WEBVTT

1
00:11:11.785 --> 00:11:12.634
<v Olivia Clark>You're, you're over here.

2
00:11:12.844 --> 00:11:14.302
<v Olivia Clark>You're over here, dear.

3
00:11:14.350 --> 00:11:15.008
<v Olivia Clark>You're over here.

4
00:11:15.327 --> 00:11:20.922
<v Loretta Smith>I know, I'm so used to having you right here.

5
00:11:21.001 --> 00:11:21.836
<v Olivia Clark>You're over here.

6
00:11:21.980 --> 00:11:22.845
<v Ting Lu>Kind of sad.

7
00:11:23.101 --> 00:11:24.351
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, good morning everyone.

8
00:11:25.730 --> 00:11:29.015
<v Olivia Clark>I call the meeting of the Public Works Committee to order.

9
00:11:29.128 --> 00:11:32.446
<v Olivia Clark>It is Tuesday, April the 14th at 9:30 AM.

10
00:11:33.440 --> 00:11:34.995
<v Olivia Clark>Diego, will you please call the roll?

11
00:11:36.245 --> 00:11:36.693
<v Diego>Good morning.

12
00:11:37.110 --> 00:11:41.860
<v Diego>I'm having troubles with my boat tracker, so apologies if this is order— out of order, excuse me.

13
00:11:42.423 --> 00:11:42.792
<v Diego>Kanal?

14
00:11:44.431 --> 00:11:44.977
<v Diego>Koyama Lane?

15
00:11:45.219 --> 00:11:45.668
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

16
00:11:46.985 --> 00:11:47.371
<v Diego>Smith?

17
00:11:47.725 --> 00:11:47.918
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

18
00:11:49.059 --> 00:11:49.789
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

19
00:11:49.967 --> 00:11:50.066
<v Mitch Green>Here.

20
00:11:50.389 --> 00:11:50.779
<v Diego>Clark?

21
00:11:51.039 --> 00:11:51.153
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

22
00:11:52.889 --> 00:11:53.360
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

23
00:11:53.538 --> 00:11:55.972
<v Olivia Clark>And Claire, can you please read the statement of conduct?

24
00:11:57.240 --> 00:11:59.418
<v Claire>Good morning and welcome to the meeting of the Public Works Committee.

25
00:12:00.014 --> 00:12:05.325
<v Claire>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at portland.gov.

26
00:12:08.471 --> 00:12:10.644
<v Claire>/Council/agenda/publicworkscommittee or by calling 311.

27
00:12:11.287 --> 00:12:14.472
<v Claire>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

28
00:12:15.052 --> 00:12:17.821
<v Claire>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

29
00:12:18.389 --> 00:12:23.607
<v Keelan McClymont>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

30
00:12:24.126 --> 00:12:25.926
<v Keelan McClymont>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

31
00:12:26.509 --> 00:12:27.456
<v Keelan McClymont>The chair preserves order.

32
00:12:27.619 --> 00:12:35.131
<v Keelan McClymont>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, Or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

33
00:12:35.741 --> 00:12:37.701
<v Keelan McClymont>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

34
00:12:38.118 --> 00:12:40.269
<v Keelan McClymont>Further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

35
00:12:40.783 --> 00:12:43.754
<v Keelan McClymont>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

36
00:12:44.299 --> 00:12:47.335
<v Keelan McClymont>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

37
00:12:48.250 --> 00:12:50.192
<v Keelan McClymont>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

38
00:12:50.498 --> 00:12:52.441
<v Keelan McClymont>When testifying, state your name for the record.

39
00:12:52.986 --> 00:12:55.797
<v Keelan McClymont>If you are a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

40
00:12:56.118 --> 00:12:59.746
<v Claire>And finally, virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

41
00:13:01.558 --> 00:13:02.248
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Claire.

42
00:13:03.241 --> 00:13:08.418
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, welcome to the new, the new Public Works Committee with my new vice chair.

43
00:13:08.532 --> 00:13:14.815
<v Olivia Clark>I was hoping to welcome our new member, Councilor Kanal, but I think he's, he's joining us a little bit later.

44
00:13:15.745 --> 00:13:27.705
<v Olivia Clark>Um, so today I'm looking forward to talking about this new era and where we're going, but first we have a couple of other items we need to take care of today.

45
00:13:28.187 --> 00:13:29.230
<v Olivia Clark>We actually have 3.

46
00:13:29.856 --> 00:13:34.386
<v Olivia Clark>The first item that we're going to hear is a property rights ordinance from PBOT.

47
00:13:34.466 --> 00:13:35.431
<v Olivia Clark>I see them, they're here.

48
00:13:36.458 --> 00:13:45.019
<v Olivia Clark>Then we're going to consider the water revenue bonds, which will include a quick update on the Bull Run filtration project.

49
00:13:45.759 --> 00:13:52.408
<v Olivia Clark>And we've also invited CA Lee to join us around 10 o'clock in case there are questions about bonding.

50
00:13:53.722 --> 00:13:59.990
<v Olivia Clark>Then we'll have a discussion on our committee priorities and look ahead to the rest of this year.

51
00:14:00.759 --> 00:14:09.783
<v Olivia Clark>I'm really hoping that we are— even though we have 3 hours, I'm hoping that we don't take or need the whole 3 hours for this agenda today, but we'll play it by ear.

52
00:14:10.874 --> 00:14:14.015
<v Olivia Clark>So, um, Diego, can you please read the first item?

53
00:14:14.801 --> 00:14:32.879
<v Diego>Item 1, authorize the Bureau of Transportation to acquire certain permanent property rights necessary for replacement rockfall mitigation system for the West Burnside Road Southwest Tichenor Drive slide project through the exercise of the city's eminent domain authority.

54
00:14:34.433 --> 00:14:35.243
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Diego.

55
00:14:35.340 --> 00:14:45.855
<v Olivia Clark>So we have the team from PBOT here with an ordinance on permanent property rights that are needed to support a rockfall mitigation, which happened in Councilor Green and I's district.

56
00:14:46.778 --> 00:14:48.062
<v Olivia Clark>Um, on Titchener.

57
00:14:48.784 --> 00:14:50.230
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, it's very familiar to us.

58
00:14:50.326 --> 00:14:53.104
<v Olivia Clark>We, we live in a hilly place where there are a lot of rockfalls.

59
00:14:53.923 --> 00:14:59.847
<v Olivia Clark>Um, so I'm going to hand it off to the PBOT staff to give us the specifics, and, and then we'll move into a decision.

60
00:15:00.682 --> 00:15:02.255
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, DCA Dhanapal.

61
00:15:03.235 --> 00:15:06.624
<v Priya Dhanapal>Uh, good morning, Chair Clark and members of the Public Works Committee.

62
00:15:06.703 --> 00:15:09.400
<v Priya Dhanapal>This is Priyadana Pal, um, DCA for Public Works.

63
00:15:09.577 --> 00:15:18.815
<v Priya Dhanapal>I just wanted to take a moment to say that we we are really excited about the new committee, and welcome to the committee in its new form, and also welcome to Councilor Kanal from District 2.

64
00:15:19.378 --> 00:15:26.221
<v Priya Dhanapal>We are thrilled about continuing to work together with this committee and delivering the work that keeps the city moving and functioning every day.

65
00:15:26.302 --> 00:15:29.854
<v Priya Dhanapal>And we're also thrilled that all districts are represented in Public Works Committee right now.

66
00:15:30.961 --> 00:15:43.404
<v Priya Dhanapal>We are here to present an update on the Southwest Ishna Drive landslide response and the associated ordinance with that, I'll pass it on to David from PBOT.

67
00:15:44.052 --> 00:15:44.684
<v David McEldowney>Thank you very much.

68
00:15:45.320 --> 00:15:45.625
<v David McEldowney>Good morning.

69
00:15:45.739 --> 00:15:46.724
<v David McEldowney>I'm David McEldowney.

70
00:15:46.788 --> 00:15:52.277
<v David McEldowney>I'm PBOT's Real Property Services Division Manager, and today joining me is my colleague.

71
00:15:52.889 --> 00:15:54.052
<v Michael McGee>My name is Michael McGee.

72
00:15:54.133 --> 00:15:59.727
<v Michael McGee>I'm the interim city engineer for Transportation Bureau and also construction services manager.

73
00:15:59.808 --> 00:16:00.100
<v Claire>Good morning.

74
00:16:01.910 --> 00:16:20.073
<v David McEldowney>The item, uh, agenda item before you today is an ordinance of intent necessity surrounding the Tichenor slide, this is an ordinance that we hope that the committee moves forward to the full council with your support for their consideration.

75
00:16:20.971 --> 00:16:31.744
<v David McEldowney>This is something that you've all seen before over the last year several times at council, but this one's going to be a little bit different because typically we bring these to you before we construct a project.

76
00:16:32.208 --> 00:16:41.087
<v David McEldowney>In this particular case, The project has already been constructed, and the property owners are expecting us to come back and acquire the easements.

77
00:16:41.763 --> 00:16:43.432
<v David McEldowney>And with that, I'm going to kick it over to Michael McGee.

78
00:16:44.798 --> 00:16:45.216
<v Michael McGee>Thank you.

79
00:16:45.441 --> 00:16:51.191
<v Michael McGee>I'm just going to give a little overview and some background and context of the work that was performed that's led us here.

80
00:16:52.298 --> 00:16:58.033
<v Michael McGee>March of last year, we had a landslide at the Titchener and Burnside intersection.

81
00:16:58.129 --> 00:16:59.044
<v Michael McGee>You can see it in the photo.

82
00:16:59.173 --> 00:17:06.115
<v Michael McGee>This is looking westward, if you don't know, March is a common landslide time for us.

83
00:17:06.179 --> 00:17:09.847
<v Michael McGee>We have one in the West Hills at Fairmount currently with the road closure.

84
00:17:09.977 --> 00:17:13.455
<v Michael McGee>So the heavy rains combined with our topography, we end up with these.

85
00:17:13.520 --> 00:17:14.217
<v Michael McGee>Some are smaller.

86
00:17:14.329 --> 00:17:15.803
<v Michael McGee>This is a quite large one.

87
00:17:17.616 --> 00:17:24.359
<v Michael McGee>So you're looking west here and you can see the material that came down on and near the roadway.

88
00:17:24.441 --> 00:17:45.583
<v Michael McGee>What you can't tell very and then we— this road is a main access to Arlington Heights, also for emergency services.

89
00:17:45.839 --> 00:17:51.112
<v Michael McGee>So it became a priority for us also with the springtime and Washington Park and people being interested in there.

90
00:17:51.160 --> 00:17:51.257
<v Michael McGee>Thank you.

91
00:17:51.305 --> 00:17:58.741
<v Michael McGee>And then we— So we worked with a lot of our community partners to get that road closed and make this awareness until we come up with a safe solution.

92
00:18:01.692 --> 00:18:04.731
<v Michael McGee>Just an overview of the work and what it was required.

93
00:18:05.167 --> 00:18:13.555
<v Michael McGee>We had to work with urban forestry to remove the trees at the brow, which is the top edge, which was a contributing factor to some of the issues that we had.

94
00:18:14.238 --> 00:18:25.873
<v Michael McGee>We had to get an emergency declaration put in place with assistance from the deputy city administrators so we could act quickly and get a contractor with the skills in place to perform the work.

95
00:18:25.953 --> 00:18:29.833
<v Michael McGee>It's a specialized skill with certain equipment that they have to use.

96
00:18:31.690 --> 00:18:36.611
<v Michael McGee>They use air tools, hydraulic jacks, specialized safety harnesses.

97
00:18:36.723 --> 00:18:38.692
<v Michael McGee>You can see the large machinery that they have to do.

98
00:18:39.289 --> 00:18:45.523
<v Michael McGee>Then they have to hang the mesh down before the blasting was a consideration that we had in the toolbox.

99
00:18:45.829 --> 00:18:51.865
<v Michael McGee>We were fortunate enough that we didn't have to do that because if we had to blast the road, we would have had to close Burnside for safety.

100
00:18:52.903 --> 00:18:59.071
<v Michael McGee>So it's a pretty significant effort that they make look easy, but it takes quite a bit of skill to get that done.

101
00:18:59.169 --> 00:19:10.335
<v Michael McGee>And you can see a lot of the details, significant, significant amount of material that fell prior to and with the work when they scraped the sides and did their work.

102
00:19:10.708 --> 00:19:18.138
<v Michael McGee>That area that they're working from is where the PBOT maintenance operations stores the sand piles for all of the winter weather operations.

103
00:19:18.809 --> 00:19:25.861
<v Michael McGee>So that way we were fortunate that that's where it landed, but we needed to make sure that we wouldn't proceed further towards into the roadway.

104
00:19:27.086 --> 00:19:31.855
<v Michael McGee>So we were successful in that and reconstructing a new version of essentially what was there before.

105
00:19:34.644 --> 00:19:35.665
<v Michael McGee>And then a quick timeline.

106
00:19:35.778 --> 00:19:37.415
<v Michael McGee>And you can see this is an after photo.

107
00:19:38.867 --> 00:19:42.534
<v Michael McGee>But we— March 29th, that's when the landslide occurred.

108
00:19:43.001 --> 00:19:45.295
<v Michael McGee>We worked to get the emergency declaration in place.

109
00:19:45.827 --> 00:19:55.828
<v Michael McGee>May 15th, we set up some— a web page and did a tremendous amount of outreach, emergency services, the neighborhoods, keep them apprised.

110
00:19:56.662 --> 00:20:01.098
<v Michael McGee>We were— we were still allowing bikes and peds to walk along the sidewalk portion of there.

111
00:20:01.163 --> 00:20:04.909
<v Michael McGee>There's a bus stop at the bottom of the hill, so we wanted to keep that open for them.

112
00:20:06.856 --> 00:20:11.787
<v Michael McGee>We had to get permits of entry so we could get up on the top across some 3 properties.

113
00:20:11.835 --> 00:20:17.068
<v Michael McGee>So right at the top, the leading edge of that, there's 3 properties that Dave is going to talk more about.

114
00:20:17.134 --> 00:20:24.969
<v Michael McGee>But we had to get onto their property so we could assess what was happening and make some judgments and refine our plan of how to approach the situation.

115
00:20:25.082 --> 00:20:26.012
<v Michael McGee>So permits entry.

116
00:20:27.410 --> 00:20:44.981
<v Michael McGee>And then we worked with them all along the way to make them aware of okay.

117
00:20:45.138 --> 00:20:45.643
<v David McEldowney>Thank you, Michael.

118
00:20:46.730 --> 00:20:56.210
<v David McEldowney>Once again, the purpose here today is to seek the authority from council to begin the negotiations with the property owners and offer just compensation.

119
00:20:56.259 --> 00:20:56.582
<v David McEldowney>Thank you, Councilor.

120
00:20:57.738 --> 00:21:07.965
<v David McEldowney>And if we are unable to reach a resolution with the property owners, then that would give us the ability, or the City Attorney's Office, the ability to condemn property rights through the court system.

121
00:21:09.153 --> 00:21:15.512
<v David McEldowney>We have 3 properties, as Michael mentioned, up on the top of the hill there that we need to acquire easements from.

122
00:21:15.978 --> 00:21:16.556
<v David McEldowney>Excuse me.

123
00:21:16.621 --> 00:21:30.472
<v David McEldowney>There are 3 permanent easements for that rockfall system and then one permanent easement that provides access from Champlain Drive to the site along one of the unimproved properties.

124
00:21:31.788 --> 00:21:34.452
<v David McEldowney>We've been in touch with property owners throughout.

125
00:21:34.534 --> 00:21:40.711
<v David McEldowney>They're invited to the council meeting, and we've had communication with them.

126
00:21:41.595 --> 00:21:45.221
<v David McEldowney>So I'll orientate you to this map that's on the screen now.

127
00:21:45.895 --> 00:21:47.692
<v David McEldowney>At the top of the— this is an overhead view.

128
00:21:47.917 --> 00:21:52.250
<v David McEldowney>At the top of the screen is Burnside, and at the bottom is Champlain Drive.

129
00:21:52.895 --> 00:22:04.760
<v David McEldowney>The 3 properties in question are the yellow parcels, and the green area is that cable mesh net that you saw in the photos earlier.

130
00:22:05.146 --> 00:22:16.717
<v David McEldowney>The triangles represent the anchors that hold that mesh net in place, and you'll see that 9 of those anchors are spread out across those properties.

131
00:22:17.400 --> 00:22:26.109
<v David McEldowney>So what we would be looking to get is the permanent easements that cover the green portion that overlaps the yellow on that map.

132
00:22:26.494 --> 00:22:27.936
<v Olivia Clark>David, can I interrupt for just a second?

133
00:22:28.034 --> 00:22:32.778
<v Olivia Clark>Are those, um, are the property owners losing some of that land to the slide?

134
00:22:32.843 --> 00:22:36.096
<v Olivia Clark>And I— it sounds like you're, you're putting anchors into their property.

135
00:22:37.332 --> 00:22:37.813
<v David McEldowney>Correct.

136
00:22:38.438 --> 00:22:42.237
<v David McEldowney>Um, Michael, do you want to discuss that part of it?

137
00:22:42.285 --> 00:22:49.723
<v Michael McGee>Yeah, the, the dashed line that you see in there is essentially that top of that brow, and you can see how when there the loose material was removed.

138
00:22:49.771 --> 00:22:52.961
<v Michael McGee>Some of it fell naturally and some of it was taken out by the effort.

139
00:22:53.507 --> 00:22:55.013
<v Michael McGee>It changed that topography.

140
00:22:55.142 --> 00:22:57.898
<v Michael McGee>So that's what that dashed line represents.

141
00:22:57.946 --> 00:22:59.982
<v Michael McGee>It reaches into their properties.

142
00:23:01.362 --> 00:23:08.207
<v David McEldowney>Yeah, I believe the beforehand situation was already a slope headed down to Burnside.

143
00:23:08.270 --> 00:23:12.695
<v David McEldowney>This just made part of that slope a little more steep.

144
00:23:13.625 --> 00:23:17.457
<v David McEldowney>And essentially, that's what that is.

145
00:23:18.674 --> 00:23:20.501
<v David McEldowney>And that is our presentation.

146
00:23:20.775 --> 00:23:22.987
<v David McEldowney>We're happy to answer any questions that you might have.

147
00:23:23.740 --> 00:23:25.471
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much for the presentation.

148
00:23:25.807 --> 00:23:26.657
<v Olivia Clark>It's very clear.

149
00:23:27.185 --> 00:23:30.520
<v Olivia Clark>I'm glad that the Arlington Heights neighbors were alerted.

150
00:23:30.633 --> 00:23:36.996
<v Olivia Clark>I mean, they must have been scared after their— not their backyard exactly, but was falling down.

151
00:23:38.310 --> 00:23:40.618
<v Olivia Clark>And it sounds like they've been very cooperative.

152
00:23:42.076 --> 00:23:44.726
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, do we have any questions or comments?

153
00:23:44.823 --> 00:23:45.977
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith.

154
00:23:46.286 --> 00:23:46.708
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

155
00:23:46.871 --> 00:23:48.788
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you for the presentation.

156
00:23:49.660 --> 00:23:51.779
<v Loretta Smith>What does something like this cost?

157
00:23:52.442 --> 00:23:55.680
<v Loretta Smith>What are we offering the residents?

158
00:23:57.200 --> 00:24:07.497
<v David McEldowney>Well, typically we come, we wait for the council to approve the ordinance, and then we go out and get appraisals, and then we have a better idea at that point.

159
00:24:08.516 --> 00:24:17.393
<v David McEldowney>Um, so these are permanent easements, but they're not over a large area, and it doesn't really change the use of the property.

160
00:24:18.371 --> 00:24:21.383
<v David McEldowney>Um, so we haven't quantified that amount yet, though.

161
00:24:21.832 --> 00:24:26.493
<v Loretta Smith>What if I don't like the amount that you're going to offer, and then if we give you permission to do it first?

162
00:24:26.815 --> 00:24:28.545
<v David McEldowney>I'm, I'm sorry, can you repeat that?

163
00:24:28.721 --> 00:24:35.371
<v Loretta Smith>I said, what if I don't like what you're offering and we give you permission to do it, and we don't know what we're giving you permission for?

164
00:24:36.311 --> 00:24:39.974
<v David McEldowney>Well, they— we were in communication with them, so they, they knew what it was for.

165
00:24:40.121 --> 00:24:45.705
<v David McEldowney>They knew what, what we were constructing out there, and they knew that we would come back to them.

166
00:24:46.161 --> 00:24:48.893
<v Loretta Smith>Um, no, I, I think you're missing what I'm saying.

167
00:24:49.087 --> 00:25:02.194
<v Loretta Smith>If you're asking me for permission, and I don't know if I want to give you permission because I don't know how much you're going to ask, that you're going to offer them for the— what we're going to be paying for this easement.

168
00:25:04.267 --> 00:25:04.717
<v David McEldowney>Yeah.

169
00:25:04.828 --> 00:25:06.096
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is that a negotiation?

170
00:25:06.354 --> 00:25:07.397
<v David McEldowney>It is a negotiation.

171
00:25:07.478 --> 00:25:07.798
<v David McEldowney>Okay.

172
00:25:07.878 --> 00:25:12.743
<v David McEldowney>Yeah, I mean, they— we make our offer and it's based on just compensation.

173
00:25:13.561 --> 00:25:18.971
<v David McEldowney>And once just compensation is informed by the appraisal, we make that offer to them.

174
00:25:19.663 --> 00:25:27.464
<v David McEldowney>If they think we're wrong and we've missed something, we're happy to hear what they have to say and we go into a negotiation from there.

175
00:25:27.849 --> 00:25:37.722
<v David McEldowney>And if we're unable to get it settled at some point, then it would go to the City Attorney's Office Um, to, to file for, um, file with the courts for possession.

176
00:25:37.981 --> 00:25:49.866
<v Loretta Smith>To, to make me more comfortable, because I've been in this before and I've had it done the other way around when I was on the County Commission, that you, you make the offer and then you bring it back to us and then we either approve it or don't.

177
00:25:50.478 --> 00:25:54.107
<v Loretta Smith>But if I give you blanket approval right now, I have no idea what I'm approving.

178
00:25:57.137 --> 00:25:59.942
<v David McEldowney>Well, I mean, that's traditionally the way it's done.

179
00:26:00.039 --> 00:26:01.972
<v David McEldowney>If it's through eminent domain.

180
00:26:02.069 --> 00:26:03.272
<v David McEldowney>That's the route.

181
00:26:03.512 --> 00:26:05.663
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, so this is eminent domain?

182
00:26:05.775 --> 00:26:05.983
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

183
00:26:06.336 --> 00:26:08.116
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, okay.

184
00:26:08.727 --> 00:26:10.570
<v Loretta Smith>I see, I see, I see, I see.

185
00:26:10.748 --> 00:26:20.500
<v David McEldowney>Yeah, if this was like a, you know, Parks or somebody that was acquiring this through a willing seller, willing buyer, that's typically how it goes.

186
00:26:20.596 --> 00:26:23.259
<v David McEldowney>Then we come back with a specific number for you.

187
00:26:23.902 --> 00:26:25.313
<v David McEldowney>But this is eminent domain.

188
00:26:25.490 --> 00:26:25.713
<v Priya Dhanapal>Yes.

189
00:26:25.826 --> 00:26:36.528
<v Loretta Smith>And we should have had a conversation prior to this, prior to this hearing, so that we understand what the, the rules of engagement are.

190
00:26:37.460 --> 00:26:41.227
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith, maybe we can, um, put that on a future agenda to learn.

191
00:26:41.372 --> 00:26:41.840
<v Ting Lu>It's too late.

192
00:26:42.181 --> 00:26:49.080
<v Olivia Clark>Well, on this one, um, but we can actually have a, a conversation in the future about how this, uh, process works.

193
00:26:49.291 --> 00:26:53.018
<v Olivia Clark>I think it would be— maybe you've already been through it at the county, but the rest of us maybe have not been through it.

194
00:26:53.551 --> 00:26:53.760
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

195
00:26:54.355 --> 00:27:00.296
<v Olivia Clark>And I imagine that you— this eminent domain is not used frequently, but when you have to, you use it.

196
00:27:01.403 --> 00:27:13.012
<v Loretta Smith>Well, so I would've liked to have an executive session where you could have explained to us what the parameters and what we were prepared to do before we have— before we came to this position.

197
00:27:13.703 --> 00:27:16.528
<v Loretta Smith>And so you're asking me to do something that I feel uncomfortable with right now.

198
00:27:19.826 --> 00:27:22.413
<v Loretta Smith>And I think we should have had an executive session first.

199
00:27:24.583 --> 00:27:25.756
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

200
00:27:27.459 --> 00:27:30.271
<v Olivia Clark>Do we have any other comments or questions from the other committee members?

201
00:27:31.843 --> 00:27:33.700
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, would someone like to make a motion?

202
00:27:36.595 --> 00:27:43.973
<v Olivia Clark>I would entertain a motion to send the ordinance document number 2026-133 to the full council with a recommendation to pass.

203
00:27:45.035 --> 00:27:45.615
<v Mitch Green>So moved.

204
00:27:46.146 --> 00:27:46.532
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>Second.

205
00:27:46.871 --> 00:27:47.355
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

206
00:27:48.079 --> 00:27:51.527
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, the, uh, measure has been moved and seconded.

207
00:27:51.640 --> 00:27:53.962
<v Olivia Clark>Moved by Councilor Smith, seconded by Councilor Koyama Lane.

208
00:27:54.059 --> 00:27:55.210
<v Loretta Smith>No, it wasn't moved by me.

209
00:27:55.534 --> 00:27:56.829
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, I'm sorry, sorry, I said Green.

210
00:27:56.911 --> 00:27:58.028
<v Olivia Clark>I'm sorry, misspoke.

