WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.491
<v Unidentified speaker>Test, test, captions test.

2
00:04:31.088 --> 00:04:32.413
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

3
00:04:32.702 --> 00:04:39.596
<v Unidentified speaker>I am calling to order this, the, the Wednesday, April 29th afternoon meeting of the Portland City Council.

4
00:04:42.045 --> 00:04:42.786
<v Unidentified speaker>Keelan, can we please call the roll?

5
00:04:43.350 --> 00:04:43.882
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

6
00:04:44.221 --> 00:04:44.591
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

7
00:04:46.250 --> 00:04:46.781
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

8
00:04:48.569 --> 00:04:48.795
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

9
00:04:50.889 --> 00:04:51.283
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

10
00:04:53.619 --> 00:04:53.783
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

11
00:04:54.990 --> 00:04:55.101
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

12
00:04:55.343 --> 00:04:55.745
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick.

13
00:04:55.906 --> 00:04:56.019
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

14
00:04:56.550 --> 00:04:56.872
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

15
00:04:57.192 --> 00:04:57.305
<v Steve Novick>Here.

16
00:04:57.675 --> 00:04:57.869
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

17
00:04:58.625 --> 00:04:59.091
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman.

18
00:04:59.750 --> 00:05:00.057
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos.

19
00:05:00.908 --> 00:05:01.762
<v Unidentified speaker>Present.

20
00:05:02.244 --> 00:05:02.389
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

21
00:05:03.370 --> 00:05:03.627
<v Unidentified speaker>Here.

22
00:05:04.319 --> 00:05:04.480
<v Unidentified speaker>Lundby.

23
00:05:04.901 --> 00:05:05.175
<v Unidentified speaker>Here.

24
00:05:06.031 --> 00:05:08.148
<v Unidentified speaker>And can we please have the attorney read the rules of decorum?

25
00:05:09.036 --> 00:05:09.649
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

26
00:05:10.004 --> 00:05:11.620
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome to the Portland City Council.

27
00:05:12.180 --> 00:05:17.625
<v Unidentified speaker>To testify before council in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the council agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda.

28
00:05:21.062 --> 00:05:24.608
<v Unidentified speaker>Information on engaging with council can be found on the council clerk's webpage.

29
00:05:25.235 --> 00:05:29.134
<v Unidentified speaker>Individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the presiding officer states otherwise.

30
00:05:29.646 --> 00:05:31.845
<v Unidentified speaker>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

31
00:05:32.519 --> 00:05:34.060
<v Unidentified speaker>The presiding officer preserves order.

32
00:05:34.315 --> 00:05:42.805
<v Unidentified speaker>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or council deliberations will not be allowed.

33
00:05:43.511 --> 00:05:45.483
<v Unidentified speaker>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

34
00:05:46.014 --> 00:05:48.307
<v Unidentified speaker>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

35
00:05:48.389 --> 00:05:48.581
<v Nancy Thorington>Thank you.

36
00:05:48.966 --> 00:05:52.598
<v Unidentified speaker>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

37
00:05:53.079 --> 00:05:56.180
<v Unidentified speaker>Additionally, council may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

38
00:05:56.855 --> 00:05:59.153
<v Unidentified speaker>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

39
00:05:59.651 --> 00:06:01.610
<v Unidentified speaker>When testifying, state your name for the record.

40
00:06:01.692 --> 00:06:03.120
<v Unidentified speaker>Your address is not necessary.

41
00:06:03.603 --> 00:06:06.254
<v Unidentified speaker>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

42
00:06:06.800 --> 00:06:10.254
<v Unidentified speaker>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the council clerk calls your name.

43
00:06:10.495 --> 00:06:10.834
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

44
00:06:11.379 --> 00:06:12.086
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

45
00:06:12.665 --> 00:06:14.963
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, our first item is agenda approval.

46
00:06:15.701 --> 00:06:20.516
<v Unidentified speaker>Are there any requests to amend the agenda, to reorder items, or reschedule an item for a future meeting date?

47
00:06:23.877 --> 00:06:29.708
<v Unidentified speaker>Seeing no one, do I have unanimous consent to approve the agenda?

48
00:06:31.333 --> 00:06:31.947
<v Unidentified speaker>Lots of nods.

49
00:06:31.995 --> 00:06:33.576
<v Unidentified speaker>It looks like the agenda is approved.

50
00:06:34.158 --> 00:06:35.658
<v Unidentified speaker>Please move to public communications.

51
00:06:39.675 --> 00:06:41.980
<v Unidentified speaker>First item, public communications.

52
00:06:42.254 --> 00:06:44.557
<v Unidentified speaker>First up, we have Rebecca Wise Barton.

53
00:06:47.839 --> 00:06:48.274
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome.

54
00:06:48.387 --> 00:06:50.064
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, please feel free to introduce yourself.

55
00:06:50.274 --> 00:06:52.127
<v Unidentified speaker>You're welcome to share your pronouns, and you have 3 minutes.

56
00:06:52.610 --> 00:06:54.336
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Rebecca Wise Barton.

57
00:06:55.410 --> 00:07:04.230
<v Unidentified speaker>So I know we are in budget world right now, but I just wanted to call attention back to something that's going on here.

58
00:07:04.536 --> 00:07:08.310
<v Unidentified speaker>So esteemed councilors, when was your last civics test?

59
00:07:08.615 --> 00:07:10.019
<v Unidentified speaker>I've got a pop quiz for you.

60
00:07:10.245 --> 00:07:20.783
<v Unidentified speaker>What was the name of the document that was the predecessor to and was used as the framework for our country's Oh, Councilor Smith, I think that's right.

61
00:07:20.848 --> 00:07:22.822
<v Unidentified speaker>The Articles of Confederation.

62
00:07:23.293 --> 00:07:24.475
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, extra credit.

63
00:07:24.961 --> 00:07:28.096
<v Unidentified speaker>How many amendments have been made to the US Constitution?

64
00:07:28.755 --> 00:07:31.654
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Councilor Green, right again, 27.

65
00:07:32.798 --> 00:07:42.807
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here today to talk about this council's goal to amend City Code Chapter 3.02, or as I like to call it, Portland's Articles of Confederation.

66
00:07:43.696 --> 00:07:59.851
<v Unidentified speaker>Maybe a misnomer considering emergency ordinance number 19-2021 would technically be the equivalent of the original articles, but I wanted to make a joke and Councilor Novick says all jokes need context, so here we are.

67
00:08:01.103 --> 00:08:05.286
<v Unidentified speaker>Jokes aside, this new form of government— this is a new form of government.

68
00:08:05.814 --> 00:08:07.288
<v Unidentified speaker>Portlanders voted for this.

69
00:08:07.817 --> 00:08:11.841
<v Unidentified speaker>This council in this format represents the will of the people.

70
00:08:12.386 --> 00:08:14.774
<v Unidentified speaker>There's so much great success to be had.

71
00:08:15.350 --> 00:08:26.983
<v Unidentified speaker>This council's inability to amend Chapter 3.02 and the continuation of governance based on an emergency ordinance that is over a year old is a disappointment.

72
00:08:27.704 --> 00:08:29.690
<v Unidentified speaker>A disappointment, not a failure.

73
00:08:29.802 --> 00:08:36.035
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, I'm gonna speak directly to my district councilors now, so the rest of you don't eavesdrop.

74
00:08:36.980 --> 00:08:39.592
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilors Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, and Ryan.

75
00:08:40.719 --> 00:08:43.171
<v Unidentified speaker>You have got to work together to get this done.

76
00:08:44.203 --> 00:08:48.528
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Kanal, I know you want the language to be as precise as possible.

77
00:08:49.168 --> 00:08:55.096
<v Unidentified speaker>The word I just used just now, precise, I looked it up in a thesaurus with the prompt word clear.

78
00:08:55.964 --> 00:09:03.833
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm gonna waste a little bit more of my precious allotted 3 minutes to drive home a point that has already been made clear.

79
00:09:06.363 --> 00:09:08.852
<v Unidentified speaker>You're voting no on a lot of proposed amendments.

80
00:09:09.399 --> 00:09:13.960
<v Unidentified speaker>The first time I gave testimony before this council, I told you I was in support of this item.

81
00:09:14.394 --> 00:09:16.850
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanted to see it go through the democratic process.

82
00:09:17.221 --> 00:09:19.227
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm still in support of this item.

83
00:09:19.918 --> 00:09:22.633
<v Unidentified speaker>Please listen to and collaborate with your peers.

84
00:09:23.613 --> 00:09:25.620
<v Unidentified speaker>No ordinance is perfect, you know that.

85
00:09:26.681 --> 00:09:31.899
<v Unidentified speaker>But with the input from these 11 dedicated, passionate individuals, it could be quite good.

86
00:09:31.980 --> 00:09:32.076
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

87
00:09:32.302 --> 00:09:34.133
<v Unidentified speaker>Better than the original proposal even.

88
00:09:37.323 --> 00:09:41.239
<v Unidentified speaker>Teach them, be the bridge between experience and passion and precision.

89
00:09:42.414 --> 00:09:43.847
<v Unidentified speaker>You've seen the way it used to work.

90
00:09:44.009 --> 00:09:47.230
<v Unidentified speaker>You have the opportunity to forge a new path towards the way it will work.

91
00:09:47.568 --> 00:09:49.388
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilors, this is just the beginning.

92
00:09:49.929 --> 00:09:59.980
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't know what the future holds, but just like 39 Americans before you who strove to more— to form a more perfect union, ordain and establish this Constitution of Portland.

93
00:10:00.331 --> 00:10:00.714
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

94
00:10:01.078 --> 00:10:02.256
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much for being here today.

95
00:10:04.642 --> 00:10:07.625
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Talia Giardini online.

96
00:10:11.062 --> 00:10:13.091
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, hi, my name is Talia Giardini.

97
00:10:14.186 --> 00:10:24.967
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I'm here to testify on, um, absolutely opposing the TUF, um, as does 76% of those with writ that did written testimony.

98
00:10:25.096 --> 00:10:27.145
<v Unidentified speaker>This fee goes against the will of the voters.

99
00:10:27.274 --> 00:10:29.177
<v Unidentified speaker>It seems every week there's a new article or a tax or fee.

100
00:10:29.241 --> 00:10:34.698
<v Unidentified speaker>We shouldn't instead cut the overpaid bureaucrats that were supposed to be temporary middle managers.

101
00:10:35.759 --> 00:10:41.042
<v Unidentified speaker>It's insane that you want to charge more money and no sacrifice on your end or the nonprofits.

102
00:10:41.138 --> 00:10:45.056
<v Unidentified speaker>Clean up your house first and reform department spending before asking for more money.

103
00:10:46.469 --> 00:10:51.591
<v Unidentified speaker>If the TUF does pass, every single penny should go to maintenance and sidewalks, not Vision Zero.

104
00:10:51.895 --> 00:10:59.797
<v Unidentified speaker>Traffic fatalities have gone down recently, but it's dishonest to say it was due to Vision Zero, which was adopted in 2016, while traffic deaths continue to rise.

105
00:10:59.860 --> 00:10:59.972
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

106
00:11:00.501 --> 00:11:09.514
<v Unidentified speaker>Despite millions spent, deaths only began trending down in 2023 when traffic and camping enforcement started, something we should be investing more in.

107
00:11:09.626 --> 00:11:18.510
<v Unidentified speaker>Maybe that 12.5% could go to police since no amount of road designs will stop drunk drivers or people from walking into the street high on drugs.

108
00:11:18.927 --> 00:11:24.635
<v Unidentified speaker>The last Vision Zero audit showed there's been zero studies to measure effectiveness on the streets where it was implemented.

109
00:11:24.700 --> 00:11:26.945
<v Unidentified speaker>The signage is confusing and inconsistent.

110
00:11:27.442 --> 00:11:36.967
<v Unidentified speaker>Which goes directly against the National Research Board on Traffic Safety recommendations, which conclude consistency and enforcement are key to reducing accidents and traffic deaths.

111
00:11:37.788 --> 00:11:44.597
<v Unidentified speaker>Most Portlanders would prefer the Vision Zero team be cut altogether instead of charging us more money that we can guarantee will go up yearly.

112
00:11:45.273 --> 00:11:49.465
<v Unidentified speaker>Another issue, issue with Vision Zero is it impedes emergency vehicles.

113
00:11:49.546 --> 00:11:52.131
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a nurse and I travel all around town to see my patients.

114
00:11:52.179 --> 00:11:54.861
<v Unidentified speaker>I need safe roads and to know emergency will be there when I call.

115
00:11:54.927 --> 00:11:55.038
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

116
00:11:55.537 --> 00:12:01.351
<v Unidentified speaker>PBOT argues Vision Zero doesn't impact emergency vehicles, but they're not the ones driving them or rushing to save lives.

117
00:12:01.416 --> 00:12:06.635
<v Unidentified speaker>They're bureaucrats, bureaucrats who rely on studies with a clear conflict of interest.

118
00:12:07.118 --> 00:12:09.094
<v Unidentified speaker>Every single minute counts in an emergency.

119
00:12:09.206 --> 00:12:14.956
<v Unidentified speaker>Why are we basing our roads around the Netherlands instead of what emergency teams tell us right here in Portland?

120
00:12:15.134 --> 00:12:20.337
<v Unidentified speaker>This very unpopular fee should not go to nice-to-haves for some and aggravating for others.

121
00:12:20.836 --> 00:12:22.582
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't remodel my kitchen when I'm broke.

122
00:12:22.630 --> 00:12:23.192
<v Unidentified speaker>Neither should you.

123
00:12:23.576 --> 00:12:28.947
<v Unidentified speaker>But instead, we get the same old excuses instead of addressing disorganization, overspending, and neglect.

124
00:12:29.587 --> 00:12:37.652
<v Unidentified speaker>Lastly, Councilor Avalos, I really liked what you said the other week, calling out that this is a tax and acknowledging how much your constituents are suffering.

125
00:12:37.860 --> 00:12:38.741
<v Unidentified speaker>Are you going to vote with them?

126
00:12:38.806 --> 00:12:40.008
<v Unidentified speaker>Are you going to vote with the block?

127
00:12:40.712 --> 00:12:45.298
<v Unidentified speaker>I strongly oppose this fee, and I'm even more opposed to any of that money going to Vision Zero.

128
00:12:45.457 --> 00:12:50.856
<v Unidentified speaker>We already pay enough and deserve Basic road maintenance, potholes filled, and sidewalks for our kids.

129
00:12:51.211 --> 00:12:52.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

130
00:12:52.823 --> 00:12:53.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

131
00:12:55.743 --> 00:12:57.323
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Joe Condon.

132
00:12:59.048 --> 00:13:00.817
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi there, my name is Joe Condon.

133
00:13:01.011 --> 00:13:02.716
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks for the opportunity to appear today.

134
00:13:03.447 --> 00:13:08.119
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here about the Portland Metro Levy System project and its impact on Heron Lakes Golf Course.

135
00:13:09.039 --> 00:13:17.009
<v Unidentified speaker>For nearly a year now, a map has been posted in the clubhouse at Heron Lakes showing that this project will significantly reduce the property footprint and require a redesign of the Great Blue Course.

136
00:13:19.121 --> 00:13:20.600
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland's best city golf course.

137
00:13:21.532 --> 00:13:28.264
<v Unidentified speaker>There has been no further communication of the city that I'm aware of, so I and other golfers who call Heron Lakes home are left to speculate.

138
00:13:29.003 --> 00:13:30.014
<v Unidentified speaker>Is the course downsizing?

139
00:13:30.754 --> 00:13:32.537
<v Unidentified speaker>Will the integrity of the design be preserved?

140
00:13:33.163 --> 00:13:35.317
<v Unidentified speaker>Will there be funding if a major redesign is necessary?

141
00:13:36.056 --> 00:13:42.337
<v Unidentified speaker>These are questions that I have as a golfer who enjoys Heron Lakes, and I hope the city will communicate more proactively as plans develop.

142
00:13:43.140 --> 00:13:45.438
<v Unidentified speaker>Emails to the Parks Department have not received a response.

143
00:13:45.486 --> 00:13:45.615
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

144
00:13:46.960 --> 00:13:50.291
<v Unidentified speaker>As a resident of Portland, I also have larger questions about this project.

145
00:13:51.099 --> 00:13:55.158
<v Unidentified speaker>The levee along Columbia Slough was originally built to protect the residential community of Vanport.

146
00:13:55.869 --> 00:13:58.414
<v Unidentified speaker>After the Vanport flood, the golf course was built in its place.

147
00:13:59.173 --> 00:14:07.234
<v Unidentified speaker>The use of this area has changed, changed significantly since the levee was originally designed, and my understanding is that the city is funding 35% of the levee rebuild.

148
00:14:08.042 --> 00:14:12.580
<v Unidentified speaker>Why are we spending millions of dollars rebuilding a section of levee that now protects a golf course and a raceway?

149
00:14:12.629 --> 00:14:13.274
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Smith, I think you're muted.

150
00:14:13.962 --> 00:14:16.270
<v Unidentified speaker>Golf courses handle flooding pretty well, as far as I know.

151
00:14:16.912 --> 00:14:22.297
<v Unidentified speaker>Would it not be better to focus our limited public funds on the upstream levees that protect major residential areas and Portland Airport?

152
00:14:23.259 --> 00:14:30.504
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand that it would be easy for a non-golfer to look at this project and say, hey, there are 2 courses at Heron Lakes, what's the big deal?

153
00:14:31.352 --> 00:14:32.730
<v Unidentified speaker>But these 2 courses are not equal.

154
00:14:33.421 --> 00:14:37.443
<v Unidentified speaker>Great Blue is a difficult championship-level course capable of hosting major events.

155
00:14:38.004 --> 00:14:41.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Greenback is a parkland course designed for beginners, comparable to other city courses.

156
00:14:42.413 --> 00:14:51.642
<v Unidentified speaker>The area of public impact shown on the map is the 2nd 9 of Great Blue, the stretch that makes that course interesting, challenging, and one of the best values for public golf in the state.

157
00:14:52.283 --> 00:14:56.200
<v Unidentified speaker>The only other courses at this level in the area are private country clubs that I can't afford.

158
00:14:56.841 --> 00:15:07.658
<v Unidentified speaker>It would be hard, if not impossible, to maintain that quality in a smaller footprint, and any meaningful loss in quality affects every golfer who relies on public facilities, including youth programs and school teams.

159
00:15:07.947 --> 00:15:11.303
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll close with an alternative vision for Heron Lakes.

160
00:15:12.106 --> 00:15:21.178
<v Unidentified speaker>The Pacific Northwest has not hosted a PGA-level men's tournament in 10 years, since the 2015 U.S. Open at Chambers Bay, a course built by the same designer as Great Blue.

161
00:15:22.046 --> 00:15:33.109
<v Unidentified speaker>Given its location on the I-5 corridor adjacent to the Expo Center and Raceway, with the length and difficulty required for high-level events, some investment could position Heron Lakes as a viable host for future professional tournaments.

162
00:15:34.657 --> 00:15:41.032
<v Unidentified speaker>I hope the council will find a way to preserve this community resource and improve public visibility of this project moving forward.

163
00:15:41.695 --> 00:15:42.278
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your time.

164
00:15:43.167 --> 00:15:43.765
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

165
00:15:48.205 --> 00:15:49.524
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Mike Lazito.

166
00:15:56.073 --> 00:15:56.184
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome.

167
00:15:59.888 --> 00:16:00.947
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Michael Ozito.

168
00:16:01.285 --> 00:16:03.357
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a Portland early childhood educator.

169
00:16:04.145 --> 00:16:06.668
<v Unidentified speaker>I am here today because childcare is infrastructure.

170
00:16:07.053 --> 00:16:12.163
<v Unidentified speaker>Just like roads, transit, and housing, childcare is essential to keeping this city functioning.

171
00:16:13.225 --> 00:16:19.924
<v Unidentified speaker>When childcare is unstable, parents miss work, businesses lose employees, families fall behind, and educators leave the field.

172
00:16:20.953 --> 00:16:29.077
<v Unidentified speaker>I spent over a decade working in early childhood education, including Preschool for All funded classrooms here in Multnomah County and Portland.

173
00:16:29.864 --> 00:16:31.034
<v Unidentified speaker>I support Preschool for All.

174
00:16:31.451 --> 00:16:35.205
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe in the vision of making childcare accessible and affordable for families.

175
00:16:36.183 --> 00:16:37.868
<v Unidentified speaker>But access alone is not enough.

176
00:16:38.750 --> 00:16:42.359
<v Unidentified speaker>A childcare system is only as strong as the workforce holding it together.

177
00:16:43.096 --> 00:16:56.154
<v Unidentified speaker>Across multiple preschool programs, I have seen a pattern of experienced educators taking on increasing responsibilities without fair wages, without the respect this work deserves, and sometimes without safe and sustainable working conditions.

178
00:16:56.235 --> 00:16:58.528
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Teachers deserve fair pay.

179
00:16:58.961 --> 00:17:00.067
<v Unidentified speaker>Teachers deserve respect.

180
00:17:00.259 --> 00:17:01.750
<v Unidentified speaker>Teachers deserve safe workplaces.

181
00:17:02.424 --> 00:17:04.990
<v Unidentified speaker>And families deserve consistency and quality care.

182
00:17:06.017 --> 00:17:10.587
<v Unidentified speaker>Public funds are flowing into Portland businesses through childcare programs and public investment.

183
00:17:11.388 --> 00:17:19.166
<v Unidentified speaker>The city may not directly oversee these programs, but the city does have a role in protecting working families and supporting a stable childcare workforce.

184
00:17:20.144 --> 00:17:26.929
<v Unidentified speaker>I urge the city to formally advocate for stronger oversight and accountability in publicly funded childcare programs operating in Portland.

185
00:17:26.992 --> 00:17:27.105
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

186
00:17:27.843 --> 00:17:37.773
<v Unidentified speaker>And I urge the city to convene educators, providers, and families to examine workforce conditions, wage transparency, and solutions to stabilize the childcare workforce.

187
00:17:38.270 --> 00:17:42.170
<v Unidentified speaker>Because when teachers are underpaid, overworked, and undersupported, they leave.

188
00:17:42.844 --> 00:17:45.089
<v Unidentified speaker>When teachers leave, classrooms become unstable.

189
00:17:45.971 --> 00:17:50.785
<v Unidentified speaker>And when classrooms become unstable, working families and employers across Portland feel the impact.

190
00:17:51.250 --> 00:17:52.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Childcare is not just a family issue.

191
00:17:52.854 --> 00:17:53.095
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

192
00:17:53.352 --> 00:17:57.222
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a workforce issue, it is an economic issue, and it is infrastructure.

193
00:17:57.529 --> 00:17:58.191
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your time.

194
00:17:58.819 --> 00:17:59.367
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

195
00:18:05.113 --> 00:18:06.702
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up we have Gavin Gentry.

196
00:18:06.979 --> 00:18:07.660
<v Unidentified speaker>Look here.

197
00:18:09.006 --> 00:18:09.169
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

198
00:18:42.390 --> 00:18:42.601
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome.

199
00:18:42.911 --> 00:18:43.335
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello.

200
00:18:43.400 --> 00:18:46.546
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for being patient with me while I came down the stairs.

201
00:18:48.846 --> 00:18:49.779
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, my name is Gavin.

202
00:18:50.134 --> 00:18:51.905
<v Unidentified speaker>I am with NextUp.

203
00:18:52.566 --> 00:18:58.653
<v Unidentified speaker>We are here to empower young people to make sure their voices are heard in government and make sure that their interests are represented.

204
00:18:59.477 --> 00:19:06.838
<v Unidentified speaker>I wanted to begin by expressing my gratitude towards all the councilors for passing the resolution to accelerate the Inner Eastside planning project.

205
00:19:07.423 --> 00:19:07.810
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

206
00:19:09.913 --> 00:19:13.809
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm also here to express some concern for the amendment Councilor Ryan passed.

207
00:19:15.045 --> 00:19:20.150
<v Unidentified speaker>Anytime we are making impactful changes, we are asked to balance thoroughness with speed.

208
00:19:20.743 --> 00:19:27.872
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Ryan's amendment widens the scope of the report, choosing to be more thorough at a time where we should be prioritizing urgency.

209
00:19:28.707 --> 00:19:34.694
<v Unidentified speaker>The intention of this resolution was to find a strategy to deliver housing to Portlanders as quickly as possible.

210
00:19:35.113 --> 00:19:43.987
<v Unidentified speaker>There is already a beautiful report put together by 3 bureaus going over some of the metrics They use to determine whether an area would be appropriate for rezoning.

211
00:19:45.839 --> 00:19:56.951
<v Unidentified speaker>Determining methodology and metrics the city will use to evaluate affordability, displacement risk, and equity impacts is something that could have been done later in the process after community engagement.

212
00:19:59.198 --> 00:20:00.070
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, sorry, I'm a little winded.

213
00:20:01.623 --> 00:20:03.758
<v Unidentified speaker>Or after new zoning codes have been proposed.

214
00:20:04.534 --> 00:20:10.434
<v Unidentified speaker>Creating a report that drills down on creating a faster timeline would've been better aligned with the urgency Portlanders deserve.

215
00:20:10.483 --> 00:20:10.614
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

216
00:20:12.025 --> 00:20:13.839
<v Unidentified speaker>Young people are not purchasing homes.

217
00:20:14.273 --> 00:20:16.411
<v Unidentified speaker>The median age of homebuyers is now 40.

218
00:20:16.989 --> 00:20:24.136
<v Unidentified speaker>Frequently, we are living in higher-density apartment complexes that cannot currently be built in the areas most ready to support them.

219
00:20:24.795 --> 00:20:30.594
<v Unidentified speaker>We want to live in walkable areas where we can shop, talk to our neighbors, work, and live.

220
00:20:31.236 --> 00:20:35.798
<v Unidentified speaker>Zoning that supports that vision would bring in young people ready to start businesses and innovate.

221
00:20:36.746 --> 00:20:47.490
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilors, as we move forward in evaluating what zoning codes would best serve Portlanders, current and yet to be, I request we act more on the side of urgency and less on the side of being thorough.

222
00:20:48.146 --> 00:20:51.162
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Ryan, I am very glad that you are working on this effort.

223
00:20:51.819 --> 00:20:56.422
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm confident that you will deliver appropriate KPIs and a well-thought-out proposal.

224
00:20:57.063 --> 00:21:07.487
<v Unidentified speaker>Just be aware, future Portlanders, the young people who will serve Portland, save Portland from this economic crisis with their skills and tax dollars, need places to live sooner rather than later.

225
00:21:07.535 --> 00:21:07.694
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

226
00:21:08.760 --> 00:21:10.201
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

227
00:21:14.102 --> 00:21:15.380
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes communications.

228
00:21:15.493 --> 00:21:16.125
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

229
00:21:16.940 --> 00:21:18.221
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks to everybody who came and testified.

230
00:21:19.480 --> 00:21:22.261
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, next item on our agenda is the council president update.

231
00:21:22.682 --> 00:21:25.239
<v Unidentified speaker>This week is National Youth Violence Prevention Week.

232
00:21:26.048 --> 00:21:33.285
<v Unidentified speaker>Mayor Wilson issued a proclamation recognizing this, and the Community and Public Safety Service Area has asked me if I could read that proclamation from the dais.

233
00:21:34.544 --> 00:21:37.674
<v Unidentified speaker>As a dad and a former youth violence prevention educator in the David Douglas School District, I'm honored to do so.

234
00:21:39.836 --> 00:21:45.922
<v Unidentified speaker>So with the thanks to Mayor Wilson, the National Youth Violence Prevention Week Proclamation.

235
00:21:46.018 --> 00:22:08.401
<v Unidentified speaker>Whereas youth violence is a pressing issue that affects individuals, families, and communities, posing significant challenges to the health, safety, and well-being of our young people, and whereas National Youth Violence Prevention Week, observed from April 27th to May 2nd, serves as a critical opportunity to raise awareness, foster community engagement, and promote proactive solutions to prevent violence among youth.

236
00:22:08.657 --> 00:22:22.548
<v Unidentified speaker>And whereas the City of Portland is committed to creating safe and supportive environments for young people by addressing the root causes of violence and investing in programs that promote education, mentorship, mental health support, and positive youth development.

237
00:22:22.708 --> 00:22:37.030
<v Unidentified speaker>And whereas preventing youth violence requires a collaborative effort from all sectors of society, including families, educators, law enforcement, community leaders, and youth themselves, to foster a culture of nonviolence, respect, and mutual support.

238
00:22:38.041 --> 00:22:51.028
<v Unidentified speaker>And whereas the City of Portland encourages all residents to participate in National Youth Violence Prevention Week by supporting local initiatives, engaging with youth, and advocating for policies and resources that promote their safety and well-being.

239
00:22:51.781 --> 00:23:21.396
<v Unidentified speaker>Now therefore, Keith Wilson, the mayor of the City of Portland, Oregon, the City of Roses, does hereby proclaim April 7th through May 2nd, 2026, to be National Violence Prevention Week in Portland and urges all residents, organizations, and stakeholders to work together in building a safer now we're going to turn over to our city administrator, city, uh, Raymond Lee, to see if there's any updates regarding federal interventions in our city.

240
00:23:22.865 --> 00:23:36.593
<v Unidentified speaker>Just a reminder for council, uh, on the update I gave a few weeks ago, after appealing the city's decision to the city code hearings officer, The hearings officer dismissed the appeal at the building owner's request.

241
00:23:36.673 --> 00:23:43.392
<v Unidentified speaker>The building owner then asked the hearing officer to reconsider the dismissal, which the hearing officer granted.

242
00:23:43.840 --> 00:23:47.721
<v Unidentified speaker>A hearing on the merits of the appeal is still scheduled for May 5th.

243
00:23:48.394 --> 00:23:56.859
<v Unidentified speaker>While appeals process are ongoing, it is standard practice within the permitting bureau to pause timelines for corrective actions or fees.

244
00:23:57.838 --> 00:24:11.602
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, under the detention facility fee update, the detention Center Impact Fee Working Group is steady making progress and will be reviewing internal draft of the permanent rule this week.

245
00:24:12.021 --> 00:24:17.996
<v Unidentified speaker>PP&D is on target to have the permanent rule out for public comment by the end of May.

246
00:24:18.463 --> 00:24:18.691
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

247
00:24:19.275 --> 00:24:20.070
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, City Administrator.

248
00:24:21.791 --> 00:24:23.058
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we please call item number 4?

249
00:24:25.385 --> 00:24:27.576
<v Unidentified speaker>Item number 4 is the consent agenda.

250
00:24:28.238 --> 00:24:30.541
<v Unidentified speaker>No items have been pulled from the consent agenda.

251
00:24:30.605 --> 00:24:31.009
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll call the roll.

252
00:24:36.567 --> 00:24:37.803
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, consent agenda?

253
00:24:37.867 --> 00:24:38.664
<v Unidentified speaker>Consent, yep.

254
00:24:39.153 --> 00:24:39.738
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, aye.

255
00:24:42.324 --> 00:24:42.453
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

256
00:24:43.055 --> 00:24:43.104
<v Keelan McClymont>Aye.

257
00:24:43.787 --> 00:24:43.836
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

258
00:24:45.902 --> 00:24:46.079
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

259
00:24:48.096 --> 00:24:48.144
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

260
00:24:50.682 --> 00:24:50.730
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

261
00:24:58.202 --> 00:25:02.038
<v Unidentified speaker>The consent agenda is approved with a vote of 12 ayes.

262
00:25:02.386 --> 00:25:02.968
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

263
00:25:03.516 --> 00:25:04.627
<v Unidentified speaker>Please call item number 5.

264
00:25:07.950 --> 00:25:23.128
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 5, document 2026-113, establish a new transportation utility fee to help fund basic maintenance and safety of the city's transportation system, add code chapter 17.20.

265
00:25:24.445 --> 00:25:26.872
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, this is the second reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

266
00:25:26.936 --> 00:25:28.028
<v Unidentified speaker>Is there any further discussion?

267
00:25:30.768 --> 00:25:33.712
<v Unidentified speaker>Seeing no one in the queue, Keelan, can we please call the roll?

268
00:25:34.473 --> 00:25:34.846
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

269
00:25:36.398 --> 00:25:36.448
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

270
00:25:38.417 --> 00:25:38.578
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

271
00:25:39.156 --> 00:25:39.702
<v Olivia Clark>No.

272
00:25:42.032 --> 00:25:42.080
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

273
00:25:44.604 --> 00:25:44.941
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

274
00:25:45.969 --> 00:25:50.901
<v Unidentified speaker>I am so proud of this council for taking a— an act that has been vitally needed for the past 40 years.

275
00:25:51.325 --> 00:25:51.374
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

276
00:25:52.547 --> 00:25:52.563
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

277
00:25:54.942 --> 00:25:55.087
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

278
00:25:56.073 --> 00:25:56.121
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

279
00:25:56.799 --> 00:25:57.186
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman.

280
00:25:59.076 --> 00:25:59.336
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

281
00:26:01.240 --> 00:26:01.548
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos.

282
00:26:01.968 --> 00:26:02.017
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

283
00:26:02.759 --> 00:26:03.001
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith.

284
00:26:03.762 --> 00:26:03.990
<v Loretta Smith>No.

285
00:26:04.881 --> 00:26:05.106
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy.

286
00:26:05.690 --> 00:26:05.819
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

287
00:26:06.839 --> 00:26:10.661
<v Unidentified speaker>The ordinance passes with a vote of 9 ayes and 3 nos.

288
00:26:12.519 --> 00:26:13.494
<v Unidentified speaker>Congratulations, everybody.

289
00:26:14.583 --> 00:26:16.208
<v Unidentified speaker>Could we please move— call item number 6?

290
00:26:18.846 --> 00:26:21.673
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 6, document 2026-148.

291
00:26:23.811 --> 00:26:37.717
<v Unidentified speaker>Ratify a collective bargaining agreement with American Federation of State, County, Municipal Employees Local 189 for represented employees within the Auditor's Office for 2025 through 2028.

292
00:26:38.807 --> 00:26:40.844
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, this is the first reading of an emergency ordinance.

293
00:26:41.373 --> 00:26:47.227
<v Unidentified speaker>We have with us Sarah Daly, labor relations analyst, and our very own elected City Auditor, Simone Rennie.

294
00:26:48.108 --> 00:26:48.653
<v Unidentified speaker>Take it away.

295
00:26:49.457 --> 00:26:57.015
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead.

296
00:26:57.223 --> 00:26:58.061
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, I'm introducing.

297
00:26:58.159 --> 00:27:00.285
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, well, thank you, President Dunphy.

298
00:27:01.219 --> 00:27:03.377
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, councilors and fellow Portlanders.

299
00:27:04.117 --> 00:27:06.470
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Simone Reddy and I'm Portland City Auditor.

300
00:27:07.477 --> 00:27:12.092
<v Unidentified speaker>As your elected auditor, I am dedicated to ensuring an open and accountable city government.

