WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.272 --> 00:00:04.953
<v Jamie Dunphy>In the sessions ahead, we will be dealing with the budgets and programs fully inside the City of Portland.

2
00:00:05.001 --> 00:00:20.603
<v Jamie Dunphy>But today we're going to begin with an item partially in and partially out of our jurisdiction, the continuum of our shared responsibility for housing, homelessness response, behavioral health response, public environmental management, and public safety between the City of Portland and Multnomah County.

3
00:00:21.422 --> 00:00:27.466
<v Jamie Dunphy>Today we're going to get an update on the homelessness data from the county and overviews of our respective budgets addressing this work.

4
00:00:27.530 --> 00:00:27.739
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

5
00:00:27.931 --> 00:00:43.207
<v Jamie Dunphy>And during questioning at the end, it's my hope that we can come to an understanding of what the mayor and the chair have proposed in their budgets and to identify where our amendment process may yield the best collaboration, efficiency, and dare I say synergy.

6
00:00:44.042 --> 00:00:47.520
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm now passing this over to Jillian Schoney and Ryan Deibert from the county to kick us off.

7
00:00:48.130 --> 00:00:48.386
<v Jillian Schoney>Welcome.

8
00:00:49.155 --> 00:00:49.539
<v Jillian Schoney>Thank you.

9
00:00:50.918 --> 00:00:51.832
<v Jillian Schoney>Thank you, Council President.

10
00:00:51.881 --> 00:00:53.707
<v Jillian Schoney>That was very well done as usual.

11
00:00:53.884 --> 00:00:55.118
<v Jillian Schoney>I feel no need to say more.

12
00:00:55.246 --> 00:01:04.376
<v Jillian Schoney>I'm just gonna kick it over to my colleague Ryan Deibert to give you our most recent monthly data that is up on the Homeless Services Department dashboard.

13
00:01:04.795 --> 00:01:05.132
<v Jillian Schoney>Take it away.

14
00:01:05.597 --> 00:01:05.775
<v Josh Roper>Great.

15
00:01:05.936 --> 00:01:10.079
<v Ryan Deibert>Good afternoon, Council President, Chair, Mayor, Councilors, Commissioners.

16
00:01:10.754 --> 00:01:12.055
<v Ryan Deibert>For the record, Ryan Deibert.

17
00:01:12.183 --> 00:01:16.504
<v Ryan Deibert>I use he/him pronouns, Deputy Director of the Homelessness Response System.

18
00:01:16.938 --> 00:01:30.237
<v Ryan Deibert>That shared system was established by each of your elected bodies through an intergovernmental agreement to help guide our shared investments and shared priorities across jurisdictions and with our partners across multiple sectors.

19
00:01:30.751 --> 00:01:43.052
<v Ryan Deibert>Central to that shared work is an agreement to monitor our system-wide performance against 12 key performance indicators that both of your legislative bodies adopted at the beginning of this year.

20
00:01:44.063 --> 00:02:00.305
<v Ryan Deibert>We'll begin publishing quarterly reports using those new KPIs next month, but many of the data sources are already available, and we're regularly reviewing monthly updates to those data with our steering and oversight implementation and community advisory committees.

21
00:02:00.754 --> 00:02:06.188
<v Ryan Deibert>Consistent with that practice, we wanted to start today by grounding you in the current trends that we're observing.

22
00:02:06.846 --> 00:02:18.403
<v Ryan Deibert>And then following the mayor and chair's reports on their respective budget proposals, we'll share with you some of our best estimates for how those proposed budgets might shape these trends in the coming fiscal year.

23
00:02:19.126 --> 00:02:32.883
<v Ryan Deibert>The data I'll share here all come from the dashboard maintained by the Multnomah County Homeless Services Department, but they reflect data from all publicly funded homeless next slide, please.

24
00:02:34.280 --> 00:02:40.954
<v Ryan Deibert>First, I wanna start by noting that our systems are collectively sheltering and housing more people than ever before.

25
00:02:41.498 --> 00:02:56.163
<v Ryan Deibert>In the first 2 years of our Homelessness Response Action Plan, you'll recall that we collectively sheltered or housed more than 23,000 people, far exceeding our initial 2-year goals and serving almost 50% more people than in the 2 years prior.

26
00:02:56.211 --> 00:02:56.707
<v Steve Novick>Next slide, please.

27
00:02:57.205 --> 00:03:09.693
<v Ryan Deibert>As of February of this year, more than 9,000 people who were formerly homeless were being supported by our systems in permanent housing, and hundreds more transition from homelessness into housing every month.

28
00:03:10.670 --> 00:03:28.493
<v Ryan Deibert>Even with that though, this graph demonstrates that over the past 2 years, inflow into homelessness, which we track as our new KPI number 5, shown here as the green line on this graph, has consistently outpaced outflow, KPI number 10, shown here as the orange line.

29
00:03:29.075 --> 00:03:38.665
<v Ryan Deibert>On average over the last 6 months, that gap between those 2 lines is roughly 360 more people entering homelessness each month than are leaving.

30
00:03:40.098 --> 00:03:46.447
<v Ryan Deibert>It's important to understand though that the volume of movement in and out of homelessness is pretty large in each month.

31
00:03:46.512 --> 00:03:59.516
<v Ryan Deibert>So on average, we have about 1,675 people entering homelessness each month, Roughly 3/4 of whom haven't accessed services before, or at least in the last 2 years.

32
00:04:00.372 --> 00:04:04.659
<v Ryan Deibert>We also have about 1,300 people who are exiting homelessness each month.

33
00:04:04.806 --> 00:04:09.320
<v Ryan Deibert>About a third of those are exiting to permanent housing, 400 or so each month.

34
00:04:10.385 --> 00:04:12.788
<v Ryan Deibert>We track that as our new KPI number 11.

35
00:04:13.224 --> 00:04:18.596
<v Ryan Deibert>But most, about 70% of those folks are leaving homelessness to inactivity.

36
00:04:18.644 --> 00:04:28.512
<v Ryan Deibert>So in other words, they accessed services at some point, but then left services and didn't next slide, please.

37
00:04:29.434 --> 00:04:47.759
<v Ryan Deibert>So again, pulling from several of our new KPIs, again via the Homeless Services Systemwide Dashboard, when you have inflow outpacing outflow each month, that means that the total number of people known to be experiencing homelessness, which is our new KPI number 1, has continued to grow over time.

38
00:04:48.244 --> 00:04:50.809
<v Ryan Deibert>So this picture is the graphic form of our by-name list.

39
00:04:50.906 --> 00:04:57.610
<v Ryan Deibert>And you can see that the number of people experiencing homelessness As of our most recent data from February, that list stands at 18,250 people.

40
00:04:58.235 --> 00:05:04.264
<v Ryan Deibert>This is the general upward curve that we've observed over the past 2 years that we've tracked this by-name list.

41
00:05:04.891 --> 00:05:13.517
<v Ryan Deibert>But later in today's presentation, we'll be taking a closer look at how different budget decisions before you this year can start to bend the shape of that curve.

42
00:05:14.913 --> 00:05:22.257
<v Ryan Deibert>On the last day of each month, the Homeless Services Department also pulls a snapshot of which proportion of those people are known to be sheltered.

43
00:05:22.307 --> 00:05:22.595
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

44
00:05:22.915 --> 00:05:24.293
<v Ryan Deibert>Our new KPI number 8.

45
00:05:24.678 --> 00:05:28.269
<v Ryan Deibert>That's currently about a third of the total population experiencing homelessness.

46
00:05:28.766 --> 00:05:34.874
<v Ryan Deibert>That's represented there in the orange in the middle of each month's bar versus those who are known to be unsheltered.

47
00:05:34.937 --> 00:05:42.232
<v Ryan Deibert>So right now, just under half represented by the dark green at the bottom of each monthly bar or an unknown status.

48
00:05:42.312 --> 00:05:45.774
<v Ryan Deibert>That's our light, the light blue section, roughly a quarter right now.

49
00:05:47.040 --> 00:05:51.497
<v Ryan Deibert>As people come onto the by-name list through inflow, they add to the total number.

50
00:05:51.545 --> 00:05:54.415
<v Ryan Deibert>As they leave the by-name list through outflow, they get subtracted.

51
00:05:54.463 --> 00:05:54.574
<v Commissioner Singleton>Thank you.

52
00:05:54.639 --> 00:05:55.456
<v Ryan Deibert>From the total number.

53
00:05:55.810 --> 00:06:01.339
<v Ryan Deibert>So together, those are some of the core system-level metrics that we are currently following monthly.

54
00:06:01.805 --> 00:06:07.095
<v Ryan Deibert>Again, you'll see this curve show up in several of the slides that we're going to discuss later today.

55
00:06:07.815 --> 00:06:13.795
<v Ryan Deibert>But in the meantime, I'll transition it back to Jillian to introduce the Chair and Mayor's executive budget presentations.

56
00:06:14.773 --> 00:06:17.690
<v Jillian Schoney>Yeah, so for part 2 is the proposed executive budgets.

57
00:06:17.738 --> 00:06:24.214
<v Jillian Schoney>We'll first start with Multnomah County Chair Jessica Vega-Peterson, and then we'll follow with Mayor Wilson and team.

58
00:06:24.791 --> 00:06:26.394
<v Jillian Schoney>And each of you aim for about 7 minutes.

59
00:06:26.720 --> 00:06:28.755
<v Jillian Schoney>7 Minutes total for us to stay on time.

60
00:06:34.639 --> 00:06:35.206
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Good afternoon.

61
00:06:36.274 --> 00:06:37.764
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Oh, thank you, thank you.

62
00:06:39.028 --> 00:06:40.533
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Um, okay, thank you everyone.

63
00:06:40.581 --> 00:06:41.927
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Yep, I'll try to keep it to 7 minutes.

64
00:06:43.175 --> 00:06:45.060
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Um, so we'll go ahead and get started.

65
00:06:45.108 --> 00:06:52.666
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So this, um, what I'm going to talk about today is just give an overview, and I think all, all of us are aware that this is a really tough budget cycle.

66
00:06:53.175 --> 00:06:55.454
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Um, there were tough decisions to be made, hard decisions.

67
00:06:55.502 --> 00:06:58.747
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>There were no easy or good decisions that thank you.

68
00:06:58.795 --> 00:07:00.331
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>There's a lot of decisions to be made in putting the budget together.

69
00:07:00.475 --> 00:07:17.096
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>But this is really, you know, this budget also is the second year where we've had to take cuts to the county budget as well, which has been, you know, which is those accumulating impacts are felt through all of the departments across the county.

70
00:07:18.016 --> 00:07:21.776
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So I wanted to highlight some facts here on this slide just overall about the county budget.

71
00:07:22.452 --> 00:07:25.281
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So we have about $3.9 billion budget.

72
00:07:25.329 --> 00:07:27.738
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Our operating budget is about $2.9 billion.

73
00:07:28.588 --> 00:07:41.499
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Of that, we have $794 million in general fund dollars, which as we all know is the most flexible dollars that we have, but also some of the most valuable dollars that we have to fund county programs.

74
00:07:42.622 --> 00:07:48.052
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>That general fund is about a 2.3% decrease from our last year's adopted budget.

75
00:07:48.540 --> 00:07:56.444
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Overall, we have about a 3.9% decrease overall for all funding sources across the county from last year to this year.

76
00:07:57.877 --> 00:08:02.829
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Um, I think a few changes worth noting for our federal and state funding.

77
00:08:03.165 --> 00:08:18.661
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Um, there is, uh, the $94.2 million decrease is primarily from $64.7 million decrease in Homeless Services Department and a $2.9 million reduction for the Health Department.

78
00:08:18.709 --> 00:08:22.298
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So that's where we're seeing some of those impacts for state, federal, or other government cuts.

79
00:08:23.857 --> 00:08:31.050
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>For the Supportive Housing Services Measure Fund, we have a $20 million— $20.4 million decrease in this fund.

80
00:08:31.387 --> 00:08:44.860
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And that's a combination of the Metro's most recent forecast, which was revised downward by about $2.4 million, and a reduction in the assumed carryover of those one-time-only dollars that we've had from year to year in previous years.

81
00:08:46.081 --> 00:08:52.567
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We have an increase in some funds, including the Preschool for All Fund, and we have the Multnomah County Library Capital Construction Fund.

82
00:08:52.633 --> 00:08:52.825
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Thank you.

83
00:08:53.258 --> 00:08:54.172
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Yes.

84
00:08:54.524 --> 00:08:58.580
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>This is a significant decrease, but that has to do with the fact that we're actually building our libraries.

85
00:08:58.756 --> 00:09:05.232
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And we invite everyone to check out our new East County Library in Gresham, Oregon, when it's open a little bit later next month.

86
00:09:05.826 --> 00:09:06.626
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

87
00:09:06.772 --> 00:09:10.409
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Yes, just in case you're wondering.

88
00:09:11.035 --> 00:09:24.756
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We have the majority of our FTE decreases actually in the Health Department, in our Department of Community Justice, which does parole and probation and juvenile, and our Department of County Assets.

89
00:09:25.767 --> 00:09:37.562
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>The reductions incorporate state and federal rebalances that we have taken over the course of the past fiscal year, and we are fully funding our reserves for both the general fund and the business income tax.

90
00:09:37.883 --> 00:09:39.518
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Okay, next slide.

91
00:09:40.927 --> 00:09:51.618
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So this gets into some of the highlights for the Homeless Services Department budget, as well as some of the deficits that we have across the board.

92
00:09:51.666 --> 00:09:54.294
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So our Homeless Services Department's total budget is $2.5 million.

93
00:09:54.375 --> 00:09:54.663
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

94
00:09:55.696 --> 00:09:56.774
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>$239 Million.

95
00:09:57.788 --> 00:10:03.408
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We also have some SHS dollars in other county departments that total about $16.8 million.

96
00:10:05.147 --> 00:10:15.087
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>There are county general fund investments in my budget that support our overall homelessness response system that are reflected in the Homeless Response Action Plan.

97
00:10:15.457 --> 00:10:23.315
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So these investments exist across the county to support all aspects of our system that commits to providing the services someone needs to leave homelessness.

98
00:10:23.793 --> 00:10:25.847
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Or to never have to experience it in the first place.

99
00:10:26.361 --> 00:10:36.174
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>For example, I've added $2.5 million of county general funds in our Department of County Human Services for eviction prevention and prioritized behavioral health programs.

100
00:10:36.239 --> 00:10:39.658
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And I'll get more into those behavioral health programs in a couple slides.

101
00:10:40.654 --> 00:10:51.061
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I also invested $10 million in one-time-only dollars to mitigate the impact of shelter closures and to provide more efficiency in housing placements from shelters.

102
00:10:51.173 --> 00:10:59.259
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So when we take a look at some of our HREP goals, This is actually a really key investment that is going to help make reaching our goals possible.

103
00:10:59.307 --> 00:11:00.721
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So that's important.

104
00:11:01.043 --> 00:11:04.597
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Having that $10 million for those purposes is going to be really important.

105
00:11:06.725 --> 00:11:13.619
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I will say that, and then we do have the $67 million gap in homeless services.

106
00:11:14.293 --> 00:11:19.875
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Part of that is explained by the revisions of the budget and the SHS funding that I talked about earlier.

107
00:11:22.647 --> 00:11:30.008
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And some of it is from the changes in the agreements of the city dollars that we had previously received.

108
00:11:32.299 --> 00:11:33.614
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>All right, next slide.

109
00:11:35.552 --> 00:11:49.682
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So as we were putting together the Homeless Services Department budget for both the department and myself, our key principles in this were really keeping people housed, prioritizing housing placements, and maximizing shelter effectiveness.

110
00:11:49.730 --> 00:11:50.005
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

111
00:11:50.772 --> 00:11:55.662
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We— I wanted to make sure that no one would lose their county-supported housing due to a cut in our budget.

112
00:11:56.222 --> 00:12:05.841
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We have nearly 9,000 formerly homeless neighbors in this county who are sustained right now in short- and long-term housing, and so keeping those folks housed was a huge priority for me.

113
00:12:06.562 --> 00:12:09.927
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We want to make sure that the progress that we've made is going to be kept.

114
00:12:10.570 --> 00:12:15.875
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>In prioritizing housing placements, that is essential to ending someone's homelessness permanently.

115
00:12:16.115 --> 00:12:30.173
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>It's an intentional strategy informed by the recent county report on shelter outcomes, which shows that by increasing By increasing the outflow of people from shelters into homes, we can ensure a better balance in our homeless services system and more effectively use limited resources.

116
00:12:30.605 --> 00:12:40.302
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And that truly will enable us to reach our goal of resolving homelessness, placing people in permanent housing with the services they need to stay there.

117
00:12:40.943 --> 00:12:50.688
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And then I already mentioned in terms of maximizing shelter effectiveness, the importance of that $10 million one-time only investment to improve the efficacy of shelter placement into housing.

118
00:12:50.753 --> 00:12:50.865
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you.

119
00:12:51.577 --> 00:12:52.288
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Next slide, please.

120
00:12:52.740 --> 00:12:57.918
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Okay, this is taking a look at our Homeless Services Department overall.

121
00:12:57.984 --> 00:12:59.517
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I gave that total a little bit earlier.

122
00:13:00.469 --> 00:13:02.474
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We do have some contingency dollars in there.

123
00:13:04.649 --> 00:13:04.956
<v Loretta Smith>There are—.

124
00:13:05.392 --> 00:13:13.464
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And so I think this is just— we can just take a look at this slide and move on to the next one.

125
00:13:16.850 --> 00:13:17.070
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

126
00:13:19.081 --> 00:13:25.196
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So what we wanted to do is to really make sure that we are building on the success that we've had before.

127
00:13:25.596 --> 00:13:31.052
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So right now we know that we are moving more people off the street into housing than ever before.

128
00:13:32.144 --> 00:13:42.719
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>83% Of people housed remain housed 2 or more years later, and that's something that I think we can all be proud of with the investments that we've made in the system.

129
00:13:43.135 --> 00:13:46.730
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We also have made great progress in our data upgrades measuring the thank you.

130
00:13:46.730 --> 00:13:47.750
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So this report is providing a comprehensive overview of the homeless services department's scope, progress.

131
00:13:47.750 --> 00:13:55.120
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>It's providing transparency, and recent independent analysis from the Oregonian confirmed our data collection is sound and the best available.

132
00:13:55.870 --> 00:14:02.980
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We have seen multiple years of decreasing homeless services department budget while we know that the service needs are increasing.

133
00:14:03.250 --> 00:14:09.629
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So we really need to focus, and my focus this year was on the better balance between prevention, shelter, and housing.

134
00:14:09.629 --> 00:14:14.779
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And that's one of the great things about having the homeless resources excuse me.

135
00:14:14.827 --> 00:14:22.274
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Homelessness response system is that coordination across departments with Portland and our other cities and partners to avoid duplication.

136
00:14:23.107 --> 00:14:25.707
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We know that we have record evictions this year.

137
00:14:25.900 --> 00:14:31.452
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Investing in ongoing rent assistance and prevention are 2 of the ways in this budget that we're addressing that.

138
00:14:32.657 --> 00:14:43.907
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>There is 1,677 24-hour, 7-day-a-week shelter beds that are preserved, including the new Harrison Village and an expansion of our DV shelter system.

139
00:14:43.955 --> 00:14:44.115
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Thank you.

140
00:14:46.297 --> 00:14:48.238
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Let's go ahead and go to the next slide.

141
00:14:49.568 --> 00:14:54.013
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I went through a couple of these talking points before, so we could take a look at that.

142
00:14:54.076 --> 00:15:01.969
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I think one of those worth noting is that we are planning to house 3,119 people with county housing programs this year.

143
00:15:03.364 --> 00:15:05.754
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Next slide.

144
00:15:06.764 --> 00:15:08.144
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And I know I'm about out of time.

145
00:15:08.208 --> 00:15:10.599
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I want to— I did want to get to the behavioral health investments, though.

146
00:15:10.759 --> 00:15:11.400
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Thank you.

147
00:15:11.738 --> 00:15:12.267
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Councilor Herbold.

148
00:15:12.363 --> 00:15:23.631
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So for those struggling with addiction, this budget sustains a wide variety of substance use prevention, harm reduction, treatment, and recovery options provided by the county in collaboration with over 100 community partners.

149
00:15:24.225 --> 00:15:32.465
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And that includes our Downtown Behavioral Health Resource Center, which has welcomed over 100,000 total visits since opening less than 4 years ago.

150
00:15:32.880 --> 00:15:38.443
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>My budget ensures that this critical program will not see a reduction in hours or days open.