211
00:27:58.207 --> 00:27:58.984
<v Olivia Clark>Excuse me.

212
00:27:59.713 --> 00:28:05.886
<v Olivia Clark>Um, so, uh, if there's no more discussion, uh, can the clerk please call the roll?

213
00:28:08.271 --> 00:28:08.429
<v Diego>Kanal.

214
00:28:10.226 --> 00:28:10.807
<v Diego>Koyama Lane?

215
00:28:11.343 --> 00:28:11.391
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

216
00:28:12.426 --> 00:28:12.702
<v Diego>Smith?

217
00:28:13.301 --> 00:28:13.528
<v Loretta Smith>No.

218
00:28:14.661 --> 00:28:14.887
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

219
00:28:15.390 --> 00:28:15.567
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

220
00:28:16.701 --> 00:28:17.009
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

221
00:28:17.575 --> 00:28:17.704
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

222
00:28:18.450 --> 00:28:29.114
<v Diego>With 3 ayes, 1 nay, and 1 absent, the motion carries, and the ordinance document number 2026-133 will move to the full council with a recommendation to pass.

223
00:28:31.606 --> 00:28:32.252
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Diego.

224
00:28:33.401 --> 00:28:35.229
<v Olivia Clark>Diego, can you please read the next item?

225
00:28:35.974 --> 00:28:51.493
<v Diego>Item 2, authorize water revenue bonds to finance water system capital improvements for an amount sufficient to produce net proceeds of up to $525 million and to refund outstanding water revenue bonds.

226
00:28:52.680 --> 00:28:53.339
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Diego.

227
00:28:53.421 --> 00:29:03.772
<v Olivia Clark>Committee members, we're going to receive some transportation infrastructure-related finance items that previously may have gone to the Finance Committee, but it's come to us today.

228
00:29:04.493 --> 00:29:06.432
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, the item is an example of that.

229
00:29:06.721 --> 00:29:12.361
<v Olivia Clark>Um, we'd like to authorize the issuance of the water revenue bonds to finance needed capital improvements.

230
00:29:12.489 --> 00:29:13.948
<v Olivia Clark>That's what's before us today.

231
00:29:14.587 --> 00:29:25.115
<v Olivia Clark>I've also invited, uh, City Administrator Lee to join us for this conversation and perhaps highlight, uh, this kind of practice since some of the— some of us may not be, uh, that versed in it.

232
00:29:25.980 --> 00:29:37.490
<v Olivia Clark>And because we have DCA Danipal and the Water Bureau here with us today, I've asked them to first provide us with a very brief update on the Bull Run filtration project and related financing.

233
00:29:38.099 --> 00:29:47.468
<v Olivia Clark>So we'll have the staff give us that brief update on, uh, the water filtration system and then pause for any committee questions before we move to the revenue bond issue.

234
00:29:48.288 --> 00:29:50.104
<v Olivia Clark>So DCA Danapal, would you like to begin?

235
00:29:50.939 --> 00:29:52.481
<v Priya Dhanapal>Uh, good morning, Chair Clark and councilors.

236
00:29:52.546 --> 00:29:56.048
<v Priya Dhanapal>Again, for the record, this is Priya Danapal, the Deputy City Administrator for Public Works.

237
00:29:57.267 --> 00:30:01.481
<v Priya Dhanapal>As Councilor Clark mentioned, we will be walking through the Build Run Filtration Project.

238
00:30:02.394 --> 00:30:03.469
<v Priya Dhanapal>Why is it required?

239
00:30:03.676 --> 00:30:05.743
<v Priya Dhanapal>How the project has evolved over the years?

240
00:30:06.257 --> 00:30:09.142
<v Priya Dhanapal>And how are we managing cost, schedule, and risk?

241
00:30:09.686 --> 00:30:20.391
<v Priya Dhanapal>This is a large and complex infrastructure project, and over time, both cost and schedule have changed as the design has advanced and the market conditions have shifted and the permitting processes were completed.

242
00:30:21.096 --> 00:30:28.459
<v Priya Dhanapal>Our focus is treating straightforward, which is to deliver a compliant and reliable system while managing cost and risk with discipline.

243
00:30:29.237 --> 00:30:29.867
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide, please.

244
00:30:35.230 --> 00:30:44.105
<v Priya Dhanapal>So today, uh, Public Portland Public Utilities Director Ting Lu will begin with why the filtration is required, followed by the project's evolution.

245
00:30:44.784 --> 00:30:50.737
<v Priya Dhanapal>We will then cover how we are actively managing risk with measures in place to maintain control of cost, schedule, and delivery.

246
00:30:51.412 --> 00:30:55.153
<v Priya Dhanapal>We will also cover how we are ensuring accountability and transparency for the project.

247
00:30:55.587 --> 00:31:05.577
<v Priya Dhanapal>And finally, Matt Gurak, our city's debt manager, will be walking through how the projects— projects like this are funded and the long-term financing approach that supports them.

248
00:31:06.107 --> 00:31:07.762
<v Priya Dhanapal>With that, I'll turn it over to Director Lu.

249
00:31:08.662 --> 00:31:10.220
<v Ting Lu>Thank you so much, DC Downapark.

250
00:31:10.285 --> 00:31:14.509
<v Ting Lu>Good morning, Chair Clark and Public Works Committee members.

251
00:31:14.928 --> 00:31:16.428
<v Ting Lu>For the record, my name is Ting Lu.

252
00:31:16.653 --> 00:31:21.090
<v Ting Lu>I'm the Public Utilities Director serving both Water Bureau and the BES.

253
00:31:21.881 --> 00:31:27.941
<v Ting Lu>So I'll begin with a brief overview of the Bow Run treatment projects with how they have evolved over time.

254
00:31:28.326 --> 00:31:28.939
<v Ting Lu>Next slide.

255
00:31:31.869 --> 00:31:32.804
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

256
00:31:35.210 --> 00:31:39.815
<v Ting Lu>Since 1895, the Bow Run watershed has been Portland's primary water source.

257
00:31:40.250 --> 00:31:43.175
<v Ting Lu>It has been the backbone for the region's health and economy.

258
00:31:43.922 --> 00:31:51.712
<v Ting Lu>Today, we are required to treat the water to meet federal regulations, and specifically the treatment is for Cryptosporidium.

259
00:31:52.321 --> 00:31:58.478
<v Ting Lu>Since 2017, the city has been under the binding legal agreement with Oregon Health Authority.

260
00:31:59.295 --> 00:32:04.520
<v Ting Lu>That is to establish both the requirement and also the timeline for the treatment.

261
00:32:05.386 --> 00:32:09.891
<v Ting Lu>This agreement explicitly directs the filtration as the type of the treatment.

262
00:32:10.019 --> 00:32:11.541
<v Ting Lu>So this is not optional.

263
00:32:12.375 --> 00:32:15.548
<v Ting Lu>City Council selected filtration as a treatment approach.

264
00:32:16.060 --> 00:32:21.653
<v Ting Lu>UV treatment was considered but was not providing the best defense for increasing risk.

265
00:32:22.391 --> 00:32:34.314
<v Ting Lu>Beyond meeting the regulatory requirement, filtration provides also the long-term resilience necessary to manage the impact of wildfire, extreme storm events, and also earthquakes.

266
00:32:34.809 --> 00:32:35.338
<v Ting Lu>Next slide.

267
00:32:37.777 --> 00:32:42.430
<v Ting Lu>When we talk about the Bull Run Treatment Project, it actually includes 3 components of that.

268
00:32:42.750 --> 00:32:48.670
<v Ting Lu>The first is a filtration facility that is providing the filtered water to meet the regulatory requirement.

269
00:32:49.070 --> 00:32:56.996
<v Ting Lu>The second piece is the 7 miles of a new pipeline that is connecting the filtration facility to the existing water distribution system.

270
00:32:57.509 --> 00:33:05.704
<v Ting Lu>The third is an improved corrosion control facility completed in 2022. to provide immediate lead reduction at the tap.

271
00:33:06.675 --> 00:33:15.135
<v Ting Lu>When the filtration facility goes live, the corrosion control treatment will be integrated as part of the filtration facility.

272
00:33:15.570 --> 00:33:21.961
<v Ting Lu>So together, these 3 components function as one system, and the project costs reflect all 3 together.

273
00:33:24.781 --> 00:33:25.324
<v Ting Lu>Next slide.

274
00:33:26.653 --> 00:33:42.630
<v Ting Lu>This one is a A little bit more complex, but the key takeaway of this slide is that projects progress in multiple stages with the increasing definition of scope and the increasing certainty in cost over the last few years.

275
00:33:43.222 --> 00:33:48.032
<v Ting Lu>In 2017, filtration was selected to meet the regulatory requirement.

276
00:33:48.432 --> 00:33:56.994
<v Ting Lu>At that point, key elements of a project such as site location, facility design, pipeline connections had not yet to be defined.

277
00:33:57.731 --> 00:34:05.873
<v Ting Lu>And then in 2018, Council made the foundational decision on all this additional component, allowing the project to move into design.

278
00:34:06.769 --> 00:34:17.362
<v Ting Lu>By 2021, as a preliminary design was completed, the project reached a more defined scope, and the cost estimate was refined based on the early engineering work.

279
00:34:17.987 --> 00:34:39.476
<v Ting Lu>In 2023 and 2024, as the design advanced and we have reached To the higher level of cost certainty, the city entered into guaranteed maximum price, or GMP, contracts, which established a ceiling price based on the detailed design and contractor bids, providing greater cost certainty moving forward.

280
00:34:39.989 --> 00:34:47.503
<v Ting Lu>And then last year, we all have aware of this required land use approval and also the policy in 2025.

281
00:34:48.418 --> 00:34:55.612
<v Ting Lu>So that's really the pause and the additional associated elements has been impacting the project cost and schedule.

282
00:34:56.329 --> 00:35:05.876
<v Ting Lu>So the land use permitting process has now been resolved with the permitting affirmed and upheld, including the LUBA decision in 2026.

283
00:35:06.215 --> 00:35:11.652
<v Ting Lu>This really provides us a legal ground and certainty for continued construction moving forward.

284
00:35:12.090 --> 00:35:12.494
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide.

285
00:35:14.963 --> 00:35:30.012
<v Ting Lu>We know it has been a complex project, and I'll walk with you all how the project evolved with respect to budget and schedule, including the transition from early conceptual estimate to greater cost certainty based on advanced design and marketing pricing.

286
00:35:32.329 --> 00:35:32.818
<v Priya Dhanapal>Next slide.

287
00:35:34.646 --> 00:35:37.307
<v Ting Lu>So this is our project budget evolution.

288
00:35:38.429 --> 00:35:42.648
<v Ting Lu>So along with the bottom lines are from the year from 2017 to today.

289
00:35:43.277 --> 00:35:46.494
<v Ting Lu>The bars are showing the project cost at each stage.

290
00:35:46.931 --> 00:35:52.867
<v Ting Lu>The labels at the bottom indicate the project phase and level of certainty at the cost estimate for each stage.

291
00:35:53.530 --> 00:36:02.835
<v Ting Lu>As we move from the left to the right, as the project progressed from planning to design to construction, the estimate become more defined and more reliable.

292
00:36:03.175 --> 00:36:06.121
<v Ting Lu>This is typical for large infrastructure projects.

293
00:36:07.760 --> 00:36:14.344
<v Ting Lu>As I mentioned, in 2017, the estimate was really conceptual, and that's about the $500 million under a regulatory timeline.

294
00:36:14.409 --> 00:36:14.505
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

295
00:36:16.539 --> 00:36:20.119
<v Ting Lu>Timeline before key elements of decision was defined.

296
00:36:20.730 --> 00:36:33.478
<v Ting Lu>As we advance to the design, including early engineering work in 2018 through 2021, the project scope become clear and the estimate was refined to approximately $1.5 billion.

297
00:36:34.635 --> 00:36:41.797
<v Ting Lu>By the time construction contracts were finalized in 2024, costs reflected actual market conditions.

298
00:36:42.262 --> 00:36:46.880
<v Ting Lu>Including labor and material pricing, reached approximately $2.1 billion.

299
00:36:48.036 --> 00:36:57.483
<v Ting Lu>At that stage, the city entered into the second guaranteed maximum pricing contract, which established ceiling price for us.

300
00:36:57.965 --> 00:37:02.985
<v Ting Lu>We then updated cost estimate to $2.6 billion this year.

301
00:37:03.900 --> 00:37:11.519
<v Ting Lu>This reflects the impact of permitting pause and schedule extension, along with updated contingencies for remaining the work.

302
00:37:12.114 --> 00:37:18.490
<v Ting Lu>So in summary, earlier estimates during the planning and early design phases were based on limited information.

303
00:37:18.925 --> 00:37:29.429
<v Ting Lu>And today, as we are moving to the construction phase, it provides a more reliable understanding and high confidence for the remaining costs to complete the project.

304
00:37:29.831 --> 00:37:35.838
<v Ting Lu>Other than major events like force majeure, remaining risks are intended to be managed within the project.

305
00:37:35.902 --> 00:37:36.030
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

306
00:37:40.190 --> 00:37:40.673
<v Loretta Smith>Contingencies.

307
00:37:41.028 --> 00:37:46.643
<v Ting Lu>And this slide shows the, um, tied with our compliance agreement with Oregon Health Authority.

308
00:37:47.161 --> 00:37:50.268
<v Ting Lu>The original completion target was 2027.

309
00:37:50.766 --> 00:37:51.989
<v Ting Lu>As the project moved through the—.

310
00:37:51.989 --> 00:37:52.969
<v Priya Dhanapal>Sorry, next slide, please.

311
00:37:54.481 --> 00:37:55.478
<v Ting Lu>Oh, yes.

312
00:37:55.751 --> 00:37:56.590
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

313
00:37:57.532 --> 00:38:04.336
<v Ting Lu>Um, as the project moved through the permitting, the construction started shifting from 2023 to 2024.

314
00:38:05.143 --> 00:38:09.324
<v Ting Lu>And then in addition, there was a temporary pause due to the land use appeal.

315
00:38:10.690 --> 00:38:14.514
<v Ting Lu>So this total delay resulted in 16 months of delay.

316
00:38:17.248 --> 00:38:20.661
<v Ting Lu>And that process has now been resolved, as I shared earlier.

317
00:38:21.128 --> 00:38:28.543
<v Ting Lu>Based on this impact, we requested and received approval from OHA to extend the completion date by 2 years.

318
00:38:28.675 --> 00:38:29.954
<v Ting Lu>So now it's 2029.

319
00:38:31.284 --> 00:38:42.923
<v Ting Lu>The updated schedule includes not only recovery of the time lost, but also approximately 8 months of contingency to managing remaining construction risk.

320
00:38:43.342 --> 00:38:49.474
<v Ting Lu>So the key point for this slide is that our current schedule is both realistic and achievable.

321
00:38:50.068 --> 00:38:56.411
<v Ting Lu>It ensures we maintain the highest safety standard as well as delivering a high-quality finished product.

322
00:38:59.766 --> 00:39:06.092
<v Ting Lu>Um, so we have looked at how the project has evolved to meet today's market realities and schedule changes.

323
00:39:06.686 --> 00:39:11.358
<v Ting Lu>Now I really want to focus on how we are protecting this investment moving forward.

324
00:39:11.664 --> 00:39:26.673
<v Ting Lu>Our priority is to managing the cost and schedule proactively, and a risk management and mitigation plan is designed to catch any potential issues early, giving us 2 tools to manage the unknowns and stay focused on the safe, successful delivery.

325
00:39:27.353 --> 00:39:27.918
<v Ting Lu>Next slide.

326
00:39:30.230 --> 00:39:33.210
<v Ting Lu>So we're— next slide, please.

327
00:39:34.273 --> 00:39:40.134
<v Ting Lu>We're using a proactive risk management strategy to protect the budget and keep construction moving.

328
00:39:40.809 --> 00:39:45.436
<v Ting Lu>This table shows the top 4 risks that we are actively tracking and managing.

329
00:39:46.030 --> 00:39:57.036
<v Ting Lu>Because of schedule delay, we're now resetting our project baselines to making sure we are holding contractors accountable for their deadlines, ensure every change is negotiated with clarity.

330
00:39:57.708 --> 00:40:08.458
<v Ting Lu>The second is we are analyzing the impact of a contractor's changes to prevent cost duplication and ensure that every firm remains financially responsible for their performance.

331
00:40:09.083 --> 00:40:16.469
<v Ting Lu>We are also optimizing our document and the workflow controls to making sure to manage the scale of this project.

332
00:40:17.318 --> 00:40:21.628
<v Ting Lu>We are preparing for the complex startup and commissioning phase early.

333
00:40:21.820 --> 00:40:21.949
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

334
00:40:22.126 --> 00:40:28.012
<v Ting Lu>To ensure that the completed facility delivers a high-quality project from day one.

335
00:40:29.096 --> 00:40:29.952
<v Ting Lu>Next slide, please.

336
00:40:32.889 --> 00:40:37.925
<v Ting Lu>So our risk mitigation strategies helps us to manage the unknowns of construction.

337
00:40:38.443 --> 00:40:50.817
<v Ting Lu>These actions are designed to maintain the control of cost and schedule, equally important to ensure visibility into that work and ensure we have accountability and transparency measures for the project.

338
00:40:50.871 --> 00:40:51.036
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

339
00:40:52.847 --> 00:40:56.347
<v Ting Lu>Now I'll provide our accountability and transparency measures.

340
00:40:57.583 --> 00:41:06.222
<v Ting Lu>So beyond our reporting schedules, we have built in multiple layers of expert oversight to act as a watchdog for our ratepayers.

341
00:41:06.976 --> 00:41:10.333
<v Ting Lu>These are just— these aren't just administrative checks.

342
00:41:10.413 --> 00:41:20.081
<v Ting Lu>They are specialized teams that are designed to challenge our assumptions, finding savings, And ensure every dollar is spent according to the contract.

343
00:41:20.788 --> 00:41:29.699
<v Ting Lu>By bringing in outside eyes and industry experts, we are adding a level of scrutiny that protects both the project future and community's investment.

344
00:41:30.960 --> 00:41:37.255
<v Ting Lu>So these are multiple layers from the early— before the construction starts, value engineering.

345
00:41:37.690 --> 00:41:42.307
<v Ting Lu>We have engaged 17 independent reviewers with industry experts.

346
00:41:42.456 --> 00:41:42.505
<v Matt Giurach>Wow.

347
00:41:43.143 --> 00:41:44.668
<v Ting Lu>For the filtration facility.

348
00:41:45.170 --> 00:41:50.217
<v Ting Lu>This work resulting more than $200 million plus in construction savings.

349
00:41:52.146 --> 00:42:03.231
<v Ting Lu>We have also established a Project Delivery Advisory Team, also called PDAT, which included experienced construction managers and members of Portland Utility Board members.

350
00:42:03.831 --> 00:42:19.880
<v Ting Lu>They are helping us to actively evaluating project construction staffing structure, risk communications, and operational readiness, and their findings are incorporated into the continuous improvement also bring to the PAB and the city leadership.

351
00:42:20.764 --> 00:42:35.867
<v Ting Lu>We have also engaged a team of independent claim analysts who scrutinize major change cost proposals, advise us on potential dispute, and ensure that every dollar claimed for change aligns with our contractual agreements.

352
00:42:36.574 --> 00:42:44.715
<v Ting Lu>This kind of expertise is really important to allow us to identify potential risks and prevent our cost overruns.

353
00:42:45.246 --> 00:42:59.827
<v Ting Lu>Right now, for example, the claim analyst team is doing independent assessment of a suspension cost schedule and scope change request to ensure contract compliance and advise on dispute resolution.

354
00:43:00.518 --> 00:43:09.398
<v Ting Lu>In addition, under the DCA's guidance, I have issued a directive to refresh project governance, ensure we have clear reporting and accountability.

355
00:43:10.219 --> 00:43:17.500
<v Ting Lu>Starting in March, these updates included detailed tracking of budget and schedule performance and risk mitigation measures.

356
00:43:18.163 --> 00:43:23.538
<v Ting Lu>I have also initiated a supply chain audit to identify any cost increase.

357
00:43:25.059 --> 00:43:31.007
<v Ting Lu>And in addition, we have the project update as a monthly update for schedule and construction.

358
00:43:36.289 --> 00:43:36.677
<v Ting Lu>Cost.

359
00:43:36.822 --> 00:43:49.367
<v Ting Lu>Um, on top of this, we're also adding another layer of accountability through establishment of independent financial oversight panel to provide truly external review and reinforce financial accountability.

360
00:43:49.947 --> 00:44:02.000
<v Ting Lu>I'll be bringing a draft implementation plan to the city administrator, deputy city administrator, and City Council for feedback with the goal of having the panel in place by summer.

361
00:44:05.170 --> 00:44:05.606
<v Ting Lu>Next slide.

362
00:44:07.608 --> 00:44:20.152
<v Ting Lu>Our commitment to accountability is reflected in a rigorous reporting structure that keeps city leaders, regulatory bodies, and general public informed at every stage of the project.

363
00:44:20.539 --> 00:44:30.248
<v Ting Lu>Since 2018, we have delivered a comprehensive annual report to to the City Council, providing a transparent record of operational progress.

364
00:44:30.985 --> 00:44:44.199
<v Ting Lu>We have also integrated a dedicated project status update to the monthly city update, ensuring council members have real-time visibility into current development since March 2026.

365
00:44:44.936 --> 00:44:51.559
<v Ting Lu>As far as the Public Portland Utility Board, we maintain a regular briefing with the pub members.

366
00:44:51.606 --> 00:44:51.815
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

367
00:44:52.152 --> 00:44:57.898
<v Ting Lu>Inviting project team members and delivery advisory teams to share updates on a regular basis.

368
00:44:58.556 --> 00:45:08.492
<v Ting Lu>For our communities and public, we have used a variety of traditional prints and also virtual outreach tools to connect with the communities and neighbors.

369
00:45:09.086 --> 00:45:19.713
<v Ting Lu>We have also launched a new website that including additional project information such as the cost, schedule data that will be updated on a monthly basis.

370
00:45:21.206 --> 00:45:27.706
<v Ting Lu>Finally, as a recipient of federal funding, we adhere to reporting requirements with EALONs.

371
00:45:28.014 --> 00:45:33.510
<v Ting Lu>This ensures that our project management meets a high federal standard for compliance and progress.

372
00:45:34.443 --> 00:45:43.300
<v Ting Lu>Together, this effort ensures that the project's actively monitored, transparently reported, and accountable at every stage of the delivery.

373
00:45:44.045 --> 00:45:47.268
<v Ting Lu>With that, I'll turn over back to DC Donapal to wrap us up.

374
00:45:48.150 --> 00:45:49.063
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you, Director Lew.

375
00:45:49.963 --> 00:45:56.606
<v Priya Dhanapal>Director Lew shared today how we are managing this important project end to end by the Water Bureau.

376
00:45:56.862 --> 00:46:01.579
<v Priya Dhanapal>To summarize, we have resolved the permitting challenges and established a clear path forward.

377
00:46:02.253 --> 00:46:08.704
<v Priya Dhanapal>We have a more defined and reliable understanding of the cost, which is grounded in advanced design and market pricing.

378
00:46:09.217 --> 00:46:14.014
<v Priya Dhanapal>We have an updated schedule that reflects both past impacts and a realistic plan for delivery.

379
00:46:14.833 --> 00:46:20.760
<v Priya Dhanapal>And we have strong systems in place for risk management, accountability, and transparency.

380
00:46:21.500 --> 00:46:25.034
<v Priya Dhanapal>And we are definitely operating with a time is money mindset.

381
00:46:25.132 --> 00:46:29.358
<v Priya Dhanapal>Every risk we mitigate is a direct active measure to keep the total cost down.

382
00:46:30.369 --> 00:46:41.217
<v Priya Dhanapal>The key message that we wanted to convey in this discussion today is that the project is now in a more controlled phase with the tools, oversight, and discipline needed to deliver it successfully.

383
00:46:41.666 --> 00:46:47.646
<v Priya Dhanapal>And with that, I'll pass it on to Matt Giurach to walk through how utility infrastructure is financed.

384
00:46:49.050 --> 00:46:50.576
<v Matt Giurach>Good morning, Public Works Committee.

385
00:46:51.331 --> 00:46:54.851
<v Matt Giurach>For the record, I'm Matt Giurach, debt manager in the Office of the CFO.

386
00:46:55.815 --> 00:47:00.646
<v Matt Giurach>I'm going to provide a quick overview of infrastructure funding and the bond authorization.

387
00:47:01.653 --> 00:47:02.271
<v Matt Giurach>Next slide, please.

388
00:47:05.349 --> 00:47:17.184
<v Matt Giurach>Infrastructure is generally funded through current revenues, also known as pay-as-you-go, issuance of revenue bonds for large projects, and also applying for and receiving grant funds.

389
00:47:18.228 --> 00:47:22.338
<v Matt Giurach>Depending on the city bureau, the mix of these different sources will vary.

390
00:47:22.932 --> 00:47:28.295
<v Matt Giurach>For the water system, the city typically utilizes ratepayer revenues and revenue bonds.

391
00:47:29.532 --> 00:47:47.402
<v Matt Giurach>The use of bonds provides the ability to finance large capital projects when immediate cash resources are not available, and also provides intergenerational equity as current ratepayers are not solely— are not solely responsible for funding projects that benefit multiple generations like the water treatment plant.

392
00:47:48.414 --> 00:48:05.990
<v Matt Giurach>It's notable that the use of revenue bonds also relies on the use of ratepayer revenues in order to repay the debt and interest, keeping the mix of pay-go funding and bonds at a healthy level is managed through long-term financial planning standards, which I'll discuss further on.

393
00:48:06.576 --> 00:48:07.128
<v Matt Giurach>Next slide, please.