301
00:27:13.141 --> 00:27:29.181
<v Unidentified speaker>While my office is administratively independent, our labor agreement a contract involves the commitment of city funds across multiple fiscal years, which only City Council has the authority to make and relies in part on the Bureau of Human Resources to implement.

302
00:27:29.887 --> 00:27:40.934
<v Unidentified speaker>So because of these ties, we defined roles and responsibilities for negotiating this contract, as well as the first one, through an interagency agreement with the Bureau of Human Resources.

303
00:27:41.834 --> 00:27:41.978
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

304
00:27:42.635 --> 00:27:47.063
<v Unidentified speaker>I really appreciate council's consideration of our successor agreement today.

305
00:27:48.088 --> 00:27:56.972
<v Unidentified speaker>After nearly a year of bargaining, we have drafted a contract that balances the needs of the auditor's office, the city, and auditor's office employees.

306
00:27:58.432 --> 00:28:15.686
<v Unidentified speaker>The contract outlines employment terms and conditions for 30 represented employees in my office, folks who are in positions that deliver high-quality public services across archives, audit services, council clerk, elections, hearings, and ombudsman.

307
00:28:17.430 --> 00:28:25.566
<v Unidentified speaker>This contract ensures people are paid fairly and provides them with new protections so that they can stay in those positions for years to come.

308
00:28:27.000 --> 00:28:32.944
<v Unidentified speaker>Retention of employees in my office helps us serve the public more reliably, which increases trust.

309
00:28:34.982 --> 00:28:47.617
<v Unidentified speaker>This successor contract, like our first, reflects my office's and the city's core values of transparency, equity, and fiscal responsibility, and continues to respect the independence of the Auditor's Office.

310
00:28:49.082 --> 00:28:57.167
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to thank AFSCME Local 189 and their bargaining team members Mindan, Mason, Riva, and chief negotiator Carly Edwards.

311
00:28:58.347 --> 00:29:05.002
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate their direct communication about the priorities of their members and their willingness to engage in constructive dialogue.

312
00:29:06.366 --> 00:29:15.611
<v Unidentified speaker>I also want to thank Bureau of Human Resources, especially Labor Relations team members Kelly Hess and Sarah Daly, for their leadership and professionalism.

313
00:29:16.653 --> 00:29:29.893
<v Unidentified speaker>And finally, I want to thank my executive team, in particular Chief Deputy Reed Brodersen, who worked closely with Human Resources and sat on our bargaining councillors, I want to thank you again for your consideration.

314
00:29:30.086 --> 00:29:33.720
<v Unidentified speaker>And with that, I will pass it to Sarah to highlight the details of the agreement.

315
00:29:35.369 --> 00:29:36.257
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Auditor Reddy.

316
00:29:36.837 --> 00:29:40.936
<v Unidentified speaker>I do have a slide that I can see, but I'm not sure if you can.

317
00:29:41.307 --> 00:29:42.663
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, great.

318
00:29:43.777 --> 00:29:55.439
<v Unidentified speaker>So this is a basic outline of what was agreed to with the AFSCME team, which I would like to echo the thanks to the AFSCME team who was a great table partner and we were able to reach a negotiated settlement.

319
00:29:59.084 --> 00:30:23.209
<v Unidentified speaker>So the duration of the contract is from July of last year to the end of 2028, and some of the highlights of the agreement are COLA based on CPI for each year of the CBA, including the 2025 COLA, 1% across the board increases for each year of the contract.

320
00:30:23.884 --> 00:30:35.079
<v Unidentified speaker>A one-time lump payment of $3,000 that will be coming out of the existing auditor's budget, and so will not have an impact to other funds.

321
00:30:36.509 --> 00:30:48.164
<v Unidentified speaker>Seniority-based bumping rights, those will be effective in 2027 to allow the auditor's office some time to format what that change will look like for future years.

322
00:30:49.256 --> 00:30:59.186
<v Unidentified speaker>A 2% longevity premium, as well as a 1% archive stacks premium for the 2 employees that work in the physical archive stacks.

323
00:31:00.876 --> 00:31:13.306
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, a portion of their professional development fund, which already exists, will be held aside for the purposes of travel to trainings for individuals' professional development.

324
00:31:13.887 --> 00:31:23.921
<v Unidentified speaker>And then there's also language about the creation of a VIBA for the AFSCME auditors group Uh, that we're eager to get started on.

325
00:31:24.676 --> 00:31:34.651
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, as far as the total cost for a 3.5-year agreement, there is $1.1 million in budgeted funds, um, for COLA.

326
00:31:35.329 --> 00:31:45.690
<v Unidentified speaker>There is $145,000 in additional spending that's coming out of the auditor's budget, and then, um, $537,000 in ongoing costs.

327
00:31:47.729 --> 00:31:49.380
<v Unidentified speaker>And that is the end.

328
00:31:49.444 --> 00:31:51.273
<v Unidentified speaker>So if there are any questions—.

329
00:31:51.532 --> 00:31:52.132
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

330
00:31:52.278 --> 00:31:54.269
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, are there any technical or clarifying questions?

331
00:31:56.950 --> 00:31:58.096
<v Unidentified speaker>Do we have anybody signed up to testify?

332
00:31:58.516 --> 00:31:59.646
<v Unidentified speaker>We have 2 people signed up.

333
00:31:59.825 --> 00:32:03.135
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, first up we have Minden Vuong.

334
00:32:16.320 --> 00:32:19.319
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, Councilors, Auditor Reddy, staff.

335
00:32:20.009 --> 00:32:21.709
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Mindan Vuong.

336
00:32:21.853 --> 00:32:33.351
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm an employee of the Auditor's Office, and I'm speaking to you today as a member leader with AFSCME Local 189, representing 30 employees, public servants in the Auditor's Office.

337
00:32:34.361 --> 00:32:39.653
<v Unidentified speaker>Your vote on this item today will cap off 12 months of bargaining a labor agreement.

338
00:32:40.198 --> 00:32:47.155
<v Unidentified speaker>My members went into this bargaining seeking fair wages, Layoff protections, and work location guarantees.

339
00:32:47.733 --> 00:32:53.953
<v Unidentified speaker>My members have spoken up about what is important to them and have been extraordinarily patient throughout this process.

340
00:32:54.787 --> 00:33:07.868
<v Unidentified speaker>Bargaining means finding common ground between the union and the employer, and we have scaled back many of our initial demands in the interest of achieving long-term security on wages and working conditions.

341
00:33:08.750 --> 00:33:18.688
<v Unidentified speaker>Of course, the employer side also made some movements, so the agreement before you today is the best mutually agreeable deal between the union and the city.

342
00:33:19.568 --> 00:33:25.065
<v Unidentified speaker>We bargained especially hard over economics, of course, recognizing the city's fiscal condition.

343
00:33:26.522 --> 00:33:35.079
<v Unidentified speaker>As you are digesting the mayor's proposed budget, you will see that the budget cuts 2 positions of AFSCME-represented employees in the auditor's office.

344
00:33:36.073 --> 00:33:41.057
<v Unidentified speaker>My 2 members have already received the layoff notices, and that has turned their world upside down.

345
00:33:41.121 --> 00:33:41.505
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Sameer Kanal.

346
00:33:42.419 --> 00:33:47.598
<v Unidentified speaker>If you allow these layoffs to go through, you will be kicking skilled employees to the curb.

347
00:33:47.935 --> 00:33:57.863
<v Unidentified speaker>And if you allow these layoffs to go through, you will have allowed the executive branch to cut the budget of another branch of government that is supposed to hold the executive branch accountable.

348
00:33:58.905 --> 00:34:07.244
<v Unidentified speaker>We are all hearing, I believe you as well, more calls from community members for more accountability from our City of Portland government.

349
00:34:07.743 --> 00:34:22.465
<v Unidentified speaker>You have the power with the budget to decide the fate of my members, and I'm asking you respectfully to fully fund the labor agreement, restore our 2 positions, and thereby support accountability and transparency as our community demands.

350
00:34:22.804 --> 00:34:23.081
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

351
00:34:23.614 --> 00:34:24.246
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

352
00:34:29.822 --> 00:34:33.119
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Asis Patel.

353
00:34:47.784 --> 00:34:53.248
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, I see you signed up for the wrong one.

354
00:34:53.346 --> 00:34:56.255
<v Unidentified speaker>Do you want to come— can you come down and like, yeah, sign up for the right one?

355
00:34:56.902 --> 00:35:00.065
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, Okay.

356
00:35:00.521 --> 00:35:00.635
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay.

357
00:35:00.929 --> 00:35:01.516
<v Keelan McClymont>All righty.

358
00:35:01.824 --> 00:35:03.063
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, I got it.

359
00:35:03.210 --> 00:35:03.487
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

360
00:35:03.780 --> 00:35:04.139
<v Unidentified speaker>That's good.

361
00:35:04.204 --> 00:35:04.481
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

362
00:35:04.545 --> 00:35:05.588
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

363
00:35:06.099 --> 00:35:09.114
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, colleagues, is there any council discussion of this item?

364
00:35:12.784 --> 00:35:14.110
<v Unidentified speaker>See— oh, Councilor Knoll.

365
00:35:14.626 --> 00:35:29.387
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I just want to note before we vote on this that we will be having a, I'm sure, spirited conversation around the item that was mentioned in, in testimony around the budget of the Auditor's Office in general, and I don't want the fact that we're not talking about it here to be conveyed to anybody as we're ignoring it.

366
00:35:29.436 --> 00:35:32.112
<v Unidentified speaker>It's just not particularly relevant to this exact item right now.

367
00:35:32.434 --> 00:35:33.418
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanted to acknowledge that.

368
00:35:33.467 --> 00:35:33.755
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

369
00:35:34.190 --> 00:35:35.056
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

370
00:35:37.918 --> 00:35:41.307
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, colleagues, this is a first reading of an emergency ordinance.

371
00:35:41.677 --> 00:35:43.063
<v Unidentified speaker>Requires 9 votes to pass.

372
00:35:43.369 --> 00:35:44.195
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we please call the roll?

373
00:35:45.148 --> 00:35:45.438
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal.

374
00:35:46.264 --> 00:35:46.425
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

375
00:35:46.992 --> 00:35:47.460
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney.

376
00:35:47.735 --> 00:35:47.847
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

377
00:35:48.365 --> 00:35:48.592
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan.

378
00:35:49.012 --> 00:35:49.028
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

379
00:35:49.514 --> 00:35:50.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane.

380
00:35:55.143 --> 00:35:56.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Councilor Koyama Lane?

381
00:35:58.856 --> 00:35:59.518
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, absent.

382
00:36:00.391 --> 00:36:00.713
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo?

383
00:36:01.521 --> 00:36:01.570
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

384
00:36:02.264 --> 00:36:02.586
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

385
00:36:03.119 --> 00:36:03.152
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

386
00:36:03.570 --> 00:36:03.954
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

387
00:36:04.420 --> 00:36:04.469
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

388
00:36:05.079 --> 00:36:05.289
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

389
00:36:05.706 --> 00:36:05.755
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

390
00:36:06.286 --> 00:36:06.639
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

391
00:36:06.913 --> 00:36:07.088
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

392
00:36:07.490 --> 00:36:07.780
<v Keelan McClymont>Avilos?

393
00:36:08.117 --> 00:36:08.166
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

394
00:36:08.679 --> 00:36:08.985
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

395
00:36:09.563 --> 00:36:09.612
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

396
00:36:10.288 --> 00:36:10.592
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

397
00:36:11.010 --> 00:36:11.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

398
00:36:12.039 --> 00:36:15.764
<v Unidentified speaker>The ordinance passes with a vote of 11 ayes and 1 absent.

399
00:36:16.885 --> 00:36:17.391
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

400
00:36:17.456 --> 00:36:18.775
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we please move to item number 7?

401
00:36:26.230 --> 00:36:39.137
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 7, document 2026-149, add code to prohibit the sale or provision of certain force-fed poultry products, add code chapter 17.110.

402
00:36:39.909 --> 00:36:42.193
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, this is the first reading of a non-emergency ordinance.

403
00:36:42.273 --> 00:36:48.088
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to turn it over to thank you, Mr.

404
00:36:48.362 --> 00:36:49.231
<v Unidentified speaker>Council President.

405
00:36:49.278 --> 00:36:57.362
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll keep my initial sponsor remarks brief because I note that we have 75 people signed up for testimony and this has been allotted 80 minutes.

406
00:36:58.184 --> 00:37:01.702
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to briefly say why I think we should do this at this time.

407
00:37:02.771 --> 00:37:09.545
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that we should adopt this ordinance to ban the sale of force-feeding for certain poultry products because it's the right thing to do.

408
00:37:09.592 --> 00:37:09.914
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

409
00:37:11.068 --> 00:37:12.349
<v Unidentified speaker>Force-feeding animals is cruel.

410
00:37:13.329 --> 00:37:17.432
<v Unidentified speaker>And while I recognize it doesn't end all animal cruelty, it does limit some.

411
00:37:17.496 --> 00:37:23.253
<v Unidentified speaker>And we should always strive to take some— take measures that are simple and clear to limit harms under our purview.

412
00:37:23.574 --> 00:37:25.306
<v Unidentified speaker>That's what government's for.

413
00:37:25.579 --> 00:37:27.871
<v Unidentified speaker>That's what governments at all levels should be trying to do at this time.

414
00:37:28.802 --> 00:37:36.449
<v Unidentified speaker>So at this moment, I'm going to call forward the panel that's going to talk a little bit about how we developed this policy, unless— I have 3 other co-sponsors.

415
00:37:36.498 --> 00:37:37.829
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, if you guys want to take a minute to—.

416
00:37:37.829 --> 00:37:38.213
<v Unidentified speaker>I think we should take a minute.

417
00:37:40.610 --> 00:37:41.146
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, great.

418
00:37:41.503 --> 00:37:45.670
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, uh, so at the dais I see Sam with Pro Animal Futures.

419
00:37:45.817 --> 00:37:46.855
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, why don't you take us away?

420
00:37:59.030 --> 00:38:00.614
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks, Councilor Green.

421
00:38:01.358 --> 00:38:03.688
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, my name is Sam Schillinger.

422
00:38:03.927 --> 00:38:08.047
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a Portland District 3 resident and the campaign director for Pro Animal Oregon.

423
00:38:08.800 --> 00:38:17.184
<v Unidentified speaker>Pro Animal Oregon is a movement of volunteers, voters, and donors organizing politically to move Oregon towards a future beyond factory farming.

424
00:38:18.177 --> 00:38:26.786
<v Unidentified speaker>You have the opportunity to advance legislation that will put Portland on the map as a trailblazer in responsible food, prohibiting the sale of force-fed foie gras.

425
00:38:27.715 --> 00:38:31.889
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to warn you, there are some graphic images in this presentation that may be difficult to look at.

426
00:38:33.409 --> 00:38:34.945
<v Unidentified speaker>So what exactly is foie gras?

427
00:38:35.606 --> 00:38:43.503
<v Unidentified speaker>French for fatty liver, it's the diseased liver of a duck who's been force-fed until their liver swells up to 10 times its normal size.

428
00:38:44.565 --> 00:38:53.353
<v Unidentified speaker>Marketed as a luxury product at French and upscale restaurants, the hefty price tag reflects the extreme costs of keeping a diseased animal alive.

429
00:38:55.161 --> 00:38:57.469
<v Unidentified speaker>Why should Portland prohibit the sale of force-fed foie gras?

430
00:38:58.713 --> 00:39:03.606
<v Unidentified speaker>Ducks raised for foie gras are force-fed 2 to 3 times a day for nearly 2 weeks.

431
00:39:04.552 --> 00:39:11.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Force-feeding meant to induce liver disease is an extreme form of animal cruelty that doesn't align with Portland's values.

432
00:39:12.088 --> 00:39:17.284
<v Unidentified speaker>This narrow and focused policy sets Portland apart as a leader in humane food systems.

433
00:39:18.681 --> 00:39:24.215
<v Unidentified speaker>This bill has broad public support from local business, as 58 Portland restaurants have endorsed it.

434
00:39:25.257 --> 00:39:37.186
<v Unidentified speaker>In addition to local business support, 32 veterinary professionals have formally endorsed this ordinance, showing this legislation reflects the most current scientific understanding of avian welfare and veterinary standards.

435
00:39:38.487 --> 00:39:42.130
<v Unidentified speaker>While this policy would set a bold precedent, Portland wouldn't be the first to do it.

436
00:39:42.677 --> 00:39:46.818
<v Unidentified speaker>The entire state of California banned the sale and production of foie gras.

437
00:39:47.172 --> 00:39:52.952
<v Unidentified speaker>The sale of foie gras has also been banned in New York City, Pittsburgh, and Brookline, Massachusetts.

438
00:39:53.514 --> 00:39:55.407
<v Unidentified speaker>These have consistently been upheld.

439
00:39:56.259 --> 00:40:02.875
<v Unidentified speaker>Several major retailers, including Target, Costco, Whole Foods, and IKEA, have also stopped selling foie gras.

440
00:40:03.710 --> 00:40:12.909
<v Unidentified speaker>Finally, there's an international legal and ethical trend, as at least 27 countries have banned or phased out foie gras sales, production, or import.

441
00:40:14.130 --> 00:40:18.878
<v Unidentified speaker>The proposed ordinance prohibits the commercial sale or provision of force-fed poultry products.

442
00:40:19.518 --> 00:40:29.250
<v Unidentified speaker>This applies to restaurants, retailers, and food services, but does not restrict personal possession, consumption, online sales, or non-force-fed liver.

443
00:40:30.018 --> 00:40:35.838
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a narrow, focused policy meant to keep products made from force-feeding out of the Portland marketplace.

444
00:40:36.751 --> 00:40:43.016
<v Unidentified speaker>On top of the standard 30-day implementation period following adoption, we propose an additional 60-day transition period.

445
00:40:43.760 --> 00:40:50.844
<v Unidentified speaker>To encourage compliance, violators will get a written notice with clear guidance and time to come into compliance before being fined.

446
00:40:52.730 --> 00:40:56.503
<v Unidentified speaker>Prohibiting foie gras sales would result in no economic harm.

447
00:40:57.117 --> 00:41:04.512
<v Unidentified speaker>This is because less than 1% of Portland businesses actually sell foie gras in an almost exclusively high-end fine dining context.

448
00:41:05.288 --> 00:41:10.891
<v Unidentified speaker>We searched local menus to see who this would affect Currently, only 7 restaurants and 1 retailer are selling it.

449
00:41:11.501 --> 00:41:16.045
<v Unidentified speaker>However, we found 16 restaurants and 2 retailers that have offered foie gras over the past year.

450
00:41:16.333 --> 00:41:26.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Because it's a seasonal item that often rotates on and off menus, and some places have stopped serving it, we looked at a full year of data to provide the most honest picture of the local marketplace.

451
00:41:27.637 --> 00:41:32.407
<v Unidentified speaker>This number still represents a fraction of a percent of the 2,500+ food businesses in Portland.

452
00:41:33.119 --> 00:41:39.744
<v Unidentified speaker>Even so, every serving represents an individual bird subjected to multiple forced feedings a day for many days of their life.

453
00:41:40.539 --> 00:41:50.829
<v Unidentified speaker>For those businesses who do sell it, it's an insignificant source of revenue, a single niche product that can easily be replaced with a more local, ethical, and sustainable alternative.

454
00:41:52.295 --> 00:42:02.230
<v Unidentified speaker>As proof of concept of the negligible economic impact, 7 Portland businesses have begun phasing out foie gras with no reported loss in revenue, customer traffic, or jobs.

455
00:42:03.135 --> 00:42:12.664
<v Unidentified speaker>This shows that a seamless transition away from foie gras is not only feasible for local businesses, but that a local prohibition reinforces an already existing trend.

456
00:42:13.570 --> 00:42:15.739
<v Unidentified speaker>Many chefs routinely adapt menus.

457
00:42:20.592 --> 00:42:27.425
<v Unidentified speaker>A recent study from the Colorado State University Animal-Human Policy Center shows that Portlanders overwhelmingly support prohibiting the sale of foie gras.

458
00:42:27.634 --> 00:42:35.889
<v Unidentified speaker>Among the 250 Portlanders surveyed, weighted results show that 84% support banning the sale of foie gras where force-feeding was used.

459
00:42:36.594 --> 00:42:44.097
<v Unidentified speaker>This data shows that prohibiting force-fed products in Portland is a market-driven policy that aligns community values and consumer demand.

460
00:42:45.170 --> 00:42:52.592
<v Unidentified speaker>Force-feeding causes liver disease that results in pre-slaughter mortality rates 9 to 19 times higher than 9 force-fed birds.

461
00:42:53.251 --> 00:42:54.485
<v Unidentified speaker>This harm is not incidental.

462
00:42:54.614 --> 00:42:55.079
<v Unidentified speaker>It's the point.

463
00:42:55.913 --> 00:42:58.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Liver disease is required to create a marketable product.

464
00:42:59.280 --> 00:43:03.657
<v Unidentified speaker>On the right is a healthy liver, and on the left is a diseased liver of a bird who's been force-fed.

465
00:43:05.134 --> 00:43:08.710
<v Unidentified speaker>There is no U.S. commercial supply of non-force-fed foie gras.

466
00:43:09.463 --> 00:43:16.039
<v Unidentified speaker>The photo here was taken from Hudson Valley Foie Gras, where they have a permit to confine up to 100,000 ducks at a time.

467
00:43:16.423 --> 00:43:22.956
<v Unidentified speaker>This is consistent with what the EPA defines as a large concentrated animal feeding operation, otherwise known as a factory farm.

468
00:43:23.650 --> 00:43:29.954
<v Unidentified speaker>What's more, by legal definition in the U.S., foie gras must meet a minimum liver weight that's only achievable through forced feeding.

469
00:43:32.750 --> 00:43:37.599
<v Unidentified speaker>On February 19th, an independent photojournalist went to Hudson Valley Foie Gras where this footage was taken.

470
00:43:38.262 --> 00:43:43.833
<v Unidentified speaker>Hudson Valley is the largest foie gras factory farm in the country and the primary supplier for Portland businesses.

471
00:43:44.092 --> 00:43:49.492
<v Unidentified speaker>This footage was captured during a publicly available tour, meaning these conditions aren't a hidden side of the industry.

472
00:43:49.929 --> 00:43:53.646
<v Unidentified speaker>They represent the best-case scenario that the industry is comfortable showing the public.

473
00:43:54.358 --> 00:43:57.931
<v Unidentified speaker>They found ducks confined in pens on metal grates covered in their own waste.

474
00:43:58.400 --> 00:44:05.697
<v Unidentified speaker>Workers were documented using thick, foot-long metal tubes to force-feed the birds, dragging them across the pen to position them for feeding.

475
00:44:08.030 --> 00:44:13.083
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras is destructive to the environment because production is incredibly resource-intensive, and wasteful.

476
00:44:14.045 --> 00:44:19.813
<v Unidentified speaker>Extreme overfeeding leads to highly concentrated runoff, which has resulted in over 1,100 violations of the Clean Water Act.

477
00:44:20.775 --> 00:44:26.704
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras also poses a serious threat to public health due to the risk of spreading animal-to-human disease, namely bird flu.

478
00:44:27.344 --> 00:44:29.427
<v Unidentified speaker>Keep in mind, we're talking about diseased liver.

479
00:44:29.603 --> 00:44:32.648
<v Unidentified speaker>It's often served raw or only partially cooked.

480
00:44:33.914 --> 00:44:35.900
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland is ready to end force-feeding.

481
00:44:36.639 --> 00:44:42.706
<v Unidentified speaker>There are no factory farms within city limits, and industrial animal agriculture is primarily regulated at the state and federal levels.

482
00:44:43.445 --> 00:44:48.284
<v Unidentified speaker>A foie gras sales ban addresses what the city can regulate: the sale of an inherently cruel product.

483
00:44:48.913 --> 00:44:54.661
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland already regulates what can be sold locally based on ethical, environmental, and public health concerns.

484
00:44:55.047 --> 00:44:59.867
<v Unidentified speaker>For example, we passed a phased ban on leaf blowers this year to reduce pollution and improve public health.

485
00:45:00.793 --> 00:45:05.744
<v Unidentified speaker>Prohibiting the sale of force-fed foie gras is a values-based, market-driven consumer protection policy.

486
00:45:06.403 --> 00:45:09.793
<v Unidentified speaker>It upholds Portland's reputation as a leader in responsible food.

487
00:45:10.275 --> 00:45:19.025
<v Unidentified speaker>There's no reason we can't pass narrow-focused policy like this while continuing to address important larger issues such as housing affordability and mental health.

488
00:45:19.541 --> 00:45:21.351
<v Unidentified speaker>With that, I urge you to vote yes.

489
00:45:21.947 --> 00:45:22.384
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

490
00:45:23.244 --> 00:45:24.893
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

491
00:45:25.025 --> 00:45:25.987
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much for the presentation.

492
00:45:28.284 --> 00:45:29.065
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank, thank you, Sam.

493
00:45:29.130 --> 00:45:36.199
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think we're going to hear briefly from Hannah Truxell at the Human League, which is going to talk through some, I think, some of the finer details of the what the, what the ordinance does.

494
00:45:36.574 --> 00:45:36.865
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

495
00:45:38.570 --> 00:45:40.456
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, thanks so much for having me.

496
00:45:41.170 --> 00:45:45.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Council President Dunphy and members of the City Council, uh, good afternoon.

497
00:45:45.525 --> 00:45:49.480
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Hannah Truxell and I'm the Senior Policy Counsel at the Humane League.

498
00:45:50.106 --> 00:45:55.789
<v Unidentified speaker>My team and I have been supporting Pro-Animal Oregon and Councilman Green's office on this proposal.

499
00:45:56.336 --> 00:46:04.277
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here today to discuss how this proposal would work in practice through effective thank you.

500
00:46:05.929 --> 00:46:10.822
<v Unidentified speaker>This ordinance was intentionally designed to be straightforward and low impact to administer.

501
00:46:12.083 --> 00:46:22.394
<v Unidentified speaker>First, enforcement is complaint-based, meaning the city is not required to proactively inspect businesses but will respond only to complaints of violations.

502
00:46:23.168 --> 00:46:27.309
<v Unidentified speaker>Second, outreach is already being conducted with affected businesses.

503
00:46:28.164 --> 00:46:38.161
<v Unidentified speaker>With a 90-day transition period after passage, impacted businesses will have ample time to use existing inventory, update menus, and come into compliance.

504
00:46:39.315 --> 00:46:45.221
<v Unidentified speaker>Third, and importantly, implementation does not require new city funding or additional staff.

505
00:46:45.815 --> 00:47:05.746
<v Unidentified speaker>Current conversations with local agencies under the Community and Economic Development Service Area are proving that enforcement of this proposal fits within existing enforcement frameworks, including discussions around an intergovernmental agreement with Multnomah County's Office of Environmental Health.

506
00:47:06.659 --> 00:47:12.476
<v Unidentified speaker>And finally, this ordinance emphasizes education first, with compliance as the goal.

507
00:47:13.293 --> 00:47:20.952
<v Unidentified speaker>Violators of the ordinance will be first given a written warning and an opportunity to correct any violation before penalties apply.

508
00:47:21.112 --> 00:47:21.224
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

509
00:47:21.565 --> 00:47:25.070
<v Unidentified speaker>Ensuring a fair and predictable implementation process.

510
00:47:26.010 --> 00:47:35.331
<v Unidentified speaker>Pro-Animal Oregon is prepared to support the city post-passage by assisting with outreach, guidance materials, and direct business education.

511
00:47:36.443 --> 00:47:46.018
<v Unidentified speaker>Overall, this policy is practical, easy to implement, and aligns with Portland's values regarding humane treatment of animals and sustainable food systems.

512
00:47:46.682 --> 00:47:49.873
<v Unidentified speaker>We urge you to support this measured and effective proposal.

513
00:47:49.938 --> 00:47:50.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

514
00:47:50.581 --> 00:47:55.306
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

515
00:47:57.735 --> 00:48:02.492
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, colleagues, uh, couple of process notes for everybody.

516
00:48:02.556 --> 00:48:05.934
<v Unidentified speaker>There are— first of all, Keelan, how many people are signed up to testify on this?

517
00:48:07.704 --> 00:48:10.693
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, we have at this time 81.

518
00:48:11.277 --> 00:48:13.697
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so there are 81 people signed up to testify.

519
00:48:14.610 --> 00:48:20.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, this item took a bit of a, a, uh, Thank you.

520
00:48:20.132 --> 00:48:21.923
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a bit of an odd path to get to council.

521
00:48:23.195 --> 00:48:38.621
<v Unidentified speaker>This actually was heard in the former Arts and Economy Committee where it did not receive support but was put on our schedule by letters of— 4 release letters from councilors.

522
00:48:39.619 --> 00:48:46.010
<v Unidentified speaker>Because this was also a bit of an odd process, I'm also going to be making an extraordinary choice here.

523
00:48:46.076 --> 00:48:47.384
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to be limiting testimony to only 80 minutes.

524
00:48:47.447 --> 00:48:50.862
<v Unidentified speaker>We worked on this with with the, with the sponsors.

525
00:48:51.442 --> 00:49:01.525
<v Unidentified speaker>So folks who are going to testify, if you agree with the previous testimony and your testimony is very, very similar, ditto is a great way to just have it, however that might be.

526
00:49:01.893 --> 00:49:06.791
<v Unidentified speaker>Before we dive into that, are there any technical or clarifying questions from colleagues?

527
00:49:07.177 --> 00:49:12.780
<v Unidentified speaker>And then also there are 3 invited testimony that I'll call before we move to public testimony.

528
00:49:12.829 --> 00:49:13.197
<v Unidentified speaker>So, okay.

529
00:49:14.177 --> 00:49:15.141
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mayor.

530
00:49:15.623 --> 00:49:33.157
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we please also hear, uh, as requested by Councilor Green, we have Amber Canavan, a former investigator from PETA, Ryan Koger, a chef from Feral, and Anna Lavallee— I'm certain I screwed that up, I apologize— an organizer with Direct Action Everywhere.

531
00:49:34.007 --> 00:49:35.387
<v Unidentified speaker>This is invited testimony?

532
00:49:35.612 --> 00:49:36.784
<v Unidentified speaker>This is an invited, yes.

533
00:49:38.262 --> 00:49:39.547
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

534
00:49:46.121 --> 00:49:48.927
<v Unidentified speaker>Whoever wants to start us, go ahead.

535
00:49:49.472 --> 00:49:49.583
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

536
00:49:50.914 --> 00:49:51.907
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Council.

537
00:49:52.869 --> 00:49:54.264
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Amber Canavan.

538
00:49:54.536 --> 00:49:56.413
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a resident of District 3.

539
00:49:57.038 --> 00:50:05.581
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm also here on behalf of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals and our over 20,000 members and supporters in the Portland area.

540
00:50:06.559 --> 00:50:36.159
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm also here as a former cruelty investigator who witnessed firsthand the suffering that ducks I would like to share what I saw and also state that a recent investigation released by Pro-Animal Future confirms that the conditions that these ducks are forced to live in and what is done to them during the violent force-feeding process appear to remain unchanged in any meaningful way since I last visited.

541
00:50:37.088 --> 00:50:48.077
<v Unidentified speaker>Council member what I saw and discovered was that birds were and still are being kept in wire-bottom pens suspended over a river of their own waste.

542
00:50:48.943 --> 00:50:58.228
<v Unidentified speaker>The skin and feathers of many of the ducks were and still are crusted from feces from the filthy conditions they're forced to live in.

543
00:50:59.304 --> 00:51:05.699
<v Unidentified speaker>Many of the ducks had and still have difficulty walking and breathing because of their huge engorged livers.

544
00:51:10.648 --> 00:51:22.875
<v Unidentified speaker>There is a reason that foie gras is banned by so many companies and governments in the United States and around the world, including just yesterday Brazil voted to ban foie gras.

545
00:51:24.518 --> 00:51:29.106
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland needs to catch up and do its part by passing this foie gras ban.

546
00:51:29.447 --> 00:51:29.867
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

547
00:51:30.483 --> 00:51:31.246
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

548
00:51:36.474 --> 00:51:37.838
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, members of committee.

549
00:51:38.224 --> 00:51:39.460
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Anna Lavallee.

550
00:51:40.068 --> 00:51:50.481
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 4, and I'm an organizer with Portland chapter, uh, Direct Action Everywhere, which is an animal rights organization that fights for the total liberation of all animals.

551
00:51:51.492 --> 00:51:56.594
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm going to keep it simple and ask a question: how can you create change and make a more positive world?

552
00:51:56.643 --> 00:51:56.835
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

553
00:51:57.717 --> 00:52:09.722
<v Unidentified speaker>For us at the Portland chapter of Direct Action Everywhere, that means every single week we stand outside restaurants that serve foie gras to show our opposition to this abject cruelty.

554
00:52:10.813 --> 00:52:17.498
<v Unidentified speaker>Nearly every person that I have stopped and had a conversation with falls into 2 categories of conversation.

555
00:52:18.090 --> 00:52:20.463
<v Unidentified speaker>They either say, what is foie gras?

556
00:52:21.119 --> 00:52:30.099
<v Unidentified speaker>Or once I explain what foie gras is, They grimace and look at the restaurant with disdain because it is abject cruelty.

557
00:52:31.909 --> 00:52:40.987
<v Unidentified speaker>Members of our group and other grassroots animal rights organizations have worked for years to act upon that truth that many people in Portland know to be true.

558
00:52:42.297 --> 00:52:45.777
<v Unidentified speaker>These years of collective effort have made indelible change.

559
00:52:46.550 --> 00:53:01.675
<v Unidentified speaker>The current series of protests that Direct Action Everywhere Portland has done has been going on for a little bit less than a year, and even so, 7 restaurants have dropped foie gras, and multiple others are in dialogue with us about doing so right now.

560
00:53:03.041 --> 00:53:12.172
<v Unidentified speaker>Despite this change, foie gras still has a presence in Portland, and as long as it does, Direct Action Everywhere Portland will continue to show up and speak the truth.

561
00:53:13.634 --> 00:53:23.793
<v Unidentified speaker>This committee, on the other hand, has power to make a different change than we make, one that aligns with Portland's values of compassion for animals.

562
00:53:25.202 --> 00:53:38.983
<v Unidentified speaker>Protesting a restaurant may remove it from one menu, but all of you here have the choice to remove it from every single menu in Portland, and that is a large change that you can make.

563
00:53:40.425 --> 00:53:50.329
<v Unidentified speaker>While this might affect independent business owners, foie gras is not a sole item that sustains any of their menus, nor will it ever be at any restaurant.

564
00:53:51.871 --> 00:54:03.414
<v Unidentified speaker>And I would argue that it's always worth facing temporary discomfort if it means that you can live in a more kind and compassionate world that aligns with your values.

565
00:54:04.827 --> 00:54:24.382
<v Unidentified speaker>So let Portland stand and lead in the way of showing compassion for animals, because when historians look back upon the decision made in this room right now, we want to know that the change you made made a more kind and compassionate world.

