could come down as well.

1348
02:32:42.389 --> 02:32:43.957
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's what I'm struggling with.

1349
02:32:44.408 --> 02:33:05.575
<v Eric Zimmerman>And having the different variations of how overtime is expended, statuses like approved but not filled, or excuse me, approved but not funded, these are the challenges that make, when we're talking about such a small number as $2.5 million, that make it very challenging to know what the right math is.

1350
02:33:05.622 --> 02:33:21.859
<v Eric Zimmerman>So my next question is, is the overtime budget for the Fire Bureau an on-time, or excuse me, an ongoing line item of general fund dollars, or is it every year we put in a number that is one-time only, knowing full well that you have to have an overtime budget?

1351
02:33:21.907 --> 02:33:24.011
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just trying to get for what is the practice here.

1352
02:33:24.959 --> 02:33:28.717
<v Ginger Damron>The funding, so there's a, I think there's kind of 2 answers.

1353
02:33:28.909 --> 02:33:34.220
<v Ginger Damron>One is, There has not been adequate ongoing funding to afford all of the overtime needed.

1354
02:33:34.284 --> 02:33:39.227
<v Ginger Damron>So there's been one-time dollars given to the Fire Bureau the last couple of years.

1355
02:33:39.420 --> 02:33:44.699
<v Ginger Damron>This year it is $5.3 million of one-time funding in FY26.

1356
02:33:45.211 --> 02:33:50.314
<v Ginger Damron>Next year there is $2 million of one-time funding in the overtime.

1357
02:33:50.650 --> 02:33:51.613
<v Eric Zimmerman>What do you mean next?

1358
02:33:51.774 --> 02:33:53.475
<v Eric Zimmerman>Oh, this one we're talking about right now?

1359
02:33:53.523 --> 02:33:53.700
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1360
02:33:54.406 --> 02:33:57.694
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, and where, where in the budget can I find such information?

1361
02:33:59.165 --> 02:34:01.599
<v Ginger Damron>We noted it in the decision package narrative.

1362
02:34:02.049 --> 02:34:11.361
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, I'm looking for like spreadsheets and numbers because I sure got a whole lot of narratives, but I sure don't have a lot of numbers, and I am finding decision-making to be incredibly difficult.

1363
02:34:12.074 --> 02:34:12.414
<v Ginger Damron>I see Ruth.

1364
02:34:12.477 --> 02:34:13.416
<v Ginger Damron>Come on up, Ruth.

1365
02:34:16.059 --> 02:34:18.203
<v Eric Zimmerman>I mean, I'll just— I want to do a little bit of commentary.

1366
02:34:18.269 --> 02:34:29.733
<v Eric Zimmerman>Just even the way that the presentations are going is challenging because it is full of narrative and void of real numbers and year-over-year comparisons.

1367
02:34:29.959 --> 02:34:33.641
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I really appreciated Elizabeth with PBIM.

1368
02:34:34.081 --> 02:34:37.477
<v Eric Zimmerman>She said we're getting rid of 4 and put in parentheses of 8 vehicles.

1369
02:34:37.889 --> 02:34:40.302
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's the kind of context that we need to make decisions.

1370
02:34:40.352 --> 02:34:44.450
<v Eric Zimmerman>And very few presentations this far have had that context.

1371
02:34:44.514 --> 02:34:46.188
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just, that's an editorial note there.

1372
02:34:46.666 --> 02:34:47.691
<v Eric Zimmerman>Ruth, you stepped up.

1373
02:34:47.840 --> 02:34:48.996
<v Rebecca Dobert>Sure.

1374
02:34:49.262 --> 02:34:50.800
<v Candace Avalos>Sure, Ruth Levine, Budget Director.

1375
02:34:51.329 --> 02:34:56.443
<v Candace Avalos>I stepped up to speak to the question about the one-time versus ongoing.

1376
02:34:57.597 --> 02:35:06.174
<v Candace Avalos>I think, I believe it's in the tables in the bureau summary of the proposed budget book.

1377
02:35:06.896 --> 02:35:18.519
<v Candace Avalos>There's also, I would direct people again to the City Budget Office dashboard for the proposed budget, which can link links from our website.

1378
02:35:18.566 --> 02:35:19.656
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's different than OpenBook?

1379
02:35:20.509 --> 02:35:21.265
<v Candace Avalos>It is, yes.

1380
02:35:21.329 --> 02:35:33.566
<v Candace Avalos>There's a Tableau dashboard that just, you can actually download data from there and has a little bit more, it's more dynamic than OpenBook, which is static, obviously.

1381
02:35:35.079 --> 02:35:39.684
<v Candace Avalos>So those are probably the first places I would recommend people go.

1382
02:35:41.505 --> 02:35:46.944
<v Candace Avalos>I believe we can, if we haven't already, we can also— I think we have.

1383
02:35:48.463 --> 02:36:03.257
<v Candace Avalos>Post some raw data of the prior 2 fiscal years and the budget in Excel on our website so that people can play with that themselves.

1384
02:36:03.451 --> 02:36:07.447
<v Candace Avalos>But so there are a couple of different places to answer that question.

1385
02:36:07.786 --> 02:36:30.760
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if I'm looking at, and I am right now looking at Portland Fire and Rescue budget revenues by major object, expenses by major object, I've basically got some big fat buckets, one of which is personnel, $171, $172 million, and that doesn't tell me much.

1386
02:36:31.755 --> 02:36:32.077
<v Dan Ryan>Right.

1387
02:36:32.157 --> 02:36:44.284
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's where I'm not loving the idea that I have to have a decoder ring that goes outside of the budget documents to go find the information because that that is going to be challenging for the rest of the season.

1388
02:36:44.397 --> 02:36:53.863
<v Eric Zimmerman>And it's again a challenge from— that we noted last year in terms of what makes up $171 million if it is not all actually straight personnel.

1389
02:36:54.270 --> 02:36:56.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I'm challenged by that.

1390
02:36:57.110 --> 02:36:57.255
<v Bob Causie>The—.

1391
02:37:07.647 --> 02:37:11.972
<v Rebecca Dobert>Thank you.

1392
02:37:12.953 --> 02:37:32.643
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think, um, in terms of— I'd like to get a sense, and as I close this out, I'd like to just get a sense of, um, kind of how the, the last part was, and I really appreciated whomever it was.