151
00:15:39.133 --> 00:15:49.625
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>It also preserves core functions of our corrections house transition services programs to ensure that individuals exiting jail have immediate resources and improved access to healthcare upon release.

152
00:15:51.470 --> 00:16:09.605
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>There is the $1 million investment in our Stabilization Readiness Program, which is run through our Department of Community Justice, which connects high-risk, high-need justice-involved individuals to supervision and services with low-barrier, low-barrier day shelter services in our central downtown business district.

153
00:16:10.964 --> 00:16:26.038
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>This year we have a $12.4 million investment in the building of our permanent sobering and crisis stabilization center, and we have almost half a million dollars in general fund for deflection and sobering services to support this shared resource in our community.

154
00:16:26.732 --> 00:16:30.250
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And with that, I will turn things back over to the mayor.

155
00:16:34.589 --> 00:16:40.543
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you, Chair, and thank you to our Multnomah County colleagues for visiting us here today, and good afternoon to the thank you, Councilor Smith.

156
00:16:40.607 --> 00:16:46.660
<v Keith Wilson>City of Portland, council colleagues, thank you for this opportunity and to these words on our budget.

157
00:16:49.480 --> 00:16:56.000
<v Keith Wilson>Everybody in Portland should be able to live, get around, work, and recreate without facing harm, violence, or fear.

158
00:16:56.921 --> 00:17:06.102
<v Keith Wilson>Public health and a sense of safety should be a universal right regardless of age, race, religion, sexuality, national origin, disability, or their housing status.

159
00:17:07.028 --> 00:17:12.181
<v Keith Wilson>The City of Portland has stepped up to respond to the humanitarian crisis and most urgent challenges on our street.

160
00:17:13.127 --> 00:17:27.432
<v Keith Wilson>Regarding our budget, we will no longer exchange funds with Multnomah County for homeless services and instead focus on providing outreach and core shelter services to our most vulnerable neighbors, as well as public space activation and maintenance.

161
00:17:28.153 --> 00:17:37.535
<v Keith Wilson>Although Portland Solutions provides important programmatic services, reliance on one-time funding has required us to realign some funding sources and reduce some services.

162
00:17:39.700 --> 00:17:49.432
<v Keith Wilson>Those are: our city shelter services will see a net reduction of 31%, taking the overall spend to just under $40 million.

163
00:17:49.593 --> 00:17:59.511
<v Keith Wilson>City outreach will be reduced by 37%, or $2.8 million will be its funding amount.

164
00:17:59.963 --> 00:18:01.222
<v Keith Wilson>Impact Reduction Program?

165
00:18:01.689 --> 00:18:07.884
<v Keith Wilson>The total budget is set at $15 million, and it's proposed to cut its reliance on general fund by 10%.

166
00:18:09.307 --> 00:18:22.727
<v Keith Wilson>The Public Environment Management Office, or PMO, will use 68% fewer general fund dollars by realigning previously appropriated Portland Clean Energy Community Benefits Fund dollars to conduct approved fund-aligned programming.

167
00:18:24.529 --> 00:18:29.368
<v Keith Wilson>On October 7th, 2015, the Portland City Council declared a housing and homelessness emergency.

168
00:18:30.230 --> 00:18:33.778
<v Keith Wilson>To address the city's growing homeless and affordable housing crisis.

169
00:18:34.709 --> 00:18:47.489
<v Keith Wilson>This ordinance, which has been renewed repeatedly since, emphasizes the need for emergency shelter, the ongoing shortage of affordable housing units, and the immediate need to provide and maintain housing for those who need it most.

170
00:18:48.837 --> 00:18:58.406
<v Keith Wilson>In addition to reallocating pass-through funding historically sent to Multnomah County's Homeless Services Department, the bureau will take slight reductions in external materials and legal services.

171
00:18:58.471 --> 00:18:58.615
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

172
00:19:00.633 --> 00:19:02.457
<v Keith Wilson>Of $675,000.

173
00:19:03.020 --> 00:19:11.881
<v Keith Wilson>Funding agreements with the Bureau of Technology will be reduced by $252,000, and we will eliminate 2 vacant data analyst positions for $298,000.

174
00:19:12.236 --> 00:19:14.803
<v Keith Wilson>Most other services will remain intact.

175
00:19:15.142 --> 00:19:15.674
<v Keith Wilson>Next slide.

176
00:19:17.837 --> 00:19:21.601
<v Keith Wilson>Our budget was crafted with a significant deficit.

177
00:19:21.958 --> 00:19:36.836
<v Keith Wilson>In turn, we had to focus on core values and deliverables with the administration and our directors focusing on a shared vision with shared priorities, shared necessity, and unfortunately shared sacrifices throughout our entire city.

178
00:19:37.823 --> 00:19:38.422
<v Keith Wilson>Next slide.

179
00:19:40.928 --> 00:19:50.429
<v Keith Wilson>A brief introduction as we begin to unveil Portland's Promise is a program in which we frame my approach to our investments today and in the future through the administration.

180
00:19:51.332 --> 00:19:55.228
<v Keith Wilson>And today we'll focus on housing, which is one of our 4 foundations.

181
00:19:55.276 --> 00:19:58.130
<v Keith Wilson>And I'd like to turn it over to Josh Roper in our Portland Housing Bureau.

182
00:19:58.530 --> 00:19:59.044
<v Keith Wilson>Josh, thank you.

183
00:19:59.107 --> 00:20:00.439
<v Josh Roper>Thank you, Mayor Wilson.

184
00:20:01.175 --> 00:20:03.163
<v Josh Roper>Good afternoon, councilors and commissioners.

185
00:20:03.452 --> 00:20:06.803
<v Josh Roper>I'm going to spend a little time walking us through the budget.

186
00:20:06.948 --> 00:20:09.336
<v Josh Roper>I'll start with the housing goals for the city.

187
00:20:10.394 --> 00:20:11.147
<v Josh Roper>3 Listed here.

188
00:20:11.292 --> 00:20:14.867
<v Josh Roper>Reducing affordable housing unit vacancies is a major priority.

189
00:20:15.540 --> 00:20:17.593
<v Josh Roper>So piloting a home sharing program.

190
00:20:17.641 --> 00:20:27.435
<v Josh Roper>So the goal is to have 250 new affordable home share rooms available over the course of that pilot, and then a target of 700 Portlanders being reunified with their loved ones.

191
00:20:27.902 --> 00:20:41.352
<v Josh Roper>And you'll see moonshot goals to the side of 2,500 new housing permits issued in Central City by the end of 2030, and then 20,000 new housing permits issued by December 31st, 2032.

192
00:20:41.887 --> 00:20:42.423
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

193
00:20:44.307 --> 00:20:45.166
<v Josh Roper>So I'll dive into the budget.

194
00:20:45.248 --> 00:20:49.749
<v Josh Roper>This is the Supplemental PHP budget, the spring budget adjustment.

195
00:20:50.213 --> 00:20:54.353
<v Josh Roper>This is the piece that is focused on immediate stabilization and eviction defense.

196
00:20:54.480 --> 00:20:57.127
<v Josh Roper>You'll see portfolio stabilization at the top.

197
00:20:57.192 --> 00:21:04.105
<v Josh Roper>This has been referred to as buydown, rent buydown, debt buydown work that has a stabilizing effect.

198
00:21:04.827 --> 00:21:19.476
<v Josh Roper>There are 3 buckets of sort of connected financial assistance, rent assistance, expanded rent assistance, and new rent So the first is focused on households before they face eviction.

199
00:21:20.069 --> 00:21:23.375
<v Josh Roper>The second is connected to our eviction legal defense program.

200
00:21:24.000 --> 00:21:29.424
<v Josh Roper>And the third is for folks who are experiencing homelessness, housing placements out of homelessness.

201
00:21:30.661 --> 00:21:32.442
<v Josh Roper>Then there's eviction defense services.

202
00:21:32.521 --> 00:21:36.277
<v Josh Roper>This is also bundled together with a potential right to counsel pilot.

203
00:21:37.384 --> 00:21:38.941
<v Josh Roper>Down payment assistance for tenants.

204
00:21:39.005 --> 00:21:40.931
<v Josh Roper>This is work that the Housing Bureau does already.

205
00:21:40.994 --> 00:21:41.154
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

206
00:21:42.653 --> 00:21:45.048
<v Josh Roper>So that will supplement current work.

207
00:21:45.290 --> 00:21:50.694
<v Josh Roper>And then an expansion of our landlord and tenant education work with that last line.

208
00:21:51.099 --> 00:21:54.223
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

209
00:21:54.288 --> 00:21:56.926
<v Josh Roper>And then a few other things from the same process.

210
00:21:56.976 --> 00:22:03.166
<v Josh Roper>So there is a social housing-focused revolving loan fund or acquisition fund.

211
00:22:04.199 --> 00:22:06.007
<v Josh Roper>We have a new housing investment manager.

212
00:22:06.200 --> 00:22:07.910
<v Josh Roper>I'm very excited about that.

213
00:22:08.502 --> 00:22:11.255
<v Josh Roper>She is already getting started on looking into how that will work.

214
00:22:12.204 --> 00:22:21.163
<v Josh Roper>Broadway Corridor Parcel 6 development, that's using TIF River District funds, and then gap financing for a specific project is the last item there.

215
00:22:21.584 --> 00:22:22.457
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

216
00:22:25.029 --> 00:22:30.855
<v Josh Roper>And then zooming out a little bit, so $134 million for affordable multifamily development.

217
00:22:31.163 --> 00:22:38.590
<v Josh Roper>Our affordable multifamily development program aims to produce and preserve regulated affordable housing for low-income Portlanders.

218
00:22:38.704 --> 00:22:46.576
<v Josh Roper>It leverages city resources to finance the development and preservation of high-quality, long-term rent-regulated housing up to 99 years.

219
00:22:46.688 --> 00:22:50.592
<v Josh Roper>It also leverages other resources beyond city coffers.

220
00:22:51.443 --> 00:22:55.348
<v Josh Roper>And then a list of partners we work with, a non-exclusive list.

221
00:22:55.863 --> 00:22:56.280
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

222
00:22:58.611 --> 00:23:13.209
<v Josh Roper>There's also an economic opportunity initiative in the budget for $2.1 million this is funded using CDBG, or Community Development Block Grant, dollars, and it is administered by Prosper.

223
00:23:13.272 --> 00:23:17.147
<v Josh Roper>So it's a pass-through to Prosper, and they administer that money.

224
00:23:17.436 --> 00:23:17.807
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

225
00:23:20.089 --> 00:23:22.717
<v Josh Roper>Homeowner Access and Retention for $14.6 million.

226
00:23:23.491 --> 00:23:29.759
<v Josh Roper>This program provides services and assistance that promote homeownership and housing stability for low- to moderate-income Portlanders.

227
00:23:30.528 --> 00:23:37.935
<v Josh Roper>It prioritizes households and families who have been displaced or are at risk of displacement while strengthening residents' financial stability.

228
00:23:38.211 --> 00:23:46.029
<v Josh Roper>This includes direct services, and we also administer subrecipient contracts with service providers to deliver services like home repair.

229
00:23:46.400 --> 00:23:48.263
<v Josh Roper>And this also includes down payment assistance.

230
00:23:49.244 --> 00:23:49.582
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

231
00:23:51.382 --> 00:23:56.477
<v Josh Roper>Our inclusionary housing program— this is both inclusionary housing and our development incentives work.

232
00:23:57.346 --> 00:24:04.384
<v Josh Roper>So that includes certain fee exemptions, property tax exemptions, bonus density, the administration of those programs.

233
00:24:04.961 --> 00:24:12.109
<v Josh Roper>This promotes affordable housing and otherwise market-rate developments, in particular inclusionary housing does that.

234
00:24:12.190 --> 00:24:18.409
<v Josh Roper>And then it assists affordable housing developed and operated by nonprofit and for-profit partners through financial incentives.

235
00:24:18.538 --> 00:24:19.644
<v Josh Roper>So filling gaps.

236
00:24:20.685 --> 00:24:26.275
<v Josh Roper>And then it also supports the creation of more affordable homeownership opportunities for low to moderate income households.

237
00:24:26.807 --> 00:24:27.064
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

238
00:24:31.542 --> 00:24:32.734
<v Josh Roper>The Rental Services Office.

239
00:24:32.815 --> 00:24:43.287
<v Josh Roper>This is $27.3 million, and we'll see overlap with some of what I talked about earlier from the budget adjustment, spring budget adjustment.

240
00:24:44.186 --> 00:24:53.132
<v Josh Roper>This is an office in the Housing Bureau that's responsible for research and policy recommendations, program development, and regulation related to landlord-tenant policy in Portland.

241
00:24:54.044 --> 00:25:13.027
<v Josh Roper>It improves tenants' ability to access and maintain housing through policies for— including contract management, application and screening rules, security deposit rules, and mandatory renter relocation, and provides direct services and contracts with a range of partners, some of whom are listed here.

242
00:25:14.359 --> 00:25:14.811
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

243
00:25:21.029 --> 00:25:24.513
<v Josh Roper>And then $3 million federal grant administration.

244
00:25:24.561 --> 00:25:28.721
<v Josh Roper>These aren't all of our federal grants, but we wanted to highlight this bucket.

245
00:25:29.378 --> 00:25:34.582
<v Josh Roper>So this is the Emergency Solutions Grant and Housing Opportunities for Persons with AIDS, or HOPWA.

246
00:25:34.855 --> 00:25:36.042
<v Josh Roper>So ESG and HOPWA.

247
00:25:36.750 --> 00:25:49.761
<v Josh Roper>And this pot of money helps people who are experiencing homelessness regain stability and permanent housing, provides housing assistance and supportive services for low-income people with HIV/AIDS and their families when we're talking about HOPWA.

248
00:25:50.347 --> 00:25:53.050
<v Josh Roper>And then a list of grant recipients at the bottom there.

249
00:25:53.789 --> 00:25:54.792
<v Josh Roper>Next slide.

250
00:25:55.665 --> 00:25:57.105
<v Josh Roper>Okay, I'll turn it over to Skyler.

251
00:25:57.689 --> 00:25:58.270
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Thanks, Josh.

252
00:25:58.513 --> 00:26:01.038
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Skyler Brokernop, Director of Portland Solutions, for the record.

253
00:26:01.086 --> 00:26:01.636
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Good to see you all.

254
00:26:02.529 --> 00:26:08.095
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Just very quickly, so we will be doing a budget work session on Portland Solutions budget May 12th.

255
00:26:08.529 --> 00:26:11.692
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So for all of my city colleagues, we'll have that in front of you.

256
00:26:11.757 --> 00:26:13.175
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We'll have a lot deeper dive on that.

257
00:26:13.546 --> 00:26:17.125
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>County colleagues, you're welcome to watch it if you want more budget work session fun.

258
00:26:17.865 --> 00:26:19.453
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>It will be online.

259
00:26:20.031 --> 00:26:28.365
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>But just a quick overview, as the mayor mentioned, so we're seeing about a third reduction, give or take, for the shelter services budget.

260
00:26:28.959 --> 00:26:36.217
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We provide currently overnight alternative shelter and day center services right now, and we've already had some news.

261
00:26:36.265 --> 00:26:38.319
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So you all have gotten emails thank you.

262
00:26:38.576 --> 00:26:41.161
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I know there's been some questions about our Northwest Northrup overnight shelter.

263
00:26:41.305 --> 00:26:47.355
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We're still in legal negotiations on when that would close, so I'll let you know as soon as we have a finalized date.

264
00:26:47.403 --> 00:26:52.009
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>There's been some media on certain dates, but I promise you there's not a finalized date yet.

265
00:26:52.057 --> 00:26:55.138
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>The lawyers are still negotiating, so as soon as we know, you will know.

266
00:26:56.166 --> 00:26:59.857
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>But right now we're just figuring out when that ramp-down period would be.

267
00:27:00.901 --> 00:27:04.207
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>The Centennial overnight shelter is ramping down right now for the end of this month.

268
00:27:04.352 --> 00:27:05.814
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So it'll be closed later this week.

269
00:27:06.182 --> 00:27:14.233
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We've had a long process with that organization as they've dissolved and will be dissolved at the end of this fiscal year, Sunstone Way.

270
00:27:14.635 --> 00:27:20.291
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And then Widler Village, you also got an email about, which is an alternative shelter that we are slowly closing down.

271
00:27:20.596 --> 00:27:23.778
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>It's the oldest Safe Rest Village in the portfolio.

272
00:27:24.597 --> 00:27:28.952
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>It has probably about 23 pods that are no longer usable.

273
00:27:29.032 --> 00:27:29.708
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>They're end of life.

274
00:27:29.820 --> 00:27:29.949
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

275
00:27:30.484 --> 00:27:33.759
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>But 15 will be reallocated across the system.

276
00:27:33.807 --> 00:27:40.933
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So we're looking at the best ways to add those pods to other villages for the most efficient kind of use of resources.

277
00:27:41.769 --> 00:27:43.103
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>More to come on that as well.

278
00:27:43.874 --> 00:27:50.647
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So we're still looking at what the total budget might be and what some different proposals would be from our shelter services team.

279
00:27:51.020 --> 00:27:54.117
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>That will be part of the discussion for the budget work session on the 12th.

280
00:27:54.750 --> 00:27:55.366
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Next slide, please.

281
00:27:56.955 --> 00:27:59.059
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And then just quickly on our city outreach team.

282
00:27:59.124 --> 00:28:06.574
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So it's called the Street Services Coordination Center, and they're seeing about a third of their budget cut as well, just due to funding constraints.

283
00:28:06.928 --> 00:28:10.990
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Most of that will be from a loss of a contracted outreach team.

284
00:28:11.086 --> 00:28:20.205
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So we're retaining our city FTE, so it's about 9 outreach workers, and we're gonna be losing a contracted outreach service.

285
00:28:20.865 --> 00:28:20.977
<v Josh Roper>Thank you.

286
00:28:21.699 --> 00:28:23.500
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>But we're hoping to make it work.

287
00:28:23.628 --> 00:28:30.289
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We'll dive in more during that budget work session on the 12th again, but I'll leave it there because I know we're tight on time.

288
00:28:30.788 --> 00:28:31.047
<v Jillian Schoney>Thanks.

289
00:28:33.544 --> 00:28:34.092
<v Jillian Schoney>Wonderful.

290
00:28:34.348 --> 00:28:35.412
<v Jillian Schoney>Thanks to all of you.

291
00:28:35.637 --> 00:28:39.922
<v Jillian Schoney>Okay, now to part 3, the impact of proposed budgets.

292
00:28:40.002 --> 00:28:40.984
<v Jillian Schoney>So thank you, Chair.

293
00:28:41.178 --> 00:28:42.659
<v Jillian Schoney>Thank you, Mayor, staff.

294
00:28:43.448 --> 00:28:49.211
<v Jillian Schoney>Our final section of the presentation is laying out a few scenarios relative to inflow and outflow.

295
00:28:49.260 --> 00:28:59.846
<v Jillian Schoney>The goal of this exercise is to inform the investment I'm going to lay out 2 investment decisions before you that y'all will debate and discuss over the next several weeks.

296
00:29:00.249 --> 00:29:12.343
<v Jillian Schoney>Your final decisions will also lay the groundwork for the goal setting related to our new key performance indicators that the SOC will take up later this summer after all of you collectively set the trajectory.

297
00:29:13.321 --> 00:29:21.721
<v Jillian Schoney>Before we get to those scenarios, I'm going to explain in very brief how we estimate projected inflow and outflow because they are different.

298
00:29:21.835 --> 00:29:21.994
<v Meghan Moyer>Thank you.

299
00:29:22.911 --> 00:29:23.505
<v Jillian Schoney>Next slide.

300
00:29:24.517 --> 00:29:28.210
<v Jillian Schoney>So first, a reminder that we don't completely control inflow.

301
00:29:28.434 --> 00:29:36.031
<v Jillian Schoney>There are a variety of factors that directly or indirectly influence an individual or a family's ability to stay housed.

302
00:29:36.866 --> 00:30:01.913
<v Jillian Schoney>What we've done here to illustrate that is pull a variety of news headlines, of recent news headlines, stories about layoffs or low wages or not enough work in the face of rising costs of living impeding a family's ability to pay that rent, um, manage increases in food bills, utility bills, gas bills, costly health events, trauma that happens such as domestic violence.

303
00:30:01.992 --> 00:30:03.967
<v Jillian Schoney>I think all of you are very well aware of that.

304
00:30:04.641 --> 00:30:16.982
<v Jillian Schoney>And if you read through the first part of Portland State's recently released Pathways report, it's the financial challenges and trauma that are the 2 leading common experiences that causes someone to become homeless.

305
00:30:17.240 --> 00:30:17.608
<v Jillian Schoney>Next slide.