566
00:54:25.010 --> 00:54:28.635
<v Unidentified speaker>So please vote yes on this ordinance to ban foie gras.

567
00:54:29.789 --> 00:54:30.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

568
00:54:30.521 --> 00:54:31.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

569
00:54:34.025 --> 00:54:35.338
<v Unidentified speaker>Do we have Ryan Koger here?

570
00:54:37.186 --> 00:54:39.067
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Ryan Koger.

571
00:54:39.277 --> 00:54:43.715
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the chef Owner of Feral in Northeast Portland.

572
00:54:45.175 --> 00:54:46.762
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, I support this ban.

573
00:54:47.179 --> 00:54:50.179
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, we're a 100% vegan restaurant.

574
00:54:50.309 --> 00:54:52.072
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't serve any animal products.

575
00:54:52.393 --> 00:55:19.750
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we're able to produce rich, delicious pâtés, steaks, roasts, um, using little more than mushrooms, uh, some ferments, um, processed kale, vegetables, um, Early in my career, I was working in restaurants in Cincinnati, Ohio that had pretty extensive butchery and charcuterie programs.

576
00:55:20.420 --> 00:55:33.840
<v Unidentified speaker>I was a vegan butcher, and as a vegan butcher, my chefs were always trying to justify to me their use of animal products.

577
00:55:35.014 --> 00:55:40.039
<v Unidentified speaker>And their kind of bottom line was, at least I would never touch foie gras.

578
00:55:40.538 --> 00:55:58.425
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, they had creative ways of utilizing other animal organ meat, um, offal, and, uh, other animal liver, um, non-force-fed duck liver to emulate the same flavors and textures.

579
00:55:58.762 --> 00:56:01.467
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, This was 15 years ago.

580
00:56:02.079 --> 00:56:06.175
<v Unidentified speaker>There's no reason for restaurants to still be using this ingredient.

581
00:56:07.130 --> 00:56:07.664
<v Unidentified speaker>It's archaic.

582
00:56:07.728 --> 00:56:09.039
<v Unidentified speaker>It's cruel.

583
00:56:13.295 --> 00:56:26.184
<v Unidentified speaker>Any chef claiming the success of their restaurant depends on any single product is not only being melodramatic and sensational, they're just a bad chef as far as I'm concerned.

584
00:56:29.909 --> 00:56:42.838
<v Unidentified speaker>If this isn't a new, a new thing, banning unethical foods, um, if it was, then we would still be serving horse meat, shark fins, turtle soup.

585
00:56:43.304 --> 00:56:45.393
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we're not banning books.

586
00:56:45.554 --> 00:56:56.016
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a group of people trying to do the right thing and, um, stop this incredibly inhumane practice from happening.

587
00:56:56.356 --> 00:57:02.518
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, it's completely, yeah, inhumane to force-feed an animal to death no matter what.

588
00:57:02.842 --> 00:57:10.056
<v Unidentified speaker>Morbidly so for a luxury food item that can be easily substituted, as I stated before.

589
00:57:10.490 --> 00:57:27.159
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, and yeah, my hope today is that as chefs, purveyors, Portlanders, uh, council members, politicians That we're leading the way to protect our humanity in a time that seems pretty ethically bankrupt.

590
00:57:27.384 --> 00:57:30.597
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, yeah, that's all I really have to say.

591
00:57:30.677 --> 00:57:30.983
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

592
00:57:31.802 --> 00:57:32.429
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

593
00:57:33.523 --> 00:57:40.563
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, so because there are so many folks, we are reducing— unfortunately have to reduce the number of— the amount of testimony to 90 seconds apiece.

594
00:57:41.393 --> 00:57:44.626
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Keelan, can you please call up our first panel of testifiers?

595
00:57:44.739 --> 00:57:47.795
<v Unidentified speaker>And thank you both of thank you.

596
00:57:48.235 --> 00:57:53.925
<v Unidentified speaker>Before I call the first names, when your name is called, you can come to the testimony table.

597
00:57:54.005 --> 00:57:56.907
<v Unidentified speaker>Once seated, state your name for the record and begin your testimony.

598
00:57:57.666 --> 00:58:00.375
<v Unidentified speaker>You'll see the timer displayed on the monitor in front of you.

599
00:58:00.440 --> 00:58:05.565
<v Unidentified speaker>The timer will sound when you have 30 seconds remaining and again when your time has expired.

600
00:58:08.050 --> 00:58:10.496
<v Unidentified speaker>And then, yeah, okay, thanks.

601
00:58:10.739 --> 00:58:11.880
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm gonna call you up in groups of 5.

602
00:58:11.929 --> 00:58:12.043
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

603
00:58:15.911 --> 00:58:25.929
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, first up we have Eva Hamer, Andrew Fortgang, Brave Roberson, Kurt Huffman, Adrian Tortolo.

604
00:58:28.130 --> 00:58:28.940
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome, folks.

605
00:58:30.235 --> 00:58:32.954
<v Unidentified speaker>Introduce yourself for the record in 90 seconds.

606
00:58:33.369 --> 00:58:38.507
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, my name is Eva Hamer, resident in District 3, executive director of Pro Animal Oregon.

607
00:58:39.630 --> 00:58:45.072
<v Unidentified speaker>You may hear today that foie gras is humane or that it should be judged by the best farms and not the worst.

608
00:58:45.735 --> 00:58:50.793
<v Unidentified speaker>But foie gras production depends on force-feeding ducks until they develop fatty liver disease.

609
00:58:51.083 --> 00:58:52.083
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not a side effect.

610
00:58:52.130 --> 00:58:52.969
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not an accident.

611
00:58:53.576 --> 00:58:54.902
<v Unidentified speaker>It happens just sometimes.

612
00:58:55.371 --> 00:58:56.876
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras is fatty liver disease.

613
00:58:58.619 --> 00:59:01.998
<v Unidentified speaker>Folks in opposition might say that besides the force-feeding, these farms are actually very nice.

614
00:59:02.128 --> 00:59:03.469
<v Unidentified speaker>And we are talking about the same farms.

615
00:59:04.293 --> 00:59:06.088
<v Unidentified speaker>They won't remind you that ducks are built to swim.

616
00:59:06.168 --> 00:59:06.298
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

617
00:59:07.094 --> 00:59:11.184
<v Unidentified speaker>And this is one of the natural behaviors that they're denied in the factory farms that produce foie gras.

618
00:59:12.291 --> 00:59:20.802
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm talking about painful deformities in the legs and sores on the feet caused by too much pressure on weak legs that never get relief from the water.

619
00:59:22.458 --> 00:59:31.150
<v Unidentified speaker>You might hear that Portland has bigger issues to address, but this ordinance is simple and narrow, and passing this now will be much more efficient than by ballot initiative later.

620
00:59:31.360 --> 00:59:31.632
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

621
00:59:32.376 --> 00:59:38.494
<v Unidentified speaker>Finally, you might wish that this ordinance did more to help other animals who suffer in factory farms, like chickens used for meat.

622
00:59:38.800 --> 00:59:43.583
<v Unidentified speaker>I agree that other animals also need protection, and I look forward to working with you on that.

623
00:59:44.516 --> 00:59:47.567
<v Unidentified speaker>But some cruelty is not a reason to allow other cruelty to continue.

624
00:59:48.434 --> 00:59:52.864
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a narrow, practical step against a uniquely indefensible product.

625
00:59:53.588 --> 00:59:54.262
<v Unidentified speaker>I urge you to vote yes.

626
00:59:54.856 --> 00:59:55.032
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

627
00:59:55.498 --> 00:59:55.835
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

628
00:59:59.528 --> 00:59:59.802
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead.

629
01:00:00.958 --> 01:00:02.514
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, my name is Andrew Fortgang.

630
01:00:02.563 --> 01:00:06.833
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a resident of District 4 and co-owner of Le Pigeon and Canard restaurants in District 3.

631
01:00:07.074 --> 01:00:16.789
<v Unidentified speaker>The proposed ordinance and supporting documents presented with it are not representative of the foie gras that is actually sold in Portland, which comes from 2 family-owned organic farms in upstate New York.

632
01:00:17.351 --> 01:00:23.934
<v Unidentified speaker>La Belle Farm is where the foie gras we use comes from, as well as the majority of the foie gras served in Portland, is owned by Salvadoran immigrants.

633
01:00:24.014 --> 01:00:32.099
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a 40-acre vertically integrated farm, meaning they grow their own corn and soy for feed, and the manure is redistributed to their fields as well as their neighbors for fertilizer.

634
01:00:32.597 --> 01:00:39.463
<v Unidentified speaker>The ducks are kept in well-ventilated, climate-controlled barns where they have plenty of space to roam within those barns, never in cages.

635
01:00:40.056 --> 01:00:43.601
<v Unidentified speaker>Not only is the liver used, all of the duck is used and sold.

636
01:00:43.650 --> 01:00:44.565
<v Unidentified speaker>None goes to waste.

637
01:00:44.869 --> 01:00:47.324
<v Unidentified speaker>This is exactly the type of farming we should be encouraging.

638
01:00:48.077 --> 01:00:58.255
<v Unidentified speaker>The supplemental materials used used as the basis for this proposal include, include the false claim that birds raised for foie gras in the United States are under intensive confinement, in many cases hundreds of thousands at a time.

639
01:00:58.320 --> 01:01:00.706
<v Unidentified speaker>That is simply impossible based on the actual numbers.

640
01:01:01.300 --> 01:01:03.159
<v Unidentified speaker>Label raises 180 ducks a year.

641
01:01:03.880 --> 01:01:07.967
<v Unidentified speaker>350 Are grown throughout the United States versus 9 billion chickens.

642
01:01:08.030 --> 01:01:10.097
<v Unidentified speaker>But that industry is too big to go after.

643
01:01:10.579 --> 01:01:12.485
<v Unidentified speaker>Proponents of this ban want to have it both ways.

644
01:01:12.661 --> 01:01:19.543
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras is a large factory farming hurting, damaging the environment, but also a small niche luxury product.

645
01:01:19.592 --> 01:01:20.385
<v Unidentified speaker>It can't be both.

646
01:01:21.195 --> 01:01:29.563
<v Unidentified speaker>Responsible lawmaking does not ignore all of these contradictions when it considers taking away the citizenry's choice, something that is not to be taken lightly.

647
01:01:29.661 --> 01:01:30.360
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

648
01:01:31.010 --> 01:01:31.838
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much for being here.

649
01:01:34.882 --> 01:01:35.657
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon.

650
01:01:35.867 --> 01:01:37.144
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Adrian Turtolo.

651
01:01:37.289 --> 01:01:40.684
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a District 4 resident, and I support the fog raw ban.

652
01:01:41.818 --> 01:01:45.893
<v Unidentified speaker>I've been following the range of work Councilor Green has been advancing.

653
01:01:46.550 --> 01:01:58.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Programs like Keep Portland Housed, planning efforts like Inner Eastside for All, and current policy work such as the transportation utility fee and the street damage restoration fee.

654
01:01:59.481 --> 01:02:06.172
<v Unidentified speaker>That's housing stability, long-term development, and infrastructure funding all moving forward at the same time.

655
01:02:06.300 --> 01:02:06.605
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

656
01:02:07.168 --> 01:02:10.807
<v Unidentified speaker>This ordinance is a clear and focused decision within that broader framework.

657
01:02:11.130 --> 01:02:19.463
<v Unidentified speaker>It addresses a specific practice causing extreme animal suffering, and it does so in a way that aligns with Portland's values.

658
01:02:20.153 --> 01:02:22.018
<v Unidentified speaker>It fits within the larger picture.

659
01:02:22.291 --> 01:02:23.672
<v Unidentified speaker>It doesn't take away from it.

660
01:02:24.155 --> 01:02:26.545
<v Unidentified speaker>Please vote yes on the foie gras sales ban.

661
01:02:26.967 --> 01:02:27.307
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

662
01:02:27.632 --> 01:02:28.396
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

663
01:02:30.942 --> 01:02:33.445
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Dunphy and fellow councilors, my name is Kurt Huffman.

664
01:02:33.869 --> 01:02:35.407
<v Unidentified speaker>I own a company called Chef Stable.

665
01:02:36.045 --> 01:02:43.349
<v Unidentified speaker>And since 2008, we've opened over 100 restaurants here in Portland with the mission of giving chefs the opportunity to own their own restaurants.

666
01:02:44.280 --> 01:02:45.891
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not here today to debate foie gras.

667
01:02:46.425 --> 01:02:50.472
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to call out a process that should alarm anyone who cares about how this city governs.

668
01:02:52.179 --> 01:02:57.329
<v Unidentified speaker>2 Days ago, in a conversation with Councilor Novick, I learned this proposal has been in development for nearly a year.

669
01:02:58.713 --> 01:02:58.907
<v Unidentified speaker>A year.

670
01:03:00.496 --> 01:03:08.141
<v Unidentified speaker>And during that entire time, neither Councilor Green nor Councilor Dunphy made any meaningful effort to engage the industry this policy would impact.

671
01:03:09.820 --> 01:03:12.409
<v Unidentified speaker>My company operates more than 30 restaurants here in Portland.

672
01:03:12.925 --> 01:03:15.726
<v Unidentified speaker>I sit on the board of the Oregon Restaurant Lodging Association.

673
01:03:16.307 --> 01:03:18.606
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the current chairman of the Board of Travel Portland.

674
01:03:19.820 --> 01:03:23.835
<v Unidentified speaker>Collectively, those organizations represent a huge share of the city's hospitality economy.

675
01:03:24.831 --> 01:03:34.594
<v Unidentified speaker>And not one call until just prior to the Arts and Economy hearing several weeks ago Not one meeting, not one attempt at serious dialogue.

676
01:03:36.481 --> 01:03:46.608
<v Unidentified speaker>Instead, the only engagement we've seen came from the proponents of this ban targeting our restaurant, St. Jack, reserving a table, waiting for the dining room to fill, and then standing up to shout invectives at staff and guests.

677
01:03:47.561 --> 01:03:48.856
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not public process.

678
01:03:49.519 --> 01:03:50.295
<v Unidentified speaker>That's intimidation.

679
01:03:51.541 --> 01:03:54.438
<v Unidentified speaker>And it filled the vacuum left by a complete absence of leadership.

680
01:03:54.518 --> 01:03:56.969
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember let's be clear about what's happening here.

681
01:03:58.931 --> 01:04:14.086
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm going to run out of time, but I'll just say that it's deplorable how this has come to a vote without engaging an industry like ours that has done more for the city's reputation and tourism than any other industry by tenfold.

682
01:04:15.175 --> 01:04:16.148
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's just regrettable.

683
01:04:17.668 --> 01:04:18.132
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

684
01:04:18.878 --> 01:04:19.474
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you all.

685
01:04:21.731 --> 01:04:22.965
<v Unidentified speaker>Brave is joining us online.

686
01:04:29.043 --> 01:04:31.478
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, Council.

687
01:04:32.025 --> 01:04:32.717
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Brave.

688
01:04:33.219 --> 01:04:52.507
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm from District 3, and Portland's future is of compassion and justice, and this foie gras ban would further represent what we all would want to see in our world, and I greatly support those ban.

689
01:04:53.056 --> 01:04:53.394
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

690
01:04:55.719 --> 01:04:56.253
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

691
01:04:57.822 --> 01:05:08.860
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Adriana Voss-Andrie, Annalise Day, Nicole Corrado, Juliet Dunn, Naomi McKusick.

692
01:05:13.411 --> 01:05:14.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome folks, come on up.

693
01:05:15.456 --> 01:05:16.592
<v Unidentified speaker>Introduce yourself for the record.

694
01:05:16.675 --> 01:05:18.445
<v Unidentified speaker>Feel free to share your pronouns and you have 90 seconds.

695
01:05:23.179 --> 01:05:24.641
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Juliet Dunn.

696
01:05:24.900 --> 01:05:28.621
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm from District 4 and I am supporting the foie gras ban.

697
01:05:29.500 --> 01:05:34.844
<v Unidentified speaker>When I have had personal exchange— I have had a personal exchange with a chef who formerly served foie gras.

698
01:05:35.038 --> 01:05:40.643
<v Unidentified speaker>I have also had conversations with other ones and I find that what they believe believe in private is very different from what they say in public.

699
01:05:41.204 --> 01:05:54.867
<v Unidentified speaker>I had a conversation with the chef who sent me footage of LaBelle, and when I pointed out the very clear welfare issues, he said he agrees, but unfortunately, due to the nature of force-feeding, there can't be any higher welfare provided.

700
01:05:55.045 --> 01:05:57.675
<v Unidentified speaker>The ducks have to be confined in pens to force-feed them.

701
01:05:57.786 --> 01:05:58.460
<v Unidentified speaker>They will never swim.

702
01:05:59.150 --> 01:06:00.079
<v Unidentified speaker>That's just how it is.

703
01:06:00.257 --> 01:06:11.125
<v Unidentified speaker>And I would say that that is proof enough that if best of the industry cannot provide a semblance of a happy life for these animals, then why should it exist?

704
01:06:11.286 --> 01:06:11.916
<v Keelan McClymont>Ban foie gras.

705
01:06:12.271 --> 01:06:12.802
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

706
01:06:13.239 --> 01:06:13.922
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

707
01:06:16.202 --> 01:06:17.664
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Naomi McKusick.

708
01:06:17.793 --> 01:06:24.304
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a resident of District 4, and I fully support this ban, and I'm going to share a little personal story with you.

709
01:06:24.929 --> 01:06:34.500
<v Unidentified speaker>So I recently lost my aunt to a very long battle with breast cancer, and during the end of her life, Her tumors metastasized and spread to her liver, which caused it to massively expand.

710
01:06:34.949 --> 01:06:37.213
<v Unidentified speaker>I witnessed firsthand how much torture this was to her.

711
01:06:37.277 --> 01:06:40.007
<v Unidentified speaker>She was constantly bloated, she could barely move, and she had no appetite.

712
01:06:40.489 --> 01:06:44.264
<v Unidentified speaker>And because of this, she had to be forcefully tube-fed, which she did not want.

713
01:06:44.891 --> 01:06:48.199
<v Unidentified speaker>And it was one of the biggest factors in making the end of her life so miserable.

714
01:06:48.583 --> 01:06:53.514
<v Unidentified speaker>Now I want you to imagine that, but without the freedom and familial support a cancer patient receives.

715
01:06:53.804 --> 01:06:56.695
<v Unidentified speaker>This is what happens to thousands of ducks daily in the foie gras industry.

716
01:06:56.742 --> 01:06:56.855
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

717
01:06:57.351 --> 01:07:02.128
<v Unidentified speaker>Ducks are deeply intelligent creatures and they experience and conceptualize pain just like us.

718
01:07:02.641 --> 01:07:08.780
<v Unidentified speaker>Banning foie gras in Portland ensures that another chunk can be taken out of an industry that tortures these beautiful birds.

719
01:07:09.134 --> 01:07:10.063
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's why I support this ban.

720
01:07:10.239 --> 01:07:10.431
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

721
01:07:10.800 --> 01:07:11.777
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

722
01:07:13.204 --> 01:07:15.369
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Adriana Vos-Andre.

723
01:07:15.465 --> 01:07:21.331
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a voter in District 3 and also have a small business in District 4.

724
01:07:22.342 --> 01:07:38.188
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to express That I urge you to listen to your constituents, listen to the preponderance of people who are constituents, not only who showed up today, but also who represented in the poll.

725
01:07:39.199 --> 01:07:43.731
<v Unidentified speaker>And we know the vast majority of your constituents want this ban to happen.

726
01:07:43.778 --> 01:07:44.947
<v Unidentified speaker>So I urge you to vote yes.

727
01:07:45.405 --> 01:07:45.748
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

728
01:07:46.206 --> 01:07:46.811
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

729
01:07:50.074 --> 01:07:50.400
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

730
01:07:51.070 --> 01:07:52.474
<v Unidentified speaker>Calling Annalise Day.

731
01:07:53.447 --> 01:07:54.320
<v Unidentified speaker>Nicole Corrado.

732
01:07:58.920 --> 01:08:00.244
<v Unidentified speaker>Hillary Tifer.

733
01:08:01.809 --> 01:08:02.507
<v Unidentified speaker>Gabriel Rucker.

734
01:08:03.788 --> 01:08:04.697
<v Unidentified speaker>Sean Rice.

735
01:08:06.447 --> 01:08:07.291
<v Unidentified speaker>Connor Rucker.

736
01:08:09.286 --> 01:08:13.016
<v Unidentified speaker>Alderman Ordel.

737
01:08:13.356 --> 01:08:14.686
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome, folks.

738
01:08:14.882 --> 01:08:15.465
<v Unidentified speaker>Come on up.

739
01:08:16.113 --> 01:08:17.185
<v Unidentified speaker>Introduce yourself for the record.

740
01:08:19.487 --> 01:08:20.454
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, I'm Gabriel Rucker.

741
01:08:20.536 --> 01:08:22.779
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the chef-owner of Le Pigeon here in Portland, Oregon.

742
01:08:24.408 --> 01:08:25.087
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for my time.

743
01:08:25.716 --> 01:08:28.524
<v Unidentified speaker>When I think of Portland, I don't think of it as my city.

744
01:08:29.015 --> 01:08:30.001
<v Unidentified speaker>I think of it as our city.

745
01:08:30.645 --> 01:08:38.019
<v Unidentified speaker>When I think about Portland, I don't think about what's wrong with it, but I think about what is right with it and what do we have going for ourselves.

746
01:08:38.068 --> 01:08:38.729
<v Unidentified speaker>How can we be better?

747
01:08:39.375 --> 01:08:43.020
<v Unidentified speaker>Our restaurants are the lifeblood of the city, the city that makes the heart beat.

748
01:08:43.471 --> 01:08:44.957
<v Unidentified speaker>When people are in need, we feed them.

749
01:08:45.472 --> 01:08:46.586
<v Unidentified speaker>We organize fundraisers.

750
01:08:46.859 --> 01:08:48.006
<v Unidentified speaker>When our schools can't get enough funding, we donate our own funds.

751
01:08:48.069 --> 01:08:48.135
<v Unidentified speaker>Order.

752
01:08:50.101 --> 01:08:51.865
<v Unidentified speaker>Funds that we barely have any excess of.

753
01:08:52.653 --> 01:08:53.743
<v Unidentified speaker>People come to Portland to eat.

754
01:08:54.015 --> 01:08:55.251
<v Unidentified speaker>People come for our restaurants.

755
01:08:55.555 --> 01:08:57.497
<v Unidentified speaker>They spend money on shopping, hotels.

756
01:08:57.962 --> 01:08:59.534
<v Unidentified speaker>They come for my foie gras profiteroles.

757
01:09:00.192 --> 01:09:05.229
<v Unidentified speaker>I can't think of any time that someone has not come to visit Portland because a restaurant serves foie gras.

758
01:09:05.984 --> 01:09:12.256
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that we are missing the forest for the trees here, and that going after us and the farms that produce foie gras is performative at best.

759
01:09:12.480 --> 01:09:14.838
<v Unidentified speaker>It doesn't tackle the real issues around food that we face.

760
01:09:15.770 --> 01:09:19.747
<v Unidentified speaker>I also think that we all share a lot more in common in this room than we have differences.

761
01:09:20.806 --> 01:09:24.162
<v Unidentified speaker>We want what is good for our city, the people that live here, and the planet.

762
01:09:25.078 --> 01:09:32.671
<v Unidentified speaker>I propose that instead of making laws that tell people what they can eat, we put our differences aside and figure out how to educate people on what is good to eat for their health and for our Mother Earth.

763
01:09:33.185 --> 01:09:35.755
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's not just be the city that works, but the city that works together.

764
01:09:35.996 --> 01:09:36.413
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's pay—.

765
01:09:36.542 --> 01:09:43.800
<v Unidentified speaker>Make Portland look good, because when you're in the news for making it legal to smoke crack on our sidewalks, you might want to think twice about making duck liver illegal.

766
01:09:43.944 --> 01:09:45.372
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

767
01:09:46.176 --> 01:09:47.123
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

768
01:09:48.583 --> 01:09:49.676
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Hannah Rucker.

769
01:09:50.269 --> 01:09:51.296
<v Unidentified speaker>I oppose this ban.

770
01:09:51.793 --> 01:09:57.363
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that Pro-Animal Oregon doesn't represent the majority of Portland.

771
01:09:57.492 --> 01:10:02.435
<v Unidentified speaker>They're just the loudest, and they're going after low-hanging fruit in order to gain attention.

772
01:10:03.204 --> 01:10:09.432
<v Unidentified speaker>They're choosing the easiest route, and that choice will affect independently owned businesses that are a vibrant part of the Portland community.

773
01:10:10.427 --> 01:10:16.416
<v Unidentified speaker>Food tourism is a balance to the rampant drug use happening on our streets, lack of school funding, and houseless crisis.

774
01:10:17.091 --> 01:10:25.488
<v Unidentified speaker>Everybody that's an adult has a choice of what they want to eat, and there's lots of restaurants for people to eat in that offer a variety of different foods.

775
01:10:26.097 --> 01:10:36.375
<v Unidentified speaker>The people that don't have a choice on what they eat are the students in the Portland Public School System, and I just want to read a little bit of the menu that we're serving them.

776
01:10:37.242 --> 01:10:38.140
<v Unidentified speaker>For lunch every day?

777
01:10:38.685 --> 01:10:47.617
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, first breakfast: Cinnamon Toast Crunch, vanilla cream breadsticks, French toast sticks, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Liege waffle, apple cinnamon muffin, mini pancakes.

778
01:10:48.065 --> 01:11:02.145
<v Unidentified speaker>For lunch, we have crackers and chicken jerky, we have chicken fried waffles, we have— I just want to say that this chicken is coming from Goldkist Farms, which is a huge production farm.

779
01:11:02.417 --> 01:11:09.293
<v Unidentified speaker>They kill 8 million chickens a day and serve them to our children in the public school systems, which desperately need funding.

780
01:11:09.405 --> 01:11:12.990
<v Unidentified speaker>And we are sitting here wasting taxpayers' time and money.

781
01:11:13.893 --> 01:11:25.300
<v Unidentified speaker>And I don't think that pro-animal Oregon should be involved in the government decisions of what's happening for independent businesses that pay taxes and contribute to the community that we live in.

782
01:11:26.993 --> 01:11:27.680
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

783
01:11:29.530 --> 01:11:30.890
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Aldrin Ordell.

784
01:11:31.021 --> 01:11:39.012
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm from Northwest I'm a small business owner, and I support this ban on foie gras because consumer choice should not dictate public policy.

785
01:11:39.595 --> 01:11:44.841
<v Unidentified speaker>Law, legal precedent, and the morals and ethics of your constituents should be primary concerns.

786
01:11:45.019 --> 01:11:45.359
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

787
01:11:46.153 --> 01:11:46.752
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

788
01:11:49.256 --> 01:11:55.828
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, I'm Sean Rice, District 3 voter resident, and, uh, I support this ban.

789
01:11:55.957 --> 01:11:58.051
<v Unidentified speaker>I hope that you do too because it's pretty simple.

790
01:11:59.335 --> 01:11:59.935
<v Unidentified speaker>Go Ducks!

791
01:12:01.182 --> 01:12:03.599
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

792
01:12:06.943 --> 01:12:10.832
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Hillary Tifer.

793
01:12:15.480 --> 01:12:28.828
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up we have Sophie Surlick-Rittenbaum, Ashley Hall, Rox Zeta, Matt Hall, Welcome, folks.

794
01:12:29.105 --> 01:12:29.612
<v Unidentified speaker>Come on up.

795
01:12:32.260 --> 01:12:33.163
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, Council.

796
01:12:33.421 --> 01:12:34.341
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Rox Zada.

797
01:12:34.390 --> 01:12:36.408
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a District 4 resident.

798
01:12:37.216 --> 01:12:42.533
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to support the foie gras ban, but I also want to recognize Councilor Green's work.

799
01:12:43.684 --> 01:13:02.302
<v Unidentified speaker>It is varied, and, um, from his ban on predatory AI rent-setting algorithms and the resolution to investigate Zenith Energy To his amazing program, Keep Portland Housed, which has helped thousands of down-on-the-luck Portlanders avoid eviction and stay in their homes.

800
01:13:03.762 --> 01:13:06.988
<v Unidentified speaker>This work is already happening, it's ongoing, and it's making a big difference.

801
01:13:08.030 --> 01:13:11.015
<v Unidentified speaker>And at the same time, we have a clear decision in front of us here today.

802
01:13:11.784 --> 01:13:15.619
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras production involves force-feeding animals in a way that causes severe suffering.

803
01:13:16.293 --> 01:13:18.893
<v Unidentified speaker>This policy addresses our support of that directly.

804
01:13:18.940 --> 01:13:19.037
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

805
01:13:19.956 --> 01:13:21.828
<v Unidentified speaker>For me, these aren't separate conversations.

806
01:13:21.894 --> 01:13:28.484
<v Unidentified speaker>They come from the same place— reducing harm where we can and making thoughtful choices about what we allow in our city.

807
01:13:28.970 --> 01:13:29.411
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

808
01:13:30.148 --> 01:13:30.966
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

809
01:13:34.500 --> 01:13:35.310
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Matt Hall.

810
01:13:36.118 --> 01:13:38.742
<v Unidentified speaker>I am in District 4 and a voter, and I oppose this ban.

811
01:13:39.818 --> 01:13:46.627
<v Unidentified speaker>I feel based on the numbers, you know, to conflate factory farms, which I think everyone agrees with is a bad thing—.

812
01:13:46.659 --> 01:13:59.734
<v Unidentified speaker>Over 9 billion chickens are killed a year in the United States for food Food processing, foie gras production makes up roughly 0.0005% of all animals that are killed for food.

813
01:14:00.136 --> 01:14:08.469
<v Unidentified speaker>I feel that the city owes it to its residents as adults, as people that can make our own decisions, to choose what we are okay and not okay with.

814
01:14:08.869 --> 01:14:22.283
<v Unidentified speaker>And I find it particularly rich coming from the city saying we know things are bad and we shouldn't do it when the 3rd largest revenue-producing thing we have in our state is video lottery, an addictive thing that we all willingly sell, willingly go with.

815
01:14:22.331 --> 01:14:38.091
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember and are okay with because it inflates our pockets, not the pockets of small business owners, not the pockets of people that come in here for tourism, not the people that employ hundreds of employees in the food restaurant paying taxes, paying a living wage to their employees and taking care of them.

816
01:14:38.220 --> 01:14:39.021
<v Unidentified speaker>We are all adults.

817
01:14:39.103 --> 01:14:40.242
<v Unidentified speaker>We can all make our own decision.

818
01:14:40.305 --> 01:14:43.435
<v Unidentified speaker>If you don't like it, I agree with your decision 1 million percent.

819
01:14:43.500 --> 01:14:44.399
<v Unidentified speaker>You are entitled to it.

820
01:14:44.720 --> 01:14:46.356
<v Unidentified speaker>However, my stomach, my choice.

821
01:14:46.725 --> 01:14:47.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

822
01:14:47.833 --> 01:14:48.314
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

823
01:14:49.242 --> 01:14:53.640
<v Unidentified speaker>Ashley Hall, District 4 voter.

824
01:14:54.030 --> 01:14:55.460
<v Unidentified speaker>I am against the ban.

825
01:14:57.015 --> 01:15:05.028
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe that the heart of our city is in our restaurants and our culinary, what we've done.

826
01:15:05.140 --> 01:15:13.681
<v Unidentified speaker>Restaurants like Le Pigeon have been around for almost 20 years, and they are institutions by the awards they've won, putting Portland on the map.

827
01:15:13.783 --> 01:15:29.770
<v Unidentified speaker>And the fact that we would want to harm businesses that are not moving out of Multnomah County but staying here when we have a 32% commercial issue with, um, vacancy in our city, I think is just— this is not where we need to put our time and our efforts.

828
01:15:30.395 --> 01:15:32.547
<v Unidentified speaker>You can choose to eat if you want to with your pocketbook.

829
01:15:32.724 --> 01:15:33.815
<v Unidentified speaker>Let that be how it goes.

830
01:15:33.912 --> 01:15:36.145
<v Unidentified speaker>But we should not be the ones telling anyone.

831
01:15:36.497 --> 01:15:37.493
<v Unidentified speaker>It is our choice.

832
01:15:38.167 --> 01:15:38.472
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

833
01:15:39.307 --> 01:15:39.837
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

834
01:15:41.787 --> 01:15:45.560
<v Unidentified speaker>John Vandenberg, and I've worked in the city for 37 years.

835
01:15:45.818 --> 01:15:51.122
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd say our firm's probably brought in hundreds of millions of dollars over our time in the city.

836
01:15:51.380 --> 01:15:56.359
<v Unidentified speaker>I support this ordinance, and I thank all of you for your service and for your empathy.

837
01:15:58.039 --> 01:15:58.710
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

838
01:16:00.677 --> 01:16:02.546
<v Unidentified speaker>Hillary is joining us online.

839
01:16:12.386 --> 01:16:15.246
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, let's move to Sophie and we'll check on Hillary.

840
01:16:15.519 --> 01:16:16.081
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead, Sophie.

841
01:16:16.948 --> 01:16:18.971
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Sophie Chirlik-Rittenbaum.

842
01:16:19.115 --> 01:16:23.436
<v Unidentified speaker>I use she/her/they pronouns and I'm here to testify in support of the ban.

843
01:16:24.176 --> 01:16:31.708
<v Unidentified speaker>I will try and keep this short because I have seen so many written comments online about how this is a waste of council's time and they could be focusing on more important things.

844
01:16:32.380 --> 01:16:40.771
<v Unidentified speaker>And yet some of those people also chose to show up here today, and I assume are also waiting to testify to take more of council time to tell you off for using council time to pass this.

845
01:16:42.525 --> 01:16:47.556
<v Unidentified speaker>I have seen the sponsor of this bill say that we can walk and chew gum at the same time, and I couldn't agree more.

846
01:16:48.070 --> 01:16:51.998
<v Unidentified speaker>As others have pointed out, he's already sponsored legislation around surrounding housing and our economy.

847
01:16:52.355 --> 01:16:57.125
<v Unidentified speaker>This clearly isn't taking some huge chunk of council time away from issues that we might think are more important.

848
01:16:57.895 --> 01:16:58.970
<v Unidentified speaker>It's here in front of us now.

849
01:16:59.451 --> 01:17:00.908
<v Unidentified speaker>It is easy to vote yes on now.

850
01:17:01.582 --> 01:17:03.313
<v Unidentified speaker>There is no reason not to at this point.

851
01:17:04.065 --> 01:17:04.850
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras is cruel.

852
01:17:05.203 --> 01:17:06.662
<v Unidentified speaker>There is no reason to keep using it.

853
01:17:06.949 --> 01:17:10.731
<v Unidentified speaker>As others have pointed out, it is the lowest of the low for animal cruelty.

