WEBVTT

1
00:03:56.354 --> 00:03:56.905
<v Olivia Clark>They're really happy.

2
00:03:57.308 --> 00:03:57.907
<v Keelan McClymont>I've missed you.

3
00:03:58.294 --> 00:04:00.412
<v Candace Avalos>I wanted to challenge the order.

4
00:04:00.719 --> 00:04:02.223
<v Mitch Green>I'm so happy to be back where they used to be.

5
00:04:02.288 --> 00:04:02.675
<v Dan Ryan>So wholesome.

6
00:04:05.009 --> 00:04:06.050
<v Candace Avalos>Dark over here.

7
00:04:06.328 --> 00:04:07.336
<v Olivia Clark>I think that's weird.

8
00:04:07.467 --> 00:04:08.361
<v Olivia Clark>Why is it so dark?

9
00:04:09.824 --> 00:04:10.248
<v Keelan McClymont>Dark skirt.

10
00:06:18.043 --> 00:06:18.509
<v Sameer Kanal>Good morning.

11
00:06:18.942 --> 00:06:23.035
<v Sameer Kanal>I call the first ever meeting of the Portland City Council Committee of the Whole to order.

12
00:06:23.213 --> 00:06:26.490
<v Sameer Kanal>It is Thursday, April 2nd at 9:31 AM.

13
00:06:27.089 --> 00:06:28.372
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Keelan, will you please call the roll?

14
00:06:28.680 --> 00:06:29.180
<v Olivia Clark>Good morning.

15
00:06:29.454 --> 00:06:29.904
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney.

16
00:06:31.692 --> 00:06:31.918
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan.

17
00:06:32.497 --> 00:06:32.610
<v Dan Ryan>Here.

18
00:06:33.624 --> 00:06:34.091
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane.

19
00:06:34.509 --> 00:06:34.637
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Here.

20
00:06:35.072 --> 00:06:35.701
<v Keelan McClymont>Murillo.

21
00:06:37.745 --> 00:06:37.937
<v Angelita Morillo>Here.

22
00:06:38.132 --> 00:06:39.783
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sorry, I couldn't get my mic undone.

23
00:06:41.019 --> 00:06:41.247
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick.

24
00:06:42.422 --> 00:06:42.552
<v Steve Novick>Here.

25
00:06:43.401 --> 00:06:43.677
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark.

26
00:06:43.971 --> 00:06:44.151
<v Olivia Clark>Here.

27
00:06:44.559 --> 00:06:44.771
<v Keelan McClymont>Green.

28
00:06:45.048 --> 00:06:45.324
<v Mitch Green>Here.

29
00:06:45.846 --> 00:06:46.238
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman.

30
00:06:48.009 --> 00:06:48.254
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos.

31
00:06:48.613 --> 00:06:48.973
<v Candace Avalos>Present.

32
00:06:49.350 --> 00:06:49.759
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy.

33
00:06:49.987 --> 00:06:51.100
<v Sameer Kanal>Way over here on the side.

34
00:06:54.038 --> 00:06:54.264
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith.

35
00:06:55.189 --> 00:06:56.341
<v Loretta Smith>Here.

36
00:06:57.608 --> 00:06:59.555
<v Sameer Kanal>Christopher, will you please read the statement of conduct?

37
00:07:01.269 --> 00:07:03.696
<v Sameer Kanal>Welcome to the meeting of the Finance and Governance Committee of the Whole.

38
00:07:03.906 --> 00:07:16.110
<v Sameer Kanal>To testify before this committee in person or virtually, you must sign up in advance on the committee agenda at www.portland.gov/council/agenda/finance-and-governance-committee-whole or by calling 311.

39
00:07:16.163 --> 00:07:17.000
<v Shoshana Cohen>Information on engaging with the committee can be found at this link.

40
00:07:19.379 --> 00:07:22.189
<v Sameer Kanal>Registration for virtual testimony closes 1 hour prior to the meeting.

41
00:07:22.189 --> 00:07:25.009
<v Sameer Kanal>In-person testifiers must sign up before the agenda item is heard.

42
00:07:25.110 --> 00:07:30.949
<v Keelan McClymont>If public testimony will be taken on an item, you may testify for 3 minutes unless the Chair states otherwise.

43
00:07:31.029 --> 00:07:33.439
<v Keelan McClymont>Your microphone will be muted when your time is over.

44
00:07:33.569 --> 00:07:34.649
<v Keelan McClymont>The Chair preserves order.

45
00:07:34.649 --> 00:07:40.509
<v Keelan McClymont>Disruptive conduct such as shouting, refusing to conclude your testimony when your time is up, or interrupting others' testimony or committee deliberations will not be allowed.

46
00:07:40.509 --> 00:07:42.269
<v Keelan McClymont>If you cause a disruption, a warning will be given.

47
00:07:42.269 --> 00:07:44.230
<v Keelan McClymont>Further disruption results in ejection from the meeting.

48
00:07:44.230 --> 00:07:46.810
<v Keelan McClymont>Anyone who fails to leave once ejected is subject to arrest for trespass.

49
00:07:47.089 --> 00:07:49.009
<v Keelan McClymont>Additionally, the committee may take a short recess and reconvene virtually.

50
00:07:49.009 --> 00:07:53.610
<v Keelan McClymont>Your testimony should address when testifying, state your name for the record.

51
00:07:53.670 --> 00:07:56.310
<v Sameer Kanal>If you're a lobbyist, identify the organization you represent.

52
00:07:56.310 --> 00:07:58.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Virtual testifiers should unmute themselves when the clerk calls your name.

53
00:07:58.750 --> 00:08:00.189
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

54
00:08:00.189 --> 00:08:01.709
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Christopher.

55
00:08:01.709 --> 00:08:03.490
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, welcome to the Committee of the Whole.

56
00:08:03.629 --> 00:08:04.910
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm Sameer Kanal, the chair of the committee.

57
00:08:05.009 --> 00:08:11.689
<v Sameer Kanal>I am joined by my 2 vice chairs, Dan Ryan to my right, your left, and Tiffany Koyama Lane to my left, your right.

58
00:08:11.689 --> 00:08:16.300
<v Sameer Kanal>This is the first ever Committee of the Whole, so we're gonna start with a very brief description of what it is.

59
00:08:16.750 --> 00:08:20.910
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm gonna give both vice chairs as well as the council president a chance to address this part as well.

60
00:08:20.910 --> 00:08:21.029
<v Sameer Kanal>Following that, we'll have public testimony.

61
00:08:22.790 --> 00:08:28.192
<v Sameer Kanal>We have a brief Chair's update to look ahead to future meeting items that are coming up over the course of the month of April.

62
00:08:28.512 --> 00:08:36.014
<v Sameer Kanal>And then we have the bulk of our meeting devoted to 2 transportation funding items, which will be read together today for potential referral to the full Council.

63
00:08:36.831 --> 00:08:50.553
<v Sameer Kanal>As you all know, committees in general are a common way of allowing for informal discussion of items that are at the earlier stages of their development prior to final consideration at the full Council or for evaluating and discussing and receiving presentations from the administration.

64
00:08:51.034 --> 00:08:59.337
<v Sameer Kanal>Committees of the Whole, as the name implies, have all members of the full Council on them, but also allow for more relaxed rules of discussion, as well as, of course, different presiding officers.

65
00:08:59.450 --> 00:09:18.110
<v Sameer Kanal>In our committee restructure, we assigned several areas of work to this particular committee, including internal governance items, large-scale or broader finance items, government oversight, emergency response, including federal response, as well as items that cross over multiple committee jurisdictions or don't really fit into any particular committee of the other 4.

66
00:09:19.248 --> 00:09:25.836
<v Sameer Kanal>For all but the oversight piece, you'll see a fairly typical committee process with the same referral process for legislation to the full council and so on.

67
00:09:25.899 --> 00:09:30.500
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not designed to be a pro forma exercise, a step to just get things to the full council.

68
00:09:30.708 --> 00:09:31.783
<v Sameer Kanal>Instead, it's the opposite.

69
00:09:31.831 --> 00:09:36.543
<v Sameer Kanal>It's designed to be a place where real work on items can get done before they go to the full council.

70
00:09:37.041 --> 00:09:48.903
<v Sameer Kanal>And to that end, I anticipate that items that are referred out of this committee with a do pass recommendation, and I've asked the council president if we're able to just put those on the full council consent agenda.

71
00:09:49.368 --> 00:10:06.940
<v Sameer Kanal>Whereas items that still need some work can get referred out, but not with necessarily the do pass recommendation, but just referred out to the full council and then still have that work at On the other hand, you know, anyone can pull anything off the consent agenda as always.

72
00:10:07.210 --> 00:10:09.429
<v Sameer Kanal>For oversight hearings, it's going to work a little bit differently.

73
00:10:09.570 --> 00:10:22.730
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll talk about that more as we get closer to our first one, which the council president has scheduled in this committee on Thursday, April 23rd, pursuant to the resolution about looking into the housing dollars and how that came to be the $20.7 million.

74
00:10:22.889 --> 00:10:25.049
<v Sameer Kanal>And then finally, this committee has a unique schedule.

75
00:10:25.049 --> 00:10:28.590
<v Sameer Kanal>We meet the first 4 weeks of each month, although this month it will also meet on the 5th week, April 30th.

76
00:10:28.590 --> 00:10:32.799
<v Sameer Kanal>It'll take a recess in the middle of the month, and then we'll resume typically be Thursday mornings from 9:30 to 12:30.

77
00:10:33.217 --> 00:10:40.115
<v Sameer Kanal>However, the week that we have an evening council meeting, the 3rd week of each month, we're going to meet on Wednesday afternoons from 2 to 5 right before that.

78
00:10:41.100 --> 00:10:45.905
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, 2:30 to 5:30 right before the full council.

79
00:10:47.330 --> 00:10:50.842
<v Sameer Kanal>Vice Chairs Koyama Lane, Ryan, is there anything you'd like to add before we continue?

80
00:10:53.402 --> 00:10:54.061
<v Keelan McClymont>Thanks, Chair.

81
00:10:54.833 --> 00:10:57.312
<v Keelan McClymont>I'll take a moment to welcome everyone.

82
00:10:57.424 --> 00:10:57.956
<v Keelan McClymont>Good morning.

83
00:10:58.212 --> 00:11:02.717
<v Keelan McClymont>I personally get very nerdy about governance work and love to talk things through.

84
00:11:02.990 --> 00:11:07.260
<v Keelan McClymont>And so it's exciting to be able to do this with even more folks up here.

85
00:11:07.325 --> 00:11:18.143
<v Keelan McClymont>I do think governance works best when we have a range of perspectives, and especially when we're making decisions about how our body is going to function in this newish form of government.

86
00:11:18.191 --> 00:11:21.192
<v Keelan McClymont>It's important that we all have a chance to weigh in on items.

87
00:11:21.369 --> 00:11:24.499
<v Keelan McClymont>And so I'm just looking forward to many productive discussions together.

88
00:11:25.076 --> 00:11:26.056
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

89
00:11:27.227 --> 00:11:27.725
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

90
00:11:27.806 --> 00:11:37.719
<v Dan Ryan>And thank you, Chair Kanal, for— actually, we met right before break, the 3 of us, and Your vision and what this committee is has evolved since then, and I appreciate it.

91
00:11:39.033 --> 00:11:41.038
<v Dan Ryan>That's my way of saying welcome everybody.

92
00:11:41.341 --> 00:11:42.657
<v Dan Ryan>We're building something here.

93
00:11:43.506 --> 00:11:45.446
<v Dan Ryan>I think we're trying to figure out what this will be.

94
00:11:46.488 --> 00:11:51.667
<v Dan Ryan>Is it kind of like a work session prior to the official council meeting?

95
00:11:52.965 --> 00:11:56.364
<v Dan Ryan>You brought up something new about maybe things can go directly under consent.

96
00:11:56.427 --> 00:12:00.692
<v Dan Ryan>I can imagine that will be a debate led by you often.

97
00:12:01.477 --> 00:12:03.352
<v Dan Ryan>So I think that we're just gonna— I think we're gonna have to do that.

98
00:12:03.722 --> 00:12:05.135
<v Dan Ryan>Figure this out as we go along.

99
00:12:05.393 --> 00:12:14.822
<v Dan Ryan>I think today is a good example of something that all of us want to have more exposure to than going from a smaller committee directly to the whole council.

100
00:12:14.885 --> 00:12:18.115
<v Dan Ryan>So the agenda item today is, I think, a really good one to begin with.

101
00:12:18.178 --> 00:12:20.331
<v Dan Ryan>And thank you, Councilor Clark, in advance for all your work.

102
00:12:21.005 --> 00:12:26.532
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm here to help and build this with you, and let's be comfortable with the process.

103
00:12:26.788 --> 00:12:27.945
<v Dan Ryan>It'll be messy at times.

104
00:12:28.201 --> 00:12:28.379
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

105
00:12:28.845 --> 00:12:29.004
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

106
00:12:29.341 --> 00:12:30.351
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you both, Vice Chairs.

107
00:12:30.528 --> 00:12:32.178
<v Sameer Kanal>Council President Dunphy, anything you'd like to add?

108
00:12:32.467 --> 00:12:42.455
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, I just want to thank my colleagues, the city staff, and the public broadly for your patience and your willingness to try and pivot.

109
00:12:42.630 --> 00:12:43.320
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a big pivot.

110
00:12:43.368 --> 00:12:45.179
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a new change of how we are doing things.

111
00:12:45.756 --> 00:12:47.952
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not a new concept altogether.

112
00:12:48.017 --> 00:12:50.903
<v Sameer Kanal>It's quite common in other bodies, but we haven't done it yet.

113
00:12:51.047 --> 00:13:00.520
<v Sameer Kanal>And I look forward to seeing if this is a new part of our system that actually helps get the wheels of this machinery moving more efficiently.

114
00:13:01.395 --> 00:13:02.259
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you all for this.

115
00:13:02.374 --> 00:13:04.393
<v Sameer Kanal>And also I'm excited to be sitting on this side of the dais.

116
00:13:07.345 --> 00:13:08.678
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Council President Dunphy.

117
00:13:09.418 --> 00:13:18.505
<v Sameer Kanal>We're gonna do a brief chair's update at the— or report at the beginning of each of these meetings, mostly just to give some transparency as to what's coming up in the future agendas.

118
00:13:19.008 --> 00:13:24.775
<v Sameer Kanal>So first thing to mention is that if we don't have items filed, I'm very comfortable not having this committee meet.

119
00:13:25.003 --> 00:13:30.884
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think as we make the pivot over to the new system and things are still getting filed and reassigned, nothing's actually filed for next week.

120
00:13:31.908 --> 00:13:35.674
<v Sameer Kanal>So there is not going to be a Committee of the Whole meeting on Thursday, April 9th.

121
00:13:36.605 --> 00:13:46.206
<v Sameer Kanal>So I encourage anyone who's interested in, on this side of the dais or in the administration, to file things so that if you'd like them to be on here, because we're not going to just meet for the sake of meeting.

122
00:13:46.960 --> 00:13:49.172
<v Sameer Kanal>We will have a meeting on the 30th, as I mentioned.

123
00:13:49.220 --> 00:14:02.349
<v Sameer Kanal>So on the 15th, which is the Wednesday immediately before the evening council meeting, we have 3 appointments that we're expecting to be filed, as well as 2 bond-related issues relating to public works that we're expecting to be filed.

124
00:14:02.734 --> 00:14:05.951
<v Sameer Kanal>Should those be filed meet the, the administrative deadlines.

125
00:14:06.000 --> 00:14:08.339
<v Sameer Kanal>Those will be on the agenda the 15th.

126
00:14:08.452 --> 00:14:14.193
<v Sameer Kanal>The 23rd, the entire meeting is going to be that oversight hearing related to the housing dollars.

127
00:14:14.291 --> 00:14:17.850
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's Resolution 37734 that set that up.

128
00:14:18.335 --> 00:14:24.688
<v Sameer Kanal>And then on the 30th, we'll be talking primarily about federal response and items related to ICE.

129
00:14:27.226 --> 00:14:30.878
<v Sameer Kanal>As we go forward, I should have this written out in something that will be pre-filed as well.

130
00:14:32.289 --> 00:14:32.433
<v Sameer Kanal>Wow.

131
00:14:32.803 --> 00:14:55.620
<v Sameer Kanal>With that, this meeting the committee will consider an ordinance to establish a new transportation utility fee to help fund maintenance and safety of the city's transportation system, as well as considering a resolution to support the modification of the Portland Bureau of Transportation's street opening permits to utilities to include damage cost recovery related to long-term pavement degradation associated with excavation in the public right-of-way.

132
00:14:56.298 --> 00:14:59.354
<v Sameer Kanal>Keelan, would you please read both of these 2 agenda items together?

133
00:15:00.418 --> 00:15:13.566
<v Keelan McClymont>Agenda item 1, document number 2026-113, establish a new transportation utility fee to help fund basic maintenance and safety of the city's transportation system, ad code chapter 17.20.

134
00:15:13.630 --> 00:15:29.402
<v Keelan McClymont>Item 2, document number 2026-114, support modification of Bureau of Transportation street opening permits to utilities to include damage cost recovery related to long-term pavement degradation associated with excavation in the public right-of-way.

135
00:15:30.672 --> 00:15:32.870
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Keelan.

136
00:15:33.945 --> 00:15:40.990
<v Sameer Kanal>Vice President Clark is both the chair of the committee where this conversation was initiated and the lead sponsor, so I'll pass it over to her to begin the presentation.

137
00:15:41.903 --> 00:15:44.921
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you very much and good morning, Chair Kanal.

138
00:15:45.916 --> 00:15:46.494
<v Olivia Clark>Excuse me.

139
00:15:46.557 --> 00:16:06.412
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very pleased that transportation finance is the first issue that we're going to discuss in the Committee of the Whole because it's one of the most important and urgent infrastructure issues that we face these 2 measures are coming to you with the unanimous support of the T&I committee members.

140
00:16:07.245 --> 00:16:16.073
<v Olivia Clark>And over the last year, our committee set out to learn about asset management and the state of one of our most important assets, which is our streets and our roads.

141
00:16:17.099 --> 00:16:21.714
<v Olivia Clark>We learned that our streets are riddled with potholes and many of the streets are failing.

142
00:16:22.547 --> 00:16:25.158
<v Olivia Clark>The condition has worsened over the last 5 years.

143
00:16:25.206 --> 00:16:25.335
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

144
00:16:25.447 --> 00:16:25.639
<v Unidentified speaker>Order.

145
00:16:26.234 --> 00:16:35.297
<v Olivia Clark>We learned that if we do not act now to address the degradation of our streets, it will cost us up to 10 times more to replace them in the future.

146
00:16:36.500 --> 00:16:42.772
<v Olivia Clark>We learned that our streets, whether you drive on them or not, touch every Portland resident.

147
00:16:43.236 --> 00:16:52.828
<v Olivia Clark>They carry our food, our goods, our teachers, our doctors, our emergency vehicles, our buses, and they are our lifeline.

148
00:16:54.208 --> 00:17:06.309
<v Olivia Clark>And given what the 5 of us learned about street conditions and budget cuts, the budget cuts that PBOT has experienced over the last 7 budget cycles, we asked the bureau to research how to address the problem.

149
00:17:07.465 --> 00:17:11.990
<v Olivia Clark>And this was in a resolution that all of us voted for unanimously, I believe, in July.

150
00:17:12.200 --> 00:17:15.136
<v Olivia Clark>It was Resolution 37712.

151
00:17:15.650 --> 00:17:19.212
<v Olivia Clark>This last December, then, PBOT delivered that report to our committee.

152
00:17:19.902 --> 00:17:21.423
<v Olivia Clark>It's an excellent report, I must say.

153
00:17:21.505 --> 00:17:23.474
<v Olivia Clark>If you haven't looked at it, it's very comprehensive.

154
00:17:23.971 --> 00:17:32.977
<v Olivia Clark>And in January, we then asked the Bureau to take the top funding models to the streets, as it were, for a robust public engagement process.

155
00:17:33.922 --> 00:17:42.221
<v Olivia Clark>As a result of this work, the research, and the public input, we're here today with our T&I committee recommendations on how to move forward.

156
00:17:43.375 --> 00:17:51.512
<v Olivia Clark>Given the research in the report and what we've learned, we understand the extreme risk of doing nothing, and we are anxious to proceed today.

157
00:17:52.970 --> 00:18:02.273
<v Olivia Clark>PBOT today will review the challenge, the results of their work, and the outreach that led to the T&I Committee to bring forward the ordinance and resolution before you today.

158
00:18:04.742 --> 00:18:22.012
<v Olivia Clark>Before we turn this hearing over to the bureau and all the folks in the chamber who are here to offer their comments, Councilor Kanal, I would like to I invite my committee colleagues to each make a comment regarding today's process and the proposals.

159
00:18:23.248 --> 00:18:31.314
<v Olivia Clark>If we can, I'd like to begin with my esteemed co-chair— or vice chair, almost co-chair— Councilor Morillo to make a comment.

160
00:18:32.372 --> 00:18:35.852
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, Chair Clark, for your leadership on this issue.

161
00:18:36.461 --> 00:18:42.490
<v Olivia Clark>I'm very excited that we're discussing this as the first item of the Committee of the Whole, and I'm so grateful for the PBOT staff that are here today.

162
00:18:43.116 --> 00:18:54.003
<v Olivia Clark>I first want to commend them for all of the amazing work and research that they always bring to the table and how much outreach was done to arrive at this conclusion.

163
00:18:54.534 --> 00:19:07.588
<v Olivia Clark>There were open houses, there were online surveys, and we found that 78% supported the TUF and 87% supported the street damage restoration fee in those surveys.

164
00:19:08.038 --> 00:19:19.615
<v Olivia Clark>So I think that there is a myth that people don't want to pay more for good services, but I think that what we're actually seeing is that people are willing to pay as long as government is willing to deliver on those services.

165
00:19:20.593 --> 00:19:24.711
<v Olivia Clark>And our roads and our infrastructure is something that we can't allow to further decay.

166
00:19:25.320 --> 00:19:32.278
<v Olivia Clark>A few weeks ago, I got to do a tour at PBOT, and I got to meet with employees who are doing those frontline services.

167
00:19:32.855 --> 00:19:46.859
<v Olivia Clark>And the things that they told me about how critical maintenance is and the things that we don't even think about day to day, If we don't take care of that maintenance today, then our infrastructure is not going to survive the next few decades, let alone the next few years.

168
00:19:47.373 --> 00:19:50.689
<v Olivia Clark>So we have to make really difficult decisions right now.

169
00:19:51.521 --> 00:19:56.249
<v Olivia Clark>And there was a lot of community feedback given in order to arrive at this process.

170
00:19:56.729 --> 00:20:00.061
<v Olivia Clark>And we also now heard more feedback, and that's good.

171
00:20:00.190 --> 00:20:01.407
<v Olivia Clark>That's how democracy works.

172
00:20:01.455 --> 00:20:05.846
<v Olivia Clark>Sometimes things have to be adjusted as we gain new information and new perspectives.

173
00:20:06.261 --> 00:20:08.073
<v Olivia Clark>And so I'm really looking forward to the discussion today.

174
00:20:08.121 --> 00:20:08.729
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

175
00:20:09.146 --> 00:20:14.827
<v Olivia Clark>There are no easy fixes to the budget difficulties that we're facing and to the infrastructure difficulties.

176
00:20:15.260 --> 00:20:26.542
<v Olivia Clark>But I think that we have a lot of good people in this room and in this city who care about it and who want to do things for the long term at whatever cost that is to us personally, politically.

177
00:20:26.638 --> 00:20:29.800
<v Olivia Clark>I think we all are here in service of the city first and foremost.

178
00:20:29.865 --> 00:20:31.871
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you everyone for being here today.

179
00:20:31.934 --> 00:20:41.116
<v Olivia Clark>I'm really excited to have this discussion with everybody off the committee and I will miss the Transportation Committee very dearly, so I'm glad that we get to have these discussions here.

180
00:20:41.326 --> 00:20:41.598
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

181
00:20:41.807 --> 00:20:42.787
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Morillo.

182
00:20:43.348 --> 00:20:45.276
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Koyama Lane, would you like to make a comment?

183
00:20:46.240 --> 00:20:56.001
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, I want to start by thanking you, Councilor Clark, for your leadership in bringing this forward through the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, which that work will now be in the Public Works Committee.

184
00:20:56.901 --> 00:21:05.028
<v Keelan McClymont>And I see this item before us at its core I see it as aligning our values with our investments.

185
00:21:05.734 --> 00:21:15.874
<v Keelan McClymont>All 12 of us and Mayor Wilson have said we're committed to eliminating traffic deaths and serious injuries on our streets here in Portland, also known as Vision Zero.

186
00:21:16.276 --> 00:21:19.730
<v Keelan McClymont>But we know Vision Zero isn't just a statement of intent.

187
00:21:20.036 --> 00:21:36.501
<v Keelan McClymont>If it's going to be real, it has to require sustained, reliable funding to redesign streets, to reduce speeds, to make safety improvements, This ordinance takes a step in that direction by establishing a transportation utility fee.

188
00:21:36.821 --> 00:21:47.340
<v Keelan McClymont>We're creating a more stable funding source for the basics— maintaining our streets, fixing sidewalks, investing in safer infrastructure across the city, across the system.

189
00:21:48.191 --> 00:21:50.771
<v Keelan McClymont>And I want to underscore something really important.

190
00:21:52.070 --> 00:21:54.828
<v Keelan McClymont>Vision Zero is explicitly named in this ordinance, and that matters.

191
00:21:54.893 --> 00:21:55.005
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

192
00:21:55.566 --> 00:21:57.971
<v Keelan McClymont>It signals that safety isn't an afterthought.

193
00:21:58.387 --> 00:22:02.315
<v Keelan McClymont>It's a core priority guiding how these dollars should be spent.

194
00:22:03.356 --> 00:22:08.502
<v Keelan McClymont>And I also want to acknowledge my office has been hearing a lot from community members, especially in the last week or two.

195
00:22:08.727 --> 00:22:13.615
<v Keelan McClymont>We've been reading a lot of emails, picking up the phone, and hearing a lot about the transportation utility fee.

196
00:22:14.017 --> 00:22:22.127
<v Keelan McClymont>I look forward to hearing directly from the public as we move forward on this and want to acknowledge that this proposal is not perfect.

197
00:22:22.272 --> 00:22:36.586
<v Keelan McClymont>And for some families, we talked about this in the T&I committee, the additional cost is significant, and it's so important that we are thoughtful about that and make sure that we're planning for and supporting households that truly can't afford to pay more.

198
00:22:36.715 --> 00:22:42.865
<v Keelan McClymont>And these are conversations that we've all had, and I know that you're— we're all committed to continuing.

199
00:22:43.717 --> 00:22:52.419
<v Keelan McClymont>So I do believe if we're serious about reducing traffic deaths, we have to match the commitment with real resources, and I believe that this gets us closer to doing exactly that.

200
00:22:52.920 --> 00:22:55.411
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, Councilor Koyama Lane.

201
00:22:56.074 --> 00:23:00.230
<v Olivia Clark>I know that Councilor Loretta Smith will join us later, but let's turn to Councilor Mitch Green.

202
00:23:02.113 --> 00:23:03.465
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Madam Vice President.

203
00:23:05.259 --> 00:23:22.824
<v Mitch Green>Colleagues, when I ran for this seat, a lot of what I talked about was infrastructure, and I talked about investments, and I basically made the argument that what we really need in a city council are leaders who recognize that if we don't invest today, Aye.

204
00:23:23.727 --> 00:23:26.325
<v Mitch Green>Those are the stakes.

205
00:23:26.792 --> 00:23:41.867
<v Mitch Green>And I think when you drive down our roads and you hit the pothole and you experience that, you're dealing with the cost of previous generations' decision not to invest forward.

206
00:23:41.932 --> 00:23:45.528
<v Mitch Green>So this is a rolling lifecycle obligation that we have.

207
00:23:46.458 --> 00:23:50.248
<v Mitch Green>And so, you know, no one wants to be the city councilor that votes yes on a new fee.

208
00:23:50.836 --> 00:23:54.681
<v Mitch Green>And you might get thrown out for it, but that's the job, and I'm prepared to do it.

209
00:23:56.070 --> 00:24:06.498
<v Mitch Green>I think that if we allow our assets to depreciate fully, that's not only an inconvenience, but that is a significant cost to future generations.

210
00:24:07.396 --> 00:24:16.644
<v Mitch Green>And I think that impact is borne disproportionately on some of our lowest-income Portlanders, because in areas like District 1, if Councilor Smith were here, she would make this point.

211
00:24:16.693 --> 00:24:23.882
<v Mitch Green>I know I know the other 2 councilors are thinking about it too, is District 1 has neighborhoods that have never even had the infrastructure.

212
00:24:24.829 --> 00:24:28.509
<v Mitch Green>And areas in my district also suffer that same experience as well.

213
00:24:28.685 --> 00:24:46.634
<v Mitch Green>And so if we don't pass a stable revenue structure that we can rely upon year over year, then we're going to see an increasing share of our scarce resources go to paying for the ever-increasing rising costs those are the stakes.

214
00:24:47.404 --> 00:24:51.036
<v Mitch Green>And so those communities will wait even longer.

215
00:24:51.824 --> 00:24:54.314
<v Mitch Green>And so I think that's why we need to pass a TUF today.

216
00:24:54.731 --> 00:24:56.032
<v Mitch Green>We need to do this.

217
00:24:56.096 --> 00:24:57.640
<v Mitch Green>This is a moment for bold leadership.

218
00:24:57.703 --> 00:25:08.709
<v Mitch Green>And I really, really want to thank you for your leadership, Councilor Clark and Councilor Murillo, in orienting the transportation infrastructure to give the space and direction to PBOT to bring us forward with a TUF.

219
00:25:08.821 --> 00:25:09.126
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

220
00:25:12.476 --> 00:25:23.325
<v Mitch Green>Later on in the discussion, I'll have another idea that we should contemplate that I'm hearing from community, but I want to be very clear that my intention is to pass a TUF.

221
00:25:24.238 --> 00:25:26.786
<v Mitch Green>And so let's get into that discussion.

222
00:25:26.882 --> 00:25:27.426
<v Mitch Green>Thank you so much.

223
00:25:28.163 --> 00:25:29.589
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Green.

224
00:25:30.502 --> 00:25:35.117
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Kanal, without further ado, shall we have PBOT make their presentation?

225
00:25:35.165 --> 00:25:35.886
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

226
00:25:36.432 --> 00:25:41.059
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, so I, I just want to note that there are, uh, 5 invited panels after this.

227
00:25:41.107 --> 00:25:46.087
<v Sameer Kanal>So from a timing perspective, our goal is to get through everybody, uh, before we take a break in the middle of the meeting.

228
00:25:46.136 --> 00:25:51.887
<v Sameer Kanal>And I've been asked by the sponsor to, uh, assist in assertively reminding people of the timing.

229
00:25:52.481 --> 00:25:57.558
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, so, uh, I'll be gentle about that, but just wanted to give a heads up.

230
00:25:57.943 --> 00:26:15.012
<v Sameer Kanal>And I believe that we'll have staff in the room afterwards, so if, if it's possible to hold questions to the degree that it thank you, Chair Kanal, and thank you, Vice President Clark.

231
00:26:15.238 --> 00:26:19.451
<v Unidentified speaker>For the record, my name is Priya Dhanapal, the Deputy City Administrator for Public Works Service Area.

232
00:26:20.486 --> 00:26:28.128
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to acknowledge the members of the Committee of the Whole and Chair Kanal as well as you begin your work together on this— on important citywide issues.

233
00:26:28.726 --> 00:26:33.048
<v Unidentified speaker>And we appreciate the opportunity to bring this issue forward early on in your discussions.

234
00:26:34.500 --> 00:26:46.606
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to thank Mayor Wilson, Council Vice President Clark, and members of the former Transportation and Infrastructure Committee for your leadership and partnership in advancing this conversation about the future of transportation funding in Portland.

235
00:26:47.721 --> 00:26:51.646
<v Unidentified speaker>We are here today to present this resolution and ordinance for your consideration.

236
00:26:54.115 --> 00:27:09.957
<v Unidentified speaker>As Chair Clark mentioned, every day Portlanders rely on our transportation system to get to school, our transportation network is the connective tissue of the city's economy, livability, and safety.

237
00:27:11.200 --> 00:27:15.792
<v Unidentified speaker>And yet the system is facing a fundamental structural funding challenge.

238
00:27:17.211 --> 00:27:19.746
<v Unidentified speaker>When that happens, the system does not stay the same.

239
00:27:20.214 --> 00:27:20.893
<v Unidentified speaker>It declines.

240
00:27:21.748 --> 00:27:25.784
<v Unidentified speaker>Streets get worse, safety projects get delayed, and basic services get reduced.

241
00:27:25.848 --> 00:27:26.026
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

242
00:27:27.310 --> 00:27:35.765
<v Unidentified speaker>The result is a growing gap between community expectations and the ability to maintain streets, sidewalks, and bridges Portlanders depend on.

243
00:27:38.680 --> 00:27:49.035
<v Unidentified speaker>During the recent Public Works Services Service Area budget work session, you heard that PBOT is facing a significant shortfall for the fiscal year 26-27.

244
00:27:50.535 --> 00:27:52.345
<v Unidentified speaker>This is not a new problem.

245
00:27:53.534 --> 00:28:00.416
<v Unidentified speaker>PBOT has faced funding gaps for 7 consecutive years, and the structural reasons are clear.

246
00:28:01.416 --> 00:28:10.040
<v Unidentified speaker>The transportation revenues at the federal, state, and local levels have not kept pace with the cost of maintaining and operating a safe and reliable system.

247
00:28:11.890 --> 00:28:33.476
<v Unidentified speaker>This year's shortfall is the latest in a long line of years where we've had to cut services, draw down resources, and reduce our workforce without additional stable revenue sources, PBOT will increasingly be forced to scale back basic maintenance, safety improvements, and core transportation services Portland is dependent on.

248
00:28:34.681 --> 00:28:42.445
<v Unidentified speaker>This council directed us to find a path forward and explore sustainable alternative funding approaches, and that work is what you'll hear about today.

249
00:28:43.544 --> 00:28:53.817
<v Unidentified speaker>This discussion today is critical to stabilizing Portland's transportation system and ensuring that we can continue to provide and protecting the infrastructure that Portlanders rely on every day for our safety, for our economy, and for the quality of life.

250
00:28:54.703 --> 00:28:55.333
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

251
00:28:59.922 --> 00:29:14.087
<v Unidentified speaker>I want to acknowledge the significant work done by PBOT, our partners in the Revenue Division, and the CFO's Office over the past several months to analyze options, develop and refine revenue approaches, and provide meaningful opportunities for community outreach.

252
00:29:14.784 --> 00:29:15.105
<v Unidentified speaker>Input.

253
00:29:16.053 --> 00:29:25.095
<v Unidentified speaker>I also want to thank many of you for helping spread the word about our open houses in each of your districts and for participating in the engagement process, including attending them.

254
00:29:26.412 --> 00:29:40.449
<v Unidentified speaker>I believe this effort has been a good demonstration of how in this new form of government we can work collaboratively across bureaus, service areas, and across the executive and legislative branches to address long-term financial challenges.

255
00:29:41.692 --> 00:29:42.305
<v Unidentified speaker>Next slide, please.

256
00:29:44.451 --> 00:29:52.738
<v Unidentified speaker>Today's presentation will walk through the transportation funding challenge, the analysis and engagement work that has been completed, and the proposed revenue options before you today.

257
00:29:53.401 --> 00:29:57.736
<v Unidentified speaker>And after the presentation, you'll hear both invited testimony as well as public testimony.

258
00:29:58.442 --> 00:30:05.223
<v Unidentified speaker>And with that, I will turn it over to Director Williams to provide an overview of our transportation funding challenges and system impacts.

259
00:30:06.477 --> 00:30:07.103
<v Millicent Williams>Next slide, please.

260
00:30:08.242 --> 00:30:09.205
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you, DC Adonapal.

261
00:30:09.847 --> 00:30:14.825
<v Millicent Williams>Good morning, Chair Kanal, Vice Chairs Koyama Lane and Ryan, and members of council.

262
00:30:15.227 --> 00:30:19.786
<v Millicent Williams>For the record, my name is Millicent Williams, and I am the director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

263
00:30:20.701 --> 00:30:29.179
<v Millicent Williams>I want to start by acknowledging that those of you on the former Transportation and Infrastructure Committee have seen most of these slides before, some of them a few times.

264
00:30:29.596 --> 00:30:49.358
<v Millicent Williams>However, for others of you, this may be new information, so we have a good amount to cover, and we'll try to do that We don't want to miss important notes, though, so please have a little patience with us as we want to make sure that we are amplifying significant points so that you, as well as those watching, will be able to understand fully what we're talking about.

265
00:30:50.402 --> 00:30:58.372
<v Millicent Williams>A series of actions, as has been mentioned, and a lack of action at every level have led us to our current transportation funding crisis.

266
00:30:59.190 --> 00:31:01.226
<v Millicent Williams>Transportation revenues have simply not kept pace with the growth of our city.

267
00:31:01.355 --> 00:31:01.595
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

268
00:31:02.237 --> 00:31:04.036
<v Millicent Williams>With significantly rising costs.

269
00:31:04.727 --> 00:31:12.871
<v Millicent Williams>Federal funding really never addresses our maintenance and operations needs, and even federal grants for capital projects have become more limited.

270
00:31:13.497 --> 00:31:27.295
<v Millicent Williams>At the state level, the referral of the 2025 State Transportation Funding Bill to voters means we cannot count on the $10.6 million that we would have received this fiscal year and the $24 million that we would have received for next year.