306
00:30:18.186 --> 00:30:18.813
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

307
00:30:19.165 --> 00:30:31.894
<v Jillian Schoney>In addition to that, there are the investment decisions made by other governments, the consequences of which land on our— the doorstep of local government and the literal doorstep of members of our community.

308
00:30:32.471 --> 00:30:47.461
<v Jillian Schoney>Recent examples include the state largely walking away from eviction prevention, the federal cuts to food assistance that have already affected tens of thousands of Oregonians, and the threat that HUD is about to walk away in large part from investments in permanent supportive housing.

309
00:30:48.296 --> 00:30:54.311
<v Jillian Schoney>We here at the local level are asked to respond to the consequences of all those decisions, and we do.

310
00:30:55.659 --> 00:31:08.396
<v Jillian Schoney>The city and the county both spend millions of dollars each year on eviction prevention, and County Human Services spends millions more on other stability programs to keep people housed, particularly households with children.

311
00:31:09.615 --> 00:31:13.470
<v Jillian Schoney>But it's not enough to overcome what we can't control, as we thank you.

312
00:31:13.470 --> 00:31:13.470
<v Jillian Schoney>Thank you, Mayor.

313
00:31:13.470 --> 00:31:13.470
<v Jillian Schoney>I'm going to start with the good news.

314
00:31:13.470 --> 00:31:13.470
<v Jillian Schoney>We are seeing a decline in homelessness.

315
00:31:13.470 --> 00:31:15.359
<v Jillian Schoney>We're seeing a decline in homelessness that we see in our monthly inflow data.

316
00:31:16.349 --> 00:31:26.049
<v Jillian Schoney>The big exception to this, and I want to give credit where credit is due, is that more deeply affordable housing is the leading homelessness prevention strategy, and I don't want to leave that unsaid.

317
00:31:26.690 --> 00:31:32.420
<v Jillian Schoney>The city and the region do have measurable, measurable control over that with Metro and the state as partners.

318
00:31:32.650 --> 00:31:37.539
<v Jillian Schoney>We need to build more housing overall and correct for what the market will never build.

319
00:31:38.069 --> 00:31:49.932
<v Jillian Schoney>BPS and PHB are putting a lot of time and energy and smart thinking into that right now, and they recently presented to the SOC last Friday, and it's just, it's all great, phenomenal work.

320
00:31:50.590 --> 00:31:52.017
<v Jillian Schoney>So I want to say that, all that.

321
00:31:52.834 --> 00:32:08.460
<v Jillian Schoney>So what all of this means is that it is impossible to predict with absolute certainty that every single household would have become homeless if not for our eviction prevention support.

322
00:32:09.181 --> 00:32:15.640
<v Jillian Schoney>For example, if we prevent the court-ordered eviction of one person or family, we cannot yes.

323
00:32:15.736 --> 00:32:24.183
<v Jillian Schoney>Confident— confidently translate that into a one-for-one reduction in inflow to literal homelessness.

324
00:32:25.915 --> 00:32:28.618
<v Jillian Schoney>So what do we do for inflow?

325
00:32:29.200 --> 00:32:50.297
<v Jillian Schoney>What we do in our calculation is that we look at overall trends— how many people are new to our system each month compared to the overall investments in imminent prevention work and specifically the changes in those event— uh, uh, in those investments from one fiscal year to the next.

326
00:32:51.050 --> 00:33:03.435
<v Jillian Schoney>In other words, if inflow numbers are on an upward trend and we cut our eviction prevention investments, we project generally that inflow will get worse.

327
00:33:04.286 --> 00:33:13.815
<v Jillian Schoney>Conversely, if inflow is staying roughly the same and y'all choose to increase our eviction prevention investments, we estimate generally that inflow would decrease.

328
00:33:13.894 --> 00:33:14.038
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

329
00:33:17.021 --> 00:33:18.209
<v Jillian Schoney>Outflow is different.

330
00:33:18.481 --> 00:33:20.213
<v Jillian Schoney>It's much more straightforward.

331
00:33:21.048 --> 00:33:29.596
<v Jillian Schoney>We know that for about $13,000 on our, our average cost per housing placement, you increase our outflow by 1.

332
00:33:29.964 --> 00:33:34.856
<v Jillian Schoney>So we can estimate with higher confidence how your investments will influence outflow.

333
00:33:35.866 --> 00:33:39.298
<v Jillian Schoney>For example, on Wednesday, a person was in one of our shelters.

334
00:33:39.652 --> 00:33:41.079
<v Jillian Schoney>We housed them on Thursday.

335
00:33:41.160 --> 00:33:43.244
<v Jillian Schoney>We've got that move-in date put in HMIS.

336
00:33:43.325 --> 00:33:43.436
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

337
00:33:44.064 --> 00:33:51.576
<v Jillian Schoney>And so it is, it is a one-to-one from our homeless count directly off of our by-name list and into our housed count.

338
00:33:52.106 --> 00:33:52.959
<v Jillian Schoney>Much more straightforward.

339
00:33:55.114 --> 00:33:55.535
<v Jillian Schoney>So next slide.

340
00:33:56.295 --> 00:34:04.642
<v Jillian Schoney>Knowing that these are estimations, my proposition to you is that we should use our best data to focus on what we can control to reshape our impact.

341
00:34:05.415 --> 00:34:08.222
<v Jillian Schoney>And right now our system is not financially sustainable.

342
00:34:08.431 --> 00:34:09.188
<v Jillian Schoney>It's not balanced.

343
00:34:10.150 --> 00:34:28.614
<v Jillian Schoney>We can't get there in one fiscal year, especially in a cuts year, but we can begin to set ourselves on a better trajectory that over time will create that effective, balanced, and reliable homelessness response system we need here in Portland and Multnomah County.

344
00:34:29.931 --> 00:34:34.496
<v Jillian Schoney>With that, I'll pass it to Ryan, who will run through some high-level projections for you.

345
00:34:34.545 --> 00:34:34.724
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Mayor.

346
00:34:36.389 --> 00:34:40.541
<v Ryan Deibert>So if I did my job in the intro, this curve should look familiar.

347
00:34:41.487 --> 00:34:51.891
<v Ryan Deibert>Each of the red bars here reflects the actual data from our by-name list of the total number of people experiencing homelessness in Multnomah County measured each month for the past 2 years.

348
00:34:52.068 --> 00:34:56.315
<v Ryan Deibert>So again, that's our KPI number one that we're tracking and will continue to track.

349
00:34:57.438 --> 00:35:06.077
<v Ryan Deibert>Again, remember that within this graph, there's a really dynamic picture of thousands of people moving in and out of homelessness each month.

350
00:35:06.126 --> 00:35:06.510
<v Ryan Deibert>It's definitely not static.

351
00:35:06.719 --> 00:35:13.882
<v Ryan Deibert>So this is definitely not a static population, but with inflow outpacing outflow, the overall numbers continue to grow each month.

352
00:35:14.539 --> 00:35:27.983
<v Ryan Deibert>So the first scenario that we wanted to present today assumes that we continue with essentially the same level and mix of investments in prevention and housing placement that we have in our current fiscal year that's underway right now.

353
00:35:29.009 --> 00:35:45.840
<v Ryan Deibert>Unsurprisingly, the general trend represented here by the black line continues on the same general course with continued growth in the by-name list, adding hundreds of people each month and totaling several thousand additional people experiencing homelessness over the next 2 years.

354
00:35:46.594 --> 00:35:58.282
<v Ryan Deibert>More specifically, I would say this is the picture of maintaining heavy investments in shelter, especially at the expense of housing placement to move people quickly out of shelter and back to stability.

355
00:35:58.876 --> 00:36:02.248
<v Ryan Deibert>In that scenario, things only continue to get worse.

356
00:36:02.311 --> 00:36:07.458
<v Ryan Deibert>Our shelters will fill up, We get further and further away from outflow beating inflow.

357
00:36:07.554 --> 00:36:15.170
<v Ryan Deibert>If you go to the next slide, I'm glad to say though that the mayor and chair are proposing a better scenario.

358
00:36:15.650 --> 00:36:21.965
<v Ryan Deibert>So this slide illustrates the estimated impacts of the proposed executive budgets on both the city and the county side.

359
00:36:22.030 --> 00:36:23.617
<v Ryan Deibert>You just heard the summaries of those.

360
00:36:24.195 --> 00:36:26.983
<v Ryan Deibert>This is what it looks like to bring those together numerically.

361
00:36:28.378 --> 00:36:36.264
<v Ryan Deibert>Again, the status quo is represented by the black line and the estimated impact of the proposed executive budgets are represented by the blue line.

362
00:36:37.500 --> 00:36:50.981
<v Ryan Deibert>Even with the revenue constraints that we face in fiscal year '27, these budgets propose moving to that more balanced system by cutting some shelter resources while adding resources to prevention and housing placement work.

363
00:36:51.445 --> 00:36:55.869
<v Ryan Deibert>You can see the meaningful change in the trajectory here when you do that.

364
00:36:56.574 --> 00:36:57.889
<v Ryan Deibert>We begin to bend the curve.

365
00:36:57.954 --> 00:36:59.043
<v Ryan Deibert>That's the good news.

366
00:36:59.541 --> 00:37:06.802
<v Ryan Deibert>But with constrained resources, we still do not beat inflow by an estimate of a little more than 1,600 people across the fiscal year.

367
00:37:06.882 --> 00:37:07.155
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

368
00:37:07.900 --> 00:37:16.224
<v Ryan Deibert>So again, this is what it looks like to rebalance our system in the right direction, even if it's not fully resourced for maximum impact.

369
00:37:17.036 --> 00:37:18.063
<v Ryan Deibert>If we can go to the next slide.

370
00:37:19.900 --> 00:37:27.197
<v Ryan Deibert>Luckily for you, as the legislative bodies for our jurisdictions, your decisions don't have to end at the executive budget proposals.

371
00:37:27.773 --> 00:37:32.175
<v Ryan Deibert>You've charged us to help you think collectively about how you can do more.

372
00:37:32.936 --> 00:37:36.092
<v Ryan Deibert>And so we wanna help you consider some additional scenarios, specifically—.

373
00:37:36.092 --> 00:37:36.318
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

374
00:37:36.922 --> 00:37:45.927
<v Ryan Deibert>We want you to understand how increases in levels of effort on the front end in prevention and on the back end in housing placement affect the estimated trajectories.

375
00:37:46.554 --> 00:37:49.893
<v Ryan Deibert>So this first scenario isn't a hypothetical, actually.

376
00:37:50.952 --> 00:38:16.061
<v Ryan Deibert>Since the Chair's proposed budget was filed, the Department of County Human Services did some work to estimate what it would take to draw down more Medicaid-funded eviction prevention money from the one-time health-related social needs that's a federally funded Medicaid money that's carved out for eviction prevention to support people on the Oregon Health Plan who are facing both health and housing instability.

377
00:38:17.072 --> 00:38:24.168
<v Ryan Deibert>The program started through Oregon's most recent Medicaid waiver, and it's due to expire in September of 2027.

378
00:38:24.539 --> 00:38:29.547
<v Ryan Deibert>So in that sense, this is use it or lose it, likely one-time statewide resource.

379
00:38:29.597 --> 00:38:29.789
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

380
00:38:30.766 --> 00:38:35.465
<v Ryan Deibert>And DCHS is pretty certain we can use more of it in Multnomah County in the next year.

381
00:38:36.170 --> 00:38:54.994
<v Ryan Deibert>If DCHS were to hire 3 more limited duration FTE at a total cost of around $300,000, they think that would give them the capacity to draw down an additional $7.8 million in Medicaid prevention assistance for eligible households that they otherwise wouldn't have the capacity to serve.

382
00:38:55.635 --> 00:39:05.556
<v Ryan Deibert>We estimate that the subsequent reduction in inflow would further bend this curve beyond the current proposed budgets should the county board decide to go in that direction.

383
00:39:05.605 --> 00:39:18.168
<v Ryan Deibert>Again, the status quo is the black line, the proposed executive budgets are the blue line, and the dashed yellow line shows the estimated impact of that additional Medicaid prevention spending coming into our community.

384
00:39:18.762 --> 00:39:25.717
<v Ryan Deibert>So again, inflow would still outpace outflow for the year, but less so than without the additional federal resources in the mix.

385
00:39:25.782 --> 00:39:25.943
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

386
00:39:27.434 --> 00:39:28.317
<v Ryan Deibert>Next slide.

387
00:39:29.184 --> 00:39:43.527
<v Ryan Deibert>And then last, we wanna demonstrate a scenario that builds on that additional Medicaid-funded prevention resource and adds an additional $5 million in investment in housing placement beyond the current proposed budgets.

388
00:39:44.056 --> 00:39:47.858
<v Ryan Deibert>So that scenario is represented here as the green dotted line.

389
00:39:48.307 --> 00:39:52.110
<v Ryan Deibert>So combined, we estimate that those actions would draw us nearly even even.

390
00:39:52.318 --> 00:40:03.266
<v Ryan Deibert>Even, inflow to outflow on the year, shifting us from year-to-year increases of people experiencing homelessness in the thousands instead to increases potentially in the hundreds.

391
00:40:04.085 --> 00:40:10.907
<v Ryan Deibert>In several of those months across the next fiscal year under this scenario, you might see outflow outpacing inflow.

392
00:40:11.483 --> 00:40:19.766
<v Ryan Deibert>And on average across the year, monthly inflow might outpace outflow by closer to 30 people compared to our current rates of about 300.

393
00:40:20.990 --> 00:40:27.867
<v Ryan Deibert>So it's important to keep in mind that the outflow-focused housing placement investments are scalable too.

394
00:40:28.237 --> 00:40:34.989
<v Ryan Deibert>So for each $5 million that you invest, it's reasonable to expect that you increase annual outflow by more than 300 people.

395
00:40:36.596 --> 00:40:49.971
<v Ryan Deibert>We estimate that you'd need to increase housing placement investments by roughly $11 million beyond the executive proposed budgets to get to a net neutral line here where inflow equals outflow for the year.

396
00:40:50.619 --> 00:40:55.864
<v Ryan Deibert>Investments beyond that additional $11 million could actually bend that curve negative again.

397
00:40:57.706 --> 00:41:14.369
<v Ryan Deibert>In a budget year as tough as this one though, I anticipate that it's both— this is both a challenging and sobering set of projections, but I hope it helps us collectively understand that you have some solid options to begin moving things in the right direction.

398
00:41:14.974 --> 00:41:21.795
<v Ryan Deibert>And that your alignment across our jurisdictions can sustain and expand on that progress in future fiscal years.

399
00:41:21.923 --> 00:41:23.568
<v Ryan Deibert>I'll kick it back to Jillian.

400
00:41:24.320 --> 00:41:27.623
<v Jillian Schoney>Yeah, just some key takeaways, Council President, before I kick it back to you.

401
00:41:29.713 --> 00:41:34.106
<v Jillian Schoney>What we— I think we have demonstrated is that your budgets can and should work together to bend the curve.

402
00:41:34.300 --> 00:41:36.021
<v Jillian Schoney>I think the proposed budgets have done that.

403
00:41:36.739 --> 00:41:44.666
<v Jillian Schoney>Continued heavy investments in shelter at the expense of prevention and placement will only lead to increased increases in overall homelessness and unsheltered homelessness.

404
00:41:45.762 --> 00:41:52.690
<v Jillian Schoney>We need enough prevention, enough shelter, and enough placement to create an effective, balanced, and reliable system.

405
00:41:53.835 --> 00:41:58.039
<v Jillian Schoney>And cuts are hard, yet the proposals in front of you do put us on a better pathway forward.

406
00:41:58.088 --> 00:42:00.036
<v Jillian Schoney>So I think that is to be noted and celebrated.

407
00:42:00.507 --> 00:42:01.108
<v Jillian Schoney>Thank you so much.

408
00:42:03.170 --> 00:42:04.233
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, team.

409
00:42:05.731 --> 00:42:09.172
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, we have about 75 minutes and there are 14 of us.

410
00:42:09.237 --> 00:42:12.981
<v Jamie Dunphy>That means we each get We have about 5 minutes of time to ask questions and back and forth.

411
00:42:13.061 --> 00:42:18.639
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, uh, uh, City Council colleagues, feel free to throw your hand up in the queue.

412
00:42:19.074 --> 00:42:22.213
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, County colleagues, just make eye contact with me and I'll add you to the list.

413
00:42:23.244 --> 00:42:23.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Green.

414
00:42:25.931 --> 00:42:27.561
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, uh, Council President.

415
00:42:27.610 --> 00:42:36.170
<v Mitch Green>I threw my hand up because I had a technical question on the slide, but I guess we're, we're just now in the broad thing, so I'll— maybe I'll ask my question and come back in the queue if I, I have more.

416
00:42:37.050 --> 00:42:37.793
<v Mitch Green>Or maybe I'll do it all now.

417
00:42:37.907 --> 00:42:38.166
<v Mitch Green>We'll see.

418
00:42:38.876 --> 00:42:42.175
<v Mitch Green>Can you go back to the trend line?

419
00:42:43.942 --> 00:42:47.498
<v Mitch Green>I think the first trend line data that you were presenting, please.

420
00:42:49.791 --> 00:42:53.423
<v Mitch Green>Ryan?

421
00:42:54.916 --> 00:42:56.181
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, that's it.

422
00:42:56.295 --> 00:42:56.538
<v Mitch Green>Perfect.

423
00:42:57.007 --> 00:43:19.771
<v Ryan Deibert>So my question is, on the predicted trend line, is that a sort of So what we're able to do is to, we take, we look at the current trends in inflow, we project that forward.

424
00:43:20.289 --> 00:43:28.853
<v Ryan Deibert>We look at our current levels of investment in moving people back into housing, subtract that from inflow, and that's how you get that line carried forward.

425
00:43:28.902 --> 00:43:29.130
<v Ryan Deibert>Thank you.

426
00:43:30.688 --> 00:43:31.012
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

427
00:43:31.188 --> 00:43:32.528
<v Mitch Green>I think that answers my question.

428
00:43:32.626 --> 00:43:40.025
<v Mitch Green>It's a little hard to see that continuing on a straight line out that years.

429
00:43:40.235 --> 00:43:43.250
<v Mitch Green>I understand forecasting is an imprecise science.

430
00:43:43.947 --> 00:43:45.795
<v Mitch Green>But if that's the case, that's alarming.

431
00:43:47.969 --> 00:43:56.905
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate the sort of later slides where you look at the effect of the proposed budgets and then, you know, sort of a function of the effort approach.

432
00:43:56.969 --> 00:43:57.016
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

433
00:43:57.494 --> 00:43:58.976
<v Mitch Green>To bend or sort of flatten the curve.

434
00:43:59.041 --> 00:43:59.476
<v Mitch Green>That's good.

435
00:44:00.217 --> 00:44:01.619
<v Mitch Green>I want to make sure I heard you correctly though.

436
00:44:01.684 --> 00:44:13.478
<v Mitch Green>You said at the end of your presentation that for each $5 million that we invest— and I'm not sure exactly where we were investing, was it, was it the sort of placement stuff?

437
00:44:14.632 --> 00:44:15.199
<v Mitch Green>Okay, placements.

438
00:44:15.911 --> 00:44:21.260
<v Mitch Green>Then for each $5 million, we reduce or we increase outflows by 300 people.

439
00:44:21.356 --> 00:44:21.405
<v Mitch Green>Is—.

440
00:44:21.827 --> 00:44:22.378
<v Mitch Green>Did I hear that correctly?

441
00:44:22.943 --> 00:44:27.338
<v Ryan Deibert>Yeah, it varies depending on the level of intervention.

442
00:44:28.079 --> 00:44:34.623
<v Ryan Deibert>Our current estimates of around $13,000 per household would yield about 380 households that you could place.

443
00:44:36.329 --> 00:44:41.692
<v Ryan Deibert>For folks with higher levels of acuity that need additional support, those costs can be higher.

444
00:44:41.773 --> 00:44:46.190
<v Ryan Deibert>So I hedged my statement to 300 instead of 380.

445
00:44:46.418 --> 00:44:52.494
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's good to know that there's already that hedge built in 'cause I was gonna then ask, Does this scale linearly?

446
00:44:53.009 --> 00:44:58.048
<v Mitch Green>Like if you were to say, okay, $5 million gets you something, but does $10 million get you twice what $5 million got?

447
00:44:58.144 --> 00:45:00.985
<v Mitch Green>Does $15 million get you 3 times what $5 million got?

448
00:45:01.612 --> 00:45:07.983
<v Mitch Green>I sort of start to— I feel like intuitively that there's going to be some bottleneck and scale issues there potentially.