854
01:17:11.197 --> 01:17:15.636
<v Unidentified speaker>I am also confused by opponents of this ban saying that, well, what about all the other animal cruelty?

855
01:17:16.421 --> 01:17:17.990
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not a reason to not pass this.

856
01:17:18.038 --> 01:17:22.270
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a reason to come back with more legislation later that addresses that animal cruelty.

857
01:17:22.493 --> 01:17:33.860
<v Unidentified speaker>It is not a reason to keep I'm really grateful for the people who brought this forward, both in council and for Pro-Animal Oregon and other sponsors and other organizers who made this happen.

858
01:17:34.443 --> 01:17:36.520
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your time, and I hope you vote yes on this ban.

859
01:17:37.720 --> 01:17:38.377
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

860
01:17:39.659 --> 01:17:49.037
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Ryan Mead, Kimiko Matsuda, Joshua Porter, Ted Baskin, Peter Hurd.

861
01:17:52.197 --> 01:17:53.037
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome, folks.

862
01:17:53.118 --> 01:17:53.793
<v Unidentified speaker>Come on down.

863
01:17:57.800 --> 01:17:59.577
<v Unidentified speaker>You're welcome to go first since you're here.

864
01:17:59.931 --> 01:18:00.868
<v Unidentified speaker>Are you Ryan?

865
01:18:01.451 --> 01:18:01.871
<v Unidentified speaker>No, I'm Ted.

866
01:18:02.096 --> 01:18:02.759
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, great.

867
01:18:03.340 --> 01:18:06.036
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, hello, I'm Kimiko Matsuda.

868
01:18:06.505 --> 01:18:19.885
<v Unidentified speaker>I work across Portland small business, culinary, and cultural communities focused on economic recovery, tourism, and long-term investment in this I respect the values behind the proposal.

869
01:18:20.350 --> 01:18:26.208
<v Unidentified speaker>My perspective is less about Mardi Gras and is about stewardship and how we lead in this moment.

870
01:18:27.171 --> 01:18:29.289
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland's recovery remains fragile.

871
01:18:29.643 --> 01:18:33.880
<v Unidentified speaker>Our culinary community is one of our strongest economic and cultural assets.

872
01:18:34.537 --> 01:18:40.636
<v Unidentified speaker>They create jobs, drive tourism, and shape Portland's identity at a national and global level.

873
01:18:41.712 --> 01:18:49.207
<v Unidentified speaker>Support from their perspective is stability, partnership, and meaningful engagement in decisions that affect their industry.

874
01:18:50.268 --> 01:18:53.462
<v Unidentified speaker>Decisions are not experienced in isolation.

875
01:18:53.798 --> 01:18:55.243
<v Unidentified speaker>They accumulate over time.

876
01:18:55.981 --> 01:19:04.394
<v Unidentified speaker>They shape how it feels to operate a business in Portland and whether people choose to invest, expand, or build here in the future.

877
01:19:05.613 --> 01:19:08.166
<v Unidentified speaker>There is a real risk of investment fatigue.

878
01:19:08.807 --> 01:19:20.313
<v Unidentified speaker>The people driving this city's recovery have continued to show up and reinvest, and we want to make sure that we do not impact that erosion or momentum.

879
01:19:21.007 --> 01:19:22.569
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a moment that calls for discipline.

880
01:19:23.114 --> 01:19:26.954
<v Unidentified speaker>Our policies should strengthen, not strain, the people building the future.

881
01:19:27.582 --> 01:19:29.557
<v Unidentified speaker>I ask you to vote no on this ban.

882
01:19:29.926 --> 01:19:30.248
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

883
01:19:30.795 --> 01:19:31.367
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

884
01:19:33.846 --> 01:19:34.368
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Ted.

885
01:19:34.661 --> 01:19:37.658
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 3, and I support the ban on foie gras.

886
01:19:39.060 --> 01:19:39.751
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

887
01:19:42.659 --> 01:19:47.091
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Josh Porter, District 4, Navy vet, PSU student.

888
01:19:47.994 --> 01:19:57.274
<v Unidentified speaker>While some argue that we should focus on the broader issues of factory farming, which is awesome, we shouldn't let the pursuit of a perfect solution stop us from taking meaningful action now.

889
01:19:58.195 --> 01:20:01.689
<v Unidentified speaker>Force feeding causes undeniable suffering, and the city has the power to end it today.

890
01:20:02.359 --> 01:20:03.158
<v Unidentified speaker>So please vote aye.

891
01:20:04.023 --> 01:20:09.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

892
01:20:11.125 --> 01:20:12.335
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Peter Hurd.

893
01:20:12.560 --> 01:20:13.917
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a District 2 voter.

894
01:20:14.840 --> 01:20:21.836
<v Unidentified speaker>We have heard from restaurants in the area who are concerned at how this will affect them, the handful of restaurants that actually do serve foie gras.

895
01:20:22.497 --> 01:20:28.623
<v Unidentified speaker>I say that we help them out by giving everyone an equal footing under this regulation.

896
01:20:29.380 --> 01:20:33.686
<v Unidentified speaker>By enacting a restaurant ban on serving foie gras.

897
01:20:33.784 --> 01:20:34.141
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

898
01:20:35.101 --> 01:20:35.913
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

899
01:20:37.279 --> 01:20:38.425
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Ryan Mead.

900
01:20:38.667 --> 01:20:40.894
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to discuss the proposed ban on foie gras.

901
01:20:40.942 --> 01:20:45.426
<v Unidentified speaker>Obviously, I spent over 20 years working with the restaurant industry here in Portland.

902
01:20:45.702 --> 01:20:47.233
<v Unidentified speaker>I've dedicated my career to it.

903
01:20:48.020 --> 01:20:53.756
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not just here as an individual, but someone who has worked alongside chefs and restaurants.

904
01:20:55.170 --> 01:20:56.502
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to start with a simple idea.

905
01:20:56.882 --> 01:20:58.144
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's consumer free choice.

906
01:20:59.047 --> 01:21:06.046
<v Unidentified speaker>At its core, that means adults have the right to eat where they would like to eat, buy what they want to buy, and decide where they'd like to spend their money.

907
01:21:06.789 --> 01:21:08.067
<v Unidentified speaker>You don't have to like foie gras.

908
01:21:08.326 --> 01:21:09.555
<v Unidentified speaker>You don't have to agree with it.

909
01:21:09.958 --> 01:21:10.814
<v Unidentified speaker>You don't have to order it.

910
01:21:11.710 --> 01:21:17.823
<v Unidentified speaker>But the choice to do so should remain at the individual level, and that idea is tied directly to a free market.

911
01:21:18.341 --> 01:21:23.164
<v Unidentified speaker>And a free market works because it lets consumers decide what succeeds and what doesn't.

912
01:21:24.171 --> 01:21:29.034
<v Unidentified speaker>If people don't want to eat foie gras, they don't have to order it, and restaurants will stop serving it.

913
01:21:30.855 --> 01:21:31.983
<v Unidentified speaker>And that brings me to restaurants.

914
01:21:32.320 --> 01:21:35.880
<v Unidentified speaker>Small independent restaurants in Portland are already under immense pressure.

915
01:21:36.426 --> 01:21:41.875
<v Unidentified speaker>Rising costs, increased regulation, and declining traffic have made it harder than ever to survive.

916
01:21:42.618 --> 01:21:46.850
<v Unidentified speaker>Adding yet another restriction doesn't just limit a single ingredient, it limits creativity.

917
01:21:47.706 --> 01:21:48.675
<v Unidentified speaker>My argument is simple.

918
01:21:49.122 --> 01:21:53.502
<v Unidentified speaker>Whether you personally agree with, agree with FOIA or not, this is about where we draw the line.

919
01:21:54.095 --> 01:22:00.704
<v Unidentified speaker>Local government stepping in to dictate what restaurants can and cannot serve is a precedent that everyone in this room should be concerned about.

920
01:22:01.073 --> 01:22:05.020
<v Unidentified speaker>At the end of the day, this doesn't stop consumption, it pushes it somewhere else.

921
01:22:06.512 --> 01:22:12.448
<v Unidentified speaker>Let chefs create, let restaurants cook, let consumers choose, and let the market decide.

922
01:22:12.784 --> 01:22:13.185
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

923
01:22:13.747 --> 01:22:14.597
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

924
01:22:14.711 --> 01:22:15.015
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you all.

925
01:22:15.079 --> 01:22:15.701
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks for being here.

926
01:22:18.898 --> 01:22:29.868
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, next up we have Stephen Freitag, Olga Ilyuk, Tien Tran, Jessica Lang, Molly Flanagan.

927
01:22:32.944 --> 01:22:33.780
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome, folks.

928
01:22:40.390 --> 01:22:41.487
<v Unidentified speaker>Whoever wants to go first.

929
01:22:41.635 --> 01:22:51.789
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, hi, I'm Jessica Lang, a constituent of District 2, and I support the ban on Thank you very much.

930
01:22:53.173 --> 01:22:54.444
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Tien Tran.

931
01:22:54.622 --> 01:22:55.813
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm from District 1.

932
01:22:56.311 --> 01:22:57.326
<v Unidentified speaker>I support this ban.

933
01:22:57.695 --> 01:22:58.002
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

934
01:22:58.904 --> 01:22:59.371
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

935
01:23:00.675 --> 01:23:02.011
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, good afternoon, Council.

936
01:23:02.445 --> 01:23:03.878
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Olga Ilyuk.

937
01:23:04.119 --> 01:23:07.969
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 1 in Portland, and I support the foie gras ban.

938
01:23:09.273 --> 01:23:23.269
<v Unidentified speaker>I wanted to just say that there has been a discussion— multiple people mentioned that, um, We should be talking about animals that are being mistreated on the larger scale, such as chickens, for example.

939
01:23:23.429 --> 01:23:29.295
<v Unidentified speaker>And I agree that those are important issues, and there definitely should be discussion about this.

940
01:23:29.375 --> 01:23:46.572
<v Unidentified speaker>However, today what we have in front of us, it is a very specific and focused policy, the policy about foie gras production that involves mistreatment of animals, force-feeding of animals that causes extreme And well-documented suffering.

941
01:23:47.470 --> 01:23:52.837
<v Unidentified speaker>And it is a distinct practice that the city does have the authority to regulate.

942
01:23:53.720 --> 01:24:04.600
<v Unidentified speaker>And if we wait until we can address all the issues with farmed animals all at once, we will never be able to move forward and take any steps forward.

943
01:24:05.337 --> 01:24:13.350
<v Unidentified speaker>So right now we are in this place where the harm is clear, the policy is focused, and the city has the ability to act.

944
01:24:14.023 --> 01:24:22.301
<v Unidentified speaker>So we can have larger conversations about farmed animals and our food systems, and we also can make this decision today.

945
01:24:22.979 --> 01:24:25.167
<v Unidentified speaker>So I urge you to support this foie gras ban.

946
01:24:25.626 --> 01:24:25.920
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

947
01:24:26.426 --> 01:24:27.095
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

948
01:24:28.595 --> 01:24:31.333
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Stephen Freitag, District 4, and I support the ban.

949
01:24:32.095 --> 01:24:33.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much, guys.

950
01:24:35.720 --> 01:24:38.576
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Molly Flanagan, District 3, and I support this ban.

951
01:24:38.689 --> 01:24:40.078
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much for hearing us.

952
01:24:40.470 --> 01:24:41.073
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

953
01:24:44.603 --> 01:24:58.586
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up we have Kelsey Glasser, York Hayes, Valerie Tabita, Amina Butterfly, Heather Robertson.

954
01:24:58.926 --> 01:24:59.993
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome, come on down.

955
01:25:00.140 --> 01:25:00.479
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

956
01:25:01.599 --> 01:25:03.028
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, my name is Kelsey Glasser.

957
01:25:03.189 --> 01:25:05.983
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm an independent restaurant owner and I oppose this motion.

958
01:25:06.583 --> 01:25:09.412
<v Unidentified speaker>Caring about animal welfare is something I take very seriously.

959
01:25:09.989 --> 01:25:14.800
<v Unidentified speaker>I myself grew up on a farm in the Willamette Valley and have seen firsthand what ethical farming should look like.

960
01:25:15.377 --> 01:25:19.434
<v Unidentified speaker>Restaurants like mine don't source from factory-farmed industrial meat systems.

961
01:25:19.867 --> 01:25:26.328
<v Unidentified speaker>We work with small farmers because we know this choice is better for our planet, our guests, and most importantly, the animals themselves.

962
01:25:27.065 --> 01:25:29.182
<v Unidentified speaker>That's why this proposal feels so misdirected.

963
01:25:29.728 --> 01:25:42.412
<v Unidentified speaker>I know it comes from a place of concern for animal welfare, but focusing on one highly visible ingredient raised on a very small scale while overlooking the much larger impacts of industrial agriculture does not create meaningful change.

964
01:25:42.957 --> 01:25:54.715
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras production is extremely limited in the U.S., and by contrast, conventional poultry production slaughters over 9 billion chickens each year, where animals have markedly worse living conditions and shorter lifespan.

965
01:25:55.613 --> 01:25:59.686
<v Unidentified speaker>If the goal is to reduce harm, industrial factory farming is where the true issue lies.

966
01:26:00.199 --> 01:26:07.452
<v Unidentified speaker>Instead, this policy places additional pressure on small businesses like mine trying to operate thoughtfully and keep the lights on.

967
01:26:07.981 --> 01:26:13.326
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland's economy still has not recovered, and we are navigating rising costs and ongoing challenges.

968
01:26:13.984 --> 01:26:21.126
<v Unidentified speaker>Now it feels like our character is being questioned by a city government that claims it wants to support small business but has not consistently backed those claims up.

969
01:26:21.783 --> 01:26:29.006
<v Unidentified speaker>If we truly want to move the needle, we should focus our energy on the systems that have the greatest impact and the policies that could actually make a difference.

970
01:26:29.247 --> 01:26:29.648
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

971
01:26:30.194 --> 01:26:34.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very Good afternoon, council members.

972
01:26:34.921 --> 01:26:35.707
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is York Hayes.

973
01:26:35.994 --> 01:26:38.158
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a business owner, a resident of District 4.

974
01:26:39.103 --> 01:26:40.353
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to support the ban.

975
01:26:40.609 --> 01:26:45.304
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to speak briefly about the idea we've heard a ton today about, uh, taking away personal choice.

976
01:26:46.394 --> 01:26:50.127
<v Unidentified speaker>Cities make decisions all the time about what can and cannot be sold in the marketplace.

977
01:26:50.319 --> 01:26:56.728
<v Unidentified speaker>That's part of how we set standards, whether it's for safety, for health, or basic levels of harm that we're willing to accept.

978
01:26:56.792 --> 01:26:58.779
<v Unidentified speaker>This policy operates in that same space.

979
01:26:59.479 --> 01:27:02.564
<v Unidentified speaker>It doesn't tell people what they can eat.

980
01:27:02.791 --> 01:27:09.913
<v Unidentified speaker>It, it has the city determine what is allowed to be sold based on those standards.

981
01:27:10.011 --> 01:27:13.021
<v Unidentified speaker>Passing this ban is a decision about standards, not personal diets.

982
01:27:13.248 --> 01:27:14.201
<v Unidentified speaker>People still have choices.

983
01:27:14.715 --> 01:27:19.006
<v Unidentified speaker>What changes is that our marketplace reflects a baseline that excludes this level of harm.

984
01:27:19.215 --> 01:27:22.349
<v Unidentified speaker>For me, that's a reasonable and appropriate role for the local government.

985
01:27:22.590 --> 01:27:23.324
<v Unidentified speaker>Please vote yes.

986
01:27:24.164 --> 01:27:24.551
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

987
01:27:26.532 --> 01:27:27.479
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, Council.

988
01:27:27.671 --> 01:27:30.417
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Valerie Tabita, and I'm a District 4 resident.

989
01:27:30.867 --> 01:27:43.327
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here in support of the ban on force-fed foie gras, and I also want to recognize the work that Councilor Mitch Green has been doing on the transportation utility fee, which is looking at how we create stable, reliable funding for our streets and transportation system.

990
01:27:43.792 --> 01:27:52.832
<v Unidentified speaker>This is the kind of policy that affects daily life, whether people can get to work safely, whether streets are maintained, whether our system is actually sustainable long-term.

991
01:27:53.282 --> 01:28:08.386
<v Unidentified speaker>And I believe that supporting this ban on force-fed foie gras takes This is something small and easy that we can get past that will give people something to feel good about while the city continues to work on much bigger priorities.

992
01:28:08.820 --> 01:28:11.600
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think this ordinance aligns with Portland's values.

993
01:28:11.777 --> 01:28:14.957
<v Unidentified speaker>I strongly urge members of the council to vote yes on the ban of force-fed foie gras.

994
01:28:15.167 --> 01:28:15.472
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

995
01:28:15.954 --> 01:28:16.529
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

996
01:28:18.720 --> 01:28:20.425
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Heather Robertson from District 1.

997
01:28:21.350 --> 01:28:23.882
<v Unidentified speaker>Force-fed foie gras is an inhumane practice, and I support a ban.

998
01:28:23.931 --> 01:28:24.078
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

999
01:28:25.101 --> 01:28:26.266
<v Unidentified speaker>Awesome, thank you very much.

1000
01:28:29.199 --> 01:28:30.122
<v Unidentified speaker>Amina.

1001
01:28:31.091 --> 01:28:32.386
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Amina Butterfly.

1002
01:28:32.547 --> 01:28:33.729
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 1.

1003
01:28:34.085 --> 01:28:39.475
<v Unidentified speaker>Pleasure and business should not, um, come at the cost of exploitation of those who cannot defend themselves.

1004
01:28:40.140 --> 01:28:40.771
<v Unidentified speaker>Please vote yes.

1005
01:28:42.764 --> 01:28:43.417
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1006
01:28:48.416 --> 01:28:50.496
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up we have Amy Meyer.

1007
01:28:51.337 --> 01:29:05.439
<v Unidentified speaker>Cheyenne Hollowell, Joby Bailey, Beth Redwood, Danny Rookin.

1008
01:29:07.220 --> 01:29:11.738
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome.

1009
01:29:12.336 --> 01:29:16.306
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Cheyenne, and I'm here to voice my support for the ban on FALCRA.

1010
01:29:17.444 --> 01:29:18.052
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1011
01:29:19.127 --> 01:29:23.778
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Joby Bailey, and I am in opposition of the ban on foie gras.

1012
01:29:24.179 --> 01:29:28.509
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a longtime resident of the Portland area and a 25-year veteran of our local restaurant industry.

1013
01:29:29.069 --> 01:29:33.207
<v Unidentified speaker>I've had the privilege of watching Portland grow into one of the most celebrated food cities in the country.

1014
01:29:33.865 --> 01:29:42.429
<v Unidentified speaker>I've also seen how difficult it has been for our industry to recover from the pandemic, especially as our city continues to work through broader economic and reputational challenges.

1015
01:29:43.505 --> 01:29:48.931
<v Unidentified speaker>While this proposal directly impacts restaurants, I believe the broader issue before you is one of personal choice.

1016
01:29:49.671 --> 01:30:00.140
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland has long prided itself on being a place where individuals are trusted to make their own decisions, where diversity is— diversity of thought, lifestyle, and expression are not only accepted but protected.

1017
01:30:00.203 --> 01:30:02.740
<v Unidentified speaker>That principle extends beyond social identity.

1018
01:30:03.270 --> 01:30:07.958
<v Unidentified speaker>It applies to everyday decisions, including the people that choose to eat or what people choose to eat.

1019
01:30:08.729 --> 01:30:18.422
<v Unidentified speaker>Restricting that choice, particularly when it affects small number of producers and a narrow segment of the dining public, raises important questions about where we draw the line on personal freedoms.

1020
01:30:19.207 --> 01:30:21.259
<v Unidentified speaker>For many of our community, that line matters.

1021
01:30:21.916 --> 01:30:23.903
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd also ask the council to consider our priorities.

1022
01:30:24.720 --> 01:30:34.975
<v Unidentified speaker>Our city is facing significant challenges—budget constraints, public safety concerns, infrastructure needs, and the access—and access to essential services like education and mental health.

1023
01:30:36.365 --> 01:30:44.618
<v Unidentified speaker>At a time when resources are stretched thin, allocating attention and enforcement toward the issue may not reflect the most urgent needs of our residents.

1024
01:30:48.177 --> 01:30:49.533
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1025
01:30:52.118 --> 01:30:53.475
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Danny Ruken.

1026
01:30:53.829 --> 01:30:54.863
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, Council.

1027
01:30:55.671 --> 01:30:59.627
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in Portland District 1, and I'm here to support the foie gras ban.

1028
01:31:00.353 --> 01:31:02.338
<v Unidentified speaker>I've been following the work happening at City Hall.

1029
01:31:02.469 --> 01:31:04.939
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to acknowledge that there's a lot moving forward right now, and I'm very proud of the work that's being done.

1030
01:31:05.355 --> 01:31:17.057
<v Unidentified speaker>Including work led by Councilor Green, programs like Keep Portland Housed, Inner City— Inner East Side for All, and the transportation utility fee and the street damage restoration fee.

1031
01:31:17.137 --> 01:31:17.762
<v Unidentified speaker>They're in process.

1032
01:31:17.939 --> 01:31:18.564
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

1033
01:31:19.078 --> 01:31:20.408
<v Unidentified speaker>That's a lot, and it matters.

1034
01:31:21.065 --> 01:31:25.939
<v Unidentified speaker>As a resident, what I see is a city trying to take care of people in real, tangible ways.

1035
01:31:26.676 --> 01:31:29.128
<v Unidentified speaker>This policy fits into that same pattern.

1036
01:31:29.497 --> 01:31:31.310
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a smaller decision, but it's a councilmember Herbold.

1037
01:31:31.310 --> 01:31:31.310
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

1038
01:31:31.310 --> 01:31:32.770
<v Unidentified speaker>The issue before us is a simple and clear one.

1039
01:31:32.770 --> 01:31:39.180
<v Unidentified speaker>It's about whether we allow a practice that causes extreme animal suffering when we don't have to.

1040
01:31:39.189 --> 01:31:43.109
<v Unidentified speaker>For me, this comes down to what kind of community we are across the board.

1041
01:31:43.590 --> 01:31:49.619
<v Unidentified speaker>While we're doing the work on housing, on infrastructure, on long-term planning, we have an opportunity to reduce harm.

1042
01:31:50.149 --> 01:31:56.060
<v Unidentified speaker>New York City has been the most recent city to finally pass the, uh, a ban on foie gras.

1043
01:31:56.529 --> 01:32:01.176
<v Unidentified speaker>And if they can do it with their nonstop full plate of critical issues, so can we.

1044
01:32:01.354 --> 01:32:02.979
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not a zero-sum game.

1045
01:32:03.350 --> 01:32:04.703
<v Unidentified speaker>We can walk and chew gum.

1046
01:32:04.798 --> 01:32:05.104
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1047
01:32:05.507 --> 01:32:06.377
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1048
01:32:09.827 --> 01:32:10.907
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Amy Meyer.

1049
01:32:11.197 --> 01:32:15.211
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a resident and voter in District 3, and ditto, I support the ban.

1050
01:32:15.501 --> 01:32:15.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1051
01:32:16.757 --> 01:32:17.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1052
01:32:19.882 --> 01:32:20.095
<v Unidentified speaker>Beth.

1053
01:32:22.342 --> 01:32:23.873
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Beth Redwood.

1054
01:32:24.101 --> 01:32:28.465
<v Unidentified speaker>I've lived in District 2 for 12 years, and I support the foie gras ban.

1055
01:32:29.057 --> 01:32:31.382
<v Unidentified speaker>To me, it's simply a matter of conscience.

1056
01:32:31.639 --> 01:32:45.873
<v Unidentified speaker>Do we prioritize the palate pleasure of a few people who could easily choose to eat something else, or the obvious, well-documented pain and torture inflicted on the animals whose enlarged, diseased fatty livers are the product?

1057
01:32:46.595 --> 01:32:57.543
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe in good conscience that when Portlanders have an opportunity to stop supporting egregious suffering and cruelty to living beings, that we will take the ethical, humane stand.

1058
01:32:58.010 --> 01:32:59.664
<v Unidentified speaker>Please support the ban.

1059
01:33:00.260 --> 01:33:00.685
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1060
01:33:01.518 --> 01:33:02.248
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1061
01:33:06.664 --> 01:33:17.216
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, next up we have Linda Liu, Jacqueline Reingens, Ryan Co— oh no, sorry, Ryan already testified.

1062
01:33:19.307 --> 01:33:20.904
<v Unidentified speaker>John Gramstad.

1063
01:33:21.564 --> 01:33:22.435
<v Unidentified speaker>Shannon Leahy.

1064
01:33:34.181 --> 01:33:35.832
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Jacqueline Reingans.

1065
01:33:35.962 --> 01:33:37.079
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in Washington County.

1066
01:33:37.582 --> 01:33:39.427
<v Unidentified speaker>This cruelty is unacceptable.

1067
01:33:39.542 --> 01:33:40.643
<v Unidentified speaker>I support this ban.

1068
01:33:40.820 --> 01:33:41.597
<v Unidentified speaker>Please vote yes.

1069
01:33:43.105 --> 01:33:43.655
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1070
01:33:47.148 --> 01:33:48.987
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, let me make sure we don't have any folks online.

1071
01:33:49.118 --> 01:33:49.873
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, go ahead, Linda.

1072
01:33:51.443 --> 01:33:53.463
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, hello, my name is Linda Liu.

1073
01:33:53.689 --> 01:33:55.404
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a District 4 voter.

1074
01:33:55.953 --> 01:34:00.188
<v Unidentified speaker>I support the ban on force-fed foie gras and beg that you do too.

1075
01:34:00.899 --> 01:34:01.569
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your time.

1076
01:34:02.788 --> 01:34:03.496
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

1077
01:34:06.780 --> 01:34:09.694
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, um, John Gramstad.

1078
01:34:12.822 --> 01:34:13.564
<v Unidentified speaker>Shannon Leahy.

1079
01:34:15.662 --> 01:34:17.243
<v Unidentified speaker>Sean Christine.

1080
01:34:19.180 --> 01:34:20.470
<v Unidentified speaker>Marissa Croes.

1081
01:34:22.425 --> 01:34:23.393
<v Unidentified speaker>Dylan DeLowe.

1082
01:34:25.880 --> 01:34:26.442
<v Unidentified speaker>Hamish Bradley.

1083
01:34:29.270 --> 01:34:30.056
<v Unidentified speaker>Avery Lang.

1084
01:34:35.150 --> 01:34:40.594
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm gonna pause for a minute in case Anybody else here?

1085
01:34:48.659 --> 01:34:48.900
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead.

1086
01:34:49.255 --> 01:34:54.601
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Avery Lang from District 3, and I support the foie gras ban.

1087
01:34:55.359 --> 01:34:55.632
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1088
01:34:56.743 --> 01:34:57.355
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1089
01:35:15.670 --> 01:35:15.831
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome.

1090
01:35:16.090 --> 01:35:17.189
<v Unidentified speaker>Hey there, thanks for being patient.

1091
01:35:17.238 --> 01:35:18.207
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Dylan DeLowe.

1092
01:35:18.676 --> 01:35:27.662
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, I live across the river in Camas, Washington, uh, frequenter of Portland restaurants and someone who earned an agriculture degree here in the state of Oregon.

1093
01:35:28.145 --> 01:35:30.000
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to voice my support for the Flock Rock Band.

1094
01:35:30.570 --> 01:35:31.885
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1095
01:35:32.354 --> 01:35:33.345
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, my name is Hamish.

1096
01:35:33.426 --> 01:35:36.555
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a nursing assistant in District 3, and I support the ban.

1097
01:35:38.229 --> 01:35:39.463
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Sean Christian.

1098
01:35:39.609 --> 01:35:43.005
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a District 3 resident and voter, and I support the Mardi Gras ban.

1099
01:35:43.996 --> 01:35:45.002
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you all so much for being here.

1100
01:35:52.619 --> 01:35:54.012
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't think my video is working.

1101
01:35:54.259 --> 01:35:54.898
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you hear me?

1102
01:35:56.337 --> 01:35:57.957
<v Keelan McClymont>Yep, we can hear you.

1103
01:35:58.519 --> 01:36:00.011
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Marissa Cruz.

1104
01:36:00.108 --> 01:36:01.407
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 3.

1105
01:36:01.712 --> 01:36:05.627
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a chef and local bakery owner here in Portland.

1106
01:36:06.364 --> 01:36:13.328
<v Unidentified speaker>I support this ban because Portland is a city that prides itself on compassion, progress, and supporting our community.

1107
01:36:14.065 --> 01:36:16.376
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't believe foie gras represents these values.

1108
01:36:17.033 --> 01:36:21.172
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe supporting this ban is the right thing to do for people, for animals, and for the planet.

1109
01:36:22.023 --> 01:36:27.524
<v Unidentified speaker>Over 99% of restaurants, chefs, and food shops in the city do not serve or sell foie gras.

1110
01:36:28.180 --> 01:36:29.368
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a reason for that.

1111
01:36:29.944 --> 01:36:38.140
<v Unidentified speaker>If Portland chefs believed in this product and believed the people of Portland wanted to eat it, there would be more than 8 places that currently sell it.

1112
01:36:38.685 --> 01:36:42.085
<v Unidentified speaker>The people and chefs of Portland overwhelmingly do not want foie gras.

1113
01:36:42.774 --> 01:36:50.453
<v Unidentified speaker>A chef here today made the argument at the last hearing that we should be focusing on factory farming and ending that and not foie gras.

1114
01:36:50.791 --> 01:36:54.347
<v Unidentified speaker>And I agree, as a society, factory farming should end.

1115
01:36:55.052 --> 01:37:02.104
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't support factory farming with my dollars, but you don't decide not to change anything because you can't change everything.

1116
01:37:02.569 --> 01:37:08.208
<v Unidentified speaker>Social change is a collection of small acts of individuals, of communities and cities.

1117
01:37:08.354 --> 01:37:13.448
<v Unidentified speaker>And I don't think anyone here today believes that we shouldn't make any changes because we can't change everything.

1118
01:37:14.203 --> 01:37:17.976
<v Unidentified speaker>Or believes that we shouldn't end some harm to animals because we can't end all harm.

1119
01:37:18.636 --> 01:37:20.948
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras will end in this country.

1120
01:37:21.011 --> 01:37:22.039
<v Unidentified speaker>It's just a matter of time.

1121
01:37:22.393 --> 01:37:32.219
<v Unidentified speaker>It's already declining significantly across Europe and the United States, and I hope Portland, city that I love and call home, is on the right side of history today and supports this ban.

1122
01:37:32.524 --> 01:37:33.118
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1123
01:37:33.551 --> 01:37:35.447
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1124
01:37:40.569 --> 01:37:41.349
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead.

1125
01:37:41.479 --> 01:37:42.240
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh no, sorry.

1126
01:37:42.662 --> 01:37:43.537
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Shannon?

1127
01:37:47.381 --> 01:37:49.524
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, yes, my name is Shannon Leahy.

1128
01:37:49.653 --> 01:37:50.796
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a Portland resident.

1129
01:37:50.940 --> 01:37:52.115
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 4.

1130
01:37:53.613 --> 01:37:56.786
<v Unidentified speaker>Like the majority of the citizens polled, I strongly support this ban.

1131
01:37:57.560 --> 01:37:59.798
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm deeply moved by the testimony being given today.

1132
01:38:00.460 --> 01:38:14.489
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland can lead as a forward-thinking city, and I believe it is in our best interest to embrace We should embrace every opportunity to adapt and invest in positive changes that support our communities, not to uphold broken, destructive systems that benefit only a few.

1133
01:38:15.118 --> 01:38:22.818
<v Unidentified speaker>We should unequivocally stand up against cruelty and prioritize important issues like this ban that cost us nothing as a community to champion.

1134
01:38:23.612 --> 01:38:24.002
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1135
01:38:29.362 --> 01:38:45.206
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, next up we have Matt Russo, Sarah Barham, Pranav Merchant, Finn Spoor, Nicole Funskeindl.

1136
01:38:50.710 --> 01:38:55.229
<v Unidentified speaker>Hey, I'm Finn Spoor and I'm from District 4 and I support the ban.

1137
01:38:56.470 --> 01:38:57.569
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1138
01:39:07.831 --> 01:39:07.948
<v Unidentified speaker>Pranav.

1139
01:39:07.997 --> 01:39:08.315
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, so sorry.

1140
01:39:12.409 --> 01:39:23.024
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, sorry, uh, I wanted to thank the council and the city of Portland first of all for allowing people from out of the city to testify because I, uh, I don't live in Portland but I visit often because I have family there.

1141
01:39:23.511 --> 01:39:45.016
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanted to say I think all the arguments about personal choice and culture and business vitality are all great, but I don't think any of that should be found— should be based on unnecessary cruelty and violence towards animals.

1142
01:39:45.082 --> 01:39:47.694
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think morals come first before any of the other—.

1143
01:39:47.841 --> 01:39:48.489
<v Unidentified speaker>Any of those other considerations.

1144
01:39:49.449 --> 01:39:52.337
<v Unidentified speaker>So I hope you guys pass the ban and, you know, keep Portland—.

1145
01:39:52.337 --> 01:39:53.025
<v Unidentified speaker>I think, what was it, ahead of the curve?

1146
01:39:53.076 --> 01:39:53.404
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland, Oregon.

1147
01:39:53.850 --> 01:39:55.542
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

1148
01:39:59.500 --> 01:40:00.659
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Nicole Von Schindle.

1149
01:40:01.399 --> 01:40:09.033
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a worker in the food service industry in District 1, and I support this ban because my right to choose does not give me a right to abuse animals.

1150
01:40:09.695 --> 01:40:10.002
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1151
01:40:10.583 --> 01:40:10.908
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1152
01:40:12.216 --> 01:40:13.331
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Sarah Barham.

1153
01:40:13.493 --> 01:40:17.402
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm born and raised in Portland, and I currently live in District 2, and I support this ban.

1154
01:40:18.390 --> 01:40:18.912
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1155
01:40:19.627 --> 01:40:20.542
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, I'm Nat Russo.

1156
01:40:20.768 --> 01:40:26.917
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in Fairview, just a few streets out of Portland, and I frequent restaurants in the Portland area quite often.

1157
01:40:27.896 --> 01:40:28.667
<v Unidentified speaker>I support this ban.

1158
01:40:29.358 --> 01:40:52.279
<v Unidentified speaker>I want you to picture yourself having a tube down your throat force-feeding you for 2 weeks and how much that suffering causes, and try to have some empathy for those animals and really think about the power you have today to to stop that, stop some of the amount of suffering that this world has, and be on the right side of, of it all.

1159
01:40:53.215 --> 01:40:53.472
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1160
01:40:53.779 --> 01:40:54.408
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1161
01:40:58.336 --> 01:41:09.561
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, next up we have Johnny Lieberman, Matthew King, Peter Missona, Alex Vitor, Tammy Dunn.

