WEBVTT

1
00:06:49.014 --> 00:06:49.848
<v Mitch Green>Good afternoon.

2
00:06:49.896 --> 00:06:52.593
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am calling back to order the council.

3
00:06:52.882 --> 00:06:56.747
<v Jamie Dunphy>Work session on the afternoon of Wednesday, April 8th.

4
00:06:56.959 --> 00:07:01.370
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to first turn it over ever so briefly to CFO Jonas Biery.

5
00:07:03.172 --> 00:07:03.574
<v Jonas Biery>Great.

6
00:07:03.718 --> 00:07:07.644
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you, Council President and councilors.

7
00:07:10.273 --> 00:07:10.742
<v Jonas Biery>Good afternoon.

8
00:07:10.790 --> 00:07:19.988
<v Jonas Biery>For the record, Jonas Biery, City's Chief Financial Officer, here with City Economist Peter Holzman, who's going to share a few slides with details about the most recent general fund forecast.

9
00:07:20.726 --> 00:07:26.918
<v Jonas Biery>That document was published and also distributed directly to council offices on March 24th.

10
00:07:27.985 --> 00:07:33.161
<v Jonas Biery>We previewed some of this information at prior budget work sessions, at the spring town work session last week.

11
00:07:33.887 --> 00:07:47.579
<v Jonas Biery>Also, just note for those following along online at home, the presentation that we're going to have today was distributed to council late yesterday afternoon and is available publicly on the work session page on portland.gov.

12
00:07:48.574 --> 00:07:53.940
<v Jonas Biery>Before handing to Peter, I just want to spend a couple of minutes framing up some facts about the city's forecasting efforts.

13
00:07:54.841 --> 00:08:08.963
<v Jonas Biery>The city's forecast objective is to estimate revenues and expenses as closely to accurate as reasonably possible, using assumptions based on verifiable data and economic trends and informed by specialized economic expertise and experience.

14
00:08:09.639 --> 00:08:11.598
<v Jonas Biery>Forecasts can be a very tricky thing.

15
00:08:12.338 --> 00:08:19.055
<v Jonas Biery>When projections are too high, Forecasts can be villainized because revenues were lower than projected and spending needs to be adjusted.

16
00:08:19.649 --> 00:08:26.906
<v Jonas Biery>When forecasts are too low, they can be villainized because not enough revenues were put on the table initially to support timely decision-making.

17
00:08:27.980 --> 00:08:37.000
<v Jonas Biery>Because inputs to forecasts are highly variable, and we'll hear about some of this today, changes are inevitable, especially in an organization as large and complex as the city.

18
00:08:37.898 --> 00:08:42.110
<v Jonas Biery>Often changes to the forecast result from externalities that are outside the city's control.

19
00:08:42.799 --> 00:08:52.883
<v Jonas Biery>For example, global volatility and unexpected state or federal legislation can impact the forecast in sometimes unpredictable ways, and we'll hear about some of that today, and we already have.

20
00:08:53.283 --> 00:09:04.279
<v Jonas Biery>Additionally, recent city forecasts have been impacted by never-seen-before reductions in property tax values or reduction in property tax value growth that developed in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic.

21
00:09:04.697 --> 00:09:10.965
<v Jonas Biery>It's because of this expectation of change that the city economist provides multiple updates to the forecast throughout the year.

22
00:09:12.134 --> 00:09:18.447
<v Jonas Biery>One of my favorite wonky quotes, which some of you, maybe all of you, heard me say before is, all predictions guaranteed wrong.

23
00:09:19.591 --> 00:09:25.360
<v Jonas Biery>I love that quote because it's sort of a cheeky nod to the fact that it's impossible to expect perfection in forecasting.

24
00:09:25.798 --> 00:09:31.086
<v Jonas Biery>Forecasts will be imperfect by their very nature, but hopefully minimally so.

25
00:09:31.490 --> 00:09:41.179
<v Jonas Biery>I'll also preview, we'll hear more about this in a moment, but I'll preview that the 5-year general fund forecast remains balanced over that 5-year period consistent with current city policy.

26
00:09:41.758 --> 00:09:45.542
<v Jonas Biery>However, it's important to call out that the forecast is based upon current appropriation levels or CAL.

27
00:09:47.721 --> 00:09:48.812
<v Jonas Biery>Not current service levels.

28
00:09:49.565 --> 00:09:50.479
<v Jonas Biery>We know— or CSL.

29
00:09:50.847 --> 00:09:54.374
<v Jonas Biery>We know that CSL expectations are typically higher than Cal.

30
00:09:54.599 --> 00:10:04.345
<v Jonas Biery>So if that trend continues to hold true and nothing else changes, we can expect some amount of gap next fiscal year despite the current forecast appearing balanced at zero next year.

31
00:10:05.499 --> 00:10:19.253
<v Jonas Biery>Lastly, and as previously discussed in this room, I'm on the very front edge of working on a 5-year financial stabilization and recovery plan, and I expect that effort will provide support for future council discussions and deliberations about long-term forecasts and finances.

32
00:10:20.268 --> 00:10:25.027
<v Jonas Biery>And look forward to sharing more with you as that work begins over the next couple of months and over the summer.

33
00:10:25.591 --> 00:10:26.640
<v Jonas Biery>With that, I'll hand over to Peter.

34
00:10:26.705 --> 00:10:26.931
<v Jonas Biery>Thank you.

35
00:10:28.109 --> 00:10:30.619
<v Peter Holzman>For the record, Peter Holzman, City Economist.

36
00:10:30.830 --> 00:10:32.389
<v Peter Holzman>And can we go to the next slide, please?

37
00:10:34.182 --> 00:10:42.764
<v Peter Holzman>So this shows my favorite least favorite graph, which is about economic uncertainty.

38
00:10:43.102 --> 00:10:47.356
<v Peter Holzman>And so in forecasting and economics, we differentiate between risk and uncertainty.

39
00:10:48.259 --> 00:10:50.190
<v Peter Holzman>Risk being something that's quantifiable.

40
00:10:50.936 --> 00:10:54.000
<v Peter Holzman>You have a probability of this thing happening.

41
00:10:54.115 --> 00:10:59.269
<v Peter Holzman>And uncertainty being we have no— we generally don't know the range of—.

42
00:10:59.302 --> 00:11:04.519
<v Mitch Green>Peter, sorry, and I hate to interrupt, but I wanted to start before we jumped into this.

43
00:11:04.585 --> 00:11:06.902
<v Mitch Green>I just need to get— I just need to say something.

44
00:11:07.419 --> 00:11:21.443
<v Mitch Green>Earlier in this chambers, in these dais, there was a characterization of another bureau As engaging in malfeasance because one of my colleagues did not like the answers that they were getting, has been frustrated.

45
00:11:21.491 --> 00:11:27.238
<v Mitch Green>I think we've all been frustrated with the changing balances of the housing-related stuff, but you guys are doing hard work.

46
00:11:27.318 --> 00:11:29.812
<v Mitch Green>Jonas, you said it yourself, all forecasts are wrong.

47
00:11:31.568 --> 00:11:34.504
<v Mitch Green>I can't let something like that go stand without correcting the record.

48
00:11:34.875 --> 00:11:40.312
<v Mitch Green>The people who work in the Housing Bureau are some of the hardest working, and they devote their hearts and souls into this work.

49
00:11:40.378 --> 00:11:42.750
<v Mitch Green>And so if we have an issue with our bureaus, we have an issue of accountability.

50
00:11:42.799 --> 00:11:42.995
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

51
00:11:44.506 --> 00:11:46.110
<v Mitch Green>That needs to stay at the level of leadership.

52
00:11:46.350 --> 00:11:50.153
<v Mitch Green>We can talk about needing to change our organizational structures.

53
00:11:50.201 --> 00:11:51.581
<v Mitch Green>We can talk about the need for oversight.

54
00:11:52.125 --> 00:12:01.751
<v Mitch Green>We never just wholesale critique a bureau as being corrupt or engaging in malfeasance, or in previous situations, like maybe you're doing a bad job as the city economist.

55
00:12:01.847 --> 00:12:03.082
<v Mitch Green>I'm just going to rebuke that.

56
00:12:03.692 --> 00:12:05.104
<v Mitch Green>If I hear it again, I'm going to rebuke it again.

57
00:12:05.153 --> 00:12:08.826
<v Mitch Green>And I just— I needed to say that before you guys launch into this, because this is going to be a heady topic too.

58
00:12:09.628 --> 00:12:10.558
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for allowing me to jump in.

59
00:12:10.654 --> 00:12:10.750
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

60
00:12:11.152 --> 00:12:11.392
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

61
00:12:12.818 --> 00:12:18.413
<v Peter Holzman>And just to continue, so I just distinguish between risk and uncertainty.

62
00:12:19.408 --> 00:12:24.905
<v Peter Holzman>We have a way of tracking uncertainty, which is basically how often it comes up in newspapers, periodicals, and that sort of thing.

63
00:12:26.203 --> 00:12:28.496
<v Peter Holzman>And this is the index from the mid-'80s.

64
00:12:28.705 --> 00:12:32.552
<v Peter Holzman>And as you would expect, during COVID economic uncertainty was at an all-time high.

65
00:12:33.370 --> 00:12:47.230
<v Peter Holzman>It was also at an all-time high last April when I released the April forecast, largely related to the tariff announcements and the uncertainty that that created for both economic policy, financial markets reactions, and things like that.

66
00:12:47.668 --> 00:12:54.269
<v Peter Holzman>You'll note that while it is not at those levels this April, it is reaccelerating.

67
00:12:55.014 --> 00:13:10.785
<v Peter Holzman>And so I just wanna flag that as important context because basically this chart shows all the many ways that I could be wrong by things that are not in my, like I'm not assuming, I'm not assuming a recession, I'm not assuming—.

68
00:13:10.822 --> 00:13:11.051
<v Loretta Smith>Inflation.

69
00:13:11.605 --> 00:13:16.561
<v Peter Holzman>Some sort of further escalation of geopolitical conflict, anything along those lines.

70
00:13:16.706 --> 00:13:26.198
<v Peter Holzman>And so as all those possibilities exist, it sets the context for the forecast that I'm gonna present today.

71
00:13:26.361 --> 00:13:27.388
<v Peter Holzman>And so we can go to the next slide.

72
00:13:29.653 --> 00:13:32.985
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Council President, can I ask a clarifying question about that slide first before we move on?

73
00:13:33.196 --> 00:13:33.374
<v Angelita Morillo>Yep.

74
00:13:33.859 --> 00:13:34.312
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you.

75
00:13:36.025 --> 00:13:40.991
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am wondering if what we're looking at here is a look forward, a look back, or a point in time and what I— Point in time.

76
00:13:41.961 --> 00:13:56.703
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So just to clarify that, the top of the blue line is where we sit today based on the reality on the ground today, meaning we are not making any projections about what we think could happen.

77
00:13:57.620 --> 00:14:06.581
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But it is also not a backwards look where the last month on here is, for example, February, and we're saying this is what the uncertainty was in February.

78
00:14:06.758 --> 00:14:33.110
<v Peter Holzman>It is literally the top point of that line is yeah, and just because your question, I think I should explain the methodology a little bit, which it's basically tracking how often economic uncertainty is mentioned as a major risk in periodicals and things along those lines.

79
00:14:33.110 --> 00:14:33.980
<v Peter Holzman>And so those are daily.

80
00:14:34.389 --> 00:14:36.690
<v Peter Holzman>And so this is an aggregate of the last 365 days.

81
00:14:36.690 --> 00:14:36.789
<v Loretta Smith>So it's not a snapshot.

82
00:14:36.806 --> 00:14:37.783
<v Peter Holzman>A daily measure.

83
00:14:38.264 --> 00:14:39.563
<v Peter Holzman>That is, I believe it's weekly.

84
00:14:39.644 --> 00:14:41.856
<v Peter Holzman>So this week we are at this level.

85
00:14:42.370 --> 00:14:50.674
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So to that end, that means that there are not adjustments looking back after the fact to say, oh, we got it wrong, uncertainty was higher or lower.

86
00:14:50.770 --> 00:14:57.634
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It is literally a metric of how often do people talk about uncertainty as a condition that matters.

87
00:14:58.532 --> 00:15:04.928
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And therefore it is, in a sense, maybe a look back of a day or 2 because it's a reflection of what has just occurred.

88
00:15:05.179 --> 00:15:05.836
<v Peter Holzman>Yes, exactly.

89
00:15:05.933 --> 00:15:06.787
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

90
00:15:06.836 --> 00:15:07.394
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>That's helpful.

91
00:15:07.754 --> 00:15:09.477
<v Peter Holzman>All right, now next slide.

92
00:15:11.169 --> 00:15:17.989
<v Peter Holzman>And so while I know we're here to talk about fiscal year '26-'27, I think this is a good opportunity to talk about the current year deficit as well.

93
00:15:19.250 --> 00:15:29.932
<v Peter Holzman>Sometimes in my effort to daylight every small change to the forecast or trend muddled by fiscal years or accounting idiosyncrasy, I think I might have missed an opportunity to better highlight a relatively simple story.

94
00:15:31.886 --> 00:15:38.899
<v Peter Holzman>House Resolution 1, otherwise known as the Big Beautiful Bill, passed in July after the April 2025 forecast, which set the budget.

95
00:15:40.639 --> 00:15:46.722
<v Peter Holzman>The Legislative Revenue Office at the state estimated the impact to the state revenue similar to the ones that make up the business license tax.

96
00:15:46.772 --> 00:15:53.250
<v Peter Holzman>So it's a portion of the personal income tax and all of the corporate excise tax at $362 million for the current fiscal year.

97
00:15:53.975 --> 00:16:04.404
<v Peter Holzman>I worked with LRO, Legislative Revenue Office, over the fall and tracked returns in October and November to estimate the impacts of House Resolution 1 to the City of Portland's business license tax revenue.

98
00:16:05.320 --> 00:16:12.653
<v Peter Holzman>I estimated that the state's $362 million translated to about $21.4 million for the current fiscal year for the City of Portland.

99
00:16:13.245 --> 00:16:17.418
<v Peter Holzman>This analysis was completed after the fall TAO in November, December.

100
00:16:17.578 --> 00:16:21.365
<v Peter Holzman>And again, I was waiting in part on final returns.

101
00:16:21.413 --> 00:16:24.654
<v Peter Holzman>And then there was also discussion of disconnecting earlier.

102
00:16:24.719 --> 00:16:28.538
<v Peter Holzman>And if they had disconnected, if they had formed a special session and disconnected earlier.

103
00:16:28.649 --> 00:16:28.778
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

104
00:16:29.710 --> 00:16:36.532
<v Peter Holzman>They could have actually impacted tax year, the previous tax year, and we wouldn't have felt it in the current year.

105
00:16:39.052 --> 00:16:50.416
<v Peter Holzman>And so as a reminder, current year revenues are expected to come in $17.1 million below the April 2025 forecast, which is less than the estimated impact of HR 1 on the current fiscal year.

106
00:16:51.042 --> 00:16:58.812
<v Peter Holzman>So I think it is fair to say that based on these estimates, had HR 1 not become law after the April 2025 forecast, there would be no current year deficit.

107
00:16:58.861 --> 00:16:58.961
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

108
00:17:00.245 --> 00:17:12.336
<v Peter Holzman>I do also think that this ties back to that opening slide on uncertainty because in April of last year, my number one concern was not federal tax policy of this kind, it was federal tax policy of the tariff kind.

109
00:17:12.964 --> 00:17:14.626
<v Peter Holzman>And that was my primary concern.

110
00:17:14.675 --> 00:17:22.925
<v Peter Holzman>And that kind of shows the range of potential outcomes of things that could disrupt the forecast is that it's not necessarily predictable what it could be.

111
00:17:25.426 --> 00:17:27.096
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

112
00:17:28.154 --> 00:17:31.573
<v Peter Holzman>And then I, I, since the slide is up, let me explain the rest of it.

113
00:17:31.765 --> 00:17:38.681
<v Peter Holzman>Um, first of all, the impact of HR 1 broken down by type is shown in the, the table below.

114
00:17:39.242 --> 00:17:46.239
<v Peter Holzman>You'll note that the bonus depreciation section is grayed out and that the totals at the bottom do not include that.

115
00:17:46.303 --> 00:17:52.416
<v Peter Holzman>That is because the state's partial federal disconnection disconnected from that provision specifically.

116
00:17:53.507 --> 00:17:58.570
<v Peter Holzman>So this March forecast update includes that disconnect.

117
00:17:59.036 --> 00:18:03.779
<v Peter Holzman>And the other, this is the business license tax forecast going forward.

118
00:18:03.844 --> 00:18:09.917
<v Peter Holzman>One of the reasons we are on track to get $220 million is in part related to the tariff story.

119
00:18:10.205 --> 00:18:21.825
<v Peter Holzman>The tariffs, while it did not have the impact I anticipated or may have anticipated, it did shift some revenue forward between fiscal years and also has reduced underlying liability.

120
00:18:22.048 --> 00:18:22.786
<v Peter Holzman>And so you'll see—.

121
00:18:22.851 --> 00:18:22.979
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

122
00:18:23.976 --> 00:18:30.040
<v Peter Holzman>That I'm actually anticipating and forecasting we collect less business license tax revenue next year.

123
00:18:32.279 --> 00:18:35.734
<v Peter Holzman>Next slide.

124
00:18:36.473 --> 00:18:41.054
<v Peter Holzman>So the March forecast is really an update.

125
00:18:41.150 --> 00:18:49.078
<v Peter Holzman>It's almost a changelog compared to the much longer and more detailed December forecast release.

126
00:18:50.115 --> 00:18:56.692
<v Peter Holzman>And so these are all of the changes that have occurred since the December forecast and they're rolled into this.

127
00:18:57.613 --> 00:19:08.246
<v Peter Holzman>On net, it is a positive, but there's a lot of, you know, canceling out of different effects.

128
00:19:08.342 --> 00:19:13.011
<v Peter Holzman>And so I'm just gonna hit on like the big ones and if there's any questions on any of them, please let me know.

129
00:19:14.064 --> 00:19:18.663
<v Peter Holzman>First of all, business license taxes, that is directly related to that $5.3 million.

130
00:19:18.712 --> 00:19:19.480
<v Peter Holzman>That is the federal disconnect.

131
00:19:19.528 --> 00:19:19.594
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

132
00:19:21.579 --> 00:19:22.509
<v Peter Holzman>$1 million more next year.

133
00:19:22.653 --> 00:19:23.695
<v Peter Holzman>That is in the forecast.

134
00:19:24.897 --> 00:19:29.193
<v Peter Holzman>You'll notice that there's negative $3 million on utility license and franchise fees.

135
00:19:29.450 --> 00:19:35.605
<v Peter Holzman>Last time I came here, I talked about the other category, the 150+ other utility franchises.

136
00:19:36.343 --> 00:19:43.717
<v Peter Holzman>And previously they had, or last fiscal year, we got $16 million from that group.

137
00:19:44.358 --> 00:19:50.182
<v Peter Holzman>I had previously had forecast $13 million because, you know, Some, we get back payments and things like that.

138
00:19:50.391 --> 00:19:52.207
<v Peter Holzman>We're on track for about $11 million.

139
00:19:52.480 --> 00:19:57.106
<v Peter Holzman>And so that is mostly me accounting for the current year tracking of utility license fees.

140
00:19:59.298 --> 00:20:07.278
<v Peter Holzman>Most of the other ones are smaller adjustments, but I'll also note that the current appropriation level or CAL, there's been expense reductions.

141
00:20:07.375 --> 00:20:19.727
<v Peter Holzman>The biggest one of those is that because of the ongoing cuts that we need to take, we no longer have to do a general fund transfer or a transfer to the general fund reserve to meet our 10% threshold.

142
00:20:20.645 --> 00:20:26.309
<v Peter Holzman>And so our 10% threshold doesn't change by the amount that was previously anticipated.

143
00:20:26.712 --> 00:20:28.554
<v Peter Holzman>And so we do not have to make that transfer anymore.

144
00:20:28.958 --> 00:20:35.003
<v Peter Holzman>The net of all of this is an improvement of $2.5 million in fiscal year '26-'27.

145
00:20:36.109 --> 00:20:40.385
<v Peter Holzman>Next slide.

146
00:20:40.805 --> 00:20:45.130
<v Peter Holzman>So this is what this all means in terms of the 5-year balanced forecast.

147
00:20:45.484 --> 00:20:49.901
<v Peter Holzman>As a reminder, this is, Current appropriation level, not current service level.

148
00:20:50.030 --> 00:20:53.856
<v Peter Holzman>My forecast by financial policy is current appropriation level.

149
00:20:55.819 --> 00:21:04.458
<v Peter Holzman>And that $50.1 million is made up of $35.6 million in ongoing cuts and $15.1 million in one-time cuts.

150
00:21:05.652 --> 00:21:11.913
<v Peter Holzman>I think the other thing I would flag on this is that it's balanced in fiscal year '27-'28.

151
00:21:11.979 --> 00:21:12.076
<v Raymond C. Lee>Okay.

152
00:21:12.705 --> 00:21:15.582
<v Peter Holzman>There's not a whole lot of room in '28-'29.

153
00:21:15.873 --> 00:21:18.845
<v Peter Holzman>The $1.8 million is a very thin gap.

154
00:21:20.250 --> 00:21:28.260
<v Peter Holzman>But the other piece of better news is that in fiscal year '29-'30, there is significantly more available revenue anticipated.

155
00:21:28.750 --> 00:21:32.372
<v Peter Holzman>This is largely due to pension obligation bonds falling off.

156
00:21:32.566 --> 00:21:34.248
<v Peter Holzman>We'll have completed paying those.

157
00:21:34.522 --> 00:21:36.414
<v Peter Holzman>And so that's $19 million of that.

158
00:21:37.772 --> 00:21:38.128
<v Peter Holzman>Next slide.

159
00:21:38.665 --> 00:21:40.492
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

160
00:21:42.061 --> 00:21:44.730
<v Peter Holzman>And then, so what's next?

161
00:21:45.214 --> 00:21:54.071
<v Peter Holzman>So this shows current year business license tax collections and what is anticipated for the rest of the year.

162
00:21:55.006 --> 00:22:04.304
<v Peter Holzman>You'll see the bump where we got the larger payments in September, October that were for prior years, possibly tariff related.

163
00:22:06.965 --> 00:22:23.619
<v Peter Holzman>What is next is that in May, if we get revenues above or below expectations significantly just for business license taxes, I will come to Council and basically give a revenue update on that in early May.

164
00:22:25.211 --> 00:22:31.288
<v Peter Holzman>At this time, I don't anticipate that happening, or if I do, it would be a relatively small positive amount.

165
00:22:31.673 --> 00:22:37.909
<v Peter Holzman>But going back to that first slide on uncertainty, it applies here as well.

166
00:22:38.894 --> 00:22:40.316
<v Peter Holzman>And then last slide.

167
00:22:42.028 --> 00:22:50.221
<v Peter Holzman>And finally, and just to circle back on the uncertainty question, these are a few recession probability odds that I grabbed.

168
00:22:50.398 --> 00:22:54.632
<v Peter Holzman>And I think 2 things I would note is that they're sort of all over the place.

169
00:22:55.914 --> 00:22:57.032
<v Peter Holzman>No one really can agree.

170
00:22:58.159 --> 00:23:00.048
<v Peter Holzman>Again, tying back to the uncertainty slide.

171
00:23:00.728 --> 00:23:05.737
<v Peter Holzman>And 2, a recession is not in anyone's baseline, which I think is important because it is not in mine either.

172
00:23:08.346 --> 00:23:13.166
<v Peter Holzman>And that may change in the coming months, and I hope it doesn't.

173
00:23:13.263 --> 00:23:21.613
<v Peter Holzman>But a little bit of good news, I guess, is that no one is expecting currently a recession.

174
00:23:22.863 --> 00:23:24.226
<v Peter Holzman>And that is all I have.

175
00:23:24.275 --> 00:23:24.404
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

176
00:23:25.506 --> 00:23:26.137
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Peter.

177
00:23:26.544 --> 00:23:26.867
<v Jonas Biery>Excellent.

178
00:23:26.949 --> 00:23:28.862
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, questions about the presentation?

179
00:23:28.910 --> 00:23:29.444
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

180
00:23:30.450 --> 00:23:30.644
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

181
00:23:30.693 --> 00:23:31.357
<v Mitch Green>I have 2 questions.

182
00:23:31.503 --> 00:23:32.623
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for the presentation, Peter.

183
00:23:34.961 --> 00:23:41.163
<v Mitch Green>I really appreciate that you led with the EPI or the, I'm sorry, Economic Policy Uncertainty Index.

184
00:23:41.290 --> 00:23:43.973
<v Mitch Green>I appreciated Councilor Pirtle-Guiney's questions.

185
00:23:44.038 --> 00:23:46.257
<v Mitch Green>I think I wanna make sure I connect the dots for folks.

186
00:23:46.792 --> 00:23:56.853
<v Mitch Green>Did you lead with that because It is a direct explanatory variable or perhaps a way to contextualize volatility in the BLT?

187
00:23:58.667 --> 00:24:00.078
<v Peter Holzman>It's primarily tied to BLT.

188
00:24:00.306 --> 00:24:00.874
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah.

189
00:24:01.182 --> 00:24:19.986
<v Peter Holzman>I think that's the most direct connection is there's a lot of aspects that influence business license taxes that are not necessarily in the city's control or have to do with anything, and it has to do more with international and national and federal tax policy or situations.

190
00:24:20.034 --> 00:24:22.309
<v Peter Holzman>And so that is a big reason why, yes.

191
00:24:22.854 --> 00:24:25.145
<v Mitch Green>Thanks for just level-setting that.

192
00:24:26.027 --> 00:24:37.259
<v Mitch Green>I think for all the good things that we're trying to do to bring folks back downtown to kind of activate stuff, we are facing that headwind of just a random variable shock almost every day.

193
00:24:37.965 --> 00:24:41.315
<v Mitch Green>I'm very concerned about the looming energy crisis.