449
00:45:09.139 --> 00:45:12.751
<v Mitch Green>But the $300 versus the $350 is a way to kind of hedge that a little bit.

450
00:45:13.873 --> 00:45:29.668
<v Mitch Green>So in our proposed budget, that we're contemplating, we are not sending $31 million to the county, and we are instead putting that into Portland Solutions to do our own overnight shelter program and alternative shelter program.

451
00:45:32.670 --> 00:45:42.913
<v Mitch Green>That, by my math, that's— you divide 5 into $30 million 6 times, so that would reduce— that would increase outflow by 1,800 people.

452
00:45:42.960 --> 00:45:43.204
<v Mitch Green>That's not true.

453
00:45:44.911 --> 00:45:45.184
<v Candace Avalos>Roughly?

454
00:45:45.956 --> 00:45:48.028
<v Ryan Deibert>Roughly, if you were to invest it that way, yes.

455
00:45:48.077 --> 00:46:02.842
<v Mitch Green>So instead of maintaining a year of an overnight shelter program that on the first data slide shows that we've only increased our unsheltered population since then, we could, we could house 1,800 people by this.

456
00:46:03.146 --> 00:46:05.090
<v Mitch Green>Okay, I think that's all I've got for now.

457
00:46:05.572 --> 00:46:05.813
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

458
00:46:06.199 --> 00:46:06.987
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

459
00:46:07.822 --> 00:46:09.958
<v Jamie Dunphy>Next in the queue is going to be Avalos Singleton Novick.

460
00:46:10.907 --> 00:46:11.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos.

461
00:46:12.385 --> 00:46:12.978
<v Candace Avalos>Great, thank you.

462
00:46:14.679 --> 00:46:16.538
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you all for your presentation.

463
00:46:16.795 --> 00:46:21.804
<v Candace Avalos>Um, before I get to my question, I just want to acknowledge something important that I'm seeing in these presentations.

464
00:46:22.711 --> 00:46:30.472
<v Candace Avalos>I really appreciate the emphasis on eviction prevention and rent assistance, rapid rehousing, uh, and housing stabilization strategies.

465
00:46:30.746 --> 00:46:35.552
<v Candace Avalos>Those investments matter deeply, and they have a real impact on Portlanders that are trying to stay housed.

466
00:46:36.621 --> 00:46:47.907
<v Candace Avalos>I also want to be clear that many of those investments happened because members of this council pushed hard for them prior— during prior budget discussions and the spring budget adjustment that we just did last week or 2 weeks ago.

467
00:46:48.244 --> 00:46:59.561
<v Candace Avalos>So I want to thank my co-sponsors of Keep Portland Housed who partnered with me to ensure that we're investing in the stabilizing methods that we are seeing in this data are helpful.

468
00:46:59.625 --> 00:47:12.295
<v Candace Avalos>Because frankly, without those investments, much of the— what I see of the broader direction of the city's presentation is still heavily centered on shelter operations and public environment management, downstream crisis response.

469
00:47:12.376 --> 00:47:21.784
<v Candace Avalos>And so I think it's important that we recognize the distinction between investments that stabilize people upstream versus investments that manage the impacts of homelessness after they've already fallen into crisis.

470
00:47:22.411 --> 00:47:29.139
<v Candace Avalos>And what also stood out to me is that the data and projections that we were shown appear to reinforce the importance of those upstream investments.

471
00:47:29.637 --> 00:47:36.429
<v Candace Avalos>The presentations identify housing costs, wage stagnation, evictions, and broader economic instability as the major drivers of inflows.

472
00:47:36.510 --> 00:47:37.407
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

473
00:47:37.568 --> 00:47:47.793
<v Candace Avalos>And also those projections are showing or suggesting that increasing prevention investments improves the long-term trajectory compared to simply continuing the current approach.

474
00:47:47.873 --> 00:48:04.327
<v Candace Avalos>So what I'm trying to better understand is whether the city and county are operating from different theories of change when it comes to the homelessness response system, because the county presentation to me seems to point strongly toward prevention and stabilization and reducing inflow upstream.

475
00:48:04.777 --> 00:48:10.813
<v Candace Avalos>While I see many of the city's investments still appear concentrated in shelter activation, public environment.

476
00:48:11.295 --> 00:48:24.108
<v Candace Avalos>So my question is, if the data and projections are telling us that prevention and housing stabilization meaningful— meaningfully reduce inflow, how are the city and county currently dividing responsibilities across the homelessness response system?

477
00:48:24.623 --> 00:48:29.246
<v Candace Avalos>And does the city see its role differently from the county when it comes to prevention versus downstream response?

478
00:48:29.342 --> 00:48:36.106
<v Candace Avalos>Councilmember Koyama Lane, And I'll just for time, I'll add my second part of my question and anyone is willing or is able to answer.

479
00:48:36.811 --> 00:48:45.112
<v Candace Avalos>And then I also just in general worry that we are increasingly investing in managing the visibility of homelessness rather than reducing homelessness itself.

480
00:48:45.161 --> 00:48:55.449
<v Candace Avalos>So how are we ensuring that activation, shelter management, and public environment strategies are not crowding out investments in prevention, stabilization, and permanent exits to housing?

481
00:48:55.539 --> 00:48:58.023
<v Candace Avalos>I don't know who that— who can answer that.

482
00:48:58.070 --> 00:49:01.317
<v Candace Avalos>I don't know if that's like a leadership question, if that's, you know, you all as staff.

483
00:49:01.414 --> 00:49:03.248
<v Candace Avalos>I'll just kind of leave it open for whoever is willing.

484
00:49:05.246 --> 00:49:05.637
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Thanks.

485
00:49:06.057 --> 00:49:09.643
<v Jillian Schoney>Do either the mayor or the chair want to take that first, and then we can layer in?

486
00:49:11.170 --> 00:49:11.706
<v Josh Roper>You can go ahead, Mayor.

487
00:49:15.273 --> 00:49:25.153
<v Keith Wilson>I think Councilor Avalos— I think Councilor Avalos has already heard from me so much over the last year or so, so I would say from the high level, I understand your question.

488
00:49:25.266 --> 00:49:28.317
<v Keith Wilson>We want the most effective dollars to be used where necessary.

489
00:49:29.119 --> 00:49:31.480
<v Keith Wilson>I think Councilor Green hit on a very important point.

490
00:49:32.074 --> 00:49:39.153
<v Keith Wilson>You know, if there's $40 million in the sheltering services, the majority of that is in our alternative shelters and SRV sites.

491
00:49:40.342 --> 00:49:46.074
<v Keith Wilson>I'd be loath to close those because those are individuals that are currently housed in it 24/7.

492
00:49:46.137 --> 00:50:00.264
<v Keith Wilson>So if we were to use that, That strategy of taking $5 million reduction in shelter for 300 souls to be housed at 18,000 souls that are listed, it would only reduce it by 600.

493
00:50:00.829 --> 00:50:05.998
<v Keith Wilson>And we would be— we wouldn't be able to provide a public safety response to those suffering on the street.

494
00:50:06.853 --> 00:50:13.431
<v Keith Wilson>So I'd be loath to remove and reduce that because as the City of Portland and as the mayor, you know, our purview is public safety.

495
00:50:13.478 --> 00:50:13.688
<v Jillian Schoney>Thank you.

496
00:50:14.429 --> 00:50:18.119
<v Keith Wilson>And public space to care for our community members.

497
00:50:18.233 --> 00:50:24.481
<v Keith Wilson>And so my point would be, I think we have to continue to have a shelter system and a fully funded continuum of care.

498
00:50:25.516 --> 00:50:36.648
<v Keith Wilson>But I think if we remove one in favor or overweight another, then we have a system that's not gonna be fully functioning and meeting our community members where they're at at that particular moment.

499
00:50:36.728 --> 00:50:36.889
<v Keith Wilson>So.

500
00:50:38.657 --> 00:50:49.501
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yeah, I'll just add a little bit to, I think, Yes, we have different responsibilities, and I think we— the city gets a lot of the immediate things are on fire, literally, calls.

501
00:50:49.934 --> 00:50:51.653
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We have all the first responders.

502
00:50:51.702 --> 00:50:52.842
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We manage the public space.

503
00:50:52.907 --> 00:50:58.804
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think as long as there are people living in the public space, the city will be asked to manage that.

504
00:50:59.510 --> 00:51:00.635
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I just named that.

505
00:51:00.699 --> 00:51:07.865
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think we're going to probably be in the shelter system or some similar kind of business as long as there are people living on the streets.

506
00:51:07.914 --> 00:51:08.139
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Councilor Smith.

507
00:51:08.251 --> 00:51:09.260
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>The streets of Portland.

508
00:51:09.757 --> 00:51:11.231
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And so I think there's a tension there.

509
00:51:12.081 --> 00:51:19.052
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>But I also will say we work with our county partners every single day because of exactly what Jillian and Ryan were walking us through.

510
00:51:19.164 --> 00:51:29.436
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I'll just mention today I had a call with someone at the county about, okay, if we're able to have a little bit of carryover of this color of money, could we use this for a few more placements?

511
00:51:29.485 --> 00:51:38.460
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And how would that help both the city and the county in the system to house more So that's happening every single day, and we're trying to make sure those hydraulics make sense.

512
00:51:39.342 --> 00:51:52.985
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We're just doing the best we can with the information we have, and I think it's always a balance, and you're always trying to learn, but you're doing it in real time because we're taking emails, phone calls, and thousands of reports every single day on what's going on on the streets of Portland.

513
00:51:53.034 --> 00:51:58.228
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I think we're all just trying to manage all those manifestations and really help people.

514
00:51:59.126 --> 00:52:01.739
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>There's a lot of ways to do that, and I think it's not a one-to-one.

515
00:52:01.932 --> 00:52:03.500
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So what the mayor is saying about alternatives thank you.

516
00:52:03.500 --> 00:52:03.500
<v Loretta Smith>So I think that's a great question.

517
00:52:03.500 --> 00:52:13.389
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So when we think about alternative shelter, what I've seen personally is there are some folks who we could put with the housing placement right now and they will succeed and they will do great, and that's awesome.

518
00:52:13.559 --> 00:52:19.219
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And there's some folks that are going to need some time to stabilize, to have wraparound services, and are not quite ready.

519
00:52:19.699 --> 00:52:22.389
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And an alternative shelter is a great spot for them for right now.

520
00:52:22.420 --> 00:52:27.099
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>It's an expensive resource, but I always say you also have to think about the ROI.

521
00:52:27.099 --> 00:52:31.873
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So a jail bed, a the return on investment of your investment dollars.

522
00:52:32.289 --> 00:52:39.309
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So a jail bed, a bed at Unity, a bed at a hospital, an ED visit, those are all incredibly expensive as well.

523
00:52:39.534 --> 00:52:46.568
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I think we're just weighing all those different elements, but I think we have to be really intentional in how we make those investments.

524
00:52:46.648 --> 00:52:50.670
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And I think the mayor and the chair really debated all of those pieces with their proposed budgets.

525
00:52:51.295 --> 00:52:55.028
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And Councilor, if I could, I just, I appreciate the question so much.

526
00:52:55.141 --> 00:53:02.784
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I think there is a difference in the roles between the city and the county, and I think— and I'm happy to explain my perspective on that.

527
00:53:02.833 --> 00:53:20.690
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>But I think the important thing is like it's not just about the difference in roles, but how are we making sure that in the work that's being done, whatever it is, that we're not duplicating services, that we're not creating parallel systems that aren't working, that we're not— that we're being efficient about and really leaning into the strengths of each of our governments.

528
00:53:21.012 --> 00:53:23.090
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So for me, Multnomah County is responsible Councilor Smith.

529
00:53:23.090 --> 00:53:23.090
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Thank you, Mayor.

530
00:53:23.090 --> 00:53:42.440
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I think that we're all responsible for addressing homelessness overall, which is why for me, as I was putting my budget together, making sure that we were investing in our overall system in a smart way so that we're not overinvesting in one part of our system in an unsustainable way that doesn't actually bend that curve that we were seeing before.

531
00:53:42.909 --> 00:53:52.047
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And that was why the decision to have to cut shelter beds, for instance, was made so that we could have more resources to invest in eviction prevention, in housing placement dollars, Thank you.

532
00:53:52.112 --> 00:53:53.268
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And in permanent housing, right?

533
00:53:53.862 --> 00:54:06.097
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Um, I think the thing that I haven't heard yet that is so critical though to the success that we're having is something that is truly a city-focused, um, a city responsibility is housing and building housing.

534
00:54:06.146 --> 00:54:14.688
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Like, that is just something that, that is not in the wheelhouse of the county, but it is critical to the solutions that we need in order to get more affordable housing options for people.

535
00:54:15.619 --> 00:54:31.568
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And then I will say the other thing that the that the county does that we, we are, you know, always in dialogue and in partnership, but really, um, is a, is a, um, county thing as the local, um, mental health authority, is behavioral health issues and, and the investments that we've made there and the work that we do with our partners too.

536
00:54:32.226 --> 00:54:34.456
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you for those responses.

537
00:54:34.632 --> 00:54:39.557
<v Candace Avalos>Um, I'll— I think I'll just end because I, uh, Commissioner Singleton, you're after me, right?

538
00:54:39.621 --> 00:54:49.438
<v Candace Avalos>So maybe I'll pose this because you might want to speak to this because I know we've discussed this a lot around like public space management and, you know, That being an explicit role of the city, yes.

539
00:54:50.190 --> 00:54:55.463
<v Candace Avalos>But I think my growing concern is that exactly what the Chair said of like these parallel systems.

540
00:54:55.960 --> 00:55:10.574
<v Candace Avalos>And if the county is deciding based on their data to make certain investments in things that are going to actually start to work to that, if the city's not on the same page and they're making investments in things that you are de-investing from, there's another word for that, uninvesting?

541
00:55:10.637 --> 00:55:10.909
<v Jamie Dunphy>Disinvesting.

542
00:55:10.958 --> 00:55:12.096
<v Candace Avalos>Disinvesting, okay, thank you.

543
00:55:13.282 --> 00:55:15.269
<v Candace Avalos>Then what does that mean for our partnership?

544
00:55:15.349 --> 00:55:22.516
<v Candace Avalos>That's what I don't understand as we're entering this budget, trying to figure out again, what is our specific role that we have all identified as the city's role?

545
00:55:22.563 --> 00:55:30.402
<v Candace Avalos>And I agree that housing is our main one, but this is what I'm trying to square is like, if we are disinvesting, why can I not think of that word?

546
00:55:31.701 --> 00:55:34.971
<v Candace Avalos>In an area at the county that we're investing in at the city.

547
00:55:35.067 --> 00:55:38.144
<v Candace Avalos>I mean, I'm not saying that that's not overall a negative thing, right?

548
00:55:38.208 --> 00:55:41.286
<v Candace Avalos>There might be things where it's like, we're gonna go lower here so we can go higher there.

549
00:55:41.719 --> 00:55:46.039
<v Candace Avalos>But I don't know that I'm really seeing how the data is reflecting how those investments are shifting.

550
00:55:46.458 --> 00:55:54.431
<v Candace Avalos>And I just want to understand, you know, especially from the mayor and the chair who are proposing the first budget, how you're looking at that, how you're working together to come to the investments that you've put forward.

551
00:55:54.545 --> 00:55:57.382
<v Candace Avalos>So I'll just leave that as open-ended for people to respond to.

552
00:55:57.949 --> 00:55:58.338
<v Candace Avalos>But thank you.

553
00:55:59.391 --> 00:56:00.347
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

554
00:56:00.947 --> 00:56:03.130
<v Jamie Dunphy>Next 3 are going to be Singleton, Novick, Kanal.

555
00:56:03.291 --> 00:56:04.067
<v Jamie Dunphy>Commissioner Singleton.

556
00:56:05.777 --> 00:56:06.213
<v Commissioner Singleton>Thank you.

557
00:56:07.730 --> 00:56:09.505
<v Commissioner Singleton>And Councilor Avalos, I agree.

558
00:56:09.568 --> 00:56:14.918
<v Commissioner Singleton>I think some of our conversation has been How does the council want to show up in this work?

559
00:56:15.126 --> 00:56:21.980
<v Commissioner Singleton>And if it is around community safety and public space management, there are lots of options for you all on what that means.

560
00:56:22.108 --> 00:56:29.860
<v Commissioner Singleton>And you and I've talked a little bit about a model in Seattle, a program called We Deliver Care, that does this very differently than we do here.

561
00:56:30.614 --> 00:56:34.530
<v Commissioner Singleton>I think that you have day centers and thinking about how you want to invest in those.

562
00:56:35.429 --> 00:56:43.509
<v Commissioner Singleton>It may be that overnight-only shelters make 24/7 makes sense for services.

563
00:56:43.605 --> 00:56:51.739
<v Commissioner Singleton>I think that's part of what we're all wrestling with, and I think you all will have to wrestle with as a council as you're looking at how you want to show up in the budget.

564
00:56:53.733 --> 00:56:59.922
<v Commissioner Singleton>But I do agree, the duplicative administrative structure is something that comes up not just in this part of the system.

565
00:57:00.556 --> 00:57:03.677
<v Commissioner Singleton>It is coming out as a core recommendation out of the Eviction Prevention Workgroup.

566
00:57:03.724 --> 00:57:04.210
<v Commissioner Singleton>I think that's a good point.

567
00:57:04.360 --> 00:57:04.536
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

568
00:57:04.889 --> 00:57:16.481
<v Commissioner Singleton>I think we've heard from the legal services group that contractors do not want to continue having legal services contracts with both the city and the county, and our rent assistance contractors do not want to continue managing 2 contracts, one with the city and the county.

569
00:57:16.914 --> 00:57:24.251
<v Commissioner Singleton>So I do think we have to figure out how to say, you all do legal services and eviction prevention well, you pay for that.

570
00:57:24.925 --> 00:57:26.963
<v Commissioner Singleton>We do this part well, we'll pay for that.

571
00:57:27.108 --> 00:57:30.784
<v Commissioner Singleton>And if there's additional funds that need to pass through, then that's something we should consider.

572
00:57:32.436 --> 00:57:36.724
<v Commissioner Singleton>And I'd love to keep getting into the weeds on the actual numbers with you on that as all of our budgets progress.

573
00:57:38.485 --> 00:57:50.054
<v Commissioner Singleton>I do want to ask a couple of questions, and I apologize because the slides aren't numbered, so I'm just going to say it's the housing goals slide, and it talks about reducing vacancies and affordable units.

574
00:57:50.686 --> 00:57:57.545
<v Commissioner Singleton>I know on the last steering and oversight committee, we heard that there are 1,600 vacant units in Affordable housing.

575
00:57:57.659 --> 00:58:01.393
<v Commissioner Singleton>Do we know what the income level, the AMI level of those units are?

576
00:58:02.552 --> 00:58:04.418
<v Josh Roper>I don't have that offhand, but we can look into it.

577
00:58:05.309 --> 00:58:05.389
<v Josh Roper>Okay.

578
00:58:05.599 --> 00:58:13.295
<v Commissioner Singleton>I would love to look at what those— no, and if there's any at 0 to 30, like, okay, let's get those right now, right?

579
00:58:13.360 --> 00:58:15.405
<v Commissioner Singleton>We've got folks on fixed income who qualify for that.

580
00:58:15.518 --> 00:58:16.065
<v Commissioner Singleton>Let's move them.

581
00:58:16.885 --> 00:58:21.512
<v Commissioner Singleton>I'm concerned that most of them are in the 60% AMI level.

582
00:58:21.784 --> 00:58:34.449
<v Commissioner Singleton>And we know from our data that the folks in our homelessness services system So they're still not making enough money to live in those vacant units.

583
00:58:34.730 --> 00:58:47.679
<v Commissioner Singleton>And we have got to reconcile, I think, as 2 bodies, are we going to continue to subsidize in private market, or are we going to put subsidies into our affordable portfolio and buy these rents down so that we can serve more people?

584
00:58:48.429 --> 00:58:51.590
<v Commissioner Singleton>I think we have to have a more earnest conversation about that.

585
00:58:51.590 --> 00:58:53.250
<v Loretta Smith>And there's been a lot of, you know, the mayor has been very vocal about this.

586
00:58:53.250 --> 00:58:53.489
<v Josh Roper>I think we have to have a more earnest We've conversation about that.

587
00:58:53.489 --> 00:58:59.679
<v Commissioner Singleton>And there's been a lot known of, you know, about these vacancies for almost a year now, and I don't feel like I'm seeing a lot of movement on how we're filling them.

588
00:59:00.340 --> 00:59:04.952
<v Commissioner Singleton>I don't know what is needed or if you all have an idea or a concept on what will move forward next.