1393
02:37:32.693 --> 02:37:35.728
<v Eric Zimmerman>Somebody was talking about making decisions against risk factors, right?

1394
02:37:35.906 --> 02:37:41.398
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that's an incredibly important and sometimes nuanced and lost aspect.

1395
02:37:41.462 --> 02:37:47.391
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I was hoping, Chief, that you could articulate a little bit about what risk factors, right?

1396
02:37:47.441 --> 02:37:51.756
<v Eric Zimmerman>As anybody who's evaluated risk, we put more— it's a weighted total, right?

1397
02:37:51.806 --> 02:37:53.552
<v Eric Zimmerman>We put weight on certain items.

1398
02:37:54.070 --> 02:38:09.481
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can you talk about relative to the double company stations, what types of risk factors you were giving more weight to versus other risk factors in that decision-making process, because I think it is quite helpful to understand that.

1399
02:38:09.531 --> 02:38:14.316
<v Rebecca Dobert>Yeah, no, I appreciate that question, and it's important to speak to all of you about that.

1400
02:38:14.459 --> 02:38:18.907
<v Rebecca Dobert>So as I mentioned, there are 8 double company stations in the city.

1401
02:38:20.128 --> 02:38:23.082
<v Rebecca Dobert>In District 1, there's Station 2 and Station 7.

1402
02:38:23.981 --> 02:38:28.959
<v Rebecca Dobert>District— or Station 2 2 is a double company house that we use as our training environment.

1403
02:38:29.055 --> 02:38:40.536
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so that— it was not an option to close because it would impact the pipeline for recruits and trainees that come out to the field and ultimately fill those vacancies that we've been talking about.

1404
02:38:41.323 --> 02:38:43.233
<v Rebecca Dobert>Station 7 is our hazmat station.

1405
02:38:43.570 --> 02:38:46.734
<v Rebecca Dobert>That's a county resource that's also called on by the state.

1406
02:38:46.942 --> 02:38:55.034
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so that team needs to stay together and stay intact to provide hazmat protection for the City of Portland.

1407
02:38:55.452 --> 02:39:01.779
<v Rebecca Dobert>Let me talk about District 4, which has 3 stations— Station 3, Station 4, and Station 1.

1408
02:39:01.890 --> 02:39:05.215
<v Rebecca Dobert>Those are all closest into the downtown city core.

1409
02:39:05.969 --> 02:39:12.858
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so in terms of risk analysis there, one, call volume is high for all of those stations.

1410
02:39:13.852 --> 02:39:21.111
<v Rebecca Dobert>Additionally, the call volume for the stations that would move up and fill in to those locations are also already high.

1411
02:39:21.800 --> 02:39:25.606
<v Rebecca Dobert>And so they wouldn't be available to come in and take that workload.

1412
02:39:26.683 --> 02:39:29.798
<v Rebecca Dobert>And then we also have the hazards that are downtown.

1413
02:39:29.845 --> 02:39:41.198
<v Rebecca Dobert>So I mentioned a core group of high-rise buildings that require us to assemble a larger number of firefighters before we can ever engage a fire that's taking place in one of those buildings.

1414
02:39:43.033 --> 02:39:44.933
<v Rebecca Dobert>District 3 has Station 25.

1415
02:39:45.513 --> 02:39:59.647
<v Rebecca Dobert>It was also probably the other place that would have been considered for a closure, except that it is east and it is going to be heavily impacted by the closure, the part-time closures of the 3 rescues.

1416
02:40:00.208 --> 02:40:04.677
<v Rebecca Dobert>So it's going to shift the run volume from Stations 19, 11, and 31.

1417
02:40:05.049 --> 02:40:09.540
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's going to be pushed over to the 2 apparatus that are at Station 25.

1418
02:40:11.084 --> 02:40:12.530
<v Rebecca Dobert>13 Is in District 2.

1419
02:40:12.691 --> 02:40:25.548
<v Rebecca Dobert>That is the other double company house that is just outside of the downtown core and responds in, but their call volume is high enough that a surrounding station could not move up and absorb that and, and be available.

1420
02:40:25.870 --> 02:40:29.718
<v Rebecca Dobert>We would be calling units from further out to come to 13.

1421
02:40:30.639 --> 02:40:32.645
<v Rebecca Dobert>That really leaves us at Station 25.

1422
02:40:34.518 --> 02:40:42.855
<v Rebecca Dobert>No good decision was to be made there, but just to be clear about how much thought went into making that choice.

1423
02:40:43.504 --> 02:40:46.322
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, thank you for walking us through that.

1424
02:40:46.646 --> 02:40:50.370
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that is helpful, and it's kind of the sense I've been feeling.

1425
02:40:50.420 --> 02:40:51.390
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's no good decisions here.

1426
02:40:53.920 --> 02:41:10.125
<v Eric Zimmerman>I share the concerns with Councilor Smith the factors of the slough, the peninsula, having lived in St. Johns myself and knowing what that situation is like, and given the— like, I share that.

1427
02:41:10.222 --> 02:41:10.952
<v Eric Zimmerman>I understand it.

1428
02:41:12.414 --> 02:41:26.798
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's why when we talk about $2.5 million to keep an engine on shift, I think it's worthy to dig into the budget dust.

1429
02:41:27.457 --> 02:41:50.757
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'll end with, Council President, I'll end with, from a DCA perspective, I think that there is, and I have some interest in, certain vacancy savings across the service area not being assumed to yes.

1430
02:41:50.822 --> 02:42:16.409
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think it's important that we don't just stay within various bureaus or offices by default, and that there's a decision-making at a DCA level perhaps for how we operationalize our day-in and our day-out frontline services through the vacancy situation across the organization and not just single bureaus.

1431
02:42:16.523 --> 02:42:19.807
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just, I say that for future development.

1432
02:42:20.031 --> 02:42:20.930
<v Eric Zimmerman>But thanks, Mr. President.

1433
02:42:21.877 --> 02:42:22.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1434
02:42:22.775 --> 02:42:31.554
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we have about 12 min— or sorry, 22 minutes left, and there are 4 colleagues in the queue who have not spoken yet and 2 who are hoping to get to a second round.

1435
02:42:31.602 --> 02:42:32.612
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know that's going to happen.

1436
02:42:32.661 --> 02:42:35.261
<v Jamie Dunphy>So Councilor Smith, followed by Green and Ryan.