194
00:24:41.892 --> 00:24:53.218
<v Mitch Green>Our stockpiles are pretty good in North America, if you look at Southeast Asia, that's an indication of what could be coming our way if this situation in the Middle East doesn't resolve itself very soon.

195
00:24:56.309 --> 00:24:57.606
<v Mitch Green>Dismal science, right?

196
00:24:59.230 --> 00:25:08.463
<v Mitch Green>The other question I have is the 20— if you go back to the slide that has the '26-'27 forecast, it might just be the table of numbers.

197
00:25:09.132 --> 00:25:09.636
<v Mitch Green>We'll do it.

198
00:25:09.946 --> 00:25:10.191
<v Raymond C. Lee>Okay.

199
00:25:10.962 --> 00:25:12.182
<v Mitch Green>I think there was— yeah, that one.

200
00:25:13.192 --> 00:25:22.483
<v Mitch Green>Um, does this forecast include the expected incremental revenue, uh, from the BLT that we're expected to get from the Moda Center transaction?

201
00:25:23.654 --> 00:25:23.943
<v Peter Holzman>No.

202
00:25:24.121 --> 00:25:25.132
<v Mitch Green>The Trailblazers transaction?

203
00:25:25.403 --> 00:25:25.565
<v Ruth Levine>No.

204
00:25:25.981 --> 00:25:26.270
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

205
00:25:26.703 --> 00:25:28.869
<v Mitch Green>Do we have a sense of how much that is expected to be?

206
00:25:28.934 --> 00:25:35.079
<v Mitch Green>Because I mean, it's a known value, it's a single transaction, so we should be able to know roughly what it is.

207
00:25:35.257 --> 00:25:37.326
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, Councilor, I'll jump in and answer that question.

208
00:25:37.583 --> 00:25:49.719
<v Jonas Biery>Um, I won't be able to give you a number for that because under taxpayer confidentiality law, we can't comment on tax liability of any specific taxpayer.

209
00:25:49.782 --> 00:26:01.339
<v Jonas Biery>So I know that's not a satisfactory answer, but from the advice from the city attorney is that we should not, from at least the seat I sit in, not codify a number on that.

210
00:26:02.125 --> 00:26:17.334
<v Mitch Green>I understand that you've got that guidance from the city attorney, but that law is designed to make sure that we're not revealing of a traded sector some competitive advantage, but there's just one— it's obvious that it's—.

211
00:26:17.383 --> 00:26:20.657
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, so let me— I'll answer the question this way without a number.

212
00:26:20.851 --> 00:26:31.959
<v Jonas Biery>I mean, I think the expectation is at some point a transaction will occur that will result in a tax liability that will, ergo, result in a large payment related to that.

213
00:26:35.309 --> 00:26:37.430
<v Mitch Green>That was reported in the press, right?

214
00:26:37.638 --> 00:26:39.260
<v Mitch Green>It was like $4.28 billion, right?

215
00:26:40.577 --> 00:26:43.726
<v Jonas Biery>I have heard numbers reported in the press, yeah.

216
00:26:43.871 --> 00:26:48.126
<v Jonas Biery>And I think there's some numbers that folks have done where they've— there's been numbers publicly stated and you can do the math.

217
00:26:48.704 --> 00:26:53.009
<v Jonas Biery>The reality is we don't know what that actual tax payment is until it comes in and it's audited.

218
00:26:53.861 --> 00:27:11.343
<v Jonas Biery>So I think there's a— there's been publicly discussed expectation, and we don't carry that in the forecast just as we, you know, any large— we can't predict any— the timeline or outcome of any specific large, you know, revenue income stream beyond what we see in the trending.

219
00:27:12.064 --> 00:27:22.355
<v Jonas Biery>So the expectation is, my understanding is that when that revenue stream comes in, is audited and verified and received in our coffers, then that amount is—.

220
00:27:22.531 --> 00:27:24.022
<v Mitch Green>We're not going to forecast it.

221
00:27:24.544 --> 00:27:26.181
<v Mitch Green>We're gonna wait for it to accrue.

222
00:27:27.779 --> 00:27:33.893
<v Mitch Green>And if it— is it generally true if a transaction happens in the current fiscal year, we could expect the revenue in the next fiscal year?

223
00:27:34.586 --> 00:27:35.636
<v Mitch Green>Is there that kind of a lag?

224
00:27:38.066 --> 00:27:48.786
<v Peter Holzman>The lag is not necessarily predictable, which is one of the reasons why I don't include it in the forecast because things can get challenged and—.

225
00:27:48.786 --> 00:27:59.621
<v Jonas Biery>And also possible that that could come in over, you know, More than one tax cycle depending on how, you know, it's structured by the property, by the individual taxpayer.

226
00:27:59.845 --> 00:28:01.403
<v Mitch Green>Okay, so thank you.

227
00:28:01.451 --> 00:28:03.411
<v Mitch Green>I think that's about all I needed to level set.

228
00:28:03.459 --> 00:28:06.558
<v Mitch Green>I just didn't know if that was already being assumed in here or not.

229
00:28:07.329 --> 00:28:16.518
<v Mitch Green>And so if we're going to talk about the uses of those funds, it's just I need to know if we're going to double count the use of those funds, if we're— if is it on balance sheet, is it off balance sheets?

230
00:28:16.566 --> 00:28:21.300
<v Mitch Green>But I think I understand what you're trying to thank you, Councilor Green.

231
00:28:21.478 --> 00:28:22.028
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

232
00:28:26.407 --> 00:28:27.525
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

233
00:28:28.270 --> 00:28:29.811
<v Loretta Smith>Peter, it's good to see you.

234
00:28:29.990 --> 00:28:30.461
<v Candace Avalos>Good to see you too.

235
00:28:33.875 --> 00:28:35.277
<v Loretta Smith>Um, franchise fees.

236
00:28:37.080 --> 00:28:37.483
<v Loretta Smith>We got it.

237
00:28:37.644 --> 00:28:43.073
<v Loretta Smith>We all got an email from PG&E that said that they were raising their, um, their rates.

238
00:28:44.212 --> 00:28:50.298
<v Loretta Smith>So since they're raising their rates, are we gonna raise our rates, our franchise fee rates to them?

239
00:28:52.105 --> 00:29:05.400
<v Peter Holzman>Yeah, so we don't raise the rates to them, but we get the— so if they increase fees by 5%, then that passes through to the city because we charge them 5% on their revenues.

240
00:29:06.076 --> 00:29:08.346
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, just curious.

241
00:29:10.348 --> 00:29:29.519
<v Loretta Smith>The other thing I see, the, the BLT was, uh, forecasted at $212 million, and now it's forecasted for March for $217 million, which is a nice jump from December, what we thought it was going to be.

242
00:29:30.555 --> 00:29:33.949
<v Loretta Smith>And we always have this conversation about when we need to fill a gap.

243
00:29:35.016 --> 00:29:36.779
<v Loretta Smith>The first thing that I hear from yes.

244
00:29:36.972 --> 00:29:42.196
<v Loretta Smith>From CBO and others and Jonas, we were down on BLT.

245
00:29:43.482 --> 00:29:47.204
<v Loretta Smith>But when I look at the numbers, it doesn't appear to look that way.

246
00:29:48.093 --> 00:29:54.373
<v Loretta Smith>It looks like we actually have increased our numbers in the BLT from the original forecast.

247
00:29:56.000 --> 00:30:05.178
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, so does that have a bigger impact on what— how much we're going to have for the general fund for our budget?

248
00:30:06.950 --> 00:30:07.111
<v Keith Wilson>Yes.

249
00:30:07.369 --> 00:30:10.604
<v Peter Holzman>And so let me rewind a little bit.

250
00:30:10.684 --> 00:30:16.103
<v Peter Holzman>That $5.3 million is directly connected to the federal disconnect.

251
00:30:16.329 --> 00:30:24.499
<v Peter Holzman>So since the state passed the partial federal disconnect, that is what was added back basically as that provision.

252
00:30:26.816 --> 00:30:29.299
<v Peter Holzman>And short answer is yes, that just directly.

253
00:30:29.430 --> 00:30:34.732
<v Peter Holzman>And this kind of, This slide goes through all of the changes of that.

254
00:30:35.503 --> 00:30:41.778
<v Peter Holzman>And the net is that it's $2.5 million better because some things got a little bit worse and some things got a little bit better.

255
00:30:41.875 --> 00:30:43.961
<v Peter Holzman>But on net, $2.5 million better.

256
00:30:44.851 --> 00:30:46.128
<v Loretta Smith>And I have 2 last questions.

257
00:30:49.241 --> 00:30:56.388
<v Loretta Smith>We're in such a global predicament right now, and we have started a couple different wars.

258
00:30:57.087 --> 00:31:01.835
<v Loretta Smith>Do you include that kind of thing when you're forecasting what's happening on the federal level?

259
00:31:01.883 --> 00:31:02.924
<v Loretta Smith>Because I'm really concerned.

260
00:31:03.086 --> 00:31:05.219
<v Loretta Smith>Every day I hear a different thing from our president.

261
00:31:06.436 --> 00:31:08.778
<v Loretta Smith>He's saying he's going to blow things up, blow up civilians.

262
00:31:08.858 --> 00:31:10.157
<v Loretta Smith>I mean, I don't know what he's going to do.

263
00:31:11.023 --> 00:31:13.589
<v Loretta Smith>We could wake up all dead tomorrow morning and not know it.

264
00:31:14.215 --> 00:31:21.336
<v Loretta Smith>But he concerns me in how we actually are able to keep our assets safe.

265
00:31:22.074 --> 00:31:22.651
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

266
00:31:23.511 --> 00:31:27.015
<v Loretta Smith>Improving instead of going up instead of going down.

267
00:31:28.814 --> 00:31:32.332
<v Peter Holzman>I hear your concern and I completely agree.

268
00:31:32.429 --> 00:31:34.247
<v Peter Holzman>And actually, could we go back to the first slide?

269
00:31:34.601 --> 00:31:35.067
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

270
00:31:35.808 --> 00:31:52.888
<v Peter Holzman>So that was kind of how I opened my presentation was talking about the massive amount of uncertainty that has been created both last April with tariffs, this April with geopolitical conflict, and also it just, Huge legs.

271
00:31:53.049 --> 00:31:53.675
<v Peter Holzman>Huge legs.

272
00:31:53.867 --> 00:31:56.019
<v Peter Holzman>And it is a real forecasting challenge.

273
00:31:57.144 --> 00:32:06.826
<v Peter Holzman>I don't include any specific scenarios like that in the forecast, in part because there are so many ways that anything could play out.

274
00:32:06.954 --> 00:32:13.666
<v Peter Holzman>And not just talking geopolitically, but also talking recession or AI bubble bursting or things along those lines.

275
00:32:14.823 --> 00:32:19.769
<v Peter Holzman>But that is one of the many ways that my forecast could go wrong.

276
00:32:20.298 --> 00:32:28.026
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, well, I appreciate it, and it's— although it's not where I would want it to be, but it is looking better.

277
00:32:29.990 --> 00:32:34.596
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah, thank you, Councilor Smith.

278
00:32:34.951 --> 00:32:36.001
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

279
00:32:37.844 --> 00:32:38.780
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

280
00:32:39.055 --> 00:32:54.126
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Um, I want to start with a question totally separate from anything we've talked about, um, on the forecast line, it says that your forecast on transient lodging taxes is down by $1 million.

281
00:32:55.268 --> 00:33:02.762
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that based on actuals that we've seen in the first quarter of the year, or is that based on projections for summer travel or something else?

282
00:33:02.892 --> 00:33:04.291
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>How concerned should we be?

283
00:33:06.170 --> 00:33:11.632
<v Peter Holzman>So I was projecting some growth in both occupancy and average room rates.

284
00:33:12.230 --> 00:33:13.669
<v Peter Holzman>I have not seen that growth.

285
00:33:13.983 --> 00:33:19.897
<v Peter Holzman>These in the most recent data, I've actually seen a slight decline is the most recent trend.

286
00:33:21.726 --> 00:33:26.665
<v Peter Holzman>And so I basically reduced the forecast to next year to be, it's the same as this year.

287
00:33:26.844 --> 00:33:27.538
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

288
00:33:27.634 --> 00:33:33.616
<v Peter Holzman>Until I see actual data that shows improving, then that will then flow into the forecast.

289
00:33:34.163 --> 00:33:35.451
<v Peter Holzman>How concerned should we be?

290
00:33:35.532 --> 00:33:38.142
<v Peter Holzman>There is a lot of factors that influence that.

291
00:33:38.351 --> 00:33:43.523
<v Peter Holzman>And I mean, a big one that I spoke about last time is reduced travel from Canada.

292
00:33:45.799 --> 00:33:46.138
<v Loretta Smith>There's—.

293
00:33:46.220 --> 00:33:52.026
<v Peter Holzman>And it's really hard to compare year to year sometimes as well because we have events at different times and things along those lines.

294
00:33:52.932 --> 00:34:03.442
<v Peter Holzman>In general, I wouldn't overweight a $1 million adjustment and worry necessarily about that.

295
00:34:03.506 --> 00:34:08.764
<v Peter Holzman>I would worry more about the longer-term trend, which is that the last 3 years there really hasn't been any improvement.

296
00:34:08.813 --> 00:34:08.927
<v Peter Holzman>Thank you.

297
00:34:10.543 --> 00:34:15.063
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And your projection that there might be, I think, has left folks a little optimistic.

298
00:34:15.110 --> 00:34:22.610
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And it sounds like we're not necessarily projecting a decrease at this time, but we are putting off the increase.

299
00:34:23.027 --> 00:34:27.449
<v Peter Holzman>Yeah, and as a reminder, summer travel is the biggest time for us.

300
00:34:27.594 --> 00:34:34.228
<v Peter Holzman>And so that, I think post-summer would be the time that I would update and potentially increase that forecast again.

301
00:34:35.304 --> 00:34:38.251
<v Jonas Biery>And Councilor, if I can just jump in and note too, I think it's important context.

302
00:34:40.630 --> 00:34:55.528
<v Jonas Biery>Peter's probably too modest, but I mean, a lot of work is spent collaborating with Peter's colleagues at the county, at Metro, PSU, the state, regionally to make sure that we're sort of sharing information about some of those expectations.

303
00:34:56.061 --> 00:35:00.922
<v Jonas Biery>For example, the VFTA, the Visitor Facilities Trust Account, relies heavily on that transient lodging tax.

304
00:35:01.523 --> 00:35:02.389
<v Jonas Biery>Revenue stream as well.

305
00:35:02.485 --> 00:35:09.480
<v Jonas Biery>And so there's a lot of activity to make sure that we're having that collective dialogue and being as informed as we can about those, those long-term assumptions.

306
00:35:10.731 --> 00:35:22.186
<v Dan Ryan>Can I just want to jump in for a sec to say that when I talk to people close to this issue, they say until the convention center accounts start going up again, that we're not in a good place.

307
00:35:22.619 --> 00:35:26.838
<v Dan Ryan>The majority of our lodging tax comes from big successful conventions.

308
00:35:27.577 --> 00:35:29.436
<v Dan Ryan>And they're struggling right now to book events.

309
00:35:29.581 --> 00:35:31.487
<v Dan Ryan>They're looking better about 2 to 3 years out.

310
00:35:31.697 --> 00:35:32.706
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, that's a trailing indicator.

311
00:35:32.818 --> 00:35:35.047
<v Dan Ryan>They're in kind of a very deep valley at the moment.

312
00:35:35.206 --> 00:35:37.947
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yeah, that's a trailing indicator because they book so far out.

313
00:35:37.996 --> 00:35:40.528
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'm saying this so it's on the record in this conversation.

314
00:35:40.577 --> 00:35:50.836
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>They book so far out that what we're seeing now are things that for the most part were booked 2 or 3 or 4 years ago, except for the small things that book just a year out.

315
00:35:51.333 --> 00:35:52.039
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we're still seeing—.

316
00:35:52.039 --> 00:35:58.143
<v Dan Ryan>Luckily, we got a lot of bookings in 2019, and we still lived off a little bit of that, but we have not done well since.

317
00:35:58.192 --> 00:36:05.918
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We now have the tail from 2021 and 2022 that we're experiencing, and we expect that to tick up in the next couple of years.

318
00:36:06.342 --> 00:36:06.927
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

319
00:36:07.577 --> 00:36:09.804
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, next question.

320
00:36:13.202 --> 00:36:13.398
<v Olivia Clark>The—.

321
00:36:13.851 --> 00:36:19.445
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>You mentioned that the projections are based on CAL, not current service level.

322
00:36:20.567 --> 00:36:27.684
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And we have an increase in the expected CAL on the slide after this.

323
00:36:28.922 --> 00:36:41.650
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>If we were looking at current service level instead, and I'm just, I'm still a year in wrapping my head around how we do our projections and how this new CSL fits in with CAL that we still rely on.

324
00:36:44.349 --> 00:36:48.989
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>When we think about CSL and how these projections could be affected by that.

325
00:36:49.760 --> 00:37:08.451
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do you project the angle of the CSL line to divert and continue to get farther from Cal, or do you project CSL to be higher than Cal but maintain the same angle as it increases into the future?

326
00:37:09.860 --> 00:37:11.945
<v Peter Holzman>I understand the question.

327
00:37:12.443 --> 00:37:20.204
<v Peter Holzman>I will say I don't project anything with current service levels because it's Council adopted as one time.

328
00:37:21.184 --> 00:37:23.773
<v Peter Holzman>And yes, I think Ruth is probably better to answer this one.

329
00:37:27.519 --> 00:37:27.876
<v Ruth Levine>Sorry.

330
00:37:31.974 --> 00:37:32.961
<v Ruth Levine>Ruth Levine, for the record.

331
00:37:33.577 --> 00:37:34.646
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't have your mic yet.

332
00:37:34.775 --> 00:37:35.456
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>It's still red.

333
00:37:37.518 --> 00:37:37.916
<v Angelita Morillo>There we go.

334
00:37:38.400 --> 00:37:38.715
<v Ruth Levine>Thank you.

335
00:37:39.527 --> 00:37:41.067
<v Ruth Levine>Ruth Levine, for the record, budget director.

336
00:37:43.369 --> 00:38:08.327
<v Ruth Levine>I mean, I think it really depends ultimately on quite a few variables that, you know, things like, you know, the cost of labor negotiations, the cost of health benefits going into the future, that will be in Cal going forward.

337
00:38:10.750 --> 00:38:18.945
<v Ruth Levine>Choices around things like things we buy with our internal service funds, money.

338
00:38:19.074 --> 00:38:20.913
<v Ruth Levine>So all of those will impact it.

339
00:38:24.929 --> 00:38:29.554
<v Ruth Levine>I think the— it's really hard to say.

340
00:38:29.635 --> 00:38:37.097
<v Ruth Levine>There's also So this like kind of step function in the gap, right, from the one-time money, like the gap, the line is really higher above it.

341
00:38:37.612 --> 00:38:42.039
<v Ruth Levine>So I think it's, um, hard to say.

342
00:38:42.423 --> 00:38:46.788
<v Ruth Levine>The part I can speak to is that we're trying to capture more.

343
00:38:47.012 --> 00:38:57.512
<v Ruth Levine>So things like the Internal Service Fund rates, we're trying to do a better job at capturing those so that that doesn't surprise us as like a gap between Cal and current service level.

344
00:38:59.630 --> 00:39:09.293
<v Ruth Levine>But I think going forward, the— this forecast for Cal on the total expense line will inevitably increase in the out years.

345
00:39:09.391 --> 00:39:18.994
<v Ruth Levine>But to some extent, that is, you know, impacted by council decisions that you all have control over.

346
00:39:19.074 --> 00:39:39.351
<v Ruth Levine>I think some of the external variable risks to the forecast are more on like the health fund, on the health benefits side, just with the cost of claims and things like risk insurance rates, things that we don't have as much control over as a city.

347
00:39:39.530 --> 00:39:41.318
<v Ruth Levine>Those are kind of the main risks there.

348
00:39:41.478 --> 00:39:42.204
<v Ruth Levine>But yeah.

349
00:39:42.525 --> 00:39:56.666
<v Jonas Biery>And apologies to keep jumping in, but I also would just note that the delta between those two, the sort of the legacy, you know, there were very good reasons why Cal was established in policy as the baseline, you know, 20-plus years ago.

350
00:39:57.954 --> 00:39:59.034
<v Jonas Biery>And the world has changed.

351
00:39:59.161 --> 00:40:04.507
<v Jonas Biery>And so I mentioned up at the top the kind of 5-year stabilization plan project.

352
00:40:04.554 --> 00:40:25.179
<v Jonas Biery>And this is an example of one of the types of things I think might be a topic of that work is to identify how do we, you know, better align in a policy and practice perspective so that we don't necessarily have 2 separate and competing sets of assumptions to facilitate making these decisions and making it a little more clear to support transparency in decision-making.

353
00:40:25.980 --> 00:40:27.134
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

354
00:40:27.197 --> 00:40:28.351
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll look forward to seeing that.

355
00:40:29.025 --> 00:40:31.172
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Final question on the same slide.

356
00:40:31.829 --> 00:40:46.777
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>In '29-'30, you talked about a— I'm not going to call it significant, but a meaningful increase in available ongoing revenue based on some pension obligation bonds fulfilling.

357
00:40:48.469 --> 00:40:57.858
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Is that $25.6 million accounted for in the $830.3 cal in 2030-31?

358
00:40:58.838 --> 00:41:09.054
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Or if that $25.6 million is fully allocated, will we have a deficit in 2030-31?

359
00:41:10.744 --> 00:41:11.498
<v Peter Holzman>Great question.

360
00:41:11.706 --> 00:41:13.853
<v Peter Holzman>That gets into the weeds of how this table's constructed.

361
00:41:14.574 --> 00:41:26.740
<v Peter Holzman>It is basically assumed that that $25.6 million will be allocated to ongoing programming, and that makes up the $830.3 million, includes that.

362
00:41:26.789 --> 00:41:29.161
<v Peter Holzman>So there is no new deficit.

363
00:41:29.418 --> 00:41:36.838
<v Peter Holzman>It's that we will not only— And that's how the balancing works is that it needs to be balanced over all 5 years.

364
00:41:37.512 --> 00:41:57.318
<v Peter Holzman>And so yes, at this time, if there are no new labor agreements, no new ongoing costs, and current appropriation levels hold like that and revenues hold like that, we will be allocating $25.6 million of new revenue, of new ongoing in '29-'30, largely related to pension obligation bonds.

365
00:41:57.557 --> 00:42:00.393
<v Peter Holzman>I will say there's a lot of ifs in that statement, but—.

366
00:42:00.490 --> 00:42:03.679
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>A lot of ifs that we know will not actually be negatives.

367
00:42:04.056 --> 00:42:04.480
<v Peter Holzman>Probably.

368
00:42:04.561 --> 00:42:06.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those things will all happen or change.

369
00:42:07.817 --> 00:42:22.615
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But under the projections, which is all we can work with, the neutral $0 million available ongoing in 2030-31 means that we have allocated the $25.6 million to ongoing program.

370
00:42:22.775 --> 00:42:27.644
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We don't have anything new extra in '30-'31, but we're not running a deficit from that allocation.

371
00:42:28.077 --> 00:42:34.579
<v Peter Holzman>Yeah, and I'll just say me putting the $8.2 million in one-time versus ongoing is just a choice.

372
00:42:34.740 --> 00:42:47.849
<v Peter Holzman>I could have put that in ongoing as well, but because I don't project out the next 5 years, uh, I— it feels incorrect, like an incorrect assumption to put it in ongoing because I don't know if I— the next 5 years of revenue can support it.

373
00:42:48.445 --> 00:42:49.476
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay, thank you.

374
00:42:50.206 --> 00:42:51.242
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

375
00:42:51.664 --> 00:42:52.701
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

376
00:42:52.815 --> 00:42:53.431
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

377
00:42:55.391 --> 00:42:56.364
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council President.

378
00:42:57.742 --> 00:43:00.809
<v Dan Ryan>I saw your email and eventually we'll get to the priorities, right?

379
00:43:00.873 --> 00:43:01.291
<v Candace Avalos>Mm-hmm.

380
00:43:01.420 --> 00:43:04.293
<v Dan Ryan>This question is looking at expenses.

381
00:43:04.565 --> 00:43:04.822
<v Dan Ryan>There it is.

382
00:43:04.887 --> 00:43:06.155
<v Dan Ryan>I guess the slide is up.

383
00:43:06.974 --> 00:43:09.831
<v Dan Ryan>We're spending more time on revenue 'cause that's what you focus on.

384
00:43:10.650 --> 00:43:16.494
<v Dan Ryan>Now I see your friend up there, Jonas, who has more, he sees everything of course.

385
00:43:17.313 --> 00:43:24.286
<v Dan Ryan>But on the expense side, I started to get a little bit like yours is definitely, A forecast.

386
00:43:24.416 --> 00:43:25.548
<v Dan Ryan>It's an economic forecast.

387
00:43:25.597 --> 00:43:30.998
<v Dan Ryan>Everything you said, I was a minor in economics, a minor, so I kind of followed everything you were saying.

388
00:43:31.128 --> 00:43:32.016
<v Dan Ryan>So yes, true.

389
00:43:32.485 --> 00:43:36.338
<v Dan Ryan>On the expense side, it's usually a little bit more certain, I would think.

390
00:43:36.822 --> 00:43:41.865
<v Dan Ryan>And Jonas, I'm not tracking what I'm seeing here.

391
00:43:42.414 --> 00:43:48.623
<v Dan Ryan>So next year you have one number and then it goes down quite a bit.

392
00:43:48.688 --> 00:43:48.737
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

393
00:43:49.675 --> 00:43:54.150
<v Dan Ryan>In '27-'28, and then it jumps back up again.

394
00:43:57.556 --> 00:43:59.092
<v Dan Ryan>I'm tracking that.

395
00:43:59.206 --> 00:44:04.304
<v Dan Ryan>I'm trying to figure out, were those numbers that you're really attached to talking about right now, or is this too soon?

396
00:44:07.561 --> 00:44:09.507
<v Peter Holzman>So for that first—.