271
00:31:27.958 --> 00:31:36.330
<v Millicent Williams>And at the local level, our 10-cent gas tax has lost half of the buying power that it had when it was first passed in 2016.

272
00:31:37.140 --> 00:31:41.692
<v Millicent Williams>This is all significantly eroding our ability to maintain our transportation system.

273
00:31:42.230 --> 00:31:42.832
<v Millicent Williams>Next slide, please.

274
00:31:44.440 --> 00:31:47.430
<v Millicent Williams>This slide illustrates the limitations of our funding streams.

275
00:31:47.948 --> 00:31:59.651
<v Millicent Williams>Most of the revenue that comes in is in restricted— excuse me— is in restricted locations and dedicated to specific projects and activities that cannot be shifted.

276
00:32:00.692 --> 00:32:01.685
<v Millicent Williams>And I want to underscore that.

277
00:32:02.134 --> 00:32:09.618
<v Millicent Williams>We often— and you often get emails from your constituents or calls from your constituents or when you're out in community and they say, why isn't PBOT doing this instead of that?

278
00:32:10.132 --> 00:32:13.803
<v Millicent Williams>It is because we have restrictions on the ways that we can use the funding.

279
00:32:14.378 --> 00:32:19.042
<v Millicent Williams>And if we could, we would divert as much of that to those basic fundamental needs.

280
00:32:19.364 --> 00:32:23.611
<v Millicent Williams>But that is something that we are simply not able to do legally or by policy.

281
00:32:23.659 --> 00:32:23.755
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

282
00:32:24.877 --> 00:32:33.842
<v Millicent Williams>Many of these funds are grant funds that we've applied for to build specific projects, and they can only be used on those projects and cannot be reallocated in other ways.

283
00:32:34.035 --> 00:32:40.913
<v Millicent Williams>Unfortunately, there are generally not grant funds available for maintenance and operations activities, only for new capital projects.

284
00:32:41.796 --> 00:32:50.199
<v Millicent Williams>Another example of our restricted funds is the work that we do for other bureaus, like the Bureau of Environmental Services, who pays us to provide sewer and stormwater maintenance work.

285
00:32:50.712 --> 00:32:53.426
<v Millicent Williams>Those funds must be used for that work.

286
00:32:54.069 --> 00:33:03.835
<v Millicent Williams>The discretionary funding that we have for basic maintenance, safety, and operations, like filling potholes, is General Transportation Revenue, or GTR, which you will hear referenced several times today.

287
00:33:04.509 --> 00:33:11.882
<v Millicent Williams>These funds come from state highway funds, parking revenue, and Transportation Network Company ride fees, or TNC ride fees.

288
00:33:12.460 --> 00:33:18.545
<v Millicent Williams>These are the user fees that currently pay for the majority of the maintenance and safety next slide, please.

289
00:33:19.941 --> 00:33:25.894
<v Millicent Williams>As you all know, PBOT manages a complex transportation system with assets worth almost $22 billion.

290
00:33:26.922 --> 00:33:35.634
<v Millicent Williams>Again, our limited revenues simply have not been keeping up, and we would now need over $6 billion to bring the system up to fair or better condition.

291
00:33:36.388 --> 00:33:37.078
<v Millicent Williams>Next slide, please.

292
00:33:38.298 --> 00:33:51.887
<v Millicent Williams>PBOT has faced, as has been mentioned, years of budget challenges, and since 2019, we have had to take $42 million in reductions to general transportation revenue-funded programs and services such as paving maintenance and residential street sweeping.

293
00:33:52.576 --> 00:33:59.618
<v Millicent Williams>We've also had to draw down our GTR reserves and cut 66 general transportation revenue-funded full-time equivalent positions.

294
00:34:00.373 --> 00:34:03.147
<v Millicent Williams>We are now facing another year of severe budget challenges.

295
00:34:03.500 --> 00:34:12.789
<v Millicent Williams>Without new revenues, we will have a budget gap of at least $25 million, which will further erode our ability to maintain and operate the transportation system.

296
00:34:13.077 --> 00:34:13.817
<v Millicent Williams>Next slide, please.

297
00:34:14.715 --> 00:34:17.300
<v Millicent Williams>You can see the impacts of our funding challenges on our streets.

298
00:34:17.782 --> 00:34:19.516
<v Millicent Williams>Pavement conditions are declining.

299
00:34:19.612 --> 00:34:29.070
<v Millicent Williams>Currently, 72% of our local streets are in poor or very poor condition, and 64% of our busy streets are in poor or very poor condition.

300
00:34:29.809 --> 00:34:30.355
<v Millicent Williams>Next slide, please.

301
00:34:31.351 --> 00:34:39.853
<v Millicent Williams>And even though the number of traffic fatalities and serious injuries on our streets has declined in recent years, They remain unacceptably high.

302
00:34:40.862 --> 00:34:41.514
<v Millicent Williams>It is unacceptable.

303
00:34:42.619 --> 00:34:46.831
<v Millicent Williams>We have unfunded traffic safety projects with proven crash reduction strategies.

304
00:34:47.349 --> 00:34:50.572
<v Millicent Williams>Additional funding would help us to complete more of these projects.

305
00:34:51.277 --> 00:34:51.746
<v Millicent Williams>Next slide, please.

306
00:34:53.088 --> 00:35:01.862
<v Millicent Williams>Simply put, new funding sources would help us stabilize our workforce, stabilize our services, and address critical needs.

307
00:35:02.608 --> 00:35:03.014
<v Millicent Williams>Next slide, please.

308
00:35:04.311 --> 00:35:09.789
<v Millicent Williams>Now I'll turn it over to Mark Lear, who will review how we got to the resolution and ordinance before you today.

309
00:35:10.496 --> 00:35:12.570
<v Millicent Williams>And with that, Mark, next slide, please.

310
00:35:13.887 --> 00:35:14.980
<v Mark Lear>Thank you, Director Williams.

311
00:35:15.237 --> 00:35:16.731
<v Mark Lear>For the record, my name is Mark Lear.

312
00:35:16.795 --> 00:35:19.510
<v Mark Lear>I'm PBOT's Policy Partnership and Resource Manager.

313
00:35:20.394 --> 00:35:26.452
<v Mark Lear>This slide in front of you highlights the process that Council Vice President Clark just described.

314
00:35:27.063 --> 00:35:27.271
<v Mark Lear>Move in.

315
00:35:27.608 --> 00:35:29.380
<v Mark Lear>Oh, the Council President thank you, Mr.

316
00:35:29.380 --> 00:35:29.460
<v Mark Lear>Chair.

317
00:35:29.460 --> 00:35:40.389
<v Mark Lear>So the document Vice President Clark just described, it describes a process that really kicked off in July with council moving forward with a resolution that directed staff to develop the alternative funding report.

318
00:35:40.639 --> 00:35:52.469
<v Mark Lear>We provided that report back to council, or to the T&I Committee, in January, and they forwarded that recommendations for us to go out and have our public conversation with in February and March.

319
00:35:52.719 --> 00:35:57.420
<v Mark Lear>We now are here today to talk to you more in more detail about those recommendations.

320
00:35:58.541 --> 00:35:58.976
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

321
00:36:00.135 --> 00:36:05.545
<v Mark Lear>This next slide includes a list of the 23 different revenue mechanisms that were evaluated in our report.

322
00:36:06.376 --> 00:36:12.413
<v Mark Lear>The initial list of options were identified by reviewing funding mechanisms being used in Oregon and other cities across the country.

323
00:36:12.751 --> 00:36:13.219
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

324
00:36:15.092 --> 00:36:32.789
<v Mark Lear>Each of the potential funding mechanisms was evaluated using the following 5 evaluation criteria: revenue capacity, Next slide.

325
00:36:34.731 --> 00:36:49.083
<v Mark Lear>This slide highlights the 4 options that rose to the top in our evaluation: the transportation utility fee, a street damage restoration fee, a retail delivery fee, and a prepared food delivery fee, which are still at the top of the list.

326
00:36:49.550 --> 00:36:53.094
<v Mark Lear>In more of the conceptual phase at this point.

327
00:36:53.563 --> 00:36:58.804
<v Mark Lear>The proposals before you today are focused on a transportation utility fee and the street damage restoration fee.

328
00:36:59.157 --> 00:36:59.608
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

329
00:37:01.574 --> 00:37:09.538
<v Mark Lear>A transportation utility fee is a monthly fee charged to residents and businesses to pay for basic road maintenance and safety improvements.

330
00:37:10.119 --> 00:37:22.318
<v Mark Lear>In all of the 31 Oregon cities that have a transportation utility fee, the fee is collected on the public utility bill yes.

331
00:37:22.818 --> 00:37:37.525
<v Mark Lear>This mechanism has a number of advantages, including it is broad-based, allows for substantial revenue generation at relatively low cost for each payer, revenue is not tied to fossil fuels, and it uses existing billing systems to lower administrative costs.

332
00:37:38.563 --> 00:37:46.025
<v Mark Lear>Everyone pays, everyone benefits, and there are opportunities to address equity issues using existing low-income discount programs.

333
00:37:46.380 --> 00:37:46.913
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

334
00:37:48.864 --> 00:38:00.963
<v Mark Lear>This slide highlights the 9 jurisdictions in the Portland metro area with transportation utility fees, and it includes the rate for single-family homes and multifamily homes or properties.

335
00:38:01.494 --> 00:38:07.626
<v Mark Lear>This is not a new tool, and its simplicity and ease of implementation has been one of the keys to its success.

336
00:38:08.907 --> 00:38:20.097
<v Mark Lear>As of today, the regional average charge per month for a single-family home is $12.08, and the regional average per month for multifamily properties is $9.49 per unit.

337
00:38:20.804 --> 00:38:33.697
<v Mark Lear>Multifamily properties pay less per month than single-family properties because on average they generate fewer trips per property due to factors like owning fewer cars, living closer to daily needs, and consolidated deliveries.

338
00:38:34.440 --> 00:38:40.282
<v Mark Lear>At the regional level, properties pay— multifamily properties pay about 79% of the single-family rate.

339
00:38:40.784 --> 00:38:47.512
<v Mark Lear>Our proposal sets that multifamily rate at 70% of the single-family rate based on trip generation estimates.

340
00:38:48.010 --> 00:38:48.461
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

341
00:38:50.525 --> 00:39:01.039
<v Mark Lear>This slide highlights the 3 transportation utility fee scenarios that were shared with the public at our open houses and online survey and in meetings with different organizations.

342
00:39:01.795 --> 00:39:10.581
<v Mark Lear>The scenarios were developed to represent 50%, 75%, and 100% of the regional average for the single-family household.

343
00:39:11.373 --> 00:39:39.670
<v Mark Lear>Based on trip generation analysis of trips associated with residential properties and nonresidential properties, all 3 of these scenarios assume that 70% are based on 70% of trips generated by residential properties the nonresidential commercial portion of this fee is proposed to be collected based on a percentage of the existing water, sewer, and stormwater bill.

344
00:39:39.670 --> 00:39:42.409
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

345
00:39:42.409 --> 00:39:49.030
<v Mark Lear>The next couple of slides provide more detail on the specific— the street damage restoration fee.

346
00:39:49.030 --> 00:39:53.164
<v Mark Lear>The street damage restoration fee would compensate the city for the damage caused Aye.

347
00:39:53.150 --> 00:39:53.230
<v Candace Avalos>By the stormwater event.

348
00:39:53.230 --> 00:39:53.269
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

349
00:39:53.307 --> 00:39:53.628
<v Candace Avalos>Opposed?

350
00:39:53.677 --> 00:39:53.708
<v Candace Avalos>Nay.

351
00:39:53.773 --> 00:39:54.206
<v Mark Lear>Motion passes.

352
00:39:54.253 --> 00:39:58.340
<v Mark Lear>The city will charge a street opening permit fee for a portion of the lost asset life resulting from utility cuts and trenching work.

353
00:39:59.126 --> 00:40:10.331
<v Mark Lear>Engineering studies indicate that trenching work reduces the useful life of roads by over 60%, resulting in streets needing to be repaved every 5 years versus every 15 years.

354
00:40:11.148 --> 00:40:17.126
<v Mark Lear>While we currently have a street opening permit, the fee that we charge only covers the cost of administer— administering the program.

355
00:40:17.512 --> 00:40:20.637
<v Mark Lear>It does not compensate the city for the damage caused to the roadway.

356
00:40:21.248 --> 00:40:27.302
<v Mark Lear>This new fee would be proportional to the pavement damage that a utility causes when accessing their infrastructure.

357
00:40:27.833 --> 00:40:34.081
<v Mark Lear>Revenue from this fee would be dedicated to improved pavement management, preservation, rehabilitation, and reconstruction.

358
00:40:34.675 --> 00:40:46.704
<v Mark Lear>The fee can also serve as an incentive for better coordination before pavement cuts by reducing the number of cuts and preserving the pavement life by waiving the fee or discounting the fee where there's that coordination.

359
00:40:47.347 --> 00:40:54.001
<v Mark Lear>Other cities that have implemented a street damage restoration fee include Los Angeles, San Francisco, Oakland, and San Diego.

360
00:40:54.257 --> 00:40:54.771
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

361
00:40:56.246 --> 00:41:03.206
<v Mark Lear>This slide highlights the 3 street damage restoration fee scenarios that we presented to the public in February and March.

362
00:41:03.704 --> 00:41:08.210
<v Mark Lear>They are based on the percentage of damage recovery at 25%, 50%, or 75%.

363
00:41:09.092 --> 00:41:13.324
<v Mark Lear>We are still refining the revenue estimates with ongoing data refinement.

364
00:41:13.971 --> 00:41:19.469
<v Mark Lear>And those— these estimates may be reduced a little bit as we do that additional work.

365
00:41:19.744 --> 00:41:20.909
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

366
00:41:22.380 --> 00:41:29.487
<v Mark Lear>This slide shows how the potential street damage restoration fee compares to other cities currently using this approach.

367
00:41:30.052 --> 00:41:42.248
<v Mark Lear>The slide indicates that our 25% and 50% damage recovery scenarios are below the rates charged in other cities, and that our 75% damage recovery is in the middle of the rates charged by other cities.

368
00:41:42.846 --> 00:41:43.347
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

369
00:41:45.757 --> 00:41:59.358
<v Mark Lear>After getting direction from Transportation and Infrastructure Committee in late January, we started talking with the public around the city about transportation funding challenges and potential revenue approaches, including the slides I just shared with you.

370
00:41:59.989 --> 00:42:03.695
<v Mark Lear>We held 4 in-person open houses in each of the council districts.

371
00:42:04.181 --> 00:42:06.804
<v Mark Lear>We also posted the same information and ran a parallel online survey.

372
00:42:06.869 --> 00:42:06.965
<v Shoshana Cohen>Thank you.

373
00:42:07.963 --> 00:42:08.496
<v Sameer Kanal>Next slide.

374
00:42:10.217 --> 00:42:19.596
<v Mark Lear>The open houses were drop-in style where people could go from room to room and learn more about the, the information, as well as talk to staff who were posted at each of the stations.

375
00:42:19.985 --> 00:42:23.447
<v Mark Lear>We asked people to provide feedback through a series of interactive exercise.

376
00:42:23.942 --> 00:42:30.262
<v Mark Lear>It was great to see the amount of turnout that we had and have that opportunity to talk directly with neighbors through this process.

377
00:42:30.697 --> 00:42:31.148
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

378
00:42:33.478 --> 00:42:49.952
<v Mark Lear>During that same 3-week period we hosted in-person open houses, we also hosted an online open house that had that same information and allowed people to provide the same feedback that was provided at the open houses.

379
00:42:50.389 --> 00:42:54.085
<v Mark Lear>And we received 477 responses to the online survey.

380
00:42:54.746 --> 00:42:55.262
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

381
00:42:57.893 --> 00:43:11.338
<v Mark Lear>We also reached out to a variety of organizations and committees and we gave presentations at committee meetings, shared information with organizations, and asked them to help spread the word about our open houses and the online opportunities.

382
00:43:11.855 --> 00:43:17.306
<v Mark Lear>We had a number of small meetings with organizations and representatives that you can see on the slide in front of you.

383
00:43:18.311 --> 00:43:18.554
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

384
00:43:20.092 --> 00:43:33.467
<v Mark Lear>At the open houses and an online survey, we asked for specific feedback on the funding scenarios for the transportation utility fee, This slide highlights the summary of the feedback we received about the fee scenarios.

385
00:43:34.849 --> 00:43:41.807
<v Mark Lear>Of the over 600 people who weighed in on the transportation utility fee, we had 76% support.

386
00:43:42.081 --> 00:43:52.172
<v Mark Lear>The most popular scenario was based on 100% of the regional average, the $12 per family, per single-family home per month, which received 48%.

387
00:43:52.219 --> 00:44:07.152
<v Mark Lear>The next slide highlights the 87% of people were supportive of a street damage restoration fee at some level, and the most popular scenario was 75%— was the 75% damage recovery fee scenario, which was supported by 51% of people.

388
00:44:07.554 --> 00:44:08.115
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

389
00:44:09.561 --> 00:44:15.583
<v Mark Lear>In addition to the DOT exercise, we gave people the opportunity both in person and online to provide open-ended feedback.

390
00:44:16.289 --> 00:44:18.039
<v Mark Lear>You can see on this slide some of the key themes.

391
00:44:18.456 --> 00:44:19.050
<v Mark Lear>That we heard.

392
00:44:20.141 --> 00:44:26.302
<v Mark Lear>So for the transportation utility fee, we heard general support because of that the fee is already being used in other Oregon cities.

393
00:44:26.817 --> 00:44:30.315
<v Mark Lear>There was some concern about the cumulative impact on utility bills.

394
00:44:30.989 --> 00:44:38.579
<v Mark Lear>There were some questions about how the existing low-income discount program gets to all Portlanders that are low-income, especially multifamily.

395
00:44:39.012 --> 00:44:44.918
<v Mark Lear>And we had some support for exemptions or discounts for minority women-owned businesses or for people who don't own cars.

396
00:44:45.094 --> 00:44:45.271
<v Mark Lear>Thank you.

397
00:44:46.539 --> 00:45:09.163
<v Mark Lear>Key themes for the street damage restoration fee was first, general dissatisfaction with the quality of patching of our current trenching work, concerns with how this fee could impact housing development, concerns about how the fee could impact other bureaus, city bureaus like Water, BES, and questions about how much of this increase in fees would be passed on to other consumers.

398
00:45:09.918 --> 00:45:10.398
<v Mark Lear>Next slide.

399
00:45:12.163 --> 00:45:30.237
<v Mark Lear>At the open houses and in the online survey, we asked people to indicate their preference for how the revenue should be spent, and we provided a list of 15 different types of investment activities like filling potholes, maintaining signals, traffic calming projects, and people could also choose higher-level categories like overall maintenance and overall safety.

400
00:45:30.974 --> 00:45:36.438
<v Mark Lear>You can see on this slide the top 5 investment priorities for the whole pool, for the whole pool of respondents.

401
00:45:37.143 --> 00:45:40.893
<v Mark Lear>These results are pretty similar to of pulling work that we've done in the past.

402
00:45:41.266 --> 00:45:50.610
<v Mark Lear>High support for things like filling potholes, overall maintenance, and also high support for overall safety, intersection safety improvements, and sidewalk infill.

403
00:45:50.708 --> 00:45:55.373
<v Mark Lear>It's very consistent with the feedback that we've gotten on our Fixing Our Streets program over time.

404
00:45:55.922 --> 00:46:00.469
<v Mark Lear>Now I'm going to hand it over to Shoshana Cohen to talk more about the funding proposals.

405
00:46:00.614 --> 00:46:00.967
<v Mark Lear>Thank you.

406
00:46:02.751 --> 00:46:03.280
<v Shoshana Cohen>Good morning.

407
00:46:03.876 --> 00:46:04.293
<v Shoshana Cohen>Thank you.

408
00:46:04.422 --> 00:46:06.528
<v Shoshana Cohen>For the record, I'm Shoshana Cohen, PBOT Chief of Staff.

409
00:46:07.469 --> 00:46:08.085
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

410
00:46:11.032 --> 00:46:20.411
<v Shoshana Cohen>The request before you today is to refer an ordinance to establish the transportation utility fee and a resolution that affirms council support to establish a street damage restoration fee.

411
00:46:20.992 --> 00:46:26.768
<v Shoshana Cohen>Both of these pieces of legislation include proposed rates, proposed investment categories, and accountability measures.

412
00:46:27.304 --> 00:46:27.902
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

413
00:46:30.215 --> 00:46:41.817
<v Shoshana Cohen>For the transportation utility fee, the proposal is to set the rates based on the existing regional average for a single-family household and as Mark mentioned, this was the rate that received the highest level of support during the public feedback phase.

414
00:46:42.960 --> 00:46:55.018
<v Shoshana Cohen>As you can see, that would mean a $12 per month single-family rate, an $8.40 per month multifamily rate— multifamily unit rate, and a non-residential commercial rate of 4.3% of the utility bill.

415
00:46:55.567 --> 00:46:56.114
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

416
00:46:58.016 --> 00:47:05.115
<v Shoshana Cohen>One of the existing advantages of the transportation utility fee is that we can use the already existing low-income discount programs for the utility bill.

417
00:47:05.981 --> 00:47:11.557
<v Shoshana Cohen>For people who are already enrolled in the discount programs, they'll be automatically enrolled in a discounted transportation utility fee.

418
00:47:12.246 --> 00:47:17.422
<v Shoshana Cohen>The LINK program is the financial assistance program that serves low-income households in single-family residences.

419
00:47:18.016 --> 00:47:23.864
<v Shoshana Cohen>Households earning up to 30% and 60% of the state median family income are eligible for discounts.

420
00:47:24.570 --> 00:47:47.440
<v Shoshana Cohen>There's also the regulated affordable multifamily assistance program, or We appreciate that during this project we've heard feedback as we engaged about the gap for low-income households living in market-rate multifamily units.

421
00:47:47.440 --> 00:47:52.219
<v Shoshana Cohen>We've begun conversations with our partners in the Public Works service area about how to address this.

422
00:47:52.260 --> 00:47:54.519
<v Olivia Clark>I specifically want to thank Queesha Lightfoot, who is the director of Public Works, for her leadership on this issue.

423
00:47:54.519 --> 00:47:54.559
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

424
00:47:54.541 --> 00:48:02.132
<v Shoshana Cohen>Customer Service Director for the Utilities, and Kenny Scott, Financial Assistance Program Manager, who have provided assistance and shared information with us.

425
00:48:03.192 --> 00:48:13.527
<v Shoshana Cohen>In our conversations with Quesha's team to date, we've heard that there are already a number of community groups trying to tackle the challenge of getting credits and discounts to people in multifamily properties.

426
00:48:14.280 --> 00:48:18.373
<v Shoshana Cohen>And in those conversations, they mentioned one of the nonprofits, SUMA, who is doing this type of work.

427
00:48:19.255 --> 00:48:21.068
<v Shoshana Cohen>And I believe someone from SUMA is here to speak briefly.

428
00:48:21.150 --> 00:48:27.460
<v Shoshana Cohen>Briefly during invited testimony today to share more about how this type of service works, just as one of the potential paths forward.

429
00:48:28.730 --> 00:48:40.762
<v Shoshana Cohen>We are— we know this is something that's come up a lot and of great interest to folks, and we're excited about the potential to continue collaborating with our public works partners and exploring how to better address this gap.

430
00:48:41.184 --> 00:48:41.882
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

431
00:48:44.686 --> 00:48:53.331
<v Shoshana Cohen>The ordinance also directs PBOT to work with the Revenue Division to continue to consider additional methodologies for the non-residential portion of the transportation utility fee.

432
00:48:54.235 --> 00:49:04.547
<v Shoshana Cohen>There's also a proposed review every 2 years of the revenue split between commercial and residential properties and an acknowledgment that moving forward the rates can be adjusted through the city's annual budget process.

433
00:49:05.387 --> 00:49:06.003
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

434
00:49:08.139 --> 00:49:11.228
<v Shoshana Cohen>The ordinance describes the use of revenue for the transportation utility fee.

435
00:49:11.871 --> 00:49:16.648
<v Shoshana Cohen>Revenue will be deposited into a dedicated account within the city's transportation operating fund.

436
00:49:17.422 --> 00:49:27.262
<v Shoshana Cohen>And as described, no less than 75% of the annual net revenues will be expended on maintenance and preservation activities, including those that support the city's Vision Zero goals.

437
00:49:28.123 --> 00:49:28.806
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

438
00:49:30.686 --> 00:49:46.820
<v Shoshana Cohen>Additional funding may be used for Vision Zero programming and capital projects associated with maintenance, preservation, or safety of existing infrastructure, including things like Vision Zero improvements next slide, please.

439
00:49:46.820 --> 00:49:48.539
<v Shoshana Cohen>Oh, sorry, I'm sorry, that was my notes.

440
00:49:48.980 --> 00:50:00.980
<v Shoshana Cohen>The investments will be informed by data about critical infrastructure and safety needs, and we'll also work to prioritize areas that have historically experienced disinvestment and have high concentrations of low-income households.

441
00:50:01.139 --> 00:50:06.719
<v Shoshana Cohen>And funding may be used— as, as you've heard, we have a current service level gap, so funding may be used to address that.

442
00:50:06.719 --> 00:50:06.760
<v Shoshana Cohen>Councilmember Herbold.

443
00:50:07.900 --> 00:50:14.820
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

444
00:50:14.820 --> 00:50:21.119
<v Shoshana Cohen>We also talked with the public a lot about accountability and heard support for all of these accountability structures.

445
00:50:22.239 --> 00:50:33.739
<v Shoshana Cohen>So the proposal includes using the Fixing Our Streets accountability sort of structure that we have, including allocating the funding to define programs and services and annual reports to council, and then also having a performance review process.

446
00:50:33.739 --> 00:50:33.780
<v Shoshana Cohen>Thank you.

447
00:50:34.199 --> 00:50:39.420
<v Shoshana Cohen>Annual external audits, and working with a community committee to provide ongoing guidance and oversight.

448
00:50:40.726 --> 00:50:41.355
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

449
00:50:43.139 --> 00:50:50.835
<v Shoshana Cohen>The street damage restoration fee is set at the 75% cost recovery rate, which is equal to $10.38 per square foot.

450
00:50:51.175 --> 00:50:54.668
<v Shoshana Cohen>And this again was the rate that received the highest support during public feedback.

451
00:50:56.010 --> 00:50:59.958
<v Shoshana Cohen>As as Mark already noted, the revenue expected from the street damage restoration fee will likely.

452
00:51:00.092 --> 00:51:07.318
<v Shoshana Cohen>Likely be lower, both because of continued data refinement and as a result of better pavement trenching coordination, which we hope the fee incentivizes.

453
00:51:08.568 --> 00:51:09.193
<v Shoshana Cohen>Next slide, please.

454
00:51:10.507 --> 00:51:16.324
<v Shoshana Cohen>Revenue from this fee will be used strictly for pavement maintenance and coordination of this utility permitting function.

455
00:51:17.237 --> 00:51:22.733
<v Shoshana Cohen>We'll work to ensure better pavement trenching coordination, which will help to reduce cuts itself and extend asset life.

456
00:51:23.487 --> 00:51:35.809
<v Shoshana Cohen>And we'll again provide annual reports to council on the revenues next slide, please.

457
00:51:36.632 --> 00:51:38.791
<v Shoshana Cohen>And this is really the final slide where we'll leave you.

458
00:51:38.840 --> 00:51:40.565
<v Shoshana Cohen>It summarizes the 2 proposals.

459
00:51:40.824 --> 00:51:43.436
<v Shoshana Cohen>And before closing up, I'll turn it back to Director Williams.

460
00:51:43.501 --> 00:51:44.614
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you, Shoshana.

461
00:51:45.519 --> 00:51:57.278
<v Millicent Williams>I'd want to end by once again thanking all of you for your time today and your interest in this effort, and more broadly, Thanking you for your support of the Bureau of Transportation and the city's transportation system.

462
00:51:58.117 --> 00:52:05.958
<v Millicent Williams>I want to particularly thank Council Vice President Clark and members of the T&I Committee who have worked so hard to get us to this point.

463
00:52:06.605 --> 00:52:15.929
<v Millicent Williams>Solving the transportation funding crisis will not be an easy effort, and we appreciate the opportunity to talk with you today about moving forward with more sustainable funding.

464
00:52:16.608 --> 00:52:20.717
<v Millicent Williams>This funding could be transformational for the bureau, transformational for the city.

465
00:52:21.394 --> 00:52:25.960
<v Millicent Williams>We've been in cut mode for so long, and we've been constrained in what we can do because of a lack of funding.

466
00:52:26.476 --> 00:52:28.733
<v Millicent Williams>And you're seeing it and you feel it every day.

467
00:52:29.215 --> 00:52:46.215
<v Millicent Williams>And in fact, I was thinking about and talking about just yesterday how we actually can't appropriately plan for future years, because every year, at least since I've been director, every year I've come into each new fiscal year with a $25 to $35 million budget gap.

468
00:52:46.289 --> 00:52:47.476
<v Millicent Williams>That we were working to fill.

469
00:52:48.070 --> 00:52:57.246
<v Millicent Williams>And by moving forward with something that would innovatively fill that gap or provide a sustainable funding source, that conversation would end.

470
00:52:57.856 --> 00:53:01.210
<v Millicent Williams>And that's an exciting opportunity for this city at this time.

471
00:53:02.123 --> 00:53:12.007
<v Millicent Williams>While we won't be able to solve all of the problems, and certainly not immediately, it could provide a much more stable base and allow staff to do the good work that we know that they can and want to do.

472
00:53:12.748 --> 00:53:19.632
<v Millicent Williams>I'll end there because I know we have a lot of invited testimony and, uh, we want to make sure that we leave time to answer your questions.

473
00:53:19.889 --> 00:53:20.518
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you all so much.

474
00:53:23.527 --> 00:53:25.672
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you to all of our staff presenters.

475
00:53:26.172 --> 00:53:28.817
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Councilor Clark, would you like me to introduce everyone, or do you have—.

476
00:53:29.172 --> 00:53:30.478
<v Olivia Clark>Either way, I have a list.

477
00:53:30.527 --> 00:53:31.478
<v Sameer Kanal>Please feel free to go ahead.

478
00:53:31.940 --> 00:53:33.318
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, panel.

479
00:53:33.675 --> 00:53:34.681
<v Olivia Clark>Terrific presentation.

480
00:53:35.688 --> 00:53:38.668
<v Olivia Clark>Let's call up a panel of witnesses.

481
00:53:38.733 --> 00:53:46.822
<v Olivia Clark>We have Nate McCoy, Leisha Shria, Kurt Huffman, and Jana Jarvis.

482
00:53:47.259 --> 00:53:48.650
<v Olivia Clark>I haven't— is Jana here?

483
00:53:48.715 --> 00:53:50.536
<v Olivia Clark>I haven't seen her.

484
00:53:54.530 --> 00:53:55.257
<v Olivia Clark>All right, how's it going?

485
00:53:57.527 --> 00:53:58.304
<v Olivia Clark>Oh, great.

486
00:53:58.418 --> 00:53:58.775
<v Olivia Clark>Welcome.

487
00:53:58.905 --> 00:54:00.492
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much for coming today.

488
00:54:01.757 --> 00:54:02.793
<v Olivia Clark>Nate, do you want to kick it off?

489
00:54:04.360 --> 00:54:05.106
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor McCoy.

490
00:54:05.514 --> 00:54:05.903
<v Shoshana Cohen>Absolutely.

491
00:54:06.733 --> 00:54:09.804
<v Mark Lear>Good afternoon, Chair Kanal and members of the committee.

492
00:54:10.539 --> 00:54:20.231
<v Mark Lear>My name is Nate McCoy, President and CEO of the Oregon Chapter of the National Association of Minority Contractors and Interim Executive Director of the Black Business Association of Oregon.

493
00:54:20.766 --> 00:54:24.599
<v Mark Lear>And yes, as we discussed yesterday, I will be joining the bald club very soon.

494
00:54:25.375 --> 00:54:31.853
<v Mark Lear>I'm here in strong support alongside my friends at SUMMA and And the Street Trust and Jana Jarvis and others in the room.

495
00:54:32.751 --> 00:54:40.260
<v Mark Lear>And we're here to support the proposed ordinance and resolution to establish stable, sustainable funding for the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

496
00:54:40.918 --> 00:54:47.367
<v Mark Lear>At its core, this is about fiscal stability and protecting a long-term economic health of our city.

497
00:54:47.672 --> 00:54:53.496
<v Mark Lear>PBOT is facing a structural funding challenge with declining revenues, rising costs, and limited flexibility.

498
00:54:53.913 --> 00:54:56.365
<v Mark Lear>At this time, Our infrastructure is deteriorating.

499
00:54:56.414 --> 00:55:01.621
<v Mark Lear>Streets are getting worse, and the costs to fix them are only increasing as we longer wait.

500
00:55:02.023 --> 00:55:06.237
<v Mark Lear>Transportation is— transportation is the operating system of our economy.

501
00:55:06.653 --> 00:55:14.250
<v Mark Lear>When it breaks down, small businesses, contractors feel it first through delays, higher costs, and lost opportunities.

502
00:55:14.762 --> 00:55:17.134
<v Mark Lear>These businesses do not find a way to survive.

503
00:55:17.309 --> 00:55:20.981
<v Mark Lear>For these businesses we represent, especially small and diverse firms, Thank you, Councilor Smith.

504
00:55:21.173 --> 00:55:21.349
<v Mark Lear>Thank you, Mayor.

505
00:55:21.398 --> 00:55:23.518
<v Mark Lear>In these uncertain times, reliable infrastructure is not optional.

506
00:55:23.983 --> 00:55:25.588
<v Mark Lear>We all know it's foundational.

507
00:55:26.070 --> 00:55:38.081
<v Mark Lear>The transportation utility fee provides a stable and predictable funding source focused on maintenance and safety, helping us preserve what we have and avoid more costly repairs down the road.

508
00:55:38.418 --> 00:55:46.028
<v Mark Lear>The street damage restoration fee ensures that those who cause the most long-term damage to the roads contribute fairly to their upkeep.

509
00:55:47.329 --> 00:55:58.735
<v Mark Lear>Together, those tools create balanced approach to stabilizing PBOT's finances, which we talked about, protecting our infrastructure and supporting economic opportunity, which is vitally important.

510
00:55:59.072 --> 00:56:08.148
<v Mark Lear>In fact, stable funding creates more consistent pipeline of work, opening the doors for greater participation by small and diverse firms over time.

511
00:56:08.628 --> 00:56:11.648
<v Mark Lear>We also appreciate the strong accountability measures included in the legislation.

512
00:56:12.001 --> 00:56:18.862
<v Mark Lear>And encourage continued attention to affordability to ensure small businesses are not disproportionately impacted.

513
00:56:19.440 --> 00:56:28.369
<v Mark Lear>This is the right step at the right time in the right community to stabilize a critical system and support Portland's economic future.

514
00:56:29.059 --> 00:56:30.068
<v Mark Lear>Thank you for your time.

515
00:56:30.132 --> 00:56:36.400
<v Mark Lear>I'm trying to be sensitive with the time limitations, but appreciate having another opportunity to be in front of you all.

516
00:56:37.155 --> 00:56:37.539
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Nick.

517
00:56:37.619 --> 00:56:38.422
<v Olivia Clark>Great.

518
00:56:38.775 --> 00:56:40.268
<v Olivia Clark>We have Alicia online.

519
00:56:40.317 --> 00:56:41.472
<v Olivia Clark>Would you like to go next?

520
00:56:42.228 --> 00:56:42.483
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sure.

521
00:56:43.335 --> 00:56:45.887
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning, Chair Kanal and councilors.

522
00:56:46.081 --> 00:56:47.188
<v Unidentified speaker>My name is Alicia Shrestha.

523
00:56:47.349 --> 00:56:50.400
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the executive director of Division Midway Alliance.

524
00:56:50.978 --> 00:56:58.411
<v Unidentified speaker>We are a place-based nonprofit serving residents and businesses along one of East Portland's highest crash corridors.

525
00:56:59.231 --> 00:57:09.518
<v Unidentified speaker>Our work focuses on building a safe, resilient, and economically thriving community through culturally specific, community-driven programs and transportation equity is central to that work.

526
00:57:10.081 --> 00:57:20.233
<v Unidentified speaker>Through our Transportation Education and Safety Youth Ambassador Program, we are building youth leaders who educate their communities on transit options, pedestrian safety, and mobility access.

527
00:57:20.748 --> 00:57:26.538
<v Unidentified speaker>We also provide safety workshops, low-income fare enrollment, and Learner's Permit Program support.

528
00:57:27.148 --> 00:57:33.853
<v Unidentified speaker>In 2023, we partnered with PBOT to understand that safety— what safety means from the community perspective.

529
00:57:33.900 --> 00:57:34.012
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you.

530
00:57:37.824 --> 00:57:45.648
<v Unidentified speaker>One key takeaway from our Beyond Traffic Safety report, which you can see on the background, is that safety is not just about infrastructure.

531
00:57:45.811 --> 00:57:49.945
<v Unidentified speaker>It's also about how people experience and use public spaces.

532
00:57:50.550 --> 00:57:58.101
<v Unidentified speaker>This report also includes a personal safety toolkit with practical community-based strategies to improve safety and belonging.

533
00:57:58.840 --> 00:58:02.454
<v Unidentified speaker>This work shows that investing in mobility infrastructure supports community safety and belonging.