589
00:59:05.275 --> 00:59:11.186
<v Commissioner Singleton>I know this is about budget, but I feel like if I need to make budget investments to activate those vacancies, I want to know that now.

590
00:59:12.271 --> 00:59:17.123
<v Commissioner Singleton>So I'm curious what the plan is or if there is a plan to address those vacant units.

591
00:59:17.284 --> 00:59:19.614
<v Josh Roper>Yeah, I'll say you're right.

592
00:59:19.809 --> 00:59:19.889
<v Josh Roper>Right.

593
00:59:20.228 --> 00:59:28.306
<v Josh Roper>At a high level, I don't have the specific numbers, but it is primarily the 60% units, not the deeper affordability units.

594
00:59:29.820 --> 00:59:40.152
<v Josh Roper>One piece is the budget adjustment, $8.8 million, that is focused on some form of buydown that it's meant to translate into lower rents.

595
00:59:40.201 --> 00:59:46.467
<v Josh Roper>So that is an area that PHB has done work in already, and I think that investment will be meaningful.

596
00:59:46.887 --> 00:59:51.780
<v Josh Roper>And there is broader work happening around vacancy activation led by the mayor and team.

597
00:59:51.990 --> 00:59:54.202
<v Josh Roper>So there is work happening.

598
00:59:55.181 --> 01:00:05.907
<v Josh Roper>It is a large undertaking to sort of shift these units toward usability for people experiencing homelessness in a meaningful way.

599
01:00:06.068 --> 01:00:10.893
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Commissioner, I would also just share there's another table that's focused kind of on stabilizing buildings.

600
01:00:10.942 --> 01:00:16.632
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So looking at the 20 buildings that are kind of most affected for a lot of different factors and reasons.

601
01:00:16.905 --> 01:00:28.393
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Without getting too far into the weeds, and I'm happy to go through it with you at some point, but we looked at kind of BOEC calls per building, and, you know, in some cases it's averaging a call to 911 per unit per month.

602
01:00:28.780 --> 01:00:29.791
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So that's really high.

603
01:00:30.628 --> 01:00:42.304
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And so there's a lot of vacant units in those buildings, and we're trying to figure out how to stabilize and create some sense of security for folks because We're hearing folks anecdotally are saying, I won't move in there, or folks who are living there are saying, we don't feel safe.

604
01:00:42.367 --> 01:00:48.755
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I think there's a couple different aspects that we're working on to try to make sure that we stabilize current buildings and then also move folks in.

605
01:00:49.655 --> 01:00:50.088
<v Commissioner Singleton>Thank you.

606
01:00:50.313 --> 01:00:52.960
<v Commissioner Singleton>And I definitely will get into the weeds with you, so I'll follow up.

607
01:00:54.068 --> 01:00:57.503
<v Commissioner Singleton>I would just say at some point we need to bring this to a case staffing level.

608
01:00:57.775 --> 01:01:02.686
<v Commissioner Singleton>I know there are plenty of caseworkers who have a handful of people that they are looking for apartments for.

609
01:01:03.376 --> 01:01:08.822
<v Commissioner Singleton>So to have high-level conversations about vacancies and not connect it to the work on the ground is a disservice.

610
01:01:08.887 --> 01:01:10.617
<v Commissioner Singleton>So we should try to figure that piece out.

611
01:01:12.097 --> 01:01:23.018
<v Commissioner Singleton>My last question, at least for now, although I might have taken more than 5 minutes, are how many 0 to 30% units are in the development pipeline for the Housing Bureau right now?

612
01:01:24.179 --> 01:01:25.253
<v Josh Roper>Sorry, I'd have to get back to you.

613
01:01:25.596 --> 01:01:26.702
<v Commissioner Singleton>Okay, no worries.

614
01:01:27.061 --> 01:01:34.777
<v Commissioner Singleton>And part of what I want to start getting yeah.

615
01:01:35.114 --> 01:01:51.547
<v Commissioner Singleton>And generally, when I've looked at the pipeline, it is maybe a couple of units in each building that are at 0 to 30, but the majority being in that 30 to 60, 60 to 80% income level, which is, you know, these are teachers, these are workforce that most of this is built for.

616
01:01:51.869 --> 01:01:56.420
<v Commissioner Singleton>So we're not really addressing the need for folks exiting homelessness.

617
01:01:56.836 --> 01:02:04.088
<v Commissioner Singleton>And that outflow trajectory will never look different if we don't figure out the actual way for those folks to afford housing in the long run.

618
01:02:04.681 --> 01:02:09.847
<v Commissioner Singleton>At a minimum, people who are stuck on fixed income will continue to be at 0 to 30.

619
01:02:09.913 --> 01:02:12.847
<v Commissioner Singleton>So we've got to figure out how to, how to get more development at that end.

620
01:02:13.282 --> 01:02:13.682
<v Commissioner Singleton>Thank you.

621
01:02:14.485 --> 01:02:15.414
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Commissioner Singleton.

622
01:02:15.688 --> 01:02:17.981
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have Novick, Kanal.

623
01:02:18.559 --> 01:02:19.635
<v Jamie Dunphy>Did Jones-Dixon leave?

624
01:02:20.003 --> 01:02:20.565
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Oh, he had to leave.

625
01:02:20.829 --> 01:02:22.710
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>He had to leave about 15 minutes ago.

626
01:02:22.710 --> 01:02:24.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh shoot, well, I should have called him sooner.

627
01:02:24.630 --> 01:02:26.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, we're gonna go Novick, Kanal, Smith.

628
01:02:27.150 --> 01:02:28.150
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

629
01:02:28.769 --> 01:02:30.949
<v Steve Novick>Um, on out— I have 3 questions.

630
01:02:30.969 --> 01:02:31.929
<v Steve Novick>One on outflow.

631
01:02:31.949 --> 01:02:39.840
<v Steve Novick>I think Ryan said that, um, of the 1,300 per month of outflow, about 400 move into permanent housing and the rest become inactive.

632
01:02:40.309 --> 01:02:42.969
<v Steve Novick>Um, okay, I'm a little confused by that.

633
01:02:42.969 --> 01:02:45.949
<v Steve Novick>It seems like to me outflow would be moving into permanent housing.

634
01:02:46.070 --> 01:02:47.469
<v Steve Novick>What does become inactive mean?

635
01:02:47.469 --> 01:02:50.690
<v Steve Novick>Does it mean that they're still homeless but we don't know, but they aren't accessing services?

636
01:02:50.972 --> 01:02:52.817
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>You wanna take that?

637
01:02:53.137 --> 01:03:05.458
<v Ryan Deibert>Yeah, it means that at some point they've accessed services, they've ended their access to services, and then don't initiate additional services for at least 90 days.

638
01:03:06.052 --> 01:03:09.197
<v Ryan Deibert>At that point, they're considered inactive and they move off of the list.

639
01:03:09.822 --> 01:03:16.128
<v Ryan Deibert>There is a chunk of inflow that's accounted for by people coming out of, back out of inactivity.

640
01:03:16.449 --> 01:03:23.880
<v Ryan Deibert>So they were inactive for at least 90 days, then they access services again, they come back in on inflow, and we track that separately.

641
01:03:24.907 --> 01:03:27.780
<v Ryan Deibert>But that's what it's meant to capture.

642
01:03:27.860 --> 01:03:33.108
<v Steve Novick>Okay, so is your best guess that most of them don't actually exit homelessness, they just stop accessing services?

643
01:03:34.599 --> 01:03:52.943
<v Ryan Deibert>Yeah, if you look, just if you just compare, and I can look it up, the actual numbers, but if you compare the number who leave to inactivity in any given compared to the number who come back from inactivity, the folks who return from inactivity are quite a bit lower than the number of folks who leave to inactivity.

644
01:03:53.056 --> 01:03:53.152
<v Steve Novick>Huh.

645
01:03:53.391 --> 01:03:58.086
<v Ryan Deibert>So it's pretty reasonable to assume that they are moving out of that, moving out of homelessness entirely.

646
01:03:58.166 --> 01:03:58.407
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

647
01:03:58.744 --> 01:04:01.114
<v Steve Novick>We just don't know that they moved into permanent housing, but they might have.

648
01:04:01.226 --> 01:04:01.498
<v Keith Wilson>Correct.

649
01:04:01.931 --> 01:04:02.748
<v Steve Novick>Okay.

650
01:04:03.550 --> 01:04:04.190
<v Steve Novick>Next question.

651
01:04:04.255 --> 01:04:14.842
<v Steve Novick>I think this feeds a bit into Councilor Green's comment about scalability and the the chair's comment about the city role being housing.

652
01:04:15.990 --> 01:04:29.150
<v Steve Novick>When you say that we can expect to place one person in housing for every $13,000 we spend, to what extent is that dependent on the overall supply of housing growing?

653
01:04:29.813 --> 01:04:38.307
<v Steve Novick>Could we do that forever with the current supply of housing, or at some point would we run into the fact that we just don't have enough housing, so $13,000 won't buy you a new place?

654
01:04:38.505 --> 01:04:41.909
<v Jillian Schoney>Josh, do you want to—.

655
01:04:42.360 --> 01:04:59.925
<v Josh Roper>I mean, I mean, I'd have to look at the numbers to answer that specifically, but at some point, yes, we're going to run out of supply, or we're going to get to a point where vacancy is low enough that there is just a constrained market that really won't accommodate the kind of throughput that we need to lower the numbers.

656
01:05:00.985 --> 01:05:01.387
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

657
01:05:01.965 --> 01:05:06.349
<v Steve Novick>And finally, can you give me a sense of what that $13,000 per person pays for?

658
01:05:09.143 --> 01:05:09.753
<v Steve Novick>What is it usually?

659
01:05:09.849 --> 01:05:13.449
<v Jillian Schoney>Anna Plum's going to come up, interim director of the Homelessness Services Department.

660
01:05:13.882 --> 01:05:15.699
<v Jillian Schoney>I meant to invite her up earlier, my apologies.

661
01:05:17.550 --> 01:05:18.016
<v Anna Plum>Good afternoon, everyone.

662
01:05:18.146 --> 01:05:19.389
<v Anna Plum>For the record, my name is Anna Plum.

663
01:05:19.599 --> 01:05:21.824
<v Anna Plum>I'm the interim director for Multnomah County Homeless Services.

664
01:05:22.503 --> 01:05:31.753
<v Anna Plum>So the $13,000 a household is what we estimate for our rapid rehousing program, which is up to 2 years of a combination of rent assistance and case management.

665
01:05:32.269 --> 01:05:33.807
<v Anna Plum>So that $13,000 is exactly I'll say that.

666
01:05:33.856 --> 01:05:40.476
<v Anna Plum>Some of it is rent assistance and some of it is funding to pay for FTE to support folks as they're navigating through housing case management.

667
01:05:40.925 --> 01:05:43.570
<v Anna Plum>I want to be clear, $13,000 is a pretty low estimate.

668
01:05:44.211 --> 01:05:49.324
<v Anna Plum>It's what we use for budgeting because we are able to, across the span of folks' need, kind of land on that as an average.

669
01:05:49.661 --> 01:05:52.130
<v Anna Plum>But we have consistently heard that higher amounts would be better.

670
01:05:52.788 --> 01:05:58.365
<v Anna Plum>And I do also want to flag that all of those estimates are built upon assuming that person only needs that shorter-term investment.

671
01:05:58.719 --> 01:06:15.280
<v Anna Plum>We do know there's a— Jillian kind of alluded to this earlier, or maybe it was Ryan, one of the smart people— that we also have a lot of folks who could— who need a higher thank you.

672
01:06:15.280 --> 01:06:16.889
<v Steve Novick>I was going to ask about that last point.

673
01:06:17.059 --> 01:06:26.119
<v Steve Novick>I mean, do we have statistics on how many people who got $13,000 worth of assistance for 2 years are fine afterwards and don't need any more assistance?

674
01:06:26.199 --> 01:06:28.409
<v Anna Plum>Yes, we report on that monthly on our dashboard.

675
01:06:28.960 --> 01:06:32.159
<v Anna Plum>And so, and the key point that you noted is we look at retention and we look at retention rates.

676
01:06:32.878 --> 01:06:39.648
<v Anna Plum>And at 24 months, it's in the high 80s of folks who are maintaining that housing 2 years after the subsidy has ended.

677
01:06:40.436 --> 01:06:41.382
<v Steve Novick>2 Years after it ended?

678
01:06:41.623 --> 01:06:41.719
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

679
01:06:42.119 --> 01:06:42.601
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

680
01:06:43.483 --> 01:06:44.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

681
01:06:44.751 --> 01:06:51.891
<v Ryan Deibert>I'm sorry, to your earlier question, I was able to look at the actual numbers because they're available on the Homeless Services Department dashboard.

682
01:06:52.373 --> 01:06:59.818
<v Ryan Deibert>You can think it varies month to month, but you can think of it's about 900-ish folks that are leaving homelessness to inactivity or to employment.

683
01:07:00.400 --> 01:07:03.862
<v Ryan Deibert>And about 200-ish that are returning from inactivity.

684
01:07:03.992 --> 01:07:10.385
<v Steve Novick>So again, so that gap is of people who are not returning is significant.

685
01:07:10.449 --> 01:07:11.018
<v Steve Novick>Thanks.

686
01:07:12.072 --> 01:07:12.867
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

687
01:07:13.030 --> 01:07:15.219
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, then Smith, then Moyer.

688
01:07:16.840 --> 01:07:17.711
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

689
01:07:17.760 --> 01:07:18.536
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to presenters.

690
01:07:18.666 --> 01:07:20.572
<v Sameer Kanal>Always good to have our colleagues from across the river.

691
01:07:20.815 --> 01:07:23.483
<v Sameer Kanal>I have 2 questions and a comment, so please be brief if you can.

692
01:07:23.644 --> 01:07:26.538
<v Sameer Kanal>Josh, you had a section on what the RSO office does.

693
01:07:26.994 --> 01:07:29.793
<v Sameer Kanal>That says that it creates policy recommendations.

694
01:07:30.295 --> 01:07:36.552
<v Sameer Kanal>Have I missed it, or has the Rental Services Office made any pro-renter policy recommendations to council since 2025?

695
01:07:36.858 --> 01:07:38.742
<v Sameer Kanal>And is there anything in the works right now on this?

696
01:07:40.240 --> 01:07:45.570
<v Josh Roper>I think one of the more exciting pieces connected to this is the evaluation work that's getting started.

697
01:07:45.617 --> 01:07:59.972
<v Josh Roper>So that's going to be an opportunity to look with consultant support, but at landlord-tenant policy sort of globally within Portland, including our existing programs, our existing laws, Fair mandatory relocation, other policies.

698
01:08:01.190 --> 01:08:10.835
<v Josh Roper>And out of that, we're going to have sort of a community-involved process, and I suspect some recommendations will come forth from that.

699
01:08:11.317 --> 01:08:13.996
<v Josh Roper>Also, the social housing work— we have a technical assistance panel.

700
01:08:14.510 --> 01:08:18.587
<v Josh Roper>There's a work group that's focused on tenant protections and stability.

701
01:08:19.117 --> 01:08:28.648
<v Josh Roper>So we've convened that group, and they are focused on developing a set of recommendations that will ultimately make its way to council under the sort of social housing umbrella.

702
01:08:29.673 --> 01:08:37.103
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd like to hear that, and I'd like to make sure that that's centering renters in this conversation when you convene those workgroups.

703
01:08:37.230 --> 01:08:37.488
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

704
01:08:38.113 --> 01:08:41.065
<v Sameer Kanal>Sky, there's a slide that talks about closing a safe rest village.

705
01:08:41.868 --> 01:08:44.322
<v Sameer Kanal>I think there was some missing context there.

706
01:08:44.771 --> 01:08:48.077
<v Sameer Kanal>The slide referred to the village in District 2 as Widler Village.

707
01:08:48.350 --> 01:08:50.192
<v Sameer Kanal>What's the other name for that village?

708
01:08:50.929 --> 01:08:53.043
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>It's the BIPOC Affinity Village.

709
01:08:53.091 --> 01:08:58.685
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We changed it because of the federal requirements, kind of in consultation with the City Attorney's Office.

710
01:08:59.100 --> 01:09:12.737
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so I think we're seeing a step back from equity here that I want to call out explicitly in terms of that name change without any real knowledge in terms of the executive order.

711
01:09:13.842 --> 01:09:22.354
<v Sameer Kanal>The mayor also has come out against doing the bare minimum to try to determine if ICE impersonators are harassing immigrants, refugees, asylum seekers, and other communities of color.

712
01:09:22.515 --> 01:09:24.229
<v Sameer Kanal>That was earlier today while we've been in here.

713
01:09:24.838 --> 01:09:33.479
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I wanna just get, keeping it on the housing piece, but noting that there is a broader context, it's really disconcerting to see that step back.

714
01:09:33.976 --> 01:09:43.354
<v Sameer Kanal>And I wanna know how we're going to ensure that we're doing anything to support beyond, you know, after we're closing this off.

715
01:09:43.578 --> 01:09:48.020
<v Sameer Kanal>And that's a rhetorical question, so I'll stop here and reserve my other 2 and a half minutes, but thank you.

716
01:09:48.310 --> 01:09:56.207
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I, uh, Councilor, I will just say quickly, um, we are making efforts, um, right now to work with every single member, um, who participant in that village.

717
01:09:56.735 --> 01:10:04.471
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Um, a lot of those folks are Spanish-speaking immigrants, so we are working with them, um, to make sure we have Spanish, um, language services wherever they're placed.

718
01:10:05.002 --> 01:10:06.559
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Um, but we'll continue to work with each participant.

719
01:10:06.606 --> 01:10:07.666
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Happy to talk to you more about it.

720
01:10:08.949 --> 01:10:09.832
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

721
01:10:10.475 --> 01:10:12.448
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith, then Moyer, then Brim Edwards.

722
01:10:13.829 --> 01:10:14.777
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mr. President.

723
01:10:15.354 --> 01:10:17.216
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for, uh, the presentation.

724
01:10:17.279 --> 01:10:18.099
<v Loretta Smith>I appreciate it.

725
01:10:18.404 --> 01:10:21.789
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I appreciate the presentation, Jillian and, and Sky.

726
01:10:21.966 --> 01:10:25.417
<v Loretta Smith>Miss, um, Brockman-Knapp, her new name.

727
01:10:26.588 --> 01:10:32.944
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, question, uh, there's been a lot of talk about the, uh, overnight shelter in Northwest Portland.

728
01:10:33.426 --> 01:10:35.529
<v Loretta Smith>It's a 200-bed, uh, shelter.

729
01:10:36.074 --> 01:10:38.128
<v Loretta Smith>How much does that cost to operate a year?

730
01:10:38.962 --> 01:10:39.652
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yeah, great question.

731
01:10:39.939 --> 01:10:44.154
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think it's around $2.1 million if I remember correctly, but don't hold me to that.

732
01:10:44.810 --> 01:10:50.306
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>It's about an $18,000 a month lease, so it is one of our most expensive kind of overnight shelter leases.

733
01:10:51.140 --> 01:10:58.382
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And our average kind of participant level has hovered around 130 people maximum, kind of 115 to 130 people.

734
01:10:58.430 --> 01:11:01.715
<v Loretta Smith>And so we're closing that shelter, correct?

735
01:11:02.195 --> 01:11:07.412
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yes, so we're in current negotiations with the landlord, so I don't want to— I mean, Yes, we anticipate closing.

736
01:11:07.529 --> 01:11:09.012
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I just don't know exactly when it's going to be.

737
01:11:10.667 --> 01:11:14.444
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm trying to separate the operator, which is Salvation Army.

738
01:11:14.765 --> 01:11:15.007
<v Candace Avalos>Correct.

739
01:11:15.056 --> 01:11:17.896
<v Loretta Smith>And so it costs them $2.1 million to run.

740
01:11:18.671 --> 01:11:21.128
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>$2.1 Is the entire cost, I believe.

741
01:11:21.193 --> 01:11:28.020
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So the lease would be a part of that and kind of any food service that they offer and bedding and materials, that kind of thing.

742
01:11:28.150 --> 01:11:35.203
<v Loretta Smith>So I imagine we had to have a private sector lease on the, the North Fruit.

743
01:11:35.300 --> 01:11:38.382
<v Loretta Smith>That's, that's separate from the operating costs.

744
01:11:38.896 --> 01:11:41.289
<v Loretta Smith>And I imagine we had to have a long-term lease.

745
01:11:41.402 --> 01:11:43.472
<v Loretta Smith>Did we have a 5-year or 10-year lease?

746
01:11:43.970 --> 01:11:45.448
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>That lease is a little complicated.