397
00:44:09.507 --> 00:44:12.557
<v Dan Ryan>Is this still the economist that will talk about our expenses?

398
00:44:12.978 --> 00:44:17.900
<v Peter Holzman>Yeah, and just because this table's my fault, That's right.

399
00:44:18.061 --> 00:44:23.494
<v Peter Holzman>So the— I think you're looking at the total expenses CAL line.

400
00:44:23.927 --> 00:44:33.465
<v Peter Holzman>That is before the decisions that you will make or Council will make, which includes that $35.6 million of ongoing cuts.

401
00:44:33.545 --> 00:44:42.056
<v Peter Holzman>If you look at the bottom line, that is where we need to be in terms of what the available resources will support.

402
00:44:42.826 --> 00:44:58.550
<v Peter Holzman>The total expenses after accounting for adds, cuts, and one-time spending, and I probably should have made that more clear, is $742.5 million, which is the amount of revenue that is anticipated for fiscal year '26-'27.

403
00:44:59.079 --> 00:45:04.413
<v Peter Holzman>So it's total expenses before ongoing reductions.

404
00:45:04.990 --> 00:45:14.349
<v Peter Holzman>And then the line at the bottom is after the ongoing reductions, and that's where you get you made sense.

405
00:45:14.570 --> 00:45:21.449
<v Dan Ryan>And the exercise, when I looked at it, it looked like, well, we had to match our expenses 'cause we have to balance our budget unlike the federal government.

406
00:45:21.610 --> 00:45:25.579
<v Dan Ryan>And so we did that exercise by balancing it.

407
00:45:25.590 --> 00:45:33.110
<v Dan Ryan>But this presentation's been explaining our revenue side, but we haven't explained our expense side.

408
00:45:33.110 --> 00:45:33.989
<v Dan Ryan>That's all.

409
00:45:33.989 --> 00:45:36.110
<v Dan Ryan>And I don't need to do that here, but I But think it's important to understand to that.

410
00:45:36.110 --> 00:45:36.150
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

411
00:45:36.157 --> 00:45:42.722
<v Dan Ryan>Me it just felt like we were filling in the cell on the spreadsheet to make sure it matched the revenue that comes in.

412
00:45:44.460 --> 00:45:49.829
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, Councilor, to some degree, I mean, the words you just said are true, right?

413
00:45:49.992 --> 00:45:51.155
<v Dan Ryan>That's all I can go from.

414
00:45:51.431 --> 00:45:56.503
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, we forecast the revenues and then we have to build a budget that fits within the expected resources we have.

415
00:45:57.036 --> 00:46:01.635
<v Jonas Biery>Ergo, in this year, a reduction to get to the $742 million.

416
00:46:01.764 --> 00:46:13.610
<v Jonas Biery>And then just to be clear, you know, The $767,000 in '27-'28 is an increase above that $742,000 number for the current year.

417
00:46:13.610 --> 00:46:14.630
<v Jonas Biery>Does that make sense?

418
00:46:14.630 --> 00:46:36.054
<v Jonas Biery>So it's not— it does show revenues are continuing to increase from $742,000 in '26-'27 to a projected $767,000 in '27-'28, et cetera, based upon CAL specifically and the sort of technical vagaries of how that Is that helpful?

419
00:46:37.601 --> 00:46:42.989
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, I don't think I'm going to take any more of our time up on the expense side.

420
00:46:43.121 --> 00:46:45.414
<v Dan Ryan>I think we're going to have plenty of time to dive into that.

421
00:46:46.811 --> 00:46:47.472
<v Dan Ryan>So I'll let it go.

422
00:46:48.639 --> 00:46:52.628
<v Dan Ryan>But I think today's presentation from our economist is about the revenue.

423
00:46:54.280 --> 00:46:55.099
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

424
00:46:55.150 --> 00:46:56.722
<v Dan Ryan>And I will make more comments on that later.

425
00:46:57.844 --> 00:46:58.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes, sir.

426
00:46:58.878 --> 00:46:59.056
<v Candace Avalos>Great.

427
00:46:59.362 --> 00:47:00.396
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

428
00:47:00.572 --> 00:47:01.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Smith.

429
00:47:01.784 --> 00:47:02.139
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

430
00:47:02.284 --> 00:47:05.094
<v Loretta Smith>I want to piggyback on what, um, Councilor Ryan was talking about.

431
00:47:05.858 --> 00:47:22.628
<v Loretta Smith>Um, when we were in the previous committees, um, I was the chair of the Labor and Workforce Committee, and there were 450, um, people who are current employees that were eligible for, um, full 30-year retirement.

432
00:47:23.934 --> 00:47:33.800
<v Loretta Smith>Are there any policies that, um, that we have around retirement and being at full retirement and what that looks like?

433
00:47:34.282 --> 00:47:52.463
<v Loretta Smith>I know that's a huge deal because we have to pay out vacation time on all those employees and convert some of their sick time into time that we have to pay, but just in terms of expenses It would be helpful to see what those expenses are.

434
00:47:52.737 --> 00:47:55.543
<v Loretta Smith>Are they FTE expenses?

435
00:47:56.690 --> 00:48:01.239
<v Loretta Smith>Are they external services, internal services?

436
00:48:01.304 --> 00:48:04.579
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just trying to figure out where that count is.

437
00:48:05.161 --> 00:48:13.539
<v Loretta Smith>And the other thing I would really like to see, I've been asking about it, but I'd like to see, and I think this number reflects it, but I just don't know what the breakout is.

438
00:48:13.619 --> 00:48:13.782
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

439
00:48:15.114 --> 00:48:20.307
<v Loretta Smith>Of our debt service over the 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 next 5 years.

440
00:48:20.371 --> 00:48:34.271
<v Loretta Smith>It would be great just to see when does debt service drop off and how does that impact these, uh, total, um, total expenses and total resources, just so that I can see what, what it looks like.

441
00:48:34.400 --> 00:48:36.536
<v Loretta Smith>What are we paying in total debt service right now?

442
00:48:38.255 --> 00:48:42.128
<v Peter Holzman>Let me, let me take the, the second question and then I'll pass it to the first.

443
00:48:42.208 --> 00:48:48.967
<v Peter Holzman>So the, the debt service I have been including, and I, I should I should start including in presentations because it's a question I get asked a lot.

444
00:48:49.530 --> 00:48:50.798
<v Peter Holzman>The general fund debt service.

445
00:48:50.960 --> 00:48:51.072
<v Loretta Smith>Yes.

446
00:48:51.121 --> 00:48:52.695
<v Peter Holzman>So I have a table that breaks that down.

447
00:48:52.824 --> 00:49:01.548
<v Peter Holzman>And as I mentioned, a big reason why we have available resource in '29-'30 is related to debt service falling off.

448
00:49:01.838 --> 00:49:07.735
<v Loretta Smith>And that's what I was thinking that was, but I didn't see where that was coming from.

449
00:49:07.927 --> 00:49:11.028
<v Loretta Smith>And that was gonna be my next question is that big jump.

450
00:49:11.222 --> 00:49:16.663
<v Loretta Smith>In '29-'30, a debt service, lack thereof debt service.

451
00:49:16.983 --> 00:49:24.302
<v Peter Holzman>Yeah, so it's related to about $19 million of pension obligation bonds falling off and then just a little bit of other revenue.

452
00:49:24.543 --> 00:49:25.635
<v Peter Holzman>But that's the big piece.

453
00:49:26.614 --> 00:49:28.364
<v Peter Holzman>And I can get you that table.

454
00:49:28.797 --> 00:49:32.248
<v Peter Holzman>We do a lot more debt service than just what's in the general fund.

455
00:49:32.344 --> 00:49:34.431
<v Peter Holzman>I mean, the Water Bureau and all those do that, but—.

456
00:49:34.480 --> 00:49:36.036
<v Loretta Smith>But I would like to see that too.

457
00:49:36.405 --> 00:49:39.438
<v Loretta Smith>I'd like to see the total debt service even in the restricted funds.

458
00:49:40.596 --> 00:49:41.494
<v Loretta Smith>Because that's important.

459
00:49:41.559 --> 00:49:44.545
<v Loretta Smith>That helps me to understand if there are things that are going on.

460
00:49:44.594 --> 00:49:46.297
<v Loretta Smith>It's not just this.

461
00:49:46.360 --> 00:49:59.353
<v Loretta Smith>This is a pension obligation fund, but the debt service that's in those big departments like the water, transportation, parks, those kind of things.

462
00:50:00.172 --> 00:50:03.192
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, yeah, Councilor, we certainly have that information.

463
00:50:03.384 --> 00:50:09.005
<v Jonas Biery>It's published in a few different places at various points throughout the year and happy to redirect you to those.

464
00:50:10.498 --> 00:50:10.916
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

465
00:50:11.141 --> 00:50:14.172
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

466
00:50:14.849 --> 00:50:15.461
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

467
00:50:16.380 --> 00:50:16.653
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

468
00:50:16.847 --> 00:50:22.202
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a few things that I think have come up that I wanna make sure there's room to discuss in the appropriate space.

469
00:50:22.266 --> 00:50:26.302
<v Sameer Kanal>So just mentioning for the future, I think there's a conversation about internal rates.

470
00:50:26.447 --> 00:50:32.427
<v Sameer Kanal>There's a conversation around trying to anticipate what our long-term paths on a few of these things are.

471
00:50:32.911 --> 00:50:34.940
<v Sameer Kanal>But one thing I wanted to circle back to that Yeah.

472
00:50:35.005 --> 00:50:38.809
<v Sameer Kanal>My colleague asked about here was the transient lodging tax.

473
00:50:40.449 --> 00:50:43.632
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you can go back to that slide, I'd really appreciate it.

474
00:50:43.713 --> 00:50:55.942
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so this one shows the reduction in the forecast, but as part of the conversation, Councilor Ryan mentioned that there's a conversation specific to the convention center.

475
00:50:56.233 --> 00:51:13.101
<v Sameer Kanal>What I'd love to know is how that data can be broken down further to understand geographically, size of hotel, whatever sort of information that that can be broken down on at least those 2 levels.

476
00:51:13.150 --> 00:51:14.605
<v Sameer Kanal>If there's other levels, that would be helpful.

477
00:51:16.621 --> 00:51:32.394
<v Sameer Kanal>As a person with event planning experience, including here in Portland, I can say that there is a lot of— kind of actually similar to many of our other problems We have incentives to come here for the first time, but not a lot to help you when you're already here.

478
00:51:33.907 --> 00:51:36.773
<v Sameer Kanal>And we also don't have a lot of help for event planners who are trying to scale.

479
00:51:38.369 --> 00:51:43.942
<v Sameer Kanal>So this is a challenge that I think could be highlighted.

480
00:51:44.199 --> 00:51:53.748
<v Sameer Kanal>I was intending to talk about this in the earlier conversation today, but obviously we went over time to try and use some of the TLT money that we're already collecting.

481
00:51:54.115 --> 00:52:01.239
<v Sameer Kanal>To reinvest into helping some of our events who like to stay here continue to do that.

482
00:52:01.431 --> 00:52:07.447
<v Sameer Kanal>Because if it's actually— the parallels to other conversations are really high here.

483
00:52:07.992 --> 00:52:11.554
<v Sameer Kanal>If we're able to bring in some new business but maintain all of it, we will do better.

484
00:52:11.844 --> 00:52:16.480
<v Sameer Kanal>Whereas if we are bringing in new business but we are losing our existing business, we will be spinning our wheels.

485
00:52:16.929 --> 00:52:19.463
<v Sameer Kanal>So I would love to understand that a little bit better.

486
00:52:19.625 --> 00:52:25.512
<v Peter Holzman>Is that Yes, there is revenue by location.

487
00:52:25.626 --> 00:52:30.498
<v Peter Holzman>It's normally split between like 4 business areas, 4 or 5.

488
00:52:31.434 --> 00:52:37.079
<v Peter Holzman>The big ones tend to be around the airport and downtown and then other areas related.

489
00:52:38.632 --> 00:52:47.492
<v Peter Holzman>I believe our revenue division can get more granular, but the convention center also, we have pretty good data on that too as well.

490
00:52:47.557 --> 00:52:47.623
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

491
00:52:47.806 --> 00:53:15.922
<v Jonas Biery>Yeah, I was just going to add, as part of the VFTA, the Visitor Facilities Trust Account, those projections which are managed by the county, the collector of the transient lodging tax has a breakout for it specific to the convention center hotel, but the revenues that they collect under that broader tax, TLT, regional TLT, and a forecast that's a little more tied to projected activity at the convention center.

492
00:53:15.985 --> 00:53:22.619
<v Jonas Biery>And so that's a really good proxy of expectations relative to convention center activity over the next few years.

493
00:53:22.668 --> 00:53:24.402
<v Jonas Biery>And so that's certainly something that's available.

494
00:53:24.514 --> 00:53:30.184
<v Jonas Biery>And then, yeah, happy to explore getting additional data by other disaggregation.

495
00:53:31.244 --> 00:53:32.753
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, that'd be super helpful.

496
00:53:33.572 --> 00:53:54.307
<v Sameer Kanal>I think over time it would be something that might be worth trying to develop more tools for that to understand, because there is a difference between an event, some, you know, meeting space revenue from bookings that include a meeting space component or not, I guess, is the question I'm looking at there.

497
00:53:55.387 --> 00:53:56.626
<v Sameer Kanal>The other thing I wanted to mention—.

498
00:53:56.626 --> 00:54:00.748
<v Dan Ryan>Mr. Kanal, while we're on this, I'm used to work sessions being a little more conversation.

499
00:54:00.813 --> 00:54:01.199
<v Dan Ryan>Is that okay?

500
00:54:01.376 --> 00:54:03.469
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm glad that we're having this dialogue.

501
00:54:03.619 --> 00:54:17.110
<v Dan Ryan>The reason I wanted to bring that up earlier is because when I was with a group of hotel, motel owners and managers and restaurateurs, I wanted to hear how exciting March Madness was 'cause I saw a lot of tourists here.

502
00:54:17.913 --> 00:54:29.141
<v Dan Ryan>And they said they experienced a little bit of bump, but they all agreed that it was mostly around the big conventions that influenced their numbers more so than a big sporting event for a few days.

503
00:54:30.121 --> 00:54:30.974
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, that makes sense.

504
00:54:31.021 --> 00:54:36.545
<v Dan Ryan>And so I think that we're onto something that we really need to stay tuned with, um, the convention center data.

505
00:54:37.025 --> 00:54:39.610
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, I think, um, we, we talk a little bit about—.

506
00:54:39.610 --> 00:54:41.713
<v Dan Ryan>And then summer travels is down.

507
00:54:42.081 --> 00:54:42.273
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes.

508
00:54:42.322 --> 00:54:46.382
<v Dan Ryan>And some of it now we're, we're experiencing at the, at the, at the gas station, if you will.

509
00:54:46.590 --> 00:54:48.967
<v Dan Ryan>But, um, it's also for other reasons.

510
00:54:49.784 --> 00:54:53.893
<v Dan Ryan>And I think our reputation is down, so people don't travel here like they used to.

511
00:54:54.038 --> 00:54:54.936
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think the, the reputation—.

512
00:54:54.936 --> 00:54:56.380
<v Dan Ryan>And they all talked about that.

513
00:54:56.766 --> 00:55:18.724
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, is going to— it's going to be a trailing indicator in both But it's going to be more— the trail will be longer for events, but we will see it manifest more quickly in people who might be in Spokane and choosing, or somewhere, you know, broader regionally, and might be choosing whether to spend a weekend in Seattle or a weekend here or a weekend in San Francisco, that kind of thing.

514
00:55:19.483 --> 00:55:23.597
<v Sameer Kanal>Which is why I think that separation of meeting space versus not.

515
00:55:23.695 --> 00:55:28.157
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's interesting that you mentioned the sports piece because that might be a sort of Yeah.

516
00:55:28.237 --> 00:55:34.998
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that's a third category that otherwise gets lost in the sauce with the things that— with the larger events.

517
00:55:35.045 --> 00:55:44.695
<v Sameer Kanal>Because often if a sports team is coming here, they'll book a meeting room to do a group meal or something, even though the primary purpose of their visit is not to do an event in the hotel.

518
00:55:45.081 --> 00:55:48.983
<v Sameer Kanal>But instead, that's just a secondary thing before they go to the arena or something.

519
00:55:49.353 --> 00:55:53.478
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think those are— whatever we can do there would be helpful.

520
00:55:53.981 --> 00:56:06.507
<v Sameer Kanal>The other thing, I read the OPB article that I think you were referencing about Canadian tourists, which by the way is 3.5 times the second biggest chunk of our international visitors by dollars.

521
00:56:08.190 --> 00:56:09.815
<v Sameer Kanal>29%, I believe, was the stat.

522
00:56:10.137 --> 00:56:19.273
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also know that maybe more than any other location, there's a component of exchange rates.

523
00:56:20.835 --> 00:56:21.188
<v Sameer Kanal>To this.

524
00:56:21.333 --> 00:56:35.199
<v Sameer Kanal>And so I'd love to understand not only in the context of other, the sort of new and emerging terrible things that might affect our relationships with the rest of the world, but the existing ongoing things that might be good or bad on a given day.

525
00:56:35.601 --> 00:56:43.592
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously, if the Canadian dollar is stronger, then they will have more purchasing power to come here or wherever they might go in the United States.

526
00:56:44.507 --> 00:56:46.978
<v Sameer Kanal>So I would love to understand that a little bit better.

527
00:56:47.139 --> 00:56:48.648
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't know if that's something that falls into your purview.

528
00:56:48.760 --> 00:56:48.889
<v Steve Novick>It does.

529
00:56:48.985 --> 00:57:07.782
<v Sameer Kanal>Shop in the slightest, or if it's something that might be— and part of the reason I'm asking you this question is I have yet to get a straight answer as to who owns the tourism portion, because I keep getting Prospera Travel Portland, or— but who in the city owns this is a question I don't get a straight answer to ever.

530
00:57:08.375 --> 00:57:11.210
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, and that's not on you at all, that's, that's more this box.

531
00:57:11.498 --> 00:57:22.074
<v Sameer Kanal>But I'd love to understand if that data exists anywhere, or who would be the, the person My interaction would be with how that impacted our TLT revenues.

532
00:57:22.266 --> 00:57:24.594
<v Peter Holzman>But beyond that, I don't know.

533
00:57:24.820 --> 00:57:37.621
<v Peter Holzman>And I would say that it would be very hard to pull out that specifically from the broader TLT conversation, separate of the tourism question you asked.

534
00:57:38.070 --> 00:57:39.806
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that's super helpful.

535
00:57:41.925 --> 00:57:48.860
<v Sameer Kanal>Either the mayor or the city administrator may have any information on who should I be going to in the administration to talk about tourism.

536
00:57:50.766 --> 00:57:51.769
<v Keith Wilson>Sure, Council President.

537
00:57:51.898 --> 00:58:00.764
<v Keith Wilson>I sit on the Visitors Development Fund, and it's primarily a Travel Portland-generated table, and it has county, metro, and the city.

538
00:58:00.878 --> 00:58:06.206
<v Keith Wilson>And we're talking about how do we bring in or attract conventions and other tourists and such.

539
00:58:06.335 --> 00:58:07.608
<v Keith Wilson>So there is that table.

540
00:58:07.657 --> 00:58:17.686
<v Keith Wilson>It's It's just, I think Councilor Ryan hit it, reputationally we're in that sort of doldrums, and then also nationally we're just not a destination for international travelers right now.

541
00:58:17.750 --> 00:58:18.630
<v Sameer Kanal>But we're working at it.

542
00:58:18.710 --> 00:58:21.179
<v Keith Wilson>I mean, we are definitely talking about it often.

543
00:58:22.222 --> 00:58:22.990
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that.

544
00:58:23.039 --> 00:58:23.809
<v Sameer Kanal>That's all good news.

545
00:58:24.081 --> 00:58:27.576
<v Sameer Kanal>But who in the administration owns it?

546
00:58:27.704 --> 00:58:29.018
<v Sameer Kanal>Because that's Travel Portland.

547
00:58:29.371 --> 00:58:30.556
<v Sameer Kanal>That's the mayor's office.

548
00:58:31.679 --> 00:58:34.885
<v Sameer Kanal>Maybe there's council involvement that I'm not aware of, but I'd love to be a part of that.

549
00:58:35.382 --> 00:58:35.639
<v Dan Ryan>That's a—.

550
00:58:35.880 --> 00:58:37.036
<v Sameer Kanal>My background has a lot of that.

551
00:58:37.085 --> 00:58:38.771
<v Sameer Kanal>So if so, but yeah.

552
00:58:39.077 --> 00:58:47.943
<v Raymond C. Lee>I know mostly it'll be in our Community and Economic Development portfolio under Donnie Oliveira, who would be responsible for that information.

553
00:58:48.409 --> 00:58:57.018
<v Raymond C. Lee>Since there is a group, a combination of different entities that are housing that information, he would be the main point person for us to gather that.

554
00:58:57.405 --> 00:59:06.228
<v Raymond C. Lee>I'm not for sure if we have a main focal point in our city as a person or division within our city that is tracking that type of information.

555
00:59:06.612 --> 00:59:10.637
<v Raymond C. Lee>Typically, that's more in your economic development arm of your organization.

556
00:59:10.701 --> 00:59:13.682
<v Raymond C. Lee>That is with, uh, in our case, is with Prosper.

557
00:59:14.612 --> 00:59:26.186
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, so that's, that's something that I'd like to see an in-house conversation with because it's— I don't want to be in situations where it's counting on someone who happens to agree or, or putting a request into the void.

558
00:59:28.000 --> 00:59:34.498
<v Sameer Kanal>And often in the conversation around tourism, I've been— this is an over a year-long set of questions that I've been having there.

559
00:59:34.596 --> 00:59:36.601
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't want to get too far afield.

560
00:59:37.403 --> 00:59:39.731
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll have the Committee of the Whole to talk about all this stuff later.

561
00:59:40.853 --> 00:59:45.041
<v Sameer Kanal>But there was a thread leading off from the TLT here.

562
00:59:45.668 --> 00:59:53.498
<v Sameer Kanal>I guess what I'm trying to say is, and I'm grateful for having a mayor who speaks positively about our city, something that we have not always had.

563
00:59:53.547 --> 00:59:53.659
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

564
00:59:55.054 --> 00:59:57.166
<v Sameer Kanal>That to help with the reputational piece, by the way.

565
00:59:57.458 --> 01:00:06.726
<v Sameer Kanal>But I am looking forward to that being a larger percentage of our revenue stream in the future and want to have that conversation in the appropriate place.

566
01:00:06.840 --> 01:00:07.780
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

567
01:00:07.876 --> 01:00:08.702
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

568
01:00:08.864 --> 01:00:09.414
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

569
01:00:11.601 --> 01:00:12.719
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. President.

570
01:00:14.000 --> 01:00:19.159
<v Mitch Green>Because we're on the transient lodging tax line item, Peter, I do have to clarify something.

571
01:00:20.086 --> 01:00:25.956
<v Mitch Green>And I'm not trying to make your job any more difficult than it already is, but how do you go about forecasting that?

572
01:00:26.036 --> 01:00:27.447
<v Mitch Green>Like, what's your general methodology?

573
01:00:28.184 --> 01:00:46.097
<v Peter Holzman>Yeah, it's relatively— I say this, but it's relatively simple where you just take the number of rooms that you expect, the average occupancy rate, and this is— I use publicly available Travel Portland, Travel Oregon data to track and kind of come up with an estimate of our occupancy rate.

574
01:00:46.717 --> 01:00:48.744
<v Peter Holzman>And they also provide average room rate.

575
01:00:48.969 --> 01:00:50.192
<v Peter Holzman>And I know our tax rate.

576
01:00:50.416 --> 01:00:57.559
<v Peter Holzman>You can just multiply all those together by the number of days in a year and you get a pretty close estimate.

577
01:00:58.179 --> 01:01:01.094
<v Peter Holzman>I, generally speaking, true it up to what we actually receive.

578
01:01:03.106 --> 01:01:09.275
<v Peter Holzman>And where the forecasting component comes in is changing average room rate.

579
01:01:10.193 --> 01:01:14.333
<v Peter Holzman>We're not building a lot of hotels, so I don't really change the number of rooms available.

580
01:01:14.480 --> 01:01:14.755
<v Keith Wilson>Okay.

581
01:01:15.445 --> 01:01:18.519
<v Peter Holzman>But it's really changing average room rate and average occupancy rate.

582
01:01:18.648 --> 01:01:26.903
<v Peter Holzman>And right after COVID, for example, we saw a big spike in the average room rate even though the occupancy rate wasn't there.

583
01:01:27.916 --> 01:01:36.081
<v Peter Holzman>That died relatively quickly and both have been up and down but relatively flat for the last 3 years.

584
01:01:37.322 --> 01:01:37.659
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

585
01:01:38.351 --> 01:01:39.608
<v Mitch Green>So I think I've got a pretty good handle on that.

586
01:01:39.655 --> 01:01:50.965
<v Mitch Green>So you're not trying to sort of like do a hedonic pricing, like forward-looking, Oh, the cost of fuel affects flights, then affects the vacancy or the occupancy rates and that sort of thing?

587
01:01:53.740 --> 01:02:07.972
<v Peter Holzman>You could get to that level of detail when forecasting the specific average room rate or occupancy rate, and I will look at that sort of thing, but I don't have any built-out model in part because the actual data themselves are modeling assumptions.

588
01:02:08.603 --> 01:02:09.474
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate that.

589
01:02:09.748 --> 01:02:19.505
<v Mitch Green>Because this is a work session, I am going to request to share my screen because I think it's important for us to think through because it's a non-trivial share of our income.

590
01:02:19.552 --> 01:02:21.496
<v Mitch Green>So I'm just going to just try to do this.

591
01:02:21.579 --> 01:02:22.210
<v Mitch Green>I hope it works.

592
01:02:23.989 --> 01:02:24.195
<v Dan Ryan>Here we go.