1437
02:42:35.388 --> 02:42:37.138
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'll just go ahead and take myself out of the queue.

1438
02:42:37.924 --> 02:42:39.144
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

1439
02:42:39.449 --> 02:42:46.959
<v Loretta Smith>Um, first I'd like to say to, uh, DCA Causey, thank you for your over 30 years worth of service for the City of Portland.

1440
02:42:47.873 --> 02:42:51.819
<v Loretta Smith>It has been exemplary, exemplary, uh, you know, experience.

1441
02:42:51.965 --> 02:43:00.691
<v Loretta Smith>And what you've done with the 911 system prior to coming to DCA, I always told you that you should have offered a master class on how to do that.

1442
02:43:01.686 --> 02:43:09.756
<v Loretta Smith>You really manage the, um, the vacancies and improve the efficiencies there, and that was what I was able to see.

1443
02:43:09.805 --> 02:43:10.859
<v Loretta Smith>So thank you so much thank you.

1444
02:43:10.929 --> 02:43:11.870
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much for all of your service.

1445
02:43:12.979 --> 02:43:17.879
<v Loretta Smith>But let me tell you a little bit about my concern about the Public Safety Department.

1446
02:43:20.272 --> 02:43:40.078
<v Loretta Smith>My concern is that this budget says we're preserving core services, emergency response, but the reductions before us touch every part of the emergency response chain: 911 call-taking, emergency preparedness, fire apparatus, rescue units, on-duty firefighters, and alternative medical response.

1447
02:43:40.725 --> 02:44:00.897
<v Loretta Smith>I want to understand whether these alternative efficiencies— are they truly efficiencies, or whether we're accepting slower response times, greater overtime risks, and reduced service in communities that already experience the greatest disparities, like District 1?

1448
02:44:01.512 --> 02:44:12.441
<v Loretta Smith>So my first question for you is, Portland Fire and Rescue proposes eliminating 2 administrative support positions, which will shift duties to higher-level staff and executives.

1449
02:44:12.859 --> 02:44:27.476
<v Loretta Smith>How much executive or sworn staff time will be redirected to administrative tasks, and could that create a hidden operational cost in overtime for these very—.

1450
02:44:28.877 --> 02:44:38.390
<v Rebecca Dobert>These are higher-paid I, I can speak to that, Councilor, just to help answer the question.

1451
02:44:38.987 --> 02:44:53.920
<v Rebecca Dobert>It's, it's my plan that the administrative tasks are either done within the regular 40-hour weeks or they're shifted to our executive staff that are salaried employees and don't incur overtime costs.

1452
02:44:55.275 --> 02:45:06.342
<v Loretta Smith>So they're So how do they actually get that work done if the redirected administrative tasks are going to the executives?

1453
02:45:06.438 --> 02:45:08.677
<v Loretta Smith>How do they get the work done that they need to get done?

1454
02:45:09.032 --> 02:45:10.000
<v Loretta Smith>Who does that work?

1455
02:45:11.602 --> 02:45:13.298
<v Rebecca Dobert>I appreciate the point.

1456
02:45:14.574 --> 02:45:21.484
<v Rebecca Dobert>It is a lot of hours that over, you know, year over year, these cuts, like you guys have mentioned, have impacted most of the staff.

1457
02:45:21.579 --> 02:45:26.592
<v Rebecca Dobert>Mostly the office staff so that we could maintain frontline firefighters.

1458
02:45:26.932 --> 02:45:32.085
<v Rebecca Dobert>And there are a small but mighty group that are taking on additional duties.

1459
02:45:32.682 --> 02:45:43.370
<v Rebecca Dobert>And then I think faced with these changes, we will have a roster that we plan to discuss with the DCA and CA and the mayor about what's not going to get done potentially.

1460
02:45:45.168 --> 02:45:45.707
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1461
02:45:47.461 --> 02:46:06.138
<v Loretta Smith>The mayor's proposed public safety materials note that PF&R's 2-person rescue units and CHAT units that serve East Portland and communities where racial income and educational health literacy and access disparities are the highest.

1462
02:46:07.019 --> 02:46:13.860
<v Loretta Smith>Given that, how did the administration evaluate the equity impact of reducing Councilor Smith.

1463
02:46:13.860 --> 02:46:13.860
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mayor.

1464
02:46:13.860 --> 02:46:13.860
<v Loretta Smith>I have a question for Deputy City Administrator Donnie Oliveira.

1465
02:46:13.860 --> 02:46:18.620
<v Loretta Smith>How many fire rescue units available and the capacity of CHAT?

1466
02:46:21.819 --> 02:46:43.768
<v Loretta Smith>And either one of you all can answer that question because I think there needs to be an equity lens put over the entire budget, and that equity lens needs to look at those, those things that I discussed around education, health literacy, access to Fresh foods, high crash corridors, all those things.

1467
02:46:44.188 --> 02:46:45.139
<v Loretta Smith>That's District 1.

1468
02:46:45.801 --> 02:46:50.380
<v Loretta Smith>You cannot name a disparity that's had in this city that District 1 is not leading.

1469
02:46:51.603 --> 02:46:56.176
<v Loretta Smith>And so as we look at the budget, I see District 1 being pounced on.

1470
02:46:58.691 --> 02:47:05.429
<v Rebecca Dobert>I can start with acknowledging the equity impact, and that was something, a lens that we used as we developed our entire budget.

1471
02:47:05.801 --> 02:47:09.784
<v Rebecca Dobert>Budget and just want to acknowledge and validate that you're right.

1472
02:47:09.897 --> 02:47:15.902
<v Rebecca Dobert>Those units are there for a reason, and it's because that community has a higher demand.

1473
02:47:16.384 --> 02:47:27.286
<v Rebecca Dobert>And just in general, I think I may have mentioned it earlier in the meeting, but we know that the majority of people who need to use 911 services do come from underserved or underprivileged communities.

1474
02:47:28.137 --> 02:47:35.825
<v Rebecca Dobert>So from my standpoint, when I had to make the decision about cutting to achieve the amount of savings that we've got to do for the Fire Bureau.

1475
02:47:36.324 --> 02:47:44.693
<v Rebecca Dobert>The reason why, and the only reason why, those rescues were on that list is because we can't also use them for fire protection.

