WEBVTT

1
00:01:58.090 --> 00:02:27.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Morning.

2
00:02:27.750 --> 00:02:28.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Good afternoon.

3
00:02:28.069 --> 00:02:33.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is 2 o'clock on Tuesday, April 14th.

4
00:02:33.707 --> 00:02:37.925
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am calling to order the first meeting of the City Life Committee.

5
00:02:38.750 --> 00:02:40.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could you please call the roll?

6
00:02:41.693 --> 00:02:41.919
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Ryan.

7
00:02:43.806 --> 00:02:43.919
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

8
00:02:44.456 --> 00:02:45.106
<v Jules Bailey>Murillo.

9
00:02:46.406 --> 00:02:46.534
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

10
00:02:47.229 --> 00:02:47.584
<v Courtney Varano>Timmerman.

11
00:02:49.149 --> 00:02:49.455
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Avalos.

12
00:02:50.375 --> 00:02:50.665
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

13
00:02:51.424 --> 00:02:51.828
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney.

14
00:02:52.617 --> 00:02:52.860
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Here.

15
00:02:53.828 --> 00:02:56.187
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Christopher, could you please read our rules of order and decorum?

16
00:02:57.063 --> 00:02:58.817
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome to the meeting of the City Life Committee.

17
00:02:58.866 --> 00:03:10.806
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance in advance in the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/committee-life-committee or by calling 311.

18
00:03:11.258 --> 00:03:13.518
<v Dan Ryan>Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

19
00:03:13.905 --> 00:03:16.632
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

20
00:03:16.745 --> 00:03:19.508
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

21
00:03:19.896 --> 00:03:24.713
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If public testimony will be taken on an item, individuals may testify for 3 minutes unless the chair states otherwise.

22
00:03:25.052 --> 00:03:26.737
<v Dan Ryan>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

23
00:03:27.177 --> 00:03:28.057
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The chair preserves order.

24
00:03:28.139 --> 00:03:38.830
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations further disruption will result in ejection from the meeting.

25
00:03:38.961 --> 00:03:41.634
<v Dan Ryan>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

26
00:03:42.789 --> 00:03:45.080
<v Eric Engstrom>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

27
00:03:45.564 --> 00:03:47.485
<v Eric Engstrom>Your testimony should address the matter being considered.

28
00:03:47.743 --> 00:03:49.373
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When testifying, state your name for the record.

29
00:03:49.502 --> 00:03:51.859
<v Eric Engstrom>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

30
00:03:52.150 --> 00:03:54.560
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

31
00:03:54.735 --> 00:03:54.961
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

32
00:03:56.181 --> 00:03:56.680
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

33
00:03:59.314 --> 00:04:03.704
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, of all the new committees that have been put together, in some ways this one feels the most new.

34
00:04:06.042 --> 00:04:17.834
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our portfolio combines what used to be parts of or all of the work of 3 separate committees, and I don't believe that any of us sat on all 3 of those last time around.

35
00:04:18.651 --> 00:04:32.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So while many of the things that we will do will be a continuation of work that those committees did, many of the themes are the same of the themes in those committees, and I know that a few of you sat on one or more of those previous committees.

36
00:04:32.992 --> 00:04:41.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Getting to talk about these issues together and in light of the themes that we're bringing in from each of those committees is a new space for our council.

37
00:04:41.891 --> 00:04:49.507
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm immensely optimistic about the work ahead of us and about the perspectives that the 5 of us together bring as we do that work.

38
00:04:50.213 --> 00:05:00.778
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know we all care deeply about the city and the constituencies who we will be hearing from in this work, and that we all bring important and unique experiences to the table.

39
00:05:01.838 --> 00:05:04.178
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope that we can hold on to that as we do this work.

40
00:05:04.564 --> 00:05:15.194
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will try to ensure that we hear from a broad group of Portlanders who represent the various perspectives and experiences we will need to hear to bring all of these ideas together as well.

41
00:05:16.446 --> 00:05:21.545
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The City Life Committee is focused on the day-to-day lived experiences of Portlanders.

42
00:05:22.779 --> 00:05:27.687
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll consider policies that define what it's like to live, work, and play in our city.

43
00:05:28.810 --> 00:05:41.987
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our mission entails a broad set of issues: economic development, labor, workforce, climate resilience, sustainability, tourism, parks programming, arts, entertainment, sports, and more.

44
00:05:43.302 --> 00:05:57.329
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To orient us and Portlanders to our assignment, my office has developed a framework which I hope will serve as a useful starting point, though I assume it will shift as we all leave our marks on the work before us.

45
00:05:58.869 --> 00:06:00.473
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It will guide our panels today.

46
00:06:01.533 --> 00:06:09.185
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The framework will be up on the screen as we open our first agenda item, and I believe it is posted online as well.

47
00:06:10.180 --> 00:06:17.319
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It contains 3 buckets that I think help to define how these very different issues relate to each other.

48
00:06:18.377 --> 00:06:20.831
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What is the future of Portland's economy?

49
00:06:21.747 --> 00:06:23.062
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Where is it set right now?

50
00:06:23.896 --> 00:06:25.966
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And is that the direction we want it to move in?

51
00:06:27.107 --> 00:06:36.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How do we build community resilience, broadly encompassing the people, sustainability, our environment, our spaces?

52
00:06:37.233 --> 00:06:41.004
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what is the experience of the people who live here and the people who visit here?

53
00:06:42.031 --> 00:06:44.214
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And is it what we want it to be?

54
00:06:45.257 --> 00:06:46.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This framework is a starting place.

55
00:06:47.521 --> 00:06:52.848
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our policy direction, the overarching themes, the work that we do will, of course, be defined by the 5 of us.

56
00:06:52.913 --> 00:06:53.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

57
00:06:53.701 --> 00:07:00.500
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And our colleagues who bring work to this committee, as well as the Portlanders who testify before us over the course of the next year.

58
00:07:02.327 --> 00:07:16.182
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This public engagement piece is absolutely critical, and you'll note that after today's meeting, I will set aside 15 minutes at the start of every City Life meeting for a period of public communication, just like we have at full council.

59
00:07:16.987 --> 00:07:21.069
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>For Portlanders who are watching our meeting today, please hear this as an invitation.

60
00:07:22.108 --> 00:07:36.742
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you have thoughts on topics related to the work of this committee, sign up for a public communication slot so that we can hear from you and make sure that the things you're thinking about are part of, part of the dialogue that we have as we do our work.

61
00:07:38.089 --> 00:07:40.946
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The new form of government promised to be engaging and responsive.

62
00:07:41.603 --> 00:07:44.620
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to make sure that at every meeting we set aside time for that.

63
00:07:46.033 --> 00:08:00.447
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Today will be an exception, and instead we have about an hour and a half of panels with leaders in our community who represent a broad range of backgrounds and fields, all of which relate in some way to the themes before us.

64
00:08:02.317 --> 00:08:17.125
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In all of our future meetings, expect to start with that public communication period, colleagues, and then expect that we'll have one meaty topic, a big policy that needs a lot of discussion and work, a presentation about something that we should be thinking about for the future.

65
00:08:17.930 --> 00:08:25.898
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A chance for discussion about the direction that we're headed, as well as time set aside every work— every week for the work that just has to get done.

66
00:08:27.894 --> 00:08:30.071
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>To ground our year ahead, we'll need to level set.

67
00:08:30.699 --> 00:08:32.230
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're not starting from scratch.

68
00:08:32.649 --> 00:08:34.875
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is already work happening in our bureaus.

69
00:08:35.212 --> 00:08:38.105
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There is already work that the committees that came before us started.

70
00:08:39.191 --> 00:08:41.313
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But we need to know what direction we want to head.

71
00:08:42.870 --> 00:08:44.465
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Our goal is not to solve everything.

72
00:08:45.606 --> 00:08:58.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But it is to identify where this committee can make the biggest difference for Portlanders and how we can be thinking about the issues in front of us and the places where our collective visions for our city intersect.

73
00:08:59.090 --> 00:09:05.278
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm enormously excited by the panels that we have today to help us start to think about those different directions.

74
00:09:06.528 --> 00:09:14.496
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll get to those panels in just a few minutes, but before we get any further, I'd like to invite our Vice Chair, Councilor Zimmerman, to say a few words if you'd like.

75
00:09:14.561 --> 00:09:14.817
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Council Chair.

76
00:09:18.236 --> 00:09:19.087
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think you've summed it up.

77
00:09:19.376 --> 00:09:26.120
<v Eric Zimmerman>I mean, I appreciate the work that you did as chair in terms of bringing us together to kind of say what's the direction that we're going to go.

78
00:09:26.346 --> 00:09:34.422
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that watching you chair a committee this cycle is going to be fun, and we can switch chairs and I'll be your vice chair.

79
00:09:34.936 --> 00:09:36.349
<v Eric Zimmerman>You were a great vice chair to me last year.

80
00:09:36.942 --> 00:09:38.051
<v Eric Zimmerman>I plan to do the same for you.

81
00:09:38.485 --> 00:09:39.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for setting the direction here.

82
00:09:39.913 --> 00:09:40.235
<v Jessica Green>Thank you.

83
00:09:40.995 --> 00:09:42.187
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

84
00:09:43.460 --> 00:09:51.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we have a series of panels before us and then 2 other agenda items today, so I'd like to have us dive in.

85
00:09:53.299 --> 00:09:56.236
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, could you please call agenda item 1?

86
00:09:58.000 --> 00:10:11.837
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Item number 1, document number 2026-130, City Life Committee Introduction: The Future of Portland's Economy, Community resilience, and the experience of residents and visitors.

87
00:10:12.912 --> 00:10:13.232
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

88
00:10:13.408 --> 00:10:18.009
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, we have 3 panels before us today organized around those 3 themes.

89
00:10:18.763 --> 00:10:22.866
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In the first panel, we'll hear about the future of our economy.

90
00:10:22.995 --> 00:10:28.669
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll hear from business and workforce leaders, a labor economist, all talking about where we're headed.

91
00:10:29.486 --> 00:10:41.899
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Andrew Hone, President and CEO of the Portland Metro Chamber, will kick us off, followed by Dr. Mary King, Emerita Professor of Economics at Portland State University and former board member and Vice President of the Oregon Center for Public Policy.

92
00:10:42.671 --> 00:10:45.884
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Stephen Green, co-founder and Executive Director of Better Portland.

93
00:10:46.429 --> 00:10:49.273
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Patrick Gehring, Chief Program Officer at Worksystems.

94
00:10:49.321 --> 00:10:52.469
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Jules Bailey, Executive Director at the Clean Industry Hub.

95
00:10:52.533 --> 00:10:55.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If you all want to come up while I announce the other panels, that's fine.

96
00:10:56.291 --> 00:11:05.125
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next, we'll hear from community and city leaders on the work being done to build community resilience, including human economic sustainability and environmental resilience.

97
00:11:05.942 --> 00:11:14.407
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The panelists are Nate McCoy, President and CEO of the National Association of Minority Contractors and Interim Executive Director of the Black Business Association of Oregon.

98
00:11:15.465 --> 00:11:20.097
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Amy Nagy, Interim Director for Development and Investments at Prosper Portland.

99
00:11:20.835 --> 00:11:22.951
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Tracy Scott, Co-Chair of the PCEF Committee.

100
00:11:23.095 --> 00:11:26.461
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Vivian Satterfield, Portland's Chief Sustainability Officer.

101
00:11:26.782 --> 00:11:30.356
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Jeremy Van Curen, our Community Preparedness Manager at PBEN.

102
00:11:31.414 --> 00:12:02.225
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we'll close out with a committee that explores the work we have before us impacting the experiences of people who live and visit Portland, where we'll hear from Courtney Verano, Deputy Director of Movement Building at For All Families Oregon, Bernal Cruz Munoz, a member of the city's New Portlanders Policy Commission, Sabashini Ganesan-Forbes, former chair of the Oregon Arts Commission, Jessica Green, Executive Director with the Portland Parks Foundation, and Lori Wimmer, Executive Secretary-Treasurer of the Northwest Oregon Labor Council.

103
00:12:03.171 --> 00:12:14.471
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Each panelist will give some brief remarks, and my hope is that at the end of each panel, we will have time for a few questions or comments from colleagues, those of us up here.

104
00:12:15.328 --> 00:12:31.957
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Because we are trying to hear a lot of voices from the community today, we won't have time for everybody's questions about everything, but I am happy to make sure if there are people we want to hear more from or topics we want more discussion time on, to make sure those make our future agendas.

105
00:12:32.023 --> 00:12:35.625
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So please let me know after the meeting where you'd like us to spend more time.

106
00:12:36.788 --> 00:12:40.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With that, I will turn it over to our first panel.

107
00:12:40.256 --> 00:12:42.135
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And Mr. Hone, would you like to begin?

108
00:12:42.826 --> 00:12:43.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sure.

109
00:12:43.292 --> 00:12:47.096
<v Andrew Hone>And I do have a slide deck to accompany this.

110
00:12:47.225 --> 00:12:49.778
<v Andrew Hone>I was told that was way overboard.

111
00:12:51.095 --> 00:12:52.716
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is up on our computers.

112
00:12:52.860 --> 00:12:54.354
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Maybe we can get it up on the screen.

113
00:12:54.466 --> 00:12:54.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Perfect.

114
00:12:54.884 --> 00:12:56.505
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that folks online can see as well.

115
00:12:56.955 --> 00:12:57.275
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There we go.

116
00:12:57.903 --> 00:12:59.475
<v Andrew Hone>Why don't you kick us to the first slide then?

117
00:13:00.711 --> 00:13:01.177
<v Andrew Hone>Oh, there it is.

118
00:13:01.289 --> 00:13:01.482
<v Andrew Hone>Great.

119
00:13:01.836 --> 00:13:02.350
<v Andrew Hone>Well, thank you.

120
00:13:02.798 --> 00:13:07.035
<v Andrew Hone>Hi, Andrew Hone, President and CEO, Portland Metro Chamber, proud registered lobbyist.

121
00:13:07.934 --> 00:13:11.448
<v Andrew Hone>You'll be hearing a lot about research and reports in my slide deck here and presentation.

122
00:13:11.625 --> 00:13:13.342
<v Andrew Hone>These have been all transmitted to you in advance.

123
00:13:13.952 --> 00:13:16.970
<v Andrew Hone>I want to state also clearly my gratitude for being invited.

124
00:13:17.081 --> 00:13:23.485
<v Andrew Hone>I've been 8 years on the job, and this is the first time I have ever been asked to join this council to present generally on the economy.

125
00:13:24.159 --> 00:13:27.739
<v Andrew Hone>I represent the largest business advocacy organization in the state of Oregon.

126
00:13:27.787 --> 00:13:27.899
<v Andrew Hone>Thank you.

127
00:13:28.236 --> 00:13:28.605
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

128
00:13:30.197 --> 00:13:36.173
<v Andrew Hone>So I think first and foremost, we've had some dark days going from the pandemic, and obviously we still have challenges.

129
00:13:36.284 --> 00:13:44.417
<v Andrew Hone>But one thing that should be clear by all the headlines we've been reading over the last several years is that we are capable of big things and we are still worthy of investment.

130
00:13:44.787 --> 00:13:48.640
<v Andrew Hone>And yes, we have had major successes and we celebrate all of these.

131
00:13:49.077 --> 00:13:49.384
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

132
00:13:51.520 --> 00:13:53.835
<v Andrew Hone>None more than I think the improvements in livability.

133
00:13:54.152 --> 00:14:01.611
<v Andrew Hone>Those improvements have overwhelmingly delivered increases in the things that I think we visibly understand as vibrancy, and that's foot traffic.

134
00:14:02.094 --> 00:14:08.190
<v Andrew Hone>And you can see here the overall nexus between livability improvements and foot traffic going up year in and year out.

135
00:14:08.655 --> 00:14:12.409
<v Andrew Hone>This is good news, but this is where the good news ends.

136
00:14:13.469 --> 00:14:19.469
<v Andrew Hone>Based on this progress, it would take 10 more years to fully recover the vibrancy in the central city.

137
00:14:19.974 --> 00:14:20.345
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

138
00:14:22.635 --> 00:14:24.120
<v Andrew Hone>We can't lie to ourselves anymore.

139
00:14:25.149 --> 00:14:30.124
<v Andrew Hone>We have an economic policy challenge in Portland, clearly stated.

140
00:14:30.591 --> 00:14:31.043
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

141
00:14:33.256 --> 00:14:35.366
<v Andrew Hone>This is what we call the anti-superlative slide.

142
00:14:36.139 --> 00:14:46.344
<v Andrew Hone>You'll note that in all of these, we are last in the nation in all the categories that you do not want to be last in, and we are first in all the categories that you do not want to be first in.

143
00:14:47.201 --> 00:14:53.394
<v Andrew Hone>Most importantly, if you look to the very bottom note there, we are nearly last in the nation in employment.

144
00:14:54.346 --> 00:14:54.605
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

145
00:14:57.259 --> 00:15:00.091
<v Andrew Hone>The Oregon Employment Department released this just last week.

146
00:15:00.350 --> 00:15:05.485
<v Andrew Hone>Over the past 12 months, the metro area has lost nearly 23,000 jobs.

147
00:15:06.482 --> 00:15:09.316
<v Andrew Hone>23,000 individuals who no longer have employment.

148
00:15:09.943 --> 00:15:10.427
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

149
00:15:10.846 --> 00:15:16.327
<v Andrew Hone>If you want to ask the question about how we're doing here in Multnomah County, this was released in September of last year.

150
00:15:17.267 --> 00:15:21.279
<v Andrew Hone>We have lost 10,000 jobs in a single year just in Multnomah County.

151
00:15:21.409 --> 00:15:26.087
<v Andrew Hone>If you're wondering what that little red arrow is in the lower left-hand corner there, that's Portland.

152
00:15:26.557 --> 00:15:31.783
<v Andrew Hone>That's where we stack up against every other city in the nation— second to last.

153
00:15:32.953 --> 00:15:33.614
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

154
00:15:37.975 --> 00:15:38.684
<v Andrew Hone>I want to point to this.

155
00:15:39.216 --> 00:15:40.375
<v Andrew Hone>It's a tale of two counties.

156
00:15:41.275 --> 00:15:51.363
<v Andrew Hone>Our region is capable if you note this since pre-pandemic times, the difference between Multnomah County and Clark County could not be more stark.

157
00:15:52.450 --> 00:15:59.950
<v Andrew Hone>This committee should take every effort to understand this, why we got here, how we got here, and what do we do about it.

158
00:16:00.306 --> 00:16:00.791
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

159
00:16:02.796 --> 00:16:03.589
<v Andrew Hone>This is my favorite slide.

160
00:16:04.922 --> 00:16:07.817
<v Andrew Hone>It's also important to recognize the Oregon Trail is dead.

161
00:16:07.868 --> 00:16:08.197
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

162
00:16:09.399 --> 00:16:09.609
<v Dr. Mary King>Next slide.

163
00:16:09.658 --> 00:16:11.980
<v Andrew Hone>Natural increases in population will not happen.

164
00:16:12.495 --> 00:16:14.253
<v Andrew Hone>There are now more deaths than there are births.

165
00:16:15.039 --> 00:16:19.133
<v Andrew Hone>Due to current federal immigration policies, we will not be seeing international migration to our community.

166
00:16:19.764 --> 00:16:22.077
<v Andrew Hone>And that means one thing and one thing simply put.

167
00:16:22.596 --> 00:16:28.706
<v Andrew Hone>We must compete to retain and attract every household and every single business in our community.

168
00:16:29.208 --> 00:16:29.548
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

169
00:16:32.037 --> 00:16:33.072
<v Andrew Hone>You asked for the big ideas.

170
00:16:33.508 --> 00:16:35.068
<v Andrew Hone>Well, there's no shortage of ideas.

171
00:16:35.134 --> 00:16:41.610
<v Andrew Hone>And I would just point, we have publicly available data both from our chamber, other chambers, just like Better Portland, that all I'll put it out there very publicly.

172
00:16:41.691 --> 00:16:44.096
<v Andrew Hone>There are thousands of ideas about how to improve our economy.

173
00:16:45.379 --> 00:16:48.111
<v Andrew Hone>The most important question is, why should we improve the economy?

174
00:16:48.625 --> 00:16:49.076
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

175
00:16:51.022 --> 00:16:54.221
<v Andrew Hone>If you care nothing else for the private sector, then know this.

176
00:16:54.738 --> 00:16:55.947
<v Andrew Hone>Third bullet point.

177
00:16:56.836 --> 00:17:03.636
<v Andrew Hone>Business taxes grew in collections 85% between 2019 fiscal year and 2023 fiscal year.

178
00:17:04.578 --> 00:17:07.942
<v Andrew Hone>At that point in time, business taxes accounted for half of the general fund revenue.

179
00:17:07.991 --> 00:17:08.137
<v Andrew Hone>Thank you.

180
00:17:08.474 --> 00:17:12.290
<v Andrew Hone>Now, that has changed over the last several years, and we'll be re-releasing this report.

181
00:17:12.789 --> 00:17:17.411
<v Andrew Hone>But just to note, for the private sector to thrive, that means the public sector will as well.

182
00:17:17.829 --> 00:17:19.749
<v Andrew Hone>Our success is your success.

183
00:17:20.442 --> 00:17:20.814
<v Andrew Hone>Next slide.

184
00:17:22.459 --> 00:17:25.218
<v Andrew Hone>So I want to talk about solutions and just end on this note.

185
00:17:25.266 --> 00:17:28.201
<v Andrew Hone>Generally speaking, at the end of the day, you'd ask for the big idea.

186
00:17:28.345 --> 00:17:29.842
<v Andrew Hone>The big idea is culture change.

187
00:17:30.679 --> 00:17:39.594
<v Andrew Hone>The relationship between the private sector and the public sector has for well over a decade We must change this relationship.

188
00:17:40.395 --> 00:17:41.630
<v Andrew Hone>It's about collaboration.

189
00:17:42.799 --> 00:17:48.570
<v Andrew Hone>If every single business or private sector employer looks like a nail, then the only tool you have is a hammer.

190
00:17:49.788 --> 00:17:52.691
<v Andrew Hone>The difference has to be stark, dramatic, and urgent.

191
00:17:53.075 --> 00:17:56.425
<v Andrew Hone>We need collaboration on the big ideas so that we can solve them together.

192
00:17:57.723 --> 00:17:57.980
<v Andrew Hone>Thank you.

193
00:17:58.348 --> 00:17:59.615
<v Andrew Hone>That's all I have for my presentation.

194
00:18:00.512 --> 00:18:01.394
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

195
00:18:01.555 --> 00:18:12.971
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'll note as we move through that presentations are all posted online, as are, um, Supplemental materials with full testimony from a few of the folks who are here today.

196
00:18:13.179 --> 00:18:19.513
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, I'm passing out a handout that Dr. King has asked us to have in front of us as she speaks.

197
00:18:19.673 --> 00:18:20.731
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Dr. King, go right ahead.

198
00:18:21.597 --> 00:18:23.682
<v Dr. Mary King>Thank you very much, and thank you for inviting me.

199
00:18:24.724 --> 00:18:25.431
<v Dr. Mary King>Next slide, please.

200
00:18:25.784 --> 00:18:28.877
<v Dr. Mary King>Oh, do you have my slides?

201
00:18:29.070 --> 00:18:29.455
<v Dr. Mary King>Thank you.

202
00:18:29.551 --> 00:18:30.240
<v Angelita Morillo>Next slide, please.

203
00:18:30.835 --> 00:18:31.268
<v Jessica Green>Thanks.

204
00:18:32.117 --> 00:18:57.382
<v Dr. Mary King>We certainly have challenges affordability, I believe, at the top of the list, but slowed in-migration of young professionals, the ongoing loss of young families soon after their children are born, falling office building values due to the workshop and study-from-home revolution, lack of federal dollars since Reagan, but really worsening, and no replacement for cities and local governments of the property taxes limited in the '90s.

205
00:18:57.990 --> 00:18:58.695
<v Dr. Mary King>Next slide, please.

206
00:18:59.450 --> 00:19:01.421
<v Dr. Mary King>We also have a lot of advantages.

207
00:19:01.534 --> 00:19:02.784
<v Dr. Mary King>We think of our natural setting.

208
00:19:03.280 --> 00:19:16.190
<v Dr. Mary King>One thing I'd like to point out is consistently next slide, please.

209
00:19:16.190 --> 00:19:16.190
<v Dr. Mary King>So local economic development, what do we do?

210
00:19:16.190 --> 00:19:23.049
<v Dr. Mary King>The best metric for local economic development is higher income per person, a sample too small to deal with the lack of participation in 2020.

211
00:19:23.049 --> 00:19:24.789
<v Dr. Mary King>People did not fill out their forms.

212
00:19:25.269 --> 00:19:26.930
<v Dr. Mary King>Next slide, please.

213
00:19:26.930 --> 00:19:29.430
<v Dr. Mary King>So local economic development, what do we do?

214
00:19:29.430 --> 00:19:35.809
<v Dr. Mary King>The best metric for local economic development is higher income per person, especially at the bottom and the middle.

215
00:19:35.809 --> 00:19:41.739
<v Dr. Mary King>We want to make sure that we're not just growing the economy, We want a higher proportion of better jobs, not just jobs.

216
00:19:42.412 --> 00:19:53.092
<v Dr. Mary King>And the point is to create a more inclusive economy, more people working for higher pay, spending more locally, less need for social services, and more tax revenue.

217
00:19:53.701 --> 00:20:01.606
<v Dr. Mary King>The best strategies for raising incomes per person are investing in people, and a skilled labor force is what attracts businesses.

218
00:20:01.719 --> 00:20:08.405
<v Dr. Mary King>I've got several, and you can see education, training, childcare, healthcare, several other things, economic security.

219
00:20:08.453 --> 00:20:08.567
<v Dr. Mary King>Thank you.

220
00:20:09.000 --> 00:20:11.358
<v Dr. Mary King>We can go in more detail at another time.

221
00:20:12.386 --> 00:20:16.978
<v Dr. Mary King>But I wanna show you an example of how powerful these kinds of investments are.

222
00:20:17.057 --> 00:20:17.828
<v Dr. Mary King>Next slide, please.

223
00:20:18.583 --> 00:20:25.453
<v Dr. Mary King>And that, this example is investments in young children's programs or families versus business tax incentives.

224
00:20:26.048 --> 00:20:31.201
<v Dr. Mary King>And what the metric is, the impact on per capita income relative to cost.

225
00:20:31.586 --> 00:20:35.904
<v Dr. Mary King>And what you can see is, for instance, universal pre-K on the left is enormous.

226
00:20:36.241 --> 00:20:43.756
<v Dr. Mary King>The economic results of that, followed here by childcare for children from low-income families from birth.

227
00:20:44.590 --> 00:20:47.721
<v Dr. Mary King>Second, help with parenting from a nurse-parentation partnership.

228
00:20:48.202 --> 00:20:50.980
<v Dr. Mary King>And the one on the far right is business tax incentives.

229
00:20:51.076 --> 00:20:57.563
<v Dr. Mary King>And those are very tightly targeted, which are the most effective, of course, but are not the most common.

230
00:20:58.221 --> 00:20:59.169
<v Dr. Mary King>So next slide, please.

231
00:21:00.003 --> 00:21:15.205
<v Dr. Mary King>In short, I believe that we should worry less about raising taxes or cutting tax breaks when it comes to location decisions, people locate for family, jobs, schools, amenities like culture and outdoor recreation, very rarely for taxes.

232
00:21:15.960 --> 00:21:19.133
<v Dr. Mary King>And to think more about investing in people's capacities.

233
00:21:19.645 --> 00:21:23.460
<v Dr. Mary King>Again, we also want to think about, again, attracting young professionals.

234
00:21:23.636 --> 00:21:29.711
<v Dr. Mary King>These are the high-income households of the future, and they're far more mobile than older high-income households.

235
00:21:30.208 --> 00:21:32.275
<v Dr. Mary King>And retaining young families.

236
00:21:32.548 --> 00:21:34.423
<v Dr. Mary King>And that's critically about affordability.

237
00:21:34.471 --> 00:21:34.598
<v Dr. Mary King>Thank you.

238
00:21:35.336 --> 00:21:36.042
<v Dr. Mary King>Next slide, please.

239
00:21:37.021 --> 00:21:41.915
<v Dr. Mary King>Strategies for Portland right now in terms of what are my ideas that I think we should be looking at.

240
00:21:42.574 --> 00:21:43.905
<v Dr. Mary King>Affordability in housing.

241
00:21:44.499 --> 00:21:51.077
<v Dr. Mary King>With building prices falling, it's changing what— how much conversion to housing pencils from office buildings.