1162
01:41:12.242 --> 01:41:14.921
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, I see Matthew online.

1163
01:41:15.099 --> 01:41:15.404
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead.

1164
01:41:16.720 --> 01:41:18.564
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, can you hear me okay?

1165
01:41:19.110 --> 01:41:19.849
<v Keelan McClymont>We can hear you.

1166
01:41:20.490 --> 01:41:20.587
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1167
01:41:21.197 --> 01:41:24.614
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, my name is Matthew King and I represent the Christian Animal Rights Association.

1168
01:41:25.127 --> 01:41:27.519
<v Unidentified speaker>The Bible condemns animal cruelty in Proverbs 12:10.

1169
01:41:28.675 --> 01:41:37.628
<v Unidentified speaker>Based on Proverbs 12:10, our ministry supports the ban on force-fed products like foie gras in Portland because it is incredibly cruel to animals, and even to the biblical writers it would not be acceptable.

1170
01:41:38.545 --> 01:41:41.804
<v Unidentified speaker>Force-fed products like foie gras have no place in a civilized society.

1171
01:41:42.623 --> 01:41:50.154
<v Unidentified speaker>Other compassionate cities like Pittsburgh, Brookline, Massachusetts, New York City, and the entire state of California have banned foie gras.

1172
01:41:51.408 --> 01:41:58.795
<v Unidentified speaker>Someone earlier defended LaBelle Farms, yet that producer has faced significant ongoing accusations of animal cruelty because of their force-feeding methods.

1173
01:41:59.823 --> 01:42:02.809
<v Unidentified speaker>And it's interesting how a lot of the arguments don't address the animal cruelty issue.

1174
01:42:03.500 --> 01:42:15.895
<v Unidentified speaker>They talked about other issues like crack, school funding, free and personal choice, budget, public safety, the lottery, investment in factory farming, which doesn't involve force-feeding, to function as a distraction to the issue.

1175
01:42:16.762 --> 01:42:19.621
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a menu item that no one needs and is very much a luxury item.

1176
01:42:20.456 --> 01:42:25.320
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, our ministry supports the ban on force-fed products like foie gras in Portland because it is incredibly cruel to animals.

1177
01:42:26.155 --> 01:42:26.814
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for your time.

1178
01:42:27.761 --> 01:42:28.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1179
01:42:30.956 --> 01:42:32.141
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, thanks, council members.

1180
01:42:32.479 --> 01:42:36.966
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Peter Misona, uh, live in District 3, small business owner.

1181
01:42:37.927 --> 01:42:41.166
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I'm here to ban the proposal.

1182
01:42:41.694 --> 01:42:50.413
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland should think very clearly, carefully before it rushes into a foie gras ban because it risks feeling good while doing almost nothing to actually help animals.

1183
01:42:51.087 --> 01:42:54.132
<v Unidentified speaker>The truth is foie gras is a tiny niche product.

1184
01:42:54.694 --> 01:43:19.833
<v Unidentified speaker>Meanwhile, the overwhelming majority of animal suffering comes from factory farming where Banning a single luxury item— menu item might make for a strong headline, but it does not make meaningful change in the system.

1185
01:43:20.904 --> 01:43:26.177
<v Unidentified speaker>What it does do is put yet another burden on a small handful of restaurants and shops.

1186
01:43:26.226 --> 01:43:26.648
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Herbold.

1187
01:43:27.176 --> 01:43:30.837
<v Unidentified speaker>While the real engine of cruelty in our food system continues untouched.

1188
01:43:31.528 --> 01:43:34.064
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland is a thoughtful, values-driven city.

1189
01:43:35.045 --> 01:43:46.829
<v Unidentified speaker>We should be leading on policies that actually reduce suffering at scale, supporting higher welfare standards, rewarding humane farms, and pushing back on the worst factory farming practices.

1190
01:43:47.439 --> 01:43:51.807
<v Unidentified speaker>If this council wants to stand up for animals, let's be honest about where the harm really is.

1191
01:43:51.872 --> 01:43:52.081
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1192
01:43:52.564 --> 01:43:59.716
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's not settle for a symbolic ban that targets an easy, visible villain while ignoring the everyday realities of industrial farming.

1193
01:44:00.297 --> 01:44:02.460
<v Unidentified speaker>We can do better than feel-good legislation.

1194
01:44:02.734 --> 01:44:09.069
<v Unidentified speaker>We owe it to both animals and small businesses to pursue reforms that are serious, effective, and truly compassionate.

1195
01:44:10.189 --> 01:44:10.319
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1196
01:44:10.546 --> 01:44:11.162
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1197
01:44:12.657 --> 01:44:12.948
<v Unidentified speaker>Johnny.

1198
01:44:15.643 --> 01:44:18.532
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Johnny Lieberman, District 1 in Portland.

1199
01:44:23.537 --> 01:44:24.231
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1200
01:44:27.337 --> 01:44:33.408
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up we have Alex— uh, oh, uh, let's check, see if Alex Vittore is here, or Tammy Dunn.

1201
01:44:37.257 --> 01:44:38.503
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Tammy Dunn.

1202
01:44:38.957 --> 01:44:40.914
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in the Portland metro area.

1203
01:44:41.805 --> 01:44:45.364
<v Unidentified speaker>I can't imagine opposition to this ban when the harm to sentient beings is so clear.

1204
01:44:45.634 --> 01:44:53.596
<v Unidentified speaker>Sentient beings is so grave, and the product it produces is insignificant to the well-being of any person or business.

1205
01:44:54.487 --> 01:44:58.019
<v Unidentified speaker>These are the same sweet animals we take our kids to the park to see.

1206
01:44:58.862 --> 01:44:59.818
<v Unidentified speaker>I support the ban.

1207
01:44:59.996 --> 01:45:00.400
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1208
01:45:01.778 --> 01:45:02.328
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

1209
01:45:04.943 --> 01:45:18.743
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have, uh, Soph Parnock, Michelle Casey, Jeremy Beckham, Go ahead, Michelle.

1210
01:45:21.345 --> 01:45:21.811
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1211
01:45:22.052 --> 01:45:23.488
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Michelle Casey.

1212
01:45:23.828 --> 01:45:29.311
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 2, and I fully support the foie gras ban.

1213
01:45:29.748 --> 01:45:30.136
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1214
01:45:31.108 --> 01:45:31.658
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

1215
01:45:34.762 --> 01:45:36.063
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Nicholas Selby.

1216
01:45:36.573 --> 01:45:38.054
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 2.

1217
01:45:38.971 --> 01:45:42.180
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm here to support the ban on force-fed foie gras.

1218
01:45:42.845 --> 01:45:43.153
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1219
01:45:44.140 --> 01:45:44.773
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1220
01:46:01.405 --> 01:46:03.689
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Jolene Rutherford.

1221
01:46:05.750 --> 01:46:09.220
<v Unidentified speaker>This issue comes down to personal choice.

1222
01:46:09.800 --> 01:46:14.470
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland has always trusted its residents to make informed decisions about what they eat, even when those choices differ.

1223
01:46:15.960 --> 01:46:18.739
<v Unidentified speaker>If we start deciding what people are allowed to eat, we lose something bigger.

1224
01:46:18.739 --> 01:46:19.949
<v Unidentified speaker>We lose trust in our community.

1225
01:46:20.300 --> 01:46:22.140
<v Unidentified speaker>Please don't replace that trust with a ban.

1226
01:46:22.140 --> 01:46:23.199
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1227
01:46:23.199 --> 01:46:24.569
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1228
01:46:26.680 --> 01:46:28.359
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Jeremy Beckham.

1229
01:46:28.359 --> 01:46:30.560
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a student here at Lewis Clark Law School.

1230
01:46:30.560 --> 01:46:36.444
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a member of the I think the images that everyone saw today of how foie gras is produced kind of speak for themselves.

1231
01:46:37.649 --> 01:46:40.551
<v Unidentified speaker>It's a form of animal torture, and I'm here to support the ban.

1232
01:46:40.744 --> 01:46:41.083
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1233
01:46:41.777 --> 01:46:42.131
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1234
01:46:47.435 --> 01:47:02.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Soph Parnock, Eleanor Roberts Caudill, Jesse Caldwell, Marika Diaz, Sierra Barnes, Victoria Castillo.

1235
01:47:08.039 --> 01:47:08.280
<v Unidentified speaker>Welcome.

1236
01:47:08.394 --> 01:47:14.157
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, I'm Jesse Caldwell from Portland District 3, and I'm here to express my full support for the ban.

1237
01:47:15.712 --> 01:47:27.561
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd also just like to say that with any issue of rights, be it civil rights or labor rights, It always is organized at the community level first before large sweeping changes can be enacted.

1238
01:47:28.335 --> 01:47:32.868
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think it's important that we do that here, and it's more than just performative.

1239
01:47:33.051 --> 01:47:33.479
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1240
01:47:34.435 --> 01:47:35.045
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1241
01:47:41.613 --> 01:47:43.320
<v Unidentified speaker>Sierra is joining us online.

1242
01:47:46.009 --> 01:47:46.253
<v Keelan McClymont>Sierra.

1243
01:47:48.220 --> 01:47:53.956
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, can you hear me?

1244
01:47:54.507 --> 01:47:55.141
<v Unidentified speaker>We can hear you now.

1245
01:47:56.930 --> 01:47:57.238
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, great.

1246
01:47:57.757 --> 01:47:58.716
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Sierra Barnes.

1247
01:47:58.927 --> 01:48:00.569
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a constituent in District 4.

1248
01:48:01.413 --> 01:48:04.078
<v Unidentified speaker>I would like to testify in support of the foie gras ban.

1249
01:48:04.569 --> 01:48:26.340
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I think we've heard a lot about how this is potentially a waste of time, but I'd like to point out that even with, uh, 0.0005% With billions of animals being killed for food, that's still a big number of individuals, and this is a real chance to make a large impact for animals.

1250
01:48:26.702 --> 01:48:27.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1251
01:48:28.262 --> 01:48:29.085
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1252
01:48:32.307 --> 01:48:35.054
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Marika Diaz, and I live in District 3.

1253
01:48:35.521 --> 01:48:40.029
<v Unidentified speaker>I support this ban, and I'm urging you to also support it because of the life and well-being of sentient animals.

1254
01:48:40.708 --> 01:48:48.347
<v Unidentified speaker>The life and well-being of a sentient being should always take priority over somebody's choice to use another's body for sensory pleasure or profit.

1255
01:48:48.766 --> 01:48:49.024
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1256
01:48:49.444 --> 01:48:50.431
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1257
01:48:53.712 --> 01:48:59.328
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Victoria Castillo, and I'm a member of Vegan Scouts, a local community organization that also supports this ban.

1258
01:49:00.087 --> 01:49:01.716
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak today.

1259
01:49:03.060 --> 01:49:05.216
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not a waste of time or money to fight for what's right.

1260
01:49:06.279 --> 01:49:09.911
<v Unidentified speaker>Saying this ban is not meaningful because bigger problems exist just avoids the question.

1261
01:49:10.457 --> 01:49:12.015
<v Unidentified speaker>Small changes still reduce harm.

1262
01:49:13.157 --> 01:49:16.676
<v Unidentified speaker>Former arguments bringing up chicken consumption distracts from actual policy questions.

1263
01:49:17.255 --> 01:49:20.740
<v Unidentified speaker>The fact that chicken farming is larger doesn't mean smaller issues shouldn't be addressed.

1264
01:49:20.902 --> 01:49:24.228
<v Unidentified speaker>Scale alone does not determine whether something is worth regulating.

1265
01:49:25.626 --> 01:49:31.538
<v Unidentified speaker>The arguments pertaining to personal choice are not very strong if the issue involves harm to others, public health, animal welfare.

1266
01:49:32.212 --> 01:49:36.396
<v Unidentified speaker>Environmental impact or regulation just skips over those competing concerns.

1267
01:49:36.637 --> 01:49:38.081
<v Unidentified speaker>It's an oversimplification.

1268
01:49:39.507 --> 01:49:46.994
<v Unidentified speaker>Some may argue that banning foie gras limits choice or impacts businesses, but we routinely draw lines around what is acceptable in the marketplace.

1269
01:49:47.524 --> 01:49:52.109
<v Unidentified speaker>We do not permit products that are produced through unnecessary suffering when humane alternatives exist.

1270
01:49:52.800 --> 01:49:55.349
<v Unidentified speaker>This is an opportunity for Portland to lead, not follow.

1271
01:49:56.006 --> 01:50:15.453
<v Unidentified speaker>Other cities have already taken steps in this direction, and your action today can reinforce a broader movement Consider what it means to allow practice that depends on the prolonged suffering of animals for luxury consumption, and consider the message it sends about who we are as a city.

1272
01:50:16.145 --> 01:50:17.658
<v Unidentified speaker>Please act with compassion and integrity.

1273
01:50:18.094 --> 01:50:18.738
<v Unidentified speaker>Ban foie gras.

1274
01:50:20.579 --> 01:50:21.121
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1275
01:50:23.520 --> 01:50:25.204
<v Unidentified speaker>Next up, we have Tous Henry.

1276
01:50:26.300 --> 01:50:40.993
<v Unidentified speaker>Tina Ciccarello, Brian Peace, Nicholas Burgantine, Daniel Redwood.

1277
01:50:41.867 --> 01:50:43.685
<v Unidentified speaker>Good afternoon, members of the Portland City Council.

1278
01:50:44.238 --> 01:50:48.952
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Tuce Henry, and I'm a proud Oregonian and resident of Portland's Hollywood District 2.

1279
01:50:49.541 --> 01:50:58.546
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here today to urge this council to ban the sale of foie gras In Multnomah County, not as a radical act, but as a natural expression of who we are as a city and who we choose to be as a culture.

1280
01:50:59.591 --> 01:51:06.430
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland has long stood apart in a national climate increasingly defined by indifference to each other, to animals, and to the planet.

1281
01:51:06.912 --> 01:51:08.646
<v Unidentified speaker>The city has chosen to lead with compassion.

1282
01:51:09.466 --> 01:51:16.996
<v Unidentified speaker>We believe that how we treat the most vulnerable among us defines our character, and that belief extends beyond our species and into the greater web of life that sustains us all.

1283
01:51:17.172 --> 01:51:17.398
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1284
01:51:18.296 --> 01:51:20.043
<v Unidentified speaker>What we spend money on shapes the world we live in.

1285
01:51:20.797 --> 01:51:25.416
<v Unidentified speaker>Every dollar spent on a product rooted in deliberate cruelty is a small vote for a crueler world.

1286
01:51:26.570 --> 01:51:37.779
<v Unidentified speaker>And every time a city chooses to remove that option from its local economy, it sends a different signal— that here we choose kindness and compassion over the deliberate production of pain for the selfish sake of profit or personal preference.

1287
01:51:38.662 --> 01:51:40.297
<v Unidentified speaker>This ban asks very little of Portland.

1288
01:51:40.762 --> 01:51:44.211
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras is a luxury item with a minimum footprint in our local food economy.

1289
01:51:44.274 --> 01:51:56.502
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember no jobs are lost, no communities disrupted, and what we stand to gain is much more valuable: an alignment of values that sets our city apart and joins it with some of the most socially advanced cities and nations in the world.

1290
01:51:57.211 --> 01:51:59.112
<v Unidentified speaker>That matters more now than it ever has.

1291
01:51:59.771 --> 01:52:03.993
<v Unidentified speaker>When cruelty is normalized at scale, local acts of conscience are not small things.

1292
01:52:04.605 --> 01:52:08.220
<v Unidentified speaker>They are the building blocks of a culture rooted in cooperative intention.

1293
01:52:09.204 --> 01:52:10.318
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland has always understood that.

1294
01:52:12.020 --> 01:52:12.795
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1295
01:52:13.974 --> 01:52:25.634
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, council members, for taking this up.

1296
01:52:25.698 --> 01:52:26.877
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Brian Pease.

1297
01:52:26.989 --> 01:52:32.442
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a civil rights and environmental attorney in San Diego, California, where I've been for the past 20 years.

1298
01:52:32.699 --> 01:52:44.296
<v Unidentified speaker>In the early 2000s, I co-founded a group called Animal Protection and Rescue League, and we visited these foie gras farms and exposed the cruelty there, which helped get the California ban passed.

1299
01:52:44.520 --> 01:52:50.213
<v Unidentified speaker>And the idea that Labelle Farms, for instance, is a smaller farm— it's not.

1300
01:52:50.326 --> 01:52:52.411
<v Unidentified speaker>It's massive, just like Hudson Valley Foie Gras.

1301
01:52:52.458 --> 01:52:53.949
<v Unidentified speaker>These are massive factory farms.

1302
01:52:53.997 --> 01:52:59.289
<v Unidentified speaker>When you're in these sheds, as far as the eye can see, you just see rows and rows of these pens, the forced feeding pens with the ducks.

1303
01:53:00.011 --> 01:53:03.266
<v Unidentified speaker>The reason that there's a lot more chickens killed is because there are a lot more farms.

1304
01:53:03.395 --> 01:53:08.899
<v Unidentified speaker>But here we have 2 farms They're supplying the entire United States supply of foie gras.

1305
01:53:09.149 --> 01:53:12.810
<v Unidentified speaker>Labelle and Hudson Valley have also been under fire for exploiting their migrant workers.

1306
01:53:12.810 --> 01:53:15.380
<v Unidentified speaker>There have been class action lawsuits about that.

1307
01:53:15.569 --> 01:53:20.109
<v Unidentified speaker>In California, we passed other bans after the foie gras ban, including by voters.

1308
01:53:20.109 --> 01:53:22.560
<v Unidentified speaker>We have cage-free eggs only in California.

1309
01:53:22.729 --> 01:53:24.069
<v Unidentified speaker>So New York City did the same thing.

1310
01:53:24.069 --> 01:53:26.489
<v Unidentified speaker>They passed it as a package of animal welfare laws.

1311
01:53:26.489 --> 01:53:27.729
<v Unidentified speaker>It wasn't just foie gras.

1312
01:53:27.729 --> 01:53:29.090
<v Unidentified speaker>So this is an important piece.

1313
01:53:29.210 --> 01:53:33.699
<v Unidentified speaker>But the idea that restaurants will stop serving if consumers stop eating it is simply Not true.

1314
01:53:33.699 --> 01:53:34.579
<v Unidentified speaker>In fact, it's the opposite.

1315
01:53:34.840 --> 01:53:46.550
<v Unidentified speaker>The reason that the restaurants have to serve it, if some restaurants are going to turn a blind eye to the cruelty, is that then they figure, well, we might lose business to the few consumers who don't care about the cruelty, and we're going to offer it as long as it's legal.

1316
01:53:46.880 --> 01:53:48.359
<v Unidentified speaker>We need to set some standards.

1317
01:53:48.998 --> 01:53:52.439
<v Unidentified speaker>If somebody wanted to walk down the street kicking their dog in the head, we wouldn't allow that either.

1318
01:53:52.439 --> 01:53:58.960
<v Unidentified speaker>So choice here is not— this is what government is for, is to level the playing field and create humane standards for all the businesses.

1319
01:53:59.497 --> 01:54:02.216
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1320
01:54:06.279 --> 01:54:06.604
<v Unidentified speaker>Tina.

1321
01:54:09.045 --> 01:54:11.225
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, my name is Tina Ciccarello.

1322
01:54:11.935 --> 01:54:12.952
<v Unidentified speaker>Empathy matters.

1323
01:54:13.646 --> 01:54:15.956
<v Unidentified speaker>These force-fed ducks are babies.

1324
01:54:17.578 --> 01:54:20.377
<v Unidentified speaker>They're typically only 10 to 12 weeks old.

1325
01:54:21.293 --> 01:54:24.479
<v Unidentified speaker>A duck's lifespan is typically 5 to 15 years.

1326
01:54:25.719 --> 01:54:35.813
<v Unidentified speaker>If people aren't okay with showing the force-feeding footage of ducks to their kids or grandkids, then they already know how cruel it is.

1327
01:54:36.952 --> 01:54:40.386
<v Unidentified speaker>I wouldn't want someone I love to be treated like these birds.

1328
01:54:41.686 --> 01:54:44.622
<v Unidentified speaker>I hear quite a bit of people mention the word choice.

1329
01:54:45.554 --> 01:54:47.368
<v Unidentified speaker>These birds aren't given one.

1330
01:54:48.122 --> 01:54:53.524
<v Unidentified speaker>When we know better, we have the opportunity to make kinder choices.

1331
01:54:54.222 --> 01:54:55.212
<v Unidentified speaker>So why don't we?

1332
01:54:56.055 --> 01:54:57.011
<v Unidentified speaker>I support the ban.

1333
01:55:01.340 --> 01:55:02.012
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1334
01:55:03.439 --> 01:55:03.680
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead.

1335
01:55:04.131 --> 01:55:08.350
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, my name is Nick Burgantine, and it's nice to see everyone.

1336
01:55:08.689 --> 01:55:10.895
<v Unidentified speaker>You have multiplied since the last time I was here.

1337
01:55:12.372 --> 01:55:16.475
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I support the ban, just I wouldn't want that to happen to me.

1338
01:55:16.948 --> 01:55:17.822
<v Unidentified speaker>Very Very basically.

1339
01:55:18.801 --> 01:55:22.751
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a little bit jealous of the other individuals here though because I can't really prepare stuff.

1340
01:55:22.847 --> 01:55:26.716
<v Unidentified speaker>It's also my weakness as a substitute teacher.

1341
01:55:26.765 --> 01:55:28.354
<v Unidentified speaker>If you give me a script, I'm not great with it.

1342
01:55:29.414 --> 01:55:30.587
<v Unidentified speaker>But it's like reasons like this.

1343
01:55:30.779 --> 01:55:42.002
<v Unidentified speaker>I took the bus here and I overheard this gem of someone talking about how their friend eats pizza 22 days of the month and a sandwich the other 8 days of the month.

1344
01:55:42.083 --> 01:55:42.469
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not true.

1345
01:55:44.229 --> 01:55:45.925
<v Unidentified speaker>Folgrado is not one of the days.

1346
01:55:48.567 --> 01:55:52.740
<v Unidentified speaker>The truth is people don't overwhelmingly care about this.

1347
01:55:53.743 --> 01:55:56.186
<v Unidentified speaker>As a sub, I'm really worried about next year's school year.

1348
01:55:57.305 --> 01:56:05.081
<v Unidentified speaker>I think people do probably want to vote on this, and the numbers are actually really clear, uh, that people don't like that.

1349
01:56:06.507 --> 01:56:09.421
<v Unidentified speaker>People don't really eat it too much, and it just seems Very very cruel.

1350
01:56:12.579 --> 01:56:14.505
<v Unidentified speaker>I also like really bad analogies, so I apologize.

1351
01:56:14.552 --> 01:56:18.807
<v Unidentified speaker>But the WNBA season—we have a team that's really really exciting.

1352
01:56:19.631 --> 01:56:20.195
<v Unidentified speaker>I can't wait.

1353
01:56:20.599 --> 01:56:21.677
<v Unidentified speaker>Sunday preseason.

1354
01:56:22.837 --> 01:56:25.158
<v Unidentified speaker>In basketball, good passes are ahead of the person.

1355
01:56:27.015 --> 01:56:30.635
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not trending towards oh there's more and more foie gras everywhere.

1356
01:56:30.682 --> 01:56:31.511
<v Unidentified speaker>It's going one way.

1357
01:56:31.623 --> 01:56:33.814
<v Unidentified speaker>People like oh this is a cruel practice.

1358
01:56:34.595 --> 01:56:37.643
<v Unidentified speaker>I have 5 seconds, but there's been 2 times this is overturned.

1359
01:56:37.740 --> 01:56:40.868
<v Unidentified speaker>Once was a clerical error and the other was some dude from Chicago.

1360
01:56:42.300 --> 01:56:42.783
<v Unidentified speaker>People, man.

1361
01:56:43.297 --> 01:56:43.619
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1362
01:56:44.506 --> 01:56:44.877
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1363
01:56:48.355 --> 01:56:48.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Daniel.

1364
01:56:50.644 --> 01:56:51.899
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Daniel Redwood.

1365
01:56:52.141 --> 01:56:54.221
<v Unidentified speaker>I am a resident of District 2.

1366
01:56:54.979 --> 01:56:59.073
<v Unidentified speaker>I strongly support the ban and urge the council to pass it.

1367
01:56:59.944 --> 01:57:00.342
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1368
01:57:01.439 --> 01:57:02.121
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1369
01:57:06.798 --> 01:57:18.644
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, next up we have Asis Patel, Michael Thielen, Drew McCormick, Andrew Esposito, Leslie Burke.

1370
01:57:21.728 --> 01:57:21.971
<v Unidentified speaker>Go ahead.

1371
01:57:22.539 --> 01:57:22.766
<v Unidentified speaker>Me?

1372
01:57:23.189 --> 01:57:23.286
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1373
01:57:23.416 --> 01:57:27.087
<v Unidentified speaker>Hey everyone, Mike Thielen, District 3, Sunnyside, where I've lived most of my adult life.

1374
01:57:28.639 --> 01:57:30.515
<v Unidentified speaker>I think we all agree everyone cares.

1375
01:57:30.564 --> 01:57:31.253
<v Unidentified speaker>That's why they're here.

1376
01:57:31.382 --> 01:57:40.944
<v Unidentified speaker>I think what really compelled me to show up today, it just bothered me to hear from Kurt and from Kelsey and from others that, you know, they had reached out to the backers of this van and they haven't felt engaged.

1377
01:57:40.993 --> 01:57:41.907
<v Unidentified speaker>They hadn't felt heard.

1378
01:57:42.837 --> 01:57:47.779
<v Unidentified speaker>I've had the luxury and the pleasure and the privilege of working with the culinary community in Portland for 20 years.

1379
01:57:47.827 --> 01:58:03.429
<v Unidentified speaker>I started Feast Portland among some other projects, and this community represents the very best of what this city does in terms of sourcing, in terms of sustainability, stewardship, regeneration, in terms of keeping the neighborhoods alive, in terms of creating jobs, tax revenue, all that.

1380
01:58:03.943 --> 01:58:11.712
<v Unidentified speaker>I would ask before we make decisions, we do a better job to engage with this community and respect what they do before we blanket bans.

1381
01:58:11.826 --> 01:58:18.505
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, really as leaders, find ways for all of us to work together to address larger issues related to animal cruelty.

1382
01:58:18.585 --> 01:58:19.194
<v Unidentified speaker>I oppose this ordinance.

1383
01:58:25.240 --> 01:58:26.742
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, my name is Ases Patel.

1384
01:58:29.060 --> 01:58:31.591
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a visitor from out of state, and I support the ban.

1385
01:58:33.180 --> 01:58:33.721
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1386
01:58:35.896 --> 01:58:36.317
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, everyone.

1387
01:58:36.818 --> 01:58:38.239
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Andrew Esposito.

1388
01:58:38.402 --> 01:58:39.564
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a voter in District 2.

1389
01:58:40.033 --> 01:58:41.149
<v Unidentified speaker>I strongly oppose this ban.

1390
01:58:42.898 --> 01:58:46.400
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here today in my 90 seconds to talk to the group of people behind me and the group of people ahead of me.

1391
01:58:46.466 --> 01:58:46.925
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a parent of 2 children.

1392
01:58:47.823 --> 01:58:52.081
<v Unidentified speaker>The group of people behind me have vocally protested at restaurants over the last couple of weeks.

1393
01:58:52.643 --> 01:58:59.645
<v Unidentified speaker>Real-life anguish has happened to employees at these businesses that are dealing with these protesters in a way that they shouldn't have to.

1394
01:59:00.095 --> 01:59:01.364
<v Unidentified speaker>They're employees of this business.

1395
01:59:01.412 --> 01:59:06.649
<v Unidentified speaker>They aren't making decisions, and instead they're dealing with very loud, disruptive protests in front of their business.

1396
01:59:07.501 --> 01:59:18.275
<v Unidentified speaker>I ask the group in front of me, have we done anything to contact the police department to work with them Knowing that some of this could be coming to light, knowing that there are vocal disruptions and protests happening.

1397
01:59:18.903 --> 01:59:21.390
<v Unidentified speaker>And I ask the people behind me to please show up better.

1398
01:59:21.729 --> 01:59:30.479
<v Unidentified speaker>I understand that you're very passionate about this and you feel a certain way about it, but you are disrupting the business in this city that has helped put this city on the map.

1399
01:59:31.185 --> 01:59:38.251
<v Unidentified speaker>This avenue right here is the correct way to spread your message, not showing up and forcing the cops to be called on you as you harass guests.

1400
01:59:40.856 --> 01:59:43.520
<v Unidentified speaker>Please keep your fellow city council members in check.

1401
01:59:43.942 --> 01:59:44.396
<v Unidentified speaker>Please.

1402
01:59:45.386 --> 01:59:45.971
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1403
01:59:47.092 --> 01:59:47.645
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1404
01:59:50.734 --> 01:59:52.106
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Leslie Burke.

1405
01:59:52.430 --> 01:59:54.805
<v Unidentified speaker>I live in District 3, and I support the ban.

1406
01:59:55.564 --> 01:59:55.886
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1407
01:59:56.792 --> 01:59:57.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1408
02:00:03.640 --> 02:00:04.002
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, Drew?

1409
02:00:10.060 --> 02:00:11.787
<v Unidentified speaker>Hello, can you hear me?

1410
02:00:12.192 --> 02:00:12.805
<v Unidentified speaker>We can hear you.

1411
02:00:12.935 --> 02:00:13.242
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1412
02:00:13.711 --> 02:00:15.923
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, I'm Drew McCormick.

1413
02:00:16.296 --> 02:00:18.185
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you for taking the time to listen.

1414
02:00:18.251 --> 02:00:22.689
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here to strongly support this ban on foie gras.

1415
02:00:23.399 --> 02:00:25.563
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, we talked about chickens and factory farming.

1416
02:00:25.676 --> 02:00:27.386
<v Unidentified speaker>As far as I know, chickens are not force-fed.

1417
02:00:28.229 --> 02:00:29.886
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, two wrongs do not make a right.

1418
02:00:30.512 --> 02:00:35.587
<v Unidentified speaker>We talked about free choice, but the government regulates and restricts what enters the market all the time.

1419
02:00:36.855 --> 02:00:38.911
<v Unidentified speaker>We talked about whether this was meaningful change.

1420
02:00:39.408 --> 02:00:42.251
<v Unidentified speaker>I absolutely think this is meaningful change.

1421
02:00:42.314 --> 02:00:47.100
<v Unidentified speaker>You can stop foie gras, and you saw the images, you saw the videos.

1422
02:00:47.854 --> 02:00:53.682
<v Unidentified speaker>The common technique to make foie gras is to restrain the bird by hand or machine with its neck extended.

1423
02:00:54.100 --> 02:00:55.256
<v Unidentified speaker>A tube is pushed down its throat.

1424
02:00:55.320 --> 02:00:55.417
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1425
02:00:55.882 --> 02:00:59.548
<v Unidentified speaker>And the food is forced down the throat either manually or mechanically.

1426
02:01:01.028 --> 02:01:02.153
<v Unidentified speaker>These birds are sentient.

1427
02:01:02.716 --> 02:01:03.649
<v Unidentified speaker>They feel pain.

1428
02:01:04.109 --> 02:01:06.529
<v Unidentified speaker>Some ducks even die from suffocating on the food.

1429
02:01:07.029 --> 02:01:09.253
<v Unidentified speaker>Foie gras is inhumane and incredibly hurtful.

1430
02:01:09.689 --> 02:01:10.560
<v Unidentified speaker>Please support the ban.

1431
02:01:10.818 --> 02:01:11.140
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1432
02:01:11.947 --> 02:01:12.609
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1433
02:01:15.202 --> 02:01:21.262
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, next up we have Gert Arts, followed by Violet Russell.

1434
02:01:24.221 --> 02:01:31.238
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm gonna also run through the names that I've called just to make sure nobody has shown up.

1435
02:01:31.367 --> 02:01:42.070
<v Unidentified speaker>Annalise Day, Nicole Corrado, Hillary Tefer, John Gramstad, Alex Vitor, Soph Parnock, Eleanor Roberts Caudle.

1436
02:01:44.109 --> 02:01:46.375
<v Unidentified speaker>Hi, I'm Gert Arts, a Portland homeowner.

1437
02:01:46.506 --> 02:01:55.435
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you imagine in your own home Your cat or dog having a tube stuffed down its throat until it became sick or diseased, you wouldn't stand for it.

1438
02:01:56.420 --> 02:02:02.820
<v Unidentified speaker>It's very easy for you not to stand for that for ducks either by just saying yes on this ordinance.

1439
02:02:02.902 --> 02:02:03.288
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1440
02:02:04.110 --> 02:02:04.676
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1441
02:02:07.734 --> 02:02:11.204
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, hi, I'm Violet Russell from District 2, and I support this ban.

1442
02:02:12.458 --> 02:02:13.045
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1443
02:02:14.007 --> 02:02:17.840
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Eleanor Roberts Caudle, and I support this ban.

1444
02:02:18.854 --> 02:02:19.144
<v Unidentified speaker>Please.

1445
02:02:19.497 --> 02:02:19.868
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1446
02:02:20.625 --> 02:02:21.237
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you very much.

1447
02:02:24.432 --> 02:02:25.381
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

1448
02:02:25.750 --> 02:02:29.783
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, colleagues, we are at almost exactly the time limit that I set for this.

1449
02:02:30.475 --> 02:02:33.404
<v Unidentified speaker>We are going to continue this item to a future hearing.

1450
02:02:33.453 --> 02:02:39.484
<v Unidentified speaker>We're going to have a second first reading so we can have council discussion, but we are out of time for today to discuss this.

1451
02:02:40.115 --> 02:02:41.166
<v Unidentified speaker>I need to move on to the next item.

1452
02:02:41.310 --> 02:02:47.413
<v Unidentified speaker>So we will— more action on this next soon.

1453
02:02:47.865 --> 02:02:50.199
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we please move to item number 8?

1454
02:02:50.297 --> 02:02:51.774
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you all for being here today.

1455
02:02:54.760 --> 02:03:05.257
<v Unidentified speaker>Item 8, document 2026-039, amend chronic nuisance property code to address human trafficking, gun violence, and administrative challenges.

1456
02:03:06.167 --> 02:03:10.470
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1457
02:03:21.042 --> 02:03:31.045
<v Unidentified speaker>So colleagues, this matter was previously considered on March 13th, upon which, uh, Councilor Kanal moved to divide Councilor Novick's motion to consider a bundle of amendments.

1458
02:03:34.780 --> 02:03:41.359
<v Unidentified speaker>Under our code, councilors may divide questions by right without debate or a vote.

1459
02:03:41.743 --> 02:03:45.497
<v Unidentified speaker>The original introducer may designate the order in which the elements will be voted on.