747
01:11:45.978 --> 01:11:54.615
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I think it was maximum of 10 years and then has different points within the lease that you can get out of basically the lease at different periods of time.

748
01:11:55.354 --> 01:11:57.908
<v Loretta Smith>And it's probably going to cost us a lot of money to get out of that lease.

749
01:11:59.014 --> 01:12:00.335
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>The negotiations are ongoing.

750
01:12:00.786 --> 01:12:06.841
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think my guess is we will pay maybe a couple extra months, maybe, of the lease cost.

751
01:12:07.614 --> 01:12:07.953
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, really?

752
01:12:08.662 --> 01:12:09.597
<v Loretta Smith>Only a couple months?

753
01:12:10.033 --> 01:12:13.078
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>That's my hope, and I'm sorry to the lawyers if I'm overstepping.

754
01:12:13.779 --> 01:12:18.938
<v Loretta Smith>No, no, what I'm trying to figure out, because I know generally when you have those private sector leases, they won't let you out for 2 months.

755
01:12:19.329 --> 01:12:24.047
<v Loretta Smith>They're gonna, they're gonna make you pay a huge premium for breaking the lease.

756
01:12:24.948 --> 01:12:37.002
<v Loretta Smith>And if it is a 10-year lease, I'm concerned that we may not have the money in the budget to pay that long-term lease that they're going to request us to pay.

757
01:12:37.536 --> 01:12:39.930
<v Loretta Smith>If it was only going to be 2 months, that would have been a done deal.

758
01:12:39.996 --> 01:12:40.918
<v Loretta Smith>You wouldn't have to have lawyers.

759
01:12:41.412 --> 01:12:44.444
<v Loretta Smith>But we're not going to get out of that unscathed.

760
01:12:45.122 --> 01:12:48.349
<v Loretta Smith>And I just want to know what that amount is and where it's coming from.

761
01:12:48.574 --> 01:12:49.913
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yeah, absolutely, Councilor.

762
01:12:49.979 --> 01:12:54.052
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I will say all of our leases by law have to have a non-appropriations clause.

763
01:12:54.260 --> 01:13:00.908
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So if you folks don't appropriate money, kind of, that will go toward that, we are able to get out of that lease.

764
01:13:02.337 --> 01:13:08.393
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So there is a penalty clause in that lease, and that would be the extra couple months that we're negotiating over.

765
01:13:08.440 --> 01:13:14.175
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So happy to get into the details with you, maybe with the attorneys though, 'cause I don't know what I'm kind of allowed to say while they're in active negotiations.

766
01:13:14.351 --> 01:13:17.145
<v Loretta Smith>I don't have to go into the attorneys with this.

767
01:13:17.242 --> 01:13:23.265
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just thinking, as when I was reading the stories, I was like, this is gonna cost us a lot of money to get out of this lease.

768
01:13:24.162 --> 01:13:27.529
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think I'm actually— it's looking good.

769
01:13:27.770 --> 01:13:28.636
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Okay, okay.

770
01:13:28.811 --> 01:13:33.942
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I can, I can keep you updated, but I've actually been really appreciative of the negotiations.

771
01:13:34.341 --> 01:13:37.467
<v Loretta Smith>So we have 8 overnight shelters, correct?

772
01:13:38.654 --> 01:13:38.878
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yes.

773
01:13:39.856 --> 01:13:42.292
<v Loretta Smith>And how many are we closing in this new budget?

774
01:13:42.918 --> 01:13:47.984
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So right now, we actually this fiscal year have closed the Centennial overnight shelter.

775
01:13:48.913 --> 01:13:55.576
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Everything else so Northrop was kind of one of our first decision points because of the cost.

776
01:13:55.993 --> 01:13:57.872
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Everything else we're looking at right now.

777
01:13:58.225 --> 01:14:06.863
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I'll probably have a proposal for you for the budget work session that we're going to do on the 12th, but my shelter services team is kind of running every single potential option.

778
01:14:06.912 --> 01:14:15.164
<v Loretta Smith>So the mayor did not identify that he was going to cut any— because he said shelter services were going to be cut 30%, and I'm trying to figure out what does that look like?

779
01:14:15.646 --> 01:14:16.529
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yeah, so we are too.

780
01:14:17.188 --> 01:14:34.786
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So based on kind of the money— based on the money that we have now within the budget, so a 30% cut, we're looking at a variety of different scenarios that include consolidation or closure or flex capacity only during the winter season, for example, and what all those hydraulics might be.

781
01:14:34.867 --> 01:14:40.519
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I'll be able to present maybe some of those scenarios for you and maybe what we recommend from an operational standpoint.

782
01:14:40.567 --> 01:14:40.694
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Thank you.

783
01:14:40.887 --> 01:14:44.243
<v Loretta Smith>So I'm, I'm, I haven't read the entire budget.

784
01:14:44.564 --> 01:14:54.086
<v Loretta Smith>We got that late last week, but I'm trying to figure out the— did the mayor not give you direction on what he wanted in terms of overnight shelters?

785
01:14:54.904 --> 01:15:01.953
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>He has told us this is the budget that we're to work with and to make some scenarios and some proposals based on that amount of money.

786
01:15:02.291 --> 01:15:04.202
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So that's what we're going through right now, is that process.

787
01:15:04.475 --> 01:15:05.132
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay.

788
01:15:05.439 --> 01:15:06.208
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Of kind of some options.

789
01:15:06.787 --> 01:15:15.088
<v Loretta Smith>And, but we do know that we're gonna eliminate Centennial, which is in my district, and the, the Northrop shelter.

790
01:15:15.457 --> 01:15:22.506
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yes, and Centennial, we're talking to them about potentially flexing up and using them in the wintertime, but that's an ongoing discussion.

791
01:15:23.020 --> 01:15:23.806
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, perfect.

792
01:15:23.887 --> 01:15:24.546
<v Loretta Smith>Yep, thank you.

793
01:15:24.626 --> 01:15:25.252
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yes, absolutely.

794
01:15:26.135 --> 01:15:26.921
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

795
01:15:27.372 --> 01:15:29.811
<v Jamie Dunphy>Commissioner Moyer, then Brem Edwards, then Koyama Lane.

796
01:15:32.734 --> 01:15:44.391
<v Meghan Moyer>I do think a lot about what the city is funding and what the county is funding and how we better, um, create a coherent system for people.

797
01:15:44.439 --> 01:15:52.372
<v Meghan Moyer>I don't want individuals to get caught up in different systems, which is, is hard.

798
01:15:52.645 --> 01:15:53.335
<v Meghan Moyer>I mean, it just is.

799
01:15:53.784 --> 01:16:08.029
<v Meghan Moyer>So some of the questions I have is around you know, I think we're both funding various forms of outreach, and I'm really unclear, do we need that much overlapping outreach?

800
01:16:08.430 --> 01:16:11.974
<v Meghan Moyer>What are city outreach versus county-funded outreach?

801
01:16:12.615 --> 01:16:16.463
<v Meghan Moyer>I feel similarly around case management.

802
01:16:17.329 --> 01:16:20.393
<v Meghan Moyer>I have feelings about case management.

803
01:16:20.617 --> 01:16:25.028
<v Meghan Moyer>I don't think it's appropriate for a provider to then also be case manager.

804
01:16:25.123 --> 01:16:43.548
<v Meghan Moyer>That's a conflict of interest, um, if it's true case management, which would be having the ability to access resources, uh, and, and help find an appropriate next step in somebody's, uh, journey to— in their recovery.

805
01:16:44.207 --> 01:17:14.431
<v Meghan Moyer>Um, but I, I'm wondering, to what degree are our 2 systems talking about what— who's doing what type of outreach, what are the resources that they can or can't connect people to, and how do we make sure if I'm going to go to an overnight shelter, how am I still on a path to hopefully housing placement or, or other supports that help me in my homelessness?

806
01:17:15.322 --> 01:17:15.725
<v Jillian Schoney>Well, sorry.

807
01:17:16.509 --> 01:17:18.261
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Okay, sure.

808
01:17:18.438 --> 01:17:20.172
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I'll start and then I'll pass it to Anna.

809
01:17:20.350 --> 01:17:21.893
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>But Commissioner, there's a lot there.

810
01:17:21.957 --> 01:17:24.945
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I think outreach, I'll just start with.

811
01:17:24.993 --> 01:17:34.876
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So the city outreach, and in this proposed budget, it's really just those 9 people that are FTEs on my team, and they really perform that coordination work within the city.

812
01:17:35.246 --> 01:17:43.657
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So they're working with the park rangers and the police, and they're working with our public space management folks, and they're able to kind of look at the whole city.

813
01:17:43.930 --> 01:17:52.198
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>They get all the reports that come in for requests and outreach worker, but also all the campsite reports, and they're able to try to offer folks services kind of at that juncture.

814
01:17:52.279 --> 01:17:59.537
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So it's a slightly different function, I would say, than what the county outreach workers are doing that are contracted, and Anna can speak to that.

815
01:18:00.146 --> 01:18:05.814
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>But I will say from a coordination aspect, though, we work with all the county contracted outreach workers.

816
01:18:06.425 --> 01:18:07.951
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So we have coordination calls.

817
01:18:07.998 --> 01:18:12.880
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We talk, I mean, almost daily probably, and are coordinating different resources.

818
01:18:12.992 --> 01:18:15.689
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>There are different services offered by different outreach teams.

819
01:18:15.801 --> 01:18:25.323
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I think people say outreach is kind of this catch-all, kind of like case management, and you're really seeing a different service connection, a different service delivery with those different people.

820
01:18:25.372 --> 01:18:42.675
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So quickly to case management, we're working with Jillian's team right now on a case management kind of inventory So city, county, others to really standardize, because I think you're totally right, is what we're seeing is case management means a very different thing to every single person.

821
01:18:43.515 --> 01:18:46.588
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And so trying to standardize that across the system, that's going to take some work.

822
01:18:47.246 --> 01:18:48.972
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Outreach, I think we are a little further along.

823
01:18:49.037 --> 01:18:56.523
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>We've done some more inventory, we've actually consolidated some, and we've been able to coordinate better than we have in previous years.

824
01:18:56.725 --> 01:18:57.079
<v Loretta Smith>Yep.

825
01:18:58.192 --> 01:18:58.865
<v Anna Plum>Agree with all of that.

826
01:18:59.220 --> 01:19:08.998
<v Anna Plum>I would just add that in addition to the case management inventory, the county is also working on an outreach manual which will codify what we mean when we say outreach and what are the nuances therein and what are the goals therein.

827
01:19:09.046 --> 01:19:11.474
<v Anna Plum>And that's— we've collaborated with the city on that as well.

828
01:19:12.671 --> 01:19:19.323
<v Anna Plum>And I think it's one of the places where we've been able to say we are doing these services that are slightly different, different as we constrain resources.

829
01:19:19.371 --> 01:19:23.555
<v Anna Plum>How do we really focus in on what the different types of outreach need to be and how can we coordinate?

830
01:19:24.000 --> 01:19:26.896
<v Anna Plum>And Sky and I talk every Friday at 8 AM with all of our outreach workers.

831
01:19:29.521 --> 01:19:29.587
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

832
01:19:29.747 --> 01:19:41.055
<v Meghan Moyer>Um, within the, uh, unhoused and sheltered population, um, we got some information.

833
01:19:41.184 --> 01:19:54.954
<v Meghan Moyer>I, I think everyone's aware of it, where Health Share was able to lay their utilization data and, and health record data on top of our by-names list.

834
01:19:55.039 --> 01:19:55.248
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

835
01:19:56.021 --> 01:20:05.319
<v Meghan Moyer>And it was very, very clear that our shelters have a— people who, they may not be there overnight, but had been in shelter.

836
01:20:05.384 --> 01:20:08.993
<v Meghan Moyer>I think it was a couple-month time period they overlapped.

837
01:20:10.747 --> 01:20:22.673
<v Meghan Moyer>Um, over 50%, or about 50% of people, uh, who have accessed shelters within that 2-month period had a pre-existing diagnosis of a severe and persistent mental illness.

838
01:20:24.140 --> 01:20:30.742
<v Meghan Moyer>A significant portion also had a co-occurring substance use disorder.

839
01:20:30.822 --> 01:20:46.979
<v Meghan Moyer>I'm not sure if I remember the data on people who were just experiencing— self-identified as experiencing substance use disorder, but there is clearly a very significant connection with people who are experiencing homelessness and behavioral health.

840
01:20:47.106 --> 01:20:52.127
<v Meghan Moyer>That's certainly an area that the county We talk about all the time.

841
01:20:52.698 --> 01:21:07.194
<v Meghan Moyer>But I am interested because that population also tends to be unhoused longer, tends to live unsheltered more.

842
01:21:08.063 --> 01:21:14.425
<v Meghan Moyer>What is the overnight-only shelter approach to behavioral health need?

843
01:21:14.715 --> 01:21:28.345
<v Meghan Moyer>And and how are we thinking about those intersections when people, um, are not receiving services?

844
01:21:28.442 --> 01:21:35.350
<v Meghan Moyer>I think, you know, both systems— we see it in our jail, so I am assuming the police are seeing this.

845
01:21:35.447 --> 01:21:35.576
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Right.

846
01:21:35.832 --> 01:21:48.550
<v Meghan Moyer>And, and how are we coordinating and talking about yeah, great.

847
01:21:48.550 --> 01:21:49.250
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Also great question.

848
01:21:49.289 --> 01:21:53.539
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Happy to go kind of in the weeds with you separately, but I'll just say a couple things quickly.

849
01:21:54.569 --> 01:22:04.510
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So right now I'm really excited about a potential partnership at one of our overnight shelter sites that we've seen a significant aging population and disabled population.

850
01:22:04.510 --> 01:22:06.270
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So not necessarily the SPMI population, but a population significant aging population and disabled population.

851
01:22:06.493 --> 01:22:13.980
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>That you mentioned, but we're partnering with the Behavioral Health Department and Aging and Disability and really looking at what we can do to connect folks to those resources.

852
01:22:14.045 --> 01:22:17.579
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So just shout out to County Behavioral Health, thank you.

853
01:22:18.529 --> 01:22:25.502
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And we're also talking to our day center locations and our outreach workers to connect folks to different resources.

854
01:22:25.567 --> 01:22:30.885
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So my outreach workers, for example, are around every kind of shelter site in the morning.

855
01:22:31.319 --> 01:22:36.666
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>They're looking folks that are exiting the overnight shelters in the morning and connecting them to resources when possible.

856
01:22:36.713 --> 01:22:45.095
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So trying to make sure we have that connection point at that physical location, but also at those day center locations to be that connection to services.

857
01:22:45.512 --> 01:22:54.890
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And I would say we, whenever possible, are trying to connect folks to the alternative shelter or to behavioral health and kind of mental health services.

858
01:22:55.579 --> 01:22:57.555
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Overnight shelter is not going to help with that.

859
01:22:58.069 --> 01:23:04.532
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>It's really there just as that last resort of I need someplace safe and warm to sleep tonight.

860
01:23:05.252 --> 01:23:10.801
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So we're really trying to make an effort to make sure that we're connecting folks to those relevant resources when it makes sense.

861
01:23:11.042 --> 01:23:13.978
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think you mentioned it's a huge part of the population.

862
01:23:14.490 --> 01:23:22.637
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And so I think what that amazing data showed is that we have a really sick population and it's not super easy to make sure that we resolve that.

863
01:23:22.685 --> 01:23:23.279
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think that's a great point.

864
01:23:23.777 --> 01:23:32.167
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think we need a lot more, frankly, from the state level to be able to help a lot of the folks who are really, really sick.

865
01:23:32.439 --> 01:23:34.462
<v Commissioner Singleton>I don't know.

866
01:23:34.557 --> 01:23:34.943
<v Candace Avalos>Sorry.

867
01:23:35.344 --> 01:23:47.632
<v Anna Plum>I would just add one little thought, which is I think that's one of the reasons we talk so much about making sure folks get to the right shelter, that we have that different type of shelter access so that we can have shelters that are more resourced for folks who have that higher need.

868
01:23:47.697 --> 01:24:00.069
<v Anna Plum>But it's also more importantly when you look at our budget priorities, why we focused on not making cuts to permanent supportive housing, because that is the resource that will end homelessness for a lot of the folks who have that high acuity behavioral health need.

869
01:24:00.677 --> 01:24:02.216
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>They need it to be true PSH.

870
01:24:02.279 --> 01:24:05.613
<v Anna Plum>They need a higher degree of services than we have in our community at this time.

871
01:24:06.046 --> 01:24:13.015
<v Anna Plum>But it's one of the reasons that Multnomah County really emphasized keeping that supportive housing as like the key part of our budget and making sure we didn't make reductions there.

872
01:24:13.896 --> 01:24:17.037
<v Jillian Schoney>And I just want to layer on here as an example where there yes.

873
01:24:17.101 --> 01:24:20.877
<v Jillian Schoney>The staff-level work is every day.

874
01:24:20.975 --> 01:24:34.118
<v Jillian Schoney>So another example with the overnight-onlys that city staff noticed, you know, there are folks being taken to overnight-onlys in the middle of the night, those discharges from our emergency departments.

875
01:24:34.681 --> 01:24:38.377
<v Jillian Schoney>Those people only get a few hours of sleep and then they want to go back to the ED.

876
01:24:38.650 --> 01:24:49.884
<v Jillian Schoney>So we are working on a new partnership to figure out how to keep those individuals from going back to the ED and instead getting them into a 24/7 shelter.

877
01:24:50.658 --> 01:24:58.119
<v Jillian Schoney>There isn't a ton of capacity there, but at a staff level, that day-to-day coordination is happening in a variety of ways.

878
01:25:00.252 --> 01:25:00.591
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

879
01:25:00.654 --> 01:25:01.186
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Thank you.

880
01:25:01.283 --> 01:25:02.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Commissioner Moyer.

881
01:25:02.427 --> 01:25:05.296
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have Commissioner Brem Edwards, then Koyama Lane, then Zimmerman.

882
01:25:10.099 --> 01:25:11.458
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Thank you.

883
01:25:12.770 --> 01:25:16.154
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, so just have a couple comments and then some questions.

884
01:25:16.755 --> 01:25:27.949
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So since my first day in the commission, when I came to these chambers, uh, different, uh, lineup at the, at the time, um, I was going to look at you, but I guess you weren't there at that time, but, uh, you were there before.

885
01:25:28.337 --> 01:25:43.136
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, at the time I said that the city and Multnomah County needed to work together on our biggest challenges, including achieving a net reduction in homelessness and and unsheltered homelessness and moving people into housing, that we essentially needed to end the finger-pointing and work together.

886
01:25:44.628 --> 01:25:57.046
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I want to just say I have appreciated the opportunity for all of us to sit in the same chambers and talk about places where we're doing duplicative work or places where there's gaps and how do we fill those.

887
01:25:57.703 --> 01:26:05.658
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I also like seeing the affordable multifamily housing development fund to preserve and finance the development of housing that was in the city's presentation.

888
01:26:08.817 --> 01:26:23.891
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Also, I would say one of the first things that I also have said is that the county, even if we have a very effective, efficient system of services and case management, that we have to have places for people to go.

889
01:26:24.229 --> 01:26:26.369
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>This is back to the chair's comment on housing.

890
01:26:27.382 --> 01:26:35.962
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I really appreciate I appreciate that there has been, from the council and the mayor, really a focus on that piece of the city's work.

891
01:26:36.463 --> 01:26:45.970
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Because again, when the county is sort of operating in a highly efficient way, hopefully there'll be a place for people to go to.

892
01:26:46.697 --> 01:26:54.256
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I also will say that I appreciate that there's a weekly strike team that's working to get after the vacant units and the barriers to filling them.

893
01:26:54.323 --> 01:26:54.391
<v Jillian Schoney>Yes.

894
01:26:56.264 --> 01:27:12.801
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I've been a participant in some of those meetings, and I'm glad to see that happening because I think from the public trust standpoint, when people see vacant units and also an increasing number of homeless people that don't have a path to housing, that they expect us to get after that.

895
01:27:13.474 --> 01:27:19.868
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I also appreciate the leveraging of the one-time Medicaid eviction money to leverage additional dollars.

896
01:27:20.125 --> 01:27:43.779
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I love seeing so my questions are, I think what I heard the conclusion of, even with the— if you take the 2 budgets and then the expected Medicaid dollars, which are one-time, there's still a net increase in overall homelessness with the current 2 budgets.

897
01:27:44.550 --> 01:27:44.840
<v Ryan Deibert>Correct.

898
01:27:45.739 --> 01:27:46.849
<v Ryan Deibert>That's what we would estimate.