242
00:21:51.142 --> 00:22:06.368
<v Dr. Mary King>And that's something the city can facilitate, as well as supporting publicly owned, permanently affordable mixed-income housing developments that the market will not provide, and to pursue more evidence-based strategies on getting people housed who currently are not.

243
00:22:07.442 --> 00:22:09.623
<v Dr. Mary King>Investing in people, what can the city do?

244
00:22:10.167 --> 00:22:10.842
<v Dr. Mary King>A few things.

245
00:22:10.890 --> 00:22:15.473
<v Dr. Mary King>I think youth employment programs and diversion from the criminal justice system are a couple.

246
00:22:16.163 --> 00:22:19.481
<v Dr. Mary King>Finding more space in the public buildings for preschool for all is another.

247
00:22:20.171 --> 00:22:29.259
<v Dr. Mary King>And I think we need to consider at this point some sort of, I'd say local levy, but I really mean a tax supporting our schools locally and Portland State.

248
00:22:29.869 --> 00:22:37.997
<v Dr. Mary King>And examples would be cranking up Novick's equality tax, a high-end payroll tax, and testing our ability to expand Peace Center.

249
00:22:38.060 --> 00:22:38.221
<v Dr. Mary King>Thank you.

250
00:22:38.478 --> 00:22:42.355
<v Dr. Mary King>A very successful tax to other industries for other uses.

251
00:22:42.547 --> 00:22:43.540
<v Dr. Mary King>We're grandfathered in.

252
00:22:44.309 --> 00:22:51.199
<v Dr. Mary King>But last, I want to say I think we need to recognize that the work and shop from home revolution is here to stay.

253
00:22:51.983 --> 00:23:09.929
<v Dr. Mary King>And for that reason, we should become a little bit less downtown-centric in terms of where we expect economic activity to concentrate and work a little harder and further on encouraging our 15-minute livable, walkable neighborhoods that include employment thank you.

254
00:23:10.490 --> 00:23:13.743
<v Dr. Mary King>Happy to answer questions anytime, including later.

255
00:23:14.498 --> 00:23:15.443
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much.

256
00:23:16.116 --> 00:23:20.381
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are going to move through the panel and then take some questions.

257
00:23:20.509 --> 00:23:24.548
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I would love to have us hear next from Stephen Green with Better Portland.

258
00:23:24.836 --> 00:23:25.317
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

259
00:23:26.200 --> 00:23:29.148
<v Stephen Green>Chair, Vice Chair, members of City Life Committee, my name is Stephen Green.

260
00:23:29.582 --> 00:23:32.771
<v Stephen Green>I'm one of the co-founders of Better Portland and founder of Vanport Studio.

261
00:23:33.492 --> 00:23:38.446
<v Stephen Green>I've spent over 20 years in economic development, business finances, and as a founder here in Portland.

262
00:23:39.023 --> 00:23:43.067
<v Stephen Green>I've worked at one of the largest largest banks in the city as well as one of the smart— smallest.

263
00:23:43.532 --> 00:23:51.846
<v Stephen Green>And I've been part of hundreds of real estate transactions as a commercial banker and later working for the City of Portland, as well as thousands of deals for local small businesses.

264
00:23:52.601 --> 00:23:59.951
<v Stephen Green>And through all of that, I've tried to carry forward a belief that always has been part of what makes the business landscape here so special: community over competition.

265
00:24:01.188 --> 00:24:07.382
<v Stephen Green>I was asked here today to share a big idea about how we can meaningfully move forward the economy Now and into the future.

266
00:24:07.623 --> 00:24:08.472
<v Stephen Green>I'll be direct.

267
00:24:08.970 --> 00:24:17.165
<v Stephen Green>I believe both a path forward may actually require us to actually look small, more local, more intentional, and more Portland.

268
00:24:17.790 --> 00:24:25.298
<v Stephen Green>In the coming weeks, we're going to hear a lot about what's missing from the budget, but we should spend just as much time talking about where the money we already have is going.

269
00:24:26.195 --> 00:24:32.434
<v Stephen Green>Every year, the City of Portland spends hundreds of millions of dollars on contracts, goods, services, construction, technology.

270
00:24:33.028 --> 00:24:34.199
<v Stephen Green>That spending is not neutral.

271
00:24:34.857 --> 00:24:46.887
<v Stephen Green>Who we choose to power wash City Hall, what catering business provides food for an evening meeting, or where we get our morning tea are debits or credits into the trust bucket with the local companies that are the backbone of this city's economy.

272
00:24:47.707 --> 00:24:54.967
<v Stephen Green>Every dollar is either— every dollar either stays here and circulates through our neighborhoods or leaves the city and doesn't come back.

273
00:24:55.512 --> 00:24:56.186
<v Stephen Green>The data is clear.

274
00:24:56.557 --> 00:25:00.315
<v Stephen Green>When a dollar goes to a national firm, about 33 cents stays in the community.

275
00:25:01.053 --> 00:25:04.211
<v Stephen Green>When it goes to a locally owned business, it's closer to 68 cents.

276
00:25:04.661 --> 00:25:08.958
<v Stephen Green>That gap, 33 versus 68, is where I believe the opportunity lives.

277
00:25:09.791 --> 00:25:16.880
<v Stephen Green>When you look at what the city spends each year, even partially closing that gap equals tens of millions of dollars staying local each year.

278
00:25:17.472 --> 00:25:21.513
<v Stephen Green>That's jobs, that's business growth, that's real momentum in neighborhoods that need it most.

279
00:25:22.123 --> 00:25:24.592
<v Stephen Green>And here's the key point: that money's already moving.

280
00:25:25.185 --> 00:25:26.917
<v Stephen Green>We're not deciding whether to spend it.

281
00:25:27.190 --> 00:25:27.719
<v Stephen Green>We already are.

282
00:25:28.313 --> 00:25:32.000
<v Stephen Green>We're deciding who it reaches and whether it builds Portland or leaves it.

283
00:25:32.962 --> 00:25:39.185
<v Stephen Green>The state of Oregon's 2023 disparity study looked at $3.18 billion in public spending.

284
00:25:39.762 --> 00:25:48.006
<v Stephen Green>It found that minority and women-owned contracting firms make up 34% of the available businesses here but received just 11% of contract dollars.

285
00:25:48.743 --> 00:25:53.799
<v Stephen Green>When you dig deeper, Black-owned businesses made up 0.5% of available firms but only got thank you.

286
00:25:53.799 --> 00:25:55.710
<v Stephen Green>Portland's racial equity gap is about 0.1% of the dollars awarded.

287
00:25:56.779 --> 00:25:59.779
<v Stephen Green>Those numbers aren't an indictment, they're a baseline.

288
00:25:59.980 --> 00:26:00.930
<v Stephen Green>But here's the issue.

289
00:26:01.000 --> 00:26:04.480
<v Stephen Green>Portland hasn't completed a disparity study since 2009.

290
00:26:04.480 --> 00:26:07.240
<v Stephen Green>We're operating without a clear picture of today's reality.

291
00:26:07.640 --> 00:26:12.849
<v Stephen Green>And while we absolutely need to update the data, we don't need to wait to start doing better.

292
00:26:13.559 --> 00:26:14.559
<v Stephen Green>So here's my idea.

293
00:26:14.779 --> 00:26:16.759
<v Stephen Green>First dollar, local dollar.

294
00:26:16.759 --> 00:26:17.339
<v Stephen Green>Simple.

295
00:26:17.339 --> 00:26:26.723
<v Stephen Green>For every discretionary expenditure and city contract under $150,000, which is the range where the city already has flexibilities bureaus start local.

296
00:26:27.334 --> 00:26:35.105
<v Stephen Green>They reach out to 3, at least 3 qualified local businesses, and if they don't know of any, they can ask the Office of Small Business staff to help them.

297
00:26:36.020 --> 00:26:41.559
<v Stephen Green>They document that outreach, and if a local firm can do the work at a fair price, they get the contract.

298
00:26:41.961 --> 00:26:43.711
<v Stephen Green>If not, it goes to the open market.

299
00:26:44.113 --> 00:26:44.481
<v Stephen Green>That's it.

300
00:26:44.851 --> 00:26:50.487
<v Stephen Green>Not a goal, not a pilot, a standard first step that is not an aspiration but a scoreboard.

301
00:26:51.387 --> 00:26:53.381
<v Stephen Green>Other cities are already doing this in different ways.

302
00:26:53.656 --> 00:26:55.958
<v Stephen Green>Chicago, New Orleans, Phoenix, Seattle.

303
00:26:56.800 --> 00:27:01.762
<v Stephen Green>What they've all learned is simple: when you change the default, you have a better chance of changing the outcome.

304
00:27:02.362 --> 00:27:07.626
<v Stephen Green>You don't have to exclude anyone; you just have to make sure local businesses actually get a real first look.

305
00:27:08.619 --> 00:27:09.730
<v Stephen Green>Let's be honest about where we're at.

306
00:27:10.165 --> 00:27:17.047
<v Stephen Green>Portland's rebuilding, downtown's reimagining, and our local business ecosystem, especially Black, Latino, and AAPI-owned businesses.

307
00:27:17.676 --> 00:27:19.909
<v Stephen Green>Took a generational hit over the last 6 years.

308
00:27:20.824 --> 00:27:25.512
<v Stephen Green>But the people that are still here, they're resilient, they're ready, and they're open for business right now.

309
00:27:26.186 --> 00:27:27.503
<v Stephen Green>What they're looking for is a signal.

310
00:27:28.434 --> 00:27:32.513
<v Stephen Green>The city is— that the city is serious about building an economy that includes them.

311
00:27:33.107 --> 00:27:36.366
<v Stephen Green>This policy sends that signal, and it does it without new dollars.

312
00:27:36.736 --> 00:27:39.787
<v Stephen Green>It's about using what we already spend more intentionally.

313
00:27:40.478 --> 00:27:41.537
<v Stephen Green>This is within your reach.

314
00:27:41.713 --> 00:27:42.403
<v Stephen Green>This committee could—.

315
00:27:42.403 --> 00:27:42.517
<v Stephen Green>Thank you.

316
00:27:43.013 --> 00:27:43.349
<v Stephen Green>Thank you.

317
00:27:43.446 --> 00:27:50.480
<v Stephen Green>We need to issue an executive directive, ask for updated procurement policies, and help set clear expectations across the bureaus.

318
00:27:51.233 --> 00:27:53.348
<v Stephen Green>And Portland already has infrastructure to track it.

319
00:27:53.942 --> 00:28:00.607
<v Stephen Green>We were the first city in the country to adopt the Open Contracting Data Standard, giving us access to city spend in real time.

320
00:28:01.008 --> 00:28:03.042
<v Stephen Green>So the data is there, the systems are there.

321
00:28:03.731 --> 00:28:10.108
<v Stephen Green>We just need to know— what we need right now is the decision, because this isn't about whether we have enough resources.

322
00:28:10.623 --> 00:28:14.203
<v Stephen Green>It's about whether we're willing to use the ones we already have on purpose.

323
00:28:14.958 --> 00:28:17.640
<v Stephen Green>The businesses that would benefit from this are already here.

324
00:28:18.153 --> 00:28:23.035
<v Stephen Green>They've stayed, they've invested, they've bet on Portland even when it hasn't been that easy.

325
00:28:23.628 --> 00:28:25.234
<v Stephen Green>This is our chance to bet on them back.

326
00:28:25.876 --> 00:28:34.323
<v Stephen Green>And if we can make that the standard and not the exception, we won't just be taking— we won't just be talking about economic recovery, we'll actually be practicing it.

327
00:28:34.386 --> 00:28:34.612
<v Stephen Green>Thank you.

328
00:28:34.692 --> 00:28:34.964
<v Stephen Green>Thank you.

329
00:28:35.720 --> 00:28:40.002
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for that overview and idea.

330
00:28:41.125 --> 00:28:44.269
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Patrick Gearing, you want to talk to us about workforce?

331
00:28:44.894 --> 00:28:46.868
<v Patrick Gehring>Thank you, Chair, and thank you, councilors.

332
00:28:47.205 --> 00:28:55.867
<v Patrick Gehring>I want to echo my colleague Dr. Kim's support for employment programs and summer jobs for youth, and I'm bringing a different big idea.

333
00:28:56.526 --> 00:29:04.276
<v Patrick Gehring>So everyone knows yesterday that peace talks broke down between the U.S. and Iran, and we're going to see some serious economic consequences.

334
00:29:05.015 --> 00:29:18.538
<v Patrick Gehring>This is because about 20% of the global oil supply moves through the Strait of Hormuz, and dependency globally on that supply chain will create an economic shock if we don't reopen the strait.

335
00:29:19.390 --> 00:29:33.259
<v Patrick Gehring>But there's another potentially more debilitating supply chain threat we're already addressing through national industrial policy, where our region, the Portland Metro Metro area plays a key role in the Strait of Taiwan.

336
00:29:33.613 --> 00:29:43.074
<v Patrick Gehring>One company in one country produces over 60% of the semiconductor chips and 90% of the super advanced chips.

337
00:29:43.700 --> 00:29:50.434
<v Patrick Gehring>And China has been crystal clear: it believes that Taiwan is part of China and will someday take it back.

338
00:29:51.718 --> 00:29:57.703
<v Patrick Gehring>As you know, semiconductors are essential in everything from from cars to computers to drones and AI.

339
00:29:58.795 --> 00:30:09.071
<v Patrick Gehring>Because of this militarily and economically compromising dependency, the United States is reshoring our semiconductor industry, beginning with the CHIPS Act.

340
00:30:10.195 --> 00:30:17.678
<v Patrick Gehring>Of course, the cradle of the American and global semiconductor industry is in Washington County, not in Portland.

341
00:30:18.127 --> 00:30:19.894
<v Patrick Gehring>So why is this about Portland?

342
00:30:21.034 --> 00:30:26.862
<v Patrick Gehring>37% Of Portland workers go to work outside of the city of Portland.

343
00:30:27.520 --> 00:30:34.778
<v Patrick Gehring>They then come home to spend their money, send their kids to school, buy goods and services here in Portland.

344
00:30:35.469 --> 00:30:46.434
<v Patrick Gehring>In fact, manufacturing has the highest economic multiplier of any industry and can support broad economic prosperity and a solid middle class.

345
00:30:47.140 --> 00:30:50.298
<v Patrick Gehring>It also includes entry-level jobs that pay good wages.

346
00:30:51.613 --> 00:30:59.115
<v Patrick Gehring>A while ago, I was at a forum in Hillsboro, and I heard an elected official there say that no state is great without a great major city.

347
00:30:59.868 --> 00:31:06.778
<v Patrick Gehring>That's an acknowledgment of the interests and fates in our region of the cities and counties which are intertwined.

348
00:31:07.002 --> 00:31:09.695
<v Patrick Gehring>And she was talking about Portland, not her own community.

349
00:31:10.594 --> 00:31:20.708
<v Patrick Gehring>I think it can be easier for people in a big city like Portland to be looking more inwardly and not paying attention to what's happening in cities, counties, and regions around them.

350
00:31:22.765 --> 00:31:28.068
<v Patrick Gehring>But that's not what more than a third of Portland workers are doing when they go to other cities to work.

351
00:31:28.375 --> 00:31:31.053
<v Patrick Gehring>Our workforce and our economy is regional.

352
00:31:32.182 --> 00:31:46.299
<v Patrick Gehring>At Work Systems, we're starting to see the threats from AI materializing in work that entails disembodied intelligence like coding, writing, analyzing data, and developing big ideas to present to city councilors.

353
00:31:47.646 --> 00:32:04.381
<v Patrick Gehring>Manufacturing is a hands-on process that does not share this vulnerability to displacement by AI, and to the contrary, AI will drive employment growth in the semiconductor industry as demand for chips grows to meet the process needs.

354
00:32:05.134 --> 00:32:10.719
<v Patrick Gehring>Semiconductor will be countercyclical to AI job losses.

355
00:32:10.894 --> 00:32:18.420
<v Patrick Gehring>In other words, these jobs are growing, they pay well, and they include opportunities at all skill levels.

356
00:32:19.654 --> 00:32:27.692
<v Patrick Gehring>We recently collaborated with Intel, PCC, and others to develop a program called Quick Start to Manufacturing.

357
00:32:27.757 --> 00:32:30.132
<v Patrick Gehring>This was reported in The Economist magazine.

358
00:32:30.243 --> 00:32:35.230
<v Patrick Gehring>We train people for semiconductor manufacturing jobs Thank you.

359
00:32:36.096 --> 00:32:46.079
<v Patrick Gehring>What that means is that the 14% of Portlanders whose highest level of educational attainment can go into these good careers at family wages.

360
00:32:47.554 --> 00:32:55.615
<v Patrick Gehring>We are at the precipice of a chip-hungry era of AI, and we're embarking on a national project to reshore semiconductor manufacturing.

361
00:32:56.448 --> 00:32:58.386
<v Patrick Gehring>We can't afford not to catch this train.

362
00:33:00.246 --> 00:33:20.780
<v Patrick Gehring>We need our elected officials and policymakers across the regional economy, including Portland, Multnomah County, Washington County, Beaverton, Hillsboro, and the state of Oregon, to work together to put the Portland metro area back front and center in the effort to reshore American semiconductor manufacturing.

363
00:33:21.279 --> 00:33:21.602
<v Patrick Gehring>Thank you.

364
00:33:23.130 --> 00:33:27.203
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, and I promise I will I will always look to people first for policy ideas.

365
00:33:29.539 --> 00:33:35.905
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Jules Bailey, can you talk to us a little bit about— this is actually a great segue to talking about clean tech.

366
00:33:37.500 --> 00:33:38.031
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Absolutely.

367
00:33:38.096 --> 00:33:44.167
<v Jules Bailey>Councilors, I'm Jules Bailey, and I am the newly minted executive director contracted to the Clean Industry Hub.

368
00:33:44.717 --> 00:33:50.357
<v Jules Bailey>When I say newly minted, this is day 2, so get to get thrown right in here with the city council.

369
00:33:50.498 --> 00:33:54.412
<v Jules Bailey>And I get to be a bit of a palate cleanse between this panel and the next one.

370
00:33:54.476 --> 00:33:58.951
<v Jules Bailey>And, and we've heard a lot of really important concerns today, but this is mostly good news.

371
00:33:59.288 --> 00:34:09.682
<v Jules Bailey>And before I get to it though, I do want to take a point of personal privilege and say, as I believe the only former elected official on these panels, thank you.

372
00:34:10.838 --> 00:34:12.217
<v Jules Bailey>You all have a very hard job.

373
00:34:12.538 --> 00:34:17.061
<v Jules Bailey>And in fact, in many ways, it's a lot harder than when I was in this, which is getting to be a long time ago now.

374
00:34:18.036 --> 00:34:26.552
<v Jules Bailey>And the fact that you show up and that you have put yourself forward and that you have given personal sacrifice to this city does not go unnoticed by a lot of people.

375
00:34:26.601 --> 00:34:29.494
<v Jules Bailey>So thank you for the work that you're doing and your willingness to serve, all of you.

376
00:34:31.295 --> 00:34:33.458
<v Jules Bailey>The Clean Industry Hub is really exciting.

377
00:34:33.715 --> 00:34:42.108
<v Jules Bailey>It's the embodiment of partnership, and it's a partnership between the city, between private— the private sector, between community groups and environmental advocates and more.

378
00:34:42.835 --> 00:34:47.097
<v Jules Bailey>It's received seed funding from PSEF, and we take that investment seriously.

379
00:34:47.635 --> 00:34:52.284
<v Jules Bailey>The community groups that created PCF had a lot of foresight, and we honor that.

380
00:34:53.244 --> 00:34:54.063
<v Jules Bailey>So here's the challenge.

381
00:34:54.768 --> 00:35:00.440
<v Jules Bailey>Heavy industry has been an important part of Portland's economy for the last 100 years.

382
00:35:00.552 --> 00:35:08.101
<v Jules Bailey>In many ways, this is a manufacturing town, and the metals and manufacturing have built a lot of the economy in Portland.

383
00:35:08.951 --> 00:35:15.250
<v Jules Bailey>As a result, industry is about 12% of Portland's carbon emissions, but it's the hardest one of those sectors to get at.

384
00:35:15.297 --> 00:35:16.436
<v Jules Bailey>It's not the biggest sector.

385
00:35:16.500 --> 00:35:17.028
<v Jules Bailey>Transportation is bigger.

386
00:35:17.108 --> 00:35:17.429
<v Jules Bailey>It's not the biggest sector.

387
00:35:21.402 --> 00:35:29.876
<v Jules Bailey>The Portland Climate Emergency Work Plan acknowledges the importance of this sector and the need to decarbonize it while keeping businesses operating.

388
00:35:31.036 --> 00:35:38.251
<v Jules Bailey>Industrial decarbonization is tricky because it requires big investments, a lot of times at once, and potentially long horizons.

389
00:35:38.990 --> 00:35:42.268
<v Jules Bailey>And many of the processes are complex and energy intensive.

390
00:35:42.847 --> 00:35:46.670
<v Jules Bailey>You can't impose a one-size-fits-all tax or regulation and expect it to work across these diversity of businesses.

391
00:35:46.733 --> 00:35:47.425
<v Jules Bailey>I think that's a great point.

392
00:35:49.829 --> 00:35:58.324
<v Jules Bailey>It's very high-touch, it's high facilitation, it's costly, and it often requires the right technology and access to low-carbon fuels to make it work.

393
00:35:59.190 --> 00:36:00.153
<v Jules Bailey>So here's the big idea.

394
00:36:01.132 --> 00:36:02.369
<v Jules Bailey>This is where the hub comes in.

395
00:36:02.898 --> 00:36:11.746
<v Jules Bailey>Portland has the opportunity to be a national leader in the clean and circular industry and industrial decarbonization field.

396
00:36:12.291 --> 00:36:15.132
<v Jules Bailey>We created this hub modeled after a really successful one in Denmark.

397
00:36:16.653 --> 00:36:25.994
<v Jules Bailey>It's unique in the U.S., and it puts Portland on the map at the intersection of economic development and climate action.

398
00:36:26.992 --> 00:36:35.019
<v Jules Bailey>And it's grown out of this really remarkable partnership between Prosper, BPS, PSU, and a wide range of community stakeholders and partners.

399
00:36:36.092 --> 00:36:41.125
<v Jules Bailey>There are community benefits baked into every part of this effort, and it identifies potential projects that will create jobs and create economic growth.

400
00:36:41.641 --> 00:36:45.699
<v Jules Bailey>And maps public and private investment into them aligned with the state and the state's goals.

401
00:36:46.516 --> 00:36:50.911
<v Jules Bailey>So it's a model based on partnership incentives and symbiosis, not just regulation.

402
00:36:51.985 --> 00:36:53.012
<v Jules Bailey>So what can you all do?

403
00:36:54.391 --> 00:36:55.320
<v Jules Bailey>In many ways, you've already done it.

404
00:36:56.315 --> 00:37:00.853
<v Jules Bailey>But going forward, we need to streamline the path to getting these projects identified and done.

405
00:37:01.367 --> 00:37:19.710
<v Jules Bailey>And that means Prosper, the Hub, BPS, and others all have to work together to map opportunities and direct investment And we have to build trust with the private sector and the organizations that serve them, like the Port of Portland, as well as continue to serve community and community-based groups that have been part of this process all along.

406
00:37:20.851 --> 00:37:33.005
<v Jules Bailey>Once those projects get identified, then we need to be able to work quickly to map dollars into them and clear any administrative hurdles in order to get these projects done and implemented as fast as possible and as efficiently as possible.

407
00:37:34.034 --> 00:37:39.621
<v Jules Bailey>Industrial processes are by definition energy intensive, and efficiency alone won't be enough.

408
00:37:39.668 --> 00:37:48.532
<v Jules Bailey>So we also need clean, low-carbon energy fuels available for decarbonization of industrial facilities, and that means removing some of the barriers to investment in those things.

409
00:37:49.543 --> 00:37:50.764
<v Jules Bailey>So this is an emerging effort.

410
00:37:51.054 --> 00:37:58.407
<v Jules Bailey>We're just getting off the ground, and we look forward to coming back to you later this year with concrete projects and demonstrated results and checking back in.

411
00:37:58.552 --> 00:37:58.856
<v Jules Bailey>Thank you.

412
00:38:00.851 --> 00:38:01.561
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much.

413
00:38:01.659 --> 00:38:06.637
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So colleagues, we have about 10 minutes before we need to start our next panel.

414
00:38:06.913 --> 00:38:16.786
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Are there questions for any of our panelists, comments or thoughts on anything that you've heard, or anything else you'd like to add while we're still thinking about the future of our economy?

415
00:38:20.922 --> 00:38:21.619
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

416
00:38:22.686 --> 00:38:25.534
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, Professor King, right?

417
00:38:25.615 --> 00:38:25.956
<v Eric Zimmerman>You got that right?

418
00:38:26.684 --> 00:38:31.856
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just wanted to appreciate your bullet point about finding more space in public buildings for Preschool for All.

419
00:38:32.931 --> 00:38:35.597
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that is the path to success for that program.

420
00:38:36.385 --> 00:38:49.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think a lot of people are not aware that actually that program took off and tried to create a lot of new hard space and building of buildings, but we also had declining enrollment in PPS at the same time and classrooms that went empty.

421
00:38:50.230 --> 00:38:54.277
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for noting that in a very nonpartisan way of just like, we have opportunities.

422
00:38:54.342 --> 00:38:54.614
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

423
00:38:55.657 --> 00:39:06.338
<v Eric Zimmerman>And Preschool for All has been bounced around at different times, but it truly is— I mean, that metric that you showed about its earnings impact on people's lives is huge.

424
00:39:06.563 --> 00:39:12.961
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we have all the space that we probably need to achieve that commitment to all of Multnomah County.

425
00:39:13.635 --> 00:39:15.047
<v Eric Zimmerman>And now it's just about execution.

426
00:39:15.318 --> 00:39:19.985
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for highlighting one of the very easy executable dots on the map there.

427
00:39:20.065 --> 00:39:20.226
<v Eric Engstrom>It's great.

428
00:39:20.451 --> 00:39:20.594
<v Patrick Gehring>Thank you.

429
00:39:23.806 --> 00:39:24.403
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

430
00:39:24.516 --> 00:39:25.228
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

431
00:39:27.909 --> 00:39:28.184
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

432
00:39:28.248 --> 00:39:28.847
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair.

433
00:39:29.056 --> 00:39:30.704
<v Dan Ryan>That was a— this is quite a panel.

434
00:39:31.302 --> 00:39:33.938
<v Dan Ryan>You've offered a lot of variety of opinions, and I appreciate that.

435
00:39:34.536 --> 00:39:42.882
<v Dan Ryan>I wanted to start with, first of all, Andrew, we did have economic data presented at the first meeting with your group, right?

436
00:39:43.090 --> 00:39:44.494
<v Dan Ryan>Wasn't that correct last year?

437
00:39:44.961 --> 00:39:45.170
<v Dan Ryan>All right.

438
00:39:45.623 --> 00:39:45.880
<v Andrew Hone>Correct.

439
00:39:46.509 --> 00:39:49.298
<v Dan Ryan>And I appreciate that you level-setted us with some data as well.

440
00:39:49.976 --> 00:39:53.380
<v Dan Ryan>And I was fascinated by the diversity of thought that came out.

441
00:39:53.523 --> 00:39:56.349
<v Dan Ryan>Also diving into different industries was great.

442
00:39:57.039 --> 00:40:09.706
<v Dan Ryan>I think what I'd like to follow up with, with the professor— you're a doctor professor, okay, PSU— yeah, is how do you explain the contrast between Multnomah County and Clark County?

443
00:40:10.284 --> 00:40:21.226
<v Dan Ryan>When I listened to what you said, it was easy to listen to and support, but it's true that a lot of families have left Portland even though we've been passing some of the policies that you mentioned.

444
00:40:22.077 --> 00:40:28.313
<v Dan Ryan>And so seeing that contrast between Multnomah County and Clark County was pretty stark in the earlier slides.

445
00:40:29.291 --> 00:40:36.362
<v Dan Ryan>What's your thought on how to explain what— with 2 things could be true perhaps, and I'd like to hear you explain how 2 things can be true.

446
00:40:36.844 --> 00:40:42.391
<v Dr. Mary King>Well, for starters, I don't think we're as different as that data would imply.

447
00:40:43.561 --> 00:40:55.789
<v Dr. Mary King>If we look at the loss of of young families from large urban counties through the pandemic years, that applied to every county in our metro area, including Clark.