534
00:58:05.903 --> 00:58:19.043
<v Unidentified speaker>We continue to partner with PBOT to implement these strategies on ground, including exploring the launch of Division Corridor Transportation Safety Stewards and placemaking pilot project.

535
00:58:19.317 --> 00:58:24.264
<v Unidentified speaker>And our goal is to replicate this model in other parts of the city.

536
00:58:25.164 --> 00:58:46.197
<v Unidentified speaker>I support this funding proposal because this provides P-BOT, a stable foundation to partner with community-based organizations like ours and invest more in District 1, because as I heard Councilor Green talking about, that this is— District 1 needs more support in infrastructure development.

537
00:58:46.630 --> 00:58:54.128
<v Unidentified speaker>So actually, it helps deliver what communities are asking for: better sidewalks, safer streets, improved lighting.

538
00:58:55.108 --> 00:58:57.659
<v Unidentified speaker>Thank you so much.

539
00:58:58.880 --> 00:59:00.195
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for being here today, Weetje.

540
00:59:00.356 --> 00:59:01.992
<v Olivia Clark>We really appreciate that testimony.

541
00:59:02.650 --> 00:59:04.030
<v Olivia Clark>Kurt, would you like to go next?

542
00:59:04.577 --> 00:59:05.155
<v Mitch Green>Yes, thank you.

543
00:59:05.378 --> 00:59:08.878
<v Dan Ryan>Um, good morning, councilors, uh, and thank you for the opportunity to testify.

544
00:59:09.231 --> 00:59:11.911
<v Dan Ryan>My name is Kurt Huffman, and I own a company called Chef's Table.

545
00:59:12.536 --> 00:59:20.528
<v Dan Ryan>For the past 18 years, I've helped chefs, bakers, brewers, winemakers, and other hospitality operators open and grow over 100 businesses here in Portland.

546
00:59:21.418 --> 00:59:24.019
<v Dan Ryan>I'm here to support PBOT's transportation utility fee.

547
00:59:25.311 --> 00:59:27.105
<v Dan Ryan>The proposal will cost our businesses money.

548
00:59:28.963 --> 00:59:41.208
<v Dan Ryan>Based on our own utility bills, and I'm referring to my notes because I did a lot of data research to get this right, it would add about $611 per year or $51 per month to our average restaurant.

549
00:59:42.228 --> 01:00:03.097
<v Dan Ryan>To put that in context in my industry, and by the way, we pay the highest water fees of any businesses A restaurant with $1 million in annual sales will have approximately $5,400 in related utility expenses, and that 4.3% fee would represent $232 of annual expense increase.

550
01:00:04.206 --> 01:00:24.126
<v Dan Ryan>Since we also manage food cart pods, and since food carts are such a vital part of our community, I thought it'd be helpful to point out that for the average food cart that we have, for instance, at Midtown Beer Garden, Their annual related expenses are about $1,000 a year, so this fee would add $43 annually to their water bills.

551
01:00:25.876 --> 01:00:31.099
<v Dan Ryan>You know, that's, that's real money, and our small businesses will feel it.

552
01:00:32.730 --> 01:00:36.835
<v Dan Ryan>But PBOT's funding shortfall is also a problem for our small businesses.

553
01:00:37.527 --> 01:00:40.346
<v Dan Ryan>Our industry depends on clean, safe, well-maintained streets.

554
01:00:40.733 --> 01:00:41.989
<v Dan Ryan>We need reliable sidewalks.

555
01:00:42.789 --> 01:00:45.826
<v Dan Ryan>Lighting, pavement, bike parking, curb access, and outdoor seating.

556
01:00:46.677 --> 01:00:53.594
<v Dan Ryan>We need neighborhoods that are walkable, bikeable, transit accessible, and drivable because that is how our customers, employees, and deliveries reach us.

557
01:00:54.791 --> 01:01:03.280
<v Dan Ryan>I also want to say clearly that in my experience, no city agency has been more proactive or more helpful to small businesses than PBOT.

558
01:01:04.791 --> 01:01:22.385
<v Dan Ryan>Programs like street seating, outdoor dining, parklets, This experience clearly informs my feelings about this matter because there is a history of trust with PBOT, knowing that they are true advocates and champions for our success.

559
01:01:24.639 --> 01:01:29.126
<v Dan Ryan>This fee is not painless for small business, but neglected streets are not free either.

560
01:01:30.349 --> 01:01:33.344
<v Dan Ryan>Portland's neighborhood economy depends on the infrastructure PBOT maintains and maintains well.

561
01:01:33.393 --> 01:01:33.699
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

562
01:01:34.579 --> 01:01:40.197
<v Dan Ryan>If we want vibrant neighborhood business districts, we need the public infrastructure that makes them possible.

563
01:01:40.822 --> 01:01:42.956
<v Dan Ryan>I urge you to support PBOT's recommendation.

564
01:01:43.311 --> 01:01:43.567
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

565
01:01:44.177 --> 01:01:44.980
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, Kurt.

566
01:01:45.059 --> 01:01:48.172
<v Olivia Clark>Having grown up in the restaurant industry, I really appreciate your testimony.

567
01:01:48.429 --> 01:01:48.927
<v Olivia Clark>Yeah, thank you.

568
01:01:49.344 --> 01:01:51.110
<v Olivia Clark>I think we saved the best for last.

569
01:01:51.175 --> 01:01:52.682
<v Olivia Clark>Jana, good to see you.

570
01:01:52.780 --> 01:01:53.550
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for coming.

571
01:01:53.822 --> 01:01:54.351
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

572
01:01:55.266 --> 01:01:59.327
<v Millicent Williams>Good morning, Chair Kanal, Vice Chairs Ryan and Koyama Lane, and councilors.

573
01:02:00.306 --> 01:02:02.411
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today.

574
01:02:03.036 --> 01:02:13.027
<v Millicent Williams>I'm Jana Jarvis, President and CEO of the Oregon Trucking Association, here to express our support for the transportation utility fee and the street damage restoration fee.

575
01:02:14.038 --> 01:02:18.438
<v Millicent Williams>For the city to thrive, it must have a functional transportation system.

576
01:02:19.193 --> 01:02:23.931
<v Millicent Williams>Those of us who work in the freight industry know the importance of this because we live it every day.

577
01:02:24.735 --> 01:02:38.931
<v Millicent Williams>For our drivers, the roads are their And the industry depends on working, effective, well-designed street surfaces, signals, lighting, signage, and striping— literally all of the transportation infrastructure.

578
01:02:39.878 --> 01:02:45.668
<v Millicent Williams>When freight is able to move safely and efficiently, it holds costs down and everyone benefits.

579
01:02:46.710 --> 01:02:54.697
<v Millicent Williams>With all of the conversation at the state level focused on how to fund transportation, Portland's proposed solution to treat it as a utility makes sense.

580
01:02:54.891 --> 01:02:55.114
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

581
01:02:57.396 --> 01:03:03.878
<v Millicent Williams>The whole community depends on it working effectively, so it's reasonable to ask the whole community to help fund the system.

582
01:03:05.119 --> 01:03:12.583
<v Millicent Williams>We appreciate that the ordinance for the transportation utility fee requires that at least 75% of the revenue be allocated for maintenance.

583
01:03:13.760 --> 01:03:21.728
<v Millicent Williams>Preventative maintenance ensures that we keep roads in good working order, and it minimizes the significant additional costs of reconstruction.

584
01:03:23.329 --> 01:03:32.702
<v Millicent Williams>The street damage restoration fee also makes sense to anyone who's driven over a patched trench or has watched the street around that patch crumble after trenching.

585
01:03:33.458 --> 01:03:37.213
<v Millicent Williams>And that's particularly true for the trucking industry in terms of maintenance costs.

586
01:03:38.673 --> 01:03:47.485
<v Millicent Williams>We also appreciate your commitment to use the accountability structure that has made the Fixing Our Streets programs and the heavy vehicle use tax so successful.

587
01:03:49.090 --> 01:03:56.621
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you for recognizing the urgent need for more transportation funding, and we look forward to working with you to make these programs a success.

588
01:03:58.099 --> 01:03:59.077
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, Janet.

589
01:03:59.141 --> 01:04:00.427
<v Olivia Clark>Thanks to all of our panelists.

590
01:04:00.652 --> 01:04:01.936
<v Olivia Clark>We appreciate your being here today.

591
01:04:02.257 --> 01:04:02.675
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

592
01:04:03.782 --> 01:04:05.130
<v Olivia Clark>Let's call up the next panel.

593
01:04:05.949 --> 01:04:10.157
<v Olivia Clark>Mike Dennis, Lindsay Huber, Indy Nemkung, and Steven Landridge.

594
01:04:15.516 --> 01:04:16.242
<v Keelan McClymont>Where are we going?

595
01:04:16.322 --> 01:04:17.630
<v Dan Ryan>Yeah, where's a good spot?

596
01:04:18.114 --> 01:04:19.777
<v Unidentified speaker>Sit next to you, Nancy.

597
01:04:19.969 --> 01:04:20.728
<v Millicent Williams>Perfect.

598
01:04:21.648 --> 01:04:22.875
<v Olivia Clark>Mike, would you like to start?

599
01:04:23.181 --> 01:04:24.101
<v Mark Lear>Yes, thank you.

600
01:04:25.440 --> 01:04:37.016
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Chair Kanal and Vice Chair Koyama Lane and Ryan and members of the council for this opportunity to provide some testimony in support of the transportation utility fee.

601
01:04:37.934 --> 01:04:42.942
<v Dan Ryan>I'm Mike Dennis with Oregon Walks, and we are a pedestrian advocacy group.

602
01:04:43.737 --> 01:04:53.092
<v Dan Ryan>And I'm here as our new executive director, taking over for Zachary Lorentzon, who many of you may know and may have had the pleasure of working with.

603
01:04:53.157 --> 01:04:57.315
<v Dan Ryan>And Zachary fortunately is staying with Oregon Walks, which I'm very happy about.

604
01:04:58.780 --> 01:05:14.327
<v Dan Ryan>So you all have been handed a difficult problem, a transportation system that is very expensive to maintain and previous electeds Who didn't set aside revenue to maintain that system.

605
01:05:15.724 --> 01:05:21.250
<v Dan Ryan>Finding new revenue to do something may not be popular, but it is courageous.

606
01:05:22.309 --> 01:05:26.101
<v Mark Lear>Thank you for your leadership to step up and do something about this problem.

607
01:05:26.903 --> 01:05:33.650
<v Dan Ryan>And I also wanna thank the PBOT staff, Director Williams, Shoshana, Cynthia, Mark, and the rest of the team.

608
01:05:34.677 --> 01:05:39.402
<v Dan Ryan>So while you may hear a lot of different ideas here today, I wanna focus on one Thank you.

609
01:05:39.514 --> 01:05:44.757
<v Dan Ryan>I'd like to focus on one critical piece, the safety provisions for vulnerable road users.

610
01:05:46.420 --> 01:05:53.021
<v Dan Ryan>The Vision Zero investments that the transportation utility fee advances are critical.

611
01:05:53.858 --> 01:05:59.963
<v Dan Ryan>We saw the city's deadly traffic report show there's much to do to reduce traffic violence in our city.

612
01:06:00.563 --> 01:06:07.876
<v Dan Ryan>Vulnerable road users continually advocate for increased safety investments, especially in our underinvested communities.

613
01:06:08.724 --> 01:06:22.708
<v Dan Ryan>And the Vision Zero safety investments in this ordinance bring fairness to the estimated third of Portlanders who can't drive, but who will also be paying for this fee through their household.

614
01:06:24.311 --> 01:06:28.653
<v Dan Ryan>We all share a goal that people can use our transportation system and get home safely.

615
01:06:29.253 --> 01:06:39.916
<v Dan Ryan>We are thrilled that the council, and particularly Councilor Koyama Lane's leadership, that you all reaffirmed the commitment to Vision Zero.

616
01:06:40.141 --> 01:06:40.688
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

617
01:06:41.989 --> 01:06:49.436
<v Dan Ryan>But as they say, and as a number of you said, words are cheap and real priorities are expressed in how we spend our money.

618
01:06:50.498 --> 01:06:55.282
<v Dan Ryan>This resolution identifies a minimum spending of 75% on maintenance.

619
01:06:56.298 --> 01:07:03.315
<v Dan Ryan>We are asking that you also identify a minimum spending on safety projects of 20%.

620
01:07:03.429 --> 01:07:03.559
<v Olivia Clark>Second.

621
01:07:03.708 --> 01:07:04.463
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

622
01:07:05.139 --> 01:07:07.603
<v Dan Ryan>Let's not just say we are prioritizing safety.

623
01:07:08.119 --> 01:07:09.695
<v Dan Ryan>Let's put money toward the goal.

624
01:07:11.260 --> 01:07:21.115
<v Dan Ryan>A final note is we urge in the middle of these conversations that the future of the voter-approved Fixing Our Streets 10-cent gas tax not be lost or negotiated away.

625
01:07:21.998 --> 01:07:28.425
<v Dan Ryan>It's our only price signal to drive smaller vehicles, to drive slower, and to drive less.

626
01:07:28.570 --> 01:07:29.918
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you for your leadership.

627
01:07:30.532 --> 01:07:38.786
<v Dan Ryan>This is really a once-in-a-generation opportunity to invest in safety, maintenance, communities, and our thriving city.

628
01:07:40.038 --> 01:07:41.094
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, Mike.

629
01:07:41.257 --> 01:07:41.907
<v Olivia Clark>Appreciate that.

630
01:07:42.217 --> 01:07:43.923
<v Olivia Clark>Lindsay, would you like to start?

631
01:07:44.699 --> 01:07:48.507
<v Unidentified speaker>Good morning, Committee Chair Kanal and members of council.

632
01:07:49.134 --> 01:07:52.942
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm Lindsay Huber, interim executive director of the Street Trust.

633
01:07:53.327 --> 01:07:57.137
<v Unidentified speaker>We advocate for safe, accessible, equitable, and low-carbon streets.

634
01:07:57.304 --> 01:07:58.844
<v Unidentified speaker>Streets for all Oregonians.

635
01:07:59.744 --> 01:08:09.923
<v Unidentified speaker>Every day, our work shows that Portland streets are incomplete and unsafe, threatening lives, limiting economic prosperity, and worsening existing inequities.

636
01:08:10.599 --> 01:08:15.239
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm here today to speak in support of the proposed transportation utility fee.

637
01:08:15.737 --> 01:08:18.515
<v Unidentified speaker>PBOT's funding is in crisis.

638
01:08:19.109 --> 01:08:30.337
<v Unidentified speaker>The state transportation package was referred to voters and the Fixing Our Streets 10 cents gas tax now buys half as much of what it did when it was initially passed in 2016.

639
01:08:30.997 --> 01:08:39.019
<v Unidentified speaker>Current revenue streams are predicted to continue to decline even as maintenance needs, traffic fatalities, and serious injuries remain high.

640
01:08:39.793 --> 01:08:53.465
<v Unidentified speaker>While we support renewing the Fixing Our Streets gas tax, adding this TUF fee would as well would provide stable, predictable funding to address those critical safety and maintenance needs.

641
01:08:54.170 --> 01:09:04.761
<v Unidentified speaker>The TUF is straightforward and easy to implement using existing utility billing systems, which would allow PBOT to stabilize its workforce and services effectively.

642
01:09:05.532 --> 01:09:10.291
<v Unidentified speaker>This is a strong first step, and we appreciate the work that has gone into this proposal.

643
01:09:10.916 --> 01:09:13.110
<v Unidentified speaker>We also see opportunities to strengthen it.

644
01:09:13.560 --> 01:09:36.386
<v Unidentified speaker>For example, we echo the encouragement that council set a clear baseline for safety investments of no less than 20%, similar to the maintenance spending floor of 75%, so that a meaningful share of funding is dedicated to these Vision Zero outcomes, protecting our most vulnerable road users, including pedestrians and people riding bikes.

645
01:09:37.203 --> 01:09:40.554
<v Unidentified speaker>We also encourage continued work to ensure that affordability.

646
01:09:40.619 --> 01:09:46.796
<v Unidentified speaker>Protections reach low-income households, including renters who may not directly receive utility bills.

647
01:09:47.533 --> 01:09:50.390
<v Unidentified speaker>This fee isn't perfect, but it's a critical first step.

648
01:09:50.998 --> 01:09:53.903
<v Unidentified speaker>Portland needs reliable transportation funding now.

649
01:09:54.689 --> 01:10:04.555
<v Unidentified speaker>Approving the TUF will allow PBOT to maintain safe streets, prevent costly repairs later, and support a more equitable, reliable transportation system.

650
01:10:04.877 --> 01:10:05.213
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

651
01:10:06.064 --> 01:10:06.609
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Lindsay.

652
01:10:06.706 --> 01:10:08.003
<v Olivia Clark>We appreciate that testimony.

653
01:10:08.805 --> 01:10:10.408
<v Olivia Clark>Indi, am I pronouncing that right?

654
01:10:10.632 --> 01:10:11.225
<v Keelan McClymont>Yes, you are.

655
01:10:11.435 --> 01:10:15.667
<v Keelan McClymont>Good morning, Councilor Clark, Chair Kanal, Vice Chairs Koyama Lane and Ryan.

656
01:10:16.020 --> 01:10:17.542
<v Keelan McClymont>For the record, my name is Indi Namkha.

657
01:10:17.783 --> 01:10:24.163
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm the Transportation Justice Coordinator for Verde, and I'm gonna be commenting primarily on the transportation utility fee this morning.

658
01:10:24.917 --> 01:10:33.622
<v Keelan McClymont>The low-income communities of color that Verde works with in Colley and across the city are struggling with the current unsafe and inaccessible state of transportation in Portland.

659
01:10:34.055 --> 01:10:42.976
<v Keelan McClymont>We hear from people pretty constantly about concerns with dangerous dangerous speeds on our roads, poor lighting, unsafe crossing, unfinished sidewalks, and limited access to transit.

660
01:10:43.041 --> 01:10:44.518
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm sure you have heard this all before.

661
01:10:45.546 --> 01:10:52.786
<v Keelan McClymont>So we really appreciate the work that's gone into this from PBOT, the leadership of Councilor Clark, Councilor Murillo, and all of those helping to put this together.

662
01:10:53.395 --> 01:10:59.560
<v Keelan McClymont>As we've learned from the state legislature over the past couple of years, raising transportation revenue is not an exercise for the faint-hearted.

663
01:10:59.721 --> 01:11:06.368
<v Keelan McClymont>So I want to honor both the political courage that you've demonstrated and the strength of the public engagement and the outreach that we've seen around this.

664
01:11:06.432 --> 01:11:06.625
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

665
01:11:07.426 --> 01:11:12.701
<v Keelan McClymont>We want to be able to join you in championing proposals to raise money locally and invest in the changes we need.

666
01:11:13.278 --> 01:11:22.479
<v Keelan McClymont>This ordinance makes a strong start, but we want to flag, as proposed, it has some outstanding issues that could worsen existing inequities that are facing low-income Portlanders.

667
01:11:23.055 --> 01:11:29.805
<v Keelan McClymont>These issues are serious and they are very much fixable, so we urge you to resolve them before passing the final ordinance.

668
01:11:30.510 --> 01:11:34.662
<v Keelan McClymont>As written, the TUF would expose more renters in Portland to eviction.

669
01:11:35.015 --> 01:11:40.917
<v Keelan McClymont>Tenants can face eviction for unpaid or late utility charges if they're billed by their landlord rather than by the utility.

670
01:11:40.965 --> 01:11:44.224
<v Keelan McClymont>So as utility costs grow, so does this risk.

671
01:11:44.945 --> 01:11:51.832
<v Keelan McClymont>Language should be added to the ordinance specifying that nonpayment of the TUF or late payment of the TUF may not be used as grounds for eviction.

672
01:11:52.893 --> 01:12:02.395
<v Keelan McClymont>As written, low-income discounts on the TUF, as you've heard, will only be available to residents of single-family homes because that's how our existing affordability programs work.

673
01:12:02.444 --> 01:12:03.470
<v Keelan McClymont>This is an old problem.

674
01:12:03.921 --> 01:12:07.997
<v Keelan McClymont>If you pay your water bill to your landlord and not to the Water Bureau, you can't tap into these programs.

675
01:12:08.061 --> 01:12:08.640
<v Keelan McClymont>You have to pay the full price.

676
01:12:08.720 --> 01:12:08.817
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

677
01:12:09.859 --> 01:12:12.942
<v Keelan McClymont>Most lower-income Portlanders live in multifamily housing.

678
01:12:13.359 --> 01:12:15.847
<v Keelan McClymont>That's not a super effective affordability measure yet.

679
01:12:16.039 --> 01:12:22.349
<v Keelan McClymont>And we've heard that PBOT is exploring a pilot partnership with SUMA to provide an alternative that would reach multifamily residents.

680
01:12:22.685 --> 01:12:31.884
<v Keelan McClymont>And I want to urge you to ensure that they have the support that they need to get those services ready to roll out with the TUF so that low-income Portlanders aren't left waiting and racking up charges.

681
01:12:32.878 --> 01:12:39.444
<v Keelan McClymont>Now finally, as written, non-driving households will be paying a disproportionately high fee relative to their impact to the system and the benefits they'll see.

682
01:12:39.524 --> 01:12:39.780
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

683
01:12:40.246 --> 01:12:41.256
<v Keelan McClymont>Are a little unclear.

684
01:12:42.024 --> 01:12:49.653
<v Keelan McClymont>The entirety of the street damage restoration fee revenues and the majority of the TUF revenues are currently slated to go to preservation and maintenance of existing infrastructure.

685
01:12:49.733 --> 01:12:55.854
<v Keelan McClymont>And that need is undeniable, but our existing infrastructure still overprioritizes cars at the expense of other modes.

686
01:12:56.591 --> 01:13:01.752
<v Keelan McClymont>If we focus all of our new revenues on preservation and maintenance of that system, we preserve the inequity too.

687
01:13:02.938 --> 01:13:11.542
<v Keelan McClymont>Because our low-income communities are more likely to live in multifamily housing and more likely not to drive, this triples down on the burden the proposed language will ask them to bear.

688
01:13:11.591 --> 01:13:11.686
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

689
01:13:12.391 --> 01:13:21.493
<v Keelan McClymont>But dedicating a minimum share of the dollars in the TUF to proposed— to projects and programs that would improve non-driving options, not just preserve the ones that we have, would correct for this.

690
01:13:22.310 --> 01:13:35.431
<v Keelan McClymont>If it's not possible to offer a Hillsboro-style targeted discount to non-driving ratepayers, and I'm not saying it's not possible, but if we can't do that, then it's all the more essential that the TUF is providing clear and proportionate benefits to everybody who's paying in.

691
01:13:35.881 --> 01:13:40.686
<v Keelan McClymont>I'll provide some more detailed written comments for the record, and we're really eager to see this develop in the coming weeks.

692
01:13:40.734 --> 01:13:40.846
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

693
01:13:41.122 --> 01:13:42.569
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Indy.

694
01:13:42.649 --> 01:13:47.056
<v Keelan McClymont>Appreciate that.

695
01:13:47.653 --> 01:13:48.006
<v Olivia Clark>Stephen.

696
01:13:48.988 --> 01:13:55.925
<v Sameer Kanal>Hello, my name is Stephen McLandrich, and I am one of the chairs of our Fixing Our Streets Oversight Committee.

697
01:13:56.729 --> 01:14:04.694
<v Sameer Kanal>Our committee is tasked with providing oversight of the use of the gas tax revenue that's generated through the Fixing Our Streets program.

698
01:14:05.539 --> 01:14:16.592
<v Sameer Kanal>Through my work in this role, I bear witness to the tremendous need for funding of basic repairs and maintenance, as well as safety improvements throughout our community.

699
01:14:17.489 --> 01:14:27.601
<v Sameer Kanal>Our committee's role in providing oversight of Fixing Our Streets revenue can be replicated to provide oversight for revenue generated through this fee.

700
01:14:28.627 --> 01:14:40.789
<v Sameer Kanal>In our oversight capacity role, we are involved in the intentional selection process for funding of projects and are an avenue to provide community input throughout the selection process.

701
01:14:41.878 --> 01:14:48.240
<v Sameer Kanal>Additionally, through Fixing Our Streets, PBOT is required to publish an annual report of the use of this funding.

702
01:14:48.913 --> 01:15:00.738
<v Sameer Kanal>Currently, Fixing Our Streets revenue supports projects for both maintenance, such as paving, as well as small to large, very necessary safety improvement projects.

703
01:15:01.814 --> 01:15:11.010
<v Sameer Kanal>I urge you to have fee-generated revenue support safety projects in addition to buoying operation and maintenance needs.

704
01:15:12.246 --> 01:15:23.849
<v Sameer Kanal>My personal assessment of our maintenance and safety project backlog is that if additional transportation revenue can be generated through fees, the gas tax should be left in place.

705
01:15:24.346 --> 01:15:48.220
<v Sameer Kanal>The gas tax keeps some revenue generated thank you.

706
01:15:48.220 --> 01:15:50.319
<v Olivia Clark>And thank you for your service on the Oversight Committee.

707
01:15:50.319 --> 01:15:51.140
<v Olivia Clark>Really appreciate it.

708
01:15:51.140 --> 01:15:51.859
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, panelists.

709
01:15:51.859 --> 01:15:52.699
<v Olivia Clark>Great testimony.

710
01:15:52.699 --> 01:15:53.279
<v Olivia Clark>Very thoughtful.

711
01:15:53.279 --> 01:15:53.319
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

712
01:15:56.061 --> 01:16:04.242
<v Olivia Clark>Our next panel, it's Paul Cohn, James O'Loughlin, Kari Ko, and Rob Martineau.

713
01:16:09.449 --> 01:16:10.512
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for being here today.

714
01:16:15.989 --> 01:16:16.521
<v Sameer Kanal>Hi, good morning.

715
01:16:17.371 --> 01:16:18.403
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is Paul Cohn.

716
01:16:19.029 --> 01:16:19.029
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

717
01:16:19.029 --> 01:16:20.569
<v Sameer Kanal>Good afternoon, Chair Kanal, members of the committee.

718
01:16:21.510 --> 01:16:25.489
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm speaking today as president of the Portland chapter of PROTEC 17.

719
01:16:25.489 --> 01:16:27.029
<v Sameer Kanal>We're a city employee union.

720
01:16:27.029 --> 01:16:40.810
<v Sameer Kanal>We represent almost 1,000 city employees across most bureaus— engineers, engineering technicians in PBOT and other bureaus, IT professionals, planners, permit techs— and we actually represent Portland Street Response mental health workers.

721
01:16:41.149 --> 01:16:45.109
<v Sameer Kanal>PBOT, we have over 200 employees who work in planning, engineering, maintenance, and property management.

722
01:16:46.117 --> 01:16:49.079
<v Sameer Kanal>All while advancing the city's climate, accessibility, and equity goals.

723
01:16:49.127 --> 01:16:54.162
<v Sameer Kanal>So we've partnered for years to support a stable funding plan for the city's transportation system.

724
01:16:54.211 --> 01:17:01.766
<v Sameer Kanal>However, in light of recent developments locally and nationally, as you know, state and federal revenue sources have proven to be unreliable.

725
01:17:01.846 --> 01:17:03.578
<v Sameer Kanal>So it's clear that we need a local solution.

726
01:17:05.310 --> 01:17:10.572
<v Sameer Kanal>These perpetually strained budgets, as you've heard already from PBOT staff, have just weakened that bureau year after year.

727
01:17:10.689 --> 01:17:19.810
<v Sameer Kanal>Fear of layoffs also take a major toll on morale with our, with our members, and workers wonder if they can trust their families' livelihoods to the twists and turns of the bureau's budget.

728
01:17:21.250 --> 01:17:25.421
<v Sameer Kanal>Unstable funding also means it takes longer for expensive projects to finish.

729
01:17:26.230 --> 01:17:30.257
<v Sameer Kanal>Deferred maintenance backlog is well known, clear to any Portlander driving our streets.

730
01:17:30.322 --> 01:17:34.407
<v Sameer Kanal>I noted in the presentation earlier that potholes again are the number one thing.

731
01:17:36.109 --> 01:17:37.734
<v Sameer Kanal>Major projects get bogged down.

732
01:17:38.488 --> 01:17:45.608
<v Sameer Kanal>Deferred maintenance puts smaller projects that could be low-hanging fruit for advancing safety, climate, accessibility goals out of reach.

733
01:17:45.703 --> 01:17:51.987
<v Sameer Kanal>So for many otherwise simple projects, the poor condition of pavement quickly makes the project too expensive to consider.

734
01:17:53.271 --> 01:17:58.350
<v Sameer Kanal>These smaller projects would otherwise be extremely cost-effective, but instead they're left on the shelf.

735
01:17:58.398 --> 01:18:02.479
<v Sameer Kanal>So the voters of Portland have passed Fix Our Streets a few times.

736
01:18:02.576 --> 01:18:03.649
<v Sameer Kanal>In a row.

737
01:18:04.194 --> 01:18:05.909
<v Sameer Kanal>The last 2 ballot measures passed by 70%.

738
01:18:05.957 --> 01:18:09.581
<v Sameer Kanal>Portlanders are willing to pay for safe, well-maintained streets.

739
01:18:10.430 --> 01:18:14.310
<v Sameer Kanal>They understand that this will help our economic recovery and give us more livable communities.

740
01:18:14.373 --> 01:18:20.833
<v Sameer Kanal>So if national and state political entities are not trusted partners, we have to provide for ourselves.

741
01:18:22.309 --> 01:18:31.903
<v Sameer Kanal>Transportation utility fee as well as the street opening damage recovery fee their approving tool in neighborhood and neighboring jurisdictions.

742
01:18:32.015 --> 01:18:39.262
<v Sameer Kanal>Cities across the U.S., including 31 in Oregon, have implemented a TUF to pay for basic road maintenance and safety improvements.

743
01:18:39.648 --> 01:18:43.311
<v Sameer Kanal>So this ultimately will save the city money over time.

744
01:18:43.359 --> 01:18:48.309
<v Sameer Kanal>So we really appreciate you taking a look at this, and we're with you in supporting this measure.

745
01:18:48.743 --> 01:18:48.904
<v Candace Avalos>So thank you.

746
01:18:48.967 --> 01:18:49.627
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Paul.

747
01:18:49.787 --> 01:18:50.447
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate that.

748
01:18:50.574 --> 01:18:51.972
<v Olivia Clark>I think we have James online.

749
01:18:56.181 --> 01:18:58.172
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, good morning, councilors.

750
01:18:58.703 --> 01:18:59.939
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is James O'Loughlin.

751
01:19:00.067 --> 01:19:04.787
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm a father of 2 native Portlanders and a field rep with Laborers 483.

752
01:19:05.494 --> 01:19:18.886
<v Sameer Kanal>Our union represents workers throughout the city, with nearly 300 serving on the front lines in PBOT as utility workers, concrete finishers, automotive equipment operators, and a variety of other roles.

753
01:19:19.930 --> 01:19:20.411
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

754
01:19:20.506 --> 01:19:29.872
<v Sameer Kanal>I can't tell you how pleased I am to be here today and hear most of what I had to say already be said, chiefly by councilors themselves.

755
01:19:30.962 --> 01:19:34.524
<v Sameer Kanal>Still, I do want to echo my support for that message.

756
01:19:35.117 --> 01:19:45.588
<v Sameer Kanal>I think Councilor Clark said it particularly well when she mentioned how transportation infrastructure, it touches all of us regardless of whether or not we ever get in a car in our daily lives.

757
01:19:46.807 --> 01:19:59.139
<v Sameer Kanal>It brings our food, it transports our children, it's essential for emergency services reaching us when we need them, and it is a huge driver of economic outcomes in the city.

758
01:20:00.037 --> 01:20:08.680
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, not even mentioning how transportation dollars is one of the most effective ways you can spend to improve public safety.

759
01:20:09.835 --> 01:20:15.900
<v Sameer Kanal>So I think it's phenomenal that this taxes being undertaken by the city.

760
01:20:16.496 --> 01:20:38.628
<v Sameer Kanal>And I deeply appreciate the councilor's support for this work when taxation has a natural negative stigma with the public, and still recognizing the nature of our challenges in getting this investment, especially when our partners at the state and federal level are not as solid as we would hope they would be.

761
01:20:39.462 --> 01:20:43.345
<v Sameer Kanal>I think it's wonderful to see us looking at these kinds of solutions.

762
01:20:44.740 --> 01:21:12.828
<v Sameer Kanal>Just from a frontline worker's perspective, I can tell you that the past decade of underfunding in transportation has had real impacts, not just in the natural stress that is created when you don't know if your job providing essential work for the city is going to be there for you year over year, But in your understanding of the value that city leadership places on that work.

763
01:21:13.613 --> 01:21:26.795
<v Sameer Kanal>It can be a real culture poison for the workplace to feel like you're not considered or thought of when every day you go out there and handle problems that you know are directly benefiting the community.

764
01:21:27.885 --> 01:21:35.570
<v Sameer Kanal>So seeing this kind of action taken to put that investment in our frontline staff to do their essential duties.

765
01:21:36.405 --> 01:21:54.716
<v Sameer Kanal>It's not just, you know, the obvious positives of having that reliable income that prevents us from having a crisis model of funding where we have this backlog that breaks and fixing it in those extreme circumstances is 10 times as costly as the routine repair and maintenance.

766
01:21:55.582 --> 01:22:09.020
<v Sameer Kanal>It also puts that, that kind of morale boost into our workforce that gets them bought into the initiative of the city to accomplish this work that they're dedicating parts of their lives to.

767
01:22:10.110 --> 01:22:21.490
<v Sameer Kanal>So I do want to say that there's been a lot of communication around the exact nature of this tax, especially, you know, how each individual household is managed.

768
01:22:22.405 --> 01:22:26.932
<v Sameer Kanal>And I do just want to caution about not letting the perfect be the enemy of the good here.

769
01:22:26.980 --> 01:22:27.109
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

770
01:22:28.024 --> 01:22:52.939
<v Sameer Kanal>Having a reliable stream of revenue that we can count on that is not too complex to implement and actually bring into the city is going to be so, so valuable to actually achieving our frontline goals in getting our transportation, you know, not just up to par, but implementing the innovations that I know we've been talking about for decades.

771
01:22:54.173 --> 01:23:00.396
<v Sameer Kanal>So I really just wanted to say thank you for all the work that has gone into the assessment of these 2 taxes.

772
01:23:01.215 --> 01:23:20.426
<v Sameer Kanal>And, you know, whatever kind of blowback that this council might receive for trying to enrich the community in this way, just because it has a cost, you know, please know that you have dedicated support in this city that's willing to take your thank you.

773
01:23:21.420 --> 01:23:22.125
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, James.

774
01:23:22.717 --> 01:23:23.726
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for your testimony.

775
01:23:23.903 --> 01:23:25.362
<v Olivia Clark>Kari, would you like to go next?

776
01:23:25.841 --> 01:23:26.386
<v Unidentified speaker>Yeah, thank you.

777
01:23:26.707 --> 01:23:27.604
<v Unidentified speaker>Uh, my name is Kari Ko.

778
01:23:28.069 --> 01:23:29.416
<v Unidentified speaker>I share they pronouns.

779
01:23:29.591 --> 01:23:32.460
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm the president of the City of Portland Professional Workers Union.

780
01:23:33.037 --> 01:23:37.252
<v Unidentified speaker>We represent, uh, about 800 folks all around the city in every bureau.

781
01:23:37.925 --> 01:23:42.363
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, we provide essential services that we like to call the glue that holds the city together.

782
01:23:42.891 --> 01:23:48.090
<v Unidentified speaker>Um, I'm here today because stable funding is is crucial for our members and for the broader Portland community.

783
01:23:48.668 --> 01:23:59.877
<v Unidentified speaker>And the issues faced by PBOT are not only about the roads themselves, but about how the roads are connectivity, multimodal transportation, and about safe communities, which we've heard people speak well to today.

784
01:24:00.889 --> 01:24:05.592
<v Unidentified speaker>So our streets not only need to be well maintained, but safe spaces and community spaces.

785
01:24:05.850 --> 01:24:30.461
<v Unidentified speaker>Building stable funding here at the local level, I think, allows council to be more in control about not only supporting the really important visible work of filling potholes out in our community and doing other critical maintenance, but also supporting the internal-facing work that, that is included in all of the services that PBOT provides, these essential pieces of building a healthy, safe, and well-connected city.

786
01:24:31.261 --> 01:24:32.800
<v Keelan McClymont>And this is the work that our members do.

787
01:24:32.895 --> 01:24:57.341
<v Unidentified speaker>It looks like being in regular direct contacts with residents, businesses, schools, communities about safety issues, repair, engagement, impact, creating third spaces, the safe community places that the people of Portland value, whether that's safe routes to schools, street plazas, Sunday parkways, and overseeing capital controls, financial analysis, ensuring contract work on big projects is completed on time and on budget.

788
01:24:57.886 --> 01:25:09.328
<v Unidentified speaker>As with all core services, this is the work that allows the other work to happen effectively and efficiently, and that is part of the overall funding project that I'm hoping thank you.

789
01:25:09.440 --> 01:25:13.774
<v Unidentified speaker>Our streets and roads are some of the most dangerous places in the city, as we know.

790
01:25:14.528 --> 01:25:16.597
<v Keelan McClymont>So we support moving forward with this fee.

791
01:25:16.902 --> 01:25:18.250
<v Unidentified speaker>We're happy to be here in support of it.

792
01:25:18.844 --> 01:25:41.250
<v Unidentified speaker>But we also encourage you to continue pushing on other concepts so that we can solve how multinational corporations and their subcontractors that dominate many of our roads with their delivery vehicles can use a fee of some sort to be part of our future transportation infrastructure planning, that if companies want to use our public assets, They must pay their fair share.