394
00:48:11.610 --> 00:48:18.474
<v Matt Giurach>Next, I'll go over a little bit more in detail about utility revenue bonds that are typically used to finance water infrastructure.

395
00:48:19.958 --> 00:48:36.135
<v Matt Giurach>These are typically viewed as one of the lowest-risk bond investments from the perspective of investors and credit rating agencies because of the essential service nature of the water and sewer assets for livable communities and the financial separation of the ratepayer funds.

396
00:48:37.275 --> 00:48:44.195
<v Matt Giurach>Because of this, the bonds are usually in high demand and also benefit from strong credit ratings that reduce ongoing interest costs.

397
00:48:45.175 --> 00:49:01.340
<v Matt Giurach>The credit rating analysis of utility bonds also includes an evaluation of the general characteristics of the As you can see in the lower left-hand box, and also financial metrics as shown in the lower right-hand box.

398
00:49:02.489 --> 00:49:15.900
<v Matt Giurach>Performance under some of these evaluation factors are directly controlled by the city, most notably the financial metrics of cash on hand and operating income relative to debt service, which is also known as debt service coverage.

399
00:49:15.900 --> 00:49:15.940
<v Matt Giurach>Thank you.

400
00:49:17.257 --> 00:49:29.653
<v Matt Giurach>In addition, maintaining assets in good working order and minimizing deferred maintenance is a focus of evaluating operational management to ensure reliability and meeting regulatory compliance mandates.

401
00:49:30.204 --> 00:49:30.900
<v Matt Giurach>Next slide, please.

402
00:49:35.530 --> 00:49:42.346
<v Matt Giurach>This slide provides a summary of the city's water system revenue bonds that are used to finance water infrastructure improvements.

403
00:49:43.443 --> 00:50:00.945
<v Matt Giurach>The first lien bonds maintain the second highest possible credit ratings at AA1 and AA+ from Moody's and S&P respectively, and the second lien bonds a standard one notch lower at AA2 and AA, which are considered to be high quality and very low credit risk.

404
00:50:01.989 --> 00:50:11.751
<v Matt Giurach>Maintaining these high credit ratings has helped achieve a low interest rate for the water system of approximately 2.6% based on the public bonds currently outstanding.

405
00:50:13.213 --> 00:50:25.400
<v Matt Giurach>Utilities like the Portland Water Bureau maintain its credit ratings through long-term planning of water rates that are sufficient to meet its financial planning standards around debt service coverage and cash levels.

406
00:50:26.780 --> 00:50:33.605
<v Matt Giurach>The bureau also plans its rates in order to meet legal tests for issuing additional bonds under its existing bond legal documents.

407
00:50:34.507 --> 00:50:42.873
<v Matt Giurach>Which require current water system net income to be 110% of the future maximum annual debt service after a bond issuance.

408
00:50:43.594 --> 00:50:44.023
<v Matt Giurach>Next slide, please.

409
00:50:47.545 --> 00:50:54.398
<v Matt Giurach>The project is funded through a combination of revenue bonds and current revenues and will not entirely be funded with borrowing.

410
00:50:55.842 --> 00:50:59.103
<v Matt Giurach>At the newly revised project budget level, a total of roughly $2.

411
00:50:59.199 --> 00:51:06.842
<v Matt Giurach>$2.5 billion of bonds will be issued in order to meet project construction requirements and to fund other critical capital work.

412
00:51:07.804 --> 00:51:19.902
<v Matt Giurach>The city has already obtained $1 billion of bond funding through the federal WIFIA program, leaving roughly $1.5 billion remaining to be issued, inclusive of the 2026 bonds that we're discussing today.

413
00:51:20.943 --> 00:51:33.250
<v Matt Giurach>By 2029, when the project is completed, there will be roughly $2.9 billion of water revenue bonds outstanding, which is equivalent to 7.8 times projected annual water system revenues at that point in time.

414
00:51:34.646 --> 00:51:49.402
<v Matt Giurach>While this falls far from the AA median benchmark, credit rating agencies and investors understand that debt levels peak shortly after completing a significantly large project, with the expectation that revenues will continue to grow and debt will normalize over time.

415
00:51:49.547 --> 00:51:51.184
<v Olivia Clark>Next slide.

416
00:51:51.250 --> 00:51:53.105
<v Matt Giurach>Next slide.

417
00:51:55.800 --> 00:52:09.307
<v Matt Giurach>With the issuance of the project bonds through 2029, debt service paid by the water system is projected to ramp up significantly through fiscal year 2033, when the city's WIFIA bonds will begin to be repaid at that time.

418
00:52:10.467 --> 00:52:25.376
<v Matt Giurach>With debt service set to increase roughly threefold in a 7-year time frame, it will require sustained significant water rate increases from the current and future city councils to increase revenues in order to meet legal tests and the city's financial metrics.

419
00:52:26.380 --> 00:52:34.344
<v Matt Giurach>Different rate scenarios will result in different outcomes in terms of debt levels, financial metrics, and the pace of system reinvestment.

420
00:52:36.152 --> 00:52:53.023
<v Matt Giurach>At the new project budget, the projections will be reviewed by an independent third-party financial feasibility consultant prior to issuing the 2026 bonds to ensure that the projections are sound and the city can meet its obligation— obligations under the assumed water rate schedule.

421
00:52:54.260 --> 00:52:54.677
<v Matt Giurach>Next slide.

422
00:52:58.197 --> 00:53:16.005
<v Matt Giurach>This slide shows a base case scenario of expected water, sewer stormwater, and combined annual rate increases required to meet the mentioned financial requirements for the bonds and ensuring the Portland Water Bureau and the Bureau of Environmental Services can continue meeting its operating requirements.

423
00:53:17.018 --> 00:53:28.458
<v Matt Giurach>Under this scenario, water rates are anticipated to increase by 9.8% annually through fiscal year 2031 and then increase at a more moderate rate of around 6% per year.

424
00:53:29.791 --> 00:53:44.483
<v Matt Giurach>Because the sewer system is in a more stable period of capital financing, rate increases are projected to be lower, resulting in an effect— an effective combined utility rate increase of 5% by fiscal year 2032.

425
00:53:46.166 --> 00:53:46.668
<v Jonas Beery>Next slide.

426
00:53:47.865 --> 00:53:53.099
<v Matt Giurach>We'll conclude with a brief summary of the upcoming issuance of the 2026 bonds.

427
00:53:54.121 --> 00:53:59.692
<v Matt Giurach>The bonds will provide up to $525 million of proceeds for water system capital improvements.

428
00:53:59.740 --> 00:53:59.838
<v Matt Giurach>Thank you.

429
00:54:01.329 --> 00:54:11.028
<v Matt Giurach>Additionally, subject to market conditions, we'll be evaluating the refinancing of the Series 2016A water bonds for interest savings.

430
00:54:11.719 --> 00:54:18.735
<v Matt Giurach>At today's interest rates, the city could realize roughly $4 million of total savings from that refinancing.

431
00:54:18.911 --> 00:54:24.661
<v Matt Giurach>However, we will not know what the interest— we will not lock those interest rates until the actual bond sale.

432
00:54:26.233 --> 00:54:34.583
<v Matt Giurach>The bonds will be amortized over a 30-year repayment term and structured to satisfy the city's legal requirements for the additional bonds test.

433
00:54:35.931 --> 00:54:46.304
<v Matt Giurach>With the inclusion of the feasibility consultant report, the process will take approximately 12 to 16 weeks with an estimated closing of late July or early August.

434
00:54:47.572 --> 00:54:49.467
<v Matt Giurach>And that concludes the presentation.

435
00:54:49.597 --> 00:54:50.527
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

436
00:54:52.027 --> 00:54:52.527
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Matt.

437
00:54:52.672 --> 00:54:55.137
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, um, all of you for the presentation.

438
00:54:55.572 --> 00:55:01.597
<v Olivia Clark>Um, we've heard some of this before, but we took a little bit of a deeper dive actually today in the bonding.

439
00:55:02.175 --> 00:55:08.489
<v Olivia Clark>I would like to invite our City Administrator Lee to make a comment about what we've heard today, if you don't mind.

440
00:55:08.536 --> 00:55:14.500
<v Olivia Clark>And I know that this is very common across all local governments, and maybe you could address that.

441
00:55:14.612 --> 00:55:15.001
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

442
00:55:17.623 --> 00:55:20.092
<v Lee>Thank you, Vice President Clark.

443
00:55:20.333 --> 00:55:23.827
<v Lee>And I actually appreciate the invite to the conversation today.

444
00:55:24.117 --> 00:55:33.784
<v Lee>We had a great overview of kind of some of the initial thoughts and concepts as it relates to bonding overall.

445
00:55:34.521 --> 00:55:36.061
<v Lee>And I will share this first.

446
00:55:36.222 --> 00:55:38.402
<v Lee>Bonding is not good or bad or indifferent.

447
00:55:39.012 --> 00:55:49.001
<v Lee>I think it's really a tool that we use to really gain capital access to dollars that we need to truly move the city forward in a progressive fashion.

448
00:55:49.835 --> 00:56:21.407
<v Lee>When we're looking at some of the issues that we are faced as a city today, some of the financial issues that we see in our general fund, aging infrastructure as a city, and really trying to determine the long-term strategic direction as a city, bonding is going to be a tool that we use, or we should be using within our toolkit to help advance some of the capital infrastructure issues and challenges we are faced with as a community.

449
00:56:22.322 --> 00:56:27.340
<v Lee>A lot of communities have battled the question, should we do pay-as-you-go or bond?

450
00:56:27.757 --> 00:56:32.072
<v Lee>I think it's really built upon the makeup of the city and where they are financially.

451
00:56:32.568 --> 00:56:46.748
<v Lee>But when you have organizations like ourselves that are complex organizations with multifaceted operational pieces moving, funding becomes more of that, one of those critical tools to use to be able to move things forward.

452
00:56:47.326 --> 00:57:10.817
<v Lee>Keep in mind, there's 2 really main bonding sources that the city can use: revenue bonds, which we are describing today as a source, but also general obligation bonds that are typically paid through general fund revenues, our property taxes, or any other tax that may be coming in that supports our general fund.

453
00:57:11.121 --> 00:57:21.280
<v Lee>And I think when we're looking at this long-term as a city, we have to be strategic in how we build out our long-term capital improvement plan, CIP plan.

454
00:57:21.873 --> 00:57:38.471
<v Lee>And that is going to be a major tool to help guide council in some of the decision-making as we're looking at the different options we have to fund some of our aging infrastructure, but also new infrastructure in our city as our city continues to develop.

455
00:57:38.969 --> 00:57:49.726
<v Lee>So as we continue this conversation, I want to make sure that we're grounded in the work that needs to be done as it relates to building out our long-term capital improvement plan.

456
00:57:50.322 --> 00:57:53.931
<v Lee>And this is a bigger conversation than just water and sewer.

457
00:57:54.027 --> 00:57:57.007
<v Lee>This is also our transportation and PBOT.

458
00:57:57.329 --> 00:58:01.579
<v Lee>This is also looking at some of our environmental things as well.

459
00:58:02.304 --> 00:58:05.364
<v Lee>Also, capital could also be fleet and other equipment.

460
00:58:05.443 --> 00:58:05.507
<v Michael McGee>Yes.

461
00:58:05.936 --> 00:58:09.753
<v Lee>That also could be categorized into that equation as well.

462
00:58:10.346 --> 00:58:30.134
<v Lee>We just need to make sure as we are having this conversation that we are looking at all the tools that we have to address these issues, but also that we're doing things that build long-term stability financially and also in our actual hard assets as an organization.

463
00:58:30.550 --> 00:58:32.378
<v Lee>So I'm here for the conversation.

464
00:58:32.795 --> 00:58:41.592
<v Lee>I love to actually have this conversation because I think this is critical in where we are now as an organization and what we're trying to build for future Portland.

465
00:58:42.971 --> 00:58:44.668
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much for that, CA Lee.

466
00:58:44.893 --> 00:58:51.447
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate the perspective and grounding us, and it has been an excellent overview, excellent presentation.

467
00:58:52.023 --> 00:59:05.742
<v Olivia Clark>I have the sense that you didn't use the word asset management, but that's really what we're talking about, and we are very far behind I think in many respects in taking care of what we have across the city, and this is going to be our finance challenge.

468
00:59:06.865 --> 00:59:18.054
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate that this new form of government, I think there's going to be more accountability around how we do manage our assets and how we protect them and improve them, and new ones included.

469
00:59:18.344 --> 00:59:19.097
<v Olivia Clark>Mm-hmm.

470
00:59:20.074 --> 00:59:26.728
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's very important, however, that you did mention the independent financial oversight team.

471
00:59:27.451 --> 00:59:36.498
<v Olivia Clark>And I appreciate that and all of the other measures that you have put in place to address risk, cost overruns, whatever it is.

472
00:59:36.771 --> 00:59:39.418
<v Olivia Clark>I think you've put a very good structure in place.

473
00:59:39.882 --> 00:59:44.021
<v Olivia Clark>But I want to ask colleagues, bear with me, and then I'll turn it over to you.

474
00:59:44.150 --> 00:59:54.244
<v Olivia Clark>But I had the sense that we needed more than just that panel, that we need an outside independent analysis or audit of, of, uh, the Water Bureau.

475
00:59:54.403 --> 01:00:02.393
<v Olivia Clark>And you can, um, give me your feedback on that, particularly the last $450 million bump that which brings us to today.

476
01:00:03.086 --> 01:00:07.188
<v Olivia Clark>But I, I appreciate that you have put together an independent financial oversight team.

477
01:00:07.625 --> 01:00:12.974
<v Olivia Clark>But tell me, uh, if you think we need an, an outside audit, because I'm, I'm kind of leaning in that direction.

478
01:00:17.050 --> 01:00:19.836
<v Priya Dhanapal>I think Councilor Clark, that's a good question.

479
01:00:20.655 --> 01:00:29.248
<v Priya Dhanapal>This project has multiple layers of accountability measures in place, and the independent oversight panel will also help.

480
01:00:29.344 --> 01:00:37.262
<v Priya Dhanapal>But the one that you're asking is for an independent consultant to look into the work that we are doing, especially with respect to cost increases.

481
01:00:37.856 --> 01:00:41.518
<v Priya Dhanapal>And I'm assuming it's also for the work that is going to be moving forward.

482
01:00:42.016 --> 01:00:59.349
<v Priya Dhanapal>And typically that work Is done through an owner's advisory consultant who oversees the entire project and, you know, looking over the change orders that happen, reviewing any claims, and advising the city based on that.

483
01:00:59.750 --> 01:01:07.123
<v Priya Dhanapal>I think that is something that would be helpful for us to have, and that's something that we as a, you know, the Water Bureau is looking at it as well.

484
01:01:07.188 --> 01:01:17.170
<v Priya Dhanapal>And we've had conversations with the city administrator on making sure that We look into having an owner's advisory consultant to help us with this project overall.

485
01:01:17.637 --> 01:01:20.436
<v Lee>And I'd like to share some insight on this.

486
01:01:20.693 --> 01:01:37.498
<v Lee>On any major project of this magnitude, I know we have subject matter expertise that are within our bureaus that have the capability of managing it, but it's always a plus if you have the funding and the resources to have an owner's rep.

487
01:01:37.599 --> 01:01:37.840
<v Ting Lu>Yes.

488
01:01:38.112 --> 01:01:46.784
<v Lee>Who is looking at these bills that are coming in, coming through and checking it against what we said we were gonna actually pay for and do.

489
01:01:47.346 --> 01:01:54.057
<v Lee>That's a plus for us in our conversations as it relates to how we manage this project moving forward.

490
01:01:54.652 --> 01:02:19.418
<v Lee>As you look at adding another layer on top of this and looking at a potential audit of funds funds moving forward or going back, that's always something we can evaluate as well if we're seeing discrepancies in the information that we're seeing from the invoices that are coming through or the change orders that are happening as it relates to this project.

491
01:02:19.755 --> 01:02:38.067
<v Lee>And keep in mind, every change order as it relates to this project has to come through my office for my, uh, signature for review and, and consultant before we move forward with any change, uh, of the pricing or work that we say we're going to be performed as a part of this project.

492
01:02:38.789 --> 01:02:42.416
<v Lee>We could evaluate milestones in this as well.

493
01:02:43.106 --> 01:02:52.608
<v Lee>And when I say milestones, once we hit certain milestones, we have an independent review of what's happened and what has taken place during that time frame.

494
01:02:53.137 --> 01:02:59.137
<v Lee>That's something else that has been done previously before in projects of this magnitude and size.

495
01:02:59.570 --> 01:03:07.585
<v Lee>But the owner's rep is a best management practice across the board when it's related to projects of this size and magnitude.

496
01:03:08.467 --> 01:03:08.980
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for that.

497
01:03:09.027 --> 01:03:14.094
<v Olivia Clark>And so to date, we have not had an owner's rep. We're going to get an owner's rep now?

498
01:03:14.862 --> 01:03:18.422
<v Priya Dhanapal>We've had multiple, and I'll let Director Lew add to it.

499
01:03:18.485 --> 01:03:32.893
<v Priya Dhanapal>From my understanding, we've had multiple firms working on the project already, um, but, uh, advising us from an ownership capacity, um, but not one holistic consulting firm overlooking the whole project end to end.

500
01:03:33.262 --> 01:03:34.483
<v Priya Dhanapal>And I think that would be beneficial.

501
01:03:34.532 --> 01:03:41.474
<v Priya Dhanapal>We've had multiple teams looking at different sections of the project, but not one independent oversight.

502
01:03:42.003 --> 01:03:43.338
<v Lee>And that's what I would recommend.

503
01:03:43.385 --> 01:04:04.192
<v Lee>That's one of the first things when I came in I asked as we were looking at this project, do we have an owner's rep that is advising us, that is reviewing our invoices, that are looking at the plans, that are signing off on top of what our team is currently doing, just to provide that extra layer of protection for the city as a whole?

504
01:04:04.672 --> 01:04:09.483
<v Lee>Because in some of these owner reps' contracts, they take on some liability as well.

505
01:04:09.949 --> 01:04:13.349
<v Lee>So all liability is not just solely rested on the city.

506
01:04:14.342 --> 01:04:15.016
<v Olivia Clark>That's good to hear.

507
01:04:15.626 --> 01:04:31.920
<v Olivia Clark>I don't want to put words in your mouth, but I want to see if I understand what you're saying, that when we get— or we have an owner's rep, I think you're suggesting that we wait on an independent financial review until we get the owner's rep and we establish this process.

508
01:04:32.320 --> 01:04:32.947
<v Olivia Clark>Mm-hmm.

509
01:04:33.186 --> 01:04:39.009
<v Olivia Clark>I think what you're asking for is that we wait on that and that we come back and discuss that at another time.

510
01:04:39.746 --> 01:04:50.851
<v Lee>Yes, I would always say that's an option that we can keep for us as we have our owner's rep come in and kind of evaluate where we are in the process, really look at things that have taken place.

511
01:04:51.364 --> 01:04:57.612
<v Lee>I would also advise that that owner rep come to meetings like this to kind of talk about the project as well.

512
01:04:57.934 --> 01:05:09.126
<v Lee>And if council and this committee is seeing some discrepancies in the information that they're seeing and what is being reported out, Let's take a deeper dive into it and look at adding a different layer.

513
01:05:09.192 --> 01:05:25.391
<v Lee>Because I don't know currently right now if the project is budgeted for additional oversight over the owner's rep, and we would need to try to allocate some money outside of the project cost or increase the project cost for independent audit of it as well.

514
01:05:25.925 --> 01:05:32.038
<v Olivia Clark>Well, I just want to express my support for having that independent review, but I'm willing to wait.

515
01:05:32.135 --> 01:05:45.436
<v Olivia Clark>I want to hear from the other committee members as But I think we owe it to the public to have an owner's rep, to have very tight controls of this project because of the escalating costs and what that's going to do to our utility rates.

516
01:05:46.559 --> 01:05:46.766
<v Michael McGee>No doubt.

517
01:05:46.815 --> 01:05:48.097
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you for that comment.

518
01:05:48.146 --> 01:05:50.295
<v Olivia Clark>I hope you will stay while we have this conversation.

519
01:05:50.871 --> 01:05:52.331
<v Olivia Clark>I'm going to turn it over now.

520
01:05:52.411 --> 01:05:54.110
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for indulging me, colleagues.

521
01:05:54.175 --> 01:05:57.623
<v Olivia Clark>I'm going to turn it over to Councilor Green for his questions and comments.

522
01:05:58.409 --> 01:05:59.820
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Councilor Clark.

523
01:05:59.867 --> 01:06:06.855
<v Mitch Green>And I know that we've got— I think we've got a few people up for testimony, so I don't know if you want us to belay our questions until after testimony, or—.

524
01:06:06.918 --> 01:06:12.911
<v Olivia Clark>We actually haven't gotten to the, um, or actually that was the overview of the bond sale.

525
01:06:13.088 --> 01:06:15.155
<v Olivia Clark>I guess we can, um, go into it.

526
01:06:15.588 --> 01:06:17.494
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm happy to do it either way you want.

527
01:06:17.798 --> 01:06:18.248
<v Olivia Clark>Let's go ahead.

528
01:06:18.295 --> 01:06:25.554
<v Olivia Clark>And, and I just want to also mention that Councilor, um, Kanal has joined us online, um, and at the perfect timing.

529
01:06:26.371 --> 01:06:28.454
<v Olivia Clark>And we do have someone signed up to testify.

530
01:06:28.550 --> 01:06:32.724
<v Olivia Clark>Would you Do you want to speak before we have the testimony or have the testimony?

531
01:06:32.804 --> 01:06:38.536
<v Mitch Green>Maybe I'll just kind of ask some questions and then we can hear testimony and then based upon that, we can have a discussion.

532
01:06:38.969 --> 01:06:39.932
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, sounds good.

533
01:06:40.333 --> 01:06:43.882
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam Chair, Madam Vice President, whichever.

534
01:06:44.188 --> 01:06:45.407
<v Mitch Green>Well, you're wearing your chair hat right now.

535
01:06:46.210 --> 01:06:47.896
<v Mitch Green>Thanks so much for the presentation today.

536
01:06:48.925 --> 01:06:51.317
<v Mitch Green>Matt, thank you for your debt service projections.

537
01:06:51.735 --> 01:06:53.869
<v Mitch Green>You know, I like to get into the numbers myself.

538
01:06:54.963 --> 01:06:55.730
<v Mitch Green>I do have a couple questions.

539
01:06:55.778 --> 01:06:58.110
<v Mitch Green>Can you go to, uh, slide 21, please?

540
01:07:02.309 --> 01:07:02.471
<v Matt Giurach>Thank you.

541
01:07:02.519 --> 01:07:05.896
<v Mitch Green>So this is a helpful chart, and I just want to make sure I understand it.

542
01:07:05.978 --> 01:07:10.614
<v Mitch Green>So this is a chart that shows on the y-axis the annual debt service?

543
01:07:11.643 --> 01:07:12.639
<v Mitch Green>Okay, that's correct.

544
01:07:12.688 --> 01:07:19.989
<v Mitch Green>And it's the annual debt service from our existing bonds, our future non-WIFIA bonds in green, and then any other WIFIAs we've taken, right?

545
01:07:20.153 --> 01:07:20.483
<v Matt Giurach>That's correct.

546
01:07:20.751 --> 01:07:32.481
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so what I'm trying to wrap my mind around is presumably the green series that starts next year is the result of the action we take today.

547
01:07:32.563 --> 01:07:33.045
<v Mitch Green>Is that right?

548
01:07:33.286 --> 01:07:33.864
<v Matt Giurach>That's correct.

549
01:07:34.106 --> 01:07:43.840
<v Mitch Green>Okay, and so what I'm seeing is a steady escalation from 2027 through, looks like 2032, and it peaks.

550
01:07:45.981 --> 01:07:46.606
<v Michael McGee>Is that—.

551
01:07:46.739 --> 01:07:54.079
<v Matt Giurach>It looks like it goes, So we're trying to make sure it doesn't jump too much in any given year.

552
01:07:54.143 --> 01:07:59.297
<v Matt Giurach>So we're kind of smoothing our way up to a debt service level that's manageable.

553
01:07:59.362 --> 01:08:07.228
<v Mitch Green>So, you know, council would authorize $525 million, but you'd only issue so much over the course of the years to smooth that impact?

554
01:08:08.193 --> 01:08:17.887
<v Matt Giurach>This issuance would be issued all at once, and then we would be coming back to city council to get the authorization for the remaining billion dollars over time.

555
01:08:18.421 --> 01:08:18.939
<v Mitch Green>I see.

556
01:08:18.988 --> 01:08:30.935
<v Mitch Green>So this projection actually looks at, it's not just the $525, this is the sort of the full stack given what the GMP2 is and our current estimation.

557
01:08:31.016 --> 01:08:33.658
<v Mitch Green>Like those are all the future bonds we need to issue as well?

558
01:08:34.015 --> 01:08:34.358
<v Matt Giurach>Correct.

559
01:08:34.927 --> 01:08:40.809
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so then if you go to the next slide, I'm trying to figure that.

560
01:08:40.856 --> 01:08:43.130
<v Mitch Green>So I'm following what you're saying.

561
01:08:43.177 --> 01:08:59.037
<v Mitch Green>So what you're saying is based upon the assumptions in the previous slide, we know that the water rate needs to be raised on a sustained basis of 9.8% per year through 2031, but then it falls to 6%.

562
01:08:59.134 --> 01:09:12.030
<v Mitch Green>And I'm just having a difficult time sort of marrying that with the escalating debt service that plateaus at 168% on the previous slide.

563
01:09:12.095 --> 01:09:21.131
<v Mitch Green>So can you help me understand how we get from that discontinuity where we go from 9.8% down to 6% in 2031?

564
01:09:21.387 --> 01:09:22.783
<v Matt Giurach>That's a great question.