1460
02:03:46.332 --> 02:03:48.386
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick, do you have a preferred order?

1461
02:03:49.604 --> 02:03:51.914
<v Unidentified speaker>I think simply doing them in numerical order is fine.

1462
02:03:52.268 --> 02:03:52.604
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1463
02:03:53.470 --> 02:04:14.338
<v Unidentified speaker>And I also want to note that we do have an additional proposed amendment, uh, Koyama Lane, Novick 1, which addresses a suggestion by the Multnomah County Health Department, which submitted testimony in favor of the ordinance, but they also suggested the inclusion of requirement for annual public reporting in the implementation.

1464
02:04:15.350 --> 02:04:15.478
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1465
02:04:16.168 --> 02:04:16.636
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Kanal.

1466
02:04:18.661 --> 02:04:24.992
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to just quickly, for the sake of time, withdraw and substitute that motion okay.

1467
02:04:25.168 --> 02:04:34.188
<v Unidentified speaker>To divide, uh, instead of dividing it into 5 categories, I would like to divide it into 2, which I think would save us all a little bit of time.

1468
02:04:34.645 --> 02:04:35.902
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm just checking my notes.

1469
02:04:35.951 --> 02:04:38.904
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, I didn't remember that this was pending when we got there.

1470
02:04:39.659 --> 02:04:54.947
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so 3— sorry, Novick 3, Novick 4, Um, and there's one more.

1471
02:05:00.662 --> 02:05:16.265
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick 6 would be in one category, Novick 5 would be in the other, and I'm trying to remember where— yeah, Novick 3, 4, and 6 in one category, Novick 5 and Pirtle-Guiney 3 in the other okay.

1472
02:05:16.587 --> 02:05:22.710
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick, do you have an opinion on which of these we would move on first?

1473
02:05:25.233 --> 02:05:27.304
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd like to do 3, 4, and 6.

1474
02:05:27.466 --> 02:05:27.613
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1475
02:05:27.956 --> 02:05:30.548
<v Unidentified speaker>6 Actually I think is the most significant.

1476
02:05:31.688 --> 02:05:41.967
<v Unidentified speaker>So Novick 3 relates to what activities are defined as nuisance activities, and the purpose of Novick 3 is to yes.

1477
02:05:42.225 --> 02:06:03.251
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick 3 is to hone in on defining— with regards to human trafficking, to delete a reference to prostitution or related offenses and to add human trafficking or related offenses so that— to make it clear that we're focusing on the traffickers and the buyers rather than on the sex workers.

1478
02:06:05.306 --> 02:06:11.359
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick 4 Is, um, uh, actually I'm going to talk about Novick 6 first.

1479
02:06:11.408 --> 02:06:13.358
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that actually kind of makes more sense.

1480
02:06:14.742 --> 02:06:23.154
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, Novick 6, um, it would— this is actually based on a suggestion by Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1481
02:06:23.738 --> 02:06:42.309
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, the, um, what the original ordinance did was, um, take the— the current law says that You can— the city can invoke the chronic nuisance property law if there is 3 documented instances of nuisance crime activity within 30 days.

1482
02:06:43.136 --> 02:06:49.440
<v Unidentified speaker>And my proposal was to change that to 3 in— to 2 in 90 days.

1483
02:06:50.412 --> 02:06:55.310
<v Unidentified speaker>At Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's suggestion, this would switch that to 3 in 90 days.

1484
02:06:56.377 --> 02:06:58.814
<v Unidentified speaker>And That would apply to both.

1485
02:06:58.990 --> 02:06:59.184
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1486
02:06:59.328 --> 02:07:01.689
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's one thing.

1487
02:07:01.753 --> 02:07:09.176
<v Unidentified speaker>The other thing is also a part of Novick 6, also relates to a concern that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney expressed.

1488
02:07:09.689 --> 02:07:19.859
<v Unidentified speaker>Currently, the law refers to 3 instances documented in police reports, but it doesn't say what the police report has to be based on exactly.

1489
02:07:20.453 --> 02:07:34.109
<v Unidentified speaker>So we want to clarify that it's 3 or more police reports or other official documentation That a police officer has determined that probable cause exists to believe the nuisance activity has occurred, as opposed to, for example, a grumpy neighbor made a complaint that wasn't verified.

1490
02:07:34.237 --> 02:07:41.725
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't think it was ever applied that way, but I thought it was worth, um, um, it was worth clarifying that at Councilor Burger-Gilley's suggestion.

1491
02:07:42.416 --> 02:07:45.061
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, that's Novick 6.

1492
02:07:45.301 --> 02:07:45.574
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1493
02:07:46.826 --> 02:07:51.157
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so that— and again, I said Novick 3, as I noted Okay.

1494
02:07:51.335 --> 02:07:55.994
<v Unidentified speaker>The first one, as I mentioned before, was about what fits into the definition of nuisance crime.

1495
02:07:56.800 --> 02:08:04.881
<v Unidentified speaker>Then consistent with Novick 6 adjustment to the timeline, Novick 4 would adjust a different timeline.

1496
02:08:06.851 --> 02:08:21.451
<v Unidentified speaker>Currently, as my original proposal read, it said that if the person in charge responds and agrees to abate the nuisance activities giving rise to the violation, The city administrator may postpone referring the matter to the city attorney.

1497
02:08:21.965 --> 02:08:28.511
<v Unidentified speaker>If no agreement concerning abatement is reached within— we had 30 days, this would change that to 60 days.

1498
02:08:29.329 --> 02:08:38.108
<v Unidentified speaker>Or if no agreed-upon course of action does not result in the abatement, the actual abatement within— we had 60 days, that extends to 90 days.

1499
02:08:38.990 --> 02:08:41.398
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's a timeline issue.

1500
02:08:41.846 --> 02:08:44.527
<v Unidentified speaker>And okay, I think that concludes— Thank you.

1501
02:08:45.596 --> 02:08:47.841
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1502
02:08:48.680 --> 02:08:50.052
<v Unidentified speaker>5 Is out.

1503
02:08:50.279 --> 02:08:50.376
<v Unidentified speaker>What?

1504
02:08:50.506 --> 02:08:54.738
<v Unidentified speaker>5 will be a separate— No, 5 is part of a separate package as per Councilor Kanal's motion.

1505
02:08:54.899 --> 02:08:59.686
<v Unidentified speaker>So the first division is focusing on Novick 3, 4, and 6.

1506
02:09:00.220 --> 02:09:05.490
<v Unidentified speaker>The second division, second separate vote will be Novick 5 and Pirtle-Guiney 3, which we'll discuss in a second.

1507
02:09:05.813 --> 02:09:11.274
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, is there any discussion on Novicks 3, 4, and 6?

1508
02:09:12.086 --> 02:09:13.625
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Knoll, are you still in the queue?

1509
02:09:13.720 --> 02:09:13.864
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1510
02:09:13.976 --> 02:09:14.394
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, Legacy.

1511
02:09:14.698 --> 02:09:18.929
<v Unidentified speaker>Just point of information previously, just because, yeah, a lot happened there.

1512
02:09:19.009 --> 02:09:26.123
<v Unidentified speaker>So 3, 5, and 6, we are voting on— I'm sorry, 3, 4, and 6, we are voting on as one package right now?

1513
02:09:26.283 --> 02:09:26.475
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1514
02:09:26.685 --> 02:09:30.979
<v Unidentified speaker>That's the goal?

1515
02:09:31.636 --> 02:09:32.372
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

1516
02:09:33.414 --> 02:09:34.104
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman.

1517
02:09:35.322 --> 02:09:37.115
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, I can support 3 and 6.

1518
02:09:37.180 --> 02:09:37.837
<v Unidentified speaker>I won't support 4.

1519
02:09:41.649 --> 02:09:44.375
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we treat that as a further motion to divide, Councilor Zimmerman?

1520
02:09:48.134 --> 02:09:49.086
<v Unidentified speaker>Certainly.

1521
02:09:49.391 --> 02:09:51.920
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm not really sure why you've grouped so many things together.

1522
02:09:52.002 --> 02:09:54.923
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm usually, you know, we do an amendment, do an amendment, do amendments.

1523
02:09:57.407 --> 02:10:03.381
<v Unidentified speaker>So I certainly would prefer it that way because I think amendments should stand on their own because these are not just like a bunch of technical changes.

1524
02:10:03.493 --> 02:10:05.128
<v Unidentified speaker>These are a bunch of substantive changes.

1525
02:10:05.194 --> 02:10:11.551
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm not sure what the thought was when the council president read off all the things from the last meeting.

1526
02:10:11.600 --> 02:10:18.354
<v Unidentified speaker>Frankly, I was like trying to catch up to what the divide was about, but I just wanted to signal for you where I was at.

1527
02:10:18.514 --> 02:10:23.006
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, in that case, if— hey, let's see.

1528
02:10:23.792 --> 02:10:26.534
<v Unidentified speaker>I think the only way for you to do that is to further divide.

1529
02:10:26.711 --> 02:10:30.480
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll move myself.

1530
02:10:30.545 --> 02:10:35.645
<v Unidentified speaker>Can I move to further divide let's say 3 and 6 from 4.

1531
02:10:37.365 --> 02:10:39.167
<v Unidentified speaker>Point of information.

1532
02:10:39.230 --> 02:10:41.194
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, I'm in the queue and I was gonna share—.

1533
02:10:41.305 --> 02:10:43.640
<v Unidentified speaker>I was gonna divide the question, so maybe I could.

1534
02:10:44.203 --> 02:10:44.478
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Great.

1535
02:10:44.640 --> 02:10:45.720
<v Unidentified speaker>Are you dividing all of them?

1536
02:10:45.769 --> 02:10:47.494
<v Unidentified speaker>Because I think we just need to divide all of them.

1537
02:10:48.318 --> 02:10:54.985
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I was— since Councilor Zimmerman said his issue was with 4, which was part of a package with 3 and 6, I was just separating out 4.

1538
02:10:56.314 --> 02:11:03.530
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, if we— if we— if it's— if it's simp— if it's actually simpler to vote on all of them individually, then I think it would be.

1539
02:11:03.773 --> 02:11:04.708
<v Unidentified speaker>That would be my preference.

1540
02:11:04.903 --> 02:11:05.081
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1541
02:11:05.306 --> 02:11:07.567
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, do I need to move that, or—.

1542
02:11:07.567 --> 02:11:10.472
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's what Councilor Novick is dividing the question.

1543
02:11:11.448 --> 02:11:12.573
<v Steve Novick>Okay, so I'll move that.

1544
02:11:12.654 --> 02:11:13.046
<v Unidentified speaker>There we go.

1545
02:11:13.127 --> 02:11:19.199
<v Unidentified speaker>We will vote on each of the amendments sequentially, so we will start, okay, with Novick 3.

1546
02:11:19.797 --> 02:11:21.917
<v Unidentified speaker>And is there further discussion on Novick 3?

1547
02:11:24.582 --> 02:11:33.953
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, just because we are coming back after many weeks, it would be helpful if you could just, at the beginning of each amendment, just give us a quick rationale, Councilor Novick, before we vote?

1548
02:11:35.472 --> 02:11:35.750
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure.

1549
02:11:36.188 --> 02:11:39.194
<v Unidentified speaker>I thought I tried to do that earlier, but I'll emphasize.

1550
02:11:40.739 --> 02:11:45.015
<v Unidentified speaker>There's a list of crimes that are defined as nuisance activities.

1551
02:11:45.757 --> 02:11:56.007
<v Unidentified speaker>And in our original proposal, or maybe it was the original law, it included loitering to solicit prostitution and prostitution-related offenses.

1552
02:11:56.841 --> 02:12:03.895
<v Unidentified speaker>After listening to public testimony, we realized that that could be construed as we're targeting sex workers, which is not the intent.

1553
02:12:04.712 --> 02:12:12.920
<v Unidentified speaker>So we removed those 2 from the list of nuisance activities but added human trafficking-related offenses as defined in ORS.

1554
02:12:14.329 --> 02:12:19.893
<v Unidentified speaker>So that those are crimes where the focus is on the traffickers and the buyers.

1555
02:12:21.143 --> 02:12:32.735
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's just a matter of thank you, Councilor.

1556
02:12:33.331 --> 02:12:34.538
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Avalos, further question?

1557
02:12:35.783 --> 02:12:35.929
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1558
02:12:36.268 --> 02:12:36.833
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Green.

1559
02:12:37.626 --> 02:12:39.645
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Council President.

1560
02:12:39.953 --> 02:12:46.234
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick, just speaking to Novick 3, I'm supporting this amendment.

1561
02:12:46.556 --> 02:12:54.800
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it deals with one of my biggest pieces of heartache, which was the ordinance that was passed in 2018 that You know, sort of anti-sex worker language here.

1562
02:12:55.073 --> 02:12:56.770
<v Unidentified speaker>I think this is an improvement on that.

1563
02:12:56.850 --> 02:12:59.238
<v Unidentified speaker>And so for that reason, I'm prepared to support Novick 3.

1564
02:13:00.121 --> 02:13:00.826
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1565
02:13:01.882 --> 02:13:02.908
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1566
02:13:03.983 --> 02:13:04.815
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Council President.

1567
02:13:04.863 --> 02:13:25.318
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick, I just want to thank you for working through the language on this piece of it, hearing the feedback that was given, and making sure that we are putting something in place that really does target Human trafficking and the offenses that we are concerned with and does not inadvertently catch up people who are doing work.

1568
02:13:25.899 --> 02:13:26.078
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1569
02:13:26.853 --> 02:13:27.886
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1570
02:13:30.501 --> 02:13:34.698
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue, can we please call the roll on Novick 3?

1571
02:13:38.202 --> 02:13:38.760
<v Unidentified speaker>Our mics aren't working.

1572
02:13:41.837 --> 02:13:42.158
<v Unidentified speaker>They are now.

1573
02:13:43.220 --> 02:13:43.444
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1574
02:13:43.846 --> 02:13:43.895
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1575
02:13:45.712 --> 02:13:46.194
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

1576
02:13:46.500 --> 02:13:46.661
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1577
02:13:47.546 --> 02:13:47.770
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan.

1578
02:13:48.109 --> 02:13:48.157
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1579
02:13:49.460 --> 02:13:52.676
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane, absent.

1580
02:13:53.453 --> 02:13:53.841
<v Unidentified speaker>Morillo.

1581
02:13:54.649 --> 02:13:54.698
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1582
02:13:56.039 --> 02:13:56.380
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick.

1583
02:13:56.752 --> 02:13:56.800
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1584
02:13:57.577 --> 02:13:57.965
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark.

1585
02:13:58.207 --> 02:13:58.238
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1586
02:13:59.000 --> 02:13:59.194
<v Unidentified speaker>Green.

1587
02:13:59.501 --> 02:13:59.548
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1588
02:14:00.163 --> 02:14:00.617
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

1589
02:14:00.876 --> 02:14:00.891
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1590
02:14:01.538 --> 02:14:01.911
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

1591
02:14:02.331 --> 02:14:02.380
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1592
02:14:03.140 --> 02:14:03.689
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, sorry.

1593
02:14:04.287 --> 02:14:05.257
<v Keelan McClymont>Nope.

1594
02:14:05.582 --> 02:14:07.911
<v Unidentified speaker>My order is a little bit out of order.

1595
02:14:07.990 --> 02:14:08.104
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry.

1596
02:14:10.393 --> 02:14:10.408
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1597
02:14:12.966 --> 02:14:13.564
<v Unidentified speaker>Absent.

1598
02:14:13.792 --> 02:14:14.131
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

1599
02:14:14.828 --> 02:14:14.876
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1600
02:14:16.203 --> 02:14:16.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1601
02:14:17.417 --> 02:14:21.590
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendment is approved with a vote of 10 aye votes and 2 absent.

1602
02:14:22.328 --> 02:14:22.730
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1603
02:14:23.148 --> 02:14:27.261
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick, could you give us another just brief one sentence on Novick 4?

1604
02:14:27.743 --> 02:14:29.920
<v Unidentified speaker>It might take a little more than one sentence.

1605
02:14:30.307 --> 02:14:50.988
<v Unidentified speaker>So Novick 4 relates to the timeline after the city has notified somebody that their property there's a timeline for reaching an agreement for what steps the owner will take to mitigate the nuisance, or— and then when the nuisance is actually abated.

1606
02:14:51.167 --> 02:15:08.993
<v Unidentified speaker>So basically it says— the amendment says that if no agreement concerning abatement is reached within 60 days— it was 30— or if an agreed-upon course of action does not result in the abatement of the nuisance activities within 90 days, the city will issue a notice of the city administrator, the designees may refer the matter to the city attorney.

1607
02:15:09.667 --> 02:15:14.244
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's lengthening the timelines for that negotiation and for the actual abatement of the nuisance.

1608
02:15:14.887 --> 02:15:15.850
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1609
02:15:16.317 --> 02:15:17.024
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman.

1610
02:15:17.761 --> 02:15:19.256
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, it all sounds good.

1611
02:15:19.368 --> 02:15:23.640
<v Unidentified speaker>I'd encourage you to put yourself in the position of a person who lives next to a nuisance property.

1612
02:15:23.784 --> 02:15:27.671
<v Unidentified speaker>You've already gone through a 90-day period and you're about to add another 90 days to it.

1613
02:15:27.752 --> 02:15:39.104
<v Unidentified speaker>So, uh, in that case, a half a year where people can drag their feet, allow bad behavior, have screaming, have nuisance, have whatever activity happening.

1614
02:15:39.634 --> 02:15:57.440
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would encourage you to just think about what that means in all of your constituent relations as you're trying to work through a problem, and that we are not quick to determine if a property is a nuisance to then give another longer period.

1615
02:15:57.586 --> 02:16:04.296
<v Unidentified speaker>I think we are being nice at this, at the Portland polite level of extremism.

1616
02:16:04.945 --> 02:16:14.421
<v Unidentified speaker>And this is an area where once you've been identified as a nuisance property in this type of behavior, we're not a city who applies these standards loosely.

1617
02:16:14.711 --> 02:16:19.403
<v Unidentified speaker>In fact, watching this occur is very— it's not used often.

1618
02:16:19.756 --> 02:16:23.614
<v Unidentified speaker>And so we're using it in cases where I think extreme situations have occurred.

1619
02:16:23.663 --> 02:16:24.123
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's a good point.

1620
02:16:25.037 --> 02:16:32.950
<v Unidentified speaker>So I wouldn't ask your neighbors— I'm not going to ask my neighbors to then give another 90 days to somebody who is not working with us to put a solution together.

1621
02:16:32.998 --> 02:16:35.148
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's why I'm going to vote no, and I'd encourage you to do the same.

1622
02:16:36.254 --> 02:16:37.280
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1623
02:16:40.888 --> 02:16:44.736
<v Unidentified speaker>Seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, could we please call the roll on Novick 4?

1624
02:16:46.204 --> 02:16:56.230
<v Unidentified speaker>And I would like to clarify really quickly or confirm that The motions for all of these were moved by Councilor Novick and seconded by Councilor Ryan.

1625
02:16:57.386 --> 02:16:58.106
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that correct?

1626
02:16:59.292 --> 02:16:59.468
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1627
02:17:00.592 --> 02:17:08.206
<v Unidentified speaker>The original motion, uh, not the motion to divide, but the original motion to move the amendments was seconded by you back in March.

1628
02:17:08.606 --> 02:17:10.450
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that still— That does seem like a long time ago.

1629
02:17:10.594 --> 02:17:12.663
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so what's my question?

1630
02:17:12.710 --> 02:17:13.399
<v Unidentified speaker>Am I good with this?

1631
02:17:13.479 --> 02:17:16.269
<v Unidentified speaker>I just need to confirm for the record that we have a second.

1632
02:17:16.350 --> 02:17:18.452
<v Unidentified speaker>Second on this particular—.

1633
02:17:18.532 --> 02:17:19.673
<v Jamie Dunphy>On all of the amendments.

1634
02:17:20.861 --> 02:17:23.959
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure, it'll save time.

1635
02:17:24.554 --> 02:17:31.185
<v Unidentified speaker>So Ryan, if you have cold feet on any of them, I will replace your second, but let's get to that after we move forward here.

1636
02:17:31.539 --> 02:17:34.253
<v Unidentified speaker>The timeline one has me questioning.

1637
02:17:34.942 --> 02:17:36.581
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, I'll offer a second on this one.

1638
02:17:36.870 --> 02:17:38.362
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, okay, thank you.

1639
02:17:38.540 --> 02:17:40.306
<v Unidentified speaker>How friendly was that?

1640
02:17:40.707 --> 02:17:40.995
<v Unidentified speaker>Very.

1641
02:17:41.173 --> 02:17:41.574
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1642
02:17:42.468 --> 02:17:42.888
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1643
02:17:43.601 --> 02:17:45.039
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Kanal.

1644
02:17:45.879 --> 02:17:46.333
<v Unidentified speaker>On Novick 4.

1645
02:17:46.608 --> 02:17:46.881
<v Unidentified speaker>For 4.

1646
02:17:47.028 --> 02:17:47.075
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1647
02:17:47.496 --> 02:17:48.564
<v Sameer Kanal>Wait, where are we?

1648
02:17:48.628 --> 02:17:49.452
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney.

1649
02:17:49.986 --> 02:17:50.147
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1650
02:17:50.795 --> 02:17:50.940
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan.

1651
02:17:51.293 --> 02:17:51.664
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm sorry.

1652
02:17:52.501 --> 02:17:53.354
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, sorry.

1653
02:17:53.611 --> 02:17:53.853
<v Unidentified speaker>Is there—.

1654
02:17:53.950 --> 02:17:56.495
<v Unidentified speaker>We're on 5.

1655
02:17:56.849 --> 02:17:57.670
<v Unidentified speaker>We're on 4.

1656
02:17:58.941 --> 02:17:59.022
<v Keelan McClymont>4.

1657
02:17:59.200 --> 02:17:59.634
<v Unidentified speaker>Still on 4.

1658
02:17:59.988 --> 02:18:00.811
<v Unidentified speaker>We voted on 3.

1659
02:18:00.861 --> 02:18:01.944
<v Eric Zimmerman>To the no on 4.

1660
02:18:05.084 --> 02:18:11.353
<v Unidentified speaker>And I didn't say anything earlier, so I will just say Very quickly, we had something similar to this in permitting work.

1661
02:18:11.806 --> 02:18:14.434
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I understood Eric's comments.

1662
02:18:14.531 --> 02:18:14.887
<v Unidentified speaker>I vote no.

1663
02:18:17.440 --> 02:18:17.924
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

1664
02:18:19.557 --> 02:18:19.897
<v Unidentified speaker>Absent.

1665
02:18:19.977 --> 02:18:21.076
<v Unidentified speaker>Murillo?

1666
02:18:22.095 --> 02:18:29.252
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, I know that we're like going through this quickly and I'm trying to process the language changes and all of the amendments as we're voting.

1667
02:18:29.674 --> 02:18:30.957
<v Keelan McClymont>Apologies.

1668
02:18:31.412 --> 02:18:32.061
<v Unidentified speaker>No, it's okay.

1669
02:18:33.301 --> 02:18:41.138
<v Unidentified speaker>I think I will vote yes on the amendment because I think it improves it, but I think maybe I have a question for the underlying ordinance after that.

1670
02:18:41.314 --> 02:18:48.413
<v Unidentified speaker>As far as, is a property designated a chronic nuisance based on 2 incidents in 90 days?

1671
02:18:48.540 --> 02:18:51.137
<v Unidentified speaker>So that doesn't have to be convictions, arrests, or charges.

1672
02:18:52.370 --> 02:18:53.092
<v Unidentified speaker>Is that correct?

1673
02:18:54.052 --> 02:19:06.625
<v Unidentified speaker>We're actually proposing to change 2 in 90 to 3 in 90, and it would It's based on documentation in the police report, which states that the police officer has found probable cause to believe that this activity exists.

1674
02:19:08.248 --> 02:19:15.907
<v Unidentified speaker>But so probable cause, my understanding, is not a very high bar because it's enough for arrest, not for adjudication.

1675
02:19:17.269 --> 02:19:19.773
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're like, anyone could call the cops on anyone.

1676
02:19:23.209 --> 02:19:26.962
<v Unidentified speaker>Well, but officers are used to dealing with the concept of probable cause.

1677
02:19:27.305 --> 02:19:28.202
<v Unidentified speaker>It is a real standard.

1678
02:19:29.444 --> 02:19:39.945
<v Unidentified speaker>But it is true that if you want to have a conviction for a nuisance activity as a basis for designation nuisance activity, this does not do that.

1679
02:19:40.025 --> 02:19:40.186
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1680
02:19:40.346 --> 02:19:42.948
<v Unidentified speaker>And colleagues, we are in a vote.

1681
02:19:43.076 --> 02:19:43.638
<v Unidentified speaker>I just want to make sure.

1682
02:19:43.879 --> 02:19:44.923
<v Unidentified speaker>I apologize, Councilor.

1683
02:19:45.341 --> 02:19:46.721
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, sure.

1684
02:19:46.850 --> 02:19:51.683
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm a yes on the amendment, and then I will have that question coming for when we discuss it further.

1685
02:19:51.763 --> 02:19:53.064
<v Unidentified speaker>We will discuss the underlying for sure.

1686
02:19:53.128 --> 02:19:53.657
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1687
02:19:57.600 --> 02:19:58.421
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, sorry.

1688
02:19:58.566 --> 02:20:00.691
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, so Morillo, how— what was the vote?

1689
02:20:00.996 --> 02:20:01.529
<v Angelita Morillo>That was a yes.

1690
02:20:01.801 --> 02:20:02.527
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, thank you.

1691
02:20:02.688 --> 02:20:02.945
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry.

1692
02:20:03.799 --> 02:20:04.218
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Novick?

1693
02:20:04.603 --> 02:20:04.653
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1694
02:20:06.360 --> 02:20:06.552
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark?

1695
02:20:06.795 --> 02:20:07.020
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1696
02:20:07.922 --> 02:20:08.131
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

1697
02:20:08.791 --> 02:20:08.808
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1698
02:20:09.436 --> 02:20:09.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

1699
02:20:10.500 --> 02:20:10.661
<v Olivia Clark>No.

1700
02:20:11.306 --> 02:20:11.595
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

1701
02:20:12.256 --> 02:20:12.305
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1702
02:20:13.787 --> 02:20:14.013
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

1703
02:20:15.481 --> 02:20:15.984
<v Loretta Smith>Absent.

1704
02:20:16.179 --> 02:20:16.519
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1705
02:20:17.264 --> 02:20:17.313
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1706
02:20:18.658 --> 02:20:29.774
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendment is approved with a vote of 7 ayes We move to Novick 5, please.

1707
02:20:30.829 --> 02:20:32.254
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick.

1708
02:20:32.560 --> 02:20:33.596
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Mr. President.

1709
02:20:34.809 --> 02:20:39.325
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick 5 makes some edits to the section on abatement measures.

1710
02:20:41.069 --> 02:21:05.977
<v Unidentified speaker>One is that the court, in determining whether to order somebody to take abatement measures, is supposed to take a variety of factors into account, including the sort of financial impact and so we decided that, that the same standard should apply to the city administrator or designee in determining what abatement measures should be included in an agreement.

1711
02:21:06.409 --> 02:21:11.353
<v Unidentified speaker>The city administrator should consider the same factors that the court has to consider.

1712
02:21:12.144 --> 02:21:40.587
<v Unidentified speaker>And then we also, as a potential abatement activity, and we, I think we did have sex trafficking in mind when we had this in, One abatement activity designated to something that you could do is work with peer-led groups, including on-property visits, to increase availability of resources, services, and support, and communicate information about resources for victims, including support groups, advocate information, and the National Human Trafficking Hotline.

1713
02:21:41.021 --> 02:21:47.542
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're adding that to the list of abatement activities as sort of a menu of possibilities.

1714
02:21:47.996 --> 02:21:50.316
<v Unidentified speaker>So we're adding that to the list of possibilities.

1715
02:21:51.079 --> 02:21:52.216
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1716
02:21:52.361 --> 02:21:54.048
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, discussion of Novick 5?

1717
02:21:54.324 --> 02:21:55.004
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Murillo?

1718
02:21:58.194 --> 02:21:59.361
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't have anything on this.

1719
02:21:59.490 --> 02:22:00.609
<v Unidentified speaker>I think these are good improvements.

1720
02:22:01.336 --> 02:22:01.466
<v Unidentified speaker>Great.

1721
02:22:02.000 --> 02:22:02.774
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman?

1722
02:22:03.388 --> 02:22:03.775
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1723
02:22:08.554 --> 02:22:13.039
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor— pausing for more dramatic effect because I feel bad cutting off Councilor Murillo earlier.

1724
02:22:14.792 --> 02:22:18.811
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, can we please move to a vote on Novick 5?

1725
02:22:21.932 --> 02:22:22.629
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1726
02:22:23.862 --> 02:22:23.943
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1727
02:22:25.404 --> 02:22:25.468
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1728
02:22:27.027 --> 02:22:27.546
<v Unidentified speaker>Absent.

1729
02:22:33.381 --> 02:22:35.016
<v Unidentified speaker>Are we moving through these too quickly?

1730
02:22:35.082 --> 02:22:40.934
<v Unidentified speaker>Because I'm hearing nos and then I'm not understanding the logic, and I would love to hear people's answers as to why.

1731
02:22:42.525 --> 02:22:51.282
<v Unidentified speaker>I just, uh, like, this is— to be honest, these are a lot of amendments that we are going through in a, in a reading at full council, so I'm trying to understand.

1732
02:22:54.020 --> 02:22:55.465
<v Unidentified speaker>All right, are we just pushing along?

1733
02:22:55.641 --> 02:22:58.100
<v Unidentified speaker>Because it— Councilor Kanal, can you say why?

1734
02:22:59.031 --> 02:22:59.370
<v Unidentified speaker>Can I?

1735
02:23:00.140 --> 02:23:03.209
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I'm happy to give Councilor—.

1736
02:23:03.209 --> 02:23:10.028
<v Unidentified speaker>Let Councilor Kanal do this, but also I'm trying to move us forward when no one was in the queue, so I, I—.

1737
02:23:10.477 --> 02:23:10.975
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, please.

1738
02:23:11.231 --> 02:23:11.745
<v Unidentified speaker>A question.

1739
02:23:11.922 --> 02:23:19.079
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, as a presiding officer, yeah, we're, we're normally allowing 1 or 2 sentences, you know, sure, as part of explaining the vote.

1740
02:23:19.225 --> 02:23:19.400
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure.

1741
02:23:19.737 --> 02:23:20.653
<v Unidentified speaker>So may I revise?

1742
02:23:21.005 --> 02:23:21.471
<v Unidentified speaker>Absolutely.

1743
02:23:21.647 --> 02:23:49.218
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, given that context, because I do not believe we should be adding more and more abatement measures and making it hard applying the same standard of the court, which I think will ultimately lead to more— I think that this amendment maximizes the, the impact on the, uh, the people who are 199 feet away from a nuisance activity.

1744
02:23:49.573 --> 02:23:50.797
<v Unidentified speaker>And for that reason, I'm voting no.

1745
02:23:52.110 --> 02:23:52.936
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1746
02:23:57.251 --> 02:23:58.707
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, I think we're back in the vote.

1747
02:24:00.072 --> 02:24:02.006
<v Unidentified speaker>Unless— are other people going to say something else?

1748
02:24:03.441 --> 02:24:03.602
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

1749
02:24:04.166 --> 02:24:05.424
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I'm an aye.

1750
02:24:06.745 --> 02:24:07.132
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1751
02:24:08.777 --> 02:24:10.102
<v Unidentified speaker>Sorry, just to confirm, that was aye?

1752
02:24:10.717 --> 02:24:11.282
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, thank you.

1753
02:24:11.591 --> 02:24:13.225
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Novick?

1754
02:24:13.613 --> 02:24:13.662
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1755
02:24:14.277 --> 02:24:14.665
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark?

1756
02:24:14.908 --> 02:24:14.957
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1757
02:24:15.572 --> 02:24:15.863
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

1758
02:24:17.255 --> 02:24:17.416
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1759
02:24:18.194 --> 02:24:18.372
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

1760
02:24:18.649 --> 02:24:18.877
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

1761
02:24:19.771 --> 02:24:20.079
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

1762
02:24:20.355 --> 02:24:20.518
<v Candace Avalos>No.

1763
02:24:21.801 --> 02:24:22.030
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

1764
02:24:22.777 --> 02:24:23.281
<v Unidentified speaker>Absent.

1765
02:24:23.524 --> 02:24:23.816
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

1766
02:24:24.320 --> 02:24:24.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1767
02:24:25.308 --> 02:24:29.985
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendment is approved with a vote of 7 ayes, 3 nos, and 2 absent.

1768
02:24:30.899 --> 02:24:31.125
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1769
02:24:33.189 --> 02:24:34.236
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick 6.

1770
02:24:35.027 --> 02:24:35.671
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick.

1771
02:24:36.799 --> 02:24:38.509
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, thank you, Mr. President.

1772
02:24:38.588 --> 02:24:49.213
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick 6 again, um, moves the standard for chronic nuisance property from 2 nuisance activities in 90 days to 3 in 90 days.

1773
02:24:50.068 --> 02:25:08.739
<v Unidentified speaker>And again, It says that rather than just simply saying that the city administrator can act to designate a nuisance property based on police reports, quote unquote, it has to be reports that a police officer has determined that probable cause exists to believe that a nuisance activity has occurred.

1774
02:25:09.173 --> 02:25:16.747
<v Unidentified speaker>So this actually adds a strong— I mean, strengthens the standard from what it was before because it didn't actually say what the police report had to say.

1775
02:25:16.811 --> 02:25:17.037
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1776
02:25:18.286 --> 02:25:28.880
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's not a matter of— it's not a matter of previously the nuisance law said that it could only be— invocation could only be based on a conviction.

1777
02:25:29.384 --> 02:25:30.600
<v Unidentified speaker>It's never been that.

1778
02:25:31.329 --> 02:25:35.140
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's sort of— it's, you know, in a way, the intention is to sort of tighten it up.

1779
02:25:37.585 --> 02:25:38.617
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1780
02:25:39.502 --> 02:25:42.191
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, discussion to Novick 6?

1781
02:25:42.481 --> 02:25:42.965
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman.

1782
02:25:44.268 --> 02:25:51.433
<v Unidentified speaker>So there's some comments earlier about what constitutes, you know, an offense in this case.

1783
02:25:51.497 --> 02:26:04.370
<v Unidentified speaker>And I just— I think that when you're dealing with properties, and I do think we've been going through these too fast, and this probably should have just been scheduled immediately thereafter in the following meeting, because I think we have moved through some stuff with a little bit of loss.

1784
02:26:04.417 --> 02:26:09.050
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, a lot of weeks have gone by, and I think that's a fair thing to, like, remember the entire conversation.

1785
02:26:09.114 --> 02:26:09.338
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Smith.