793
01:25:41.894 --> 01:25:45.805
<v Unidentified speaker>So thank you for having me here today, and we look forward to continuing to be a part of the conversation.

794
01:25:46.649 --> 01:25:47.358
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you so much, Carrie.

795
01:25:47.472 --> 01:25:48.742
<v Olivia Clark>Sorry I mispronounced your name.

796
01:25:48.971 --> 01:25:49.483
<v Unidentified speaker>Oh, that's okay.

797
01:25:52.682 --> 01:25:53.006
<v Jamie Dunphy>Good morning.

798
01:25:54.221 --> 01:25:54.756
<v Eric Zimmerman>My name is—.

799
01:25:56.958 --> 01:25:57.703
<v Mitch Green>My name is Rob Martineau.

800
01:25:57.850 --> 01:26:04.054
<v Mitch Green>I'm the president of AFSCME Local 189, representing over 1,000 city employees across 26 bureaus.

801
01:26:05.845 --> 01:26:11.099
<v Mitch Green>It's clear from your open today and, and the tone in this room that if I want an argument, I'll have to change the subject.

802
01:26:11.487 --> 01:26:13.248
<v Mitch Green>And so I just want to make this brief.

803
01:26:13.880 --> 01:26:17.413
<v Mitch Green>You have a difficult choice, not a complicated one.

804
01:26:18.475 --> 01:26:25.505
<v Mitch Green>I want to encourage you to resist suggestions that this is nuanced or that it somehow needs to be more complex or added to.

805
01:26:26.213 --> 01:26:29.198
<v Mitch Green>PBOT, at your direction, has already done the work.

806
01:26:30.663 --> 01:26:31.251
<v Olivia Clark>Big decisions.

807
01:26:31.792 --> 01:26:38.623
<v Mitch Green>Our city council will either fund or fail its largest infrastructure system.

808
01:26:40.295 --> 01:26:40.488
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

809
01:26:42.479 --> 01:26:43.045
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Rob.

810
01:26:43.141 --> 01:26:43.871
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, panelists.

811
01:26:43.951 --> 01:26:46.038
<v Olivia Clark>Really appreciate your being here, all of you.

812
01:26:47.520 --> 01:26:52.926
<v Olivia Clark>Let's call up our next panel: Alan Hippolito, Don Bach, and Ryan Hashigan.

813
01:26:57.244 --> 01:26:57.681
<v Olivia Clark>One more.

814
01:26:59.171 --> 01:27:01.694
<v Olivia Clark>It's okay.

815
01:27:02.018 --> 01:27:03.020
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for being here.

816
01:27:03.377 --> 01:27:04.930
<v Olivia Clark>I know Don's on his way.

817
01:27:06.770 --> 01:27:07.480
<v Olivia Clark>Alan, should we start with you?

818
01:27:07.837 --> 01:27:08.645
<v Mitch Green>Sure, thank you.

819
01:27:09.390 --> 01:27:10.570
<v Mitch Green>Buenos días, consejeras.

820
01:27:10.667 --> 01:27:12.042
<v Mitch Green>Me llamo Alan Hipólito.

821
01:27:13.012 --> 01:27:14.015
<v Mitch Green>I work for SUMA.

822
01:27:14.081 --> 01:27:22.408
<v Mitch Green>We're a Portland-based nonprofit that builds technology with low-income people, people of color, adults with disability, and other vulnerable Portlanders.

823
01:27:24.208 --> 01:27:42.234
<v Mitch Green>This includes the Summa app, an e-commerce marketplace where low-income Portlanders purchase and save money on essential expenses, overcoming privacy and other barriers that these customers have told us prevent them from using their phones to pay for food, transportation, and utilities.

824
01:27:43.550 --> 01:27:48.408
<v Mitch Green>Now, there's a lot here that we're happy to discuss at another time, but it doesn't really fit into 2 minutes.

825
01:27:48.618 --> 01:27:54.027
<v Mitch Green>So today I want to share one of the barriers that we're solving for with our users and partners.

826
01:27:54.782 --> 01:28:07.398
<v Mitch Green>Low-income community members know that subsidies and public benefit programs are out there for them, but accessing these benefits can be challenging, stressful, and time-consuming, and so many benefits are left on the table.

827
01:28:08.425 --> 01:28:21.868
<v Mitch Green>More specifically, I want you to know that SUMA, our users, and our partners— groups like Apano, Hacienda CDC, Do Good Multnomah, Home Forward Miracles Club, Brown Hope, the Uprise Collective, and many, many others.

828
01:28:22.462 --> 01:28:30.332
<v Mitch Green>We see the same challenge as you do and that Indy articulated as necessary work for the TUF ordinance to be successful.

829
01:28:30.622 --> 01:28:39.101
<v Mitch Green>How do we distribute a utility bill-based rebate to eligible low-income households who don't receive a bill from that utility?

830
01:28:39.918 --> 01:28:45.694
<v Mitch Green>The many low-income Portlanders who live in master-metered family units thank you.

831
01:28:47.139 --> 01:29:07.545
<v Mitch Green>For example, we see this issue in community solar, which is a way for an individual subscriber to benefit from an offsite solar array, such as the PSEF-funded array Apano is building with the Bird Alliance of Oregon and Bonneville Environmental Foundation in PacificCorp territory in the Jade District.

832
01:29:08.572 --> 01:29:16.367
<v Mitch Green>In the existing practice, as a low-income subscriber benefits via a reduced PacificCorp electricity bill.

833
01:29:17.313 --> 01:29:30.398
<v Mitch Green>But this means that residents who live in PGE territory in the Jade District or who live in a master meter building anywhere in the Jade cannot benefit from the existing practice.

834
01:29:31.136 --> 01:29:41.106
<v Mitch Green>So Apano asked us, can we use the Suma app to deliver these community solar benefits to our community members who aren't served by community solar's on-bill model.

835
01:29:41.939 --> 01:29:43.863
<v Mitch Green>And that's what we're doing together with Apano.

836
01:29:43.943 --> 01:29:48.412
<v Mitch Green>We're enrolling 119 Jade community members in the Bilingual Suma app.

837
01:29:48.654 --> 01:30:09.082
<v Mitch Green>Collectively, these users will save $37,000 annually on app products as we leverage those community solar benefits, PSEF subsidy, PBOT's transportation wallet, alongside discounts from vendors like Fubon, Hung Phat, Lime, and Biketown, all in the user's Suma app wallet.

838
01:30:09.885 --> 01:30:18.761
<v Mitch Green>We're excited to work with PBOT, PWB, and others to explore a TUF pilot in the Jade that leverages all this existing work we're already doing.

839
01:30:18.953 --> 01:30:24.240
<v Mitch Green>This would allow us to bring new users, new partners, new subsidy, and new vendors to the project.

840
01:30:25.057 --> 01:30:34.998
<v Mitch Green>Distributing a utility bill-based rebate to eligible low-income households who don't receive a bill from that utility is thank you, Alan.

841
01:30:36.917 --> 01:30:39.559
<v Olivia Clark>I think we're all very interested in cutting-edge technology.

842
01:30:40.212 --> 01:30:40.676
<v Olivia Clark>Appreciate that.

843
01:30:40.940 --> 01:30:41.389
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

844
01:30:42.184 --> 01:30:43.327
<v Olivia Clark>Don, would you like to go next?

845
01:30:45.439 --> 01:30:46.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>Hi, I'm Don Bach.

846
01:30:46.439 --> 01:30:51.247
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm a 52— 54-year resident of Hillsdale, founder of Southwest Trails.

847
01:30:51.344 --> 01:30:56.202
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm wearing my jacket because if you don't wear a jacket in Southwest, you put yourself in danger.

848
01:30:56.913 --> 01:30:58.998
<v Jamie Dunphy>75% Of our streets don't have sidewalks.

849
01:31:00.006 --> 01:31:01.882
<v Jamie Dunphy>Crosswalks are almost nonexistent.

850
01:31:02.011 --> 01:31:04.752
<v Jamie Dunphy>We can't get PBOT to build them where we want them.

851
01:31:05.537 --> 01:31:07.542
<v Jamie Dunphy>So some of the things here we're going to be talking about.

852
01:31:07.717 --> 01:31:09.930
<v Jamie Dunphy>Number one, I highly support this proposal.

853
01:31:10.603 --> 01:31:21.632
<v Jamie Dunphy>I would suggest you put a sunset of 5 or 7 years so that this can be relooked at at that point in time, because budgeting and all that gets very busy and you really need to look at it again.

854
01:31:22.210 --> 01:31:24.966
<v Jamie Dunphy>And I, for one, don't want to see a lot of proposals that don't go away.

855
01:31:25.063 --> 01:31:25.158
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

856
01:31:25.586 --> 01:31:26.747
<v Jamie Dunphy>Sunset it at some point.

857
01:31:27.617 --> 01:31:36.079
<v Jamie Dunphy>In the 30 years I've been advocating for improved pedestrian and logical bicycle improvements in Southwest Portland, I've seen a great decline in the quality of our streets.

858
01:31:36.869 --> 01:31:50.073
<v Jamie Dunphy>2 things that have not been mentioned here that I think are really important: potholes and poor street maintenance costs a lot to the individual car, truck, and TriMet owners.

859
01:31:50.251 --> 01:31:54.962
<v Jamie Dunphy>You know, and we're the owner of TriMet, but they damage the street a lot, but they're also damaging the equipment when we have poor streets.

860
01:31:55.030 --> 01:31:55.134
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

861
01:31:57.724 --> 01:32:05.748
<v Jamie Dunphy>That hasn't been mentioned, and I think that's a very important thing that people need to understand is if we don't fix our streets, we individually are going to pay a great cost.

862
01:32:06.167 --> 01:32:10.622
<v Jamie Dunphy>And those with older cars pay a greater cost because they're easier to break and they're tougher to repair.

863
01:32:12.752 --> 01:32:15.185
<v Jamie Dunphy>Funding is not the only thing that I think needs fixing in PBOT.

864
01:32:15.233 --> 01:32:20.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>So I'm going to divert a little bit from this whole thing of funding and talk about some things that are really important to us in Southwest.

865
01:32:22.199 --> 01:32:24.895
<v Jamie Dunphy>First of all, the project selection and management process.

866
01:32:24.979 --> 01:32:32.016
<v Jamie Dunphy>The process for new improvements needs to have a lot more citizen involvement early on and throughout the process.

867
01:32:32.947 --> 01:32:37.114
<v Jamie Dunphy>Right now, in the past, and it's getting a little better, but it needs to change dramatically.

868
01:32:37.194 --> 01:32:41.716
<v Jamie Dunphy>PBOT has basically ruled the roost and told us, this is what we're going to do.

869
01:32:42.003 --> 01:32:46.573
<v Jamie Dunphy>And then at the end they say, by the way, we're going to have an open house here to talk about our project that we've decided to do.

870
01:32:47.134 --> 01:32:53.436
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's a complete waste of time, and it doesn't involve the people in the appropriate time, nor give us a chance to really do things.

871
01:32:54.030 --> 01:32:58.783
<v Jamie Dunphy>And so we need to be early on in every project of any significance and consulted.

872
01:32:58.847 --> 01:33:00.789
<v Jamie Dunphy>And if we don't have a lot to say, that's fine.

873
01:33:00.854 --> 01:33:03.439
<v Jamie Dunphy>If we got things to say, needs to be considered carefully.

874
01:33:04.851 --> 01:33:05.719
<v Jamie Dunphy>ADA policies.

875
01:33:05.895 --> 01:33:13.119
<v Jamie Dunphy>Right now, as I understand the rules in PBOT, we can't do anything that doesn't meet ADA policy in terms of investment.

876
01:33:13.617 --> 01:33:19.976
<v Jamie Dunphy>And it's gotten so bad that in several occasions, PBOT's come to Southwest Trails to say, Would you build this trail here?

877
01:33:20.041 --> 01:33:24.539
<v Jamie Dunphy>Because we knew we can't do it because our policies prevent it, because it doesn't make ADA rules.

878
01:33:25.167 --> 01:33:26.082
<v Jamie Dunphy>That's nonsense.

879
01:33:26.628 --> 01:33:30.838
<v Jamie Dunphy>In Southwest, the terrain prevents us from making ADA things in any feasible way.

880
01:33:31.353 --> 01:33:40.543
<v Jamie Dunphy>The grades are steep, and a lot of places we have to use stairs, and we need to be able to have policies that accommodate that in where the terrain is set.

881
01:33:40.623 --> 01:33:48.613
<v Jamie Dunphy>So what we need to change is basically say, where feasible, meet the ADA standards, and where they're not, you don't have to— that we can move forward.

882
01:33:49.710 --> 01:33:50.148
<v Jamie Dunphy>Crosswalks.

883
01:33:50.391 --> 01:33:56.715
<v Jamie Dunphy>In my experience, cars in Southwest do not stop for pedestrians standing by the street.

884
01:33:58.181 --> 01:34:04.359
<v Jamie Dunphy>I had, you know, we basically have a lot of trails that cross streets where the drivers don't even realize the trails are there.

885
01:34:05.039 --> 01:34:08.818
<v Jamie Dunphy>And as a result, they speed by, they don't stop, and they don't slow down.

886
01:34:09.127 --> 01:34:09.583
<v Jamie Dunphy>I've seen that.

887
01:34:10.337 --> 01:34:13.498
<v Jamie Dunphy>What we need is zebra crossings for where trails cross busy streets.

888
01:34:13.564 --> 01:34:14.462
<v Jamie Dunphy>We don't need them on every street.

889
01:34:14.511 --> 01:34:17.720
<v Jamie Dunphy>We need them on major streets where there's a lot of speeding traffic.

890
01:34:18.234 --> 01:34:26.033
<v Sameer Kanal>Sir, I'm going to have to ask you to get to the close of it because we do have several more invited testimonies and we're out of time.

891
01:34:26.082 --> 01:34:27.975
<v Jamie Dunphy>I'm going to finish up real quickly.

892
01:34:28.329 --> 01:34:38.560
<v Jamie Dunphy>Crosswalks for Forti Trail needs to be improved and the crosswalk policy needs major revision, particularly as it relates to Southwest Streetcar expansion, I don't see a need for that right now.

893
01:34:38.560 --> 01:34:39.279
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

894
01:34:39.279 --> 01:34:40.670
<v Jamie Dunphy>I support this.

895
01:34:40.739 --> 01:34:41.760
<v Jamie Dunphy>Put a sunset on it.

896
01:34:41.760 --> 01:34:42.550
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, sir.

897
01:34:42.640 --> 01:34:47.340
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Don, and thank you for your 50 years of experience and sharing that with us.

898
01:34:47.340 --> 01:34:48.260
<v Olivia Clark>I appreciate it.

899
01:34:48.279 --> 01:34:51.399
<v Olivia Clark>Alan— or Ryan, sorry.

900
01:34:51.399 --> 01:34:51.920
<v Sameer Kanal>All good.

901
01:34:51.920 --> 01:34:52.760
<v Sameer Kanal>It's been a busy morning.

902
01:34:53.579 --> 01:34:54.600
<v Sameer Kanal>Hello, City Council.

903
01:34:54.699 --> 01:34:55.560
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for your time today.

904
01:34:55.800 --> 01:35:00.199
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is Ryan Hashiken, and I run a manufacturing business in Old Town, Icicle Tricycles.

905
01:35:00.199 --> 01:35:05.988
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm also one of the elected business representatives and the current co-chair of the Land Use and Transportation Committee for the Old Town Community Thank you.

906
01:35:06.917 --> 01:35:26.618
<v Sameer Kanal>Our business directly relies on Portland's transportation infrastructure, from daily freight shipments to our main location, to using the protected bike lanes on the Burnside Bridge to access suppliers in the Central East Side, to relying on crucial PBOT repairs like the Northeast 33rd Street Bridge to access our powder coating and sandblasting contractors.

907
01:35:27.676 --> 01:35:40.159
<v Sameer Kanal>I want to thank all of City Council, the mayor, and especially Councilor Clark and the land— and the Transportation Infrastructure Committee for putting forth this broad-based fee to address transportation infrastructure maintenance that Portland's businesses depend upon.

908
01:35:41.186 --> 01:35:44.270
<v Sameer Kanal>I also appreciate a Vision Zero lens being applied to maintenance expenses.

909
01:35:44.720 --> 01:35:54.708
<v Sameer Kanal>I hope that approximately 25% of funds and no less than 20% of funds are dedicated to safety and vulnerable users while continuing to engage with community oversight of any program deliverables.

910
01:35:55.625 --> 01:36:09.167
<v Sameer Kanal>I believe this is a promising sign of our new form of government addressing some of the thorniest Thank you all for considering this proposal that received unanimous support from the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee members.

911
01:36:10.002 --> 01:36:15.385
<v Sameer Kanal>Portland businesses need transportation infrastructure maintenance to keep everyone rolling along and succeeding into our future.

912
01:36:15.770 --> 01:36:16.091
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

913
01:36:17.055 --> 01:36:17.489
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Ryan.

914
01:36:17.555 --> 01:36:18.646
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, panelists, very much.

915
01:36:18.760 --> 01:36:20.944
<v Olivia Clark>We're running up against a time crunch.

916
01:36:21.009 --> 01:36:22.213
<v Olivia Clark>We have one more panel.

917
01:36:23.082 --> 01:36:32.893
<v Olivia Clark>Alan DeAnda Hall, Joseph Perez, And I don't know if Earl Blumenauer is here, but he's on the list, and Tyler Frisbee.

918
01:36:33.686 --> 01:36:34.725
<v Olivia Clark>I'm not sure they're here.

919
01:36:35.698 --> 01:36:36.247
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you both.

920
01:36:36.587 --> 01:36:41.122
<v Olivia Clark>Alan, do you want to talk about the Pedestrian Advisory Committee?

921
01:36:42.119 --> 01:36:42.328
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

922
01:36:43.983 --> 01:36:45.332
<v Sameer Kanal>Good morning, council committee members.

923
01:36:45.509 --> 01:36:50.072
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is Alan DeAndahal, and I'm here speaking as a member of the city's Pedestrian Advisory Committee.

924
01:36:50.810 --> 01:37:00.052
<v Sameer Kanal>The PAC is supportive of measures to enhance funding for projects that will bring the city closer to to a future with zero road deaths and a more climate-friendly and safe transportation system.

925
01:37:00.871 --> 01:37:05.363
<v Sameer Kanal>We believe that walking to get to where you need to go should not only be safe, but also a joyful part of your day.

926
01:37:06.261 --> 01:37:07.689
<v Sameer Kanal>Our funding crisis is not new.

927
01:37:08.027 --> 01:37:11.685
<v Sameer Kanal>Communities throughout Portland lack critical infrastructure to cross streets and walk safely.

928
01:37:12.198 --> 01:37:16.979
<v Sameer Kanal>With the loss of state funding and federal leadership, we're on our own to build the solutions our city needs.

929
01:37:17.653 --> 01:37:20.188
<v Sameer Kanal>At the same time, we have the power to shape these solutions.

930
01:37:21.037 --> 01:37:26.997
<v Sameer Kanal>The proposed ordinance before you has improved since the previous draft to acknowledge our goals for safer travel throughout Portland.

931
01:37:27.494 --> 01:37:31.068
<v Sameer Kanal>However, the following changes would make this ordinance stronger.

932
01:37:31.292 --> 01:37:35.009
<v Sameer Kanal>Explicitly prioritize, not just allow, maintenance projects that improve safety.

933
01:37:35.506 --> 01:37:44.014
<v Sameer Kanal>For example, including leading pedestrian intervals, pedestrian-only phases, and otherwise limiting dangerous situations that occur between turning traffic and people crossing the street.

934
01:37:45.055 --> 01:37:49.556
<v Sameer Kanal>Include ADA accessibility improvements under Section G without the modifier associated with maintenance.

935
01:37:50.637 --> 01:37:55.855
<v Sameer Kanal>Bringing our streets up to modern standards that make them accessible to all is a valid form of repair in its own right.

936
01:37:57.170 --> 01:38:00.416
<v Sameer Kanal>Additionally, this is only part of the bigger transportation funding picture.

937
01:38:00.898 --> 01:38:10.567
<v Sameer Kanal>Fixing our streets remains available program to fund capital projects, and this proposal would not offset those funds or other revenue streams lost from— like those from pausing SDCs.

938
01:38:11.279 --> 01:38:15.289
<v Sameer Kanal>Council should refrain from commitments to claw back revenue sources before PBOT's budget is sustainable.

939
01:38:15.337 --> 01:38:15.548
<v Sameer Kanal>Second.

940
01:38:16.467 --> 01:38:24.993
<v Sameer Kanal>We also still encourage council not to lose sight of a greater need for sustainable improvements to compensate for historic disinvestment, including our existing sidewalk and crossing gaps.

941
01:38:25.380 --> 01:38:39.123
<v Sameer Kanal>We appreciate the SIPP concept that Loretta Smith and Mitch Green have previously floated, and we still need to see a serious plan from our leadership for designing a program that brings our streets into a future that equitably and sustainably serves the entire community.

942
01:38:39.750 --> 01:38:40.072
<v Shoshana Cohen>Thank you.

943
01:38:40.247 --> 01:38:41.099
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you, Rowland.

944
01:38:42.260 --> 01:38:42.453
<v Olivia Clark>Joseph.

945
01:38:42.858 --> 01:38:43.244
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

946
01:38:43.746 --> 01:38:44.360
<v Mitch Green>Hello, councilors.

947
01:38:44.587 --> 01:38:45.654
<v Mitch Green>My name is Joseph Perez.

948
01:38:46.073 --> 01:38:47.253
<v Mitch Green>Hello, City Administrator Lee.

949
01:38:47.448 --> 01:38:49.936
<v Mitch Green>Welcome on behalf of the Bicycle Advisory Committee.

950
01:38:50.518 --> 01:39:02.653
<v Mitch Green>I'm the vice chairperson, and as you may know, the Bicycle Advisory Committee is, is formed to advise City Council and all departments of the city on all matters relating to the use of the bicycle.

951
01:39:04.278 --> 01:39:07.250
<v Mitch Green>The Bicycle Advisory Committee appreciates the city's commitment thank you, Mr.

952
01:39:07.250 --> 01:39:07.250
<v Eric Zimmerman>Mayor.

953
01:39:07.250 --> 01:39:07.289
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you, Councilor Dan Ryan, for your presentation.

954
01:39:07.289 --> 01:39:14.640
<v Mitch Green>I want to thank the public for their engagement to the robust public discussion over the past few months about how we maintain our streets that have citywide significance.

955
01:39:15.489 --> 01:39:22.270
<v Mitch Green>Now the time has come to act, to approve the transportation utility fee and the street damage restoration fee.

956
01:39:22.929 --> 01:39:33.369
<v Mitch Green>Some roads are still crumbling, and meanwhile, you all recently voted on a strong Vision Zero resolution to recommit the city to zero fatal crashes and serious injuries.

957
01:39:34.117 --> 01:39:43.289
<v Mitch Green>And also recently, a 2026-2027 addendum to Portland's Vision Zero Action Plan was released, released last week.

958
01:39:43.994 --> 01:39:47.891
<v Mitch Green>Portland has adopted goal of 25% of all trips by bicycle by 2030.

959
01:39:48.725 --> 01:39:55.140
<v Mitch Green>Driving a car is a privilege, a very expensive privilege, and Portlanders know and want a better way.

960
01:39:55.862 --> 01:40:06.608
<v Mitch Green>The 2022 Portland Insights survey stated that 60.2% of Portlanders 45% want to ride bicycles if they were affordable and safe.

961
01:40:07.337 --> 01:40:08.778
<v Mitch Green>So we need safer streets.

962
01:40:09.520 --> 01:40:11.722
<v Mitch Green>Portlanders expressed this to the city more than 3 years ago.

963
01:40:12.527 --> 01:40:16.145
<v Mitch Green>Now we need funding for safer streets.

964
01:40:16.466 --> 01:40:17.175
<v Mitch Green>We need your leadership.

965
01:40:17.920 --> 01:40:20.118
<v Mitch Green>We need to pay for the safe streets that we want.

966
01:40:20.698 --> 01:40:23.609
<v Mitch Green>And after Portlanders pay, Portlanders want the city to deliver.

967
01:40:24.420 --> 01:40:29.786
<v Mitch Green>At the March meeting, the Bike Advisory Committee adopted a motion to request that the City Council take action to address the transportation funding gap in Portland.

968
01:40:29.833 --> 01:40:33.501
<v Mitch Green>Councilmember shortfall during this fiscal year 2026-2027.

969
01:40:34.560 --> 01:40:37.707
<v Mitch Green>We need a fee that everybody pays so that everybody benefits.

970
01:40:38.092 --> 01:40:40.212
<v Mitch Green>This important funding will be put to good use.

971
01:40:40.421 --> 01:40:50.761
<v Mitch Green>As I said before, 75% of the fee to go toward needed maintenance, and I am excited to hear others talking about no less than 20% for safety improvements for Vision Zero.

972
01:40:50.954 --> 01:41:01.128
<v Mitch Green>The Bike Advisory Committee is excited to engage with City Council on how to best use these resources going forward for walking and bicycling safety projects that are not related to maintenance.

973
01:41:03.310 --> 01:41:09.947
<v Mitch Green>As bicycle advocates, our lived experience is that safe, smooth, clean bikeways encourage people to ride bicycles.

974
01:41:10.550 --> 01:41:12.457
<v Mitch Green>We need to maintain existing infrastructure.

975
01:41:12.521 --> 01:41:18.747
<v Mitch Green>We advocate for you all to invest in the infrastructure that encourages good behavior and discourages bad behavior.

976
01:41:19.296 --> 01:41:21.104
<v Mitch Green>People don't smoke in restaurants anymore.

977
01:41:21.492 --> 01:41:23.929
<v Mitch Green>People now wear seat belts when they choose to drive.

978
01:41:24.300 --> 01:41:32.815
<v Mitch Green>So we need fees that pay for the projects that make our city safer and projects that encourage people to ride public transit and ride bicycles.

979
01:41:35.239 --> 01:41:42.614
<v Mitch Green>A few months ago, our chair said to the Transportation Infrastructure Committee, we want you to strive for greatness instead of the mediocre.

980
01:41:43.479 --> 01:41:46.547
<v Mitch Green>It is never going to be easy, but it is time to get started.

981
01:41:47.371 --> 01:41:57.542
<v Mitch Green>Future you— future you is not going to be satisfied future you is counting on you to do the work now, to do the hard work now.

982
01:41:58.180 --> 01:42:00.797
<v Mitch Green>Future you is here.

983
01:42:01.827 --> 01:42:06.292
<v Mitch Green>The Bicycle Advisory Committee really looks forward to helping you out on this important matter.

984
01:42:06.711 --> 01:42:10.909
<v Mitch Green>Thank you all for your service to the community, and remember, Portland is what we make it.

985
01:42:12.516 --> 01:42:15.881
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you both for being here, and thank you both for serving on the advisory committees.

986
01:42:16.011 --> 01:42:16.698
<v Olivia Clark>We appreciate that.

987
01:42:16.845 --> 01:42:21.002
<v Olivia Clark>And with that, Uh, Chair, I think we're done with the invited testimony.

988
01:42:21.596 --> 01:42:24.181
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, uh, Councilor Clark, Vice President Clark.

989
01:42:24.310 --> 01:42:28.998
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, we will be— if, if, uh, Congressman Blumenauer does get here, we'll of course make sure there's time.

990
01:42:29.529 --> 01:42:39.387
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, before we go into testimony, or before we take a break and then go into testimony, I did want to ask if there are any sponsor amendments or any very brief technical questions.

991
01:42:40.127 --> 01:42:49.310
<v Sameer Kanal>We've got a couple minutes for that, so if not, uh, I know there are people in the queue, but just wanted to, um, say if you don't have a technical question, we'll definitely keep your spot in the queue.

992
01:42:49.760 --> 01:42:51.912
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, Councilor Green, is, is it a technical question?

993
01:42:53.229 --> 01:42:54.770
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Zimmerman, is it a technical question?

994
01:42:55.220 --> 01:42:56.792
<v Sameer Kanal>Please go ahead and I'll come to you next.

995
01:42:57.868 --> 01:42:58.253
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, thanks.

996
01:42:58.752 --> 01:43:03.600
<v Dan Ryan>I am hoping that, um, you guys don't have to stay at the dais there.

997
01:43:03.664 --> 01:43:05.737
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, because it's certainly not to you.

998
01:43:05.978 --> 01:43:15.885
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm, I'm going to pose this I'll ask this question to the administration because I've been through a lot of street fee conversations and presentations in my career.

999
01:43:16.655 --> 01:43:20.846
<v Eric Zimmerman>As we move forward, I hope that we can get some metric, right?

1000
01:43:21.231 --> 01:43:32.938
<v Eric Zimmerman>Road miles paved, number of intersections improved, potholes fixed, how we plan to finally keep bike lanes clean and clear, and as we just heard, smooth and ready to be used.

1001
01:43:33.354 --> 01:43:46.024
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I don't expect that in the moment, but I do think that that actually qualifies as a technical question for this because I need to really understand what this is.

1002
01:43:46.121 --> 01:43:51.082
<v Eric Zimmerman>There was a lot of testimony today about the safety improvements that will be funded with this.

1003
01:43:51.260 --> 01:43:57.073
<v Eric Zimmerman>And in all of my reading, I've found zero specific examples of what will be funded.

1004
01:43:57.121 --> 01:44:00.926
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I think that falls in the technical category.

1005
01:44:00.990 --> 01:44:05.680
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I'm going to offer that up as a previewing question because I think it It will come with some— there'll be some background work.

1006
01:44:05.746 --> 01:44:06.912
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that's all I have, Chair.

1007
01:44:08.322 --> 01:44:08.581
<v Jamie Dunphy>Thank you.

1008
01:44:08.630 --> 01:44:10.136
<v Sameer Kanal>If there's a brief response, feel free.

1009
01:44:10.670 --> 01:44:10.845
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah.

1010
01:44:10.926 --> 01:44:21.041
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, I know staff is currently working on all of those details to pull back to council as it relates to how we would actually spend the money.

1011
01:44:21.137 --> 01:44:31.842
<v Sameer Kanal>I know some of the conversation has been around kind of what the percentage breakdown of what would be potentially dedicated towards maintenance to kind of really see what a real program will look like.

1012
01:44:32.367 --> 01:44:45.805
<v Sameer Kanal>As we roll forward with maintenance, we do have data that talks about, you know, the average cost of potholes and how many potholes we feel we could fix and how many street maintenance repairs we can actually do with the amount of dollars that we have.

1013
01:44:45.869 --> 01:44:49.097
<v Sameer Kanal>And we can make sure that information is available.

1014
01:44:49.644 --> 01:44:53.287
<v Mark Lear>But take it a little step further than what you've just mentioned.

1015
01:44:53.818 --> 01:45:08.833
<v Sameer Kanal>One thing that I'll be looking for as we move this thing forward that we're actually marketing and actually communicating to the public how these dollars are being spent and actually having a webpage actually talk about where these dollars are actually being spent.

1016
01:45:09.073 --> 01:45:14.823
<v Sameer Kanal>So we're very transparent regarding the impact that these dollars are making within the community as a whole.

1017
01:45:15.417 --> 01:45:24.139
<v Sameer Kanal>And if we are using it to do major projects, to have the marketing around that to show, hey, this is where your TUF dollars are going and being used in the city.

1018
01:45:24.811 --> 01:45:36.310
<v Sameer Kanal>So these are all things that we want to make sure as we move forward with transparency and how we're spending the taxpayers' dollars, that they understand where those dollars are going and the actual impact of it.

1019
01:45:36.694 --> 01:45:46.911
<v Sameer Kanal>So we will be rolling out that kind of dashboard transparency to actually show the matrix as well once we fine-tune where we actually spending those dollars and the best use of those dollars.

1020
01:45:47.006 --> 01:45:47.247
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thanks.

1021
01:45:47.488 --> 01:45:48.322
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm going to expand, Chair.

1022
01:45:48.386 --> 01:45:50.774
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm sorry, I have another technical related to that.

1023
01:45:52.313 --> 01:46:02.453
<v Eric Zimmerman>The breakdown, and I don't have a page— slide 30, I think, was a breakdown of the percentage, the cost by single-family or multifamily.

1024
01:46:05.560 --> 01:46:10.478
<v Eric Zimmerman>What I haven't been able to deduce there is what is expected to be raised in each of those categories.

1025
01:46:11.159 --> 01:46:18.329
<v Eric Zimmerman>So 4.3% against the commercial utility bill represents what percentage of the $46 million that's targeted for that?

1026
01:46:19.025 --> 01:46:19.122
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yes.

1027
01:46:19.188 --> 01:46:20.934
<v Eric Zimmerman>If we could get that, that would be helpful.

1028
01:46:21.676 --> 01:46:34.123
<v Eric Zimmerman>And then in terms of— I think one of the challenges that we heard with the last iteration of the parks levy was that it got focused a lot on coordinators and back-of-office folks instead of frontline folks.

1029
01:46:34.525 --> 01:46:55.859
<v Eric Zimmerman>If we could have an idea for where the bureau plans to go with frontline workers versus coordinators and planners, I think that's helpful to understand how much is actually going to be cleaned in the road Thanks.

1030
01:46:55.859 --> 01:46:57.680
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to go to Councilor Dunphy in a second.

1031
01:46:57.680 --> 01:47:03.359
<v Sameer Kanal>Just wanted to mention slide 18 says it's 70% residential, 30% commercial in the TUF.

1032
01:47:03.359 --> 01:47:09.060
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that the answer, Councilor Clark, to the question?

1033
01:47:09.060 --> 01:47:09.560
<v Sameer Kanal>And while we're—.

1034
01:47:09.560 --> 01:47:12.020
<v Olivia Clark>I think the bureau actually has more detailed information.

1035
01:47:13.000 --> 01:47:15.880
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I wanna make sure we have time to actually discuss it today.

1036
01:47:16.130 --> 01:47:20.439
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm concerned that if we start turning it over to questions, we're not gonna have time for testimony.

1037
01:47:20.909 --> 01:47:21.189
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I just wanna—.

1038
01:47:21.189 --> 01:47:23.590
<v Mitch Green>That's why I was just kind of previewing a few that get to me.

1039
01:47:23.590 --> 01:47:25.310
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, so I'll pass to Councilor Dunphy then.

1040
01:47:25.890 --> 01:47:26.909
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1041
01:47:26.909 --> 01:47:29.090
<v Sameer Kanal>My question hopefully is relatively brief.

1042
01:47:29.090 --> 01:47:37.550
<v Sameer Kanal>It's about the low-income discounts that we're going to be, and I understand that they're, I don't know if it's best suited for Director Williams or perhaps from Alan from Public Communications.

1043
01:47:38.087 --> 01:47:43.305
<v Sameer Kanal>Suma or who, but how is the— how are we going to be implementing?

1044
01:47:43.369 --> 01:47:50.640
<v Sameer Kanal>Can we just be a little bit more explicit about the low-income discounts, the pilot project that I understand is gonna be part of working with Suma?

1045
01:47:50.689 --> 01:47:53.082
<v Sameer Kanal>How are we implementing these things?

1046
01:47:53.260 --> 01:48:00.514
<v Unidentified speaker>I'm sorry, Councilor Dunphy, I would like to call Carisha Leicht, our customer service manager, to share information on that.

1047
01:48:00.743 --> 01:48:00.970
<v Unidentified speaker>Okay.

1048
01:48:03.462 --> 01:48:05.166
<v Unidentified speaker>Or Becky Anaker.

1049
01:48:05.551 --> 01:48:12.682
<v Shoshana Cohen>Can I also, while they're coming up, we've identified this problem and we've started talking with Quisha and her team.

1050
01:48:13.164 --> 01:48:14.850
<v Shoshana Cohen>We still have more work to do.

1051
01:48:14.948 --> 01:48:18.996
<v Shoshana Cohen>So she can talk about some of the work they're doing, but we don't have a specific proposal yet.

1052
01:48:19.123 --> 01:48:21.791
<v Shoshana Cohen>We are sort of committing to figuring this out.

1053
01:48:22.819 --> 01:48:27.556
<v Unidentified speaker>But we're happy to share what the— how the loan discount program works in the Water Bureau.

1054
01:48:28.038 --> 01:48:30.930
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes, Becky Anaker, Interim Customer Service Director, for the record.

1055
01:48:31.573 --> 01:48:38.283
<v Millicent Williams>We have a robust, uh, low-income discount program that we currently serve for water, sewer, and stormwater customers.

1056
01:48:38.395 --> 01:48:39.536
<v Unidentified speaker>It's multi-tiered.

1057
01:48:40.145 --> 01:48:46.551
<v Unidentified speaker>And in addition to that, we also have a ramp program that we've talked about, um, previously with council and for our multifamily.

1058
01:48:46.600 --> 01:49:00.689
<v Unidentified speaker>So there is, um, basis for this and the reciprocity that we would be happy to support in developing a program, um, for PBOT, uh, throughout customer service and be happy to offer that to our customers and operationalize that as well.

1059
01:49:01.091 --> 01:49:01.203
<v Sameer Kanal>Great.

1060
01:49:01.331 --> 01:49:07.243
<v Sameer Kanal>You know, uh, District 1, uh, East Portland, we have, uh, average income about 2/3 the rest of the city.

1061
01:49:07.581 --> 01:49:12.212
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, it is a— I mean, but we also have the worst infrastructure in a lot of the ways.

1062
01:49:12.340 --> 01:49:14.984
<v Sameer Kanal>So, um, it is a careful balance for my folks.