593
01:02:24.282 --> 01:02:24.730
<v Mitch Green>This will work.

594
01:02:28.063 --> 01:02:28.737
<v Mitch Green>Can you guys see that?

595
01:02:29.333 --> 01:02:29.460
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yes.

596
01:02:29.911 --> 01:02:30.072
<v Olivia Clark>Okay.

597
01:02:30.152 --> 01:02:37.567
<v Mitch Green>So what I've got on the screen here is PLATS, S&P Global Energy PLATS has an index for jet fuel price.

598
01:02:38.635 --> 01:02:53.469
<v Mitch Green>And you know where I'm going with this, Peter, is since the, um, since the oil war that the president has pulled us into, uh, by— for unknown reasons, um, the, the price of jet fuel has spiked, uh, extraordinarily.

599
01:02:53.985 --> 01:03:08.050
<v Mitch Green>And I've just— every day I read a new article that says airlines are now raising a baggage fee, or they are now, um, going out and trying to secure contracts in the forward market, futures market, to try to lock in based upon expectations that this is going to continue to go up.

600
01:03:08.679 --> 01:03:13.820
<v Mitch Green>And so I guess I'm really concerned, and I don't know if there's much we can do about it because these are external global impacts.

601
01:03:13.885 --> 01:03:15.260
<v Mitch Green>This is a global energy market.

602
01:03:15.992 --> 01:03:30.155
<v Mitch Green>But I am concerned that we're going to have a leading indicator from this that's going to put a serious drag on our lodging, transportation lodging, line item.

603
01:03:30.219 --> 01:03:50.744
<v Mitch Green>So if you have a heuristic method that sort of is scenario-based that says, well, let's suppose there's a bad case that we need to think about and plan for that you don't necessarily explicitly model at the level of a hedonic pricing approach, I would encourage us to maybe consider that because I think that's coming our way.

604
01:03:51.956 --> 01:03:53.989
<v Peter Holzman>I think that's a great point, Councilor.

605
01:03:55.981 --> 01:04:04.918
<v Peter Holzman>This ties very well in with, again, that economic uncertainty slide because not only all the things you mentioned, but they're cutting flights.

606
01:04:05.130 --> 01:04:11.699
<v Peter Holzman>And that's probably the bigger concern because we're not a major hub or anything along those lines.

607
01:04:13.869 --> 01:04:16.637
<v Peter Holzman>So yeah, it's certainly a risk.

608
01:04:16.943 --> 01:04:20.307
<v Peter Holzman>It's not necessarily a risk I want to put into the forecast until—.

609
01:04:20.307 --> 01:04:20.516
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yeah.

610
01:04:21.547 --> 01:04:30.192
<v Peter Holzman>It continues on a little bit longer and we have time and we see how it plays out over the summer, which is again the biggest time for revenue.

611
01:04:30.304 --> 01:04:32.869
<v Peter Holzman>But yeah, great comments.

612
01:04:33.175 --> 01:04:34.121
<v Mitch Green>And I appreciate that.

613
01:04:34.168 --> 01:04:36.237
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's kind of more for this body to think through.

614
01:04:36.318 --> 01:05:06.557
<v Mitch Green>And it's more for, you know, Jonas, when we do this financial get-well plan working group and we're thinking through the 5-year plan is When we make decisions that draw down reserves or we make decisions that sort of draw down contingencies and those contingencies are based upon risk assessments, I hope that we're thinking about some very difficult to model risks that affect probably directly this lodging revenue structure, but maybe indirectly some of the others through the BLT.

615
01:05:07.106 --> 01:05:12.168
<v Mitch Green>So I'll stop lecturing and I'll yield at this point.

616
01:05:13.422 --> 01:05:14.449
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Professor Green.

617
01:05:17.538 --> 01:05:18.625
<v Jonas Biery>Councilor Smith.

618
01:05:18.771 --> 01:05:19.338
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

619
01:05:19.826 --> 01:05:22.617
<v Loretta Smith>And you may have talked about this before I, I, I was here.

620
01:05:23.599 --> 01:05:36.963
<v Loretta Smith>Just curious, where is the line item for the $7.8 million that, um, our Portland Housing Bureau, uh, receive— is receiving or going to receive from, um, the Ritz agreement?

621
01:05:39.130 --> 01:05:41.646
<v Peter Holzman>I, I, that— I do not believe that's going to the general fund.

622
01:05:41.728 --> 01:05:43.099
<v Peter Holzman>I believe it's going, um—.

623
01:05:43.099 --> 01:05:43.985
<v Loretta Smith>I see Michael here.

624
01:05:44.050 --> 01:05:45.034
<v Loretta Smith>I know he signed it.

625
01:05:45.422 --> 01:05:46.438
<v Loretta Smith>I saw his name on it.

626
01:05:47.681 --> 01:05:49.818
<v Loretta Smith>Is, is that in this year's, the 7.8?

627
01:05:49.965 --> 01:05:51.454
<v Loretta Smith>Excuse me, I'll let you come up.

628
01:05:58.295 --> 01:06:02.266
<v Jonas Biery>Council President, councilors, Michael Bonaccord, interim director for the Portland Housing Bureau.

629
01:06:02.655 --> 01:06:18.543
<v Jonas Biery>Councilor, the the negotiation process is ongoing, so it would be if we come to an agreement and the money is sort of finalized and secured, it would be added in a TAO, I would imagine.

630
01:06:19.458 --> 01:06:22.284
<v Loretta Smith>So are we going to do a budget modification once we get the $7.8 million?

631
01:06:23.617 --> 01:06:26.554
<v Loretta Smith>Or I thought the $7.8 million was already a done deal.

632
01:06:26.684 --> 01:06:28.385
<v Loretta Smith>I thought you signed off on it in March.

633
01:06:29.333 --> 01:06:31.144
<v Jonas Biery>No, there are ongoing negotiations.

634
01:06:31.659 --> 01:06:42.936
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, so that would be really good to know because that's not something that we're really expecting, and that's a nice piece of general fund money, a one-time— I look at it as one-time-only money.

635
01:06:44.317 --> 01:06:47.637
<v Loretta Smith>So can we go ahead, Ruth?

636
01:06:48.807 --> 01:06:51.086
<v Peter Holzman>Just to clarify again, it's not general fund.

637
01:06:51.231 --> 01:06:52.032
<v Loretta Smith>It's not general fund?

638
01:06:52.112 --> 01:06:53.284
<v Loretta Smith>Yeah, it's going to housing.

639
01:06:53.413 --> 01:06:54.005
<v Candace Avalos>Is it housing?

640
01:06:54.262 --> 01:06:55.048
<v Loretta Smith>It's for the rental.

641
01:06:56.405 --> 01:07:07.936
<v Loretta Smith>The inclusionary, because they were supposed to be having affordable units over there and they had to pay us in lieu of having those units.

642
01:07:08.474 --> 01:07:09.177
<v Loretta Smith>Am I correct?

643
01:07:10.909 --> 01:07:11.411
<v Peter Holzman>That's correct.

644
01:07:11.670 --> 01:07:12.317
<v Loretta Smith>Okay, okay.

645
01:07:12.414 --> 01:07:14.306
<v Loretta Smith>So I should have explained that in the beginning.

646
01:07:15.050 --> 01:07:16.764
<v Loretta Smith>I know people are wondering, what is she talking about?

647
01:07:17.556 --> 01:07:18.882
<v Loretta Smith>That's good.

648
01:07:18.947 --> 01:07:33.684
<v Loretta Smith>But I do want to know, And I'll, and I'll ask occasionally over the budget cycle if we've gotten that $7.8 million in yet, because I want to make sure that we account for it in this coming up fiscal year, '26-'27.

649
01:07:34.469 --> 01:07:46.164
<v Loretta Smith>Um, we have a gap, so I'm just— I know it's housing money, but it still can offset our budget in some kind of way to pay for those things.

650
01:07:46.340 --> 01:07:50.148
<v Jonas Biery>It will, it will definitely be known when we come to an okay, I appreciate you.

651
01:07:50.293 --> 01:07:50.630
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

652
01:07:51.097 --> 01:07:52.626
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

653
01:07:53.175 --> 01:07:55.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, very quickly, time is currently 3:30.

654
01:07:56.088 --> 01:08:06.452
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have a hard stop at 5 o'clock, and we still have to move to the second half of our item this afternoon, which is discussing council priorities through the budget.

655
01:08:08.179 --> 01:08:09.923
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

656
01:08:10.844 --> 01:08:28.025
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Very briefly, I just wanted to chime in on the conversation that Councilor Kanal had with I believe that is part of the very broad charge for our City Life Committee.

657
01:08:28.154 --> 01:08:33.270
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And if there are conversations that you'd like to make sure we are having that are not currently being had, let me know.

658
01:08:33.414 --> 01:08:36.448
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'd be happy to make sure that we dig in on the topic more this year.

659
01:08:38.469 --> 01:08:39.333
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

660
01:08:39.466 --> 01:08:40.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

661
01:08:40.213 --> 01:08:40.695
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor.

662
01:08:42.703 --> 01:08:42.783
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

663
01:08:43.011 --> 01:08:45.257
<v Jamie Dunphy>Seeing no one else, thank you, gentlemen.

664
01:08:49.099 --> 01:08:56.524
<v Jamie Dunphy>Colleagues, the format for the rest of this afternoon, first I'm going to turn it to the mayor to see if he has any updates about budget process or anything he'd like to share with the council first.

665
01:08:56.668 --> 01:09:07.036
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then the remainder of our afternoon is in response to Resolution 37732, which was when we adopted our budget calendar.

666
01:09:07.100 --> 01:09:20.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>There was an amendment specifically, explicitly requiring council to hold a work session in front of the mayor in order for us to be able to express our— what cuts we find acceptable and what cuts we find unacceptable.

667
01:09:21.890 --> 01:09:23.546
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to turn it over to Mayor Wilson to start.

668
01:09:25.449 --> 01:09:26.800
<v Keith Wilson>Council President, thank you so much.

669
01:09:26.899 --> 01:09:27.115
<v Keith Wilson>A few words.

670
01:09:28.243 --> 01:09:29.975
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for having me, council colleagues.

671
01:09:31.367 --> 01:09:35.568
<v Keith Wilson>As you all know, we are in a challenging financial position, far more challenging than last year.

672
01:09:37.368 --> 01:09:40.436
<v Keith Wilson>We have hard and important work ahead to close the looming funding gap.

673
01:09:41.671 --> 01:09:44.773
<v Keith Wilson>Virtually every program will take at least some cuts.

674
01:09:45.931 --> 01:09:51.564
<v Keith Wilson>In order to lessen the pain for crucial core services, other programs will need to take a far more painful reduction.

675
01:09:53.096 --> 01:09:56.643
<v Keith Wilson>I know many of these programs are important to you and they benefit our community.

676
01:09:56.935 --> 01:09:57.792
<v Keith Wilson>I'm sorry for that.

677
01:10:00.318 --> 01:10:04.198
<v Keith Wilson>This is a reset moment for the City of Portland, and how we show up for each other matters.

678
01:10:05.536 --> 01:10:09.197
<v Keith Wilson>We can't just tell each other what we want to hold harmless.

679
01:10:09.774 --> 01:10:12.569
<v Keith Wilson>That isn't a realistic option in our current situation.

680
01:10:13.564 --> 01:10:22.684
<v Keith Wilson>Instead, we need to come to each other with open hearts, creativity, compromise, and most of all, with the willingness to put forth meaningful and specific sacrifices.

681
01:10:23.663 --> 01:10:29.154
<v Keith Wilson>Those specific cuts must include program areas that are important to us personally.

682
01:10:29.332 --> 01:10:29.604
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

683
01:10:30.409 --> 01:10:35.726
<v Keith Wilson>I promise we'll get through this and that we have far brighter days ahead.

684
01:10:37.050 --> 01:10:40.179
<v Keith Wilson>We see signs of a renewed and resurgent Portland everywhere.

685
01:10:41.518 --> 01:10:49.586
<v Keith Wilson>We may have less funding to work with, but we have the same underlying obligation to foster a safe, activated, prosperous community.

686
01:10:50.173 --> 01:10:52.134
<v Keith Wilson>And thank you, and thank you for all that you do for Portland.

687
01:10:54.091 --> 01:10:54.434
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Mayor.

688
01:10:55.006 --> 01:11:06.659
<v Jamie Dunphy>So colleagues, we're now going to enter into an opportunity just where folks can have I would love it if— let's see, we have 90, about 90 minutes left and about 9 of us on the dais.

689
01:11:06.725 --> 01:11:09.171
<v Jamie Dunphy>So let's try to aim for 10 minutes apiece.

690
01:11:09.769 --> 01:11:16.064
<v Jamie Dunphy>Folks can tell the mayor specifically what your priorities might be, what cuts you find acceptable and which cuts you find unacceptable.

691
01:11:18.097 --> 01:11:20.051
<v Jamie Dunphy>As the mayor said, this is a cut year.

692
01:11:20.777 --> 01:11:22.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>Nothing is gonna be held harmless.

693
01:11:24.369 --> 01:11:31.595
<v Jamie Dunphy>But, and while I'm sure much of the mayor's budget is already sort of proposed and ready to go with some futzing on the margins.

694
01:11:32.095 --> 01:11:45.809
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think this is also a good opportunity for us to preview what those red lines are going to be for us each, what amendments might be coming forward from each of your offices if it's not reflected in the mayor's budget, and a general discussion about prioritization.

695
01:11:45.970 --> 01:11:48.573
<v Jamie Dunphy>So feel free to jump in the queue and I'll start with Councilor Zimmerman.

696
01:11:51.222 --> 01:11:52.702
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks, Mr. President.

697
01:11:53.238 --> 01:11:54.765
<v Mitch Green>And Councilor Smith.

698
01:11:55.041 --> 01:12:03.048
<v Eric Zimmerman>To the mayor and city administrator, it's no easy task to propose a budget, a balanced budget in a year like this.

699
01:12:03.194 --> 01:12:07.840
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so I recognize the position y'all are in.

700
01:12:08.613 --> 01:12:14.518
<v Eric Zimmerman>So it's an interesting time to weigh in on the cuts when we don't know what the cuts are.

701
01:12:14.969 --> 01:12:21.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I think it is helpful, and I've always believed this in my career, of kind of outline where those priorities are.

702
01:12:21.498 --> 01:12:22.858
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think this is a valuable exercise.

703
01:12:22.975 --> 01:12:27.576
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that you have all the decisions or information to make decisions, Mayor.

704
01:12:27.640 --> 01:12:35.012
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think one of the challenges that governments often face are, do we make across-the-board cuts or do we make targeted cuts?

705
01:12:35.797 --> 01:12:48.668
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not a particular fan of across-the-board cuts, usually because in the time of doing that, there is a crisis or a part of our civic life that is not going well.

706
01:12:48.813 --> 01:12:51.104
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so if you do across-the-board cuts, I believe them to be—.

707
01:12:51.104 --> 01:12:51.185
<v Angelita Morillo>I agree.

708
01:12:51.969 --> 01:12:58.603
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, kind of erroneous in terms of what our focus is or our improvement area or our, um, you know, key indicator of success.

709
01:12:58.667 --> 01:13:09.350
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, there have been times where I've seen that occur, and I'd say those were the— they were good times but for the budget situation.

710
01:13:09.479 --> 01:13:25.131
<v Eric Zimmerman>I don't think that's where we're at, meaning I'm very comfortable with targeted cuts because a targeted cut Or a greater targeted cut versus everybody cut that's equal means that you're highlighting the key areas that you want to prioritize.

711
01:13:25.243 --> 01:13:27.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I actually think that that's important for Portlanders.

712
01:13:27.507 --> 01:13:28.872
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it's important for this council.

713
01:13:29.483 --> 01:13:41.512
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'll be more favorable to a plan that says, here's what I'm prioritizing, and because I'm doing that, I'm recognizing that I'm putting a larger cut in other areas versus an across-the-board percentage.

714
01:13:42.106 --> 01:13:57.119
<v Eric Zimmerman>So if that's what we see I think I will respond to that favorably, even though I admit there will be some areas that, that either will not exist or they will take such significant cuts that it's going to be a significant emotional event for some folks.

715
01:13:58.065 --> 01:14:08.041
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I think, I think we still are in crisis time, and those conversations we had last year about what do you focus on in crisis time, I think we're still present with a lot of that.

716
01:14:08.168 --> 01:14:17.591
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so for me, I Those areas that I hope you are preserving wherever possible, Mayor, of course, are in the livability and cleanliness areas.

717
01:14:18.104 --> 01:14:25.730
<v Eric Zimmerman>Anything we can do that we think will increase the amount of capacity, the capacity of units available for people to live in.

718
01:14:25.795 --> 01:14:30.009
<v Eric Zimmerman>So housing capacity, which really gets at that affordability matrix.

719
01:14:30.104 --> 01:14:37.042
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think a year or 2 ago, I think people were talking a lot more about public safety, but I think affordability is front of mind for so many people in a way.

720
01:14:37.734 --> 01:14:46.019
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because I do see some significant improvements that have happened in the public safety and livability realm because of your efforts, because of all of our efforts.

721
01:14:47.359 --> 01:14:51.622
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then of course protecting those, the public safety areas.

722
01:14:52.443 --> 01:15:03.463
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm looking for, I'll say slight system improvements in how our neighborhood associations get to participate and weigh in and work with us.

723
01:15:03.529 --> 01:15:03.594
<v Angelita Morillo>Yeah.

724
01:15:04.274 --> 01:15:08.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I don't foresee significant budgetary changes.

725
01:15:08.532 --> 01:15:16.188
<v Eric Zimmerman>I just see more of a direct recognition of the role in which they play in the community that you might be able to articulate.

726
01:15:18.256 --> 01:15:31.893
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I say that because I'm going to be— I'm going to take seriously all system-type approaches when I put those in the category of none of those will be easy decisions, I'm sure.

727
01:15:31.989 --> 01:15:32.038
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

728
01:15:33.698 --> 01:16:00.493
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm not going to— or perhaps it's a red flag to use or a red line to use the council president's— the cute headline type of cuts or kind of the silliness cuts of proposing, you know, I want to— if we see those types of things get put up, I'm going to react a little differently because I'm not sure that they really fall into a fixing of the system approach.

729
01:16:01.123 --> 01:16:07.698
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if you look at that forecast we just looked— cute headlines aren't going to save us.

730
01:16:08.438 --> 01:16:11.506
<v Eric Zimmerman>We've got to have a system of like, what are we reducing?

731
01:16:11.587 --> 01:16:16.027
<v Eric Zimmerman>What are we no longer investing in because we've changed what our core lines of business are?

732
01:16:16.577 --> 01:16:19.663
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those lines of effort where we spend our time, they matter.

733
01:16:20.051 --> 01:16:29.198
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that safe roads, safe public space, livable public space, public safety apparatus that actually picks up the phone when you call 911.

734
01:16:29.752 --> 01:16:39.003
<v Eric Zimmerman>That actually gets there when they dispatch, that is building homes, that isn't stopping you at the permit line.

735
01:16:39.524 --> 01:16:40.872
<v Eric Zimmerman>Those are our core functions.

736
01:16:41.554 --> 01:16:44.037
<v Eric Zimmerman>And everything else kind of falls in the extra category.

737
01:16:45.399 --> 01:16:49.787
<v Eric Zimmerman>Making this new government work is a core function, right?

738
01:16:50.448 --> 01:16:55.750
<v Eric Zimmerman>Setting up this government to work was a big part of our duty in this first year.

739
01:16:55.802 --> 01:16:55.908
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

740
01:16:56.140 --> 01:16:56.640
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

741
01:16:56.689 --> 01:17:00.421
<v Eric Zimmerman>Steps backwards in that realm will not be met favorably.

742
01:17:01.247 --> 01:17:32.561
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then lastly, I just will say, I guess looking at— I'm approaching this budget differently than I've ever approached any budget in my career, which is I am not bringing a list of things I want to fund because I think the system is so dire and our number is so dire, but I am coming with a list of things I want to protect that are, I think, going to be in the areas based on what I've seen you portray to the public.

743
01:17:33.630 --> 01:17:37.872
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's very different than normally, I think, of the way a district councilor thinks about stuff.

744
01:17:37.936 --> 01:17:47.295
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I am putting that guardrail on myself, and I'm hoping to have those be considered core functions by you and your administration.

745
01:17:49.170 --> 01:18:04.051
<v Eric Zimmerman>Councilor I welcome the opportunity, if you see it, if there's something that's not working, instead of leaving it on life support, pull the plug.

746
01:18:05.895 --> 01:18:16.795
<v Eric Zimmerman>Meaning, if we see a cut of some program at a 50% or more, I'm really going to actually have the question in my head, not how to restore it, but does it need to exist?

747
01:18:16.859 --> 01:18:17.037
<v Angelita Morillo>Thank you.

748
01:18:17.720 --> 01:18:32.395
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I share that very publicly because I want to give that opportunity of if there's something that's not working, we're keeping it there for the sake of tradition or the sake of previous councils tried to do it and it's just been languishing for a long time, but it's not producing results.

749
01:18:33.715 --> 01:18:39.359
<v Eric Zimmerman>If you are seeing that from the administration, I hope you'll share that with us so that we can take significant change there.

750
01:18:40.792 --> 01:18:52.030
<v Eric Zimmerman>Because in order to preserve the lines of business that are core, We may have to fully abandon some lines of business that are not, and I don't know what that looks like from your chair.

751
01:18:52.319 --> 01:19:02.194
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I'm giving you is an invitation that if that opportunity exists, I, I will listen to it, uh, without being reactionary on how to restore it, right?

752
01:19:02.259 --> 01:19:04.134
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I think that that's a real change.

753
01:19:04.823 --> 01:19:31.177
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I want to share with my colleagues, based on the last Steering and Oversight Committee that I went to with Multnomah County, we got a pretty good and in-depth report on quite by the numbers on how SHS, how Medicaid funding, how our system works with permanent supportive housing versus Oregon State Hospital and the mentally ill and the co-occurring and et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.

754
01:19:32.109 --> 01:19:40.322
<v Eric Zimmerman>And most of my career in government has been based upon where governments have generally said, what are we not doing really well at?

755
01:19:40.661 --> 01:19:43.457
<v Eric Zimmerman>And we have tried to put resources at how to be better at that thing.

756
01:19:44.832 --> 01:20:13.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>But that last assessment by Health Share and by the county, I think, has solidified me in the position of I'm interested in funding the things we're good at at a higher level, meaning we can— we are doing well, by members of our community who are, who are facing homelessness from a poverty-only position, and we shouldn't have anybody who from that perspective isn't supported.

757
01:20:13.606 --> 01:20:14.762
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we can do better there.

758
01:20:15.613 --> 01:20:30.668
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what we were also seeing is that our, our system in this community of permanent supportive housing is probably obscuring the numbers for what— of people who the Oregon State Hospital probably is the most responsible entity to be caring for.

759
01:20:31.359 --> 01:20:44.635
<v Eric Zimmerman>And so if we are not— if we're putting a lot of money at an area we're having a really bad outcome for, I want— I'm going to look to be supportive of stopping that until we figure out what the problem is, because right now it ain't working.

760
01:20:45.457 --> 01:20:47.823
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that was— that really jumped off the page.

761
01:20:47.904 --> 01:20:56.932
<v Eric Zimmerman>And after a year plus of that, I think I'm to that position of money after what works, recognizing that someone's not going to be at the table.

762
01:20:56.997 --> 01:20:57.064
<v Candace Avalos>Right.

763
01:20:57.686 --> 01:21:07.440
<v Eric Zimmerman>But I'm not going to do things at a lower quality to ensure that something that we're really bad at is at least at the table for the sake of saying it's at the table.

764
01:21:07.569 --> 01:21:09.734
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think that we've got to get serious about what we're good at.

765
01:21:10.632 --> 01:21:11.739
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just share that, Mayor.

766
01:21:11.884 --> 01:21:13.103
<v Eric Zimmerman>You have a tough job coming up.

767
01:21:13.184 --> 01:21:16.118
<v Eric Zimmerman>Colleagues, I know we're all going to come about this from 12 different perspectives.

768
01:21:16.938 --> 01:21:19.856
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know I'm approaching this budget in a very different manner.

769
01:21:20.403 --> 01:21:22.167
<v Eric Zimmerman>There's your 9 minutes, Mr. President.

770
01:21:22.729 --> 01:21:23.643
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Zimmerman.

771
01:21:23.997 --> 01:21:24.710
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

772
01:21:26.603 --> 01:21:27.735
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

773
01:21:28.157 --> 01:21:30.761
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think I will need more than half my time.

774
01:21:31.912 --> 01:21:35.552
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Mr. Mayor, this is not a surprise to you.

775
01:21:36.246 --> 01:21:40.289
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Number one red line for me— we made a promise to voters last summer.

776
01:21:41.198 --> 01:21:49.935
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We said we are referring a parks levy, and if you support this, we will make sure that certain services within our parks are maintained.

777
01:21:50.837 --> 01:21:50.917
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

778
01:21:51.573 --> 01:21:56.750
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Bottom line, we cannot come in less than a year later and break that promise.

779
01:21:57.743 --> 01:22:09.729
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I understand everybody's going to take cuts and there will be some things within parks that need to see some reductions, but those things that we promised to voters would be funded if they passed a parks levy must be funded.

780
01:22:10.546 --> 01:22:17.367
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Otherwise, we all lose credibility with the people who supported us when we asked them to dig a little bit deeper.

781
01:22:19.563 --> 01:22:22.081
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to talk about long-term impacts of cuts.

782
01:22:23.416 --> 01:22:45.498
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I agree with my colleague that we should be looking at targeted cuts, but I want to make sure that where we are making cuts doesn't have a first-year cost savings at the expense of a second and third-year cost Thank you.

783
01:22:46.456 --> 01:22:46.764
<v Loretta Smith>I will—.

784
01:22:46.877 --> 01:22:51.561
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll be using that lens when I look at the budget you bring to us.

785
01:22:53.020 --> 01:23:01.671
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I'll flag 2 things that I will look at critically because of that lens, but it's a broader lens for me than just these 2 things.