1476
02:47:47.702 --> 02:47:47.816
<v Candace Avalos>Hmm.

1477
02:47:48.605 --> 02:47:48.879
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1478
02:47:49.185 --> 02:47:51.524
<v Loretta Smith>I'm going to have to process that for a second.

1479
02:47:53.459 --> 02:47:54.093
<v Loretta Smith>Next question.

1480
02:47:55.926 --> 02:48:22.840
<v Loretta Smith>Page 25 says the budget eliminates 4 vehicles I think 8 vehicles was probably too many for the bureau.

1481
02:48:22.840 --> 02:48:28.408
<v Elizabeth Perez>We are maintaining 4 vehicles that all have different uses.

1482
02:48:28.522 --> 02:48:47.126
<v Elizabeth Perez>So we have one that is an electric vehicle, which is good for, you know, moving around, and then we have 3 that help us transport supplies, as well as one that will do— be employed when there is a disaster, so rugged terrain.

1483
02:48:48.724 --> 02:48:51.612
<v Elizabeth Perez>In my opinion, the, the 4 other vehicles were not necessary.

1484
02:48:52.129 --> 02:49:07.355
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor and I, I, I can appreciate that, um, that, um, and we probably could have addressed that last year too if, if that was the case.

1485
02:49:07.468 --> 02:49:10.140
<v Loretta Smith>We could have really done some things last year.

1486
02:49:10.206 --> 02:49:12.024
<v Loretta Smith>But I want to— I, I, I have very limited time.

1487
02:49:12.218 --> 02:49:13.477
<v Loretta Smith>I thank you for that, Elizabeth.

1488
02:49:14.304 --> 02:49:40.710
<v Loretta Smith>Um, the presentation states that Public Safety Service Area has 2,250 proposed staff and a $611 million proposed budget on page 3, but the financial overview chart on page 7 appears to show the fiscal year '26-'27 proposed budget at approximately $620 million point 4.

1489
02:49:41.725 --> 02:49:45.605
<v Loretta Smith>So can somebody clarify to me what is the actual budget?

1490
02:49:45.686 --> 02:49:53.138
<v Bob Causie>Is it I think I would need, uh, Ruth or Ginger to come up.

1491
02:49:53.525 --> 02:49:53.783
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1492
02:49:57.092 --> 02:50:00.742
<v Ginger Damron>I see $620 million, so the $611 may be a typo.

1493
02:50:00.790 --> 02:50:10.938
<v Ginger Damron>There's also some charts that are showing program expenses specifically, and so then contingency, general fund overhead, and debt doesn't show up.

1494
02:50:11.019 --> 02:50:15.698
<v Ginger Damron>So sometimes there's Discrepancies that have to do with what is classified as program expenses.

1495
02:50:15.746 --> 02:50:24.903
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, it just said that it was the proposed budget, it was $611 million, but what you're saying is it's $620.4 million.

1496
02:50:25.824 --> 02:50:26.534
<v Loretta Smith>Is that what you're saying?

1497
02:50:26.889 --> 02:50:30.813
<v Loretta Smith>That's the real number, the $620?

1498
02:50:31.247 --> 02:50:31.585
<v Ginger Damron>Yeah.

1499
02:50:31.649 --> 02:50:32.084
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1500
02:50:32.519 --> 02:50:35.558
<v Loretta Smith>And I think this goes back to what Councilman Zimmerman said.

1501
02:50:36.540 --> 02:50:37.861
<v Loretta Smith>We have narratives yes.

1502
02:50:38.584 --> 02:50:43.154
<v Loretta Smith>And I've been saying this for 2 years and through each TAO that we've had since I've been here.

1503
02:50:43.796 --> 02:50:54.332
<v Loretta Smith>We don't have spreadsheets, and that's a problem because all these stories that you all are telling so brilliantly in the budget, they're having different numbers.

1504
02:50:54.379 --> 02:50:57.652
<v Loretta Smith>And this is not the first time that I caught this.

1505
02:50:57.811 --> 02:51:03.648
<v Loretta Smith>It— last week there was another issue because you guys are putting these numbers in narratives.

1506
02:51:03.729 --> 02:51:03.778
<v Steve Maudsley>Yes.

1507
02:51:04.181 --> 02:51:06.130
<v Loretta Smith>If I have an Excel spreadsheet, it is there.

1508
02:51:06.325 --> 02:51:06.888
<v Loretta Smith>I can see.

1509
02:51:08.194 --> 02:51:08.888
<v Loretta Smith>I can look at it.

1510
02:51:09.323 --> 02:51:14.067
<v Loretta Smith>But I can't do that in this kind of format.

1511
02:51:14.795 --> 02:51:15.780
<v Loretta Smith>It's really tough.

1512
02:51:16.102 --> 02:51:22.248
<v Loretta Smith>But one of the things that I learned early on was to read and to add longhand.

1513
02:51:24.522 --> 02:51:26.719
<v Loretta Smith>My grandkids don't know how to add longhand.

1514
02:51:26.865 --> 02:51:27.778
<v Loretta Smith>They don't know how to do that.

1515
02:51:27.859 --> 02:51:28.429
<v Loretta Smith>But I do.

1516
02:51:30.791 --> 02:51:43.834
<v Loretta Smith>So the other piece is BOEC is proposing to eliminate 2 911 call-taking positions, and the presentation states that this could impact call answer times.

1517
02:51:45.280 --> 02:51:56.501
<v Loretta Smith>What is the expected impact on 911 answer times, especially during high call periods, major incidents, heat events, wildfire smoke emergencies?

1518
02:51:57.736 --> 02:51:58.984
<v Loretta Smith>Etc., etc., etc.

1519
02:51:59.436 --> 02:52:05.869
<v Loretta Smith>How do you plan to make that work?

1520
02:52:05.933 --> 02:52:11.908
<v Loretta Smith>Because when I was running for City Council before, the big thing was response timing.

1521
02:52:11.958 --> 02:52:16.073
<v Loretta Smith>Now we're going to increase response time, so that doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

1522
02:52:17.596 --> 02:52:21.974
<v Loretta Smith>Director Adesia Causey, you worked so hard to get that done, but now it's—.

1523
02:52:21.974 --> 02:52:22.038
<v Keith Wilson>Yes.

1524
02:52:22.149 --> 02:52:25.197
<v Loretta Smith>We're getting ready to lose some of those things.