1063
01:49:15.112 --> 01:49:43.257
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just really interested to make sure that those cases, um, you know, obviously we need to do this, uh, obviously I'm going to be supportive of this today, but, um, I'm— I, I do want to make sure that for those folks in our community that we are being front and center about this and being innovative and trying to err on the side of being overly generous, I suppose, is sort of my preference at this point to right-size these things because we're also getting a notice about other cost increases like PGE going to be raising their utility fees.

1064
01:49:43.595 --> 01:49:45.314
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm interested.

1065
01:49:45.442 --> 01:49:54.167
<v Sameer Kanal>I would love to be kept up— I hope the council will be kept up to date as we finish all this and if there's more for us to be able to do to help implement something like that.

1066
01:49:54.344 --> 01:50:18.860
<v Millicent Williams>Councilor, if I may, I just wanted to mention part of the reason why we are proposing that we would not start implementation until January 1st, 2027 is to allow us the time after the budget passes, presuming that this makes it, that we would be able to work through all of those details and effectively communicate about how we intend to implement the program and how it will support the whole of community.

1067
01:50:19.296 --> 01:50:27.123
<v Millicent Williams>So that's, that's really what we anticipated would be the need, that 5 to 6 month period of, uh, ramping up to ensure that we are serving well.

1068
01:50:28.483 --> 01:50:28.757
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

1069
01:50:30.115 --> 01:50:31.182
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Dunphy.

1070
01:50:31.572 --> 01:50:52.069
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, I do see that, that Congressman Blumenauer has arrived, so I want to make sure we give, uh, him time, and then, um, we'll, we'll take our break right after that, come back and do, uh, any floating of amendments, public test, and we'll even get into but, um, but, uh, and I'm not sure if Tyler Frisbee is also here, but I would love to welcome you up as well.

1071
01:50:52.439 --> 01:50:52.778
<v Eric Zimmerman>I see you.

1072
01:50:55.646 --> 01:50:56.037
<v Jamie Dunphy>Yeah.

1073
01:50:56.313 --> 01:50:56.913
<v Dan Ryan>I'm good.

1074
01:50:57.838 --> 01:50:58.293
<v Mark Lear>I, I—.

1075
01:50:58.488 --> 01:50:59.917
<v Mitch Green>This makes me feel uncomfortable.

1076
01:51:02.730 --> 01:51:05.345
<v Sameer Kanal>Any, anytime I got a gavel, we'll make sure you have time here.

1077
01:51:05.489 --> 01:51:07.685
<v Sameer Kanal>So, uh, thank you so much for being here, Congressman.

1078
01:51:07.734 --> 01:51:11.707
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, well, I, I appreciate very much, uh, Thank you, Mr.

1079
01:51:11.756 --> 01:51:11.820
<v Mitch Green>Mayor.

1080
01:51:11.868 --> 01:51:21.719
<v Mitch Green>Thank you for the council taking this on and giving me the opportunity to be here with my colleague Tyler Frisbee, who's the director of the Institute for Metropolitan Studies.

1081
01:51:23.865 --> 01:51:32.806
<v Mitch Green>I've spent a little time dealing with these issues in the past, and I'm well aware of the BIPE that you are dealing with now.

1082
01:51:33.356 --> 01:51:37.962
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate the fact that you are sinking your teeth in at a time that's not easy to do.

1083
01:51:38.311 --> 01:51:39.067
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1084
01:51:39.114 --> 01:51:54.898
<v Mitch Green>To make sure that when you deal with things like a broad utility fee and a charge for those who work in the right-of-way and make problems that you have to clean up later, this is a big challenge for livability.

1085
01:51:55.411 --> 01:52:00.628
<v Mitch Green>And I appreciate some of you looking at the asset management and the big picture.

1086
01:52:01.190 --> 01:52:17.141
<v Mitch Green>And at a time when there are tremendous It's— Cross pressures that you're stepping up and doing this in a way that may not always be that popular with the general public, but is absolutely critical to be able to maintain the livability of our community.

1087
01:52:17.976 --> 01:52:19.278
<v Mitch Green>This is broad-based.

1088
01:52:19.439 --> 01:52:21.319
<v Mitch Green>It's an ongoing revenue stream.

1089
01:52:22.314 --> 01:52:31.054
<v Mitch Green>The historic foundations in terms of how the city has funded transportation in the past, this is a variation on that.

1090
01:52:31.520 --> 01:52:31.680
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1091
01:52:31.859 --> 01:52:33.462
<v Mitch Green>This is not a break with tradition.

1092
01:52:34.207 --> 01:52:37.965
<v Mitch Green>And as you've seen, other communities are doing this around the country.

1093
01:52:38.655 --> 01:52:47.606
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate your dealing on a comprehensive basis with something to avoid problems in the future with all the other things you've got going on.

1094
01:52:48.115 --> 01:52:54.353
<v Mitch Green>I appreciate the focus on the transportation infrastructure and dealing with things that will make a difference.

1095
01:52:57.350 --> 01:53:02.118
<v Mitch Green>I'd love to have lemonade with any of you if you wanna talk about some of the checkered past.

1096
01:53:03.161 --> 01:53:14.046
<v Mitch Green>But I appreciate what the new council is doing, dealing with an old problem and an interminable one in a way that looks like it'll be sustainable in the past.

1097
01:53:14.560 --> 01:53:21.063
<v Mitch Green>I would like to turn to my colleague, if I could, Ms. Frisbie, who worked with me in Congress.

1098
01:53:21.143 --> 01:53:26.488
<v Mitch Green>She's, as you may know, not only the Institute, but she's also on the TriMet board.

1099
01:53:26.569 --> 01:53:30.733
<v Mitch Green>She's into this up to her elbows, and I would like to defer to her if I could.

1100
01:53:33.510 --> 01:53:34.333
<v Olivia Clark>Good morning, Council.

1101
01:53:34.576 --> 01:53:35.351
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you for having us.

1102
01:53:35.481 --> 01:53:36.452
<v Olivia Clark>My name is Tyler Frisbee.

1103
01:53:36.677 --> 01:53:40.088
<v Olivia Clark>I am here on behalf of the Institute of Metropolitan Studies at Portland State.

1104
01:53:41.042 --> 01:53:50.538
<v Olivia Clark>And as many of you know, when we developed our strategic plan last year, we talked to over 120 folks around the region about the biggest problems facing their community.

1105
01:53:51.457 --> 01:53:59.087
<v Olivia Clark>I knew we would hear about transportation funding from the City of Portland, we were shocked by how much it came up in conversations with folks across the region.

1106
01:53:59.905 --> 01:54:07.599
<v Olivia Clark>And I think I'm here today to help both remind you that this is a deep-seated problem in Portland, but you are not alone.

1107
01:54:08.418 --> 01:54:12.128
<v Olivia Clark>This is something that our folks across the region are dealing with and across the state.

1108
01:54:12.755 --> 01:54:20.640
<v Olivia Clark>And you are taking a step today to address a structural deficit that has been going for a while and without action will continue.

1109
01:54:21.444 --> 01:54:25.747
<v Olivia Clark>The transportation utility fee has been adopted by 30 cities across the state of Oregon.

1110
01:54:26.582 --> 01:54:30.837
<v Olivia Clark>So you, Portland, will be, as is the nature in Oregon, the largest by far.

1111
01:54:31.302 --> 01:54:32.570
<v Olivia Clark>But this is a step.

1112
01:54:32.618 --> 01:54:33.711
<v Olivia Clark>This is a best practice.

1113
01:54:33.806 --> 01:54:43.184
<v Olivia Clark>This is something that occurs frequently in other places, acknowledging the reality of transportation funding and that the old system does not work.

1114
01:54:43.746 --> 01:54:47.376
<v Olivia Clark>That was the theme we heard over and over when we talked to folks across the region.

1115
01:54:48.034 --> 01:54:55.487
<v Olivia Clark>For the past 100 years, we funded transportation mostly dependent on federal dollars with a healthy amount of money coming from the state.

1116
01:54:55.969 --> 01:55:02.859
<v Olivia Clark>And then the city could kind of plug in as needed to do things that felt really important to the city itself.

1117
01:55:03.502 --> 01:55:08.337
<v Olivia Clark>Those federal dollars have not been adjusted for inflation since I was in grade school.

1118
01:55:09.845 --> 01:55:17.167
<v Olivia Clark>The state is deeply behind in terms of the money they need for their own system, much less their ability to support local governments.

1119
01:55:17.793 --> 01:55:21.006
<v Olivia Clark>And the needs of the cities all look very different now.

1120
01:55:21.663 --> 01:55:23.559
<v Olivia Clark>You're not just about maintaining potholes.

1121
01:55:23.606 --> 01:55:24.988
<v Olivia Clark>You're about sidewalk infill.

1122
01:55:25.518 --> 01:55:28.215
<v Olivia Clark>You're about helping make sure people have transit options.

1123
01:55:28.792 --> 01:55:33.079
<v Olivia Clark>You are about making sure that our public plazas are inviting and safe and welcoming places to be.

1124
01:55:34.412 --> 01:55:46.268
<v Olivia Clark>Your needs as So I will say from the Institute's perspective, we are about halfway through a local transportation funding research project.

1125
01:55:46.720 --> 01:55:55.769
<v Olivia Clark>We're very sad that we are not able to support you more in this work, and I'm really happy to come back and talk about that research, what it shows as we get further along.

1126
01:55:56.479 --> 01:55:59.466
<v Olivia Clark>But the challenge that you are addressing today is real.

1127
01:55:59.759 --> 01:56:00.295
<v Olivia Clark>It is felt across the country.

1128
01:56:00.359 --> 01:56:00.537
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

1129
01:56:00.681 --> 01:56:12.643
<v Olivia Clark>The state, it's felt across the region, it's felt across the country, and you are taking a step that is really important in sort of revamping and redeveloping a way of funding transportation in our city.

1130
01:56:13.212 --> 01:56:13.979
<v Olivia Clark>So thank you.

1131
01:56:14.989 --> 01:56:15.528
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you both.

1132
01:56:17.601 --> 01:56:24.929
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, colleagues, I wanted to give everyone— yesterday, uh, Council President Dunphy mentioned that when we're going to float amendments, we'll just ask for a 2-sentence summary.

1133
01:56:25.009 --> 01:56:28.908
<v Sameer Kanal>So if you intend to move an amendment to the to the documents, either of them today.

1134
01:56:29.021 --> 01:56:35.715
<v Sameer Kanal>I wanted to give an opportunity for anyone to, to give a brief summary of that, and then, uh, we can— you'll have more time to get into it after testimony.

1135
01:56:36.329 --> 01:56:40.139
<v Sameer Kanal>Does anyone have, uh, one of— I'm going to go through the queue, and feel free to add yourself to the queue.

1136
01:56:40.203 --> 01:56:40.750
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Green?

1137
01:56:42.533 --> 01:56:51.140
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, one sentence amends the ordinance, uh, under the directive section, item K. Very small tweak.

1138
01:56:51.944 --> 01:57:04.972
<v Mitch Green>Um, That reads PBOT will propose rate adjustments including inflationary increases, and then adds a new clause that says, or rate design proposals to the council through the city's annual budget process.

1139
01:57:05.037 --> 01:57:11.389
<v Mitch Green>So just creates a permission structure to change not just the adjustment of the rate, but also what the rate is and how it's composed.

1140
01:57:12.175 --> 01:57:12.431
<v Dan Ryan>Thanks.

1141
01:57:12.817 --> 01:57:13.859
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Green.

1142
01:57:14.100 --> 01:57:16.795
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, Councilor Smith, is it an amendment?

1143
01:57:17.228 --> 01:57:17.260
<v Sameer Kanal>No.

1144
01:57:17.420 --> 01:57:18.783
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, we'll keep your place in the queue.

1145
01:57:18.927 --> 01:57:20.114
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, I see you online.

1146
01:57:27.114 --> 01:57:28.345
<v Sameer Kanal>Looks like you're having connectivity.

1147
01:57:28.393 --> 01:57:32.097
<v Sameer Kanal>You might want to turn off the, uh, the camera, and I think you're also muted.

1148
01:57:34.319 --> 01:57:38.050
<v Olivia Clark>Did you— you couldn't hear me before, Councilor?

1149
01:57:40.759 --> 01:57:44.966
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I think it came through, but no, no amendment right now.

1150
01:57:45.046 --> 01:57:45.578
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that what I'm hearing?

1151
01:57:48.856 --> 01:57:54.509
<v Olivia Clark>No amendment, just a clarification that I was hoping to get in during technical questions.

1152
01:57:54.556 --> 01:57:56.338
<v Olivia Clark>I'm not sure what happened with my hand there.

1153
01:57:57.399 --> 01:57:59.326
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I'll come right back to you.

1154
01:57:59.550 --> 01:58:01.396
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Zimmerman, do you have an amendment?

1155
01:58:01.573 --> 01:58:10.436
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm going to ask some questions, but I am likely to propose an amendment to take the 75% street damage restoration fee to 100%.

1156
01:58:11.755 --> 01:58:12.141
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1157
01:58:12.884 --> 01:58:30.039
<v Sameer Kanal>And then I have an amendment I've pre-filed that would require looking into the discount programming and assessing if there's ways to provide more support for vulnerable road users and for historically underserved communities.

1158
01:58:30.787 --> 01:58:34.685
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll give you a chance to ask a question, Councilor Pirtle-Guiney, and then we do need to take that break.

1159
01:58:37.345 --> 01:58:40.070
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Chair Kanal.

1160
01:58:40.470 --> 01:58:42.506
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, I don't need this answered now.

1161
01:58:43.306 --> 01:59:03.626
<v Olivia Clark>I see that folks are no longer up at the table, but, um, at some point I would like to understand what falls into the definition of a portion of funds— I think it's 70%— that must be used for maintenance of current infrastructure, um, in parts of our city with more yes.

1162
01:59:03.722 --> 01:59:20.743
<v Keelan McClymont>So for example, we have roads that can be maintained, but they don't have sidewalks on them, or we have greenways that are not— don't have the safety features that greenways in other parts of the city have.

1163
01:59:20.904 --> 01:59:29.659
<v Olivia Clark>I'm trying to understand if upgrading that would count as maintenance of current assets, or if that would not count in that portion.

1164
01:59:29.921 --> 01:59:33.984
<v Keelan McClymont>And at some point, if the bureau can get back back to us all with the answer, I'd appreciate it.

1165
01:59:35.122 --> 01:59:35.266
<v Millicent Williams>Great.

1166
01:59:35.378 --> 01:59:37.671
<v Sameer Kanal>I see them listening and actively in the back.

1167
01:59:37.720 --> 01:59:40.911
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not sure if your angle allows for it, but I'm sure they'll have a—.

1168
01:59:41.136 --> 01:59:41.328
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1169
01:59:41.856 --> 01:59:42.963
<v Sameer Kanal>And then Councilor Koyama Lane.

1170
01:59:43.461 --> 02:00:04.310
<v Keelan McClymont>Well, I'm not sure if this is the only time to bring amendments, and I'm not— this is not fully baked, but I will just— I want to say to the people that testified, um, hearing you all— I hear you all talking about changing G so that no less than 20% of the TUF revenues are expended on traffic safety activities that move us closer to Vision Zero.

1171
02:00:04.952 --> 02:00:08.850
<v Keelan McClymont>I have nothing drafted, but I'm just putting that out there.

1172
02:00:08.979 --> 02:00:09.427
<v Keelan McClymont>I hear you.

1173
02:00:09.524 --> 02:00:10.728
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm interested in that.

1174
02:00:10.775 --> 02:00:13.952
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm not exactly sure what that means for what we have time for today.

1175
02:00:14.994 --> 02:00:15.252
<v Sameer Kanal>Thanks.

1176
02:00:15.332 --> 02:00:21.123
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, so we'll come back in, let's say, 8-ish minutes, and then we'll get going with public testimony.

1177
02:00:21.171 --> 02:00:24.524
<v Sameer Kanal>We might ask— fair warning— we might ask testifiers to keep your time to 2 minutes.

1178
02:00:25.492 --> 02:00:29.337
<v Sameer Kanal>So please start thinking about that, and we'll be back at 11:33.

1179
02:00:29.595 --> 02:00:31.413
<v Sameer Kanal>What's the intent today?

1180
02:12:20.037 --> 02:12:21.087
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, thank you.

1181
02:12:21.167 --> 02:12:22.057
<v Sameer Kanal>We're gonna come back.

1182
02:12:23.594 --> 02:12:24.872
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1183
02:12:27.770 --> 02:12:33.291
<v Sameer Kanal>We're going to come back to conclude our recess.

1184
02:12:34.140 --> 02:12:35.778
<v Sameer Kanal>So if everyone could please take their seats.

1185
02:12:37.255 --> 02:12:38.409
<v Sameer Kanal>First off, thanks for bearing with us.

1186
02:12:38.475 --> 02:12:39.613
<v Sameer Kanal>We took a slightly longer break.

1187
02:12:39.677 --> 02:12:41.893
<v Sameer Kanal>We are able to go a little later in this meeting.

1188
02:12:42.407 --> 02:12:43.369
<v Sameer Kanal>So just flagging that.

1189
02:12:43.449 --> 02:12:44.541
<v Sameer Kanal>And that means 2 things.

1190
02:12:44.717 --> 02:12:53.577
<v Sameer Kanal>One, we may actually have time to do these conversations, but also we are not going to need to cut it for the public testimony further than 2 minutes, which was an option as well.

1191
02:12:53.801 --> 02:12:54.460
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1192
02:12:54.507 --> 02:13:13.359
<v Sameer Kanal>Having said that, before we call public testimony, I did want to say you have the right to use the full 2 minutes, but the best thing for someone who wants this to happen today can— the best thing that they could do is not use the whole time because there will be questions and discussion later and we want to make sure there's space for that while you still, of course, have the right to use the full 2 minutes.

1193
02:13:13.407 --> 02:13:15.286
<v Sameer Kanal>So with that, we're going to get into public testimony.

1194
02:13:15.960 --> 02:13:17.453
<v Sameer Kanal>Keelan, would you please call the first panel?

1195
02:13:20.060 --> 02:13:23.612
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, I will call people up in groups of 5.

1196
02:13:23.773 --> 02:13:28.922
<v Keelan McClymont>Please come up to the table and go ahead and unmute and state your name for the record.

1197
02:13:29.744 --> 02:13:38.792
<v Keelan McClymont>First up, we have Eric Fruits, Jordan Lewis, RJ Shepherd, Karen Chire, Thomas Bussey.

1198
02:13:44.096 --> 02:13:46.757
<v Sameer Kanal>Please feel free to get started while folks are still taking their seats.

1199
02:13:51.113 --> 02:13:52.675
<v Mitch Green>Good morning, members of City Council.

1200
02:13:52.819 --> 02:13:53.899
<v Mitch Green>My name is Eric Fruits.

1201
02:13:53.947 --> 02:13:56.072
<v Mitch Green>I'm a Portland resident and business owner.

1202
02:13:56.930 --> 02:14:04.653
<v Mitch Green>I was here and actively involved in the 2014 street fee debacle, so I can tell you that I know what I'm talking about.

1203
02:14:05.270 --> 02:14:14.284
<v Mitch Green>I'm also an economist, and in that role, I'm here to warn you that the mechanics behind the proposed transportation packages are fundamentally broken.

1204
02:14:14.887 --> 02:14:22.690
<v Mitch Green>The transportation utility fee, the street damage restoration fee, are legally risky, highly regressive, and intentionally mislabeled.

1205
02:14:23.283 --> 02:14:24.613
<v Mitch Green>Let's be honest with the public.

1206
02:14:25.527 --> 02:14:26.537
<v Mitch Green>These are not fees.

1207
02:14:26.792 --> 02:14:27.738
<v Mitch Green>They are taxes.

1208
02:14:28.411 --> 02:14:31.503
<v Mitch Green>A fee is a charge for a service that you choose to use.

1209
02:14:32.001 --> 02:14:34.420
<v Mitch Green>You can avoid a fee by avoiding the service.

1210
02:14:35.364 --> 02:14:36.662
<v Mitch Green>You cannot avoid a tax.

1211
02:14:37.047 --> 02:14:42.752
<v Mitch Green>Under this proposal, a household cannot avoid the transportation utility fee by driving less, Yes.

1212
02:14:42.896 --> 02:14:43.925
<v Eric Zimmerman>Or getting rid of their cars.

1213
02:14:44.502 --> 02:14:48.069
<v Mitch Green>Simply living behind 4 walls triggers this tax.

1214
02:14:48.533 --> 02:14:52.711
<v Mitch Green>There is no way to opt out, and when you cannot opt out, it is a tax.

1215
02:14:53.497 --> 02:14:56.212
<v Mitch Green>Because it's a flat tax, it's deeply regressive.

1216
02:14:56.871 --> 02:14:59.423
<v Mitch Green>It will disproportionately burden the poorest Portlanders.

1217
02:15:00.501 --> 02:15:06.378
<v Mitch Green>The city's promise of looking for some low-income rate— rent relief or rate relief is disingenuous at best.

1218
02:15:06.845 --> 02:15:11.567
<v Mitch Green>Low-income renters in multifamily buildings with master meters do not receive a water Next.

1219
02:15:12.368 --> 02:15:22.154
<v Mitch Green>Any of the current low-income reductions are practically unavailable to most of the vulnerable households that actually need them, despite any promises or efforts that staff have told you.

1220
02:15:23.613 --> 02:15:27.672
<v Mitch Green>Next, the commercial rate on the TUF is economically absurd.

1221
02:15:28.506 --> 02:15:37.859
<v Mitch Green>You are proposing a 4.3% tax on commercial utility bills to pay for roads, but a business's water consumption has absolutely no correlation with its actual transportation use.

1222
02:15:39.095 --> 02:15:42.082
<v Sameer Kanal>The street damage restoration fee is just a hidden ratepayer hike.

1223
02:15:42.612 --> 02:15:54.398
<v Mitch Green>Presenting this as some sort of restoration fee is just fraudulent because we know under cost of service rate making that those costs will be passed on 100% or more to the ratepayers.

1224
02:15:54.751 --> 02:16:00.033
<v Sameer Kanal>When we have skyrocketing utility rates, this will add another 10 to 15%, and you must reject it.

1225
02:16:05.729 --> 02:16:06.900
<v Sameer Kanal>Go ahead.

1226
02:16:07.012 --> 02:16:07.462
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, good morning.

1227
02:16:07.510 --> 02:16:08.439
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is Thomas Bessie.

1228
02:16:08.551 --> 02:16:12.030
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm the treasurer of the Libertarian Party of Oregon, a resident of District 4.

1229
02:16:12.224 --> 02:16:23.752
<v Sameer Kanal>I earn $27 an hour, had to take vacation time off to be here today, and live in a rinky-dinky market-rate studio and do not have a car because I cannot afford one.

1230
02:16:24.810 --> 02:16:35.709
<v Sameer Kanal>Under this highly regressive tax, I would be paying more than my senator who never returns my calls, Lisa Reynolds, who guzzles A million gallons a year at her mansion.

1231
02:16:36.158 --> 02:16:39.087
<v Sameer Kanal>I'd be paying more than most of you at this dais.

1232
02:16:40.170 --> 02:16:41.140
<v Sameer Kanal>I don't understand that.

1233
02:16:41.254 --> 02:16:46.140
<v Sameer Kanal>This is a regressive tax, and I have actually about 25 years in government budgeting.

1234
02:16:46.190 --> 02:16:49.507
<v Sameer Kanal>You saw up there on the screen, Portland has a general fund.

1235
02:16:50.119 --> 02:16:52.115
<v Sameer Kanal>It can fund PBOT out of its general fund.

1236
02:16:52.164 --> 02:16:53.806
<v Sameer Kanal>It has an annual budgeting process.

1237
02:16:53.918 --> 02:16:57.509
<v Sameer Kanal>It can choose to fund PBOT out of that annual budgeting process.

1238
02:16:57.590 --> 02:16:58.543
<v Sameer Kanal>It has chosen not to.

1239
02:16:58.610 --> 02:16:59.202
<v Sameer Kanal>It's the same thing with the arts tax.

1240
02:16:59.252 --> 02:16:59.664
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm sorry, I'm sorry.

1241
02:17:00.584 --> 02:17:02.030
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, let's fund arts education.

1242
02:17:02.110 --> 02:17:02.944
<v Sameer Kanal>What does the school district do?

1243
02:17:03.619 --> 02:17:06.638
<v Sameer Kanal>It cuts arts education and instead it funds teachers' pensions.

1244
02:17:06.685 --> 02:17:08.388
<v Sameer Kanal>So what's going on in the Portland General Fund?

1245
02:17:09.415 --> 02:17:09.623
<v Sameer Kanal>PERS.

1246
02:17:10.299 --> 02:17:11.021
<v Sameer Kanal>That's what this is about.

1247
02:17:11.102 --> 02:17:13.028
<v Sameer Kanal>You're not gonna get more transportation out of this.

1248
02:17:13.430 --> 02:17:18.085
<v Sameer Kanal>You're just enabling an unsustainable PERS balance, which can be fixed.

1249
02:17:18.647 --> 02:17:22.277
<v Sameer Kanal>You have a PSF overage, put that toward paying down your PERS liabilities.

1250
02:17:22.341 --> 02:17:25.006
<v Sameer Kanal>That'll free up the general fund across the board in the city.

1251
02:17:25.070 --> 02:17:25.215
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1252
02:17:25.974 --> 02:17:28.834
<v Sameer Kanal>And I'm not gonna leave you with another solution.

1253
02:17:29.734 --> 02:17:34.087
<v Sameer Kanal>How about a 3% sales tax on concessions at the Portland International Airport?

1254
02:17:34.634 --> 02:17:39.298
<v Sameer Kanal>Half to the city, to the general fund so you can allocate it where it needs to go, and half to TriMet.

1255
02:17:40.056 --> 02:17:45.337
<v Sameer Kanal>But regressive taxes for a progressive city and a progressive board make no sense.

1256
02:17:46.615 --> 02:17:46.927
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1257
02:17:52.125 --> 02:17:53.184
<v Keelan McClymont>We have RJ online.

1258
02:17:53.233 --> 02:17:54.195
<v Sameer Kanal>Hello.

1259
02:17:55.174 --> 02:17:55.352
<v Sameer Kanal>Great.

1260
02:17:55.399 --> 02:17:55.897
<v Sameer Kanal>Can you all hear me?

1261
02:17:57.022 --> 02:17:57.760
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, go for it, RJ.

1262
02:17:57.824 --> 02:17:58.145
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1263
02:17:59.350 --> 02:17:59.621
<v Sameer Kanal>Perfect.

1264
02:17:59.815 --> 02:18:00.762
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, good morning, councilors.

1265
02:18:01.180 --> 02:18:09.063
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, today I'm speaking on behalf of Strong Towns PDX, an all-volunteer organization working to make Portland a safe, livable, and financially resilient place for everyone.

1266
02:18:09.704 --> 02:18:17.234
<v Sameer Kanal>We want to thank Councilor Green for proposing an attachment and motion to study moving the TUF to a use-based TUF, which includes a fixed and variable component.

1267
02:18:17.635 --> 02:18:23.691
<v Dan Ryan>Utility fees are often structured this way, with a fixed fee as your hookup charge and a variable component based on your use.

1268
02:18:24.605 --> 02:18:29.684
<v Sameer Kanal>This attachment, which originated from Strongtown's PDX, is a proposal for a fairer TUF.

1269
02:18:30.389 --> 02:18:34.604
<v Sameer Kanal>In the case of the current proposed TUF, there's effectively zero variable component for the residential households.

1270
02:18:35.278 --> 02:18:35.646
<v Dan Ryan>This is—.

1271
02:18:35.998 --> 02:18:36.254
<v Olivia Clark>This—.

1272
02:18:36.398 --> 02:18:43.754
<v Sameer Kanal>Because this applies to transportation and the largest consumers of our roads, which are 53% of the total consumption, reside outside of our city.

1273
02:18:45.110 --> 02:18:54.700
<v Dan Ryan>For the amount of miles driven by Portland residents, the current TUF also does a poor job of approximating road use.

1274
02:18:55.040 --> 02:19:00.479
<v Dan Ryan>The approximation is based on the Traffic Engineer's Manual, which uses data primarily from suburbs.

1275
02:19:00.739 --> 02:19:02.159
<v Sameer Kanal>Portland is not a suburb.

1276
02:19:02.159 --> 02:19:05.979
<v Sameer Kanal>We have census tracts where 25% of residents don't own a vehicle.

1277
02:19:06.219 --> 02:19:11.219
<v Sameer Kanal>The current TUF does not address the 50% of driver— 53% of drivers who get to drive for free through the City throughout of Portland's transit system.

1278
02:19:11.219 --> 02:19:11.260
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilmember Herbold.

1279
02:19:11.247 --> 02:19:20.180
<v Sameer Kanal>The city, but a proposed route use-based TUF from Councilor Green means a TUF that better approximates VMT for the residents that do use our roads.

1280
02:19:20.532 --> 02:19:33.010
<v Sameer Kanal>The proposed fee of $3 as a fixed fee or a hookup fee and 10 cents per 100 square feet of parcel is simple and can be applied uniformly across the city instead of the 3 different structures currently planned.

1281
02:19:33.522 --> 02:19:49.636
<v Dan Ryan>The proposal would mean that the average Portland household living on an R-5 zoned please work to implement this use-based TUF so that it is a fair TUF for multi-family residents.

1282
02:19:50.182 --> 02:20:02.266
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, it will also address the issues around commercial properties where large Amazon warehouses who are efficient will pay less overall than, say, OHSU that works very hard to use their land use very efficiently.

1283
02:20:02.315 --> 02:20:02.995
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilmember Smith, you have 2 minutes.

1284
02:20:13.784 --> 02:20:15.368
<v Keelan McClymont>Karen is joining us online.

1285
02:20:21.639 --> 02:20:22.716
<v Keelan McClymont>Karen, you're muted.

1286
02:20:23.182 --> 02:20:24.177
<v Keelan McClymont>There we go.

1287
02:20:24.981 --> 02:20:25.656
<v Keelan McClymont>I can hear you.

1288
02:20:26.235 --> 02:20:29.304
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, hello, my name is Karen T. Ray.

1289
02:20:29.545 --> 02:20:32.975
<v Keelan McClymont>I'm both a resident and a business owner deeply invested in the future of our community.

1290
02:20:34.105 --> 02:20:44.117
<v Keelan McClymont>The proposed transportation utility fee represents yet another burden that threatens to stifle local businesses and strain the financial resources of hardworking residents.

1291
02:20:44.614 --> 02:20:47.710
<v Keelan McClymont>As a business owner, I know firsthand that every dollar counts.

1292
02:20:47.759 --> 02:20:56.710
<v Keelan McClymont>With rising costs from various angles— rent, utilities, wages— this new fee feels like a heavy weight added to an already overflowing plate.

1293
02:20:57.305 --> 02:21:02.694
<v Keelan McClymont>The prospect of additional taxes and fees is detrimental to our ability to maintain operations and retain employees.

1294
02:21:02.791 --> 02:21:03.385
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilmember Smith, you have 2 minutes.

1295
02:21:04.363 --> 02:21:09.146
<v Keelan McClymont>I have heard repeated claims about lost federal funding, yet we must ask, why did this happen?

1296
02:21:09.724 --> 02:21:15.275
<v Keelan McClymont>Why is— is it possible that misalignment with federal priorities led to funding being pulled?

1297
02:21:15.676 --> 02:21:23.653
<v Keelan McClymont>The federal government has significant resources available, and it raises serious questions about our local leadership's ability to secure necessary support.

1298
02:21:24.182 --> 02:21:30.568
<v Keelan McClymont>If we can't align with federal initiatives, how can we expect to effectively manage local funding and infrastructure projects?

1299
02:21:30.649 --> 02:21:31.002
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilmember Smith.

1300
02:21:31.563 --> 02:21:48.202
<v Keelan McClymont>I testified twice to the state transportation House Bill 3991 that wanted to raise gas taxes, fees on hybrid and electric vehicles, and other fees, which is just more of our money going to pay for fiscal mistakes made by state government and federal funds being pulled.

1301
02:21:48.572 --> 02:21:53.941
<v Keelan McClymont>Top-to-bottom government audits should be conducted prior to asking residents and businesses to pay more.

1302
02:21:54.406 --> 02:21:56.459
<v Keelan McClymont>Oregon has one of the highest taxes already.

1303
02:21:56.540 --> 02:21:56.731
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1304
02:21:57.213 --> 02:22:02.959
<v Keelan McClymont>As a lifelong Oregonian, I have witnessed how funds collected in the past have not yielded visible results.

1305
02:22:03.391 --> 02:22:07.404
<v Keelan McClymont>We have invested in our community through taxes and fees, yet we often see little in return.

1306
02:22:07.709 --> 02:22:15.316
<v Keelan McClymont>How can we ensure that the revenue generated from the transportation utility fee will be used effectively and transparently?

1307
02:22:15.588 --> 02:22:20.259
<v Keelan McClymont>Well, in your presentation you outlined how the money would be spent, but nothing is guaranteed.

1308
02:22:20.564 --> 02:22:43.067
<v Keelan McClymont>We need solid assurances that our contributions In closing, while I support— while I understand the need for funding to maintain our transportation systems, the introduction of the transportation utility fee without clear accountability and commitment to responsible governance will only serve to drive businesses away and further burden residents.

1309
02:22:43.325 --> 02:22:43.711
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1310
02:22:47.248 --> 02:22:48.054
<v Keelan McClymont>Jordan Lewis.

1311
02:22:48.808 --> 02:22:49.597
<v Keelan McClymont>Jordan Lewis here.

1312
02:22:49.936 --> 02:23:01.170
<v Keelan McClymont>Uh, next up we have John Gibbon, Terry Parker, Carl Rhode, Brett Hofstetter, Kyle Johnson.

1313
02:23:04.558 --> 02:23:05.738
<v Mitch Green>My name is John Gibbon.

1314
02:23:06.094 --> 02:23:08.391
<v Mitch Green>I live in Southwest Portland, District 4.

1315
02:23:09.152 --> 02:23:36.920
<v Mitch Green>Uh, the Quail Park Association, an Oregon nonprofit corporation, uh, aka the Quail Park Homeowners Association, of the City of Portland, Multnomah County, State of Oregon, and most crucially for this discussion, the situs of the City of Portland Southwest Quail Post Road Water Local Improvement District, which I see Commissioner Ryan remembers.

1316
02:23:37.914 --> 02:23:48.543
<v Mitch Green>We have 3/10 of a mile of mainline road that connects Next, Lancaster Boulevard to Lancaster Road.

1317
02:23:48.608 --> 02:23:51.804
<v Mitch Green>Excuse me, Lancaster's other boulevard in Salem.

1318
02:23:52.481 --> 02:23:55.046
<v Mitch Green>Lancaster Road to Huber Street.

1319
02:23:55.549 --> 02:24:09.302
<v Mitch Green>And we have 7/10 of a mile of individual privately owned streets that reach the 93 houses in our subdivision.

1320
02:24:09.828 --> 02:24:53.509
<v Mitch Green>And on top of that, and I'm gonna paraphrase, I think it was Abraham Lincoln, to tell Commissioner Ryan that I can report that we have now successfully interconnected the water line that we're building on an LID from Lancaster Road to— I guess the paraphrase would be now Bull Run water flows unvexed from Lancaster Road to Huber Street, which was an accomplishment we had to do because 50 years ago the city forgot to build the water line that the Planning Commission requested between Lancaster and Huber.

1321
02:24:54.165 --> 02:25:03.512
<v Mitch Green>And we lived for 50 years on a single pipeline, common metered single pipeline.

1322
02:25:04.184 --> 02:25:06.947
<v Mitch Green>So So we're in the middle of an LID.

1323
02:25:07.638 --> 02:25:14.593
<v Mitch Green>We greatly appreciate the work the city has done to facilitate that LID to get that water line in.

1324
02:25:15.202 --> 02:25:21.917
<v Mitch Green>We couldn't meet qualifications for state licensing with just a single connection like we'd had for 50 years.

1325
02:25:22.030 --> 02:25:24.406
<v Mitch Green>So the city had to step in and help us.

1326
02:25:25.243 --> 02:25:30.960
<v Mitch Green>But we, when it's all said and done, we still will own the road, not the city.

1327
02:25:31.024 --> 02:25:32.534
<v Sameer Kanal>Being here, we're actually out of time.

1328
02:25:36.880 --> 02:25:40.556
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1329
02:25:41.010 --> 02:25:49.004
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm not sure who's next, but please feel free to get started.

1330
02:25:50.280 --> 02:25:51.246
<v Sameer Kanal>Hi, uh, councilors.

1331
02:25:51.746 --> 02:25:53.052
<v Mitch Green>My name is Brett Hofstetter.

1332
02:25:53.279 --> 02:25:59.165
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm recently retired and have worked and lived in the Portland area for the last thank you.

1333
02:26:00.323 --> 02:26:04.138
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm here today to ask you to please stop making this town so unaffordable.

1334
02:26:06.389 --> 02:26:09.569
<v Mitch Green>We already have some of the highest combined water sewer rates in the country.

1335
02:26:09.650 --> 02:26:17.130
<v Sameer Kanal>The most recent increase of July of 2025 was 6%, which is the largest increase in the—.

1336
02:26:17.244 --> 02:26:18.497
<v Mitch Green>In more than 10 years.

1337
02:26:19.479 --> 02:26:24.129
<v Mitch Green>I've watched as many of the local professional businesses have left our beloved city over the last 10 years.

1338
02:26:25.174 --> 02:26:34.898
<v Sameer Kanal>I've worked in many of the buildings in downtown Portland when they were full of taxpaying businesses and spent time in many of the same buildings that are now empty.