786
01:23:02.865 --> 01:23:07.673
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>The first is our community violence prevention programs.

787
01:23:08.916 --> 01:23:17.256
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We know that many of the things within that category perhaps not all, but many of them reduce costs in the long run.

788
01:23:18.506 --> 01:23:29.494
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And to take short-term cost savings there, knowing the cost growth we will see when violence increases, that's not a 1-year cost savings that I can support.

789
01:23:30.909 --> 01:23:38.238
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Similarly, we know that there is often pressure to reduce internal costs thank you.

790
01:23:38.337 --> 01:23:42.332
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So we can cut costs and then contract out work to make sure we can still do the same things.

791
01:23:43.029 --> 01:23:46.163
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Sometimes we can do that in the short term at a lesser rate.

792
01:23:47.909 --> 01:24:01.787
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Often cost savings come from offloading assets or from one-time cost savings for not having to upgrade assets, and those things almost always end up costing more in the long run.

793
01:24:02.851 --> 01:24:23.216
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I want to make sure that we are not devastating our own workforce to try to save costs in ways that will then not only leave more Portlanders unemployed, which has a cost to us, but leave us with costs to make up for that as contract costs grow in the future.

794
01:24:25.489 --> 01:24:28.673
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So that principle— what are the long-term impacts?

795
01:24:28.722 --> 01:24:30.489
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Do we have a year-one cost thank you.

796
01:24:30.587 --> 01:24:35.034
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>So the principle of a year or 2 of cost savings, but a year or 2, 3, 4 cost growth is a critical one for me.

797
01:24:35.552 --> 01:24:42.935
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Those are 2 examples where I've seen public entities go awry on that principle in the past.

798
01:24:45.039 --> 01:24:58.503
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>We were asked to look at both cuts and revenue, and I'm not going to propose revenue increases, but I just want to talk about some principles there.

799
01:25:00.152 --> 01:25:13.416
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I am concerned that there are a lot of places where we are looking at revenue needs that end up shifting costs from a broader to a narrower base.

800
01:25:15.612 --> 01:25:37.574
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>And I am concerned that we are becoming more and more reliant on fees that generally have a flat rate, maybe with some exceptions, but that our tax system is not as progressive as we like to think it is.

801
01:25:40.609 --> 01:25:44.036
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I don't think I can say we have to hold a bottom line on those 2 things right now.

802
01:25:47.603 --> 01:26:13.150
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>But I do want us to look holistically at the changes that we are asking Portlanders for in the fee and tax and other revenue space and make sure that the collective impact of our decisions doesn't end up putting continuously more and more pressure on working families in our community.

803
01:26:14.619 --> 01:26:18.979
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>At the expense of broader and more progressive revenue-raising measures.

804
01:26:21.615 --> 01:26:25.534
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>I think I'll end there so as not to dilute the impact of those things.

805
01:26:25.890 --> 01:26:26.859
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thank you, Council President.

806
01:26:27.086 --> 01:26:28.154
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney.

807
01:26:28.557 --> 01:26:29.172
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith.

808
01:26:31.470 --> 01:26:33.006
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Council President.

809
01:26:35.140 --> 01:26:40.698
<v Loretta Smith>Um, I thought we were going to have a conversation, so I haven't heard you respond to any of the things that you've heard.

810
01:26:41.570 --> 01:26:42.997
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Smith.

811
01:26:43.920 --> 01:26:44.324
<v Loretta Smith>Okay.

812
01:26:49.287 --> 01:26:55.595
<v Loretta Smith>I don't have any just outstanding things that I need other than things just to maintain what's already been in the budget.

813
01:26:56.985 --> 01:27:05.887
<v Loretta Smith>I'm always going to fight for putting resources in our underserved youth for summer jobs, period.

814
01:27:07.322 --> 01:27:07.451
<v Steve Novick>Yes.

815
01:27:07.788 --> 01:27:08.255
<v Loretta Smith>Uh, given.

816
01:27:09.252 --> 01:27:16.136
<v Loretta Smith>And I'm really concerned about the apprenticeship programs and the pre-apprenticeship programs that are expected to be reduced.

817
01:27:16.233 --> 01:27:25.523
<v Loretta Smith>I've gotten lots of text messages from Andrew McGough and from Work Systems that they've received letters already, and I thought that was odd.

818
01:27:27.171 --> 01:27:55.965
<v Loretta Smith>The other thing that is, that is really brewing under the, you know, surface are the, the neighborhood associations and the, uh, district coalition offices, and that they're currently being asked to send back an RFP, um, that will include other nonprofits to be able to, to manage what— manage the relationships with the neighborhood associations and how they do their work.

819
01:27:56.445 --> 01:28:05.480
<v Loretta Smith>They basically pay for all of the, uh, fest festivals and their insurance and those kinds of things, and they're behind in getting their resources.

820
01:28:06.059 --> 01:28:28.871
<v Loretta Smith>I met with them this past Saturday and they wanted a sit-down with, um, the city administrator to, to go over it, and I told them that I would ask you about it, um, this week, and this is what I'm doing because I think we need to sit down first before we, um, talk to the mayor so that we understand clearly what, what it is that, that's different in how we do business.

821
01:28:29.577 --> 01:28:41.930
<v Loretta Smith>Um, the way they're being asked to do business, they, they reduce the district coalitions from 7 or 8 now down to 4, and that's in, uh, the community engagement.

822
01:28:42.507 --> 01:28:47.207
<v Loretta Smith>The interaction that they've been having with our community engagement officer has not been a positive one.

823
01:28:47.865 --> 01:28:56.868
<v Loretta Smith>They're not getting the answers that they— consistent answers about how they go about, why are they being asked to do it this way, is there a possibility to change.

824
01:28:58.417 --> 01:29:05.467
<v Loretta Smith>There's a lot of institutional information on how they do the business that they do within the neighborhood association.

825
01:29:06.024 --> 01:29:08.591
<v Loretta Smith>So that has always been an issue.

826
01:29:08.655 --> 01:29:10.181
<v Loretta Smith>I've watched it over 30 years.

827
01:29:10.863 --> 01:29:16.876
<v Loretta Smith>But with this new change, there are new ways for them to get their money.

828
01:29:16.939 --> 01:29:18.134
<v Loretta Smith>They're getting their money late.

829
01:29:18.213 --> 01:29:18.295
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Yes.

830
01:29:19.078 --> 01:29:31.778
<v Loretta Smith>And as a result, if District 1 Coalition had not put some money in reserves, they wouldn't be able to put on all the festivals and get the insurance for this spring and this summer.

831
01:29:32.539 --> 01:29:33.512
<v Loretta Smith>So that's a problem.

832
01:29:33.902 --> 01:29:39.065
<v Loretta Smith>And I know it feels like it's minute, but it's important to them.

833
01:29:39.648 --> 01:30:01.108
<v Loretta Smith>And there is a kind of a rift between what they consider, um, white homeowners and, um, diverse renters and who and how they run the neighborhood associations.

834
01:30:02.011 --> 01:30:10.155
<v Loretta Smith>And so there has been countless, you know, meetings in the past about being inclusive, and I rec— I Yes.

835
01:30:10.268 --> 01:30:22.162
<v Loretta Smith>I pointed out to them on Saturday that I was the only— me and my staff were the only diverse folks that was sitting around the table, and that we can't have renters and homeowners fighting.

836
01:30:23.476 --> 01:30:29.457
<v Loretta Smith>We need to get you all information so that you can make the best decisions about what we're doing as a city.

837
01:30:30.145 --> 01:30:36.509
<v Loretta Smith>So that— there's an undercurrent there that I wanted you to know about, and I'll work with you yes.

838
01:30:36.671 --> 01:30:41.155
<v Loretta Smith>Um, City Administrator about getting a, um, a roundtable meeting with them.

839
01:30:41.949 --> 01:30:49.384
<v Loretta Smith>The other piece that's really concerning is, um, the overnight shelters.

840
01:30:51.984 --> 01:31:00.684
<v Loretta Smith>I'm just so concerned that we're not going to be able to pay the full freight for the overnight shelters because we don't have the money.

841
01:31:01.119 --> 01:31:03.829
<v Loretta Smith>And I know you've been working hard talking to other counties Councilor Smith.

842
01:31:03.829 --> 01:31:03.829
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you, Mayor.

843
01:31:03.829 --> 01:31:05.430
<v Loretta Smith>I just wanted to say thank you to everybody who's been working to try to get additional resources.

844
01:31:06.329 --> 01:31:10.250
<v Loretta Smith>But everybody's talking about the homeless infrastructure.

845
01:31:10.250 --> 01:31:19.510
<v Loretta Smith>It is no question that our city has been beautified as a result of the work that we've done over this last year.

846
01:31:19.949 --> 01:31:20.979
<v Loretta Smith>It has changed.

847
01:31:23.600 --> 01:31:26.109
<v Loretta Smith>It has changed in a big way.

848
01:31:26.109 --> 01:31:28.020
<v Loretta Smith>Even in my neighborhood, it's changed.

849
01:31:28.529 --> 01:31:29.710
<v Loretta Smith>And everybody recognizes that.

850
01:31:29.710 --> 01:31:30.159
<v Loretta Smith>I recognize that.

851
01:31:30.225 --> 01:31:36.213
<v Loretta Smith>And so, oh yeah, the District Coalition folks said they wanted me to tell you thank you for cleaning up because the streets do look better.

852
01:31:36.262 --> 01:31:37.551
<v Loretta Smith>They did tell me to tell you that too.

853
01:31:38.430 --> 01:31:40.125
<v Loretta Smith>So, and I agree with that.

854
01:31:40.802 --> 01:31:47.229
<v Loretta Smith>But I think we have an issue around how we're going to pay for those one-time resources.

855
01:31:48.550 --> 01:31:55.551
<v Loretta Smith>And I don't know, I'm glad I don't have the first look at it and to make those very important cuts.

856
01:31:55.615 --> 01:31:55.890
<v Raymond C. Lee>Councilor Smith.

857
01:31:57.027 --> 01:31:58.729
<v Loretta Smith>And you're going to have to make some cuts.

858
01:31:59.275 --> 01:32:10.743
<v Loretta Smith>And I, I, I would rather try to live with some of the cuts that you're going to make now instead of saying that during the year we're going to, we're going to make those cuts and we're going to realign during the year.

859
01:32:10.967 --> 01:32:12.208
<v Loretta Smith>It just puts us so behind.

860
01:32:12.890 --> 01:32:16.189
<v Loretta Smith>I just wanted to let you know that, that, that's, that's a problem.

861
01:32:17.413 --> 01:32:17.815
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

862
01:32:18.154 --> 01:32:19.328
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

863
01:32:20.006 --> 01:32:20.537
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

864
01:32:22.237 --> 01:32:23.393
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. President.

865
01:32:23.601 --> 01:32:24.935
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Mr. Mayor, for being here.

866
01:32:25.432 --> 01:32:27.440
<v Mitch Green>This is an important set of conversations.

867
01:32:28.051 --> 01:32:29.368
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to do some dittos.

868
01:32:29.720 --> 01:32:31.198
<v Mitch Green>Wait, let me set my timer here.

869
01:32:31.970 --> 01:32:37.318
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to start with a ditto on Councilor Smith.

870
01:32:37.413 --> 01:32:49.730
<v Mitch Green>You talked about the need to make sure we're supporting those neighborhood associations on their insurance and sort of their— they have a minimum viable money that they need that if they lose that, They cease to exist.

871
01:32:50.355 --> 01:32:52.649
<v Mitch Green>You know, we can have our critique of that model.

872
01:32:52.921 --> 01:32:58.021
<v Mitch Green>That's a— that's an interesting philosophical discussion to happen, but I know a lot of good things happens out of those neighborhood associations.

873
01:32:58.069 --> 01:33:01.212
<v Mitch Green>So I, I'm going to want to not cut that deeper into the bone.

874
01:33:02.207 --> 01:33:05.880
<v Mitch Green>Um, I'm going to ditto everything that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said.

875
01:33:06.554 --> 01:33:09.537
<v Mitch Green>I think that you hit, uh, I think the core of my top lines.

876
01:33:10.306 --> 01:33:23.065
<v Mitch Green>I just want to reaffirm very directly that we did make a promise to voters I knocked doors for the levy personally, and I told them at the doors that we were going to— we were not going to lose service delivery on that.

877
01:33:23.587 --> 01:33:27.137
<v Mitch Green>And I'm not going to go back on that in the budget.

878
01:33:29.765 --> 01:33:32.703
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to support closing fire stations.

879
01:33:32.945 --> 01:33:36.609
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to support cutting public safety specialists.

880
01:33:36.658 --> 01:33:38.671
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to support cutting Portland Street Response.

881
01:33:39.159 --> 01:33:42.601
<v Mitch Green>Those are things that are going to yield long-term savings in our public safety investments.

882
01:33:42.650 --> 01:33:42.748
<v Peter Holzman>Thank you.

883
01:33:43.442 --> 01:33:45.086
<v Mitch Green>And if we cut those now, we're going to lose a lot of progress.

884
01:33:48.645 --> 01:33:52.954
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to support using the Portland Clean Energy Fund as an ad hoc budget plug.

885
01:33:53.425 --> 01:33:55.434
<v Mitch Green>We've seen some glimpse of how that might work.

886
01:33:56.090 --> 01:33:57.635
<v Mitch Green>I'm a hard no on that at this point.

887
01:33:58.052 --> 01:33:59.711
<v Mitch Green>We just amended the Climate Investment Plan.

888
01:33:59.904 --> 01:34:01.770
<v Mitch Green>We just went through a robust community process.

889
01:34:01.931 --> 01:34:06.539
<v Mitch Green>And so to come in in the budget and add in some other stuff there, that's not going to work for me.

890
01:34:08.677 --> 01:34:17.720
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to support cutting the auditor's budget beyond 3%, which is what she's agreed to, because I understand that we all need to share the load in this thing.

891
01:34:17.833 --> 01:34:19.778
<v Mitch Green>There's no magic money tree out there.

892
01:34:21.255 --> 01:34:27.759
<v Mitch Green>But that's an independent branch of this government with a duly elected official that needs to carry out her charge.

893
01:34:28.935 --> 01:34:34.534
<v Mitch Green>And I worry about the city council and the mayor bringing forward cuts to undermine her ability to execute as the auditor.

894
01:34:35.266 --> 01:34:36.479
<v Mitch Green>That, that startles me.

895
01:34:36.948 --> 01:34:39.873
<v Mitch Green>Um, so I, I, I, I won't support a cut beyond 3%.

896
01:34:39.970 --> 01:34:55.310
<v Mitch Green>Um, things I will support, because I know that we've got to find the money, um, I will support pulling forward in time our expectations on what the business license tax revenue is going to be from the transaction of the Trail Blazers, which is $40 to $50 million.

897
01:34:55.713 --> 01:34:58.032
<v Mitch Green>I know Jonas couldn't say it, but I can because I've seen it in the press.

898
01:34:58.934 --> 01:35:05.845
<v Mitch Green>Um, I will, I will support Using that money to backfill the things that we know are one-time costs, because that's a one-time revenue.

899
01:35:07.429 --> 01:35:11.588
<v Mitch Green>I'm not going to support the same level of the shelter model that you proposed last time.

900
01:35:12.831 --> 01:35:21.314
<v Mitch Green>You know, we can— we have to have further conversations on what the right size is, but I think it's too expensive, and I don't think we need that 1,500-bed capacity.

901
01:35:23.551 --> 01:35:34.948
<v Mitch Green>In terms of the impact reduction program, you know, I'm going to take some heat for saying this, but I think we need to cut deeply into that We have a legal requirement to do a minimum amount of sidewalk campsite clearances.

902
01:35:35.061 --> 01:35:36.268
<v Mitch Green>We have a Creek settlement.

903
01:35:36.444 --> 01:35:38.278
<v Mitch Green>I think it's the Creek settlement, ADA settlement.

904
01:35:38.680 --> 01:35:40.600
<v Mitch Green>We've got a lot of settlements, so I'm mixing my stuff up.

905
01:35:40.680 --> 01:35:47.185
<v Mitch Green>But I know that there is a mandated minimum level of that work that we need to do, whether I like it or not.

906
01:35:47.621 --> 01:35:48.475
<v Mitch Green>We need to execute to that.

907
01:35:50.137 --> 01:36:07.067
<v Mitch Green>What I worry about is that that's just a cost basis in our budget that continues to grow because, you know, you might, you might clear some folks out of downtown, but you're continuing to throw away their stuff over and over and over again, and it's, it just burns cash.

908
01:36:07.949 --> 01:36:10.805
<v Mitch Green>Um, so I think that there's, there is a right level of spending there.

909
01:36:11.881 --> 01:36:34.810
<v Mitch Green>Whatever we approve in the budget, I want to make sure that we are spreading that resource across the entire year so we don't come in later in a fall towel and say we need, we need to, uh, I'm also deeply worried that if we continue down that same path, we're going to push people into Forest Park because they're driven out of downtown.

910
01:36:34.810 --> 01:36:38.260
<v Mitch Green>This is what I've heard from some folks who are thinking about going deeper because they're worried.

911
01:36:38.949 --> 01:36:43.100
<v Mitch Green>And that introduces a very unacceptable fire risk to me and my constituents.

912
01:36:45.270 --> 01:36:52.101
<v Mitch Green>I do support looking at the number of senior executives that we have in the city, the deputy directors, the deputy city managers, the deputy city attorneys, the deputy city managers' Councilors.

913
01:36:52.215 --> 01:37:01.113
<v Mitch Green>The directors, you know, deputy city administrators, and asking the question of whether we need to continue funding those at that same level.

914
01:37:01.176 --> 01:37:03.389
<v Mitch Green>I know you guys are doing span of control work right now.

915
01:37:04.082 --> 01:37:14.186
<v Mitch Green>I know you guys are already thinking about that, but it's going to be really hard for me to accept the budget that cuts into our rank and file if we have just allowed and validate— validated sort of bloat at the top.

916
01:37:15.100 --> 01:37:16.095
<v Mitch Green>That's going to be a red line for me.

917
01:37:18.037 --> 01:37:26.920
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Kanal, you've raised this many times in many different settings, but I don't think that we've really done a satisfactory deep dive on the EMS contracts that we have.

918
01:37:26.967 --> 01:37:44.766
<v Mitch Green>I know that we've done some little stuff here and there, but if there are planned-for consultancy external contracts that are buried in some contingency funds that are waiting to be spent over the course of 5 years, let's do an evaluation on what can wait, what doesn't need to happen next year, and let's cut into those.

919
01:37:44.814 --> 01:37:44.943
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

920
01:37:45.315 --> 01:37:47.265
<v Mitch Green>I think there's probably a lot to be gained there.

921
01:37:49.497 --> 01:37:57.677
<v Mitch Green>And again, similar to what Councilor Zimmerman was laying out, there's nothing comfortable about this budget, and everyone's going to hate it in some way, shape, or form.

922
01:37:57.726 --> 01:38:00.773
<v Mitch Green>So I sympathize with you even though I'm pushing back on your shelter plan.

923
01:38:01.103 --> 01:38:01.597
<v Mitch Green>I really do.

924
01:38:03.176 --> 01:38:11.121
<v Mitch Green>I think that various times in this council, we've adopted budgets that have 5-year plans in them or have long-run plans in them.

925
01:38:11.168 --> 01:38:18.136
<v Mitch Green>And so Our bureaus have planned through contingency balances resources to execute on some of those plans.

926
01:38:18.954 --> 01:38:28.001
<v Mitch Green>And if there's not work that's already started, or if there's work that can be pivoted at a big cost savings, let's have that discussion and let's see if there's something that we don't spin up that already hasn't spun up.

927
01:38:29.605 --> 01:38:30.784
<v Mitch Green>I know you're looking under the hood.

928
01:38:31.204 --> 01:38:34.564
<v Mitch Green>I've said, I've said sort of my broad strokes here.

929
01:38:34.872 --> 01:38:37.295
<v Mitch Green>I'm still digesting what we saw last week.

930
01:38:37.359 --> 01:38:37.505
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

931
01:38:38.380 --> 01:38:44.577
<v Mitch Green>Um, and I'll try to do my part in offering more specific suggestions as we get further down the road.

932
01:38:44.625 --> 01:38:46.712
<v Mitch Green>So, um, I'll leave it there for now.

933
01:38:47.618 --> 01:38:48.426
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

934
01:38:48.702 --> 01:38:49.301
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

935
01:38:49.511 --> 01:38:52.408
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy— or President Dunphy.

936
01:38:54.349 --> 01:38:56.015
<v Dan Ryan>Mr. Mayor, let me start this thing.

937
01:38:58.393 --> 01:39:00.918
<v Dan Ryan>Mr. Mayor, CA Lee, I am counting on you.

938
01:39:01.615 --> 01:39:06.024
<v Dan Ryan>And as has been mentioned, something I have said in my career for decades No targeted cuts.

939
01:39:06.720 --> 01:39:11.168
<v Dan Ryan>I think across the board cuts are actually lazy, and please be strategic.

940
01:39:12.269 --> 01:39:19.197
<v Dan Ryan>I expect to see bold restructuring to find efficiencies, the efficiencies in this new form of government we were all expecting.

941
01:39:20.592 --> 01:39:25.528
<v Dan Ryan>The voters didn't expect to pay more for the new form of government, but that's exactly what we're currently experiencing.

942
01:39:27.186 --> 01:39:37.408
<v Dan Ryan>I started asking in 2024 for a plan to make the operational efficiencies That the voters asked for in the change of government and thought that would happen after they voted for it.

943
01:39:38.438 --> 01:39:39.771
<v Dan Ryan>I asked for that in 2024.

944
01:39:40.077 --> 01:39:40.967
<v Dan Ryan>It didn't materialize.

945
01:39:41.097 --> 01:39:42.605
<v Dan Ryan>I said, let's give it a year.

946
01:39:44.260 --> 01:39:46.837
<v Dan Ryan>As you can recall, I asked for it last year at this time.

947
01:39:47.377 --> 01:39:54.279
<v Dan Ryan>So this is my 3rd year hoping for a reasonable request to make more efficiencies in our enterprises finally granted.

948
01:39:55.670 --> 01:39:59.769
<v Dan Ryan>As such, for the 3rd budget season, Please make it a priority to evaluate this.

949
01:40:00.497 --> 01:40:07.065
<v Dan Ryan>We built out the DCA level of the city and didn't take offsetting reductions in the bureaus at the same time.

950
01:40:08.552 --> 01:40:10.229
<v Dan Ryan>Again, I brought this up in the old council.

951
01:40:10.488 --> 01:40:11.537
<v Dan Ryan>I brought it up last year.

952
01:40:11.762 --> 01:40:12.698
<v Dan Ryan>I'm bringing it up again.

953
01:40:13.956 --> 01:40:15.310
<v Dan Ryan>There are some efficiencies in there.

954
01:40:15.956 --> 01:40:21.841
<v Dan Ryan>They're not going to feel good, but it's why we're here to make these bold decisions now.

955
01:40:21.970 --> 01:40:22.100
<v Loretta Smith>Thank you.

956
01:40:23.619 --> 01:40:28.404
<v Dan Ryan>Since this work was not done by the former administration, I am counting on the two of you.

957
01:40:29.090 --> 01:40:33.725
<v Dan Ryan>I want to see this restructuring for efficiencies in the operations as part of this proposed budget.

958
01:40:35.350 --> 01:40:44.229
<v Dan Ryan>The expected desiloing, and that means at the DCA level, was as promised to voters again in the charter, the right-sizing of a new structure.

959
01:40:45.086 --> 01:40:48.865
<v Dan Ryan>That's really complicated, but people have done this in the past.

960
01:40:48.914 --> 01:40:49.125
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

961
01:40:49.323 --> 01:40:52.694
<v Dan Ryan>When they restructure and they make these efficiencies.

962
01:40:53.051 --> 01:40:56.470
<v Dan Ryan>And yes, it turns out to be cuts, usually at the upper management level.

963
01:41:00.420 --> 01:41:04.688
<v Dan Ryan>And please, while you do it, don't let perfect be the enemy of the good.

964
01:41:05.609 --> 01:41:06.305
<v Dan Ryan>Give us something.

965
01:41:07.521 --> 01:41:15.965
<v Dan Ryan>Another priority for the mayor's proposed budget that I hope to see is that we change our practice about how we give out money through grants to nonprofits.

966
01:41:17.088 --> 01:41:21.579
<v Dan Ryan>That takes needed resources from every bureau and office in the city's enterprise.

967
01:41:23.140 --> 01:41:24.671
<v Dan Ryan>This is a service organization.

968
01:41:25.239 --> 01:41:29.425
<v Dan Ryan>Our customer service must always go well beyond the bottom line, and I'm proud of that.

969
01:41:30.711 --> 01:41:31.427
<v Dan Ryan>And we are not a foundation.

970
01:41:33.171 --> 01:41:41.962
<v Dan Ryan>I think the public would be shocked to know how much of their tax dollars that we are giving to nonprofits rather than using them to directly fund our city's services.

971
01:41:42.011 --> 01:41:42.106
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

972
01:41:46.420 --> 01:41:51.270
<v Dan Ryan>I will call out some exceptions to this.

973
01:41:51.270 --> 01:41:53.189
<v Dan Ryan>The voters approved the Portland Children's Levy.

974
01:41:53.189 --> 01:41:54.449
<v Dan Ryan>The voters approved PSF.

975
01:41:54.449 --> 01:41:56.180
<v Dan Ryan>The voters approved an arts fund.

976
01:41:56.510 --> 01:42:04.810
<v Dan Ryan>Those were created specifically to fund programs often run by the nonprofits to deliver specific community-focused services.

977
01:42:05.430 --> 01:42:08.170
<v Loretta Smith>Like Councilor Kanal's repeated point about stop the cuts, we are stop not proposing to cut services.

978
01:42:08.170 --> 01:42:08.210
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

979
01:42:08.277 --> 01:42:12.567
<v Dan Ryan>Spending, stop sending out money for professional contracts.