448
00:40:56.110 --> 00:41:05.371
<v Dr. Mary King>I mean, so affordability is an issue and was, and the working from home changed things all over the country in large urban counties.

449
00:41:05.869 --> 00:41:07.009
<v Dr. Mary King>So that's part of it.

450
00:41:07.795 --> 00:41:14.994
<v Dr. Mary King>The, the and it seems to me that's the major number.

451
00:41:15.170 --> 00:41:24.208
<v Dr. Mary King>But I would go back and say that the data that we have on Multnomah County losing young children, I know further back than I do for Clark County.

452
00:41:24.719 --> 00:41:31.498
<v Dr. Mary King>And I know that it's been true in the— shows up in the census 2000, 2010, and 2020.

453
00:41:31.947 --> 00:41:41.753
<v Dr. Mary King>So well prior to any tax changes or anything like that, but already building affordability issues for families with young children.

454
00:41:42.059 --> 00:41:51.161
<v Dr. Mary King>So we have lost in those 3 census years 10% of the kids born in the county by preschool age.

455
00:41:52.193 --> 00:41:55.304
<v Dr. Mary King>So families are looking for more house for their money.

456
00:41:56.422 --> 00:42:02.360
<v Dr. Mary King>And the other thing I wonder about Clark County is about the perceived quality of the schools.

457
00:42:02.813 --> 00:42:06.215
<v Dr. Mary King>I mean, Oregon's been underfunding their schools now for 30 years.

458
00:42:06.306 --> 00:42:06.362
<v Dr. Mary King>Yeah.

459
00:42:06.836 --> 00:42:08.331
<v Dr. Mary King>And we're really up against it.

460
00:42:09.103 --> 00:42:17.838
<v Dr. Mary King>And I— we haven't been able to see much effective leadership to restore us to the situation before property tax limitations.

461
00:42:18.336 --> 00:42:22.139
<v Dr. Mary King>So I think that's a big difference between Oregon and Washington at the moment.

462
00:42:23.268 --> 00:42:36.398
<v Dr. Mary King>And when you talk taxes between Oregon and Washington, Washington residents pay more in tax than Oregonians do, but they don't feel it as easily because so much of it is sales tax.

463
00:42:37.998 --> 00:42:41.483
<v Dan Ryan>And earlier your statement was that you didn't agree with some of the data.

464
00:42:41.565 --> 00:42:42.657
<v Dan Ryan>Is that your comment?

465
00:42:43.235 --> 00:42:47.940
<v Dr. Mary King>No, it was more about what are we losing to Clark County.

466
00:42:48.438 --> 00:42:54.766
<v Dr. Mary King>I think I'm addressing a different angle on that, which is the situation for young families.

467
00:42:55.280 --> 00:42:55.521
<v Candace Avalos>Okay.

468
00:42:56.710 --> 00:42:58.188
<v Dan Ryan>Um, Andrew, do you have any comments?

469
00:42:59.681 --> 00:43:03.135
<v Andrew Hone>Uh, yeah, you know, yeah, I'll quote the county economist.

470
00:43:03.199 --> 00:43:03.391
<v Andrew Hone>Yes.

471
00:43:03.713 --> 00:43:05.847
<v Andrew Hone>We are in what's known as a donut economy.

472
00:43:06.585 --> 00:43:12.186
<v Andrew Hone>And that is that growth is exclusive to the exterior of our region.

473
00:43:12.282 --> 00:43:13.469
<v Andrew Hone>We're a one-regional economy.

474
00:43:13.967 --> 00:43:18.155
<v Andrew Hone>So in fact, Clackamas and Washington Counties still continue to grow.

475
00:43:18.476 --> 00:43:21.927
<v Andrew Hone>That's on the Oregon side of the river, a little bit, but not much.

476
00:43:22.313 --> 00:43:23.836
<v Andrew Hone>Clark County is obviously the leader.

477
00:43:23.916 --> 00:43:29.550
<v Andrew Hone>If you took Clark County out of our region, we would be definitively in a remarkable recession right now.

478
00:43:30.657 --> 00:43:44.371
<v Andrew Hone>And then specifically to the regional economy look, There is no place that is defined by a regional economy in this country that has such a segregation of outcomes.

479
00:43:45.143 --> 00:43:54.650
<v Andrew Hone>Simultaneously, there is no place in this country that has a bigger difference in their tax structure than our local economy.

480
00:43:55.068 --> 00:43:56.914
<v Dan Ryan>When you— especially when you compare Multnomah and Clark.

481
00:43:57.235 --> 00:43:57.413
<v Andrew Hone>Correct.

482
00:43:57.476 --> 00:43:59.548
<v Dan Ryan>That's the biggest nexus you can find nationally.

483
00:43:59.983 --> 00:44:13.356
<v Andrew Hone>To the point that if you went 4 miles north of where we are presently located and you are a single individual potentially making $150,000, you could receive potentially upwards of a 14% pay raise.

484
00:44:14.014 --> 00:44:16.726
<v Andrew Hone>And so in some cases, people are making specific choices.

485
00:44:17.320 --> 00:44:21.351
<v Andrew Hone>That's not a wholesale, you know, commentary on the overall tax structure.

486
00:44:21.414 --> 00:44:30.045
<v Andrew Hone>But at the end of the day, the most important thing that happens is if you're going to have the tax structure we do have, You must deliver quality services and execute on those services.

487
00:44:30.463 --> 00:44:37.981
<v Andrew Hone>And then simultaneously recommend— or again, let me step back and point out, I think it's important for this committee to ask the questions themselves.

488
00:44:38.655 --> 00:44:39.985
<v Andrew Hone>Why are businesses leaving?

489
00:44:40.257 --> 00:44:41.476
<v Andrew Hone>Why are we losing jobs?

490
00:44:42.405 --> 00:44:44.793
<v Andrew Hone>You don't have to take our word for it at all.

491
00:44:45.210 --> 00:44:47.599
<v Andrew Hone>I would invite businesses that have left this community.

492
00:44:48.096 --> 00:44:51.333
<v Andrew Hone>I would invite people that have left this community and ask this question of them.

493
00:44:52.039 --> 00:44:57.137
<v Andrew Hone>Because it's up to you to make these decisions not based on talking heads, but on the experiences of people that are leaving.

494
00:44:57.650 --> 00:45:02.884
<v Andrew Hone>And I would just ask the the folks, the 10,000 individuals that lost their jobs over the last 12 months here just in Multnomah County.

495
00:45:03.590 --> 00:45:04.056
<v Andrew Hone>What happened?

496
00:45:05.340 --> 00:45:08.728
<v Andrew Hone>Why is our economy more challenged than every other city in this country?

497
00:45:09.001 --> 00:45:09.867
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

498
00:45:09.931 --> 00:45:10.445
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair.

499
00:45:10.735 --> 00:45:16.932
<v Dan Ryan>I found the 2 presentations back to back were the most fascinating, and I just wanted to give you a chance to explain further.

500
00:45:17.061 --> 00:45:18.184
<v Dan Ryan>I believed your data.

501
00:45:18.266 --> 00:45:21.974
<v Dan Ryan>I believe what you're saying too, trying to reconcile this.

502
00:45:22.215 --> 00:45:24.302
<v Dr. Mary King>Could I say one thing about the tax structure?

503
00:45:24.527 --> 00:45:26.599
<v Dr. Mary King>Our total taxes are not higher.

504
00:45:27.675 --> 00:45:33.135
<v Dr. Mary King>The only tax that is higher is the marginal tax level on incomes.

505
00:45:33.858 --> 00:45:38.195
<v Dr. Mary King>The rest of them as a package, or all of them as a package, are lower.

506
00:45:38.773 --> 00:45:50.996
<v Dr. Mary King>So, and we have had a difference, a huge difference in income tax levels with Washington forever, and we have not seen mass migration.

507
00:45:51.045 --> 00:45:54.996
<v Dr. Mary King>So I think we need to look at other factors when we're thinking about what's going on.

508
00:45:55.043 --> 00:45:55.221
<v Lionel Irvin>Thank you.

509
00:45:55.847 --> 00:45:57.550
<v Dan Ryan>Dr. Mary King, do you have data on that?

510
00:45:58.916 --> 00:45:59.190
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

511
00:45:59.318 --> 00:45:59.592
<v Dan Ryan>Just said.

512
00:46:00.025 --> 00:46:01.985
<v Dr. Mary King>Yes, I'd be happy to share that data with you.

513
00:46:03.480 --> 00:46:08.364
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Let's make sure we get that to everybody on the committee so that we're all looking at the same things.

514
00:46:08.478 --> 00:46:09.393
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

515
00:46:10.309 --> 00:46:13.829
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Murillo, and then we'll move to the next panel after that.

516
00:46:14.583 --> 00:46:16.721
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you all so much for this presentation.

517
00:46:17.476 --> 00:46:22.505
<v Angelita Morillo>Really appreciate the perspective that we're getting today and excited to be on this committee and to explore this further with everybody.

518
00:46:23.163 --> 00:46:25.474
<v Angelita Morillo>And thank you, Professor King, for clarifying that.

519
00:46:25.554 --> 00:46:28.829
<v Angelita Morillo>I was gonna raise my hand to say the same thing, so I appreciate that.

520
00:46:29.842 --> 00:46:32.137
<v Angelita Morillo>I had a question for Mr. Bailey.

521
00:46:33.117 --> 00:46:37.885
<v Angelita Morillo>At the end of what you were talking about, I, I think I may have missed it.

522
00:46:37.934 --> 00:46:38.784
<v Angelita Morillo>I just wanted to clarify.

523
00:46:39.394 --> 00:46:42.974
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think you said that there needs to be some investment in more clean fuels.

524
00:46:43.088 --> 00:46:45.255
<v Angelita Morillo>Is that correct, or did I misunderstand you or mishear you?

525
00:46:46.362 --> 00:46:55.547
<v Jules Bailey>Thank you, Councilor what I said was that we need access to clean fuels because a lot of these industrial processes are energy intensive.

526
00:46:55.610 --> 00:47:07.605
<v Jules Bailey>So the fact that you need heat in many ways to make these industrial processes work, so making sure that there's an availability for those kinds of fuels that are low carbon fuels that can provide heat is important.

527
00:47:08.697 --> 00:47:11.746
<v Angelita Morillo>And are you referring to renewable fuels when you're talking about that, or?

528
00:47:12.454 --> 00:47:30.148
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes, renewable fuels would be important or other sources of and what is your perspective on moving away from fuel entirely and starting to move towards expanding our electricity grid, given what's happening and may be happening for a very long time?

529
00:47:31.077 --> 00:47:34.025
<v Jules Bailey>I'm certainly in favor of electrification as well, too.

530
00:47:34.170 --> 00:47:44.264
<v Jules Bailey>And so some of it is dependent on the specific industrial process, whether or not electricity can replace that equipment within a particular facility to replace that industrial process.

531
00:47:44.344 --> 00:47:45.128
<v Jules Bailey>But where that's possible, I'm certainly in favor of that.

532
00:47:45.755 --> 00:47:46.306
<v Jules Bailey>Absolutely.

533
00:47:46.402 --> 00:47:50.585
<v Jules Bailey>Having clean electricity and having a secure and reliable grid is incredibly important.

534
00:47:51.927 --> 00:47:52.476
<v Jessica Green>Thank you.

535
00:47:53.947 --> 00:47:56.648
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you to all our panelists on our first panel.

536
00:47:56.875 --> 00:48:02.130
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I really appreciate you bringing such varied perspectives to help us start thinking about our work.

537
00:48:02.840 --> 00:48:03.472
<v Andrew Hone>Thank you.

538
00:48:03.568 --> 00:48:04.038
<v Dr. Mary King>Thank you.

539
00:48:09.869 --> 00:48:18.114
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second panel is Nate McCoy, Amy Nagy, Tracy Scott, Vivian Satterfield, and Jeremy Van Keuren.

540
00:48:19.014 --> 00:48:24.253
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And on this panel, we'll hear different perspectives on building community resilience.

541
00:48:24.880 --> 00:48:33.074
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Community resilience encompasses a lot of different types of ways, or ways of being resilient.

542
00:48:33.235 --> 00:48:49.541
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And rather than different perspectives on a similar topic on this panel, I suspect we will hear a lot of different meanings of the term resilience and a lot of different ways that we need to make sure we are strengthening our community in Portland.

543
00:48:49.782 --> 00:48:51.771
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Nate, would you like to kick us off?

544
00:48:52.492 --> 00:48:57.016
<v Nate McCoy>Yes, thank you, Chair, Vice Chair, members of the City Life Committee.

545
00:48:57.081 --> 00:48:58.541
<v Nate McCoy>Thank you for having me here today.

546
00:48:59.150 --> 00:49:04.764
<v Nate McCoy>For the record, my name is Nate McCoy, President and CEO of the National Association of Minority Contractors.

547
00:49:04.829 --> 00:49:10.407
<v Nate McCoy>For the state of Oregon, as well as the interim executive director of the Black Business Association of Oregon.

548
00:49:10.807 --> 00:49:15.969
<v Nate McCoy>I'm going to kind of blend both panels because I could see myself in both of these panels, the prior and this one.

549
00:49:16.626 --> 00:49:25.266
<v Nate McCoy>But let me first state that small businesses and communities most impacted by policies tend to be the most resilient folks in our communities.

550
00:49:25.523 --> 00:49:26.757
<v Nate McCoy>So I just want to state that.

551
00:49:26.822 --> 00:49:30.076
<v Nate McCoy>That's where I think our parallels definitely are between panels.

552
00:49:30.204 --> 00:49:31.565
<v Nate McCoy>I wanted to give a quick brief—.

553
00:49:31.565 --> 00:49:31.806
<v Nate McCoy>Thank you.

554
00:49:32.672 --> 00:49:37.990
<v Nate McCoy>I guess, mission background of both organizations for some that may not know NAMAC and BBAO very well.

555
00:49:38.519 --> 00:49:45.905
<v Nate McCoy>And then certainly lean into some structural challenges that we see past, present, and probably in the future.

556
00:49:45.969 --> 00:49:47.891
<v Nate McCoy>But hopefully we together can work on it.

557
00:49:48.371 --> 00:49:56.798
<v Nate McCoy>The mission of NAMAC Oregon focuses primarily on construction and design industries and economic inclusion within public and private projects.

558
00:49:57.407 --> 00:50:03.159
<v Nate McCoy>Our mission is to eliminate barriers to full and profitable participation for small construction and design firms.

559
00:50:03.496 --> 00:50:13.782
<v Nate McCoy>Supporting capacity building and business development for those firms, and promoting diverse workforce inclusion as these businesses have equitable procurement and pathways to grow their business.

560
00:50:15.065 --> 00:50:25.271
<v Nate McCoy>Overall, NAMAC Oregon's purpose is to ensure businesses of color have access, relationships, skills, and opportunity pipelines to compete and succeed in construction economy.

561
00:50:25.817 --> 00:50:30.503
<v Nate McCoy>And we support that through a variety of what we call owner's rep services at NAMAC and BBAO.

562
00:50:32.702 --> 00:50:35.688
<v Nate McCoy>Which I will paraphrase as some of the big bond projects.

563
00:50:35.833 --> 00:50:50.766
<v Nate McCoy>If we look at Multnomah County Library Bond, Portland Public School Bond, Portland Community College Bond, and the beautiful airport that NAMAC played the role as owner's rep on, you can't deny how much inclusion we've had on a couple of projects.

564
00:50:51.023 --> 00:50:55.936
<v Nate McCoy>And I just can see how we could expand those opportunities to be more resilient.

565
00:50:55.983 --> 00:50:56.097
<v Nate McCoy>Thank you.

566
00:50:56.786 --> 00:50:59.978
<v Nate McCoy>And how we support bandwidth of our agencies.

567
00:51:00.650 --> 00:51:09.038
<v Nate McCoy>Procurement staffs across the board are pretty small and thin, but yet procurement is the pathway to all economic opportunities for small businesses in the community.

568
00:51:09.086 --> 00:51:13.288
<v Nate McCoy>So we want to see that replicated and expanded and scaled.

569
00:51:13.721 --> 00:51:32.460
<v Nate McCoy>And then on the Black Business Association Oregon side, focused, as Steven Green and Andrew Hone and others said, solely on economic development policy and an agenda to change some of the baselines that continue to show inequities that we clearly see in disparity studies at the state and local levels.

570
00:51:33.697 --> 00:51:46.355
<v Nate McCoy>And the, the big center, if you will, for us is empowering Black-owned businesses to grow, lead, and thrive, and advocating for those policies and systems changes so that we can see sustainable economic equity.

571
00:51:47.190 --> 00:51:57.358
<v Nate McCoy>And then, you know, this is very big— building infrastructure partnerships and cultural responses I mean, I think we all know that from youth all the way up to adults.

572
00:51:57.471 --> 00:52:01.534
<v Nate McCoy>We have to, we have to have best business practices.

573
00:52:01.648 --> 00:52:09.791
<v Nate McCoy>And some of these firms know how to do the work but haven't been in places to where they've ran businesses to know how to run the business side of the work.

574
00:52:10.659 --> 00:52:15.351
<v Nate McCoy>And so we're helping support them through mentoring and a lot of different programming.

575
00:52:15.849 --> 00:52:20.217
<v Nate McCoy>And so in essence, BBL works to create lasting systemic change thank you.

576
00:52:20.266 --> 00:52:27.684
<v Nate McCoy>So Black entrepreneurs and our collective small business communities can achieve long-term economic mobility and success in Oregon.

577
00:52:28.952 --> 00:52:50.304
<v Nate McCoy>So with that said, the biggest thing I want folks to hear, because with the federal rhetoric you would think that much of what we do for small businesses are handouts, protecting small businesses through our work and others is less about shielding and, you know, handholding to the point of like we're running these businesses for folks.

578
00:52:51.041 --> 00:53:00.811
<v Nate McCoy>These firms are very resilient, and what they really, really need politicians and certainly electeds to hear is that their problems are not in their business.

579
00:53:01.117 --> 00:53:09.474
<v Nate McCoy>It's the structural challenges, reducing barriers, increasing access to opportunity and sustainable workforce.

580
00:53:09.876 --> 00:53:14.739
<v Nate McCoy>And as Andrew Hone and others mentioned, The problem really is the systems that we operate in.

581
00:53:15.655 --> 00:53:28.791
<v Nate McCoy>I can look at many of the systems that we have at City of Portland as a former employee of the City of Portland, and many of the procurements always talk about large businesses and how much experience you have to have to build anything.

582
00:53:29.304 --> 00:53:39.309
<v Nate McCoy>If you're a small business who feels they're set to build a big project, a pool, a convention center, or whatever it might be, there should be a pathway for you to be able to achieve that goal.

583
00:53:39.742 --> 00:53:44.771
<v Nate McCoy>We have some within the NAMAC family who are doing that, and we again want to see more succeed.

584
00:53:45.108 --> 00:53:47.115
<v Nate McCoy>Here are the big, big problems though.

585
00:53:48.255 --> 00:53:58.489
<v Nate McCoy>We have disparity studies that have no implementation strategy, and I go back 15 years with disparity studies, all the way back to Vera Katz's days here.

586
00:53:59.661 --> 00:54:07.001
<v Nate McCoy>We've done nothing with these disparity studies other than continue to have conversations, committees, and we need to move past words and into real action.

587
00:54:07.050 --> 00:54:07.146
<v Nate McCoy>Thank you.

588
00:54:07.960 --> 00:54:16.527
<v Nate McCoy>And I think that's where the partnerships happen with those that can help move the needle and understand these systems we've operated in for far too long.

589
00:54:16.800 --> 00:54:19.556
<v Nate McCoy>Contract access and relationship brokerage.

590
00:54:20.105 --> 00:54:26.367
<v Nate McCoy>I think it's a myth that small businesses have the same luxury and relationships as large businesses.

591
00:54:26.885 --> 00:54:32.597
<v Nate McCoy>Many of the project managers within the bureaus— I won't name folks, but they've worked with a lot of these contractors for 20-plus years.

592
00:54:32.646 --> 00:54:32.695
<v Nate McCoy>Yeah.

593
00:54:33.507 --> 00:54:37.735
<v Nate McCoy>And you wonder why they keep showing up and getting the same projects year after year.

594
00:54:38.184 --> 00:54:46.639
<v Nate McCoy>We've got to change that dynamic and put them in a little bit more of a visibility seat so that they can see their market opportunities just as well as big business.

595
00:54:47.387 --> 00:54:49.206
<v Nate McCoy>Capacity building and technical assistance.

596
00:54:50.150 --> 00:54:58.594
<v Nate McCoy>Working with procurement, I can tell you that in the last budget cycle, we slashed a lot of technical assistance resources that were helping my nonprofit.

597
00:54:58.643 --> 00:54:58.724
<v Nate McCoy>Yes.

598
00:54:59.306 --> 00:55:06.907
<v Nate McCoy>And a lot of other nonprofits help people earn while they learn on City of Portland projects, Bull Run being one of those examples.

599
00:55:07.661 --> 00:55:15.246
<v Nate McCoy>But we know that these systems can change, and if we can dedicate more resources, we can see a little bit more ROI on that spin.

600
00:55:16.481 --> 00:55:22.590
<v Nate McCoy>The other thing I'll also mention is a collective voice and market visibility.

601
00:55:22.639 --> 00:55:26.311
<v Nate McCoy>I'm happy to be on a panel with a lot of other folks who help support support the community.

602
00:55:26.889 --> 00:55:36.545
<v Nate McCoy>I want to see us challenge ourselves to work more inclusively together with you all, but then outside of these 4 walls that we're also convening and coming up with strategies together.

603
00:55:36.610 --> 00:55:42.673
<v Nate McCoy>So my commitment will not just be about what you all do, but what I also do in my own beloved community as well.

604
00:55:43.492 --> 00:55:56.260
<v Nate McCoy>And then one cool one that I, I really love to say that I think will hopefully enhance COBID, the system that a lot of small businesses have to go through to get certification to be be accounted for on goals set by public agencies on projects.

605
00:55:56.887 --> 00:56:01.601
<v Nate McCoy>We find that over 60-70% of businesses out there have no idea what COBID is.

606
00:56:02.195 --> 00:56:06.445
<v Nate McCoy>So we decided to spend our own resilient funds to create our own CRM system.

607
00:56:06.847 --> 00:56:12.958
<v Nate McCoy>That CRM system already holds 350 firms that we've found with the 12 staff that we have at NAMAC.

608
00:56:13.487 --> 00:56:16.744
<v Nate McCoy>I think we could expand it at the state level and find more and more.

609
00:56:16.856 --> 00:56:20.737
<v Nate McCoy>And both me and Stephen Green and support of PMC will be thank you.

610
00:56:20.802 --> 00:56:28.096
<v Nate McCoy>I'm going to be talking with Secretary Tobias Reed to talk about how we find more and more businesses throughout the state that have to renew their business.

611
00:56:28.496 --> 00:56:43.534
<v Nate McCoy>So can we somehow collect that data so that we can go out to these communities that we're a part of and help people get COBID certified and just help them find that opportunity as a design, construction, or goods and service business for our, for our whole state of Oregon?

612
00:56:44.527 --> 00:56:46.387
<v Nate McCoy>Here's the big idea for me.

613
00:56:46.771 --> 00:56:47.061
<v Nate McCoy>Absolutely.

614
00:56:47.173 --> 00:56:50.963
<v Nate McCoy>And let me just state what I wrote down because this kind of encapsulates it.

615
00:56:51.364 --> 00:56:54.527
<v Nate McCoy>NAMAC Oregon and BBL don't just support diverse businesses.

616
00:56:55.121 --> 00:57:14.994
<v Nate McCoy>What we really truly do is stabilize them in an ecosystem with other people at the same size of their company so they can feel empowered, so they can feel like they're not alone, and so they can feel also there's a network of, uh, supports as well as workforce so that as they do scale they're not looking outward.

617
00:57:15.268 --> 00:57:20.557
<v Nate McCoy>They can come to a NAMAC and our business hub and others to like get the supports and resources they need.

618
00:57:20.894 --> 00:57:26.440
<v Nate McCoy>So for me, I've said it before, the Prime Contractor Development Program, I can't say it enough.

619
00:57:26.809 --> 00:57:32.036
<v Nate McCoy>The program goes back to when I was a city employee 10 years ago out of a disparity study.

620
00:57:32.501 --> 00:57:44.606
<v Nate McCoy>It was a way to literally create tiers of contractors, $200,000 and below, Contractors, after they graduated that program, basically as Stephen Green said, you can let direct contracts out to them.

621
00:57:45.088 --> 00:57:47.621
<v Nate McCoy>There was technical assistance fund tied to the program.

622
00:57:48.119 --> 00:57:53.074
<v Nate McCoy>Once you got a couple of projects in that level of Tier 1, you would rise up to the Tier 2.

623
00:57:53.250 --> 00:57:59.889
<v Nate McCoy>You'd have million-dollar and below contracts that would almost be in your pipeline of small business bidding opportunities.

624
00:58:00.322 --> 00:58:04.298
<v Nate McCoy>And then when you got through with that one, you could go up to Tier 3, which would be a little above a million.

625
00:58:04.958 --> 00:58:24.851
<v Nate McCoy>I can't name a better program that we need to reinvest in and really stand back up so that we can add hopefully goods and service businesses to that so that we can create a pool of, call it, 100 businesses that can be directed contract work opportunities, get technical assistance, and then hire from their own communities.

626
00:58:25.204 --> 00:58:33.001
<v Nate McCoy>Program worked well until we had some challenges with nepotism and some folks who had shoplifted the program, if I'm being honest.

627
00:58:33.065 --> 00:58:35.677
<v Nate McCoy>But those folks were not some of the contractors of color.

628
00:58:36.047 --> 00:58:49.956
<v Nate McCoy>So the program went away for a while, and we're hoping that we can reinvest, because to me, that would be the quickest way for us to start showing our community that we are open for business and that these disparity studies will not dictate your opportunity or not.

629
00:58:50.789 --> 00:58:55.501
<v Nate McCoy>So with that said, I am here along with my panelists to answer questions as we all talk today.

630
00:58:55.581 --> 00:58:55.869
<v Nate McCoy>Thank you.

631
00:58:56.157 --> 00:58:56.704
<v Nate McCoy>So thank you.

632
00:58:57.570 --> 00:58:59.304
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for kicking us off here.

633
00:59:00.396 --> 00:59:08.840
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have Amy Nagy next talking about how the new iteration of TIF districts work to build community resilience.

634
00:59:09.210 --> 00:59:09.483
<v Amy Nagy>Great.

635
00:59:09.626 --> 00:59:10.847
<v Amy Nagy>Thank you so much for having me.

636
00:59:12.099 --> 00:59:12.981
<v Amy Nagy>I do have a deck.

637
00:59:14.362 --> 00:59:14.556
<v Amy Nagy>Great.

638
00:59:14.925 --> 00:59:15.117
<v Amy Nagy>Awesome.

639
00:59:15.166 --> 00:59:15.630
<v Amy Nagy>Thank you so much.

640
00:59:16.610 --> 00:59:18.632
<v Amy Nagy>So for the record, I am Amy Nagy.

641
00:59:18.922 --> 00:59:26.208
<v Amy Nagy>I am currently serving as the interim director of development and investment at Prosper Portland, which is the city's economic development agency.

642
00:59:27.300 --> 00:59:35.081
<v Amy Nagy>The department is responsible for managing the city's tax increment finance districts, also known as TIF districts, in coordination with the Portland Housing Bureau.

643
00:59:36.027 --> 00:59:46.987
<v Amy Nagy>In more recent years, this has been done through district action plans that set the community priorities and investments in 5-year increments with the goal of creating healthy and vibrant neighborhoods.

644
00:59:47.581 --> 01:00:02.043
<v Amy Nagy>As you all know, 6 new TIF districts were approved in 2024, we're replicating the co-creation model that was developed in the Colee TIF District to set priorities and budget allocations in partnership with community members in each of these districts.

645
01:00:03.003 --> 01:00:03.637
<v Amy Nagy>Next slide, please.

646
01:00:06.992 --> 01:00:09.407
<v Amy Nagy>Community members asked for a new approach to TIF.

647
01:00:10.250 --> 01:00:19.251
<v Amy Nagy>This led to roughly a 4-year process to create the Colee TIF District Plan, which outlines the long-term vision, the goals, and eligible projects.

648
01:00:19.300 --> 01:00:19.398
<v Amy Nagy>Thank you.

649
01:00:19.851 --> 01:00:30.639
<v Amy Nagy>Prosper Portland and PHB worked with the Colee Community Leadership Committee, a community-based advisory committee, to create the district's first action plan, which you all approved recently.

650
01:00:30.751 --> 01:00:31.568
<v Amy Nagy>Thank you so much.