565
01:09:22.847 --> 01:09:24.083
<v Matt Giurach>Thank you, Councilor Green.

566
01:09:24.694 --> 01:09:25.625
<v Matt Giurach>Happy to clarify that.

567
01:09:25.993 --> 01:09:44.087
<v Matt Giurach>So on slide 21, that debt service schedule is only So as with the water system, the sewer system, other systems across the whole country, there are periodic issuances that kind of happen kind of continuously.

568
01:09:44.199 --> 01:09:49.787
<v Matt Giurach>So on that slide 21, that would be just the issuances through 2029.

569
01:09:50.685 --> 01:09:55.648
<v Matt Giurach>In order to just keep up with the cost of projected inflation and then future revenue bonds that will happen over time, we do have to keep up with that.

570
01:09:55.712 --> 01:10:04.015
<v Matt Giurach>So that's where rates will continue to need to increase over time to make sure that the water system's fully financially sustainable.

571
01:10:05.724 --> 01:10:05.871
<v Michael McGee>Okay.

572
01:10:07.341 --> 01:10:19.832
<v Mitch Green>So this slide that I'm looking at right now, is that just looking at debts issued through 2029, or is this sort of— no, this is what we expect the impact to be through the full array?

573
01:10:20.942 --> 01:10:24.038
<v Matt Giurach>This would be through 2036.

574
01:10:24.103 --> 01:10:28.587
<v Matt Giurach>So this is like just the longer-term projections of the Water Bureau.

575
01:10:29.069 --> 01:10:33.470
<v Matt Giurach>So in addition to whatever would be issued through 2029.

576
01:10:34.179 --> 01:10:43.563
<v Matt Giurach>So slide 21 is mostly focused on the debt issued to fully fund the project and then the other capital work that occurs through 2029.

577
01:10:43.675 --> 01:10:51.082
<v Matt Giurach>This slide is more focused on just the longer-term projections okay.

578
01:10:51.872 --> 01:10:55.981
<v Mitch Green>So this does have the impact of the Bull Run Filtration Project in it?

579
01:10:56.787 --> 01:10:57.384
<v Matt Giurach>That's correct.

580
01:10:57.432 --> 01:11:01.105
<v Mitch Green>Including all the WIFIA balloon stuff that starts in 2035?

581
01:11:01.685 --> 01:11:02.038
<v Matt Giurach>Correct.

582
01:11:02.328 --> 01:11:02.489
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

583
01:11:02.762 --> 01:11:06.609
<v Mitch Green>It cuts off at 2035, so I don't know if it goes back up after that.

584
01:11:07.891 --> 01:11:11.430
<v Matt Giurach>I would have to defer to the Water Bureau finance staff on that one.

585
01:11:12.338 --> 01:11:12.599
<v Matt Giurach>Okay.

586
01:11:13.029 --> 01:11:13.381
<v Matt Giurach>Thank you.

587
01:11:13.880 --> 01:11:16.430
<v David McEldowney>Thank you.

588
01:11:17.311 --> 01:11:25.185
<v Mitch Green>You know, riffing off of something that the city administrator mentioned, you know, it is important that we invest in our assets, and it is a common tool to use debt to do so.

589
01:11:26.548 --> 01:11:39.059
<v Mitch Green>I just, I think the thing that I'm increasingly having a hard time with is just squaring with the cumulative impact on the water bill just from the status quo right now.

590
01:11:39.298 --> 01:11:46.655
<v Mitch Green>And if we issue, if we approve these bills today, we are basically committing to doubling the water bill in under 8 years.

591
01:11:47.738 --> 01:11:50.854
<v Mitch Green>That's the cumulative impact of 9.8% per year.

592
01:11:50.903 --> 01:11:56.490
<v Mitch Green>So if you take the rule of 72, you divide it by 9.8, you get 7.35 years.

593
01:11:57.634 --> 01:12:02.292
<v Mitch Green>And in the work session slides, the average water bill is $72 per month.

594
01:12:02.792 --> 01:12:08.966
<v Mitch Green>So that would mean that 7 and a third years from now, the average water bill is $133 per month.

595
01:12:09.548 --> 01:12:10.305
<v Mitch Green>So that's my math.

596
01:12:10.659 --> 01:12:13.122
<v Mitch Green>That's the math that I think folks in the community might be doing.

597
01:12:13.975 --> 01:12:18.484
<v Mitch Green>I'm not saying that we should defund our Public Works, our Water Bureau.

598
01:12:18.532 --> 01:12:19.451
<v Mitch Green>I'm absolutely not saying that.

599
01:12:19.515 --> 01:12:28.666
<v Mitch Green>But I am cautious to say yes to a $525 million issuance that then locks us into that.

600
01:12:28.762 --> 01:12:36.279
<v Mitch Green>Because what I'm— what I think I'm seeing here is that if we were to— the 9.8% per year is a function of us approving these $525 million.

601
01:12:36.466 --> 01:12:39.033
<v Mitch Green>Today, plus some others in the debt service plan.

602
01:12:39.836 --> 01:12:43.832
<v Mitch Green>So if we did not approve these today, we would not be facing a 9.8% debt service.

603
01:12:43.944 --> 01:12:47.988
<v Mitch Green>I mean, of course we would have other consequences we need to talk through, but that's the way I'm reading it.

604
01:12:49.384 --> 01:12:52.239
<v Ting Lu>Can I add some clarification here, Councilor Green?

605
01:12:52.689 --> 01:13:08.600
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, so first I want to clarify this chart is showing the rate projections for the current service level, so it's a 9.8%, but if it's— we are going to like a Scenario 2 was the forecasted previous rate, and then the rate will be going down.

606
01:13:08.649 --> 01:13:11.229
<v Ting Lu>So that's the first clarification I want to make.

607
01:13:11.293 --> 01:13:11.518
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah.

608
01:13:11.597 --> 01:13:28.376
<v Ting Lu>The second clarification for this is the bond is not only for this additional $450 million, but it's for the entire additional cost for the filtration project beyond what the WIFIA loan has provided, plus additional capital project for the Water Bureau.

609
01:13:28.457 --> 01:13:31.341
<v Ting Lu>So that's the whole portfolio of a project.

610
01:13:31.485 --> 01:13:38.939
<v Ting Lu>Obviously, the filtration treatment is a big part of the capital project, but that's the entire 5-year project cost.

611
01:13:39.518 --> 01:13:40.880
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I appreciate that.

612
01:13:40.944 --> 01:13:42.546
<v Mitch Green>And that's really important to level set.

613
01:13:42.692 --> 01:13:57.988
<v Mitch Green>That reminds me that I did want to ask, so the title of the bond issuance is really about the, you know, in the sort of term sheet, it says this is for the water filtration plant, but then it also says as refunding action for 2016 bonds.

614
01:13:58.037 --> 01:14:03.256
<v Mitch Green>So is there some part of this that just refinances some previous bonds?

615
01:14:04.363 --> 01:14:06.595
<v Matt Giurach>That would be connected to this.

616
01:14:06.692 --> 01:14:08.715
<v Matt Giurach>So it would be outside of the 525.

617
01:14:08.779 --> 01:14:11.396
<v Matt Giurach>The 525 is just for the new money proceeds.

618
01:14:11.670 --> 01:14:20.469
<v Matt Giurach>And then the 2016 bonds, those would just be refunded assuming that there's advantageous interest rates that achieve savings at that time.

619
01:14:22.604 --> 01:14:54.002
<v Mitch Green>Okay, uh, I just wanted to note that in the financial impact statement for the ordinance, it, it reads that, um, and this is important for the transparency to our, to our community, that, um, including all water system debt issuance through fiscal year '29, annual debt service is expected to grow from $55.6 million in fiscal year 2026 to $168 million thank you.

620
01:14:54.243 --> 01:15:04.103
<v Mitch Green>And so not everyone can get that from reading a bar chart like this, but it's something that I don't want us to gloss over as we're having this discussion.

621
01:15:04.150 --> 01:15:06.734
<v Mitch Green>I know that there's people watching us very closely.

622
01:15:06.798 --> 01:15:08.207
<v Mitch Green>Affordability is top of mind.

623
01:15:08.256 --> 01:15:14.087
<v Mitch Green>And so we have to balance, we have to figure out how to balance the investments in our system and ask the questions of whether or not there are alternatives.

624
01:15:16.078 --> 01:15:21.585
<v Mitch Green>With what we are leaving to future councils, future mayors, and our ratepayers.

625
01:15:22.179 --> 01:15:32.052
<v Mitch Green>I have said previously, to be fair, that the way that you grow out of this cost disease is by growing and developing and adding more ratepayers to our region.

626
01:15:32.614 --> 01:15:33.850
<v Mitch Green>That's what we absolutely must do.

627
01:15:34.123 --> 01:15:34.300
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

628
01:15:34.862 --> 01:15:41.380
<v Mitch Green>Whether or not we can double our residents inside the City of Portland to offset this impact inside of a decade is that remains to be seen.

629
01:15:41.444 --> 01:15:43.368
<v Mitch Green>And that's what we should strive to do every single day.

630
01:15:44.252 --> 01:15:50.108
<v Mitch Green>I just worry that the rate at which we are going to increase the water bill because of this debt service cuts against that.

631
01:15:50.524 --> 01:15:51.728
<v Mitch Green>So there's an interactive effect.

632
01:15:51.775 --> 01:15:53.894
<v Mitch Green>So I think I'll leave my comments there for now.

633
01:15:54.376 --> 01:15:59.028
<v Mitch Green>I'm curious to have this kind of back and forth and then hear from the public.

634
01:15:59.109 --> 01:16:01.386
<v Mitch Green>And then I think we've probably got plenty of time for discussion.

635
01:16:01.819 --> 01:16:02.140
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

636
01:16:02.462 --> 01:16:05.846
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Carmelo, do you mind if I just riff a little bit on Councilor Green?

637
01:16:07.274 --> 01:16:18.198
<v Olivia Clark>We are going to be— I think this committee will be confronted at some point with the discussion of the rate increase, and I do not foresee us going to this rate.

638
01:16:18.518 --> 01:16:22.543
<v Olivia Clark>I'm just putting a little stake in the ground now.

639
01:16:23.137 --> 01:16:24.068
<v Olivia Clark>We're not going this high.

640
01:16:24.837 --> 01:16:26.201
<v Olivia Clark>We can't.

641
01:16:26.762 --> 01:16:28.158
<v Olivia Clark>And that's going to rework this chart.

642
01:16:29.474 --> 01:16:39.438
<v Olivia Clark>So just to presage that, folks, we're going to be discussing the rates at a different maybe I see Jonas in the back.

643
01:16:39.533 --> 01:16:40.000
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know we're—.

644
01:16:40.033 --> 01:16:48.057
<v Olivia Clark>We are just nodding yes, we are going to review the rates at some point, and we will have a decision to make, just like this committee did last year as well.

645
01:16:49.453 --> 01:16:53.621
<v Olivia Clark>Are you suggesting that the rates are going to go up after 2035, that we should see that?

646
01:16:54.261 --> 01:17:03.653
<v Mitch Green>Well, I'm suggesting that in the financial impact statement for this ordinance, it says the interest okay.

647
01:17:03.782 --> 01:17:05.832
<v Mitch Green>And so that won't start compounding until that year.

648
01:17:06.220 --> 01:17:11.323
<v Mitch Green>And so you see that actually in the bar chart for the gray series.

649
01:17:11.389 --> 01:17:21.842
<v Mitch Green>I think you see it jump from a pretty de minimis amount to a substantial piece, almost as large as our current debt service.

650
01:17:22.180 --> 01:17:26.226
<v Mitch Green>And so that grows and that doesn't really fall off until 2065.

651
01:17:26.958 --> 01:17:27.712
<v Mitch Green>So that's what I'm saying.

652
01:17:28.371 --> 01:17:28.692
<v Olivia Clark>I hear you.

653
01:17:28.804 --> 01:17:29.975
<v Matt Giurach>It's on the prior slide.

654
01:17:30.216 --> 01:17:32.574
<v Olivia Clark>There are so many unknowns.

655
01:17:33.280 --> 01:17:36.521
<v Olivia Clark>We don't know what the bond market will be like then.

656
01:17:36.715 --> 01:17:38.351
<v Olivia Clark>We don't know what interest rates will be then.

657
01:17:38.416 --> 01:17:40.694
<v Olivia Clark>So it's kind of hard to predict out that far.

658
01:17:41.865 --> 01:17:45.091
<v Olivia Clark>But we will come back to the rate discussion at a different time.

659
01:17:45.154 --> 01:17:48.701
<v Olivia Clark>Did you want to add a note, Jonas, before we continue our discussion?

660
01:17:49.021 --> 01:17:50.305
<v Jonas Beery>Thank you, Councilor.

661
01:17:50.354 --> 01:17:52.921
<v Jonas Beery>For the record, Jonas Beery, the city's chief financial officer.

662
01:17:53.242 --> 01:17:54.639
<v Jonas Beery>Yeah, I just wanted to reinforce yes.

663
01:17:54.703 --> 01:18:04.867
<v Jonas Beery>For the public record that yes, there will be a separate rate ordinance that comes back at which council will authorize whatever rate increase you decide for fiscal '26-'27.

664
01:18:08.800 --> 01:18:22.608
<v Jonas Beery>If, and maybe when is what I'm hearing, but if that rate projection is lower than what's projected here, then this team, the debt team, will have to manage the issuance, the structure, and the forecast within that rate increase that council authorizes.

665
01:18:22.672 --> 01:18:24.345
<v Jonas Beery>So I just wanna be clear about that, that that's not making— that this is not making that rate decision today.

666
01:18:26.932 --> 01:18:33.704
<v Jonas Beery>Today, it presages sort of those expectations, but also just acknowledging that they're not— there's some flexibility, right?

667
01:18:33.769 --> 01:18:47.146
<v Jonas Beery>That if Council ultimately comes back and approves a different rate that puts this on a different trajectory, that has trade-offs to the amount that maybe can be issued and how that folds through the project and the future impacts and projections.

668
01:18:47.243 --> 01:18:51.082
<v Jonas Beery>But it isn't like a hard stop to this authorization.

669
01:18:51.131 --> 01:18:52.115
<v Jonas Beery>It would just create a different—.

670
01:18:52.115 --> 01:18:52.180
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>Yeah.

671
01:18:53.444 --> 01:18:55.547
<v Jonas Beery>Constraint that that issuance would need to work within.

672
01:18:55.707 --> 01:18:56.703
<v Olivia Clark>All right, thank you, Jonas.

673
01:18:56.881 --> 01:18:59.707
<v Mitch Green>Wait, because Jonas is up here, can I just follow up?

674
01:18:59.771 --> 01:19:01.891
<v Mitch Green>Sorry, I just want to be clear.

675
01:19:03.161 --> 01:19:18.868
<v Mitch Green>If we approve an action that creates a debt service obligation and then we approve a rate proposal that doesn't validate or meet that debt service obligation, i.e., if we say, well, we're going to limit our rate increase, does that cut against our credit rating?

676
01:19:19.126 --> 01:19:22.447
<v Mitch Green>Because our credit rating is a function of our willingness to raise our rates to satisfy our debts, right?

677
01:19:22.654 --> 01:19:23.810
<v Jonas Beery>Yeah, Councilor, it's a great question.

678
01:19:23.859 --> 01:19:42.131
<v Jonas Beery>I mean, at the end of the day, we, and really Matt Giurach and the debt management team, would manage the issuance to make sure that we're— this is why I say the trade-off would probably be downsizing to make sure that we're not going past a level of prudent management vis-à-vis those rate expectations.

679
01:19:42.628 --> 01:19:57.859
<v Jonas Beery>It would be also worth noting that it is, For City of Portland, for all cities that issue this kind of debt, as CA Lee described, that council elected body willingness to increase rates is a large credit positive.

680
01:19:58.296 --> 01:20:11.318
<v Jonas Beery>And so that is something that's considered by the rating agencies when they provide that rating is the, you know, in a complex matrix of all the things they consider, including affordability impacts that this council's and ourselves are interested in.

681
01:20:11.764 --> 01:20:15.939
<v Jonas Beery>That is part of that matrix as well, is that willingness to increase rates to support the capital needs.

682
01:20:16.942 --> 01:20:20.863
<v Olivia Clark>It is a bit of a Gordian knot, isn't it, how all these things are connected?

683
01:20:21.568 --> 01:20:22.845
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Koyama Lane.

684
01:20:26.930 --> 01:20:27.756
<v Priya Dhanapal>Thank you, Chair Clark.

685
01:20:27.837 --> 01:20:29.021
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you everyone for being here.

686
01:20:29.801 --> 01:20:30.887
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That was helpful to hear.

687
01:20:31.261 --> 01:20:36.350
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I had a question just about the cumulative impact of rate and fee increases.

688
01:20:37.109 --> 01:20:41.615
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So appreciate that it's on the radar of many of, of the folks up here.

689
01:20:42.163 --> 01:20:49.024
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, one of my questions is around grants and if the city's been able to apply for any to offset project costs.

690
01:20:49.493 --> 01:20:56.649
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are we lobbying at all for this at the federal, state level, uh, maybe even with local partners who are in similar positions?

691
01:20:56.761 --> 01:20:57.729
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can anyone speak to that?

692
01:21:01.342 --> 01:21:03.655
<v Ting Lu>I— yeah, I can speak about that.

693
01:21:03.770 --> 01:21:05.707
<v Ting Lu>That's part of how we manage rates.

694
01:21:06.170 --> 01:21:19.800
<v Ting Lu>So there's multiple ways we're managing rates from cost management, what we talk about the project cost management to CIP project, prioritizing the CIP to really committing to seeking external funding opportunities.

695
01:21:19.912 --> 01:21:21.645
<v Ting Lu>And Councilor, that's what you are asking.

696
01:21:22.094 --> 01:21:27.882
<v Ting Lu>So we have the 2 WIFIA loans and we have also get the grants from Energy Trust of Oregon.

697
01:21:28.011 --> 01:21:36.686
<v Ting Lu>So we are— the funding landscape is not very optimistic right now, but we are continuing exploring and looking to both the federal and state.

698
01:21:36.734 --> 01:21:36.926
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

699
01:21:38.137 --> 01:21:40.731
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

700
01:21:40.813 --> 01:21:44.395
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>How many— so how many grants has the city applied for specifically?

701
01:21:44.476 --> 01:21:46.244
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Are you able to share that for this project?

702
01:21:47.231 --> 01:21:55.050
<v Ting Lu>I know for the 2 WIFIA loans, and I don't have the number, but happy to follow up with you on the grants part.

703
01:21:55.292 --> 01:21:55.872
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That would be great.

704
01:21:55.935 --> 01:21:56.516
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you so much.

705
01:21:58.100 --> 01:21:59.654
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

706
01:21:59.770 --> 01:22:02.373
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith, did you have your hand up?

707
01:22:02.569 --> 01:22:03.909
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, ma'am.

708
01:22:03.909 --> 01:22:05.109
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you so much.

709
01:22:07.310 --> 01:22:19.960
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I have some of the same concerns that, um, Councilman Green has about putting this extra debt on the ratepayers.

710
01:22:20.289 --> 01:22:27.210
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, the other issue I was thinking about when I was reading through your information, you said something about green bonds.

711
01:22:27.210 --> 01:22:28.350
<v Loretta Smith>What is that?

712
01:22:31.599 --> 01:22:32.371
<v Matt Giurach>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

713
01:22:32.418 --> 01:22:33.832
<v Matt Giurach>That's a great question.

714
01:22:34.493 --> 01:22:48.059
<v Matt Giurach>Green bonds are— it's a marketing tool where some bond investors will prefer to purchase bonds that relate to a project that are, you know, green-focused.

715
01:22:48.108 --> 01:22:55.067
<v Matt Giurach>So something that really improves the environment or delivers, you know, quality drinking water Mm-hmm.

716
01:22:55.179 --> 01:22:59.554
<v Matt Giurach>So it's a marketing tool that issuers will periodically use.

717
01:23:00.274 --> 01:23:05.996
<v Matt Giurach>It's most commonly used for taxable bonds, for taxable projects.

718
01:23:06.043 --> 01:23:07.983
<v Matt Giurach>That's where we see like a financial benefit.

719
01:23:08.304 --> 01:23:08.608
<v Matt Giurach>Okay.

720
01:23:09.168 --> 01:23:19.280
<v Matt Giurach>For tax-exempt bonds like these, there typically is not a financial benefit, but we wanted to kind of leave that option open in case there looks to be some sort of benefit to marketing the bonds as green bonds.

721
01:23:19.489 --> 01:23:23.262
<v Loretta Smith>The backend stuff to be able to sell the bonds very quickly?

722
01:23:24.740 --> 01:23:28.242
<v Matt Giurach>It's to increase investor demand potentially.

723
01:23:28.289 --> 01:23:40.975
<v Matt Giurach>So if you're able to garner orders from bond funds that specialize in holding green bonds for their investors, perhaps you can get additional orders in that regard.

724
01:23:41.362 --> 01:23:41.762
<v Olivia Clark>Right.

725
01:23:43.112 --> 01:24:07.453
<v Loretta Smith>We, me and DCA Priya, Donna Paul talked a little bit about the type of, um, bond companies that we use, and I want to go further, um, um, CA Lee, in regards to creating a minority bond, uh, table.

726
01:24:08.614 --> 01:24:11.661
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, we did something like this a little bit at, at the county.

727
01:24:12.256 --> 01:24:18.609
<v Loretta Smith>I know we don't have a lot of those companies like they do in Chicago and other places.

728
01:24:19.271 --> 01:24:32.266
<v Loretta Smith>But I think as we're talking about using these resources and making sure that— because people, I mean, this is a— in addition to creating this infrastructure, it is people are making money.

729
01:24:33.810 --> 01:24:38.618
<v Loretta Smith>And I don't want just minority communities just to make money on construction.

730
01:24:39.261 --> 01:24:42.104
<v Loretta Smith>Because there's money on the other side, lots of money on the other side.

731
01:24:42.939 --> 01:24:54.837
<v Loretta Smith>And I want us to be just as diligent about working with minority contractors as we are when we contract out our bond companies and who we're talking to and who does that.

732
01:24:55.463 --> 01:25:02.238
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I briefly talked to, um, uh, Prosper Portland about this as well because they actually do the same thing too.

733
01:25:02.865 --> 01:25:11.845
<v Loretta Smith>So I will double back on this And, um, thank you for engaging me in the conversation this weekend because I, I brought it up to you at an Earth Day event.

734
01:25:12.443 --> 01:25:14.639
<v Loretta Smith>So, so thank you a lot.

735
01:25:14.864 --> 01:25:23.033
<v Loretta Smith>Um, the other thing is, um, I'm concerned right now.

736
01:25:23.082 --> 01:25:25.997
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not troubled, and that's a good thing for everyone.

737
01:25:26.126 --> 01:25:35.932
<v Loretta Smith>I'm not troubled, but I am concerned About the type of money that we're bonding out for, for this project.

738
01:25:36.413 --> 01:25:44.877
<v Loretta Smith>I was not happy to learn about the $500 million in new, um, uh, uh, uh, expenditure for this project.

739
01:25:45.631 --> 01:26:01.359
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'm— when I'm, when I'm looking at this and I was trying to figure out which projects for, for $530 million, it did not, um, desegregate what projects are going to be done within this, um, to, to bind?

740
01:26:01.422 --> 01:26:04.429
<v Loretta Smith>What is this $530 million paying for?

741
01:26:05.603 --> 01:26:12.628
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I didn't see specifically, you just said the filtration project, so I don't know what in the filtration project are you paying for.

742
01:26:13.338 --> 01:26:21.938
<v Loretta Smith>So that would help me get a better idea before I can say, you know, yeah, let's go bond for this, you guys.

743
01:26:22.988 --> 01:26:30.193
<v Loretta Smith>I know we did not have, and I agree with the chair, we do need to have an owner's rep.

744
01:26:30.775 --> 01:26:33.735
<v Loretta Smith>I know we had an owner's rep on the Sellwood Bridge.

745
01:26:33.930 --> 01:26:38.344
<v Loretta Smith>It was a $330 million project, and that went well.

746
01:26:38.601 --> 01:26:42.471
<v Loretta Smith>It went under budget, and it was on time.

747
01:26:42.586 --> 01:26:43.712
<v Loretta Smith>It was before time.

748
01:26:44.300 --> 01:26:46.078
<v Loretta Smith>I still like to take credit for that.

749
01:26:46.730 --> 01:26:47.384
<v Eric Zimmerman>But—.

750
01:26:48.247 --> 01:26:58.027
<v Loretta Smith>So it, it's important for me to, to wrap my arms around what this new $530 million is paying for.

751
01:26:58.971 --> 01:27:06.314
<v Loretta Smith>Is it like, oh, if this happens, we, we'll have the money on hand and we won't have to come and ask council for new money?

752
01:27:07.051 --> 01:27:08.574
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I, I don't know.

753
01:27:08.990 --> 01:27:10.770
<v Loretta Smith>Could you give me an idea of what that looks like?

754
01:27:10.899 --> 01:27:20.407
<v Olivia Clark>Would it be helpful to go back to the slide that shows the 3 different components and then discuss maybe some of the costing, what we attribute the cost increases to.

755
01:27:20.454 --> 01:27:22.154
<v Olivia Clark>Would that be possible?

756
01:27:22.219 --> 01:27:30.829
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, I think that slide, we can go back to that slide and I can add additional details about what is exactly the $450 million include there.

757
01:27:31.599 --> 01:27:44.203
<v Priya Dhanapal>And I, before you talk about that, one thing I do want to mention to this committee is that the $450 million cost increase, a good majority of it was beyond the control of the city.

758
01:27:44.283 --> 01:27:51.805
<v Priya Dhanapal>It was because of external influences from the remand itself and the land use decisions and the schedule impacts as a result.