1339
02:26:36.156 --> 02:26:39.734
<v Mitch Green>I am concerned that with this unaffordability, our neighborhoods will be next.

1340
02:26:40.709 --> 02:26:42.772
<v Mitch Green>The, the emigration has already started.

1341
02:26:42.836 --> 02:26:47.254
<v Sameer Kanal>We all have friends and neighbors that have moved away from Portland.

1342
02:26:47.481 --> 02:26:51.825
<v Sameer Kanal>We've experienced a net loss over 18,200 residents between 2010 and 2020.

1343
02:26:51.938 --> 02:26:52.115
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1344
02:26:56.799 --> 02:26:59.356
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1345
02:27:06.576 --> 02:27:11.753
<v Mark Lear>Please go ahead.

1346
02:27:12.829 --> 02:27:13.728
<v Sameer Kanal>Good morning, councilors.

1347
02:27:13.990 --> 02:27:14.890
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm Carl Rohde.

1348
02:27:15.381 --> 02:27:22.359
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, thank you all for your long, uh, holding keeping up the tradition of making Portland the best European city in America.

1349
02:27:24.840 --> 02:27:26.129
<v Sameer Kanal>I am a native Oregonian.

1350
02:27:26.227 --> 02:27:30.164
<v Sameer Kanal>As of yesterday, I'm a homeowner in Portland for 21 years.

1351
02:27:32.459 --> 02:27:36.909
<v Sameer Kanal>In 1919, Oregon became the first state in the nation to pass a gas tax.

1352
02:27:37.150 --> 02:27:42.759
<v Sameer Kanal>And that worked really well right up until about the '70s when gasoline was no longer essentially free.

1353
02:27:43.865 --> 02:27:51.328
<v Sameer Kanal>Automobile manufacturers had to start making efficiency improvements to them, and the erosion began in the effectiveness of the gas tax.

1354
02:27:52.130 --> 02:27:54.459
<v Sameer Kanal>We've been dealing with this for a long time.

1355
02:27:54.780 --> 02:28:01.343
<v Sameer Kanal>I can think of discussions about the dwindling revenue that comes in from a gas tax going back over 3 decades.

1356
02:28:02.755 --> 02:28:14.040
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's why in 2003, when I was on the Lake Oswego City Council, we had adopted a street maintenance fee, which you're calling a transportation utility fee.

1357
02:28:15.084 --> 02:28:16.353
<v Sameer Kanal>We did a lot of public outreach.

1358
02:28:17.269 --> 02:28:26.501
<v Sameer Kanal>We explained that we had a different system than what's in place in Lake Oswego now, but it really stabilized our funding to be able to maintain the streets.

1359
02:28:27.144 --> 02:28:38.065
<v Sameer Kanal>And we rated— we put a rating on the streets from A to F that allowed us to determine as a council what do we want the overall transportation system in the city of Lake Oswego to look like.

1360
02:28:38.113 --> 02:28:42.573
<v Sameer Kanal>And I think at the time we decided we wanted to at least raise it from C- to B+.

1361
02:28:43.865 --> 02:28:49.165
<v Sameer Kanal>And that gave us a target amount of funding that we needed to raise from the transportation utility fee.

1362
02:28:51.736 --> 02:28:58.204
<v Sameer Kanal>One of the things that we explained to a lot of people was that the cost of transportation infrastructure has increased faster than the rate of inflation.

1363
02:28:59.639 --> 02:29:03.547
<v Sameer Kanal>And unless you've recently unless you've paved your driveway, you have no idea what the cost of asphalt is.

1364
02:29:04.368 --> 02:29:05.189
<v Sameer Kanal>And most people don't.

1365
02:29:05.672 --> 02:29:08.665
<v Sameer Kanal>And they also don't realize that asphalt is merely a cover on the road.

1366
02:29:09.750 --> 02:29:15.163
<v Sameer Kanal>So I would encourage you, in the name of the great corporation Nike, to just do it.

1367
02:29:16.925 --> 02:29:22.397
<v Sameer Kanal>And in paraphrasing Gretchen Whitmer from the state of Michigan, fix the damn roads.

1368
02:29:24.418 --> 02:29:24.868
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1369
02:29:26.435 --> 02:29:27.030
<v Sameer Kanal>Please go ahead, sir.

1370
02:29:28.297 --> 02:29:31.200
<v Mitch Green>Terry Parker, District 3.

1371
02:29:31.489 --> 02:29:32.516
<v Mitch Green>Equity is absent.

1372
02:29:32.950 --> 02:29:36.478
<v Mitch Green>As an example, take 2 individuals who travel the same distance to work every day.

1373
02:29:36.719 --> 02:29:38.468
<v Mitch Green>One drives a car, the other rides a bus.

1374
02:29:39.030 --> 02:29:44.003
<v Mitch Green>The person riding the bus has a far greater impact on the roadway than the person who drives the car.

1375
02:29:44.084 --> 02:29:49.522
<v Mitch Green>That's because one standard bus does as much wear and tear to the pavement as 1,200 cars.

1376
02:29:49.939 --> 02:29:59.384
<v Mitch Green>That calculates out to about 30 cars per bus Due to the weight of batteries, the amount of wear doubled— is doubled to about 60 cars per bus seat for an electric bus.

1377
02:30:00.629 --> 02:30:07.913
<v Mitch Green>Bicycle advocates, askabists, provide a lot of lip service for what they want, but they pay nothing for the bike lanes they ride in.

1378
02:30:10.046 --> 02:30:10.627
<v Mitch Green>Expect it.

1379
02:30:11.352 --> 02:30:18.908
<v Mitch Green>It's the number of people within a household that make a difference on how much transportation infrastructure is utilized.

1380
02:30:19.778 --> 02:30:21.254
<v Mitch Green>Not the amount of water used.

1381
02:30:21.559 --> 02:30:29.379
<v Mitch Green>Expecting single-family households to pay more than apartment renters or condo households is a form of discrimination.

1382
02:30:30.069 --> 02:30:35.995
<v Mitch Green>It is this: you want to be little dictators as to what type of housing people live in, coupled with how people travel.

1383
02:30:36.236 --> 02:30:44.488
<v Mitch Green>It's especially discriminating to senior citizens living on fixed incomes who simply want to age in place in the home they worked for a lifetime to pay for and now own.

1384
02:30:44.569 --> 02:30:53.610
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1385
02:30:53.610 --> 02:31:14.430
<v Mitch Green>Second.

1386
02:31:14.430 --> 02:31:14.569
<v Mark Lear>Motion carries.

1387
02:31:14.569 --> 02:31:14.610
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1388
02:31:14.610 --> 02:31:14.770
<v Dan Ryan>Next item on the agenda is Public Communications.

1389
02:31:16.209 --> 02:31:29.469
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1390
02:31:29.469 --> 02:31:31.170
<v Sameer Kanal>Mr. Chair—.

1391
02:31:31.170 --> 02:31:33.209
<v Keelan McClymont>Go ahead, Kyle.

1392
02:31:33.209 --> 02:31:33.950
<v Sameer Kanal>Hello.

1393
02:31:33.950 --> 02:31:35.430
<v Sameer Kanal>Hello, City Council.

1394
02:31:35.430 --> 02:31:36.770
<v Sameer Kanal>I will keep this brief.

1395
02:31:36.770 --> 02:31:40.290
<v Sameer Kanal>My name is Kyle Johnson, and I'm the vice chair of BikeLoud PDX.

1396
02:31:40.290 --> 02:31:43.549
<v Sameer Kanal>BikeLoud urges you to do what our previous form of government, the city council, did not do.

1397
02:31:46.630 --> 02:32:06.489
<v Keelan McClymont>Okay, next up we have John Serra, John Giacoppi, Santiago Nolasco Galicia.

1398
02:32:06.993 --> 02:32:07.171
<v Sameer Kanal>Are you—.

1399
02:32:07.609 --> 02:32:10.917
<v Mitch Green>Uh, one question, uh, will you accept written testimony after the public testimony?

1400
02:32:12.349 --> 02:32:12.739
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1401
02:32:12.935 --> 02:32:15.967
<v Mitch Green>We had a power outage of 8 hours last night.

1402
02:32:16.358 --> 02:32:23.521
<v Dan Ryan>Good afternoon, Chair Kanal and members of the Portland City Council.

1403
02:32:23.634 --> 02:32:28.608
<v Dan Ryan>For the record, my name is John Serra, and I am speaking to you today as a registered lobbyist on behalf of TriMet.

1404
02:32:29.270 --> 02:32:36.451
<v Dan Ryan>I would like to extend our support for PBOT's efforts to find a funding solution that secures the agency's future for the vital infrastructure that it is responsible for.

1405
02:32:36.909 --> 02:32:43.379
<v Dan Ryan>To state the obvious, TriMet buses drive on Portland roads.

1406
02:32:43.379 --> 02:32:52.059
<v Dan Ryan>The City of Portland's ability to adequately maintain those streets impacts not only the quality of the ride for TriMet riders, but also has a significant impact on our bottom line.

1407
02:32:53.139 --> 02:32:57.319
<v Dan Ryan>Poorly maintained roads slow down our buses and increase our maintenance costs.

1408
02:32:57.319 --> 02:33:02.200
<v Dan Ryan>As TriMet continues to address our budget constraints, adequate PBOT funding will have a significant impact on the agency's the ability to meet its experience mission.

1409
02:33:02.200 --> 02:33:02.239
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1410
02:33:02.602 --> 02:33:12.200
<v Dan Ryan>Of our riders, our attractiveness to new riders, and our ability to direct every available dollar to those who need it most, not just the upkeep of our buses.

1411
02:33:12.859 --> 02:33:21.702
<v Dan Ryan>I want to thank PBOT Director Millicent Williams, the DCA, and her many staff that have all dedicated countless hours to the planning and public outreach necessary for this effort.

1412
02:33:22.103 --> 02:33:37.475
<v Dan Ryan>And I want to thank you all, especially Councilor Clark and the members of the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee PBOT's work is an essential function of government, and we rely on its success to deliver our own essential services to this community.

1413
02:33:37.846 --> 02:33:38.655
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you all for your leadership.

1414
02:33:42.030 --> 02:33:42.220
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1415
02:33:42.308 --> 02:33:42.832
<v Sameer Kanal>Please go ahead.

1416
02:33:49.009 --> 02:33:49.185
<v Keelan McClymont>Yeah.

1417
02:33:49.570 --> 02:33:50.550
<v Mitch Green>Oh, sorry.

1418
02:33:52.559 --> 02:33:53.572
<v Mitch Green>Good morning, councilors.

1419
02:33:53.717 --> 02:33:55.837
<v Mitch Green>My name is Santiago Nolasco Galicia.

1420
02:33:55.933 --> 02:33:57.668
<v Mitch Green>I'm a climate policy assistant at 350 PDX.

1421
02:33:59.353 --> 02:34:07.073
<v Mitch Green>We support finding new sources of revenue to fund transportation, but we implore detailed scrutiny before adopting the transportation utility fee.

1422
02:34:07.477 --> 02:34:11.184
<v Mitch Green>I'll mention very briefly that we do support the street damage restoration fee.

1423
02:34:11.490 --> 02:34:19.877
<v Mitch Green>It makes sense that entities tearing into the road should pay part of the cost of that and to reduce the times that we disrupt the streets.

1424
02:34:20.753 --> 02:34:25.358
<v Mitch Green>The transportation utility fee, on the other hand, would inequitably affect everyone's bills.

1425
02:34:25.797 --> 02:34:26.711
<v Mitch Green>Basically immediately.

1426
02:34:27.820 --> 02:34:35.577
<v Mitch Green>Before passing the fee, you should really modify it to ensure it is more equitable and helps meet our goals of transportation decarbonization.

1427
02:34:36.510 --> 02:34:39.786
<v Mitch Green>Our biggest issue with the TUF is that it is a regressive fee.

1428
02:34:40.268 --> 02:34:48.636
<v Mitch Green>This flat fee would apply to multifamily and single-family households regardless of whether they own a car, primarily use public transit, walk, or bike.

1429
02:34:49.326 --> 02:34:56.769
<v Mitch Green>As someone who regularly walks and uses transit, Should I really be required to pay the same fee as other Portlanders who are actively driving?

1430
02:34:57.683 --> 02:35:04.462
<v Mitch Green>Existing low-income discounts also will not capture every household that relies on alternative methods of transportation.

1431
02:35:04.976 --> 02:35:13.439
<v Mitch Green>We would ask you to please include a waiver system for households without a vehicle who primarily use transit as their means of transportation.

1432
02:35:14.753 --> 02:35:26.459
<v Mitch Green>Ideally, we would like the council to explore a more progressive system based on income level, Or maybe vehicle miles traveled, just something that can better reflect the reality of how we actually each use the roads.

1433
02:35:26.950 --> 02:35:32.329
<v Mitch Green>Our next concern is that it needs to clearly— it needs to more clearly aid in transportation decarbonization.

1434
02:35:33.530 --> 02:35:42.959
<v Mitch Green>Finally, if a TUF passes, there needs to be clear guardrails in the ordinance to ensure that this funding goes into its intended purposes rather than disappearing into the general fund.

1435
02:35:43.010 --> 02:35:46.469
<v Mitch Green>As we move forward into a more equitable future, we encourage the council to be good stewards of the public funds of the city.

1436
02:35:46.469 --> 02:35:46.510
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1437
02:35:48.247 --> 02:35:59.700
<v Mitch Green>We support the street damage restoration fee and the TUF, uh, and if the TUF is destined to move forward, ensure that the ordinance captures the reality of how we actually use our infrastructure, include that waiver system.

1438
02:36:00.282 --> 02:36:01.640
<v Mitch Green>Uh, thank you very much for your time.

1439
02:36:02.886 --> 02:36:03.209
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1440
02:36:04.001 --> 02:36:05.213
<v Keelan McClymont>John is joining us online.

1441
02:36:09.290 --> 02:36:11.329
<v Dan Ryan>Good morning, or afternoon now, councilors.

1442
02:36:11.673 --> 02:36:13.530
<v Dan Ryan>Um, thank you for your detailed thank you.

1443
02:36:13.530 --> 02:36:13.530
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

1444
02:36:13.530 --> 02:36:14.129
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Councilor Dan Ryan, for calling attention to this matter.

1445
02:36:14.569 --> 02:36:17.870
<v Dan Ryan>I did not have time to change my Zoom background, so don't get too distracted by it.

1446
02:36:18.389 --> 02:36:20.670
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to give 2 brief points here.

1447
02:36:20.670 --> 02:36:22.250
<v Dan Ryan>I'm not like a policy expert.

1448
02:36:22.250 --> 02:36:28.870
<v Dan Ryan>I'm a secretary of the Eco-Socialist Working Group of the Portland DSA, but I'm speaking strictly on my own behalf here.

1449
02:36:29.329 --> 02:36:33.569
<v Dan Ryan>There's a lot of discussion about how this fee is regressive, and I believe that's true.

1450
02:36:33.569 --> 02:36:39.690
<v Dan Ryan>And I do believe that there needs to be some policy analysis as to how we can make it less regressive with a waiver system.

1451
02:36:39.709 --> 02:36:39.870
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

1452
02:36:39.917 --> 02:36:46.549
<v Dan Ryan>I think that this is a very important item for households that do not own a car or that primarily use public transit being a very appealing option.

1453
02:36:47.208 --> 02:36:49.391
<v Dan Ryan>However, urgency is critical here.

1454
02:36:49.615 --> 02:36:55.879
<v Dan Ryan>I do not want us to begin significantly tampering with the fee and not get it across the deadline in the time we need it.

1455
02:36:56.102 --> 02:36:58.238
<v Dan Ryan>We clearly need more effective road maintenance now.

1456
02:36:58.769 --> 02:36:59.893
<v Dan Ryan>And this brings me to point 2.

1457
02:37:00.855 --> 02:37:08.558
<v Dan Ryan>We've got 75% of the transportation utility fee going explicitly to maintenance and then 25% going to Vision Zero.

1458
02:37:09.183 --> 02:37:21.430
<v Dan Ryan>I am comfortable with the split if PBOT is doing effective work at doing some of the work that I know Mitch Green and others have been talking about in previous council sessions, and that is looking at what roads we can afford to maintain.

1459
02:37:22.263 --> 02:37:28.210
<v Dan Ryan>We cannot simply be seeking to maintain our entire existing road infrastructure system based on our current revenue.

1460
02:37:28.675 --> 02:37:29.413
<v Dan Ryan>We know we can't.

1461
02:37:29.861 --> 02:37:31.770
<v Dan Ryan>We need to begin effectively triaging thank you.

1462
02:37:32.042 --> 02:37:37.438
<v Dan Ryan>And seeing what is critical maintenance and what these funds could be most practically applied for.

1463
02:37:37.502 --> 02:37:45.322
<v Dan Ryan>We don't want to be spending money maintaining parts of our road system that in the long run we know we're not going to be able to keep in their current use state.

1464
02:37:45.915 --> 02:37:48.516
<v Dan Ryan>So I'd like you to encourage— I'd like to encourage you to do that.

1465
02:37:48.967 --> 02:37:57.465
<v Dan Ryan>And then lastly, I just said that we shouldn't be tampering with this too much, but I can guarantee you that if we do not have protection, Thank you.

1466
02:37:57.561 --> 02:38:00.602
<v Dan Ryan>My concern is, by applying this to a water bill, that people will be evicted.

1467
02:38:02.495 --> 02:38:04.126
<v Dan Ryan>I personally, I live in an apartment.

1468
02:38:04.513 --> 02:38:07.191
<v Dan Ryan>I pay my water utility bill through my landlord.

1469
02:38:07.998 --> 02:38:10.436
<v Dan Ryan>I have known people in this apartment complex who have been evicted.

1470
02:38:11.840 --> 02:38:13.698
<v Dan Ryan>Part of it is because of unpaid utility bills.

1471
02:38:14.119 --> 02:38:16.478
<v Dan Ryan>You will see evictions if you do not include this waiver.

1472
02:38:17.530 --> 02:38:19.614
<v Dan Ryan>And you will see, candidly, I think more of them than you expect.

1473
02:38:20.219 --> 02:38:22.114
<v Dan Ryan>Please make that an urgent priority and fix that.

1474
02:38:22.165 --> 02:38:22.729
<v Dan Ryan>I think it's a serious issue.

1475
02:38:24.182 --> 02:38:29.737
<v Keelan McClymont>That completes testimony.

1476
02:38:31.547 --> 02:38:32.079
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, everyone.

1477
02:38:33.208 --> 02:38:34.606
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, thank you all of our testifiers.

1478
02:38:34.863 --> 02:38:38.978
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, we do have, uh, several people in the queue, so we'll just get started with that.

1479
02:38:39.123 --> 02:38:41.198
<v Sameer Kanal>Uh, it'll be Councilor Green followed by Councilor Smith.

1480
02:38:42.790 --> 02:38:45.534
<v Mitch Green>Thank you, Chair Kanal, and thank you to everyone who provided testimony today.

1481
02:38:45.729 --> 02:39:02.342
<v Mitch Green>Colleagues, um, I'll try to be efficient with my time because Last night I emailed you all and I emailed the clerk a document that I wanted attached to this item, not because I want that document to be an amendment.

1482
02:39:02.390 --> 02:39:22.190
<v Mitch Green>I want to be very clear, what I'm about to talk to you is not an amendment to the currently proposed thing, because as, as someone who has worked in a rate-making institution for my career prior to being elected, if you try to change rates and that's just a fact.

1483
02:39:22.190 --> 02:39:36.809
<v Mitch Green>And so the reason I have done this method of sort of introducing a concept informally and filing it, so it can stay with the item as the item moves through the different parts of our legislative concept, so we can talk to the community in response to the community.

1484
02:39:36.809 --> 02:39:39.159
<v Mitch Green>And so I'll describe what it is and I'll say where it came from.

1485
02:39:40.069 --> 02:39:42.409
<v Mitch Green>Basically, you guys all may have seen in your inboxes that there was a survey that was sent out.

1486
02:39:42.409 --> 02:39:42.430
<v Mitch Green>Yes.

1487
02:39:42.590 --> 02:39:59.227
<v Mitch Green>Boxes, Zendesk, some appeals from organizations like Strong Towns PDX, but also some other kind of urban land use nerds, for lack of a better term, for an alternative proposal that I think is really smart.

1488
02:39:59.856 --> 02:40:00.923
<v Mitch Green>And it's also quite elegant.

1489
02:40:01.470 --> 02:40:08.235
<v Mitch Green>And it also gets us away from some of the issues that we heard from, in particular, Eric Fruits, who made the— who critiqued the commercial thank you.

1490
02:40:08.283 --> 02:40:14.746
<v Mitch Green>So I think we're going to move on to the next piece that would be assessing a fee as a function of your water consumption, which I personally don't like.

1491
02:40:14.860 --> 02:40:19.852
<v Mitch Green>And I think that's outside of the— it crosses principles in rate design in this.

1492
02:40:19.916 --> 02:40:21.748
<v Mitch Green>So I'll briefly describe it.

1493
02:40:21.844 --> 02:40:36.007
<v Mitch Green>The basic idea, and I hope this conversation will provide inspiration to PBOT and allow us to update this proposal over the course of the weeks and months to consider it by council, is to construct a fee based upon a 2-part system.

1494
02:40:36.608 --> 02:40:40.382
<v Mitch Green>You have a flat rate component and you have a variable rate component.

1495
02:40:41.025 --> 02:40:46.092
<v Mitch Green>So every single billable unit, every sort of door in the City of Portland pays $3.

1496
02:40:46.905 --> 02:40:51.213
<v Mitch Green>That's it, irrespective of your use of the system or whatever other consideration.

1497
02:40:51.902 --> 02:41:01.061
<v Mitch Green>And then the variable component is a function of how much of the zone— of the buildable zoned land you use per parcel.

1498
02:41:01.335 --> 02:41:05.549
<v Mitch Green>So for example, I have a 10,000-square-foot lot in Southwest Portland.

1499
02:41:06.100 --> 02:41:07.520
<v Mitch Green>There's one house on that lot.

1500
02:41:08.319 --> 02:41:13.940
<v Mitch Green>I'm responsible for paying for the entire 10,000 square feet of that land.

1501
02:41:13.940 --> 02:41:18.190
<v Mitch Green>But let's suppose there's another 10,000-square-foot lot and you've got 10 units on it.

1502
02:41:18.500 --> 02:41:22.200
<v Mitch Green>It's reasonable to say that each tenant should pay for a tenth of that.

1503
02:41:22.299 --> 02:41:27.649
<v Mitch Green>And so the idea is it scales a variable proportion as a function of your square footage occupation.

1504
02:41:27.649 --> 02:41:27.770
<v Mitch Green>I think that's a reasonable idea.

1505
02:41:28.622 --> 02:41:41.489
<v Mitch Green>And if you, if you design it like this, uh, it does align better with cost causation principles, and it sends a price signal to use our land more efficiently, and it doesn't subsidize sprawl.

1506
02:41:41.698 --> 02:41:54.421
<v Mitch Green>The current proposal as it stands, which I'm going to support because we need to pass it so we can get something to build off of, uh, subsidizes and incentivizes sprawl, which then increases the ongoing cost of our transportation system.

1507
02:41:54.485 --> 02:41:54.645
<v Mitch Green>Thank you.

1508
02:41:54.909 --> 02:41:56.199
<v Mitch Green>So let me say that again.

1509
02:41:57.215 --> 02:42:16.506
<v Mitch Green>If we validate a transportation network that does not try to intentionally create more densification and move away from car use, then the ongoing liability of our operations and maintenance of our transportation network will continue to grow per person per year over the decades.

1510
02:42:17.022 --> 02:42:28.345
<v Mitch Green>But if you do this other proposal, proposal that incentivizes and apportions your your burden based upon how much square footage of zoned land you occupy, then that shares that burden more equitably.

1511
02:42:28.395 --> 02:42:31.028
<v Mitch Green>So that's in the attachment.

1512
02:42:31.670 --> 02:42:37.932
<v Mitch Green>I'm happy to answer any questions, but based upon the math that I've done, this generates roughly the same amount of money.

1513
02:42:38.879 --> 02:42:43.921
<v Mitch Green>And a person who lives in a 1,200-square-foot apartment pays about $4 a month.

1514
02:42:45.141 --> 02:42:46.088
<v Mitch Green>I would pay $13 a month.

1515
02:42:47.484 --> 02:42:54.617
<v Mitch Green>The commercial operator, the gentleman, I think his name was Kurt, will no longer pay a fee based upon water consumption.

1516
02:42:55.353 --> 02:43:00.498
<v Mitch Green>If they're a 1,200-square-foot storefront, Councilor Ryan, they'll pay $4 a month under my proposal.

1517
02:43:00.547 --> 02:43:01.750
<v Mitch Green>So I got you.

1518
02:43:02.134 --> 02:43:03.095
<v Mitch Green>You're saving storefronts over here.

1519
02:43:03.144 --> 02:43:07.135
<v Mitch Green>So anyway, that's the proposal that I'm not moving today formally.

1520
02:43:07.183 --> 02:43:08.001
<v Mitch Green>I want to be very clear.

1521
02:43:08.657 --> 02:43:10.485
<v Mitch Green>I'm just bringing it into the public.

1522
02:43:10.662 --> 02:43:18.840
<v Mitch Green>I'm responding to communities to say I'm taking this very seriously and I'm uplifting what I am moving is an amendment to— let me pull that up here.

1523
02:43:19.001 --> 02:43:19.995
<v Mitch Green>It's called Green 1.

1524
02:43:21.149 --> 02:43:25.577
<v Mitch Green>That creates the permission structure to change our rate design year by year by year.

1525
02:43:26.347 --> 02:43:36.518
<v Mitch Green>As it's currently written, it suggests that we're only adjusting our rates, which would imply once we've adopted a rate design, then we're really just tweaking the levers inside of that design.

1526
02:43:37.014 --> 02:43:40.816
<v Mitch Green>I would like us to consider on an annual basis changing our rate designs as appropriate.

1527
02:43:40.864 --> 02:43:43.674
<v Mitch Green>And so Green 1 reads PBOT.

1528
02:43:43.771 --> 02:43:56.487
<v Mitch Green>It's item K under the directive part of the ordinance that PBOT will propose rate adjustments, including inflationary increases, and then adds or new rate design proposals to the city council through the city's annual budget process.

1529
02:43:56.792 --> 02:44:02.397
<v Mitch Green>I want to be clear: if we're going to engage in rate design studies and engagement, you can't wait until the budget to do that.

1530
02:44:02.477 --> 02:44:06.555
<v Mitch Green>And so, if we adopt this amendment, even if we don't adopt this amendment.

1531
02:44:07.148 --> 02:44:21.969
<v Mitch Green>I'm going to try to work through the Public Works Committee to have that type of process really intentionally developed so we can consider the trade-offs and the equity considerations of different ways of designing a fee, not just whether or not we should adopt a fee.

1532
02:44:22.628 --> 02:44:25.117
<v Mitch Green>So with that, colleagues, I hope I can get your support on that amendment.

1533
02:44:25.838 --> 02:44:31.265
<v Sameer Kanal>So there's been a motion to add or new rate design proposals to Section K. Is there a second?

1534
02:44:34.729 --> 02:44:35.030
<v Sameer Kanal>Second.

1535
02:44:35.113 --> 02:44:36.665
<v Sameer Kanal>I think that'll give that to Avalos.

1536
02:44:38.069 --> 02:44:44.217
<v Sameer Kanal>Colleagues who are still in the queue, we'll keep track of that separately, so feel free to drop out of the queue if you're not discussing the amendment.

1537
02:44:44.700 --> 02:44:47.783
<v Sameer Kanal>And if you are looking to discuss the amendment, please feel free to get into the queue.

1538
02:44:47.865 --> 02:44:49.162
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll just kind of ask as we go.

1539
02:44:51.149 --> 02:44:52.434
<v Sameer Kanal>So this is a debatable motion.

1540
02:44:52.549 --> 02:44:54.647
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Zimmerman, are you here to speak to the amendment?

1541
02:44:57.860 --> 02:44:57.907
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1542
02:44:58.152 --> 02:44:59.566
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll go to Councilor Koyama Lane.

1543
02:44:59.615 --> 02:45:00.639
<v Sameer Kanal>Are you speaking to the amendment?

1544
02:45:00.966 --> 02:45:01.600
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Avalos?

1545
02:45:02.835 --> 02:45:03.877
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick online?

1546
02:45:09.266 --> 02:45:09.889
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan?

1547
02:45:10.823 --> 02:45:11.888
<v Dan Ryan>No, but point of order.

1548
02:45:13.377 --> 02:45:15.878
<v Dan Ryan>I'm worried that— well, I'll just speak for myself.

1549
02:45:16.055 --> 02:45:19.814
<v Dan Ryan>People that aren't in the committee, this is our first time, just ask some bigger picture questions.

1550
02:45:20.329 --> 02:45:23.538
<v Dan Ryan>And I chose not to do it during the technical because I wanted to make space for the testimony.

1551
02:45:24.474 --> 02:45:25.757
<v Dan Ryan>We're not going to finish this today.

1552
02:45:26.078 --> 02:45:27.797
<v Dan Ryan>It looks like we're having that meeting next week, Chair.

1553
02:45:28.325 --> 02:45:32.403
<v Dan Ryan>And so I hope that I could have a chance to just ask some bigger picture questions right now.

1554
02:45:33.606 --> 02:45:35.468
<v Sameer Kanal>So we— the rules have it—.

1555
02:45:35.613 --> 02:45:40.846
<v Dan Ryan>So I'm fine with the second, but I don't think it's time to do discussion and then vote on amendments today.

1556
02:45:41.391 --> 02:45:47.075
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm fairly certain we're required to do so while we're in the motion by our rules.

1557
02:45:47.572 --> 02:45:48.968
<v Dan Ryan>Look at your book, it's over here.

1558
02:45:49.337 --> 02:45:49.948
<v Dan Ryan>It is over there.

1559
02:45:50.059 --> 02:45:51.472
<v Sameer Kanal>So if you can grab it for me.

1560
02:45:51.682 --> 02:45:54.814
<v Sameer Kanal>This is Sameer's book.

1561
02:45:55.022 --> 02:45:56.742
<v Sameer Kanal>Yeah, thanks.

1562
02:45:57.047 --> 02:46:06.637
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but I, I, I will say that I, I do want to make sure that there's time for, for the general conversation because 7 of us are not on that, right, the old transportation infrastructure.

1563
02:46:06.700 --> 02:46:07.906
<v Sameer Kanal>I agree with the broader point.

1564
02:46:08.611 --> 02:46:20.359
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, if you'll bear with me just a moment, I am not seeing anybody else in the queue right now for the amendment, so it is possible that we could vote on the amendment and then get back into that general discussion in the span of a about 30 seconds.

1565
02:46:20.987 --> 02:46:26.555
<v Sameer Kanal>So if, uh, if that's all right with you, um, I will continue with that while we verify it.

1566
02:46:27.217 --> 02:46:29.478
<v Sameer Kanal>Is there anyone else looking to add to the queue for this?

1567
02:46:30.061 --> 02:46:33.144
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, on the amendment, Keelan, would you please call the roll?

1568
02:46:33.273 --> 02:46:33.906
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Pirtle-Guiney?

1569
02:46:34.036 --> 02:46:34.441
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absent.

1570
02:46:34.505 --> 02:46:34.668
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1571
02:46:47.090 --> 02:46:49.536
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Green, I might be able to get to a yes on this, but not today.

1572
02:46:49.715 --> 02:46:49.796
<v Dan Ryan>No.

1573
02:46:50.314 --> 02:46:51.708
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Koyama Lane?

1574
02:46:52.290 --> 02:46:52.340
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1575
02:46:52.695 --> 02:46:55.548
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Morillo?

1576
02:46:55.629 --> 02:46:55.709
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

1577
02:46:55.840 --> 02:46:57.494
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Novick?

1578
02:47:03.780 --> 02:47:06.801
<v Keelan McClymont>Councilor Novick?

1579
02:47:08.903 --> 02:47:09.420
<v Steve Novick>Absent.

1580
02:47:10.761 --> 02:47:11.182
<v Keelan McClymont>Clerk?

1581
02:47:11.634 --> 02:47:11.649
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1582
02:47:12.399 --> 02:47:12.415
<v Shoshana Cohen>Aye.

1583
02:47:12.480 --> 02:47:12.772
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1584
02:47:13.114 --> 02:47:13.211
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1585
02:47:14.040 --> 02:47:14.397
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1586
02:47:14.902 --> 02:47:15.065
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1587
02:47:15.796 --> 02:47:16.104
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1588
02:47:16.527 --> 02:47:16.575
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1589
02:47:17.518 --> 02:47:17.891
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1590
02:47:18.152 --> 02:47:18.315
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1591
02:47:19.030 --> 02:47:20.060
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1592
02:47:20.945 --> 02:47:21.208
<v Loretta Smith>No.

1593
02:47:22.583 --> 02:47:23.123
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1594
02:47:24.750 --> 02:47:24.765
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

1595
02:47:25.842 --> 02:47:31.915
<v Keelan McClymont>The amendment is approved with 8 yes votes, 2 no votes, and 2 absent.

1596
02:47:32.172 --> 02:47:34.036
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, that amendment has been approved.

1597
02:47:34.084 --> 02:47:43.811
<v Sameer Kanal>We'll now go back into the main queue, which continues on with Councilor Smith, followed by Zimmer- thank you, colleagues, councilors.

1598
02:47:44.710 --> 02:47:58.912
<v Candace Avalos>I wholeheartedly support moving forward on the transportation utility fee because our transportation system here in the city of Portland, and especially in District 1, is failing, and it's falling behind the needs of our residents.

1599
02:47:59.691 --> 02:48:18.023
<v Candace Avalos>Last March, I introduced a resolution called SIP, and it's better known to some of you by the sidewalk improvement and paving project, which identified District 1 and District 4 as the 2 areas in the city that needed sidewalks the most and pothole filling and street paving.

1600
02:48:18.793 --> 02:48:35.265
<v Candace Avalos>And I want to give a special thanks to Council Vice President Clark and Mayor Wilson for their leadership with the TUF and my Public Works Committee and Transportation Committee members members for their leadership in trying to get this across the finish line.

1601
02:48:37.665 --> 02:48:57.066
<v Candace Avalos>In East Portland and throughout District 1, which is east of 82nd, too many people are still walking on the high— in the high-crash corridor network, representing only about 8% of Portland streets, but it accounts for the majority of deadly crashes.

1602
02:48:57.114 --> 02:48:57.131
<v Shoshana Cohen>Aye.

1603
02:48:57.260 --> 02:48:57.661
<v Candace Avalos>Crashes.

1604
02:48:58.656 --> 02:49:05.363
<v Candace Avalos>And many of those dangerous corridors run through East Portland communities that have been underinvested in for decades.

1605
02:49:06.215 --> 02:49:19.486
<v Candace Avalos>If we are serious about safety, access, and equity, then we have to create stable transportation funding and start addressing these gaps at the scale of the problem that it demands.

1606
02:49:20.402 --> 02:49:33.113
<v Candace Avalos>District 1 residents have already told us what they need fixing potholes was a top priority for District 1 residents, both in person and on the survey these past couple of months.

1607
02:49:33.947 --> 02:49:40.195
<v Candace Avalos>A majority of District 1 residents who attended the open house— this is also a public safety issue.

1608
02:49:40.661 --> 02:49:53.550
<v Candace Avalos>In 2025, District 1 had 11 of Portland's 39 traffic deaths, the second highest total of any district, even after East Portland saw an improvement from the prior years.

1609
02:49:54.611 --> 02:50:06.203
<v Candace Avalos>Portland's high-crash network makes up about 8% of the city streets, but it accounted for an average of 67% of traffic deaths from 2020 to 2024.

1610
02:50:07.055 --> 02:50:10.763
<v Candace Avalos>That tells us the status quo is not acceptable.

1611
02:50:11.791 --> 02:50:15.596
<v Candace Avalos>For District 1, the fee is about equity and basic infrastructure.

1612
02:50:16.460 --> 02:50:30.836
<v Candace Avalos>And safe sidewalks, smoother pavement, safer crossings, and streets that do not put residents at risk just for walking outside, rolling, or driving to school, work, or to a bus stop.

1613
02:50:36.057 --> 02:50:39.502
<v Candace Avalos>District 1 is still dealing with major sidewalk inequities.

1614
02:50:40.262 --> 02:50:56.147
<v Candace Avalos>Portland has more than 170 miles of missing sidewalk Council adopted SIP, the SIP resolution that states that most streets in District 1 and District 4 lack sidewalks entirely.

1615
02:50:57.605 --> 02:51:04.783
<v Candace Avalos>We're asking District 1 residents to live with deteriorating infrastructure every single day.

1616
02:51:05.617 --> 02:51:10.792
<v Candace Avalos>PBOT estimates nearly 2/3 of the city's local streets are in poor and very poor condition.

1617
02:51:10.841 --> 02:51:11.129
<v Millicent Williams>Councilmember Herbold.

1618
02:51:12.310 --> 02:51:12.407
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1619
02:51:12.489 --> 02:51:17.218
<v Candace Avalos>And well over half of the busy streets are in similarly bad shape.

1620
02:51:19.110 --> 02:51:25.052
<v Candace Avalos>I would like to urge my colleagues to not delay this and bog this down with a bunch of amendments.

1621
02:51:25.930 --> 02:51:41.537
<v Candace Avalos>Let's pass this so we can get this on the docket and help those underserved, underinvested neighborhoods that have not had a chance to be upgraded thank you for doing this, Councilor Clark.

1622
02:51:42.504 --> 02:51:44.103
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

1623
02:51:44.781 --> 02:51:47.753
<v Sameer Kanal>Next up is Councilor Zimmerman, followed by Councilor Koyama Lane.