651
01:00:32.914 --> 01:00:38.909
<v Amy Nagy>The plan sets 5-year priorities and allocates the funding for the selected programs and projects.

652
01:00:39.487 --> 01:01:01.976
<v Amy Nagy>It serves as a roadmap to guide the implementation and ensure accountability for housing and economic outcomes that are intended next slide, please.

653
01:01:02.248 --> 01:01:13.288
<v Amy Nagy>The action plan currently directs $31 million of funding to investments focused on community stabilization and anti-displacement goals through wealth building and ownership opportunities for people in Colegate.

654
01:01:14.293 --> 01:01:32.945
<v Amy Nagy>Funding through grant and loan programs can be assessed by the community for costs associated with climate preparedness and environmental adaptation costs, including roof replacements, energy systems, new windows, solar panel installation, etc., amongst others associated with construction.

655
01:01:34.099 --> 01:01:43.621
<v Amy Nagy>These types of investments are designed to support community resilience by keeping people in their homes next slide, please.

656
01:01:45.760 --> 01:01:55.141
<v Amy Nagy>The action plan establishes a financial certainty for the community to know funding is available to make improvements when needed and further their own goals.

657
01:01:55.963 --> 01:02:00.458
<v Amy Nagy>The CLC can be— can also recommend changes to those priority allocations.

658
01:02:00.505 --> 01:02:05.063
<v Amy Nagy>They have the power to do that, and if they see the opportunity to achieve a different outcome, they can recommend that.

659
01:02:05.806 --> 01:02:06.469
<v Amy Nagy>Midway through.

660
01:02:08.380 --> 01:02:25.632
<v Amy Nagy>Ongoing engagement and relationship building amongst community-based liaisons that are on the ground and having a key presence in that district is helping us to build trust with community residents, with business owners, et cetera.

661
01:02:26.085 --> 01:02:47.391
<v Amy Nagy>And it's creating actually a stronger, I would say, more adaptable social network that's helping create some stability and in particularly I'll close with this, is that a commitment to resilience, kind of the big idea, if you will, the commitment to resilience is really a commitment to the long-term engagement and centering that particular community's needs.

662
01:02:48.610 --> 01:02:52.231
<v Amy Nagy>Getting to that point, it can be super bumpy, as you all know.

663
01:02:52.695 --> 01:02:58.369
<v Amy Nagy>It took 4 years just to get to the actual TIF district plan, and then 2 more years for the action plan.

664
01:02:58.416 --> 01:03:03.782
<v Amy Nagy>I think it's important to note that the but, and it takes a long time, but the lasting, it's lasting.

665
01:03:03.958 --> 01:03:06.726
<v Amy Nagy>And that is, I think, what we actually need to be prioritizing at this time.

666
01:03:07.449 --> 01:03:07.777
<v Amy Nagy>Thank you.

667
01:03:09.452 --> 01:03:11.554
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for bringing that into the conversation.

668
01:03:12.847 --> 01:03:17.635
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next committee, we have Tracy Scott to talk about the PSAP community grants.

669
01:03:17.733 --> 01:03:18.885
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here.

670
01:03:19.409 --> 01:03:23.335
<v Tracy Scott>Yeah, good afternoon, Chair Pirtle-Guiney and members of the committee.

671
01:03:23.867 --> 01:03:24.869
<v Tracy Scott>Thank you for having me.

672
01:03:25.014 --> 01:03:33.286
<v Tracy Scott>I'm Tracy Scott, the co-chair of the Portland Clean Energy Fund and director of energy programs at Energy Trust of Oregon.

673
01:03:33.784 --> 01:03:35.454
<v Tracy Scott>I'm here today in both capacities.

674
01:03:36.289 --> 01:03:51.141
<v Tracy Scott>Energy Trust, for the record, is— thank you so much, maybe I scoop forward— is an independent nonprofit that helps Oregonians access clean, affordable energy, including here in the city of Portland.

675
01:03:51.541 --> 01:04:06.251
<v Tracy Scott>Reaching Portland's priority populations requires coordination across programs and partners, so we should continue and strengthen the alignment between PSEF and Energy Trust to maximize impact in the years ahead.

676
01:04:07.166 --> 01:04:12.469
<v Tracy Scott>PSEF, through the Climate Investment Plan and community grants, is one part of the system.

677
01:04:12.853 --> 01:04:17.436
<v Tracy Scott>Energy Trust, through incentives, services, and technical expertise, is another.

678
01:04:18.384 --> 01:04:24.934
<v Tracy Scott>When these efforts are aligned, we deliver stronger and more efficient results for Portland communities.

679
01:04:25.688 --> 01:04:47.331
<v Tracy Scott>Working together allows us to go deeper with the same households and neighborhoods, for example, by stacking PSF funding with Energy Trust incentives, coordination, coordinating outreach, and through trusted community-based organizations, and sharing technical expertise, makes participation easier for Portlanders.

680
01:04:48.231 --> 01:04:54.172
<v Tracy Scott>The one big idea is to treat cooling as essential infrastructure.

681
01:04:54.670 --> 01:04:57.608
<v Tracy Scott>One of the clearest shifts we're seeing is around heat.

682
01:04:58.284 --> 01:05:00.916
<v Tracy Scott>This is already affecting Portlanders today.

683
01:05:01.576 --> 01:05:08.047
<v Tracy Scott>Through Cooling Portland, PSEF has helped bring cooling into more than 20,000 homes.

684
01:05:08.561 --> 01:05:18.485
<v Tracy Scott>Energy Trust is also supporting heat pump adoption at scale by helping expanding access to more permanent heat cooling solutions for customers.

685
01:05:19.400 --> 01:05:32.726
<v Tracy Scott>At the same time, we're seeing progress at the state level, particularly around landlord-provided cooling, recognizing that access to cooling needs to be more consistent across all housing types.

686
01:05:33.273 --> 01:05:36.612
<v Tracy Scott>Taken together, this is pointing in the same direction.

687
01:05:37.126 --> 01:05:39.032
<v Tracy Scott>Cooling is no longer optional.

688
01:05:39.385 --> 01:05:41.483
<v Tracy Scott>It's a basic health and safety need.

689
01:05:41.932 --> 01:05:51.835
<v Tracy Scott>The opportunity now is to treat it that way, less as a programmatic response and more as a standard part of housing and infrastructure, infrastructure going forward.

690
01:05:52.684 --> 01:06:03.789
<v Tracy Scott>At its core, resiliency means can people stay safe, cool, connected, and supported during extreme heat, wildfire smoke, and power outages?

691
01:06:04.461 --> 01:06:09.958
<v Tracy Scott>Investments that help people during those moments also strengthen communities for the long term.

692
01:06:10.791 --> 01:06:19.893
<v Tracy Scott>Through PCEP's Cooling Portland Initiative— I'm sorry, the most effective investments deliver multiple benefits all at once.

693
01:06:20.967 --> 01:06:32.233
<v Tracy Scott>Deep energy retrofits and home upgrades can lower utility bills, improve indoor air quality, increase safety during heat events, and reduce emissions.

694
01:06:32.666 --> 01:06:40.905
<v Tracy Scott>In some cases, households have saved over $1,000 per year while gaining critical cooling and energy resilience.

695
01:06:41.643 --> 01:06:54.916
<v Tracy Scott>PSEF's value is also reflected in who it reaches and how it delivers solutions to— into communities and facilities that traditional systems do not always reach effectively.

696
01:06:55.413 --> 01:07:01.065
<v Tracy Scott>And those solutions are by organizations that understand their communities best.

697
01:07:01.851 --> 01:07:16.891
<v Tracy Scott>We're facing compounding climate impacts— more heat, more smoke, and more extreme weather— alongside underinvestments in priority population buildings and increasing affordability pressure.

698
01:07:17.902 --> 01:07:20.378
<v Tracy Scott>Clean energy upgrades help address both.

699
01:07:21.228 --> 01:07:33.284
<v Tracy Scott>These strategies save energy, generate renewable power, store energy when it's needed, and ultimately lower bills while protecting people from rising costs.

700
01:07:33.893 --> 01:07:35.465
<v Tracy Scott>We cannot do this work alone.

701
01:07:36.043 --> 01:07:45.882
<v Tracy Scott>It depends on partnerships among cities, programs like PSEF, utilities, community organizations, and customers we serve.

702
01:07:46.572 --> 01:07:52.210
<v Tracy Scott>We align our efforts— the more we align our efforts, The stronger results we'll deliver.

703
01:07:52.630 --> 01:08:00.981
<v Tracy Scott>So in closing, Energy Trust looks forward to continuing and strengthening this work alongside PSEF for all Portlanders.

704
01:08:01.639 --> 01:08:11.981
<v Tracy Scott>Work that keeps people safe during extreme heat, work that maintains critical services during outages, and work that lowers bills and emissions at the same time.

705
01:08:12.385 --> 01:08:12.710
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

706
01:08:14.251 --> 01:08:16.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much, and thank you for bringing forward that.

707
01:08:17.333 --> 01:08:19.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That big idea connected to the theme as well.

708
01:08:21.091 --> 01:08:26.614
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next committee, we will hear from Vivian Satterfield about some of our climate action work at the city.

709
01:08:27.033 --> 01:08:27.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

710
01:08:28.172 --> 01:08:30.099
<v Vivian Satterfield>Thank you, Chair, Vice Chair, members of the committee.

711
01:08:30.243 --> 01:08:31.577
<v Vivian Satterfield>Thank you for having me this afternoon.

712
01:08:31.769 --> 01:08:34.595
<v Vivian Satterfield>I'm Vivian Satterfield, your Chief Sustainability Officer.

713
01:08:35.092 --> 01:08:37.662
<v Vivian Satterfield>I want to start my comments today with the big picture.

714
01:08:38.432 --> 01:08:42.301
<v Vivian Satterfield>Every issue that this committee has purview over— economic development, Thank you.

715
01:08:42.398 --> 01:08:43.024
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Every issue we address in this committee—.

716
01:08:43.024 --> 01:08:47.485
<v Vivian Satterfield>Housing, development, parks, labor, equity, community resilience— has a climate dimension.

717
01:08:48.865 --> 01:08:51.000
<v Vivian Satterfield>Portland faces an enormous challenge ahead.

718
01:08:51.930 --> 01:09:07.692
<v Vivian Satterfield>To meet our 2030 climate goal established by the 2020 Climate Emergency Declaration of reducing community-wide carbon emissions by at least 50% below 1990 levels, we must reduce emissions by 24% in the next 4 years.

719
01:09:07.742 --> 01:09:16.469
<v Vivian Satterfield>That's essentially doubling the pace of our annual reductions for four years, and that's a Herculean task that weighs heavy on the minds of the city's climate practitioners.

720
01:09:18.402 --> 01:09:23.721
<v Vivian Satterfield>We cannot meet those goals without recognizing how deeply interdependent climate action is with our energy system.

721
01:09:24.550 --> 01:09:33.128
<v Vivian Satterfield>Our ability to decarbonize while maintaining affordability depends on a grid and utility partners that are prepared, accountable, and aligned.

722
01:09:33.239 --> 01:09:34.363
<v Vivian Satterfield>Aligned with our climate goals.

723
01:09:35.760 --> 01:09:39.806
<v Vivian Satterfield>At the same time, we must prepare our community for the impacts that are already here.

724
01:09:41.220 --> 01:09:51.849
<v Vivian Satterfield>As mentioned, the 2022 Climate Emergency Work Plan called out the need for Portlanders to be resilient to everyday climate stresses like heat, wildfire smoke, power outages, flooding.

725
01:09:52.699 --> 01:09:54.322
<v Vivian Satterfield>And these events don't hit everyone equally.

726
01:09:54.851 --> 01:09:59.207
<v Vivian Satterfield>They deepen disparities that communities of color and low-income Portlanders already thank you.

727
01:09:59.759 --> 01:10:01.283
<v Vivian Satterfield>Our work must start from that reality.

728
01:10:01.625 --> 01:10:05.404
<v Vivian Satterfield>We appreciate the work of the PSF committee for dedicating their time and resources there as well.

729
01:10:07.390 --> 01:10:15.819
<v Vivian Satterfield>Early findings from the climate change risk assessment that I've initiated with the Oregon Climate Change Research Institute point to heat as one of our most urgent threats.

730
01:10:17.050 --> 01:10:21.770
<v Vivian Satterfield>We expect roughly 60 days each year with a heat index above 80 degrees Fahrenheit.

731
01:10:22.257 --> 01:10:24.140
<v Vivian Satterfield>That's 3 weeks more than in the past.

732
01:10:25.206 --> 01:10:29.511
<v Vivian Satterfield>We're also looking at increases of 9 to 11 days of extreme fire danger.

733
01:10:31.199 --> 01:10:37.323
<v Vivian Satterfield>We all lived through the deadly 2021 heat dome, but 70 community members in Multnomah County did not.

734
01:10:38.431 --> 01:10:43.853
<v Vivian Satterfield>We know how disruptive wildfire smoke and extreme storms are when they close parks, schools, and cancel events.

735
01:10:44.402 --> 01:10:53.430
<v Vivian Satterfield>So I take these climate projections seriously because they give us a sobering reality check on the climate impacts to public health, our infrastructure, our economy, and workforce.

736
01:10:54.845 --> 01:11:08.458
<v Vivian Satterfield>This February, the city auditor told us plainly what we already knew as part of their climate justice audit: Portland has lacked clear direction, measurable strategies, and accountability structures to meet its own climate commitments and community needs for resiliency.

737
01:11:10.270 --> 01:11:16.604
<v Vivian Satterfield>The final climate emergency work plan progress report stated it clearly: this moment invites Portland to lead with transparency and courage.

738
01:11:17.520 --> 01:11:23.755
<v Vivian Satterfield>What we need is discipline, resource commitments, and steady follow-through to actualize our climate goals.

739
01:11:25.300 --> 01:11:31.387
<v Vivian Satterfield>One concept to follow through on that could meaningfully improve Portland's future is to align our energy and resilience strategies.

740
01:11:32.655 --> 01:11:46.668
<v Vivian Satterfield>A coordinated energy strategy in the form of a Portland virtual power plant could help us get ahead of rising energy costs and plan for a future where households builds, neighborhoods, businesses, and community institutions produce and manage more of their own energy.

741
01:11:47.985 --> 01:11:50.650
<v Vivian Satterfield>We've already got many of those familiar toolbox in our toolbox.

742
01:11:50.956 --> 01:11:59.354
<v Vivian Satterfield>Think small-scale battery storage, community-based renewables, smart thermostats— you probably have these in your homes— heat pumps, even electric vehicles.

743
01:12:00.028 --> 01:12:05.069
<v Vivian Satterfield>Those all give us flexibility in how energy is generated and stored close to where we need it.

744
01:12:05.969 --> 01:12:07.462
<v Vivian Satterfield>When coordinated, Thank you.

745
01:12:07.654 --> 01:12:13.739
<v Vivian Satterfield>When community centers are fully automated, they strengthen grid reliability, support decarbonization, and keep energy affordable.

746
01:12:15.041 --> 01:12:17.417
<v Vivian Satterfield>And importantly, they provide resilience during outages.

747
01:12:18.252 --> 01:12:25.926
<v Vivian Satterfield>Imagine community centers functioning as true resilience hubs with backup power that keeps people safe during extreme heat or storms.

748
01:12:27.307 --> 01:12:37.961
<v Vivian Satterfield>One way this committee can support is to connect climate directly to housing and economic economic development projects and make the linkage explicit in policy and budgetary decisions.

749
01:12:39.034 --> 01:12:59.817
<v Vivian Satterfield>That could look like adopting carbon performance and cooling standards for buildings to become more resilient to hotter days, advancing resilience hubs citywide, adopting a smart surfaces approach, investing in trees, solar, reflective and permeable surfaces, cool roofs that can all reduce heat, save energy, Thank you.

750
01:13:01.353 --> 01:13:06.961
<v Vivian Satterfield>There are additional recommendations and ready concepts that I look forward to sharing with you at a future time if you choose to focus your efforts here.

751
01:13:08.720 --> 01:13:13.789
<v Vivian Satterfield>Lastly, I'll leave you with this: climate work doesn't follow an election cycle or even a linear project timeline.

752
01:13:14.610 --> 01:13:16.719
<v Vivian Satterfield>It demands steady, sustained commitment.

753
01:13:17.695 --> 01:13:32.567
<v Vivian Satterfield>The role I'm in as your CSO, alongside the recently established Sustainability and Climate Commission, we're designed here to provide support to you as city decision makers, develop measurable strategies, and offer a level of coordination that simply hasn't existed before.

754
01:13:32.967 --> 01:13:40.996
<v Vivian Satterfield>I encourage you to take advantage of this moment to protect Portlanders, grow equitably, and build a future that is more resilient, more affordable, and more just.

755
01:13:41.381 --> 01:13:41.637
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

756
01:13:41.782 --> 01:13:44.109
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you very much.

757
01:13:45.137 --> 01:13:50.226
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, we'll close out this panel with Jeremy Van Keuren talking about our NET team.

758
01:13:50.452 --> 01:13:54.402
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Thank you, Chair, Vice Chair, and members of the committee.

759
01:13:54.481 --> 01:14:00.213
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>My name is Jeremy VanKeuren, and I'm the Community Preparedness Manager for the Portland Bureau of Emergency Management.

760
01:14:01.113 --> 01:14:12.497
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And if you've heard me speak before, something I often open with is to point out that in the aftermath of a disaster, between 90 to 95% of all the people who are rescued are rescued by their neighbors.

761
01:14:12.706 --> 01:14:15.467
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>So community resilience is something that's very important to us.

762
01:14:16.141 --> 01:14:25.582
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>With my team, I manage the Neighborhood Emergency Team program, which includes 1,500 Portlanders in 80 neighborhoods trained as disaster responders for their communities.

763
01:14:26.176 --> 01:14:31.090
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>We also manage the COAD, which stands for Community Organizations Active in Disaster.

764
01:14:31.636 --> 01:14:40.194
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>This is a network of community-based organizations and faith-based institutions working with us to prepare their constituent communities for climate emergencies.

765
01:14:41.173 --> 01:14:44.545
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>In emergency management, we say that relationships are infrastructure.

766
01:14:45.186 --> 01:14:48.409
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>NET and the COAD are how we are building that infrastructure.

767
01:14:48.506 --> 01:14:55.242
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And that brings me to one of the ideas I was looking forward to broaching, which is to expand and socialize the COAD.

768
01:14:55.787 --> 01:15:01.287
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>COAD organizations are common in areas of the country that experience frequent disasters.

769
01:15:02.104 --> 01:15:10.908
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>In Florida, for example, anytime there's a hurricane, the local NGOs and faith groups there already know their role and how to interface with emergency responders.

770
01:15:11.515 --> 01:15:17.439
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>They've already prepared their communities and they are immediately ready and available to help.

771
01:15:18.377 --> 01:15:26.600
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>With the growing threat of climate emergencies, we need to build that same level of trust and socialization with nonprofits and faith organizations in our region.

772
01:15:27.443 --> 01:15:30.819
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And it was gratifying to hear Nate bring up the procurement process.

773
01:15:31.431 --> 01:15:39.029
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Something that would be really helpful to us is we, you know, we work with, again, with small organizations.

774
01:15:39.095 --> 01:15:40.966
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>We might contract with them to open a cooling center.

775
01:15:41.948 --> 01:15:44.502
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>During summer heat emergencies.

776
01:15:45.738 --> 01:15:52.131
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>But the procurement process is not particularly friendly to your corner church or your very small nonprofit organization.

777
01:15:52.869 --> 01:15:59.520
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And I want to emphasize that procurement staff that I've worked with have been nothing but helpful as much as they can be when we do work with them.

778
01:15:59.632 --> 01:16:06.925
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>But the system itself, I would say, is not particularly conducive to working with folks at that scale.

779
01:16:08.384 --> 01:16:12.648
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Another big idea that we're interested in and monitoring is the start of climate resilience districts.

780
01:16:13.256 --> 01:16:18.338
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>This is a movement we've been observing in California, and it's too soon to say if it'll bear fruit.

781
01:16:19.284 --> 01:16:29.302
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>But the idea is that local governments are creating geographic districts where they have the option of using mechanisms like tax increment financing, bonds, and grants to invest in climate resilience.

782
01:16:30.168 --> 01:16:43.207
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And finally, and I apologize, my, my I think our new form of government offers new opportunities for bureaus and partner government offices to collaborate on community resilience.

783
01:16:43.818 --> 01:16:48.140
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Community resilience means many different things to many different people, as was pointed out at the beginning.

784
01:16:49.296 --> 01:16:55.836
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>I work in the disaster management space, but many other bureaus are working on their own points of entry to community resilience.

785
01:16:56.591 --> 01:16:59.948
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And I'm hoping to be part of a more holistic and cross-bureau approach to community resilience.

786
01:17:01.586 --> 01:17:06.719
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Thank you so much.

787
01:17:06.766 --> 01:17:08.364
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you to all of our panelists.

788
01:17:08.445 --> 01:17:14.439
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we have about 5 minutes if anybody has any questions or points that you'd like to highlight from this panel.

789
01:17:22.065 --> 01:17:24.127
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm pausing because I have somebody looking at their notes.

790
01:17:24.176 --> 01:17:27.243
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think the most important thing is that we're I hope so.

791
01:17:30.739 --> 01:17:33.525
<v Dan Ryan>I'll just off the cuff, I didn't know you were going to allow us to do this.

792
01:17:33.605 --> 01:17:34.073
<v Dan Ryan>It's great.

793
01:17:34.492 --> 01:17:37.793
<v Dan Ryan>So I am listening and then it makes me want to ask questions since I'm listening to you.

794
01:17:37.921 --> 01:17:42.229
<v Dan Ryan>Jeremy, what you brought up at the end was really fascinating and you were careful.

795
01:17:42.375 --> 01:17:50.518
<v Dan Ryan>You're very diplomatic, but you were talking about procurement and that there's some roadblocks to working with certain organizations.

796
01:17:53.002 --> 01:17:56.854
<v Dan Ryan>Not— maybe not be as diplomatic and be a little more concrete on what that means.

797
01:17:57.694 --> 01:17:57.970
<v Nate McCoy>Sure.

798
01:17:58.034 --> 01:18:11.828
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>So we are caught in an intersection with working with community-based organizations, CBOs, where the state of Oregon is tightening up their rules around insurance.

799
01:18:12.037 --> 01:18:17.488
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And at the same time, here at the city, we're introducing a new procurement system through a REBA.

800
01:18:18.243 --> 01:18:30.712
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Which has been pretty efficient, but trying to onboard some of our contractors and consultants, frankly, has been— it's been extremely challenging.

801
01:18:31.212 --> 01:18:35.454
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And I think there's just some growing pains there.

802
01:18:36.149 --> 01:18:41.560
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>But for example, you know, I have invoices from last September that have still not been paid.

803
01:18:42.253 --> 01:18:45.185
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And our partners have been very patient with us.

804
01:18:45.248 --> 01:18:46.503
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>They get it, they understand it.

805
01:18:46.649 --> 01:18:51.313
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>That this is a new system, but that's just not acceptable, especially for small organizations.

806
01:18:53.350 --> 01:18:57.630
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>So I don't know if I'm completely addressing your question, but those are definitely the challenges.

807
01:18:57.726 --> 01:19:00.215
<v Dan Ryan>Know how to have more meetings and ask more questions.

808
01:19:00.408 --> 01:19:04.837
<v Dan Ryan>And I can see why you brought Nate in, in terms of that issue.

809
01:19:04.918 --> 01:19:08.864
<v Dan Ryan>I have a better understanding of, 'cause I've heard about it for a longer period of time.

810
01:19:09.829 --> 01:19:13.514
<v Dan Ryan>I remember with just with bonds and that they can't do certain projects.

811
01:19:14.219 --> 01:19:18.292
<v Dan Ryan>So it's like you're small and you're growing, but you're not there yet.

812
01:19:18.404 --> 01:19:19.511
<v Dan Ryan>Like, when are you ever going to be there?

813
01:19:20.474 --> 01:19:28.475
<v Dan Ryan>And so it kind of gets down to the I part of DEI and how we can be more inclusive when we start building these systems.

814
01:19:29.132 --> 01:19:34.185
<v Dan Ryan>And sometimes our policies choke each other from the state to local.

815
01:19:34.296 --> 01:19:36.430
<v Dan Ryan>And that's me trying to be diplomatic.

816
01:19:36.751 --> 01:19:37.408
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah.

817
01:19:37.488 --> 01:19:38.530
<v Dan Ryan>And say that I heard you.

818
01:19:38.690 --> 01:19:40.619
<v Dan Ryan>Did Am I following what you're—.

819
01:19:40.619 --> 01:19:41.199
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Yeah, I think so.

820
01:19:41.199 --> 01:19:42.399
<v Dan Ryan>And why you connected with Nate?

821
01:19:42.550 --> 01:19:44.930
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And yeah, and I think that would be a good idea.

822
01:19:45.500 --> 01:19:55.038
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And yeah, so situations like we'll have an independent consultant who is delivering lifesaving training in the community that is culturally relevant and in a different language.

823
01:19:55.500 --> 01:20:06.859
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>And then, but then when we ask 'em to come on as a vendor, even if they are their own person, they have to have auto insurance, liability insurance, just all kinds of insurance, carrying like $1 million worth of it for just one event.

824
01:20:06.859 --> 01:20:08.640
<v Dan Ryan>That's why you went back to the neighbors helping neighbors.

825
01:20:09.743 --> 01:20:13.319
<v Dan Ryan>And that some of our policies make that difficult to do.

826
01:20:13.898 --> 01:20:24.947
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>Yeah, and I want to be careful to say that I don't think people should carry less insurance, but the insurance regime that we seem to have is not helpful for us and the communities that we serve.

827
01:20:25.461 --> 01:20:26.407
<v Dan Ryan>I didn't hear you say that.

828
01:20:26.567 --> 01:20:32.533
<v Dan Ryan>And I just have to say, when I've been at neighborhood association meetings, I think twice where you're there, it's like, it's so great when you're there.

829
01:20:32.837 --> 01:20:34.328
<v Dan Ryan>Like, you really do engage the room.

830
01:20:34.618 --> 01:20:35.886
<v Dan Ryan>That's not always an easy room.

831
01:20:36.512 --> 01:20:40.927
<v Dan Ryan>You engage the room and they really do connect with one another and you can see it taking off.

832
01:20:41.282 --> 01:20:42.518
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you for your service.

833
01:20:42.952 --> 01:20:43.127
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

834
01:20:43.337 --> 01:20:45.858
<v Dan Ryan>And that's the one question I was drilling in on.

835
01:20:46.226 --> 01:20:47.207
<v Dan Ryan>Does anyone else have any?

836
01:20:47.350 --> 01:20:47.608
<v Lionel Irvin>Yeah.

837
01:20:47.703 --> 01:20:53.725
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we're gonna move to our next panel and I know there are other questions for you all.

838
01:20:53.789 --> 01:21:07.100
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll get them to you and make sure that we follow up on other things, but I'd like to make sure we have time for a break So thank you all so much for being part of our overview and helping us to start out our thinking on our work today.

839
01:21:09.340 --> 01:21:14.770
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, for our final panel, we're looking at the experience of people who live and visit Portland.

840
01:21:14.833 --> 01:21:20.671
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is a broad spectrum of the work that's been assigned to our committee.

841
01:21:21.413 --> 01:21:29.073
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll hear from Courtney Verano about— from For All Families Oregon about the impact experience of families in our community.

842
01:21:29.907 --> 01:21:40.454
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Bernal Cruz Munoz from the New Portlanders Policy Commission about the experience of members of our community who are new to Portland and to this country.

843
01:21:41.127 --> 01:21:47.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll hear from Subhashini Ganason-Forbes from our Arts Commission about arts broadly.

844
01:21:48.261 --> 01:21:52.975
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Arts intersect with this committee in a lot of ways, so this will be just a taste of that work.

845
01:21:53.856 --> 01:22:04.453
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>From Jessica Green about how parks help to create the foundation for the experience of people who are here, and from Lori Wimmer looking broadly at the experience of working people in Portland.

846
01:22:05.574 --> 01:22:06.985
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Courtney, please go right ahead.

847
01:22:07.323 --> 01:22:07.963
<v Amy Nagy>Thank you.

848
01:22:08.604 --> 01:22:19.328
<v Courtney Varano>Uh, Chair Pirtle-Guiney, Vice Chair Zimmerman, members of the committee, for the record, my name is Courtney Varano, my pronouns are she and her, and I'm here on behalf of For All Families Oregon.

849
01:22:19.474 --> 01:22:20.037
<v Courtney Varano>Thank you.