759
01:27:52.206 --> 01:27:54.948
<v Priya Dhanapal>And I wanted to make sure that is set on the record.

760
01:27:55.011 --> 01:27:59.470
<v Priya Dhanapal>And I'll pass it on to Director Lu to talk more about the breakdown.

761
01:28:00.079 --> 01:28:04.842
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, 'cause I had the same question when I first understanding the budget request.

762
01:28:05.212 --> 01:28:09.252
<v Ting Lu>So the $450,000 really break Up into 4 categories.

763
01:28:09.684 --> 01:28:18.030
<v Ting Lu>The first one, like DC Downer-Paul said, is because of the land use-related suspension and all this work that previously has happened.

764
01:28:18.095 --> 01:28:24.728
<v Ting Lu>That's the 5 months of the construction pause, which leads to the 7 months of the delay for the project.

765
01:28:25.208 --> 01:28:31.088
<v Ting Lu>And early on, we also have 9 months of a complex permitting land use late start.

766
01:28:31.136 --> 01:28:32.242
<v Ting Lu>So that's 16 months.

767
01:28:32.289 --> 01:28:32.417
<v Ting Lu>Mm-hmm.

768
01:28:32.835 --> 01:28:37.784
<v Ting Lu>There is a lot of suspension costs because we still have to have the cranes and everything on site.

769
01:28:38.057 --> 01:28:44.078
<v Ting Lu>So that's the big part of the cost increase as part of this for $50 million.

770
01:28:45.088 --> 01:28:58.957
<v Ting Lu>Additionally, the second category is about the support costs related to the suspension costs, including the Bureau additional costs to making sure we can manage this project, as well as like I mentioned about the claim team.

771
01:28:59.006 --> 01:29:05.475
<v Ting Lu>So we are exploring, we are adding the additional independent claim team to look into managing the project.

772
01:29:05.956 --> 01:29:07.221
<v Ting Lu>Change order and everything.

773
01:29:08.038 --> 01:29:12.188
<v Ting Lu>The third one, the category is managing a lot of these contingencies.

774
01:29:12.701 --> 01:29:20.103
<v Ting Lu>It's because we have, with the land use requirement, we can't have everyone to drive to the construction site.

775
01:29:20.295 --> 01:29:22.938
<v Ting Lu>We're doing the busing to group people together.

776
01:29:23.274 --> 01:29:26.686
<v Ting Lu>So that's additional logistic and the project cost that's added.

777
01:29:27.039 --> 01:29:31.413
<v Ting Lu>And then the last category is the, we call it unknown unknowns.

778
01:29:31.510 --> 01:29:33.384
<v Ting Lu>That's the contingency I mentioned.

779
01:29:33.448 --> 01:29:35.274
<v Ting Lu>So that's about $100 million.

780
01:29:35.354 --> 01:29:35.755
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

781
01:29:35.916 --> 01:29:45.783
<v Ting Lu>For the remaining time till 2029, whether that's extreme weather and other things that we want to make sure we have the contingencies.

782
01:29:46.233 --> 01:29:57.782
<v Ting Lu>So we are intended to managing the project completion within this $450 million, other than like earthquake or major force majeure that we can't control.

783
01:29:59.895 --> 01:30:00.546
<v Ting Lu>I'm happy to—.

784
01:30:00.693 --> 01:30:02.920
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, that was what I was gonna ask you.

785
01:30:02.984 --> 01:30:10.094
<v Loretta Smith>Do we already have any contingency put aside for this project aside from getting the bonding?

786
01:30:11.570 --> 01:30:18.604
<v Loretta Smith>Do we have money that's in a fund that is a contingency pot of about 10% or something?

787
01:30:19.373 --> 01:30:19.454
<v Priya Dhanapal>8%.

788
01:30:19.599 --> 01:30:20.128
<v Loretta Smith>It's 8%?

789
01:30:21.525 --> 01:30:24.287
<v Loretta Smith>Is it— is, is the 8% coming out of this?

790
01:30:25.619 --> 01:30:26.166
<v Loretta Smith>Out of this?

791
01:30:26.422 --> 01:30:30.565
<v Loretta Smith>But do we have money right now for this project in contingency?

792
01:30:32.106 --> 01:30:33.215
<v Loretta Smith>In a contingency fund?

793
01:30:33.391 --> 01:30:35.944
<v Loretta Smith>Because I, I think we should.

794
01:30:37.020 --> 01:30:43.167
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, we have already previously the— we have the GMP, guaranteed maximum pricing.

795
01:30:43.216 --> 01:30:49.430
<v Ting Lu>So there is already that kind of a project, uh, budget that requested.

796
01:30:50.024 --> 01:30:55.481
<v Loretta Smith>And so what's, what's the GMP on this, uh, before we even do this extra money?

797
01:30:55.626 --> 01:30:56.750
<v Loretta Smith>What, what's the GMP?

798
01:30:56.926 --> 01:31:00.806
<v Ting Lu>The— that's the previous slide we can go back to.

799
01:31:00.935 --> 01:31:12.568
<v Loretta Smith>Let's see, it's the, um, guaranteed maximum price for those folks who don't know.

800
01:31:12.746 --> 01:31:13.422
<v Priya Dhanapal>Slide 9.

801
01:31:19.800 --> 01:31:32.497
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, uh, for slide 9, so the, the previously the GMP is $2.13 billion, and that's what happened before the remand and everything.

802
01:31:32.609 --> 01:31:34.837
<v Ting Lu>And now we are adding this for $50 million.

803
01:31:36.831 --> 01:31:41.310
<v Loretta Smith>So it would go up to $2.63 billion?

804
01:31:41.827 --> 01:31:42.230
<v Ting Lu>Correct.

805
01:31:43.185 --> 01:31:48.591
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, the new GMP, $2.63 billion.

806
01:31:49.043 --> 01:31:53.845
<v Priya Dhanapal>Um, Okay.

807
01:31:54.344 --> 01:32:09.605
<v Loretta Smith>And so the money that we have in contingency right now, the 8%, that, that would just move over and we're gonna add some of the new money to add to the growing price of this filtration project?

808
01:32:10.283 --> 01:32:10.703
<v Ting Lu>Correct.

809
01:32:10.768 --> 01:32:24.511
<v Ting Lu>Because of the schedule delay and the cost escalation, there's additional uncertainties we want to cover, but we are hoping to really managing that within the budget and, uh, not using all the contingency fund.

810
01:32:24.672 --> 01:32:25.813
<v Loretta Smith>I, I agree.

811
01:32:26.342 --> 01:32:28.815
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I think there's 2 things.

812
01:32:29.072 --> 01:32:35.319
<v Loretta Smith>We need to get an owner's rep. We need to have an independent evaluation of the resources in, in the restricted funds.

813
01:32:36.137 --> 01:32:42.592
<v Loretta Smith>Um, and we also need to have an outside watchdog, um, on this.

814
01:32:42.657 --> 01:32:59.921
<v Loretta Smith>I read an article in the, in the Oregonian a few weeks ago, and there was some talk about a previous council that that had, uh, basically promised a watchdog group of, um, of ratepayers to, to overlook this.

815
01:32:59.970 --> 01:33:10.804
<v Loretta Smith>I think we also need that group in addition to our owner's rep because that also keeps us honest on what we're looking at and, and what we're not looking at.

816
01:33:11.530 --> 01:33:21.640
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, this is a great opportunity for us as a region to be able to have, um, some of the best water that I know in the country.

817
01:33:22.384 --> 01:33:32.492
<v Loretta Smith>And, and I've been all over, and Oregon's water, Portland's water, the Bull Run, it is some good water, and I want to keep it safe.

818
01:33:34.041 --> 01:33:37.235
<v Loretta Smith>The other piece is, um, I for— I don't know who said it.

819
01:33:37.284 --> 01:33:42.637
<v Loretta Smith>I think it was Koyama Lane who said we, we need to grow our, um, Our revenue.

820
01:33:43.457 --> 01:33:47.359
<v Loretta Smith>And we need to go back to those folks like Gresham.

821
01:33:47.712 --> 01:33:48.724
<v Loretta Smith>That's a big deal.

822
01:33:48.836 --> 01:33:50.457
<v Loretta Smith>We lost a big client.

823
01:33:51.324 --> 01:33:59.480
<v Loretta Smith>We need to figure out ways in which to reduce the ratepayer costs, if even if we have to give them a reduced rate.

824
01:33:59.578 --> 01:34:09.597
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know if we can do that, but whatever it takes to get our, our, our customers— a good 40% of our customers are not coming with us and and that's why we're having to pay this.

825
01:34:09.645 --> 01:34:12.413
<v Loretta Smith>So it's— there's, there's some, there's some there there.

826
01:34:13.270 --> 01:34:20.140
<v Loretta Smith>And we talked about this in the Transportation, um, Committee, but that is an issue.

827
01:34:20.204 --> 01:34:24.752
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm going to say it again, I, I asked y'all to go talk to the tribes.

828
01:34:25.188 --> 01:34:34.515
<v Loretta Smith>The tribes is always running out of water, and, um, maybe they can, um, connect into our, um, our water system.

829
01:34:35.703 --> 01:34:45.005
<v Loretta Smith>But, um, it's, it's, it's clear that this is a— this is, this is going to be one, an economic driver for our small businesses.

830
01:34:45.582 --> 01:34:51.060
<v Loretta Smith>It is going to be a great opportunity for us to keep a very clean source, safe source of water.

831
01:34:51.703 --> 01:34:54.529
<v Loretta Smith>But we're going to have some growing pains getting there.

832
01:34:54.899 --> 01:35:06.445
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, many of us up here about the, the price of, of paying for this new system is, is steadily going up.

833
01:35:07.409 --> 01:35:18.347
<v Loretta Smith>And I remember last year that the big thing was, oh, we got this federal WIFIA, we don't have to pay the, um, interest on it till later, it's not going to change anybody's bill right now, it's going to be later.

834
01:35:18.832 --> 01:35:19.618
<v Loretta Smith>Was it 2035?

835
01:35:21.042 --> 01:35:24.065
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, wow, 2035.

836
01:35:24.395 --> 01:35:24.493
<v Matt Giurach>Yeah.

837
01:35:26.832 --> 01:35:33.844
<v Loretta Smith>That's, you know, I don't think folks' Social Security checks go up that high every year, 9%.

838
01:35:34.327 --> 01:35:37.596
<v Loretta Smith>And so we got to be thinking about how we're paying for this.

839
01:35:38.112 --> 01:35:44.338
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know, Jonas, do you know how much money we got in ARPA over the, the, the 2020 to 2023?

840
01:35:45.845 --> 01:35:48.338
<v Jonas Beery>Uh, Councilor, apologize, I don't know that off the top of my head.

841
01:35:48.469 --> 01:35:51.570
<v Jonas Beery>I'm not, um, and I'm not sure any of it was I know.

842
01:35:51.860 --> 01:35:56.676
<v Loretta Smith>I always like to pay for, for, you know, when we get one-time money, pay for one-time things.

843
01:35:57.693 --> 01:36:05.479
<v Loretta Smith>I bet we, we had enough money to pay for, for this new $500 million that we have to bond for.

844
01:36:05.819 --> 01:36:06.453
<v Loretta Smith>So that's the other thing.

845
01:36:06.516 --> 01:36:17.216
<v Loretta Smith>So what I, what I'm just going back, I wanted to find out, are there any other bonding sources that we have to use other than the revenue bonds?

846
01:36:17.796 --> 01:36:20.713
<v Loretta Smith>Is it just the GO bonds that are available?

847
01:36:23.109 --> 01:36:23.592
<v Jonas Beery>Yeah, Councilor.

848
01:36:23.640 --> 01:36:32.065
<v Jonas Beery>So for, yeah, for the water system, typically your options are the revenue bond structure that we've traditionally used and continue to use.

849
01:36:32.630 --> 01:36:42.237
<v Jonas Beery>There are local governments that have gone and asked voters for property tax levy increases specific to utility borrowing.

850
01:36:43.252 --> 01:36:53.976
<v Jonas Beery>That's not something I think we've pursued at the city, given that that's a tool that's available, an option to fund other needs that don't have revenue sources that the water system and sewer system do have.

851
01:36:54.057 --> 01:36:55.595
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, this is a smart way.

852
01:36:55.740 --> 01:36:58.591
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, it's definitely the smartest way to do it.

853
01:36:59.206 --> 01:37:14.475
<v Loretta Smith>It's just going to bring a lot of angst to people who are in my district in particular, because they, The average salary of a family of 4 is $60,000 in District 1.

854
01:37:15.567 --> 01:37:35.737
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'm just worried, and I hope that when we have the rate conversation that we also make sure that there is an opportunity for those vulnerable ratepayers who can't afford to pay this new double, um, $150 bill, that, that they have an opportunity to get their bill paid for.

855
01:37:36.538 --> 01:37:38.688
<v Loretta Smith>If that's embedded in the system.

856
01:37:39.088 --> 01:37:42.697
<v Olivia Clark>You, you remember we have a low-income program in the Water Bureau.

857
01:37:43.018 --> 01:37:43.194
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

858
01:37:43.578 --> 01:37:47.957
<v Olivia Clark>And, um, we might want to revisit that at some point to see if that's adequate.

859
01:37:48.052 --> 01:37:56.184
<v Loretta Smith>If that is an adequate amount, because it's— it seems like that, um, in the next 8, 9 years we're going to have a big bump.

860
01:37:57.065 --> 01:37:58.974
<v Loretta Smith>So I thank you all for bringing this forward.

861
01:37:59.198 --> 01:38:06.170
<v Loretta Smith>I think it's important, and, um, I think I think the entire council needs to have a better understanding of this.

862
01:38:08.189 --> 01:38:08.805
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

863
01:38:08.853 --> 01:38:13.288
<v Olivia Clark>I just want to add to one of your comments about oversight.

864
01:38:13.689 --> 01:38:22.323
<v Olivia Clark>I think that the public— our utility board is made up of citizens, is that right, who we consult on some of these decisions?

865
01:38:22.597 --> 01:38:23.389
<v Olivia Clark>We get their input.

866
01:38:23.809 --> 01:38:27.664
<v Olivia Clark>Does that— that functions as a community board in some respects?

867
01:38:28.556 --> 01:38:37.515
<v Ting Lu>Uh, community board as well as they have oversight, so, um, so we provide them the update on our budget and other information as they request.

868
01:38:38.188 --> 01:38:38.444
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

869
01:38:38.492 --> 01:38:45.494
<v Olivia Clark>You know, I think we might, in a committee, might want to invite the Public Utility Board people to come in and talk to us at some point, um, down the road.

870
01:38:45.542 --> 01:38:46.841
<v Olivia Clark>We can add that to our agenda.

871
01:38:47.627 --> 01:38:54.787
<v Olivia Clark>Um, seeing no other hands up right now, um, thank you so much It was a great overview.

872
01:38:55.095 --> 01:38:55.483
<v Keelan McClymont>We really—.

873
01:38:55.661 --> 01:38:58.719
<v Olivia Clark>We dug deeper than I thought we would, but it was very valuable.

874
01:38:59.739 --> 01:39:00.752
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that.

875
01:39:00.880 --> 01:39:09.787
<v Olivia Clark>And we will continue our discussion, but we would like to hear from the people who have signed up to testify today on this bond sale matter.

876
01:39:10.547 --> 01:39:12.782
<v Olivia Clark>Diego, would you call them up?

877
01:39:12.975 --> 01:39:16.585
<v Diego>Yes, we have one individual signed up, Samuel Diaz.

878
01:39:17.734 --> 01:39:23.073
<v Diego>And apologies, Samuel, the time the timer in Zoom isn't working, so I'm gonna go the analog route.

879
01:39:23.137 --> 01:39:24.846
<v Diego>I'm gonna play the timer from my phone.

880
01:39:28.020 --> 01:39:29.363
<v Diego>You'll hear the timer ding twice.

881
01:39:29.734 --> 01:39:32.096
<v Samuel Diaz>We practiced this, we're good.

882
01:39:32.225 --> 01:39:32.548
<v Diego>Great.

883
01:39:34.086 --> 01:39:34.958
<v Diego>You may begin when you're ready.

884
01:39:35.234 --> 01:39:35.864
<v Samuel Diaz>Great, thank you.

885
01:39:36.204 --> 01:39:40.331
<v Samuel Diaz>Good morning, Chair Clark, Vice Chair Smith, and Councilors Koyama Lane, Green, and Kanal.

886
01:39:41.280 --> 01:39:42.779
<v Samuel Diaz>For the record, my name is Sam Diaz.

887
01:39:42.891 --> 01:39:45.677
<v Samuel Diaz>I am the Executive Director for 1000 Friends of Oregon.

888
01:39:46.292 --> 01:40:02.011
<v Samuel Diaz>From Portland for Everyone to Anti-Displacement PDX to the multiple levy and bond measures, 1000 Friends has been proud to fundraise, organize, research, and advocate to bring solutions forward to make Portland a more affordable, beautiful, and prosperous place to live for everyone.

889
01:40:03.198 --> 01:40:06.707
<v Samuel Diaz>And that may be why today's item feels like a punch to the gut.

890
01:40:07.524 --> 01:40:12.027
<v Samuel Diaz>This is an alarming setback in fighting for a future Portland that is affordable for everyone.

891
01:40:13.296 --> 01:40:17.293
<v Samuel Diaz>Quote, it will be $4 billion once they're done, I guarantee it.

892
01:40:18.273 --> 01:40:29.993
<v Samuel Diaz>The amount of debt that will need to be issued and paid back for the filtration plant will put the city right back in the exact same place as the Bureau of Environmental Services 15, 20 years ago when they worked on Project Big Pipe.

893
01:40:30.877 --> 01:40:37.315
<v Samuel Diaz>The city will be raising rates at a rate that will drive you nuts, and they will be constraining the operational budget at the same time.

894
01:40:38.007 --> 01:40:40.523
<v Samuel Diaz>You should be talking to the City Council about this issue.

895
01:40:41.248 --> 01:40:45.296
<v Samuel Diaz>There is nowhere I could look from the chair I sat in and not see a fiscal problem.

896
01:40:46.670 --> 01:40:52.694
<v Samuel Diaz>These are the words from Administrator Mike Jordan during a City Club of Portland exit interview just 3 months ago.

897
01:40:54.242 --> 01:41:00.076
<v Samuel Diaz>Before the City Council authorizes this request and similar requests, this council and the public need answers and names.

898
01:41:00.729 --> 01:41:09.092
<v Samuel Diaz>Why is the City Council still receiving outdated project cost estimates when former Administrator Mike Jordan is publicly saying the project will cost more than $4 billion?

899
01:41:10.248 --> 01:41:15.274
<v Samuel Diaz>Why are key staff who pushed for the project while at the city now changing their tune once they leave?

900
01:41:16.447 --> 01:41:23.189
<v Samuel Diaz>What happens to the projected rate increases when 3 large ratepayer classes leave the system before this project is even built?

901
01:41:24.217 --> 01:41:33.369
<v Samuel Diaz>Did the City of Portland comply with its comprehensive plan's anti-displacement policy to analyze how many families will experience shutoffs and are priced out of the city altogether?

902
01:41:33.931 --> 01:41:40.390
<v Samuel Diaz>What about a Title VI impacts analysis and mitigation plan that is required when federal funding like the WIFIA loan is involved?

903
01:41:40.902 --> 01:41:47.119
<v Samuel Diaz>When I was a City Hall staffer, we had a term and standard for items requested by the bureaus: council ready.

904
01:41:48.016 --> 01:41:56.173
<v Samuel Diaz>It meant the due diligence, the outreach, the scenarios, and the questions raised by the people who are elected to serve the public was, for the most part, done.

905
01:41:57.167 --> 01:41:59.779
<v Samuel Diaz>And I will tell you, this item is not council ready.

906
01:42:00.837 --> 01:42:08.091
<v Samuel Diaz>I urge this committee to ask the Bureau to withdraw the request, brief this committee on contingency plans, and decide the rate increase first.

907
01:42:08.860 --> 01:42:19.756
<v Samuel Diaz>I also invite each of you to come meet with a group of farmers and local businesses, Portland residents, and community organizations who are more and more concerned with the direct impact of the project and the water rate increases.

908
01:42:20.574 --> 01:42:21.890
<v Samuel Diaz>It is not too late to adapt.

909
01:42:22.034 --> 01:42:27.538
<v Samuel Diaz>There are viable, affordable options to proactively plan to treat the water we drink in case of emergencies.

910
01:42:27.957 --> 01:42:31.953
<v Samuel Diaz>We do not need to price out and force working Portlanders out of this city.

911
01:42:33.028 --> 01:42:36.078
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for your testimony.

912
01:42:36.622 --> 01:42:38.774
<v Diego>That concludes testimony.

913
01:42:39.832 --> 01:42:40.891
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Diego.

914
01:42:41.599 --> 01:42:46.958
<v Olivia Clark>Um, interesting, Thousand Friends is doing a lot more than just land use planning these days.

915
01:42:48.018 --> 01:42:51.131
<v Olivia Clark>Um, Councilor Smith, is that a legacy hand?

916
01:42:51.243 --> 01:42:52.945
<v Loretta Smith>Nope, it's a new hand.

917
01:42:53.010 --> 01:42:53.443
<v Olivia Clark>Go for it.

918
01:42:54.122 --> 01:42:54.398
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

919
01:42:54.609 --> 01:42:58.463
<v Loretta Smith>Is, um, is DCA Donapal here?

920
01:43:07.018 --> 01:43:07.372
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

921
01:43:07.516 --> 01:43:11.171
<v Loretta Smith>And am I— I meant to ask this question before.

922
01:43:11.864 --> 01:43:14.047
<v Loretta Smith>What happens if we don't approve this today?

923
01:43:14.438 --> 01:43:19.537
<v Loretta Smith>What will not get done if we don't pass this today?

924
01:43:19.822 --> 01:43:20.358
<v Priya Dhanapal>The bond?

925
01:43:20.877 --> 01:43:26.690
<v Priya Dhanapal>Yeah, I, I would like to invite our finance team to answer that question.

926
01:43:33.967 --> 01:43:36.715
<v Matt Giurach>Uh, uh, for the record, Matt Gearhock, debt manager.

927
01:43:36.796 --> 01:43:39.123
<v Matt Giurach>Uh, thank you for the question, uh, Councilor Smith.

928
01:43:39.787 --> 01:43:57.524
<v Matt Giurach>Uh, if it does not get approved today, um, the bond sale will have to So the further it gets pushed out, the further we kind of have to push out the financing schedule.

929
01:43:59.100 --> 01:44:09.488
<v Matt Giurach>And with the Water Bureau needing to pay its construction bills, they would have to continue to utilize its funding sources.

930
01:44:10.020 --> 01:44:18.917
<v Matt Giurach>So WIFIA, And potentially dip into its second WIFIA loan that's already in place that has a higher interest rate.

931
01:44:19.909 --> 01:44:23.091
<v Matt Giurach>So we're trying to avoid using that because then we would effectively—.

932
01:44:23.091 --> 01:44:26.753
<v Loretta Smith>So are you saying we're not gonna be using the WIFIA and this is gonna supplant the WIFIA?

933
01:44:26.947 --> 01:44:32.594
<v Matt Giurach>No, we're planning on— I'm sorry, we're trying to delay the use of our second WIFIA loan.

934
01:44:32.658 --> 01:44:35.994
<v Matt Giurach>So one WIFIA loan has an interest rate of 1.89%.

935
01:44:36.681 --> 01:44:38.386
<v Matt Giurach>And that's the one that we've been using.

936
01:44:40.180 --> 01:44:47.275
<v Matt Giurach>The second WIFIA loan is a higher interest rate because when we locked in that interest rate, the bond market was in a different state.

937
01:44:47.859 --> 01:44:50.353
<v Matt Giurach>So that interest rate is 4.49%.

938
01:44:50.770 --> 01:44:52.154
<v Loretta Smith>And we haven't used any of it yet.

939
01:44:52.395 --> 01:44:53.506
<v Matt Giurach>We haven't used any of it yet.

940
01:44:53.859 --> 01:44:55.097
<v Loretta Smith>So how much is in that one?

941
01:44:56.055 --> 01:44:58.063
<v Matt Giurach>I believe $319 million.

942
01:44:58.645 --> 01:44:58.889
<v Matt Giurach>Okay.

943
01:45:00.507 --> 01:45:13.608
<v Matt Giurach>And so we're trying to do defer using that loan because we don't— one, we don't want to compound interest on that loan, and then secondly, there's a one-shot rate reset.

944
01:45:13.752 --> 01:45:21.965
<v Matt Giurach>So if we do see a decline in long-term Treasury rates, we could ask the EPA to reset the interest rate on the loan.

945
01:45:22.045 --> 01:45:26.529
<v Matt Giurach>If we draw on the loan, then we can't get that benefit of resetting the rate.

946
01:45:26.787 --> 01:45:31.681
<v Loretta Smith>And so I was saying, so this actually Actually, this is higher.

947
01:45:32.005 --> 01:45:34.319
<v Loretta Smith>This bond rate is higher than the 4-point.

948
01:45:36.345 --> 01:45:38.462
<v Matt Giurach>Currently, it's about the same interest rate.

949
01:45:39.512 --> 01:45:44.649
<v Matt Giurach>Another aspect of managing the debt is that we want to mitigate interest rate risk.

950
01:45:44.698 --> 01:45:48.783
<v Matt Giurach>So there's always the chance also that interest rates just go up.

951
01:45:49.686 --> 01:45:58.148
<v Matt Giurach>So that's one of the cost components of the overall project, We're trying to lock in and mitigate how much interest rate risk.

952
01:45:58.453 --> 01:46:01.605
<v Loretta Smith>And when are we expected to finish and complete this project?