1525
02:52:25.886 --> 02:52:27.923
<v Steve Maudsley>And I'll tell you, uh, Councilor, thanks for the question.

1526
02:52:28.516 --> 02:52:32.461
<v Steve Maudsley>The reduction of the 2 call-taking dispatcher positions, uh, is not great news.

1527
02:52:32.525 --> 02:52:42.277
<v Steve Maudsley>Any reduction to our operational workforce, albeit it is 1.5% of our operational FTE, um, it's still not great news.

1528
02:52:42.693 --> 02:52:50.007
<v Steve Maudsley>Uh, but you know what we intend on doing is hosting our 2 academies over the next year and, uh, bringing in 2 less people than we would anyway.

1529
02:52:50.087 --> 02:52:55.140
<v Steve Maudsley>So impacting call answer times you said specifically during, I think, high-volume times.

1530
02:52:56.022 --> 02:53:08.969
<v Steve Maudsley>We would intend on targeting the, you know, summer call load, our highest call volume times, and reserving operational overtime, for example, throughout the year, postponing training.

1531
02:53:09.884 --> 02:53:15.209
<v Steve Maudsley>I said reserving operational overtime for surge events throughout the year is what I meant to say.

1532
02:53:16.316 --> 02:53:17.808
<v Steve Maudsley>In addition, postponing training.

1533
02:53:18.548 --> 02:53:23.429
<v Steve Maudsley>Until the fall when our call volume starts to drop, as we've historically seen.

1534
02:53:24.119 --> 02:53:33.850
<v Steve Maudsley>As I mentioned earlier, one thing we don't control, but we talked to the mayor about recently is the last 2 fiscal years we have seen a 5% decrease in overall 911 call volume.

1535
02:53:34.218 --> 02:53:34.828
<v Steve Maudsley>That's promising.

1536
02:53:34.925 --> 02:53:39.533
<v Steve Maudsley>I hope that's the new normal, although I can say over the last several years we've said new normal way too many times.

1537
02:53:40.144 --> 02:53:41.894
<v Steve Maudsley>And, you know, to be surprised by some things.

1538
02:53:42.263 --> 02:53:43.033
<v Loretta Smith>I hope it sticks.

1539
02:53:44.030 --> 02:53:44.221
<v Steve Maudsley>Sorry.

1540
02:53:44.398 --> 02:53:45.378
<v Loretta Smith>I hope it sticks.

1541
02:53:45.602 --> 02:53:45.876
<v Steve Maudsley>Me too.

1542
02:53:45.940 --> 02:53:47.320
<v Steve Maudsley>Well, I hope it's more than 5%.

1543
02:53:47.626 --> 02:53:49.408
<v Steve Maudsley>We could use less 911 calls for sure.

1544
02:53:50.114 --> 02:53:54.547
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'll, I'll leave, I'll leave some time for folks, but I have one last question.

1545
02:53:55.477 --> 02:54:13.361
<v Loretta Smith>BOEC proposes eliminating 325,000 in contracted security personnel for BOEC, PBIM, and BTS, and the presentation says this reduces visible deterrent and on-site response to threats or concerns.

1546
02:54:14.115 --> 02:54:22.171
<v Loretta Smith>What specific security risk does this create for emergency communications and emergency management staff?

1547
02:54:23.486 --> 02:54:27.899
<v Steve Maudsley>Yeah, so the security does allow a visible presence both inside the facility and out.

1548
02:54:27.979 --> 02:54:33.371
<v Steve Maudsley>They do patrol parking lot and the perimeter of the building many times during the hours that they're, that they're present.

1549
02:54:34.638 --> 02:54:36.725
<v Steve Maudsley>You know, we have expanded lighting in the parking lot.

1550
02:54:37.046 --> 02:54:38.507
<v Steve Maudsley>Really worked on that the last year or so.

1551
02:54:39.775 --> 02:54:46.166
<v Steve Maudsley>And existing security protocol, badged access, locked facility, gated access, and all of that.

1552
02:54:46.551 --> 02:54:52.363
<v Steve Maudsley>So those procedures, those items will continue.

1553
02:54:53.343 --> 02:55:01.725
<v Steve Maudsley>You know, what I can see this impacting is the visible presence where you won't see someone in a neon vest walking around the parking lot providing that extra patrol.

1554
02:55:01.790 --> 02:55:02.238
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Herbold.

1555
02:55:03.200 --> 02:55:03.768
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1556
02:55:04.010 --> 02:55:08.864
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, again, DCA Kazi, I thank you for your, for your service.

1557
02:55:09.736 --> 02:55:12.493
<v Loretta Smith>And just one last, uh, request.

1558
02:55:12.799 --> 02:55:22.153
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I think we need to work on the policy of us as a city when we get grants.

1559
02:55:23.156 --> 02:55:28.612
<v Loretta Smith>If we're going to backfill every grant that we have, that's going to put us in a yes.

1560
02:55:29.079 --> 02:55:29.691
<v Loretta Smith>In a pickle.

1561
02:55:31.253 --> 02:55:40.120
<v Loretta Smith>And so when we do those extra and expanded kinds of services, we just need to look at those and say that's what they were.

1562
02:55:40.763 --> 02:55:41.855
<v Loretta Smith>We got funded for them.

1563
02:55:42.691 --> 02:55:47.370
<v Loretta Smith>We don't have the money anymore because we can't backfill everything that we get a grant for.

1564
02:55:48.551 --> 02:55:51.334
<v Loretta Smith>And there were like $600 million in the grants department.

1565
02:55:51.465 --> 02:55:54.226
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm like, okay, if we tried to backfill all of that, Yes.

1566
02:55:54.738 --> 02:55:58.475
<v Loretta Smith>If we didn't get those grants again, we couldn't do it.

1567
02:55:58.667 --> 02:56:03.751
<v Loretta Smith>So we have to identify as a council what our book of business is.

1568
02:56:04.969 --> 02:56:07.760
<v Loretta Smith>And if we get something extra and we can do it, yes, that's fine.

1569
02:56:08.257 --> 02:56:20.429
<v Loretta Smith>But what we're doing is putting everybody else who've been at the city for a long time at risk when we start new programs that are paid for with outside sources and then those sources leave.

1570
02:56:20.590 --> 02:56:20.670
<v Steve Maudsley>Yes.