899
01:27:48.591 --> 01:27:49.335
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Okay, so that's one thing.

900
01:27:49.463 --> 01:27:57.484
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Then KPI number 8, that's the key performance indicator relating to unsheltered homelessness, is that right?

901
01:27:59.250 --> 01:28:00.587
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

902
01:28:00.684 --> 01:28:08.547
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So in the presentation today, what I didn't see is a trend line projected for that key performance indicator.

903
01:28:10.195 --> 01:28:38.025
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>And I hope we include it because in the county's budget, there's 700 shelter units that are going to be unfunded, and including several hundred in District 3, including one, Chestnut Tree, that was sort of held up as sort of a high-performing shelter in terms of getting people, placing them into housing.

904
01:28:39.378 --> 01:28:54.543
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So my question is, My question is, since it wasn't included as part of the presentation, key performance indicator number 8, with the 2 budgets, do we expect to see a net increase or decrease in unsheltered homelessness?

905
01:28:56.507 --> 01:29:03.350
<v Anna Plum>I can speak to the folks served in— so it's a little sneak preview for next week's budget presentation.

906
01:29:03.708 --> 01:29:06.134
<v Anna Plum>Our Homeless Services Department is doing our budget presentation next Tuesday.

907
01:29:06.229 --> 01:29:07.832
<v Anna Plum>I'll do the same shout-out that Sky did.

908
01:29:08.505 --> 01:29:18.054
<v Anna Plum>And we did try to estimate not necessarily changes in unsheltered homelessness, but how many folks we think would be served in our shelters based upon where we understand both of our budgets to be.

909
01:29:19.479 --> 01:29:35.069
<v Anna Plum>And we are looking at— for next year, given the reductions that we have proposed and our understanding of like the current status of the city-proposed reductions, it would be slightly less than who we expect to serve this year, but not like a major decrease in who is served in shelter across the whole year.

910
01:29:41.630 --> 01:29:41.886
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Okay.

911
01:29:42.064 --> 01:30:01.916
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I'm less looking at that because I think one of the things with the public when we say we've placed 500 people into housing, implying that we've reduced that number, but when actually the net number, which, you know, I spent 2 years trying to get a dashboard, which we have now, talking about the net number.

912
01:30:01.965 --> 01:30:02.488
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So that's what I'm looking at.

913
01:30:02.600 --> 01:30:12.042
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So what I'm interested in, again, is tracking the key performance indicator which was set to understand that as well.

914
01:30:12.171 --> 01:30:27.917
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Because while I think we all agree shelter is not the ultimate destination, it is for many people a safe place off the street, a place to stabilize, a place to get basic services where they have bathrooms, showers, laundry.

915
01:30:28.621 --> 01:30:29.561
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>A place to get food.

916
01:30:31.189 --> 01:30:40.033
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I would appreciate if we continue to track that as well, because we can't just track the overall number.

917
01:30:40.097 --> 01:30:41.324
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I mean, that's not what we agreed to.

918
01:30:42.065 --> 01:30:48.426
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I'd appreciate getting— and maybe I'm getting it next week, but I also think this body needs to understand it because it's our joint work.

919
01:30:49.805 --> 01:30:55.380
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>The last question I had is accountability related to Home Forward.

920
01:30:56.296 --> 01:31:03.324
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Um, the lack of action on their vacant units and executive expenditures, um, which I think is really straining public trust.

921
01:31:05.841 --> 01:31:06.925
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I don't know who wants to take that.

922
01:31:09.072 --> 01:31:26.056
<v Jillian Schoney>I mean, I'm recalling this off the top of my head, Commissioner, but, um, based on a variety of things that they've done— they've bought down some rents, they have plugged into our Housing Connector tool to market their units more, they're working with the city on some sort sort of safety, property management safety issues.

923
01:31:27.195 --> 01:31:33.774
<v Jillian Schoney>My recollection is that from February to March, they saw their vacancy drop by 2%.

924
01:31:35.009 --> 01:31:37.046
<v Jillian Schoney>So the work is happening.

925
01:31:37.238 --> 01:31:45.372
<v Jillian Schoney>They're moving in that direction, and we are all working with them in particularly the meetings that you attend on the city side of the equation to continue to help them.

926
01:31:46.463 --> 01:31:49.287
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>But it's still significantly above what it should be.

927
01:31:50.346 --> 01:31:51.542
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I mean, 11% is still—.

928
01:31:52.328 --> 01:31:52.886
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Yeah.

929
01:31:55.239 --> 01:31:55.353
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

930
01:31:55.676 --> 01:31:57.341
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>I don't know if anybody wants to speak to the accountability.

931
01:31:57.390 --> 01:32:00.868
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So is that— is that from the city's perspective?

932
01:32:00.917 --> 01:32:06.632
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Is that their account— accountability, or how's that playing?

933
01:32:07.166 --> 01:32:13.158
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I will say I will not speak for Director Bonaccor, but, um, I do know of a couple pieces that are kind of in play.

934
01:32:13.224 --> 01:32:20.024
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>And I think, um, as you're aware, The city appoints 5 members of the board, the county appoints 2, Gresham appoints 2.

935
01:32:20.088 --> 01:32:24.600
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So I think there are discussions about accountability in terms of board holding folks accountable.

936
01:32:24.649 --> 01:32:34.219
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>I think there are discussions underway right now, so I don't wanna speak ahead of them, but I think that's fair to say that there are discussions happening because I think folks are also concerned.

937
01:32:35.166 --> 01:32:36.242
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Great, thank you very much.

938
01:32:37.333 --> 01:32:37.494
<v Mitch Green>Yep.

939
01:32:38.088 --> 01:32:40.529
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Oh, I'm sorry, this is like maybe a presiding officer question.

940
01:32:42.430 --> 01:32:47.304
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I don't think we have another quarterly meeting until maybe after the budgets are done.

941
01:32:47.918 --> 01:33:07.211
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>So I'm wondering what the most efficient way, just given sort of all the interconnectedness between the 2 bodies, how we can have a sort of free flow of information between like the totality since we're now at a point where the presiding officers and the presiding officer of the County Commission and the mayor have proposed their budgets.

942
01:33:07.259 --> 01:33:07.340
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Yeah.

943
01:33:07.762 --> 01:33:18.337
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>That it's really now to all of us to sort of make decisions, and it would be helpful to know kind of what the puts and takes are happening on either side of the river.

944
01:33:18.967 --> 01:33:32.387
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, I'll say that, A, I personally welcome any future conversation with my county colleagues, and I know all my city council colleagues will as well, and we could even potentially do some smaller group things to this topic specifically.

945
01:33:33.115 --> 01:33:35.960
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm always trying to defer the work back to our committee structure.

946
01:33:36.283 --> 01:33:43.837
<v Jamie Dunphy>So we have a Housing and Permitting Committee, which I think Chair Avalos would be happy to dig into some details as well as Vice Chair Greene.

947
01:33:45.296 --> 01:33:49.305
<v Jamie Dunphy>If anybody has any good ideas of ways we can collaborate, I'm all ears.

948
01:33:50.046 --> 01:33:56.042
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we will continue to have, well, this body's gonna continue to have a series of work sessions like this.

949
01:33:56.997 --> 01:33:59.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think we have like 100 more.

950
01:34:00.818 --> 01:34:04.860
<v Jamie Dunphy>So a lot of opportunities for us to hear more about good ideas.

951
01:34:04.957 --> 01:34:08.935
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then we are aiming towards the 3rd week of May for amendments.

952
01:34:09.145 --> 01:34:16.429
<v Jamie Dunphy>So anytime between then and now, I encourage us all to look for opportunities for collaboration or even public discussion about it.

953
01:34:16.748 --> 01:34:17.167
<v Julia Brim-Edwards>Great, thank you.

954
01:34:17.470 --> 01:34:18.016
<v Jamie Dunphy>Absolutely.

955
01:34:18.996 --> 01:34:25.011
<v Jamie Dunphy>Commissioner— sorry, no, Councilor Koyama Lane, then Zimmerman, then Kanal.

956
01:34:25.509 --> 01:34:26.295
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you, Council President.

957
01:34:27.016 --> 01:34:30.082
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I would like to start by appreciating the presentation today.

958
01:34:30.885 --> 01:34:34.912
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think it was a really strong and thoughtful framing of the issue.

959
01:34:35.362 --> 01:34:35.779
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

960
01:34:36.436 --> 01:34:37.592
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I have a couple questions.

961
01:34:37.704 --> 01:34:51.506
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think the first question, or at least part of it, was raised earlier, but I'd welcome any additional details or context that can be shared, specifically around the analysis of the cost side of prevention versus response.

962
01:34:51.842 --> 01:35:02.039
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Specifically, do we have estimates on how the cost of preventing an eviction compares to the downstream cost of providing homeless services to that same household?

963
01:35:02.826 --> 01:35:18.502
<v Jillian Schoney>I do not have an exact number on the front end or the back end, but I can tell you it is much, much more expensive to rehouse an individual once they experience literal homelessness than it is to prevent it in the first spot.

964
01:35:19.064 --> 01:35:25.059
<v Jillian Schoney>But what is hard about all of that, right, is that it is hard, again, how we look at inflow versus outflow.

965
01:35:25.171 --> 01:35:27.886
<v Jillian Schoney>Outflow is one-to-one, easy to track, easy to measure.

966
01:35:27.966 --> 01:35:32.880
<v Jillian Schoney>Like, we know the person moves off of our by-name list and into an apartment, right?

967
01:35:32.944 --> 01:35:35.594
<v Jillian Schoney>That is easy to track, measure, cost out.

968
01:35:36.252 --> 01:35:41.118
<v Jillian Schoney>Again, on the eviction prevention, you can't say it's one-to-one.

969
01:35:41.310 --> 01:35:57.797
<v Jillian Schoney>I can't say for every person that DCHS or the Portland Housing Bureau provides eviction prevention services, legal or otherwise, financial assistance, rent assistance, I can't say that that person would have become homeless if not for that investment.

970
01:35:57.862 --> 01:35:59.519
<v Jillian Schoney>So that's what makes it hard.

971
01:36:01.733 --> 01:36:03.042
<v Jillian Schoney>But it is much more expensive.

972
01:36:03.106 --> 01:36:04.885
<v Jillian Schoney>We all know and agree to that.

973
01:36:05.774 --> 01:36:16.347
<v Jillian Schoney>The cost of that person in shelter, other related services, the housing placement, that is much more expensive than just that 3 to 4 months of rent assistance that we give in an eviction prevention program.

974
01:36:17.435 --> 01:36:19.318
<v Jillian Schoney>I feel like Singleton's itching to say something.

975
01:36:19.368 --> 01:36:23.324
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, Council President, I would love to Thank you.

976
01:36:24.503 --> 01:36:28.913
<v Commissioner Singleton>The rent assistance portion is about $5,000 per household in eviction prevention.

977
01:36:28.962 --> 01:36:36.880
<v Commissioner Singleton>It's not the same just because they're not doing— they're not analyzing the cost of staff, but it is a cheaper amount on rent assistance for sure.

978
01:36:38.729 --> 01:36:39.817
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Yep.

979
01:36:40.627 --> 01:36:41.050
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

980
01:36:41.586 --> 01:36:43.922
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then my other question is a clarifying question.

981
01:36:44.052 --> 01:36:51.332
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm wondering if we're able to state for the record exactly how many How many shelter beds are proposed to be cut in the mayor's budget?

982
01:36:51.796 --> 01:36:57.337
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Or can we confirm that we're not sure that— or can we confirm that that number is still unknown at this time?

983
01:36:57.738 --> 01:36:58.011
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Unknown.

984
01:36:58.139 --> 01:37:00.997
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>So that'll be part of the scenarios that we're bringing forward.

985
01:37:01.253 --> 01:37:04.994
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>There will be a certain number that are cut and there will be some consolidation.

986
01:37:05.042 --> 01:37:10.229
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>But right now we're looking at different scenarios and then we'll bring forward a couple for you in the budget work session.

987
01:37:10.646 --> 01:37:12.990
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And do we know which work session, what date?

988
01:37:13.247 --> 01:37:14.594
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>Okay, thank you.

989
01:37:16.539 --> 01:37:17.578
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

990
01:37:17.756 --> 01:37:21.131
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Zimmerman, then I'll go Zimmerman, Smith, Kanal.

991
01:37:21.485 --> 01:37:21.840
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

992
01:37:23.000 --> 01:37:27.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, oh, Kanal fell out of the— never mind, sir.

993
01:37:27.587 --> 01:37:42.524
<v Eric Zimmerman>So last year, as Mayor Wilson, as you described your, your, your shelter plan, it was the robust kind of the, the The framing of your first year of your administration.

994
01:37:43.581 --> 01:37:57.025
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, you and I had a conversation that has kind of guided how I've, how I've interpreted how your part fits into this joint effort, um, which is, which is where my support came from.

995
01:37:58.501 --> 01:38:04.445
<v Eric Zimmerman>Largely, the county has always engaged in 24-hour shelters, right?

996
01:38:04.510 --> 01:38:05.793
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we understood Thank you.

997
01:38:07.719 --> 01:38:19.006
<v Eric Zimmerman>And 2 years ago, the County Commission drove to get to the number of 1,000 county-provided shelter beds in the community.

998
01:38:20.070 --> 01:38:28.779
<v Eric Zimmerman>You took office and you put, I think, the last remaining, like, deep need of a Band-Aid, which is you went with the overnight shelters.

999
01:38:29.136 --> 01:38:47.988
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I say that because there was, in my mind, And somewhat of a recognition that, yes, 24-hour was good, but there was still so much that was not being met based on the number of people we were seeing sleep outside that you went quite tactical with the overnight.

1000
01:38:49.649 --> 01:38:57.963
<v Eric Zimmerman>That system made sense to me, given that there are challenges that come with that type of a shelter.

1001
01:39:00.246 --> 01:39:16.137
<v Eric Zimmerman>But now I'm very concerned given the cuts to the county shelters, because I think largely this body still exists— frankly, it kept the City of Portland at the table when the county got up to 1,000 shelter beds being provided.

1002
01:39:16.265 --> 01:39:20.676
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not sure that the county and the city would still have a joint agreement but for that.

1003
01:39:20.773 --> 01:39:26.650
<v Eric Zimmerman>In large part, I think that was a signal of the county is going to get into the sheltering business.

1004
01:39:26.698 --> 01:39:50.055
<v Eric Zimmerman>So given the county's withdrawal, uh, 2 budgets later by— I think we just heard 700 out of that 1,000— I guess I begin to wonder, and you've said in your, in your budget documents that the city's no longer going to send its $30 million to the county, and there's some back and forth.

1005
01:39:50.104 --> 01:39:55.198
<v Eric Zimmerman>So Do we truly have a joint agreement anymore?

1006
01:39:56.274 --> 01:40:06.067
<v Eric Zimmerman>Do we have a joint effort anymore, or is this kind of moving into performance-based versus an agreement about the types of numbers that we're going to see in terms of funded?

1007
01:40:06.163 --> 01:40:15.104
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because the city's approach to sheltering has always been kind of secondary to the county's, and I'm seeing a significant change coming there.

1008
01:40:15.394 --> 01:40:26.045
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm just kind of wondering, what is the impact of the overnight— excuse me, what is the impact of the county shelter closures on the overnight program that the city now is administering?

1009
01:40:27.930 --> 01:40:28.643
<v Eric Zimmerman>It's really to you, Mayor.

1010
01:40:33.020 --> 01:40:36.752
<v Keith Wilson>The budgets are proposed that the chair and I are bringing forward.

1011
01:40:37.479 --> 01:40:47.042
<v Keith Wilson>And to the question I think Commissioner Moyer noted was, you know, What's the change going to be, if you will?

1012
01:40:48.689 --> 01:40:49.759
<v Keith Wilson>Sir, we're gonna have to wait and see.

1013
01:40:49.855 --> 01:41:02.135
<v Keith Wilson>And you are right, the HRAP as it was written, Homeless Response Action Plan, was to— had 2 outcomes, not KPIs, not measurements, but outcomes, which is what we should be striving for.

1014
01:41:02.509 --> 01:41:03.954
<v Keith Wilson>What do we want to achieve?

1015
01:41:04.962 --> 01:41:10.588
<v Keith Wilson>One of 'em was that the county would add 1,000 new 24/7 shelter beds.

1016
01:41:11.509 --> 01:41:19.019
<v Keith Wilson>The other was that it would reduce 50% of the unsheltered population when the HRAAP was designed or developed in June.

1017
01:41:19.100 --> 01:41:32.060
<v Keith Wilson>Forgive me, you can correct me if I'm wrong, but those were 2 specific outcomes that the City of Portland agreed to, neither of which, if this budget goes forward, will still stand met.

1018
01:41:32.141 --> 01:41:38.320
<v Keith Wilson>And so we're gonna have to reevaluate the agreement with the county at that particular time and determine what are the outcomes now necessary.

1019
01:41:38.368 --> 01:41:38.466
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1020
01:41:39.426 --> 01:41:42.984
<v Keith Wilson>To continue that cross-collaboration relationship.

1021
01:41:43.849 --> 01:41:58.109
<v Keith Wilson>If the question is about how is it gonna affect our sheltering system, Sky, Brandy and her team have been working very hard modeling different funding and outcome expectations, and we are using it as a flexible system.

1022
01:41:58.509 --> 01:42:05.078
<v Keith Wilson>We will have to increase overnight versus alternative SRV if it's cut any further.

1023
01:42:05.302 --> 01:42:25.817
<v Keith Wilson>If it currently stands at the amount, they're going to keep open all the SRV and TAS sites, make a meaningful reduction in overnight, but keep a flexible system to meet severe weather, heat domes, cold weather temperatures, so we don't have to have any Portlander on the street at night who wants a bed tonight.

1024
01:42:25.978 --> 01:42:30.319
<v Keith Wilson>So it's a flexible question with a flexible system that we're building.

1025
01:42:31.483 --> 01:42:49.011
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, I appreciate it because this is I think generally most people understand that in the world of shelter, to Commissioner Broom-Edwards' point, we all recognize it's not the end goal, but in the world of shelter, that a 24-hour, like a pod village, is a form of shelter that's better than an overnight.

1026
01:42:49.091 --> 01:42:55.314
<v Eric Zimmerman>But there's not enough money to do that broadly, and so we went with an overnight approach for the last Band-Aid, if you will.

1027
01:42:55.667 --> 01:43:13.903
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just— I am concerned that the challenges with overnight are going to be exacerbated by the fact that we're going to have a lot of people exasperated by the closure of the county's 24-hour shelters and what that impact will do, and if it's going to now demand either more of some form or more of the neighborhood enhancements.

1028
01:43:14.032 --> 01:43:26.363
<v Eric Zimmerman>But it remains a huge concern with me given that we largely have improved the sheltering situation in Portland over the last 2 years because of these concurrent efforts, and I feel like we're really retracting from that.

1029
01:43:28.578 --> 01:43:29.380
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to move a little bit.

1030
01:43:29.604 --> 01:43:30.439
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate it.

1031
01:43:30.488 --> 01:43:32.590
<v Eric Zimmerman>There were some comments earlier about, about Home Forward.

1032
01:43:32.814 --> 01:43:32.863
<v Eric Zimmerman>I—.

1033
01:43:33.953 --> 01:43:36.104
<v Eric Zimmerman>We had the Steering and Oversight Committee this last week.

1034
01:43:37.243 --> 01:43:43.390
<v Eric Zimmerman>At that committee, colleagues, we learned of 1,600 units was reported of Portland-regulated units are vacant.

1035
01:43:44.081 --> 01:43:59.787
<v Eric Zimmerman>So regulated units in our community, variety of different owners, operators, but 1,600 are vacant on top of the the articles that we've seen about the 6-month vacancy timeline and how long it takes to fill.

1036
01:44:02.055 --> 01:44:42.488
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, I also— I'm not sure there's much else that we should be talking about, because if we have built units with subsidies to be affordable and we're getting a bevy of excuses about can or can't a 6-month vacancy rate for a Portland affordable unit is criminal.

1037
01:44:42.681 --> 01:44:44.920
<v Eric Zimmerman>A 6-month vacancy rate is criminal.

1038
01:44:44.969 --> 01:44:46.542
<v Eric Zimmerman>A 6-month vacancy rate is criminal.

1039
01:44:48.444 --> 01:44:52.547
<v Eric Zimmerman>I've seen zero leadership on here's what I'm doing to fix it.

1040
01:44:53.412 --> 01:45:08.770
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so at this point, not only do I have no faith in the leadership, but I really think all of our bodies— this body, this county, City of Gresham— it's time to reinterview our board nominees to that organization.