850
01:22:20.086 --> 01:22:22.355
<v Courtney Varano>I'm with Portland Families Forward Oregon, formerly Family Forward Oregon.

851
01:22:22.484 --> 01:22:29.949
<v Courtney Varano>And this is actually my first time as a Portlander testifying in front of City Council, so check off my bucket list.

852
01:22:32.849 --> 01:22:44.528
<v Courtney Varano>We organize caregivers, parents, and childcare providers in the fight for racial, gender, and economic justice, and to really center and uplift care at the center of our communities.

853
01:22:46.158 --> 01:23:08.905
<v Courtney Varano>When caregivers and advocates talk about making Portland family-friendly, we're not just talking about parks and playgrounds, but we are talking about whether parents can afford to live here while raising children, whether childcare providers can make enough to stay in the profession, and the fact that so many families are just one missed paycheck away from losing everything.

854
01:23:09.899 --> 01:23:10.720
<v Courtney Varano>Because here Thank you.

855
01:23:10.787 --> 01:23:14.420
<v Courtney Varano>Childcare is a tough reality about Portland.

856
01:23:15.750 --> 01:23:21.886
<v Courtney Varano>Childcare is unaffordable for nearly all families in Portland, regardless of income.

857
01:23:23.012 --> 01:23:33.944
<v Courtney Varano>A Portland family paying for infant care faces an average cost of nearly $20,000 per year, outpacing the cost of in-state public college tuition by about 50%.

858
01:23:35.224 --> 01:23:44.432
<v Courtney Varano>A recent LendingTree study shows a household with 2 children needs to make over $400,000 a year for it to be deemed affordable.

859
01:23:46.493 --> 01:23:53.547
<v Courtney Varano>Meanwhile, this is actually more than 3 times the median income for a family of 4 in the city.

860
01:23:54.969 --> 01:23:57.163
<v Courtney Varano>So what happens when families can't access care?

861
01:23:58.970 --> 01:24:11.871
<v Courtney Varano>One thing we can look to actually is the Portland Metro Chamber's recent study that found women with children under 6 participation rates of any women, or of all women.

862
01:24:12.465 --> 01:24:20.319
<v Courtney Varano>And the report explicitly states that the high cost and limited availability of infant and toddler care is a key barrier.

863
01:24:21.360 --> 01:24:28.350
<v Courtney Varano>This is even more troubling when we understand that the childcare workforce is 95% self-identified women.

864
01:24:29.279 --> 01:24:32.277
<v Courtney Varano>Black, brown, melanated, and immigrant women are disproportionately underrepresented in the workforce.

865
01:24:32.828 --> 01:24:40.761
<v Courtney Varano>Are disproportionately represented in this essential workforce, yet they make an average of just $35,000 a year.

866
01:24:42.194 --> 01:24:51.380
<v Courtney Varano>Providers are closing because they can't afford to stay open, and it's creating the largest workforce shortage gap in Oregon across all sectors.

867
01:24:54.681 --> 01:24:56.231
<v Courtney Varano>So what's the big idea?

868
01:24:57.356 --> 01:25:07.712
<v Courtney Varano>Portland has to start treating treating childcare like the essential economic infrastructure it is alongside transportation, housing, utilities.

869
01:25:08.546 --> 01:25:15.172
<v Courtney Varano>Every $1 invested returns $4 to $16 in economic benefit.

870
01:25:16.247 --> 01:25:20.386
<v Courtney Varano>That's better than almost any infrastructure project that this city could fund.

871
01:25:21.476 --> 01:25:25.327
<v Courtney Varano>So here are 3 concrete actions that Portland can take.

872
01:25:26.113 --> 01:25:30.028
<v Courtney Varano>First, eliminate zoning and building code red tape.

873
01:25:30.909 --> 01:25:36.831
<v Courtney Varano>Childcare providers are facing months, even years, navigating permits and zoning.

874
01:25:37.970 --> 01:26:02.703
<v Courtney Varano>The city should create a fast-track approval process, waive all permitting fees for new and expanding centers, and assign a dedicated navigator to help providers, particularly a dedicated navigator that, and program that is multilingual, multicultural to serve this really unique workforce that we have.

875
01:26:03.889 --> 01:26:10.270
<v Courtney Varano>Second, subsidize the childcare worker wages through existing infrastructure that we already have.

876
01:26:11.185 --> 01:26:14.536
<v Courtney Varano>The city doesn't need to make any new bureaucracy to do this.

877
01:26:15.434 --> 01:26:19.105
<v Courtney Varano>The Center for Career Development and Childhood Care at PSU thank you.

878
01:26:19.202 --> 01:26:26.507
<v Courtney Varano>The Center for Early Childhood Education at PSU has already disbursed millions in direct payments to the childcare workforce in 2024 and 2025.

879
01:26:27.390 --> 01:26:37.105
<v Courtney Varano>So Portland should commit city funds to partner with the center and PSU and continue these wage supplements for Portland providers past the 2026 year.

880
01:26:37.667 --> 01:26:42.372
<v Courtney Varano>This is direct economic support to workers that make every other sector possible.

881
01:26:43.591 --> 01:26:49.212
<v Courtney Varano>And third, We should provide pregnant mothers and families much-needed financial support.

882
01:26:50.350 --> 01:27:07.577
<v Courtney Varano>Portland should create a city-funded direct cash program with no strings attached payments for pregnant mothers and families with children under the age of one, similar to RxKids, which has been enormously successful in several cities across the state of Michigan.

883
01:27:08.091 --> 01:27:14.997
<v Courtney Varano>And in fact, we actually have a privately funded program operating just starting right here in Multnomah County, the Bridge Project.

884
01:27:17.149 --> 01:27:33.837
<v Courtney Varano>Research shows that direct cash has one of the highest ROI of any anti-poverty intervention, reducing childhood poverty, improving maternal health, and increasing housing stability, actually reducing the amount of evictions of families and people that are living in urban areas.

885
01:27:35.109 --> 01:27:45.868
<v Courtney Varano>And we learned this firsthand actually during the pandemic when the expanded child thank you.

886
01:27:46.934 --> 01:27:50.180
<v Courtney Varano>So to conclude, the question is simple.

887
01:27:50.567 --> 01:28:00.622
<v Courtney Varano>Does Portland want to be a city where only the wealthy can raise children, or a city where working families can put down roots, build wealth, and contribute long-term?

888
01:28:01.708 --> 01:28:16.121
<v Courtney Varano>These 3 policies I've outlined are achievable and funded by investments and frankly, they are necessary if we want Portland to be a city where families don't just survive but thrive.

889
01:28:16.649 --> 01:28:16.922
<v Courtney Varano>Thank you.

890
01:28:17.355 --> 01:28:20.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for kicking off this panel for us.

891
01:28:22.412 --> 01:28:24.320
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Bernal, you are up next.

892
01:28:24.400 --> 01:28:24.673
<v Dr. Mary King>Thank you.

893
01:28:24.738 --> 01:28:25.332
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>Good afternoon.

894
01:28:25.461 --> 01:28:29.439
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>It's nice to see you all again, and thank you for having me here today, members of this committee.

895
01:28:30.179 --> 01:28:32.377
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>I'm here today— oh, my name is Bernal Cruz.

896
01:28:33.007 --> 01:28:46.845
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>And I'm here today representing the New Portlanders City Commission, whereby members have been elected to represent and sort of bring voice to newcomers to the city, mainly migrants and folks who have been displaced.

897
01:28:48.868 --> 01:29:13.634
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>It is an honor to speak with you today and to be a resource, to continue to be a resource to City Life to carry out the good work of developing good policy that advances the interests of the NPPC really believes that Portland should pay close attention to the safety and the sense of wellness and belonging currently among migrants and all migrant and displaced people in the community.

898
01:29:14.532 --> 01:29:21.650
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>Many are facing concerns about ICE presence, rising xenophobic rhetoric, and the fears of family separation.

899
01:29:22.404 --> 01:29:25.002
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>As a result, some of us feel hesitant to leave our homes.

900
01:29:25.051 --> 01:29:25.179
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>I agree.

901
01:29:26.189 --> 01:29:30.628
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>Some of us feel worry and concern about traveling not just in our own communities but abroad.

902
01:29:31.221 --> 01:29:37.777
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>My father is actually one person who has decided not to return for a visit to Guatemala for fear of how he might be treated on the way back.

903
01:29:39.140 --> 01:29:43.483
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>This weighs very heavily on my family, but I know it's not true just for my family but our community at large.

904
01:29:44.942 --> 01:29:58.412
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>So one big idea for this complicated problem, or an opportunity for improvement, is this strengthening of the community support and making a clear, visible commitment from local government to protect vulnerable populations.

905
01:29:59.537 --> 01:30:05.751
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>This means more intentionally engaging the broader community and partner organizations to promote safety and wellness.

906
01:30:06.586 --> 01:30:12.783
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>It also means investing in programs and strategies that center these needs, as seen recently in efforts like funding SOAR.

907
01:30:14.277 --> 01:30:19.479
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>It is important that we continue to bear in mind that wellness is not defined by the lack of pathology.

908
01:30:20.143 --> 01:30:24.505
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>That is to say, just because we aren't ill, one should not conclude that our communities are well.

909
01:30:26.800 --> 01:30:57.002
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>City Council has a key role to play by being present, actively listening— thank you— and standing in solidarity with these communities, showing up to events, building trust through consistent engagement, communicating transparently about the actions being taken, and taking a proactive approach that anticipates the needs and supports safety and well-being before the crisis arises, and then responding only after harm has already occurred.

910
01:30:58.149 --> 01:31:05.716
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>Let us consider, for instance, that the wellness of our migrant communities is a measure of public health and therefore in the interest of the public at large.

911
01:31:06.056 --> 01:31:06.234
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

912
01:31:08.751 --> 01:31:12.954
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for bringing that into the conversation and making sure it's part of the work that we do.

913
01:31:13.470 --> 01:31:16.171
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, colleagues.

914
01:31:16.235 --> 01:31:22.220
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Next, we will hear from Subhashini Ganesan Forbes, um, about arts in our community.

915
01:31:24.246 --> 01:31:24.583
<v Candace Avalos>Please.

916
01:31:24.953 --> 01:31:28.239
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>For the record, my name is Subhashini Ganesan Forbes.

917
01:31:28.980 --> 01:31:32.427
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Thank you for including me in this conversation.

918
01:31:33.530 --> 01:31:41.784
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>I come to you today, uh, with my full self as a choreographer, nonprofit founder, and administrator and civic leader.

919
01:31:42.587 --> 01:31:56.329
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>In my various roles, I am honored to interact with the arts, music, and culture sector of our city and beyond through many different ways, and that helps me bring what I hope is a holistic perspective to this work.

920
01:31:57.630 --> 01:32:10.019
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>It's a little daunting to speak on behalf of arts and music and culture, so I want to lay, lay a little groundwork tell you my big idea, say why, and give you some hows.

921
01:32:11.413 --> 01:32:28.139
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>There are 3 major components of the arts, culture, and music sector that needs tending at all times if City Council's goal is to strengthen quality of life and belonging across Portland: people, product, place.

922
01:32:28.972 --> 01:32:32.948
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>People— that means artists, creatives, culture bearers.

923
01:32:33.608 --> 01:32:47.936
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Think choreographers, visual artists, muralists, playwrights, actors, dancers, musicians, composers, conductors, authors representing a vast array of cultures that represent our city.

924
01:32:48.948 --> 01:33:06.747
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>People also means arts education specialists, teaching artists, art specialists within our school systems, and all those who bring the precious and critical type of learning into classrooms where young people learn to be creative, innovative, and curious.

925
01:33:07.518 --> 01:33:21.524
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>People also means technicians— the lighting designers, sound designers, backstage staff, costume designers, set designers, book layout experts, preservationists, restoration experts, and that goes on.

926
01:33:22.037 --> 01:33:38.060
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>People also means the administrators, those who are supporting the mission of the sector by taking on executive development, communication, finances-related positions and organizations to support the making and thriving of the sector.

927
01:33:39.779 --> 01:33:46.787
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>And people also means voters and civic leaders who shape the well-being of our city for decades.

928
01:33:47.447 --> 01:33:48.493
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Now we go to product.

929
01:33:49.238 --> 01:33:51.823
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>All the people I listed are making things.

930
01:33:52.550 --> 01:34:15.235
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Their artistic and creative processes lead to plays, dance performances, books, literary magazines, music albums, music concerts, operas, street art, public art, murals, book fairs, TEDx events, film festivals, year-round seasons of intergenerational arts, culture, and music experiences.

931
01:34:17.149 --> 01:34:17.841
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>And thirdly, place.

932
01:34:18.934 --> 01:34:33.019
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>We can call them venues— big venues, small venues, theaters, concert halls, galleries, museums, bookshops, arenas, parks, and alternative venues like schools.

933
01:34:33.934 --> 01:34:39.837
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>These are the spaces that become imbued and embodied with arts, culture, and music activations.

934
01:34:40.992 --> 01:34:44.233
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>That is the community and sector that I'm speaking on behalf of.

935
01:34:44.280 --> 01:34:44.425
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Thank you.

936
01:34:45.260 --> 01:34:58.929
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>So the big idea: all 3 components need tending to simultaneously and equitably in order for Portland to shine as a safe, community-resilient city.

937
01:34:59.844 --> 01:35:09.998
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>The tendency sometimes is to prioritize place first, product next, and trust that the people will therefore be taken care of.

938
01:35:11.378 --> 01:35:14.105
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>This trickle-down theory just does not work.

939
01:35:15.085 --> 01:35:25.271
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Equally supporting the people, product, and place of the sector will benefit Portland economically and elevate community resilience and safety.

940
01:35:26.217 --> 01:35:30.694
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>I could tell you all the economic data that exists.

941
01:35:31.384 --> 01:35:36.871
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>I trust you know, or else I will send them to you, but I feel that Councilmember Herbold.

942
01:35:36.984 --> 01:35:42.524
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>With that, I want to talk about a different kind of economic well-being of this 3-prong approach.

943
01:35:43.328 --> 01:35:54.378
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Resources allow the people of the sector to gather as a thriving artistic community, making, creating, and celebrating the core of risk-taking and creativity.

944
01:35:54.813 --> 01:35:58.395
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>And this is economically attractive in so many ways.

945
01:35:59.213 --> 01:36:04.675
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>People who are making the product need assurance of some steady resources.

946
01:36:05.332 --> 01:36:13.524
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>So in addition to place, say, a residency option, provide a monetary stipend.

947
01:36:14.293 --> 01:36:18.204
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>As you all know, making money comes from spending money.

948
01:36:18.814 --> 01:36:30.868
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>To trust that economic growth could come with no compensation for the people of the sector, but only monetary incentives for place and products, is a viewpoint that needs to be shifted.

949
01:36:30.932 --> 01:36:31.045
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Thank you.

950
01:36:32.520 --> 01:36:37.042
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>So let's look at the other side, which is community resilience and safety perspective.

951
01:36:37.698 --> 01:36:39.382
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>It's all about brain science.

952
01:36:40.024 --> 01:37:06.220
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Research shows that human experiences of awe and wonderment— so think about going to nature and seeing a mountain, think about the night sky with the Milky Way, think about that dance performance that made you cry and you don't know why— so these experiences of awe and wonderment are scientifically proven to provide pathways for our brains to be resilient, be more creative, and bring our full selves to any situation.

953
01:37:06.733 --> 01:37:16.878
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>With neuroarts and neuroaesthetics burgeoning in the last 20 years, we see a clear pathway to well-being, community cohesion, and safety.

954
01:37:17.391 --> 01:37:30.743
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>People are experiencing artistic expression, and/or when the same people engage in artistic activity, they allow for their brains to enter spaces of surprise curiosity, and risk-taking.

955
01:37:31.176 --> 01:37:40.359
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>This immediately allows for synapses to transmit that feeling of safety, and this safety allows for even more creativity.

956
01:37:40.889 --> 01:37:47.091
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>So innovation, future thinking, and true community-centered problem-solving opportunities.

957
01:37:47.685 --> 01:38:05.143
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>So the people, product, and place of the arts, culture, and music sector become this ability— have this ability to be in the driver's seat So if at this point you're thinking, well, that's all great, Subha, what are we going to do about this?

958
01:38:06.569 --> 01:38:07.115
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Glad you asked.

959
01:38:08.092 --> 01:38:09.367
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>I have a few things to tell you.

960
01:38:11.229 --> 01:38:18.229
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Use the Our Creative Future cultural plan that the City of Portland led and then adopted in 2024.

961
01:38:19.797 --> 01:38:27.300
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>It's got a lot of intelligent ways that tangible steps can be taken to make sure that we're It's divided into 5 goals with a lot of subsections.

962
01:38:28.648 --> 01:38:34.422
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>But I think it would be a missed opportunity if this committee did not use that document as a start of a playbook.

963
01:38:35.560 --> 01:38:49.324
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Secondly, build an accessible, sleek, sophisticated, and central clearinghouse that is a one-stop shop for locals and tourists to know the riches that is the arts, music, and culture sector of Portland.

964
01:38:50.126 --> 01:38:56.421
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Clearinghouse exists, lists exist, but I'm going to bold, sophisticated, and sleek.

965
01:38:58.095 --> 01:39:12.646
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Thirdly, find a way to truly embed arts education across our schools so that the next generation of audiences, philanthropists, civic leaders, and donors will naturally find their way to the fold.

966
01:39:13.359 --> 01:39:22.355
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Consistent arts education supports our youth in battling loneliness, and builds healthy, empowered ways to build relationships across our nation.

967
01:39:22.435 --> 01:39:32.109
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Research after research shows that arts education effectively reduces absenteeism and promotes overall academic achievement levels.

968
01:39:32.623 --> 01:39:42.875
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>If we're going to attract families to live, create, and be a long-term member of our city, we need arts education in schools to support our youth in educational life.

969
01:39:43.020 --> 01:39:43.261
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Thank you.

970
01:39:44.163 --> 01:39:51.739
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Fourth, downtown is truly at the front and center of so many conversations right now, probably rightfully so.

971
01:39:52.813 --> 01:39:54.096
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>But Portland is larger.

972
01:39:54.600 --> 01:39:57.672
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>We're many microcultures as much as we are microclimates.

973
01:39:58.756 --> 01:40:26.832
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>And I would urge the committee to find ways to resource the people, product, and places across the 4 districts and convene a citywide resource council rather than an oversight committee, from stakeholders in the arts, culture, and music sector so that you have partners in the community who can give you the latest on the heartbeat of the people, product, and place you want to know about.

974
01:40:28.069 --> 01:40:47.810
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>There's so much we can do together without overthinking it if you can join the thousands of artists, culture bearers, and creatives who work alongside organizations to build meaningful artistic experiences and expressions in unique, powerful venues all across our city.

975
01:40:48.326 --> 01:41:06.404
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>The people, the products, and places of the arts, culture, and music sector are doing the work right now, and it will be an absolute honor to join hands with the Civic Life Committee to strengthen and enliven our city through resourced and thoughtful projects.

976
01:41:07.067 --> 01:41:11.078
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Thank you so much.

977
01:41:12.880 --> 01:41:17.707
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are, committee members, moving on to Jessica Green to talk about parks.

978
01:41:19.046 --> 01:41:19.805
<v Jessica Green>Thank you, Council.

979
01:41:20.161 --> 01:41:20.435
<v Jessica Green>Can you hear me?

980
01:41:21.796 --> 01:41:23.065
<v Jessica Green>My name is Jessica Green.

981
01:41:23.113 --> 01:41:25.701
<v Jessica Green>I'm the executive director of the Portland Parks Foundation.

982
01:41:26.295 --> 01:41:32.989
<v Jessica Green>We're a citywide parks nonprofit that exists to mobilize support for our parks and natural areas.

983
01:41:33.814 --> 01:41:39.770
<v Jessica Green>I've been asked to speak today about the role of parks programming in supporting families and community life here in Portland.

984
01:41:40.439 --> 01:41:42.572
<v Jessica Green>It is a topic near and dear to my heart.

985
01:41:42.670 --> 01:41:45.796
<v Jessica Green>I have 3 children who spend more time on sports fields than anywhere else.

986
01:41:46.956 --> 01:41:52.234
<v Jessica Green>I'm also the current board chair of Friends of Tryon Creek and on the board of the Oregon Girls Lacrosse Association.

987
01:41:53.010 --> 01:41:55.479
<v Jessica Green>All that is to say, parks programming is my life.

988
01:41:57.135 --> 01:42:07.582
<v Jessica Green>I want to take a moment to also say thank you councilors for referring the levy last year to preserve parks programming, especially discounted parks programming as we experience it today.

989
01:42:09.011 --> 01:42:22.722
<v Jessica Green>While parks programming is quite broad, and like Subha, I was a little intimidated to be covering all of parks programming, I am narrowing the focus today to youth parks programming and its impact on the livability for families in our city.

990
01:42:23.814 --> 01:42:31.475
<v Jessica Green>I'd like to start out with the fact that play serves as a powerful, accessible tool to meet basic fundamental human needs for kids.

991
01:42:32.391 --> 01:42:36.617
<v Jessica Green>Play fosters physical health, mental well-being, and social connection.

992
01:42:37.371 --> 01:42:46.253
<v Jessica Green>Portland Parks and Recreation and partner programming in our public parks and community centers plays an essential role in equitable access to play for Portland's kids.

993
01:42:47.185 --> 01:42:55.423
<v Jessica Green>Summer camps, after-school programs, sports teams, recreational classes, swim lessons, teen services, just to name a handful.

994
01:42:56.467 --> 01:43:08.863
<v Jessica Green>For families, youth parks programming means reliable, affordable childcare outside school hours, safe, structured environment for kids, the ability to stay employed and economically stable.

995
01:43:09.649 --> 01:43:20.515
<v Jessica Green>So when we talk about youth parks programming, we're also talking about economic stability, public safety, Councilmember Smith.

996
01:43:21.867 --> 01:43:24.134
<v Jessica Green>Thank you, Mayor.

997
01:43:24.600 --> 01:43:32.407
<v Jessica Green>Thank you, Councilmember Smith.

998
01:43:41.250 --> 01:43:47.029
<v Jessica Green>Parks programming above everything else other than litter pickup, which matched it.

999
01:43:48.523 --> 01:43:54.993
<v Jessica Green>So I came today with three opportunities to present to City Council in a way that you can lead in this space.

1000
01:43:56.359 --> 01:44:00.243
<v Jessica Green>First, protect and prioritize youth programming as a core service.

1001
01:44:01.673 --> 01:44:06.715
<v Jessica Green>Parks and our partners are doing an incredible job at innovative and affordable programs.

1002
01:44:06.779 --> 01:44:12.845
<v Jessica Green>Programming, but we cannot deliver consistent, high-quality program without stable funding and functional spaces.

1003
01:44:13.739 --> 01:44:20.904
<v Jessica Green>The good news is Parks is developing a long-range financial plan, and I ask that you ensure that it explicitly centers youth programming.

1004
01:44:22.471 --> 01:44:28.730
<v Jessica Green>I also encourage you to better understand the broader issue of play by getting involved with local coalitions.

1005
01:44:29.569 --> 01:44:42.505
<v Jessica Green>For example, with support from Nike, Aspen Institute's Project Play is working on the State of Play report for Portland, a report coming later this year that will highlight barriers and opportunities for children across the region to play sports and be physically active.

1006
01:44:43.163 --> 01:44:51.207
<v Jessica Green>The project's goal is to build consensus around high-impact strategic initiatives that will support all youth to thrive through sport and movement.

1007
01:44:52.091 --> 01:44:59.605
<v Jessica Green>I encourage someone from this council to be an active member of future coalition work coming out of that report and the policy building that will follow.

1008
01:45:00.938 --> 01:45:06.510
<v Jessica Green>Second, I encourage this council to invest in what enables programs to run.

1009
01:45:07.649 --> 01:45:12.257
<v Jessica Green>All too often, asset maintenance and program delivery are pitted against each other.

1010
01:45:12.546 --> 01:45:16.192
<v Jessica Green>They're a team, and they need to be treated that way.

1011
01:45:16.818 --> 01:45:19.595
<v Jessica Green>Deferred maintenance is already canceling or limiting programs.

1012
01:45:20.494 --> 01:45:27.284
<v Jessica Green>I encourage you to support reforms, capital dollars, and partnerships to better support usable program-ready spaces.

1013
01:45:29.481 --> 01:45:34.677
<v Jessica Green>Third, no surprise here, use partnerships to enhance and expand programming.

1014
01:45:35.970 --> 01:45:42.180
<v Jessica Green>First, do this by leaning into PPNR's Project Connect and community partnership work that came out of the 2020 Parks Levy.

1015
01:45:42.921 --> 01:45:45.051
<v Jessica Green>If you aren't familiar with it, I encourage you to learn more.

1016
01:45:45.358 --> 01:46:00.932
<v Jessica Green>A ton of park programming is led by amazing partners working to fill gaps and who are committed to keeping play affordable and accessible versus pay-to-play models that have become the norm and are eliminating affordable community-based programs and excluding kids from participating in play.

1017
01:46:01.743 --> 01:46:03.430
<v Jessica Green>I can't speak more highly about this work.

1018
01:46:04.619 --> 01:46:13.289
<v Jessica Green>I encourage you to convene key stakeholders in this work, both from city staff and from the program participants, and identify additional opportunities and gaps.

1019
01:46:15.890 --> 01:46:19.680
<v Jessica Green>And lastly, also pave the way for private investment.

1020
01:46:19.904 --> 01:46:23.404
<v Jessica Green>We've talked about this a lot in the last year, and I'm going to continue to talk about it.

1021
01:46:24.015 --> 01:46:33.520
<v Jessica Green>And I would love to work with council, even hearing Jeremy speak earlier, to remove internal barriers in order to accelerate partner projects and programs to expand access.

1022
01:46:34.194 --> 01:46:39.878
<v Jessica Green>Parks are so uniquely positioned with strong private interests to invest in projects that could expand programming.

1023
01:46:40.712 --> 01:46:50.311
<v Jessica Green>So let's create pathways for trusted partners to supplement the system through privately led, city-approved projects to expand reach, affordability, and the speed in which we can do this.

1024
01:46:51.770 --> 01:47:02.282
<v Jessica Green>So to summarize the takeaways from today, the opportunity in front of you is to align policy and funding so that youth parks programming can be delivered reliably, equitably, and at scale.

1025
01:47:02.971 --> 01:47:08.243
<v Jessica Green>This includes stabilizing operations funding So programs are not dependent on short-term solutions.

1026
01:47:09.381 --> 01:47:13.819
<v Jessica Green>Protecting youth programming as a core service, especially in communities with the greatest need.

1027
01:47:14.525 --> 01:47:18.836
<v Jessica Green>Prioritizing capital investments that restore and activate spaces where programs happen.

1028
01:47:19.717 --> 01:47:23.963
<v Jessica Green>And leverage partnerships to expand impact, not to replace core responsibility though.

1029
01:47:25.006 --> 01:47:29.829
<v Jessica Green>Access to youth programming is one of the reasons families choose and stay in Portland.

1030
01:47:29.909 --> 01:47:38.159
<v Jessica Green>If we want to retain families, Thank you so much.

1031
01:47:38.159 --> 01:47:44.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we will wrap up this panel with Lori Wimmer talking about working people in our community.

1032
01:47:44.180 --> 01:47:44.989
<v Angelita Morillo>Right ahead, Lori.

1033
01:47:45.140 --> 01:47:47.158
<v Lori Wimmer>Thank you, Madam Chair and committee members.

1034
01:47:47.158 --> 01:47:54.010
<v Lori Wimmer>For your record, Lori Wimmer representing the Northwest Oregon Labor Council, keenly aware that I am the person standing between you and break.

1035
01:47:55.979 --> 01:47:59.739
<v Lori Wimmer>I want to offer my congratulations to the new City Life Committee, which holds a critical thank role in our city's economic development.

1036
01:47:59.869 --> 01:47:59.869
<v Patrick Gehring>You, Councilor Smith.

1037
01:47:59.869 --> 01:47:59.869
<v Patrick Gehring>Thank you, Mayor.

1038
01:47:59.869 --> 01:47:59.869
<v Patrick Gehring>Thank you, Council President Herbold, for the opportunity to speak to you today.

1039
01:47:59.869 --> 01:48:03.770
<v Lori Wimmer>This committee holds space across a giant landscape of issues critical to Portland livability.

1040
01:48:04.529 --> 01:48:09.960
<v Lori Wimmer>Just as your mission is vast, so too are the concerns of the workers for whom I'm honored to speak today.