1571
02:56:21.343 --> 02:56:24.683
<v Loretta Smith>And then we have to figure out how to, how to put these things in.

1572
02:56:24.941 --> 02:56:27.831
<v Loretta Smith>You know, ongoing money should be for ongoing money.

1573
02:56:28.634 --> 02:56:31.138
<v Loretta Smith>If we want to keep some of those things, then we got to take something out.

1574
02:56:31.540 --> 02:56:37.128
<v Loretta Smith>We can't just keep adding to the budget because we think we need to do those things.

1575
02:56:38.188 --> 02:56:41.719
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm just— and I'm looking at you all because you all are doing a great job.

1576
02:56:42.057 --> 02:56:45.879
<v Loretta Smith>I know you have Ceasefire and all those programs that were paid with ARPA money.

1577
02:56:46.779 --> 02:56:53.604
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm just— I'm concerned that our need is bigger than what our revenue is.

1578
02:56:54.120 --> 02:57:06.391
<v Loretta Smith>But I also know that we have to have a policy decision that says when we don't— and fortunately with the SAMHSA grant, Chief Johnson, we're going to be able to keep some of those folks with CHAT.

1579
02:57:07.072 --> 02:57:11.737
<v Loretta Smith>But when we don't have that money, we got to be— we got to have a hard line on that.

1580
02:57:11.786 --> 02:57:11.834
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

1581
02:57:11.920 --> 02:57:12.978
<v Loretta Smith>But, but thank you.

1582
02:57:13.379 --> 02:57:14.165
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

1583
02:57:15.226 --> 02:57:16.092
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1584
02:57:16.429 --> 02:57:21.421
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, colleagues, we're going to get to Councilors Green and Ryan, and then we're going to adjourn for the day.

1585
02:57:21.581 --> 02:57:22.111
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1586
02:57:23.426 --> 02:57:24.341
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. President.

1587
02:57:24.389 --> 02:57:26.637
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to be very brief because I know our time's short.

1588
02:57:27.182 --> 02:57:30.617
<v Mitch Green>Um, DCA Causie, I just want to thank you for your service to the city.

1589
02:57:31.113 --> 02:57:36.154
<v Mitch Green>Um, I think we were better, better for, uh, the city was better for your service to the city.

1590
02:57:36.201 --> 02:57:36.827
<v Mitch Green>So thank you.

1591
02:57:37.774 --> 02:57:43.121
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm going to echo everyone, what everyone has already said about Station 22.

1592
02:57:43.170 --> 02:57:44.278
<v Mitch Green>I don't need to repeat that.

1593
02:57:44.695 --> 02:57:46.879
<v Mitch Green>The critical energy infrastructure hub is in my district.

1594
02:57:46.943 --> 02:57:49.239
<v Mitch Green>That's the first thing I thought about when I saw the presentation.

1595
02:57:49.335 --> 02:57:52.659
<v Mitch Green>I know, Chief, you didn't make the recommendation lightly.

1596
02:57:52.709 --> 02:57:53.929
<v Mitch Green>I'm sure you lost a little sleep.

1597
02:57:55.052 --> 02:57:57.316
<v Mitch Green>And so I, you know, recognize that too.

1598
02:57:58.087 --> 02:58:10.764
<v Mitch Green>I do want to recognize though that this budget as a whole is a statement of priorities, and there's a number of places throughout the entire budget where we've promoted a manager from 1 to 2 or from 2 to 3.

1599
02:58:11.566 --> 02:58:14.869
<v Mitch Green>And colleagues, a manager 3 is an executive-level role.

1600
02:58:15.046 --> 02:58:15.751
<v Steve Maudsley>Okay?

1601
02:58:16.376 --> 02:58:18.813
<v Mitch Green>So when you add all that up, that's a fire engine.

1602
02:58:20.143 --> 02:58:27.068
<v Mitch Green>When you look at all these things and like just the other day we were talking about the investments we need to make in the CA's office.

1603
02:58:27.132 --> 02:58:29.072
<v Mitch Green>And I agree the CA needs some investments.

1604
02:58:29.137 --> 02:58:31.668
<v Mitch Green>But that is a DCA role in this budget.

1605
02:58:31.760 --> 02:58:47.828
<v Mitch Green>I question whether or not we need to be making that investment while we're cutting trucks and we're cutting, frankly, services that are core, life-saving services to the City of Portland.

1606
02:58:50.010 --> 02:58:55.770
<v Mitch Green>There is an interplay between sheltering our homelessness and the cost to our public safety bureaus.

1607
02:58:55.770 --> 02:58:57.329
<v Mitch Green>I'll note that we have not reduced our public safety bureaus.

1608
02:58:57.329 --> 02:58:57.370
<v Ginger Damron>Thank you.

1609
02:58:57.797 --> 02:59:00.064
<v Mitch Green>The number of unsheltered homeless people in the city of Portland.

1610
02:59:00.690 --> 02:59:13.612
<v Mitch Green>And so if we're going to cut into CHAT and we're going to cut into our sort of vehicles that can deploy while we're not making any headway on the homelessness problem, I think that just sets us back.

1611
02:59:14.844 --> 02:59:28.204
<v Mitch Green>Last thing I want to say is earlier in the week, maybe last week, I got a report on the status of Green 13, which was intended to provide $2.2 million to the public safety as a whole to improve capability and capacity.

1612
02:59:28.718 --> 02:59:33.295
<v Mitch Green>I note that we left— we let $160,000 of that go back to the general fund in the spring TAO.

1613
02:59:34.177 --> 02:59:48.147
<v Mitch Green>And I wonder if where that money went once it went into the general fund and whether or not $160,000 could have helped keep our capacity in line for CHAT for one more year while we figure out— I mean, that's a third of the CHAT cut.

1614
02:59:48.853 --> 02:59:52.611
<v Mitch Green>So these are the sorts of things that I'm going to be looking at as we get into the budget as a whole.

1615
02:59:53.126 --> 03:00:00.209
<v Mitch Green>I know there's money in this budget to make whole some of these into-the-bone cuts that we have made in public safety.

1616
03:00:00.530 --> 03:00:01.173
<v Mitch Green>So I'll leave it there.

1617
03:00:01.541 --> 03:00:01.879
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1618
03:00:02.923 --> 03:00:03.693
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1619
03:00:03.870 --> 03:00:04.416
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1620
03:00:04.593 --> 03:00:05.879
<v Dan Ryan>Yes, thank you, Council President.