1624
02:51:49.879 --> 02:51:50.409
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you, Chair.

1625
02:51:51.212 --> 02:52:02.486
<v Eric Zimmerman>I actually have some questions about the restoration fee that I'd like to ask to the staff that's in the room so I can better understand the nuances to that program.

1626
02:52:04.246 --> 02:52:13.031
<v Eric Zimmerman>Let me just start with, it seems weird that we don't charge an organization or a person who cuts into our pavement.

1627
02:52:13.416 --> 02:52:24.002
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, um, to go from not to 75%, and then I, as I highlighted earlier, I'm considering going to 100% of the restoration.

1628
02:52:24.146 --> 02:52:31.291
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm just trying to understand what that really means as a person who, when I bought my home, I had I had to redo the sewer line.

1629
02:52:31.550 --> 02:52:38.588
<v Eric Zimmerman>Obviously, that means cutting some pavement, but I paid that contractor through that permitting process to take care of that work.

1630
02:52:38.912 --> 02:52:43.890
<v Eric Zimmerman>And included in that may have been some asphalt, right?

1631
02:52:44.019 --> 02:52:49.532
<v Eric Zimmerman>So that payment occurred from me to the contractor because it's not that PBOT didn't come out and do that work.

1632
02:52:49.692 --> 02:52:53.266
<v Eric Zimmerman>It was Bob's new pipe business, whatever.

1633
02:52:54.270 --> 02:53:01.933
<v Eric Zimmerman>So What is— is this about when PBOT is replacing pavement, or is this when anybody's cutting in?

1634
02:53:02.125 --> 02:53:04.530
<v Eric Zimmerman>And can we talk about what that means a little bit?

1635
02:53:04.931 --> 02:53:05.202
<v Millicent Williams>Sure.

1636
02:53:05.572 --> 02:53:07.222
<v Millicent Williams>Thanks for the question, Councilor Zimmerman.

1637
02:53:07.334 --> 02:53:10.429
<v Millicent Williams>Millicent Williams, for the record, Director of the Portland Bureau of Transportation.

1638
02:53:11.343 --> 02:53:15.799
<v Millicent Williams>The street damage restoration fee is just what you mentioned at the last part of your conversation.

1639
02:53:16.055 --> 02:53:36.380
<v Millicent Williams>It is a fee that is assessed to those who are cutting into the pavement that are typically, um, uh, the utilities, uh, uh, folks like, of course, the Water Bureau, um, BES, uh, Verizon, uh, Comcast, Lucent, Lumen Technologies, uh, all of, all of those folks.

1640
02:53:36.590 --> 02:53:40.092
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's because they also use our public right-of-ways for their conduits.

1641
02:53:40.574 --> 02:53:49.424
<v Millicent Williams>So they're currently paying a permit— that's right, they're currently paying a permit fee, but they aren't paying, uh, for, uh, the damage that is done to the asset once they make that cut.

1642
02:53:49.890 --> 02:54:00.700
<v Millicent Williams>So when a cut is made into the pavement, especially at the depths that we're anticipating— oh great, Alex, our chief engineer, is here, who will take this over as soon as I finish this statement.

1643
02:54:02.163 --> 02:54:04.572
<v Millicent Williams>In fact, I'm going to just let him dig in right now.

1644
02:54:04.797 --> 02:54:05.551
<v Millicent Williams>Alex, take it away.

1645
02:54:05.631 --> 02:54:06.564
<v Eric Zimmerman>So to speak, huh?

1646
02:54:07.061 --> 02:54:07.543
<v Dan Ryan>All right.

1647
02:54:07.864 --> 02:54:09.454
<v Mitch Green>Alex Maharno, chief engineer, PBOT.

1648
02:54:10.113 --> 02:54:16.743
<v Mitch Green>Your question is basically, is that contractor paying for that piece, or will they It's the effect of—.

1649
02:54:17.736 --> 02:54:19.754
<v Millicent Williams>We don't charge for street damage restoration right now.

1650
02:54:20.299 --> 02:54:27.382
<v Millicent Williams>We are proposing this fee that would go onto the utilities that are in fact cutting into the street.

1651
02:54:27.912 --> 02:54:40.395
<v Millicent Williams>The question is around the damage that's created by that cut and how— probably how the utilities are receiving the information that they are going to be now assessed a fee.

1652
02:54:40.877 --> 02:54:43.299
<v Millicent Williams>That extends beyond just that permit fee.

1653
02:54:43.603 --> 02:54:45.000
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah, yeah, I think—.

1654
02:54:45.145 --> 02:54:45.272
<v Sameer Kanal>Right.

1655
02:54:45.400 --> 02:54:55.525
<v Mitch Green>So basically, you know, anytime you cut the pavement, there is the associated fee with the cut itself, and then there's associated damage that the surrounding soils, what have you, are loosened, if you will.

1656
02:54:55.574 --> 02:54:58.430
<v Mitch Green>So the cut impact is bigger than just the cut.

1657
02:54:58.477 --> 02:55:01.927
<v Mitch Green>So this would be applied to anybody who's cutting pavement.

1658
02:55:02.489 --> 02:55:06.020
<v Mitch Green>It would not apply to behind the curb because it is not pavement, right?

1659
02:55:06.084 --> 02:55:16.538
<v Mitch Green>So any concrete or asphalt you do cut will have this fee, including contractors, what have you, they would be assessed this as part of their street opening permit.

1660
02:55:17.244 --> 02:55:22.148
<v Eric Zimmerman>Okay, so I'm going to use Northwest Natural.

1661
02:55:22.373 --> 02:55:24.120
<v Eric Zimmerman>They have to cut into a street.

1662
02:55:24.217 --> 02:55:26.349
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm going to use 4th Avenue because we're on 4th Avenue.

1663
02:55:27.230 --> 02:55:31.206
<v Eric Zimmerman>And they are— they pay a utility fee, right?

1664
02:55:31.254 --> 02:55:33.932
<v Eric Zimmerman>And that's to have the pipes in the ground— or excuse me, a franchise fee.

1665
02:55:33.979 --> 02:55:35.118
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's to have the pipes in the right.

1666
02:55:35.182 --> 02:55:44.395
<v Eric Zimmerman>We're going to cut 12 feet of pavement, and when they do that, it's Northwest Natural's contractors are the ones who are actually putting the new asphalt down and finishing it.

1667
02:55:44.716 --> 02:55:52.215
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what we're saying is when you make a dent in the overall product, that product's lifespan reduces.

1668
02:55:52.310 --> 02:55:58.207
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think we heard 60% earlier in the presentation, and now we want to capture a fee for that degradation.

1669
02:55:59.457 --> 02:56:02.277
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to make sure I'm just saying this the right way and I'm understanding the impact.

1670
02:56:02.389 --> 02:56:02.646
<v Mitch Green>Right.

1671
02:56:02.887 --> 02:56:03.064
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1672
02:56:03.449 --> 02:56:07.380
<v Mitch Green>The, the only nuance to that is Northwest Natural is paying that fee, not the contractor.

1673
02:56:07.540 --> 02:56:09.434
<v Mitch Green>Northwest Natural is having their contractor do that.

1674
02:56:09.483 --> 02:56:09.804
<v Mitch Green>But yes.

1675
02:56:09.963 --> 02:56:10.189
<v Eric Zimmerman>Yeah.

1676
02:56:10.671 --> 02:56:17.411
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, okay, so historically we have not charged that facet of it, correct?

1677
02:56:17.459 --> 02:56:17.924
<v Olivia Clark>That's correct.

1678
02:56:18.148 --> 02:56:20.363
<v Eric Zimmerman>What is the reason that you're aware of?

1679
02:56:20.412 --> 02:56:21.711
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I'm sure it predates you.

1680
02:56:22.081 --> 02:56:24.601
<v Eric Zimmerman>Can you talk a little bit about why that has been the case?

1681
02:56:25.755 --> 02:56:27.923
<v Mitch Green>I could speak at this, uh, for a long time.

1682
02:56:28.034 --> 02:56:29.752
<v Mitch Green>Uh, I've been here with Almost 32 years.

1683
02:56:30.248 --> 02:56:36.329
<v Mitch Green>I've proposed this street damage restoration fee probably 20 years ago, and we've worked through this process.

1684
02:56:36.378 --> 02:56:40.997
<v Mitch Green>So I can't tell you how excited I am that we're at this point.

1685
02:56:41.431 --> 02:56:43.886
<v Mitch Green>So once we get this, I'll retire.

1686
02:56:44.222 --> 02:56:44.558
<v Mitch Green>Okay.

1687
02:56:44.943 --> 02:56:48.104
<v Mitch Green>But no, really, this is really something that we've talked about for a long time.

1688
02:56:48.313 --> 02:56:48.923
<v Mitch Green>It is needed.

1689
02:56:49.340 --> 02:56:50.656
<v Mitch Green>The degradation is there.

1690
02:56:51.057 --> 02:56:51.602
<v Mitch Green>It's real.

1691
02:56:52.083 --> 02:56:58.440
<v Mitch Green>Other cities, we, you know, explained Los Angeles and other areas other cities have experienced this, and so they've identified ways to address this.

1692
02:56:58.665 --> 02:57:01.925
<v Mitch Green>We're just now catching up to that, and that's why we're trying to move this forward.

1693
02:57:02.038 --> 02:57:08.832
<v Millicent Williams>As has been the case, Councilor Zimmerman, it's a series of choices that have been made over the course of the past many years.

1694
02:57:09.409 --> 02:57:24.028
<v Millicent Williams>And when we've had the opportunity to bring things forward, it was at the pleasure of previous councils to make a determination about whether or not we would move forward with something, when we would recommend solutions to the problems that we see.

1695
02:57:24.740 --> 02:57:26.783
<v Millicent Williams>They were met with varying degrees of support.

1696
02:57:27.156 --> 02:57:29.930
<v Millicent Williams>And so we find ourselves where we are now.

1697
02:57:31.617 --> 02:57:33.613
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think about insurance rules in Oregon.

1698
02:57:33.663 --> 02:57:35.773
<v Eric Zimmerman>If you're in a car accident, it allows you to get made whole.

1699
02:57:37.072 --> 02:57:40.245
<v Eric Zimmerman>And this seems kind of similar to like we should make the product whole.

1700
02:57:40.520 --> 02:57:51.024
<v Eric Zimmerman>And since we can't, we do that by collecting a fee so that when the whole road gets redone, we have been collecting because it's going to get done earlier than it would have but for this work that occurred.

1701
02:57:51.665 --> 02:57:52.916
<v Eric Zimmerman>I want to make sure that we're connecting.

1702
02:57:53.253 --> 02:57:53.477
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah.

1703
02:57:53.525 --> 02:57:57.292
<v Millicent Williams>So there's some— I don't want to call it nuance.

1704
02:57:57.356 --> 02:58:03.000
<v Millicent Williams>There's some process that's related to the determination about whether or not the fee would even be charged.

1705
02:58:03.048 --> 02:58:16.370
<v Millicent Williams>First of all, if 4 entities come together and say we are going to do work on 4th Avenue, let's coordinate so that we can make sure that if you're putting in something that's below the surface, you do that first.

1706
02:58:16.417 --> 02:58:17.907
<v Millicent Williams>You go in the year before and do that.

1707
02:58:18.355 --> 02:58:33.193
<v Millicent Williams>And then ultimately we would come in as the final portion of that work and do that top layer of pavement so that we aren't seeing that pavement cut and degraded immediately, as unfortunately is the case right outside of this door.

1708
02:58:33.995 --> 02:58:35.820
<v Millicent Williams>So we have lots of—.

1709
02:58:35.820 --> 02:58:39.090
<v Eric Zimmerman>The other option, we could say if we've paved it in the last 5 years, tough luck.

1710
02:58:39.170 --> 02:58:41.156
<v Eric Zimmerman>You don't get to do upgrades unless something breaks.

1711
02:58:41.253 --> 02:58:45.811
<v Millicent Williams>And that's part of what this would move toward facilitating.

1712
02:58:46.228 --> 02:58:50.037
<v Millicent Williams>It's the timelines within which a cut would be proposed.

1713
02:58:50.101 --> 02:58:51.081
<v Millicent Williams>It's the age of a street.

1714
02:58:51.162 --> 02:58:54.697
<v Millicent Williams>It's the current condition of the street, whether or not the fee would be assessed.

1715
02:58:54.841 --> 02:59:04.546
<v Millicent Williams>If we're all thumbs up on coordination, which is what we're working toward, then those utilities would not actually have a fee to pay.

1716
02:59:04.867 --> 02:59:05.092
<v Shoshana Cohen>Right.

1717
02:59:05.397 --> 02:59:06.152
<v Millicent Williams>So while the—.

1718
02:59:06.152 --> 02:59:07.807
<v Eric Zimmerman>They just say, hey, we're about to do a major project.

1719
02:59:07.854 --> 02:59:08.095
<v Eric Zimmerman>That's right.

1720
02:59:08.176 --> 02:59:09.269
<v Eric Zimmerman>Today's the day to get your stuff together.

1721
02:59:09.686 --> 02:59:10.281
<v Millicent Williams>Absolutely.

1722
02:59:10.441 --> 02:59:11.550
<v Millicent Williams>So that's our hope.

1723
02:59:11.935 --> 02:59:13.880
<v Eric Zimmerman>For the sake of time, I'm sorry to cut you off a little bit.

1724
02:59:14.104 --> 02:59:39.810
<v Eric Zimmerman>For the sake of time, colleagues, I am gonna move that amendment because I'd actually rather start at the 100% restoration instead of— and if there's discussion as we go through this process, so I think my team has posted it, but if they have not yet, in the very second to last be it resolved, I believe, in the agenda, In this, it has a, it has a 75% number.

1725
02:59:40.233 --> 02:59:46.021
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'm moving to move that to a 100% number for damage recovery amount as part of the transportation fee schedule.

1726
02:59:48.418 --> 02:59:49.415
<v Eric Zimmerman>Uh, so there's a pause.

1727
02:59:49.833 --> 02:59:50.540
<v Eric Zimmerman>So there's my movement.

1728
02:59:50.636 --> 02:59:51.856
<v Eric Zimmerman>I'd appreciate any second.

1729
02:59:52.018 --> 02:59:52.420
<v Eric Zimmerman>Thank you.

1730
02:59:52.822 --> 02:59:57.289
<v Sameer Kanal>Motion has been made by Councilor Zimmerman, seconded by Green, to amend the resolution.

1731
02:59:57.936 --> 02:59:59.507
<v Sameer Kanal>Once again, we're going to pause this queue.

1732
02:59:59.751 --> 03:00:04.200
<v Sameer Kanal>I'll run through everybody quickly if you'd like to be in the queue to discuss the amendment, you can, uh, rejoin.

1733
03:00:04.787 --> 03:00:07.538
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, so Councilor Koyama Lane, would you like to speak to the amendment?

1734
03:00:10.147 --> 03:00:10.617
<v Keelan McClymont>Kind of.

1735
03:00:11.199 --> 03:00:25.123
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, I think I, I'd like to know how this interacts with Vision Zero and some conversations that, um, Director Williams— we were starting to have and, um, was chatting with Councilor Clark to see, um, how this amendment would interact.

1736
03:00:25.189 --> 03:00:30.407
<v Keelan McClymont>And let me know if this is outside of the scope, if I may, it's too different.

1737
03:00:30.974 --> 03:00:31.168
<v Candace Avalos>Is it?

1738
03:00:31.459 --> 03:00:35.274
<v Keelan McClymont>Well, would this change anything around if we were to make the 20% of the—.

1739
03:00:35.274 --> 03:00:36.809
<v Millicent Williams>Totally different.

1740
03:00:36.873 --> 03:00:39.102
<v Eric Zimmerman>This is the other ordinance or other resolution.

1741
03:00:39.620 --> 03:00:42.672
<v Millicent Williams>This is for the street damage restoration fee, not for the transportation utility fee.

1742
03:00:44.217 --> 03:00:47.324
<v Millicent Williams>Okay, okay, thank you.

1743
03:00:48.667 --> 03:00:49.524
<v Keelan McClymont>No comment on this.

1744
03:00:49.816 --> 03:00:50.204
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you.

1745
03:00:50.448 --> 03:00:50.772
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you.

1746
03:00:51.094 --> 03:00:52.795
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Avalos, would you like to speak to this amendment?

1747
03:00:53.007 --> 03:00:54.129
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing a shake of the head there.

1748
03:00:54.193 --> 03:00:55.443
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan to the amendment?

1749
03:00:56.342 --> 03:00:57.495
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm next in the queue.

1750
03:00:57.944 --> 03:01:01.199
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm just going to say I support it and nothing else on the amendment.

1751
03:01:01.246 --> 03:01:03.042
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Novick, would you like to speak to the amendment?

1752
03:01:04.212 --> 03:01:04.726
<v Sameer Kanal>I support it.

1753
03:01:05.415 --> 03:01:05.575
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay.

1754
03:01:05.736 --> 03:01:07.708
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Green, would you like to speak to the amendment?

1755
03:01:08.604 --> 03:01:24.944
<v Mitch Green>Yeah, I seconded it because I think if you're going to send— if you're going to establish a fee that really tries to establish a price signal that changes behavior and recovers the cost of Causation of such a behavior, then it needs to be aggressive enough to change that behavior.

1756
03:01:25.268 --> 03:01:34.302
<v Mitch Green>And so if we do it right, then we won't collect this fee at all because then we will have coordinated this work ahead of time and everyone saves money, including the ratepayers.

1757
03:01:34.995 --> 03:01:38.837
<v Mitch Green>And I think you send a stronger signal if it's 100% versus 75%, and that's why I support it.

1758
03:01:41.118 --> 03:01:42.156
<v Sameer Kanal>Great, thank you so much.

1759
03:01:42.204 --> 03:01:47.890
<v Sameer Kanal>Seeing nobody else in the queue right now, we have information sorry, I'm reading through the amendment.

1760
03:01:47.954 --> 03:01:48.885
<v Candace Avalos>Can I ask a question?

1761
03:01:49.460 --> 03:01:51.720
<v Candace Avalos>Maybe, maybe let me get in the queue so I can ask a question.

1762
03:01:51.816 --> 03:01:56.224
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, so I don't think you have the one that I sent you, one that's not on this one.

1763
03:01:56.288 --> 03:01:57.378
<v Eric Zimmerman>You're, you're looking at a different one.

1764
03:01:58.130 --> 03:01:59.829
<v Candace Avalos>What you emailed us is not what we're talking about?

1765
03:02:00.118 --> 03:02:07.057
<v Eric Zimmerman>No, I'm talking about the resolution on this, the restoration, not the, not the transportation utility fee.

1766
03:02:07.889 --> 03:02:12.443
<v Eric Zimmerman>I know that 75 is used in both, but okay, it is confusing.

1767
03:02:13.617 --> 03:02:15.399
<v Candace Avalos>Maybe I just need a second to see.

1768
03:02:16.573 --> 03:02:18.019
<v Candace Avalos>Do I have something in front of me, or—.

1769
03:02:18.019 --> 03:02:19.625
<v Eric Zimmerman>I think it might be on the way.

1770
03:02:19.850 --> 03:02:24.460
<v Eric Zimmerman>Apparently the clerk's not posting amendments right now to the webpage, so we're having to send them out.

1771
03:02:24.540 --> 03:02:25.873
<v Eric Zimmerman>So apologies for that.

1772
03:02:26.050 --> 03:02:28.236
<v Sameer Kanal>But Councilor Zimmerman, can I clarify?

1773
03:02:28.332 --> 03:02:28.509
<v Eric Zimmerman>Please.

1774
03:02:28.861 --> 03:02:48.064
<v Sameer Kanal>In the resolution, which is the second item on the agenda, the second to last, be it further resolved, I believe that in that second line where it says be it further resolved, the council supports the city administrator's intent to include a street damage restoration fee at the 75% damage recovery amount, that this would change the 75% to 100%.

1775
03:02:48.938 --> 03:02:51.448
<v Sameer Kanal>And I also believe that that is the totality of the amendment.

1776
03:02:51.997 --> 03:02:52.549
<v Eric Zimmerman>That is correct.

1777
03:02:53.250 --> 03:02:55.156
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I'm getting— yeah, that verified there.

1778
03:02:55.237 --> 03:03:01.819
<v Sameer Kanal>So that's just changing the 75% to 100%, second to last, be it further resolved in the, uh, resolution.

1779
03:03:02.975 --> 03:03:11.649
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, there is no one else in the queue, so Councilor Avalos, if you want to a question, this is a, uh, good time to do it, but it is literally, I think, 2 characters, not even a full word.

1780
03:03:11.971 --> 03:03:15.790
<v Eric Zimmerman>So, uh, uh, yeah, okay, sorry for the confusion there.

1781
03:03:17.997 --> 03:03:21.213
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, seeing no one else in the queue, Keelan, would you please call the roll on the amendment?

1782
03:03:22.659 --> 03:03:23.013
<v Keelan McClymont>Pirtle-Guiney?

1783
03:03:25.768 --> 03:03:26.155
<v Elana Pirtle-Guiney>Absent.

1784
03:03:26.235 --> 03:03:26.524
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

1785
03:03:26.862 --> 03:03:26.912
<v Dan Ryan>Aye.

1786
03:03:27.506 --> 03:03:29.038
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

1787
03:03:29.360 --> 03:03:29.407
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

1788
03:03:30.165 --> 03:03:30.712
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

1789
03:03:31.066 --> 03:03:32.254
<v Olivia Clark>Look at all of us agreeing.

1790
03:03:32.370 --> 03:03:33.924
<v Olivia Clark>Hope the Oregonian publishes it.

1791
03:03:34.173 --> 03:03:34.221
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1792
03:03:38.165 --> 03:03:38.536
<v Keelan McClymont>Novick?

1793
03:03:38.712 --> 03:03:38.745
<v Steve Novick>Aye.

1794
03:03:39.180 --> 03:03:39.582
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

1795
03:03:40.049 --> 03:03:40.096
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

1796
03:03:40.628 --> 03:03:40.837
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

1797
03:03:41.255 --> 03:03:41.305
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

1798
03:03:42.318 --> 03:03:42.704
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman?

1799
03:03:43.188 --> 03:03:43.236
<v Eric Zimmerman>Aye.

1800
03:03:45.522 --> 03:03:45.827
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

1801
03:03:46.584 --> 03:03:49.728
<v Candace Avalos>This is a good example of why we need the ability to make amendments.

1802
03:03:50.117 --> 03:03:50.197
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

1803
03:03:51.665 --> 03:03:52.037
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

1804
03:03:52.376 --> 03:03:52.424
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

1805
03:03:53.377 --> 03:03:53.813
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

1806
03:03:54.313 --> 03:03:54.475
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

1807
03:03:55.200 --> 03:03:55.411
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

1808
03:03:56.250 --> 03:03:58.869
<v Sameer Kanal>Before I vote, I just noticed Councilor Pirtle-Guiney is back online.

1809
03:03:58.933 --> 03:04:04.254
<v Sameer Kanal>So before you call the answer, can we allow her to make a point of order if she'd like to cast a vote?

1810
03:04:05.717 --> 03:04:05.914
<v Candace Avalos>Sure.

1811
03:04:05.978 --> 03:04:06.735
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, I'm gonna vote aye.

1812
03:04:07.031 --> 03:04:08.904
<v Sameer Kanal>And if we could pause for— to give her a second.

1813
03:04:10.879 --> 03:04:11.171
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you.

1814
03:04:11.236 --> 03:04:12.272
<v Keelan McClymont>Can you hear my point of order?

1815
03:04:12.531 --> 03:04:12.790
<v Angelita Morillo>Yes.

1816
03:04:13.988 --> 03:04:14.734
<v Keelan McClymont>Fantastic.

1817
03:04:14.944 --> 03:04:18.022
<v Keelan McClymont>I had said aye, but I think it was too late.

1818
03:04:19.314 --> 03:04:20.058
<v Sameer Kanal>I think you're still good.

1819
03:04:20.122 --> 03:04:21.934
<v Keelan McClymont>So I'd like to add an aye vote.

1820
03:04:22.791 --> 03:04:24.054
<v Sameer Kanal>Perfect.

1821
03:04:25.380 --> 03:04:29.513
<v Keelan McClymont>All right, the amendment is approved with 12 yes votes.

1822
03:04:30.909 --> 03:04:31.186
<v Eric Zimmerman>Great.

1823
03:04:31.253 --> 03:04:33.638
<v Eric Zimmerman>Chair, I had one more before I go.

1824
03:04:33.719 --> 03:04:43.647
<v Eric Zimmerman>And on this one, I'm— you're doing a great job at like getting us to vote on them, but I want to put this up there as a— I don't think we'll close this out, so I guess I'm going to propose it.

1825
03:04:43.728 --> 03:04:47.503
<v Eric Zimmerman>And if we have a second to put it in the background for a while, I'm fine with that.

1826
03:04:48.165 --> 03:04:54.245
<v Eric Zimmerman>But what I have sent you colleagues is another amendment, and this now pertains to the overall transportation utility fee.

1827
03:04:55.021 --> 03:04:59.441
<v Eric Zimmerman>As you're aware, 75%, as was laid out in the presentation, is going to maintenance.

1828
03:05:00.421 --> 03:05:12.409
<v Eric Zimmerman>Um, the other 25% is about Vision Zero, and that's been important, but my assessment of that is that it was a little loose in what could be spent and how it would be spent.

1829
03:05:13.115 --> 03:05:21.862
<v Eric Zimmerman>So I've sent you an amendment that articulates 12.5%— that's half— to the SIP Thank you.

1830
03:05:22.745 --> 03:05:30.594
<v Eric Zimmerman>And the other 12.5% specifically has to be spent on Vision Zero, not just a can be spent on Vision Zero.

1831
03:05:31.316 --> 03:05:39.052
<v Eric Zimmerman>And I expect that this amendment will get some discussion, and that's why, Chair, I'd like to put it up there.

1832
03:05:39.182 --> 03:05:41.252
<v Eric Zimmerman>It is getting posted.

1833
03:05:42.070 --> 03:05:43.627
<v Eric Zimmerman>You've extended the deadlines for this meeting.

1834
03:05:43.772 --> 03:05:49.934
<v Eric Zimmerman>I have to leave at this moment, so I wanted to highlight it and know that you all have it, and I'm happy to discuss through it later.

1835
03:05:50.673 --> 03:05:53.998
<v Sameer Kanal>So I'm going to interpret that the way that Councilor Green's comment was.

1836
03:05:54.047 --> 03:05:59.059
<v Sameer Kanal>So something that can live with this as it goes to the full— to the next time we discuss it and then can be formally moved.

1837
03:05:59.123 --> 03:05:59.477
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that—.

1838
03:05:59.655 --> 03:06:00.511
<v Eric Zimmerman>That would be appreciated.

1839
03:06:01.109 --> 03:06:01.853
<v Sameer Kanal>Great, thank you.

1840
03:06:01.950 --> 03:06:04.231
<v Sameer Kanal>So that is in everyone's email as well.

1841
03:06:05.575 --> 03:06:09.183
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, we'll go to Councilor Koyama Lane followed by Councilor Avalos.

1842
03:06:11.016 --> 03:06:11.777
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you, Chair.

1843
03:06:12.554 --> 03:06:32.596
<v Keelan McClymont>Um, I am wondering if we can maybe have some can some leaders, representatives from PBOT speak a bit to the feasibility of if we were to amend that subsection G to require that something like no less than 20% of the TUF revenues be dedicated to traffic safety activities?

1844
03:06:33.600 --> 03:06:34.458
<v Keelan McClymont>Can you speak to that?

1845
03:06:34.522 --> 03:06:35.541
<v Keelan McClymont>How feasible is that?

1846
03:06:35.591 --> 03:06:42.099
<v Keelan McClymont>How would you define, outline which types of projects or measures qualify as traffic safety?

1847
03:06:42.700 --> 03:06:44.012
<v Keelan McClymont>What should we consider and know?

1848
03:06:45.791 --> 03:06:49.967
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane, for the question and for raising your concern.

1849
03:06:50.549 --> 03:06:59.254
<v Millicent Williams>We can certainly do what this council directs as relates to the ways that we would apply the funding that would come through the TUF.

1850
03:07:00.380 --> 03:07:15.850
<v Millicent Williams>The recommendation around a percentage that should be dedicated to one area of interest or another is just something that we would need to build into The overall programmatic implementation and budget based on whatever passes through this council.

1851
03:07:16.572 --> 03:07:27.684
<v Millicent Williams>Very similar to what we do with Fixing Our Streets, there is a percentage of projects that initially when we set up Fixing Our Streets that were dedicated to maintenance and 47% were for safety.

1852
03:07:27.733 --> 03:07:29.801
<v Millicent Williams>53% Maintenance, 47% safety.

1853
03:07:30.218 --> 03:07:32.014
<v Millicent Williams>And we had to report on that according to that.

1854
03:07:32.608 --> 03:07:35.447
<v Millicent Williams>And we had to define what a safety project was versus a maintenance project.

1855
03:07:35.495 --> 03:07:35.606
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

1856
03:07:36.231 --> 03:07:45.301
<v Millicent Williams>We would do the same with this funding source to ensure that people are really clear when we say a safety project or a Vision Zero project or a traffic operations project.

1857
03:07:45.926 --> 03:07:47.256
<v Millicent Williams>This is what that means.

1858
03:07:47.433 --> 03:07:51.150
<v Millicent Williams>It includes these elements or does not include these elements.

1859
03:07:51.279 --> 03:07:52.432
<v Millicent Williams>A maintenance project is this.

1860
03:07:52.753 --> 03:07:59.531
<v Millicent Williams>Now, what I will also share is that just because it's classified as a maintenance project doesn't mean that it's not a safety project as well.

1861
03:08:00.668 --> 03:08:07.181
<v Millicent Williams>We hope to, in all of our efforts, ensure that the maintenance work that we're doing is actually supporting overall safety.

1862
03:08:07.582 --> 03:08:23.180
<v Millicent Williams>So, and I'm not saying that to get us out of doing some very specific Vision Zero work, but I do want to provide the assurance that we are thinking about a full range of need when we're talking about the work that we're doing.

1863
03:08:23.371 --> 03:08:36.977
<v Millicent Williams>And we're looking at opportunities to enhance projects, especially to ensure that we are meeting a higher threshold than we perhaps are even legally required to do to ensure that we are meeting the safety expectations.

1864
03:08:37.515 --> 03:08:52.245
<v Millicent Williams>I will share that the City of Portland does go above and beyond most cities as it relates to imposing safety guidance and planning and design on our projects than most cities do in the country.

1865
03:08:53.503 --> 03:08:55.099
<v Millicent Williams>So it's not a problem, to answer your question.

1866
03:08:56.968 --> 03:09:04.174
<v Keelan McClymont>Thank you so much for explaining that and for your commitment to this area and for being so thoughtful about that process.

1867
03:09:04.690 --> 03:09:11.342
<v Keelan McClymont>I'll make sure my office works directly with you all and Chair Clark to see what makes sense moving forward.

1868
03:09:11.648 --> 03:09:11.923
<v Unidentified speaker>Thanks.

1869
03:09:11.987 --> 03:09:12.245
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

1870
03:09:12.941 --> 03:09:14.470
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Koyama Lane.

1871
03:09:14.520 --> 03:09:15.900
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Avalos, followed by Ryan.

1872
03:09:19.959 --> 03:09:20.906
<v Candace Avalos>Thank you, Chair.

1873
03:09:22.748 --> 03:09:25.463
<v Candace Avalos>All right, so a couple of thoughts and then a couple of questions.

1874
03:09:26.684 --> 03:09:37.029
<v Candace Avalos>First, I just want to, like everybody else has, appreciate the work that's gone into bringing this forward and bringing forward a long-term solution to Portland's transportation funding challenges.

1875
03:09:37.606 --> 03:09:45.862
<v Candace Avalos>I hear from my constituents all the time about potholes and safety issues and basic maintenance, and it's clear that we need a more stable and sustainable funding source to address those needs.

1876
03:09:46.939 --> 03:09:52.362
<v Candace Avalos>At the same time, this proposal raises important questions to me about fairness and affordability.

1877
03:09:52.971 --> 03:10:01.047
<v Candace Avalos>For many Portlanders, especially in East Portland, the cost of living is already high, and any new fee, no matter how small it may seem, really adds up.

1878
03:10:01.847 --> 03:10:11.430
<v Candace Avalos>In fact, I regularly have constituents set up meetings with me in my constituent office hours, particularly elders on fixed incomes, and they literally bring me their bills.

1879
03:10:11.781 --> 03:10:17.967
<v Candace Avalos>They bring me their utility bills so that I can see the impact, and they say, if you do not stop this, I will be homeless.

1880
03:10:19.218 --> 03:10:30.272
<v Candace Avalos>Let that sink in, because people really are on the edge, and any increases on their utility fees adds up to them not being able to pay their bills, and then they're worried about their housing stability.

1881
03:10:30.720 --> 03:10:35.726
<v Candace Avalos>So that does come up often, and I need to speak up for those, those constituents.

1882
03:10:37.105 --> 03:10:42.753
<v Candace Avalos>I also have some concerns about the commercial fee structure, which is based on a percentage of a utility bill.

1883
03:10:42.816 --> 03:10:52.567
<v Candace Avalos>It's not really clear to me yet that the utility usage is the best proxy for transportation system use, and I just want to better understand how this will impact different types of businesses.

1884
03:10:53.546 --> 03:11:04.033
<v Candace Avalos>And finally, I just want to ensure that investments from this fee are equitably distributed, particularly for us in East Portland, because we have significant infrastructure gaps and safety needs.

1885
03:11:04.884 --> 03:11:11.009
<v Candace Avalos>So I'm supportive of the goal, but I, I do want some more clarity and some stronger guardrails around equity, transparency, and accountability.

1886
03:11:11.863 --> 03:11:13.956
<v Candace Avalos>So with that, let me start here.

1887
03:11:15.430 --> 03:11:24.810
<v Candace Avalos>District 1 residents have been waiting a long time for basic infrastructure, things like pothole repair, sidewalk maintenance, and in some cases are experiencing stagnant or declining service levels.

1888
03:11:25.405 --> 03:11:35.129
<v Candace Avalos>So if we are asking them to pay more through this fee, what guarantees are in place to ensure that they are seeing a proportional and meaningful return on their investment?

1889
03:11:36.727 --> 03:11:37.469
<v Millicent Williams>And you want that answer today?

1890
03:11:37.550 --> 03:11:40.698
<v Millicent Williams>Okay, I just wasn't sure if that was one that you wanted us to posit, that you were positing for later.

1891
03:11:40.843 --> 03:11:40.957
<v Millicent Williams>Sure.

1892
03:11:43.085 --> 03:11:50.658
<v Millicent Williams>We recognize, and we see this every day, that there are parts of the community that are underinvested or have been disinvested over decades.

1893
03:11:51.786 --> 03:12:01.888
<v Millicent Williams>One of the efforts that is underway, and this is something that we are doing all the time, is assessing overall condition of the system.

1894
03:12:02.436 --> 03:12:10.766
<v Millicent Williams>It's the streets, it's the sidewalks, it's where the gaps are, it's access, it's all of those things that make living comfortable for people.

1895
03:12:11.174 --> 03:12:12.863
<v Millicent Williams>And so we do know where the areas of greatest need are.

1896
03:12:12.959 --> 03:12:20.893
<v Millicent Williams>Greatest need are to be able to very quickly assess how we might be able to go in and provide the levels of support that communities would need.

1897
03:12:21.325 --> 03:12:41.168
<v Millicent Williams>I think if we are looking at, and as we've talked about, the SIP program, one of the expectations of that program is that we'd be able to go in and see where the areas of greatest need are and invest there to get folks up to a level of at least good so that we can level the playing field and everyone has access to the services that they need.

1898
03:12:41.217 --> 03:12:41.328
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

1899
03:12:44.584 --> 03:12:46.750
<v Millicent Williams>So we do think about that all the time.

1900
03:12:46.814 --> 03:12:49.668
<v Millicent Williams>We have tools that we use to inform our decision-making.

1901
03:12:50.278 --> 03:12:59.644
<v Millicent Williams>Some of those were developed in past years, but we still use that guidance to help to inform how we make our decisions about what we are going to do.

1902
03:12:59.724 --> 03:13:00.510
<v Millicent Williams>I'll give you an example.

1903
03:13:00.590 --> 03:13:00.670
<v Millicent Williams>Okay.

1904
03:13:01.070 --> 03:13:04.855
<v Millicent Williams>We were talking about the 80th and Mill work that was done several years ago.

1905
03:13:05.305 --> 03:13:07.037
<v Millicent Williams>There's an elementary school that is located on 80th and Mill.

1906
03:13:07.229 --> 03:13:09.441
<v Millicent Williams>That's at the intersection of 80th and Mill.

1907
03:13:09.888 --> 03:13:13.237
<v Millicent Williams>Uh, the kids were literally walking to school through gigantic mud puddles.

1908
03:13:13.815 --> 03:13:18.621
<v Millicent Williams>Uh, we were able to work with PPS and the community, uh, to develop an LID.

1909
03:13:18.718 --> 03:13:31.263
<v Millicent Williams>Now, this is something that, that's a different, um, funding mechanism, but we developed an, an LID to ensure that those, uh, streets were in fact, uh, ones— and sidewalks were ones that the, the community could use.

1910
03:13:31.456 --> 03:13:36.424
<v Millicent Williams>And it has made a tremendous difference in the quality of the lives of the children that are trying to get to school on a daily basis.

1911
03:13:37.628 --> 03:13:42.438
<v Millicent Williams>But we've done some work, especially as it relates to the walk shed for schools.