1786
02:26:10.173 --> 02:26:22.879
<v Unidentified speaker>But in property code, in property nuisance issues, we're really not talking about did it go to a court of law and then get proven at a court of law that a thing happened.

1787
02:26:22.976 --> 02:26:24.242
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not what nuisance is.

1788
02:26:24.417 --> 02:26:30.154
<v Unidentified speaker>Nuisance is largely based on code compliance officers and officers' ability to observe a thing.

1789
02:26:30.362 --> 02:26:46.779
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think that largely this has gotten thrown into the category Because of the way it was free— it was prefaced during the committee brief about being along the reins of, of prostitution, human trafficking.

1790
02:26:46.890 --> 02:27:02.966
<v Unidentified speaker>But frankly, most all of this could have been written without ever mentioning those words or without ever really focusing on those, those activities, because what this is really about is some of the stuff that comes with it that is certainly a nuisance in the neighborhood.

1791
02:27:03.014 --> 02:27:03.127
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1792
02:27:03.495 --> 02:27:10.111
<v Unidentified speaker>A nuisance on the block, and that that part of it is not about it.

1793
02:27:10.272 --> 02:27:11.620
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not about the sex work.

1794
02:27:11.684 --> 02:27:13.242
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not about a buyer.

1795
02:27:13.547 --> 02:27:15.505
<v Unidentified speaker>Those those parts of our code are not changing.

1796
02:27:15.554 --> 02:27:16.245
<v Unidentified speaker>We have all those.

1797
02:27:16.773 --> 02:27:29.153
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think we've gotten a little bit cross-eyed just in terms of there's a lot of reaction to a a changing topic in our community, and one that I think government is getting better about targeting the right part of a chronic issue.

1798
02:27:29.250 --> 02:27:29.666
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1799
02:27:30.165 --> 02:27:35.707
<v Unidentified speaker>But, but on this, um, you know, moving to 3 in a 90-day, that makes sense to me.

1800
02:27:35.787 --> 02:27:37.072
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll be supportive of it.

1801
02:27:37.152 --> 02:27:47.111
<v Unidentified speaker>But I am speaking to it because applying, applying the same standard of you have to go to court to get proven for things, that's just not how this will go.

1802
02:27:47.208 --> 02:28:04.025
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I just wanted to raise that given how we use property nuisance codes across the city, and you could talk about it for It could be somebody who, you know, has something going on in their lawn that is just— it's not safe for the general public to go around.

1803
02:28:04.105 --> 02:28:12.492
<v Unidentified speaker>We would apply very similar types of nuisance abatement issues, and I think that that's important to keep in mind here.

1804
02:28:13.807 --> 02:28:19.099
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's more of what this underlying ordinance is about than some of the other stuff.

1805
02:28:19.611 --> 02:28:21.086
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think 6 is a fine change.

1806
02:28:21.360 --> 02:28:21.617
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1807
02:28:21.665 --> 02:28:21.985
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Herbold.

1808
02:28:22.711 --> 02:28:23.585
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1809
02:28:24.022 --> 02:28:24.620
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Maria.

1810
02:28:28.048 --> 02:28:30.118
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks for that, Councilor Zimmerman.

1811
02:28:30.327 --> 02:28:41.379
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, I think that is actually what concerns me, though, is that this is being painted as something that addresses human trafficking, and you have, I think, stated more plainly that it actually doesn't.

1812
02:28:44.073 --> 02:28:58.665
<v Unidentified speaker>Because, again, if the requirement is that it's a chronic nuisance based on 2 or more you know, three or multiple incidents within 90 days, and it's a police report with probable cause.

1813
02:28:58.778 --> 02:29:11.334
<v Unidentified speaker>And we know that police officers can say almost anything is probable cause to arrest somebody, and that there tends to be racial profiling in how they do all of that, and who they tend to target, what businesses they tend to target.

1814
02:29:12.746 --> 02:29:16.825
<v Unidentified speaker>I have a hard time understanding how this is going to be helping in that.

1815
02:29:21.102 --> 02:29:37.783
<v Unidentified speaker>Because under nuisance code, if an officer believes that someone took a substantial step toward disorderly conduct, that's one of your incidents, even if the person had a lawful reason to be there, even if no crime was actually committed.

1816
02:29:40.837 --> 02:29:42.197
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's kind of where I'm struggling with this.

1817
02:29:42.246 --> 02:29:42.432
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Smith.

1818
02:29:44.406 --> 02:29:47.668
<v Unidentified speaker>And association by location.

1819
02:29:47.797 --> 02:30:02.003
<v Unidentified speaker>Like, if our neighborhoods are pretty dense, so I'm just struggling with like, if it's 200 feet away from a property, if you're at a bus stop and something is happening near your property, you're going to be held liable for things that you're not directly responsible for.

1820
02:30:02.229 --> 02:30:05.354
<v Unidentified speaker>I just have a lot of questions about this as a whole.

1821
02:30:06.368 --> 02:30:07.593
<v Unidentified speaker>Mr. President, could I respond to that?

1822
02:30:07.675 --> 02:30:08.067
<v Unidentified speaker>Absolutely.

1823
02:30:08.159 --> 02:30:09.524
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1824
02:30:09.654 --> 02:30:16.788
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll actually take up your second issue first, Councilor Morillo.

1825
02:30:17.656 --> 02:30:27.474
<v Unidentified speaker>This only applies when a person associated with the property has committed a nuisance offense.

1826
02:30:27.619 --> 02:30:43.985
<v Unidentified speaker>And a person associated with the property means a person who, on the occasion of a nuisance activity, has entered, patronized, Or a person present on the property, including without limitation any officer, director, customer, agent, employee, or any independent contractor of a property, person in charge, or owner of a property.

1827
02:30:44.032 --> 02:30:51.659
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's not just the activity occurred within 200 feet of the business, it's the activity was done by somebody who had this association with the property.

1828
02:30:52.703 --> 02:30:53.539
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's one thing.

1829
02:30:53.843 --> 02:30:54.888
<v Unidentified speaker>Can I ask a follow-up on that?

1830
02:30:55.161 --> 02:30:55.369
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure.

1831
02:30:55.915 --> 02:30:56.990
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, that's helpful.

1832
02:30:57.488 --> 02:31:11.036
<v Unidentified speaker>Does that mean that okay, if I'm a hotel owner and someone stayed at my hotel and then later they did human trafficking at a bus stop or something, does that mean because they stayed at my hotel that they had association with me?

1833
02:31:11.823 --> 02:31:14.200
<v Unidentified speaker>It says on the occasion of a nuisance activity.

1834
02:31:14.650 --> 02:31:21.637
<v Unidentified speaker>So it's basically to get at you're sort of using the property as a base for the nuisance activity.

1835
02:31:24.297 --> 02:31:42.989
<v Unidentified speaker>And what I will note is this is another instance where we have actually tightened up the preexisting law, 'cause the preexisting law, and this we did in amendments approved in committee, the preexisting law said that it also applied if a person attempted to visit the property.

1836
02:31:43.879 --> 02:31:45.271
<v Unidentified speaker>We decided that was too broad.

1837
02:31:45.319 --> 02:31:50.582
<v Unidentified speaker>You shouldn't hold a property owner responsible for the activities of somebody who didn't actually visit, but just attempted to visit.

1838
02:31:51.405 --> 02:31:51.599
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1839
02:31:54.427 --> 02:32:07.476
<v Unidentified speaker>And the other thing I just wanted to mention on the, the issue of the probable cause issue is that the city can't itself on its own force a property owner to undertake mitigation activities.

1840
02:32:07.893 --> 02:32:14.690
<v Unidentified speaker>The city instigates a negotiation with the property owner, but only a court can force the property owner to do something.

1841
02:32:15.138 --> 02:32:19.658
<v Unidentified speaker>So ultimately, the city would have to go to court and the court would have to make that determination.

1842
02:32:19.707 --> 02:32:19.898
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1843
02:32:22.155 --> 02:32:25.890
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, that makes sense.

1844
02:32:26.118 --> 02:32:37.218
<v Unidentified speaker>I think maybe the tension here is the inherent trust or distrust of our criminal justice system and how it will be applied to these different people and property owners.

1845
02:32:37.814 --> 02:32:41.056
<v Unidentified speaker>Because I think you're right, there is going to be a court process.

1846
02:32:41.525 --> 02:32:53.966
<v Unidentified speaker>Whether that due process to force the sale of someone's property based on police reports exactly the question that this ordinance is going to be litigated over at the city's expense.

1847
02:32:54.911 --> 02:33:01.977
<v Unidentified speaker>So, Councilor, I just have to say that instances where property is forced to be sold are going to be exceedingly rare.

1848
02:33:02.746 --> 02:33:06.961
<v Unidentified speaker>Normally would be the court would order the property owner to take certain mitigation measures.

1849
02:33:07.539 --> 02:33:07.666
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah.

1850
02:33:08.051 --> 02:33:12.138
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, and then we'll be asking council members to vote on the ordinance.

1851
02:33:12.610 --> 02:33:13.704
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, sure.

1852
02:33:15.057 --> 02:33:17.119
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, thank you, Councilor Murillo.

1853
02:33:17.843 --> 02:33:18.423
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Knoll.

1854
02:33:19.791 --> 02:33:20.097
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1855
02:33:20.177 --> 02:33:28.434
<v Unidentified speaker>First, I, I wanna say I agree with the assessment that Councilor Zimmerman gave, and I also agree with Councilor Murillo's point that that is in fact the concern.

1856
02:33:30.131 --> 02:33:35.384
<v Unidentified speaker>For— we're— because we're, we're still, I believe, technically on Novick 6.

1857
02:33:35.529 --> 02:33:35.641
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

1858
02:33:36.640 --> 02:33:41.394
<v Unidentified speaker>I, I wanna, I think the changes from 2 to 3 are all good.

1859
02:33:42.790 --> 02:33:45.697
<v Unidentified speaker>And so there's 4 things in this, 3 of them are changing 2 to 3.

1860
02:33:46.724 --> 02:33:49.630
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's why I think I'll probably be voting yes on this.

1861
02:33:49.759 --> 02:33:57.738
<v Unidentified speaker>I also agree that there's— it does narrow the scope to say that there— to say probable cause versus not.

1862
02:33:57.819 --> 02:34:10.675
<v Unidentified speaker>I think part of the challenge is, in my opinion, and I think each person's assessment of this are gonna be a little different, These are small changes that don't necessarily address the underlying big picture concern with the ordinance.

1863
02:34:11.126 --> 02:34:12.890
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'll be voting for this amendment.

1864
02:34:13.114 --> 02:34:17.784
<v Unidentified speaker>I think there's a broader conversation on the underlying to have that we should do.

1865
02:34:19.148 --> 02:34:52.466
<v Unidentified speaker>The one thing I did want to mention, because it was brought up in the debate, I don't know that it is— Councilor Novick, I want to just question one piece of the assessment definition of persons associated with, because what it says in here is persons associated with means any person who on the occasion of a nuisance activity has entered, patronized, or visited a property or person present on the property, including without limitation any officer, director, customer, agent, employee, or any independent contractor of a property, person in charge, or owner of a property.

1866
02:34:52.627 --> 02:35:03.985
<v Unidentified speaker>And it is factual to say that the text or attempted to enter, patronize, or visit, or waited to enter, patronize, or visit And that, I think, that is an improvement.

1867
02:35:04.066 --> 02:35:10.064
<v Unidentified speaker>But I don't know that I would go as far as to say that that means it has to have been used as a base.

1868
02:35:11.766 --> 02:35:15.447
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that is not as narrow as this text reads.

1869
02:35:16.185 --> 02:35:22.161
<v Unidentified speaker>And I want to just bring that up in the context of maybe that's an underlying conversation, but I wanted to mention it since it was brought up here.

1870
02:35:24.322 --> 02:35:24.934
<v Unidentified speaker>I appreciate that.

1871
02:35:25.129 --> 02:35:40.281
<v Unidentified speaker>I also want to note that I think that many of the objections here are to the existing law, not to the amendments I'm bringing, because actually in many cases we're trying to sort of tighten up the pre-existing law.

1872
02:35:40.826 --> 02:35:48.790
<v Unidentified speaker>So I think that, I mean, what we are trying to do, the big thing is extend 3 and 30 days to 3 and 90 days, and then a few other things.

1873
02:35:49.703 --> 02:35:57.131
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that the primary objections that we've heard are to the underlying law, not to thank you, Councilor Novick.

1874
02:35:58.748 --> 02:35:59.217
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Green.

1875
02:36:00.364 --> 02:36:01.852
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1876
02:36:01.899 --> 02:36:08.435
<v Unidentified speaker>That actually just gets right to my questions, and partly is because I'm not as informed about this as you are.

1877
02:36:09.664 --> 02:36:21.042
<v Unidentified speaker>So Novick 6, is Novick 6 in procedure sub A, is that just adjusting your also innovation, or is it adjusting something that already exists in law?

1878
02:36:21.125 --> 02:36:21.433
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you clarify that?

1879
02:36:21.621 --> 02:36:22.945
<v Unidentified speaker>Can you help me understand?

1880
02:36:23.156 --> 02:36:25.382
<v Unidentified speaker>There's probably 2 moving pieces there that I need to understand.

1881
02:36:25.915 --> 02:36:35.713
<v Unidentified speaker>So Novick 6, the 2 to 3, originally we started off with the existing law as 3 instances within 30 days.

1882
02:36:37.022 --> 02:36:40.406
<v Unidentified speaker>Out of committee, we passed 2 instances in 90 days.

1883
02:36:40.911 --> 02:37:02.281
<v Unidentified speaker>So now that we'll be changing that to 3 in 90 days, and the rest of it is currently, the city administrator can tell a person their property's been determined to be nuisance property based on 3 or more police reports without clarification.

1884
02:37:02.618 --> 02:37:06.559
<v Unidentified speaker>And we're saying police reports that an officer has determined probable cause, blah, blah, blah.

1885
02:37:06.799 --> 02:37:08.627
<v Unidentified speaker>So that's on top of currently existing law?

1886
02:37:08.802 --> 02:37:10.341
<v Unidentified speaker>That's on top of currently existing law.

1887
02:37:10.886 --> 02:37:14.331
<v Unidentified speaker>The 2 to 3 thingamabob, the currently existing law is 3 and 30.

1888
02:37:14.893 --> 02:37:18.168
<v Unidentified speaker>We've been committee, we had it at 2 and 90, now we're having it as 3 and 90.

1889
02:37:18.810 --> 02:37:19.084
<v Unidentified speaker>Got it.

1890
02:37:19.292 --> 02:37:21.588
<v Unidentified speaker>I can support Novick 6.

1891
02:37:21.637 --> 02:37:25.876
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it improves currently existing law and what has already been discussed.

1892
02:37:25.956 --> 02:37:26.212
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1893
02:37:26.918 --> 02:37:27.706
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1894
02:37:28.781 --> 02:37:30.002
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Knoll, is that a legacy?

1895
02:37:30.371 --> 02:37:30.548
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1896
02:37:31.993 --> 02:37:36.698
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, any further discussion of Councilor Novick's, I guess Novick 6?

1897
02:37:42.777 --> 02:37:44.181
<v Unidentified speaker>Could we please move to a roll call vote?

1898
02:37:44.875 --> 02:37:45.181
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

1899
02:37:46.407 --> 02:37:46.456
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1900
02:37:47.052 --> 02:37:48.085
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

1901
02:37:49.393 --> 02:37:49.441
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1902
02:37:51.280 --> 02:37:52.388
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1903
02:37:52.629 --> 02:37:52.838
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

1904
02:37:53.497 --> 02:37:53.546
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1905
02:37:54.703 --> 02:37:54.768
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1906
02:37:56.969 --> 02:37:57.308
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absent.

1907
02:37:57.452 --> 02:37:57.468
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1908
02:37:58.320 --> 02:37:58.369
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1909
02:37:59.350 --> 02:37:59.560
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

1910
02:38:00.097 --> 02:38:00.147
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1911
02:38:00.911 --> 02:38:01.074
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1912
02:38:02.049 --> 02:38:02.099
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1913
02:38:03.611 --> 02:38:03.823
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

1914
02:38:04.245 --> 02:38:04.407
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1915
02:38:04.994 --> 02:38:05.384
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

1916
02:38:08.190 --> 02:38:08.206
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1917
02:38:08.639 --> 02:38:09.283
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

1918
02:38:10.217 --> 02:38:10.265
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1919
02:38:11.038 --> 02:38:11.327
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

1920
02:38:12.067 --> 02:38:12.117
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1921
02:38:13.532 --> 02:38:17.959
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendment is approved with a vote of 11 ayes and 1 absent.

1922
02:38:18.507 --> 02:38:19.103
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

1923
02:38:20.215 --> 02:38:23.388
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, are you able to discuss Pirtle-Guiney 3?

1924
02:38:26.183 --> 02:38:28.004
<v Unidentified speaker>I will try if you can hear me all right.

1925
02:38:28.278 --> 02:38:28.728
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, we can.

1926
02:38:29.469 --> 02:38:29.775
<v Unidentified speaker>Perfect.

1927
02:38:29.825 --> 02:38:31.468
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'm sorry I had to leave, colleagues.

1928
02:38:31.645 --> 02:38:32.997
<v Unidentified speaker>I need to be somewhere by 5.

1929
02:38:34.751 --> 02:38:49.697
<v Unidentified speaker>So Pirtle-Guiney 3 is admittedly confusing looking because we were trying to note how it changed from the originally submitted Pirtle-Guiney 2 when we were first looking at this and that amendment had been submitted early.

1930
02:38:50.290 --> 02:39:11.263
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would ask you, when you look at Pirtle-Guiney 3, to— the, the parts that are being proposed as changes are in the The first paragraph, the addition of the words of delivery of the notice, and then the entirety of the new sub-5 that is listed here.

1931
02:39:12.018 --> 02:39:15.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, please ignore the highlights and other notations.

1932
02:39:15.566 --> 02:39:18.504
<v Unidentified speaker>This is an amendment to an amendment to an amended version.

1933
02:39:19.565 --> 02:39:52.611
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, what Pirtle-Guiney 3 does is attempts in 2 ways When I first read Councilor Novick's ordinance, I was concerned that a property owner could have action taken against them when they hadn't in fact received the notice because somebody else had either knowingly or unknowingly intercepted the notice.

1934
02:39:52.658 --> 02:39:53.815
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick, accepted it.

1935
02:39:54.296 --> 02:39:58.199
<v Unidentified speaker>So this clarifies when that clock begins.

1936
02:39:58.311 --> 02:40:10.807
<v Unidentified speaker>It's 14 days— within 14, or it is at 14 days of delivery of the notice, not just when the city has, has processed it, but it may take a while to get to, to delivery.

1937
02:40:11.545 --> 02:40:33.559
<v Unidentified speaker>And then it has new language for number 5, which is attempting to raise the bar slightly thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

1938
02:40:33.559 --> 02:40:36.479
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilors, discussion of Pirtle-Guiney 3?

1939
02:40:36.479 --> 02:40:39.420
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Kanal.

1940
02:40:39.420 --> 02:40:40.860
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Council President.

1941
02:40:40.860 --> 02:40:46.000
<v Unidentified speaker>So I, I support the first part of this, which is the clarification of adding of delivery of the notice.

1942
02:40:46.000 --> 02:40:46.180
<v Unidentified speaker>I think it's important that we have that clarification.

1943
02:40:46.212 --> 02:40:47.988
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't think it's necessary, but I think it helps.

1944
02:40:48.554 --> 02:40:51.684
<v Unidentified speaker>But because I oppose the second half of it, I'll be voting no on it.

1945
02:40:51.765 --> 02:41:02.549
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think this provides the opportunity to hold someone who is a person in charge accountable if an employee does not actually comply or pass on the notice.

1946
02:41:03.065 --> 02:41:07.531
<v Unidentified speaker>And so that's why I think it's a challenge here.

1947
02:41:07.759 --> 02:41:20.799
<v Unidentified speaker>And I recognize that there's some issues with this that I think relate to I think that's what Councilor Novick was bringing up earlier, that a lot of when we talk about the amendment, sometimes we're talking about the underlying, but I'm looking at net benefit here.

1948
02:41:20.799 --> 02:41:21.940
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's my assessment.

1949
02:41:21.940 --> 02:41:24.719
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't think this is necessarily like attempting to create a problem.

1950
02:41:24.719 --> 02:41:25.639
<v Unidentified speaker>That's just how I assess it.

1951
02:41:25.879 --> 02:41:26.159
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1952
02:41:26.159 --> 02:41:27.680
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1953
02:41:27.680 --> 02:41:28.959
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman.

1954
02:41:28.959 --> 02:41:30.100
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1955
02:41:30.100 --> 02:41:31.399
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, I'm going to vote no on this too.

1956
02:41:31.479 --> 02:41:37.399
<v Unidentified speaker>I think this is just an example of like we woke up and decided we had to figure out a government policy for the first time in 100 years.

1957
02:41:37.409 --> 02:41:38.130
<v Unidentified speaker>150 Years.

1958
02:41:38.418 --> 02:41:40.359
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm pretty sure we know how to deliver a notice.

1959
02:41:41.770 --> 02:41:43.822
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I think this is just making it messy.

1960
02:41:44.879 --> 02:41:48.599
<v Unidentified speaker>And frankly, we have an entire section of employees, a codebook that's this thick.

1961
02:41:48.663 --> 02:41:50.956
<v Unidentified speaker>We have a bureau full of 880-some-odd people.

1962
02:41:52.110 --> 02:41:58.088
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know, and no one has ever brought to me, that we somehow had to rewrite how to deliver an official notice.

1963
02:41:58.345 --> 02:42:04.299
<v Unidentified speaker>And so this continued need to pare down and rewrite and put councilor Smith.

1964
02:42:04.299 --> 02:42:04.299
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

1965
02:42:04.299 --> 02:42:08.440
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that the way that we're trying to shoehorn ourselves into prescription every possible thing, I think, is making this a mess.

1966
02:42:08.440 --> 02:42:23.049
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I don't know that the changes are terribly impactful other than the fact that it is not making it as clear as it could be.

1967
02:42:23.100 --> 02:42:31.360
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think it's an example of trying to shoehorn ourselves into something that I'm really not sure what it's about.

1968
02:42:31.360 --> 02:42:41.429
<v Unidentified speaker>I know that this government has successfully delivered official notifications to hundreds, thousands, potentially hundreds of thousands of people over the course of its existence.

1969
02:42:42.367 --> 02:42:45.630
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1970
02:42:48.038 --> 02:42:49.153
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Knoll, are you still in the queue?

1971
02:42:50.010 --> 02:42:52.152
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, okay, all good.

1972
02:42:55.421 --> 02:43:01.663
<v Unidentified speaker>Seeing no one else in the queue, can we please Vote on Pirtle Guinea 3.

1973
02:43:03.847 --> 02:43:04.156
<v Unidentified speaker>Canal?

1974
02:43:04.576 --> 02:43:04.738
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1975
02:43:05.224 --> 02:43:06.179
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle Guinea?

1976
02:43:07.085 --> 02:43:07.215
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1977
02:43:07.959 --> 02:43:08.120
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

1978
02:43:08.393 --> 02:43:08.554
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1979
02:43:09.840 --> 02:43:10.370
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

1980
02:43:11.752 --> 02:43:12.105
<v Unidentified speaker>Absent.

1981
02:43:12.185 --> 02:43:13.456
<v Unidentified speaker>Murillo?

1982
02:43:13.777 --> 02:43:14.002
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1983
02:43:14.981 --> 02:43:15.319
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

1984
02:43:15.850 --> 02:43:15.897
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1985
02:43:17.152 --> 02:43:17.314
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark?

1986
02:43:17.620 --> 02:43:17.668
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

1987
02:43:18.591 --> 02:43:18.816
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

1988
02:43:19.981 --> 02:43:20.208
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1989
02:43:21.274 --> 02:43:21.727
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

1990
02:43:21.922 --> 02:43:22.067
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1991
02:43:22.795 --> 02:43:23.102
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

1992
02:43:23.377 --> 02:43:23.458
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1993
02:43:24.331 --> 02:43:24.558
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

1994
02:43:25.835 --> 02:43:25.932
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

1995
02:43:27.030 --> 02:43:27.159
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1996
02:43:28.904 --> 02:43:33.909
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendment fails with a vote of 4 ayes, 7 nos, and 1 absent.

1997
02:43:35.417 --> 02:43:35.561
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1998
02:43:36.125 --> 02:43:40.740
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick, are you able to speak to Novick/Koyama Lane 1?

1999
02:43:41.737 --> 02:43:42.896
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, because it's very short.

2000
02:43:45.104 --> 02:43:54.072
<v Unidentified speaker>It simply says the city administrator or their designee will, for 3 years following implementation of updates to Chapter 14B60, report annually on implementation.

2001
02:43:54.655 --> 02:44:02.240
<v Unidentified speaker>Reporting will summarize data pertaining to the use of the code, including how often it is used, outcomes from implementation, and any implementation challenges.

2002
02:44:02.837 --> 02:44:07.939
<v Unidentified speaker>Reporting will address any unintended consequences or equity impacts due to implementation of the code updates.

2003
02:44:08.326 --> 02:44:09.827
<v Unidentified speaker>Reports will be made available to the public.

2004
02:44:12.814 --> 02:44:13.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

2005
02:44:15.106 --> 02:44:17.253
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, Councilor Novick, are you moving this amendment?

2006
02:44:17.301 --> 02:44:19.372
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a new— sorry, yes, I move great.

2007
02:44:19.718 --> 02:44:22.040
<v Unidentified speaker>And is there a second on this amendment?

2008
02:44:23.762 --> 02:44:24.131
<v Olivia Clark>Second.

2009
02:44:24.709 --> 02:44:27.715
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Clark seconds to the amendment.

2010
02:44:28.004 --> 02:44:28.791
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman.

2011
02:44:31.555 --> 02:44:36.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Nothing that Multnomah County Health Department loves more than a report about not much.

2012
02:44:36.667 --> 02:44:44.905
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would encourage you to really consider your source here, um, particularly in the last couple of years.

2013
02:44:45.084 --> 02:44:50.923
<v Unidentified speaker>And the Multnomah County Public Health Department or this division bringing this forward was inappropriate.

2014
02:44:51.147 --> 02:44:57.468
<v Unidentified speaker>And frankly, you know, this is probably a nothing burger, right?

2015
02:44:57.531 --> 02:45:08.168
<v Unidentified speaker>Because I imagine they're going to use this like one time, maybe 2 times in the 3-year period, and they're going to say probably in a sticky note, Councilor Novick, we used it 2 times, thank you very much, right?

2016
02:45:08.233 --> 02:45:09.389
<v Unidentified speaker>That's about the extent of it.

2017
02:45:09.519 --> 02:45:15.672
<v Unidentified speaker>But there's this idea that everything we do, we then have to put an Report requirement into the ordinance.

2018
02:45:15.977 --> 02:45:20.748
<v Unidentified speaker>And some stuff doesn't have to always be reported on, right?

2019
02:45:20.894 --> 02:45:22.950
<v Unidentified speaker>We can— it doesn't mean we don't find out about it.

2020
02:45:22.998 --> 02:45:28.541
<v Unidentified speaker>It doesn't mean we don't go in and say, hey, can you run that for me, if we find some malfeasance or we're having a sense that there could be.

2021
02:45:29.329 --> 02:45:35.066
<v Unidentified speaker>But we're starting to lean toward this idea that we have to put this type of clause at the back end of everything.

2022
02:45:35.113 --> 02:45:38.938
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think this was to scratch an itch for a friend at a health department, and I don't get it.

2023
02:45:38.986 --> 02:45:39.099
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2024
02:45:40.335 --> 02:45:43.228
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2025
02:45:43.389 --> 02:45:44.161
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Kanal.

2026
02:45:45.060 --> 02:45:45.397
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

2027
02:45:45.542 --> 02:45:52.099
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I, I would prefer that we don't have the equity impacts instead that we, uh, instead of reporting on them.

2028
02:45:52.532 --> 02:45:55.954
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's, uh, the, the broad concern I have about this one.

2029
02:45:56.421 --> 02:46:03.844
<v Unidentified speaker>I'll also note that the use of the word unintended, um, legislative intent's been established that this is designed to help this code be used more frequently.

2030
02:46:03.893 --> 02:46:04.825
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, that's, that's the intent of the ordinance.

2031
02:46:04.889 --> 02:46:05.851
<v Unidentified speaker>That's been brought up in committee.

2032
02:46:05.947 --> 02:46:08.927
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't think there's any— I think that's a neutral way of framing it.

2033
02:46:09.391 --> 02:46:18.591
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I also would note that the, uh, last sentence of the community impacts says that we— there is an understanding that there will be opposition.

2034
02:46:18.782 --> 02:46:25.770
<v Unidentified speaker>And I, I don't know if that's intended or not, but that there's at least acknowledged impact on owners of motels in this.

2035
02:46:25.834 --> 02:46:29.006
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't know that unintended captures that particular impact at all.

2036
02:46:29.504 --> 02:46:31.908
<v Unidentified speaker>So for those reasons, I'm, I'm against Mr.

2037
02:46:32.727 --> 02:46:34.509
<v Unidentified speaker>President, may I direct respond?

2038
02:46:34.557 --> 02:46:34.684
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

2039
02:46:35.440 --> 02:46:49.416
<v Unidentified speaker>I actually, um, upon reflection, I think that reference— I obviously haven't had an opportunity to consult with Councilor Koyama Lane on this, but yeah, I think references to unintended outcomes are inherently confusing because who intended what?

2040
02:46:49.897 --> 02:47:02.894
<v Unidentified speaker>So I would actually remove this proposal simply saying reporting will address any equity impacts and get rid of unintended okay.

2041
02:47:03.297 --> 02:47:03.895
<v Sameer Kanal>Wait, what are you doing?

2042
02:47:03.942 --> 02:47:05.315
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm moving to amend my own amendment.

2043
02:47:05.638 --> 02:47:06.719
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

2044
02:47:07.834 --> 02:47:13.850
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick's moved to change the language to remove the last part of it there.

2045
02:47:14.790 --> 02:47:14.951
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

2046
02:47:15.260 --> 02:47:17.075
<v Unidentified speaker>Not to remove the— just to remove some words.

2047
02:47:17.156 --> 02:47:17.593
<v Unidentified speaker>A couple of words.

2048
02:47:17.690 --> 02:47:29.182
<v Unidentified speaker>Reporting will address, um, any— and stay— cross out any unintended outcomes okay.

2049
02:47:29.636 --> 02:47:30.542
<v Unidentified speaker>That's removing it.

2050
02:47:30.786 --> 02:47:31.500
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

2051
02:47:31.824 --> 02:47:35.184
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman, Kanal— oh, Smith.

2052
02:47:36.503 --> 02:47:37.756
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Council President.

2053
02:47:37.933 --> 02:47:44.985
<v Unidentified speaker>All I have to say is Councilor Zimmerman's remarks, he was thinking the same thing I was thinking.

2054
02:47:45.050 --> 02:47:46.111
<v Unidentified speaker>Ditto, ditto, ditto.

2055
02:47:46.763 --> 02:47:52.497
<v Unidentified speaker>This is— we're getting a little bit out of bounds in the reporting.

2056
02:47:52.755 --> 02:48:06.698
<v Unidentified speaker>And I know in the, in the, in the charter, it gives us that option of having the city administrator do a report, and it's, it's not really necessary.

2057
02:48:08.327 --> 02:48:09.522
<v Unidentified speaker>We have so much work to do.

2058
02:48:10.425 --> 02:48:17.519
<v Unidentified speaker>And, you know, I, I said it the other, other day, none of these things came up When it was going through committee.

2059
02:48:18.597 --> 02:48:26.405
<v Unidentified speaker>None of these issues with all of these, um, amendments, they never came up.

2060
02:48:27.191 --> 02:48:33.444
<v Unidentified speaker>And people had some of the same questions, but they wait to the BIC Council to drop all these amendments to something.

2061
02:48:35.365 --> 02:48:42.049
<v Unidentified speaker>And it's, it's his amendment, it's his, it's his original underlying, and he probably forgot something.

2062
02:48:44.420 --> 02:48:46.456
<v Unidentified speaker>But, and I, and I, I support that.

2063
02:48:47.079 --> 02:48:48.623
<v Unidentified speaker>Do you want to— I can let you talk.

2064
02:48:50.549 --> 02:48:51.308
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor.

2065
02:48:52.097 --> 02:48:55.290
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so ditto, ditto, ditto, Councilor Zimmerman.

2066
02:48:55.566 --> 02:48:58.210
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I won't be in support of this at all.

2067
02:48:59.032 --> 02:48:59.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

2068
02:49:03.963 --> 02:49:11.385
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue— oh, just to clarify, Okay, you had seconded for the purposes of the board.

2069
02:49:11.449 --> 02:49:12.379
<v Unidentified speaker>Did you second the second?

2070
02:49:12.492 --> 02:49:15.556
<v Unidentified speaker>Sure, I'll second that removal.

2071
02:49:16.422 --> 02:49:24.412
<v Unidentified speaker>It may be easier to withdraw, uh, Novick Koyama Lane 1 and reintroduce with a second.

2072
02:49:24.763 --> 02:49:25.663
<v Unidentified speaker>I should have remembered that.

2073
02:49:25.727 --> 02:49:26.191
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2074
02:49:26.593 --> 02:49:32.881
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I hereby withdraw the original and move it as previously edited.

2075
02:49:33.202 --> 02:49:34.854
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, we'll call this Novick 7.

2076
02:49:36.501 --> 02:49:38.566
<v Unidentified speaker>And Councilor Clark, are you okay to second that?

2077
02:49:38.630 --> 02:49:38.727
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

2078
02:49:38.777 --> 02:49:39.118
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

2079
02:49:41.378 --> 02:49:42.433
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, any further discussion?

2080
02:49:45.559 --> 02:49:47.041
<v Unidentified speaker>Can we please move to a roll call vote?

2081
02:49:49.079 --> 02:49:49.322
<v Unidentified speaker>Kanal?

2082
02:49:49.840 --> 02:49:50.002
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No.

2083
02:49:50.470 --> 02:49:51.101
<v Unidentified speaker>Pirtle-Guiney?

2084
02:49:52.735 --> 02:49:53.010
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

2085
02:49:54.029 --> 02:49:54.255
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

2086
02:49:54.853 --> 02:49:55.000
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

2087
02:49:56.440 --> 02:49:56.845
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

2088
02:49:58.079 --> 02:49:58.519
<v Unidentified speaker>Absent.

2089
02:49:58.584 --> 02:49:59.039
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

2090
02:50:00.127 --> 02:50:00.354
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

2091
02:50:03.343 --> 02:50:03.390
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2092
02:50:05.525 --> 02:50:05.672
<v Steve Novick>No.

2093
02:50:07.628 --> 02:50:07.806
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2094
02:50:09.100 --> 02:50:09.974
<v Olivia Clark>No.