1621
03:00:06.039 --> 03:00:09.476
<v Dan Ryan>And I will skip all the niceties, but it's great to see everybody.

1622
03:00:09.814 --> 03:00:10.407
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks for being here.

1623
03:00:10.471 --> 03:00:12.398
<v Dan Ryan>Bob will get back to you later.

1624
03:00:13.185 --> 03:00:15.498
<v Dan Ryan>I want to focus on the overtime strategy.

1625
03:00:15.835 --> 03:00:20.231
<v Dan Ryan>I've been here since 2022 when we implemented that strategy.

1626
03:00:20.969 --> 03:00:23.103
<v Dan Ryan>Bob, you were the architect of that, as I recall.

1627
03:00:23.537 --> 03:00:29.762
<v Dan Ryan>And we've seen how that's benefited BOEC because we played it out long enough to see that.

1628
03:00:31.254 --> 03:00:40.543
<v Dan Ryan>We implemented in fire and police, but we're doing that thing, Mr. Mayor, that's challenging when you've been around a while now, coming up to 6 years in September.

1629
03:00:40.608 --> 03:00:41.088
<v Dan Ryan>I'm not going to say anything.

1630
03:00:41.602 --> 03:00:52.299
<v Dan Ryan>And that is we have these really smart strategies so that we get to a place where the service delivery is where it should be, and then we experience these fits and starts.

1631
03:00:52.972 --> 03:00:58.361
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think when we're doing budgets, there has to be a vision about long-term results.

1632
03:00:59.147 --> 03:01:05.737
<v Dan Ryan>And when we make certain cuts to those strategies, we don't get to experience the results that Portlanders desire.

1633
03:01:06.556 --> 03:01:15.122
<v Dan Ryan>So I took about 5 paragraphs on that and tried to be more succinct, but I'm concerned that we're not allowing that to play out.

1634
03:01:15.764 --> 03:01:19.486
<v Dan Ryan>And so that would go to basically fire for sure in this conversation.

1635
03:01:20.400 --> 03:01:26.272
<v Dan Ryan>Um, I really appreciate the ride-alongs and sit-alongs I've experienced with all of you of late.

1636
03:01:26.674 --> 03:01:31.536
<v Dan Ryan>It's definitely the best way for me to have insight and my respect for the first responders.

1637
03:01:32.145 --> 03:01:35.324
<v Dan Ryan>So I wanted to make sure I acknowledge that.

1638
03:01:36.061 --> 03:01:46.900
<v Dan Ryan>I think it would be remiss, especially the 3 of us in District 2 had our budget listening session, and it was remarkable about the testimony that came on Station 22.

1639
03:01:48.264 --> 03:01:52.246
<v Dan Ryan>No offense, but it wasn't just people that were there because they work for the Bureau.

1640
03:01:52.376 --> 03:01:55.602
<v Dan Ryan>It wasn't there because the political sector told them to be there.

1641
03:01:56.197 --> 03:01:58.429
<v Dan Ryan>It was neighbors that just showed up.

1642
03:01:59.167 --> 03:02:08.737
<v Dan Ryan>So in my experience as a public servant, when you experience that type of testimony, it goes to your heart a bit more.

1643
03:02:09.540 --> 03:02:15.128
<v Dan Ryan>And I think my 2 colleagues have expressed similar thoughts on this, so I'll try not to repeat theirs.

1644
03:02:15.867 --> 03:02:19.447
<v Dan Ryan>And I'll just add one more that I didn't hear.

1645
03:02:19.736 --> 03:02:23.574
<v Dan Ryan>Maybe they were allowing this Oregonian to talk about this.

1646
03:02:23.654 --> 03:02:23.959
<v Dan Ryan>Councilmember Herbold.

1647
03:02:25.123 --> 03:02:29.201
<v Dan Ryan>We are experiencing the lowest snowmelt in the history and snowpack.

1648
03:02:29.315 --> 03:02:31.905
<v Dan Ryan>Sorry, we're experiencing the lowest snowmelt because we don't have enough snowpack.

1649
03:02:32.770 --> 03:02:33.980
<v Dan Ryan>Snowpack is a big deal.

1650
03:02:34.481 --> 03:02:44.760
<v Dan Ryan>It's about— it's our energy infrastructure, it's our irrigation, and it's our safety infrastructure because wildfires peak in those years where we have low snowpack.

1651
03:02:45.129 --> 03:02:45.772
<v Dan Ryan>We all know this.

1652
03:02:46.014 --> 03:02:49.665
<v Dan Ryan>We're experiencing conditions already that are more like early July.

1653
03:02:50.216 --> 03:02:51.195
<v Dan Ryan>And it's early May.

1654
03:02:52.335 --> 03:03:00.878
<v Dan Ryan>So where it's located, and this has been mentioned, we have jurisdictions that come up to our borders all the way out to Scappoose.

1655
03:03:01.632 --> 03:03:15.361
<v Dan Ryan>And so I need to know if there were conversations, Mr. Mayor and Chief, with those jurisdictions that we share space with where there's all those forests between here and the borders of Multnomah County.

1656
03:03:15.913 --> 03:03:21.427
<v Dan Ryan>And so, you know, it says that area of the peninsula is a gateway to nature for a reason, 'cause it is.

1657
03:03:22.182 --> 03:03:37.805
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think the conditions this summer might make the current data that we use to make decisions missing some of those nuances about what the conditions are for the summer that we're projecting for the summer of 2026.

1658
03:03:38.530 --> 03:03:39.884
<v Dan Ryan>Was that part of the conversation?

1659
03:03:41.452 --> 03:03:45.211
<v Dan Ryan>So I'll answer first.

1660
03:03:45.371 --> 03:03:49.676
<v Rebecca Dobert>I haven't talked to the chief at SCAPUS about these changes yet.

1661
03:03:51.090 --> 03:03:54.993
<v Dan Ryan>And I know you've been busy, so I'm not trying to say that you did anything wrong.

1662
03:03:55.088 --> 03:04:03.103
<v Dan Ryan>I just think that when we make decisions with our borders, we have such a responsibility because wildfires spread rather quickly.

1663
03:04:03.522 --> 03:04:03.875
<v Rebecca Dobert>I agree.