1041
01:48:10.829 --> 01:48:15.000
<v Lori Wimmer>I was asked to address for a few minutes how Portland workers are faring.

1042
01:48:15.029 --> 01:48:23.210
<v Lori Wimmer>Given that our council represents thousands of public and private sector workers, there's a lot to say, but I will just share the top lines here.

1043
01:48:23.210 --> 01:48:27.350
<v Lori Wimmer>I have my full report for you in your written materials, and I hope you will take a look at it.

1044
01:48:27.476 --> 01:48:33.988
<v Lori Wimmer>The time to read it because they— about 16 labor leaders gave us their input, and I believe it's worth your time.

1045
01:48:35.279 --> 01:48:47.640
<v Lori Wimmer>Given the need to boil it all down this afternoon though, uh, and with apologies to Sesame Street, let me say that today's testimony is brought to you by the letter P. Apparently we both did that.

1046
01:48:49.051 --> 01:48:58.011
<v Lori Wimmer>People, projects, partnerships, public safety, priorities, proximity, parks, First, people.

1047
01:48:58.969 --> 01:49:09.025
<v Lori Wimmer>Workers, especially at the lower end of the earnings spectrum, identify issues of safety, fear for the future, economic struggles, and low morale.

1048
01:49:10.255 --> 01:49:16.634
<v Lori Wimmer>After past layoffs, those still employed are asked to do more with less, and this has become unsustainable.

1049
01:49:18.340 --> 01:49:22.797
<v Lori Wimmer>One union leader told us that a side effect of the consolidation project at the city is that workers are being asked to work longer hours.

1050
01:49:23.402 --> 01:49:29.301
<v Lori Wimmer>Is that dozens of union jobs are disappearing to be replaced by unrepresented positions.

1051
01:49:30.213 --> 01:49:34.750
<v Lori Wimmer>Reductions in force should never result in deunionization.

1052
01:49:36.225 --> 01:49:36.865
<v Lori Wimmer>Projects.

1053
01:49:37.828 --> 01:49:39.686
<v Lori Wimmer>Contracting remains a key issue.

1054
01:49:40.072 --> 01:49:46.530
<v Lori Wimmer>Our building trades folks point out that there is a need for trans-bureau consistency in contract administration.

1055
01:49:47.043 --> 01:49:51.340
<v Lori Wimmer>One example brought to me was that apprenticeship is required for all crafts thank you.

1056
01:49:51.387 --> 01:50:00.197
<v Lori Wimmer>It is required for the City of Portland to have 2 drafts on the Bull Run project that you heard about earlier, but under the same agreement, it's not required for the Carolina Trunk Sewer Rehab Project.

1057
01:50:01.000 --> 01:50:03.887
<v Lori Wimmer>Consistency is the necessary ingredient.

1058
01:50:04.914 --> 01:50:18.970
<v Lori Wimmer>As it relates to contracting out of city jobs, we continue to stress in our city budget letter, which is also incorporated with my written testimony, that Portland overpays for the work of contractors to do the same work that city employees do.

1059
01:50:19.596 --> 01:50:34.201
<v Lori Wimmer>Ending this practice would recover significant sums of money please refer to that labor coalition paper that we, we submitted that talks about that in a great deal of detail.

1060
01:50:35.829 --> 01:50:49.557
<v Lori Wimmer>Our workforce also believes that public funds, whether for city employees or for money that flows to partners, grantees, and contractors, should come with the expectation that these recipients provide good family-wage jobs.

1061
01:50:49.639 --> 01:50:49.944
<v Lori Wimmer>Thank you.

1062
01:50:57.119 --> 01:50:57.814
<v Lori Wimmer>Partnerships.

1063
01:50:57.943 --> 01:51:09.903
<v Lori Wimmer>As projects emerge on the horizon, workers are asked that successful working partnerships with public and private entities be forged that leverage resources and problem-solve to meet this moment.

1064
01:51:10.646 --> 01:51:36.130
<v Lori Wimmer>Our IATSE members, for example, concerned about the future of P5 venues, have been working with the city to ensure that the city's Public safety.

1065
01:51:36.130 --> 01:51:41.050
<v Lori Wimmer>Aspects of this topic rose again and again in my conversations with workers in Portland.

1066
01:51:41.529 --> 01:51:54.277
<v Lori Wimmer>Our firefighters, PSR, and CHAT employees, for example, have faced faced a 10-year recruitment and retention problem that will only be exacerbated by the COLA reductions being floated in for the next budget.

1067
01:51:55.288 --> 01:52:03.708
<v Lori Wimmer>And budget decisions that lengthen response times by cutting replacement workers will also imperil not only worker safety but that of all Portlanders.

1068
01:52:05.091 --> 01:52:13.167
<v Lori Wimmer>Our public safety sector does its utmost to keep us all safe, but they are understaffed for the level of community distress that we still confront.

1069
01:52:14.561 --> 01:52:23.555
<v Lori Wimmer>Our grocery workers, bus drivers, parks employees, healthcare workers, and many others have reported that they still feel unsafe on the job.

1070
01:52:24.501 --> 01:52:33.863
<v Lori Wimmer>Our workforce asks that the issue be taken for the serious quality of life concern it is, especially in our lowest-income neighborhoods and in our marginalized communities.

1071
01:52:35.256 --> 01:52:35.786
<v Lori Wimmer>Priorities.

1072
01:52:36.925 --> 01:52:55.010
<v Lori Wimmer>When addressing budget balancing this spring, you will be challenged to minimize service losses and maximize our workers ask that you prioritize union representation, which is the best way to ensure that workers can live here and thrive.

1073
01:52:57.359 --> 01:52:59.260
<v Lori Wimmer>Proximity.

1074
01:52:59.260 --> 01:53:05.520
<v Lori Wimmer>The housing affordability crisis has pushed out many of our workers who can no longer afford to live in the city where they work.

1075
01:53:06.479 --> 01:53:11.159
<v Lori Wimmer>A GIS study was done by one of those private sector workforce unions, and it found that the average commute time for Portland workers is 30 minutes.

1076
01:53:11.300 --> 01:53:15.761
<v Lori Wimmer>The answer was far.

1077
01:53:16.807 --> 01:53:27.188
<v Lori Wimmer>This means long commutes, which is a cost and time burden for the employee, but also for governments facing down infrastructure costs, diminished revenues, to say nothing of climate impacts.

1078
01:53:28.659 --> 01:53:28.917
<v Lori Wimmer>Parks.

1079
01:53:29.724 --> 01:53:39.047
<v Lori Wimmer>The experience of our seasonal and permanent parks workers related to us issues of affordability, workplace safety, and exploitation of the casual workforce.

1080
01:53:39.097 --> 01:53:39.556
<v Lori Wimmer>I think that's a great question.

1081
01:53:40.824 --> 01:53:46.506
<v Lori Wimmer>They experience daily theft and drug-related incidents and weekly assaults on staff.

1082
01:53:47.469 --> 01:53:52.509
<v Lori Wimmer>Yet there's no on-site security, and responses from rangers and law enforcement are slow.

1083
01:53:53.663 --> 01:53:58.447
<v Lori Wimmer>As the largest employer of teenagers in Portland, this is particularly troubling.

1084
01:53:59.923 --> 01:54:00.548
<v Lori Wimmer>PSU.

1085
01:54:01.463 --> 01:54:08.958
<v Lori Wimmer>PSU is one of the key institutions that could be a part of Portland's economic recovery, but instead it's facing a historic contraction.

1086
01:54:09.471 --> 01:54:21.042
<v Lori Wimmer>Due to its own insufficient funding, which may result in laying off 200 of the 1,100 faculty and professional academics in their employ.

1087
01:54:22.036 --> 01:54:29.023
<v Lori Wimmer>Part of the cause of this crisis is declining enrollment accelerated by the perception of a downtown that is unsafe.

1088
01:54:30.240 --> 01:54:34.487
<v Lori Wimmer>Clearly, the fate of the college is connected to the fate of the city and vice versa.

1089
01:54:35.755 --> 01:54:36.926
<v Lori Wimmer>Finally, my parting words.

1090
01:54:37.921 --> 01:55:06.532
<v Lori Wimmer>Also a P. While nearly 9,000— actually, I heard 10,000 today, my numbers were slightly lower— uh, 9,000 jobs have been lost in the Portland metro region in the recent past, and with a shift to part-time work accelerating at the highest rate in a decade, our workforce continues to bear the brunt of the systemic and community-wide ills that have beset us since the pandemic, as well as of policy decisions at various government levels.

1091
01:55:07.350 --> 01:55:14.551
<v Lori Wimmer>For instance, our plumbers and pipefitters at UA 290 report that they have the lowest job levels in 13 years.

1092
01:55:15.945 --> 01:55:23.610
<v Lori Wimmer>In preparation for this presentation, as I said, I spoke to 16 union leaders representing thousands of public and private sector workers.

1093
01:55:23.722 --> 01:55:28.100
<v Lori Wimmer>I won't list them here in the interest of time, but you have them in your written information.

1094
01:55:28.774 --> 01:56:08.573
<v Lori Wimmer>But nearly universally, I will say that they ask that you support frontline workers over administrative bloat, that you end, for the city workers, expensive contracting out, that you ensure partnering entities receive city funds— partnering entities that receive city funds make sure they're good-paying employers, and ensure that all of us, businesses and individuals, pay our fair share to support finally, they ask that we provide just transitions for workers whose industries are negatively impacted by policies, however noble, that result in eliminating their jobs.

1095
01:56:09.076 --> 01:56:10.863
<v Lori Wimmer>Thank you so much for considering our perspectives.

1096
01:56:13.399 --> 01:56:15.780
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for closing us out with that overview.

1097
01:56:15.862 --> 01:56:19.765
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think we're going to take one question so that we have time for a break.

1098
01:56:20.162 --> 01:56:22.399
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, go right ahead.

1099
01:56:23.970 --> 01:56:24.699
<v Candace Avalos>All right, thank you.

1100
01:56:24.877 --> 01:56:26.564
<v Candace Avalos>It's a couple comments, is that all right?

1101
01:56:26.887 --> 01:56:32.189
<v Candace Avalos>All right, um, well, thank you all, uh, for being here and sharing your experiences.

1102
01:56:32.301 --> 01:56:39.688
<v Candace Avalos>I think that the stories that you've shared very much align with my goals and what I'm trying to tackle as a committee member.

1103
01:56:39.817 --> 01:56:44.560
<v Candace Avalos>So I just wanted to share just a couple of quick notes about how I'm thinking about the work ahead.

1104
01:56:45.140 --> 01:56:49.306
<v Candace Avalos>So it doesn't Thank you.

1105
01:56:50.238 --> 01:56:58.612
<v Candace Avalos>I just, you know, we have been talking about how there's a big scope for this committee, and, um, but I don't see that the City Life portfolio is a set of separate issues, right?

1106
01:56:58.740 --> 01:57:07.114
<v Candace Avalos>As we are discussing, it's all an interconnected system, and our economy, our communities, and the experience of living in Portland are all deeply linked, right?

1107
01:57:07.180 --> 01:57:07.693
<v Candace Avalos>We know that.

1108
01:57:08.141 --> 01:57:16.905
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that our role in this committee is to pull at those threads and understand how decisions in one area impact others in— impact outcomes in another area.

1109
01:57:17.292 --> 01:57:23.216
<v Candace Avalos>And I wanted to just name something that I think is critical, that climate work no longer has a dedicated committee home.

1110
01:57:23.713 --> 01:57:27.118
<v Candace Avalos>And I don't want climate justice to get lost or buried because of that.

1111
01:57:27.631 --> 01:57:42.773
<v Candace Avalos>I think the previous panel really shared the interconnectedness of climate work in all of this, and I just wanted to elevate that because climate justice isn't just about sustainability, it's about core resilience for our city, and it shapes public health and economic opportunity, housing stability, right?

1112
01:57:42.885 --> 01:57:48.761
<v Candace Avalos>Whether Portlanders, especially those that are most impacted by environmental injustice, can thrive in the long term.

1113
01:57:49.226 --> 01:57:56.018
<v Candace Avalos>So I just wanted to state that because I believe that if we're serious about building a strong and inclusive economy, that climate justice needs to be part of that.

1114
01:57:57.253 --> 01:58:03.498
<v Candace Avalos>Also, I wanted to lift up something that I heard as it relates to immigrant businesses and refugee businesses.

1115
01:58:04.467 --> 01:58:15.987
<v Candace Avalos>Right now, many of those small businesses are navigating unique and rapidly changing sets of challenges, particularly uncertainty driven by federal actions.

1116
01:58:16.051 --> 01:58:26.412
<v Candace Avalos>And so I just think that this is a space where I want to elevate that particular issue because it is sensitive and time-sensitive to what's going on right now.

1117
01:58:26.768 --> 01:58:31.005
<v Candace Avalos>And I think that we need to make sure to not just be fair-weather friends to the small businesses, but to be there for them.

1118
01:58:31.052 --> 01:58:31.181
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1119
01:58:35.430 --> 01:58:48.140
<v Candace Avalos>And lastly, I'll just say that, you know, as we're talking about the economy broadly, what's important to remember and what I'm hearing in your words, right, is that our local economy is powered by our communities.

1120
01:58:48.579 --> 01:58:50.649
<v Candace Avalos>So the people that live here and work here and invest.

1121
01:58:51.239 --> 01:58:57.039
<v Candace Avalos>And so when we talk about growing our economy, then our response needs to be investing in those communities, right?

1122
01:58:57.039 --> 01:58:58.189
<v Candace Avalos>Investing in those small businesses, investing in our communities.

1123
01:58:58.189 --> 01:58:58.229
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1124
01:58:59.014 --> 01:59:02.703
<v Candace Avalos>And making sure that we're building some lasting economic resilience from the ground up.

1125
01:59:02.800 --> 01:59:05.447
<v Candace Avalos>So that doesn't mean large corporate tax breaks.

1126
01:59:05.655 --> 01:59:10.372
<v Candace Avalos>That means investing in community-based orgs and small businesses that are already the backbone.

1127
01:59:11.109 --> 01:59:31.443
<v Candace Avalos>Ultimately, I hope that this committee can really connect those dots between economic development and community resilience and do that in a way that is reflective of the lived experience of Portlanders, especially with this last panel shared with us of the economic and affordability issues that I believe the city has some levers that we need to be pulling.

1128
01:59:31.523 --> 01:59:33.225
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you for your perspectives.

1129
01:59:33.273 --> 01:59:38.458
<v Candace Avalos>I'm really grateful to hear all the partners that are excited to work with us.

1130
01:59:38.716 --> 01:59:40.643
<v Candace Avalos>And so I'm sure I'll be seeing you a lot this year.

1131
01:59:41.445 --> 01:59:41.654
<v Candace Avalos>That's all.

1132
01:59:41.863 --> 01:59:42.104
<v Candace Avalos>Thanks.

1133
01:59:42.505 --> 01:59:43.372
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1134
01:59:43.453 --> 01:59:52.681
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And thank you to our panel for bringing some really important perspectives about how all of this affects people who are here every day.

1135
01:59:53.216 --> 01:59:54.462
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We appreciate all of your input.

1136
01:59:56.740 --> 01:59:58.195
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>May I ask you a question very quickly?

1137
01:59:58.908 --> 02:00:00.621
<v Dr. Mary King>What is the national threshold for poverty?

1138
02:00:00.880 --> 02:00:03.046
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, we'll get that data to you.

1139
02:00:03.369 --> 02:00:05.652
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't have it off the top of my head, but we can look it up.

1140
02:00:05.717 --> 02:00:09.618
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We're going to move to a short break in just a minute, and I'm sure someone can get it for you.

1141
02:00:10.828 --> 02:00:14.067
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, colleagues, as we wrap up this agenda item, I just want to thank you.

1142
02:00:14.114 --> 02:00:25.813
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know this was a lot for a We'll get our voices in more as we move forward, but I wanted to make sure we could hear these 15 different perspectives on the work that we have before us.

1143
02:00:26.587 --> 02:00:30.759
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And a huge thanks to all of our panelists for being part of the conversation.

1144
02:00:31.579 --> 02:00:39.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are going to take a 7-minute break and be back here at 4:05.

1145
02:00:39.805 --> 02:00:40.369
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We are in recess.

1146
02:00:40.497 --> 02:00:41.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council is recessed.

1147
02:08:53.979 --> 02:08:55.260
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome back.

1148
02:08:55.390 --> 02:08:58.001
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am reconvening our committee meeting.

1149
02:08:58.292 --> 02:09:01.324
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I know our colleagues will be here in just a moment.

1150
02:09:02.510 --> 02:09:06.417
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And could we please hear item 2 on our agenda?

1151
02:09:08.149 --> 02:09:23.634
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Item number 2, document number 2026-131, amend franchise granted to Comcast of Oregon to thank you.

1152
02:09:27.945 --> 02:09:34.444
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And colleagues, I believe we have a staff presentation from Eric Engstrom and Andrew Spear.

1153
02:09:35.291 --> 02:09:48.996
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I'll note before we get started that in, I believe, 2 committee meetings, we will have additional ordinances related to the Mount Hood Cable Regulatory Commission coming before us.

1154
02:09:49.685 --> 02:09:55.479
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>These are coming unfortunately not all together because of some of the timing needs of a few of them.

1155
02:09:56.346 --> 02:10:06.170
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But as we move through the conversation today, know that we will have other conversations coming that are related to this topic.

1156
02:10:07.005 --> 02:10:07.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Eric, go right ahead.

1157
02:10:08.288 --> 02:10:09.460
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you, Chair.

1158
02:10:10.150 --> 02:10:11.225
<v Eric Engstrom>For the record, Eric Engstrom.

1159
02:10:11.274 --> 02:10:13.488
<v Eric Engstrom>I'm the Director of the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.

1160
02:10:13.569 --> 02:10:13.750
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you, Mayor.

1161
02:10:13.750 --> 02:10:13.750
<v Eric Engstrom>Thank you, Mayor.

1162
02:10:13.750 --> 02:10:17.720
<v Eric Engstrom>I'm the Deputy City Attorney, and with me is Andrew Spear, who's the manager of our franchise utility program at the city.

1163
02:10:19.909 --> 02:10:26.829
<v Eric Engstrom>And you alluded to one of the things I want to just start off by saying is exactly that, that this is one of several things.

1164
02:10:27.810 --> 02:10:48.762
<v Eric Engstrom>As you may know, the Mount Hood Cable Regulatory Commission manages cable television franchises throughout the county, and there's a process right now going on to dissolve that commission and devolve those responsibilities back to the and so there are a number of actions that are coming to council in a sequence related to the unwinding of that.

1165
02:10:49.372 --> 02:10:50.222
<v Eric Engstrom>This is one of them.

1166
02:10:50.944 --> 02:11:02.333
<v Eric Engstrom>We're also amending city code to remove some incidental references to the commission, and we also need to set up a new city fund to take dedicated revenue related to the cable franchise.

1167
02:11:03.328 --> 02:11:12.654
<v Eric Engstrom>And then there— the mayor's budget, I anticipate, will have at least a couple decision packages related to movement of money around to accommodate that revenue coming to the city.

1168
02:11:12.734 --> 02:11:16.059
<v Eric Engstrom>So that's the overall context, is there's several of these things.

1169
02:11:16.234 --> 02:11:26.095
<v Eric Engstrom>The, the amendment to the cable franchise is largely technical because the city will continue to have that franchise, and we're not changing any other terms with the franchise.

1170
02:11:26.208 --> 02:11:29.131
<v Eric Engstrom>And I'll turn it over to Andrew to, to talk about that.

1171
02:11:29.501 --> 02:11:30.480
<v Andrew Spear>Great, thanks, Eric.

1172
02:11:31.091 --> 02:11:31.974
<v Andrew Spear>Good afternoon, everyone.

1173
02:11:32.070 --> 02:11:51.435
<v Andrew Spear>My name is Andrew Spear, and I'm the manager of the franchise and we're here, as Eric said, to recommend amendment to the franchise agreement for Comcast related to aspects of the franchise that cite or make reference to the Mt.

1174
02:11:51.484 --> 02:11:53.957
<v Andrew Spear>Hood Cable Regulatory Commission.

1175
02:11:55.113 --> 02:12:00.234
<v Andrew Spear>And the urgency around this is just that as part of our city's charter, we have a 90-day notice period.

1176
02:12:00.283 --> 02:12:00.378
<v Andrew Spear>Thank you.

1177
02:12:02.195 --> 02:12:19.806
<v Andrew Spear>And so in order to have a period that is within the next payment window for the quarterly payments that Comcast provides the city, we wanted to have an effective date within the next quarter as we start quarter 1 of the fiscal year.

1178
02:12:24.701 --> 02:12:30.180
<v Andrew Spear>Just wanted to provide a couple slides with some background about the MHCRC dissolution.

1179
02:12:31.640 --> 02:12:47.984
<v Andrew Spear>And part of what we're timing here is, is in the last— so since the fall of this past year, the commission underwent committee work to recommend dissolution of the committee as recommended as part of their strategic planning process as a commission.

1180
02:12:49.157 --> 02:13:07.734
<v Andrew Spear>That's a long runway discussion that ties back to the changing since about the past 10 years, we've seen a 100,000 decline within the cable subscribers that MHCRC covers for its jurisdiction.

1181
02:13:10.420 --> 02:13:17.875
<v Andrew Spear>In January of 2026, the Cable Commission and the jurisdictions agreed on a dissolution.

1182
02:13:19.359 --> 02:13:35.693
<v Andrew Spear>Of the commission, which is part of the IGA that formed the commission, required all the jurisdictions to sign a dissolution agreement, which we've all have signed and are working on implementing as part of this process that we're here before you today, and then other work that's undergoing.

1183
02:13:38.601 --> 02:13:42.100
<v Andrew Spear>This is just a brief timeline of where we've been and where we're at.

1184
02:13:42.666 --> 02:14:01.375
<v Andrew Spear>On the far right is where we're at currently, and it was through the past 6 months that we've identified that the cable franchise would need to be amended as part of this work to dissolve the commission and ensure continuity of the franchise agreement through time with the City of Portland.

1185
02:14:01.872 --> 02:14:12.604
<v Andrew Spear>And I just wanted to note this cable franchise was approved last year by this council, but again, it included references to the MHCRC, so which is why we're here today.

1186
02:14:12.670 --> 02:14:12.845
<v Andrew Spear>Thank you.

1187
02:14:16.782 --> 02:14:37.807
<v Andrew Spear>Um, so the need, uh, or the why of the need of to, to be here to amend the franchise agreement, um, as part of the franchise agreement, there's certain aspects of compliance and reporting and other, um, technical aspects of the operation of the agreement that require, uh, oversight.

1188
02:14:38.033 --> 02:14:48.159
<v Andrew Spear>And as part of that oversight, those functions had been previously delegated to the MHCRC, um, And we actually in our bureau staff the MHCRC work.

1189
02:14:49.110 --> 02:14:56.681
<v Andrew Spear>And so that will be changing as the dissolution happens, but, and refocusing more towards the franchise utility work in my group.

1190
02:14:57.229 --> 02:15:08.725
<v Andrew Spear>But as part of our work, we just need to be able to have clear lines on who the granting body is responsible for administering the franchise.

1191
02:15:09.159 --> 02:15:14.252
<v Andrew Spear>And so just the practical removal of language related to MHCRC.

1192
02:15:14.738 --> 02:15:33.764
<v Andrew Spear>And then other aspects are— I'll get to on the next slide— relate to some technical areas around the reporting and the ensuring that sections that had been negotiated as a whole for MHCRC are memorialized in the agreement now that it is just Portland's agreement.

1193
02:15:38.372 --> 02:15:44.157
<v Andrew Spear>This slide just includes where the practical changes are in the agreement.

1194
02:15:44.445 --> 02:15:51.606
<v Andrew Spear>And I believe in your exhibit you had a red line that included these direct changes if you wanted to reference.

1195
02:15:51.752 --> 02:16:05.225
<v Andrew Spear>But in short, the MHCRC or the callout of MHCRC in the agreement, those are all stricken and either put back to city or grantor.

1196
02:16:06.556 --> 02:16:11.730
<v Andrew Spear>And then we added sections that have been negotiated.

1197
02:16:11.779 --> 02:16:20.194
<v Andrew Spear>I was referencing just a bit ago the sections that have been negotiated in the agreement that are tied to video on demand as an example.

1198
02:16:20.403 --> 02:16:29.143
<v Andrew Spear>The number of hours of video on demand that were negotiated as part of the contract, that was for the whole of MHCRC that Comcast would need to agree to.

1199
02:16:29.756 --> 02:16:41.595
<v Andrew Spear>And so there's a section added in the agreement that includes references to those sections that have thank you.

1200
02:16:42.222 --> 02:16:51.694
<v Andrew Spear>We also removed the section that cites and calls out the formation of the IGA that created the MHCRC, just as a practical matter.

1201
02:16:52.594 --> 02:17:05.023
<v Andrew Spear>And then there was a few brief deletions at the back end of the agreement that comports with the mayor's directive on DEI language as it pertains to contracts.

1202
02:17:05.412 --> 02:17:06.284
<v Andrew Spear>That was a practical matter as recommended by our legal counsel.

1203
02:17:11.915 --> 02:17:13.489
<v Andrew Spear>And that concludes my presentation.

1204
02:17:13.538 --> 02:17:15.095
<v Andrew Spear>I'm happy to take questions from the committee.

1205
02:17:16.413 --> 02:17:16.751
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1206
02:17:16.815 --> 02:17:33.263
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So just to summarize, this was the dissolution of the MHCRC was brought forward by the board or by the commission as a recommendation, and all of the members of MHCRC are now moving through the process of dissolution.

1207
02:17:33.343 --> 02:17:50.263
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What we have for us today is the code changes or the contract changes to ensure that come July 1st, we can have our own individual relationship with Comcast rather than working through the MHCRC, which will be dissolving.

1208
02:17:50.360 --> 02:17:50.986
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that accurate?

1209
02:17:51.403 --> 02:17:51.547
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1210
02:17:51.819 --> 02:17:52.752
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1211
02:17:52.863 --> 02:17:54.356
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos, you have questions?

1212
02:17:55.593 --> 02:17:56.299
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, thank you.

1213
02:17:57.423 --> 02:18:03.763
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm understanding that the dissolution is again due to the lack of funding and many other things.

1214
02:18:04.119 --> 02:18:12.689
<v Candace Avalos>But I'm curious, what specific responsibilities will the city now take that were previously handled regionally?

1215
02:18:14.174 --> 02:18:18.061
<v Andrew Spear>So the MHTRC was staffed by Portland staff.

1216
02:18:18.479 --> 02:18:30.007
<v Andrew Spear>And so functionally, Portland won't face any changes in service related to administering the Comcast franchise agreement and running any compliance related to the agreement.

1217
02:18:30.324 --> 02:18:33.674
<v Andrew Spear>So practically, we won't see any change on our end as Portland.

1218
02:18:34.139 --> 02:18:38.084
<v Eric Engstrom>But what the commission has done is they oversee compliance.

1219
02:18:38.727 --> 02:18:46.376
<v Eric Engstrom>So they do play some role in fielding calls or complaints about Comcast or other franchisee services.

1220
02:18:47.353 --> 02:19:18.575
<v Eric Engstrom>They have historically run a grant program with some of the PEG funds that we receive, or public education and government funds, and then they disburse okay, that's helpful.

1221
02:19:18.898 --> 02:19:27.887
<v Candace Avalos>And then to one of the last points you made, I'm curious how we plan to ensure will there be further continuity in the community media funding and services during this transition?

1222
02:19:27.951 --> 02:19:31.117
<v Candace Avalos>And are there any partners or programs impacted that we should know about?

1223
02:19:31.791 --> 02:19:48.775
<v Eric Engstrom>Yeah, that's part of the purpose of doing this is that the group of jurisdictions responsible for the MHCR concluded that we could preserve that funding longer if we removed the cost of running a commission jointly.

1224
02:19:49.129 --> 02:19:54.639
<v Eric Engstrom>That ends up being $1 million-plus a year to run a commission of that size and complexity.

1225
02:19:54.816 --> 02:20:04.165
<v Eric Engstrom>So the— this action of dissolution actually preserves more money for a longer amount of time, assuming that cable franchise revenue continues to drop.

1226
02:20:04.647 --> 02:20:15.138
<v Eric Engstrom>Um, the biggest impact probably is we're reaching a point right now where it's no longer viable to both support the community media centers and run the grant program.

1227
02:20:15.251 --> 02:20:24.755
<v Eric Engstrom>So we are, um, planning to sunset the grant program over the next year, although there are grants being released this year before the commission dissolves.