980
01:42:13.274 --> 01:42:18.229
<v Dan Ryan>We need that same challenge on the money going out to the general funds of the nonprofits.

981
01:42:20.384 --> 01:42:30.779
<v Dan Ryan>Now let's talk about the federal funding we received during COVID That big infusion of one-time federal funds created a system of passing dollars from the city to the nonprofits.

982
01:42:31.264 --> 01:42:32.411
<v Dan Ryan>That's when this exploded.

983
01:42:33.524 --> 01:42:35.155
<v Dan Ryan>The system is now entrenched.

984
01:42:35.578 --> 01:42:41.015
<v Dan Ryan>Although the money is no longer there, the federal dollars to our city coffers have dried up.

985
01:42:42.148 --> 01:42:47.511
<v Dan Ryan>In fact, much of the earlier conversation about rent vouchers were financed by that COVID windfall.

986
01:42:49.212 --> 01:42:51.827
<v Dan Ryan>I don't want to reopen the debates, but had to mention that.

987
01:42:52.198 --> 01:42:56.766
<v Dan Ryan>And we all knew they were, they were not sustainable after the COVID windfalls.

988
01:42:58.774 --> 01:43:08.485
<v Dan Ryan>We need to use our city operational dollars to fund City operations, and I want to scrub the agreements we have that are funded by the city's general fund.

989
01:43:10.402 --> 01:43:15.389
<v Dan Ryan>Those who are paying taxes rightly expect that we have responsiveness to our city services.

990
01:43:16.695 --> 01:43:21.654
<v Dan Ryan>There were some agreements on this actually when we met as an elected body doing our priorities.

991
01:43:22.490 --> 01:43:23.554
<v Dan Ryan>You'll find those, they're there.

992
01:43:24.833 --> 01:43:28.393
<v Dan Ryan>We got to some basics as a group of 12 who don't always agree with each other.

993
01:43:28.442 --> 01:43:28.637
<v Dan Ryan>I agree with you.

994
01:43:28.948 --> 01:43:30.984
<v Dan Ryan>But there were some similarities on some.

995
01:43:33.618 --> 01:43:38.608
<v Dan Ryan>I need to see these bold and rational decisions when you deliver your proposed budget.

996
01:43:39.414 --> 01:43:42.127
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Mayor Wilson and City Administrator Lee.

997
01:43:42.483 --> 01:43:44.939
<v Dan Ryan>You are the dynamic duo that we have been waiting for.

998
01:43:45.649 --> 01:43:47.797
<v Dan Ryan>Please impress me and all Portlanders.

999
01:43:48.314 --> 01:43:48.639
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1000
01:43:49.527 --> 01:43:50.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1001
01:43:50.641 --> 01:43:51.222
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Novick.

1002
01:43:52.658 --> 01:43:53.644
<v Steve Novick>Thank you, Mr. President.

1003
01:43:54.193 --> 01:44:02.667
<v Steve Novick>I wanted to follow up on one of the things that Councilor Ryan just said about how we've added a new level of administration with the DCAs and haven't made countervailing cuts.

1004
01:44:03.533 --> 01:44:22.413
<v Steve Novick>And I talked a while ago to a former bureau director who said that, you know, it used to be under the commission form of government that the bureau director was sort of the public-facing person and the person who dealt with the commissioner, and the deputy sort of ran the bureau day to day.

1005
01:44:22.975 --> 01:44:26.552
<v Steve Novick>Now that the individual directors have a different role, do they still need deputies?

1006
01:44:27.162 --> 01:44:32.454
<v Steve Novick>I'm not going to target any particular bureau, but I just think that's a, that's a reasonable question, question to ask.

1007
01:44:33.144 --> 01:44:53.135
<v Steve Novick>Um, the public needs to know that the vast majority of the general fund goes to police, fire, parks, and other public safety, um, entities such as the community violence prevention folks that Councilor Pirtle-Guiney was talking about, Portland Street Response Etc.

1008
01:44:53.329 --> 01:45:01.170
<v Steve Novick>I do not want to cut any of those things, but we probably are going to have to cut them.

1009
01:45:01.783 --> 01:45:10.983
<v Steve Novick>In terms of— one thing I want to do is second what Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said about I do not want to cut the community violence prevention entities such as Ceasefire.

1010
01:45:12.179 --> 01:45:21.291
<v Steve Novick>When it comes to the police, I hope that we can avoid cutting out the special missions to address particular types of crime which the public really values.

1011
01:45:22.447 --> 01:45:28.789
<v Steve Novick>The special missions to address street racing, human trafficking, stolen vehicles, retail theft.

1012
01:45:29.657 --> 01:45:34.601
<v Steve Novick>One thing that the police do that I'm on record as saying I question is drug interdiction.

1013
01:45:35.774 --> 01:45:44.613
<v Steve Novick>Not breaking up open-air drug markets, which I think they should be doing, but trying to interrupt the overall, you know, international flow of drugs, which I think We're pretty bad at.

1014
01:45:45.891 --> 01:45:53.841
<v Steve Novick>When it comes to parks, as Councilor Pirtle-Guiney said, we made a promise to voters that if they pass the levy, we maintain the parks.

1015
01:45:55.703 --> 01:46:01.399
<v Steve Novick>I am not going to say right now that I'd support closing fire stations in order to preserve that promise.

1016
01:46:02.358 --> 01:46:04.801
<v Steve Novick>I suspect there will be some cuts to parks.

1017
01:46:05.746 --> 01:46:14.400
<v Steve Novick>One thing I will say is that in some circumstances, Raising recreation fees, although unpleasant, might be a reasonable option.

1018
01:46:16.023 --> 01:46:20.153
<v Steve Novick>When it comes to fire, all of the choices are incredibly unpleasant.

1019
01:46:22.079 --> 01:46:29.926
<v Steve Novick>There are— I wouldn't be surprised if the mayor comes out saying that some— there's some fire stations got a lot fewer calls than others.

1020
01:46:30.631 --> 01:46:42.052
<v Steve Novick>So I wouldn't be surprised if the mayor comes out with a budget that says we're going to close down the fire stations to get the the problem with that is that then you're saying to a neighborhood, if your house catches fire, it's going to burn to the ground.

1021
01:46:42.761 --> 01:46:43.469
<v Steve Novick>And I don't want to say that to anybody.

1022
01:46:44.681 --> 01:46:51.170
<v Steve Novick>On the other hand, another possible cut to fire is cutting the 2-person medical vehicles.

1023
01:46:52.893 --> 01:46:59.260
<v Steve Novick>And we could say that that's not as core as fighting fires, but those medical vehicles save lives.

1024
01:46:59.309 --> 01:46:59.895
<v Steve Novick>And they're not as expensive.

1025
01:47:00.329 --> 01:47:04.792
<v Steve Novick>So I have no brilliant suggestions as to what to— as to how to cut fire.

1026
01:47:05.405 --> 01:47:07.604
<v Steve Novick>I think that it's harder than anything else.

1027
01:47:08.537 --> 01:47:14.162
<v Steve Novick>Uh, so, uh, do they have anything else to say?

1028
01:47:16.069 --> 01:47:18.382
<v Steve Novick>Uh, no, that's about it.

1029
01:47:18.967 --> 01:47:19.292
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1030
01:47:20.349 --> 01:47:21.323
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Novick.

1031
01:47:22.298 --> 01:47:23.744
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Mayor, I put myself in the queue.

1032
01:47:24.329 --> 01:47:30.751
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, It is easy to list off things that I don't support cutting.

1033
01:47:31.170 --> 01:47:35.188
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to list some of those, but I'm going to start by saying things I do support cutting.

1034
01:47:37.350 --> 01:47:38.807
<v Jamie Dunphy>And some of these are going to make me deeply unpopular.

1035
01:47:41.880 --> 01:47:57.109
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I will start by quickly saying I had a meeting with the District 1 Coalition office, and almost every neighborhood association in District 1, plus an additional 50 15 nonprofits or NGOs that are serving, specifically serving populations in East Portland.

1036
01:47:57.591 --> 01:48:00.515
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I said explicitly to them, we have to cut the general fund.

1037
01:48:00.563 --> 01:48:04.980
<v Jamie Dunphy>That is police, that is fire, that is Portland Solutions, homeless services, and parks.

1038
01:48:05.381 --> 01:48:07.711
<v Jamie Dunphy>What are your red lines in this room?

1039
01:48:07.792 --> 01:48:10.956
<v Jamie Dunphy>What are the things that you absolutely need me to not cut?

1040
01:48:11.550 --> 01:48:15.983
<v Jamie Dunphy>And over and over and over again, the only thing I heard in the entire meeting was do not cut parks.

1041
01:48:16.930 --> 01:48:17.958
<v Jamie Dunphy>Honestly, I was genuinely surprised.

1042
01:48:19.418 --> 01:48:24.489
<v Jamie Dunphy>One person who's particularly mad about the fire department suggested we gut the fire department.

1043
01:48:24.890 --> 01:48:26.511
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't— I'm not advocating for that.

1044
01:48:26.961 --> 01:48:46.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I was surprised that the folks in East Portland who are most on the ground in the neighborhoods are advocating so strongly for parks as a public safety tool that when we let things— when we let the grass get overmowed, if we are, you know, overgrown and we don't mow it, if we let yes.

1045
01:48:46.311 --> 01:48:49.372
<v Jamie Dunphy>We plant trees and we let them die because we don't water them.

1046
01:48:50.622 --> 01:48:58.795
<v Jamie Dunphy>If we allow these public spaces to rot, they become attractive nuisances for bad behavior that degrades the broader neighborhood.

1047
01:48:59.292 --> 01:49:06.903
<v Jamie Dunphy>The example of Ventura Park was brought up to me where the— for over 3 years, the bathroom was chained shut.

1048
01:49:07.528 --> 01:49:12.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>When the bathroom was chained shut because it was broken and we weren't fixing it, parents stopped bringing their kids to the park.

1049
01:49:12.912 --> 01:49:15.412
<v Jamie Dunphy>When the kids stopped coming to the parks, tents started showing up.

1050
01:49:15.556 --> 01:49:17.818
<v Jamie Dunphy>When the tents started showing up, more tents started showing up.

1051
01:49:17.881 --> 01:49:22.722
<v Jamie Dunphy>At some point, drug dealing and violence showed up in the park and it became unusable.

1052
01:49:22.994 --> 01:49:25.576
<v Jamie Dunphy>When we fixed the bathroom, most of those problems went away.

1053
01:49:26.121 --> 01:49:33.382
<v Jamie Dunphy>So my community is telling me very clearly, please keep parks as whole as possible.

1054
01:49:33.574 --> 01:49:42.936
<v Jamie Dunphy>That said, I think that there are some really thoughtful reductions and discrete reductions within the cut packages that are proposed here around community centers, around tightening the margins.

1055
01:49:43.033 --> 01:49:47.850
<v Jamie Dunphy>I understand that we, you know, I I think the community centers are vital community public safety.

1056
01:49:49.677 --> 01:49:56.677
<v Jamie Dunphy>But I think that there are some thoughtful ways we can reduce some of the hours and really identify who we are saving and who we are serving.

1057
01:50:00.264 --> 01:50:06.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to say something unpopular that my council colleagues in District 2 will not appreciate.

1058
01:50:06.243 --> 01:50:06.404
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Pool.

1059
01:50:06.908 --> 01:50:08.398
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to talk about the pool center.

1060
01:50:08.974 --> 01:50:10.090
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to talk about the aquatic center.

1061
01:50:10.957 --> 01:50:24.144
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because in a moment where— not— in a moment where we are talking about which of our precious public assets we have to get rid of, I can't— I don't know.

1062
01:50:24.208 --> 01:50:30.059
<v Jamie Dunphy>It doesn't make sense to me for us to this year, in a moment where we are in a tough spot, to prioritize new items.

1063
01:50:31.394 --> 01:50:35.609
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I would be supportive of delaying the opening of the North Portland Aquatic Center.

1064
01:50:35.997 --> 01:50:37.266
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I apologize to the 3 of you.

1065
01:50:37.349 --> 01:50:38.016
<v Jamie Dunphy>You can fight me later.

1066
01:50:39.320 --> 01:50:50.206
<v Jamie Dunphy>I think that there are some really thoughtful proposals in this package around public safety overtime reductions, some staffing models, some efficient uses of available technology.

1067
01:50:52.555 --> 01:50:57.364
<v Jamie Dunphy>Some cuts around material purchases for playgrounds and pools makes sense to me.

1068
01:50:57.916 --> 01:51:04.402
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have some questions around a proposal in here that is— it's actually an ad package, and I have no idea if it's a real thing, but—.

1069
01:51:04.402 --> 01:51:04.854
<v Peter Holzman>It's not.

1070
01:51:05.134 --> 01:51:12.134
<v Jamie Dunphy>There's a $350,000 set aside for an Analyst 4 position around the transition of the P5 venues.

1071
01:51:12.570 --> 01:51:14.235
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want the P5 venues to transfer.

1072
01:51:14.284 --> 01:51:16.230
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm not sure why that position would cost $350,000.

1073
01:51:18.944 --> 01:51:27.350
<v Jamie Dunphy>Additionally, I'm hoping that you would consider looking at additions to the revenue collections staff.

1074
01:51:27.836 --> 01:51:37.311
<v Jamie Dunphy>I spoke with the Revenue Division Director who's told me that if they were to hire additional revenue collectors, they would bring in more money than they are— they cost.

1075
01:51:37.779 --> 01:51:48.600
<v Jamie Dunphy>So there is an opportunity that especially around arts tax and around some of the other taxes that we are having a harder time collecting, additional capacity will actually lead to further collection.

1076
01:51:49.182 --> 01:51:52.264
<v Jamie Dunphy>I don't know how to materially do that, but that is a thought.

1077
01:51:54.606 --> 01:52:07.398
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I will say I cannot myself justify voting for I'm not supporting the overnight shelters if we are laying off a single public employee in order to do that.

1078
01:52:07.720 --> 01:52:15.110
<v Jamie Dunphy>I know that you are working hard to find ways to support this and right-size this overnight shelter system right now, but it cannot be my priority.

1079
01:52:15.644 --> 01:52:19.595
<v Jamie Dunphy>Saving what we have here as a city and our employees has to be my priority.

1080
01:52:22.050 --> 01:52:23.619
<v Jamie Dunphy>Cuts that I don't support.

1081
01:52:24.493 --> 01:52:34.367
<v Jamie Dunphy>I am still vaguely disturbed by a piece of information I learned from the Bureau of Transportation that they add a cost multiplier for maintenance in East Portland because it is further away from the maintenance facility.

1082
01:52:35.168 --> 01:52:44.831
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to make sure that as we are doing thoughtful reductions, the aggregate effect is not disproportionate to reducing East Portland.

1083
01:52:46.179 --> 01:52:49.533
<v Jamie Dunphy>When we add nice things, sometimes East Portland still gets the less benefit.

1084
01:52:49.789 --> 01:53:02.231
<v Jamie Dunphy>And when we start cutting, for example, last year when there was a proposal around parks maintenance, half of the parks that were being proposed, I don't believe by you, but half the parks that were being proposed for cut of maintenance We're east of I-205.

1085
01:53:02.716 --> 01:53:06.534
<v Jamie Dunphy>We have very little and we need as much as we can get.

1086
01:53:07.020 --> 01:53:16.056
<v Jamie Dunphy>I want to add my support to what Councilor Smith and Green were saying with regard to neighborhood support programs like the neighborhood associations and the coalition offices.

1087
01:53:18.601 --> 01:53:24.636
<v Jamie Dunphy>I care a lot about what happens to children from the hours of 3 o'clock until 8 o'clock at night.

1088
01:53:25.297 --> 01:53:42.198
<v Jamie Dunphy>I started my career I spent a year working in middle schools, and I saw explicitly how teenagers who don't have something to do in the afternoon will find something to do, and they often get themselves into trouble and set themselves onto lifelong paths that they cannot correct.

1089
01:53:42.631 --> 01:53:47.201
<v Jamie Dunphy>Programs like Teen Force, Sun School, Summer Free-for-All, they literally save lives.

1090
01:53:48.774 --> 01:53:51.095
<v Jamie Dunphy>I have kids who are alive today because of Teen Force.

1091
01:53:53.740 --> 01:54:01.832
<v Jamie Dunphy>Similarly, I think that we've made a lot of really thoughtful progress with regard to some of the non-police public safety responses.

1092
01:54:01.930 --> 01:54:07.324
<v Jamie Dunphy>The police are our most expensive, most highly trained, most specialized tool in our toolbox.

1093
01:54:08.271 --> 01:54:17.198
<v Jamie Dunphy>And items like CHAT, PSR, PS3s are able to reduce the burden ultimately over time on them so that they can go do the jobs that only cops can do.

1094
01:54:18.002 --> 01:54:21.030
<v Jamie Dunphy>And we don't need them stopping traffic for car accidents and things like that.

1095
01:54:22.474 --> 01:54:29.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>As the economy is collapsing around us, workforce development programs feel obviously very important.

1096
01:54:30.007 --> 01:54:39.113
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as part of that, similarly, I'm urging this body to think broadly about the Office of Arts and Culture as a tool for economic development.

1097
01:54:39.161 --> 01:54:42.591
<v Jamie Dunphy>It needs to be considered an extension of our economic development work.

1098
01:54:43.024 --> 01:54:50.314
<v Jamie Dunphy>If we treat art as something precious, And something that just fulfills our soul, then of course it's the thing you want to cut out of the budget because it's disconnected.

1099
01:54:50.458 --> 01:54:59.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>But with diminishing dollars for Prosper Portland to invest in economic development, we're not going to build a new, you know, building anytime soon.

1100
01:54:59.511 --> 01:55:12.538
<v Jamie Dunphy>Light economic development through the existing music and arts scene are a way that we can get people safely out of their homes and into the public square and spending money and going to restaurants and going to shopping and all the things.

1101
01:55:12.603 --> 01:55:13.019
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Dan Ryan.

1102
01:55:15.090 --> 01:55:28.277
<v Jamie Dunphy>Lastly, I will say we need to make sure that we do not accidentally spite our future efforts by cutting PP&D, by cutting permitting and development staff, where I know that's not general fund.

1103
01:55:28.326 --> 01:55:29.565
<v Jamie Dunphy>It is obviously revenue division.

1104
01:55:30.242 --> 01:55:32.270
<v Jamie Dunphy>Their revenue is dependent on their own collections.

1105
01:55:32.399 --> 01:55:44.435
<v Jamie Dunphy>But we got to make sure that all the good work that this body is doing to encourage and demonstrate to the private sector that we are ready and open for for business, that there's somebody there to take their business when they come.

1106
01:55:44.516 --> 01:55:47.938
<v Jamie Dunphy>So very quickly going through my list of other things.

1107
01:55:50.250 --> 01:55:57.255
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, one other additional cut that I saw proposed in here was a grant that the city gives to the Multnomah County District Attorney's Office.

1108
01:55:57.787 --> 01:56:00.649
<v Jamie Dunphy>It's a nice-to-have, but we are not in nice-to-have years.

1109
01:56:00.698 --> 01:56:02.904
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so I would encourage us to cut that.

1110
01:56:03.195 --> 01:56:04.104
<v Peter Holzman>Thank you.

1111
01:56:06.458 --> 01:56:12.752
<v Jamie Dunphy>And additionally, I'll also voice my support that the cuts to the Auditor's Office beyond 3%.

1112
01:56:12.817 --> 01:56:21.054
<v Jamie Dunphy>Wanna make sure we are doing what we can to respect our fellow elected official in the execution of her duties.

1113
01:56:21.103 --> 01:56:25.646
<v Jamie Dunphy>So those are my very brief list of things that I care about.

1114
01:56:25.743 --> 01:56:26.432
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much.

1115
01:56:27.091 --> 01:56:27.895
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Clark.

1116
01:56:31.203 --> 01:56:32.480
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Council President.

1117
01:56:32.561 --> 01:56:33.386
<v Olivia Clark>Can you hear me okay?

1118
01:56:33.710 --> 01:56:33.920
<v Dan Ryan>Yep.

1119
01:56:35.552 --> 01:56:46.256
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I want to thank the mayor, uh, and the administration for creating this opportunity for us to share our thoughts about the budget, not just with you but with each other.

1120
01:56:46.483 --> 01:56:54.119
<v Olivia Clark>It's been valuable for me to hear all of you, what you have to say about your priorities, about your thinking about things.

1121
01:56:54.250 --> 01:56:55.765
<v Olivia Clark>So I, I really appreciate that.

1122
01:56:56.555 --> 01:57:06.198
<v Olivia Clark>I'm going to circle back To the issue of the city's core functions, that's what drives me, and it's really that back-to-basics theme.

1123
01:57:06.858 --> 01:57:08.302
<v Olivia Clark>I talk about it all the time.

1124
01:57:08.382 --> 01:57:10.293
<v Olivia Clark>I talked about it during the campaign.

1125
01:57:11.032 --> 01:57:20.939
<v Olivia Clark>I think that we in Portland have had a— our desires really don't match our pocketbook, and now we really do have to get back to basics.

1126
01:57:21.148 --> 01:57:23.653
<v Olivia Clark>And for me, one of those basics thank you.

1127
01:57:23.733 --> 01:57:31.985
<v Olivia Clark>The first thing that comes to mind when I think about police is really keeping us safe, improving 911 response times, keeping the streets safe with more eyes on the streets.

1128
01:57:32.146 --> 01:57:34.699
<v Olivia Clark>And, and that happens in lots of different ways.

1129
01:57:35.037 --> 01:57:41.604
<v Olivia Clark>But if I had a red line, mine would be no cuts to the number of police officers that we have.

1130
01:57:42.181 --> 01:57:47.417
<v Olivia Clark>We're already understaffed and we're experiencing retirements that we can barely keep up with.

1131
01:57:49.021 --> 01:57:53.556
<v Olivia Clark>I would offer a counterpoint to my colleague, Councilor Green.

1132
01:57:54.134 --> 01:57:57.851
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very— a strong supporter of the impact reduction program.

1133
01:57:57.899 --> 01:58:02.033
<v Olivia Clark>It's very important to me and to the neighborhoods in District 4.

1134
01:58:03.427 --> 01:58:19.922
<v Olivia Clark>I would offer a thought that I think in this process we need to do everything we can to improve our systems management, whether that's span of control, whether that's looking at asset management differently, and also tracking what it is that we own and what can we dispose of.

1135
01:58:20.820 --> 01:58:23.097
<v Olivia Clark>What can we offload as a city as well?

1136
01:58:23.145 --> 01:58:28.149
<v Olivia Clark>And we've talked about that in my committee in regards to, to some of our streets.

1137
01:58:29.176 --> 01:58:31.597
<v Olivia Clark>I think the core alignment process is good.

1138
01:58:31.662 --> 01:58:37.002
<v Olivia Clark>It's one of those system improvements that you really expect to come out of charter change.

1139
01:58:37.533 --> 01:58:41.895
<v Olivia Clark>I'd like to echo the support for neighborhood associations.

1140
01:58:41.990 --> 01:58:52.738
<v Olivia Clark>I'm really happy to hear many of my colleagues saying the same thing, that we need to support the neighborhood associations through the district coalition.

1141
01:58:53.412 --> 01:58:54.408
<v Olivia Clark>I think they're vital.

1142
01:58:54.681 --> 01:58:55.871
<v Olivia Clark>They provide services.

1143
01:58:56.064 --> 01:59:02.780
<v Olivia Clark>They bring value, whether it's a neighborhood emergency team, festivals, or whatever it is.

1144
01:59:02.893 --> 01:59:04.788
<v Olivia Clark>They bring a lot of value to us.

1145
01:59:05.368 --> 01:59:09.176
<v Olivia Clark>And I would echo Councilor Smith's comments regarding their dissatisfaction.

1146
01:59:09.224 --> 01:59:09.448
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Smith.

1147
01:59:09.962 --> 01:59:12.212
<v Olivia Clark>With their relationship with civic life.

1148
01:59:13.563 --> 01:59:19.974
<v Olivia Clark>Um, I think it's important to leverage their efforts and really to support volunteerism across the city.

1149
01:59:21.355 --> 01:59:32.025
<v Olivia Clark>And I've been an advocate for looking for opportunities for public-private partnerships, not just offloading assets, but as the mayor likes to say, how can we make our assets sweat?

1150
01:59:33.262 --> 01:59:45.390
<v Olivia Clark>I think that as a city, we need to be looking to making the parks sweat more, and we need to be more entrepreneurial when it comes to our parks and our assets.

1151
01:59:49.076 --> 02:00:01.087
<v Olivia Clark>And I know that in the past I've heard Councilor Zimmerman talk about programs that used to be in the parks that engage neighborhoods more, maybe looking out for their, their parks, more eyes on the parks.

1152
02:00:01.152 --> 02:00:02.221
<v Olivia Clark>I don't remember what that was called.

1153
02:00:02.287 --> 02:00:02.578
<v Loretta Smith>Parks for All.

1154
02:00:05.046 --> 02:00:12.426
<v Olivia Clark>Not exactly park rangers, but some sort of neighbors that really have a sense of ownership of their parks and protecting their parks.

1155
02:00:13.628 --> 02:00:19.372
<v Olivia Clark>Lastly, I would just say, I know that Councilor Zimmerman brought up or mentioned behavioral health.

1156
02:00:20.125 --> 02:00:30.215
<v Olivia Clark>That's not in our bailiwick, but we certainly experience the downstream problems with having people on the street that don't have services, that don't have a place to go.

1157
02:00:30.936 --> 02:00:48.720
<v Olivia Clark>I know that whatever we can do working with the county or whoever to address behavioral health and the impact on our streets, it's not a line item, a budget item, but I think it needs to be, it needs to be really focused, maybe our legislative agenda or whatever.

1158
02:00:49.971 --> 02:00:52.378
<v Olivia Clark>But those are just my high-level comments.

1159
02:00:53.662 --> 02:01:02.786
<v Olivia Clark>I know there has to be cuts, but I hope we can be really thank you, Councilor Clark—.

1160
02:01:02.786 --> 02:01:03.689
<v Jamie Dunphy>Vice President Clark.