953
01:46:03.978 --> 01:46:09.484
<v Matt Giurach>I believe the substantial completion date now is September 2029.

954
01:46:10.000 --> 01:46:11.421
<v Loretta Smith>September 2029.

955
01:46:12.947 --> 01:46:13.194
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

956
01:46:16.251 --> 01:46:33.082
<v Loretta Smith>But your sense is that we have to approve this this month to kind of mitigate maybe future rising rates and not to jump into the second WIFIA loan?

957
01:46:34.542 --> 01:46:35.698
<v Matt Giurach>That is a risk, yes.

958
01:46:36.740 --> 01:46:45.148
<v Loretta Smith>Do we have any other sources of income that are in contingency that we can use until we have a real good understanding?

959
01:46:45.212 --> 01:46:54.538
<v Loretta Smith>Because see, I, I I heard the testifier talk about what a previous city administrator said about this project.

960
01:46:55.646 --> 01:47:15.905
<v Loretta Smith>I don't know if it's true or not, but even if it is, I mean, it's kind of reckless to go back on something that you were responsible for for the last 5 years and say that it's gonna double without giving Um, any level setting of what that— of why that is.

961
01:47:16.421 --> 01:47:27.095
<v Loretta Smith>So, I mean, that, that brings me some concern that, that, that maybe someone is saying that who had intimate knowledge of what was going on here and had intimate control over what went on here.

962
01:47:27.176 --> 01:47:37.809
<v Loretta Smith>So to have that conversation after they walk out the door, uh, is troubling to me, but it doesn't stop me from wondering why is it being said.

963
01:47:38.283 --> 01:47:48.775
<v Loretta Smith>It's based on something, something that we don't know, something that, that we're going to have to pay for that has not been foreseen to the councilors yet.

964
01:47:49.599 --> 01:47:51.145
<v Loretta Smith>And I always worry about that.

965
01:47:53.105 --> 01:47:58.893
<v Loretta Smith>Whether I agree with what someone is saying or the timing of, of how they say things, that's a whole nother story.

966
01:47:59.087 --> 01:48:05.047
<v Loretta Smith>But the fact of the matter is, I know that I'm not privy to every single thing about this project.

967
01:48:05.951 --> 01:48:08.604
<v Loretta Smith>I understand that we should have done some things.

968
01:48:09.106 --> 01:48:14.122
<v Loretta Smith>We should have filed the right permits or we wouldn't have been in this problem to begin with, and that was our problem.

969
01:48:16.987 --> 01:48:28.692
<v Priya Dhanapal>Councilor Smith, the issues with respect to permits were external to the city's control, and I cannot speak for the previous city administrator.

970
01:48:29.064 --> 01:48:29.259
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

971
01:48:29.469 --> 01:48:32.220
<v Priya Dhanapal>I can speak for what the project team is working on right now.

972
01:48:32.981 --> 01:48:34.118
<v Priya Dhanapal>The conditions right now.

973
01:48:35.545 --> 01:48:38.782
<v Priya Dhanapal>Last year, the year before, there were things that were very uncertain.

974
01:48:38.829 --> 01:48:41.041
<v Priya Dhanapal>The project phase was in a different phase.

975
01:48:41.457 --> 01:48:41.698
<v Ting Lu>Yeah.

976
01:48:41.954 --> 01:48:47.658
<v Priya Dhanapal>Right now, the legal complications with respect to the land use is no longer there.

977
01:48:47.722 --> 01:48:52.947
<v Priya Dhanapal>We have, you know, the approval has been upheld by LUBA.

978
01:48:53.011 --> 01:48:55.751
<v Priya Dhanapal>So we have legal certainty moving forward.

979
01:48:56.198 --> 01:49:00.045
<v Priya Dhanapal>And with the cost, we also have certainty with respect to the cost.

980
01:49:00.462 --> 01:49:07.961
<v Priya Dhanapal>We have a, you know, we have an updated cost number based on the remand, and that is also at a higher confidence level.

981
01:49:08.394 --> 01:49:10.974
<v Priya Dhanapal>So this was not there a year or 2 ago.

982
01:49:11.375 --> 01:49:22.784
<v Priya Dhanapal>So aside from force majeure events and the stage at which the project is in right now, we are at 90% design, construction is already beginning, we are at 30% construction.

983
01:49:23.233 --> 01:49:25.765
<v Priya Dhanapal>So the confidence level of the cost estimate is high.

984
01:49:26.181 --> 01:49:33.152
<v Priya Dhanapal>And then we have multiple teams looking at minimizing the risk early and mitigating the risk.

985
01:49:33.569 --> 01:49:38.617
<v Priya Dhanapal>So the confidence level of all of that is higher than how it was a year or 2 ago.

986
01:49:38.984 --> 01:49:40.203
<v Loretta Smith>But what's the possible risk?

987
01:49:40.346 --> 01:49:41.324
<v Loretta Smith>I trust you, Priya.

988
01:49:41.869 --> 01:49:43.889
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, I trust you.

989
01:49:45.171 --> 01:49:47.717
<v Loretta Smith>But what could the possible risk be?

990
01:49:47.814 --> 01:49:49.385
<v Loretta Smith>What else is there risk of?

991
01:49:50.682 --> 01:49:52.317
<v Priya Dhanapal>Director Liu, you want to speak to that risk?

992
01:49:52.877 --> 01:50:00.201
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, I mean, there's an extreme like the earthquake or something, that's a risk we're not covering for this $450 million.

993
01:50:00.457 --> 01:50:09.655
<v Ting Lu>But the majority of the things, because we are already in the construction, deep into the construction, and then we have this guaranteed price, maximum pricing.

994
01:50:10.024 --> 01:50:14.800
<v Ting Lu>So the certainty now, it's very different from 2 years ago or 1 year ago.

995
01:50:15.280 --> 01:50:22.850
<v Ting Lu>And then the LUBA remained as We are continuing to conforming and upheld our permit.

996
01:50:23.011 --> 01:50:26.201
<v Ting Lu>This provides a legal ground for us to continue construction.

997
01:50:26.572 --> 01:50:28.599
<v Ting Lu>So all of that is being behind us.

998
01:50:30.189 --> 01:50:30.287
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

999
01:50:31.132 --> 01:50:39.765
<v Loretta Smith>So the likelihood that this is going to go off at the price point that we are saying it is, is likely, right?

1000
01:50:41.002 --> 01:50:41.420
<v Loretta Smith>I hope.

1001
01:50:41.886 --> 01:50:56.966
<v Loretta Smith>You know, when I hear people come up and I didn't— We only had one person testify today, but it concerns me that folks think that this project is gonna bloom to double.

1002
01:50:57.591 --> 01:51:00.161
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm trying to figure out where could that doubling come from?

1003
01:51:01.525 --> 01:51:12.059
<v Priya Dhanapal>There are things that we, you know, we have accounted for what the known unknowns, there are the unknown unknowns like fuel prices, if there are tariffs that are, Right.

1004
01:51:12.461 --> 01:51:13.746
<v Priya Dhanapal>So those are things that we don't know.

1005
01:51:14.211 --> 01:51:14.452
<v Loretta Smith>Right.

1006
01:51:14.596 --> 01:51:16.395
<v Priya Dhanapal>It's difficult to predict the future.

1007
01:51:16.862 --> 01:51:21.631
<v Priya Dhanapal>So based on the things that we do know, we are trying to mitigate the risks so far.

1008
01:51:22.145 --> 01:51:27.479
<v Priya Dhanapal>And there's a person from the project team here to talk more about that specifically.

1009
01:51:27.783 --> 01:51:34.466
<v Olivia Clark>Colleagues, before we dive any deeper here, I just want to say we only have another 14 minutes before we need to take a break.

1010
01:51:34.530 --> 01:51:43.400
<v Olivia Clark>And I was really hoping we could get to a decision before we that we could actually take a vote on this and then come back and talk about the committee agendas.

1011
01:51:44.073 --> 01:51:45.436
<v Olivia Clark>So just a heads up.

1012
01:51:46.479 --> 01:51:48.899
<v Olivia Clark>So I appreciate your line of questioning, Councilor Smith.

1013
01:51:48.963 --> 01:51:51.609
<v Olivia Clark>I just wanted to put everybody on notice about the timing.

1014
01:51:51.752 --> 01:51:57.699
<v Loretta Smith>I, I, I, Mr., Mrs. Chairman, I am, I'm trying to get there with you.

1015
01:51:57.779 --> 01:51:57.972
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

1016
01:51:58.324 --> 01:51:59.127
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm not there yet.

1017
01:51:59.528 --> 01:52:14.922
<v Loretta Smith>And just so you know, I'm trying to be very cognizant confident about this, about this, um, opportunity that's set before us to level set us and make sure that we have the, the, the funding at a particular price.

1018
01:52:15.551 --> 01:52:26.167
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm also trying to make sure that our ratepayers, even the ones who can pay it, that, that they feel that they're getting a bang for their buck.

1019
01:52:26.360 --> 01:52:43.992
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, I, I— the water is great and it's good, I'm just trying to be comfortable before I take this vote on, um, what kind of mitigating things that could cause this, this project to, to blossom up to another $2 billion.

1020
01:52:44.265 --> 01:52:53.005
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm just trying— I, I don't see where that could happen based on what you're telling me, and I'm, I'm just trying to be comfortable in taking this vote.

1021
01:52:54.351 --> 01:52:57.625
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I, I know the project did you have something to add?

1022
01:52:58.862 --> 01:53:00.113
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>I could add something.

1023
01:53:00.243 --> 01:53:03.984
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>So my name is, for the record, my name is Muriel Gueza-Teufel.

1024
01:53:04.064 --> 01:53:07.676
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>I'm the interim chief engineer for the Water Bureau.

1025
01:53:08.255 --> 01:53:15.993
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>I've been in the role officially for about 3 weeks, but I came from the BES side of the city managing larger programs.

1026
01:53:16.619 --> 01:53:21.372
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>So in that respect, I bring that experience, and I think it's great that we could keep it in-house at the city.

1027
01:53:21.984 --> 01:53:23.510
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>To manage megaprojects.

1028
01:53:24.954 --> 01:53:30.240
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>So the remaining risks, to your question, the biggest risk we have now is maintaining schedule.

1029
01:53:30.578 --> 01:53:32.489
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>That's our biggest risk.

1030
01:53:32.747 --> 01:53:33.309
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>Okay.

1031
01:53:33.935 --> 01:53:45.533
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>The cost to keep the machine churning, so to speak, with numerous contractors, trailers, trucks, people on site all the time is our biggest cost risk.

1032
01:53:45.920 --> 01:53:46.095
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>Okay.

1033
01:53:46.884 --> 01:53:49.869
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>Because the construction site has moved out of the ground.

1034
01:53:49.934 --> 01:53:55.854
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>We do have a tunnel underway where we found some things and there's remaining tunneling to do.

1035
01:53:55.935 --> 01:54:00.619
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>That's always a risky area, but I believe that our contingencies are covering for that risk.

1036
01:54:01.261 --> 01:54:08.753
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>So at this point, it's really our ability to control and manage the project within the contingencies and the budget that we're requesting.

1037
01:54:08.945 --> 01:54:09.555
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>And that's our job.

1038
01:54:10.069 --> 01:54:12.604
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay, good.

1039
01:54:13.021 --> 01:54:13.904
<v Loretta Smith>And thank you.

1040
01:54:15.349 --> 01:54:20.807
<v Matt Giurach>I did want to ask or add one additional fact just to make sure.

1041
01:54:20.904 --> 01:54:27.600
<v Matt Giurach>I did fail to mention that there is a credit facility that the Water Bureau does have that we have as a fallback mechanism.

1042
01:54:27.712 --> 01:54:36.768
<v Matt Giurach>Essentially, when we were unable to draw on the WIFIA loan during the remand, there is about $260 million that is not drawn on that credit facility.

1043
01:54:36.881 --> 01:54:46.280
<v Matt Giurach>But drawing on that credit facility essentially locks in the bureau to issue long-term bonds to pay off the credit facility when it expires, uh, in 2028.

1044
01:54:46.457 --> 01:54:47.795
<v Matt Giurach>So just wanted to clarify.

1045
01:54:47.844 --> 01:54:48.748
<v Loretta Smith>I'm messing with that, right?

1046
01:54:49.998 --> 01:54:51.458
<v Matt Giurach>Uh, prefer not to draw on that.

1047
01:54:51.556 --> 01:54:52.091
<v Loretta Smith>That alone.

1048
01:54:53.747 --> 01:54:55.983
<v Loretta Smith>I think Jonas is here, but we'll leave that alone, Jonas.

1049
01:54:58.735 --> 01:55:00.217
<v Loretta Smith>Um, okay, thank you.

1050
01:55:00.362 --> 01:55:01.360
<v Loretta Smith>I, I appreciate that.

1051
01:55:01.554 --> 01:55:07.677
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, um, I hadn't thought about the tunneling piece but thank you.

1052
01:55:09.042 --> 01:55:09.828
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1053
01:55:10.164 --> 01:55:11.672
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, great, great questions.

1054
01:55:11.930 --> 01:55:18.347
<v Olivia Clark>And about the no approval, I really appreciate that because I think it also sends a bad signal to the bond market.

1055
01:55:19.069 --> 01:55:21.685
<v Olivia Clark>Um, and, uh, I'll just leave it at that.

1056
01:55:22.278 --> 01:55:23.930
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Green, you had your hand up.

1057
01:55:25.101 --> 01:55:25.663
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam Chair.

1058
01:55:25.743 --> 01:55:31.872
<v Mitch Green>I know you're trying to move us to a vote, but this is a pretty important one, so I'm just gonna, um, state where I'm at right now.

1059
01:55:34.792 --> 01:55:38.738
<v Mitch Green>I'm not convinced this is the only way we can address our EPA requirements.

1060
01:55:39.363 --> 01:55:48.653
<v Mitch Green>Um, there is room in our, uh, STWA regulations and the EPA regulations for point-of-use and point-of-entry filtration.

1061
01:55:49.582 --> 01:55:53.432
<v Mitch Green>It's hard to get the variance, but it is worth pursuing given the cost.

1062
01:55:53.721 --> 01:56:02.929
<v Mitch Green>Um, you know, if you put a whole-house water filter on a On a house that ranges between $1,500 and $4,500 all in.

1063
01:56:03.827 --> 01:56:07.722
<v Mitch Green>And at the most Cadillac implementation of that, that's $800 million.

1064
01:56:08.332 --> 01:56:09.134
<v Mitch Green>Most Cadillac.

1065
01:56:10.000 --> 01:56:14.875
<v Mitch Green>At the sort of probably entry-level place, we're looking at $200 million.

1066
01:56:15.773 --> 01:56:18.546
<v Mitch Green>And I think that that is worth discussing with our attorneys.

1067
01:56:18.595 --> 01:56:22.332
<v Mitch Green>I know that's a change in strategy, but that saves billions of dollars.

1068
01:56:23.246 --> 01:56:28.631
<v Mitch Green>And that saves the potential ratepayer considerable money over the course of the next decade.

1069
01:56:28.712 --> 01:56:31.292
<v Mitch Green>And so I'm not prepared to vote yes today on this bond.

1070
01:56:31.340 --> 01:56:34.047
<v Mitch Green>I think that's the only control I have over the cost of this project.

1071
01:56:34.689 --> 01:56:40.681
<v Mitch Green>I'd like to learn more with our city attorney on what precisely is our objective and what are we constrained to.

1072
01:56:40.953 --> 01:56:48.085
<v Mitch Green>I mean, I, I have heard from the presentation that we have to do this for regulatory compliance, but I'm, I'm reading the code myself right now and I see other ways to comply.

1073
01:56:48.789 --> 01:57:02.725
<v Mitch Green>And I think that if we're not testing the boundaries with unconventional methods, I mean, frankly, I just have to say, I think it's crazy that a centralized plant is more expensive than a distributed water filtration system across 300,000 households.

1074
01:57:03.327 --> 01:57:04.057
<v Mitch Green>I think that's wild.

1075
01:57:04.220 --> 01:57:06.608
<v Mitch Green>And that just speaks to the inflationary environment we're in right now.

1076
01:57:06.721 --> 01:57:09.435
<v Mitch Green>It speaks to the other cost schedule risks that we have.

1077
01:57:10.835 --> 01:57:16.304
<v Mitch Green>But I'm a no vote right now on this bond issuance package out of committee.

1078
01:57:16.384 --> 01:57:20.158
<v Mitch Green>And we— I'm going to commit to have these conversations inside this building.

1079
01:57:21.645 --> 01:57:26.557
<v Mitch Green>But if there's a way for us to get to clean water compliance that saves the ratepayer money, that's what I'm going to work on.

1080
01:57:27.345 --> 01:57:30.539
<v Olivia Clark>So Councilor Green, are you suggesting that we just stop the project altogether?

1081
01:57:31.439 --> 01:57:34.489
<v Mitch Green>I'm suggesting that we need to be in that sort of decisions phase right now.

1082
01:57:34.569 --> 01:57:42.725
<v Mitch Green>We need to seriously contemplate that because I think what has happened is a series of decisions have been made for us that put us on a timeline, that put us on a cost trajectory.

1083
01:57:43.465 --> 01:57:50.886
<v Mitch Green>And if we operate within the sort of like, well, we have to do this, Then we're stuck on a rate trajectory that I think is unsustainable.

1084
01:57:51.306 --> 01:57:55.469
<v Mitch Green>What I haven't seen is a stress test on a legal basis on what our other options are.

1085
01:57:57.453 --> 01:58:07.755
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, so what you're suggesting is that we stop the project, we go and we look at what every single household in Portland can do to ensure they have clean water on their own?

1086
01:58:08.832 --> 01:58:11.970
<v Mitch Green>What I'm saying is that the City of Portland can show some leadership.

1087
01:58:12.051 --> 01:58:17.364
<v Mitch Green>This Council can show some leadership and say, here are 2 different ways, or a range of options.

1088
01:58:17.429 --> 01:58:20.528
<v Mitch Green>Here's what the all-in cost is to get the same level of outcome.

1089
01:58:21.122 --> 01:58:30.016
<v Mitch Green>And so under EPA regulations, you can do a distributed point of entry and point of use system as long as the municipality maintains that system.

1090
01:58:30.595 --> 01:58:38.012
<v Mitch Green>And so my understanding is we need to have— if we were to fail to do this, that we would face daily water boil.

1091
01:58:38.270 --> 01:58:38.670
<v Mitch Green>Notices.

1092
01:58:39.487 --> 01:58:48.780
<v Mitch Green>Um, but if we were to mitigate that with filtration opportunities— and I'm spitballing here— what I'm trying to say is I'm not going to vote yes on $525 million today.

1093
01:58:49.533 --> 01:58:55.975
<v Mitch Green>I need a little more time, and I think that there's a different way to pay for this and solve our problems that cost the ratepayers significantly less money.

1094
01:58:57.194 --> 01:59:09.243
<v Olivia Clark>What— and I think what you're suggesting though would require that we go back to the drawing board and completely redesign a system where every single person in Portland would have to buy something for their water filtration.

1095
01:59:09.519 --> 01:59:10.604
<v Mitch Green>Oh, I say we buy it for them.

1096
01:59:11.237 --> 01:59:11.675
<v Olivia Clark>I'm sorry?

1097
01:59:11.949 --> 01:59:12.631
<v Mitch Green>We buy it for them.

1098
01:59:14.161 --> 01:59:17.962
<v Mitch Green>So we— you may not like my approach, but I'm just telling you how I'm voting today.

1099
01:59:18.106 --> 01:59:26.109
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that, and I'm just wondering how that jives with our federal mandate, with the extension we've been given and that we've worked on from OHA.

1100
01:59:27.403 --> 01:59:32.920
<v Olivia Clark>I think we're really between a rock and a hard place when it comes to this, so I appreciate your concern for the ratepayer.

1101
01:59:32.967 --> 01:59:34.863
<v Olivia Clark>I think we all share those concerns.

1102
01:59:35.457 --> 01:59:38.350
<v Olivia Clark>But I think what you're suggesting is you want more time.

1103
01:59:38.912 --> 01:59:57.421
<v Olivia Clark>But I think it's also a complete step backwards, back to the Cryptosporidium days, when, when actually this plant is designed to deal with the fact that we have climate change going on and that something that we had not anticipated are forest fires and what that's going to do to our water supply.

1104
01:59:59.076 --> 02:00:06.025
<v Olivia Clark>In terms of turbidity, in terms of all of the fire ash that's going to come into the system.

1105
02:00:06.539 --> 02:00:14.742
<v Olivia Clark>And I don't know how every single household in Portland will be able to filter that if we don't have an upstream approach.

1106
02:00:15.350 --> 02:00:18.417
<v Olivia Clark>So that really concerns me about climate change.

1107
02:00:18.578 --> 02:00:22.478
<v Olivia Clark>And climate change is costing us all a lot in a variety of different ways.

1108
02:00:23.055 --> 02:00:36.162
<v Olivia Clark>And I think this was really a silver lining to this plant is that we're getting ahead of that, what could be horrific damage to our very wonderful water supply, which we should be doing a better job marketing our wonderful water.

1109
02:00:36.837 --> 02:00:42.475
<v Olivia Clark>So I appreciate what you're saying, that you're not willing to vote on that today, but I think we are really taking a real step backward.

1110
02:00:43.070 --> 02:00:46.877
<v Olivia Clark>So, Councilor Koyama Lane, did you want to make a comment?

1111
02:00:47.552 --> 02:00:49.594
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, I appreciate the conversations.

1112
02:00:49.641 --> 02:01:01.164
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I agree with a lot of the different things that I'm hearing up I have heard more— I was interested in what Councilor Green was saying about his solution.

1113
02:01:01.293 --> 02:01:05.578
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that in these complex times, we have to throw all those ideas out there.

1114
02:01:06.030 --> 02:01:10.172
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I've heard more about the idea of, like, UV treatment.

1115
02:01:10.722 --> 02:01:13.586
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I agree we're in between a rock and a hard place.

1116
02:01:15.680 --> 02:01:17.858
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>One thing is we have this federal mandate.

1117
02:01:17.922 --> 02:01:19.528
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We have to meet these federal water standards.

1118
02:01:19.577 --> 02:01:19.953
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I think that's a great idea.

1119
02:01:20.301 --> 02:01:22.594
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>What happens if we don't meet those?

1120
02:01:23.893 --> 02:01:24.310
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Do we know?

1121
02:01:24.470 --> 02:01:24.823
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Is it clear?

1122
02:01:25.015 --> 02:01:28.045
<v Ting Lu>We'll be facing daily fines and penalties there.

1123
02:01:28.172 --> 02:01:33.511
<v Ting Lu>So we could definitely follow up on some of the additional impact if we don't do this.

1124
02:01:33.606 --> 02:01:35.225
<v Ting Lu>What is the cost of that?

1125
02:01:35.289 --> 02:01:40.420
<v Ting Lu>But it's a— this is an entering into already a binding agreement here.

1126
02:01:40.980 --> 02:01:41.140
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Okay.

1127
02:01:41.462 --> 02:01:44.956
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then can someone talk a little bit about specifically the UV treatment?

1128
02:01:45.069 --> 02:01:47.819
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Because I was looking into that and I saw So that was interesting.

1129
02:01:47.884 --> 02:01:56.594
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I also am seeing that the UV— so the big issue is the diarrhea parasite, right, the Cryptosporidium.

1130
02:01:56.885 --> 02:02:07.423
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So that UV treatment can help with that, but not treat for, like, we're having more wildfires and there's particles coming in, and that's something we need to deal with with our water.

1131
02:02:07.520 --> 02:02:13.314
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can we talk about, um, filtration versus UV light in that area?

1132
02:02:14.828 --> 02:02:36.092
<v Ting Lu>Yeah, I see it's really adding that additional long-term resilience because the UV is a point of the technology, but filtration provides more flexibility not only to remove the Cryptosporidium, but it has the flexibility to remove additional emerging contaminants by changing some of the medium and technology.

1133
02:02:36.493 --> 02:02:44.302
<v Ting Lu>And UV is just light bulb, you know, there's various Very kind of a straightforward technology to remove this one pathogen.

1134
02:02:44.752 --> 02:02:58.506
<v Ting Lu>So what the approach that the team has said is having more long-term resilience, not only on the extreme weather, earthquake, and wildfires, but also for the additional emerging regulation compliance.

1135
02:02:58.603 --> 02:03:02.225
<v Ting Lu>We'll have that flexibility to address them in the future as well.

1136
02:03:02.546 --> 02:03:04.966
<v Ting Lu>So this is for the generations to come for.

1137
02:03:05.030 --> 02:03:05.158
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1138
02:03:08.613 --> 02:03:08.935
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1139
02:03:09.000 --> 02:03:10.173
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>That's all really helpful.

1140
02:03:10.367 --> 02:03:19.813
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>While I agree we're in this hard place, I do think it's important that we are thinking down the road and that we make sure that we have— continue to have good drinking water.

1141
02:03:20.988 --> 02:03:24.789
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I definitely think we need to be having accountability and oversight.

1142
02:03:27.039 --> 02:03:29.921
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But yeah, I think this is where we're at.

1143
02:03:30.328 --> 02:03:32.462
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I do plan, I think, to support this.

1144
02:03:32.528 --> 02:03:32.673
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1145
02:03:34.386 --> 02:03:35.720
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1146
02:03:35.815 --> 02:03:37.710
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith, is that a legacy hand?

1147
02:03:37.757 --> 02:03:39.347
<v Loretta Smith>No, it's a new hand.

1148
02:03:39.604 --> 02:03:52.416
<v Loretta Smith>And I just want to say we are in between a rock and a hard place, and we have GMP already signed, we have subcontractors already signed, and if we delay those, one of two things is going to have to happen.

1149
02:03:52.463 --> 02:04:03.563
<v Loretta Smith>You're going to have to put forward the second WIFIA at a higher rate and instead of being able to pay this with, with ratepayers.