1228
02:20:25.686 --> 02:20:40.792
<v Andrew Spear>And as part of the timeline to dissolve the commission, we're working internally to work to reestablish the grants between Portland and Open Signal for the distribution of the PEG funds that they receive.

1229
02:20:40.858 --> 02:20:55.203
<v Andrew Spear>And also there's a citywide procurement process going on to establish them as the contractor who will, you know, who actually broadcasts these meetings and other meetings across the city with different commissions and so on.

1230
02:20:55.316 --> 02:21:00.271
<v Andrew Spear>So that work is part of our dissolution process internally here at the city as well.

1231
02:21:02.670 --> 02:21:02.765
<v Jessica Green>Okay.

1232
02:21:03.971 --> 02:21:10.048
<v Candace Avalos>Well, that's a bummer to hear as far as the grant program, you know, not being sustainable.

1233
02:21:10.175 --> 02:21:15.288
<v Candace Avalos>But I think I just want to keep an eye to how we support some of these programs.

1234
02:21:17.710 --> 02:21:27.500
<v Candace Avalos>Um, lastly, was just curious, I mean, it sounds like overall, like you said, we're taking off our MHCC hat, but most things seem to be the same, right?

1235
02:21:27.823 --> 02:21:36.243
<v Candace Avalos>But are there any regional standards or protections under MH CRC that will change now that we're administering independently that we should be aware of?

1236
02:21:37.788 --> 02:21:59.582
<v Eric Engstrom>The commission has, you know, has a— has had a presence over the previous few decades in— at the national level, just in terms of advocacy for, um, you know, community media generally, and, um, in ongoing, you know, work that we've done to, to address things like FCC rules that address cable and, and broadcasting.

1237
02:21:59.629 --> 02:22:02.486
<v Eric Engstrom>And so there is a loss there a little bit.

1238
02:22:02.599 --> 02:22:11.103
<v Eric Engstrom>And so to some okay.

1239
02:22:11.492 --> 02:22:12.202
<v Candace Avalos>Well, thank you so much.

1240
02:22:12.623 --> 02:22:24.886
<v Candace Avalos>I understand that this is, you know, mostly technical, but wanted to make sure that we feel like the programming and that it's going to continue in its mostly its same form.

1241
02:22:24.934 --> 02:22:25.791
<v Candace Avalos>And that's what I'm hearing.

1242
02:22:25.889 --> 02:22:27.638
<v Candace Avalos>So I am supportive of that.

1243
02:22:27.832 --> 02:22:28.673
<v Candace Avalos>And thanks for answering my questions.

1244
02:22:28.802 --> 02:22:28.965
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1245
02:22:32.345 --> 02:22:33.206
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1246
02:22:33.628 --> 02:22:36.938
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I will pause for a minute to see if there's any public testimony.

1247
02:22:39.638 --> 02:22:40.397
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>No one signed up.

1248
02:22:41.042 --> 02:22:43.157
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, we'll continue with council discussion then.

1249
02:22:43.207 --> 02:22:43.900
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

1250
02:22:44.159 --> 02:22:45.176
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, thank you, Chair.

1251
02:22:46.440 --> 02:22:47.344
<v Dan Ryan>I, uh, I first of all thank you.

1252
02:22:47.587 --> 02:22:52.310
<v Dan Ryan>The process that you outlined that you're going through, it's very technical and you're handling it really well.

1253
02:22:52.456 --> 02:22:53.620
<v Dan Ryan>Don't let me get in the way of that.

1254
02:22:54.881 --> 02:22:58.009
<v Dan Ryan>I'm going to ask a question I have a question that I don't know the answer to, obviously.

1255
02:22:58.120 --> 02:23:02.828
<v Dan Ryan>And I also don't even know if I think it's relevant, but it gets at that programming.

1256
02:23:03.359 --> 02:23:13.191
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm one of those people that likes to get my information from like C-SPAN and watching boring meetings because then I don't have someone translating to me what I'm hearing.

1257
02:23:14.011 --> 02:23:18.059
<v Dan Ryan>And I think there's a lot of people that still like to get their information that way.

1258
02:23:18.541 --> 02:23:30.057
<v Dan Ryan>So is the access to that information that I think comes from the traditional cable challenges that are now becoming not watched as much because so many people have cut their cables.

1259
02:23:30.716 --> 02:23:35.709
<v Dan Ryan>I thought I heard that the programming access will still be something we care about.

1260
02:23:36.271 --> 02:23:38.808
<v Andrew Spear>Yeah, under these changes—.

1261
02:23:39.306 --> 02:23:41.489
<v Dan Ryan>And am I in the right place to ask that question?

1262
02:23:41.890 --> 02:23:42.115
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah.

1263
02:23:42.436 --> 02:23:44.989
<v Dan Ryan>All right, I know we were in such a technical conversation.

1264
02:23:45.246 --> 02:23:45.936
<v Andrew Spear>I believe so.

1265
02:23:46.450 --> 02:23:56.197
<v Andrew Spear>Under the changes of the there's nothing in here that changes the operations or technical aspects of cable operation in the city.

1266
02:23:58.081 --> 02:24:01.507
<v Andrew Spear>And there are no policy item changes within it either.

1267
02:24:01.637 --> 02:24:05.209
<v Andrew Spear>And so what we have today will be going forward.

1268
02:24:06.900 --> 02:24:12.387
<v Eric Engstrom>This, in the short term, yeah, there's no changes to, you know, like what channels they're required to carry for public access.

1269
02:24:13.551 --> 02:24:24.684
<v Eric Engstrom>In the long run, we will face this issue existential crisis of if cable revenue continues to decline over the long run, we eventually will reach a point where it's not going to be an industry, and then that—.

1270
02:24:25.052 --> 02:24:25.309
<v Eric Engstrom>Right.

1271
02:24:25.373 --> 02:24:29.191
<v Eric Engstrom>That will force us to rethink how we provide those services.

1272
02:24:29.302 --> 02:24:38.171
<v Eric Engstrom>But this action by moving away from a commission that costs money to operate will buy us a few more years to keep talking about that solution.

1273
02:24:39.068 --> 02:24:39.325
<v Eric Engstrom>Okay.

1274
02:24:39.566 --> 02:24:41.906
<v Dan Ryan>So what I brought up is being discussed somewhere.

1275
02:24:43.737 --> 02:24:45.311
<v Eric Engstrom>Yes.

1276
02:24:45.889 --> 02:24:57.245
<v Andrew Spear>Yeah, I mean, I think there's a lot of discussions around cable and you, you see the channels falling off and, you know, but those aren't necessarily related directly to— This is the public agreement.

1277
02:24:57.390 --> 02:25:02.739
<v Dan Ryan>This is a public access so that, you know, there's really that true raw democracy that continues.

1278
02:25:03.254 --> 02:25:13.606
<v Andrew Spear>Yeah, and we, we engage with Open Signal, um, regularly and as part of their long-term strategic planning, they're engaged with us as partners.

1279
02:25:13.800 --> 02:25:22.566
<v Eric Engstrom>And I think part of that topic, that long-term strategy topic, would be an appropriate thing for this committee to discuss in the future in another venue as well.

1280
02:25:24.360 --> 02:25:24.715
<v Candace Avalos>What'd you say?

1281
02:25:25.022 --> 02:25:25.362
<v Bernal Cruz Munoz>I couldn't hear.

1282
02:25:25.604 --> 02:25:35.764
<v Eric Engstrom>I just— I think that topic, that strategic thinking about how we solve for this in the future, would be a good topic for this committee to continue talking okay, thank you so much.

1283
02:25:38.852 --> 02:25:39.563
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Councilor.

1284
02:25:40.161 --> 02:25:46.207
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to clarify something based on what I heard in your answers to Councilor Ryan and in the presentation.

1285
02:25:47.656 --> 02:26:13.549
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think that the money that has come into the MHCRC in the past was spent in 3 different ways, ensuring that we have public access, not broader what's on cable, but that we have our local public access stations, grants to look at programming for those stations, and the operating costs of the commission itself.

1286
02:26:13.679 --> 02:26:21.131
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I think that the recommendation that came from the commission was that we must preserve that public access at all costs.

1287
02:26:21.468 --> 02:26:33.881
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And what we're doing right now is dissolving the commission and over the next year or 2, moving away from the grant programs so that we can retain our local public access stations for a little bit longer.

1288
02:26:34.396 --> 02:26:35.600
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that correct?

1289
02:26:36.162 --> 02:26:36.354
<v Andrew Spear>Yes.

1290
02:26:36.885 --> 02:26:38.650
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, perfect.

1291
02:26:38.810 --> 02:26:42.360
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just making sure when we got into the questioning there, I wasn't quite sure.

1292
02:26:42.424 --> 02:26:43.756
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, that's why I bounced off of—.

1293
02:26:44.030 --> 02:26:44.462
<v Stephen Green>Yeah.

1294
02:26:45.154 --> 02:26:48.990
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, are there any other questions, concerns, discussion?

1295
02:26:50.917 --> 02:26:53.632
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you so much for the information.

1296
02:26:54.452 --> 02:27:09.474
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I believe this is coming to us as an emergency ordinance so that it can come to full council and go into effect before July 1st when the recommendation for the dissolution of the MHCRC goes into effect.

1297
02:27:10.147 --> 02:27:15.336
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we are voting to refer to full council.

1298
02:27:15.433 --> 02:27:19.558
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I would take a motion to that So moved.

1299
02:27:20.167 --> 02:27:21.082
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Second.

1300
02:27:21.674 --> 02:27:22.075
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1301
02:27:22.253 --> 02:27:23.936
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And this is an emergency ordinance.

1302
02:27:24.256 --> 02:27:30.014
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, just to confirm, moved by Ryan and seconded by, by Murillo?

1303
02:27:30.993 --> 02:27:31.200
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

1304
02:27:31.394 --> 02:27:32.885
<v Courtney Varano>Okay, uh, Ryan?

1305
02:27:33.542 --> 02:27:33.558
<v Andrew Spear>Aye.

1306
02:27:34.521 --> 02:27:34.986
<v Angelita Morillo>Murillo?

1307
02:27:35.788 --> 02:27:35.835
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1308
02:27:36.380 --> 02:27:36.718
<v Courtney Varano>Zimmerman?

1309
02:27:37.086 --> 02:27:37.166
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1310
02:27:37.888 --> 02:27:38.176
<v Tracy Scott>Avalos?

1311
02:27:38.513 --> 02:27:38.674
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1312
02:27:39.572 --> 02:27:40.021
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney?

1313
02:27:40.358 --> 02:27:40.534
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1314
02:27:41.400 --> 02:27:52.245
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, with a vote of 5 ayes, The motion to refer the ordinance document number 2026-131 to City Council with a recommendation it be passed has passed.

1315
02:27:52.807 --> 02:27:53.368
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1316
02:27:53.449 --> 02:27:55.823
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could you please read our final agenda item for us?

1317
02:27:56.897 --> 02:28:08.995
<v Courtney Varano>Item number 3, document 2026-131, approve funding recommendations of the Portland Children's Levy Allocation Committee for July 1st, 2026.

1318
02:28:12.777 --> 02:28:13.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much.

1319
02:28:13.757 --> 02:28:21.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We have a number of folks from the Children's Levy who are coming up to share some information with us today.

1320
02:28:21.954 --> 02:28:33.388
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I want to just remind us all that as we talk about the Children's Levy, Council has a very limited and specific role.

1321
02:28:34.129 --> 02:28:38.876
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This ordinance covers the first item on the agenda is grant decisions that have been made by the Allocation Committee.

1322
02:28:39.550 --> 02:28:51.057
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The Allocation Committee is required by the levy ballot measure and authorizing legislation, and their role is to allocate resources generated by the levy.

1323
02:28:51.639 --> 02:28:57.031
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>This includes deciding the funding process and the grants that result from that process.

1324
02:28:57.950 --> 02:29:00.645
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't pick the individual grants.

1325
02:29:00.774 --> 02:29:24.250
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>What we do is consider the process and the decisions that came out of it, and whether that process meets the, the bar, meets the standard that is set for them, and either approve the grants that came through that process because we believe the process was correct, or remand the grants back to the allocation committee to reconsider their process.

1326
02:29:25.109 --> 02:29:29.048
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>By law, the funds must be used for direct services to support children, youth, and families.

1327
02:29:30.459 --> 02:29:36.031
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Before we hand it over to the Children's Levy team, Councilor Ryan, I know you sit on their committee.

1328
02:29:36.079 --> 02:29:38.963
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there anything that you would like to share to kick us off today?

1329
02:29:40.500 --> 02:29:40.906
<v Dan Ryan>I'm good.

1330
02:29:40.987 --> 02:29:42.061
<v Dan Ryan>I'm glad that you're all here.

1331
02:29:42.762 --> 02:29:49.721
<v Dan Ryan>I hope that you all enjoyed listening to them explain the very diligent process that they went through to get to this place.

1332
02:29:50.414 --> 02:29:50.880
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate it.

1333
02:29:50.961 --> 02:29:52.798
<v Dan Ryan>It's always data-driven and very transparent.

1334
02:29:53.136 --> 02:29:53.394
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1335
02:29:54.054 --> 02:29:54.457
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1336
02:29:55.450 --> 02:29:57.745
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Director McElroy, would you like to start us off?

1337
02:29:58.564 --> 02:29:58.980
<v Angelita Morillo>Absolutely.

1338
02:29:59.045 --> 02:29:59.445
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1339
02:29:59.511 --> 02:30:03.747
<v Angelita Morillo>Good afternoon, councilors, and thanks for welcoming us to your first City Life Committee meeting.

1340
02:30:04.261 --> 02:30:05.480
<v Angelita Morillo>My name is Meg McElroy.

1341
02:30:05.690 --> 02:30:06.637
<v Angelita Morillo>I use she/her pronouns.

1342
02:30:06.748 --> 02:30:16.490
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm the interim director at the Children's Levy, and presenting with me today are Erica Bridgeman, grants manager with the Children's Levy, and Alex Sanchez, who serves on our community council advisory body.

1343
02:30:16.540 --> 02:30:24.254
<v Angelita Morillo>You'll hear more about that work in this presentation, as well as Katrina Peterson, who's our policy and engagement coordinator, is here to help us answer questions.

1344
02:30:28.819 --> 02:30:35.135
<v Angelita Morillo>So the ordinance before you covers 2 funding decisions made by the Children's Levy Allocation Committee for City Council's consideration.

1345
02:30:35.717 --> 02:30:49.703
<v Angelita Morillo>The first is $2.5 million in 3-year grants that resulted from our recent small grants funding process that was implemented over the past year, and the second is an 8% funding increase to the levy's current 3-year large grants.

1346
02:30:50.174 --> 02:30:54.284
<v Angelita Morillo>And this presentation will review the process and the rationale for those decisions.

1347
02:30:55.909 --> 02:31:11.368
<v Angelita Morillo>Just as a reminder, the children's— excuse me, City Council Resolution 37610 referred the children's levy to voters in spring of 2023, and voters overwhelmingly reauthorized it for a 4th time, extending the current levy through June 30th, 2029.

1348
02:31:12.475 --> 02:31:24.372
<v Angelita Morillo>The authorizing legislation that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney referred to earlier, as she said, requires the 5-member allocation committee to make all funding decisions, to have oversight over the funding process and of levy performance.

1349
02:31:25.063 --> 02:31:32.787
<v Angelita Morillo>It caps administration of the fund at 5%, and is— that is subject to annual audits, all of which can be found on our website.

1350
02:31:33.734 --> 02:31:45.863
<v Angelita Morillo>Uses of the funds must be for direct services for children and families families in 6 specific program areas: after-school, child abuse prevention intervention, early childhood, foster care, hunger relief, and mentoring.

1351
02:31:47.757 --> 02:32:19.220
<v Angelita Morillo>We're required to conduct a community engagement process every 5 years to inform the funding priorities in those 6 areas, and the allocation committee must operate a competitive grant process and fund applications based on scores for the record, my name is Erica Bridgeman, and I use she/her pronouns, and I manage the small and the mentoring grants at the Portland Children's Levy.

1352
02:32:20.280 --> 02:32:25.275
<v Eric Zimmerman>PCL had 2 major equity efforts result from community engagement 6 years ago.

1353
02:32:26.014 --> 02:32:36.397
<v Eric Zimmerman>These efforts were recommended by Empress Rules Consulting and a team from PSU Center for Improvement for Child and Family Study— Child and Family Services.

1354
02:32:37.390 --> 02:32:53.806
<v Eric Zimmerman>In response, PCL launched its first small grant in 2020 to increase access to levy funds for smaller organizations and to strengthen their capacity to serve children and families, including Black, Indigenous, children of color, and children with disabilities.

1355
02:32:54.720 --> 02:33:08.333
<v Eric Zimmerman>In addition, PCL launched its Community Advisory Council in 2023, we have 12 volunteer members that represent a diverse range of experience and PCL's program areas and communities served.

1356
02:33:09.174 --> 02:33:16.684
<v Eric Zimmerman>They advise community engagement, funding priorities, application questions, scoring criteria, and the grant review process.

1357
02:33:19.520 --> 02:33:25.177
<v Eric Zimmerman>In sum, 3 groups have different roles and responsibilities in PCL's grants funding process.

1358
02:33:26.096 --> 02:33:34.084
<v Eric Zimmerman>PCL's Community Council advises staff and Allocation Committee members on the design of the funding process.

1359
02:33:34.451 --> 02:33:38.430
<v Eric Zimmerman>They've also made funding recommendations to the Allocation Committee.

1360
02:33:39.504 --> 02:33:59.099
<v Eric Zimmerman>The Allocation Committee decides all the funding decisions, including allocations of PCL resources, the funding processes, which applications to fund, the grant amounts, and they consider advice and recommendations from the Community Council, the staff, and public testimony.

1361
02:34:00.479 --> 02:34:15.143
<v Eric Zimmerman>By law, grant decisions made by the Allocation Committee must go to City Council for final approval or remand the set of decisions back to the Allocation Committee if City Council finds that the Allocation Committee did not follow its requirements.

1362
02:34:16.047 --> 02:34:26.765
<v Eric Zimmerman>For today's ordinance, The city attorney advised that council may approve or remand the set of small grants entirely and approve or reject all large grants amendments entirely.

1363
02:34:30.986 --> 02:34:38.561
<v Eric Zimmerman>PCL small grants are for organizations with annual revenues in their last closed fiscal year of between $90,000 and $750,000.

1364
02:34:40.420 --> 02:34:46.958
<v Eric Zimmerman>Organizations with revenues over $750,000 were eligible for PCL PCL's large grants last year.

1365
02:34:47.825 --> 02:34:53.527
<v Eric Zimmerman>The 3-year minimum small grant is for $81,000 and the maximum is $240,000.

1366
02:34:54.652 --> 02:35:02.137
<v Eric Zimmerman>All PCL grants, including the small grants, are for direct services to children and families and not for general operating costs.

1367
02:35:02.843 --> 02:35:06.810
<v Eric Zimmerman>They must address at least one funding priority in the PCL program area.

1368
02:35:07.677 --> 02:35:18.532
<v Eric Zimmerman>PCL's funding priorities come from our 2024-25 community engagement process that was led by Camille E. Tremor in collaboration with PKS International.

1369
02:35:19.015 --> 02:35:25.511
<v Eric Zimmerman>They spoke with over 700 Portlanders in 26 languages through surveys, focus groups, and interviews.

1370
02:35:26.818 --> 02:35:34.528
<v Eric Zimmerman>PCL published its small grants application on October 15th, 2025.

1371
02:35:35.322 --> 02:35:56.004
<v Eric Zimmerman>The application included 2 components: written questions, which focus on the organization's experience with children and families and proposed program services and annual grant budgets, and a smartphone video of up to 5 minutes addressing the applicant's unique strengths, successes, and proposed uses of PCL funds.

1372
02:35:56.759 --> 02:36:01.376
<v Eric Zimmerman>The video component was offered to help applicants tell their story conversationally.

1373
02:36:02.593 --> 02:36:04.983
<v Eric Zimmerman>All scoring criteria were listed in the application.

1374
02:36:06.137 --> 02:36:16.152
<v Eric Zimmerman>PCL staff hosted information sessions PCL published all emailed questions from applicants and our answers on our website.

1375
02:36:17.262 --> 02:36:19.960
<v Eric Zimmerman>Applications were due on December 1st, 2025.

1376
02:36:21.262 --> 02:36:31.622
<v Eric Zimmerman>Reviewers completed training on anti-bias scoring criteria and more, and the review process took place in December and January of 2025.

1377
02:36:33.251 --> 02:36:52.781
<v Eric Zimmerman>Among the 12 people reviewing grants, 67% identified as Black, Indigenous, or people of color, 33% identified as white, 33% identified as LGBTQIA2S+, and 25% identified as having a disability.

1378
02:36:54.193 --> 02:37:00.825
<v Angelita Morillo>So while those grants were being reviewed and scored, in December of 2025, we received updated revenue projections.

1379
02:37:01.338 --> 02:37:09.479
<v Angelita Morillo>So typically each year in December, the city economist provides the Children's Levy with revenue projections for the current fiscal year and future fiscal years.

1380
02:37:10.234 --> 02:37:17.025
<v Angelita Morillo>Projections in December 2024 were what we used to determine the grant amounts for grantmaking in spring 2025.

1381
02:37:17.941 --> 02:37:24.557
<v Angelita Morillo>The projections that we received most recently in December 2025 showed higher forecasts compared to what we were provided in 2024.

1382
02:37:25.568 --> 02:37:29.759
<v Angelita Morillo>We've experienced that type of variation both up and down with projections in the past.

1383
02:37:30.481 --> 02:37:43.504
<v Angelita Morillo>So we asked the city economist about the increase, and he explained that the main factors were that the forecast for 2024 was more conservative than actual growth on assessed values, and that compression impacts were not as steep as he projected in 2024.

1384
02:37:44.193 --> 02:37:52.110
<v Angelita Morillo>So based on the economist's projections and other factors, the levy has an additional $6.5 million in projected future revenue, revenue over thank you.

1385
02:37:52.157 --> 02:37:52.960
<v Angelita Morillo>The revenue bonds will provide $6 million over 3 years.

1386
02:37:53.009 --> 02:37:54.743
<v Angelita Morillo>That's approximately $2 million per year.

1387
02:37:55.834 --> 02:38:10.606
<v Angelita Morillo>They come from the following sources: $2.8 million from increased tax revenues for fiscal years '26, '27, and '28; $1.7 million from an offset on compression from the new parks levy for the next fiscal years in '27 and '28.

1388
02:38:11.394 --> 02:38:21.269
<v Angelita Morillo>The resolution that council passed referring the parks levy to voters continued a longstanding agreement for the parks levy to offset compression revenue losses to the children's levy.

1389
02:38:22.408 --> 02:38:36.987
<v Angelita Morillo>And then $2 million are from various factors, including higher actual revenues in fiscal year '25, projected increase— interest on the children's levy for fiscal years '26, '27, and '28, and grant underspending from grants that ended in fiscal year '25.

1390
02:38:37.566 --> 02:38:53.200
<v Angelita Morillo>So to be clear, these are mainly projected future property tax revenues, and they have not been yet collected, but So one month after learning that information, our allocation committee met on the 27th of January and voted unanimously to allocate the money as follows.

1391
02:38:53.954 --> 02:39:03.263
<v Angelita Morillo>They added an additional $1 million to small grants, bringing the 3-year total to $2.5 million for fiscal years '27 through '29 and funding up to 12 grants.

1392
02:39:03.809 --> 02:39:08.720
<v Angelita Morillo>That's an increase over their original plans in October of 2025 to allocate $1.5 million.

1393
02:39:08.769 --> 02:39:08.864
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

1394
02:39:09.850 --> 02:39:16.238
<v Angelita Morillo>They added an additional $5.2 million to our current 94 3-year grants.

1395
02:39:16.772 --> 02:39:24.629
<v Angelita Morillo>So this would be an 8% increase on those 3-year grant awards available for grants to grantees to use in fiscal years '27 and '28.

1396
02:39:25.427 --> 02:39:33.367
<v Angelita Morillo>And it left a balance of $300,000 in our fund balance toward grant renewals in fiscal year '29 when current 3-year grants will be eligible for renewal.

1397
02:39:33.447 --> 02:39:33.945
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilmember Herbold.

1398
02:39:34.654 --> 02:39:42.007
<v Angelita Morillo>And just a reminder, revenue from the children's levy is legally required to be spent on grants that support children and families and not for other purposes.

1399
02:39:44.159 --> 02:40:08.115
<v Angelita Morillo>The committee's rationale for these decisions include, with regard to small grants, the ability to meet more of the demand in the applicant pool, which you'll hear more about shortly, funding up to 12 grants as close as possible to their full funding request, and trying to strike a balance between funding more grants grants in that application process with the fact that those are higher need grants for capacity building and working within our current staff capacity.

1400
02:40:09.665 --> 02:40:40.756
<v Angelita Morillo>Their rationale for the increases for the large grants was to move these grant— excuse me, these resources as efficiently as possible into community with amending current grants effective July 1st, 2026, to support COLAs at our current grants and to stabilize service services for children and families where these grantee organization partners are facing other funding cuts from local, state, and federal sources to mitigate the impact of the 21% reductions that these— that were made last year when these grants were provided in the spring.

1401
02:40:41.608 --> 02:40:48.625
<v Angelita Morillo>And finally, the allocation committee decided against revisiting the 74 unfunded applications from its previous grants process.

1402
02:40:49.218 --> 02:41:01.252
<v Angelita Morillo>The majority of those scored below median several had past performance challenges with their levy grants, and requiring staff to design a process for the unfunded applications would delay these resources getting into community.

1403
02:41:02.167 --> 02:41:07.679
<v Angelita Morillo>Altogether, these decisions honor PCL's community-centered funding process implemented over the past 3 years.

1404
02:41:08.032 --> 02:41:11.343
<v Candace Avalos>For the record, my name is Alex Sanchez.

1405
02:41:11.390 --> 02:41:12.900
<v Candace Avalos>I use he/him or they/them pronouns.

1406
02:41:13.479 --> 02:41:17.127
<v Nate McCoy>Returning to PCL small grants, our review wrapped up in January.

1407
02:41:17.592 --> 02:41:28.102
<v Nate McCoy>Total points available for an application was 76, and the median total score for these applications was 54, and the 33 applications scored at the median or higher.

1408
02:41:28.808 --> 02:41:35.104
<v Nate McCoy>PCL's Community Council met February 23rd in a public meeting to recommend applications to the Allocation Committee.

1409
02:41:35.793 --> 02:41:46.644
<v Candace Avalos>Staff developed 3 policy lenses for the Community Council to consider: score order, the high number of afterschool applications, and a balancing across All 6 program areas.

1410
02:41:47.703 --> 02:41:53.547
<v Candace Avalos>After rounds of small and large group discussion, Community Council received an electronic ballot with all 55 applications.

1411
02:41:54.125 --> 02:42:03.709
<v Candace Avalos>Our first round of votes resulted in 11 applications selected and a tie for 12th place amongst 3 applications, each receiving 4 of 9 votes.

1412
02:42:04.672 --> 02:42:07.256
<v Candace Avalos>A second round of voting on only those 3 broke the tie.

1413
02:42:07.867 --> 02:42:12.250
<v Candace Avalos>It resulted in 1 application receiving 5 of 9 votes, 1 receiving 4 of 9 votes, Yes.

1414
02:42:12.298 --> 02:42:14.770
<v Nate McCoy>2 receiving 2 votes and 1 receiving no votes in that second round.

1415
02:42:15.492 --> 02:42:21.158
<v Nate McCoy>In general, council prioritized total score in their decision-making.

1416
02:42:21.352 --> 02:42:23.566
<v Candace Avalos>On the ballot, members were asked to—.

1417
02:42:24.627 --> 02:42:34.082
<v Nate McCoy>Asked which factors influenced their vote: score balancing across program area, prioritization of particular program area or funding priority, or other factors.

1418
02:42:34.579 --> 02:42:56.718
<v Eric Zimmerman>And of the 9 members voting, 7 said score was highly influential and this slide outlines the steps in March leading to the allocation committee meeting on April 7th for small grants funding decisions.

1419
02:42:57.611 --> 02:43:03.647
<v Eric Zimmerman>Applicants and the allocation committee received all funding recommendations on March 3rd.

1420
02:43:04.488 --> 02:43:09.244
<v Eric Zimmerman>The allocation committee had previously received all scores and applicant videos in February.

1421
02:43:11.045 --> 02:43:16.390
<v Eric Zimmerman>Applicants had the option to submit up to 400 words of written testimony during March.

1422
02:43:17.066 --> 02:43:19.522
<v Eric Zimmerman>The allocation committee met on April 7th.