1664
03:04:03.923 --> 03:04:10.587
<v Dan Ryan>And I haven't experienced too many Augusts or Septembers where there there isn't a fire on the bluff that you all respond to.

1665
03:04:10.683 --> 03:04:11.358
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for that.

1666
03:04:11.808 --> 03:04:22.020
<v Dan Ryan>So I do think when I hear about the lack of water with this change, it just makes everybody feel unsafe in North Portland.

1667
03:04:22.165 --> 03:04:26.354
<v Dan Ryan>But it spreads beyond North Portland, across the bridge, like everyone has mentioned.

1668
03:04:26.836 --> 03:04:32.327
<v Dan Ryan>So I think what you're hearing is a united front that we have to figure out how to restore that service.

1669
03:04:32.377 --> 03:04:32.584
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1670
03:04:33.003 --> 03:04:35.333
<v Dan Ryan>And I think we'll be all very dogged about that.

1671
03:04:35.815 --> 03:04:40.394
<v Dan Ryan>And so I needed to use my time to express that.

1672
03:04:40.876 --> 03:04:43.977
<v Dan Ryan>I think that was different than what the two of you said, so it was additive.

1673
03:04:44.636 --> 03:04:46.147
<v Dan Ryan>CHAT's really close to my heart.

1674
03:04:46.243 --> 03:04:51.400
<v Dan Ryan>I've been a part of the stewardship of trying to bring in the local grant with Health Share.

1675
03:04:51.546 --> 03:05:01.373
<v Dan Ryan>And I think where we've maybe— I think where we failed is we haven't shown up where we have received that partnership with our commitment.

1676
03:05:01.858 --> 03:05:08.906
<v Dan Ryan>And it's hard to steward a grant if we're not putting our skin in the game, if you will.

1677
03:05:09.745 --> 03:05:21.068
<v Dan Ryan>And so I'm pausing right now to say I'm here to be helpful, but I think it's a moment in time where the emergency, the ER unit that's on the ground is CHAT.

1678
03:05:22.191 --> 03:05:29.629
<v Dan Ryan>I can't be the only one that's had ER nurses tell me this would be devastating cut to this, the healthcare ecosystem of this area.

1679
03:05:30.093 --> 03:05:36.519
<v Dan Ryan>The appreciation that ER units have for CHAT is immense because that was a missing link.

1680
03:05:37.224 --> 03:05:47.944
<v Dan Ryan>And they say that those who show up in ERs is different than it was 4 years ago because of CHAT getting stronger and having more of an impact in our community.

1681
03:05:48.634 --> 03:05:57.513
<v Dan Ryan>So I also think there's a united front about how this council wants to work with the mayor to figure out how to reinstate the investment for CHAT.

1682
03:05:58.011 --> 03:05:59.533
<v Dan Ryan>So I wanted to make sure I said that.

1683
03:05:59.597 --> 03:06:08.190
<v Dan Ryan>I care a lot about all the other units that were here today, the other public safety systems that were here today, but I'm the last one.

1684
03:06:08.237 --> 03:06:11.202
<v Dan Ryan>I'm keeping everybody from lunch, so I'll try to keep it brief.

1685
03:06:11.476 --> 03:06:12.822
<v Dan Ryan>So there you go.

1686
03:06:13.608 --> 03:06:16.075
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you for being here, and I look forward to more conversations.

1687
03:06:16.653 --> 03:06:32.081
<v Dan Ryan>And Mr. Mayor and City Clerk Lee, I just have to say that I think we're at a moment where I know we didn't do across the board, but I do think that there are certain bureaus that you can't touch.

1688
03:06:32.563 --> 03:06:43.369
<v Dan Ryan>There's a contract with Portlanders that say, I pay high dollar to live in Portland, Oregon, and I expect quick response times to emergencies.

1689
03:06:44.506 --> 03:06:53.385
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think that a lot of us might look at public safety differently— understatement of the year— but we all can agree, because we agreed on one thing.

1690
03:06:53.560 --> 03:06:57.150
<v Dan Ryan>One thing was at the top of our list in that meeting we had about our priorities.

1691
03:06:57.743 --> 03:07:00.435
<v Dan Ryan>That was to improve response times.

1692
03:07:01.012 --> 03:07:09.233
<v Dan Ryan>This body of 12 very different points of view agreed that that was at the top of our list based on what I was seeing from that day and some of the reports.

1693
03:07:09.281 --> 03:07:09.408
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1694
03:07:09.489 --> 03:07:16.837
<v Dan Ryan>We're making decisions if we approve this budget that would, would, would backslide that.

1695
03:07:17.623 --> 03:07:24.843
<v Dan Ryan>I don't think that's acceptable to anybody, but most importantly, it's not acceptable to the Portlanders that want public safety to be at the top of our list.

1696
03:07:25.147 --> 03:07:25.485
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1697
03:07:25.950 --> 03:07:26.977
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1698
03:07:27.090 --> 03:07:28.887
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much for being here today.

1699
03:07:29.640 --> 03:07:34.292
<v Jamie Dunphy>I took myself out of the queue, didn't get to ask my question, so I'm going to email my questions and follow up to you all.

1700
03:07:34.373 --> 03:07:49.185
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hope you can get some answers I have one last statement to say that while I agree with the concerns that I heard about the cuts to Station 22, if the cut— my understanding is that if the cuts to Station 22 are taken, call response times will still be faster than in the Centennial neighborhood on the east side.

1701
03:07:49.876 --> 03:07:51.190
<v Jamie Dunphy>So that is worth noting.

1702
03:07:52.023 --> 03:07:53.563
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, couple programming notes.

1703
03:07:53.611 --> 03:07:55.790
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have work sessions the next 3 days in a row.

1704
03:07:56.816 --> 03:07:59.718
<v Jamie Dunphy>I will be implementing a public-facing timer.

1705
03:08:00.343 --> 03:08:01.145
<v Jamie Dunphy>We went pretty long today.

1706
03:08:01.603 --> 03:08:05.929
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so I'm going to try and be holding us to 10 minutes of talking going forward through these work sessions.

1707
03:08:06.590 --> 03:08:08.527
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, with that, we are adjourned.

1708
03:08:08.945 --> 03:08:09.720
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all so much.

1709
03:08:10.027 --> 03:08:10.689
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Sorry.