1041
01:45:08.881 --> 01:45:13.914
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because all I've seen so far in the media has been defense of the operations, defense of the executive.

1042
01:45:14.131 --> 01:45:14.686
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1043
01:45:14.865 --> 01:45:17.051
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I find that to be criminal.

1044
01:45:19.804 --> 01:45:57.877
<v Eric Zimmerman>So until we start talking about 6 months moving into 1 or 2 months, and until we start talking about dozens of units instead of 1,600 units that are vacant, the rest of this seems fruitless because these are available units that were built for members of our community who I think there are a lot of reasons why people aren't in them because of a lack of urgency, a lack of creative thinking, a lack of designing their system not to be beholden to a pretty bad loan situation, a lack of trying, a lack of leadership.

1045
01:45:58.024 --> 01:46:18.811
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I do think it is time, since we have the County Commission and we have the City Council here in one fell swoop, that we get real serious about the fact that we have this semi-public private-public entity with its own governing board who uses our money to put people in housing, and they're not meeting the mark.

1046
01:46:20.260 --> 01:46:31.140
<v Eric Zimmerman>And given our own situations at the City of Portland with the Housing Bureau, I think we have a lot of area that we need to, like, dig in only on this, right?

1047
01:46:31.204 --> 01:46:40.573
<v Eric Zimmerman>The shelter part of our continuum, we're spending a lot of time Skyler and her team are doing well, but I think collectively we need to get on this vacancy piece of it.

1048
01:46:41.201 --> 01:46:48.448
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I need, deeply need leadership to come out of the Housing Bureau and Home Forward for a path forward.

1049
01:46:50.127 --> 01:46:57.367
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I just say that because I'm starting to bubble over in terms of frustration.

1050
01:46:58.042 --> 01:47:13.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I feel like at this point, Mayor, as a member of the SOC, at this point, Chair, as a member of the SOC, I think we've all given enough time for the situation to develop, and I don't see it developing in a positive direction, and it might take our involvement to right that ship.

1051
01:47:15.096 --> 01:47:24.962
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I have no— I'm looking at board members on here, and I just, I don't know who is going to give leadership to that but for us, the combined effort of these 2 bodies.

1052
01:47:25.011 --> 01:47:29.652
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I offer that up, and I appreciate your presentation.

1053
01:47:29.733 --> 01:47:32.601
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I'm in the SOC, I have seen almost all of this already, and so thank you to those that presented.

1054
01:47:32.649 --> 01:47:32.747
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1055
01:47:34.698 --> 01:47:44.846
<v Eric Zimmerman>I am going to encourage the members of this joint effort to accept— not accept the non-answer from Home Forward that we've gotten for the last several months.

1056
01:47:45.167 --> 01:47:45.425
<v Ryan Deibert>Thanks.

1057
01:47:46.050 --> 01:47:46.851
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

1058
01:47:46.931 --> 01:47:49.801
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, we have about 9 minutes left and I got 3 folks in the queue.

1059
01:47:49.850 --> 01:47:53.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>So it's going to go Councilor Smith, Commissioner Singleton, and Chair Vega-Petersen will take us home.

1060
01:47:54.564 --> 01:47:55.573
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

1061
01:47:56.167 --> 01:48:02.885
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Zimmerman, we were thinking the same thing because I wanted to find out, do we have an IGA right now?

1062
01:48:03.447 --> 01:48:06.530
<v Loretta Smith>Is it good until 2027?

1063
01:48:06.578 --> 01:48:08.153
<v Skyler Brocker-Knapp>June of 2027, yes.

1064
01:48:09.005 --> 01:48:09.855
<v Loretta Smith>It's good until when?

1065
01:48:10.274 --> 01:48:11.863
<v Jillian Schoney>June 30th of 2027.

1066
01:48:12.377 --> 01:48:14.353
<v Loretta Smith>June 30th of 2027.

1067
01:48:14.882 --> 01:48:28.135
<v Loretta Smith>So I think as we're talking about and negotiating what goes into the IGA, that is the platform that we can use to determine if the county is going to do rental assistance, because that's their bailiwick.

1068
01:48:28.198 --> 01:48:29.819
<v Loretta Smith>That's what they Yes.

1069
01:48:30.444 --> 01:48:31.822
<v Loretta Smith>That's their book of business.

1070
01:48:32.061 --> 01:48:33.841
<v Loretta Smith>It has not been our book of business.

1071
01:48:33.904 --> 01:48:43.119
<v Loretta Smith>The only reason why we, um, budgeted those funds was because those were the funds that were unbudgeted, and we decided that we wanted to put those somewhere.

1072
01:48:43.744 --> 01:48:48.921
<v Loretta Smith>What, what my concern is with those, with those budgeted funds was $9 million.

1073
01:48:50.137 --> 01:48:59.993
<v Loretta Smith>And since we have to create a system, I would like to I would like to pass that over to Multnomah County and let you all do it because that's what you do.

1074
01:49:00.090 --> 01:49:02.894
<v Loretta Smith>You can get that out the door like yesterday.

1075
01:49:03.037 --> 01:49:04.672
<v Loretta Smith>I talked to Director Bonacar.

1076
01:49:05.280 --> 01:49:09.063
<v Loretta Smith>He said we have to create our system, we have to do an RFP.

1077
01:49:09.543 --> 01:49:13.326
<v Loretta Smith>We probably won't even get that out until September of '26.

1078
01:49:13.710 --> 01:49:27.242
<v Loretta Smith>Now that's criminal for us to have an emergency and to say we wanted to house folks who are being evicted but yet those funds are not even going to leave the city's coffers until September, October.

1079
01:49:27.984 --> 01:49:31.046
<v Loretta Smith>Why don't we pass those funds over to Multnomah County?

1080
01:49:31.127 --> 01:49:37.867
<v Loretta Smith>Because they have relationships, they have contracts with folks who need to get that housing.

1081
01:49:39.369 --> 01:49:40.820
<v Loretta Smith>We're a joint body.

1082
01:49:40.917 --> 01:49:42.337
<v Loretta Smith>We can, we can see that.

1083
01:49:43.095 --> 01:49:46.500
<v Loretta Smith>I'm willing to put an ordinance on the floor, but— Councilor Loretta Smith.

1084
01:49:47.372 --> 01:49:51.809
<v Loretta Smith>We need to have that conversation with the leaders who are, who are putting together that IGA.

1085
01:49:52.917 --> 01:50:04.421
<v Loretta Smith>That's a conversation that we need to have like within the next week because we're not going to be able to house those 1,600 people until we get that money out the door.

1086
01:50:05.354 --> 01:50:10.136
<v Loretta Smith>And that money is being held right here in the '25-'26 budget.

1087
01:50:10.929 --> 01:50:21.466
<v Loretta Smith>And what's going to end up happening is it's going to get rolled over to our '27-'28 26-27 budget, and they're going to slow walk it, slow walk it out.

1088
01:50:21.948 --> 01:50:24.484
<v Loretta Smith>And that is just ridiculous to me.

1089
01:50:25.417 --> 01:50:35.871
<v Loretta Smith>And that's why, you know, the ordinance that I had, I identified Sun School organizations that could get that money out, that they actually do rental assistance.

1090
01:50:35.935 --> 01:50:52.561
<v Loretta Smith>And I think we need to either, you know, stop being territorial, get that money over to Multnomah County, let them get it out the door before June 30th so these people who are in the balance of being evicted from their homes, that they can get some relief over the summer.

1091
01:50:52.626 --> 01:51:02.488
<v Loretta Smith>Because if we don't get that money out until September, October, what was all this conversation about this last 6 months, 4 months, about, you know, slowing the flow?

1092
01:51:02.889 --> 01:51:04.027
<v Loretta Smith>It's not slowing the flow.

1093
01:51:04.091 --> 01:51:07.314
<v Loretta Smith>It was just, it was just, you know, being very territorial.

1094
01:51:07.443 --> 01:51:09.655
<v Loretta Smith>I want to do this, I want to make us do that.

1095
01:51:09.783 --> 01:51:13.472
<v Loretta Smith>And then in that IGA, we need to also say next year Yes.

1096
01:51:13.858 --> 01:51:17.359
<v Loretta Smith>Are we going to— are we going to continue?

1097
01:51:17.407 --> 01:51:23.364
<v Loretta Smith>Because that's a one-time-only thing, and I don't want folks thinking that that's what we do, because that's not what we do.

1098
01:51:24.231 --> 01:51:25.307
<v Loretta Smith>We don't do rent assistance.

1099
01:51:25.355 --> 01:51:36.484
<v Loretta Smith>We need to be very clear, and I think that's the platform that both the city and the county should use, that IGA, to say, what is your book of business and what is our book of business?

1100
01:51:37.158 --> 01:51:40.435
<v Loretta Smith>And just be done with it, not trying to boss up on each other.

1101
01:51:41.012 --> 01:51:49.207
<v Loretta Smith>But just stick to what we know we can do and we can afford to do, because we can't afford to do parallel tracks, and that's what we're doing right now.

1102
01:51:49.672 --> 01:51:56.264
<v Josh Roper>Let me just add, um, or say we share your commitment to getting these dollars out into the community as soon as possible.

1103
01:51:56.328 --> 01:52:03.000
<v Josh Roper>And there are different tracks that are possible depending on which pot of money under that $9 million we're referring to.

1104
01:52:03.064 --> 01:52:08.755
<v Josh Roper>So there's placement out of shelter, there there's sort of before-facing eviction money.

1105
01:52:08.979 --> 01:52:16.688
<v Loretta Smith>There's long-term, the short-term, and then there's a shelter-to-housing money that we directed to be funded for '25-'26.

1106
01:52:16.768 --> 01:52:21.703
<v Loretta Smith>It does not look like— and I talked to Michael, he can't get it out before June 30th.

1107
01:52:21.751 --> 01:52:23.578
<v Loretta Smith>He told me that specifically.

1108
01:52:23.738 --> 01:52:31.301
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm concerned because we fought for the last 4 months because we were fighting for people who are being evicted right now.

1109
01:52:32.296 --> 01:52:42.250
<v Loretta Smith>And if we can't help those people, those numbers that you're talking about, that we're netting about 600 people, we're going to be netting more than that over the summer.

1110
01:52:43.011 --> 01:52:47.069
<v Loretta Smith>So why don't we just get it out and get it gone and help people today?

1111
01:52:47.579 --> 01:52:52.856
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, I challenge the mayor and the chair to come together to get those dollars out the door.

1112
01:52:53.579 --> 01:53:05.743
<v Jillian Schoney>Well, and what I would offer is that the director of Portland Solutions Housing Bureau, Human Services, and Homeless Services comes together to just talk about how that can work.

1113
01:53:06.913 --> 01:53:07.106
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1114
01:53:07.314 --> 01:53:08.614
<v Jillian Schoney>If you're amenable to that.

1115
01:53:08.662 --> 01:53:11.534
<v Loretta Smith>Because my thing is— no, no, no, it's another amendment passed.

1116
01:53:11.631 --> 01:53:12.337
<v Loretta Smith>It's gone.

1117
01:53:12.512 --> 01:53:20.823
<v Loretta Smith>But what it is, is it— I don't want us to not have that conversation when we can get it out the door right now.

1118
01:53:21.273 --> 01:53:21.753
<v Commissioner Singleton>Yeah.

1119
01:53:22.059 --> 01:53:22.988
<v Loretta Smith>That's what you do.

1120
01:53:23.037 --> 01:53:28.314
<v Loretta Smith>We don't have to have the longer conversation who's going to do what, but we do need to get that rental assistance money out the door.

1121
01:53:28.380 --> 01:53:28.555
<v Jillian Schoney>Yep.

1122
01:53:29.132 --> 01:53:36.072
<v Jillian Schoney>And it is all tied to also the $10 million in OTO that is in the Chair's proposed on the county side of the equation, how that works with the $2 million.

1123
01:53:37.403 --> 01:53:39.759
<v Jillian Schoney>It is not just about that one pot of money.

1124
01:53:39.935 --> 01:53:41.746
<v Jillian Schoney>Like, our monies should work together.

1125
01:53:42.338 --> 01:53:46.489
<v Jillian Schoney>And I also don't wanna have that conversation outside the context of shelter closures.

1126
01:53:46.666 --> 01:53:53.462
<v Jillian Schoney>Like, we should never have a shelter conversation solely focused on total number of shelter units available.

1127
01:53:53.894 --> 01:53:57.997
<v Jillian Schoney>It should always be directly tied to the amount of housing placement funds in our system.

1128
01:53:58.109 --> 01:53:58.222
<v Jillian Schoney>Right.

1129
01:53:58.564 --> 01:53:59.163
<v Loretta Smith>So we have—.

1130
01:53:59.195 --> 01:54:00.865
<v Jillian Schoney>We are talking about throughput.

1131
01:54:01.222 --> 01:54:03.427
<v Jillian Schoney>A shelter bed should not serve one human a year.

1132
01:54:03.493 --> 01:54:06.297
<v Jillian Schoney>And when we separate those conversations, that's what happens.

1133
01:54:06.909 --> 01:54:08.770
<v Loretta Smith>That's a deep conversation right there, ma'am.

1134
01:54:08.818 --> 01:54:08.914
<v Loretta Smith>Right?

1135
01:54:08.963 --> 01:54:15.127
<v Jillian Schoney>We need to have multiple, ideally a minimum of 2, ideally 4 a year for every shelter bed.

1136
01:54:15.256 --> 01:54:19.599
<v Jillian Schoney>And we can do the math now to make sure that those pots of money are connected.

1137
01:54:19.792 --> 01:54:21.615
<v Jillian Schoney>And in talking about that throughput—.

1138
01:54:21.729 --> 01:54:22.649
<v Loretta Smith>That's the IGA thing.

1139
01:54:23.037 --> 01:54:26.573
<v Loretta Smith>I'm talking about right now, these people who are being evicted right now.

1140
01:54:26.627 --> 01:54:27.520
<v Loretta Smith>That's Yes.

1141
01:54:33.048 --> 01:54:33.899
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1142
01:54:34.318 --> 01:54:37.731
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Commissioner Singleton and then Chair Vega Peterson.

1143
01:54:37.942 --> 01:54:38.652
<v Jamie Dunphy>We'll get out of here.

1144
01:54:39.796 --> 01:54:40.636
<v Commissioner Singleton>I will be fast.

1145
01:54:40.845 --> 01:54:53.862
<v Commissioner Singleton>Um, I just wanted to say no person on this dais or in the community or over there or any of our providers is happy about shelters closing, but everybody does want that balanced system.

1146
01:54:53.958 --> 01:55:06.025
<v Commissioner Singleton>And I think I think it's really important to say out loud that the shelter goals of the original HRAP were an unfunded mandate that were never going to be met because neither entity was putting the dollars in that needed to happen to do that.

1147
01:55:06.475 --> 01:55:10.948
<v Commissioner Singleton>If they were, it was one-time-only dollars with no long-term funding stability plan.

1148
01:55:11.685 --> 01:55:19.925
<v Commissioner Singleton>I am super frustrated about those previous decisions to use one-time-only dollars for ongoing funds and ongoing programs, but this is where we are.

1149
01:55:20.005 --> 01:55:20.229
<v Loretta Smith>Councilor Smith.

1150
01:55:20.826 --> 01:55:24.877
<v Commissioner Singleton>And I do think it's critical that we keep that perspective that you were just talking about.

1151
01:55:25.006 --> 01:55:28.010
<v Commissioner Singleton>Folks have to move through the system and not just be in shelter.

1152
01:55:28.332 --> 01:55:30.612
<v Commissioner Singleton>I have run a shelter without housing placement assistance.

1153
01:55:30.984 --> 01:55:32.293
<v Commissioner Singleton>It is not fun for the staff.

1154
01:55:32.682 --> 01:55:37.359
<v Commissioner Singleton>It is not fun for the people who have to stay there and the people who never get to get into housing.

1155
01:55:37.909 --> 01:55:40.145
<v Commissioner Singleton>There's no— the milieu is so challenging.

1156
01:55:40.532 --> 01:55:41.833
<v Commissioner Singleton>So we cannot do that to people.

1157
01:55:41.882 --> 01:55:43.619
<v Commissioner Singleton>We have to keep this system functioning.

1158
01:55:44.135 --> 01:55:44.359
<v Commissioner Singleton>Thanks.

1159
01:55:44.520 --> 01:55:45.180
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thanks.

1160
01:55:46.337 --> 01:55:46.673
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Thank you.

1161
01:55:46.819 --> 01:55:50.095
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Um, so, and thank you, Councilor, uh, or President Dunphy.

1162
01:55:50.591 --> 01:55:56.983
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Um, I, I feel like a little bit of the historian here because except possibly for Councilor Novick, I think I've been here the longest of anyone.

1163
01:55:57.110 --> 01:56:00.917
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And so I really do want to correct the record on a few things that have been said today.

1164
01:56:01.109 --> 01:56:12.863
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>First of all, um, when the joint office was first formed between the city and the county, the— and Commissioner, uh, Smith, you— yes, I was like, wait a second, Commissioner Smith, you were here when this was yes.

1165
01:56:13.489 --> 01:56:18.677
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And so you were here because I actually was just coming on the board right before the Joint Office was formed.

1166
01:56:18.725 --> 01:56:30.243
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So, you know, the City of Portland was actually putting more money into the homelessness system in Multnomah County than Multnomah County was when the Joint Office was first formed.

1167
01:56:30.291 --> 01:56:35.688
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So like, it is disingenuous to say that like this is not something that the city has done.

1168
01:56:35.737 --> 01:56:40.435
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>The city has probably been invested in it just as long as the, as the county has.

1169
01:56:40.547 --> 01:56:47.296
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And so that is why the joint office was formed, to try to, to, you know, deduplicate some of the work that was happening to make it more efficient.

1170
01:56:47.345 --> 01:56:49.123
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>The same kind of conversation we're having today.

1171
01:56:49.685 --> 01:57:08.632
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I think it's also, um, it also needs to be stated that, um, the goal that was set for the— in the original HREP was that, um, that we needed to increase the number of people that were being sheltered in Multnomah County by 2,699.

1172
01:57:08.680 --> 01:57:08.777
<v Jillian Schoney>Thank you.

1173
01:57:10.350 --> 01:57:13.081
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>And so the mayor's correct, we did not make that goal.

1174
01:57:13.417 --> 01:57:14.350
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We exceeded it.

1175
01:57:14.525 --> 01:57:16.998
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>We met that goal by 125%.

1176
01:57:17.192 --> 01:57:27.966
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So instead of having a total of 18,658 people by the end of 2025, we had housed or sheltered 23,301 people of that.

1177
01:57:28.047 --> 01:57:30.231
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So I just wanna make that really clear.

1178
01:57:30.617 --> 01:57:35.466
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>There was a lot of work that made— that went into making sure that we were achieving things.

1179
01:57:35.643 --> 01:57:37.073
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>It is true thank you.

1180
01:57:37.170 --> 01:57:39.644
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>It is true that we are going to be impacted by the shelter beds.

1181
01:57:39.756 --> 01:57:46.087
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I think, Commissioner Singleton, you said it best when you said nobody is happy to see this, but we have to have a functioning system.

1182
01:57:46.586 --> 01:57:58.059
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>I just want to direct everyone's attention to the letter that I sent out to both the Portland City Council and copied my commissioners on yesterday that goes into details about the decisions that are in my budget.

1183
01:57:58.300 --> 01:57:59.842
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>You should have all received this yesterday.

1184
01:58:00.309 --> 01:58:06.377
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>In there, it includes a a chart of the shelter closings that are planned for the county in 2027.

1185
01:58:06.810 --> 01:58:22.605
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>Included in there are the shelters that were previously funded by City of Portland dollars of that $31 million that you all had been sending over to us, including those that are scheduled for closing and the ones that I have backfilled in my budget with county dollars or SHS dollars.

1186
01:58:22.654 --> 01:58:37.475
<v Jessica Vega-Peterson>So I want to make sure that all of that information is available for folks so that we have a clear picture of what we're talking about as we're going forward and making these very important budget decisions, and I look forward to the continued conversation, um, on, on those decisions as we're being made.

1187
01:58:37.572 --> 01:58:39.528
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, colleagues, that brings us to a conclusion.

1188
01:58:40.185 --> 01:58:42.204
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, thank you all so much for your presentation today.

1189
01:58:42.381 --> 01:58:44.592
<v Jamie Dunphy>To my county colleagues, thank you for coming over and joining us.

1190
01:58:44.672 --> 01:58:47.863
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr. Mayor, Mr. City Administrator, City Council, thank you all.

1191
01:58:48.296 --> 01:58:50.074
<v Jamie Dunphy>We are adjourned.