1423
02:43:19.956 --> 02:43:26.666
<v Eric Zimmerman>They shared individual reflections on applicant testimony and their policy lenses in preparing for funding decisions.

1424
02:43:27.486 --> 02:43:35.787
<v Eric Zimmerman>The committee deliberated on the applications and voted unanimously to fund the 12 applications recommended by the community council.

1425
02:43:39.063 --> 02:43:42.899
<v Eric Zimmerman>This slide shows the 12 applications for small grants.

1426
02:43:43.397 --> 02:43:45.261
<v Eric Zimmerman>This list is in alphabetical order.

1427
02:43:46.031 --> 02:43:50.896
<v Eric Zimmerman>Each grant is recommended at the 3-year amount requested by the applicant.

1428
02:43:51.827 --> 02:44:01.269
<v Eric Zimmerman>The capital letters after— the capital letter abbreviations after the names of the applicant indicate the program area that the applicant proposes to offer services in.

1429
02:44:01.706 --> 02:44:06.706
<v Eric Zimmerman>They are after-school mentoring, hunger relief, early childhood, and foster care.

1430
02:44:08.430 --> 02:44:17.932
<v Eric Zimmerman>As we wrap our presentation, we want to acknowledge the difficult budget season— we want to acknowledge the difficult budget season facing the city.

1431
02:44:18.915 --> 02:44:24.467
<v Eric Zimmerman>Hopefully, this is one bright spot where the city can invest in Portland children and families.

1432
02:44:25.290 --> 02:44:31.442
<v Eric Zimmerman>We request the committee to forward the allocation committee's decision to the full City Council for consideration.

1433
02:44:35.040 --> 02:44:37.015
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for that overview, colleagues.

1434
02:44:37.079 --> 02:44:47.958
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We do have a few people signed up for public testimony, but are there any clarifying questions for the folks from the children's levy before we turn to public testimony?

1435
02:44:50.200 --> 02:44:52.280
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, don't go too far.

1436
02:44:52.362 --> 02:44:56.353
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We may have questions later, but let's hear from members of the community first.

1437
02:44:56.754 --> 02:44:57.173
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Go right ahead.

1438
02:44:58.522 --> 02:45:00.191
<v Angelita Morillo>We have 2 people signed up.

1439
02:45:00.834 --> 02:45:07.577
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, when I call your name, come up to the dais if you are in the room, or— I don't see anybody online, so I think they're both in the room.

1440
02:45:08.139 --> 02:45:10.420
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, and you can begin your testimony whenever you get here.

1441
02:45:11.110 --> 02:45:15.670
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Uh, first is Jennifer Hardnett, and second is Lionel Irving.

1442
02:45:19.782 --> 02:45:20.199
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome.

1443
02:45:20.281 --> 02:45:21.612
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for joining us today.

1444
02:45:26.479 --> 02:45:27.290
<v Candace Avalos>You said I can just go ahead and begin?

1445
02:45:27.549 --> 02:45:27.744
<v Angelita Morillo>Okay.

1446
02:45:27.954 --> 02:45:28.750
<v Candace Avalos>Hi, thank you.

1447
02:45:29.025 --> 02:45:29.610
<v Candace Avalos>Um, pleasure being here.

1448
02:45:29.674 --> 02:45:32.398
<v Candace Avalos>My name is Jennifer Hartnett, and I'm here on behalf of Longevity.

1449
02:45:33.323 --> 02:45:43.629
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>I serve as a business manager, not a consultant, and that distinction matters because my role is to build systems that function with stability, integrity, and measurable outcomes.

1450
02:45:44.443 --> 02:45:47.863
<v Candace Avalos>I want to be clear about what accountability truly means in funding.

1451
02:45:48.475 --> 02:45:51.075
<v Candace Avalos>Accountability is not just about compliance and reporting.

1452
02:45:51.525 --> 02:45:57.579
<v Candace Avalos>It's about whether funding systems are structured in a way that allows organizations to actually deliver consistently without disruption.

1453
02:45:58.800 --> 02:46:03.056
<v Candace Avalos>If systems are not built for delivery, outcomes will fail regardless of compliance.

1454
02:46:04.261 --> 02:46:06.043
<v Candace Avalos>And accountability has to be two-sided.

1455
02:46:06.364 --> 02:46:08.790
<v Candace Avalos>We cannot only measure organizational performance.

1456
02:46:08.837 --> 02:46:13.268
<v Candace Avalos>We must also ensure funding systems are structured to support that performance.

1457
02:46:14.134 --> 02:46:15.386
<v Angelita Morillo>Right now, there's gaps.

1458
02:46:16.717 --> 02:46:24.787
<v Candace Avalos>Organizations are often expected to front costs, carry payroll, or wait on reimbursement, disrupting services in real time.

1459
02:46:25.460 --> 02:46:35.551
<v Candace Avalos>At the same time, when organizations can no longer qualify or unable to fully expend funds, there is no clear mechanism to respond without alternates.

1460
02:46:36.129 --> 02:46:50.018
<v Subhashini Ganesan-Forbes>Immediate during that time, additional work could have been done, services expanded, and outcomes strengthened across Portland districts.

1461
02:46:50.661 --> 02:46:54.015
<v Candace Avalos>If we are serious about impact, funding must be able to move with the work.

1462
02:46:54.497 --> 02:47:00.118
<v Candace Avalos>That means building systems that support delivery on the front end and adapt conditions change.

1463
02:47:00.278 --> 02:47:02.013
<v Candace Avalos>Because when we get this right, we get more impact.

1464
02:47:02.060 --> 02:47:02.173
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1465
02:47:02.784 --> 02:47:07.442
<v Candace Avalos>We are not just funding programs, we're ensuring resources and communities when they are needed.

1466
02:47:08.358 --> 02:47:17.942
<v Candace Avalos>So I would recommend that we relook at how we did the allocations for these individual recommendations and suggest an alternate.

1467
02:47:18.721 --> 02:47:19.111
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1468
02:47:22.198 --> 02:47:34.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just to clarify, are you making that proposal for both the short but both the small grants and the extensions or the, the expansion?

1469
02:47:34.182 --> 02:47:34.488
<v Dan Ryan>Both.

1470
02:47:34.780 --> 02:47:35.733
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1471
02:47:39.004 --> 02:47:40.025
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Last call for Lionel.

1472
02:47:45.528 --> 02:47:46.899
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Welcome, thank you for being here.

1473
02:47:53.236 --> 02:47:54.048
<v Lionel Irvin>Good afternoon, councilors.

1474
02:47:54.170 --> 02:47:54.683
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Irvin.

1475
02:47:54.827 --> 02:47:56.079
<v Lionel Irvin>My name is Lionel Irvin.

1476
02:47:56.192 --> 02:48:31.906
<v Lionel Irvin>I am the executive director of Love Is Stronger, and I will say today that I am truly blessed because I was able to see and hear the panels that you guys had come before the community, and I really appreciate that because I was able to— I'm a stakeholder for all panels as we deal with young men and women who have experienced some of the most traumatizing events in their life, and so I just really encouraged to hear the kind of work that was happening in our city, but also made me think of if all the adults are having this much trouble, you know, being sustainable inside our city, what is happening to our youth?

1477
02:48:32.420 --> 02:48:45.911
<v Lionel Irvin>And as I stand in the balance for the young men and women for Love Is Stronger, I came to advocate for Love Is Stronger to be the alternate for the PCO small grant because we had the score that would put us in like 13th or 12th place.

1478
02:48:46.159 --> 02:48:53.510
<v Lionel Irvin>But also because of what makes us— set us apart from other organizations is we're not a culturally specific program.

1479
02:48:53.780 --> 02:49:03.629
<v Lionel Irvin>We're culturally delivered, meaning that when you walk into our space, you see representation from all the community members of young men and women who have experienced a lot of traumatic events.

1480
02:49:03.940 --> 02:49:21.209
<v Lionel Irvin>And to me, that is where the real power is, is when we stop trying to identify young people by color or economics and we start identifying by their conditions and we start putting them in position to help them heal so they can fill some of these spaces of this clean energy boom that we're about to have.

1481
02:49:21.336 --> 02:49:29.014
<v Lionel Irvin>Love and Stronger is currently in contract with PSEFT for a planning grant for workforce development for underserved community members.

1482
02:49:29.465 --> 02:49:43.359
<v Lionel Irvin>And it is my goal to create pathways for our most underserved, overlooked community members to be successful because our economics is only as strong as our youth are, especially those who are overlooked and often under-resourced.

1483
02:49:43.806 --> 02:49:50.409
<v Lionel Irvin>So I don't— and I don't, you know, envy you guys at all because you stand in a tough place to stand in front of the community.

1484
02:49:50.859 --> 02:49:53.216
<v Lionel Irvin>But I appreciate you guys for the service that you do.

1485
02:49:53.761 --> 02:49:58.264
<v Lionel Irvin>And there never should be ever competition between community-based organizations.

1486
02:49:58.344 --> 02:49:59.659
<v Lionel Irvin>It should only be collaboration.

1487
02:50:00.012 --> 02:50:10.174
<v Lionel Irvin>That's why I stand before you guys and ask to be the alternate, because I know the rigors for the City of Portland's requirements for insurance, which is a huge boom that they talked about earlier today.

1488
02:50:10.440 --> 02:50:12.379
<v Lionel Irvin>Which is a barrier.

1489
02:50:12.379 --> 02:50:15.379
<v Lionel Irvin>And I will just say that the young lady just got up there when she started talking about accountability.

1490
02:50:16.180 --> 02:50:22.389
<v Lionel Irvin>What I thought about accountability is when accountability is only one way, then it becomes a barrier.

1491
02:50:23.120 --> 02:50:24.059
<v Lionel Irvin>Accountability is both ways.

1492
02:50:24.059 --> 02:50:27.139
<v Lionel Irvin>It's just not from the service providers, but it's also from the funders.

1493
02:50:27.139 --> 02:50:32.319
<v Lionel Irvin>And so when we get to that lens, then we can continue to have long-lasting impact.

1494
02:50:32.520 --> 02:50:36.159
<v Lionel Irvin>Thank you guys for the work that you do, and I truly appreciate each and every one of you.

1495
02:50:36.159 --> 02:50:40.781
<v Lionel Irvin>If I see I look forward to seeing plenty of you guys out inside the community, and, uh, I thank you for that.

1496
02:50:41.040 --> 02:50:41.847
<v Lionel Irvin>Have a great day.

1497
02:50:43.693 --> 02:50:45.485
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much for being here with us today.

1498
02:50:46.609 --> 02:50:48.254
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And that completes public testimony.

1499
02:50:49.100 --> 02:50:50.113
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Fantastic, thank you.

1500
02:50:51.208 --> 02:50:52.077
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Avalos.

1501
02:50:52.817 --> 02:50:53.849
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1502
02:50:56.100 --> 02:50:57.936
<v Candace Avalos>Um, and the folks are still in the room, right?

1503
02:50:58.147 --> 02:50:59.259
<v Candace Avalos>Did I— okay, they're there.

1504
02:50:59.436 --> 02:50:59.549
<v Candace Avalos>All right.

1505
02:51:00.227 --> 02:51:04.579
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so first of all, I appreciate the intent behind the small Councilor Smith.

1506
02:51:04.579 --> 02:51:04.579
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Mayor.

1507
02:51:04.579 --> 02:51:10.680
<v Candace Avalos>I just wanted to thank you for the work that you've done to expand our grants program to expand access and create more opportunities for these smaller community-based groups.

1508
02:51:10.680 --> 02:51:21.280
<v Candace Avalos>It's also clear from the presentation that demand continues to far exceed our available resources, which is always the case, but it just speaks to the, the need for ongoing investment.

1509
02:51:21.280 --> 02:51:28.739
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you for taking those steps, and great to hear that we can invest more due to some updated revenue projections.

1510
02:51:28.739 --> 02:51:36.727
<v Candace Avalos>So especially in times I just have a couple of quick questions about, you know, this effort.

1511
02:51:36.856 --> 02:51:47.347
<v Candace Avalos>So the small grants program was designed to expand access, and so can you talk to me a little bit about how successful this round was in reaching smaller and culturally specific organizations?

1512
02:51:49.263 --> 02:51:57.395
<v Eric Zimmerman>So all of the organizations who apply for small grants must be— have revenues between $90,000 to $750,000.

1513
02:51:57.475 --> 02:51:59.725
<v Eric Zimmerman>So they are all smaller organizations.

1514
02:52:01.283 --> 02:52:25.291
<v Eric Zimmerman>In terms of culturally specific, we were able to ask for some demographic information about organization staff and their board of directors on the application questions, but the allocation committee and the community council did not consider those demographic questions as part of their decision-making due to the restrictions of the executive order.

1515
02:52:26.037 --> 02:52:35.474
<v Eric Zimmerman>However, after that, we were able to analyze some of the data that was given to us by the applicants.

1516
02:52:36.067 --> 02:52:44.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so 11 of 12 applications that were selected had 50% or more of their staff identifying as Black, Indigenous, or people of color.

1517
02:52:45.777 --> 02:52:54.829
<v Eric Zimmerman>And 9 of the 12 applications selected had boards of directors that were 50% or more Black, Indigenous, thank you.

1518
02:52:54.942 --> 02:53:02.970
<v Candace Avalos>I don't love hearing though that, um, that executive order continues to be a barrier, and it's something that we need to keep talking about.

1519
02:53:03.676 --> 02:53:12.733
<v Candace Avalos>Um, was curious, of the 55 applicants, do we have any insight into who was not funded and if there are any patterns in who is getting left out from these opportunities?

1520
02:53:13.808 --> 02:53:16.104
<v Angelita Morillo>It's a great question.

1521
02:53:16.441 --> 02:53:20.212
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I'm not sure we've analyzed it thoroughly.

1522
02:53:20.453 --> 02:53:31.941
<v Angelita Morillo>I would say, having looked at it briefly based on the amount of funding that applicants requested— so applicants could request up to $240,000, that was the maximum 3-year amount.

1523
02:53:32.486 --> 02:53:42.306
<v Angelita Morillo>And also applicants were limited to requesting— this is true for all of our applications— no more than 30% of their annual revenues in the last closed fiscal year for a grant.

1524
02:53:42.627 --> 02:53:44.621
<v Angelita Morillo>So if they requested smaller amounts.

1525
02:53:44.686 --> 02:53:47.376
<v Angelita Morillo>That means they were smaller organizations by revenue.

1526
02:53:47.987 --> 02:54:04.936
<v Angelita Morillo>And in general, of the 12 organizations recommended for funding, they tended to be on that higher funding request level, meaning they were asking for maximum grants, meaning their organization size in that range from up to $750,000 annually.

1527
02:54:05.308 --> 02:54:07.481
<v Angelita Morillo>They were closer to that than they were at the lesser range.

1528
02:54:07.530 --> 02:54:07.835
<v Angelita Morillo>Does that make sense?

1529
02:54:07.899 --> 02:54:08.029
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1530
02:54:08.430 --> 02:54:09.744
<v Angelita Morillo>Does that answer your question, Councilor?

1531
02:54:10.128 --> 02:54:10.433
<v Candace Avalos>It does.

1532
02:54:11.810 --> 02:54:24.630
<v Candace Avalos>And therefore brings me to my last question in how we measure success for both the small grants and the large grants, because I think that's part of the issue, is that we want to ensure that we are bringing in some of these smaller groups.

1533
02:54:24.727 --> 02:54:29.583
<v Candace Avalos>But when you measure them side by side, it's an unfair, right, comparison.

1534
02:54:29.630 --> 02:54:35.626
<v Candace Avalos>So now that we've added, you know, a lot of these newer small grants, can you talk about how you bet.

1535
02:54:36.710 --> 02:54:41.388
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think one measurement of success is that this is the second time we've done a round of small grants.

1536
02:54:42.010 --> 02:54:47.253
<v Eric Zimmerman>The first round of small grants, we had 7 grantees that were awarded of that.

1537
02:54:47.915 --> 02:54:52.097
<v Eric Zimmerman>Of those 7, 6 were eligible and applied for large grants in this round.

1538
02:54:52.195 --> 02:54:57.275
<v Eric Zimmerman>So their capacity had grown to where they were no longer eligible for small grants and they applied for large grants.

1539
02:54:57.806 --> 02:55:01.606
<v Eric Zimmerman>Of those 6, 4 were funded in what, you know, is a highly competitive round.

1540
02:55:02.431 --> 02:55:09.918
<v Eric Zimmerman>So even though it was a highly competitive round, even though there were smaller organizations, 4 of the 6 were funded in that round.

1541
02:55:10.760 --> 02:55:12.212
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that indicates some success.

1542
02:55:12.745 --> 02:55:22.475
<v Eric Zimmerman>A big part of the emphasis of the small grants portfolio is to do capacity building of these organizations.

1543
02:55:23.055 --> 02:55:46.134
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I do think those who are funded at the higher end, that like $750,000 range or $500,000 up, um, are able to really take advantage of the additional training, additional support, and kind of coaching that comes from the small grants, and then grow into becoming larger organizations, um, that are able to provide more services for more children, youth, and families.

1544
02:55:47.048 --> 02:55:47.432
<v Candace Avalos>That's great.

1545
02:55:47.593 --> 02:55:48.394
<v Candace Avalos>I love to hear that.

1546
02:55:48.474 --> 02:55:59.644
<v Candace Avalos>And I think in general we need to keep working on that because, um, there are a lot of small groups that could really use some more technical assistance and guidance so that they can be more successful for community, but it requires our help.

1547
02:55:59.724 --> 02:56:03.556
<v Candace Avalos>So this is a thing that I'm bringing up across many different bureaus.

1548
02:56:03.895 --> 02:56:04.811
<v Candace Avalos>Um, so thanks for your work.

1549
02:56:04.941 --> 02:56:06.197
<v Candace Avalos>Uh, I look forward to supporting this.

1550
02:56:06.888 --> 02:56:07.291
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1551
02:56:09.063 --> 02:56:16.771
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to— I just want to acknowledge something, that they have a limitation of 5%, um, of, of the whole pot to be spent on staffing.

1552
02:56:17.370 --> 02:56:26.935
<v Dan Ryan>And so the fact that you use technical assistance work and how much you, you get in there and work with each, um, grantee is really impressive considering that constraint.

1553
02:56:27.259 --> 02:56:28.259
<v Dan Ryan>I just wanted to lift that.

1554
02:56:29.226 --> 02:56:29.564
<v Tracy Scott>Thank you.

1555
02:56:31.894 --> 02:56:32.665
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Zimmerman.

1556
02:56:34.289 --> 02:56:34.788
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, thanks.

1557
02:56:35.013 --> 02:56:43.775
<v Eric Zimmerman>You know, going through the, the list of awards, etc., just, it is quite clear, you know, that the saying it takes a village is quite true.

1558
02:56:44.391 --> 02:56:57.602
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that's just a really important part of this work and and sometimes with funding packages, we have a tendency to go through the list with a fine-tooth comb.

1559
02:56:58.371 --> 02:57:02.510
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in this case, and in this, I think the importance is actually not to do it.

1560
02:57:02.558 --> 02:57:07.626
<v Eric Zimmerman>I actually appreciate how we preambled that this is about the process and whose role is what here.

1561
02:57:08.780 --> 02:57:16.013
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because when it takes a village, it is fair to say not everybody understands what it takes for every member of that village.

1562
02:57:16.093 --> 02:57:18.759
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I think that that's really reflective in what you've put forward here.

1563
02:57:19.530 --> 02:57:30.479
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate the effort toward a small grant while ensuring that the larger, more established remains still the focus in terms of where our outcomes are at.

1564
02:57:30.543 --> 02:57:34.188
<v Eric Zimmerman>I believe in innovation, but that it can't be the main thing.

1565
02:57:34.300 --> 02:57:39.968
<v Eric Zimmerman>You still got to stay on the main line of effort while you see what you can like help along to see if it gets any grasp.

1566
02:57:40.161 --> 02:57:45.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in the innovation track, it's okay to stumble occasionally, but in the main track, right, we've got to stay true to the mission.

1567
02:57:46.050 --> 02:57:59.524
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think you've, I think you've laid out what looks to me to be very fair, to be very thoughtful, appreciative of just the, the depth and breadth and diversity of the village.

1568
02:57:59.654 --> 02:58:03.540
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I think that's the heart of where I see this at and why deeply supportive.

1569
02:58:05.389 --> 02:58:13.069
<v Eric Zimmerman>I appreciate what our council president said recently, and he says often, is that his concern is the 3 o'clock to 8 o'clock hours for kids.

1570
02:58:13.199 --> 02:58:21.879
<v Eric Zimmerman>And given the earlier panels about childcare and things of those natures, anything that is moving in the pro-social direction is a good idea.

1571
02:58:21.959 --> 02:58:25.284
<v Eric Zimmerman>If it gets you off of these, that's a good idea.

1572
02:58:25.350 --> 02:58:28.209
<v Eric Zimmerman>And most of these programs look like they're headed in that direction.

1573
02:58:28.329 --> 02:58:29.871
<v Eric Zimmerman>So thanks for helping the schools out.

1574
02:58:29.939 --> 02:58:31.083
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks for helping the parents out.

1575
02:58:32.788 --> 02:58:34.461
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think your awards will make the neighborhoods better.

1576
02:58:34.711 --> 02:58:36.397
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks, Councilor.

1577
02:58:37.281 --> 02:58:37.810
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor Ryan.

1578
02:58:38.532 --> 02:58:41.005
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, Council President, I think— sorry, it's a habit.

1579
02:58:41.439 --> 02:58:42.483
<v Dan Ryan>Chair, thank you so much.

1580
02:58:42.899 --> 02:58:45.870
<v Dan Ryan>Can you please explain our next step when it comes to alternates?

1581
02:58:46.416 --> 02:58:47.427
<v Dan Ryan>'Cause we did discuss that.

1582
02:58:47.700 --> 02:58:49.243
<v Angelita Morillo>Sure, Councilor Ryan.

1583
02:58:49.387 --> 02:59:02.554
<v Angelita Morillo>At the Allocation Committee meeting on April 7th, there was discussion after the 12 applications were selected for grants about whether or not there should be consideration of an alternate grant.

1584
02:59:02.970 --> 02:59:13.568
<v Angelita Morillo>And that came up because in our first cohort of small grants, originally 8 grants were made, and in the course of grant negotiations, one applicant declined their grant.

1585
02:59:14.227 --> 02:59:16.057
<v Angelita Morillo>So this was before they entered into contract.

1586
02:59:16.940 --> 02:59:25.290
<v Angelita Morillo>And in fact, to Lionel's point, the entity that declined their grant had a hard time with the insurance requirements.

1587
02:59:25.386 --> 02:59:41.846
<v Angelita Morillo>And At that time, the funds were distributed— the allocation committee at that time decided to distribute those funds to the remaining 7 small grantees because they had been funded for less than they were eligible to receive.

1588
02:59:42.691 --> 02:59:50.511
<v Angelita Morillo>But it came up again in this context because there were so many applicants this time, and the allocation committee was trying to decide whether they should fund all of them.

1589
02:59:50.559 --> 02:59:51.077
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that's a good point.

1590
02:59:51.445 --> 02:59:58.542
<v Angelita Morillo>More applicants if they could and really decided against doing that in order to not stretch staff capacity further.

1591
02:59:58.672 --> 03:00:03.070
<v Angelita Morillo>We've already increased total grants by 26% with the same FTE that we've had.

1592
03:00:03.906 --> 03:00:11.902
<v Angelita Morillo>And instead, we're looking to whether or not they should create an alternate for these grants should somebody decline their grant in the course of negotiations.

1593
03:00:12.736 --> 03:00:21.416
<v Angelita Morillo>They decided to table that discussion until their June meeting because they have no process for identifying So they want to discuss that in June.

1594
03:00:22.172 --> 03:00:23.906
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor, did that answer your question?

1595
03:00:24.261 --> 03:00:24.694
<v Dan Ryan>Absolutely.

1596
03:00:24.743 --> 03:00:32.736
<v Dan Ryan>We decided not to do it on the fly at that meeting, but we wanted to make sure that we'd had a thorough process, and I look forward to that conversation at the next meeting.

1597
03:00:33.551 --> 03:00:34.033
<v Nate McCoy>Thanks.

1598
03:00:35.143 --> 03:00:36.959
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Councilor, thank you for asking that question.

1599
03:00:37.006 --> 03:00:41.087
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think what that means is that we heard testimony today about alternates.

1600
03:00:41.569 --> 03:00:51.136
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>There's not a recommendation before us on that topic, but there may be a recommendation coming to us in the future based on the conversations that are forthcoming with the committee.

1601
03:00:51.842 --> 03:00:52.420
<v Angelita Morillo>Is that correct?

1602
03:00:52.484 --> 03:00:52.902
<v Angelita Morillo>That's correct.

1603
03:00:52.950 --> 03:01:00.432
<v Angelita Morillo>If I can offer one clarification, it'll be forthcoming, but at a time potentially after this ordinance goes forward to full council.

1604
03:01:01.058 --> 03:01:02.694
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It would be something we would adopt in the future?

1605
03:01:02.984 --> 03:01:03.272
<v Angelita Morillo>Correct.

1606
03:01:03.722 --> 03:01:24.086
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, colleagues, seeing no one else in the queue for discussion, we do have an opportunity to refer both Exhibit A, the small grants, and Exhibit B, the amendments to the budget that was approved last year, to full council with a do pass recommendation.

1607
03:01:24.263 --> 03:01:25.773
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is there a motion to that end?

1608
03:01:25.983 --> 03:01:26.689
<v Jeremy Van Keuren>So moved.

1609
03:01:28.135 --> 03:01:28.665
<v Eric Zimmerman>Is there a second?

1610
03:01:28.728 --> 03:01:29.324
<v Tracy Scott>Second.

1611
03:01:30.077 --> 03:01:31.828
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

1612
03:01:32.134 --> 03:01:33.177
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Could we call the roll?

1613
03:01:34.238 --> 03:01:37.754
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Just want to confirm moved by Zimmerman and seconded by Murillo?

1614
03:01:38.173 --> 03:01:38.654
<v Angelita Morillo>Correct.

1615
03:01:39.120 --> 03:01:39.906
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>All right, thank you.

1616
03:01:40.340 --> 03:01:40.532
<v Candace Avalos>Ryan?

1617
03:01:41.288 --> 03:01:41.335
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1618
03:01:41.881 --> 03:01:42.412
<v Angelita Morillo>Murillo?

1619
03:01:43.536 --> 03:01:43.584
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1620
03:01:44.273 --> 03:01:44.627
<v Courtney Varano>Zimmerman?

1621
03:01:44.899 --> 03:01:45.060
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1622
03:01:45.638 --> 03:01:45.927
<v Tracy Scott>Avalos?

1623
03:01:46.585 --> 03:01:46.634
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1624
03:01:47.325 --> 03:01:47.774
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pirtle-Guiney?

1625
03:01:48.352 --> 03:01:48.400
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Aye.

1626
03:01:49.814 --> 03:02:00.346
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>With a vote of 5 ayes, the motion to refer the ordinance document number 2026-132 to City Council with the recommendation it be passed has passed.

1627
03:02:01.934 --> 03:02:02.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

1628
03:02:02.479 --> 03:02:03.425
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you all so much.

1629
03:02:04.404 --> 03:02:11.218
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Colleagues, we do have a committee meeting in 2 weeks on April 28th, though our timing is a little bit off that day.

1630
03:02:11.299 --> 03:02:12.405
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We'll be meeting in the morning.

1631
03:02:13.143 --> 03:02:20.983
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will have our first opportunity for public communication from Portlanders about topics that are within this committee's jurisdiction.

1632
03:02:21.640 --> 03:02:29.225
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We will hear a one-on-one presentation from Prosper Portland, uh, in light of their leadership changes within the last year.

1633
03:02:29.352 --> 03:02:34.175
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They have requested the opportunity to talk to us about their programs and their plans.

1634
03:02:34.944 --> 03:02:41.658
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And then we will hear some ordinances presented by the council president about arts tax reforms.

1635
03:02:42.172 --> 03:02:44.816
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you for bearing with me with a long agenda today.

1636
03:02:45.441 --> 03:02:56.931
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we do have posted online supplemental materials from our first agenda item, including that overview of the themes before Our committee that my staff has put together.

1637
03:02:57.012 --> 03:02:58.094
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I hope you review that all.

1638
03:02:58.628 --> 03:02:59.323
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you so much.

1639
03:02:59.501 --> 03:03:01.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And with that, today's meeting is adjourned.

1640
03:03:05.865 --> 03:03:06.638
<v Nate McCoy>Thank you.