2095
02:50:11.430 --> 02:50:11.592
<v Unidentified speaker>No.

2096
02:50:12.191 --> 02:50:12.548
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

2097
02:50:13.212 --> 02:50:13.390
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

2098
02:50:14.104 --> 02:50:14.413
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

2099
02:50:15.483 --> 02:50:15.726
<v Candace Avalos>No.

2100
02:50:16.634 --> 02:50:21.174
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendment fails with a vote of 3 ayes, 8 nos, 1 absent.

2101
02:50:21.434 --> 02:50:29.117
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, colleagues, are there any other amendments I don't have note of them.

2102
02:50:29.650 --> 02:50:30.281
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Kanal.

2103
02:50:31.025 --> 02:50:33.095
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, I filed it on February 24th.

2104
02:50:33.677 --> 02:50:35.763
<v Unidentified speaker>I haven't had a chance to do it yet.

2105
02:50:36.439 --> 02:50:39.306
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm going to move Kanal 1.

2106
02:50:39.725 --> 02:50:53.398
<v Unidentified speaker>And just to speak to it, in 14B-6010 and 14B-60030, A2 in the first case, B in the second case, it says on or within 200 feet of a property.

2107
02:50:54.163 --> 02:51:05.313
<v Unidentified speaker>And my amendment would remove or within 200 feet of and hold property owners accountable for what occurs on their property, but not what occurs 199 feet away from it.

2108
02:51:05.474 --> 02:51:06.596
<v Unidentified speaker>Second.

2109
02:51:07.237 --> 02:51:09.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Kanal moves Kanal 1.

2110
02:51:09.227 --> 02:51:11.779
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Green moves or seconds.

2111
02:51:12.516 --> 02:51:15.676
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Kanal, can I just clarify the red line?

2112
02:51:15.725 --> 02:51:22.564
<v Unidentified speaker>I assume this is a scrivener's error, but with the red line of on paragraph A2, it reads property on which which.

2113
02:51:24.439 --> 02:51:25.487
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, that is a scrivener's error.

2114
02:51:25.568 --> 02:51:26.956
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2115
02:51:27.665 --> 02:51:30.441
<v Unidentified speaker>On which any person— there's not supposed to be the word which twice.

2116
02:51:30.586 --> 02:51:30.716
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

2117
02:51:31.055 --> 02:51:31.328
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2118
02:51:31.636 --> 02:51:39.979
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll note that this was written, if you'll notice the below, later in the file, it shows a red line from the version as it was then.

2119
02:51:40.495 --> 02:51:46.088
<v Unidentified speaker>But these upper 2 places, I think, where it shows the actual amendment itself indicates clearly what it is.

2120
02:51:46.137 --> 02:51:47.654
<v Unidentified speaker>It is removing or within 200 feet.

2121
02:51:52.077 --> 02:51:52.222
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

2122
02:51:52.319 --> 02:51:56.698
<v Unidentified speaker>To the, uh, Canal 1, uh, Councilor Zimmerman.

2123
02:51:57.230 --> 02:51:57.554
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

2124
02:51:57.780 --> 02:52:04.354
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, so I, I'd like you to think about what it is I— that Councilor Novick has brought this overall for.

2125
02:52:05.111 --> 02:52:13.709
<v Unidentified speaker>And what we're really talking about are properties that serve as centers of gravity for other types of stuff that happens in the direct proximity of them.

2126
02:52:13.824 --> 02:52:37.090
<v Unidentified speaker>200 feet is a and so when you think about the nature of the issues we're talking about, if the property isn't of itself the center of gravity and a person steps off that property but is directly, as we talked about, directly connected to, directly using it as a home base, that's what this gets to.

2127
02:52:37.316 --> 02:52:40.949
<v Unidentified speaker>And so by removing the 200-foot piece here.

2128
02:52:41.158 --> 02:52:57.710
<v Unidentified speaker>It does a couple of things that I hope you will not support this amendment because we can write laws all single— all day long that, um, and, and, and they'll be on the, if this occurs at this time, therefore it's illegal.

2129
02:52:58.459 --> 02:53:14.407
<v Unidentified speaker>Most nuisance property laws, because nuisance property is so darn hard to, to really tie to how does it fit, it takes a holistic and encompassing look at what is— whom is the center of gravity.

2130
02:53:14.761 --> 02:53:31.701
<v Unidentified speaker>And so the 200 feet serves as a flexible measure for the people we're asking to deal with a very hard job when it comes to interpreting what they're observing on a street, on a neighborhood block face, in an area.

2131
02:53:32.247 --> 02:53:48.097
<v Unidentified speaker>That work is not easy when— anytime, and it's certainly not easy if If the only standard for an act that considers itself to be illegal or it's an act that is a nuisance is that you must have a foot on a given property.

2132
02:53:48.162 --> 02:54:03.868
<v Unidentified speaker>So if you were standing on one property and something happens, but then half an hour later or 30 days later, you were doing that on the sidewalk instead of on the driveway, for the neighborhood who's going through the nuisance, there's no meaningful difference.

2133
02:54:03.915 --> 02:54:04.284
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's a good point.

2134
02:54:05.120 --> 02:54:17.466
<v Unidentified speaker>And I'll just, to get to the larger point, and I think that Councilor Kanal, you're probably proposing this so that we don't over-enforce against property owners who are not participating in the activity.

2135
02:54:17.513 --> 02:54:29.344
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think that that's a fair thing, but it's also how nuisance code is written is so that they can take a look at, is it all about, is the activity all about centering on this place?

2136
02:54:29.557 --> 02:54:29.638
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

2137
02:54:31.219 --> 02:54:33.668
<v Unidentified speaker>Agreeably, against their will, etc.

2138
02:54:33.750 --> 02:54:35.183
<v Unidentified speaker>And I, and I'll use this example.

2139
02:54:36.086 --> 02:54:46.479
<v Unidentified speaker>I am sure that in any one of our hotels downtown that a person has engaged in purchasing of sex.

2140
02:54:46.945 --> 02:54:48.441
<v Unidentified speaker>That, of course, has occurred.

2141
02:54:49.682 --> 02:54:57.378
<v Unidentified speaker>The question is, is that hotel centering its business model on being the place where they know they can do that and get away with it?

2142
02:54:57.458 --> 02:54:57.539
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

2143
02:54:58.997 --> 02:55:10.363
<v Unidentified speaker>Are they encouraging or being the place where the same group of people hang out on the sidewalk or in the street adjacent waiting for the business opportunity to come?

2144
02:55:12.842 --> 02:55:25.123
<v Unidentified speaker>But the difference here is that a thing occurring in a hotel room— and to Councilor Murillo kind of was saying— is like, just because you stayed a place, does that make it a crime because you then went to that place and engaged in a thing at the bus stop.

2145
02:55:25.444 --> 02:55:32.863
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's, that's a really good example because this is about, is a certain place serving as a center of gravity for that activity?

2146
02:55:33.761 --> 02:55:38.152
<v Unidentified speaker>And in the case that Councilor Murillo brought up, I don't, I don't think that would be an enforceable situation.

2147
02:55:38.200 --> 02:55:49.753
<v Unidentified speaker>So I, I think I understand the intent here, but I do think it really— it allows us to write a law to Councilor Novick's overall and overarching ordinance, pat ourselves on the back, and be completely unenforceable.

2148
02:55:49.800 --> 02:55:49.944
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

2149
02:55:50.626 --> 02:56:07.844
<v Unidentified speaker>So if we do this 200-foot— we excise the 200-foot piece from here, I think the likelihood that any sort of nuisance property will be used to abate some of the places that we heard about from the testimony near the high school and others really will almost be zeroed out with this.

2150
02:56:07.958 --> 02:56:15.103
<v Unidentified speaker>Because what we heard from the school principal is not because their students walked onto the property that is the problem.

2151
02:56:15.237 --> 02:56:17.025
<v Unidentified speaker>It's that as their students walked along 89th Street, right.

2152
02:56:17.162 --> 02:56:27.886
<v Unidentified speaker>Second, they were at multiple points along the area faced with some pretty nuisance property type of activities, knowing that there are a couple of bases, centers of gravity.

2153
02:56:28.079 --> 02:56:32.613
<v Unidentified speaker>And so for that, I just would encourage you to really think through that.

2154
02:56:32.693 --> 02:56:36.573
<v Unidentified speaker>For this one, I'll vote no, and I certainly appreciate the debate.

2155
02:56:37.513 --> 02:56:38.470
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2156
02:56:38.827 --> 02:56:39.477
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Murillo.

2157
02:56:41.424 --> 02:56:42.559
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Council President.

2158
02:56:44.400 --> 02:56:52.257
<v Unidentified speaker>To be honest, that rationale is making me less and less willing to support this for a few reasons.

2159
02:56:53.157 --> 02:56:56.885
<v Unidentified speaker>For one thing, like, let's, let's go through the sequence of events here.

2160
02:56:57.512 --> 02:57:06.846
<v Unidentified speaker>The threshold under this ordinance is that a property can be designated a chronic nuisance based on a few incidents, however many we've amended, in 90 days.

2161
02:57:06.895 --> 02:57:08.854
<v Unidentified speaker>Again, it's not convictions, it's not arrests, it's just incidents.

2162
02:57:08.918 --> 02:57:09.336
<v Unidentified speaker>And that's the threshold?

2163
02:57:09.822 --> 02:57:10.582
<v Unidentified speaker>It's not charges.

2164
02:57:11.245 --> 02:57:14.415
<v Unidentified speaker>It's police reports with probable cause, which is not a high bar.

2165
02:57:14.640 --> 02:57:15.644
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to emphasize that again.

2166
02:57:15.692 --> 02:57:19.023
<v Unidentified speaker>It is not a high bar for a police officer to write a report.

2167
02:57:20.156 --> 02:57:27.804
<v Unidentified speaker>Then those incidents don't even need to be completed crimes under ORS 161.405.

2168
02:57:28.290 --> 02:57:33.582
<v Unidentified speaker>An attempt is going to be defined as a substantial step that doesn't even need to be unique to criminal conduct.

2169
02:57:34.049 --> 02:57:35.308
<v Unidentified speaker>It counts as a nuisance activity.

2170
02:57:35.913 --> 02:57:41.726
<v Unidentified speaker>If an officer believes that someone took a substantial step toward disorderly conduct, that's one of your incidents.

2171
02:57:42.255 --> 02:57:50.976
<v Unidentified speaker>Even if the person had a lawful reason to be there, even if no crime was actually committed, impossibility is not a defense under Oregon's attempted statute.

2172
02:57:51.795 --> 02:57:56.114
<v Unidentified speaker>And then, then we move into the 200-foot radius issue.

2173
02:57:57.191 --> 02:57:59.824
<v Unidentified speaker>Those attempted offenses don't need to happen on the property.

2174
02:57:59.904 --> 02:58:01.494
<v Unidentified speaker>They can happen within 200 feet.

2175
02:58:01.606 --> 02:58:08.548
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think the fact that you're saying that it's about the center of gravity of where potential, like, sex work is happening.

2176
02:58:08.979 --> 02:58:15.822
<v Unidentified speaker>To me, that indicates that, again, this policy is not— first, we're saying it's not really addressing trafficking, it's addressing nuisance.

2177
02:58:16.351 --> 02:58:30.227
<v Unidentified speaker>Then we're saying this is about the center of gravity for where sex work could be happening, which to me, it's like we're revealing that we're calling this a trafficking policy, obviously, because it looks really bad for anyone who votes down on it.

2178
02:58:30.274 --> 02:58:30.691
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilmember Loretta Smith.

2179
02:58:31.092 --> 02:58:36.868
<v Unidentified speaker>You know, but it's not actually addressing the underlying issue that we're really concerned about.

2180
02:58:38.215 --> 02:58:43.364
<v Unidentified speaker>But it is a very emotional and intense thing to say that it is addressing when it is not.

2181
02:58:44.471 --> 02:58:59.861
<v Unidentified speaker>And in our neighborhoods that are so dense, I don't see how 200 feet from a property boundary, which includes sidewalks, transit stops, parks, and neighboring buildings, could not possibly impact other people who are, who are in the vicinity.

2182
02:59:00.681 --> 02:59:03.105
<v Unidentified speaker>And the association requirement is really broad.

2183
02:59:03.813 --> 02:59:12.309
<v Unidentified speaker>On the property itself, quote, under Section A1, there is no requirement that the person committing the nuisance activity have any connection to the property or its owner.

2184
02:59:12.663 --> 02:59:25.814
<v Unidentified speaker>Within the 200-foot radius, Section A2 requires that a person be associated with the property, but that's also defined to include anyone who has entered, patronized, or visited For a motel or a business, that's literally every customer.

2185
02:59:26.391 --> 02:59:31.684
<v Unidentified speaker>The property owner doesn't need to have any involvement in the activity whatsoever to be held liable.

2186
02:59:32.343 --> 02:59:50.215
<v Unidentified speaker>So the consequence of this is that the city administrator or their undefined designee can demand abatement measures including surveillance cameras, ID verification of all visitors, visitor logs, and trespass agreements giving police enforcement authority on private property.

2187
02:59:51.257 --> 03:00:03.645
<v Unidentified speaker>If the owner doesn't comply, or if compliance doesn't satisfy the designee, the city can go to court for $1,000 per day in civil penalties, closure of the property for up to a year, for sale, or demolition.

2188
03:00:04.592 --> 03:00:24.905
<v Unidentified speaker>So under this ordinance, if a police officer writes a few police reports within 90 days saying that the customer or visitor at or near your property appears to attempt a misdemeanor, and you don't install surveillance cameras and hand your visitor logs to police, the city can seek to take your building, and no crime needs to be completed on your part.

2189
03:00:25.273 --> 03:00:26.654
<v Unidentified speaker>No one needs to be arrested.

2190
03:00:27.022 --> 03:00:29.174
<v Unidentified speaker>You don't have to have done anything wrong.

2191
03:00:30.328 --> 03:00:51.784
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm concerned about the way that our own surveillance state is being used for people who are being accused of things because of proximity, and, and that it is not actually going to address human trafficking, which I I do think that it's a real issue.

2192
03:00:52.916 --> 03:00:57.377
<v Unidentified speaker>I do support sex workers, and human trafficking is distinctly different from sex work.

2193
03:00:58.022 --> 03:01:02.489
<v Unidentified speaker>But I, I don't see how this is accomplishing any of that.

2194
03:01:03.039 --> 03:01:05.440
<v Unidentified speaker>So I will be supporting Councilor Kanal's amendment.

2195
03:01:06.727 --> 03:01:16.101
<v Unidentified speaker>But I, I wanted to walk through that rationale of why that $200,000 Foot distance is really critical, and I have to like analyze this as a whole to explain that.

2196
03:01:16.181 --> 03:01:17.415
<v Unidentified speaker>So thanks for giving me some time.

2197
03:01:18.251 --> 03:01:19.117
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

2198
03:01:19.694 --> 03:01:20.336
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick.

2199
03:01:21.058 --> 03:01:25.951
<v Unidentified speaker>First of all, I just want to note that as I understand it, Councilor Kanal's saying on the property, right?

2200
03:01:26.593 --> 03:01:28.423
<v Unidentified speaker>Not on the property itself.

2201
03:01:28.584 --> 03:01:29.802
<v Unidentified speaker>That's what would be remaining, yes.

2202
03:01:29.979 --> 03:01:43.377
<v Unidentified speaker>So that to me means that if you're a sex trafficker is standing 2 feet in front of a property saying, um, if you come in here, there's a 12-year-old girl ready to have sex with you, Then that's— then that doesn't, that doesn't count.

2203
03:01:44.066 --> 03:01:50.370
<v Unidentified speaker>And I also want to say that if Councilor Knoll's amendment passes, I will vote against my own ordinance.

2204
03:01:50.900 --> 03:01:58.873
<v Unidentified speaker>We've talked with law enforcement about it, and they say that if you have it just be on the property, then it's less, it's less useful.

2205
03:01:59.066 --> 03:02:04.263
<v Unidentified speaker>I mean, that outweighs the 3 in 30 versus 3 in 90.

2206
03:02:04.842 --> 03:02:09.109
<v Unidentified speaker>So if we pass this amendment, that's a death knell for the ordinance itself.

2207
03:02:09.494 --> 03:02:09.895
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

2208
03:02:10.396 --> 03:02:16.682
<v Unidentified speaker>Also, I was a little confused by Councilor Morillo talking about there just has to be a step towards a crime.

2209
03:02:17.067 --> 03:02:20.029
<v Unidentified speaker>That sounds like the definition of conspiracy law or something.

2210
03:02:20.141 --> 03:02:30.362
<v Unidentified speaker>But what it says, the police officer has determined that probable cause exists to believe that a nuisance activity has occurred, that a crime has actually occurred, not that a step towards a crime has occurred.

2211
03:02:32.754 --> 03:02:35.032
<v Unidentified speaker>So anyway, that said.

2212
03:02:35.228 --> 03:02:35.754
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Herbold.

2213
03:02:36.362 --> 03:02:37.245
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's, that's enough.

2214
03:02:37.551 --> 03:02:37.985
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2215
03:02:38.049 --> 03:02:38.772
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor.

2216
03:02:39.718 --> 03:02:41.468
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Knell.

2217
03:02:42.128 --> 03:02:42.385
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2218
03:02:42.449 --> 03:02:44.215
<v Unidentified speaker>And I respect that disagreement.

2219
03:02:44.310 --> 03:02:46.929
<v Unidentified speaker>I agree with Councilor Zimmerman's point that this is a debate worth having.

2220
03:02:47.425 --> 03:02:56.948
<v Unidentified speaker>The way I would frame this is about guilt by association in the primary sense is, are you responsible for what happens 199 feet away from you?

2221
03:02:57.541 --> 03:03:14.968
<v Unidentified speaker>And is it possible for that determination of your responsibility right now in the current code, as well, and this is not something Councilor Novick created, this is the underlying code, and I want to fully acknowledge that, that right now that is allowed.

2222
03:03:15.308 --> 03:03:17.443
<v Unidentified speaker>And this code is not currently used that frequently.

2223
03:03:17.507 --> 03:03:22.854
<v Unidentified speaker>I think I brought this up earlier that part of the reason for this is to make it more possible for it to be used.

2224
03:03:23.081 --> 03:03:27.637
<v Unidentified speaker>And my concern is that this weakness in the underlying code that allows for that guilt by association is not being used.

2225
03:03:27.734 --> 03:03:27.846
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2226
03:03:29.046 --> 03:03:31.397
<v Unidentified speaker>Then becomes more often used.

2227
03:03:33.475 --> 03:03:57.816
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to point to a person who testified about something that was even happening on their property in the meeting back in March, where they were going to be, in their view, and I think it's fair to say even in the current version, held accountable for something that they called police to try to get help for and were not given support.

2228
03:03:58.362 --> 03:04:10.569
<v Unidentified speaker>And so, and I bring that up to say, because there was a conversation around, um, you know, that we wouldn't be holding someone accountable for something happens happening on the sidewalk outside of their building, you know, down a few feet.

2229
03:04:10.699 --> 03:04:14.709
<v Unidentified speaker>That's accurate because it wouldn't be something that is their fault.

2230
03:04:15.126 --> 03:04:25.384
<v Unidentified speaker>The, the problem that we're facing with human trafficking, we brought this up in the committee pretty clearly the human trafficking unit does not have the resources to address this.

2231
03:04:26.569 --> 03:04:28.413
<v Unidentified speaker>They do not have any overtime.

2232
03:04:28.461 --> 03:04:29.529
<v Unidentified speaker>They did 2 years ago.

2233
03:04:29.577 --> 03:04:32.504
<v Unidentified speaker>That's their own accounting in committee.

2234
03:04:33.216 --> 03:04:46.605
<v Unidentified speaker>And they currently do not have overtime dollars despite the fact that this council adopted a budget note to move overtime dollars into a suite of programs within the police bureau that includes human trafficking.

2235
03:04:46.757 --> 03:05:05.022
<v Unidentified speaker>And the idea that we can't do what is already authorized, but instead have to find some other way, and we have found that the property owner is available and doesn't have that, that, uh, the resource to, to combat this and have put the responsibility on them.

2236
03:05:05.503 --> 03:05:11.900
<v Unidentified speaker>And, and again, that's not Councilor Novick, that's not this proposal, that predates, um, this entire conversation.

2237
03:05:12.237 --> 03:05:24.574
<v Unidentified speaker>And I think in order to be able to talk about how we would utilize this code more, it would be really important to me to see that guilt by association is removed from this, this conversation.

2238
03:05:25.408 --> 03:05:29.796
<v Unidentified speaker>And I, I just want to preempt one other conversation, say I did file this back in February.

2239
03:05:30.052 --> 03:05:32.365
<v Unidentified speaker>This is something I raised as a concern back in the committee as well.

2240
03:05:32.639 --> 03:05:32.944
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

2241
03:05:33.426 --> 03:05:34.182
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

2242
03:05:34.245 --> 03:05:36.318
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, I will note it is currently 5 o'clock.

2243
03:05:37.299 --> 03:05:46.039
<v Unidentified speaker>We are not going to be able to get to the general discussion of this today, but we will We'll continue this item at the top of the agenda tomorrow afternoon, but we're not— I'm not closing out.

2244
03:05:46.120 --> 03:05:48.048
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to limit debate in the—.

2245
03:05:49.574 --> 03:05:50.329
<v Sameer Kanal>Point of order on that.

2246
03:05:50.475 --> 03:05:50.636
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

2247
03:05:51.843 --> 03:05:52.536
<v Unidentified speaker>2 Things.

2248
03:05:52.713 --> 03:05:54.405
<v Unidentified speaker>One is this is the last amendment.

2249
03:05:54.727 --> 03:05:54.920
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

2250
03:05:55.001 --> 03:05:59.742
<v Unidentified speaker>If we were to vote on this, we could conclude our first reading on this today.

2251
03:05:59.807 --> 03:06:00.002
<v Unidentified speaker>Good.

2252
03:06:00.148 --> 03:06:00.393
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

2253
03:06:00.555 --> 03:06:09.439
<v Unidentified speaker>And the second piece of it is I would strongly request that it not be at the top of the agenda if it is Okay, well, let's see if we can get through—.

2254
03:06:10.193 --> 03:06:15.444
<v Unidentified speaker>Let's get through the 3 in the queue and then go to a vote and call it a night.

2255
03:06:16.296 --> 03:06:16.938
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Zimmerman.

2256
03:06:17.243 --> 03:06:17.675
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2257
03:06:18.608 --> 03:06:20.518
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a good— this is a good part of the conversation.

2258
03:06:20.614 --> 03:06:23.568
<v Unidentified speaker>It's an important— where I think some of the confusion has happened.

2259
03:06:23.617 --> 03:06:31.757
<v Unidentified speaker>So I'm going to talk about this city's enforcement of nuisance types of codes against a property.

2260
03:06:32.495 --> 03:06:36.773
<v Unidentified speaker>And how it could have gone to anybody within 200 feet, but it didn't.

2261
03:06:36.903 --> 03:06:40.058
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I'm going to talk about 4th and Washington in my district.

2262
03:06:40.908 --> 03:06:44.337
<v Unidentified speaker>And within 20 feet is Kelly's Olympian.

2263
03:06:44.690 --> 03:06:46.692
<v Unidentified speaker>Another 20 feet is Casa Nightclub.

2264
03:06:47.334 --> 03:06:50.315
<v Unidentified speaker>On the other side, we've got the, the, the new food carts.

2265
03:06:50.522 --> 03:06:52.430
<v Unidentified speaker>We've got the Royal Sonesta Hotel.

2266
03:06:53.086 --> 03:07:02.494
<v Unidentified speaker>My point in bringing that up is that code compliance, Portland Police, Portland Fire, PBOT, Myself, when I worked in the mayor's office, we went to the target.

2267
03:07:02.558 --> 03:07:03.888
<v Unidentified speaker>We went to the center of gravity.

2268
03:07:04.081 --> 03:07:07.656
<v Unidentified speaker>We talked about the issues that were going on at that one property.

2269
03:07:09.033 --> 03:07:23.412
<v Unidentified speaker>And if we saw things that happened to be in front of Kelly's Olympian that we knew to be related to 4th and Washington, we didn't extend that to Kelly's Olympian as being a contributing factor.

2270
03:07:23.957 --> 03:07:37.971
<v Unidentified speaker>At the same time, and during this, this era, We were having some pretty serious conversations with our club owners in town about the prevalence of their clubs being used as kind of the place everybody got amped up and then had a gunfight in Old Town.

2271
03:07:38.630 --> 03:07:42.037
<v Unidentified speaker>So we had conversations with, with Casa Nightclub and other places.

2272
03:07:42.293 --> 03:07:52.007
<v Unidentified speaker>And you know what, at the same time, even though we had a nuisance property at 4th and Washington, we kept that part of the conversation confined to Casa, which was across the street, well within 200 feet.

2273
03:07:52.056 --> 03:07:52.264
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

2274
03:07:53.006 --> 03:08:11.344
<v Unidentified speaker>The reason I say that is in my entire time in government, I've never had anybody come and say, I'm being accused of participating in an— or convening or having or promoting a nuisance property with something I am not involved in.

2275
03:08:12.643 --> 03:08:13.668
<v Unidentified speaker>That's just never happened.

2276
03:08:14.998 --> 03:08:19.295
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that it's easy to think of the boogeyman.

2277
03:08:20.835 --> 03:08:30.647
<v Unidentified speaker>But also, I think our systems have largely got a lot of crosschecks to make sure that we attribute a nuisance only to those who are involved.

2278
03:08:30.791 --> 03:08:43.653
<v Unidentified speaker>And frankly, the, the standard has been in Portland that we're quite careful not to apply nuisance to those, even in rough areas, even on, on streets that are really struggling, to those that are not participating.

2279
03:08:43.797 --> 03:08:51.444
<v Unidentified speaker>And frankly, in Old Town, that's a daily occurrence for us in terms of some folks are really trying to contribute positively.

2280
03:08:51.588 --> 03:08:55.702
<v Unidentified speaker>They're right next door to some folks who are not, and we have split that out.

2281
03:08:55.831 --> 03:09:07.030
<v Unidentified speaker>And so I have faith that if we got a whiff of it being used inappropriately, that we have the tools to correct that quickly, but also that the systems would have a cross-check.

2282
03:09:07.093 --> 03:09:13.754
<v Unidentified speaker>But in my entire career, I've never had somebody say, I'm being accused of a nuisance property issue, and I wasn't participating.

2283
03:09:13.819 --> 03:09:15.566
<v Unidentified speaker>I don't know where they got this accusation.

2284
03:09:15.903 --> 03:09:16.992
<v Unidentified speaker>It, it just hasn't been the case.

2285
03:09:17.103 --> 03:09:19.652
<v Unidentified speaker>So I just want to offer that up, uh, and I appreciate it.

2286
03:09:19.700 --> 03:09:20.101
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2287
03:09:20.325 --> 03:09:21.287
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

2288
03:09:21.367 --> 03:09:22.007
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Novick.

2289
03:09:22.792 --> 03:09:23.851
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, thank you, Mr. President.

2290
03:09:23.995 --> 03:09:42.459
<v Unidentified speaker>I just wanted to note that, um, Taran Patel of the Asian American Hotel Owners Association came to us the first hearing on this, um, in committee and said, I want to be sure that when one of my folks calls up to report a crime and that's not held against them as a nuisance act, as a nuisance instance.

2291
03:09:42.861 --> 03:09:44.994
<v Unidentified speaker>So we passed an amendment to address that.

2292
03:09:46.611 --> 03:09:52.569
<v Unidentified speaker>And I also want to say that we don't have businesses coming in front of us saying this is a big threat to them.

2293
03:09:53.156 --> 03:10:05.239
<v Unidentified speaker>And it's actually somewhat ironic to me that the councilors who occasionally get accused of being anti-business are standing up for— seeming to stand up for business when the businesses themselves don't think they need to be standing up.

2294
03:10:05.306 --> 03:10:09.245
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor finally, this is not just about human trafficking.

2295
03:10:10.360 --> 03:10:16.643
<v Unidentified speaker>It also can be used in cases where properties are being used for gunplay or for drug dealing.

2296
03:10:17.920 --> 03:10:25.113
<v Unidentified speaker>But I will note that Safety Compass, which survivors of sex trafficking who advocate for victims of sex trafficking, was supportive of the proposal.

2297
03:10:26.120 --> 03:10:26.281
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2298
03:10:26.395 --> 03:10:27.772
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

2299
03:10:27.918 --> 03:10:28.503
<v Unidentified speaker>Councilor Murillo.

2300
03:10:30.189 --> 03:10:31.243
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you for that.

2301
03:10:32.802 --> 03:10:45.816
<v Unidentified speaker>I know, I do think it is a little bit funny because, you know, we had Apano and other organizations who represent a lot of Asian American businesses on 82nd Avenue actually have a lot of issues with this.

2302
03:10:45.880 --> 03:10:47.429
<v Unidentified speaker>So I don't think that's necessarily true.

2303
03:10:48.474 --> 03:10:50.904
<v Unidentified speaker>And they came and spoke to us and sent us a lot of emails.

2304
03:10:50.952 --> 03:10:52.466
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sure you saw them all as well.

2305
03:10:53.786 --> 03:10:58.600
<v Unidentified speaker>The argument that if, you know, Councilor Novick again is painting a very councilor Smith.

2306
03:10:58.665 --> 03:11:10.451
<v Unidentified speaker>So the argument that's being made is a very, I think, emotional story of, okay, there's a little girl getting sold on the sidewalk right outside of a hotel, and if we remove the 200 feet, that's going to prevent us from stopping human trafficking.

2307
03:11:10.579 --> 03:11:13.498
<v Unidentified speaker>That's just not true because human trafficking is illegal right now.

2308
03:11:13.643 --> 03:11:19.513
<v Unidentified speaker>So if a little girl is getting sold on the sidewalk right outside of the hotel, theoretically the police would be able to stop them right now.

2309
03:11:19.961 --> 03:11:23.875
<v Unidentified speaker>The reason they're not doing that is because they can't be everywhere all at once.

2310
03:11:24.372 --> 03:11:30.608
<v Unidentified speaker>We don't, and we police are frankly not the tool to actually address human trafficking if that's what this is truly about.

2311
03:11:31.427 --> 03:11:36.713
<v Unidentified speaker>There is not a single published study that connects chronic nuisance property ordinances to reductions in human trafficking.

2312
03:11:37.292 --> 03:11:45.038
<v Unidentified speaker>The Polaris Project, the organization that operates the National Human Trafficking Hotline, does not recommend most of the measures in this ordinance's abatement menu.

2313
03:11:45.647 --> 03:11:49.584
<v Unidentified speaker>Polaris recommends staff training, visible hotline information in guest rooms, which we did approve, and I.

2314
03:11:50.260 --> 03:12:05.444
<v Unidentified speaker>All of the academic research found that nuisance abatement against trafficking venues was rarely used, and when it was, it displaced operations to neighboring jurisdictions rather than ending them.

2315
03:12:06.070 --> 03:12:16.569
<v Unidentified speaker>So if the issue is truly with the underlying policy, then to me that means that this actually— what we need to do is truly address the underlying policy and the gaps that exist within it.

2316
03:12:16.618 --> 03:12:17.034
<v Unidentified speaker>I think that's a great point.

2317
03:12:18.575 --> 03:12:26.307
<v Unidentified speaker>And not to pretend that this is going to actually address big harms in our community like human trafficking, which deserve real consideration.

2318
03:12:27.781 --> 03:12:35.385
<v Unidentified speaker>So I assume with the makeup of who's sitting up here, this amendment is going to fail, and I look forward to having further discussions.

2319
03:12:36.218 --> 03:12:41.864
<v Unidentified speaker>But I will say, I will leave it on this because in the following days we're going to have complicated policies coming forward.

2320
03:12:42.395 --> 03:12:45.009
<v Unidentified speaker>Most of the amendments brought here today were by the sponsor themselves.

2321
03:12:45.509 --> 03:12:46.605
<v Unidentified speaker>That's not being held against him.

2322
03:12:47.847 --> 03:12:57.041
<v Unidentified speaker>And last-minute amendments keep getting brought up, so I don't want to hear anything later when we have other complicated policies coming up this week about who can and cannot do that.

2323
03:12:57.299 --> 03:12:57.671
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

2324
03:12:58.090 --> 03:12:59.379
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

2325
03:13:02.050 --> 03:13:05.445
<v Unidentified speaker>Colleagues, I'd like to move to a roll call vote on Canal 1, please.

2326
03:13:06.843 --> 03:13:06.859
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2327
03:13:07.493 --> 03:13:07.540
<v Unidentified speaker>Aye.

2328
03:13:13.500 --> 03:13:14.050
<v Unidentified speaker>Absent.

2329
03:13:14.650 --> 03:13:14.878
<v Unidentified speaker>Ryan?

2330
03:13:15.299 --> 03:13:15.429
<v Dan Ryan>No.

2331
03:13:16.824 --> 03:13:17.293
<v Unidentified speaker>Koyama Lane?

2332
03:13:18.541 --> 03:13:19.045
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Absent.

2333
03:13:19.239 --> 03:13:20.773
<v Unidentified speaker>Murillo?

2334
03:13:20.822 --> 03:13:20.837
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2335
03:13:21.855 --> 03:13:22.179
<v Unidentified speaker>Novick?

2336
03:13:22.888 --> 03:13:23.050
<v Steve Novick>No.

2337
03:13:24.213 --> 03:13:24.537
<v Unidentified speaker>Clark?

2338
03:13:24.843 --> 03:13:25.085
<v Olivia Clark>No.

2339
03:13:25.893 --> 03:13:26.183
<v Unidentified speaker>Green?

2340
03:13:26.522 --> 03:13:26.652
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2341
03:13:27.250 --> 03:13:27.620
<v Unidentified speaker>Zimmerman?

2342
03:13:27.993 --> 03:13:28.139
<v Eric Zimmerman>No.

2343
03:13:28.709 --> 03:13:29.018
<v Unidentified speaker>Avalos?

2344
03:13:29.359 --> 03:13:29.522
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2345
03:13:29.960 --> 03:13:30.236
<v Unidentified speaker>Smith?

2346
03:13:32.058 --> 03:13:32.286
<v Loretta Smith>No.

2347
03:13:33.018 --> 03:13:33.326
<v Unidentified speaker>Dunphy?

2348
03:13:35.238 --> 03:13:35.432
<v Jamie Dunphy>No.

2349
03:13:36.147 --> 03:13:40.583
<v Unidentified speaker>The amendment It fails with a vote of 4 ayes, 6 nos, and 2 absent.

2350
03:13:40.888 --> 03:13:43.093
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay, colleagues, we are over time.

2351
03:13:43.143 --> 03:13:44.462
<v Unidentified speaker>We have no more pending amendments.

2352
03:13:45.209 --> 03:13:52.531
<v Unidentified speaker>This item now moves to second reading, and we are recessed until tomorrow at 2 o'clock.