1912
03:13:43.144 --> 03:13:53.519
<v Millicent Williams>There's a school, and I don't know if our pedestrian coordinator is here or if Art's back there and can yell it out from the back of the room, about a school that right now has a 300-foot walk shed.

1913
03:13:53.664 --> 03:14:03.545
<v Millicent Williams>But with some very strategic and thoughtful planning, we will be able to, with a decent investment, get to a mile walk shed from that school.

1914
03:14:03.673 --> 03:14:05.712
<v Millicent Williams>That's the type of work that we would be able to do.

1915
03:14:06.099 --> 03:14:17.872
<v Millicent Williams>One of the things that we talked about most recently was ensuring that we're looking at all of the schools in the area to make sure— that's a tier that we need to make sure we're focusing on, to make sure that those folks are getting to and from their destinations safely.

1916
03:14:18.307 --> 03:14:18.933
<v Millicent Williams>How do we do that?

1917
03:14:19.029 --> 03:14:19.864
<v Millicent Williams>That's the sidewalks.

1918
03:14:19.913 --> 03:14:20.586
<v Millicent Williams>That is the streets.

1919
03:14:20.636 --> 03:14:25.101
<v Millicent Williams>And so, yes, of course, District 1 is one of those areas where we know we've done—.

1920
03:14:25.935 --> 03:14:38.110
<v Candace Avalos>We can do more and we Yeah, and I think to echo a little bit of what I heard earlier from Councilor Zimmerman around like, how are you measuring it, right?

1921
03:14:38.110 --> 03:14:47.090
<v Candace Avalos>Because, um, Councilor Dunphy and I did a town hall a few months ago, and we had a table— it was about Gateway— we had a table about transportation.

1922
03:14:47.250 --> 03:14:54.190
<v Candace Avalos>And one thing that stuck out to me from what people were saying was, we are interested in these kinds of improvements, you just need to communicate it to us.

1923
03:14:54.190 --> 03:14:54.329
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I think that's a great point.

1924
03:14:56.494 --> 03:14:58.773
<v Candace Avalos>How is it impacting our safety?

1925
03:14:58.983 --> 03:15:01.134
<v Candace Avalos>Are we lowering the amount of traffic deaths?

1926
03:15:01.182 --> 03:15:03.591
<v Candace Avalos>So how are you all communicating this?

1927
03:15:03.655 --> 03:15:08.728
<v Candace Avalos>Because this is sure a structural fiscal thing, but this is also a political problem for us, right?

1928
03:15:08.938 --> 03:15:13.995
<v Candace Avalos>As you hear, people are frustrated to hear that they're, you know, to them it's their taxes, right?

1929
03:15:14.092 --> 03:15:16.870
<v Candace Avalos>Regardless of what you call it, it's more money they gotta pay every month.

1930
03:15:17.528 --> 03:15:24.736
<v Candace Avalos>And so what does it look like to be able to measure that, to communicate that out, and to show real tangible, like, results?

1931
03:15:24.817 --> 03:15:25.603
<v Candace Avalos>Yeah, I think that's a great question.

1932
03:15:25.559 --> 03:15:27.780
<v Candace Avalos>Like change on the ground.

1933
03:15:27.920 --> 03:15:37.719
<v Candace Avalos>Um, you know, I, uh, like many people are big, uh, Mayor Mom Donny fan, and he posted a video where he was like, we filled 8,000 potholes in a day.

1934
03:15:37.719 --> 03:15:38.819
<v Candace Avalos>They did like a whole blitz.

1935
03:15:38.819 --> 03:15:39.489
<v Candace Avalos>And I was like, how?

1936
03:15:39.540 --> 03:15:42.379
<v Candace Avalos>I told the mayor, I told Mayor Wilson, I was like, can we have a pothole blitz?

1937
03:15:42.680 --> 03:15:48.879
<v Millicent Williams>Can we have a day where we can just like go out there and just fill— we had March Madness a couple years ago and did thousands and thousands of potholes.

1938
03:15:48.879 --> 03:15:50.180
<v Millicent Williams>And yes, we can do that.

1939
03:15:50.239 --> 03:15:50.579
<v Candace Avalos>I believe—.

1940
03:15:50.579 --> 03:15:51.600
<v Millicent Williams>I, I hear you.

1941
03:15:51.600 --> 03:15:54.943
<v Millicent Williams>And, uh, people do know to know the impact of their investment.

1942
03:15:55.153 --> 03:16:07.060
<v Millicent Williams>Again, using Fixing Our Streets as the example, the byline is Our Dime at Work, and we can point specifically to projects that your dime went to make an impact in the community for or with.

1943
03:16:07.766 --> 03:16:10.447
<v Millicent Williams>So we will be able to do that with this program as well.

1944
03:16:10.959 --> 03:16:19.209
<v Millicent Williams>As the city administrator just mentioned a few minutes ago before the recess, being able to have signage that says TUF paid for this and this is how.

1945
03:16:20.123 --> 03:16:21.939
<v Millicent Williams>There's been an impact to community.

1946
03:16:22.195 --> 03:16:29.341
<v Millicent Williams>We also will have the dashboards that folks can go in and see where we are literally from day to day in terms of the work that we're intending to do.

1947
03:16:29.983 --> 03:16:36.436
<v Millicent Williams>That's really, really important for us internally as well as for those who are investing in us.

1948
03:16:36.502 --> 03:16:45.637
<v Millicent Williams>We want to make sure that people know that we take their investment very seriously and we want to be good stewards of the investments that's being made.

1949
03:16:45.748 --> 03:16:51.583
<v Millicent Williams>And we want for people to be able to trust that we are going to do what they're expecting for us to do.

1950
03:16:51.663 --> 03:16:52.656
<v Millicent Williams>We hear it all the time.

1951
03:16:53.425 --> 03:16:54.628
<v Millicent Williams>I don't have a sidewalk.

1952
03:16:54.691 --> 03:16:55.574
<v Millicent Williams>I don't have a street.

1953
03:16:55.814 --> 03:16:58.411
<v Millicent Williams>How do you expect me to A, B, C, D, E, F, G?

1954
03:16:59.355 --> 03:17:00.414
<v Millicent Williams>And we recognize that.

1955
03:17:00.461 --> 03:17:02.801
<v Millicent Williams>We want to make sure that we're addressing that and correcting that.

1956
03:17:02.881 --> 03:17:20.420
<v Millicent Williams>Now, I will share, and this came up even last week when we were for a different— before the T&I committee about the cost— no, it was full council— about the cost cost of doing business in certain parts of town where there is no existing infrastructure.

1957
03:17:21.316 --> 03:17:24.424
<v Millicent Williams>So that— it will cost more because there is nothing there.

1958
03:17:25.494 --> 03:17:43.487
<v Millicent Williams>But once we make the investment and we make the best investment, we will be able to see the length of time that those assets last based on this ongoing investment, have the cumulative effect of really being able to So we make the investment initially.

1959
03:17:43.825 --> 03:17:45.737
<v Millicent Williams>We don't just say, oh, we built it and we're gone.

1960
03:17:46.171 --> 03:17:58.049
<v Millicent Williams>We build into the building of new infrastructure the maintenance of infrastructure so that we won't find ourselves in this really downward spiral regarding the infrastructure investments that are being made.

1961
03:17:58.097 --> 03:18:03.385
<v Millicent Williams>So we'll talk about how we're able to communicate about the work that we're doing.

1962
03:18:03.497 --> 03:18:05.459
<v Millicent Williams>We do want people to know that, yep, this is a priority.

1963
03:18:05.559 --> 03:18:05.692
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

1964
03:18:05.790 --> 03:18:07.792
<v Millicent Williams>This is what you paid for that light.

1965
03:18:08.129 --> 03:18:09.524
<v Millicent Williams>You paid for that sidewalk square.

1966
03:18:09.653 --> 03:18:10.647
<v Millicent Williams>You paid for that ramp.

1967
03:18:10.694 --> 03:18:12.506
<v Millicent Williams>You paid for that bit of street.

1968
03:18:13.581 --> 03:18:19.575
<v Millicent Williams>And we also, though, want to make sure that folks know that every place where we invest will not look the same.

1969
03:18:19.769 --> 03:18:27.512
<v Millicent Williams>Some of that's because it cannot, based on topography and based on urgency to do something.

1970
03:18:27.703 --> 03:18:31.375
<v Millicent Williams>So we are adjusting the ways that we're thinking about even doing our work.

1971
03:18:32.336 --> 03:18:52.648
<v Millicent Williams>Alex and his team are evaluating how we might look at a series of alternatives that make the list of options for us broader in terms of being able to very quickly go out, do the things that are important for people, and then also looking out on the horizon for how we can do those really big transformational work— that big transformational work as well.

1972
03:18:53.337 --> 03:19:02.266
<v Unidentified speaker>A couple of quick things that I want to add, final points to what Director Liam said, um, in— so these are things that we can do as the project goes on as well.

1973
03:19:02.411 --> 03:19:08.534
<v Unidentified speaker>We also will have the customer bill inserts, and we can include information on what those, uh, fees are for.

1974
03:19:09.128 --> 03:19:23.554
<v Unidentified speaker>And in addition to that, Public Works is planning to have a, um, district-by-district newsletter that we will share with each of the councilors, uh, so you can share what is the ongoing, uh, infrastructure work that is happening in each of your districts and upcoming work as well.

1975
03:19:23.666 --> 03:19:26.800
<v Unidentified speaker>So you can Thank you.

1976
03:19:27.449 --> 03:19:37.158
<v Candace Avalos>And, you know, I'll just say as it relates to like engagement and all of that, my staff were in a briefing yesterday about 120 seconds.

1977
03:19:37.287 --> 03:19:55.815
<v Candace Avalos>I know we're trying to make that safer, sounds great, but I am a little concerned about what I heard from that briefing, which is that it's like we're barreling through and, you know, the staff are like, present this big pretty plan, and it's like, I know that my constituents are going to be mad about some of the things in this plan.

1978
03:19:56.313 --> 03:19:57.629
<v Candace Avalos>And so I just want to name that.

1979
03:19:57.709 --> 03:20:07.951
<v Candace Avalos>I think District 1 in particular, what I heard a lot when I was knocking on doors was they felt frustrated that they were like, we appreciate when PBOT comes in, but we don't always feel like they listen to us about what's best for us.

1980
03:20:08.674 --> 03:20:11.163
<v Candace Avalos>And that is an ongoing thing I keep hearing this year.

1981
03:20:11.210 --> 03:20:34.615
<v Candace Avalos>So again, you know, that's every, you know, person in Portland, but I just hear it so particularly in D1 because because, for example, they were like, PBOT came in and put in this bike lane here, and it's like, if they would've talked to us, we would've preferred that they put it on this side, 'cause now you have a bike lane next to the park, and now parents who bring, you know, drive a car with their kids to this park have to cross the street, right?

1982
03:20:34.664 --> 03:20:42.073
<v Candace Avalos>That's a simple thing that could've just from talking to the neighbors in that area, they could've told you, yes, we are okay with the bike lane, we would've preferred on the other side.

1983
03:20:42.120 --> 03:20:43.836
<v Candace Avalos>So these are the kinds of things that I hear.

1984
03:20:44.542 --> 03:20:47.273
<v Candace Avalos>The frustrations that I hear from D1 about PBOT.

1985
03:20:47.337 --> 03:20:58.503
<v Candace Avalos>And so I'm raising those as we look at, um, you know, not only implementing this, but also one thing that you mentioned, let me flag, because that I'm concerned about, um, you know, like it costs more, right?

1986
03:20:58.600 --> 03:20:59.370
<v Candace Avalos>It costs more in D1.

1987
03:20:59.467 --> 03:21:00.672
<v Candace Avalos>We don't have the infrastructure.

1988
03:21:00.753 --> 03:21:03.628
<v Candace Avalos>We don't have— we don't even have the hubs in East Portland.

1989
03:21:03.675 --> 03:21:08.061
<v Candace Avalos>So just miles per hour, things cost more just because you got to drive all the way out to East Portland.

1990
03:21:08.543 --> 03:21:18.924
<v Candace Avalos>That's really unfair to us that we're going to have to pay a pretty penny more even though we have less, and they're all paying their tax— their taxes, and they do not feel like they're getting their investment back, right?

1991
03:21:18.988 --> 03:21:20.559
<v Candace Avalos>So that's why I'm asking that first question.

1992
03:21:21.218 --> 03:21:27.102
<v Candace Avalos>But then also, when it— as it relates to maintenance, this, you know, from, you know, the 75% of it is going to maintenance.

1993
03:21:27.166 --> 03:21:28.417
<v Candace Avalos>Is that how I'm understanding?

1994
03:21:28.851 --> 03:21:32.636
<v Candace Avalos>So again, great, but you can't maintain something that doesn't exist.

1995
03:21:32.683 --> 03:21:32.780
<v Sameer Kanal>Sure.

1996
03:21:32.876 --> 03:21:38.554
<v Candace Avalos>So I want to make sure that that doesn't mean that all of the other streets are going to get all their pretty streets, everything's going to be great.

1997
03:21:38.793 --> 03:21:40.783
<v Candace Avalos>And we're still not going to have streets to maintain at all.

1998
03:21:41.281 --> 03:21:43.221
<v Candace Avalos>So I, I don't know how to square that right now.

1999
03:21:43.270 --> 03:21:46.783
<v Candace Avalos>I'm thinking through that still and, um, plan to bring some ideas forward.

2000
03:21:46.896 --> 03:21:49.190
<v Candace Avalos>But, um, let me ask one more quick question.

2001
03:21:50.104 --> 03:22:10.990
<v Candace Avalos>From my understanding, in Oregon City they have a model— this is about the commercial one— they have a model for commercial pavement maintenance utility fee where non-residential, non-residential are charges based on the type and size of development instead of a So can you just clearly explain why a percentage of utility bill is the best proxy in your view?

2002
03:22:13.461 --> 03:22:28.316
<v Mark Lear>Councilor Avalos, Mark Lear, PBOT, the short answer is that we established the water and sewer bill as a proxy, as an immediate tool for us to make sure that we have that balance between residential properties paying and commercial properties paying.

2003
03:22:28.364 --> 03:22:29.226
<v Mark Lear>But we are looking at other ways to do that.

2004
03:22:29.489 --> 03:22:40.327
<v Mark Lear>But we have established in the ordinance that we would report— we're required to report back to council about 18 months after we start the program to provide alternatives.

2005
03:22:40.825 --> 03:22:54.040
<v Mark Lear>Either a traditional approach, which is based on the type of business and the multiplier per 1,000 square feet of trips, or some kind of an appeals process for that initial proxy that we're using of the water and sewer bill.

2006
03:22:56.111 --> 03:22:57.972
<v Candace Avalos>Okay, um, let me just end it there.

2007
03:22:58.342 --> 03:22:59.386
<v Candace Avalos>Really grateful for this.

2008
03:22:59.466 --> 03:23:04.458
<v Candace Avalos>I, I think that, um, I'm— let me just ask maybe a process question because we're coming up on time.

2009
03:23:04.586 --> 03:23:08.439
<v Candace Avalos>What is the expectation for how this con— this conversation continues after this?

2010
03:23:09.498 --> 03:23:17.379
<v Sameer Kanal>At this moment, if it should be referred out, it would be referred to the full council and up to Council President Dunphy when to put it on the full council agenda for either or both items.

2011
03:23:17.443 --> 03:23:28.317
<v Sameer Kanal>They can be separately handled, and if they're not, they'd be continued over to the next meeting of this committee, which is going to okay.

2012
03:23:28.704 --> 03:23:32.557
<v Candace Avalos>And so we would need to take some sort of action to move it out if that's what we wanted?

2013
03:23:32.815 --> 03:23:33.023
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes.

2014
03:23:33.234 --> 03:23:33.395
<v Dan Ryan>Okay.

2015
03:23:33.975 --> 03:23:34.264
<v Candace Avalos>Sounds good.

2016
03:23:34.426 --> 03:23:34.620
<v Olivia Clark>Thank you.

2017
03:23:35.167 --> 03:23:36.166
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Avalos.

2018
03:23:36.280 --> 03:23:37.729
<v Sameer Kanal>Councilor Ryan followed by Novick.

2019
03:23:38.148 --> 03:23:40.675
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you so much, Chair Kanal.

2020
03:23:41.835 --> 03:23:52.412
<v Dan Ryan>Councilor Avalos, you remind me that since I've been in elected office in this body, if there's one consistency It's every neighborhood association meeting and many other meetings.

2021
03:23:52.909 --> 03:23:54.547
<v Dan Ryan>PBOT's at the top of the agenda.

2022
03:23:54.868 --> 03:23:59.153
<v Dan Ryan>So Portlanders have a lot of passionate opinions about PBOT, and I know that you all know this.

2023
03:24:00.211 --> 03:24:09.070
<v Dan Ryan>First, I want to really take a moment to recognize the amazing and hardworking PBOT staff that are out there doing the tough work on the ground, repairing, paving as we speak.

2024
03:24:09.681 --> 03:24:12.618
<v Dan Ryan>I don't think they get lifted enough when we have conversations like this.

2025
03:24:13.131 --> 03:24:14.174
<v Dan Ryan>I really appreciate you, Councilor Clark.

2026
03:24:14.222 --> 03:24:14.334
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

2027
03:24:14.399 --> 03:24:18.460
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you, Council Clerk, and the former Transportation Committee for the diligence you've done on this topic.

2028
03:24:18.990 --> 03:24:27.916
<v Dan Ryan>Please know, for those of us that aren't on the committee, this is how the system works, and we just now have an opportunity to, to dive in ourselves and ask some bigger picture questions perhaps.

2029
03:24:28.478 --> 03:24:37.790
<v Dan Ryan>When I'm looking and trying to understand a problem that requires major reforms, I like to understand the current revenue, which I thought you did a good job of in the presentation explaining that.

2030
03:24:37.838 --> 03:24:38.015
<v Dan Ryan>Thank you.

2031
03:24:38.496 --> 03:24:49.637
<v Dan Ryan>I also like to understand how we deliver efficiency In other words, nothing like a crisis to do some major reforms and turn it into an opportunity.

2032
03:24:50.549 --> 03:24:52.208
<v Dan Ryan>So over the decades, a lot of things have changed.

2033
03:24:52.336 --> 03:24:54.575
<v Dan Ryan>I don't think all this was lifted as much as it should have been.

2034
03:24:54.688 --> 03:24:57.006
<v Dan Ryan>We've seen a slowdown of federal revenue.

2035
03:24:57.102 --> 03:24:58.213
<v Dan Ryan>That was explained very well.

2036
03:24:58.875 --> 03:25:02.974
<v Dan Ryan>We have added better bike, transit, and pedestrian infrastructure in our city.

2037
03:25:03.884 --> 03:25:06.628
<v Dan Ryan>Our city has taken on more maintenance that used to be with the state.

2038
03:25:07.313 --> 03:25:07.923
<v Dan Ryan>82Nd.

2039
03:25:08.211 --> 03:25:12.416
<v Dan Ryan>A good decision, but it also added a maintenance burden that we didn't have prior to that.

2040
03:25:12.850 --> 03:25:22.288
<v Dan Ryan>Declining fossil fuel revenue, and while electrical vehicles do not add fossil fuels into our air and water, they are also heavier and causing more damage on our roadways.

2041
03:25:22.625 --> 03:25:24.052
<v Dan Ryan>So how is that connected?

2042
03:25:24.727 --> 03:25:38.734
<v Dan Ryan>And finally, and often not said out loud, our frontline PBOT staff have to spend increasing time managing their vital work around the humanitarian crisis on our streets that increased since the implementation of Measure 110.

2043
03:25:39.486 --> 03:25:43.000
<v Dan Ryan>Albeit reformed, the impact is seen by Portlanders daily.

2044
03:25:43.817 --> 03:25:51.403
<v Dan Ryan>I want to thank those often unsung outreach workers that are from PBOT that are doing that work daily.

2045
03:25:51.675 --> 03:25:53.536
<v Dan Ryan>And again, I don't think we talk about it enough.

2046
03:25:53.697 --> 03:25:54.948
<v Dan Ryan>It gets put under the rug.

2047
03:25:55.748 --> 03:26:02.085
<v Dan Ryan>And so along with TriMet, I want to lobby That we should be able to leverage Metro SHS funds for this work.

2048
03:26:02.557 --> 03:26:04.621
<v Dan Ryan>And that should be another revenue stream that we should consider.

2049
03:26:05.500 --> 03:26:08.673
<v Dan Ryan>So thank you for listening, colleagues and leaders of PBOT.

2050
03:26:08.995 --> 03:26:12.668
<v Dan Ryan>That was a lot of context and background that I would've asked if I was in the committee.

2051
03:26:14.132 --> 03:26:14.813
<v Dan Ryan>I need to ask this.

2052
03:26:14.941 --> 03:26:24.280
<v Dan Ryan>Were all of these factors I just mentioned discussed when proposing what is the other side of the street, the revenue solution, not the practice and infrastructure solution?

2053
03:26:24.328 --> 03:26:24.394
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

2054
03:26:27.409 --> 03:26:29.655
<v Sameer Kanal>Is that for Councilor Clark or for staff?

2055
03:26:29.932 --> 03:26:31.704
<v Dan Ryan>It could be from either.

2056
03:26:35.531 --> 03:26:36.369
<v Shoshana Cohen>Thank you for the question.

2057
03:26:36.819 --> 03:26:45.234
<v Shoshana Cohen>I think many of those things, yes, we have sort of a longer story of how we got here that we have used sort of through many of these discussions.

2058
03:26:45.282 --> 03:26:58.557
<v Shoshana Cohen>And the things that you mentioned around decreasing fuel tax, increasing EVs and the impact on roads, um, us staff having to spend increased amount of time because of changing conditions on the streets.

2059
03:26:58.958 --> 03:27:01.488
<v Shoshana Cohen>All of those are part of the story of how we got here.

2060
03:27:02.162 --> 03:27:08.763
<v Shoshana Cohen>And yes, we sort of the, um, we've had a combination of changing our practices and thinking about new revenue.

2061
03:27:08.843 --> 03:27:10.447
<v Shoshana Cohen>So yes.

2062
03:27:10.815 --> 03:27:25.865
<v Millicent Williams>And specifically to the efficiency, uh, question, I do want to share that the bureau has, uh, over the course of the past several years, again, based on the fact that we've recognized the need to fill a gap in our budget, looked at how we might do things differently.

2063
03:27:26.555 --> 03:27:36.334
<v Millicent Williams>So we did engage in a realignment exercise, bringing bodies of work, like bodies of work together, and determining how we would more efficiently move through the work.

2064
03:27:36.397 --> 03:27:55.448
<v Millicent Williams>That did not necessarily mean a reduction in force exercise as much as it was bringing the errant— not In bringing the separated functions more closely together, one of the areas that was specifically an area of focus, it's both within the engineering space and the transportation operations space.

2065
03:27:56.602 --> 03:28:16.209
<v Millicent Williams>We brought together engineering departments that were servicing development but were also servicing capital projects, brought that together under one roof, making sure that those engineers that are doing that work are now well-rounded in a body of work that allows for them to do more than one thing well, multiple things well.

2066
03:28:16.336 --> 03:28:30.113
<v Millicent Williams>And so we're able to find the opportunity to provide that longevity for staff to ensure that there's consistency in the ways that we apply the work and the policy and that we're able to carry out a number of things.

2067
03:28:30.162 --> 03:28:39.156
<v Millicent Williams>So we did some realignment because we recognized that we were too dispersed in the ways that we were managing our work.

2068
03:28:39.203 --> 03:28:55.828
<v Millicent Williams>So transportation operations now not only includes just signals and street lighting and street design, but also parking enforcement and parking regulatory, because they are responsible for the movement and the management of the right-of-way in that particular way.

2069
03:28:55.924 --> 03:28:58.334
<v Millicent Williams>They also manage the TSUB permits.

2070
03:28:58.575 --> 03:28:59.475
<v Millicent Williams>Thank you.

2071
03:29:00.342 --> 03:29:06.391
<v Millicent Williams>So people who are coming in, the 25,000 people who get permits a year, that's all under transportation operations.

2072
03:29:06.456 --> 03:29:08.815
<v Millicent Williams>It used to be dispersed in other parts of the organization.

2073
03:29:08.862 --> 03:29:15.876
<v Millicent Williams>So we've done some efficiency work to ensure that we can find answers in one place versus having to shop around even internally.

2074
03:29:16.453 --> 03:29:24.541
<v Dan Ryan>As we're making this case during an affordability crisis, I think we have to be more crisp and clear on how we're improving operations.

2075
03:29:24.895 --> 03:29:25.296
<v Dan Ryan>Absolutely.

2076
03:29:25.778 --> 03:29:29.096
<v Dan Ryan>And I don't think I've heard that today, and that's what I'm getting at.

2077
03:29:29.706 --> 03:29:35.635
<v Dan Ryan>So I've always lived by a policy: you have to take care of your side of the street before you can ask others to join you and be a partner.

2078
03:29:36.100 --> 03:29:39.305
<v Dan Ryan>And I think we're, we're not making that case as clearly as possible.

2079
03:29:39.816 --> 03:29:44.769
<v Dan Ryan>So when I hear what you're saying now, that's pleasing, but what does that continuous improvement plan look like?

2080
03:29:44.913 --> 03:29:46.388
<v Millicent Williams>Sure, we can certainly provide that.

2081
03:29:46.451 --> 03:29:51.675
<v Dan Ryan>I'm just pressuring you before we get to the final vote of this, of thinking about how we could make that case.

2082
03:29:51.724 --> 03:29:52.748
<v Mark Lear>Can I add one on top of that?

2083
03:29:52.829 --> 03:29:55.783
<v Mark Lear>Yeah, um, thanks for the question, Councilor Ryan.

2084
03:29:56.137 --> 03:30:02.013
<v Mark Lear>Um, I've overseen the Fixing Our Streets program for— since its start in 2016.

2085
03:30:02.639 --> 03:30:14.233
<v Mark Lear>And to me, one of the— building on what Director Williams said— one of the most exciting things that's happened and sort of how we've specifically— how we've connected some of the work is we've been triaging work for a long time, right?

2086
03:30:14.281 --> 03:30:17.557
<v Mark Lear>We're paving the busiest streets, the high-crash corridors, that kind of thing.

2087
03:30:18.069 --> 03:30:23.546
<v Mark Lear>But we used to We used to have this practice when a street got to a pavement condition that we said, okay, we just have to rebuild it, right?

2088
03:30:24.156 --> 03:30:40.887
<v Mark Lear>And as we were doing that, and we were totally broke, we started hearing from some of our maintenance crews that were saying, you know, if we did a grind and pave in this section, we did a reconstruction where it's— the road's failing, but then we could stretch our dollar and do a 2-inch grind and overlay on some other parts of the street.

2089
03:30:41.272 --> 03:30:46.876
<v Mark Lear>We could really do a lot more, and we could potentially touch streets that are our most important streets, right?

2090
03:30:47.358 --> 03:30:50.922
<v Mark Lear>That, right, otherwise we're like, ah, we just don't have enough money to do the full rebuild, right?

2091
03:30:50.969 --> 03:30:54.342
<v Mark Lear>And Director Williams and the team both— and it was amazing to me, right?

2092
03:30:54.423 --> 03:31:02.949
<v Mark Lear>The maintenance crews that are more engaged in the conversation with the engineers, and it's oftentimes, you know, one side of the river and the other, they're having these conversations, right?

2093
03:31:03.270 --> 03:31:16.381
<v Mark Lear>When we get those groups together and we really hear the ground, the smarts from the ground, right, of the crews doing the work, we We've figured out how to do projects that are a tenth as expensive as they might have been if we were doing full reconstruction.

2094
03:31:16.431 --> 03:31:18.371
<v Mark Lear>So I think that's a story that we're starting to tell more.

2095
03:31:18.515 --> 03:31:19.431
<v Mark Lear>We need to tell it more.

2096
03:31:19.959 --> 03:31:22.671
<v Mark Lear>And it's those conversations we're having at the Fixing Our Streets Committee.

2097
03:31:22.736 --> 03:31:23.682
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate everything you said.

2098
03:31:23.729 --> 03:31:24.355
<v Dan Ryan>I'll wrap up.

2099
03:31:24.435 --> 03:31:32.425
<v Dan Ryan>My point is I just don't want to keep investing in a system that's not being overhauled, but, but is being overhauled with some necessary reforms at the same time.

2100
03:31:32.859 --> 03:31:37.478
<v Dan Ryan>People don't want to see status quo thank you.

2101
03:31:38.415 --> 03:31:42.245
<v Dan Ryan>So I can hear that you have that appetite.

2102
03:31:42.870 --> 03:31:45.655
<v Dan Ryan>I'll end with this, and that is role clarity.

2103
03:31:45.782 --> 03:31:51.738
<v Dan Ryan>I think a lot of people don't understand what the state maintains, what the county maintains— bridges.

2104
03:31:51.868 --> 03:31:54.879
<v Dan Ryan>A lot of people don't realize that the county's responsible for bridges.

2105
03:31:55.539 --> 03:32:01.647
<v Dan Ryan>And then we all know that there was a lot of controversy with transportation bills down in Salem this past session.

2106
03:32:02.240 --> 03:32:07.042
<v Dan Ryan>And I think that I would like to hear more how this is intersecting with our other partners.

2107
03:32:07.637 --> 03:32:09.565
<v Dan Ryan>Who's on first for what?

2108
03:32:10.368 --> 03:32:19.297
<v Dan Ryan>And I hear that we have to take care of our own, but are we also being too gratuitous to take care of things that really should be under other jurisdictions?

2109
03:32:19.425 --> 03:32:28.227
<v Dan Ryan>And if we are, the public needs to know about that because they're feeling like they're being, uh, getting invoiced from all 3 sources and wondering if they're working together.

2110
03:32:28.388 --> 03:32:29.158
<v Dan Ryan>Does that make sense?

2111
03:32:29.399 --> 03:32:29.961
<v Millicent Williams>It makes sense.

2112
03:32:30.042 --> 03:32:37.647
<v Millicent Williams>And I think we have some opportunities to, uh, further provide further information on our current budget because there are things that we do pay for that are not ours.

2113
03:32:38.310 --> 03:32:41.094
<v Millicent Williams>Um, uh, some debt and— sorry, I'm sorry.

2114
03:32:41.629 --> 03:32:42.130
<v Sameer Kanal>We're—.

2115
03:32:42.195 --> 03:32:44.656
<v Dan Ryan>I appreciate that we got to have some dialogue.

2116
03:32:44.703 --> 03:32:45.805
<v Millicent Williams>Happily, happy to share that.

2117
03:32:46.000 --> 03:32:46.065
<v Unidentified speaker>Yes.

2118
03:32:47.572 --> 03:32:48.788
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thank you, Councilor Ryan.

2119
03:32:48.852 --> 03:32:53.180
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm sorry, I'm not trying to cut you off, just making sure that there's time for your conversation.

2120
03:32:53.228 --> 03:33:03.799
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm, I'm I'm currently interpreting this as you effectively still having the floor, but because we're going to have to continue this in order to get out, uh, on time here, I'm just making sure.

2121
03:33:04.811 --> 03:33:12.406
<v Sameer Kanal>And that means I, I'm noting that Councilor Novick, Councilor Clark, and myself are still in the queue, and I'll maintain that when we come back to it.

2122
03:33:13.065 --> 03:33:18.572
<v Sameer Kanal>Um, but unless there's any motions that I need to be aware of right now, um, I'm going to—.

2123
03:33:18.620 --> 03:33:29.126
<v Olivia Clark>Councilor Councilor Kanal, I would like to call the question on the street restoration fee, which is document 2026-114.

2124
03:33:29.727 --> 03:33:31.609
<v Olivia Clark>I think we've had a pretty good discussion of that.

2125
03:33:31.674 --> 03:33:37.675
<v Olivia Clark>We've amended it, and while I would like to have them both move together, if I can get one moving, that's great.

2126
03:33:38.980 --> 03:33:42.977
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm going to interpret that as a motion to refer the item to the full council.

2127
03:33:43.074 --> 03:33:43.524
<v Olivia Clark>I'm sorry.

2128
03:33:43.782 --> 03:33:44.007
<v Dan Ryan>Yes.

2129
03:33:45.309 --> 03:33:45.507
<v Candace Avalos>Second.

2130
03:33:45.756 --> 03:33:47.763
<v Sameer Kanal>All right, I see a second from Councilor Murillo.

2131
03:33:49.319 --> 03:33:55.485
<v Sameer Kanal>Colleagues, this I believe does not require debate since we've been debating the item, but I'm going to verify that.

2132
03:33:56.394 --> 03:34:09.168
<v Sameer Kanal>But seeing nobody else add to the queue, pause for dramatic effect, I will ask Keelan if you would please call the roll on a motion to refer the resolution to the full council.

2133
03:34:10.833 --> 03:34:12.022
<v Keelan McClymont>With a do pass, so we don't—.

2134
03:34:12.103 --> 03:34:13.375
<v Sameer Kanal>Oh, with a do pass recommendation.

2135
03:34:13.423 --> 03:34:14.726
<v Sameer Kanal>With a do pass recommendation.

2136
03:34:14.773 --> 03:34:15.979
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you for clarifying that.

2137
03:34:16.156 --> 03:34:17.637
<v Sameer Kanal>Yes, and that's as amended, of course.

2138
03:34:19.549 --> 03:34:20.048
<v Jamie Dunphy>Okay.

2139
03:34:23.823 --> 03:34:23.871
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2140
03:34:25.109 --> 03:34:25.334
<v Keelan McClymont>Ryan?

2141
03:34:26.490 --> 03:34:31.542
<v Dan Ryan>I just want to qualify this by saying that I would have needed more time to get to a yes, so for today I'm a no.

2142
03:34:33.329 --> 03:34:33.655
<v Keelan McClymont>Koyama Lane?

2143
03:34:34.077 --> 03:34:34.239
<v Tiffany Koyama Lane>Aye.

2144
03:34:34.906 --> 03:34:35.298
<v Keelan McClymont>Morillo?

2145
03:34:35.412 --> 03:34:35.459
<v Angelita Morillo>Aye.

2146
03:34:39.248 --> 03:34:46.430
<v Mark Lear>I am going to vote aye, but I will ask the chair in future to limit each councilor's time for discussion so that we all have time to discuss.

2147
03:34:46.914 --> 03:34:46.930
<v Mark Lear>Aye.

2148
03:34:48.120 --> 03:34:48.459
<v Keelan McClymont>Clark?

2149
03:34:48.926 --> 03:34:48.975
<v Olivia Clark>Aye.

2150
03:34:49.570 --> 03:34:49.796
<v Keelan McClymont>Green?

2151
03:34:50.618 --> 03:34:50.713
<v Mitch Green>Aye.

2152
03:34:52.003 --> 03:34:53.066
<v Keelan McClymont>Zimmerman, absent.

2153
03:34:53.274 --> 03:34:53.581
<v Keelan McClymont>Avalos?

2154
03:34:53.918 --> 03:34:54.079
<v Candace Avalos>Aye.

2155
03:34:54.870 --> 03:34:55.111
<v Keelan McClymont>Dunphy?

2156
03:34:55.288 --> 03:34:55.335
<v Jamie Dunphy>Aye.

2157
03:34:56.045 --> 03:34:56.367
<v Keelan McClymont>Smith?

2158
03:34:56.897 --> 03:34:56.945
<v Loretta Smith>Aye.

2159
03:34:57.879 --> 03:34:58.104
<v Keelan McClymont>Kanal?

2160
03:34:59.070 --> 03:34:59.231
<v Sameer Kanal>Aye.

2161
03:35:00.279 --> 03:35:09.500
<v Keelan McClymont>Motion to refer the resolution as amended, document number 2026-01-02, Councilor Herbold, I have the report of the Committee on Finance and Government Affairs on Ordinance 2026-114 to City Council with the recommendation it be adopted.

2162
03:35:09.500 --> 03:35:13.629
<v Keelan McClymont>Passes with 10 yes votes, 1 no, and 1 absent.

2163
03:35:13.860 --> 03:35:14.659
<v Sameer Kanal>Okay, thank you.

2164
03:35:14.659 --> 03:35:24.639
<v Sameer Kanal>I'm gonna continue the discussion of the ordinance until our next meeting, which again is the 2 o'clock on the 15th.

2165
03:35:24.639 --> 03:35:30.579
<v Sameer Kanal>And with that, before I adjourn, just wanted to, A, say thank you for everyone bearing with us.

2166
03:35:30.760 --> 03:35:30.899
<v Sameer Kanal>Thank you, Councilor Smith.

2167
03:35:30.899 --> 03:35:32.319
<v Sameer Kanal>That concludes our first Committee of the Whole meeting.

2168
03:35:32.319 --> 03:35:34.049
<v Sameer Kanal>Appreciate the grace as we get through this.

2169
03:35:34.340 --> 03:35:35.319
<v Sameer Kanal>We're learning, we're growing.

2170
03:35:35.319 --> 03:35:36.180
<v Sameer Kanal>This was a tough meeting.

2171
03:35:36.799 --> 03:35:38.459
<v Sameer Kanal>Haha, uh, needed to get one of those out of the way.

2172
03:35:38.920 --> 03:35:40.719
<v Sameer Kanal>Sorry, uh, get a groaner going.

2173
03:35:40.719 --> 03:35:43.479
<v Sameer Kanal>But, um, looking forward to this, uh, in the future.

2174
03:35:43.559 --> 03:35:46.920
<v Sameer Kanal>And, um, with that, we will adjourn the first meeting of the Committee of the Whole.

2175
03:35:47.399 --> 03:35:48.100
<v Shoshana Cohen>All right.