1161
02:01:03.753 --> 02:01:04.608
<v Jamie Dunphy>I keep doing that, I'm sorry.

1162
02:01:05.460 --> 02:01:06.038
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Morillo.

1163
02:01:09.662 --> 02:01:10.371
<v Angelita Morillo>Thanks everyone.

1164
02:01:11.271 --> 02:01:17.756
<v Angelita Morillo>Mayor, thank you so much for being here today, and I want to say I'm sorry that you're— we're all having to make these budget decisions.

1165
02:01:17.819 --> 02:01:24.786
<v Angelita Morillo>I think it's an incredibly difficult time to be governing, and I appreciate everything that people have brought forward so far.

1166
02:01:25.353 --> 02:01:29.335
<v Angelita Morillo>I agree with a lot of what my colleagues have said, so I'll just be fairly brief.

1167
02:01:29.912 --> 02:01:40.606
<v Angelita Morillo>I agree with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney that we told the voters that we would be passing a parks levy so that we could preserve these services for the public, and I think that we have to keep our word and we have to do that.

1168
02:01:41.153 --> 02:01:53.573
<v Angelita Morillo>I also agree with her comments about preserving, making sure that we are not doing temporary cuts to public safety prevention work in order to do temporary savings that are actually going to cost us down the line.

1169
02:01:53.702 --> 02:02:09.613
<v Angelita Morillo>I'm specifically thinking about programs like the Office of Violence Prevention and everything that falls under that umbrella, because ceasefire and programs like that are what allow us to have a more diminished police force so that we can actually do some of that preventative work.

1170
02:02:10.015 --> 02:02:20.783
<v Angelita Morillo>And we know that when it comes to gun violence, when it comes to sex trafficking, when it comes to all of those types of issues, if we don't do that preventative work, It's not actually going to be resolved on later down the line.

1171
02:02:20.832 --> 02:02:26.041
<v Angelita Morillo>So I think anything that we can do to preserve our public safety prevention work is absolutely critical.

1172
02:02:26.921 --> 02:02:38.926
<v Angelita Morillo>Um, I am also not going to be supportive of using PCF dollars to backfill other parts of the budget that are not applicable to PCF dollars, and I'm going to guard that fairly carefully.

1173
02:02:39.583 --> 02:02:50.957
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that we have a lot of things that it has been flagged for its use, and Um, we cannot use PSF to address poor budgeting in other areas.

1174
02:02:51.213 --> 02:02:54.649
<v Angelita Morillo>I, I don't think that's healthy for our budget or for the expectations of the voters.

1175
02:02:55.389 --> 02:03:01.779
<v Angelita Morillo>The areas that I am comfortable cutting into— I agree with Councilor Dunphy, and I apologize to my colleagues in District 2.

1176
02:03:02.550 --> 02:03:05.649
<v Angelita Morillo>I do think the aquatic center needs to be removed.

1177
02:03:06.162 --> 02:03:11.108
<v Angelita Morillo>We should not be focusing on new assets while we are struggling to maintain the ones that we currently have.

1178
02:03:11.686 --> 02:03:23.222
<v Angelita Morillo>I also think we need to cut— I got really crucified last year for offering to cut part of the Portland Solutions package, even a small part of it.

1179
02:03:23.319 --> 02:03:27.859
<v Angelita Morillo>And the reality is we're probably going to have to have cuts to all of those things, including sweeps.

1180
02:03:29.099 --> 02:03:35.250
<v Angelita Morillo>We were promised that you would find additional funding for your shelter program that had one-time funding before.

1181
02:03:36.023 --> 02:03:38.603
<v Angelita Morillo>I hope that that comes into fruition, but I am not sure that it will.

1182
02:03:38.653 --> 02:03:38.963
<v Candace Avalos>Councilor Loretta Smith.

1183
02:03:39.466 --> 02:03:41.087
<v Angelita Morillo>And if that is the case, I agree.

1184
02:03:41.313 --> 02:03:51.171
<v Angelita Morillo>I don't think we should be cutting into our city infrastructure to support these temporary shelter programs because that's not really in our bucket to be working on.

1185
02:03:51.427 --> 02:03:57.046
<v Angelita Morillo>And I think the further we entrench ourselves in this system, the more concerns I have about its long-term viability.

1186
02:03:58.492 --> 02:04:03.341
<v Angelita Morillo>I also believe we need to be cutting back on the grants that go to the District Attorney's Office.

1187
02:04:03.404 --> 02:04:05.186
<v Angelita Morillo>These are dollars that we desperately need.

1188
02:04:05.395 --> 02:04:15.078
<v Angelita Morillo>We need to beef up our infrastructure, so they can't be going to a different the last thing I'll say is that I think we really need to maintain PS3s.

1189
02:04:15.895 --> 02:04:23.523
<v Angelita Morillo>They are an inexpensive part of our public safety system, inexpensive part of police, and we need to do everything we can to maintain that.

1190
02:04:23.747 --> 02:04:27.801
<v Angelita Morillo>Overall, I also think we need to take a look at when we are cutting departments.

1191
02:04:27.930 --> 02:04:35.957
<v Angelita Morillo>I think that we need to make sure we are not too management and top-heavy because we have a lot of people that do carry out the day-to-day work of the city and they need to be able to do that.

1192
02:04:36.020 --> 02:04:37.996
<v Angelita Morillo>Councilor Smith, and actually interface with Portlanders.

1193
02:04:38.349 --> 02:04:47.020
<v Angelita Morillo>And if we remove too many of those people, then we are going to lose the ability to give proper service to Portlanders and to get their questions and things answered in an expedient manner.

1194
02:04:47.518 --> 02:04:57.939
<v Angelita Morillo>So my focus is really going to be on making sure that we're reducing how many contracts we are contracting out for and instead building state and staff capacity for the city of Portland.

1195
02:04:58.645 --> 02:05:10.600
<v Angelita Morillo>These are all really tough decisions that have to be made, and I do not envy the task of having to present the first package, but, um, we are ready to, to help in that venture.

1196
02:05:10.649 --> 02:05:11.426
<v Angelita Morillo>So thank you.

1197
02:05:12.412 --> 02:05:13.287
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1198
02:05:13.448 --> 02:05:15.908
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Smith, you've spoken one time, right, so far?

1199
02:05:16.636 --> 02:05:17.346
<v Jamie Dunphy>Oh, okay, gotcha.

1200
02:05:17.654 --> 02:05:25.297
<v Jamie Dunphy>Uh, Councilor Avalos, uh, we cannot hear you.

1201
02:05:38.609 --> 02:05:39.207
<v Jamie Dunphy>Still nothing.

1202
02:05:40.771 --> 02:05:48.015
<v Dan Ryan>She said she'll be back.

1203
02:05:48.112 --> 02:05:49.737
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay, Councilor Avalos, we'll come right back to you.

1204
02:05:49.784 --> 02:05:52.841
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green, you, you have spoken, so I'm going to go to Councilor Kanal, come back to you.

1205
02:05:53.740 --> 02:05:54.224
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal.

1206
02:05:54.448 --> 02:05:55.654
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President.

1207
02:05:58.457 --> 02:06:01.266
<v Sameer Kanal>So yeah, I appreciate everything that's been said before.

1208
02:06:01.331 --> 02:06:13.244
<v Sameer Kanal>I think what I'm hearing, I'm feeling, and I hope we're all feeling a little validated by the fact that our colleagues have clearly listened to each other over the course of this last year and a half together, because I'm hearing stuff from people that I've heard from other people before, and I like that.

1209
02:06:14.497 --> 02:06:17.194
<v Sameer Kanal>Big picture, I love the idea of recommitting.

1210
02:06:17.628 --> 02:06:27.802
<v Sameer Kanal>I think one of the challenges that we have is that the core services the things that people largely view outside of our core services are often funded through a restricted pot of money anyway.

1211
02:06:28.203 --> 02:06:31.797
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's not as though that's going to alleviate a concern with the general fund.

1212
02:06:32.150 --> 02:06:39.819
<v Sameer Kanal>But I do really appreciate the theme of prevention and avoid being pennywise and pound foolish, to use Councilor Clark's phrase.

1213
02:06:40.235 --> 02:06:44.150
<v Sameer Kanal>First, let me say I agree with the broad philosophical approaches of both Councilors Zimmerman and Pirtle-Guiney.

1214
02:06:44.520 --> 02:06:50.484
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with the critique from Councilor Smith that our investments in the Office of the City Attorney Office of Community Engagement are not currently yielding what we hope they would.

1215
02:06:50.774 --> 02:06:58.965
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with Councilor Ryan as well around grants, especially as it relates to non-restricted, you know, general funds and reducing the part of the city that acts as a foundation.

1216
02:06:59.430 --> 02:07:06.354
<v Sameer Kanal>I have some acceptable cuts and some red flag cuts, but I want to start with the completely unacceptable cuts, meaning the ones that would change my vote on a budget.

1217
02:07:06.707 --> 02:07:09.158
<v Sameer Kanal>And these can easily be simplified down to will of the voters.

1218
02:07:09.735 --> 02:07:11.771
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe we owe it to voters to do what they told us to do.

1219
02:07:11.916 --> 02:07:13.279
<v Sameer Kanal>This holds true for the parks levy.

1220
02:07:13.342 --> 02:07:18.186
<v Sameer Kanal>I also knocked doors for that and I I know a lot of us did, and I agree 100% with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney here.

1221
02:07:18.427 --> 02:07:21.171
<v Sameer Kanal>It also applies to the OCPA and of course PCF.

1222
02:07:21.699 --> 02:07:22.984
<v Sameer Kanal>PCF is not for sweeps.

1223
02:07:23.385 --> 02:07:33.251
<v Sameer Kanal>We cannot lose the fragile trust we're rebuilding with our community and our new form of government by taking a fund designed to help communities in need and instead use it to harm an overlapping list of communities in need.

1224
02:07:33.733 --> 02:07:35.833
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also want to stress the will of council.

1225
02:07:35.881 --> 02:07:40.679
<v Sameer Kanal>There are a few things that have been voted on last year that would have saved money that have not been implemented.

1226
02:07:41.257 --> 02:07:46.095
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to really talk through that because that's an important thing to talk about.

1227
02:07:46.560 --> 02:07:49.533
<v Sameer Kanal>I have some lists of acceptable cuts and unacceptable cuts.

1228
02:07:49.951 --> 02:07:54.858
<v Sameer Kanal>I also have some acceptable revenue options and unacceptable revenue options.

1229
02:07:55.213 --> 02:08:01.614
<v Sameer Kanal>But I want to lead off with an investment that I think will save us money in the long run, which is awards for employees who find savings.

1230
02:08:02.054 --> 02:08:05.112
<v Sameer Kanal>This is something that the Secretary of State's office in Washington State does.

1231
02:08:05.453 --> 02:08:08.838
<v Sameer Kanal>This is something that's— there's chief savings officers in New York now.

1232
02:08:09.287 --> 02:08:20.564
<v Sameer Kanal>I think if an employee comes up with a way to, uh, without losing any quality of service, save $400,000, a giant check for $1,000 to reward them and a photo op is a good use of our time and money.

1233
02:08:21.222 --> 02:08:23.710
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, acceptable cuts.

1234
02:08:23.805 --> 02:08:30.832
<v Sameer Kanal>I do think we need to have a conversation about overnight shelters and the conversation, um, around, uh, that in particular.

1235
02:08:30.927 --> 02:08:39.783
<v Sameer Kanal>I, I, I noted the, uh, ombudsman's report today about, um, how the number of complaints about Portland Solutions, which includes but is not limited to that.

1236
02:08:39.849 --> 02:08:43.716
<v Sameer Kanal>And I, I don't want to pin this on the shelter program, it's the broader, uh, strokes.

1237
02:08:44.166 --> 02:08:48.595
<v Sameer Kanal>Had it at 27%, uh, and, and transportation at 28%.

1238
02:08:48.819 --> 02:08:57.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Anyone who's followed along with the ombuds reports knows that, uh, transportation generally gets the most complaints, um, because they do the most different things.

1239
02:08:57.646 --> 02:09:01.064
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but specifically I'm talking about sweeps and the impact reduction program.

1240
02:09:01.274 --> 02:09:14.957
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to double down on everything Councilor Green and Councilor Maria I do think that it's time to find the small amounts of cost savings, but still real ones, that we will have from incorporating Portland Solutions into the regular flow of the administration.

1241
02:09:15.694 --> 02:09:19.896
<v Sameer Kanal>Either make it a service area or put it into the existing service areas.

1242
02:09:20.988 --> 02:09:23.442
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to look at going into overtime.

1243
02:09:23.554 --> 02:09:28.926
<v Sameer Kanal>I think we've done a really good job, and I want to commend both you as well as PPB and fire leadership.

1244
02:09:29.408 --> 02:09:35.390
<v Sameer Kanal>I also know that they've both done a good job in hiring, so we should expect to see some overtime reductions as a result of that.

1245
02:09:36.722 --> 02:09:42.096
<v Sameer Kanal>And this is where I think the council direction on how to spend overtime dollars is a conversation that I'll be looking at.

1246
02:09:42.417 --> 02:09:47.502
<v Sameer Kanal>If they're spending it in line with council priorities, that helps me justify why they should continue to get it.

1247
02:09:47.631 --> 02:09:49.235
<v Sameer Kanal>If not, it doesn't.

1248
02:09:49.395 --> 02:09:49.942
<v Sameer Kanal>Contracts.

1249
02:09:50.118 --> 02:09:51.658
<v Sameer Kanal>Grateful that many people brought this up.

1250
02:09:51.722 --> 02:09:59.824
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll note that New York City just canceled a contract with McKinsey that they found they'd already paid $4 million to assess if trash cans were better than leaving trash bags in the street.

1251
02:10:01.336 --> 02:10:01.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's absurd.

1252
02:10:02.380 --> 02:10:03.729
<v Sameer Kanal>Mayor Muddati found that money.

1253
02:10:04.082 --> 02:10:05.689
<v Sameer Kanal>Let's see if we're doing anything like that too.

1254
02:10:05.833 --> 02:10:09.542
<v Sameer Kanal>Even that's scaled to Portland's budget size, I think it would be worth saving the money.

1255
02:10:10.921 --> 02:10:16.083
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm looking forward to the administrator's report including that so we can dig deep into it.

1256
02:10:16.551 --> 02:10:19.278
<v Sameer Kanal>Contracted employees who could be converted to city employees for cheaper.

1257
02:10:19.632 --> 02:10:21.088
<v Sameer Kanal>Protect 17 sent a letter.

1258
02:10:21.496 --> 02:10:22.457
<v Sameer Kanal>I co-sign it.

1259
02:10:23.125 --> 02:10:25.127
<v Sameer Kanal>And then span of control has already been mentioned.

1260
02:10:25.460 --> 02:10:25.893
<v Steve Novick>Thank you.

1261
02:10:27.323 --> 02:10:29.637
<v Sameer Kanal>Cuts I'd like to avoid: prevention programs.

1262
02:10:30.136 --> 02:10:34.041
<v Sameer Kanal>Underfunding prevention at the expense of intervention only makes our future budget woes worse.

1263
02:10:34.490 --> 02:10:36.668
<v Sameer Kanal>There's value to balancing those out.

1264
02:10:36.782 --> 02:10:47.251
<v Sameer Kanal>Violence prevention like OVP and Ceasefire, crime prevention like Safe Blocks, Rose City Self-Defense, interventions that keep people from becoming houseless such as affordable and social housing and rent assistance.

1265
02:10:48.619 --> 02:10:55.560
<v Sameer Kanal>And cutting— an unacceptable cut would be cutting the alternative shelter to fund overnight shelter.

1266
02:10:56.444 --> 02:10:57.615
<v Sameer Kanal>Community safety programs.

1267
02:10:57.969 --> 02:11:01.324
<v Sameer Kanal>Portland's in the process of building out a holistic community and public safety system.

1268
02:11:01.405 --> 02:11:06.414
<v Sameer Kanal>We need to rethink how we evaluate what parts of those systems are core.

1269
02:11:07.041 --> 02:11:09.578
<v Sameer Kanal>We need to maintain momentum in building out that system.

1270
02:11:10.237 --> 02:11:22.054
<v Sameer Kanal>Obviously armed officers and firefighters are essential, and I'm not suggesting cutting there, but I really want to make sure we're talking about Portland Street Response, Chat, PS3s, park rangers, PBEM.

1271
02:11:22.439 --> 02:11:34.029
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'll just highlight 2 specific programs: victim advocates at PPB, which are force multipliers for work in a particular sector of PPB's work, and the rescues, those 2-person response vehicles at fire.

1272
02:11:34.719 --> 02:11:36.694
<v Sameer Kanal>I really want to make sure that we're not cutting those.

1273
02:11:36.742 --> 02:11:38.346
<v Sameer Kanal>Those save money in the long run as well.

1274
02:11:39.615 --> 02:11:39.921
<v Candace Avalos>Equity.

1275
02:11:40.996 --> 02:11:45.523
<v Sameer Kanal>We cut OEHR down to the bone last year, so I want to see no more cuts.

1276
02:11:46.037 --> 02:11:54.153
<v Sameer Kanal>I also want to point out that my attempt to save— to cut deputy directors last year included that I was trying to save positions in OEHR with that money.

1277
02:11:54.506 --> 02:12:05.819
<v Sameer Kanal>I do want to look at the efficiencies we can find out of deputy directors, but I will be opposing any cuts to OEHR, including a cut to deputy directors in that space, if we don't add back positions there.

1278
02:12:07.112 --> 02:12:16.851
<v Sameer Kanal>And then the last 2 categories, democracy, small donor elections, the auditor's office, Council operations and offices, security for the spaces Portlanders come to to take part in their government.

1279
02:12:17.189 --> 02:12:19.886
<v Sameer Kanal>And I agree on the neighborhood associations conversation as well.

1280
02:12:20.560 --> 02:12:31.877
<v Sameer Kanal>And then finally, the people that help us raise money and, and save, uh, save costs, volunteerism work, and people who help achieve private investment in public goods, in particular within the Parks Bureau.

1281
02:12:32.761 --> 02:12:38.427
<v Sameer Kanal>On the revenue side, um, I just want to continue pushing back on regressive fee structures.

1282
02:12:38.541 --> 02:12:43.710
<v Sameer Kanal>I think Councilor Pirtle-Guiney basically hit everything there, so we'll save some time and I won't go back through it.

1283
02:12:44.144 --> 02:12:58.640
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I want to talk about 5 revenue options that I don't think have been brought up much, one of which will require a small upfront investment and start yielding a growing savings over time, which is FPDR.

1284
02:12:59.251 --> 02:13:05.414
<v Sameer Kanal>And I want to be clear for those whose hackles are raised already, I do not want to change a single part of the benefit structure.

1285
02:13:05.752 --> 02:13:09.202
<v Sameer Kanal>I want people to get what they are entitled to, what they've earned, and what they've agreed to.

1286
02:13:09.908 --> 02:13:22.533
<v Sameer Kanal>However, I want to make sure that the way we pay for it also includes an investment component, and that might involve a small capitalization up front to start yielding some investment returns that can help defray those costs over time.

1287
02:13:22.597 --> 02:13:28.806
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not going to cause— it's not going to save us a lot of money now, but it's something that I think is worth doing to save money in the long run.

1288
02:13:29.658 --> 02:13:35.881
<v Sameer Kanal>And again, it wouldn't affect a single thing of what our retired firefighters or police officers are receiving.

1289
02:13:37.466 --> 02:13:41.016
<v Sameer Kanal>The package delivery fee conversation, I'm excited to get back into that.

1290
02:13:41.725 --> 02:13:48.853
<v Sameer Kanal>Both of the budget notes on commercial and residential vacancy fees were delayed coming out of SEDSA.

1291
02:13:48.981 --> 02:13:50.935
<v Sameer Kanal>Those were supposed to be back on February 28th.

1292
02:13:51.305 --> 02:13:55.355
<v Sameer Kanal>The reason people haven't heard back is that they're now delayed to February 20th, I believe.

1293
02:13:55.823 --> 02:13:56.336
<v Jamie Dunphy>Might be 30th.

1294
02:13:56.528 --> 02:14:01.126
<v Sameer Kanal>But that's that's, uh, cutting it close for this year's budget, and that's why I picked February 28th.

1295
02:14:01.318 --> 02:14:11.045
<v Sameer Kanal>Unfortunately, we also saw that SEDSA spent $62,000 contracting out that work, which is deeply disappointing and not part of the conversation at all.

1296
02:14:11.654 --> 02:14:21.653
<v Sameer Kanal>But if it works out and we are able to raise some money, I think primarily on the commercial side, if this works out, that's something that can help not only pay for the $62,000 but start defraying some costs.

1297
02:14:22.710 --> 02:14:23.912
<v Sameer Kanal>And finally, Thank you.

1298
02:14:23.992 --> 02:14:24.088
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1299
02:14:24.136 --> 02:14:24.440
<v Sameer Kanal>Cost recovery.

1300
02:14:24.953 --> 02:14:26.332
<v Sameer Kanal>So I brought this up a few times.

1301
02:14:26.381 --> 02:14:29.057
<v Sameer Kanal>These are all pretty small things, but I think collectively they can do a lot.

1302
02:14:29.202 --> 02:14:33.354
<v Sameer Kanal>I know you're already committed to most of this, by the way, Mayor, in particular on the cost recovery side.

1303
02:14:33.435 --> 02:14:42.684
<v Sameer Kanal>But when we hire out police officers to staff, to block a road or something like that, it has impacts on wellness, it has impacts on overtime and things like that.

1304
02:14:42.747 --> 02:14:47.012
<v Sameer Kanal>But it also— we want to make sure we're getting paid the amount that it costs us to do.

1305
02:14:47.557 --> 02:14:49.529
<v Sameer Kanal>I think a bigger issue is the fire alarms.

1306
02:14:50.524 --> 02:14:53.333
<v Sameer Kanal>We send out commercial fire alarms, often go off.

1307
02:14:53.654 --> 02:15:00.347
<v Sameer Kanal>We have firefighters responding to that, or fire response to that, and BOEC obviously has to dispatch as well.

1308
02:15:00.957 --> 02:15:03.766
<v Sameer Kanal>They're often false alarms, and we don't charge for that.

1309
02:15:04.393 --> 02:15:11.359
<v Sameer Kanal>We've already explored this a little bit with the transportation side on the street repair side.

1310
02:15:11.712 --> 02:15:12.002
<v Sameer Kanal>I love it.

1311
02:15:12.338 --> 02:15:14.280
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to build off of that and do more.

1312
02:15:14.747 --> 02:15:21.846
<v Sameer Kanal>And so anytime we are— because really what we're not when we don't do cost recovery, what we're doing is subsidizing an activity.

1313
02:15:22.572 --> 02:15:28.699
<v Sameer Kanal>So if you don't charge enough for repairing the roads, you're subsidizing the utility to cut up the road.

1314
02:15:29.247 --> 02:15:36.882
<v Sameer Kanal>If you don't charge enough for cost recovery for a fire alarm, you are subsidizing someone not having to worry about whether or not their fire alarm's working.

1315
02:15:37.398 --> 02:15:39.988
<v Sameer Kanal>So these are the sorts of things I want to talk about on the revenue side too.

1316
02:15:40.132 --> 02:15:41.582
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't envy your job doing it.

1317
02:15:41.806 --> 02:15:43.190
<v Sameer Kanal>I appreciate that you're always willing to listen.

1318
02:15:43.876 --> 02:15:44.869
<v Sameer Kanal>And thanks for the time.

1319
02:15:44.997 --> 02:15:46.858
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just before my window.

1320
02:15:47.113 --> 02:15:48.733
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1321
02:15:49.405 --> 02:15:52.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Avalos, coming back to you to see if it works now.

1322
02:15:52.372 --> 02:15:52.948
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, does it work now?

1323
02:15:53.269 --> 02:15:54.390
<v Jamie Dunphy>We can hear you.

1324
02:15:54.872 --> 02:15:55.145
<v Candace Avalos>Perfect.

1325
02:15:55.256 --> 02:15:55.609
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1326
02:15:56.635 --> 02:15:57.854
<v Candace Avalos>And sorry I'm off center.

1327
02:15:57.981 --> 02:15:59.296
<v Candace Avalos>It's just very bright here.

1328
02:15:59.537 --> 02:16:01.748
<v Candace Avalos>So thanks, everybody.

1329
02:16:02.005 --> 02:16:04.666
<v Candace Avalos>Really appreciate what I've heard so far.

1330
02:16:04.905 --> 02:16:06.702
<v Candace Avalos>I'll start with my dittos.

1331
02:16:07.679 --> 02:16:11.658
<v Candace Avalos>I love a lot of what I heard from Kanal just now and thank you, Councilor Morillo.

1332
02:16:13.202 --> 02:16:27.706
<v Candace Avalos>Earlier from Council President, you know, I'm going to second a lot of what you said for East Portland and agree too with, you know, Green, Morillo, I think Kanal as well, who said do not touch PSF.

1333
02:16:28.271 --> 02:16:28.822
<v Candace Avalos>I've said enough.

1334
02:16:28.918 --> 02:16:29.889
<v Candace Avalos>You already know how I feel.

1335
02:16:31.322 --> 02:16:35.311
<v Candace Avalos>Overall, we need to protect the will of the voters and use their dollars appropriately.

1336
02:16:35.960 --> 02:16:44.278
<v Candace Avalos>I want to also echo The need to protect parks, and in particular, as I've already shared with you, Mayor, you got to fix the boiler at the East Portland Community Center.

1337
02:16:44.486 --> 02:16:54.950
<v Candace Avalos>It is unacceptable that that pool is closed indefinitely right now, and we are the only district that only has one community center, and we have the largest share of the city's children.

1338
02:16:55.078 --> 02:16:58.075
<v Candace Avalos>So you got to fix that at a bare minimum.

1339
02:16:58.443 --> 02:17:03.924
<v Candace Avalos>But like everyone else said, parks is what we hear the most about, especially Especially in East Portland.