1150
02:04:03.627 --> 02:04:09.404
<v Loretta Smith>So I, um, I will be supporting this going forward, um, Madam Chairwoman.

1151
02:04:10.728 --> 02:04:11.663
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1152
02:04:11.921 --> 02:04:14.971
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I would like to move this item.

1153
02:04:15.795 --> 02:04:21.725
<v Olivia Clark>Um, we've got a just a minute or so before we have to take a break, so I would like to entertain an ordinance.

1154
02:04:21.871 --> 02:04:23.367
<v Olivia Clark>I think it's, uh, which one are we at now?

1155
02:04:23.431 --> 02:04:24.618
<v Olivia Clark>2024-01.

1156
02:04:26.439 --> 02:04:27.623
<v Olivia Clark>26-134, Is that correct?

1157
02:04:28.320 --> 02:04:30.560
<v Olivia Clark>To the full council with a recommendation to pass.

1158
02:04:32.416 --> 02:04:33.091
<v Olivia Clark>I would move that.

1159
02:04:33.140 --> 02:04:33.766
<v Olivia Clark>Can I get a second?

1160
02:04:33.831 --> 02:04:34.039
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

1161
02:04:34.698 --> 02:04:35.085
<v Loretta Smith>Second.

1162
02:04:35.180 --> 02:04:36.225
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1163
02:04:36.291 --> 02:04:40.278
<v Olivia Clark>The motion has been moved by myself and a second by Councilor Smith.

1164
02:04:41.778 --> 02:04:44.506
<v Olivia Clark>I don't think there's any more conversation about this.

1165
02:04:44.554 --> 02:04:46.523
<v Olivia Clark>So Diego, could you please call the roll?

1166
02:04:47.831 --> 02:04:48.185
<v Diego>Kanal.

1167
02:04:52.323 --> 02:04:55.225
<v Diego>Councilor Kanal, if you're still online.

1168
02:04:58.595 --> 02:04:59.760
<v Diego>Looks like you might have dropped off.

1169
02:05:01.067 --> 02:05:01.375
<v Diego>Um, Koyama Lane?

1170
02:05:01.877 --> 02:05:02.041
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1171
02:05:03.420 --> 02:05:03.631
<v Diego>Green?

1172
02:05:04.896 --> 02:05:05.042
<v Mitch Green>No.

1173
02:05:06.747 --> 02:05:07.136
<v Diego>Smith?

1174
02:05:07.882 --> 02:05:07.931
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1175
02:05:09.521 --> 02:05:10.390
<v Olivia Clark>Clark?

1176
02:05:10.502 --> 02:05:10.518
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1177
02:05:11.210 --> 02:05:22.444
<v Diego>With 3 ayes, 1 nay, and 1 absent, the motion carries, and the ordinance document number 2026-134 We'll move to the full council with a recommendation to pass.

1178
02:05:23.662 --> 02:05:24.494
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, colleagues.

1179
02:05:24.559 --> 02:05:25.055
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Diego.

1180
02:05:25.119 --> 02:05:29.766
<v Olivia Clark>Let's take a 10-minute break now, and we'll come back and talk about the committee.

1181
02:18:16.068 --> 02:18:17.843
<v Diego>Councilor Kanal, it looks like you're online.

1182
02:18:21.470 --> 02:18:21.888
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, I am.

1183
02:18:21.952 --> 02:18:23.656
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm switching over to computer.

1184
02:18:23.864 --> 02:18:24.539
<v Diego>Okay, perfect.

1185
02:18:24.603 --> 02:18:25.213
<v Claire>Thank you.

1186
02:18:30.323 --> 02:18:34.141
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, well, we, we can reconvene and, and the 3 of us can, can start.

1187
02:18:34.416 --> 02:18:38.777
<v Olivia Clark>Um, the others are just going to miss out on a really fascinating conversation.

1188
02:18:39.602 --> 02:18:41.510
<v Olivia Clark>About the future of our committee.

1189
02:18:42.431 --> 02:18:45.500
<v Olivia Clark>Diego, you want to go ahead and call the next item?

1190
02:18:46.402 --> 02:18:49.746
<v Diego>Item 3, Public Works Committee Priorities Discussion.

1191
02:18:51.227 --> 02:18:51.565
<v Michael McGee>Great.

1192
02:18:51.853 --> 02:18:55.472
<v Olivia Clark>Well, what I'd like to do is chat a little bit.

1193
02:18:55.989 --> 02:18:57.238
<v Olivia Clark>Hello, Councilor Kanal, are you still there?

1194
02:18:59.204 --> 02:18:59.529
<v Olivia Clark>Is he there?

1195
02:19:00.711 --> 02:19:01.165
<v Sameer Kanal>I am, I am.

1196
02:19:01.457 --> 02:19:03.757
<v Olivia Clark>Great, super, because I want your input on this.

1197
02:19:04.356 --> 02:19:06.545
<v Olivia Clark>I can hear more voices coming down the hallway.

1198
02:19:07.157 --> 02:19:07.628
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

1199
02:19:07.709 --> 02:19:11.611
<v Olivia Clark>But what I'd like to do is just discuss some of our priorities for the coming year.

1200
02:19:12.755 --> 02:19:23.718
<v Olivia Clark>And I want to start by talking a little bit about what the old T&I Committee did do before we look ahead at the future.

1201
02:19:23.799 --> 02:19:34.533
<v Olivia Clark>So let me just share with you some— I think what I think are some of the highlights of what we did in the last year, knowing that all of our issues sort of fall into 3 buckets.

1202
02:19:34.760 --> 02:19:36.574
<v Olivia Clark>There's the policy bucket.

1203
02:19:37.204 --> 02:19:42.859
<v Olivia Clark>There's the information items, you know, learning about things, which we did some in the very beginning.

1204
02:19:43.556 --> 02:19:49.088
<v Olivia Clark>And then there are administrative or executive items that come to us on a regular basis.

1205
02:19:49.137 --> 02:19:50.799
<v Olivia Clark>So there's kind of 3 categories.

1206
02:19:51.255 --> 02:19:54.003
<v Olivia Clark>It's hard to believe that we had 22 meetings.

1207
02:19:54.603 --> 02:19:55.904
<v Olivia Clark>Where does the time go?

1208
02:19:57.316 --> 02:20:03.498
<v Olivia Clark>And we actually considered and recommended to council 22 legislative items.

1209
02:20:03.547 --> 02:20:03.594
<v Jonas Beery>Wow.

1210
02:20:04.448 --> 02:20:05.127
<v Loretta Smith>Excuse me.

1211
02:20:05.175 --> 02:20:10.363
<v Olivia Clark>Which was a combination of executive and councilor-sponsored or councilor-initiated items.

1212
02:20:11.156 --> 02:20:31.147
<v Olivia Clark>So some of the highlights from the councilor-sponsored legislation and discussion were asset management, of course my favorite topic, asset management strategy, the PBOT alternative funding strategies, the Vision Zero led by Councilor Craighead, Koyama Lane.

1213
02:20:32.537 --> 02:20:41.498
<v Olivia Clark>We've affirmed our commitment to the SIP, the sidewalk and street safety through the SIP, and that was led by Councilor Smith.

1214
02:20:41.693 --> 02:20:44.452
<v Olivia Clark>I just mentioned that you, you led the Vision Zero.

1215
02:20:44.599 --> 02:20:46.579
<v Olivia Clark>We're talking about last, last year.

1216
02:20:47.983 --> 02:20:55.523
<v Olivia Clark>And then we also had a resolution directing an investigation of Zenith Energy that was led by Councilor Green and Councilor Murillo.

1217
02:20:57.251 --> 02:21:01.569
<v Olivia Clark>And we supported the naming of Portland's very own Brooklyn Bridge.

1218
02:21:01.763 --> 02:21:03.897
<v Olivia Clark>That was led by Councilor Morillo, which was a fun thing.

1219
02:21:04.235 --> 02:21:05.295
<v Olivia Clark>Mm-hmm.

1220
02:21:05.921 --> 02:21:16.373
<v Olivia Clark>And then we had a lot of consideration of executive items from that bucket, and those included the 82nd Avenue project with PBOT.

1221
02:21:16.855 --> 02:21:20.629
<v Olivia Clark>We authorized the sale of the Sailwood Community House to community ownership.

1222
02:21:21.352 --> 02:21:27.914
<v Olivia Clark>We approved the city's next steps in renaming a portion of Southwest Jackson Street to Southwest Rose Hill Street.

1223
02:21:28.490 --> 02:21:32.389
<v Olivia Clark>We also monitored the Bull Run project.

1224
02:21:32.903 --> 02:21:42.786
<v Olivia Clark>We educated ourselves on the city's water management and conservation efforts, solid waste and recycling, innovative traffic safety and public rights-of-way projects.

1225
02:21:43.476 --> 02:21:56.363
<v Olivia Clark>And we heard from community members who were engaged in a complex of Uh, complex transportation projects, um, including from the city PBOT's modal committees, the Rose Quarter project stakeholders.

1226
02:21:56.620 --> 02:22:04.841
<v Olivia Clark>We took a tour of the Interstate Bridge project, um, and, uh, yeah, we did that in Washington.

1227
02:22:04.888 --> 02:22:05.818
<v Olivia Clark>That was interesting.

1228
02:22:06.492 --> 02:22:12.581
<v Olivia Clark>So looking ahead from now, uh, at least till the end of this year, I guess that's about 8 months or so.

1229
02:22:12.725 --> 02:22:12.885
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>8 Months.

1230
02:22:13.849 --> 02:22:24.108
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I— here's what I've got on my list, and I'd like to plan out the next, uh, 8 months as much as possible so we have some predictability.

1231
02:22:24.845 --> 02:22:31.493
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I'm not a big fan of taking up the full 3 hours if we can avoid it, but, um, but we do have plenty of time.

1232
02:22:32.263 --> 02:22:51.719
<v Olivia Clark>So of course we're going to follow up on asset management, and we're, we're due to get that report in September, and then the budget amendment said that they would also develop an asset management finance plan, which I know Councilor Green's very interested in, from September to December that we'll want to work on together.

1233
02:22:53.163 --> 02:22:58.036
<v Olivia Clark>I would like to get an update on the transportation system plan and really get my head around how that works.

1234
02:22:58.870 --> 02:23:08.123
<v Olivia Clark>We need to do some parks oversight now that parks is more squarely within the scope of this committee here in U.S. Folden into Public Works.

1235
02:23:08.172 --> 02:23:12.832
<v Olivia Clark>So we need to do some oversight of the, um, the parks levy.

1236
02:23:14.213 --> 02:23:28.371
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, I know that we are definitely going to consider, uh, and continue to talk about utility rates, and we may want to, um, do a deeper dive into the low-income program, but also in the future the possibility of restructuring the rates as well.

1237
02:23:28.451 --> 02:23:30.922
<v Olivia Clark>And I know Councilor Green has a strong interest in that.

1238
02:23:31.987 --> 02:23:41.878
<v Olivia Clark>I'd also like to receive, um, continued updates on the, um, facility, the Bull Run facility, and I'm hopeful that maybe we could take a tour, uh, this summer.

1239
02:23:42.825 --> 02:23:57.674
<v Olivia Clark>Um, depending on council action this week on the transportation utility fee and the street damage restoration fee, uh, if those pass, we want to closely monitor that and really exercise our oversight, um, because that's a really big deal.

1240
02:23:59.619 --> 02:24:02.326
<v Olivia Clark>So with that, those are just a few of the things.

1241
02:24:02.504 --> 02:24:06.777
<v Olivia Clark>I am planning out the next 8 months, so I'd really like to have your input.

1242
02:24:06.856 --> 02:24:12.828
<v Olivia Clark>And I haven't had the opportunity to share that with our Vice Chair yet, so I haven't gotten her input.

1243
02:24:12.894 --> 02:24:17.736
<v Olivia Clark>But I would really like to hear from you 3, the 3 of you.

1244
02:24:20.092 --> 02:24:20.835
<v Olivia Clark>Who wants to go first?

1245
02:24:20.899 --> 02:24:22.694
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Green, you want to go first?

1246
02:24:22.986 --> 02:24:23.536
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, thank you.

1247
02:24:25.054 --> 02:24:25.907
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Clark.

1248
02:24:26.004 --> 02:24:41.109
<v Mitch Green>I always really appreciate some space for a little bit more of a freeform visioning type of thing so we can not only get on the same page in the light of day, but, you know, share that with the community, you know?

1249
02:24:41.206 --> 02:24:46.297
<v Mitch Green>So I think for me, I mean, I like everything that you listed.

1250
02:24:46.345 --> 02:24:47.752
<v Mitch Green>I think those are all top priorities.

1251
02:24:47.816 --> 02:24:51.470
<v Mitch Green>I think your prioritization is, Is spot on for that work.

1252
02:24:51.519 --> 02:24:57.965
<v Mitch Green>I think my focus in the committee for the next year is going to be really on the rate design stuff.

1253
02:24:58.029 --> 02:24:58.975
<v Mitch Green>So you hinted at that.

1254
02:25:00.113 --> 02:25:08.164
<v Mitch Green>I think that— I don't think this city does rate hearings or rate cases on a very frequent basis the way that other utilities would.

1255
02:25:08.211 --> 02:25:10.584
<v Mitch Green>And I'd like to see us mature into that space a little bit.

1256
02:25:10.632 --> 02:25:16.838
<v Mitch Green>I know it comes— I know it requires resources of staff time, and there's a lot of public engagement.

1257
02:25:17.352 --> 02:25:24.245
<v Mitch Green>But I think, you know, whatever decisions we make on our big infrastructure projects, like, we pay for those through rates.

1258
02:25:24.325 --> 02:25:45.772
<v Mitch Green>And so if we can have a steady cadence every 2 years, every 5 years, whatever we think the right cadence is, where we run through a full rate case where we say, here's our costs, here's what our cost of service analysis shows us, here is our risk bands, like, this is our worst case, this is our best case, case, and here's our expectation for median to median.

1259
02:25:46.224 --> 02:25:48.368
<v Mitch Green>Also, here were other designs that we could contemplate.

1260
02:25:48.804 --> 02:26:02.559
<v Mitch Green>I think that gives the public an opportunity to really understand how it is we pay for infrastructure, but then also stress test to see whether or not there's some different designs that can allocate who pays and in what proportion.

1261
02:26:02.673 --> 02:26:08.609
<v Mitch Green>Because I mean, I think that we've got a little room to do on our, at least our water rate.

1262
02:26:09.022 --> 02:26:09.804
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

1263
02:26:09.916 --> 02:26:13.525
<v Mitch Green>I know we've talked a little bit internally about our BES rates as well.

1264
02:26:13.575 --> 02:26:15.183
<v Mitch Green>And so I'd like to have some of those discussions in public.

1265
02:26:16.939 --> 02:26:35.147
<v Mitch Green>I think based upon what this council does with the transportation utility fee, you know, I did put an amendment in to sort of explicitly say we should have rate design at least maybe like at least the possibility for it on an annual basis to create space for folks who might be dissatisfied with the proposal as it yes.

1266
02:26:36.110 --> 02:26:52.199
<v Mitch Green>I would love for our committee to make some space as soon as practical, probably couldn't be in the middle of budget, but maybe sometime this summer to begin a conversation on what an adjustment on rate design to the TUF might look like after we've adopted what we have on the floor.

1267
02:26:53.370 --> 02:26:58.460
<v Mitch Green>I think that could go a long ways to assuaging some of the concerns that are outside this building on that.

1268
02:26:58.590 --> 02:27:01.977
<v Mitch Green>And I think our committee should lead that sounds great.

1269
02:27:05.111 --> 02:27:16.096
<v Mitch Green>And then, you know, finally, I think strong, strong echo on oversight, but I would extend that to potentially other rate-making bodies in the city that we might have franchise regulation over.

1270
02:27:16.146 --> 02:27:25.300
<v Mitch Green>So we might want to have some kind of a hearing to pull in PG and Northwest Natural and the waste haulers to talk about rates with them.

1271
02:27:25.635 --> 02:27:26.636
<v Mitch Green>I think that could be really useful.

1272
02:27:27.343 --> 02:27:38.031
<v Mitch Green>Again, affordability is top of mind for Portlanders, and just making sure that they see that we are asking questions about their cost of service analysis and how they show up for the communities is also important.

1273
02:27:38.079 --> 02:27:38.786
<v Mitch Green>So just some ideas.

1274
02:27:39.764 --> 02:27:43.086
<v Olivia Clark>Would you mind if I— I just want to respond to that.

1275
02:27:43.135 --> 02:27:44.836
<v Olivia Clark>We can have more of a conversation here today.

1276
02:27:45.943 --> 02:27:57.308
<v Olivia Clark>I was going to raise the PGE, so I'm really glad you did, that we invite them in or other utilities to talk about their services, how they set their rates, whatever, just to educate ourselves.

1277
02:27:57.373 --> 02:28:01.371
<v Olivia Clark>I'm really glad you brought that up, and there's no sense in waiting.

1278
02:28:03.577 --> 02:28:08.396
<v Olivia Clark>I also wondered, you were talking about our own utilities.

1279
02:28:08.909 --> 02:28:17.344
<v Olivia Clark>You know, other communities have spun these off as independent special districts, like in Oakland.

1280
02:28:17.522 --> 02:28:19.816
<v Olivia Clark>They have, you know, their water and sewer— I think it's water and sewer.

1281
02:28:19.897 --> 02:28:20.799
<v Olivia Clark>Water and wastewater.

1282
02:28:21.729 --> 02:28:22.822
<v Olivia Clark>Is South Bay MUD.

1283
02:28:23.560 --> 02:28:26.708
<v Olivia Clark>The municipal utility is spun off from the city.

1284
02:28:27.173 --> 02:28:31.268
<v Olivia Clark>You know, that kind of— those kind of ideas we might want to just look at.

1285
02:28:31.829 --> 02:28:32.070
<v Olivia Clark>I don't know.

1286
02:28:32.150 --> 02:28:36.759
<v Olivia Clark>I don't want to scare anybody, but just thinking broadly about our utilities.

1287
02:28:36.807 --> 02:28:38.621
<v Olivia Clark>So I really appreciate your ideas.

1288
02:28:38.975 --> 02:28:46.843
<v Mitch Green>I mean, that's like, you know, I won't give you any opinion right now on what I think is the right answer for that, but that's exactly the kind of thing we should be talking in public Mm-hmm.

1289
02:28:47.004 --> 02:28:55.088
<v Mitch Green>So if we're contemplating creating a different public body, because SMUD, that's another municipal utility.

1290
02:28:55.824 --> 02:28:57.777
<v Mitch Green>It's still under public ownership, so I like that.

1291
02:28:57.841 --> 02:29:11.485
<v Mitch Green>But if we think that there's this other delivery system where it doesn't fall just on the City of Portland, but maybe it's like, maybe it's something that the consortium might step into to consider, maybe a joint management tenancy, those are conversations that are important to have in public.

1292
02:29:13.014 --> 02:29:13.978
<v Olivia Clark>Cool, that's great.

1293
02:29:14.685 --> 02:29:18.106
<v Olivia Clark>Um, okay, uh, Councilor Smith, we're just talking now.

1294
02:29:18.620 --> 02:29:23.230
<v Olivia Clark>We reviewed what we did in the past, and now we're just talking about the things that we want to focus on in the future.

1295
02:29:23.360 --> 02:29:24.789
<v Olivia Clark>So, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1296
02:29:25.704 --> 02:29:26.122
<v Ting Lu>Thank you.

1297
02:29:26.492 --> 02:29:29.944
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>First, I want to genuinely say thank you, Chair Clark.

1298
02:29:30.105 --> 02:29:34.587
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I appreciate how you take time to hear from us and how you're open.

1299
02:29:35.165 --> 02:29:39.344
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I've shared this before, but I have learned a lot from watching you lead this committee.

1300
02:29:39.458 --> 02:29:44.119
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Your organization approach, the way you run these meetings, has taught me a lot.

1301
02:29:45.123 --> 02:29:54.122
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So adding on, I heard this said already, feeling hopeful that the transportation utility fee and the street damage restoration fee will hopefully pass.

1302
02:29:54.836 --> 02:30:07.299
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I like the idea of this committee being committed to continuing to hear updates about especially the TUF and including how it's being implemented, how it's What the impacts are to Portlanders.

1303
02:30:07.878 --> 02:30:13.887
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I'm interested in more of these conversations that Councilor Green is interested in about rate design.

1304
02:30:14.465 --> 02:30:21.679
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I still— I want to continue to explore some of the other transportation and infrastructure funding options.

1305
02:30:21.727 --> 02:30:35.974
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>We started talking about some different ones, and part of the conversation was around EASE and if we were ready to implement some of those, but would love to keep exploring exploring funding options that don't place an additional burden on our residents.

1306
02:30:36.638 --> 02:30:49.460
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So we had talked about fees on food delivery, package delivery services, different mechanisms that can better align costs with also the corporate use of our roads.

1307
02:30:51.020 --> 02:31:06.210
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I would like to hear updates on programs like the bike bus programs and Safe Routes to Schools, especially since there have been cuts at the state level that will impact us, and I'd like us to know what those effects are.

1308
02:31:09.149 --> 02:31:09.653
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>Let's see.

1309
02:31:09.734 --> 02:31:14.216
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Yeah, making sure that we're partnering with schools and community organizations in that area.

1310
02:31:14.768 --> 02:31:24.096
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'd like us to talk some more about tactical urbanism and just maybe get some education around that and talk around possibilities, maybe our committee.

1311
02:31:24.210 --> 02:31:24.405
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Thank you.

1312
02:31:24.916 --> 02:31:28.806
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can have a chance to learn a bit more and discuss tactical urbanism.

1313
02:31:28.870 --> 02:31:37.900
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>It's low-cost, quick-build approaches and allows us to test different safety improvements before making permanent investments.

1314
02:31:38.897 --> 02:31:43.814
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Can help us move faster, figure out what works, engage community in the process.

1315
02:31:44.039 --> 02:31:56.379
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And we can look to a lot of other cities like Austin, Nashville, Atlanta, and New York City has a notorious example of tactical urbanism in the way that they've transformed Times Square into a pedestrian zone.

1316
02:31:56.827 --> 02:32:12.404
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>So, and I also think about how tactical urbanism can really go hand in hand with conversations that we've had, Chair Clark, about ways to create meaningful hands-on volunteer opportunities and give community members a direct role in the city.

1317
02:32:12.579 --> 02:32:16.088
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so, and for this, it can be building safer streets or other opportunities.

1318
02:32:17.530 --> 02:32:26.046
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And then a big one that I have is I'd like to request a commitment to us getting regular Vision Zero updates at this committee.

1319
02:32:27.808 --> 02:32:42.507
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think I've talked to our citywide Vision Zero lead and saying that maybe the first one can be about 20 minutes, but if she could even be coming ideally every other month or so, we could have 10 to 15 minutes just to ask questions.

1320
02:32:43.407 --> 02:32:53.092
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think that helps with consistency, accountability, keeps the work visible, ensures that we're tracking progress towards eliminating traffic deaths.

1321
02:32:53.269 --> 02:33:01.271
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I appreciate how City Administrator Lee is adding a section to his report each month about Vision Zero.

1322
02:33:01.561 --> 02:33:08.694
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I know that we've been getting regular updates on when there are crashes in our district and also monthly data.

1323
02:33:09.083 --> 02:33:13.125
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And this is something that I know Mayor Wilson has been talking a lot more about.

1324
02:33:13.494 --> 02:33:21.027
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Our citywide Vision Zero lead said he consistently is the person that actually emails back when those emails go out about there being fatalities.

1325
02:33:21.203 --> 02:33:26.070
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And so it's great to hear that more folks are, are really talking about this.

1326
02:33:27.147 --> 02:33:43.028
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I think for us to all know too, we have— we're pulled in so many different directions, but that we have a citywide Vision Zero lead who's willing to meet with any councilor, any district, to talk specifically about each of our districts and, um, how we can be making sure that we are tackling traffic fatalities.

1327
02:33:43.742 --> 02:33:49.472
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Um, so thank you again, Chair Clark, for your leadership, openness, and your support, um, especially around Vision Zero.

1328
02:33:49.538 --> 02:33:52.853
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And I see you nodding that we can, um, hopefully have an update.

1329
02:33:52.903 --> 02:34:01.503
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>I'm hoping we can bring her maybe before the end of this fiscal year for a short meeting, um, to this committee to come, come meet with us.

1330
02:34:01.729 --> 02:34:03.944
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>And, um, I'll follow up with you and your team.

1331
02:34:04.250 --> 02:34:04.909
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1332
02:34:04.989 --> 02:34:07.036
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1333
02:34:07.084 --> 02:34:08.372
<v Olivia Clark>That's a great list.

1334
02:34:08.452 --> 02:34:11.496
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate some of these other ideas I hadn't thought of.

1335
02:34:12.389 --> 02:34:14.695
<v Olivia Clark>I love what you said too about volunteer opportunities.

1336
02:34:14.761 --> 02:34:14.792
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>I—.

1337
02:34:15.003 --> 02:34:19.970
<v Olivia Clark>And I hope you're not talking about pothole vigilantes, are you?

1338
02:34:20.632 --> 02:34:21.551
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>No, I'm not.

1339
02:34:21.617 --> 02:34:36.757
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>But I do think the more opportunities that we have for community members to be engaged and to be part of the process, The, the more likely that maybe people won't fill potholes, or else if people don't feel like they're part of it, they're going to find some way to be part of it.

1340
02:34:37.592 --> 02:34:38.441
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much.

1341
02:34:39.341 --> 02:34:40.688
<v Olivia Clark>Uh, Councilor Smith.

1342
02:34:41.185 --> 02:34:46.832
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, uh, Councilor Clark— Chairwoman Clark, Vice President Clark.