1340
02:17:03.971 --> 02:17:10.239
<v Candace Avalos>That's also what rose to the top at my— what is it— my budget survey.

1341
02:17:11.649 --> 02:17:15.850
<v Candace Avalos>Agree with Councilor Pirtle-Guiney as it relates to protecting jobs.

1342
02:17:16.459 --> 02:17:21.012
<v Candace Avalos>You know, we don't want to hurt our workforce long-term to fix short-term problems.

1343
02:17:21.509 --> 02:17:27.343
<v Candace Avalos>And frankly, in this economy that is really fragile, we really need to do everything in our power to keep high-quality jobs.

1344
02:17:27.841 --> 02:17:29.636
<v Candace Avalos>That's going to protect the stability of the city overall.

1345
02:17:29.700 --> 02:17:29.907
<v Mitch Green>Councilor Smith.

1346
02:17:31.689 --> 02:17:41.130
<v Candace Avalos>Um, reflecting on what I heard from Councilor Zimmerman, I definitely agree to an extent as it relates to making hard decisions to cut things that aren't working.

1347
02:17:42.045 --> 02:17:45.042
<v Candace Avalos>But I don't think that all things that aren't working need to be cut.

1348
02:17:45.476 --> 02:17:49.868
<v Candace Avalos>And what I mean by that is I want to understand how we're measuring what's working.

1349
02:17:50.460 --> 02:17:55.990
<v Candace Avalos>I think that's, you know, so far from what I can tell, uh, in my year-plus at the city thank you.

1350
02:17:56.055 --> 02:18:05.518
<v Candace Avalos>So the success of programs is variable, and often the programs that are failing are due to not only a lack of resources but also a lack of political will to make them work.

1351
02:18:05.950 --> 02:18:11.323
<v Candace Avalos>So, and historically, those kinds of programs are the ones that most impact vulnerable communities.

1352
02:18:11.387 --> 02:18:23.289
<v Candace Avalos>So, you know, this is why I keep saying that I want to understand how we're measuring the services that we deliver as a city, and particularly I expect bureau directors to explain their vision and how they plan to execute it.

1353
02:18:23.882 --> 02:18:35.873
<v Candace Avalos>And, you know, by better— for us as legislators, by better understanding that, we can weigh those outcomes that we're fighting for, for our communities, against what our city is already doing, what they're good at doing.

1354
02:18:35.922 --> 02:18:44.300
<v Candace Avalos>Like Councilor Zimmerman said, I agree that we should, like, really invest more in what we're good at doing, but also where are we falling short for communities.

1355
02:18:44.429 --> 02:19:06.939
<v Candace Avalos>And obviously, I want to— I want to be able to participate in a discussion about making those hard decisions with the benefit of that kind of vision and more measurable outcomes that we can use to judge what's working and what's not, and therefore where we need to make hard decisions to cut things.

1356
02:19:07.761 --> 02:19:15.617
<v Candace Avalos>As far as broader priorities go, housing stability is the foundation for everything else, and we cannot afford to fall short here.

1357
02:19:16.072 --> 02:19:22.370
<v Candace Avalos>I think that my priorities are pretty clear based on how I've approached the investments with the unbudgeted housing funds, for example.

1358
02:19:23.206 --> 02:19:30.325
<v Candace Avalos>Right now, tenants, renters, they desperately need our intervention to prevent deepening the crisis on our streets.

1359
02:19:30.372 --> 02:19:38.695
<v Candace Avalos>So we have to keep investing in eviction prevention and rental assistance type things and all the kinds of wraparound services that keep people housed.

1360
02:19:39.933 --> 02:19:45.963
<v Candace Avalos>For transportation, You know, we need to ensure that our streets are safe and maintained at an equitable rate.

1361
02:19:46.269 --> 02:19:50.644
<v Candace Avalos>Again, that's something that East Portland and District 1 councilors are always going to harp on.

1362
02:19:51.637 --> 02:19:59.617
<v Candace Avalos>But we really just can't continue to take on projects and investments in order of price, but rather in order of least to most invested.

1363
02:20:00.674 --> 02:20:07.485
<v Candace Avalos>And communities that have historically been underinvested in, like East Portland, they cannot continue to sit at the bottom of that list.

1364
02:20:08.143 --> 02:20:14.610
<v Candace Avalos>This was something that was very much at the top of the East Portland Budget Survey as well that I did.

1365
02:20:14.721 --> 02:20:30.222
<v Candace Avalos>And particularly East Portlanders shared that they believe that the traffic and transportation inequities are a big contributor to their lack of community safety and feeling safe in East Portland.

1366
02:20:30.592 --> 02:20:32.726
<v Candace Avalos>They fear just walking around, right?

1367
02:20:32.854 --> 02:20:38.010
<v Candace Avalos>If you can't even just walk around, it's not just about crime, of course, that came up as well.

1368
02:20:39.250 --> 02:20:49.183
<v Candace Avalos>East Portlanders had shared in the budget survey that they struggle with walking around at night, but it's not just because of their fear of somebody hurting them.

1369
02:20:50.057 --> 02:20:52.725
<v Candace Avalos>It's also their fear of a car hitting them.

1370
02:20:52.805 --> 02:20:55.986
<v Candace Avalos>It's their fear of just not having the infrastructure to get from A to B.

1371
02:20:57.164 --> 02:21:02.709
<v Candace Avalos>And so I just want to elevate how important transportation justice is for community safety in East Portland.

1372
02:21:03.242 --> 02:21:08.963
<v Candace Avalos>Speaking of community safety, I think that we need to continue to invest in solutions that meet people where they are.

1373
02:21:09.798 --> 02:21:18.372
<v Candace Avalos>When we continue to put the burden on law enforcement to continually expand and push outside of their scope and work overtime, that is unfair.

1374
02:21:18.709 --> 02:21:27.413
<v Candace Avalos>We need to do our part to invest in the proven preventative measures like safe streets and clean parks, modern community spaces, and accessible health services.

1375
02:21:28.149 --> 02:21:34.672
<v Candace Avalos>Speaking of health, I really would like to see CHAT increase to a higher frequency, ideally 24/7.

1376
02:21:35.252 --> 02:21:46.278
<v Candace Avalos>If not this year due to obvious need for budget cuts, then I want to see a scaling-up plan for what that looks like in the coming years because CHAT is becoming more and more of an urgent need in East Portland.

1377
02:21:47.811 --> 02:21:59.059
<v Candace Avalos>Lastly, as it relates to just protecting our communities overall from the racial and social injustices that we're seeing, especially from the White House.

1378
02:21:59.690 --> 02:22:09.799
<v Candace Avalos>I did an interview this week with Noticias Noroeste, which by the way is the only Spanish language news station right now because Univision closed down at the end of 2024.

1379
02:22:10.575 --> 02:22:13.545
<v Candace Avalos>And I say that because people are really struggling to get information.

1380
02:22:14.206 --> 02:22:24.559
<v Candace Avalos>And one of the things that he said to me was that, you know, we were talking about the unbudgeted housing funds and he was like, okay, well, how are you going to get that information out to communities that don't speak English?

1381
02:22:24.627 --> 02:22:25.602
<v Candace Avalos>Because they are struggling.

1382
02:22:25.652 --> 02:22:25.701
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah.

1383
02:22:25.981 --> 02:22:27.475
<v Candace Avalos>To get access to resources.

1384
02:22:28.470 --> 02:22:31.843
<v Candace Avalos>So I just want to flag that as a continued need.

1385
02:22:32.308 --> 02:22:40.851
<v Candace Avalos>And as I said earlier, we now also are seeing that HUD is going to be denying a bunch of rental services to mixed-status families.

1386
02:22:40.915 --> 02:22:46.774
<v Candace Avalos>So again, putting yet another barrier in front of these communities that are already under attack.

1387
02:22:47.481 --> 02:22:51.254
<v Candace Avalos>And this particularly impacts children, often children who are citizens, by the way.

1388
02:22:52.218 --> 02:23:02.602
<v Candace Avalos>And so I think that the— and the other thing, the last thing he said to me was, you know, they were talking about like just broadly, you know, everything around immigration enforcement.

1389
02:23:03.131 --> 02:23:07.851
<v Candace Avalos>And the thing that he hears the most though is that people need food and a roof over their head.

1390
02:23:08.027 --> 02:23:09.841
<v Candace Avalos>That is the most urgent need right now.

1391
02:23:09.985 --> 02:23:11.990
<v Candace Avalos>So these are the basics for survival.

1392
02:23:12.778 --> 02:23:33.972
<v Candace Avalos>So I just want us to continue to think about how not only are we investing in those basics and investing and working in partnership with other governments, with organizations to reach communities, to share our resources so we can make the best use of them, but also to get that information out to people in a way that they can reach, right?

1393
02:23:34.149 --> 02:23:43.718
<v Candace Avalos>And we are just seeing these attacks on our communities becoming more violent, and their lasting impact is going to be really detrimental to our society and to our community's health.

1394
02:23:43.997 --> 02:23:46.279
<v Candace Avalos>And so we have to look at it from a health perspective.

1395
02:23:46.748 --> 02:23:50.584
<v Candace Avalos>I'm really concerned about a lot of families who are losing their breadwinners.

1396
02:23:50.648 --> 02:23:51.636
<v Candace Avalos>They're about to be homeless.

1397
02:23:51.700 --> 02:23:55.015
<v Candace Avalos>They have less resources because federal government is shutting them out.

1398
02:23:55.338 --> 02:24:00.300
<v Candace Avalos>It is our job as a city to step in where the federal government is clearly trying to hurt them.

1399
02:24:00.592 --> 02:24:02.337
<v Candace Avalos>So those are my priorities.

1400
02:24:02.434 --> 02:24:08.340
<v Candace Avalos>I know you have a tough job ahead, and I know I didn't give you perfect answers of all the things that you should cut.

1401
02:24:08.405 --> 02:24:09.837
<v Candace Avalos>I think it is kind of hard, as I've thank you.

1402
02:24:09.886 --> 02:24:20.888
<v Candace Avalos>I shared with you in the meeting as well to say what is the exact thing I should cut, because I feel like I will continue to say I would love for us to improve the kind of information that councilors are getting ahead of time.

1403
02:24:21.049 --> 02:24:31.475
<v Candace Avalos>I don't think that I have the tools right now to be able to assess all of the city's bureaus and their services and make thoughtful suggestions for things to cut.

1404
02:24:31.522 --> 02:24:37.707
<v Candace Avalos>So I know we're still in a growth year as far as trying to work out this system for how we do budgeting and how we legislate.

1405
02:24:38.494 --> 02:24:54.293
<v Candace Avalos>But I will continue to urge that we invest in our ability to have this information at our fingertips, to follow along while you're making your hard decisions so that by the time it comes to us, we are informed and we aren't just shooting in the dark.

1406
02:24:54.549 --> 02:25:01.791
<v Candace Avalos>We are able to be a partner to you in making those hard decisions instead of just a barrier because we are uninformed.

1407
02:25:01.855 --> 02:25:03.220
<v Candace Avalos>That's going to make your job harder.

1408
02:25:03.766 --> 02:25:11.787
<v Candace Avalos>So the more that your office, the city administrator, the budget office can do to give us more information, I think the better outcome for this entire process.

1409
02:25:12.123 --> 02:25:13.183
<v Candace Avalos>That's all.

1410
02:25:13.470 --> 02:25:13.664
<v Ruth Levine>Thanks.

1411
02:25:14.032 --> 02:25:14.978
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

1412
02:25:15.316 --> 02:25:18.427
<v Jamie Dunphy>Um, Councilor Kanal just pinged me that he forgot one thing before.

1413
02:25:18.637 --> 02:25:22.888
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to turn it to him, and then Councilor Green, you'll have the last word, and then Mayor, City Administrator, I'll turn it to you for the final.

1414
02:25:23.914 --> 02:25:24.492
<v Jamie Dunphy>So, Councilor Kanal.

1415
02:25:24.861 --> 02:25:25.358
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thanks.

1416
02:25:25.502 --> 02:25:30.539
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, first, I forgot to mention that I categorically oppose any pause to the North Portland Aquatic Center.

1417
02:25:31.148 --> 02:25:32.114
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, Council President.

1418
02:25:32.565 --> 02:25:33.272
<v Sameer Kanal>It's fine.

1419
02:25:33.370 --> 02:25:36.395
<v Sameer Kanal>But we did give up on the Columbia Pool.

1420
02:25:36.523 --> 02:25:39.420
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to be clear, the city did give that up.

1421
02:25:39.949 --> 02:25:40.416
<v Sameer Kanal>Not we.

1422
02:25:41.064 --> 02:25:44.407
<v Sameer Kanal>We, the city, at this moment is trying to give up on it.

1423
02:25:44.472 --> 02:25:56.398
<v Sameer Kanal>So I want to really focus on ensuring that we're investing in the places that have these inequities and try to make sure that we're cleaning those up.

1424
02:25:56.925 --> 02:25:57.183
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1425
02:25:57.566 --> 02:25:58.625
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1426
02:25:58.849 --> 02:25:59.250
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Green.

1427
02:26:00.083 --> 02:26:01.765
<v Mitch Green>It's a perfect segue for me.

1428
02:26:02.454 --> 02:26:10.290
<v Mitch Green>Uh, Council President, I, uh, I got back in the queue because I want to acknowledge that, you know, there is a difference of opinion among councilors in District 4 on some issues.

1429
02:26:11.108 --> 02:26:16.972
<v Mitch Green>Um, with all the due love and respect to Councilor Clark, we, we'll get, we'll get along just fine no matter how we show up in this budget.

1430
02:26:17.597 --> 02:26:28.069
<v Mitch Green>I suspect we won't be united like we are on the, uh, District 2, uh, North Portland Portland Aquatic Center, United Front, as oppositional to the council president on things like impact reduction plan.

1431
02:26:28.328 --> 02:26:28.815
<v Mitch Green>That's okay.

1432
02:26:28.976 --> 02:26:30.254
<v Mitch Green>Reasonable people can disagree.

1433
02:26:31.129 --> 02:26:37.435
<v Mitch Green>Um, I, I am standing for constituents that we have though that have asked specifically for me to take this position.

1434
02:26:37.485 --> 02:26:38.762
<v Mitch Green>So they're out there.

1435
02:26:39.408 --> 02:26:40.995
<v Mitch Green>They may not be at your town halls, but they're at mine.

1436
02:26:41.659 --> 02:26:47.533
<v Mitch Green>Um, I will say this, uh, you surfaced up something, Councilor Kanal, that I forgot.

1437
02:26:47.599 --> 02:26:47.680
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

1438
02:26:48.433 --> 02:26:49.396
<v Mitch Green>To motivate a little bit.

1439
02:26:49.459 --> 02:26:56.584
<v Mitch Green>When I think about Portland Solutions, it's not that I don't like a lot of the things that happen from Portland Solutions.

1440
02:26:56.631 --> 02:26:57.643
<v Mitch Green>I think they're doing great work.

1441
02:26:58.701 --> 02:27:05.923
<v Mitch Green>I just worry there's some stuff I don't agree with, but I think I don't throw the baby out with the bathwater.

1442
02:27:06.869 --> 02:27:16.031
<v Mitch Green>But I think what I'm really worried about is during the pandemic years, we created this ad hoc stand-apart organization that was designed to actually operate outside of the bureau.

1443
02:27:17.943 --> 02:27:22.423
<v Mitch Green>And I have yet to see that get integrated into our— we've had this conversation, City Administrator Lee.

1444
02:27:22.795 --> 02:27:27.128
<v Mitch Green>I've yet to see that get integrated into a way that's matrixed with our service areas.

1445
02:27:27.225 --> 02:27:28.631
<v Mitch Green>So I don't want 5 service areas.

1446
02:27:28.697 --> 02:27:36.752
<v Mitch Green>I want 4 service areas and a sort of way to have a span of control and a direct accountability that flows to the DCAs if we're going to have DCAs.

1447
02:27:36.800 --> 02:27:42.384
<v Mitch Green>So there are things in Portland Solutions' budget that I support and I like.

1448
02:27:42.432 --> 02:27:42.674
<v Keith Wilson>I agree.

1449
02:27:42.962 --> 02:27:47.557
<v Mitch Green>It's not a wholesale rejection of the group as a whole.

1450
02:27:48.427 --> 02:27:48.685
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Thanks.

1451
02:27:48.831 --> 02:27:49.765
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1452
02:27:51.443 --> 02:27:54.927
<v Jamie Dunphy>City Administrator, Mr. Mayor, any final parting words for us?

1453
02:27:55.930 --> 02:28:16.319
<v Raymond C. Lee>Yes, I first off want to just thank the councilors for providing their feedback today as it relates to the things that are resonating with them as they have a very important decision point coming up As the mayor's proposed budget is— will be released to the city council and the public as a whole.

1454
02:28:17.520 --> 02:28:35.959
<v Raymond C. Lee>I would also like to say in this as well, just a thank you to the staff that helped prepare the information, that helped formulate the budget that the mayor is still working on and tweaking on, but will potentially be developed and presented to the city council.

1455
02:28:36.448 --> 02:28:41.349
<v Raymond C. Lee>As a way for us to be able to move this organization and this community forward.

1456
02:28:42.172 --> 02:28:44.879
<v Raymond C. Lee>You know, but I would like to level set in this as well.

1457
02:28:45.950 --> 02:29:02.587
<v Raymond C. Lee>You know, some of the things that I hear the councilors talk about, every city I've been in have talked about similar things as it relates to how we make decisions, how information is being disseminated, how we're tracking the performance of how we're growing.

1458
02:29:03.227 --> 02:29:06.278
<v Raymond C. Lee>And developing and improving as an organization.

1459
02:29:07.674 --> 02:29:10.125
<v Raymond C. Lee>Those are all things we all strive to do.

1460
02:29:11.587 --> 02:29:20.700
<v Raymond C. Lee>But I just want to remind us, we're still at the infant stages of where we are as an organization and figuring out what our rhythm is as an organization.

1461
02:29:21.459 --> 02:29:23.981
<v Raymond C. Lee>We will get there, no doubt.

1462
02:29:24.111 --> 02:29:26.342
<v Raymond C. Lee>I have no question in my mind in that.

1463
02:29:27.360 --> 02:29:44.637
<v Raymond C. Lee>But as we go through this budget process, We're learning too, trial by error, as we go through this and really work with councilors as it relates to the information that you're going to need to make the important decisions that you have to make as you look forward to adopting the city's budget in the coming year.

1464
02:29:45.469 --> 02:29:55.148
<v Raymond C. Lee>You have the full commitment of the administration staff to get you the information that you need to make those decisions, but we have a lot of tough decisions ahead of us.

1465
02:29:55.727 --> 02:30:00.045
<v Raymond C. Lee>A lot of tough decisions that were going to be made in the mayor's proposed budget.

1466
02:30:00.542 --> 02:30:11.122
<v Raymond C. Lee>And nothing is easy in these type of cuts when you're looking at roughly $169 million of general fund operations and services.

1467
02:30:11.813 --> 02:30:21.926
<v Raymond C. Lee>So as we continue to go through it, we're open to the suggestions and bringing back information that will help make thoughtful and deliberate and intentional decisions.

1468
02:30:22.682 --> 02:30:25.965
<v Raymond C. Lee>Thank you.

1469
02:30:26.945 --> 02:30:27.332
<v Jamie Dunphy>Mr. Mayor.

1470
02:30:28.459 --> 02:30:30.533
<v Keith Wilson>Council President, colleagues, thank you for this opportunity.

1471
02:30:30.630 --> 02:30:31.354
<v Keith Wilson>I thought it was very thoughtful.

1472
02:30:32.180 --> 02:30:33.932
<v Keith Wilson>I thought it was a great conversation to hear from you.

1473
02:30:34.864 --> 02:30:36.150
<v Keith Wilson>I think there's a lot of alignment.

1474
02:30:36.231 --> 02:30:39.415
<v Keith Wilson>I want to thank Jonas, Ruth, and your teams.

1475
02:30:39.528 --> 02:30:47.379
<v Keith Wilson>We've spent weekends, weeknights, an awful lot of work, and I've told others this is frankly professionally the hardest thing I've ever done.

1476
02:30:48.435 --> 02:30:52.960
<v Keith Wilson>To Councilor Zimmerman's point at the very beginning of this, he said he doesn't want to see cute cuts.

1477
02:30:53.041 --> 02:30:58.662
<v Keith Wilson>There's nothing cute about this budget in the sense that these are always humans we're talking about.

1478
02:30:59.338 --> 02:31:03.467
<v Keith Wilson>These are teammates, these are coworkers, these are families, these are friends.

1479
02:31:04.209 --> 02:31:23.567
<v Keith Wilson>And so everything that we're going to provide to you has been thoughtful, has been built with a scaffolding sort of approach because it's about shared partnership, collaboration that our city's Bureaus have got to work and collaborate together because not one can stand alone anymore with the new org that we put together.

1480
02:31:23.617 --> 02:31:29.718
<v Keith Wilson>So I just thought that this was a great opportunity to hear from you and want to thank you for that gratitude.

1481
02:31:29.781 --> 02:31:35.016
<v Keith Wilson>Thank you for the grace of this conversation, and we're almost there.

1482
02:31:36.043 --> 02:31:36.284
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1483
02:31:36.671 --> 02:31:37.264
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you much, Mayor.

1484
02:31:38.050 --> 02:31:38.596
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Ryan.

1485
02:31:39.720 --> 02:31:40.844
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, President Dunphy.

1486
02:31:41.165 --> 02:31:52.592
<v Dan Ryan>One thing that wasn't lifted, and when we have conversations with the county on trying to get to role clarity and efficiency with housing and homelessness, when are we going to do that with public safety?

1487
02:31:53.057 --> 02:31:58.496
<v Dan Ryan>Half of the public safety services are at the county, but most Portlanders don't realize that.

1488
02:31:59.155 --> 02:32:07.644
<v Dan Ryan>And so our first responders struggle with where they're supposed to take people when many of the corrections have been closed, when treatment centers have been closed.

1489
02:32:07.756 --> 02:32:07.949
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1490
02:32:08.385 --> 02:32:21.246
<v Dan Ryan>When the DA's office has been defunded for about a decade, when we don't have enough district— when we don't have enough defenders, public defenders, so court cases can move, and then we're told that we just catch and release people quickly.

1491
02:32:21.906 --> 02:32:25.281
<v Dan Ryan>That's on the county, and the city gets blamed for that.

1492
02:32:25.377 --> 02:32:31.477
<v Dan Ryan>And we've never, in my opinion, I've been asking for this for 5 years, when are we gonna have that conversation with the county?

1493
02:32:35.337 --> 02:32:35.851
<v Keith Wilson>Council President?

1494
02:32:35.915 --> 02:32:36.188
<v Dan Ryan>Sure.

1495
02:32:36.700 --> 02:32:38.638
<v Keith Wilson>You know, I'm glad you brought that up, Councilor.

1496
02:32:38.863 --> 02:32:50.834
<v Keith Wilson>We have been having ongoing meetings with the judges, DA, sheriff, PPB, and our public safety officials on an ongoing basis because how we integrate together, it has to be a seamless system.

1497
02:32:51.299 --> 02:32:54.039
<v Keith Wilson>And when they have bottlenecks, we need to know.

1498
02:32:54.183 --> 02:32:59.055
<v Keith Wilson>And we're actually integrating that communication with, uh, real-time information back and forth now.

1499
02:32:59.310 --> 02:32:59.920
<v Keith Wilson>I, I agree with you.

1500
02:33:00.095 --> 02:33:04.118
<v Keith Wilson>It is something that's hurting our community writ large.

1501
02:33:04.278 --> 02:33:06.073
<v Keith Wilson>And so we really started that conversation.

1502
02:33:06.120 --> 02:33:07.514
<v Keith Wilson>I'm happy to say it's going well.

1503
02:33:07.963 --> 02:33:09.245
<v Keith Wilson>Plenty of room for improvement.

1504
02:33:09.406 --> 02:33:12.737
<v Dan Ryan>I hope in this budget process we hear how that's being actualized.

1505
02:33:13.476 --> 02:33:18.763
<v Dan Ryan>And since I'm on the public record and wanting to merge the city and the county, I'm very comfortable to push on this issue.

1506
02:33:18.939 --> 02:33:19.260
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1507
02:33:20.364 --> 02:33:21.199
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Ryan.

1508
02:33:21.343 --> 02:33:22.304
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Kanal, last word.

1509
02:33:22.384 --> 02:33:23.104
<v Jamie Dunphy>We got 1 minute.

1510
02:33:23.345 --> 02:33:35.316
<v Sameer Kanal>I just wanted to agree on having the conversation and say, when we say we, I'd love it if we included somebody, you know, include council in that because I'm sure the county commission has at least some insight into it.

1511
02:33:35.379 --> 02:33:44.709
<v Sameer Kanal>And it's sometimes frustrating not feeling like we have as much insight into the relationship building, at least in the public safety space, as maybe our colleagues on the commission over there do.

1512
02:33:44.772 --> 02:33:48.627
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'd love to be a part of that conversation or have someone on council be.

1513
02:33:48.932 --> 02:33:50.875
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Kanal.

1514
02:33:50.954 --> 02:33:52.047
<v Jamie Dunphy>Councilor Smith, 30 seconds.

1515
02:33:53.027 --> 02:33:55.575
<v Loretta Smith>Who is our, um, counselor on LPSIC?

1516
02:33:56.219 --> 02:33:56.930
<v Loretta Smith>Novick.

1517
02:33:57.139 --> 02:33:57.414
<v Loretta Smith>Novick.

1518
02:33:57.495 --> 02:34:01.757
<v Loretta Smith>So he's the person that you need to take those concerns— Novick.

1519
02:34:02.308 --> 02:34:07.828
<v Loretta Smith>Oh, because he— we have a LPSIC person that handles all of the law enforcement public safety stuff.

1520
02:34:07.909 --> 02:34:07.990
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Okay.

1521
02:34:18.906 --> 02:34:20.093
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you very much, colleagues.

1522
02:34:20.190 --> 02:34:22.066
<v Jamie Dunphy>With that, we are adjourned.