1343
02:34:47.602 --> 02:34:51.036
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I have to give you all your titles.

1344
02:34:51.772 --> 02:34:54.837
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I, I think this is an excellent opportunity to go back.

1345
02:34:54.902 --> 02:35:10.245
<v Loretta Smith>I want to go back to something that we started earlier today, and I have to forgive folks, forgive me, to ask for forgiveness because I was not clear on what actually was taking place when we were doing eminent domain.

1346
02:35:10.470 --> 02:35:10.922
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1347
02:35:11.003 --> 02:35:24.903
<v Loretta Smith>And so I think we need to come up with some rules of engagement on how our departments bring us eminent domain, because first of all, eminent domain is a real serious thing.

1348
02:35:25.817 --> 02:35:32.463
<v Loretta Smith>And people need to know first that when you do eminent domain, it's because that's the nuclear option.

1349
02:35:33.218 --> 02:35:43.605
<v Loretta Smith>There obviously have been, um, conversations with trying to, to, to get the easement without eminent domain.

1350
02:35:43.815 --> 02:35:49.882
<v Loretta Smith>And so when things don't work, and the public should know that, that's the tool that we use.

1351
02:35:50.477 --> 02:35:59.906
<v Loretta Smith>And if we're using the tool tool, that tool first without trying to have a conversation with, with getting the easement without eminent domain, there's a problem.

1352
02:36:00.659 --> 02:36:20.236
<v Loretta Smith>Secondly, and once you decide that this is— this has got— gotten to the point where we need to put that in place, uh, there should be an executive session on eminent domain so that you can discuss, um, the kinds of resources that you're going to need to put forward to be able to do that.

1353
02:36:20.300 --> 02:36:31.218
<v Loretta Smith>And so for me, that is so important for us to know that first because it just caught me off guard and I had some questions to it and I just thought it was just a regular easement.

1354
02:36:31.282 --> 02:36:39.584
<v Loretta Smith>I didn't realize it was, and it's right up in the first paragraph, but I was looking at it just a regular easement that we were paying for.

1355
02:36:39.647 --> 02:36:44.577
<v Loretta Smith>But then when it dawned on me that they were asking for eminent domain, I—.

1356
02:36:44.801 --> 02:36:45.444
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1357
02:36:47.402 --> 02:36:50.188
<v Loretta Smith>Initially, I got real concerned.

1358
02:36:51.492 --> 02:36:53.377
<v Loretta Smith>Not troubled, but I was concerned.

1359
02:36:53.940 --> 02:36:57.250
<v Olivia Clark>Can I just clarify for the public that eminent domain is a takings?

1360
02:36:57.509 --> 02:36:58.977
<v Olivia Clark>We're taking something, right?

1361
02:36:59.284 --> 02:36:59.414
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

1362
02:36:59.542 --> 02:37:00.206
<v Loretta Smith>Yes, ma'am.

1363
02:37:00.657 --> 02:37:07.543
<v Loretta Smith>And eminent domain is the thing that they took with the Albina descendants, and they did not give them anything for their property at all.

1364
02:37:07.608 --> 02:37:13.198
<v Loretta Smith>And that's why we had to go back and take care of a historical wrong and make it right.

1365
02:37:14.006 --> 02:37:16.282
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, this is the other issue too.

1366
02:37:17.292 --> 02:37:24.218
<v Loretta Smith>Um, if I had to go back again and, and ask some more questions, I probably would have asked some, some other questions.

1367
02:37:24.281 --> 02:37:34.990
<v Loretta Smith>Because when I looked at our protocol afterwards, I pulled up our protocol for the City of Portland and as it relates to eminent domain, and there is supposed to be a public conversation.

1368
02:37:35.808 --> 02:37:42.763
<v Loretta Smith>And so I don't know if there was a public conversation with with the residence owners, and they said in front of council.

1369
02:37:43.356 --> 02:37:52.891
<v Loretta Smith>And I didn't see anybody here who was a resident, and I don't know if they're— and, and it was specific that they have to be in front of council.

1370
02:37:53.676 --> 02:38:05.630
<v Loretta Smith>And so I think we need to be briefed, um, by the city administrator and the mayors to, to, to let us know about how eminent domain should go.

1371
02:38:06.352 --> 02:38:16.820
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm willing to, um, to draft with any one of my committee members some, uh, rules of engagement on how we will do that because this came fairly quickly.

1372
02:38:17.174 --> 02:38:18.536
<v Loretta Smith>But there's another issue too.

1373
02:38:19.161 --> 02:38:31.120
<v Loretta Smith>The issue is that we don't find out about these things until Friday at noon, that we know what's going to be on the, the physical agenda.

1374
02:38:31.825 --> 02:38:35.948
<v Loretta Smith>And I find that very— it's hard to plan for.

1375
02:38:36.989 --> 02:38:38.209
<v Loretta Smith>It is really hard to plan for.

1376
02:38:38.256 --> 02:38:45.425
<v Loretta Smith>And we didn't do this, and I hate to keep talking about Multnomah County, but we were able to see what was on the agenda further than a week in advance.

1377
02:38:45.554 --> 02:38:47.846
<v Loretta Smith>And so I could have conversations with people.

1378
02:38:48.601 --> 02:38:56.506
<v Loretta Smith>And so I'm not able to have that conversation, particularly with this group, is because I only have a day to make those calls.

1379
02:38:56.716 --> 02:38:57.181
<v Loretta Smith>Mm-hmm.

1380
02:38:57.325 --> 02:39:00.291
<v Loretta Smith>And we were going over it on Friday in my district office.

1381
02:39:00.468 --> 02:39:01.638
<v Loretta Smith>And so we were having the conversation.

1382
02:39:01.976 --> 02:39:03.918
<v Loretta Smith>Thought that it was something different.

1383
02:39:04.673 --> 02:39:05.958
<v Olivia Clark>Can I interrupt you just for a second?

1384
02:39:06.005 --> 02:39:14.002
<v Olivia Clark>I think, um, you and I will be meeting and sitting down and plotting out— we're going to know in advance, well in advance, what's coming.

1385
02:39:14.099 --> 02:39:17.453
<v Olivia Clark>Maybe not the absolute specifics about it, but we, we will know what's coming.

1386
02:39:18.129 --> 02:39:22.575
<v Loretta Smith>And so also in the future, I'd like to get more information around road maintenance.

1387
02:39:22.625 --> 02:39:35.433
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm off the eminent domain, um, road maintenance, uh, Of course, I am so into making sure that potholes and paving and road repairs are things that we do.

1388
02:39:35.513 --> 02:39:43.288
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm very much in support of SIP and figuring out how to do that and what that looks like.

1389
02:39:43.772 --> 02:39:53.328
<v Loretta Smith>And as it relates to waste management, I think there calls for some discussions on garbage collection, recycling programs, and litter control.

1390
02:39:54.597 --> 02:39:59.318
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, water supply and sewage issues related to water, uh, quality.

1391
02:39:59.431 --> 02:40:04.906
<v Loretta Smith>And I think we, we will be doing a lot of that because of our, um, Bull Run.

1392
02:40:04.970 --> 02:40:08.118
<v Loretta Smith>We'll be having that plumbing and, and, and all those things.

1393
02:40:08.165 --> 02:40:17.190
<v Loretta Smith>And parks and recreation, um, there's a lot of opportunity there, uh, the maintenance of our public parks, our playgrounds, and our recreational facilities.

1394
02:40:17.254 --> 02:40:22.950
<v Loretta Smith>And we do a lot of programming Um, that's paid for outside of the city in our parks.

1395
02:40:23.575 --> 02:40:33.344
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, I would like you to join me because I'm going to go on a parks tour in my district, and I'm going to go to every single park in District 1.

1396
02:40:34.323 --> 02:40:44.685
<v Loretta Smith>And, um, whether it be, uh, attending their lunch programs or any other recreational programs, I'm going to know every single park in my district.

1397
02:40:44.765 --> 02:40:49.032
<v Loretta Smith>And that is, um, it's going to be the Smith that is so cool.

1398
02:40:49.081 --> 02:40:50.058
<v Olivia Clark>You're going to invite all of us?

1399
02:40:50.363 --> 02:40:51.054
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, I'll invite you.

1400
02:40:51.102 --> 02:40:52.209
<v Olivia Clark>You're going to give us advance notice?

1401
02:40:52.289 --> 02:40:53.363
<v Loretta Smith>I'll give you advance notice.

1402
02:40:53.427 --> 02:40:54.519
<v Loretta Smith>I'll give you advance notice.

1403
02:40:55.610 --> 02:40:58.305
<v Loretta Smith>Safety and accessibility, you know, infrastructure.

1404
02:40:58.641 --> 02:41:09.534
<v Loretta Smith>And when you come back with the asset management report, and I'll be looking through a lens of safety and accessibility to our infrastructure and what that looks like.

1405
02:41:10.336 --> 02:41:21.054
<v Loretta Smith>I think that pedestrians, cyclists, Cyclists, sidewalks, bike lanes, those kinds of things we need to be clear about.

1406
02:41:21.183 --> 02:41:24.134
<v Loretta Smith>But we own a lot of assets.

1407
02:41:24.634 --> 02:41:26.634
<v Loretta Smith>$85 billion.

1408
02:41:26.827 --> 02:41:27.038
<v Keelan McClymont>Oh my God.

1409
02:41:27.457 --> 02:41:29.474
<v Loretta Smith>$85 billion worth of assets.

1410
02:41:29.716 --> 02:41:30.555
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah.

1411
02:41:33.103 --> 02:41:39.245
<v Loretta Smith>And just the whole public funding and budgeting and how we allocate the restricted funds and those kinds of things.

1412
02:41:39.847 --> 02:41:48.707
<v Loretta Smith>And I think we get a, we get a bunch of opportunity when we get these multifaceted, um, uh, ordinances to do things.

1413
02:41:48.899 --> 02:41:50.617
<v Loretta Smith>It, it crosses a lot of different things.

1414
02:41:50.665 --> 02:41:56.394
<v Loretta Smith>So we're talking about easements, and then we're talking about eminent domain, and then we're talking about transportation.

1415
02:41:56.859 --> 02:41:59.218
<v Loretta Smith>So it's, it all comes together.

1416
02:41:59.877 --> 02:42:03.536
<v Loretta Smith>This is, um, I am so lucky.

1417
02:42:03.584 --> 02:42:09.540
<v Loretta Smith>I'm, I'm, I'm happy to be sitting in the vice chair to you because you have so much information.

1418
02:42:09.588 --> 02:42:15.595
<v Loretta Smith>And then I have my finance guru over here sitting to my left, Professor Green.

1419
02:42:16.013 --> 02:42:18.825
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, oh my, they gave you a different title.

1420
02:42:18.921 --> 02:42:20.592
<v Mitch Green>It's a different day of the week.

1421
02:42:20.849 --> 02:42:24.929
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, so I, I appreciate you.

1422
02:42:25.088 --> 02:42:35.637
<v Loretta Smith>And, uh, and, uh, Councilor Koyama Lane, you always bring a community element, asking about how the community, um, really is going to be impacted by things.

1423
02:42:35.700 --> 02:42:38.958
<v Loretta Smith>And so I really appreciate those kinds of, um, conversations.

1424
02:42:39.615 --> 02:42:43.240
<v Loretta Smith>And, and I know that, uh, Councilor Kanal— I don't know if he's here—.

1425
02:42:43.240 --> 02:42:43.336
<v Muriel Gueza-Teufel>Yes.

1426
02:42:43.721 --> 02:42:49.064
<v Loretta Smith>But he, um, he also brings that community lens, and he's very technical too.

1427
02:42:49.111 --> 02:42:56.763
<v Loretta Smith>So we have a good group of people who, who care about the, the public works, uh, side of the city.

1428
02:42:57.100 --> 02:43:00.551
<v Loretta Smith>And I think this is going to be, uh, Very, very good.

1429
02:43:01.023 --> 02:43:01.674
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

1430
02:43:01.805 --> 02:43:03.416
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, Councilor Smith.

1431
02:43:04.165 --> 02:43:05.208
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate your comments.

1432
02:43:06.245 --> 02:43:07.538
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Kanal, great to see you.

1433
02:43:07.635 --> 02:43:11.768
<v Olivia Clark>And we did mention you at the beginning as our new member.

1434
02:43:11.994 --> 02:43:14.770
<v Olivia Clark>You weren't here, but we did give you a shout out.

1435
02:43:16.649 --> 02:43:18.387
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Chair Clark.

1436
02:43:19.783 --> 02:43:24.623
<v Sameer Kanal>First, let me say how excited I am to join this committee, even though I can't be there in person due to traveling this week.

1437
02:43:25.552 --> 02:43:32.331
<v Sameer Kanal>But yeah, honored to join it, honored to be District 2's first representative at the table for transportation, infrastructure, utilities.

1438
02:43:33.789 --> 02:43:42.024
<v Sameer Kanal>I think the core thing that I bring to this, and I know it overlaps with many of you, is the things that you directly interact with as a Portlander tangibly.

1439
02:43:42.394 --> 02:43:47.073
<v Sameer Kanal>So I could spend all my time talking about potholes, potholes, and potholes, but I'll probably get to that in future meetings.

1440
02:43:47.184 --> 02:43:51.415
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll start with some themes of things I'd love to see on the agenda.

1441
02:43:52.394 --> 02:43:53.117
<v Sameer Kanal>First, safety.

1442
02:43:53.197 --> 02:43:58.399
<v Sameer Kanal>Safe routes to school was the first thing on my campaign platform, and I view it as a leading indicator or metric.

1443
02:43:58.479 --> 02:44:06.186
<v Sameer Kanal>The things that you would have to do to make it safe for children to get to and from school also make it safer for everyone to get around regardless of their mode of travel.

1444
02:44:07.005 --> 02:44:11.566
<v Sameer Kanal>We have some work to do because of the state's inaction on this, and I'm excited to get into that.

1445
02:44:12.867 --> 02:44:17.024
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think this is about having a particular focus on vulnerable and historically underserved communities.

1446
02:44:17.361 --> 02:44:18.292
<v Sameer Kanal>Communities.

1447
02:44:18.388 --> 02:44:28.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Infrastructure is pipes and pavement, but it's about people, uh, and ensuring that our systems are reliable, resilient, protective for those who've been historically underserved is a huge part of this.

1448
02:44:29.220 --> 02:44:30.809
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, second, affordability.

1449
02:44:31.147 --> 02:44:32.270
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I'm a renter.

1450
02:44:32.367 --> 02:44:35.271
<v Sameer Kanal>I know how utility costs can stretch already tight budgets.

1451
02:44:35.318 --> 02:44:39.459
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm committed to making sure our systems work for everyone, not just those who can most easily afford them.

1452
02:44:40.052 --> 02:44:43.921
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, this isn't just about costs that we directly assess to Portlanders either.

1453
02:44:44.386 --> 02:44:47.656
<v Sameer Kanal>But about the costs we create when we choose not to be involved in something.

1454
02:44:48.154 --> 02:44:55.835
<v Sameer Kanal>My car repair costs are higher in Portland than they have been in any other city I've driven in because of the state of our roads.

1455
02:44:56.413 --> 02:45:08.022
<v Sameer Kanal>And if I knew for certain that a fee that I would pay would help people like me avoid large, unpredictable car repair costs, that would make me overwhelmingly supportive of it.

1456
02:45:08.311 --> 02:45:10.764
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's about making sure that we can guarantee that.

1457
02:45:11.005 --> 02:45:12.111
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, as part of the process.

1458
02:45:12.625 --> 02:45:18.846
<v Sameer Kanal>And this also applies in the context of fixing our ratio of road users, meaning residents, to road miles.

1459
02:45:19.280 --> 02:45:26.930
<v Sameer Kanal>We're in a structural problem there, um, and I want to talk about how we get out of it because costs are going up, making road miles more and more expensive.

1460
02:45:26.977 --> 02:45:31.595
<v Sameer Kanal>And without the density to make that work, we're going to be constantly falling behind.

1461
02:45:32.414 --> 02:45:34.162
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, 3rd, equity in service delivery.

1462
02:45:34.738 --> 02:45:39.536
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, every Portlander deserving access to fair uh, fair access to essential services.

1463
02:45:40.113 --> 02:45:48.592
<v Sameer Kanal>But I'll also just take a moment to talk about ensuring that District 2 gets the investments it needs for road safety and reducing road deaths.

1464
02:45:48.961 --> 02:45:56.603
<v Sameer Kanal>This happened in 2024 when District 3's deaths declined by over 50% due to investments that occurred there.

1465
02:45:57.134 --> 02:46:02.336
<v Sameer Kanal>It happened in 2025 where District 1's deaths declined by over 50%.

1466
02:46:03.877 --> 02:46:16.600
<v Sameer Kanal>And as the first representative in this committee from District 2, which now has the highest traffic deaths in the city, I want that same level of focus we saw in those other 2 districts in the last 2 years to happen in 2026 in District 2.

1467
02:46:17.336 --> 02:46:24.852
<v Sameer Kanal>Because had they, 10 of my constituents would be alive today that weren't— that didn't make it through 2025.

1468
02:46:25.045 --> 02:46:27.479
<v Sameer Kanal>And the final theme I'll mention is good governance.

1469
02:46:27.528 --> 02:46:29.498
<v Sameer Kanal>So strong oversight, accountability.

1470
02:46:29.835 --> 02:46:30.688
<v Sameer Kanal>And thoughtful management.

1471
02:46:30.736 --> 02:46:37.837
<v Sameer Kanal>I did get to hear the presentation earlier from the Public Works service area about the oversight portion.

1472
02:46:37.886 --> 02:46:48.395
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm excited to get into that conversation as well, and looking forward to the leadership that has been brought by DCA Dunlap on that side, but also by you, Chair Clark.

1473
02:46:48.957 --> 02:46:55.449
<v Sameer Kanal>A couple specific projects I'm interested in, and these— I'm going to use some specific locations, but it's really about the policy.

1474
02:46:55.865 --> 02:47:08.845
<v Sameer Kanal>I look at the folks who live on Trenton or by McCoy Park or by the Montessori School on Lombard and Mississippi, places where schools and students are and the crosswalks aren't, or on MLK where pedestrians have a long and now recent history of trauma from drivers.

1475
02:47:09.279 --> 02:47:19.514
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think about opening the doors to greater levels of painting and repainting crosswalks, which is very cost effective, and then where possible, adding in other crossing safety measures like islands and lighting.

1476
02:47:19.948 --> 02:47:25.809
<v Sameer Kanal>I look at daylighting, which Is to say ensuring visibility at intersections by setting back parking from the corner.

1477
02:47:26.411 --> 02:47:28.747
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm looking at a proposal I've received from community.

1478
02:47:30.000 --> 02:47:38.998
<v Sameer Kanal>These are folks who may at some point become vigilantes, and I hope that we can make them volunteers instead by allowing more people to repaint their corners when the paint there fails.

1479
02:47:40.340 --> 02:47:41.115
<v Sameer Kanal>I look at utility rates.

1480
02:47:41.181 --> 02:47:47.538
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with everything that Councilor Green said, but I wanted to add in higher unit pricing at the higher usage levels.

1481
02:47:47.585 --> 02:47:47.635
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1482
02:47:48.009 --> 02:47:58.558
<v Sameer Kanal>So that extremely high usage entities like data centers, the type that force investment in expanding production and transmission, are paying their fair share of that required investment with higher per unit rates.

1483
02:47:59.577 --> 02:48:00.985
<v Sameer Kanal>Looking at improving engagement.

1484
02:48:01.033 --> 02:48:06.146
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's not just the people who live on the block, but everyone who uses a road that gets to weigh in on its future.

1485
02:48:06.639 --> 02:48:11.947
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm thinking about the area up by Columbia Park and the Columbia Annex right now on that.

1486
02:48:12.579 --> 02:48:18.664
<v Sameer Kanal>And then, um, I'm excited to discuss parks as well, get to work on ensuring maintenance adherence to the levy.

1487
02:48:19.081 --> 02:48:33.189
<v Sameer Kanal>But I really want to talk about, uh, also the, the work on community centers, protecting and expanding community centers as a public safety investment by giving young people a place to go, but also as a free third space for more and more Portlanders to use.

1488
02:48:33.765 --> 02:48:50.486
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think that this committee can talk about third spaces quite a bit because of community centers, but also because of free plazas and Sunday parkways and a lot of the things that the Public Works service area does to make free and available parts of our city that are historically pay-to-play.

1489
02:48:51.032 --> 02:48:52.558
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm excited for that going forward.

1490
02:48:53.073 --> 02:48:53.972
<v Sameer Kanal>So thanks.

1491
02:48:54.968 --> 02:48:55.805
<v Olivia Clark>That's terrific.

1492
02:48:56.093 --> 02:48:58.134
<v Olivia Clark>I really appreciate your list, Councilor Kanal.

1493
02:48:58.199 --> 02:49:00.218
<v Olivia Clark>We're really happy to have you join us.

1494
02:49:00.865 --> 02:49:20.083
<v Olivia Clark>As you were talking, I was just thinking that about Vision Zero and bike buses that we used to call, when I was in the environmental field, we used to call salmon the indicator species, that if the water is good for salmon, that it's good for everyone.

1495
02:49:20.210 --> 02:49:31.257
<v Olivia Clark>And I think that if our streets are safe for children and for the elderly, they're our indicator species for the rest of us, just to use an analogy.

1496
02:49:32.320 --> 02:49:34.888
<v Olivia Clark>And I also appreciate your comment about vigilantism.

1497
02:49:35.001 --> 02:49:45.359
<v Olivia Clark>I think we actually could train people to repaint area— their sidewalks or whatever, but I love the idea of expanding that as well.

1498
02:49:45.440 --> 02:49:47.219
<v Olivia Clark>So great, great list.

1499
02:49:48.752 --> 02:49:50.121
<v Olivia Clark>Anything else for the good of the order?

1500
02:49:50.202 --> 02:49:53.573
<v Olivia Clark>We've got quite a lot to do in the next 8 months.

1501
02:49:53.751 --> 02:49:56.266
<v Olivia Clark>Any other final thoughts before we adjourn?

1502
02:49:56.396 --> 02:49:57.604
<v Olivia Clark>And I do have a couple of announcements.

1503
02:50:01.000 --> 02:50:01.095
<v Michael McGee>Sure.

1504
02:50:01.176 --> 02:50:01.805
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, Councilor Green.

1505
02:50:02.224 --> 02:50:03.770
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I think— thanks so much.

1506
02:50:04.333 --> 02:50:05.879
<v Mitch Green>Uh, again, appreciate this discussion.

1507
02:50:05.927 --> 02:50:21.779
<v Mitch Green>I think that for us, um, the, the work of this committee is to sort of really remind folks that, you know, good assets require maintenance, but we are taking very seriously the, uh, life cycle costs and the prioritization exercise.

1508
02:50:21.877 --> 02:50:37.807
<v Mitch Green>And this is the committee where we want to prioritize that work and make sure that we are giving tools to the city to execute on that and, um, and continuing to sort of invest in our active transportation and, um, you know, link those costs with the benefits that we have is basically what I'm trying to say.

1509
02:50:38.288 --> 02:50:46.698
<v Mitch Green>Because if we don't, then we run the risk of, um, our, our community members just sort of not knowing that we're doing great things and that there are opportunities.

1510
02:50:46.745 --> 02:50:49.459
<v Mitch Green>Like you mentioned the low-income discount program earlier in the session today.

1511
02:50:49.522 --> 02:50:51.513
<v Mitch Green>Like, those things exist and and it's not clear everyone knows about it.

1512
02:50:51.563 --> 02:50:55.338
<v Mitch Green>So, um, I'm really excited to be on this committee again.

1513
02:50:55.387 --> 02:50:59.033
<v Mitch Green>I'll appreciate, uh, serving with you on, on, on this committee.

1514
02:50:59.210 --> 02:51:00.560
<v Mitch Green>So, uh, thanks for having me.

1515
02:51:00.770 --> 02:51:02.344
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1516
02:51:02.698 --> 02:51:04.159
<v Olivia Clark>I, I appreciate your comments.

1517
02:51:04.385 --> 02:51:13.881
<v Olivia Clark>Um, yes, you know, as Councilor Smith said, I think we own about $85 billion of assets, and the majority of those fall under Public Works.

1518
02:51:14.122 --> 02:51:17.063
<v Olivia Clark>So we do have a real responsibility As a committee.

1519
02:51:18.201 --> 02:51:22.921
<v Olivia Clark>Okay, so let me just make a couple of announcements and we'll get it out of here before the 3 hours.

1520
02:51:23.739 --> 02:51:31.379
<v Olivia Clark>Um, because of the budget process that we're beginning to undergo, um, it's going to get really intense.

1521
02:51:31.523 --> 02:51:35.873
<v Olivia Clark>We're only going to have one meeting of this committee in May.

1522
02:51:36.274 --> 02:51:40.175
<v Olivia Clark>We've only been given one, so we'll curate that carefully.

1523
02:51:40.945 --> 02:51:47.282
<v Olivia Clark>But just so you know, we unfortunately will not be meeting again and my gosh, that's well over a month away.

1524
02:51:48.532 --> 02:51:56.916
<v Olivia Clark>Um, and at that meeting, I was really hoping to have an update of the transportation systems plan and maybe a couple items from Parks.

1525
02:51:56.965 --> 02:52:06.840
<v Olivia Clark>But what I'll do is take all the input that you have, um, shared, colleagues, and we'll put it in the blender and we'll figure out, um, what goes where.

1526
02:52:07.064 --> 02:52:19.582
<v Olivia Clark>And I'll do that in conjunction with, um, my vice chair here, Councilor so, um, if there aren't any other comments, I'm going to adjourn the meeting of the— of what's now the Public Works Committee.

1527
02:52:19.984 --> 02:52:22.728
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

